﻿

   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
About This Book
EPIDEMIOLOGY AND PHYSIOLOGY
Coronavirus Myths and Facts | S Novella
COVID-19 update: What you need to know now that it’s officially a pandemic | Science-Based Medicine
More COVID-19 News | S Novella
Winning the COVID Marathon | S Novella
The Origins of SARS-CoV-2 | S Novella
The origin of SARS-CoV-2, revisited | D Gorski
New Studies on the Origin of COVID-19 | S Novella
No, James Lyons-Weiler did not “break the coronavirus code” | D Gorski
COVID Lab Leak Theory Rises Again | S Novella
The rise and fall of the lab leak hypothesis for the origin of SARS-CoV-2 | D Gorski
The New York Times promotes “lab leak” conspiracy theories | D Gorski
The Lab Leak Theory and the Complicit Media | A Neitzel
How conspiracy theories like COVID-19 “lab leak” harm science and public health | D Gorski
Why is The New York Times now promoting an anti-science agenda? | J Moore & G Gonsalves
Great Barrington Declaration Author Joins COVID-19 Lab Leak-Pushing Group | A Neitzel
Biosafety Now: Releasing The Virus Was Mass Murder. Intentionally Spreading It Was Forgivable. | J Howard
Medical conspiracy theories and COVID-19 | D Gorski
Latest Science on Origins of SARS-CoV-2 | S Novella
Zoonotic Spillover Is A Problem | S Novella
The Pro-Virus Misinformation of Matt Ridley and the Toxic Apathy of Dr. Alina Chan | J Howard
Plandemic: Judy Mikovits and the mother of all COVID-19 conspiracy theories | Science-Based Medicine
Plandemic: Judy Mikovits and the mother of all COVID-19 conspiracy theories (some final thoughts) | Science-Based Medicine
Heritage Covid Commission Wants China Accountable… What About Trump? | A Neitzel
Was New York’s Spring 2020 COVID Wave an Illusion? | J Howard
EcoHealth Alliance Fights Back | A Neitzel
COVID-19 – The Second Wave | S Novella
The New SARS-CoV-2 Variants | S Novella
The Delta Variant | S Novella
Variants of Interest | S Novella
Omicron | S Novella
There is no COVID-19 “casedemic.” The pandemic is real and deadly. | D Gorski
Summer COVID Wave | S Novella
The Subvariants Are Coming | S Novella
COVID Is Still Here, But Changing | S Novella
Is COVID-19 transmitted by airborne aerosols? | D Gorski
Airborne Transmission of SARS-CoV-2 | S Novella
COVID in Children | S Novella
Joe Mercola: Falsely demonizing the flu vaccine by claiming it increases your risk of COVID-19 | D Gorski
COVID-19 “super-spreaders” and “super-spreading events”: The controversy | S Novella
Superspreading Events | S Novella
COVID-19 parties: Urban legend or real thing? | D Gorski
Spike Proteins, COVID-19, and Vaccines | S Novella
No – COVID-19 Is Not Just a “Bad Flu” | S Novella
COVID-19 and Excess Deaths | S Novella
The Toll of COVID | S Novella
COVID Morbidity | S Novella
Emerging Evidence of Intrauterine SARS-CoV-2 Infections | C Jones
COVID-19 infection during pregnancy is associated with higher rates of autism and neurodevelopmental diagnoses | D Gorski
Science-based medical lessons from President Trump’s case of COVID-19 (thus far) | Science-Based Medicine
COVID Fatality Improving | S Novella
COVID-19 Testing | S Novella
Is RSV Being Misdiagnosed as COVID-19? | J Howard
When Did “Herd Immunity” Become a Taboo Phrase? | J Howard
The “spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration” promotes antivaccine misinformation | D Gorski
Brownstone uses flawed data analysis to minimize COVID in NYC; An NYC hospitalist’s perspective | E Burnett
Will Natural Herd Immunity End the Pandemic? | S Novella
Super Immunity vs Anti-Vaxxers | S Novella
“Natural immunity” versus the vaccine for COVID-19 | D Gorski
The JCVI Speaks: “Natural Infection in Children Could Have Substantial Long-Term Benefits On COVID-19 in the UK” | J Howard
Which is best, vaccine-induced immunity, “natural immunity,” or “super immunity” to COVID-19? | D Gorski
“Natural Immunity” Stans Forget Babies Will Always be Vulnerable to COVID | J Howard
“We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April”: Reflections on a Failed Prediction | J Howard
“Their Plan is Incongruent With My Existence” | J Howard
Deaths and Excess Deaths in Brazil | A Karlinsky
The COVID-as-bacterial-pneumonia conspiracy theory rises again | D Gorski
Smoking and COVID | S Gavura
Race and COVID | J Howard
“This Thing Has Killed Less Than Or About As Many As Flu Would Kill In A Normal Year In Kids, I Say Hardly Any” & “80-Year-Olds, Their Time To Death In General Is Not That Long.” | J Howard
The CDC Releases New Data on COVID-19 in Children | C Jones
Are COVID-19 Hospitalizations for Children Inflated? | J Howard
COVID-19 is Deadlier Than the Flu for Children | J Howard
Children, Underlying Conditions, and COVID-19 | J Howard
The CDC Should Do Better | J Howard
Will You Share These Numbers? | J Howard
Normalizing Dead Children | J Howard
Was the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic to Blame for an Increase in Unexpected Infant Deaths in 2020? | C. Jones
Vulnerable Children Really Count | J Howard
Cognitive Illusions and How Not to Write About COVID-19 and Children | J Howard
The Consequences of a Medical Myth | J Howard
They Have Names | Science-Based Medicine
COVID and Our Warped Sense of Normal | J Howard
The CDC Goofs and Doctors React | J Howard
Children and COVID-19: A Few Facts and Figures from the Pandemic’s First Three Years | C Jones
Covid-19 in Children: A New Study Out of China | H Hall
Science Fiction at the Wall Street Journal | J Howard
Was the Delta Variant 😂 for Children? | J Howard
Excess in Non-COVID Deaths | S Novella
The Suicide Holiday Myth, Now with COVID | S Novella
Should We Accept Unvaccinated Children Dying of COVID as a “Matter of Course”? | Science-Based Medicine
COVID-19 and Children: More Useless Comparisons | J Howard
COVID-19 is a leading cause of death among children, but that doesn’t stop some of my colleagues from arguing against vaccinating them | D Gorski
I Reject Your Medical Reality and I Substitute Death | M Crislip
COVID-19 puts the spotlight on an unexpected racial disparity in health care | D Gorski
Was 2022 the “year of the gaslighter” with respect to COVID-19? | D Gorski
The State of Florida spreads antivaccine disinformation disguised as an epidemiological “study” | D Gorski
Is COVID-19 “the forever plague”? | D Gorski
A Rare and Mysterious Inflammatory Syndrome in Children is Linked to COVID-19 | C Jones
Stroke in COVID-19 Patients | S Novella
Neurological Manifestations of COVID | S Novella
COVID Associated With Neurodegenerative Disorders | S Novella
Is It Safe? | G Ritchey
COVID-19 and Tooth Loss | G Ritchy
Yes. I Remember it Well. A COVID 45 Retrospective | M Crislip
A New Covid-19 Myth? | H Hall
I Won’t Stop Talking About COVID Until You Stop Talking About COVID | J Howard
In the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, can we trust the CDC and FDA any more? | D Gorski
Frozen meat vs. COVID-19 misinformation: The strange case of Steak-umm | Science-Based Medicine
WHO Declares COVID Emergency Over | S Novella
Preventing The Next Pandemic | S Novella
The Next Pandemic | S Novella
Terrain in Vain | M Crislip
CONTRARIANS. ALWAYS IN ERROR NEVER IN DOUBT
COVID-19: Out-of-control science and bypassing science-based medicine | D Gorski
The confluence of antivaccine beliefs and conspiracy theories in COVID-19 denial | Science-Based Medicine
The Great Barrington Declaration: COVID-19 deniers follow the path laid down by creationists, HIV/AIDS denialists, and climate science deniers | D Gorski
Part 1: We Don’t Have to Wonder if the Great Barrington Declaration Could Have “Worked”. In the Real World, It Failed. | J Howard
Part 2: We Don’t Have to Wonder if the Great Barrington Declaration Could Have “Worked”. In the Real World It Failed & Redefining Basic Medical Terms Won’t Change That. | J Howard
A Challenge For Dr. Edward Livingston: Defend the Great Barrington Declaration Without Censoring the Great Barrington Declaration | J Howard
Defenders of the Great Barrington Declaration Neither Know Nor Care What it Proposed. The Deliberate Erasure of the We Want Them Infected Movement Has Succeeded. | J Howard
The Great Barrington Declaration and “natural herd immunity” versus public health three years later | D Gorski
Paul Thacker relitigates criticisms of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington Declaration | D Gorski
Brownstone Institute admits that the Great Barrington Declaration was wrong (without actually admitting it was wrong) | D Gorski
Is Anything About the Great Barrington Declaration Even Remotely Relevant? | J Howard
A Review of “In Covid’s Wake”: According to Laptop Class Professors, the Heroes of the Pandemic Were Laptop Class Professors | J Howard
“Is it Your Assertion That Picking Deadlines of Dead Kids is a Good Way to Evaluate a Policy?” | J Howard
2020 and the pandemic: A year of (some) physicians behaving badly | D Gorski
The making of COVID-19 “contrarian” doctors | D Gorski
Medical “Conservatives” Are Medical Radicals | J Howard
“New school” COVID-19 antivaxxers are becoming less and less distinguishable from “old school” antivaxxers | D Gorski
The Top COVID-19 Hucksters and Grifters…so far | S Gavura
Reader Beware | J Howard
“We’re Pro-Vaccine But” | J Howard
Denis Rancourt and “no virus”: COVID-19 symptoms were due psychological stress from the pandemic response! D. Gorski
Dr. Jerome Adams Was Right. They Wanted Them Infected. That’s a Fact. | J Howard
Verbicide: Language as a Pandemic Casualty | J Howard
The ultimate COVID-19 antivax conspiracy theory, courtesy of The Brownstone Institute and Jeffery Tucker | D Gorski
Does the Mass Infection of Unvaccinated Young People Follow the “Basic Principles of Public Health”? | Science-Based Medicine
Should An Infectious Disease Epidemiologist Comment on Child Vaccination? | J Howard
Incorrect Numbers | J Howard
Our Current Medical Establishment Would Have Botched COVID, The Same Way They Are Botching Measles | J Howard
The Covid Amnesia Project and the Plot to Erase 2020 | J Howard
How Journalists Enable the COVID Amnesia Project | J Howard
The COVID Amnesia Project: Erasing Your Free Will to Preserve the Fantasy of the Optional Pandemic | J Howard
Since They Won’t Remind You, Here’s What Drs. John Ioannidis, Jay Bhattacharya, and Scott Atlas, Actually Said 6 Years Ago | J Howard
A Tale of Two Books: We Want Them Infected & In COVID’s Wake | J Howard
An Open Letter to Professor Katy Milkman: Don’t Censor John Ioannidis, Jay Bhattacharya, and Emily Oster. Amplify Their Voices. | J Howard
JAY BHATTACHARYA
JAMA promotes the false equivalence of ‘focused protection’ | M Burkard
The tendentious libertarianism of the Great Barrington Declaration | E Kramer
Jay Bhattacharya: “If It’s True That The Novel Coronavirus Would Kill Millions Without Shelter-In-Place Orders and Quarantines, Then the Extraordinary Measures Being Carried Out in Cities and States Around the Country Are Surely Justified” | Science-Based Medicine
Jay Bhattacharya errs on excess mortality in New Zealand | E Kramer
Did New Zealand Let Too Few People Die of COVID? | J Howard
I Didn’t Encourage the Spread of COVID. Was I Unethical? | J Howard
Through The Looking Glass With Dr. Jay Bhattacharya | J Howard
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Responds to Words I Never Said | J Howard
Prediction: Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Will Never Treat COVID as “One of 200 Diseases That Affect People”. | J Howard
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: “The Unspoken Root Idea Of His Is That The General Public Owed It To Doctors To Not Get COVID Because It Would Place Doctors At Risk Of Getting COVID. Of Course This Is An Inversion. “ | J Howard
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, April 2021: “The Central Problem Right Now I Think Is The Fear That People Still Feel About COVID.” | J. Howard
Every Time Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Talks About COVID, He Proves He Was Totally Wrong About COVID | J Howard
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: “An Infection Is A Severe Problem For Older Populations, and Also For People Who Have Certain Chronic Conditions. For Younger Populations Under 70, It’s Much Milder.” | J Howard\
A “Biosafety” Organization Partnering With Dr. Jay Bhattacharya To Guard Against Viruses Is Like A Zebra Teaming Up With A Lion To Promote Vegetarianism | J Howard
If Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Saw What I Saw, He’d Realize That Being Called “Fringe” Isn’t So Bad After All | J Howard
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Was Nice to Someone During a Debate. That Doesn’t Erase the Consequences of His Misinformation. | J Howard
The COVID Amnesia Project III: The Plot to Erase Who Ordered Lockdowns in 2020 | J Howard
Science Based Satire: My 2026 Interview with Jay Bhattacharya. It’s Still Lockdowns All the Way Down. | J Howard
Welcome to the Resistance UCSF Doctors | J Howard
Are Frontline Healthcare Workers The Laptop Class? | J Howard
Laptop Class Doctors Think Doctors Who Treat Patients Are Lazy, Dumb, Cowardly, Sheep | J Howard
Conspirituality: A Book Recommendation | J Howard
Dr. Martin Kulldorff, Who Posted Pictures of Guillotines and Promised Herd Immunity Would Arrive 3-6 Months After Lockdowns Ended, Fired for “Clinging to the Truth”. | Science-Based Medicine
A Tale of Two Interviews: Martin Kulldorff and James Baker | L Shaffer
Why It’s Worthwhile to Debunk Shivambu | J Howard
Dr. Kelly Brogan Wakes Up to the “Ball Earth Hoax”. What Does This Reveal About Prominent Professors From Prominent Medical Schools? | J. Howard
Why Are Sensible Medicine Doctors Indifferent to the Nonsense Comments of Sensible Medicine Commentators? As Instructed, I Consider the Dualities of Interest and Motivating Biases. | J. Howard
“New school” antivax goes old school as Byram Bridle asks if COVID-19 vaccines will drive an “epidemic” of autism | D. Gorski
Dr. Adam Cifu: “We Now Need to Accept That This is Here to Get Infected With Again and Again.” | J. Howard
Dr. Lucy McBride: “As physicians, dispensing false hope is dangerous & unethical.” | J. Howard
The Failed “We Want Them Infected” Movement Is Trying to Rebrand Itself As The “All We Really Wanted Was Poor Kids in School” Movement. | J Howard
Countering Geert Vanden Bossche’s dubious viral open letter warning against mass COVID-19 vaccination | Science-Based Medicine
Dr. Scott Atlas: “To Me, It’s Unconscionable When a Society Uses its Children as Shields for Adults.” | Science-Based Medicine
Pandemic Revisionism: Doctors Who Defend Dr. Scott Atlas Are Afraid to Accurately Quote Dr. Scott Atlas. I’m Not. | J Howard
Dr. Scott Atlas: “I Never Read the Full Great Barrington Declaration Website and Everything”. | J Howard
Open Letter to Pamela Paul of the New York Times: Watch Some Interviews With Dr. Marty Makary. They Are More Important Than Peanut Allergies. | J Howard
STEVE KIRSCH
“Debate me, bro!”: Debate challenges by science deniers in the age of COVID-19 | Science-Based Medicine
Steve Kirsch: How “anti-COVID-19 vaccine” antivax often becomes radicalized and just plain antivaccine | D Gorski
Steve Kirsch and Brandolini’s law | D Gorski
Steve Kirsch’s “mother of all revelations” about the “deadliness” of COVID-19 vaccines goes poof | D. Gorski
Can COVID Vaccines Travel in Space and Time? | J Howard
VINAY PRASAD
1,200 is More Than 6 | J Howard
1,200 Equals 6 | J Howard
The Road to Hitler is Paved with… Masks and Vaccines? | Science-Based Medicine
Doctors Must be Honest with Parents About Known Risks of COVID-19 | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad: “Public Health’s (Mis)Truth Problem” | L Scaffer
Dr. Vinay Prasad echoes a common antivax trope that portrays concern about a deadly disease as irrational fear | D Gorski
Anti-Vaccine Doctors: “Kids Don’t Need the Vaccine Because They Are Less Likely to Acquire SARS-CoV-2 and Because Most Already Had COVID-19” | J Howard
Are Vaccine-Advocates “Idiots”, Indifferent to the Death of a Mentally Ill Woman and Her Family? | Science-Based Medicine
Dr. Vinay Prasad fully embraces the antivax message of “do not comply” | D Gorski
I Agree with Dr. Vinay Prasad: It’s Entirely Predictable That More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad vs. a VAERS study finding more reports of vaccine injury in red states | D Gorski
Dr. Vinay Prasad: It’s “Good” That Parents Who Want To Vaccinate Their Kids Against COVID Get Reported To Child Protective Services | J Howard
I Don’t Think Vaccine Side Effects Are Worse Than Death. Am I Off My Rocker? | J Howard
Moral outrage is not a good guide to pandemic policy reform. Vinay Prasad, please take note. | E Kramer
Dr. Vinay Prasad Pretends to Admit Error: I Was Optimistic That Vaccination Would Halt the Spread of the Virus—I Was Wrong. | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad Opposed The Pediatric COVID Vaccine Before There Was A Pediatric COVID Vaccine | J Howard
A Simple Challenge For Drs. Vinay Prasad and Tracy Hoeg: Denounce Robert Kennedy Jr. For Promoting The Movie Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill | J Howard
Making Up Reasons to Let Unvaccinated Kids Get COVID: Pediatricians Will Run Out of Time and Measles Will Return | J Howard
Dr. Adam Cifu Should Recognize, Dr. Vinay Prasad Will Never Admit Measures to Limit Viruses “Work” | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad: “I Don’t Believe in Forgiveness Because in My Opinion These Pieces of Shit Are Still Lying.” | J Howard
Defenders of Dr. Vinay Prasad’s Vulgar, Vengeful Vitriol Have No Right to Sanctimoniously Scold Anyone About Decorum | J Howard
I Confess My Sins: I Was Too Slow and Timid to Call Out Propaganda For What It Is. | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad Embraces Policy-Based Evidence Making | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad Said He Would Deliver New COVID Vaccine RCTs. He Failed and Should STFU. | J Howard
Dr. Vinay Prasad’s Latest Evidence the COVID Vaccine Killed Kids: “Trust Me, Bro.” | J Howar
What’s the Opposite of a Vaccine Selfie? | J Howard
Dr. Jeffrey Flier: Those Who Express Different Views on Health Equity Should Be Demonized, Not Heard | Science-Based Medicine
Woke Washing the Pandemic: If You Really Were Progressive, You’d Want Them Infected | J Howard
Is it “Natural and Healthy” When Children Get Sick With COVID? | J Howard
Dr. Sunetra Gupta Versus Dr. Sunetra Gupta | J Howard
JOHN IOANNIDIS
What the heck happened to John Ioannidis? | D Gorski
Intubations and Accusations: Doctors were “just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated” | J Howard
John Ioannidis and the Carl Sagan effect in science communication about COVID-19 | D Gorski
John Ioannidis uses the Kardashian Index to attack critics of the Great Barrington Declaration | Science-Based Medicine
Intubations and Accusations Part 2 | J Howard
Misinformation is Censorship | J Howard
“This Would Translate to About 10,000 Deaths” Reflections From the Start of the Pandemic | Science-Based Medicine
Dr. John Ioannidis: “The Biggest Mistakes I am Sure Are Mine.” | J Howard
“Panel stacking”: John Ioannidis versus a Delphi consensus statement on COVID-19 | D Gorski
Dr. John Ioannidis: Yet Another Doctor Who Treats Theoretical Death From The Vaccine With More Gravity Than Actual Death From COVID | J Howard
An Absurd Thought Experiment | J Howard
“What Exactly Did the Virus do to All These People?” Reflections on Ted Nugent, Mel Q, Kelly Brogan, and John Ioannidis | J Howard
Doctors Respond to Being Quoted: “I Don’t Think You Realize How Silly You Look Right Now” | J Howard
Quoth quacks, “The medical consensus has changed before, making my quackery science!” | D Gorski
“I know you are, but what am I?” Dr. Aseem Malhotra rails against COVID-19 “misinformation” | D Gorski
The Aseem Malhotra lecture isn’t what you think it is | F Han
Unsafe and Ineffective: Aseem Malhotra | J Laxton
Minimizing COVID Via Pseudo-Profound Bullshit | J Howard
An Impossible, Unethical Study of Dubious Value That’s Not Meant to be Taken Seriously | J Howard
Peter Gøtzsche teams with an antivaxxer to exaggerate the harms of COVID-19 vaccines | D Gorski
Apples, Oranges, and How Not to Analyze a Vaccine RCT | J Howard
Statistical Shenanigans? | H Hall
Antivaccine leader Del Bigtree on COVID-19: “Let’s catch this cold!” Why antivaxxers and coronavirus conspiracy theorists are often one in the same. | D Gorski
J.B. Handley’s unthinking person’s guide to the COVID-19 pandemic | D Gorski
Did Lockdowns Cause Cancer? | J Howard
Examining COVID-19 misinformation propagated by US physicians | Science-Based Medicine
Sensible Medicine: Medical Misinformation and Medical Groupthink From the Medical Establishment | J Howard
When Doctors Have Different Standards of Evidence for the Virus and the Vaccine | J Howard
It Was Misinformation When I Said Vaccines Are 100% Effective at Preventing Bad Outcomes & Will End the Pandemic | J Howard
Naked Emperors and Laptop Class Doctors | J Howard
The Pro-Vaccine Test | J Howard
A “not antivaccine” antivax pediatrician asks how we will know a COVID-19 vaccine is safe and effective | D Gorski
RFK Jr.: A fart-filled argument gives way to an antisemitic conspiracy theory that COVID-19 is an “ethnically targeted” bioweapon | D Gorski
We Want Them Infected Doctors Sanewashed Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Will He Reward Them With Appointments at the CDC, FDA, and NIH? | J Howard
Yet another example of how “new school” anti-COVID vaccine antivaxxers have become just antivaxxers now | D Gorski
Why Should We Trust Journalist David Zweig Regarding COVID and Schools When He Pals Around With Proud Child-Labor Advocates? | J Howard
MAHA and the Triumph of Feelings Based Medicine | J Howard
Praise for Dr. Monica Gandhi | J Howard
When an antivax physician “dies suddenly”: The case of Dr. Rashid Buttar | D Gorski
A Letter to My Critics: To Refute Me, Stand Up For Your Own Words | J Howard
Might “Vitriolic Attacks” Against Emily Oster Rival COVID’s Carnage? | J Howard
Neil deGrasse Tyson makes the unforced error of “debating” antivax propagandist Del Bigtree on The Highwire | D Gorski
A Phony Invitation for “Discussion and Debate” | J Howard
Debating How to Debate Instead of Actually Debating | J Howard
Loud Silenced Doctors | J Howard
Silent Silenced Doctors | J Howard
Supposedly Silenced Scientists and Dr. Rick Bright | J Howard
I’ve Been Silenced, Censored, and Cancelled. The Reason Why Matters. | J Howard
Did I Lie About My Conference Invitation? How Bad Faith Engagement Functions As A Distraction and Silencing Technique. | J Howard
The “Heterodox” Media: Using Groupthink and Misinformation to Inhibit Free Thought | J Howard
Minimizing COVID Via Postmodernism | J Howard
Once a Doctor Has Minimized Literal Death for Young People, Should We Value Their Opinion on Any Topic Less Consequential Than Literal Death? | J Howard
A Salesman’s Trick, Ignoring R0, Shaming, Conspiracy, Premature Declaration, Strategic Omission, and Fanciful Fiction | J Howard
Contrarian Doctors: The Pandemic is Over, Again | J Howard
Contrarian Doctors, The Pandemic is Over Again, Again | J Howard
The Hypocrisy Is The Point. Doctors Who Said Not To Mix Politics & Medicine. | J Howard
Ayn Rand, Objectivists, and COVID | J Howard
Is Discussing the Consequences of Anti-Vaccine Disinformation Fun? | J Howard
“Coronaphobia”: How antivaxxers and pandemic minimizers pathologize fear of disease | D Gorski
They Have Names, Part 2 | J Howard
An Open Letter to ZDoggMD | J Howard
Joe Mercola: An antivaccine quack tycoon pivots effortlessly to profit from spreading COVID-19 misinformation | D Gorski
I Won’t Call Dr. Paul Offit an Anti-Vaxxer | J Howard
COVID-19 conspiracy theories: Vaccines and 5G (along with Bill Gates) are responsible! | D Gorski
The Opinion Class: Practicing Focused Protection From Reality | J Howard
“We Want Them Infected” – My Book is Done! | J Howard
The Videos THEY Don’t Want You to See. A Silenced, Censored Doctor Speaks Out. | J Howard
LONG COVID
Long COVID | S Novella
Update on Long COVID | S Novella
More on Long COVID | S Novella
The search for long COVID treatments | S Gavura
A Bit of Good News: Kids Appear to Have Lower Risk of Post-COVID Conditions Than Previously Thought | C Jones
Long COVID: Alternative medicine sees a business opportunity | S Novella
VACCINE
Pfizer’s COVID Vaccine | S Novella
Moderna’s COVID Vaccine | S Novella
Possible Universal Coronavirus Vaccine | S Novella
Nasal Spray Vaccine for SARS-CoV-2 | S Novella
Vaccine safety monitoring in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic | Science-Based Medicine
To unblind or not to unblind? That is the question about clinical trials of COVID-19 vaccines | D Gorski
Antivaxxers launch a preemptive disinformation war against a COVID-19 vaccine that doesn’t yet exist | D Gorski
Recycling old antivax tropes as “bioethics”-based arguments against COVID-19 vaccination for children | D Gorski
Yes, the FDA really HAS given full approval to the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine | D Gorski
Vaccines Don’t Save Lives | J Howard
When Will We Need a COVID Vaccine Booster? | S Novella
Third Dose Prevents Infection | S Novella
Vaccines Vaccines and more Vaccines | S Novella
COVID Vaccines Probably Prevent Spread | S Novella
The Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine doesn’t prevent transmission: Antivax disinformation goes viral again | D Gorski
The “12% efficacy” myth from the “Pfizer data dump”: The latest slasher stat about COVID-19 vaccines | D Gorski
Three New Studies Show the COVID Vaccines Are Very Safe for Children | J Howard
Was an Article Titled “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization” About Vaccinating Children? | J Howard
An Open Letter to Dr. Stefan Baral: Let’s Revisit Your Article “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization.” | J Howard
Should COVID-19 vaccines be administered to children under an emergency use authorization? | J Howard
New Study – mRNA Vaccines Safe | S Novella
The FDA’s Proposed “Black Box” Warning for COVID-19 Vaccines | H Miller
Novavax: It’s the vaccine that scares antivaxxers, not moth DNA or any ingredient in any vaccine | D Gorski
The Effectiveness of COVID Vaccines | S Novella
Russian and Other COVID Vaccines | S Novella
COVID Vaccine Hesitancy | S Novella
Deciding between a vaccine and…an infection? | S Gavura
Christian Elliot’s “18 Reasons I Won’t Be Getting a Covid Vaccine”: Viral antivaccine misinformation | D Gorski
A Race Against Vaccine Hesitancy | S Novella
The Causes of Vaccine Hesitancy | S Novella
Everything old is new again | D Gorski
A poorly framed article on COVID-19 vaccine injury in the New York Times | D Gorski
Some Doctors Cared Much More About Sore Arms Than Cold Bodies | J. Howard
Doctors on Measles: “NEVER Listen to the Anti-Vax Cult When They Say This ‘Natural’ Disease is Harmless”. Doctors on COVID: 😂 | J Howard
Oxford-AstraZeneca Vaccine Safety | S Novella
Did the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine cause a fatal case of ITP? | D Gorski
Johnson & Johnson Vaccine and Blood Clots | S Novella
Update on AstraZeneca Vaccine and Blood Clots | S Novella
A clot too far: An embalmer dissects antivax misinformation about blood clots in Died Suddenly | B Schmidt
COVID-19 pandemic deniers and the antivaccine movement: An unholy alliance | D Gorski
Don’t use a COVID-19 vaccine, cry the antivaxxers, because of the horseshoe crab! | D Gorski
The efforts of antivaxxers to portray COVID-19 vaccines as harmful or even deadly continue apace… | D Gorski
The efforts of antivaxxers to portray COVID-19 vaccines as harmful or even deadly continue apace (VAERS edition) | D Gorski
The Anti-Vaxxer Playbook to Destroy Confidence in COVID-19 Vaccines | S Gavura
Syncope and Bell’s palsy: Distinguishing correlation from causation for adverse events observed after COVID-19 vaccination | D Gorski
As 2021 shambles to a close, the misuse of VAERS by antivaxxers continues apace | D Gorski
Why is anyone surprised that there are so many antivax physicians? | D Gorski
Antivaxxers misuse the Defense Medical Epidemiology Database to demonize COVID-19 vaccines | D Gorski
How antivaxxers weaponize vaccine safety studies to falsely portray vaccines as dangerous | D. Gorski
How antivaxxers weaponize vaccine safety studies to falsely portray vaccines as dangerous, part 2: The children | D Gorski
Echoes of measles outbreaks in 2019: Antivaxxers are targeting Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn with COVID-19 misinformation | D Gorski
Died Suddenly: A tsunami of antivax misinformation and conspiracy theories | D Gorski
When antivax “died suddenly” conspiracy mongering vultures target a friend and colleague | D Gorski
Has MSU economics professor Mark Skidmore been “exonerated” over his retracted paper claiming that COVID vaccines killed 278,000? | D Gorski
COVID-19 vaccines versus “purity of essence” | D Gorski
COVID-19 vaccines versus “purity of essence,” revisited | D Gorski
The COVID-19 “Vaccine Holocaust”: The latest antivaccine messaging | D Gorski
“Depopulation” by COVID-19 vaccines? | D Gorski
It was inevitable that antivaxxers would claim that COVID-19 vaccines make females infertile | D Gorski
“COVID-19 vaccines are going to sterilize our womenfolk,” Take 2 | D Gorski
The latest antivax false claim: mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 are not vaccines but “medical devices” or “gene therapy” | D Gorski
Lipid nanoparticles in COVID-19 vaccines: The new mercury to antivaxxers | D Gorski
The “deadly” coronavirus spike protein (according to antivaxxers) | D Gorski
No, the Moderna and Pfizer RNA vaccines for COVID-19 will not “permanently alter your DNA” | D Gorski
Antivaxxers, COVID-19 vaccines, and “hacking the software of life” | D Gorski
The return of the revenge of “COVID-19 mRNA vaccines permanently alter your DNA” and “lab leak” | D Gorski
“The vaccinated are a danger to the unvaccinated because of shedding!”: The latest COVID-19 antivaccine disinformation | D Gorski
Do mRNA vaccines produce harmful “junk proteins” that “gunk up” the cell and cause unintended “off-target” immune responses? | D. Gorski
Can mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease or Alzheimer’s? | D Gorski
Prions. Why did it have to be prions? (Again.) D. Gorski
Hypervaccination | S. Novella
“I Don’t Know What’s in It” | H Hall
Closing the vaccine hesitancy gap | S Gavura
Chipping Away at Vaccine Hesitancy | S Novella
Once again, The BMJ, wittingly or unwittingly, reinforces an antivax narrative | D Gorski
The Anti-Vaccine Movement Supports Big Pharma | J Howard
Goodbye to the Novavax Vaccine? Our Flailing Medical Establishment Rejects Medical Freedom and Refuses to Fund Gold-Standard Science. | J Howard
TURBO CANCER
Here we go again: Another study is being misrepresented as evidence that COVID vaccines cause cancer | D Gorski
Antivaxxers misrepresent a study to falsely claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer | D Gorski
There is no evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are causing cancers associated with “accelerated aging” | D Gorski
Do COVID-19 vaccines cause “turbo cancer”? | D Gorski
Dr. William Makis and “turbo cancer”: Falsely blaming COVID-19 vaccines for cancer | D Gorski
COVID-19 vaccine-caused “turbo cancer” nonsense just keeps getting more turbocharged | D Gorski
Forget “turbo cancers” caused by COVID-19 vaccines. Does COVID itself cause cancer? | D Gorski
Quoth Myrna Mantaring: “US government data” confirms a “143,233% increase in cancer cases due to COVID vaccination”? I answer with a plea for math-based reality checks. | D Gorski
The opposite of “turbo cancer”: COVID-19 vaccines sensitize cancer to immunotherapy | D Gorski
And so 2026 begins…with a resurrection of the myth that COVID vaccines cause “turbo cancers” | D Gorski
COVID-19 vaccination and screening mammography | D Gorski
Are vaccines driving the emergence of “escape mutant” variants of COVID-19? | D Gorski
Why antivax arguments for COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” remind me of homeopathy | D. Gorski
Antivax quacks are continuing to make up fantastical biological mechanisms for COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” | D. Gorski
COVID-19 Vaccination Significantly Reduces Risk of Severe Inflammatory Syndrome in Kids | C. Jones
Is the Pediatric COVID Vaccine in Competition with Routine Vaccinations? | J Howard
The Alternative to Vaccinating Children Isn’t Just “Not Vaccinating” Them | J Howard
Study laundering: IPAK, antivax “scientists,” and the return of living dead antivax studies | D. Gorski
How antivaxxers laid the groundwork to blame COVID-19 vaccines for Damar Hamlin’s cardiac arrest | D Gorski
The “Disinformation Dozen” spreading anti-vaccine messaging on social media | S Gavura
Deliberately Spoiled Vaccines: Conspiracy thinking and health professionals | S Gavura
Justin Bieber, Ramsay Hunt syndrome, SADS, and how to antivaxxers everything is always about vaccines | D Gorski
If the BMJ Wants to Revisit Venerable Institutions Who Misled the Public in 2021, They Should Look Inward at the BMJ | J Howard
MYOCARDITIS
Myocarditis and how to think about it… like a cardiologist | F Han
Myocarditis and COVID-19: A Tale of Two Articles | J Howard
COVID-19 and balancing the risks: The vaccine or the virus | J Howard
Peer review of a VAERS dumpster dive | D Freedman
Dumpster diving in the VAERS database to find more COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis in children | D Gorski
The dumpster diving VAERS preprint debacle: How did we get here? | D Gorski
More Thoughts on the VAERS Pre-Print | J Howard
The Vaccine Versus the Virus: An Update | J Howard
COVID Vaccines and Cardiac Effects – Reality vs Lies | S Novella
Why Can’t We Discuss This Taboo Subject Everyone is Talking About? | J Howard
That latest article on the post vaccine myocarditis autopsy analysis | F Han
COVID-19 vaccination and myocarditis: another preprint | F Han
Medical Conservatives: A High Rate of COVID-Myocarditis is “Good News”, A Low Rate of Vaccine-Myocarditis is “Deeply Concerning” | J Howard
“Among patients aged 12-39 years with no predisposing comorbidities, the relative risk of heart failure or death was markedly higher for myocarditis associated with covid-19 disease than for myocarditis associated with vaccination.” | Science-Based Medicine
Dr. Vinay Prasad: “The Incidence of Myocarditis Found for Young Men after SARS-CoV-2 Infection is Larger Than What We Found for Myocarditis Following COVID-19 Vaccination.” | J Howard
Dr. Marty Makary: Using Dead Children to Create a Spectacle of Accusations | J Howard
The PULS test and COVID-19 vaccinations | F Han
Letter to a Medical Student: You Erred. You Are Owed an Apology. | J Howard
Part 1: “Don’t Minimize Myocarditis From The Vaccine”, By the Author of “Don’t Fear Literal Death From COVID”. | J Howard
Part 2: Is an Abnormal Lab Value After Vaccination More Concerning Than Death From COVID? | J Howard
As Diseases Spread and Trust in the FDA Crumbles, Its Leaders Are Obsessed with an MRI Abnormality in 1 in 61,500 Males Ages 12-24 | J Howard
Yet Another Silly Reason Doctors Give For Leaving Babies Vulnerable to COVID: 🍒-Picking | J Howard
Viral Videos of Alleged Vaccine Side Effects | S Novella
COVID-19 Vaccination and Factors Contributing to Vaccine Refusal | S Gavura
The Trolley Problem and Vaccinating Young People Against COVID-19 | J Howard
Overhyping Vaccines Wasn’t Pro-Vaccine. It Was Pro-Stop-Worrying-About-COVID. | J Howard
Do Covid-19 Vaccines Affect Fertility? | H Hall
Antivaxxers rejoice at the “silver lining” from the pandemic, spillover of distrust of COVID-19 vaccines to all vaccines | D Gorski
What the heck happened to The BMJ? | D Gorski
Peer review fail: Vaccine publishes antivax propaganda disguised as “reanalyses” of Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccine clinical trial data | D Gorski
Scientific review articles as antivaccine disinformation | D Gorski
Nobel for Medicine Goes To mRNA Vaccine Science | S. Novella
Methodolatry and COVID | J Howard
Take a Pledge to Enroll in a Randomized-Controlled Trial | J Howard
The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 1/10) | F Han
The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 2/10) | F Han
The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 3/10) | F Han
The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 4/10) | F Han
The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 5/10) | F Han
PREVENTION
As imperfect as they are, public health interventions save lives | D Gorski
The Great Barrington Declaration Wasn’t a Plan For Public Health Officials. It Was a List of Absurd Demands of Them. | J. Howard
Old antivax tropes never die: “COVID theater,” “Urgency of Normal,” and the Great Barrington Declaration | D Gorski
Pro-Infection Doctors Didn’t Honestly Question Whether Mitigation Measures Slowed COVID. They Sought To Undermine Them Precisely Because They Slowed COVID. | J.Howard
Advice and Encouragement for the “Urgency of Normal” Team | J Howard
The Smoke Alarm Fallacy | J Howard
Do Masks Work? | S Novella
Do face masks decrease the risk of COVID-19 transmission? | D Gorski
Misinformation and disinformation about facemasks and COVID-19 | D Gorski
The Mask Ask: Understanding and Addressing Mask Resistance | G Ritchey
“Masks make you sicker”: The COVID-19 myth that just won’t die. | D Gorski
One More Time – Masks Work | S Novella
How antimaskers weaponize techniques of scientific analysis to attack mask mandates | D Gorski
School mask mandate wars: Politics (Florida) v. Science (North Carolina) | J Bellamy
Legislatures and litigation: anti-vaxxers continue attacks on COVID mitigation | J Bellamy
Masks Revisited | S Novella
The Cochrane mask fiasco: How the evidence-based medicine paradigm can produce misleading results | D Gorski
ZShield: Unproven Protection from SARS-CoV-2 Infection, Especially for Kids | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Kinesiology Masks Revolutionize Coronavirus Prevention | C Jones
Handwashing to Prevent Pandemic | S Novella
Part of a Complete Breakfast | M Crislip
Letter to a Medical Student: There Is No Elite RCT Strike Force | J Howard
What’s So “Wonderful!” About an Article That Provoked Hateful Revenge Fantasies Against Frontline Doctors and Public Health Officials? | J Howard
Lions Led by Donkeys, 1917 | J Howard
Pro-Infection Doctors Didn’t Just Want Kids in School. They Wanted Them There Unvaccinated, Untested, and Unmasked. They Wanted Them Infected. | J Howard
Yes, Schools Were Closed in Sweden | J Howard
A Modest Proposal: Schools Must Open With Untested, Unmasked, Unvaccinated Children | J Howard
Looking Back 5 Year Later – Were Lockdowns Worth It? | S Novella
Was Closing Schools an Obvious and Colossal Mistake? | J Howard
Why Did the “Urgency of Normal” Stop Caring About the Mental, Social, Emotional, and Behavioral Health of our Children? | J Howard
Can Air Purifiers Stop Spread of COVID-19 Virus? | S Novella
Hospital Measures Prevented COVID Transmission | S. Novella
Nasal Sprays To Prevent COVID | S Novella
Can “optimizing your metabolism” through diet prevent or cure COVID-19? | D Gorski
Vitamin D for the prevention of COVID-19: A randomized controlled trial | S Gavura
Chiropractors falsely claim they can protect patients from coronavirus | J Bellamy
THERAPY
Two New Antivirals Targeting COVID-19 | S Novella
Alternative Medicine Exploits Coronavirus Fears | H Hall
More Pseudoscience for COVID-19 | S Novella
An incomplete list of COVID-19 quackery | S Gavura
ProtocolKills.com: Repackaging an old narrative about conventional medicine versus alternative medicine for COVID-19 | D Gorski
ProtocolKills.com: Misinformed refusal on steroids | D Gorski
Misinformation, Trust, and Non-Evidence-Based COVID-19 Treatments | S. Gavura
Black Market Anti-virals | S Novella
“Base Spike Detox” and Signature Spike Support Formulas: Nattokinase quackery to treat COVID-19 and COVID-19 “vaccine injury” | D Gorski
It rises again! Bleach as an “early treatment” alternative to vaccines and a cure for COVID-19 | D Gorski
The misuse and abuse of meta-analyses | S Gavura
Jumping the Gun: Antibody Drugs for Covid-19 | H Hall
Zinc and COVID | S Gavura
Vitamin D shows no efficacy against moderate to severe COVID-19 infections | S Gavura
The effectiveness of zinc and vitamin C on the duration of COVID-19 infections | S Gavura
Does convalescent plasma work against COVID-19? Who knows? | D Gorski
HYDROXYCHLOROQUINE
Are hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin an effective treatment for COVID-19? | D Gorski
Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin versus COVID-19: Grift, conspiracy theories, and another bad study by Didier Raoult | D Gorski
“Miracle cure” testimonials aside, azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine probably do not work against COVID-19 | D Gorski
Dexamethasone and Hydroxychloroquine: Why Randomized Controlled Trials Matter | S Gavura
Hydroxychloroquine and the price of abandoning of science- and evidence-based medicine | D Gorski
Hydroxychloroquine, retinal toxicity, and COVID-19 | D Weinberg
Hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19: Evidence can’t seem to kill it | D Gorski
IVERMECTIN
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine | S Gavura
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 2 | D Gorski
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 3: Conspiracy theories vs. science | D Gorski
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 4: Bret Weinstein misrepresents meta-analyses | W Paolo
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 5: The Nobel Prize gambit | D Gorski
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 6: Incompetence and fraud everywhere! | D Gorski
Ivermectin: The acupuncture of COVID-19 treatments | D Gorski
Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine Six Years On | S Novella
Pfizer’s new COVID-19 protease inhibitor drug is not just “repackaged ivermectin” | D Gorski
Science-based medicine isn’t just for CAM. The case of ivermectin shows that it never was. | D Gorski
Ivermectin booster Dr. Tess Lawrie goes all-in for homeopathy for COVID and long COVID | D Gorski
Courts should not order hospitals and physicians to administer ivermectin against their will | J Bellamy
The Brownstein protocol is not a proven treatment for COVID-19 | D Gorski
Oleandra – The New COVID Snake Oil | S Novella
Chiropractors continue to make claims about chiropractic and COVID-19 | S Gavura
TCM for COVID-19 | H Hall
Chinese government recommends bear bile for COVID-19 | J Bellamy
Fake Homeopathy COVID Scam | S Novella
Homeopathy and COVID 45: The Toothless Old Man Laughs | M Crislip
Naturopaths exploit COVID-19 with unproven treatments and self-promotion | J Bellamy
Pandemic drives huge surge in herbal remedy sales | S Gavura
BOO: Or how “magic dirt” became a MLM miracle cure scam for COVID-19 | D Gorski
Bovine Pancreatic Insufficiency | M Crislip
Doctors Who Performatively Fetishized RCTs Aren’t Out to Advance Medical Research, But Rather to Sow Doubt & Mistrust | J. Howard
Do You Have Coronaphobiaphobia? Ask Your Doctor if Notmybizumab is Right for You. | J Howard
Treating the Unvaccinated | S Novella
More drug shortages due to COVID-19 | S Gavura
POLITICS, LAW, AND REGULATIONS
Dr. Joseph Ladapo’s assault on public health in Florida: Will it be coming to the federal government next year? | D Gorski
Hopkins Business School to Platform COVID-19 Contrarians at Health Policy Symposium | A Neitzel
Stanford University will host a conference on pandemic planning featuring the usual (COVID-19) suspects | D Gorski
An Open Letter to the President of Stanford, Jonathan Levin: Don’t Censor Drs. Scott Atlas, John Ioannidis, Sunetra Gupta, Marty Marky, Monica Gandhi, Jay Bhattacharya, and Vinay Prasad. Amplify Their Voices. | J Howard
Open Letter II: President Levin, There Are Now 160 Million Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Have Censored We Want Them Infected Doctors | J Howard
The President of Stanford Is Unsure Which Number is Larger, 9 or 133 | J Howard
Canadian authorities warn chiropractors and naturopaths against making false COVID-19 claims | J Bellamy
NewsGuard identifies social media “super-spreaders” of COVID-19 misinformation | J Bellamy
Trump administration announces some COVID-19 tests can skip FDA review, providing new opportunities for dubious lab tests | J Bellamy
Is the FDA is Hiding “Evidence” the COVID Vaccine Killed Children? | J Howard
“Fauci Files” and Florida’s Grand Jury Investigations Fail to Deliver | M Harris
Government watchdog to investigate politicization of CDC and FDA during COVID-19 pandemic | J Bellamy
FDA and FTC issue more warning letters citing products and services making illegal COVID claims | J Bellamy
COVID-19 vaccine rollout creates new scamming opportunities for crooks | J Bellamy
“Health Freedom” group promotes legislation negating masks, other public health measures | J Bellamy
Experts Abused for Talking to the Public | S Novella
The “Natural Immunity is Real Act”: Real or an act? | J Bellamy
FTC warns naturopaths, acupuncturists, physicians, and chiropractors about false and misleading COVID-19 claims | J Bellamy
FTC targets physicians’ COVID claims with cease-and-desist letters | J Bellamy
Are the FDA’s VRBPAC and the CDC’s ACIP hopelessly compromised by conflicts of interest over COVID-19 vaccines? | D Gorski
Why are physicians threatened by efforts to report doctors to their state medical board for COVID-19 misinformation? | D Gorski
The Oregon Medical Board suspends the medical license of antivax pediatrician Dr. Paul Thomas | D Gorski
State legislators dispense with standard of care for COVID treatment and encourage medical misinformation | J Bellamy
State legislatures consider bills prohibiting COVID-19 vaccination mandates and other public health measures | J Bellamy
Dr. Joseph Ladapo of “America’s Frontline Doctors” is now in charge of public health in Florida | J Bellamy
Florida Surgeon General declares single positive COVID test proves immunity forever | J Bellamy
The ABIM vs. medical misinformation: Better late than never? | D Gorski
“Censorship” and “thoughtcrime”? Antivaxxers and COVID-19 contrarians attack California AB 2098 | D Gorski
The Great Barrington Declaration Was Silenced. So Why are They Silencing Me? | J Howard
Consumer groups urge feds to act against Mercola and his false COVID-19 claims | J Bellamy
Mercola and Kennedy sue Sen. Elizabeth Warren for combating their COVID misinformation | J Bellamy
COVID-19 vaccines and the Nuremberg Code | D Gorski
COVID vaccine manufacturers should explore legal action against anti-vaxxers spreading disinformation | J Bellamy
Plexus: MLM Strikes Again | H Hall
Voices in the Vacuum | N Solenkova
The Pandemic As Spectacle | J Howard
Audience Capture: When COVID Influencers Follow Their Followers | J Howard
The Wellness Company: How antivaccine grift becomes plain old quackery | D. Gorski
The Federation of State Medical Boards vs. COVID-19 misinformation: A losing battle so far | D Gorski
State medical boards vs. COVID-19 misinformation, an update | D Gorski
Tennessee hamstrings medical board fight against COVID misinformation and unproven treatments | J Bellamy
COVID-19 has exposed the toothlessness of state medical boards | D Gorski
Open Letter to a Dean: You’re Allowed to Speak | J Howard
Retracted papers about COVID-19 are more highly cited than they should be | D Gorski
Open Letter to a Medical Student Part 2: “It Was Criminal in My Mind” | J Howard
It Will Take More Than “Courage” to Restore Public Trust in Medicine | J Kreinbrook
Ron Johnson’s “vaccine round table” does little to actually help patients. | F Han
Federal employment rights agency inundated with thousands of COVID-related discrimination claims | J Bellamy
Anti-vaccination ideology and COVID misinformation in chiropractic continuing education courses: “Plandemic” edition | J Bellamy
A Modest Proposal: Close Pediatric Cancer Hospitals | J Howard
Dear President Trump: Jealous Deep State Haters and Losers Want to Destroy YOUR Genius, Lifesaving, Nobel-Prize Winning Achievement. YOUR Vaccine. | J Howard
Our Medical Establishment Supports Viral Mandates | J Howard
Baffled | M Crislip
Science Based Satire: What I Would Have Done | J. Howard
Science Based Satire: BOMBSHELL NEWS!!! The Virus I Told You Not to Worry About and Worked to Infect You With… CAME FROM A LAB!!! | J Howard
Science Based Satire: We Should Repeatedly Expose Unvaccinated Children to a Novel Virus That Came From a Lab in China. | J Howard
Science Based Satire: The CDC’s Unyielding, Unscientific Push to Vaccinate Children Against COVID Caused a Measles Outbreak in Europe | J. Howard
Science-Based Satire: Vaccine-Mandates and the Denial of the Existence of Natural Immunity After COVID Recovery. A Deadly Anti-Science Position | J Howard
Science Based Satire: Trashing the COVID Vaccine is the Only Way to Maintain Trust in Vaccines | J Howard
Science Based Satire: Sure, COVID Is Killing 1,500 Americans Per Week, But I Saw a Stranger Wearing a Mask…OUTSIDE! | J Howard
Science Based Satire: We Need Randomized Controlled Clinical Trials of SARS-CoV-2 | J Howard
   
Science-Based Medicine Reviews: COVID
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2025 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 

So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through ??. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.

You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.

Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 





EPIDEMIOLOGY AND PHYSIOLOGY

Coronavirus Myths and Facts
The novel Coronavirus 2019 is a serious outbreak that is reason for concern, but not panic, and we will all benefit from an evidence-based approach.
Steven Novella on March 4, 2020
Link

There is legitimate reason to be concerned about the novel Coronavirus epidemic, but that does not mean there is reason to panic. Fear is fertile ground for conspiracy theories, snake oil, and general misinformation, and it seems like we are due for a round of separating fact from fiction about the Coronavirus. Let’s start with some basic background and an update on the numbers.
SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19
Coronavirus is a genus of viruses that are zoonotic, meaning they can be shared between humans and other animals, and cause respiratory illness in humans. There are four strains known to cause the common cold. There are now three strains that cause severe respiratory illness – SARS (technically SARS-CoV), MERS, and now SARS-CoV-2, as the new strain is officially known. SARS stands for “Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome” while MERS stands for “Middle Eastern Respiratory Syndrome”. The new virus is similar to SARS, and so is essentially SARS-2.
The illness produced by SARS-CoV-2 is the Coronavirus Disease 2019, or COVID-19 for short. We are still in the middle of this epidemic, and so it will take time to sort out the full characteristics of this illness. But here are the numbers so far: Total confirmed infections: 94,200; Total deaths: 3,219. There are reported cases in over 80 countries. Neither the CDC nor the WHO have declared the disease a pandemic yet, but it seems inevitable and imminent. The term “pandemic” does not have a strict technical definition, but basically it means there is sustained person-to-person spread in multiple countries. If we are not there yet, we are close. In any case, the CDC and WHO are talking about “pandemic preparedness”.
The mortality rate of COVID-19 so far is about 6% (counting completed cases). About 17% of people confirmed to have the disease have a serious illness, while most people will have a mild to moderate illness. These percentages can change depending on whether or not you count people who have the virus but are asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic. But of course, that will also significantly increase the number of cases.
To put these numbers into further perspective, the 2019-2020 flu season so far has seen 32-45 million cases in the US alone, with 18,000-46,000 deaths. A typical flu year kills 646,000 people worldwide. These numbers dwarf the scale of COVID-19 – that’s over 200 times as many deaths so far. But this does not mean there is no reason for concern about COVID-19. The death rate is much higher (6% vs 0.1%). If COVID-19 spreads on a scale similar to a typical flu, the death toll would be in the tens of millions worldwide.
That is what the CDC, WHO, and world governments are trying to prevent. This is exactly why now is the time to take action to limit the spread of COVID-19.
Will COVID-19 spontaneously burn out?
This is a tough question to answer, and has grabbed headlines with President Trump’s declaration that the virus will die out as soon as Spring hits. The bottom line, however, is that no one knows. Flu and other respiratory viruses do not like the heat. They do not last as long on surfaces, and do not spread as easily. This is likely to be the case for SARS-CoV-2, but we simply don’t know how significant this will be. There are other reasons that respiratory viruses spread more in the winter – children are together in schools, and they have less immunity because they have not been exposed to as many viruses.
There are therefore a range of possibilities here. In the best case scenario, spread of the virus will significantly decrease when Summer hits the Northern Hemisphere. However, this is also when Winter will hit the Southern Hemisphere. The worst-case scenario is that the virus will still spread during the Summer, just less, and will bounce back in the Winter (like what happens every flu season). In this case SARS-CoV-2 will become endemic, with continuous seasonal spread around the world. We may have to live with this new virus like we live with the flu.
Prospects for a vaccine
There is both good and bad news for a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine. First the bad news – best-case scenario, it takes 18-24 months to develop and test an effective vaccine, and this is an accelerated timetable. So a vaccine is not going to stop the current outbreak. The race to develop a vaccine is therefore about stopping the future spread of the virus.
The good news is that researchers are making progress. The CDC is able to grow the virus in their labs for study. Researchers have identified the spike protein on the outside of the virus that allows it to bind and infect human cells. Antibodies against this protein could be an effective vaccine. Further, so far the virus has not displayed any extreme mutation, so vaccine targets might be stable over time. Bottom line – the prospects of a vaccine are good, but it’s going to take a couple of years probably.
There is also the potential for drug treatments of the infection. Researcher have also identified a protease necessary for the virus to replicate, and this can potentially be blocked by drugs. Such a drug would likely work against all Coronaviruses. Again, though, this takes time to develop and test.
I think the way to look at drugs and vaccines for COVID-19 is this – if the disease runs its course over 2020 and then burns itself out, then great. If not, then we will have drugs and vaccines coming online soon to help mitigate the disease. But these are not going to help us in 2020, so we need standard procedures to reduce the spread of infection. I already wrote about such techniques – wash your hands with soap for at least 15 seconds. Do this when you are traveling, out in public, or may have been exposed. Masks can be helpful if you wear them properly and consistently in an outbreak area, but don’t rely on them. Stay away from people who may be infected, and if you are sick, stay home. Of course, it’s difficult to get billions of people to all do the right thing at the same time.
COVID-19 pseudoscience
Of course there is also rank pseudoscience taking advantage of the fear and ignorance about COVID-19 and science and medicine in general. Many of the familiar snake oils are making the rounds, such as colloidal silver. This is a dangerous product that should not be taken internally, and there is no evidence it is effective against any infection.
The virus is also an opportunity to spread fear and conspiracies, and use the resulting panic to sell things like bulk food. Alex Jones has perfected this model and continues to do so with COVID-19.
There are too many quack remedies out there to do anything approaching a complete guide. The best advice is to rely on authoritative sites, like the CDC, WHO, or respected research institutions for information. Take the common-sense precautions I outlined above, read the CDC documents on what to do, and don’t panic. Don’t believe conspiracy theories, or claims for miracle cures. Probably any alleged cure out there has already been debunked here and elsewhere, so look for skeptical information on any such claims.

COVID-19 update: What you need to know now that it’s officially a pandemic
On March 11, the World Health Organization officially declared the COVID-19 to be a pandemic. The causative virus, SARS-CoV-2 is spreading through the population. What can be done? Social distancing is the only hope of slowing down spread of the disease.
David Gorski on March 16, 2020
Link

As I sat down to write today’s post, I realized that it would be hard to write about anything other than the coronavirus pandemic, given that last week was the week that, as they say, “shit got real” and the news is about little else. This is not the sort of post that I normally do, given that it’s more straight “medical blogging” than we usually do here at SBM, but it’s the sort of post that I, as editor, think that we need to write. Even though Steve did a great post a couple of weeks ago on coronavirus, events have been moving so rapidly that an update is definitely indicated. I write this realizing that, given how fast events are progressing, this post could be obsolete in just a week or two.
Of course, things got bad at least a couple of weeks ago in Italy (and several weeks before that in China), where in Lombardy hospitals and intensive care units are now so completely overwhelmed that the Italian College of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Resuscitation and Intensive Care (SIAARTI) wrote a remarkable set of guidelines stating that, in essence, wartime triage has become necessary because there are simply too many patients for all of them to receive adequate medical care. To give you an idea, over the weekend Italy reported its highest single-day death toll from COVID-19 (368), bringing its death toll to 1,809 deaths. Multiple European nations are following Italy’s lead in closing their borders, and France ordered all “non-indispensable” businesses closed, including restaurants, bars and movie theaters. It’s not alone. [NOTE added later: Monday morning, Michigan shut down all bars and restaurants except for carryout and delivery.]
Meanwhile, Seattle is under strain and suffering staffing shortages as its hospitals groan under the burden of COVID-19 patients, and it likely won’t be long before parts of the US resemble Lombardy, the wealthy area of Italy that’s been hardest hit. Meanwhile, panic buying of toilet paper (among other things) has spread throughout the entire US. (Indeed, I went to CVS on Saturday to pick up my blood pressure medicine prescription, and the store was totally cleaned out of ibuprofen, of all things.) It won’t be long before other parts of the US follow.
Elsewhere, in New Jersey Hoboken imposed a citywide 10 PM curfew and closed all of its bars, while Teaneck imposed self-quarantine on its residents. Friday, unable to deny the severity of the crisis any more, President Donald Trump finally declared a national state of emergency on Friday afternoon. In my own state, the governor ordered all schools closed at least until April 5; my university extended spring break a week in order to give faculty time to make the rest of their courses this term online-only; Henry Ford Hospital and its satellites are making contingency plans to set up tents to screen people before they enter the hospital and triage potential coronavirus patients; Detroit-area hospitals and nursing homes have imposed strict visitor restrictions. The list goes on. As I said, last week was the week when shit got real in the US. So let’s get into it.
What are coronaviruses and COVID-19?
Coronaviruses are a genus of viruses that can infect humans and animals. In humans, coronaviruses can cause the “common cold” (the common cold is actually caused by a number of different viruses, but coronavirus strains cause around one-quarter) but certain strains can cause severe disease in humans. For instance, there was an epidemic of SARS (severe acute respiratory distress syndrome), which was caused by a novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV) that started in the Guangdong province of southern China in 2002 and went on to involve 26 countries, infect over 8,000 people, and result in nearly 800 deaths between 2002 and 2003. (I remember that the American Association for Cancer Research meeting in April 2003 was canceled and rescheduled for July.) Even more deadly was the MERS (Middle Eastern respiratory syndrome, caused by MERS-CoV) outbreak, which originated in Saudi Arabia and resulted in 1,000 cases and over 400 deaths from 2012-2015. SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and SARS-CoV-2 belong to the betacoronavirus subtype.
The first cases of disease in the current pandemic were reported in Wuhan, China in December 2019. Just a word on nomenclature, the new strain of coronavirus responsible for the pandemic has been named SARS-CoV-2, and the disease it causes “coronavirus disease 2019” (abbreviated “COVID-19”). According to the CDC, COVID-19 has been detected in more than 100 locations internationally, and on January 30, 2020, the International Health Regulations Emergency Committee of the WHO declared the outbreak a “public health emergency of international concern.” On March 11, the WHO officially declared COVID-19 to be a pandemic, and, as I mentioned above, on March 13, President Trump declared a national emergency in response.
How does SARS-CoV-2 spread?
The first cases of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China were thought to have arisen due to spread of this novel coronavirus from animal to human. Currently, it’s thought that SARS-CoV-2 arose in bats and made the jump to humans through an intermediary species in the Wuhan markets. That “other species” is still not clear, although it is suspected that the intermediary might have been pangolins, which are popular in traditional Chinese medicine. (No, contrary to a conspiracy theory popular now, SARS-CoV-2 is not an escaped bioweapon that came from a failed attempt to develop a vaccine to the 2002-2003 SARS.)
Of course, now person-to-person transmission is the main way that COVID-19 is spread. People with the disease cough or sneeze, spreading respiratory droplets, which can land either in another person’s nose or mouth or on nearby objects, which other people can touch. When those people then touch their face, nose, mouth, or eyes, the disease infects them. Usually, symptoms start with a cough and fever, but in a minority of those infected the virus infects the lungs, leading to severe disease.
That’s why hand washing and trying very hard not to touch your face is so important. And I don’t mean the half-assed hand washing that we all sometimes do when we’re in a hurry, but rather a good solid hand washing with soap and water scrubbing all surfaces for at least 20-30 seconds. Hand sanitizers with at least 60% alcohol work too, but not as well as hand washing. Basically, wash your hands after touching anything that might harbor the virus. It’s also not a bad idea to carry around disposable paper towels to use open when opening doors and pushing elevator buttons and the like.
Regular facemasks are not very effective and only recommended by the WHO if you are taking care of someone with a known or suspected case of COVID-19 or if you’re coughing yourself, to avoid infecting others. The much more stringent N95 respirators are recommended only for health care personnel during procedures and contact that generate respiratory droplets, and I note that such respirators must be fit-tested to be effective. Unfortunately, there’s been a run on masks, both regular and N95 respirators, leading to shortages for health care personnel who need them.
Finally, social distancing is an important strategy to prevent infection (more on that later).
Why is COVID-19 so concerning?
COVID-19 symptoms can range from asymptomatic to severe pneumonia leading to organ failure and death. COVID-19 in most people is mild and resembles the common cold. According to the WHO, symptoms include fever (87.9%), dry cough (67.7%), fatigue (38.1%), sputum production (33.4%), shortness of breath (18.6%), sore throat (13.9%), headache (13.6%), muscle or joint aches (14.8%), chills (11.4%), nausea or vomiting (5.0%), nasal congestion (4.8%), diarrhea (3.7%), coughing up blood (0.9%), and conjunctival congestion (0.8%). Symptoms generally occur an average of 5-6 days after infection, but the range is from one to 14 days.
Now here’s the reason the prospect of COVID-19 spreading through the population is so concerning. Quoting the WHO report:
Most people infected with COVID-19 virus have mild disease and recover. Approximately 80% of laboratory confirmed patients have had mild to moderate disease, which includes non-pneumonia and pneumonia cases, 13.8% have severe disease (dyspnea, respiratory frequency ≥30/minute, blood oxygen saturation ≤93%, PaO2/FiO2 ratio <300, and/or lung infiltrates >50% of the lung field within 24-48 hours) and 6.1% are critical (respiratory failure, septic shock, and/or multiple organ dysfunction/failure). Asymptomatic infection has been reported, but the majority of the relatively rare cases who are asymptomatic on the date of identification/report went on to develop disease. The proportion of truly asymptomatic infections is unclear but appears to be relatively rare and does not appear to be a major driver of transmission.
Dyspnea means shortness of breath, and a respiratory frequency of greater than 30 breaths/minute is very alarming (a normal respiratory rate is between 12-20 breaths/minute), and an O2 saturation of <93% on room air in someone who was previously healthy is not good. As for lung infiltrates on chest X-ray, when disease is severe, SARS-CoV-2 causes bilateral diffuse lung infiltrates. An infiltrate is nothing more than a substance denser than air that shows up as white blotches on chest X-ray. In the lungs, such infiltrates usually mean fluid, inflammation, or pus. Here’s what they look like:

Here’s what a normal chest x-ray looks like:
You get the idea. Let’s just say that such infiltrates result in impaired oxygen exchange. In any case, this pneumonia can set off a cascade of systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) and multiple organ dysfunction, which, when it happens, has a high mortality.
Understandably, what everyone worries about is simple: What are my odds of dying if I get COVID-19? (And a lot of us are going to get it.) The answer, of course, is: It depends. Last week the CDC estimated the case fatality rate for COVID-19 (the percent of patients with confirmed disease who die) to from 0.25%-3.0%. That’s all comers. Why the uncertainty? Compared to the likely prevalence of COVID-19, not very many people have been tested, particularly in the US, where, in my not-so-humble opinion (and not just me), testing has been criminally botched. In calculating case fatality rates, the denominator is the number of people with the disease, and we just don’t have a good handle on that yet, meaning that these estimates are likely too high. Even so, the lowest estimates (around 0.7%) are at least five to seven times higher than the case fatality rates for seasonal influenza (0.1%), and the highest CDC-estimated rate is around 30 times more deadly than the flu.
There’s a wrinkle, though. Although it’s true that we could be overestimating case fatality rates because of asymptomatic transmission and an unknown number of asymptomatic cases artificially lowering the denominator, we could also be underestimating the case fatality rate. Correspondence published last week in The Lancet Infectious Diseases noted:
As of March 1, 2020, 79,968 patients in China and 7,169 outside of China had tested positive for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).1 Among Chinese patients, 2873 deaths had occurred, equivalent to a mortality rate of 3.6% (95% CI 3.5–3.7), while 104 deaths from COVID-19 had been reported outside of China (1·5% [1.2–1.7]). However, these mortality rate estimates are based on the number of deaths relative to the number of confirmed cases of infection, which is not representative of the actual death rate; patients who die on any given day were infected much earlier, and thus the denominator of the mortality rate should be the total number of patients infected at the same time as those who died. Notably, the full denominator remains unknown because asymptomatic cases or patients with very mild symptoms might not be tested and will not be identified. Such cases therefore cannot be included in the estimation of actual mortality rates, since actual estimates pertain to clinically apparent COVID-19 cases.
And:
We re-estimated mortality rates by dividing the number of deaths on a given day by the number of patients with confirmed COVID-19 infection 14 days before. On this basis, using WHO data on the cumulative number of deaths to March 1, 2020, mortality rates would be 5·6% (95% CI 5.4–5.8) for China and 15.2% (12·5–17·9) outside of China. Global mortality rates over time using a 14-day delay estimate are shown in the figure, with a curve that levels off to a rate of 5.7% (5·5–5·9), converging with the current WHO estimates. Estimates will increase if a longer delay between onset of illness and death is considered. A recent time-delay adjusted estimation indicates that mortality rate of COVID-19 could be as high as 20% in Wuhan, the epicentre of the outbreak.6 These findings show that the current figures might underestimate the potential threat of COVID-19 in symptomatic patients.
So which is it, 0.25%-3.0% or around 5.7%? Or is it something different, such as reported here, where estimates range from 3.9% in China to 2.4% for the rest of the world? The answer is: We don’t know yet, because we don’t know how many people have been infected and how many of those are asymptomatic. It is, however, very likely that symptomatic patients will have a higher case fatality rate, but there isn’t anything particularly striking in that observation because asymptomatic patients are highly unlikely to die of COVID-19. Suffice to say that, right now, estimates for case fatality rates are all over the map between around 0.5% and 6.0%. Over time, estimates will likely converge on a more reliable rate. There’s a caveat, though. It’s important to remember that case fatality rates are context-specific, changing with time and location. There is no single case fatality rate for a disease. We also need to be very careful interpreting case fatality rate estimates during the middle of an outbreak or pandemic. Many are currently infected, and we don’t yet know which ones will recover or die—or even accurately which ones are infected.
Again, though, this is for all comers. If there’s one thing we know thus far, it’s that COVID-19 appears to be much less serious in children and that it’s much deadlier for the elderly. For instance, in China, there were no reported deaths in children 9 years old and under, but the case fatality rate in adults over 80 was high. Here is a graph from Vox:
Here are data from China comparing COVID-19 to seasonal influenza:
Here are data from Italy:
3. Some data from the Lombardy #Covid19 outbreak — like elsewhere, almost no deaths under age 50. pic.twitter.com/AQxtz4PztC
— Helen Branswell 🇨🇦 (@HelenBranswell) March 13, 2020
The median age for those who died was 64:
5. More data from Cecconi’s #Covid19 presentation through #JAMALive. pic.twitter.com/OFvxW0O9j8
— Helen Branswell (@HelenBranswell) March 13, 2020
And here’s a useful comparison:
Case fatality rate of COVID-19 vs 1918 flu vs seasonal flu as a function of age. COVID-19 is worse than seasonal flu but doesn’t seem to have the mortality peaks for young children and young adults that were seen in 1918 flu. https://t.co/o3961J3Nle pic.twitter.com/j2WeURchUT
— Claus Wilke (@ClausWilke) March 2, 2020
No matter what the “true” case fatality rates turn out to be, there is no denying that COVID-19 is much deadlier if you’re over 60 and alarmingly deadly for those over 80.
Flattening the curve
There’s more to worry about than case fatality rates, though. As noted above, roughly 20% of those with COVID-19 will develop disease severe enough to require hospitalization, with roughly 5-6% requiring mechanical ventilation. Given those numbers, it wouldn’t take very many cases relative to the total population to completely overwhelm our medical system. This has already happened in Italy, as I mentioned early on, to the point where Italian doctors have little choice but to institute wartime-like triage, and, again, Lombardy is a wealthy region with excellent medical facilities. It’s no wonder that, in the light of what we’re seeing in other parts of the world, doctors and public health officials are becoming very alarmed, with good reason.
Here’s where social distancing and the concept of “flattening the curve” comes in. Social distancing involves avoiding close contact with other people, preferably maintaining a six foot distance whenever possible. It is to promote social distancing that so many colleges have closed classes down in favor of online-only learning; so many schools have closed; NCAA March Madness is canceled; the baseball season put on indefinite hold; the basketball and hockey seasons prematurely has ended; so many professional conferences have been canceled or postponed; and so many universities and companies have banned business travel. It’s why Italy has closed all businesses except for the most essential, such as grocery stores and drug stores. It’s why Hoboken closed all of its bars, restaurants, daycares, movie theaters, gyms, and playgrounds.
How does this work? First, you have to understand that at this point we can’t prevent SARS-CoV-2 from spreading. It’s far, far too late for that. (The horse has left the proverbial barn, so to speak.) The virus is out and has been in the US several weeks at least. The strategy now is therefore to slow its spread as much as possible, the idea being, even if the total number of cases ends up being the same (although we do want to lower the total number of cases as much as possible and social distancing can achieve that), to keep the peak number of new cases per day/week/month as low as possible, hopefully low enough that COVID-19 cases don’t completely overwhelm our healthcare system and ICU bed capacity. When our hospital and ICU bed capacity is overwhelmed, more people die of coronavirus. However, more people also die of other causes due to delays in treatment when healthcare resources are unavailable due to being tied up caring for coronavirus patients.
You might have seen this graph, or one like it, on social media. It explains visually what I was trying to explain verbally:
Our #FlattenTheCurve graphic is now up on @Wikipedia with proper attribution & a CC-BY-SA licence. Please share far & wide and translate it into any language you can! Details in the thread below. #Covid_19 #COVID2019 #COVID19 #coronavirus Thanks to @XTOTL & @TheSpinoffTV pic.twitter.com/BQop7yWu1Q
— Dr Siouxsie Wiles (@SiouxsieW) March 10, 2020
Here is another version of the curve:
Of course, the peak of the lower curve could well brush up against or surpass the medical system’s capacity. Likely it will do just that in some parts of the country. Even so, that would be far more manageable than a scenario like the high peak number of cases, because the capacity of the healthcare system would be surpassed by much less.
Will it be enough? I don’t know. I have my doubts because of some Tweets I saw over the weekend. Here was Dublin on Saturday night:
Just sent to me from Temple bar.
Glad we are taking this serious.#COVIDー19 #CloseThePubs pic.twitter.com/YI1YOwzDV7
— Gareth Neary (@Tiananmens) March 14, 2020
And here was Chicago:
Just drove through Wrigleyville. Every bar on Clark Street has a long line of people ingreen regalia waiting to get drunk and spread a virus. pic.twitter.com/m28q5SnF3J
— Unlike web sites of the past. (@spiderstumbled) March 14, 2020
Elsewhere:
We are doomed pic.twitter.com/EpIXKo84IH
— Barstool Sports (@barstoolsports) March 15, 2020
Then there were utterly brain dead Tweets like this:
The fear is far worse than the virus. The governments have it wrong. Stay open for business. If not, so many more people will die from a crashing economy than from this virus. #corona #dustbowl #food #clothing #shelter
— Tim Draper (@TimDraper) March 14, 2020
And this:
I fear more draconian measures will soon be necessary in the US, measures similar to those in Italy. In fact, they’re arguably necessary now. We have the luxury of being a couple of weeks behind Europe in terms of the progress of the pandemic within our borders.
And then there are articles like this one by Heather Mac Donald on New Criterion, which uses “whataboutism” to downplay the potential severity of the COVID-19 pandemic:
Much has been made of the “exponential” rate of infection in European and Asian countries—as if the spread of all transmittable diseases did not develop along geometric, as opposed to arithmetic, growth patterns. What actually matters is whether or not the growing “pandemic” overwhelms our ability to ensure the well-being of U.S. residents with efficiency and precision. But fear of the disease, and not the disease itself, has already spoiled that for us. Even if my odds of dying from coronavirus should suddenly jump ten-thousand-fold, from the current rate of .000012 percent across the U.S. population all the way up to .12 percent, I’d happily take those odds over the destruction being wrought on the U.S. and global economy from this unbridled panic.
Her comparison of deaths due to automobile collisions elsewhere in the article is a particularly silly bit of whataboutism. Automobile collisions are not contagious, and we already do a lot of things to decrease the death rates, from requiring safety harnesses and airbags to improving highway and road design. Moreover, in the article, she also basically dismisses concerns about how hard COVID-19 hits the elderly because they don’t have much longer to live anyway. (Read it for yourself if you think I’m being unfair.) In any event, Ms. Mac Donald’s fear quotes around the word “pandemic” aside, her bit about whether the pandemic “overwhelms our ability to ensure the well-being of U.S. residents with efficiency and precision” is exactly the reason social distancing measures instituted early are so important, to prevent our health care system from being overwhelmed. Let’s put it another way. It’s estimated that, under a worst-case scenario, as many as three million in the US could require ventilation:
The maximum number of ventilators that could be put in the field in the United States is about 160,000. So under those scenarios, there would theoretically be enough capacity to meet the need.
But if the coronavirus outbreak gets worse, we could quickly run out. In a situation more similar to the Spanish flu pandemic (675,000 dead in the US), about 742,500 people in the United States would require ventilation, according to government estimates. We don’t have that many.
The health system is much more than ventilators, of course, and the concerns about capacity apply to the rest of it, too. As HuffPost’s Jonathan Cohn reported, US hospitals have about 45,000 beds in their intensive care units. In a moderate outbreak, about 200,000 patients may need to be put in the ICU, but under a more severe outbreak, it could be nearly 3 million.
That number can be drastically lowered through social distancing interventions. Moreover, acting early is far more effective at flattening the curve than acting late, as infectious disease epidemiologist Britta Jewel showed in a thought experiment in which she modeled the exponential growth of the number of COVID-19 cases:
She explains:
The graph illustrates the results of a thought experiment. It assumes constant 30 percent growth throughout the next month in an epidemic like the one in the U.S. right now, and compares the results of stopping one infection today — by actions such as shifting to online classes, canceling of large events and imposing travel restrictions — versus taking the same action one week from today.
The difference is stark. If you act today, you will have averted four times as many infections in the next month: roughly 2,400 averted infections, versus just 600 if you wait one week. That’s the power of averting just one infection, and obviously we would like to avert more than one.
The principle is that, with the exponential growth phase of an epidemic, individual and institutional actions such as social distancing taken early on can have a much greater impact than if the same actions are taken even a week later.
If you want another way to visualize how to “flatten the curve”, check out this simulator.
Ironically, to protect our population and our health care system is why we’re doing these things. Arguably, it might well be too little, too late. Only time will tell. Remember these words from Michael Levitt, former Secretary of Health and Human Services, “Everything we do before a pandemic will seem alarmist. Everything we do after a pandemic will seem inadequate.”
I really hope that, when this is all over, our actions today seem alarmist. I fear that they won’t, though. To show why, just look at this Tweet with graphs showing how accurate projections were for the number of cases and number of ICU patients in Italy:
Striking @TheLancet data on Italy’s increase in #COVID19 cases. I adapted their figure with today’s count: they are spot on. From 2,000 to 20,000 in 2 weeks (10X increase). Likewise expected rise in ICU pts. US government: #ActNow #SaveLives #CancelEverything #SocialDistancing pic.twitter.com/nGE8JocmuD
— Mark Drazner (@MarkDrazner) March 15, 2020
And if you really want to be alarmed, the worst case scenario modeled by the CDC for the US suggest as many as 214 million infected and 1.7 million dead.
Make no mistake. SARS-CoV-2 is in the US, and we are currently at the early end of these curves. The only question how robust the exponential phase of growth of the number of cases will be and whether we can successfully flatten the curve
Quackery and conspiracy theories
Unsurprisingly, whenever there are outbreaks or new pandemics, there are quacks. There is another time and place when I might write about them, such as the claim that SARS-CoV-2 is a bioweapon that escaped or the result of an attempt at a SARS vaccine gone wrong or that the flu vaccine increases susceptibility to COVID-19 (there’s no evidence that it does). There are also quacks galore recommending everything from homeopathy to colloidal silver to supplements to Hulda Clark’s zapper to chiropractic to prevent or treat COVID-19. It’s so bad that my local police department just emailed a notice to residents to beware of COVID-19 scams. I’m sure there will be plenty to write about in the coming months. And, make no mistake; this pandemic is not going to be over as quickly as many seem to think. It will last months, not weeks. It’s very difficult to predict, but not in the two- or three-week timeframes of current social distancing measures. They will very likely need to be extended much longer. On Meet the Press yesterday, Dr. Anthony Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, warned that US citizens would have to make personal sacrifices and comply with government guidelines to avoid a “worst-case scenario” and said, “Americans should be prepared that they are going to have to hunker down significantly more than we as a country are doing.”
So, until I (and others here) get a chance to write about more of these scams than the handful we’ve touched upon, be careful out there. Stay home as much as possible. (That goes double if you’re over 60, triple if you’re 80 or older.) Don’t fly if you can avoid it. Try not to touch your face. (Much easier said than done, as I’ve discovered.) If you can work from home, do so. Avoid unnecessary contact with strangers as much as you can. If you start developing symptoms, contact your doctor for instructions. If you test positive for SARS-CoV-2, self-quarantine as instructed unless you start to develop shortness of breath and need to go to the emergency room.
And, above all else, wash your stinking paws, you damned dirty apes!

More COVID-19 News
Some good and bad news about the Coronavirus.
Steven Novella on March 18, 2020
Link

On the one hand, everyone is probably tired of the incessant Coronavirus/Covid-19/pandemic news, but on the other hand that is the big news everyone wants to hear. We’re trying to strike a balance here, and in fact we should probably be writing more about it given the number of questions and requests I am receiving. David Gorski gave an excellent update just two days ago, and I wrote about Coronavirus myths vs facts two weeks ago. But the information is moving quickly and there has already been a few bits of news I thought worthy of another update.
I won’t give the numbers. Dave’s update will do, and there are plenty of sites from the CDC to the WHO if you want the latest up-to-the-second numbers. Bottom line – it’s bad. If you just look at the raw numbers it may not seem that impressive, especially since the number of cases and deaths are much higher in for the seasonal flu. But don’t be confused – this is a much more deadly virus, it is very contagious, and causes serious illness. I will reinforce was Dave reported and what the experts are endlessly saying – our hospital system will be overwhelmed (like it is in Italy) if we don’t slow down the spread of this disease through aggressive social distancing. Everyone needs to take this very seriously.
Ironically, if we are successful and avoid a worst-case scenario, like Hong Kong and some other locations have, then the uninformed cynics will say that it was all hype and panic. Don’t believe them. Don’t believe the talking heads saying that it is not that bad, that you should still go out and keep up your economic activity. Rather, we should be seriously preparing for social isolation for several weeks at least. This is likely beyond the experience of most Westerners living today, and it may be challenging, but I think we’re up to it if we ignore the naysayers. Listen to the experts instead.
Here are some bits of virus news, some encouraging, some sobering:
The virus can last for hours to days
This is a robust virus that can last for longer than we suspected in water droplets and on surfaces. A new study published in the NEJM found:
The scientists found that severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) was detectable in aerosols for up to three hours, up to four hours on copper, up to 24 hours on cardboard and up to two to three days on plastic and stainless steel.
This is important information, it means we have to consider all surfaces as contaminated. You do not need direct contact with someone who is sick in order to get CoV-2, you just have to touch a doorknob that someone touched the day before. Again, this is why social isolation is so important. And also, I will be the one millionth person to tell you – wash your hands in soap and water, scrubbing them for 20 seconds, and rinse in running water. Hand sanitizer with at least 60% alcohol will do as well, but you need to use a large amount (fill your palm) and scrub thoroughly. Don’t touch your face (you will, but just keep this in mind).
But also – keep surfaces not just clean but antiseptic. Use Lysol or an alcohol-based cleaner, and keep any surface people touch clean. This is especially important in public places. At the hospital where I work they hired a team of people to essentially roam around the hospital constantly sanitizing all surfaces. Also, if you have to go out, don’t touch things with your hands. You can operate many doors and other things with your elbow. A common route of the virus into your body is from your hands to your face. You touch something crawling with Coronavirus, then scratch your nose. This chain must be broken.
But of course, the virus survives for hours in aerosols, so keep your distance from other people, don’t go out, and if you have to, the masks help a little but don’t get a false sense of security from them.
SARS CoV-2 has a natural origin
This may be “yeah, duh” news for most people reading this, but it is important to note that scientists have studied the novel Coronavirus specifically to determine its origin. A recent study concludes that it was definitely not engineered. It is a naturally-occurring virus, meaning that it evolved outside of the lab, and was not created in any way. The authors write:
SARS-CoV-2 is the seventh coronavirus known to infect humans; SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 can cause severe disease, whereas HKU1, NL63, OC43 and 229E are associated with mild symptoms6. Here we review what can be deduced about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 from comparative analysis of genomic data. We offer a perspective on the notable features of the SARS-CoV-2 genome and discuss scenarios by which they could have arisen. Our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus.
This is important factual information for countering all the conspiracy theories out there. Of course it will not sway the conspiracy theorists themselves, they are immune to facts (that is the core nature of conspiracy thinking). They will dismiss this news as part of the conspiracy. But for those who still respect facts, this is reassuring. It is also good information for those who heard about the conspiracies and are curious, but able to be persuaded by information.
Vaccine development moves to human trials
I will end with some good news – the scientific study of CoV-2 has been incredibly fast, almost unprecedented. The scientific community is essentially “scienceing the shit” out of this pandemic. Already we are starting the first human trials of a potential vaccine. This is just preliminary testing, mostly for safety but also to look at biological markers to see if the vaccine is doing what it is supposed to do. This is not a live-virus vaccine, so cannot cause disease, but rather contains a DNA fragment from the virus.
We cannot predict exactly how long it will take to fully develop and deploy a vaccine. Estimates are from 12-18 months, hopefully at the sooner end of the spectrum. We also don’t know how protective it will be. But anything will help, it will reduce the number of receptive hosts, and make it more difficult for the virus to spread through a population (herd immunity).
This is, perhaps, one good thing that will come out of this pandemic. It is coming at a time when reality, facts, and expertise are under fire. The basic concepts themselves are being challenged. But now we are seeing in an obvious first-hand way the pitfalls of making your own reality, of denying facts and science. Real scientists are also coming to the rescue.
Perhaps the world will take note – when it really matters, we need facts and science. Reality doesn’t care what we believe. It does not alter itself to conform to our delusions and desires. So we better conform our beliefs to reality. That’s science.

Winning the COVID Marathon
The most important difference between the COVID-19 pandemic and all previous pandemics is the power of our science. We should acknowledge and maximize that.
Steven Novella on June 3, 2020
Link

The COVID-19 pandemic, caused by the novel SARS-CoV-2 virus, has stressed many of our institutions and revealed weaknesses and disparities in our society. But it also has showcased a great deal of strength. The question is – which forces will predominate in the end? I think the overarching lesson the pandemic has reinforced is that science is the most powerful tool humanity has developed to deal with nature, but it needs support from society and other institutions.
Let’s start by quickly reviewing the state of the science of COVID-19. In December 2019 four pneumonia cases were identified in Wuhan, China that were all tied to an animal market. This triggered a rapid response team which used epidemiological disease tracing to identify more patients and determine that there was person-to-person spread. By January 12 the novel coronavirus was isolated and identified as the cause of a new respiratory illness. On January 24 a full genome sequence of the new virus was published. This sequence was rapidly shared with the world. Scientists around the world then began sequencing different strains of the virus, which played an important role in our ability to track the spread of the virus.
It’s easy to take this technology for granted, but we should not forget how powerful and recent this tool is. In about a month we went from discovering an entirely new disease to identifying and sequencing the genome of the responsible virus, then using it to track its spread. This information has also armed scientists with tools they could use to understand the virus, probe for its strengths and weaknesses, and begin the search for treatments.
That search also started very early on in the pandemic. Hydroxychloroquine has received a disproportionate amount of attention, but for political, not scientific reasons. In any case this spawned dozens of scientific studies, with increasing rigor, and again within a couple of months we were able to determine that the drug probably does not work for COVID-19, and in fact may make outcomes worse due to cardiac side effects. Still, even more rigorous studies are under way to increase our confidence in this conclusion.
But hydroxychloroquine is not the only game in town. Doctors have tried over 100 different drugs for off-label use against the virus, based upon scientific plausibility. This is perhaps not ideal, but because of the nature of the pandemic speed is being prioritized. As long as some scientific method is used to determine as objectively as possible if there is any benefit, some useful treatment may come out of this.
Perhaps most promising so far is remdesivir. Clinical trials have now shown that recovery is quicker for patients receiving this anti-viral drug, although the percentage of patients recovering was not statistically different – although there was a trend toward greater survival. More studies are needed to confirm these results, and more powerful studies may reach statistical significance on survival. But we will wait to see what these trials show, and will listen to the data whatever it says.
In fact, one challenge for doctors and scientists is dealing with the flood of scientific evidence:
By one estimate, the COVID-19 literature published since January has reached more than 23,000 papers and is doubling every 20 days—among the biggest explosions of scientific literature ever.
What this means is that we have a deep reserve of scientists in the world, who can mobilize their efforts to address an acute threat, like COVID-19. This is an incredibly rapid explosion of knowledge.
Scientific research has also informed us about the accuracy of our various testing methods. We can test for the virus to see if someone is currently infected. We can test for antibodies to see if someone has been previously exposed. Better and more rapid tests are being developed, with greater sensitivity and specificity.
Scientists are studying the effectiveness of wearing masks, in what situations, and by whom.
There is also research promising to introduce new treatments for COVID-19. A recent study was the first clinical trial published of convalescent plasma for the treatment of COVID-19. This uses the plasma from blood of patients who have recovered from the disease, which likely contains antibodies to the virus. These antibodies can provide temporary treatment against the virus in those who are currently sick but whose immune systems have not had enough time to gear up against the virus. This is a preliminary study, showing safety and that the outcomes appear promising. But it sets the stage for more rigorous studies that will determine effectiveness.
And of course scientists are working on rapidly developing a vaccine for SARS-CoV-2 that could potentially change the nature of this pandemic. It remains to be seen how long this will take, and how effective such a vaccine will be. But a vaccine is perhaps the best hope of reducing the spread of the virus so it is no longer at pandemic levels.
Because of the strain of the lockdown, and climbing numbers of cases and deaths, and the disruption to society, it may seem like this pandemic has been going on for a long time. But in reality it has only been a total of five months since the first cases. Still, the burden it taking a heavy toll and in the US and elsewhere we are moving into a tricky phase of this pandemic. This is where patience and a respect for the power of the science that has been unleashed against this virus is important.
This is the great irony of humanity. We have incredibly powerful tools, and the ability to use them quickly to understand and deal with this threat. We are doing it, more quickly than ever before. There is still a lot we don’t know about this virus, but the amount of information we do know increases daily. Doctors are getting better at treating the disease. We are collectively getting better at knowing how to flatten the spread. Treatments are coming online, with many promising treatments in the pipeline.
We also can use science to quickly spot pseudoscience, snake oil, and the hucksters that would use the pandemic to cynically make money off their fellow citizens. A lot of this snake oil is still thriving, but for people who want to listen to the science, they can protect themselves.
But in the face of all this powerful science, we are also seeing the weaknesses in our other institutions. Clearly China failed to quickly warn the world about this disease, and the delay has contributed to the pandemic. The slow response of the US has also demonstrably led to increased deaths. Politicians and pundits have also not always listened to scientists.
This is a time when understanding and dealing with reality in incredibly important, with immediate and obvious results. The penchant of politicians and those in power to determine their own reality simply does not work. The virus does not listen to political propaganda.
Epidemiologists are now showing the path forward, for how we can safely open up while minimizing the chance and size of a second wave. This includes using objective metrics, testing, contact tracing, and targeted isolation. We don’t know what will happen, but we have a good idea how to give ourselves the best chance of minimizing the damage this pandemic is causing. Right now we are trying to buy time so that we can identify effective drugs to treat the disease, develop a vaccine, and bring other treatments online such as plasma treatments. The key is – not to get restless. We need the endurance to see this through.
I find it helpful to think of past pandemics. Imaging living through the 1918 flu pandemic that conservatively killed 50,000,000 people around the world. That virus was no worse than SARS-CoV-2, and may not even have been as deadly by itself. The difference was largely in the state of the science at the time. Imagine how helpless people felt at the time. Think about how much more powerful our response is to COVID-19. The difference is the power of our science.

The Origins of SARS-CoV-2
The joint WHO-China investigation report concludes that a lab origin for COVID-19 is “extremely unlikely” but doubts remain.
Steven Novella on March 31, 2021
Link

It may seem strange that more than a year after the emergence of the coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 and the COVID-19 pandemic it created we are still debating the origins of the virus. The question remains important, however, and recently the World Health Organization (WHO) and Chinese scientists concluded their investigation into those origins. The report was frustratingly less than conclusive.
The investigation was actually launched in May of 2020, with groundwork investigations beginning in July. Final investigations in China were completed earlier this year, and the full report was just published. According to the report:
The joint international team comprised 17 Chinese and 17 international experts from other countries, the World Health Organization (WHO), the Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network (GOARN), and the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) (Annex B). The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) participated as an observer. Following initial online meetings, a joint study was conducted over a 28-day period from 14 January to 10 February 2021 in the city of Wuhan, People’s Republic of China.
Let’s review the main findings, keeping in mind that science is often a matter of probability. There was no smoking gun proving a specific origin, and the team has had to rely on scientific inference.
One focus of the investigation was simply tracking the emergence of COVID-19. The team found no evidence of an increase in pneumonia-like illness, all-cause mortality, or even purchase of medications to treat fever or respiratory symptoms prior to the emergence of illness in Wuhan in late 2019. Increase in hospitalizations and deaths started to rise in Wuhan in January 2020, and then later outside Wuhan but within Hubei Province. So the evidence does support the emergence of COVID-19 in and around Wuhan. Further, extensive review of hospital records did not find any likely cases of COVID-19 in October or November 2019 in Wuhan, so it was likely not circulating prior to its emergence in December.
That was the epidemiological evidence. Scientists on the team also looked at molecular evidence – studying the virus itself. They found:
Evidence from surveys and targeted studies so far have shown that the coronaviruses most highly related to SARS-CoV-2 are found in bats and pangolins, suggesting that these mammals may be the reservoir of the virus that causes COVID-19. However, neither of the viruses identified so far from these mammalian species is sufficiently similar to SARS-CoV-2 to serve as its direct progenitor. In addition to these findings, the high susceptibility of mink and cats to SARS-CoV2 suggests that additional species of animals may act as a potential reservoir.
This supports the prior conclusion that SARS-CoV-2 is a zoonotic virus – coming from an animal reservoir. The scientists think it is likely that the virus originated in bats but came to humans through another species, as yet unidentified. This is supported by other investigations finding that SARS-CoV-2-related coronaviruses are endemic in the bat and pangolin populations of Southeast Asia. However, SARS-CoV-2 itself was not found in any wild or domestic animal population in China. So it did not come directly from an animal reservoir, but mutated to SARS-CoV-2 as it jumped to humans, probably through an intermediary species.
Molecular analysis can also track the viral strains as they spread. Fortunately Hunan hospitals kept samples from early patients, so those viruses could be studied. They found that there was likely a cluster of cases from the Huanan meat market, but that was not the origin of the virus as different strains were already circulating. They also calculated the time to the most recent common ancestor of all the early strains, which dates to probably late November to early December 2019. An earlier origin in October cannot be ruled out, however.
A lot of attention was paid to the Huanan market as a possible origin of the virus. They did find many samples from the market that were contaminated with SARS-CoV-2. They could have been contaminated by people in the market already sick with COVID-19. Also, the market included cold-chain meats and products from 20 different countries. It is possible that the virus came to that market through one of these cold chains, although no evidence of a specific source of contamination was found. The virus can survive in frozen meats, however, so this possibility remains plausible.
Through their direct investigation and review of the published literature, the WHO team considered four possible sources for COVID-19 and the likelihood of each:
    • direct zoonotic spillover is considered to be a possible-to-likely pathway;
    • introduction through an intermediate host is considered to be a likely to very likely pathway;
    • introduction through cold/food chain products is considered a possible pathway;
    • introduction through a laboratory incident was considered to be an extremely unlikely pathway
Of course, the “extremely unlikely pathway” of a lab accident has received a lot of media attention, which is understandable. The investigators could not rule out a lab origin, but there was no direct evidence for it, and the totality of evidence from epidemiology and molecular biology make it the least likely scenario. The joint WHO-China findings have received some international criticism. In a joint statement of 14 countries, including the US, the WHO and China were urged to provide full transparency, and criticized the mission for: “significantly delayed and lacked access to complete, original data and samples”.
This leaves the door open that China was hiding data that may have pointed to a lab origin for SARS-CoV-2. Many have pointed to the Wuhan Institute for Virology, which is the world’s expert on bat-derived coronaviruses. This may seem like a coincidence, but it is not surprising that a research lab will exist in a part of the world where such viruses exist. In other words, both the location of the lab and the COVID-19 outbreak may be related to the fact that zoonotic coronaviruses are endemic to the region. But still, the coincidence is noted.
Examinations of the virus itself have not revealed any smoking gun of genetic manipulation. But results have been conflicting about the potential for a lab origin. Some published studies have concluded that the virus is incompatible with a lab origin. Other studies conclude that genetic manipulation cannot be ruled out. This is why many pinned hopes on the WHO team to resolve the debate, which they did not do definitively. For now we will have to be content with “extremely unlikely”, and continue for calls for fuller, more transparent research to finally put the question to bed.
All of this matters for various reasons. Experts are already warning that pandemics like COVID-19 are likely going to be more common going forward. The world is much more interconnected than ever before, we are living closer to natural habitats (some might say invading), and there is a global trade in animals parts. All of these factors conspire to make the occurrence and spread of zoonotic infections, including developing into full-blown pandemics, more likely. COVID-19 is far from the most deadly disease out there, and this pandemic is likely a dress-rehearsal for worse pandemics to come.
Unless, of course, we make some changes. One major goal of the WHO study was to identify possible sources of the pandemic, in hopes of producing actionable items to limit the risk of future pandemics. Further, the report produced an international call for full cooperation and transparency. We now all know in a very visceral way that things that happen in distant parts of the world can come to our shores and dramatically affect us. In a very real sense, we are all in this together, and we have to work together to have a much better reaction to the next pandemic.

The origin of SARS-CoV-2, revisited
Since early in the pandemic, scientists have overwhelmingly concluded that evidence points to a natural origin for SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, as a far more likely explanation for the pandemic than a laboratory origin. In May, however, there has been a lot of media chatter about the “lab leak” hypothesis, and President Biden even ordered US intelligence agencies to look into it. What, if anything, has changed? Is there new evidence? Spoiler alert: The answer to both questions is no. The “lab leak” hypothesis is fast becoming a conspiracy theory.
David Gorski on May 31, 2021
Link

If, as I have, you’ve been paying attention to these things for a number of years, you know that, whenever there is a major outbreak, epidemic, or pandemic of infectious disease, one conspiracy theory always—and I do mean always—arises. That conspiracy theory is that the causative microbe was developed in a laboratory and/or escaped a laboratory. HIV, H1N1, the original SARS, Ebola virus, every single one of them gave birth to such conspiracy theories. Unsurprisingly, given its global scope and death toll, so it was with SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19.
Even as far back as February 2020, I noted that antivaxxer James Lyons-Weiler was falsely claiming that he had “broken the coronavirus code” and found nucleotide sequences in its genome indicating that it had come from a laboratory working on coronavirus vaccines, while Nobel Laureate turned crackpot Luc Montagnier also endorsed the “engineered virus” idea. For someone who is supposedly an expert in bioinformatics, his analysis was risibly bad. Then came the “plandemic” conspiracy theory, in which antivaxxer and disgraced scientist Judy Mikovits claimed that SARS-CoV-2 was not only engineered but intentionally released. As we discussed at the time, the nucleotide sequence of isolates of SARS-CoV-2 analyzed early in the pandemic showed no evidence of “engineering,” no telltale signs of having been synthesized or modified in a laboratory, and a more recent WHO report similarly concludes that the likelihood of a laboratory origin for the virus compared to the odds of a natural origin is very low.
The “lab leak” hypothesis is resurrected
The idea that SARS-CoV-2 originated in a laboratory has continued to bubble under the surface of discussions of the pandemic but wasn’t really a major discussion point for a number of months—that is, until recently. Last week, for example, President Biden instructed US intelligence agencies to “redouble” their efforts to “collect and analyze information that could bring us closer to a definitive conclusion” regarding the origin of SARS-CoV-2. Before that, journalist Nicholas Wade published an article in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists (who knows why it was published there instead of in a virology or molecular biology journal) arguing that the virus originated in so-called “gain-of-function” experiments and was accidentally released.
This followed a letter published in Science by a number of scientists advocating investigating the origins of the coronavirus and saying that we “must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data”. The authors were apparently unhappy with a joint Chinese and World Health Organization (WHO) investigation published in March that concluded that an animal origin for SARS-CoV-2 was far more likely than a lab leak, as Steve Novella discussed at the time. Personally, I was unhappy at how unconcerned at least one of the signatories was over how their letter had been used by conspiracy theorists as support for their ideas.
Then there was Fox News publicizing a fact-checking event earlier in May held by Politifacts that quoted Dr. Fauci thusly when asked about whether he was confident that SARS-CoV-2 arose naturally:
“No actually,” Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergies and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) said, around 12 minutes into footage of the event, which was held earlier this month but overlooked by most media outlets. “I am not convinced about that, I think we should continue to investigate what went on in China until we continue to find out to the best of our ability what happened.”
“Certainly, the people who investigated it say it likely was the emergence from an animal reservoir that then infected individuals, but it could have been something else, and we need to find that out. So, you know, that’s the reason why I said I’m perfectly in favor of any investigation that looks into the origin of the virus,” he continued.
“Will you in front of this group categorically say that the COVID-19 virus could not have occurred by serial passage in a laboratory?” Sen. Rand Paul had asked Fauci during a Senate hearing last Tuesday.
Fauci did not explicitly rule out such a possibility: “I do not have any accounting of what the Chinese may have done, and I’m fully in favor of any further investigation of what went on in China,” he said. “However, I will repeat again, the NIH and NIAID categorically has not funded gain of function research to be conducted in the Wuhan Institute of Virology.”
Meanwhile, a week ago The Wall Street Journal published a story titled “Intelligence on Sick Staff at Wuhan Lab Fuels Debate on Covid-19 Origin” (there’s no evidence presented that they were sick with COVID-19), while the Washington Post published an analysis titled “Timeline: How the Wuhan lab-leak theory suddenly became credible“. To be honest, the latter story simply told me how the conspiracy theory that SARS-CoV-2 had a laboratory origin had arisen even earlier than I thought it had, all without providing any new data that would lead me to view the “lab leak” hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 origin as more likely than a natural origin. Moreover, the first article basically doesn’t provide such evidence either, given that US intelligence officials are still not certain what the researchers actually had and Director of National Intelligence Avril Haines told Congress last month that “the intelligence community does not know exactly where, when, or how Covid-19 virus was transmitted initially”.
These developments led me to start to wonder if there was anything in the evidence base that had led most scientists to conclude that the most likely origin of SARS-CoV-2 was natural. Meanwhile, there seems to be a lot of Twitter activity of this sort:
Bayes theorem applies. The longer we go without identifying a natural source the more probability shifts to lab.
— John Gordon (@[email protected]) (@jgordonshare) May 27, 2021
We here at SBM are big fans of Bayes’ theorem, and as a big fan of Bayesian analysis, let me just say that Mr. Gordon demonstrates an epic misunderstanding of Bayes’ theorem. Personally, I like this response:
Sure? Occam's razor. So many people are exposed to bats every day in South East Asia. So many chances for this to happen. Day in day out. Versus a lab accident where all stars would have to align.
— Florian Krammer (@florian_krammer) May 27, 2021
See? Bayes theorem can cut both ways with respect to estimating prior probabilities. As many have pointed out, when a virus makes the jump from animals to humans, it often takes years to figure out the origin. As Dan Samorodnitsky points out:
So, figuring out where this particular virus came from will be a challenge. It can take years, decades, or more to find the source of a virus. Ebola, for instance, was identified in 1976, has caused multiple epidemics, and we still don’t really know what animal it spilled over from. To confirm beyond a reasonable doubt the virus’s origins, we’d have to sample wild animals and sequence the viruses they carry to find a close genetic relative, an astronomical task, haystacks within haystacks. In the absence of a smoking gun, there’s still good research that points in one direction. Take the phylogenetic analysis in preprint this week that, once again, suggests bats as a reservoir for SARS-CoV-2, with pangolins or civets as possible intermediate steps.
In other words, it’s only been less than a year and a half since the virus was identified and sequenced. Just because scientists haven’t yet found “smoking gun” evidence for what specific animal coronavirus made the jump to humans as SARS-CoV-2 (and where) does not make a lab origin more likely. It just doesn’t. The argument is just plain silly, and the vacuous invocation of Bayes’ theorem makes my brain hurt.
Bad logic and math aside, I’ve noticed that the lab leak hypothesis has definitely—shall we say?—evolved during the last year. Given the utter lack of evidence in the nucleotide sequences of SARS-CoV-2 for an “engineered” origin, the “respectable” people now claiming that the coronavirus came from a lab hasten to deny that they think it was “engineered” or a “bioweapon.” Basically, there are now two main versions of the “lab leak” hypothesis:
     1.  An engineered SARS coronavirus created at the Wuhan Institute of Virology through “gain of function” experiments somehow escaped and caused the pandemic.
     2.  A natural SARS coronavirus stored and studied at the Wuhan Institute of Virology somehow escaped and caused the pandemic.
I can say with a high degree of confidence based on existing evidence that the first version is so implausible as to have drifted well into conspiracy theory territory. The second is the version that “reasonable” people consider plausible, but there is no good evidence for either version. In any event, given how much these hypotheses have been discussed in the news as though there were some new evidence that now makes the “lab leak” hypothesis more likely (spoiler alert: there isn’t) and assaulted me on social media, coming from conspiracy theorists and non-conspiracy theorists, I just had to look into this issue again. Let’s look at each version of the hypothesis. I’ll start with the much less plausible version and then examine the more plausible “variant” (if you’ll excuse the term).
Version 1: The virus was engineered and escaped.
An excellent entry point to the claim that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered and then somehow accidentally released into the wild, thus causing the COVID-19 pandemic, is a news story in The Daily Mail that I saw on Saturday, because it contains a couple of major themes that I’ve found used by many to argue for a lab origin for the virus, as well as the dubious scientific arguments. The story touts an as-yet unpublished paper by British Professor Angus Dalgleish and Norwegian scientist Dr. Birger Sørensen, described in the story as being “set to be published in the Quarterly Review of Biophysics Discovery.” In typical Daily Mail fashion, the headline is basically a conspiracy theory:
The rationale in the paper, judging from the excerpts and statements by Dalgleish and Sørensen, rests on an appeal to incredulity, specifically disbelief that SARS-CoV-2 could have arisen from a natural source. Such arguments are perhaps the most common arguments for a “lab leak” that I’ve seen, usually accompanied with incorrect reasons why such an origin is “impossible.” This article is no different in that general form.
When I first read the article, I had never heard of these scientists before and had no idea who they were; so I did a bit of Googling. Unfortunately, a lot of what came up first in the search results were links to the Daily Mail story and others reprinting the story, but I did learn that Dr. Dalgleish is an oncologist at St. George’s, University of London and ran for Parliament as a member of the UK Independence Party during the 2015 United Kingdom general election, finishing fourth. He is also a Fellow of the Academy of Medical Sciences, the Royal College of Physicians, the Royal College of Pathologists, and the Royal Australasian College of Physicians. He’s famous for having been the co-discoverer of the CD4 receptor as the major cellular receptor for HIV. Sørensen is the chair of a pharmaceutical company, Immunor, which developed a coronavirus vaccine candidate called Biovacc-19.
Normally I don’t blog about unpublished papers, preferring to wait for the whole paper to be published, but The Daily Mail not only published the abstract, but several tables and figures from the unpublished paper. That’s really, really unusual. Most journals would not be in the least bit pleased to see a newspaper do that. The story states that the article was “exclusively obtained by DailyMail.com and slated for publication in the coming days.” Given the apparently enthusiastic participation of Dalgleish and Sørensen in interviews for the news story, it’s very hard to imagine how The Daily Mail might have gotten a copy of the paper from any other source besides the authors, although one of the three authors of the manuscript, Andres Susrud, posted an earlier version of the paper, which was not accepted:
There’s another huge red flag about this study and that’s the journal in which it was published, which was not in a molecular biology, biochemistry, or virology journal, but rather a biophysics journal. That’s not the first place I’d choose to publish an article of this sort, although QRB Discovery does describe itself as publishing “physical observations of relevance to biological systems, both experimental and theoretical, that may point towards an exciting direction, rather than the presentation of a traditional comprehensive study”, which might explain why Dalgleish and Sørensen decided to publish there instead of a more appropriate journal. Then there’s this excerpt of the story:
They said they tried to publish their findings but were rejected by major scientific journals which were at the time resolute that the virus jumped naturally from bats or other animals to humans.
So basically the authors went shopping until they found a journal that would accept their manuscript. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that. (Pretty much every scientist, myself included, has submitted a manuscript to a different journal after rejection by another journal, and many of us have had the unpleasant experience of having to submit to three or more journals before we could get an article published.) However, it does raise eyebrows when an article like this ends up in a journal that doesn’t seem appropriate for the material. Just look at the sorts of articles in the latest issue. They’re all pretty heavily weighted towards fairly hard core biophysical studies, rather than sequence analysis. Moreover, contrary to how it’s being described, as a “study,” in reality it’s more of a review article, with no new research published, at least as far as I can tell.
Now, let’s look at the Abstract and Conclusion sections, helpfully provided by the Daily Mail. Here’s the abstract:
Here’s the conclusion:
I can’t help but note the rather strange wording of the abstract, namely the authors’ claim that their analysis is so compelling that it “reverses the burden of proof” for those who consider a laboratory origin of the virus highly unlikely and a natural origin much more so. Be that as it may, before I discuss the article and the figures, I have to point out yet another red flag that I discovered in the Daily Mail article. It was such a big one that it literally deserves a facepalm. Here’s the excerpt from the article:
One tell-tale sign of alleged manipulation the two men highlighted was a row of four amino acids they found on the SARS-Cov-2 spike.
In an exclusive interview with DailyMail.com, Sørensen said the amino acids all have a positive charge, which cause the virus to tightly cling to the negatively charged parts of human cells like a magnet, and so become more infectious.
But because, like magnets, the positively charged amino acids repel each other, it is rare to find even three in a row in naturally occurring organisms, while four in a row is ‘extremely unlikely,’ the scientist said.
‘The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,’ Dalgleish told DailyMail.com.
Their new paper says these features of SARS-Cov-2 are ‘unique fingerprints’ which are ‘indicative of purposive manipulation’, and that ‘the likelihood of it being the result of natural processes is very small.’
And here’s the facepalm, much deserved:
There’s really only one word to describe this claim: Bullshit. I’m sorry if anyone is offended by mild profanity, but that really is the only word to describe the claim above, and scientists were quick to call it out as such on social media, with examples:
I guess someone should let nucleoplasmin know it doesn’t obey the laws of physics (but apparently does for the laws of biochemistry)https://t.co/uJstGPgtBZ
— Jason Kindrachuk, PhD (@KindrachukJason) May 30, 2021
Here, btw, is the champion in the human genome:
NP_001171491.1 protein BEAN1 isoform 1 RHRHRHHRHHHHHHHHRRRRHR
— Michael Eisen (@mbeisen) May 30, 2021
There are 9,701 matches to [RK][RK][RK][RK][RK] in the human proteome….
— Michael Eisen (@mbeisen) May 29, 2021
The CoV HKU1 furin cleavage site is RRKRR. Five in a row!
— Stephen Goldstein (@stgoldst) May 29, 2021
Personally, these are my two favorite responses:
Indeed. If it truly “violates the laws of physics” to have four positively charged amino acids all in a line next to each other in a protein, then it would be utterly impossible to engineer a nucleotide sequence that could encode such a protein, because translation would fail! Seriously, how could any journal allow a review article to make such a nonsensical argument? It turns out that four positively charged amino acids in a row is quite common, a motif found in thousands of different proteins. It’s tempting just to dismiss the whole thing based on such epic ignorance, but let’s dig in a little bit more because Dalgleish and Sørensen make another claim that is commonly made by those arguing for a laboratory origin.
The key claim made by Dalgleish and Sørensen is this:
Dalgleish and Sørensen claim that scientists working on Gain of Function projects took a natural coronavirus ‘backbone’ found in Chinese cave bats and spliced onto it a new ‘spike’, turning it into the deadly and highly transmissible SARS-Cov-2.
They base their argument on, in essence, an argument from ignorance, with a bit of conspiracy theory added. Yes, it is possible to create genetic sequences without, for instance, typical restriction enzyme sites of the sort that were frequently used to insert sequences into genomes. However, it isn’t nearly as easy as Dalgleish and Sørensen make it sound. Basically, to them these nefarious Chinese scientists were supposedly so clever that they not only did something that’s not at all trivial but did it without leaving behind any telltale signs in the sequence of genetic manipulation, other than the ones that only Dalgleish and Sørenson “discovered,” such as the six areas on the protein that basically every other scientist didn’t find suspicious. Then there’s the argument that a natural virus pandemic would be expected to “mutate gradually” to become more infectious but less pathogenic (i.e., deadly). Certainly, we’ve seen the former with the emergence of more transmissible variants of SARS-CoV-2 all over the world, but we haven’t seen the latter.
As virologist Angela Rasmussen pointed out:
Lol what Dr. Kindrachuk said. Also this makes no sense at all, and let me just address the big claim that seems to come up more and more: viruses don’t automatically evolve to be more transmissible and less pathogenic. Natural evolution has many possible outcomes.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) May 30, 2021
SARS-CoV-2 is already not that pathogenic, and isn’t likely to evolve much in either direction with regard to pathogenicity. It infects the majority of hosts without killing them. It gets more transmissible because it’s had so many opportunities to acquire adaptive mutations.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) May 30, 2021
Again, this argument is, quite simply, incorrect, and we wouldn’t necessarily expect SARS-CoV-2 to evolve to become less pathogenic and less deadly. Given that the infection fatality rate of SARS-CoV-2 is already well under 1% and a significant fraction of its infections are asymptomatic or only mildly symptomatic, there really isn’t likely to be that much selective pressure for mutations that make it less deadly, particularly when it’s still spreading so widely and easily.
As for the rest of the article, it’s a lot of handwaving and appeals to ignorance and conspiracy. Again, its two main points (that a four amino acid stretch of positive residues is so unusual) and that evolution would inevitably lead to a slow increase in transmissibility and decrease in pathogenicity, are clearly incorrect and cannot explain the origin of SARS-CoV-2. Indeed, there are now several papers that show how the virus likely evolved from previously existing coronaviruses and how it is continuing to evolve as is spreads. (Here is a good recent review article, and potential evolutionary pathways that could have led to SARS-CoV-2 were known as early as July 2020.)
Then there are the articles claiming to have slam-dunk scientific evidence that SARS-CoV-2 could not have arisen naturally. Chief among these (at least now) have been articles by Li-Meng Yan claiming that the published bat coronavirus RaTG13 genome, identified in a horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus affinis) and sharing 96% sequence homology with SARS-CoV-2, was, in essence, “fake” and generated as a cover-up to prop up the “natural origin theory.” (No, I’m not exaggerating; Yan even claims that any data questioning the “natural origin theory” is censored by scientific journals.) RaTG13 was found in archived bat specimens stored at the Wuhan Institute of Virology after having been collected in 2013. Others have demonstrated rather conclusively that they could generate the RaTG13 sequence from the raw sequence data submitted to public databases, concluding that the “published RaTG13 genome is supported by raw sequence data of good quality.” Uncoincidentally, Yan is also known for attacking scientists, such as Angela Rasmussen, who noted this in a commentary.
Another example of supposed “slam-dunk” evidence is the claim popularized in Wade’s article (mentioned above) that a site called a furin cleavage site is unique to SARS-CoV-2 among SARS beta coronaviruses. As I mentioned in last week’s article, the spike protein in SARS-CoV-2 consists of two subunits. Between those two subunits, S1 and S2, sits a site where a human protein called furin cleaves the protein, to produce the two functional subunits. Wade claimed:
Viruses have all kinds of clever tricks, so why does the furin cleavage site stand out? Because of all known SARS-related beta-coronaviruses, only SARS2 possesses a furin cleavage site. All the other viruses have their S2 unit cleaved at a different site and by a different mechanism.
How then did SARS2 acquire its furin cleavage site? Either the site evolved naturally, or it was inserted by researchers at the S1/S2 junction in a gain-of-function experiment.
Basically, Wade’s argument seems to be that because a furin cleavage site of this sort hasn’t been seen in SARS-related beta coronaviruses before it must have been engineered. The problem is that such furin cleavage sites are common in a wide variety of viruses, including coronaviruses, and that scientists already had identified plausible mechanisms by which it could have ended up where it did in SARS-CoV2 last year:
Again, this was known for months.
But the problem is the non-experts who like saying 'lab leak seems possible', don't know enough on the biology to challenge Wade on this.https://t.co/CqgXfDxcXphttps://t.co/zrnitS3Ixehttps://t.co/Fc5Vvhx103https://t.co/Id3yKZpBx9 pic.twitter.com/RRPr7Cvb3H
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) May 7, 2021
I could go on and on and on with this stuff, but basically all the claims that SARS-CoV-2 couldn’t have arisen naturally don’t show anything of the sort and often betray ignorance of the actual molecular biology of the virus and even greater ignorance of how animal models work. One other claim that keeps popping up is that SARS-CoV-2 appeared “perfectly adapted” to humans as a host. (Wade alludes to this.) This study suggests a pathway by which natural selection in bats could have created a more “generalist” virus, rather than specifically adapted to humans. In other words, SARS-CoV-2 isn’t “perfectly adapted to humans,” just well adapted enough to infect them efficiently.
A more general take on the “lab leak” of an “engineered” virus
Perhaps the most basic refutation to the “engineered” virus narrative is a simple one. As good as virologists are, they don’t know a priori the features that make a virus more likely to infect and harm humans. As Ethan Siegel at Forbes put it:
The science of what can be done in virology, with modern techniques, is quite impressive. But what the conspiracy attests must have happened reaches far beyond the capabilities of even the most advanced research teams in the world.
The first red flag that should leap out at you, but perhaps only if you have some knowledge of virology to begin with, is the very idea that you could “know” what certain mutations would do — i.e., that you’d know what you’d create and what effect it would have on humans — without extensive testing in humans themselves.
And:
While we do have the ability to manipulate the genomes of viruses, or any other organism, for that matter, what we don’t have the ability to do is to know how that will translate into effects of the virus in human (or any living) subjects.
That’s not entirely true. It’s not that we can’t always predict what specific mutations might do. We now know enough about protein structure and function to make educated guesses about how changing an amino acid to another is likely to affect protein structure in some instances. Siegel is correct, though, that we do not have the sort of fine-tuned ability to make precise predictions.
As University of North Carolina virologist Ralph Baric put it:
Baric said that sars-CoV-2 was different enough from known viruses that to retrofit it from an ancestral strain would have required a truly unprecedented feat of genetic reëngineering. “And of course you don’t know what you’re engineering, because sars-CoV-2 would not have existed,” Baric said.
The engineering of a virus that didn’t exist yet (without knowledge of how to make it more transmissible between humans) seems very unlikely
Version 2: Lab leak of a “natural” SARS beta coronavirus
The second version of the “lab leak” hypothesis is basically the claim that SARS-CoV-2 escaped from the Wuhan Institute of Virology but wasn’t engineered. Rather, according to this version, it was a bat coronavirus that had been collected for study and stored at the Institute. The closest thing to “new evidence” that I’ve seen cited in favor of this has been reporting from The Wall Street Journal last week, for example, The Wuhan Lab Leak Question: A Disused Chinese Mine Takes Center Stage. First, there’s the background:
On the outskirts of a village deep in the mountains of southwest China, a lone surveillance camera peers down toward a disused copper mine smothered in dense bamboo. As night approaches, bats swoop overhead.
This is the subterranean home of the closest known virus on Earth to the one that causes Covid-19. It is also now a touchpoint for escalating calls for a more thorough probe into whether the pandemic could have stemmed from a Chinese laboratory.
In April 2012, six miners here fell sick with a mysterious illness after entering the mine to clear bat guano. Three of them died.
Chinese scientists from the Wuhan Institute of Virology were called in to investigate and, after taking samples from bats in the mine, identified several new coronaviruses.
Now, unanswered questions about the miners’ illness, the viruses found at the site and the research done with them have elevated into the mainstream an idea once dismissed as a conspiracy theory: that SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, might have leaked from a lab in Wuhan, the city where the first cases were found in December 2019.
All this story tells us is that bats harbor all sorts of interesting and potentially dangerous coronaviruses. (One notes, however, that this is how the RaTG13 sequence was initially collected, as I mentioned above.) Then there was another WSJ article reporting:
Three researchers from China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology became sick enough in November 2019 that they sought hospital care, according to a previously undisclosed U.S. intelligence report that could add weight to growing calls for a fuller probe of whether the Covid-19 virus may have escaped from the laboratory.
The details of the reporting go beyond a State Department fact sheet, issued during the final days of the Trump administration, which said that several researchers at the lab, a center for the study of coronaviruses and other pathogens, became sick in autumn 2019 “with symptoms consistent with both Covid-19 and common seasonal illness.”
This is some really thin gruel. It isn’t even known if these researchers actually had what is now called COVID-19. They could have had influenza or another virus.
Both forms of the lab leak hypothesis share one element, namely constant finger pointing at the Chinese for being less than enthusiastic and cooperative about letting investigators into the Wuhan Institute of Virology to try to determine if a lab leak happened. This is, of course, not surprising and not in and of itself evidence for a lab leak. China is an authoritarian regime, and such regimes tend to be secretive. However, for an authoritarian regime, China appears to have actually cooperated more than you might have imagined, at least based on this interview with some of the actual scientists who went to Wuhan to investigate for the WHO. Or at least you can say that the Chinese weren’t nearly as obstructionist as claimed:
Think of it this way. What country would welcome investigators with open arms into one of their major research institutions to look for evidence that its scientists had screwed up and caused a major disaster? Even if a government were confident that no such error had occurred, it might not be too thrilled with such an investigation, particularly when it’s coupled with what can only be called accusations of wrongdoing and being instigated by people hostile to you. That the Chinese are testy and unenthusiastic about cooperating is not a strong argument in favor of a lab leak. Sure, it could be a sign of a coverup, but it could also just be a normal reaction to accusations.
Bottom line: There is no new evidence that we haven’t known about for a long time that would lead to the reprioritizing of the two hypotheses to lead the lab leak hypothesis to become much more plausible.
Two hypotheses ≠ equally likely hypotheses
From the very beginning, the general scientific hypothesis has been that, while it is possible that SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a lab, it’s far more likely that it had a natural origin. As Samorodnitsky put it:
Though there is no direct evidence for either idea, the natural origins hypothesis has scientific precedence. The coronavirus family of viruses, that SARS-CoV-2 is a part of, have spilled over into humans (SARS and MERS) and caused pandemics. Natural origin also takes into consideration natural phenomena that happen all the time in wild viruses — they reproduce rapidly, mutate frequently, acquire bits of DNA like a boat collecting barnacles, and change behavior, particularly when they shift from one host to another. These processes happen in all viruses.
But, the permanent uncertainty of SARS-CoV-2’s origins has made other explanations, no matter how complex, attractive.
I’m going to quote this paragraph too, because I wish I had thought of a way this good of saying this:
If the question is “are both hypotheses possible?” the answer is yes. Both are possible. If the question is “are they equally likely?” the answer is absolutely not. One hypothesis requires a colossal cover-up and the silent, unswerving, leak-proof compliance of a vast network of scientists, civilians, and government officials for over a year. The other requires only for biology to behave as it always has, for a family of viruses that have done this before to do it again. The zoonotic spillover hypothesis is simple and explains everything. It’s scientific malpractice to pretend that one idea is equally as meritorious as the other. The lab-leak hypothesis is a scientific deus ex machina, a narrative shortcut that points a finger at a specific set of bad actors. I would be embarrassed to stand up in front of a room of scientists, lay out both hypotheses, and then pretend that one isn’t clearly, obviously better than the other.
Precisely. The natural origin hypothesis tends to the default for any new disease that arises for the simple reason that it is by far the most likely to be the correct explanation. It’s very common for viruses to mutate and evolve in animals and then jump over to humans and pandemics have been caused this way before. Again, the likelihood of the two hypotheses is nowhere near close to equal, and the plausibility of the hypothesis of a lab leak of an engineered virus is so low that it makes that version of the “lab leak” hypothesis even less likely than a leak of a natural virus. Even prominent signatories of the Science letter don’t actually believe that SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a lab:
On Tuesday evening, I spoke by video call with Ralph Baric, the U.N.C. virologist whose work had fallen under Rand Paul’s suspicious gaze. Baric had also signed Relman’s letter in Science, but he told me that his concerns had been with the W.H.O.’s failure to conduct a thorough, transparent review of biosafety measures at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. “I really believe that the genetic sequence for sars-CoV-2 really points to a natural-origin event from wildlife,” he said. Baric was sturdy-looking, with a paintbrush mustache and slightly melancholy eyes. The suggestion that it would have taken some Chinese science experiments to get the virus from bats in Yunnan to human beings in Wuhan seemed to leave him slightly affronted, on behalf of the natural world. However large the Wuhan Institute’s library of bat viruses, he said, the repository of viruses out in nature exceeded it by “many orders of magnitude.”
So why has the lab leak hypothesis seemingly risen from its grave and shambled off to social media and the news? One reason is politics. However another reason is, quite simply, likely to be pandemic fatigue. Knowledge is power, and it is also comforting. If we were to know the origin of this pandemic, the thinking goes, then we would better know how to prevent future pandemics. Maybe so, but here’s the thing. Even if the lab leak hypothesis is true, and SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a lab in China, it would make absolutely zero difference in how we need to deal with the pandemic now.
As Samorodnitsky put it:
The most bothersome thing about all this is that it does not particularly matter where SARS-CoV-2 came from. Making a scapegoat out of China doesn’t do anything about the political and economic systems that allowed millions to die, especially in wealthy nations like the US that could easily afford muscular public health responses.
And:
Creating a webbed story of cover-ups and conspiracy allows us to ignore how in many ways all humans caused the COVID-19 catastrophe. What if it wasn’t one bad Chinese government’s fault, but the whole world’s fault for destroying habitats, mining too deeply, and creating the perfect conditions for natural viral spillovers?
What if, indeed. Early in the pandemic, knowing the source of an outbreak can certainly guide efforts to contain it, including contact tracing, shutting down specific sites of the outbreak, and quarantine anyone exposed to the virus. That time for COVID-19 came and went a long time ago. Even in the unlikely event that the lab leak hypothesis is confirmed, it won’t help us deal with the pandemic now. I’d even question just how much this knowledge would help us prevent future pandemics, except briefly, given that it is human nature to forget and any safety measures implemented would likely fade in intensity with time.
Unfortunately, now the lab leak hypothesis has become, in essence, a conspiracy theory. It is weaponized uncertainty designed to frighten people for political purposes.
ADDENDUM: This Week in Virology has done another video podcast on the issue of a “lab leak.”

New Studies on the Origin of COVID-19
New evidence strongly supports the conclusion that SARS-CoV-2 emerged from the wet markets of Wuhan, killing the lab-leak hypothesis.
Steven Novella on July 27, 2022
Link

Since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic there has been a debate about the origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, with the two main theories being that it either was a spillover event from wild animals, likely originating in the Wuhan wet market, vs a leak from the nearby Wuhan Institute of Virology. Actually initially there were accusations that the virus was deliberately engineered and released from the lab, but direct examination of the genetics of the virus argued strongly against it being genetically modified. (To be clear, there was debate on this topic as well, but eventually a consensus emerged that the virus is not engineered). The lab-created hypothesis was then replaced with the lab-leak hypothesis – that the virus was still naturally occurring, but it spilled over from the lab to technicians working there who then spread the virus in the community.
Unfortunately, this important scientific question became the subject of politics, with many in the public holding opinions not based on the status of the scientific evidence but their political allegiance. Two years later, what is the status of that scientific evidence? The research has moved steadily in the direction of the wet market origin hypothesis.
There are several types of evidence we can bring to bear. One is simply investigational evidence regarding the activities and events occurring within the Wuhan lab and the Wuhan market. In this respect, the WHO has had teams investigating the lab. They have not found evidence to prove the lab-leak hypothesis, but neither have they been able to rule it out completely, and are calling for still more investigation. This is partly because China has been less than fully cooperative, partly because they are very defensive about the lab-leak theory, which they see as blaming them for the pandemic. Unfortunately this has fueled conspiracy theories and kept the lab-leak idea alive.
A second line of evidence is the genetics of the virus itself. As stated, this has largely ruled out the notion that the virus was genetically modified. It supports the hypothesis that the virus naturally emerged from animal populations and then spilled over into the human population. However, this type of examination has not found the “smoking gun” – the specific species (the intermediate host) or even the individual animal in which the new form of the virus emerged. This is not surprising, and does not call into question the animal spillover hypothesis, although it is often used to do just that. Currently several animals species remain possible intermediate hosts for SARS-CoV-2, including American minks, red foxes, and raccoon dogs, all of which are sold in the Wuhan wet market.
The third type of evidence we can use to address this question is epidemiological, tracking the spread of the earliest cases of COVID. This evidence has always favored Wuhan as the origin, but of course both the wet market and the virology lab are in Wuhan. We needed more precise data to differentiate these two hypotheses. Two studies just published (although released earlier this year as preprints) argue strongly for the wet market theory.
The first study used genetic analysis of the virus in the earliest cases to trace their origin and spread. You can use genetic analysis to trace spread as the virus mutates rapidly, splitting off into branching subtypes identifiable by genetic markers. This analysis finds that there were very likely two distinct spillover events, not just one, although they happened close together in space and time – in Wuhan in late November and early December 2019. The authors conclude:
These findings indicate that it is unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 circulated widely in humans prior to November 2019 and define the narrow window between when SARS-CoV-2 first jumped into humans and when the first cases of COVID-19 were reported. As with other coronaviruses, SARS-CoV-2 emergence likely resulted from multiple zoonotic events.
This is a body blow to the lab leak hypothesis. The second study then delivers the knock-out punch. They tracked the earliest cases of COVID, and also looked at environmental DNA samples to track where the virus may have been at the time. They found:
We report that live SARS-CoV-2 susceptible mammals were sold at the market in late 2019 and, within the market, SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples were spatially associated with vendors selling live mammals. While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, and exact circumstances remain obscure, our analyses indicate that the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 occurred via the live wildlife trade in China, and show that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Their evidence shows the virus was in the market and the first cases likely occurred in the market. Lead author Michael Worobey characterized the data this way:
In a city covering more than 3,000 sq miles (7,770 sq km), the area with the highest probability of containing the home of someone who had one of the earliest Covid-19 cases in the world was an area of a few city blocks, with the Huanan market smack dab inside it.
The data is even visually compelling, as you can see from the main image. This data is almost impossible to align with the lab-leak hypothesis. You would have to believe that there were two lab-leak events, both of which promptly went to the Huanan market and spread the virus. That represents epic-level special pleading, and is not sound epidemiological reasoning.
At this point the lab-leak hypothesis should be scientifically dead. The dominant hypothesis, that COVID resulted from zoonotic spillover events in the Huanan market, has now emerged as a fairly solid conclusion. This is critical to understand, as it relates to our efforts to prevent future spillover events. There were more than 47,000 individual live animals from 38 different species sold in the Huanan market between May 2017 and November 2019 in the market. Further, the conditions were often unhygienic and unsafe. This is exactly the kind of close contact between animals and humans the predispose to zoonotic spillover events.

No, James Lyons-Weiler did not “break the coronavirus code”
Last week, a new conspiracy theory about the coronavirus outbreak by James Lyons-Weiler went viral (if you’ll excuse the term) after antivax conspiracy theorist Del Bigtree interviewed him. Lyons-Weiler strongly implies that the strain of coronavirus behind the outbreak (2019-nCoV) has a SARS-like sequence that came from a laboratory working on a SARS vaccine. Fortunately, Dr. Gorski has the mad molecular biology skills to show why his conspiracy theory is nonsense.
David Gorski on February 10, 2020
Link

There are two things that I’ve learned about antivaccine activists, an aspect of their movement that has remained and continues to remain very consistent. The first is that to them it is always, always, always about the vaccines. To them, no matter what the disease or health condition, vaccines cause or exacerbate it. I’ve long recognized this aspect of antivaxxers. A recent example occurred when antivaxxers tried to blame the vaccine strain of measles for the deadly measles outbreak in Samoa late last year.
The second is that they are conspiracy theorists par excellence. This observation should not be surprising given that antivaccine views are strongly grounded in conspiracy theories, particularly what I like to call the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, namely that “they” (the CDC, big pharma, doctors, etc.) “know” that vaccines cause autism and all the adverse health effects falsely attributed to them by antivaxxers but are covering up the studies and data showing that vaccines are harmful and don’t work. For instance, in 2005, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. first promulgated a version this “they knew but are covering it up” conspiracy theory with his take on the CDC Simpsonwood conference. Indeed, the entire “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory is a variant of “‘they’ know but cover it up,” as was Del Bigtree’s recent dishonest cherry-picking of quotes from the World Health Organization Vaccine Safety Summit a couple of months ago. Second, to antivaxxers, it’s always, always, always the vaccines. This brings me to the coronavirus outbreak.
Not surprisingly, any time there’s an outbreak, antivaxxers find a way to blame it on vaccines or to spin it as a conspiracy on the part of big pharma to force a new vaccines on an unsuspecting population. They did that during the H1N1 pandemic ten years ago, and again during the Ebola virus outbreaks a few years ago. So it’s no surprise that it’s happening now that there is a large outbreak of a new strain of coronavirus (2019-nCoV) that can cause severe disease. Coronaviruses are very common, and most cause relatively mild upper respiratory infections, but there have been coronavirus strains that cause severe disease, such as SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome), which caused a major outbreak 18 years ago in Asia, and MERS (Middle East Respiratory Syndrome), which was even more lethal (a greater than 30% case fatality rate), which was first reported in Saudi Arabia in 2012. The current outbreak due to newly identified 2019-nCoV strain began in Wuhan, China and has since spread throughout China (and beyond) and killed over 800 so far and sickened tens of thousands (at least that are known). So it’s not surprising that the conspiracy theories popping up about the 2019-nCoV outbreak are heavily tainted with antivaccine spin.
Let’s take a look at one such conspiracy theory that, although nonsensical from a scientific viewpoint, is not the sort of nonsense that even most lay people can spot as ridiculous, like the conspiracy theory that Bill Gates created 2019-nCoV in order to push vaccines or that the virus is being pushed out by shadowy forces in order to impose “harmful” 5G technology and radiation on an unsuspecting populace. The following conspiracy theory relies on misinterpreting science in a manner that could sound very plausible to the lay public, because it relies on the misuse of the tools of molecular biology in order to blame the 2019-nCoV outbreak on, in essence, an attempt to make a vaccine against the SARS coronavirus 15 years ago.
James Lyons-Weiler: 2019-nCoV was due to a failed attempt at a coronavirus vaccine
This conspiracy theory blew up last week after it had been featured on the antivaccine YouTube show The HighWire With Del Bigtree that was first released on January 31, followed by press releases last Monday that really drove the show viral:
The basic idea that I’ll discuss in more detail in a moment, comes to us courtesy of James Lyons-Weiler. We’ve met him once before on this blog, when he attacked a study that found that autism is primarily genetic. In brief, he’s a former scientist. (I say “former” because he has abandoned good science in favor of antivaccine pseudoscience and no longer rates that title in my estimation, given the sorts of antivaccine pseudoscience he’s published lately.) Unfortunately, this conspiracy theory has blown up to the point where Lyons-Weiler is bragging that he’s gotten over 200,000 unique visits to his website over the week since Del Bigtree featured him on his show.
The conspiracy theory begins in this post, “On the Origins of the 2019-nCoV Virus, Wuhan, China“, in which he goes to great lengths to convince you that his conspiracy theory is reasonable by first “considering,” seemingly very carefully, alternate explanations for the phenomenon being “explained” by their conspiracy theory. Thus, Lyons-Weiler tries to knock down three alternate explanations before coming to the fourth:
     1.  2019-nCoV is related to bat coronaviruses and not a recombined virus.
     2.  2019-nCoV coronavirus is a recombined virus that naturally picked up a SARS-like spike protein in it N-terminus (3′ end) of the viral genome.
     3.  2019-nCoV coronavirus is a recombined virus made in a laboratory for the purpose of creating a bioweapon.
     4.  2019-nCoV coronavirus is a recombined virus made in a laboratory for the purpose of creating a vaccine.
Of course, most scientists have already rejected #1 and consider #2 the most likely origin of the new strain, as I will discuss at the end of this section. #3, of course, is a conspiracy theory that crops up every time there’s an outbreak caused by a dangerous new pathogen, and it doesn’t help that there’s supposedly a high security biolab around 30 miles away from Wuhan, whose proximity to the city led the conspiracy theories to write themselves.
So on what basis does Lyons-Weiler base his claim that 2019-nCoV is a recombined virus made for the purpose of creating a vaccine? The long version is in the post to which I linked above. The short version is in this press release:
Dr. Lyons-Weiler, of the Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge, showed and explained how the coronavirus’s genetic sequence–which has been publicly released by China– contains a unique “middle fragment” encoding a SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome) spike protein that appears, according to his genomic analysis, to have been inserted into the 2019-nCoV virus using “pShuttle” technology. This technique can only be done in a lab, as it has never occurred naturally in nature.
Dr. Lyons-Weiler buttresses his point with the following facts:
    • The sequence similarity of nCoV middle fragment to other coronavirus genome sequences is lower to its most similar sequences in any coronavirus than the rest of the genome;
    • The high sequence similarity of the fragment to a SARS spike protein;
    • The significant sequence similarity of the 2019-nCoV genome middle fragment to a pShuttle vector that was in use in the late 1980’s in China to create a more immunogenic coronavirus
    • Other scientists have ruled out a natural recombination origin of 2019-nCoV but no one has provided any other explanation for the novel middle fragment.
“This isn’t a ‘conspiracy theory,’ it is a scientific, medical theory,” says Del Bigtree, the Emmy-winning producer and founder of non-profit Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN). “Its foundation is based on sound science, logic, and research, and the mainstream media needs to be asked whether it is going to pursue this link to SARS instead of trying to censor anyone who is trying to pursue truth via scientific fact.”
No, it’s a conspiracy theory. Lyons-Weiler rejects possibilities #1 and #2 without good reason. Indeed, he rejects #2 in particular as a “speculative hypothesis” by drawing upon a single paper that proposed that 2019-nCoV came about as a result of a recombination event between a strain of bat coronavirus (which 2019-nCoV most resembles in its RNA sequence, its being an RNA virus) and a SARS-like spike protein from a snake virus. The authors based their conclusion on their observation that the codon bias of the insert was most like that of snakes. (A codon is the three nucleotide “word” that codes for a given amino acid in the protein into which the nucleotide sequence is translated in the cell. The genetic code is redundant, meaning that a given amino acid is coded for by more than one three-nucleotide codon, and different species have different “biases” in which specific codon is used to specify a given amino acid.) The problem is that paper was not very good and was widely criticized by scientists as not having examined a wide enough range of species to conclude that the insert found in 2019-nCoV exhibited a codon bias for snakes. In his original post, though, Lyons-Weiler presented that paper as though it were the only evidence for a recombination event between a bat coronavirus strain and that infecting a different animal.
Which brings us to Lyons-Weiler’s claim that this virus is due to a vaccine strain that escaped:
IPAK researchers found a sequence similarity between a pShuttle-SN recombination vector sequence and INS1378. Here’s a shot of the alignment and the DOT Plot. Here’s the nucleotide sequence at NCBI’s Nucleotide database. Here’s a patent for its use in recombination virology. The pShuttle-SN vector was among many described in a 1998 paper by Bert Vogelstein et al; here is a company where one can purchase the pShuttle-SN vector.
Before I go any further, I did some BLAST searches for the “INS1378” sequence helpfully provided by Lyons-Weiler. (BLAST stands for Basic Local Alignment Search Tool; it’s an algorithm used to find similarities in nucleotide sequences in DNA and RNA. I’ve used it since I was a graduate student in the 1990s, and there’s a handy website with the tool maintained by the NIH that anyone can use.) Here is the result:
Not surprisingly, it’s all sequences related to the Wuhan market outbreak, although there is one short 361 nucleotide segment that closely resembles (78% identity) the bat sequence. I decided to try to replicate it by aligning the “INS1378” sequence with the pShuttle-SN sequence using the BLAST tool. My analysis found a sequence 1,182 nucleotides long with 68% identity (which, let me tell you, is not very high, particularly with all the gaps). Here’s a map of the pShuttle vector:
The molecular biologists will note that, like many vectors, pShuttle has a gene for neomycin resistance, allowing the selection of cells that take up the vector, and sequences known as “right arm” and “left arm” plus two ITR (inverted terminal repeats) that are used in transfer plasmids used to insert genes into adenovirus vectors because they facilitate recombination of the insert into the adenovirus. Basically, the “right arm” contains Ad5 (Adenovirus 5) nucleotides 3,534–5,790, which mediate homologous recombination with pAdEasy vectors used to insert genes into adenovirus to be used to infect cells and make the protein of interest. (For you molecular biology geeks, here’s the paper in which the construction of pShuttle was originally reported.)
Now here is the paper in which construction of pShuttle-SN was reported. It was indeed an attempt to make a vaccine against the SARS coronavirus, and, for you molecular biology geeks out there, here is how the vector was constructed, using an insert for the SARS coronavirus spike protein cloned into Xho4 and Kpn1 restriction enzyme sites:
And here are the results of my BLAST alignment:
This is pretty good alignment, but certainly nowhere near slam dunk evidence for the origin of 2019-nCoV being the SARS-like spike protein coding sequence inserted into pShuttle-SN, especially when it’s almost certainly more likely that this sequence could have arisen naturally, given how many coronaviruses have SARS-like sequences in them. If this particular sequence in 2019-nCoV actually did come from the vector and the version of the SARS spike protein gene that was inserted into pShuttle to make pShuttle-SN, there should be large swaths of 100% match, if not 100% match.
Indeed, an actual expert pointed out on Twitter that the match should be close to 100% for the entire sequence:
I looked at that alignment – the two aligned sequences are distantly related, but this would argue against his claim. If the insert came from a commercial vector, it would be near-identical. He doesn't seem to know what he's talking about, but he knows just enough to fake it
— Steven Salzberg (@StevenSalzberg1) January 31, 2020
I’m starting to think I know why Lyons-Weiler no longer runs a bioinformatics core.
Lyons-Weiler doesn’t stop there: Immunogenicity and SARS vaccines
Lyons-Weiler, not content just to point to his rather unconvincing sequence alignments and BLAST searches, has to find other reasons to justify his conspiracy theory, which is why he pivots straight to another leap of “logic”:
The very researchers conducting studies on SARS vaccines have cautioned repeatedly against human trials;
“An early concern for application of a SARS-CoV vaccine was the experience with other coronavirus infections which induced enhanced disease and immunopathology in animals when challenged with infectious virus [31], a concern reinforced by the report that animals given an alum adjuvanted SARS vaccine and subsequently challenged with SARS-CoV exhibited an immunopathologic lung reaction reminiscent of that described for respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in infants and in animal models given RSV vaccine and challenged naturally (infants) or artificially (animals) with RSV [32], [33]. We and others described a similar immunopathologic reaction in mice vaccinated with a SARS-CoV vaccine and subsequently challenged with SARS-CoV [18], [20], [21], [28]. It has been proposed that the nucleocapsid protein of SARS-CoV is the antigen to which the immunopathologic reaction is directed [18], [21]. Thus, concern for proceeding to humans with candidate SARS-CoV vaccines emerged from these various observations.” – Tseng et al.,
The disease progression in of 2019-nCoV is consistent with those seen in animals and humans vaccinated against SARS and then challenged with re-infection. Thus, the hypothesis that 2019-nCoV is an experimental vaccine type must be seriously considered.
This doesn’t even make sense. Yes, in animal models, animals vaccinated with a SARS vaccine then challenged with the SARS coronavirus developed severe disease due to an excessive immune reaction to the virus primed by the vaccine. That is indeed a reason to be very cautious moving to clinical trials of vaccines against SARS, MERS, or 2019-nCoV. It is quite a stretch to think that this observation strongly suggests that 2019-nCoV is likely to have come from a strain made in order to produce a coronavirus vaccine. Even Lyons-Weiler seems to realize this, characterizing the sequence homology (match) between INS1378 and pShuttle as low, but adding “but highly significant” in parentheses, going on to point that RNA viruses can mutate quickly, which is true but irrelevant to whether this low homology match between the insert found in 2019-nCoV and pShuttle means that 2019-nCoV came from a failed Chinese effort to make a vaccine against SARS. Seriously. Lyons-Weiler used to do genomics for a living before he turned to pseudoscience. Surely, at some level deep down, he must know what thin gruel he’s cooking up.
None of this stops him from fear mongering about 2019-nCoV:
The implications are clear: if China sensitized their population via a SARS vaccine, and this escaped from a lab, the rest of world has a serious humanitarian urgency to help China, but may not expect as serious an epidemic as might otherwise be expected.
In the worst-case scenario, if the vaccination strain is more highly contagious and lethal, 2019-nCoV could become the worst example of vaccine-derived contagious disease in human history. With an uncharacteristic aysmptomatic prodromal period of 5-7 days, individuals returning from China to other countries must be forthright and cooperative in their now-prescribed 2-week quarantine.
Yes, Lyons-Weiler is actually suggesting that the Chinese sensitized their population with a SARS vaccine (which, he implies, was created using pShuttle-SN) and that the vaccine strain of virus escaped from the lab. He then seems to realize that that possibility would mean that this outbreak would likely be short and quickly contained, as there is no evidence that China ever conducted a mass vaccination program against SARS, which would leave very few “sensitized” individuals. There is, after all, as yet no approved vaccine for SARS. So he has to add that bit about the “worst case scenario” in which 2019-nCoV is more contagious and lethal. The problem is that we already know that it’s definitely not more lethal than MERS (not even close, given that MERS is 34% fatal) and likely not more lethal than SARS. He’s just pulling these speculations out of his nether regions. Whatever the origin of 2019-nCoV, Institut Pasteur has not only isolated and sequenced the responsible strain, but figured out how to grow large amounts of it in culture, paving the way to studies to determine the mechanism for its pathogenicity and to develop an effective vaccine.
James Lyons-Weiler takes his conspiracy theory and runs with it
Lyons-Weiler is clearly very pleased with the attention his conspiracy theory is getting and the traffic to his website it’s generating, because since that first post, it’s been close to all coronavirus all the time on his blog. For instance, in a follow-up post, he is wildly speculating based on a variety of papers that the SARS-like spike protein did not come from a natural recombination event. In one passage, he dismisses speculation by scientists about a natural recombination event in which 2019-nCoV and SARS or a SARS-like coronavirus share a common ancestor because there are genomic differences between 2019-nCoV and the most recent common ancestry of the 2019-nCoV, the bat coronavirus strain HKU9-1, writing:
We can say with certainty that 2019-nCoV has at least two ancestors: the ancestry of the entire genome, and the ancestry of the SARS spike protein.
I discount the wild recombination idea because natural selection would likely remove individual animals if the recombination occurred in nature due to high mortality. So recombination in the wild is purely speculative.
Actually, recombination in the wild is far more plausible than Lyons-Weiler’s hare-brained extrapolation from a low homology match between the SARS spike protein sequence in pShuttle-SN and the SARS-like spike protein sequence in 2019-nCoV. Also, mortality of the infected animal would have to be incredibly high before it would impact natural selection. Why? Because natural selection would be working on the virus, not the animal infected with the virus. Seriously, how does Lyons-Weiler not know how evolution works?
Particularly amusing is how in the comments a real scientist who has worked extensively on coronaviruses including SARS coronaviruses, Marc Wathelet, schools Lyons-Weiler on his misinterpretation of data. I encourage every one of you to read the exchange. I love reading how little Lyons-Weiler understands about coronaviruses:
I am sorry, I am a scientist and worked on the SARS-CoV for more than ten years, you can pubmed me if you don’t believe it. I commented on your other article too, I am afraid you are not understanding the issues. I must be doing a terrible job of explaining it, though.
Go download all the bat coronaviruses and align their spike sequences to that of SARS-CoV and you will see tremendous levels of homology, thus all bat coronaviruses have a SARS-like spike protein, this is very well established. Of course it is not exactly conserved, but there is also variations in spike among human isolates; these are RNA viruses and their sequences are constantly drifting as expected.
You will noticed that with all the criticisms and the interesting conspiracy theories, no scientist has expressed surprise to find a SARS-like spike protein in a virus like 2019-nCoV that belongs to the SARS family, because the surprise would indeed be to NOT have a SARS-like spike protein in this new 2019-nCoV that is so homologous elsewhere to the SARS-CoV genome!
Exactly. What Lyons-Weiler is characterizing as an oddity so odd that it must indicate the possibility of a laboratory origin of 2019-nCoV is nothing odd at all. Virologists are utterly unsurprised at this finding because it is utterly unsurprising to those who study these particular viruses.
In answer to a challenge by Lyons-Weiler to “show me any example of a bat coronavirus that has a recognizably SARS-like spike protein other than the one from the Chinese military”:
Again, I am confused: I had run blastp with the spike sequence of CZ45, the other military sequence, and I got 43 other bat coronavirus spike sequences, including a dozen or so from the very reputable HongKong University, all with very high homology. And of course all the SARS-CoV human isolates come up as well. Don’t know what to tell you but to go back and rerun you’re analyses with the spike protein of the 2019-nCoV and blastp it on the nr database of Genbank and you should get the same results as I did.
BLASTP does alignment searches for protein sequences, rather than nucleotide sequences, while BLASTN does nucleotide searches.
The criticism from real scientists must finally be registering, though, because in one of his most recent posts, Lyons-Weiler is reduced to JAQing off, as he does here:
Before we look at the evolutionary trees, I want to stress that I have published and will repeat that given the mass casualities [sic] in China and the prospect of such events around the world, keeping the possibility of one or more recombination events on the table, or even a laboratory origin of nCoV2019 is important specifically and exclusively for scientific and humanitarian purposes.
Again, I suspect that, at some level, even Lyons-Weiler knows that he’s peddling the molecular biology/bioinformatics equivalent of snake oil. He’s also reduced to further conspiracy theory generation, based on being contacted by a person who evidently knew about a “natural” bat coronavirus isolated in July 2013 at the Institute of Virology in Wuhan, China “who pointed us to a sequence available NCBI’s Nucleotide database but that had been uploaded only in January, 2020”:
The oddities in the behavior of the sequence data “updates” deserve further scrutiny [sic]. Why would two peer-reviewed publications, one from China, mention a middle fragment that could not be aligned? These questions require transparency.
He’s also denying that he ever said that the similarity he found between the SARS spike protein in pShuttle-SN and in 2019-nCoV implied a laboratory origin of 2019-nCoV when he did, although he obscures it by saying:
The data do not support a 1:1 relationship with pShuttle-SN (as published in 2005) and the SARS-like spike protein in 2019-nCoV, and I never posited that relationship. I merely pointed out it was similar to it, when no one else could match the middle fragment to anything But the pShuttle-SN has ALSO been evolving in the lab, no doubt, and I would like to see a newly deposited sequence in NCBI’s Nucleotide database. Other vector tech has no doubt been used by other labs putting the SARS spike protein.
No, he didn’t claim a 1:1 relationship between the pShuttle-SN sequence and the SARS-like spike protein of 2019-nCoV (no one said he did), but he sure implied that the SARS-like spike protein from the sequence in pShuttle-SN was the origin of the similar sequence in 2019-nCoV. Amusingly, he’s also now denying that he ever concluded that a bioweapon, that favorite conspiracy theory that rears its ugly head during every major outbreak of a new pathogen, is not a distinct possibility. I also note that on Del Bigtree’s show, he explicitly said that this particular virus has a laboratory origin (starting around 26:14). Watch the show if you don’t believe me and can stand to watch Del Bigtree bloviate, mock, and pontificate.
Did 2019-nCoV jump to humans via pangolins in the Wuhan seafood market?
Unfortunately for Lyons-Weiler, it appears that the mystery of how the SARS-like spike sequence got into a bat coronavirus to produce the 2019-nCoV strain might be getting close to being solved. One can never know for certain, but one can assign probabilities, and we’re seeing science that strongly suggests a couple of likely possibilities that don’t involve vaccines (or bioweapons). It was recently reported that nCoV-2019 shares 96.3% overall genome sequence identity to the bat RaTG13 coronavirus genome. If true, this is just one more bit of evidence that 2019-nCoV arose from a naturally occurring bat coronavirus strain.
Muddling the issue even more, though, is a more recent finding, not yet published in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature, that was reported Friday in Nature:
Researchers in Guangzhou, China, have suggested that pangolins — long-snouted, ant-eating mammals often used in traditional Chinese medicine — are the probable animal source of the coronavirus outbreak that has infected more than 30,000 people and is wreaking havoc worldwide.
Scientists say that the suggestion, based on a genetic analysis, seems plausible — but caution that the researchers’ work is yet to be published in full. “This is an extremely interesting observation. Although we need to see more details, it does make sense as there are now some other data emerging that pangolins carry viruses that are closely related to 2019-nCoV,” says Edward Holmes, an evolutionary virologist at the University of Sydney, Australia.
The identity of the animal source of the coronavirus, named nCoV-2019, has been one of the key questions that researchers have been racing to answer. Coronaviruses are known to circulate in mammals and birds, and scientists have already suggested that nCoV-2019 originally came from bats, a proposal based on the similarity of its genetic sequence to those of other known coronaviruses. But the virus was probably transmitted to humans by another animal.
This observation has not been published in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature yet. It came from a university press release from South China Agricultural University in Guangzhou, which announced on Friday that two of its researchers, Shen Yongyi and Xiao Lihua, have identified the pangolin as the potential source of nCoV-2019 on the basis of a genetic comparison of coronaviruses taken from the animals and from humans infected in the outbreak and other findings. According to Yongyi and Lihua, the sequences are 99% similar.
If this observation turns out to be accurate, and the animal that initially transmitted 2019-nCoV to humans really is the pangolin, it implies yet another adverse effect from traditional Chinese medicine other than torture of bears for their bile, poisoning from heavy metals in herbs, and extinction of endangered species whose various body parts are used in TCM. It implies that TCM could facilitate outbreaks of new strains of pathogens. Of course, for a variety of reasons this observation, even if correct, might not indicate that 2019-nCoV jumped species from bat to human via pangolin. (I never thought I’d type a sentence like that.) It could be a contaminant, for instance. Also, without knowing the prevalence of this strain found in pangolins, particularly in the Wuhan fish market, where the outbreak originated, it’s hard to conclude with any degree of certainty that pangolins were the source of this strain.
What is not hard to conclude is that Lyons-Weiler is full of it.
The danger of science-y sounding conspiracy theories
In the end, what we have here is a classic case of antivaccine “logic” applied to science. Lyons-Weiler started out looking for a reason to blame the 2019-nCoV outbreak on vaccines or a bioweapon, and he used his knowledge of molecular biology to find a reason to do it that appears plausible to those who don’t know anything about molecular biology and virology. Of course there was some homology between the SARS-like spike protein sequence in the 2019-nCoV strain and the SARS-like spike protein sequence in an vector made to generate protein to to use to develop an experimental SARS vaccine! As Marc Wathelet pointed out, it would have been surprising if there weren’t a SARS-like sequence in 2019-nCoV, because such sequences are what make virulent coronavirus strains as virulent as they are. The problem is that Lyons-Weiler’s particular conspiracy theory will sound plausible to those without a lot of background in molecular biology, bioinformatics, and virology, and it will take a lot of explaining to shoot it down, if we can even ever shoot it down. (Just look how long this post ended up being. I was going to discuss several other coronavirus conspiracy theories, but ended up deciding not to because this post had already grown more than long enough.) After all, if there’s one thing about antivaccine tropes, it’s that they never die. Ever. They always rise again. The same is true of antivaccine conspiracy theories.
These conspiracy theories mutate, too. Lyons-Weiler is already backpedaling, reshuffling, and moving to other laboratory sources, such as biological warfare labs under the—shall we say?—selective pressure of scientists telling him his pShuttle-SN hypothesis is nonsense.
ADDENDUM: In a post published yesterday that I didn’t see when I was writing this, James Lyons-Weiler finally admitted that he was full of crap without actually giving up his conspiracy mongering. The all caps nature of this announcement is his:
UPDATE – 2/9/2020 – IPAK HAS CONDUCTED FURTHER, IN-DEPTH STUDIES OF THE GENOMIC AN PROTEIN SEQUENCES OF THE 2019-nCoV CORONAVIRUSES AND THEIR RELATIVES AND HAVE COMPELLING RESULTS OF A KEY SIGNATURE USEFUL FOR IDENTIFYING A PARTICULARLY PATHOGENIC CORONAVIRUSES LINEAGE. GIVEN THAT WE HAVE FOUND THIS SIGNATURE, A FUNCTIONAL MOTIF FINGERPRINT, PRESENT IN THE HK-3 CoV FROM 2005, WE BELIEVE THIS EXONERATES RECOMBINATION IN THE LAB AS A SOURCE OF THE VIRUS. THIS DOES NOT EXONERATE ACCIDENTAL RELEASE, HOWEVER. WE ARE WORKING TO PUBLISH OUR FINDINGS.
IN THE INTEREST OF TRANSPARITY, WE ARE KEEPING THE ARTICLE BELOW AS ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED FOR POSTERITY AND PROVENANCE. – JLW
The “article below,” I presume, is the original article that I discussed above. One wonders if Del Bigtree will have Lyons-Weiler on his show again to retract the rather explicit claim he made a week and a half ago that the SARS-like spike protein sequence in 2019-nCoV has an origin in the laboratory. Somehow, I doubt it.

COVID Lab Leak Theory Rises Again
FBI Director supports the lab leak hypothesis, but there is no new evidence, and scientists still favor the spillover hypothesis.
Steven Novella on March 1, 2023
Link

COVID-19 is the most significant pandemic that almost everyone alive today has lived through, and yet we are still not completely sure about its origins. There is no smoking gun by which we can definitively trace the origins of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes COVID. Recent statements by US government officials has reignited the debate about its origins, a topic we have covered here extensively.
SARS-CoV-2 is a novel virus, so it had to come from somewhere. Scientific papers were published as early as March 2020 exploring this question. There have always been two major hypothesis, what we now call the “lab leak” hypothesis, and the “spillover” hypothesis. Unfortunately this has not been a pure scientific debate as politics has intruded from the beginning. China in particular objects to any suggestion that their lab in Wuhan caused the worst pandemic in a century.
It is worth pointing out, however, that the lab leak theory has its origins in a lab-created bioweapon theory. Very early on, and continuing at least through 2022, some scientists and others were hypothesizing that the virus was bioengineered as a weapon, which may then have either been deliberately or accidentally released. This question can be primarily answered by examining the virus itself, looking for telltale signs of bioengineering. The book is basically closed on this question – the evidence strongly supports a natural (not bioengineered) origin for the virus.
Once the evidence was moving strongly in the direction of a natural origin for the virus, further promotion of the idea that it was bioengineered took on strong conspiratorial tones. Such conspiracy theories were widely criticized (correctly so). However, the bioweapon hypothesis soon became replaced by the lab leak hypothesis – in this narrative the Wuhan lab was just studying (but not modifying) the SARS-CoV-2 virus when it accidentally was leaked from the lab, likely through infected lab workers. The lab leak hypothesis was compatible with the growing evidence for a non-bioengineered origin of the virus.
It seems that some of the bioengineered conspiracy theorists migrated over to the lab leak hypothesis, contaminating the debate with conspiracy theories. Meanwhile earnest proponents of the lab leak hypothesis bristle at any suggestion that they are conspiracy theorists. Fair enough – but they have to understand the history and recognize that the lab leak side is rife with conspiracy theories.
If we put all that aside and just take a look at the scientific question – what does the evidence say about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 – there are basically two ways to address the question. The first stems from virology, tracing the genetic sequence of the various strains of SARS-CoV-2 and trying to draw the lines back to its origin. We can also compare the genetic sequence to the most closely related viruses to try to piece together where the virus came from.
When we do this the evidence currently favors the interpretation that SARS-CoV-2 is a spillover virus, a coronavirus that infects animals that crossed over to humans either through mutations or combining genetic material from human-infecting viruses in order to be pathogenic against humans. The best animal candidates for hosts of the virus origin are minks, red foxes, and racoon dogs, all of which are sold in the Wuhan wet market. Epidemiological evidence also traces the first infections back to the wet market. For this reason this is the most popular hypothesis among scientists. However, we have still not found the smoking gun original virus, so there is still a little room for questions.
The second way of approaching the question of the origin of the virus is to investigate the Wuhan virology lab and China’s early handling of the outbreak. This is more akin to a detective investigation than a scientific study. The World Health Organization and the US government have both executed these types of investigations, and their results are equivocal. They say, essentially, that there is no evidence for a lab leak but China has not been transparent enough for the lab leak hypothesis to be definitively ruled out.
This is the situation we have been living with for about the past year. Individuals can defend whichever hypothesis they prefer by emphasizing whichever aspect of the evidence they choose. For example, those who favor the lab leak hypothesis can argue that China would have not reason to be cagey unless they were hiding something. This is a weak argument, in my opinion, because authoritarian governments are cagey by design. I find the scientific evidence more compelling that the equivocal investigative evidence. Just following this evidence and expert opinion, I think the best current summary is that the evidence strongly favors the spillover origin hypothesis, but there is still some small room for doubt, and of course we should be open to more evidence. This will essentially remain the case unless and until scientists do find the actual host species and virus of origin for SARS-CoV-2, but that may never happen.
The lab leak hypothesis is back in the news not because of any new scientific evidence, but because Christopher Wray, Director of the FBI, has now publicly said that:
The FBI has for quite some time now assessed that the origins of the pandemic are most likely a potential lab incident
In response the White House put out a statement saying that there is no consensus among the various federal agencies as to the origin of SARS-CoV-2. It is not surprising that an investigative body would favor investigative evidence, while scientific bodies favor scientific evidence. Also, while the science is completely transparent, the FBI chief can only refer to classified information. So while I, of course, cannot know anything about any alleged classified information, Wray did emphasize in his interview that China “has been doing its best to try to thwart and obfuscate” their investigation. So it seems his reasoning is similar to what we already had – China is being cagey.
Intelligence agencies are divided on their conclusions, while scientific institutions are more united. In the end I don’t think Wray’s statements change anything. I would still favor the spillover hypothesis based on the scientific evidence, and the lack of any firm investigative conclusion. But of course I also favor more transparency on the part of China, which may be sitting on information that could more definitively confirm or deny the lab leak hypothesis. At the very least they can address the argument that they are not being transparent by being more transparent.
Going forward it seems that we need international standards of safety, transparency, and supervision for any lab dealing with viruses that can potentially cause a serious pandemic. No nation can ethically claim that they don’t have such international responsibilities, especially after the dramatic example of the COVID pandemic.

The rise and fall of the lab leak hypothesis for the origin of SARS-CoV-2
Two new studies were published last week that strongly support a natural zoonotic origin for COVID-19 centered at the wet market in Wuhan, China. Naturally, lab leak proponents soberly considered this new evidence and thought about changing their minds. Just kidding! They doubled down on the conspiracy mongering, because of course they did.
David Gorski on August 1, 2022
Link

Ever since the coronavirus now known as SARS-CoV-2 was first identified as the cause of an outbreak of a mysterious severe viral pneumonia in Wuhan, China two and a half years ago, a disease that later spread to the rest of the world as the COVID-19 pandemic, there has been intense curiosity about the origins of the virus. The most plausible hypothesis was that, like many diseases before, SARS-CoV-2 had a zoonotic origin; i.e., it developed the ability to “jump” from an animal reservoir to humans. Far less plausible, albeit not impossible, was the hypothesis that the novel coronavirus was created in a laboratory and then escaped, either through incompetence or malfeasance, a hypothesis that became more colloquially known as the “lab leak” hypothesis. Last week, two papers were finally published in Science that, under normal circumstances, would be, if not the final nails in the coffin of the lab leak hypothesis, getting very close. One examined the molecular epidemiology of SARS-CoV-2 and the other demonstrated that the wet market in Wuhan was indeed an early epicenter of the pandemic. Steve Novella has already discussed the studies, but that’s never stopped me before, given that having a few days to look at them allowed me also to judge reactions. Let’s just say that, contrary to the assertions of some optimists, these studies haven’t made much of an impact on conspiracy theorists, other than to provide them with targets to try to discredit.
Before I get to the studies, though, let’s look at some background on the lab leak hypothesis and conspiracy theories. I do this for two reasons. First, I want to show what these studies add to what we know about the origin of SARS-CoV-2. Second, it’s been a long time since I’ve written about this issue, and I think a recap is overdue.
A brief history of the lab leak hypothesis/conspiracy theory
Since the early days of the pandemic, there has been a question of whether SARS-CoV-2 arose naturally or had escaped from a lab. The latter hypothesis didn’t start out as a conspiracy theory, as lab leaks have happened before—although none had ever caused a pandemic that caused millions of deaths worldwide, over a million in the US alone. However, it rapidly took on the characteristics of a conspiracy theory such that even those advocating the “lab leak” hypothesis often had difficulty not interspersing more serious scientific arguments with what can be only described as a dollop of conspiratorial thinking. As time went on, if anything, the lab leak hypothesis drifted further and further from legitimate science and deeper and deeper into conspiracyland, such that, try as I might, I now have a difficult time finding examples of lab leak advocates who don’t add conspiracy mongering narratives to their arguments.
Here’s what I mean. By by May 2021 it clearly had developed all the hallmarks of a conspiracy theory, complete with a coverup narrative in which China and powerful forces in the US were “suppressing” all mention of a lab leak as a “conspiracy theory”, attacks on funding sources of investigators doing research on coronaviruses, bad science in the form of anomaly hunting (Nicholas Wade and furin cleavage sites or Steven Quay and Richard Muller and CGGCGG, anyone?) in which any observed oddity in the nucleotide sequence of the virus was portrayed as clear-cut evidence of lab manipulation by scientists doing gain-of-function research (which, apparently, went very wrong), all coupled with an utter resistance to disconfirming evidence. It didn’t help, of course, that the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) was not far from the wet markets that were first identified as likely sources of the outbreak and that the WIV was studying coronaviruses and thus had them on premises. Lab leak proponents are also fond of other kinds of conspiratorial thinking, such as attribution errors, weaponization of disagreements within a general consensus, shifting the burden of proof, moving the goalposts in response to disconfirming evidence, and others, all accompanied by an intense belief in a coverup at the highest levels of multiple governments.
Of course, conspiracy theories about a lab origin for a new pathogen (often as a “bioweapon” that somehow “leaked” from a biowarfare research lab) are nothing new. They inevitably arise whenever a deadly new pathogen appears to cause major outbreaks or, as in the case of SARS-CoV-2, a pandemic. It happened with HIV/AIDS, Ebola, and H1N1. For instance, there was a major conspiracy theory about HIV/AIDS that involved its creation at Fort Detrick when scientists supposedly spliced together two other viruses, Visna and HTLV-1 and then tested the results on prison inmates. (Interestingly, this turned out to be a Russian propaganda operation codename Operation INFEKTION designed to blame the AIDS pandemic on the US biological warfare program.) Other conspiracy theories include claims that HIV had contaminated various vaccines (smallpox, hepatitis B, etc., depending on the specific version of the conspiracy theory) and thereby gotten into the population. It’s therefore no surprise that almost as soon as SARS-CoV-2 was identified as the source of the initial outbreak in Wuhan, China so did conspiracy theories about a lab origin for the virus, among other things.
One of the earliest conspiracy theories had arisen by February 2020, when James Lyons-Weiler claimed to have “broken the coronavirus code“, claiming the novel coronavirus whose nucleotide sequence had been published a week or two before, was actually the result of a failed attempt to develop a vaccine for SARS, the coronavirus-caused disease that nearly became a pandemic in 2002-2003. Hilariously, he tried to claim that the novel coronavirus showed evidence of containing nucleotide sequences from a plasmid (a circular DNA construct into which scientists insert genes that can then be introduced into cells to get them to make the protein products of those genes), which, if true, certainly would have been slam-dunk evidence that SARS-CoV-2 had been created in a laboratory. Let’s just say that Lyons-Weiler, for all his claims of molecular biology expertise, made some rather glaring errors. Another variation on this theme was the claim that there were HIV sequences in the virus that indicated that the pandemic had come about as the result of a failed attempt to develop a vaccine against AIDS.
By March 2020, direct examination of the nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 had led scientists to conclude that the virus was highly unlikely to have been engineered in a laboratory. Predictably, that revelation didn’t stop the conspiracy theories claiming that the virus had been created in a lab and escaped, at least not right away. It took time and more accumulating evidence. In the meantime, distorted claims about the rarity of certain base combinations in the virus and its furin cleavage site had proliferated. Still, by late last year, it had become pretty clear that these narratives were not consistent with scientific data; so, as Steve noted, the goalposts shift (as they often do when conspiracy theories run headlong into disconfirming evidence). The “bioweapon” or lab-engineered version of the lab leak hypothesis then, as conspiracy theories tend to do, morphed into a version that was much harder to falsify, namely that the origin of SARS-CoV-2 was indeed a lab leak, just of a naturally occurring coronavirus that had been collected from bats or pangolins and stored for study at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, such as the bat virus RaTG13, which was incorrectly claimed to be a direct precursor to SARS-CoV-2. Then, of course, there were claims that workers at WIV were infected with SARS-COV-2 in November 2019, but exhaustive contact tracing failed to find these cases.
None of this is to say that the lab leak hypothesis is impossible, or even homeopathy-level improbable. As I mentioned once, lab leaks of pathogens have occurred before, although none have led to a global pandemic. Rather, conspiracy theorists simply tended to assume that because lab leak was possible that implied that it was equally likely as a natural origin, when the preponderance of evidence has long suggested the conclusion that a lab leak origin for this pandemic is incredibly unlikely. Before I move on to the studies and the reaction to them, I’ll quote Dan Samorodnitsky from over a year ago:
If the question is “are both hypotheses possible?” the answer is yes. Both are possible. If the question is “are they equally likely?” the answer is absolutely not. One hypothesis requires a colossal cover-up and the silent, unswerving, leak-proof compliance of a vast network of scientists, civilians, and government officials for over a year. The other requires only for biology to behave as it always has, for a family of viruses that have done this before to do it again. The zoonotic spillover hypothesis is simple and explains everything. It’s scientific malpractice to pretend that one idea is equally as meritorious as the other. The lab-leak hypothesis is a scientific deus ex machina, a narrative shortcut that points a finger at a specific set of bad actors. I would be embarrassed to stand up in front of a room of scientists, lay out both hypotheses, and then pretend that one isn’t clearly, obviously better than the other.
Change that to lab leak requiring a “colossal cover-up and the silent, unswerving, leak-proof compliance of a vast network of scientists, civilians, and government officials” to over two years now, and the two studies published last week just add to the difference. As was noted last year, there are a number of coronaviruses that routinely infect humans and are known to have had an animal origin and “there is no data to suggest that the WIV—or any other laboratory—was working on SARS-CoV-2, or any virus close enough to be the progenitor, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic”.
Molecular epidemiology: Two lineages likely jumped to humans
The first study comes from Joel O. Wertheim at the University of California at San Diego (UCSD) and was first authored by Jonathan E. Pekar. As is often the case with papers of this sort, the list of authors is long, with multiple labs contributing, because studies of this sort require a lot of expertise and materials and single institutions rarely have everything needed to do them.
I read the whole paper, as well as its very copious supplementary materials and figures (all 31 supplemental figures!), and although my knowledge of bioinformatics and molecular biology is not sophisticated enough to understand the finer details of the analysis, I can help to summarize the overall findings. In brief, the authors queried several large nucleotide sequence databases maintained by different countries, including the GISAID database, GenBank, and National Genomics Data Center of the China National Center for Bioinformatics (CNCB), for complete high-coverage SARS-CoV-2 genomes collected early in the pandemic, specifically by February 14, 2020. They then analyzed the sequences by computer to reconstruct the likely origin and evolution of different viral lineages and used epidemic modeling to surmise when the virus was likely introduced into the human population, as well as to reconstruct the sequence of a probable common ancestor.
The first clear finding is that it is highly unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 circulated widely in humans before November 2019. Indeed, the authors were able to use their phylogenetic analysis to estimate that the first zoonotic transfer from animals to humans likely occurred sometime around November 19, 2019, with a range from October 23- December 8. Interestingly, a news story cites Chinese government data finding that the earliest confirmed case of COVID-19 in China could be traced back to November 17, 2019, which is pretty close to the date of zoonotic transmission that this study found. On that date a 55-year-old man from Hubei province might have been the first person to have contracted COVID-19. Every day after that, one to five new cases were reported each day, and by December 15 the total number of infections stood at 27. By December 20, the total number of confirmed cases had reached 60, and then it was off to the races for the outbreak.
The second clear finding is that a single zoonotic event can’t explain the data, but rather required two such events from two different lineages, dubbed Lineage A and Lineage B by the scientists. The study found that Lineage B was the first to make the jump to humans. Tellingly, it was only found in people who had a direct connection to the Wuhan wet market. Lineage A appears to have made the jump within weeks—or even days—of when Lineage B did; it was found only in samples from humans who lived near or stayed close to the market. From the paper:
Therefore, our results indicate that lineage B was introduced into humans no earlier than late-October and likely in mid-November 2019, and the introduction of lineage A occurred within days to weeks of this event.
And:
The first zoonotic transmission likely involved lineage B viruses around 18 November 2019 (23 October–8 December), while the separate introduction of lineage A likely occurred within weeks of this event. These findings indicate that it is unlikely that SARS-CoV-2 circulated widely in humans prior to November 2019 and define the narrow window between when SARS-CoV-2 first jumped into humans and when the first cases of COVID-19 were reported. As with other coronaviruses, SARS-CoV-2 emergence likely resulted from multiple zoonotic events.
Now, I know what lab leak proponents are thinking. Two zoonotic events introducing this novel coronavirus into the human population? Isn’t that highly unlikely?
Yes and no:
The likelihood that such a virus would emerge from two different events is low, acknowledged co-author Joel Wertheim, an associate adjunct professor of medicine at the University of California, San Diego.
“Now, I realize it sounds like I just said that a once-in-a-generation event happened twice in short succession, and pandemics are indeed rare, but once all the conditions are in place — that is a zoonotic virus capable of both human infection and human transmission that is in close proximity to humans — the barriers to spillover have been lowered such that multiple introductions, we believe, should actually be expected,” Wertheim said.
Also, as the authors noted in their discussion:
Successful transmission of both lineage A and B viruses after independent zoonotic events indicates that evolutionary adaptation within humans was not needed for SARS-CoV-2 to spread (49). We now know that SARS-CoV-2 can readily spread after reverse-zoonosis to Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus), American mink (Neovison vison), and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), indicating its host generalist capacity (50–55). Furthermore, once an animal virus acquires the capacity for human infection and transmission, the only remaining barrier to spillover is contact between humans and the pathogen. Thereafter, a single zoonotic transmission event indicates the conditions necessary for spillovers have been met, which portends additional jumps. For example, there were at least two zoonotic jumps of SARS-CoV-2 into humans from pet hamsters in Hong Kong (56) and dozens from minks to humans on Dutch fur farms (52, 53).
In other words, if SARS-CoV-2 was already able to infect humans, it shouldn’t be surprising that more than one introduction occurred. In any case, this study is robust evidence that the most likely origin of SARS-CoV-2 was in an animal reservoir and that it very likely it first made the jump to humans in the wet market at Wuhan in November 2019. The study did not successfully identify the intermediary animal and is observational. It is, however, powerful.
But what about the second study?
Early cases clustered
The second study has a similarly large list of authors from different institutions, with the corresponding author being Kristian Andersen. It’s a correlative study that can’t prove the origin of the pandemic by itself, but when coupled with the first study is highly suggestive that COVID-19 arose in late 2019 in Wuhan as a result of zoonotic transfer from an animal at the market to humans.
The authors examined a number of data sources for their analysis
COVID-19 case data from December 2019 was obtained from the WHO mission report (7) and our previous analyses (5). Location information was extracted and sensitivity analyses performed to confirm accuracy and assess potential ascertainment bias. Geotagged January/February 2020 data from Weibo COVID-19 help seekers was obtained from the authors (26). Population density data was obtained from worldpop.org (27). Sequencing- or qPCR-based environmental sample SARS-CoV-2 positivity from the Huanan market was obtained from a January 2020 China CDC report (data S1) (24).
Also:
To estimate the relative amount of intra-urban human traffic to the Huanan market compared to other locations within the city of Wuhan, we utilized a location-specific dataset of social media check-ins in the Sina Visitor System as shared by Li et al. 2015 (33). This dataset is based on 1,491,499 individual check-in events across the city of Wuhan from the years 2013-2014 (5-6 years before the start of the COVID-19 pandemic), and 770,521 visits are associated with 312,190 unique user identifiers. Location names and categories were translated using a Python API for Google Translate.
So what did the investigators find? I think a picture, specifically the spatial analyses in Figure 2, is worth a thousand words:

Leading to the conclusions:
Several lines of evidence support the hypothesis that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic and that SARS-CoV-2 emerged from activities associated with live wildlife trade. Spatial analyses within the market show that SARS-CoV-2-positive environmental samples, including cages, carts, and freezers, were associated with activities concentrated in the southwest corner of the market. This is the same section where vendors were selling live mammals, including raccoon dogs, hog badgers, and red foxes, immediately prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. Multiple positive samples were taken from one stall known to have sold live mammals, and the water drain proximal to this stall, as well as other sewerages and a nearby wildlife stall on the southwest side of the market, tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 (24). These findings suggest that infected animals were present at the Huanan market at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic; however, we do not have access to any live animal samples from relevant species. Additional information, including sequencing data and detailed sampling strategy, would be invaluable to test this hypothesis comprehensively.
And the answer to one major criticism of the hypothesis that zoonotic transfer first occurred at the Huanan market in Wuhan:
One of the key findings of our study is that ‘unlinked’ early COVID-19 patients, those who neither worked at the market or knew someone who did, nor had recently visited the market, resided significantly closer to the market than patients with a direct link to the market. The observation that a substantial proportion of early cases had no known epidemiological link had previously been used as an argument against a Huanan market epicenter of the pandemic. However, this group of cases resided significantly closer to the market than those who worked there, indicating that they had been exposed to the virus at, or near, the Huanan market. For market workers, the exposure risk was their place of work not their residential locations, which were significantly further afield than those cases not formally linked to the market.
The authors also note that the “live animal trade and live animal markets are a common theme in virus spillover events” and that markets like the Huanan market “selling live mammals being in the highest risk category,” comparing SARS-CoV-2 to SARS-CoV-1 outbreaks from 2002-2004, which were “traced to infected animals in Guangdong, Jiangxi, Henan, Hunan, and Hubei provinces in China”.
Again, is this one study slam-dunk evidence in and of itself for zoonotic transfer? No. However, the two studies together constitute powerful evidence that SARS-CoV-2 was not introduced into the human population from a laboratory, but rather transferred from animals to human, almost certainly in the Huanan market, from which is spread to the rest of Wuhan province, to China, and then to the world.
Indeed, the combination of studies was so powerful that it convinced a couple of the scientists doing the studies that lab leak is no longer a viable hypothesis to explain the origin of SARS-CoV-2:
Andersen said the studies don’t definitively disprove the lab leak theory but are extremely persuasive, so much so that he changed his mind about the virus’ origins.
“I was quite convinced of the lab leak myself, until we dove into this very carefully and looked at it much closer,” Andersen said. “Based on data and analysis I’ve done over the last decade on many other viruses, I’ve convinced myself that actually the data points to this particular market.”
Worobey said he too thought the lab leak was possible, but the epidemiological preponderance of cases linked to the market is “not a mirage.”“It’s a real thing,” he said. “It’s just not plausible that this virus was introduced any other way than through the wildlife trade.”
That’s what real scientists (and skeptics) do. When the evidence becomes overwhelming, even if not absolutely 100% definitive, they change their minds. But will it make a difference to lab leak proponents? I think you know the answer.
Lab leak proponents react
If there’s one thing that’s true about conspiracy theorists, it’s that evidence that would tend to refute their hypotheses doesn’t persuade them to question their beliefs. Instead, it tends to make them double down. I can’t help but quote a comment after Steve’s post last Wednesday as an example, in which one of our commenters dismisses the studies solely based on this:
Anything to exculpate the elites who foisted this on us.
But there’s a lot of money going back and forth between the NIH, Big Pharma, and their CCP buddies. To appropriate a public metaphor, one hand washes the other.
Truly a clown world that we live in.
And then on Twitter the other day:
The US-funded scientists spiking the football w/ their NIH-funded paper based on public & self-edited Chinese data, is a thing to behold.
The “Funding” section of the Wuhan wet market epicenter paper has so many NIH grants, needed 2 screen shots.🧐https://t.co/wTlXgdQhMz pic.twitter.com/6suwYPhAB7
— sheila (@capitolsheila) July 30, 2022
Despicable Fauci trying to cover his Arse again.Funding: This project funded in whole or in part with Federal funds from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health (NIH) https://t.co/2PXLi9ASCj
— Ocular Deliberation (@ODeliberation) July 26, 2022
Note the conspiratorial thinking that because the NIH funded these studies that must mean they are hopelessly biased and that “Fauci is trying to cover his Arse”. This is a frequent narrative among conspiracy theorists, to personalize decisions by government agencies to a preferred bogeyman who can be attacked and to be unable to imagine that any government institution would provide research money to any group opposed to its messaging or to fund any research whose results might not line up with the message it wants to promote. I’ve discussed this issue many times before; whatever its flaws in funding mechanisms, the NIH peer review process for funding grants is arguably about as close to a true meritocracy as you will ever find in a government agency. Scientists on study sections review each grant for merit based on science, if the preliminary evidence supports their hypotheses, whether the proposed methodology is appropriate to address the scientific questions asked, if the investigators and institution are capable of carrying out the proposed research with, and the appropriateness of the budget requested. A priority score (lower is better) is assigned by the study section, and then in the best scoring grants are funded until the money runs out.
Then, just yesterday, I came across this:
I'm also looking forward to what promises to be a highly nuanced and non-conspiratorial analysis of the the recent papers (https://t.co/DBEOGUxbhN, https://t.co/QV3w210Xk3) finding lab leak to be increasingly implausible pic.twitter.com/XxiYQ5HbfD
— bad_stats 🕜💵🖨️🕣 (@thebadstats) July 31, 2022
That’s evolutionary biologist Heather Heying on the podcast that she does with her husband, biologist Bret Weinstein, claiming that it’s a conspiracy to “definitely” show that it was “those people” who caused the pandemic, not a lab leak. In a massive exercise in projection, she calls claims that the pandemic started at the Huanan market “racist,” apparently ignoring the blatant anti-Chinese racism and xenophobia behind lab leak, whose proponents often ascribe a nefarious coverup to the Chinese government, or:
Yah that was weird. I'm guessing she was trying squeeze in a talking point about how "they" would call *other* people racist for saying the virus came from the wet market, but she didn't think through it and accidentally just became an antiracist fanatic for a second
— bad_stats 🕜💵🖨️🕣 (@thebadstats) July 31, 2022
At the end, Weinstein promises to discuss these studies more in the future. Given his previous promotion of ivermectin as a cure-all for COVID-19 based on misunderstood meta-analyses, I’m sure his discussions will be as nuanced as his wife’s ascribing racism to the investigators.
Then there’s the appeal to personal incredulity:
4/ Did:
1. A pangolin kiss a Turtle?
2. A bat fly into the cloaca of a turkey and sneeze into chili.
No. But Stuart’s bit tapped into the obvious:
1. The proximity of the lab to the market.2. The nature of the work and the virus’ at the lab.https://t.co/iHYLaeG3ta
— Brent Carpenter (@BrentCa24718741) July 31, 2022
As I like to say, just because you personally find it difficult to believe that zoonosis is the much more likely explanation for SARS-CoV-2 than lab leak does not mean that lab leak is the more viable hypothesis. Also, in that interview from last year Jon Stewart disappointed me in the extreme by sounding very much like the sort of conspiracy theorists that he used to mock on The Daily Show.
Another favorite conspiracist narrative is that the wording of the conclusions of the Science papers is less definitive than it was in the preprint versions published in February. Specifically, they’ve homed in on this sentence in the second study:
While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, and exact circumstances remain obscure, our analyses indicate that the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 occurred via the live wildlife trade in China, and show that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic.
And:
Twice now I've seen people tweet the following sentence from the introduction of our recent paper out of context:
"However, the observation that the preponderance of early cases were linked to the Huanan market does not establish that the pandemic originated there."
— Michael Worobey (@MichaelWorobey) July 27, 2022
With one conspiracy theorist from US Right to Know going on about:
A COVID origins preprint that made splashy headlines a few months ago has now been published in a scientific journal.
But the words "dispositive evidence" appear to have not survived peer review.https://t.co/fDPy4gqVZI
— Emily Kopp (@emilyakopp) July 26, 2022
And another:
Those preprints from a while ago, arguing for wet market spillover (against e.g. lab leak followed by market super-spreading), are now published.
Idk when I'll get to them but at least they don't say "dispositive" anymore.https://t.co/nXAvtTN5PThttps://t.co/zyXaHuGIaP
— David Bahry (@DavidBahry) July 26, 2022
And another:
And another:
The editors wanted to push this narrative.
— Florian (@Florian_Hanover) July 26, 2022
You get the idea. Lab leak conspiracy theorists seem to be perseverating on how the word “dispositive,” which was apparently used in the preprints to describe this evidence but was removed from the final versions of the studies as published in Science. To be honest, it was a mistake on the part of the authors to use a word like that, given that it is a legal term, not scientific one, meaning something that resolves a legal issue, claim or controversy. If there’s one thing I’ve learned over the years, it’s that science deniers love to substitute legal reasoning for scientific reasoning; a favorite example that I like to cite is falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus, meaning “false in one thing, false in all.” Cranks love to imaging that interrogating science is like interrogating a witness, where this legal principle allows the jury to assume that if the witness is incorrect or lies about one thing they can discount everything that witness says. Science doesn’t work like that, because the path to a scientific consensus is almost never straight and there is almost always something “false” to find if you look hard enough.
In fact, the toning down of the language in the conclusions and discussion sections of a scientific paper is a feature, not a bug, of peer review. I could point to a number of examples that I’ve personally experienced getting papers published over the last 30 years. That the final versions of the paper include more carefully nuanced language than the initial versions is not a conspiracy. It’s something that very frequently happens with peer review. Think of it this way. Scientists like to state their conclusions as clearly as possible; however peer-reviewers often see the caveats more strikingly and require toned down language. It’s normal.
Failing that, conspiracy theorists attack peer review itself:
Lab leakers will disparage any evidence that counters their theory.
— Sense Strand (@sense_strand) July 31, 2022
No one ever said, though, that peer review is anything magical. It does, however, mean that scientists carefully examined the submitted manuscript, its data, and its supplementary data and figures and decided that the data did support the hypothesis being tested and was therefore worthy of publication in the journal for which the manuscript was being considered. Again, note the conspiratorial thinking in all the criticisms:
    • It’s a coverup by Anthony Fauci and the NIH (and big pharma and who knows who else).
    • Anomaly hunting, in which minor issues with the papers are portrayed as fatal flaws.
    • Arguments based on personal incredulity of the results.
    • Cherry picking of opposing studies.
    • Failure to consider the totality of the evidence and perseveration about bits of evidence that appear to support your view.
Science is a process, and definitive scientific conclusions rarely flow from a single study. The rejection of the lab leak hypothesis and conclusion that a zoonotic origin for SARS-CoV-2 is far more likely derive not from any single study—or even from these two studies—but from an accumulation of evidence obtained using different methodologies that all converge on the same conclusion. While lab leak proponents are correct that these studies don’t absolutely rule out a lab leak hypothesis, when they are taken together with existing evidence, they do deliver blows to lab leak so devastating that the hypothesis should be considered dead until and unless proponents can produce evidence sufficiently compelling to persuade scientists to resurrect it.
At this point, I can’t help but think that lab leak hypothesis has become the parrot in a classic Monty Python sketch, pining for the fjords.

The New York Times promotes “lab leak” conspiracy theories
Last week, the New York Times ran an op-ed by Alina Chan, Queen of lab leak conspiracy theories and then gave it a prominent place in its Sunday Magazine this weekend. How is it wrong? Let me count the ways.
David Gorski on June 10, 2024
Link

[Ed. note: This is special bonus post for today. Basically, I wrote a long discussion at my not-so-secret-other blog about an a conspiracy-mongering, misinformation-packed op-ed promoting “lab leak” as the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and, over the weekend, regretted that I hadn’t saved it for SBM. So I decided to take the editor’s prerogative and crosspost a modified version here in addition to my normal weekly post, which will go live soon. Enjoy a double dose of my verbosity! (I hope.)]
Three years ago, I described how the idea that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic, had escaped from a laboratory (which had already become known as the “lab leak” hypothesis) was fast becoming a conspiracy theory. I noted at the time that, while it was certainly not impossible that the source of SARS-CoV-2 had been a laboratory, specifically the Wuhan Institute of Virology, the weight of evidence at the time was far more in favor of a more mundane, common origin for viral pandemics, zoonotic spillover. In other words, the “boring” hypothesis that the virus had, as so many viruses before it had done, acquired the ability to infect humans and then to be transmissible between humans, was far more likely to be true, based on the totality of existing scientific evidence, than a “lab leak.” I also noted that every outbreak or pandemic of a new pathogen over the last several decades had spawned conspiracy theories that the pathogen was a “bioweapon” that had escaped (or been intentionally released from) a laboratory, a list that included HIV/AIDS, Ebola, and H1N1. For instance, there was a major conspiracy theory about HIV/AIDS that involved its creation at Fort Detrick when scientists supposedly spliced together two other viruses, Visna and HTLV-1 and then tested on prison inmates. (Interestingly, this turned out to be a Russian propaganda operation codename Operation INFEKTION designed to blame the AIDS pandemic on the US biological warfare program.)
In fairness, I also note that “lab leak” didn’t necessarily start out as a conspiracy theory, as lab leaks have happened before—although none had ever caused a pandemic that has thus far claimed millions of deaths worldwide, over a million in the US alone. However, it did rapidly take on the characteristics of a conspiracy theory such that even those advocating the “lab leak” hypothesis often had difficulty avoiding interspersing their more serious scientific arguments with what can be only described as a heaping helping of conspiratorial thinking. As time went on, if anything, the lab leak hypothesis drifted further and further from legitimate science and deeper and deeper into conspiracyland, such that, try as I might, I can no longer find examples of lab leak advocates who don’t add conspiracy mongering narratives to their arguments; for example, Alina Chan.
I mention Alina Chan here because over the three years period since I first noted that lab leak had become a conspiracy theory more than a serious scientific hypothesis to explain the origin of the pandemic, Alina Chan has become the queen of lab leak conspiracy theories, even though, as a Human Frontier Science Program fellow at the Broad Institute at MIT and Harvard, she really should know better. Unfortunately, that didn’t stop her from coauthoring with formerly good science writer turned conspiracy theorist Matt Ridley a book entitled Viral: The Search for the Origin of COVID-19, which tries (and fails) to prove their conspiracy theory that COVID-19 arose as the result of a lab leak. Worse, earlier this week the New York Times inexplicably gave her a very prominent bit of op-ed real estate, complete with help from its graphic department, to produce a very slick rehashing of lab leak conspiracy theories entitled Why the Pandemic Probably Started in a Lab, in 5 Key Points. Depressingly, Chan’s article not only rehashes old debunked lab leak conspiracy theories, complete with mis-cited and cherry picked studies to support them, but it was published right before a conspiracy-charged hearing of the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic at which Anthony Fauci was deceptively attacked as the author of “lab leak” and therefore the COVID-19 pandemic:
Ahead of today's hearing in Congress: my opinion piece with the @nytimes on why Covid-19 was likely caused by a lab accident.My hope since 2020 has been for leaders, especially scientists, to lead the charge in investigating a plausible lab #OriginOfCovid – as opposed to…
— Alina Chan (@Ayjchan) June 3, 2024
If I were conspiracy-minded myself, I would almost think that the publication of Chan’s conspiracy disinfofest of an article right before every COVID crank in Congress ganged up to attack Anthony Fauci for having made possible the “lab leak” and having covered it up had been—shall we say?—engineered. Indeed, you’ll forgive me if I suspect that. Maybe my delving into conspiracy theories so much is starting to affect me. However the decision to publish this dreck was made, the NYT did its readers a severe disservice publishing old nonsense in a trusted venue such that conspiracy mongers immediately interpreted it as “validation. My retort is: Just because the NYT op-ed page published a bullshit article by Alina Chan does not mean that lab leak is becoming a “point of consensus,” and all Tony Fauci did was to say that he keeps an open mind regarding the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and to deny that he tried to “suppress” research into a lab leak as the origin of the viral pandemic. Left out is what Fauci also said:
“I don’t think the concept of there being a lab leak is inherently a conspiracy theory,” Fauci said. “What is conspiracy is the kind of distortions of that particular subject, like it was a lab leak and I was parachuted into the CIA like Jason Bourne and told the CIA that they should really not be talking about a lab leak. That’s the conspiracy.”
Or maybe like the conspiracy theory promoted by people like Jeffrey Tucker, who thinks that SARS-C0V-2 was an accidental lab leak as a result of US bioweapons research in China (seriously?) that was used as a pretext to promote mRNA vaccination and suppress “natural herd immunity” approaches to containing the pandemic so that the vaccines could get the credit. Chan’s article is only marginally better than Tucker’s; she’s just better at wrapping her conspiracy theories in a patina of science just good enough to impress the rubes, also wrapped in the respectability of the Old Gray Lady‘s op-ed page. Unfortunately, the NYT gave her article the opportunity to succeed at beyond anyone’s wildest dreams.. Let’s dig in.
Why Alina Chan is the queen of lab leak conspiracy theories, in 5 key points
So let’s get back to Chan’s article, Why the Pandemic Probably Started in a Lab, in 5 Key Points. I must confess that the title made me wonder if the headline editor insisted on inserting the word “probably” into the headline, all in order to soften the message a bit and avoid charges of conspiracy mongering. If so, the tactic failed. Early in the article, Chan, being the Queen of Lab Leak, asserts bluntly:
Although how the pandemic started has been hotly debated, a growing volume of evidence — gleaned from public records released under the Freedom of Information Act, digital sleuthing through online databases, scientific papers analyzing the virus and its spread, and leaks from within the U.S. government — suggests that the pandemic most likely occurred because a virus escaped from a research lab in Wuhan, China. If so, it would be the most costly accident in the history of science.
Notice that nowhere does Chan provide any direct evidence. It’s another example of double standards. What do I mean? Lab leak conspiracists frequently criticize the scientific evidence base pointing to a natural origin for SARS-CoV-2 through zoonotic spillover because it is largely a circumstantial base, in which disparate lines of evidence point in the same direction but which also contains a number of holes. Yet, they love to point to a much less comprehensive evidence base that relies largely on anomaly hunting, cherry-picked data and evidence, plus a whole lot of speculation as slam-dunk evidence (or a “growing volume of evidence”) for lab leak. Of course, a “growing volume of evidence” means nothing if what is growing is largely crappy evidence and speculation. However, it’s not even that; in reality the evidence base for lab leak has remained largely unchanged since I first started writing about it three years ago, other than lab leak aficionados like Chan making like this the famous Pepe Silvia rant that has become a meme:
Lab leak advocates basically do this with the same bits of evidence they’ve been using since 2020.
The first point is the only thing that Chan says that is inarguably true: “The SARS-like virus that caused the pandemic emerged in Wuhan, the city where the world’s foremost research lab for SARS-like viruses is located.” Yup. She’s got us there! Back in late 2019, SARS-CoV-2 caused the first major outbreak of viral respiratory pneumonia that ultimately beyond China to spread to become the COVID-19 pandemic. Chan also goes on to make the following assertions:
    • At the Wuhan Institute of Virology, a team of scientists had been hunting for SARS-like viruses for over a decade, led by Shi Zhengli.
    • Their research showed that the viruses most similar to SARS‑CoV‑2, the virus that caused the pandemic, circulate in bats that live roughly 1,000 miles away from Wuhan. Scientists from Dr. Shi’s team traveled repeatedly to Yunnan province to collect these viruses and had expanded their search to Southeast Asia. Bats in other parts of China have not been found to carry viruses that are as closely related to SARS-CoV-2.
The idea, of course, is that it must have been those careless scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology who had those samples from bats that they’d been tinkering with using “gain-of-function” methods and then somehow let one of the viruses get out, all because the bats harboring the viruses most similar to SARS-CoV-2 weren’t in the immediate area. The further implication is that there’s no way natural zoonotic spillover could have happened.
However, Angela Rasmussen notes:
Yes the virus emerged in Wuhan & the WIV is there & studies SARS-related CoVs, but that’s where the truth ends.Shi Zhengli’s lab does great work on SARSr-CoVs, but they aren’t the only lab in the world doing so. They aren’t even the only lab in China doing this work. pic.twitter.com/p1fGheV5ZQ
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) June 4, 2024
Fun fact: early in 2020 I joined a WHO Expert Group on experimentally modeling SARS-CoV-2. Multiple folks from China were there, none of whom were from WIV or Wuhan. SARS-CoV-1 emerged in China, so many labs there study these viruses. Wuhan isn’t special & WIV is one of many.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) June 4, 2024
The Wuhan Institute of Virology is, of course, central to lab leak conspiracy theories; so conspiracists do their damnedest to portray it as utterly unique and special, the only possible place where the “lab leak” could have occurred. It’s not. It just happened to be in the city where the first major outbreak due to the novel coronavirus happened.
Next up is the point that initially wasn’t a huge part of the lab leak conspiracy theory but has since become central to it, because it allows conspiracists to blame Anthony Fauci, a scientist named Peter Daszak, and, of course, the Chinese:
The year before the outbreak, the Wuhan institute, working with U.S. partners, had proposed creating viruses with SARS‑CoV‑2’s defining feature.
What, you might ask, was that “defining feature”? Lab leak aficionados will immediately recognize what she’s talking about:
    • In 2021, The Intercept published a leaked 2018 grant proposal for a research project named Defuse, which had been written as a collaboration between EcoHealth, the Wuhan institute and Ralph Baric at the University of North Carolina, who had been on the cutting edge of coronavirus research for years. The proposal described plans to create viruses strikingly similar to SARS‑CoV‑2.
    • Coronaviruses bear their name because their surface is studded with protein spikes, like a spiky crown, which they use to enter animal cells. The Defuse project proposed to search for and create SARS-like viruses carrying spikes with a unique feature: a furin cleavage site — the same feature that enhances SARS‑CoV‑2’s infectiousness in humans, making it capable of causing a pandemic. Defuse was never funded by the United States. However, in his testimony on Monday, Dr. Fauci explained that the Wuhan institute would not need to rely on U.S. funding to pursue research independently.
Furin cleavage sites. Why did it have to be furin cleavage sites? Again.
After conceding that the furin cleavage site in SARS-CoV-2 could have arisen naturally through evolution, Chan tries to convince you without evidence, using an argument to personal incredulity, that the site in SARS-CoV-2 could not possibly have arisen naturally and therefore the site must have been engineered:
While it’s possible that the furin cleavage site could have evolved naturally (as seen in some distantly related coronaviruses), out of the hundreds of SARS-like viruses cataloged by scientists, SARS‑CoV‑2 is the only one known to possess a furin cleavage sitein its spike. And the genetic data suggest that the virus had only recently gained the furin cleavage site before it started the pandemic.
What is a furin cleavage site? In brief, as I explained three years ago, the spike protein in SARS-CoV-2 consists of two subunits. Between those two subunits, S1 and S2, sits a site that a human protein called furin recognizes and uses to cleave the protein, resulting in its the two functional subunits. Chan appears to be recycling Nicholas Wade’s argument about the SARS-CoV-2 furin cleavage site in which he basically argued that, because a furin cleavage site of this sort hadn’t been seen in SARS-related beta coronaviruses before, it must have been engineered. It was basically a huge argument to incredulity. The problem with that argument is that such furin cleavage sites are common in a wide variety of viruses, including coronaviruses, and that scientists already had identified plausible mechanisms by which it could have ended up where it did in SARS-CoV2:
Again, this was known for months.But the problem is the non-experts who like saying 'lab leak seems possible', don't know enough on the biology to challenge Wade on this.https://t.co/CqgXfDxcXphttps://t.co/zrnitS3Ixehttps://t.co/Fc5Vvhx103https://t.co/Id3yKZpBx9 pic.twitter.com/RRPr7Cvb3H
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) May 7, 2021
Moreover, contrary to the implication that SARS-CoV-2 was “engineered,” the result of “gain of function” research on SARS-CoV-1 and other coronaviruses got wrong, everything we know strongly suggests that SARS-CoV-2 is natural, the result of viruses doing what viruses unfortunately do in the wild, evolving to be capable of infecting more hosts. If you want a detailed history of the scientific hunt for the origins of SARS-CoV-2 that is accessible to the layperson, you’d have a hard time doing much better than reading Philip Markolin’s recent post, Treacherous ancestry: An extraordinary hunt for the ghosts of SARS-CoV-2. Let’s just say that the evidence base for a natural zoonotic origin of the virus is far more extensive, multithreaded, and complex than represented by lab leak enthusiasts.
More importantly, though, the grant was never funded. Indeed, I laughed at one of the scientists’s responses to Chan’s article because, seriously, she must know how ridiculous and out of touch with the realities of grant funding her conspiracy mongering sounds, given that she works at the Broad Institute:
It’s amazing how Twitter grifter Alina Chan has gotten all of covid-contrarian twitter to get excited again over something we knew since 2021. DEFUSE was a rejected grant proposal. It was never funded. To all of us who’ve been awarded Fed research grants, this is hysterical https://t.co/Zndazju90g
— Chris Komatsu (@chris_komatsu) June 4, 2024
It’s even more hysterical to those of us who have been awarded federal research grants and also have submitted lots of federal research grants that didn’t make the cut to be funded. Of course, a little fact like an unfunded grant never stopped a good conspiracy theory, which is why lab leak conspiracists claim without evidence that scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology did the proposed experiments anyway. Unfortunately for them and Chan, not only is there no evidence that such work was carried out at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, but, even if the grant had been funded, the gain-of-function work was to have been carried out in the US, under US biosafety regulations:
And could this work have been done despite the multimillion dollar grant intended to support it? Sure. Is there evidence that this work was carried out anyway? None whatsoever. Most people don’t apply for DARPA grants they don’t need if they already have millions lying around
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) June 4, 2024
Also in this point, Chan does her damnedest to convince you that those Chinese scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology were so reckless and careless that they didn’t use appropriate lab safety protocols for work with viruses like coronaviruses. She also insinuates a conspiracy in which the scientists there hid what they had:
By 2019, Dr. Shi’s group had published a database describing more than 22,000 collected wildlife samples. But external access was shut off in the fall of 2019, and the database was not shared with American collaborators even after the pandemic started, when such a rich virus collection would have been most useful in tracking the origin of SARS‑CoV‑2. It remains unclear whether the Wuhan institute possessed a precursor of the pandemic virus.
“Remains unclear”? Again, let Dr. Rasmussen explain why all of this is deceptive:
That’s pretty simple. It doesn’t matter what containment level the WIV was using for other SARSr-CoVs because those viruses are not SARS-CoV-2, nor could these viruses ever become SARS-CoV-2. The viruses that WIV was known to have are more closely related to SARS-CoV-1.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) June 4, 2024
I also like how biochemist Larry Moran addresses point 2 very succinctly:
This is extremely misleading. The researchers at WIV worked in collabortion with scientists in other countries, including the United States, on investigating the features of coronaviruses that could lead to infection of humans. That’s exactly what you would expect them to do. They never created a virus that could be infectious.
Conspiracy theorists gonna conspiracy.
Onward to key point three: “The Wuhan lab pursued this type of work under low biosafety conditions that could not have contained an airborne virus as infectious as SARS‑CoV‑2.” First, see Dr. Rasmussen’s rebuttal above, as well as Larry Moran’s rebuttal:
The labs followed all the standard procedures for work of this type and passed an international inspection.
In brief, if the virus or a close precursor wasn’t there, even if there were a “lab leak” from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, it couldn’t be SARS-CoV-2 or a close precursor that could easily acquire the mutations that would make it transmissible between humans.
In an exceedingly weak swing for the fences, Chan also adds:
One alarming detail — leaked to The Wall Street Journal and confirmed by current and former U.S. government officials — is that scientists on Dr. Shi’s team fell ill with Covid-like symptoms in the fall of 2019. One of the scientists had been named in the Defuse proposal as the person in charge of virus discovery work. The scientists denied having been sick.
This is an old claim from at least three years ago that I characterized as “some really thin gruel.” It isn’t even known if these researchers actually had what is now called COVID-19. They could easily have had influenza or another virus. I also cited Michael Hiltzik, who quite reasonably pointed out:
Virologists point out, moreover, that it would be unlikely for COVID to affect only three people seriously enough to warrant hospital care without infecting hundreds of others in the lab or their households. The other victims might have had milder symptoms, but an outbreak of that magnitude would have been difficult to keep under wraps.
The virus, apparently, is exactly as transmissible at every time point as lab leak conspiracy theorists need it to be, no more and no less.
Key point four just made me laugh out loud:
The hypothesis that Covid-19 came from an animal at the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan is not supported by strong evidence.
Bullshit. I’m sorry, but this is the purest bullshit. The evidence was actually quite strong three years ago and has gotten only stronger since that the outbreak arose at the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan. An April 2024 review article published in in the Annual Review of Virology by Edward Holmes is the currently most recent and comprehensive summary of the evidence regarding the origins of SARS-CoV-2, although a review article published in the Journal of Virology by Alwine et al in 2023 that concludes the same thing is also quite good. (It’s just more than a year old.) I’m going to quote a key passage from the Holmes article explaining why scientists believe that the virus arose at the animal market:
There are sound reasons to conclude that the Huanan market inWuhan was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic. A detailed analysis of the geolocations of the residences of the earliest COVID-19 cases—155 patients who experienced COVID-19 during December 2019—revealed a strong spatial clustering around the Huanan market (44) (Figure 2). This clustering not only applied to those who had direct contact with the Huanan market but also applied to those with no known links to the market (45) (Figure 2). The latter is expected if the Huanan market was indeed the pandemic epicenter. Although there are likely earlier cases than those documented to date, there is no evidence for any spatial clustering away from the Huanan market, nor of outbreaks in other parts of Wuhan. Similarly, there is no evidence of systematic sampling bias toward the Huanan market, of the Huanan market being part of the early case definition, nor of the Huanan market only representing an amplifying event (44, 45). Indeed, the Huanan market had relatively low visitor numbers compared with other locations inWuhan, even other markets and shopping malls (44).What it did have were wildlife, including those known to be susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 (see below).
Phylogenetic analysis of SARS-CoV-2 genome sequences also points to the Huanan market being the epicenter of the pandemic, with the Huanan market sequences falling at the root of the SARS-CoV-2 tree. The earliest split in the SARS-CoV-2 phylogeny, which seemingly oc- curred in Wuhan, is between the A and B lineages that differ by two nucleotide substitutions (45) yet gave rise to many descendent lineages. Remarkably, despite its relatively low number of visitors, both these lineages were present at the Huanan market (44, 46, 47). The odds of this co-occurrence without the market being the global epicenter are extremely low. Molecular clock studies of SARS-CoV-2 evolution also point to a market origin. Estimates of the time to the most recent common ancestor (tMRCA) for the epidemic as a whole, of the specific outbreak inWuhan, and of the sequences from the Huanan market overlap with a time span encompassing November and December 2019, again suggestive of an outbreak that started at the Huanan market (47). This timescale also means that the virus was circulating for only a short interval before it was first de- tected by physicians in Wuhan. Additionally, these observations fit the available epidemiological and serological data from Wuhan, which provide no evidence for SARS-CoV-2 in that city prior to December 2019 (44, 48).
Holmes addresses lab leak as well:
The allegation that SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a research laboratory comes in a wide variety of often mutually exclusive forms, from a willfully engineered bioweapon to an accident during genetic engineering or a routine laboratory procedure and even to a worker infected during bat fieldwork (68–73) (Figure 3). Whether such an escape is deliberate or accidental, the laboratory in question almost certainly must have known that an incident had occurred, such that their denial necessarily indicates a cover-up (74).
This is a master class in calling lab leak a conspiracy theory without actually using the term “conspiracy theory.” Holmes also notes that, if the Wuhan Institute of Virology were the origin, there should be cases associated with the site; there are not. As this post is already getting long, I might discuss this article in more depth another time. Suffice to say that Holmes addresses the furin cleavage site and why it almost certainly evolved naturally, as well as just how weak the evidence is for an lab leak.
Chan was also busted mischaracterizing papers that she cites:
A pair of papers published in Science in 2022 made the best case for SARS‑CoV‑2 having emerged naturally from human-animal contact at the Wuhan market by focusing on a map of the early cases and asserting that the virus had jumped from animals into humans twice at the market in 2019. More recently, the two papers have been countered by other virologists and scientists who convincingly demonstrate that the available market evidence does not distinguish between a human superspreader event and a natural spillover at the market.
Greg Tucker-Kellogg calls her out for this misuse of the studies cited:
I chose that example because it's captured in a single bullet, but the same patterns hold throughout. It's a shame, because Chan *could* be an advocate for healthy critique and biosafety, but is choosing instead to be an apologist for some really lousy science.
— Greg Tucker-Kellogg (@gtuckerkellogg) June 3, 2024
That would describe Alina Chan.
Finally, she argues: “Key evidence that would be expected if the virus had emerged from the wildlife trade is still missing.”
This is true, but (1) deceptively incomplete and (2) risibly stupid when compared to the amount of evidence that is missing that would be expected if the virus had emerged from a laboratory. As is always the case with lab leak believers, there is an extreme double standard at work regarding the level of evidence they require to start to accept a natural zoonotic origin for SARS-CoV-2 compared to what they accept to convince them of lab leak.
As Larry Moran puts it, saying basically what I said above, just even more sarcastically:
It’s true that the exact infectious animal carrying SARS-CoV-2 has not been identified but the circumstantial evidence is strong—just as strong as the circumstantial evidence that sends some people to jail. It’s crazy to say that evidence for animal transmission is missing when ALL the evidence for the presence of SARS-CoV-2 at WIT is also missing.
And as Angela Rasmussen puts it:
However, that doesn’t mean the evidence we DO have doesn’t support market origin. Existing affirmative evidence isn’t invalidated by a lack of other types of evidence.Again, I have yet to see an alternative explanation for the multiple threads of evidence supporting zoonosis.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) June 4, 2024
Evidence isn’t a carton of milk. It doesn’t expire if you don’t find it. Intermediate hosts of SARS1 and MERS were not found in days as claimed and sometimes they are never found. It took years to find the reservoir for Marburg virus. Nobody debates that it is zoonotic.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) June 4, 2024
Indeed, and it’s only been a little over four years since the pandemic hit.
Alina Chan is a conspiracy theorist, and the NYT screwed up, bad
I already knew three years ago that lab leak had become a conspiracy theory. Indeed, I’ve been documenting attempts by conspiracy theorists to claim that SARS-CoV-2 had been “engineered,” starting with James Lyons-Weiler’s risibly nonsensical (from a molecular biology standpoint) claim that there were plasmid sequences in the published sequence of the virus, which indicated that it had been engineered. He went on to claim that SARS-CoV-2 had been the result of a failed attempt to make a vaccine against the original SARS (now SARS-CoV-1) that had escaped. When was this? Early February 2020, shortly after the nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 was first published.
Even so, before I close, let me just reiterate that it is not impossible that SARS-CoV-2 arose in a lab, either due to scientists carrying out modifications on existing coronaviruses or from a collection of natural coronaviruses, in which the virus escaped. The claim is not impossible, like the claims made for homeopathy. However, as I like to say, just because a hypothesis is possible does not mean that it is equally possible (or even more so) compared to a competing hypothesis. You have to look at the evidence. Lab leak conspiracy theorists love to point out missing evidence that would make a natural zoonotic origin for SARS-CoV-2 an unquestioned slam dunk, even as they gloss over the fact that their evidence base is nothing but holes that they try desperately to fill with appeals to personal incredulity that the virus could have arisen naturally, wild speculation as to how it might have escaped from a lab, conspiracy mongering about “cover-ups” everywhere, and lots and lots drawing links between facts and observations that are probably unrelated. Moreover, if there’s one thing that all versions of lab leak share, it’s suspicion and constant finger pointing at the Chinese for being less than enthusiastic and cooperative about letting investigators into the Wuhan Institute of Virology to try to determine if a lab leak happened. This is, of course, not surprising and not in and of itself evidence for a lab leak. China is an authoritarian regime, and such regimes tend to be secretive.
Also, as I pointed out before, what country would welcome investigators with open arms into one of their major research institutions to look for evidence that its scientists had screwed up and caused a worldwide disaster that’s killed millions of people and counting? Even if a government were confident that no such error had occurred, it might not be too thrilled with such an investigation, particularly when it’s coupled with what can only be called very hostile accusations of wrongdoing by high ranking legislators of a nation that is, at best, a competitor and, at worst, a geopolitical global rival, meaning that the investigation is being proposed by powerful people profoundly hostile to your country. Again, that the Chinese have been less than enthusiastic about cooperating with such accusatory investigations is not in and of itself a strong argument in favor of a lab leak. Sure, it could be a sign of a coverup, but it could also just be the normal human reaction to accusations of sloppiness, recklessness, wrongdoing, and even malfeasance by those who are less than friendly to one’s country. We just don’t know.
I can’t help at this point from quoting again Dan Samorodnitsky, as I did three years ago, regarding what lab leak really is. He started by asking a question about the plausibility of lab leak versus natural zoonosis, and then continued:
If the question is “are both hypotheses possible?” the answer is yes. Both are possible. If the question is “are they equally likely?” the answer is absolutely not. One hypothesis requires a colossal cover-up and the silent, unswerving, leak-proof compliance of a vast network of scientists, civilians, and government officials for over a year. The other requires only for biology to behave as it always has, for a family of viruses that have done this before to do it again. The zoonotic spillover hypothesis is simple and explains everything. It’s scientific malpractice to pretend that one idea is equally as meritorious as the other. The lab-leak hypothesis is a scientific deus ex machina, a narrative shortcut that points a finger at a specific set of bad actors. I would be embarrassed to stand up in front of a room of scientists, lay out both hypotheses, and then pretend that one isn’t clearly, obviously better than the other.
Besides the hazy science, there is an undeniable political aspect to this argument. When violence against Asian people in the US is spiking, it’s naive at best and violent gaslighting at worst to pretend that supporting an evidence-free hypothesis that clearly adds fuel to the idea that China inflicted COVID-19 upon the world, that they did this to us, is noble scientific dispassion. There’s a choice being made here between two ideas — one that falls neatly within the world of biology, and the other that knots together conspiracy theory, political intrigue, and xenophobia.
Nothing has happened in the last three years that alters that, nor has any evidence been presented that changes my conclusion (or Dan Samorodnitsky’s conclusion) that the lab leak is a conspiracy theory. Without compelling evidence, lab leak is indeed nothing more than a scientific deus ex machina, an idea that eliminates the need for any real scientific investigation and, conveniently enough, provides a villain, something that all conspiracy theories require. Samorodnitsky was very prescient too, observing:
And since we will never be able to prove the exact moment that SARS-CoV-2 jumped from an animal to a human, this is instead going to devolve into a culture war. We are witnessing the real-time birth of a new axis of half-truths, convenient omissions, and quackery.
Three years later, that culture war has only increased in intensity and that axis half-truths, convenient omissions, and quackery only become more impenetrable by science, evidence, and reason. Indeed, it’s grown and metastasized to eat the brains not just of conspiracy mongering hacks like the members of the Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic (like Marjorie Taylor Greene, Ronnie Jackson, Brad Wenstrup, and, heck, every Republican on the Committee), but of PhD postdoctoral fellows who really should know better, like Alina Chan, and even more senior scientists (e.g., molecular biologist Richard Ebright and microbiologist Bryce Nickels). Indeed, it’s the COVID-19 conspiracy theory that appears to have become almost equally attractive to the left as well as rightwing nutjobs. The weaponized uncertainty behind the lab leak hypothesis (now conspiracy theory) worked and continues to work to stoke fear. Moreover, if you don’t believe that lab leak is a conspiracy theory, check out this article by Stephan Lewandowsky, Peter Jacobs, and Stuart Neil contrasting the scientific method with conspiracy theory:
Revising or rejecting failed hypotheses in light of refuting evidence is central to the scientific process. Not so with conspiracy theories and pseudoscience. One of their hallmarks is that they are self-sealing: as more evidence against the conspiracy emerges, adherents keep the theory alive by dismissing contrary evidence as further proof of the conspiracy, creating an ever more elaborate and complicated theory.
Sound familiar? This is what lab leak has become; this is what lab leak adherents are doing, building an ever more complicated and unfalsifiable edifice. Lewandowsky correctly compared it to climate science denial; the similarities are striking. No matter how many scientific studies are published supporting a zoonotic origin for SARS-CoV-2 (or how high quality they are and strong the evidence is) lab leak believers always find reasons to reject them in favor of lab leak, without ever producing any evidence for lab leak that is anywhere near as high quality or strong as the evidence for zoonosis.
Indeed, Alina Chan herself is an excellent example of how wondering about a potentially reasonable explanation led her down the road away from reason and deep into pseudoscience, science denial, and conspiracy. In 2021, she was at least still capable of expressing a bit of doubt about whether her “lab leak” conspiracy theory might be the correct explanation for the pandemic:
“I have days where I think this could be natural. And if it’s natural, then I’ve done a terrible thing because I’ve put a lot of scientists in a very dangerous spot by saying that they could be the source of an accident that resulted in millions of people dying,” she says. “I would feel terrible if it’s natural and I did all this.”
Today, I don’t see even this much acknowledgment of doubt from her, and she should feel bad. My prediction is that, having been totally captured by her audience, she won’t. Meanwhile, as former ScienceBlogs colleague Ethan Siegel put it:
By following the evidence, we have learned that is precisely the case. It is natural. The observed recombination patterns that exist in the genome of SARS-CoV-2 must have been left behind by recombination events between parental lineages in the wild: where all of these different viral strains were able to meet and interbreed. Importantly, those patterns that are written in the genome of SARS-CoV-2 cannot be produced, simulated, or faked by any means in a laboratory environment.
Given that information, and the fact that this information is now nearly three full years old, it’s long past time to move past the ever-changing conspiracy theory of the lab leak hypothesis, and embrace reality. The genome of SARS-CoV-2 demonstrates it has a natural origin, whether we ever find the original virus in a wild population of animals or not. The misinformation being spread, and the scientists being vilified, over gain-of-function research has no basis in reality. A lot of scientists are, and have been for a few years now, in a very dangerous spot due to proponents of the lab leak hypothesis, as they are being accused of creating an accident that started the COVID-19 pandemic when in fact they were the proverbial firefighters working to extinguish it. It’s time to replace our conspiratorial fears with scientific truths, and to invest resources where they belong: in scientists who work to understand the Universe as it is, and to help humanity cope with the cold, hard reality that we all face.
As Siegel put it, we knew this three years ago, and in the interim the evidence bas supporting a natural origin for SARS-CoV-2 has only grown. In marked contrast, little regarding the evidence base for lab leak has changed in the last three years except that, increasingly, mainstream news outlets are giving space and fuel to conspiracy theorists like Alina Chan. The New York Times should be ashamed for lending its reputation to a conspiracy theory and the attacks on science and scientists resulting from it, but, sadly, it is far from alone when it comes to mainstream news outlets publishing credulous takes on this conspiracy theory. Even the usually reliable Pro Publica published a “train wreck” conspiracyfest of an article promoting lab leak. Apparently there’s something about this particular conspiracy theory that leads people whom I previously had thought not to be prone to conspiratorial thinking to don their tinfoil hats.

The Lab Leak Theory and the Complicit Media
How the media’s need for tales of intrigue and villains fosters the political weaponization of uncertainty
Allison Neitzel on June 27, 2024
Link

The discussion over the lab leak COVID-19 origin theory has bubbled up once again thanks to the GOP-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic (HSSCP) and The New York Times opinion section. One might be led to believe this means there is new information pointing to a definitive answer on how the pandemic emerged, but one would be mistaken.
Two recent NYT opinion pieces, Alina Chan’s “Why the Pandemic Probably Started in a Lab, in 5 Key Points” and Zeynep Tufekci’s “An Object Lesson From Covid on How to Destroy Public Trust,” have been discussed by Gregg Gonsalves and John Moore both here and in The Nation.
Pushback
This Week in Virology as well as Kristian Andersen provided helpful pushback on the factual issues with Chan’s buzzy OpEd. As I do not have advanced training in virology or immunology like the team at TWiV and Andersen do, respectively, I defer to their expertise and commentary on the scientific subject matter.
Gonsalves and Moore’s articles did an excellent job contextualizing the issues arising from Chan and Tufekci’s recent publications in today’s polarized political and media landscape. Having written about the right-wing pandemic disinformation machine that Chan and Tufekci’s articles feed, regardless of their intention, I would like to add to this part of the discussion.
In political theater, timing is everything
The publishing of Chan’s OpEd on the eve of Dr. Anthony Fauci’s hearing before the HSSCP harkens back to another buzz-generating article on the lab leak theory in February 2023. Two days before the HSSCP’s opening hearing, the Wall Street Journal published “Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid-19 Pandemic, Energy Department Now Says.” The article – but not the headline – discussed how the conclusion was updated with only “low confidence” and did not include the report from the department itself. But the story blew up online just in time for political theater show time.
As Gonsalves and Moore discussed, most of the US intelligence organizations hold that a natural origin from animal spillover, as has been seen in previous pandemics, is most likely. This is in line with the majority of virologists (see here, here, here, here, here, and here) and there is plenty of evidence against the lab leak theory. Frustratingly, no one has a definitive answer to the exact mechanism of the origins, and, as former Surgeon General Dr. Jerome Adams said recently, we may never reach one thanks to China withholding and destroying information.
This lack of cooperation does not excuse then-President Trump’s racist commentary regarding China during the outbreak. It does not make disinformation-spewing, MAGA mastermind Steve Bannon’s promotion of Chinese virologist Li-Meng Yan and her conspiracy theory that COVID-19 was a bio-weapon intentionally released by the Chinese Communist Party to momentary right-wing media stardom any less devious. And it does not make the Pentagon’s secret anti-vaccine campaign in the Philippines to undermine faith in Chinese science any less abhorrent.
Road map to an alternate reality
A month before the WSJ lab leak article and HSSCP season opener, the right-wing Heritage Foundation published their 80-page “Forging a Post-Pandemic Policy Agenda: A Road Map for COVID-19 Congressional Oversight.” It lists “veiling the origins of COVID-19” alongside “suppressing of scientific dissent” from the authors of the scientifically rebuked, pro-economy/anti-lockdown, Koch-tied Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) as “key weaknesses” in the federal pandemic response.
GBD authors Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff as well as frequent Fox News guest and WSJ contributor Dr. Marty Makary testified at the HSSCP’s first hearing. All three are members of the Norfolk Group, which was created to provide the subcommittee with aligned “experts.” This group was formed through a meeting organized by the dark money funded, anti-science pushing outfit the Brownstone Institute, which bills itself as the “spiritual child” of the GBD. Bhattacharya and Kulldorff, who worked with Trump in the White House, have written for Brownstone and were involved in a right-wing legal effort regarding “censorship” on social media (which was just knocked down by the Supreme Court).
The Heritage “Road Map” states, “By 2021, rather than being dismissed as a baseless conspiracy theory or a product of former President Trump’s undisguised hostility to Red China’s dictatorship, the lab leak theory had become progressively respectable.” That year, President Biden ordered the US intelligence organizations to increase investigation into COVID-19 origins and “continue to press for China to participate in a full investigation.” This did not mean the lab leak origin theory was any more likely.
Spinning the narrative
An outstanding 2021 WIRED article, “The Covid-19 Lab Leak Theory Is a Tale of Weaponized Uncertainty,” explained how the lack of definitive answer regarding the pandemic origins is mined by the political Right. This pairs with the crying of censorship in order to create mistrust in the “establishment,” which has been seen with the GBD and their “silenced” authors as well as by pushers of failed COVID-19 pharmaceutical cures who Brownstone and Heritage continue to support.
This is all deeply political, something a sociologist such as Tufekci should understand. In this intensely polarized political climate – in a key election year, no less – we cannot ignore the GOP’s conspiracy elephant in every media room. The spin doctors are ready and waiting to misconstrue any headline – especially if it comes from as big a name source as the NYT – for their narrative.
Emotions over facts
Which is why it is particularly disappointing that virologist Jim Alwine claims the NYT has rejected his and his colleagues’ pro-zoonosis articles – including an attempted rebuttal of Chan’s flawed OpEd. The response the NYT did publish rehashed her points alongside some arguments for natural origins – hardly a counterbalance to Chan’s one-sided piece.
As Alwine said, “The lab leak theory is great clickbait, a flashy tale with intrigue and purported villains. But the presentation of scientific facts and truths will never make the Hollywood screen.” Whether or not it is the intention of the NYT opinion editors, prioritizing engagement in this way serves the political party that plays to emotions over facts.
Big money and the erosion of public trust
Compared to American politics, science is pretty boring. Throughout the pandemic, scientists have had to fight a David vs. Goliath battle against the deep-pocketed right-wing disinformation machine to get high-quality messaging out to the public. This has played a key role in the erosion of public trust in science and our American scientific institutions – which plays into a larger attack on our institutions (the courts, education, the election system, etc.).
The Heritage Foundation is also behind Project 2025, the truly frightening policy roadmap for a second Trump presidency, which essentially aims to take a sledgehammer to our institutions and democracy. Their road map for the congressional COVID-19 inquiry in the lead-up to the election supports Trump’s campaign by distracting from his absolute failure of leadership during the pandemic outbreak, which hit as he was gearing up for his last election and desperate for COVID-19 to simply disappear.
Competing narratives and media fatigue
The HSSCP’s similarly named, Democrat-led predecessor, the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis (HSSCC), published three key reports in the summer and fall of 2022 on the Trump administration’s interference with the federal pandemic response before the Left lost control of the House in the 2022 midterm elections. Unfortunately, due to media fatigue with the pandemic and likely thanks to being overshadowed by the prime time January 6th Committee Hearings, these reports got little, if any, media attention.
These key HSSCC reports detail the pushing of the herd immunity strategy (this report names Bhattacharya and Kulldorff), the antagonism of the Food and Drug Administration over Trump’s false miracle cure hydroxychloroquine, and the unprecedented interference with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s public messaging. Ideally we would have a House subcommittee continuing the investigations into such issues today, but the HSSCP appears to be following the Heritage script.
Wild accusations
This Heritage HSSCP is going beyond weaponized uncertainty of the pandemic’s origins, claiming scientists such as Fauci and EcoHealth Alliance president Peter Daszak are the “villains” responsible for COVID-19 and covering up its origins. As Gonsalves and Moore said regarding the lab leak theory, “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” – and neither the HSSCP nor Chan have the proof to back them up. Yet the personal consequences for the scientists they implicate and demonize are very real.
HSSCP Republicans frankly embarrassed themselves during the Fauci hearing (looking at you, MTG) with their lack of evidence for extreme accusations of wrongdoing regarding ties to research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology and this supposed cover-up. There is, however, plenty of evidence to pin avoidable deaths on Trump’s mishandling of the COVID-19 outbreak and the MAGA movement’s anti-science crusade.
Failed leadership
It is important to investigate the pandemic’s origins – to the extent that we can, given China’s lack of transparency – in order to learn as much as possible to safeguard the future as much as is humanly possible. But regardless of how COVID-19 came to be, we would have been a whole lot safer with almost anyone but Trump in the Oval Office.
This is not to say that the Biden administration has handled the pandemic situation they inherited perfectly. But we need a proper post-mortem on the Trump administration’s myriad failures in the crucial early days in order to learn from them and try to heal as a nation. We clearly cannot expect this investigation to come from the HSSCP, so we must lean on the media to fulfill this need. As the “paper of record,” the NYT is failing in its leadership role on this and exacerbating an already out of control political problem.
Avoiding a dystopian future
There has been deserved recent media coverage of Heritage’s Project 2025. A preview of the dystopian future that awaits us should there be a second Trump presidency is playing out with the dragging of scientists – who have already suffered years of death threats due to the right-wing pandemic disinformation machine – before the HSSCP for Stalinist show trials.
This should shock and deeply disturb the public, but first the public needs to be made aware of what exactly is going on and who is pulling the strings. If the media needs a tale of intrigue and villains to care, well, here it is. But it never should have reached this point, and the complicit mainstream media bears some of the blame.
        ◦ I wish I could end this on a more uplifting note, but all I can do is put out a plea to leaders in the media to do better by your nation’s weary scientific community and the American public before it’s too, too late. It’s already too late.

How conspiracy theories like COVID-19 “lab leak” harm science and public health
Ever since COVID-19 first emerged in 2020, evidence-free claims that it had arisen due to a “lab leak” have proliferated. A recent paper argues that this conspiracy theory has been very harmful to science. I argue that it’s more than just lab leak that is harmful.
David Gorski on August 5, 2024
Link

“Lab leak,” or the hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 (the coronavirus that causes COVID-19) arose and escaped from a virology lab, has been a frequent topic on SBM since very early in the pandemic, for obvious reasons. After all,  every outbreak or pandemic of a new pathogen over the last several decades had spawned conspiracy theories that the pathogen was a “bioweapon” that had escaped (or been intentionally released from) a laboratory, a list that included HIV/AIDS, Ebola, and H1N1. For instance, there was a major conspiracy theory about HIV/AIDS that involved its creation at Fort Detrick when scientists supposedly spliced together two other viruses, Visna and HTLV-1 and then tested on prison inmates. (Interestingly, this turned out to be a Russian propaganda operation codename Operation INFEKTION designed to blame the AIDS pandemic on the US biological warfare program.) So it was completely predictable that similar conspiracy theories would emerge about COVID-19. Despite the paucity of scientific evidence in support of lab leak in the virology community, it has emerged as the most popular explanation for COVID-19 on social media and even in the mainstream press, particularly in, but nowhere near limited to, right wing sources. In the context of that history, I was very interested to come across a commentary in the Journal of Virology by James Alwine and 40 other authors entitled The harms of promoting the lab leak hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 origins without evidence. In the lay press, there was also an article in STAT news by John P. Moore, one of the co-authors of the Journal of Virology commentary, entitled The coronavirus lab leak hypothesis is damaging science.
Both articles make a compelling argument that the scientific hypothesis turned conspiracy theory known as lab leak is causing harm to science. I wanted to take a look at the arguments made, which are compelling, but point out that lab leak is far from alone in terms of conspiracy theories that harm science, public health, and society in general. First, however, let’s take a step back.
Lab leak: A somewhat plausible scientific hypothesis turned conspiracy theory
As was completely predictable, it didn’t take long after the emergence of a major outbreak of pneumonia in late 2019/early 2020 due to a novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China for conspiracy theories to arise claiming that the novel pathogen had “leaked” from a lab, a claim that ultimately came to be known as the “lab leak.” The first version that I encountered claimed, based on the recently published nucleotide sequence of the coronavirus that later came to be named COVID-19, that the new pathogen had been the result of a failed attempt to develop a vaccine against SARSwhich had threatened to become a pandemic in 2002—that had somehow “leaked” had of a lab. (Unsurprisingly, antivax conspiracy theorist James Lyons-Weiler made this claim on Del Bigtree‘s podcast in February 2020.) It didn’t take long for the conspiracy theory to—shall we say?—evolve to claims that COVID-19 was a bioweapon gone wrong (and escaped) or, as it became much clearer to the more “reasonable” conspiracy theorists that there were no compelling features in the nucleotide sequence of COVID-19 to indicate genetic engineering or “gain-of-function” research having produce the new virus, that a natural coronavirus collected from bats for study had somehow “leaked” from the lab. (I note that it’s very convenient that the coronavirus just happened to be one that could infect humans relatively efficiently and cause life-threatening disease in a minority.)
Conspiracy theories aside, however, I’ve been consistent in emphasizing that a lab leak origin for COVID-19 was possible. My position has simply been, since early on, that there has been no convincing scientific evidence for lab leak. Instead, the evidence promoted by lab leak adherents consists mainly of speculative handwaving based on the location of the Wuhan Institute of Virology in the same city where the first outbreak was identified, misidentification of features of the virus (e.g., the furin cleavage site) as evidence of “engineering,” and extreme distrust of the Chinese government. In contrast, emerging evidence since very early in the pandemic has consistently favored a natural zoonotic origin for the virus; i.e., that, like many previous pathogens, SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, jumped from an animal reservoir to humans. Indeed, I had recognized by 2021 that, regardless of whether or not lab leak was possible as an explanation for the origin of SARS-CoV-2, evidence was far more in favor of zoonosis than lab leak, while the versions of lab leak that had taken hold among ideologues and politicians had rapidly become more of a conspiracy theory than a valid scientific hypothesis. Fast forward to a couple of months ago when I last discussed lab leak in the context of the New York Times inexplicably having decided to lend its platform and prestige to Alina Chan, whom I’ve dubbed the queen of lab leak conspiracy theories, publishing an op-ed by her on the same day that Anthony Fauci was scheduled to testify in front of the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis (HSSCC). While no new substantive evidence—nada, zero, zip!—has emerged for lab leak since 2021, evidence for zoonosis has only accumulated, as I have summarized a number of times. While one cannot yet entirely rule out lab leak as the origin for SARS-CoV-2, I tend to make that argument in the same way that I discuss alternative medicine quackery. At this point, the onus is on lab leak conspiracy theorists to produce actual positive scientific evidence for lab leak as the origin of SARS-CoV-2, rather than their usual spreading of fear, uncertainty, and doubt about current scientific evidence surrounding SARS-CoV-2 and its origins.
Most importantly, lab leak now shares all of the components of conspiracy theory that I discussed in May 2020, just as the full gravity of how horrific the pandemic would become was starting to dawn on the general public:
It should be self-explanatory how these elements, particularly “I” (immune to evidence) and “N” (nefarious intent) apply to lab leak.
I won’t belabor this too much, but lab leak stories are contradictory. Was SARS-CoV-2 a “bioweapon”? Was it the result of “gain-of-function” research? Was it the result of a failed attempt to make a SARS vaccine? Was it just a natural coronavirus stored for study that had somehow “leaked”? Depending on which lab leak proponent you ask, it could be any or all of these! Of course, overriding suspicion and nefarious intent are largely self-explanatory, too, with the suspicion being mainly focused on China and its supposedly nefarious intent. (Remember, in a conspiracy theory, the Bad Thing is never due to incompetence, accident, or mischance; it’s always Them intending us harm. The overriding suspicion found in conspiratorial thinking results in the belief that nothing occurs by accident, which often results in re-interpreting randomness.) Of course, being authoritarian, the Chinese government sometimes made it too easy for conspiracy theorists to paint its actions in the worst possible light, but far more of the evidence supposedly supporting lab leak seems to be rooted in suspicion of the Chinese than in actual science. Naturally, any pandemic would produce the sense that “something must be wrong,” but in this case, although conspiracy theorists may occasionally abandon specific ideas when they become untenable, the revisions never change their overall feeling that “something must be wrong” and the “official account” is based on deception.
Most importantly, though, lab leak is immune to evidence. Even as scientific evidence accumulates in favor of zoonosis, with no concomitant accumulation of evidence in favor of lab leak, lab leak adherents fervently cling to their idea as the One True Origin of SARS-CoV-2. It doesn’t matter how lopsided in favor of zoonotic origin the scientific evidence base is. To the conspiracy theorist, that very lopsidedness is evidence that “they” (e.g., virologists, evolutionary biologists specializing in viruses, and other infectious disease scientists who have increasingly concluded that SARs-CoV-2 jumped to humans in a zoonotic event) are ideologically captured and evidence for “lab leak” is being either covered up or ignored.
But how do lab leak conspiracy theories harm science?
The proliferation of a conspiracy theory
Before we discuss how lab leak conspiracy mongering has harmed science, let’s set the stage by citing a passage in the Journal of Virology in which Alwine et al compare the two hypotheses, but, more importantly, contrast the scientific attitude towards evidence with the attitude towards evidence exhibited by lab leak proponents:
There are two broad competing hypotheses for the origins of SARS-CoV-2: (i) the lab leak hypothesis, the most discussed version of which posits that the virus was modified, or even created, in the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) and, by some mechanism, escaped the laboratory; and (ii) the zoonosis hypothesis, wherein the virus emerged into the human population through a naturally occurring animal-to-human transmission. Viruses often spill over into humans, but these are typically dead-end events that rarely lead to sustained human-to-human transmission and rarely spark a pandemic. Wildlife coronaviruses have long been poised for emergence into humans (1). It is estimated that there are ~66,280 people infected with SARS-CoVs each year due to human-to-bat contact, most of which result in asymptomatic infections with limited or no human-to-human transmission (2). However, in the past 25 years, there have been at least 12 instances of zoonotic transfer of viruses into humans, including three coronaviruses, which resulted in epidemics or pandemics (3).
Dr. Fauci testified that, after examining the scientific data, most scientists have concluded that SARS-CoV-2 most likely emerged in humans as a zoonosis. The evidence supports the scenario that two distinct ancestral lineages of SARS-CoV-2 jumped from animals into humans, and that the Huanan Seafood Market in Hubei Provence, China, where wild animals were routinely present and slaughtered, was the epicenter of the pandemic (4–9). Importantly, Dr. Fauci acknowledged that he remains open to evidence supporting a lab leak if it were to become available. Indeed, all scientists must be open to this possibility. Factoring in new data that are sound and validated, even if a prevailing hypothesis were contradicted, is an essential aspect of scientific training. A critical guiding principle of science is that knowledge is continually revised and updated based on quality new evidence.
Again, let’s go back to one of the characteristics of conspiracy theories, that they are immune to evidence. In contrast, science is not. If someone were to produce highly compelling scientific evidence in favor of lab leak as the origin for SARS-CoV-2, scientists would consider it, debate it, try to replicate and expand upon it, and then, if the evidence passed all those tests, lab leak would supplant zoonosis as the dominant hypothesis. As I like to point out, the process would likely be messy and contentious and might take longer than one might wish, but science does eventually correct itself in response to evidence. I can honestly say that I have not seen a single piece of evidence or a single argument for lab leak that is not a rehash or modified version of evidence or arguments that I first saw in 2020. Yet, none of that stopped the New York Times from not only green lighting an op-ed by conspiracy theorist Alina Chan entitled Why the pandemic probably started in a lab, in 5 key points. In actuality, the NYT did more than just publish this op-ed; it promoted it, lent considerable resources to producing eye-popping graphics for it, and published it on the same day that Fauci testified. (Complicit media, indeed!) Alwine et al note that Chan’s “presented the same points she has offered over the past four years” that are “based on conjecture, correlation, and anecdote” and misrepresent and underplay “the existing scientific data supporting a zoonotic origin of SARS-CoV-2.”
As Alwine et al note:
Many questions about the origins of SARS-CoV-2 remain unanswered and may never be fully resolved. We cannot currently disprove the lab leak hypothesis. Nevertheless, the lines of evidence needed to validate one hypothesis over another are not epistemically comparable (16). Validating the zoonotic origin is a scientific question that relies on history, epidemiology, and genomic analysis, that when taken together, support a natural spillover as the probable origin. This evidence is driven by scientific data that must be gathered and interpreted by experts. Much of the evidence that could have been obtained from animals at the Huanan Market was forever lost due to the clearance and cleansing of the market before any animals could be tested. Nonetheless, the available scientific evidence supports a zoonotic origin. Validating the lab leak hypothesis requires intelligence evidence that the WIV possessed or carried out work on a SARS-CoV-2 precursor virus prior to the pandemic. Neither the scientific community nor multiple western intelligence agencies have found such evidence.
Sound familiar? The same lack of epistemic comparability applies to the evidence base for many of the medical claims that we routinely discuss on SBM, including antivax, acupuncture, alternative medicine quackery, and homeopathy. As I like to say with respect to lab leak, just because it is possible and cannot be absolutely disproven at present does not imply that it is a hypothesis whose likelihood of being correct is equivalent to zoonosis.
How lab leak harms science
Unfortunately, as is frequently the case, among those with preexisting beliefs predisposed to accept a conspiratorial narrative, science generally loses in the public narrative. We have seen this phenomenon play out for evolution, climate science, vaccines, alternative medicine, and other scientific topics. In the case of lab leak, Alwine et al note:
Despite the absence of evidence for the escape of the virus from a lab, the lab leak hypothesis receives persistent attention in the media, often without acknowledgment of the more solid evidence supporting zoonotic emergence (17). This discourse has inappropriately led a large portion of the general public to believe that a pandemic virus arose from a Chinese lab. These unfounded assertions are dangerous. As discussed in detail below, they place unfounded blame and responsibility on individual scientists, which drives threats and attacks on virologists. It also stokes the flames of an anti-science, conspiracy-driven agenda, which targets science and scientists even beyond those investigating the origins of SARS-CoV-2. The inevitable outcome is an undermining of the broader missions of science and public health and the misdirecting of resources and effort. The consequence is to leave the world more vulnerable to future pandemics, as well as current infectious disease threats (17).
One of the authors, Angela Rasmussen, has described on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, just how lab leak has fueled threats to her and other virologists:
This is beyond name calling on Twitter. I have filed multiple police reports due to violent threats, including being named on a “kill list” that Kristian Andersen described in his @COVIDSelect testimony. My workplace had to alter security procedures due to concerns for my safety.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) August 2, 2024
In particular, Fauci’s descriptions of how his wife and daughters were targeted with threats of sexual violence were gutting for me to hear. I am a survivor of sexual assault and much of the abuse I’ve received has been gender-based, including sexual harassment and rape threats. https://t.co/98cfPcO037
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) August 2, 2024
Allegations that I’m a mega-bitch are probably accurate, though, because being barraged by a steady stream of targeted loathing has certainly had an impact.I have a pretty thick skin. I am very self-confident. I am resilient. But this has taken a piece of my fucking soul.
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) August 2, 2024
Again, does this sound familiar? Long before COVID-19, Dr. Paul Offit described in his book Autism’s False Prophets how he and his family had suffered threats from antivaxxers that had led his University and hospital to increase security and screen his mail. This was in 2008. More recently in the era of the pandemic, Dr. Peter Hotez has been relentlessly harassed for his speaking out against antivaccine misinformant. In another branch of science entirely, climate scientists like Michael Mann have been harassed by climate science deniers in similar manners. Heck, even I, a mere blogger with nowhere near the voice of someone like Drs. Offit, Hotez, or Rasmussen, have been harassed on and off since 2005, including a campaign of defamation by Mike Adams and a spurious libel suit by a quack. I, too, have even received the odd death threat, although nothing on the order of what Drs. Offit, Hotez, and Rasmussen have received. Then, of course, there are always the random social media posts fervently hoping that I will be included in the group of “guilty” scientists and physicians that antivaxxers fantasize about dragging before tribunals and hanging.
Then, of course, if we are too outspoken, negative, or sarcastic, the very same people fueling hate against scientists compare us to Hamas:
Perhaps my struggle with engaging the lab leakers is related to their practice of “rational and polite” discourse.I criticized Alina Chan’s qualifications and misleading pro-lab leak book, so her co-author called me “emotional, extreme, and nasty” and compared me to Hamas. pic.twitter.com/LHm4Tns5iR
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) August 2, 2024
All of this is a result of how conspiratorial thinking by definition requires villains. Who are the villains in the lab leak narrative? Scientists, of course, specifically the scientists who supposedly either created SARS-CoV-2 through reckless “gain-of-function” research (they didn’t) or carelessly let stored natural coronaviruses escape. In effect, this casting scientists as the villains in lab leak primes the public to distrust the very scientists working on preventing the next pandemic thusly:
Scientists who studied coronaviruses or led the response to the pandemic have been accused of engineering SARS-CoV-2 or allowing it to escape from a lab due to inadequate biosafety. Some have been unfairly accused of being part of an international cover-up or accused of taking bribes from NIH. Yet more scientists have been attacked for using objectively gathered data to conclude that zoonosis is the most likely origin of the pandemic or for simply engaging in communication of the evidence with the media and the general public. The unsubstantiated claims of the lab leak theory have provoked harassment, intimidation, threats and violence towards scientists, which are often vile in the online space. An article in Science reported that, of 510 researchers who had published on SARS-CoV-2 or COVID-19, 38% acknowledged harassment ranging from personal insults to threats of violence, “doxing,” and personal contact (18). A second survey, which included 1,281 scientists in a wide range of fields, found that 51% experienced at least one form of harassment, sometimes repeatedly for years.
As Dr. Moore notes in STAT:
My concern, and that of many other virologists, is that the evidence-light lab leak hypothesis is damaging the virology research community at a time when it has an essential role to play in the face of pandemic threats. The attacks on Fauci are far from unique. Coronavirus virologists have been falsely accused of engineering SARS-CoV-2, allowing it to escape from a lab due to inadequate safety protocols, being participants in an international cover-up, and taking grants as bribes from NIAID for favoring the zoonosis hypothesis. There is mounting harassment, intimidation, threats and violence towards scientists that are particularly vile in the online space.
I’ve written about that how conspiracy theorists portray NIH grants not as funding that is awarded on a competitive basis using scientific merit and supporting evidence as the main criteria to determine who gets funded, but rather as largesse doled out by a Godfather-like NIH to reward loyalty, in which scientists approach the NIH much like this:
Hint: NIH awards are not doled out like this, with Anthony Fauci playing the role of the Godfather.
As Alwine et al (and Moore) note, lab leak conspiracy theories, like other science-denying conspiracy theories, serve another purpose. They demoralize scientists to the point of wanting to quit in order to escape the harassment and just general hassle; alternatively, some seriously consider shifting the focus of their work to less politically charged topics, with the following dangerous results:
We now see a long-term risk of having fewer experts engaged in work that may help thwart future pandemics, and of fewer scientists willing to communicate the findings of sophisticated, fast-moving research topics that are important for global health. Research that could prepare us for future pandemics has been deferred, diverted, or abandoned (3). Most worrisome for future preparedness, the next generation of scientists has well-founded fears about entering fields related to emerging viruses and pandemic science (19–21).
I, too, fear that the science-denying conspiracy theories that have become so dominant will discourage young people interested in science from pursuing a scientific career. After all, an academic scientific career is damned hard enough as it is. The difficulty getting through graduate school, developing a research project, and then competing for limited funding to keep one’s research chugging along productively is draining enough. If you add to that the concern that your work will bring you under attack or force you to respond to attacks by conspiratorial politicians, social media influencers, and press and even face threats of physical violence, you can see how a career in science becomes a lot less attractive.
It’s not just the threat to scientists, though. The dominance of lab leak narratives in science can also result in policies that hinder science. For instance, the deceiving narratives regarding biosafety can paradoxically lead to less effective biosafety, as Alwine et al note:
While biosafety standards are critically important for research, the anxiety evoked by the lab leak hypothesis has resulted in some proposals for policies that, if adopted, would unnecessarily restrict research required for developing vaccines and antivirals in the US (20, 22). The US has one of the strongest and safest infrastructures for research globally. The policies aimed at virology research in the US will not protect against work with viruses of known pandemic potential occurring at inadequate biosafety containment (below biosafety level 3) in other countries, which poses the risk of lab exposures.
Indeed. The “concern” about biosafety exhibited by lab leak proponents goes beyond concern based on evidence and science to inform evidence-based strategies to improve biosafety and plows straight into the realm of paranoia. As Dr. Moore adds:
All virologists embrace the need for laboratory safety. None of them ignore the implications of the lab leak hypothesis — that there could be a future escape of a dangerous virus from a research laboratory. However, lab leak anxiety underpins proposals for policies that would unnecessarily restrict research on vaccines and antiviral agents in the U.S. The overarching concern here is that the lab leak narrative fuels mistrust in science and public health infrastructures. The increasingly virulent and widespread anti-science agenda damages individual scientists and their institutions, and hinders planning to counter future epidemics and pandemics.
Also, going back to Alwine et al:
Moreover, a looming threat for future pandemics is the illegal wildlife trade coupled with wet markets abroad. The US State Department and the United Nations (UN) estimate that the wildlife trade is the third largest illegal trafficking activity behind drugs and weapons, generating up to $20 billion annually. Animals slaughtered and sold in wet markets are a clear threat for zoonotic virus transmission to humans. Globally, policymakers have done little to curtail or effectively regulate the illegal wildlife trade and wet market practices. As well as the clear risk of future spillover events, these economic practices also undermine health security, destabilize habitats and communities, and fuel the spread of infectious diseases more generally. Further, high density commercial farming of animals (e.g., chickens, pigs, cattle) in the US and abroad also poses a major pandemic threat, as evidenced by the avian H5N1 influenza virus that is now spreading through dairy cows and other mammals with some transmission to humans. These wider dynamics underpin why our societal understanding about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 matters.
From an SBM perspective, I can’t help but note that much of the illegal trade in wildlife mentioned above involves trade in wildlife whose parts are used to produce quack treatments, particularly those rooted in traditional Chinese medicine. As I like to say, it’s all interrelated. In this case, the popularity of non-evidence-based quackery, including its integration into “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and “integrative medicine” contributes to the demand for quack treatments that drive demand for the illegal wildlife trade.
Finally:
Science is humanity’s best insurance against threats from nature, but it is a fragile enterprise that must be nourished and protected (23). What is now happening to virology is a stark demonstration of what is happening to all of science. It will come to affect every aspect of science in a negative and possibly a dangerous way, as has already happened with climate science. It is the responsibility of scientists, research institutions, and scientific organizations to push back against the anti-virology attacks, because what we are seeing now may be the tip of the proverbial iceberg.
It is the tip of the proverbial iceberg. I like to argue that all science denial is a form of conspiracy theory. In this, barring compelling new evidence that has not been produced in four years and will likely never be produced, lab leak is no different from climate science denial, creationism, antivax, and the medical beliefs that result in quackery. All weaken the scientific enterprise and fuel distrust of science far beyond healthy skepticism based on a reality-based assessment of how science and medicine have performed historically. All have been strengthened immeasurably by the conspiracy theories that have arisen during the pandemic. It is long past time that we pushed back, as futile as the task might appear right now.

Why is The New York Times now promoting an anti-science agenda?
This essay stems from concerns about two editorials published in The New York Times recently. We felt that they were problematic in that the past is viewed through a blurred prism to produce revisionist history. By John P. Moore and Gregg Gonsalves.
John Moore, Gregg Gonsalves on June 22, 2024
Link

The New York Times’ science reporters have provided outstanding coverage of Covid-19 since the earliest days in 2020, including how the pandemic started. Unfortunately, the paper’s opinion desk has had a far more checkered record, culminating in two highly controversial essays that were released online last week and co-published in a two-page spread in the print edition on Sunday, June 9. The Times has made it clear to colleagues that it is not interested in considering articles that rebut these two essays. Despite that attitude, the outlandish nature of the two articles does require a public reckoning.
The essay by Alina Chan reiterates speculation that the Covid-19 pandemic originated via a leak of an infectious virus from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV), in Wuhan, China, in late 2019. There is no information in her essay, as it reiterates points made on multiple occasions elsewhere, including in her book. She adds into the mix the persistent allegation that NIH-funded research was instrumental in the creation of the coronavirus that sparked the pandemic. These are extraordinary claims: Science, and US tax dollars, are being blamed for a pandemic that has killed over 1.1 million Americans, and perhaps as many as 20 million people worldwide. But extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and there is no verifiable proof that what Chan alleges actually happened. Multiple US intelligence agencies have investigated the origin of the Covid-19 pandemic. None of them has been able to come up with a definitive answer as to what happened, a reflection of the lack of evidence. Some intelligence community (IC) reports favor a lab leak, but without high confidence, but a majority of the IC reports suggest that a natural origin, via animal-to-human transmission in a Wuhan market, is the more likely explanation that is consistent with all the scientific evidence we have to date. There remains uncertainty about happened, which may never be resolved because only the Chinese government has access to more definitive information – and it’s not releasing what it may know. That lack of surety is why it remains valid to consider both the lab leak and “natural origins” as on the table.
Despite the evidence gaps, Chan, however, has written an essay that is deeply slanted towards the lab leak hypothesis. To her, speculation, however much it has been debunked over the past 4 years, becomes fact – or as near to it as makes no difference. The “science” she presents, the underlying virology of what she claims happened at the WIV, has all been debunked over and over again, both in the science literature and in online essays. Chan highlights at considerable length what’s not known about the “natural origin” hypothesis, implying that the absence of evidence is in some way sinister – while skating over the much bigger evidence gaps involved in her preferred lab leak explanation. The alleged role played by the NIH in funding dangerous virology experiments at the WIV has also been thoroughly refuted. Of note is that the WIV’s funding for coronavirus research came overwhelmingly from the Chinese government; if something problematic did in fact happen, to blame the NIH is to entirely miss the main point. Here is but one example of the fallacious thinking inherent to Chan’s analyses. She, correctly, states that pandemic started in Wuhan, and that the WIV is located in Wuhan. But she then asserts that these two facts must be inter-connected. That’s false logic. Let’s pose another hypothetical: If a new pandemic were first identified via samples collected in a food court at Hartsdale International Airport in Atlanta, Georgia, would we conclude that a leak from the CDC’s laboratory in that cite was responsible? Or would we factor in that Hartsdale is America’s busiest airport, and hence a potential source of virus dissemination between humans? Overall, Chan seeks to blame science for the pandemic, but she can offer no proof that adequately underpins her opinions.
The accompanying essay by Zeynep Tufekci blames scientists and public health specialists in the Trump administration for poor decision-taking and messaging in the tumultuous early months of the pandemic. Having 20/20 hindsight about 2020 is all very well, but not to us, who also remember what it was like in February through April of that year. Decisions had to be taken under circumstances where hard evidence was hard or impossible to come by. It was entirely reasonable (and the only option) to base decisions on the assumption that CoV-2 would behave like SARS-CoV-1 and/or influenza. In early 2020, nobody knew then what only became clear very much later about how the virus was transmitted under what circumstances. That kind of knowledge only emerged over time. The fuss Dr. Tufekci makes about the “6-foot rule” for social distancing is way wide of the mark. Of course there was no hard evidence about 6-foot, as opposed to 5- or 7-, 4- or -8. How could there be at that time? But the recommendation was neither irrational nor unreasonable, as it was based on available information about other viruses. We also now know, in mid-2024, that masks do in fact reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Obtaining, collating and understanding the data on complex social topics isn’t a rapid process. Criticizing good faith decisions made at a time of international crisis is simply not helpful.
The leading European democracies, Canada, and other nations all made decisions comparable to what was done in the USA. Indeed, many public health specialists, and ongoing national enquiries (e.g., in the UK), have concluded that lockdowns, masking recommendations and other restrictions were generally applied too little and too late – and this was at a time when American cities were seeing bodies pile up in refrigerated trucks. It should also be recalled that American public health officials were working in the administration of a President, Trump, who had no understanding of the science and who was susceptible to the pseudoscience and quackery poured into his ears by other administration officials, Republican politicians, and a grab-bag of business people whose only interest was in corporate profits. How could a science-based, public health agenda ever predominate in that environment? Why blame the rational officials who did their best in impossible circumstances? And why did Dr. Tufekci ignore the one true public health fiasco in the early days – the CDC’s appalling failure over COVID tests under the supine leadership of Dr. Robert Redfield?
Tufekci makes favorable comments on how the UK handled key aspects of Covid, based on a brief visit she made to London in 2021. One of us is British by birth and has many family members and friends in that country. First, the UK’s initial response to Covid was, if anything, worse than the USA’s – leading to a 2020 death rate that was among the worst in Europe. Poor leadership from Prime Minister Johnson was to blame, as is now also becoming clear from the UK’s national Covid inquiry. Dr. Tufekci suggests that trust in the National Health Service was at the heart of why Britons embraced the Covid vaccines more than in the USA. The reality, however, is that all three of the UK’s main political parties, and every leading newspaper, supported the vaccine rollout in 2020-2021. In the UK, there was little or none of the politically motivated vaccine polarization that we saw in the USA, a phenomenon that created “Red Covid” (i.e., Republican voters were persuaded to forego the Covid vaccines, and hence died of Covid at a sadly disproportionate rate). Indeed, the right-of-center Conservative party has even expelled a member who spread anti-vaccine propaganda. Is there a universe in which our Republican party would kick out, for example, Marjorie Taylor Greene for expressing similar views? Yes, disinformation about Covid exists in the UK, but not at the level we now experience in America.
It is disinformation about COVID-19, and particularly vaccines that has so damaged “public trust” in science and public health, particularly among Republican voters and the consumers of information (sic) pumped out by right-wing media. In her essay, Dr. Tufekci badly misses this key point when she focuses her criticism on the actions of Trump administration scientists and public health specialists during the first months of the pandemic. The real villains lie elsewhere. Accordingly, Dr. Tufekci has done our professions a great disservice. And, sadly, she was enabled by The New York Times opinion desk editors. What has this “paper of record” now become? Does it value online clicks over accuracy? Has it become merely a vehicle that backs its outstanding and very popular Games Apps? Does the Times truly seek to energize the anti-science agenda that is now such a feature of right-wing media outlets such as the New York Post, the Washington Examiner, the Epoch Times? It would not have surprised us to see the Chan and Tufekci essays on those websites. But to see them in The New York Times was simply shocking.

Great Barrington Declaration Author Joins COVID-19 Lab Leak-Pushing Group
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and the merging of political pandemic narratives
Allison Neitzel on August 24, 2024
Link

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya has linked up with another fringe group of scientists. The Stanford University health economist disastrously advised Trump on pandemic policy and was a co-author of the scientifically rebuked, pro-economy/anti-lockdown Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). Now, he is on the board of directors for a group that continues pushing the lab leak COVID-19 origin hypothesis. Biosafety Now announced the addition of Bhattacharya on their Twitter/X account on August 14.
🚨ANNOUNCEMENT🚨Biosafety Now is pleased to announce the addition of five new members to our Leadership Team.Board of Directors:➡️ Jay Bhattacharya (M.D., Ph.D., Professor of Health Policy, Stanford) @DrJBhattacharya Advisory Board:➡️ Simon Wain-Hobson (Ph.D., Emeritus…
— Biosafety Now! (@BiosafetyNow) August 14, 2024
Weaponizing uncertainty
While Republican politicians and a concerning portion of the general public have embraced the lab leak origin narrative, the overwhelming majority of the virology community hold that a natural origin from animal spillover, as has been seen in previous pandemics, is most likely. The lack of definitively identified mechanism for the likely animal spillover has, for years now, been a source of weaponizable uncertainty.
Trump began pushing the lab leak narrative early in the pandemic. In April 2020, the strategic communications firm O’Donnell & Associates published their “Corona Big Book” of suggested anti-China messaging for Republicans, which featured lab leak talking points. Despite a lack of evidence to support the leak, the Trump administration controversially cut National Institutes of Health funding to the Wuhan Institute of Virology and EcoHealth Alliance, an organization that conducts federally-funded global research into viruses. Seventy-seven US Nobel Laureates in the sciences signed a letter speaking out against this decision in May 2020.
This is not to say the scientific community was automatically closed off to the lab leak hypothesis. As EcoHealth Alliance recently discussed in a public statement on the ongoing political attack on their organization, former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and chief medical advisor to Trump, Dr. Anthony Fauci, maintains an open mind regarding a lab leak origin while asserting the natural origin to be most likely. Emails obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request show Fauci in 2020 cooperating with scientists who were looking into whether the novel virus could have arisen from lab research.
What is Biosafety Now?
Biosafety Now was founded by two Rutgers University professors, molecular biologist Dr. Richard Ebright and microbiologist Dr. Bryce Nickels in February of 2023. While calling for laboratory safety measures is not inherently wrong, they have refused to be open to evidence pointing away from the lab leak origin to which they have anchored themselves. And the behavior of these two academic professionals cannot be justified.
In March, a dozen scientists who have been on the receiving end of online harassment from Ebright and Nickels filed a formal complaint with Rutgers. It highlighted instances of the two scientists comparing their “opposition” on the origins issue to “historical war criminals and mass murderers, including Pol Pot, Adolf Eichmann, Josef Mengele, and Shirō Ishii” and encouraging their large online followings to harass their fellow members of the scientific community. The GBD crowd has engaged in their own vengeful rhetoric in calls for accountability for “lockdowners.”
Last month, Nickels and Bhattacharaya co-authored an OpEd for the New York Post titled “Why science should never try to triumph over nature.” Their piece promotes the lab leak and calls on Congress “to enact and implement independent oversight for research that represents an existential risk to humanity.” A week prior to their Post article, BioSafety Now shared an interview Nickels and Bhattacharya conducted with Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY), who has been one of the louder voices in Congress to push the lab leak narrative.
Bhattacharya and the Biosafety Now founders are no strangers to The Hill. Bhattacharya is a member of the Norfolk Group created to send GOP-friendly “experts” to the Republican-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic (HSSCP) and testified in their opening hearing on “examining COVID policy decisions” in February 2023. In June, Ebright testified to the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs for the “Origins of COVID-19: An Examination of Available Evidence” hearing. Paul serves as the ranking member of this Senate committee and used his time to further promote the lab leak.
Politics over science
As I have previously discussed, the GBD and the lab leak were highlighted in the right-wing think tank Heritage Foundation’s “Road Map for COVID-19 Congressional Oversight” published a month ahead of the first HSSCP hearing featuring Bhattacharya. The GOP-led subcommittee appears to be following this script and has focused on the lab leak throughout this spring and summer. This has seen EcoHealth Alliance president Dr. Peter Daszak and now-retired Fauci dragged before Congress for harassing show trials motivated by political agenda over science.
As I more recently discussed, the Heritage Foundation’s own “non-partisan” commission published a report on China and COVID-19 last month. This report laid out a case, based around the lab leak, to hold China responsible for US pandemic damage and recommended legal and policy actions to hold them accountable.
Bhattacharya isn’t the only new addition to Biosafety Now. As noted in the tweet above, they also announced the addition of four new members to their advisory board. They included two scientists as well as technology futurist and geopolitical commentator Jamie Metzl and science writer Matt Ridley. Metzl was the chairman of the aforementioned Heritage Foundation commission. Ridley, who has a history of climate science denialism, co-authored a book with researcher Dr. Alina Chan, who published a buzzy but flawed lab leak-promoting New York Times opinion piece the day Fauci testified to the HSSCP.
Why now? (Hint: Election year)
The seriousness with which Bhattacharya and the lab leak-pushing GOP are now taking the pandemic should be contrasted with their years of minimizing messaging. It must not be ignored that this shift comes during a key presidential election year. Notably, and by no accident, many pushing the lab leak narrative fail to address Trump’s failure of leadership in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic.
As certain narratives become less useful and others find a (manufactured) resurgence — as is currently happening with the lab leak — we see a common thread of ideologically motivated individuals like Bhattacharya spouting party-line messaging. Some new names who have promoted ideas deemed useful to this agenda find themselves players in a much larger political strategy. People like Bhattacharya, however, do so expressly for the benefit of their politics and themselves — and to the detriment of science.

Biosafety Now: Releasing The Virus Was Mass Murder. Intentionally Spreading It Was Forgivable.
I suppose it’s my turn to be called a fraudster, liar, perjurer, felon, grifter, stooge, imbecile, and maybe even murderer. What I won’t get is a reasonable explanation as to why supposedly releasing a deadly virus was mass murder, but intentionally spreading it was a forgivable “policy position”.
Jonathan Howard on September 6, 2024
Link

Fraudsters. Liars. Perjurers. Felons. Grifters. Stooges. Imbeciles. Murderers.
In a previous article, BOMBSHELL NEWS!!! The Virus I Told You Not to Worry About and Worked to Infect You With… CAME FROM A LAB!!!, I satirized Dr. Jay Bhattacharya whose sole concern about SARS-CoV-2 was where it came from, not what it did to people.
Of course, where SARS-CoV-2 came from says nothing about how we should have handled it, and it reveals nothing about the damage it did. This is obviously what matters the most. We should not forget that SARS-CoV-2 killed 1.2 million Americans, injured many more, and is not done with us yet. Much of this was preventable. One study estimated that from May 30, 2021 to September 3, 2022:
At least 232,000 deaths could have been prevented among unvaccinated adults during the 15 months had they been vaccinated with at least a primary series
If video emerged of Fauci himself, blowing SARS-CoV-2 out from a lab in Wuhan, that doesn’t mean it was OK to spread the virus once it arrived here. Irrefutable evidence that the virus leaked from a lab wouldn’t affect a single word I’ve written about it. Only someone who never treated COVID patients would say the origin of the virus was its most important feature. To me, passionate debates about how the virus emerged were often used to distract from its impact and protect doctors who openly cheered its spread. Every movement spent discussing where the virus came from, was a moment not spent discussing how the virus hurt people.
Of course, the origin of SARS-CoV-2 matters. It’s important to know the truth. However, it seems wise to act like it came from both a lab and an animal market. Its absurd to only worry about a new virus emerging from one of these sources. Normal people don’t want a deadly virus to emerge period, and ideally people handling viruses in labs and animals in the wild will all be very careful. Achieving this vital but challenging goal requires cooperation and good-faith engagement from multiple stakeholders, not performative vitriol and enmity.
I also lack expertise on this topic, and as such, I listen to scientists I’ve learned to trust. I give credence to people who have proven themselves credible in other areas, such as vaccines, and who let the evidence speak for itself, rather than resorting to juvenile, content-free taunts and accusations. I’ve received plenty of those myself, and I am sure more are headed my way.
Indeed, I am well aware that some scientists who believe SARS-CoV-2 came from a lab have launched a deluge of juvenile, content-free taunts and accusations against those who question their rectitude in any way. According to an article titled: ‘Lab-leak’ Proponents at Rutgers Accused of Defaming and Intimidating COVID-19 Origin Researchers:
Fraudsters. Liars. Perjurers. Felons. Grifters. Stooges. Imbeciles. Murderers. When it comes to describing scientists whose peer-reviewed studies suggest the COVID-19 virus made a natural jump from animals to humans, molecular biologist Richard Ebright and microbiologist Bryce Nickels have used some very harsh language. On X (formerly Twitter), where the two scientists from Rutgers University are a constant presence, they have even compared fellow researchers to Nazi war criminals and the genocidal Cambodian dictator Pol Pot.
A dozen scientists filed a formal complaint with Rutgers, noting that “several of the people Drs. Ebright and Nickels interact with have made direct threats of death and sexual violence.” Even though public health officials have needed bodyguards, Professor Ebright responded to their pleas to protect their personal safety by saying:
The first, second, third, and fifth signers of the letter provably are fraudsters; the first and third signers provably are perjurers; and all signers provably are coauthors of fraudsters and perjurers.
Charming stuff.
Non-natural potential pandemic pathogens poses existential risks to humanity
Professors Nickels and Ebright also founded an organization called Biosafety Now, which describes itself by saying:
Biosafety Now is a US-based NGO working for a future where scientific research on pathogens supports human life without also threatening it & public trust in science is restored. Biosafety Now believes that research that creates new, non-natural potential pandemic pathogens poses existential risks to humanity and provides few, if any, benefits for science, medicine, public health, or national security. We are convinced that public health and safety require that all such research be subject to independent external controls, rather than be trusted to the oversight of the scientists performing or the organizations funding the research.
They say elsewhere:
The rapidly increasing power and rapidly decreasing cost of advanced biotechnology has made lab-generated pandemics a threat to the survival of the human species.
Biosafety Now feels the threat is real and the stakes couldn’t be higher. Fair enough. While no one would object to biosafety, it’s not clear this organization can point to any real-world example where they actually improved biosafety and made the world a safer place. They do however, solicit donations and sell merch.
One of their products is called the Innocent Wildlife collection. According to Biosafety Now:
The Innocent Wildlife collection highlight animals implicated by scientists as the “intermediate host animal” from which SARS-CoV-2 may have entered humans. It also includes some animals that have not yet been accused but are concerned they may be blamed in the future. Although it is theoretically possible that one of these “innocent” animals served as the intermediate host, the evidence provided so far to support these claims is not convincing.
Members of the Innocent Wildlife collection include, Pete the Pangolin, Sid the Sloth, Alastair the Raccoon Dog, Adeline the Raccoon Dog, Cindy the Civet, and Axel the Raccoon Dog.
The organization that worries non-natural potential pandemic pathogens might obliterate humanity feels very differently about natural potential pandemic pathogens. One is the gravest threat imaginable, while the other is a opportunity to make jokes and push products.
I don’t know anyone who sells cutesy merch mocking the lab leak theory. I shudder to think of furious reaction that a Sarah the Scientist DIDN’T CAUSE THE PANDEMIC T-shirt would generate from Biosafety Now.
Bhattacharya, Gupta, and Kulldorff are not merely wrong. They are charlatans and quacks who are dispensing deadly advice, and who need to be held accountable for their role in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
As Dr. Allison Neitzel wrote here at SBM, Biosafety Now, which believes non-natural potential pandemic pathogens poses existential risks to humanity, recently partnered with none other than Dr. Bhattacharya, an anti-vaccine, pro-virus doctor who teamed up with crank RFK Jr. and spread a deluge of misinformation about an actual pandemic pathogen while other doctors were busy treating patients with it. Professor Nickels has been vigorously promoting and defending Dr. Bhattacharya on social media, launching juvenile, content-free taunts and accusations against myself and Dr. David Gorksi. We sinned by discussing the many flaws in Dr. Bhattacharya’s “plan” for herd immunity via natural immunity.
Professor Ebright had strong feelings when Dr. Bhattacharya’s announced his plan to get rid of the virus by spreading the virus in October 2020. Professor Ebright said at the time:
Bhattacharya, Gupta, and Kulldorff are not merely wrong. They are charlatans and quacks who are dispensing deadly advice, and who need to be held accountable for their role in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
I’ve never produced such pugnacious prose. Professor Ebright also laid out his preferred approach at the time, and it could not have been more diametrically opposed to Dr. Bhattacharya’s plan. Professor Ebright said:
Testing, tracing, quarantine of contacts, isolation of cases, partial lockdown and distancing at all times, full lockdown when tranmission is high, masks, and, decisively, when available, vaccines.
However, Professor Ebright explained his willingness to abandon his principles and partner with a “charlatan and quack” by telling me:
My views on the @gbdeclaration have not changed, but my views on Bhattacharya have changed.
Professor Ebright believes that Dr. Bhattacharya is utterly separate from the pro-virus Declaration he authored and continues to vigorously defend. Professor Ebright feels that I am unable to read and reason because I insist on linking Dr. Bhattacharya with the words and ideas of Dr. Bhattacharya.
Speaking as if COVID were a distant historical event, Professor Ebright continued:
His advice was wrong. Dead wrong. But it now is 2024 (not 2020), and the discussion at hand is how to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic (not how to respond to the last one). I will work with any person from any party and any background to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic. The importance and urgency of the objective over-ride partisan differences and ideological differences (as should be clear to any rational person).
Despite the promise to work with any person from any party and any background, no one from Biosafety Now ever reached out to me. I did my part to limit COVID’s harms, both in and out of the hospital, and Professors Nickels and Ebright treated me with scorn and contempt. Perhaps if I had made YouTube videos and tried to spread a virus during an actual pandemic, I too could have been placed on the Board of Directors of Biosafety Now, which to remind you, believes non-natural potential pandemic pathogens poses existential risks to humanity.
The Central Problem Right Now I Think Is The Fear That People Still Feel About COVID.
Of course, Dr. Bhattacharya’s critics don’t have “partisan differences and ideological differences” with him (as should be clear to any rational person). Rather, we object to his pandemic-long campaign to numb Americans to the threat of COVID. We felt COVID was the “central problem” while Dr. Bhattacharya felt the central problem was “the fear that people still feel about COVID.” We thought “natural immunity” was dangerous and something to be avoided, while Dr. Bhattacharya thought it should be venerated and widely embraced, claiming it would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months. We don’t feel rare, usually mild vaccine side-effects are a fate worse than death, and we don’t feel COVID was mild for people under 70.
We believe Dr. Bhattacharya’s repeated factual errors and farcical forecasts led to unnecessary suffering. Future historians will be able to perfectly track the course of the pandemic by reading Dr. Bhattacharya’s preposterous predictions and knowing the exact opposite happened. To pick one example amongst many, Dr. Bhattacharya assured Floridians “We have protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population” immediately before the Delta wave ripped through the state leaving carnage in its wake.
Mostly, Dr. Bhattacharya’s critics feel his plan of herd immunity through mass infection of unvaccinated “not vulnerable” people was both a moral abomination and a total failure, as Professor Ebright wisely recognized it would be in his unflinching statement from 2020.
Imagine waving this all away as “partisan differences and ideological differences”.
“Partisan differences and ideological differences”
Strongly disagreeing with someone’s policy positions doesn’t make them a mass murderer- unless, of course, they also played a role in reckless research that triggered the COVID-19 pandemic.
But let’s be clear what’s happening now in 2024. According to to Professors Nickels and Ebright, those who allegedly released the virus are fraudsters, liars, perjurers, felons, grifters, stooges, imbeciles, and murderers, comparable to Nazi war criminals and the genocidal Cambodian dictator Pol Pot.
In contrast, doctors who repeatedly minimized the virus in order to spread the virus to 250 million unvaccinated Americans aren’t so bad after all. Sure, they were wrong, but their errors were pardonable, they were just “partisan differences and ideological differences”. Even though these doctors still glorify “natural immunity” in the middle of yet another COVID surge, their sins are ancient and worth overlooking. A future pandemic pathogen might kill us all, yet doctors who spread a deluge of misinformation about an actual pandemic pathogen are worth defending and promoting. They were charlatans and quacks who dispensed deadly advice. They needed to be held accountable for their role in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths. However, that was in 2020, forever ago. Today, they need a safe space to shield their feelings from these exact words.
Releasing SARS-CoV-2 was “mass murder”. Purposefully spreading it to millions of unvaccinated people was just a “policy position”.
As with doctors who treat theoretical harms from the vaccine with more seriousness than actual harms from COVID, Professors Nickels and Ebright make a grand public display of being very concerned(!) about a hypothetical non-natural pandemic pathogen, while simultaneously encouraging placidity about a hypothetical natural pandemic pathogen and apathy about a current pandemic pathogen. Indeed it’s not 2020 anymore, but according to BNO News, COVID killed 1,000 American for the 3rd week in a row, though Professors Nickels’ and Ebright’s partnership with Dr. Bhattacharya reveals these actual deaths don’t concern them. They’ve moved on and are only bothered by anyone who still cares about COVID’s current impact.
Of course, if a new pandemic pathogen were to arrive, Dr. Bhattacharya would undoubtedly undermine efforts to contain it no matter where it came from. And having poisoned the public against mitigation measures by portraying them as one of the worst catastrophes to befall mankind, Dr. Bhattacharya will face much less resistance opposing them than he did with COVID. Dr. Bhattacharya also benefits from his partnership with Biosafety Now. It allows him to absurdly portray himself as someone who is also very concerned(!) about protecting humanity from dangerous viruses.
In reality, thanks to his ceaseless efforts, we are significantly less prepared to handle a pandemic than we were in 2020. If a devastating pandemic pathogen were to escape from a lab, which is a real and immediate danger according to Biosafety Now, public health officials would need drastic measures and buy-in from the public to contain it. Yet, anyone who seeks to enact the mitigation measures Dr. Ebright championed in 2020, will have a much harder time doing so thanks to Dr. Bhattacharya and his ilk.
Perhaps if this new pandemic pathogen arrives and Dr. Bhattacharya again suggests infecting unvaccinated people with it, Dr. Ebright would revert to calling him:
Not merely wrong, but a charlatan and quack who is dispensing deadly advice, and who needs to be held accountable for his role in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
But today, Professors Nickels and Ebright don’t care about this at all. An organization that believes “non-natural potential pandemic pathogens pose existential risks to humanity” is eager to elevate and legitimize a man who tried to spread an actual potential pandemic pathogen and would happily do so again. They are not at all upset that anyone minimized an actual pandemic pathogen. They save their scorn and childish mockery for anyone who remembers the tragic, real-world consequences of doctors’ pro-virus advocacy. Since memory was sinful, amnesia was portrayed as a virtue:
But it now is 2024 (not 2020), and the discussion at hand is how to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic (not how to respond to the last one).
Obviously, there’s no reason why anyone should care about the origins of a virus if they’re indifferent to the consequences of that virus and those who helped it along the way.
I suppose it’s my turn to be called a fraudster, liar, perjurer, felon, grifter, stooge, imbecile, and maybe even murderer. This essay will generate a temper tantrum for sure. What I won’t get is a reasonable explanation as to why supposedly releasing a deadly virus was mass murder, but intentionally spreading it was a forgivable “policy position”. This is because these juvenile professors, totally sheltered from the consequences of their words, are entirely unserious about limiting dangerous viral infections. Rather they’re narcissistic, histrionic performers who treated the pandemic as a spectacle and picked fights to draw attention to themselves and showcase their malignant contrarianism.
And I know that’s harsh. But at least I’ve never compared anyone to Nazi war criminals and the genocidal Cambodian dictator Pol Pot.
Being captured by hateful conspiracy myths radicalizes.
Many activists in the #lableak community have lost any grip on reality, not realizing that their behavior is so far off any normal conduct that average citizens are shocked when they observe just a fraction of it. pic.twitter.com/P5pdUBr6Aq
— Philipp Markolin, PhD (@PhilippMarkolin) March 15, 2024

Medical conspiracy theories and COVID-19
The COVID-19 pandemic has spawned almost innumerable conspiracy theories, and conspiracists like the antivaccine movement have joined forces with COVID-19 conspiracy theorists. To combat the proliferation of pseudoscience rooted in conspiracy theories, it is useful to step back and examine the nature of conspiracy theories, including ones that are not medical, even ones like QAnon. Critical thinking is the key to inoculating the susceptible against conspiratorial thinking.
David Gorski on May 18, 2020
Link
Conspiracy theories having to do with medicine are quite common, and we’ve written about them here before, particularly among the antivaccine movement. I even coined a term, the “central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement” and argued that the entire antivaccine belief system, as disparate as the individual beliefs and subsidiary conspiracy theories that make it up can be, can basically be boiled down to the contention that vaccines are dangerous but “they” are hiding it from you. Who are “they”? They’re the CDC, medical profession, big pharma, and the rest of government who, in the central conspiracy theory, “know” that vaccines cause autism and all manner of harm but are covering up the evidence. That’s why the antivaccine propaganda and conspiracy movie disguised as a documentary VAXXED resonated so much, telling, as it did, the story of the “CDC whistleblower“, who supposedly revealed that the CDC “knew” that the MMR vaccine greatly increased the risk of autism in African-American boys but “covered it up” in the study in which that result was supposedly found. That this “evidence” came in the form of an incompetent reanalysis of a CDC-published paper by a biochemical engineer turned clueless epidemiologist named Brian Hooker mattered not at all. In this, the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory very much resembled the Simpsonwood conspiracy theory from the early 2000s, in which Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. pushed a claim that the CDC “knew” that thimerosal in vaccines was causing autism but covered it up at a conference at the Simpsonwood conference center near Atlanta in 2000.
I started thinking about conspiracy theories in medicine again because the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in a massive proliferation of conspiracy theories about coronavirus, its origin, its spread, potential treatments, a possible vaccine, and more spreading at a magnitude that I’ve never seen conspiracy theories reach before. I just spent my last two posts discussing the conspiracy theories of Judy Mikovits, a disgraced virologist who is claiming that she was unjustly targeted for her work claiming that a retrovirus was associated with chronic fatigue syndrome and might be the cause, when in fact her results were spurious and likely fraudulent. She even managed to bring Anthony Fauci into her conspiracy theories not just once, but twice. Her Plandemic video went viral in a huge way, to the point where people whom I had thought reasonable were sharing it on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and other social media. Then there are the conspiracy theories that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, originated in a virology laboratory in Wuhan, China, and don’t even get me started on the conspiracy theories about Bill Gates, 5G, and the pandemic, hydroxychloroquine as a treatment for COVID-19, or the flu vaccine as a predisposing factor for the disease. Then I saw a project at The Atlantic that is almost enough for me to consider subscribing again after a lapse of over a decade after The Atlantic‘s miserable reporting on the H1N1 pandemic. It’s called Shadowland, and it gave me an excuse to discuss conspiracy theories as a topic in general and then relate them to medicine. Just as antivaccine pseudoscience is rooted in conspiracy theories, I contend that medical pseudoscience in general can be understood much better if you realize that, like antivaccine beliefs, damned near all quackery is also rooted in conspiracy theory.
It’s also important to recognize that there are, in fact, real conspiracies. They exist. For example, Big Tobacco did conspire to deceive the public about the adverse health effects of smoking. That is indisputable. The 9/11 terrorists did conspire to destroy the World Trade Center and Pentagon. Volkswagen did conspire to cheat emissions tests. The big differences tend to be that real conspiracies have evidence demonstrating them and tend to be a lot more limited, while conspiracy theories persist and, seemingly, mutate despite there being no clear evidence to support them. More on that later.
Q and antivaccine conspiracy theories
At this point, after over three years of its existence, nearly everyone has heard of QAnon, but I bet a lot of people don’t really know what the Q conspiracy theory is. Oddly enough, I was blissfully unaware until Shadowland introduces its subject matter thusly:
America owes its existence, at least in part, to conspiracy thinking. In the colonies, a theory was born that King George III was plotting the enslavement of all Americans. Even without evidence, this theory helped tip the scales toward revolution.
Yet conspiracism here and around the world has destroyed great institutions, eradicated knowledge, endangered democracy, and ended lives. Now—fueled by the internet, partisan media, and the 45th president of the United States—paranoid thinking is more powerful, and more dangerous, than ever, threatening not just individual facts, but the idea that empirical truth exists at all.
The rise of mainstream conspiracism is the result not just of bad information or bad politics or bad thinking, but of systems built to stoke paranoia and to profit from mistrust. This project is an attempt to illuminate the forces that have created this unreality—and chart a course for how we might feel our way out.
It’s important to realize this last fact here. To those not familiar with antivaccine conspiracy theories, it might seem odd that antivaccine activists have so easily made common cause with COVID-19 conspiracy theorists on the surface, until you realize that antivaxxers have always made common cause with epidemic and pandemic conspiracy theorists. They did it in 2009 with the H1N1 pandemic. They did it during the Ebola outbreaks in 2014. They did it when Zika virus was spreading and leading to microcephaly in the babies of pregnant women infected with the virus. One conspiracy theory that antivaxxers always embrace whenever there are outbreaks of a new disease with the threat of a pandemic is the claim that the disease will be used as a pretext to impose “forced vaccination” on everyone (for example, as stated here nearly two months ago by antivaccine activist Lyn Redwood on RFK Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense website).
To illustrate what I mean about conspiracy theories, I consider it important to look at a conspiracy theory that isn’t related to medicine, and Adrienne LaFrance’s article on the QAnon conspiracy theory, “The Prophecies of Q“, is as good a place to start as any, if only for my education as well. I’ve been paying attention to these matters long enough to have watched the birth of multiple conspiracy theories in real time, including “9/11 Truthers,” the Simpsonwood conspiracy theory, H1N1 conspiracy theories, and the “CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory.” Oddly enough, though, I didn’t pay much attention to the Q conspiracy theory as it arose in 2016 and 2017. The introduction, however, should sound familiar:
If you were an adherent, no one would be able to tell. You would look like any other American. You could be a mother, picking leftovers off your toddler’s plate. You could be the young man in headphones across the street. You could be a bookkeeper, a dentist, a grandmother icing cupcakes in her kitchen. You may well have an affiliation with an evangelical church. But you are hard to identify just from the way you look—which is good, because someday soon dark forces may try to track you down. You understand this sounds crazy, but you don’t care. You know that a small group of manipulators, operating in the shadows, pull the planet’s strings. You know that they are powerful enough to abuse children without fear of retribution. You know that the mainstream media are their handmaidens, in partnership with Hillary Clinton and the secretive denizens of the deep state. You know that only Donald Trump stands between you and a damned and ravaged world. You see plague and pestilence sweeping the planet, and understand that they are part of the plan. You know that a clash between good and evil cannot be avoided, and you yearn for the Great Awakening that is coming. And so you must be on guard at all times. You must shield your ears from the scorn of the ignorant. You must find those who are like you. And you must be prepared to fight.
You know all this because you believe in Q.
Don’t see it? Let me make a few minor changes:
If you were an adherent, no one would be able to tell. You would look like any other American. You could be a mother, picking leftovers off your toddler’s plate. You could be the young man in headphones across the street. You could be a bookkeeper, a dentist, a grandmother icing cupcakes in her kitchen. You may well have an affiliation with an evangelical church. But you are hard to identify just from the way you look—which is good, because someday soon dark forces may try to track you down. You understand this sounds crazy, but you don’t care. You know that a small group of manipulators, operating in the shadows, pull the planet’s strings. You know that they are powerful enough to abuse children by forcing them to take toxic vaccines without fear of retribution. You know that the mainstream media are their handmaidens, in partnership with the government, big pharma, and the medical-industrial complex. You know that only Andrew Wakefield, Del Bigtree, RFK Jr., Stanislaw Burzynski, Joe Mercola, and a band of resisters stand between you and a damned and ravaged world in which most of our children are autistic because of vaccines and adults are dependent on big pharma. You see plague and pestilence of vaccine-, GMO-, 5G-, and pharma-caused chronic diseases sweeping the planet, and understand that they are part of the plan. You know that a clash between good and evil cannot be avoided, and you yearn for the Great Awakening that is coming. And so you must be on guard at all times. You must shield your ears from the scorn of the ignorant. You must find those who are like you. And you must be prepared to fight.
If you think I exaggerate, please feel free to read the apocalyptic imagery of a segment of the hardcore antivaccine movement that openly fantasizes about leaders of the conspiracy surrendering and being forced to publicly confess their “crimes.” When you understand this aspect of these conspiracy theories, the comparison frequently made between those promoting science-based medicine, including vaccines, and Nazis becomes a bit easier to understand. Obviously, the ones whose belief in the conspiracy theories behind medical pseudoscience are a small minority, but it’s a small minority that feeds the conspiracy machine, so that the conspiracy theory can infect, in a weaker form, those who are merely vaccine-hesitant or have legitimate reasons to distrust the medical profession, such as African-Americans and other marginalized people.
QAnon first burst into the national consciousness as a result of “Pizzagate,” the conspiracy theory that Hillary Clinton and other “deep state” operatives were running a child sex ring out of a Washington pizzeria called Comet Ping Pong. The conspiracy theory led a man named Edgar Maddison Welch to walk into the pizzeria with three loaded guns on December 4, 2016 to rescue the children who were the victims of this alleged sex ring, firing several rounds into a locked door to open it, there (or so he thought) to find the children being held prisoner. When he didn’t find them, he put his guns down and surrendered, but you can see how the incident could have gone very differently. Now look at what happened next:
While Welch may have expressed regret, he gave no indication that he had stopped believing the underlying Pizzagate message: that a cabal of powerful elites was abusing children and getting away with it. Judging from a surge of activity on the internet, many others had found ways to move beyond the Comet Ping Pong episode and remain focused on what they saw as the larger truth. If you paid attention to the right voices on the right websites, you could see in real time how the core premises of Pizzagate were being recycled, revised, and reinterpreted. The millions of people paying attention to sites like 4chan and Reddit could continue to learn about that secretive and untouchable cabal; about its malign actions and intentions; about its ties to the left wing and specifically to Democrats and especially to Clinton; about its bloodlust and its moral degeneracy. You could also—and this would prove essential—read about a small but swelling band of underground American patriots fighting back.
All of this, taken together, defined a worldview that would soon have a name: QAnon, derived from a mysterious figure, “Q,” posting anonymously on 4chan. QAnon does not possess a physical location, but it has an infrastructure, a literature, a growing body of adherents, and a great deal of merchandising. It also displays other key qualities that Pizzagate lacked. In the face of inconvenient facts, it has the ambiguity and adaptability to sustain a movement of this kind over time. For QAnon, every contradiction can be explained away; no form of argument can prevail against it.
And that’s a key aspect to conspiracy theories, medical or otherwise. The ones that survive and thrive are the ones that are the most adaptable, the ones that are hardest to falsify. They’re the ones that tolerate internal contradictions. QAnon has become incredibly complex, to the point where, no matter how many predictions or claims by Q (whoever Q is) are falsified, the overall conspiracy theory can’t be falsified. In this, antivaccine conspiracy theories are far less complex than Q, although extreme versions of them are almost as apocalyptic, which might limit their appeal compared to more general-purpose conspiracy theories like Q. However, given the paranoid elements, the extreme distrust of the “elites,” and the extreme belief that “something” is very wrong, it should perhaps not be surprising that, not only are antivaxxers making common cause with COVID-19 science deniers, but they are increasingly merging with QAnon conspiracy theorists. For example, Plandemic went viral largely as the result of the efforts of Zach Vorhies, an ex-Google employee and QAnon believer.
Grift forever
Another characteristic of a good conspiracy theory is that there are always grifters, who might or might not be true believers, to monetize the conspiracy theory. In the case of antivaccine movement, their names are too numerous for me to list here, but foremost among antivaccine grifters are people like Andrew Wakefield, Joe Mercola, Del Bigtree, and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Just because these people are grifters, though, doesn’t mean that they aren’t also true believers to one degree or another. Certainly, for instance, Del Bigtree is very much a true believer, his speeches to antivaccine groups sounding very much like the sermon of a fundamentalist preacher in cadence, appeal to emotion, and style.
In the case of Q, there are also many such grifters. One featured in LaFrance’s article is David Hayes (online handle: PrayingMedic), who dons the mantle of a skeptic while cleaning up. with 300,000 YouTube followers letting him make a career of promoting Q:
Hayes has developed a following in part because of his sheer ubiquity but also because he skillfully wears the mantle of a skeptic—I’m not one of those crazies. Hayes is not a QAnon hobbyist, though. He’s a professional. There are income streams to be tapped, modest but expanding. On Amazon, Hayes’s book Calm Before the Storm, the first in what he says could easily be a 10-book series of “Q Chronicles,” sells for $15.29. Hayes writes in the introduction that he and Denise have devoted their attention full-time to QAnon since 2017. “Denise and I have been blessed by those who have helped support us while we set aside our usual work to research Q’s messages,” he wrote. He has published several other books, which offer a glimpse into an earlier life. The titles include Hearing God’s Voice Made Simple, Defeating Your Adversary in the Court of Heaven, and American Sniper: Lessons in Spiritual Warfare. Hayes registered Praying Medic as a religious nonprofit in Washington State in 2018.
Hayes tells his followers that he thinks Q is an open-source intelligence operation, made possible by the internet and designed by patriots fighting corruption inside the intelligence community. His interpretation of Q is ultimately religious in nature, and centers on the idea of a Great Awakening.
Of course, the antivaccine equivalent to the Great Awakening is the realization among the public that antivaxxers were “right,” that vaccines cause autism, sudden infant death syndrome, autoimmune diseases, and all the various ills that antivaxxers blame on vaccines, and that there was indeed a conspiracy to suppress the evidence implicating vaccines in all these ills. It’s a powerful cult-like belief system that is basically an invitation to opportunists looking to make a buck.
Conspiratorial thinking and elements of a conspiracy theory
I’ve alluded to the elements of a good conspiracy theory before in discussing why COVID-19 conspiracy theories are so attractive. First and foremost, conspiracy theories are about secret or hidden knowledge, knowledge that only the believers in the conspiracy theory possess, knowledge to which the average person not accepting the conspiracy theory is not privy. Holding such knowledge makes the believer feel special, superior, greater than all the “sheeple” out there who do not hold the conspiracy theory. Whether the conspiracy theory is Q, antivaccine pseudoscience, belief that there is a cure for cancer but “they” are keeping it from the people, the believer is special.
The believer is also simultaneously a victim of persecution and a hero. One element common to the most attractive conspiracy theories is that something is very, very wrong with the world and that it is not an accident that this something is so wrong. Rather, it’s wrong intentionally, usually as the result of a dark conspiracy of powerful forces that is doing causing the wrong and hiding its involvement. Naturally, the believer perceives himself to be a victim of this “wrongness,” and his waking up to his victimhood and deciding to fight against it lets him claim the mantle of hero. These elements of the conspiracy theory also make the believer feel special and heroic, because not only is he privy to secret knowledge, but he is now a warrior fighting against these dark forces to reverse his victimization by trying to make the knowledge more public and persuading others of its correctness. Conspiracy theories are thus attractive because they are an antidote to a feeling of powerlessness, explain unlikely events (such as 9/11) and even some not-so-unlikely events (e.g., the coronavirus pandemic, some variant of which has been predicted for nearly two decades since the SARS epidemic in 2002), and coping with threats.
It’s thus no wonder that many, if not most, conspiracy theories are ultimately hopeful. They almost always come to the present with “the people” finally “waking up” to the danger and, with the help of the conspiracy theorists spreading the “true” information about the conspiracy, “rising up” to throw off the shackles of their oppressors. We see this in antivaccine conspiracy theories, in which “They” (the CDC, Big Pharma, the medical profession) are finally taken to account for the “misdeeds” of which they’re accused. We see it in Q, bigtime, with Q’s “prophecies” leading patriots to rise up against the deep state or whatever else is the threat at the time. We see it in cancer conspiracy theories in which the “people” are waking up to, for example, “natural cures” for cancer (which are, of course, suppressed by the “cancer industry”) that don’t involve the toxicity of conventional therapies, such as chemotherapy, surgery, and radiation.
Stephan Lewandowsky and John Cook have published an excellent short e-book on recognizing conspiracy theories and countering conspiratorial thinking, The Conspiracy Theory Handbook. They identify seven characteristics of conspiratorial thinking, after first pointing out the key differences between conventional and conspiratorial thinking:
They note:
Actual conspiracies do exist but they are rarely discovered through the methods of conspiracy theorists. Rather, real conspiracies get discovered through conventional thinking—healthy skepticism of official accounts while carefully considering available evidence and being committed to internal consistency. In contrast, conspiratorial thinking is characterized by being hyperskeptical of all information that does not fit the theory, over-interpreting evidence that supports a preferred theory, and inconsistency.
This is the key difference, and these are the characteristics of conspiratorial thinking, under the mnemonic CONSPIR:
    • Contradictory: Conspiracy theorists can simultaneously believe in ideas that are mutually contradictory. For example, believing the theory that Princess Diana was murdered but also believing that she faked her own death. This is because the theorists’ commitment to disbelieving the “official” account is so absolute, it doesn’t matter if their belief system is incoherent.
    • Overriding suspicion: Conspiratorial thinking involves a nihilistic degree of skepticism towards the official account. This extreme degree of suspicion prevents belief in anything that doesn’t fit into the conspiracy theory.
    • Nefarious intent: The motivations behind any presumed conspiracy are invariably assumed to be nefarious. Conspiracy theories never propose that the presumed conspirators have benign motivations.
    • Something must be wrong: Although conspiracy theorists may occasionally abandon specific ideas when they become untenable, those revisions don’t change their overall conclusion that “something must be wrong” and the official account is based on deception.
    • Persecuted victim: Conspiracy theorists perceive and present themselves as the victim of organized persecution. At the same time, they see themselves as brave antagonists taking on the villainous conspirators. Conspiratorial thinking involves a self-perception of simultaneously being a victim and a hero.
    • Immune to evidence: Conspiracy theories are inherently self-sealing—evidence that counters a theory is re-interpreted as originating from the conspiracy. This reflects the belief that the stronger the evidence against a conspiracy (e.g., the FBI exonerating a politician from allegations of misusing a personal email server), the more the conspirators must want people to believe their version of events (e.g., the FBI was part of the conspiracy to protect that politician).
    • Re-interpreting randomness: The overriding suspicion found in conspiratorial thinking frequently results in the belief that nothing occurs by accident. Small random events, such as intact windows in the Pentagon after the 9/11 attacks, are re-interpreted as being caused by the conspiracy (because if an airliner had hit the Pentagon, then all windows would have shattered) and are woven into a broader, interconnected pattern.
Regular readers will recognize most, if not all, of these elements in antivaccine conspiracy theories, as well as various conspiracy theories spread in the service of promoting quackery, such as the conspiracy theory spread by Erin Elizabeth (Joe Mercola’s partner) that nefarious forces are out there killing “natural health” providers, starting with Jeff Bradstreet.
How to respond to conspiracy theories
Lewandowsky and Cook conclude with a number of strategies to respond to conspiratorial thinking. Regular readers are likely familiar with debunking, which can be fact-based, logic-based, source-based, or based on fact checking. Obviously, we here at SBM do a combination of some or all of these, although I like to note that my writing is not aimed at the hard-core conspiracy theorists themselves. The likelihood of changing their minds significantly is low to non-existent. If you’re lucky you might plant a seed or two that might germinate later, but only at the cost of a lot of effort. Rather, it is likely better to inoculate those susceptible to conspiracy theories with the knowledge about the nature of conspiracy theories and other information that will make them less susceptible to a conspiracy theory. It is in this vein that I really like Lewandowsky and Cook’s concept of “pre-bunking” in addition to debunking:
If people are preemptively made aware that they might be misled, they can develop resilience to conspiratorial messages. This process is known as inoculation or prebunking. There are two elements to an inoculation: an explicit warning of an impending threat of being misled, and refutation of the misinformation’s arguments. Prebunkings of anti-vaccination conspiracy theories have been found to be more effective than debunking.
Fact-based and logic-based inoculations have both been successful in prebunking a 9/11 conspiracy. This indicates some promise in logic- based prebunking, given the seven tell-tale traits of conspiratorial thinking (remember CONSPIR?). If people are made aware of the flawed reasoning found in conspiracy theories, they may become less vulnerable to such theories.
Most importantly, people need to be empowered against misinformation and disinformation:
Conspiracy thinking is associated with feelings of reduced control and perceived threat. When people feel like they have lost control of a situation, their conspiracist tendencies increase. But the opposite also applies. When people feel empowered, they are more resilient to conspiracy theories.
There are several ways to “cognitively empower” people, such as encouraging them to think analytically rather than relying on intuition. If people’s sense of control is primed (e.g., by recalling an event from their lives that they had control over), then they are less likely to endorse conspiracy theories. Citizens’ general feeling of empowerment can be instilled by ensuring that societal decisions, for example by government, are perceived to follow procedural justice principles. Procedural justice is perceived when authorities are believed to use fair decision-making procedures. People accept unfavourable outcomes from a decision if they believe that procedural fairness has been followed.
Finally, it’s also very important to recognize that many conspiracy theories are tactical. In other words, the origin of some conspiracy theories is not genuinely held erroneous beliefs, but rather they are the result of an intentional campaign of disinformation designed to produce a political end. Climate science denial is likely the most important example of a tactical conspiracy theory designed to promote a political viewpoint by casting doubt on a strong scientific consensus. As Lewandowsky and Cook emphasize, while logical incoherence is one attribute of conspiratorial thinking, that doesn’t mean that all conspiracy theories are irrational. Denialist rhetoric is very effective at casting doubt on specific science that conflicts with one’s ideology, which is one reason why it can be so difficult to combat these conspiracy theories.
Getting back to Shadowland, I recommend reading the entire series. It’s a long read, with several of the articles weighing in at several thousand words (longer, even, than one of my SBM posts). As I read these articles, I kept thinking: Dealing with this sort of misinformation is exactly what skeptics have been doing for a long time, and yet, in medicine at least, such efforts are often dismissed as beneath physicians, as if countering the claims of alternative medicine, for example, are too easy to be worthwhile, as if nonsense like homeopathy were self-evidently bunk. It turns out that countering conspiracy theories is among the most difficult science communication tasks there is. (Just look at the article on 5G conspiracy theories for an example.)
In the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s become so much more important than it might have seemed in the past, as well. Particularly depressing to me was the first article in the Shadowland series, an article by Jeffrey Goldberg entitled “The Conspiracy Theorists Are Winning“, mainly because it’s hard for me to argue with this conclusion given the proliferation of misinformation weaponized by political actors and amplified by social media. Goldberg paints conspiratorial thinking as an existential threat, and, in the age of COVID-19, it’s a threat to us all in a way that we never recognized before. Even if such conspiracy theories are not an existential threat, at the very least they demoralize frontline health care workers, confuse the public, and lead to behaviors detrimental to public health.

Latest Science on Origins of SARS-CoV-2
Steven Novella on March 4, 2026
Link

Six years after the COVID-19 pandemic, which had claimed over 7 million lives worldwide by April 2024 (figures are no longer being tracked), we are still debating the origins of this novel virus. The intelligence community is divided between the zoonotic hypothesis (the virus evolved in animal reservoirs and then crossed over to humans) and the lab leak hypothesis. Essentially the consensus is – they cannot reach a confident conclusion without further evidence.
The scientific community, on the other hand, has consistently favored the zoonotic spillover event hypothesis. The latest group to weigh in on this question are 23 of the 27 original members of the Advisory Group for the Origins of Novel Pathogens (SAGO) for the World Health Organization (WHO). They were tasked with reviewing all available scientific evidence to determine the origins of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.
Interestingly there is one point on which they agree with the Intelligence community – there is insufficient evidence to reach a rock-solid conclusion, partly because China is not being fully cooperative. But they are highly confident that a spillover event from a zoonotic origin is the most likely scenario.
They emphasize that the purpose of their review is not to place blame or point fingers, but to understand the origins of this pandemic with the aim of helping prevent future pandemics. This is a familiar medical attitude, in which we frequently evaluate negative outcomes in order to reduce the risk of similar negative outcomes in the future, in an environment free from blame or recrimination. This difference in culture likely partly explains the different conclusions between the medical and the intelligence communities.
The SAGO group addressed four possible hypotheses: 1 – zoonotic spillover local to Wuhan, China, 2 – zoonotic spillover imported from elsewhere, 3 – accidental lab leak of an experimental virus, 4 – deliberate release of a bioengineered virus.
The easiest of these four hypotheses to dispense with is number 4 – that SARS-CoV-2 is an engineered virus. This notion was, in fact, quickly disproved within weeks of the start of the pandemic. This hypothesis can be evaluated by looking at the virus itself, it’s genetics and structure. Therefore there is the most direct evidence to bring to bear. The SAGO group concludes”
“We did not find evidence to suggest that SARS-CoV-2 resulting from experimental manipulation was a more likely scenario than it emerging from naturally occurring mutations or recombination events.”
This is stated with typical scientific precision and caution, but it basically means there is no evidence the virus was deliberately genetically manipulated. There are no fingerprints of genetic engineering on the virus.
This is, in fact, the reason the lab leak hypothesis was even proposed. For those who favor the notion that China had something to do with the release of the virus, the fact that the virus was clearly not engineered inconveniently put an end to such speculation. It did not take long, however, for this idea to resurface as a “lab leak” hypothesis – the virus was not engineered but was still being studied in the Wuhan lab and accidentally leaked to the public through careless workers, lax protocols, or some breach in protocols.
There are two types of evidence, broadly speaking, we can bring to bear on this question. The first is epidemiological – looking at the earliest cases of COVID including the strains of virus with which they were infected, and data on the virus (such as in waste water) in the local environment. This evidence is looked at through the lens of – which is more likely, a local zoonotic spillover or a lab leak. The SAGO authors conclude that the evidence strongly supports the zoonotic spillover hypothesis. In fact, three of the four original SAGO members who did not sign this report were protesting the inclusion of the lab leak hypothesis at all, which they claim lacks any evidence. I disagree with that approach – this is a popular claim that should be addressed directly by such a scientific report.
But there is another kind of evidence that can address the spillover hypothesis, and the authors conclude that they frustratingly lack this evidence:
“Repeated requests have been made to the Chinese government by the WHO to release the health records of research-lab staff, biosafety and biosecurity protocols, and audits or independent inspections conducted to verify the safety procedures of labs in Wuhan. These include those of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention in Wuhan and the Wuhan Institute of Virology, a leading research centre for bat coronaviruses. In our view, the government has not provided the necessary information that we have requested since the launch of SAGO in November 2021 to investigate a potential biosafety breach. The National Health Commission of China states that the country has shared all relevant data and information, and proposes that investigations be undertaken instead in labs in other countries where coronavirus research has been conducted.”
For this reason the lab leak hypothesis cannot be fully put to bed. It seems that China is fanning the flames of the very idea they are hoping to tamp down. This is also why some in the intelligence community continue to favor this hypothesis – what is China hiding? But only low confidence can be placed on such speculation. It is still true that the epidemiology favors a spillover event and there is no evidence for a lab leak. There should be more international pressure on China to release all the information requested by the WHO to definitely answer this question.
The SAGO authors are therefore left with hypotheses 1 and 2 – this was a zoonotic spillover event, either local to Wuhan or imported from elsewhere. Clearly the first outbreak occurred in and around the Huanan seafood market. The authors point out that 60% of these early cases, occurring in late 2019, had a direct connection to that market. But the virus could have been imported to that market.
The SAGO authors, however, are pretty dismissive of this idea:
“SARS-CoV-2 was detected on frozen goods, but only several months into the pandemic when the virus was already widespread in humans. By this point, infected people could have contaminated surfaces. Also, no further evidence has become available to suggest that the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 to humans from frozen products occurred at Huanan Seafood Market, at any other market in Wuhan or elsewhere at the start of the pandemic.”
Therefore, they conclude, a local zoonotic spillover event remains the most likely origin for SARS-CoV-2. They do not know the specific species, and proving a specific vector would be one way to confirm this hypothesis. However, there are many candidate species. Several species of bat are reservoirs for coronaviruses very similar to SARS-CoV-2. There are also many candidate intermediate hosts:
“Metagenomic sequencing of environmental samples collected at the market has indicated that several wildlife species had been there before it was cleaned and sterilized on 1 January 2020 by the Chinese authorities in response to the outbreak. These include raccoon dogs (Nyctereutes procyonoides), hoary bamboo rats (Rhizomys pruinosus) and palm civets (Paguma larvata), all of which are known to be susceptible to the early strains of SARS-CoV-2. “
It is possible we many never know for sure the exact path that this virus took to get into the human population. Such is the nature of science – we make the best inference possible with the data we have, but we rarely know anything for certain. Right now the best inference is that SARS-CoV-2 was a spillover event coming from the Huanan market.
Going forward, the WHO needs to continue to put pressure on China to release the data they are looking for. This should also become standard procedure, with international agreements for standard safety protocols and transparency.
It is likely that such pandemics will accelerate in the future, due to increased globalization and increasing encroachment of human spaces on wild spaces. This is a shared worldwide problem, and requires shared worldwide responsibility to address it.

Zoonotic Spillover Is A Problem
Steven Novella on March 25, 2026
Link

Recently I gave the latest update on the origins of SARS-CoV-2 – bottom line, it was very likely a zoonotic spillover event and not a lab leak. Following that, I interviewed a researcher, Dr. Andersen, who is an expert on the origins of epidemics/pandemics and has researched this very question. He reinforced the spillover hypothesis, indicated he had considered the lab leak hypothesis early on but it was quickly shown to be highly unlikely.
More important than that, however, was the discussion about why a zoonotic spillover was so likely, and why, if anything, we are more vulnerable to another such event today. Far from learning from the COVID pandemic how to reduce the chance and prepare for the next inevitable such event, COVID has caused “pandemic fatigue” and left us worse prepared than we were. Further, it’s unlikely to be a century until the next such pandemic.
A zoonotic spillover event refers to an infectious agent, usually a virus, that is endemic in an animal population that crosses over into the human population. Viruses evolve and adapt, and therefore a species that is not adapted to humans with a very limited (but non-zero) ability to infect a human can evolve in a human host to become more infectious and virile. When a virus gains the ability to transmit from human to human, we consider that as spilling over into the human population. That is what happened with COVID.
The chances of this happening are proportional to the number of viruses circulating in animals that are in close proximity to humans. The Huanan seafood market in Wuhan China was the perfect setup for this to happen. In this market there is a vast trade in wildlife and farmed animals for human consumption. The supply chain of these animals could not be more risky if it were designed to maximize the spread of viruses.
Every step in the chain – commercial breeding, transport, buying, selling, storage, processing, and killing – puts animals from diverse taxa in close proximity to each other. Often these are animals that would not be in close contact in the wild. The conditions are often unsanitary, the animals are stressed, and they attract rodents that contribute to the circulation of disease. In this environment animals that perhaps had few or no viruses in the wild acquire multiple viruses. This not only magnifies their spread, it allows for recombination – for different viruses to combine, gaining different abilities that expand their ability to infect and spread.
Amanda Fine, WCS Health Program Associate Director, Asia, and a co-author of a study on origins of COVID, said: “Wildlife supply chains, and the conditions the animals experience while in the supply chain, appear to greatly amplify the prevalence of coronaviruses. In addition, we documented exposure of rodents on wildlife farms to both bat and bird coronaviruses. These high prevalence rates and diversity of coronaviruses, added to the species mixing we see in the wildlife trade, create more opportunities for coronavirus recombination events as well as spillover.”
The same is true not just of coronaviruses, but of many virus types. We then take these now virus-ridden stressed animals, we pack them into a market in the middle of an urban center that we further pack with humans. So if a virus does jump to a human, there will be plenty of other people around to spread the new virus to.
Even though China continues to deny that SARS-CoV-2 originated in the Wuhan market, there have been steps to improve conditions. This includes the proposal of a classification system of wet markets to quantify their risk and to highlight the steps necessary to reduce this risk. The authors write:
“We identify six key risk factors of wet markets that can affect human health: (1) presence of high disease-risk animal taxa, (2) presence of live animals, (3) hygiene conditions, (4) market size, (5) animal density and interspecies mixing, and (6) the length and breadth of animal supply chains.”
In 2020 China quickly closed the Huanan wet market, and it remained closed. They also tightened restrictions and monitoring of other wet markets and officially banned the illegal trade of wild animals. It is too early to tell how much this has helped. The wild animal market was a critical part of the food chain in that part of the world, and cannot instantly be replaced. Also, demand for wild animals is still driven by Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). Much of the market has simply shifted to a black market trade, which uses the internet to conceal its activity. There is also a problem of laundering – of selling wild animal products as if they are legal and farmed.
According to the most extensive recent study on the topic:
“The annual value of the illegal trade in wildlife in Southeast Asia has been estimated at USD 8–11 billion and likely exceeds that. The annual wildlife farming industry in China was valued at USD 74 billion.”
This is a critical food source, and you cannot simply take it away overnight. It is also a huge industry that will not quietly go away. The best option might be to carefully regulate it to improve conditions and reduce the chance of spillover events. Banning the trade and pushing it underground may actually worsen conditions and make it more difficult to monitor and evaluate them.
At least there was an immediate reaction after COVID to improve conditions in China, but it remains to be seen how the international wild meat market reacts and adapts, and what the net effect will be. These markets are also only part of the problem – humans are increasingly pushing their living spaces into wild spaces, putting them at increasing proximity to wild animals. These animals also have diminishing wild spaces (through deforestation, climate change, urban spread and other factors), and so they are increasingly encroaching into human spaces to find food. And the legal market of domestic animals also often packs many animals into small spaces, making the spread of disease more likely.
The conditions still exist for zoonotic spillover events to happen, despite some efforts to address the worst conditions. In fact, recent studies find the risk is increasing, and historically has been increasing by about 5% per year. A more comprehensive global effort is needed to reverse this trend.



The Pro-Virus Misinformation of Matt Ridley and the Toxic Apathy of Dr. Alina Chan
You might think that someone who purports to be sincerely concerned about the origins of SARS-CoV-2 would also be unwilling to collaborate with someone who sought to spread SARS-CoV-2. You’d be wrong though.
Jonathan Howard on August 25, 2026
Link
“I also now disagree with the claim that we need to know how COVID-19 originated to prepare for the next pandemic: there no reason that the next one should follow the same pattern, and we should prepare for all possible threats.”
If my house caught fire, I would eventually want to know if an arsonist was after me or if I had been careless with my electronics. However my first thought would be to get out. Looking back on my escape plan, I wouldn’t judge its success or failure based on what caused the blaze, and regardless of the cause, my new house would have plenty of smoke detectors and fire extinguishers. They work exactly the same on fires caused by accidents and arson.
This is how I feel about SARS-CoV-2. It spread like wildfire without mitigations, and once it reached our shores, its origin was of no relevance for how we should have handled it. The same will be true if SARS-CoV-3 arrives. How we should prepare for and combat a new virus has nothing to do with where it came from. This shouldn’t be controversial
Obviously COVID’s origins matter. The truth is worth knowing for its own sake. All of the scientific evidence I’ve seen supports a zoonotic origin, and Philipp Markolin’s Lab Leak Fever is an excellent book on this topic. The “evidence” supporting a lab leak, in contrast, reads like a spy novel, involving hidden e-mails, coded exchanges, and now, scientists under arrest.
We also need to learn what went wrong in 2019 to lower the risk of it happening again, though as evolutionary biologist Dr. Florence Débarre pointed out, even that knowledge might not be that useful. As she put it:
I also now disagree with the claim that we need to know how COVID-19 originated to prepare for the next pandemic: there no reason that the next one should follow the same pattern, and we should prepare for all possible threats.
That sounds right to me, normal people don’t want a new pandemic coming from either a lab or an animal.
However, even if indisputable video emerged of Fauci blowing SARS-CoV-2 out the window of a Wuhan lab in 2019, what would that really change? Nothing that I care about. It wouldn’t mean zoonotic viruses suddenly stopped being a threat. It wouldn’t tell us what to do if COVID-27 arrived. It wouldn’t affect any of my pandemic writing. It wouldn’t bring back a single life or restore anyone’s health.
The exact cause of infection #1 is infinitely less important to me the enormous suffering caused by subsequent infections, the ones that killed and injured people. The human toll of COVID is what matters, especially considering much of it was preventable. Large numbers of people were killed by pro-infection disinformation, no matter where SARS-CoV-2 came from.
“I would feel terrible if it’s natural and I did all this.”
Not everyone sees it that way. There are some pandemic pundits who act as if infection #1 is the only thing that really matters about the whole tihng. COVID’s origin became their identity and brand, and it got them a lot of attention. These people shared several traits in common.
    • They promoted the lab leak with near total certainty.
    • They blamed people tasked with controlling SARS-CoV-2 for the creation of SARS-CoV-2 and denounced them constantly.
    • They experienced the pandemic from their laptops and were entirely incurious about happened in hospitals when COVID raged. They never thought they had anything to learn from those of us who worked in them.
    • They partnered with pro-infection MAHA/MAGA disinformation agents and scolded those of us who corrected their factual errors.
All of these are red flags, especially that last one. These people did not necessarily deny existence of the We Want Them Infected (WWTI) movement. They just didn’t care about it, and that deliberate indifference alone means there’s no reason to care about their musings on COVID’s origins.
Though there are many such people, one exemplar is Dr. Alina Chan, a molecular biologist who became well-known for promoting the lab leak, writing several articles about it in the New York Times. In a moment of self-reflection, she said:
I have days where I think this could be natural. And if it’s natural, then I’ve done a terrible thing because I’ve put a lot of scientists in a very dangerous spot by saying that they could be the source of an accident that resulted in millions of people dying. I would feel terrible if it’s natural and I did all this.
It’s hard to argue with that.
“Viral’s authors have unintentionally exposed the entire farce of the lab leak discourse.”
Dr. Chan’s magnum opus was a book titled Viral: The Search for the Origin of COVID-19, and many critics panned it. In her review of this “terrible book,” Lindsay Beyerstein wrote:
Viral’s authors have unintentionally exposed the entire farce of the lab leak discourse—showing both the exceptional flimsiness of the lab leakers’ narrative and also why this very flimsiness makes the lab leak conspiracy theory so hard to eradicate. By relying on an ever-growing arsenal of seemingly suspicious facts, each pointing in a slightly different direction, lab leaker discourse renders itself completely unfalsifiable.
Michael Hiltzik made similar points in his review:
“Viral” is a laboratory-perfect example of how not to write about a scientific issue. The authors rely less on the scientists doing the painstaking work to unearth the virus’ origin than on self-described sleuths who broadcast their dubious claims, sometimes anonymously, on social media. In the end, Chan and Ridley spotlight all the shortcomings of the hypothesis they set out to defend.
In his review, Mark Honigsbaum wrote:
Chan and Ridley are clever writers and in their “search for the origin of Covid-19” they venture into the deepest recesses of cyberspace, aided by an eclectic band of internet sleuths who go by such names as the “Seeker”. The result is a viral whodunnit that is sure to appeal to armchair detectives and sceptics of scientific orthodoxies. There is just one problem: nowhere do they present proof that Sars-CoV-2 was manufactured…
The tragedy is that in their desire to make a plausible case for a lab accident, Chan and Ridley neglect the far more urgent and compelling story of how the trade in wild animals, coupled with global heating and the destruction of natural habitats, makes the emergence of pandemic viruses increasingly likely. That is the more probable origin story and the scenario that should really concern us.
However, my aim here is not to join on this pile-on, but rather to explain why no one should care about her book in the first place.
The reason not to care right there on the cover. Dr Chan co-wrote her book with an advocate of herd immunity via mass infection who drastically underestimated COVID in 2020, and that’s enough to dismiss it entirely.
“Students Who Catch COVID May Be Saving Lives.”
Dr. Chan’s co-author was Matt Ridley, a science writer with a problematic history, and it’s worth delving into his pandemic philosophy, past and present. They are very different things, though his opposition to mitigations has been constant. That’s been his guiding principle and he’s never questioned it.
In May 2020, Mr. Ridley had good news to share about COVID. He said:
Despite only moderate social-distancing measures, the epidemic stopped growing in Stockholm County by mid-April, and has since shrunk significantly, implying that the herd immunity threshold was reached at around 20% of the population being immune:
Things didn’t work out that way in Sweden, and even today, six years and billions of infections later, the headlines read CDC: COVID Infections Likely Rising in 50 States.
While that could be blown off as an early, forgettable goof, Mr. Ridley was all in on the WWTI movement in 2020 and, real people got hurt by it. This is neither an innocent nor a forgivable error. There should be no question about this.
Mr. Ridley wrote an article in October 2020, a pivotal time in the pandemic, titled Students Who Catch COVID May Be Saving Lives, which opposed smoke detectors and fire extinguishers for COVID. His “counterintuitive” plan to stop the fire was to spread the fire. He wrote:
It is counterintuitive but the current spread of Covid may on balance be the least worst thing that could happen now. In the absence of a vaccine, and with no real prospect of eradicating the disease, the virus spreading among younger people, mostly without hitting the vulnerable, is creating immunity that will eventually slow the epidemic.
Though Mr. Ridley spoke of the “absence of a vaccine,” vaccines arrived just two months later. Mr. Ridely continued:
The second wave is real, but it is not like the first. It would be a mistake to tackle it with compulsory lockdowns (even if called ‘circuit breakers’), whether national or local. The cure would be worse than the disease.
Though Mr. Ridley spoke about a second wave that was “real, but it is not like the first“, three months later, the headlines read U.S. Reports Record Number Of COVID Deaths In January.
Mr. Ridley continued:
If you cannot extinguish an epidemic at the start, the best strategy is for the healthy to get infected first…. The Great Barrington Declaration, signed by over 20,000 doctors and medical scientists (but disgracefully censored by Google’s search engine), calls for focused protection: help the elderly and vulnerable stay at home, but let the young and invulnerable go out and achieve immunity for us all, while earning a living. The extraordinary truth is that a student catching Covid might be saving Granny’s life rather than threatening it.
This was all known to be false at the time. As early as April 2020 the headlines read Hundreds Of Young Americans Have Now Been Killed By The Coronavirus, Data Shows snd Young And Middle-Aged People, Barely Sick With Covid-19, Are Dying Of Strokes. Frontline doctors shared what they witnessed:
“Young people who are otherwise fit can tolerate this longer, but at the expense of their heart and their pulmonary functions,” said Evans, who likened some of the symptoms in younger people to prolonged carbon monoxide exposure.
He said younger patients he has seen tend to come in later, after battling the disease at home for longer. But for those who take a tragic turn, it often happens quickly.
“When they do deteriorate, they do so much more dramatically,” he said.
By January 2021 the headlines read Covid-19 Has Killed Thousands Of Young Americans. This Is Not Just A Tragedy For The Elderly. Young people were not invulnerable. Mr. Ridley experience all this from his laptop, and it all would have been much worse had we listened to people like him in October 2020.
Not only were some young people tragically vulnerable, infections in them could not have stayed isolated to them. A CDC report from early October unsurprisingly found:
Across the southern United States in June 2020, increases in percentage of positive SARS-CoV-2 test results among adults aged 20–39 years preceded increases among those aged ≥60 years by 4–15 days.
Either Mr. Ridley didn’t know about this, or he didn’t care about it.
However, even in a fantasyland where letting unvaccinated youngsters get COVID somehow saved Granny, that does not mean it would be the right thing to do. Using infants, children, and young adults as human shields to “achieve immunity for us all” is a moral abomination under any circumstance. This is all Mr. Ridley should be known for regarding COVID. There’s no reason to care what someone thinks about the origins of SARS-CoV-2 when they aimed to spread SARS-CoV-2.
“It’s their virus.”
Predictably, Mr. Ridley does not want to revisit what he actually said in 2020. He’s left all that behind. Instead, he only wants to talk about the origins of the SARS-CoV-2, the very virus he minimized and wanted to spread widely six-years ago.
He is not alone, and it’s important to understand why. The lab leak serves a valuable function for those who wanted to spread SARS-CoV-2 in 2020 and to protect Trump in 2026.
Even though they told everyone else to stop talking about COVID years ago, WWTI doctors have almost universally embraced the lab leak, and they discuss it constantly today. Not only does this bring them attention on social media, it allows them to distract from the scenes of overflowing hospitals and morgues in 2020, as well as their pro-infection disinformation throughout the pandemic.
It also allows them to absolve Trump of any wrongdoing in 2020. There’s a reason Trump made the website covid.gov all about the lab leak as soon as he could.
The lab leak further allows them shift blame for the SARS-CoV-2 onto to those whose job it was to contain SARS-CoV-2. In the propaganda video below, Dr. Bhattacharya, accusatory as always, says as Fauci’s face flashes across the screen:
They had supported the research that led to the creation of the virus, this gain of function research. It’s their virus.
Beyond this, Mr. Ridley now claims that the origin of SARS-CoV-2 dictates how we should have handled it, and wouldn’t you know it, he was right the whole time! How does he pull off this nifty intellectual trick?
According to Mr. Ridley’s latest and greatest justification for his opposition to mitigations in 2020, because SARS-CoV-2 leaked from a lab, that alone automatically means we should have done virtually nothing to contain it. He had the following exchange with journalist James Surowiecki, who asked a very reasonable question:
Surowiecki: How would knowing that Covid came from a lab – assuming for the sake of argument that it did, and that we could know that with certainty – have saved lives? What would have been different about our response?
Ridley: This is a common view – that knowing where Covid came from would not have helped. I disagree. Knowing it was pre-trained on human cells would have told us that lockdowns were futile.
That’s quite the leap, and sane, ethical people would argue opposite. If we imagine that if SARS-CoV-2 was “pre-trained on human cells” in a Chinese lab, then it’s probably not a good idea to let kids get infected with it over and over again.
Yet, even after it was clear it could kill and injure some of them, Mr. Ridley felt the mass infection of unvaccinated young people with SARS-CoV-2- the virus he claims was “pre-trained on human cells” in a Chinese lab- was the key to ending the pandemic. That’s the wisdom and sophistication he brought to the table.
Today, Mr. Ridley uses the lab leak to retroactively justify his 2020 approach to COVID. Though truthfully, he wanted them infected that year, he now claims the lab leak is the reason he was against mitigations. He’s spun a COVID origin myth that proves he was right about mitigations all along. That’s certainly convenient for him, especially when combined with his refusal even acknowledge his plan to “let the young and invulnerable go out and achieve immunity for us all.”
This isn’t just about 2020, of course. Mr. Ridley’s revisionist history has implications for future pandemics. In his telling, if there is a new lab leak virus, then we should all throw up our hands and recognize the futility of even try to stop it. However, if there is a new zoonotic virus, then mitigation measures will presumably be appropriate. That is obvious nonsense, like planning your escape from a burning building based on the fire’s cause. However, if COVID-27 arrives, then people like Mr. Ridley, who were primarily concerned about people “earning a living” regarding COVID-19, would once again have a powerful incentive invoke a lab leak, wouldn’t they? After all, knowing it was pre-trained on human cells would have told us that lockdowns were futile.
Unsurprisingly, Mr. Ridley dedication to promoting the lab leak earns him accolades from leaders of the MAHA/MAGA movement today. Dr. Bhattacharya honored him by allowing him lecture about the lab leak fo the inaugural NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture. I suggest you read this review by Zach Hensel and this review by Dr. Débarre.
Fundamentally, as I discussed previously regarding the Biosafety Now bros, by using the lab leak to legitimize the MAHA/MAGA agenda, Mr. Ridley helped ensure we are all much more vulnerable to dangerous pathogens, both old and new, from labs and from nature. Again, this is not theoretical. As Mr. Ridley speculates about what really happened in Wuhan 7 years ago, real diseases are already spreading today thanks to the efforts of many prominent lab leakers.
“I have a rare ability to work well with people on shared challenges even when I may not agree with their other positions.”
You might think that someone who purports to be sincerely concerned about the origins of SARS-CoV-2 would also be unwilling to collaborate with someone who sought to spread SARS-CoV-2. You’d be wrong though. The only thing that bothered Dr. Chan about Mr. Ridley’s pro-infection misinformation was that anyone would criticize it. I had a revealing social media exchange with her about her about this:
Me: Given that you collaborate with people who wanted to infect unvaccinated kids with Covid, why do you care about where it came from? Was infection #1 a tragedy and after that the lack of infections was the problem? Can you explain? I’m lost.
I also included a screenshot of Mr. Ridley’s article Students Who Catch COVID May Be Saving Lives. Dr. Chan replied:
Chan: I have a rare ability to work well with people on shared challenges even when I may not agree with their other positions. imo if more people had this ability, society would be much kinder, less polarized, and more progressive.
Me: So the fact that he wanted to mass infect millions of unvaccinated young people wasn’t a deal breaker for you, and you view this as a sign of how superior you are to those who might decide otherwise.
It’s true. I lack Dr. Chan’s “rare ability.” I would never write about COVID with someone who sought to spread it.
In contrast, Dr. Chan feels it’s virtuous not to remember or care about advocates of herd immunity via natural immunity. She boasts of her utter indifference to the WWTI movement and therefore to the real people hurt by it. Her “rare ability” turns out to be noxious indifference. She also feels if more people were like her, willing to legitimize MAHA/MAGA royalty like Mr. Ridley, then “society would be much kinder, less polarized, and more progressive.” Incredible stuff.
Dr. Chan further had the gall to ask me if had read Mr. Ridley’s article after I posted it. Yes, Alina, I read his article. She even defended the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), writing:
The Great Barrington declaration called for focused protection of the vulnerable while others attain natural immunity.
SBM readers will know not to be impressed that the GBD merely “called for” things, while simultaneously promoting “natural immunity.” However, Dr. Chan was totally ignorant about this topic. To defend the honor of GBD, she asked:
Which GDB (sic) signatory/signatories spread anti-vaccine disinformation? I would appreciate knowing this as well. Thank you.
Myself and many others have answered that question countless time in books, articles, YouTube videos, social media posts, and podcasts. Though there’s no shortage of material about pandemic disinformation, Dr. Chan was, apparently, ignorant of it all. She been too busy blaming scientists for infection #1 to learn or care about anything that happened after that, including the pro-infection disinformation of Mr. Ridley.
I concluded my exchange with Dr. Chan by saying:
You can overlook advocates of herd immunity by mass immunity.
You argue with people who communicated accurate information and worked in hospitals.
Not much more to gain.
Take care.
Indeed, toxic apathy is disqualifying.
Dr. Chan should read my books, however. She obviously has a lot to learn, and it’s all more important than the precise cause of infection #1. I can teach her all about the WWTI movement. I can teach her about the people hurt by their disinformation, what happened in hospitals when their pro-infection philosophy was embraced, and how it birthed MAHA/MAGA.
I can’t make her care about any of it though.


Plandemic: Judy Mikovits and the mother of all COVID-19 conspiracy theories
Judy Mikovits is a disgraced scientist who published a paper claiming that a retrovirus called XMRV causes chronic fatigue syndrome, results that other investigators were unable to replicate. Since then, she’s been a regular on the antivaccine circuit, but now she’s been reborn as a “Fire Fauci” COVID-19 conspiracy theorist. Sadly, it worked. Her book is #1 on Amazon.
David Gorski on May 8, 2020
Link

[NOTE: This is an updated and revised version of a post that was originally posted on my not-so-secret other blog on Wednesday. The original video on YouTube that went viral has been removed by the platform, and Facebook has announced that it is removing it as well for spreading COVID-19 misinformation. My original post went viral, too, and the resulting incoming traffic impressively crashed my modest hosting capabilities several times from Wednesday night through the day yesterday until the hosting service and I finally got it under control by scaling back the blog to a plain vanilla template and turning off nearly every plugin other than the anti-spam comment plugin. I pay for my personal blog with my own money, which means I can’t afford to go whole hog on a corporate hosting account. In contrast, SBM has a much more robust hosting plan and should thus be able to handle the load if this updated version of the post gets a lot of traffic too.]
By now you’ve almost certainly heard of or seen a “trailer” to a “full length documentary” called Plandemic, which is being previewed by the release of a “series of vignettes,” the first of which was released yesterday. The YouTube video went viral for two days, spreading all over social media to the point it was almost impossible to avoid, before YouTube and Facebook removed it for spreading dangerous COVID-19 misinformation. From the name, you can tell that this video is a conspiracy-fest of a “documentary”, arguing that the current COVID-19 pandemic was somehow planned. We’ll get to that shortly. The “star” of this first segment of Plandemic is Judy Mikovits, a disgraced virologist who made a splash in 2009 when she somehow got a horrible paper published in Science concluding that chronic fatigue syndrome is caused by a retrovirus, XMRV. For a long time, she was a minor antivaccine celebrity showing up at antivax confabs like Autism One and being interviewed by various antivaccine activists. Now, as is the case with a lot of cranks and antivaxxers, Mikovits has jumped on the COVID-19 conspiracy bandwagon.
Here’s the trailer, which includes the video, self-hosted apparently. The blurb for this movie is just plain bonkers:
Humanity is imprisoned by a killer pandemic. People are being arrested for surfing in the ocean and meditating in nature. Nations are collapsing. Hungry citizens are rioting for food. The media has generated so much confusion and fear that people are begging for salvation in a syringe. Billionaire patent owners are pushing for globally mandated vaccines. Anyone who refuses to be injected with experimental poisons will be prohibited from travel, education and work. No, this is not a synopsis for a new horror movie. This is our current reality.
No, people are being arrested for overcrowding and refusing to social distance sufficiently. As yet, I haven’t seen any nations collapsing due to COVID-19, although it’s certainly possible that this could happen if an unstable nation is sufficiently stressed. As for the “billionaire patent owners,” one wonders to whom the filmmaker is referring, one does. (OK, you likely know that it’s Bill Gates, whose advocacy for public health and vaccines have made him one of the most reviled people in existence to the tinfoil hat conspiracy crowd, particularly the antivaccine contingent. Basically, to them, he’s a sweater-wearing Darth Vader, Lord Sauron, and Voldemort all rolled up into one, except that he’s working behind the scenes like Frank Underwood in the first couple of seasons of House of Cards before he became President to enslave us all with vaccines and pharmaceuticals.)
The movie boldly paddles up the river of pseudoscience and deeper into tinfoil hat conspiracy territory:
In the early 1900s, America’s first Billionaire, John D. Rockefeller bought a German pharmaceutical company that would later assist Hitler to implement his eugenics-based vision by manufacturing chemicals and poisons for war. Rockefeller wanted to eliminate the competitors of Western medicine, so he submitted a report to Congress declaring that there were too many doctors and medical schools in America, and that all natural healing modalities were unscientific quackery. Rockefeller called for the standardization of medical education, whereby only his organization be allowed to grant medical school licenses in the US. And so began the practice of immune suppressive, synthetic and toxic drugs. Once people had become dependent on this new system and the addictive drugs it provided, the system switched to a paid program, creating lifelong customers for the Rockefellers. Currently, medical error is the third leading cause of death in the US. Rockefeller’s secret weapon to success was the strategy known as, “problem-reaction-solution.” Create a problem, escalate fear, then offer a pre-planned solution. Sound familiar?
Flash forward to 2020…
They named it COVID19. Our leaders of world health predicted millions would die. The National Guard was deployed. Makeshift hospitals were erected to care for a massive overflow of patients. Mass graves were dug. Terrifying news reports had people everywhere seeking shelter to avoid contact. The plan was unfolding with diabolical precision, but the masters of the Pandemic underestimated one thing… the people. Medical professionals and every-day citizens are sharing critical information online. The overlords of big tech have ordered all dissenting voices to be silenced and banned, but they are too late. The slumbering masses are awake and aware that something is not right. Quarantine has provided the missing element: time. Suddenly, our overworked citizenry has ample time to research and investigate for themselves. Once you see, you can’t unsee.
I’ll give the filmmaker credit for…imagination…for going all the way back to John D. Rockefeller as the origin of the evil plot that has now culminated a century later in the COVID-19 pandemic. At this point, I can’t resist mentioning that medical error is not the third leading cause of death. Not even close. That’s a myth that just won’t die. (It’s my duty to point that out any time someone parrots that idiocy.)
I do love that last paragraph. It is exactly why people are prone to conspiracy theories. A good conspiracy theory turns the believer into a hero, a warrior with secret knowledge to which the other ignorant “sheeple” aren’t privy, against powerful forces arrayed against him. A good conspiracy theory almost always has a part at the end in which the “people” (in this case, the people believing the conspiracy theory) “wake up” and see what is being “suppressed” by the powerful forces seeking to keep them ignorant. Conspiracy theories like this both make the believer feel special and brave for having secret knowledge and fighting to make it public, but also provide an explanation for bad things happening in the world. Yes, the conspiracy theory in Plandemic is utterly ridiculous to those of us who know science, medicine, and history, but most people don’t know the relevant science, medicine, and history. To them, it sounds plausible.
Judy Mikovits as portrayed by Mikki Willis
We now get to Judy Mikovits, who is portrayed in the clip above as just the sort of brave maverick scientist and truth teller that every good conspiracy theory needs, a woman with hidden knowledge who’s fighting dark powerful forces seeking to “silence her”. The sad thing is, at one time she was a decent scientist, unlike some other legitimate scientists turned antivaccine cranks, like Christopher Shaw, Christopher Exley, Jeffrey Lyons-Weiler, and Andrew Wakefield, who were almost certainly never very good scientists even before they turned into cranks.
Before I delve into the clip and Judy Mikovits’ story, I had to look into the filmmaker. Oddly enough, I didn’t see his name, Mikki Willis, on the Plandemic website, although a bunch of YouTube videos showed up at the end of the trailer featuring him. A quick Google search revealed that Willis is a director who founded Elevate, a film company that supposedly does “transformative media”. (Conspiracy theory movies are transformative, albeit not in a good way, I guess. Just look at VAXXED. I’m getting a distinctly Del Bigtree vibe.) Willis is also grandiose:
September 11th, 2001 marked a turning point in Mikki Willis’ life and career. Having been inside the twin towers just hours before they fell, he helped to organize a group of civilians who remained at Ground Zero for 3 days to aid in the search and rescue efforts. It was atop the rubble of the World Trade Center that the vision for the Elevate was born.
Hmmm. I wonder if this is where Willis’ penchant for conspiracy theories was born. A perusal of his filmography on IMDb reveals a definite penchant for woo, though, with a film called The Rub of Attraction about The Secret, Ten Seconds to Midnight (which appears to be about the end of the world in 2012 foretold by the Mayan calendar), and The Shadow Effect, featuring Deepak Chopra, Marianne Williamson, James Van Praugh, and Mark Victor Hansen.
Back to the trailer.
Right from the very beginning, Mikovits is introduced as a great scientist (“one of the most accomplished scientists of her generation”) who was demonized and exiled from the world of science by big pharma and the dogmatic gatekeepers of science after having reported something that “they” didn’t want you to know about. (A “blockbuster article in the journal Science” that supposedly found that the “common use of animal and fetal tissue were unleashing devastating plagues of chronic diseases.” I’ll get into the details a bit in a moment.) It’s a nauseatingly familiar exaggerated narrative, complete with ominous music and an oh-so-serious voiceover, as Mikovits is shown walking and talking with Willis. The voiceover intones, “For exposing their deadly secrets, the minions of big pharma waged war on Dr. Mikovits, destroying her name, career, and personal life”. (Seriously, that was so over-the-top that I actually laughed when I heard it, and I was only less than a minute into the video.)
The voiceover continues:
Now, as the fate of nations hangs in the balance, Dr. Mikovits is naming names and in the plague of corruption that places all human life in danger.
The reality is, as you will see, quite different.
Dr. Judy Mikovits’ pre-conspiracy career
First, let’s look at Dr. Mikovits’ pre-crank scientific career. Let’s just say that her background has been…embellished. Wikipedia notes that in her early career, after having been awarded a Bachelor of Science degree in Chemistry with a specialization in biology at the University of Virginia in 1980, Mikovits went to the National Cancer Institute in 1980, where she worked as a researcher in the laboratory of Francis “Frank” Ruscetti, developing purification methods for interferon-alpha. (For those of you who disingenuously object to the use of Wikipedia for anything, note that this is only a starting point, and I examined many of the primary sources linked to in the article and used them whenever possible.)
Mikovits also briefly worked at Upjohn Pharmaceuticals in Kalamazoo, MI to develop production methods to ensure biological materials manufactured using human blood products were free of contamination from HIV-1. Given that she only had a Bachelor degree, that tells me she worked as a technician in Dr. Ruscetti’s laboratory. She did, however, ultimately get a PhD in a joint program in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology at George Washington University in 1992, with her PhD thesis being entitled “Negative Regulation of HIV Expression in Monocytes”. I note that Mikovits and her admirers often claim that her doctoral thesis “changed the treatment of HIV-AIDS” but have struggled to find evidence that this was so or that her thesis was such a “game changer”. Quite simply, she worked in Dr. Ruscetti’s laboratory, did some good work, but was never a “brilliant” scientist, much less “one of the most accomplished scientists of her generation.” She has 34 publications in PubMed, for which she’s first author only on eight and corresponding author on only four, only one of them from her time at the NIH.
This archived entry in the Wayback Machine from 1998 describes her thusly:
Dr. Mikovits obtained her Ph.D. in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology from George Washington University. Her doctoral research focused on HIV-1 latency under the direction of Francis Ruscetti. Dr. Mikovits performed postdoctoral work on the molecular genetics of HTLV-1 under David Derse at the National Cancer Institute-FCRDC.
The mechanisms by which human retroviruses alter the function of the immune system and other host responses resulting in pathogenesis are not well understood. The current focus of our studies is to define viral and cellular factors involved in pathogenesis. Specifically, we have examined viral and cellular factors involved in regulating HIV infectivity and expression, cell death and mechanisms of immune dysfunction. In this regard, we and others have shown that HIV-1 expression in monocytes and helper T lymphocytes can be silenced and that this latency can be overcome by both immune activation and hypomethylation. Studies of SIV and HIV infection in the lymph nodes indicate that the capacity of the host to control viral load is predictive of disease progression. The importance of latent reservoirs is underscored by recent studies showing patients in which plasma virus is reduced to undetectable levels following highly active triple drug antiretroviral therapy, however soon after cessation of therapy high viral titers are again detected, suggesting long lived reservoirs of latent virus exist. Therefore, we have focused our efforts on examining infectivity of HIV-1 and HTLV-1 and defining cytokines and other cellular mechanisms involved in maintaining a balance between human retroviral expression and latency.
Those of you who know what all that means can see that she did what looks like some good work. Those of you who know how science works will also know that that, as of 1998, Mikovits had never become independent. She was not a principal investigator. She was doing work in a principal investigator’s lab supervised by that PI. As far as I can tell, she was never an independent researcher at the NIH. In fact, she left in 2001 to get married and take a job at a biotech startup, EpiGenX Pharmaceuticals.
The descent into conspiracy mongering begins
There’s a New York Times article from 2009 that picks up the story of Judy Mikovits by describing the findings that Mikovits published. At the time, she was the research director for the Whittemore-Peterson Institute for Neuro-Immune Disease, a nonprofit in Reno, NV founded recently by the parents of a young woman who has chronic fatigue syndrome, Andrea Whittemore-Goad, in 2006. It’s interesting to note how Mikovits was recruited by Harvey and Annette Whittemore to become the director of their institute:
She and her husband had the means, the knowledge and the connections. They are real estate developers and part owners of a gas company and an energy drink, and they hold interests in other businesses. Mr. Whittemore is also a lawyer and a lobbyist. Starting in the fall of 2004, they put $5 million of their own money into setting up an institute at the University of Nevada’s medical school. They also persuaded the governor and State Legislature to commit $10 million for a new building that would house the institute’s researchers and a clinic, as well as scientists from the university and the Nevada Cancer Institute. The research began in 2006, and a clinic for patients is scheduled to open in about a year.
Rather than just doling out money to far-flung researchers, the Whittemores wanted to employ their own scientists who would be devoted full time to the cause. In the spring of 2006, they met Dr. Judy A. Mikovits, a virus expert who had spent 22 years working at the National Cancer Institute. She had left the institute in 2001 to get married and move to California, where she went to work for a drug development company that failed. She was tending bar at a yacht club when a patron said her constant talk about viruses reminded him of someone he knew in Nevada. That person was a friend of Annette Whittemore’s. Dr. Mikovits soon found herself at a conference on chronic fatigue syndrome.
I find it rather…interesting…that the Whittemores recruited a scientist who hadn’t worked in the field for five years and was apparently working on cancer therapies at a small drug development firm and tending bar at the time to direct an institute into which they were pouring millions of dollars. This is particularly true to me given that chronic fatigue syndrome is a condition whose cause has long eluded scientists to the point where some question whether it’s a real diagnosis for a single syndrome. To be successful in cracking a problem whose answer has eluded scientists for decades requires an excellent scientist. Picking someone like Mikovits hardly seemed like a good recipe for success! Of course, that is the problem with private institutes run by wealthy philanthropists. If the philanthropists are fixated on one idea, they’ll hire people and fund research looking for evidence to support that idea. Mikovits had one tool, a hammer (in this case, her study of viruses for two decades), and so every problem (in this case chronic fatigue syndrome) was a nail. Reading between the lines, I get the feeling that the Whittemores were taken with the idea that CFS was caused by a virus, leading to the hiring of Mikovits.
In any event, after meeting Dr. Daniel L. Peterson, who described how some of his chronic fatigue syndrome patients developed a rare form of lymphoma, an observation that led Mikovits to conclude that it must be a retrovirus causing CFS. The result:
Dr. Mikovits began connecting the dots almost immediately. She knew that some patients with chronic fatigue syndrome, and some men with prostate cancer, had a certain enzyme deficiency. And she also knew that tissue samples from men with prostate cancer had been found to harbor a retrovirus called XMRV, for xenotropic murine leukemia virus-related virus. She began working part time with the institute, and by the fall of 2006, the Whittemores had hired her as research director. One of her first projects was to look for XMRV in blood samples from people with chronic fatigue syndrome and from healthy control subjects.
Many of the samples from syndrome patients – 68 of 101, or 67 percent – were infected, she and her colleagues reported in Science. Only 3.7 percent of the healthy controls carried the virus. XMRV, the scientists suggested, may cause or at least contribute to chronic fatigue syndrome. Further tests found the virus in 90 of the 101, Dr. Mikovits said.
XMRV is a mouse retrovirus, but “xenotropic” is applied because it can replicate in the cells of other animals. A spoiler alert right here is in order. Mikovits’ paper was ultimately retracted two years later, but at the time it was published in Science and breathlessly reported in articles in the mainstream media like the NYT article I’ve been quoting from and this other article.
How did the retraction occur? First, there were a number of criticisms of Mikovits’ methods, which were poorly described, and three independent studies trying to replicate her results failed to find evidence of XMRV in either healthy controls or CFS patients. A nine-center study was begun to try to confirm the preliminary results of Mikovits’ study. Coded replicate samples of blood from 15 subjects previously reported to be XMRV–positive (14 with CFS) and from 15 healthy donors previously determined to be negative for the viruses were distributed in a blinded fashion to nine laboratories, which performed assays designed to detect XMRV nucleic acid, virus replication, and antibody. The results were disappointing. Only two labs reported evidence of the virus, but replicate sample results disagreed and there was no difference in detection between CFS subjects and negative controls without CFS. Science published an editorial expression of concern, noting:
Since then, at least 10 studies conducted by other investigators and published elsewhere have reported a failure to detect XMRV in independent populations of CFS patients. In this issue, we are publishing two Reports that strongly support the growing view that the association between XMRV and CFS described by Lombardi et al. likely reflects contamination of laboratories and research reagents with the virus. In one Report, “Recombinant origin of the retrovirus XMRV” (2), T. Paprotka et al. trace the ancestry of XMRV and provide evidence that the virus originated when two mouse leukemia viruses underwent recombination during experimental passage of a human prostate tumor xenograft in mice in the 1990s. A combination of sequencing, phylogenetic, and probability analyses lead Paprotka et al. to conclude that laboratory contamination with XMRV produced by a cell line (22Rv1) derived from these early xenograft experiments is the most likely explanation for detection of the virus in patient samples. In the other Report, “No evidence of murine-like gammaretroviruses in CFS patients previously identified as XMRV-infected” (3), K. Knox et al. examined blood samples from 61 CFS patients from the same medical practice that had provided patient samples to Lombardi et al. Comprehensive assays by Knox et al. for viral nucleic acids, infectious virus, and virus-specific antibodies revealed no evidence of XMRV in any of the samples.
In other words, XMRV is almost certainly the result of a recombination event in the 1990s in different prostate cancer cell lines grown in immunodeficient mice. Mikovits almost certainly based her conclusion on her detection of a laboratory contaminant.
There’s more, though. Here’s an excerpt from the retraction notice:
In addition, there is evidence of poor quality control in a number of specific experiments in the Report. Figure 1, table S1, and fig. S2 have been retracted by the authors (3). In response to concerns expressed about Fig. 2C [summarized in (4)], the authors acknowledged to Science that they omitted important information from the legend of this figure panel. Specifically, they failed to indicate that the CFS patient–derived peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) shown in Fig. 2C had been treated with azacytidine as well as phytohemagglutinin and interleukin-2. This was in contrast to the CFS samples shown in Figs. 2A and 2B, which had not been treated with azacytidine.
Why is this important? Azacytidine is a chemical that activates retroviruses, which means that the CFS-derived cells were treated with a chemical to bring out their retroviruses while the control cells were not. That’s scientific fraud, as far as I’m concerned.
That’s the end of the story from a scientific standpoint, but only the beginning of the story of the conspiracy theory. I also note that the antivaccine movement jumped on the XMRV story when antivax propagandist (at the time) David Kirby linked XMRV to autism in an evidence-free speculative article published in The Huffington Post shortly after Mikovits’ paper in 2009, “Is Autism Associated with a Viral Infection?” (now deleted but preserved, thanks to the almighty Wayback Machine). In it, Mikovits speculated:
“On that note, if I might speculate a little bit,” she said, “This might even explain why vaccines would lead to autism in some children, because these viruses live and divide and grow in lymphocytes — the immune response cells, the B and the T cells. So when you give a vaccine, you send your B and T cells in your immune system into overdrive. That’s its job. Well, if you are harboring one virus, and you replicate it a whole bunch, you’ve now broken the balance between the immune response and the virus. So you have had the underlying virus, and then amplified it with that vaccine, and then set off the disease, such that your immune system could no longer control other infections, and created an immune deficiency.”
So there you have it – a possible explanation of regressive autism in a significant number of cases associated with immune system deregulation triggered by vaccination.
So Mikovits was antivaccine even back then.
A conspiracy theory is born
Early on in her interview for Plandemic, Mikovits describes being arrested and portrays it as a false arrest for no reason other than to silence her. Naturally, Willis leads with that part of the story, and, given the background I’ve related, you’re probably asking: What the heck is that all about? Unsurprisingly, after Mikovits’ Science paper was retracted, she was fired. Then this happened:
A little more than 1 month after firing Mikovits, the Whittemore Peterson Institute for Neuro-Immune Disease (WPI) on 4 November filed suit against its former research director. According to WPI, after Mikovits was terminated on 29 September, she wrongfully removed laboratory notebooks and kept other proprietary information on her laptop and in flash drives and in a personal e-mail account. WPI, a nonprofit organization that’s based on the campus of the University of Nevada, Reno, also won a temporary restraining order that forbids Mikovits from “destroying, deleting, or altering” any of the related files or data.
Mikovits attorney, Lois Hart, said her client cannot speak to the media about the case, but she strongly denies any wrongdoing. In an e-mail to ScienceInsider, Hart stressed that “Dr. Mikovits’ integrity goes to the bone.”
Basically, the Whittemore-Peterson Institute reported that a number of Mikovits’ lab notebooks, plus flash drives containing years’ worth of research data, were found to be missing after she had been terminated, noting that she had the only key to the locked desk in which they were stored. (Her contract stipulated that lab notebooks and data had to remain with the institute if she ever left her job, a near universal clause in such employment contracts with corporations and nonprofits doing research.) Mikovits’s attorney countered that several people had keys to her office and laboratory, although, conspicuously, I never saw any mention of anyone else having a key to the desk. A few days later, Mikovits was arrested for theft. Ultimately, criminal charges were dismissed. Complicating matter was the fact that the judge initially overseeing the civil case had received campaign donations from WPI co-founder Harvey Whittemore, who himself has been criminally charged with making illegal campaign contributions to a federal official. That part certainly didn’t help with respect to being fodder for a conspiracy theory.
Conveniently, Willis and Mikovits leave out some key information. For instance, a research assistant named Max Pfost, who was also rooming in Mikovits’ home, provided a sworn affidavit detailing his complicity in stealing the notebooks and delivering them to Dr. Mikovits. This affidavit was the basis for the warrants, issued by the Reno Justice Court in Washoe County, to search her home and arrest her. It’s worth reading in full. Basically, he stated that Mikovits instructed him to retrieve the notebooks and drives and that he did. Another researcher named Amanda McKenzie also provided a sworn affidavit in which she attests that Mikovits asked her to remove laboratory samples and other materials and deliver them to one of her co-authors but that she declined.
Also, contrary to Mikovits’ claim in Plandemic that she was arrested without warrant, jailed without charges, there were warrants issued by the University of Nevada at Reno Police Department on November 17, 2011. Dr. Mikovits was arrested at her home on November 18, 2011 and charged with two felonies: 1. possession of stolen property and 2. unlawful taking of computer data, equipment, supplies, or other computer related property. She was held without bail for 5 days while awaiting arraignment and hearing on extradition to Nevada on felony charges after the laboratory notebooks, computer, and other items belonging to WPI were recovered from her home following the search. Criminal charges were later dismissed without prejudice pending the outcome of the civil trial against Dr. Mikovits for losses related to the stolen but recovered notebooks.
That’s a very different story than the one told in Plandemic. Even so, thus was born a conspiracy theory, one that Mikovits has been milking for all it’s worth since at least 2011. With the COVID-19 pandemic, Mikovits has found a new road to prominence, after having posted a video three weeks ago saying that we don’t need a coronavirus vaccine, after having gotten involved in the “Fire Fauci campaign” after claiming that Dr. Fauci had sabotaged her XMRV research:
Soon, Dr Fauci, everyone will know who you "really are". pic.twitter.com/GyD0j7UbWW
— Judy A. Mikovits PhD (@DrJudyAMikovits) April 19, 2020
Also:
In the same video, Mikovits rejected the notion of wearing a mask, since, she claimed, the coronavirus is actually secretly caused by a bad strain of flu shot that was circulating between 2013 and 2015. Masks will help “activate” the virus and reinfect a mask-wearer over and over, she claimed.
“Wearing a mask will kill more people than—this virus is not coughed through the air from healthy people, who are almost certainly immune, as they’ve almost certainly been infected over the last four or five years,” Mikovits said.
Ironically, in a video full of COVID-19 misinformation, it was the ridiculous claim that wearing a mask will kill more people than the virus that got the Plandemic video yanked from YouTube and Facebook.
That bit about the flu vaccine is so nonsensical that even David Kirby, an antivaccine propagandist whose mention is a real blast from the past on this blog, saw through it and posted this on Facebook:
With this background, Mikovits’ claims in the Plandemic video start to make more sense as persecution complex and misinformation based on conspiracy theories. Also, she’s pushing her new book, Plague of Corruption: Restoring Faith in the Promise of Science. You can tell just how far into tinfoil hat territory this book plunges by the fact that she co-wrote it with Kent Heckenlively, a man known for Walter Mitty-like fantasies of heroic action against evil purveyors of vaccines, and that the foreword was written by antivaccine leader Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Worse, as you will see, this viral video has been highly successful in promoting this conspiracy-fest of a book.
She fits right in, too. After Willis notes that “apparently their attempt to silence you has failed” and asks how she can have the “confidence” to “name names” and “call out these dark forces” without fearing for her life, her response tells me how far down the rabbit hole she’s gone:
Because if we don’t stop this now, we can not only forget our republic and our freedom, but we can forget humanity because we’ll be killed by this agenda.
At this point, Mikovits weaves a conspiracy theory in which Dr. Fauci ordered a coverup of her results, claiming that “everyone was paid off” with “millions of dollars of funding” from Anthony Fauci through the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease (NIAID). Her story is that Dr. Fauci came into her laboratory when Dr. Ruscetti was gone and demanded a copy of the paper they had just submitted documenting the detection of HIV in the saliva and blood of AIDS patients from Luc Montagnier’s group in France. It was a confirmatory study. She then claimed that Fauci screamed at her to give him the paper. Why? She claims that Fauci had been working with Robert Gallo and that he held up the publication of Ruscetti ‘s paper for several months to allow Robert Gallo to publish his own paper.
As you might imagine, the story sounds very fishy. First of all, there were telephones back then. Making a trans-Atlantic phone call was a possibility! Yes, international calls were expensive in the 1980s, but people made them especially for the government and corporations. There’s no reason why Fauci couldn’t have called Ruscetti, particularly since Mikovits claims that it was several weeks before he came back from overseas. There was even mail. Heck, there was even email back in the mid-1980s for government institutions. (I even had an email account at the University of Michigan in the mid-1980s.) So, why did Fauci supposedly do this, colluding with Robert Gallo and Robert Redfield, who’s now the Director of the CDC? Money and patents, of course! And, of course, she brings in Bill Gates, with his advocacy of vaccines, because antivax grifters gonna grift.
The story doesn’t make sense from a timeline perspective, either. It is true that Robert Gallo falsely took credit for discovering the AIDS virus in 1984 when the virus was actually discovered at the Pasteur Institute in 1983. It’s also true that Gallo did work with Mikovits’ boss Dr. Ruscetti to make some major discoveries in the field of retroviruses in 1980, that same year was the year that Mikovits graduated from college and took a job at the National Cancer Institute in Frank Ruscetti’s lab. As Zachariah Wiedeman asks about Mikovits’ story:
Are we to believe that somehow, fresh out of college, sometime between 1980 and 1983 she was at the forefront of groundbreaking work to isolate and confirm HIV, and that she actually discovered it, then Gallo stole the credit from her, but he also simultaneously stole the credit from the Pasteur Institute where he obtained his sample, that he didn’t actually have, because Mikovits had it. What, the what??
Also, at the time, Dr. Fauci was Chief of the Laboratory of Immunoregulation at the National Institute of Health and wasn’t appointed director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease until 1984. Just from Dr. Fauci’s role at the NIH during the time period, Mikovits’ story makes no sense. It defies plausibility that Fauci would even ask a laboratory technician, fresh out of college, for her boss’ unpublished manuscript, much less that he would browbeat her and yell at her when she refused.
Towards the middle of the video, Willis asks Mikovits if she’s antivaccine, which, of course, she denies. After characterizing vaccines as an “immune therapy”, she then goes on to buying into the conspiracy that SARS-CoV-2 (the coronavirus that causes COVID-19) was “manipulated and studied” in a laboratory and then escaped. She then makes the utterly nonsensical claim that if SARS-CoV-2 had evolved naturally it would have taken 800 years. (Seriously, she’s a virologist?) Her difference is that she claims that the virus must have been released somehow between Fort Detrick and the Wuhan laboratory. She even claimed that in 1999 she worked at Fort Detrick in order to “teach Ebola how to infect human cells,” further claiming that Ebola couldn’t infect human cells until it had been “taught” how to do it. Apparently Ebola came from a lab too. Never mind that Ebola was first reported in humans in 1976.
Indeed, the amount of nonsense, misinformation, disinformation, and conspiracy mongering in Mikovits’ response to questions is truly epic. She likens COVID-19 infection to chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), which is even more nonsensical. She agrees with the conspiracy theory that doctors are being pushed to misclassify deaths due to other causes as due to COVID-19. Willis even included a clip of Dr. Dan Erickson making that claim. You might recall that he and Dr. Artin Massihi made a misinformation-laden video claiming that COVID-19 prevalence was so much higher than estimated and using that estimate to claim that COVID-19 is actually five times less lethal than seasonal flu. I emphasize that, in reality, the case and death count from COVID-19 is grossly underestimated. Why the pressure? Because government reimbursement is higher for a diagnosis of COVID-19, apparently. Basically, all the common conspiracy theories about COVID-19 make an appearance, including the claim that it was the flu vaccine that got it started, but with a spin. Mikovits claims that Italy was hit so hard because the virus for the flu vaccine it used was grown in dog cells and dog cells have a lot of coronavirus. She also cites the bogus claim that the flu vaccine increases your chance of getting COVID-19 by 36%. It doesn’t.
Oh, and hydroxychloroquine makes an appearance, too, because of course it does. Hydroxychloroquine probably doesn’t work, but Mikovits is all-in with conspiracy theories about it.
Mark and Chris Hoofnagle coined a term “crank magnetism”, in which a person who believes in one form of pseudoscience or one conspiracy theory will tend to believe in multiple pseudoscientific beliefs and conspiracy theories. When, late in the video, Mikovits asks why we’re closing beaches because there are “healing microbes in the sand”, I had to stop. There’s just so much idiocy I can tolerate. I’ll give Mikovits credit, though. She somehow instinctively knew just how to make her story go viral by latching on to the right wing campaign to smear Dr. Fauci. As a result, her book is currently #1 on Amazon:
Sadly, as Judy Mikovits demonstrates, the COVID-19 pandemic is drawing cranks and conspiracy theorists like it moths to a light. Chief among them are antivax grifters like Judy Mikovits. She’s so wrong she’s not even wrong, and she’s gone full conspiracy theorist, taking advantage of the COVID-19 pandemic to be reborn as a COVID-19 crank, grifting with her book and a “doctor education” company. Sadly, she’s not alone.

Plandemic: Judy Mikovits and the mother of all COVID-19 conspiracy theories (some final thoughts)
Last Friday, I deconstructed Plandemic, a misinformation conspiracyfest of a video that went viral last week. It turns out that Judy Mikovits, the disgraced scientist featured in the video has even more conspiracy theories and misinformation up her sleeve.
David Gorski on May 11, 2020
Link

After having written about Plandemic, the video featuring disgraced scientist Judy Mikovits that went viral last week, I was pointed to material that, if anything, revealed that Mikki Willis, the filmmaker responsible for this bit of conspiracy mongering propaganda attacking Anthony Fauci, had exercised restraint. What do I mean? Simple, I was pointed to other sources that reveal that Judy Mikovits is far more out-there than even the 26-minute video I deconstructed shows. So I thought it would be worth it to do a follow-up post to discuss Mikovits’ conspiracy theories a bit more, because, believe it or not, there’s more there to unpack.
More on Dr. Mikovits’ Anthony Fauci conspiracy theory
The first place I will visit is the website of the organization founded by the person who wrote the foreword to Mikovits’ book that she was promoting in Plandemic, Plague of Corruption: Restoring Faith in the Promise of Science, namely Children’s Health Defense, the antivaccine organization founded by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., a man well-familiar to regular readers of this blog. As an aside, at this point I can’t resist mentioning how many comments on Twitter and after the first version of the post over at my not-so-secret other blog took me to task for referring to Judy Mikovits (and RFK Jr.) as an antivaxxer, retorting that Mikovits and RFK Jr. have both said that they are not antivaccine. I must say, these people must think that the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea is a democracy. I mean, seriously. RFK Jr. is a man who’s compared the vaccination program to the Holocaust not just once but at least three times that I know of and blames vaccines for making the current generation of American’s youth the “sickest generation” (they’re not) while Mikovits has been a feature on the antivaccine circuit, including the yearly antivaccine quackfest known as Autism One, since 2010 at least. Not only that, but the co-author of her book is Kent Heckenlively, one of the more radical antivaxxers out there, a man who fantasizes about a tribunal to force people like Bill Gates and other high profile promoters of vaccination programs, to “confess” their “crimes,” saying, “I will accept your unconditional surrender”. (I politely declined.) The point is, of course, that antivaxxers almost always deny that they are antivaccine, so much so that I almost have more respect for the antivaxxers who proudly admit that they are antivaccine. At least they’re being honest with themselves and others.
In any event, RFK Jr. has been promoting Mikovits’ book since it was released last month. In one of the posts on the Children’s Health Defense website, Mikovits elaborates on her accusations against Anthony Fauci. As I said last time, I almost have to give her credit for clever opportunism. Yoking her story to the “Fire Fauci” political movement was a stroke of genius, at least strictly from the point of view of self-promotion. Sadly, it worked, as her book shot to number one on the Amazon sales charts. In any event, here is a video that one might view as a precursor to the segment in Plandemic in which Mikovits accuses Fauci of all sorts of horrible things:
The video starts out doing just what the Plandemic video did, pumping up Dr. Mikovits as an authority by listing her degrees and work history, finishing by listing her as a “target of Dr. Anthony Fauci”. Dr. Fauci, of course, has been the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) since 1984 and has emerged as a key figure in the federal response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Given that he is one of the federal officials trying to keep the federal response as science-based as possible, he has been the target of conspiracy theories and political attacks, of which this is yet another one. The video goes on to accuse Fauci thusly:
In Washington DC Fauci’s tactics are an open secret. Intimidation. Bullying. And reckless disregard for the health and safety of the American people.
Dr. Judy Mikovits was one of the most skilled scientists of her generation. She had a 20-year collaboration with Frank Ruscetti, a pioneer in the field of human retro virology.
Seeing an antivaccine organization accuse anyone of a “reckless disregard for the health and safety of the American people” fried yet another one of my irony meters. Once again, we see the claim that Mikovits is “one of the most skilled scientists of her generation”. As I said last time when I discussed her, I’ve been unable to find anything to support this characterization of Mikovits. It’s also rather odd to refer to a 20-year collaboration with Dr. Ruscetti. While it’s true that Mikovits worked in Ruscetti’s laboratory at the NIH for most of a 21 year period (1980 to 2001), the first several of those years she only had a bachelor’s degree and worked as a technician, for four or five years she was a graduate student, and the remaining years were spent as, in essence, a postdoctoral fellow in Ruscetti’s laboratory. This was not a collaboration of equals. Mikovits was always Ruscetti’s subordinate, at least while she was at the NIH, although the two did collaborate from 2006-2009, the time period when Mikovits was director of the Whittemore Peterson Institute for Neuro-Immune Disease and doing the later-retracted research reporting that a retrovirus (XMRV) was associated with and might cause chronic fatigue syndrome. (I can’t help but wonder what Ruscetti thinks now of his protégé.) It’s also frequently claimed that her PhD thesis revolutionized the treatment of HIV/AIDS, saving millions of lives. I’ve yet to be able to find evidence that this claim is true, either.
In this video, Mikovits repeats the same accusation she made in Plandemic:
Mikovits: When Frank Ruscetti was out of town, I received a call from Dr. Fauci and he demanded that I give him our manuscript on the isolation and confirmation of HIV, while it was still in press. I refused to do that because it’s unethical. These manuscripts are confidential and only authors can give him a copy.
Mikovits: He threatened to fire me for insubordination but still I refused. It’s unethical.
Mikovits: When Frank Ruscetti returned a few weeks later, he gave the manuscript to Dr. Fauci, and Dr. Fauci purposely delayed the publication of our manuscript in order that his crony, Dr. Robert Gallo, could copy our work and submit a competing manuscript and get it into press before ours.
I described in detail why this story doesn’t pass the smell test and is most likely utter BS, given that when this happened Mikovits was a technician in Ruscetti’s laboratory and at most out of college only three or four years. At most.
There’s more, though, which is why I’m discussing this video. Here’s more of the annotated transcript:
Mikovits: In 2006 I co-founded and developed the first neuroimmune disease institute to study the cause and treatments of chronic fatigue syndrome.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome became epidemic in the 1980s. Doctors dismissed the ailment as psychosomatic “yuppie flu.” CFS primarily struck women. The medical community assumed they were physically and emotionally fragile and cracked under the pressure of corporate jobs.
Dr. Mikovits discovered that 67% of women affected with CFS carried a mouse virus–called XMRV– Xenotropic Murine Leukemia related Virus–that appeared in healthy women only 4% of the time. XMRV is also associated with cancers like prostate, breast, ovarian, leukemia, and multiple myeloma. Many women with XMRV go on to have children with autism.
Of course, one notes that no one was able to replicate this finding and that, ultimately, Mikovits’ results were spurious and almost certainly due to contamination. Children’s Health Defense also conveniently fails to note how Mikovits treated the chronic fatigue syndrome patient-derived cells, but not control cells, with a chemical that activated their retroviruses.
Next:
Mikovits: Then in 2011, our research strongly suggested that it entered the human virome through a contaminated blood supply and vaccines.
Other researchers linked the first CFS outbreak to a polio vaccine given to doctors and nurses that resulted in the “1934 Los Angeles County Hospital Epidemic.” That vaccine was cultivated on pulverized mouse brains. Retroviruses from dead animals can survive in cell lines and permanently contaminate vaccines.
XMRV is so hazardous that the mere presence of mouse tissue in a laboratory can contaminate other tissues in the same room.
That last line cracked me up, because the reference cited basically ends up with a mea culpa admitting that the finding of XMRV in blood samples from patients with chronic fatigue syndrome was the result of laboratory contamination. As for the supposed “first outbreak” of CFS due to a polio vaccine, the reference linked to is discussing epidemic myalgic encephalitis, an alternate name for chronic fatigue syndrome. While it’s true that there have been outbreaks of CFS associated with viral illnesses, including polio, none of this demonstrates that retroviruses cause the syndrome, much less that vaccines containing retroviruses do. I can’t help but note that there are no studies cited to support her claims, not even her own.
Unsurprisingly, this “brave maverick doctor” was going to sound the alarm, but claims to have been stifled by Anthony Fauci:
Mikovits: We recognized that this mouse retrovirus was causing an alarming national health crisis. That is if the blood supply and vaccines were heavily contaminated with mouse retroviruses of many strains.
As Dr. Mikovits and her team prepared to sound the alarm, Dr. Fauci used his power to silence her.
Mikovits: What Tony Fauci, Ian Lipkin and Harold Varmus did was pressure me to be silent and withdraw our manuscript. I refused again.
Anthony Fauci gave his own career and the vaccine program priority above the health and safety of all Americans.
Mikovits: When I refused to be silent, Dr. Fauci stepped in and ordered that my computers and notebooks be confiscated and orchestrated the retraction of our Science paper.
Dr. Fauci abused his power and misused his office.
Mikovits: He then removed all of my funding and prevented me from getting a job in government research from 2012 forward.
Hundreds of millions of Americans may have received vaccines contaminated with XMRV.
Anthony Fauci has failed us.
Are you prepared to trust him?
Yes, because Mikovits is a crank. Let’s unpack these claims a bit. Her conspiracy theory has evolved in a convenient manner to include Dr. Anthony Fauci. What is she talking about? I don’t know for sure, but I can make an educated guess. What tipped me off is the claim that Fauci “removed all my funding”. There’s a tool that those of us who apply for government research grants know about called NIH RePORTER. It’s a searchable database of all government grants. Entering Mikovits’ name into the database easily found every NIH grant she had ever had, the relevant one being “New Strategies to Decipher the Pathophysiology of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome“, with the grant organization being the Nevada Center for Biomedical Research, which was where the Whittemore Peterson Institute was housed. This was an R01 grant whose start date was September 1, 2010, which implied to me that it was based, at least in part, on preliminary data that resulted in Mikovits’ 2009 Science paper. This grant, unsurprisingly given that it was examining possible viral causes of chronic fatigue syndrome, was through the NIAID, the Institute Dr. Fauci leads.
Notably, Dr. Mikovits is listed as principal investigator of this grant for only two years, but the grant is for five years. For years three through five, someone named Vincent Lombardi is listed as the principal investigator. So what happened? If you know the story, it’s obvious. Mikovits was fired from the WPI in September 2011, which would have been during year two of the grant. At this point, it’s necessary to understand that NIH grants go to institutions, not people. While it’s true that there is a “gentleman’s agreement” among universities in which universities generally agree to let NIH grants follow a researcher to a new institution if she switches jobs, that agreement doesn’t apply if a researcher is fired for cause. In that case, the institution will assign the grant to a new investigator to serve as PI for the remainder of the grant period. That’s almost certainly what happened here, no intervention from the NIAID, much less Dr. Fauci himself, necessary. In fact, it’s highly unlikely that Fauci even knew about it, as this sort of reassignment is handled at a much lower level than Institute director.
What about Mikovits’ last claim, that Fauci prevented her from getting a job in government research from 2012 onward? That claim is just silly. Fauci doesn’t have that power. The reason Mikovits couldn’t get a job in research after that is most likely because she had had a major paper retracted, had been fired from her previous job and prosecuted for having stolen research notebooks and flash drives with research data from her former employer. Even though she was not convicted, she did lose a civil suit over the theft. In other words, what university, government agency, or even private company would want to hire someone with such a record, especially someone who had started to rise to prominence in the antivaccine movement?
Mikovits jumped on the COVID-19 conspiracy theory bandwagon early
One thing I didn’t realize is just how early and enthusiastically Mikovits had jumped on the COVID-19 bandwagon. As I searched around, I found this podcast interview on the Autism One website. In it, she starts right out comparing COVID-19 to AIDS in that, according to her, leaders were lying about how it was transmitted, and how it originated. She repeated the conspiracy theory that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, came from the now-infamous research laboratory in Wuhan, China, going on and on about how “convenient” it is that there were already test kits and candidate vaccines for the coronavirus. To her it doesn’t matter if the virus was engineered or not, just that to her it obviously came from that lab, not the Wuhan fish market commonly attributed.
It’s not long before she gets back to retroviruses, going on a rant about how supposedly thirty million Americans have been infected with XMRV through “contamination” of vaccines and blood products. I must grudgingly admit that Mikovits is clever. She’s taken the finding that her detection of XMRV in cells taken from the blood of CFS patients was a laboratory contaminant and cleverly pivoted to say that it’s such a common contaminant that it’s in vaccines as well and responsible for all the health conditions for which antivaxxers blame vaccines.
Of course, to her it’s all a big scam, a deception, for the CDC to cover up its “plague of corruption” over XMRV-contaminated vaccines. Basically, she claims that the CDC his hyping coronavirus as a threat, as it hyped Ebola and H1N1 before it, to distract the public from all the health problems caused (she says) by “contaminated vaccines” and, of course, to pave the way towards forced vaccination. I’m not kidding when I characterize her interview as a “rant”. Just listen for yourself if you don’t believe me. To her, the coronavirus is part of a worldwide cover-up:
Yes, they’ve unleashed a virus that can be dangerous to some people. There’s no doubt about it. There’s a coronavirus, but those coronaviruses are always out there. God only knows when this virus hit the population. They just needed a cover-up of the December 2019 revelation caught on tape at the WHO International Summit on Vaccine Safety, where the CDC, the WHO, the FDA officials all admitted no safety testing at all on vaccines, any of them, in the 21st century schedule, in the schedule that they’re taking away human rights, taking away our ability to go to school. It’s severely injuring our children, causing death, destroying families’ lives, and nobody’s paying for it, except for the victims of the plague of corruption. Isn’t funny that the doctor at this Chinese facility is dead? He didn’t die of coronavirus. They killed him!
Indeed, it’s hard to keep up with all the conspiracies, although it is easy to point out that, no, WHO, CDC, and FDA scientists did not “admit” that there was no vaccine safety testing for any of the vaccines on the current schedule. They just didn’t. Seriously, though, I wonder if Plandemic would have gone as viral as it did if Mikki Willis hadn’t judiciously edited the really wild stuff that Mikovits routinely says out of the video and kept her much calmer than she is in this interview, where she’s ranting her way into full tinfoil hat conspiracy territory, repeating the phrase “plague of corruption” many times.
Back in February, she was planning on meeting the VAXXED bus in San Diego and had apparently latched onto Gardasil as her preferred vaccine to rail against. Particularly amusing is the part where she complains about not being allowed to be an expert witness in Vaccine Court any more. To my mind, the only bizarre aspect of Mikovits’ experience with Vaccine Court is that she was ever accepted as an expert witness in the first place. As I listened to her rant about how all the smoking and air pollution were more contributory to deaths from coronavirus in Wuhan in January than the virus itself, as she claimed that the virus was never isolated from sick people. Truly, she was a head of the curve when it comes to coronavirus conspiracy theories. Indeed, she’s exhausting to listen to, and, I must confess, I didn’t make it through the entire hour of her interview.
Tinfoil hat conspiracy theories, made palatable
One major reason why the Plandemic video could go viral is that it’s slickly produced. A professional filmmaker, Mikki Willis, took a woman whose media appearances tend to devolve into really wild conspiracy theories and toned her down to make her sound reasonable and appear authoritative. He sanded the rough edges off and, above all, edited out the really nutty stuff, leaving a lot of stuff that was out there but at least had the patina of plausibility if you didn’t look too deep. If Plandemic had featured Mikovits ranting about how the Chinese doctor who raised the alarm on the pandemic and died of coronavirus was actually murdered by the Chinese government and how coronavirus is a distraction take people’s attention away from the “revelation” that the WHO and CDC “admitted” that there’s no vaccine safety testing, my guess is that it wouldn’t have gone viral in the way that it did.
Tara Haelle wrote a very good explanation of why the video was so effective and compelling to so many people:
The people producing this video know what they’re doing, and they’re very good at it. On a subconscious level, no matter what words are being said, this video feels factual simply because of how it was produced. It’s intentionally manipulative. It’s a textbook example of effective propaganda. (That’s the line. Next is the sinker.)
This video successfully employs “pathos” and “ethos” to persuade people
Aristotle introduced a concept over two thousand years ago that remains more relevant than ever: modes of persuasion, or rhetorical appeals. The three main appeals speakers can use to persuade others are ethos, pathos and logos.
Ethos is an appeal to the authority and credibility of the speaker. As Haelle notes, the first 8-10 minutes of the video is designed to get the audience to trust Mikovits as an authority, to present her as an honest expert, a scientist persecuted for telling the truth over the objection of powerful forces. Never mind that it’s not true, that she did terrible science and likely falsified data. First impressions are important and hard to overcome, even with factual disconfirming evidence.
Even more important to persuasion is pathos:
Pathos is an appeal to emotion. The video appeals to viewers’ emotions by portraying Mikovits as a victimized underdog and by repeatedly using stock video of harrowing images, such as patients dying from AIDS and malnourished children in Africa. The video claims people are dying because they cannot get the appropriate treatments they need, appealing to viewers’ sense of injustice. The video even uses stock images of a SWAT team arrest to make it look like she was arrested at home in a major operation—but that’s unrelated stock footage. In fact, Mikovits turned herself in without incident.
Logos is an appeal to facts and logic. Of course, what the film does is appeal to misinformation that sounds plausible and then barrels headlong into a Gish gallop:
Instead of reasoned arguments with supportive evidence, the film uses a common debating strategy called the Gish gallop. This technique overwhelms the audience with so many assertions and arguments at one time, without regard to how strong or true they are, that it’s impossible to keep up with them or refute them all. It’s usually pointless to try because it’s the nonstop bombardment of statements coming at you that makes it effective. (This is partly why debunking this video isn’t a productive use of time.)
Here’s where I disagree, and, to be honest, Haelle appears to be giving mixed messages, saying that debunking the video isn’t a productive use of time but then referring to several comprehensive takedowns and fact checkings, mine included, at the end of her article. Personally, I think it’s highly useful to point out the specific lies, misinterpretations of data, and things left out that would have provided context, but I think I get where Haelle’s coming from in that she seems to mean that it’s not really a productive use of time for the average person seeing Plandemic posted on social media by a friend to get into a lot of the specifics of why it’s deceptive.
In any event, if there’s one thing Plandemic teaches us, it’s that in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic misinformation and disinformation have been supercharged because people are scared, angry, and hungry for information that will alleviate their fear. Conspiracy theories serve that purpose, and the ease with which this Gish galloping misinformation-packed video went viral should concern us all. After all, this video’s going viral was not an accident. It was planned.

Heritage Covid Commission Wants China Accountable… What About Trump?
The Heritage Foundation’s COVID-19 Commission Calls for Chinese “Accountability” for US Pandemic Damage
Allison Neitzel on July 14, 2024
Link

On July 8, The Heritage Foundation released a report from their own ‘Non-Partisan Commission on China and COVID-19’ and held an event bearing the same name as the report’s title: “Holding China Accountable for Its Role in the Most Catastrophic Pandemic of Our Time: COVID-19.” This commission, from the organization behind Trump’s Project 2025, lays out recommendations for legal and policy strategies for the White House and Congress to take against China.
.@JohnRatcliffe and the @Heritage Nonpartisan Commission on China and COVID-19 have built a blueprint to hold China accountable for Covid-19.Read the commission's recommendations 👉 https://t.co/VWupKcOud3 pic.twitter.com/VS6SiMWL85
— Heritage Foundation (@Heritage) July 9, 2024
Doubling down
I previously discussed Heritage’s “Road Map for COVID-19 Congressional Oversight” that the decidedly partisan House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic (HSSCP) appears to be following. It embraces Trump’s “censored” herd immunity-pushing doctors and promotes the evidence-lacking lab leak origin theory. Unsurprisingly, this new Heritage report doubles down on the lab leak as part of their arguments to hold China accountable for U.S. pandemic damage.
HSSCP Chairman Rep. Brad Wenstrup (R-OH) gave introductory remarks at the July 8 event hosted by Heritage president Kevin Roberts. Also featured were:
    • John L. Ratcliffe, a former Republican Congressman, the Director of National Intelligence under Trump, and a Heritage visiting fellow
    • David Feith, an adjunct senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security and former Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs in the U.S. Department of State
    • Jamie Metzel, founder of OneShared.World who served on the U.S. National Security Council and in the State Department in the Clinton administration
    • Dr. Robert Redfield, the Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) under Trump
Metzel and Redfield have both promoted the lab leak theory and testified before the HSSCP during a March 2023 hearing on COVID-19 origins as guests of the Republican subcommittee majority.
Who are these people?
Redfield, a controversial figure from the HIV crisis, has been sharply criticized for his CDC’s handling of the pandemic outbreak. Under his leadership, the CDC rejected the World Health Organization’s COVID-19 test in favor of creating a more complicated one, which faltered and wasted crucial early weeks in the U.S. response.
Later, the public messaging of Redfield’s CDC was commandeered by the Trump administration. An October 2022 report from the HSSCP’s Democrat-led predecessor, the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis (HSSCC), detailed the unprecedented political control exerted over their gold-standard Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Reports during a time of crisis. While Redfield broke with Trump over the importance of masks, he was largely seen as submissive to the then-president.
Another controversial COVID-19 character from the former president’s administration, Dr. Robert Kadlec, who served as Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response in the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) under Trump, is listed as a “commissioner” of the new Heritage report. Going into the pandemic, Air Force veteran Kadlec was said to have been more focused on bioweapons than his public health-focused Obama era predecessor Dr. Nicole Lurie.
In May 2020, Dr. Rick Bright, who Kadlec had removed from his position as head of the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority the previous month, filed a whistleblower complaint against Kadlec and the HHS (settled the following year) and testified before Congress about the lack of leadership and plan within the pandemic response.
Trump’s Big HCQ Lie
Bright claimed he was ousted over his raising concerns about the Trump administration’s embrace of the anti-malarial drug hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) as a COVID-19 cure and their desire to make it publicly available outside of clinical trials. Trump’s promotion of HCQ as a “game changer” forced his chief medical advisor Dr. Anthony Fauci to publicly counter the president, damaging their working relationship. HCQ would prove ineffective against the virus in a major trial by early June 2020.
An August 2022 HSSCC report details Trump insiders’ behind-the-scenes “knife fight” with the Food and Drug Administration over HCQ and their relentless (but ultimately failed) attempts to get its COVID-19 emergency use authorization reapproved after it had already proven ineffective. At the same time, a group of right-wing physicians, America’s Frontline Doctors (AFLDS), was brought together in coordination with the Trump 2020 reelection campaign to publicly push the MAGA-endorsed, scientifically disproven pandemic miracle drug and instill faith in reopening the U.S. economy before a vaccine was available.
Pot, meet Kettle
Troublingly, Heritage continues to uphold Trump’s Big HCQ Lie. Pharmacist and Heritage fellow David Gortler testified before the HSSCP in March, stating that those who prescribed HCQ or its follow-up GOP “cure” ivermectin were correct to do so. They were not, and Heritage and the HSSCP have been working to protect Trump and the GOP by distracting from pandemic leadership failures and gaslighting the public.
“To the countries, physicians, & pharmacists who prescribed ivermectin or hydroxychloroquine…you were right.” – Dr. David GortlerWe’ll never forget those who gaslit Americans about COVID treatments and tried to force Americans to take the vaccine. pic.twitter.com/UJInVqdSdb
— Heritage Foundation (@Heritage) July 10, 2024
The new Heritage report opens by quantifying the U.S. pandemic damage, citing the 1.1 million American death toll and their calculation of $18 trillion in economic losses. While the report “does not rule out that many other governments, institutions, and individuals may have played contributing roles in the pandemic,” it asserts that “China has been in a league uniquely of its own in its active and aggressive opposition to honesty, transparency, and accountability regarding the virus and its spread.”
The seriousness with which the Heritage report takes the damage wrought by COVID-19 must be contrasted with the actions of public health-antagonizing and publicly non-transparent Trump during the early days of the pandemic. Despite privately confiding in journalist Bob Woodward that COVID-19 was “deadly stuff” in early February 2020, Trump tweeted that the situation was “very much under control in the USA” and referred to the virus as the Democrats’ “new hoax” during a rally later that month.
The Coronavirus is very much under control in the USA. We are in contact with everyone and all relevant countries. CDC & World Health have been working hard and very smart. Stock Market starting to look very good to me!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) February 24, 2020
Casualties of politics
As Fauci recently recounted, the former president – who was focused on his 2020 re-election campaign and desperate for the pandemic to disappear – went from embracing HCQ as a pandemic quick fix to bringing in contrarian advisors like Dr. Scott Atlas who told him what he wanted to hear, science be damned.
Heritage’s “Road Map” highlights Great Barrington Declaration authors turned HSSCP “experts” Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff, who are subjects of a June 2022 HSSCC report on their “dangerous and discredited herd immunity via mass infection strategy”, insinuated themselves into the Trump White House with Atlas. Their work was done behind the back of White House Coronavirus Response Coordinator Dr. Deborah Birx, who testified to the HSSCC in 2022 that Atlas’s presence “destroyed any cohesion in the response in the White House itself.”
Birx stated that failure to deliver “concise, consistent communication about the seriousness of the pandemic resulted in inaction early on across our agencies” and “created a false sense of security in America.” She claimed this federal mismanagement led to 130,000 preventable COVID-19 deaths before the vaccines were available.
The GOP – and groups like AFLDS – would wage war on the life-saving vaccines, creating massive public confusion leading to 232,000 preventable unvaccinated COVID-19 deaths during the delta and initial omicron waves and an increased death rate among Republican voters compared to their Democrat counterparts by 2022.
Look! Over there!
While the Heritage report claims to “lay the groundwork for holding accountable those whose negligence or overt actions exacerbated the pandemic’s severity,” this only extends to China. Through their HSSCP “Road Map,” Heritage has laid the groundwork for Trump and the MAGA GOP’s evasion of accountability for lack of leadership and exacerbation of the pandemic’s severity in the U.S. While the commission has wrangled some individuals with Democrat pedigrees in order to call themselves “non-partisan,” this report must be viewed in the context of Heritage’s other work.
There is agreement throughout the scientific community and across the political aisle that China has not been forthcoming with information regarding the COVID-19 outbreak. There should be calls for accountability for this, but not in the absence of calls for accountability for our nation’s own failures in 2020. China is not responsible for Trump’s dereliction of duty.
All over the World the CoronaVirus, a very bad “gift” from China, marches on. Not good!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) May 28, 2020
There must be an understanding that China’s lack of cooperation and transparency in investigating how COVID-19 came to upend global life does not make it any more likely that the virus emerged from a lab leak at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The consensus amongst the majority of virologists is still that the COVID-19 pandemic most likely occurred as a result of animal spillover, as has been the case in previous pandemics.
Bring in the scapegoat
But the lab leak narrative generates emotion and buzz. And, in addition to distracting from Trump’s failures, it has had the added benefit of being a narrative the HSSCP could weaponize against MAGA Public Enemy #1 – former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Anthony Fauci — via questions regarding US funding of viral research in Wuhan. Thus far,however, the HSSCP’s attempts to smear Fauci with this have fallen flat and garnered the now retired doctor support from both Democrats and the public
The same cannot be said for Peter Daszak. As the president of EcoHealth Alliance – an organization that conducts federally-funded global research into viruses, which has included work at the WIV – Daszak has been the target of a years-long unfounded attack originating under Trump, who was quick to push the lab leak narrative. Most recently, this has seen Daszak dragged before the HSSCP and debarred from funding, putting the organization’s future at risk.
EcoHealth has a decades-long track record of important work researching viral epidemics and attempting to predict and thwart viruses that pose a risk to human life. This must be understood as a form of international security. Shutting them down for a short-sighted political strategy or a geo-political agenda only harms us.
What’s to be done?
In the calls for accountability for the Trump administration’s mishandling of the pandemic outbreak and MAGA’s subsequent vengeful war on science, we must include the atrocious treatment of our own scientists over the last few years. And we must not let the deeply politically compromised Heritage Foundation drive this discussion on pandemic accountability.

Was New York’s Spring 2020 COVID Wave an Illusion?
Asking for “evidence” that New York City got hit hard by COVID makes as much sense as asking for “evidence” that New York City exists in the first place.
Jonathan Howard on November 18, 2022
Link

The headlines from the start of the pandemic were horrific. “Shocking Video Shows The Bodies Of NYC Coronavirus Victims Being Forklifted Into A Refrigerated Truck Used As A Temporary Morgue” said one. “Bodies Of 750 Covid-19 Victims In New York City Remain In Refrigerated Trucks“, said another. There are many videos and photos documenting all this. Prisoners were asked to dig graves. Children who lost their parents described their loss. Myself and many countless healthcare workers wrote about what we witnessed. War analogies were common. One traveling nurse, who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, estimated that he saw 3,000 people die of COVID, saying “War doesn’t even compare to this…I would rather die, any other way of dying, than dying with coronavirus”. A doctor at Elmhurst Hospital in Queens said:
If you watch a war movie to see people shooting from all over, that’s what this almost felt like. One thing after the next after next, you can’t even catch up with what has to happen.
Many healthcare workers contracted COVID themselves, and not all of them survived, including friends of mine. This plaque now sits outside Bellevue Hospital to memorialize workers there who died during that first wave.
I say this all to make an important but simple point. You don’t need hard data to know that COVID hit New York City badly in the spring of 2020. Of course, variations of this would soon play out around the world. New York City was hit hard and early, but our experience didn’t turn out to be that much of an outlier, sadly. Hospitals continued to be deluged even after vaccines were available.
However, clever internet sleuths, safe on their couches, claim to have discovered something remarkable: None of this really happened. Myself and many thousands of others are said to have hallucinated or even caused the entire thing. I am referring to an article by Dr. Jessica Hockett, an educational psychologist, titled “More Questions about Spring 2020 Covid in New York City Hospitals“, which was recently posted at the anti-vaccine site, The Brownstone Institute. It claimed that “New York City’s hospital emergency departments were not at a breaking point in spring 2020. In fact, they were relatively empty and saw a 50% drop in visits”. This startling conclusion was based on five “observations”:
     1.  NYC Emergency Departments weren’t overrun by people with COVID-19 (this is false).
     2.  NYC Emergency Room respiratory visit spike may have been panic-driven (this is false).
     3.  Most people who visited NYC emergency rooms between March 2020 and June 2021 for respiratory symptoms were not admitted to the hospital (many were admitted to the hospital).
     4.  Many patients counted as COVID hospitalizations in spring 2020 were not admitted with COVID-like illness (CLI; this is false).
     5.  The relationship between hospital inpatient deaths with COVID on the death certificate and people who were hospitalized because they had COVID is unclear (this is false).
The article (falsely) concluded that doctors may have been deadlier than the virus. It said:
It’s no wonder Michael Senger, Ethical Skeptic, and other analysts (including me) have said it was misuse of ventilators, protocol-induced staffing shortages, isolation, failure to treat, similar factors that resulted in thousands of Spring 2020 iatrogenic deaths in New York City and elsewhere.
Dr. Eric Burnett, an internist at Columbia University, deconstructed Ms. Hockett’s five “observations” on Twitter. It’s worth quoting his entire thread [Editor’s note: minor changes were made for readability and clarity].
This is absolute rubbish, coming from a non-clinician who never once treated a patient, let alone treated patients in the epicenter of a global pandemic. So allow me, a NYC hospitalist, to break apart this “analysis”. A brief look at this “analysis” shows that she relied heavily upon medical billing codes during the pandemic. This is not an accurate reflection of what we were actually seeing in the hospital as I will get to later. But let me address each of her claims one by one.

Her first claim: “NYC Emergency Departments weren’t overrun by people with covid-19.”
This is objectively false. Our ERs were over capacity for weeks during the initial surge. We had critically ill, ICU level patients intubated and vented in our ED, this hasn’t happened before. She backs this claim up by saying “Only 3% of the people who came to New York City hospital EDs during the spring 2020 March [were diagnosed – Ed.]” this is because we had little to no testing in March of 2020! The testing we did have was reserved for people who traveled from mainland China.
When we secured a test it took a week to get back bc there was only one lab that ran the PCR. We had to test patients for Flu and other resp viruses. When those were neg we gave them a presumed dx ofC19 (along with the clinical presentation supporting the diagnosis).
Saying our EDs weren’t overrun bc you didn’t see a lot of lab confirmed C19 at that time is ridiculous. On a personal note, we lost an ED physician to suicide bc of the sheer amount of devastation she bore witness to. It’s extremely disrespectful to suggest a this.

Claim number 2: NYC Emergency Room respiratory visit spike may have been panic-driven.
She backs this claim up by saying “But most emergency room visitors with respiratory symptoms were not diagnosed with covid. Huh.” I’ll refer you to my point about lack of testing above.
The amount of pts p/w acute hypoxemic respiratory failure was so great we had to train non pulm faculty on how to manage vents, HFNC, and BiPAP. We had ethics meetings about the possibility of scarce resource allocation should we run out of ventilators. This is not a normal.

Point 3: Most people who visited NYC emergency rooms between March 2020 and June 2021 for respiratory symptoms were not admitted to the hospital
We literally had to convert non-clinical spaces like our lobby into patient care units.
We had to convert a football field into a patient ward. We needed to expand hospital capacity in the state by 50% to accommodate admissions. Our traditional hospitalist census is around 100-110 patients, that ballooned to 250 during the worst of the surge. save me this excuse.
She backs this up by saying “Peak hospital admissions for covid-like illness (CLI) were 40% of respiratory emergency department visits”
We didn’t admit everyone with a respiratory illness. If they weren’t hypoxic then they didn’t get admitted.
That’s because our hospitals were over capacity and we couldn’t admit every single person with resp symptoms. It’s called triage, you should look it up. Only the sickest covid patients were admitted to the hospital.

Claim 4: Many patients counted as covid hospitalizations in spring 2020 were not admitted with covid-like illness (CLI). Data indicate that approximately 40% of inpatients with a covid diagnosis[…]from mid-March through April 2020 had not been admitted with covid-like illness.
This is what happens when you rely solely upon medical billing codes rather than talking to actual HCW. NYS issued immunity from record keeping liability during the worst of the pandemic. Medical coding [didn’t] accurately reflect the reality.
re medical record keeping liability:“Including, but not limited to, requirements to maintain medical records that accurately reflect the evaluation and treatment of patients, or requirement to assign diagnostic codes, or to create or maintain other records for billing purposes.”
When a patient came in with covid we documented it, but didn’t always list every other symptom they had. Medical billing and coding took a backseat to admitting and treating our patients, running codes, updating families, and trying to keep our patients alive.

Claim 5: The relationship between hospital inpatient deaths with covid on the death certificate and people who were hospitalized because they had covid is unclear.
This is also ridiculous. There is clear evidence of a spike in deaths during the peak of the pandemic. We needed morgue trucks to accommodate the overflow of dead patients as a result of this disease.
She attributes these deaths to iatrogenic causes without a shred of evidence to back it up. It’s clear she’s never taken care of a critically Ill covid patient. My guess is she never had to call a family member and tell them that their loved one died despite our best efforts.
She doesn’t have to live with the pain of making those calls. She never laid in bed awake at night worrying if her patients were still going to be there in the morning.
This is pure gaslighting at a time when healthcare workers are burnt out and leaving the profession in record numbers. If Jessica would like to join me on rounds this fall/winter during our respiratory virus surge I would be happy to accommodate her.
Something tells me Ms. Hockett will decline this invitation.
However, we again have the opportunity to witness a pernicious medical myth being created in real time. Despite abundant evidence to the contrary, sheltered disinformation agents will successfully convince many Americans that COVID’s threat was always overblown. Their message can be summarized as: Don’t believe the newspapers. Don’t believe the videos or photographs. Don’t believe the official death statistics. Don’t believe thousands of healthcare workers. Don’t believe gravediggers. Don’t believe those who lost multiple family members. We told you COVID wouldn’t be that bad in the spring of 2020, and we were right. Frontline doctors were always to blame.
Asking for “evidence” that New York City got hit hard by COVID makes as much sense as asking for “evidence” that New York City exists in the first place. George Orwell understood this all very well.

EcoHealth Alliance Fights Back
The organization scapegoated by the lab leak-promoting GOP-led House Covid subcommittee publishes its defense
Allison Neitzel on October 31, 2024
Link

As I have recently discussed, the evidence-lacking COVID-19 lab leak origin theory has been part of a right-wing partisan effort pushed by the GOP-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic (HSSCP), the Heritage Foundation, and established pandemic political bad actors. Recommendations on lab leak talking points were featured in the April 2020 “Corona Big Book” published for Republicans by the strategic communications firm O’Donnell & Associates. Around this time, Trump began pushing the theory and has repeated it on the campaign trail as recently as a few weeks ago.
This attention-grabbing narrative has stoked mistrust in science and distracted from the Trump administration’s horrendous mismanagement of the pandemic outbreak. EcoHealth Alliance, an organization that conducts federally funded virology research which has included work at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, has been made the scapegoat and erroneously accused of being responsible for the deadly pandemic – amid MAGA’s all-out war on science.
The quest for a villain
In May, EcoHealth president Peter Daszak was dragged before the GOP-led HSSCP (full transcript here) and received a concerning lack of support from Democrat subcommittee members, despite saying in his opening statement, “Our organization, staff, and even my own family were often targeted with false allegations, death threats, break-ins, media harassment, and other damaging acts.” Daszak has frighteningly found himself, his wife, and children on a “kill list” on 4chan.
The HSSCP did not have evidence to substantiate their lab leak claims – and they certainly did not have proof to show a coordinated cover up of a lab leak including the likes of Dr. Anthony Fauci, who Democratic subcommittee members were quicker to defend.
While the lab leak narrative dates back to the early days of the pandemic under the Trump administration, those who have pushed it have failed in the last 4+ years to provide proof needed to make such extreme accusations. Publications in favor of the lab leak have relied on a great deal of speculation and cherry-picking – yet this has been sufficient for the GOP and complicit media to run with in their quest for a villain figure.
How low can they go?
The sole point the GOP-led subcommittee had against EcoHealth involved a progress report that was filed late, which EcoHealth asserted was due not to negligence on the part of the organization but an issue with the National Institutes of Health’s (NIH) website. Regardless, barring a scientist from NIH funding for filing a late report may be unprecedented. Subjecting him to a congressional grilling for doing so seems bizarre in the extreme, especially given EcoHealth’s decades-long track record at the forefront of important ecological research.
Following the hearing, EcoHealth was recommended for debarment for future federal funding by the subcommittee. Shortly after, Health and Human Services (NIH’s parent organization) announced movement to debar EcoHealth, citing the work of the HSSCP. HSSCP chairman Rep. Brad Wenstrup (R-OH) made public comments about debarring Daszak personally – a display of how low the subcommittee was willing to stoop in their scapegoating – and the HHS obliged, filing a personal suspension and proposed a debarment notice to Daszak.
This drew strong criticism from members of the scientific community, including vaccine expert and disinformation fighter Dr. Peter Hotez, who has also found himself on the receiving end of harassment from the HSSCP.
EcoHealth responds to HSSCP accusations
At the May hearing, Daszak asserted the accusations made against both EcoHealth and him personally could and would be disproven. After months of work with lawyers – a process that was likely quite costly – EcoHealth has now published a 146-page response on its website, fighting back at the congressional and public smearing.
For years, EcoHealth Alliance (EHA) has received intense scrutiny from the federal government, culminating in a Congressional hearing on May 1, followed by a Suspension and Debarment notice issued by the Department of Health and Human Services. (1/3)
— EcoHealth Alliance (@EcoHealthNYC) September 24, 2024
This comes on the heels of the publication of a major paper in Cell on the genetic tracing of wildlife at the Wuhan wet market where the COVID-19 pandemic is believed to have emerged. While the paper did not reveal the exact mechanism of spillover, it showed the presence of animals and virus in the section of the wet market where most of the positive samples were collected.
One of the paper’s authors, virologist Dr. Angela Rasmussen explained the significance of their paper:
This is one more piece on top of a mountain of evidence supporting a zoonotic origin. We have the pandemic beginning at the same time as the virus began circulating at the market, we have the earliest known cases expanding outward from the market and not a lab, we have the samples within the market testing positive in the same place where live animals were sold, and now we have evidence that susceptible animals were actually there. These data can’t be explained in any kind of realistic laboratory or research-related scenario.
Dogs with a bone
Unfortunately, it is unlikely that the GOP and their allies will drop the narrative anytime soon. After all, the HSSCP has been propping up the authors of the anti-public health, pro-economy Great Barrington Declaration, which was never a viable strategy, and proponents of the failed COVID-19 early treatment drugs pushed by Trump and his allies.
Wrong. 

The entire body of evidence indicates that COVID-19 did not originate at a lab in China. It originated in nature & emerged into humans via the live animal trade at the Huanan Seafood Market.

“Deficiencies in @NIH’s oversight” refers to a progress report submitted late. https://t.co/xufr6WyJCn
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) October 25, 2024
Additionally, a recent and concerning Stanford conference hosting COVID-19 minimizing contrarians – some of whom have been majority expert witnesses at the HSSCP – featured a panel on the lab leak with individuals involved with the problematic organization Biosafety Now. The panel was moderated by a senior editor from the Epoch Times, a “global conservative multimedia company championing former President Donald Trump and conspiracy theories.” The Epoch Times has published numerous pieces targeting Daszak and EcoHealth Alliance.
As Rasmussen said,
In my opinion, my professional field owes EcoHealth our gratitude for their contributions to our scientific field. And from the people outside our field who have persecuted them relentlessly for political reasons, they are also owed an apology.


COVID-19 – The Second Wave
A second wave seems likely, but the evidence suggests our measures are working, and may even prevent a second wave.
Steven Novella on June 10, 2020
Link

As we are seeing the beginning of the end of the first wave of COVID-19, the burning question is – will there be a second wave? No one knows, and there are both reasons for hope and caution. One sobering fact – the last 14 flu pandemics all had a second wave or multiple waves. SARS-CoV-2 is not the flu, but it is a respiratory virus and spread may be similar. This may also be a function of the dynamics of pandemics more than the characteristics of a specific virus.
A 2013 study modeling the most recent flu pandemics also found they all had at least a second wave. However their models also found that if measures were taken to reduce the number of infections in the first wave, and to “flatten the curve”, this could prevent a second wave. The COVID-19 pandemic is unique in recent history due to the extreme lengths we have all gone to flatten the curve. Perhaps our efforts, if we sustain them long enough, will prevent a second wave. That’s quite an incentive.
Have those efforts actually worked? The evidence suggests the answer is a huge – yes. A recent study published in Nature found:
We estimate that across these six countries ( China, South Korea, Italy, Iran, France, and the United States), interventions prevented or delayed on the order of 62 million confirmed cases, corresponding to averting roughly 530 million total infections.
In the US that was over 5 million confirmed cases and 60 million total cases. How many deaths would this have translated into? That is still a hard figure to come by, and we won’t really know until the pandemic is over and we can review data. The case mortality ratio also varied widely among different countries. In the US at present the case mortality ratio for confirmed cases in 5.7%. If we take 5% of 5 million cases, that is an additional 250,000 deaths avoided by the lockdown.
A separate study looking only at Europe also published in Nature found that non-pharmacological measures of reducing infection prevented an additional 3.1 million deaths. We can also look at the data the other way – how many more lives could we have saved if the we locked down earlier? A study published in May found that if the US had locked down 1 week early, this would have saved 36,000 lives.
So flattening the curve by social distancing and other measures works. These measures save significant lives, and could have saved more if we had jumped on this pandemic sooner. These measures may even save us from a second wave, but that remains to be seen.
Let’s drill down a bit to what measures specifically work. David Gorski has already done an excellent job of reviewing the most recent evidence of the efficacy of wearing masks, so I won’t repeat that review. The bottom line is that wearing masks does help prevent spread, but needs to be done properly. I do want to emphasize an issue which seems to have caused confusion (based on what I encounter online and questions from my own patients). At one point the WHO recommended wearing masks if you are sick or exposed to those who are, but not necessarily if you are healthy and out in public. The CDC, on the other hand, recommended everyone wear a mask in public. The reason for the WHO’s caution on recommending everyone wear a mask was not because they don’t work, but because at the time the recommendation was made we were having a shortage. The thought was – if you are healthy and not around sick people, don’t take a mask away from a health care worker who is on the front lines. The WHO basically left it up to individual countries based on their needs and resources. In any case – wear an appropriate mask, do it properly, and do it consistently.
But masks are not a panacea. Hand washing is also critical. Do it thoroughly, do it often, and don’t touch your face with unwashed hands. Don’t touch any public surface if you don’t have to. Elbows are your friends.
And finally, social distancing is still essential, and the evidence shows that it works. But here also there are many details. Do we need three feet, six feet, or nine feet (1, 2, or 3 meters)? The greater the distance, the greater the efficacy, until you are completely out of droplet range. This is also where masks come into play, by reducing the spread of droplets. Not physically touching other people is now also the norm, and this is critical.
The question is now turning to this – for how long do we need to ban large gatherings? When do we open up restaurants, hair salons, non-essential stores, and other public places? When can we start having sporting events with fans, conferences, concerts, and conventions? The answer is – we don’t know, so we need to proceed one step at a time, measure the outcome, and go from there.
But we may be experiencing a spontaneous and unplanned natural experiment in the US. Protests over the killing of George Floyd have resulted in mass gatherings in cities around the country. Many (but not all) protesters are wearing masks, but social distancing is not being practiced. It is not my intention to debate the relative importance of the pandemic vs social justice – just to point out that we will likely discover in the next few weeks what is likely to happen when we relax social distancing.
Social distancing is also the measure that is taking the greatest toll on people mentally and economically. For example, patients in hospitals have had to go through their experience without the benefit of visitors, and family members cannot see their loved ones, even if they are dying. It can be painful, and even have a negative impact on outcomes. And of course everyone is anxious to open up the economy.
Which brings us back to the core question – will there be a second wave? The consensus seems to be – probably. We can hope that we will avoid it, but we need to be prepared for it. It is way too early to hope for a vaccine, which is at least six months away if not more. There are medications being studied, but no guarantees of a treatment at this point. The summer heat will also not automatically save us. We are a long way from herd immunity, with only a few percent of people being exposed to SARS-CoV-2 so far. This is still a new virus, and we are a naïve population.
        ◦ But at least now we know what works. We have prevented millions of cases and deaths with the non-pharmacological measures – masks, hand washing, and social distancing. We may prevent millions more, and may prevent or at least minimize a second or even multiple waves. We are partly buying time to develop a vaccine and effective medications. It’s working. We need to continue the fight, even as we start to open up. The COVID pandemic is a marathon, not a sprint.

The New SARS-CoV-2 Variants
Two new variants of the virus that causes COVID-19 have been detected that are more infectious. What are the implications?
Steven Novella on January 6, 2021
Link

Two new variants of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, have been detected and are spreading. The first is the Kent variant (B.1.1.7 strain), which emerged in the UK, and has already spread to many other countries including the US. It is also now the dominant strain in the UK, responsible for more than 50% of new cases. The second variant emerged in South Africa (E484K strain), and the BBC reports:
It is already the dominant virus variant in the Eastern and Western Cape provinces of South Africa. Other countries including Austria, Norway and Japan, have also found cases.
What are the implications of these new strains? Are they more infectious, or more deadly, and will the current vaccines work against them?
How do new variants emerge?
The emergence of new strains or variants of a virus occurs through natural mutations in the virus as it replicates. Different viruses mutate at different rates. The flu virus, for example, mutates rather quickly, with many infectious strains identified. Each flu season, in fact, new strains are likely to be circulating from the previous year. The coronavirus, however, has error-correction abilities that reduce the number of mutations while it replicates, and so it mutates much more slowly than the flu virus. It still mutates, however.
This is a significant long-term risk to allowing the pandemic to spread for as long as it has. The emergence of new variants is inevitable. In fact, there are thousands of strains of the virus circulating, and this is partly how scientists track the spread of the virus. Most mutations are inconsequential – they either don’t alter the amino acid sequence of proteins or any changes does not affect the overall structure and function of the protein. Occasional mutations may make structural changes to a viral protein without a dramatic effect on its properties.
But occasionally a mutation will change an important structural protein and alter the virus’s ability to infect hosts, to spread, or the severity of the illness they produce. This is always the worry, and why we don’t like to let epidemics or pandemics simmer for a long time. The more the virus replicates, the greater the opportunity for chance mutations that will give rise to a more serious strain.
The Kent variant
The new strain that arose in Kent in the UK was first detected on September 20th. Researchers were investigating a surge in COVID cases in Kent, and tracing variants to map the spread. They found the dominant variant had a cluster of 23 new mutations, which itself is unusual. Later study found that this variant is more infectious than previously identified variants. Eight of these mutations are on the infamous spike protein that gives the coronavirus family its name, and is what allows the virus to enter and infect cells.
Scientists are still trying to sort out the effect of these mutations, but so far it seems that the Kent variant has a greater ability to infect and to spread. Patients with this variant may remain infectious longer, and the virus seems to have a greater ability to infect cells. This is why this variant quickly dominates once it spreads to a region.
The good news, however, is that this variant does not appear to be more deadly. Also, it appears to be as vulnerable to neutralizing antibodies produced by the approved vaccines – so the vaccines will protect against this variant.
How this variant emerged is also still under investigation, but the current hypothesis is that chronically ill patients, with an active COVID infection for months, gave the virus an opportunity to accumulate multiple mutations. Specifically, patients with compromised immune systems provide fertile ground for the virus to replicate and mutate. Also, patients treated with partially effective treatments, that allowed them to survive for a long time but did not eradicate the infection, gave the virus the opportunity to mutate.
The South African variant
The second new variant of concern was first detected in South Africa, and is now also in other countries, with cases detected as far as the UK. This variant also has mutations on the spike protein, including some of the same mutations found in the Kent variant. These are almost certainly independent mutations, and not due to a common source. Because it has some of the same mutations, and ones specifically that confer greater infectivity, this variant is also more infectious and will tend to dominate once it spreads to a region.
However, the South Africa variant has a new property that is extremely concerning – the mutations to its spike protein allow it to partially evade antibodies produced by prior infection or vaccination. So far it seems that such antibodies have some effect against this new strain, just diminished. Researchers will have to specifically study how effective existing vaccines are against this strain, but they are likely to be less effective (although not worthless).
Fortunately it will not take much time to reformulate existing vaccines to cover this new variant. The mRNA vaccines in particularly could be created in a matter of days, once they have the genome of the new variants. This will definitely complicate vaccination efforts, however. It may mean that people need to get vaccinated every year or so, not only to maintain immunity but also to cover new emerging strains.
What does all this mean?
The fact that SARS-CoV-2 mutates relatively slowly was considered reassuring by epidemiologists. If we could get this pandemic under control quickly enough, we could stop it before any new and worse strains emerge. However, mutating slowly is still mutating, and new strains have been emerging at a steady rate. It was inevitable that new strains would emerge that possess greater infectivity or deadliness or that have properties that allow them to evade the immune system. This is evolution in action.
In fact, our attempts at treating patients with COVID-19, which we have to do, provides further evolutionary pressure, and even further opportunity (by allowing some patients to survive for a long time with an active infection) for new strains to emerge. This is just a microcosm of the bigger picture – that humanity is engaged in an evolutionary war against a host of infectious agents. This is just one battle in that never-ending war.
Further, the pandemic itself, and the emergence of these new strains, highlight the fact that fighting infections is a global species-wide problem, and we have to face it together with a coordinated response. We simply don’t have the option of allowing pandemics to spread, to ride them out and take the hit. This is one more reason why public health measures aimed at stopping the pandemic are so important. The longer the pandemic is allowed to continue, the greater the chance that new and deadlier strains will emerge. These new strains can emerge from any part of the world and wind up on our shores.
This is also one more reason why mask denialism and anti-vaxxer propaganda is so deadly. These choices affect everyone.
One might reasonably argue that we are fighting a losing war against infectious disease. New germs are evolving faster that we can deal with them. Pandemics are emerging at an increasing rate. The World Health Organization warned that the COVID-19 pandemic, as bad as it is, might not be “The big one”. We likely have more deadly pandemics in our future.
The good news is that science is steadily advancing. The ability to produce multiple highly effective vaccines in less than a year is testimony to that. But this is coupled with serious bad news – the pandemic has revealed that politically we do not have our stuff together. It has revealed weaknesses in the system, and if we don’t fix them science will not save us in the future. One of those weaknesses is the ease with which pseudoscience and misinformation are spread. Misinformation is perhaps the most deadly pandemic, and we have no system in place for dealing with it.

The Delta Variant
The emergence of the delta variant of SARS-CoV-2, leading to more cases of COVID-19, is a reminder that we have not won this race against the pandemic yet.
Steven Novella on June 23, 2021
Link

As we watch this once in a century pandemic unfold, experts have been keeping a close eye on the emergence of new variants of SARS-CoV-2. In fact, experts have long known that the true scope and harm of this pandemic will likely be determined by a race between getting enough people vaccinated to reach herd immunity and the emergence of new variants that are potentially more contagious and deadly. The worst case scenario would be the emergence of a variant that is largely immune to existing vaccines and can re-infect previously infected people, resetting the clock on the pandemic.
That worst case scenario has not happened yet. But the increasing emergence and rapid dominance of new variants is worrisome. The recent delta variant (technically known as the B.1.617.2 lineage) is the most worrisome of all. This variant was first detected in India in December 2020. By April 2021 it was the most common variant in India, and is largely the cause of their recent and deadly wave of infections. It has now spread to at least 80 countries, including the UK and the US. In fact it is likely the most common variant in the UK. As of May 22, it was 2.7% of cases in the US.
What makes the delta variant concerning is that it appears to be about 60% more infectious than the alpha variant (previously known as the UK variant), which itself is more infectious that the original variants of SARS-CoV-2. This means that the virus spreads more easily and more quickly, which is why it rapidly dominates any population it spreads to.
UK data also shows that those infected with the delta variant are more likely to be hospitalized with their illness, so it appears to cause a more serious infection. However, almost all of those admitted to the hospital with the delta variant have not been vaccinated. Two doses of the mRNA vaccines prevent hospitalization by about 90%.
The delta variant highlights exactly what experts warned about earlier in the pandemic. The more this virus has an opportunity to spread, the greater the probability that new variants will emerge. The more infectious a new variant, the more it will dominate new infections. And then eventually we get variants of variants, and mutations favorable to the virus begin to accumulate. The virus will progressively adapt to its human hosts.
We can also see the effectiveness of the currently available vaccines. They prevent spread of the illness, and reduce severity of infections. This in turn reduces hospitalizations and the need for resources to treat seriously ill patients. India’s recent experience is an example of what happens when resources are overwhelmed – when you run out of oxygen, the death rate spikes.
The good news is that our vaccines still work against the spread of the current batch of variants. But we are not at herd immunity yet. The delta variant is spreading in the US and Canada in pockets of populations that are unvaccinated. This could not make the situation more clear – those who refuse to get vaccinated are putting everyone else at risk by allowing the virus to spread, maintaining the pandemic, and allowing for new variants to emerge and spread.
This leads to a now common question – when and if we will need a booster vaccine to maintain protection and to cover new variants. So far, it seems the vaccines are maintaining immunity, and they are covering known variants. We can only make an educated guess about when boosters will become necessary, and hopefully the vaccine will hold for at least a year. However, we may need boosters before that to extend coverage to new variants. Moderna is already working on newer versions of the vaccine specific to the new variants.
Where will all this end up? There are several possible outcomes. The worst outcome would be something like the 1918 flu pandemic, that eventually burned itself out but only after killing 50 million or more people worldwide (the COVID-19 death toll is approaching 4 million). That is not the path we want to take to herd immunity. The best outcome is that we will get enough people vaccinated, while maintaining sufficient measures like social distancing to reduce spread, and achieve herd immunity without any significant further waves. This would likely take a greater effort than the world is currently doing.
The third, and perhaps most likely, outcome is that COVID-19 becomes endemic (like the flu). The infection never fully burns itself out, but it is sufficiently reduced that we are no longer in a pandemic. Rather, the infection simmers along causing occasional epidemics, mostly in unvaccinated populations. It seems likely that we will be getting our annual COVID vaccine alongside our annual flu vaccine, and organizations like the CDC will have to track annual infections and deaths every year like they track the flu.
Unfortunately, it seems like we missed our window to prevent COVID from becoming endemic, but we may still luck out. Leaving it to luck, however, is not a good plan. Now is the time to vaccinate the world against this disease, because a pocket of infection in a distant country can breed a new variant that will ultimately spread around the world. We may still win this race, but the emergence of the delta variant makes it seem more likely that we may have to settle for a tie.

Variants of Interest
The World Health Organization and medical experts are keeping an eye on new variants as the pandemic simmers on.
Steven Novella on September 8, 2021
Link

No, this is not (unfortunately) about Loki and the Time Variance Authority (although I do recommend this series if you like that sort of thing). Rather, there are more COVID variants beyond Delta, and we need to keep an eye on them. It was just three months ago I wrote about the Delta variant, and we are now living through a new COVID Delta variant surge. But delta is not the final letter of the Greek alphabet, nor is the SARS-CoV-2 virus limited by such linguistic conventions.
Variants are simply versions of the virus with different properties due to mutations in one or more genes. These mutations may have a number of effects – making the virus more or less deadly, more or less easy to spread, more or less able to evade the host’s immune system, or the ability to survive in different environments, for example. Experts have warned throughout the pandemic that the longer it continues, the greater the probability of random mutations producing new variants that will perpetuate, and even worsen, the pandemic. The Delta variant has shown that warning to be absolutely true.
A recent study in Nature shows that the Delta variant is less sensitive to neutralizing antibodies produced from earlier variants. This kind of mutation is referred to as “immune escape” because it allows the virus to bypass (at least partially) host immunity. This is partly why the Delta variant is more infectious; more of the virus is allowed to replicate, so there is simply more virus in those droplets of water we spread around to each other. The virus is also better at replicating, and hangs out in those droplets longer. The result is that people infected with the Delta variant have about 1,000 times the virus in their system, and are about twice as likely to spread COVID as the original variant. Further, while the vaccines are still effective against the Delta variant, they are less so.
The World Health Organization (WHO) designates “variants of concern” if they demonstrate one or more of the following properties: increased infectivity or virulence, or evasion of one or more public health measures to limit spread (masks, distancing, vaccines). So far there are four variants of concern, alpha through delta. A “variant of interest” is used for:
[Variants] with genetic changes that are predicted or known to affect virus characteristics such as transmissibility, disease severity, immune escape, diagnostic or therapeutic escape; AND
Identified to cause significant community transmission or multiple COVID-19 clusters, in multiple countries with increasing relative prevalence alongside increasing number of cases over time, or other apparent epidemiological impacts to suggest an emerging risk to global public health.
They now list Eta, Iota, Kappa, Lambda and Mu as variants of interest. In short, variants of interest have mutations that might cause the virus to become more infectious or deadly, while variants of concern definitely do have such properties. One of the variants of interest, however, deserves special attention.
Mu variant
The Mu variant of SARS-CoV-2 was first detected in Colombia in January 2021. It has since spread to 40 countries, and currently represents only 0.1% of new infections. Colombia has the highest percentage, at about 39%. Currently in the US the Mu variant represents 0.2% of infections, with the Delta variant responsible for >99%. There is some good and bad news with the Mu variant, which is representative generally of what can happen with variants during a pandemic.
First the bad news – the Mu variant is a variant of interest because it has mutations to the spike protein that gives coronaviruses their ability to infect humans. As the WHO reports:
The Mu variant has a constellation of mutations that indicate potential properties of immune escape. Preliminary data presented to the Virus Evolution Working Group show a reduction in neutralization capacity of convalescent and vaccinee sera similar to that seen for the Beta variant, but this needs to be confirmed by further studies.
Some of these mutations are to locations where the vaccines are typically targeted. Not only, therefore, does this raise the possibility of immune escape but specifically of vaccine resistance escape. But as stated above, so far preliminary tests show this capacity is similar to the Beta variant.
The good news is that so far the Mu variant is not outcompeting the Delta variant. Even if the Mu variant has some very concerning properties, it might simply be outcompeted by the Delta variant, which is very contagious. This is what makes variants so hard to predict. No one mutation is going to give a virus an entire suite of properties, making them more infectious, virulent, and deadly all at the same time. A new variant may emerge that is very competitive in terms of infectivity, but mild in terms of severity. Or, a deadly virus may emerge that never gets a foothold against other more competitive variants.
But the more we allow variants to emerge because we fail to tamp down the pandemic adequately, the greater the probability of (by chance) a variant emerging that does have several bad properties all at once. Another concern is that different variants may target different subpopulations. The major concern for the Mu variant is that it may significantly evade COVID vaccines. If this is the case, then it may spread among the vaccinated, who are relatively protected from the otherwise more infectious Delta variant. There are too many possibilities to accurately predict what will happen. The WHO simply has to monitor and study variants as they emerge, and that’s what they are doing.
In the end the majority of experts predict that COVID will simply become endemic. We have already passed the point of being able to stop the pandemic, and it will now become like the flu or other circulating coronaviruses – here to stay. However, this does not mean it remains as it is today. Through infections and vaccines, the world’s population will become increasingly resistant to COVID. This will not be enough to stop it, and new variants means the virus will be constantly escaping immunity. But like the flu, it will probably settle down to a background infection we all have to live with, but will not mean lockdown and disruption.
It will likely change our lives. I expect, as a health care worker, wearing a mask to work is now the new normal. We will likely see masks out in public as a permanent fixture, and this is probably a good thing. If you have the sniffles or a fever, or have been exposed to someone who has COVID, stay home or if in doubt wear a mask. People will probably wear masks in large indoor or close crowds. And now we have a new vaccine to fight over, and hopefully most people will do the responsible thing and just get their annual booster (or whatever turns out to be optimal).
And now for something completely different – good news
        ◦ To end on some good news – early reports from Israel suggest that getting a third dose or booster shot has a significant effect in reducing their current wave of COVID. Scientific research has provided the tool to fight this pandemic. Vaccines work. Get vaccinated.

Omicron
Omicron is the latest variant of concern. It’s too early to know what this means, but there is reason for concern.
Steven Novella on December 1, 2021
Link

It’s a sign of the times that the meaning of a single Greek letter is immediately understood and can strike a frenzy in the media and dread in the public. Omicron is the latest “variant of concern” according to the World Health Organization (WHO). Just two months ago I wrote here about variants of interest and variants of concern, warning that the recent delta variants of SARS-CoV-2, responsible for a massive wave of COVID infections over the summer, was likely not the last significant variant of this pandemic. On cue the omicron variant arrives to threaten our Winter.
While it is definitely a cause for concern, it is still too early to conclude that omicron will be another delta variant or worse. Here is what we know so far.
First, to quickly review, variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus are caused by mutations in its genome. This is not a particularly fast mutating virus (not as fast as flu viruses, for example) but the number of infections around the world provides ample opportunities for mutations to occur. Most mutations are silent, meaning that they do not change the amino acid sequence of the protein for which they code. Such mutations, however, may influence expression, although this may not be relevant in a virus. Many of the mutations which do alter which amino acids are coded for may still not produce a functional change in the protein – it will still fold the same way and act the same way. A small subset of mutations are functional, in that they alter the structure and function of the protein they code for. Many of these mutations are lateral moves, not dramatically altering the behavior of the overall virus. But some mutations do alter the virus’s behavior in a clinically significant way, and these are the mutations that scientists are interested in.
With the coronaviruses, the primary protein that represents the “business end” of the virus is the spike protein. This sticks out from the outer shell of the virus like a crown, giving this family of viruses its name, and is also responsible for its ability to infect host cells. Mutations in the spike protein are of particular interest.
The WHO has been tracking the emergence of new variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus throughout the pandemic. It has created a list of variants of interest, which have identified mutations that might alter the characteristics of the virus. These mutations are likely to make the virus either more infectious, more deadly, or allow it to escape detection or preventive measures (like masks, distancing, or vaccines). In addition, to be a variant of interest the variant must be responsible for significant community transmission. If a variant is not spreading, it’s not a threat.
One notch up in the threat level is a variant of concern, which the new omicron variant has been designated. These are variants of interest that also have demonstrated:
Increase in transmissibility or detrimental change in COVID-19 epidemiology; ORIncrease in virulence or change in clinical disease presentation; ORDecrease in effectiveness of public health and social measures or available diagnostics, vaccines, therapeutics.
Omicron was first detected in South Africa. We need to recognize that South Africa has a robust detection system, sequencing the entire genome of viruses taken from COVID patients in order to monitor for the emergence of new variants. Our preliminary data on omicron comes mostly from them. Right now the delta variant is the variant to beat, and I mean that literally. It is responsible for almost all COVID infections around the world, outcompeting all other variants. Any new variant must therefore outcompete delta in some way to get a foothold.
Recently a variant of interest, mu, was identified that had a relative degree of resistance to existing vaccines. However, it was not able to outcompete delta, and so essentially fizzled. This is often what happens during a pandemic. Evolutionary selective pressures favor viruses that spread more easily and aggressively, so these variants dominate over time. These are not necessarily the same properties that allow a virus to be more deadly or escape treatments. There is therefore a statistical probability that as a pandemic simmers along, variants predominate that produce milder disease. This is one way pandemics peter out. So far we have not been so lucky with COVID-19.
The question now is – will omicron go the way of mu, not able to compete against the delta variant, or will it replace delta and cause new waves of infection around the world? At this point either outcome is possible. The WHO is concerned because in South Africa where the variant is being detected there has been a spike in infections. If this is due to the variant itself, we need to prepare ourselves for a new wave of the pandemic. However, the WHO has not ruled out that other factors may be responsible for this increase in infections. This is scientists being cautious, and we need to be patient and let them do their investigations.
Omicron is also concerning because it has 30 mutations (26 of which are unique to omicron) on the spike protein itself. This is more than any other variant. This means the omicron variant has the potential for many new properties all together.
Regarding disease severity the WHO reports:
Preliminary data suggests that there are increasing rates of hospitalization in South Africa, but this may be due to increasing overall numbers of people becoming infected, rather than a result of specific infection with Omicron. There is currently no information to suggest that symptoms associated with Omicron are different from those from other variants.
It will likely take several weeks of gathering data before we can make a firm conclusion about disease severity with omicron. In terms of the effectiveness of existing countermeasures, there is early reason for concern in that the reinfection rate seems to be higher with omicron. Therefore, antibodies from past infections may not be as protective against this variant. But again, this needs to be confirmed. The effectiveness of existing vaccines (a huge question) is being actively investigated, and we should have some preliminary data in a few weeks. The first studies are looking at the effectiveness of antibodies from vaccinated individuals at neutralizing the omicron variant. It will take longer to gather epidemiological data on how the variant is behaving out there in the world.
Existing testing is still effective at detecting this variant, and in fact the PCR test can not only detect it but identify it as the omicron variant. This will make it easy to track the spread of this variant.
Again, it is too early to tell what the full implications of the omicron variant will be, and it is good that scientists are jumping on this variant to learn as much as possible as quickly as possible. Best case scenario, we will have a mu-variant fizzle. The worst case scenario is that we are in for another wave of the pandemic to sweep the world. At this time the full spectrum is possible, but we will know more in a matter of weeks.
Regardless, the omicron variant has implications for public policy. First, we need to recognize the success of the South African monitoring program and replicate it in as many countries as possible. Their early-warning system has given us a jump on this variant. These systems also need to be coordinated world wide, with free sharing of data, so that anywhere a new variant emerges we will learn about it quickly.
Omicron and other variants, like delta, have implications for our vaccination program. These newer variants of concern are tending to drift away from the original type virus against which the vaccines are targeted. While the vaccines are still effective, efficacy is tending to decrease with these newer variants. This absolutely does not decrease the need to get vaccinated – it increases it. We now know that the booster shots are significantly increasing antibody titers, above that of simply being fully vaccinated. These increased antibodies will be effective even against variants that are partially resistant. Right now boosting is the best defense against new variants.
Meanwhile vaccine manufacturers are exploring updates to their vaccines to cover emerging variants, but do not wait to get vaccinated or boosted. The current vaccines are your best protection against delta and omicron.
The emergence of variants also shows that a variant can emerge anywhere in the world and still spread to anywhere else in the world. This means we have to seriously consider our global vaccination strategy. Essentially we need to increase our efforts to vaccinate the world. A rich country with high vaccination rates can still be threatened by a variant that emerges in a poor country half-way around the world.
Vaccines also reduce the chance of new variants emerging. Prolonged infection where the virus has a chance to replicate extensively within a single host is where mutations tend to emerge. Vaccines reduce the duration of disease and the ability of the virus to replicate, dramatically decreasing the opportunity for new mutations to accumulate.
The year 2020 of the COVID-19 pandemic was defined by a race to slow down spread of the virus to give scientists time to develop effective vaccines. We essentially failed to contain the virus, but scientists did succeed in developing multiple highly effective vaccines.
The year 2021 of the pandemic is defined by a race to get the world vaccinated before new variants emerged. We lost this race, partly because we did not get enough vaccine distributed in poorer countries, but also due to vaccine resistance in wealthy countries. We have likely now missed our window to prevent SARS-CoV-2 from becoming endemic, meaning an enduring part of our world.
But the race is not over. These newer variants, such as delta and possibly omicron, have extended the pandemic. But they did not hit the full reset button on the pandemic, because the existing vaccines are still effective. Perhaps 2022 will be defined by the next leg of the race – can we get enough of the world vaccinated before a truly scary variant emerges, one that can mostly or completely evade the vaccine, or that is much more deadly than existing variants?
        ◦ This is an open question. One thing is for sure – this pandemic is not over yet. While we are all anxious for things to get back to normal, they are not normal. They may never return to pre-pandemic normal. We now have to live with this virus, and that means doing whatever it takes to get as many people vaccinated as possible.

There is no COVID-19 “casedemic.” The pandemic is real and deadly.
Antivaccine activists and pandemic minimizers Del Bigtree and Joe Mercola are promoting the myth of the “casedemic” that claims that the massive increase in COVID-19 cases being reported is an artifact of increased PCR testing and false positives due to too sensitive a threshold to the test. As they have done for vaccines and vaccine-preventable diseases many times before, they are vastly simplifying and exaggerating a scientific controversy to cast doubt on the scope and deadliness of the pandemic.
David Gorski on November 23, 2020
Link

Ever since the COVID-19 pandemic reared its ugly head in China and then made its way to Europe and the rest of the world, conspiracy theorists have had a field day. Whether it was the idea that the 5G rollout in Wuhan, China somehow sparked or accelerated the COVID-19 outbreaks that evolved into the pandemic, that the influenza vaccine makes you more susceptible to COVID-19, or that COVID-19 was bioengineered in a laboratory and thus the pandemic is really a “plandemic” designed to control and subjugate the population (or even to depopulate the earth by over 90% so that elites, working with aliens—yes, aliens!—could exploit the population and its resources), conspiracy theories have been flowing fast and furious since early this year. Meanwhile, antivaxxers rapidly formed an unholy alliance with antimaskers, COVID-19 pandemic minimizers and deniers, and others opposing public health mandates to control the spread of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19 (including QAnon believers!) while infusing that movement with antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories and launching a pre-emptive disinformation war against COVID-19 vaccines. Antivax leader and propagandist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr has gone all-in on COVID-19 minimization/denial, and Del Bigtree, who made the antivaccine propaganda film VAXXED with Andrew Wakefield, has urged his listeners to “catch this cold” in order to build up herd immunity among the “healthy,” because, to him, COVID-19 is not dangerous except to those who deserve to be endangered, specifically those with chronic conditions due to overeating, lack of exercise, excess drink, and the like. It was blaming the victim at its most blatant, very typical of antivaccine activists.
This brings me to the latest propaganda line being promoted by COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers, that of the “casedemic”.
What is the “casedemic”?
What is a “casedemic”? Last week, über-quack tycoon (worth over $100 million!) Joseph Mercola, DO published an article entitled “Asymptomatic ‘Casedemic’ Is a Perpetuation of Needless Fear“. Amusingly, Mercola prominently lists his article as having been “fact-checked”, to which I can only respond: “Fact-checked? You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”
Before I deconstruct Mercola’s claims, let’s take a moment to consider why “casedemic” has been a buzzword among COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers lately. As of my writing this yesterday, COVID-19 is spreading out of control throughout huge swaths of the US, with the number of (known) cases hitting 12 million and the number of deaths surpassing a quarter of a million. Hospitalizations are climbing, and in large areas of the US, hospitals and the healthcare system are straining under the load of caring for so many COVID-19 patients. The situation is only getting worse, with hospitals in half the states facing massive staffing shortages, especially shortages of ICU nurses. In the face of such empirical numbers, it’s difficult to deny how severe the COVID-19 pandemic currently is in the US; that is, unless you find a way to redefine your terms. Enter the “casedemic”, in which antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers try to claim that what we are seeing is an epidemic of positive tests, not of real disease, hence the term. Indeed, if you do a search of the term “casedemic”, you’ll find articles from the usual COVID-19 denying suspects arguing that the now-exponential increase in COVID-19 cases is not due to real disease, but rather an artifact of wider testing.
Basically, “casedemic” is just a new name for an old COVID-19 denier trope, that increased testing explains the pandemic and that COVID-19 is not dangerous. Indeed, a Google Trends search shows that the term didn’t show up as Google searches until early August, but I’ve been as yet unable to figure out who coined the word:
The earliest example in which the term “casedemic” was used was this Tweet:
I think that might be the first instance of “casedemic” and that Ivor Cummins might well have been the person who coined the term, but I really don’t know for sure. Ivor Cummins, for those unfamiliar with him, is an engineer who decided he knew more about nutrition and health than actual, you know, nutritionists and physicians and had established himself as a nutrition quack under the title “Fat Emperor” long before COVID-19. Once the pandemic hit, he rapidly pivoted to become a COVID-19 grifter and has become hugely influential among the COVID-19 denial crowd. His shtick has been pretty much this, to claim that COVID-19 numbers are being vastly inflated due to increased testing and that it’s not that dangerous. Cummins rates a post of his own, and I’ve been meaning to do one discussing his pseudoscience about diet and COVID-10, but today is not the day for it.
Here’s where antivaxxers glom on. After all, if COVID-19 is not dangerous, particularly if it’s not more dangerous than the flu, then there’s no need for masking, no need for social distancing, no need for public health interventions such as restricting activities known to be sources of spread (such as indoor dining at restaurants and having those who can work from home do so), and, above all, no need for a vaccine.
Now let’s get back to Mercola. Mercola relies largely on a video by Del Bigtree. (It’s always a bad idea to use such an unreliable source, but if there’s one thing that Bigtree is skilled at, it’s crafting science-denying and antivaccine propaganda that sounds convincing to people who are not well versed in the relevant sciences.) I’m not going to embed it or link to it; it’s in the article if you really want to subject yourself to 23 minutes of Bigtree’s rambling. It also amuses me when someone who knows nothing about PCR pontificates about PCR, the way that Bigtree and Mercola do.
PCR basics
I know PCR, which stands for “polymerase chain reaction” and is a highly sensitive technique to amplify tiny quantities of specific DNA sequences. (I’ve discussed PCR before in the context of its misuse by antivaccine advocates.) Before I drifted away from doing benchwork myself—as lab directors tend to do as time goes on—I had done literally thousands of PCR assays personally in my time as a lab rat, dating back to the 1990s, when PCR was new. I had done thousands of real time quantitative PCR assays as well. Even though it’s been a few years since I’ve personally done PCR, I know PCR. I’ve troubleshot more PCR reactions than I can remember. So, it was with a combination of amusement and disgust that I watched Bigtree and Mercola cherry pick facts about PCR and twist known problems with PCR testing into casting doubt on the reliability of all PCR testing for COVID-19.
This brings us back to Mercola:
As coronavirus testing takes place en masse across the U.S., many are questioning whether the tests are accurate enough to trust, especially in people who are asymptomatic. Positive reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) tests have several drawbacks that make mass testing problematic and rife for misleading fearmongering.
For starters, the PCR test is not designed to be used as a diagnostic tool as it cannot distinguish between inactive viruses and “live” or reproductive ones.1 This is a crucial point, since inactive and reproductive viruses are not interchangeable in terms of infectivity. If you have a nonreproductive virus in your body, you will not get sick and you cannot spread it to others.
It really irks me when a quack like Mercola lectures about a fact regarding a medical test or intervention as though scientists and physicians have never thought of it before! Here’s how reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) works. Because COVID-19 is an RNA virus, in order to amplify part of its sequence, first the RNA has to be converted to DNA, which is done with an enzyme called reverse transcriptase, which reverse transcribes RNA to DNA. Then that DNA can be amplified using a standard PCR reaction, which uses two primers designed to match specific sequences on the target DNA sequence. Basically, two different primers (short stretches of DNA designed to be complementary to and thus bind to a sequence of interest, each of which are on opposite strands “aimed” at each other are mixed with the sample containing the DNA of interest and then run through different temperature steps. First is the denaturation step at 95° C, which guarantees that all the DNA of interest has been separated into its two complementary strands. Next, the temperature is dropped lower to allow the primers to bind to their complementary sequences (the annealing phase). This temperature can’t be too low, or nonspecific binding of primer to other DNA sequences that don’t exactly match will occur, leading to amplification of DNA other than the intended sequence. It can’t be too high either, or there won’t be enough binding. Next, comes the elongation phase, where the temperature is increased to 72° or thereabouts, which is near the optimal temperature for Taq polymerase to do its thing. Finally comes another denaturation phase, where the temperature is briefly boosted to 95° to separate the strands, after which the temperature is dropped again to the annealing temperature and the cycle begins anew. Because the number of copies of the target DNA sequence roughly doubles every cycle, after 30-40 cycles even single DNA copies can be detected. Here’s what it looks like in schematic form:

There’s a variant of PCR known as real time quantitative PCR, in which each cycle releases a fluorescent marker, whose signal can be quantified with each cycle. Back in the old days, PCR was basically a yes-no test. You’d run the PCR reaction for a given number of cycles, and you either could or could not see a band on a DNA separation gel. With real time PCR, accurate quantification of the DNA target present is possible. For purposes of my discussion, you really don’t need to know the details other than to know that this is the case.
In any event, the greatest power of PCR also leads to the biggest pitfalls in its application. Basically, PCR is so sensitive that it’s very easy for a PCR reaction to amplify a contaminant or for the primers to anneal to sequences that are similar but not identical and thus amplify DNA other than the sequence of interest. Indeed, I’ve encountered all of these pitfalls and more. That is why controls are of the utmost importance. For example, there has to be a good negative control to let the researcher know that the chosen PCR conditions are not amplifying junk. Moreover, if you’ve designed your primers poorly or if you anneal at too low a temperature, you can get nonspecific binding and amplify sequences that you don’t want to. Overall, PCR can be a very tricky game, and it gets trickier the more cycles you use to amplify and the lower amounts of target sequence you are trying to amplify. PCR is an exponential amplification; small variations in early cycles can have enormous effects in later cycle, producing wide variation in results. Every scientist who’s ever done a significant amount of PCR knows these pitfalls and takes steps to avoid them. Mercola treats them as though no one knows about them and that describing them is some sort of “revelation” or “secret” that scientists are hiding from you.
Back to the “casedemic”.
Joe Mercola: Regurgitating disinformation about COVID-19
So let’s get to the primary claim that falls under the term “casedemic”:
In summary, the PCR swab collects RNA from your nasal cavity. This RNA is then reverse transcribed into DNA. However, because the genetic snippets are so tiny, they must be amplified to become discernible.
Each round of amplification is called a cycle, and the number of amplification cycles used by any given test or lab is called a cycle threshold. Amplification over 35 cycles is considered unreliable and scientifically unjustified. Some experts say nothing above 30 cycles should be used,3 yet Drosten tests and tests recommended by the World Health Organization are set to 45 cycles.4,5,6
When you go above 30 cycles, even insignificant sequences of viral DNA end up being magnified to the point that the test reads positive even if your viral load is extremely low or the virus is inactive and poses no threat to you or anyone else.
Isn’t that last part pretty much what I was saying above? See what I mean about quacks treating well-known problems with a medical test or intervention as a “revelation” of “secret knowledge” that “they” don’t want you to know about.
Yes, it is true that doing PCR on swab tests from the nasopharynx only tells you whether there is detectable SARS-CoV-2 RNA present in the specimen; it does not say whether that RNA comes from infectious virus or is causing a clinical infection. Yes, it is true that PCR picks up many asymptomatic cases, but it is also true that asymptomatic patients can still spread COVID-19, old WHO statements in June notwithstanding, which is why identifying these cases is important. It is also true that there has been a bit of controversy over what the appropriate PCR threshold count should be for COVID-19 testing, as well as that early in the pandemic PCR tests were a lot less reliable. (Just witness the CDC debacle when it tried designing its own PCR test for SARS-CoV-2.) However, now, nearly a year into the global pandemic and nearly ten months after the pandemic hit US shores, we have a lot more experience with these tests. More on that in a moment, but first let’s let Mercola have some more rope to hang himself with, scientifically speaking:
When labs use these excessive cycle thresholds, you end up with a far higher number of positive tests than you would otherwise. At present, and going back a number of months now, what we’re really dealing with is a “casedemic,”7,8 meaning an epidemic of false positives.
Remember, in medical terminology, when used accurately, a “case” refers to someone who has symptoms of a disease. By erroneously reporting positive tests as “cases,” the pandemic appears magnitudes worse than it actually is.
Hilariously, reference #7 is not a scientific paper. It’s an article from PJ Media, the right-wing propaganda “news” network, and is basically a rant against Joe Biden that, amusingly, self-references another article in PJ Media that quotes a New York Times article without actually linking to it. What did the article say? Basically, the NYT looked at a bunch of PCR tests done by one lab, the Wadsworth Center (a New York State lab) and identified 872 positive tests in July, positives that were based on a threshold of 40 cycles. They found that with a cutoff of 35, about 43% of those tests would no longer have qualified as positive and that about 63% would no longer have been judged positive if the cycles were limited to 30. Interestingly, this NYT article was published in late August, but I have yet to see any peer-reviewed publication on it. The only possibly relevant publication I could find from the Wadsworth Center reported its evaluation of the NeuMoDx™ SARS-CoV-2 assay, performed on a NeuMoDx molecular system, a rapid, fully automated, qualitative real-time RT-PCR diagnostic test with throughput of up to 288 tests in an 8 hour shift. The article concluded that this automated system had a similar sensitivity and specificity to the CDC assay. So this does sound rather odd, but in reality way too much is being made of this single survey by a newspaper and not published in the peer-reviewed medical literature.
As for the second “reference”, it’s to an article published on the website of that medical conspiracy theorist group disguised as a medical professional organization, the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), which is known for its antivaccine views, denial of climate science, and all manner of conspiracy theories. (AAPS even published an article by Andrew Wakefield predicting a “mass extinction” due to the MMR vaccine. I kid you not.) Hilariously, even the AAPS acknowledges that “coronavirus is not a pseudo-epidemic” and that “thousands have died”, even as it speculates that the ‘dreaded “second wave” might be a surge of false positive tests that are inevitable in mass screenings of healthy persons’. Of course, AAPS fails to mention that hospitalizations and deaths are also rising rapidly, which would definitely go against the latest COVID-19 wave being a “casedemic”.
Why, though? Why would governments, scientists, physicians, and public health officials who’ve dedicated their lives to combatting infectious disease want to do this? I bet you know where this is going:
“The goal is to keep you scared, isolated and demoralized for a purpose,” says PJ Media.9 “Only a beaten nation would stand for what comes next.” And that next step is a reset of America as you know it, with the UN’s one-world Agenda 2030 at the helm.
Mercola even links to an article of his from three weeks ago called “The Great Reset“, in which he posits that the COVID-19 pandemic is being used as a pretext for the “Great Reset”, whose purpose is to “usher in a tech-driven dystopia free of democratic controls” and create a “new ‘social contract’ that ties you to it through an electronic ID linked to your bank account and health records, and a ‘social credit’ ID that will dictate every facet of your life.” Because of course it is. And, to Mercola and his fellow conspiracy mongers, COVID-19 PCR testing is a primary tool in achieving that end by creating a “casedemic” of illusory COVID-19 cases.
There’s just one problem. Actually, there are several.
The problem with the “casedemic” conspiracy theory
Anyone who’s done PCR knows that cranking up the number of cycles does indeed increase the chances of amplifying a contaminant or a sequence that is similar, but not identical, to the intended target sequence. (Again, it amuses me how cranks like Joe Mercola treat this long known issue with PCR as though it were some sort of astounding revelation that scientists have never thought about much before.) Is it a potential problem that PCR tests might be too sensitive for their intended purpose, namely screening for COVID-19 infection? Yes. However, as is almost always the case in these situations, the COVID-19 denialist cranks and conspiracy theorists have latched on to a problem and amplified it far out of proportion to its significance, all in order to cast doubt on the entire process of COVID-19 screening. Gideon M-K, a.k.a. the Health Nerd, pointed this out a couple of weeks ago, which seems to be when this whole “casedemic” thing started to percolate up onto social media in a way not seen since August:
There is no 'casedemic' – why the idea that COVID-19 cases can rise by deaths will not is simply a myth @MackayIM @CaulfieldTim https://t.co/BxTcTyYhH9
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) November 6, 2020
Here’s what he points out:
As cases of COVID-19 skyrocket across Europe and the United States, a new myth has emerged to add to our ever-increasing list of coronavirus-related nonsense. The idea is that the current massive epidemic in Europe and elsewhere is not an issue, because this is a ‘casedemic’ — an increase in cases without any concomitant increase in sickness or deaths.
Basically, it’s another way of saying that the pandemic is over, from people who’ve been saying that it was over every month since March.
Thing is, this new piece of disinformation is simply factually inaccurate, and is driven by a simple misunderstanding: that the second wave of COVID-19 was dramatically different to the first. In fact, the two waves are much more alike than you’d imagine, because the disease probably hasn’t changed enormously in the last 6 months or so no matter how much we wish that it has.
In other words, while the number of cases that are appearing positive now seems far higher than at the start of the year, in fact what we know is that we missed a huge proportion of cases back in March and actually it’s more than likely that the current wave looks very similar to the first.
This, again, is not a new observation. Early in the pandemic, scientists pointed out that, due to the massive shortage of COVID-19 tests that led to, in essence, rationing in which only those who were hospitalized or had severe symptoms were tested (and sometimes not even they were always tested), huge numbers of milder cases were being missed. Many were the public health officials who predicted that, as more testing became available, the apparent infection fatality rate (IFR, the percent who have the infection and die, whether symptomatic or not) would decline as more mild and asymptomatic cases that weren’t being detected before started being detected.
To demonstrate this, the Health Nerd did a clever back calculation based on the number of deaths per time period, correcting for age, to extrapolate what the IFR would have been early in the pandemic if we were doing as many tests then as we are now and found:
Suddenly, the difference disappears! Indeed, it looks like the first wave might have even been a bit BIGGER than the second. This makes perfect sense when you consider that, at least in the United States, the number of tests being done each week in March was in the hundreds of thousands, and limited mostly to people who were being hospitalized for COVID-19. So we missed almost everyone with a mild infection, and cannot have picked up the millions of cases that almost certainly existed at the time.
He further predicts, based on what’s happened before, that hospitalizations and deaths will increase, because when a lot more people test positive for COVID-19, a lot more people will be hospitalized even if only a relatively small percent of the total infections get that sick, and, eventually, a lot of those people will die, even if the total is “only” less than 1% of the total infection rate. There’s just a lag of several weeks for the virus to do its work, for people to die, and for the deaths to be reported.
Ian Mackay, virologist and adjunct Associate Professor at the University of Queensland had another way of putting it, namely More testing shows more iceberg. Like the Health Nerd, Mackay emphasizes that, early in the pandemic, there was a massive shortage of testing kits:
One thing is pretty clear: laboratories and biotechnology companies worldwide were unprepared for the scale of a pandemic. This wasn’t a slow-moving SARS-CoV or a poorly transmitting MERS-CoV. This was a fast-moving, fully armed, well-equipped, respiratory virus. Labs couldn’t keep pace. And even though test development was super-quick, the fuel to feed and power what those tests needed, quickly became scarce.
Despite the lab challenges posed by Ebola virus epidemics in Africa just a few years ago, and Zika virus epidemics across the world, testing wasn’t ready enough for pandemic 2020. In today’s world, a pandemic was always going to mean using real-time PCR-based tools to detect the virus. These were the most sensitive tests we had. Also, we didn’t have a better tool because no replacement had hit the mainstream. Despite the recurring promise of new platforms pitched during recent outbreaks and epidemics, PCR hasn’t faced a mainstream challenger since its real-time iteration hit the brights [sic] lights in 2009.
The analogy is simple. Early in the pandemic, we were only detecting the “tip of the iceberg” of COVID-19 cases. With more testing, we’re now seeing more of the iceberg, namely the part that lies “below the water,” so to speak, and wasn’t detected in March and April because not enough people were being tested and a lot of cases were going undiagnosed and undetected.
More importantly, though, to counter the claim of a “casedemic”, using PCR to detect a virus is more complicated than someone like Mercola lets on. It depends on so many things, not the least of which is sample collection, which can result in a high degree of variability in detectable RNA in a person’s sample. As cranks ignore that complexity, Mackay shares my amusement at how cranks portray a certain observation as such an amazing revelation:
Look, I fully agree that the later (higher number) the threshold cycle (CT “cycle number”) of the RT-PCR result, the less target RNA is present at the start of the reaction. That RNA is a surrogate marker for the amount of virus but not an actual measure because PCR methods can’t tell you a virus is infectious.
People are very chuffed to have learned this fact in 2020 by the way. You can tell because they say so. A lot. But despite their newfound out-of-context knowledge they actually know very little about what they’re talking about.
See what I mean? Yes, Mr. Bigtree and “Dr.” Mercola, real scientists who do PCR are laughing at you.
In any event, Mackay cites a study from Eurosurveillance that highlights the variability in PCR results, as well as the “gold standard” test of demonstrating the ability of virus from an isolate to be able to infect appropriate cells in cell culture, pointing out, based on the result reported that from among 5/60 (8.3%) of patient samples with a CT greater than 35, infectious virus was still present:
The figure shows that if you were to blindly and ignorantly rely on single CT values to proclaim lack of infectious risk – let’s say 35 or greater – you would miss people who were still shedding infectious virus.
If you surveyed more labs with expertise in cell culture and virus isolation and labs that could get hold of fresh samples and samples from the actual site of virus replication, I’m sure you could find even later CTs. You can also find labs who can’t isolate virus from samples with CTs this late. This biological variability means we need to step back from these stupid single number cut-offs.
Precisely. Setting the threshold count (CT) cutoff on a PCR test is a balancing act, in which you balance the increased sensitivity of using a higher CT and more amplification cycles as your cutoff and the attendant possibility of more false positives associated with that more sensitive cutoff against the possibility of missing a lot more cases of real infection if you use a lower CT. Another way of looking at it is this. If there were so many false positives, then PCR reactions all over the world should be generating them in huge numbers now. But:
Well in the denialist parallel universe, no one ever dies of Covid. They either die "with", or it's a "false positive".Never mind that largely Covid-free countries like AUS or NZ use the same testing methods and report ~0.1% *total* positives.
— Klaus Hentrich 🇺🇦 (@KHInnovation) November 20, 2020
Mackay points to the example of Australia, which currently has no reported local transmission of SARS-CoV-2, noting that “Australia’s COVID-19 cases right now are almost exclusively in quarantine hotels and among Aussies returning, or special-purpose travellers visiting, from a world on fire” and that Australia has “had a few clusters spin out from quarantine but they’ve–so far–been squished dead in weeks to months.” He further notes that Australia’s testing rate hasn’t fallen below 20,000/day since June. He then notes:
All that testing provides a good number of opportunities for those so-called false-positive PCR results to show up in our daily reported numbers. Surely more testing should mean a steady flow of false positives if these conspiracies are correct? And others love to add that it should be even more of a problem in a low prevalence setting. Australia certainly fits that bill. Plus, we’re testing mostly sick people but also asymptomatic and presymptomatic people.
But lo and behold there is no steady stream of false positives. We don’t have an issue because once again, this is an over-oxygenated amateur conspiracy theory and not an actual issue.
Local context also matters. For example, in a situation in which the disease being tested for is present at low prevalence (say, less than 2% of the population), even a test that is very specific and sensitive can produce a lot of false positives compared to “true” positives. I won’t go into the gory details (if you want discussions of sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values, go here, here, and here), can lead to a lower positive predictive value (PPV), which is the likelihood, given a positive test, that there really is disease present. To put it simply (but hopefully not simplistically), the lower the prevalence of a disease, the lower the positive predictive value of a test for that disease, even a good one, is likely to be, because even low rates of false positivity will be high (half, equal, or even greater) compared to the actual prevalence of the disease in the population.
Basically, yes, there are false positives on PCR testing, but false positives are not nearly as huge a problem as people like Del Bigtree and Joe Mercola want to lead you to believe, and, contrary to their portrayal of scientists, physicians, and public health officials as oblivious to this problem, all these people working to find science-based methods to slow the spread of COVID-19 and bring the pandemic under control do consider the potential for false positives and seek to find ways to account for them and reduce them. Also, when the PCR testing is done properly in the context of a larger public health effort, the overall process will make sure that the lab results are considered along with the epidemiological and clinical context. Similarly, because the issues with PCR tests are known, other tests are being increasingly used. Rapid antigen tests are less sensitive, but detect the actual proteins made by cells as a result of SARS-CoV-2 infection, something not seen from an inactive virus. Serum antibody tests, which detect antibody to SARS-CoV-2 in the blood made as a result of infection, can tell us who has recovered from infection (or been infected long enough to develop an antibody response).
COVID-19 science denial is basically no different from any other form of medical science denial that we’ve covered here. It uses the same techniques of distraction to produce disinformation. In this case, Bigtree and Mercola are latching on to a legitimate controversy over the minutiae of a lab test and vastly exaggerating the significance of the controversy and magnitude of the problems it causes in order to cast doubt on the very process of testing for the disease itself, which is their real purpose. They are not promoting better and more accurate COVID-19 testing, which is what we all want, especially physicians and scientists on the front lines fighting the pandemic. They are doing their best to deny that COVID-19 is as huge and deadly a problem as it actually is, because if COVID-19 really is that big a problem then it does, contrary to their views, justify massive public health interventions to decrease infection and death rates, and, ultimately, a mass vaccination program.

Summer COVID Wave
COVID is still here, happily mutating, and we need to adapt to this new reality.
Steven Novella on August 30, 2023
Link

The COVID emergency has officially ended. The CDC, WHO, and most governments have ended any emergency designations for the COVID pandemic. Does that mean the pandemic is over? Not really, it just means we are entering another phase. We might think of this as the tail end of the pandemic, or we can think of it as a transition to endemic COVID.
Meanwhile, the CDC is talking about a possible late summer wave of COVID. There has definitely been an uptick in COVID infections and hospitalizations. There has been a 17% increase in hospitalizations between June and July nationwide, and while August numbers are not in yet, the trend seems to be continuing. The reason for the increase is likely several things. Summer heat waves are forcing people to spend more time indoors. Summer vacation travel is also a good way to spread the virus around. But perhaps most importantly, people have largely returned to their pre-pandemic behavior. For example, in July my hospital ended their mask-wearing mandate. Now, very few people are masking.
But we also need to keep this summer wave in perspective. The numbers are still far lower than they were a year ago, or anytime during the pandemic. This is because the population is generally much more resistant to the virus now. Most people have either been vaccinated, or they have had COVID at least once, or both.
On the other hand, the virus is still mutating, degrading the protective effect of prior immunity. The dominant strain circulating right now is EG.5, but dominant means only 20% of cases. There are many strains circulating. Experts have also detected a new strain of interest – BA.2.86. This one is of interest because it has more than 35 mutations on the spike proteins. This makes this virus as different from prior strains as Omicron was from the original virus. The spike proteins are the business end of the virus that allow it to enter human cells. So far there are only a few detected cases, but in many countries, including the US.
The reason the many mutations are of interest is because this suggests the virus may be good at evading existing immunity. This may be the new phase we are in, similar to the ongoing flu pandemic but not as seasonal. We may be in an endless arms race between immunity and viral mutations to evade immunity.
So what does all this mean practically? It’s important to recognize that even if the state of emergency is over, even if we consider the pandemic to be over, we are not living in a prepandemic world. We are now living in a world with endemic COVID. This means we can’t go back to our prepandemic behavior, but nor do we need to maintain our pandemic precautions. So what’s the new normal?
First – keep up to date on your COVID vaccines and boosters. The FDA has approved new versions of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines that cover new variants of the virus, dubbed XBB1.5. It appear these vaccines will cover the EG.5 variant well. So the easiest and best thing you can do to protect yourself going forward is to get an updated booster. This will not only increase your immunity, it will target the newer variants. This new vaccine is coming out in a few weeks, so if you are due for a booster it is best to wait for the new one. Only people who have a specific reason to get a booster now should do so, like travel or other activity that will put them at high risk.
Universal mask wearing is not necessary. However, that does not mean you should never wear a mask. Targeted mask wearing should become the new normal. It is reasonable to mask up if you are having what might be early symptoms of a respiratory infection. Masks will protect against the flu and cold viruses too, not just COVID. So when you get the sniffles, or feel achy like you might have a virus, wear a mask if you have to be in public. Or work from home, if that is an option. Going out in public unprotected when you might be sick and contagious is simply no longer acceptable.
You may also wish to wear a mask when you are going to be in a large crowd. If you are going to be in a sea of people at a concert, convention, busy airport, or other similar situation, the probability of getting infected with a virus is statistically high. These are nexus points for disease spread. Protecting yourself with a mask is a reasonable standard precaution, like washing your hands after going to the bathroom.
The bottom line is that we are living in a world awash in infectious diseases, because there are 8 billion people on the planet and we have robust international travel. Basic hygiene includes taking common sense precautions against getting exposed to and spreading infectious diseases. This means keeping up to date on your vaccines, staying home when you are sick, washing your hands, and wearing a mask in targeted situations of high risk.

The Subvariants Are Coming
A wave of Omicron subvariants are coming. So get vaccinated.
Steven Novella on October 26, 2022
Link

It sort-of feels as if the pandemic is at least partially over, or at least sliding into the next phase where COVID is more endemic, like the flu. It’s something we have to deal with every year in the background, but life goes on as normal. The problem is – the pandemic is not over.
After the initial phase of the pandemic, prior to the vaccine, we started to tamp down new cases and reduce the severity of infections through better treatment and later through vaccine protection. Then the variants started hitting giving us additional waves of infection, often evading earlier immunity. The WHO warns that we seem to be getting into the next phase of the pandemic, marked by swarms of multiple subvariants.
This is how evolution works. The virus has hit upon a successful configuration of proteins in the Omicron variant, and now is developing variations of the Omicron variant that further evade existing immunity. The new subvariants are all Omicron, but labeled with additional letters and numbers, such as BA.2.75. In this nomenclature, all subvariants are contained within the category prior to each period. So the BA.2 subvariant contain all those that start with BA.2, regardless of any further numbers. Essentially these are variations on variations. The virus is further fine-tuning its ability to infect and avoid immunity.
All these Omicron subvariants have tweaks to the binding region of the spike protein, the place where an antibody will bind to the virus in order to destroy it. By altering the binding location, antibodies are less able to identify and bind the virus. Those viruses better able to evade immunity are more likely to spread, so these variants increasingly dominate and generate even more tweaked subvariants. The WHO tracks variants that impact transmissibility, severity, or immunity, and the list of such variants is growing.
All of this likely means that we are in for another wave of COVID this winter, fueled by these subvariants. It won’t be anything like the initial waves of COVID, because at that time the virus was spreading into a “naïve” population without any pre-existing immunity. Now most people have at least partial resistance, and again, we have effective treatments such as Paxlovid.
How can we shore up our immunity to prevent getting hit by this likely winter wave? The answer by now should be obvious – be up to date with your vaccines. The new COVID booster available is a bivalent vaccine, which means it covers the original variant of SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID-19), but also the BA.4 and BA.5 variants of the virus. This booster, therefore, is a lot closer to the subvariants likely to be spreading this winter.
It’s important to remember that immunity is not black or white, either with complete immunity or none. Antibodies have a certain amount of affinity for specific binding sites, which can vary anywhere from zero to 100% (perfect match) affinity. Immune effectiveness is partially determined by the number and affinity of circulating antibodies. The booster accomplished two goals – increasing the affinity and numbers of circulating antibodies.
So the answer is simple – get the new booster (when you are eligible). Don’t wait, get it now. Even if you have been previously boosted, or previously infected. These new subvariants can evade your waning immunity. You want the highest number of antibodies that are as close to these new subvariants as possible.
While you’re at it, get the flu vaccine. Experts predict a worse than average flu season, because the last two flu seasons were very mild (because masks and social distancing work, and these prevented most flu infections). But this also means that there is less native immunity out there. Again – the best way to maintain your immunity without having to suffer through the flu is to get vaccinated every year.
It is safe to get both vaccines together (coadministration). This is recommended because it increases the total number of people who get up to date on all their vaccines. There is only a slight (11% vs 8%) increase in side effects from coadministration – not worth the risk of missing out on one of these important vaccines.
What does the existence of these new subvariants mean for the pandemic? First, basically – we blew it. Our COVID response was not a complete failure, but the initial response was, and later compliance was simply not enough to really knock down the virus. Lackluster vaccination rates are what has allowed these subvariants to multiply. India, for example, is about to destroy 100 million doses of unused and expired COVID vaccines because of lack of demand. Only 79% of Americans have received at least one dose of COVID vaccine, and only 68% are considered fully vaccinated. We need these numbers to be in the 90+% range. As a result the US has had 97 million cases of COVID and 1.06 million deaths.
The result is that we likely have more waves of COVID coming. This pandemic is not over yet. It will eventually burn itself out, as more people gain partial immunity through getting infected if not vaccinated. That doesn’t mean it will go away. Expect to get your annual COVID booster along with your flu vaccine for the foreseeable future.
Experts also believe that pandemics in general are likely to become more frequent, due to increasing populations, long-distance travel, and exposure to wild animal populations. We need to improve our global pandemic readiness. The problem is, we seem to have short memories. Our failures with COVID did not prepare us for the later monkeypox. Although this is now getting under control, we did not jump on it as fast as we should have.
Experts are also warning about a new Ebola outbreak, with a variant that evades the Ebola vaccine. This new outbreak has already spread to Kampala, a city of 1.5 million people. This is very concerning. It’s also disappointing. After the 2014 outbreak, for which we were completely unprepared, world governments vowed to be more prepared next time. While readiness has improved, it has not improved to the point that we are really prepared for a major outbreak. We keep taking our eye off the ball.
Many fear the same is happening with COVID. People have COVID fatigue, and are tired of the precautions. But the pandemic is not over, and new pandemics are looming. We need sustainable preventive measures, and we need to have the endurance to maintain them. The world has changed, and we need a cultural change to match it. We need a more robust infrastructure to monitor and respond to outbreaks. And we need to strike a sustainable balance between living our lives, and taking reasonable infection precautions.
This means, above all else, get vaccinated. Further, the anti-vaccine movement is now a threat to global health, and it needs to be treated that way. This is not some fringe we can ignore.

COVID Is Still Here, But Changing
Steven Novella on January 15, 2025
Link
My hospital just reinstituted mask mandates for all staff working with patients. They also advise patients to wear masks while in the hospital, but have not made it a requirement. I still have a stash of N95 masks so it was easy, and all too familiar, for me to comply, but I admit it created an unpleasant flash-back. All things considered, I would rather not have to wear a mask at work all day. But that is now part of the job, like washing your hands, wearing gloves, occasionally having to gown, and keeping up to date with your vaccines.
It seems that collectively, as a society, we all have a bit of COVID-19 PTSD. I get it. ln a way, we were all innocent pre-pandemic, thinking we lived in a world where modern medicine meant we did not have to live in fear of infectious illness, or alter our lives around minimizing spread of disease. We knew this existed, but it was more an afterthought, and an occasional nuisance when we or people close to us caught a cold or flu. We also knew there were vulnerable people who needed to be protected. The COVID pandemic made us all feel vulnerable. It changed the world we live in.
So it’s likely that no one wants to be reminded that COVID is still with us, and some of the pandemic-era precautions are still necessary, although to a lesser degree. Pretty much as predicted, COVID has gone from an acute pandemic infection to a persistent background infection, one of many that we have to track and take precautions for.
The reason for the mask recommendations is because it’s respiratory virus season in the Northern hemisphere, including COVID, flu, and RSV (respiratory syncytial virus). Together these viruses represent a significant health risk that need to be managed. There are several things to consider – the risk of getting infected, the likely severity of infection, the risk of hospitalization, and the risk of death or long-term morbidity (like long-COVID).
Risk of hospitalization is important because, as we saw, hospital resources can get easily overwhelmed by a surge of illness. This is why hospitals remain acute aware of such illnesses. The CDC reports “from October 1 through November 30, 2024, there have been between 64,000 and 110,000 hospitalizations due to COVID-19.” This is still significant, even if COVID has mostly faded from our collective consciousness.
Experts also continue to track SARS-Cov-2 as it evolves. The Omicron variant and its subtypes remain dominant. However, there is now an XEC variant which emerged likely from a cross between two strains. This is now the dominant strain. Researchers were initially very worried because the strain has a novel spike protein and can evade existing immunity. However, in the wild the strain appears to cause more mild illness. In fact, many people who have it may think they just have a cold, or their infection may even be subclinical. This is just luck more than anything else.
One way to track the spread of these viruses and their strains is through wastewater. We can track the DNA/RNA (SARS-Cov-2 is a single-stranded RNA virus) of organisms that gets into waste water through excretions. This is a powerful tool to measure spread and track strains.
What does the XEC variant teach us? A few things. First, these viruses will continue to evolve. This means that we must keep on top of them to minimize spread. Vaccines need to be updated, and people should continue to get vaccine boosters to keep their immunity up to date. Again as predicted, an annual flu and COVID vaccine should just be standard practice for most people. Despite this, COVID vaccine rates have significantly dropped off. According to the CDC:
“The percent of the population reporting receipt of the updated 2024─25 COVID-19 vaccine is 11.0% (10.0-12.0) for children and 22.8% (21.7-24.0) for adults age 18+, including 46.4% (42.2-50.7) among adults age 65+.”
This is unfortunate, because vaccines are a major reason that the COVID illness is becoming more mild over time. This is also due to the fact that most people have caught the virus one or more times. Vaccines plus natural exposure leads to robust immunity, so we can fight off the virus before it has a chance to cause more serious illness or chronic symptoms. But as the virus evolves, the best way to keep ahead of it is with keeping up on the vaccines.
Another lesson is that these viruses will continue to change in unpredictable ways. COVID is evolving to be more of an upper respiratory virus than a pneumonia causing virus, which is a good thing, but this is not inevitable or predictable. It is also possible that coronaviruses like SARS-CoV-2 could evolve into an enterovirus, spreading through the GI system. A new variant can emerge that is really good at evading existing immunity (like XEC), or that causes more severe illness.
This is simply the world we now live in. There are over 8 billion people on the planet, and we are connected through a robust global network. We have made ourselves, in short, a tempting target for any bug that wants to infect us. We live with a constant background of such germs, with new one popping up, old ones evolving, and surges occasionally happening. This will never be over.
Of course we rely heavily on our immune systems to protect us. But we also have lots of tools to increase that protection and minimize death, morbidity, and overwhelming our healthcare infrastructure. It would be nice if we could use those methods based on the best scientific evidence available with a rational risk and cost vs benefit analysis, free of politics, ideology, and wasteful nonsense. But that is also not the world we live in.


Is COVID-19 transmitted by airborne aerosols?
A recurring debate about COVID-19 bubbled up late last week, when a group of scientists announced an as-yet unpublished open letter to the World Health Organization arguing that COVID-19 transmission is airborne and urging it to change its recommendations. What is this debate about, and, if coronavirus is airborne, should we be more scared?
David Gorski on July 6, 2020
Link

One of the biggest mysteries early on in the COVID-19 pandemic that continues to some extent even today is how SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, spreads. While it’s always been known to spread primarily through respiratory droplets (and that is still thought to be the primary method of spread), there are still so many questions that remain. For instance, you might remember that early on in the pandemic, fomites (objects on which virus-laden respiratory droplets could land and thereby harbor the virus) were thought to be a major source of infection, as people would touch such objects and then touch their face, and no doubt many of you remember all the breathless stories in March about studies showing that SARS-CoV-2 could survive up to three days on plastic and metal surfaces and up to 24 hours on cardboard. Then, a month ago, the CDC published a news release and updated its website to say that indirect contact from a surface contaminated with coronavirus is a potential way to contract COVID-19 but not the most prominent way that the virus infects people, emphasizing that the “primary and most important mode of transmission for COVID-19 is through close contact from person-to-person” and stating that fomite transmission is not “thought to be the main way the virus spreads.” None of this makes it any less of a good idea or any less imperative that you wash your hands frequently and avoid touching your face. The virus can still spread that way; it’s just not the primary driver of infection.
The real debate though bubbled up in the news over the 4th of July weekend in the form of a story in The New York Times entitled “239 Experts With 1 Big Claim: The Coronavirus Is Airborne“:
The World Health Organization has long held that the coronavirus is spread primarily by large respiratory droplets that, once expelled by infected people in coughs and sneezes, fall quickly to the floor.
But in an open letter to the W.H.O., 239 scientists in 32 countries have outlined the evidence showing that smaller particles can infect people, and are calling for the agency to revise its recommendations. The researchers plan to publish their letter in a scientific journal next week.
Even in its latest update on the coronavirus, released June 29, the W.H.O. said airborne transmission of the virus is possible only after medical procedures that produce aerosols, or droplets smaller than 5 microns. (A micron is equal to one millionth of a meter.)
Proper ventilation and N95 masks are of concern only in those circumstances, according to the W.H.O. Instead, its infection control guidance, before and during this pandemic, has heavily promoted the importance of handwashing as a primary prevention strategy, even though there is limited evidence for transmission of the virus from surfaces. (The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention now says surfaces are likely to play only a minor role.)
I’ll try to remember to update this once the scientists’ actual letter has been published. In the meantime, I thought of two things. First, the reaction to this story reminds me of the reaction to stories that have emerged regarding how presymptomatic and asymptomatic COVID-19 patients can spread coronavirus to others. The second—and more relevant—thing was that this debate reminded me of a very similar debate that I wrote about nearly six years ago. At the time, the nation was gripped in fear that the deadly Ebola virus would make its way here from Africa in order to cause outbreaks, and there was a similar question: Could Ebola be spread by air? Because I’ve written about this before, it allows me to expand a bit on the same basic concepts that I discussed in the context of Ebola and discuss them in the context of what we know about COVID-19. I’ll be very straightforward in admitting that I don’t know yet what to believe on this question, but I’ll look at the basic concepts and the evidence.
Airborne transmission: Droplet size matters
Before I discuss evidence, it’s necessary to know what the experts are talking about when they debate whether COVID-19 spread is airborne. Basically, it all boils down to the size of respiratory droplets. To explain the difference, I’m going to go back to an article by an infectious disease expert named Heather Lander that I cited 6 years ago (remember, in this article she was discussing droplets in the context of claims that Ebola could undergo airborne spread, hence the mention of a bloody wash cloth):
Bodily secretions that make it into the air from various orifices (e.g., nose, mouth) are called droplets and are classified based on size and distance traveled. The smaller the droplet, the longer it stays suspended in the air, the farther it travels and the deeper into the respiratory tract it can go upon inhalation by the person sitting down the aisle from you on the airplane. Teeny-tiny droplets (less than 5 microns) are generally referred to as “aerosols” and can be generated by a cough, a sneeze, exhaling, talking, vomiting, diarrhea, passing gas etc. Aerosols can also be generated mechanically by things like flushing a toilet, mopping, or rinsing out a bloody wash cloth. When aerosols are infectious, they transmit disease when they are inhaled by an organism and its [sic] called “aerosol transmission”. When droplets are larger than 10 microns they are called “large-droplets” and if infectious, they transmit disease by inhalation if the organism being infected is close enough to inhale the particles before they settle out of the air. They can also transmit virus if someone gets showered with droplets from, for example, a sneeze, or touching a droplet that is on the surface of an object (fomite) or someone’s skin and it’s called “large-droplet transmission”.
By way of comparison, SARS-CoV-2 is a bit more than 100 nm in diameter, or 0.1 micron.
It’s more complicated than even that, though:
Not all viruses can form infectious aerosols. It depends on where the virus goes in your body and what happens when it gets there. Aerosol infectivity of a virus is determined by how long the virus remains infectious in the air, how deep into the lungs it can travel, and how many virus particles are actually in each droplet compared to how many are required to actually establish an infection. If a viral infection generates aerosols containing 10 virus particles per droplet, but it takes 1000 virus particles per human cell to establish an infection, then those aerosols are not infectious, even though they contain virus. In addition, while airborne, aerosols begin to lose water content by evaporation and virus particles, especially enveloped particles like Ebola, can be affected by other environmental conditions such as humidity, air currents, and sunlight. These particles are also subject to the laws of physics and mechanical forces. A good example of a virus for which these characteristics have been better defined is influenza and this is an excellent article [PDF] that really explains the different kinds of aerosols and how they are transmitted.
If you keep this in mind, then those studies that you’ve no doubt seen in the press trumpeting how researchers have “isolated coronavirus” from respiratory droplets make more sense. Just detecting virus in droplets doesn’t mean that those droplets are infectious. In particular, remember that most such studies use polymerase chain reaction to detect viral nucleic acid sequences, whose presence alone doesn’t necessarily equate to infectivity. Thus, such droplets might be infectious, but it depends upon how many virus particles are in them and how many virus particles are required to get an infection rolling.
Another important thing to remember is that we are dealing with a continuum. The 5-micron cutoff between an “aerosol” droplet that can hang in the air for a long time and a larger droplet that falls out of the air rapidly, to land on nearby objects, is arbitrary. Humans beings, when coughing, sneezing, or speaking, produce a range of droplet sizes, ranging from aerosols to larger droplets. In order to understand the range of possibilities, this article from the CDC is useful [PDF, linked in the above quote]. Basically, by definition, aerosols are suspensions in the air small enough that they remain airborne for prolonged periods of time because of their low settling density. The article reports that for spherical particles of unit density, settling times for a 3-meter fall are 10 seconds for 100 microns, 4 minutes for 20 microns, 17 minutes for 10 microns, and 62 minutes for 5 microns. Particles with a diameter less than 3 microns in essence do not settle. So for a disease to be truly airborne, it has to produce aerosols that hang in the air for a long time, such that prolonged contact (or even any direct contact at all) with the infected individual isn’t necessary for disease transmission. Also affecting this equation is how far these tiny particles can get into the lung. Particles greater than 6 microns tend to be trapped in the upper respiratory tract, while essentially no deposition of particles into the lower respiratory tract occurs for particles greater than 20 microns. To sum it up, a good rule of thumb is that particles in the micron or submicron range are referred to as, and will behave like aerosols; particles greater than 10 to 20 microns are referred to as large droplets, will settle rapidly, and won’t be deposited in the lower respiratory tract.
It’s even more complicated than that:
Whether propelled by sneezing, coughing, talking, splashing, flushing or some other process, aerosols (an over-arching term) include a range of particle sizes. Those droplets larger than 5-10 millionths of a meter (a micron [µm]; about 1/10 the width of a human hair), fall to the ground within seconds or impact on another surface, without evaporating (see Figure). The smaller droplets that remain suspended in the air evaporate very quickly (/10 sec in dry air), leaving behind particles consisting of proteins, salts and other things left after the water is removed, including suspended viruses and bacteria. These leftovers, which may be more like a gel, depending on the humidity, are called droplet nuclei. They can remain airborne for hours and, if unimpeded, travel wherever the wind blows them. Coughs, sneezes and toilet flushes generate both droplets and droplet nuclei. Droplets smaller than 5-10µm almost always dry fast enough to form droplet nuclei without falling to the ground, and it is usual for scientists to refer to these as being in the airborne size range. It is only the droplet nuclei that are capable of riding the air currents through a hospital, shopping centre or office building.
When infectious disease experts say that a virus is “airborne”, they have a very specific meaning. What they are saying is that the virus is capable of aerosol transmission via inhalation, even when the person inhaling the virus is not in close proximity to the source of the aerosol. In other words, if someone with measles (a very highly infectious virus that can be transmitted through the air), coughs up droplets in a room and then leaves the room and then you enter the room, you can breathe in the measles aerosol and will be very likely to contract measles (that is, if you haven’t been vaccinated against measles or had it before). In other words, droplet transmission is not the same thing as airborne transmission. Airborne transmission can occur in places where the infected patient has been, even if it were hours ago, while droplet transmission requires being close to the infected patient.
That is what this debate is about.
Is COVID-19 transmitted by airborne route?
A few weeks ago, I discussed the evidence addressing whether facemasks work to slow the spread of COVID-19. The specific meta-analysis that I discussed also examined the effect of social distancing on the transmission of coronavirus. The meta-analysis found that a physical distance of more than 1 meter was associated with an 82% decrease in the risk of virus transmission, more precisely that the absolute risk of infection from an exposed individual was 12.8% at 1 m and 2.6% at 2 m, while each additional meter of increased distance resulted in a doubling in the change in relative risk. Taken at face value, this evidence tends to suggest that COVID-19 is transmitted through larger droplets that settle rapidly after short distances. However, it doesn’t exclude the possibility of aerosol transmission.
Most of the evidence for aerosol transmission is anecdotal thus far, albeit nonetheless worrying:
Dr. Morawska and others pointed to several incidents that indicate airborne transmission of the virus, particularly in poorly ventilated and crowded indoor spaces. They said the W.H.O. was making an artificial distinction between tiny aerosols and larger droplets, even though infected people produce both.
“We’ve known since 1946 that coughing and talking generate aerosols,” said Linsey Marr, an expert in airborne transmission of viruses at Virginia Tech.
Scientists have not been able to grow the coronavirus from aerosols in the lab. But that doesn’t mean aerosols are not infective, Dr. Marr said: Most of the samples in those experiments have come from hospital rooms with good air flow that would dilute viral levels.
The incidents cited above included the spread of coronavirus in a choir at choir practice in March:
The full choir consists of 122 singers, but only 61 made it that night, including one who had been fighting cold-like symptoms for a few days.
That person later tested positive for the coronavirus, and within two days of the practice, six more members of the choir had developed a fever. Ultimately, 53 members of the choir became ill with Covid-19, the disease caused by the virus, and two of them died.
The event, which was reported in March by various news organizations, demonstrated how contagious and dangerous the coronavirus is, especially among older populations. The median age for those attending the practice that night was 69.
On the other hand, the story notes that the choir seats were “were packed together, six to 10 inches apart, far closer than the minimum six-foot recommendation by the CDC during the pandemic.” This incident, to me at least, is not compelling anecdotal evidence of airborne spread beyond large respiratory droplets over short distances landing on fomites.
More suggestive of airborne spread is an incident that occurred in a restaurant in Guangzhou, China in January early in the course of the pandemic, in which one diner infected with coronavirus but not yet feeling ill appeared to spread the disease to nine other people in the restaurant. The hypothesis was that the restaurant’s ventilation system blew virus particles around the dining room. However, 73 other diners in the restaurant did not become sick, nor did the eight employees working the floor at the time. Moreover, all of the people who became sick at the restaurant were either at the same table as the infected person or at one of two neighboring tables. Thus, this particular anecdote isn’t very compelling evidence, either, at least not to me.
Still more suggestive anecdotal evidence of airborne spread comes from a German meatpacking plant, where coronavirus infected more than 1,500 workers:
An outbreak of coronavirus that infected more than 1,500 people at a German slaughterhouse may have been spread by “circulating air”.
Experts fear COVID-19 can be spread inside facilities like the Toennies meat plant in Guetersloh because of the systems they use to pump out cool, moist air inside enclosed rooms.
Martin Exner, director of the Institute for Hygiene and Public Health at the University of Bonn, said: “What has not been known so far is that under such conditions circulating air can keep an aerosol moving.
This outbreak is more consistent with airborne spread of coronavirus.
Basically, most of the evidence for airborne spread is either anecdotal or inferred. For example, one recently published review article notes:
While evidence for airborne transmission of COVID-19 is currently incomplete, several hospital-based studies have performed air-sampling for SARS-COV-2, including one published paper (Ong et al. 2020), one early-release paper (Guo et al., 2020) and 5 papers still in pre-print at the time of writing (Chia et al., 2020, Ding et al., 2020, Jiang et al., 2019, Liu et al., 2020, Santarpia et al., 2020). Four of these studies found several positive samples for SARS-CoV-2 genome (RNA) in air using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing (Chia et al., 2020, Jiang et al., 2019, Liu et al., 2020, Santarpia et al., 2020), two found very small numbers of positive samples (Ding et al., 2020), and only one (Ong et al., 2020) found no positive air samples. This evidence at least demonstrates a potential risk for airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2.
And:
A recent mechanistic modelling study showed that short-range airborne transmission dominates exposure during close contact (Chen et al., 2020). Other studies investigating the transport of human-expired microdroplets and airflow patterns between people also provide substantive support for this transmission route (Ai et al., 2019, Li et al., 2007, Liu et al., 2017). Therefore, in light of this body of evidence for these other respiratory viruses; we believe that SARS-CoV-2 should not be treated any differently – with at least the potential for airborne transmission indoors.
The modeling study by Chen et al is interesting in that it found that, even in short range transmission, smaller exhaled droplets are important, with the large droplet route only predominating when the subjects are within 0.2 m while talking or 0.5 m while coughing and that the large droplet route contributes less than 10% of exposure when the droplets are smaller than 50 microns at 0.3 m apart. Of course, this study is a mathematical modeling study and doesn’t have empirical support for its conclusions, but its finding is consistent with both small aerosol droplets being an important mode of transmission and the observation that transmission efficiency drops off rapidly after 1-2 meters.
The authors further note:
Whilst this evidence may be deemed to be incomplete at present, more will arise as the COVID-19 pandemic continues. In contrast, the end-stage pathway to infection of the droplet and contact transmission routes has always been assumed to be via self-inoculation into mucous membranes (of the eyes, nose and mouth). Surprisingly, no direct confirmatory evidence of this phenomenon has been reported, e.g. where there have been: (i) follow-up of fomite or droplet-contaminated fingers of a host, self-inoculated to the mucous membranes to cause infection, through the related disease incubation period, to the development of disease, and (ii) followed by diagnostic sampling, detection, sequencing and phylogenetic analysis of that pathogen genome to then match the sample pathogen sequence back to that in the original fomite or droplet. It is scientifically incongruous that the level of evidence required to demonstrate airborne transmission is so much higher than for these other transmission modes (Morawska et al., 2020).
They do have a point. It’s been accepted that fomites and self-inoculation are a means of spreading coronavirus, but the evidence has been mostly circumstantial and not that rigorous. The one recent study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science (PNAS) that found masks are very effective in slowing the spread of COVID-19 has been cited as indicating that the predominant mode of spread of COVID-19 is airborne was riddled with methodological shortcomings, so much so that dozens of scientists petitioned the journal to retract it, saying the study has “egregious errors” and contains numerous “verifiably false” statements, so much so that a scientist named James Heathers wrote an article for Retraction Watch about it (and one other paper) entitled I agree with your conclusions completely, and your paper is still terrible. (That about sums it up.) Part of the problem is a good thing for you to know, namely that PNAS has a special track, called the “contributed” track, by which members of the National Academies of Science (NAS) can solicit their own peer reviews and submit them with the manuscript. That’s why PNAS has long been known as a dumping ground for NAS members to publish their cast-offs or to publish in areas outside their area of expertise. It’s how, for instance, Linus Pauling got some of his terrible papers claiming that vitamin C is an effective treatment for cancer published. More recently, PNAS has switched to a more standard peer-reviewed model of publishing, but the contributed track still remains for NAS members.
The bottom line
The question of whether COVID-19 can spread by aerosol remains without a definitive answer; however, it could be that the debate has been framed in a way that isn’t helpful. Again, respiratory droplets exist on a continuum, from tiny droplets and droplet nuclei that can travel far and hang in the air a long time to larger droplets that float to earth within seconds to minutes. They can also contain varying numbers of infectious virus particles. As one scientist put it:
People generally “think and talk about airborne transmission profoundly stupidly,” said Bill Hanage, an epidemiologist at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
“We have this notion that airborne transmission means droplets hanging in the air capable of infecting you many hours later, drifting down streets, through letter boxes and finding their way into homes everywhere,” Dr. Hanage said.
Experts all agree that the coronavirus does not behave that way. Dr. Marr and others said the coronavirus seemed to be most infectious when people were in prolonged contact at close range, especially indoors, and even more so in superspreader events — exactly what scientists would expect from aerosol transmission.
Dan Diekema, an infectious disease specialist in Iowa, concurs, referring to the controversy as a “tiresome spat“:
As we’ve outlined here and here, a major problem plaguing this discussion is the false dichotomy between “droplet” and “airborne” transmission that we use in healthcare settings (for simplicity of messaging, and because it has served us well for several decades—for reasons I’ll get back to later). This dichotomy divides application of transmission-based precautions between those pathogens spread via respiratory droplets, all of which must absolutely fall to the ground within 6 feet of the source, and those pathogens which become airborne, meaning they travel long distances on air currents, remain in the air for very long periods of time, and most importantly, can cause infection after their airborne sojourns if they find the right mucosal surface.
But we know (and WHO experts know) that there is no such dichotomy—it’s more of a continuum. At the very least there is a middle category, let’s call it Small Particle Aerosol Transmission (or SPAT). Many respiratory viruses (not just SARS-CoV-2) can remain suspended in aerosols and travel distances > 6 feet. As Jorge outlined, it’s probable that transmission events occur when these aerosols are concentrated in closed, poorly ventilated spaces or in very large amounts (e.g. a 2+ hour choir practice, a 3 hour indoor birthday party, a crowded bar). This may explain the superspreading events that drive a lot of SARS-CoV-2 transmission.
The Center for Evidence-based Medicine (CEBM) published a recent review on the evidence base supporting the two-meter rule of social distancing to reduce COVID-19 transmission. In it the authors also discussed the evidence that COVID-19 is transmitted by air and concluded, among other things, that the “longstanding dichotomy of large droplet versus small airborne droplet transmission is outdated and SARS-CoV-2 may be present and stable in a range of droplet sizes, which will travel across a range of distances, including some beyond 2 metres” and that “single thresholds for social distancing, such as the current 2-metre rule, over-simplify what is a complex transmission risk that is multifactorial,” adding that “social distancing is not a magic bullet to eliminate risk,” while further recommending that a “graded approach to physical distancing that reflects the individual setting, the indoor space and air condition, and other protective factors may be the best approach to reduce risk.”
What’s really needed is more science. The amount of science, both excellent, terrible, and every level of quality in between, that’s been produced since the pandemic began is truly amazing, but it’s only been less than seven months since the pandemic started in China. As Kimberly Prather and co-authors argue, what’s needed is this:
Aerosol transmission of viruses must be acknowledged as a key factor leading to the spread of infectious respiratory diseases. Evidence suggests that SARS-CoV-2 is silently spreading in aerosols exhaled by highly contagious infected individuals with no symptoms. Owing to their smaller size, aerosols may lead to higher severity of COVID-19 because virus-containing aerosols penetrate more deeply into the lungs (10). It is essential that control measures be introduced to reduce aerosol transmission. A multidisciplinary approach is needed to address a wide range of factors that lead to the production and airborne transmission of respiratory viruses, including the minimum virus titer required to cause COVID-19; viral load emitted as a function of droplet size before, during, and after infection; viability of the virus indoors and outdoors; mechanisms of transmission; airborne concentrations; and spatial patterns. More studies of the filtering efficiency of different types of masks are also needed. COVID-19 has inspired research that is already leading to a better understanding of the importance of airborne transmission of respiratory disease.
        ◦ The information gathered on these characteristics of SARS-CoV-2, how it spreads, and how it causes disease will then be of use in the study of other respiratory viruses and future pandemics. In the meantime, I’m coming to the conclusion that we should assume that respiratory aerosol is a major mode of spread of COVID-19 and act accordingly. In many ways, we are already doing that, as social distancing and masks are primary means of preventing the transmission of viruses transmitted this way. However, more can be done, particularly in buildings. Additional strategies to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 in buildings could include refreshing stale indoor air, passing recirculated air through a high-efficiency filter to prevent infecting people in adjacent rooms, and other means of keeping airborne virus confined to limited areas. Then, as the science comes in, recommendations can be fine-tuned based on what we learn. In the meantime, there is no reason to be any more alarmed or even, in most cases, to change what we’re doing to protect ourselves and others.

Airborne Transmission of SARS-CoV-2
To what extent is SARS-CoV-2 airborne, and what does this mean in terms of preventing spread?
Steven Novella on September 23, 2020
Link

On Friday the CDC posted updated guidelines on the spread of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. They have been updating their website regularly, as new information becomes available, so this was not unusual. But it was noticed that the new recommendations include some significant changes, specifically the CDC warned about airborne transmission of the virus, something previously considered to be a minor risk. However, they quickly reversed course and pulled the new recommendations, claiming that the update was just a draft and the publication a mistake. The site now has reverted to their prior warnings, focusing on large droplet spread.
All of this would be of very little interest (mistakes like this are not uncommon or particularly suspicious), except there already is a grave concern of political interference at the CDC. Politico, for example, recently reported that White House officials have been regularly reviewing CDC reports, and changing wording to align the reports more with Trump’s political interests. They have also been trying to shut down reporting from the CDC altogether. In this light, the recent SNAFU by the CDC can seem more nefarious. At the very least they no longer deserve the benefit of the doubt.
Let’s put the recent updating-then-backtracking on transmission guidelines into perspective – how is COVID-19 spread?
There is a strong consensus, and no real doubt, that the primary way in which COVID-19 is spread is through large droplets. There are droplets that come from breathing, talking, coughing, sneezing, shouting, or singing. Viral particles are encapsulated in globs of mucus, saliva, and water. These globs can spread several feet, exactly how far is still a little controversial, but 6 feet is generally considered to be a minimal safe distance.
Mechanism of spread is tied to the methods that will prevent spread. Therefore, social distancing – keeping at least six feet away from other people – reduces the risk of being sprayed by infected droplets. Mask wearing is also a major method for reducing spread. Masks have been shown to dramatically reduce the spread of large particles from the mouth. Basic cloth masks, therefore, are very good at protecting other people. They may also protect the wearer to a small degree, but they do not prevent breathing in viral particles. For that you need N95 masks (which block 95% of viral particles) or better.
Since the major route of transmission is through large droplets, the main mechanism to prevent spread is social distancing and wearing masks.
There is also the possibility of direct physical spread, mainly through direct contact. If an infected person touches their nose or mouth they can get viral particles on their hands, and if they then shake hands with someone else they can transfer the virus to their hands, and when that person scratches their nose they can catch the virus. The way to prevent this transmission is to not touch other people, and to frequently and effectively wash your hands and use hand sanitizer.
Indirect transmission through physical objects (called fomites) is also possible – through a doorknob, for example. The virus can survive on some surfaces for hours, and perhaps days, but this is considered a minor (but not insignificant) route of transmission. To avoid fomite spread, keep surfaces clean and wash public surfaces regularly with an antiseptic agent. Also, try to avoid touching such surfaces with your hands (elbows can be efficacious). In some settings wearing disposable gloves makes sense, but you still can’t touch your face with the gloves or that defies the purpose.
This brings us to aerosolized spread – the matter of the CDC controversy. Can viral particles survive in tiny droplets, the kind that can remain airborne for a long time? Larger droplets tend to fall quickly to the ground, and so mainly spread as projectiles from the mouth or nose. But aerosolized droplets can remain suspended in air, and travel much greater distances, through an indoor space. Cloth masks, as I said above, also don’t protect against breathing them in, only higher-end N95 masks or better do that effectively. Adding to the complexity is the fact that the distinction between “large” droplets and aerosols is somewhat arbitrary and settling time is actually a continuum based on droplet size.
One recent review found:
The case studies found worldwide indicate that the behavior of the SARS-CoV-2 virus has been unprecedentedly unique with more survival and viable rates in the air and believed to linger in the air for an extended period.
Another review was more stark:
The case studies that have come out in different countries have, with prima facie evidence, manifested that the airborne transmission plays a profound role in contracting susceptible hosts.
Yet another recent review concluded:
The authors believe that airborne transmission is possible and that HVAC systems when not adequately used may contribute to the transmission of the virus, as suggested by descriptions from Japan, Germany, and the Diamond Princess Cruise Ship. Previous SARS outbreaks reported at Amoy Gardens, Emergency Rooms and Hotels, also suggested an airborne transmission.
This seems to be the emerging consensus – there is reasonable evidence of airborne spread of COVID-19. All the reviewers also call for more research, but this is to dig deeper on the relative risk in different situations – in a home, building, hospital, car or airplane, and with different ventilation systems. But the fact that the risk of airborne spread is non-trivial now seems very likely.
What does this mean for our recommendations to minimize spread? Essentially it means no mass gatherings indoors. That social distancing alone is not adequate to prevent indoor spread. In high risk situations, like hospitals, N95 or better masks are required to protect workers. Good ventilation reduces, but does not eliminate, the risk.
It should also be pointed out that all of these protective measures need to be done concurrently. Having a good ventilation system, for example, does not mean you don’t need to wear masks or use hand sanitizer – these methods are all preventing different routes of spread. We need to simultaneously do everything.
But also, the realization that airborne spread is non-trivial should inform public policy in terms of school reopening and holding large indoor events. Further, people who are sick still need to isolate, which further means we need continued testing and contact tracing. COVID-19 is, overall, highly contagious, and the best method to prevent spread is simply isolation of anyone carrying the virus.

COVID in Children
Recent evidence suggests children can be carriers of SARS-CoV-2, which has implications as schools reopen this Fall.
Steven Novella on September 2, 2020
Link

In the northern hemisphere children are returning to school, and in countries where COVID-19 is still spreading this is a serious concern. There is still a great deal we don’t know about the SARS-CoV-2 virus, although we are rapidly learning. One big question is the role that children play in the pandemic. Specifically, we need to know the risk of children catching the virus, if they do what is the risk they will develop clinical COVID-19 (as Clay discussed several months back – the risk seems generally low but there are reasons to be concerned), and either way what is the risk they will pass on the virus and become a vector for spread?
A recent UK study adds some information to these questions. The study is being reported as “reassuring” but only relatively so. The study looked at 651 children admitted to the hospital with confirmed SARS-CoV-2. Of these children 18% were admitted to critical care and 1% died. This is less than the figures for adults (27% of those admitted to the hospital with COVID die), but I’m not sure parents would be “reassured” by a 1% mortality rate. However, they also found that these children who were admitted to ICU or died were far more likely (42%) to have an underlying medical condition – “the most common ones being illnesses affecting the brain and nervous system (11%), cancer (8%) and asthma (7%).”
Also, 11% met the WHO MIS-C criteria – this is a multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children. This tended to occur in older children in this study. MIS-C is still a bit mysterious, but it appears that in a subset of children with COVID-19 they develop an autoimmune syndrome with inflammation affecting different organ systems. This can be a serious and even life-threatening illness. In general we are finding that the immune system’s reaction to COVID-19 is often more dangerous than the infection itself, especially in severe cases. There is something about the virus which affects certain people, probably due to the genetics of their immune function, in a way that triggers an extreme immune reaction.
The study also found that the poor and minorities were more likely to be admitted and die from the disease.
In terms of the susceptibility of children to COVID, it does appear to be much less than adults – but it’s not insignificant. This study does suggest that it would be relatively safe for the children themselves to return to school, with the caveat that children with serious underlying medical conditions probably shouldn’t.
What about the question of whether or not children can be asymptomatic carriers of the virus, which could play a huge factor in spreading the pandemic as children return to school? Here we have a recent study from South Korea, which is the opposite of reassuring. South Korea has an extensive program of contact tracing, which follows infected people with serial testing until they clear the virus. This provides a great opportunity to trace how the virus spreads and who is spreading it.
They found that children can have the SARS-CoV-2 virus detectable in nasal swabs for up to three weeks, even if they are asymptomatic. Further, they found that family contact of children currently attending school were the most likely contacts to contract COVID. Younger children 0-9 years old who were currently not in school were the least likely to pass on the virus.
A recent comprehensive review of the research so far also finds that children are asymptomatic carriers of the virus, and that they generally have high viral loads. High viral loads generally translates to being highly contagious – there is more virus to shed and spread to others. Further, when children are symptomatic they tend to have mild non-specific symptoms, which can easily mimic a cold. So COVID may be harder to detect in children.
We don’t know exactly what the risk is of asymptomatic children passing on the virus, but this study suggests it is not negligible. This, of course, would be the worst-case-scenario for opening schools – that children can be asymptomatic carriers and spreaders of the virus, bringing it back to the adults in their home. Meanwhile, the American Academy of Pediatric is urging a “safe” return to school this fall, especially for younger children. They are concerned about the learning and socialization of children, especially since we have essentially already lost a semester. How do we balance these two concerns?
In countries where the pandemic is still spreading, like the US, we need to carefully consider our strategy for returning children safely to school while containing the pandemic. Here the South Korea model may be instructional – use extensive testing and contact tracing to detect any spreaders and isolate them quickly. No such system is in place in the US, however.
Basic precautions will help to some degree. Many schools are reducing the number of days children will be in school and instituting rules for social distancing, mask wearing, and hand hygiene. This will help. Younger children may find it harder to comply, but they are also less likely it appears to contract the virus and spread it in any case. Shifting as much as possible to online learning is also one strategy.
Many schools, however, lack the resources to fully implement a COVID strategy for this fall. This is all a massive experiment, and we may not like the outcome.

Joe Mercola: Falsely demonizing the flu vaccine by claiming it increases your risk of COVID-19
September is the time of the year when the CDC, state public health authorities, and doctors urge everyone to be vaccinated against the flu. In the year of the COVID-19 pandemic, that means antivaxxers like Joe Mercola have a new angle to demonize the flu vaccine: Falsely claiming it increases your risk of catching COVID-19.
David Gorski on September 21, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: I’m sorry to do this twice in one month, but real life has intervened again and I have an urgent grant deadline tomorrow. As a result, I’m repurposing a post that some of you might have seen before in the last month. As always, if you don’t read my not-so-secret other blog, it’ll be new to you. If you do read that blog, I will reassure you that I did make some changes/updates so it’s not entirely a repost. It’s partially new to you. There will be all-new material next week, but I will warn you that I have two grants due, one on October 5 and one on October 6, which means that this might happen again for my October 5 post, although it’s not that likely, given that I have to upload my grant at least a business day—preferably two days—before the deadline. Also, I’ll try to arrange a guest post if I can’t get something together that week.]
The COVID-19 pandemic has now been going on for nine months, and it’s been six months since the first lockdowns were imposed in the US to slow the spread of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus responsible for the pandemic. Now we’re approaching the 2020-21 flu season, which threatens to make a bad situation even worse by adding another potentially lethal respiratory virus to the mix with SARS-CoV-2 and to confuse the care of severely ill patients with symptoms of respiratory infection, as doctors now have to consider the diagnostic possibility of seasonal influenza. Of course, antivaxxers have long targeted the flu vaccine because, compared to most other vaccines, it is an easier target. Different strains of flu predominate every year, forcing public health officials to make a “best guess” in the spring as to which influenza strains will dominate in the fall and winter, so that vaccines can be developed and manufactured in time. A consequence of this necessity is that the efficacy of the flu vaccine can vary widely from year to year. Mismatches between circulating flu strains and the vaccine can lead to poor efficacy some years, while during years that there is a good match to the circulating strains the efficacy is much better. Also, the response to the vaccine tends to be less robust in one group who most needs its protection, the elderly, although higher dose shots can partially solve that problem. Then there’s the issue that flu vaccine uptake is basically never sufficient to achieve community immunity in any given year. Even Mark Crislip used to concede that the flu vaccine is “suboptimal” but nonetheless argued that the evidence is sufficiently robust for its benefit to recommend it every year. Unfortunately, flu vaccines are only moderately effective, but it is clear that they are safe, and it should be remembered that influenza still kills, contrary to the claims of antivaxxers that the flu is not a serious illness.
With the arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic, it was not long before antivaxxers, being the conspiracy theorists that they are, latched onto a new conspiracy theory linking the flu vaccine to increased susceptibility to COVID-19. Indeed, the first I heard about this was in January, before the coronavirus and the disease it causes had even received their final, formal name. (That happened in March.) Back then, antivaxxers were blaming the flu vaccine for having sparked the COVID-19 outbreak in Wuhan, China that later spread to become a pandemic based on China’s having allegedly purchased more doses of flu vaccine than a usual year and a tenuous link to some science about viral interference that I’ll explain in a bit more depth in this post. I bring this up because a couple of weeks ago I came across an article on the website of Dr. Joe Mercola, the über-quack who’s built an online empire that’s made him worth over $100 million, asking “Might Flu Shots Increase COVID-19 Pandemic Risk?” The short answer is no. The long answer follows, and I consider it important to amplify my original rebuttal to this nonsense on a platform with several times more regular readers because antivaccine activists all across the quackosphere (like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.) are parrotting the same claim as Mercola.
So the claim that the flu vaccine increases your risk of getting a life-threatening form of COVID-19, by 36% or by however much, is something I’ve written about at least twice already, once in January for my not-so-secret other blog and once in March for SBM. (Oh, wait, there was one other time.) So why revisit it? Simple. Flu season is upon us, which means that, pandemic or no pandemic, public health officials are rolling out the seasonal flu vaccine, as they do every year around this time. Indeed, I just got mine last week, and I had a really bad reaction to it. (Just kidding. I did have an adverse reaction, but it was nothing more than a sore shoulder for a couple of days, more sore than most years. It’s also here that I have to express the disappointment that I express nearly every year that my cancer center chose to use Fluarix Quadrivalent, which does not contain thimerosal. I almost asked the nurse administering the vaccine if she could add some extra thimerosal to it. OK, I’ll stop with the thimerosal jokes. At least the lack of thimerosal in Fluarix saved you from my older—and, I now realize, sometimes offensive to some—jokes when I did receive thimerosal containing vaccines about how the vaccine didn’t make me autistic.)
Of course, I don’t mind the yearly hassle. I get a flu vaccine every year and still remember the one time I didn’t twelve years ago and ended up knocked on my posterior for a week, sick as a dog with the flu. In any event, with the flu vaccine making its way to doctors’ offices, hospitals, and pharmacies near you, with public health messaging urging everyone to get vaccinated, it’s predictable that the antivaccine movement would do what the antivaccine movement always does at this time of year and try to convince people that the vaccine is dangerous. This year, more than even 2009-2010 (the year of the H1N1 influenza pandemic), this antivaccine pushback has the potential to be really dangerous. After all, with fall coming, there is a very real possibility of a resurgence of COVID-19 cases and deaths at the very same time that influenza cases will be increasing in the same way they do every year. We don’t have a vaccine against COVID-19 yet, but we do have one against influenza.
That’s why I decided to call out Mercola’s disinformation, which begins:
Could a “perfect storm” be brewing, ready to be unleashed this fall? If the regular influenza season ends up converging with a resurgence of SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks, or even a new SARS-CoV-3, the results are anyone’s guess at this point. Confounding matters is the possibility that influenza vaccination may increase people’s risk of other viral infections.
Mercola quotes Michael Osterholm, virologist and director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis, and Edward Belongia, director of the Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Population Health at the Marshfield Clinic Research Institute in Marshfield, who warned in an editorial in Science in June about the possibility of such a “perfect storm” of influenza and COVID-19 and urged an aggressive influenza vaccination campaign:
We do not yet have a COVID-19 vaccine, but safe and moderately effective influenza vaccines are available. Their widespread use is more important now than ever, and we encourage health care providers, employers, and community leaders to promote vaccination. Vaccine effectiveness varies by season and subtype, but vaccination offers similar protection against laboratory-confirmed influenza hospitalization and outpatient illness. Widespread misinformation on social media includes the false claim that influenza vaccination increases the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection. Scientists, health care providers, and public health leaders must counter these claims with clear, evidence-based information on the importance of influenza vaccination during the COVID-19 pandemic.
It’s at this point that Mercola pulls a gambit that made me literally laugh out loud:
But this so-called “false claim” is not a rumor pulled out of thin air. As is so often the case, Osterholm and Belongia are actually insulting fellow virologists and researchers when slapping a hoax label on such claims, seeing how there is published research showing that, yes, influenza vaccination appears to worsen outcomes during viral pandemics.
If Osterholm and Belongia wanted to be factual and clear, they should dissect the actual studies using scientific methods and reasoning, and not just dismiss them as made-up internet hoaxes.
The fact that peer-reviewed studies have come to the conclusion that previous flu vaccination seems to increase patients’ risk of contracting more severe pandemic illness at least worthy of consideration and review.
You got that? By strongly refuting the unproven claim that influenza vaccination can increase the risk of COVID-19 and subsequent severe illness and death and characterizing it as “false”, Osterholm is insulting his fellow virologists and not listening to the science! Indeed, Mercola, amusingly, takes it one step further:
I’m not surprised though, seeing how Osterholm appears to routinely ignore the reality of published science. In a March 10, 2020, interview with Joe Rogan,2 in which the question of SARS-CoV-2’s origin came up, Osterholm stated that “we could not have crafted a virus like this to do what it’s doing; I mean we don’t have the creative imagination or the skill set.”
This simply does not line up with reality. Again, published research shows we clearly have the technology, know-how and “creative imagination” to create SARS-CoV-2.
Actually, Osterholm is correct. Although we have considerable expertise in genetic engineering and splicing genes in and out of viruses, it takes a lot more than that. In order to engineer something like SARS-CoV-2, you have to know enough about how coronaviruses cause disease and how they are transmitted and then about what structural features are required in the virus’ proteins to achieve the desired virulence and contagiousness, and we just don’t. Moreover, as I’ve pointed out many times before, once the complete nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 was elucidated, it became very clear that the virus was of natural origin. It had no tell-tale signs of having been engineered, as documented in a study in Nature in March. There’s just a lot of evidence that the virus was not engineered, but that doesn’t stop this conspiracy theory from popping up again and again, such as in Plandemic, the film featuring disgraced scientist Judy Mikovits and its sequel Plandemic: Indoctornation, or, as I like to call it, Plandemic 2: Electric Boogaloo.
Mercola bases his claim that the flu vaccine increases your risk of COVID-19 on five pieces of information. The last I’ll deal with first because it’s easy. I’ve already dealt with it before. Contrary to what Mercola claims, a 2020 study did not find that people were 36% more likely to get some form of coronavirus infection if they had been vaccinated against influenza. That claim is based on a gross misinterpretation of the study in question, plus a bit of misdirection. The study examined Department of Defense personnel from 2017-2018, long before SARS-CoV-2 emerged to cause the COVID-19 pandemic, meaning that the coronaviruses that the influenza virus allegedly interfered with in a phenomenon known as “viral interference”, the “interference” blocked by vaccination against the flu, were not SARS-CoV-2. Moreover, as I pointed out at the time, the study used to justify the “36%” claim was actually a negative study, with the coronavirus number cherry picked from a single table.
The rest of the studies that Mercola cites are, unsurprisingly, cherry picked and shoehorned into his narrative. First, there’s this:
So, what is the basis for these claims? Research raising serious questions about flu vaccinations and their impact on pandemic viral illnesses include a 2010 review3,4 in PLOS Medicine, led by Dr. Danuta Skowronski, a Canadian influenza expert with the Centre for Disease Control in British Columbia, which found the seasonal flu vaccine increased people’s risk of getting sick with pandemic H1N1 swine flu and resulted in more serious bouts of illness.
People who received the trivalent influenza vaccine during the 2008-2009 flu season were between 1.4 and 2.5 times more likely to get infected with pandemic H1N1 in the spring and summer of 2009 than those who did not get the seasonal flu vaccine.
The second study cited by Mercola is a study in ferrets that was presented at the 2012 Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy. All Mercola could provide was a reference to a MedPage Today article. I wonder why, given that the actual study is easily locatable on PubMed, and I did locate it, where the authors conclude:
Although ferrets are considered the ideal animal model for human influenza infection, there are anticipated differences in immunologic and clinical aspects of immunization, infection and illness responses (timing, dosing and intensity) across species. Overall patterns may be compared but ferret studies do not support precise quantification of actual risk in humans. The greater likelihood of more severe disease based on several clinical indicators (weight loss, lung virus titers) among vaccinated compared to unvaccinated ferrets may not replicate the greater likelihood of medically-attended A(H1N1)pdm09 illness we previously reported in vaccinated humans.
Unsurprisingly, Mercola neglects to provide the appropriate level of uncertainty about this review article, as mentioned in this commentary by Marry McKenna:
But the authors warn that, since all four studies were observational, even careful design cannot rule out the possibility that some undetected methodologic bias affected the results. That caution is echoed in a companion editorial, written by US researchers unconnected to the Canadian study, who cite the contradictory results of six other studies conducted in Mexico, Australia, and the United States at the same time as the Canadian ones. Four of those studies found no association between seasonal flu vaccination and pandemic flu illness, while the two done in Mexico paradoxically found that seasonal flu shots may have had a protective effect.
And:
“We have looked at our data at the CDC nationally,” Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the CDC, said on Sept. 25, 2009. “I have looked carefully at the data from New York City where we had a very large outbreak and lots of information about what vaccine was received. The Australians have looked at it and published their information. And in none of those data is there any suggestion that the seasonal flu vaccine has any impact on your likelihood of getting H1N1. If data is published in the scientific literature, by all means, we would love to see it. If there’s preliminary data, we would love to see it. But nothing that we’ve seen suggests that that is likely to be a problem.”
Funny how Mercola neglected to mention this. What I was seeing at this point after the H1N1 pandemic was consistent with statistical noise. I was also amused to note that Danuta Skowronski also recently published a paper that found no increased risk of coronavirus or other non-influenza respiratory infection attributable to the influenza vaccine, thus refuting the “36%” claim Mercola parrots later in the article. (I also can’t resist mentioning this article that makes the case that selection bias is the reason for the apparent relationship between coronavirus diagnosis and the odds of prior influenza vaccination.)
Next up, Mercola picks more cherries:
Another study,7 published in the Journal of Virology in 2011, found the seasonal flu vaccine weakens children’s immune systems and increases their chances of getting sick from influenza viruses not included in the vaccine.
Further, when blood samples from 27 healthy, unvaccinated children and 14 children who had received an annual flu shot were compared, the former unvaccinated group was found to have naturally built up more antibodies across a wider variety of influenza strains compared to the latter vaccinated group, which is the type of situation Collignon referred to in the quote above.
Then there’s a 2012 study in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases, which found that children receiving inactivated influenza vaccines had a 4.4 times higher relative risk of contracting noninfluenza respiratory virus infections in the nine months following their inoculation.
The authors proposed the theory that “Being protected against influenza, trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine recipients may lack temporary nonspecific immunity that protected against other respiratory viruses.”
First off, the first study did not find that the seasonal flu vaccine “weakens the immune system.” Immunologists don’t use terminology like “weaken” or “strengthen” the immune system. Second, this is a small study. Third, the study compared T-cell responses of normal children unvaccinated against the flu with children with cystic fibrosis who underwent yearly vaccination. That’s different from the way Mercola described it. It’s not clear if CF affected the results. The authors tried to argue that it did not, and maybe it didn’t, but we don’t know for sure because there was not the ideal control group, as the authors themselves acknowledged. Moreover, the finding reported is much more subtle than Mercola portrayed it. Basically, the finding was that a certain subset of T-cell response was less in the children vaccinated every year, but the authors noted that a live virus vaccine didn’t have that problem.
As for the second study cited, that’s a cherry picked study. As the CDC notes:
After that study was published, many experts looked into this issue further and conducted additional studies to see if the findings could be replicated. No other studies have found this effect. It’s not clear why this finding was detected in the one study, but the majority of evidence suggests that this is not a common or regular occurrence and that flu vaccination does not, in fact, make people more susceptible to other respiratory infections.
Maria Sundaram et al. (2013). Influenza Vaccination Is Not Associated With Detection of Noninfluenza Respiratory Viruses in Seasonal Studies of Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness.
Then Mercola throws a red herring in there to distract:
So, on the one hand, studies have shown that when you get the flu vaccine, you may become more prone to flu caused by influenza viruses that are not contained in the vaccine, or other noninfluenza viral respiratory illnesses, including coronavirus infections (more on that below).
Conversely, researchers recently found that common colds caused by the betacoronaviruses OC43 and HKU1 might actually make you more resistant to SARS-CoV-2 infection, and that the resulting immunity might last as long as 17 years.
The authors suggest that if you’ve beat a common cold caused by a OC43 or HKU1 betacoronavirus in the past, you may have a 50/50 chance of having defensive T-cells that can recognize and help defend against SARS-CoV-2.
This is, of course, good news if it’s true. If the finding is replicated, it would imply that many of us who get the common cold could also as a result have some immunity to COVID-19 without ever having had it. Of course, what Mercola is up to here is not reassurance. He’s using this example to suggest plausibility of his previous Gish galloping with cherry picked studies claiming that the flu vaccine increases your susceptibility to COVID-19, even though coronaviruses are very different from influenza viruses, meaning that having cross immunity between two coronaviruses does not necessarily imply the same relationship between flu viruses and coronaviruses like SARS-CoV-2.
Finally, Mercola pulls out a claim by someone named Dr. Michael Murry on Facebook dated March 30 that the flu vaccine resulted in a higher mortality among the elderly who contracted COVID-19:
Could a new flu vaccine be partly responsible for the COVID-19 mortality rate in Italy?In case you are not aware, the…
Posted by Dr. Michael Murray on Monday, March 30, 2020
Naturally, there is no scientific evidence presented to support this wild speculation. In addition, Dr. Vasquez runs a website called Inflammation Mastery and is, in addition to being a DO, a chiropractor and a naturopath. His website screams, “Quack!” It touts something called the “Functional Inflammation Protocol”, claiming brain inflammation is a cause of pain and fibromyalgia, and a book blaming autism on the “gut-brain axis”.
In the end, what we have here from “Dr.” Mercola is nothing more than a Gish gallop of cherry picked studies and observations without context designed to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the flu vaccine. We also know that, despite extensive refutation online and in the mainstream media, the claim that influenza vaccines increase your risk of contracting COVID-19 by 36% (or by whatever) and increase your risk of dying from COVID-19 is yet another antivax slasher claim. What I mean by that is that this claim is like Jason Voorhees in the Friday the 13th movies or Michael Myers in the Halloween movies. No matter how many times you think he’s been killed at the end of one movie, he always returns for yet another sequel, and, when the sequels finally run out, there’ll always be a reboot of the series. Yes, conspiracy theories are the iconic hockey or William Shatner mask of the COVID-19/antivaxxer unholy alliance.
Mercola concludes with a warning about fast-tracked COVID-19 vaccines, which is a concern many of us on the provaccine side have brought up ourselves, thus providing the one bit of semi-reasonable concern sprinkled into the fear mongering, in order to provide a touch of plausibility. Also, there’s the grift. There’s always the grift, complete with a plug for an antivaccine conference in October by the National Vaccine Information Center, Barbara Loe Fisher’s antivaccine organization that Mercola has been generously supporting for over a decade.
Because of course there is.

COVID-19 “super-spreaders” and “super-spreading events”: The controversy
Evidence is emerging suggesting that COVID-19 does not spread equally. A minority of infected individuals seem to spread the virus easily to many people, while most infected individuals spread it to few others or no one at all, likely through a combination of circumstance, environment, and possibly biology. Why is this, and what does it mean for coronavirus containment strategies?
David Gorski on July 20, 2020
Link

SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes the disease known as COVID-19, is a novel virus. It is undeniably true that science has made many discoveries about the virus and disease in record time (remember, the first cases were only reported only late last year in China), including isolating the offending coronavirus and sequencing its genome in record time, developing tests for it, and even finding potential treatments that appear to decrease mortality, such as dexamethasone and remdesivir. However, even with the rapid pace of discovery, some of it based on what we know about other coronaviruses, including SARS and MERS, and at times showing science at its messiest, thus leaving the door open to grifters and conspiracy theorists, there still remain many mysteries about COVID-19, how it is spread, how its spread can be prevented and slowed, and why a minority of people become ill with life-threatening disease while the majority do not, with a third or more having no symptoms at all, or symptoms so mild that they don’t think much of them.
We’ve written before about the recent controversy over whether COVID-19 can spread through aerosols (answer: probably, but it’s complicated) and whether masks work to slow the infection (answer: yes, contrary to the misinformation being spread about masks). These are not just academic questions. Given how COVID-19 is spreading rapidly in many parts of the US, perhaps the most urgent question remains, amazingly enough; How does COVID-19 most efficiently spread? If we can target how COVID-19 spreads, we have the best chance of having the most impact in slowing down its spread. This brings us to the topic of so-called “super-spreaders” and “super-spreading events”. It’s a great example of how confusing science at the “bleeding edge” can be and, more importantly, how hard it is to make decisions based on science when the science is still uncertain and in flux.
An article yesterday in the Washington Post by Ariana Eunjung Cha, unfortunately, starts with just such an event in my state:
It wasn’t until Day 7 of her team’s coronavirus investigation when it dawned on Linda Vail, the health officer for Michigan’s Ingham County, that this was going to be a big one. It had started with just two infections at the college bar on June 18, not long after the state began reopening. But the numbers quickly jumped to 12, then 18, then 34.
As of Friday, she was staring at a spreadsheet with 187 infected at Harper’s Restaurant and Brew Pub.
“The tables were six feet apart, but no one stayed there,” she said. “The DJ was playing music so people were shouting, the dance floor started to get crowded. We had flattened the curve and then boom.”
The East Lansing case is what’s known as a super-spreading event — possibly the largest so far in the United States among the general public. Many scientists say such infection bursts — probably sparked by a single, highly infectious individual who may show no signs of illness and unwittingly shares an enclosed space with many others — are driving the pandemic. They worry these cases, rather than routine transmission between one infected person and, say, two or three close contacts, are propelling case counts out of control.
More than 1,000 suspected clusters — ranging from the single digits to thousands — have been logged in a database compiled by a coder in the Netherlands. A megachurch in South Korea. A political rally in Madrid. An engagement party in Rio de Janeiro. Nearly all took place indoors, or in indoor-outdoor spaces.
These “super-spreader” events all share certain characteristics. Specifically, nearly all of them took place indoors or in indoor-outdoor spaces. Unfortunately, although so-called “COVID parties“, parties in which people intentionally try to be infected with COVID-19, are probably far more urban legend than reality, there are lots of events still occurring in which people don’t wear masks, don’t social distance, and are in general very cavalier and careless about the possibility of contracting COVID-19, such as underground parties being held in New York City.
While we know that COVID-19 is mostly spread by larger respiratory droplets, there’s emerging evidence that it can also be spread by aerosols, smaller respiratory droplets that can hang in the air a lot longer. (Again, I discussed this issue in detail a couple of weeks ago.) Now, here’s the strange part:
Why, for instance, didn’t the earliest infections in the United States, or the infamous Lake of the Ozarks party, spur lots of cases, while a much smaller gathering at a Michigan bar produced nearly 200? Why out of countless large gatherings held — church services, soccer games, choir rehearsals, and Zumba classes — did only a fraction ignite significant infections?
Part of the uneven spread of the coronavirus — and the phenomenon of superspreading — can be explained by extreme individual variation in infectivity, researchers say.
Some people will not transmit the virus to anyone, contact tracing has shown, while others appear to spread the virus with great efficiency. Overall, researchers have estimated in recent studies that some 10 to 20 percent of the infected may be responsible for 80 percent of all cases.
Scientists are only starting to understand the different factors — physiological, behavioral, environmental — that play a role in amplifying transmission.
There’s a term used by infectious disease experts known as R0 (pronounced “R-not”), which is an estimate of the average number of people a single individual with an infectious disease will infect. Measles, a disease we used to discuss a lot in the context of the antivaccine movement’s depressing vaccination coverage with the MMR vaccine and the measles outbreaks that have resulted, is one of the most easily transmissible viruses there is, with an R0 of around 12-18, while Ebola, which I’ve also discussed before in the context of comparing its transmissibility with measles, has an R0 of around 2, but that number is an uncertain estimate because it depends on a lot of factors.
As Carl Zimmer put it:
The new coronavirus turned out to have a reproductive number somewhere between two and three. It’s impossible to pin down an exact figure, since people’s behavior can make it easier or harder for the virus to spread. By going into lockdown, for instance, Massachusetts drove its reproductive number down from 2.2 at the beginning of March to 1 by the end of the month; it’s now at .74.
This averaged figure can also be misleading because it masks the variability of spread from one person to the next. If nine out of 10 people don’t pass on a virus at all, while the 10th passes it to 20 people, the average would still be two.
One critical factor is that COVID-19 can spread from people who are either presymptomatic (they don’t have symptoms yet but go on to develop symptoms) or asymptomatic (they never go on to develop symptoms), meaning that people who can transmit the disease often interact with people while releasing the virus. One prominent common trope spread by COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and deniers of the severity of the pandemic is that asymptomatic COVID-19 patients do not spread the virus, but the evidence for asymptomatic spread has become much stronger over the last couple of months, along with the evidence that facemasks work to slow the spread of coronavirus.
There also appear to be large differences in how effectively a given infected person spreads COVID-19. For example, in a recent study out of Hong Kong that is currently available as a preprint—as always, remember that this means it hasn’t undergone peer review yet—researchers investigated several COVID-19 clusters and looked at the results of contact tracing to determine the chain of transmission. What they found in these “super-spreading events” is that about 20% of those infected were responsible for about 80% of viral transmission. Another group, consisting of around 10% of the total, infected one or two others, consistent with an R0 of around 1.5, while the remaining 70% didn’t infect anyone at all. The reasons for this difference were not entirely clear:
Superspreading is considered a function of both variations in individual transmissibility and individual susceptibility or exposure. Our results show that the number of individual secondary cases was significantly higher within social settings such as bars and restaurants compared to family or work exposures (p<0.001). This is certainly due to the greater numbers of contacts expected in such settings. Social exposures are therefore at an increased risk for SARS-CoV-2 transmission and likely constitute the core behavioural risk factor for SSEs. Targeted interventions should therefore focus on reducing extreme numbers of social contacts at high-risk venues such as bars, nightclubs and restaurants, which also appear at increased risk of SSE (22), either via closures or physical distancing policies, both of which currently remain implemented in Hong Kong (17).
There are other studies that come to similar conclusions. For example, in this one from Israel, currently in preprint, investigators sequenced 212 SARS-CoV-2 nucleotide sequences and used the information to perform a comprehensive analysis to trace the origins and spread of the virus, estimating an R0 of around 2.0 to 2.6 and noting large differences in transmission of SARS-CoV-2, with around 1-10% of infected individuals resulting in 80% of secondary infections. Another study, this one from Georgia and also in preprint, estimates that 2% of individuals seeded 20% of cases. There’s also another parameter, the k-value, which estimates how much viral infections tend to cluster, which has been estimated to be around 0.1, indicating that 10% of infected people might be responsible for 80% of secondary spread.
These observations have significant implications, if they are borne out in further research. As noted in May in Science:
That could explain some puzzling aspects of this pandemic, including why the virus did not take off around the world sooner after it emerged in China, and why some very early cases elsewhere—such as one in France in late December 2019, reported on 3 May—apparently failed to ignite a wider outbreak. If k is really 0.1, then most chains of infection die out by themselves and SARS-CoV-2 needs to be introduced undetected into a new country at least four times to have an even chance of establishing itself, Kucharski says. If the Chinese epidemic was a big fire that sent sparks flying around the world, most of the sparks simply fizzled out.
Especially compared with other viruses:
The lower k is, the more transmission comes from a small number of people. In a seminal 2005 Nature paper, Lloyd-Smith and co-authors estimated that SARS—in which superspreading played a major role—had a k of 0.16. The estimated k for MERS, which emerged in 2012, is about 0.25. In the flu pandemic of 1918, in contrast, the value was about one, indicating that clusters played less of a role.
So we know that COVID-19 tends to spread in clusters. What could be the factors that determine who is and is not a “super-spreader”? We already know that enclosed indoor spaces are conducive to the spread of coronavirus. It’s been speculated that the situation matters more than the person infected. Yes, there could be biological differences among people regarding how much coronavirus reproduces and how much virus is in their respiratory droplets, but scientists suspect it’s the situation that matters more:
Some people also have more opportunity to get sick, and to then make other people sick. A bus driver or a nursing home worker may sit at a hub in the social network, while most people are less likely to come into contact with others — especially in a lockdown.
Dr. Nelson suspects the biological differences between people are less significant. “I think the circumstances are a lot more important,” she said. Dr. Lloyd-Smith agreed. “I think it’s more centered on the events.”A lot of transmission seems to happen in a narrow window of time starting a couple days after infection, even before symptoms emerge. If people aren’t around a lot of people during that window, they can’t pass it along.
And certain places seem to lend themselves to superspreading. A busy bar, for example, is full of people talking loudly. Any one of them could spew out viruses without ever coughing. And without good ventilation, the viruses can linger in the air for hours.
Still, scientists don’t discount the possibility of biological differences as a cause for “super-spreading”:
While it’s often impossible to identify the person who triggered an outbreak, there have been some commonalities among those who have been pinpointed as the likely source in studies. They tend to be young. Asymptomatic. Social.
Scientists suspect these “super-emitters” may have much higher levels of the virus in their bodies than others, or may release them by talking, shouting or singing in a different way from most people. Research based on the flu, which involved college students blowing into a tube, showed that a small percentage tended to emit smaller particles known as aerosols more than others. These particles tend to hang or float, and move with the flow of air — and therefore can go much farther and last longer than larger droplets.
In a study published in Emerging Infectious Diseases by Japan’s Hitoshi Oshitani at Tohoku University of 22 superspreading individuals with the coronavirus, about half were under the age of 40, and 41 percent were experiencing no symptoms.
This is mainly speculation, though. There is a paucity of evidence supporting even the existence of especially infectious people with COVID-19.
Personally, I’m more on the side of concluding that it’s more the situation, than the biology of the infected, that determines who can be a “super-spreader”. However, I also did several PubMed searches, and I must admit that the literature on this phenomenon is very confusing right now. It also doesn’t help that “super-spreader” doesn’t have a very clear epidemiological definition, as discussed in depth in this article by Emma Cave. She notes that this is not a new term and is defined (usually in retrospect) as an individual who has a greater than average propensity to infect a larger number of people. (Perhaps the most famous example of a “super-spreader” was Typhoid Mary.)
However, the terms “super-spreader” and “super-spreading” are problematic for a number of reasons, as Cave argues. Again, its precise meaning in epidemiology remains rather vaguely defined. More importantly, though, it is a term that can easily take on a moral judgment and be used to blame certain individuals:
The term is particularly problematic when applied to individual ‘super-spreaders’, as it can mean different things to different groups. Media interest in super-spreaders focuses on the early stages of the epidemic when efforts are being made to contain, trace and delay. Used in this way, a ‘super-spreader’ will generally have interacted with a larger than average number of people, making tracing difficult or impossible. At the other end of the spectrum, scientific interest can focus on the heterogeneity of populations in the transmission of infectious disease. Used in this sense, ‘super-spreading’ is connected to the scientific nature of the virus and the way it manifests in some humans. There is speculation that some people with COVID-19 are especially infectious (Boseley and Belam 2020).
Super-spreading is therefore a product of biological, behavioural and environmental factors. It can be used to describe decisions, policies, events, settings and individuals—in fact, anything that contributes to increased rates of infection can be seen (by some groups) as super-spreading. The wide and varied use of the term ‘super-spreader’ is problematic for two reasons considered in subsequent sections: it can lead to apportionment of moral blame to alleged super-spreaders and it could detract from scientific investigation into heterogeneity of COVID-19 if misunderstanding leads to diminished public support and trust.
Cave concludes by proposing that a different, more neutral term be used. She makes a good argument.
The COVID-19 pandemic has, unfortunately, provided a perfect storm of information mixed with misinformation and rapidly changing science that confuses not just the general public but the public policy response. The entire issue of “super-spreading” is one such issue. On the other hand, if “super-spreading events” really are the main driver of the COVID-19 pandemic, it could be possible to tailor a public health response that isn’t so blunt, that doesn’t limit so much of what we can do. For example, in Japan health officials have noted that “many COVID-19 clusters were associated with heavy breathing in close proximity, such as singing at karaoke parties, cheering at clubs, having conversations in bars, and exercising in gymnasiums”, and Japan’s Prime Minister’s Office and the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare announced three situations that could increase the risk for COVID-19 cases and advised the population to avoid the “Three Cs”: closed spaces with poor ventilation, crowded places, and close-contact settings.
And wear a mask!
I’ll conclude by warning that the tsunami of misinformation mixed with rapidly evolving science is likely to continue to get worse before it gets better. There’s an election coming up, and it’s likely that science will be politicized even more than it’s been thus far, particularly as various candidates for vaccines go into clinical trials and preliminary results are breathlessly reported to the press. That, however, is a topic for another day.

Superspreading Events
Superspreader events seem to play a large role in spreading COVID-19, which gives us a powerful method of reducing spread.
Steven Novella on November 4, 2020
Link

We are getting to one full year of the COVID-19 pandemic, which does feel like a long time, but it’s important to remember a couple of things. First, this is a relatively new virus and we still have a great deal to learn about it. Also, we are still in the middle of this pandemic. In fact, we are at the beginning of a third peak which looks to be bigger than the first two. It increasingly looks like this pandemic has a long way to go, and we will likely need an effective vaccine to get back to some semblance of pre-pandemic normal.
One of the aspects of COVID-19, and the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes it, that we are still studying is the epidemiology – how does the virus spread? The more we know about how this virus spreads, the better we will be able to take steps to minimize it. For example, we now know that the primary way the virus is spread is through droplets which are spread directly from one person to another. This is why mask-wearing and social distancing are effective, and remain the primary methods of reducing spread. But we also know that the virus can spread through aerosolized smaller droplets, which means they can be carried long distances and spread from one person to the next just by being in the same enclosed space. This means we need to avoid large indoor crowds, and that indoor spaces should be well ventilated. Physical spread through direct contact or indirect contact via fomites (like door handles) plays a smaller role, but is still important, necessitating hand washing and wiping down surfaces.
One question researchers have been tracking is the role of so-called superspreader events, by definition when one person spreads the virus to more than six other individuals. David Gorski wrote about this question previously, but we have already learned more since then. Even three months ago we knew that the virus does not spread uniformly. The basic reproduction number for COVID-19 – on average how many people will each infected person spread the virus to – is three. That’s actually a high number and makes this a very infectious illness. But this obviously does not mean that everyone who catches COVID-19 will spread it to three other people; this is just an average. Some people may spread the virus to no one while others spread it to many people. 
A new study adds some further insight into this question. Researchers at MIT modeled the spread of SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 based on published reports of superspreading events. These are considered extreme events, because they deviate significantly from the average. But the question is: how common are such events and how much of a role do they play in the overall spread of the virus? In mathematical terms, how “fat” is the statistical tail? This refers to a graph of the numbers of people that each infected person spreads the virus to. There will be a peak around 3 with a tail to the left (down to zero) and the right. The fatter the right tail, the more common are extreme spreader events where one person spreads the virus to many people.
Their data confirms what was previously suspected – the graph of COVID-19 spreaders has a fat tail, with extreme superspreader events being fairly common. As David pointed out in his previous article, it was estimated that between 10-20% of those infected are responsible for 80% of new cases. The new models confirm that basic picture, with most cases coming from relatively few superspreader events (if you count all the subsequent people infected by those who were infected at a superspreader event).
This information also tells us how best to limit the spread of this virus – avoid superspreader events. This means avoiding large gatherings of people, especially indoors. The researchers suggest that gatherings in hot zones should be limited to 10 people or fewer. Smaller gatherings also make it easy to social distance. When possible such events should be outdoors.
But it is important to recognize that being outdoors is not a panacea. Often I hear people say that they can relax their mask-wearing and social distancing because they are outdoors. The White House superspreader event was outdoors, just giving one example of why this is not true. Being outdoors limits aerosolized spread, but does not limit large droplet spread, which is the main vector of spread anyway. If you are talking to someone a few feet away without a mask, you are showering them in droplets from your mouth, and if those droplets are teeming with SARS-CoV-2 they will likely catch it, whether or not you are outdoors.
Even before, but certainly with this new study, it is fairly clear that one of the most effective methods for minimizing the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic is to limit large gatherings. This one step can prevent superspreader events, which can reduce the spread of the virus by as much as 80%. This is inconvenient, but a lot less inconvenient than getting COVID-19. We may just have to accept this reality until we can widely distribute an effective vaccine.

COVID-19 parties: Urban legend or real thing?
You’ve probably seen breathlessly scolding stories in the media about young people holding “COVID parties”, in which attendees intentionally try to become infected with COVID-19. Are these parties really a thing, or are they an urban legend? The answer is not entirely clear yet, but current evidence (more specifically, the lack of evidence) for them is much more consistent with the latter more than the former.
David Gorski on July 13, 2020
Link

Today I’m going to write about something that’s been bugging me for a couple of months now. It’s a topic a little different than the usual topics on SBM, more of a discussion of general skepticism and critical thinking, but it’s useful to discuss, as it’s about COVID-19 stories that are, at best, implausible, unproven, and unlikely, and, at worst, urban legends. I’m referring to the phenomenon known as “COVID parties”. No doubt you’ve seen several news stories about so-called “COVID parties”, in which people allegedly gather in order to intentionally catch SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. There was one such story on TV just yesterday from ABC News, and it followed a familiar template:
From the text of the story:
“I think I made a mistake. I thought this was a hoax, but it’s not.”
Those were the final words of a 30-year-old patient who died at Methodist Hospital in San Antonio this week after attending a so-called “COVID party,” according to the hospital.
Dr. Jane Appleby, chief medical officer for Methodist Hospital and Methodist Children’s Hospital, said in a recorded statement that the unidentified patient told nurses about the party, which she said is hosted by someone diagnosed with coronavirus.
“The thought is people get together to see if the virus is real and if anyone gets infected,” Appleby said.
Let’s look at another such story. This one was promoted by a former Florida Health Department geographic data scientist named Rebekah Jones who was fired in May after, according to her account, refusing to “manipulate” COVID-19 data to justify reopening and set up a new data dashboard called Florida COVID Action in order to counter the state’s numbers, which she deemed inaccurate and manipulated in order to make the situation in Florida seem less severe. (Obviously, the state’s response denies this.) In any event, here’s the story:
Carsyn Leigh Davis https://t.co/OyAZ2P1C30
— Rebekah Jones (@GeoRebekah) July 6, 2020
In response to national reporting on the issue, the original Story about Carsyn Leigh Davis on Florida Covid Victims has been altered. Thankfully, the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org still exists, allowing me to go back to the original story. By way of background, Carsyn had multiple severe health issues, including an autoimmune disorder and cancer, which she had survived at the time of contracting COVID-19.
Here’s the story as originally published:
With all the public articles relating to this poor girl’s death on June 23, and all the interviews done with Carsyn’s mother, why did so many fail to ask her why and how Carsyn got sick?
The Florida Department of Law Enforcement detailed the last two weeks of Carsyn’s life in a public Medical Examiner’s report.
On June 10, Carysn’s mom, Carole, took Carsyn, a 16-year-old girl who was immuno-compromised with a history of health issues (including cancer), to a “COVID party” at her church, where more than 100 children without masks were in attendance.
Her mom, who is not a doctor, then prescribed her daughter azithromycin, an anti-bacterial drug with no known benefits for fighting COVID-19, for several days. During that “treatment period,” Carsyn developed headaches, sinus pressure and a cough.
A few days later, without taking her to a doctor, her mother would later report that her daughter “looked gray” on June 19, so she put Carsyn on her grandfather’s oxygen machine.
Ultimately:
Carsyn immediately worsened and was finally taken to medical professionals where she admitted to the Pediatric ICU.
When she couldn’t breathe on her own, her mother declined intubation.
The hospital began plasma therapy on June 20-21, but the damage to Carsyn’s cardio-respiratory system was too severe and she was ordered to be intubated on June 22. She died the next day.
Now, don’t get me wrong. What Carsyn’s mother, Carol Brunton Davis, did was incredibly irresponsible. She brought her daughter to a church party with roughly 100 children, where masks were not worn and social distancing was not enforced. But is this evidence that Carsyn had attended a “COVID party”? It turns out that, if you read the actual coroner’s report that was referenced in Jones’ original post, it was not. All the report says about how Carsyn contracted COVID-19 is this:
On June 10, the decedent attended a church function with 100 other children. She did not wear a mask. Social distancing was not followed. The parents prophylactically treated her with azithromycin (6/10-6/15).
The best that Jones could come up with was that the First Youth Church, the church that hosted the party, called the party a “Release Party”:
Church called their covid party a "Release Party," and hosted hundreds of people, including more than 100 children, often wrote about covid being God's will pic.twitter.com/UrODqAozMX pic.twitter.com/zNvrt9tXOQ
— Rebekah Jones (@GeoRebekah) July 7, 2020
So, there was no evidence that this was a “COVID party”. Was it irresponsible—reckless, even—to hold such a party? Yes, definitely. The church was in essence asking for a COVID outbreak by hosting such a party, and the mother was irresponsible in the extreme to have allowed her immunocompromised daughter to attend such a party. However, say what you will about the extreme recklessness of it all, there is no evidence of intent to intentionally catch COVID-19. Indeed, the fact that the mother “prophylactically” treated her daughter with azithromycin is strongly suggestive that her intent was to prevent her daughter from contracting COVID-19, given that azithromycin has been touted, in combination with hydroxychloroquine, as a very effective treatment for COVID-19 by a group that includes a “brave maverick” French Doctor named Didier Raoult, as well as Donald Trump, his economic advisor Peter Navarro, and even Dr. Oz. (The girl’s parents later treated her with hydroxychloroquine as well after she developed symptoms. Her father is a physician’s assistant and could thus prescribe the drug.) Remember, “COVID party” implies that the idea is similar to measles parties, namely that the attendees contract the disease in order to “get it over with” and become immune. Even if the church did say that whether one caught COVID-19 or not is “God’s will” does not mean that there was intent for kids to catch coronavirus, although it does indicate religious-inspired indifference.
It wasn’t long before Rebekah Jones faced backlash for her characterization of a death that was horrific enough without the misrepresentation:
The case has drawn backlash from critics in the medical field after it was reported over the weekend by Florida data scientist Rebekah Jones on her Florida COVID Victims site, the Post reported. Jones describes the church function as a “COVID Party” and alleges that the teen’s mother, nurse Carole Brunton Davis, brought her to the event to “intentionally expose her immuno-compromised daughter to this virus.”
As you might imagine, I was one of those “critics in the medical field”.
These stories are not new, at least compared to the pandemic. It turns out that there are a lot of these stories, dating back to even March, when Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear announced that at least one person in Kentucky is infected after taking part at a “coronavirus party,” with a group of young adults and partygoers intentionally getting together “thinking they were invincible” and purposely defying state guidance to practice social distancing. Note that this one sounds a bit more plausible in that there have been a fair number of gatherings among people, but, again, there is no evidence presented that this party was hosted with the intent of partygoers to become infected. It’s not just the US, either. In Belgium, Het Laatste Nieuws reported in March that many people celebrated the evening right before new lock-down rules took effect. This was clearly a “one last fling” kind of event, where one last party was held before the lockdown put a stop to parties. In Manchester, England, police had to break up 660 partiesover Easter weekend.
The first example of warnings about “COVID parties” that I could find dates back to early April, when an epidemiology professor named Greta Bauer published a New York Times op-ed, perhaps in response to the story from Kentucky, “Please, Don’t Intentionally Infect Yourself. Signed, an Epidemiologist“.
A month later, in early May, the Washington Department of Health Tweeted this, perhaps the earliest report of “COVID parties” in the US that gained wide attention:
We've been getting reports of “coronavirus parties” where uninfected people are mingling with #COVID19 positive individuals intentionally to try to contract the virus. Bad idea! This is dangerous and puts people at risk for hospitalization or even death. https://t.co/3hZYF7KjQN
— Washington State Department of Health (@WADeptHealth) May 7, 2020
The statement:
Washington State Department of Health officials are alarmed by reports of “coronavirus parties” in which uninfected people are mingling with COVID-19 positive individuals to try to contract the virus.
“Gathering in groups in the midst of this pandemic can be incredibly dangerous and puts people at increased risk for hospitalization and even death,” John Wiesman, Washington State Secretary of Health said. “Furthermore, it is unknown if people who recover from COVID-19 have long-term protection. There is still a lot we don’t know about this virus, including any long-term health issues which may occur after infection. This kind of unnecessary behavior may create a preventable uptick in cases which further slows our state’s ability to gradually re-open.”
DOH encourages every Washingtonian to continue to follow Governor Inslee’s Stay Home, Stay Healthy order.
Oops:
Rumblings had developed into rumors by the start of May, when a public health official in Walla Walla, Washington, claimed to have discovered, via careful contact tracing, that at least two patients had indeed attended “Covid parties” so as to “get it over with.” The local police chief told reporters that he wouldn’t rule out criminal charges for any other such events, but assured them that “we’re not going to overreact.” Two days later, the same public health official admitted she’d been wrong: “We have discovered that there were not intentional Covid parties,” she said. “Just innocent endeavors.”
Perhaps the most outrageous “COVID party” story so far made the rounds in the media a couple of weeks ago. It occurred in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, and…well, I’ll quote a typical story about the event, with a clickbait headline, “Tuscaloosa students held parties, bet on who got coronavirus first“:
Several college students in an Alabama city organized “COVID-19” parties as a contest to see who would get the virus first, officials said.
Tuscaloosa City Councilor Sonya McKinstry said students hosted the parties to intentionally infect each other with the new coronavirus, news outlets reported.
McKinstry said party organizers purposely invited guests who tested positive for COVID-19. She said the students put money in a pot and whoever got COVID first would get the cash.
“It makes no sense,” McKinstry said. “They’re intentionally doing it.”
Tuscaloosa Fire Chief Randy Smith confirmed the incidents to the City Council Tuesday.
The department thought the parties were rumors but Smith said after some research, the department found out the parties were real.
“We did some research. Not only do the doctors’ offices confirm it but the state confirmed they also had the same information,” Smith said.
I smelled BS immediately, a story that reeked of urban legend. Could such “COVID-catching” parties have happened? Possibly, although the plausibility is rather low. Whether they happened or not, the stories, like the one above and so many other stories filled with slack-jawed coverage of these alleged parties don’t provide anything resembling compelling evidence that they occurred. This particular story’s only source was a single city councilwoman named Sonya McKinstry whose claim was based on secondhand and thirdhand information, with all the “corroboration” coming from—you guessed it!—second and thirdhand reports from people without direct knowledge. No one who had attended such a party was interviewed. There was no epidemiological evidence presented, such as from contact tracers tracing COVID-19 outbreaks to such parties or data showing people attending such parties all contracted the same strain of COVID-19.
Part of what I think is going on is that media outlets have been anxious to attribute intent (specifically, intent to get infected) that is likely not there. What is there, clearly, is either indifference or disbelief that coronavirus is a threat. One might argue that that’s a distinction without a difference. After all, there might be very little practical difference between a party of people not social distancing and not wearing masks because they scoff at the virus and a party of people not social distancing and not wearing masks attending a party where people known to have COVID-19 will attend because they want to contract coronavirus, but there is a difference in the public discourse: An overwhelming desire to blame someone, to shame someone. For that, intent to become infected is much more blameworthy than indifference or denial. It’s also far more clickbaity.
As E. J. Dickson wrote in Rolling Stone about the Walla Walla story after the Washington Department of Health had walked back its claim that there had been “COVID parties”:
In other words, people had contracted COVID-19 from attending parties, but did not attend for the purpose of contracting COVID-19 — a far more believable, if not less headline-grabby, version of events. But at that point, the story of coronavirus parties had already been credulously aggregated by multiple national news outlets, and the Washington State Department of Health, however, has yet to amend its statement or its original tweet.
In a statement to Rolling Stone, the public information for the DOH said: “The state Department of Health is encouraged to hear that reports of COVID-19 parties in the Walla Walla area may not have been accurate. Unfortunately, this was not the first time we had heard that these parties may be happening locally and nationally.” She added that the department wanted to be clear that “we strongly believe COVID-19 parties can be incredibly dangerous.”
Ultimately, the coronavirus-party story went viral for the same reason that all social distancing-shaming content does: it gives people cooped up in their homes a reason to pat themselves on the back and congratulate themselves for their own sacrifices. There’s also undoubtedly an element of generational animosity at play here: if you believe that young people are all selfish assholes, then you’re more likely to believe that they’re gathering en masse to purposefully infect themselves with a potentially deadly virus.
So could “COVID parties” be a thing? Certainly, it’s not impossible. After all, antivaxxers have long been known to hold measles and chickenpox parties in order to intentionally infect their children to achieve “natural immunity”, although I’ve always thought that such parties are far less common than they are portrayed as being. On the other hand, although it’s possible there have been honest-to-goodness “COVID parties” in which attendees intend to become infected to “get it over with,” there is very good reason to doubt many of the stories so credulously regurgitated by the press.
And, as Gilead Edelman at WIRED put it:
It is, of course, technically impossible to rule out the existence of Covid parties. Maybe somewhere in this vast and complex nation there are some foolish people getting infected on purpose. It’s also possible that the miasma of media coverage will coalesce into a vector of its own, inspiring Covid parties that otherwise would not have happened. But so far there’s no hard evidence that even a single one has taken place—just a recurring cycle of breathless, unsubstantiated media coverage.
It’s also been noted that these “COVID party” stories share similarities with previous moral panics and urban legends. As Edelman notes:
The press just can’t stop pushing the narrative that people are trying to get themselves infected. And they always seem to push it the same way: Local reporters write down what some official said, and then national publications pick up those claims, citing the local reports as evidence. At no point in this chain has anyone bothered to confirm the underlying claim. The whole thing is reminiscent of the supposed scourge, in the mid-2000s, of “pharm parties,” at which America’s wayward teens were said to put their parents’ prescription drugs into a bowl and then consume them at random. This did not really happen.
As Dickson also notes:
There’s good reason for this, says urban folklorist Benjamin Radford: “coronavirus parties” are probably BS. “They’re a variation of older disease urban legends such as the ‘bug chaser’ stories about people trying to get AIDS,” he tells Rolling Stone, referring to a brief spate in the early-aughts when so-called “bug-chasing” parties were subject to extensive media coverage (including a controversial story by this magazine). Such stories fed into a general sense of “moral panic” over the disease, resulting in it sticking around in the public imagination regardless of the lack of supporting evidence.
Indeed, there is an element to these stories that reminds me of the satanic ritual abuse moral panic that originated in the United States in the 1980s and spread throughout many parts of the world by the late 1990s. There’s never hard evidence presented, and the press credulously lapped up lurid stories.
Why do these stories proliferate, though? I think Edelman is on to something here:
Why do these stories keep catching on? In part, it’s thanks to journalists’ long-standing and uncritical reliance on the pronouncements of public officials. These tales also reinforce existing stereotypes—anti-vaxxer hippies in rural Washington, MAGA bros in the Deep South—and may scratch a psychic itch among readers who already tend to pin responsibility for the ongoing pandemic on other people’s bad choices.
The reality is distressing enough, thank you very much. People may not be throwing Covid parties, but they are throwing parties where Covid spreads, which is just as bad.
Unfortunately, right now it’s very hard not to argue that the response of the United States to the COVID-19 pandemic has been anything other than an utter disaster. Contrary to claims that we are entering a “second wave” of COVID-19 infections, in actuality we never left the first wave. Daily case counts had been gradually falling between early April and early June, but case counts are now skyrocketing, leading to Kara Gavin at Michigan Health to say that the “COVID-19 curve has unflattened fast.” Daily case counts are climbing in at least 33 states, leading to overtaxed hospitals and intensive care units in what are currently the most hard-hit states, Arizona, Texas, and Florida.
Edelman sardonically (and quite correctly) notes that, even if COVID-19 parties were a real thing, rather than events that are likely either rare or nonexistent, even “if there really were infected frat boys pounding beers and doing snot-shots, it would hardly matter” and that their “bad behavior would be a mere sideshow” to a massive policy failure that led to coronavirus raging, in essence, out of control throughout huge swaths of the US. In the meantime, whenever you see stories about events like “COVID-19” parties, be skeptical. Look at the evidence presented. Is it just the pronouncement of a government or law enforcement official based on secondhand or thirdhand stories? Is there any other corroborating evidence of a more concrete and objective nature? So far, for every “COVID party story” I’ve seen, the answer is “no” to both questions. I’m not ruling out the possibility that these parties happen, and maybe one day there will be an account with undeniable (or at least compelling) evidence that these parties are a thing. I have not yet seen such a story yet.

Spike Proteins, COVID-19, and Vaccines
A new study further elucidates the role of spike proteins in COVID-19.
Steven Novella on May 5, 2021
Link

A recent study looks at the effects of the SARS-CoV-2 spike proteins, showing that they can cause some of the harm of COVID-19 by themselves. This is an important advance in our understanding of the disease and hopefully will lead to new therapeutic interventions.
The spike protein is what gives the coronavirus family of viruses their name. The spikes jut out from the surface of the spherical virus, giving it a crown-like halo, hence “corona”. We have also known for a long time that the spike protein is the business end of these viruses, it is what gives the virus its ability to target, latch onto, and enter the cells that it infects. Mutations in the spike protein are also what determine different variants of SARS-CoV-2, and can alter its ability to infect and cause harm.
The new study, however, is the first to directly show that the spike proteins themselves are able to cause harm, and also confirms that COVID-19 is primarily a vascular disease that damages blood vessel walls.
What the researchers did was create a pseudovirus – a protein shell with spike proteins but no viral RNA inside. Therefore these pseudoviruses are unable to actually infect cells or replicate. The point was to isolate as much as possible the effects of the spike proteins themselves. They report:
We administered a pseudovirus expressing S protein (Pseu-Spike) to Syrian hamsters intratracheally. Lung damage was apparent in animals receiving Pseu-Spike, revealed by thickening of the alveolar septa and increased infiltration of mononuclear cells.
They had control animals with a mock virus that did not show this damage. The spike protein binds to the ACE2 receptor on cells, downregulates their function, and causes damage to the endothelium cells that line lung tissue and blood vessels. The damage is apparently caused by effects on the mitochondria (energy producing organelles) in the cells – they change their shape and have reduced function. They then reproduced these effects in vitro using a culture of lung endothelial cells exposed to the spike protein.
These results explain many of the clinical features of COVD-19. While the disease has been largely thought of as a respiratory illness, it is primarily a vascular disease. It affects the lungs, but also affects other organs in the body, and can cause strokes and blood clots. While the vascular effects of coronaviruses have long been known, this study demonstrates a clear mechanism of this injury. Knowing the precise mechanism may lead to treatments to prevent or limit the vascular damage from infection. The next step is to study exactly how downregulating the ACE2 receptor damages the mitochondria.
This study, of course, did not come out of the blue but was built on previous studies showing many of the same findings. It was known, for example, that the ACE2 receptor is important for coronavirus infection, and that it related to endothelium damage. In fact a comment to the FDA by Dr. Whelan nicely summarizes a lot of this research as of December 2020. This research, however, has raised some questions about the safety of the mRNA vaccines that produce spike proteins. To be clear, the safety data on the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA vaccines are now extensive, with hundreds of millions of doses give and months of data, without any significant side effects apparent.
The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines produce the full-length spike protein. Pfizer studied several formulations initially, but found that the full length protein vaccine had fewer side effects and was better tolerated than other vaccine candidates, so that is the one they went with. It is also likely that the full protein contains more epitopes (sites for immune activity) and therefore produces more thorough and longer lasting immunity. The proteins, however, are in a fixed state, they are unable to change their confirmation, which is necessary to bind to cells. So they function differently than spike proteins on infecting virus.
After the Pfizer vaccine full spike proteins are expressed on the vaccinated cells for presentation to the immune system. But the vaccine-induced proteins do not appear to cause any harmful effects. This may be because the vaccine is administered in the muscle, and so muscle cells are the ones taking up the mRNA and making spike proteins. There is a vigorous immune response which neutralizes the spike proteins before they can cause any harm. This is very different from a virus replicating throughout the body.
Unfortunately, the complexity of COVID, mRNA, immunity, and vaccines is such that those who wish to raise fears about the vaccine can exploit partial information. There is a tremendous amount of misinformation about the COVID vaccines, and the mRNA vaccines in particularly, which then has to be constantly rebutted and debunked. That has become almost a full-time job for David Gorski here at SBM. Meanwhile, there is legitimate complexity and concerns that scientists need to carefully sort out, which they are doing, transparently and vigorously.
It’s important not to confuse not knowing everything with knowing nothing. The safety data on the mRNA vaccines is robust. Most vaccine serious side effects occur within six weeks, which is why the FDA wanted at least 6 weeks of safety data before giving the vaccines an EUA. We now have more than 6 months of data, including several months with millions of doses. It is very unlikely there are any surprises still in store with either of the mRNA vaccines. The risk is vanishingly small, while the benefit is clear.

No – COVID-19 Is Not Just a “Bad Flu”
By any measure, COVID-19 is more than just a bad flu season, which is pretty bad to begin with.
Steven Novella on April 22, 2020
Link

Pandemics breed more than a contagious disease. They spread fear, misinformation, pseudoscience, and exploitation. Unfortunately our society is proving to be fertile ground for such things, and no amount of physical distancing will slow the spread of contagion over social media. And like any contagion, we can track the spread of certain strains of misinformation, that replicate and mutate with the most infectious tending to spread the widest.
One such nugget of misinformation, spread by those who are motivated to minimize the severity of COVID-19, is the narrative that this pandemic is just a bad flu season. We don’t go to extreme measures every year to minimize deaths from the flu, so why are we freaking out now? This, however, is a false comparison in many ways and entirely misses the point of physical distancing.
Flu season
The flu is a serious illness, make no mistake, and we do tend to ignore it because we have been living with it for so long. So what is a typical flu season like? Between 2010 and 2019 the annual flu season (deaths over an entire year, but not a calendar year – from the fall of one year through the spring of the next) ranged between 12,000 and 61,000 deaths in the US alone. That is from 9.3-45 million illnesses and 140-810 thousand hospitalizations. That is a significant disease burden every year, although spread out over about 8 months.
This means that the case fatality rate from getting the flu is about 0.1%. But that one number is not the only way to measure disease burden. There is also morbidity – negative health outcomes other than death. There is also the economic burden from direct health care costs and lost productivity. We can also consider lost years of life – is the flu killing mostly old sick people or young healthy people? The CDC estimates that 71-85% of flu deaths occur in those >= 65 years old. The flu also affects very young children and infants – and is generally considered to be most dangerous to the very young and the very old.
New flu strains can also be the source of pandemics of their own, such as the bird flu or H1N1 pandemics. These are generally caused by new and particularly virulent strains, and may be superimposed upon the natural cycle of the flu season.
There are two main measures that we take to minimize the morbidity and mortality from the flu. The first is targeted physical distancing – if you are symptomatic, stay at home. Don’t go to work and minimize contact with other people until you are no longer contagious. The second critical measure is the flu vaccine. The efficacy of the vaccine varies each year, because we are guessing which strains are most likely to hit us each season and those guesses, as informed as they are, may not be accurate. Even still, some coverage is better than none and it is always a good idea to get the flu vaccine every year (unless you have a medical contraindication).
The CDC estimates that for children 6 months to 17 years old flu vaccine coverage was 62.6%, and for adults 18 and over it was 45.3%. These numbers are sadly low. We would like >90% coverage to get effective herd immunity to reduce the spread of the flu.
Looking at the numbers, saying that a pandemic is a “bad flu season” is not really accomplishing the goal of minimizing it. The flu is a serious infectious illness with a substantial disease burden. The experts don’t ignore the flu, it’s just that the approach to minimizing it is public education about personal physical distancing for those who are symptomatic, good hygiene like hand washing, coughing into your elbow, and keeping surfaces clean, and getting the flu vaccine. When an actual “bad flu season” hits in the form of a flu pandemic, extreme physical distancing may be necessary.
But perhaps what one might conclude is that we have become complacent about the flu and should be more aggressive in mitigating it, not that we should be complacent about COVID-19.
The COVID-19 pandemic
Now let’s look at COVID-19. As of April 21, according to the CDC there were 776,093 cases in the US with 41,758 deaths. That is a case fatality rate of 5.3%, much higher than the flu. But that number has become highly controversial, and that’s because it is genuinely not reliable. The reason you cannot look at these numbers and compare it to the flu is that we are still in the middle of this pandemic. We won’t know the true case fatality rate until it is all over and we can look back at the numbers.
Let me first point out that these numbers are over essentially the last two months, not the 6-8 months of a typical flu season. That is critical, because one of the primary risks of the COVID-19 pandemic is that it overwhelms our resources. And in fact that is already happening. We are having shortages of personal protective equipment (PPE) and ventilators. We are stretching our ICU capacity beyond its limits. In my own hospital neurologists are being recruited to cover medical services because there aren’t enough doctors to cover the wave of COVID-19 cases. In some hospitals in New York patients are sharing ventilators. We don’t have the testing capacity to shift to an individual isolation strategy.
This is the whole point of physical distancing to “flatten the curve”. We are trying to spread out cases over a longer period of time to keep from overwhelming our medical resources. It doesn’t take much of an imagination to figure out that there will be incredible downstream negative effects, even on non-COVID-19 patients, if our hospitals are overwhelmed.
This brings up the additional point that the numbers I quotes above are with physical distancing. What would the numbers look like if we were not in the middle of a lockdown? We will never know for sure, but the models predicted about 2 million deaths in the US, and 40 million worldwide. That is similar to the 1918 flu pandemic that killed 50 million (conservatively). These “worst case” models have been highly criticized so let’s explore that a bit.
Such models are inherently variable because exponential processes like a pandemic are extremely sensitive to small changes. There are many assumptions in the models about individual behavior, infection rates, how infection rates change over time, the effects of immunity, and other variables. So they generally produce a wide range of estimates, and picking the extreme end is unlikely to be very predictive.
But we can say this – right now we have >40 thousand deaths in the US and we are clearly somewhere in the middle of this pandemic. The number of cases perhaps are just starting to flatten, but not drop, and the mortality numbers lag about two weeks behind the case numbers. The figure, therefore, is certain to climb significantly higher. And this is with the lockdown we are currently experiencing. We can argue about the details of the models, but no expert would disagree with the conclusion that the numbers would be significantly higher without physical distancing. How high we can’t know – but higher.
Also, since even now we are overwhelming our hospital capacity in hot-spots, the strain on the medical system would be much worse. It is hard to predict the effects this would have. When systems start to break down, the negative effects tend to cascade.
Now let’s take a closer look at the case fatality rate. Some have argued that the true number of cases (the denominator) is much higher because there are many unrecognized asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic cases. This is true but misleading. First, this doesn’t really affect the “case fatality” rate, if we define cases as those diagnosed with COVID-19. It is still meaningful to say that if you are diagnosed with COVID-19, the mortality rate is about 5%.
However, that number is likely even higher because the true case fatality rate is underestimated if you look at current cases, rather than only completed cases. That’s because some current cases will not survive, but they are counted as survivors if you use them in the denominator. If you look only at completed cases worldwide, the case fatality rate is 20%. That should probably be considered the high end of the range of estimates based on various methods. The low end would consider all current cases, including estimates of asymptomatic cases, which produces a mortality rate as low as 0.2%, close to the flu. But this is just as misleading as quoting a 20% case fatality rate.
The bottom line is that – we don’t know the case fatality rate, because we are still in the middle of the pandemic. I would point out, however, that just diluting the denominator with asymptomatic cases doesn’t really tell us anything about the disease burden. It makes the case fatality rate lower – by making the number of cases much higher. In the end, the number of deaths and morbidity is what we care about. We also don’t know what the seasonality of the disease will be, and if there will be a second or third wave. Remember, in the 1918 flu pandemic it was the second wave that killed the most people.
We also don’t know how good immunity is from getting the virus. Are all those asymptomatic infected people now immune? We don’t know. If there are, that’s a good thing, but we don’t currently know.
In the end, trying to minimize the severity of the COVID-19 pandemic by comparing it to a typical flu season is misleading in many ways. We know that COVID-19 is a serious illness that causes hospitalization in many cases, requiring ICU beds and ventilator support in some. In hot spots this is overwhelming our resources. The numbers are already serious, and we are still in the middle of this pandemic – hopefully, we don’t know what the future brings. We also know that without physical distancing it would be much worse, although it is difficult to say exactly how much.
The best we can do at this point is listen to the experts, but also be realistic about the nature of predicting and modeling a pandemic while we are in the middle of it.

COVID-19 and Excess Deaths
Excess deaths during the pandemic help tell a more complete picture of the impact of COVID-19.
Steven Novella on July 22, 2020
Tweet

How many people have died so far from the COVID-19 pandemic? This is actually a challenging question to answer, and there are several different approaches that can be taken. Different methods have different strengths and weaknesses, but they are all legitimate.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has the current total cases at over 14.5 million, and deaths at 607,000. The CDC calculates that the total number of cases in the US is 3.8 million, with over 140,000 deaths. The CDC details the limits of this data, however:
However, counting exact numbers of COVID-19 cases is not possible because COVID-19 can cause mild illness, symptoms might not appear immediately, there are delays in reporting and testing, not everyone who is infected gets tested or seeks medical care, and there are differences in how completely states and territories report their cases.
You may notice that all of these factors would tend to underestimate the number of COVID-19 deaths. Is there any way figures might be overestimated? Potentially – the numbers are based on death certificates which indicate the cause of death, which is determined by the doctor or coroner. If COVID-19 is listed as a causal factor in the reported death, it is counted. Doctors may list COVID-19 on the certificate if a patient died with COVID-19, even if it was not directly from COVID-19 (if they had a heart attack while suffering from the illness, for example). Also, some people may die from a respiratory illness that clinically looks like COVID-19 even though that particular virus was not confirmed by testing.
But there is little reason to think there is any significant overcounting of COVID-19 deaths. If someone is very ill from COVID-19 and they die, it is highly likely they would not have died if they were not sick from the virus. And during a pandemic, if you have an illness that clinically looks like the pandemic illness, statistically it’s a good bet that is what you have. So while it is possible there may be some overcounting, it is likely minimal and dwarfed by the underreporting. This is why most experts agree that, if anything, we are underestimating the death toll from this pandemic.
Another way to approach this question is to count so-called excess deaths. This is simply a comparison of the historical baseline death rate of a region or population compared to the actual death rate during the pandemic. It is likely that any excess deaths are either directly or indirectly due to the pandemic. This method has been used to estimate total deaths from a hurricane or other natural disaster, for example.
There have been a number of studies looking at this question. One study published in JAMA, for example, found that in the US:
…the number of deaths due to any cause increased by approximately 122 000 from March 1 to May 30, 2020, which is 28% higher than the reported number of COVID-19 deaths.
Another study looking at the early months of the pandemic in the US found that 35% of excess deaths were attributed to causes other than COVID-19, including heart disease, stroke, other pneumonia, and diabetes. The authors speculate that the number of excess deaths not attributed to COVID was higher early in the pandemic because of lack of familiarity and diagnostic testing. We now know, for example, that the illness is not purely a respiratory illness, and can cause vascular effects leading to strokes and heart attacks.
Unfortunately, we do not have good data for the entire world. In order to calculate excess deaths you need a good baseline, and you need adequate reporting of current deaths, and many countries lack this. However, data from other countries with adequate reporting has been varied but on average similar. In the UK, as of June 5th, they had 51,804 official COVID-19 deaths, but also 12,729 other excess deaths, or about 20% of the total. In Spain the percent of excess deaths not attributed to COVID-19 is 40%, Italy 33%, Netherlands 38%, but France only 3%.
So what is going on? Should we count any of these excess deaths from other causes as actually being from the pandemic? There is no way to objectively answer that question, but here are the possibilities. One is that the excess deaths are mostly directly due to COVID-19 but are simply missed or incorrectly labeled deaths. These may be people who died at home and were never tested and the cause of death is simply listed as heart failure or some other proximal cause without any link to COVID being noted, even though that was a contributing cause. They may be deaths not properly attributed for other reasons.
At the other end of the spectrum we might speculate that most of the excess deaths not attributed to illness with COVID-19 were from other causes entirely, but related to the effects of the pandemic. For example, people have been fearful of going to the ER. Hospitals have been admitting fewer strokes and heart attacks overall. There is no reason to think there is a real drop in the incidence of stroke, and so it is likely that people are just staying away. This will have an obvious negative effect on the outcome of these serious conditions. Further, we may be seeing the effect of hospital and other health care resources being overwhelmed. When the ICUs are full of COVID-19 patients, patients with other serious but unrelated medical problems may not get the care they would have outside the pandemic.
As a side note, we are seeing fewer deaths from homicides and car accidents during shutdowns, and this is obscuring some of the rise in excess deaths from other causes.
Wherever the reality is across the spectrum from direct to indirect effects of the pandemic, the total excess deaths is an important and informative number to follow. First, it shows that we are clearly not overestimating the number of COVID-19 deaths. If anything we are undercounting such deaths – the only question is, by how much? But further, the excess deaths show the total impact of the pandemic. We can argue about the relationship between the pandemic and excess deaths that cannot be tied to illness with COVID-19, but in the end what matters is the excess deaths. It is reasonable to consider this a part of the total burden of the pandemic. Teasing apart the exact causes is important in order to know how to mitigate the effects of the pandemic, but does not reduce the impact of the pandemic itself.
The pandemic is also not over yet, and in fact the worst may yet to be seen. There is a clear increase in anxiety and depression during the pandemic and the resulting economic hardships. Mental health experts are warning of a potential surge in suicides; although this has not manifested yet, the reporting and effects may simply be lagging.
It will likely be years before we can calculate the total impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, but the excess deaths we can calculate are already telling a pretty consistent story.

The Toll of COVID
We can’t take our eyes off the ball just yet – what’s the state of the pandemic?
Steven Novella on May 11, 2022
Link

Last week the US passed what many are calling a “grim milestone” – over one million deaths related to the COVID-19 pandemic. While this was dutifully reported in mainstream media, there was little fanfare or handwringing, a testament to the level of pandemic fatigue we are also experiencing. As has also been widely reported, people may be done with the pandemic, but the pandemic is not done with us. Many people I speak to, including some fellow healthcare providers, have the attitude – I’ve already caught COVID, I’m fully vaccinated, I’m just going to live my life and not worry about it anymore. This is understandable, but we have to be realistic about what this will mean.
What we are experiencing is what a world-wide pandemic looks like. The 1918 flu pandemic lasted two years and killed an estimated 50 million people worldwide. Improved medical care is mitigating the death toll of this pandemic, but perhaps it is also extending its duration. We have passed the two year mark, and experts are warning of a potential new wave this Fall. The problem, of course, is the new variants of SARS-Cov-2, with the Omicron subvariant BA.2 being of special concern.
Pandemic fatigue is everywhere as restrictions are being lifted, and Congress is stalled on passing new funding for pandemic relief. The sense of urgency is apparently gone. People want life to get back to normal, and are willing to live with COVID. At some point we do need to make this transition, just like we live with the flu every year. But timing is important, and we simply may not be ready for the consequences of what living with COVID will mean at this time. 
The WHO recently estimated that the actual death toll from COVID may be about three times the officially reported number. They estimate there were 14.9 million excess deaths in 2020 and 2021 (not even including 2022 so far). These are numbers that are starting to look like the 1918 pandemic. Some countries like India are still facing high numbers. While China may have been successful early in shutting down to prevent spread of the virus, they are facing a vulnerable population and are increasing their restrictions again.
Also, using death as the only marker for the health toll of this pandemic is misleading. Those who survive may experience significant morbidity, chronic symptoms collectively referred to as long COVID. A recent study, for example, found that having severe COVID correlates with brain shrinkage and cognitive deficits equivalent to normal aging between ages 50 and 70 – 20 years of brain aging. This was correlation only, but it is extremely likely that most or all of the correlation was caused by the infection. As a neurologist I am seeing many patients referred for cognitive, fatigue, and other neurological symptoms following COVID. People generally recover to some extent, but not always or completely.
Generally pandemics burn themselves out when enough people get infected, and therefore have some level of immunity, so that the infectious agent cannot easily spread. Also there is selective pressure toward new variants that are more contagious, but not necessarily more deadly, so by chance alone we may see highly competitive variants that are not as deadly. So far we have seen increasingly infectious variants, like Omicron, but they have not really waned in severity.
There is, of course, another way to gain resistance to infection without getting infected – vaccines. Vaccines remain our best weapon against the virus and the single most effective way to bring this pandemic to a close. In the US about 78% of the population has received at least one dose of a COVID vaccine, while about two thirds are considered fully vaccinated. While these numbers are high enough to reduce the severity of the pandemic, and have certainly helped reduce hospital admissions, they are not high enough to provide a solid herd immunity effect that would prevent waves of spreading virus. These relatively low vaccination numbers are nothing short of a self-inflicted tragedy.
Let me be the one billionth person to point out the ironic disconnect here – we are lucky to have the benefit of advanced mRNA and other vaccine technology, able to bang out multiple highly effective vaccines within a year of the pandemic emerging. And yet, a third of our population is not fully vaccinated. Around the world the numbers are more variable. Many industrialized nations have rates in the 90s. Africa lagging the most, with extremely low vaccination rates due to poor availability of the vaccine.
There is absolutely no logistical reason why the US and every industrialized nation cannot have vaccination rates higher than 95%, enough to effectively shut down this pandemic. We are experiencing a societal failure that we need to examine and remedy. This pandemic is not over, and it may not be over for a long time. Further, this will not be the last pandemic, and it likely won’t be a century until the next one.

COVID Morbidity
The emerging burden of long COVID is significant, and needs to be considered when evaluating the risk vs benefit of pandemic measures.
Steven Novella on May 26, 2021
Link
There is a known bias toward oversimplification. We like to distill complex situations down to a number, or a simple dichotomy. It allows us to mentally manage a complex world. The risk, of course, is that important details will be lost. In medicine that bias is hopefully beaten out of us by training and experience. We learn to embrace the complexity, but still we must be vigilant.
When evaluating the COVID-19 pandemic, reporting has focused almost exclusively on two numbers – the numbers of cases and the number of deaths. Many news outlets explicitly track those two numbers, with graphs and statistics. It has been a useful marker to follow the course of the pandemic. But that should not lull us into thinking these two numbers are all that matter when evaluating the total burden of this pandemic. Now that we have had more than a year of experience with COVID-19 researchers are increasingly tracking morbidity from the disease – health effects in those who survived. In short, death is not the only negative health outcome from contracting COVID.
A recent study published in PM&R looked patient records for those discharged from hospital between March and April 2020. Arguably, medical care improved throughout the pandemic as doctors gained more experience and research provided new tools. The case-fatality rate decreased over time. More updated numbers would therefore be interesting, but this does give us a glimpse at the potential morbidity of COVID. They found:
Nearly twenty percent of COVID-19 survivors discharged to a location other than their home. Forty-five percent of survivors experienced functional decline impacting their discharge. Eighty-seven (80.6%) of survivors who showed functional change during hospitalization were referred for additional therapy at discharge.
Nearly half of patients had a functional decline from their baseline. As many of these patients were older, especially early on in the pandemic, recovery was likely slow and incomplete. Another recent study published in BMJ Open looked at so-called “long COVID” – following patients for an average of 12.8 weeks after diagnosis. They found:
81.1% (596/735) reported pain and discomfort, 79.5% (584/735) problems with usual activities, 68.7% (505/735) anxiety and depression and 56.2% (413/735) problems with mobility.
This is an enormous burden, and the study documents that this affects not only the patients but their families and caregivers.
Anecdotally, as a neurologist who does not care for acute COVID illness itself but is referred patients with neurological complications and symptoms, I started seeing patients with neurological symptoms following COVID about six months into the pandemic. These numbers have steadily increased. Common complications include chronic headache and fatigue, mental fogginess, and chronic pain.
The numbers above and my experience are consistent with other published data. An Italian study, for example, found that 44% of patients had chronic symptoms of “fatigue, shortness of breath, joint pain, and chest pain, in that order”. Symptoms last for weeks or months after initial infection, and long after symptoms of acute illness, like fever, have resolved.
As we have learned more about COVID-19 these long term symptoms make sense. Originally we thought of COVID as a respiratory illness, because it presents with fever and cough. But in reality we have learned that it is also, or perhaps more so, a vascular illness. SARS-CoV-2 gets entry into cells by binding its spike protein to the ACE2 receptor – but these receptors are not found only on respiratory cells, they are widely distributed throughout the body and in many organs. This creates the potential for widespread effects of the infection, but the vascular effects appear to be dominant.
The virus attaches to blood vessels that line various organs and will also cause widespread inflammation and blood clots. The more severe the illness, of course, the more severe these effects can be, and the greater the morbidity. But even people with mild disease can have lingering symptoms.
There are at least 167 million cases of COVID so far worldwide, 33 million in the US. The health burden of long COVID is therefore potentially huge. When calculating the health cost of this pandemic, we cannot only count lives lost but also the reduce health of survivors. The death rate itself is staggering – almost 3.5 million worldwide and almost 600k in the US. This is not a “bad flu” even if just looking at the mortality numbers. But when we add the long COVID cases, the true size of the health burden becomes clearer.
This is an important point to drive home as we also, individually and collectively, calculate the risk vs. benefit of the various COVID vaccines. The vaccines currently being distributed have been proven safe and effective. As a public health measure, they are a clear home-run – extremely cost effective. When we add the emerging burden of long COVID or post-COVID disability, the benefits are even greater.
COVID morbidity needs to be part of any conversation about the risk and cost vs. benefit of any measures we contemplate to mitigate this pandemic.

Emerging Evidence of Intrauterine SARS-CoV-2 Infections
New evidence supports the potential for intrauterine spread of SARS-CoV-2 to a developing fetus. It’s uncommon, but something to take seriously. Also some good news from the AAP regarding the care of babies born to mothers with COVID-19!
Clay Jones on July 24, 2020
Link

Pregnant women apparently don’t already have enough to worry about.
Since the pandemic began, there have been numerous reports of young infants, even newborns, being diagnosed with COVID-19. While most of these infections have been mild or even asymptomatic, there have been severe cases and even reports of deaths. In newborns who have been tested, either because of the development of concerning symptoms or because of screening in the setting of maternal infection, it has been unclear exactly how these children acquired the infection.
Were they infected during delivery when exposed to maternal body fluids? Could a caregiver or even a hospital staff member have unknowingly been shedding the virus? Or were they infected prior to delivery, with the virus having evaded the placenta’s protective mechanisms? Although it is likely a rare event, we now have increasing evidence that intrauterine transmission does occur.
While I would never claim that the human placenta is not deserving of our utmost respect and admiration, it is far from perfect when it comes to sparing a developing fetus from a harm. There are, in fact, numerous infectious agents that can cross over from mother to fetus. As a newborn hospitalist, I have historically focused on diseases such as syphilis, HIV, HSV, CMV, and Hepatitis B, all of which are capable of causing severe illness with serious long term consequences. Many intrauterine infections cause damage prior to delivery and can result in the loss of the pregnancy or the need for urgent medical intervention at the time of delivery.
Prior to SARS-CoV-2, the Zika virus was the most recent new potential cause of intrauterine infections, quickly changing how we screen mothers and newborns. One potential pathogen, rubella, is still on my checklist of things to worry about every time I admit a new baby, but it is extremely unlikely that I will ever see a case. Rubella is no longer endemic in the United States, thanks to a very successful vaccine (the R in the MMR), and there are only about five cases of congenital rubella syndrome diagnosed each year. Typically these cases occur when mothers have recently emigrated from countries without a rubella immunization program. Part of my job is to make sure that all my patients’ mothers have documented immunity, and if not, are offered a booster to reduce the risk during a potential future pregnancy.
Reports of congenital SARS-CoV-2 emerge
As I mentioned above, there have been plenty of cases of newborns testing positive for SARS-CoV-2. 2-5% of infants born to mothers with COVID-19 near delivery have tested positive within the first 96 hours of life, most of which have likely not gone on to develop symptoms. But again, some have.
Earlier this month, multiple reports were published where intrauterine infection was found to be extremely likely if not definitively to blame. The first case that I came across involved a premature infant born in Dallas and was published in The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal. Born at 34 weeks, the baby was initially asymptomatic but was tested at 24 hours of life per hospital protocol because her mother was ill (fever and diarrhea) with COVID-19. This initial test was positive. On the second day of life she began to develop fever and respiratory distress, and a repeat SARS-CoV-2 PCR test at 48 hours of life was again positive.
Other potential causes of fever and respiratory distress in a neonate were considered, such as bacterial pneumonia or sepsis, and were even empirically treated. Tests for these conditions were negative. It was also very unlikely that prematurity would have been the culprit considering the onset after 24 hours of initial stability. After a few days of respiratory support, thankfully not requiring mechanical ventilation, her symptoms had resolved and she was stable breathing only room air. She remained SARS-CoV-2 positive on day 14, but was continuing to feed and grow without symptoms. She was discharged home with mother on day 21.
The hospital performed histopathologic examination of the placenta, which showed diffuse inflammation, and antibody studies of the tissue were positive for SARS-CoV-2. They even performed ultrastructural examination by electron microscopy, which revealed structures consistent with viral particles. The authors, one of whom I used to work with back in the day at Texas Children’s Hospital, concluded that this represented confirmation of congenital SARS-CoV-2 infection. What remains unclear in this case is whether or not the placenta became infected because of maternal viremia and subsequent spread via the blood, or there was ascending spread from the GI tract (remember she had diarrhea) to the placenta by way of the vaginal canal.
Another one!
A second case of almost certain transplacental transmission was reported this month in Nature Communications. This case involved a 35-week infant also born to a mother with COVID-19 and who also developed concerning symptoms after an initial period of stability. Instead of respiratory distress, however, he developed neurologic symptoms and was found to have evidence of inflammation in the spinal fluid believed to be caused by COVID-19 after other possible etiologies were ruled out.
Just as in the first case, the baby was found to have evidence of SARS-CoV-2 infection and the placenta was inflamed and practically teeming with the virus. One interesting addition to the work up that wasn’t included in the first case was testing of the amniotic fluid prior to rupture of membranes. It was also found to be positive. The authors concluded that they had demonstrated transplacental transmission and a rare case of cerebral vasculitis in a newborn.
What does this mean for pregnant women?
There is some benefit from confirmation that SARS-CoV-2 can potentially be spread to a fetus via the placenta. There are a lot of people not taking this pandemic as seriously as they should and this may serve as an inspiration for better adherence to physical distancing recommendations and proper use of facemasks. There is still so much we don’t know about the potential future repercussions, even after asymptomatic infections. Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C) is a prime example of this. Another potential problem, and one which I’m surprised wasn’t mentioned in either of these case reports, is that COVID-19 may result in preterm labor or a need for preterm delivery.
Hot off the presses!
On July 22nd, the AAP issued updated guidance on the management of newborns born to mothers with confirmed and suspected COVID-19. I will likely cover this issue in more depth in a future post, but I wanted to leave readers with one bit of good news. The AAP initially recommended temporary separation of newborns from their mothers in this context, and most hospitals have done this. I hope that it goes without saying that this is problematic for many, many reasons.
As more data has poured in over the past few months, it has become increasingly clear that there is not a significant difference in the likelihood of infant infection between babies who are separated from their mother and babies who room-in as long as caregivers follow the recommended infection prevention measures, such as wearing a mask during breastfeeding and practicing good hand hygiene. This of course also assumes that the mother is well enough to appropriately care for her child during the newborn’s hospital stay.

COVID-19 infection during pregnancy is associated with higher rates of autism and neurodevelopmental diagnoses
A recent study found that infection with SARS-CoV-2 during pregnancy is associated with a higher risk of autism and neurodevelopment disorders. This is yet another reason why vaccination during pregnancy is important.
David Gorski on November 3, 2025
Link
One of the most pernicious myths promoted by antivaxxers during the pandemic is that vaccination against COVID-19 during pregnancy is dangerous. One only has to search an antivax activist site using the terms “pregnancy” and “COVID-19 vaccine” (as I did here for Children’s Health Defense and the Brownstone Institute as examples) to produce a long list of fear mongering articles about how supposedly vaccination during pregnancy increases the rate of fetal death and miscarriage, “attacks the placenta and ovaries,” along with various false and misleading claims of a “cover-up” of adverse outcomes in pregnancy associated with vaccination. Unsurprisingly, when longtime antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. took over as Secretary of Health and Human Services in February, it didn’t take long for him to put his finger on the scales to alter government policy so that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention no longer recommends COVID vaccination for pregnant women and “healthy” children and announcing it on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter:
Today, the COVID vaccine for healthy children and healthy pregnant women has been removed from @CDCgov recommended immunization schedule. Bottom line: it’s common sense and it’s good science. We are now one step closer to realizing @POTUS’s promise to Make America Healthy Again. pic.twitter.com/Ytch2afCLP
— Secretary Kennedy (@SecKennedy) May 27, 2025
Of course, as regular readers of this blog would know, there is no evidence that COVID-19 vaccination is associated with any of those harms when administered during pregnancy, and lots of evidence that they are not. Indeed, it is the overwhelming scientific consensus that COVID-19 vaccines are safe and effective during pregnancy, with numerous studies demonstrating that they are safe for the developing fetus and are not teratogenic (i.e., do not cause congenital anomalies in the developing fetus). Indeed, vaccination in general during pregnancy, not just with COVID vaccines, is safe for the mother-infant dyad. Indeed, a recently updated meta-analysis shows that COVID-19 vaccination during pregnancy reduces maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection risk by 48%, with mRNA vaccines showing higher efficacy (52% vs. 43% for inactivated), decreases maternal hospitalization risk by 42% and the risk of severe outcomes by 50%, while improving neonatal outcomes improved, including reduced infection, preterm birth, stillbirth, and neonatal death, as well as concluding that third-trimester vaccination likely offers better protection against preterm birth.
In contrast, you know what is dangerous to developing fetuses and pregnant individuals? It’s not what antivaxxers claim, obviously. I expect that you probably guessed it right away: SARS-CoV-2 infection, resulting in COVID-19 disease. Not only does it result in increased risk to the pregnant individual, including of pre-eclampsia, but to the fetus. For example, pregnancy is a risk factor for severe disease, a risk that remains elevated for up to a month after giving birth. Moreover, COVID-19 infection during pregnancy has been associated with increased risks of preterm birth, stillbirth, intrauterine growth restriction, requiring care in a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU), and adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes.
This brings us to today’s topic, a study published last week in Obstetrics & Gynecology by Shook et al and a research group from Harvard and Massachusetts General Hospital, entitled Neurodevelopmental Outcomes of 3-Year-Old Children Exposed to Maternal Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) Infection in Utero. Spoiler alert: It turns out that, in addition to all the bad things that COVID-19 infection has been shown to cause during pregnancy, COVID-19 infection during pregnancy is also associated with an increased risk of receiving a neurodevelopmental diagnosis, including autism, by age 3.
COVID-19 during pregnancy and neurodevelopmental outcomes
Before I discuss the study itself, it’s worth describing why investigators might suspect that SARS-CoV-2 infection during pregnancy might increase the risk of neurodevelopmental disorders in the infant. The authors tell it straight up right in the introduction:
A substantial body of evidence links maternal infection during pregnancy to adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes in offspring. Large national registry studies have reported increased risks of neuropsychiatric disease such as autism spectrum disorder, cognitive delay, schizophrenia, and mood disorders after in utero exposure to maternal infections. 1–4 For example, a Swedish study of 2.3 million births found a 30% increase in risk for autism spectrum disorder among the offspring of women hospitalized with an infection during pregnancy, 2 and a subsequent analysis of 1.8 million births identified a 79% increase in risk for autism spectrum disorder and a 24% increase in risk of major depression among offspring exposed to any maternal infection in pregnancy, whether hospitalized or not. 3 Relevant to severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), which is only rarely vertically transmitted, 5 adverse offspring neurodevelopmental effects from maternal viral infection can occur even without vertical transmission, as has been observed with influenza. 6–8
The link between maternal infection and offspring neurodevelopmental disorders, even in the absence of vertical pathogen transmission to the fetus, has been demonstrated in animal models. Data from rodent and nonhuman primate models demonstrate that maternal immune activation disrupts normal fetal brain development through alterations in neuronal migration, synaptic function, and microglial activity. 9–16 We therefore hypothesized that, as with other viral and bacterial infections in pregnancy that are only rarely vertically transmitted, maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection could be associated with increased rates of neurodevelopmental diagnoses in offspring.
The authors then cite previous work by their group, for example, this 2023 study, that observed that “male but not female offspring born to mothers with a positive SARS-CoV-2 polymerase chain reaction test result during pregnancy were more likely to receive a neurodevelopmental diagnosis in the first 12 months after delivery, even after accounting for preterm delivery.” A contemporaneous NPR article describing the study noted that the abnormalities found in the group born after COVID-19 infection during pregnancy were of the type that often presaged a diagnosis of autism but, given that it was only 2023, the cohort was too young for any conclusions to be made. They also noted that “not all studies have identified this elevated risk, particularly those that did not consider clinical diagnoses or employed shorter-term follow-up.” As a result, they wanted to do this study now that they could examine neurodevelopmental outcomes out to 36 months after birth.
Researchers from @EdlowLab and colleagues discovered that COVID-19 during pregnancy is linked to higher risk of neurodevelopmental disorders in children. 

Read more of the @greenjrnl study: https://t.co/vlrnwOrXvD https://t.co/CuRXsmsvWl pic.twitter.com/TvzvgTfQ8u
— Mass General Brigham Research (@MGBResearchNews) October 31, 2025
The cool thing about this study was that it was designed to look at live births during the early stages of the pandemic, so that only a very small percentage of the pregnant individuals studied actually received any COVID-19 vaccines. Let’s take a look. The investigators did a retrospective cohort study of 18,124 live births to individuals who delivered between March 1, 2020, and May 31, 2021, within the Massachusetts General Brigham health system. The exposure of interest was maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection, which was defined as a positive SARS-CoV-2 polymerase chain reaction test result during pregnancy, while the outcome of interest was any neurodevelopment diagnosis by the age of 36 months, defined and identified using International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, Tenth Revision diagnostic codes. The authors then looked to determine if there were any association between SARS-CoV-2 exposure during pregnancy and neurodevelopmental diagnoses using logistic regression models and controlling for confounders including maternal age, race and ethnicity, insurance type, hospital type, and preterm birth.
So what did the authors find? First of all, because this was early in the pandemic, only 8% of uninfected mothers had received at least one COVID-19 vaccine dose during pregnancy, compared with only 2% of mothers in the cohort who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, with only 13 infections identified in women who had received at least one dose. Moreover, 65% of the infections observed occurred during the third trimester.
Of the 861 children whose mothers had COVID-19 while pregnant, 16.3% were diagnosed as having at least one neurodevelopmental condition by age 3, compared with 9.7% of the 17,263 children from COVID-negative pregnancies. After adjusting for maternal age, race, insurance and hospital type, and preterm birth, COVID-19 infection in pregnancy was linked to a 29% higher risk of a neurodevelopmental disorder in children.
Here’s the unadjusted data summarized in a table:
As you can see, the risk of any neurodevelopmental diagnosis by age three is significantly elevated in the cohort who had been exposed to SARS-CoV-2 during pregnancy. When the authors adjusted for various risk factors associated with neurodevelopmental diagnoses, the correlation still held:
I will admit that an odds ratio of 1.29, portending a 29% increased risk of a condition, is not a huge increased risk in a study of this type, but it does so far appear to be real. Moreover, the risk appears to be highest if the COVID-19 exposure occurs during the third trimester:
According to the analysis of this cohort, however, the group of infants at highest risk for a neurodevelopmental diagnosis are boys whose in utero exposure to SARS-CoV-2 occurred during the third trimester:
Among male offspring, third-trimester maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection was significantly associated with an increased risk of neurodevelopmental diagnosis at age 3 years (aOR of 1.43, 95% CI, 1.05–1.91, P5.02 (Fig. 3). The magnitude of risk in female offspring with third-trimester exposure was more modest and not statistically significant (aOR 1.27, 95% CI, 0.85–1.85, P5.23; Appendix 3, available online at http://links.lww.com/AOG/E396).
The authors note that these findings align with what was already known before about infections during fetal development as a potential trigger for neurodevelopmental disorders, noting that the “sex-specific vulnerability aligns with previous human and animal data indicating greater susceptibility of the male placenta and fetal brain to maternal immune activation, 11,27–29 including in the setting of SARS-CoV-2. 30–32” Looking up the references cited, I noted with interest that there is indeed a lot of evidence supporting a link between maternal immune activation and childhood neurodevelopmental disorders, including autism spectrum disorder, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and Tourette syndrome and that there are animal studies that suggest that animal models suggest that there are different mechanisms for male and female fetuses in how maternal immune activation can impact neurological development, with males exhibiting more acute social and learning-related behavioral abnormalities and females exhibiting elevated anxiety-related behavior as adults. How well these findings in mice map to humans is unknown, but the authors did find distinct mechanisms in males and females, which led them to entitle their paper “Females are not just protected males.”
These observations are particularly notable in light of their biological plausibility. We have previously shown that SARS-CoV-2 exposure affects the transcriptional programs and biological function of human placental Hofbauer cells, 35 which may serve as a proxy cell type reflecting the effects of maternal exposures on fetal brain microglia, immune cells that play a key role in early neurodevelopment. 36 Maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection has been demonstrated to be associated with sex-specific patterns of immune activation in the placenta, 30 altered synaptic pruning behavior of induced microglialized placental cells, 35 and more deleterious effects on the male fetal brain in a humanized ACE2 knock-in mice. 32 Maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection also has been shown to be associated with activation of fetal–placental complement pathways, contributing to fetal inflammation independent of fetal virus exposure, 37 as well as compromised blood vessel integrity and disrupted microglial organization associated with cortical hemorrhages in the human fetal brain exposed to maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection. 38,39 Taken together, these studies provide a potential mechanism by which maternal SARS-CoV- 2 infection may contribute risk to the developing fetal brain even in the absence of vertical transmission.
You don’t have to understand all of the technical terms above to realize that what the authors are saying is that SARS-CoV-2 exposure and infection can affect the biology of the placenta and immune cells playing a key role in the development of the nervous system and that the effects of maternal immune activation seem to be more severe in male fetuses.
Of course, this study is hardly bulletproof and hardly the last word. For one thing, it’s retrospective, which means that there can always be confounders that might not have been accounted for. For another thing, as large as the cohort is, it’s still only a single institution, even if that institution includes Mass General Hospital and Harvard. The authors note that there was also a lack of a truly systemic diagnostic assessment, but further argued that, even if that were the case, it would tend to bias the results towards the null; i.e., make it more likely that any correlation between SARS-CoV-2 exposure and neurodevelopmental diagnoses by age 3 will be missed and to decrease the observed magnitude of any odds ratio calculated if a correlation is observed. They also admitted that, although there was universal screening for SARS-CoV-2 in the labor and delivery units during the period of time encompassing this cohort, it is nonetheless possible that asymptomatic COVID-19 could have been missed in some patients. However, like the lack of systematic diagnostic assessment in every case, they argue that this any misclassification of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 cases as negative would also tend to bias the findings of the study towards the null hypothesis.
As with all studies of this type, the key will be two-fold:
     1.  What is observed in this cohort as time goes on, and I’m sure that the authors plan on re-analyzing their data every couple of years to document just that.
     2.  Replication in other studies and cohorts. This will require other databases and other cohorts that include a large number of births early in the pandemic before vaccines were available, a necessary precondition to have a “cleaner” dataset.
The overall point, however, is that if you look at existing high-quality evidence about the safety and efficacy of COVID-19 vaccination during pregnancy, there are two strong conclusions. First, the vaccines are indeed safe and effective when administered during pregnancy. I realize that antivaxxers frequently invoke all the stuff that I discussed above regarding maternal immune activation interfering with neurodevelopment and potentially increasing the risk of autism and neurodevelopmental disorders, particularly in boys, but ask yourself this: What activates the immune system more, infection or vaccination? Then note that there is as yet no high-quality evidence suggesting that COVID-19 vaccination (or any vaccination, for that matter), increases the risk of autism or neurodevelopmental disorders, the recent “study” by the antivax McCullough Foundation being touted by antivaxxers right now notwithstanding. (I will have to address this “report” at some point, but it’s 82 pages long, and I just didn’t have time this weekend. Nor will I link to it now.) Next, this study and a number of other lines of evidence strongly suggest that it is actually SARS-CoV-2 infection, even just exposure, that is the real danger to developing fetuses, particularly in the third trimester. Granted, the risk still remains low, and the increased risk is low, but it appears to be real. If you add that increased risk of neurodevelopmental disorder due to COVID-19 to the known increased risk of stillbirth, intrauterine growth retardation, and the like, and there is an even stronger rationale for maternal immunization.
Indeed, if one looks holistically—yes, I used that word—at the existing scientific evidence, it suggests that infection in general during pregnancy is a risk factor for neurodevelopmental disorders. Perhaps the most studied example is congenital rubella syndrome, first described in 1971, in which infection with rubella during pregnancy produces a congenital syndrome, in addition to which there is a highly elevated risk of autism. While more recent evidence has cast some doubt on the strength of this correlation, it is generally accepted that fever during pregnancy is associated with an elevated risk of neurodevelopmental disorders like autism, and the most common cause of fever is infection.
Not that any of this science or these facts stops antivaxxers. For example:
With all due respect, a peer-reviewed study with over 18,000 pregnancies is stronger evidence than your personal anecdotal claims

The study defines Covid during pregnancy
— Evidence Challenge (@dense_evi) October 31, 2025
Of course it’s a chiropractor.
Here’s the funny thing, though. I’ve perused all the usual antivax sources, and I’ve seen almost no mention of this study. I find that telling. If the study had any obvious flaws that antivaxxers could point to, someone at Children’s Health Defense, the Brownstone Institute, or any of a number of antivax blogs, Substacks, and websites would have written a detailed takedown by now, given that the study was published on October 30. Three or four days is plenty of time for this, as anyone who’s been following the disinformation space would know.
The bottom line is that the myth that vaccination during pregnancy, be it with mRNA-based COVID vaccines or vaccines that have long been on the CDC recommended schedule, harms the developing fetus and/or causes neurodevelopmental conditions like autism is a pernicious one. Unfortunately, now that we have a rabid antivaxxer in charge of public health and vaccine policy, both infants and their mothers will suffer unnecessary harm from policies not based in science and evidence. Such is the world that we are living in now.


Science-based medical lessons from President Trump’s case of COVID-19 (thus far)
We learned early Friday morning that President Trump has COVID-19. As the story evolved, it was hard not to take a look at potential science-based lessons in medicine that this story provides.
David Gorski on October 5, 2020
Link
I approached what to write about for SBM this Monday with some trepidation. My original plan had been to do a swift pivot away from COVID-19 for this week, given that the pandemic has dominated my blogging ever since March, but events made that increasingly difficult. Late Thursday night, I was working on a grant due Tuesday but that, because of my university grant office’s policy, had to be uploaded by early Friday afternoon, in order to give the university time to process it and submit it before the deadline, when I came across this Tweet being commented on in my Twitter timeline:
Tonight, @FLOTUS and I tested positive for COVID-19. We will begin our quarantine and recovery process immediately. We will get through this TOGETHER!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 2, 2020
This came after the night before, when President Trump had Tweeted:
Hope Hicks, who has been working so hard without even taking a small break, has just tested positive for Covid 19. Terrible! The First Lady and I are waiting for our test results. In the meantime, we will begin our quarantine process!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 2, 2020
The next morning, as I scrambled from my home office to gather all the necessary documents, do the last minute proofreading and corrections necessary before uploading my grant application, and converting the many Microsoft Word Documents to the PDF format required, I could not help but be momentarily distracted from time-to-time by the rapidly moving story, as I felt compelled to check my Twitter feed at least once an hour. The initial reports were that President Trump and the First Lady had “mild symptoms,” but the situation rapidly evolved, with news reports leading many to question just how “mild” Trump’s symptoms were, although White House physician Dr. Sean Conley reported that Trump had developed fever, congestion, and cough by Thursday night.
Of course, as an obese 74-year-old male, President Trump is in a group at high risk for serious COVID-19 complications and even death, and doctors who treat coronavirus patients know that patients with initially mild symptoms can take a serious turn for the worse really fast, usually days after the onset of symptoms. Also, like many people, I was disturbed by the lack of Tweeting, as many have pointed out that if the President weren’t very sick, chances were that he’d have been Tweeting up a storm. The silence made us worry.
Then, late Friday afternoon after I had successfully uploaded all my files (albeit not without delays and last-minute complications), I learned that President Trump was being taken to Walter Reed Medical Center, where they have a Presidential suite. He definitely looked under the weather in the videos showing him walking from the White House to the helicopter, but not deathly ill. (Of course, if he were deathly ill, likely they would have transported him on a stretcher.) Around the same time, his Twitter account Tweeted this:
pic.twitter.com/B4H105KVSs
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 2, 2020
Again, he didn’t look entirely well in that brief video, but he didn’t look seriously ill, either, and he was obviously able to keep from coughing for the brief video and the walk to and from the helicopter. As the news accelerated over the weekend, by Sunday (when I’m writing this), I knew I had to comment, even at the risk of developments making my post outdated by the time it published on Monday. (That’s what addendums and updates are for, anyway.) The reason is that there are a number of SBM-related take-home points that this development tells us, the first of which every doctor knows: VIP care is not necessarily the best care. Other take home lessons include the observations that science matters, that masks and social distancing matter, and that being cavalier about them is a recipe for disaster.
Rosy political spin versus “everything but the kitchen sink”
It’s a well-known axiom in medicine that VIPs often get more care, not better care. Pretty much every doctor who’s ever taken care of a celebrity or other VIP knows that these patients tend to get more tests, more consults, and more interventions for the same condition than a non-celebrity non-VIP patient would. I can speculate about the reasons, but they seem to boil down to a perception of a much greater penalty for missing something or getting something wrong, combined with the desire of everyone involved to be near the celebrity, to be able to be seen as contributing something, and the higher level of entitlement and demandingness that many celebrities demonstrate. This is all in addition to the natural incentives always to “do more” in medicine compared to the relative lack of incentives to be more conservative and do less.
Indeed, I have written about this very conflict between the desire to “do more,” even if that “more” isn’t necessarily better, in our many posts about the phenomenon of overdiagnosis and overtreatment of cancer and other diseases. It’s not just screening, though. It’s treatment as well. It’s a trap that a lot of doctors fall into, one having gone so far as to blame The New York Times for having “killed” his patient with prostate cancer by publishing articles questioning the value of PSA screening for the disease. Moreover, patients love aggressive screening and treatment. They are very uncomfortable with “watchful waiting” and conservative measures. As I’ve written before, there thus exists a positive feedback loop in which patients want more aggressive screening, testing, and care, and physicians are rewarded because more aggressive screening and testing finds more problems they can “treat,” whether those problems really need to be treated or not. Then, as I’ve discussed, during the COVID-19 pandemic we have seen a phenomenon where science-based medicine has all too often been abandoned, with doctors bypassing clinical trials in the urge to “do something, anything,” even at the cost of abandoning the dictum, “First, do no harm.” Add this tendency to the most “VIP-est” of VIP patients, like President Trump, who’s already shown himself to be enamored of all manner of dubious treatments anyway for COVID-19, and you can imagine how this tendency would be magnified.
It is this very conflict that makes it so difficult to figure out what President Trump’s real condition is. Ever since Friday, news reports have alternated between glowing reports about how well he is doing with a drip-drip-drip of reports of the President receiving interventions that strongly suggest that he is considerably sicker than is being reported. It started with news reports on Friday that, while still at the White House before he was transported to Walter Reed, President Trump had received a dose of Regeneron’s experimental cocktail of monoclonal antibodies, plus, seemingly, everything but the kitchen sink. (Actually, not yet. The kitchen sink came later in the weekend.) From The New York Times:
President Trump has received a dose of an experimental antibody cocktail being developed by the drug maker Regeneron, in addition to several other drugs, including zinc, vitamin D and the generic version of the heartburn treatment Pepcid, according to a letter from his doctor that was released by the White House Friday afternoon.
Mr. Trump and the first lady, Melania Trump, announced early Friday morning that they had tested positive for the coronavirus. The president has a low-grade fever, nasal congestion and a cough, according to two people close to Mr. Trump.
In the letter, Mr. Trump’s doctor, Dr. Sean P. Conley, said “he completed the infusion without incident” and that he “remains fatigued but in good spirits.”
I’ve discussed the use of convalescent plasma before. It’s an old concept that involves harvesting pooled plasma from patients who have recovered from COVID-19 and using it to treat patients in the hopes that the antibodies raised by the patients who have recovered will fight the infection in new patients. Indeed, the FDA issued an EUA for convalescent plasma in late August, despite the lack of randomized controlled trial evidence that it works. The Regeneron product is not convalescent plasma. Rather, it’s a cocktail of two monoclonal antibodies directed at the main surface spike protein that helps SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, attach to a receptor on human cells called angiotensin-converting enzyme-2 (ACE2):
The targeted region is dubbed the receptor binding domain. One antibody comes from a human who had recovered from a SARS-CoV-2 infection; a B cell that makes the antibody was harvested from the person’s blood and the genes for the immune protein isolated and copied. The other antibody is from a mouse, which was engineered to have a human immune system, that had the spike protein injected into it.
I’m not sure why they chose to do a mixture between human and a “humanized” mouse antibody, but that’s what the cocktail is. It’s been tested in 275 patients with COVID-19 who were asymptomatic or, at worst, moderately ill in a placebo-controlled trial and reported (although not yet in the peer-reviewed literature) to reduce the amount of virus in patients who were seronegative (had no antibodies to SARS-CoV-2) but to show little effect in patients who already had antibodies to the virus. Interestingly, the most dramatic drops in SARS-CoV-2 levels were seen in seronegative patients who had the highest levels of virus at the trial’s start. In any event, the idea is that the antibody cocktail might be able to prevent progression to severe disease in patients with mild disease who have not yet developed their own antibodies. The trial was not powered to show decreased progression to more severe disease in patients receiving the antibody.
I will admit that I was puzzled when I first learned that Trump had received the Regeneron cocktail, viewing it as an indication of more severe disease, but reading more led me to realize that he was probably an appropriate patient for this intervention, although we can’t know because the President’s viral load was not reported, nor was it reported whether he had detectable SARS-CoV-2 antibodies. The use of the compassionate use mechanism to get this product to the President also raised all sorts of ethical questions:
In an interview Friday afternoon, Regeneron’s chief executive, Dr. Leonard S. Schleifer, said Mr. Trump’s medical staff reached out to the company for permission to use the drug, and that it was cleared with the Food and Drug Administration.
“All we can say is that they asked to be able to use it, and we were happy to oblige,” he said. He said that so-called compassionate use cases — when patients are granted access to an experimental treatment outside of a clinical trial — are decided on a case-by-case basis and he is not the first patient to be granted permission to use the treatment this way. “When it’s the president of the United States, of course, that gets — obviously — gets our attention.”
Dr. Schleifer has known Mr. Trump casually for years, having been a member of his golf club in Westchester County.
And:
The notion that VIPs should get plasma and antibodies is, honestly, bonkers.
These are not proven treatments.
They have harms.
We deride fake experts for hawking hydroxychloroquine based on terrible “studies.”
So should we with other unproven treatments!
Wtf!
— Jeremy Faust MD MS (ER physician) (@jeremyfaust) October 2, 2020
Do NOT experiment your pet theories on humans, outside of a clinical trial.
Do not mistake using your patients as guinea pigs for your poorly vetted ideas with “being aggressive” or “brave.”
Do not experiment on the poor.
Nor minorities.
Nor VIPs.
People are people.
— Jeremy Faust MD MS (ER physician) (@jeremyfaust) October 2, 2020
And:
Dr. George Yancopoulos, Regeneron’s president and chief scientific officer, said the company is already preparing for an expected influx of requests.
“This is certainly putting us in a difficult situation,” Dr. Yancopoulos said. The company is also planning for how to allocate the product if it is authorized for emergency use or approved. Regeneron has an arrangement with the Department of Defense to distribute the first 300,000 doses once it is available. “We didn’t want to decide who gets a limited number of doses,” he said.
Interestingly, the Regeneron cocktail was not administered under “right-to-try.” (Sorry, I couldn’t resist.) I also can’t resist saying that this is exactly the sort of thing that VIP medicine attracts, the use of the patient’s celebrity to gain access to treatments that others don’t have access to that might or might not be helpful. It could also be what led Trump’s doctors to give him an 8 g dose of the drug, when Regeneron’s own data show that 2-4 g is as effective as higher doses.
It wasn’t long before we learned more in the news reports, starting Friday night, when it was announced that he had received the first dose of a five day course of remdesivir. Remdesivir is an antiviral drug for which the existing data has most definitely not impressed me very much. In May Gilead Biosciences, the company that makes remdesivir, announced its results, rather than publishing them, and the results were not that impressive, but the FDA still issued an EUA for the drug for patients with severe disease. More results were published in July suggesting (but not nailing down) a reduction in mortality, and in August the EUA was expanded to all hospitalized patients with COVID-19, irrespective of their severity of disease. (Of course, if you’re hospitalized, you must have at least moderate disease or be in a group at high risk for complications.)
Then, as I was writing this post yesterday, the last (or maybe just the latest) shoe dropped:
To treat his Covid-19, President Trump has started receiving dexamethasone, a common steroid that has been shown to be helpful in people with severe cases of the disease but that doctors warn should not be used early in the course of the illness.
The announcement from Trump’s medical team Sunday morning that the president is on dexamethasone is sure to increase speculation about the president’s illness and was at odds with the generally upbeat description of his condition provided by his physicians. His doctors said Trump had not had a fever since Friday morning and did not have any shortness of breath. One even said that, if Trump “continues to feel and look as well as he does today,” their goal was for him to return to the White House on Monday.
Dexamethasone is generally reserved for patients who have serious disease. The National Institutes of Health’s treatment guidelines for Covid-19 say dexamethasone should be used only in hospitalized patients who are on ventilators or who require supplemental oxygen, and specifically “recommends against using dexamethasone for the treatment of Covid-19 in patients who do not require supplemental oxygen.”
These NIH guidelines are based on the RECOVERY trial, a multicenter, randomized, open-label trial in hospitalized patients with COVID-19, which showed a lower mortality among patients who received steroids (specifically dexamethasone 6 mg per day for up to 10 days or until hospital discharge, whichever comes first) in patients who require either mechanical ventilation or supplemental oxygen. In fact, the NIH panel that published the guidelines specifically recommended “against using dexamethasone for the treatment of COVID-19 in patients who do not require supplemental oxygen.”
So what’s going on with the President’s condition? His doctors’ reports have often been in conflict with other reporting regarding his condition. Notably, on Saturday, Dr. Sean Conley admitted that Trump had developed a fever, but stated that he had been “fever-free” for 24 hours and ducked and weaved regarding whether Trump had ever required supplemental oxygen:
But the briefing raises as many questions as it answers, specifically whether oxygen was administered to the president. Conley says no oxygen was administered Thursday, Saturday or Friday after Trump arrived at the hospital. But he does not rule out that oxygen was administered Friday before Trump traveled to Walter Reed.
Note how that leaves open the possibility that Trump had received oxygen on Friday before leaving for Walter Reed, and it turned out that there had been drops in his oxygen saturation on Friday and Saturday:
President Trump has “improved,” according to White House physician Sean Conley, but experienced significant oxygen drops on Friday and Saturday. His doctors said he has had no fever since Friday morning and could be discharged as early as tomorrow.
Conley declined to answer questions about the president’s lungs, including whether there is scarring or whether Trump has pneumonia.
Also on Sunday:
NEW: Trump’s doctor says he declined to share yesterday that the president had been put on oxygen because he was trying to reflect an “upbeat attitude.” pic.twitter.com/rALeBnufcH
— BuzzFeed News (@BuzzFeedNews) October 4, 2020
So the White House physician was basically leaving out critical information in order to be “upbeat” on Saturday. His desire to be “upbeat” also contradicted reports on Saturday from senior White House officials that the “President’s vitals over the last 24 hours were very concerning and the next 48 hours will be critical in terms of his care. We are still not on a clear path to a full recovery.”
This Twitter thread by Dr. Bob Wachter, chair of medicine at UCSF dissects the disconnect between Dr. Conley’s rosy assessment and things said and left unsaid:
Impressions of today's Walter Reed presser:
a) Conley's mea culpa: “I was trying to reflect the upbeat attitude of the team. Didn’t want to give any information that would steer the course of his illness.” Trump's fingerprints.
But even so, today was only slightly better. (1/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
b/ Biggest news is that T had 2 episodes of hypoxia (down to 93-94% O2 saturation), & Conley evaded whether sat was ever <90. "Never in low 80s" is all he offered.
c/ Re: Chest CT: "There were some expected findings but nothing of concern." What the hell does that mean?…(2/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
…To be clear, the "expected findings" on a chest CT is NORMAL. If it was normal, he should say that. Anything else should have been described.
(The only semi-benign interpretation would be if the prez has a known chronic finding – like a benign nodule – that was seen)…(3/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
… But it seems far likelier that they found evidence of pneumonia or other manifestations of Covid lung involvement or inflammation, which is serious and raises the level of concern and risk. (4/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
d/ They pulled trigger & started dexamethasone. So they were clearly concerned. Given documented low O2, dex definitely was indicated.
e/ Said they're starting to plan for possible discharge, as early as tomorrow. Even w/ WH's medical capacity, that seems like an awful call. 5/8
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
f/ Yes, they could give his last doses of IV remdesivir in WH, but still risky to discharge. In RECOVERY trial (which proved value of dexamethasone), mortality rate in TREATMENT group for pts requiring O2 was 23.3% (vs. 26.2% in usual care). A nearly 1-in-4 risk of death. (6/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
g/ Finally, most tellingly: when T was hypoxic, they tried to put him on O2. "He was adamant he didn't need oxygen." In my 35 years of practice, I've never seen a pt refuse oxygen. It's crazy, & illustrates who is running the show, which may well be scariest thing I heard. (7/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
Bottom line: it seems like Trump is stable, but remains at high risk, given transient hypoxemia, some findings on chest imaging. The happy talk and evasions are clearly at Trump's direction, putting the docs in a terrible position. No way he's ready for discharge tomorrow. (8/8)
— Bob Wachter (@Bob_Wachter) October 4, 2020
In fairness to the President, one characteristic of COVID-19 that stood out early on in the pandemic is that some patients have “silent hypoxemia” (sometimes also called “happy hypoxia”) in which they are profoundly hypoxic but do not show the symptoms that people with such low oxygen saturations usually do. So President Trump, given his penchant for always showing “strength” and his hatred of ever showing anything he considers to be “weakness,” might well have thought his doctors were being alarmist. Be that as it may, we are getting conflicting stories regarding how sick the President really is, with some stories stating that he had experienced significant shortness of breath while his doctors paint a much rosier picture. Perhaps the worst part of the press conference Sunday was, as Dr. Wachter pointed out, the strange way they described the chest CT results. Reading between the lines, I really do get the feeling that the President is significantly sicker than he is letting on, the video that he released Saturday afternoon notwithstanding. The way Dr. Conley danced around the question of whether Trump’s oxygen saturations had ever dipped into the high 80s was also telling, given his history of evasion.
pic.twitter.com/gvIPuYtTZG
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 3, 2020
So how do we put it all together? I can only provide educated (I hope) speculation and suggest one lesson. Personally, I’m observing a conflict between the image that the President wants to project compared to the treatments he’s receiving, which suggest a significantly sicker patient than is being admitted. Of the three main treatments being given, one (dexamethasone) is definitely not appropriate for a patient with mild disease, as steroids are immunosuppressive and, if they are not needed to reduce major inflammation, run the risk of doing more harm than good, and it took until Sunday before we knew for sure that Trump had had transient hypoxia. Meanwhile, one is an experimental therapy not yet approved by the FDA (or even released under an EUA). Why did Trump get that one? I rather suspect it’s because he demanded it, and, he being the VIP-est of VIP patients, his doctors acquiesced, with the company being more than happy to provide it for the President. Two things are strongly suggested. First, Trump is likely being treated maximally, and, second, the perils and pitfalls of VIP medicine are likely strongly influencing his care, coupled with Trump’s known tendency to believe in untested treatments. Truly, practicing SBM under such conditions must be incredibly difficult, and I do not envy his doctors. The lesson? You should hold fast to SBM, but realize that it’s going to be damned near impossible with a patient like Donald Trump.
Perhaps the best summation of the question I’m asking comes from Dr. Thomas McGinn, a top physician at Northwell Health, the largest health care provider in New York State:
“The dexamethasone is the most mystifying of the drugs we’re seeing him being given at this point,” said Dr. Thomas McGinn, a top physician at Northwell Health, the largest health care provider in New York State.
The drug, he said, was normally not used unless the patient’s condition seemed to be deteriorating.
“Suddenly, they’re throwing the kitchen sink at him,” Dr. McGinn said. “It raises the question: Is he sicker than we’re hearing, or are they being overly aggressive because he is the president, in a way that could be potentially harmful?”
Of course, given the patient, there may be another explanation.
Some experts raised an additional possibility: that the president is directing his own care, and demanding intense treatment despite risks he may not fully understand. The pattern even has a name: V.I.P. syndrome.
It could, of course, be a combination of these possibilities. Again, I don’t envy President Trump’s doctors, although I do think that Dr. Conley should be slapped down for his evasiveness and lying by omission.
Coronavirus doesn’t care if you don’t believe in epidemiology and virology
It wasn’t so long ago that I wrote about so-called “super spreading events“, mainly gatherings in which COVID-19 spreads easily and widely. Another lesson that came out of this debacle soon made itself known as more and more administration officials and prominent Republicans started to test positive for COVID-19, namely that testing alone is not enough to prevent spreading. Masks and social distancing matter at least as much. This lesson was driven home by a drip-drip-drip of announcements that led to a list of at least ten people in Trump’s circle who have thus far tested positive for COVID-19 (as of Sunday afternoon), including: Donald and Melania Trump, Hope Hicks, Nicholas Luna, Senator Mike Lee of Utah, Senator Tom Tillis of North Carolina, Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, his former counselor Kellyanne Conway, his campaign manager Bill Stepien, RNC Chairwoman Rona McDaniel, and former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie.
Almost immediately after Trump announced that he and his wife had contracted COVID-19, it was pointed out in many stories and op-eds how lackadaisical his administration had been towards masks and social distancing. Indeed, it’s long been known that masks, even though they work to decrease the likelihood of COVID-19 transmission, had become a political symbol, largely because President Trump detested them and mocked them as signs of “weakness” and because, apparently, he and his staff believed that testing would be enough to protect them:
The president has maintained that he doesn’t need to wear a mask because he and the people in close proximity to him are tested for the virus. But only staffers who interact with the president are tested regularly, leaving the hundreds of others who work in the White House complex vulnerable. A White House official said a random sample of staffers who work in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building next to the White House are tested daily, but the official didn’t say how many.
Indeed, at the Presidential debate last Tuesday, Trump said this about his opponent Joe Biden:
“When needed, I wear masks. I don’t wear masks like him,” the president said. “Every time you see him, he’s got a mask. He could be speaking 200 feet away from me, and he shows up with the biggest mask I’ve ever seen.”
See what I mean? The President was basically mocking masks as a sign of weakness, as performance, as a signifier of political leanings—his supporters are still accusing Biden of using masks as a “prop”—while members of Trump’s entourage pointedly took their masks off after being seated to watch the debate. (Unfortunately, he’s not wrong about masks having become a signifier of political beliefs, but he is largely responsible for that.) Indeed, he’s said even worse. It wasn’t just masks, though. The New York Times published an article Saturday detailing the hostility in the White House to masks and social distancing, describing the pressure West Wing occupants felt not to wear a mask and to act as though the virus was not a threat and how, if you didn’t want the President to be displeased with you and mock you, you didn’t wear a mask. This hostility towards masks has also manifested itself in pressure on the CDC to downplay the importance of masks and social distancing, even as it’s becoming clearer that SARS-CoV-2 is transmitted through a combination of large respiratory droplets and, to a lesser extent, smaller aerosol particles. This lack of concern for COVID-19 transmission led to an article in August in The Atlantic referring to the White House as a Petri dish, the author noting that the “most famous address in America now feels like a coronavirus breeding ground”.
All of this has led to speculation that the reception held in the Rose Garden last Saturday for Trump’s Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett was a “super spreader” event, because of how the White House flouted coronavirus guidelines recommended by public health officials:
The White House gathering on Sept. 26 to introduce Amy Coney Barrett as President Donald Trump’s nominee to serve on the Supreme Court has emerged as a likely superspreader event in the growing cluster of COVID-19 cases surrounding the president.
So far, the majority of the people who have tested positive were at the Rose Garden gathering and associated events, including individuals whose schedules would otherwise not obviously have brought them together. And the timing of their reported positive tests fits with the date of the event. It was also surrounded by other meetings with key Republicans to discuss the coming confirmation hearings
While it’s true that the event was held outside and that gatherings outside are less risky than indoor events, there were also indoor components of the reception, with not a mask to be seen, no social distancing, and even a lot of hugging. Just take a look at the photos included in this New York Times article about the reception. There are lots of shots of people indoors, with no masks, not staying anywhere near six feet from each other, and even a fair amount of hugging and getting in each other’s faces going on. In the days leading up to the Presidential debate last Tuesday, there were also a number of closed door sessions to prepare, again with no masks and no social distancing.
The lesson?
You can’t escape virology and epidemiology. Masks work to slow the spread of COVID-19, no matter how much you believe they don’t. Social distancing works. Handwashing works. Are they perfect? Of course not. They decrease, not eliminate, the risk of COVID-19 transmission. Moreover, the reason testing alone, which is what the White House was relying on, is insufficient is because there is a significant false negative rate for COVID-19 tests, as there is time between the virus infecting you and its being detectable by nasal swab when you can still be infectious and it is known that people are most infectious a couple of days before they develop symptoms and people can be contagious days before testing positive for the virus. Testing is important, so that asymptomatic and presymptomatic COVID-19 carriers can self-isolate, but without other public health interventions, including social distancing and masks, testing alone will not keep a group safe, as described here:
The administration relied on Abbott Laboratories’ ID Now rapid test at the Sept. 26 event for Judge Barrett. After guests tested negative, they were ushered to the Rose Garden, where few people were wearing masks. The White House didn’t comment on whether anyone screened at the event tested positive.
Public-health experts say the White House isn’t using the test appropriately, and that such tests aren’t meant to be used as one-time screeners. Regardless of the type or brand of test, any strategy that relies solely on testing is insufficient for protecting the public against the virus, epidemiologists and researchers say.
The problem is that the White House seems to view COVID-19 testing is akin to a metal detector and that a one-time test means that a person is safe when infected people can transmit COVID-19 before they test positive for the virus:
All tests, including those processed in a lab, can produce false negatives, he and other experts say. Some studies have shown that the Abbott Now ID test, which can produce a result in minutes, has around a 91% sensitivity—meaning 9% of tests can produce false negatives.
“A metal detector that misses 10% of weapons—you’d never, ever say that’s our only layer of protection for the president,” said Dr. Jha.
Abbott itself points out that no test detects the virus immediately after the person becomes infected.
In the end, what is surprising is not that President Trump and a growing number of his associates got COVID-19 last week. What’s surprising is how lucky the White House has been that something like this hasn’t happened until now. You can’t fool Mother Nature, as they say, and Trump didn’t even try to protect his people, not even letting several of his key allies know after he tested positive that they had been exposed. Worse, he arrived to the debate on Tuesday too late to be tested for COVID-19 and was allowed in on the “honor system”. Given the timing, it was not unreasonable to wonder if Trump could have infected Joe Biden, although fortunately, so far, it appears that this did not happen.
Basically, SARS-CoV-2 doesn’t care if you believe in science or not.
Returning home to science-based medicine
It is rather amusing to recall how much Trump has promoted dubious and unproven treatments for COVID-19 starting back in March. Just search this blog for “hydroxychloroquine” for a sampling. I don’t want to go into detail regarding the story of this drug, as I’ve discussed it many times already, but for those who don’t want to click on the links I’ll helpfully provide, this is the Cliffs Notes version.
Back in January, as the pandemic first hit Wuhan, China, some Chinese doctors thought they had made an observation that the novel coronavirus did not infect 80 patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) who were taking quinine-based drugs like hydroxychloroquinine (HCQ) and chloroquinine (CQ). As a result of that and old evidence of antiviral activity for the drugs, they became interested in using these antimalarial drugs to treat COVID-19. (Never mind that immunosuppressed patients are exactly the patients most likely to assiduously follow the recommendations of public health authorities during a pandemic.) A number of clinical trials were registered, and, based on anecdotal reports and small clinical trials (nearly all of which are as yet unpublished), in February the Chinese government published an expert consensus recommending CQ or HCQ for patients with COVID-19. Other nations, thinking the Chinese must know what they’re talking about, took the recommendation at face value, and it wasn’t long before HCQ (±azithromycin, ±zinc, etc.) became a de facto standard of care for COVID-19. A “brave maverick doctor” in France named Didier Raoult published some breathtakingly bad studies supporting the use of the drug, and eventually President Trump got on the bandwagon, leading to an emergency use authorization (EUA) by the FDA for HCQ in late March. Meanwhile, a number of quacks, complete with “miracle cure” testimonials, were hyping HCQ, including the aforementioned Dr. Raoult, Dr. Vladimir Zelenko (who claimed to have treated hundreds of patients successfully), Dr. Stephen Smith (ditto), and even America’s quack, Dr. Mehmet Oz himself. Also, President Trump himself said in May that he was taking HCQ to prevent COVID-19, although he apparently stopped before too long.
Over the next few months, there was a drip-drip-drip of negative studies, ultimately including negative randomized controlled clinical trials, of hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19, and ultimately the FDA rescinded the EUA and hydroxychloroquine fell out of favor, although that hasn’t stopped even quackier doctors, such as Dr. Stella Immanuel, a Houston physician who believes that sex with demons causes illness and has claimed to have cured hundreds of COVID-19 patients with HCQ. Amusingly, she is very unhappy that President Trump has not, as far as anyone can tell from news reports, actually used HCQ to treat his COVID-19, Tweeting:
Whoever told the president to stop taking HCQ should be punched in the face. This did not have to happened. I am so upset. This is our president for crying out loud. No one need to get sick or pcr positive. #HCQ4prevention
— Dr. Stella Immanuel MD (@stella_immanuel) October 2, 2020
And, publicity hound that she is, Dr. Immanuel even offered to prescribe it herself:
Everyone in the White House get on HCQ twice a month. With daily vit C, D, and zinc. If your doctors will not prescribe it I will. I can see you via telehealth emergency licensed in DC. Use https://t.co/jTDgb5Et5p and I will hook you guys up. POTUS, FLOTUS don’t wait to get sick.
— Dr. Stella Immanuel MD (@stella_immanuel) October 2, 2020
I was quite amused by this for a number of reasons, but the most important one of all is what I started out saying, namely that it’s all fun and games (and/or grift) to promote unproven “cures” for a deadly disease, but when the quack’s life is on the line it’s funny how fast he comes back to science-based medicine. Sure, President Trump is reportedly getting some unproven therapies, such as vitamin D and zinc, but chances are that vitamin D and zinc probably don’t do any harm. It’s also true that he availed himself of an experimental treatment, but that experimental treatment at least has some promising preliminary data and is scientifically plausible as a potentially effective treatment for COVID-19. However, otherwise, Trump seems to be accepting more or less science-based treatment for his COVID-19, albeit likely with its level of aggressiveness amped up because of his VIP status. Basically, he’s (mostly) ignored the quacks and listened to doctors at Walter Reed Medical Center.
So we’ve learned at least three lessons here, I hope. First, VIPs do not necessarily get the best care, particularly when the VIP is Donald Trump and particularly when evidence-based protocols for COVID-19 are still in flux, but particularly when the VIP’s political need to paint the rosiest picture possible of his condition conflicts with the need for transparency. (He even staged a photo op showing him “working” in which he appeared to be signing a blank piece of paper.) Second, the virus doesn’t care if you believe in science or not. Finally, for many a quack and grifter, it’s all fun and grift to promote pseudoscience until you yourself are facing a potentially life threatening condition. I’m sure there will be more lessons as this story unfolds.

COVID Fatality Improving
COVID-19 is becoming less deadly, due to a variety of reasons that do not seem to include changes to the virus itself.
Steven Novella on October 28, 2020
Linl

Over the course of the pandemic the death rate in people diagnosed with COVID-19 (the case-fatality rate) has declined. It’s not easy to unpack all the reasons this may be the case, but it may help us understand this pandemic. This is an extremely contagious and deadly disease, and nothing has changed that, but there is evidence we are making some progress.
One recent study looking at the case fatality rate in the New York region from March to August found that the death rate for those admitted to the hospital dropped from 27% to 3%. They also found many possible reasons for this dramatic decrease. One is the fact that in March New York hospitals were overwhelmed with COVID cases. They did not have enough ICU beds or ventilators, and doctors were crushed beneath the initial wave of cases of a disease they had no experience with. In fact, out of desperation, some hospitals were placing two patients on a single ventilator. So simply “flattening the curve” and reducing pressure on hospitals is one important factor.
Another study out of the UK found that from March to June the fatality rate of COVID patients admitted to the ICU decreased from 41% to 21%. This was even after controlling for demographic and medical history factors, so this was likely not due to patients being healthier at baseline. The study attributed the improvement to two factors – the decrease in stress on hospital systems (again), and improvements in the care of critically ill patients with COVID. This latter reason is the most encouraging reason for the decline – the steep learning curve of knowing how to treat those who are seriously ill with COVID. Doctors have learned through direct experience how to better manage COVID patients, and many interventions became standard practice between March and August. For example, it is better to rest patients on their stomach than their back, and it is better to delay ventilation as long as possible. The discovery that steroids can reduce the risk of cytokine storm was perhaps a significant improvement. Some patients now get convalescent plasma, something that obviously could not have happened early on. Remdesevir was given emergency use authorization, but a recent study by the WHO found no survival benefit from this drug (or from hydroxychloroquine; a combination of the anti-HIV drugs lopinavir and ritonavir; and interferon).
While we still do not have a cure for COVID-19 or a proven effective anti-viral, management has significantly improved and this has definitely contributed to survival. However – this is not the only effect, and may not even be the major effect.
The recent WHO study also found that as the pandemic progresses, younger and healthier people are being infected. They naturally have a higher survival rate, even if they become sick enough to get admitted to a hospital. It seems from this data, to put it bluntly, that the first surge of the pandemic in the New York region killed many vulnerable people, and now there are simply fewer of them alive to catch and die from the virus. Now we are seeing larger numbers of people infected, but they are healthier at baseline, so the case fatality rate drops.
As a side point, some have used the fact that the pandemic tends to kill older sicker people to minimize the significance of the death toll, as if these are mostly people who would have died soon anyway. But that is not the case. The pandemic does not mostly kill people who were already on death’s door (although certainly that describes some victims). The chronic conditions that make people vulnerable to dying from COVID, such as hypertension, obesity, or asthma, are also compatible with years of quality life. Anyone with an elderly parent who has chronic illnesses but is still a valued and loved member of the family would bristle at the suggestion that their death is no big deal.
But now, while the case fatality rate is lower, the pandemic has moved on to younger and healthier victims. And keep in mind, the average daily death rate of the pandemic is still very high in the US, over 700 deaths per day on average, because new cases remains high and is increasing as we enter what looks like a third surge.
Another recent study identifies a different potential reason for the decline in the case fatality rate – the protective measures being used to reduce spread of the virus. If, for example, you social distance and wear a mask but still get sick (it’s possible, because these protections are not perfect, people do not completely adhere to them, and the virus is very contagious) you will likely get a lower initial viral load than someone who was hugging someone, without a mask, who was infected. What the study found was two things – that the initial viral load correlates with the risk of death, and that as the pandemic progresses people are presenting with a lower viral load on average. So protective measures seem to be shifting to lower exposure, so many people do not contract the virus and those that do will tend to have lower viral loads. This will tend to generate lots of milder cases, some of which will be diagnosed and even admitted to hospital but have a lower fatality rate.
This study also finds that there is likely a significant effect from earlier diagnosis. We are doing more testing than in March, which means some people will be diagnosed at an earlier phase of their illness, be treated earlier, and have better outcomes. This is a good thing, and is another reason to have aggressive testing – to prevent spread of the virus, but also to treat people early. Ironically, some have suggested that the numbers are being inflated by aggressive testing – but this testing reduces the case fatality rate by increasing the number of mild cases.
In addition to all this, is the virus mutating and becoming less deadly? The short answer is no. The virus is mutating very slowly (which is typical for this family of viruses) – about two changes per month. There are many variants of the virus, which helps virologists track the spread, and one variant seems to be increasing in frequency. Unfortunately this variant carries a mutation of the spike protein that potentially allows the virus to be more infectious. So if anything, the virus has become worse over time. So hoping for the virus to have mutated into a more benign form is not a good strategy. It mutates slowly, and may, if anything, become worse.
The available studies don’t have the power or rigor (because it’s hard to control for confounding variables in ecological studies) to determine with precision the relative contribution of all these factors. But they are all plausible and well-established phenomena in general, and the evidence does show they are all playing a role. People are surviving more because our care is improving and we are diagnosing cases earlier, but also because the pandemic has moved on from the most vulnerable to healthier victims and our public health measures are not only preventing new cases but shifting cases toward the milder end of the spectrum through lower viral loads.
None of this should make us complacent. The death rate remains high, and even a 3% case fatality rate, or 21% death rate for ICU admissions, makes this a very deadly illness.

COVID-19 Testing
Currently available tests for COVID-19 are imperfect but useful if used properly, with rapidly evolving research on new tests underway.
Steven Novella on May 20, 2020
Link
As states are beginning to phase out total lockdown in the US, there is much discussion about how best to do it, minimizing the chance of causing a resurgence in COVID-19 cases. Just about every expert questioned about this topic focuses on testing – we have to do lots of testing in order to track people who have the disease, trace their contacts, and isolate them. At its core the idea is simple – instead of isolated everyone, we isolate those who have the virus, but in order to do that we have to know who has it and who doesn’t. Symptoms are one guide, but you can have the virus and pass it on without displaying symptoms. Therefore testing is critical. Some experts estimate we will need to do millions of tests per day to safely open up.
What is the state of our testing technology, and how reliable is it? There is a lot of work in this area, so this is a rapidly moving target, but some recent reviews help put things into perspective. First some background on technology. Often the media talks about how “accurate” the tests are, but this is not a technical way to evaluate testing. For that we need to understand sensitivity and specificity.
Sensitivity, specificity, and predictive value
Sensitivity is the percentage of individuals with the condition being tested for who test positive, the so-called true-positive rate. So if a test in 90% sensitive (usually written as 0.90), it will come back positive in 90% of people who have the condition. Specificity is the percentage of people who don’t have the condition who test negative, the true-negative rate. A test that is 90% specific will be negative 90% of the time in people who do not have the condition, and will have a 10% false positive rate.
Sensitivity and specificity, however, only get you halfway to where you need to go. What you really want to know is the predictive value of a test – if a test is positive what is the chance you have the disease, or if negative that you don’t have it? In order to know this you not only need to know the sensitivity and specificity, you need to know the base rate of the disease in the population being tested. The more people who have the disease the more false negatives you are going to get compared to true negatives, and the fewer people with the condition the more false positives compared to true positives. This matters when we consider testing only people who are symptomatic, vs testing the general population.
By the way, I often use this as an analogy for science-based medicine itself. In order to interpret a p-value of a study you need to know the prior probability of the hypothesis. Even with a low p-value, if the hypothesis being tested is highly unlikely (like homeopathy) it is still far more likely the study is a false positive.
Available tests
DNA/RNA tests for active infections
The most widely used current test for active infection with the SARS-CoV2 virus that causes COVID-19 is a PCR test for viral RNA. PCR is polymerase chain reaction, a method of amplifying a tiny bit of RNA or DNA into a large amount that can then be detected. A test will key in on a segment of RNA that is specific to SARS-CoV2. A false positive can occur if the subject has other viruses with overlap in the RNA sequence that triggers a positive test. Also, the PCR is so powerful it can amplify a tiny bit of viral RNA that is a contaminant at any point in the process, and not from the subject being tested.
At first it was thought that if you have viral RNA in your body, you are infected with the virus, and this is still largely true. However some patients who were cleared of the virus tested positive with a PCR RNA test. This caused some concern that they may have been re-infected. However, it seems that these subjects tested positive because they still had bits of dead virus in them from the prior infection.
How good are the currently available PCR tests for active virus? A recent review concludes that the quality of the various tests is highly variable, and that protocols and testing quality need to improve and be standardized. There are too many different tests to review here so I will just mention some of the more common ones.
Perhaps the most common PCR test being used in retrospect has been found to have a sensitivity of 0.777 and a specificity of 0.988. That is great specificity, which means if you test positive you likely have the virus – but again, depending on the prior probability. If you are symptomatic during a pandemic, or were exposed to someone, then yeah, you probably have it. The sensitivity is a concern, however – about 23% of those with the virus will be missed by the test.
This is still a very useful test, however. One of the reasons for a false negative might be that it was done too early, and the virus was below detectable levels. You can improve the predictive value of the test by repeating it, therefore.
One of the emerging tests that promises to perhaps be even better than PCR is a CRISPR-based test. They claim a 100% specificity, but also a 97% sensitivity. We’ll have to see if these numbers hold up in independent testing.
There are other important features of a screening test if it is going to be used in millions of subjects – cost, time, and resources needed. Current testing can take days if it has to be sent to a lab, and requires testing equipment and trained professionals to administer. CRISPR and other testing being developed promised to be quicker, available in minutes, and easier to administer, possibly even self-administered. Again, we’ll see, but it does sound promising.
Antibody tests for past infections
An entirely different type of testing is serological testing that looks not for the presence of the virus but for the presence of antibodies to the virus. This would indicate not necessarily active infection, but past infection (at least long enough to have formed antibodies, and for as long as the antibodies persist). These tests would be used not to screen people to see if they have COVID-19 and need to be isolated, but to see if they had COVID-19 (even asymptomatically) in the past and now have antibodies to the virus.
This is useful mostly if those antibodies confer resistance, even immunity, to reinfection. Right now this is somewhat of an open question. If antibodies prove protective, then antibody testing could be used to provide “antibody passports” – an indication of immunity that will free people from lockdown.
There are two manifestations of immunity that need to be studied. The first is whether or not the presence of antibodies protects the individual from getting infected by keeping the virus from establishing a foothold. The second is whether or not the antibodies will protect someone from getting sick, even if they get the virus. And the third consideration is whether the antibodies will reduce the virus enough that it will not be passed on to others. All three are important and will affect recommendations in terms of the “passport” approach.
Here is a good review of currently available antibody testing. The bottom line is that there is a lot of variability, and we need more data. We specifically need more data on how protective the antibodies being tested for are.
Conclusion: SARS-CoV-2 tests are a moving target
        ◦ Given all the uncertainty, the currently available tests for SARS-CoV-2 are useful, if not perfect, and are getting better. Tests are being rapidly developed and tested in the middle of the pandemic, and we don’t know as much as we would like, but the situation is steadily improving. Even the currently available imperfect tests are incredibly useful in guiding treatment and behavior to limit the spread of the virus.

Is RSV Being Misdiagnosed as COVID-19?
Doctors who claimed that COVID-19 was essentially harmless to children are now being confronted with the sad fact that it is sometimes quite dangerous to them. How they respond reveals much about them and little about the virus.
Jonathan Howard on August 13, 2021
Link

In many parts of the United States, COVID-19 is affecting children more now than at any time this pandemic. 94,000 children were diagnosed with COVID-19 last week alone. The Delta variant appears to be causing more severe illness per the experience of multiple pediatricians, e.g.:
Dr. Kline Physician-in-Chief at Children's Hospital New Orleans: This delta variant is affecting a lot of young people. We are hospitalizing record number of children. Half of the children in our hospital are under 2 years of age pic.twitter.com/vgiWDHIcYh
— Cleavon MD 💉 💉 💉 (@Cleavon_MD) August 9, 2021
As Dr. Seth D. Kaplan, president of the Texas Pediatric Society, said,
We’re seeing a significantly greater number of children who are being hospitalized with COVID-19. Some are requiring ICU care, more than we’ve seen with previous surges, and that’s related to the increased transmissibility of delta. This is just a more aggressive variant. It’s sickening more children, and requiring more to be hospitalized.
While the rate of negative outcomes for children is still very low fortunately, the overall harms can add up to non-trivial numbers when this many children get infected. At least I feel that way. According to the CDC, an average of 239 children are being admitted to the hospital every day, the highest level of the pandemic so far.Over 200 children were diagnosed with MISC-C in July, and children with MIS-C are really sick, most needing treatment in the ICU. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, 22 children died of COVID-19 from 7/22/21 to 8/05/21.
Faced with these numbers, a suggestion emerged that perhaps COVID-19 really isn’t that bad, as children are being overdiagnosed with the virus. I first encountered this idea from Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg, a sports medicine doctor with a PhD in Epidemiology and Public Health. Dr. Høeg wondered on Twitter if the increases in COVID-19 diagnoses were perhaps due to misdiagnosis of RSV:
Fascinating. Looking at the @CDCgov 's COVID-NET, you see that it has been the 0-4 year olds driving up COVID hospitalization rates recently. 5-17 year olds have decreased/remained stable. I wonder if the recent RSV surge is resulting in some infant RSV cases being labeled COVID. pic.twitter.com/9qJQHvtKYy
— Tracy Høeg, MD, PhD (@TracyBethHoeg) August 5, 2021
The observation that prompted Dr. Høeg’s query was, “the 0-4 year olds driving up COVID hospitalization rates recently. 5-17 year olds have decreased/remained stable.” As she explained, a hospitalization due to RSV could be mis-labelled COVID-19 if they have a positive COVID test:
COVID-NET: https://t.co/iIZp3wom3C
RSV typically affects this 0-4 age group and, a child hospitalized for RSV may be labeled "covid" if they test positive for COVID.
Figure below via @contrarian4data showing recent increase in RSV in the US (https://t.co/ySPfUAWVc5). pic.twitter.com/iwbcNWlWsF
— Tracy Høeg, MD, PhD (@TracyBethHoeg) August 5, 2021
This notion garnered attention from a cadre of contrarian doctors who have largely denied that COVID-19 can cause severe illness in young people. Dr. Høeg also said, “Please teach me. Tell me if I am wrong. I don’t have all the answers”. I don’t have all the answers either, but I will try to clarify the issue.
Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a very common respiratory illness that can present with a runny nose, fever, wheezing, and a cough. It can spread to the lower respiratory tract, causing pneumonia or bronchiolitis. It can be quite severe, even deadly, in infants younger than 6 months or children under 2 years with chronic heart and lung conditions. According to the CDC, which tracks the virus, each year in the US RSV causes “approximately 58,000 hospitalizations with 100-500 deaths among children younger than 5 years old”.
Though it is usually a winter virus, it was basically absent the past winter due to pandemic restrictions. It is increasing now as people emerge from pandemic isolation, and many hospitals are seeing large volumes of children with RSV. Both RSV and COVID-19 are serious diseases, and a few children have both viruses.
So, are large numbers of children with RSV being misdiagnosed as having COVID-19? Do you really need to ask? As pediatrician Dr. Jennifer Chen noted, the two are unlikely to be confused unless you are trying to confuse:
Nope, not an issue except for contrarians actively trying to confuse non-pediatricians 🙃 pic.twitter.com/pL3ijAAHOq
— Dr. Jennifer Chen, MD FAAP 林 明 堯 (@DrJenChen4kids) August 8, 2021
Let’s explore why this is so.
The source for Dr. Høeg’s data about COVID-19 hospitalization rates is a federal database called COVID-NET. According to the CDC, “COVID-NET is limited to COVID-19-associated hospitalizations captured in the COVID-NET surveillance area.” In other words, a child has to have a positive test for SARS-CoV-2 to be included in the database, though some children who have been hospitalized for other reasons and happen to test positive have been counted.
COVID-NET covers only about 10% of the country. As such, the absolute numbers of pediatric hospitalizations reported by COVID-NET are quite small. The doubling of the hospitalization rate for children ages 0-4 years from week 28 to 29 was an increase of only 11 cases, and the 22% drop from week 29 to 30 was a decrease of only 5 cases (ages 0-4 are in yellow, ages 5-17 are in blue in the graph below). There were many other weeks earlier in the pandemic where younger children had a higher hospitalization rate than older children, even though RSV was not circulating at that time.Moreover, the last data point from when Dr. Dr. Høeg made her comment shows hospitalizations decreasing for children ages 0-4 and increasing for children ages 5-17. As older children are not hospitalized for RSV, this is the exact opposite of what one would expect if RSV was being inappropriately diagnosed as COVID-19. Of course, the hospitalization rate for children older than 12-years will be somewhat blunted by the fact that millions of them are vaccinated, though the overall vaccination rate remains depressing low.
As the graph of COVID-19 hospitalization rates shows, there are some broad trends throughout the year, but the numbers jump around erratically from week to week. Trying to find a meaningful pattern based on a few weeks data of a small number of cases is a bit like finding faces in clouds – it reveals something interesting about the person who discovers the “pattern” and nothing at all about the virus.
Pediatricians on social media were justifiably furious at the suggestion that they could not distinguish between these two viruses:
Quick spot check amongst my pediatric colleagues who have been taking care of children throughout the pandemic and not a single one was confused about RSV vs COVID or how to determine the difference. Not a single one.
— Christina Johns, MD MEd (@DrCJohns) August 8, 2021
Is this the new BS? We are misdiagnosing RSV as COVID? Are people aware that a) they are completely different diseases and b) there's a test?
— David Levine MD (@DavidLevineMD1) August 8, 2021
Pediatricians were very confident they could tell the viruses apart on clinical ground alone, in addition to the separate tests that exist for these diseases. RSV is diagnosed with a rapid antigen or PCR test, which is more likely to be used in the hospital setting. COVID-19 is, of course, diagnosed with a PCR test, and false positive tests are extremely rare.
For a child to be mistakenly diagnosed with COVID-19 when they actually have RSV, it would have to mean that their pediatrician is unable to distinguish these diseases clinically, the COVID-19 test would have to be a false positive, and the RSV test would have be to a false negative. Basically, as noted by Dr. Rebekah Diamond, the only way large numbers of children with RSV could be misdiagnosed with COVID-19 is if pediatricians and labs throughout the country were abysmally incompetent:
To be clear we universally test with pcr for both so there is a 0% chance we are miscounting cases, but the diagnosis of has always been clear even before the pcr results. The insistence on spewing nonsense that is debunked in 3 seconds by any pediatrician is astounding
— Rebekah Diamond MD (@rebekah_diamond) August 9, 2021
Notably, the doctors who now question whether COVID-19 is being misdiagnosed as RSV only consider that COVID-19 is being overdiagnosed, not the reverse. Early this summer when COVID-19 rates were falling and RSV rates were increasing, these doctors didn’t wonder whether COVID-19 was being misdiagnosed as RSV. This is quite revealing.
We should be honest about why someone would suggest that RSV is being misdiagnosed as COVID-19. It is clearly just another attempt to minimize COVID-19 by casting doubt on the fundamental numbers that we rely on to make judgments about the pandemic. It is also an attack on the basic competency of frontline pediatricians and laboratory pathologists caring for the sickest children with COVID-19. What they are really saying boils down to: Don’t believe the numbers you read or what the frontline pediatricians are saying. COVID-19 isn’t really so bad for kids after all.
But if you chose to believe the numbers provided by the American Academy of Pediatrics and the reports of frontline pediatricians, as I do, COVID-19 is actually pretty bad for a lot of children right now. This reality can’t be wished away. As Alex Haley said, “Either you deal with what is the reality, or you can be sure that the reality is going to deal with you”.
Of course, when there is evidence the numbers are problematic, it is important and necessary to point this out. As I have written previously, incidental COVID-19 diagnoses have led to the overcounting of pediatric hospitalizations and even potentially the overcounting of pediatric deaths. However, there are also reasons these metrics can be undercounted. Those who seek to convey complete and accurate information will acknowledge both sources of error. In contrast, those who wish to advance a narrative that COVID-19 isn’t that bad for children will instead only acknowledge the overcounting of COVID-19.
Doctors who claimed that COVID-19 was essentially harmless to children or that the vaccine was too risky, are now being confronted with overwhelming evidence that the virus is quite dangerous to a substantial number of them. While COVID-19 was always a danger to some children, it seems to be especially the case with the Delta variant. Children old enough to be vaccinated have died from the virus.
Sadly, few COVID-contrarian doctors are willing to adjust their prior beliefs, even as pediatric hospitals are full of really sick children and some children are dying. Having built their brand with editorials, news interviews, and Twitter hot takes, these doctors are now unwilling to even acknowledge the veracity of the grim statistics that opened this article. Uncomfortable facts become unmentionable facts.
Doctors who wish to avoid reality by suggesting that COVID-19 is being misdiagnosed are obligated to prevent compelling evidence this is the case. They do a grave disservice to children when they make absurd insinuations based on random data fluctuations of a very small number of patients. Much more is at stake here than attention-generating social media hot takes from COVID-contrarians.
Sadly, the myth that children with COVID-19 actually have RSV may already be influencing both public opinion and policy decisions. In Florida, where 32 children were hospitalized every day with COVID-19 the last week of July, Governor Ron Desantis clearly articulated what the contrarians clearly implied. He said,
COVID, I view as a very minor risk… When you see pediatric admissions, some of the may be COVID positive, or suspected COVID, it may ultimately turn out that RSV is what they end up being treated for.
There are real-world consequences when doctors with large, public platforms spread misinformation about COVID-19. This is true even if they claim to be very humbly “just asking questions“.

When Did “Herd Immunity” Become a Taboo Phrase?
Doctors who repeatedly predicted herd immunity in 2020 and 2021, mocking and berating those who disagreed, now treat herd immunity as a taboo phrase.
Jonathan Howard on September 12, 2023
Link

Herd immunity
An article from Johns Hopkins University describes herd immunity as:
When most of a population is immune to an infectious disease, this provides indirect protection – or population immunity (also called herd immunity or herd protection) – to those who are not immune to the disease.
The article gives examples of measles, mumps, polio, and chickenpox as diseases for which herd immunity exists in the U.S. Outbreaks of these diseases can still occur in pockets of unvaccinated people, but due to herd immunity, they fade away and don’t spiral out of control. If we had herd immunity to COVID, there would still be sporadic, limited outbreaks here and there, but no sustained transmission of the virus.
We do not have herd immunity to COVID.
It’s Mad That ‘Herd Immunity’ Was Ever a Taboo Phrase
With this definition of herd immunity in mind, let’s flashback to May 27th, 2021. On that day, two of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff, published an overly optimistic article titled It’s Mad That ‘Herd Immunity’ Was Ever a Taboo Phrase. They said:
Herd immunity is fundamental in epidemiological science. COVID spreads in populations when infectious individuals come in contact with individuals who are not already immune. Herd immunity reflects the obvious concept that an uninfected individual is less likely to catch the disease when a larger part of the population is immune. While COVID cannot be eradicated, herd immunity assures that in the long run, it will stay at low levels with few hospitalisations and deaths.
Just like gravity, herd immunity is a scientific fact. To the shock of many infectious disease epidemiologists, politicians, some media, and scientists turned it into a dirty word. Some talked about a ‘herd immunity strategy,’ but every strategy leads to herd immunity, so that is as nonsensical as pilots using a ‘gravity strategy’ to land a plane. The plane will reach the ground no matter what; the key is to land safely….
This denial of a basic scientific concept by so many prominent authorities is stunning. Rather than engage in a good-faith debate on how to protect the elderly better while minimising collateral public health damage from lockdowns, it was easier to demagogue the issue, turning a basic scientific concept – herd immunity – into a propaganda weapon to demonise lockdown opponents within the scientific community…
We now have considerable COVID immunity in the US and the UK, primarily due to natural infections with some help from vaccines. We know this since COVID deaths peaked three months earlier in 2021 than in 2020, while most people were still unvaccinated. As we enter summer with a lower herd immunity threshold, there are no public health reasons to keep the current lockdowns in place. Even the staunchest lockdown supporters should leave the summer months alone. If they understood herd immunity, they would.
As with everything from these doctors, this aged poorly. COVID’s death toll us the USA was 589,000 at the time, and immune-evading variants have since killed nearly 600,000 more Americans and sickened many millions more. Moreover, the last remnants of “lockdown” were going away forever when the piece was published.
However, the title – It’s Mad That ‘Herd Immunity’ Was Ever a Taboo Phrase – is worth discussing. In one sense, it was as wrong as the content of the article. However, in another sense it was just ahead of its time.
‘Herd immunity’ wasn’t a taboo phrase
The title was wrong in that herd immunity wasn’t a taboo phrase in 2020 and 2021. In fact, many doctors, most of whom lacked real-world responsibility for treating COVID patients, discussed herd immunity all the time. As early as April 2020 an article appeared titled, Swedish Official Anders Tegnell Says ‘Herd Immunity’ in Sweden Might be a Few Weeks Away. In July 2020, an interview with the third author of the GBD was published titled We May Already Have Herd Immunity – an Interview With Professor Sunetra Gupta. In February 2021, Dr. Marty Makary wrote an editorial titled We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April and the next month he wrote another titled Herd Immunity Is Near, Despite Fauci’s Denial. In May that year he said, “Most of the country is at herd immunity.” In February 2021, an article was published titled Pandemic Exit Interviews: Stop Panicking About the COVID-19 Variants, Says UCSF’s Monica Gandhi. Dr. Gandhi also recorded a podcast with Dr. Zubin Damania that month tilted The End of the Pandemic. In March 2021, Dr. Lucy McBride wrote an article titled I’ve Been Yearning for an End to the Pandemic. Now That it’s Here, I’m a Little Afraid. An article from May 2021 was titled California ‘Weeks Away’ From Reaching Herd Immunity, UCSF Doctors Say. There are many more examples. Though he would later say herd immunity was “unattainable” for COVID, even Dr. Anthony Fauci, the GBD’s scapegoat, was the subject of an article from December 2020 titled Fauci Predicts U.S. Could See Signs Of Herd Immunity By Late March Or Early April.
“The term is herd immunity”
The GBD itself talked about herd immunity extensively. It very reasonably defined herd immunity by saying:
Herd immunity occurs when enough people have immunity so that most infected people cannot find new uninfected people to infect, leading to the end of the epidemic/pandemic.
It also said:
When herd immunity is reached, they (vulnerable people) can live normally again with minimal risks. How long that takes depends on the strategy used. If age-wide lockdown measures are used to try and suppress the disease, it could take a year or two or three, making it very difficult for older people to protect themselves for that long. If focused protection is used, it will likely only take 3 to 6 months.
The Twitter feed of the GBD had multiple tweets about herd immunity – in 2020 and 2021. In December 2020, they said:
For COVID-19, all strategies lead to herd immunity, making it nonsensical to denote one specific approach as a herd immunity strategy just as it does not make sense for airplane pilots to talk about a “gravity strategy” for safely landing a plane. The Declaration advocates a strategy that minimizes mortality until herd immunity is reached. That is done by minimizing the number of older high-risk people in the group that get infected while maximizing them among those that are still uninfected when herd immunity arrives.
They had good news to share. They said:
Despite an estimated 750 million worldwide to date after 10 months living with the virus, we have seen only a handful of reinfections. If the virus is like other corona viruses in its immune response, recovery from infection will provide lasting protection against [sic].
They again said herd immunity could arrive in less than 6 months. In December 2020, they had the following Twitter exchange:
Question: So at six months you would anticipate herd immunity in the young and fit and it would be safe for the vulnerable to reintegrate to society?
Answer: Yes, between 3 – 6 months and then natural immunity should be at an acceptable level.
‘Herd Immunity’ is now a taboo phrase
The title was ahead of its time in that after 2021, mentions of herd immunity essentially stopped. The few doctors who mentioned herd immunity after this, did so only to absurdly redefine the term to make it seem as they had been right all along. Blatantly contradicting what he wrote in the GBD, Dr. Bhattacharya, said in December 2022:
Herd immunity for coronaviruses means a widescale decoupling of cases from deaths caused by the virus due to immunity.
However, most doctors who spoke ceaselessly about herd immunity in 2020 and 2021, refuse to do so today. In fact, they act as if they had never mentioned herd immunity at all. There has been scant acknowledgement that their preposterous predictions of the pandemic’s end failed to arrive. They’ve made no effort to grapple with the real-world consequences of telling people herd immunity was around the corner, when in fact the worst was yet to come. Instead of reflecting on their previous claims of herd immunity, these doctors now encourage repeat mass infection, saying:
Repeat infections are inevitable. More the longer you live. Nothing can be done about it.
And thus it becomes clear, doctors who previously mocked and berated those who supposedly treated herd immunity as a taboo phrase, now treat herd immunity, as they defined it in 2021, as a taboo phrase. As cases and hospitalizations rise once again, I wonder why that is.

The “spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration” promotes antivaccine misinformation
The signatories of the Great Barrington Declaration and its “spiritual child” the Brownstone Institute, swear up and down that they are not anttivaccine. If that’s so, why are Brownstone-affiliated academics spreading antivaccine misinformation in Uganda?
David Gorski on January 24, 2022
Link

As I approached the question of what to write about this week, I looked at our guest post about the Great Barrington Declaration authors and the Brownstone Institute spreading antivaccine misinformation under the guise of libertarianism and thought: Here we go. I’ve been meaning for a while now to revisit the Great Barrington Declaration, its authors, and the new right wing “institute” promoting it. Although I’ve written about it a number of times over at my not-so-super-secret other blog, I haven’t really addressed it here much since it was published in October 2020 and I originally likened it to “magnified minority”-style disinformation with more than a dash of eugenics in the form of the Declaration’s call about the virus, in essence, to “let ‘er rip” while somehow using “focused protection” to prevent mass death among those vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19.
Tellingly, what “focused protection” would actually mean in public health practice and how it would protect the vulnerable were never really described in sufficient detail to determine if this was a viable strategy. (Hint: It wasn’t, and, despite more recent claims by Great Barrington signatories, still isn’t.) Basically, when I first encountered the Great Barrington Declaration, I couldn’t help but get the feeling that the whole thing had a very strong “Screw the elderly and sick!” vibe to it that reeked of eugenics. Amusingly, when criticized, AIER portrayed itself and the advocates of the Great Barrington Declaration as the “new abolitionists,” parroting a common antimask and antivaccine theme that likens public health interventions against COVID-19 to “slavery“.
In any event, the idea behind the Great Barrington Declaration, such as it was, was that letting as many of the “low risk” and “healthy population” become infected with the virus would produce “natural herd immunity” and hasten the end of the pandemic. As I and a number of other have long pointed out, it’s not possible to protect the vulnerable if a contagious respiratory virus is spreading unchecked through the rest of the “healthy” population, and the cost of achieving “natural herd immunity” is widespread infection and far more death and suffering. More recently, the rise of the Delta and Omicron variants, the latter of which can easily reinfect many with “natural immunity” from prior infection, shows how foolish such a strategy would have been then and is now, given the existence of effective vaccines that can, at the very minimum, vastly decrease the risk of severe disease.
A lot has happened in the last 15 months. In October 2020 I did not view the Great Barrington Declaration signatories Dr. Sunetra Gupta (University of Oxford), Dr. Martin Kulldorff (then at Harvard University), and Dr. Jay Bhattacharya (Stanford University) as antivaccine. However, it must be remembered that the Declaration was first published two months before the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine was distributed to the public under an emergency use authorization (EUA), and events have moved in a direction that leads me to doubt my previous characterization. The most recent revelation comes in the form of a report by Alice McCool and Khatondi Soita Wepukhulu, US conservatives spreading anti-vax misinformation to unvaccinated Uganda. Its tagline? “Revealed: US Christian legal organisation and a Texas-based think tank are among those promoting anti-lockdown and vaccine hesitancy messages in Uganda”.
Why is the fact that the think tank behind spreading these messages is based in Texas? Here’s why. The think tank spreading misinformation about “lockdowns,” vaccines, and masks is the Brownstone Institute. I’ll start by revisiting the Great Barrington Declaration and the birth of the Brownstone Institute. I hope that my narrative leads you to see that it wasn’t a matter if the Great Barrington Declaration signatories and the think tanks behind them would start drifting into standard antivaccine territory, but when.
The influence of the Great Barrington Declaration thus far
The Great Barrington Declaration was the product of a long weekend retreat held in early October 2020 in Great Barrington, MA at the headquarters of the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), the free market right wing/libertarian think tank from which the Brownstone Institute spun off. It’s worth recounting first just how influential the Great Barrington Declaration has been and how this conference came about, because both of these bits of history help illustrate how the Great Barrington Declaration is astroturf.
First, this is how influential the Declaration has been (full disclosure, I was co-author of this article):
The GBD influenced covid-19 policy on both sides of the Atlantic. According to the Sunday Times, in September 2020, Gupta, along with Oxford University’s Carl Heneghan and Sweden’s state epidemiologist Anders Tegnell, advised UK prime minister Boris Johnson not to institute a national “circuit breaker” lockdown to forestall a predicted second wave, persuading him to delay. Details of this meeting, and of the opposition to a circuit breaker by Gupta and Heneghan, were described by Dominic Cummings in his testimony to members of parliament on 26 May 2021. However, Gupta and Heneghan dispute Cummings’s recollection of the meeting and have provided written evidence to the Health and Social Care Committee and Science and Technology Committee detailing their version of events. They deny Cummings’ claim that they said that there was already herd immunity in the population and that there would be no second wave. Their written evidence suggests that they discussed the need for a strategy to control covid, while minimising societal disruption. Johnson’s “delay in imposing national restrictions,” argues Alan McNally, professor of microbial genomics at the University of Birmingham, “resulted in an estimated 1.3 million extra covid infections.” Gupta also kept Georg von Opel apprised of her efforts: in April 2020, after a television appearance on a Channel 4 debate called “Can Science beat the Virus?”, she wrote an email to von Opel obtained by Open Democracy under Freedom of Information legislation, “I tried to make the point even more strongly that we cannot just consider the question of lifting lockdown in the single dimension of what it will do to the pandemic, but they [Channel 4 news] have cut it down dramatically.”
In October 2020, Gupta, Kulldorff, and Bhattacharya met with two of US President Donald Trump’s senior health officials, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar and Scott Atlas. Atlas was at the time on leave from his fellowship at the Hoover Institution, a conservative think tank affiliated with Stanford University. The meeting reportedly led the administration to eagerly embrace the GBD. Nor did the GBD authors limit their efforts to national governments. For example, in March 2021 Florida Governor Ron DeSantis hosted a video roundtable with Atlas, Gupta, Kulldorff, and Bhattacharya, where they expressed opposition to masks, testing and tracing, physical distancing, and mass vaccination. YouTube removed the video “because it included content that contradicts the consensus of local and global health authorities regarding the efficacy of masks to prevent the spread of Covid-19.” GBD authors, predictably, cried, “Censorship!” Bhattacharya continues to advise Governor DeSantis on Florida’s covid-19 policies, including providing legal testimony in support of DeSantis’s ban on mask mandates in public schools.
More recently, physicians supportive of the Great Barrington Declaration have achieved positions of influence that would allow them to implement their policies. For example, a few months ago, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis appointed Dr. Joseph Ladapo, a member of the COVID-19 minimizing, ivermectin-promoting America’s Frontline Doctors, as Florida’s Surgeon General and head of the state’s Department of Health. Predictably, Dr. Ladapo immediately began dismantling the puny remains of Florida’s pandemic response by implementing policies based on “natural herd immunity“.
Even more recently, recently elected Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin appointed Dr. Marty Makary to chair his medical advisory team. Regular readers will recall that Dr. Makary is a surgical oncologist at Johns Hopkins who first came to our notice six years ago for his innumerate and poorly supported claim that medical errors are the “third leading cause of death” in the US. More recently, he has been using similarly incorrect numbers to prematurely declare the pandemic “over” and referring to the masking of children as “abusive”, while making the false claim that masks are “vectors for pathogens“. He used these sorts of arguments to promote a “herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, even after having made the risible claim (even then) nearly a year ago that we would have “herd immunity by April“. It was a prediction that Makary used to as a basis to propose very Great Barrington Declaration-like policies involving the loosening COVID-19 restrictions. (Eleven months later, how’d that prediction work out? Maybe Dr. Makary meant April 2022. Oh, wait…) Now he’s in charge of the advisory committee guiding Virginia’s COVID-19 response. This will not end well.
Before I move on to the current activities of Great Barrington Declaration-associated scientists and groups, let’s first discuss how the Declaration came about.
The birth of the Great Barrington Declaration
The conference that led to the drafting of the Great Barrington Declaration, it turns out, was a spur-of-the-moment affair. It came about through a combination of behind-the-scenes recruitment by AIER leaders combined with a fortuitous (for AIER) discovery of a scientist who enthusiastically agreed with them. I first looked into the origins of the Great Barrington Declaration after seeing its authors complain about the article I cited above:
Slander and lies have been hallmarks of attacks on the @gbdeclaration.
This is because lockdown proponents have weak arguments. Their lockdown love has hurt millions via collateral damage & benefited only the laptop class to which many of them belong.https://t.co/M3P9b5BBy4
— Jay Bhattacharya (@DrJBhattacharya) October 12, 2021
That was Dr. Jay Bhattacharya sharing a Spectator article by Martin Kulldorff (who, spoiler alert, was AIER’s first recruit of the three signatories). In the article, Kulldorff tries to deny being the tool of a right wing think tank and even invokes the Galileo gambit and fantasy of future vindication. Let’s start, though, by looking at what AIER itself said about the conference that resulted in the Great Barrington Declaration:
First, though, let’s look at what AIER itself said:
From October 1-4, 2020, the American Institute for Economic Research hosted a remarkable meeting of top epidemiologists, economists, and journalists, to discuss the global emergency created by the unprecedented use of state compulsion in the management of the Covid-19 pandemic. The result is The Great Barrington Declaration, which urges a “Focused Protection” strategy.
As I like to say, sure, they were there just for “media interviews”. From the AIER description, it sure sounds as though it was more than just that. One might speculate that the Great Barrington Declaration was a hoped-for outcome of the meeting, its protestations otherwise notwithstanding:
The AIER staff did not even know about the Declaration until the day before it was signed, and the AIER president and board did not know about it until after publication.
Unfortunately for Kulldorff, Jeffrey Tucker, “founder of the Brownstone Institute and an independent editorial consultant who served as Editorial Director for the American Institute for Economic Research”, was, as the famous song from the Broadway musical Hamilton goes, in the “room where it happened,” as he stated at around 5:15 in this episode of the official podcast of the John Locke Foundation posted to YouTube only a week after the confab at the AIER headquarters that led to the Great Barrington Declaration:
I can’t resist transcribing what Tucker said about the Great Barrington Declaration soon after it had been issued and his role in its drafting, given that it’s contemporaneous and before all the mythology AIER built up around it:
I was there while it [the Great Barrington Declaration] was being drafted. I was very moved. I made a couple of suggestions here and there.
Remember, in 2020 Tucker the editorial director of AIER. He was in charge of its entire messaging apparatus. Earlier in the video, he also characterized the process of writing the Great Barrington Declaration this way:
Scientists—most scientists—are not political people. They’re in science and epidemiology and public health because they want to help people and minimize the social damage of infectious diseases and pathogens. They’re scientific people, not political people. Unfortunately, because of lockdowns, suddenly infectious disease became highly political. It never should have happened, but it happened, and they found themselves in awkward positions.
So after months and months some of them began to speak out. I noticed in particular Martin Kulldorff, and then also I noticed Sunetra Gupta, who’s a godlike figure in epidemiology, and also Jay Bhattacharya, who’s similarly a highly credentialed MD/PhD at Stanford. Sunetra is over at Oxford and Kulldorff is at Harvard. I noticed that they started to speak out a little bit. I began to feel bad for Martin because I thought that it must be a lonely life over at Harvard being against lockdowns, and he was taking a risk to his career speaking out this way. I quickly dropped him a Twitter notice, “We’ve got a nice place, why don’t you come and visit here?” We’re a few hours away. We’ll feed you well and relax a bit, and he wrote me back, “OK.”
So when I realized that Kulldorff was coming, I dropped a note to an attorney in New Jersey, Stacey Rudin, and then another one in New York who had become anti-lockdown…and said, “Listen, Martin Kulldorff is coming. Why don’t you join?” So they all came here. We had no agenda whatsoever. We went out to the cider mills, enjoyed each other’s company, got to know each other, because he had lost all of his old friends, you know….So we just had a really lovely weekend.
Besides having written a number of articles for AIER, Rudin is the one who likened lockdowns to “slavery” and the AIER and other “anti-lockdown” activists to “abolitionists”.
After Kulldorff went back home to Boston, having spent a weekend hanging out with Tucker, Rudin, and other AIER luminaries and hangers-on, he emailed Tucker, as Tucker describes:
Well, within about ten days, he wrote me back and said: I have an idea. Let’s bring some high end journalists from around the country. We can meet at your place, and then I’ll get Jay Bhattacharya flown in from Stanford and then I’ll get Sunetra Gupta from Oxford. Well, I was nonplussed, thinking, “That sounds…interesting. When do you propose to do this, because we can’t do it until the 31st of October?”
He said, “No, we’re going to do it this weekend.” He said, “We can’t wait until the 31st, the crisis is too bad.”
So the next thing you know, we had all these people here, and we scrambled to get the recordings right. We didn’t have a big agenda, but we held a question-answer session. We taped a few interviews and that sort of thing, and they wrote the declaration and released it. We built and released the website in 18 hours (something like that), and it was all kind of crazy and wonderful.
This account explains this observation:
Weird that AIER didn't know about the Great Barrington Declaration before it was announced on Oct 4, 2020, yet AIER registered gbdeclaration dot org on Oct 3, 2020 🤔
— Justin Feldman (@jfeldman_epi) October 13, 2021
Let me remind you again what Jeffrey Tucker’s job was at AIER at the time, as described by AIER President Edward Stringham himself:
Jeffrey will join me and colleagues to expand the influence of AIER, an illustrious institution founded in 1933 by MIT professor E.C. Harwood (1900–1980). AIER became the first market-oriented research institution in the world, inspiring the creation of many more and giving the liberal movement the boost it needed. An early contributor to what is now referred to as the Austrian theory of the business cycle, Harwood warned about the coming stock market crash that came in 1929, and the ill-effects of monetary expansion and devaluation on human wellbeing. He was friends with Henry Hazlitt and F.A. Hayek and his work helped shape the free-market thinking in the United States.
With the hiring of Jeffrey, I feel confident that AIER will take that necessary next steps in expanding our impact to help promoting economic knowledge in America and beyond. Thanks to his joining our team, we are honored and very excited for the future.
There’s no doubt that, through his role in facilitating and publicizing the Great Barrington declaration, Tucker succeeded beyond Stringham’s wildest expectations in expanding the impact of the AIER and its influence among governments with similar political alignments.
Mythologizing of the Great Barrington Declaration aside, the story that I perceived was that Kulldorff, at least, was an enthusiastic participant, if not the instigator of the Great Barrington Declaration. If Tucker’s contemporaneous account is to be believed, AIER reached out to Kulldorff and invited him for a weekend at AIER to be wined and dined while hanging out with like-minded anti-lockdown activists. Kulldorff, perceiving that he’d finally found his people, signed on enthusiastically to AIER’s mission and then brought on board Bhattacharya and Gupta to help him and the AIER promote its anti-lockdown message, crafting, with Tucker’s help, a very effective propaganda tool.
That propaganda tool was the Great Barrington Declaration.
The birth of the Brownstone Institute
Two months ago, it was announced that Kulldorff had resigned his tenured faculty position as professor at Harvard University in order to join an institute formed last year called the Brownstone Institute as Senior Scientific Director:
The Brownstone Institute is pleased to announce that Dr. Martin Kulldorff is joining our institute as Senior Scientific Director. Having served as a professor at Harvard Medical School for the past ten years, he will guide the scientific activities of the Institute, particularly as it relates to the pandemic and the needed public health recovery and reform so that no country will repeat the terrible errors of 2020-21.
Professor Kulldorff’s position at Brownstone begins on November 1, 2021.
“We cannot overstate the excitement we feel about Kulldorff’s deep involvement with our work,” says Brownstone Institute founder and president Jeffrey Tucker. “He brings rigor, focus, and true brilliance, and his position portends great things for us as an institution.”
The Brownstone Institute was founded in 2021 to respond to this crisis with research, publishing, education, and other programs intended as a guiding light out of the crisis.
But what is the Brownstone Institute? In brief, it was founded by the aforementioned Jeffery Tucker last May. Unsurprisingly, Tucker strenuously denies that AIER had any involvement in the founding of the new institute, claiming that AIER “in no way sponsored or backed Brownstone,” but rather Brownstone really is “the child of [his] own obsession” and that Brownstone aims to publish content that represents all political backgrounds, perspectives, and ideologies. Amusingly, though, if you search the mailing address for Brownstone, it resolves to Scan Mailboxes, in Austin, TX. The Brownstone Institute, as yet it appears, has no physical address other than a mail drop.
Consistent with its founder’s politics, the website describes the Brownstone Institute as the “spiritual child” of the Great Barrington Declaration:
The mission of the Brownstone Institute – which is, in many ways, the spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration – is constructively to come to terms with what happened, understand why, discover and explain alternative paths, and prevent such events from happening again. Lockdowns have set a precedent in the modern world and without accountability, social and economic institutions will be shattered once again. Brownstone Institute is essential in preventing the recurrence of lockdowns by holding decision makers intellectually to account. In addition, the Brownstone Institute hopes to shed light on a path to recovery from the devastating collateral damage, while providing a vision for a different way to think about freedom, security, and public life.
Brownstone Institute looks to influence a post-lockdown world by generating new ideas in public health, scientific discourse, economics, and social theory. It hopes to enlighten and mobilize public life to defend and promote the liberty that is critical for an enlightened society from which everyone benefits. The purpose is to point the way toward a better understanding of essential freedoms – including intellectual freedom and free speech – and the proper means to preserve essential rights even in times of crisis.
You can see from this that the Brownstone Institute is primarily a political and, indeed, mostly aligned with the right, its denials notwithstanding:
Our content is neither left nor right, though our contributors have their own views. As an institution, Brownstone celebrates democratic institutions, freedom as the path to scientific progress, a trustworthy system of public health, a vibrant culture, and economic prosperity. We also share a concern for all members of society, including the poor and the working class. In accordance with these ideals, we publish a wide variety of perspectives and viewpoints, including contradictory views by different authors.
Let’s just say that I’ve long perused the Brownstone Institute’s list of articles, and they are depressingly similar in their message, be it promoting disproven treatments like hydroxychloroquine (the promotion of which first brought America’s Frontline Doctors to prominence in 2020) and ivermectin, deceptive promotion of “natural immunity” as a way out of the pandemic, more false descriptions of masking children as “abusive“, a hilariously and dramatically overblown article by Stacey Rudin titled “The Monumental Sacrifice of Novak Djokovic” (the tennis player barred from Australia for being unvaccinated), articles credulously touting the “lab leak” conspiracy theory, and articles arguing that COVID-19 vaccines aren’t working and against vaccinating children. There’s even an article that compared vaccine mandates to the sort of “othering” of minority populations that led to the crimes of the Soviet gulag, the Holocaust, Jim Crow, Rwanda. This, of course, is a common blatantly antivaccine narrative going back, well, as long as I’ve been paying attention to the antivaccine movement.
More recently, Drs. Bhattacharya and Kulldorff are promoting COVID-19 misinformation claiming that “natural immunity” undercuts the case for vaccine mandates; vaccine mandates for healthcare workers harm patients; vaccine mandates are destroying labor markets and hospitals; Fauci was wrong about school closures; and Fauci oversold masks and undersold better ventilation. These claims are all at best deceptive and at worst false. Unsurprisingly, in addition to Kulldorff, the other two signatories of the Great Barrington Declaration, Jay Bhattacharya and Sunetra Gupta, are regular contributors to the Brownstone Institute, along with some of the doctors speaking at yesterday’s antivaccine rally in Washington, DC, such as Aaron Kheriaty, Paul Alexander (he of “we want them infected” fame), and Pierre Kory. Indeed, yesterday, Brownstone Institute flacks were posting glowing articles praising the protesters as the “rise of the resistance,” with Jeffrey Tucker himself beside himself likening vaccine mandates as “segregation” as he begged for donations, and Clayton Fox gushing about a “coalition of medical doctors and PhD’s all heavily credentialed in their fields” that included Peter McCullough, Pierre Kory, Paul Marik, and Robert Malone, while marveling at Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. while (sort of) conceding that some of the speakers were antivaccine.
Also, no surprise, Vinay Prasad and Peter Doshi have contributed, as well. One wonders how long it will be before Brownstone commissions an article by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., you know, in order to show that they are accepting of voices from the left as well, as long as those voices agree with the right-wing, anti-lockdown, anti-(vaccine)mandate voices that make up 100% of Brownstone’s output.
Given this history, the activities of the Brownstone Institute in Uganda should come as no surprise.
Promoting anti-public health misinformation in poor countries: A common antivax theme
So what is the Brownstone Institute up to in Uganda? According to Alice McCool and Khatondi Soita Wepukhulu, it’s behind a campaign called End Lockdown Now:
US Christian legal organisation Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) and Texas-based libertarian think tank the Brownstone Institute are among the organisations backing Uganda’s ‘End Lockdown Now’ campaign.
And:
End Lockdown Now has platformed anti-vax, anti-mask, anti-lockdown and pandemic-denying arguments, with journalists and scientists from Europe and Australia among those spreading misinformation to Ugandans at the group’s online events. One such event was hosted by ADF.
And:
Just 5% of Uganda’s population is fully vaccinated, with the country on the cusp of reopening after one of the world’s longest and toughest lockdowns. Last week the virus was the number two cause of death in the country.
End Lockdown Now was launched in June by Ugandan lawyer and preacher Simon Ssenyonga, It has platformed arguments for the use of ivermectin, an unproven treatment for the virus, and a recent Facebook post shared by the campaign claims that PCR testing is not a valid way to detect COVID. Ssenyonga insists his organisation is “not a misinformation campaign” and says it does not “propagate” the use of ivermectin.
Brownstone Institute founder Jeffrey Tucker, who made the “natural immunity” claim, also stated falsely at the same event that COVID-19 vaccines were “a technology that’s not been proven as safe and effective”.
But wait! I thought that Tucker and Brownstone were “provaccine”! He even says so when contacted by the journalists:
Asked for comment, Tucker said: “Though neither scientist nor doctor, I am a fan of vaccines for those who will benefit from them and the Brownstone Institute has published articles favouring vaccination against COVID. Lockdowns are the worst assault on the poor, working-class communities and small businesses all over the world.”
I searched the Brownstone Institute for such articles in all its articles tagged with “vaccines“. I can’t help but wonder if Tucker meant articles like the one about the “monumental sacrifice of Novak Djokovic,” the one lamenting the “defenstration of Dr. Robert Malone” (who, recall, has gone full antivax lately and was a headliner at the antivax confab yesterday), the one portraying the “denial” of “natural immunity” as “psychological cruelty” (by Tucker himself!), or the one touting “146 studies” that prove “natural immunity” is better than vaccine-induced immunity (they don’t). Maybe he meant Vaccines Save Lives, which, despite its title, is chock full of antivax omissions, factual errors, and flaws in logic, as recounted by Jonathan Howard, or maybe the concession in an article about COVID-19 that it “would appear that vaccination is protective of severe disease” that attributed strokes and cardiac deaths to the vaccine while arguing that masks don’t work.
Unsurprisingly, Ssenyonga is very much antivaccine, as a quick search of his Twitter feed showed me:
But why do our governments insist we all get vaccinated when the “vaccines” are known to be unsafe and so many people have natural immunity?#EndLockdownNow pic.twitter.com/hBuYVTdqjl
— Ssenyonga Simon (@_SimonSsenyonga) October 15, 2021
This shift in messaging, from “we are all in this together” and “everyone who WANTS a vaccine will get one” to “everyone MUST get a vaccine or else be excluded from most aspects of society” That's the narrative being spinned by government and its cronies.#EndLockdownNow pic.twitter.com/pFPtjuyelO
— Ssenyonga Simon (@_SimonSsenyonga) October 14, 2021
And he’s sharing Brownstone content:
Cease the illogical, irrational, inaccurate, and nonsensical absurdity that Covid-19 vaccine immunity is superior to naturally acquired immunity when the science is clear that natural exposure immunity is similar to if not way superior to COVID vaccines https://t.co/ne9V7iv5PA
— Ssenyonga Simon (@_SimonSsenyonga) September 24, 2021
While referring to vaccine mandates as “medical tyranny”:
Medical tyranny growing in Uganda.@Parliament_Ug is subtly normalising vaccine mandates disguised as "setting an example" and @Educ_SportsUg also subtly introducing vaccine mandates for school reopening after 77 weeks closure.Definately, we are resisting this.#EndLockdownNow pic.twitter.com/2n54ejm0Ug
— Ssenyonga Simon (@_SimonSsenyonga) October 28, 2021
So it’s unsurprising that Brownstone-affiliated academics are a favorite of End Lockdown Now events:
Writers attached to Tucker’s Brownstone Institute have been a common thread through many of the online events for End Lockdown Now. At one event, Netherlands-based immunologist Carla Peeters said she believed COIVID-19 had already entered its “endemic” stage, meaning it was no longer a pandemic. She also claimed masks do not prevent transmission and that the virus is “not that dangerous for younger people”.
Gigi Foster, another Brownstone author and professor with the School of Economics at the University of New South Wales, Australia, claimed at another event that lockdowns are “the wrong thing for public health” and said politicians around the world are “facing personal incentives to keep the narrative going”.
Nothing like a variation on the “pharma shill gambit” to convince me that this isn’t a conspiracy theory! Pray, continue, though:
A number of key players at the Brownstone Institute, including Tucker himself, were involved in writing the Great Barrington Declaration – an online statement promoting ‘herd immunity‘ through mass infection approach to the pandemic, a strategy criticised as “unethical” by the World Health Organization.
Leading to:
“We thought that the Barrington Declaration offered something which was reasonable, something which was based on science,” said Ssenyonga, adding that the authors’ credentials made him “even more critical” of government COVID-19 mandates.
Add to that the natural suspicion people of color and people in less wealthy countries have of European countries and the US based on their historical experience with imperialism, and it’s no wonder that the Brownstone Institute found a receptive audience in Uganda.
Same as it ever was
Antivaxxers have a long and horrible history of trying to export their message to minorities and poor nations, populations where antivaccine messaging can do the most harm. I first started discussing this unfortunate tactic many years ago, when antivaxxers targeted the Somalian immigrant community in Minnesota with Andrew Wakefield’s message that the MMR vaccine causes autism (with Wakefield himself appearing there at least once), resulting in years and years of intermittent measles outbreaks. In 2019, mere months before the pandemic hit, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and other antivaxxers targeted Samoa, which at the time was in the middle of one of the worst measles outbreaks imaginable, with dozens of deaths. The misinformation about MMR and measles spread by RFK Jr. and his acolytes (including a letter by RFK Jr. himself to the Samoan Prime Minister mere weeks before the outbreak of a novel coronavirus disease in Wuhan, China started making the news) hampered vaccination campaigns for months.
Here in the US, these efforts take the form of targeting minorities, particularly communities of color, to spread conspiracy theories about vaccines, using examples of medical atrocities from history like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, to stoke the fear and mistrust that lead to vaccine hesitancy in these communities. How is what Brownstone Institute-associated people are doing in Uganda by appearing at local events virtually any different than these previous efforts to stoke vaccine hesitancy? It isn’t, other than being virtual appearances, rather than the in-person appearances that antivaxxers made in, for example, Minnesota.
        ◦ Deny it as much as Jeffrey Tucker might, the Brownstone Institute has tilted decisively in the direction of spreading antivaccine misinformation. If there was ever any doubt, seeing Suntra Gupta herself argue two months ago that the way out of the pandemic was “natural herd immunity” through “repeated infection” with different strains of COVID-19 and “our long history of previous exposure to seasonal coronaviruses may well have protected many of us from severe Covid-19”. (Ironically, she didn’t mention Omicron, which at the time was preparing to take off in the US and globally, thanks to its increased transmissibility compared to Delta and its ability to evade previous immunity, both vaccine-induced and “natural.”) I knew, even fifteen months ago, that the Great Barrington Declaration signatories and everyone associated with that misbegotten piece of astroturf were going to go this way.

Brownstone uses flawed data analysis to minimize COVID in NYC; An NYC hospitalist’s perspective
Guest posters Drs. Eric Burnett and Jonathan Laxton provide a lengthy rebuttal to Dr. Jessica Hockett’s claims that NYC did not suffer a deadly, almost overwhelming wave of COVID-19 in 2020.
Eric Burnett on December 1, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: Two weeks’ ago Jonathan Howard highlighted some flaws in Dr. Jessica Hockett’s claims about the 2020 COVID-19 wave in NYC, extensively quoting a Twitter-based analysis Columbia’s Dr. Eric Burnett. Dr. Burnett has collaborated with Dr. Jonathan Laxton to provide a long-form post elaborating on the Twitter thread, which is presented below.]
COVID-19 denialism and disinformation have exacerbated the spread of SARS-CoV-2 and slowed the pandemic response in the U.S. Recently Hockett, who holds a Ph.D. in educational psychology, published a series of articles for the Brownstone Institute (e.g. this one). Using city-level data, she claims that the COVID-19 surge in New York City in the spring of 2020 was exaggerated. The Brownstone Institute relies on COVID-19 minimization techniques to help them forward their anti-lockdown, anti-mask, and anti-vaccine agenda and make such measures appear as overreactions and government overreach. Does Jessica Hockett present an accurate picture of COVID-19 in New York City? No, not even close.
Before getting too deep into this, you should know more about me. I am a board-certified internist and work as an academic hospitalist at a major NYC hospital (just an FYI, my views here are my own and don’t reflect those of my employer). This means I specialize in the care and management of hospitalized patients. I was one of the first physicians deployed to a COVID care team at my institution. I sat in on daily departmental meetings, which discussed how best to deploy COVID surge teams and map ICU and hospital bed capacity. I helped create a COVID patient care curriculum for our internal medicine residents so that we could all be kept up to date on the evidenced-based management of our patients. I was the attending physician for one of our COVID step-down units. I admitted and cared for hundreds of COVID patients throughout this pandemic. I bore witness to a tremendous amount of loss and human suffering, but I also saw the beauty in life’s fragility. This was my life for three months working in the epicenter of a global pandemic. My experience matters, and my expertise matters.
Hockett and her supporters have accused me of using appeals to emotion and authority to justify my claims. They feel as though I’m gatekeeping the analysis of these data, that I am saying only a doctor can express an opinion on this matter. Some have gone so far as to claim my “trauma-addled brain” is preventing me from remembering facts correctly. Let’s be clear, I don’t owe her or anyone else a response to such ludicrous claims. I could end this here and let my experiences and expertise serve as a rebuttal to her analysis, but I won’t. Hockett’s attempt at historical revisionism is not only disrespectful to the thousands of COVID victims and NYC frontline healthcare workers who sacrificed so much during the pandemic, but it also undermines public health efforts. It will make dealing with the next public health crisis much more difficult.
Please consider one thing while reading this post: which is the more likely scenario? Did thousands of healthcare workers in NYC, the media, and the lay public somehow band together to concoct an elaborate lie about hospitals being overwhelmed in the spring of 2020? Or did one person misinterpret data that she did not understand, arrive at the wrong conclusion and publish it on her Substack? Her claims have been debunked previously, such as this post by John Howard about the reality in New York. But I feel like an NYC hospitalist’s perspective is also called for. So, allow me to debunk Hockett’s claims, not with emotional appeals to authority, but with cold, hard facts.
Claim one: NYC emergency departments were not overwhelmed due to decreased patient visits
In her posts, Hockett makes many assumptions about NYC in the spring of 2020. She has previously suggested that NYC hospitals were not overrun because emergency department (ED) volume decreased during that time.
This is a vast oversimplification and demonstrates a lack of understanding of hospital operations and how the pandemic affected ED visits. Healthcare systems can become overwhelmed for various reasons: staffing shortages, increased patient volume, increased patient acuity, an influx of more complex medical cases leading to an increased length of stay, and reduced bed capacity. The raw number of patients is not the only factor. The changes in ED patient volume were dynamic during the pandemic. This has been well documented in both the scientific literature and lay press.
The CDC MMWR published data on the declining ED visits during the early stages of the pandemic, which showed some specific trends:
During the early 4-week interval in the COVID-19 pandemic, ED visits were substantially lower than during the same 4-week period during the previous year; these decreases were especially pronounced for children and females in the Northeast. In addition to diagnoses associated with lower respiratory disease, pneumonia, and difficulty breathing, the number and ratio of visits (early pandemic period versus comparison period) for cardiac arrest and ventricular fibrillation increased.
As you can see in this table, minor conditions such as muscle and joint pain/injuries, sprains, urinary tract infections, high blood pressure, headaches, and other less urgent presentations decreased significantly. Other studies have confirmed decreases in presentations with non-fatal trauma (25% decrease), motor vehicle-related injuries (23.3% decrease), and injuries related to falls (25.1% decrease). If people are staying home due to pandemic health orders, you can see why these presentations would decline. Many of these conditions were handled by telehealth visits to decompress the emergency department and create space/resources for the ever-growing number of COVID-19 patients. An increase in critically ill COVID-19 patients can quickly consume the resources normally used to manage less-urgent patients. You can imagine that 30 patients in multi-organ failure, requiring central line placement, intubation, mechanical ventilation, vasopressor support, emergent diagnostic imaging, and CPR are much more burdensome and overwhelming to the healthcare system than 100 people with non-urgent concerns. The resources freed up by reductions in non-urgent visits were not enough to offset the requirements of COVID-19 patients.
Claim two: NYC emergency departments were not overrun by people with COVID-19
Hockett claims:
Only 3% of the people who came to New York City hospital EDs during the spring 2020 March-May wave were clinically diagnosed* with the virus. At no point did the percentage of visits to NYC hospital EDs with a COVID diagnosis exceed 10%.

*Per NYC department of health, a clinically diagnosed COVID ED visit is ‘a visit with an ICD-10 discharge diagnosis cde of U07.1 or a SNOMED code of 840539006.’ A clinical diagnosis does not have to include a laboratory-confirmed test for SARS-CoV-2, but a positive test irrespective of symptoms would receive diagnosis.
This argument assumes the EDs were not overrun with COVID-19 patients because there were few COVID-19 diagnoses based solely on ICD-10 codes. There are a few issues with this observation.
    • Testing in the beginning weeks of the pandemic was very limited and available testing was bogged down with bureaucratic red tape. For example, if we had a patient under investigation (PUI) for COVID-19, initially we could not test them unless they had traveled from mainland China. Later, testing was allowed for anyone in contact with someone from mainland China and then anyone exposed to a known patient with COVID-19. If they did not meet these criteria, despite having symptoms of COVID-19, they could not receive a test.
    • We now know that there is significant presymptomatic spread of COVID-19, therefore these policies would have missed many cases in the city.
    • When we were able to secure a test, there was initially only one lab that would run the PCR, so the results took days to come back (this improved as more labs opened up in the city and hospitals began running in-house PCRs).
    • If patients did not require admission, they were discharged home and told to quarantine until their test results returned. Their discharge diagnosis would usually be documented as upper respiratory tract infection (URI), bronchitis, viral URI not otherwise specified (NOS), or pneumonia. If you only search ED visits with a discharge diagnosis of COVID-19 using the ICD-10 code U07.1, you would miss the majority of the patients who had COVID-19 early in the pandemic but were coded as something else.
Hockett claims:
But NYC hospitals had tests in March. For example, one week after obstetricians at New York Presbyterian/Columbia University Irving Medical Center reported a COVID case in an obstetrical patient on March 13, 2020, all women admitted to the labor and delivery unit were being tested for SARS-CoV-2 infection.
This does not prove that tests were widely available in New York City but rather were made available for a high-risk population of patients (pregnant women). This chart demonstrates the number of tests in New York City versus people presenting with respiratory symptoms to the EDs. You can see it was not until March 17th that number of tests reached same the same level as respiratory presentations.
Hockett then discusses the test positivity rate seen in New York City in the spring:
The positivity rate of 50%-75% apparently didn’t raise questions about whether SARS-CoV-2 had been circulating among millions of people after many months. Instead, it led public health & elected officials to see “spread” and call for more testing.
The test positivity rate does not support her assertions, as it shows that we were primarily testing sick COVID patients in the hospital and not patients in the community, given the lack of widespread testing at the time. Look at the spike in the test positivity rate and compare it to New York’s excess mortality. The positivity rate peaks at 71.2% about two weeks before the peak in excess deaths (a lagging indicator of COVID severity). If COVID-19 had been circulating in the community before, why did it take months to see this spike in excess deaths? It appears to be remarkably related to the spike in test positivity, meaning it was related to COVID infections. You cannot just assume that all of these positive cases were just “incidental” when there was a surge of excess deaths that followed.
It is also important to note that there was no ICD-10 for COVID-19 infection at the beginning of the pandemic. This did not become available until April 2020. Basing an analysis on an ICD-10 code unavailable during a portion of the period under study is fatally flawed.
The CDC gave us interim guidance for documenting other ICD-10 codes to use in February 2020, including pneumonia (J12.89, B97.29), acute bronchitis (J20.8, B97.29, J40), lower respiratory infection (J22, B97.29, J98.8), acute respiratory distress syndrome or ARDS (J80, B97.29), and exposure to COVID-19 (Z03.818, Z20.828). Coding was also provided for some symptoms if a definitive diagnosis was not made, such as cough (R05), shortness of breath (R06.02), and fever unspecified (R50.9). Therefore, you can see that relying on data analysis using only the COVID-19 ICD-10 code U07.1 missed large numbers of patients presenting to the ED or admitted with COVID-19. This is the problem with relying on ICD-10 codes for data analysis without understanding the full history of the situation and how it evolved.
Data presented in The New York Times is consistent with this fact, demonstrating an unseasonable increase in deaths from pneumonia and respiratory illnesses above what would normally be expected during the spring of 2020 (900 excess deaths from respiratory diseases in New York alone). For the reasons outlined above, these were likely COVID-19 deaths that were not categorized as such, given the lack of both sufficient testing capacity and a COVID-specific ICD-10 code. Just ask yourself: did people suddenly start dying in larger numbers from respiratory illnesses out of the blue, or was this increase in deaths because of a novel respiratory virus (SARS-CoV-2) circulating in the community?
The CDC data shows that hospitalizations from the 2019-2020 influenza season had significantly decreased by mid-March 2020, which would not explain the spike in deaths from respiratory diseases. Widespread influenza testing was available, so influenza patients would not have been reclassified as COVID-19 patients.
Claim three: NYC emergency department spike in respiratory presentations may have been “panic-driven”
Hockett claims:
Respiratory visits for the 2019-2020 peaked in January, and were on the way down. New York Governor Cuomo issued a lockdown directive on March 10, 2020, and calls to Emergency Medical Services soared, as did the number of people going to emergency rooms with respiratory symptoms.
Her image accurately demonstrates a spike in emergency department visits with respiratory symptoms. The peak she referred to in January and February corresponds to the peak in the CDC influenza hospitalization data presented above and was much lower than the March 2020 spike. Visits for respiratory illnesses increased again in March because COVID-19 cases increased, caused by the new respiratory virus that hit the city. She suggests that people were contacting Emergency Medical Services (EMS) out of panic. This does not make sense in light of the excess deaths from respiratory diseases presented above. There have also been studies looking at the increase in home cardiac arrests during the spring of 2020 in NYC, which demonstrated a three-fold increase in at-home cardiac arrests when comparing March/April 2020 to the same period in 2019.
What was the difference between spring 2019 and 2020? Did people become more ill over that year, increasing their risk of at home cardiac arrest? Or was there a novel respiratory virus causing severe illness? I am unaware of any type of panic that could lead to a three-fold increase in at home cardiac arrests. However, respiratory failure from viral pneumonia can cause cardiac arrest. Now, she might claim that people avoided the ED out of fear and were just dying at home from their chronic medical conditions. But which is it? Are people panicking and rushing to the emergency department at the first sign of a cough, or are they staying home and dying because they are afraid to present to the ED? The data from the CDC MMWR also showed that ED visits for cardiac arrests and ventricular arrhythmias increased during the pandemic, which is consistent with patients presenting with a severe illness and not “panic”.
Furthermore, CDC data from New York shows an increase in all-cause excess death starting near the end of March 2020. I am unaware of any physiological change that would result in people with “psychogenic illness” dying in excess numbers. She has also claimed that people may have been admitted “with COVID”, but I am not sure how that would account for the excess deaths. Excess mortality data do not rely on PCR testing or the clinical diagnosis of COVID-19, or other reasons Hockett may give to dismiss the data. It is purely people who died in larger numbers than normal in March and April 2020, which contradicts her claim that “SARS-CoV-2 has been circulating among millions of people for many months”. If it was circulating for many months, where did the excess deaths come from?
Hockett goes on to claim:
But most emergency room visitors with respiratory symptoms were not diagnosed with COVID. Huh. To me, it appears the dramatic rise and fall was triggered by fear rather than “spread.”
Again, this shows a lack of understanding of all the above points. Patients with respiratory symptoms had COVID-19, but due to the lack of testing and appropriate diagnostic codes, they were not labeled as such. If she audited the medical records of these patients (and not just billing codes), she would see that they had respiratory symptoms and x-rays consistent with COVID-19. Below is a typical chest x-ray of a patient with COVID-19 pneumonia. I do not think you need a doctor to confirm that this person was not just presenting to the ED with “panic”.We also had to devise strategies to split ventilators between two patients because of shortages. This would only happen in a crisis. We would not need to ration ventilators if the hospitals were just full of the “worried well”.
Claim four: Most people presenting to the emergency room were not admitted to the hospital
Hockett claims:
Peak hospital admissions for COVID-like illness (CLI) were 40% of respiratory emergency department visits – another data point that hints at folks rushing to the ER at the first sign of a cough.
She is falsely assuming that because the majority of respiratory viral-like illnesses were not admitted to the hospital that the hospitals were not overwhelmed, and the patients only had minor concerns. This assumption is incorrect. Relying on diagnostic codes for COVID-19 and COVID-like illness (CLI) does not capture the full scope because (as noted above) many were given diagnostic codes for bronchitis, pneumonia, lower respiratory tract infection, and ARDS. COVID-like illness was defined as fever and either cough or shortness of breath. However, many people with late COVID-19 disease do not have a fever. This JAMA study found that only 30.7% of a cohort of patients were febrile at presentation to a hospital in New York in March-April 2020. The other 69.3% of patients hospitalized with COVID-19 would not have met the definition of “COVID-like illness”. Thus, her chart below is a gross underestimate of patients admitted with COVID-19, as many did not fit the definition of CLI.
One must take into account many factors when deciding whom to admit to the hospital, including overall bed capacity, occupancy, staffing, and available resources. The patients admitted to the hospital were critically ill, required a tremendous amount of care, and were often hospitalized for several weeks. This creates bed shortages and made admitting new patients from the ED more difficult. You can see that the average length of stay for non-ICU/non-intubated patients (no ventilator) was close to 10 days.Critically ill patients in the ICU had lengths of stay from 3 weeks to over a month. The turnaround time from admission to discharge was not quick. This creates a backlog of patients in the hospital. So even if the patient volumes were lower due to fewer patients coming to the ED, a surge of high-acuity patients when the hospital is at capacity would quickly overwhelm the system. The flow of patients from the ED to the hospital is a complex network and involves multiple steps, personnel, and resources. These nuances cannot be appreciated by looking at numbers on a spreadsheet.
We could not have possibly admitted every single patient with COVID-19 to the hospital; there were not enough resources for that. There was a triage process that reserved hospital admission for the sickest COVID-19 patients. New York Presbyterian developed a program that sent borderline COVID-19 patients home with portable oxygen, an oxygen saturation monitor, and twice-daily telehealth monitoring to divert admitting patients to the hospital.
There was an increase in patients dying in the emergency department as well, which would have also contributed to lower numbers of admissions, as per this CDC data:
Despite all these measures and decreased total emergency department patients, the admissions rate increased. It was found that despite emergency presentations decreasing by 63.5% in New York hospitals, the admission rate increased by 149%.
Hockett had this to say about the JAMA paper:
Mount Sinai’s rise in admissions from the ED was short-lived. The rate increase is more dramatic than the raw-number increase due to the ED visit drop. Without historical data, I can’t say whether the 266 admits from the ED on March 30 was unprecedented, or what admission criteria/protocols were being followed.
266 admissions in a day, up from 150 to 200 in the weeks prior, is an incredible increase if you understand how hospital admissions work. These are not just random numbers. They represent critically ill patients who require an incredible amount of care. I cannot stress enough that the length of stay of these patients could exceed three weeks. This puts a huge strain on resources, which is why our hospitals had rapidly expanded our capacity, especially in the ICU. Again, you do not need to be an expert to understand this simple equation: if the number of patients admitted exceeds the number of patients discharged and you have a fixed number of beds, then your system quickly becomes overwhelmed.
She said, “I can’t say whether the 266 admits from the ED was unprecedented or what admission criteria/protocols were being followed”. This could have been easily answered if she had spoken with a physician who worked at one of these hospitals during the pandemic. I have already offered to have this discussion with her but my requests have been rebuffed.
It is important to note that hospitals are not homogenous. They are made up of many different departments, including medicine, obstetrics and gynecology, and surgery, to name a few. COVID-19 is a medical disease, so the medical department had to expand its capacity while the others shrank. The entire inpatient structure had to be changed. Why would we need to increase staff on our units, expand bed capacity, convert rooms to negative pressure, and turn operating rooms/coronary angiography labs and post-anesthesia care units into ICUs (all of which cost a ton of money at a time when revenue was low) if we did not see a surge in hospital admissions? We wouldn’t have created the extra capacity just because we wanted more room for activities.
This article outlines the restructuring at New York University Hospitals to accommodate the surge of COVID-19 admissions. Table 4 demonstrates that the medicine/ICU capacity at NYU Tisch increased by a whopping 62% from its pre-COVID baseline.The primary source of those admissions was the emergency department. ICU-staffed teams increased by 90%, medical-staffed teams by 55%, and ICU nurses by 91%. I again ask Hockett, why did we have to do this if hospitals were not overwhelmed in the spring of 2020? Why did we need to expand general medicine and ICU team capacity? Why did the peak census more than double? Did we do this to accommodate panicked patients who were not really sick? Did we have to do all this to accommodate mass amounts of incidental COVID patients? Or was there a genuine need to do this because a novel respiratory virus devastated our city? You can also review the restructuring that took place at Cornell and Columbia.
In her most recent post “NYC’s Hospital System Never Reached Full Capacity in Spring 2020” Hockett states:
Systemwide, New York City hospitals did not reach full capacity in spring 2020. The city’s staffed acute care and ICU beds were 85% and 90% occupied, respectively, at their late March/early April peaks.
This is yet another example of Hockett not understanding the complexities of hospital capacity in the middle of a global pandemic. Her analysis amounts to bed capacity = X and occupied beds = Y, X > Y, so hospitals were not overwhelmed. As I mentioned earlier, hospitals can become overwhelmed for various reasons.
One thing Hockett forgot to consider in her analysis is that the NYC hospital system is not a monolith. She is assuming that every single hospital in NYC was impacted the exact same way by COVID, so therefore not exceeding the city-wide bed capacity meant that the system was not overwhelmed; but this was not the case. For instance, there are several specialty hospitals in NYC (Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Hospital and The Hospital for Special Surgery) that did not see the same influx of COVID patients the other hospitals did. There are many reasons for this, one of which is that many of these hospitals are not associated with emergency departments (most COVID admits were through the ED). The bed capacity for these less-impacted hospitals is also included in Hockett’s dataset. So she used city-wide data on hospital bed capacity but did not realize that the dataset is very heterogeneous and does not accurately reflect the impact COVID had on many hospitals that accepted COVID patients primarily. This could have been avoided if she had analyzed bed and ICU capacity data from individual medical centers throughout the city.
I have added the orange line to her ICU bed capacity figure. You can see that the original ICU capacity of the city was greatly exceeded. The occupied beds above this orange line represent the expanded capacity to accommodate the surge. If these beds had not been expanded, the city-wide ICU capacity clearly would have been exceeded. She’s essentially saying that we weren’t overwhelmed because we didn’t exceed the worst case scenario disaster plan. But hopefully you can see that we had to greatly expand ICU capacity in the city to accommodate the surge in critically ill patients.
What Hockett fails to include in her analysis is that these are not just random numbers on a spreadsheet. They represent critically ill human beings who required a tremendous amount of care. ICU-level COVID patients were often intubated and mechanically ventilated (hooked up to a breathing machine); they were on several continuous drips of medications which required constant monitoring and titration. These medications were essential to keep the patients sedated and paralyzed while on the ventilator, maintain their blood pressure at an appropriate range, and help their hearts pump blood. COVID had many extra-pulmonary manifestations, which resulted in conditions such as renal failure requiring continuous venovenous hemodialysis (a machine hooked up to a large catheter inserted into the neck that filters the blood when the kidneys no longer work). Intubated patients often needed to be placed in a prone position several times a day. This is when we literally flipped patients from their backs onto their abdomens to help with ventilation. This required a whole team of trained professionals to do it successfully. Other patients were placed on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) machines, which also require highly trained teams to manage. I hope you can appreciate just how complex this situation was.
In her follow-up post, Hockett tries to refute my claim that EDs were filling up with critically ill, ICU-level COVID patients:
There is no data corroborating claims about ICU-level patients being intubated and vented in the EDs. How staff felt in NYC EDs, and why, was not the subject of my November 3 post.
She could have avoided this if she had taken the time to ask someone who worked in the ED during this time. Because ICU beds were full of critically ill patients (many of whom had greater than a 3-week length of stay), the ED began to fill up with ICU-level patients. There was nowhere to admit these patients, so they needed to board in the ED until a bed became available. This highlights the fact that EDs can become overwhelmed for a variety of reasons (one of which being highly complex acutely ill patients boarding in the ED due to lack of hospital capacity).
This study discusses a Philadelphia hospital’s strategy to open an ED-ICU to care for ICU-level patients boarding in the ED. I can tell you that most NYC hospitals had similar ED-ICU setups (you can read about them in the articles outlining the COVID surge protocols at NYU, Columbia, and Cornell above). The data presented shows that 55% of patients in the ED-ICU were intubated and required mechanical ventilation.
Claim five: Many patients counted as COVID hospitalizations in the spring of 2020 were not admitted with COVID-like illness
Hockett states:
Data indicate that approximately 40% of inpatients with a COVID diagnosis (via test, symptoms, or both) from mid-March through April 2020 had not been admitted with COVID-like illness.
She claims that because there was a discrepancy between patients admitted with a COVID diagnosis and COVID-like illnesses, most patients were not admitted with COVID-19. As previously demonstrated, fever, a requirement for CLI, was not universal in COVID-19 patients. She claims these admissions were not COVID-19 because they did not get classified as CLI. I would ask her why she thinks they were admitted (as I’ve already demonstrated, the hospital wards were full, so why would we needlessly admit patients).
NYC hospitals began running out of supplies, including inhaled medications, kits to place central lines in veins, and portable oxygen tanks. Why on earth would we be running out of basic supplies if our hospitals were not full of very sick patients who were admitted through the ED? Incidental COVID patients don’t consume massive amounts of oxygen.
This assumption again relies upon billing codes, which are insufficient when used in isolation, absent of the clinical context of the situation. She could have avoided spreading all of this disinformation by just asking someone who does this for a living.
Under normal circumstances, if a patient came in with a COVID-like illness (fever, cough, shortness of breath, pneumonia) and tested positive for COVID after the note was written, a window for billing would pop up. You would code for COVID and then list the subsequent ICD-10 codes for their other symptoms only if those symptoms didn’t represent a manifestation of the disease itself.
The American Hospital Association provided guidelines on billing during the pandemic:
People infected with COVID-19 may vary from being asymptomatic to having a range of symptoms and severity. Therefore, for coding purposes, signs and symptoms associated with COVID-19 may be coded separately, unless the signs and symptoms are routinely associated with a manifestation. For example, cough would not be coded separately if the patient had pneumonia due to COVID-19, as cough is a symptom of pneumonia
We did not have to code for the three cardinal symptoms of COVID-like illness (cough, fever, shortness of breath) if those symptoms were due to COVID-19. Therefore, the label of “COVID-like illness” would not be applied to these COVID-19 patients.
It is also worth mentioning that billing and coding take time, time that we did not have, as our wards were filling up with sick and dying patients. Ensuring we accurately documented every single symptom for billing purposes took a back seat to ensure our patients stayed alive. Because of this, the NY governor set forth a list of liability waivers to protect healthcare workers during the worst of the surge and one of these waivers provided immunity from record-keeping liability. As a result, we did not have to be as meticulous with our billing and coding. We were not hounded by billing compliance officers during the worst of the surge (mostly because they were nurses and redeployed to the COVID units).
Providing further evidence, as the caseload improved in NYC, the COVID diagnoses matched the CLI diagnoses as the healthcare system became less overburdened and time was available for proper coding/billing.
She then goes on to explain why she thinks the “gap” between COVID-19 and CLI diagnoses occurred:
While the gap between the two sets of numbers could point to nosocomial or attendant-borne spread, it could also simply be the result of incidental positives.
This is complete conjecture on her part. I will refer again to the need to create new ICU space, expand capacity, track and ration ventilator use, and split ventilators. We would not need to do this if people presented with “incidental COVID”. We sent COVID patients home with portable oxygen; we certainly would not be admitting incidental COVID cases just for funsies.
Claim six: The relationship between hospital inpatient deaths with COVID on the death certificate and people who were hospitalized because they had COVID is unclear
Hockett claims:
The gap between CLI admissions and COVID hospitalizations (shown below) started seven days after the stay-[at]-home order. In the weeks that followed, it appears more people were being coded daily as COVID hospitalizations than were being admitted to the hospital with CLI. From March 18th through May 30th, there were ~16,200 more COVID positive hospitalizations than CLI admissions.
In addition to my explanation above for the “gap” between COVID diagnoses and CLI, this statement contradicts her argument that “hospitals were not overwhelmed with patients”. Why were there 15,000 inpatient deaths in NYC if the hospitals were not full of sick and dying patients? Why were there so many deaths if the hospital was just full of “worried well” or asymptomatic incidental COVID patients? Excess death data from New York shows there were almost 21,000 excess deaths in the spring of 2020, for which she has no alternate explanation if COVID-19 was not the cause.
She goes on to say:
Over 15,000 NYC hospital inpatient deaths in these weeks have COVID on the death certificate, per CDC WONDER. Without [a] detailed record review, there’s no way of knowing how many of the 15K had COVID symptoms when they were admitted
This is consistent with COVID-denialism arguments that patients died “with COVID” instead of it. However, some poor employees at the CDC went through 375,000 death certificates of COVID-19 patients because of these claims. They found that 97% had “a plausible chain-of-event condition (e.g., pneumonia or respiratory failure)” indicating these patients indeed died of symptomatic COVID-19.
Again, she’s making assumptions. If she looked at actual medical records and death certificates, she would see that the patients dying from COVID were actually dying from COVID.
She could also have asked any doctor who had to fill out COVID death certificates during this surge for some collateral information.
She continues her attempt at gaslighting NYC frontline workers with this quote:
It’s no wonder Michael Senger, Ethical Skeptic, and other analysts (including me) have said it was misuse of ventilators, protocol-induced staffing shortages, isolation, failure to treat, similar factors that resulted in thousands of Spring 2020 iatrogenic deaths in New York City and elsewhere.
She blames this surge in deaths not on the disease itself but on the doctors inappropriately treating patients with bad protocols (which was not true). I want to remind the reader that Hockett did not provide care for COVID patients in NYC at the height of the surge and never has. Any critique of the management of these patients on her part is not based on the clinical reality of practicing crisis-level care during a global pandemic.
Ventilators were a scarce resource during the pandemic, and they were reserved for the sickest COVID patients. We do not intubate healthy patients. Intubation is a measure of last resort. There are other, less invasive methods of ventilation that were trialed first: high-flow nasal cannula (HFNC) and BiPAP. There were also legitimate concerns about aerosolization from HFNC/BiPAP combined with concerns about PPE shortages and limited negative pressure rooms at the beginning of the pandemic which limited their use initially.
But this is where being a clinician who actually treated these patients comes in handy.
If you follow me on Tik Tok (Dr.Eric.B), you know that anyone who wants to play armchair doctor gets the medical question of the day! So, I would ask Hockett (or any skeptic) what she would do in the following situation (this is a very common patient that we saw in the spring of 2020):
A 65-year-old woman with a past medical history of hypertension, non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, and dyslipidemia presented to the ED in the setting of fever and cough for four days. She tested positive for COVID.
The patient’s vitals on presentation were a heart rate of 110 bpm, a blood pressure of 150/62 mmHg, a respiratory rate of 22 breaths/min, and oxygen saturation (SpO2) of 94% on 6 liters by nasal cannula.
She is admitted to the medicine floor. Over the next day, her oxygen requirement increased, and she was placed on 15 liter non-rebreather mask with a SpO2 of 92%. She is using accessory muscles to breathe. She is somnolent and barely rousable to noxious stimuli. Arterial blood gas (ABG) is 7.30/58/60. She is escalated to BiPAP 15/5 mmHg with 100% FiO2. Chest x-ray (CXR) demonstrates worsening bilateral infiltrates consistent with ARDS. Despite max BiPAP settings, the patient’s SpO2 is 84%, RR 40, HR 135, ABG 7.15/85/50.
Would you intubate this patient? If not, what would be your plan? I’m not doing this to be cheeky or to flex my medical knowledge, but I am doing it to show you just how complex the management decisions were. It’s easy to play Monday morning quarterback when you weren’t the one having to make these life and death decisions in real time.
Let’s not pretend like we intubated every patient who presented to the ED with a cough just because. We reserved intubation for the sickest patients. And if you needed intubation with COVID-19, the likelihood of survival was low because your disease state was far too advanced. This was also at the pandemic’s beginning when we had little-to-no therapies to treat COVID. These management decisions were incredibly complex and made in real time with very little information at our disposal. It’s frustrating that non-clinicians feel emboldened to chime in with their opinions on how these patients should have been treated. .
Hockett ends her most recent post with the pièce de résistance of gaslighting:
I understand that New York City doctors and nurses may find these data challenging to integrate with their ‘lived experiences’ in spring 2020, or may believe that only people who were working in the city’s hospitals at the time – or medical doctors/researchers – should be able to speak to these data.
You don’t have to be a NYC doctor to speak to these data. However, experience, an understanding of the nuances of the emerging situation at the time, and expertise matter, no matter what Hockett would have you believe. This is the same for any profession. I would never presume to critique a pilot’s ability to fly a plane when I have no expertise in that field. We have to stop pretending that everyone’s opinions on this subject are equal. They’re not. The data analysis of a Ph.D. reviewing numbers on an Excel spreadsheet from her living room is not the same as the data analysis of a medical doctor who actually lived through the NYC surge. This isn’t credentialism, it’s the facts.
At the end of the day, her articles amount to a sad attempt at gaslighting, historical revisionism, and disinformation thinly veiled under the guise of “legitimate” data analysis. She sat in the comfort and safety of her living room, hundreds of miles away from New York City, analyzing data she didn’t understand because she lacked the appropriate clinical context. It’s very easy for her to do this when she never once stepped foot inside one of our hospitals, never once had to worry if she had enough PPE to make it through the day, never once had to walk past refrigerated morgue trucks parked in front of the hospital, never once had to make life and death decisions with little information. I have offered Hockett and many of her supporters the opportunity to discuss this live. However, my requests have been flatly rejected. I truly believe that a face-to-face conversation with someone who lived through the surge of 2020 would force her out of her comfort zone and force her to realize that the reality of the situation was in stark contrast to her data analysis. Most importantly, it would force her to realize that she is wrong.
As I said in the beginning, I don’t owe Hockett an explanation or justification. I know what I lived through, what my colleagues lived through. No amount of Hockett’s data analysis can change that. You can call this an appeal to emotion, and I don’t care. You can call this an appeal to authority. I don’t care. I have provided evidence and an explanation of the data, which demonstrate that our hospitals were indeed overwhelmed in the spring of 2020. The proof of this is incontrovertible. I don’t expect this to change her or the rest of her colleagues at the Brownstone Institute’s minds. They are intransigent, and convincing them to face reality and admit they don’t know what they’re talking about would be a Sisyphean effort. Despite this, my offer to have this discussion with Hockett live still stands, I truly believe she could benefit from this conversation.
I’m sorry if my tone came across as a bit pointed at times. I would like you to imagine how awful it would feel to be told that what you experienced never happened. That all the suffering, pain, and horrors from the spring of 2020 were somehow a figment of your imagination. That all the peer-reviewed papers, first-hand accounts, news articles, and morgue trucks full of dead COVID victims were an elaborate lie. That one person who never stepped foot inside a NYC hospital has the audacity to call all NYC healthcare workers liars (and let’s be clear, that’s exactly what Hockett is doing). I won’t sit idly by as she and others try to rewrite history and try to minimize the impact COVID had on my hospital, on my city, and my life. I challenge more healthcare workers from NYC and worldwide to take up the mantle and battle this blatant disinformation. Go out there and share your stories. They are worth telling and worth listening to. Don’t let people like Jessica Hockett diminish the power of your voice.

Will Natural Herd Immunity End the Pandemic?
Is natural herd immunity a viable path to controlling the pandemic? Here is why that is a terrible idea.
Steven Novella on October 14, 2020
Link

As we approach the anniversary of the worst pandemic in a century “pandemic fatigue” is becoming a serious problem. This is more than just being tired of dealing with the changes to daily routine, there can be serious economic and even health consequences to the steps taken to stem the pandemic. Treatments are coming online, and our management of COVID-19 illness is slowly improving over time. But the daily new cases worldwide is still increasing, and deaths remain high and steady.
The reasonable question on everyone’s mind is – when will this end? Also, how do we make it end more quickly? Aggressive measures to “flatten the curve” have largely worked, but in many areas they mostly delayed infections. Successful countries have managed to return to some semblance of normal, but nowhere is the pandemic gone.
So what will it take to end this pandemic? Perhaps it won’t end, and the SARS-CoV-2 virus will become endemic in the human population, like the flu. It will simply wax and wane and circulate around the world. An effective vaccine with high uptake is clearly the best option. Through vaccination we can achieve herd immunity and shut down circulation of the virus. This will probably not eradicate it, but can keep the spread limited to levels that would not be disruptive. This, I think, is the most likely option – but we are still waiting for a vaccine to be proven safe and effective, get approval, and then be widely distributed. Optimistically this can happen by the end of 2021, but I stress that is optimistic.
What about natural herd immunity? This strategy is essentially to let the virus circulate, and after enough people have caught the virus and survived there will be enough resistance to reduce spread and the pandemic will end. This option is occasionally floated by politicians, and even some fringe scientists, but has been repeatedly criticized by the majority of experts.
Recently the World Health Organization stated that the goal of achieving natural herd immunity is both unscientific and unethical. They made this statement partly in response to President Trump and others stating that we may achieve natural herd immunity. How plausible in natural herd immunity and what would it entail?
The short answer is – we don’t know, but it isn’t looking good. We simply do not know enough yet about this novel virus. Pertinent questions include: how effective is the immunity that results from infection and (this is critical) how long does it last? How much of an infection is necessary to trigger immunity? Will asymptomatic cases be immune? And what level of immunity in the population is necessary to achieve herd immunity, given this varies for different viruses depending on how contagious and infectious it is?
We don’t really know the answer to any of these questions, but the early clues are not encouraging. Coronaviruses in general tend not to provoke lasting immunity (years), and SARS-CoV-2 may be no different. One recent study published in The Lancet, for example, found that, if you standardize to the general US population, about 9.3% of people have antibodies to SARS-CoV-2. There were regional differences that follow the density of COVID cases, with the highest regional percentage being about 25% in the Northeast (and about 35% in NY state). This number is about 10 times the number of confirmed COVID cases, so many people are being exposed to the virus without ever being diagnosed (whether or not they develop symptoms).
This number is low compared to what is needed for herd immunity, which varies from 50-90% depending on the virus. Even for the low end of the spectrum, we would need five times as many people exposed as we have now. That would probably mean about 1 million Americans dead just to reach the low end of the herd immunity range. That number could easily have to double, as COVID is highly contagious.
But also, we still don’t know how long immunity lasts. We know it lasts at least 3 months, but that is not very long. What if it lasts for a year? That is well within the range of likelihood. That would mean that most people who were previously infected would be losing their immunity long before we achieved natural herd immunity. In this scenario the virus would simply continue spreading around the world.
There are now numerous cases, although still somewhat rare, of people getting COVID for the second time (after just months). How many cases will there be of reinfection after a year or two years?
We also don’t know what the long-term effects of this illness are, and there are some early indications that people who survive a severe infection with COVID-19 may have long-term symptoms. We won’t know for years what the full toll of infection is on health, and so it is a very dangerous gamble to let people get sick just to achieve immunity. This could have profound impacts on our health care system for decades.
It is true that all pandemics eventually burn themselves out, or settle down into the background. But this is not necessarily a good thing. This is what we have with the flu, which claims between 20-60,000 US lives per year, and that is with a vaccine program. We don’t want COVID to become another permanent flu, but that is where we may end up. Keep in mind that HIV is also an ongoing pandemic, lasting decades. We don’t think of it that way because we have accepted that it exists and we deal with it.
In terms of, let’s call them “acute”, pandemics like what we currently have with COVID, it is very likely that no matter what we do eventually disease resistance will increase in the population, the population of highly susceptible people will be reduced, and the pandemic will wane. The question is – what will it take to get there? In 1918 the flu pandemic killed at least 50 million people worldwide – that is 50 times the current death toll for COVID. I don’t think anyone wants to see that before achieving some level of herd immunity.
What the WHO is essentially saying is that in getting to the end of this pandemic, or at least to an acceptable background level, the worst possible path to take is through natural herd immunity. That is the path of maximum disease and death, with many perilous unknowns. The best path right now is to continue to flatten the curve with proven methods, such as mask wearing, social distancing, good hygiene, and avoiding mass gatherings, especially inside. We also need testing and contact tracing to reduce spread. We need to keep doing all this until we have an effective vaccine and can distribute it. That is the path to herd immunity, we just need the patience to get there.

Super Immunity vs Anti-Vaxxers
Anti-vaxxers continue to spread demonstrable misinformation, while the evidence for the benefits of COVID vaccines grows.
Steven Novella on January 26, 2022
Link

In a recent march on DC antivaxxers were angry and spewing forth a firehose of misinformation. Among them were Robert F. Kennedy Jr, number 2 on the misinformation dozen list. Kennedy was a one-time environmental activist who descended into the world of anti-vaccine misinformation, in what appears to be a combination of confirmation bias and motivated reasoning. If you look hard enough for a conspiracy, you can find one. At the rally Kennedy claimed: “if you take the vaccine, you have a 21 percent increased chance of dying over the next six months.”
I could not source this claim with anything published, but Kennedy keeps touting VAERS (the voluntary open reporting system that anti-vaxxers love to troll), an unscientific source of information just made for confirmation bias. By comparison actual CDC data finds:
During October–November, unvaccinated persons had 13.9 and 53.2 times the risks for infection and COVID-19–associated death, respectively, compared with fully vaccinated persons who received booster doses, and 4.0 and 12.7 times the risks compared with fully vaccinated persons without booster doses.
An unvaccinated person was more than 50 times as likely to die from COVID as a fully boosted person during that time period.
While the pandemic has been long and difficult with many twists and turns including new variants just when we thought things were slowing down, it has actually played out pretty much like experts predicted (once we knew what we were dealing with). This is how major pandemics of highly contagious respiratory illnesses roll. They rip through the population, killing the old and sick first but also indiscriminately, then moving on to others and coming back around, spawning new variants as it goes. After a few years it slowly burns itself out, mainly through increasing immunity in the population, until it becomes a relatively mild background or seasonal infection, just another cold or flu.
Our modern world has been both a boon and a bane for the pandemic. Our global economy and massively interconnected populations allow the virus to spread quickly to every corner of the world. However, our modern medical technology gives us unprecedented tools to fight the pandemic, minimize its impact, and perhaps shorten its course. You know where this is headed – the COVID vaccines are the most critical tool for fighting the pandemic.
A recent study adds yet more weight to the body of evidence supporting the use of vaccines as a major strategy to fight the pandemic – “Vaccination before or after SARS-CoV-2 infection leads to robust humoral response and antibodies that effectively neutralize variants” published in Science Immunology. The researchers looked at three groups of people:
    • Those who were vaccinated but never infected
    • Those who were vaccinated after being infected
    • Those who had a breakthrough infection after being vaccinated
The results:
We find that human immune sera following breakthrough infection and vaccination following natural infection, broadly neutralize SARS-CoV-2 variants to a similar degree. While age negatively correlates with antibody response after vaccination alone, no correlation with age was found in breakthrough or hybrid immune groups. Together, our data suggest that the additional antigen exposure from natural infection substantially boosts the quantity, quality, and breadth of humoral immune response regardless of whether it occurs before or after vaccination.
That’s good news. Hybrid immunity is about 10 times that of vaccination or infection alone, and the antibody titers are high enough to combat the Omicron variant. Further, this robust hybrid response was not diminished with age, which might turn out to be critical for protecting the older and more vulnerable population.
Remember, however, the goal is to not get COVID. This is still a deadly virus, with potentially severe long-COVID symptoms. The ideal is to get vaccinated, be responsible in terms of exposure and pandemic protocol, and simply never get COVID. The second best scenario, however, is to get vaccinated and if you do get COVID the chances are high that the infection will be mild, and leave you with super hybrid immunity for extra protection against reinfection or new variants. Further, if you have been infected already, all the more reason to get vaccinated as another path toward hybrid immunity. Many people use past infection as an excuse not to get vaccinated, but the reality is the opposite.
Slowly we will more toward a more and more resistant population, and that will beat back the pandemic into just another endemic respiratory illness that we live with, but not something that disrupts society. And again, I want to emphasize, we want to get there mainly through vaccination, not through the spread of the virus. Vaccination also slows the emergence of new variants, while spreading infections increases that risk.
In addition, the CEO of Pfizer announced that they have an Omicron version of their vaccine ready for release in March. That is how we can stay ahead of the pandemic, by adjusting the available vaccines to optimally cover new variants as they emerge. Anti-vaxxers make a big deal about the fact that we need booster shots to maintain immunity, but this is misguided. We need an annual flu vaccine, which is also adjusted every year to track the variants that are spreading. The same will likely be true with SARS-CoV-2, we may need an annual vaccine which will be updated to track new variants. This is just part of modern life, and is far better than the alternative.
The reality is that COVID-19 is a severe pandemic, historically a once-a-century pandemic, although such pandemics may become more common given the human population and interconnectivity combined with our propinquity to wild animal populations increasing the risks of zoonotic cross-over infections. But also, vaccines work. They are safe and provide effective resistance to the virus, significantly reducing the severity of illness, taking it from something that may put you in the hospital and even result in death to just a bad cold.
As the anti-vaxxer rally in DC shows, that community is not based in reality. The rally was angry and seething with every sort of conspiracy theory. They do not have facts or even basic common sense on their side. Their anger is about something else entirely, but the spillover effect is that they are hampering our efforts to get the pandemic under control while minimizing the damage.

“Natural immunity” versus the vaccine for COVID-19
Antivaxxers have long appealed to “natural immunity” as being somehow inherently superior to vaccine-induced immunity, which is apparently “artificial”. This is a trope that comes from alternative medicine concepts about purity and contamination that is now endangering us in the age of the pandemic.
David Gorski on October 4, 2021
Link

Ever since COVID-19 hit, I’ve been repeating the mantra, “Everything old is new again”. The reason is simple. Key to understanding a lot of the misinformation about COVID-19, its spread, and COVID-19 vaccines is an understanding that none of this misinformation is new. Rather, it’s the same misinformation that we at SBM have long been dealing with, just applied to the pandemic. Examples abound, including the minimization of the severity of COVID-19 that so much resembles how antivaxxers minimized the severity of the measles, misuse of the VAERS database to attribute harms to the COVID-19 vaccine that are very likely coincidental, false claims that COVID-19 vaccines cause infertility, and the appeal to “natural immunity” to the coronavirus and “natural herd immunity” as being inherently superior to vaccine-induced immunity or herd immunity from mass vaccination, which are denigrated as being somehow less than natural, artificial even—or even outright harmful. Never mind that achieving “natural herd immunity” requires that huge numbers of people be sickened and die of the disease, just as individual immunity from the disease requires the individual to be sickened and face the risk of severe disease and death.
Indeed, there is an eerie parallel between claims by Geert Vanden Bossche and Peter McCollough that COVID-19 mass vaccination is not just less effective but will lead to a “holocaust” and “depopulation” due to the emergence of ever more virulent COVID-19 “escape mutants” and the speculation by Andrew Wakefield pre-pandemic that the MMR vaccine will lead to a mass extinction due to the emergence of ever more virulent measles escape mutants.
Which brings me back to “natural immunity” and “purity.” Both are concepts embedded in alternative medicine, and an op-ed by Alan Levinovitz, an associate professor of religious studies at James Madison University and author of Natural: How Faith in Nature’s Goodness Leads to Harmful Fads, Unjust Laws, and Flawed Science, got me to thinking about them again in relation to COVID-19:
What began as a viral TikTok hashtag has infected every social media platform: Many of the proudly unvaccinated now identify themselves as #Pureblood.
Troubled observers have variously tied this term to the Harry Potter franchise (in which purebloods are Wizards untainted by muggle ancestry) and the eugenic Nazi fantasies of pure Aryan blood. But both comparisons miss the mark. The meaning of the hashtag is inseparable from vaccine refusers’ strong preference for “natural immunity,” a seemingly innocuous term that is actually a centerpiece of anti-vaccination ideology and ought to be abandoned immediately.
Although scientific authorities widely use “natural immunity” as a neutral description of immunity acquired through infection, it has different significance outside of medical journals. That’s because people often treat naturalness as synonymous with purity and goodness, even holiness. “God gave us a natural immunity,” said an announcer recently on Victory TV, a popular Christian network. “I personally choose God-given natural immunity over the new experimental vaccine for the safety and protection of myself and my family,” writes a chiropractor at Infinite Wellness Natural Healing Center. “How about you?”
I take a moment to observe right here that using the term “natural immunity”, as neutral as it sounds from a scientific perspective, was a huge mistake on the part of scientists for the reasons that Levinovitz describes above. Like the word “theory,” which in science implies a very high degree of certainty behind a proposition (e.g., theories of evolution and relativity) but in colloquial terms tends to connote any old wild guess, the term “natural” has very different connotations in the way most people who are not scientists use it.
Of course, vaccine-induced immunity is every bit as “natural” as immunity acquired after recovering from COVID-19, with the advantage that vaccine-induced immunity doesn’t require you to suffer through the disease and be at risk for the complications, long term disability, and death that it can cause. Otherwise, it uses the same “natural” processes that the wild-type virus does. As much as it perturbs me that this has to be explained again and again, boiling the concept of vaccination down to its essence, all a vaccine does is prime the immune system with a dead pathogen, a protein (or part of a protein from it), or a related but harmless pathogen so that the body can respond so much more quickly when the actual pathogen is actually encountered “in the wild”. The end result is to prevent you from becoming sick due to that pathogen. The best vaccines, of course, do more than that and prevent you from being infected at all (a phenomenon known as sterilizing immunity), but a good vaccine doesn’t have to induce sterilizing immunity or to be 100% effective at preventing transmission to accomplish a lot of very good things, again, not the least of which is preventing severe disease.
There is, of course, a scientific debate going on right now about post-infection immunity versus vaccine-induced immunity in terms of strength and duration of immunity, but that’s not what the invocation of “natural immunity” by COVID-19 contrarians and antivaxxers is about. What they are about is to deny the efficacy of vaccines and assert the supposed superiority of “natural” post-infection immunity, frequently in the context of minimizing or denying the likelihood of severe disease and death due to the coronavirus. The answers are coming in, seemingly slowly, but remember that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, only first reared its ugly head in China less than two years ago. That’s not a very long time at all to answer these questions. So it is not surprising that, thus far, the scientific literature is not entirely settled, which leads to people who want to believe that “natural immunity” is superior to be able to cherry pick articles to support their viewpoint. Oddly enough, Friday Daniel Lawrence Whitney, a.k.a. Larry the Cable Guy, did just that:
The crazy thing here is the comments. They hammer Paul but completely ignore his actual factual information about natural immunity. Regardless of what they think of him his info is correct. It’s not hard to find the studies.. How can they be that clueless.
— Larry The Cable Guy (@GitRDoneLarry) October 1, 2021
I’m on the side of truth and he was right. Studies everywhere say the same thing. The Israel study is comprehensive. It’s disingenuous to poo poo it because you don’t like the messenger. The other guy if we’re being critical had 0 medical degrees or science. I mean seriously.
— Larry The Cable Guy (@GitRDoneLarry) October 1, 2021
That’s nice that you acknowledge that the science may not be settled. So, why does the federal government continue to infringe on basic civil liberties as though the science IS settled on certain conclusions?
— Leslie ن 🇺🇸☦️ (@LADowd) October 1, 2021
“Not settled,” however, does not mean that there is no scientific consensus or that it’s not strengthening.
Also:
"new cases of re-infection suggest that immunity may only be transient and incomplete and new emerging viral variants clearly have begun to escape natural immunity"https://t.co/TOjviNwml2
— packergirl (@p9cker_girl) October 2, 2021
In any event, as summarized here (although I really do wish that the doctors who had written this had used the term “post-infection immunity” rather than “natural immunity”), there are a number of issues with post-infection immunity that make vaccination, even after recovery from COVID-19, desirable, including that:
    • More than a third of COVID-19 infections result in zero protective antibodies
    • “Natural immunity” fades faster than vaccine immunity, particularly after mild infection
    • “Natural immunity alone” is only half as effective as natural immunity plus vaccination
As for that Israeli study, which has been widely cited for its conclusion that those vaccinated with the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine were 13-fold more likely to suffer COVID-19 infection from the Delta variant than those who have recovered from the disease, it has…problems. First, it’s on a preprint server and hasn’t been peer-reviewed yet, which should tell you that you should take it with even more of a grain of salt than you take any study. Second, one thing I noticed right off the bat is how its tables and charts only report odds ratios (that “13-fold” number). You have to dig into the text to see that the absolute numbers of infections were quite low (for example, only 19 reinfections in one group) and actually do the math yourself to figure out that the breakthrough infection rates after vaccination were low. For instance, in model #1, the breakthrough infection rate was 238/16,215, or 1.5%; in model #2, it was 640/46,035, or 1.4%. I found that omission very curious, as well as the framing that didn’t mention that this study actually showed that the Pfizer vaccine was quite effective. It also showed that those who had recovered from COVID-19 and were later vaccinated were much less likely to be diagnosed with COVID-19. In addition, as described in this presentation, this study appears to have suffered from significant selection bias based on how different the populations being studied were. It also suffered from survivorship bias.
The bottom line: Contrary to the narrative being pushed, for COVID-19 “natural immunity” is not superior to vaccine-induced immunity, which is less variable and more reliable. Even if it were, yet again, I must emphasize that vaccine-induced immunity has a key advantage over post-infection immunity. It doesn’t require you to suffer through the illness and face the risks of severe disease and death from the disease to acquire it.

“Purity of essence”
Regular readers know that, from time to time, I like to invoke one of my favorite movies of all time, Dr. Stranglove, Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb. Old fart that I am, I sometimes find myself explaining (with difficulty) to younger people with no memory of life during the Cold War what it was like to live during the Cold War and how we were really afraid that any day nuclear bombs might rain down on our cities. Even though some of that paranoia ramped up again in the 1980s, it was nothing like the level during the 1950s and early 1960s, when the movie was made.
For purposes of this blog, though, one character resonates: General Jack D. Ripper, the unhinged “purity”-obsessed commander of a bomber group who at the beginning of the movie launches an unauthorized bomber first strike against the Soviet Union that the leaders of the U.S. frantically spend the rest of the movie trying to stop before the planes reach their targets and the bombs start falling. (Ramping up the consequences even beyond that of a nuclear war, there was also a revelation about a Soviet “doomsday” weapon that would be exploded if even a single enemy nuclear bomb were to explode on Soviet territory and render the surface of the earth uninhabitable for decades.) Indeed, that’s likely why we’ve mentioned this character several times over the years. In fact, re-watching the movie in the age of COVID-19 and QAnon, I’m struck with how much Gen. Ripper would fit into today’s zeitgeist, with his fanatical emphasis on “purity of essence” and his antifluoridation views. (Although the movie does not mention vaccines, I have no doubt that Gen. Ripper was also antivaccine. It’s all of a piece.) In fact, the reason Gen. Ripper launches his bombers to carry out a first strike was so as not to allow, as he put it, “Communist infiltration, Communist indoctrination, Communist subversion, and the international Communist conspiracy to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids” (around 1:10):
(I always wondered at how Gen. Ripper could smoke cigars and drink alcohol while being so obsessed with his “purity of essence,” but no one ever said people were consistent.)
In any event, elsewhere in the movie, in a discussion with his assistant, an RAF officer named Mandrake, Gen. Ripper details his obsession with his “purity of essence” and his determination to deny women his “essence” during “the act of love”, as he puts it. Unsurprisingly (for the time), Gen. Ripper believed that the fluoridation of water was the mechanism by which Communists were accomplishing this nefarious aim to “impurify” Americans’ “precious bodily fluids”, as he explains while US troops are attacking his base as part of the government’s effort to take over the base, locate the recall code, and thereby abort the first strike:
I love General Ripper’s first question, “Mandrake, have you ever seen a Commie drink a glass of water?”
As I’ve discussed in detail before, General Ripper’s fear of “contamination” (or, as he puts it, “impurification”) of his “precious bodily fluids”, his obsession with “purity of essence” (the very term playing a large role in the plot), and his conspiracy theory that “they” are out to contaminate that purity in order to conquer him and the US, remind me very much of how antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers are discussing the pandemic and, of course, COVID-19 vaccines. What I haven’t discussed before (other than alluding to it) is how this all ties into the idea that “natural” (i.e., post-infection) immunity is superior to vaccine-induced (and therefore “artificial”) immunity. The idea of “purity” versus “contamination” lie at the heart of many alternative medicine beliefs, and it is those beliefs, which tend to be religious in nature, that pervade the discourse over “natural” versus vaccine-induced immunity to COVID-19. Moreover, such beliefs tend to victim shame as well given that, like so many alternative medicine beliefs, they suggest that if you only eat the right foods, do the right exercises, and use the right supplements, you can render yourself almost immune to disease. A long time ago, I discussed this in the context of Bill Maher’s claim that he would not catch influenza on a plane because of his superior immunity, which led Bob Costas to retort, “Oh, come on, Superman!” I also discussed it in terms of Del Bigtree’s horrendous victim shaming when he urged his viewers to “catch this cold” to contribute to “natural herd immunity” against COVID-19, while blaming people with chronic diseases influenced by lifestyle (such as obesity and type II diabetes) for having brought it on themselves.
My response to Del Bigtree is the same response I make to every antivaxxer who urges “natural herd immunity” to COVID-19: You first. Oddly enough, those advocating that the “healthy” be infected never seem to seek out the infection themselves.
Let’s go back to what now seems like ancient history, the year 2019. Truly, from the perspective of 2021, 2019 seems like another time, but even then the seeds of what we see now were fully germinated in the context of measles outbreaks that were occurring around the country because of low uptake of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine in some areas. Statements like this were not uncommon:
You can't attack @DarlaShine unless you have a vaxx vs unvaxx study proving #vaxxed are healthier. #MawsonStudy shows #unvaxxed far healthier. What is @CDC @US_FDA hiding @CNN? Science is on our side. #vaccines #vaccine #flushot #FakeNewshttps://t.co/M8xSECoFcS
— Del Bigtree (@delbigtree) February 15, 2019
Yes, that’s Del Bigtree joining in to support the misinformation. Unsurprisingly, Darla Shine soon doubled down:
I had the #Measles #Mumps #ChickenPox as a child and so did every kid I knew – Sadly my kids had #MMR so they will never have the life long natural immunity I have.
Come breathe on me!
— Darla Shine 👑 (@DarlaShine) February 13, 2019
Although there was pushback:
He doesn't but he should. Would love to know how much he made off of Vaxxed. How much did he earn for putting babies' lives at risk I wonder…
— Linda Girgis MD (@DrLindaMD) February 14, 2020
And even more ludicrously:
"The virus strain was engineered and weakened in a lab"
This wasn't anything like just getting measles as a disease.
Vaccines save children's lives. The experts know it, and vaccinate their own children (as do I!).
Please don't feed the conspiracy theories. Kids pay the price.
— Colin (@Kolyin) February 13, 2019
Again, none of this is surprising. The appeal to “natural immunity” is a very old trope that is frequently combined with conspiracy theories about vaccine “profits”:
The big issue with natural immunity is that nobody gets rich.
— Robert J. O'Neill (@mchooyah) October 2, 2021
By early December 2019, just as the first large COVID-19 outbreak that led to the pandemic was picking up steam in Wuhan, China, antivaxxers were traveling to Samoa, where a huge measles outbreak had sickened over 4,000 children and killed 60, to spread their disinformation about the MMR vaccine. No less a luminary than Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. wrote a letter to Samoan Prime Minister Tuilaepa Aiono Sailele Malielegaoi touting “natural immunity” to measles due to maternal antibodies in breast milk, while blaming a “defective” vaccine and implying that it was actually the vaccine strain that had caused the outbreak. His evidence? He had none. He was just handwaving and JAQing off. Let’s take a trip down memory lane and briefly quote his RFK Jr.’s letter:
Media reports from Samoa suggest that the infection is targeting young infants who are not yet of age to receive the measles vaccine. If true, the culprit is most likely a vaccine that failed to produce antibodies in the vaccinated mothers sufficient to provide the infant with maternal immunity. Young infants contracting measles is a relatively new phenomena first recognized in the 1990’s. Prior to the development and widespread use of Merck’s measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine, mothers passed protection to their infants via passive immunity derived from the placenta and breast milk. In contrast, mothers vaccinated with a defective Merck vaccine provide inadequate passive immunity to their babies. Merck’s version of the MMR has created a crisis where infants under the age of one are now highly vulnerable to these infections. These young infants suffer a much higher morbidity and mortality compared to populations historically impacted by wild measles later in childhood.
As I pointed out, none of this is actually correct, and maternal IgG antibodies to measles fall to zero by 6-12 months of age, while the IgA antibodies in milk are not nearly as protective and wane even more rapidly. I’m not going to relitigate the relevant science here; my point in bringing this up is as an example of how antivaxxers blamed the lack of “natural immunity” in Samoan mothers who had been vaccinated with MMR for their babies dying of measles in the outbreaks from two years ago. I also pointed out that high vaccine uptake is the best way to protect infants like these, coupled with earlier vaccination during outbreaks. If herd immunity is high, faster waning of immunity due to maternal antibodies is then much less of a problem. If herd immunity is not high, than vaccinating earlier is a viable option to protect these infants. In his letter, RFK Jr. also lamented how vaccines might not result in lifelong immunity to measles, another way that “natural” immunity is supposedly superior. Of course, post-infection immunity to measles isn’t always lifelong, and even if it were, lifelong immunity can be maintained with booster shots, something that antivaxxers seem to consider anathema.
Perhaps the most striking example of how in the age of COVID-19 everything old is new again comes from reconsidering an argument that the godfather of the modern antivaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield, made about measles five years ago. In brief, he claimed that mortality from measles had been falling long before the vaccine because of “natural herd immunity” due, of course, to “natural” infection and that this was so much better than the herd immunity due to the MMR vaccine. You can tell from where RFK Jr. got his argument about the immunity in mothers due to vaccination being “inferior” to immunity due to “natural” infection, though, because Wakefield made the very same argument three years earlier:
Vaccinated mothers do not confer adequate passive immunity upon their infants (
You can also see a precursor of a COVID-19 era antivaccine claim back then, as Wakefield also said:
The increasing Herd Immunity associated with natural measles and the accompanying decrease in morbidity and mortality, has been interrupted by vaccination. This makes it difficult to predict how vaccinated populations might respond to, say, a new strain of measles virus that has escaped the ‘protection’ conferred by measles vaccine (escape mutant). Because that population is not immune to the escape mutant we risk high morbidity and mortality from measles once again.
See the message? It’s that vaccinating will leave the population vulnerable to escape mutants. That’s a favorite antivaccine trope now used to argue against COVID-19 vaccination. Of course, I had the counterargument five years ago: Those who have “natural” post-infection immunity will also be vulnerable to escape mutants! Also, as must be repeated yet again, immunity from vaccination means not having to suffer through the disease itself to achieve immunity. As it turns out, this 2016 Wakefield argument was a precursor to an even more ludicrous argument in which he predicted that the MMR vaccine would lead to a “sixth mass extinction” (presumably of humans) due to the development of ever more virulent escape mutants. Other than some differences at the edges, at its core, Wakefield’s claim for the MMR and measles was identical to a claim made in a viral letter by COVID-19 crank Geert Vanden Bossche for the COVID-19 vaccine. The main difference is that Vanden Bossche claimed that a mass vaccination campaign during a pandemic is particularly dangerous, which made me wonder: When would be a better time to undertake a mass vaccination campaign than during a global pandemic that’s killed millions so far? Unsurprisingly, Vanden Bossche continues to fear monger about the emergence of “escape mutants” due to selection by COVID-19 vaccines, ignoring the observation from science that the richest source of new mutations is allowing the virus to spread and proliferate among the largest population possible.
It turns out, though, as Levinovitz points out, that the antivax appeal to “natural immunity” goes way, way back:
The language of naturalness short-circuits clear thinking about vaccines, substituting a theological binary — natural immunity vs. unnatural immunity — for empirical evidence. The standard vocabulary of medical science thus unwittingly undermines the very public health goals it is meant to serve by implicitly endorsing immunity that doesn’t come from vaccines.
None of this should be surprising, since we’ve known about the relationship between “pure blood,” naturalness and vaccine refusal for more than a century. The historian Nadja Durbach documented examples from Victorian anti-vaccination movements that would be right at home on TikTok: a father who feared his vaccinated baby had not a “drop of pure blood in its body”; an 1885 anti-vaccine banner that read “Pure blood and no adulteration”; and activists who asserted that vaccination was “pollution of our veins.”
For these Victorians, pure blood was “natural” and, by association, godly, because natural invoked the order ordained by God. The resulting ideology was, according to Durbach, a kind of “physical Puritanism” that granted vaccine resistance a divine mandate. Activists whipped up fear by describing vaccination as an “unnatural and dangerous” assault on the human body, unapproved by “Heaven’s will.”
Which brings us back to General Ripper:
The same associations remained powerful in the mid-20th century, when opponents of water fluoridation complained about unnatural adulteration of what should be pure. Their position — described by social scientists at the time as “naturalist syndrome” — was so mainstream that Stanley Kubrick skewered it in his classic “Dr. Strangelove,” wherein the lunatic Brig. Gen. Jack D. Ripper bemoans how fluoride corrupts the “pure blood of pure Americans.”
“Purity” vs. “contamination,” with disease and bad things caused by “contamination,” are at the root of much of alternative medicine and thus at the root of a lot of antivaccine sentiment. It’s at the root of the belief that “toxins” are the cause of disease and that “detoxification” is the cure. Before the pandemic, this belief manifested itself in many of the common antivaccine tropes involving “toxins” such as the false claim that vaccines are loaded with toxic chemicals, contain “fetal parts” or “fetal DNA,” and involve, as Bill Maher once put it, “injecting disease”, merely a different way of expressing the antivaccine trope that vaccines are “disease matter”. In the antivaccine world, as in the alternative medicine world, pharmaceutical products like vaccines are portrayed as “artificial” and “contamination” (of our precious bodily fluids) associated with decomposition, putrefaction, and impurity. Indeed, a decade before the pandemic, I encountered antivaxxers portraying vaccines as “transhumanism“. These same ideas from alternative medicine have manifested themselves during the pandemic in similar ways, with the added claims that mRNA vaccines somehow “alter your DNA,” thus by extension, presumably, “corrupting” your bodily essence, and, yes, “transhumanism” figures in this characterization too.
Never mind that:
There is no such thing as artificial immunity. Its all natural. Either the body produces an immune response or it doesn't. The body doesn't care how it got exposed to an antigen.
— Obi Dox Kenobi (@obibluraven) October 3, 2021
Exactly.
The consequences of the term “natural immunity”
The idea that “natural immunity” is somehow superior to immunity acquired through vaccines has real-world consequences, too, particularly when it is applied to the pandemic. First and foremost, this idea is used by advocates as an intentional argument to oppose vaccine mandates of any kind, as we’ve seen many times. The line of argument goes like this: People with previous COVID-19 infection should not be required to get the vaccine as a condition of their jobs, to enter public spaces, or for any other reason. Again, this ignores the science showing that post-infection immunity is far more variable and might not be as long lasting as vaccine-induced immunity, as well as the logistical problems of documenting who has and hasn’t had COVID-19 for the purposes of such mandates.
When it comes to the claimed superiority of “natural herd immunity” things get even more dangerous and potentially deadly. After all, “natural herd immunity” was the rationale behind the Great Barrington Declaration, a declaration promoted a year ago by the free market libertarian think tank the American Institute for Economic Research that advocated, in essence, letting COVID-19 rip through the “healthy” population in order to achieve “natural herd immunity,” while using “focused protection” to keep those most vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19 safe. As I discussed when it was first published, the Great Barrington Declaration did not describe how the vulnerable could be protected when the coronavirus was spreading unchecked through the rest of the population (it couldn’t) and actually represented eugenics more than anything else, as well as a technique of a “magnified minority” that sought to make a very minority fringe opinion seem mainstream. It’s a technique that had been used by climate science deniers, HIV/AIDS denialists, and creationists before, but unfortunately, unlike the case for those science denialists, the Great Barrington Declaration was a raging success. For example, UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and then-President Donald Trump eagerly embraced the principles and ideas of the declaration. More recently, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis appointed a signatory and apostle of the GBD Dr. Joseph Ladapo as Surgeon General and Secretary of the Florida Department of Health.
The religious idea of “purity” versus “contamination” (with sin or evil or whatever) that requires “purification” is a very old one. It’s at the root of damned near all alternative medicine and is never lurking far from antivaccine views. This concept goes hand-in-hand with the idea that “natural” means “virtuous” and is always better than the “unnatural”, such as those nasty pharmaceuticals and vaccines. (Never mind that immunity from vaccination is natural.) It’s also a profoundly harmful idea. It was harmful before the pandemic when cancer patients sought out “natural cures”—but cancer is natural!—and antivaxxers touted “natural immunity,” and, as Levinovitz points out, it’s even more harmful now:
Of course, natural does not mean good or safe. For most of human history, natural childbirth killed massive numbers of women, and still does in areas with limited access to unnatural hospitals. Natural selection worked its divinely mandated magic by killing off scores of infants. And acquiring “natural” immunity to the coronavirus means getting sick in the first place, an experience far riskier — for oneself, one’s loved ones and one’s community — than the “unnatural” vaccines developed to protect against it. But accustomed as we are to equating natural with good, it is easy to overlook the many ways it is not.
Indeed. “Nature” doesn’t care if you or I live or die. Cancer is entirely “natural”. So is COVID-19.
        ◦ Truly, everything old is new again. One might even say that everything ancient (such as the belief that “natural” is always better) is new again, mainly because prepandemic most people had not been exposed to how quacks and antivaxxers had weaponized these ancient ideas against modern medicine in general and vaccines in particular. The optimist in me hopes that people, now exposed to the fallacy that “natural is better” will understand how it was always a fallacy, and not just about vaccines. In the meantime, henceforth I will no longer use the term “natural immunity” without qualification to describe post-infection immunity, because messaging matters.

The JCVI Speaks: “Natural Infection in Children Could Have Substantial Long-Term Benefits On COVID-19 in the UK”
The UK’s Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation suggested using sick children as human shields to protect adults.
Jonathan Howard on October 30, 2021
Link

“There are reasons that children get sick. Getting sick is not a bad thing.”

In a previous article, I explored what I thought it meant to be anti-vaccine. In that article I wrote, “the core that unites anti-vaccine thought is: 1) inappropriate minimization of the risk from the virus, and 2) inappropriate minimization of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine”. Some anti-vaxxers take the first of these tenets to an extreme and claim that it’s actually beneficial for children to get vaccine-preventable diseases. As American Loon #1,931, Jennifer Margulis said,
Why are we giving children so many vaccines? They get four times the number of vaccines than I got when I was child growing up in the ’70s. As a parent, I would rather see my child get a natural illness and contract that the way that illnesses have been contracted for at least 200,000 years that homo sapiens has been around. I’m not afraid of my children getting chickenpox. There are reasons that children get sick. Getting sick is not a bad thing.
Statements such as this are rightly characterized as not just anti-vaccine, but pro-virus. The idea that disease-causing viruses are good for children is relatively common in the anti-vaccine world, and it leads to some pretty bizarre claims, such as that measles helps prevent cancer. Of course all of this is just the appeal to nature fallacy on steroids. This fallacy is usually associated with scientific luminaries such as Gwyneth Paltrow who said, “I don’t think anything that is natural can be bad for you”.
“Natural infection in children could have substantial long-term benefits on COVID-19 in the UK”
With this in mind, let’s take a trip to the UK and meet the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI), which advises UK health departments on vaccine policy. In September, the JCVI declined to recommend the COVID vaccine to all children between 12 and 15 years old, saying that the benefits were only “marginally greater than the potential known harms”, and the margin was “too small to support universal Covid-19 vaccination for this age group at this time”. The JCVI recently released minutes (here and here) of their meetings this May that reveals a window into their decision-making process. While some of their discussions seem to represent a necessary and thoughtful approach to balancing the risks and benefit of the vaccine, much of their rhetoric is full of the type of COVID-19 minimization I have discussed several times previously. However, other talking points were much more problematic.
Some of the JCVI’s arguments against vaccination were:
    • Children rarely develop severe disease or die of COVID-19; even children with underlying comorbidities have a very low risk.
    • All adults will be vaccinated and there is a low risk of child-to-child transmission. Staff and parents will be protected.
    • Childhood infections reflect adult infection in the community; vaccinating adults will lead to lower community infection rates and lower risk of transmission to children.
    • There is an argument for allowing the virus to circulate amongst children which could provide broader immunity to the children and boost immunity in adults.
The minutes also included the following statements:
    • The Committee agreed that there was little direct or indirect benefit from routinely vaccinating children aged 12-15 years.
    • Members commented that natural infection in children could have substantial long-term benefits on COVID-19 in the UK.
    • Members commented that the vaccination of children was unlikely to have a substantial impact on a fourth wave.
    • Members commented that given the very low risk of serious disease in children, that routine vaccination of those aged 12-15 years may not be necessary. The theoretical advantages of exposure to natural infection (with very low risk of serious disease) were noted.
    • Members considered that in the absence of vaccination, future generations would be exposed to COVID-19 in childhood, with a relatively mild disease. This early infection would then provide protection against severe disease throughout life. Circulation of COVID-19 in childhood could therefore periodically boost immunity in adults through exposure.
Though the UK government eventually overruled the JCVI’s recommendation, allowing one vaccine dose for adolescents, it was mostly too little too late. As the JCVI intended, the virus spread unchecked throughout the pediatric population. According to an estimate by Britain’s Office for National Statistics, “9.14% of older school children had COVID-19 during the week ending Oct. 22.” Even though the vast majority of children do well with COVID-19, when large numbers of them get sick, some suffer. Over 10,000 children have been hospitalized in England alone thus far, and according to news reports, over 100 children there have died, including “13 children dying in the seven weeks since schools reopened”. The death toll includes some children who would have been eligible for vaccination had they lived outside of the UK. The JCVI’s statement that “Children rarely develop severe disease or die of COVID-19” will be cold comfort to the families of these children.
While the choice to leave children vulnerable to COVID-19 was itself problematic, the JCVI’s rationale for this decision is even more disturbing. Reading the minutes of the JCVI meetings, I was reminded of the pro-virus statements by Ms. Margulis. It’s clear that some JCVI members are not just against the vaccine, but like Ms. Margulis, they are actively on the side of virus. Ms. Margulis said “Getting sick is not a bad thing,” and they clearly couldn’t agree more. A sociologist advising the JCVI, Robert Dingwall, previously voiced this opinion writing that school closures may, “have an immediate cost in terms of depriving children of the opportunity to acquire immunity to the infection”. He also said, “Given the low risk of Covid for most teenagers, it is not immoral to think that they may be better protected by natural immunity generated through infection than by asking them to take the possible risk of a vaccine”. At least Mr. Dingwall can’t be accused of believing COVID-19 is an “opportunity” only for children. Praising death from the virus, he previously said the following:
There is, though, a first question: who says it is desirable to prevent every death regardless of the cost? My impression is that the loudest voices are coming from young or middle-aged people who have yet to accept that death is a normal part of life. It comes to all of us in good time. A wise person would, of course, prefer to die later rather than sooner, but they might also consider that some deaths are easier to bear than others. It is not for nothing that pneumonia was described as ‘the old man’s friend’ in the days before antibiotics. Contrary to some media coverage, no-one is advocating that any old person is abandoned to die without professional nursing care. However, we should acknowledge that many frail old people might see Covid-19 infection as a relatively peaceful end compared with, say, several years of dementia or some cancers.
We’ll see if Mr. Dingall chooses to contract COVID-19 at some point in the future to ease his own passing.
The JCVI: Getting everything exactly backwards
The notion that “early infection would then provide protection against severe disease throughout life” is standard anti-vaccine Pablum, akin to using pregnancy as a form of birth control. Of course, there was never evidence that viral-induced immunity was long-lasting. The JCVI may be surprised to learn that SARS-CoV-2 is a brand new virus, and only time will tell how long immunity to it will last. In fact, recent evidence suggests that vaccine-induced immunity is likely more robust that viral-induced immunity. The JCVI had it exactly backwards.
Similarly, there was never any evidence that allowing the virus to spread throughout the pediatric population would benefit adults. Again, the JCVI had it exactly backwards. They suggested in May that “vaccinating specific age groups amongst children had little overall impact on hospitalisations and deaths in older adults” and that “All adults will be vaccinated and there is a low risk of child-to-child transmission”. Today, the headlines report that “Children Drive Britain’s Longest-Running Covid Surge” and “England’s COVID Prevalence Rises To Highest Since Start Of Year, ONS Says“. Deaths and hospitalizations have increased as well, though fortunately, there has been some decoupling of cases and these metrics thanks to vaccines. (Predictably contrarian doctors in the US who lavishly praised the JCVI’s “nuance” and “rationality & numeracy” several months ago have absolutely nothing to say about any of this today.)
(Top image credit Paul Mainwood)
“Children should not be left to face mass infection with the very same virus they made sacrifices to protect adults from”
Even if the JCVI’s predictions happened to be right, the logic they used to justify their decision is more dreadful than Ms. Margulis’s statement. At least she genuinely believed getting sick is somehow beneficial to children. In contrast, the JCVI proposed that children be infected to “boost immunity in adults”, even as they recognized the rare child can become very sick and even die from the virus. The notion that vaccinating children will lead to increased disease in adults is also an old, evidence-free anti-vaccine trope. For example, some anti-vaxxers argue against the chickenpox vaccine for children, claiming the lack of circulating virus leads to shingles in adults. In fact, this myth may be the reason that children in the UK are not vaccinated against chickenpox.
From the viewpoint of some JCVI members, children aren’t independent agents with a right to be protected from a potentially dangerous virus. Rather, to their minds, because they can serve as human shields for more vulnerable adults, it’s downright good when children get sick. They explicitly stated that “natural infection in children could have substantial long-term benefits for COVID-19 in the UK”. Not only is this scientific nonsense, as the high number of infections in the UK clearly shows, it’s a moral abomination. As Dr. Nisreen Alwan said:
Mass infection of kids with a virus less than 2 years old is not ethical, not moral, not scientifically evidenced, not socially just & medically risky. There’s no good argument for this. And no, boosting population immunity to protect the adults is not a valid argument.#Childism
— Prof Nisreen Alwan 🌻 (@Dr2NisreenAlwan) October 30, 2021
She also lambasted the UK’s policy by writing, “children should not be left to face mass infection with the very same virus they made sacrifices to protect adults from”.
        ◦ Yet, children were left to face mass infection, and some suffered greatly as a result. The JCVI should be judged for their decision, as should governors in the southern USA who quietly adopted this policy without having the courage to put it in writing.

Which is best, vaccine-induced immunity, “natural immunity,” or “super immunity” to COVID-19?
Those opposed to public health interventions to slow the spread of COVID-19, including masks, “lockdowns,” and vaccine mandates, are hyping “natural” immunity again as somehow “superior” to vaccine-acquired immunity. It’s a deceptive simplification of a complex issue.
David Gorski on February 21, 2022
Link

Over the last few weeks, I’ve noticed the resurgence of messaging that emphasizes “natural immunity” as being superior to vaccine-induced immunity to COVID-19, particularly for the more recent variants of SARS-CoV-2, such as Delta, Omicron, and, most recently, the Omicron subvariant BA.2. For example, Jeffrey Tucker published an article at the Brownstone Institute website asking “Are They Finally Admitting Natural Immunity?”, as though public health officials have somehow been “covering up” this “natural immunity”, the better to keep enforcing “lockdowns” and masking and vaccine mandates. (Translation: “Natural immunity” is the way out of the pandemic that “they” don’t want you to know about.) Meanwhile, conservative-leaning mainstream media outlets like Fox News and The Wall Street Journal have had a number of stories and articles touting “natural immunity”, with, as just one of many examples, Johns Hopkins surgical oncologist Dr. Marty Makary having tried to portray a “high cost of disparaging natural immunity to COVID-19” and claiming that public health officials have “ruined many lives by insisting that workers with natural immunity to Covid-19 be fired if they weren’t fully vaccinated”. This narrative has, in particular, been deployed to defend the Canadian trucker convoys that recently besieged Ottawa and, just across the river from me in Windsor, blocked the Ambassador Bridge to Detroit in order to protest Canadian vaccine mandates.
Before I get to the science, in the interests of transparency I like to make my position clear. The term “natural immunity” is a very poor descriptor whose very use of the word “natural” has made it very easy for ideologues and antivaxxers to weaponize to argue against COVID-19 vaccines and restrictions. I’ve discussed before, as has Alan Levinovitz, how scientists made a huge mistake in adopting the term “natural immunity”. The reason is that it is an inherently misleading term; people often view naturalness as synonymous with purity and goodness. Moreover, vaccine-induced immunity is every bit as “natural” as post-infection immunity (the more appropriate term to describe immunity after an infection), with the added huge advantage of not having to suffer through the disease and risk its potential complications, up to and including death, to acquire immunity. Worse, advocates of “natural immunity” not limited to antivaxxers frequently describe this immunity as having quasi-magical properties, implying that it is lifelong, far better against everything, and even beneficial, with some even going so far to argue that it’s better, for instance, to let children become infected. (Of course, even though children do have a much lower risk of severe disease and death from COVID-19, there are those pesky large—for children—COVID-19 death tolls that rebuke this argument every bit as much as the death toll in the US that is now approaching one million rebukes previous predictions that we would achieve herd immunity soon.)
Sadly, it’s not just antivaxxers and antimaskers who have started promoting the “natural immunity” narrative in which letting COVID-19 rip through the “healthy” population and children will get us to “natural herd immunity” faster than just vaccination campaigns. It’s doctors who should know better. As a result, increasingly activists, pundits, and politicians—sadly, including some doctors and scientists—opposed to vaccine and COVID-19 mandates of any kind are co-opting the term “natural immunity” to give anyone previously infected and recovered a free pass from any restrictions, sometimes taking the idea to ridiculous extremes.
Leaving aside my contention that “natural immunity” is a horrible term (which is why I never use it except with scare quotes), what is the real situation? As is often the case with such issues, it’s complicated. We cannot discuss this question, however, without taking a look at the dominant narrative with respect to “natural immunity”, in particular because the science is not consistent with this narrative.
The Great Barrington Declaration
I debated about whether to bring up the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) yet again, having done so just last week in the context of John Ioannidis’ awful “study” that attempted to argue that the GBD was somehow overwhelmed in the social media narrative by “science Kardashians” with far more Twitter firepower than scientific contributions. It is an article that is being used by GBD advocates to cast opponents as unserious social media creatures. However, it is appropriate, given how the GBD, its authors, its signatories, and its boosters have dominated the media narrative on “natural immunity” and “natural herd immunity”.
The ideas behind the GBD, which was first published in October 2020 (before safe and effective COVID-19 vaccines were available to the public anywhere except in clinical trials) were threefold. First, “lockdowns” (however you define “lockdown”, and GBD proponents seem to define it as any government public health edict closing or restricting businesses or placing any restrictions whatsoever on private individuals) do far more harm than good. Second, “natural herd immunity” is inevitable, and, therefore third, we should adopt a “let ‘er rip” strategy with respect to COVID-19 and the “healthy” and “young” population and use “focused protection” to keep those at high risk of serious disease, complications, and death from COVID-19, safe. Moreover, contrary to their penchant for describing themselves as “silenced“, GBD authors and advocates have long had preferential access to media and government officials. Indeed, as Stanford PhD student Mallory Harris has noted, the recent release of a book by Scott Atlas, President Trump’s COVID-19 advisor, basically confirmed this preferential access:
The day after the Augusr meeting, the President described his strategy: "sheltering those at highest risk, especially the elderly, while allowing lower risk Americans to safely return to work and to school…they have to get back to work."https://t.co/7sEZgoRzXP pic.twitter.com/zCoI3VgIB0
— Mallory Harris (@malar0ne.bsky.social) (@malar0ne) February 18, 2022
And it was ≈ a month after HHS Science Adviser Paul Alexander sent an email saying "open up and flood the zone and let the kids and young folk get infected…we want them infected."
He now writes for the Brownstone Institute, GBD's "spiritual child."https://t.co/2jdbdhrqmj
— Mallory Harris (@malar0ne.bsky.social) (@malar0ne) February 18, 2022
We still don't know when this meeting was arranged. Presumably, the invitation preceded the public announcement of the document.https://t.co/ZliT8YfPmS
— Mallory Harris (@malar0ne.bsky.social) (@malar0ne) February 18, 2022
We also know that the GBD was propped up by right-wing corporate interests, including AIER, the libertarian thinktank that hosted the event where the documented was written.https://t.co/KyHp0C05P7
— Mallory Harris (@malar0ne.bsky.social) (@malar0ne) February 18, 2022
Problems abounded with the GBD with respect to all three ideas behind it. First, its adherents tended to vastly exaggerate the harms of “lockdowns” and minimize the ability of “lockdowns” and other mandates, such as masks (collectively known as nonpharmacological interventions, or NPIs), to slow the spread of COVID-19, an issue still debated today, while promoting a caricature of public health officials as completely ignoring any negative consequences of such policies in relation to potential benefits.
Second, the assumption that “natural herd immunity” was inevitable was just that, an assumption. “Natural herd immunity” is the epidemiological principle that over time an infectious disease will infect enough of the population to produce enough post-infection immunity to result in herd immunity, the level of immunity at which the number of new infections reaches a steady state and there are no longer large spikes in incidence and epidemics. Because such immunity required that a huge fraction of the population suffer through the disease, GBD adherents had to bend over backwards to portray COVID-19 as a “mild disease” by lowballing death estimates and portraying it as “harmless” to children. More importantly, “natural herd immunity” also requires that post-infection immunity be long-lived, if not life-long. If immunity wanes too quickly in individuals or virus variants crop up that can evade the immunity from previous infections, “natural herd immunity” will likely never be reached. I can only cite Omicron and the new Omicron subvariant BA.2 as evidence that this has been the case with COVID-19, but even 16 months ago given how the Omicron variant has led to a massive surge in reinfections, despite all we didn’t know, we did know that post-infection immunity to coronaviruses is often transient and that variants that evade immunity commonly develop. Even as long as a year ago, scientists were beginning to fear that herd immunity even as a result of post-infection immunity plus vaccine-induced immunity was probably out of reach because too high a percentage of the population would need to be immune, waning immunity (both vaccine- and infection-induced), insufficient prevention of forward transmission of the virus, and new virus variants, all the failed predictions of academics like Dr. Makary about how soon we will have “herd immunity” notwithstanding.
Finally, the concept of “focused protection” in the GBD was ill-defined to the point of being basically meaningless (and remains so today). It ignored the incredible difficulty—if not impossibility—of protecting the large segment of the population that is at high risk of severe disease and death, including the elderly and those with chronic health conditions, while a respiratory virus is ripping through the young, “healthy” population, while seemingly arguing just keeping the elderly and high-risk population locked away from society indefinitely to “protect” them while not unduly inconveniencing everyone else. It was a profoundly ableist and, dare I say, even eugenicist idea couched in terms of claiming that letting the young be infected would somehow also protect the vulnerable. It was always nonsense, a politically motivated faux proposal given that it originated in a conference organized by a right wing think tank opposed to “lockdowns” and other COVID-19 restrictions.
The political use and misuse of “natural immunity,” particularly by GBD-linked sources like the Brownstone Institute notwithstanding, it is worth reviewing recent evidence to evaluate the relative value of post-infection immunity. It’s also worth doing so in the context of the narrative of GBD-linked sources, such as the Brownstone Institute, whose founder recently asked the question about “admitting” to “natural immunity”. Why? Because Tucker references a recent CDC study to make his claim:
In late January, the CDC published a report that made what might have been regarded as a shocking claim. If you have had Covid, the CDC demonstrated in a chart, you gain robust immunity that is better than that of vaccination, especially concerning duration.
That should be nothing surprising. Brownstone has chronicled 150 studies making that point. What made this new chart different was that it came from the CDC, which has buried the point so deeply for so long as to amount to a near denial.
So there: the CDC says it. So nonchalant! So uneventful!
If people had understood this two years ago, plus been made more completely aware of the dramatic risk gradient by age and health, lockdowns would have been completely untenable.
The society-wide mandates and lockdowns depended on keeping the public ignorant on settled points of cell biology and immunology, plus pressuring social media companies to censor anyone who didn’t fall in line. Here we are all this time later and the truth is coming out.
Had the knowledge of risk gradients and immunities been in the forefront of policy makers’ minds – instead of wild fear and obsequious deference to Fauci – we would have focused on protecting the vulnerable and otherwise allowed society to function normally so that the virus would become endemic. We would not only have saved thousands of lives; we could have avoided the vast economic, educational, cultural, and public-health wreckage all around us.
Those poor, “silenced” advocates for “natural herd immunity”! Note the way that Brownstone writer Paul Alexander—yes, that Paul Alexander, the HHS science advisor who once wrote in an email that we “want them [infants, kids, teens, young people, young adults, middle aged with no conditions] infected” to reach “natural herd immunity”—conflates number of studies with quality of data – a favorite tactic among antivaxxers as well. Note also how he blamed Anthony Fauci for it all, even though many months went by in 2020 when Trump barely spoke to Fauci because he didn’t like what Fauci had to say.
But what about that study? The narrative lately appears to be a tale of a couple of recent studies, which starts with the CDC study.
Did the CDC really say that “natural immunity” to COVID-19 is superior?
The study referenced by Tucker was published three weeks ago in Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR), the chief scientific outlet of the CDC, and he is quite taken by a video “analysis” written by Dr. Vinay Prasad. Before the pandemic, Dr. Prasad was known for critiquing the sometimes poor quality of clinical evidence used in oncology and other medical specialties, although even before the pandemic he had little but contempt for those of us who take the time to refute quackery and antivaccine misinformation. It’s ironic, then, how since the pandemic he’s pivoted to becoming a rich (and, to the public, an unfortunately seemingly authoritative) source of such misinformation, even describing public health interventions as potentially the first step on the road to fascism.
His entire claim is based on this graph from the paper:

This figure represents data from California and New York (which account for 18% of the U.S. population) in order to assess what happened as the Delta wave became predominant, with the CDC stating in the discussion:
Across the entire study period, persons with vaccine- and infection-derived immunity had much lower rates of hospitalization compared with those in unvaccinated persons. These results suggest that vaccination protects against COVID-19 and related hospitalization and that surviving a previous infection protects against a reinfection. Importantly, infection-derived protection was greater after the highly transmissible Delta variant became predominant, coinciding with early declining of vaccine-induced immunity in many persons (5). Similar data accounting for booster doses and as new variants, including Omicron, circulate will need to be assessed.
So what we have is a snapshot of what happened as the Delta wave ramped up but before Omicron crashed onto the scene, which led to different results than what were observed with the original COVID-19 strain, for which vaccine-induced immunity was more potent than post-infection immunity. Is this slam-dunk evidence that “natural immunity” is superior? Not exactly. As the CDC notes, these data don’t come close to taking into account the Omicron variant and the effect of the increasing number of people receiving boosters. Indeed, the CDC noted at least seven limitations, among them no stratification of the analysis by time since vaccine receipt; misclassification of persons with undiagnosed COVID-19 infection as having had COVID-19, which would decrease apparent differences between the vaccinated and unvaccinated; unmeasured confounding due to differential risk; no information on severity of initial infection; lack of ascertainment of receipt of additional or booster COVID-19 vaccine doses, given that the study was conducted before many persons were eligible or had received additional or booster vaccine doses; lack of precision in some samples due to sample size limitations; and the fact that the analysis was carried out before Omicron.
Indeed, another analysis that tries to do that (referenced in the article) is not nearly as clear:
That’s why the CDC concluded:
Vaccination protected against COVID-19 and related hospitalization, and surviving a previous infection protected against a reinfection and related hospitalization during periods of predominantly Alpha and Delta variant transmission, before the emergence of Omicron; evidence suggests decreased protection from both vaccine- and infection-induced immunity against Omicron infections, although additional protection with widespread receipt of booster COVID-19 vaccine doses is expected. Initial infection among unvaccinated persons increases risk for serious illness, hospitalization, long-term sequelae, and death; by November 30, 2021, approximately 130,781 residents of California and New York had died from COVID-19. Thus, vaccination remains the safest and primary strategy to prevent SARS-CoV-2 infections, associated complications, and onward transmission. Primary COVID-19 vaccination, additional doses, and booster doses are recommended by CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices to ensure that all eligible persons are up to date with COVID-19 vaccination, which provides the most robust protection against initial infection, severe illness, hospitalization, long-term sequelae, and death.
So, basically, yes, in this one study looking at the original COVID-19 strain and the Delta variant, post-infection immunity appears to be more robust, but with a lot of caveats, none of which stopped GBD adherents from claiming that this study was slam dunk evidence that “natural immunity” is “6x better than vaxx.” Again, let’s just say that it’s way more complicated and nowhere near that clear, even if you look at just this CDC study.
The “natural immunity” wars continue
There are, of course, a number of other studies, and, taken together, what they say about post-infection versus post-vaccination immunity is…confusing, at best. For example, here’s one study, published in JAMA, that GBD proponents were touting last month. It’s from Dr. Makary’s group, which isn’t a good sign, and it examined only antibody levels. Worse, get a load of its recruitment methods:
Healthy adults who reported no SARS-CoV-2 vaccination were recruited via 1 public Twitter post and 1 public Facebook advertisement between September 11, 2021, and October 8, 2021. Participants completed an online questionnaire about demographics, COVID-19 status, and mask use. Using weighted random sampling (relative weights based on the estimated unvaccinated US population by age, race and ethnicity, and education1), we created 3 equally sized sample groups among those who reported a test-confirmed COVID-19 infection (“COVID-confirmed”), believed they had COVID-19 but were never tested (“COVID-unconfirmed”), and did not believe they ever had COVID-19 and never tested positive (“no-COVID”). These groups were invited to undergo antibody testing at LabCorp facilities nationwide.
Yes, you read that right. There’s no control group, and recruitment was by a highly dubious method. Yet Makary misrepresented his paper on Twitter thusly:
Our Natural Immunity Study out today in JAMA:👍🏼816 people👍🏼99.3% with prior Covid had circulating antibodies (unvax)👍🏼Durable for ~2yrs studied👍🏼Lexicon of immune/non-imm >> vax/unvax👍🏼Don't try to get Cov. But if you had it, imm more durable than vax https://t.co/mlR2GIhzOh https://t.co/PuP1L1cNIi pic.twitter.com/7tLqPlbIvk
— Marty Makary MD, MPH (@MartyMakary) February 3, 2022
I am simply going to go right to the Discussion section to quote Dr. Makary and colleagues themselves:
Study limitations include lack of direct neutralization assays, the fact that antibody levels alone do not directly equate to immunity,4,6 the cross-sectional study design, a convenience sample with an unknown degree of selection bias due to public recruitment, self-reported COVID-19 test results, the study population being largely White and healthy, and lack of information on breakthrough infections. Participants were given only 1 month to complete antibody testing, which may have contributed to the 52% rate among those invited to test.
Plus this rather…harsh…takedown that is, in my opinion, entirely justified:
9/U
And no, I'm not cherry-picking when I focus on neutralization.
For example, neutralization is central for assessing topics Makary has fabricated about for awhile now, such as herd immunity and viral transmission.https://t.co/nsphk6rXlThttps://t.co/bNMPMfg1pj pic.twitter.com/Vx1QXUUocD
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) February 10, 2022
11/U
Here's the thing, though:Anybody reading the literature knew that already for months. 🤷‍♂️https://t.co/nAhAMTyEbvhttps://t.co/omBjxPdkov[https://t.co/vTxjjftrIu]https://t.co/5wXXCMXkPMhttps://t.co/2cSjh5qgMEhttps://t.co/gSdvM0uEiyhttps://t.co/T5reK822yI pic.twitter.com/PM5Ok1KHR4
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) February 10, 2022
Another study was published as correspondence to the New England Journal of Medicine from Qatar suggested that previous infection also protected against the Beta variant (B.1.3510), just not as much as against the original Alpha variant up to a year later, while earlier data from Qatar found that those who were reinfected were 90% less likely to be hospitalized or to die. Still more recent data from Qatar find that infection with a previous variant is only 56% protective against Omicron.
Then there is another recent Nature paper that used both antibody quantification and functional neutralization assays for antibodies against the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein receptor binding domain (RBD), which is responsible for binding to the ACE2 receptor on cells in order to facilitate the entry of the virus into the cell to do its dirty work, to assess the immune responses in convalescent plasma after infection compared to plasma from vaccinated individuals against various SARS-CoV-2 variants. To boil it down:
In this study, we showed that mRNA vaccinated blood donors have a median of 17 times higher RBD antibody levels when compared with those who became seropositive due to prior COVID-19. Our results indicated an exceptional strong association between high RBD antibody levels in and the ability to biochemically neutralize RBD binding to the cellular ACE2 receptor. The N501Y mutation, while did not alter the neutralizing antibody binding, presented with a fivefold greater affinity to ACE2, which resulted in a drastically reduced ability of COVID-19 convalescent antisera to neutralize its ACE2 binding. Fortunately, the vaccinated blood samples, due to their much-elevated RBD antibody levels, were far more effective in neutralizing both the WT and N501Y RBD from binding to ACE. With an average of 16-fold greater potency than convalescent blood, the vaccinated blood samples were more than sufficient to compensate for the fivefold increased affinity of N501Y RBD, resulting in the highly effective inhibition of both the WT and N501Y RBD from binding to ACE2.
That last part is important. The mutation that results in Omicron’s immune escape doesn’t so much decrease antibody binding to RBD as it results in an RBD that is a lot “stickier” to the ACE2 receptor, which means that it’s more likely to bind to the ACE2 receptor before an antibody can bind to it and neutralize it than is the case for the RBD of previous variants of SARS-CoV-2. Again, this study is preliminary, involving only 33 donors with previous COVID-19 plus 38 samples obtained from the Department of Laboratory Medicine of NIH as diagnostics samples and 28 people who received mRNA vaccines against COVID-19. Moreover, this study also suggests waning antibody levels after vaccination at 6 months, consistent with recent prior studies.
From my perspective, boiling it all down from the studies above and the ones cited in the above Twitter discussion, for now it does appear that infection-induced immunity is roughly as efficacious as the mRNA vaccines, not including boosters, and, like the vaccines, not as effective against later variants, an entirely expected finding that just needs quantification of how much less effective “natural immunity” is against later variants. Regardless of whether one views this “natural immunity” as superior or more robust than immunity from the vaccines, contrary to the claims made by boosters—if you’ll excuse the term—of “natural immunity” and “natural herd immunity,” even by the most optimistic metrics post-infection immunity is nowhere near lifelong and probably doesn’t last a lot longer than post-vaccination immunity, particularly for new variants. Indeed, even if post-infection immunity were to be found to persist two or three times longer than post-vaccination immunity, that would still be nowhere near good enough to make “natural herd immunity” a viable strategy to end the pandemic, particularly with the emergence of new variants and the variability in immune response after infection.
Again, it’s simplistic to look only at the “natural”/vaccine-induced immunity dichotomy, which brings me to “super” immunity and hybrid immunity. A better question is: How do we optimize protection against COVID-19, regardless of prior infection status and variant?
“Super-immunity” (a.k.a. hybrid immunity)
There are now a number of studies looking at what is known as “hybrid immunity,” or immunity to COVID-19 produced as a result of the combination of infection and vaccination, whether it’s as a result of a “breakthrough” infection after vaccination or of vaccination after a previous COVID-19 infection. Unfortunately, there’s another term that is being used for this type of immunity:
Another study, conducted by Oregon Health & Science University, found that a breakthrough infection in a vaccinated person leads to “super immunity.” The study compared blood samples from 52 Pfizer-vaccinated employees of the university infected with different strains of the virus—Alpha, Beta, Gamma, and Delta.
The study found that antibodies measured after breakthrough cases were more abundant and more effective than antibodies generated two weeks after a second dose of the Pfizer vaccine. “You can’t get a better immune response than this,” said Fikadu Tafesse, the author of the report and an assistant professor at the OHSU School of Medicine.
Regular readers likely could easily have predicted that I would absolutely detest the term “super immunity,” even more than I detest the term “natural immunity.” I realize that it’s probably an attempt from public health officials and scientists to counter the term “natural immunity,” but, if anything, “super immunity” is more misleading than “natural immunity,” which is why I prefer the more neutral term “hybrid immunity.” But what about that study and a number of others either published or in the pipeline of pre-prints? It’s possible that I might have missed a study, but let’s look at a quick rundown of what I did find.
There is a recent Israeli study published in Annals of Internal Medicine that’s a retrospective cohort that compared incidence rate of SARS-CoV-2 reinfection in previously infected persons to that of previously infected persons who subsequently received a single dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech mRNA vaccine using the centralized database of Maccabi Healthcare Services in Israel. This study has the drawback that the data used were largely from before the rise of the Omicron variant; and so nothing about non-Delta variants could be inferred. Nonetheless:
A statistically significant decreased risk (hazard ratio, 0.18 [95% CI, 0.15 to 0.20]) for reinfection was found among persons who were previously infected and then vaccinated versus those who were previously infected but remained unvaccinated. In addition, there was a decreased risk for symptomatic disease (hazard ratio, 0.24 [CI, 0.20 to 0.29]) among previously infected and vaccinated persons compared with those who were not vaccinated after infection. No COVID-19–related mortality cases were found.
There was no statistically significant difference in hospitalizations, though, likely because only 10 patients were hospitalized. That’s why a certain doctor whom we’ve met before and who should know better is claiming that this study shows no additional benefit from vaccination after infection, while labeling it the “best” study (because, of course, any study that reinforces your prior beliefs is the “best”). Let’s just say that it’s not the best (although it is good), but the point is taken that, in this study, both groups did so well that the numbers of hospitalized patients were too small to determine if there was a statistically significant difference between them, while the hazard ratios for infection and statistical disease revealed an impressive decline in the risk of Delta in those recovered from prior infection who received a dose of the Pfizer vaccine that would lead me to predict that a larger study would have found differences in hospitalizations, too.
More interestingly, there were two studies published in last week’s NEJM addressing this question as well, one from the SIREN (SARS-CoV-2 Immunity and Reinfection Evaluation) study group and another from an Israeli group. The SIREN study is a multicenter, prospective cohort study involving health care workers in the United Kingdom and consisting of asymptomatic adults who underwent polymerase-chain-reaction (PCR) testing every 2 weeks, among whom more than 30% of the participants were seropositive for SARS-CoV-2 at enrollment. The Israeli study is another retrospective cohort study using two databases maintained by Clalit Health Services. Both suggest the same thing, that hybrid immunity is superior to either post-vaccination or post-infection.
The SIREN study was begun in June 2020 and for this NEJM publication included 35,768 participants, of which 27% (9,488) had a previous SARS-CoV-2 infection. Because of the prospective nature of the study, it was possible to follow these participants over time and determine infection and reinfection risk for various cohorts. The study found that, although the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine provided excellent short term immunity, its immunity waned after 6 months, while immunity from prior infection was waning after a year. The very best immunity came from a combination of prior infection and vaccination, which remained robust after a year.
The second study, from Israel, also found that the cumulative risk of reinfection was much lower in those who were vaccinated after recovery, including those over 65 years of age, a high risk group. In brief, reinfections were more than four times more likely in those who remained unvaccinated afterwards:
This study also found that there was no significant difference in vaccine effectiveness between those who received one dose or two doses after infection, in line with other studies suggesting that one dose of vaccine is sufficient in people preventing reinfection in people who recovered from COVID-19.
There are also laboratory studies that support the concept of hybrid immunity. Steve Novella wrote about one of them last month; so I won’t retread the same ground, other than to say that human immune sera following breakthrough infection and vaccination following natural infection (which contains the antibodies that neutralize the virus), broadly neutralize SARS-CoV-2 variants to a similar degree, implying that the order (infection, then vaccination, versus breakthrough infection after vaccination) doesn’t matter as much as the hybrid nature of the immunity and that the robust hybrid response was not diminished with age.
More recently, a recent study out of OHSU suggests that breakthrough infections work much the same way, finding substantial boosting of humoral (antibody-mediated) immunity after breakthrough infections after vaccination with the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine, including against the Delta variant. A preprint from a different group suggests that the same occurs for Omicron after breakthrough infection. The limitations of these studies are that the numbers are small (52 in the first study, only 23 participants in the second, of which only 10 were breakthrough cases), but the studies did measure virus neutralization by immune serum from participants rather than just antibody titers. It won’t surprise me if larger studies confirm these observations about hybrid immunity, but I’ll wait until, at least, the second paper is published in a peer-reviewed journal.
Why does hybrid immunity appear to be more potent against SARS-CoV-2 and possibly longer lasting? According to one of the investigators of the SIREN study:
According to Crotty, hybrid immunity allows the body to create more diverse antibodies to neutralize a wider variety of variants. This also happens with full vaccination and a booster, but it happens much faster with infection followed by vaccination.
“Hybrid immunity has got a whole bunch of additional bonuses to it. One, that these studies are showing quite presently, is durability. Durability is quite robust,” Crotty said.
This makes intuitive sense, of course, although I always hasten to add that what is “intuitive” in science does not mean that it will turn out to be true. I will, however, point out that I really do not like one narrative that is coming from these studies, particularly the study that found enhanced immunity to other variants after breakthrough Omicron infection, that the Omicron variant could be “Mother Nature’s way of vaccinating the masses and curbing the pandemic, even going so far as to speculate that “omicron mimics these live attenuated vaccines because it causes milder infection and trains the body to trigger a strong immune response against the delta variant”. My response: Define “milder.”
And the beat goes on…
I started by asking whether “natural immunity” (a.k.a. postinfection immunity) was “better” than vaccine-induced immunity, which, it turns out, is the wrong question. Neither are “better”, but there are differences. Think of it this way. Given the risk of death and complications such as long COVID-19 and increasingly recognized cardiovascular complications from even mild disease, it is better not to get COVID-19. Thus, vaccination is preferable because it confers immunity without those potential risks and complications. However, contrary the narrative promoted by advocates of “natural herd immunity”, there’s nothing magical about “natural immunity”. It might or might not be more robust. It probably lasts longer, but, contrary to the magical properties ascribed to it those touting a “natural herd immunity” narrative, it is definitely not anywhere near lifelong, particularly against new variants, which means that “natural herd immunity” is almost certainly not achievable, although herd immunity might be achievable through a combination of vaccines and post-infection immunity. Moreover, if you have been unable to avoid getting COVID-19 and are fortunate enough to have recovered, it’s best to augment your “natural immunity” with vaccination because emerging evidence strongly suggests that hybrid immunity is the most robust immunity of all and helps protect more against new variants as well.
Contrary to the narrative being promoted by those who oppose vaccine mandates and advocate a “natural herd immunity approach”, no one in public health—and I mean no one—”denies natural immunity”. That part of the “natural immunity” narrative is one that I find profoundly insulting to physicians, scientists, public health officials, and vaccine advocates. It’s a massive straw man, which is why I’m going to quote this here:
We know how the immune system works. We know that you’ll probably produce some antibodies and will likely have some T cell memory after an infection. BUT. We also know that this response is variable. We don’t know how long your antibodies will last.
— Leah B. Gilliam, MD (@DrGRuralMD) November 14, 2021
There may be some difference in immune memory between those with mild infections and those who have been more seriously ill.
— Leah B. Gilliam, MD (@DrGRuralMD) November 14, 2021
We recognize it. But we also acknowledge the reality that it’s not absolute – and we’re ok with that because NOTHING in medicine is absolute. It makes sense that this wouldn’t be either.
— Leah B. Gilliam, MD (@DrGRuralMD) November 14, 2021
So please, if you’re reading this and you want to argue with a healthcare worker about whether or not these vaccines are necessary, come up with a better argument than “you need to recognize natural immunity!”
— Leah B. Gilliam, MD (@DrGRuralMD) November 14, 2021
Indeed, I would counter that the absolutists are the ones who tout post-infection “natural immunity” and “natural herd immunity” as being magically superior to vaccine-induced immunity to the point that it is the preferred way out of the pandemic, don’t recognize (or do their best to downplay) hybrid immunity, and minimize the harm and deaths that COVID-19 has caused—and continues to cause. In reality, scientists see nuance that the ideologues behind efforts of the GBD do not as they falsely portray their preferred solution and their contortions of science to justify it as “nuance” versus “vaccine absolutism”. They struggle to synthesize the flood of data—more often than we’d like, conflicting—into a science-based set of interventions that will minimize suffering and the loss of life and yet still be achievable without inflicting too much other harms. If that involves treating a prior COVID-19 infection like one course of vaccination (which might well be reasonable), so be it; contrary to how we are portrayed we are not dogmatically opposed to that. We merely want good evidence that this is a sound strategy in terms of minimizing the harm of the pandemic. In contrast, GBD proponents start from the idea that “lockdowns” do more damage than COVID-19 and, along with mask and vaccine mandates, are unacceptable assaults on individual freedom and then use motivated reasoning to find evidence to support their desired conclusion. Indeed, ask yourself why the same “anti-lockdowners” and antimaskers have aligned themselves with the antivaccine movement, given that no more powerful tool than the vaccines exists to implement an actual policy of “focused protection”.
As I’ve always said, we call it science-based medicine because medicine (and its related specialty public health) can never be purely science. Science can provide the parameters of what we can do by giving us interventions to combat the pandemic and telling us what the risk-benefit ratio of those interventions are, but in the end value judgments over the trade-offs involved are based on a given society’s values. Those behind the GBD have made it very clear what their values prioritize, and it’s definitely not the minimization of suffering and death. Unfortunately, they have also wielded outsized influence compared to their numbers, particularly among actual public health scientists.

“Natural Immunity” Stans Forget Babies Will Always be Vulnerable to COVID
Children are still getting hospitalized with COVID, no matter how many times contrarian doctors mindlessly repeat the mantra “natural immunity”. Doctors who know where babies come from understand why this might be.
Jonathan Howard on July 29, 2022
Link

In previous articles, I discussed several fallacious arguments against vaccinating young children. These include:
    • The vaccine was not studied in an unethical, impossible randomized-controlled trial of a million children. (Discussed here.)
    • Preventing babies from getting COVID will somehow undermine confidence in vaccines for other “more significant” diseases, even though these other disease have impacted children much less than COVID. (Discussed here.)
    • Though it is rare and nearly always mild, the vaccine can cause myocarditis in adolescents, not younger children. (Discussed here.)
Another nugget of sophistry
However, the arguments in favor letting babies get COVID contain many other nuggets of sophistry. Here’s what I’ll be discussing today.
Dr. Marty Makary:
The CDC reported reported that, as of February 2022, 75% of children 0-17 years-old already had COVID-19. Given how rampant the Omicron strain has circulated since then, upwards of 80-90% of children have likely had COVID-19. There is absolutely zero clinical evidence to support vaccinating healthy children who already had COVID. Natural immunity, inexplicably ignored by public health officials, confers strong protection against severe disease.
Dr. Tracy Hoeg:
With rates of severe disease now much lower in children than at the start of the pandemic—due to higher levels of natural immunity and lower rates of severe disease caused by omicron—trials would have needed to enroll hundreds of thousands of children, if not over a million, in order to detect a significant impact of the pediatric vaccine against severe disease.
Dr. Vinay Prasad:
Most kids already had COVID-19. CDC estimates 75% as of February, but this number is an underestimate, as millions have been infected since.
These doctors are right that many children have contracted COVID. In an ideal world, they’d reflect on how their failed predictions of “herd immunity by April” and relentless vaccine fear-mongering helped create this widespread “natural immunity” with all its consequences.
However, instead of showing a trace of humility, they remain dedicated to their perverse mission of ensuring unvaccinated children contract COVID. Though they have every right to bask in their success, they’re not content that just 80-90% of children have had the virus. Seeking to get that number as close to 100% as possible, they now protest there’s no evidence the vaccine will benefit children who’ve already had the disease. They are right. They also think they are making a clever argument. They are wrong.
More methodolatry
I previously stressed that doctors are right to take reasonable actions in the absence of pristine evidence from massive randomized-controlled trials, especially in the middle of a raging pandemic (here and here). Decisions must be made, and time is not an unlimited luxury, even though contrarian doctors portray it as such.
Immediately after the results from the adult mRNA vaccination trials were announced, there was no evidence they saved lives. Only one person died in these trials. However the vaccine was very effective at stopping SARS-CoV-2 infections (it’s obviously not this effective now), and the vaccine was approved on this basis. Reasonable people surmised that since the vaccine prevented SARS-CoV-2 infections, it would also stop people from dying of COVID.
Their embrace of the extremely obvious paid off. Countless lives were saved because we didn’t wait until we had evidence the vaccine saved lives before we started to use the vaccine to save lives. The same is true for the pediatric vaccine. Some children are alive today because of the vaccine, and many more were spared hospitalization. This would not be the case had we demanded RCTs of a million children.
Image credit Kareem Carr
Doctors have to make choices with incomplete information all the time, and repeatedly exposing unvaccinated children to the virus is absolutely a choice. While it’s true we don’t know everything about the vaccine, we also don’t know everything about the virus. There have been zero randomized-controlled trials of the virus after all.
Nonetheless, I fully agree that a toddler who had the sniffles with Omicron, as nearly all do, has little to fear from a reinfection in the short-term. I’m not knocking viral-induced immunity. In one study from England of nearly 700,000 children from Jan. 27, 2020, to July, 31, 2021, only 1 in 300 suffered a reinfection. While 2.4% of children with reinfections were hospitalized, the same as a first infection, no children died.
Though this is generally encouraging, the study ended before Omicron arrived, and its relevance to variants circulating today is unclear. Meanwhile, there is evidence that vaccination after infection can limit reinfections, at least for adults (here and here). It’s reasonable to assume that hybrid immunity will also benefit some children. While viral-induced immunity shouldn’t be denigrated, responsible doctors shouldn’t plagiarize Melanie’s Marvelous Measles with statements such as “Natural Immunity wins again“, especially because the study that supposedly gave “natural immunity” its victory concluded “A single dose of vaccine after infection reinforced protection against reinfection”.
Currently, there’s no evidence that a child who had COVID-19 in March 2020 will have lifelong immunity to all future variants, nor is there evidence that repeated exposures to the virus are safe for developing children. We have to be humble about the possibility of long-term consequences, and we don’t know if worse variants may be circulating in a few months time. There’s uncertainty about both the vaccine and the virus. Honest brokers admit this instead of wielding the misleading phrase “natural immunity” as a magical talisman that perfectly wards off all future harms.
There are obviously still vulnerable children out there
However, there’s a much bigger flaw in the argument that pediatric vaccines aren’t needed since most young children since have already had COVID. It overlooks something very obvious and very important things. You see, if 80-90% of children have had COVID already, that means 10-20% of children have not, and this translates to millions of children in the US. Doctors should embrace the opportunity protect all children from rare but severe outcomes with a simple vaccine.
According to the CDC, over 300 children are being hospitalized daily with COVID. Of course, contrarian doctors haven’t acknowledged such children before, and they’re not about to start now. Unwanted facts are unmentionable facts. However, that’s a lot of sick children, and it nearly matches the Delta peak of last year. While MIS-C has happily vanished with current variants, this may not be true in the future. Meanwhile, the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker keeps slowly increasing its grim pediatric death tally, which is now over 1,700 children. There are obviously still vulnerable children out there, no matter how many times sheltered doctors mindlessly repeat the mantra “natural immunity”.
Where are these vulnerable children coming from? In addition to rare reinfections and the millions of children who have not yet contracted COVID, it so happens that 8 million babies have been born in the US since the start of the pandemic. Newborns don’t arrive with “natural immunity”, and reasonable people want to keep it that way. Not only are there currently children who are still vulnerable to COVID, 10,000 more arrived today in the US alone. There were will always be vulnerable children. Allowing them to contract the virus to protect them from the virus makes as much sense as giving away all your money to protect yourself from thieves. It works, but…
Image credit xkcd.com
Though contrarian doctors seem unaware that 3.6 million children will be born this year in the US, regulators with skin in the game know where babies come from, and so they voted 21-0 to approve the vaccine for young children. As such, babies today will have an opportunity their older siblings lacked. If they can dodge the virus for 6-months and if their parents haven’t been fooled by anti-vaccine doctors, they can be vaccinated before they encounter the virus.
And here’s where it’s helpful to have some basic knowledge about vaccines and viruses. Prior to the vaccine, measles would rise and fall at predictable intervals as it infected a new crop of children. Given their interest in vaccines is both recent and shallow, I’d be shocked if contrarian doctors know this. I suspect – and hope – they’re entirely unaware their efforts could help recreate a similar situation for COVID, with all the suffering that entails. Given their complete lack of real-world responsibility for sick children, I am not optimistic about their potential for future enlightenment.
We all know the COVID vaccine isn’t as effective as the measles vaccine, but it’s far from useless, and updated vaccines will hopefully provide better protection. So why not try to do to COVID what we did to measles in the 1960s? Why should we sit back and watch as millions of children get COVID every year? Should we just do this year after year? What would have to happen for these doctors to change their minds and enthusiastically embrace vaccinating kids?
For some sheltered doctors, the answer is simply “It really doesn’t matter“. This is false. It really does matter.
Again, it only requires basic knowledge of this virus to understand why. It turns out that babies have by far the highest risk of dying of all children, though you could read every article by every contrarian doctor and not learn this simple fact. Like I said, unwanted facts are unmentionable facts.
So far, COVID has killed over 500 children under 5 years. That’s a tragically large number, and it’s higher every time I check it. Given the abysmal vaccination rates for young children, COVID will likely continue to kill an unacceptable number of children for the foreseeable future. Normal people think this is sad and are eager to try to prevent it. While death is the most severe outcome, it is not the only bad one, and the vaccine has been shown to limit pediatric hospitalizations in older children, even with the Omicron variant. While most children do well, some hospitalized children are very sick.
It’s true there’s currently no evidence the vaccine will prevent these rare, but tragic outcomes in young children. But based on how the vaccine has helped every other age group, there’s every reason to think it will help some babies and toddlers too. The argument against vaccinating children is that since severe disease is rare, there’s not really a point. The argument boils down to “the vaccine won’t help that many children”. I think that’s a horrible argument. I think doctors should strive to have zero children suffer or die for lack of a vaccine. This shouldn’t be controversial.

“We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April”: Reflections on a Failed Prediction
Surgical oncologist Dr. Marty Makary predicted in February that we would have herd immunity to COVID-19 in April. In late July now, it is clear that we do not, but Dr. Makary continues to make dubious and outright incorrect statements about COVID-19 on national platforms to which he has access. Why can’t he just admit that his prediction had been in error?
Jonathan Howard on July 25, 2021
Link
A prelude: “Where is the humility in our public health officials to simply say we were wrong?”
On May 25th 2021, The New York Times published an article that criticized the CDC for saying that “less than 10 percent” of Covid-19 transmission occurred outdoors. It correctly said that “Saying that less than 10 percent of Covid transmission occurs outdoors is akin to saying that sharks attack fewer than 20,000 swimmers a year. (The actual worldwide number is around 150.) It’s both true and deceiving.”
This article caught the eye of Dr. Marty Makary a professor of surgery at Johns Hopkins University. Dr. Makary has been discussed on this blog before, in particular his dubious claim that medical errors were the third leading cause of death in the US. Dr. Makary reacted to The New York Times article by reasonably asking on Twitter:
It’s a fair question.
“Covid-19 will be mostly gone by April.”
With this is mind, it is worth revisiting another claim of Dr. Makary’s. In an article from February 18th 2021 titled “We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April,” Dr. Makary predicted that “Covid-19 will be mostly gone by April.” He felt that due to widespread immunity, from both the virus and vaccines, “there may be very little Covid-19 by April”. Many scientists found the article flawed at the time and debate ensued. Time would tell who was right and who was wrong.
Herd immunity 101
An article from Dr. Makary’s university described herd immunity thusly: “When most of a population is immune to an infectious disease, this provides indirect protection—or population immunity (also called herd immunity or herd protection)—to those who are not immune to the disease”. The article gave examples of measles, mumps, polio, and chickenpox as diseases for which herd immunity exists in the US, while noting that outbreaks can still occur in pockets of unvaccinated people, as occurred with measles during an outbreak in Disney World in 2019.
Herd immunity depends on both the virus and the population. A more contagious virus will have a higher herd immunity threshold. The chances of achieving herd immunity increases with every person who becomes immune, either through the virus or a vaccine. People’s behavior also matters. A community where choirs gather in a small, poorly ventilated rooms will have a higher herd immunity threshold than a village of isolated hermits. In the words of Dr. James Hamblin, “if we all sealed ourselves in isolation pods today,” COVID-19 could not spread and “there would be no more deaths.” Few of us are hermits though, so widespread immunity in the population, hopefully via the vaccine, is our only way out of this mess.
Importantly, herd immunity is often a highly local phenomenon. One neighborhood may have herd immunity while another may not. Outbreaks can occur in highly vaccinated populations if unvaccinated people cluster together, as they often do. There was a measles outbreak in New York in 2019 that clustered over a few neighborhoods where parents had not vaccinated their children. The rest of the city was spared.
The notion of herd immunity arriving to an entire country of 330 million people, as Dr. Makary suggested would happen in April, is largely fantastical for the foreseeable future. We’ll know the US has reached herd immunity for COVID-19 when there are sporadic, limited outbreaks here and there, but there is no sustained transmission of the disease, as is currently the case for measles and chickenpox.
“The concept of herd immunity was one that got misinterpreted as eradication”
Soon April came and went. Dear reader, I have some sad news. The US did not reach herd immunity to COVID-19 in April. On April 1st, there were over 65,000 COVID-19 cases, on April 16th, there were over 78,000 cases, and on April 30th, there were over 50,500 cases. Well over 1.5 million Americans were infected with COVID-19 in April, reflecting sustained transmission of the virus.
At this point, Dr. Makary had a choice:
So @MartyMakary has a choice. He can say “I was wrong” and ideally do so in another @WSJopinion piece. I am not suggesting he abase himself- just write a piece setting the record straight and considering why his prediction was odd. 3/n
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) April 1, 2021
He could admit herd immunity had not arrived to the US or he could claim it had. Dr. Makary chose to claim the US had reached herd immunity. In an article from June 8th, he wrote that “The news about the U.S. Covid pandemic is even better than you’ve heard”. He then said:
With more than 8 in 10 adults protected from either contracting or transmitting the virus, it can’t readily propagate by jumping around in the population. In public health, we call that herd immunity, defined broadly on the Johns Hopkins Covid information webpage as “when most of a population is immune.” It’s not eradication, but it’s powerful.
According to Dr. Makary, there was no problem with his prediction of herd immunity in April. Rather, everyone else failed understand the concept. As he put it in an interview, “the concept of herd immunity was one that got misinterpreted as eradication”.
Herd immunity has not arrived in the US
Unfortunately, the virus did not read Dr. Makary’s article, and it doesn’t know that “it can’t readily propagate by jumping around in the population”. In fact, according to The New York Times, as of July 23rd, cases have increased 173% in the past two weeks and cases are on the rise in all 50 states. There were 81,732 cases on July 23rd. Not once during the summer of 2020 did this many people contract COVID-19. According to one report, “91 million people, live in a county considered to have ‘high’ Covid-19 transmission, according to data from the CDC”. Florida is leading the way with an average of 10,000 cases per day. Los Angeles, which Dr. Makary singled out as a success story to demonstrate herd immunity had arrived, had 10,000 new cases last week. According to one news report, “The county reported a 20-fold increase in new cases over the previous month, according to the public health department.”
I never thought herd immunity was around the corner, but we seem to be in much worse shape than I thought we’d be just six weeks ago.  At that time I wrote, “Barring a nasty variant, the worst is over for America and its children.”  Sadly, a nasty variant arrived, and I now fear the worst may be yet to come for children in America.
Perhaps Dr. Makary is right, and I am confusing the concept of herd immunity with eradication. But cases rising 173% over the past two weeks does not seem consistent with a country that has enough immunity that the non-immune are protected. If there was enough immunity for that kind of protection, how could cases have risen by 173%? Tens of thousands of people are still getting COVID-19 every day. This number doesn’t disturb us as much as it should because we compare it to the hundreds of thousands of Americans who contacted the virus daily this winter.
“We need to move on at some point”
We will likely never completely eradicate COVID-19, but we are getting a bit closer every day as hundreds of thousands of Americans gain immunity. Happily, many more people are gaining immunity via the vaccine than via the virus. Just because I acknowledge the obvious fact that herd immunity has not arrived for the US, I am not obligated to take a pessimistic view of America’s future. Dr. Makary is right that most adults in America are immune to COVID-19. We will almost certainly never have months in a row where over 1,000 Americans die daily. Again with the caveat that a nasty variant could change everything, I am confident the worst is over for the US as a whole, at least for vaccinated people.
But it’s not entirely over, and the trends are not encouraging. Currently, decreasing numbers of people are gaining immunity via the vaccine and increasing numbers of people are gaining immunity via the virus. Many parts of the country are having worse outbreaks than they did in 2020. The stories coming out from places such as Arkansas and Missouri are heartbreaking, especially since many children and young adults are getting really sick, an avoidable fate for those 12 years and older.
As with cases, hospitalization and deaths are also increasing. Hospitalizations have increased 57% and deaths have increased 20% over the past two weeks. 271 Americans are dying every day of COVID-19. Again, I think this number seems small only because we compare it to the horror of this winter. There’s no expectation that this will change for the better in the immediate future. Some disease models are forecasting it will get much worse in a few months, actually. Hopefully this is wrong.
However, tens of millions of Americans remain vulnerable, and though the reasons are varied, many of them won’t be vaccinated it seems. Eventually, I believe almost every American will gain some form of immunity to COVID-19. This is probably true for most people in the world, actually. Hopefully most people will get immunity via the vaccine. Unfortunately, vaccinations rates remain very low in large swaths of the country, and this is unlikely to change.
In 2019, measles outbreaks impacting just over 1,000 people none of whom died were rightly considered unacceptable. I remember in 2015 when the death of one woman from measles was a big deal. Now, 270 people are dying an easily-preventable death every day. Many thousands more are hospitalized. COVID-19 has drastically changed our perception of how much death and suffering we find acceptable. This is especially the case considering that almost none of this would be happening now if every eligible American had been vaccinated. Indeed, the news is full of people regretting their decision not to get vaccinated.
I realize that some people still have significant barriers to getting vaccinated, but I don’t think we’ve really appreciated the stunning body count that is the direct responsibility of the anti-vaccine movement today. Anti-vaxxers recently harassed a cancer patient for wearing a mask. There is something deeply broken in our country. Dr. Makary did acknowledge that people “need to be careful if they’re unvaccinated and not had the infection” but he followed this by saying “we need to move on at some point”.
This raises an interesting question. As Dr. Makary thinks the US has reached herd immunity and we need to “move on,” why is he still talking about COVID-19? This question also applies to other doctors who have begged others to stop talking about the pandemic and said it was “essentially done“. Some doctors have an unfortunate habit of declaring herd immunity was at hand in places (India, California, India again) that had large surges (India, California) shortly thereafter. Every editorial they write, every interview they give, and every tweet they send on COVID-19 is a tacit admission they were wrong, and the pandemic is not over. If doctors feel the pandemic is largely over for COVID-19 and that we need to “move on” and stop talking about it, shouldn’t they lead by example?
“I am not aware of a single healthy child in the US who has died of COVID-19 to date.”
It’s a tragedy how much vaccine is sitting unused in American refrigerators, but it’s understandable to a degree. Many young, unvaccinated Americans and their parents likely believe herd immunity has already arrived in the US. They too believe it’s time to “move on.” Many young people also likely believe the disease holds “almost no risk” for someone like them. I know where they got these ideas. Smart doctors with stellar academic credentials told it to them.
For example, in an article written June 10th 2021 titled “Think Twice Before Giving the COVID Vax to Healthy Kids”, Dr. Makary wrote:
In reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date.
As evidence for his extraordinary claim that no healthy children died of COVID-19 in the US, he referenced his own paper and claimed it was a study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths”.
He said this paper found that “100% of pediatric COVID-19 deaths were in children with a pre-existing condition”. In another editorial titled “The Flimsy Evidence Behind the CDC’s Push to Vaccinate Children”, he suggested that pediatric death tallies may be inflated. He again touted his paper, saying it examined “approximately 48,000 children under 18 diagnosed with Covid” and that “Our report found a mortality rate of zero among children without a pre-existing medical condition such as leukemia.” “If that trend holds, it has significant implications for healthy kids and whether they need two vaccine doses,” he continued.
Dr. Makary’s report, was titled “Risk Factors for COVID-19 Mortality among Privately Insured Patients: A Claims Data Analysis”. It was published as a “white paper,” not in a medical journal. Though he claimed it was a study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths”, the words “child,” “children,” and “pediatrics” do not appear in the paper, though there is a discussion of Alzheimer’s disease in relation to COVID-19.
The paper reported on 2,753 people who died of COVID-19 from April 1, 2020, through August 31, 2020. Of these, 0.11% deaths occurred in children under 18-years. This means his supposed study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths” reported on just three deceased children.   He has mentioned this paper in at least three editorials thus far, which equals the number of deceased children it contained.
Dr. Makary’s claim that every American child who died of COVID-19 had a pre-existing condition was based on a paper that ended in August 2020 where just three children died and his own inability to find examples of healthy children who died. The “trend” he says has “significant implications” for vaccine policy was based on less than 1% of the total pediatric deaths and cases as of today. Though Dr. Makary castigated the CDC by writing, “I can think of no journal editor who would accept the claim that 335 deaths resulted from a virus without data to indicate if the virus was incidental or causal, and without an analysis of relevant risk factors such as obesity,” his paper doesn’t meet this standard. It presented no data about the three deceased children beyond noting they were under age 18 years and had some underlying condition.
It’s great that no healthy children died of COVID-19 in his paper.  But it does not follow that all the children who died of COVID-19 therefore had underlying disabilities. The only conclusion one can possibly draw from this paper is that children are much less likely to die if they contract COVID-19 than adults, but we knew that by November 2020 when it was published. The paper says nothing about the characteristics of children who died from COVID-19. To learn about this population, we would need to study the 99.4% of deceased children that were not covered in his paper. Dr. Makary does not mention in his editorials that his paper included just three deceased children. I wonder why this is.
If we pretend that meaningful information about pediatric mortality could be gleaned from a paper with just three deceased children, we’d realize it found a relatively high mortality rate. It examined 467,773 patients diagnosed with COVID-19 and 6.61%, (31,000 patients) were under age 18 years. (I do not know why Dr. Makary claimed in an editorial that it studied “approximately 48,000 children.”) As three children died, this means about 1 in 10,000 children died, a much higher rate than reported elsewhere. As there are 73 million children in the US, this death rate would mean that over 7,000 children would die if the virus were allowed to spread unchecked throughout the pediatric population. This would easily make COVID-19 one of the leading causes of death for American children. As they say, “big, if true.” Yet, to my knowledge, Dr. Makary has not commented on this particular “trend” his paper uncovered. I wonder why this is.
I am aware of healthy children in the US who have died of COVID-19
Like Dr. Makary, I too reviewed the medical literature and news reports. I found different results. According to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, 498 children 17 years or younger years have died of COVID-19 in the US. This number was derived from an analysis of 83% of the total number of COVID-19 deaths, so the actual number of pediatric deaths is certainly a bit higher than this.
Moreover, a simple Google search returned an article titled “Parents Say 5-Year-Old Daughter Who Died From COVID-19 was ‘Perfectly Healthy'” and another titled “4-Year-Old CNY Boy Who Died of Covid Complications Had Been Healthy: ‘I Lost My Miracle Baby.'” I read about a child from Minnesota in an article titled “Child Under 10 With No Underlying Conditions Dies From COVID.” A 9-month-old who “did not have an underlying health condition” also died in Minnesota. I read about a child “with no underlying conditions” who died in Tennessee and a 7-year-old from Georgia who “had no underlying health conditions.” Kimora Lynum, a 9-year-old with “no underlying conditions” died in my hometown, Gainesville, Florida. Skylar Herbert, a 5 year-old from Detroit also had “no underlying health conditions” when she died of COVID-19. I read about Dykota Morgan, a 15-year-old girl from Illinois, “whose parents said she had no underlying medical conditions.” She was a basketball player who died just two days after contracting the virus.
Even though my quick Google search yielded triple the number of data points as Dr. Makary’s paper, I am well aware that the only conclusion that can be drawn from such a small sample size is that Dr. Makary is wrong – some healthy children have died of COVID-19. Dr. Makary’s supposed “trend” of no healthy children dying of COVID-19 didn’t hold up, sadly.  Each of these deaths is a tragedy, and I encourage you to read about a few of these children. Even though healthy children rarely die of COVID-19, it’s important to remember there are real lives behind the numbers. As CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky said, “Children are not supposed to die”.
More formal evidence exists that healthy children can die of COVID-19 is readily available. In September 2020 the CDC reported on 121 deaths of people younger than 21 years, half of whom were younger than 18 years. It found that “Among the 121 decedents, 30 (25%) were previously healthy (no reported underlying medical condition).” Presumably at least one of these 30 deaths was in someone younger than 18 years. Although I would like to see updated numbers, there’s no reason to think that they would be substantially different than these 121 cases. Dr. Makary is either unaware of this study or inexplicably chose to omit it from his editorials. In fact, he wrote a whole editorial in a major American newspaper largely predicated on his belief that this CDC analysis did not exist.
To be clear, I fully agree that healthy children dying of COVID-19 is an exceptionally rare occurrence. It is so rare that these tragedies often make the news. The overwhelming majority of children who contract COVID-19 will be just fine, thankfully. About 500 children have died of COVID-19 and over 26 million have been infected, according to CDC estimates. This means that only about 1 child in 50,000 who contracts COVID-19 will die, and the risk for healthy children is lower than this.
But there is some risk of a devastating outcome, for even healthy children, and these low-risk events multiplied many millions of times add up to non-trivial numbers. At least I feel that way. As around 25% of deaths are in healthy children, this means COVID-19 has killed about 125 healthy children so far. Tens of millions of children remain vulnerable, and more healthy children will certainly die moving forward, including some who are currently eligible for the vaccine.
Though Dr. Makary has not minimized the dangers to children with underlying medical conditions, many others ignore these children too. I’ve read multiple essays on COVID-19 and children that don’t even mention that children can die of COVID-19. Instead, they only describe severe harms to children as “very rare”. Often on social media it seems as if children with medical co-morbidities don’t really matter.  But as obesity and asthma are the most common underlying condition in children who die of COVID-19, most deceased children were robbed of many decades of life.  Even the vast majority children with leukemia, which Dr. Makary gave as an example of an underlying condition, are expected to be alive five years from now.
Of course, the death of a vulnerable child is just as tragic as the death of a healthy child. This is too often forgotten, as is the fact that these vulnerable children can be further protected when their healthy classmates are vaccinated.  Again, children are not supposed to die,
Death is not the only bad outcome from COVID-19
In one of his editorials on the vaccine, Dr. Makary said “A tremendous number of government and private policies affecting kids are based on one number”, the number of children who have died of COVID-19. While death is clearly the worst outcome of COVID-19, it is not the only bad outcome, and Dr. Makary is wrong that policies are based solely on the number of deceased children.
The CDC was quite explicit that preventing hospitalizations was a driving force behind vaccinating adolescents. As they put it, “The benefits (prevention of COVID-19 disease and associated hospitalizations, ICU admissions, and deaths) outweighed the risks (expected myocarditis cases after vaccination) in all populations for which vaccination has been recommended”. They even calculated exactly how many cases and hospital/ICU admissions they expected the vaccine would prevent and put this on widely-viewed slides.
Readers of Dr. Makary’s editorial won’t know any of this, of course.  Dr. Makary’s incorrect claim that vaccine policies are based on just one number opens his editorial, and the rest proceeds in a similar fashion.
Many children have been hospitalized with COVID-19. Even accounting for over-counting due to incidental COVID-19 cases, tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized. A non-trivial number of these children are very sick, intubated in the ICU.  A very small number of children have been devastated by the virus.  One 17-year-old needed a double lung transplant, while a 10-year-old had his hands and feet amputated.  Strokes have also been reported in children due to COVID-19.  These children survived, thankfully, but they suffered tremendously, and their lives have been permanently altered.  Those of us who favor vaccination in adolescents expect the vaccine will prevent these tragedies as well as save lives.
There are warnings the next few months could be very difficult for the vast majority of children who are unvaccinated.  According to one doctor in Arkansas, half of the children currently hospitalized with COVID-19 are “old enough to be vaccinated but have not received the vaccine yet”.  He said these adolescents are “the ones that are in the ICU that have COVID-pneumonia and are requiring significant support”. He also said that hospitalization rates are increasing, and incidental COVID-19 diagnoses are now uncommon.  Additionally, there may be long-term consequences we cannot currently appreciate. Articles that suggest healthy children should not be vaccinated against COVID-19 rarely mention any of this, even as they invariably mention the shorter, less frequent hospitalizations caused by vaccine-induced myocarditis.
To his credit, in one of his editorials, Dr. Makary did acknowledge multisystem inflammatory syndrome (MIS-C) and its complications, including death in some children. Surprisingly, many articles on children and COVID-19 omit this devastating entity. Dr. Makary noted that no cases of MIS-C were reported to the CDC the week he wrote his editorial. At that time, he reported 4,018 children had the disease. Eighteen days later the CDC reported 4,196 MIS-C cases, though this may be a substantial undercount of the total cases. So, 178 cases of MIS-C were added to the tally less than three weeks after Dr. Makary wrote his article. Most children with MIS-C go to the ICU and many need to be intubated. These children are very sick, and MIS-C can affect children without underlying conditions.
People who declare some bad aspect of the pandemic over because metrics are good at that moment remind me of Senator Jim Inhofe, who famously brought a snowball to Congress to refute climate change. Because it was cold that day, he reasoned, climate change must be a hoax. COVID-19 will ebb and flow as viruses always do, but it won’t vanish, and we must not be too careful to predict its future by looking at a small snapshot of time. If unvaccinated people wish to avoid the virus, they will not just have to do so not just this week or this fall, but for the rest of their lives. I think the Delta variant will make that very difficult to do for all but the most isolated people. As recently as May, UK health ministers were predicting COVID-19 would be gone there by August. I thought it was possible too. Now cases are surging there even before they fully opened up. This is all due to the Delta variant, which accounts for 83% of new cases in the US.
It is reasonable to expect a doctor with a large platform to be accurate and thorough when engaging with the public about children and a deadly virus
The CDC report and the articles of healthy children dying of COVID-19 were all written before Dr. Makary’s June 10th editorial where he said he was “not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date”. If I found these articles in 10 seconds, he could have as well. In fact, two of these articles appear just below his article if you Google “healthy child died covid” as I did. Perhaps he knows something I don’t about these cases. Perhaps the CDC and news reports are all wrong. Perhaps all of these children were found to have underlying medical problems after all. It’s possible. If so, Dr. Makary should publish his findings. If not one “single healthy child” died from the virus in the US that would be important to know.
Presently however, it seems that Dr. Makary, a professor at a top medical school who claims to have reviewed “the medical literature and news reports”, actually didn’t bother to do the most basic fact-checking when he claimed no healthy American child had died of COVID-19. He referenced his own “study”, where just three children died, to claim that no healthy child in all of American has died of COVID-19. He lambasted the CDC for not providing information on deceased children when it had done so several months prior. This is in contrast to his “study,” which gave no such information. He did this all in widely read articles meant for the general public. It may seem that I am nitpicking, but this is a big deal to me.  This includes earlier this month when Dr. Makary favorably tweeted out a study that purportedly showed that masks harm children. The study was written by literal anti-vaxxers and was laughably bad, as many people pointed out to him. It has since been retracted, but not before Dr. Makary and others helped spread it far and wide.
There are real-world consequences to spreading wrong information to the public.  With help from other doctors who also didn’t bother the fact-check the claim, the notion that healthy children don’t die of COVID-19 seems poised to become a medical myth on par with the old trope that we only use 10% of our brains. Indeed, anti-vaxx propagandist Tucker Carlson repeated Dr. Makary’s claim verbatim on his program. Misinformed politicians have also repeated this false claim as if it were established fact during congressional hearings. Unfortunately, this is not the first time I’ve written about the consequences when supposed proponents of evidence-based medicine make claims that are not just without evidence, but in direct contradiction to readily available evidence. It is reasonable to expect a doctor with a large platform to be accurate and thorough when engaging with the public about children and a deadly virus.
So, why can’t some people simply say they were wrong?
I’ve written previously of the highly credentialed academics and QAnon fanatics/right-wing politicians (there’s sometimes no difference), whose minimization of COVID-19 and fear mongering about the vaccine has led us to a point where hundreds of Americans are dying a preventable death every day. In these essays, along with Dr. Makary, I too have wondered why some people readily admit error while others tie themselves in knots to avoid doing so.
Infectious-disease expert Dr. Paul Offit, for example, predicted on March 2nd, 2020 that COVID-19 would cause less than “one-tenth of the damage that influenza causes every year in the United States”. He later acknowledged his error saying, “If you’re going to be wrong, be wrong in front of millions of people. Make a complete ass of yourself”. I trust him completely as does everyone else I know and admire. Former Surgeon General Dr. Jerome Adams recently acknowledged his early advice not to wear masks was wrong. I too have acknowledged errors. This wasn’t fun, but it wasn’t particularly hard either. I’ll do it again when I have to. I deserve no special credit for this. We all make mistakes and acknowledging them doesn’t require self flagellation.
So, why can’t some people simply say they were wrong? I have no idea. However, Dr. Makary seems to be in the perfect position to answer to his own question.

“Their Plan is Incongruent With My Existence”
The authors of the Great Barrington Declaration never asked “vulnerable” people if they were on board with their plan to lock them down for month on end, with no backup plan if herd immunity never arrived. They just wanted to impose their will on tens of millions of vulnerable Americans whether they wanted it or not.
Jonathan Howard on June 2, 2023
Link

The Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was premised on the fiction that death was the only bad outcome from COVID, that one infection meant permanent immunity, and that “vulnerable” people could both be easily identified and completely walled off from “not vulnerable” people in a short period of time. With this gargantuan task accomplished, “vulnerable” people would be sealed in a bubble of zero COVID while “not vulnerable” people would live in a world of pure COVID. Once hundreds of millions of unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans were infected, herd immunity would arrive, and “vulnerable” people could emerge from their hibernation. Spreading the virus would eliminate the virus, and the pandemic would be “naturally over“ in just 3-6 months.
What could possibly go wrong?
Obviously, the pandemic curtailed everyone’s life drastically. However, in the real world, when communities made good faith efforts to control the virus, many vulnerable people were able to go shopping, see their doctor, and even protest COVID restrictions without a certainty they’d be exposed to the virus at every step along their journey. This was all incomparable with the GBD.  In their vision, anytime “vulnerable” people left their involuntary cocoon they’d be immersed in the virus.  Every trip to Not Vulnerableland would be a potential death sentence.  Remember, no “vulnerable” people were vaccinated when the GBD was published either.
This is what could possibly go wrong.
Though they might not always be visible, “vulnerable” people are everywhere and they interact with “not vulnerable” people all the time. Indeed, many “vulnerable” people depend on “not vulnerable” people to meet their basic needs. The GBD’s authors never sought input from “vulnerable” people, though they were influenced by a man who has advocated for child labor and child smoking, while writing for a racist organization called League of the South.
You can’t make this stuff up.
Since the GBD never acknowledged the voices of the people they wanted to lock down, I’ll introduce you to disability-advocate Beatrice Adler-Bolton. She told me:
Their plan immediately tells me that they don’t know a lot of vulnerable people, and they (incorrectly) assume all vulnerable people somehow live out of society and do not work or go to school, or share households with people who work or go to school. The non-workability of a plan like “focused protection” is immediately obvious to people who are vulnerable. We do not all live on a little island together, we do not all live in nursing homes, long term care facilities, and hospitals.
We are all over the place and the GBD’s plan not only clearly was ignorant of this: if it wasn’t then it expects the vulnerable constantly disclose their vulnerability and that broad *collective* interventions like universal masking and vaccination be implemented in every single community that the vulnerable live in to accommodate their status…and spoiler alert that means every community when COVID is circulating in the air we all share.
It turns out, that not all “vulnerable” people were on board with the GBD’s plan to effectively place them under house arrest.  Another voice ignored by the GBD, Abby Mahler, a young person with lupus who corrects misinformation about hydroxychloroquine told me about her experience this pandemic.  They said:
It has been a nightmare. My entire life has changed; I had to find new employment – leaving behind networks hard built – as well as forgo decades old family traditions, friendships, & medical maintenance for my existing chronic illnesses. Their plan is incongruent with my existence.
The authors of the GBD never asked “vulnerable” people if they were on board with their plan to turn them into shut-ins for months on end, with no backup plan if herd immunity never arrived.
They just wanted to impose their will on tens of millions of vulnerable Americans whether they wanted it or not.

Deaths and Excess Deaths in Brazil
By misinterpreting excess mortality statistics, Nobel Laureate Michael Levitt minimizes the significance of the COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil (and also America).
Ariel Karlinsky on April 23, 2021
Link

[Editor’s note: Today we introduce a new guest poster discussing some issues with excess mortality calculations in Brazil, Ariel Karlinsky. Welcome!]
If you follow the news, you probably heard that the COVID-19 situation in Brazil is dire, with cases and deaths on a sharp upward trajectory.
Could this be pure scare-mongering? Informing us only of the number of COVID-19 deaths daily – much like if they would inform us of the daily number of people who died from traffic accidents, cancer or even the flu – the numbers would be even higher! This is the byline promoted by many, including persons much more distinguished than I, such as Chemistry Nobel Laureate Michael Levitt. Levitt is one of the key people in denial of, or more politely “minimization” of, COVID-19 and its effects. He has downplayed the significance of the pandemic for over a year. His claims regarding the COVID situation have included things like:
     1.  In mid-March 2020, he said “I’ll be surprised if more than 10 Israelis will die of COVID”. Current reported COVID deaths in Israel are over 6,300.
     2.  In July 2020, he said “COVID19 will be done in 4 weeks with total reported deaths below 170,000”. Current reported COVID deaths in the US are over 560,000.
But what is really happening?
The importance of excess mortality
There’s a very-well-established metric (dating back to the 19th century, at least! [PDF]) that can demonstrate the impact of COVID-19 on a population. It’s called “excess mortality”: the number of deaths over and above those expected in a certain country or area during a week, month, quarter, or year. It is incredibly easy to predict the expected number of deaths; in a sense, it behaves like the weather – winters are colder (and deadlier) than summers. There’s variation and some trend, but you can bet that August in Miami, Florida is going to be nice and sunny. Based on the expected weather for a time period, we can identify when an event is a significant outlier – like when the temperature in Miami drops below freezing in the middle of August.
Levitt attempted to estimate the increase in deaths in 2020 in Brazil and found that it was “…7%… same as EuroMOMO (7.5%) & half USA (13.2%)… Pity newspapers are not a bit smarter…”.
Just 60 min of Excel, the results are gratifying.
All-cause death in Brazil is increasing by 90,000 per year. When accounted for, the excess death in 2020 is 94,000 or 7% of natural death. Same as EuroMOMO (7.5%) & half USA (13.2%).
Pity newspapers are not a bit smarter… https://t.co/xxlc39deS4 pic.twitter.com/s7blCRTZiX
— Michael Levitt (@MLevitt_NP2013) April 11, 2021
There are several glaring flaws in Levitt’s analysis that I will detail below. In short, I can tell you that 2020 deaths in Brazil are 17.5% higher than expected (with Levitt’s own method) and that deaths from March 2020 to March 2021 are 26.7% higher.
What Levitt gets wrong in Brazil
Wrong data for 2015 to 2019
First and foremost, Levitt uses a very incomplete data source for deaths in Brazil – the automatic reports published by the Civil Registry. The CR is part of an ongoing reform in many Latin American countries to modernize its system to track vital events (such as births, marriages, and deaths). Since it was introduced pretty recently, it suffered from a severe under-registration in its first years. For example, total deaths in 2015 were registered at 905,549. Just 5 years later in 2019, it registered 1.266 million deaths – a horrifying 40% (!) increase with no extreme events or reasons to justify it. When the numbers are “too good to be true”, maybe it’s because they are. This difference is not due to a natural increase or variation in annual deaths, but an artificial spike caused by an increase in coverage and registration.
Had Levitt looked around a bit, he would have found official deaths reports by the Brazilian Ministry of Health (also known as SUS or SIM), which shows higher, but more plausible, numbers compared to every year available for the CR (1.264 million deaths in 2015, 1.349 million deaths in 2019).
Using the CR data source throughout, Levitt estimates a linear trend on 5 annual data points and obtains an extremely upward-biased prediction for 2020 (“an increase of 90K per year”) of 1.361 million deaths. Subtracting that expectation from the CR figure for 2020 of 1.454 million deaths, he obtains this “7% increase”.
It should be noted that a 7% yearly increase in mortality is HUGE. It does not happen regularly. Annual deaths usually vary by no more than a couple of percentage points or fractions thereof.
Wrong data for 2020
Deaths registration in the CR has picked up in 2020, but it is still highly incomplete. The CR figure for number of deaths in May 2020 is 132,240, while the latest data released by the Brazilian Ministry of Health shows May 2020 to be at 154,135.
The CR has its uses however, as it is currently the only “real-time” publicly-available death registration mechanism in Brazil, where the number of deaths reported is updated daily. While SIM has data only up to May 2020, the CR already has info for March 2021.
My colleague Dmitry Kobak and I, with the help of Brazilian researchers Marcelo Oliveira and Otavio Ranzani, have integrated both of these data sources as part of our international all-cause mortality dataset World Mortality. We use the ratio between total deaths reported in SIM to those reported in CR from January to May 2020 (1.1). This allows us to have very up-to-date figures, while also correcting for the under-registration which exists in the CR even in 2020.1
Combining these two sources, our estimated total deaths in Brazil in 2020 stand at 1.603 million. Since the actual, final, published figures for 2015-2019 are much higher than those in the CR, the yearly trend between them is much smaller (17.8k per year) and using Levitt’s own method – 2020 is 17.5% higher than expected.
Why so annual?
In ordinary times, we are used to thinking and operating in useful time frames – a day, a month, a year. In ordinary times, researchers mostly care for annual number of deaths. COVID-19 cares not for our ways and did not start in Brazil on January 1st 2020, and did not end on December 31st. When we look at the number of deaths in Brazil from 2015 to 2021 by month, we can see that 2020 starts as quite a normal year, with deaths in January and February very much in line with previous years and our prediction (based on the monthly average for seasonality with the addition of a yearly trend). In March, the death count in 2020 started rising, a gap between expected deaths began to form, and it has not closed since.
Moreover, in 2021 – this gap increases. Deaths in January and February 2021 are far above expectation, with deaths in March 2021 – one year since SARS-CoV-2 began to spread in Brazil – crossing 203,000 persons. This monthly figure is 80% above expectation.
When we sum excess deaths since COVID-19 started in Brazil to our latest data point of March 2021, we arrive at slightly more than 395,000 EXCESS deaths. This is 26.7% above expected.
These excess deaths go in tandem with reported COVID-19 deaths, but are slightly higher. These excess deaths are no doubt caused by SARS-CoV-2, as it spreads more and more in the country, leading to more cases, and deaths, due to COVID-19.
Levitt’s mishandling of excess deaths in America
This is not the first time Levitt has failed to perform even minimal vetting of data he uses to downplay the extent of the harm done by COVID-19. Several times, he has used weekly CDC all-cause mortality data in the US to claim that the pandemic is over:
US COVID19 will be done in 4 weeks with a total reported death below 170,000. How will we know it is over? Like for Europe, when all cause excess deaths are at normal level for week. Reported COVID19 deaths may continue after 25 Aug. & reported cases will, but it will be over. https://t.co/lnpxZ3bHIy
— Michael Levitt (@MLevitt_NP2013) July 25, 2020
The reality is that the US has been in a state of significant excess mortality since mid-March of 2020:
So how did Levitt see “deaths coming back to baseline” during 2020? He used incomplete data. The CDC continuously reports deaths during weeks and includes a small indication that data for certain weeks is incomplete. Even without seeing this, it shouldn’t be hard to miss – when weekly deaths during a pandemic fall to less than the minimal weekly deaths since 2015, the best course of action is to WAIT and see if this is true, or just a mirage created by delayed registration of real-time data.
Conclusion: Properly reported excess deaths show the truth
In conclusion, in Brazil, America, and many other countries around the world (our detailed analysis of excess mortality in 89 countries and territories is available here), the appropriate use of excess death statistics show the clear impact of COVID-19. Excess mortality is much higher in both nations than Levitt claimed and they go hand-in-hand with COVID-19 deaths.

1 We believe the 1.1 ratio is a lower-bound estimate for under-registration in RC, as evident by the ratio in May 2020 which stands at 1.16 and by the SIM data itself being preliminary.

The COVID-as-bacterial-pneumonia conspiracy theory rises again
In yet another example of everything hold being new again, antivaxxers have resurrected the claim that deaths due to COVID-19 are actually due to bacterial pneumonia, just as antivaxxers used to say the same thing about influenza deaths. It is, of course, another case of confusing cause and effect in order to obfuscate.
David Gorski on September 4, 2023
Link

To antivaccine conspiracy theorists, it is always of the utmost importance to find a way to explain deaths from the pathogens that cause vaccine-preventable diseases as somehow not being due to that pathogen. The reason is simple. If antivaxxers can spin a convincing-sounding narrative claiming that a specific pathogen isn’t causing disease and death that can be prevented by vaccines targeted against that pathogen, then they can add to that narrative the claim that the vaccine doesn’t work (because it’s not targeting the “true” cause of the disease and death) and is therefore unnecessary. Add to that claims that the vaccine is dangerous, and they can spin a narrative that seems compelling if you don’t know a lot about infectious disease. For COVID-19, we saw this narrative in the form of conspiracy theories falsely claiming that death certificates were misattributing deaths during the pandemic as being due to COVID-19 when they supposedly were not, leading to false claims that people were dying “with COVID-19” and “not of COVID-19” or that “only” 6% of deaths attributed to COVID-19 were actually caused by COVID-19. That latter lie was based figures showing that 94% of COVID-19 death certificates had multiple contributing factors but also involved conflating sequelae of COVID-19 infection that ultimately led to death with primary causes of death. As I like to say, everybody dies of cardiac arrest. Whatever ultimately kills you, your proximate cause of death will be cardiac arrest. That’s a trivial observation. The far more important thing to know is: What caused the cascade of events that led to your cardiac arrest and death.
Antivaxxers are still doing it, as I noticed over the weekend when I came across a Substack post published last Friday—because of course it was a Substack post spreading COVID-19 misinformation—by Mathew Crawford titled “The COVID-As-Pneumonia Hypothesis“. My first thought reading that title was that the word “hypothesis” is doing some very heavy lifting here, as in science the word “hypothesis” generally means a falsifiable prediction that has enough evidence behind it to make testing it through experimentation, and clinical testing in the case of medical hypotheses, reasonable. In reality, it was a conspiracy theory that what was “really causing” all those COVID-19 deaths wasn’t COVID-19 at all for the most part, but actually bacterial pneumonia that “They” somehow didn’t want to admit but rather attribute to SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Why would they want to do this? Reasons. Nefarious reasons. Of course. Because it’s a conspiracy theory.
Mathew Crawford, Norman Fenton, and their antivax pals regurgitate an old antivax conspiracy theory. Again.
In his Substack, Crawford cites a number of “sources” to justify the conspiracy theory that it’s bacterial pneumonia, not viral pneumonia associated with COVID-19 that killed most COVID victims and that “They” are intentionally misclassifying these deaths as due to COVID-19. Unsurprisingly, nearly all of his sources are other Substack articles by COVID-19 cranks and antivaxxers, starting with this introduction:
At some point last year, I was emailing with Drs. Brian Tyson and George Fareed, telling them that it may very well be that most of the [true] COVID-19 deaths were due to pneumonia, and that the most important mechanism behind their protocol might be the antibiotic effects of both hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin/doxycycline. Brian’s response suggested that not only did they agree, but that they were ahead of me on that thought. And that’s good to see—the doctors who were sane enough to focus on early treatment in 2020 were open-minded and aware of the branching hypotheses over what they saw on a clinical level.
This week I was extremely glad to see Martin Neil, Jessica Hockett, Jonathan Engler, and Norman Fenton—a group in which I have high trust—take on what we might term “The Bacterial-COVID Hypothesis”.
The specific Substack that Crawford most relied upon was published on Norman Fenton’s Substack and titled “Whodunnit? {unabridged}“, which “boldly” asked, “Was SARS-CoV-2 or Pneumonia the primary cause of respiratory Covid-19 deaths?”
Personally, given the length and tendentiousness of Fenton’s post, I would have preferred the abridged edition. I like how Fenton and his merry band of antivaxxers and COVID-19 minimizers frame their “hypothesis” all as investigating a mystery, as if scientists and physicians had never before considered the question of differentiating viral pneumonia from bacterial pneumonia. Personally, I like to point out that, contrary to the entire argument being made by people claiming that most COVID-19 deaths were really due to bacterial pneumonia, it actually does matter if a viral pneumonia leads to lung damage that predisposes to a superimposed bacterial pneumonia and the bacterial pneumonia—or, more commonly, a combination of the viral and bacterial infection—ultimately leads to the patient’s death. Why? Because the bacterial pneumonia wouldn’t have been superimposed on the viral pneumonia if the lungs hadn’t been damaged by the viral pneumonia and also because, patients placed on ventilators for a viral pneumonia would not have been predisposed to ventilator-associated bacterial pneumonia if they damage to their lungs hadn’t necessitated the institution of mechanical ventilation in the first place. It isn’t rocket science to understand that if a viral infection damages the lungs enough to predispose them to a bacterial infection that results in sepsis that finishes the patient off, it was the viral infection that caused the death.
As is often the case in such arguments, the authors focus on choosing anything other than the virus as the “primary” cause of death, conveniently ignoring or downplaying what started the cascade of events leading to a patient’s death. I’m going to keep harping on this. For example, if advanced cancer filling a patient’s liver leads to liver failure, which ultimately leads to metabolic disturbances that kill the patient, yes, liver failure was a more proximal cause of death than the cancer, but it was still the cancer that killed the patient. Arguments like Fenton’s and Crawford’s rely on citing events further down the cascade of complications from COVID-19 as the “true” causes of death, not the virus that incited the cascade. (Hmmm. I might become as repetitive as the COVID-19 cranks, but damn if they don’t rather force me to.) Also, in most cases I’m sure that people like Fenton (for example) know this. What they also know is that most people without a medical background can be easily misled by specious arguments like theirs. Yes, after three years of observing them, I no longer give them the benefit of the doubt; in my opinion they are intentionally deceiving.
Let’s dig in.
Tell me you don’t understand viral respiratory diseases without telling me you don’t understand viral respiratory diseases
Let’s pivot over to the Substack by Fenton and friends. I’ve discussed Norman Fenton’s tendency to play fast and loose with definitions and defending antivax p-hacking before elsewhere (albeit, oddly enough, not on SBM until now), but I honestly did not recall any of his “coauthors.” Let’s just say that Fenton has gone from being a “new school” antivaxxer who spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about COVID-19 vaccines—e.g., here, where he spreads a common conspiracy theory that “they” altered COVID-19 death certificates to attribute non-COVID deaths to COVID and (of course!) deaths due to COVID vaccines to COVID—into someone who is increasingly becoming just plain antivaccine, as shown by his receptiveness to really old school antivax claims that vaccines cause autism:
I’ll be looking at these data https://t.co/vJR5VmiR9H
— Prof Norman Fenton (@profnfenton) May 20, 2023
As for the rest of the “co-authors,” Jessica Hockett is a Brownstone Institute author (because of course she is!) who’s used that platform to spread the lie that New York City hospitals were not overwhelmed by COVID-19 cases in the spring of 2020, a lie debunked here on more than one occasion. Indeed, our very own Dr. Jonathan Howard addressed the very claims made by Dr. Hockett, who in analyzing infectious disease epidemiological data shows that she’s an educational psychologist. She was still at it as of yesterday:
“In Apr 2020, Airmen & Soldiers were deployed in NYC to help the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner deal w/ a surge in deaths due to COVID-19. The Guard members helped retrieve the remains of 2,822 New Yorkers from homes & facilities."https://t.co/r5BqAQDceT
— Jessica Hockett 🏹 (@Wood_House76) September 3, 2023
Jonathan Engler is co-chair of the HART Group (Health Advisory & Recovery Team), a group of UK-based “open everything up” COVID-19 minimizers and antivaxxers and prime spreaders of disinformation, while Martin Neil is a professor of computer science and statistics at Queen Mary University of London who is spreading the same message that it’s bacterial pneumonia, not COVID-19, that killed people:
What was happening immediately before COVID arrived?
How do you know the pneumonia is bacterial,and not viral?
Why would you think it's bacterial and not viral?Isn't that Biased? pic.twitter.com/1w8MunwRaN
— John Cullen 🐓 (@I_Am_JohnCullen) September 1, 2023
Note the conspiracy mongering that links influenza to the same narrative that it’s bacterial pneumonia, not SARS-CoV-2, that killed people. In his post, Fenton claims he will show these things. I will reproduce his “summary” of bullet points, in order to go through them, noting that the point in the Tweet above is one that he and Fenton, along with Hockett and Angler, make in their post:
We have investigated the pneumonia hypothesis: that a proportion of covid-19 deaths, those with associated respiratory symptoms (rather than deaths coded as covid-19 because of a positive PCR test, that are absent symptoms), were caused by bacterial pneumonia, and that bacterial pneumonia was the primary, not the secondary, infection.
Our argument in favour of the hypothesis is:
Conflating pneumonia & covid-19 repeats an official longstanding tactic of conflating the attribution of influenza and pneumonia. The reduction in the public’s perceived threat of flu may have prompted the pharmaceutical industry to attempt a rebranding of the threat along with a new suite of marketable products to respond to that threat.We investigated the hypothesis that a proportion of covid-19 deaths, those with associated respiratory symptoms (rather than deaths coded as covid-19 because of a positive PCR test, that are absent symptoms), were caused by bacterial pneumonia, and that maybe bacterial pneumonia was the primary, not the secondary, infection.Does pre-existing exposure to bacterial pneumonia lead to a higher propensity to acquire a viral infection, such as SARS-CoV-2? And we suggest that SARS-Cov-2 infection may mask or be secondary to pneumonia infection and not necessarily the other way around, in which SARS-CoV-2 is assumed to lead to bacterial pneumonia as a secondary infection.Given this the actual burden of risk to hospitalized patients may not have been SARS-CoV-2 (or other viruses) at all but bacterial pneumonia.High rates of ventilator induced pneumonia are confounded by changes in protocols, delays in admission, and overuse of ventilation etc. and estimates of rates of attribution to SARS-CoV-2 cannot therefore be relied upon. Respiratory deaths in hospitals may therefore have beeb [sic] caused by bacterial pneumonia but wrongly attributed to SARS-CoV-2.The pattern of spread of SARS-CoV-2 in spring 2020, and the geographical concentration of the SARS-CoV-2 mortality toll is not what one would expect from a spreading respiratory virus. It is highly localised in specific geographically distant regions and cities. It is a pin-point pandemic.Under modern sanitary conditions large scale pneumonia outbreaks in highly concentrated areas are unlikely to occur naturally. We must look elsewhere for explanations, including the possibility of human agency.Given that rates of pneumonia deaths in 2020 were similar to those seen in previous years, changes in ventilation policy and practices coupled with new PCR testing, would be enough to cause the pin-point pandemic effect.The central question is therefore: Was SARS-CoV-2 a bystander or decoy virus and were bacterial pneumonia deaths mistakenly or intentionally used as proof that SARS-CoV-2 was a deadly respiratory pathogen?
Events are akin to a scene from an Agatha Christie novel where SARS-CoV-2, a bystander used as a decoy, is guilty of the crime, with ventilation as the accomplice, but the actual criminal, who has got off scot-free, is in fact bacterial pneumonia. In other words, SARS-CoV-2 has been framed.
I do like how in the very first bullet point Fenton and crew demonstrates exactly what I’m talking about while also demonstrating that to antivax cranks every accusation is a confession. That’s because it has been a longstanding trope of the antivax movement to claim that what kills many people who die of the flu is a superimposed bacterial pneumonia and then try to claim that the pneumonia was the “primary cause” of that person’s death, not the “harmless”—or “mostly harmless” (except to the old and debilitated and who cares about them anyway?)—flu. They even added Agatha Christie and tried to characterize COVID-19 as having been the innocent bystander dupe who’s been “framed.” They even cite James Lyons-Weiler:
False attribution/conflation of pneumonia deaths to a virus is not a new phenomenon. James Lyons Weiler reports on a long history of manipulation of definitions and statistics to inflate the perceived danger from the flu, when the actual danger is bacterial pneumonia. Pneumonia deaths were henceforth coded as influenza/pneumonia.
This leads to the conspiracy theory of why “they” would do such a thing as to intentionally blame deaths from bacterial pneumonia on COVID-19:
Before SARS-CoV-2 came on the scene, there was a belief in pharmaceutical circles that the flu wasn’t perceived to be dangerous enough and a concern that flu vaccination rates were dropping. To some it may have looked like the vaccine enterprise and pharmaceutical industry itself might be in danger of terminal decline. In October 2019, there were calls for a universal high-tech flu vaccine to face upcoming viral threats and ‘blow up’ the existing system, with the necessity of having many people dying for the sense of urgency to occur.”
The reduction in the public’s perceived threat of flu may have prompted the pharmaceutical industry to attempt a rebranding of the threat along with a new suite of marketable products to respond to that threat.
That’s right. To conspiracy theorists, it’s all about profit. Just as they accuse public health officials before the pandemic of ginning up the fear of influenza by falsely attributing deaths from pneumonia to the flu, all in order to sell vaccines and antivirals, they now accuse public health officials during the pandemic of ginning up fear of COVID-19 by falsely attributing deaths from pneumonia to COVID-19, all in order to—you guessed it!—sell vaccines and antivirals like remdesivir and Paxlovid (instead of the supposedly cheap and effective treatments that aren’t, like ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine.
They even try to claim that Anthony Fauci agrees with them:
Bacterial pneumonia has a track record of previous/prior convictions yet appears to get off the hook in 2020 as well as during previous influenza seasons.
We have argued that the steepness of the mortality spikes in Lombardy, Italy and New York City do not reflect those we might expect from a virus. Hence, we must look elsewhere for an alternative explanation. Might they be better explained as localised pneumonia outbreaks?
Fauci et al believe that the 1918 pandemic was largely caused by pneumonia:
The similarity of the mechanism between 1918 and 2020 is uncanny. The flu pandemic might be more accurately called a pneumonia pandemic. In 1918, influenza was blamed, but pneumonia did the deed. Yet with 1918 and 2020-2023, the historical lesson from public health is that people need to fear viruses, yet pneumonia does not get public attention.
Of course, if you actually read the 2008 Fauci paper cited, you’ll soon realize that Anthony Fauci and his coauthors say no such thing as “the 1918 pandemic was largely caused by pneumonia.” Rather, they wrote that most of the deaths during the 1918 pandemic were caused by complicating bacterial pneumonia:
The majority of deaths in the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic likely resulted directly from secondary bacterial pneumonia caused by common upper respiratory-tract bacteria. Less substantial data from the subsequent 1957 and 1968 pandemics are consistent with these findings. If severe pandemic influenza is largely a problem of viral-bacterial copathogenesis, pandemic planning needs to go beyond addressing the viral cause alone (e.g., influenza vaccines and antiviral drugs). Prevention, diagnosis, prophylaxis, and treatment of secondary bacterial pneumonia, as well as stockpiling of antibiotics and bacterial vaccines, should also be high priorities for pandemic planning.
They even manage to throw in some antimask claims:
It is also to be noted that in this study carried out in Japan and published in Nature, nearly all face coverings retrieved from a series of users in Japan had evidence of potentially pathogenic – and mainly commensal – bacterial and fungal colonies, which might have been particularly dangerous for the immunocompromised, such as the elderly,
If I were to swab Prof. Fenton’s throat, there’s a decent chance that there probably be potentially pathogenic bacteria there, too. There are also some pretty nasty bugs that normally live in our digestive tract and skin. As an amusing aside relevant to a recent post that I wrote, that very study cited by Fenton found that those who ate natto on a daily basis had a lot more of the spore-forming bacterium Bacillus subtilis on their masks, which made me laugh because COVID-19 quack Dr. Peter McCullough has been selling nattokinase, an enzyme made by this bacterial species, as “spike protein detox“, basically a cure for COVID-19. Sure, it’s theoretically possible that immunosuppressed people might be susceptible to their natural flora, but that’s not really what Fenton et al. are implying.
The argument being made by Fenton et al., again, assumes that the bacterial pneumonias recorded had nothing whatsoever to do with influenza infections, which any infectious disease doctor will tell you is not the case, which brings us to the second bullet point, the conspiracy theory that “they” coded COVID-19 deaths as COVID-19 deaths in patients who supposedly had an asymptomatic case of COVID-19 who just happened—by coincidence!—to die of a bacterial pneumonia. In fact, in the third bullet point, they reverse the polarity, so to speak, and claim that it’s exposure to bacterial pneumonia that predisposes to COVID-19. Of course, I can’t resist pointing out that their pulling this trick implicitly admits that the proximal cause is not necessarily “the cause” of death. To make this argument, Fenton et al. have to assume that SARS-CoV-2 is a nearly harmless virus, like viruses that cause the common cold.
At this point, I was beginning to wonder what evidence they actually had, because for the most part the whole Substack is one big load of handwaving and JAQing off, along with appeals to incredulity; e.g., the claim that “the steepness of the mortality spikes in Lombardy, Italy and New York City do not reflect those we might expect from a virus” and “pattern of spread, and the geographical concentration of the Covid-19 mortality toll is not what one would expect from a respiratory virus.” Of course, the pattern of spread of SARS-CoV-2 actually very much like what we would have expected from a novel respiratory virus that originated in a single place (around Wuhan, China) and then spread to different parts of the world along via infected travelers, where at each new location the infected travelers started spreading the infection to others, thereby causing “pinpoint” epidemics in highly populated areas like New York that spread and grew until all the mini-epidemics started to converge into one huge global pandemic.
Similarly, Fenton et al. argue from their incredulity that under “modern sanitary conditions large scale pneumonia outbreaks in highly concentrated areas are unlikely to occur naturally” and that therefore we “must look elsewhere for explanations, including the possibility of human agency” (bold text Fenton’s). Again, on what planet do these people live? Although very important in preventing the spread of water-borne disease or diseases spread by the fecal-oral route, sanitation appears not to play a major role in preventing outbreaks of transmissible highly infectious respiratory diseases, although simple handwashing can. Population immunity (e.g., vaccination) and population density do. When people live packed in small spaces with poor ventilation (as all too many humans do), even in “modern” cities, it’s a perfect setup for a respiratory virus to spread. What can slow the spread of respiratory viruses are long-used physical measures. As for the “possibility of human agency”, it sounds to me as though Fenton is implying some sort of cover-up or nefarious intervention of public health officials and government.
Pretty much all of what Fenton et al. express such incredulity about turns out to be nothing more than what we’ve long known that respiratory viruses do, how they spread, and how they can be complicated by a secondary bacterial pneumonia. The principles of virology and viral pneumonias didn’t change overnight when COVID-19 arrived. While COVID-19 had some unusual characteristics, it was (and is) still a respiratory virus, a subtype of coronaviruses, which had been fairly extensively studied before the pandemic, particularly after the SARS epidemic in 2003, which fortunately—and unlike COVID-19—fizzled out before becoming a pandemic.
But what evidence do Fenton and his antivaxxers have?
Cherry picking, thy name is Fenton (et al.)
As I have explained, pretty much everything that confuses Fenton and colleagues into thinking that COVID-19 could not be the primary cause of death and that bacterial pneumonia must have been the culprit has been consistent with what we know about viral pneumonia and how to treat it. The principles haven’t changed: Support the respiratory status of those suffering from viral pneumonia, with supplemental oxygen, pulmonary hygiene to loosen secretions, and even with mechanical ventilation if necessary. Use antivirals if there are any effective ones against the particular virus-causing pneumonia and treat secondary bacterial infections with appropriate antibiotics if they arise. It’s the same set of principles used to treat ARDS (acute respiratory distress syndrome). This, of course, brings us back to ventilators, because Fenton et al. blame ventilators for COVID-19 deaths. First, though, they muddy the waters by selectively interpreting and quoting a large retrospective cohort study of over 19,000 patients with COVID-19 and other respiratory diseases between March 10th, 2020 to December 31st, 2020, a study whose findings were actually fairly interesting and complex.
In brief, the authors found:
…a 2.6-fold increase (P < 0.001) in respiratory culture ordering in COVID-19 patients. On a per-patient basis, COVID-19 patients were 1.5-fold more likely than non-COVID patients to have positive respiratory cultures (46.8% versus 30.9%, P < 0.001), which was primarily driven by patients requiring intubation. Among patients with pneumonia, a significantly higher proportion of COVID-19 patients had ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) relative to non-COVID patients (86.3% versus 70.8%, P < 0.001), but a lower proportion had community-acquired (11.2% vs 25.5%, P < 0.01) pneumonia. There was also a significantly higher proportion of respiratory cultures positive for methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, Klebsiella pneumoniae, and antibiotic-resistant organisms in COVID-19 patients. Increased rates of respiratory culture ordering for COVID-19 patients therefore appear to be clinically justified for patients requiring intubation, but further research is needed to understand how SARS-CoV-2 increases the risk of VAP.
Basically, this study published in 2022 concluded that there’s something about SARS-C0V-2 that results in a higher rate of ventilator-associated bacterial pneumonia. Of course, VAP is a common complication during prolonged ventilation for respiratory failure, particularly if the lung is injured. This study concluded that the risk of VAP complicating ventilation for COVID-19 was most increased relative to that for non-COVID-19 ventilated patients after ten days of mechanical ventilation. Of course, this is not the only study looking at this question. If one looks at the overall evidence, it appears that COVID-19 does result in a higher risk of VAP compared to other causes of ARDS, a risk attributed thusly in one study:
In patients admitted in an intensive care unit (ICU) and ventilated for Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS) due to SARS-CoV-2, ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) is a common complication, ranging from 30% to 86% of patients [1,2]. The cumulative incidence among COVID-19 patients can reach approximately 35/1000 ventilator days in European cohorts, which is 50% to 80% higher than in ARDS from other etiologies [3,4]. Several mechanisms explain the higher incidence of these superinfections [5,6]. They involve mucus plugs favoring atelectasis, diffuse alveolar damages, viral-induced immunoparalysis, impaired lung perfusion due to endothelial dysfunction, altered coagulation, and immunothrombosis [7,8]. Of note, the risk truly induced by corticosteroids or other immunomodulator therapies remains debated [9]
How do Fenton et al. spin these results? First, they don’t like the fact that the definition of VAP precludes pneumonia acquired less than two days after intubation:
Likewise, it looks like the majority of respiratory culture tests were performed post intubation, and unfortunately, any positive culture tests found for intubated patients collected at least 2 days prior to intubation were excluded from the study (because they would not qualify under the class “ventilator acquired pneumonia” versus hospital or community acquired). It is thus possible that cases may have tested positive for competing pathogens contracted before ventilation but subsequently discovered during ventilation and classified as a secondary pneumonia were actually a primary pneumonia contracted in the hospital or in the community.
Now that’s some serious JAQing off, as in, “Hey, what if all these patients diagnosed with VAP actually had bacterial pneumonia when they were intubated but it was missed because VAP is defined as bacterial pneumonia that develops more than two days after intubation? And, hey, what about this:
When reporting for their own hospital, Columbia University Irving Medical Center (CUIMC) located in New York City, they report that respiratory cultures were ordered for test in 16% of SARS-CoV-2 positive patients compared to 6.2% in negative patients. So, as the overwhelming majority of covid-19 patients were not tested for competing pathogens, it cannot be ruled out that those showing respiratory symptoms attributed to SARS-CoV-2 might have been suffering from another viral or bacterial coinfection.
These people are clearly not clinicians. They don’t think like clinicians, nor do they think like clinical investigators. There’s a saying in medicine: When you hear hoofbeats, don’t look for zebras. (A “zebra” is slang for a rare or uncommon diagnosis in a given clinical situation.) Yes, sometimes you will find a zebra, but only rarely. When a patient has the symptoms of COVID-19 over a time period consistent with COVID-19 and tests positive for COVID-19, that patient has COVID-19 unless there are other things in their clinical picture that make us think that there might be something else going on. Moreover, in the middle of the first surge of the pandemic, testing all patients for “competing respiratory pathogens” would not have been justified given resource constraints. Indeed, look at it this way: Clinicians were testing COVID-19 patients for “competing pathogens” nearly three-fold more frequently than they were doing so for non-COVID-19 patients.
Fenton also can’t help but doing a bit more conspiracy mongering here:
They also say:
“….between March 10th and 23rd, testing was performed by clinical suspicion due to limited testing capacity….”
So, there was an absence of rigorous data collection at the height of the ‘pandemic’ in NYC and at other times the rates at which culture testing is done appears selective, and cases appear to have been removed from the analysis due to classification requirements. This suggests that the rates at which bacterial and viral coinfection, and the stage at which infections are detected (community, hospital ICU) are highly sensitive and dependent on local testing and record keeping practices, and also differences between practices extant prior to the ‘pandemic’ and during it.
See what I mean about resource constraints? Yet Fenton et al. use that admission to imply that somehow this means that many “co-infections” were missed.
In the rest of their Substack, Fenton et al. cite papers confirming what was found above, namely that COVID-19 appeared to be associated with a higher risk of VAP, with ventilation being portrayed as an “accomplice” in their fanciful murder mystery. They even cite one s tudy in order to imply that doctors were ignoring all the other microbes they found in patients with COVID-19:
They found that:
“…..morbidity was principally due to SARS-CoV-2 infection and some other microbiologic characteristics, such as an association with positive blood cultures and polymicrobial cultures rather than patients’ related risk factors, such as immune-depression and co-morbidities.”
So here the authors acknowledge that other microbiologic and polymicrobial cultures are to be found at the ‘crime scene’ yet are not directly implicated in the deaths. SARS-CoV-2 is named as the guilty culprit.
Yes, because, absent SARS-CoV-2, all the other polymicrobial infections wouldn’t have happened! Indeed, it is telling how Fenton et al. ignored this part of the study, which said:
In our study, VAP occurred in more than 50% of COVID-19 patients receiving mechanical ventilation, and it was associated with death in 50% of cases. These results are aligned with data presented by other authors [8,9,10]. Additionally, no significant difference in mortality rate was detected between COVID-19 patients with and without VAP. This result is encouraging, and it suggests that VAP can be managed in ICUs, and the risk of VAP should not be a limitation to mechanical ventilation in COVID-19 patients.
In actuality, this study supports not what Fenton claims, but rather that the bacterial pneumonias were secondary infections that could be managed and did not appear to be the primary drivers of mortality in COVID=19 patients. That, too, is why the authors concluded that SARS-CoV-2, not bacterial pneumonia, was the primary cause of death.
As for the repeated observation that the risk of VAP went way up the longer COVID-19 patients were kept on mechanical ventilation, Fenton et al. also spin a conspiracy theory. Citing another study looking at VAP in ventilated COVID-19 patients, they write:
The act of keeping people on ventilators for longer, perhaps to protect staff as an early FDA statement indicated, confounds any claim that SARS-CoV-2 was more deadly.
I encourage you to actually read the FDA statement. It says nothing about keeping people on ventilators for longer to protect medical staff. Go ahead. Click on the link. I’ll wait. The notice is from March 2020 and is all about increasing the supply of ventilators for patients by issuing “an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) to allow for the emergency use in health care settings of certain ventilators, anesthesia gas machines modified for use as ventilators, and positive pressure breathing devices modified for use as ventilators (collectively referred to as “ventilators”), ventilator tubing connectors, and ventilator accessories that the FDA determines meet specified criteria for safety, performance and labeling.” and increasing the supply of personal protective equipment (PPE), such as respirators, N95 masks, etc. Fenton et al. are basically lying about what the FDA statement says, counting on the fact that most people won’t click on the link, much less read what the FDA statement says.
None of this stops them from citing two studies showing similar things (a higher rate of VAP and prolonged ventilator support) and then concluding:
Both of these studies suggest that any conclusion that SARS-CoV-2 was the primary causal factor in mortality is heavily confounded, inter alia, by bacterial infection and changes in treatment protocols. Patients were in the ICU for longer and the increase in bacterial pneumonia, from prolonged exposure to ventilation, may well have led to an increased mortality rate and the misattribution of this to SARS-CoV-2.
They also use the observation that fewer invasive procedures were done (e.g., bronchoscopy) to collect sputum samples in COVID-19 patients on ventilators in order to try to claim again that many bacterial pneumonias were missed:
Furthermore, it appears that established protocols for bacterial sampling were changed to reduce exposure of hospital staff to the virus:
“Additionally, VAP incidence may vary according to the bacteriological test used. Indeed, to avoid healthcare workers (HCW) contamination when the diagnosis of VAP is suspected, the use of bacteriological samples and bronchoscopy have been reduced, and gram stain examination not performed.”
This suggests that bacterial causes for acute respiratory distress might not have been detected at all in many cases, but not because it wasn’t present, but because it was never tested for.
Apparently, Fenton et al. have never heard of empirical treatment of VAP. As I learned back in my trauma days, you don’t always isolate the bug causing VAP, or sometimes you isolate several. In these cases, antibiotics are chosen empirically. Basically, if there is clinical suspicion for a bacterial pneumonia, ICU docs will institute empirical treatment for it. Just because there’s no culture doesn’t mean there’s no diagnosis. Indeed, Fenton cites research indicating that the vast majority of patients with severe COVID-19 were treated with antibiotics at some point during their course. That would seem to go against his “hypothesis,” but not if you’re a good conspiracy theorist:
In the VAP studies, cited earlier rates of first line antibiotic treatment were similar across groups, as was targeted treatment with antibiotics. At first glance this appears to falsify the claim (discussed here) that denial of antibiotics caused SARS-CoV-2 respiratory deaths. However, as with all medical treatments the important question is whether, if people had pneumonia, they were given antibiotics on time, in the community or in hospital, before they were presented to the ICU and experienced VAP. Langford et al report that “the majority of patients with Covid-19 received antibiotics” – estimated at 72%. But what if the wrong people got the antibiotics, and those with pneumonia did not? The study authors don’t say but the effect of any misallocation would naturally be to increase the mortality rate of those with pneumonia.
Pneumonia symptoms overlap heavily with SARS-CoV-2 symptoms and given the edict that antibiotics do not help in the treatment of SARS-CoV-2, it is inevitable that many patients suffering from pneumonia would have been denied antibiotics until it was too late for them to have a material effect.
Got it? Even though most ventilated COVID-19 patients did receive treatment with antibiotics, they didn’t get the right antibiotics at the right time, because that’s the only way Fenton et al. could JAQ off about it in a way to cast doubt on the rather obvious refutation of their conspiracy theory. They go beyond even this, though:
Furthermore, in spring 2020 people were told to self-isolate if they suffered covid symptoms. This would buy time for pathogens to multiply and for a more severe condition to develop, which might be subsequently harder to manage. Many people would have then presented late to ICU, with incipient or lingering pneumonia (perhaps from the previous normal flu season), disguised as covid-19, and were left untreated with antibiotics until their condition deteriorated further. The reluctance to perform bacteriological investigations may have been a further contributory factor. They would therefore have suffered higher levels of ARDS than would have been seen historically. Given the lateness of presentation to hospital, and despite the administration of antibiotics, this may have came too late to save them from what was a (detected or undetected) bacterial pneumonia infection. A proportion of these would have been attributed to SARS-CoV-2.
At this point I was getting tired. It was variation upon variation of the same misunderstanding regarding how viral pneumonias are often complicated by bacterial pneumonia during their clinical course. They express amazement that cases of pneumonia graphed against time overlap COVID-19 surges, as if that were evidence that it was bacterial pneumonia, not COVID-19, causing the waves of death during those surges, while citing antivaxxers like James Lyons-Weiler, who in his Substack claimed that a single study suggested that “the stunning potential that perhaps 58% of “COVID” cases were respiratory issues other than COVID (43% bacterial pneumonia, 16% non-pathogen causes of respiratory failure),” rendering them “doomed to a fate of non-treatment due to mis- or under-diagnosis.”
Oh, and Fenton also points to a study showing a large decrease in antibiotic prescriptions from January to May 2020, as though this were some sort of conspiracy not to treat bacterial pneumonia in favor of misclassifying it as COVID-19, when the study itself notes that the decrease was most likely due to pandemic mitigation measures.
Confusing cause and effect to spread antivax propaganda
During the pandemic, there have been a number of false messages promoted by pandemic minimizers and antivaxxers, including:
    • That COVID-19 death tolls are being intentionally exaggerated by the media and government for nefarious purposes; for example, early in the pandemic it was claimed that the “true” toll was “only 6%” of the toll usually cited.
    • That “only” the sick and the old are at risk.
    • That you don’t have to worry about COVID-19 if you don’t have one or more of the comorbid conditions listed.
    • That, because “only 6%” died of “only COVID-19,” lockdowns, social distancing, masks, etc., are unnecessary.
Fenton’s messaging is very much of a piece of this, specifically the common antivax claim heard from time immemorial that vaccine-preventable diseases are not actually dangerous. We’ve seen this claim many times before for influenza, measles, varicella, and a number of other vaccine-preventable diseases, and, predictably, we’re now seeing it for COVID-19. What Fenton and his buddies are doing is yet another strategy antivaxxers like to use to claim that vaccines are not necessary and/or that the vaccine is more dangerous than the disease: To downplay the severity of the disease by confusing a complication of the disease with the disease itself, and then to claim that the complication is the “true” cause of death, not the virus causing the disease.
The worst thing is, I believe it’s very likely that Fenton and his friends know that their arguments are a load of fetid dingos’ kidneys. What they are spreading is disinformation more than misinformation.

Smoking and COVID
Does smoking worsen COVID infections? Or is it protective? As more evidence emerges, the smoke is starting to clear.
Scott Gavura on May 14, 2020
Link
With new data appearing so quickly, it’s impossible to keep up with the flood of new scientific and clinical information emerging about COVID-19. The unknowns are still considerable, however, and as of time of writing there are no demonstrably effective treatments to prevent or treat COVID. This uncertainty has led to experimentation and even speculation about whether existing drugs could potentially be repurposed. I have an ongoing poll with my pharmacist colleagues over which drug product will be touted as the next treatment for COVID. First it was hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin, which after some unfounded hype may actually cause more harm than good. Last week famotidine (Pepcid), a popular over-the-counter stomach acid suppressant was identified as potentially beneficial. (My hunch is that even the humble neti pot will, at some point, be touted as a treatment.) Among the products I would not expect to be touted as possibly effective against COVID is something that already kills 7 million people per year. I was admittedly surprised in late April when France was reported as restricting sales of nicotine replacement medicines (like gums and patches) after a unpublished (preprint) study suggested that tobacco smoking appeared to be protective, as smokers were under-represented in COVID cases and deaths, consistent with signals that some researchers suggest may exist in Chinese data. The analysis, which received considerable media attention, concluded:
Our cross sectional study in both COVID-19 out- and inpatients strongly suggests that daily smokers have a very much lower probability of developing symptomatic or severe SARS-CoV-2 infection as compared to the general population.
So is smoking potentially protective? As they say, it’s a bit more complicated than that.

Does cigarette smoke protect smokers?
The Pitié-Salpêtrière analysis was a survey of the smoking incidence among hospitalized and non-hospitalized COVID patients. The patient-reported rates were compared to the French population, and standardized for age and sex. Eligible patients were those hospitalized (non-ICU) or had consulted and diagnosed with COVID but were recovering at home. Data was collected from February through April, 2020. Smoking status was obtained by direct questions, and the frequency and type of smoking (e.g., cigars, cigarettes) was documented.
Overall 343 inpatients and 139 outpatients were included. The demographics were as follows:
The inpatient group was composed of 343 patients, median age 65 years: 206 men (60.1%, median age 66 years) and 137 women (39.9%, median age 65 years). The rate of daily smokers was 4.4 (5.4% of men and 2.9% of women).
The outpatient group was composed of 139 patients, median age 44 years: 62 men (44.6 %, median age 43 years, and 77 women (55.4 %, median age 44 years). The daily smokers rate was 5.3% (5.1% of men and 5.5 % of women).
The rate of daily smokers in inpatients (4.4%) and outpatients (5.4%) didn’t differ significantly. They did differ significantly from the overall French population, where approximately 25% overall are smokers.
It’s the comparison with the general population where it gets interesting. In the image below you can see the Standardized Incidence Ratio (SIR) which are age- and sex-adjusted smoking rates based on a 2018 survey of almost 10,000 individuals in France, compared with the population smoking rates in (A) outpatients and (B) inpatients. The survey suggests that smokers are dramatically under-represented among COVID patients:
One of the glaring gaps in this survey is that it didn’t include ICU patients – so we don’t know if smokers ended up with significantly worse outcomes. Or never made it to the hospital at all. The observed differences are interesting, but that’s about all we can say: a cross-sectional survey cannot establish causality – just correlation. There could be one or more confounders. Smokers could have been under-represented among COVID patients for other reasons (e.g., the proportion that were health care workers may have been high.) Smoking could have been under-reported because patients may not have wanted to disclose this information. Still, the results feed the hypothesis that there are one or more chemicals in cigarette smoke that could be modulating viral action. They authors speculate that it could be nicotine’s interaction with the angiotensin converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) receptor (the receptor targeted by ACE inhibitor drugs).
Based on the results of this study, multiple groups appear to be launching clinical trials with nicotine-replacement products like patches. Whether there’s a real effect at all, or if nicotine patches are a good substitute for cigarettes (when it comes to these findings) remains to be seen. The authors did point out that their findings seem to be supported by another analysis of clusters of COVID infections in Oise, France. In that analysis they examined 661 people and found that smokers were significantly less likely to have an infection compared to non smokers (7.2% vs. 28%, which was statistically significant). Many of the limitations in this analysis are the same.
Puzzling data from the NHS
Ben Goldacre, who is no stranger to regular readers of this blog, was the senior author of a massive analysis of 17.4 million UK adults to determine risk factors associated with COVID death. An electronic health record dataset was linked to a registry of COVID deaths. The dataset included 5,707 deaths from COVID and identified factors associated with death. These factors include being male, older age, uncontrolled diabetes, severe asthma, and ethnicity. Available as a preprint (and has not yet undergone peer review), it also included smoking status in its analysis. Here is their comment on smoking:
Both current and former smoking were associated with higher risk in models adjusted for age and sex only, but in the fully adjusted model there was weak evidence of a slightly lower risk in current smokers (fully adjusted HRs 0.88, CI 0.79-0.99). In post-hoc analyses we added individual covariates to the model with age, sex and smoking to explore this further: the change in HR appeared to be largely driven by adjustment for chronic respiratory disease (HR 0.93, 0.83-1.04 after adjustment) and deprivation (HR 0.98, 0.88-1.10 after adjustment). Other individual adjustments did not remove the positive association between current smoking and outcome.
It is possible that there was a confounder here – respiratory status – something pointed out in a thoughtful Medscape editorial on the paper by Perry Wilson:
The fully adjusted model adjusts for respiratory disease. So when we look at the adjusted risk of smoking, what we are saying is, basically, If all these smokers didn’t have respiratory disease, they’d actually be more likely to survive COVID-19 than nonsmokers. Okay. But that’s just like saying, If all these people who don’t wear their seatbelt didn’t fly through the window, they’d be more likely to survive car accidents. Fine, I guess, but definitely not a reason to take off your seatbelt. The researchers actually looked at this, and found—sure enough—that all you have to do is adjust for respiratory disease to make smoking look protective. The key take-home here is that you need to be super-thoughtful when you are trying to assess causality in observational data. “Adjust for everything” is not a good strategy because you run the risk of adjusting for things on the causal pathway, which totally screws up your results.
So while some of the headlines can’t resist the “Smoking may be protective” story here, a cautious read of the study, and its limitations, doesn’t suggest that idea is well supported.
Emerging evidence starts to clear the air
Finally, I’ll comment a few other papers that have appeared in the past few days. First, a peer-reviewed study that was published just three days ago. It examines chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and smoking in patients with COVID-19. This was a meta-analysis (a study of 15 studies) including 2,473 COVID patients. All but one of the studies were in China. Smoking history was reported in eight of these studies, encompassing 221 COVID cases. This paper concluded that the prevalence of COPD among this group of COVID patients was low but COPD patients were at higher risk of more severe disease, which was associated with significantly higher mortality. The prevalence of current smokers in COVID patients in this sample was 9% (while the reported Chinese prevalence is about 25%). Current smokers were about 1.5x more likely to have severe complications of COVID compared to former/never smokers. Current smokers were also noted to have a higher mortality rate.
Another paper posted three days ago is the work of three Canadian researchers who have looked at the UK Biobank, to examine if smokers may be less likely to test positive for COVID compared to non-smokers. Of the <500,000 individuals in the BioBank, 2,237 individuals were tested for COVID between March 16 and April 26. In that sample, 908 testing positive, suggesting that testing is concentrated in those considered to be at high risk of disease. Smoking prevalence at enrollment was slightly but not significantly lower in those that tested positive. (16.6% vs. 17.5%). After adjusting for different variables, current smokers were slightly more likely to test positive for COVID, but again the difference was non-significant.
In a paper that was published yesterday (May 13) in Nicotine and Tobacco Research, researchers summarized 19 peer-reviewed papers (from China, South Korea, and the US) that examined the association between smoking and the severity of COVID in hospitalized and non-hospitalized patients. This was a systematic search that encompassed 11,590 COVID patients. The outcome of interest was progression of COVID to severe/critical conditions or death. Of the population studied, 2,133 experienced disease progression. 29.8% of smokers experienced disease progression, compared with 17.6% of non-smokers. The authors conclude that smokers with COVID appear to have 1.91x odds of worsening disease, compared to non-smokers. While the prevalence of smoking among COVID patients was low, the authors suggest there may be other factors leading to this finding:
“The fact that smoking prevalence is lower among COVID patients than the general population has been cited as evidence for a protective effect of smoking,” said Roengrudee Patanavanich, MD, PhD, a visiting scholar at UCSF from the Department of Community Medicine at Ramathibodi Hospital at Mahidol University, Thailand. “But this low prevalence may actually be due to an under-assessment of smoking, especially when you consider the difficult conditions involved when caring for people in often overwhelmed health systems.”
Conclusion: Probably not a good idea to take up smoking
Early (March 2020) data on Chinese COVID patients identified the low prevalence of smoking noted among hospitalized patients. This led to the hypothesis that smoking, or perhaps nicotine itself, may provide some protection against infection or worsening disease. Data that has emerged since that time does not give strong support to the “smoking is protective” hypothesis. There is no question that cigarette smoking causes lung damage, and it kills millions per year. Whether or not nicotine has any beneficial effects on COVID is a related but distinct question that is now under investigation, using nicotine replacement (patches) to study the question. Over the next several months, better data should be available to provide a more definitive response. Until that time, quitting smoking (or not starting) even during a pandemic, remains an appropriate health strategy.

Race and COVID
I suspect the mass infection of unvaccinated children wouldn’t have been openly championed if more White children died.
Jonathan Howard on April 3, 2022
Link

Though many White children have died this pandemic, research shows that in the US, about 75% of pediatric deaths occurred in Hispanic, non-Hispanic Black, and non-Hispanic American Indian/Alaskan Native children. This matters. If the pandemic’s chief victims weren’t also it’s most marginalized, I imagine that fewer people of privilege would be so desperate to minimize COVID’s impact on children.
A new paper titled “Highlighting COVID-19 Racial Disparities Can Reduce Support for Safety Precautions Among White U.S. Residents” supports this hypothesis. Allison Skinner-Dorkenoo, assistant professor of psychology at the University of Georgia and co-author of the study, said,
“When white people in the U.S. were more aware of racial disparities in Covid-19, they were less fearful of Covid-19. We found evidence of less empathy for people who are vulnerable to Covid-19 and we also found evidence of reduced support for safety precautions to prevent the spread of Covid-19.”She added that the findings show that white people tend to care less about Covid and its impact when they believe it is “not a white people problem.”
Pediatric COVID is mostly not a White people problem and so from the secure and sheltered, there is more outrage about museum vaccination requirements than about children suffering from a largely vaccine-preventable virus (even with Omicron). I’m not an expert on racism and what policies can mitigate its harms, but I suspect the mass infection of unvaccinated children wouldn’t have been openly championed if more White children had died.

“This Thing Has Killed Less Than Or About As Many As Flu Would Kill In A Normal Year In Kids, I Say Hardly Any” & “80-Year-Olds, Their Time To Death In General Is Not That Long.”
If were are supposed to be indifferent to the deaths of young people because “hardly any” died, and we are supposed to be indifferent to the deaths of older people because “their time to death in general is not that long,” which of the 1.1 million COVID deaths should we care about?
Jonathan Howard on June 9, 2024
Link

Even though this thing has killed less than you know, or, or about as many as flu would kill in a normal year in kids, I say hardly any.
Most of my writing has focused on how doctors minimized COVID for children and young people. To pick one example amongst many, in April 2021, Dr. Zubin Damania (ZDoggMD) absurdly compared COVID’s pediatric death toll with mitigation measures in place, to flu’s pediatric death toll without mitigation measures. In a podcast titled Focused Protection For COVID with pro-infection misinformation doctor Jay Bhattacharya, Dr. Damania minimized the threat of variants and said:
Even though this thing has killed less than you know, or, or about as many as flu would kill in a normal year in kids, I say hardly any.
Around 300 children had died of COVID by April 2021– hardly any– though the worst was yet to come. The variants that Dr. Damania casually dismissed arrived within a year killing many more children. Naturally, Dr. Damania did not consider adverse outcomes aside from death.
And if you look at a population of 80-year-olds, their time to death in general is not that long.
Because Drs. Damania and like-minded doctors believed that measures to contain the virus posed a greater threat than the virus itself, they needed a different technique to numb their audience to the deaths of older people.
In a podcast titled Omicron Panic, Natural Immunity, Fluvoxamine, & More from December 2021, just before the Omicron variant took off. Dr. Damania, along with fellow misinformation doctors Vinay Prasad and Marty Makary, shamed and mocked anyone who wanted a booster, even though there was evidence from an RCT that it prevented 95% of COVID cases. Dr. Makary falsely claimed that the booster’s only benefit was that it would lower the hospitalization rate from 1 in 26,000 to 1 in 260,000 in people older than age 65. He added that “the average age of a breakthrough death is 80″, to which Dr. Damania replied:
And if you look at a population of 80-year-olds, their time to death in general is not that long.
Several months later, the New York Times added a sober dose of reality to their jocular fantasy with an article titled During the Omicron Wave, Death Rates Soared for Older People that said:
Almost as many Americans 65 and older died in four months of the Omicron surge as did in six months of the Delta wave, even though the Delta variant, for any one person, tended to cause more severe illness.
Many of these seniors might still be alive today had they lived with a bit more “panic” and opted for a simple booster.
“This Thing Has Killed Less Than Or About As Many As Flu Would Kill In A Normal Year In Kids, I Say Hardly Any” & “80-Year-Olds, Their Time To Death In General Is Not That Long.”
These are everyday people who are dying. They’re losing time with their kids, their grandkids, their opportunities to build their futures.
Not all doctors were so blasé about COVID’s victims, young and old alike. Doctors who actually treated COVID patients know many of them had their lives shortened by several decades. As Dr. Nina Shapiro said in November 2020:
Those who are in terrific shape, are young and have no prior illness can, indeed, become critically illfrom COVID. Many have died and many will die.
Research supports the observations of frontline doctors. One study from October 2020 calculated that the virus had stolen 2.5 million years of potential life in the US. Just under half of these years were taken from people younger than 65 years. As the paper’s author, Dr. Stephen J. Elledge said, “COVID-19 has wiped out millions of years of productive, active, and happy existence.”
Later variants would pose a greater risk to younger people, especially the Delta variant. In fact, the number of years of life lost for each COVID death increased by 35.7% in 2021 compared to 2020. Another study from May 2022 calculated the virus had stolen 3.9 million years of life away from Americans and the average COVID victim lost over 9 years of life. Not all COVID victims were 90-year-olds with advanced cancer, only days away from dying, when they happened to test positive for SARS-CoV-2 as some doctors implied. In the words of Dr. Utibe Essien:
These are everyday people who are dying. They’re losing time with their kids, their grandkids, their opportunities to build their futures.
No one lives forever, and I certainly know that someone who receives more medical care hasn’t necessarily received better medical care. However, if my older relatives are hospitalized with COVID, I hope doctors don’t just casually discard them as old people whose time has come. I hope someone with Dr. Essien’s compassion is looking out for them.
Which of the 1.1 million COVID deaths should we care about?
Beyond this, Drs. Damania’s callous dismissal of COVID fatalities of both children and seniors- and he was hardly alone in doing this- raises an obvious question. If were are supposed to be indifferent to the deaths of young people because “hardly any” died, and we are supposed to be indifferent to the deaths of older people because “their time to death in general is not that long“, which of the 1.1 million COVID deaths should we care about?

The CDC Releases New Data on COVID-19 in Children
Another large data set, this time from the CDC, supports the anecdotal observations that pediatric COVID-19 cases tend to be mild and that a very small percentage of children are requiring intensive care. The absence of obvious symptoms increases the risk of spreading the virus, so social distancing and proper hygiene are key when it comes to kids.
Clay Jones on April 10, 2020
Link

At the end of March, Harriet discussed data out of China on pediatric COVID-19 cases. That study supported the general observation of the medical community that children have not been hit very hard by SARS-CoV-2 infections and tend to present a bit differently than adults, with more mild and asymptomatic cases. The Chinese study did report that roughly 6% of children had severe (5%) or critical (0.6%) disease, however, and one teenage boy lost his life. Now we have another large data set to look at in the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) that was released this week.
New data from the CDC on pediatric COVID-19
From February 12th to April 2nd, 149,760 cases of COVID-19 in the United States were confirmed by the CDC. Of the 149,082 cases where age was known, 2,572 (1.7%) of these occurred in children less than 18 years of age. Unfortunately, data on several key variables, such as presenting signs and symptoms, underlying medical conditions, and hospitalization status weren’t available for many of these cases, which is a significant limitation – along with the fact that there are undoubtedly a large number of cases that have been missed because of inadequate testing.
Looking at what was available, we can see that children appear to be less likely to present with specific signs and symptoms when compared to patients aged 18 to 64 years. Most (73%) of the children with COVID-19 had fever, cough, or shortness of breath, which is 20% fewer than cases in the older population. The largest discrepancy found between children and adults was in the presence of shortness of breath, which occurred in 13% of children and 43% of older patients. Again, this is all limited by the absence of documentation of the clinical presentation in a lot of these cases. Also, it isn’t well explained why they stopped at 64 years of age in this report, but it’s safe to assume that patients 65 years and older fared worse in all categories.
Roughly 6% of children were hospitalized, but that assessment is hampered by the lack of specific documentation in 2/3 of cases. That number would be consistent with the Chinese data though. Also consistent is the finding that about 0.6% of children required critical care and that children less than a year old were the most likely to have severe disease. Three pediatric deaths were reported by the CDC, but they did not go so far as to confirm that their deaths were definitely caused by COVID-19.
Boys vs. girls
There have been numerous observations made around the world that men appear to be having a rougher time with SARS-CoV-2 infections, both in incidence and severity. As limited and preliminary as they are, the new CDC data on American kids also demonstrate a consistent difference between boys and girls in all age groups when it comes to COVID-19. The CDC report revealed that 57% of pediatric patients were males.
What isn’t known is what is at the heart of these differences. Environmental and lifestyle factors, such as higher rates of smoking among men, have been bandied about as a possible explanation, but pediatric data, particularly involving children less than a year of age, speaks against that strongly. Biology, and genetics, appear to be a more likely culprit.
Conclusion: The kids are (mostly) alright
So we now have two studies involving a fairly large number of pediatric patients demonstrating that children are considerably less likely than adults to have severe COVID-19 presentations. Still, there have been a number of hospitalizations for severe and critical disease, and survival is not a certainty. Parents should not be panicking over this possibility, but knowing that children are more likely to have asymptomatic or mild disease makes a focus on social distancing and good hygiene practices even more important.

Are COVID-19 Hospitalizations for Children Inflated?
Some recent articles portray children as relatively safe from the harms of COVID-19. Taking a critical look at the numbers and arguments, I see things a different way.
Jonathan Howard on June 4, 2021
Link

A recent article by David Zweig titled New Research Suggests Number of Kids Hospitalized for COVID Is Overcounted claimed:
The reported number of COVID-19 hospitalizations, one of the primary metrics for tracking the severity of the coronavirus pandemic, was grossly inflated for children in California hospitals, two research papers published Wednesday concluded.
The two papers were accompanied by a commentary by Drs. Amy Beck and Monica Gandhi titled Adjudicating Reasons for Hospitalization Shows That Severe Illness From COVID-19 in Children Is Rare. The commentary claimed that “Both demonstrate that reported hospitalization rates greatly overestimate the true burden of COVID-19 disease in children.” I believe there are several limitations to these studies that make it difficult to reach the conclusion that harms to children from COVID-19 have been greatly exaggerated.
Let’s examine these studies further. As screening for SARS-CoV-2 is now standard of care at most hospitals, both studies examined all admitted children who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2. They retrospectively reviewed their charts to best determine which percentage of COVID-19 cases were found incidentally. An example of incidental infection would be a child who suffered a fracture and tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 upon admission screening.
The first paper: Webb & Osburn
The first paper is titled Characteristics of Hospitalized Children Positive for SARS-CoV-2: Experience of a Large Center by Drs. Nicole Webb and T. Shea Osburn. The study was conducted at the second-largest children’s hospital in California and included patients 22 years or younger. It spanned 5/1/2020 to 9/30/20, several months before California’s big COVID-19 surge. It found 163 patients screened positive for SARS-CoV-2 on admission. 17 patients were diagnosed with multisystem inflammatory syndrome (MIS-C), a potentially severe complication of COVID-19 in children. These 17 patients were excluded from the analysis as the “focus was acute SARS-CoV-2 positivity”, leaving 146 patients for their analysis. The authors reviewed these charts to determine if the COVID-19 diagnosis was incidental, potentially symptomatic, or significantly symptomatic
Of these 146 patients, 58 (39.7%) were classified as having incidental infection. Of the children with symptomatic COVID-19, some were very sick. Twenty children (14%) were “significantly symptomatic” defined as “patients with respiratory or cardiac symptoms consistent with COVID-19 requiring respiratory support or ICU-level care”. These children were hospitalized for an average of 12.6 days. Several patients required “substantial respiratory support”. One 16-year-old “medically complex” child died of COVID-19. Children with common conditions, namely obesity and asthma, which are present in at least 20% of American children, were at higher risk for severe disease.
The second paper: Kushner et al.
The second paper by Kushner et al. is titled For COVID” or “With COVID”: Classification of SARS-CoV-2 Hospitalizations in Children. It examined children 18-years or younger from 5/10/20 to 2/10/21. It started the day universal screening of all admissions began at this hospital. 117 children were identified. Of these, 39.3% were asymptomatic and 45% of admissions were categorized as unlikely to be caused by SARS-CoV-2. Again, some of the children with symptomatic COVID-19 were very sick. 7.7% had severe illness, and 12.8% had critical illness. 26.5% required ICU admission due to COVID-19 or MIS-C. One immunocompromised child died.
So are the numbers inflated?
On Twitter, science writer David Zwieg stated that “Pediatric COVID hospitalization numbers are inflated by *at least* 40%, per two peer reviewed studies”:
Pediatric COVID hospitalization numbers are inflated by *at least* 40%, per two peer reviewed studies
It's hard to overstate the significance of this
My 🔥SCOOP🔥 for @NYMag, with official commentary from @MonicaGandhi9 and context from @sdbaral
/1https://t.co/xXDqKiDVLX
— David Zweig (@davidzweig) May 19, 2021
Mr. Zwieg wrote in an article for New York Magazine that “the official tallies were found to be so far off.” Which “official tallies” are these? Beyond the two specific California hospitals where the studies occurred, he does not say. Drs. Beck and Gandhi also claim that the studies “demonstrate that reported hospitalization rates greatly overestimate the true burden of COVID-19 disease in children?” Which specific source for “reported hospitalization rates” do Drs. Beck and Gandhi think is flawed? They do not say, and no reference is given for their claim.
But are they right? Are incidental SARS-CoV-2 infections frequently included in the hospitalization tallies? The best answer I can give is: Likely yes, but it depends on the tally, undercounting may be a bigger problem, and even using the lowest estimate, the number of hospitalized children is not trivial.
How many children have been hospitalized due to COVID-19?
Getting accurate information on exactly how COVID-19 has affected children is difficult. There are several “reported hospitalization rates”, and several tallies of hospitalized children. Additionally, recognizing that undercounting is a significant problem, the CDC has tried to estimate the actual number of hospitalized children. Organizations openly acknowledge the significant challenges they face in trying to accurately determine the number of children hospitalized with COVID-19. For example, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) notes that the “format, content, and metrics of reported COVID-19 data differed substantially by state”. Different states even have different definitions of at what age someone is considered a child.
Given the difficulty in collecting accurate information, the range of pediatric hospitalization rates is wide. According to the AAP, “Children were 1.3%-3.1% of total reported hospitalizations, and between 0.1%-1.9% of all child COVID-19 cases resulted in hospitalization”. Overall, the AAP calculates that 0.8% of children with COVID-19 are hospitalized. A CDC report found that among 69,700 laboratory-confirmed cases of COVID-19 in children younger than 20 years, 2,082 were hospitalized (3%). This study relied “on information systems developed at the local, state, and federal level over decades for communicable disease surveillance that were rapidly adapted to meet an enormous, new public health threat”. Another study by Preston et al. of 869 medical facilities and 20,714 children with COVID-19 found that 2,430 (11.7%) were hospitalized. It included children “who had an inpatient or emergency department encounter with a primary or secondary COVID-19 discharge diagnosis”.
It would be interesting to examine the 2,082 cases in the CDC report and the 2,430 cases in the study by Preston et al. to see if any children with fractures and such were included in the count. It certainly wouldn’t surprise me if a high percentage were. But even if that were the case, these studies again demonstrate that COVID-19 can take a severe toll on some children. In the study by Preston et al., 31% of hospitalized children had severe COVID-19, which was defined as care “requiring treatment in an intensive care unit or step-down unit, involving use of invasive mechanical ventilation, or resulting in death.” In the CDC study, 17% of children required care in the ICU.
Though there is no single “official” count of all hospitalized children in the US, there are several tallies. The AAP aggregates statewide data and there are two federal datasets. These are all prone to two problems: including incidental SARS-CoV-2 cases and undercounting cases.
The AAP’s tally began with 891 cases on 5/21/2020 (at the tail end of the pandemic’s first wave) with data from 17 states and New York City. It currently collects data from 24 states and New York City. California, where both studies were conducted, is not one of these states. From these state dashboards, it reports that 16,013 children have been hospitalized. Extrapolating from this, one can estimate that between 35,000-40,000 children have been hospitalized in the US. The AAP acknowledges that the state dashboards may include incidental SARS-CoV-2 infections, writing “At this time, states are not providing data related to symptoms”.
Do all of these state dashboards systemically inflate hospitalizations as is implied? While it is entirely plausible that a large number of incidental SARS-CoV-2 infections have been counted in many, perhaps all, states, I’ve not seen anyone level this charge against any particular state. It’s just assumed, without concrete evidence, that because two hospitals in California counted incidental SARS-CoV-2 that infections every other dataset in the entire country is similarly flawed. Perhaps this is so, but that’s a pretty big assumption. I will note that both hospital systems where I work, New York University and the NYC Health and Hospitals Corporation, require clinicians to distinguish symptomatic from asymptomatic cases from the moment the test is ordered:

I always thought this was to give extra information to the person performing the test. I was wrong. Per my discussions with epidemiologists at both hospitals, this is so admissions can be categorized as either “due to COVID” or “COVID positive, admission due to non-COVID reasons”. So, unlike the two California hospitals in this study, other (larger) hospital systems do make an effort to distinguish between incidental and symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infections. The AAP notes that two states (Arizona and Nebraska) have made downward revisions of cumulative child hospitalizations, indicating that states try to report data accurately and correct errors when discovered. Of course, undercounting is a problem as well. For example, Georgia, where 1,260 children have been hospitalized, notes that their methods do “not capture hospitalizations that occur after a confirmed case was reported and, as such, is likely an underestimation of actual hospitalizations”.
At the federal level, the CDC maintains a dataset called COVID-NET that covers 100 counties in 14 states representing all 10 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services regions. As of 5/15/2021, COVID-NET reports that 2,960 children under 17-years have been hospitalized. As COVID-NET covers about 10% of the US population, this implies that about 30,000 children have been hospitalized throughout the US. Most hospitalized children had no underlying condition.
According to Dr. Christopher A. Taylor, the Deputy Lead at COVID-NET, “COVID-NET includes all children who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 during hospitalization or up to 14 days prior to admission even if their primary reason for admission was likely not related to COVID-19-associated illness.” As such, this tally almost certainly contains cases of incidental SARS-CoV-2 infection. However, undercounting is a potential problem too. In discussing their numbers, the CDC states “the rates provided are likely to be underestimated as COVID-19-associated hospitalizations can be missed due to test availability and provider or facility testing practices.”
An early study based on this data, when 576 children had been reported, involved a complete medical chart review for 208 of them. The study did not mention the discovery of any cases of “incidental” SARS-CoV-2 infection in their chart review, but that doesn’t mean they weren’t there. Consistent with every other study, some of the children were very sick. Sixty-nine (33.2%) were admitted to the ICU, and invasive mechanical ventilation was required by 12 (5.8%). Hispanic and Black children had the highest rates of COVID-19–associated hospitalization, a universal finding in all studies. One child with multiple underlying conditions died.
A dataset maintained by the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services has collected 20,425 pediatric hospitalizations. Given that it relies on “facility-level data for hospital utilization,” it too certainly contains some children with incidental SARS-CoV-2 infection. Either through false negatives, lack of testing capacity or incomplete reporting, many cases of hospitalization due to COVID-19 are surely missed.
Yet other numbers are available. Another CDC report found 11,882 children younger than 17-years had been hospitalized by 12/12/2020, before the pandemic’s peak in January 2021. 7.4% of children in this study needed ICU-level care, a lower rate than other studies. According to data presented by the CDC during the Emergency Use Authorization for the COVID-19 vaccine, 13,000 children between the ages of 12-17 years had been hospitalized. The hospitalization rate for children due to COVID-19 is higher than during the 2009-10 H1N1 influenza pandemic.
As these datasets tally reported hospitalizations to governmental agencies, they are likely a substantial undercount. The CDC has tried to estimate the actual number, writing “Because current surveillance systems do not capture all cases of COVID-19 occurring in the United States, CDC provides these estimates to better reflect the larger burden of COVID-19.” The CDC has a discussion on the limitations of simply counting hospitalizations, noting many ways in which cases could have be missed, especially early in the pandemic when testing was scarce. They created a “simple probabilistic multiplier model” to estimate hospitalizations that is similar to how they have estimated the flu burden for years.
This CDC estimate of hospitalized children is significantly higher than the tallies discussed so far. For the entire population of the United States, the CDC estimates the actual number of hospitalizations is 2.5 times the reported number and pediatric hospitalizations were the most prone to undercounting, writing that “underdetection multipliers…were consistently highest among children.” If this model is correct, then the state and federal tallies are much more likely to underestimate than overestimate pediatric hospitalizations, even if 40% of their dataset is composed of children with incidental SARS-CoV-2 infection. The CDC estimated that by September 2020 65,040 children had been hospitalized with COVID-19. Importantly, they state that “Probable, asymptomatic, and travel-associated cases were excluded from counts of confirmed cases used in this analysis.” Currently, an estimated 192,000 children younger than 17-years have been hospitalized according to the CDC’s Estimated Disease Burden of COVID-19.
Neither Mr. Zwieg nor Drs. Beck and Gandhi discussed these particular datasets, the CDC estimate, or how the new studies might impact these numbers.
What can the studies teach us? Framing matters.
Taken together, the studies reveal two key points. The obvious one is that when all children admitted to the hospital are screened for COVID-19, asymptomatic cases are common. This is an important point, though not a particularly surprising one given that asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection has been known to be common in children since early in the pandemic. Tallies that do not attempt to tease out this difference – and it is clear some do not – could certainly inflate the number of hospitalized children by a significant amount. These studies offer an important warning to future researchers that all hospitalized children with SARS-CoV-2 are not hospitalized because of SARS-CoV-2. As lead author of one of the studies Dr. Roshni Mathew said, “Just knowing that a child is hospitalized and has the virus is not enough information to determine if they are actually sick with COVID-19”.
Second, these studies demonstrate that children admitted with symptomatic COVID-19 are often very sick. Keep in mind one of the studies excluded 10% of children who were diagnosed with MIS-C. Even after this, many children needed ICU-level care, some were intubated, and two died, points that were neglected by many in discussions of these studies.
Perhaps the most interesting lesson is how these studies can be framed in different ways to portray drastically different pictures of how COVID-19 affects children, especially when controversial topics such as school closings are relevant. Stressing the high percentage of incidental COVID-19 cases led to headlines such as Studies Suggest Child Hospitalization Numbers From COVID Are Inflated, Studies Find Hospitalization Data Overstate Kids’ COVID-19 Risk, and The COVID Panic is Over. Let’s Stop Punishing The Innocents – Our Kids.
Yet, I can frame these studies in a much more pessimistic way. One study examined 117 hospitalized children who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, and 55% were hospitalized for symptoms due to COVID-19. Of all children with SARS-CoV-2, 20.5% had severe or critical illness and 26.5% required ICU admission due to COVID-19 or MIS-C. Five required invasive ventilation and one died. The other study examined 163 hospitalized children who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, and 64% were hospitalized for symptoms due to COVID-19. Of these 163 children, 17 had MIS-C and another 20 were “significantly symptomatic” needing respiratory support or ICU-level care. One child died. A journalist could use these studies (and others with similar findings) to write a perfectly accurate article titled “Severe COVID is Common in Hospitalized Children”.
Even noting that children are frequently asymptomatic carriers of SARS-CoV-2 can be framed in a way that is not reassuring to many people. Older teachers may not feel safe returning to classrooms full of unvaccinated children. Parents of high-risk children (or parents who are high-risk themselves) similarly may not feel comfortable sending their children back to crowded schools after reading these papers. One could easily imagine a journalist using this fact in an article urging that vulnerable teachers and children be kept home. My hypothetical, fearmongering journalist could even reference an article by Dr. Gandhi, who last year authored an article titled Asymptomatic Transmission, the Achilles’ Heel of Current Strategies to Control Covid-19.
It is critical that the risks of COVID-19 to children be portrayed accurately
Of course, there is no conflict between these two ways of framing the data. The studies clearly show that asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection is common in children and a small minority will become quite sick, needing ICU-level care. A very small percentage will die. Balanced discussions acknowledge all of these facts. We will never know the exact number of hospitalized children. There are factors that can lead to both an undercounting and overcounting of cases. Balanced discussions acknowledge both of these potential errors.
Even if the final best estimate of hospitalized children turns out to be only 60% of the current best estimate, 60% of a large number is still a large number. If one assumes every hospitalized child was accounted for and that incidental SARS-CoV-2 infections were included in both the COVID-NET and AAP tallies at the 40% rate found in these studies, this means a minimum of 20,000 children have been hospitalized. That’s not nothing, especially when up to 30% are sick enough to go to the ICU. If we instead use the CDC’s estimate of 192,000 children and assume it too is inflated by 40%, this means 115,000 children have been hospitalized.
Drs. Beck and Gandhi write that “via these studies, parents and policy makers should be reassured that pediatric hospitalization for severe COVID-19 disease is indeed rare.” This does not seem to be a valid conclusion from the papers. Just because some children are incidentally found to have SARS-CoV-2 on hospital admission, we cannot then conclude that severe COVID-19 disease is “rare”. Study author Dr. Mathew noted his research doesn’t accurately measure the rate at which kids get sick with COVID-19. Dr. Stefan Baral similarly noted that the hospital datasets used in these studies “were not designed to infer the prevalence and severity of an infectious virus”.
Of course, we also lack a shared definition of “rare”. With polio, 70% of children have no symptoms and less than 1% develop flaccid paralysis. Of the 1% of children with flaccid paralysis only 2-5% died, though this number would certainly be smaller today with modern medical care. Are the harms of polio rare? While I fully agree that the rate of severe COVID-19 is low in children, uncommon outcomes multiplied many millions of times add up. Even reducing the “official estimate” by 40% still means that tens of thousands or even over 100,000 children were hospitalized. This fact was mostly absent from discussions on these studies, and reasonable people might not consider this outcome “rare.”
Additionally, the CDC has documented 3,742 cases of MIS-C. 60-70% of these patients are admitted to intensive care and 1-2% die. During the peak of the pandemic, up to 100 children were hospitalized every week in the UK with MIS-C. Serious conditions such as MIS-C are also prone to undercounts. Recently, Texas Children’s Hospital reported it has cared for more than 150 young patients with MIS-C, even though the official CDC tally for all of Texas is less than 100 cases. As Dr. Lara Shekerdemian, chief of critical care at Texas Children’s said, “If our hospital has seen well over 150, then clearly that number is not accurate”. According to Dr. Shekerdemian, about 75% of children with MIS-C need ICU-level care. Though the death rate is mercifully very low, between 437 and 582 children have died in the US. Again, that’s not nothing, and, excluding infants, COVID-19 will be one of the top 10 killers of children during the pandemic. Beyond these direct harms, tens of thousands of children have been orphaned, and it is a near certainty that some of these deceased parents contracted the disease from their children. The fact that many asymptomatic children screen positive for SARS-CoV-2 on hospital admission doesn’t change any of these numbers.
The toll COVID-19 has taken on children equals or exceeds that of several other vaccine-preventable diseases prior to vaccines being discovered, even with much of normal life suspended. Drs. Beck and Gandhi also write that the risk of COVID-19 to children should be “contextualized in comparison to other common respiratory illnesses (i.e. influenza and RSV)”. In the past three years, with society open and normal, the flu killed an average of 176 children per year. During the 2020-2021 flu season, with COVID-19 restrictions in place, the CDC recorded just a single pediatric death. Clearly, COVID-19 is much more dangerous to children than the flu. (I was unable to find data for RSV this year).
Additionally, we still have much to learn. Admissions where SARS-CoV-2 infection was deemed “incidental” in these studies, such as seizures, diabetic ketoacidosis, and even appendicitis might not turn out to be incidental after all, a possibility acknowledged by Kushner et al. Moreover, the potential long-term effects of COVID-19, if any, won’t be known for years. Some children, even those who weren’t sick enough to be hospitalized, may not fully recover. Some children have not regained their sense of smell and taste. At least five American hospitals have opened “long-haul clinics” for pediatric patients. Some children, even those without symptoms, meet criteria for thrombotic microangiopathy, which causes small clots in blood vessels. The long-term significance of this, if any, is unknown. The study author, Dr. David Teachey said, “The biggest take-home message for me is we still have lots to learn about SARS-CoV-2 in children and adults. We should not make guesses about the short- and long-term impact of infection in children.” I agree.
Even among the vast majority of children who do fully recover, some were nonetheless quite sick for a period. Estimates from the UK are “that 12.9% of UK children aged 2 to 11, and 14.5% of children aged 12 to 16, still have symptoms five weeks after their first infection”. According to another study, less than 2% of children had symptoms lasting longer than 8-weeks, a fact celebrated on Twitter by Drs. Gandhi and Beck as “good news” and “great to know”. However, as the CDC estimates that over 26 million American children have had COVID-19, this means that about 500,000 children had symptoms for 8-weeks or longer.
From recent research, 98% of kids with Covid recover in 8 weeks or less.
From recent research, about 500,00 American children have Covid symptoms 8 weeks or more.
Both of these are saying the same thing.
Pay attention to how data is framed. pic.twitter.com/ijGFmO9Xx6
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) May 31, 2021
Reasonable people many not consider this number to be “good news”. Many of these affected children don’t show up in any statistics currently. It will take years before researchers are able to adequately quantify how COVID-19 affects children.
I believe that those writing about COVID-19 and children should present these basic facts and raw numbers so readers can decide for themselves if they feel the harms to children are “rare” or not. Reasonable people may look at how COVID-19 has harmed some children and conclude these harms are not “rare.”
To be clear, I am very optimistic for the US and other countries fortunate enough to have access to vaccines. Barring a nasty variant, the worst is over for America and its children. Cases and deaths are falling. It’s beautiful. Thanks to vaccines and the virus itself, there’s enough immunity that COVID-19 will never overwhelm an American city again, and there are hopeful signs that this immunity will persist for years. I fully hope and expect that schools will be able to open safely this fall and was very happy to learn schools will be open for my children. However, COVID-19 is not gone, and it probably never will be. Vaccine uptake remains depressingly low in large swaths of the country. Millions of children have been vaccinated, but most are not and many never will be. COVID-19 remains nearly as dangerous as ever for the unvaccinated.
These studies have made an important contribution, and everyone should welcome the notion that COVID-19 has hospitalized fewer children than initially thought. Drs. Gandhi and Beck wrote eloquently on the harms of school closures and social isolation. These harms are real and they must be part of the conversation, though we are just learning about these as well. There some hopeful signs the harms of school closures may not be as great as initially feared.
Conclusion: COVID still hurts kids
Millions of children have contracted COVID-19. Millions more remain vulnerable. Discussions on COVID-19 and children should acknowledge the totality of how it affects them. No one benefits when the risks are sensationalized or completely glossed over. This is true for both the harms of the virus and the restrictions enacted to contain it. The vast majority of children who get COVID-19 will be fine, but not all. Preventing children from getting and spreading COVID-19 is good. This shouldn’t be controversial. As Drs. Gandhi and Beck write “It is critical that the risks of COVID-19 to children be portrayed accurately”.
Indeed.
ADDENDUM: Seen yesterday on Twitter:
Tomorrow's @CDCMMWR will have details on "troubling data regarding the hospitalizations of adolescents with COVID-19," @CDCDirector said at today's @WHCOVIDResponse briefing https://t.co/zult2HNXya pic.twitter.com/7Kbcqrmxb9
— Alexander Tin (@Alexander_Tin) June 3, 2021
It might well be necessary to update this post after this study is released.

COVID-19 is Deadlier Than the Flu for Children
While COVID-19 killed 500 children over the past year, the flu killed just one.
Jonathan Howard on July 16, 2021
Link

It is natural for people to compare COVID-19 to other contagious diseases, namely influenza. Journalists and politicians often compare the two diseases, particularly in children. Many who make this comparison claim the impact of the two diseases is similar, and thus the reaction to COVID-19, at least for children, has been overwrought. Even some doctors make this comparison. Dr. Monica Gandhi, for example, tweeted this March:
Saw ? about what child should wear on plane when they go and visit their vaccinated grandparents with vaccinated parents- just simple mask. Children much less at risk severe disease (11 deaths in CA from COVID-19 in children; 16 from influenza 2 yrs ago)https://t.co/ul2skm6G97
— Monica Gandhi MD, MPH (@MonicaGandhi9) March 16, 2021
Currently, California reports that 28 children have died of COVID-19. I wonder if she will update her tweet.
There are two ways to compare the diseases: which is more dangerous for those who contract it and which is more harmful overall, the latter being the more important of the two metrics from the point of view of public health. It may be true that children younger than 5 years have a slightly lower risk of dying if they catch COVID-19 than if they catch the flu. However, as COVID-19 is much more contagious, its total harms for children exceed that of the flu, a very simple point that often eludes those who compare these diseases.  Think about it this way. I’d rather have my son get COVID-19 than Ebola, but he was much safer when the first Ebola patient came to New York City than when the first COVID-19 patient arrived here.
Comparisons between the flu and COVID-19 are confounded by the fact that much of normal life was suspended the past year and masks were ubiquitous. These measures lowered the transmission of both diseases. Therefore, the most meaningful comparison between the two diseases is the past year. The numbers couldn’t be clearer. According to the CDC, 490 children under age 17 years have died of COVID-19 in the US. This number was derived from an analysis of 83% of the total number of COVID-19 deaths, so the actual number of pediatric deaths is certainly a bit higher than this.
In contrast, the CDC reported that just one child died of the flu during the 2020-2021 flu season.  Those who compare the two diseases curiously omit this fact.  Even in previous years, the flu killed less children than COVID-19. According to the CDC:
Since 2004-2005, flu-related deaths in children reported to CDC during regular flu seasons have ranged from 37 to 199 deaths. (During the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, 358 pediatric flu-related deaths were reported to CDC from April 2009 to September 2010.)
The CDC would later increase the estimate of deaths to 1,090 during the H1N1 pandemic.  Aside from this pandemic strain, not once since the CDC started tracking pediatric flu deaths in 2004-2005 has the flu killed more children in a year than COVID-19.  This is true even taking into account incomplete reporting of the flu.  The CDC said in the deadliest flu season, 2018-2019, that “statistical modeling suggests approximately 434 deaths may have occurred” even though only 199 deaths were reported.  Of course, there is no guarantee that the CDC has tallied every pediatric death from COVID-19.  (Addendum 11/2021:  The CDC released data showing that the flu hospitalized just 9 children ages 5-11 years this year.  During the same time frame COVID-19 hospitalized 8,300 children ages 5-11 years.)
While the number of children killed by the flu would certainly be higher without the flu vaccine, promoting flu vaccination is unfortunately not the goal of people who compare it to COVID-19. This highlights an interesting fact – most people who compare these diseases ignore their most crucial similarities. Both diseases can kill hundreds of children per year. Both diseases can send tens of thousands children to the hospital, some needing ICU-level care. Both diseases can be largely prevented with a tragically underused vaccine.
Acknowledging that COVID-19 is deadlier than the flu for children does not mean that policy recommendations automatically follow. In contrast, denial of this reality limits our ability to honestly discuss the trade-offs of various policies. As such, those who write about children and COVID-19 have an obligation to present facts, rather than specious comparisons. A disease that killed 500 children the past year is much worse than a disease that killed one child. Writers who suggests otherwise are woefully misinformed. So are their readers.

Children, Underlying Conditions, and COVID-19
That we can identify children who have a higher risk for severe outcomes shouldn’t be used to minimize the virus and argue against vaccination in healthy children. Rather, we should recognize there are populations of vulnerable children that need extra protection, and the best way to do this is through vaccinating ourselves and all eligible children.
Jonathan Howard on November 5, 2021
Link

A common strategy for those who wish to minimize the impact of COVID-19 on children and young people is to claim that only those with underlying conditions die from the virus. As such, it is worthwhile to explore the veracity of this claim, to examine the underlying conditions that endanger children, and to consider the implications of these findings. Information on this topic comes from two studies, one by McCormick et al. that examined 112 deceased people under age 21 years, and another by Bixler et al. that examined 121 deaths in this age group.
What percentage of deaths occur in healthy young people?
The study by McCormick et al. found that 86% of decedents had at least one underlying condition, while the study by Bixler et al found that 75% of decedents had an underlying condition. Overall, 46 out of 233 (20%) young people who died in these studies had no underlying conditions. Considering the base rate, specifically that about 75% of children are healthy, this means the risk of death to any individual healthy child is exceedingly low. No one knows the exactly number of infected children, but a ballpark estimate is that fewer than 1 in 100,000 healthy children who contract COVID-19 will die from it.
Which are the risk factors for severe disease and death in young people?
The study by McCormick et al. found that found that obesity (42%), asthma (29%), and developmental disorders (22%) were most common underlying conditions in deceased young people. The study by Bixler et all found that asthma (28%), obesity (27%), neurologic and developmental conditions (22%), and cardiovascular conditions (18%) were the most common underlying conditions in deceased young people. In both studies, about 75% of deaths occurred in Hispanic, non-Hispanic Black, and non-Hispanic American Indian/Alaskan Native persons. Another study found that, obesity, type 1 diabetes and cardiac/circulatory congenital anomalies are risk factors for severe COVID-19 illness, as is prematurity for children younger than 2 years-old.
This means the risk for healthy young people is very low, but not zero
It is clear that certain common underlying conditions pose a significant risk for death from COVID-19 for young people. However, the risk of death for healthy children is not zero. As millions of children have contracted COVID-19, rare risks have added up. According to the CDC’s COVID data tracker, 805 children younger than 18 years have died of COVID-19 thus far. If 20% of decedents were healthy, this means that around 161 healthy children have died of COVID-19 in the USA. 161 dead children isn’t nothing – at least I feel that way. It’s less than the number of children who drown per year, but it’s more than the number of children who die from school shootings or bike accidents each year, as well as from other multiple other vaccine-preventable diseases before vaccines were available.
I previously argued that how COVID-19 affects children is independent of how it affects elderly people. COVID-19 isn’t necessarily benign for children just because elderly people are more endangered. Similarly, COVID-19’s potential impact on healthy children is independent of how it affects children with underlying conditions. COVID-19 isn’t necessarily benign for healthy children just because children with underlying conditions are more endangered. Healthy children have some risk of dying, and of course death is not the only bad outcome from COVID-19. Healthy children are also at risk for hospitalization, and some hospitalized children are extremely sick, needing mechanical ventilation. Other children may feel sick, some for weeks. We need to be humble about the possibility of long-term consequences we cannot currently appreciate. There have been over 5,200 cases of MIS-C. Other than being more common in Black and Hispanic children, MIS-C seems to strike children randomly. The majority of children with MIS-C spend time in the ICU and 20% need mechanical ventilation. 46 children have died of MIS-C. The vast majority of healthy children who contract COVID-19 will be fine, thankfully, but not all.
This means most children who died from covid-19 had decades of life stolen from them
The most common underlying conditions that predispose to severe outcomes, obesity and asthma, are generally not fatal childhood diseases. Despite the claims of contrarian doctors who wish to minimize COVID-19’s impact on young people, few pediatric COVID-19 deaths occurred in children with leukemia who were fated to die on a Saturday when they instead succumbed to the virus on a Friday. Most children with underlying conditions who died from COVID-19 had decades of life stolen from them.
This means all children matter and should be vaccinated against COVID-19
Happily, the vaccine can protect adolescents from these grave outcomes. A recent CDC report found that among 179 hospitalized COVID-19 patients ages 12-18 years, 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. It further found that “All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients”. As the vaccine is 90% effective against symptomatic COVID-19 in children ages 5-11 years, I fully expect similar data will soon emerge for this age group, along with news reports of regretful parents who falsely believed the virus posed zero risk to their children. The safety of the vaccine, especially myocarditis, will also have to be tracked over time as the vaccine is rolled out to younger children. However, as myocarditis is generally less common in young children compared to teenagers, vaccine experts are cautiously optimistic it will be less of an issue for them.
Though the benefits of vaccinating healthy children are significantly less than for everyone else, they are nonetheless very real. To make an analogy, the risk of death from any individual car trip is also exceedingly low, but my kids are buckled in every time, even though seat belts have risks too. 161 healthy children would be alive today had they been vaccinated. Tens of millions of children in the US have yet to contract the virus, and the vaccine will certainly save some of their lives. I can’t believe I have to say this, but this is a good thing. The only group of children that won’t benefit from vaccination are those that can miraculously dodge the virus for the next 80 years. Though it’s often portrayed as a means to help protect society at large, the purpose of vaccinating healthy children is to primarily protect them from COVID-19. It’s just a nice bonus that this may also protect their parents and more vulnerable classmates.
This brings me to my most important point: those vulnerable classmates matter. The lives of children with underlying conditions are no less valuable and important than the lives of healthy children. They deserve to go to school and be safe. They deserve the opportunity to grow and have children of their own. I expect these children’s lives would be valued more highly if the victims were primarily healthy White children. Too often, discourse on these children tacitly treats them as expendable. The JCVI in the UK even said, “On the whole children who died had serious underlying conditions such that they may have succumbed to other winter respiratory viruses”. In other words, “Don’t feel too bad about these weak, dead kids.  Some other virus was going to get them soon anyway.” This notion seems plagiarized from an anti-vaccine article, a medical textbook from 1850, or worse.
That we can identify children who have a higher risk for severe outcomes shouldn’t be used to minimize the virus and argue against vaccination in healthy children. Rather, we should recognize there are populations of vulnerable children that need extra protection, and the best way to do this is through vaccinating ourselves and all eligible children.
        ◦ It’s astonishing and depressing that this is controversial.

The CDC Should Do Better
The CDC’s failure to report clear and accurate data about how COVID-19 is affecting children has opened the door to those who wish to minimize its impact by spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt. The CDC needs to do better.
Jonathan Howard on August 5, 2021
Link

A problem at the CDC
The CDC maintains two separate tallies for COVID-19 deaths. The first of these, the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, which covers 83% of COVID-19 deaths thus far, reports that 534 children have died of COVID-19. This number is derived from “deaths reported by state, local, and territorial health departments”. The second of these, the provisional COVID-19 death counts from the National Center for Health Statistics, reports that 349 children have died of COVID-19. This number is derived from “information from death certificates” and it “offers the most accurate death counts”. I am unsure what explains the large discrepancy between these two numbers.
Things get more confusing. A CDC analysis found that death certificates have been very reliable overall this pandemic. Only 2.5% of them “had co-occurring diagnosis codes that could not be plausibly categorized as either a chain-of-event or significant contributing condition”. This included deaths such as suicide, homicide, and accidents. However, the CDC’s analysis found that of 182 death certificates for children under 18 years-old, 64 (35.2%) were unlikely to be due to COVID-19.
The National Center for Health Statistics notes that “most deaths from COVID-19 must be coded by a person” and that “COVID-19 should not be reported on the death certificate if it did not cause or contribute to the death”. They claim there is an “ongoing review of death certificates as they are received” and that they are “always working towards 100% completeness and accuracy of death certificates”. As such, I presume this tally would exclude a child who died in a car crash and tested positive for COVID-19, but I am not completely certain of this. It would be a problem if 35% of the deaths in either of the CDC’s tallies were incidental COVID-19 cases. Of course, undercounting pediatric deaths is likely a problem as well as there is no guarantee that every child who died of COVID-19 was reported to the CDC. One credible site maintained by three epidemiologists tallied 582 pediatric deaths by March 2021.
I was recently critical of a problematic editorial by Dr. Marty Markay questioning whether healthy children should be vaccinated against COVID-19. In that piece, Dr. Makary said that a “tremendous number of government and private policies affecting kids are based on one number”, the number of children killed by COVID-19. As policy is based on much more than this one number, this statement is completely false. However I completely agree with a core point of his essay that the CDC should give clearer information about how COVID-19 has affected children. Even the director of the CDC did not give a precise number during recent testimony, saying that about 400 children had died of COVID-19.
The virus is worse than the vaccine
It is possible to criticize the CDC and still recognize the benefits of the vaccine outweigh the risks of the virus. Despite Dr. Makary’s insinuation otherwise, no reasonable person would alter their opinion on this topic depending on whether the number of deceased children was 300 or 600. After all, if COVID-19 killed 300 children, that’s still 300 more children who died of the virus than of the vaccine, and 8.9 million adolescents have been vaccinated so far.
Of course death is not the only bad outcome from COVID-19, an often overlooked point. Many thousands of children have been hospitalized due to COVID-19, some in the ICU need mechanical ventilation. Thankfully most survive, but a handful really suffer. Even if every child who went to the ICU survived, preventing these devastating hospitalizations, as well as potential long-term symptoms (discussed here by Dr. Steven Novella) of COVID-19, would justify the vaccine, in my opinion. Complications of the vaccine, namely myocarditis, are real, but are less common and generally much less severe than hospitalizations due to the virus. There may be preliminary evidence that post-vaccine myocarditis is much less common than previously thought. According to one news report from Israel, there were just 3 cases out of 200,000 people vaccinated age 12-15.
Unfortunately, many people are under the illusion that COVID-19 is completely harmless to children, and as a result, things are currently not going well for children in many states (such as Arkansas, Florida, Texas, Oklahoma, Missouri, Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, South Carolina, Kansas, Tennessee, and Georgia). Overall, according to a report from the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Children’s Hospital Association, 72,000 children contracted the virus last week, compared to 39,000 just one week before. About 1 in 3,200 children are expected to contract multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), a potentially devastating disorder that affects the GI tract, skin, and heart. In Florida, 32 children were hospitalized per day the last week of July. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, which also tallies pediatric deaths, 9 children died from COVID-19 just last week.
Pediatricians are sounding the alarm bell:
Dr. Trey Dunbar, neonatologist & Pres. of Our Lady of the Lake Children’s Health is seeing a 5-6 fold increase in +COVID children in the ER. 50% of admissions need ICU for breathing support, including oxygen & ventilators. Children do die from COVID pic.twitter.com/m99F60dpwK
— Cleavon MD 💉 💉 💉 (@Cleavon_MD) August 3, 2021
Dr. Mark Kline Physician-in-Chief at Children's Hospital New Orleans dispels the myth that only children with pre-existing conditions are getting sick: "Half the children we are seeing with COVID were perfectly healthy" pic.twitter.com/ABXzlhJfgR
— Cleavon MD 💉 💉 💉 (@Cleavon_MD) August 2, 2021
According to Dr. Rick Barr, the chief clinical officer at Arkansas Children’s Hospital, parents of hospitalized children are “shocked” because the “messaging out there has been that kids don’t really get sick with Covid, and we didn’t see serious illnesses, except for rare instances, with the previous variant”. Having seen what COVID-19 has done to their child, parents of hospitalized children are now “encouraging other parents to get their kids vaccinated,” he said.
Fortunately, the vaccine seems to be working very well. According to Dr. Marcos Mestre from Nicklaus Children’s Hospital in Miami, “We have not yet admitted a child 12 and over who’s been vaccinated and required hospitalization”. Most countries with abundant supply are vaccinating adolescents. Even one of the last holdouts, the UK, recently decided to vaccinate 16 and 17-year olds. Predictably there are reports of parents regretting their decision to not vaccinate their child after they become seriously ill with COVID-19. I expect to see many more such stories in the future, and each one will be a preventable tragedy.
Though we will never get an exact tally, we deserve more reliable information about how many children have died of COVID-19 and the characteristics of these children. The CDC’s failure to provide this information has been a gift to those who exploit this inexactitude to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines, children, and COVID-19.

Will You Share These Numbers?
Doctor who value evidence should be willing to share basic facts.
Jonathan Howard on February 13, 2022
Link
I’ve previously proposed that COVID-19 is more dangerous than the flu for children. Yet many smart doctors disagree. They believe that “For the unvaccinated child, COVID presents a health risk to children that is on par with the flu”, and that “While children do get infected, their risk for COVID death is minuscule, lower than their already low risk of dying from the flu”.
Though we don’t see eye-to-eye on this topic, I am certain we all agree that doctors who communicate with the general public about COVID-19 have an obligation to to share essential, accurate facts with their readers. Here are two such facts.
     1.  According to the CDC, since the pandemic started, 6 children have died of the flu.
     2.  According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, 21 children died of COVID-19 last week.
Whether in articles or on social media, I expect pro-vaccine doctors who opine about the relative severity of COVID-19 and the flu will have no reservations about simply sharing these two basic numbers, presented without any editorializing. To provide a bit more detail, I expect some people may want to note the AAP’s COVID-19 death tally, which does not collect data from every state, jumped from 807 to 828 last week.
Regardless of our opinions, doctors who value evidence and nuance should be willing to share basic facts about the two viruses since the start of the pandemic.
Right?

Normalizing Dead Children
Pediatric fatalities from both guns and COVID could be greatly reduced if more people simply cared.
Jonathan Howard on April 22, 2022
Link
In a previous article, I described how COVID has warped our sense of what is acceptable when it comes to children suffering from a vaccine-preventable disease. Previously, doctors agreed it was unacceptable to have a single child die from such a disease. Today, influential doctors with large platforms feel differently. They relentlessly minimize the virus and over-hype every vaccine side effect, suggesting the vaccine will kill as many healthy children as the virus. This is standard anti-vaccine blather and should be called out as such.
I also wrote about how some doctors discourage anyone from acknowledging any individual child who dies from the virus. One doctor said doing so was “crass & undignified,” while another said sharing such information was “fear-based messaging“, a sign of communication “gone awry”. Some doctors have written many volumes on pediatric COVID, neglecting to mention the simple fact that over 1,000 children have died.
I noted how this erasure of pediatric tragedies was unique to COVID, with one major exception, guns. Indeed, there seems to be many similarities to how pediatric deaths from COVID and guns are treated. Various forces want us to sweep these tragedies under the rug. They are just the cost of allowing adults to do whatever they want. In the same way that some doctors disparage those who wish to acknowledge the existence of children who died of COVID, after a mass shooting, certain politicians predictably say that “this is not a time” to discuss how to keep more children alive – as if there is ever an inappropriate time for such a topic.
In extreme cases, we are encouraged to doubt that children are dying at all. Wretched conspiracy theorist Alex Jones famously called the Sandy Hook shooting a hoax, leading to abuse of grieving parents. I’m thrilled he has finally faced real consequences for this. With COVID, there are those who suggest that large numbers of children are dying with COVID, not of COVID. We are falsely told that only children with leukemia, with limited life expectancies, die of COVID – though of course normal people are saddened any time a child’s life is cut short.
Today, guns are a leading cause of fatalities in children and young adults, even more than car crashes. According to recent commentary in The New England Journal of Medicine:
For more than 60 years, motor vehicle crashes were the leading cause of injury-related death among young people. Beginning in 2017, however, firearm-related injuries took their place to become the most common cause of death from injury.
Thousands of young lives are now lost due to guns every year – a horrific tragedy. The authors of the NEJM commentary had it exactly right when they said:
This change occurred because of both the rising number of firearm-related deaths in this age group and the nearly continuous reduction in deaths from motor vehicle crashes. The crossing of these trend lines demonstrates how a concerted approach to injury prevention can reduce injuries and deaths — and, conversely, how a public health problem can be exacerbated in the absence of such attention.
When we care and focus on a problem, we can make real improvements and save lives. Conversely, when we ignore a problem, it can fester and worsen. It’s shameful to drive drunk, but Congressmen and their families proudly pose with powerful weapons on their Christmas cards. The National Rifle Association, which acted as a “foreign asset” in providing Russian officials access to American political organizations in 2016, admonished doctors who advocated policies they would keep children from dying, saying they were “self-important” and they should “stay in their lane”. Amazingly, for 25 years, the CDC was refused funding to even study gun violence in America. Talk about sticking your head in the sand. Imagine how little progress would have been made if the automobile industry managed to enact a similar research ban on traffic fatalities.
People more knowledgeable than I have proposed solutions to gun violence in America. I wish there were a vaccine against bullets, though some doctors would invariably advise against it, arguing that only a small percentage of children die from guns and adults are killed more often. However, I hope you’ll notice how normalized preventable pediatric deaths have become. The next time you read about children being shot at school or church, you may be horrified, but you won’t be surprised. A headline that reads “5-year-old boy murdered execution style in Detroit home, family says, mom and her boyfriend also killed” isn’t astonishing. These headlines appear every day. Similarly, the American Academy of Pediatrics added 28 children to its grim tally of pediatric COVID deaths this week alone with little outcry.
There is yet another similarity between these two killers. In both instances, most of the victims are non-White, and I suspect that their deaths would receive more attention otherwise. Henrika McCoy, a social worker in Chicago and associate professor of social work said about Black shooting victims, “We don’t, as a group, harken a lot of sympathy. So more often than not, people think that if something happened to us, we deserved it.” She’s right.
Pediatric fatalities from both guns and COVID could be greatly reduced if more people simply cared. Instead, we’ve lost our capacity to be shocked. It’s just normal for all of us that large numbers of children will die preventable deaths. It’s normal that influential voices, including doctors, will encourage us to erase these children, to not acknowledge their existence and the manner of their deaths.
How sad is that?

Was the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic to Blame for an Increase in Unexpected Infant Deaths in 2020?
New CDC data on unexpected infant deaths in 2020 show an increase, but only in Black infants. There is a good chance that this is an indirect result of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic.
Clay Jones on March 31, 2023
Link

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has resulted in millions of deaths worldwide and a wide variety of adverse health outcomes ranging from mild inconveniences to serious acute and chronic complications. In the pediatric population, death is a concern but thankfully has been relatively uncommon. But many children, particularly those that are not white and wealthy, have faced severe health challenges.
Earlier this month, freshly reported CDC data on sudden and unexpected infant deaths (SUID) from 2020 was analyzed and published in Pediatrics. The findings raise the question that an increase in certain causes of infant death might be yet another sequela of this grossly mishandled pandemic. And, as I’ll explain shortly, once again it appears that communities of color are bearing the brunt of coronavirus related misfortune.
I last wrote about CDC data on SUID data back in May of 2021. In that post, I discussed SUID, SIDS, accidental suffocation and strangulation in bed (ASSB), as well as the history of our tracking and response to these outcomes in detail, so please check it out. At the time, a study breaking down newly released CDC numbers had revealed that we still had a long way to go when it came to education of families on modifiable risk factors contributing to these preventable deaths.
In that 2021 paper, also published in the flagship journal of the AAP, researchers looked at CDC data from 2011 to 2017 using an improved systematic approach that avoided most of the confusion inherent in historical reporting of SUID cases. They found that 72% of cases were associated with unsafe sleep practices. Clearly, as I summarized in my conclusion to the post, our approach to preventing these tragic outcomes was failing our patients and their families:
After analyzing the data, the authors determined key implications for pediatric healthcare professionals. Because more than 70% of SUID cases involved unsafe sleep environments, it is crucial that we figure out why caregivers aren’t following our recommendations. It is imperative that we develop more effective ways to educate caregivers and to help them adhere to guidelines. One potential way to improve adherence and to save infant lives would be to determine high risk groups and target our educational outreach.”
In the new study looking at CDC SUID data from 2015 to 2020, researchers discovered an unsettling increase in cases designated as sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), which is a subcategory of SUID. This was the first increase in this cause of death in 5 years, and it occurred in a year that saw a record low overall infant mortality rate in the United States. There could be an explanation other than a true increase in cases, but as you’ll see shortly I’m skeptical, and questions remain that will only be answered by more detailed data over the next few years.
In 2020, 542 infant deaths per 100,000 live births occurred, a record low in the United States. That same year, however, the overall rate of SIDS specifically was 15% higher than in 2019, with 38.2 deaths per 100,000 live births. The total SUID rate per 100,000 live births was also higher, increasing from 89.5 to 92.1 in 2020, but this wasn’t a statistically significant increase. There is, of course, more to the story.
SUID rates have always been considerably higher in Black and Native American populations, and this trend continued in 2020 with rates of 214 and 205.1 per 100,000 live births respectively. To put this in perspective, SUID in White babies occurred at a rate of 75.6 per 100,000 live births in 2020. Hispanic and non-Hispanic Asian infants historically have had even lower rates, and this didn’t change in 2020. The rate of SUID in the latter group was only 23.3 per 100,000 live births, which is higher than zero, so too high, but still remarkably low in comparison.
What really stood out in the 2020 numbers was that every group had SUID rates that were either lower or stable except for Black infants. This group saw an increase of 11%, from 189.9 to 214 cases per 100,000 live births. So if the increase in SIDS cases is real, and I think it is, it isn’t a stretch to imagine that most of those additional deaths involved Black infants.
What could have been behind the increase in SIDS cases, and the increase in SUID in Black infants in 2020? There isn’t any proven explanation, but honestly this seems pretty obvious to me. Maybe not as obvious as the relationship between parachutes and skydiving survival, but I don’t think it’s that much of a mystery really.
First off, the authors state quite correctly that these increases were not caused directly by infection with SARS-CoV-2. That would have been easy to pick up on. Considerably more plausible is that it was an indirect effect of COVID-19 as it swept across the country in 2020, and the subsequent measures put into place in order to reduce its spread, both of which were more likely to cause severe disruptions in communities of color.
The ultimate cause is almost certainly multifactorial, involving increased financial stress and decreased access to prenatal and pediatric care as well as safety-net support programs like WIC and Healthy Start. During these encounters, caregivers of young infants will often receive education on safe sleep. There are numerous additional potential variables that could have resulted in families being less likely to adhere to recommendations aimed at reducing the risk of SUID. For example, perhaps some families were more likely to bedshare, or less likely to place a baby to sleep on their backs, because of significant psychological stress related to unemployment or being evicted from a stable home. Childcare upheaval resulting in adults or even older children needing to assume caregiver duties might also have played a role in some of these deaths.
The authors of the study point out that a potential factor in the increase in reported SIDS cases was diagnostic substitution. There were new guidelines for certification and reporting of SUID cases published by the National Association of Medical Examiners and the Radcliffe Congress in 2019 that could have increased the likelihood of designating a death as SIDS rather than ASSB. But, as they also point out in the paper, it is unlikely that any new guidelines would have been adopted widely enough to make a difference that quickly. Also, and I’m surprised that the authors did not mention this, there was not a corresponding decrease in ASSB cases in 2020.
Diagnostic substitution would also not explain an increase in unexpected deaths only in Black infants. But maybe this data is just noise, or a statistical fluke. Maybe more data over the next few years will demonstrate a regression to the mean and even a return to the steady decline in SIDS cases we had been experiencing. I certainly hope so.
In the meantime, there is simply no good reason not to focus on social determinants of health, and the significant disparities in care, as the primary causal factors. As the study authors state, it has been abundantly clear since the beginning that the pandemic has impacted communities of color, including infants, more severely for a number of key reasons:
Factors exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic and related stay-at-home orders (eg, access to health care, changes to or loss of childcare, parental or caregiver financial and emotional stressors, and increased parental or caregiver substance use) may have also influenced the increased SUID rate among non-Hispanic Black infants in 2020.
Though I’m sadly not very optimistic at this point, we need to better acknowledge how these negative social determinants of health are unfairly clustered in certain groups. And we need to better recognize the generational harm that can occur, increased SUID rates being only one example. Armed with a better understanding, efforts should be focused on reaching these groups with targeted education on how to make infant sleep as safe as possible and to “support, follow-up, and follow-through with families.”

Vulnerable Children Really Count
Why were misinformation doctors so eager to spread the easily-refutable myth that “no healthy child” had died of COVID?
Jonathan Howard on August 25, 2023
Link

One zombie myth spread by misinformation doctors is that COVID had a “mortality rate of zero among children without a pre-existing medical condition such as leukemia.”  While deaths of children with “no prior health issues” are mercifully extremely rare, nearly every child in the US has contracted COVID.  A small percentage of a big number can be a big number, especially when it comes to largely preventable deaths of children. Moreover, most children felled by COVID had common, non-fatal conditions, namely obesity and asthma, not leukemia, though even this is not always a death sentence today. The tragic truth is that nearly all children who died of COVID were robbed of many decades of life, and of course, death is not the only bad outcome from COVID.
So why were some doctors so eager to spread the easily-refutable fiction that only vulnerable children died from COVID? Why did they say this was “good news”? I’m not a mind reader, but none of them seemed motivated to raise awareness about the conditions that left millions of children particularly vulnerable. They never launched a campaign to vaccinate children with obesity, or even leukemia for that matter. That would have been laudable. So would have an editorial titled “The Importance of Protecting Vulnerable Children.” Instead, it seemed the purpose of error-filled editorials titled “The Flimsy Evidence Behind the CDC’s Push to Vaccinate Children” was to convince parents: Your child has no risk. They don’t need the vaccine. COVID only kills children who are about to die anyways.
Some people also heard an implicit message here: Vulnerable children don’t really count. This was made explicit on social media recently. In response to a banal comment of mine that “Covid has actually killed and injured kids”,  a philosopher (who later deleted her account) replied:
Consider what this person is saying. Jonathan Howard was wrong to say that COVID killed kids. All the kids who died of COVID were sick anyways. Vulnerable children don’t really count. 
Of course, vulnerable children really count. And even doctors who lack real-world responsibility for treating them should have been willing to promote this message throughout the pandemic.

Cognitive Illusions and How Not to Write About COVID-19 and Children
Many people minimize the deaths and damage COVID-19 has wrought on children because it is “worse in adults”. While it is true that more adults suffer due to the disease, that does not make the harms done to children vanish in a puff of smoke.
Jonathan Howard on July 30, 2021
Link
A problematic statement
In an interview on May 11th 2021, Dr. Monica Gandhi said:
Children and young adults are very low risk for severe disease, about one in a million chance of death for a child under 19 from COVID as opposed to 600 deaths [per million] in the U.S. from adults.
These numbers are all wrong. By the time Dr. Gandhi made this statement, at least 500 people younger than age 19-years had died of COVID-19. As there are not 500 million youngsters in the US, her statement is mathematically impossible. She was also wrong about the death rate for adults, which was about 2,200 per million when she made her statement. Sadly, a highly credentialed doctor from a prestigious university making obvious errors about basic facts in a public forum is now so commonplace, it is worth mentioning only to note these errors always understate, but somehow never overstate, the risks of COVID-19. However, even if Dr. Gandhi had stated factual information, I believe it is problematic to frame pediatric deaths in this manner.
The contrast effect
How our brains perceive an object is determined by what surrounds it as much as the object itself. Optical illusions take advantage of this fact to trick our brains, something psychologists call the contrast effect. The two orange circles below are the same size, but they sure don’t look that way. (Interestingly, this illusion, called the Ebbinghaus illusion, doesn’t seem to trick children.)
The contrast effect can similarly affect how we perceive numbers. Salesmen know this. A $30,000 car might not seem so expensive after you’ve been shown one that costs $60,000. Often during this pandemic, “blue circles facts,” as I will call them, have been used to obscure our ability to appreciate the reality of how COVID-19 has harmed children, the “orange-circle facts” in the middle. Some blue-circle facts are that:
     1.  Children constitute only about 0.08% of the total COVID-19 deaths. They are much less likely to die of the disease than older people.
     2.  Children are more likely to die of suicide than of COVID-19.
     3.  COVID-19 kills only 1 in 50,000 (0.0019%) of children who get it. This number is even lower for healthy children.
These statements are all true and potentially quite useful. It is not necessarily wrong to compare pediatric deaths to adult deaths or to other harms that befall children. We are deluged with information and need some way to contextualize the numbers we encounter daily. The infection fatality rate (the percentage of people who die after contracting a disease) is an important statistic. Blue-circles facts are not intrinsically problematic, and though the word “rare” is imprecise, I agree with those who say the rate at which children suffer severe harms from COVID-19 is very low. I’ve said as much myself. Thankfully, the overwhelming number of children who get COVID-19 will be just fine. I wouldn’t have been too worried had my kids contracted COVID-19. However, blue-circle facts by themselves are incomplete and can be used to distort our understanding of how COVID-19 has harmed children.
Some orange-circle facts are that:
     1.  According to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, COVID-19 has killed over 500 children in the US.
     2.  About 25% of these deaths occurred in healthy children. The most common underlying conditions in children who die are asthma and obesity. As such, these children had their lives shorted by many decades.
     3.  Even accounting for incidental infections, COVID-19 has hospitalized tens of thousands of children, many needing ICU-level care and mechanical ventilation.
     4.  At least 4,196 children have been diagnosed with MIS-C, and most of these children need ICU-level care. This number may be a substantial undercount.
Orange-circle facts are independent of blue-circle facts. The number of children killed or hospitalized by COVID-19 does not depend on how the virus affects adults or how many children commit suicide each year. For example, COVID-19 would not be a worse disease for children if adults were completely spared or if only ten children committed suicide annually. Everyone knows and nobody denies that more children die of accidents, drownings, and suicide than COVID-19. However, hundreds of children have died of COVID-19. That’s not nothing, in my opinion. Of course, COVID-19 is different than accidents, drownings, and suicides in that two injections can prevent the disease in adolescents. Predictably there are news reports of parents regretting their decision not to vaccinate their child after they become seriously ill with COVID-19. I expect to see many more such stories in the future.
The fallacy of minimizing one harm by pointing out a more severe harm is called the fallacy of relative privation, and it has been commonly employed to minimize how COVID-19 has harmed children. No one would be taken seriously if they argued against a suicide prevention program because teens are more likely to die in accidents. No one should be taken seriously if they argue against the COVID-19 vaccine because children are more likely to die of something other than COVID-19.
Though the infection-fatality rate is extremely low for children, rare outcomes multiplied millions of times add up to non-trivial numbers. I fundamentally agree with Dr. Saurabh Jha who wisely said early in the pandemic, “the continued obsession with the denominator, when the numerator speaks for itself is bizarre.” COVID-19 has killed 500 children and is the leading cause of infectious deaths in children. These 500 tragedies are independent of the total number of children who contracted the virus. For example, COVID-19 would not be a worse disease if only 1,000 children contracted it, but 50% died. Either way, 500 children are dead. As CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky said, “Children are not supposed to die”.
"I think we fall into this flawed thinking of saying, 'Only 400 of the 600,000 deaths from COVID-19 have been in children.' Children are not supposed to die."
— CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky responds to question from Sen. Roger Marshall (R-KS). pic.twitter.com/0i6ImKoxrC
— The Recount (@therecount) July 20, 2021
Additionally, we don’t have all the orange-circle facts yet. The long-term consequences of COVID-19, if any, will not be apparent for some time. I said before that I wouldn’t have been too worried had my kids contracted COVID-19, but I’m also grateful they stayed safe and healthy. I’m glad they are older than 12-years, and I vaccinated them as soon as they were eligible.
Beware of articles that omit orange-circle facts
I’ve read nearly a dozen articles suggesting in one way or another that children should not be vaccinated against COVID-19. Even though it can be done in a couple of sentences, I’ve not seen a single one include all orange-circle facts. Some articles don’t include any orange-circle facts at all. Several doctors have written multiple articles on COVID-19 and children without even mentioning that the virus has killed hundreds of children and sent tens of thousands of them to the hospital. You could read the entire works of some prolific writers this pandemic and emerge knowing zero orange-circle facts. I find this astonishing.
Instead, those who wish to minimize the impact of COVID-19 on children only use blue-circle facts. Statements such as “the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young” permeate their writing. This may be correct, but it tells us nothing about how many children have died of COVID-19. I suspect these writers know that many of their readers wouldn’t find 500 dead children and tens of thousands of hospitalized children to be trivial. As such, they only describe the harms to children as “extremely low” or “rare“, rather than explicitly enumerate how COVID-19 has harmed them.
Often these writers feel that policies designed to stop the virus have hurt children more than they’ve helped. They may or may not be right. However, acknowledging orange-circle facts doesn’t suggest any policy positions. One can acknowledge them and still believe that closing outdoor playgrounds was ill-advised or that schools should be open in the fall. I basically feel this way, though I hope schools will make common-sense efforts to prevent students from getting the virus and be willing to adjust if the virus cannot be contained. Based on CDC estimates, around 40 million America children remain vulnerable to COVID-19. If 1 in 50,000 children dies after getting COVID-19, this means that around 800 more children would die if the virus were allowed to spread unchecked throughout the pediatric population. Many thousands more would be hospitalized. This is on par with risks that didn’t shutter schools before the pandemic, but people should be aware of the facts.
What makes this especially sad is that all of this could have been avoided if eligible Americans were willing to be vaccinated. It might not have made that much difference, but I do wonder if more people would have been vaccinated if knew the orange-circle facts and not just the blue-circle facts. Most people have a natural tendency to really want to protect children, even those with underlying conditions.  As I wrote previously it often seems as if children with medical co-morbidities don’t really matter to some people, though of course, the death of a vulnerable child is just as tragic as the death of a healthy child.
Even just a single orange-circle fact can be very compelling. I urge you all to read about Wyatt Gibson, a healthy 5-year old who recently died in Georgia. According to his father,
Wyatt was nothing [but] joy and happiness. We loved having fun and going on adventures together. He loved his momma and his sister so very much, and he was always looking for ways to help.
Behind every statistic there’s a real life that has been cut tragically short and a real family that has been devastated by the loss. We should not forget that.
Doctors writing about COVID-19 and children have an obligation to inform their readers of essential facts. Making informed policy decisions requires acknowledging basic facts and presenting them in a way that doesn’t distort our perception. Articles that omit orange-circle facts actively impair our ability to make informed choices and are scarcely different from those that blatantly misstate facts, though of course many manage to do both (here and here). Thanks to these articles, many people are under the mistaken impression that COVID-19 poses essentially zero threat to young people. As Dr. Andrew Pavia, the chief of pediatric infectious diseases at the University of Utah said,
In any other time, if we had a new disease that killed 300 children, we would be pulling out all the stops, we would be doing everything we could to protect them. And yet people are saying, “well, it’s not so bad, because it’s nothing like what happens to adults.”
If you read an article with only blue-circle facts, ask yourself if the authors are truly trying to inform their readers or if they are instead trying to advance a narrative that would be undermined if they fully enumerated how COVID-19 has harmed children.
I also believe the contrast effect has impacted how some have viewed vaccine-induced myocarditis. Vaccine-related harms can be downplayed because the virus can be so much worse. However, the vaccine has sent hundreds of adolescents and young adults to the hospital. Even though the vast majority of them are back to normal after a short time, this side effect should not be minimized. Notably, many authors who omit orange-circle facts when it comes to the virus are only too willing to enumerate the harms of the vaccine. As Loretta Torrago aptly put it, “Anti-vaxxers love talking about the numerator when it comes to vaccines, but, when it comes to Covid, they fall hard for the denominator.”
My advice: Cover the blue circles
No amount of thought or effort can change how we perceive optical illusions. We can only appreciate that the two orange circles are the same size if we cover up the blue circles that surround them. We can’t do this with COVID-19, or course, but we can try. When considering how COVID-19 has harmed children, I suggest you try to transport yourself back to a blissful time before you heard of COVID-19.
How would you feel then if you knew that a virus would kill 500 American children and hospitalize many thousands more, some intubated in the ICU? Would you wait to voice an opinion until you knew the total number of infected children or how many adults died? Would you wait to form an opinion until you knew exactly how many children die of suicide? Would you shrug and merely say that the harms are “rare”? If you don’t think you would have done any of these things back then, then you shouldn’t do them now.
And if you are the kind of person who writes that “only” hundreds of children have died from COVID-19, consider that normal people won’t benefit from reading your thoughts on children and a deadly virus.

The Consequences of a Medical Myth
There are real-world consequences to medical myths spread by contrarian doctors sheltered from the consequences of their words.
Jonathan Howard on March 13, 2022
Link

A core theme of my prior articles has been that there are real-world consequences to misinformation spread by contrarian doctors who will never care for a child who becomes seriously ill with COVID. A particularly noxious example is the claim that no healthy children have died of COVID. This myth irks me, not just because it’s widespread and dangerous, but also because it’s lazy and trivially easy to refute. I have no idea why someone would claim such a thing.
I first encountered this myth from the pen of Dr. Marty Makary, a creator of many such myths (here and here). In his article “Think Twice Before Giving the COVID Vax to Healthy Kids”, Dr. Makary said the following:
In reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date.
As evidence for this extraordinary claim, Dr. Makary referenced his own paper and claimed it was a study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths”. It turns out that in this study,  three children died, and Dr. Makary used these three children to extrapolate to the hundreds of children who had died by that time. Dr. Makary would later speculate that “maybe the rate of death from the vaccine parallels the rate of death from COVID in a healthy child”. It’s no surprise Dr. Makary has been favorably profiled on RFK Jr.’s anti-vaccine website.
He was wrong about all this, of course. A simple Google search revealed multiple news stories of healthy children who had died of COVID, and a CDC report on 121 deaths of people younger than 21 years, half of whom were younger than 18 years, found that, “Among the 121 decedents, 30 (25%) were previously healthy (no reported underlying medical condition).” Overall, approximately 20% of pediatric deaths occur in healthy children.
Dr. Makary’s myth proved the adage that “a lie can travel around the world and back again while the truth is lacing up its boots”. Dr. Makary was on ZDoggMD’s large podcast where he claimed there’s “never been a documented case of an entirely healthy kid dying of COVID”. Misinformed politicians repeated this false claim as if it were established fact during congressional hearings. Anti-vaxx propagandist Tucker Carlson repeated Dr. Makary’s claim verbatim on his program, saying
Researchers at Johns Hopkins led by Dr. Marty Makary looked closely at those numbers and what they actually meant and here’s what they found, quote: “A mortality rate of zero among children without a preexisting medical condition such as leukemia.”
Even this is wrong. The most common underlying conditions in children who die of COVID are obesity and asthma, not leukemia. These children were robbed of decades of life. Even leukemia is no longer a death sentence. It’s sad when any child dies of COVID.
This brings us to the horrible decision by Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the surgeon general from Florida, who recently recommended against vaccinating healthy children based on bad advice from doctors who don’t treat sick children. Doctors who do care for sick children vigorously opposed Florida’s position- which shouldn’t just be called anti-vaccine, but also pro-virus, a phenomenon I’ve discussed before.
Part of the basis for Florida’s decision was the myth that healthy children do not die of COVID. The Florida Department of Health quoted a Dr. Joseph Fraiman as saying, “If you have a healthy child, the chances of that child dying are incredibly low, essentially close to zero if not actually zero.”
I agree that the chances of a healthy child dying of COVID are “incredibly low.” However, there’s a world of difference between “essentially close to zero” and “actually zero” when millions of children contract the virus. A rare event multiplied millions of times adds up. Overall, according to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, 1,139 children have died of COVID.* Thousands more children were sick enough to be hospitalized, sometimes in the ICU. All of this is happening nearly a year after Dr. Makary said “that Covid-19 will be mostly gone” and from a virus he referred to as “Nature’s Vaccine.”
All arguments against vaccinating healthy children really boil down to, “the vaccine won’t save the lives of that many children, so there’s really no point.” I don’t think that’s a very good argument. Do you? If so, maybe you should read about some of the healthy children who died of COVID, some after the vaccine was available to them.
You can read an article titled “Parents Say 5-Year-Old Daughter Who Died From COVID-19 was ‘Perfectly Healthy’” and another titled “4-Year-Old CNY Boy Who Died of Covid Complications Had Been Healthy: ‘I Lost My Miracle Baby.’” You can read about a child from Minnesota in an article titled “Child Under 10 With No Underlying Conditions Dies From COVID.” A 9-month-old who “did not have an underlying health condition” also died in Minnesota. You can read about a child “with no underlying conditions” who died in Tennessee and a 7-year-old from Georgia who “had no underlying health conditions.” Kimora Lynum, a 9-year-old with “no underlying conditions” died in my hometown, Gainesville, Florida. Skylar Herbert, a 5 year-old from Detroit also had “no underlying health conditions” when she died of COVID-19. You can read about Dykota Morgan, a 15-year-old girl from Illinois, “whose parents said she had no underlying medical conditions.” She was a basketball player who died just two days after contracting the virus. These children would almost certainly be alive today if they had been vaccinated.
Unfortunately, the idea that healthy children don’t die of COVID is now this pandemic’s version of “we only use 10% of our brain.”  However, healthy children have absolutely died of COVID. There is no reason more children should die in the future given that an effective vaccine exists for those older than 5. Sadly, thanks to myths spread by doctors, many children remain at risk. Medical myths have real-world consequences.
*Correction:  A previous version of this article misstated the total number of children who had died of COVID and that one-third of these deaths came during the recent Omicron surge.  This information was due to miscoded information reported by the CDC COVID Data Tracker, which erroneously added several hundred deaths to the pediatric tally.

They Have Names
Reality is not “fear-based messaging”, and fewer children will die moving forward if their parents know a bit more about what the virus can do and how the vaccine can keep children safe.
Jonathan Howard on March 5, 2022
Link

I have previously criticized doctors for glossing over the pediatric death toll from COVID. In their relentless quest to minimize the virus’s impact on children, the subjects of my criticism refuse to simply enumerate the number of children who’ve died of COVID. They instead distract their readers with irrelevant factoids, like saying only that COVID has killed many more elderly people than children. While this is true, according to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, 1,538 children have died of COVID. That’s a large number to me, and it’s not a surprise that COVID minimizers don’t want their audience to know it. Other times, these doctors spread misinformation, saying that the flu, which has killed fewer than 10 children since the start of the pandemic, is as dangerous as COVID.
Beyond steadfastly refusing to share or bungling basic facts, it’s notable that I’ve not seen any of them actually acknowledge any individual child who died, the grieving family they’ve left behind, and the regret their parents often have about not having vaccinated them. They’ve devoted many podcasts and articles to vaccine side effects, but it’s inconceivable they’d ever have a podcast or article titled “Children Lost to COVID”. This is a curious omission in their copious canon on pediatric COVID, especially considering they insist they value “nuance” and that they are “pro-vaccine“.
Some of these doctors are refreshingly forthcoming about their refusal to acknowledge deceased children. For example, after Dr. Julia Raifman shared information about an infant who died of COVID, a concierge internist who declared the pandemic over a year ago, responded by saying Dr. Raifman was engaging in “fear-based messaging” and that this was a sign of communication “gone awry”. “Clinicians have a duty to rise above fear and shame-based messaging,” she said to Dr. Raifman.
It sure sounds to me like this doctor is trying to shame Dr. Raifman. And for what reason? Dr. Raifman merely acknowledged a baby had died of COVID and expressed a hope that fewer babies would die in the future. It’s astonishing this is controversial amongst doctors.
Like Dr. Raifman, I don’t feel that sharing factual information is fear or shame-based, nor do I feel that fear is an entirely misplaced emotion for a virus that has killed over 1,500 children. Tens of thousands more children have been hospitalized from the virus, some very sick, needing intubation in the ICU. There have been at least 7,459 cases of MIS-C, and 61 children have died from this. It’s rarely serious when a child gets COVID, but the results can be very consequential to a very small percentage of them. A small percentage of a big number, can be a big number.
It is not “fear-based messaging” to recognize that children killed by COVID were real children, with real futures, robbed of their entire life by a virus that can now be prevented with a vaccine for children 5-years and older. It’s important to remember that these are flesh and blood children, not just statistics on a CDC website. Though I’ve consistently stated that the risk to any individual child is extremely low, I’ve occasionally shared stories of children who died of COVID. In a previous essay I wrote,
Kali Cook, who liked to play with worms, will never go to kindergarten. She was one of 200 American children who died before they turned 5. Ryland Daic, who loved to fish, will never graduate high school. Gigi Morse will never go to a prom. Kimora Lynum, who liked shopping for clothes, will never celebrate her college graduation. Week Day will never have her first kiss. Wyatt Gibson will never get married. Dykota Morgan, a basketball player, will never hold her own child. Ethan Govan will never get the satisfaction of earning his first paycheck. Skylar Herbert, who wanted to be a pediatric dentist, will never work at all. Maybe Fabiana Zoppelli was destined to be a brilliant scientist. Teresa Sperry loved to sing. Maybe she would have been a star. It’s possible that Landon Woodson or Azorean Tatum would have made it to the NFL.
The pediatric death tally has doubled since I wrote about these children just a few months ago. It’s a sad commentary on our times that in their urgency to return to “normal,” sheltered doctors who will never care for a sick child would prefer that these children’s names not be mentioned, their faces not be shown, their existence not be acknowledged.
Notably, this absurd code of silence is uniquely applied to COVID. Would any doctor suggest it’s inappropriate to share the names and faces of children who die from violence or cancer? Not that I’ve seen. It’s only with COVID that we are encouraged to erase the identities of deceased children. It’s only with COVID that we are encouraged to maintain a charade so denialists can continue with their illusion that children are invulnerable to the virus. It’s only with COVID that sharing accurate information in the hope of keeping children alive is deemed shameful, something to “rise above”. To me, that’s shameful. As Loretta Torrago said in an excellent Twitter thread on all of this,
Imagine the parents reading that their baby should be kept out of sight so that others might not be afraid.
Additionally, I’ve written about some of these children’s parents saying,
It’s worth it to read about some of the deceased children and the regret their parents feel about not vaccinating them. Landon Woodson’s mother implored parents to “Please Please Get Vaccinated“, after her son, a healthy football player, died of COVID-19. Similarly, Hector Ramirez, whose unvaccinated 15-year-old-daughter Victoria died this summer, said:
“I don’t want any other parent to go through what I did — seeing my daughter perfectly healthy one day, then following a week and a half, she’s gone.”
According to news reports, “He didn’t get the shot for his daughter, and he regrets it”.
Teresa Sperry’s parents became vaccine advocates after their daughter, who was not yet eligible to be vaccinated, died of COVID-19. “The only way this makes sense to me is if it saves people”, Jeff Sperry said. “We’re trying to help others so they don’t have to go through this”.
I am far from alone in sharing this sort of information, of course. Countless other doctors share do so from time to time. I’ve noticed these doctors are generally those who haven’t tried to monetize their COVID musings. Dr. Raifman, for example, doesn’t have a Substack side gig, for example. Her speaking fee isn’t $20,000-25,000.
Most notably, Dr. Cleavon Gilman, a non-concierge emergency medicine physician who has actually treated thousands of COVID-19 patients, routinely shares information about children lost to or severely harmed by COVID. It’s really sad, but very important work. His hope is that “By telling their stories we’ll ensure that their memories live on”. I’m glad he’s ignored those who would tell him he has a “duty to rise above fear and shame-based messaging”.
I realize that this isn’t scientific information, though of course I’ve shared raw statistics on how COVID has impacted children, as well as the multiple studies that show vaccines can keep children safe and out of the hospital. However, all this information is true. These children existed. They died of COVID. Their parents often regret not vaccinating them.
Such tragedies need to be shared in a thoughtful manner, of course. They shouldn’t be exploited in any way. It would not be appropriate for Pfizer to use them in a commercial. Nor should they be used to inflate the risk of COVID. The vast majority of children who get COVID will be just fine, thankfully. These stories should be shared with the intentions and empathy of Dr. Raifman.
Additionally, as Mr. Sperry realized and some evidence shows, they may have the power to convince parents to vaccinate their children. Pediatric vaccination rates are way too low. Emotionally salient stories that humanize the statistics are often more compelling than numbers alone, and all they require you to do is to tell the truth.
Philip K. Dick said, “Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn’t go away”. Like an ostrich with its head in the sand, it’s clear some doctors hope deceased children will just “go away”. However, their overt denialism doesn’t change the fact that over 1,500 children have died of COVID and that the virus has been killing 20 children per week the past few months.
Perhaps fewer children will die moving forward if their parents know a bit more about what the virus can do and how the vaccine can help keep them safe. Every pro-vaccine doctor should be willing to share accurate information that will diminish the likelihood of another child dying from a vaccine-preventable virus. Reality is reality, not “fear-based messaging.” This shouldn’t be controversial.

COVID and Our Warped Sense of Normal
Children are not supposed to die. This didn’t used to be controversial.
Jonathan Howard on March 25, 2022
Link

Vaccine-preventable diseases: Where we were
A recent article from Medscape declared that across the USA:
New cases of COVID-19 in children continued their descent toward normalcy, falling below 100,000 in a week for the first time since early August 2021, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Children’s Hospital Association.
This is very good news, and we can only hope it drops further. However, framing 100,000 pediatric infections as a “descent towards normalcy” shows how much COVID has warped our collective standards for what is normal and acceptable. I’m not trying to single out the author of the Medscape article. We’ve all changed.
I’ve been paying close attention to vaccine-preventable diseases for the past decade. I remember when an immunocompromised woman dying of measles in 2015 was a big deal. I remember when a baby dying of whooping cough in 2019 was a big deal. I remember that it was a big deal in 2019 when Gov. Matt Bevin of Kentucky exposed his children to chickenpox rather than vaccinate them. I remember in 2014 when the Disneyland measles outbreak was a big deal. I remember in 2019 when 1,261 cases of measles were considered a “public health crisis.”
An entire paper in The New England Journal of Medicine was written about the 649 measles cases here in NYC that year. Researchers reported that low vaccination rates and “measles parties” fueled the outbreak, which hospitalized 52 people and sent 16 of them to the ICU. This now seems like nothing, especially considering no children died, fortunately.
However, as I said at the time there is nothing benign about a virus that can send 16 people to the ICU. This is why prior to the pandemic, I advocated for the MMR vaccine, as well as the HPV, polio, rotavirus, pertussis, and flu vaccines. I don’t want any child to suffer from a vaccine-preventable disease.
None of this was controversial at the time, especially amongst doctors. We all agreed that children going to the hospital, especially the ICU, from a vaccine-preventable disease was utterly unacceptable. We all agreed that a child dying from a vaccine-preventable disease was a tragedy that we should strive to prevent, not something to normalize. Only the most rabid anti-vaccine quacks opposed vaccinating children. Only overt anti-vaxxers sheltered from the care of sick people argued with me on social media.
,
Vaccine-preventable diseases: Where we are
Things are very different now.
Today, with over 10,000 pediatric COVID cases, 109 pediatric hospitalizations, and 2-3 pediatric deaths every day, we are told that we are approaching normal. In fact, we are told we must get there urgently. Being careful for a few more months, so perhaps children under 5-years can be vaccinated, is portrayed as an intolerable obstacle, even though over 400 children ages 0-4 years have died.
Today, doctors from prestigious universities – who are terribly offended to be characterized as anti-vaccine – vocally declare that healthy children should not be vaccinated against COVID. Using arguments indistinguishable from someone like Andrew Wakefield, several doctors waged a relentless and successful campaign to ensure as many children as possible were infected with the virus before they were vaccinated. One doctors said that “Vaccinating healthy ≤12 year olds makes hardly difference to them directly, however we look at it.” Another doctor lamented the possibility that children might avoid the virus saying, “school closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”.
Other doctors spread blatant misinformation, repeatedly downplaying the harms of the virus and hyping the harms of the vaccine. Regulators in some countries spoke of the “benefits” of infected, sick children. Doctors who previously called out anti-vaccine “quacks” now write pro-COVID essays titled “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?” Amazingly, instead of saying “no, we should not let children catch Omicron”, the authors spew standard anti-vaccine talking points, saying,
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.
How is this all not a scandal? How have we accepted that it’s desirable for children to get sick? How is this even a topic up for debate amongst doctors who normally seek to prevent illness and suffering?
As Dr. David Gorski recently wrote,
As I like to ask all these physicians arguing that COVID-19 “isn’t very dangerous” to children, if you make that argument for COVID-19, then why don’t you also oppose school vaccine mandates for MMR and varicella? If you make the same argument about COVID-19 vaccines, like it or not, believe it or not, you are parroting very old and more general antivax talking points.
Indeed.
We have a choice
The NYC measles outbreak was declared over when it was completely over. According to health officials from NYC, “measles outbreaks are over when two incubation periods for measles — 42 days total — have passed since the last infectious day of the last infected patients”. In 2019, no one pretended that measles was gone until it was actually gone. We knew that wishing it away would not make it go away.
I’m under no illusion that we will soon eliminate COVID the way those measles outbreaks were squelched. While a big reason for this is that COVID vaccines aren’t as good as the MMR vaccine, poor uptake of the COVID vaccine in children – an outcome desired by many influential doctors divorced from patient care – is a main culprit too.
Few children will avoid exposure to SARS-CoV-2 their entire life. As such, we have a choice. We can fantasize COVID is gone and that sick children don’t matter as long as older people suffer more. Or, we can use an effective vaccine to blunt COVID’s harms. The vaccine is not perfect, but recent studies conclude “vaccination of children 5-11 years was protective against severe disease and is recommended”. The vaccine can save the lives of some children, even healthy ones. Just because it won’t save an enormous number of children doesn’t mean they are not worth saving.
A child getting sick with a vaccine-preventable disease was unacceptable prior to COVID. An unvaccinated child getting severely sick with COVID should be unacceptable today. We should not normalize children getting sick – and rarely dying- from any disease for which a vaccine exists.
Children are not supposed to die. This didn’t used to be controversial.

The CDC Goofs and Doctors React
After a CDC goof, several doctors – including me – shared incorrect information. What happened next was revealing.
Jonathan Howard on March 20, 2022
Link

The CDC recently erred by adding hundreds of extra deaths to its pediatric tally through a “coding error”. In the days before the CDC issued its correction, alarmed doctors took note of the seemingly enormous rise in pediatric deaths. I was confused as to why the American Academy of Pediatrics was raising its grim death tally by 20 children per week, while the CDC was adding this many deaths every day. I know now what happened.
Nonetheless, I reported the inflated CDC data in a recent article here and issued the following correction upon learning of the CDC’s error:
A previous version of this article misstated the total number of children who had died of COVID and that one-third of these deaths came during the recent Omicron surge. This information was due to miscoded information reported by the CDC COVID Data Tracker, which erroneously added several hundred deaths to the pediatric tally.
I don’t want my readers to learn misinformation. This matters a great deal to me.
I am not alone in this, of course. Other doctors similarly shared corrections on social media (here and here). Science writer Melody Schreiber issued a correction to her article on the subject. It is now called “A Fifth of All US Child Covid Deaths Occurred During Omicron Surge” and it says that “Since the beginning of the current year, 179 children have died from Covid-19 in the US, compared with 735 children in the preceding 20 months”.
That’s depressing. I wrote previously how important it is to remember these are actually children, not just numbers on a government website, which is what this essay is all about.
As things now stand, the CDC’s Covid Data Tracker reports 1,341 pediatric fatalities, however this comes from of pool of 782,371 deaths, or about 80% of deaths so far. The pediatric death toll will only continue to grow sadly. Death is the worst, but not the only bad outcome, of course. According to a recent CDC report about the Omicron variant, “U.S. infants and children aged 0–4 years were hospitalized at approximately five times the rate of the previous peak during Delta variant predominance. Infants aged <6 months had the highest rates of hospitalization”. Moreover, 63% of hospitalized infants and children had no underlying medical conditions. There have been 7,500 cases of MIS-C, and 63 children have died from this very serious condition.
Whatever the actual number, normal people feel over 1,000 dead children is a tragically large number, especially considering these deaths can be almost entirely prevented with a vaccine for children over 5-years. As Ms. Schreiber said:
The fact remains: more than 1,300 children have died, and vaccines will prevent more deaths.
Exactly. This is the core message. There are potential sources of both overcounting and undercounting of pediatric COVID deaths. It’s crucial that the CDC try to report as accurate numbers as possible.
However, the advice regarding the vaccine wouldn’t be substantially different if the death toll were 1,000 or 2,000 children. I advocated for pediatric COVID vaccine, when “only” 482 children had died of COVID. I bet you don’t have any clue how many children die in bike accidents per year, but your knowledge of that number wouldn’t change your opinion on the value of helmets.
Similarly, the vaccine isn’t perfect, but it’s much safer than the virus. Those of us who shared the inflated CDC data know that the case for vaccinating children is already extremely strong and that pediatric vaccination rates are way too low. We also know that children under 5-years cannot get vaccinated currently and that infants have the highest rate of dying. We don’t want any child to suffer or die from a vaccine-preventable virus. Prior to the pandemic, this wasn’t a controversial opinion in the medical field, though now it is.
However, while we all reported what we thought was accurate data from a reliable source, we nonetheless reported incorrect information. Seeing doctors who don’t want children to die of COVID report wrong information prompted one delighted Urgency of Normal fan to ask “Will there be any apologies from all the people who have been spreading panic with the old incorrect numbers?!?”
Well, I don’t think anyone but the CDC should apologize for their coding error, but doctors and journalists with integrity knew it was important to immediately and publicly set the record straight. So that’s what we did. As Dr. Julia Raifman said:
We should have high standards for correct information, esp in a pandemic…Most experts worked to share the facts.
Indeed, most experts do work to share the facts, but not all of them. Dr. Raifman also recognized that a “small number of ‘experts’ perpetuated inaccurate info & partial truths”. Readers of Science Based Medicine are very familiar with these “experts”. They can be found wherever there is a camera, not at the bedside of a sick child. Dr. Raifman’s concern for accuracy stands in stark contrast to their infinite tolerance for repeated errors of basic fact – always minimizing the risks of the virus and overstating the harms of the vaccine, never admitting error or correcting their misinformation.
Doctors should strive to be accurate and thorough and particularly when they communicate with the public about a virus that has killed over 1,300 children. This is where I’d quibble with Dr. Raifman. This is not a “high standard”. This is the bare minimum. It’s shameful that so many doctors have failed to meet it.

Children and COVID-19: A Few Facts and Figures from the Pandemic’s First Three Years
After three solid years of the pandemic, here is an admittedly incomplete rundown of how it has affected children in the United States.
Clay Jones on April 28, 2023
Link

It has been an eventful two weeks since my last post. I returned from my trip to Italy on Wednesday. It was amazing, but exhausting, and included forgotten passports, minor Vespa crashes, a cancelled flight that resulted in two unintended days in a rainy and cold Amsterdam, hauling luggage up and down countless flights of stairs, seemingly endless train and plain rides, two grumpy teenagers, and now severe jet lag. Naturally I wouldn’t have changed a thing, except for perhaps the two mile sprint through the crowded streets of Florence to retrieve our passports and make the train to Cinque Terre on time.
Today’s post will be short and, sadly, not so sweet. Though I wouldn’t dare compare the impact of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic on children to adults, particularly those who are older and in certain minority groups, it hasn’t exactly been a picnic either. I’ll run through a few facts and figures that paint a picture of how things have gone so far.
The first cases of COVID-19 were reported in January of 2020 in the United States and on March 13th of that year a national emergency was declared. During the past three years, there have been at least 16.6 million diagnosed cases in the pediatric population. This is a huge undercount, however, as millions of cases have undoubtedly gone untested and thus unreported.
Of the reported pediatric cases of COVID-19, 186,035 cases required hospitalization because of severe disease. Though a fraction (0.2%) of the total seen in higher risk populations, the death of 2,122 children as a result of COVID-19 over the past three years is horrific and on par with how many children drown every year. Of course, death isn’t the only outcome we care about and there have been at least 9,445 cases of MIS-C, with 78 deaths because of this unusual inflammatory complication of SARS-CoV-2 infection.
But wait, as I discussed in a post in December on the negative impact of the pandemic on childhood vaccinations, there is a lot more:
Adding to the possibility of that severe and even life-threatening inflammatory condition, even children with only mild COVID-19 are at increased risk of developing diabetes, to give just one of several more examples. There have also been significant increases in ED visits and hospitalizations for mental health crises in our teen and young adult populations. This really is just the tip of the iceberg as there are a number of post-COVID-19 conditions that have been seen in children, with as many as 25% still having symptoms a month after diagnosis. Between 2% and 10% of children diagnosed with COVID-19 will ultimately develop the more disruptive syndrome of post-acute sequelae of COVID (PASC), also known as “long COVID”.
Cases continue to be reported but they are decreasing. Though pediatricians, myself very much included, had one of the worst respiratory virus seasons in memory, it was largely because of RSV and not SARS-CoV-2. The last significant pediatric surge of COVID-19 cases occurred during the previous winter, when 2,000 of every 100,000 16- to 17-year-old children were diagnosed. Things are definitely much better now.
What about the vaccines? I’m afraid I don’t have great news on that front. Only 43% of all children, and less than a third of children under the age of 12 years, have received at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccination. Older kids were the most likely to have received a dose, with 72% of teens rolling up their sleeves. On the other end of the spectrum, that number falls to only 8% in kids less than 2 years. This is an unfortunate reality, with vaccine-hesitancy and even outright anti-vaccine propaganda having become much more mainstream than before the pandemic.
Sadly, I’ll end on a rather tragic note here. One of the more insidious problems faced by children during the pandemic, and one that I haven’t seen much emphasis placed on by our government leaders, is the loss of a parent or other meaningful caregiver. As of this month, nearly a quarter-million children have lost one or both parents because of COVID-19.
Unsurprisingly, because of disparities in who has been more likely to die from COVID-19, nearly two thirds of these children are Black or Latino. And more than half of them live in just 5 states: California, Texas, Florida, New York, and Georgia. The list of potential acute and long term negative effects of losing a parent is long and includes, but is certainly not limited to increased risk of mental health problems, abuse, unstable housing, and household poverty. The course of their lives has been irrevocably altered and resources should be dedicated to helping them.

Covid-19 in Children: A New Study Out of China
Children may be less likely to develop COVID-19, but they can get it too; and it may be more severe for infants.
Harriet Hall on March 31, 2020
Link


Reports on the new coronavirus disease COVID-19 have reassured us that children are less likely to be infected and are likely to have milder symptoms. An information page on the Seattle Children’s Hospital website reports that there have been no deaths of children from COVID-19 anywhere in the world. Other sources confirm that no patient under the age of 9 has died of the disease.
Now the NEJM’s Journal Watch has reported a new study in China that provides additional information. 
It was an epidemiological study of 2,143 children in the Wuhan area of China; 731 of them had laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acid diagnoses and 1,412 had suspected COVID-19 based on clinical symptoms and/or clinical laboratory results. The median age was 7 years with a range of 1 day to 18 years; 57% were boys. 50% of them lived in Wuhan itself and the rest were from adjacent areas. The disease spread rapidly during January and slowly declined in February, as draconian government-mandated measures slowed transmission by restricting travel and enforcing social isolation.
Results
    • 4% of these children were asymptomatic
    • 90% had mild or moderate disease: 50.9% mild and 38.8% moderate
    • 5% had severe disease with oxygen saturations <92%
    • 13 cases (0.6%) had critical disease with acute respiratory distress or respiratory failure and organ dysfunctions that could be life-threatening.
    • Of the 13 critical cases, 7 were in children less than one year old.
    • There was one death, in a 14-year-old boy
    • The percentage of severe and critical cases in children was 5.9% compared to 18.5% in adults
    • The number of pediatric cases peaked on February 1 and then started to decline
Children of all ages were affected. The most worrisome finding was that the highest incidence of severe/critical disease (11%) occurred in children under the age of 1 year.
How credible is this new information?
There are reasons to be cautious.
The study has been peer-reviewed but has not yet been published; the journal Pediatrics has released a pre-publication version to expedite access to the findings. The pdf is available here. “The publisher noted that it was not in final form and that subsequent changes might be made.” Due to the emergency of the situation “an ethical approval was considered to be waived by institutional review board.”
This is a single report that has not yet been corroborated elsewhere. Some of the subjects may not have actually had COVID-19 infection: two-thirds were classified only as “suspected” on the basis of symptoms (respiratory, gastrointestinal, or fatigue), suspicious blood tests, and chest x-rays. Clinical laboratory findings that raised suspicion included normal or low white blood counts and elevated C-reactive protein. It is troublesome that there were more severe and critical cases in the suspected than in the confirmed group. There could have been any number of possible confounders. They did not report whether patients had underlying health conditions that might have exacerbated their illness. Their nutritional status was not mentioned. It would have been interesting to know for certain how they caught the virus; person-to-person transmission was assumed. It would have been interesting to know what treatment they received.
The authors commented on the origin of the disease. It started in a Wuhan market that sells wild animals, and genetic analysis has shown that it probably originated in bats and passed through pangolins on its way to humans. Elsewhere it was reported that a shrimp vendor in the market might have been “patient zero”.
I wish they had collected data to compare the attack rate in the entire population of children vs. adults. But we’ll have to take what we can get.
Take-home message
We can take home this message: infants can get COVID-19 and they may be more likely to have a severe case than older children or adults. Please stay home, wash hands, be vigilant, and don’t be complacent about your children.

Science Fiction at the Wall Street Journal
Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan famously said “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts”. It’s my opinion that no child should die for lack of a vaccine. The editors of The Wall Street Journal disagree
Jonathan Howard on March 27, 2022
Link

A recent editorial in The Wall Street Journal by Allysia Finley titled “Healthy Children Don’t Need Covid Vaccines” argued that children should not be vaccinated against COVID since “for kids under 12, the risks are trivial”. This article contained the predictable, vacuous COVID minimization tropes I’ve discussed many times previously. Naturally, it argued that children should remain vulnerable to COVID since more die of suicide (discussed here) and because old people are more endangered (discussed here).
These are poor arguments. After all, more children have died of COVID so far this year than will die from bike accidents in the entire year. Is that a good reason to argue against bike helmets? Of course not.
The factoids Ms. Finely used have zero relevance as to whether or not the COVID vaccine can protect some children from rare, but catastrophic outcomes. It can. These factoids are not without their use, however. Anti-vaccine writers can use them as a rhetorical trick to prevent their readers from knowing that COVID has really harmed a non-trivial number of children, including healthy ones. Over 1,300 children have died.
Moreover, what’s true for COVID is true for many vaccine-preventable diseases. Most kids would survive into adulthood if all vaccines vanished. Only dedicated anti-vaxxers want this to be a reality, but their arguments are identical to those who argue against the COVID vaccine for healthy children. The idea that “it’s just the sick kids who die” is standard anti-vaccine balderdash. In fact, with COVID, about 20% of pediatric deaths occur in healthy children. Ms. Finley doesn’t mention this. She doesn’t feel her readers can be trusted to know this fact.
Beyond this specious reasoning, Ms. Finely’s article was full of science fiction, a universal feature of such anti-vaccine articles. Ms. Finely informed her readers that the vaccine “doesn’t amount to much”, and to bolster this point she referenced a preprint of a study that concluded “vaccination of children 5-11 years was protective against severe disease and is recommended”. As is typical for authors who aim to persuade their readers rather than inform them, other studies showing the effectiveness of the vaccine, even with the Omicron variant, go unmentioned.
Additionally, Ms. Finely claimed that “The risk of hospitalization from the flu for children 5 to 11 is 50% higher than from Covid and the related multisystem inflammatory syndrome combined”. This is completely backwards. During the same time when the flu hospitalized 9 children ages 5-11, COVID hospitalized 8,300 children this age. Either Ms. Finley was ignorant of the basic numbers regarding the subject of her editorial, she thought 9 is larger than 8,300, or she wanted to deceive her readers.
Moreover, there have been 7,500 cases of MIS-C, and most children with this condition go to the ICU. Over 60 children have died from MIS-C. These numbers would have been much higher without COVID mitigations. The vaccine has been shown to be highly protective against this severe outcome. This is why the paper Ms. Finely referenced to argue against vaccinating children concluded that “Although rarer than influenza infection, the extreme severity of MIS-C made the total economic and health burden of COVID-19 infection combined with MIS-C just as high as that of past influenza outbreaks”.
Overall, about 100 times more children have died from COVID than the flu since the pandemic started. Of course, anyone with basic critical thinking skills knows it doesn’t matter whether the flu or COVID harms more children. Normal people don’t want any child to get sick or die from any vaccine-preventable disease.
Sadly, such science fiction is the norm for editorials in The Wall Street Journal on pediatric COVID, reflecting the fact that their authors will never care for a sick child. I previously discussed an article by Drs. Nicole Saphier and Marty Makary titled “Should You Vaccinate Your 5-Year-Old?” This article claimed that only 562 children ages 5-11 years had been hospitalized with COVID-19. This was false and was easily recognizable as such by anyone familiar with this topic. Drs. Saphier and Makary misread a CDC slide to arrive at this incorrect number and haven’t bothered to correct their error.
This article also discussed a report that supposedly found “a mortality rate of zero among children without a pre-existing medical condition such as leukemia”. In fact, this “report” covered less than 1% of the pediatric deaths at the time. Healthy children have absolutely died of COVID, and the most common underlying conditions in decreased children are obesity and asthma. Almost all children who die of COVID are robbed of many decades of life.
Readers of The Wall Street Journal editorial page won’t know any of this, of course. They’ll only know COVID is worse for grandma.
Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan famously said “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts”. It’s my opinion that no child should die for lack of a vaccine. The editors of The Wall Street Journal disagree. Unfortunately, to make their case, they feel entitled to their own facts. Repeated errors of basic facts are unacceptable in a prestigious newspaper under any circumstances, but especially so when the topic is a virus that has killed over 1,000 children and a vaccine that can help prevent these rare tragedies.

Was the Delta Variant 😂 for Children?
Maybe this year, sheltered doctors will realize that variants with the potential to hospitalize and kill children can’t just be brushed away with 😂 and that sarcastic requests to wait “2 weeks🙄” rarely age well.
Jonathan Howard on June 19, 2022
Link

My essay, one year later
One year ago, I wrote an essay titled “COVID-19 and Balancing the Risks: The Vaccine or the Virus” in which I advocated vaccinating children in light of the Delta variant, which was just starting to spread in the US. I noted that Australia had locked down due to Delta, and a chief health officer there claimed it could be spread by “fleeting contact”. To avoid alarmism, I appropriately noted that “Obviously this is not scientific proof” and said “Hopefully we’ll know more definitive information about this soon.” However, I also felt that the “Delta variant will likely move faster than science’s ability to adequately evaluate” different approaches to mitigating it. While we all want pristine scientific evidence, time is not an unlimited luxury this pandemic, and decisions must be made with incomplete information.
Pressing my case to vaccinate children, I said that “I suspect that most everyone will gain immunity to COVID-19 eventually. It’s just a question of whether it’s through the vaccine or virus”. I also added,
Of course, the Delta variant is unlikely to be the last variant, and it’s not implausible a variant may arise that is significantly more dangerous to young people.
Precaution in the face of a rapidly changing threat has been a theme of my writing since my first essay on SBM when I said,
It is not inconceivable that a COVID-19 variant could significantly affect children and spread widely before we could widely vaccinate children.
My critic, one year later
Not everyone saw it this way. One podcasting, contrarian cardiologist thought my concerns about the Delta variant were 😂.
My critic continued,
Is it possible Howard & co. Are correctly predicting Armageddon unless the kids aren’t forced to be vaxxed ? Maybe.. (we’ll know in 2 weeks🙄) But that is far from certain, so giving parents some choice in the matter (even an alternative vax regimen) seems smart.
COVID, one year later
Of course, I never predicted “Armageddon” nor have I ever argued that kids should be forcibly vaccinated against the will of their parents. My critic just made that up to make me look bad. Though it’s disingenuous to put words in someone’s mouth to argue against something they never said, my critic was accidentally right about one thing – two weeks later, pediatricians would start to learn what the Delta variant could do, especially to unvaccinated children.
It wasn’t 😂 funny.
Pediatric hospitalizations increased to their highest level of the pandemic, and one study found that “pediatric hospitalization, ICU admission, mechanical ventilation, and death all peaked” later that summer. I wasn’t joking when I observed that contrarian doctors’
Sarcastic requests to wait “two more weeks” have often turned out to be reliable indicators of when cases would start soaring again.
Though the Omicron variant was milder for any individual child, its increased contagiousness meant that it hospitalized 5 times more children than the Delta variant. Over 130,000 children have been hospitalized thus far, the vast majority in the past year. Recent CDC data for the youngest children shows that less than 15% of COVID hospitalizations were for incidental infections, and just over half of hospitalized children had no underlying medical conditions. Overall, about 20% of hospitalized children need treatment in the ICU, and 5% are sick enough to need mechanical ventilation. There have been over 4,500 cases of MIS-C in the past year, and 60-70% these children are sick enough to need care in the ICU.
My critic had previously belittled pediatric hospitalizations, noting there were “75 million children under 17” in the US. Notably, he didn’t minimize vaccine-myocarditis that way. Nor should he, even though it is rare and nearly always has a favorable clinical course.
Most tragically, over 1,000 children have died of COVID since my critic guffawed at COVID variants, many of them old enough to be vaccinated. I encourage you to read about some of them to remind yourself these children are more than just statistics on a government website.
Though the vaccine isn’t perfect, it has been consistently shown to lower the rate of “critical illness” in children with both Delta and Omicron and to protect them against MIS-C. One study, which encompassed the time when the Delta variant was dominant, found that “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents”. Another study found that:
Nearly 90% of the 397 children hospitalized during Omicron’s predominance had not gotten COVID-19 shots. Cumulatively, the hospitalization rate was more than two times higher among the unvaccinated. About 30% of the children hospitalized had no underlying conditions, and about 20% required time in the intensive care unit (ICU).
The vaccine has prevented a lot of suffering for children, and the youngest are finally on the cusp of being vaccinated. Anyone who opposes vaccinating children today is anti-vaccine. There’s no virtue in pretending otherwise.
 
Déjà vu
Today the headlines are ominous once again. One recent article was titled “S. Africa Child Admissions Exceed Elderly Amid Covid Strains“. According to this article,
The number of South African children younger than nine admitted to hospital with Covid-19 has overtaken the proportion of patients aged over 80 for the first time as new omicron strains dominate infections, the country’s biggest health insurer said.
Once again, I won’t pretend these warnings are scientific proof. Once again, I will argue that as these variants spread in the US and pediatric hospitalizations creep upward, parents should choose to vaccinate their children before we find out for sure what they can do.
Maybe this year, doctors sheltered from the care of sick children will realize that variants with the potential to hospitalize and kill them can’t just be brushed away with 😂 and that sarcastic requests to wait two weeks🙄 rarely age well.

Excess in Non-COVID Deaths
What are the true causes of the excess non-COVID deaths during the pandemic?
Steven Novella on July 20, 2022
Link

In the US, since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, we have experienced 1.02 million deaths, out of about 89 million cases. There have been about 6.4 million deaths worldwide, out of 569 million cases. These numbers, however, are almost certainly an underestimate. A Lancet study, for example, found:
Although reported COVID-19 deaths between Jan 1, 2020, and Dec 31, 2021, totalled 5·94 million worldwide, we estimate that 18·2 million (95% uncertainty interval 17·1–19·6) people died worldwide because of the COVID-19 pandemic (as measured by excess mortality) over that period.
The true mortality burden of the pandemic worldwide was likely triple the official numbers. A WHO report put the number at about 15 million. For the US the disparity was not as great, but was still significant:
For the United States, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that excess deaths between the weeks ending March 7, 2020 and March 5, 2022 totaled 1,105,736, 15 percent more than the 958,864 official death toll from COVID-19 over that period.
That translates to 146,872 excess deaths not officially attributed to COVID-19 during that period. What are the causes of those unaccounted for excess deaths? Some of them are likely uncounted COVID deaths. Especially early on in the pandemic, death certificates often missed the role of COVID in some deaths. Overworked coroners often took families at their word when reporting the cause of death of a family member at home. By one estimate, COVID-19 deaths were underestimated by about 20% in the US.
However, this underestimation does not account for all the excess deaths. In the US there does appear to be an increase in non-COVID deaths during the pandemic, a phenomenon coming under increased scrutiny. A PNAS study published in September 2021 found:
Thirty-four percent of the excess life years lost for males is from non–COVID-19 causes. While minorities represent 36% of COVID-19 deaths, they represent 70% of non–COVID-19 related excess deaths and 58% of non–COVID-19 excess life years lost. Black, non-Hispanic males represent only 6.9% of the population, but they are responsible for 8.9% of COVID-19 deaths and 28% of 2020 excess deaths from non–COVID-19 causes. For this group, nearly half of the excess life years lost in 2020 are due to non–COVID-19 causes.
Non-COVID deaths were increased in all groups in the US (except children) but concentrated in minorities and those with lower socioeconomic status. What were the causes of these excess non-COVID deaths? One review of the data found:
Hypertension and heart disease deaths combined were elevated 32,000. Diabetes or obesity, drug-induced causes, and alcohol-induced causes were each elevated 12,000 to 15,000 above previous (upward) trends. Drug deaths especially followed an alarming trend, only to significantly exceed it during the pandemic to reach 108,000 for calendar year 2021. Homicide and motor-vehicle fatalities combined were elevated almost 10,000. Various other causes combined to add 18,000.
These proximate causes likely relate to a few more fundamental causes. For example, delayed or deferred hospital admission or medical care likely resulted in increased deaths from heart disease and stroke. People were simply reluctant to go to the ER for fear of catching COVID there, and because hospitals were overwhelmed. Having experienced the ER during the pandemic I can tell you it was full of a lot of unhappy patients, waiting for beds in overcrowded conditions.
Other deaths are deemed “death of despair”, due to increased alcoholism and drug overdoses. Increase in motor vehicle deaths is interesting, attributed to more fast and reckless driving provoked by relatively empty roads. Increase in homicides was similarly attributed to increases in anxiety and restlessness during the pandemic.
Of course, many of the usual suspects have tried to link excess mortality to vaccines. This has been debunked, however, and in fact the evidence shows a beneficial effect of vaccination on excess mortality.
So far I have only been discussing the US. Many other countries have had a similar experience, but with great variability. Not all countries, however, have experienced excess non-COVID deaths. In the UK, for example, there was actually a decrease in non-COVID deaths during the pandemic. A study published in December 2021 found:
In England, deaths from causes other than COVID-19 have been lower than usual for 80% of the pandemic. In January to September 2021, this was equivalent to about 34,000 (or 9%) fewer deaths than we would expect, based on historical mortality patterns. This analysis explores some of the questions arising from this reduction.
The study attributes this decrease to several factors. The first is that pandemic safety procedures decreased the incidence of other infectious illnesses, such as the flu and pneumonia. The second factor was “displaced mortality” – people who would likely have died from other causes dying first from COVID. Essentially many sick or vulnerable people, who were at high risk of mortality anyway, died from COVID.
Finally, there is likely an illusory decrease in the numbers due to delayed diagnosis. There was, for example, a decrease in death from lung cancer, which is very unlikely to be real because of a lack of any plausible mechanism. Rather, epidemiologists speculate that people were simply less likely to be diagnosed with lung cancer because they were not seeking as much care.
What this likely means is that differences in health care infrastructure and income inequality likely had a significant impact on non-COVID deaths. In the US excess non-COVID deaths were heavily concentrated in the lower socioeconomic populations and minorities, in people without insurance or with less access to health care and dependent on lower quality hospitals. This data provided an important lesson to future pandemics. They do represent a significant stress on the healthcare system, revealing weaknesses. This means we need to provide much greater support for these vulnerable populations and healthcare systems in order to weather such stresses.
This data also, to some extent, validates the “flatten the curve” approach that was taken early on in the pandemic. The goal was to limit the spread of COVID, even if the eventual numbers of those infected were not reduced, in order to reduce the strain on hospitals. That strain clearly had a significant negative impact on health care and health outcomes even beyond COVID itself. This also likely means that we need to build more resilience into our health care system in order to be prepared for spikes in demand caused by pandemics or other disasters.

The Suicide Holiday Myth, Now with COVID
There is no association between the holidays and suicide – that is a myth. The effect of the pandemic is less clear.
Steven Novella on December 2, 2020
Link

You may have heard that the suicide rate increases during the winter months due to seasonal affective disorder (the winter blues) or that it specifically increases during the holiday season. People are quick to invent explanations for this correlation, most commonly that the holidays exacerbate social isolation, loneliness, and economic or other struggles. No such explanations are necessary, however, because the correlation between suicide and holidays is a complete myth.
In fact, according to the CDC, for many years December has had the lowest rate of suicide in the US, followed by November and January. So if anything there is a protective effect of the winter and/or the holidays, or it may just be that there are factors present in other seasons that increase the risk.
It is important for the media to get this detail correct because it is possible for irresponsible reporting to actually increase the public risk of suicide. There is a phenomenon known as “suicide contagion” in which reporting on suicide can have a negative effect on vulnerable individuals, increasing their risk, which can in turn increase reporting in a positive feedback loop. To mitigate this effect there are published journalistic standards on how to report about suicide. One of those standards involves not hyping “epidemics” of suicide – especially when they are not actually true.
For the last 21 years the Annenberg Public Policy Center has been tracking reporting about the holiday suicide myth. They found that in most years there is more reporting spreading the myth than debunking it, and in only 3 of the last 21 years did 60% or more of the reporting they found debunk the myth. Interestingly, in the 2006-2007 season 90% of reporting debunked the myth, presumably due to efforts to spread reliable information. But this peak effect lasted only a year, with a majority of reporting supporting the myth again by 2009. The myth (like most such myths) has proven remarkably persistent.
Regarding the COVID-19 pandemic there is legitimate concern that this will have the effect of increasing suicides by increasing suicide risk factors. These risk factors include anxiety, depression, isolation, and economic and other stressors. We also have data from prior pandemics and epidemics that do show a tendency to increase suicide rates.
For this reason it is prudent to increase awareness of the risk of suicide, warning signs, and resources available for those at risk. These preventive measures are always a good idea, but may need to be increased as the pandemic drags on. As noted above, however, it is equally important the journalist understand how to responsibly report about these concerns, and to not exaggerate them or present them in hyperbolic terms, but rather to direct readers to helpful resources. Further, don’t fall for the “Holiday COVID” narrative, because it is simply not true.
There remains, however, the scientific question of whether or not the COVID-19 pandemic has, in fact, increased suicide rates in any locations or demographics. There is always a delay in collecting and analyzing data, so we don’t have real-time information. At present we have published data looking mostly at the Spring shutdown period. During this period there was no apparent increase in suicides, or even a decrease, at least in industrialized nations. This was shown by multiple studies. In fact, Japan saw a statistically significant decrease in suicide in the Spring by 12% (with a corresponding increase of 13% over the Summer). Other countries so far have not shown a similar Summer increase during the second wave of the pandemic.
We also need to note that data from poor and developing countries is mostly lacking, and so these conclusions cannot be extrapolated beyond the more wealthy nations where data is available.
The bottom line is that it is too early to tell what the overall effect of the pandemic is on suicide rates. The shutdown itself did not increase suicide rates. This may have been due to a “honeymoon effect” as people pulled together to deal with the pandemic, and also as people were helped by government subsidies.
As the pandemic drags on, however, there is legitimate reason for concern because suicide risk factors are increasing due to the impact of the pandemic. However, it may be possible to mitigate this risk through adequate economic aid to those most affected by the pandemic, to increased surveillance of warning signs and availability of suicide prevention resources, and through responsible reporting (following published guidelines).
Overall we need to be careful not to get ahead of the data, and not to create a pandemic-suicide myth similar to the holiday-suicide myth. Once created, myth monsters are almost impossible to slay.

Should We Accept Unvaccinated Children Dying of COVID as a “Matter of Course”?
The same doctors who scold us for potentially minimizing “slightest bit of inflammation in the heart” when the vaccine is to blame, shame us for trying to keep children from dying when the virus is to blame. 
Jonathan Howard on January 27, 2023
Link

In a previous article, I asked the question, Is it “Natural and Healthy” When Children Get Sick With COVID? The answer to this question is obvious. My article was in response to a pro-virus article titled “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?” by Dr. Vinay Prasad and Allison Krug who wrote:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.
The idea that vaccine-preventable diseases are healthy for children is an old anti-vaccine trope. Prior to the pandemic, anti-vaccine doctors claimed measles prevents cancer, for example. In reality, neither measles nor COVID is “healthy” for children.
However, the article Dr. Prasad and Krug contained another absurd claim. They also wrote:
While the death of any child is a tragedy, Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course, including drowning, vehicle accidents, and even cardiovascular disease.
This is doubly false. The CDC’s COVID data tracker added 800 deaths to its grim tally in the year before that article was published, and 800 children have since died of COVID. This is the same as the number of children who drown annually and larger than the number of children who die from cardiovascular disease. Overall, over 2,000 children have died of COVID since the start of the pandemic, and many more would have died had none been vaccinated. In 2020, 607 children younger that 12 years were killed in car crashes. It’s clear more than that would have died of COVID had we let it rip through the pediatric population before any children were vaccinated in spring 2020. It’s only because we didn’t let that happen then, that Dr. Prasad can now write COVID is less deadly than car crashes.
Beyond this, we absolutely don’t accept children dying “as a matter of course”. We normally do whatever we can to keep children safe and alive. Products that kill a relatively small number of children are rightly recalled. (Guns are a notable exception). Sadly, there is no vaccine against drowning and car accidents, and so we go to much greater lengths to keep children safe from these risks. There are crossing guards, seat belts, air bags, traffic laws, lifeguards, swim and driving lessons, life preservers, and fences around pools. None of these are as cheap and simple as a vaccine, yet none are controversial. No reasonable person would reject an improved car seat that slashed car fatalities by arguing that we should just accept such deaths as a “matter of course”. In fact, pediatric car deaths have been nearly cut in half over the past 20 years because we didn’t accept dead children as a “matter of course”.
Notably, Dr. Prasad does not feel that we should accept a rare, “mild and self-limiting” vaccine side-effect as a “matter of course”. He recently wrote that “even the slightest bit of inflammation in the heart should be treated seriously”. The same doctors who scold us for potentially minimizing “slightest bit of inflammation in the heart” when the vaccine is to blame, shame us for trying to keep children from dying when the virus is to blame. Perhaps he or another medical “conservative” can write a rebuttal to my essay titled “We Should Accept Dead Children as a Matter of Course, But Not the Slightest Bit of Inflammation in the Heart”.
At least Dr. Prasad and Krug were right that the death of any child is a tragedy. 7-year-old Adalyn Graviss died of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis less than 72-hours after testing positive for COVID. Her mother said:
She loves Jesus music, she loved being around her family and friends, she loved basketball, she loved dance, she loved going to church, she loved to play dress-up. Every day she wore my high heels and she was dancing up and down the hallway.
According to news reports, Adalyn’s parents “had been considering taking Adalyn to get her COVID-19 vaccine after she became eligible in November, but held off”. Adalyn would almost certainly be alive today had her parents chose differently.
Children will continue to die despite our best efforts. We can’t keep them locked in bubble wrap, and life isn’t risk free. However, we should never accept hundreds of children dying as a matter of course, especially when most can be saved with a simple vaccine.
This didn’t used to be controversial amongst doctors. It is now.

COVID-19 and Children: More Useless Comparisons
How COVID-19 affects children is independent of how it affects their grandparents.
Jonathan Howard on October 14, 2021
Tweet

Several months ago I wrote an article about how not to write about COVID-19 and children. In that article, I argued that writers have an obligation to inform their readers of several core facts. While the vast majority of children who contract COVID-19 will be just fine, in the USA, 686 children have died, tens of thousands have been hospitalized, 5,217 children have been diagnosed with MIS-C, and a not insignificant number will suffer from long-COVID. I further argued that writers who only note that COVID-19 is more dangerous for elderly people or that more children die from other causes, are doing their readers a disservice by omitting these core facts. Acknowledging these core facts does not mean that policy positions automatically follow, though informed policy discussions require they be recognized.
Unfortunately, several journalists seem to have used my article not was a warning, but rather as an instruction manual. For example, David Leonhardt at The New York Times wrote an article titled “COVID-19 and Age” in which he argued that COVID-19 can’t be that bad for children as long as it remains worse for their grandparents. As he put it, “An unvaccinated child is at less risk of serious Covid illness than a vaccinated 70-year-old.” While this is true, his article contained zero of the core facts about how COVID-19 has harmed children.
This was not Mr. Leonhardt’s first foray into minimizing COVID-19’s impact on children. He incorrectly argued that the flu is as dangerous to children as COVID-19, neglecting to note that COVID-19 is much more contagious than the flu. As such, in a year when COVID-19 killed hundreds of American children, the flu killed just one child.
He further noted that more children die in car crashes and drownings than from the virus. While it can be useful to contextualize COVID-19 this way, the dangers of the virus to children are independent of how it affects elderly people or how many children die from other causes. COVID-19 wouldn’t be worse for children if elderly people were spared of if car crashes and drownings were eliminated.
Moreover, we generally go to great lengths to try to keep children from dying preventable deaths, and except for guns, this is usually not a source of controversy. There are traffic laws, seat belts, swim lessons, life preservers, and fences around pools. We all agree these are good things. For COVID-19, there are masks and a vaccine. Sadly, we don’t all agree these are good things, and so teenagers who were eligible to be vaccinated have died this summer after the vaccine was available to them.
While Mr. Leonhardt’s most recent article thankfully advocated vaccinating children- though he called it a “close call”- overall it was a classic in the sad genre of articles that mislead readers through gross omissions of basic facts and the liberal use of essentially irrelevant comparisons.
However, even if Mr. Leonhardt decides to include some core facts in a future column, comparing pediatric deaths to those of their grandparents is still problematic. The reason for this is so glaringly obvious I never thought to mention it previously: unlike 70-year-olds, children who die of COVID-19 are robbed of their entire lives. As Dr. Ester Choo put it:
It’s odd to see comparisons between children and older adults, as if the health indicators and expectations are the same. We have fundamentally different frames for children’s health.
Indeed, pediatricians who have treated sick children this pandemic often have a different perspective than those who have experienced it from behind a computer screen. Responding to podcaster Joe Rogan who said “statistically speaking, there’s so few children that have died from COVID”, our own Dr. Clay Jones said,
He should be forced to watch a child die. Not read about it, or watch a news report showing the family grieving, but sit in the room with a child as they die. He can only prattle on like an ignorant asshole because he has no skin in this game. He should at least see it in person.
Since few of us will see a child die of COVID-19, thankfully, we’ll have to read about these children and remember they are more than just numbers on a CDC website. Kali Cook, who liked to play with worms, will never go to kindergarten. She was one of 200 American children who died before they turned 5. Ryland Daic, who loved to fish, will never graduate high school. Gigi Morse will never go to a prom. Kimora Lynum, who liked shopping for clothes, will never celebrate her college graduation. Week Day will never have her first kiss. Wyatt Gibson will never get married. Dykota Morgan, a basketball player, will never hold her own child. Ethan Govan will never get the satisfaction of earning his first paycheck. Skylar Herbert, who wanted to be a pediatric dentist, will never work at all. Maybe Fabiana Zoppelli was destined to be a brilliant scientist. Teresa Sperry loved to sing. Maybe she would have been a star. It’s possible that Landon Woodson or Azorean Tatum would have made it to the NFL.
        ◦ We’ll never know what life had in store for these children. They were robbed of all of it. It doesn’t matter that their grandparents were statistically more likely to die. Writers who minimize these tragedies by only reporting that COVID-19 is more dangerous for elderly people are out to advance a narrative, not inform their readers. Their future work should be read with this in mind.

COVID-19 is a leading cause of death among children, but that doesn’t stop some of my colleagues from arguing against vaccinating them
Contrary to what the “COVID-19 isn’t a threat to children” contingent says, COVID-19 is a leading cause of death among children. Yet “not antivax” doctors continue, either unknowingly or knowingly, recycle old antivax tropes to argue against vaccinating children against this disease.
David Gorski on February 6, 2023
Link

As someone who has been following the antivaccine movement for over twenty years (and blogging about it for over 18 years), before the pandemic I never thought I would see my “provaccine” colleagues claim that children don’t need to be vaccinated against an infectious disease that kills at least as many children as measles did in the days before there was a vaccine. Indeed, that is basically the entire message behind the “Urgency of Normal” movement promoting a message during the Delta wave claiming that masks and COVID-19 mitigations in schools were not necessary because so few children die of the diseases, a state public health authority actively discouraging parents from vaccinating their children against COVID-19, and academics even recycling hoary old antivax tropes in a bioethics journal to argue against the need to vaccinate children against COVID-19. I suppose I shouldn’t have been surprised, as I’ve been reminding my colleagues who are shocked at how many doctors are antivaccine that such antivax docs have always been among us, but the intensity and degree of the pushback among colleagues against vaccinating children against COVID-19 and their utter obliviousness that the arguments they were making were nothing more than old antivax arguments indistinguishable from the arguments antivaxxers used to make about measles vaccines surprised even me. What particularly surprised and disappointed me is the degree to which seemingly eminent academic physicians, while showing concern about reports of myocarditis after vaccination, seemingly shrug their shoulders about the disease, thinking it seemingly “natural and healthy” for children to die of a vaccine-preventable disease. They even argue, as antivaxxers did prepandemic for measles and chickenpox “parties,” that we should let children catch Omicron rather than impose anything resembling pandemic restrictions like masking or vaccine mandates in a school ever again.
For example, Drs. Vinay Prasad and Allison Krug actually argued:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.
As Dr. Jonathan Howard put it, the idea that vaccine-preventable diseases are healthy for children is an old anti-vaccine trope. So is this other statement by Drs. Prasad and Krug:
While the death of any child is a tragedy, Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course, including drowning, vehicle accidents, and even cardiovascular disease.
Well do I remember antivaxxers lamenting with ever-so-serious faux sorrow the deaths of children from, say, measles or Haemophilus influenza, but then quickly adding that the chances of this happening are so low that vaccines aren’t needed, or, as Drs. Prasad and Krug put it, COVID-19 should just be a risk that we accept “as a matter of course.” These “not antivax” doctors routinely take severe umbrage when it is pointed out to them that they are using exactly the same arguments that antivaxxers used to use before the pandemic for vaccines such as the MMR and pertussis vaccines, but they are, no matter how much these “not antivax” docs try to claim COVID-19 is different.
Whenever I hear arguments like theirs, I like to point out that children shouldn’t die and that, by and large, they don’t die at anywhere the same frequency as adults and old people. At least, they don’t now, given that the vaccine-preventable diseases that used to kill large numbers of children have been controlled. In other words, we correctly expect that the number of children who die of any cause every year should be small and quite rightly do not tolerate the preventable deaths of children. (At least, we didn’t until 2021 or so, when we saw the rise of physicians with a seeming—shall we say?—nonchalance to the deaths of children on media, both old and new, particularly on social media.
This brings me to a bit of data, specifically a study that was published a week ago in JAMA Network Open, Assessment of COVID-19 as the Underlying Cause of Death Among Children and Young People Aged 0 to 19 Years in the US. Let’s just say that, as Dr. Howard and I (and many others) have been arguing all along, COVID-19 is at least a comparable threat to children as any other prepandemic vaccine-preventable child infectious disease.  The study, by an international group of investigators, led by researchers at the University of Oxford’s Department of Computer Science investigated COVID-19 mortality among children and young people (CYP) aged 0-19 using data from US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention databases. Specifically, they used data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Wide-Ranging Online Data for Epidemiologic Research (WONDER) database on underlying cause of death in the US to identify the ranking of COVID-19 relative to other causes of death among children and young people from birth to age 19. COVID-19 deaths were examined in 12-month periods between April 1, 2020, and August 31, 2022, compared with deaths from leading non–COVID-19 causes in 2019, 2020, and 2021.
I’m just going to go straight to the bottom line here:
There were 821 COVID-19 deaths among individuals aged 0 to 19 years during the study period, resulting in a crude death rate of 1.0 per 100 000 population overall; 4.3 per 100 000 for those younger than 1 year; 0.6 per 100 000 for those aged 1 to 4 years; 0.4 per 100 000 for those aged 5 to 9 years; 0.5 per 100 000 for those aged 10 to 14 years; and 1.8 per 100 000 for those aged 15 to 19 years. COVID-19 mortality in the time period of August 1, 2021, to July 31, 2022, was among the 10 leading causes of death in CYP aged 0 to 19 years in the US, ranking eighth among all causes of deaths, fifth in disease-related causes of deaths (excluding unintentional injuries, assault, and suicide), and first in deaths caused by infectious or respiratory diseases when compared with 2019. COVID-19 deaths constituted 2% of all causes of death in this age group.
I can almost hear my “urgency of normal” colleagues twitching and saying, “So what? That’s still a small number of deaths relative to the number of children who have had COVID-19.” Perhaps, but I’ve never found the argument that, hey, it “wasn’t that many dead children” to be a particularly persuasive argument. I’m funny that way. Still, let’s move on to a graphical representation:

Not enough for you? How about this ranking? Notice how the death toll from COVID-19 is comparable to the prepandemic death toll due to heart disease.

Still not enough? Let’s look at infectious diseases alone:

Now let’s let the authors really lay it on the line in blunt terms:
While other causes of death, such as unintentional injuries (18.4%), assault (6.9%), and suicide (6.8%) represented a large percentage of all causes of death, COVID-19 ranked fifth in disease-related causes of deaths (excluding unintentional injuries, assault, and suicide), and first in deaths caused by infectious and respiratory diseases. Comparing deaths from COVID-19 with deaths from other vaccine-preventable diseases historically, COVID-19 caused substantially more deaths (821 deaths in our study period in CYP) than major vaccine-preventable diseases did before vaccines became available: hepatitis A (3 reported deaths in children per year in the US), rotavirus (20-60 reported deaths in children per year in the US), rubella (17 reported deaths in children per year in the US), varicella (50 reported deaths in children per year in the US),15 and measles (495 total reported deaths per year,16 the vast majority in children17).
In summary, we found that COVID-19 is now a leading cause of death for CYP aged 0-19 years in the US, and the top (first) leading cause of death among infectious and respiratory diseases.
Worse, the results of this study likely underestimate the impact of COVID-19 on the health of children. They also likely underestimate the number of deaths attributable to COVID-19, for these reasons:
Our findings need to be considered in the context of several limitations which mean that we may have underestimated the true mortality burden of COVID-19 in CYP aged 0 to 19 years. Analyses of excess deaths have suggested underreporting bias in COVID-19 deaths22; specific criteria for determining COVID-19 deaths is heterogeneous across the US and has changed over time; and delays to reporting may be substantial for recent time periods.14 We consider COVID-19 as an underlying (and not contributing) cause of death only, but COVID-19 amplifies the severe impacts of other diseases, and mortality hazards from coinfection (eg, influenza23) are increased with accompanying comorbidities. The category of deaths from influenza and pneumonia combines a variety of causes, to which SARS-CoV-2 could be a contributing factor.23,24 Recent evidence also suggests that COVID-19 may contribute to serious long-term sequelae25 in children and adolescents, which are unlikely to have been captured in these data.
In a press release, one of the coauthors puts it into proper perspective:
Assistant Professor Robbie M. Parks of Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, a co-author of the study, said: “If you look at infectious diseases in children in the US historically, in the period before vaccines became available, hepatitis A, rotavirus, rubella, and measles were all major causes of death. But when we compared those diseases to COVID-19, we found that COVID-19 caused substantially more deaths in children and young people than those other diseases did before vaccines became available; this demonstrates how seriously we need to take COVID-19 prevention and mitigation measures for the youngest age groups in the US and worldwide.”
I like to compare the death toll from COVID-19 to the death toll attributable to measles before the vaccine to make this point. In the decade before the first measles vaccine was licensed in 1963, measles routinely infected three to four million people, resulting in 400-500 deaths a year. Since the pandemic began, approximately 1,300 children and young people 0-19 years of age have died of COVID-19. That’s under three years, and most of these deaths have occurred during the last two years.
But wait! I can sense “not antivax” doctors saying that there weren’t nearly as many children in 1960 as there are now. Well, yes and no. There were 64.5 million children in the US in 1960. To be precise, I will conceded that the numbers I found aren’t strictly comparable because the old statistics count ages 0-17 as children and don’t go up to 19, but we’re not interested in three decimal point precision but ballpark figures. So, using that same source I find that there were 72.8 million children age 0-17 in the US in 2020. In other words, even adjusted for population growth, the COVID-19 death toll among children now is in the same ballpark as the death toll from measles was in 1960. To put it another way, at best, COVID-19 is roughly as deadly to children as measles was before the vaccine (and that’s even with a percentage of the population ages 0-19 having been vaccinated). More likely, COVID-19 is considerably more deadly to children than measles was in the 1950s, before the vaccine was developed.
Yet back then doctors and scientists considered measles, its status as a “normal childhood illness” notwithstanding, to be a deadly threat that warranted a vaccine—and rightly so! We shouldn’t tolerate 500 children dying every year and something like 1-3 per 1,000 suffering severe neurological sequelae, and in the 1960s we didn’t. The measles vaccine resulted in a dramatic decline in the number of cases of measles per year. In contrast, today a distressing number of physicians just shrug their shoulders metaphorically at an equal or higher level of carnage due to an infectious disease, and trot out the same old antivax arguments used for measles based on COVID-19 supposedly being “not a threat” to children in order to argue against pandemic mitigations in schools or vaccine mandates. And, yes, I’m calling out certain physicians by name, including Drs. Vinay Prasad, Allison Krug, and Tracy Beth Høeg, to begin with, for doing just this.
Let me finish by putting it this way. If you use arguments against vaccinating children against COVID-19 that are in form identical to the arguments that antivaxxers used to use before the pandemic to argue against vaccinating children against measles, pertussis, and the like, namely that the disease isn’t a threat to the children, while ignoring that the disease kills hundreds of children a year, what should I call you? You’ve lost the right to get all indignant if I call you an antivaxxer. If the name fits…

I Reject Your Medical Reality and I Substitute Death
Denying reality and substituting his own worked for Adam Savage. Not so much as an approach to COVID.
Mark CrisliponAugust 15, 2023
Link

I am, no surprise, a big fan of reality. I think I have a reasonable approximation of what reality is, mostly understood through the lens of the sciences. I learned early in my edumacation the key word is approximation. Always approaching a complete picture of life, the universe, and everything asymptotically. Zeno’s paradox is the best representation of to how I acquire understanding.
Not everyone is a fan of reality. I remember being amused back in the day by Adam Savage’s tag line of,”I reject your reality and substitute my own.” As a sci-fi guy who read a lot of alternative (complementary? integrative?) history, I thought it funny. But to a rather worrisome degree, it defines many people, except for the obvious (to me) fact that there are no other realities that can be slotted in at will.
I have often thought it should be reality-based medicine. In part, because the SCAM proponents use science, albeit, with a more Dr. Science kind of ineptness, to justify their practices, and in part it offers an easy opposite. What is the opposite of science-based medicine? The antonyms of science do not roll trippingly off the tongue, although I do kind of like witlessness-based medicine as an alternative to alternative medicine. But the opposite of reality? Fantasy-based, delusion-based, or fiction-based medicine sum the not-so-distinguished competition up so much better.
Denying reality has consequences. Few, rock climbers excepted, deny, say, the existence of gravity. Planes and bridges are not built using alternative ideas as to what constitutes gravity. The earth sucks, as an example, is not a workable construct for keeping a plane aloft.
Medicine seems particularly prone to people denying reality and substituting their own. It often doesn’t work out well. I saw many examples in my long and storied career. The first case was as a medical student doing my ER rotation. Guy came in weak with a low blood pressure and a very low hemoglobin (a measurement of how much red blood cells are in the circulation). A slow bleed, from a gastrointestinal cancer, was on the list of reasons, but taking off his shirt to listen to his lungs revealed a huge, mushroom-shaped melanoma that was oozing blood. He denied its existence. He was not the only patient I saw over the years who presented with huge, necrotic tumors whose presence were denied by the patient. Some were the size of dinner plates and the patient would say, nope, hadn’t noticed.
I have mentioned in the past the case that got me involved in SCAMs. I was called for a consult for a leg infection. Rather than an infection, it was a young female with a dead, rotting leg from a progressive sarcoma being very unsuccessfully treated by a naturopath. The tumor eroded that night into an artery and she died. ND. Not a Doctor.
I also saw many a patient who denied their AIDS diagnosis, refused care, progressed and died.
Note a pattern: reject medical reality and die.
There were no end of deaths from COVID in those who denied COVID, its prevention, appropriate treatment or the benefits of the vaccine. Reality substitution seemed to have a particular predilection for conservative talk show hosts
no less than five conservative radio talk show hosts who urged their audiences to avoid vaccines for COVID-19 have died from the virus.
Far be it for me to suggest any schadenfreude. Those COVID deaths from reality substitution were mostly anecdotes, not a careful evaluation of the epidemiology of the consequences of ignoring reality.
The epidemiology of COVID changed as the virus washed back and forth over the US. It started in the blue NW and took its time to reach the red South. The disease evolved and along with it our understanding of its spread, its treatment and prevention. So early on it was difficult to make hard-and-fast rules about who gets COVID and why, given all the flux and variation.
This was noted in early studies as COVID wandered from blue to red states.
From March 2020 to early June 2020, Republican-led states had lower COVID-19 incidence rates than Democratic-led states. On June 3, 2020, the association reversed, and Republican-led states had a higher incidence (risk ratio=1.10, 95% posterior interval=1.01, 1.18). This trend persisted through early December 2020. For death rates, Republican-led states had lower rates early in the pandemic but higher rates from July 4, 2020 (risk ratio=1.18, 95% posterior interval=1.02, 1.31) through mid-December 2020.
And while the death rates/100,000 were higher in states with Republican Governors, the comparisons were not at a steady state for the disease in the country.
Substituting reality by ignoring masking and social distancing before the vaccine was variable and direct comparisons of red or blue were problematic. The trend towards more reality substitution in red areas and subsequent suboptimal consequences appeared real and was plausible from basic infection control practice. Reality substitution is a bad idea in the hospital for infection control, there would be no reason to suspect the same principals would not apply in the real world.
So, when did we reach steady state with COVID? Got me. Sometime after the vaccine was released and after the entire country had seen the first wave would be one reasonable, or arbitrary, point. And that brings us to the most recent reality denial paper, Excess Death Rates for Republican and Democratic Registered Voters in Florida and Ohio During the COVID-19 Pandemic
Between January 1, 2018, and December 31, 2021, there were 538 159 individuals in Ohio and Florida who died at age 25 years or older in the study sample. The median age at death was 78 years (IQR, 71-89 years). Overall, the excess death rate for Republican voters was 2.8 percentage points, or 15%, higher than the excess death rate for Democratic voters (95% prediction interval [PI], 1.6-3.7 percentage points). After May 1, 2021, when vaccines were available to all adults, the excess death rate gap between Republican and Democratic voters widened from -0.9 percentage point (95% PI, -2.5 to 0.3 percentage points) to 7.7 percentage points (95% PI, 6.0-9.3 percentage points) in the adjusted analysis; the excess death rate among Republican voters was 43% higher than the excess death rate among Democratic voters. The gap in excess death rates between Republican and Democratic voters was larger in counties with lower vaccination rates and was primarily noted in voters residing in Ohio.
How widely applicable the results are is uncertain, but it is in agreement with the general trend that denying reality and substituting your own can be fatal, at least in medicine. It still worked well as a concept in MythBusters.
But consider the close election of 2024.
Arizona had 6400 COVID deaths as of November 2020 on their way to 30,000 as of this month.Biden won by 10,000 votes in 2020.
Georgia had 8500 deaths on the way to 35,000.Biden won by 12,000 votes.
Wisconsin had 3000 deaths on the way to 16000.Biden won by 20,000.
Republicans had a 43% higher death rate since the vaccine was introduced and a 15% higher death rate before the vaccine.
Ballpark calculations, and there are all sorts of ways to crunch the numbers depending on the breakdown of party affiliation, age, etc., suggests that reality denial may have helped prevent the re-election of Donald Trump. Odd to think about, but the Red Cult of Death’s reality substitution may have helped swing the election to Biden, what with the electoral college and all. Trump still would have lost the popular vote.
And for 2024 there will be more red dead than blue dead. Supporting policies that kill your constituents may be counterproductive to electoral victory. If a similarly close race happens in 2024, it may not be the dead who vote that make a difference, but the COVID dead who can no longer vote. Red Dead and no Redemption My son played that game during COVID; I particularly liked that the main character caught TB and died of it. Didn’t wear a mask or socially distance when it may have helped.
Someone with a more sophisticated understanding of the numbers should do the calculations across the US as of November 2022 and see how reality denial affected the election and might alter future elections.
In the meantime, I will continue to voice my support for reality in all its approximations, regardless of the electoral consequences.

COVID-19 puts the spotlight on an unexpected racial disparity in health care
Evidence increasingly suggests that pulse oximeters, the little finger clips that measure blood oxygen, overestimate the blood oxygenation in Black patients. It’s a problem that’s been discussed a long time that took a pandemic to bring to public consciousness. How can SBM decrease or eliminate such healthcare disparities?
David Gorski on July 18, 2022
Link

Pulse oximeters are a fairly simple, yet amazing piece of medical technology that physicians often take for granted. A non-invasive method for monitoring the oxygen content of a patient’s blood with a clip placed on a finger or earlobe, pulse oximeters took on an outsized role when the COVID-19 pandemic hit. The reason is that a key measure of severity of the pneumonia caused by COVID-19 is hypoxia. Normal oxygen saturation of the hemoglobin in the red blood cells is 95% or higher (meaning that 95% of the hemoglobin is carrying oxygen), with saturations of 90% and lower being an indicator of severe disease. Indeed, one feature of COVID-19 that doctors rapidly discovered was a phenomenon called silent hypoxia (sometimes “happy hypoxia“), in which patients are hypoxic (sometimes very hypoxic) with none of the usual symptoms of hypoxia or just minimal symptoms. Stories of patients with dangerously low oxygen saturations scrolling on their phones, chatting with doctors, and generally describing themselves as comfortable rapidly became a staple among doctors treating the then mysterious new coronavirus disease in 2020.
Pulse oximeters, which detected the silent hypoxia, are a critical tool in monitoring patients during surgery or with any disease that can impact the function of their lungs and hearts. They are used to monitor all patients undergoing general anesthesia and heavy sedation, as well as patients in ICUs, emergency rooms, and a number of other healthcare settings. But what if pulse oximeters, usually presumed to be accurate, were not so accurate for a large group of people? Last week, as I was driving to work, I listened to an NPR report about studies showing that pulse oximeters often do not provide accurate estimates of oxygen saturation (SpO2) in patients with darker skin, tending to overestimate SpO2 in patients with darker skin, including Black, Hispanic, and Asian patients, as compared to wWite patients:
Over the past two years, the pulse oximeter has become a crucial tool for tracking the health of COVID-19 patients.
The small device clips onto a finger and measures the amount of oxygen in a patient’s blood. But a growing body of evidence shows the device can be inaccurate when measuring oxygen levels in people with dark skin tones.
A study published on Monday only adds to this concern.
Researchers analyzing pre-pandemic health data also find those measurements resulted in patients of color receiving less supplemental oxygen than white patients did.
“We were fooled by the pulse oximeter,” says the study’s lead author Dr. Leo Anthony Celi, who’s clinical research director and principal research scientist at the MIT Laboratory of Computational Physiology.
“We were given the false impression that the patients were okay. And what we showed in this study is that we were giving them less oxygen than they needed,” he says.
As an example of potential disparities in COVID-19 care related to this phenomenon, the story included an anecdote about a physician, Dr. Sandra Looby-Gordon, whose son was sick with COVID-19 but for whom pulse oximeter readings gave a false impression that he was not in imminent danger:
Looby-Gordon, who’s a physician at Boston Medical Center, found herself on the phone with a triage nurse at a Florida hospital, arguing that her own son — who was very sick with COVID-19 — needed to be admitted to the hospital.
“‘Well, yeah, he is looking pretty short of breath,'” Looby-Gordon remembers the nurse responding, “‘but his oxygen levels are good.'”
The nurse was basing this on the reading from the pulse oximeter clipped to his finger, but this assessment did not feel right to Looby-Gordon.
She got off the phone with the nurse and spoke with other doctors at her medical center. One of them reminded her of a 2020 article in the New England Journal of Medicine showing the pulse oximeter tends to be inaccurate in people with dark skin tones.
“On top of that, my son is — this sounds strange — but very dark, very dark complexion,” says Looby-Gordon.
Sure enough, later when her son was given a more invasive test for measuring blood oxygen, it showed his oxygen levels were actually dangerously low.
That “more invasive test” was likely an arterial blood draw to measure the oxygen level in the patient’s arterial blood directly, rather than indirectly. Surprisingly, many physicians are not aware of this problem with pulse oximeters. Indeed, the NPR story notes that Dr. Looby-Gordon hadn’t been “fully aware of how the device could be so misleading” before her son got COVID-19 and she had to argue with treating doctors that he was sicker than his home pulse oximeter readings suggested.
This phenomenon is not something that was unknown before COVID-19. However, COVID-19 did bring it into the news and lead to a greater understanding of racial disparities in medical care can show up in unexpected places and how science-based medicine needs to pay more attention to them.
How pulse oximeters work
The most accurate test to determine the oxygen saturation is to sample arterial blood and measure arterial blood gases. An arterial blood gas (ABG), in which case the measurement is referred to as SaO2, as opposed to saturation measurements obtained by pulse oximetry (SpO2). The ABG provides not just SaO2 measurements, but partial pressures of oxygen and carbon dioxide dissolved in the blood, as well as blood pH, bicarbonate, and hemoglobin levels. These measurements allow doctors to determine, among other things, if there’s enough oxygen in the blood and whether there’s an acidosis (too much acid) or alkalosis (too little acid) and whether the acidosis or alkalosis is respiratory or metabolic in origin. However, monitoring ABGs requires either an intra-arterial catheter from which blood can be drawn or periodic arterial sticks to draw arterial blood for measurements. A pulse oximeter, although only providing estimates of SpO2 and pulse rate, is valuable because it’s non-invasive and can take continuous readings.
Pulse oximeters are cool pieces of engineering that take advantage of the different light absorbances of hemoglobin when it doesn’t have oxygen bound to it compared to when it does. In brief, pulse oximeters use a pair of LEDs, one of which emits red light (660 nm wavelength) and the other infrared (940 nm), taking advantage of difference in absorption of that light between deoxygenated hemoglobin (Hb) versus oxygenated hemoglobin (HbO2) in the near-infrared spectrum:

In brief, HbO2 absorbs more infrared light and allows more red light to pass through, while Hb allows more infrared light to pass through and absorbs more red light. I’ll borrow a nice summary of how the device works from here:
    • The LEDs sequence through their cycle of one on, then the other, then both off about thirty times per second.
    • The amount of light that is transmitted (in other words, that is not absorbed) is measured.
    • These signals fluctuate in time because the amount of arterial blood that is present increases (literally pulses) with each heartbeat.
    • By subtracting the minimum transmitted light from the peak transmitted light in each wavelength, the effects of other tissues is corrected for allowing for measurement of only the arterial blood.
    • The ratio of the red light measurement to the infrared light measurement is then calculated by the processor (which represents the ratio of oxygenated hemoglobin to deoxygenated hemoglobin).
    • This ratio is then converted to SpO2 by the processor via a lookup table based on the Beer–Lambert law.
As a result of this, the pulse oximeter produces waveforms that look like this:

Interestingly, it’s long been known that nail polish can interfere with pulse oximetry readings, rendering them less accurate. (What a surprise! A pigment interferes with readings based on measuring how much light is absorbed at different wavelengths!) Other interesting potentials failure of pulse oximetry have long been appreciated, namely carboxyhemoglobin (due to carbon monoxide poisoning, with carbon monoxide binding to hemoglobin) or methemoglobin (hemoglobin with an oxidized iron atom resulting in increased O2 binding and reduced unloading). In these cases, carboxyhemoglobin and methemoblobin have similar absorption spectra to HbO2, leading pulse oximetry readings to report a falsely elevated SpO2. Under these conditions, pulse oximetry is not accurate estimating SpO2, and physicians learn this during training.
Pulse oximetry in non-wWite patients
The inaccuracy of pulse oximetry in people with more pigmented skin is an issue that was long (sort of) known, but relatively little attention was paid to this issue before the pandemic hit, leading to an unprecedented influx of patients with hypoxia who needed monitoring, as well as the purchase of more home pulse oximeters than had ever been purchased before. In addition, smart watches and fitness monitors such as the Apple Watch and Fitbit Sense added a pulse oximeter to their health monitoring repertoire and were soon found to suffer from issues that negatively impacted their reliability. As this Washington Post story notes:
The tiny type at the bottom of Apple’s website says its blood oxygen app is “not intended for medical use” and is “only designed for general fitness and wellness purposes.” Fitbit’s small print says its blood-oxygen app is “not intended to diagnose or treat any medical condition” and is useful to “help you manage your well-being and keep track of your information.”
With the reporter noting:
Over several days of comparing my second Apple Watch’s measurements to my FDA-approved finger oximeter, Apple’s readings most often differ by two or three percentage points — though they’ve also sometimes exactly matched, and sometimes have been as much as seven percentage points lower.
And, oddly enough:
When I tested the Apple Watch on a colleague whose skin is darker than mine, the results were also off from the finger pulse oximeter, but less wildly so.
Others have found that the Apple Watch, at least, produces fairly accurate SpO2 readings.
As much as I love my Apple Watch otherwise, I ended up ultimately turning off the pulse oximeter feature because its regular SpO2 measurements were chewing up the battery, leading to greatly decreased battery life, and often reported low oxygen saturation readings that are clearly not accurate.
The first study that looked at pulse oximetry in non-White patients during COVID-19 was published as a letter in 2020 in The New England Journal of Medicine. The study came from my medical alma mater, the University of Michigan, and examined 10,789 pairs of measures of oxygen saturation by pulse oximetry and arterial oxygen saturation in arterial blood gas obtained from 1,333 White patients and 276 Black patients in a University of Michigan cohort and 37,308 pairs obtained from 7,342 White patients and 1,050 Black patients in a multicenter cohort.
The study found:
In unadjusted analyses, the area under the receiver-operating-characteristic curve for detecting an arterial blood gas oxygen saturation of less than 88% according to the oxygen saturation on pulse oximetry was 0.84 (95% CI, 0.81 to 0.87) among Black patients and 0.89 (95% CI, 0.87 to 0.91) among White patients (P=0.003). In the multicenter cohort, the unadjusted analyses involving patients with an oxygen saturation of 92 to 96% on pulse oximetry showed an arterial blood gas oxygen saturation of less than 88% in 160 of 939 measurements in Black patients (17.0%; 95% CI, 12.2 to 23.3) and in 546 of 8795 measurements in White patients (6.2%; 95% CI, 5.4 to 7.1).
Thus, in two large cohorts, Black patients had nearly three times the frequency of occult hypoxemia that was not detected by pulse oximetry as White patients. Given the widespread use of pulse oximetry for medical decision making, these findings have some major implications, especially during the current coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) pandemic. Our results suggest that reliance on pulse oximetry to triage patients and adjust supplemental oxygen levels may place Black patients at increased risk for hypoxemia. It is important to note that not all Black patients who had a pulse oximetry value of 92 to 96% had occult hypoxemia. However, the variation in risk according to race necessitates the integration of pulse oximetry with other clinical and patient-reported data.
That’s roughly one in six Black patients in the multicenter cohort with an SpO2 between 92-96% actually having occult hypoxemia, compared to one in 16 among White patients.
The study discussed in the NPR report last week was published in JAMA and examined a cohort of 3,069 patients in the intensive care unit. Specifically, it was a retrospective cohort study based on the Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care (MIMIC)-IV critical care data set. This dataset includes data from 40,000 patients admitted to intensive care units at the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, with patient identifiers removed according to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), so that the dataset could be used by a wide variety of researchers. Of note, this database is only up-to-date through 2019, which means that it did not at the time of analysis include COVID-19 patients.
The study included patients who were documented with a race and ethnicity as Asian, Black, Hispanic, or White and were admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) for at least 12 hours before needing advanced respiratory support (if it was needed). Oxygenation levels and nasal cannula flow rates for up to 5 days from ICU admission or until the time of intubation, noninvasive positive pressure ventilation, high-flow nasal cannula, or tracheostomy were analyzed. In this case, rather than comparing SaO2 measurements determined by ABG with those determined by pulse oximeter, the primary outcome measured was time-weighted average supplemental oxygen rate, with covariates including “race and ethnicity, sex, SpO2–hemoglobin oxygen saturation discrepancy, data duration, number and timing of blood gas tests on ICU days 1 to 3, partial pressure of carbon dioxide, hemoglobin level, average respiratory rate, Elixhauser comorbidity scores, and need for vasopressors or inotropes” (vasopressors cause blood vessels to relax and expand; inotropes make the heart pump harder and faster).
What this study adds to the literature is a demonstration that the overestimation of SpO2 in darker-skinned patients results in a lower oxygen use. This lower oxygen use for a given level of unsuspected hypoxemia likely results in poorer outcomes as well, as suggested by a study from 2021 that examined five databases with data from nearly 88,000 patients total that found that discrepancies in pulse oximetry accuracy among racial and ethnic subgroups were associated with higher rates of hidden hypoxemia, mortality, and organ dysfunction and that patients with and without hidden hypoxemia were demographically and clinically similar at baseline ABG measurement, but those with hidden hypoxemia subsequently experienced higher organ dysfunction scores and higher in-hospital mortality.
This racial disparity could well go beyond just patients who are critically ill. A Veterans Administration study published two weeks ago examined patients in general (non-ICU) care in VA hospitals from 2013-2019, concluding:
In general care inpatient settings across the Veterans Health Administration where paired readings of arterial blood gas (SaO2) and pulse oximetry (SpO2) were obtained, black patients had higher odds than white patients of having occult hypoxemia noted on arterial blood gas but not detected by pulse oximetry. This difference could limit access to supplemental oxygen and other more intensive support and treatments for black patients.
With the authors concluding:
Errors in pulse oximeters could be due to a combination of systematic error or bias, which is reproducible across measurements, as well as random error or noise. Because pulse oximeter error is due to a combination of both processes, the magnitude of pulse oximeter error might not be the same each time a reading is taken. We empirically show that these errors could result in clinically meaningful differences in the interpretation of pulse oximetry across racial groups. In patients with two pairs of SpO2-SaO2 readings measured on the same day, a well aligned SpO2-SaO2 pair for white patients was associated with low levels of occult hypoxemia on subsequent pairs; such concordance might be reassuring in many clinical scenarios. This concordance was less true for black patients, and these differences should be considered in deciding whether to obtain an arterial blood gas reading in appropriate clinical situations until non-racially biased pulse oximeters are in use.
Although this study found a smaller difference in the rate of hidden hypoxemia between White patients and Black patients, 15.6% compared to 19.6%, it was still significant and could be due to the patient population under study being less ill than in the other studies, which studied critically ill patients. Still, although there has been variability in results examining the accuracy of pulse oximeters, the trend is becoming more clear based on recent data. I could go on, but suffice to say that a growing body of evidence is showing that pulse oximeters can be dangerously inaccurate in some patients with darker skin, as noted in this STAT News story:
It’s been known for decades that the devices are less accurate in patients with darker skin and those wearing nail polish, but new interest and a stream of research about potential racial bias in the devices has been sparked by the racial disparities seen in Covid deaths and treatment. The measurement of oxygen levels using the devices has played a critical role in determining which Covid patients are admitted to the hospital and given supplemental oxygen and other therapies. The devices, invented in the 1970s, were tested on largely white populations.
“This is telling us what we see as disparities could be due to technology that is not optimized for all populations,” said Leo Anthony Celi, a co-author of the JAMA Internal Medicine paper, and an ICU physician and a principal research scientist at the Institute for Medical Engineering and Science at MIT who helped create the large public database of ICU patients used in the study. “We’re seeing the downstream effect. It performs poorly as soon as you apply it outside the demographic it was designed for.”
In June, the FDA updated its safety communication on pulse oximeter accuracy and limitations to announce:
The FDA continues to evaluate all available information pertaining to factors that may affect pulse oximeter accuracy and performance. Because of ongoing concerns that these products may be less accurate in individuals with darker skin pigmentations, the FDA is planning to convene a public meeting of the Medical Devices Advisory Committee later this year to discuss the available evidence about the accuracy of pulse oximeters, recommendations for patients and health care providers, the amount and type of data that should be provided by manufacturers to assess pulse oximeter accuracy, and to guide other regulatory actions as needed. Further details concerning the agenda, timing, and location of the Advisory Committee meeting will be announced in the coming weeks.
Currently, FDA guidance states that clinical trials for the approval of pulse oximeter devices should include at least two darkly pigmented people, or 15% of the subject pool, whichever is larger. It is not at all clear whether this sufficient to make sure that device makers overcome this problem
An unhelpful response
It’s becoming harder to deny that differences in pulse oximeter accuracy based on race exist and could well be harming people of color. Unfortunately, the response on the part of device manufacturers to these findings has not always been encouraging. For instance, in response to the University of Michigan study in 2020, Joe Kiani, founder and CEO of Masimo Corp., published an editorial titled “Pulse Oximeters Are Not Racist” in which, after stating that he was co-inventor of the “modern day, measure-through motion and low perfusion pulse oximeter (SET Pulse Oximeter),” he desperately tried to blame anything other than differences in skin pigment for the discrepancy in readings reported between White and Black people. He started by citing sickle cell anemia (sickle cell trait affects 10% of Black populations and can affect how pulse oximeters read), asking if sickle cell trait could account for the differences. He also asked if the pulse oximeters used at the University of Michigan were Masimo pulse oximeters, and wondered if “tissue damage and poor circulation, which afflicts Black people more than any other racial or ethnic group” had affected the pulse oximetry readings. He asked if differences in the percentage of patients in each group with carboxyhemoglobinemia could account for the difference and pointed out that various drugs can cause methemoglobinemia.
Kiani even tried to blame hydroxychloroquine, the anti-malarial drug that was repurposed for COVID-19 and later found not to work:
One of them, hydroxychloroquine, which has been recently used on COVID-19 patients, has been shown to dramatically elevate MetHb in Black patients. MetHb not only causes huge errors in pulse oximetry, including biasing pulse oximetry readings, but also can kill the patient if it’s not detected and treated immediately. Did the Michigan study account for this?
At the end, he became quite indignant:
What these publications did is regretful:
     1.  With very little explanation and underlying data, the Michigan authors sent in their findings.
     2.  The New England Journal of Medicine published their findings seemingly without asking for the kind of data that you’d expect in a scientific journal.
     3.  The Boston Review and the New York Times rushed to give the purported bias in a pulse oximeter a racist narrative.
We need to go back to our meritocracy and not let the acts of some badly behaved people change who we are.
Here’s the thing. Even though Kiani made a few reasonable points about possible confounders, his overall tone was so incredibly defensive and full of attacks on the Michigan authors that it made it hard not to view these points as questionable. Basically, what Kiani did is what so many of my White colleagues do when racial disparities are pointed out to them and it is suggested that they might be indicative of systemic racism; he took the observation as a direct accusation of racism against him to almost a comical extent, including a photo of himself holding a “Black lives matter sign” with the article and bragging about how he and his wife had marched for Black Lives Matter. That’s all very well and good and a credit to him and his wife, but it apparently didn’t prevent him from understanding that systemic racism (or even just a system in which there are racial disparities in health care) can be maintained even if he himself is about as non-racist as a White person can be. It also didn’t help that, rather than responding in a letter to the NEJM, he chose to respond with an editorial in a business journal.
He continued as well, in a press release by Masimo about a study conducted and reported by Dr. Steven J. Barker (Chief Science Officer, Masimo) and Dr. William C. Wilson (Chief Medical Officer, Masimo). It was a retrospective analysis of Masimo laboratory data obtained from Black and White volunteer subjects, in an effort to identify differences in Masimo pulse oximeter accuracy and bias between ethnic groups, and its findings were that there was no difference in accuracy. I was curious, though. Was this study ever published in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature? It turns out that it appears not to have been (at least, if it was, I was unable to find it on PubMed). This makes Kiani’s charge against the University of Michigan researchers publishing their work as a brief report in NEJM rather…incongruous.
How we should respond
I’ll also say right here that I get it. Kiani’s company is clearly his life’s work, and he felt attacked as being racist (or at least unconcerned about it). However, his response was very unhelpful in that, rather than reacting in a manner that took the observations seriously and asked what might account for the differences between his company’s claimed data and the published reports, Kiani became incredibly defensive and went on the attack. Even though these observations weren’t about him personally, Kiani certainly perceived them as being about him and responded accordingly.
As an aging White guy myself, I understand the urge to take criticism of how we do things in medicine as a personal accusation of racism. You know what helped me learn to check that tendency? Being involved with a program at our cancer institute studying racial disparities in cancer care and outcomes, as well as my several year stint on a statewide quality improvement initiative for breast cancer care. There I learned that there are indeed significant disparities in outcomes in breast cancer. For example, age-adjusted breast-cancer mortality is about 40% higher among Black women than among non-Hispanic White women, even though there is a slightly lower incidence of breast cancer among Black women. The potential causes are several, including decreased access to screening, a higher rate of lacking health insurance resulting in delayed or deferred care (particularly adjuvant treatments), and a number of other factors, some possibly hereditary. A discussion of these reasons is beyond the scope of this post, but the disparity exists. In fact, disparities in outcomes exist for a number of cancers.
In reproductive health care, racial disparities are even more stark. For instance, in 2018 Black mothers in Missouri died during pregnancy, or within one year of pregnancy, at four times the rate of White mothers in 2018. Infant mortality rates are higher for Black pregnancies as well, with 82% of pregnancy related deaths in Missouri being potentially preventable. These disparities go beyond just Missouri, with Blacks and American Indian or Alaska Native (AIAN) pregnancies having pregnancy-related mortality rates that are over three and two times higher, respectively, compared to the rate for White women. These disparities are likely to get worse now that judicial alchemy by the Supreme Court is leading to legislative alchemy to ban abortions in huge swaths of the US, particularly given the vagueness of the wording of the exceptions to such bans when the life of the mother is endangered, although this legislative alchemy will endanger healthcare for all pregnant patients.
The list of these sorts of disparities goes on.
Finally, not only can science-based medicine be used to study the causes of such disparities, in some cases, such as that of pulse oximetry, technological fixes are possible:
In an optics lab at Brown University, PhD student Rutendo Jakachira explains how a pulse oximeter works.
“If you insert your finger in this groove, the LED at the top is sending light through your finger,” says Jakachira. The device can then calculate a patient’s oxygenation by figuring out how much of the light was absorbed by hemoglobin in the blood.
“That’s key to the problem being seen in people with dark skin, says Kimani Toussaint, a professor of electrical and computer engineering, biomedical engineering, and mechanical engineering at Brown University. “It’s assuming that the only absorber of the light energy is the hemoglobin.”
But in reality the skin pigmentation also absorbs the light, he says. And for people with darker skin, that can result in a reading from the pulse oximeter that overestimates the amount of oxygen in their blood.
Toussaint stands next to a table full of technology he hopes will solve the problem.
“I wouldn’t even call this a device yet,” he says.
Unlike current pulse oximeters, the not-quite-yet-a-device uses polarized light which isn’t absorbed by skin pigmentation. If it works correctly, Toussaint says they’ll partner with manufacturers to shrink it all down into a device that could be marketed.
And:
At Tufts University, Valencia Koomson is working on tackling this problem using a different approach.
Her device uses the same kind of light as currently available pulse oximeters do, but it includes technology that can measure a person’s skin tone (people with darker skin pigmentation have higher levels of melanin).
“We can send more light if there’s a higher level of melanin present, so that melanin doesn’t become a confounding factor that obscures our results,” says Koomson, who is an associate professor of electrical and computer engineering.
In the end, though, the case of pulse oximetry is just one example of racial disparities in medicine that science-based medicine needs to address. It’s clearly an important one, and the magnitude of the disparity is unclear; it’s also unusual in that a technical fix might greatly mitigate it. Unfortunately, the rest of the disparities in care based on race, socioeconomic status, and more are not as easily addressed.
One thing is for sure. Whatever the solution is to each disparity, if we react to discussions of these disparities as though we are being personally attacked for being racist, it will only slow the process of researching the causes and solutions to them.

Was 2022 the “year of the gaslighter” with respect to COVID-19?
“Gaslighting” is a term that refers to the manipulation of someone in order to lead them to question their own reality and even sanity. Last month, a COVID-19 minimizer and antivaxxer, C. J. Hopkins, declared 2022 the “year of the gaslighter,” revealing yet again that it’s always projection with science denying propagandists. Unfortunately, 2023 looks to hold a lot more of the same in store.
David Gorski on January 2, 2023
Link

So the planet has made yet another circuit around the sun, and the old year has slunk away, to be replaced by the new year of 2023. Traditionally, the end of an old year and the start of a new one have been been the time when people reflect a bit on what occurred during the previous 12 months and considered what could happen during the next, and we at SBM tend to be no different in that respect. Last year at this time, my last post of the year was entitled As 2021 shambles to a close, the misuse of VAERS by antivaxxers continues apace, to be followed two weeks later—I took the Christmas holiday off—by a more general post, Everything old is new again. The depressing thing that I just realized is that I could very easily have simply repurposed both old posts, changing the years and updating some of the examples used, and they would have been perfectly appropriate for this new year too. In fact, as depressing as it sounds, I could just revise and update Everything old is new again every year if I wanted to, and it would remain just as relevant, likely for however long I have left on this earth and long beyond, assuming that someone took up the banner and kept updating it after my demise. But where’s the fun in that? Or the education? Or at least some minor bit of novelty?
“Gaslighting”: A new old narrative from antivaxxers
With that background, what “inspired” me (if you can call it that) to write this post was something I saw on Joe Mercola’s website on New Years’ Eve as I was contemplating potential topics for today’s post. It was an article entitled The Year of the Gaslighter, a reprint of a post by someone named C. J. Hopkins published a couple of weeks earlier on his own website, Consent Factory, Inc., under the same title. I’ll link to that version here, because Mercola’s links die after 48 hours, so that he can more easily monetize them on his Substack and also because it turns out that Hopkins published another related article in October, The Gaslighting of the Masses.

If you’re unfamiliar with what “gaslighting” is, it’s a term that was coined based on the title of the 1944 American film Gaslight, which was based on the 1938 British theatre play Gas Light by Patrick Hamilton, although the term didn’t become widely used to describe the phenomenon to which Hopkins refers in his article until the last decade or so. Indeed, “gaslighting” was named the 2022 Word of the Year by Merriam-Webster based on its skyrocketing usage. Unfortunately, a significant fraction of that usage appears to have come from those opposed to public health, if my reading of conspiracy websites and social media content is any indication.
In the film, the husband, played by Charles Boyer, emotionally manipulates his wife (played by Ingrid Bergman) to make her doubt her own grasp of reality and even sanity, so that he could steal from her. In the film, the husband isolates his wife and uses various trickery and emotionally abusive techniques to make her question reality. The title of the film refers to one example of the husband’s deception, gaslight illumination of the couple’s house that seems to dim and flicker whenever the husband leaves his wife alone at home. When she asks him, “Why do the lights keep flickering?” he responds that he doesn’t know what she’s talking about and insists that the lights are not flickering, that it’s just her imagination. Although the term “gaslighting” was little used before the 21st century, since its wider adoption in more recent years its meaning has broadened beyond emotional abuse designed to make a person question her memory and reality. It now also refers to the use of misinformation propaganda to produce a false picture of the past in order to manipulate a population. Just look at how Merriam-Webster described it:
But in recent years, we have seen the meaning of gaslighting refer also to something simpler and broader: “the act or practice of grossly misleading someone, especially for a personal advantage.” In this use, the word is at home with other terms relating to modern forms of deception and manipulation, such as fake news, deepfake, and artificial intelligence.
The idea of a deliberate conspiracy to mislead has made gaslighting useful in describing lies that are part of a larger plan. Unlike lying, which tends to be between individuals, and fraud, which tends to involve organizations, gaslighting applies in both personal and political contexts. It’s at home in formal and technical writing as well as in colloquial use…
It is clearly the broader meaning to which Hopkins refers, citing these definitions in his October post on the subject:
One of the most basic and effective techniques that cults, totalitarian systems, and individuals with fascistic personalities use to disorient and control people’s minds is “gaslighting.” You’re probably familiar with the term. If not, here are a few definitions:
“the manipulation of another person into doubting their perceptions, experiences, or understanding of events.” American Psychological Association
“an insidious form of manipulation and psychological control. Victims of gaslighting are deliberately and systematically fed false information that leads them to question what they know to be true, often about themselves. They may end up doubting their memory, their perception, and even their sanity.” Psychology Today
“a form of psychological manipulation in which the abuser attempts to sow self-doubt and confusion in their victim’s mind. Typically, gaslighters are seeking to gain power and control over the other person, by distorting reality and forcing them to question their own judgment and intuition.” Newport Institute
The main goal of gaslighting is to confuse, coerce, and emotionally manipulate your victim into abandoning their own perception of reality and accepting whatever new “reality” you impose on them. Ultimately, you want to completely destroy their ability to trust their own perception, emotions, reasoning, and memory of historical events, and render them utterly dependent on you to tell them what is real and what “really” happened, and so on, and how they should be feeling about it.
While Hopkins is (mostly) correct about the definition of gaslighting, his use of the term demonstrates how, with conspiracy theorists, it’s all about projection, accusing your critics of what you (and/or your allies) are in fact doing.
“Gaslighting” has, of course, become a favorite go-to word among antivaxxers and COVID-19 minimizers, as well. Just a search of the website of that premier astroturf COVID-19 minimizing “think tank,” the Brownstone Institute, for the term “gaslighting” brings up over 20 articles, like this one from October, claiming that we are being “gaslighted” by governments about “lockdowns,” which are described as far more draconian than they in fact were. A search of my favorite antivax and quackery conspiracy site, Natural News, produced a number of post-2019 uses of the word (and a fair number from before), from everything from COVID-19, vaccines, lockdowns, and even the conspiracy theory that the 2020 election was “stolen.” There are even a couple of articles that very much resemble Hopkins’ articles, such as Gaslighting: How leftist psychopaths demonize and demoralize their opposition and The gaslighting of the American mind, both another excellent example of projection. Unsurprisingly, Mercola features a number of articles using the word as well. Indeed, just yesterday COVID-19 minimizer and antivaxxer Dr. Peter McCullough, known for having declared COVID-19 vaccines a “holocaust” and tool of “depopulation” a year and a half ago,” happily noticed that Merriam-Webster had named “gaslighting” its 2022 Word of the Year.
Knowing that the claim that “they” are trying to “gaslight” you was a major staple of 2022 messaging from COVID-19 minimizers, antimaskers, “lockdown” opponents, and antivaxxers, let’s look at the use of “gaslighting” by COVID-19 misinformation spreaders. Again, it’s all about projection.
Projection, thy name is…antivaxxers
After posting some definitions of “gaslighting,” Hopkins went all-in down the conspiracy narrative about COVID-19 in his October post:
Since the Spring of 2020, we have been subjected to official gaslighting on an unprecedented scale. In a sense, the “Apocalyptic Pandemic” PSYOP has been one big extended gaslighting campaign (comprising countless individual instances of gaslighting) inflicted on the masses throughout the world. The events of this past week were just another example.
Basically, what happened was, a Pfizer executive confirmed to the European Parliament last Monday that Pfizer did not know whether its Covid “vaccine” prevented transmission of the virus before it was promoted as doing exactly that and forced on the masses in December of 2020. People saw the video of the executive admitting this, or heard about it, and got upset. They tweeted and Facebooked and posted videos of Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla, Bill Gates, the Director of the CDC, official propagandists like Rachel Maddow, and various other “experts” and “authorities” blatantly lying to the public, promising people that getting “vaccinated” would “prevent transmission,” “protect other people from infection,” “stop the virus in its tracks,” and so on, which totally baseless assertions (i.e., lies) were the justification for the systematic segregation and persecution of “the Unvaccinated,” and the fomenting of mass fanatical hatred of anyone challenging the official “vaccine” narrative, and the official New Normal ideology, which hatred persists to this very day.
The New Normal propaganda apparatus (i.e., the corporate media, health “experts,” et al.) responded to the story predictably. They ignored it, hoping it would just go away. When it didn’t, they rolled out the “fact-checkers” (i.e., gaslighters).
This accusation of gaslighting is, in itself, gaslighting, and the accusation that fact checkers are gaslighters is the sort of projection that I’m talking about. If you don’t believe me, remember that antivaxxers have been trotting out the claim that the Pfizer randomized clinical trial (RCT) of its vaccine carried out in 2020 didn’t show that the vaccine prevented transmission, even though it was clearly stated that such was not the purpose of the trial. Rather, the goal of the trial was to demonstrate that the vaccine decreased severe disease and death. It’s not a coincidence that Hopkins’ first post was published in October, as it was in October that the undead claim that the Pfizer RCT didn’t show that the vaccine prevented transmission was exhumed from its grave to argue that the vaccine doesn’t prevent transmission at all. I wrote about it around the same time Hopkins published his article.
I also summarized a series of studies that demonstrate that the mRNA vaccines do indeed prevent transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, but that they were less effective at preventing transmission of the Delta and Omicron variants. I also pointed out that good evidence exists that mRNA-based vaccines against COVID-19 can prevent transmission among children and even in high-risk situations, such as among the residents of nursing homes and long-term care facilities. Additional evidence suggests that the VET fell for the Delta variants. For Omicron variants, particularly the BA.4 and BA.5 variants, there is less evidence published given that the variant took off a year ago and it takes many months to do these kind of epidemiological studies, but there is still a growing body of evidence (for example, this) that Omicron variants can evade prior immune responses from vaccines and from infection with previous SARS-CoV-2 variants, but that does not mean that the vaccines “don’t prevent transmission,” but rather that they still do prevent transmission, just not nearly as effectively as they did for the original strain against which they were designed to protect.
That’s just one example. In fact, that disinformation gaslighting began almost immediately in 2020 and continues to this day. Our very own Dr. Jonathan Howard, who was at the epicenter of one of the first and largest early US COVID-19 outbreaks in New York City wrote it, asking: Was New York’s Spring 2020 COVID Wave an Illusion? His article was in response to an article published by Brownstone Institute flack Dr. Jessica Hockett, an educational psychologist, falsely claiming that “New York City’s hospital emergency departments were not at a breaking point in spring 2020. In fact, they were relatively empty and saw a 50% drop in visits.” She used “five observations” to mislead her audience to believe her claim, all ably refuted by Dr. Howard in his article and by Dr. Eric Burnett, an internist at Columbia University, in an epic Twitter thread.
I’ll just cite two of Dr. Burnett’s refutations in order to give you a taste of Dr. Hockett’s gaslighting:
She backs this claim up by saying “Only 3% of the people who came to New York City hospital EDs during the spring 2020 March” this is because we had little to no testing in March of 2020! The testing we did have was reserved for people who traveled from mainland China.
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) November 5, 2022
saying our EDs weren’t overrun bc you didn’t see a lot of lab confirmed C19 at that time is ridiculous. on a personal note, we lost an ED physician to suicide bc of the sheer amount of devastation she bore witness to. it’s extremely disrespectful to suggest a this
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) November 5, 2022
You might remember that this is very similar to the gaslighting that occurred almost as soon as the virus hit and hospitals canceled non-emergency procedures and went on emergency pandemic footing. COVID-19 minimizers claimed that hospitals were “empty” because they had discharged every patient who could be discharged and were dealing primarily with COVID-19 patients. You might even remember some influencers wandering through hospitals and emergency rooms taking smartphone videos to falsely give a picture of “empty” emergency rooms and hospitals.
Here’s another example in the same vein:
We had to convert a football field into a patient ward. We needed to expand hospital capacity in the state by 50% to accommodate admissions. Our traditional hospitalist census is around 100-110 patients, that ballooned to 250 during the worst of the surge. save me this excuse.
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) November 5, 2022
That’s because our hospitals were over capacity and we couldn’t admit every single person with resp symptoms. It’s called triage, you should look it up. Only the sickest covid patients were admitted to the hospital.
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) November 5, 2022
Seriously, this reminds me of the whole “died with COVID not of COVID” lie.
You get the idea. Dr. Hockett’s article was pure gaslighting, even as she accused “them” (e.g., the government and public health officials of “gaslighting”). There are more examples than I can list.
“The year of the gaslighter”
None of the clear projection that I document above stops Hopkins from starting his most recent article off thusly (excuse the profanity, as I’m directly quoting):
Well, it has been quite a year, 2022. I’m officially dubbing it “The Year of the Gaslighter.” I was going to dub it “The Year of the Mother of All Mindfucking Global-Capitalist Gaslighters,” but that seemed like a mouthful, so I’m opting for brevity.
Seriously, if there were an Olympics of Gaslighting, GloboCap (i.e., the global corporatocracy) would take the gold in every event. At this point, the majority of the global masses have been successfully gaslighted into a semi-conscious, quasi-cyclothymic state in which they oscillate, on a moment-by-moment basis, between robotic obedience and impotent rage,” you know, the people “walking around in their masks and prophylactic face shields and injecting themselves with experimental “vaccines” for reasons they no longer even pretend to be able to articulate without gibbering like imbeciles are genuflecting at the feet of an oligarch huckster who they believe has come to deliver them from Wokeness.” Those who are not still walking around in their masks and prophylactic face shields and injecting themselves with experimental “vaccines” for reasons they no longer even pretend to be able to articulate without gibbering like imbeciles are genuflecting at the feet of an oligarch huckster who they believe has come to deliver them from Wokeness.
If you were GloboCap, and in the process of imposing your new official ideology on the entire planet in a kind of global Gleichschaltung op, and otherwise establishing your “New Normal Reich,” and you needed the masses confused and compliant, you couldn’t ask for much more from your Gaslighting Division!
That bit about being “delivered from ‘Wokeness'” is clearly referring to Elon Musk, whom Hopkins dubs the Emperor Elonicus and who is apparently is insufficiently skeptical to Hopkins, even though he’s basically dismantled Twitter’s efforts to combat COVID-19 misinformation and let the worst antivaxxers and COVID-19 disinformation peddlers back on the platform.)
Does any of this sound familiar? It’s exactly the sort of language that Mike Adams likes to use to describe those who accept science-based narratives and treatments in medicine. It’s a profoundly flattering idea to conspiracy theorists, as it portrays them as far more aware, intelligent, and clever than all the “masses” in a “a semi-conscious, quasi-cyclothymic state in which they oscillate, on a moment-by-moment basis, between robotic obedience and impotent rage.” They are not sheeple. They are the ones who have the hidden knowlege. You can have that hidden knowledge and become like them if you just listen to their conspiracy narratives about Gleichschaltung, a favorite term invoked by a number of Godwin-loving conspiracy theorists in which they compare to what the Nazis did under their policy of Gleichschaltung, which means “coordination” or “synchronization.” Under Gleichschaltung, German political, social, and cultural life were rearranged to serve Nazi goals. Put simply, it’s the German term that Adolf Hitler and the Nazis used to refer to the Nazification of German society following Hitler’s becoming Chancellor in January 1933. (Conspiracy theorists do love their Godwins, like this and, of course, “Nuremberg 2.0.”)
Which brings us to the projection:
The gaslighting got underway in January, when the corporate media, health authorities, and other major organs of the New Normal Reich started suddenly “discovering” that the official Covid narrative was “inaccurate,” or, you know, a bunch of lies.
A series of limited hangouts ensued.
Suddenly, it appeared that the “Covid case” and “Covid death” statistics were inaccurate, or inflated, or had been fabricated. The “vaccines” didn’t work. They were killing people. Lockdowns had been a “serious mistake.” And so on. Duplicitous politicians, pusillanimous public-health authorities, perfidious pundits, and assorted other professional sycophants and lying weasels were shocked to discover they had inadvertently been part of the most insidious PSYOP that had ever been perpetrated on the masses in the history of insidious mass-PSYOPs.
The Last Days of the Covidian Cult were upon us! The Corporatocracy had overplayed their hand, and underestimated their opposition, and they knew it.
It’s worth noting the sort of “evidence” that the gaslighter C. J. Hopkins uses to accuse “Them” of gaslighting. The claim that COVID statistics had been accurate, inflated, or fabricated links to a video of a January 2022 interview at CNN between Jake Tapper and CNN medical correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta in which it was stated that 40% of patients in hospitals diagnosed with COVID-19 had been admitted for something else and didn’t have serious illness from COVID-19. I have to be honest here. both came across as pretty clueless, not understanding how diagnoses are not always straightforward, as was pointed out by a number of people on Twitter:
Not always easy to separate the incidental from those that aren’t. https://t.co/KHKM2kacx4
— Will Grad (@postgradw) January 10, 2022
And:
Treated an older man last wk who fell at home hitting his head. Found to have a temp of 39. CT-subdural. Died a few hrs later. Turned out to be COVID +. Was this “incidental” or more likely did the illness facilitate his fall? Cause of death on death certificate was the subdural.
— Will Grad (@postgradw) January 1, 2022
Again, using ambiguity in diagnoses to claim that COVID-19 case counts are overcounted is a gaslighting tactic. So is a New York Times article from December 2021 that about studies suggesting that most vaccines in existence the time would not do a good job preventing infection with Omicron variants but still offer significant protection against severe illness and that mRNA vaccines did offer some protection against infection but noting that “what you lose first is protection against asymptomatic mild infection, what you retain much better is protection against severe disease and death” and:
People with breakthrough cases may experience only asymptomatic infection or mild illness, but they can pass the virus to unvaccinated people, who could fall more severely ill, and become a source of new variants.
That’s actually what we saw in 2022, not that the “vaccines didn’t work.” Hopkins is gaslighting by omitting important context, which he continued to do. For example, the link to the claim that vaccines are killing people was a single anecdotal report of a British presenter who died of a blood clot after the AstraZeneca vaccine, a rare association primarily observed in women that was detected for this vaccine very early and led to its temporary withdrawal from use, as we discussed in April 2021, while also noting that the benefits of vaccination still outweighed the risks. Similarly, his link to the claim that “lockdowns were a mistake” is to an article describing an interview with David Frost, who did indeed express the opinion that lockdowns had been a “serious mistake.” I can only respond to this with a bit of sarcasm about how I always prefer to get my public health takes from a politician than from actual public health scientists, while noting that I’m old enough to have briefly done a double take, remembering another David Frost (now deceased) who wasn’t a political hack but rather a storied British television host and journalist.
Then, of course, Hopkins engages in that favorite of favorite crank gaslighting tactic, portraying science as religion, preferably a cult, even using a favorite COVID-19 minimizer/denier term, the “Covidian cult,” a term used by Brownstone Institute “scientific advisor” Martin Kulldorff himself and by Jay Bhattacharya and him when they likened Anthony Fauci and public health officials to a “covidian high priesthood.”
I could go on and on citing example after example of COVID-19 misinformation and disinformation peddlers like Hopkins and various Brownstone flacks accusing governments, the medical establishment, and public health organizations of “gaslighting” about the pandemic, but will spare you. It’s pure projection.
The title of my post was phrased in the form of the question, which might lead one to wonder whether Betteridge’s Law of Headlines applies. The answer is both yes and no beause the answer to the question is both yes and no. Yes, 2022 was indeed the “year of the gaslighter” with respect to COVID-19 (although, unfortunately, so were 2021 and 2020). However, the answer is simultaneously “no” in that these years weren’t the “years of the gaslighter” in the way that propagandists claiming to be satirists (like C.J. Hopkins) claim that 2022 was. Rather, 2020-2022 were the “years of the gaslighter” with respect to the pandemic because disinformation peddlers like Hopkins made them so—resoundingly and increasingly so as the years rolled on. Sadly, 2023 doesn’t look as though it will be any different. The gaslighting is worse than ever and looks as though it will only grow in intensity and quantity.

The State of Florida spreads antivaccine disinformation disguised as an epidemiological “study”
On Friday, Florida State Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo released a non-peer-reviewed “study” that recommends against males aged 18 to 39 receiving mRNA COVID-19 vaccines based on bad epidemiology and science. This is the first time that we’ve seen a state government weaponize bad science to spread antivaccine disinformation as official policy, a dangerous new escalation in antivaccine propaganda.
David Gorski on October 10, 2022
Link

We here at Science-Based Medicine (SBM) have been combatting antivaccine misinformation and disinformation for nearly 15 years. In our early days—and even our not-so-early days—such pseudoscientific misinformation was disseminated primarily by antivax quacks and the people who believed them. Think Andrew Wakefield, Robert “Dr. Bob” Sears, Paul Thomas, Sherri Tenpenny, Kelly Brogan, and the like, as well as propagandists like Del Bigtree, Mike Adams, and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Unsurprisingly, when the COVID-19 pandemic hit, it didn’t take long for these antivax propagandists to pivot first to COVID-19 minimization and then, when COVID-19 vaccines were introduced, to repurposing old antivax tropes to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about the new COVID vaccines. They were also soon joined by a new generation of antivax physicians and propagandists, as evidenced by the rise of the hydroxychloroquine-promoting America’s Frontline Doctors in 2020 during the first summer of the pandemic. Among that group of disinformation-peddling (now grifting) physicians was a man named Dr. Joseph Ladapo.
Unfortunately for the people of Florida—and, to a somewhat lesser extent, the people of the US in general—about a year ago Dr. Ladapo and his rejection of public health interventions such as masking and vaccines caught the eye of Florida’s COVID-19 minimizing and antivax Governor Ron DeSantis, who appointed him as Florida’s Surgeon General, the official in charge of the Florida Department of Health, in essence the entire medical and public health bureaucracy of the state. Unsurprisingly, Dr. Ladapo immediately started doing Gov. DeSantis’ bidding with respect to the pandemic—it is, after all, what he was hired to do—and promoting the message of “rejecting fear” as a public health strategy, while implementing the Great Barrington Declaration-like policies preferred by Gov. DeSantis that basically stopped trying to slow or mitigate the spread of COVID-19 and let children be infected in schools, even hosting a widely publicized “Urgency of Normal” roundtable with Gov. DeSantis and outright antivaxxers like Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, to promote “don’t worry, be happy” COVID-19 minimizing and denying policies. Mainstream public health officials like Dr. Ashish Jha, have noted:
Equally troubling for his critics was Dr. Ladapo’s failure to reject more fringe views on virus treatments, including the drugs hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin. He joined Mr. DeSantis in clamoring for the federal government to supply some monoclonal antibody treatments even after they had been deemed ineffective against the Omicron variant, which dominated caseloads.
“To say he’s out of the mainstream would be an understatement,” said Dr. Ashish K. Jha, dean of the Brown University School of Public Health. “His views are not only very unorthodox — they don’t make any sense.”
Indeed they don’t, so much so that one of his supervisors at UCLA stated in an evaluation requested by the Florida Senate as part of a background check that Ladapo’s hands-off approach toward managing COVID-19 made his colleagues feel uncomfortable, with the responses to questions asked on the evaluation being—shall we say?—less than glowing:
Question: “Would you recommend the applicant for employment as a surgeon general of Florida and confidence in his ability, honesty and integrity to perform related duties?” Answer: “No. In my opinion the people of Florida would be better served by a surgeon general who grounds his policy decisions and recommendations in the best scientific evidence rather than opinions.”
Then, there was a vague prompt called “personal relations (rapport with co-workers, supervisor).” The complete response: “I cannot answer… because Dr. Ladapo’s opinions, published in a number of popular media outlets, were contrary to the best scientific evidence available about the Covid-19 pandemic and caused concern among a large number of his research and clinical colleagues and subordinates who felt that his opinions violated the Hippocratic Oath that physicians do no harm. This situation created stress and acrimony among his co-workers and supervisors during the last year and a half of his employment. It is important to note that during this time at UCLA, he met all of the contractual obligations for the position that he was hired to perform, which is the underpinning of my otherwise satisfactory evaluation.”
That last bit was certainly the proverbial damning with faint praise. However, I fear that that evaluation actually made Dr. Ladapo more attractive to Gov. DeSantis and the Florida Senate. Be that as it may, unfortunately, when you hire an antivaxxer—and, yes, it’s no longer debatable to me that Dr. Ladapo has become an antivaxxer—to be in charge of your state’s public health policy, bad things happen, bad things like a study being weaponized as antivax disinformation. That’s exactly why Gov. DeSantis wanted Dr. Ladapo, to cover his predetermined policy choices with a veneer of seemingly plausible science, all to justify this conclusion:
The State Surgeon General now recommends against the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines for males ages 18-39 years old.
Individuals and health care providers should also be aware that this analysis1 found:
    • Males over the age of 60 had a 10% increased risk of cardiac-related death within 28 days of mRNA vaccination.
    • Non-mRNA vaccines were not found to have these increased risks among any population.
Floridians are encouraged to discuss all the potential benefits and risks of receiving mRNA COVID-19 vaccines with their health care provider. The risk associated with mRNA vaccination should be weighed against the risk associated with COVID-19 infection.The Department continues to stand by its Guidance for Pediatric COVID-19 Vaccines issued March 2022, which recommends against use in healthy children and adolescents 5 years old to 17 years old. This now includes recommendations against COVID-19 vaccination among infants and children under 5 years old, which has since been issued under Emergency Use Authorization.
Notice how the part about non-mRNA-based vaccines not showing this supposed effect is glossed over. If the intent of this press release and “guidance” were anything other than antivax, then you’d see a section about how all adults should be vaccinated against COVID-19 but with the caveat that young men aged 18-39 should receive vaccines that aren’t based on mRNA technology. Funny, but I didn’t see that anywhere. Maybe I missed something?
As you will see, this study doesn’t even show that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are more risky than getting COVID-19.
Dr. Ladapo issues a press release
This brings us to something I had never seen before, a state warning people not to get vaccinated based on a poor quality study that was clearly willfully misinterpreted. On Friday, Florida issued an official press release that portrayed a vaccine as more dangerous than the disease, at least for some people, State Surgeon General Dr. Joseph A. Ladapo Issues New Mrna COVID-19 Vaccine Guidance:
Today, State Surgeon General Dr. Joseph A. Ladapo has announced new guidance regarding mRNA vaccines. The Florida Department of Health (Department) conducted an analysis through a self-controlled case series, which is a technique originally developed to evaluate vaccine safety.
This analysis found that there is an 84% increase in the relative incidence of cardiac-related death among males 18-39 years old within 28 days following mRNA vaccination. With a high level of global immunity to COVID-19, the benefit of vaccination is likely outweighed by this abnormally high risk of cardiac-related death among men in this age group. Non-mRNA vaccines were not found to have these increased risks.
As such, the State Surgeon General recommends against males aged 18 to 39 from receiving mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. Those with preexisting cardiac conditions, such as myocarditis and pericarditis, should take particular caution when making this decision.
“Studying the safety and efficacy of any medications, including vaccines, is an important component of public health,” said Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo. “Far less attention has been paid to safety and the concerns of many individuals have been dismissed – these are important findings that should be communicated to Floridians.”
The analysis can be found here. The guidance can be found here.
Let’s dig in. I will start with the study, which doesn’t really show what Dr. Ladapo claims it shows, and then move on to the guidance, which clearly willfully extrapolates far beyond what this nothingburger of a study can even be claimed to show. Finally, we’ll see how news sources and antivaccine media have amplified this “study” so that its repercussions go far beyond the State of Florida.
A bad, bad study
Before I take on the study, I have to wonder what the authors of the BMJ commentary about self-controlled case series cited by Dr. Ladapo (Irene Petersen, Ian Douglas, and Heather Whitaker), feel about the antivaxxers running Florida’s public health bureaucracy co-opting their work to spin COVID-19 vaccines as more dangerous than the disease for men under 40, and after I discuss the study itself I’ll get to how their commentary actually includes points that show major flaws in Dr. Ladapo’s “study”.
As for the study itself, it’s a really odd beast in several ways. First, no authors are listed. In a way, I can sort of understand that. If I were forced by my boss to produce a study like this one, I wouldn’t want my name associated with it either. More importantly, this study was not peer-reviewed. Rather, it was just published by the Florida Department of Health on its COVID-19 website. I mean, I could publish a “study” here on SBM or my not-so-secret other blog and claim it’s a good study. No one would believe me just based on my word—nor should anyone. To be honest, for me to take this as a serious effort, other than antivax propaganda designed to come to a predetermined conclusion, I would have at least liked to see an authors’ list and a statement that this study had been submitted to a peer-reviewed journal for consideration of publication. Unsurprisingly, I saw neither thing.
But enough of my editorializing. Let’s get to the study and—I hope—my ample justification for my opinions of the study. Its stated objective is “To evaluate the risks of all-cause and cardiac-related mortality following COVID-19 vaccination”. Its methods were stated thusly:
The self-controlled case series (SCCS) method adapted to evaluate death as the outcome was used.1,2 The SCCS method, originally developed to assess vaccine safety, utilizes within-person comparisons to estimate the temporal association between a transient exposure and an acute event.1 The SCCS method estimates relative incidence (RI) by comparing incidence during a defined high-risk period following exposure with incidence during a control period (i.e., all time in the follow-up period that is not the risk period).1–4 A major strength of the SCCS method is that fixed-time confounders, such as health related risk-factors, are controlled for.1,3
The primary analysis utilized the SCCS method developed for single exposures that cannot be repeated.1,3,4 Since mRNA vaccinations require a multidose schedule, a simple modification was employed, where the last vaccination preceding death was used as the single exposure.2 In this method, the within-individual comparison is between the immediate post-exposure period and later post-exposure periods.3
Now here’s the key part, where the rubber hits the road and the deficiencies of this methodology become apparent. Note that the study was concluded on June 1, 2022:
For the primary analysis, Florida residents aged 18 years or older who died within 25-weeks of COVID-19 vaccination since the start of the vaccination roll-out (December 15, 2020) were included.
Individuals were excluded if they (1) had a documented COVID-19 infection, (2) experienced a COVID-19 associated death, (3) received a booster, or (4) received their last COVID-19 vaccination after December 8, 2021 (to ensure each individual had the 25-week follow-up period to experience the event of interest).
I found it rather interesting that the study specifically excluded residents who experienced COVID-19 infection or death. Why, one wonders, might that be? (One wonders.) After all, death from COVID-19 is the very outcome that the vaccines were intended to prevent, and excluding them from the analysis is a rather telling sign. At the very least, if you truly wanted to compare outcomes, it would have been more appropriate to do the analysis both including and excluding COVID-19-related outcomes, in order to compare death rates among those who did and did not get COVID-19 among the vaccinated and unvaccinated. Again, I wonder why the authors didn’t do that. Actually, I’m pretty sure that I know.
I think I also know why the primary outcomes were chosen this way:
The exposure of interest was the 28-day risk period following COVID-19 vaccination.
Two outcomes were assessed. Natural all-cause deaths (i.e., excluding homicides, suicides, and accidents) and cardiac-related deaths. Cardiac-related deaths were included if their death record contained an ICD-10 code of I30-I52. For the primary analysis, only participants that experienced the exposure and outcome were included in this study.
The range of ICD codes listed above are cardiac-related, with ICD30 being pericarditis and I52 being “other heart disorders in diseases classified elsewhere.” You can look at the whole list here if you wish. It includes endocarditis, valve disorders, myocarditis, cardiomyopathy, cardiac arrest, conduction system disorders, atrial fibrillation and flutter, heart failure, other cardiac arrhythmias, endocarditis, and more. Interestingly, they left out ICD code I5A, which is non-ischemic myocardial injury (nontraumatic). I had to wonder why, given that, if you believe that COVID-19 vaccines are causing an epidemic of cardiac death (as Dr. Ladapo clearly does and had this study designed to “show”), then I’d think that such deaths might pop up under this category. Be that as it may, the authors included pretty much every cardiac diagnosis, even ones that aren’t really suspected to be related to COVID-19 vaccines. Remember, there is evidence that the mRNA-based vaccines can be associated with an increased risk of myocarditis. You can even posit possible associations in which the vaccines might be associated with arrhythmias. However, it’s a real stretch to associate them with mitral, tricuspid, or any valve disease.
As I discovered after I had written this section, Dr. Kristen Panthagani pointed it out better in that she included a chart:
A couple things to note about this methodology:1. ICD-10 codes are not necessarily accurate or specific. 2. There isn't a clear rationale why they included these specific ICD-10 codes vs other cardiac-related codes (i.e. ischemic heart disease is not included?) pic.twitter.com/YqkOKioexX
— Kristen Panthagani, MD, PhD (@kmpanthagani) October 9, 2022
In particular, her point here is most appreciated:
In short, this list is too broad to be meaningful, excludes some cardiac issues but not others, and most of the diagnoses are far more likely to be caused by other ongoing disease processes rather than vaccination.
— Kristen Panthagani, MD, PhD (@kmpanthagani) October 9, 2022
Exactly. The authors included basically a wastebasket set of cardiac diagnoses in their analysis, including ones without a plausible biologic link to vaccination (e.g., valvular disease) and ones that are often included in death certificates as the final cause of death, given that the terminal event in anyone dying is, ultimately, the heart stopping its beating.
Moving on, I appreciate Dr. Deepti Gurdasani’s discussion of the study on Twitter, where she was kind enough to provide a diagram at the top of her thread discussing its key flaws:
I've tried to capture many of the key flaws visually in the FL study (non-peer reviewed & anonymous authors!) being shared by their surgeon general- rampantly in a single figure. Please do share and tag if you see someone citing it & report @FLSurgeonGen tweet as misinformation. pic.twitter.com/zVPGjWqamd
— Dr. Deepti Gurdasani (@dgurdasani1) October 9, 2022
I appreciate the chart, as it conveys the information in a more compact form than I could have in my writeup, and not just because of my tendency towards logorrhea.
Follow-up began on the day of their last COVID-19 vaccination. Participants were not censored upon death, rather, they were followed for the entire 25-week follow-up period.1–4
Or, as Dr. Gurdasani put it, first mentioning what I mentioned above, the issue of why the authors excluded the very cause of death that the vaccines were designed to prevent:
But they don't make this clear at all when they discuss the results- they refer to deaths as 'all causes' of natural death. But excluding the major cause of death that vaccines prevent? Even so, the study still finds a reduction in 'all cause death' post-vaccine!!
— Dr. Deepti Gurdasani (@dgurdasani1) October 9, 2022
Indeed, I find the wording of some of the findings particularly…bizarre:
In the 28 days following vaccination, no increase in risk was observed for all-cause deaths. A statistically significant decrease was observed for participants 60 years or older in the 28 days following vaccination (RI = 0.97, 95% CI = 0.94 – 0.99).
Why not just start out by saying that there was a statistically significant decrease in 28-day mortality among those aged 60 and older? The answer is rather obvious. The authors almost certainly wished to deemphasize that finding by stating it after another finding that found no benefit in “all-cause mortality” (which wasn’t really “all-cause” mortality given that it didn’t include COVID-19 as one of the causes) from vaccination against COVID-19.
The authors also admit a huge limitation in their discussion:
This study cannot determine the causative nature of a participant’s death. We used death certificate data and not medical records. COVID testing status was unknown for those who did not die of/with COVID. Cardiac-related deaths were ascertained if an ACME code of I3-I52 were on their death certificate, thus, the underlying cause of death may not be cardiac-related.
In other words, even the anonymous authors themselves couldn’t say for sure whether all their “cardiac” deaths were, in fact, cardiac deaths.
The authors also (sort of) acknowledge Dr. Gurdasani’s criticism when they write:
While this method has been used to assess risk of death following COVID-19 vaccination,2 it violates the assumption that an event does not affect subsequent exposure (for mRNA vaccines), which may introduce bias.6 Further, it does not consider the multidose vaccination schedule required for mRNA vaccination.
In fairness, not everyone was so harsh on the study design as I (and the doctors whom I cited above) have been. For example, Prof. Jeffrey Morris essentially agrees with the criticism that not censoring deaths that occur in the first 28-day period from consideration in the second reporting period violates the assumptions underlying the SCCS methodology, while conceding that the design “could” appropriately adjust for this bias:
I've looked more into their report/references on SCCS for death events.The methods description is quite terse, but (1) starting follow up at time of last vaccine dose and (2) comparing death rates in the first 28d post-dose to 28d-25wk could appropriately adjust for this bias…
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) October 8, 2022
He also cited another study that used a similar methodology carried out in the UK and published as a preprint in March that looked at the risk of death and cardiac-related death over 12 weeks among individuals aged 12-29. The preprint found:
    • No evidence of an association between COVID-19 vaccination and an increased risk of death in young people;
    • That SARS-CoV-2 infection was associated with substantially higher risk of cardiac-related and all-cause death.
One also notes the differences in the design of the UK study compared to the Florida “study”. First, the UK study did not exclude COVID-19 and found a six-fold increased risk of cardiac death within six weeks of infection with SARS-CoV-2, leading the authors to conclude:
Although there is a risk of myocarditis or myopericarditis with COVID-19, there is no evidence of increased risk of cardiac or all-cause mortality following COVID-19 vaccination in young people aged 12 to 29. Given the increased risk of mortality following SARS-CoV-2 infection in this group, the risk-benefit analysis favours COVID-19 vaccination for this age group.
And:
Whilst COVID-19 vaccination has been linked to an increased risk of myocarditis and other cardiac events in young people, our study shows that there is no evidence of increased risk of death due to cardiac events, which suggest that cases of myocarditis or myopericarditis due to the COVID-19 vaccination are unlikely to be fatal. This provides reassurance that the benefits of COVID-19 vaccines outweigh the risks even in young people.
There’s the big problem. The authors of the Florida study could have done such an analysis and then used it to estimate a risk-benefit ratio for vaccination versus the disease; they chose not to. Why didn’t they do that analysis, an analysis that most would consider to be very important? Again, I think you know the answer to that question. Likely such an analysis would have come to the same conclusion as that of the UK investigators, that the overall balance strongly favors COVID-19 vaccination in young people.) However, that is not the message that Dr. Ladapo wanted to convey. In fact, I strongly suspect that they probably did do such an analysis but left it out of the paper. Whatever the case, were I a peer reviewer for this article, I would refuse to endorse publishing this study unless the authors did an analysis that didn’t exclude COVID-19 cases. Failure to have done so provides a deceptive result.
In case you’re wondering how it should be done, Dr. Panthagani provided a reference to a study published in JAMA. In marked contrast to Florida’s “study,” this study looked at specific diagnoses and confirmed them using a review of medical records. The study also showed how to appropriately exclude COVID-19 cases. But wait! Didn’t the Florida authors do that? Yes, but not quite. While it is appropriate to exclude those deaths with COVID-19 listed as a cause on the death certificate, they didn’t bother to look at COVID-19 status:
So they didn't know whether or not people had COVID, unless it was listed on their death certificate.
(As a side note, this sneaky use of language in the methods section is a red flag. I don't like it.)
— Kristen Panthagani, MD, PhD (@kmpanthagani) October 9, 2022
Overall, this means that susceptibility to COVID confounded their analysis, and COVID (not COVID vaccination) very well could have contributed to some of these deaths.
Why?
Recall that after vaccination, it takes a little time for immunity to kick in.
— Kristen Panthagani, MD, PhD (@kmpanthagani) October 9, 2022
Dr. Panthagani also echoes my (and many other critics’) observation that whenever you perform a risk assessment of vaccination, it is very important also to compare the risks of the vaccine versus the risks of the disease vaccinated against. Again, very tellingly, the anonymous authors of this Florida study did not do this. Similarly, they did not do a number of standard sensitivity analyses to test the robustness of their conclusions when changes are made to their assumptions and chosen time periods. I wonder why.
Dr. Ladapo’s interpretation of the study versus a more charitable view of the study
One thing that is also important to note about this study is that, for an epidemiological study of uncommon adverse events from vaccines, the sample size is quite small. Among the age group targeted (aged 18-39) there were a grand total of 20 deaths, which means that if even a tiny number of them were misclassified, the “statistical significance” of the anonymous authors’ result goes away. This brings me to Kyle Sheldrick’s analysis of the study. He’s less harsh on it than Prof. Morris, Drs. Panthagani, Gurdasani, or I have been.
Dr. Sheldrick notes:
STROBE stands for “strengthening the reporting of observational studies in epidemiology” and comes from an “international, collaborative initiative of epidemiologists, methodologists, statisticians, researchers and journal editors involved in the conduct and dissemination of observational studies, with the common aim of STrengthening the Reporting of OBservational studies in Epidemiology”. He’s right, too. If you click on one of the checklists in the link above, it’s easy to see that a lot of elements important in STROBE were not listed.
Dr. Sheldrick takes the study results (mostly) at face value and accepts that perhaps 9 additional cardiac deaths in men aged 18-39 could be attributable to COVID-19 vaccination. That’s why he attacks the spin on this study more than the study itself. I’ll admit that I’m not as convinced as he is to give the benefit of the doubt to these anonymous authors, but I can see the utility in doing so and then showing why their results still don’t justify the recommendation not to vaccinate men under 40.
He does this by making some reasonable (and conservative) assumptions about how much COVID-19 vaccination decreases the death rate from COVID-19 in this particular population:
Disagreeing with Dr. Sheldrake I’m not convinced, based on its methodological flaws, that this study accurately shows that there were nine additional deaths among the 1.8 million men in Florida aged 18-39 who underwent COVID-19 vaccination. After all, it wouldn’t take many misattributed deaths in that group at all to make that apparent increase in cardiac mortality no longer statistically significant, and the lack of any attempt to verify cause of death with medical records or to determine COVID-19 testing status are major potential sources of bias. Still, it is definitely justifiable from a science communication standpoint of Dr. Sheldrake to point out how this study, even if you accept its results as accurate, does not provide any evidence to support Dr. Ladapo’s conclusion that men under age 40 should not receive mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines. Indeed, his conclusion goes along with all the criticism that I cited above and made myself of the anonymous authors for not doing an analysis that included COVID-19 cases and tried to determine a risk-benefit ratio for the vaccine. Again, the anonymous authors didn’t report that. (Note again that I said “didn’t report that,” as I strongly suspect that they probably did do that analysis but that Dr. Ladapo held it back, and, yes, I am suggesting that Dr. Ladapo is less than honest.)
Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz also took the study at face value. He even noted that he didn’t really care what the authors might have left out:
5/n So, main findings. In the 28 days after getting any vaccine:
1. People were less likely of any cause2. People (esp young men) were more likely to die of "cardiac-related" causes3. People were MUCH LESS likely to die of NON "cardiac-related" causes
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) October 9, 2022
He then back-calculated an estimate of non-cardiac mortality:
10/n Now, third point. Given the information for all-cause and cardiac mortality, we can back-calculate the rate of death and number of days at risk for NON-cardiac mortality as well!
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) October 9, 2022
I’m going to disagree a bit here. Even if this was a typo and the true range of ICD codes was I3-I52, that would still include a lot of diagnoses with no biologically plausible link to vaccination. Still:
12/n This effect is even bigger for younger people – for someone aged 18-39, getting a COVID-19 vaccination was associated with a whopping 45% (23-61%) reduction in non-cardiac death! Huge!
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) October 9, 2022
I have to be honest. Meyerowtiz-Katz’s analysis makes it even clearer to me that both this study was deceptively phrased to make it sound as though the COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous, and the press releases even more so. Basically, as Meyerowitz-Katz and Sheldrake show, even if you take this analysis at face value, it does not show what Dr. Ladapo says it shows.
It’s not surprising that the usual suspects are amplifying this “study” as slam-dunk evidence that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous and do more harm than good. I surveyed some of the usual suspects, and here’s just a little of what I found:
    • Steve Kirsch: Florida study shows mRNA COVID vaccines kill kids. (No, it doesn’t. Also,, you might be amused by Mr. Kirsch’s attack on yours truly the other day.)
    • Paul Alexander: Dr. Joe Ladapo, Florida’s Surgeon General (thanks Governor DeSantis), recommends against COVID mRNA vaccine in males 18-39 years, citing increased risk of myocarditis etc. Excellent move!
    • The Daily Sceptic (a denialist website): Florida Recommends Against mRNA Vaccination for Males Aged 18-39 Due to 84% Increase in Heart Death Risk
I could go on, but Twitter is worse, as you can demonstrate for yourself by just typing the URL for the Florida press release into its search box.
Unfortunately, thanks to Gov. Ron DeSantis, the entire state medical and public health apparatus of Florida has become a tool for spreading his COVID-19 minimizing antivax propaganda, with Dr. Ladapo having eagerly signed on to be his willing accomplice in spreading misinformation. It’s a hell of a thing when an actual state public health apparatus publishes something that’s not just wrong, but intentionally misleading and dangerous, such as this study with anonymous authors. It has succeeded in its purpose, to serve as what seems to lay people like scientific justification for antivaccine messaging.

Is COVID-19 “the forever plague”?
A recent article claims that Omicron reinfections confer “no immunity” such that it’s possible to be reinfected with Omicron variants every two to three weeks and calls COVID-19 the “forever plague”. Although it makes a reasonable point that “natural” postinfection immunity doesn’t last long because of variants, the article is undermines its reasonable criticisms of COVID policy with maximal fear mongering.
David Gorski on July 11, 2022
Link

We here at SBM have been very critical of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) ever since it was first published in October 2020. The GBD, as you might recall, was a document published as a result of a meeting held in Great Barrington, MA at the headquarters of the right-wing libertarian free market think tank American Institute for Economic Research (AIER). The reason that we at SBM have been so critical of the GBD—calling it right from the beginning “magnified minority” and eugenics—is because it advocated a “natural herd immunity” approach to the COVID-19 pandemic; i.e., what we referred to as a “let ‘er rip” approach in which SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, should be allowed to spread through the “low risk” young and “healthy” population, in order to produce “natural immunity” in enough people to reach herd immunity, meanwhile using “focused protection” (never well defined) to shield the elderly and those with chronic health conditions that rendered them susceptible to death and the worst complications of the virus. (Remember, this was a couple of months before the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines received emergency use authorization.) It’s an approach that never would have worked, given the practical difficulties and the observation (predicted even in October 2020) that “natural” post-infection immunity was not likely to be durable, given the rise of immune-evading variants like Omicron. Even with the history of the last two years, GBD adherents still claim that “herd immunity” would be a mere 3-6 months away if we just followed their plan. Worse, GBD authors like Martin Kulldorff and Jay Bhattacharya have pivoted to help spread antivaccine disinformation, along with the “spiritual child” of the GBD, the Brownstone Institute (for which Kulldorff is the scientific advisor), which has apparently never seen a public health intervention that it liked—although it does very much like comparing public health to fascism and Communism.
Which brings us to an article going the opposite direction of Brownstone Institute propaganda that’s gone viral. You’d think that I would approve. You’d think wrong, simply because the article lacks nuance and supports positions to which I’m sympathetic with a maximalist fear mongering argument that ends up proposing a solution to the pandemic that is a fantasy, just the opposite fantasy advocated by the “natural herd immunity” proponents.
Dueling fantasy worlds
The article to which I referred that is going around, while appropriately noting the disastrous consequences of abandoning non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs, such as masks and social distancing) and other tools to slow the spread of COVID-19 too quickly, goes so far in the opposite direction of the GBD that it needs to be called out as well. It was published on July 4 by journalist Andrew Nikiforuk entitled “Get Ready for the Forever Plague” and has the tagline, “Public health officials’ COVID complacency has opened the door to new illnesses and devastating long-term damage”. It also features a suitably ominous image:
There’s nothing like the image of a medieval plague doctor to instill fear and alarm, is there?
In any case, the image chosen for the article tells you much of what you need to know about it. There is zero nuance, and the concept is that, thanks to the Omicron variants, the only strategy to halt the pandemic is something that’s become known as “zero COVID”. I’ll skip to the conclusion first, the better to go back and demonstrate how data and information were—shall we say?—carefully chosen to support a predetermined conclusion. I’m also going to refer to an Archive.org copy of the article from July 4, because on Friday the author responded to some criticisms and edited the article to its current form, which, while less objectionable than the original, is still pretty maximalist in its fear mongering. I also realize that by writing this post I might be perceived as some as being the same side as the cranks at the Brownstone Institute. Nothing can be further from the truth, and to support that, I’ll quote Gavin Yamey, my coauthor on our BMJ article criticizing the GBD, who Tweeted:
Now, before addressing the claim above that each Omicron reinfection confers “no immunity” (which is nonsense) let’s jump to Nikiforuk’s conclusion:
We could have avoided this deteriorating situation, as The Tyee repeatedly advised, by eliminating COVID in our communities more than a year ago.
Elimination remains the only long-term and bottom-up strategy that makes any sense in terms of risk reduction. It is also imminently doable with adequate testing, masking, tracing, supported sick leave and targeted goals for reducing transmission.
But our public health officials gambled with the future and chose a fantasy world instead. Now COVID has become a runaway train with unknown biological consequences.
I’ll give Nikiforuk the last point (I’ve said similar things in the past.) I’ll also give him this point elsewhere in the article:
By abandoning the critical goal of stopping or reducing viral transmission about a year ago, authorities have given viral evolution an incredible edge.
We’ve been saying much the same thing, particularly in our criticisms of the fantasy world inhabited by GBD proponents, in which immunity to COVID-19 is lifelong, “natural herd immunity” is achievable, and it’s relatively easily to implement “focused protection” of the elderly and those with chronic illnesses. We’ve also pointed out that it’s not so much vaccines driving new variants nearly as much allowing a novel virus to circulate mostly unchecked in an immunologically naïve population.
Even so, however, I’d argue that Nikiforuk is also living in a fantasy world, just a different one than the one that he accuses public health officials of inhabiting. Public health officials in much of the world did give up too early, but much of that was based on political pressure as a result of the unholy fusion of conspiracy theorists, the far right, and antivaxxers that political leaders could not resist or that some political leaders harnessed because they, too, viewed public health interventions (particularly mask and vaccine mandates) as unacceptable assaults on “freedom”. Remember, for the elimination of COVID-19 to be even theoretically possible now would require at least the possibility of every nation on earth implementing the suggested NPIs. Given how huge swaths of the US have become totally resistant to anything resembling mask mandates (as just one example), I have a hard time wondering how Nikiforuk’s vision isn’t every bit as much of a fantasy world as that of the GBD authors. I’ll give Nikiforuk credit, though, in emphasizing that the GBD fantasy of “natural herd immunity” is utterly detached from reality; unfortunately he goes too far in the other direction.
The claim that getting to “zero COVID” is “imminently doable” struck me immediately as so out of touch with reality that I was tempted to add one of my usual facepalm images here with a sarcastic caption, as I am wont to do when I come across claims this overblown. It might have been possible—even feasible—to achieve “zero COVID” early in the pandemic with such measures, as well as with massive international cooperation of the like unseen during the pandemic. Theoretically, elimination might even have been possible to achieve even in January 2021, when the linked article was published. However, to achieve it now, after repeated waves of infection and the rise of ever more transmissible and immune-evading variants, would require international cooperation that only happens in fantasy land, and even then that ignores the fact that there is an animal reservoir for these coronaviruses that would make elimination in the human population, if not outright impossible, damned near impossible. It is not “surrender” to admit this, but if the Twitter reactions to the criticisms of this article are any indication that’s exactly the sort of accusation I’ll soon see in the comments, with some people expressing extreme “disappointment” with me or even outright anger. Assuming that happens, I’ll shake my head, given my long history dating back to before COVID-19 was even declared a pandemic of countering claims from COVID-19 contrarians and antivaxxers that COVID-19 isn’t that deadly and explaining why “natural herd immunity”-based strategies were disastrous.
I suspect that I might regret having written this post. It wouldn’t be the first time, even when I’m right. So let’s look at some specifics.
Unsupported and exaggerated claims
In examining the claims made in this article, one has to go straight for its central claim that is used to justify all the other conclusions, namely that Omicron variants have become so transmissible and immune evading that reinfections with them confer “no immunity” to future infections, leading to a horrific scenario:
New science shows that Omicron and its variants are getting better at evading immune defences induced by vaccines or by natural infection. BA.5, for example, is more transmissible than any previous variant.
As a consequence it is now possible to be reinfected with one of Omicron’s variants every two to three weeks.
The data also shows that each reinfection confers no immunity. A summer infection, for example, will not protect you against a fall infection. But each and every infection will damage your immune system regardless of how mild the symptoms.
Interestingly, the article by Eric Topol to which Nikiforuk links, although it does describe how much more transmissible and immune evading Omicron BA.5 is than previous variants, also points out that, even with the new Omicron variants, existing vaccines are still very effective at preventing death from COVID-19. I mention this because another central theme of Nikiforuk’s article is that the vaccines are increasingly useless because of how Omicron variants are becoming increasingly good at evading immunity, for example:
So the virus is getting better at thwarting vaccines and evading immunity. Although vaccine protection against hospitalization and death remains strong, it is being steadily eroded by Omicron’s subvariants. Meanwhile protection against severe disease has declined as the effectiveness of our vaccines progressively wanes.
So Nikiforuk admits that the vaccines still work quite well at preventing serious disease and death, but pivots to paint a dire picture of future horror. In doing so, he completely ignores evidence showing that the vaccines are still quite effective at preventing severe disease and death, even from Omicron variants. Is it reasonable to be concerned that future variants will erode the ability of existing vaccines to prevent severe disease and death? Of course. Is it reasonable to portray this erosion as inevitable? Not so much, given that vaccines targeting newer variants are in development. I will admit, though, that Nikiforuk has a point when he laments that SARS-CoV-2 is evolving faster, seemingly, than our ability to develop new vaccines to cover variants that are emerging.
At this point, I’ll also note that in his response to critics, Nikiforuk basically admits that he overreached here:
But to be accurate (and avoid semantic disputes) I should have said that new infections confer so little immunity — because the immune system is unable to remember them — that we must seek every other protection available. The Tyee has made that correction to the original story.
Of course, semantics matter. Perhaps the most succinct criticism of Nikiforuk’s original wording came from a pseudonymous Twitter account, and I liked it enough to quote it directly:
To start, the article claims: “As a consequence it is now possible to be reinfected with one of Omicron’s variants every two to three weeks." This is utterly false. Now, STOP right there. I'm NOT saying it's not possible to get reinfected within three weeks. I’m saying the use of
— Chise 🔜 FWA (@sailorrooscout) July 6, 2022
as a RARE occurrence and NOT as a “this is going to happen to everyone so brace yourselves” kind of thing. What we haven’t seen is ANY substantial evidence of reinfection EVERY 2-3 weeks (3 infections within 6 weeks and implication of this being ongoing). Is this possible?
— Chise 🔜 FWA (@sailorrooscout) July 6, 2022
Interestingly, if you look at the New York State reinfection data cited above, you’ll see that reinfection, while not rare, is nowhere near as common as Nikiforuk’s fear mongering would suggest. Indeed, the study states:
These data demonstrate low levels of reinfection, compared to first infections. This did not change after the Omicron variant emerged in December 2021, although the number of reinfections increased.
Data on this page also suggest that people with a prior diagnosed COVID-19 infection have had some protection against future infections. This is similar to lower levels of infection among vaccinated people (‘breakthrough infection’), compared to among unvaccinated people, which is used to demonstrate vaccine effectiveness.
Our in-depth study measured the relative protection afforded by vaccination and/or prior infection, during 2021, before the Omicron variant emerged. Both may offer protection against future infections and COVID-19 hospitalizations.
Of course, each infection carries the risk of severe disease, death, and long COVID-19; so the authors conclude that vaccination is the safest means of preventing these dire outcomes and should be the strategy employed. In any event, Nikiforuk’s take incorrectly and deceptively conflates the possibility of being reinfected with a variant once as early as two to three weeks after a COVID-19 infection with the likelihood of being reinfected multiple times every three weeks and then uses that to paint a picture of a horrific “forever plague” whose only end will be COVID elimination. It is a picture that is at odds with reality, as described here:
A few recent studies have shown it’s possible to get reinfected with another variant (or even another omicron subvariant) in as little as 20 days; back in January, Slate ran an account of a woman who was likely infected with delta one month and omicron the next. But these rapid reinfections still seem to be rare, and there are, as best as I can tell, no documented cases of people getting reinfected again one month, and then again the next, and then again the next. And while getting COVID “just” twice inside of a year might feel like a horror take on Groundhog Day, the “Forever Plague” author seems to be painting a picture of a nightmare world where the default human state is a constant state of SARS-CoV-2 infection. This is simply not the case.
To support his claim, in his original article Nikiforuk cites a VA study on reinfections, although, interestingly enough, he doesn’t directly cite the study itself (which has not been peer reviewed and is still a preprint) but rather a post on Eric Topol’s Substack. It examined findings from over 257,427 people with one COVID-19 infection, 38,926 people with 2 or more infections, and nearly 5.4 million uninfected controls, and compared risks and 6-month burdens of all-cause mortality, hospitalization, and a set of pre-specified incident outcomes, including adverse health outcomes in the pulmonary and several extrapulmonary organ systems (cardiovascular disorders, coagulation and hematologic disorders, diabetes, fatigue, gastrointestinal disorders, kidney disorders, mental health disorders, musculoskeletal disorders, and neurologic disorders) and concluded:
Compared to non-infected controls, assessment of the cumulative risks of repeated infection showed that the risk and burden increased in a graded fashion according to the number of infections. The constellation of findings show that reinfection adds non-trivial risks of all-cause mortality, hospitalization, and adverse health outcomes in the acute and post-acute phase of the reinfection. Reducing overall burden of death and disease due to SARS-CoV-2 will require strategies for reinfection prevention.
Since this is the first study of its kind, we don’t know whether it will be replicated. Even if one accepts its findings at face value, the main people whom I’ve seen arguing that infections tend to be mild are GBD proponents and antivaxxers, and they tend to dismiss the possibility of reinfection because to acknowledge reinfection would be to acknowledge that a “natural herd immunity” strategy for the pandemic is disastrous.
Progressive destruction of the immune system by SARS-CoV-2
Ironically enough, I agree with Nikiforuk that a “let ‘er rip” approach rooted in a faith in “natural herd immunity” is disastrous, even as I have a serious problem with his cherry picking and exaggeration. Where Nikiforuk goes beyond what data will support is his picture of each COVID-19 infection and reinfection progressively damaging the immune system. To that end, he cherry picks certain studies:
So the virus is getting better at thwarting vaccines and evading immunity. Although vaccine protection against hospitalization and death remains strong, it is being steadily eroded by Omicron’s subvariants. Meanwhile protection against severe disease has declined as the effectiveness of our vaccines progressively wanes.
Immunologist Anthony Leonardi, a specialist in T cells, which play a complex role in immune function, predicted such a development nearly two years ago. That’s when he speculated that COVID was destabilizing the immune system by subverting T-cell function.
And that is exactly what many researchers are now finding.
So, based on a video, Nikiforuk is arguing that variants are steadily eroding the ability of vaccines to protect against hospitalization and death, and then cites one study. So I looked at the study. Interestingly, the study isn’t quite what Nikiforuk portrays. Yes, it shows that SARS-CoV-2 can cause T-cell apoptosis (programmed cell death). It also suggests a strategy to blunt or prevent that apoptosis, namely inhibition of an enzyme involved in the process known as a caspase. However, this study looked at apoptosis of T cells during severe and fatal acute infection, specifically 11 patients “in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) for acute respiratory distress syndrome” and 30 patients “admitted to the Infectious Diseases Department (non-ICU) for symptoms of dyspnea and/or deterioration in their general condition”. It also looked at sera from 18 other hospitalized patients. It says nothing about less severe COVID-19 and representing it as generalizable to all COVID-19, as Nikiforuk does, is an example of the lack of nuance in this paper.
Elsewhere Nikiforuk cites a paper that examined infection Omicron B.1.1.529, a variant that carries multiple spike mutations with high transmissibility and partial neutralizing antibody escape, in healthcare workers with different COVID-19 infection histories and concluded:
B and T cell immunity against previous variants of concern was enhanced in triple vaccinated individuals, but magnitude of T and B cell responses against B.1.1.529 spike protein was reduced. Immune imprinting by infection with the earlier B.1.1.7 (Alpha) variant resulted in less durable binding antibody against B.1.1.529. Previously infection-naïve HCW who became infected during the B.1.1.529 wave showed enhanced immunity against earlier variants, but reduced nAb potency and T cell responses against B.1.1.529 itself. Previous Wuhan Hu-1 infection abrogated T cell recognition and any enhanced cross-reactive neutralizing immunity on infection with B.1.1.529.
What this study suggests is that “Omicron infections after vaccination recall the same antibodies that vaccines triggered against earlier strains, instead of eliciting all new responses to Omicron” and, as the authors concluded, “Some imprinted combinations, such as infection during the Wuhan Hu-1 and Omicron waves, confer particularly impaired responses”. Is this a potential problem with vaccine development? Yes. Is it, as Nikiforuk seems to suggest, slam-dunk evidence that the continued evolution of Omicron variants will result in a “forever plague” in which much of the population keeps getting sick because each wave of new variants progressively impairs the immune response? No. That’s an overgeneralization based on one study.
If you think that’s bad, buckle up, as Nikiforuk claims that COVID-19 will progressively destroy society, claiming that what we see now is worse than we’d see with a virus with much more than an order of magnitude higher mortality that passes through the population once and then disappears:
So letting the virus run unchecked is pretty much a strategy for creating a tsunami of neurological impairment and chronic illness in the general population. It is also a nihilistic prescription for sowing chaos in western societies already dancing a tango with political collapse.
Letting the virus rip also supports a nightmare scenario where initial infections disarm and sabotage immune systems leaving them more vulnerable to future infections and new pathogens such as monkeypox.
A pandemic that progressively weakens its host population with each successive wave is ultimately more dangerous than one that dispatches 10 per cent of the population and then vanishes.
Thanks to bad public policy, the frightening reality of a forever pandemic is becoming more probable day by day.
This, too, is exaggerated fear mongering and not how immunity works. Again, I refer to this article:
The empirical data coming in right now supports these basic immunological principles. If a previous omicron infection conferred little or no immunity against future omicron infections, then you’d expect that each subvariant’s surge would reach similar or even greater heights—because each subvariant is increasingly more contagious—than the original early 2022 omicron peak. But testing data from New York shows that the BA.2 wave fell far short of the original omicron wave—both in terms of total infections and reinfections. The same patterns held in Portugal, France, and Italy. The U.K. testing data followed a similar pattern (though testing data with randomized sampling, which better controls for testing rates, suggests the BA.2 peak was higher, a separate analysis from the U.K. Health Security Agency suggests reinfections were relatively rare, and not driving the spike). Testing in South Africa, where the BA.4/BA.5 surge has already peaked, showed much lower levels of infections. This is consistent with a population fortified by prior immunity.
As I like to say, when GBD proponents and antivaxxers argue that scientists and skeptics claim that natural immunity is useless, they misrepresent our position. I like to point out that postinfection immunity to some diseases is indeed lifelong; for others, like COVID-19, it’s far from it. Indeed, as I’ve pointed out, postinfection immunity to COVID-19 likely lasts a bit longer than post-vaccination immunity but is far from lifelong, one point on which Nikiforuk and I agree.
I also like to point out that vaccine efficacy will likely appear to wane just as more and more infection spreads through a population. Remember, estimates of vaccine efficacy (VE) compare infection rates in unvaccinated population to those in the vaccinated population. However, as the level of infection produces more “natural immunity” in both populations, the apparent difference between the risk of infection in the unvaccinated and the vaccinated will decrease just because the “unvaccinated” population will include a greater and greater proportion of people with prior infection and some degree of postinfection immunity.
Finally, wending its way through the entire narrative is long COVID-19. “Long COVID,” the syndrome of persistent symptoms and residual organ dysfunction after a COVID-19 infection is a real and concerning phenomenon. We’ve even said so a number of times on this very blog and that it will take years to determine the true burden of long COVID, not to mention to work out fully mechanisms and outcomes, and our resident neurologist, Steve Novella, has discussed the link between COVID-19 infection and neurodegenerative disorders. We actually agree that long COVID is likely to be a serious problem going forward. Indeed, concern about long COVID is the one of the germs of a good point in Nikiforuk’s article. Unfortunately, it is buried in all the fear mongering.
When allies go too far
Oddly enough, I was late to recognize a new phenomenon on “our side” that Nikiforuk’s article embodies, the so-called “zero COVID” movement. Pathologist Dr. Ben Mazer actually noted this a week and a half ago, a few days before Nikiforuk’s article was published:
This brings me to back to the response by my co-author Dr. Yamey:
There are 2 things I believe simultaneously:
1️⃣ There’s a lot more we should be doing to reduce the global burden of Covid, eg expanding access to vax/boosters/Paxlovid/Evusheld/sick pay & reducing indoor infection risk
2️⃣ This column is error-laden/doom mongering/disempowering pic.twitter.com/kvo1ML06kC
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) July 6, 2022
And this one, by immunologist Angela Rasmussen, that includes points made by Nikiforuk that I agree with:
Its a pity those points are swallowed by demands for a hardline elimination approach.
Testing, masking, tracing, supported sick leave, and targeted goals are all important (and the author forgot vaccination) for reducing transmission, but elimination is not “imminently doable.” pic.twitter.com/6txIr7TJYl
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) July 6, 2022
And:
Abandon hopium, all ye who enter this thread.
Instead, focus on concrete, additive actions to reduce transmission:-Get vaccinated + boosted-Wear a mask-Ventilate/filter air-Avoid crowds-Be outdoors if possible-Hygiene/disinfection-Test + isolate if infected/symptomatic
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) July 6, 2022
I’d also amplify Dr. Rasmussen’s point about how odd it is that Nikiforuk seemed to ignore vaccination as part of the strategy to reach “zero COVID”. Has there ever been a disease eliminated without the use of an effective vaccine? I think you know the answer to that. In an earlier article, Nikiforuk declared confidently:
Yet as The Tyee has consistently warned, vaccines are imperfect tools that have severe limits. Moreover no vaccine has ended any outbreak without the help of other public health tools including masks, quarantines and reductions in mobility. The assumption that a vaccine or drugs can end a novel evolving pathogen in real time without the strategic use of other interventions to bring transmission to zero has made society more fragile and not less so.
But vaccines did vastly decrease the burden of many endemic diseases, such as measles and polio. They also ended smallpox. It’s not wrong that a vaccine-only policy is likely to be less than optimally effective (not almost completely ineffective, as Nikiforuk claims), but it’s clear that Nikiforuk doesn’t think much of vaccines, which are, contrary to his seeming belief, an essential part of any strategy to minimize death from a pandemic. In his response to criticism, Nikiforuk argues that he said that vaccines are important, just not enough, a position that is reasonable. Unfortunately, given all the loaded language and relative lack of discussion of this aspect of vaccine, his original article most definitely did not leave me with that impression. Quite the opposite, in fact. Go back and read his article and see if you don’t agree.
Also, in his response, Nikiforuk more or less doubles down on everything in his original article, admitting the error mentioned above, but in essence pointing to the same data cited in the paper and appealing to unknowns:
Last April the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued a field report on reinfections. It documented ten cases of reinfection — all during the Omicron wave — the majority among children and health-care workers. The shortest interval between one infection and a subsequent reinfection with a different lineage of COVID was 23 days — hence the basis for my sentence.
The researchers added that “antigen tests are increasingly performed at home, resulting in specimens being unavailable for strain testing. Thus, most early reinfections are likely not identified.” So the actual numbers of people having reinfections within 30 or 90 days is unknown but probably much greater than what the CDC picked up. (It is important to note that reinfections may also represent relapses whereby persistent infections reappear.)
None of this actually answers the entirely valid criticism that there is no evidence that anyone can be continually reinfected every few weeks with new COVID-19 variants, or that Nikiforuk provides no evidence that he’s doing anything more than JAQing off.
I also laughed out loud at this passage:
Rasmussen, like many critics, then professed ignorance about experts downplaying COVID infections as inevitable and even beneficial. Skeptical critics implied there was no evidence of this. Let me provide two links to articles in the Wall Street Journal representing this kind of harmful thinking. One article promised a good chance of herd immunity by April.
Another said taking measures to speed the spread of Omicron would produce the best long term outcomes.
The first article cited by Nikiforuk? It’s the infamous article from 2021 by Marty Makary claiming “we’ll have herd immunity by April”. Let’s just say that we at SBM have…not been kind…to that article, and rightly so. Nor have we been kind to claims that a let ‘er rip approach to the pandemic, as advocated in the second article cited, is a valid approach to the pandemic, noting that it is, in essence, eugenics. I also note that both articles cited were op-eds published in The Wall Street Journal, which has been a font of pandemic denial, COVID-19 minimization, and antivaccine fear mongering. Tellingly, Nikiforuk seems to be implying that these doctors represent mainstream public health thought in their COVID-19 minimization and advocacy of “natural herd immunity” approaches to the pandemic. They’re not, and those who have criticized his article have been harshly critical of these academics as well—even more critical, given that, while we have some common ground with Nikiforuk, common ground between us and pandemic minimizers like Marty Makary is almost nonexistent.
Let me conclude with an observation, namely that it is possible to acknowledge more than one thing at once about the pandemic without being a “COVID minimizer”, as some “zero COVID” advocates are claiming, and acknowledging these multiple things does not validate the complaints of the real COVID-19 minimizers (e.g., Marty Makary) at having the label applied to them. COVID-19 and long COVID are very bad. COVID-19 is not just a flu-like illness caused by a different virus, and SARS-CoV-2 does more bad things than previously suspected. Not nearly enough is being done any more (if it ever was) to protect vulnerable people, particularly the immunosuppressed, for whom the cessation of NPIs to slow the spread of COVID-19 has led to a feeling of abandonment and a recurrent fear of infection and death. It is also possible to be concerned about the rise of variants that are more transmissible and can evade prior immunity, both vaccine-induced and infection-induced. None of this means that those of us criticizing views espoused by Nikiforuk and others think that COVID-19 infection or reinfection is “good”.
I wish that zero COVID-19 were actually attainable. I would love to go back to a world before late 2019, when a novel coronavirus caused an outbreak of a mysterious pneumonia in Wuhan, China. Nikiforuk cites Japan as an example of how to do it, but even Japan has not achieved zero COVID. Moreover, although we too lament how quickly most countries have abandoned effective NPIs, we also lament that most countries in the world are not like Japan in how they are combatting COVID-19. Expecting them to be, as desirable as that might be, is just not realistic. As a result, COVID-19 is unlikely to be eliminated any time soon, if ever, which means that the best that we can do is to promote better ventilation, more masking, get vaccinated and boosted, avoid crowded indoor spaces, develop better vaccines, and in general continue to try to minimize the harm from COVID-19. Saying that is not “hopium”. It is realistic, far more realistic than GBD-like strategies or “zero COVID”. Public health during a pandemic has to be based on a realistic assessment of the situation, the tools available to combat the pandemic, and the political will to use those tools. Unfortunately, the world appears to lack the last of these, something about which we agree with Nikiforuk.

A Rare and Mysterious Inflammatory Syndrome in Children is Linked to COVID-19
A mysterious inflammatory condition, likely caused by COVID-19, is affecting a small number of children. We don’t know much about it yet, but we are certain to see additional cases and to learn more about why this is happening. Still, it’s not time to panic.
Clay Jones on May 29, 2020
Link

In early April, I discussed some reassuring data from the CDC on pediatric COVID-19 cases. The bottom line was that kids tend to have mild symptoms, a very low number have required hospitalization, and deaths have been extremely rare. That is still the case. In that post, however, I did raise the concern that there are likely many asymptomatic cases, or at least cases where mild symptoms fly below the radar, potentially allowing the spread of the virus to unsuspecting higher risk people.
On Wednesday, new research was published revealing that asymptomatic cases and the potential for silent spread to high risk individuals may be more of a concern than previously thought. Published in JAMA Network and Thorax, two papers reported that patients were asymptomatic in 40% and 80% of cases respectively. My hunch is that children are even more likely than adults to fall into this category, and although it isn’t the point of my post, I’ll put a plug in right here for masks and following guidelines for social distancing as much as possible.
While children are still extremely unlikely to develop serious disease when infected with the novel coronavirus, there has been a major development since my last post. On April 27th, the NHS sent out a letter warning British physicians to be on the lookout for children with a severe systemic inflammatory disease after 12 cases had been reported that shared a similar presentation of diffuse inflammation, abdominal symptoms, and cardiac involvement. Although not every case was proven to be associated with recent Sars-CoV-2 infection by positive confirmatory labs, several were, raising concern that it played a role.
My initial response to this was skepticism that the novel coronavirus was truly to blame. These early cases were being compared to conditions that, while not common, are well known pediatric diseases. I have taken care of a child or three with Toxic Shock Syndrome over the years, and many with Kawasaki Disease, which seemed to be the primary condition being used to illustrate how these children presented. Furthermore, since the pandemic began we have been on very high alert for new or unusual COVID-19 clinical presentations, and anecdotal reports have been prevalent. So I worried that we might be forcing a pattern into the clumpy randomness of medicine.
I’m a lot less skeptical now.
Two weeks after that initial warning went out in England, more data from Italy had emerged which helped to better-define this mysterious condition. France, Switzerland, and Spain were also reporting children affected by systemic inflammation that required hospitalization and intensive care. And by May 21, around 100 cases of what is now called Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C) had been reported in New York, with smaller numbers of cases popping up in several other states where there have been significant outbreaks of COVID-19.
More and more it appeared that the novel coronavirus was to blame, and that these weren’t just typical pediatric inflammatory conditions. While a decent percentage of these pediatric patients had negative PCR studies, which attempt to detect the presence of viral DNA and acute infection, most of them had positive antibody tests. Although we still weren’t looking at huge numbers of cases, a pattern was emerging.
To start, these patients skewed older than what is typical for Kawasaki Disease by a few years. And while Kawasaki is infamous for the degree of irritability it can cause, and for its ability to damage the heart when not appropriately treated, MIS-C was resulting in much more severe inflammation and injury. Most of the patients were 3-4 weeks out from coronavirus infection, when timing was known, and no other causes, such as an infection with a toxin-producing bacteria or an autoimmune condition such as JIA or Lupus, were being identified. Rather than direct damage from the virus, the severe multisystem inflammation appears to be related to an acquired immunity to it.
On May 14th, the CDC issued recommendations to report any cases meeting MIS-C criteria to local health departments:
Case Definition for Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C)
    • An individual aged <21 years presenting with feveri, laboratory evidence of inflammationii, and evidence of clinically severe illness requiring hospitalization, with multisystem (≥2) organ involvement (cardiac, renal, respiratory, hematologic, gastrointestinal, dermatologic or neurological); AND
    • No alternative plausible diagnoses; AND
    • Positive for current or recent SARS-CoV-2 infection by RT-PCR, serology, or antigen test; or COVID-19 exposure within the 4 weeks prior to the onset of symptoms
iFever ≥38.0°C for ≥24 hours, or report of subjective fever lasting ≥24 hoursiiIncluding, but not limited to, one or more of the following: an elevated C-reactive protein (CRP), erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), fibrinogen, procalcitonin, d-dimer, ferritin, lactic acid dehydrogenase (LDH), or interleukin 6 (IL-6), elevated neutrophils, reduced lymphocytes and low albumin
Additional comments
    • Some individuals may fulfill full or partial criteria for Kawasaki disease but should be reported if they meet the case definition for MIS-C
    • Consider MIS-C in any pediatric death with evidence of SARS-CoV-2 infection
We still have a lot to learn about MIS-C. For example, is there something unique about these particular kids or is it just bad luck? Could there be a genetic predisposition? So far, it doesn’t appear that there are any specific health conditions that increase the risk, but cases have occurred a bit more frequently in boys, which fits the overall trend with COVID-19. What is the best treatment is also unclear. Many of these cases have been managed the same way that we treat Kawasaki Disease, but outcomes have been pretty good in those who weren’t. Simply put, we need more data, and now that this is a reportable disease we will likely get it.
Since the CDC advisory went out on the 14th, New York has reported another 70 cases. In the United States, there have been less than 300 cases spread across 26 states, with at least one death. Thankfully, this is still a very rare outcome and the vast majority of cases have ended with a full recovery. But if novel coronavirus infections among children were to increase, perhaps if schools or businesses are opened in an unsafe way, we will almost certainly see more MIS-C.
Parents and caregivers shouldn’t panic at every fever or complaint of tummy pain, but they should touch base with their child’s pediatrician or family doctor if they are ill appearing. If a child is experiencing difficulty breathing, chest pain, altered mental status, blue discoloration of the lips, or severe abdominal pain, they should be evaluated more urgently. Throw on a mask and don’t let fear of exposure to coronavirus delay appropriate medical care.

Stroke in COVID-19 Patients
A case series of five patients with COVID-19 and young strokes sparks many questions.
Steven Novella on April 29, 2020
Link

One of the features of the current pandemic leading to anxiety is that this is a new virus and a new disease, and so we don’t yet know what the full clinical picture of COVID-19 is. We are learning the most common clinical features (fever, chills, cough, loss of taste or smell), the asymptomatic rate, and the case fatality rate, but it will take time and more research to fully understand this disease and this virus.
It especially takes time to learn the less common features of a disease like COVID-19. One recent report illustrates this – a case series of five patients in a NYC health system presenting with young stroke (<55). Such reports are often how new medical knowledge is first acquired – a clinical observation of something out of the ordinary. These observations are critical, but are never the final word. They essentially represent a hypothesis that needs to be tested. Let’s review the report and then put it into this context.
The authors report five cases of large vessel stroke in patients with confirmed COVID-19 all younger than 50, and therefore classified as a young stroke. Strokes in those younger than 50 are relatively rare, and so always attract clinical attention. In other words, they don’t just happen as a consequence of aging (atherosclerosis, chronic hypertension, etc.). Neurologists will do an extended workup looking for an underlying cause (referred to as a “young stroke workup”). A young stroke, for example, may be due to an underlying inflammatory disease, or blood disorder leading to an increased tendency for the blood to clot (hypercoagulopathy). Trauma to a large vessel is also a possibility – a small tear in a vessel can occur even from a seemingly mild trauma.
There is circumstantial evidence that these five strokes (or at least many of them) may be causally related to COVID-19. First, they all were confirmed to have the disease. Also, they all had the same type of stroke – large vessel stroke caused by a blood clot (thrombus). That is at least consistent with a common underlying mechanism.
The authors report that:
By comparison, every 2 weeks over the previous 12 months, our service has treated, on average, 0.73 patients younger than 50 years of age with large-vessel stroke.
So that means over the two-week period reported there were an excess of about 4 young strokes. One of the five cases reported had a history of stroke, so perhaps that was the baseline stroke, but it is also possible that stroke was precipitated by COVID-19. Statistically this bump in cases is significant, and certainly deserves attention. One possibility is that COVID-19 can cause a hypercoagulable state in some patients with the disease, increasing the risk of blood clotting events like stroke. If this is true then we would also expect an increase in other clotting disorders, like heart attacks, pulmonary embolism, and deep vein thrombosis (DVT).
The authors also report:
A retrospective study of data from the Covid-19 outbreak in Wuhan, China, showed that the incidence of stroke among hospitalized patients with Covid-19 was approximately 5%; the youngest patient in that series was 55 years of age. Moreover, large-vessel stroke was reported in association with the 2004 SARS-CoV-1 outbreak in Singapore.
It’s hard to know what to make of that data without further information. So there are still significant unknowns here.
First, it is possible that these five cases are a statistical fluke. Medical experts are trained to notice statistical outliers, and organizations like the CDC track such outliers to see if there is an underlying cause. We call such outliers “clusters” and they are often reported and investigated. It is common, however, for such clusters to be nothing but statistical flukes. If you think of all the diseases in all the clinical settings, cities, and regions around the country and world, we should expect statistical clusters to occur by random chance alone. Epidemiologists can evaluate such clusters statistically to determine the likelihood that they are random or real.
In essence the medical system is mining the large set of data represented by medical cases, and will see plenty of illusory or statistical patterns that are random, but can look impressive in isolation. The ultimate test is looking at new data going forward. If the cluster is real then we would expect the trend to continue, for new excess cases to occur. One pitfall in doing follow up studies, however, is including the original data. If the original cluster was a fluke, including those original cases in later data will contaminate that data and perpetuate the fluke. For this reason follow up studies should look at only fresh data.
There is also the possibility of confirmation bias. Once you have a hypothesis, there is the tendency to look for data to confirm the hypothesis. This might mean looking in places or in ways that have not been done before, and then assuming that what is found is new (rather than just the method of looking being new). Apparent clusters can also be due to shifting definitions and diagnostic criteria, or to new diagnostic technology or standards.
If the cluster was a statistical outlier, then we would expect regression to the mean – cases would return to a more likely statistical background. Comparisons can be made to fresh data in other locations, to future sets of data, or to different subpopulations.
With regard to large vessel stroke in COVID-19 patients, do we see the same cluster in other locations? What about other age groups – why would younger patients be affected but not older ones? Is it just that strokes are more common in older patients and therefore do not garner as much attention? An excess of five older strokes might be lost in the background.
If this is a true cluster, and there is a confirmed correlation with COVID-19, what is the exact mechanism? Hypercoagulability is likely, and not uncommon in inflammatory illnesses, so a cause is plausible. If so, are there any treatments that can mitigate this increased risk? At the very least patients with COVID-19 should be on the lookout for any symptoms of early stroke, and present immediately to medical attention if they have any. Some of the patients in the case series delayed presentation to the ER because of the pandemic.
This is all one tiny facet of this new and complex disease, and will require extensive clinical research and time to fully understand. Others less common but significant features may also emerge as the pandemic unfolds.

Neurological Manifestations of COVID
The more we study COVID, the more apparent it is that neurological symptoms are common and can be long lasting.
Steven Novella on August 4, 2021
Link

It’s hard to avoid COVID news, and it’s easy to become tired of it. The pandemic is definitely stressing our endurance, individually and collectively. But as the most recent wave of COVID indicates, this pandemic is not over yet. We also still have a lot to learn about COVID-19, especially its long-term effects, which we can only study once enough time has passed for there to be a long term.
A lot of focus in terms of the impact of COVID has been on the death toll, now over 614,000 in the US and 4.2 million world-wide. But medical specialists know that when evaluating the impact of an illness you don’t look just at mortality, you have to look at morbidity as well – negative health effects other than death. Now, at least, the media is talking about so-called “long COVID”, symptoms which persist long after the acute illness is over. Further, even though COVID was initially conceived of as a respiratory illness, it is now more accurately understood as a systemic and vascular illness.
Here I am going to focus on the neurological manifestations of COVID. I have been seeing patients in my neurology clinic with symptoms following COVID starting last Summer, and increasingly so this year. The most common symptom I see is “brain fog”, but headaches and fatigue are also common. There is now an emerging literature on the neurological effects of COVID, which are significant.
Even early in the pandemic it was clear that COVID had effects outside the respiratory system, including neurological. Most of this early data, however, was about acute illness. A French study published in June 2020 showed that 84% of hospitalized patients with COVID had neurological manifestations. A majority of patients admitted to ICU with COVID are found to have delirium (a type of confusion and disorientation). Loss of taste and smell was observed early to be a sign of COVID. Cases of COVID-induced Guillain-Barré syndrome (which mostly affects the nerves) were also observed.
But still it was not known early on if these effects were cause directly by infection with SARS-CoV-2, or an indirect effect of being critically ill. With further study it became clear that COVID affects the brain in a number of ways. We now know COVID is predominantly a vascular disease, affecting the blood vessels and causing blood clots throughout the body, including the brain. This can cause ischemia, or lack of oxygen, in the brain which causes damage. Patients with COVID may also have small bleeds in the brain, which also causes damage. Finally the virus can directly cause inflammation in the brain through infection, called encephalitis.
These are all conditions neurologists are very familiar with. They can make patients acutely very neurologically ill, and recovery can be slow. Full recovery is possible, and depends on the pre-morbid health and age of the patient. But it is also common for patients after a severe illness with encephalitis to never recover to their prior baseline. We are now starting to see data that shows the same is true following severe COVID as well. A study from October 2020 found that 82% of patients hospitalized with COVID had some neurological manifestation.
The most frequent neurologic manifestations were myalgias (44.8%), headaches (37.7%), encephalopathy (31.8%), dizziness (29.7%), dysgeusia (15.9%), and anosmia (11.4%).
A study in The Lancet published in July 2021 found:
People who had recovered from COVID-19, including those no longer reporting symptoms, exhibited significant cognitive deficits versus controls when controlling for age, gender, education level, income, racial-ethnic group, pre-existing medical disorders, tiredness, depression and anxiety. The deficits were of substantial effect size for people who had been hospitalised (N = 192), but also for non-hospitalised cases who had biological confirmation of COVID-19 infection (N = 326). Analysing markers of premorbid intelligence did not support these differences being present prior to infection. Finer grained analysis of performance across sub-tests supported the hypothesis that COVID-19 has a multi-domain impact on human cognition.
This is essentially one of the symptoms people are calling long-COVID. What is concerning in this data is that sustained neurological deficits were found even among those who were not sick enough to be hospitalized. Essentially, those with moderate to severe COVID infection statistically dropped a few IQ points, which is a marker of brain injury. It is possible that after 2-3 years of recovery this effect will significantly diminish and even go away, so there is more to learn from longer term data when enough time has passed. But this is a concerning sign of brain injury from COVID infection.
It is also possible, as some researchers are warning, that the damage caused to the brain from severe COVID might have long term effects that are not recognized for years. Ischemic and inflammatory damage to brain cells may accelerate degenerative processes, increasing the risk of developing degenerative brain disease (like Alzheimer’s disease) years down the road.
Yet another study found that 55% of hospitalized COVID patient had a co-infection with the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), the virus that causes chronic fatigue syndrome in some patients. This may be due to an opportunistic reactivation of the dormant virus. It may also be partially responsible for the chronic fatigue many patients with long COVID experience. But further it reflects how much about COVID we still don’t understand – this is a complex and serious infection, and the more rocks we turn over, the more we are finding about its effects.
As was noted in an earlier SBM article, children may be relatively less affected by COVID than adults, but they are not immune. Recent data shows that:
9.8% of children aged 2–11 years and 13% aged 12–16 years reported at least one lingering symptom five weeks after a positive diagnosis.
A study published in JAMA in March 2021 found:
In this study of 1695 patients 21 years or younger hospitalized for acute COVID-19 or multisystem inflammatory syndrome, 365 (22%) had neurologic involvement. Forty-three patients (12%) developed COVID-19–related life-threatening neurologic disorders, 11 (26%) died, and 17 (40%) survived with new neurologic sequelae.
These numbers are alarming. They should not be considered less so simply because they are even worse in adults.
As we are facing a new wave of COVID, with the prospect of new variants in the future possibly extending the pandemic even further, it is important that the public have a clear picture of how serious this illness is. The death toll should be enough to indicate how severe COVID can be, but even that is not the whole picture. This is a systemic infection that can cause chronic illness, and neurological manifestations are common, more so in adults but children are affected too. This will have a significant effect on our healthcare system for decades to come.
I also have to point out that we have a powerful solution right in front of us – safe and effective vaccines.

COVID Associated With Neurodegenerative Disorders
COVID infection has been associated with an increased risk of neurodegenerative and neurovascular disease – another reason to keep our eye on this serious illness.
Steven Novella on June 29, 2022
Link

COVID is becoming like a spurned lover who is now stalking you. You can’t forget about it, and while you hope that’s it gone, you know it’s still there, lurking in the shadows. COVID has now killed over 6.3 million people worldwide, and over one million people in the US alone. But it’s possible that the greater toll of the disease is the morbidity of long COVID. A new study adds to our understanding of this burden.
We now have more effective tools than we had at the beginning of the pandemic. Physicians understand how to treat COVID acutely much better. There are effective antivirals approved for use, such as Paxlovid. And of course there are many COVID vaccines with high efficacy. Hospitals are no longer being overwhelmed, and while there can still be waves of the virus, they seem to be waning. The pandemic is evolving into the slow burn of an endemic infection, like the flu.
This, however, is not the time to take our eye off the ball. COVID is still a serious illness, and the more we learn about so-called long COVID the worse it seems. COVID is likely to become a significant source of morbidity and health care burden, and we need to treat it that way. Primarily we need to keep up pressure to get as many people vaccinated as possible, keep up with boosters, and update the vaccines to track the new variants. 
A recent study presented at the 8th European Academy of Neurology (EAN) Congress adds more data to our knowledge of the long term effects of COVID. This is a Danish population-based study, so it is observational, not experimental, which means it can establish correlation only. They found:
Out of 919,731 individuals that were tested for COVID-19 within the study, researchers found that the 43,375 people who tested positive had a 3.5 times increased risk of being diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, 2.6 times with Parkinson’s disease, 2.7 times with ischaemic stroke, and 4.8 times with intracerebral hemorrhage (bleeding in the brain).
The researchers tried to control for confounding factors, statistically matching for age and other risk factors. The results are statistically robust, but they need to be confirmed with further sets of data. Of note, other neurological diseases were not increased in COVID-positive people. The effects seem to be limited to neurodegenerative disorders and neurovascular disorders, but not autoimmune diseases or other neurological disorders.
This fits with prior evidence that infections resulting in brain inflammation can increase the risk of neurodegenerative diseases, like Alzheimer’s disease and Parkinson’s. This also fits the natural history of COVID, which can cause headaches and “brain fog”, suggesting that infection can affect the brain. Often these symptoms persist long after the acute respiratory infection.
In addition to confirming these associations, further research should explore the degree to which vaccination prevents this increased risk in those who get COVID despite being vaccinated. We know that the COVID vaccines reduce the risk of developing long COVID, with estimates in the literature varying from 15% to 50% reduction. It’s probable that vaccines would similarly reduce this increased risk in neurological disease, and since we are talking about serious illnesses, such as Alzheimer’s and stroke, even the lower end would represent a significant reduction in morbidity. But we need to study this directly.
We also have to put these findings in to the context of ongoing research into similar effects of contracting the flu. Recent research has also been moving in the direction of an association between getting the flu and later risk of neurodegenerative disorders. The current Danish study also found this association, at similar levels to COVID, except for ischemic stroke, which was higher in COVID.
This does not mean that diseases like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s are entirely caused by viral infections, but such infection may be one trigger of neurodegeneration, or exacerbate it so that it presents earlier. This association is further supported by a recent study showing that getting flu vaccines reduces the risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease:
From the unmatched sample of eligible patients (n = 2,356,479), PSM produced a sample of 935,887 flu–vaccinated-unvaccinated matched pairs. The matched sample was 73.7 (SD, 8.7) years of age and 56.9% female, with median follow-up of 46 (IQR, 29–48) months; 5.1% (n = 47,889) of the flu-vaccinated patients and 8.5% (n = 79,630) of the flu-unvaccinated patients developed AD during follow-up. The RR was 0.60 (95% CI, 0.59–0.61) and ARR was 0.034 (95% CI, 0.033–0.035), corresponding to a number needed to treat of 29.4.
That’s a relative risk reduction of 40% with an absolute risk reduction from 8.5% to 5.1% (3.4%). Again, that is highly significant, which means at least two things. First this is more evidence to support a causal link between certain viruses and neurodegenerative disease, in this case the flu viruses with Alzheimer’s. But also it highlights the protective roll of vaccines in preventing this risk. There was also a dose-response effects, with a greater number of annual flu vaccines being more protective.
The evidence is now moving in the direction that COVID is similar to flu in that it also increases the risk of degenerative diseases, with the added burden of also increasing neurovascular disorders. And while we have to confirm this, it seems highly likely that COVID vaccines will have a similar protective effect as do flu vaccines.
What all of this means is that there is a huge benefit to getting an annual flu vaccine, and likely to getting vaccinated against COVID and keeping up to date on boosters. Don’t let the lull in COVID cause a false sense of safety. This remains a serious illness, we have the tools to fight it, and we need to use them.

Is It Safe?
Is it safe to go to the dentist? Dentists are doing their best to try to ensure it is as safe as possible, with lots of guidance and extra measures to protect patients and staff.
Grant Ritchey on June 12, 2020
Link

I’ve been in solo practice for almost 34 years now. I own my own practice and am my own boss. I chose this route because I wanted to be the Captain of my own ship and never have to worry about a job. Moreover, I’m a bit lazy and have problems with authority, so I would have made a terrible employee in any field. So imagine my surprise when suddenly during the first week of March, I had to completely shut down my dental practice. Well, not completely, as I was able to go in to see emergencies a couple of times each week, but basically I was laid off by a “boss” that measured a measly 120 nanometers across. I wasn’t alone; nearly every dental practice in the US came to a screeching halt by mid-March, following national, state, and local guidelines.
At the time, we dentists were flying blind. Very little information about the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic was known, and what we were learning changed daily. This was compounded by the fact that the dental profession is among the highest risk groups at being exposed to the coronavirus (See Figure 1). Some dentists believed we should remain open to see patients, making sure to take extra infection control precautions. Others thought that everything should be shut down completely and immediately until enough data was available to make informed choices as to the appropriate responses to this crisis should be. And yet another group lobbied for dental offices being open to treat emergency patients in order to nip problems in the bud and to help alleviate dental related visits to hospital Emergency Departments that might need to be utilized for acute COVID cases. These decisions were made for the most part at the state level. Here in Kansas, we had to shut down completely except for emergencies and “urgencies”, things that had a significant likelihood of worsening over a short period of time. While I hated to close my office and lay off my wonderful team, I did feel that it was the right thing to do. So I did.
In this brief post, I will review the current (as of June 11, 2020) guidelines put forth by the American Dental Association (ADA) and the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and what dental offices are doing to safeguard the health of their patients, staff, and community. It’s important for people to know the risks associated with going to the dentist, to be able to weigh those risks with the risks inherent in delaying dental treatment, and what to look for to make sure their dental office is following the proper protocols for infection control, social distancing, and other safeguards.
Figure 1 (click to embiggen)
Risks
Until recently, most of us had never heard the term “social distancing”; now it is one of the guiding forces in our day-to-day lives. Giving wide swaths of space to others in the grocery store, the closure of businesses, and the elimination of concerts, sporting events, and other large gatherings is de rigueur. We feel naked if we venture out into public without wearing a mask, and washing our hands dozens of times of day has become the norm. We do not yet have a vaccine for SARS-CoV-2, and existing treatments for COVID are not much different than those employed during the Spanish Flu pandemic of a century ago, except they are fancier and more expensive. Until effective treatments and/or a vaccine are widely available, we have to rely on the above low tech measures as we have done since the times of the Black Death. It’s almost like the Miasma Theory of disease has made a comeback and we endeavor to avoid breathing the “toxic air” at all costs.
The problem with dental visits – for both the patient and the dental team – as it relates to the pandemic is pretty straightforward and obvious. Simply put, we are literally all up in your face. Social distancing is not an option. We can’t drill on your teeth via Zoom. Dentists, dental hygienists, and dental assistants are able to wear gloves, masks, and other PPE such as face shields, surgical gowns, and the like (when available), but patients have to present their bare faces to us, making them more vulnerable. For the dental team, the risks are heightened by the very nature of the work we do. Most dental procedures require some sort of mechanical treatment on teeth, i.e. drilling. During dental cleanings, hygienists often use ultrasonic scalers. Both of these treatments generate a fine aerosol, which is dispersed over a distance of up to several feet, depending on the layout of the room, ventilation, etc. Direct contact with saliva can be transmitted to other surfaces such as our overhead lights, drawer handles, and the like. The coronavirus can remain aerosolized for several minutes after a procedure is completed, and the virus can remain active and viable on solid surfaces for up to several hours, depending on the surface. The bottom line is that dental offices are places of high risk for disease transmission.
Before you freak out and cancel all of your upcoming dental appointments, let’s look at the flip side of the equation. Before COVID was even a thing, we dentists practice strict infection control, from autoclaving instruments, using single-use disposable materials whenever possible, employing rigorous disinfection practices between patients (e.g. wiping down all surfaces with bacterio- and virucidal wipes, covering chairs, light handles etc. with disposable wraps, and more), wearing gloves and masks, and other aseptic techniques. Transitioning to an enhanced system of disinfection and protection was an easy jump for us for the most part.
Resources
As I mentioned above, when the pandemic first hit the US in February and early March, dentists were unsure as to the appropriate steps to take. Fortunately, the CDC and the ADA were prompt with their information and guidelines. Trying to sift through new and sometimes contradictory data that was pouring in, the CDC and ADA kept us informed and updated on the current literature and the consensus advice on how to safely practice – balancing the health needs of the public with the risks inherent in dental care.
The CDC has consistently issued guidelines for dental practice reopenings, which is no easy task considering that each state has its own guidelines and different practice areas are at different risk levels (e.g. the risks for a dentist in downtown Manhattan are different from mine in Tonganoxie, KS). The ADA and affiliated state dental associations have likewise advised dentists on the best and safest practices, providing valuable educational resources (webinars, email updates, etc.), which are updated frequently. To see the statistics and guidelines for your state, the ADA has provided a handy interactive map to use.
On a more general note, I have often touted the excellent Center for Evidence Based Dentistry website, which is patient friendly and covers all areas of dentistry.
To this end, despite the higher risk level of dental procedures, there has not been a single reported case of COVID transmission from a dental office that I am aware of to date.
What can I expect?
So, if it is time for that overdue cleaning that you had to cancel in March, what can you expect when you go to your appointment? Every office will do things a little differently, of course, but in general you can expect the following precautions to be taken:
    • You will be asked if you are experiencing any signs or symptoms of COVID (fever, cough, flu-like symptoms), if you have been exposed to someone with the disease, or if you have traveled to a “hot spot” where the infection rates are high.
    • When you arrive at your appointment, you may be asked to wait in your car until it is time to be seen. You should wear a mask until a member of the dental team tells you to remove it.
    • You may have your temperature taken and be asked to wash your hands or use a hand sanitizer.
    • You may be asked to swish with a hydrogen peroxide-based mouthwash as a pre-procedural rinse to reduce the viral load in your saliva.
    • Your dental care provider will likely appear as though she/he is preparing to enter the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant, garbed in gloves, high filtration mask, face shield, and gown or lab coat.
    • Enhanced disinfection procedures – wiping down all surfaces throughout the office (not just in the operatories) on a regular basis, air purifiers, disinfection gadgets like UV light or disinfecting foggers may be employed.
If you are concerned about going to your dentist, please call them to discuss it. Some patients who are at a higher risk of infection – immunocompromised patients, elderly individuals, and those with other underlying medical conditions – might be advised to postpone any elective, non-emergency dental care. Sure, it’s important to have a sparkly smile, but if someone has an increased risk of illness, maybe that six month recall appointment can wait.
The future
        ◦ No one knows what the future holds. Will there be a second (or third) wave? Will we be able to resume our normal activities in the near future? When will an effective vaccine be available? Your guess is as good as mine and no one has a crystal ball. What I do know is that the dental profession is committed to keeping you, our valued patients, safe and healthy. I know that sounds like an infomercial, but it’s true. Guidelines and recommendations are being updated continuously and dentists are unified in their desire to adhere to the safest practices in these unprecedented times.

COVID-19 and Tooth Loss
Reports that teeth are spontaneously falling out after COVID-19 recovery are surfacing. Is tooth loss yet another complication of this disease?
Grant Ritchey on December 11, 2020
Link

We are in unprecedented times. Still. This pandemic is wearing on all of us, and we yearn to return to precedented times. As we learn more about this disease – its effects and aftereffects – it is becoming clear that COVID-19 is much more than just a respiratory illness. This has been covered (and will continue to be covered) here on Science Based Medicine and elsewhere, but suffice it to say that it seems that every day we are hearing about another manifestation of this illness.
Until recently, most of us in the dental field have not had to contend with any overt effects of COVID-19 other than desperately hoping that our inadequate PPE protects us from the potentially infectious spit that is flying all around us every day. Lately, however, there have been growing reports of dental issues that are being attributed to what is now being called “Post-Acute COVID-19 Syndrome (PACS)”, symptoms that linger long after the acute phase of the illness has resolved. In the lay public, people with PACS are called “long haulers” and their symptoms usually include persistent loss of taste and smell, fatigue, shortness of breath, sleep disorders, impaired memory and cognition (“brain fog”), and others. The incidence, natural history, and etiology of these symptoms is currently unknown. Emerging research has also proposed mechanisms by which oral health can directly or indirectly influence the transmission of the coronavirus and the severity of COVID-19.
Early in the pandemic, the dental community focused on how closures of dental offices would affect oral health. Initially, we feared that people missing their cleanings and examinations, small dental problems becoming larger ones, and other concerns would occur, and once dental offices re-opened, we attempted to reassure the public that it was safe to visit their dentist. Then, in June 2020, papers in the British Dental Journal and Medical Hypotheses floated the hypothesis that periodontal (gum) disease could be linked to the severity of COVID-19. Of course, correlation does not equal causation, but it has been shown that oral pathogens can cause respiratory illnesses – particularly aspiration pneumonia – and thus could explain a causative relationship between the two. Possible mechanisms of action include direct aspiration of oral pathogens into the lungs, periodontal disease-associated enzymes in saliva modifying oral mucosal surfaces to promote adhesion and colonization by respiratory pathogens which are then aspirated into the lungs, and inflammatory related cytokines could alter respiratory epithelium to promote infection by respiratory pathogens. Whether these observed phenomena can be extrapolated to SARS-CoV-2 infection remains to be seen. But now the dental milieu was more directly implicated in COVID-19. Of course, it could be that people who are at risk for COVID-19 (age, health, lifestyle and habits, and other co-morbidities) are also the same risk factors for periodontal disease, so that muddies the waters a bit.
The fallout
In early November, I saw a tweet from a woman who stated that her 12 year old son’s tooth fell out suddenly and without warning after having COVID-19 several months prior. This got my attention because it is extremely rare for a permanent tooth to loosen and exfoliate in a person of that age, except in instances of trauma. Other possible causes, such as Juvenile Periodontitis, can occur, but the presentation is different than this one. In this case, it was claimed that the tooth fell out painlessly and bloodlessly. This story was picked up in The New York Times, Huffington Post, and other media outlets and before long, other people were relating their COVID-related tooth loss stories on social media. Many dental problems were blamed upon the viral infection, including tooth loss, tooth mobility, increased incidence of tooth decay, discoloration of teeth, and chipped teeth, among others. Could this be yet another post-COVID complication?
As we here at Science Based Medicine frequently preach, before one can ask if something happened, one must first ask could it happen. Yes we must be open to all possibilities, but in any science-based investigation, we must ask ourselves if something is plausible before we can even entertain the idea of whether something actually occurred as reported. With this tenet as my lodestone, my first reaction when I heard about sudden tooth loss in otherwise healthy individuals was to summarily dismiss it as yet another overblown, hyperbolic misinterpretation of reality. After all, teeth don’t just fall out in otherwise healthy individuals, especially in young people. Preposterous! However, another tenet in science base inquiry which must be respected is the null hypothesis. There are many definitions of the null hypothesis, depending on how it’s used, but at its essence it can be boiled down to “start from scratch, assume nothing, and build a case from there”. In other words in the context of our scenario, begin by assuming that there is no correlation between reported dental issues and past or current SARS-CoV-2 infection and seek out good evidence. So I endeavored to do just that, hoping to either confirm or refute the claims put forth by those whom I truly believe are being sincere. And as a science detective, I wish I could shed some light on this issue, but if I want to be intellectually honest, I can’t do that at this point in time.
Disappointing, I know, but bear with me.
What we know
The first thing I did was to do a literature search using scientific resources such as PubMed, the database at the Center for Evidence Based Dentistry at the American Dental Association, Google Scholar, and others. Unfortunately, there is no literature that documents the cases being shared on social media and in the lay press as of this writing. Perhaps this is because there isn’t a true connection, but it could also mean that the science hasn’t yet caught up with the observed phenomena. After all, this is a novel virus, and we are just scratching the surface in our understanding of how it affects us all.
The second thing I did was to look for precedence with other viral infections as it relates to tooth loss. Infections of all types share many common features and presentations, so it is plausible that if other viral infections have caused similar dental problems as was claimed with the coronavirus, then it wouldn’t be unreasonable to extrapolate them to the current situation. Unfortunately, there was very little in the literature to suggest that this had historical precedence. The closest thing I could find was a case report study regarding a purported link between trigeminal herpes zoster (shingles) and spontaneous tooth exfoliation. Sadly, the authors obviously have little to no knowledge about periodontal disease, as the case reports given show profound ignorance of the etiology and progression of periodontal disease, and in no way do the reports support the conclusions they draw from the study. Despite their claims to the contrary, the case reports show evidence of massive pre-existing periodontal destruction, and the tooth loss they document is what would be expected in the natural course of the disease, not as a result of a viral infection.
Since there was no hard evidence in the literature about rapid, spontaneous tooth loss due to COVID-19 (or any other viral or bacterial diseases), the third thing I did was to grasp for possible mechanisms of action for this to happen. Again, I was disappointed. There are some tantalizing islands of data that, if you squint hard enough, could be construed as possible explanations for COVID-induced tooth loss, but they are merely suggestive of a connection, not definitive. For example, it is recognized that SARS-CoV-2 binds to ACE2 receptors in the body. One study demonstrated that the mouth, especially the tongue, contains a high number of ACE2 receptors, which could provide a rich environment for the coronavirus to take hold. In another speculative paper, it was hypothesized the periodontal pocket (the gum crevice that surrounds each tooth and which bleeds when you floss the night before your dental checkup) could be a reservoir for the virus, a safe harbor where SARS-CoV-2 could find its biological niche, lie low, and attack when the time was right. These two studies are necessary to explain a possible role in tooth loss, but they aren’t sufficient to do so. There are still a lot of dots to connect, a lot of data to be collected, a lot of missing pieces to the puzzle before any definitive correlation between PACS and dental problems can be acknowledged. Yes, we are learning that the coronavirus can affect the vascular system. Yes, we are learning that there can be neurological side effects post-COVID-19. And yes, our teeth and surrounding tissues have both vascular and neurological components. That still doesn’t give us enough confidence to say that Post-Acute COVID-19 Syndrome can cause tooth loss. That’s not how teeth work.
Conclusion: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I regret to inform you, dear readers, that this post has generated more heat than light. I accepted this assignment hoping that the research would be more definitive in its conclusions, that we could either confirm that dental issues are yet another set of problems that COVID victims would have to deal with or write it all off as the far-fetched claims of a handful of cranks seeking likes and follows on social media.
Sadly, we can do neither.
If we can draw any conclusions at this point, we can determine that either tooth loss is a part of PACS and the science just hasn’t caught up with it yet, or that what has been reported is a coincidental or misdiagnosed issue. Only time will tell.
What is lacking in every case I’ve seen posted online in Facebook groups and other social media outlets is any sort of legitimate documentation – no before and after radiographs, no dental charting, and no reports from dentists themselves. There have been no clinicians or researchers from universities or dental associations who have stepped up to suggest that this is a legitimate aftereffect of the illness. In order for researchers to seriously study this phenomenon, we need more systematic and thorough documentation and study. Until then, these isolated cases – anecdotes – have to be taken with a grain of salt. We have no reason to doubt the sincerity of people making claims of dental destruction following recovery from COVID, but until this is confirmed scientifically, we must remain skeptical yet open-minded.

Yes. I Remember it Well. A COVID 45 Retrospective
With faltering memory, questionable opinions, and sketchy references, an infectious disease revenant reflects on the last 2.5 years of COVID 45. Grizzly bear assault free. As in no assault, not the price of a Grizzly bear assault.
Mark Crislip on May 19, 2022
Link

We met at nineWe met at eightI was on timeNo, you were lateAh yes, I remember it well.We dined with friendsWe dined alone.A tenor sangA baritone.I remember it well.– I Remember It Well. Maurice Chevalier & Hermione Gingold
A classic demonstration of how my memory works at 65. Although Thank Heaven for Little Girls, from the same movie, Gigi, has become more than a little…creepy.
Hey. Remember me? For those of you who are newish to SBM, I was a twice-a-month blogger for a decade here until I ran out of steam in 2017. For you older readers: surprise. I discovered Antidote. Any errors in the blog? Well, to err is human, to really screw up takes a computer.
Dr. Gorski recently asked if I would be interested in an entry covering something related to COVID 45. I thought of saying no and let the rest of the entry be blank, but that would not work as, obviously, I said yes. For those who are unaware of my bona fides, I am an Infectious Disease doctor, on my 36th, and last, year of practice.
This post covers my memories and opinions from the last 2.5 years of COVID 45. As my wife would let you know, my opinions are as reliable as my memories, so take what follows with a grain of Dash.
Is it too soon for a COVID 45 retrospective? Perhaps. I suspect COVID is going nowhere in my lifetime, as the current, likely undercounted, surge indicates. But there are two endpoints that could mark the end of the COVID pandemic. One is that the infection goes away. Never gonna happen. The other is when as a society we transition back to normal and at some level decide to live with COVID. I marked that point when the US resumed mass killings. Sadly, back to business as usual.
I do not see why COVID would vanish. One, its genetic plasticity is remarkable. So many mutations acquired so rapidly. I can’t think of a virus that has been as effective as COVID at spitting out genetically divergent progeny. HIV was close. I have it in my brain, but can’t find the reference, that HIV, being like humans a sloppy reproducer, undergoes one mutation at every base pair during each replication in just one T cell. That is a lot of mutations, since during active disease, millions of T cells are infected. COVID seems to right up there.
And more spooky is Omicron, which came out of left field. While there was a genetic progression from the initial strain through Delta, Omicron came into the world like Venus, fully formed and with “…more than 50 mutations when compared with the original SARS-CoV-2 virus isolated in Wuhan, China”.
Omicron’s origin is still a mystery, so who knows what other coronavirus is hiding in humans or animals, mutating away, waiting to jump into the general population. Just like influenza.
It is impressive how the R0, the number of people that a single infected person can be expected to infect, goes up with each variant. I suspect the increasing infectivity, but not virulence, is a result of our half-assed approach to COVID infection control. With semi-masking, semi-social distancing, and semi-vaccination, we have probably been selecting for more infectious strains of COVID. That has likely been the case with HIV. In the old days, when patients would report hundreds or even thousands of contacts, it was easy for HIV to get transmitted. With safer sex, only the more infectious, and likely more virulent, HIV gets through. COVID has gone from an R0 of 1.5 to 7 or more. This ain’t no measles, this ain’t no pertussis, but this ain’t no fooling around. Influenza, in comparison runs an R0 slightly less than 2. Infectious diseases have always been evolution in action, and evolution in COVID is scary quick. That also raises the question: rather than half-assed COVID infection control, should we strive for no-assed or full-assed COVID infection control? The internet is silent on the topic.
The other reason COVID is going nowhere is the relative lack of immunity after vaccination and disease. The vaccine is still great for preventing severe illness and death, both good endpoints, but with emerging variants partially evading prior immunity and large, in both numbers and BMI, populations of unvaccinated people, this virus will continue to circulate forever. Omicron seems particularly good at causing reinfection.
Unless COVID pulls an English Sweating Illness and just disappears:
Sweating sickness had disappeared by late Elizabethan times. Its reign of terror barely lasted a century.
I would not hold my breath. Although not inhaling is one way to avoid COVID. Clinton may have been on to something.
The concept of herd immunity was always a chimera. There is no such thing as natural herd immunity. There is no population where everyone is simultaneously infected and the herd becomes immune. And even if everyone were to be infected all at once, susceptible populations would keep being born. Herd immunity can only happen when an entire population, preferably the world as in smallpox, is vaccinated. You and I know that isn’t going to happen in the remaining lifetime of the human species.
COVID looks to be a perfect storm for perpetual disease: genetic variation, marginal immunity, half-assed infection control, and a susceptible population. Like what we have seen for the at least 500 years with influenza. As the French say, Plus c’est la même chose plus c’est la même chose.
Good news. Heat kills COVID, with 99.9% of the virus killed at 104 F. So COVID will likely disappear from Phoenix and parts of India in the near future. Or mutate to become heat tolerant. I always look on the bright side of life.
I thought at the start of the epidemic we would have a 1.5 million dead in the US. I thought 1.5 million, while appalling, wasn’t too bad given I had spent most of my career fretting about a recurrence of a 1919 influenza pandemic with a 5% mortality rate, or flying spaghetti monster forbid, a bird flu variant, which if it maintained virulence, could kill 2/3 of the infected. Not yet. But maybe one day. See “look on bright side” note above.
Thanks to the vaccines, we will eventually get to 1.5 million dead albeit slower than I anticipated. The mRNA technology is amazing and the speed with which they developed a safe and effective vaccine still boggles my mind. It is a technology that I think would allow for the rapid development of vaccines to a wide variety of pathogens that we could then refuse to take.
From what I can tell, there is no Omicron-specific vaccine as, at least in animal models, it adds nothing to the standard three shots. I don’t know. I would still think that, like flu, the more the vaccine matches the circulating strain, the more benefit, depending on your endpoint; preventing disease, spread, hospitalization or death. If the past is prologue, matching the vaccine to the virus should be a good thing. But, as noted above, Omicron may be an exception.
But I, for one, am a little tired of the death. I started in ID 1986, right when HIV as taking off. Remember, association is not causation. The first decade or so of practice was spent watching a seemingly endless number of young men die. No one cared. Or few did. I think it was Randy Shilts who said something to the effect that if AIDS had killed young, freckle-faced children, people would care more about the cause and treatment of AIDS.
Wrong.
What the COVID 45 has really brought home is large swaths of Americans don’t give a rat’s ass about anyone else, a county of Marie Antoinettes. Engage in behaviors that would slow the spread of a fatal disease? Qu’ils mangent du COVID.
Like all ID docs, I prefer prevention over treatment, and preventing, or at least decreasing, the spread of COVID is simple. Mask and vaccine.
Masks prevent spread of COVID. Vaccines prevent spread of COVID. Not perfectly. But as you learn in a lifetime of infection control, there is no one intervention that stops the spread of infection. Prevention requires the sum of many imperfect interventions.
I find neither masking nor getting vaccination that big a deal and, unlike so many of my fellow citizens’, I like knowing I am not going to sicken and kill others. I cannot wrap my head around the idea that so many feel otherwise. Until, of course, it comes back to bite them. Death bed conversions are a little too late, although not uncommon.
And really, most people look better with a mask on. Everyone looks good from the eyes up. Ugly, and beauty, reside under the mask. Someone I have known only during COVID takes of their mask to eat and I think whoa. For aesthetic reasons, masks should be permanent. Who wants to see my robust forest of elderly nose hairs? Or am I oversharing?
The six-foot rule? I never bought into that one. In the hospital, where the infected patient is spewing infected droplets while lying in bed not moving in a room with hospital air handling, six feet of distance to prevent droplet spread is reasonable. The patient isn’t going anywhere and the air is being turned over rapidly. Air handling was likely why I did not get COVID in the early months of the pandemic when we were short on proper personal protective equipment (PPE).
In the real world? I think of people like Pig Pen, always in a haze of potential pathogens. In crowds you are always moving in and out of each others Pig Pen pathogen cloud. It is also clear the air circulation can move infectious virus aerosols farther than 6 feet, adding yet another reason to avoid being downwind of some people.
I think population density in a room that is more important than distancing, and then just because there are likely to be fewer infected people in the room. I still shop at off hours and wear a mask when I am in the store. We eat out at off hours as well, although I see no point in wearing a mask at the pub. What is 5 minutes of mask wearing going to prevent during a 60-minute maskless meal? Besides, it is well known that hops, barley, and alcohol are potent antimicrobials using the XKCD method, much better than ingesting bleach.
I remember in the first months of the pandemic arguing with a radiologist who was emphatic that everyone should be wearing N95 masks and that it was obvious that COVD was spread by aerosols. I argued back that the CDC said otherwise, that COVID was spread by droplets. Much later (very much later as radiologists got to work at home while I was seeing COVID patients wearing less than optimal PPE) I went back to radiologist and ate crow. That was painful and I am still a bit bitter at the CDC.
For years, I saw people at the airport, often arriving from Asia, wearing masks. I always wondered if masking was beneficial. It is. Not only has influenza vanished with masking but so did most respiratory infections. From the epidemiology so far, masks should be de rigueur during URI season. That’s not gonna happen either.
The unusual aspect of COVID disease and death is just how slow progression is. Most patients are admitted around day 8 and if they die, it is weeks into their illness. COVID is a disease that maximizes suffering for both patients and their family. Slow suffocation alone in the ICU. An awful way to go.
The slow course of the disease is also why interventions directed at the virus seem to do so little. As a clinician, I can’t tell that remdesiver, or any treatment, is doing all that much.
And here is a secret when wondering if a drug is going to help treat an acute viral infection: Ask two questions. One, is the drug given in the first two or three days of illness? Two. Does it interfere with a specific biochemical pathway important in viral reproduction? If the answer to either is no, then don’t expect the azithromycin or hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin to do squat. You know ahead of time drugs that do not meet both those criteria will do nothing. That’s how the world works.
I was surprised how effective immunomodulation was for COVID. Acute COVID serum didn’t work, likely because most patients received the serum too late in their course and when their own antibody response was kicking in. And, unfortunately, giving serum did not produce any super soldiers. But steroids and other immunomodulators are effective in treating the late inflammatory phase of COVID and that surprised me. Immumomodulation has a dismal treatment record for most infectious disease, it was nice to see it work.
We were lucky in Portland, the hospitals were bursting at the seams with COVID but was not as bad a New York or other places where admissions overwhelmed the resources. Close, but no cigar.
Still, COVID reinforced the understanding that the US healthcare “system” is a Frankenstein’s monster with the brain of Abby Normal. Delivering healthcare is usually an irrational pain, COVID made it all that worse. I just wish we had a single payer. Then, instead of being screwed up in a thousand different ways, healthcare would be screwed up in just one way. It was amazing just how FUBAR so much of the response has been. But then, lies and denial are a poor basis for tackling pandemics or wars.
Long COVID is interesting, and, upon reflection, is not a surprise. The virus binds to the ubiquitous ACE2 receptor so COVID has plenty of opportunity to damage a variety of organs and tissues. Identifying the cause of long COVID is a work in progress, but there are some explanations that I find more compelling than others. For example, I find the idea that CFS might be a form of human hibernation interesting. It fits CFS patients, who do seem to be hibernating with spring never arriving. I like the idea that long COVID is due to vagus nerve damage. It explains the symptom complex and perhaps explains why it persists. The nervous system is not particularly good at healing.
My biggest conclusion from the last 2.5 years?
Understanding reality is critical. Too many people prefer to ignore reality, with millions sick and dead as a result. The response to COVID prevention was relatively simple. COVID is relatively easy to combat. Many, however, chose not to participate both in reality and COVID prevention and treatment.
The behavioral changes required to combat climate change and our hot future are far more difficult and expensive than what was needed for COVID. No way are we going to step up the plate in time; we can’t be bothered with reality.
We are so doomed.
On that cheery note, it is nice to be back.

A New Covid-19 Myth?
A correspondent suggested I should have known that the pandemic was over months ago. That’s obviously a myth. But where did that idea come from?
Harriet Hall on June 29, 2021
Link

Everything I have been reading indicates that the pandemic is far from over. Around the world, people are still testing positive, being hospitalized, and dying. It is not as deadly as the 1918 flu epidemic, which has been estimated to have killed between 17 and 100 million people. So far COVID-19 has killed 3,918,958 worldwide: 618,694 in the US, 393,508 in India, 509,282 in Brazil, 232,068 in Mexico, 191,286 in Peru, and so on.
In the introduction to my monthly SkepDoc newsletter for June, I mentioned that bad news along with this good news: “Pandemic death rates are declining. On June 13, there were 105 new deaths confirmed in the U.S. compared to 6,000 deaths per day a year ago.” In response, I got a surprising email saying the pandemic has been over for months, and suggesting I would have known that had my MD degree not been “from Walgreen’s U”. I was flabbergasted. I wrote back and asked them to explain what they meant, but I didn’t get an answer.
The experts have been saying COVID-19 will probably never go away but will subside into an endemic infection similar to the current seasonal influenza. In areas where the numbers of cases and deaths have decreased, the success has been attributed to a combination of effective vaccines, masks, and restrictions. There are still many unanswered questions. The Delta variant is worrisome, but the vaccines are effective against it. Steven Novella wrote about this last week, saying “we have not won this race against the pandemic yet”. Will we need booster shots or annual vaccines? We don’t know yet.
David Gorski has been doing yeoman’s work to counter every bit of misinformation circulating about the virus and the vaccines, but I don’t recall him ever mentioning the myth that the pandemic has been over for months. I tried to find the source of that myth but I wasn’t successful. Where did that idea come from? I find it hard to believe that my correspondent thought it up independently; I’m guessing they were repeating something they had heard or read. Since many of our readers are more knowledgeable than I and more adept at searching the internet and social media, I thought I would throw it out there and see what others could find.
Conclusion: No, the pandemic has not been over for months
My correspondent was obviously wrong, but I’m intrigued to know where that wrong idea might have come from.

I Won’t Stop Talking About COVID Until You Stop Talking About COVID
What better way is there for me to convey to others that they should stop talking about COVID than for me to talk about it constantly?
Jonathan Howard on February 26, 2022
Link

Dr. Zubin Damania, AKA ZDoggMD, recently said,
We need to stop every single pandemic restriction, including vaccine mandates including mask mandates, including kids wearing masks, including thinking about it, including hearing about it on the news. All of it, I want it gone.
Amen. I too am over COVID. You urgently need to get back to normal. Everyone except for me needs to stop talking about COVID. The only voice I want to hear discussing COVID is my own voice.
And my voice will be heard ceaselessly. I must convince you things are perfectly normal. I will give numerous TV interviews on the virus, and my many podcasts, articles, and social media posts will be devoted to COVID. What better way is there for me to convince other people they should stop talking about COVID than for me to talk about it incessantly?
None of this is new for me. In contrast to doctors who actually treat COVID patients, those of us who value nuance and centrism have been saying the pandemic has been over for a year now.
While others panicked, I laughed along with Drs. Damania and Monica Gandhi about “variants, shmariants” in a podcast called “The End of the Pandemic” from February 2021. They rightly warned then not about the virus, but about a “contagion of panic and fear”. Sadly, they’ve had to spend the past year continuously discussing COVID, reminding everyone the pandemic ended last year.
I agreed with Dr. Lucy McBride who wrote an article in March 2021 called “I’ve Been Yearning for an End to the Pandemic. Now That it’s Here, I’m a Little Afraid“. In that article, Dr. McBride coined the term “Fear of Normal” to describe people who just weren’t ready for the pandemic to end. Sadly, FONO is still a big problem today, though the virus is not. If you or someone you love is suffering from FONO, please watch one of Dr. McBride’s numerous TV appearances, which are devoted exclusively to the pandemic, which she said ended a year ago.
I also agreed with Dr. Jay Bhattacharya who said in September 2021, “The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.” As is appropriate, Dr. Bhattacharya discusses no disease other than COVID.
More recently, viral immunologist Dr. Scott Balsitis, a founder of the “Urgency of Normal” campaign, said, “We believe the data point to restoring full normalcy for children. We really mean the full normal.” His Twitter feed is devoted to nothing but COVID, which is normal.
These wise people all recognize that it makes a lot of sense to constantly talk about something once it’s finished. It wasn’t easy in 2021 to listen to other people drone on and on about the pandemic, as I declared it over, over and over again. However, I’m prepared to spend the rest of this year talking about COVID and only COVID to convince everyone else they should stop talking about it.
I won’t stop talking about COVID until you stop talking about COVID.
This isn’t just normal. It’s full normal.

In the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, can we trust the CDC and FDA any more?
Since the COVID-19 pandemic reached the US, increasing concern has been expressed about the politicization of the CDC and FDA due to pressure from the Trump administration to downplay the severity of the pandemic and push out treatments and a vaccine as fast as possible, potentially at the expense of safety. This has led me to a disturbing question: Can I trust the CDC and FDA any more?
David Gorski on September 14, 2020
Link

I’ve said it many times before, but now seems as good a time as any to say it again. This blog is not, nor has it ever been, apolitical. It is, however, true that we do try to be as nonpartisan as we can be given that we are human beings, but we cannot be completely apolitical because medicine inherently has a political dimension. That is why it has been the editorial position of this blog since Steve Novella first announced it nearly 13 years ago that science-based medicine, for all its flaws, is still currently the most reliable method for determining which treatments and interventions work for various diseases and health conditions and which ones do not. Moreover, when it comes to issues like FDA regulation of supplements and homeopathy, the failure of states and the federal government to protect, for example, cancer patients from quacks like Stanislaw Burzynski, tightening of school vaccine mandates, state licensure of pseudoscientific “disciplines” like naturopathy, and, more recently, regulation impacting dubious and false medical claims about COVID-19, we certainly haven’t been shy in advocating the use of SBM to guide policy.
Now that we’re around the six month anniversary of the first lockdowns to combat the COVID-19 pandemic, I saw a story over the weekend that led me, at the risk of being too “political”, to ask a very disturbing (to me) question: Can we still trust the CDC and FDA (and other federal agencies, like the NIH, ostensibly dedicated to upholding policy based on good science)? Although the answer is still yes for most topics, for COVID-19 increasingly the answer is no. I fear that the list of topics on which the CDC and FDA can no longer be trusted will only grow if Donald Trump is reelected and that, even if he isn’t, some of the changes weakening the firewall between political appointees and the career scientific personnel of these agencies might be permanent and difficult for a President Biden to reverse. Let me explain.
Efforts to muzzle the CDC
My impression that the FDA and CDC have been co-opted by the Trump administration is one that’s been growing for a long time, ever since Trump’s inauguration, in fact, but the story that tweaked me to write this post appeared in Politico on Friday about efforts by officials in the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to water down a Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Reports (MMWR), the weekly publication of the CDC that has served as a science-based source for the agency to inform health care professionals, scientists, and the public about health topics ranging from vaccines to infectious disease to just about everything. Indeed, as mentioned in the story, one prominent example of how important MMWR has been was this June 1981 MMWR report describing five cases of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia in five young homosexual men in Los Angeles that concluded that the “above observations suggest the possibility of a cellular-immune dysfunction related to a common exposure that predisposes individuals to opportunistic infections such as pneumocystosis and candidiasis. Although the role of CMV infection in the pathogenesis of pneumocystosis remains unknown, the possibility of P. carinii infection must be carefully considered in a differential diagnosis for previously healthy homosexual males with dyspnea and pneumonia.” This report was one of the early signals that revealed the AIDS epidemic.
This isn’t the first time the Trump administration has meddled in the CDC, but this time it seems different. According to Politico:
The health department’s politically appointed communications aides have demanded the right to review and seek changes to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s weekly scientific reports charting the progress of the coronavirus pandemic, in what officials characterized as an attempt to intimidate the reports’ authors and water down their communications to health professionals.
In some cases, emails from communications aides to CDC Director Robert Redfield and other senior officials openly complained that the agency’s reports would undermine President Donald Trump’s optimistic messages about the outbreak, according to emails reviewed by POLITICO and three people familiar with the situation.
CDC officials have fought back against the most sweeping changes, but have increasingly agreed to allow the political officials to review the reports and, in a few cases, compromised on the wording, according to three people familiar with the exchanges. The communications aides’ efforts to change the language in the CDC’s reports have been constant across the summer and continued as recently as Friday afternoon.
It’s hard to overstate how disturbing this story has been to professionals trying to safeguard public health. The MMWR is a CDC publication compiled by CDC career scientists that is released week after week, usually with little or no fanfare (although certainly MMWR reports occasionally make the news, as has happened multiple times during measles outbreaks) and no interference from political appointees.
Political interference in the activities of the CDC is, of course, not unprecedented. There was political interference during the 1980s as the AIDS epidemic first blossomed, as well as during the 1990s, when Congress passed the Dickey Amendment, putting up a huge funding roadblock to the study of gun violence by the CDC and NIH. This is unsurprising history. Although the CDC, FDA, and National Institutes of Health (NIH) were meant to be as apolitical and science-based as possible, they are creations of the federal government. All of them are part of HHS, a cabinet-level department overseen by a political appointee, right now Alex Azar and earlier in the Trump Administration Tom Price. The budgets and laws creating and dictating what these agencies can and cannot do are written and passed by Congress. Some interjection of politics from the White House, Congress, and the HHS Director is inevitable, but there are statutory and regulatory roadblocks designed to insulate these agencies from political interference and, for the most part, they are largely effective, at least against gross meddling. What’s happening now, though, goes beyond the sorts of political interference we’ve seen before over the last 50 years. I certainly can’t recall ever having seen an account of direct interference in the activities of the CDC by the Executive Branch this blatant:
But since Michael Caputo, a former Trump campaign official with no medical or scientific background, was installed in April as the Health and Human Services department’s new spokesperson, there have been substantial efforts to align the reports with Trump’s statements, including the president’s claims that fears about the outbreak are overstated, or stop the reports altogether.
Caputo and his team have attempted to add caveats to the CDC’s findings, including an effort to retroactively change agency reports that they said wrongly inflated the risks of Covid-19 and should have made clear that Americans sickened by the virus may have been infected because of their own behavior, according to the individuals familiar with the situation and emails reviewed by POLITICO.
Caputo’s team also has tried to halt the release of some CDC reports, including delaying a report that addressed how doctors were prescribing hydroxychloroquine, the malaria drug favored by Trump as a coronavirus treatment despite scant evidence. The report, which was held for about a month after Caputo’s team raised questions about its authors’ political leanings, was finally published last week. It said that “the potential benefits of these drugs do not outweigh their risks.”
As I’ve written many times before, there was never particularly convincing scientific prior plausibility that hydroxychloroquine would be effective against COVID-19 and we have documented how the randomized controlled clinical trials of the drug have been resoundingly negative, which is why doctors have largely abandoned the drug as a potential promising treatment for coronavirus. Unfortunately, aided and abetted by President Trump himself (and Dr. Oz), there has been a major disinformation campaign promoting hydroxychloroquine as a miracle cure for COVID-19, an astroturf campaign that has at times gone to ridiculous lengths to sell the drug as effective. Similarly, there has been a concerted effort to portray SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, as not a big deal, as lethal only to the elderly and those with comorbid conditions.
According to Politico, the pressure was quite intense. For example, Paul Alexander, MSc, MHSc, PhD, Caputo’s scientific advisor, acted as Caputo’s hammer, as shown in this incident involving Caputo (who also accused the CDC on August 8 of attempting to use the reports to “hurt the President”) trying to get the CDC to retroactively alter MMWR issues that, he claimed, “wrongly” inflated the risks of coronavirus to children and thereby undermined Trump’s push to reopen schools:
Alexander also called on Redfield to halt all future MMWR reports until the agency modified its years-old publication process so he could personally review the entire report prior to publication, rather than a brief synopsis. Alexander, an assistant professor of health research at McMaster University near Toronto whom Caputo recruited this spring to be his scientific adviser, added that CDC needed to allow him to make line edits — and demanded an “immediate stop” to the reports in the meantime.
“The reports must be read by someone outside of CDC like myself, and we cannot allow the reporting to go on as it has been, for it is outrageous. Its lunacy,” Alexander told Redfield and other officials. “Nothing to go out unless I read and agree with the findings how they [sic] CDC, wrote it and I tweak it to ensure it is fair and balanced and ‘complete.'”
“Fair and balanced”? Who is Alexander, a Fox News pundit? It also doesn’t help that Caputo has said things like:
Caputo also said that HHS was appropriately reviewing the CDC’s reports. “Our intention is to make sure that evidence, science-based data drives policy through this pandemic—not ulterior deep state motives in the bowels of CDC,” he said.
What a jarring juxtaposition of a claim that “science-based data” will drive policy with a claim that he’s protecting science against “ulterior deep state motives” and what can only be correctly described as raving conspiracy theories! Let’s just put it this way. If you have to appeal to a conspiracy theory to justify your policy, you are not practicing science-based medicine or medical policy.
Conspiracy theories a-go-go
The conspiracy mongering coming from the administration as a justification for directly trying to control the public messaging of the CDC and FDA is even worse than that, though. The most amazingly weird example showed up this morning, when the news was full of stories like this about Alexander’s boss Caputo, who comes across as just shy of a QAnon believer. The accounts were so amazing that I had to do a quick revision of this post in order to include this new development. Don’t believe me when I say that Caputo is just shy of a QAnon believer? Then take a look what the stories published this morning are reporting:
A top communications official for the administration’s coronavirus response urged President Trump’s supporters to prepare for an armed insurrection after a contested election and accused government scientists of “sedition” in a Facebook Live chat that he described in detail to The Washington Post on Monday.
Michael Caputo, assistant secretary for public affairs at the Department of Health and Human Services, which is overseeing the coronavirus response, leveled the accusations and promoted other conspiracy theories in a Facebook Live event first reported by the New York Times. Caputo confirmed the authenticity of the video in comments he made to The Post.
Yes. you read that right. Caputo thinks the government scientists working for the CDC are seditious “deep state” operatives looking for any opportunity possible to take down President Trump, rather than career professionals, many of whom have served under Presidents of both parties, who are simply trying to do their job and communicate the current best scientific understanding of critical aspects of SARS-CoV-2 and the COVID-19 pandemic in order to guide policy. Under a normal administration, regardless of party, the President would listen to them, even if he ultimately didn’t heed their advice. He wouldn’t hire delusional conspiracy mongering sycophants, toadies, and lackeys like Michael Caputo to oversee them. I’m not saying that political interference in the CDC and FDA hasn’t occurred before. It’s just that I”m hard pressed to think of an example this blatant and disturbing, going back even to the emergence of the AIDS epidemic in the 1990s.
It gets even worse and more disturbing:
In the Facebook video, Caputo criticizes government career scientists, the media and Democrats, the Times reported and Caputo confirmed. He said he was under attack by the media and that his “mental health has definitely failed.”
Caputo also said the CDC, which is part of HHS, had a “resistance unit” that aimed to undermine Trump. Without offering any evidence, he also accused scientists “deep in the bowels of the CDC” of giving up on science and becoming “political animals.”
They “haven’t gotten out of their sweatpants except for meetings at coffee shops” to plot “how they’re going to attack Donald Trump next,” he said in the video. “There are scientists who work for this government who do not want America to get well, not until after Joe Biden is president.”
He also predicted that Trump would win the election but that Biden, the Democratic presidential nominee, would refuse to concede. “And when Donald Trump refuses to stand down at the inauguration, the shooting will begin,” he warned in the video. “The drills that you’ve seen are nothing. If you carry guns, buy ammunition, ladies and gentlemen, because it’s going to be hard to get.”
This is downright paranoid. It really is. The man in charge of messaging for the CDC and the government’s COVID-19 response is a raving conspiracy theorist who clearly has nothing contempt for scientists, given his sarcastic jibe about their not having “gotten out of their sweatpants except for meetings at coffee shops” to plot “how they’re going to attack” Trump next.
Open the schools at all costs!
Unfortunately, this is far from the only example of interference from Azar’s office and appointees in CDC messaging, although it is the most “out there.” An equally disturbing example that didn’t involve an HHS official ranting about conspiracy theories against Donald Trump occurred last month, when the CDC issued revised guidance on who should be tested for COVID-19, in which the CDC recommended not testing people who have no symptoms of the disease, even if they’ve been recently exposed to coronavirus, alarming health experts. After all, as we’ve discussed before, asymptomatic transmission is a major issue with this virus, which can contribute to “super-spreader” events when large numbers of people are together indoors. At the time, experts had nearly universally urged more, not less, testing for COVID-19, especially to reach vulnerable and marginalized sectors of the population, in order to halt the rapid spread of the virus, leading many public health scientists to react with alarm.
The Trump administration tried to deny that it had influenced the CDC to make this revision, but let’s just say that its denials were not…persuasive:
Adm. Brett P. Giroir, the administration’s coronavirus testing czar, called it a “C.D.C. action,” written with input from the agency’s director, Dr. Robert R. Redfield. But he acknowledged that the revision came after a vigorous debate among members of the White House coronavirus task force — including its newest member, Dr. Scott W. Atlas, a frequent Fox News guest and a special adviser to President Trump.
“We all signed off on it, the docs, before it ever got to a place where the political leadership would have, you know, even seen it, and this document was approved by the task force by consensus,” Dr. Giroir said. “There was no weight on the scales by the president or the vice president or Secretary Azar,” he added, referring to Alex M. Azar II, the secretary of health and human services.
Of course, who appointed Admiral Giroir and Dr. Atlas, the latter of whom was specifically recruited because, even though he’s a radiologist with no special expertise in infectious disease, his beliefs align with those of the administration when it comes to COVID-19? These people know what their bosses want and strive to provide it. The task force also threw Dr. Fauci under the bus, but then it came out later:
In a brief interview, Dr. Fauci said he had seen an early iteration of the guidelines and did not object. But the final debate over the revisions took place at a task force meeting on Thursday, when Dr. Fauci was having surgery under general anesthesia to remove a polyp on his vocal cord. In retrospect, he said, he now had “some concerns” about advising people against getting tested, because the virus could be spread through asymptomatic contact.
“My concern is that it will be misinterpreted,” Dr. Fauci said.
So great was the outcry over this obvious attempt to game the CDC’s testing guidelines, that it wasn’t long at all before the CDC walked back its new guideline, “clarifying” it by saying that it says “all close contacts of confirmed or probable COVID-19 patients” may consider testing.
Unfortunately, it’s not just the CDC. Alexander has reached beyond the CDC to try to muzzle Anthony Fauci:
Emails obtained by POLITICO show Paul Alexander — a senior adviser to Michael Caputo, HHS’s assistant secretary for public affairs — instructing press officers and others at the National Institutes of Health about what Fauci should say during media interviews. The Trump adviser weighed in on Fauci’s planned responses to outlets including Bloomberg News, BuzzFeed, Huffington Post and the science journal Cell.
Then there’s the FDA.
The FDA: Emergency use authorizations and “Operation Warp Speed”
My concern about the influence of the Trump administration on the FDA is nothing new. I’ve been writing about it since right after Trump won the 2016 election. Indeed, very early on I expressed concern that the new administration would move to fulfil a longtime right-wing goal of weakening the FDA’s regulatory authority over drug approval, a concern that became more acute not long after that when two of the finalists for the post of FDA Commissioner were cronies of libertarian Silicon Valley venture capitalist and founder of PayPal Peter Thiel, who holds the strong belief that government and the “progressive left” always impede scientific innovation with their cautiousness and lack of imagination.
The two finalists whose names were floated included Jim O’Neill, managing director of investment firm Mithril Capital Management, and Balaji Srinivasan, CEO of bitcoin start-up 21.co. O’Neill was notable for his prior proposal that the FDA give up vetting drugs for efficacy before they come to market. (He was also a free market fundamentalist into serious antiaging woo.) A direct quote:
“We should reform FDA so there is approving drugs after their sponsors have demonstrated safety — and let people start using them, at their own risk, but not much risk of safety,” O’Neill said in a speech at an August 2014 conference called Rejuvenation Biotechnology. “Let’s prove efficacy after they’ve been legalized.”
You get the idea.
Balaji Srinivasan was notable for his many utterances on Twitter attacking the FDA, which led him to hide his Twitter archive. Particularly disturbing was his idea that the FDA was not necessary to determine efficacy and safety when, according to him, the same could be done with online reviews, which some characterized as a “Yelp for drugs”. When asked, “But how do you prevent quacks?” Srinivasan’s answer was, “Scaled Internet reputation systems. Works at massive scale in other areas.” I explained in depth why this was an incredibly awful idea. Fortunately, it’s an idea that no FDA Commissioner could have implemented without first getting Congress to pass a law, given that the Kefauver-Harris Drug Amendments to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, passed in the wake of the thalidomide scandal, mandates that the FDA demonstrate safety and efficacy before approving drugs.
Ultimately, Trump chose the “least bad” of his three finalists, Scott Gottleib. Because of his extensive history in pharma and his holding positions on the boards of directors of multiple pharmaceutical companies, I referred to him at the time as an “honest-to-goodness real pharma shill”. At least he was a reasonably competent pharma shill, though. While he was definitely biased in favor of pharma, he wasn’t interested in radically restructuring the FDA in the sort of ways that O’Neill and Srinivasan might have been, which made me think that maybe O’Neill and Srinivasan were thrown in there to make Gottleib seem reasonable.
Over the last four years, I intermittently expressed concern over the effects of the administration’s general hostility to regulation and commitment of this administration to speeding up drug approval, potentially at the cost of safety, and the effects these efforts might be having on the FDA, as well as how “right-to-try” laws were passed to weaken the FDA under the guise of helping terminally ill patients. The same issue has come up with COVID-19, where the FDA has allowed the sale of dubious lab tests without FDA review in the name of “speed”.
More recently, I was very disturbed by two emergency use approvals issued by the FDA. The first occurred in March and was for—you guessed it!—hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19. I already discussed how that EUA had to be reversed because increasingly evidence didn’t support using the drug to treat coronavirus. The second was just a couple of weeks ago and was an EUA for convalescent plasma to treat COVID-19. As I discussed at the time, although the use of plasma from recovered COVID-19 patients has biological plausibility, there was as yet no good RCT evidence to support its use.
Disturbingly:
It was the third week of August, the Republican National Convention was days away, and President Trump was impatient.
White House officials were anxious to showcase a step forward in the battle against the coronavirus: an expansion of the use of blood plasma from recovered patients to treat new ones. For nearly two weeks, however, the National Institutes of Health had held up emergency authorization for the treatment, citing lingering concerns over its effectiveness.
So on Wednesday, Aug. 19, Mr. Trump called Dr. Francis S. Collins, the director of the NIH, with a blunt message.
“Get it done by Friday,” he demanded.
It wasn’t done by Friday, and on Sunday, regulators at the Food and Drug Administration still had not finished a last-minute data review intended to ease N.I.H. doubts.
But on Sunday night, the eve of the convention, the president announced, with the FDA’s approval, that plasma therapy would be available for wider use, and he declared that it could reduce deaths by 35 percent, vastly overstating what the data had shown about the benefits.
Yes, it’s that bad, which brings us to Operation Warp Speed. This is, of course, the name that the Trump administration used to describe its program to rush a COVID-19 vaccine to market. Of particular concern is the suggestion by current FDA Commissioner Stephen Hahn (Dr. Gottleib left the FDA a year and a half ago) that a COVID-19 vaccine could be released under an EUA before phase 3 clinical trials are complete. While such a suggestion is not completely unreasonable if the bar is very high (for instance, the difference between the group receiving an experimental COVID-19 vaccine and the placebo control group is so great that the institutional review board overseeing the study decides that continuing to sign up subjects for the placebo group would be unethical), unsurprisingly, many doctors and scientists, including myself, are wary.
For instance:
Doctors have worried that just before Election Day, President Trump might pressure the FDA to approve a coronavirus vaccine before it’s ready as an “October surprise” to gain votes.
“This just cannot be allowed to happen,” Dr. Francis Collins told CNN this month.
He said if FDA’s Hahn approves a vaccine based on flimsy evidence, “he’s got a lot of people he’d have to answer to.”
Collins said he’d be one of those people, and so would Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergies and Infectious Diseases and a member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force.
Collins said he, Fauci, and others would “certainly make a big noise about not supporting [the vaccine]” if the FDA were to approve it prematurely, adding that the vaccine cannot be approved “on the basis of anything other than science.”
As I’ve said before, vaccines are different from therapeutics in that they are administered to huge numbers of people, in the case of a COVID-19 vaccine hundreds of millions to, eventually, billions. The standards for vaccines are very different from those for drugs in terms of safety in that the standard for vaccines is much higher. It has to be, because, in contrast to drugs, which are administered to treat disease, vaccines are administered to huge numbers of people without disease in order to prevent disease. The tolerance for adverse reactions in a vaccine is therefore much lower than it is for drugs, particularly drugs for serious illnesses. What that means is that even a phase 3 clinical trial is only the beginning of safety monitoring. As I’ve described many times before, we have multiple postmarketing safety monitoring systems for vaccines, including one passive (Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System, or VAERS) and three active surveillance systems: the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), the Post-licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring System (PRISM), and the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment (CISA) Project. That doesn’t mean using an EUA to authorize the use of a COVID-19 vaccine might not be reasonable under certain circumstances. It’s also true that it is not unreasonable not to trust the current FDA leadership to make a science- and ethics-based decision in the face of unrelenting pressure from the White House.
Even pharma is doubtful
So unusual is the pressure for a vaccine coming from this administration that even big pharma is pushing back, with nine drug companies, three of which have COVID-19 vaccines nearing completion of their phase 3 trials, signed a joint pledge:
Nine pharmaceutical companies issued a joint pledge on Tuesday that they would “stand with science” and not put forward a vaccine until it had been thoroughly vetted for safety and efficacy.
The companies did not rule out seeking an emergency authorization of their vaccines, but promised that any potential coronavirus vaccine would be decided based on “large, high quality clinical trials” and that the companies would follow guidance from regulatory agencies like the Food and Drug Administration.
“We believe this pledge will help ensure public confidence in the rigorous scientific and regulatory process by which Covid-19 vaccines are evaluated and may ultimately be approved,” the companies said.
And:
Federal officials have been pushing back against Mr. Trump’s enthusiastic predictions. Late last week, Moncef Slaoui, the top scientist on Operation Warp Speed, the federal effort to quickly bring a vaccine to market, warned in an interview with National Public Radio that the chance of successful vaccine results by October was “very, very low.”
And on Tuesday, Dr. Anthony S. Fauci, the nation’s top infectious disease expert, said he believed that researchers would know whether the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines were effective by “November or December.”
This is actually good business and science as well as good PR. First, although beating all previous records for speed in developing a vaccine to make one for COVID-19 would be good for the reputation of pharma, equally true is that using an EUA to release a vaccine prematurely that ends up causing serious side effects could result in catastrophic damages to the reputation of any company that takes advantage of an EUA if the evidence isn’t good enough. As for business, any vaccine approved under an EUA could make it dramatically more difficult for other drug companies, whose candidate vaccines not as far along in development might actually be safer and/or more efficacious, to get their vaccines approved. Why? Once a vaccine is issued an EUA, the ethics of continuing a placebo control group in other ongoing vaccine trials becomes problematic, as the EUA would result in a de facto standard of care, and clinical trials cannot ethically deliver care that is below the standard of care. It would thus become arguably unethical to continue to use a placebo control in clinical trials, meaning that the trials might have to be altered to compare the new vaccines versus the vaccine with the EUA. This would make it difficult to tell which vaccines are the safest and most efficacious.
Can we trust the FDA and CDC any more?
Regular readers know that I’ve long supported the CDC and FDA as the two federal agencies most aligned with science-based medical care. True, they aren’t perfect, and we at SBM have criticized them many times over the last 13 years when we thought they were falling short. We’ve also criticized the laws governing the FDA’s regulation of dietary supplements and homeopathy. Before this year, my answer to the question “Can we trust the FDA and CDC?” would have been an emphatic yes, even after three years of the Trump administration. Can I still say this? I don’t know.
Why? If you want to get an idea of how significant that pressure is, a New York Times article from Saturday gives an idea:
With Election Day just over seven weeks away, Washington is witnessing the collision of two worlds: a community of largely anonymous government scientists and doctors who operate in a culture guided by research, data sets and peer review, and a president famously disdainful of science, politically wounded by his failures to contain the coronavirus and now determined to cast himself as moving as fast as possible to provide Americans with vaccines and treatments.
The EUAs for hydroxychloroquine and convalescent plasma are two examples. Operation Warp Speed is another. All contribute to the reasons why I now fear my answer to the question is: I don’t know any more, at least not when it comes to anything having to do with the COVID-19 pandemic. The agencies have been politicized in a way I’ve never seen before, and that damage will be difficult to undo, even if Donald Trump is not reelected. Worse, in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, we need more than ever a reliable FDA, CDC, and NIH, all strongly dedicated to science-based medical policy and resisting political pressure to deviate from science. I fear that, increasingly, we don’t have that anymore.

Frozen meat vs. COVID-19 misinformation: The strange case of Steak-umm
Of all the strange things that have happened during the COVID-19 pandemic, the rise of a frozen meat company as a source of critical thinking and skepticism regarding COVID-19 misinformation and disinformation is one of the strangest. How did Steak-umm become a champion of critical thinking about the pandemic?
David Gorski on November 16, 2020
Link
Since the COVID-19 pandemic hit the US close to nine months ago, a number of bizarre things that I never thought I’d see have happened. For example, I never thought I’d see a President of the United States promote unproven treatments for a deadly viral illness, as President Trump did with hydroxychloroquine. (Dr. Mehmet Oz and other medical grifters promoting unproven treatments, sure, but the President of the United States? Well, I guess I did forget momentarily who our President was.) Nor did I ever think I’d see a President say such incredibly stupid things about potential treatments for such a disease, including using light and disinfectants internally to fight the coronavirus. Don’t get me wrong, though. Given my background, certainly, I did expect there to be COVID-19 conspiracy theories and wasn’t particularly surprised to see the antivaccine movement team up so quickly with COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and cranks given their shared world view viewing the same groups as villains hiding “The Truth” from you—yes, you!—but even I was a bit taken aback at how vociferously antimask ideology became a thing even though masks do work to slow the spread of COVID-19.
Perhaps the strangest thing, though, that happened during the pandemic is the rise of the most unexpected source of reason, science, and information to fight disinformation. I’m referring to the Twitter feed of a frozen meat company called Steak-umm. To give you an idea what I mean, here’s the Twitter thread pinned to the top of Steak-umm’s Twitter profile:
friendly reminder in times of uncertainty and misinformation: anecdotes are not data. (good) data is carefully measured and collected information based on a range of subject-dependent factors, including, but not limited to, controlled variables, meta-analysis, and randomization
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
outliers attempting to counter global consensus around this pandemic with amateur reporting or unverified sourcing are not collecting data. breaking news stories that only relay initial findings of an event are not collecting data. we have to be careful in our media consumption
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
it can be difficult to know what to believe in a time when institutional trust is diminished and the gatekeepers of information have been dismantled, but it's more crucial now than ever before to follow a range of credentialed sources for both breaking news and data collection
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
all we currently have are limited and evolving metrics that experts are deciphering and acting upon immediately to the best of their ability. this terrain leaves many openings for opportunists and charismatic manipulators to lead people astray by exploiting what they want to hear
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
breaking news and storytelling will always be spun with interpretive bias from different media perspectives, but data is a science that can't be replaced by one-off anecdotes. try to remember this to avoid fear-based sensationalism or conspiracy theories taking over your mind
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
you can maintain independent, critical thinking toward institutions without dipping into fringe conspiracies that get jumpstarted by individual anecdotes being virally spread as data. it's not easy, but it's necessary to keep any semblance of responsible online information flow
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
we're a frozen meat brand posting ads inevitably made to misdirect people and generate sales, so this is peak irony, but hey we live in a society so please make informed decisions to the best of your ability and don't let anecdotes dictate your worldview ok
steak-umm bless
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
I love how whoever’s running the Steak-umm Twitter feed frequently concludes the company’s Tweets with “steak-umm bless”. In any event, notice the date on this Twitter thread: April 6, 2020. This was early in the pandemic. Notice how what Steak-umm is saying could easily be something found in a Science-Based Medicine post about how to evaluate medical information, science, and misinformation. Notice the incredible level of self-awareness in the Tweet pointing out how Steak-umm knows its Twitter feed’s purpose is to sell its product and its ads might misdirect to generate sales, while pivoting to urge people to “make informed decisions to the best of your ability and don’t let anecdotes dictate your worldview”.
Certainly, I didn’t fail to notice the irony of finding myself, as someone who’s dedicated much of his life and career to promoting science-based medicine (SBM) and combatting medical misinformation and disinformation, be it cancer quackery, fear mongering about genetically modified organisms, antivaccine pseudoscience, or other medical conspiracy theories, all while, when I deem it appropriate and imperative, also taking on the poor evidence base for a number of “conventional” medical treatments, helping to amplify the message promoted by a frozen meat company on its Twitter feed, just because the message jibes with the message I’m trying to promote. Oh, well, if this post helps Steak-umm sell more frozen meat, so be it. Even so, in the interests of full disclosure, several weeks ago Steak-umm sent me some Steak-umm swag (a hat, some coupons, a facemask) because of my interactions on Twitter, but that was only after many weeks of positive interactions and with the explicit statement that I was under no obligation to write about Steak-umm. No doubt some quack or antivaxxer will accuse me of being a shill for big frozen meat. Such is the strangeness of the times we live in.
Ever since I first noticed Steak-umm’s rather…unusual…approach to brand promotion through Tweeting messages encouraging skepticism and critical thinking, particularly about the hysteria and dubious claims being made about the COVID-19 pandemic, several months ago, I was always a bit curious about how the company’s social media arm decided on this approach and whether it was successful. Certainly, it struck me as successful from the standpoint of promoting critical thinking about COVID-19, but how could such an approach also be effective advertising? Sure, Steak-umm got lots of free publicity, and, sure, it now has nearly 170K Twitter followers, but how was it used to sell frozen meat? In other words, how did Steak-umm do well by doing good?
I can’t believe I missed this article the first time it came around, but Ekaterina Bogomoletc at North Carolina State University and Nicole Lee at Arizona State University looked at this question in an article in the Journal of Business and Technical Communication entitled “Frozen Meat Against COVID-19 Misinformation: An Analysis of Steak-Umm and Positive Expectancy Violations“. Reading the article also let me learn a bit about expectancy violation theory.
Basically, expectancy violation is a theory in communications that tries to explain the behavior of human beings while interacting. This article sums it up rather succinctly:
Expectancy violation theory emphasizes on an individual perception of the interaction in a particular situation. People while communicating will create an expectation of how the other will react. Violation to this expectation can cause to [sic] a perception that will be positive or negative. People behave differently according to the cultural values they grow up in and this influences the reaction of the people considerably.
Expectancy violation theory also is dependent on the personal space. The personal space is the boundary we keep and freedom is given to the people whom we are close with. Particular personal space is expected from the people whom they interact with according to the relationship they have with them. The theory explains that people tends [sic] to protect the personal space when they experience a violation in the expected behaviour.
You can see how Steak-umm’s Twitter feed would violate people’s expectations, albeit in a positive manner. We expect corporate social media to be primarily advertising, nothing more. However, in this case, we see a company’s social media arm being used to promote critical thinking and science about a deadly pandemic, which is definitely not something I would have expected to see.
Bogomoletc and Lee observe about the thread above that I quoted:
This thread received thousands of reposts and earned Steak-umm the titles “voice of reason” (Masnik, 2020) and “beacon of truth” (Zafarris, 2020) in the media. Within the next week, Steak-umm thanked its followers for amplifying its messages and shared five more threads addressing science communication, misinformation, and critical thinking. Meanwhile, the company demonstrated self-awareness by acknowledging its bizarre new role, apologizing for anthropomorphizing the brand and admitting that its ultimate goal was to sell its products (Masnik, 2020).
Here are examples of Steak-umm’s self-awareness:
we are just a frozen meat brand tweeting into the void hoping to provoke thought, inspire unity, and relay useful information. we are not an expert in anything or some beef god. we are a company with a bottom line being run by people. stay safe and be good to each other out there
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 10, 2020
And:
people think it's bizarre, ironic, and funny when a frozen meat company points out the importance of critical thinking, but chances are the same message would never "go viral" if it was from a person. our society values entertainment over truth and that's a huge problem
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 8, 2020
uncertainty doesn't sell. nuance doesn't sell. long, complex lectures don't sell. a video clip of someone saying "it's complicated" will never perform the way one would of someone using confident, flippant, polarizing rhetoric, and that's a huge problem
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 8, 2020
getting people credible, thoughtful, and impartial information is an uphill battle because most have evolved (and been programmed) to not care unless it's entertaining and tells them what they want to hear, but we have to try in these times of cultural crisis and polarization
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 8, 2020
And, there was another thread:
one major roadblock in getting credible information to the masses is the divide between experts and communicators. most experts aren't communicators and most communicators aren't experts. this often results in research being spun with a narrative by the time it reaches the public
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
research makes descriptive claims, while humans draw prescriptive claims from it. these interpretations are often necessary to discover the "why" and "how," but one fact remains: the experts who do the work itself are the ones with the best interpretation of their own methodology
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
since experts are often inadequate communicators, this allows space for anyone with a microphone to interpret their research however they want and project it to the masses, even if it directly opposes their conclusions. this drives partisan divide, as well as fringe conspiracies
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
there are cases when experts oppose the conclusions of other experts within their specific fields. that debate and refining is part of the scientific process, but just because someone is an expert in (x) doesn't mean they're an expert in (y), and each expert's credentials vary
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
many people seek out fringe dissenters of an expert consensus to reinforce their biases, and many times those dissenters are not credentialed in the relevant area, meaning they are:
1) wrong2) wrong / acting in bad faith3) wrong / a useful idiot4) the next galileo (unlikely)
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
the vast majority of any population look to communicators (often entertainers) for answers. because of this, we need to demand higher standards of our communicators when dealing with expert information, and we also need to encourage our experts to become better communicators
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
if people can be educated on the motivated reasoning behind where they get information from, while remaining open to expert consensus, there's room for thoughtful discussion that will hopefully bend toward the truth. but it has to start with genuine understanding
steak-umm bless
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
Again, there’s the “steak-umm bless,” which is often how Steak-umm signals its readers that a thread is finished. Steak-umm has also been raising money for Feeding America, to which the brand donated $25,000 in April.
These are just a few examples from over seven months ago. Here’s one from Friday:
how do you determine if a source is “credible?” well, it's an incredibly complex question. you need to understand the outlet and author's track record, their editorial process, associations, funding, audiences (market), critiques, and the influence of their work, for starters
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) November 13, 2020
it’s important to determine what *kind* of source you’re sharing. is it an opinion piece? breaking news? substantiated reporting? an anecdote? is it a new study with little support? is it a statistic without context? a peer-reviewed study? based on expert consensus or outliers?
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) November 13, 2020
there are various tools to use as a jumping off point for determining if a source is trustworthy, such as allsides, media bias fact check, snopes, and so on. however, these tools are limited in how they measure bias and still come from a POV, so you need to unpack more from there
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) November 13, 2020
you can use reverse google image searches to find the origins of memes, you can customize search result dates in google, you can use google scholar to find studies (although you need to be trained in how to navigate and read studies before just searching for what confirms biases)
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) November 13, 2020
trust in experts and institutions is at an all time low so it’s important for sources to be transparent about any biases and points of view they have. the standard for credible sources isn't objectivity, it's impartiality and accuracy through rigorous processes
steak-umm bless
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) November 13, 2020
Which led to this response, among others:
Why is the frozen meat spokesperson one of the greatest voices of reason in America right now, while our “leaders” are spewing nonsense? It looks like the fall of the Roman Empire.
— Balgor 🇺🇦 (@Balgor11) November 13, 2020
I was basically asking the same question.
The authors ask a rather obvious question, noting first that “authenticity” in communication can be major drivers of success, but also noting how authenticity alone is not enough to explain the rather odd success of Steak-umm’s strategy, asking, rather pointedly, “If the brand had been communicating authentically for several years, why did we see such a spike in followers now?” Based on expectancy violation theory, the authors ask: “What themes are reflected in consumer tweets about Steak-umm and to what extent do reactions reflect positive expectancy violations?”
To answer this question, the authors conducted a thematic analysis of Tweets replying or mentioning Steak-umm from April 1 to 14, 2020, limiting them to US Twitter users posting in English. (It’s at this point that I must mention that I strongly suspect some of my own Tweets from back then are likely to have been included in this analysis, because I did respond to or quote-Tweet Steak-umm at least a few times during that period.) Doing that analysis according to Smith’s five step process for developing and collapsing themes, the most prominent themes found included praise, leadership, surprise, and product mentions.
I won’t rehash the praise that much, other than to mention that, unsurprisingly, there were indeed numerous Tweets praising Steak-umm for its Tweets about how to evaluate COVID-19 information and misinformation, how to evaluate self-proclaimed “experts” on social media writing about the pandemic, COVID-19 epidemiology, and potential treatments. Mine were among them, and many of them went something like this:
When you get more responsible information from a frozen meat than from the President of the United States.
Thank you, @steak_umm. For the yummy steak sandwiches and the info. https://t.co/gq2lAYuC2Z
— Amy Mode Activated ᓚᘏᗢ ಇ. (@ActivateAmyMode) April 10, 2020
And this:
Steak-umm offering the sensible, rational defense of truth, repudiation of opportunism, and call to humanity that we all need right now. https://t.co/UGAP5GQVsO
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) April 13, 2020
Next up was leadership:
Another related theme was leadership. This theme was seen in several posts comparing its communication to that of President Trump. For example, one post said, “When you get more responsible information from a frozen meat than from the President of the United States …” (Toots the Red, 2020). It was also seen in posts saying Steak-umm, or the person behind the posts, is a hero, should run for president, or be nominated as vice president by presidential candidate Joe Biden. Examples included, “Umm, thank you, @steak_umm, for your sound reasoning. Exceptional read and quite right. Wanna run for President?” (Rau, 2020), and “Can we drop Biden and choose the @steak_umm intern instead?” (Wilson, 2020).
You get the idea. Amusingly, there was this response:
Indeed. It’s incredibly unlikely, of course, but a nice fantasy to have.
Obviously, to me, the big theme was surprise—pleasant surprise, but surprise nonetheless:
Surprise, confusion, and observations about the strangeness of 2020 were also prevalent. This came in the form of commenting on how it is odd that a frozen meat company is taking on this role and how that is a reflection of the strange reality of 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic. Exemplar posts included, “Can’t believe I’m retweeting @steak_umm but these are strange times we’re living in” (Woods, 2020), and “@steak_umm being the voice of reason is peak 2020” (Jamie Plus a 6 Foot Radius of Empty Space, 2020).
You know, I had always wondered how one cites a Tweet in an academic paper. Now I know. In any case, these are indeed strange times we’re living in, and that’s why I subtitled this post “The Strange Case of Steak-umm”.
Consistent with Steak-umm’s Twitter feed’s main purpose, which is to sell frozen meat, there were also posts that explicitly helped to sell Steak-umm product:
Most immediately related to company success were posts that endorsed Steak-umm products or explicitly stated purchase intentions. For instance, “The only way I can thank Steak-umm for the truth bombs is to buy some Steak-umm, so I’ll make some cheesesteaks soon, yo” (Valholla, 2020). Some of these tweets reflected nostalgia for the brand and referred to childhood or college. One such tweet said, “I haven’t had @steak_umm since I was a wee lass but I’m definitely getting some next grocery trip because I’m in love with their social media presence right now” (Liliana, 2020).
Again, this just goes to show that it is possible to do well by doing good, and this sort of brand message amplification was, no doubt, part of what Steak-umm’s social media team had hoped to accomplish when it started its campaign.
On the other hand, although Bogomoletc and Lee didn’t mention it, I can’t help but note that not all the responses to its Tweets have been positive. For example:
Haters aside, Bogomoletc and Lee come up with some takeaways from this campaign:
This case study provides several takeaways for strategic and technical communicators. First, the study demonstrates that companies should not be afraid to surprise their publics and show a human side. Showing humanity might be especially relevant for communicating complex matters such as misinformation or other science communication topics (Steiner, 1999). In this case, that involved a professional communicator not only communicating complex information but also providing followers insight into the technical communication process in a way for which communication practitioners and scholars are uniquely situated.
Second, previous authentic communication demonstrating the commitment of a company to its values might be a foundation for ensuring positive outcomes of expectancy violation. This takeaway demonstrates that “values [are] important in our organizations of classrooms, workplaces, and situations beyond these settings in which texts are used to establish or change policies and priorities” (Rude, 2009, p. 182). Shared values mediated through Steak-umm’s texts were clearly more important for the brand’s stakeholders than was the established decorum that dictates certain behavioral norms for organizations in a crisis situation.
It really is saying something that one of the most effective voices on Twitter against COVID-19 misinformation is the Twitter account of a frozen meat company. Surprise, indeed. As much as I might have predicted many of the things that have happened during the pandemic that I discussed at the beginning of this post, I never would have predicted that a frozen meat company would come to occupy such a prominent position in the war against COVID-19 misinformation.
Advertisers took note, too, as this AdAge article from April demonstrates. It turns out that the voice behind Steak-umm’s social media is a man named Nathan Allebach, who describes himself in his Twitter bio as “covering internet culture wars, advertising, and conspiracy theories”. Allebach was brought into the company for this express purpose:
The man behind the curtain is Nathan Allebach, a social media manager at Allebach Communications. He and his team were brought into the Steak-umm family in 2015 with the express mission of reaching the media-savvy millennial audience and a single directive: innovate.
That innovation — which had already gained recognition in 2018 after pensive tweets waxing about millennial despondency — came to fruition in early April.
In other words, this isn’t the first time that the Steak-umm Twitter feed has achieved notoriety for a rather Zen-like (or, some would say, stoner-like) bit of Twitter artistry:
why are so many young people flocking to brands on social media for love, guidance, and attention? I'll tell you why. they're isolated from real communities, working service jobs they hate while barely making ends meat, and are living w/ unchecked personal/mental health problems
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
they're crushed by student loan debt, disenfranchised by past generations, and are dreading the future of our world every day from mass media addiction and the struggle to not just be happy, but to survive this chaotic time with every problem happening at once under a microscope
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
they grew up through the dawn of internet culture and have had mass advertising drilled into their media consumption, now they're being resold their childhoods by remakes, sequels, spinoffs, and other cheap nostalgia, making them more cynical to growth or authenticity
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
they often don't have parents to talk to because they say stuff like "you don't know how good you have it," and they don't have mentors to talk to because most of them have no concept for growing up in this strange time, which perpetuates the feeling of helplessness/loneliness
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
they have full access to social media and the information highway, but they feel more alone and insecure than ever. being behind a screen 24/7 has made them numb to everything, anxious and depressed about everything, and vitriolic or closed off toward anyone different from them
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
young people today have it the best and the worst. there's so much to process and very few trusted, accessible outlets to process it all through. so they go to memes. they go to obscure or absurdist humor. they go to frozen meat companies on twitter. end rant
Steak-umm bless
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
no soundcloud to add here. at the end of the day it’s easy to tweet about problems and complain about “the other,” it’s a lot harder to improve the self and work toward solutions
be encouraged and have hope my beeflings, the world needs it
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) September 26, 2018
You can see from this thread from two years ago many of the same elements in Steak-umm’s Twitter threads about COVID-19, critical thinking, and science in 2020. There’s the self-deprecating, almost absurdist nature of the Tweets. Before the Tweets about Millennials, Steak-umm disrupted Twitter with a campaign to be “verified” by Twitter, the process that leads to those little checkmarks by the names of people on Twitter accounts, considered a badge of legitimacy that the social media company grants to company brands, journalists and famous people in the form of a blue check mark on their profile.
Basically, the 2020 Steak-umm Twitter campaign promoting critical thinking, particularly about COVID-19, is the longest and most sustained effort I’ve seen from the company. It’s gone on since early April and, as I showed above, is still ongoing. That being said, I never forget that this is an advertising campaign. It is undoubtedly an unconventional and innovative ad campaign that seeks to tie a brand to a societally useful and beneficial thing: Promoting skepticism and critical thinking about not just COVID-19, but everything.
Still, even while doing that, Steak-umm tells us that that’s what it’s doing. Indeed, it’s always been telling us that that’s what it’s doing. For example, later in April, Steak-umm opined:
note: all companies have a bottom line, so anything we publish is a form of propaganda to encourage positive association and memory with our brand, despite whatever our intentions. remember to consume advertising and PR with skepticism, even if the message is "helpful"
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 17, 2020
That’s so meta, and I couldn’t have said it better myself, even at the risk of some out there labeling me a shill for big frozen meat. I would even say that you should consume what we lay down here at SBM with skepticism as well. We do our damnedest to stick to the science, but all of us have our biases and we’re human. We’re not perfect. We are, also, not trying to sell you anything other than SBM, and we’re not charging anything for what we’re selling other than a bit of your time.

WHO Declares COVID Emergency Over
While the COVID health emergency is over, COVID itself is not, and we need to have an eye on the next potential pandemic.
Steven Novella on May 10, 2023
Link

On Friday May 5th 2023, after 1,191 days, the World Health Organization (WHO) officially declared the end of the COVID-19 health emergency, stating it was no longer a “public health emergency of international concern (PHEIC)”. That brings to an end a more than 3 year global pandemic. We have followed COVID closely since the beginning, so it seems fitting that we mark this important milestone.
Of course, COVID itself is not over. There were 441,290 cases worldwide in the last 7 days. COVID is now more of an endemic infection, like the flu, which is exactly what most experts predicted would happen (once it became established). We are now living with COVID rather than trying to live through COVID. Let’s review some of the stats.
According to the WHO the total worldwide deaths from COVID are 6,921,614 – almost 7 million. Total cases are 765 million, more than 100 times greater, which puts the mortality rate a little under 1%. There have also been 13,349,209,463 vaccine doses administered. About 70% of the world population had at least one dose, but the figure drops to 30% in low-income countries. Total deaths in the US alone was 1.12 million. That’s over 3,000 deaths per million, which ranks us 15th in the world, and more than most other wealthy developed nations. New Zealand is at the bottom of the list with 0.2. Clearly there are many factors involved, and being an island nation helps, but this also reflects public health policy effectiveness.
The WHO recognizes that these numbers are conservative and likely not accurate. If we look at excess deaths during the pandemic, rather than only confirmed cases, the number rises to about 20 million worldwide, almost three times the official estimate. This is partly due to the secondary effects of the pandemic. For example, lung cancer deaths rose 5%, likely due to delayed screening and care caused by the pandemic.
It’s would have been hard to imagine in early 2020 that the pandemic would last more than 3 years and take such a toll. In medicine it is common practice to take a look back and see how we did, where things went wrong, and where there is room for improvement. So – how did we do?
Scientifically I think we collectively did extremely well, and the pandemic could have been much worse otherwise. The virus was quickly identified and a genetic sequence available in days. There was some initial fumbling in terms of the best public health policy, but we quickly settled on masking and social distancing as the best ways to reduce infection. This was a novel virus causing an unusual infection, and the learning curve was steep that first year. But the number of studies being published on COVID was massive, and within about a year doctors had a pretty good handle on best management strategies. Also within a year multiple vaccines had been developed, and the second year of the pandemic was marked by a massive effort to vaccinate the world with a corresponding massive impact on dampening down the pandemic.
Multiple studies have estimated the impact of the COVID vaccines. After the first year of vaccines it was estimated that they saved 20 million deaths worldwide. A December 2022 study found that in the US COVID vaccines saved 3 million lives and $1.15 trillion. Another study found that vaccines saved over a million lives across Europe.  These are also likely underestimates because it is difficult to model the downstream impact of such a worsening of the economy, health care, and other aspects of society.
One area in which we did not do as well was education. We suddenly had to adapt to a deadly pandemic, and this came at an interesting time when the potential for remote online learning and working was possible but not mature or fully implemented. In my own field of medicine, this actually worked out great. We made years of advance in telehealth in just weeks and months. This is primarily because we were more than ready for telehealth and the only obstacles were bureaucratic – obstacles that were instantly cleared in the face of a pandemic.
In education the result was not as good. School systems did not have the infrastructure or training to adapt to online learning. We also did not have the data to know what the impact would be on younger children, who need the socialization as much as the learning. The negative impact of the pandemic on education was significant, widening education gaps that already existed. One study estimated that US students lost about one third of a school year due to the pandemic.
There is no simple answer to this situation. This does not mean that if we just kept schools open everything would have been just fine. Many schools struggled to stay open, even when they wanted to, because teachers and staff were out sick due to COVID, or were isolating because of exposure. We also don’t know what the net impact would have been on the pandemic itself if schools were open more, and what downstream effects that would have had. I don’t think it would have had a good long term impact on American education if the mortality rate among teachers skyrocketed.
I do think we can take away two big lessons from our experience with education during the pandemic. The first is that we underestimated the negative impact on young students of not being physically at school. The second (and this impacts the first) is that our education infrastructure was simply not ready for online learning. This is partly technological – having adequate setups at home and in the school for virtual learning, but also partly about the teaching itself. You can’t just do a live class program online. That’s like filming a play and calling it a movie. Lesson plans need to be optimized for the online experience, leveraging the advantages and mitigating the negative aspects. I have had both good and terrible online learning experiences. The question is – to what extent would a better prepared educational infrastructure have mitigated the negative impact of school shutdowns?
While we did well overall scientifically, and we did poorly overall in terms of education, I think the political response to the pandemic was mixed. This obviously varied from country to country, but also within a single country, like the US, politics had a massive impact on the pandemic. There seems to be a consensus that the pandemic revealed and exacerbated existing political dysfunction. This was partly driven by fear and uncertainty, especially early on. But the biggest negative impact was from the profound spread of misinformation and the imposition of political ideology and motivated narratives. We are still experiencing extreme misinformation about every aspect of the pandemic – people doubting the science on masking, social distancing, and the efficacy of the vaccines.
Politics mattered. There is overwhelming data now that vaccine rates in the US were lower and COVID death rates higher in Republican counties, in red states, and in people and locations that voted for Trump over Biden. Cumulative death rates in red states was 30% higher than blue states, and Republicans were 40% less likely to say that the pandemic is a serious health risk. Your attitude toward the pandemic and belief in mitigating actions and vaccines were largely determined by the information ecosystem in which you lived, and this translated into the probability of dying form COVID.
What does all this mean going forward? Specifically, are we ready for the next pandemic? While COVID is being portrayed as a once-a-century pandemic, this may be true only if we look backwards. This may no longer be true in the future, where there is increased globalization, and increased encroachment of humans into animal spaces. The experts warned us that a pandemic like COVID was coming. Our own Mark Crislip presciently laid out pretty much what a pandemic like COVID would be like, and that we would likely see such a pandemic roughly in the timeframe we did. Now those same experts are saying that another pandemic is likely sooner than later. Are we ready?
The short answer is – probably not. We need increased funding for pandemic preparedness. We need to have infrastructure ready to go. Hospitals need to have a plan, and extra capacity to handle pandemic surges. Public health organizations need to have the expertise and resources to manage communication in a world with social media and weaponized misinformation. This is not the 1950s anymore. As we saw, effective communication and countering misinformation may be the most effect tool to fight a pandemic.
We can also think about ways for schools to expand their ability to engage in remote, virtual, and online learning. Leveraging the potential of virtual learning can enhance even regular education, and those same skills and tools can become a backup for when in person learning is not safe or possible.
In short we need a pandemic game plan. And we don’t have one. This is a fixable problem. Perhaps we should take the occasion of the official end of the COVID pandemic to think seriously and plan extensively for the next one.

Preventing The Next Pandemic
Scientists saw the pandemic coming, but world leaders failed to listen. How can we prevent and minimize the next one?
Steven Novella on July 29, 2020
Link

It was recently estimated that the COVID-19 pandemic could cost the world economy $26.8 trillion over the next 5 years. This was the consensus estimate, but the range was as high as $82 trillion. This is a monumental amount of money that is hard to wrap your head around. What is easier to see, however, is that this leaves a lot of room to spend money on prevention. If, for example, the world spends $100 billion a year on preventive measures, that would still cost much less than a similar pandemic once a century – and pandemics are more frequent than that.
Another study calculates how much it would cost to significantly reduce the transmission of viruses from wild animals to humans, which is a common source of recent pandemics including HIV, MERS, SARS-CoV-1, H1N1, and SARS-CoV-2. They found:
…significantly reducing transmission of new diseases from tropical forests would cost, globally, between $22.2 and $30.7 billion each year. In stark contrast, they found that the COVID-19 pandemic will likely end up costing between $8.1 and $15.8 trillion globally–roughly 500 times as costly as what it would take to invest in proposed preventive measures.
They used an even more conservative estimate for the cost of COVID-19 than the prior study so the savings would likely be much greater. However, the “500 times” is misleading because that compares the total loss from the pandemic over years to the cost of a single year of preventive measures. This does not consider on average how many years of prevention would prevent a single pandemic. But given that we are seeing a pandemic about once a decade, their point is still extremely valid.
The preventive measures they focus on in this study is management of tropical forests. They argue that the above listed viral pandemics all represent transmission from tropical animals to human due to exposure from industry. This is due to encroaching into tropical forests for farming, herding animals, and hunting for bushmeat. Often forests are cut down in a patchwork fashion, maximizing the area of human-worked land next to wild forest.
Livestock can be another vector. They can become infected from wild animals, and then pass that infection onto humans when they are consumed. Of course, having markets with wild animals for sale, as likely happened with SARS-CoV-2, is also a vector. This is big industry. They report, for example:
In China alone, wildlife farming (a government-monitored effort to sustainably hunt wild animals without overhunting them) is an approximately $20 billion industry, employing 15 million people, say Kaufman and his peers. In many China communities, the purchase of wildlife and bushmeat–meat from wildlife species–is a status symbol.
The authors recommend regulations to ban such wildlife markets. In addition we need to spend money to manage and protect tropical forests. We need to stop incursions into wild tropical forests for farming, grazing, and hunting. China is considering banning such practices, which would be a good start.
There are likely many other things we can be doing to reduce the probability of another pandemic, or improve our response in order to minimize its impact. Given the massive global cost of such pandemics, robust measures are easily justified. Hopefully COVID-19 will be a wake up call – but it is not as if we didn’t already know this was coming.
Our own Mark Crislip, for example, in an interview on the SGU 13 years ago laid out pretty much the exact scenario we are now living through. Mark is an infectious disease expert, but not specifically an expert in pandemics. He was not part of some rarefied group of elite scientists who knew what was going on. The notion that another pandemic was coming was common knowledge among medical experts.
In his 2012 book, Spillover, David Quammen not only predicted that more pandemics were on the way, he specifically warned that the virus would come from the wild animal market. And again, this insight was not unique to him. Regarding why we weren’t more prepared, he said in an interview:
Yes, the lack of preparedness is the only thing about this whole situation that has surprised me. I didn’t have any illusions that the people who control the wheels of power and government were listening carefully to the scientists, but I thought they were listening at least enough to have some preparedness. And in this country, of course, I knew that [President] Trump was trying to defund the Centers for Disease Control as much as he could and had gotten rid of the key people on the National Security Council who were in charge of pandemic preparedness.
There is no mystery why the world was not as prepared as we should have been, and the US specifically, despite its wealth and resources, has been doing so badly. This was a political failure. The scientific community knew what was going to happen, not just in general but pretty specifically. They even warned about another novel coronavirus years ago. And yet, in a press briefing, Donald Trump said the pandemic was “a very unforeseen thing.” It could not have been more foreseen.
Quammen also agrees on the dominant cause:
Our relationship with the rest of the natural world, which is consumptive, and intrusive, and disruptive. Those things shake loose viruses from their natural hosts. All these wild animals carry their own unique viruses. When we go into a tropical forest with its great diversity, and we start cutting down trees, and capturing animals, or killing animals for food, then we offer those viruses the opportunity to become our viruses, to jump into us and find a new host, a much more abundant host. And when a virus moves from an infected animal into a human, it’s won the sweepstakes. It can now spread around the world and become one of the world’s most successful viruses, which this coronavirus now is.
In addition to better managing tropic forests and limiting contact between humans and wild animals likely to transmit viruses, we need to improve our health care preparedness. Steps were taken to do exactly that following recent pandemics, but these were easily reduced and dismantled once the memory of the last pandemic faded and according to the whims of the current administration. We need more robust, independent, and sustainable organizations to have the infrastructure necessary to nip the next pandemic in the bud. Globally we failed to do that this time, and we are paying the price.

The Next Pandemic
COVID-19 may have been a dress-rehearsal for more serious pandemics to come. How do we prepare?
Steven Novella on March 3, 2021
Tweet

We are just about at a year for the COVID-19 pandemic. After a year COVID has infected more than 115 million people and caused over 2.5 million deaths, with over half a million in the US alone. Pandemic fatigue has definitely set in, but with the rollout of various vaccines we can also see the light at the end of the tunnel. But there appears to be a strong consensus among experts that just because this pandemic ends, as all pandemics eventually do, that does not mean our concerns are over. They may just be getting started.
Dr. Mike Ryan, head of the World Health Organization (WHO) Emergencies Program warns that COVID-19 may have just been a “wake-up call”. This was a once-in-a century pandemic, but it may not be another century before the next one hits, and the next one could be far worse. What has changed?
The most obvious factor is simply that the human population has grown. Infectious diseases spread when animals congregate in large numbers. World population is now approaching 8 billion, and that population is increasingly global. Our rising population also brings other important factors. Producing enough food to feed the world includes raising large numbers of animals in close quarters, and they represent breeding grounds for viruses and infectious agents that can jump to humans.
Further, humans are increasingly encroaching onto natural habitats, raising the probability of a virus going from a non-human reservoir into the human population. That is likely what happened with COVID-19, although the exact path has not yet been proven. SARS-CoV-2, the disease that causes COVID-19, is endemic in the South Asian bat populations, and likely came from that source through wet markets and intermediate species.
There are potentially thousands of viruses in the world that have the potential to become the next pandemic, and SARS-CoV-2 is far from the worst of them. Rolling the “pandemic dice” has a good chance of producing something far worse than COVID-19, which is what Ryan and others are referring to with their warnings. The CDC keeps an eye on “Viruses of Special Concern”, such as those likely to produce the next flu pandemic. Other organizations also have published lists of potential severe pandemics, which include things like Ebola and Zika.
In addition to the direct health effects of the pandemic, it has been incredibly disruptive to life and economic activity. A study published in October estimated that the cost of the pandemic to the US was $16 trillion. At the same time the IMF estimated that world-wide lost productivity alone could cost $28 trillion. A generation of students may have effectively lost a year of education. Life expectancy in the US was decreased by 1.13 years due to COVID-19, disproportionately affecting minorities and the poor.
Once the vaccines have effectively ended the pandemic (although SARS-CoV-2 will likely remain with us, like the flu), it will be tempting to try to forget it and return to pre-pandemic normal life. But really, that will not be possible, nor should it be our goal. We need to adapt to a world where pandemics are increasingly likely.
One adaptation, which is the most hopeful thing to emerge during this pandemic, is that health science continues to advance impressively. We not only developed and deployed multiple vaccines within a year of discovering the virus, some are based on an entirely new vaccine platform – the mRNA vaccines (such as the ones developed by Pfizer and Moderna). Because sequencing and making DNA and RNA is now a mature technology, it took only weeks to sequence the genome of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, and only days to make the mRNA vaccine once the companies were handed that sequence. It then took months of clinical testing to prove the resulting vaccines were safe and effective – but there clearly is an opportunity here to fast track new vaccines, using a now-proven platform, without having to reinvent the clinical science each time. Quickly producing vaccines in response to new pandemic will likely prove to be one of our most important tools in the future.
We also need to take concrete steps to reduce the probability of new pandemic viruses from emerging. This may include changing practices at factory farms, and regulating wet markets. But we also need to carefully consider development practices that encroach on natural habitats, and habitat destruction in general.
The political challenge, as we have seen, may prove to be the most difficult. Preparedness is critical – we need to put in place, and maintain, a pandemic response infrastructure that can monitor for the emergence of new diseases, and respond effectively. This needs to be a global effort. It should be incredibly obvious now that something that happens on the other side of the planet can have devastating effects at home.
Finally, on the personal and societal level there needs to be permanent changes in culture. We have collective acquired some new skills during this pandemic, and we should not discard them once the pandemic is over. This includes mask-wearing. It should be a simple matter now, and culturally normal and expected, that anyone with cold or flu-like symptoms should remain isolated, but if they have even minor symptoms and need to be in public they should wear a mask and socially distance.
Further, working from home when sick or exposed should also be accepted as normal and responsible behavior. We can all Zoom now, and this should remain if not the default then at least an option for attending meetings and class when necessary. The pandemic also exacerbated and thereby helped reveal socioeconomic disparities. The “digital divide” now has public health consequences, and as we plan infrastructure investment it is clear that making sure everyone can attend class from home should be a priority.
In a way, we need to adapt in the same way our immune systems adapt. Once exposed to an infectious agent, our immune systems remember them so that they can respond more quickly and vigorously at the next exposure. Similarly, our world needs to respond more quickly and vigorously to the next pandemic. We must have pandemic-memory, even if we want to forget the past year.

Terrain in Vain
Mark Crislip on December 16, 2025
Link

Now I got a job, but it don’t pay
I need health insurance, I need somewhere to stay
But without all of these things I can do
But without vaccines, I won’t make it through
But you don’t understand my point of view
I suppose there’s nothing I can do
I have been on a bit of a Clash binge of late. Truly one of the great rock bands.
I will confess I am not a fan of the current approach for the next epidemic, which is to do nothing. Well, not exactly nothing. Jay Bhattacharya, director of the National Institutes of Health, writes
Whether simply by stopping smoking, controlling hypertension or diabetes, or getting up and walking more, anything that makes the population healthier will prepare us better for the next pandemic.
Asymptotically approaching nothing but not quite there. The rest of our infection control approaches from the COVID pandemic appear off the table, from school closures to vaccines. It is time:
We must stop wasting money on the traditional playbook…The best pandemic preparedness playbook for the United States is making America healthy again.
Color me, well, skeptical.
This brings up a few issues I will randomly ramble on about.
It is the old battle: Pasteur or Bechamp. Germs or terrain. Infectious pathogns or the host. Well, it is both, to varying degrees depending on the infection. Forty years an infectious disease doctor and often responsible for infection control at multiple hospitals, I think it is often much more the germ than the host that is key. Sure, we can alter the host with immunosuppressive and invasive interventions that make it easier for some pathogens to cause disease. That is more the case for bacteria such as S. aureus and E. coli and fungi than it is for pathogens that are likely to cause the next pandemic. Those are much more likely to be viri.
I am not going to argue against the idea that it is better to be healthy than not when confronted by an infectious disease. I just don’t think being healthy is any close to enough to prevent infection, especially for viri. And brain worms.
There are many pathogens that have no problem infecting people, regardless of your metabolic health. HIV. Hepatitis A and B and C. Coronavirus. Influenza. Measles. And more.
What do these viri have in common? They use us to reproduce. They have evolved extremely efficient methods to infect us, multiply, and then move on to the next human, causing symptomatic disease and, on occasion, death. Viral reproduction will always win if there is no preexisting immunity, AKA vaccines.
The next pandemic, like the viri above, will likely also have a specific and efficient method to reproduce, some human molecule or receptor it will bind to start its reproduction. And I would bet, like the infections above, its drive to reproduce will overcome any host metabolic health. Infection is their raison d etre.
I also wonder, as an aside, it Bhattacharya et. al. would like to apply the same approach to, say, surgical infections. Doubt relying only on metabolic health would prevent hospital-acquired infections. I realize that a pandemic by a novel pathogen is not the same as preventing hospital acquired infections, but there is a lot of overlap in the techniques used to prevent both. The old playbook mostly works.
I thought it was interesting that they pointed to Sweden:
Sweden, without lockdown or school closures, was the best in the world at protecting human life during the Covid pandemic.
Before COVID hit, there was a large literature concerning influenza and school closures. And school closure was effective in controlling outbreaks.
The mean reduction of the peak of the epidemic was M=29.65%. Implementing school closure before or after the epidemic reaches its peak reduced the overall influenza epidemic. School closure reduced and delayed the epidemic peak, especially if implemented earlier. The longer the duration of closure, the more the epidemic peak delayed. Additionally, closure containment effect also correlated with organisms having high attack rates and longer infectiveness duration.
So for COVID, not a bad idea? Turns out COVID was not influenza and school closures may not have done much to slow down the epidemic. Likely did save some teachers from dying. But the incidence of many other infections declined dramatically and one strain of influenza went extinct.
An unusual and tangential outcome of the COVID-19 pandemic has been the apparent extinction of one of the four circulating varieties of human influenza viruses, known as the B/Yamagata/16/88-lineage (B/Yam) viruses
So who knows with the next pandemic. If it is more like influenza than COVID, the old play book would be just the thing to control it.
It appears there are several unspoken concepts behind the idea that being metabolically fit is all you need.
One is that by eating ultraprocessed fruit, we have been banished from the garden perfect health. That our baseline should be healthy. Nope. Our baseline, before the advent of sanitation and vaccines, is to be riddled with disease, infectious and otherwise.
There are a tremendous number of diseases that will be neither prevented nor cured by metabolic perfection. Type 1 diabetes. Cancers. Lupus. And many others. When the next pandemic hits, for those and other diseases, the old play book will be of more benefit to prevent infection than metabolic fitness.
Another assumption seems to be the idea that everyone shares the same immune system. We don’t. Variation is the clay that evolution molds and the immune system has too numerous to count variations that increases or decreases your response to infection.
Influenza deaths may be genetic:
A heritable contribution to the development of severe influenza virus infection (i.e., that which results in death) has not previously been hypothesized or tested. Evidence for a heritable contribution to death due to influenza was examined using a resource consisting of a genealogy of the Utah population linked to death certificates in Utah over a period of 100 years. The relative risks of death due to influenza were estimated for the relatives of 4855 individuals who died of influenza. Both close and distant relatives of individuals who died of influenza were shown to have a significantly increased risk of dying of influenza, consistent with a combination of shared exposure and genetic effects. These data provide strong support for a heritable contribution to predisposition to death due to influenza.
You lack a chemokine receptor. Congratulations. You cannot get HIV from sex. But you are more likely to have a bad outcome from West Nile. What evolution gives, evolution takes away.
There are innumerable polymorphisms, single amino acid variations, that increase or decrease infection risk and disease. My favorite is having the wrong snot:
A mutation in SPLUNC1 affecting mucosal attachment, biofilm formation, and invasion of mucosal epithelial cells is a new genetic cause of meningococcal disease.
The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, / But in ourselves, and no attempt at metabolic fitness will alter whatever genetic predisposition, beneficial or otherwise, to disease you have.
Any response to the next pandemic should depend on the pathogen. The mode of transmission. What receptor/physiology it hijacks. The virulence of the organism. When the next pandemic starts, what to do will be uncertain. What kinds of infection control interventions will work? Can a vaccine or medication be rapidly developed? And at the beginning, when the fog is thickest and uncertainty at maximum, those tasked with controlling the pandemic will have the option of doing too much or too little. Pandemics are not porridge; there is never the option of getting the response just right. I would prefer doing too much but it looks like doing next to nothing is the current approach.
Relying on metabolic fitness is Darwinian survival of the fittest.
When I was young, I was impressed with the explanatory power of the Peter Principle:
The Peter principle states that a person who is competent at their job will earn a promotion to a position that requires different skills. If the promoted person lacks the skills required for the new role, they will be incompetent at the new level, and will not be promoted again. If the person is competent in the new role, they will be promoted again and will continue to be promoted until reaching a level at which they are incompetent. Being incompetent, the individual will not qualify for promotion again, and so will remain stuck at this final placement …And when someone reaches the highest level in their organization and yet is still competent at that level. This is only because there were not enough ranks in the hierarchy, or because they did not have time to reach a level of incompetence. Such people often seek a level of incompetence in another hierarchy.
Sound familiar? But wait (which I always hear as butt weight). There’s more.
Where the Peter Principle failed are the situations where incompetence itself is the reason for promotion to positions of authority. And that being incompetent in one hierarchy is the reason for a job that allows incompetence in another hierarchy.
Bright side? We only have to be lucky for three years and a month. Hear that bird flu? Extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis? Any other organism with pandemic potential? I know you are tempted by this wide open ecological niche with little protection you can subvert to reproduce, but hold off just a few years.
In the mean time, coffins look to be a good investment.
    • 

Contrarians. Always in Error, Never in Doubt

COVID-19: Out-of-control science and bypassing science-based medicine
During the COVID-19 pandemic, there hasn’t just been a pandemic of coronavirus-caused disease. There’s also a pandemic of misinformation and bad science. It turns out that doctors today are just as prone as doctors 100 years ago during the 1918-19 influenza pandemic to bypass science-based medicine in their desperation to treat patients.
David Gorski on May 4, 2020
Link

Longtime readers (and I do mean longtime readers) might remember that I (as well as some of our other regular bloggers) have had our differences with Shannon Brownlee and Jeanne Lenzer. The most dramatic example occurred a decade ago during another pandemic, the H1N1 pandemic, when Brownlee and Lenzer wrote a really bad article about the H1N1 influenza vaccine in The Atlantic entitled “Does the Vaccine Matter?” They were referring to the frantic effort to vaccinate people with the newly developed H1N1 vaccine. It’s rare that an article provokes a response from more than one or two of us at SBM, but Brownlee and Lenzer’s article provoked responses from Mark Crislip, Peter Lipson, and myself, as well as a certain friend of the blog, while actual public health researchers were none too pleased, either. The reason I mention this is because, although Brownlee and Lenzer often go a bit too far in their assertions that we are all “overtreated”, when they are on point, they’re really on point, as in an article published last week in Issues in Science and Technology, “Pandemic Science Out of Control”, and I’m giving credit where credit is due. Of course, the way I like to say it is that we’re not just dealing with an infectious disease pandemic, but we’re also dealing with a pandemic of pseudoscience, misinformation, disinformation, and political propaganda that risks making the pandemic far more deadly than it would otherwise have been.
Theirs is a long (!) summary of the sorts of things I was trying to say last week about the dangers of bypassing science- and evidence-based medicine during a pandemic, using the example of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin. Given that another example of (possibly) playing fast and loose with EBM occurred last week with the experimental drug remdesivir, I saw their article as a perfect time to expound a bit more on what I had written last week. Even if Brownlee and Lenzer do cover some of the same cases that I did, including Didier Raoult’s terrible science on hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin, promotion of these drugs by doctors like Dr. Vladimir Zelenko, whose incompetent “case series” tells us nothing about the efficacy of his drug cocktail, and “Dr. Phil” and Dr. Mehmet Oz, among others.
Global pandemics, a century ago and now
Brownlee and Lenzer begin with a callback to the last global pandemic as bad as the one we’re experiencing now, the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic, showing how, the more things change, the more they stay the same, or at least how some things don’t change very much, even over a century:
On September 14, 1918, in the midst of the worst pandemic in modern history, an article in the New York Times quoted Dr. Rupert Blue, then surgeon general of the US Public Health Service. Blue reported that doctors in many countries were treating their influenza patients with digitalis and the antimalaria drug quinine. There was no evidence that the two drugs were any more effective than folk remedies being used by patients, including cinnamon, goose grease poultices, and salt stuffed up the nose, but doctors were desperate and willing to try just about anything. They would eventually abandon quinine and digitalis as treatments for flu when studies showed they were not only ineffective but caused serious and sometimes deadly side effects.
Today, just shy of two months since the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a pandemic, the media are once again flooded with cures, patients such as Michigan State Representative Karen Whitsett are being quoted with claims that hydroxychloroquine “saved my life,” and doctors are prescribing drugs that have not been shown to be effective. Only this time, it’s the twenty-first century, the age of “evidence-based medicine.” Or so it might seem. But instead of no science to back up treatments, we now have bad studies being reported uncritically in the press, and Twitter storms of doctors, journalists, and researchers arguing about the ethics of withholding drugs from dying patients, even though we have no idea if those drugs do more harm than good.
I discussed the case of Karen Whitsett three weeks ago (which today seems like ancient history), because she was in the local news a lot here in Michigan before President Trump picked up on her case and started touting it as “evidence” that hydroxychloroquine works against COVID-19. You can read the article linked to for a longer explanation, but the Cliffs Notes version is that her claim that hydroxychloroquine cured her seems highly implausible given that she claimed to start feeling better within a couple of hours of her first dose after she had been ill around 12 days, which is around the time one would expect recovery, given that that’s well within the parameters of the typical time course of symptomatic COVID-19 illness for people who recover. There were also oddities, such as her having used hydroxychloroquine to treat chronic Lyme disease, a fake diagnosis beloved of quacks.
Still, I was struck by the similarity between 1918 and now, at least in terms of doctors frantically trying to repurpose every drug under the sun that might be used to treat victims of the pandemic, regardless of whether there existed good evidence or not that the drugs being tested were likely to work. We like to think that we’ve progressed so much in the last century, and we have in many ways. Sadly, though, in our desperate response to a pandemic, physicians now share much in common with physicians then:
If there is a silver lining to all the confusion, it is that this pandemic is exposing three persistent fault lines in medicine. First is the willingness on the part of clinicians to abandon the prime dictum of medicine, to do no harm, and rush into treatments that not only may not work but may well cause serious harm. The fact is, most physicians are not trained to recognize good science from bad. Nor do they have the time to analyze every study, and too many are willing to ignore the need for reliable evidence when fear sets in. Even in non-pandemic times, doctors often favor treatments that have long been in use, seem biologically plausible, are highly remunerative, or have been heavily marketed by manufacturers. In the case of two drugs now being used against COVID-19, hydroxychloroquine and remdesivir, there is a very real possibility that patients who might have recovered from the virus without them will be harmed or even killed by the treatment.
The second issue exposed by the pandemic is the role the media invariably play in hyping science and the physicians who purvey it without regard to the quality of the underlying studies. Some reporters are acting out of ignorance. They know less about good study design than the doctors they quote. Others report on faulty research because it is their business to hype the stock of drug and biotech manufacturers, which have been known to release spurious results of studies when those results favor their products. Whatever the reason, stories in the media help shore up claims of miracle cures made on the basis of poor-quality research.
Since I’ve already beat the topic of hydroxychloroquine to death on this blog, I won’t say much more about it, other than that Brownlee and Lenzer do a generally good job of describing the shortcomings in Raoult’s studies, in particular his first one, while his second and third studies were basically uncontrolled case series that were very much uninformative. Meanwhile, Raoult was once again all over French media over the last few days, sounding very Trumpian while promoting himself, denigrating and bullying his critics, and generally portraying himself as a scientific genius, whom other doctors and scientists just can’t understand.
The press, politics, and opportunism
While it’s very much true that, as Lenzer and Brownlee point out, the media have a malign role in hyping bad science and the opportunistic fame seeking (and sometimes grifting) physicians who promote it (something we’ve been discussing on this blog for many years and a characteristic of the press that’s been amplified greatly during the pandemic), this time around there’s another element: Politics. As you might know, the narrative surrounding hydroxychloroquine was hijacked early on mainly by allies of President Trump, who trumpeted Didier Raoult’s bad science in late March, ultimately leading to the FDA issuing an emergency use approval for hydroxychloroquine on March 31. Meanwhile doctors who have no idea what they are doing when it comes to clinical research were touting personal case series so flawed that it’s impossible to draw any conclusions from them. The most famous of these is Dr. Vladimir Zelenko, a NY physician who claims to have treated hundreds of COVID-19 patients with hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, and zinc, with incredible results and whose claims have been promoted by President, Laura Ingraham on Fox News, and many other Trump allies.
As Brownlee and Lenzer describe it:
Another study that received attention in the press was conducted by a New York physician, Vladimir (Zev) Zelenko, who claims to have had “100% success” treating 699 patients with a cocktail of hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, and zinc. His miracle cure is being touted on social media, but Zelenko’s results are even more suspect than Raoult’s. For one thing, most of his patients weren’t even tested for coronavirus, making any claims that he’s curing COVID-19 meaningless. For another, Zelenko’s study was not randomized and had no placebo control arm. Those 699 patients who improved on his drug cocktail may have done no better than patients who got usual care—assuming they even had the disease. Zelenko, like Raoult, also skipped the process of submitting his study for peer review; he took it straight to President Trump’s personal lawyer, former New York City mayor Rudolph Giuliani. Giuliani in turn shared the study with the president and tweeted “Hydroxychloroquine has been shown to have a 100% effective rate treating COVID-19.”
As I like to say, whenever a physician claims “100% effectiveness”, my skeptical antennae start twitching mightily. Nothing in medicine is 100% other than that we will all die someday of something. In any event, I discussed Dr. Zelenko’s incompetence at doing anything resembling a valid clinical trial on SBM and elsewhere. So, based on no good evidence and in spite of the fact that there was evidence that hydroxychloroquine probably didn’t work and could cause harm in the form of dangerous, even fatal, heart rhythm disturbances, the FDA still issued the EUA, and, as Brownlee and Lenzer mention, this could be the consequence:
Whatever the reason for the FDA’s decision, the result is that 40% of physicians, many of whom have neither the skills nor the time to do their own critical appraisals and need to trust the FDA, say they have prescribed the drug for patients with COVID-19. Some physicians are even hoarding it in case they or family members are infected. Others are denouncing colleagues who urge caution, among them Anthony Fauci, the head of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease and the most prominent member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force. On an emergency medicine email list, one physician said, “By the time everyone gets their evidence together in a nice controlled study COVID will have packed its bags and left town with thousands dead.” On Twitter, Carole Lieberman, a psychiatrist from Beverly Hills, wrote, “People r dying NOW so no time 4 studies #Fauci wants!”
I’m sorry to say that the hospitals where I have privileges made hydroxychloroquine the de facto standard of care, based on anecdotal evidence, unpublished case series, and, truth be told, hype. They’ve since backed off, as has the University of Michigan, and most other academic medical centers, as physicians saw no evidence of efficacy but were observing evidence of toxicity. The bottom line is that hydroxychloroquine probably doesn’t work against COVID-19. At least, that’s the way the evidence appears to be trending.
Bad epidemiology
Hydroxychloroquine is not the only example of bad science that was hyped by the media and used for a political purpose. Indeed, there’s also been a pandemic of armchair epidemiologists confidently spouting off about infection rates and case fatality rates, people who self-assuredly say, “I’m not an epidemiologist or infectious disease expert, but…” and then proceed to opine about the incidence, prevalence, and treatment as though they were experts. Personally, whenever anyone starts out by saying, “I’m not an infectious disease expert or epidemiologist, but…” I respond, “You should have stopped after ‘I’m not an infectious disease expert or epidemiologist’.” The problem, of course, is that estimating, for example, prevalence of exposure to COVID-19 and case fatality rates is very difficult in the middle of a pandemic in which there is insufficient testing, case numbers are still climbing, and the antibody tests likely have high false positive rates, and if you don’t have any training you don’t even know what you don’t know. For example, over the last couple of weeks, two doctors/entrepreneurs running a small chain of urgent care centers in Bakersfield, CA have been all over Fox News and other right wing media sources promoting their claim that COVID-19 is not only not more deadly than the flu but is in fact five times less deadly than seasonal flu, based on this video press conference:
Based on their “study” Drs. Erickson and Massihi have found themselves falsely elevated to the status of “experts” in the right wing COVID-19 denying crankosphere. They are in fact pseudoexperts. For one thing, from what I’ve been able to tell, although Dr. Massihi is a board-certified in emergency medicine, Dr. Erickson, who does all the talking in the first video, can’t even be viewed as an expert in emergency medicine, as he appears not to be board-certified in it based on my searches. For purposes of discussing epidemiology, it doesn’t really matter if Drs. Erickson or Massihi are boarded in emergency medicine anyway. In fact, Erickson and Massihi’s video, it turns out, is a slick mix of statements, made by doctors that are mostly true mixed with misinformation and bad science thrown together to give a message that is probably true (COVID-19 likely has a case fatality rate considerably lower than estimates made early in the pandemic) but exaggerated (it’s as low as influenza), all in service of a political message (“we should reopen America because COVID-19 is not that dangerous”).
Erickson starts out by describing how the focus on COVID-19 means that a lot of people with other medical problems, such as heart attacks and the like, are afraid to come to the hospital (or their urgent care clinics) and may be dying at home or recovering without treatment that might have minimized the damage. This is true. Erickson also notes that we should quarantine the sick and not the people who are well, which is, of course, the way we will eventually have to remove the restrictions, while dismissing the current approach of in essence “quarantining” everyone with shelter-in-place orders as overkill. The problem is that to be able to quarantine the sick and allow the well to go about their business with lesser restrictions, we need accurate testing, a lot more accurate testing. Absent a lot of testing, and the robust ability to trace the contacts of those identified as having COVID-19, the only option was the one that most nations and most states in the US chose: Shelter-in-place orders of varying strictness. While Erickson is correct that a more targeted approach to quarantine is desirable, he barely mentions what is needed to achieve that.
At this point, Erickson states that Accelerated Urgent Care centers have tested 5,213 people and that 340 of them were positive, which he characterizes as “6.5% of the population” of the Central Valley in California, their catchment area around Bakersfield. He then mentions that 12% of the tests in California were positive and 39% in New York were positive, after which they make a really brain dead extrapolation. Based on California’s population of 39 million people, if 12% tested positive then 4.5 million people in California might have had COVID-19. This is, of course, utter nonsense. Similarly, Erickson extrapolates from his observation that 6.5% of their COVID-19 tests were positive that 6.5% of the people in Bakersfield have or have had COVID-19; i.e., about 58,000 cases, far more than the 700 confirmed cases in the area thus far. He then makes the argument that hospitalization and case fatality rates should be based on these numbers, estimating the COVID-19 case fatality rate to be around 0.02%, arguing that it’s five times less lethal than the 0.1% case fatality rate due to the flu.
Finally, based on the “analysis” by himself and Dr. Massihi, Erickson identifies a number of economic and political implications, the most prominent of which, unsurprisingly, echo the COVID-19 diminishment and denial machine’s call to “reopen America” based on the argument that the shutdown is doing more harm than good. (They also make a really brain dead claim about the harm shelter-in-place is supposedly doing to our health. More on that later.) As several, including Dr. Jennifer Kasten, have pointed out, these two armchair epidemiologists made such an obvious mistake that they should be (but won’t be) embarrassed. They assumed that the population they tested, which were primarily symptomatic patients given that they had announced in March that they had lots of COVID-19 tests and would be testing patients suspected of having COVID-19, was representative of the population in their urgent care centers’ catchment area. So there was almost certainly enormous selection bias. After all, who comes to urgent care clinics to get a COVID-19 test? Obviously, it’s those who were worried that they had been exposed to COVID-19 or who had COVID-like symptoms, such as cough, fever, and shortness of breath. Far more of their patients at their urgent care centers would be likely to have COVID-19 than the general population. We also don’t know the time frame during which they were doing these tests, so the percentage of the population with COVID-19 could have been rapidly increasing.
This TV news report could easily have spurred anyone with symptoms or concerned that they had been exposed to someone with COVID-19 to head on over to an Accelerated Urgent Care center location to be evaluated and tested. And guess what? In that video, they state that only symptomatic patients would be tested. Is it any wonder that they observed a high percentage of COVID-19 positive tests? Dr. Erickson also makes the claim that sheltering in place at home harms the immune system because it encounters fewer pathogens, which is utter nonsense. I liked Dr. Kasten’s retort:
UNLESS YOU LIVE INSIDE AN AUTOCLAVE, YOUR HOME IS PLENTY PATHOGEN-RICH
The world is absolutely teeming with microbes. You’re coated in them, your house is coated in them, they enter your body with every breath you take and everything you eat. Your immune system is getting a perfectly adequate workout. You’re just restricting your exposure to a handful of things (respiratory pathogens) for a very short period of time.
One also can’t help but note that both of these doctors are big time Trump supporters and that Dr. Massihi had videos by antivaccine leader Del Bigtree linked to on his Facebook page before apparently deleting the posts. In any event, so egregious was this not-so-dynamic duo’s behavior that American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) and the American Academy of Emergency Medicine (AAEM) issued a joint statement condemning their promotion of misinformation.
This brings us to remdesivir.
Remdesivir, hype, and concerns about last week’s study
Brownlee and Lenzer discuss the state of the evidence regarding remdesivir, an experimental antiviral drug made by Gilead Sciences that had originally been developed to treat Ebola but found not to be effective, as it existed when their article was published:
Now the press and medical communities have turned their attention to remdesivir, an experimental biotech antiviral drug that has never been shown to be effective for any disease. The University of Chicago recruited 125 people for two trials, including 113 with serious symptoms of COVID-19 for a study sponsored by Gilead Pharmaceuticals, the manufacturer of remdesivir. The news outlet STAT obtained a video of researchers at the university reporting on their results to colleagues. STAT quoted Kathleen Mullane, an infectious disease specialist overseeing the studies, as saying, “The best news is that most of our patients have already been discharged, which is great. We’ve only had two patients perish.” The story also quoted Slawomir Michalak, a 57-year-old factory worker who was among the study participants, saying, “Remdesivir was a miracle.” Gilead’s stock shot up when the story broke.
STAT, in its breathless coverage, failed to emphasize that the University of Chicago studies, along with other Gilead-sponsored trials that are running simultaneously, are not randomized and have no placebo control arm. As Mullane even told her colleagues, without a randomized placebo control there is no way to know if the drug works better than no drug at all.
Yes, this was another single-arm study, and at the time of publication the only existing study of remdesivir in humans was a single-arm study published three weeks ago in the New England Journal of Medicine. This was peak COVID-19 publishing, when an uncontrolled case series of patients with severe COVID-19 treated with remdesivir under compassionate was published in a super high impact journal like NEJM and made headlines as a result. Be that as it may, the case series examined 61 patients with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection who had an oxygen saturation of 94% or less while they were breathing room air or who were receiving oxygen support. They received a 10-day course of remdesivir, consisting of 200 mg given intravenously on day 1, followed by 100 mg daily for the remaining 9 days of treatment. (Remdesivir is an intravenous drug.) The authors reported clinical improvement in 68% of evaluable patients. Unfortunately, the case series also did not collect viral load data to confirm potential antiviral activity in humans or any association between declines in viral load and clinical improvement. Basically, when you get right down to it, this study was not really much better than Didier Raoult’s latest crappy studies of his hydroxychloroquine/azithromycin combination in terms of telling us if remdesivir has activity.
Ironically, on the day after Lenzer and Brownlee’s article was published, two things happened. First, a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of remdesivir in COVID-19 patients from China was published in The Lancet. Eligible patients were adults admitted to the hospital with laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 whose symptoms had lasted less than 12 days before enrollment and who had an oxygen saturation on room air of 94% or less or a ratio of arterial oxygen partial pressure to fractional inspired oxygen of 300 mm Hg or less (another measure of hypoxia), and radiologically confirmed pneumonia. Patients were randomly assigned in a 2:1 ratio to intravenous remdesivir at the same dose as the NIH trial touted by Dr. Fauci or the same volume of placebo infusions for 10 days and were permitted concomitant use of lopinavir–ritonavir, interferons, and corticosteroids. The primary endpoint was time to clinical improvement up to day 28, defined at the time from randomization to the point of a decline of two levels on a six-point ordinal scale of clinical status (from 1=discharged to 6=death) or discharged alive from hospital, whichever came first. An intention-to-treat analysis was carried out.
Basically, this was a negative trial. Of the 255 patients screened, 237 met the eligibility criteria, and 158 were assigned to the remdesivir group, with 79 assigned to placebo control. Unfortunately, remdesivir treatment was not associated with a shorter time to clinical improvement, and mortality was not different between the two groups. Subgroup analysis looking for hypotheses found that there was a trend towards a shorter duration of symptoms (not statistically significant) in patients treated with remdesivir who had had symptoms for less than ten days. Most disappointingly, there was no detectable difference in viral load between the remdesivir groups and the placebo controls. Again, basically this was a negative study with only the barest hint that remdesivir might—I repeat, might—work if administered earlier in the course of COVID-19. Those results, of course, were not at all encouraging.
On the same day, the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease (NIAID), led by Dr. Anthony Fauci, issued a press release about a study of remdesivir in moderately ill patients:
Hospitalized patients with advanced COVID-19 and lung involvement who received remdesivir recovered faster than similar patients who received placebo, according to a preliminary data analysis from a randomized, controlled trial involving 1063 patients, which began on February 21. The trial (known as the Adaptive COVID-19 Treatment Trial, or ACTT), sponsored by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), part of the National Institutes of Health, is the first clinical trial launched in the United States to evaluate an experimental treatment for COVID-19.
An independent data and safety monitoring board (DSMB) overseeing the trial met on April 27 to review data and shared their interim analysis with the study team. Based upon their review of the data, they noted that remdesivir was better than placebo from the perspective of the primary endpoint, time to recovery, a metric often used in influenza trials. Recovery in this study was defined as being well enough for hospital discharge or returning to normal activity level.
Preliminary results indicate that patients who received remdesivir had a 31% faster time to recovery than those who received placebo (p<0.001). Specifically, the median time to recovery was 11 days for patients treated with remdesivir compared with 15 days for those who received placebo. Results also suggested a survival benefit, with a mortality rate of 8.0% for the group receiving remdesivir versus 11.6% for the placebo group (p=0.059).
More detailed information about the trial results, including more comprehensive data, will be available in a forthcoming report.
In a press conference, Dr. Fauci was quoted thusly:
“What it has proven is that a drug can block this virus,” the National Institutes of Health’s Dr. Anthony Fauci said.
“This will be the standard of care,” and any other potential treatments will now have to be tested against or in combination with remdesivir, he said.
As you can see, the difference in mortality was not statistically significantly different, although that could just be because of inadequate numbers. It’s also very important to note the part about the adaptive trial design of this trial, which puts Dr. Fauci’s comment about how remdesivir will become the “standard of care” going forward into the proper context. In this particular trial, multiple different drugs can be compared to placebo or standard of care. The idea is that, if a signal of efficacy is found with one drug, that drug becomes “standard of care” and the trial is adapted to study how adding other experimental drugs compares to the “standard of care.” So what Dr. Fauci meant was that, based on the finding, going forward remdesivir will become the “standard of care” arm for the trial and the experimental arm will become remdesivir plus another experimental therapeutic. However, given that the FDA is on the verge of issuing an emergency use authorization for remdesivir to treat COVID-19, it looks as though remdesivir will become standard-of-care in general soon.
On Twitter, there was a lot of chatter about this study, in particular by Wallid Gellad:
And James Heathers:
Here's Fauci talking about it. Give him a listen, sharpen your ears at about 0.30.
"The primary endpoint was the time to recovery, namely the ability to be discharged."
He's right, it was.
On April 16th.https://t.co/U6Cx3XSOJ6
— James Heathers (@jamesheathers) April 30, 2020
I’ll summarize, so that you don’t have to scroll through a Twitter thread if you don’t want to. As James Heathers and Waller Gellad noted, the original primary outcome of the trial when it was registered on March 20 was an 8-point severity scale (death, on ventilator, hospitalized with oxygen, all the way down to discharged with no limits on activity) but was changed to time to recovery. There’s still a similar scale for the secondary endpoints, but no numbers for that were reported. (Any bets on whether the results are negative?) This change was apparently made on or around April 16. I must admit that it did look very fishy to me. Endpoint or outcome switching, particularly late in a clinical trial is a huge red flag to me. Don’t get me wrong. There can be legitimate scientific reasons to switch primary endpoints of a trial, but they have to be really well justified. Gary Schwitzer has a good roundup of the criticism and questioning of the trial here.
I remain very suspicious that the NIH study was announced the same day that a negative study out of China of remdesivir was published. It just seems too…convenient. Maybe I’m being overly suspicious. Maybe I’m falling prey to conspiracy mongering. However, in the Trump era, when the Trump administration has politicized previously (mostly) apolitical government agencies as never before, it’s hard not to wonder, especially in light of Gilead’s increasing lobbying, if politics intervened.
Amusingly, Trump supporters are more suspicious of the remdesivir results than a lot of scientists. Why? It’s unclear exactly why other than that they still seem to prefer hydroxychloroquine, with Laura Ingraham still touting it even after negative studies and results suggesting that remdesivir appears promising. I can’t help but chuckle, given that, whatever its flaws, the remdesivir study is still a much better designed and carried out study than any study cited as evidence for the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine.
The consequences of bypassing EBM/SBM
As I’ve said before, bypassing SBM and EBM has consequences; Lenzer and Brownlee put it this way:
As always, it is the patient who suffers the harms of using a drug first and doing the right scientific studies later. In the case of hydroxychloroquine, potential side effects are not trivial. The drug can affect heart rhythm, potentially triggering a rare condition known as torsades de pointes, which can end in sudden cardiac death. One cardiologist posted an EKG tracing of a coronavirus patient on Twitter saying, “Long time since I’ve seen torsades-de-pointe! Careful out there! Please educate your community on the use of #Hydroxycholoroquine.” And a recent study of patients treated with chloroquine (a drug related to hydroxychloroquine and also granted emergency use approval by the FDA) found that 11 of 81 patients died—many with evidence of cardiac injury, which caused the researchers to stop part of the study before it was completed. Unfortunately, that study also did not include a placebo arm on the grounds that the researchers thought it would be “unethical” to deprive study participants access to the drug. But given that there is no idea whether the drug causes more harm than benefit, this appeal to ethics might itself be considered unethical.
A month after telling doctors that prescribing hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine was okay, on April 24 the FDA issued a new advisory suggesting that the drugs should only be prescribed to patients who are in the hospital or enrolled in a clinical trial. While this may or may not cut down on potentially dangerous prescriptions, it won’t do much to improve medical knowledge, because trials enrolling patients in the United States right now lack appropriate control arms, aren’t blinded, are underpowered, or have other serious design flaws.
When it comes to remdesivir, based on one trial and ignoring a negative trial, Dr. Fauci has declared remdesivir to be, in essence, the de facto standard of care for treating hospitalized patients with COVID-19. That premature adoption means we might never know how well it actually works or if it even does work. This pronouncement and the EUA from the FDA for remdesivir (issued Friday), mean that, from now on, studies (at least of hospitalized COVID-19 patients) can’t be carried out with a placebo control anymore because it would be considered unethical. All of these studies, going forward, will have to test standard of care (now remdesivir) against standard of care plus new experimental therapeutic.
And:
Perhaps patients should be forgiven for continuing to grasp at unproven remedies for a frightening disease. But what about the physicians and researchers, not to mention politicians, arguing that there is no time for randomized controlled trials? Many hold up Raoult, Zelenko, the Chicago trial, and other poorly designed studies as proof that hydroxychloroquine and remdesivir work. They are, in effect, saying that it’s better to make a decision based on bad studies now than to wait for the results of properly controlled ones. But given that bad studies are as likely to be wrong as right—and probably more likely to be wrong because they typically are biased toward the result desired by the researcher or study sponsor—why bother with a study at all? Why not try anything—prayer, iridology, homeopathy? At least those are less likely than the drugs to cause dangerous side effects.
How about intercessory prayer? No, I’m serious. This news story was all over social media this weekend about a randomized clinical trial being carried out to test whether intercessory prayer results in better outcomes in COVID-19 patients. (Here’s the ClinicalTrials.gov entry, if you don’t believe me.) It’s not even recruiting yet, but NPR did a news story about it on Friday!
Although we have not seen a pandemic like this in over 100 years, some things never change. Human nature, for instance, doesn’t change, and, now as then, physicians hate feeling powerless against a disease for which they have no disease-specific therapy, leaving them supportive care alone while hoping the patient can ride out the disease and recover. The culture of medicine is very much biased to “do something, anything” with an attitude of, “What’s the harm?” when a patient is facing imminent death. As Lenzer and Brownlee argue, though, yes, some people will die waiting for properly designed and conducted randomized clinical trials, but in the end that toll is likely to be far less than if early treatment attempts are based on bad science without proper controls. Thus far, thanks to politics, social media, old media, and opportunistic snake oil salesmen, we are failing COVID-19 patients when it comes to assuring that new treatments are based on rigorous science. Sadly, it turns out that most physicians are not nearly as dedicated to science-based medicine as they would like to believe.

The confluence of antivaccine beliefs and conspiracy theories in COVID-19 denial
It surprised some people that after the COVID-19 pandemic hit our shores antivaxxers so quickly joined forces with COVID-19 conspiracy theorists. It shouldn’t have been a surprise. Antivaxxer beliefs are themselves rooted deep in conspiracy theories.
David Gorski on September 28, 2020
Link

If there’s one thing that the COVID-19 pandemic has made crystal clear, it’s that the antivaccine movement is at its heart driven by a conspiracy theory—multiple conspiracy theories, actually. The primary conspiracy theory behind the antivaccine movement is that “they” (“they” being the CDC, big pharma, the government, the medical profession) “know” that vaccines cause autism, autoimmune diseases, and all the other conditions and diseases attributed to vaccines by antivaxxers but that “they” are keeping the data and evidence showing the links between vaccines and these conditions from you. Most antivaccine conspiracy theories are variants of this kind of conspiracy theory. The two main examples are the Simpsonwood conspiracy theory popularized by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. in 2005, which claimed that the CDC “knew” that the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that was used in several childhood vaccines until 2001 was the cause of “autism” but massaged the data to make the link go away, and the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory popularized by Del Bigtree and Andrew Wakefield in their conspiracy movie disguised as a documentary VAXXED in 2016, which claimed that the CDC “knew” that the MMR vaccine causes autism in African-American boys but massaged the data—you guessed it!—to make the link go away.
Early in the pandemic, there were naïve people who thought that the possibility of a deadly infectious disease for which there was no preexisting immunity would make antivaxxers reconsider their views on vaccines, if only out of self-interest to avoid death or the debilitating aftereffects due to COVID-19 infections. There was also some hope that this was the chance for antivaxxers to “put their money where their mouth is” when it came to their claim that, instead of vaccines, they could simply quarantine and avoid others if their children got measles, by actually supporting and following public health measures designed to slow the spread of COVID-19. So when COVID-19 denial became widespread, along with numerous conspiracy theories about, for example how the causative virus SARS-CoV-2 was “engineered” in a laboratory, how 5G is the real cause of the pandemic, how the whole pandemic is a “plandemic“, how the flu vaccine supposedly increases your chances of getting COVID-19 (it doesn’t), and a wide variety of other medical conspiracy theories (in particular Bill Gates conspiracy theories), it was no surprise that by April the antivaccine movement had thoroughly allied itself with COVID-19 deniers. COVID-19 deniers were soon using language reminiscent of the antivaccine movement (such as “I do not consent; I do not comply”) while antivaxxers were launching a pre-emptive disinformation war against COVID-19 vaccines that hadn’t yet been approved (and still aren’t). Meanwhile, antivaccine quacks are taking full advantage to peddle their quackery. Soon antivaxxers were fully involved in peddling unproven treatments for COVID-19, such as hydroxychloroquine and bleach.
What spurred me to write about this topic again was a reminder sent to me of just how deeply antivaxxers have embedded themselves into the conspiracy world. In a week and a half, Donald Trump’s Doral Hotel will host a conference of Trump supporters, QAnon conspiracy theorists, and antivaxxers:
But next month, as the COVID-19 virus could very well be entering an expected second wave, one of Trump’s hotels will become a hub for anti-vaccine activism. Some of the most notorious figures in the anti-vaccine movement are set to converge on the president’s Trump National Doral Miami resort in early October for a MAGA-world conference.
The anti-vaccine figures won’t be the only fringe GOP movement represented at Trump’s property during the American Priority Conference or “AMPFest”, which runs from October 8-11. They’ll be joined by top QAnon conspiracy theory promoters, including one with a history of anti-Semitic remarks.
There’s even a pool party.
Anti-vaccine heavyweights Robert Kennedy Jr. and Del Bigtree are scheduled to appear in early October at Doral Miami for the MAGA-heavy AMPFest, a conglomeration of Trumpworld personalities now in its third year that was started by a handful of conservative internet activists as a more explicitly pro-Trump alternative to the Conservative Political Action Conference.
Del Bigtree and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. are two of the heaviest heavyweights in the antivaccine movement at the moment, up there with Andrew Wakefield himself. In antivax world, it doesn’t get much bigger than them, and we’ve written about them here on many occasions. You might recall Del Bigtree. He produced the antivax conspiracyfest of a movie VAXXED, donned a yellow Star of David to liken the “plight” of antivaxxers to that of Jews in Nazi-occupied Europe, and, most recently, was urging everyone to “catch this cold” (COVID-19) to reach herd immunity because, according to him, it’s only deadly to the old and sick. Meanwhile, RFK Jr. has been a leader of the antivaccine movement since 2005, when he popularized the Simpsonwood conspiracy theory. In more recent years, he’s been trying to recruit African-Americans to the antivax cause, claiming that vaccines and glyphosate are responsible for the obesity epidemic, labeling the current generation of children the “sickest generation” (because of vaccines, of course), and (also of course) going all-in on COVID-19 conspiracy theories.
I perused the list of speakers for AMPFest 2020 and was not so much surprised that there were antivaxxers on the bill, but how many there are. First of all, RFK Jr. is not just a speaker at the conference, he’s a headliner, which is rather amusing given how long he’s been a liberal icon and that AMPFest is a full MAGAfest of a conference, organized by Trump supporters to lionize Trump. Notice how he’s featured in the advertising:
https://www.facebook.com/PriorityConference/posts/1212653122427692
He’s right up there with Roger Stone, Matt Gaetz, and Cory Lewandowski! Interestingly, though, this ad was from over two weeks ago, and I no longer see his name on the list of speakers on the AMP website itself, which makes me wonder if he’s still on there. Del Bigtree is still on the bill, complete with a photo, but I don’t see RFK Jr.’s name.
Be that as it may, other antivaxxers include Shannon Kroner, who’s known for having organized an antivax discussion full of false balance; Theresa Deisher, who came up with the idea that fetal DNA in Gardasil gets into the brain and causes neuroinflammation, resulting in autism; Mikki Willis, a director who made the COVID-19 conspiracy film masquerading as a documentary Plandemic and its sequel; and James Neuenschwander, a physician into alternative medicine who runs something called the Bio Energy Medical Center, who was originally going to be on Shannon Kroner’s antivaccine panel but ended up not being on it. Unsurprisingly, all the docs on this speakers’ bill are quacks; indeed Dr. Neuenschwander offers CEASE therapy for autism, a therapy based on homeopathy, and IV vitamin C and chelation therapy.
I’m guessing that there are other antivaxxers in the lineup as well, just that I’m not familiar with them. Most of them are a variety of Trump supporters, QAnon conspiracy theory adherents, and a variety of other science denialists and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and grifters. It’s a new thing for AMPFest to feature so many antivaxxers, too:
The prominence of anti-vaccine figures on the AMPFest program marks a change for American Priority, whose earlier conferences didn’t prominently feature vaccine opponents. And it comes amid a flood of medical disinformation about the coronavirus pandemic. AMPFest’s 2019 iteration became briefly infamous after the conference played an edited video from 2014 action movie Kingsman: The Secret Service that showed Trump massacring his political critics and media figures in a church.
The Trump Organization didn’t respond to a request for comment about the anti-vaccine figures appearing at Doral Miami. American Priority president Alex Phillips didn’t address the new prominence of anti-vaccine figures on this year’s program in an email to The Daily Beast, writing instead that AMPFest doesn’t have “ideological purity tests” for speakers.
“We as an organization respect the sanctity of free speech and free association as a cornerstone of the American constitution,” Phillips wrote in an email to The Daily Beast.
There are also antimaskers, such as Tina Forte, and, unsurprisingly, most of the antivaxxers appearing at the conference have also glommed on to COVID-19 denialism and grift, which is why they fit in so well with this group:
Speakers scheduled to appear at the conference include Robert F. Kennedy Jr., known for spreading misinformation about vaccinations, and Dr. Simone Gold, who in July appeared in a viral video, later tweeted by Trump, in which she claimed hydroxychloroquine cures Covid-19, among other misleading assertions. (Gold appeared in the video with Dr. Stella Immanuel, who gained notice for claiming elsewhere that sex with demons in dreams causes illness.) The conference bills Gold, who says she met in July with Vice President Mike Pence, as “censored,” in an apparent reference to social media companies removing the video for promoting coronavirus misinformation.
Stone has gone further than Gold in that regard. In an April 13 radio interview with Joe Piscopo on New York City’s AM970, Stone floated a bizarre and false theory that Bill Gates helped to create coronavirus so that he can plant microchips in people’s heads. “He and other globalists are using it for mandatory vaccinations and microchipping people so we know if they’ve been tested,” Stone said, summarizing a theory he described as “open for vigorous debate.”
Given that COVID-19 deniers and conspiracy theorists often consort with QAnon believers, it’s not surprising that antivaxxers are speaking at this conference with QAnon promoters:
The speaker’s line-up also includes Matt Couch, an internet conspiracy theorist being sued by the brother of murdered Democratic National Committee staffer Seth Rich.
QAnon conspiracy theory promoters are also set to appear at Doral Miami. Tracy Diaz, who uses the alias “Tracy Beanz” online, was one of the first QAnon promoters and is scheduled to speak at AMPFest. So is DeAnna Lorraine Tesoriero, a failed GOP congressional candidate and QAnon supporter who was recently hired at conspiracy theory outlet InfoWars.
AMPFest’s line-up also includes Zach Vorhies, a conspiracy theorist with a history of anti-Semitic remarks. Vorhies initially earned some fame on the right after serving as a “whistleblower” for undercover conservative operative James O’Keefe. But Vorhies has a long record of anti-Semitic remarks, once alleging that “Zionists” killed Andrew Breitbart and that Israel planned 9/11.
QAnon, remember, is a conspiracy theory that claims that there is a cabal of Satan-worshiping pedophiles who are plotting against President Trump while running a global sex trafficking ring. Many of them also believe that, in addition to molesting children, members of this group kill and eat their victims in order to extract a life-extending chemical from their blood. Basically, QAnon is the very old antisemitic conspiracy known as the Blood Libel, rebranded and revamped for the Facebook century. For those not familiar with it, the Blood Libel is:
A secret cabal is taking over the world. They kidnap children, slaughter, and eat them to gain power from their blood. They control high positions in government, banks, international finance, the news media, and the church. They want to disarm the police. They promote homosexuality and pedophilia. They plan to mongrelize the white race so it will lose its essential power.
Does this conspiracy theory sound familiar? It is. The same narrative has been repackaged by QAnon.
I have studied and worked to prevent genocide for forty years. Genocide Watch and the Alliance Against Genocide, the first international anti-genocide coalition, see such hate-filled conspiracy theories as early warning signs of deadly genocidal violence.
The plot, described above, was the conspiracy “revealed” in the most influential anti-Jewish pamphlet of all time. It was called The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. It was written by Russian anti-Jewish propagandists around 1902. It collected myths about a Jewish plot to take over the world that had existed for hundreds of years. Central to its mythology was the Blood Libel, which claimed that Jews kidnapped and slaughtered Christian children and drained their blood to mix in the dough for matzos consumed on Jewish holidays.
The Nazis published a children’s book of the Protocols that they required in the curriculum of every primary school in Germany. The Nazi newspaper, Der Stürmer (derived from the German word for “Storm”) spread the Blood Libel. Hitler’s Mein Kampf, his narcissistic autobiography and manifesto for his battle against the Jewish plot to rule the world, copied his conspiracy theories from the Protocols.
I’ve mentioned before that my primary gateway into conspiracy theories and pseudoscience was while refuting online Holocaust denial in the late 1990s. Then my interest widened to medical quackery and the antivaccine movement, then to more general skepticism. During that time, I learned a lot about the far right, fascism, neo-Nazi movements, and antisemitic conspiracy theories, of which Holocaust denial is among the most vile. I never thought that, 20 years later, my knowledge of these topics would be so useful. I should have realized, though, that knowledge of conspiracy theories is always useful for a skeptic. The reason is that conspiracy theories are at the heart of pretty much every form of science denial that there is.
I once coined a term, the central dogma of alternative medicine, to describe the belief that we have near-total control over our health through lifestyle, such as diet, activity, exercise, and a Secret-like belief that wishing makes it so. Antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers share that mystical, magical belief system in which they are healthy entirely because of their choices, and they (and their children) are not at risk of horrible outcomes due to infectious disease because of their choices. It never occurs to them that age is a major risk factor for death from COVID-19 and that people can’t do anything about how old they were when the pandemic hit. Similarly, it never seems to trouble antivaxxers like Bigtree or COVID-19 deniers, the vast majority of whom are white and at least middle class if not affluent, that COVID-19 has exacted a much worse toll on African-Americans and other people of color, who are far more likely to suffer severe disease and die. It should thus not be surprising that antivaxxers are so at home among antisemitic conspiracy theories.
But why are conspiracy theories so important to science denial? I’ve always thought that it was because, when you don’t have facts or science on your side, you need to have a reason to explain why the entire medical, scientific, or history establishment believes something different than you do and considers your beliefs to be quackery, pseudoscience, or pseudohistory. So you construct a conspiracy theory that makes you the hero, someone who, with only a few others, shares hidden knowledge that is being suppressed by dark and powerful forces. If, for example, you’re a creationist, then it’s a cabal of dogmatic atheist Darwinists preventing your knowledge from being accepted. If you’re a 9/11 Truther, it must be the cabal in the government that, according to your conspiracy theory, was actually responsible for the attacks who must be responsible for the “official narrative”. If you’re a cancer quack, it’s a cabal of big pharma, the FDA, and the oncology establishment preventing your cancer “cure” from being accepted as mainstream. If you’re a QAnon believer, it’s a cabal of powerful people (nearly all liberal and/or Democrats) suppressing the “truth”. If you’re a Holocaust denier, it’s obviously the Jews keeping your knowledge from being accepted. If you’re a climate science denier, it obviously must be a cabal of climate scientists and liberals who want to impose government control of industry. If you’re an antivaxxer, then of course it’s a cabal consisting of the CDC, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the medical profession, big pharma, and Bill Gates. And if you’re a COVID-19 denier, it must be the CDC, big pharma, pro-vaxxers who want a vaccine (enter Bill Gates again!), the government (who wants to control you), and others suppressing the “truth”.
No wonder antivaxxers fit in so well at this conference. No wonder antivaxxers rapidly allied themselves with COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and became leaders in the movement opposing public health interventions for COVID-19 that includes antimaskers, lockdown protesters, and the like.
Unfortunately, too many people discount conspiracy theories as obvious nonsense, fit only for ridicule:
While ridicule is an appropriate response to many conspiracy theories, it’s a mistake not to take conspiracy theories seriously. Much of the harm in the world is based on conspiracy theories, and many genocides have conspiracy theories at their heart. Conspiracy theories are also a major impediment to controlling childhood disease, addressing climate change, and, right now, remain one of the most intractable barriers, if not the most intractable barrier, to controlling the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Great Barrington Declaration: COVID-19 deniers follow the path laid down by creationists, HIV/AIDS denialists, and climate science deniers
Apparently signed by thousands of scientists, the Great Barrington Declaration argues that lockdowns in response to the coronavirus pandemic do more harm than good and that society should use “Focused Protection” for the elderly and those at high risk for severe disease and death from COVID-19 while letting the young go about their business normally. A closer look reveals that COVID-19 deniers are taking a page from a very old denialist propaganda playbook.
David Gorski on October 12, 2020
Link

When you’ve been examining pseudoscientific and quack claims for over two decades, you start to recognize patterns in the strategies and technique used by those denying science to promote their pseudoscience or quackery. Those who don’t pay attention to these sorts of issues might have been surprised by or unfamiliar with these techniques, but many skeptics were not. I was thinking about this sort of thing when I came across the latest propaganda from COVID-19 deniers, conspiracy theorists, and grifters known as the Great Barrington Declaration.
While I had heard rumblings of this “declaration” a few days ago, what really tweaked me to write about the Great Barrington Declaration in particular (and the history of such documents in general) was this Tweet from Herman Cain’s Twitter account:
So uh, why aren't the media listening to *these* scientists? https://t.co/AnOibhGMU1
— The Cain Gang (@THEHermanCain) October 10, 2020
The thing about this Tweet that is simultaneously amusing and horrifying is that it comes from the Twitter account of a man who died of COVID-19 and whose account is being maintained by…whoever. To see such an account Tweeting a link that makes unscientific claims about COVID-19 under the slogan “Listen to the science” on Herman Cain’s actual website is horrifying:
“Listen to the science.”
That’s been the rallying cry of the left on a myriad of issues over the past several years: abortion, sex and gender, climate change and, most recently, the coronavirus.
Never mind the fact that objective science often disagrees with the left’s contentions.
So, they should be happy to reopen the country now that over 6,500 scientists and medical professionals have signed an anti-lockdown petition, according to the U.K. Daily Mail.
The petition, written by Dr. Sunetra Gupta of the University of Oxford, Dr. Martin Kulldorff of Harvard and Dr. Jay Bhattacharya of Stanford, calls for the United States and the United Kingdom to end their lockdowns and promotes allowing the virus to spread among young people in order to build herd immunity.
The Great Barrington Declaration itself bemoans “lower childhood vaccination rates, worsening cardiovascular disease outcomes, fewer cancer screenings and deteriorating mental health,” claiming that these issues will lead to “greater excess mortality in years to come, with the working class and younger members of society carrying the heaviest burden,” the declaration advocates protecting the vulnerable (which the writers call “Focused Protection”) while basically letting COVID-19 race through the population in order to reach herd immunity:
Adopting measures to protect the vulnerable should be the central aim of public health responses to COVID-19. By way of example, nursing homes should use staff with acquired immunity and perform frequent PCR testing of other staff and all visitors. Staff rotation should be minimized. Retired people living at home should have groceries and other essentials delivered to their home. When possible, they should meet family members outside rather than inside. A comprehensive and detailed list of measures, including approaches to multi-generational households, can be implemented, and is well within the scope and capability of public health professionals.
Those who are not vulnerable should immediately be allowed to resume life as normal. Simple hygiene measures, such as hand washing and staying home when sick should be practiced by everyone to reduce the herd immunity threshold. Schools and universities should be open for in-person teaching. Extracurricular activities, such as sports, should be resumed. Young low-risk adults should work normally, rather than from home. Restaurants and other businesses should open. Arts, music, sport and other cultural activities should resume. People who are more at risk may participate if they wish, while society as a whole enjoys the protection conferred upon the vulnerable by those who have built up herd immunity.
On the surface, this sounds oh-so-reasonable. However, saying that we should aim for “herd immunity” is a common trope of COVID-19 deniers. While there are certainly valid concerns about potential negative effects of lockdowns and business closures on various health and economic measures and how society should balance the positive effects of preventing death from coronavirus infection versus the negative effects of restrictive measures designed to slow the spread of COVID-19, the statement above recommends a dangerous course not advocated by the vast majority of public health officials and infectious disease epidemiologists.
I’ll discuss why that’s the case in a moment, but first I’d like to take a trip down memory lane to revisit various examples of science denialists using similar “declarations,” “petitions,” and “open letters” to give the false appearance of strong scientific support for their positions. Why? Because declarations like this, although they can be used for good (such as when US climate scientists recently signed an open letter to Congress reaffirming the overwhelming scientific consensus that human activity is the primary driver of climate change and the overall warming of the climate), more frequently such letters are propaganda for pseudoscience. Indeed, such “declarations,” “open letters,” and “petitions” signed by physicians and scientists represent a technique that goes back at least to the tobacco companies lining up lists of doctors to testify to the safety of cigarettes. (One particularly ludicrous example from R.J. Reynolds in the 1940s claimed that 113,597 doctors preferred their cigarettes.) The idea was (and is) to give the false impression of a scientific controversy where none exists and to appeal to the authority of scientists and doctors to support their claims. It’s a technique that John Cook has referred to as the “magnified minority”:
Magnified minority is a denial technique amplifying the contrarians' significance to convey the impression of expert disagreement. The Global Warming Petition Project uses this technique: it amounts to less than 1% of U.S. science graduates (full video at https://t.co/RztsTyiyG9) pic.twitter.com/e9jHZH4qmg
— John Cook (@johnfocook) October 8, 2020
In this, the Great Barrington Declaration is only a little different, but at its heart it’s the same technique from the same old playbook, with that “little difference” being that COVID-19 is a new disease and the scientific consensus regarding it isn’t as solid as the consensus is in the case of, for example, evolution, climate science, and vaccines. However, I’m quick to point out that that doesn’t mean that there aren’t wrong answers. The answers just have to be farther afield to be clearly outside of the wider range of scientific consensus, and that’s the case with the Great Barrington Declaration, as I’ll discuss. First, let’s start with my very first exposure to such propaganda, an example that I encountered around 14 years ago.
Creationists against evolution
The first example of these “declarations,” “petitions,” or “open letters” (or whatever you want to call them) that I personally remember consisted of two such letters. The first was “Scientific Dissent from Darwinism,” a statement against evolution (which creationists love to refer to as “Darwinism,” as though evolution science hasn’t advanced since the 19th century when Darwin lived) by “scientists,” and “Physicians and Surgeons Who Dissent From Darwinism,” signed by, of course, physicians and surgeons going under the moniker of “Physicians and Surgeons for Scientific Integrity.” Of course, one thing that I noted right away about the latter letter is that physicians and surgeons are not experts in evolution and, alas, receive far less training in evolution than I personally think they should get. If you don’t believe me, just check out posts by our fearless leader Steve Novella, Harriet Hall (although I don’t agree with her conclusion that there’s nothing in “evolutionary medicine” that wouldn’t be concluded anyway and therefore as a discipline it adds little of value), and, yes, yours truly, that discuss the importance of evolutionary medicine.
What we see in letters like this can be demonstrated by quoting “Physicians and Surgeons Who Dissent From Darwinism,” discussed in more detail here:
As medical doctors we are skeptical of the claims for the ability of random mutation and natural selection to account for the origination and complexity of life and we therefore dissent from Darwinian macroevolution as a viable theory. This does not imply the endorsement of any alternative theory.
Obviously, one difference here between this “dissent” and that of the Great Barrington Declaration is that this “dissent” doesn’t endorse any “alternative theory”, unlike the Barrington signatories, who endorse a specific different approach to the COVID-19 pandemic. On the other hand, in the case of this “dissent from Darwin,” the preferred alternative was implied, not explicitly stated. The group that promoted this list was the Discovery Institute, which has long promoted “intelligent design” creationism over evolution as the explanation for the diversity of life. This approach is rooted in the same sort of doubt and uncertainty being sowed about our current understanding of what the sciences of epidemiology and public health tell us about how to combat the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, if you look at the most recent actual list of signatories that I could find using the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org, you’ll soon see that none of these physicians show any evidence that they have any special expertise in evolutionary biology. Indeed, I always find it most telling that only five medical oncologists in the whole world signed on to the list. After all, if there’s any specialty that recognizes the primacy of evolution, it’s oncology, where physicians are always dealing with the evolution of resistance to therapy by tumors under the selective pressure of chemotherapy and other treatments. Of course, overall, only a few hundred physicians, at most, signed this statement; so even that’s not an impressive number.
Amusingly and unsurprisingly, one of them was Dr. Michael Egnor, a creationist neurosurgeon whose nonsense about evolution I cut my skeptical teeth refuting even as I joked about putting a paper bag over my head in shame over how one of my “own,” a surgeon, could say such ridiculous things. None of this kept “intelligent design” creationism supporter Bill Dembski from touting the doctors’ statement, even as these physicians bemoaned their “persecution” at the hands of those evil Darwinists:
Sadly, academic freedom is no longer assured in America and other countries. This is especially true when it involves espousing views contrary to the theory of Darwinian macroevolution. Numerous instances have been documented where scientists and teachers have been censored and even removed from their positions for facilitating open discussion of the empirical problems of the dominant theory. In fact, one scientist who simply followed procedures in allowing a controversial article to be peer-reviewed and then published in the journal he edited, was publicly vilified and relentlessly persecuted.[1]
As academia has suppressed freedom of speech in this area, another avenue needs to be available to promote accurate knowledge and the free exchange of ideas concerning the debate over Darwinism and alternative theories on origins. To accomplish that goal, Physicians and Surgeons for Scientific Integrity (PSSI) has been established. PSSI is a means for physicians and surgeons to be counted among those skeptical of nature-driven Darwinian macroevolution.
Because cranks always portray criticism of their pseudoscience as “persecution”.
The “scientific dissent from Darwinism” (which was a project of the Discovery Institute and, as hard as it is to believe, can still be found on the web here, rather than requiring me to go to Archive.org) states:
We are skeptical of claims for the ability of random mutation and natural selection to account for the complexity of life. Careful examination of the evidence for Darwinian theory should be encouraged.
That’s nice.
This statement and list are even more ridiculous. After all, one can understand that most physicians are not scientists, but rather highly trained and skilled practitioners who apply science to treat patients, but this second list is supposed to be made up of real scientists. Hilariously, Dr. Egnor makes another appearance on the list, and if you peruse the list you’ll find that the vast majority of the scientists on the list are not evolutionary biologists or even biologists. There are a number of physicists, chemists, engineers, physicians, and the like, but a marked paucity of actual evolutionary biologists.
Amusingly, so ridiculous was this list, that the National Center for Science Education started a parody list called “Project Steve” that consisted of scientists named Steve who accept the science supporting evolution (in fairness, NCSE also accepted Stephens, Stevens, Stephanies, Stefans, and so forth and noted that Etiennes and Estebans would have also been welcome):
Creationists draw up these lists to try to convince the public that evolution is somehow being rejected by scientists, that it is a “theory in crisis.” Not everyone realizes that this claim is unfounded. NCSE has been asked numerous times to compile a list of thousands of scientists affirming the validity of the theory of evolution. Although we easily could have done so, we have resisted. We did not wish to mislead the public into thinking that scientific issues are decided by who has the longer list of scientists!
Project Steve pokes fun at this practice and, because “Steves” are only about 1% of scientists, it also makes the point that tens of thousands of scientists support evolution. And it honors the late Stephen Jay Gould, evolutionary biologist, NCSE supporter, and friend.
The current count of Steves who’ve signed the list is 1,470 as of August 12. NCSE also noted that it was not going to do similar lists for “Janes, Johns, and so on” because “it’s only funny once.”
“Reassessing” HIV as the cause of AIDS
This technique of compiling lists of scientists in order to give the appearance that the science being attacked is “in crisis” and the alternative denialists propose is scientifically legitimate is much older than 15 years. Indeed, the oldest one I paid attention to was first published a group called “The Group for the Scientific Reappraisal of the HIV-AIDS Hypothesis,” whose most prominent member was Peter Duesberg:
It is widely believed by the general public that a retrovirus called HIV causes the group of diseases called AIDS. Many biochemical scientists now question this hypothesis. We propose that a thorough reappraisal of the existing evidence for and against this hypothesis be conducted by a suitable independent group. We further propose that critical epidemiological studies be devised and undertaken.
Of course, HIV was identified and isolated as the causative virus for AIDS in 1984, and by 1991 the evidence in support of this hypothesis was overwhelming. This group tried to get the statement published in a number of scientific journals, but failed; that is, until 1995, when, inexplicably, Science published a version of it:
In 1991, we, the Group for the Scientific Reappraisal of the HIV/AIDS Hypothesis, became dissatisfied with the state of the evidence that the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) did, in fact, cause AIDS.
Specifically, we have proposed that researchers independent of the HIV establishment should audit the Centers for Disease Control’s records of AIDS cases, bearing in mind that the correlation of HIV with AIDS, upon which the case for HIV causation rests, is itself an artefact of the definition of AIDS. Since 1985, exactly the same diseases or conditions have been defined as “AIDS” when antibodies are present, and as “non-AIDS” when HIV and antibodies are absent. Independent professional groups such as the Society of Actuaries should be invited to nominate members for an independent commission to investigate the following question: How frequently do AIDS-defining diseases (or low T cell counts) occur in the absence of HIV? Until we have a definition of AIDS that is independent of HIV, the supposed correlation of HIV and AIDS is mere tautology.
Other independent researchers should examine the validity of the so-called “AIDS tests,” especially when these tests are used in Africa and Southern Asia, to see if they reliably record the presence of antibodies, let alone live and replicating virus.
The bottom line is this: the skeptics are eager to see the results of independent scientific testing. Those who uphold the HIV “party line” have so far refused. We object.
Of course, since even 1995, the evidence linking HIV to AIDS has become even stronger, particularly, as Dr. Novella noted, given how anti-retroviral drug cocktails targeting HIV have resulted in the conversion of HIV infection from a virtual death sentence to making it a chronic, manageable disease whose sufferers can, with treatment, live almost a normal lifespan. Unfortunately, as with forms of denial such as antivaccine misinformation, HIV/AIDS denial has real-world consequences in the form of the unnecessary deaths of people infected with the retrovirus, people such as Christine Maggiore and her daughter.
And all the rest
There are a number of other examples of similar statements/petitions/declarations signed by scientists designed to give the impression that the pseudoscientific or quack viewpoint in question has major scientific support. Unsurprisingly, climate science denialists have made use of this particular propaganda technique; for example, an open letter to the United Nations by the Netherlands-based Climate Intelligence Foundation (Clintel) and promoted by “Friends of Science,” a Canada-based “non-profit organization run by dedicated volunteers comprised mainly of active and retired earth and atmospheric scientists, engineers, and other professionals, claiming that there is “no climate emergency“. This “no climate emergency” is a line that Clintel in particular has been promoting. Unsurprisingly, it has been widely reported that the Friends of Science is a front group funded by Calgary’s fossil fuel industry, while, as is the usual case in these letters, very few the 500 or so signatories to the “no climate emergency” statement have any actual background in climate science, as noted by Desmogblog, while many of the signatories are well-known climate science deniers. Several years earlier, climate science denialists sent a similar letter, signed by 125 scientist to the UN Secretary-General peddling the same discredited tropes. Again, few of the signatories had any background in climate science, with most of them being engineers, physicists, geologists, and the like and one being a professor of marketing (appropriate, given that this letter was propaganda).
There are multiple other such “petitions” and “open letters” by climate science deniers, including the Oregon Petition, the International Conference on Climate Change, and the Cornwall Alliance, among others.
Perhaps my favorite such letter is the AE911Truth Petition. Yes, it’s a petition by a group adhering to the “9/11 truth” conspiracy theory that claims that the World Trade Center towers could not have been brought down by jet liners crashing into them and that the “conventional” narrative is wrong. They generally also claim that, because the crashes alone supposedly couldn’t have brought down the towers, there must have been explosives planted to result in a “controlled demolition”, perhaps as part of an “inside job”, and that’s what the petition states:
On Behalf of the People of the United States of America, the undersigned Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth and affiliates hereby petition for, and demand, a truly independent investigation with subpoena power in order to uncover the full truth surrounding the events of 9/11/01 — specifically the collapses of the World Trade Center Towers and Building 7. We believe there is sufficient doubt about the official story and therefore the 9/11 investigation must be re-opened and must include a full inquiry into the possible use of explosives that might have been the actual cause of the destruction of the World Trade Center Twin Towers and Building 7.
Sadly, it’s signed by over 3,000 architects and engineers. AE911Truth contends that these are, unlike the case for letters “dissenting from Darwin” or “doubting climate science,” supposedly actual experts who could make such a conclusion; other engineers point out a number of problems, for example:
Only a handful of architects and engineers question the NIST Report, but they have never come up with an alternative. Although at first blush it may seem impressive that these people don’t believe the NIST Report, remember that there are 123,000 members of ASCE (American Society of Civil Engineers) who do not question the NIST Report. There are also 80,000 members of AIA (American Institute of Architects) who do not question the NIST Report.
Although their field of expertise is not related to the construction of buildings – they don’t seem to have a problem with that over at AE911truth – there are also 120,000 members of ASME (American Society of Mechanical Engineers) who do not question the NIST report. There are also 370,000 members of IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) who do not question the NIST report. There are also 40,000 members of AIChE (American Institute of Chemical Engineers) who do not question the NIST Report. There are also 35,000 members of AIAA (American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics) who do not question the NIST report. So who would you rather believe?
It’s also noted that, although this group “questions” the “official 9/11 narrative”, they don’t present “any calculations that show how the NIST Report is wrong.”
But where are the antivaxxers?
One of the odd things that I realized as I was researching and writing this post was that I didn’t remember any such declarations or petitions with lists of doctors and/or scientists like this promoted by the antivaccine movement, and I’ve been paying attention to the movement since at least 2000. This troubled me, because if there’s a form of quackery and pseudoscience that I’d have thought would use the false authority of a list of scientists and doctors, it would be the antivaccine movement. There have been many “open letters” from “health freedom” and “medical freedom” organizations, for example this letter from the European Forum for Vaccine Vigilance to the World Health Organization. Yet the list of signatories appears not to include a single doctor or scientist, but does include Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and a lot of antivaccine and “health freedom” organizations. There have also been such “open letters” by lawyers on the constitutionality of school vaccine mandates, but I was unable to find anything like the letters by creationists, HIV/AIDS deniers, 9/11 Truthers, and the like.
I can only speculate, but I suspect it’s probably one or the other (or a combination of two) reasons. First, I suspect that the number of scientists and doctors who are antivaccine enough to be willing to sign their names to such a document is so small that it would not be very impressive or convincing. Second, many antivaccine doctors are into “autism biomed” quackery and grift. It’s possible that they are reluctant to “go public” and draw the attention of the FDA or state medical boards to their activities. These reasons could be wrong, but they are all I could come up with.
This brings me back to the Great Barrington Declaration.
Herd immunity against COVID-19 is likely not achievable without a vaccine
The Great Barrington Declaration basically argues these points (with my comments in brackets):
    • Lockdowns are seriously impacting public health (arguable); and
    • The SARS-Cov-2, the virus that causes COVID-19 is not as dangerous to the young as it is to the old (true but deceptive); therefore,
    • We should protect the vulnerable, such as the elderly (which means basically those over 50 or 60 years old—which could include me) and those with comorbidities known to increase the risk of life-threatening disease from COVID-19, such as obesity, diabetes, and hypertension (not as easily done as implied); and
    • The young should be allowed to go about business normally, with “simple hygiene measures, such as hand washing and staying home when sick” being “practiced by everyone to reduce the herd immunity threshold,” as high-risk vulnerable groups are protected.
On the surface, it all sounds so reasonable, but there are a lot of issues with this proposed solution, as a number of epidemiologists have pointed out. Also, as is the case with most such letters, while a handful of the signatories are actual experts, the vast majority are not. Worse, those promoting the Declaration haven’t been too careful about vetting their “expert” signatories:
The statement claims to have been signed by more than 6,000 medical scientists, but anyone can sign up claiming to be one (there are a number of fake medical signatories on the list, including a Dr Harold Shipman). When Sky News pressed one of the co-authors on this, he said: “We do not have the resources to audit each signature.” Consider what this approach would mean for scientific endeavour were it applied more broadly. And what are scientists doing fronting a campaign whose back office is run by a thinktank that flirts with climate change denial?
Examples include:
Okay I take it back, some very big names have signed this Great Barrington Declaration. #COVIDUK /thread pic.twitter.com/iKCpwgWAJ1
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
COCONUTS pic.twitter.com/M4yHMYaauo
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
HI EVERYBODY pic.twitter.com/8c7MIN1Sn4
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
Paging Dr Oakeshott pic.twitter.com/0HoOZb6EEV
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
Lipup Fatty has been banned in the U.K. since 1992 pic.twitter.com/YxYfEg7KGP
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
Bernard Castle is actual British slang for “pathetic excuse”. (This is 100% true). pic.twitter.com/7ITl9R1BK1
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
But in all seriousness 20-30% of these signatories are clearly a joke, and there is no verification in place. This was only the first page.
These headlines are very misleading.
— Dr Dominic Pimenta MD (@DrDomPimenta) October 9, 2020
Hilariously, the admins for the Declaration claim that only 0.1% of its signatories aren’t real:
The admins of #GreatBarringtonDeclaration have been working scrupulously all day and have found a 0.1% false positive rate on signatures (mostly due to trolls who announced themselves on Twitter). The attacks are desperate at this point. https://t.co/09sKNMeTLG
— Jeffrey A Tucker (@jeffreyatucker) October 10, 2020
As amusing as it is to laugh at those behind the Declaration and their foolishness, basically allowing anybody to sign it claiming to be a scientists (indeed, apparently the website’s admins have removed the search function from their website, so embarrassed are the scientists behind the Declaration over the fake signatures), let’s look at the claims in the Barrington Declaration itself. I like to start out with this rebuttal by The Real Truther to the claim that lockdowns are causing missed vaccine appointments, cancer screenings, surgeries, and deteriorating mental health when ALL are actually consequences of the pandemic:
Not only did no government mandate restrict vaccine appointments, the CDC actually issued guidance in March to ensure parents don’t skip vaccine visits because of the pandemic. pic.twitter.com/0nmXwbqR8L
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) October 9, 2020
While the US and UK issued guidance to urge parents not to miss appointments for vaccines:
Pediatricians were so concerned parents were cancelling appointments OUT OF FEAR OF THE VIRUS that they started house calls to boost vaccination rates.https://t.co/uT1MCnvRVw
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) October 9, 2020
It's not just the USA also. In the UK the government issued guidance to urge parents NOT to miss appts.https://t.co/Oxb6hvpkUa
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) October 9, 2020
And the USA:
“It is critical for children to stay current on their vaccinations, especially during this global pandemic,” says Dr. Gigi Chawla, chief of general pediatrics at Children’s Minnesota."https://t.co/J4uOry7NS1
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) October 9, 2020
The Real Truther also notes that mental health issues derive more from the pandemic itself than from lockdowns. For instance, in Sweden, where the government instituted policies more in line with what the Great Barrington Declaration wants, people weren’t spared the mental health effects, and calls for depression increased 125%, while it was estimated that around one in eight cancer cases might have gone undetected. (The same thing happened in Japan, which didn’t lock down either, with suicides increasing and screenings for cancer halted.)
Meanwhile, in the US:
An interesting paper here look at US evidence, concluding that most of the observed impacts resulted from individual/household/business responses, not government mandates..https://t.co/itMugpZYmu pic.twitter.com/djZB4n7u4v
— Jonathan Portes (@jdportes) October 10, 2020
A conservative in the UK named David Gauke actually summed it up pretty well:
But there are a couple of problems with this argument. First, if the virus takes hold, it will not matter whether pubs have to close at 10pm, 11pm or 12pm. People will not want to go to the pub or restaurant, cinema, shop or office. Most of the economic damage caused by a virus is driven by people voluntarily changing their behaviour.
Precisely. To get the economy to rebound, we have to have the virus under control.
As for herd immunity, listen to this epidemiologist explain why, without a vaccine, trying to reach herd immunity is unlikely to be successful without massive death:
The main problem is something very basic — herd immunity requires IMMUNITY to the disease. When people are proposing herd immunity as an exit strategy for COVID-19, what they are implicitly arguing is that, once infected, you cannot get the disease again — you are immune.
Unfortunately, we know that this simply isn’t the case. There are already widespread reports of people getting reinfected with COVID-19, and worryingly some of these people are having MORE severe infections the second time around. This makes herd immunity in the traditional sense largely unreachable, because some people can clearly get infected and transmit the virus on to others over and over again.
We also don’t know how long the immunity will last even in people who get infected and are then immune. Some people may be immune for months, some for years, some for their entire lives — we simply have very little idea and won’t know for sure for a while yet. If large swathes of the population are infected this year but do not develop long-lasting immunity, chances are we’ll have epidemics in the future as well.
He also notes that this pretty much demolishes the Great Barrington Declaration’s suggestion to have nursing homes staffed only with people who’ve recovered from COVID-19. Why? Because it’s unknown how long their immunity will last, and that immunity might be very transient! He also notes what it would take to protect the “vulnerable”:
This makes plans to protect the more vulnerable populations even more problematic —even if you staffed an aged care centre only with people who’d had COVID-19 before, you would expect some proportion of them to get sick the next time an epidemic broke out anyway, potentially infecting the vulnerable older people you set out to protect.
Yale epidemiologist Gregg Gonsalves has been particularly brutal in his assessment of “Focused Protection”, noting:
Let’s put this into some real-world context. In the United States, only a small proportion of older Americans live in nursing or care homes, where we have shown little ability to keep our elders safe over the past eight months. The bulk of older Americans are integrated into our communities, living alone or with their spouses or their families. Even if we could make nursing homes into impenetrable fortresses impervious to viral entry, it’s not at all clear how we’d keep the millions of elderly “safe” as they live around, among, and with us. In fact, data from CDC suggests that we haven’t done a good job at all on this, and when virus cases surge in young people, the elderly are next in line for transmission.
Another group of people to whom these three august academics give short shrift are the chronically ill in America. The CDC estimates that nearly half of all Americans (47.5 percent) have underlying conditions that predispose them to severe Covid-19 outcomes. If it is a challenge to think of sequestering the elderly, what do we do with almost half of our fellow Americans who may be at similar enhanced risk of complications and death from Covid-19?
I’m over 50 and have hypertension. That puts me in at least an intermediate risk, if not high risk, group for severe disease and death from COVID-19. Many of the readers of this blog fall into the second group, as obesity, diabetes, and hypertension are very common in our population. Gonsalves also notes that the young are not entirely safe either, particularly that for those hospitalized with COVID-19: 21% required intensive care, 10% required mechanical ventilation, and 2.7% died, while half of the young people hospitalized in this cohort were black or Latino. Also, the Great Barrington Declaration is based on a false premise, given that few, if any, epidemiologists are advocating lockdowns any more; instead, they are advocating more limited restrictions, social distancing, contact tracing, extensive testing, and the use of masks. Indeed, we aren’t in “lockdown” any more and haven’t been for some time, while even our “lockdowns” in the US have been nowhere near as drastic as they were in, for example, China early in the pandemic.
Interestingly, I noticed that, for all the recommendations to protect the vulnerable in the Great Barrington Declaration, nowhere does it mention the widespread use of masks, testing (other than for nursing home staffs), or contact tracing. I wonder why, given that masks work and are a relatively easy measure for people to use—or would be, if they hadn’t been politicized to the point where wearing or not wearing a mask is considered a signifier of one’s political “tribe,” and testing and tracing, although not adequate in and of themselves, are widely agreed to be an important part of any COVID-19 public health mitigation strategy.
To boil it all down, if you listen to epidemiologists and public health scientists, you’ll soon realize that it’s impossible to protect the vulnerable from a virus that’s rapidly spreading among the entire population, even if the risk of death or severe disease is much lower in the young. Thus, protecting the vulnerable is only part of a science-based approach to controlling the pandemic that won’t be enough on its own. Those behind the Barrington Declaration claim that they’re not advocating “locking up the elderly,” but in practice that’s exactly what they’re doing, and their plan borders on eugenics:
We’re close to a turning point in the virus: Vaccines will arrive sometime in the next year, and when they do, they’ll put us on a much safer course toward ending the pandemic. “We’ll get herd immunity, but let’s do that with a vaccine, not by sacrificing people,” said Halkitis. “It’s not 1918, for God’s sake.” In the meantime, both Halkitis and Gonsalves agreed that it would be dangerously unwise to follow the Great Barrington Declaration’s advice. “The idea that you can keep outbreaks among the young away from the elderly is ridiculous,” says Gonsalves. “They can spin it however they like, but they don’t really have a plan—it’s grotesque, and it borders on eugenics.”
I would disagree with Gonsalves in that I wouldn’t have used the word “borders”. It is eugenics.
The final wrinkle: Climate science denial meets COVID-19 denial
An interesting final wrinkle emerged on Friday, one that should surprise no one. That’s when it was reported that the “think tank” behind the Great Barrington Declaration is a climate science denialist organization funded in part by the Koch brothers:
On 3 October 2020, the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), a libertarian free-market think-tank in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, hosted a private gathering of scientists, economists and journalists to discuss responses to the COVID-19 pandemic. Among them was the distinguished Oxford University epidemiologist Professor Sunetra Gupta, among the most vocal proponents of a ‘herd immunity’ strategy.
The Great Barrington Declaration, after the town in which it was created, was drafted by Gupta with two other top US scientists, Professor Martin Kulldorff of Harvard University and Stanford Fellow Jay Bhattacharya. The Declaration itself – which calls for only the elderly and vulnerable to be quarantined while encouraging young people to contract the virus – was signed by an initial batch of some 35 scientists.
There’s big money behind it too:
Indeed the AIER is not just a free-market think-tank. It receives a large bulk of its funding from its own investment activities, not least in fossil fuels, energy utilities, tobacco, technology and consumer goods. AIER owns a major investment firm, American Investment Services Inc., which harnesses the think-tank’s research to help inform investment advice. Security Exchange Commission filings seen by Byline Times confirm that AIER’s American Investment Services Inc. runs a private fund valued at $284,492,000.
One notes that the scientists behind this Oxford professor Sunetra Gupta, Stanford physician Dr. Jay Bhattacharya (whose research interest is the economics of health care, not epidemiology), and Harvard professor Dr. Martin Kulldorff (who is a biostatistician, not an epidemiologist) stated in an accompanying video that their declaration should “sit outside politics.” I had to laugh at that given that they were supported by AIER and launched their Declaration at an event hosted by the group, given that AIER is anything but apolitical.

One possible interpretation is that Drs. Gupta, Bhattacharya, and Kulldorff are politically very naïve (or, as I’d call them, useful idiots for AIER), which, I suppose, is possible. Many scientists are pretty clueless about the political ramifications of what they do and can be duped by ideological groups. However, I tend to doubt that they’re that naïve. Instead, I believe that these scientists are likely being disingenuous and know exactly what they are doing. They almost certainly believe that they are doing good, but they are also very likely ideologically aligned with AIER, leading them to genuinely believe that the FP approach is the best balance between harm due to public health interventions and harm and death due to COVID-19. My interpretation is that, whether they realize it or not, this trio is providing “scientific cover” and a “scientists divided” narrative to cast doubt on the science they don’t accept beloved of science denialists since tobacco companies first started casting doubt on science showing the harmful health effects of smoking in the service of a free market fundamentalist “solution” to the COVID-19 pandemic. Indeed, the fact that the trio behind the document have met with White House coronavirus advisor Scott Atlas, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, all of whom advocate for immediate “reopening” of business and against maintaining strong public health interventions against COVID-19. Not coincidentally, their preferred approach is much more in line with the approach advocated in the Great Barrington Declaration, strongly suggesting that these scientists are likely to be motivated as much by ideology as their interpretation of COVID-19 public health science. So does Dr. Bhattacharya’s recent claims that he’s being “censored” and “silenced.” (As an aside, that first link was an interview with ZDoggMD, which disappoints me.)
Whether you want to call it the “magnified minority,” as John Cook does, or something else, to me the Great Barrington Declaration represents a variation on decades-old astroturf techniques. Just as those behind astroturf campaigns seek to disguise their campaigns as organically arising from grassroots efforts and activism, this form of astroturf seeks to cloak the agenda of business or ideological groups in the disguise of science by portraying their agenda as organically arising from the science, using scientists ideologically sympathetic or aligned with them to spearhead their message and then gathering as many signatures as they can from scientists and doctors, regardless of whether they have actual expertise in the relevant sciences. It’s something that’s been going on for decades, which makes it unsurprising that it’s found its way into COVID-19 denial and provided fodder for Fox News and others to argue against various COVID-19 mitigation strategies.

Part 1: We Don’t Have to Wonder if the Great Barrington Declaration Could Have “Worked”. In the Real World, It Failed.
Discussions about the GBD tend to take place in the conditional tense- what would, could, and should have happened. But the GBD actually existed and we can examine what actually happened.
Jonathan Howard on July 11, 2024
Link

The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection
The Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was published on October 4th, 2020. It was written under the watchful eye of a pro-tobacco, child-labor advocate, and it claimed we could rid ourselves of the virus by spreading the virus. The GBD claimed we could end the pandemic by April 2021 at the latest, but only if everyone worked in perfect unison. As they put it:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk. We call this Focused Protection.
In the GBD’s vision, the entire country would be informed of their Declaration, and after this, everyone would unite to abruptly and radically shift their entire approach to the pandemic. Citizens would voluntarily and appropriately sort themselves “vulnerable” or “not vulnerable” categories, and everyone would play their assigned role.
230 million or so unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans, most of whom had been diligently trying to avoid the virus thus far, would instantly reverse course and embrace “natural infection”. That some of them would get really sick and die would not be a reason for anyone to abandon the project.
COVID’s risk to young people was widely-publicized since the start of the pandemic
In contrast, 100 million “vulnerable” people would be wrapped in a bubble and hermetically sealed from the outside world, where the virus would be raging. Meanwhile, politicians at every level would lift nearly all mitigation measures and instantly create programs to care for many millions of home bound “vulnerable” people. Since the authors of the GBD believed that one infection led to durable immunity, they claimed that once enough “not vulnerable” people contracted COVID, herd immunity would arrive and the pandemic would be over.
According to its authors, none of whom treated COVID patients, if everyone did what they were supposed to do, the GBD would have worked.
The GBD would have ended the pandemic
I wouldn’t do it, and I don’t think most people my age would.
Discussions about the GBD, from both its supporters and detractors, tend to take place in the conditional tense- what would, could, and might have happened. Many people have written about the innumerable things that would have gone wrong with the GBD. Dr. David Gorksi wrote an article titled The Great Barrington Declaration Never Would Have Worked and mathematician Kit Yates led a modeling study that:
Found critical flaws which meant shielding strategies, like the GBDs “focused protection”, would have failed in practice.
The author of a fascinating Twitter thread titled Taking the GBD Seriously “tried to crunch some numbers on what it would mean in practice.” He pondered “how many people would need to totally isolate as the virus accelerates… how many people would likely die?” Noah Louis-Ferdinand wrote a valuable series titled No, Focused Protection Wouldn’t Have Worked, where he speculated on what would have happened had millions of young people been willing to contract COVID in October 2020. He wrote:
They may change course as the virus spikes, hospitalizing 1-2 of their friends, classmates, or coworkers, and leaving others disabled potentially for months. Repeat waves which seriously hurt even a small minority of those we care about would be hard to just accept when the risk is modifiable. I wouldn’t do it, and I don’t think most people my age would.
However, we don’t have to speak about the GBD this way. The GBD actually existed, and we can discuss what actually happened. While many things could have gone wrong with the GBD, it turns out something did go horribly wrong with it- most people never heard of it and those who did refused to play their assigned role.
Though Mr. Louis-Ferdinand wrote “I wouldn’t do it, and I don’t think most people my age would“, he should have written “I didn’t do it, and I don’t think most people my age did.” Indeed, most “not vulnerable” people rightly sensed their infections would invariably spill over to “vulnerable” people. They also knew the virus posed some real risk to them and that vaccines were potentially just around the corner. For these reasons, they refused to contract COVID en masse in October 2020. I didn’t rush out to get COVID when the GBD was published. I don’t know anyone who did, and I doubt you do either. There were social media posts in October 2020 of people boasting they signed the GBD, but none of them posted pictures of themselves in a crowded bar with the caption:
I read the GBD and now realize it is my obligation to protect the vulnerable by getting natural immunity.
In fact, one the authors of the GBD wisely avoided the virus until August 2021, after he had been safely vaccinated. Countless millions of Americans made the same choice, including many people who now claim the GBD would have worked. These people did not want to be part of the herd. They wanted the herd to be there for them.
As I previously discussed, the GBD was not anti-lockdown for “vulnerable” people, and many of them also rejected role the GBD assigned to them. Some “vulnerable” people were terrified by the GBD’s plans to let the virus run rampant in their community. Going shopping or traveling to the doctor’s office would have become much more dangerous in the GBD’s vision. Other “vulnerable” people refused to stay locked down. Some even attended COVID protests. The authors of the GBD never did any polling of “vulnerable” people to see if they were on board with their plans to turn them into shut-ins or move them out of their homes. They just wanted to impose their will on them.
Lastly, government officials knew they couldn’t instantly conjure the resources to care for tens of millions of home bound “vulnerable” people as the GBD demanded, and so most of them refused to lift all mitigations measures in October 2020.
Even if the GBD had been right about the durability of viral-induced immunity and children not spreading the virus (discussed here by Dr. Gorski and to be discussed in part 2 of this series), the question of whether the GBD could have worked presupposes an absurd Fantasyland where 330 millions Americans first learned of the GBD and then marched like ants in lockstep with its demands. When the authors of the GBD bemoan that “we never really tried focused protection“, their real complaint is that the entire country didn’t suddenly obey their every command in October 2020. “If only everyone had done everything we asked, things would have been just fine,” they say in essence.
For the GBD to usher in herd immunity in 3-6 months, essentially everyone had to play their assigned role. In the real world, that didn’t happen.
The declaration was signed and released and many scientists responded, mostly to argue that it was based on false premises and was not a workable solution.
Of course, anyone could devise a “plan” to solve almost any societal ill if they assumed the entire populace did everything they wanted. However, when their “plan” inevitably failed, most people would realize their “plan” wasn’t all it was cracked up to be.
In contrast, the authors of the GBD never questioned their Declaration or their powers of persuasion. Instead, they blamed others for not getting 330 million Americans on board with their Declaration. They are livid that other people did not disseminate their Declaration to the entire country, and they can’t fathom that most people who read it found it totally unconvincing. They can only claim to have been suppressed- if only YouTube hadn’t removed that video in 2021, 230 million people would have been willing to get COVID in October 2020. The authors of the GBD feel they are victims because they didn’t get as much attention as they feel they deserved. They felt their Declaration entitled them to influence COVID policy at a national level.
In reality, the authors of the GBD are to blame for its failure. They were 3 highly-credentialed, but essentially random scientists who hammered out a one-page Declaration under the sponsorship of a right-wing think tank. There was a camera crew and journalists at the signing of the GBD. They toasted champagne and bells rang. It was a campy theatrical production. The authors of the GBD had already met with President Trump who echoed their talking points. They had many powerful supporters, and they were granted an audience with Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar the next day. They authors of the GBD used their single page to become pandemic celebrities. They were omnipresent in the media, and they had direct access to powerful politicians. They had an unparalleled opportunity to convince scientists and the general public to adopt their “plan”. Even with this massive megaphone, they failed.
Their “plan” was absurd and impossible, and most people who read it figured this our right away. As one social media commentator rightly put it:
Seems to me that debate about the Barrington Declaration wasn’t quashed at all. The declaration was signed and released and many scientists responded, mostly to argue that it was based on false premises and was not a workable solution. That’s not censorship any more than subjecting journal articles to peer review is censorship. Just because your argument doesn’t hold up well under scrutiny, you don’t get to cry “censorship”. Come up with a better argument.
Indeed.
Faucism and Fascism are not the same, but there are some similarities
However, instead of quietly trying to persuade the relevant decision makers and stakeholders, the GBD’s authors took to the airwaves to launch a non-stop deluge of juvenile, bad faith attacks against anyone who opposed their planned mass infection, including trusted scientists who could have promoted and enacted their “plan” had they been convinced by it- “Dr. Fauci is probably the number one anti-vaxxer in the country“, “Faucism and Fascism are not the same, but there are some similarities“. Even though their “plan” to achieve herd immunity in 3-6 months required the whole country to come together as a synchronized team, the authors of the GBD were pugnacious brawlers and purposefully polarizing figures, alienating the people they needed to convince.
Notably, while they regularly castigated politicians for failing to lift mitigation measures, they held their fire when politicians for failed to deliver groceries to home bound seniors or prevent COVID outbreaks at nursing homes– which are still happening. That part of “focused protection”, which in theory was the core of the GBD, was mere window dressing for the GBD’s only goals- removing mitigation measures and infecting countless millions of unvaccinated Americans.
Of course, the authors of the GBD are well aware their plan was failed. Amazingly, one its authors posted a fake “review” of my book, which he did not read, imagining that he was refuting it. Had he read it, he would have known that we totally agree- in the real world, his people rejected his plan.
Misinformation Alert: The GBD’s philosophy was embraced by key members of Trump administration
Imagine… We would have won the policy argument. Schools would have opened. We would have prioritized protection of the vulnerable.
However, the real world failure of the GBD wasn’t a problem for its authors. Quite the opposite actually. It allowed them to speak about the GBD entirely in the conditional tense, as if it never really existed at all. They claim that if everyone had learned about the GBD, they would have been convinced by it, and they would have played their assigned roles. Schools would have opened, and the vulnerable would have been protected. Herd immunity would have arrived, and the pandemic would have ended. Though what the authors of the GBD actually did was make a lot of YouTube videos, they want you to enter Fantasyland to imagine all the amazing, incredible, astonishing things they would have done, if only the all-powerful combination of the Francis Collins and YouTube hadn’t stood in their way. (I previously satirized this attitude in my article What I Would Have Done).
Misinformation Alert: The director of the NIH, not inappropriately, considered writing a “devastating takedown” of the “premises” of the GBD in an email, but never did so. Many others did, however.
Florida Leads Nation in Number of COVID-19 Deaths of Nursing Home Residents and Staff.
This is not to say the pro-infection philosophy of the GBD was harmless. Its authors did a great deal of damage in those “notable exceptions” where they had influence. For these areas, we don’t have to ask what would have happened. We can examine what actually happened.
They failed to protect “vulnerable” people- Florida Leads Nation in Number of COVID-19 Deaths of Nursing Home Residents and Staff.
They failed to protect “not vulnerable” people- Child Covid Deaths More Than Doubled in Florida as Kids Returned to the Classroom.
They failed to keep schools open- School Closures Reported In Five Florida Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID. 
They failed to end the pandemic- the article Florida Sees COVID-19 Surge in Emergency Rooms, Near Last Winter’s Peaks was written just last week.
They failed to do a single thing they would have done.
Despite claims to the contrary, the GBD’s philosophy was embraced by key members of Trump administration, and though it took awhile, its sphere of influence has grown greatly since then. The GBD’s anti-vaccine rhetoric is now tolerated at top medical schools and in the mainstream media. Thanks to their misinformation, we are likely less prepared to handle a pandemic than we were in 2019. It’s been years since we tried to control the virus, and as a result, and nearly everyone has been infected, many of us many times. This was the GBD’s sole “success.”
The many real world failures of the GBD
That’s what actually happened, and as those who actually read it know, my book is about what actually happened and what I actually did caring for COVID patients, not self-glorifying, grandiose fantasies about what I would have done. However, I also venture into the conditional tense at times. COVID would have been horrible no matter what, but might some people still be alive had influential doctors tried to vaccinate them against a dangerous virus instead of purposefully expose them to it?
I sure think so.
Yet, despite this mass infection, the authors of the GBD can’t point to anywhere on earth where focused protection was used to “protect the vulnerable” and achieve herd immunity in 3-6 months. As such, we don’t have to ask if the GBD could have worked.
In the real world, it failed.

Part 2: We Don’t Have to Wonder if the Great Barrington Declaration Could Have “Worked”. In the Real World It Failed & Redefining Basic Medical Terms Won’t Change That.
We do not have herd immunity to COVID and we should reject doctors who seek to redefine basic terms because they are incapable of uttering the words “I was wrong.”
Jonathan Howard on August 23, 2024
Link

Herd immunity occurs when enough people have immunity so that most infected people cannot find new uninfected people to infect, leading to the end of the epidemic/pandemic.
The Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was premised on the idea that the mass infection of unvaccinated “not vulnerable” people would end the pandemic. For it to have “worked”, 330 million Americans would have had to determine whether they were “vulnerable” or “not vulnerable” and then been willing to play their assigned role. That didn’t happen. In a previous article, I explained that for that reason, we don’t have to wonder if the GBD could have worked, in the real world it failed. However, this was not the only thing what actually went wrong with the GBD.
With this in mind, let’s turn to the concept of herd immunity.
What is herd immunity?
Herd immunity occurs when enough people have immunity so that most infected people cannot find new uninfected people to infect, leading to the end of the epidemic/pandemic.
That reasonable statement comes from the GBD itself. Even though SARS-CoV-2 was less than a year old when the GBD was written, its authors were certain that the simultaneous infection of 230 million unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” people would lead to herd immunity, protecting more “vulnerable” people. They said:
When herd immunity is reached, they (vulnerable people) can live normally again with minimal risks… If focused protection is used, it will likely only take 3 to 6 months.
In 2020, the GBD used the universally accepted definition of herd immunity. They discussed it with regards to new infections and the risk the virus posed to those without immunity to it. Herd immunity occurs when enough people have immunity so that most infected people cannot find new uninfected people to infect, leading to the end of the epidemic/pandemic. This wasn’t controversial at all. Everyone agreed with it.
While the GBD’s definition of herd immunity wasn’t in dispute, many people wisely doubted whether natural immunity alone could lead to herd immunity in under 6-months. Because babies aren’t born with natural immunity, humanity never achieved herd immunity to any virus through infections alone. Only vaccines can lead to herd immunity. Prior to the vaccine, for example, measles cases would rise and fall every couple of years as a new crop of newborns were infected. Herd immunity didn’t arise until the vaccine arrived and measles cases plummeted. There have been 214 cases this year, which is 214 too many, but thanks to herd immunity from the vaccine, measles cases are not rising exponentially. We will lose herd immunity if not enough children are vaccinated, as discussed here by Dr. Clay Jones.
Measles cases before and after the vaccine- source
It is also not possible to reach herd immunity for a virus/vaccine that does not create durable immunity. Unfortunately, neither SARS-CoV-2 nor the vaccine does this, and reinfections were discussed by doctors in the mainstream media as early as September 2020, specifically in response to Dr. Scott Atlas’s pleas for herd immunity through mass infection. Watch the commentary of Dr. Sanjay Gupta in the second half of the video below as a reminder of what was known at the time.
We know now that COVID reinfections are trivially common, and the GBD’s plan of herd immunity was premised on the idea they would be rare events. They wrote that the immune response to COVID “appears to be quite long lasting” and that:
You can see this in the fact that that despite an estimated 750 million worldwide to date after 10 months living with the virus, we have seen only a handful of reinfections. If the virus is like other corona viruses in its immune response, recovery from infection will provide lasting protection against reinfection, either complete immunity or protection that makes a severe reinfection less likely.
The authors of the GBD spread this optimistic message widely in the first half of the pandemic. They authored articles such as Herd Immunity Is Still Key in the Fight Against Covid-19, It’s Mad That ‘Herd Immunity’ Was Ever a Taboo Phrase, We May Already Have Herd Immunity – an Interview With Professor Sunetra Gupta, and The Triumph of Natural Immunity which said:
New CDC study shows that around 75% of American children have already had covid. That means that they have strong natural immunity that protects them from covid infections as they get older.
Obviously, there couldn’t be evidence that immunity to a new virus would last years into the future. This is yet another example of doctors who just made things up. However, given their blind faith in “strong natural immunity”, the authors of the GBD didn’t just feel herd immunity was possible, they claimed it was inevitable, mocking any one who disagreed. They said:
Do you believe in herd immunity?
Yes. Herd immunity is a scientifically proven phenomenon. To ask an epidemiologist if they believe in herd immunity is like asking a physicist if they believe in gravity. Those who deny herd immunity may also wish to join the flat-earth society.
With COVID-19, can herd immunity be avoided?
No. Sooner or later, herd immunity will be reached either through natural infection or through a combination of vaccinations and natural infection.
The videos below show how all three authors of the GBD discussed herd immunity in 2020.
Video source
Video source
Video source
One of the authors of the GBD provided an optimistic follow-up in May 2021, saying:
Herd immunity means the diseases isn’t spreading at high rates. It doesn’t mean the disease is gone. In that sense, we’re kind of already there but the disease is mostly stop spreading in the US. Now it may come back, because this is very clearly a seasonal disease.
The Delta variant would arrive in full force 2 months later, ruining his fantasy of herd immunity for this “seasonal disease”, but his statement herd immunity means the diseases isn’t spreading at high rates was correct and uncontroversial.
Video source
What herd immunity looks like is you’ve had Covid before and recovered, or maybe you’ve had the vaccine, or whatever, but now if you get Covid it’s much less likely to produce severe disease and death, because you have that immunity.
A lot has happened since then. Yet amazingly, the authors of the GBD claim time has vindicated their pandemic predictions. In this video from December 2022, one of its authors says the GBD has been “proven right.” For that to be true, we must have herd immunity to COVID.
However, the authors of the GBD no longer discuss herd immunity in terms of “rates of infections” as they did in 2020. Instead, they created their own definition. One day, they and like-minded doctors simply decided that “herd immunity was likely always focused more on severity of symptoms than infection“, and since COVID is no longer overflowing morgues, they claim we now have herd immunity. As one of the authors of the GBD put it:
What herd immunity looks like is you’ve had COVID before and recovered, or maybe you’ve had the vaccine, or whatever, but now if you get COVID it’s much less likely to produce severe disease and death, because you have that immunity.
To maintain the illusion that they were right, the authors of the GBD completely rejected their original, universally-agreed on definition of herd immunity and invented a new one. It’s a lot like the parable of the rifleman who fires randomly against a wall and then later draws targets around the holes.
Video source
It’s true that COVID is killing many fewer people than before, thankfully. According to one recent article titled COVID Drops to 10th Leading Cause of Death in US:
Provisional data from the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) on the top causes of deaths in the United States in 2023 shows COVID-19 dropped to the tenth leading cause of death. In 2022, it was the fourth leading cause of death, meaning deaths from COVID dropped by 68.9% in one year.
However, unless SARS-CoV-2 mutated into significantly more virulent forms, it was always the case that that fewer people would die from it as the pandemic progressed. The actual term for this is mortality displacement, not herd immunity, and it reflects how the underlying population has changed since 2020. Not only is the virus not encountering an immunologically naive population, people can only die once. Tragically, 1.2 million Americans, who were by definition “vulnerable”, are no longer available for the virus to kill. As Olive Siffleur put it:
If a rampaging bear keeps attacking the campgrounds, all the people who weren’t able to outrun the bear the first time he attacked will already be dead the next time the bear rampages through the campsite. The lower death count doesn’t mean the bear became tamer.
Indeed, much like a rampaging bear who picked off the easy victims, COVID’s lower death count doesn’t mean SARS-CoV-2 has weakened over time. Though some doctors insist that a virus that flattens Olympians is now just a “cold“, no one can state with confidence that the consequences of repeat COVID infections will be mild for everyone. The virus is still new, after all and even old foes like measles still have surprises. Even with vaccines, COVID is still killing many more people than the flu, over 1,000 Americans last week, and reinfections can be severe for some people. One recent study found:
That severe infections from the virus that causes COVID-19 tend to foreshadow similar severity of infection the next time a person contracts the disease… About 27% of those with severe cases, defined as receiving hospital care for a coronavirus infection, also received hospital care for a reinfection.
Most importantly, the virus is infecting enough people to generate headlines like this- Summer COVID Surge Hits at Least 84 Countries and Continues to Climb.
Those who claim this is herd immunity may also wish to join the flat-earth society. Though yet again, we do not have to wonder if the GBD could have worked. In the real world it failed, and instead of absurdly trying to redefine basic medical terms, its authors could have simply uttered the words “I was wrong“.
Weekly U.S. COVID update:– New cases: 169,217 est.– Average: 159,398 (+9,581)– In hospital: 5,256 (+485)– In ICU: 567 (+74)– New deaths: 1,134– Average: 772 (+146)Note: Limited data1/8
— BNO News (@BNOFeed) August 19, 2024

A Challenge For Dr. Edward Livingston: Defend the Great Barrington Declaration Without Censoring the Great Barrington Declaration
In 2020, the GBD was all about herd immunity via natural immunity. Today, its defenders censor that.
Jonathan Howard on January 1, 2025
Link
We now know that Dr. Bhattacharya and the other GBD authors were correct
Sensible Medicine is a monetized Substack that publishes anti-vaccine nonsense and pro-RFK Jr. propaganda. A recent article there by Dr. Edward Livingston reveals a typical technique misinformation doctors use to trick their readers and rewrite the history of the pandemic: censorship.
Dr. Livingston’s article was titled The Semmelweis Effect and The Great Barrington Declaration, and it said:
Despite the rich history of the dangers of rejecting new or alternate ideas about disease, the medical establishment has not learned its lesson. With COVID, the Semmelweis Effect was in full force. This time, it was the GBD authors who were the witches burned at the stake.
Jay Bhattacharya, who authored the declaration with Dr. Martin Kulldorff and Dr. Sunetra Gupta, is the face of the GBD and a modern day Semmelweis. Bhattacharya and his colleagues issued the Great Barrington Declaration on October 4, 2020, the pandemic was raging and the response to it was chaotic, calling for a reasoned approach to COVID…
We now know that Dr. Bhattacharya and the other GBD authors were correct, and the experts were very wrong. The Semmelweis Effect. Going forward, experts should be careful before discrediting new ideas. The more passionate the experts are about countering something, the more skeptical the public will be about the experts.
Though Dr. Livingston claimed “Dr. Bhattacharya and the other GBD authors were correct” he did not quote them at all.
We at SBM reject censorship. As such, our readers know that the GBD sought to spread a deadly infection with tragic consequences. Its authors were not “the witches burned at the stake,” as Dr. Livingston histrionically claimed. Rather they where sheltered laptop class doctors who drastically underestimated COVID, but were nonetheless rewarded with power and fame. In contrast, Dr. Ignaz Semmelweis tried to save lives by limiting a deadly infection (though germ theory was not yet known). His advocacy for hand washing was rejected, and he tragically died in a mental hospital. Semmelweis and the GBD are mirror opposites in every way.
Today, Semmelweis functions as the medical version of the Galileo gambit. Dr. Livingston’s core argument was that because the medical established rejected Semmelweis in 1847, the GBD was “correct” about COVID in 2020. However, Dr. Livingston can only make this claim by censoring what the GBD actually said.
As immunity builds in the population, the risk of infection to all – including the vulnerable – falls.
Because I respect my readers and don’t hide information to deceive them, here’s the core premise of the GBD, taken from the GBD itself:
As immunity builds in the population, the risk of infection to all – including the vulnerable – falls. We know that all populations will eventually reach herd immunity – i.e.  the point at which the rate of new infections is stable – and that this can be assisted by (but is not dependent upon) a vaccine. Our goal should therefore be to minimize mortality and social harm until we reach herd immunity. 
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk. We call this Focused Protection…
People who are more at risk may participate if they wish, while society as a whole enjoys the protection conferred upon the vulnerable by those who have built up herd immunity.
The GBD further claimed that this mass infection of unvaccinated people would lead to herd immunity in under 6 months. They said:
For how long must high-risk individuals be careful and/or self-isolate? 
When herd immunity is reached, they can live normally again with minimal risks. How long that takes depends on the strategy used. If age-wide lockdown measures are used to try and suppress the disease, it could take a year or two or three, making it very difficult for older people to protect themselves for that long. If focused protection is used, it will likely only take 3 to 6 months.
In articles, interviews, and on social media the authors of the GBD spoke constantly about natural immunity leading to herd immunity the first 1.5 years of the pandemic. This was what it was all about.
I didn’t censor anything
Yet, Dr. Livingston didn’t mention this at all. He deliberately hid what the GBD proposed because he doesn’t respect Sensible Medicine readers or trust them with the truth. His article was just one small example of pandemic revisionism in which misinformation doctors seek to erase the reality of the We Want Them Infected movement and replace it with a fantasy where pro-infection doctors only cared about poor children and the working class.
On social media, Dr. Livingston absurdly protested “I didn’t censor anything.” So here’s my challenge to him and anyone else who claims the GBD was correct- write a defense of the GBD that includes the passages in this article.
We all know that will never happen.


Defenders of the Great Barrington Declaration Neither Know Nor Care What it Proposed. The Deliberate Erasure of the We Want Them Infected Movement Has Succeeded.
Defenders of the GBD won’t tell you what it actually said. I will.
Jonathan Howard on January 10, 2025
Link
The Vanishing Commissar
According to Wikipedia:
Nikolai Ivanovich Yezhov was a Soviet secret police official under Joseph Stalin who was head of the NKVD from 1936 to 1938, during the height of the Great Purge. Yezhov organized mass arrests, torture, and executions during the Great Purge, but he fell from Stalin’s favor and was arrested, subsequently admitting in a confession to a range of anti-Soviet activity including “unfounded arrests” during the Purge. He was executed in 1940 along with others who were blamed for the Purge…
Among historians, he also has the nickname “The Vanishing Commissar” because after his execution, his likeness was retouched out of an official press photo; he is among the best-known examples of the Soviet press making someone who had fallen out of favor “disappear”.
Doctors are helping to ensure the history of the pandemic unfolds on a similar trajectory as this photo.
Dr. Bhattacharya and the other GBD authors were correct, and the experts were very wrong. The Semmelweis Effect.
With this in mind, we can turn to a more familiar topic, the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). Although the GBD was sponsored by a proud child labor advocate, its authors now say their motivation arose solely from benevolent concern for poor children and the working class. Despite experiencing the pandemic entirely from their laptops, they portray themselves as heroes by cherry-picking unpopular mitigation measures and saying in essence, “All we did was opposed these, and if people listened to us they could have been avoided.”
Many incurious and credulous defenders of the GBD believe this. They claim the GBD simply “called for” vulnerable people to be protected and schools to remain open, and they treat this as a significant accomplishment. That the authors of the GBD “called for” others to do things on podcasts, was taken as proof that they would have been able to do those things if they were in charge. In this imagined universe, they would have protected vulnerable people, they would have opened schools, and we barely would have noticed the virus.
Several of my prior articles discussed how this rebranding effort distorts what the GBD actually said and what actually happened in places where it had influence. The virus made itself known. Many people died and schools closed.
In one such article, I discussed Dr. Edward Livingston and his contribution to pandemic revisionism, an article titled The Semmelweis Effect and The Great Barrington Declaration, which was published on the monetized misinformation Substack Sensible Medicine. In it, Dr. Livingston claimed that the “GBD authors were correct, and the experts were very wrong.” He further compared its authors to persecuted giants of medicine, an absurdity discussed by Dr. David Gorski.
Can you show me where it says that ‘herd immunity would arrive in 3-6 months’?
In my response, I noted that Dr. Livingston censored the core promise of the GBD- the mass infection of unvaccinated people under age 60-70 would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months. However, neglecting Hanlon’s razor, I failed to consider that Dr. Livingston didn’t deliberately censor the GBD, rather he hadn’t read it and didn’t know what it was really about. Indeed, during a discussion on social media, I informed Dr. Livingston of the GBD’s core promise, to which he replied:
Here is a link-Can you show me where it says that ‘herd immunity would arrive in 3-6 months’?
Yes, I could. I’ve read the GBD.
The GBD’s core promise of herd immunity via natural immunity in 3-6 months was in the FAQ section, and they promoted this optimistic time frame often on social media in 2020. This was its entire point. Literally everything about the GBD centered around this promise, and its authors objected to mitigation measures precisely because they suppressed the disease. They felt mitigations “postponed the inevitable” and delayed the imminent arrival of herd immunity.
Beyond informing Dr. Livingston of the GBD’s core promise, I told him about some of the many flawed arguments and fake statistics- “we’ve had more flu deaths among children this year than than COVID deaths“– its authors used to numb everyone but seniors to COVID’s risk. In addition to minimizing the virus, the GBD’s authors spoke constantly about herd immunity and natural immunity in 2020, though they have since excised these phrases from their vocabulary.
Since the GBD’s authors and defenders won’t remind you, here are their main beliefs from 2020, all of which culminated in their core promise that mass natural immunity would rapidly lead to herd immunity.
Immunity to COVID was durable and reinfections vanishingly rare:
Herd immunity was inevitable:
COVID posed a “very moderate” of death risk to young people and non-fatal outcomes could be brushed away:
COVID’s risk kicked in at 70:
Children don’t spread COVID:
The mass infection of unvaccinated people under 60-70 would protect vulnerable people and rapidly end the pandemic:
The more important issue isn’t the immunity argument
An honest broker who claimed the GBD was “correct” would acknowledge and proudly defend these points. In contrast, Dr. Livingston sought to erase them. Indeed, immediately after learning about the GBD’s promise of rapid herd immunity via natural immunity, he claimed its entire raison d’etre simply didn’t matter. He blithely declared, “The more important issue isn’t the immunity argument” and said:
Some of the posts pushing back on what I said about the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) seemed to not get past their use of the term ‘herd immunity’…
We can dispense with the concept of herd immunity. However, one still needs to consider natural immunity. My contention is that the concept the GBD authors were trying to convey with the term herd immunity can be replaced by natural immunity. This is important because simply discounting the GBD because of a term they used does not serve in the best interest of public health.
This is beyond absurd. The GBD wasn’t about semantics, and no one is “discounting the GBD because of a term they used”. We discount them because of the misinformation they spread and the damage they caused. We shouldn‘t “get past” their use of “herd immunity”. They were all about “herd immunity” in the first year of the pandemic. The GBD mentioned “herd immunity” 5 times and the FAQ devoted an entire section to it where it was mentioned 18 times. They wrote homages to it titled It’s Mad That ‘Herd Immunity’ Was Ever a Taboo Phrase, Herd Immunity is Still Key in the Fight Against COVID-19, Life Can Go Back to Normal if We Make it Our Common Goal to Achieve Herd Immunity and Delaying Herd Immunity is Costing Lives.
Moreover, the GBD’s authors constantly claimed herd immunity was just around the corner. In fact, by July 2020 all three of them declared that some part of the world had already reached herd immunity. In Dr. Livingston’s telling they were “correct” and their brilliance will echo through the ages.
However, nothing could alter Dr. Livingston’s belief about the GBD, not even reading it for the first time. Dr. Livingston felt that because the GBD “advocated for” impressive things and objected to lockdowns that ended long ago, nothing else about it matters. Of course, no one says lockdowns were perfect and harmless, and pointing out their flaws is not a defense of the GBD. The GBD opposed them precisely because of the “immunity argument” and no country, not even Sweden, avoided drastic mitigation measures when the virus surged.
But let’s be clear about what happened here. Dr. Livingston is a professor at UCLA and was a deputy editor for clinical reviews and education at JAMA. He wrote an entire article about how the GBD was “correct” and its authors were oppressed geniuses. Other highly credentialed doctors from top medical schools promoted his article on social media, calling it “tremendous“, “excellent“, and “beautifully written“.
However, not only did Dr. Livingston omit what the GBD actually proposed, he was both unaware of it and indifferent to it. He simply didn’t care what the GBD said, and so Sensible Medicine readers won’t learn any of it. No article there will ever candidly discuss the true purpose and real-world consequences of the GBD. It’s like it never happened at all. To obscure reality, Dr. Livingston conjured a sanitized fantasy of the GBD and argued that if one discards everything in it that was incorrect, what remains is reasonable. Worse yet, he demands that others join his deliberate amnesia.
I refuse. We must resist these attempts to make us forget what people said in 2020. My articles on the GBD present their videos and articles so readers can directly hear exactly what they said. Like all defenders of the GBD today, Dr. Livingston didn’t do that, and he never will.
While the GBD failed to deliver herd immunity via natural immunity, they’ve succeeded in erasing the reality of the We Want Them Infected movement. They’ve replaced it with a fiction where they were selfless champions of the poor and vulnerable, and everything would have been just fine and dandy if only the “experts” had heeded their wisdom. This is how history gets rewritten in real-time. The Soviet propagandists who erased Nikolai Ivanovich Yezhov would be proud.


The Great Barrington Declaration and “natural herd immunity” versus public health three years later
Over the weekend, Jeffrey Tucker, founder of the Brownstone Institute, crowed about how the Great Barrington Declaration and its recommendation of a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic changed everything three years ago. Unfortunately, as the John Snow Project pointed out last week, the “natural herd immunity” approach has done what could be irreparable damage to public health science and, more importantly, the political and social will to promote public health practices not just for infectious disease but more generally.
David Gorski on November 13, 2023
Link

It has been over three years now since the publication of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), whose authors in early October 2020 advocated a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, in which the young and healthy, who were (presumably) at very low risk of serious illness and death from COVID-19, would be allowed to go (mostly) about their business reopening society, while the elderly and those with chronic medical conditions, who were at the highest risk of complications and death from the novel coronavirus, would supposedly be kept safe with “focused protection.” The idea was that, by letting SARS-CoV-2 circulate in the “low risk” population we would reach “natural herd immunity” more rapidly—in six months!—all without the serious damaging consequences of business closures (which proponents of a GBD-like approach always called “lockdowns,” whether they were lockdowns or not) and all the other public health interventions instituted early in the pandemic to slow the spread of the novel coronavirus. Unfortunately, one of the requirements to achieve “natural herd immunity” is that postinfection immunity—which antivaxxers like to refer to as “natural immunity“—be durable, and, as we later learned with the Delta and Omicron waves, a coronavirus that was spreading widely through a population of billions was very capable of evolving into new variants that could not only become a lot more transmissible than the original Wuhan strain but also evade immunity acquired as a result of infection with prior variants. Then there was the problem that the GBD never really defined “focused protection” in a way that could be operationalized. It appeared to mean something akin to indefinite quarantine of the “high risk” their homes, ignoring that these people could never entirely avoid interacting with all those young healthy people spreading the virus. Moreover, in practice “focused protection” could never really have worked, anyway,
So from that consideration alone, “natural herd immunity” was always a pipe dream, but it also turns out that “focused protection” in practice could never really have worked anyway, something that even Gabrielle Bauer of the Brownstone Institute (the “spiritual child of the GBD“) implicitly admitted this year without actually admitting it. There are many good reasons why I referred to the GBD as eugenicist a mere week after it was published and continue to do so. It was (and is) eugenicist in that it basically advocated letting the elderly and unhealthy die in service of society. (Seriously, I kept thinking of the term “useless eaters” as I read the declaration.) Unfortunately, the GBD was highly influential in the US, UK, and a number of other countries and remains so to this day, even as GBD proponents, including the Brownstone Institute, have become increasingly antivaccine.
Indeed, what inspired this post were two articles, the first a bit of self-congratulatory wankery published by Jeffrey Tucker over the weekend on the Brownstone Institute website entitled The Declaration That Wasn’t Supposed to Happen. Contrast that to an article that appeared on the website of the John Snow Project, a group of public health professionals that pointed out from the beginning how misguided and dangerous GBD-like “natural herd immunity” approaches to a pandemic are, entitled ‘Endemic’ SARS-CoV-2 and the death of public health. Of course, once it had become clear to GBD advocates that “natural herd immunity” was nowhere near, much less just six months away, many of them pivoted to a shoulder shrug about how SARS-CoV-2 would just become “endemic” and that would be fine, ignoring all their claims of how the virus would be brought under control through the magic of “natural herd immunity.” I can’t help but contrast the two, particularly in light of last week’s charge—and completely accurate statement—by Dr. Jerome Adams, Surgeon-General during the Trump Administration, that advocates of a GBD-like approach to the pandemic wanted to use children as guinea pigs by letting them be infected in order to reach “natural herd immunity” faster, basically saying the same thing that we here at SBM, particularly Dr. Jonathan Howard (who even wrote a book about it) had been saying all along:
Instead of prioritizing learning loss and social isolation, most discussion was about using kids as a means to help the adults. In the future let’s remember to truly prioritize the holistic well being of our kids (especially vulnerable and caregivers). https://t.co/Xok2ScqXs8
— Jerome Adams (@JeromeAdamsMD) November 8, 2023
Also, many people (who weren’t “in the room”) are challenging my statement that Atlas was promoting a strategy of infecting kids to advance herd immunity. But you didn’t need to be in the room. Here are the receipts (late 2020, before deadly delta and omicron surges).👇🏽 pic.twitter.com/GbJU6SH1iH
— Jerome Adams (@JeromeAdamsMD) November 9, 2023
Sadly, Dr. Adams’ characterization of what happened is quite accurate. So let’s look at the Brownstone Institute’s shiny happy version of history and compare it to reality, shall we?

Jeffrey Tucker’s shiny happy “natural herd immunity,” championed by brave maverick doctors
For those of you who don’t remember, Jeffrey Tucker is the founder of the Brownstone Institute; indeed, it was he himself who, after having founded it in 2021, explicitly called his new institute the “spiritual child of the GBD.” And why not? Tucker was instrumental in creating the GBD. In the summer and fall of 2020, he was the editorial director of the right wing “free market” think tank American Institute for Economic Research, (AIER) whose headquarters in Great Barrington, MA provided the name for the GBD. It was at the AIER headquarters where Tucker, helped by a like-minded Harvard statistician and later GBD signatory named Martin Kulldorff, gathered the other two authors of the Declaration, Stanford health policy professor Jay Bhattacharya and Oxford theoretical epidemiologist Sunetra Gupta, for a press event where the three scientists just so happened to pen the GBD as well. Indeed, not long after the GBD was released, Tucker bragged on a podcast how he had invited Kulldorff to the AIER headquarters, found him so enthusiastic about opposing “lockdowns” that Kulldorff volunteered to gather other like-minded scientists for a “conference” (complete with press) where the GBD ended up being drafted and announced, and then been in the “room where it happened” (apologies to Lin-Manuel Miranda) as the GBD was being discussed and written. Basically, Tucker was the dark far-right wing ideologue who recruited Kulldorff as a useful idiot for his cause, and Kulldorff did not disappoint.
As such, Tucker remains very proud of his creation, as he brags in The Declaration That Wasn’t Supposed to Happen:
It’s been a continuing mystery for three years, at least to me but many others too. In October 2020, in the midst of a genuine crisis, three scientists made a very short statement of highly public health wisdom, a summary of what everyone in the profession, apart from a few oddballs, believed only a year earlier. The astonishing frenzy of denunciation following that document’s release was on a level I’ve never seen before, reaching to the highest levels of government and flowing through the whole of media and tech. It was mind-boggling.
And:
That was the period of the grant amnesia. The conventional wisdom turned on a dime toward full backing of regime priorities, a shift more extreme and mind boggling that anything in dystopian fiction.
This is some very seriously amnestic revisionist history. While it is true that the GBD was denounced by public health officials for the unworkable ideological (and eugenicist) example of “magnified minority” that it clearly was, such denunciations were nothing compared to the embrace of GBD-like policies by, for example, the Trump administration in the US and the Boris Johnson administration in the UK, as well as a number of state governments. Indeed, as Gavin Yamey and I noted in 2021:
In October 2020, Gupta, Kulldorff, and Bhattacharya met with two of US President Donald Trump’s senior health officials, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar and Scott Atlas. Atlas was at the time on leave from his fellowship at the Hoover Institution, a conservative think tank affiliated with Stanford University. The meeting reportedly led the administration to eagerly embrace the GBD. Nor did the GBD authors limit their efforts to national governments. For example, in March 2021 Florida Governor Ron DeSantis hosted a video roundtable with Atlas, Gupta, Kulldorff, and Bhattacharya, where they expressed opposition to masks, testing and tracing, physical distancing, and mass vaccination. YouTube removed the video “because it included content that contradicts the consensus of local and global health authorities regarding the efficacy of masks to prevent the spread of Covid-19.” GBD authors, predictably, cried, “Censorship!” Bhattacharya continues to advise Governor DeSantis on Florida’s covid-19 policies, including providing legal testimony in support of DeSantis’s ban on mask mandates in public schools.
That’s not even counting how Kulldorff, Bhattacharya, and other advocates of “natural herd immunity”—e.g., Dr. Joseph Ladapo, who is now Florida’s Surgeon-General—had met with Donald Trump himself the previous summer:
A picture from Scott Atlas' book of his secret meeting with the President, Jay Bhattacharya & Martin Kulldorff (Great Barrington Declaration), Cody Meissner, & Joe Ladapo (now Florida's Surgeon General) in August 2020.
Meeting first uncovered by @COVIDOversight over a year later pic.twitter.com/2pwsfvEU1U
— Mallory Harris (@malar0ne.bsky.social) (@malar0ne) February 19, 2022
Far from being the poor persecuted, “silenced,” and “cancelled” brave mavericks, GBD advocates were courted at the highest levels of government. While it is true that this courtship ceased when President Joe Biden was inaugurated in January 2021, they had had months of access to the highest levels of government before and after the GBD was announced.
Unsurprisingly, Tucker tries to paint the GBD as being entirely reasonable. Unfortunately, he has to engage in a bit of more misdirection to do it:
For proof that nothing in the document was particularly radical, look no further than the March 2, 2020, letter from Yale University signed by 800 top professionals. It warned against quarantines, lockdowns, closures, and travel restrictions. It said such extreme measures “can undermine public trust, have large societal costs and, importantly, disproportionately affect the most vulnerable segments in our communities.” That document appeared only two weeks before the lockdowns announced by the Trump administration.
Let’s take a look at what the letter from Yale University actually said, shall we, as opposed to what Tucker claims that it said in his link above, which emphasized issues of social and economic justice in any pandemic response, including sufficient government funding to support people and businesses affected by pandemic mitigations; prioritizing voluntary over mandatory interventions (the only part that sort of overlaps with Brownstone and the GBD but where the comparison leaves out a lot of context, such as the part where it is demanded that people subject to mandatory quarantine or “lockdown” receive adequate financial support to minimize “job loss, economic hardship, and undue burden”); and noting that the “effectiveness of regional lockdowns and travel bans depends on many variables, and also decreases in the later stages of an outbreak,” a clear swipe at the Trump administration’s early institution of poorly thought-out travel bans in early 2020.
Enter the brave maverick of AIER and the GBD:
Seven months later, the Great Barrington Declaration said something very similar to the Yale document. It was a summary statement concerning what governments and society should and should not do during pandemics. They should seek to allow everyone to live as normally as possible in order to avoid guaranteed damage from coerced disruptions. And the vulnerable population – those who would experience medically significant impacts from exposure – should be protected from exposure insofar as doing so is consistent with human rights and choice.
It was nothing particularly novel, much less radical. Indeed, it was accepted wisdom the year before and for the previous century. The difference this time, however, is that the statement was released during the wildest and most destructive science experiment in modern times. The existing policy of lockdowns was utter wreckage: of businesses, schools, churches, civic life, and freedom itself. Masks were being forced on the whole population, including children. Governments were attempting a regime of test, track, trace, and isolate, as if there were ever any hope of containing a respiratory pathogen with a zoonotic reservoir.
“Zoonotic reservoir”? I laughed out loud reading that part, given how much Brownstone and Tucker have gone all-in with “lab leak” conspiracy theories. I can only guess that Tucker included that last part as a means of seeming reasonable.
In any event, once again, this is revisionist history and bad science. Those of us around and paying attention in October 2020 immediately recognized the GBD for what it was, a propaganda document, a technique of “magnified minority” like that previously used by creationists, climate science deniers, and HIV/AIDs deniers, designed to make it appear that a fringe scientific viewpoint has a lot of support in the scientific community. (I will repeat that the GBD was also eugenicist.) Again, it was a proposal that on a very practical basis couldn’t have worked because it never defined “focused protection” adequately and the measures needed to make focused protection work would have required something resembling “lockdowns” anyway, leaving aside, again, the requirement for durable postinfection immunity for “natural herd immunity” to be achievable. That’s just one reason why I was so amused when Brownstone flack Gabrielle Bauer admitted that the GBD “didn’t get every detail right,” one of those minor details being that “neither infection nor vaccination provides durable immunity against Covid, leaving people vulnerable to second (and fifth) infections,” you know, the single most important requirement for “natural herd immunity” being durable postinfection immunity. Of course, these days, Brownstone has a two year history of parroting antivax tropes like fantasizing about a “Nuremberg 2.0” in which “lockdowners” and supporters of vaccine mandates and other public health interventions will be called to account for their “crimes”; likening public health interventions to slow the spread of COVID-19 to slavery, religion, or a Communist dictatorship; or just plain spreading pure, unadulterated antivax misinformation.
Conveniently enough, in his narrative of “censorship” and “persecution” Tucker goes right there:
Reading those words today, in light of what we now know, we can start to make sense of the sheer panic at the top. Natural infection and immunity? Can’t talk about that. The end of the pandemic is not “dependent upon” the vaccine? Can’t say that either. Go back to normal for all populations without significant medical risk? Unsayable.
You need only reflect on the astounding barrage of vaccine propaganda that began immediately upon release, the attempt to mandate it on the whole population and now the addition of the Covid jab to the childhood schedule even though children are of near zero risk. This is all about product sales, as you can easily discern from the unrelenting ad videos made by the new head of the CDC.
As for the product effectiveness itself, there seems to be no end to the ensuing problems. It was not a sterilizing inoculation, and it appears that the manufacturers always knew that. It could not stop infection or transmission. The hazards associated with it were also known early on. Every day, the news gets more grim: in the latest revelation, the CDC seems to have kept two separate books on vaccine injury, one public (showing harms without precedent but which has been deprecated by officials) and one yet to be released.
Even now, therefore, there is every effort being made to keep a lid on what surely ranks as the greatest failure/scandal in the modern history of public health. Some brave experts called it out before the whole calamity unfolded even further.
The problem with the Great Barrington Declaration was not that it was not true. It’s that – unbeknownst to its authors – it flew in the face of one of the most funded and elaborate industrial plots in the history of governance. Just a few sentences sneaking through the wall of censorship they were carefully constructing was enough to threaten and eventually dismantle the best laid plans.
Spare me, Mr. Tucker. In actuality, it was those trying to counter the GBD narrative, which was being promoted by far more than just a right wing think tank and three contrarian scientists, who were the ones drowned out by misinformation. Tucker and the Brownstone Institute can portray themselves as persecuted truth telling heroes all they want, but in reality they represented interests who saw pandemic mitigations as a threat to their ideology and profits.
Which brings us to the depressing article published at the John Snow Project, ‘Endemic’ SARS-CoV-2 and the death of public health.
The downward trajectory of public health since the pandemic
Regular readers might recall that the John Snow Memorandum was a document released by public health scientists in response to the Great Barrington Declaration. John Snow, of course, is considered one of the founders and pioneers of epidemiology, having been the 19th century physician who identified the source of a cholera outbreak in London’s Soho, a particular public water pump. The John Snow Memorandum noted, correctly:
Any pandemic management strategy relying upon immunity from natural infections for COVID-19 is flawed. Uncontrolled transmission in younger people risks significant morbidity(3) and mortality across the whole population. In addition to the human cost, this would impact the workforce as a whole and overwhelm the ability of healthcare systems to provide acute and routine care.
Furthermore, there is no evidence for lasting protective immunity to SARS-CoV-2 following natural infection(4) and the endemic transmission that would be the consequence of waning immunity would present a risk to vulnerable populations for the indefinite future. Such a strategy would not end the COVID-19 pandemic but result in recurrent epidemics, as was the case with numerous infectious diseases before the advent of vaccination. It would also place an unacceptable burden on the economy and healthcare workers, many of whom have died from COVID-19 or experienced trauma as a result of having to practise disaster medicine. Additionally, we still do not understand who might suffer from long COVID(3). Defining who is vulnerable is complex, but even if we consider those at risk of severe illness, the proportion of vulnerable people constitute as much as 30% of the population in some regions(8). Prolonged isolation of large swathes of the population is practically impossible and highly unethical. Empirical evidence from many countries shows that it is not feasible to restrict uncontrolled outbreaks to particular sections of society. Such an approach also risks further exacerbating the socioeconomic inequities and structural discriminations already laid bare by the pandemic. Special efforts to protect the most vulnerable are essential but must go hand-in-hand with multi-pronged population-level strategies.
All of which was reasonable and remains reasonable, unlike the “let ‘er rip” approach championed by the GBD, which, contrary to the claims of Tucker and his fellow “natural herd immunity” advocates, was not just “reasonable” and standard public health science. Indeed, this article argues just that, laments what has happened to public health, and expresses fear for the future the next time a new pathogen emerges.
The John Snow Project begins by noting, depressingly:
SARS-CoV-2 is now circulating out of control worldwide. The only major limitation on transmission is the immune environment the virus faces. The disease it causes, COVID-19, is now a risk faced by most people as part of daily life.
While some are better than others, no national or regional government is making serious efforts towards infection prevention and control, and it seems likely this laissez-faire policy will continue for the foreseeable future. The social, political, and economic movements that worked to achieve this mass infection environment can rejoice at their success.
Those schooled in public health, immunology or working on the front line of healthcare provision know we face an uncertain future, and are aware the implications of recent events stretch far beyond SARS-CoV-2. The shifts that have taken place in attitudes and public health policy will likely damage a key pillar that forms the basis of modern civilized society, one that was built over the last two centuries; the expectation of a largely uninterrupted upwards trajectory of ever-improving health and quality of life, largely driven by the reduction and elimination of infectious diseases that plagued humankind for thousands of years. In the last three years, that trajectory has reversed.
It’s definitely hard to argue with this depressing characterization of the state of public health today. There is now little or no effort in the US or elsewhere in infection control and prevention; it is the ultimate success of disease mongers like Jeffrey Tucker and the Brownstone Institute, along with all the other ideological forces and organizations promoting the same message and politics, that any public health interventions are an unacceptable assault on personal “freedom” that must be resisted at all costs. “We want them infected,” indeed.
The authors go on to provide a brief history of public health, noting key developments that led to its upward trajectory over the last few centuries. These include germ theory, John Snow’s identification of the source of the 1854 London cholera outbreak, vaccination, recognition of the importance of workplace environments and ventilation, and other developments. These trends continued into the 20th century, and a number of diseases were brought under much better control, including diphtheria, pertussis, hepatitis B, polio, measles, mumps, rubella, etc., because of effective vaccination, while diseases like malaria, typhus, typhoid, leprosy, cholera, tuberculosis, and many others, although not eradicated, faded from prominence because they were under better control, at least in industrialized temperate countries.
All of this history led to a recognition:
Furthermore, the idea that infectious diseases should not just be reduced, but permanently eliminated altogether began to be put into practice in the second half of the 20th century3-5 on a global level, and much earlier locally. These programs were based on the obvious consideration that if an infectious agent is driven to extinction, the incalculable damage to people’s health and the overall economy by a persisting and indefinite disease burden will also be eliminated.
Basically, the eradication of some diseases became possible and was even within sight, after the successful eradication of smallpox, with the John Snow Project noting ruefully:
When the COVID-19 pandemic started, global eradication programs were very close to succeeding for two other diseases – polio11,12 and dracunculiasis13. Eradication is also globally pursued for other diseases, such as yaws14,15, and regionally for many others, e.g. lymphatic filariasis16,17, onchocerciasis18,19, measles and rubella20-30. The most challenging diseases are those that have an external reservoir outside the human population, especially if they are insect borne, and in particular those carried by mosquitos. Malaria is the primary example, but despite these difficulties, eradication of malaria has been a long-standing global public health goal31-33 and elimination has been achieved in temperate regions of the globe34,35, even though it involved the ecologically destructive widespread application of polluting chemical pesticides36,37 to reduce the populations of the vectors. Elimination is also a public goal for other insect borne diseases such as trypanosomiasis38,39.
Noting that, because of zoonotic reservoirs of a number of diseases, this principle in dealing with emerging infectious diseases became paramount:
Because it is much easier to stop an outbreak when it is still in its early stages of spreading through the population than to eradicate an endemic pathogen, the governing principle has been that no emerging infectious disease should be allowed to become endemic. This goal has been pursued reasonably successfully and without controversy for many decades.
The most famous newly emerging pathogens were the filoviruses (Ebola44-46, Marburg47,48), the SARS and MERS coronaviruses, and paramyxoviruses like Nipah49,50. These gained fame because of their high lethality and potential for human-to-human spread, but they were merely the most notable of many examples.
Such epidemics were almost always aggressively suppressed. Usually, these were small outbreaks, and because highly pathogenic viruses such as Ebola cause very serious sickness in practically all infected people, finding and isolating the contagious individuals is a manageable task. The largest such epidemic was the 2013-16 Ebola outbreak in West Africa, when a filovirus spread widely in major urban centers for the first time. Containment required a wartime-level mobilization, but that was nevertheless achieved, even though there were nearly 30,000 infections and more than 11,000 deaths51.
SARS was also contained and eradicated from the human population back in 2003-04, and the same happened every time MERS made the jump from camels to humans, as well as when there were Nipah outbreaks in Asia.
Again, it makes perfect senses that it is easier to eliminate a new pathogen before it becomes endemic. Note that I said “easier,” not “easy.” As the example of SARS demonstrates, eliminating such a pathogen before it spreads to become pandemic is nowhere near easy. It takes a lot of resources and effort, as well as a public health infrastructure to implement containment measures. The authors also note that HIV/AIDS could not be contained because (1) it integrates into the host genome, making it nearly impossible to eliminate completely and (2) it had made the jump to humans decades before its discovery and recognition, “long before the molecular tools that could have detected and potentially fully contained it existed.” The authors further note that the threat of the emergence of a new pathogen like SARS-CoV-2 had been known and planned for a long time before SARS-CoV-2 actually did emerge, adding that its appearance “should therefore not have been a huge surprise, and should have been met with a full mobilization of the technical tools and fundamental public health principles developed over the previous decades.”
Unfortunately, that actually did not happen, except fitfully, leading the authors to lament the  resulting “death of public health and the end of epidemiological comfort,” which brings the authors to a message very much like that of Dr. Adams, Dr. Howard, myself, and many others, namely that containment was actively sabotaged:
After HIV, SARS-CoV-2 is now the second most dangerous infectious disease agent that is ‘endemic’ to the human population on a global scale. And yet not only was it allowed to become endemic, but mass infection was outright encouraged, including by official public health bodies in numerous countries81-83.
The implications of what has just happened have been missed by most, so let’s spell them out explicitly.
We need to be clear why containment of SARS-CoV-2 was actively sabotaged and eventually abandoned. It has absolutely nothing to do with the “impossibility” of achieving it. In fact, the technical problem of containing even a stealthily spreading virus such as SARS-CoV-2 is fully solved, and that solution was successfully applied in practice for years during the pandemic.
“Endemic,” of course, means that the virus is just out there and with us, uncontainable because, well, it’s everywhere, despite examples of nations that did successfully contain many COVID-19 outbreaks before abandoning the effort, including Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, Taiwan, Vietnam, Thailand, Bhutan, Cuba, and China, the last of which, according to the John Snow Project, had “successfully contained hundreds of separate outbreaks, before finally giving up in late 2022.”
Contrary to what GBD proponents will tell you, it’s not as though the tools to contain outbreaks of respiratory diseases haven’t been known for decades:
The algorithm for containment is well established – passively break transmission chains through the implementation of nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) such as limiting human contacts, high quality respirator masks, indoor air filtration and ventilation, and others, while aggressively hunting down active remaining transmission chains through traditional contact tracing and isolation methods combined with the powerful new tool of population-scale testing.
They note that using nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs_ to break transmission chains and driving the effective reproduction number (Re) to well below 1.0 and keep it there would have been much easier when Re was around 1.3 than it is with Re around 3.0, at least before a new variant emerges to bypass immunity, noting that it was not a technical failure, but rather a failure of will:
This is not a technical problem, but one of political and social will. As long as leadership misunderstands or pretends to misunderstand the link between increased mortality, morbidity and poorer economic performance and the free transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the impetus will be lacking to take the necessary steps to contain this damaging virus.
Moreover, as we have noted all along, starting when the GBD was first declared, powerful political and economic interests aligned to oppose measures necessary to contain the emerging outbreak of SARS-CoV-2 before it got out of control. Gavin Yamey and I wrote about them two years ago, and the John Snow Project reiterates our point now:
Political will is in short supply because powerful economic and corporate interests have been pushing policymakers to let the virus spread largely unchecked through the population since the very beginning of the pandemic. The reasons are simple. First, NPIs hurt general economic activity, even if only in the short term, resulting in losses on balance sheets. Second, large-scale containment efforts of the kind we only saw briefly in the first few months of the pandemic require substantial governmental support for all the people who need to pause their economic activity for the duration of effort. Such an effort also requires large-scale financial investment in, for example, contact tracing and mass testing infrastructure and providing high-quality masks. In an era dominated by laissez-faire economic dogma, this level of state investment and organization would have set too many unacceptable precedents, so in many jurisdictions it was fiercely resisted, regardless of the consequences for humanity and the economy.
None of these social and economic predicaments have been resolved. The unofficial alliance between big business and dangerous pathogens that was forged in early 2020 has emerged victorious and greatly strengthened from its battle against public health, and is poised to steamroll whatever meager opposition remains for the remainder of this, and future pandemics.
Notice how much different this reality-based view is compared to the narrative promoted by Jeffrey Tucker. The one thing that I don’t like to have to admit is that Tucker is correct when he says that the GBD won. Where we differ is that, unlike Tucker, I do not view this victory as a good thing. Quite the contrary. Neither do the authors behind the John Snow Project, who sadly note:
The long-established principles governing how we respond to new infectious diseases have now completely changed – the precedent has been established that dangerous emerging pathogens will no longer be contained, but instead permitted to ‘ease’ into widespread circulation. The intent to “let it rip” in the future is now being openly communicated84. With this change in policy comes uncertainty about acceptable lethality. Just how bad will an infectious disease have to be to convince any government to mobilize a meaningful global public health response?
I would go even further. I would argue that eugenics has basically won out over public health. Because SARS-CoV-2 killed mainly—although far from exclusively—the elderly and those with chronic illnesses, views aligning with that of antivaccine crank Del Bigtree, in June 2020 encouraged his followers to “catch this cold” in order to help achieve “natural herd immunity.” The unspoken subtext that reveals the eugenicist intent—usually denied and maybe even not acknowledged, but there nonetheless—is how Bigtree also ranted about those most at risk of COVID-19 having made themselves that way by engaging in high risk behaviors that led to chronic disease, such as drinking and smoking to excess and overeating. (Obesity is a major risk factor for severe disease and death from COVID-19.) Of course, the one risk factor for severe disease and death from COVID-19 that no one has any control over is how old we were when the pandemic hit, given that the risk of severe disease and death climbs sharply with age. I like to point out that, as much as GBD proponents claim that “focused protection” would keep the elderly safe, it couldn’t, can’t, and won’t, because unless you quarantine all the elderly indefinitely they will have interaction with the “low risk” younger people out there necessary to help take care of them. One only has to look at the debacles that occurred in nursing homes early in the pandemic to appreciate how “focused protection” was always a pipe dream, a concession tacked onto the eugenicist vision of the GBD to make it seem less eugenicist.
If you think I’m going too far, just look back a bit. Do you remember how often COVID-19 minimizers would justify doing less (or nothing) to stop the spread of disease because it “only kills the elderly”? I do, and such rhetoric came not just from bonkers antivaxxers like Del Bigtree, either. Do you remember the arguments against vaccinating children against COVID-19 because it “only” kills a few hundred of them a year? I do. Never mind that, on a yearly basis, COVID-19 kills about as many children as the measles did before the vaccine was licensed 60 years ago, adjusted for population? It’s a leading cause of death among children now. “Bioethics”-based arguments not to vaccinate children against COVID-19 are the same old antivax arguments against vaccinating children, just recycled for a new virus, with “esteemed” doctors telling us that we need to accept children dying of COVID-19 “as a matter of course.”
The John Snow Project speculates about how much deadlier COVID-19 would have to become in order to spur the political and social will to actually do something to try to contain it again and come to a depressing conclusion that, even more depressingly, I have a hard time arguing with, namely that, based on the death toll during the Delta and Omicron waves, “12–15,000 dead a day is now a threshold that will not force the implementation of serious NPIs for the next problematic COVID-19 serotype.” They’re not wrong. Over 1 million Americans died during COVID-19, a number that would have been unthinkable in 2019 but now only inspires a collective shrug. That is why the authors, also correctly unfortunately, state that there “can be no doubt, from a public health perspective, we are regressing.” Of that, there is no doubt.
Perhaps the most depressing—yes, even more depressing than the above observations—part of the whole article is how the John Snow Project relates the regression in public health science with respect to infectious disease to all of public health, including vaccines:
We can also expect previously forgotten diseases to return where they have successfully been locally eradicated. We have to always remember that the diseases that we now control with universal childhood vaccinations have not been globally eradicated – they have disappeared from our lives because vaccination rates are high enough to maintain society as a whole above the disease elimination threshold, but were vaccination rates to slip, those diseases, such as measles, will return with a vengeance.
We are, of course, already seeing this, with antivaxxers rejoicing over declines in childhood vaccination rates provoked by the antivaccine sentiment provoked by COVID-19 vaccination mandates. Particularly relevant to what Dr. Adams and Dr. Howard said about the push to reopen schools and let the kids be infected:
Infection, rather than vaccination, was the preferred route for many in public health in 2020, and still is in 2023, despite all that is known about this virus’s propensity to cause damage to all internal organs, the immune system, and the brain, and the unknowns of postinfectious sequelae. This is especially egregious in infants, whose naive immune status may be one of the reasons they have a relatively high hospitalization rate. Some commentators seek to justify the lack of protection for the elderly and vulnerable on a cost basis. We wonder what rationale can justify a lack of protection for newborns and infants, particularly in a healthcare setting, when experience of other viruses tells us children have better outcomes the later they are exposed to disease100? If we are not prepared to protect children against a highly virulent SARS virus, why should we protect against others? We should expect a shift in public health attitudes, since ‘endemicity’ means there is no reason to see SARS-CoV-2 as something unique and exceptional.
Note what I said above about how much the antivax ethos that children don’t need to be vaccinated because COVID-19 supposedly doesn’t kill that many of them has infected the discourse about whether or not children should be vaccinated against the disease. What we are seeing is the same “shoulders shrug” attitude that antivaxxers encouraged before the pandemic, when they would point to episodes of The Brady Bunch and The Flintstones from the 1960s or an episode of The Donna Reed Show from the 1950s, old sitcoms in which measles was played for laughs and treated as something that nearly all children inevitably had to endure, in other words, no big deal. This same attitude has now become common, if not dominant, about COVID-19, stoked by the likes of Tucker and the antivaccine movement. It is the same attitude that antivax doctors like Bog Sears promoted in 2015 and before about measles and other vaccine-preventable childhood diseases.
Unfortunately, as the John Snow Project argues, this lack of concern for mitigating the spread of infectious disease is likely to metastasize to other areas of public health, including worker safety or preventing nosocomial infections in healthcare facilities. After all, earlier this year mask mandates fell in hospitals, even cancer centers:
Worse, we have now entered the phase of abandoning respiratory precautions even in hospitals. The natural consequence of unmasked staff and patients, even those known to be SARS-CoV-2 positive, freely mixing in overcrowded hospitals is the rampant spread of hospital-acquired infections, often among some of the most vulnerable demographics. This was previously thought to be a bad thing. And what of the future? If nobody is taking any measures to stop one particular highly dangerous nosocomial infection, why would anyone care about all the others, which are often no easier to prevent? And if standards of care have slipped to such a low point with respect to COVID-19, why would anyone bother providing the best care possible for other conditions? This is a one-way feed-forward healthcare system degradation that will only continue.
The stress caused by the pandemic has indeed already induced major damage to our healthcare system, damage that is unlikely to be reversed during whatever years remain in my surgical career. What bothers me the most is that I find it difficult to say that the John Snow Project is wrong in its dire predictions. If anything, they might be overly optimistic.

Paul Thacker relitigates criticisms of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington Declaration
“Journalist” Paul Thacker defends Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington Declaration by rehashing the same old deceptive rhetoric.
David Gorski on March 6, 2025
Link
Monday morning, you sure don’t look fine
I always know it’s going to be an…interesting…week whenever I wake up on a Monday morning to find an email from hack conspiracy journalist and attack Chihuahua for all things COVID-19 contrarian and antivax, Paul Thacker. This time around, as has been his usual MO, Mr. Thacker cc’ed my department chair and medical school dean, a transparent tactic that cranks of all stripes have used to try to intimidate me into silence dating back to, well, April 2005. Mr. Thacker has a bit of a twist in that he says his “editor” needs comment by a certain deadline, his editor being him. (He publishes a Substack entitled The Disinformation Chronicle, for which he appears to be the main blogger, although another formerly respectable journalist turned conspiracy theory muckraker, Matt Taibbi, is also listed.) I therefore immediately knew it was, as always, a trap, and that, no matter what I responded, Mr. Thacker would do his best to make me look as bad as he possibly could.
The last time I dealt with our ever intrepid newshound conspiracy hound was last April, when I received a similar email, characteristically also cc’ing my department chair and medical school dean, requesting “comment” about whether Allison Nietzel was a real physician given that she hadn’t done a residency after medical school or obtained a medical license. My sarcastic answer was yes. Dr. Nietzel earned a valid MD at an accredited medical school, and the American Medical Association “affirms that a physician is an individual who has received a ‘Doctor of Medicine’ or a ‘Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine’ degree or an equivalent degree following successful completion of a prescribed course of study from a school of medicine or osteopathic medicine.”
I also threw in a bit of a rejoinder about Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, Stanford health economist and co-author of the Great Barrington Declaration, a very influential document published in October 2020 that advocated a “let ‘er rip” approach to the COVID-19 pandemic—before there was even a vaccine yet!—to achieve “natural herd immunity,” with a tacked-on sounding bit about “focused protection” to keep safe those at high risk of severe disease, complications, and death from COVID-19 (e.g., the elderly and those with chronic disease). Unfortunately, Dr. Bhattacharya and his co-authors Drs. Martin Kulldorff and Sunetra Gupta, appeared not to have thought too deeply about any of it, particularly the focused protection part, given that they really proposed no realistic strategy to achieve such protection. At its heart, the GBD was a profoundly social Darwinist document that, in essence, advocated abandoning the weak to the virus so that the strong could “open up” the economy again. Basically the GBD could never have worked, as one of its supporters implicitly admitted, but managed to do devastating damage to public health, due to its influence.
Here’s what I said about Dr. Bhattacharya:
Finally, I would also point out that, like Dr. Neitzel, someone whom you clearly admire given your recent appearance on his podcast (Stanford Professor Dr. Jay Bhattacharya) has no postgraduate medical training beyond completing medical school either. (Look it up if you don’t believe me.) Yet Dr. Bhattacharya bills himself as a physician in his bio at Unherd, a publication with a much larger readership than SBM. Now that you know this, may I trust that you will also ask the editors of Unherd the same questions about Dr. Bhattacharya that you have asked me about Dr. Neitzel, given that the State of California defines “physician” similarly as “an individual issued a license allowing them to practice medicine”? After all, if it’s wrong or deceptive for Dr. Neitzel to bill herself as a physician-writer in her brief bio on our blog when she does not have a medical license, then it should also be wrong for Dr. Bhattacharya (who similarly has no medical license or NPI) to do the same thing in a publication like Unherd, shouldn’t it? And you are someone with integrity, who couldn’t possibly have a double standard about things like this, right?
The reason that I mention this is because you need to know that Paul Thacker really has a bug up his posterior about my previous writings on Jay Bhattacharya and the GBD. Come to think of it, as you will see, so does Dr. Bhattacharya. This is somewhat alarming given that Dr. Bhattacharya is poised to be confirmed as the Director of the National Institutes of Health. His confirmation hearing yesterday before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions appeared to be the pretext for Mr. Thacker’s attack on critics of Dr. Bhattacharya and the GBD.
So let’s get to the letter.
Paul just wrote me a letter
On Monday morning, I fired up Outlook to check my morning email, only to be greeted by this missive from Mr. Thacker, with my department chair and medical school dean cc’ed to boot:
Hello Gorski,
I’m working on a story, and my editor needs comment back from you by Tuesday, 12 noon. I’m looping in your department chair and dean to provide you with professional support as this seemed to work out in the past.
You posted false and misleading statements about the safety AstraZeneca’s vaccine, which was found to cause blood clots. The UK government stopped offering the vaccine and the company now faces legal liability for its COVID vaccine, according to several news accounts. Several medical experts tell us your Science Based Medicine site serves as pharma marketing and you have zero expertise in vaccines or infectious diseases.
You also posted false and misleading statements about NIH Director nominee Jay Bhattacharya in an error-riddled BMJ essay. The BMJ later corrected some, but not all of your falsehoods.
We need responses to the following questions.
1) Why have you not corrected the record about the documented dangers of AstraZeneca’s COVID vaccine?
2) Do you disagree with AstraZeneca’s admission in court that their COVID vaccine causes side effects?
3) Why do medical experts tells us your Science Based Medicine website is just a pharma marketing website used to harass doctors?
4) Why have you not corrected the record about your documented falsehoods in the BMJ, as explained in several different essays?
5) Why have you not written for The BMJ since they had to correct your essay?
6) Anything we have missed?
Again, we need your response by 12 noon on Tuesday.
Thank you,
Paul– 
Paul D. Thacker
https://www.pauldthacker.com

“At the sound of the intruder, a dog barks. The other 99 dogs bark at the first dog.” – Hannah Arendt
“Hello Gorski”? Well, hello Thacker, I guess.
My first thought, me being me, was that I had to respond. Indeed, I wrote up a response, which I’ll post here, just for your edification. I, too, cc’ed my dean and department chair, because there was a message for them in it too:
Hello Thacker,
Nice to hear from you again. Thanks for your concern that I receive “professional support,” but I don’t think that I need it. It was very kind of you, though.
One notes that you don’t list precisely which statements about the AstraZeneca vaccine you consider to have been “false and misleading,” nor do you link to any specific posts in which these allegedly “false and misleading” statements were published. Similarly, you don’t specify which “medical experts” claim that our blog, Science-Based Medicine, serves as “pharma marketing” or any of the specifics of what they said and why they said it. Absent more information on these two points, it is very difficult for me to formulate a response to these two claims, except for a general response to your slur about SBM: SBM receives no financial support from pharma. Given that I am not the one who does any of the finances of SBM, I am letting Dr. Steve Novella, who founded SBM and manages its finances, know about your inquiry.
As for the 2021 commentary in The BMJ co-authored by Prof. Gavin Yamey and myself,  COVID-19 and the New Merchants of Doubt, let’s be frank. Regarding the “falsehood,” I consider that to have been somewhat sloppy wording that somehow made it through the editorial and fact-checking process but was very quickly corrected with an addendum explaining the clarification made. That error didn’t harm Drs. Bhattacharya or others. Quite the opposite, in fact, it gave the defenders of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) a convenient pretext to take one error and try to discredit everything else stated in the commentary.
Moreover, no one, not even you, appears to be denying that AIER, the right wing “free market” think tank at whose headquarters the meeting at which the Great Barrington Declaration was drafted was held, did indeed receive funding from the Koch Foundation. One also notes that Jeffrey Tucker, who at the time was serving as Editorial Director for AIER, organized this conference with Martin Kulldorff, another co-author of the GBD. To me, Mr. Tucker’s involvement in the GBD makes it difficult to argue that AIER was only just the host of the meeting and had little or nothing to do with organizing and promoting the GBD. Indeed, Mr. Tucker bragged about setting up the meeting on a YouTube video (where he also bragged about being “in the room where it happened” when the GBD was drafted), and AIER registered the GBD website a day before the declaration was issued.
I think that I answered most of your questions in the text of this letter. Also note that, depending on what I see in your final version of your Substack post, I reserve the right to publish a public response and/or take other appropriate action. After all, I am about nothing if not science-based medicine and transparency.
Best,
David
P.S. Since you have done what you and people seeking to attack me for science advocacy frequently do to try to intimidate me, specifically looping in my department chair and dean (a tactic all too frequently used by people like you to try to silence me dating back 20 years), I thought it only appropriate to include in my response a bit about your history and tactics. The first thing they should know is that you write a Substack (The Disinformation Chronicles, which I encourage them to peruse), and your only “editor” is you. The second is that claiming your “editor” needs a response by a certain deadline is a tactic you have used on me before, as explained here and in #4 below. Second, I’ll include a bit of commentary about you and your history of dishonest journalistic tactics, so that they are as aware of what you really are and how you operate as I am, should they have the time and inclination to peruse the articles below:
     1.  Paul Thacker amplifies antivaccine messaging by attacking science communicators
     2.  Paul Thacker Trolling Skeptics on Vaccines
     3.  What the heck happened to The BMJ?
     4.  Hack conspiracy journalism: Paul Thacker vs. the definition of “physician”
     5.  The Once Promising Journalist Who Became a Sadistic Troll
     6.  Thacker parrots an old antivax trope: “Vaccines are magic!”
     7.  “Transparency” should not equal a license to harass scientists
Remember how I (in part) entitled this “Paul Thacker relitigates criticism of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya”? Basically, that’s because that’s exactly what Mr. Thacker is doing here. I actually answered a lot of his loaded questions/criticisms three years ago, when GBD supporters, including Martin Kulldorff and Jay Bhattacharya, struck back. At the time, I expressed surprise that it took them a month to push back. Today, I express surprise that, more than three years after that BMJ commentary and more than four years after the GBD was published and I wrote my initial criticism of it, I still seem to be living rent-free in Dr. Bhattacharya’s head, as do several other critics. Predictably, Mr. Thacker is trying to portray us at SBM as big pharma shills; so let me just interject again: SBM does not receive funding from pharmaceutical companies.
I was all set to hit “send” on what I thought to be an epic response, when I communicated with a colleague with a cooler head, who advised no contact with Mr. Thacker. I thought about it, and I agree. Far better to post a public response, rather than to email him answers that he could cherry pick and distort! So I didn’t send the email to Mr. Thacker, although I did forward it to my dean and department chair, the better to remind them who Mr. Thacker is.
Before I move on to Mr. Thacker’s hack smear-job, let me just amuse you by pointing out that Mr. Thacker followed up the next morning with this, cc’ed (as always) to my dean and department chair:
Hello, we have not received a response. We need your response by 12 noon, today.
Thank you, Paul
I ignored this, and yesterday morning I was greeted with another email, again cc’ed to my dean and department chair:
Hello Gorski, you did not respond to questions but the piece is out.
The COVID-Era Smearing – and Resurrection – of Trump NIH Appointee Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
https://www.realclearinvestigations.com/articles/2025/03/04/the_covid-era_smearing_and_resurrection_of_trump_nih_appointee_dr_jay_bhattacharya_1095151.html
I wrote and pushed through the law that addresses conflicts of interest in medicine and helped the NIH to reformulate their regs on the matter. So I’m still a little confused by the error-riddled essay you wrote in the BMJ on Jay Bhattacharya. If you’re interested in becoming a forward-facing, productive member of the scientific community on financial conflicts in medicine, I’ll refer you to some critical points of interest.
Here’s a talk I gave at Harvard Law School on the matter and why dealing with corruption in medicine is so important: https://hls.harvard.edu/today/at-hls-former-investigator-questions-the-relationship-between-physicians-and-pharmaceutical-industry/
And here’s a piece I wrote for the Safra Center on getting the law and regs changes done: https://petrieflom.law.harvard.edu/2014/09/30/the-father-of-sunshine-2/
Enjoy your day,
Paul
I did actually enjoy my day, as I looked forward to writing this response yesterday evening, part of which was already written, thanks to my email above. I also enjoyed the rest of my day, content in knowing that, contrary to Mr. Thacker’s smear, I receive no money from big pharma. Indeed, he is more than welcome to search the Open Payments database described in his article for the Safra Center. (I bet he did and was disappointed.) I will admit to being mildly surprised that Mr. Thacker’s response hadn’t been published on his Substack, but rather on something called RealClear Investigations. Maybe he does have an editor after all, at least this one time! Perusing the website, the editor of RealClear Investigations is Tom Kuntz, of whom I’d never heard before. If Mr. Thacker’s “exposé” is typical of the quality of the “investigations” reported there, this is clearly an unreliable site.
Aha! I see what’s going on here:
The editorial board of the GBD's journal also includes their Collateral Global colleagues David Livermore (ex-HART), Carl Heneghan and Tom Jefferson (whose recent work includes dumpster diving "studies" misrepresenting responses to FOI requests from random members of the public). pic.twitter.com/4kgoW8f58x
— John Bye (@_johnbye) February 6, 2025
Their claim that papers are "peer-reviewed" also seems dubious. Bhattacharya & Kulldorff's own article attacking covid vaccine trials has two peer reviews questioning interpretation, language and citations, but no reply from the authors and no revisions yet. 🤷‍♂️

h/t @Marco_Piani pic.twitter.com/7MBhvqfMM2
— John Bye (@_johnbye) February 7, 2025
Meanwhile any of the 21 members of the editorial board (some of whom have links to cranks and conspiracy theorists) can unilaterally invite any "prominent public health scientist" to join the "Academy".

At which point its journal has to publish pretty much anything they submit. pic.twitter.com/o1uOXkxM1q
— John Bye (@_johnbye) February 9, 2025
Basically, it looks as though the GBD authors formed their own dubious journal, supported by the RealClear Foundation and associated with the RealClear Media Group. Rather than a real peer-reviewed journal, it looks as though it’s designed to be an echo chamber:
According to the academy’s guidelines, public health researchers can become members through invitation or nomination from other members. New members are accepted based on whether they are “good scientists,” Kulldorff says, something the academy establishes “either by knowing it already from our own experience as scientists, or by reading what they have published” and checking for sound methods and interpretation. Kulldorff says he doesn’t know how many members the academy currently has, but Stanford physician scientist George Tidmarsh, an author on one of the eight papers, said membership was “growing rapidly by the hour, and it will continue to grow indefinitely.”
Once members, researchers can publish “any of their public health research” in the journal, as well as contribute perspectives and reviews of papers in other journals, according to the submission guidelines. “If somebody’s a good scientist, we think they should have academic freedom to publish what they think is important,” Kulldorff says. He notes that the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) used to allow members of that academy to forgo peer review. (This approach has since faced strong criticism, and PNAS has adjusted some of its policies over the years to increase oversight of submitted articles.)
PNAS published some absolutely atrocious crap, along with its good stuff. For example, Linus Pauling, because he was a member of the Academy, was allowed to publish his dubious research on vitamin C in PNAS. This new journal doesn’t have the heft of a real National Academy of Sciences behind it, in addition to its editorial board including a who’s who of COVID-19 contrarians, “respectable” antivaxxers, and grifters, several of whom have been featured on this blog. I suppose that this is what they call “brand synergy” in the biz. Nice work if you can get it.
Let’s dig into the final product, The COVID-Era Smearing – and Resurrection – of Trump NIH Appointee Dr. Jay Bhattacharya. I’ll focus mostly on what he says about me, because it reveals his mendacity. At the same time, I couldn’t help but laugh when I saw my photo in the article, with the caption “David Gorski: Antagonist of Bhattacharya.” I’m seriously thinking of adding that to all my social media profiles. It has a nice ring to it. Thanks, “Thacker”!
If only Paul Thacker had waited a couple of days. I just got a new headshot taken for the website on Monday, but they haven’t added it to my webpage entry yet. On the other hand, the headshot above is probably 8 or 9 years old. My hairline has receded more since then, and I have more obvious wrinkles.
Living rent-free in Dr. Jay’s (and Paul’s) head
Mr. Thacker begins by portraying Dr. Bhattacharya as a suffering hero for scientific truth:
Jay Bhattacharya was in pretty terrible shape five years ago. He was losing sleep and weight, not because of the COVID-19 virus but in response to the efforts of his colleagues at Stanford University and the larger medical community to shut down his research, which questioned much of the government’s response to the pandemic.
Poor baby. Promote bad ideas, and there will be pushback. “Freedom of speech” does not mean “freedom from consequences,” and, I note, the most recent consequence for Dr. Bhattacharya’s advocacy of mass infection has been for him to be nominated to run the NIH, despite his being grossly unqualified to hold that office on the basis of his not being a physician-scientist with a strong track record of biomedical research coupled with his lack of any discernible experience running a large organization like the NIH. Naturally, Mr. Thacker touts his “vindication”:
In the years since, many of Bhattacharya’s scientific concerns about the efficacy of lockdowns and mask mandates have been corroborated. Fauci, meanwhile, accepted a pardon from President Biden, protecting him from COVID-related offenses dating back to 2014, the year he started funding research at a Wuhan, China, lab that U.S. intelligence agencies now believe probably started the pandemic. And this week, Bhattacharya looks set to achieve surprising vindication as the Senate holds a hearing on his nomination to head the NIH, in a Department of Health and Human Services run by science nonconformist Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
What apparently led Dr. Bhattacharya to have such agita five years ago was the reaction to his infamous Santa Clara County seroprevalence study, initially published as a preprint in April 2020 coauthor by (among others) his Stanford colleague Dr. John Ioannidis, which used flawed methodology to produce a much higher estimate of how many people had been infected with COVID-19, the better to produce a much lower estimate for its case fatality rate. Its methodology was widely criticized, and this study was one of the first studies during the pandemic to have wide influence despite having only been published on a preprint server. (It didn’t hit the peer-reviewed literature until a year later, and its flaws were mostly uncorrected.)
Indeed, if there’s one thing that Mr. Thacker avoids like the plague in his search to portray Dr. Bhattacharya as a scientific soothsayer unjustly persecuted by the scientific Powers That Be, as well as their apparent lackeys (e.g., me), for speaking COVID-19 truth, only to be vindicated later is how, over and over and over again, Dr. Bhattacharya has been so wrong as to be not even wrong. Our own Dr. Jonathan Howard documented his many pronouncements that turned out to be wrong in his book We Want Them Infected. Basically, fan of “natural herd immunity” fan that he is, Dr. Bhattacharya predicted that we had achieved “natural herd immunity” and/or that the pandemic would be over in 3-6 months so many times that it’s a running joke.
Indeed, it’s amazing how fast Dr. Bhattacharya went from authoring an article in March 2020 entitled Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say?, in which he wrote:
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
To this:
Although, Dr. Bendavid eventually admitted their predictions were “way off“, Dr. Bhattacharya never looked back or deviated from this message, regardless of the reality on the ground. As the pandemic progressed, he prematurely declared the danger to be gone and minimized every variant. He said COVID had been “defanged” on: April 14, 2021; May 3, 2021; July 21, 2021; July 28, 2021; and January 6, 2022. In 2021, he greatly over-hyped vaccines, saying they blocked transmission and eliminated severe disease. Future historians can understand how the pandemic unfolded by reading Dr. Bhattacharya’s predictions and knowing the opposite happened.
In July 2020 he said Sweden had reached herd immunity. Months later, Sweden limited public gatherings to eight people amidst a COVID surge. In May 2021, he said COVID was “clearly a seasonal disease” and discussed herd immunity in the U.S. by saying “we are kind of already there.”
And this:
Weeks later, Florida reported record COVID deaths, and schools, “drowning in COVID”, couldn’t stay open. Undaunted, Dr. Bhattacharya recorded an interview titled Why No One Should Panic About the Omicron Variant. The headlines later reported soaring death rates in older people and a record number of pediatric hospitalizations and deaths.
Weeks later, Florida reported record COVID deaths, and schools, “drowning in COVID”, couldn’t stay open. Undaunted, Dr. Bhattacharya recorded an interview titled Why No One Should Panic About the Omicron Variant. The headlines later reported soaring death rates in older people and a record number of pediatric hospitalizations and deaths.
Of course, later, Dr. Bhattacharya turned against COVID-19 vaccines, eventually starting a Substack and podcast with Ray Arora, the Illusion of Consensus, which has featured among the vilest of antivaxxers, including Steve Kirsch and Kevin Bass, among others. He held a “debate” with Joseph Fraiman over whether authorization for current COVID-19 mRNA vaccines should be suspended and concluded:
By the end of the debate, Joe had convinced me that not pulling the authorization makes it more likely that we will never get good clinical trial evidence testing to check whether such groups still exist in a setting of widespread recovered immunity.
Peruse his Substack, and search it for “vaccine.” You’ll see what I mean. It’s a festering mass of conspiracy theories and pseudoscience about COVID-19. So is his more recent Substack, Science From the Fringe, where it’s more of the same, including a “conversation” with Joomi Kim, who went out of her way to defend antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
Never mind all that, though. The whole first part of Mr. Thacker’s article portrays Dr. Bhattacharya as a heroic warrior for free speech and scientific inquiry whose first famous pandemic study was unjustly “canceled” through an “inquisition” by a cabal of scientists that included Stanford colleagues, then-NIH Director Francis Collins, and, of course, Anthony Fauci. The truly hilarious thing is that a implication and outright narrative running through Mr. Thacker’s article is that all of us, myself included, who criticized Dr. Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington Declaration did so at the behest of Anthony Fauci and/or Francis Collins, starting with the predictable reference to Fauci’s email about The Great Barrington Declaration:
That month, Bhattacharya and professors Martin Kulldorff, then at Harvard, and Sunetra Gupta of Oxford released the “Great Barrington Declaration,” which called for rejecting harmful COVID lockdowns in favor of “focused protection” for society’s most vulnerable, such as the elderly. With the declaration building support, Collins, four days later, on Oct. 8, 2020, sent Fauci an email with the subject line “Great Barrington Declaration.”
“This proposal from the three fringe epidemiologists who met with the [Health] Secretary seems to be getting a lot of attention – and even a co-signature from Nobel Prize winner Mike Leavitt at Stanford,” Collins wrote. “There needs to be a quick and devastating published take down of its premises. I don’t see anything like that on line yet – is it underway?”
Some hours later, Fauci forwarded Collins a “refutation” of the Great Barrington Declaration written for The Nation by his friend and advocate Gregg Gonsalves, an AIDS activist who is now a professor at Yale. Fauci rose to prominence in the 1980s as an HIV/AIDS researcher. “Indeed, and well said,”replied Collins. The Gonsalves essay referenced no actual science but denigrated Bhattacharya, Gupta, and Kulldorff for ignoring what he called “progressive principles of justice and equality” in favor of “survival of the fittest.”
Fauci has praised Gonsalves several times over the years and, in his recent memoir, singles out Gonsalves and a handful of other activists “for their unflinching support over the past few years.”
Dr. Collins was right about one thing and wrong about another. The three co-authors of the GBD are definitely fringe, but only one of them, Sunetra Gupta, is a legitimate epidemiologist.
Let’s skip ahead to what Mr. Thacker wrote about me, first:
Gorski is a self-described “misinformation debunker” and runs a website called Science Based Medicine. It doesn’t always get its facts straight. After the European Medicines Agency concluded in April 2021, for example, that unusual blood clots should be listed as a very rare side effect for AstraZeneca’s COVID-19 vaccine, Gorski decried the decision on his X account claiming, “Reported blood clots appear to be no higher than background and very likely unrelated to the vaccine.” The UK government eventually stopped offering AstraZeneca’s jab, and the company finally admitted that its COVID vaccine causes harm in what The Telegraph reported could result in millions of dollars in legal claims.
This is very typical of Mr. Thacker’s tactics. For example, he cherry picked a single Tweet, without actually linking to the Tweet, and neglected what I later wrote about the AstraZeneca vaccine. Instead, he linked to an Substack article by him attacking Steve Novella and me, whose deceptive spin and misinformation both Steve and I debunked right after the Substack was published. Here’s the Tweet referenced:
It looks like @stevennovella got to the issue of the AstraZeneca #CovidVaccine before I did, and I agree completely. Reported blood clots after vaccination appear to be no higher than background and very likely unrelated to the vaccine. https://t.co/e6sdik3PC7
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) March 17, 2021
One month later, I wrote about the AstraZeneca vaccines and blood clots, where I conceded that the evidence looked more and more consistent with an association. I even noted that the detection of rare blood clots associated with the vaccine was evidence that our vaccine safety monitoring systems were working! Steve Novella wrote about the same issue and noted the same thing: The association appeared real, although such clots were rare. You wouldn’t know that if all you knew about our writings on the Johnson & Johnson and AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccines came from Mr. Thacker’s biased writings. Basically, he’s just regurgitating an old attack he’d made on us in 2021 that Steve and I had refuted…in 2021! This also demonstrates another difference between SBM writers and Dr. Bhattacharya. We change our views when the evidence demands it—and say so.
Amusingly, apparently to Mr. Thacker I was also doing either Dr. Collins’ or Dr. Fauci’s bidding, because it never occurs to him that Dr. Bhattacharya’s critics might have minds of their own:
“Gorski is damaging to science,” said Bhattacharya. “He creates an environment where researchers can’t speak their mind if they cross the biopharmaceutical industry.” Bhattacharya described Yamey and Gorski as part of a network that carried out Collins’ devastating takedown. “I’ll never publish in a big mainstream journal,” he said a couple of years ago in an interview.
See what I mean by my living rent-free in Dr. Bhattacharya’s head? (And, apparently, also Mr. Thacker’s?) Relitigation, indeed. What really appears to have gotten under Dr. Bhattacharya’s skin, though, is a 2021 BMJ commentary that I co-authored with Gavin Yamey at Duke entitled Covid-19 and the new merchants of doubt. The next part of Mr. Thacker’s smear is basically a rehash of the same attacks launched on that commentary a month after it was published:
In late 2021, Gorski partnered with Yamey on a piece for the BMJ falsely charging that Bhattacharya and other Great Barrington Declaration signers were supported by billionaires “aligned with industry.” Bhattacharya and the other signatories met at a conference hosted by the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), which, Yamey and Gorski argued, “has also received funding from the Charles Koch Foundation, which was founded and is chaired by the right-wing billionaire industrialist known for promoting climate change denial and opposing regulations on business.”
While Gorski and Yamey provided no evidence that Koch money funded the GBD signatories, the BMJ still published their piece. Association with a nonprofit that has distant links to Koch money was apparently enough to carry the whiff of dark money corruption, a charge that still circulates on social media to this day.
“The BMJ article is full of errors that ought to have never found their way into any publication,” wrote Martin Kulldorff in The Spectator. “While the AIER has received only a single $68K (£50,000) Koch donation a few years ago, many universities have received multiple, much larger Koch donations, including million dollar gifts to Duke, Harvard, Johns Hopkins and Stanford.”
Contacted by RealClearInvestigations, Gorski did not respond when asked why he had not corrected his allegations against Bhattacharya.
I’m responding now, in public, so that Mr. Thacker can’t Thack again and twist my words, noting that Mr. Thacker doesn’t actually cite more than one “error.” As I wrote three years ago, saying that other universities receive funding from Koch-associated organizations is not exactly the slam-dunk defense that Kulldorff thinks it is. It’s more of an indictment of universities than a defense of AIER or the Great Barrington Declaration or anything else. Once again, Mr. Thacker shows that there is nothing new under the sun with GBD supporters, as I directly addressed all of this over three years ago—twice!—including this bit by Mr. Thacker: Moreover, a lot of the funding the right wing “free market” think tank AIER didn’t come directly from the Koch Foundation. In my rebuttal, I even cited John Mashey’s investigation, as well as the investigation by Dana Drugman published soon after the GBD was published. Here’s the subterfuge. Little of the Koch Brothers’ support for AIER wasn’t direct, but rather came through other Koch-affiliated entities.
For example, Mashey noted:
Prior to 2017, AIER did not appear to have many connections to Koch-tied individuals or organizations. [35]
However, at some point in early 2017 no later than February, Benjamin Powell joined AIER’s board of directors. Powell was one of several new key staff who joined AIER around that period, with many having ties to the Koch-funded George Mason University (GMU) among other Koch-funded or affiliated groups. [36]
Powell, a GMU economics graduate (PhD), is a senior fellow at the Koch-funded Independent Institute and former president of the Association of Private Enterprise Education that itself received at least $330,500 from the Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation according to DeSmog’s review of public 990 tax forms. [37]
Also:
As shown in comprehensive books including Jane Mayer’s Dark Money and Nancy MacLean’s Democracy in Chains,George Mason University’s (GMU) Economics Department, and the Mercatus Center at and Institute for Humane Studies at GMU have long been key groups for recruiting, training and connecting people for Koch-funded universities and think tanks in the Koch Network. [45], [46]
As I’ve repeated emphasized for the case of AIER and the support it gave the Great Barrington Declaration, not all support is financial, and there’s a lot of important support in terms of personnel and training that filters out from Koch-affiliated organizations to groups like AIER that allows such groups to claim plausible deniability or to discount the amount of Koch-related support as relatively inconsequential by pointing to how seemingly small any direct contributions are. I also can’t help but mention again that Jeffrey Tucker, who at the time was serving as Editorial Director for AIER, organized this conference with Martin Kulldorff, another co-author of the GBD. Again, Mr. Tucker’s involvement in the GBD makes it difficult to argue that AIER was only just the host of the meeting and had little or nothing to do with organizing and promoting the GBD, especially given how Mr. Tucker bragged about setting up the meeting on a YouTube video (where he also bragged about being “in the room where it happened” when the GBD was drafted), and AIER registered the GBD website a day before the declaration was issued.
Weird that AIER didn't know about the Great Barrington Declaration before it was announced on Oct 4, 2020, yet AIER registered gbdeclaration dot org on Oct 3, 2020 🤔
— Justin Feldman (@jfeldman_epi) October 13, 2021
I’ll also cite more of my previous refutation of this nonsense:
I wouldn’t exactly say that The BMJ “retracted,” but rather clarified the article. There is no doubt that, even if the Great Barrington Declaration signatories didn’t receive grants, direct payments, or even travel and lodging expenses from AIER, they definitely received support of considerable other value from the think tank in the form of the “coming out” press conference that the AIER held for them to announce the Declaration and access to the press and high-ranking government officials in the UK and the US. Before the Great Barrington Declaration, they were mostly unknown outside of their professional circles. After that conference, they were well on their way to becoming superstars of the anti-lockdown, antimask movement and were able to promote their ideas at the highest levels of government and for major publications like Newsweek.
Here’s the funny thing. The somewhat sloppy wording of the initial version of the commentary, which implied that the GBD had been directly funded by the Koch brothers, has provided a pretext for GBD authors and supporters to attack everything else in the commentary, none of which has been refuted. It was a wording that was rapidly corrected, but now, well over three years later, hacks like Mr. Thacker still cite it as though that one slip invalidates the central thesis of whole article. It doesn’t, basically trying, as cranks love to do, to use falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus (false in one thing, false in all things) to cast doubt on the whole narrative. What’s even funnier is that the narrative wasn’t really totally false in one thing; it was just unclear in a way that allowed for overinterpretation.
Basically, falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus is a legal principle that dates back to ancient Rome that indicates that a witness who is false about one matter can be considered to be not credible in all matters. This principle is why lawyers are often so aggressive trying to impeach the credibility of a witness and lawyers on the other side labor so hard to prevent that from happening. If a witness can be shown to have been badly mistaken or to have lied about one thing, then by the principle of falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus, it is reasonable to question everything else in that witness’ testimony. In a criminal case such questions could easily be enough to cast “reasonable doubt” on the testimony, which is all that is needed for an acquittal. However, we are not in a legal proceeding, and the GBD authors are not defendants. They are being criticized. Lack of clarity on one point does not invalidate all the other points, and, tellingly, Mr. Thacker doesn’t even try do do that, preferring instead to quote GBD author Martin Kulldorff making a blanket statement that there are a lot of errors in the commentary without actually citing what those errors are and providing evidence to show that they are errors.
Not that you’d get even a whiff of a hint of that narrative from Mr. Thacker, who invokes the usual “lab leak” conspiracy theory bogeymen about connections with EcoHealth Alliance and a a pandemic preparedness program called PREDICT to try to smear Gavin Yamey and then writes:
But the defamatory damage was already done,” Bhattacharya wrote in Newsweek, calling out Yamey and Gorski for their BMJ errors, “and many scientists stayed silent as schools closed and children were harmed, even though they knew better. They did not want to be similarly smeared.”
“Yamey is a narrative enforcer for the pandemic preparedness industry that likely funded the research that caused the pandemic,” Bhattacharya said.
I really hope that RealClearInvestigations didn’t actually pay Mr. Thacker for this tripe.
Why so angry?
I never realized that I had so much power! Living rent-free in Dr. Bhattacharya’s head? I’m crushing the evil GBD signatories, so much so that a commentary I co-authored nearly three and a half years ago still irritates the crap out of GBD supporters in general and Dr. Bhattacharya in particular. I rule! Oh, wait. Dr. Bhattacharya is about to be confirmed as the new NIH Director, and I’m just an academic surgeon with a blog who, professionally, is struggling to keep his research program going. It makes me wonder why Mr. Thacker and Dr. Bhattacharya are still so very, very angry. After all, by any reality-based assessment of influence and power, Dr. Bhattacharya appears to have “won,” so much so that I have to wonder if I will ever be competitive for an NIH grant or be allowed to serve on an NIH study section again. Indeed, given Dr. Bhattacharya’s desire to penalize universities that don’t live up to his very specific vision of “free speech” by withholding grant support, I almost wonder if he would go so far as to punish my university because it is where I am faculty. That an NIH Director would do that was once unthinkable. Not any more. He will be able, potentially, if he chooses, to force me into early retirement, at least in academics, by threatening my place of employment.
I can’t worry about that now, at least not much.
Mr. Thacker’s “report” and comparing it to what I’ve written here, I hope that it’s obvious to our readers just how slanted and deceptive Mr. Thacker’s narrative is. He really is relitigating old grievances held by GBD supporters and authors, including our new NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya. His claims were answered and refuted three years ago, but I guess the distance of time lets him trot them out, tart them up, and present them as though they were something new, right on the day Dr. Bhattacharya faced the Senate HELP Committee.
Again, why so angry? Dr. Bhattacharya won, at least politically. Scientifically, however, he lost three and a half years ago and, regardless of how much political power he amasses, he will never win in actual science. The most he can do is impose a new Lysenkoism on the NIH. I fear, working for his boss antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy Jr., he will do just that.

Brownstone Institute admits that the Great Barrington Declaration was wrong (without actually admitting it was wrong)
The Brownstone Institute’s Gabrielle Bauer claims vindication for the Great Barrington Declaration, the October 2020 document that advocated a “natural herd immunity” pandemic strategy, with an ill-defined “focused protection” strategy to protect those most at risk of death. In the fine print, however, Bauer tacitly admits that its core assumption was badly mistaken, minimizing it as not getting all the “details” right.
David Gorski on February 20, 2023
Link 
From the vantage point of three years into the COVID-19 pandemic, at times October 2020 seems like ancient history, although I do still remember it well. The pandemic was building as the first deadly winter approached, and it was not clear when (or if) there would be safe and effective vaccines against COVID-19. There was hope, of course, because the reports coming out about the clinical trials of the mRNA-based vaccines from Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna sounded promising, but even the most optimistic wouldn’t have predicted that the vaccine would receive emergency use authorization (EUA) and start rolling out to high risk frontline workers a mere two months later and then to the high risk general public not long after that. The 2020 Presidential election was in full swing, as much as it could be given the pandemic-driven restrictions on large gatherings. It was truly a bizarre election.
As far as that month goes, from a public health standpoint arguably the most pernicious development came early in the month, on October 4, when a document known as the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was announced, to great fanfare. We at SBM (particularly Dr. Jonathan Howard and I) have spilled considerable digital ink on the topic of the GBD, starting from the very beginning, when I first noted that its authors had followed a disinformation path laid down long ago by deniers of evolutionary theory, climate science, and that HIV causes AIDS in which a “statement” is proffered and signed by many people in order to give it the appearance of a scientifically respectable “alternative” position to the current scientific consensus on a topic. Never mind that the vast majority of signatories (and often the writers) of such “statements” don’t have the relevant expertise to pontificate so confidently on the scientific topic being addressed. That’s unimportant to the promoters of such “statements,” which are propaganda based on a technique known as “magnified minority,” not scientific statements:
Magnified minority is a denial technique amplifying the contrarians' significance to convey the impression of expert disagreement. The Global Warming Petition Project uses this technique: it amounts to less than 1% of U.S. science graduates (full video at https://t.co/RztsTyiyG9) pic.twitter.com/e9jHZH4qmg
— John Cook (@johnfocook) October 8, 2020
I myself like to refer to it as “scientific astroturfing,” in which “astroturfing” is a term to describe how corporations and ideological propagandists try to produce the illusion of “grass roots” support for their position by producing the appearance of popular support for it behind the scenes, hence the term “astroturf,” which is, of course, fake grass. It was also true then that, when it was published at least, the Great Barrington Declaration was a little different (but only a little different) in that COVID-19 was a new disease and the scientific consensus regarding it wasn’t nearly as solid as the consensus was in the case of evolution, climate science, and vaccines. That didn’t mean that there weren’t wrong answers, though, and the GBD was very, very wrong about a great many things. Recall that its signatories advocated a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic in which the virus should be allowed to spread through the “healthy” population, the better to reach “natural herd immunity” within 3-6 months, all while using “focused protection” to keep safe those at highest risk of severe disease and death, such as the elderly and those with chronic health conditions that predispose to severe disease and death. Notably, how, exactly, to implement “focused protection” was never really well explained, leading to GBD advocates to retrofit strategies that never would have worked anyway because it’s impossible to fully protect those most vulnerable to bad outcomes when a virus is spreading unchecked through the rest of the population. More on that later. Let’s just say that the GBD is a profoundly eugenicist document that basically falsely claims to protect the vulnerable while leaving them at the mercy of a deadly virus.
Unfortunately, as Gavin Yamey and I documented a year and a half ago, the GBD was immensely influential among certain government leaders anxious to end pandemic restrictions and get back to normal life, such as President Donald Trump in the US and Prime Minister Boris Johnson in the UK. Indeed, despite their claims of having been “silenced”, GBD authors had met with President Trump in the summer leading up to publication of the GBD and had been meeting regularly with Trump administration officials.
So why write about the GBD yet again, given that Dr. Howard correctly asked in June if anything about it was even remotely relevant and correctly answered the question with a resounding “No!” The reason is the increasingly desperate and bizarre efforts of the Brownstone Institute to promote a revisionist history in which the GBD was right and everyone else in public health was wrong. It’s an effort that has been ongoing for several months now, but it was crystallized in an article that I saw on the Brownstone Institute website last week by one of its authors (Gabrielle Bauer) titled “Focused Protection: Jay Bhattacharya, Sunetra Gupta, and Martin Kulldorff“. You will recall that these are the now disgraced trio of scientists who originally published the GBD: Jay Bhattacharya, an MD/PhD (the PhD is in economics) and Professor of Health Policy in health economics at Stanford University whose publications tended to be about health economics and policy before the pandemic; Prof. Sunetra Gupta, Professor of Theoretical Epidemiology at Oxford University; and Martin Kulldorff, who at the time was a Professor of Medicine at Harvard University, where his primary work was in biostatistics.
Bauer’s article seems to be the latest in a series of articles based on a recently published book that she edited featuring essays by the usual Brownstone Institute suspects titled, Blindsight is 2020: Reflections on Covid Policies from Dissident Scientists, Philosophers, Artists, and More. Unsurprisingly, it is published by the Brownstone Institute, which was founded by Jeffrey Tucker in 2021 as the “spiritual child of the GBD”. Interestingly, its “About” page no longer describes Brownstone’s as being “in many ways, spiritual child of the GBD,” although the almighty Wayback Machine reveals all.
Here’s the thing, though. Bauer admits in her essay that the GBD “didn’t get every detail right”. That is most assuredly true, but in reality details matter, and the “detail” that the GBD didn’t get right happens to be the core concept behind the entire declaration, namely the claim that the pandemic could be ended by “natural herd immunity.” Let’s dig into that “detail” and some of the other revisionist history about the pandemic and the GBD that Bauer posits.
The Brownstone Institute admits error without admitting error
It’s important to fast-forward to what is the most relevant passage in Bauer’s essay, because to me it represents an admission of the glaring error at the heart of the GBD that its signatories never, ever concede. Of course, Bauer does her best to minimize this admission and make it sound as though it wasn’t really an error but a minor miscalculation that didn’t invalidate the GBD at all, all while leaving it until the second from last paragraph that mentions it almost as an aside. The error? It has to do with reaching herd immunity rapidly by letting the virus rip through the “low risk” population while using “focused protection” to keep “high risk” people safe.
Given this admission late in the essay, it’s important to read and not forget the part near the beginning of her article, where Bauer cites the part of the GBD about “Focused Protection,” which tellingly is capitalized to make it seem as though it is some sort of big deal concept:
This confluence of circumstances made it impossible not to consider the question: Might we give low-risk groups back their freedom while protecting more vulnerable people? That’s exactly what the GBD proposed. I’ve reproduced it here in abbreviated form:
Current lockdown policies are producing devastating effects on short and long-term public health. Keeping these measures in place until a vaccine is available will cause irreparable damage, with the underprivileged disproportionately harmed.
We know that vulnerability to death from COVID-19 is more than a thousand-fold higher in the old and infirm than the young. We know that all populations will eventually reach herd immunity and that this can be assisted by (but is not dependent upon) a vaccine. Our goal should therefore be to minimize mortality and social harm until we reach herd immunity.
The most compassionate approach is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk. We call this Focused Protection. A comprehensive and detailed list of measures, including approaches to multi-generational households, can be implemented, and is well within the scope and capability of public health professionals.
Those who are not vulnerable should immediately be allowed to resume life as normal. Arts, music, sport and other cultural activities should resume. People who are more at risk may participate if they wish, while society as a whole enjoys the protection conferred upon the vulnerable by those who have built up herd immunity.
Also notice that, back then, GBD signatories were not (yet) rabidly antivaccine (that came later), although, as you can see, they did pointedly take pains in the GBD to minimize the importance of developing an effective vaccine to control the pandemic, citing “natural herd immunity” as the most important factor that would end the pandemic, a strategy that was doomed from the start for a number of reasons pointed out by the John Snow Memorandum (JSM), published by public health scientists alarmed at the blithe “let ‘er rip” message of the GBD. First of all, even if “natural herd immunity” were rapidly achievable as outlined in the GBD, it would require massive suffering and death to reach, if it could be reached at all. The JSM signatories labeled the GBD a “dangerous fallacy unsupported by scientific evidence” while pointing out that uncontrolled transmission “in younger people risks significant morbidity and mortality across the whole population” and, in addition to “the human cost, this would impact the workforce as a whole and overwhelm the ability of healthcare systems to provide acute and routine care.” Second, “natural herd immunity” requires that immunity after infection be lifelong, or at least very long-lived. We now know definitively that such is not the case, but even in 2020 the JSM pointed out that there was “no evidence for lasting protective immunity to SARS-CoV-2 following natural infection,” a point that today could be argued that there is considerable evidence that protective immunity to SARS-CoV-2 wanes within several months to a year and that the virus is quite capable of evolving new variants that can largely evade preexisting immunity after prior infection with preceding variants. This is not even a controversial observation any more, although Martin Kulldorff, who has since left Harvard to become the Senior Scientific Director for the Brownstone Institute, has repeatedly echoed an antivax talking point portraying “natural immunity” as far superior to immunity from a vaccine.
This brings me to another passage from Bauer’s article, in which she seems to walk back some of the GBD’s definitiveness in its claims right before her conclusions, almost as an aside:
The GBD didn’t get every detail right, of course. Nobody could have anticipated, back in the fall of 2020, all the surprises the virus had in store for us. While reasonable at the time, the Declaration’s confidence in herd immunity proved overambitious. We now know that neither infection nor vaccination provides durable immunity against Covid, leaving people vulnerable to second (and fifth) infections. And for all their effect on disease severity, the vaccines don’t stop transmission, pushing herd immunity still further from reach.
For the moment. I’ll ignore the exaggerated claims about the vaccines not stopping transmission at all, which is an antivax talking point in which black-and-white thinking is used to transform the much lesser effectiveness of the vaccine at stopping transmission compared to its much greater effectiveness in preventing severe disease and death into a narrative claiming that the vaccine does “not prevent transmission at all.” Citing the lack of durable postinfection immunity after SARS-CoV-2 infection as nothing more than a mere “detail” that the GBD didn’t quite get entirely right takes major cojones, too, given that very concept on which the GBD was based was that allowing the virus to infect those deemed at low risk of complications and death while using “Focused Protection” to keep those at high risk safe would rapidly build up “natural herd immunity” that would protect those at high risk as well as the general population. Oopsy-daisy! Bauer seems to be saying. We got that little part wrong. Oh, well, our trio of GBD authors were still correct because, well, just because!
It’s also not true that “nobody could have anticipated” this outcome either. The JSM anticipated exactly this outcome shortly after the GBD was published. Let me cite the part of the JSM addressing this issue more liberally, taking an Archive.org version from October 15, 2020, so that no one can claim that I’m citing a more recently updated version:
Any pandemic management strategy relying upon immunity from natural infections for COVID-19 is flawed. Uncontrolled transmission in younger people risks significant morbidity(3) and mortality across the whole population. In addition to the human cost, this would impact the workforce as a whole and overwhelm the ability of healthcare systems to provide acute and routine care.
Furthermore, there is no evidence for lasting protective immunity to SARS-CoV-2 following natural infection(4) and the endemic transmission that would be the consequence of waning immunity would present a risk to vulnerable populations for the indefinite future. Such a strategy would not end the COVID-19 pandemic but result in recurrent epidemics, as was the case with numerous infectious diseases before the advent of vaccination. It would also place an unacceptable burden on the economy and healthcare workers, many of whom have died from COVID-19 or experienced trauma as a result of having to practise disaster medicine. Additionally, we still do not understand who might suffer from long COVID(3). Defining who is vulnerable is complex, but even if we consider those at risk of severe illness, the proportion of vulnerable people constitute as much as 30% of the population in some regions(8). Prolonged isolation of large swathes of the population is practically impossible and highly unethical. Empirical evidence from many countries shows that it is not feasible to restrict uncontrolled outbreaks to particular sections of society. Such an approach also risks further exacerbating the socioeconomic inequities and structural discriminations already laid bare by the pandemic. Special efforts to protect the most vulnerable are essential but must go hand-in-hand with multi-pronged population-level strategies.
Yes, the JSM called it, no matter how much GBD apologists and flacks have tried to claim otherwise. That’s because it didn’t take a heck of a lot of knowledge about virology, immunology, infectious disease, and epidemiology to recognize the twin flaws at the heart of the rationale behind GBD: that it was unlikely that postinfection immunity would be durable and that it’s impossible to keep the virus confined to the “low risk” population, not to mention that it is impractical even to try, meaning that any herd immunity approach would result in many more deaths than necessary.
If we accept for the moment Bauer’s ridiculous view of the GBD signatories as some sort of heroes of freedom, we can for rhetorical purposes cast the GBD as Abraham Lincoln and the JSM as John Wilkes Booth. (Wait for it.) If we then cast Bauer as Mary Todd Lincoln, it’s difficult not to ask her a question about the pandemic, “Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?” Deluded ideologue and hack that she is, her answer appears to continue to be, “Just great!” Of course, in reality it is not the JSM signatories who were the villains and the GBD signatories the heroes. Quite the opposite! I merely use this old chestnut to show how far Bauer goes to spin her revisionist history. Bauer tried to bury this concession in a single brief paragraph added almost as an afterthought near the end of a much longer piece in order to seem “reasonable,” but it upon which the GBD was based was not only anticipated to be probably incorrect back in October 2020 but demonstrated conclusively to be incorrect over the subsequent two and a half years.
Truly, at the Brownstone Institute, the GBD reminds me of a certain fictional character from a 1970s movie meeting reality.
Reality vs. Bauer’s conception of the GBD
I was tempted to end this post here, after having pointed out that Bauer had basically admitted—while trying to minimize the admission as merely “not getting all the details right” and “who could have anticipated what would happen?”—but Bauer’s portrayal of the GBD signatories as some sort of brave soothsayers who suffered for telling the “Truth” is hard to resist at least briefly looking at. This passage stands out to me in particular, in which Bauer portrays the public and public health establishment as “frightened” and not yet “ready” to accept the “Truth” of the GBD. I will cite it at more length than I usually quote because I want you to experience it in all its “glory”:
In the early months of the pandemic, scientists concerned about lockdowns feared “coming out” in public. The GBD partners took one for the B team and did the dirty work. They paid a heavy price for it, including the loss of some personal friendships, but they held their ground. In print, on air, and on social media, Bhattacharya continues to describe lockdowns as “the single worst public health mistake in the last 100 years,” with catastrophic health and psychological harms that will play out for a generation.
It’s no longer unfashionable to agree with them. A National Post article written by four prominent Canadian doctors in late 2022 maintains that the “draconian Covid measures were a mistake.” A retrospective analysis in The Guardian suggests that, instead of going full bore on the lockdown strategy, we “should have put far more effort into protecting the vulnerable.” Even the sober Nature admits that lockdowns “exacerbate inequalities that already exist in society. Those already living in poverty and insecurity are hit hardest”—exactly the key takeaway from the Australian Fault Lines report released in October 2022.
Kulldorff captures this sea change in one of his tweets: “In 2020 I was a lonely voice in the Twitter wilderness, opposing lockdowns with a few scattered friends. [Now] I am preaching to the choir; a choir with a wonderful, beautiful voice.” The landscape has also become more hospitable for Bhattacharya, who in September 2022 received Loyola Marymount University’s Doshi Bridgebuilder Award, awarded annually to individuals or organizations dedicated to fostering understanding between cultures and disciplines.
Perhaps the concept of focused protection simply arrived too early for a frightened public to metabolize it. But the idea never died down completely, and after the paroxysms of moral indignation ran their course, it slowly grew a second skin. By September 2022, the tally of GBD co-signatories had surpassed 932,000, with over 60,000 of them from doctors and medical/public health experts. Not bad for a dangerous document by a trio of fringe epidemiologists. And would it be churlish to point out that the John Snow Memorandum maxed out at around 7,000 expert signatures?1
I note that this is the passage immediately before the bit about the GBD not getting “every detail right”. Note the narrative, in which the GBD signatories “took one for the B team” and were willing to do “the dirty work.” In truth, that last part about “dirty work” is accurate, just not in the way that Drs. Kuldorff, Bhattacharya, and Gupta” conceive it. From my perspective, they were useful idiots who did indeed to the “dirty work,” just dirty work for the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), a right wing think tank, brought together at its Great Barrington, MA headquarters by its then-Editorial Director, Jeffrey Tucker, along with a number of sympathetic journalists and PR flacks, with Tucker later bragging about how he had been “in the room where it happened” as the GBD was drafted.
If you doubt the far right wing nature of AIER and now the Brownstone Institute, which Tucker later founded and is now rife with other ideologues, COVID-19 pandemic minimizers, antimaskers, anti-lockdowners, and antivaxxers, consider that Tucker is a former Ron Paul acolyte and neo-Confederate. Let’s just say that the GBD signatories did indeed do some seriously “dirty work” for some seriously dirty people who can’t make up their minds whether to label public health fascist or Communist. I guess it’s both, depending on what Tucker and the Brownstone Institute need.
As for Dr. Bhattacharya winning the Doshi Bridgebuilder Award (Navin Doshi, not that Doshi), one has to wonder what Loyola Marymount University was smoking to think that he had in any way “fostered understanding” between cultures. The award happens to be jointly sponsored by Bellarmine College of Liberal Arts, the Department of Theological Studies, and the Navin and Pratima Doshi Professorship of Indic and Comparative Theology; so maybe that explains it. For example, past recipients include luminaries such as Rupert Sheldrake and Deepak Chopra (who was the award’s very first recipient in 2006).
According to the revisionist history of people like Bauer and many other Brownstone Institute flacks and GBD supporters, Kulldorff, Bhattacharya, and Sunetra have all been totally “vindicated”—never mind not getting all the “details” right, such as the central premise of what the GBD proposed—and now everyone’s getting on board, as evidenced by the GBD having so many more signatories than the JSM. It’s just that everyone was too “frightened” and deluded in October 2020 to see how correct the GBD would be proven to be! I have a phrase to describe this characteristics of cranks and propagandists: The fallacy of future vindication.
Perusing the Brownstone Institute’s website, I also found a bit more revisionist history, or at least oddities. For one thing, Martin Kulldorff is no longer listed as the Senior Scientific Director of Brownstone, but rather as this, in addition to a GBD co-author:
Martin Kulldorff is an epidemiologist and biostatistician. He is Professor of Medicine at Harvard University (on leave) and a Fellow at the Academy of Science and Freedom.
“On leave” from Harvard is also new. It’s been well over a year since it was announced that he would be taking on the role of Senior Scientific Director at the Brownstone Institute, and in that announcement there was nothing about him being “on leave” from Harvard, and Bauer’s article states that he had “ended an 18-year run as a Harvard University professor in 2021” and his bio described him as, “Most recently, he was professor at the Harvard Medical School for ten years.” A perusal of his Brownstone Institute entry using the Wayback Machine at Archive.org reveals that it was sometime between late June of last year and September 8, 2022 when his entry changed from his having been at Harvard for 10 years to his being “on leave.” For some reason the Wayback Machine did not crawl his bio page between June 28 and September 8, 2022. A similar tedious search led me to discover that sometime between March 18, 2022 and April 24, 2022, Kuldorff’s bio changed from describing him as “Senior Scientific Director of Brownstone Institute” to “Senior Scholar of Brownstone Institute.” So who is running the pseudoscience clown car at Brownstone these days? Dr. Kulldorff isn’t even listed any more on the “about” page of Brownstone. (I was too tired to plod through successive Archive.org crawls to see when his name disappeared.)
Maybe Kulldorff decided to become full time faculty at the Hillsdale College, a conservative college that has become a font of COVID-19 misinformation even after having managed to get its employees vaccinated ahead of schedule by February 2021, before front-line health workers (and senior citizens and K-12 teachers in Hillsdale County). He was, after all, one of the first three fellows named to Hillsdale’s Academy for Science and Freedom, along with Jay Bhattacharya and Scott Atlas. Whatever happened, it’s interesting to me that Brownstone brought Martin Kulldorff on with such fanfare in November 2021, only for him to cease to be listed as Senior Scientific Director less than six months later, and for this all to happen with few, if any, outsiders noticing, even ones who have paid a lot of attention to the Brownstone Institute.
One wonders what sort of behind-the-scenes movement among the various players at Brownstone is occurring and who is in charge of messaging, other than Jeffrey Tucker. The answer, likely, is probably: No one. He is in charge of messaging, because Brownstone Institute is very much an astroturf fake “think tank” designed to promote an ideological message, its scientists being there to provide a patina of seeming scientific respectability.
None of this stops Bauer from concluding:
Be that as it may, the GBD creators wrote a crucial chapter in the pandemic story. They planted seeds of doubt in a locked-in narrative. After all the insults were thrown, the seeds took root in our collective consciousness and may well have shaped policy indirectly. And as research continues to document the dubious benefits and profound harms of the maximum-suppression strategy, yesterday’s shamers and mockers are inching back toward the question: Could we have done it another way? Might focused protection have worked just as well, or better, and with considerably less damage?
Sadly, we already know the answer to Bauer’s question, and it is a resounding “no.” That answer notwithstanding, the Brownstone Institute continues to promote a narrative in which the GBD authors are brave mavericks who spoke “Truth” even though they were supposedly “silenced” (they weren’t), while promoting a counterfactual narrative in which those who tried to promote sound public health interventions somehow “inverted the heroic archetype“, as though it is somehow “heroic” to let oneself catch a disease that can result in severe disease and even death, as well as long term debilitating symptoms for many survivors. It’s not, and the GBD authors are not heroes who were vindicated. They served as useful idiots for ideologues who have done serious harm to public health.

Is Anything About the Great Barrington Declaration Even Remotely Relevant?
The authors of the Great Barrington Declaration still claim that herd immunity is possible in 3-6 months.
Jonathan Howard on June 2, 2022
Link

The Frequently Asked Questions section of the Great Barrington Declaration predictably laments measures to control COVID. In response to one question it said,
At the end of 2020, governments around the world, including many states in the US, continue to restrict normal activities, and some are introducing additional lockdown restrictions. Many schools remain closed to regular in-person teaching, while many businesses, concert halls, and churches are closed or only permitted to operate at partial capacity. Lockdown remains a primary tool used by many governments to address the pandemic.
That was true at the end of 2020.
Now that 2022 is nearly halfway done, I have some further questions for the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration. Specifically, I am curious about the following from their website:
For how long must high-risk individuals be careful and/or self-isolate?
When herd immunity is reached, they can live normally again with minimal risks. How long that takes depends on the strategy used. If age-wide lockdown measures are used to try and suppress the disease, it could take a year or two or three, making it very difficult for older people to protect themselves for that long. If focused protection is used, it will likely only take 3 to 6 months.
They wrote “Herd immunity occurs when enough people have immunity so that most infected people cannot find new uninfected people to infect, leading to the end of the epidemic/pandemic”.
That sounds great. I’d love for the pandemic to end this fall. Here are my questions:
    • If focused protection were to be perfectly implemented today, do you still believe we’d have herd immunity in 3 to 6 months?
    • If yes, what current government restrictions must end so that we can reach herd immunity in this time frame? Be specific.
    • If no, why haven’t you updated your website? What is your current estimate for how long must high-risk individuals be careful and/or self-isolate? How did you arrive at this number?
    • If you think we’ve reached herd immunity, could you please write an article with that title and stop talking about COVID?
And if these questions can’t be answered, is anything about the Great Barrington Declaration even remotely relevant today?
I know the answer.

A Review of “In Covid’s Wake”: According to Laptop Class Professors, the Heroes of the Pandemic Were Laptop Class Professors
The authors of the Great Barrington Declaration prevented fair and honest discussion by constantly spreading fake information. The authors of a new book don’t care at all.
Jonathan Howard on March 25, 2025
Link
A new book titled In Covid’s Wake: How Our Politics Failed Us by Stephen Macedo and Frances Lee was recently published. The authors have been making the media rounds, claiming that studies that found “stringent COVID-19 restrictions were associated with substantial decreases in excess deaths during the pandemic” don’t exist. Macedo and Lee, both political scientists at Princeton, never saw what COVID could do when it spread unchecked, and at least from what I read, their ignorance of and indifference to what happened in hospitals was on stark display.
Before deciding whether to read the whole book, I skipped to the section on the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) and it’s three authors, Drs. Sunetra Gupta, Martin Kulldorff, and Jay Bhattacharya. Based on that chapter, I am not going to waste my time reading further. There are so many things wrong with it, it’s hard to know where to begin. I feel nearly every paragraph should come with some sort of disclaimer that reads, “no one who worked on a COVID unit would ever say anything like that.”
First, however, I will start with one thing Macedo and Lee got right. Though it’s a trivial achievement, they at least quoted several paragraphs of the GBD, including the core section that laid out their plan of herd immunity via mass infection:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk. We call this Focused Protection.
A lot has happened since then. There’s plenty of natural immunity but nowhere in the world has herd immunity. Reasonable people have correctly concluded that since the central premise of the GBD was a complete failure, the rest of the document has little value.
In contrast, Macedo and Lee argue that if one discards everything the GBD got wrong, what remains is correct. Similarly, if one throws out the Yankee’s losses last year, they had a perfect season. To salvage the wreckage of the GBD, Macedo and Lee employee many of the propaganda techniques I’ve described previously.
Treating Proposals As Accomplishments
Macedo and Lee wrote that:
The authors of the Declaration argued that for the low-risk majority, normal life should otherwise resume. Schools and restaurants should reopen, and teaching should be in person (with special provision made for older or immunocompromised teachers and students).
This is true. From the comfort of their offices, the authors of the GBD argued for wonderful things and claimed they would have done them. They didn’t help schools open or protect the vulnerable, but they would have. Macedo and Lee were very impressed by these “would have” statements and treated them as genuine accomplishments.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya would have done so many wonderful and amazing things
As those of us who operate in the real world know, there was a big difference between writing the words “open schools” or “protect the vulnerable” and actually accomplishing these tasks when COVID was swirling. In areas where the GBD had influence, they failed to accomplish a single thing they would have done. In October 2021, just after the Delta wave ravished the state, Dr. Kulldorf stated, “One place where we had some success was Florida.” Let’s examine their “success” there:
    • They failed to protect “vulnerable” people: “Florida Leads Nation in Number of COVID-19 Deaths of Nursing Home Residents and Staff,” August 2021.
    • They failed to protect “not vulnerable” people: “Child Covid Deaths More Than Doubled in Florida as Kids Returned to the Classroom,” September 2021.
    • They failed to keep schools open: “School Closures Reported In Five Florida Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID,” August 2021.
    • They failed to protect educators: “15 Miami-Dade Public School Staff Members Die of COVID In Just 10 Days,” September 2021.
    • They failed to achieve herd immunity: “Florida’s COVID Deaths Reach Nearly 6,000 in 2024,” January 2025.
Macedo and Lee were careful not to let this uncomfortable reality intrude into their fantasy of the GBD.
Indifference to Disinformation
Macedo and Lee wrote the following:
The Declaration’s authors were hardly infallible. Like everyone during the Covid years, they got some things wrong.
They got some things wrong. That’s like describing the Grand Canyon as a pothole or a terrorist attack as an unfortunate accident. The authors of the GBD didn’t just say a few silly things in hastily-worded Tweets like I did. They deliberately and drastically downplayed COVID at every stage, repeatedly spread fake statistics, and treated rare, temporary vaccine side effects as a fate worse than death. These were not all innocent errors. The authors of the GBD engaged in a years-long pattern of sustained disinformation. It has taken volumes to begin to categorize their false predictions and factual errors. This 2-hour long video of mine just scratches the surface. Moreover, their errors weren’t “like everyone” else’s. I rapidly acknowledged and corrected my goofs. The authors of the GBD never did this. My errors were barely noticed and didn’t hurt anyone. In contrast, the authors of the GBD never were famous and influential. Their disinformation drove policy and had tragic, real-world consequences.
Indeed, aside from the obvious fact that COVID is more dangerous for older people, essentially every premise of the GBD was wrong. These flawed premises were:
    • People could be easily and neatly divided into “vulnerable” and “not vulnerable” categories
    • Infections in “not vulnerable” people could be prevented from spilling over into “vulnerable” people
    • Children don’t spread COVID
    • Death was COVID’s only meaningful harm
    • Reinfections were rare
    • Herd immunity was inevitable
Macedo and Lee devoted just two sentences to these errors and even then used that as an opportunity to fluff the GBD’s authors. They said:
In an interview published on May 21, 2020, for example, Sunetra Gupta opined that “I think that the epidemic has largely come and is on its way out in” the United Kingdom. In another interview published two months later, she speculated that the threshold for herd immunity might be lower than others supposed and that it might have already been reached or at least approached in some places. In both instances, she was laying out possibilities and arguing for ranges of uncertainty greater than policymakers were acknowledging. She was drawing attention to the costs of lockdowns, especially for the poor, and calling for more tolerant debate and discussion of a wider range of theories, projections, and policy responses.
According to Macedo and Lee, even when Dr. Gupta was repeatedly wrong about basic things, she was was fundamentally right.
In reality, the authors of the GBD relentlessly sought to numb people to the risks of the virus because they wanted to infect people with it. The core belief of the GBD was that spreading the virus was necessary to tame the virus. It claimed that “as immunity builds in the population, the risk of infection to all – including the vulnerable – falls”.
The GBD objected to mitigation measures not because they thought they failed to slow the virus, but precisely because they knew that’s what they did. As such, they wanted schools open without testing, masks, and vaccines, and even said it was “more dangerous for public health” to vaccinate everyone than no one. They lamented that suppressing SARS‑CoV‑2 “postponed the inevitable”- as if that was a bad thing– and delayed herd immunity, which they claimed would arrive in just 3-6 months, if only the virus was allowed to do its job. Watch below as they lay out their plan to end the pandemic by Christmas 2020 by letting the virus “sweep through the population”.
Macedo and Lee did not mention this absurdly optimistic time frame, which GBD’s authors repeated often on social media. Yet, even though the core premise of the GBD was totally wrong, Macedo and Lee blew this off, absurdly implying that only the GBD’s authors and supporters cared about the harms of mitigation measures and thought about trade-offs.
Worse still, Macedo and Lee even spread misinformation about the GBD’s disinformation. They wrote things like this:
The most notable thing about these cases is how unusual they are. The risks of Covid to healthy 22-year-olds and athletic 41-year-olds were extremely low.
While healthy young people were not immune to COVID’s harm, something obvious to those of us who worked in hospitals, this wasn’t the age range given by GBD. Dr. Gupta claimed COVID’s risk began at age 65 while Dr. Bhattacharya said COVID was “much milder” for people under 70. Macedo and Lee did not tell this to their readers, nor did they inform them that COVID was a top killer for young people in 2021, even with effective vaccines. All this would have been much worse had 250 million unvaccinated Americans simultaneously contracted COVID in the fall of 2020 as the GBD proposed.
Macedo and Lee also offended on behalf of the virus. The felt it didn’t get enough “positive” things said about it. They wrote.
Denying the positive contribution of natural infection and recovery to herd immunity became a staple of public health messaging, as we will see.
No one who worked on a COVID unit would say anything positive about natural immunity. Many people didn’t recover.
Woke-Washing the Pandemic
According to Macedo and Lee, the authors of the GBD were benevolent souls, motivated by leftist concerns of social justice and inequality. They supposedly abhorred the privilege of the “laptop class”, a phrase Macedo and Lee used many times, and were deeply concerned for the fate of:
Grocery clerks, janitors, food packing and processing workers, transportation workers, and other such people— who, in the United States, were disproportionately Black and Hispanic.
Macedo and Lee did not explain why the working-class people I saw die would have been better off if only more lawyers and bankers had died next to them. They also provided no evidence that if there were no lockdowns, “healthy low-risk people” would have happily gone to offices, schools, and restaurants where they would have been perfectly willing to contract COVID en masse.
In reality, the GBD was sponsored by a pro-tobacco, libertarian, child-labor advocate, and its authors were the epitome of laptop class privilege. During the signing of the GBD, just before the worst wave of the pandemic when 3,000 Americans would die daily, they had a champagne toast to celebrate their plan for mass infection. As Dr. Neil Stone put it:
I will never forget, at the height of the pandemic, with patients and families and healthcare workers going through awful traumas, the Great Barrington Declaration being signed in a wood paneled room to the chink of champagne glasses was the ultimate in smug, privileged disconnect
Macedo and Lee did not mention the inglorious origins of the GBD, nor any of their connections to right-wing financers and politicians, whose concern for poor Black and Hispanic janitors is decidedly lacking.
Treating YouTube Videos as More Important Than Lives
However, the longest section of their chapter opened with this abhorrent sentence:
Ultimately, the Great Barrington Declaration is less significant than its reception.
They also wrote:
Many other accomplished academics and doctors who dissented from orthodox views on Covid policy were subjected to reputational attack and social media censorship both in the United States and around the world.
That’s right. According to Macedo and Lee, the flesh and blood victims of the GBD’s anti-vaccine disinformation were less consequential than the indignities suffered by its authors. Macedo and Lee felt that advocates of herd immunity via mass infection were the pandemic’s Main Characters. They suffered “reputational attack,” which of course, they richly deserved. Macedo and Lee singled out Dr. Gregg Gonsalves for sending mean Tweets and not centering the feelings of pro-infection doctors. Macedo and Lee devoted many pages to the fate of various social media posts and the hurt feelings of Dr. Scott Atlas, an early advocate for herd immunity via mass infection who spread gross misinformation in his role as President Trump’s advisor.
Similarly, even though Dr. Bhattacharya became a media celebrity who earned $12,000 from his Twitter posts and cavorted with world leaders, parlaying his fame into a top position in the Trump administration, Macedo and Lee claim he was “censored.” They described a CNN appearance as “a rare mainstream media appearance for Bhattacharya.” They felt he was owed more TV time, and that that he didn’t get enough opportunities to deceive people, claiming that 9 flu deaths are more than 123 COVID deaths for example.
I confess that I only skimmed this section. With all that’s going on, I couldn’t summon the will to care that the authors of the GBD were called “fringe“. It’s not that big of a deal. No one should care whether or not Stanford upset Dr. Atlas by censuring him. It was a meaningless slap on the wrist. Dr. Atlas wasn’t silenced and he is just fine, no matter how hard Macedo and Lee try to portray him as victim. Other doctors suffered more.
Meanwhile, Macedo and Lee casually brushed aside the deaths and disabling of “healthy young people” by saying it was a “small number.” While they mourned the loss of a YouTube video, they ignored children in Florida, like Victoria Ramirez, who died because their parents were told, by the authors of the GBD, that they should let their unvaccinated children contact COVID. The images below are just 6-weeks apart, though Macedo and Lee didn’t mention either of them.
“Ultimately, the Great Barrington Declaration is less significant than its reception.“
While Macedo and Lee felt disinformation doctors were owed a safe space, their demands of civility and decorum were predictably applied only to critics of the GBD, not to its authors. They made no mention of Drs. Atlas’ and Bhattacharya’s juvenile, unprofessional insults and personal attacks, especially towards doctors who worked on COVID units, unlike them. Even though Dr. Fauci and his children needed bodyguards, Macedo and Lee ignored the threatening behavior of Dr. Kulldorff, who tweeted out a pictures of a guillotine with the words “the carnage is unspeakable” and compared “Faucism and fascism.”
It Needed to be Grappled With Fairly and Honestly.
Macedo and Lee concluded:
The most difficult question for pandemic management was always how to strike the right balance across harms from Covid and harms from Covid policies. The answer to this question would never be easy, but that’s just the point. It needed to be grappled with fairly and honestly.
That’s sounds nice, but if Macedo and Lee actually believed that, they would have explained how the authors of the GBD prevented fair and honest discussion by spreading fake information and throwing tantrums against those who corrected it.
Perhaps the rest of their book is much better and I owe its authors an apology. From what I read, while Macedo and Lee claim to be spokesmen for poor Black and Hispanic janitors, in reality their goal is rewrite the history of the pandemic and erase the victims of disinformation. This is because Macedo and Lee are exemplars of laptop class who wrote a book about the laptop class to protect and glorify the laptop class. This required them to spin an absurd fable where famous, sheltered doctors who wrote an error-filled, pro-virus Declaration at the behest of wealthy right-wing benefactors, were actually oppressed heroes. Today these laptop classes doctors are cheering on RFK Jr. and are poised to join a regime that is actually censoring science and purging scientists.
That’s whom this book defends.


“Is it Your Assertion That Picking Deadlines of Dead Kids is a Good Way to Evaluate a Policy?”
What matters more than reality itself?
Jonathan Howard on October 16, 2026
Link
“One place where we had some success was Florida.”
Last year, I wrote a review of the book In Covids’ Wake, written by two Princeton political scientists, Stephen Macedo and Frances Lee. My article was titled A Review of “In Covid’s Wake”: According to Laptop Class Professors, the Heroes of the Pandemic Were Laptop Class Professors, and it discussed their chapter on the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD).
The chapter had many flaws. One of the biggest was that it mistook boasts for accomplishments. For example, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya bragged that he would have opened schools and would have protected the vulnerable, and Macedo and Lee believed him. In their world, “calling for” other people to do things on Fox News was a great accomplishment. It never occurred to them that they might have something to learn from those of us who worked in hospitals. That perspective didn’t matter to them at all.
I also noted that the authors of the GBD had a track record in Florida, which Macedo and Lee ignored. I wrote:
As those of us who operate in the real world know, there was a big difference between writing the words “open schools” or “protect the vulnerable” and actually accomplishing these tasks when COVID was swirling. In areas where the GBD had influence, they failed to accomplish a single thing they would have done. In October 2021, just after the Delta wave ravished the state, Dr. Kulldorf stated, “One place where we had some success was Florida.” Let’s examine their “success” there:
    • They failed to protect “vulnerable” people: “Florida Leads Nation in Number of COVID-19 Deaths of Nursing Home Residents and Staff,” August 2021.
    • They failed to protect “not vulnerable” people: “Child Covid Deaths More Than Doubled in Florida as Kids Returned to the Classroom,” September 2021.
    • They failed to keep schools open: “School Closures Reported In Five Florida Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID,” August 2021.
    • They failed to protect educators: “15 Miami-Dade Public School Staff Members Die of COVID In Just 10 Days,” September 2021.
    • They failed to achieve herd immunity: “Florida’s COVID Deaths Reach Nearly 6,000 in 2024,” January 2025.
Macedo and Lee were careful not to let this uncomfortable reality intrude into their fantasy of the GBD.
In my view, these real-world “successes” mattered infinitely more than all the amazing, wonderful things the GBD authors “would have” done.
“Is it your assertion that picking headlines of dead kids is a good way to evaluate a policy?”
Not everyone saw it that way, and I think exploring why helps explain how we got to this sad moment. One political science professor from Stanford’s Hoover Institution was unimpressed with my critique. They weighed in in the comments here and said:
I always find it odd that someone would claim to be too busy to read a book, but not so busy that they can write a review of the book they haven’t read.
I didn’t claim to be “too busy” to read the entirety of In Covid’s Wake. The professor just made that up. In reality, I said the chapter I read was so bad “I wasn’t going to waste my time reading further”, and I didn’t review the parts I hadn’t read.
The professor continued:
One potentially useful criticism for you: picking a state (Florida) at random and grabbing some headlines about various bad outcomes is not a good way to assess the influence of a policy. I recommend reading the book though, maybe you’ll want to apologize. Or maybe you’ll want to write a longer essay about what they got wrong. At any rate, it is good to read an argument before criticizing it! You might learn something too.
I didn’t pick Florida at random. The professor just made that up too. Even though it was right there in my article, my clueless critic had no idea that I picked Florida because Dr. Martin Kulldorf was right when he said, “One place where we had some success was Florida.” The most recent addition to their list of “successes” is an article titled Florida Ranks Last in Reading, Warns Nationwide Education Report.
My critic was unbothered by these headlines, however. They didn’t matter to him at all. The professor asked me an easy question:
Is it your assertion that picking headlines of dead kids is a good way to evaluate a policy?
My answer is yes. The news reports I shared weren’t false after all, nor were they random sob stories of tragic accidents. Rather, they revealed how the authors of the GBD failed to do anything they claim they “would have” done and the immense suffering that resulted. Now that 5 years have passed, I am unaware of any formal studies or analyses showing that Florida thrived while they helped run the show in the summer of 2021.
As such, headlines of dead children, especially when combined with headlines of dead seniors, dead teachers, and closed schools, aren’t just a “good way” to evaluate a policy—they are the only way to evaluate a policy. What matters more than reality itself? As SBM commentator Mike Stevens put it:
When someone says “One place we had success with implementing Policy X was Florida”, then it is entirely apposite (sic) to look at the outcome of Policy X in Florida, and if it has failed, to point that out.
He’s absolutely right, and it’s hard to imagine this being controversial. It’s not as if Florida would have been better off had only more unvaccinated people contracted COVID, as the GBD advocated right before the Delta variant ripped through the state.
The professor, however, disagreed:
I don’t think that the evidence provided—a series of very troubling newspaper headlines—could establish the policy as a failure or success.
Of course, that “policy” was We Want Them Infected, but according to this professor, a series of very troubling newspaper headlines are insufficient grounds to judge it as a failure or success. Incredible.
“A sixth measles-related death is reported in Pennsylvania”
I am writing about this particular professor not because they were exceptional, but rather because their open apathy was common and ordinary amongst sheltered, elite opinion makers. All the credulous podcasters and “liberal” book reviewers who fawned over Macedo and Lee’s pandemic fanfiction similarly revealed that what happened in the real world didn’t matter to them either. It’s no wonder they deliberately avoided frontline healthcare workers and anyone else who might puncture their fantasy bubble with a reality needle. The pandemic was just an intellectual parlor game for these pundits, something to be debated, not experienced.
They also didn’t grasp that Florida’s catastrophe contained a warning for us. As the Delta variant arrived in Florida, the authors of the GBD spread anti-vaccine misinformation and falsely reassured people the risk was gone.
This had real-world consequences. As epidemiologist Dr. Jason Salemi put it in an article from October 2021 titled Florida Delta Wave Cases Plunge, Leaving Record Deaths in Its Wake:
An overwhelming majority of those deaths and hospitalizations could have been prevented through a combination of improved ability to get shots in arms, as well as those other mitigation strategies.
He was right, and the best predictor of the future performance is past performance. Those of us who paid attention back then aren’t the least bit surprised by what’s happening today. Even though the GBD authors are doing “their best“, COVID is still closing schools, and measles is killing unvaccinated Americans now that they have power.
    • No one can say the warning signs of MAHA’s malevolence and incompetence weren’t there. All anyone had to do was read the headlines and care about them. Sheltered laptop class professors didn’t care, however, and they didn’t hide their indifference: they were proud of it.

2020 and the pandemic: A year of (some) physicians behaving badly
Looking back on 2020, if there’s one thing that the COVID-19 pandemic has taught us, it’s that crises reveal character. Unfortunately, the character of too many physicians has been found wanting, as they spent 2020 denying the pandemic, peddling quack cures, or spreading misinformation in the service of defying public health interventions. What can be done?
David Gorski on December 28, 2020
Link

As I sat down yesterday to write this post, it suddenly occurred to me: This will be my last post of 2020. Out of curiosity, I scrolled back to the very first post I published in 2020 and noticed that it was a post about acupuncture for chronic pain (and, of course, how it doesn’t work). How quaint, I thought. I then realized that it was around that time that what later came to be known as SARS-CoV-2 but then was known just as the novel coronavirus that had first emerged in Wuhan, China was just a blip on the world news. True, I did write about it for the first time on this blog in February, when I discussed a claim by former bioinformatics scientist turned antivax quack and pseudoscientists, James Lyons-Weiler, that he had “broken the coronavirus code.” (Hint: He hadn’t; so it was unsurprising that he was making this claim on the video podcast of an even more rabid antivaccine propagandist, Del Bigtree.) It’s also true that by the end of January I had written on my not-so-super-secret other blog about the very first conspiracy theory about COVID-19 that I had encountered, namely that a larger-than-usual use of the influenza vaccine in China had led to an increased susceptibility to the novel coronavirus, thus starting the outbreak that soon turned into our current pandemic. It was a strangely precise claim that I ended up revisiting and refuting right here on this very blog as well, when über-quack Joe Mercola regurgitated it. Sadly, to this day, the claim that the flu vaccine increases your susceptibility to COVID-19 by 36% remains one of those viral bits of pandemic disinformation that just won’t die, and I still see it popping up from time to time. Worse, it’s a claim that was popularized by a physician.
The point is that, first, beginning in early March, when COVID-19 was officially declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization, this blog (and my not-so-secret other blog) were taken over by the all things coronavirus, for the simple reason that the pandemic became the single biggest focus of medical misinformation, science denial, and quackery in the world. The very next week, I was writing about the promotion of the anti-malaria drug hydroxychloroquine as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19, a topic that we at SBM have since revisited more times than I can remember. Sadly, the disinformation and astroturf propaganda campaigns spawned by the drug’s boosters, including Didier Raoult and Dr. Oz, have since metastasized to other drugs, such as ivermectin (which deserves a post of its own) and that evidence can’t seem to kill the myth that hydroxychloroquine is a cure for COVID-19 that could allow the “reopening” of the economy that “they” are hiding from you—for nefarious purposes, of course. Second, and worse, many of these claims are being spread by physicians, which brings me to my year-end theme: What do we do about physicians behaving badly, particularly in a pandemic? In other words, what do we do about physicians who actively spread antivaccine disinformation, deny or minimize the severity of COVID-19, promote (or even sell) quack (or at least unproven) “cures,” and spread other disinformation designed to discourage people from cooperating and complying with public health authority recommendations to slow the spread of the pandemic?
Antivaccine physicians in 2015: How quaint
Nearly six years ago, I wrote a post entitled, What do we do about politicians and physicians who promote antivaccine misinformation? It was written at a time when the Disneyland measles outbreak was still in full swing, an outbreak whose toll was minuscule compared to the carnage caused thus far by COVID-19, as of this writing over 19 million cases and 330K deaths and (rapidly) counting in the US alone. Yet that outbreak spawned SB 277, the California law that eliminated nonmedical “personal belief exemptions” to school vaccine mandates, a movement that spread to other states. It even led some (like myself and former SBM regular contributor Peter Lipson) to suggest that antivaccine physicians should lose their medical licenses, a suggestion that I revisited a mere three weeks ago, when the Oregon Medical Board issued a temporary emergency suspension of the license of antivaccine pediatrician Dr. Paul Thomas, an action that I heartily approved of. At around the same time, the Oregon Medical Board also issued a similar suspension of the license of Dr. Steven LaTulippe, a physician who had given a speech to a pro-Trump, anti-“lockdown” rally in which he bragged that he didn’t wear masks at his medical practice. The suspension was an action that I also heartily approved of. As they year draws to a close, this sort of case was what led me to write this post.
The reason, quite simply, is that, as dangerous as the disinformation being promoted back then by doctors like “Dr. Bob” Sears and a panoply of “integrative” physicians and pediatricians in California who started selling fake “medical exemptions” to school vaccine mandates (and, yes, Dr. Thomas, who was just starting to become famous as an antivax pediatrician back then) was, the disinformation being promoted by physicians now is so much more harmful.
2020: The year of physicians behaving very, very badly
Obviously, the one massive overarching event that will forever define 2020 and by which this year will be remembered has been the COVID-19 pandemic, which has nowhere-near run its course yet, even as the first effective vaccines are starting to roll out to healthcare workers and those most vulnerable in nursing homes. In well under a year, SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus responsible for COVID-19, has already claimed the lives of one in one thousand Americans since the first reported infections in late January and the first reported deaths in February. Not only is that estimate likely a gross undercount, but I haven’t even included the toll the virus has taken in the rest of the world, with nearly 1.8 million dead total as of this writing. Just think of it, though. Currently, COVID-19 is the leading cause of death in the US, having surpassed cancer and heart disease, and the very fact that it’s claimed one in one thousand Americans puts a very hard lower bound on its infection fatality rate of 0.1%, given that it’s killed 0.1% of the population already. Of course, given that it has only taken a small fraction of the people in the US having been infected to reach this grim milestone, that means the true IFR is likely much higher; yet we still see COVID-19 deniers referring to “99%” or even (“99.8%”) survival and saying that the disease is “no more deadly than the flu,” as though even such a “high” survival rate means that the disease is no big deal and that we’re “overreacting”. Pay no attention to all those hospitals whose ICUs are overflowing and that are hitting the point where they are having trouble taking care of the usual emergencies because they’re so busy taking care of critically ill COVID-19 patients.
That’s why I found it so depressing just how easily so many physicians jumped on board the COVID-19 denial train or started chasing shiny miracle cure objects, like hydroxychloroquine. Just out of curiosity, I perused SBM and my not-so-secret other blog for examples, restricting my search to quackery and/or disinformation peddled only by those with an MD or DO after their names. Sadly, the examples were numerous. One good overview comes to us courtesy of our very own Jann Bellamy, who discussed in June an FTC warning about all the quackery being promoted by physicians and, of course, naturopaths, chiropractors, and acupuncturists. One favorite is intravenous high dose vitamin C (because, don’tcha know, to quacks intravenous high dose vitamin C is good for everything, including cancer, the common cold, and, yes, COVID-19):
To give you an idea of the geographic and provider diversity, other clinics nabbed by the FTC for promoting IV Vitamin C for COVID-19 include the Envista Medical Neck & Back Center (California MDs and DCs), Whole Health Chicago (an “integrative” practice which includes an MD, a “chiropractic physician specializing in functional medicine”, a TCM practitioner, and a homeopath), Revive and Rally Health Lounge (Kansas, run by an MD and an RN), Aspire Regenerative Health (California ND), iCRYO (a multi-state cryotherapy-infusion franchise operation with an MD Chief Medical Officer), LotusRain Naturopathic Clinic (California), Naturopathic European Medical Centre (which, despite the name and spelling, is in Wisconsin), Holgistic Personalized Healthcare/Natural Care Institute (Michigan MD and ND partnership), Traditional Chinese Medicine Clinic (Colorado Doctors of Oriental Medicine and Acupuncturists), East Valley Naturopathic (Arizona), Gonino Center for Healing (Texas DO), Hawaii Naturopathic Retreat, Health Associates Medical Group (California MD, DO, DC and LAc combo), Restore Med Clinic (California MDs), Revival Hydration (a “100% mobile” California infusion company using unspecified “medical professionals”), Sage Integrative Medicine Clinic (Washington NDs), and Vero Clinics (Illinois MD).
Then, of course, Joe Mercola was named as a “superspreader” of COVID-19 disinformation, and so he is.
Of course, Mercola and the docs mentioned by Ms. Bellamy are the usual “integrative medicine” grifters selling dubious treatments alongside conventional medicine as the “best of both worlds”. It’s unsurprising that they view the COVID-19 pandemic as a profit opportunity that can be pursued by simply “rebranding” their usual treatments as somehow being able to prevent and/or treat COVID-19. Far more dangerous, in my view, are the physicians promoting misinformation about COVID-19, discouraging people from following public health interventions to slow the spread of the virus, or even fear mongering about new COVID-19 vaccines before they were even ready to be distributed. Inevitably, some of these physicians’ views are reflected in how they practice medicine, thus putting their patients in danger.
Take Dr. LaTulippe, for instance. The Oregon Medical Board quite appropriately suspended his license because he had openly bragged that he didn’t use or require masks at his medical practice which violated an order in Oregon requiring healthcare workers to wear face coverings in healthcare settings, and also because he was giving out dangerous misinformation to his patients. At the time, I didn’t look into just how egregious his violations were. I now rectify that error:
The order of suspension gave some examples of practices at his clinic.
It stated that a patient who contacted the clinic in July to get advice on being tested was told, “asymptomatic persons should not be tested, that wearing masks does not prevent transmission of COVID-19, and was directed not to self-isolate because being around other people would provide [the patient] with immunity to COVID-19.”
On July 23, after questioning the advice, the person was terminated as a patient.
Additionally, the suspension order said that LaTulippe repeatedly told elderly and pediatric patients incorrectly “that it was ‘very dangerous’ to wear masks because masks exacerbate COPD and asthma and cause or contribute to multiple serious health conditions, including but not limited to heart attacks, strokes, collapsed lungs, MRSA, pneumonia, and hypertension.”
The order also notes that Dr. LaTulippe “and the staff in his clinic refuse to wear masks in the clinic and urge persons who enter the clinic wearing masks to remove their masks,” “regularly tells his patients that masks are ineffective in preventing the spread of COVID-19 and should not be worn,” and “further asserts that, because virus particles are so small, they will pass through the recommended N95 masks and most other face coverings people are choosing to wear,” while directing “patients to a YouTube video providing false information about mask wearing.” The order further notes:
On December 2, 2020, a Board investigator visited Licensee’s clinic and observed: neither patients nor health providers were wearing masks; no screening procedures were in place or being conducted (e.g., taking patient temperatures on or before entering the clinic); no hand sanitizer was available in the waiting area; a sign was posted in the public area of the clinic with “warning signs” of CO2 toxicity; an article was posted in the public area of the clinic, with a portion of the article highlighted that claims 94% of the individuals who will experience serious effects of COVID-19 have co-morbidities.
The last bit is a bit of viral COVID-19 disinformation claims that because 94% of COVID-19 fatalities have comorbidities recorded on their death certificates, therefore “only 6%” of those recorded as having died of COVID-19 had actually died of COVID-19, rather than the comorbidities. It’s utter dishonest nonsense, as I explained, that I like to refer to as the “only 6% gambit“. That a physician would so willfully misunderstand how death certificates are filled out and how having comorbidities that might have contributed to one’s death by COVID-19 does not mean that COVID-19 wasn’t the cause of death is shocking, but is an example of a phenomenon that has been all too evident and common this year. Worse, horrible doctor that he is, Dr. LaTulippe even cut a patient loose from his practice for having questioned his disinformation. I also note that the order of suspension also includes a pretty good refutation of Dr. LaTulippe’s nonsense based on science. Let’s just put it this way. Masks are imperfect, but they work (and do not make you sicker), N95 masks the best of all, which is why they are used by those treating COVID-19 patients. Ditto social distancing. Ditto hand washing. Any physician who refuses to follow these practices and encourages his patients not to follow them is practicing medicine so far below the standard of care that it is, in my not-so-humble opinion, malpractice.
2020: The year of physicians spreading disinformation about a pandemic
Doctors like Dr. LaTulippe are just one example of the harm physicians spreading COVID-19 disinformation can do. If Dr. LaTulippe hadn’t drawn attention to himself by speaking at an anti-“lockdown” and antimask rally, he might have been able to go on practicing his substandard, disease-spreading medicine for a lot longer than he did. However, for a doctor to do real damage in a pandemic requires that he become well known and start spreading disinformation that encourages resistance to public health orders, such as mask mandates, the temporary closing of specific businesses where spread of contagion is more likely, and vaccines, when they become available. We’ve seen a sadly large number of examples of this phenomenon this year, starting very early in the pandemic.
I’ve written about the mania over hydroxychloroquine, going all the way back to March. A brief recap is in order. As I discussed in more depth in April, the hypothesis that antimalarial drugs might be effective treatments for COVID-19 originated in Wuhan, China during the early phase of the pandemic in January. There, Chinese physicians reported that none of their 80 patients with lupus erythematosus who were taking hydroxychloroquine went on to become infected with SARS-CoV-2. As a result of that and old in vitro evidence of antiviral activity for the drugs, they became interested in using these antimalarial drugs to treat COVID-19. (Never mind that immunosuppressed patients are exactly the patients most likely to assiduously follow the recommendations of public health authorities during a pandemic.) A number of clinical trials were registered, and, based on anecdotal reports and small clinical trials (nearly all of which are as yet unpublished), in February the Chinese government published an expert consensus recommending CQ or HCQ for patients with COVID-19. Soon after, a number of nations followed suit. By March and April, hydroxychloroquine was part of the protocol used at many hospitals in the US and all over the world, despite the incredible lack of good evidence that it actually worked.
To some extent, this was understandable, even though the abandonment of evidence-based medicine led to an unkillable story about a “miracle cure” that still hasn’t died even though randomized clinical trial evidence has now clearly shown that hydroxychloroquine does not work against COVID-19. The docs in the trenches of the ICUs and ERs were desperate for anything that might work. But then the grifters and quacks jumped on board, encouraged by the horrible “science” on hydroxychloroquine promoted by French researcher Didier Raoult. You’ve probably heard these names: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko, Dr. Mehmet Oz (yes, him!), Dr. Stephen Smith, and many others. Meanwhile, a group of doctors dubbing themselves “America’s Frontline Doctors” (none of whom are actually what I would consider pandemic frontline doctors) started promoting all manner of COVID-19 disinformation, including the claim that hydroxychloroquine is a miracle cure that “they” are keeping from the people.
Among the worst of these doctors, Dr. Stella Immanuel:
I refuse to be chained by fake science. I have successfully treated over 250 COVID patients with HCQ, zpack and zinc. No deaths. All these double blinded studies sponsored by big Phama is fake science.@ProcterMd @richardursomd @realDonaldTrump @dbongino @IngrahamAngle
— Dr. Stella Immanuel MD (@stella_immanuel) July 17, 2020
Dr. Immanuel had her 15 minutes of fame when it came out that she had been known before the pandemic for believing that gynecological problems like cysts and endometriosis are in fact caused by people having sex in their dreams with demons and witches. It’s how she got the nickname of being the “demon sperm” doctor. Among these “frontline doctors” were other quacks and grifters, such as Dr. Simone Gold, who’s also appeared at QAnon rallies.
It’s not just hydroxychloroquine quacks, though. Early in the pandemic a pair of ER physicians made a brief splash promoting dubious epidemiology to downplay the severity of COVID-19. Other physicians who have spread COVID-19 disinformation include Dr. Carrie Madej, who has promoted the myth that the new mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines will “reprogram” your DNA and are in fact transhumanism. (I kid you not.) How a physician can make it through medical school without understanding some very basic molecular biology (seriously, this is Biology 101 material, people!) that tells us that mRNA vaccines will not alter your DNA, I don’t know, but there you go. Then there’s Dr. Kelly Victory, an ER doctor who’s a veritable cornucopia of COVID-19 conspiracy theories and disinformation. The list goes on and on.
Perhaps the most despicable propaganda being promoted by some physicians is that, because COVID-19 is known to be much more lethal in older people and people with comorbidities such as type 2 diabetes, we should simply, in essence, let the virus rip through the “young, healthy population” and used “focused protection” to keep it from killing the elderly in nursing homes. Yes, I’m referring to the Great Barrington Declaration, a document produced by an epidemiologist, a biostatistician, and a Stanford physician basically advocates doing just that, never mind that it’s impossible to achieve herd immunity without a vaccine, unless you are willing to accept millions of deaths, and then it’s debatable whether it’s possible at all. Basically, the Great Barrington Declaration is a eugenics declaration, the denials of its authors notwithstanding, and a physician was one of the three authors who collaborated with the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), a right wing think tank advocating “opening up” the economy. Even more sadly, although it is true that there were a lot of fake signatories to the declaration, spoofs done to demonstrate how lax the website’s procedure for signature verification was, it is also true that a lot of apparently real physicians did sign it. Fortunately, it is also true that a great many also signed the John Snow Memorandum, an excellent refutation to the Great Barrington Declaration. Of note, the physician behind the declaration, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, later backed off a bit and seemed to be trying to have it both ways.
Arguably the absolute worst example of a physician behaving badly during a pandemic is Dr. Scott Atlas, who rose to prominence advising President Trump on his coronavirus response during the summer. Atlas is a neuroradiologist and, so it seems, a formerly well-respected one, having served as the chief of the neuroradiology section at Stanford University. Unfortunately, later he became a political hack working for the Hoover Institution at Stanford, a conservative think tank that’s been a font of bad takes on COVID-19. The reason Dr. Atlas so quickly gained Trump’s ear even though he had no relevant expertise in infectious disease, epidemiology, or public health, of course, is because told Trump what he wanted to hear, that COVID-19 was not deadly, that we could achieve herd immunity, and that the cost of the “lockdowns” was far worse than the “disease” of COVID-19 being addressed. Perhaps his most infamous moment was when he Tweeted:
Atlas had criticized Michigan’s new Covid-19 restrictions in a tweet shortly after they were announced Sunday evening, writing, “The only way this stops is if people rise up.”
“You get what you accept. #FreedomMatters #StepUp,” he said.
The message — which runs counter to the consensus of public health officials — immediately fueled new tension between the White House and Michigan Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, whom federal and state officials announced last month was the target of an alleged domestic terrorism kidnapping plot.
Unsurprisingly, Dr. Atlas was entirely on board with the Great Barrington Declaration, and, as a result, in October the Trump administration was seriously considering a herd immunity-based strategy before there was a vaccine. Truly, when the history of the pandemic is finally written with the perspective of a decade or two from now, Dr. Atlas will likely end up being one of the worst of the worst in terms of physicians promoting misinformation, largely because of his outsized influence in the Trump administration before he finally—and mercifully—resigned a few weeks ago, when it finally became absolutely clear that Trump’s legal challenges of the election results would fail and that there would be no second Trump administration, at least not in 2021.
Again, I could go on and on and on and on. The most recent wrinkles that keep surfacing are the promotion of ivermectin as a cure-all using exactly the same arguments and tactics (something I do need to write about in 2021 if it remains relevant) and doctors spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt about COVID-19 vaccines, a task that physicians who were antivaccine before the pandemic have leapt on with enthusiasm.
What do we do about doctors spreading disinformation during a pandemic?
This post has been a litany of doctors behaving very, very badly in 2020. As the year lurches to a close, that leaves the question: What can be done about these doctors in 2021? As I like to say, crises reveal character. So while this crisis has revealed a whole lot of good character among physicians and other healthcare providers, as evidenced by the number of physicians who’ve worked so hard for so long and sacrificed so much to save lives and try to ease suffering during the pandemic, sometimes at considerable risk to themselves of being infected with coronavirus, it’s also revealed a whole lot of bad character in doctors. You’ve seen it. I and my fellow SBM bloggers have written about it. These are the ideologues who’ve let their personal belief systems override science, the grifters, the science deniers, and the quacks.
Physicians are, of course, humans beings like any other. What that means is that we are just as prone to the errors in thought to which all humans are prone, including logical fallacies, confirmation bias, confusing correlation with causation, etc. Similarly, we as a group are just as prone to letting political, ideological, and/or religious beliefs influence their actions as anyone else is. I wish it were otherwise, but it clearly isn’t.
Finally, although I sometimes get some outraged blowback from my colleagues when I say this, it must be emphasized that most physicians are not scientists, and that’s OK. Most physicians don’t need to be scientists to do their jobs well and take good care of patients. I view our profession as more of an applied science, like engineering, than pure scientific research. Medicine should be, as this blog has long advocated, based in science, even if it isn’t itself a science. Having seen both sides, as an MD and a PhD, I think I can safely say this. Unfortunately, society tends to give a lot of deference to the scientific opinions of physicians, whether that deference is observed. Regular readers might remember that I used to write a lot about physicians who deny evolution; i.e., creationist physicians. So did Steve Novella. One such physician in particular comes to mind, a neurosurgeon named Dr. Michael Egnor, whom I long ago dubbed the Energizer Bunny of antievolution. So epic was his misunderstanding of evolution that a term was coined for it: Egnorance. But it wasn’t just evolution; Dr. Egnor also promoted dualism, much to Steve’s annoyance as a neurologist.
The reason that I’m bringing Dr. Egnor up again after all these years is simple. Not only was he a prime example of how easily even well-respected physicians could fall into pseudoscience when they wandered out of their area of expertise, but he also demonstrated absolute faith that medical practice keeps physicians from being so spectacularly wrong, or, as he once put it, “…medical practice is a very effective check on b.s., because in medicine ideas often have immediately obvious consequences.” My response was:
Actually, those who have been regular readers of this blog almost certainly realize that Dr. Egnor holds far too high an opinion of the utility of medical practice as an “effective check on b.s.” In fact, it is science that serves as a “very effective check on b.s.,” not medical practice. Indeed, I’ve argued that time and time again. Yes, it’s true that science is often wrong, that sometimes it takes a maddenly long time for incorrect paradigms to be overthrown by new experiments and observations, and that the process of correcting accepted scientific dogma with hypotheses that more closely fit the data and make better corrections can be incredibly messy viewed from the outside, but science is inherently self-correcting. Eventually, b.s. is cast out. Not so when it comes to pseudoscience like ID creationism and–yes, you knew I’d mention it eventually–unscientific medical practices.
After all, what is the whole concept of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) but incredibly concentrated b.s.; yet medical practice seems to have no effect preventing so many physicians to believe in a variety of unscientific and ineffective treatments. Indeed, unscientific CAM has infiltrated bastions of scientific medicine, such as Yale, Beth Israel, and others. Medical practice didn’t stop Dr. David Katz or Dr. Andrew Weil from falling into pseudoscientific woo. It certainly didn’t stop Dr. Jay Gordon from deciding that his clinical experience leading him to believe that vaccines cause autism trumps the strong science and epidemiology that say they do not, from making brain-meltingly ridiculous claims that there are “toxins” in vaccines that cause all sorts of terrible complications, or even giving speeches to rallies organized by people and groups who are antivaccine. He even exasperates the normally mild-mannered Steve Novella.) Practicing medicine didn’t stop any of these people from diving headlong into pseudoscience, even in areas directly related to their medical practice.
If anything, the COVID-19 pandemic has reinforced my opinion, first stated 12 years ago, that medical practice itself is a sadly weak check on BS, particularly when the medical system is stressed. Just look at the list of examples that I’ve discussed in this post and realize that there are many more that I could have discussed if I didn’t mind having this post balloon up to 10,000 words or more. The point, of course, is that all too often we physicians view ourselves as relatively immune to being led astray by “BS”, certainly far more so than others. It is that arrogance that leads to doctors like Dr. Scott Atlas pontificating on areas of medicine that he doesn’t understand and then portraying himself as Galileo when criticized for it. Don’t believe me?
Here you go:
Little did I realize 10-15 years ago how dangerous this tendency among some doctors would become, although I should have recognized it given how many times I encountered the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), which, I suspect, has been behind some of the astroturfing of hydroxychloroquine but has definitely been pushing the “casedemic” conspiracy theory that claims that it is false positives due to too-sensitive PCR testing that is giving the appearance of a pandemic.
Personally, I’m hardening in my opinion that it is appropriate for medical boards to investigate doctors like these, but at the same time I do recognize that there are a lot of problems with taking this course. First, state medical boards are notoriously toothless. Think about it. How many times has the Texas Medical Board gone after Stanislaw Burzynski over the last 40+ years and failed? Or what about the quack whose friendship with the town sheriff led to the identification of the nurses who complained about him and their suffering severe professional and legal consequences as a result? Or what about the neurosurgeon who can’t operate and injured many patients? Or what about the oncologist who administered chemotherapy to patients without cancer and administered medically-unnecessary chemotherapy to patients with cancer? So bad was his behavior that a nurse interviewing for a job noticed that the chemotherapy was being mixed up incorrectly and complained to the state medical board with no result. This oncologist was only brought down when the feds investigated massive Medicare fraud. Given the fusion of pro-Trump, right wing politics with COVID-19 disinformation, it’s not uncommon that doctors like the ones I’ve described align with Trump supporters and are likely to be painted as martyrs (as Dr. LaTulippe was) when medical boards come after them, even more so than Dr. Burzynski’s supporters tried to portray him. The reason is simple. Dr. Burzynski’s supporters were few (albeit vocal). Trump supporters are numerous and supported by a whole media infrastructure to get their message out.
Medical boards also need a concrete complaint, and that concrete complaint usually has to be about the actual practice of medicine. The Arizona Board, for example, might list 49 definitions of unprofessional conduct, but try fitting spreading COVID-19 disinformation into any of them.
The bottom line is that state medical boards tend to be toothless, underfunded, and overwhelmed. That’s why the only physician behaviors very likely to result in strong action consists of running a prescription mill, sexual improprieties with patients, or practicing while impaired due to abuse of alcohol or illicit substances. It’s a matter of resource allocation and prioritization. State medical boards tend to react primarily to what they perceive to be the most immediately and obviously dangerous behaviors. Practicing quackery rarely makes the cut, because medical boards are loathe to make value judgments about medical practice, and proving quackery is way harder and more resource-intensive than proving a doctor is an addict practicing while impaired or that he’s diddling patients. Even horrible surgeons like Dr. Duntsch, whose epic incompetence in the operating room resulted in multiple “clean kills” and so-alarmed colleagues that they actually took the rare action of complaining about him, all too often take a long time to take down. On the other hand, the pandemic might very well change the perception of state medical boards regarding the harm being done by misinformation and disinformation. Also, as was the case with Dr. LaTulippe, any physician who is publicly spewing anti-public health, COVID-19 denying disinformation is almost certainly also not practicing good medicine with respect to infection control practices during a pandemic, just as Dr. Thomas’ public promotion of antivaccine disinformation was accompanied by substandard medical care.
The bottom line is that practicing medicine is a privilege, one of the highest privileges society can grant to any human being. It is not a right. Unfortunately, all too often the law treats it more like a right, with state medical boards being loathe to strip quacks and other doctors practicing inarguably substandard medicine of their privilege to practice. That needs to change, and that change needs to include stopping physicians from abusing the privilege of their profession to spread disinformation that kills, as too many physicians did in 2020 and, sadly, are likely to continue to do in 2021.

The making of COVID-19 “contrarian” doctors
In 2009, I tried to answer the question: How do doctors become quacks and antivaxxers? A Twitter encounter suggested to me that an update to that post is massively overdue.
David Gorski on October 24, 2022
Link

This is one of those weeks where, going into the weekend, I thought I knew what I was going to write about for today’s post; that is, until something happened that totally changed my plans. On the other hand, what I’m going to write about today is related to my original topic. I just decided to broaden the post into more of a general discussion of something that I haven’t really written specifically about since around 2009. Basically, an exchange on Twitter told me that a 13-year-old post desperately needed updating in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. Here’s the exchange:
This reminded me of the very first article I had ever read from @gorskon at Science-Based Medicine.
I also saw it as a strong defense of the physician-scientist. https://t.co/lxpFiMXmjL
— Druv Bhagavan (@DruvBhagavan) October 22, 2022
Which led me to respond:
I might have to write an update to that old post in light of the pandemic…
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) October 22, 2022
And it’s true. That old post is one that I’m particularly proud of. At the same time, I realize that it’s spectacularly out of date, given what has happened since COVID-19 hit the world nearly three years ago, hence my thought that I really do need to update it. So, after having thought about it for a day, I decided that I had to try to do it, even if I take the risk that the update is inferior to the original. Also, Jonathan Howard published an excellent post last Friday about another possible reason why doctors gradually become “contrarians”, a state that has led too many of them to descend into worse than contrarianism, such as openly peddling antivax conspiracy theories. That reason is audience capture, and I will elaborate on it near the end of my post. Moreover, even nearly three years into the pandemic, my colleagues keep expressing surprise that there are so many physicians who’ve turned into cranks with respect to COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines, I’d like to discuss why they shouldn’t be so surprised and the factors that lead to this seeming transformation.
Physician social media influencers who’ve embraced COVID-19 contrarianism and antivax
How is my desire to update a previous post about why physicians become cranks and antivaxxers related to what I had originally planned on writing about? It turns out that a few days before the exchange above, I noticed this Tweet by Dr. Drew Pinsky, which as of my writing now is his pinned Tweet:
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Dr. Fauci, CDC & Big Pharma Collusion w/ Dr. Ke… https://t.co/Hy1lGCoZF8 via @YouTube
— Dr. Drew (@drdrew) October 19, 2022
That’s right, radio and TV personality who’s now a podcaster, Dr. Drew, hosted longtime antivax activist and leader turned general purpose COVID-19 antimasker, anti-“lockdowner”, and antivaxxer, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., on his podcast to promote the new “documentary film” adaptation of his conspiracy theory extravaganza book, The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health, first published nearly a year ago. Seeing the Tweet about my old post just a few days after having seen Dr. Drew throw away all pretense of not at least pandering to antivaxxers—if not going antivax himself—after having been seemingly semi-reasonable in years past only told me that I really did need to discuss how so many physicians who were once seemingly reasonable turned into outright COVID-19 minimizers, antimaskers, and antivaxxers in such a short period of time. (I had originally planned on reviewing the movie, but decided that a review could wait, as I’ve downloaded a copy for when the free access to it in effect now expires, thanks to a reader who managed to bypass the countermeasures designed to prevent download of the video file.) Rather, Dr. Drew had unwittingly given me an “in” to introduce my post.
Before I go on, it is important to emphasize that there is absolutely no doubt that, despite his self-righteous assertion that he is “fiercely pro-vaccine” (ironically enough, on The Dr. Oz Show), RFK Jr. is an antivax activist and has been since before 2005, when I first deconstructed an article published in both Rolling Stone and Salon.com (to the eternal shame of both publications). His article, “Deadly Immunity“, posited a conspiracy theory to “cover up” evidence that mercury in the thimerosal preservative used until around 20 years ago in some childhood vaccines had caused the “autism epidemic”. In other words, there is no arguing that RFK Jr. is not a diehard antivaccine activist or that he has built an empire fearmongering about vaccines. Having such a person on one’s show is evidence of either utter naïveté about “telling both sides” with a grifting conspiracy theorist, sympathy to antivax views, a willingness to promote antivax views to profit, or being an antivaxxer oneself. (Take your pick.) Interestingly, early in the pandemic in 2020, Dr. Drew minimized the pandemic but then apologized for it by year’s end when he caught COVID-19. Of course, it didn’t take him long to start backsliding, as by April 2021 he was railing against vaccine passports as assaults on freedom. Now, nearly two years later, he’s way worse than he ever was in promoting COVID-19 minimization and antivax views, as evidenced by his willingness to host an antivax conspiracy theorist like RFK Jr. on his show.
A week before RFK Jr. was on Dr. Drew’s show, guess who else was on his show?
Heart Scars & Kids With Myocarditis: Dr. Vinay Prasad @VPrasadMDMPH on mRNA & ACIP Vote, with Dr. Kelly Victory on @AskDrDrew https://t.co/tJV3smLwE7
— Dr. Drew (@drdrew) October 19, 2022
Yes, he had Dr. Vinay Prasad, the oncologist turned COVID-19 minimizer and antivaxxer parroting antivax tropes that were old when I started blogging, just repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines and children, and Dr. Kelly Victory, an ER doctor who by the first summer of the pandemic had become a veritable cornucopia of COVID-19 misinformation and only got worse from there. In August, Dr. Drew even had Alex Berenson on his show. You might remember that Berenson was once dubbed—and accurately so, at least at the time given that others have come to vie for the title—the “pandemic’s wrongest man“.
In fact, just take a look at the last several weeks of his Ask Dr. Drew podcast:
As you can see, Dr. Victory has been on the show multiple times since mid-September and seems to be a go-to guest, along with COVID-19 minimizers and antivaxxers like Harvey Risch, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, and, of course, RFK Jr. He promotes antivax conspiracy theories and lies, such as:
    • The awful study by anonymous scientists for the Florida Department of Health that Dr. Joseph Ladapo tried to represent as showing that the vaccines are more dangerous than the disease in men under 40;
    • The distortions around the old news that the Pfizer mRNA-based vaccine trial “never tested the ability of the vaccine to prevent transmission”, disinformation that I discussed in detail last week;
    • Misguided attacks against California law AB 2098 as some sort of horrific affront to free speech;
    • Anti-mask propaganda;
    • Fear mongering about the nanoparticles used in mRNA vaccines, a topic that once led me to dub lipid nanoparticles in mRNA vaccines the “new mercury to antivaxxers“;
    • Mass delusional psychosis, the discredited idea promoted by Dr. Robert Malone and Dr. Mark McDonald that the pandemic caused an epidemic of “delusion” that qualified as a “psychosis”.
Indeed, I can’t help but be amused by a September 8th episode of Ask Dr. Drew in which Dr. Drew asked the question, “Is Dr. Drew Anti-Vaccine?” Even though I haven’t listened to more than a few minutes of this particular episodes, judging from the topics and guests on his show over the last few months, I’m hard-pressed not to answer—and most emphatically—”yes” to this question. I mean, just look at his list of topics going back to August! By and large, his guests have been a veritable laundry list of COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers.
Before I move on to discussing why so many physicians seemingly turned into cranks after COVID-19, let me just mention that it isn’t my intention to pick on just Dr. Drew (although he richly deserves to be picked on and his audience is many times that of SBM anyway). He just happens to be unlucky enough to have been the physician social media influencer who happened to catch my attention the most recently. Here at SBM we’ve written about so very many others, including Dr. Zubin Damania (a.k.a. ZDoggMD), a physician and long-time social media influencer who went from being a skeptic I used to cite who made funny YouTube videos mocking antivaxxers, to a font of COVID-19 minimization and even antivax disinformation regarding COVID-19 vaccines and children himself; the aforementioned Dr. Vinay Prasad, an oncologist with a large Twitter following before the pandemic who had previously made reasonable criticisms of medical reversals and the oncology drug approval process but turned to COVID-19 misinformation fairly early in the pandemic, even once likening public health nonpharmaceutical interventions to incipient fascism; and so many more who can be found on Substack, which has become the new wretched hive of scum and quackery for COVID-19. Then there are some who are not so much social media influencers but have become the go-to physicians for Fox News and other outlets promoting COVID-19 disinformation, such as Dr. Marty Makary, a surgical oncologist who most recently appeared on Tucker Carlson’s show to attack the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) when it was considering adding COVID-19 vaccines to the childhood immunization schedule, and Dr. John Ioannidis, arguably the most highly published living scientist and a former hero of mine who has been reduced to promoting awful “science” that deceptively used a satirical publication index to attack critics of Great Barrington Declaration-style “let ‘er rip” pandemic policies intended to reach “natural herd immunity”.
The list goes on and on; I won’t belabor it here, although I might mention more later and ask again why so many of my colleagues are still shocked that there are so many antivax and crank physicians out there. Spoiler alert: They were always there.
Reasons why physicians and scientists become “contrarians”
Rereading my 2009 post on this topic, I believe that its conclusions are still largely accurate, just incomplete now. As mixed as my feelings about evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins are these days, nonetheless I still think that that a good way to start this part of the discussion is with a probably apocryphal story that he liked to tell. (The first time I heard it was watching his BBC documentary series The Root of All Evil?.) It was about an elderly and esteemed scientist who had supported certain scientific hypothesis for many years. One day a visiting professor from America came to give a talk at Oxford University, in which he presented evidence that conclusively refuted this professor’s favorite hypothesis. As the lecture concluded, all eyes were on the esteemed senior scientist whose favorite hypothesis had just been roundly falsified. According to Dawkins, the old professor strode to the podium, shook the speaker’s hand, thanked him profusely, and said, “I have been wrong these fifteen years” In response, the audience applauded uproariously. Whether this story is apocryphal or not or whether it’s grown with Dawkins’ retelling it over time, I don’t know. It is nonetheless the ideal towards which science strives.
I bring this story up for two reasons. First, it is indeed true that the goal of science is for a scientist to be able to let go of even a most cherished hypothesis if the evidence refutes it, something that human nature leads us to find very, very difficult to do. Indeed, most scientists would probably not have reacted quite the same way that this respected senior scientist did; instead, most probably would have argued with the visiting professor or tried to shoot down his competing hypothesis. Second and more importantly, the vast majority of physicians are not, in fact, scientists. It is not a criticism or insult to state this. Medicine is a different discipline, and clinical medicine requires a different, albeit overlapping, skillset. Medicine is, as I like to say, applied science, and a good clinician does not have to be a research scientist to be competent treating patients.
In my original post, I listed several human traits that can lead a scientist or physician astray. This time around, I’m going to stick mainly with physicians and try to synthesize my old post with what I see now, after nearly three years of pandemic and 13 years overall. I admit that this is all anecdotal and based on personal experience, but I suspect that my ideas could provide hypotheses to test in scientific studies. That shortcoming in my speculation aside, the three main characteristics, stated more succinctly and slightly differently, that I listed back then as key to understanding cranks were:
    • A pre-existing belief in alternative medicine. This one is fairly self-explanatory, as alternative medicine goes together with antivax pseudoscience, quackery, and conspiracy theories like pizza and beer. Years before the pandemic, I wrote about how a culture of acceptance of alternative medicine in the form of “integrative medicine” could lead to a physician becoming antivaccine. While it’s not surprising that physicians who were antivax before the pandemic only doubled down on their antivax views applied to COVID-19 vaccines, it also shouldn’t be surprising that physicians who before the pandemic had promoted dubious ideas about, for example, diet as a panacea for virtually every health problem turned to antivax conspiracy theories. (Yes, I’m talking about Dr. Asseem Malhotra, but not just him.) In context, it’s not at all surprising that physicians who had just dabbled with antivax ideas or pandered to antivaxxers did a full heel turn after COVID-19 vaccines were released.
    • Arrogance that the physician knows better than his medical profession and specialty, which I called the sine qua non of “contrarians” and “brave mavericks”. Among medical cranks in particular, this arrogance manifests itself in the failure to acknowledge just how easily all humans, including them, can confuse correlation with causation, engage in selective memory such as confirmation bias, and are fooled by anecdotes, personal experience, and regression to the mean. I can understand how this can happen. Even among people steeped in the scientific method, it is sometimes hard not to fall prey to these shortcomings in human cognition. It is this tendency that will lead them to liken themselves to Galileo, persecuted scientists who will someday be vindicated. We frequently call this the “arrogance of ignorance“, in which a physician does not realize how much he doesn’t know. Before the pandemic, I would note that this arrogance could lead physicians to dismiss as “sheeple” the physicians who practice science- and evidence-based medicine as lacking the vision that they have, all the while making excuses for not doing rigorous clinical studies that would confirm or disprove the efficacy of their remedies over and above a placebo. Since the pandemic, the same trait appears operative, just applied to disproven cures for COVID-19 like ivermectin, and disbelief that masks and non-pharmaceutical interventions do any good against COVID-19.
    • Ideology. Although back in the day I used to routinely discuss how there was a stereotype that antivaxxers were hippy dippy granola crunching “liberals” and “progressives”, specifically how that stereotype was misleading because there has always been a strong right-wing contingent among antivaxxers, these days it is undeniable that the most common ideological basis behind COVID-19 misinformation and antivax views has become overwhelmingly right wing, in fact far right wing, with antivax misinformation routinely amplified by the likes of Tucker Carlson and even conservative governors like Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis. Although physicians, as a whole profession, tend to lean slightly Democratic, certain specialties lean heavily conservative/Republican, such as anesthesiology, surgery, ENT, and ophthalmology. (Interestingly, infectious disease doctors were the most liberal of all specialties, with only 23% registered as Republican.) In any event, given how much the antivaccine movement has been captured by the right based on a shared affinity towards resisting “mandates” it should not be surprising that a number of physicians with a pre-existing conservative/libertarian bent would be more likely break bad with respect to the pandemic. (John Ioannidis and Jay Bhattacharya appear to be excellent examples of this phenomenon, along with the physicians who affiliated themselves with the Brownstone Institute.)
    • Ego gratification (particularly from patients) that comes with being a “brave maverick doctor” practicing medicine outside the mainstream. This derives from two things. First, it feels really, really good to successfully help a patient get better. Every physician who treats patients has felt this, and it’s a key reason why young people decide to study to become physicians in the first place – they want to help people. If a physician comes to believe that he’s discovered a treatment that helps patients whom mainstream medicine cannot, that feels even better. (Notable examples from this blog include long-time cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski, who really thinks he can cure incurable brain cancers and whose patients share that belief, and any number of “autism biomed” quacks who think that they can cure autism.) Also, never underestimate the ego gratification that can come from believing oneself to be superior to one’s colleagues, someone who has special insight that their colleagues don’t. Prepandemic, this ego gratification often led physicians to dismiss as “sheeple” their colleagues who practiced science- and evidence-based medicine as lacking the vision that they had, all the while making excuses for not doing rigorous clinical studies that would confirm or disprove the efficacy of their remedies over and above a placebo or their hypotheses that, for example, vaccines or genetically modified organisms (GMOs) caused autism. It is no coincidence that there exists a political conspiracy group disguised as a professional society, the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), that is basically dedicated to the idea that there exist “maverick doctors” who are not sheep and move ahead of the flock. These mavericks, not coincidentally, include anyone who joins the AAPS, many of whose physicians view evidence-based guidelines as unacceptable constraints on what should be their godlike power to decide upon how to treat patients as they see fit. Also not coincidentally, the AAPS has become a major promoter of COVID-19 misinformation, although it has always been antivax.
As I discussed before, it shouldn’t surprise anyone that there are a disturbingly large number of antivax physicians who are behaving badly over COVID-19 out there, to the point where everything antivax is old again. These physicians were always with us, as anyone in medicine knows; COVID-19 just gave them the excuse to unmask themselves.
But what about audience capture?
“Audience capture” or just “capture”?
I’ll finish up by elaborating on what Dr. Howard wrote about on Friday. Specifically, this passage echoed my own experience years before Dr. Howard (mainly because I’m a lot older than he is and thus discovered the antivaccine movement before he did):
Over the ensuing decade, I observed something interesting about the anti-vaccine movement. When I first encountered it, anti-vaccine influencers could gain attention by claiming vaccines caused autism. That was once cool and edgy. After a few years, however, this bogus claim was merely the price of entry into Anti-Vaxx World. Since there was nothing to be gained by merely saying vaccines caused autism, in order to gain attention, anti-vaccine influencers like Dr. Brogan were forced to blame vaccines for all manners of maladies, such as the “epidemic” of SIDS (even though SIDS rates have decreased markedly). Other anti-vaccine doctors compared vaccines to rape, and RFK Jr. compared vaccinations to the Holocaust. Attacking pediatricians became commonplace.
He’s right, too…mostly. In actuality, antivaxxers blamed vaccines for all those things long ago; it’s just that blaming vaccines for SIDS, for example, and comparing vaccines to rape or calling for doctors to be tried and hanged, guillotined, or otherwise executed for their role in promoting vaccination programs (now falling under the rubric of “Nuremberg 2.0“) were considered fringe even among antivaxxers. What Dr. Howard gets right is the increasing radicalization of the antivax movement, to the point where what was once considered fringe—embarrassing even to antivaxxers who considered themselves more “reasonable”—is now mainstream, to the point where a popular pundit like Tucker Carlson even approvingly featured RFK Jr. in his Fox News special about how society, GMOs, vaccines, and other things he doesn’t like are going to result in the “end of men”, who apparently need “bromeopathy” and testicular tanning to restore their testosterone levels. But why? I think Dr. Howard was on to something when he wrote about “audience capture”:
I think [audience capture] perfectly describes what I’ve observed before the pandemic with anti-vaxxers like Dr. Brogan and during the pandemic with contrarian doctors, several of whom I once admired as defenders of evidence-based medicine. However, they’ve since become trapped by their followers. After 2.5 years of minimizing COVID and discouraging pediatric vaccination, they’ve cornered themselves into positions they knew to be quackery prior to the pandemic. Echoing Dr. Brogan and anti-vaccine tropes about measles and HPV, they write pro-virus articles titled “The Triumph of Natural Immunity” and argue that it’s “natural and healthy” when children get sick with COVID.
I agree, but with one difference. I define the “audience” that has captured once-reasonable physicians (or at least seemingly reasonable physicians) more broadly than just their social media presence. Think of it this way. Twitter was only founded in 2006 and didn’t really take off for a few years. Facebook hadn’t yet come to dominate social media discourse in 2009. Before I wrote my post, blogs and discussion forums were about it, but audience capture still arguably happened. Although this example does not include physicians, think of it this way. I once wrote about how parents with doubts about vaccines would become radicalized and turn into antivaxxers subjecting their children to all sorts of quacky “autism biomed” to “recover” their autistic children after becoming active in antivax online discussion forums. Doctors are not immune to these sorts of social pressures.
That’s why I define the “audience” of physician influencers as including potentially not just their social media followers, but their patients (if they have any, that is—Drs. Ioannidis and Bhattacharya, for example, do not practice clinical medicine, and Dr. Vinay Prasad appears to have a minimal clinical practice and mostly does research) and followers of any sort. For example, although Dr. Marty Makary does have nearly 190K followers on Twitter, he appears not to have a podcast or a Substack (although he frequently appears on other people’s podcasts). His main fame appears to come from his regular appearances on Fox News and other conservative traditional media outlets to cast doubt on public health interventions and vaccines for COVID-19. Another example is Dr. John Ioannidis, who brags about having no social media presence (although he does appear very aware of social media discussions about him), but who is frequently quoted by the media about the pandemic and now has a hagiographic YouTube “documentary” Out To See that portrays him as the classic “brave maverick doctor” who saw everything that his colleagues did not, accused them of currying political favor (in a classic case of projection), and was unjustly “persecuted” for it.
As I pointed out on Twitter about the faux profundity in the movie, which, I suppose, I’ll have to watch at some point (I’ve only watched part of it so far), as much as it is likely to nauseate me:
Geez. He sounds like a low rent version of Deep Thoughts by Jack Handey. https://t.co/oh70C8HrcM
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) October 21, 2022
Ioannidis also voices classic eugenicist thinking that has long undergirded antivax sentiment:
The professor predicts that if we survive as a species, the virus (sc2) will probably kill billions of us. Just the kind of belief in research and progress I expect from a scientist in medicine, lol. pic.twitter.com/0GmKwyhjec
— Hypoautonomic (@hypoautonomic) October 21, 2022
And, my favorite:
"too much public health is not a good thing"
new science theory dropping pic.twitter.com/0HwRh91Q6c
— Hypoautonomic (@hypoautonomic) October 21, 2022
As I said, some of these quotes from Ioannidis sound like bad facsimiles of Jack Handey’s “Deep Thoughts” applied to medicine.
Why does audience capture do this? I refer to the same article by Gurwinder Bhogal that Dr. Howard did, “The Perils of Audience Capture“, which starts with the example of an influencer named Nicholas Perry, who discovered that “uploading mukbang videos of himself consuming various dishes while talking to the camera, as if having dinner with a friend” got him a lot of attention that his previous videos did not, noting:
These new videos quickly found a sizable audience, but as the audience grew, so did their demands. The comments sections of the videos soon became filled with people challenging Perry to eat as much as he physically could. Eager to please, he began to set himself torturous eating challenges, each bigger than the last. His audience applauded, but always demanded more. Soon, he was filming himself eating entire menus of fast food restaurants in one sitting.
In some respects, all his eating paid off; Nikocado Avocado, as Perry is now better known, has amassed over six million subscribers across six channels on YouTube. By satisfying the escalating demands of his audience, he got his wish of blowing up and being big online. But the cost was that he blew up and became big in ways he hadn’t anticipated.
Basically, Perry, who had been thin and health-conscious before, became morbidly obese and also:
Where Perry was mild-mannered and health conscious, Nikocado is loud, abrasive, and spectacularly grotesque. Where Perry was a picky eater, Nikocado devoured everything he could, including finally Perry himself. The rampant appetite for attention caused the person to be subsumed by the persona.
I’ve often said that antivax and crank beliefs are often about grift, but it is usually the ideology that comes first. While it would be easy to attribute audience capture to grift and the desire to make more money (and certainly greed and grift often play a role), as Bhogal explains, it’s actually more complicated than just financial incentives to be ever more outrageous and radical:
Audience capture is an irresistible force in the world of influencing, because it’s not just a conscious process but also an unconscious one. While it may ostensibly appear to be a simple case of influencers making a business decision to create more of the content they believe audiences want, and then being incentivized by engagement numbers to remain in this niche forever, it’s actually deeper than that. It involves the gradual and unwitting replacement of a person’s identity with one custom-made for the audience.
To understand how, we must consider how people come to define themselves. A person’s identity is being constantly refined, so it needs constant feedback. That feedback typically comes from other people, not so much by what they say they see as by what we think they see. We develop our personalities by imagining ourselves through others’ eyes, using their borrowed gazes like mirrors to dress ourselves.
He further notes that such a process was not necessarily a bad thing when humans were living in small communities where most people knew each other, as it helped social cohesion. However, that’s not the case anymore. A social media influencer can interact with people all over the world, nearly none of whom he’s met in person, and they can exercise this influence online.
I would argue that this same process also applied to physicians before the rise of social media who discovered that advocating certain quackery or antivax ideas gained them not just more patients, but more approval—adulation, even—from those patients. Just look at Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski’s adoring patients, whom he wielded as weapons against the Texas Medical Board and the FDA whenever any regulatory or law enforcement bodies tried to hold him accountable for his quackery and tell me that such adulation doesn’t have an effect. Indeed, there’s a reason why I’ve invoked Burzynski’s story as an example of how difficult it has always been to halt medical misinformation.
Again, the vast majority of physicians go into medicine because they want to help people, and helping people through diseases and medical conditions can feel really, really good and be deeply rewarding. This is particularly problematic because there is a culture among physicians in which we tend to view ourselves as above such seemingly petty influences as ego gratification or audience capture. This phenomenon can be seen in other contexts, such as in the way that physicians frequently proclaim that gifts from pharmaceutical representatives have no effect whatsoever on their clinical behavior or judgment, when science overwhelmingly shows that gifts, even small ones, can have a profound influence on behavior. Again, many of my colleagues consider themselves above such considerations. This is the same sort of arrogance that can potentially blind colleagues who develop large social (or even traditional) media followings to this possibility:
When influencers are analyzing audience feedback, they often find that their more outlandish behavior receives the most attention and approval, which leads them to recalibrate their personalities according to far more extreme social cues than those they’d receive in real life. In doing this they exaggerate the more idiosyncratic facets of their personalities, becoming crude caricatures of themselves.
The caricature quickly becomes the influencer’s distinct brand, and all subsequent attempts by the influencer to remain on-brand and fulfill audience expectations require them to act like the caricature. As the caricature becomes more familiar than the person, both to the audience and to the influencer, it comes to be regarded by both as the only honest expression of the influencer, so that any deviation from it soon looks and feels inauthentic. At that point the persona has eclipsed the person, and the audience has captured the influencer.
Or, as Dr. Howard described the dynamic between social media influencer physicians who go “contrarian” and their audience:
Their fans often lavish them with praise, telling them they are “fearless” for challenging the orthodoxy. And you can see how some doctors get cornered by their followers and are forced to adopt more extreme positions. The cardinal rule is to never stop being “heterodox”, no matter what. This is how doctors end up praising viruses.
Physicians who are science-based can be prone to such attractions, but in their case it becomes an internal battle over which aspect of their personality and/or “brand” predominates, their dedication to science- and evidence-based medical care or their desire, conscious or unconscious, to satisfy their audience. In any event, I rather suspect that this sort of dynamic is a major part of how so many social media influencers like ZDoggMD, Dr. Drew (who has been both a traditional media influencer and social media influencer over the years), Dr. Prasad, Dr. Bhattacharya, and the like started out just somewhat contrarian with respect to the pandemic and are now parroting antivax talking points retooled for COVID-19 vaccines, whether they realize these talking points are old antivax talking points or not. Everything old is new again, indeed, and “new school” COVID-19 contrarian “antivaxxers” are, more and more, coming to resemble “old school” antivaxxers. I also suspect that physicians who were already social media influencers before the pandemic hit, like ZDoggMD, Dr. Drew, and Dr. Prasad, were more prone to audience capture resulting in their turning into COVID-19 contrarians than those who were not. Moreover, no matter how much attention being a contrarian brings a physician, there is nothing particularly admirable in just being a contrarian.
As I put it in 2009:
The other point that is worth emphasizing is that being a contrarian is not in and of itself particularly impressive because scientists are so often wrong. There are far more hypotheses that are falsified than hypotheses that stand up to experimental and observational scrutiny. Indeed, I find “contrarian” scientists who won’t support their doubts of the established consensus with good science (and sometimes not even good logical arguments) of their own to be particularly annoying, like a two-year old who says “No!” to everything. Being “contrarian” is only productive if the contrarian scientist can produce actual evidence using sound experimental and observational methodology suggesting that the consensus is seriously wrong. That’s one reason why “intelligent design” creationists (or, as I’ve increasingly started calling them, evolution denialists) are not taken seriously and should not be taken seriously. They point out what they see as “shortcomings” in evolutionary theory, some valid but most based on gross misunderstandings of what evolutionary biology actually says, and do no research. Indeed, they don’t even try to do any research that might suggest alternatives. The same is true of cranks of all stripes, including “alt-med” cranks, HIV/AIDS denialists, and many other varieties.
Being a contrarian, in other words, is not in and of itself desirable. It’s one thing to be a contrarian who finds faults with existing science based on evidence (and not the cherry picked misinterpretations of evidence most commonly used by the COVID-19 contrarians that we routinely write about here); it’s quite another to be a contrarian for the sake of being a contrarian. Unfortunately, I suspect that it’s not difficult for the latter to lapse into being the former. That could well describe why physicians like Dr. Ioannidis and Prasad so easily lapsed into COVID-19 contrarianism. Before the pandemic hit, their entire “brands” had been based on criticism of the evidence base for various medical interventions and the quality of clinical trials used to justify those interventions. Naturally, the appearance of a novel virus, where the science evolved rapidly and was initially often confusing or even misleading, provided many big fat, juicy targets for their previous skills. That was the “in”. Unfortunately, arrogance and audience capture appear to have done the rest, along with methodolatry, also known as the obscene worship of the randomized clinical trial as the only valid method of clinical investigation. Now these once-respected doctors are pathetic shells of their former selves, scientifically speaking. One can ask whether they’ve changed or if they were always like this. To that, my speculative answer is yes. I suspect that they were always “like this,” but not nearly as much as they have become. In other words, yes, they’ve changed, but that change was an amplification of existing traits, not a change in character.
Avoiding audience capture and the temptation to become a “contrarian” for the sake of being a “contrarian”
Bhogal asks himself the question that all influencers should, namely whether they have been captured by their audience, and I found an echo of my thinking in this passage:
I’m no authority on the degree to which my mind has been captured by you, my audience. But I do suspect that audience capture affects me far less than most influencers because I’ve taken specific steps to avoid it. I was aware of the pitfall long before I became an influencer. I wanted an audience, but I also knew that having the wrong audience would be worse than having no audience, because they’d constrain me with their expectations, forcing me to focus on one tiny niche of my worldview at the expense of everything else, until I became a parody of myself.
It was clear to me that the only way to resist becoming what other people wanted me to be was to have a strong sense of who I wanted to be. And who I wanted to be was someone immune to audience capture, someone who thinks his own thoughts, decides his own destiny, and above all, never stops growing.
And:
In this way I ensured that my brand image—the person that my audience expects me to be—was in alignment with my ideal image—the person I want to be. So even though audience capture likely does affect me in some way, it only makes me more like the person I want to be. I hacked the system.
My brand image is, admittedly, diffuse and weak.
Me too—I think. To be honest, I’m not even sure that I have a true “brand image.” If I do, it’s not something I’ve consciously cultivated, although no doubt I must have cultivated something like it over the last couple of decades. On the other hand, I did feel something akin to audience capture early in my blogging career, before I joined SBM. I had started out with a brand based on a pseudonym named after an all-knowing computer from an obscure (in the US, anyway) British science fiction show. This computer was characterized by extreme cantankerousness and impatience with humans, which led many of my early posts to be particularly sarcastic and sometimes even nasty. My readers seemed to like that and want more, but, oddly enough, over time I actually mellowed. I can still be quite sarcastic, to be sure, but just compare posts on my personal blog c.2005-2007 to what I write now.
Also oddly enough, too much praise actually makes me very leery and sometimes even acutely uncomfortable; when I encounter it, it’s just as likely to make me question myself and what I’ve written as it is to reinforce my beliefs. Those who’ve met me in person at various skeptical conferences have likely noticed that too much attention and praise actually make me noticeably uncomfortable, particularly when that attention is a lot of praise. (People have commented on it.) I sometimes think that, were I to receive a lot of feedback telling me how “fearless” I am for voicing heterodox opinions, it might actually lead me to seriously question my views and writings.
Another key strategy to avoid audience capture is an openness to considering legitimate criticism. I don’t claim to be perfect on that score, but I do try. One example that comes to mind is from last year, for which I must make a mea culpa. Before the kerfuffle over the positive review of Abigail Shrier’s Irreversible Damage, SBM had been oblivious to the pseudoscience and conspiracy theories regarding gender dysphoria, transgender adolescents, and gender-affirming care. Since then, we have tried to remedy that longstanding oversight with science- and evidence-based discussion and analysis.
Maybe these are the keys to how I’ve (mostly, I think) avoided audience capture. I seem never to have cared nearly as much about growing my personal audience as many influencers do, and there hasn’t been anything resembling a financial motivation for me to garner more traffic in a long time. I also obsessively question my beliefs and actions presented to the public, possibly even more than is healthy. It’s been enough for almost two decades, but I never assume that it will be enough for two more; that is, if I even continue doing this for two more given how old I will be then.
Mr. Bhogal was quite correct when he pointed out that it is worse to have the wrong audience than to have no audience. During the pandemic too many physician social media influencers attracted the wrong audience, and it has corrupted and radicalized them.

Medical “Conservatives” Are Medical Radicals
Any doctor who pushes for the repeated mass infection of unvaccinated babies and toddlers with a novel, mutating virus, when an effective vaccine is available, is a medical radical.
Jonathan Howard on March 24, 2023
Link

“The Case for Being a Medical Conservative”
In previous essays, I discussed so-called medical “conservatives”, and alluded to why their unrelenting efforts to ensure unvaccinated, young people were repeatedly were exposed to SARS-CoV-2 were actually quite radical. Let’s review the philosophy behind medical conservatism and explore why several of its champions rejected their own teachings during the pandemic.
In 2019, Drs. John Mandrola, Adam Cifu, Vinay Prasad, and Andrew Foy wrote an article titled The Case for Being a Medical Conservative. They wrote that the “choice of the term ‘medical conservative’ does not imply a political philosophy.”  Instead, they recognized “that many developments promoted as medical advances offer, at best, marginal benefits”.  The crux of their article was that:
The medical conservative adopts new therapies when the benefit is clear and the evidence strong and unbiased.
Though reasonable people can have different ideas about what constitutes “strong and unbiased” evidence, broadly speaking, this strikes me as a reasonable philosophy. Medicine is full of tests and treatments that were widely adopted because they “made sense”, only to be abandoned when rigorous studies showed their risk exceeded their benefit. Many of these treatments were overly-hyped by “key opinion leaders” with ties to industry, and medical “conservatives” were right to warn us about such conflicts of interest. “Motivating biases need not be considered nefarious, only considered”, they wrote.
Of course, medical “conservatives” don’t have a monopoly on discussing overhyped tests and treatments. Such failures all been discussed here at SBM for years, and I discussed many examples in my non-bestselling book on cognitive bias in medicine. When COVID arrived, I took a medically conservative approach the virus. In my first ever article on COVID I wrote about my experience during New York’s 2020 COVID bomb and said:
I also made sure that no patient on my team received any experimental treatments (such as hydroxychloroquine). Doing “nothing” is often very difficult for doctors, but is preferable to giving out unproven treatments unless patients are clearly dying or in a clinical trial.
Medical “conservatives” weren’t the only doctors who wanted solid, unbiased evidence before unleashing a new treatment on large numbers of people. However, time is not an unlimited luxury in the middle of a raging pandemic, and different threats call for different approaches. The standards of evidence used to judge the value of a new knee procedure should not be applied to measures used to combat a rapidly-spreading, rapidly-mutating virus that would kill millions if left unchecked. Waiting for perfect evidence before acting may satisfying a doctor’s psychological need to feel blameless if harms result.  However, doing “nothing” as a virus rips through the population is doing something. As hospitals full of sick children showed, the consequences of excess “caution” can be severe.
Additionally, medical “conservatives” are not the only doctors who recognize the value of randomized-controlled trials (RCTs). I previously wrote “they are the gold-standard for their ability to randomize patients and minimize bias.” I showed my dedication to this belief not by writing essays demanding that other doctors do more RCTs, but rather by participating in a vaccine-RCT myself, bypassing my chance to get mRNA vaccines in December 2020.
Drs. Mandrola, Cifu, Prasad, Andrew Foy ended their article thusly:
The wisest of conservative physicians understand and embrace how little effect the clinician has on outcomes. While many may call this frame of reference nihilistic, the conservative clinician sees it as protective against our greatest foe—hubris.
Given this admonition against hubris, it is striking that with regards to SARS-CoV-2, many medical “conservatives” abandoned their caution, arrogantly treating a brand new virus as if it were a exaggerated, predictable entity.  Their haughty approach led them to repeatedly declare the worst of the pandemic over, to relentlessly mock those who tried to avoid the virus, and to minimize COVID’s worst harms, including dead children and young adults.
The Case for Being a Medical Conservative, Except For a Brand New Virus:
Part 1: “It’s May not March.“
As early as March 5, 2020, Dr. Mandrola praised the “strikingly calm words on #COVID19″ of a politician who warned “Fear can do more harm than the virus itself.”  Hundreds of thousands of Americans who chose not to “live in fear” are no longer here to expound on the wisdom of their decision. Even after the virus devastated New York City and multiple other cities here and abroad, Dr. Mandrola remained extremely confident that the rest of the country would be spared our sad fate. Though the virus had existed for just a few months, he was certain he could accurately predict its behavior. He said that those who disagreed with him, even before anyone had been vaccinated, were “fear-mongering” to “gain followers” on Twitter. Like other medical “conservatives,” he shamed and scolded anyone who actually took a conservative approach to the virus. Here are some of his preposterous predictions, with COVID’s cumulative death toll on that date.
    • May 1, 2020 – 68,515 deaths: I recoil against the idea that moderation of distancing measures in places in the US and Sweden is akin to human sacrifice. That sort of hyperbole and fear-mongering in medicine always leads to bad decisions. Also, no US hospital is now unprepared. It’s May, not March 9.
    • May 4, 2020 – 72,831 deaths: 1) US Hospitals not close to being over-run. It’s the opposite in most places 2) Everyplace I know of is opening up for more regular healthcare. Good. 3) We have learned how to limit nosocomial spread. It’s May not March.
    • May 5, 2020 – 75,010 deaths: US hospitals are now prepared and in little danger of being over-whelmed. In fact, many hospitals are so dormant they are nearing financial ruin.
    • May 7, 2020 – 79,237 deaths: May is different from March. People are not stupid. Public health surveillance is better. Hospitals are ready. NYC-like situations are unlikely now in the US.
November 1, 2020 – 231,003 deaths
    • December 15, 2020 – 307,343 deaths: Barring something (very) unforeseen the #covid19 pandemic is over soon. Such good news!
January 27, 2021 – 434,380 deaths
February 13, 2021 – 483,543 deaths
February 14, 2021 – 484,694 deaths
    • March 10, 2021 – 527,345 deaths: The more that people ride bikes, the more hip fractures and cranial bleeds we will see. The pandemic is essentially done. Human life has to be more than avoiding one pathogen. With respect…sir, please, stop.
    • March 10, 2021 – 527,345 deaths: Ky has vaccinated about 1 in 3 older people. CT has done even better. The vaccine squelches severe cases Millions have natural immunity. Young have almost no risk. The pandemic (of bad disease) is nearly over. And this is a really worthy cause of celebration!!!!!!
    • March 11, 2021 – 528,887 deaths: I wish I had wrote “almost done here in the US.” Frustration with fear-mongering got the best of me.
    • June 11, 2021 – 595,482 deaths: It appears to me that we have crushed COVID by simply vaccinating susceptible adults. Why not wait for more data before extending these novel therapies to young people?
    • July 29, 2021 – 608,526 deaths: If you were vaccinated and had mild to moderate URI symptoms, why on earth would you get a COVID test? Have the vaccines not transformed SARSCOV2 into just another regular respiratory virus?
July 29, 2021 – 608,526 deaths
    • July 27, 2022 – 1,029,290 deaths: We now have a diff disease: many if not most COVID+ pts we consult on have + test but an adm Dx (admitting diagnosis) for something else The pneumonias of 2020-2021 are thankfully rare.
Over a million Americans have died of COVID since Dr. Mandrola falsely reassured us that “US Hospitals not close to being over-run.” To his credit, he has acknowledged some of his poor prognostications. In an article from December 2020 he evaluated his earlier predictions and said:
Assertion 6: Non-pharmaceutical interventions, such as social distancing and masks, would not lower the infection fatality rate. Verdict: Wrong.
Early on I saw little advantage to delaying infection. I wrote: “the only way fewer people die from COVID19 over time is if the IFR declines.” I then went on to describe the slowness of medical progress.
There have been two major medical developments that (now) argue strongly for delaying infection–especially earlier this year.
First is that clinicians better understand how to care for patients with COVID19 pneumonia…Second is the huge surprise of vaccine development. I wrote that “COVID19 vaccine development is sobering.” That was dead wrong.
That’s not a trivial thing for a doctor with a large audience to have been “dead wrong” about, especially considering he both failed to learn from his mistake and he frequently bemoans the lack of trust in medicine. I’m glad I don’t have to wonder if my farcical forecasts led a vulnerable person to abandon COVID precautions only a few months before vaccines were available.
That last two sentences are true
The Case for Being a Medical Conservative, Except For a Brand New Virus:
Part 2: “I want to write a children’s book about a bear who didn’t want to leave home till it was perfectly safe.
In addition to mocking those who doubted the end of the pandemic two years ago, medical “conservatives: similarly belittled strangers who they felt tried too hard to avoid the virus. During the winter wave of 2021, at the literal peak of death for the entire pandemic, on a day when 3,523 Americans died, Dr. Prasad sarcastically tweeted:
I want to write a children’s book about a bear who didn’t want to leave home till it was perfectly safe. He never left and life passed him by. In the sequel, he stands at the window shouting at anyone outside that they are killing fellow bears and spreading disinformation.
Most Americans were unvaccinated at that time, and nearly 700,000 Americans have died since.
Dr. Prasad would later say that “Fear of long COVID is irrational. In so far as it exists, you have to accept it” and that:
It’s time for medical professionals to advise young, middle age, healthy people to throw away your n95, leave your C02 monitor at home and get back to life. These are not proportionate responses. You are not acting reasonably. Someone needs to tell you.
He expanded on this theme in an essay titled “When Scientists’ Anxiety Disorder Interferes With Other People’s Lives,” in which he said:
What word do we use to describe doctors, scientists and policy makers whose personal mental health issues affect their policy recommendations? The lives of others?..It is pathologic for anxiety to harm your own life, but I believe we enter the realm of catastrophe when personal mental health issues affect sweeping policy matters.
He went on to shame and pathologize “vocal policy analysts (doctors, scientists, professors) who’s comments might be concerning.”  As the pandemic progressed, Dr. Prasad continued to say that people who were trying too hard to avoid the virus were mentally unstable.  In November 2022 he wrote:
Some adults who have had multiple boosters wear masks to concerts. Why? You will get COVID anyway later. One in 4 won’t eat at a restaurant. I am deeply concerned these people need counseling.
He said such people were “demented” and “betray a deep ignorance about COVID19, and more generally show that they are incapable of judging risk.” Of course, masks are completely normal in countries like Japan and Singapore, which suffered a fraction of our COVID loss.
When RSV, flu, COVID overwhelmed pediatric hospitals, Dr. Prasad said parents who wanted to limit playdates were “cruel and stupid.” He implied that only people who were willing to repeatedly expose themselves to SARS-CoV-2 were properly living. He wrote:
Despite millions of news stories on COVID19, no one asked the obvious question. Respiratory viruses exist because human beings have to be close to each other. We are a social animal. We have to breathe each others air, and everything wonderful in life happens in proximity.
Medical “conservatives” urged strangers to expose themselves to SARS-CoV-2 and other viruses on a repeated basis and pathologized anyone who was unwilling to do so. Echoing pre-pandemic, anti-vaccine balderdash, Dr. Prasad even told parents it was “natural and healthy” for children to get sick with COVID and other vaccine-preventable viruses.
The Case for Being a Medical Conservative,  Except For a Brand New Virus:
Part 3: “No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus.”
It’s likely that medical conservatives were so nonchalant about the virus because they felt death from COVID was overrated, including the deaths of thousands children and young adults. After 19 children died of COVID in April 2021, Dr. Prasad argued unvaccinated children should remain vulnerable to COVID, reminding us that there are 330 million Americans who didn’t die this way. Imagine a doctor saying this if measles killed 19 kids in a single month. In a pro-virus article titled Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?, Dr. Prasad wrote what may be the coldest sentence I’ve read from a doctor this pandemic. He wrote:
And while the death of any child is a tragedy, Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course, including drowning, vehicle accidents, and even cardiovascular disease.
Similarly, in December 2020, after thousands of young people had already died of COVID and with vaccines on the way, Drs. Mandrola and Foy wrote a piece titled No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus which concluded:
The young have many reasons- ethical and moral–to adhere to social distancing during the pandemic. Fear of death is not one of them.
“An excess of 12,000 deaths sounds bad”, they wrote, but they felt it was just a “tiny absolute increase in risk”. Of course death is not the only bad outcome from COVID, a fact unacknowledged by Drs. Mandrola and Foy.
Dr. Mandrola also said at that time that other longstanding ills, which he reflexively attributed to measures to control the virus, would be worse than COVID’s death toll, writing:
The intense political divide, the growing intolerance of ideas, the racial unrest, all argue for a pessimistic case that the lives lost from the viral infection will NOT end up being the gravest harm from this contagion.
In reality, the lives lost were the gravest harm from this contagion. COVID is now the greatest mass death event in American history.
Medical “Conservatives” Are Medical Radicals
Let’s revisit the core philosophy of medical “conservatives”:
The medical conservative adopts new therapies when the benefit is clear and the evidence strong and unbiased…The wisest of conservative physicians understand and embrace how little effect the clinician has on outcomes. While many may call this frame of reference nihilistic, the conservative clinician sees it as protective against our greatest foe—hubris.
Fair enough. However, I’d also add the wisest of conservative physicians understood and embraced how little we knew about SARS-CoV-2 at the start of the pandemic. We still have a lot to learn about it, especially the consequences of repeat infections. We also don’t know what variants might be lurking on the horizon. As such, we should take a cautious, humble approach to SARS-CoV-2. We shouldn’t abandon important principles just because the virus is natural and the vaccine manmade. I believe we should repeatedly expose unvaccinated young people to the virus only “when the benefit is clear and the evidence strong and unbiased”. Currently, there is no evidence that multiple bouts of COVID are benign for developing children, especially unvaccinated ones.
Though medical “conservatives” openly trumpet their refusal to recognize unwanted realities, there is evidence COVID is really dangerous for some young people.Over 44,000 Americans ages 19-44 years have died of COVID, 6 times the number of soldiers who died fighting in wars since 9/11. Medical “conservatives” told them not to worry about this outcome. Additionally, COVID has killed around 2,000 children, and a medical “conservative” said we should accept more unvaccinated children dying “as a matter of course.”  Tens of thousands more children have been hospitalized with COVID, including many healthy children. Rarely, they have needed amputations or had strokes.  They survived, but their lives will never be the same. Medical “conservatives” ignored or minimized their suffering as well. Some children suffer from long-COVID, and we’ll be learning about its long-term sequelae for the rest of our lives. It wasn’t until 2019 that we learned measles suppresses the immune system.
A true medical conservative would be similarly humble about the potential for repeat COVID infections to have unseen consequences years from now.  It’s the height of arrogance to just assume everything will turn out fine and dandy. No matter how many times medical “conservatives” insist that the “young have almost no risk“, the virus has repeatedly shown it doesn’t read their Tweets or monetized Substack articles. “Motivating biases need not be considered nefarious, only considered”, they wrote.
From “How Anti-Vaxxers Monetize Misinformation” by Derek Beres
And thus it becomes clear:  there is nothing conservative about medical “conservatives”.
There’s nothing conservative about telling parents it’s “healthy and natural” for children to get sick with COVID. There’s nothing conversative about repeatedly declaring the pandemic over when the worst is yet to come. There’s nothing conservative about saying people are mentally ill if the want to avoid repeated exposures to SARS-CoV-2. There’s nothing conservative about mocking and shaming people who wanted a valuable booster just before a new variant rips through the population. There’s nothing conversative about repeatedly spreading fake statistics to minimize COVID’s impact on children or fear monger about the vaccine. There is nothing conservative about demanding other doctors conduct RCTs while refusing to any oneself. There is nothing conservative about rejecting real-world observational studies on vaccines, while authoring VAERS dumpster dives that purport they do more harm than good. There is nothing conversative about minimizing the deaths of young people from COVID. There is nothing conversative about treating a rare, “mild and self-limiting” vaccine side-effect as a fate worse than death.
Medical “conservatives” were right to call hubris our “greatest foe”. Their unbroken record of poor predictions and conceited COVID-minimization shows the wisdom of that statement. Any doctor who pushes for the repeated mass infection of unvaccinated babies and toddlers with a novel, mutating virus, when an effective vaccine is available, is a medical radical.

“New school” COVID-19 antivaxxers are becoming less and less distinguishable from “old school” antivaxxers
Since the COVID-19 pandemic hit, a new generation of antivaxxers has arisen. Most view themselves as pro-vaccine, just not pro-COVID-19 vaccines. Recent developments, however, have demonstrated that “new school” antivaxxers are increasingly indistinguishable from “old school” antivaxxers and that this fusion is increasingly endangering all public health, not just COVID-19 public health interventions.
David Gorski on June 6, 2022
Link

Since the pandemic hit, a new generation of antivaxxers has risen to prominence. These “new school” antivaxxers don’t view themselves as antivaccine, at least not in the classic sense. Indeed, many of them view themselves as provaccine, just not pro-COVID-19 vaccines. However, as I’ve discussed many times over the last two years, to demonize COVID-19 vaccines, they have recycled and repurposed every antivaccine trope under the sun. In the two weeks since I wrote my last post, a couple of stories have occurred that emphasized to me that these “new school” antivaxxers are increasingly indistinguishable from old school antivaxxers. In one case, a meetup of new school antivaxxers with an old school antivaxxer produced a rather…interesting…conflict. More generally, however, I am becoming increasingly concerned how radical anti-COVID-19 vaccine sentiment of the new school variety is fusing with more traditional old school antivaccinationism in order to endanger childhood vaccination in a manner we have not seen before. I have written about these two incidents recently at my not-so-secret other blog, but as I thought about what to write over the weekend, it occurred to me that it would be useful to look at these incidents and stories in the context of antivaccine misinformation. That means some of you might have read parts of this before, but such is life. Hopefully, by thinking about them this new way, I’ll be able to show you how the “new school” antivaxxers are rapidly becoming indistinguishable from the old school antivaxxers.
The first incident involves two-thirds of the Great Barrington Declaration authors, Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff, who were confronted by just how antivax the movement that they had associated themselves with truly was and said nothing. The second incident involves Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche being similarly confronted. He pushed back, but ineffectually. Both cases reveal just how much old school antivax beliefs are now entwining themselves with “new school” anti-COVID-19 vaccine beliefs and how formerly reputable (or at least not disreputable) scientists are now becoming more and associated with antivaxxers. The first example shows scientists playing footsie with antivaxxers and then trying to shrug it off. The second shows just how much new school antivaxxers are fusing with old school antivaxxers.

When Drs. Bhattacharya and Kulldorff met Steve Kirsch
Regular readers know that we at SBM are not exactly fans of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), the propaganda document released in October 2020 that advocated a “let ‘er rip” strategy for the pandemic with a strategy of “focused protection” to keep mass numbers of the vulnerable from dying. The idea was that, supposedly, COVID-19 posed so little danger to the young and healthy population without significant comorbidities that the “lockdowns” being implemented to slow its spread were, again supposedly, doing more harm than good. Basically, the GBD was the product of a libertarian free market “think tank”, the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), and three useful idiot scientists who were recruited to draft it, Jay Bhattacharya of Stanford University, Martin Kulldorff of Harvard University (but now the “scientific director” of an AIER spinoff known as the Brownstone Institute), and Sunetra Gupta of Oxford University. The whole thing was a rather obvious astroturf operation designed to get businesses open again, damn the human cost, and was, unfortunately, wildly successful in influencing government policies in the US and Europe. Since then, the spiritual child of the GBD, the Brownstone Institute, has become increasingly antivaccine, although the authors of the GBD assiduously reassure themselves that they are pro-vaccine, even as they promote antivaccine messages.
So it was three weeks ago that two-thirds of the GBD appeared at an event organized by tech bro turned antivaccine and COVID-19 conspiracy theorist Steve Kirsch:
Citation please! (In plain English.) pic.twitter.com/rXmfmswy4z
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) May 17, 2022
Helpfully, The Real Truther provided a link to Steve Kirsch and his antivax livestream:
If anyone wants to watch the panels (which also included Robert Malone because of course they did) here's the link:https://t.co/0z9ljYL6fH
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) May 17, 2022
Let’s just say that, by agreeing to appear with people promoting the most bonkers conspiracy theories about COVID-19, Kulldorff and Bhattacharya have forfeited any defense against being called “antivax”. Let’s take a look at some of the “highlights” and see why.
I was interested in the claim that COVID-19 vaccines. had killed over 500,000 people. Looking at the slide, I saw that Kirsch linked to what appear to be two of his Substack posts. One of them appears to be this post, titled “Survey shows over 500,000 killed by the COVID vaccines so far“. I laughed as I read the opening paragraphs:
A simple survey of my readers provided some extremely compelling evidence that 1) the US government has killed over 500,000 previously healthy Americans and 2) that the vaccine actually caused the deaths.
It took me around 30 minutes to create the survey and 11 hours to wait for highly statistically significant results.
I was able to accomplish something in less than 12 hours that the CDC has been unable to accomplish in 18 months: prove causality. We see both dose dependency and enormous changes in ACM deaths pre- vs. post-vaccine. We satisfy all five Bradford-Hill criteria applicable to vaccines.
Wow! If only it were so easy to determine adverse reactions up to and including death from vaccines (or any other medication or biological)! Damn! How is it that we stupid egghead scientists, epidemiologists, and clinical trialists didn’t think of something so simple and obvious! Why didn’t we just survey the readers of an antivax Substack?
Let’s take a look at the survey. It consisted of eight questions, basically if the reader knew anyone who had died after COVID-19 vaccination. From this survey, extrapolating from 400 responses, Kirsch estimated that COVID-19 vaccines had killed at least a half a million people and possibly as many as two million. The details of Kirsch’s “methodology” (such as it is) by which he carried out his incredibly innumerate extrapolation are here and here (where he claims that COVID-19 vaccines have killed more people than all other vaccines combined over the 30 year history of the VAERS database), and a deconstruction in detail can be found here. Since then, Kirsch has expanded his “methodology” to survey his readers for other COVID-19 adverse reactions, such as miscarriages, with equally innumerate results.
Kirsch is also proudly touting an upcoming interview with Andrew Wakefield, as well. Yet when people started criticizing Dr. Bhattacharya for having helped platform such horrendous antivax disinformation, his responses were…pretty weak sauce:
I do not. I support and have supported the use of the vaccine especially for focused protection of the elderly and other vulnerable people. I belive in engagement with prime of differing views and I lament the use of guilt by association attacks as a tactic in public health.
— Jay Bhattacharya (@DrJBhattacharya) May 17, 2022
My philosophy in chairing sessions is to let panelists talk. I've no idea what you are talking about re: 500k. I chimed in on the Pfizer trial.
If I spent my time correcting misinformation, I'd spend it correcting lockdowners who have caused the world's poor devastating damage.
— Jay Bhattacharya (@DrJBhattacharya) May 18, 2022
At the very least, allowing a platform for such blatant antivaccine propaganda was false balance, & poorly judged, however intentioned. Odious falsehoods do not help discussion, but do embolden cranks. Utility of vaccination is no more debatable than existence of Greenland
— Dr David Robert Grimes (@drg1985) May 18, 2022
And he even pretended that he didn’t know what Kirsch was actually saying:
I'll just leave this herehttps://t.co/H3gUKCOZHc
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) May 18, 2022
Notice that, even here, after the fact, Dr. Bhattacharya did not criticize Steve Kirsch or admit that Kirsch was spreading outrageous antivaccine misinformation, even though he had every opportunity. He could have said, “I was duped” or “I had no idea the sort of nonsense this conference was pushing” (even though he should have), but he did not. In this, we see one way that scientists who are not associated with the antivaccine movement react: With shame that leads them to try to deny that that’s what they’re doing.
Now let’s look at the second example.

The Better Way Conference
Like most of the “reasonable” (or so they think) antivaxxers who view themselves as scientific, many new school antivaxxers really, truly, honestly believe that they are not “antivaccine”. Back in the old days, antivaxxers would claim that they are “not antivaccine” but one or more of excuses such as “I’m pro-safe vaccine” or “I’m against mandates/for ‘freedom'”. New antivaxxers, while spewing the same old antivax tropes repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines (and not realizing that they are old), think of themselves as “not antivaccine” but just highly skeptical of the new COVID-19 vaccines. It turns out, though, that the longer these “new school” antivaxxers preach their pseudoscience and intermingle with long-time antivaxxers, the more they start sounding just like the old school antivaxxers they once dismissed. This principle was on display a couple of weeks ago at a panel held during an antivax conference held in Bath, England called the Better Way Conference.
This is as good a place as any to reiterate that, just as it was for “old school” antivaxxers, it is a delusion on the part of “new school” antivaxxers that they are “not antivaccine”, because they have been spewing the hoariest antivaccine tropes, just repurposed for and applied to COVID-19 vaccines, including false claims that these new vaccines:
    • Kill lots of people. This trope is based on the VAERS database and anecdotes, of course, just as the old trope was.
    • Don’t work. This trope is based on conspiracy theories and innumeracy.
    • Are loaded with “toxins” such as the spike protein and lipid nanoparticles.
    • Make women infertile and/or cause miscarriages.
    • Shed. The old version of this trope was that live attenuated vaccines shed virus, endangering those around them; the new version is that COVID-19 vaccines “shed” the spike protein used as the antigen in the mRNA- and adenovirus-based vaccines. Either way, the vaccinated are not “purebloods“.
    • Are unnecessary because the disease is harmless to all but the elderly and those with chronic diseases or is diagnosed with a bogus test that produces lots of false positives.
    • Are unnecessary or even harmful because “natural immunity” is superior to vaccine-induced immunity and the disease is (mostly) harmless, which is why we should just let the disease spread, the better to reach “natural herd immunity” faster.
    • Permanently alter your DNA. The old-school version said the same thing, although having Andrew Wakefield spew the new version was a nice touch.
    • Cause cancer. Anyone remember SV40 and polio vaccines?
    • Are immoral to use because “fetal cells” were used to produce them. (Sound familiar?)
    • And on and on and on and on…
I tried to access a free copy of the livestream of the Better Way Conference, but unfortunately, the grift is strong and the only option to watch it all would be to pay for it. Fortunately, antivaxxer Del Bigtree couldn’t help but include relevant clips in a segment of a recent episode of his video podcast The Highwire With Del Bigtree. These segments were most illuminating in that they show what happens when a new school antivaxxer is forced to confront how COVID-19 antivaxxers are becoming indistinguishable from old school antivaxxers, making them all just plain antivaxxers.
Here’s the segment:
Segment: Del Debates Geert, The Highwire, May 26, 2022.
When old school meets new school
I’m using the Better Way Conference, specifically the panel touted by Del Bigtree in which he “debates” Geert Vanden Bossche, because it demonstrates the tension between old school and new school antivaxxers that, increasingly, is being resolved by new school antivaxxers embracing old school antivax ideas about childhood vaccinations.
Let’s look at who’s on the panel. Besides Del Bigtree, who was the MC of the entire conference and moderator of this panel, there was Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines—not” Malone, Geert Vanden Bossche, Bret Weinstein, Tess Lawrie, Maajid Nawaaz, Jessica Rose (I think), and some other people whom I can’t identify, both on stage and by video conferencing. I note that Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. was also in attendance at the conference but apparently not on this panel. Truly, this was, as it has been described, the Davos of COVID conspiracy theorists.
Geert Vanden Bossche, you might recall, rose to prominence in the antivax world last year based on one idea about how COVID-19 vaccines are supposedly harmful. Specifically, he has claimed that it is very dangerous to undertake a mass vaccination program in the middle of a pandemic with a “leaky” vaccine like the COVID-19 vaccine; i.e., a vaccine that still allows some forward transmission of the virus. The reason, if you believe Vanden Bossche, is that such vaccines select for more deadly variants. In reality, this idea, while theoretically possible, is far less likely to produce more transmissible and deadly variants than just letting the virus spread far and wide in a huge population.
You might recall that I discussed why Vanden Bossche was wrong, specifically how letting the virus circulate widely was, from an evolutionary standpoint, a far more dangerous strategy to generate variants than trying to minimize transmission and how the percentage of the population that had been vaccinated where various variants had arisen wasn’t large enough to produce significant selective pressure on the virus anyway. I also noted that Vanden Bossche’s claim that mass vaccination would lead to selective pressures to create a supervirus was a very old antivax trope, one that Andrew Wakefield himself had published a mere few months before the first cases of COVID-19 were multiplying in Wuhan, China. Wakefield had even said that the MMR vaccine could lead to a “mass extinction“.
Interestingly, during his talk, Vanden Bossche stated that, while he thought that mRNA viruses were a selective force that was generating ever more transmissible variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus (and that could generate more deadly variants), he thought that live attenuated vaccines could potentially be very important for producing and maintaining herd immunity. This did not go over very well at all with Del Bigtree, who was the MC of the entire Better Way Conference and the moderator of this discussion panel. When the time came for the Q&A session after panelists’ talks, instead of simply asking the questions that were being beamed to his iPad from the audience, Bigtree decided to “go there”, as he put it.
What do I mean by “go there”? He went straight to old antivaccine talking points about the childhood vaccine schedule, including false claims that vaccines cause autism and that the current generation of children is the “sickest generation” (a favorite of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.) due mainly to the expansion of the vaccine schedule in the 1990s. He did it even though he knew he would be blindsiding panelists who had been “dancing around” the topic of the childhood vaccine schedule. In this, I think that Bigtree inadvertently did everyone a service, because his “debate” with Vanden Bossche is an excellent tool for me to show unequivocally that most “new school” COVID-19 vaccine “skeptics” are now no different than old school antivaxxers. They are, in fact, antivaccine. Vanden Bossche might be a holdout, but he’s definitely moving in that direction.
Bigtree started by asking the panel how many thought that vaccination has a place combatting the pandemic “in a ‘better way’ moving forward”. Only half of the panel raised their hands, Malone, Vanden Bossche, and Weinstein, all rather shyly. Next, Bigtree asked:
How many of you are aware that, since the increase of vaccinations, when we were giving ten vaccinations—I’ll use the United States of America stats—we were giving ten vaccines in the United States of America by the time you were 18 up until about 1986 when we took all liability away that the vaccine program increased to 54 vaccines
How many of you are aware that in that time we went from a chronic illness rate in the United States of America of 12% to a chronic illness rate of 54% and that data has been given to us since 2012? How many are aware of that increase in chronic illness?
Long-time readers and those who follow the antivaccine movement will immediately recognize these very old talking points. The first one is the claim that “all liability” was taken away from vaccine manufacturers through the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986, which is just plain false. What the NCVIA did was to mandate that all vaccine injury claims first go through a special Vaccine Court, where complainants, win or lose, are reimbursed for reasonable legal expenses and expenses incurred preparing their case, which is way better than the case for regular civil litigation. Also, the evidentiary standard for the Vaccine Court is, as they say for civil litigation, “50% and a feather”. Moreover, the Vaccine Court has a list of “table injuries” (injuries known to be caused by vaccines based on science) for which compensation is basically automatic. In addition, complainants are free to utilize Federal Courts if they lose in Vaccine Court. To fund the system, there is a tax on every dose of vaccine sold in the US.
As I’ve often noted, antivaxxers hate the NCVIA and the Vaccine Court and frequently attack it based on misinformation and distorted information. Antivax lawyers hate the vaccine court too. I’ve always strongly suspected that trial lawyers hate the Vaccine Court because they want to sue for big fat judgments of millions of dollars on contingency (from which they can extract one-third of the judgment as payment, of course), rather than simple reasonable hourly rates paid by the Vaccine Court, which, while reliable income for representing their clients—win or lose—do not provide the opportunity to win eye-watering court judgments and settlements.
The last two tropes should be familiar also. For example, the second trope was the exaggeration of the number of vaccines, which requires counting every dose of a series individually and counting combination vaccines as their component parts; e.g., the MMR vaccine would count as three vaccines each time it’s administered. The third trope was a direct citation of RFK Jr.’s “sickest generation” claim, right down to the assertion that 54% of children today suffer from a chronic illness of one sort or another, up from 12% in decades past. As I explained in detail, it’s a deceptive narrative that relies on cherry picked and carefully curated studies that ignore context and also the consequences of increased screening and widened definitions of many of the chronic illnesses cited.
So how did the panel respond? To his credit, Geert Vanden Bossche looked very uncomfortable, as though for the first time he was realizing just what he had gotten himself into and was being forced to face it. He responded first by stating that he didn’t like such “blunt statements”, how it was “more complicated than that”, and how Bigtree should be very careful about citing correlations as though they represent causation. Bigtree, seeing that Vanden Bossche had started to fall into his trap, was more than happy to concede that he was “strictly stating correlations”. Bigtree included clips showing how only Vanden Bossche had pushed back against Bigtree’s attacks on the childhood vaccination schedule, although I can’t resist repeating how Vanden Bossche remains apparently unaware that his claims about COVID-19 vaccines had echoed those of one of the big macher of the modern antivaccine movement himself, Andrew Wakefield, about the MMR vaccine.
Unfortunately, Vanden Bossche appears to have been the only panelist who even weakly pushed back against Bigtree’s antivaccine narrative about childhood vaccines. The next clip showed Robert Malone emphasizing that, when he had raised his hand to agree that vaccination should be part of a “better way” going forward to tackle COVID-19, he was not defending our current childhood vaccination schedule, adding:
In raising my hand, I was not in any way endorsing our current vaccine schedule. For me as a vaccinologist who has often assumed—has integrated—a belief system that I was brought up in about the efficacy and utility of childhood vaccines, I had a moment of epiphany when I sat down with Candace Owens and we talked about what the temporal relationship has been with many of these classic pediatric diseases and their quenching in the population, which was more concurrent with implementation of modern public health and sanitation practices than it was with implementation of vaccines. And yet the industry has taught me and many of us that there was a causal relationship when in fact it was correlation, which is one of the big flaws we’ve seen again and again, conflating correlation with causation.
Candace Owens, it turns out, is one of the new school antivaxxers who has completely embraced antivax conspiracies, old school and new school. More importantly, though, how many readers recognize the hoary old antivax trope that Malone repeated? You know, the claim that it was sanitation, not vaccination, that eliminated childhood diseases. It should not surprise anyone that Malone has embraced it, given how deeply he has drunk the antivaccine Kool-Aid and peddled conspiracy theories over the last couple of years.
It’s an easy one to debunk. All you have to do is ask: Was sanitation in the US much different in 1960 than it was in 1970? Why then, did the incidence of measles plummet so dramatically during that decade? Simple. It was the introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963. Also, measles is a highly transmissible viral respiratory disease that is primarily transmitted through the air via respiration; improved sanitation would not be expected to have much of an effect on its spread. Similarly, what about polio? Was sanitation in the US so much better in 1960 than it was in 1950? So what happened in the 1950s? The Salk polio vaccine was introduced. The list goes on and on, for example the Haemophilus influenza type B vaccine introduced in the 1990s. The “sanitation, not vaccination” trope is a deeply ahistorical and unscientific bit of misdirection. No one is saying that sanitation was not important for bringing infectious diseases spread by water or feces under control, but the fact is that vaccination was a far greater contributor to the elimination of most childhood diseases than sanitation, particularly those transmitted through respiration.
Next up, Bret Weinstein:
Is it true that a great many vaccinations is bad for you over a lifetime and that we should treat this technology very sparingly, right, that we should be choosing very carefully which few things it makes sense to use it for and what to hold it in reserve for, rather than just imagining that if vaccines are good then more vaccines are better?
Regular readers, can you name that antivaxxer trope? It sounds to me like a variation of “too many too soon” that was very commonly aimed at the childhood vaccination schedule to claim that “too many” vaccines were making our kids sick with autism, autoimmune diseases, etc., etc., etc. (Indeed, that line about “if vaccines are good then more vaccines are better” could have been directly lifted from any number of antivaccine websites 15 years ago.) It’s just not true, and we have known that it’s not true for a long time, no matter how long antivaxxers have been repeating it. Welcome, though, Bret Weinstein, to the antivax camp. I also noticed Malone nodding enthusiastically behind Weinstein. Vanden Bossche looked more and more fidgety and uncomfortable. Good. I want him to feel uncomfortable among the antivaxxers. Maybe it will lead him back from the brink, back from conspiracy theories and pseudoscience, although probably not.
Next up, Tess Lawrie. You might remember that she started out promoting ivermectin as a cure for COVID-19, but, as has been the case with so many ivermectin cultists, she’s now joined the antivaxxers:
My opinion is that our children are not suffering from infections. They’re suffering from chronic diseases, autoimmune diseases, autism, and depression. So it seems we might need to reevaluate health and now we need to look at those things that potentially might be affecting our children’s health.
Gee, are vaccines among those “other things”? Also, why are our children not primarily suffering from infections anymore? It couldn’t be due to vaccines preventing them from getting infections that used to kill so many children in previous centuries before they could grow up, would it? Lawrie has clearly gone antivax, too.
Vanden Bossche interjected that he was “having a tremendous problem here,” because “guys, guys, this is way more complicated than you’re discussing” and noted that if you are just considering safety issues you’re not “considering the impact of losing herd immunity”. And you know what? He was right! Again, referring to Tess Lawrie, the reason we’re not dealing with so many children with infections is because those infections are prevented by vaccines and the herd immunity they provide! He further noted that public health interventions not involving vaccines don’t work very well if there is asymptomatic spread, such as with COVID-19, the flu, and measles, concluding by asking how without vaccinations you can maintain herd immunity against these diseases without having the “next epidemic”.
He even said:
I’m having a huge problem with taking these shortcuts, right, and with saying, “No injections.” OK, guys, then we are not going to vaccinate, and these diseases that we have kept under control for many years through herd immunity, lose that herd immunity, and have your epidemics to reestablish it every single time.
Vanden Bossche was partially correct. Before safe and effective vaccines, there was never any true “natural herd immunity” to any of the childhood diseases for which we routinely vaccinate. The reason was simple. Every year, millions of new susceptible children were born, and, of course, many, if not most, of them got the diseases. I don’t want to be too hard on Vanden Bossche, but on the other hand he did throw in his lot with antivaxxers and has been promoting a narrative about COVID-19 variants that echoes old antivax narratives about measles and, especially, pertussis. Personally, I can’t help but feel a fair amount of schadenfreude watching Vanden Bossche being forced to grapple with his cognitive dissonance over his COVID-19 antivaccine fear mongering and the consequences of it that led him to be on a panel with some major league antivax cranks, particularly Del Bigtree.
There was a lot more there, including Vanden Bossche wondering if Bigtree wants to sacrifice the elderly and those with comorbidities that make them especially susceptible to COVID-19 and other infectious diseases. Unfortunately, he apparently doesn’t realize that Bigtree has long advocated exactly that, while blaming people for their comorbidities associated with lifestyle. (How, though, can he blame people for their age, which they have no control over?) The point is that anti-COVID-19 vaccination sentiment is now increasingly indistinguishable from old school antivax sentiment, Geert Vanden Bossche’s reaction notwithstanding.
The fusion of old school and new school antivaxxers endangers us all
I’ve long argued that the endgame of the antivaccine movement has always been to eliminate all vaccine mandates of any kind. The rise of the “new school” COVID-19 antivaccine movement has provided antivaxxers with an opportunity to realize that dream (at least in some states) far sooner than antivaxxers would have thought possible.
Moreover, the fusion of new school with old school antivaccine views is fueling a movement that is endangering childhood vaccinations, as described in a recent article in The New York Times:
In 2019, even before the pandemic struck, the World Health Organization listed growing vaccine hesitancy as one of its top 10 threats to global health. W.H.O. officials often refer to the contagion of misinformation that foments vaccine hesitancy as an “infodemic”: mountains of incorrect and sometimes flagrantly conspiratorial information about diseases that leads people to avoid lifesaving medical practices, like the vaccines used to fight them. Now the pandemic has given anti-vaccine advocates an opportunity to field-test a variety of messages and find new recruits. And one message in particular seems to be resonating widely: Vaccines and vaccine mandates are an attack on freedom.
And, thanks to anti-COVID-19 vaccination propaganda:
But instead of feeling confident about vaccines, a growing segment of the population may be primed to feel more anxious and doubtful about them, and that doubt may be seeping into their relationship with medical science — or governmental mandates — in general. Kate Williamson, one of the pediatricians I spoke to in Orange County, told me that because vaccine skepticism has become linked with patients’ political leanings, many doctor-patient conversations are now much harder. Merely bringing up “science” at all can be interpreted as a personal attack. “Politics for a lot of people, it is an identity,” she says. “It is a culture. I feel like if I talk about science, then I’m going against their political identity.”
Leading to:
Perhaps most ominous, from a public-health perspective, is that school mandates have started to come under attack in state legislatures. Numerous states have already passed laws restricting or prohibiting mandates for the Covid-19 vaccine. And in a few, including Ohio and Pennsylvania, bills have been proposed that would weaken school vaccine mandates or even prohibit them altogether. “I’m not sure that the people fighting for these bills truly believe in them, but they’re doing it because it’s politically expedient,” Jason Terk, the pediatrician in Keller, Texas, told me. “It matters not to them that there might be consequences to these bills passing.”
None of these legislative efforts have succeeded in becoming law yet, but they highlight a broader development that’s easy to overlook. “During the pandemic, the antivax movement was able to springboard to the mainstream,” Koltai says. “I don’t think it’s that taboo anymore to be vaccine-hesitant.”
Sean O’Leary, vice chairman of the Committee on Infectious Diseases at the American Academy of Pediatrics, suspects that, hesitancy aside, we are probably in for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases in the near future. Young children are undervaccinated. Polio and measles are already flaring up in some parts of the developing world, where the pandemic has stymied vaccination efforts. He worries that one of those infections will hop to the United States, where it would now find a public-health infrastructure that is stretched very thin and a combustible population of under-vaccinated bodies to burn through.
I like to jokingly (or maybe not-so-jokingly) quote Yoda’s warning to Luke Skywalker from The Empire Strikes Back:
If once you start down the dark path, forever will it dominate your destiny. Consume you it will, as it did Obi-Wan’s apprentice.
Antivaccine conspiracy theories and misinformation are a lot like the Dark Side of the Force in this, and antivaxxers who were once scientists are a lot like Jedi corrupted by the Dark Side. Once a formerly reputable scientist starts down the dark path of antivaccine pseudoscience, even if it’s to opportunistically dip his toe in the waters of “skepticism” about a single vaccine, forever will it dominate his destiny. Moreover, those who dip their toe in antivax conspiracy theories tend not to be able to resist going further in. That is what we are grappling with now, how COVID-19 antivaccine conspiracy theories are metastasizing to fuse with old school conspiracy theories about childhood vaccines. Public health is at risk.

The Top COVID-19 Hucksters and Grifters…so far
It wouldn’t be a health crisis without those that want to profit from it.
Scott Gavura on October 29, 2020
Link

The COVID-19 pandemic is the worst public health crisis in decades. As of October 2020, cases are surging again worldwide, there is no vaccine expected anytime soon, and North America is preparing to head into its winter flu season. Hospital overcrowding and growing numbers of deaths seem inevitable. While this wave feels different than the first (we know more about how the virus is transmitted, and the science has progressed significantly on the best treatment approaches), the situation is still very grim. While stories of how people have pulled together, pitched in and helped others have appeared, so have stories of those that have treated this catastrophe as an opportunity to promote or sell products and treatments that haven’t actually been shown to prevent or treat COVID-19. That’s what this post is about. With a nod to the Behind the Bastards podcast for taking on this topic back in March, here is my growing list of COVID-19 snake oil promoters.
Alex Jones
You may not know more of Alex Jones than his name alone, in which case you should count yourself lucky. Alex Jones is the man behind the InfoWars website, videos and in particular, online store. For years, Jones has touted vile conspiracy theories like calling the Sandy Hook shooting a false flag attack, none of which has harmed his credibility with President Donald Trump, who appeared on his online show in 2015. Jones has been posting paranoid rants for years, and despite being banned from most social media platforms, has used the COVID pandemic as an opportunity for him to drive more sales to his online store. In particular, colloidal silver and other silver-containing products were touted as effective anti-COVID products. His videos had statements like:
I’m just gonna tell ya, that for just your daily life, and your gums and your teeth and for regular viruses and bacteria, the patented Nano Silver we have, the Pentagon has come out and documented, and homeland security have said this stuff kills the whole SARS corona family, at point blank range. Well of course it does, it kills every virus. But they found that, this is 13 years ago, and the Pentagon uses the product we have. And the product we have in private label is about to be in Walmart . . . the Nano Silver toothpaste in the Superblue with the tea tree and the iodine, that’s the Superblue’s amazing, and we have the whitening toothpaste that has the Nano Silver and a lot more as well.
In March, the New York Attorney General ordered Jones to stop making claims that his products could protect against coronavirus infections. Then in April, the FDA issued a warning letter to Jones telling him to stop making COVID-19 claims about his “Superblue Silver Immune Gargle,” “SuperSilver Whitening Toothpaste,” “SuperSilver Wound Dressing Gel” and “Superblue Fluoride Free Toothpaste.”
Mike Adams
Mike Adams is no stranger to this blog. He promotes a variety of conspiracy theories offering something to everyone on both the far-right and the far-left, and his vast collection of websites was recently cited by the Institute for Strategic Dialogue as possibly the “largest coordinated disinformation network in the world” outside of Russia. He is an HIV/AIDs denialist, a 9/11 “Truther”, anti-vaccine, anti-chemotherapy (arguably anti-medicine), anti-fluoride, an Obama “birther”, and a climate change denialist. He believes that non-human (i.e., alien) entities are controlling “globalists” who intend to force-vaccinate us all for population control…or…something. Like Jones, Adams has been banned from Google News, Apple, YouTube, Pinterest, Twitter, and Facebook, but Adams’ dozens (possibly over 100) of websites means his content is still shared widely across social media platforms. Beyond disinformation, Adams is all about the grift. His online store (nope, not linking to it) sells supplements, potions and even products to help you become a “prepper” for when the globalists-controlled-by-aliens bring you the COVID vaccine. None of this is new for Adams, he’s been “prepping” for the past 20 years, dating back to his apocalyptic predictions about Y2K.
Joe Mercola
Any list of people providing questionable health advice seems to bring out the same names, and the next one is also well known to this blog. Joe Mercola is an osteopath and huckster who sells a wide variety of products and is also a strong verbal and financial supporter of the anti-vaccine movement. He is noted to currently claim that dozens of vitamins, supplements and other products on his blog can prevent or treat COVID-19 infections. He mixes this with false and misleading COVID-19 statements in attempts to boost the sales of products on his website. According to the Center for Science in the Public Interest, he claimed that contracting the virus after using his supplements will confer greater protection than a COVID-19 vaccine, a claim that is stunning in its foolishness.
Jim Bakker
Jim Bakker is a televangelist and convicted felon who hosts The Jim Bakker Show. He was warned by the FDA in February to stop promoting his own colloidal silver product as a COVID-19 treatment. In March the state of Missouri (where Bakker is based) filed a lawsuit against him to stop him from advertising or selling his products as a COVID treatment. This was followed by a warning from the FDA and a cease-and-desist letter from the state of New York. Subsequently his ability to accept credit cards was apparently cut off and he was said to be on the brink of bankruptcy. In June, the state of Arkansas joined Missouri by also suing Bakker for selling colloidal silver products as a COVID-19 treatment.
Mike Lindell
Steven Novella wrote about Mike Lindell, CEO of MyPillow, back in September. Oleandrin is a chemical extracted from the oleander plant. It, like thousands of other chemicals derived from natural sources, has been isolated, purified, and studied for possible medicinal value. An in-vitro (laboratory) test of oleandrin found that it may have anti-viral properties. This is promising, but that’s as far as the evidence goes. There is no in-vivo (in human) trials to show that oleandrin is safe or effective as a treatment. David Juurlink, a physician and toxicologist, noted that the presumed effective concentration is well within the toxic range for humans. Oleandrin causes nausea and vomiting, and then, arrhythmias and sometimes death. Oleandrin received more attention that it deserved through Lindell’s promotion of the chemical to the Trump administration. The FDA put a stop to this and rejected an application to treat oleandrin as a dietary supplement, because it considers the chemical to meet the definition of a drug. We shouldn’t see any oleandrin products anytime soon, considering its toxicity and lack of effectiveness. Juurlink noted,
No one should take oleandrin to prevent COVID…Anyone gullible and foolish enough to take it despite this advice should get their affairs in order beforehand.
Keith Middlebrook
Way back in March, actor Keith Middlebrook was arrested by the FBI in a sting operation where he was delivering a COVID preventative/cure to a potential “investor”, who was an undercover agent. Middlebrook had been promoting pills and some sort of injectable liquid to his millions of Instagram followers, claiming they provided immunity or a cure. Middlebrook was seeking investors, promising a guaranteed return of $30 million after an initial investment of $300,000. Since his initial arrest and subsequent release, Middlebrook continues to insist that his products are legitimate and he continues to reject the label of “con man”.
Dave Asprey
Dave Asprey is the man behind the “Bulletproof” brand – the guy who popularized putting oil and butter in your coffee. He has built his “biohacking” brand into an empire of books, podcasts, and product sales. Asprey’s output combines cherry-picked science with pseudoscience, wrapped up in a self-experimentation ethos that superficially sounds compelling but falls short in actual evidence. Asprey decided to “hack coronavirus” earlier this year and endorsed a long list of products like andrographis, probiotics, vitamins, coenzyme Q10, omega fatty acids, black cumin seed oil, hydroxytyrosol, sulforaphane and l-glutamine, and directing readers to his own products for sale. The Federal Trade Commission asked him to stop:
It is unlawful under the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 41 et seq., to advertise that a product can prevent, treat, or cure human disease unless you possess competent and reliable scientific evidence, including, when appropriate, well-controlled human clinical studies, substantiating that the claims are true at the time they are made. For COVID-19, no such study is currently known to exist for the products identified above. Thus, any Coronavirus-related prevention claims regarding such products are not supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence. You must immediately cease making all such claims.
Dominique Fradin-Read and compounding pharmacies
Dominique Fradin-Read is a medical doctor and contributor to Gwyneth Paltrow’s growing Goop empire, creating the “Madame Ovary” supplement regimen (just $90/month). In October an NPR story reported that Fradin-Read was endorsing an unapproved drug, thymosin alpha-1. She is not alone in the promotion of this chemical, but is probably the most well-known advocate for claiming it has value to prevent or treat COVID infections. Thymosin alpha-1 is a hormone secreted by the thymus which has been isolated and its biological effects are now being studied, as well as its potential as a drug product. In 2000 the FDA granted thymalfasin (a synthetic analog of thymosin alpha-1) injection (Zadaxin) orphan drug status for the treatment of liver cancer, which was followed in 2006 with the designation for malignant melanoma. It is approved as a drug is some countries, but not the US, where it is not currently approved by the FDA for the treatment of any indication, COVID or otherwise. Consequently, it is not sold as a commercial product. However, this has not prevented Fradin-Read from promoting it, which can be obtained from an array of compounding pharmacies. I have blogged about compounding pharmacies before, which can manufacture drug products not otherwise commercially available. While compounding pharmacies can provide invaluable services and access to needed, customized drug products, their products are not tested for quality or safety by the FDA. In worst-case scenarios, when quality and safety standards are ignored, contaminated products from compounding pharmacies can kill. Some compounding pharmacies have jumped on the thymosin alpha-1 bandwagon. NPR notes:
NPR found medical practices widely marketing thymosin alpha-1 for COVID-19 based in Michigan, Tennessee, Texas, Florida, Iowa, New York and California, among other places. Not every practice discloses how much it charges for these injections online, but a handful of companies list prices in the range of $369 for a one-month supply, or $400 for a “ten-syringe set.” Most of the medical practices that promoted the drug are not specialized in infectious diseases but rather focus on plastic surgery or promote “wellness,” “anti-aging” and “regenerative” medicine.
The FTC and the FDA have begun taking action against companies that claim thymosin alpha-1 can be used to prevent or treat COVID infections.
To be continued
My list is admittedly incomplete, and also too North America-centric. Who did I miss? Leave your nominations in the comments.

Reader Beware
Certain doctors may not be anti-vaccine, but they need to be fact-checked as if they are.
Jonathan Howard on August 27, 2021
Link

Doctors’ Errors
In prior articles, I discussed several doctors who opined to varying degrees that children need not be vaccinated against COVID-19 (here, here, here, and here).   Each of their arguments contained significant factual errors that undercut their argument.
    • One doctor said that there is “about one in a million chance of death for a child under 19 from COVID”.  This is false. In reality over 500 young people had died of the virus in the US when she made her claim, making her claim a mathematical impossibility that would require there to be over 500 million children in America.
    • One doctor claimed that a vaccine trial for adolescents didn’t measure “clinical outcomes … because so few kids get sick with COVID-19.”  This is false. In reality, the trial measured whether or not children got COVID-19, something that was in the title of the article.  The vaccine worked.  Sixteen children who received the placebo got the disease, while zero children who received the vaccine got the disease.  The author apparently does not consider it a “clinical outcome” when a child gets COVID-19 in a trial of a vaccine designed to prevent them from getting COVID-19 and so didn’t mention this in his article.
    • One doctor claimed that after “reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date.” This is false. In reality, a simple Google search returns multiple news reports of otherwise healthy children dying of COVID-19 in the US, and a CDC study of 121 young people who died of COVID-19 found that 25% were healthy.
This is just a small sampling of the basic factual errors highly-credentialed doctors have made this pandemic.
Errors of Omission:  The Virus
Making factual errors is one way to understate the harms caused by COVID-19.  Another way is to not mention these harms at all.  Some doctors haven’t made blatant factual errors, as their arguments not to vaccinate children are essentially devoid of any facts at all. If ten data points are needed to understand the risks and benefits of the vaccine, they cherry pick the three that support their position. For example, they rightfully cheered (here and here) when cases plummeted earlier this year, but are now silent as cases and hospitalizations rise to record levels in children.
Instead of providing concrete information about how the virus has harmed children, these doctors say only “the likelihood of severe outcomes or death associated with covid-19 infection is very low for children.”  I wrote previously about why describing harms to children in this incomplete way is problematic.  While I agree that children with COVID-19 have a low likelihood of severe outcomes and death, low likelihood events multiplied millions of times can add up to non-trivial numbers of very sick and dead children.  People should know this. Yet, some doctors have written multiple articles on COVID-19 and children without simply even stating the number of hospitalized and deceased children.  Some articles don’t even acknowledge that these tragedies can occur.
Errors of omission can be serious errors, and I try to avoid them.  Though I strongly feel that adolescents should be vaccinated against COVID-19, I hope I’ve not shied away from presenting information that weakens this case.  I’ve discussed the potential overcounting (and undercounting) of pediatric hospitalizations and deaths.  I’ve discussed vaccine-myocarditis as evenly as I could and will discuss it every time I write about the vaccine.  I’ve said previously (here and here) that a vaccine that sends young people to the hospital with heart inflammation should not be trivialized. Even if all affected individuals seem to recover back to normal after a short time, as pediatricians say they do, the possibility for long-term side effects is real and affected individuals will be advised to avoid vigorous activity for several months.  Though I don’t do it perfectly, I try to be thorough, not to selectively present information to advance my beliefs.  This doesn’t make me special.  I’d think that any honest broker would do the same, especially when writing an article likely to be read by the general public.
The approach of trying to provide readers with all relevant information proved surprisingly controversial.  One doctor defended his decision to omit harms of the virus in an article he wrote on vaccine-myocarditis by saying, “If you think *the virus* hasn’t had any airtime in the last 18 months then I’m not sure what more can be done for you.”  Another doctor reacted similarly to my criticism by saying, “Failure to cite a widely reported statistic? Seems like a rather small nit to pick. I’m sure you can find more substantive arguments, no?”  He also said that “[a] hallmark of novice science writers is starting every paper with a recitation of epidemiologic statistics which have been previously widely reported.”  He felt doing so was a “waste of ink.”
While I agree statistics on COVID-19 and children are readily available, I don’t believe they are widely known.  Do you know how many children have died of COVID-19, how many have been hospitalized, how many wind up in the ICU, or how many cases of MIS-C there have been?  Do you know how just sick children with MIS-C often are?  Do you know exactly how many children are contracting the virus and being hospitalized every day right now?  Do you know that more children are being hospitalized now than ever before?
Maybe you do know these facts, but I’m sure the average person does not.  I’m confident very few doctors know these all facts off the top of their head.  Many people falsely believe that COVID-19 poses essentially no danger to children at all.  This is precisely because basic facts have not been widely reported.  Instead, numerous articles only report the harms to children as “rare” or falsely say that COVID-19 is less dangerous than the flu (it’s not).  Of course, most scientific publications won’t be read by the general public, and it’s not necessary for every research paper to review all the numbers. However, opinion pieces published in medical journals are likely to be shared widely on social media and read by the general public.  Doctors should not just assume that all readers will have all the facts at their fingertips.  They should be cognizant of who may read their articles and what the effects of their omissions might be.
I generally believe that doctors who write about COVID-19 and children have an obligation to clearly inform their readers about the risk the virus poses relative to the vaccine, especially as this can be done in a couple of sentences.  Dr. Aaron Carroll showed how easy this is to do. In an article advocating vaccinating children, he wrote,
At least 354 kids have died from COVID-19. Many more thousands have been hospitalized. More than 4,400 have been diagnosed with multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), a “rare but serious condition associated with COVID-19,” and many more have been ill, even if they’ve recovered pretty well. Although COVID-19 has been nowhere near the danger that it has posed to adults and the elderly, it’s still been worse than most flu seasons for children.
Combined with his acknowledgment of vaccine-myocarditis, these three sentences convey crucial information while using hardly any ink at all.  (I’d only note that other tallies from the CDC and American Academy of Pediatrics report a slightly higher pediatric death toll).  I’d bet that many people would not consider these harms “rare” when they are enumerated in this straightforward manner.  I’d wager that more adolescents would be vaccinated if these numbers were widely known, especially given what the virus is doing to children right now.  180,000 children contracted the virus last week alone, the third worst week for children the entire pandemic.  In Florida, children younger than 12 years have a 23% positivity rate and children ages 12 to 19 have a positivity rate of nearly 25%.  An average of 321 children are being hospitalized with COVID-19 every day, the highest number thus far.  24 children died just last week, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics.
Recognition of past harms speaks to potential future harms and allows for informed policy discussions. Hundreds more children may die and many thousands more could be hospitalized if the virus is allowed to spread unchecked through the pediatric population, which is basically what is happening right now in many parts of the country.  Perhaps this is one reason why some doctors who have expressed skepticism about the vaccine in children are habitually unwilling to simply present the facts about the virus.  Acknowledging the reality of how COVID-19 has affected children drastically undermines their argument that they should not be vaccinated against it.  As such, unwanted facts become unmentionable facts.  It’s as if certain doctors have agreed on a collective code of silence, a form of contrarian omerta, where bad news must never be acknowledged.  Ink conservation has nothing to do with it.
Perhaps another reason why some doctors are reluctant to acknowledge the reality of COVID-19 for children is they may feel obligated to say what they would do about it.  I know that to varying degrees, these doctors are against masks, vaccines for children, vaccine mandates, and testing children in schools.  However, other than wanting schools to be open, I’m not clear what they are for.  I have no clue how they plan to keep children safe once they enter the classroom.   Some doctors are calling for randomized controlled trials of masks and similar interventions.  Doctors who say these interventions could “easily be studied” could actually do these studies.  Then we’ll know what to do when schools open in 2022.  However, these doctors’ plan for children today seems to be to cast doubt on measures to protect them, to never acknowledge unwanted news, and to repeat the mantra “severe illness in children is rare.”  Unfortunately, saying this over and over again doesn’t help the hundreds of children who are going to the hospital every day with COVID-19.  Evading reality is an easy way to evade responsibility.
Yet anyone who writes about COVID-19 and children has responsibility for their words. I basically agree with Dr. Nicholas Chrimes who said, “No one should be allowed to use the phrase ‘living with COVID’ without defining what that means in terms of acceptable rates of hospital admission & death.”  Acknowledging reality doesn’t mean that policy positions automatically follow.  Reasonable people may feel that schools should be open, but they should be honest about what the trade-offs will be.  Again, hundreds of children could die and many thousands more could be hospitalized if the virus is allowed to spread unchecked through the pediatric population.
I’m glad schools will be open for my children in New York City.  I’m really lucky my children are old enough to be vaccinated.  New York City has decent overall vaccination rate, and it will use all the measures some doctors oppose to keep children safe.  School employees are required to be vaccinated, children will wear masks, and they will be tested for the virus.  I hopes that with these measures, COVID-19 will actually be as dangerous to children as the flu, which most of us previously felt was an “acceptable” rate of hospital admission and death.  Nonetheless, some children will contract the virus at school.  Some will get really sick and it’s possible some may die.  I won’t sugarcoat this sad reality by merely describing the harms to children are “rare.”  I also feel schools should be willing to reverse course if the virus spreads uncontrollably, which has already happened in multiple places where the situation is quite different from New York City.  I don’t just want schools to open.  I want them to stay open, and I want children to be safe.  I am not sure if this is possible, but I’m certain that ignoring reality won’t help.
As Dr. Carroll showed, providing basic facts need not be alarmist.  The overwhelming majority of children with COVID-19 will be just fine thankfully.  It’s important to not forget this fortunate fact, which is why I’ve said exactly this every time I’ve written about this topic (here, here, here, and here). Even though everyone knows this, no one accused me of wasting ink for saying this.  Similarly, no one accused me of wasting ink when I wrote just before the arrival of a nasty variant, “Barring a nasty variant, the worst is over for America and its children.”  Even though it was common knowledge at the time, all of these doctors also used ink to share positive news about the virus.  In fact all of them said the pandemic was essentially over or strongly implied it was ending (here, here, here, and here).  Now that the pandemic has reached its most perilous moment for America children, ink preservation is suddenly a priority. This reveals an uncomfortable truth about the writers who insist on a rosier picture: ink is only considered “wasted” when it is used to share unwanted, inconvenient facts.
There are real-world consequences when prominent voices collectively omit information on how COVID-19 has harmed children, glossing over the harms by saying that COVID-19 is “a severe disease in adults, not in children.” One mother, whose unvaccinated 13-year-old daughter was hospitalized and intubated with COVID-19, said, “I just had a false sense of security that it was just like the flu and it wasn’t that serious.  Obviously it is that serious and it was that serious. Now I can see.”  It’s tragic that this mother had this false sense of security, though she was not alone.  One doctor wrote on Twitter, “Admitted a child for Covid & the parent said ‘What? Kids get sick from Covid?’ Seemed sincerely shocked.”  It is a clear failure of science communication that parents are still this misinformed this late into the pandemic.
Errors of Omission:  The Vaccine
Though some doctors routinely omit negative information about the virus, they are only too eager to share negative information- and only negative information- about the vaccine.  As is expected with those who are trying to convince people rather than inform them, long Twitter threads on vaccine-myocarditis make no mention of case series showing the condition has a very favorable short-term prognosis.  While I fully agree that myocarditis in young people should not be minimized, the prognosis of these cases should not be hidden either.
Of the initial 323 cases identified by the CDC, 79% had no symptoms by the time they issued their first report, and all but 9 had been discharged from the hospital.  Further cases series say:
    • “All patients in this series had a benign course; none required intensive care unit admission” (Dionne et al)
    • “Patients resolved their symptoms rapidly.” (Marshall et al)
    • “Hospital course is mild with quick clinical recovery and excellent short-term outcomes” (Jain et al)
    • “All patients received brief supportive care and were recovered or recovering at the time of this report.” (Montgomery et al)
    • The clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis-like illness appears favorable, with resolution of symptoms in all patients.” (Rosner et al)
    • “The clinical course was mild in all six patients.” (Mouch et al)
    • “All patients had resolution of their chest pain, were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, and were alive with preserved left ventricular ejection fraction at last contact.” (Larson et al)
One of these articles concluded “Despite the risks of myocarditis associated with vaccination, the benefits of vaccination likely outweigh risks in children and adolescents,” which reflects the opinion of every major medical society with relevant expertise.  Most countries with abundant vaccine supply are vaccinating adolescents.   I have little doubt that if the myocarditis from the vaccine was as severe as the myocarditis from MIS-C, which can produce cardiac shock requiring ICU-care and life support, these doctors would readily share this information, which of course, would be appropriate.
Although all studies thus far are in agreement about the excellent short-term prognosis of vaccine-myocarditis, the frequency is a bit more uncertain.  Data from Canada shows that it occurs in about 1 in 14,000 males age 12-17 years and 1 in 6,700 males age 18-24 years after the second dose.  Data from Israel of people older than 16 years showed that there were 2.7 cases of myocarditis per 100,000 people and the average age was 25-years-old.   The virus itself caused 11 cases of myocarditis per 100,000 people, as well as many other complications, of course.  An FDA model based on “non-chart-confirmed cases from a US healthcare claims database” found the myocarditis rate to be potentially as high as 1 in 5,000 for boys age 16 and 17-years.  Though I am unsure how reliable insurance claims are, it is similar to initial estimates from Israel, which reported a rate of 1 in 3,000-6,000 young males.  (Israel reported that “95% are considered to be mild cases” and so decided to vaccinate all teenagers and high-risk younger children).
Even if the higher rate of vaccine-myocarditis turns out to be accurate, it is still lower than the risk of MIS-C, which occurs in about 1 in 3,200 children who contract the virus.  Another study that reviewed electronic medical records, thus far not peer-reviewed, found that “Young males infected with the virus are up 6 times more likely to develop myocarditis as those who have received the vaccine.”  Perhaps this is why I’ve read many articles about hospitals being overwhelmed with children with COVID-19, but I have yet to read an article about any hospital being deluged with teenagers with vaccine-myocarditis.
Doctors should aim to be comprehensive when sharing information about the vaccine, especially since multiple adolescents, including some with no underlying health issues, have died of COVID-19 after the vaccine was available to them (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here). In contrast, a review by the CDC found that zero children have died from the vaccine thus far. One mother, whose unvaccinated 18-year-old son ended up needing ECMO, said, “Seeing him like this, I think what if he got vaccinated? I don’t wish this on any mom.” She didn’t vaccinate her son saying, “I didn’t feel comfortable because you hear the good and the bad.” Again, it is a clear failure of science communication that parents are still this misinformed this late into the pandemic. Fortunately, enough voices are sharing the facts, and the vaccination rate in teens is increasing. Vaccination clinics are being held in honor of dead children, such as 17-year-old Schwanda Corprew who died four days before she was supposed to be vaccinated. Enterprising teens are even figuring out how to get vaccinated against the wishes of their parents.
It bears repeating, there are real-world consequences when prominent voices collectively omit information on how the virus has harmed children and how the vaccine can protect them.  This is the central point of every article I’ve written here so far.  It is never a “waste of ink” when doctors provide relevant, accurate information in articles likely to be read by the general public. Children older than 12-years shouldn’t be dying of COVID-19 or winding up on life support in the ICU today. These tragedies are completely preventable. Yet, they will continue to happen as long as people remain ignorant of a simple fact that some have inexplicably obscured: the virus is much more dangerous for children than the vaccine.
A flashback
If I didn’t have the facts at my fingertips, these doctors’ arguments to not vaccinate all eligible children might have been very compelling.  However, I knew that over one in a million children died of COVID-19. I knew the vaccine trial measured whether or not children actually got COVID-19.  I knew some healthy children had died of COVID-19.  I knew the facts that others habitually omit.  As such, I was easily able to spot the defects in these doctors’ arguments.
In doing this, I had a flashback to when I first became interested in the anti-vaccine movement many years ago.  The first few times I read anti-vaccine articles, I found them plausible. I lacked the background knowledge to spot their flaws and was blissfully ignorant of the mendaciousness that characterizes the anti-vaccine movement.  It was only when I dug further, often with the help Science Based Medicine, that I realized their grave flaws.
For example, in a collection of articles titled “200 Evidence Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate,” Sayer Ji listed an article titled “A Measles Outbreak Was Reported in a Highly Vaccinated Population, San Diego, 2008.”  Sounds bad, right?  However, the full title of the article was “Measles Outbreak in a Highly Vaccinated Population, San Diego, 2008: Role of the Intentionally Undervaccinated.”  The article concluded that “measles outbreaks can occur among clusters of intentionally undervaccinated children, at major cost to public health agencies, medical systems, and families.”  In attempting to convince people vaccines didn’t work, Mr. Ji distorted the titles of articles that showed vaccines work quite well.
As a gullible naïf, this level of deception was astonishing to me.  I knew moving forward that I needed to double check every “fact” I read in anti-vaccine articles.  Usually these “facts” were blatantly false or crucial information was omitted.  I have come to expect this from anti-vaxxers.  I can now spot the errors and omissions in anti-vaccine articles from a mile away, and with Dorit Reiss, I wrote a book chapter about how to do this.
A realization
Before the pandemic, I didn’t feel the need to apply this level of scrutiny to articles written by a highly credentialed doctors at renowned medical schools.  I believed such people made dedicated efforts to be both accurate and thorough. If they said a vaccine trial didn’t measure a clinical outcome or that no healthy children died from a particular virus, I wouldn’t rush to confirm this myself.  I would assume the author had researched these claims and was accurately reporting their findings.
Now, as with anti-vaccine articles, I can no longer assume that some doctors accurately report basic facts or make a diligent effort to be thorough, including all relevant information.  The errors and omissions I described previously are not isolated events in these doctors’ writing.  Rather they are part of a consistent pattern where both the harms of the virus and the efficacy/safety of the vaccine are repeatedly minimized.  Notably none of these doctors has made an error overestimating the dangers of the virus to my knowledge.  All of their errors reinforce their prior belief that the virus isn’t that dangerous to children and the vaccine isn’t that great.
Unfortunately, these doctors continue to spread truly bizarre ideas in major newspapers and public forums.
    • One doctor suggested that children who wear masks “can develop a mouth deformity and elongated face.”  You can guess what the author thought about masks, even as the Delta variant is causing significant illness in children and shutting down schools everywhere.
    • Another doctor thought the evidence-free claim that kids hospitalized with COVID-19 might really have RSV was a “super-interesting observation.”  This “observation” is basically saying that the dire numbers and reports of frontline pediatricians can’t be trusted- COVID-19 isn’t really so bad after all.  On a day when an average of 330 Americans were dying of COVID-19 and the trend was only going up, he tweeted “Crises?” with a graph showing that deaths are much lower than this winter.  It is surprising that a doctor would ask whether hundreds of Americans dying a preventable death every day was a crisis, especially since he chastised those who called vaccine-myocarditis “mild.”
    • Another doctor, who in June thought “that the US should suspend all vaccination in children under 18” due to vaccine-induced myocarditis, responded to the surge in pediatric hospitalizations by essentially trolling the American Academy of Pediatrics on Twitter for attempting to reassure parents that masks are safe.  As pediatricians face harassments and threats for suggesting masks, he actually said, “there is no organization left in America that actually seeks to defend the interests of children.”  He also said that institutions are failing American children because “many people hate Donald J Trump more than they love American children.”  His own “plan” to protect children was that once “all adults are vaccinated their (children’s) risk of covid will decline precipitously.”  When indeed cases fell earlier this year, this doctor accurately noted that “cases are FALLING PRECIPITOUSLY.”  However, I have not seen him call much attention to the rise pediatric cases and hospitalizations to record levels.
    • Another doctor said at the end of June that “children are not more susceptible to the delta variant, they’re threefold less likely to get any infection with any variant with any ancestral strain, and they’re half as likely to spread it.”  The opposite of this is true, of course, and the Delta variant is affecting children more than ever before.  She added,
It’s been a hard time, and people should have their summer. Delta variant, delta shmariant.”
You read that right, “Delta variant, delta shmariant.”
Reader beware
In my opinion, the egregiousness of these doctors’ errors, omissions, and statements mocking both the seriousness of the virus and organizations such as the American Academy of Pediatrics is not categorically different than the distortions of Mr. Ji, who truncated the title of an article to distort its findings.  As with Mr. Ji, these doctors have made no obvious effort to correct their mistakes or fill in their omissions, even as the Delta variant causes increased harms to children.
Although they don’t treat children with COVID-19, they continue to have large platforms on TV, podcasts, YouTube, newspapers, and social media where they influence both public opinion and public policy.   The have stellar academic credentials, speak with complete confidence, and unless you dig a little further, everything they say sounds very plausible.  They are not obvious frauds, like Mr. Ji, who doesn’t even believe viruses make people sick.  Certainly they are very hopeful, and hope makes us all feel better.
As a result of all this, these doctors are trusted and amplified by many influential people.  Anti-vaxx propagandist Tucker Carlson repeated the false claim that no healthy American child has died of COVID-19 to millions of his viewers. Prominent politicians have made awful policy decisions based on the advice of Stanford doctors, and these politicians have parroted myths (here and here) they learned from doctors.   A false claim that started on Twitter, with a doctor “just asking questions” about whether children with COVID-19 really have RSV, has the potential to influence policy for millions of children a few days later.  Of course, these false claims always minimize the dangers of the virus to children and so children are paying the price.
I am unsure of the process by which these doctors made these errors and omissions.  I believe in the principle of charity and believe there was no ill intent.   These doctors are not supplement-selling grifters like Dr. Joe Mercola.  Only one of them is selling anything, namely his books.  I’ve written books too, and I highly recommend one of his books.  I am sure they are excellent doctors in their respective specialties.  They all have strongly encouraged adults to get vaccinated.  They all want what’s best for children, and care deeply about the real harms of school closures and social isolation (which would improve if more teens were vaccinated), as well as the tragedy of global vaccine inequity.
One of them wrote an essay (with only blue-circle facts) titled “Kids don’t need Covid-19 vaccines to return to school” in February.  In it he said, “The Covid-19 pandemic has harmed children — not because they have fallen ill from the virus, for the most part, but by the choices societies have made to protect adults who are vastly more likely to suffer from the disease.”  I am sure he sincerely believes this is still true today, and the harms of school closures should not be glossed over.  I’ve seen the harm in my own family.  I have a real shy kid who had just made a few good friends when school shut down.  They’ve only seen each other a few times since.
Moreover, it’s impossible to get everything right in the middle of a pandemic that seems to constantly shift in unpredictable ways. We are only human with biases and blind spots.  I’ve caught errors in my articles only moments before a piece was published.  I will make a mistake in one of these articles one day.  I hope that you’ll assume I just goofed and that I wasn’t trying to mislead anyone.  And please, if you spot an error or significant omission, tell me so I can issue a correction.  I don’t want wrong or incomplete information being spread under my name.  It matters how people react when others disagree with them.  It’s not easy, but I try to follow the wisdom of Ralph Waldo Emerson who said, “Let me never fall into the vulgar mistake of dreaming that I am persecuted whenever I am contradicted.”
Though I am assuming good intent, I realize that I must approach a much wider set of writers with the skepticism that I formerly applied only to anti-vaxxers.  I’m not saying these doctors are anti-vaxxers.  I’m just saying they need to be fact-checked as if they were.

“We’re Pro-Vaccine But”
Can you tell the difference between statements made by contrarian doctors and those made by anti-vaccine cranks like Dr. Joe Mercola and RFK Jr.? Find out for yourself.
Jonathan Howard on February 20, 2022
Link

In a previous essay, I discussed what it means to be pro-vaccine by saying “being pro-vaccine means taking into account all of the relevant data to make a fair, accurate risk-benefit calculation about a vaccine”. I also discussed what it means to be anti-vaccine by saying:
Obviously there is no clear-cut criteria for who is anti-vaccine, and there is a very wide spectrum of beliefs in the anti-vaccine movement. Some people proudly announce they are anti-vaxxers, while other notorious spreaders of anti-vaccine misinformation, including Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., adamantly reject this label. To me, the core that unites anti-vaccine thought is: 1) inappropriate minimization of the risk of the virus, and 2) inappropriate minimization of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine.
With this in mind, I thought a quiz might be in order. Below are 200 quotes about COVID-19, vaccines, and children. About half are taken from leading anti-vaccine cranks such as RFK Jr. and Dr. Joseph Mercola. The rest come from contrarian doctors who would bristle at any suggestion that they are anything other than pro-vaccine.
Can you tell who said what?
There are a few ground rules. First, I removed links in the quotes themselves and occasionally added my own links within the quotes to refute the misinformation contained within. Second, I used images to correct some blatant factual errors or provided relevant updates. Finally, since they support his overall message, several articles by contrarian doctors have been featured on RFK Jr.’s website. So pay attention to the author when you click on the links.
Most importantly, I urge you to also read these quotes in their full context. For example, consider this statement: “The vast majority of kids with COVID-19 will be fine. A child who contracts COVID-19 has an extremely low risk of dying.” Not only do I completely agree with this, I wrote it, and I’ve said as much in every article I’ve written on this topic. Yet, it is indistinguishable from this Quote from RFK Jr.’s site, “Children’s risk of developing serious COVID illness is minuscule”.`
However, there’s an essential difference. I’ve been clear in my articles that while the risk to any individual child is very low, COVID-19’s overall impact on children has been significant. I’ve enumerated how the virus has gravely harmed a large number of children and said,
It may be true that any individual child’s risk of dying of COVID-19 is “practically zero”, but there’s a world of difference between “practically zero” and actually zero when tens of millions of children get infected.
According to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, 1,300 children have died. To me, that’s a tragically large number of deceased children. Many thousands more children have been hospitalized, some needing ICU-level care and mechanical ventilation. There have been at least 6,851 cases of MIS-C and 59 children have died from this. I also share robust evidence the vaccine is extremely effective at preventing rare, but catastrophic outcomes in children. I try to make my articles nuanced and informative.  And as I’ll do in this essay, I’ll share information about some of the individual children who died.  It’s important that we view them as individuals who were robbed on their entire life, not just numbers on a CDC website.
All this stands in marked contrast to the articles (or tweets) from which I took the quotes below. The information in these articles may be accurate, however it is always incomplete. Any information that disconfirms the author’s viewpoint is purposefully omitted to advance a grossly distorted narrative. The authors of the quotes below never share the basic numbers about how COVID has harmed children, as I just did. The multiple studies showing vaccines help keep children alive and out of the hospital are similarly unmentionable. These writers don’t take “into account all of the relevant data to make a fair, accurate risk-benefit calculation”.
For example, in the quotes below you’ll see references to a study from Germany that found no healthy children 5 and under died of COVID-19. However, the writers who share this study neglect to mention that it concluded in May 2021, before the Delta or Omicron variants, and that studies from the US found that about 20% of fatalities in young people occur in healthy individuals. The German study is a fine study, it just doesn’t tell the whole story. Similarly, there are many positive references to several Scandinavian countries that are not vaccinating all children, without reference to the fact that they are the outliers. Almost all countries with abundant vaccine supply are vaccinating children.
Additionally, there will be claims that over 100% of American children have had COVID-19, and claims that 1,300 COVID-19 deaths is the same as 6 flu deaths. There will be misinformation about the variants. And there will be a lot of quotes about vaccine side effects.
Overall, these quotes reflect several central themes of many doctors this pandemic. These are:
    • The virus is benign or even beneficial for children
    • The vaccine is dangerous
    • Anyone who tells you otherwise can’t be trusted/I’m the real victim here
Crucially, none of the individuals of the quoted below (with one exception) unequivocally say, “Parents should absolutely vaccinate their children against COVID-19”. Despite this, many individuals quoted below still claim to be pro-vaccine. Since I am pro-vaccine, I absolutely feel parents should vaccinate their children against COVID-19. At this point, I see no clear difference between someone who denies the importance of the MMR or polio vaccine and someone who denies the importance of the COVID-19 vaccine for children.
Ready to test yourself? Let me know how many you get right.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: Relax, not that many kids die
Quote: As of May 29, 2021, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) attributed 366 deaths in children aged 0-18 to COVID out of a child population of 74 million—a mortality rate of 0.00049%.
Quote: I don’t think if there’s any good reason to vaccinate kids that young, they face a vanishingly small risk from COVID itself, near zero from mortality from COVID.
Quote: Let’s say they’re healthy. People might appropriately say, “Hey, the risk of death is infinitesimally small. Do I really need to do this?” Legitimate question. It’s not necessarily to save their life with a vaccine.
Quote: Children ages 5 to 11 are at extremely low risk of death from coronavirus. For instance, in a meta-analysis combining data from five studies, Stanford researchers Cathrine Axfors and John Ioannidis found a median infection fatality rate (IFR) of 0.0027% in children ages 0-19. In children ages 5 to 11, the IFR is even lower.
Quote: An excess of 12,000 deaths sounds bad, but Professor Don Boudreaux, from George Mason University, has noted that there are nearly 88 million people in this age group.
Quote: CDC data indicate deaths among children make up a fraction of a percentage of those who have died from COVID.
Quote: Young adults and children have a miniscule risk of hospitalization. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, children comprised only 0.00%-0.23% of all COVID-19 deaths, and eight states reported zero child deaths.
Quote: No child in the trial died or required hospitalization from COVID. Without any clinical outcomes of significance, no meaningful calculation of vaccine efficacy can be made. These results should have ended any consideration of granting Pfizer authorization of its product in this age group. Pfizer’s trial essentially proved the drugmaker’s COVID vaccine, when appropriately dosed and tested against placebo in a randomized study of young children, would reduce the risk of developing common cold symptoms by approximately 2%.
Quote: Informed doctors argue that “not even a handful of children should be endangered through mass vaccination against a disease that is not dangerous to them.”
Quote: I think we’re doing this once again to children by vaccinating them without knowing what the safety is. We are asking children to accept the vaccine, to get immunized, to protect the adults. That isn’t necessary. Children just very rarely get sick.
Quote: For this vaccine, it doesn’t make sense to me why I should vaccinate my children, when the risks are so low to them. And it doesn’t actually help with reducing the risk of disease for rest of the population.
Quote: For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%.
Quote: For younger adults and children, it is a different story, as their mortality risk is extremely low. Even a slight risk of a serious vaccine adverse reaction could tip the benefit-risk calculation, making the vaccine more harmful than beneficial. We have already observed rare problems with blood clots (J&J vaccine) and myocarditis (inflammation of the heart muscle, Pfizer and Moderna) in younger people, and additional equally serious issues might still be found.
Quote: One could vaccinate every child age 5 to 11 in the U.S. and not prevent a single hospitalization, ICU admission, or death from coronavirus — according to Pfizer’s own clinical trial data as submitted to the FDA.
Quote: For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk is completely negligible…it seems that these deaths are extremely exceptional.
Quote: There are 104 children age 0-17 who died from COVID-19 and 287 from COVID + Influenza – out of ~72 million. This equals zero risk. And we doctors won’t stand for children being offered something they do not need and of whom some unknown percentage will suffer.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: Relax, it’s just sick kids who die
Quote: We have always known that it’s very hard for the virus to hurt someone who is young and healthy.
Quote: We have since learned that 99.997% of young people ages 0-19 survive COVID-19 (with most experiencing either mild symptoms or no symptoms at all). But that does not seem to matter. Nor does a January 2021 study, which confirmed that it is only in a minuscule subset of children — mostly kids with serious underlying medical conditions — that the illness occasionally takes a turn for the worse.
Quote: A large study conducted in Germany showed zero deaths for children under 5 and a case fatality rate of three out of a million in children without comorbidities.
Quote: A study from Germany found that among healthy, unvaccinated children aged 5–11 who became infected with the disease, just 8 in 100,000 ended up in the ICU and none died.
Quote: Our report found a mortality rate of zero among children w/o a pre-existing medical condition such as leukemia.
Quote: Children have a 99.995% recovery rate, and a body of medical literature indicates that almost zero healthy children under five years old have died from COVID.
Quote: Johns Hopkins study monitoring 48,000 children diagnosed with COVID showed a zero mortality rate in children under 18 without comorbidities.
Quote: The COVID-19 death risk is clustered among kids with a comorbid condition, like obesity. Of the more than 330 COVID-19 deaths in kids under age 25, there’s good preliminary data suggesting that most or nearly all appear to be in kids with a pre-existing condition.
Quote: The Germany study shows that risks to healthy kids are very low. It also shows the massive efforts that try to distort risk.
Quote: In reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date.
Quote: A study in Nature demonstrated that children under 18 with no comorbidities have virtually no risk of death.
Quote: There’s never been a documented case of an entirely healthy kid dying of COVID.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: We shouldn’t try to prevent pediatric COVID-19 deaths because older people die more and other things kill more kids
Quote: So that’s of 100,000 kids infected maybe 2 would pass away. And to put that in perspective, when you talk about people who are 80, it’s 7,500 times as much.
Quote: The image below, put out by the CDC one year into the pandemic, shows that an 88-year-old has 8,700 times the risk of death of an 8-year-old.
Quote: While the death of any child is a tragedy, Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course, including drowning, vehicle accidents, and even cardiovascular disease.
Quote: To put that in perspective, in that same age group during non-Covid times, the risk of suicide is 10 times higher. For young adults ages 15 to 24, the risk of dying from Covid19 was 9.9 in 1,000,000, and they are also generally 10 times more likely to commit suicide.
Quote: As a cause of death for children aged 1-17, COVID-19 ranks behind injury, suicide, cancer, homicide, congenital anomalies, heart disease, influenza, chronic lower respiratory disease and cerebrovascular causes.
Quote: While anyone can get infected, there is more than a thousand-fold difference in mortality risk between the old and the young…It will take a few years until we know the Covid vaccine risk profile, and until then, we do not know whether there is more benefit or harm in vaccinating children.
Quote: These data are as real as it gets: Vaccinated 40-year-olds have higher population risks than unvaccinated kids under the age of 18 for COVID-19. You would not know that from the breathless, innumerate U.S. media landscape, but once you know it you might feel differently about risk.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: Variants, shmariants
Quote: Variants, shmariants.
Quote: We’ve done far too much damage to a generation of children over infinitesimally small risks. Unwarranted fear of variants cannot be used as an excuse to continue propagating this harm.
Quote: Younger people who get the Delta variant don’t get sick that need to be in the hospital.
Quote: Children are not more susceptible to the delta variant, they’re threefold less likely to get any infection with any variant with any ancestral strain.
Quote: Omicron infection may be nature’s vaccine.
Quote: Dr. Rochelle Walensky, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), stated earlier in January there is no evidence that the Omicron variant causes more severe illness in children, when compared to earlier strains of the virus, raising questions about the need to vaccinate young children.
Quote: In the context of the Omicron variant, which is associated with less severe disease and lower hospitalization rates, the benefit-risk ratio of COVID-19 vaccination for children 5-11 years of age becomes even harder to justify.
Quote: The risk-benefit ratio of the COVID shot is becoming even more inverted with the emergence of Omicron, as this variant produces far milder illness than previous variants, putting children at even lower risk of hospitalization or death from infection than they were before, and their risk was already negligible.
Quote: Even children for whom vaccination is not yet an option are at lower risk now than they were last summer: the Omicron variant resulted in 66% fewer hospitalizations than Delta in a study of children younger than 5 years.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: “Natural” immunity
Quote: An FDA senior advisor for risk-benefit assessment admitted that should natural immunity be equal to vaccine-induced immunity, then that would result in a 45% reduction of all the benefits in the FDA’s risk-benefit analyses.
Quote: Last week, the CDC released a large study demonstrating that natural immunity is superior to vaccinated immunity.
Quote: For these millions of children, the risks of COVID-19 vaccination outweigh the benefits, as studies show natural immunity is superior to vaccine-induced immunity.
Quote: Recovered COVID patients have strong long-lasting protection against severe disease if reinfected, and evidence about protective immunity after natural infection is at least as good as from the vaccines. Hence, it makes no sense to require vaccines for recovered patients.
Quote: Requiring the vaccine in people who are already immune with natural immunity has no scientific support.
Quote: The FDA’s risk-benefit assessment failed to account for the large proportion of children in the United States who already had COVID-19, recovered from it and now have natural immunity.
Quote: Don’t ignore scientific facts just because they don’t fit a policy imperative. For example, for most people, a Covid-19 infection results in a substantial immune response—what’s called “natural immunity.” But our officials, because of their singular focus on vaccines, have essentially ignored this basic fact, pretending natural immunity doesn’t exist.
Quote: Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
Quote: Many lives are being destroyed by the government’s failure to recognize natural immunity.
Quote: By ignoring the reality of natural immunity in favor of their desired policy of triple vaccination, our officials are not making us safer. They are undermining the trust that is essential between the experts and the public.
Quote: When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: Children should get sick to avoid getting sick and they don’t spread the disease
Quote: School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease.
Quote: Yes, diseases will continue to circulate, as they always have done. Schools are not sterile, nor should they be. Immunity is built through illness.
Quote: The need to let young people interact with each other, both for social reasons and for herd immunity, makes perfectly good common sense. I think there should have been more of that.
Quote: Not only are children at high risk for severe adverse events from the shots, but having healthy, unvaccinated children in the population is crucial to achieving herd immunity.
Quote: This view is shared by the authors of a May 2021 paper in The British Journal of Medicine, who wrote: “Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood… This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.”
Quote: When children do get the disease, they’ll likely have lifelong immunity.
Quote: It’s time to allow children to resume normal life, not simply because their exclusion is unfair or hurts them socially and psychologically, but because it is immunologically in their best interest.
Quote: With Covid, the nadir of risk is between 5–11 years old — an age where children develop more robust and durable immunity from infection than adults, even with asymptomatic silent infections.
Quote: The epidemiologist and researcher Francois Balloux puts it this way: “I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.” This idea is not as frightening as it may sound.
Quote: It has become common to criticize restrictions for children on the grounds that they harm mental health and social development. These concerns are valid, but it is important to emphasize that a more laissez-faire approach to kids and Covid makes public health sense, too. Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.
Quote: Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future.
Quote: It is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger.
Quote: These measures are premised on the idea that America’s children must be shielded from exposure to Covid-19. What kids really need, however, is a return to normal.
Quote: COVID-19 policies have disproportionately affected children — viewing children primarily as vectors of disease rather than as highly valued and vulnerable members of our society to be nurtured and cherished.
Quote: Multiple studies attribute this to a stronger innate immune response in the upper respiratory tract that prevents viral replication early on. This may explain why children are also far less likely to contribute to disease transmission.
Quote: But remember, COVID is a disease that’s passed from adults to adults. This is not a disease that spread to a large extent by children to adults.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: Impossible numbers
Quote: The (vaccine’s) benefits (at best) are going to be very small — what is lower than 3 per million? — so even rare safety signals can tip the scale.
Quote: In addition, the risk of death or other bad outcomes is low for children. Between March and October of 2020, among those between the ages of five and 14, the risk of dying of Covid-19 in the United States was 1 in 1,000,000.
Quote: Children and young adults are very low risk for severe disease, about one in a million chance of death for a child under 19 from COVID.
Quote: Kids can get covid-19 and kids can die from covid-19. But it’s extremely rare How rare? 1 in a million for kids <15 To put this in context, school-age kids are 10x more likely to die by suicide than covid-19
Quote: The FDA’s risk-benefit analysis estimated that fully vaccinating 1 million children ages 5-11 would prevent one COVID-19 death.
Quote: About one in a million kids passed away from SARS-CoV-2. Now, that’s an unfortunate end point, but to put it in perspective in that same age group the risk of suicide in non-COVID times is typically 10 times higher. So yes, kids are not invincible from it, but realistically their chance of dying from SARS-CoV-2 is not out of the ballpark with other respiratory viruses in that age group.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: COVID-19 (1,300 deaths in two years) is the same as the flu (6 deaths in two years)
Quote: Depending on the study one looks at, COVID is slightly less dangerous or roughly equivalent to the flu in children.
Quote: Very few healthy, young children died from this virus, more died from the flu last year.
Quote: The risk to children is greater from influenza than #COVID19
Quote: Schools are major transmission points for influenza, but not for COVID. While children do get infected, their risk for COVID death is minuscule, lower than their already low risk of dying from the flu.
Quote: For the unvaccinated child, COVID presents a health risk to children that is on par with the flu.
Quote: Their (children’s) Covid mortality risk is miniscule and less than the already low risk from the annual influenza, so the vaccine benefit for healthy children is very small.
Quote: It is generally not controversial to argue that SARS-CoV-2 in kids is roughly, roughly the same as influenza, maybe even less severe than influenza, seasonal influenza in kids.
Quote: First, children are at extremely low risk of severe COVID-19. Even before the emergence of omicron, which is considerably more mild than earlier strains, the virus was less deadly to children than flu and pneumonia, heart disease, car crashes or guns.
Quote: COVID is on par with Flu in terms of risk to kids.
Quote: COVID-19 is less of a threat to children than accidents or the common flu. The survival rate among American children with confirmed cases is approximately 99.99%; remarkably, recent studies find an even higher survival rate.
The virus is benign or beneficial for children: But Sweden, Norway, and Denmark
Quote: It is easy to understand why Sweden decided against recommending COVID-19 vaccines for children 5-11 years old. Arguing that the benefits did not outweigh the risks, a Swedish Health Agency official stated: “With the knowledge we have today, with a low risk for serious disease for kids, we don’t see any clear benefit with vaccinating them.”
Quote: In fact, Norwegian authorities believe that natural infection will better protect children than vaccines that rely on out-of-date variants of the virus.
Quote: Norway opted to make COVID vaccines optional for children aged 5-11.
Quote: According to the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, “the risk of a severe disease course at this age is small, and the need for vaccines for children and adolescents is limited”.
Quote: The Norwegian Institute of Public Health stated the risk of severe illness in children that is brought on by COVID is small, and that as a result, the need for children to receive a COVID vaccine is limited. Norway’s announcement, in turn, prompted the Danish Pediatric Society to request that Denmark’s Health Authority revisit its decision to recommend COVID-19 vaccination for children in Denmark.
The vaccine is dangerous: General fear mongering
Quote: So let’s say to save that one life, you gotta inoculate a million kids with vaccination to save one life. And you’re talking about maybe 14,000 kids suffering grade three fevers, and maybe 880 suffering grade four fevers, which is more than one day. And I guess when you add in the myalgia, when you add in the arthralgia, when you add in the sort of headache, the fogginess, all these things, I mean.
Quote: Before we give an intervention (the vaccine) to a kid who has almost no risk, I think we should use the precautionary principle.
Quote: The Pfizer mRNA shot fails any honest risk-benefit analysis in children ages 5 to 11.
Quote: My greatest concern with the vaccination of children under the age of 18 is the fact that there is no prior study of these individuals before Dec. of 2020.
Quote: At the same time, they haven’t really tested the vaccine on enough children to know that with any confidence with the adverse – serious adverse event rate is anything more than zero. And you say you wouldn’t the balanced this doesn’t work. Why would I vaccinate my kid against something but disease for whom but it’s not actually all that deadly? Where there’s might be some serious adverse events, I think that it is a mistake to think about this, as good for kids. It’s not good for kids.
Quote: Not only is this injection medically unnecessary for this younger age group, but there are clear signals coming from U.S. government sources that the risk to human health is real, and that adverse events to this vaccine are not rare.
Quote: Imagine you do this to hundreds of thousands of children. Just by sheer happenstance, you’re gonna have a certain number of complications, just in terms of febrile complications.
Quote: By Pfizer’s own admission, there were zero hospitalizations, ICU admissions, or deaths in the treatment or control group in their study of 2,300 children ages 5 to 11.
Quote: With a recovery rate of 99.997%, children are not at great risk of serious health consequences from COVID-19 infections — but they are at significant risk of adverse events from the vaccine.
Quote: The CDC reports that children are less likely to develop severe illness or die from Covid-19 and are more likely to be asymptomatic or show mild systems. And there are lower rates of infection among children compared with adults. (We) demand that CDC provide the reasoning behind these perplexing recommendations. Why would a vaccine be recommended that perhaps carries more risk to children’s health than the actual disease, and which has no long term safety data to support its use?
The vaccine is dangerous: Did you know the vaccine causes myocarditis and myocarditis and myocarditis and myocarditis and myocarditis and myocarditis?
Quote: In early September 2021, Tracy Beth Hoeg and colleagues posted an analysis of VAERS data on the preprint server medRxiv, showing that more than 86% of the children aged 12 to 17 who report symptoms of myocarditis were severe enough to require hospitalization.
Quote: Sorry to break it to you, vaccines can have risks of myocarditis EXCEEDING risks of myocarditis from infection.
Quote: Moreover, the FDA’s risk-benefit assessment did not account for a potentially necessary booster dose after five months. Each booster dose would carry an additional risk of myocarditis, along with the risk of other vaccine adverse events.
Quote: In total, that’s 1,475 cases of myocarditis in teens aged 18 and younger — five times the background rate. And again, this does not take into account the underreporting rate, which has been calculated to be anywhere from five to 40.
Quote: By adjusting for natural immunity (with a 42% reduction of vaccine benefits), 39 ICU stays are prevented by vaccination, but at the risk of 57 vaccine-related myopericarditis ICU stays. Additionally, while 118 hospitalizations are prevented by vaccination, this is at the risk of 156 vaccine-related myopericarditis hospitalizations, for 5-11-year-old boys and girls.
Quote: If myocarditis occurs in boys ages 5-11 at the same rate as in boys 12-15, a study of this size would not be able to document that. We are flying blind on a side effect that parents need to be informed about.
Quote: Using the FDA’s risk-benefit analysis (shown above) and conservatively adjusting for 42% of children having already acquired natural immunity through prior COVID-19 infection, the risk of hospitalization from vaccine-related heart inflammation in 5 to 11 year-old boys is greater than the number of COVID-19 hospitalizations prevented by vaccination.
Quote: So, is it actually true that “For adolescents and young adults, the risk of myocarditis caused by COVID infection is much higher than after mRNA vaccination.”? I doubt it.
Quote: It is clear that the second dose brings WAY more hospitalizations from myocarditis than can possibly be prevented.
Quote: I don’t think people realize the damage continuing to push two doses in young men will do.
Quote: How is this possibly an acceptable tradeoff for a virus you have practically zero risk of dying from as a child or adolescent?
Quote: Note that more than 95% of myocarditis cases detected by the CDC resulted in hospitalization; it seems very likely that 2nd doses of mRNA vaccines will cause more hospitalizations than they will prevent in 12–17 year old boys.
Quote: In summary, based on CDC statistics, we could expect just over two teens to contract myocarditis from COVID-19 infection. Meanwhile, we have 1,475 cases reported following the COVID jab in just six months (shots for 12- to 17-year-olds were authorized July 30, 2021).
Quote: The risk is also dose-dependent, with boys having a sixfold greater risk of myocarditis following the second dose. While our health authorities are shrugging off this risk saying cases are “mild,” that’s a frightening lie. The damage to the heart is typically permanent.
Quote: While the CDC says that myocarditis is a mild disease, cardiologists know otherwise. CDC’s own preliminary data, reported at the February 4 ACIP meeting, revealed that nearly half of the young people diagnosed with myocarditis still had symptoms 3 months later, and 39% had their activity restricted by their physician. We know this serious adverse event frequently occurs in teenagers. But no one knows how often it occurs in younger children. This is of major concern for babies and younger children.
Quote: No one says “vaccine induced myocarditis is mostly mild” like someone who just saw a graph that 20% of people 37 weeks later have not fully recovered.
Quote: Prior to the EUA expansion to 12-15 year-olds, the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) showed two deaths in 15-year-olds who had each received a Pfizer or Moderna vaccine. These adolescents may have been enrolled in clinical trials, as they could not otherwise have received the vaccines legally at the time. With about 1,000 adolescents 12-15 years old in Pfizer’s clinical trial vaccine group—and about the same number in Moderna’s trial—the death rate following either vaccination in this age group may be approximately 0.1% (two in 2,000)—over 200 times higher than the COVID-19 mortality rate.
Quote: With potentially deadly side effects including myocarditis and pericarditis disproportionately impacting youth it is reasonable to think that over time, the rate of fatal side effects from mRNA shots in children ages 5 to 11 might be similar to those in ages 12 to 24.
Quote: I wish the CDC would tell us more about the deaths of Simone Scott, 19, and Jacob Clynick, 13, both of whom died shortly after getting a second vaccine dose and developed heart inflammation. There have been 19 other deaths in youth under age 25, according to the CDC.
Quote: In the meantime, the mortality rate of vaccine-associated myocarditis cases remains uncertain. Under questioning during the meeting, Matthew Oster reported that for myocarditis unrelated to COVID-19 or COVID-19 vaccines, mortality rates are estimated in the range of 4%–9% in the literature. Fortunately, it seems likely that the rate is not so high for vaccine or COVID-19 associated myocarditis. But the rate is likely not zero, and the CDC is already investigating one possible death associated with a 2nd dose of Pfizer vaccine in a 13 year old, over a time period where no deaths would be expected to be avoided from 2nd doses of mRNA vaccines in this age group.
Quote: Maybe the rate of death from the vaccine parallels the rate of death from COVID in a healthy child.
Quote: Subjecting healthy children and babies to this vaccine poses a much greater risk through potential severe adverse reactions and even death.
Quote: Based on the data of kids w/ NO comorbid, an estimated 0-10 kids 5-11 have ever died of Covid VS. Approx 15 would die from the vax 2nd dose (extrap from adolescents).
Quote: If you inject that many children, you certainly will have lots and lots of serious side effects, including disability and death.
The vaccine is dangerous: The Emergency Use Authorization should not have been issued and childhood vaccination should stop
Quote: Children incur almost no risk from virus. Has the safety signal from JNJ & AZ given you no pause? #WeNeedFarMoreSafetyData for kids.
Quote: COVID-19 rates in children ages 5 to 11 are so low that there were ZERO cases of severe COVID-19 and ZERO cases of death from COVID in either the treatment (n= 1,518) or control group (n= 750). So any claims you see in the press about the Pfizer vaccine being “90% effective” in children are meaningless because they are referring to mild cases from which children usually recover quickly (and then have robust broad spectrum immunity). So there is literally no emergency in this population for which one could apply for Emergency Use Authorization.
Quote: Unlike for adults, however, the likelihood of severe outcomes or death associated with COVID-19 infection is very low for children, undermining the appropriateness of an EUA for child COVID-19 vaccines.
Quote: What we do know is that there is no public health emergency for this age group. Children are at extremely low risk of serious outcomes from COVID.
Quote: No further expansion of the EUAs to children under the age of 16 be granted.
Quote: If an EUA is granted, Pfizer’s pediatric vaccine will be available to nearly 20 million children under the age of five, many of whom already have robust natural immunity.
Quote: Mandating the COVID-19 vaccine thus threatens not only public health but also the future of science.
Quote: As the FDA plainly states in its COVID vaccine fact sheets, vaccines administered under EUA status are not FDA-approved and have “not undergone the same type of review as an FDA-approved or cleared product.”
Quote: We insist that the EUA not be relinquished prematurely; certainly not before trials are complete
Quote: The rarity of severe COVID-19 outcomes for children means that trials cannot demonstrate that the balance of the benefits of vaccination against the potential adverse effects are favorable to the children themselves. In short, given the rarity of severe clinical courses and limited clarity of risks, the criteria for Emergency Use Authorization do not appear to be met for children.
Quote: The EUAs should never have been granted, the EUAs should be revoked immediately.
Quote: An EUA might not be appropriate for a childhood vaccine given that the risk to kids is so low.
Quote: (I call) for health agencies to immediately halt the administration of COVID-19 vaccines to minors, whether in clinical trials or under Emergency Use Authorization.
Quote: I would also vote to suspend mRNA vaccination <18, as in line with the United Kingdom.
Quote: We could learn how safe this vaccine is if he and his fellow advisory panel members demanded that a properly powered and designed trial were conducted prior to deploying the vaccine to tens of millions of children. In any case, we have started giving it. When will we learn how safe this vaccine is? More importantly, what should we do in the meantime? Pause childhood vaccinations until data can be collected and deaths investigated? Or carry on while testing it on infants 6 months of age and older?
Quote: In other words, from a risk/benefit perspective it is more logical to… halt childhood vaccinations immediately.
“They” can’t be trusted: Pfizer, the CDC, the FDA and I’m the real victim here
Quote: Is this what we’ve come to, pharma tells us what to do and the CDC just falls in line?
Quote: Reporting only relative risk, Pfizer declared its injection “100% effective” for 12- to 15-year-olds on the basis of trials with 2,260 younger adolescents and 18 cases of COVID-19 in the placebo group (versus zero in the vaccine group). These numbers equate to a “teensy-tiny” reduction in absolute risk.
Quote: After a “positive” trial in which just over 1100 kids aged 12 to 15 years received an mRNA vaccine, a movement arose to vaccinate young and old alike. I put “positive” in quotes for two reasons: The first is that this trial measured noninferiority of the immune response, not clinical outcomes. That was necessary because so few kids get sick with COVID-19. The other reason is that the authors claimed a favorable safety profile, but 1100 kids is not enough to inform the safety of a vaccine that will be given to many millions.
Quote: Pfizer learned its lesson with the adult trial, so when the drugmaker conducted a trial of its mRNA vaccine in children ages 5 to 11 it intentionally made it too small (only 2,300 participants) and too short (only followed up for 2 months) in order to hide harms.
Quote: The US FDA must halt use of Moderna in Men <40, as other nations have. Just like they dragged their feet with J&J and VITT (vaccine induced thrombocytopic thrombosis), they drag their feet here, and people needlessly suffer due to their inaction.
Quote: The FDA is making a huge regulatory gamble with boosters, and they are cheered on by many who are not adept at data analysis. Boosting 16-40 yo men might not be in their best interest (it might be net detrimental).
Quote: It appears Pfizer was not even trying to conduct a responsible clinical trial of its mRNA shot in kids ages 5 to 11. Pfizer submitted an EUA application to the FDA showing no health benefit in children ages 5 to 11 and the FDA’s Vaccines and Related Biologics Products Advisory Committee approved it anyway.
Quote: The FDA relied upon a critically flawed risk-benefit assessment to justify EUA of Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine for children 5-11 years of age.
Quote: Despite the importance and gravity of the topic, and the high level at which this discussion was taking place, the presentation given to the committee (Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices) for the purpose of weighing those harms and benefits was fundamentally flawed…misleading statements and data can be found throughout the slidedeck.
Quote: A new study from Germany showed extremely few deaths among healthy children overall — including zero deaths among children 5 to 11 — suggesting some studies are designed to distort the risk to kids.
Quote: Pfizer and BioNTech are evaluating a third dose because they have not yet found the right dose to maximize the risk-benefit profile for our youngest vaccine recipients. And they won’t know if three doses will work until after the first two doses are approved. This is concerning. These are our babies.
Quote: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has chosen not to report on deaths by vaccination status in this age group. We are in the same predicament that Pfizer’s severely flawed and underpowered pediatric trial left us in. With fewer than 2,200 children involved and only 1,450 receiving the vaccine, the trial did not answer any questions about safety or efficacy.
Quote: The presentation (by the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices) contains much flawed analysis and misleading framings of data.
Quote: Are you certain that the federal agencies tasked with this appraisal — the same agencies that have made colossal errors — are not making errors here?
Quote: Pfizer’s claim of 90.7% vaccine efficacy in this age group is based on a total of 19 children (three in a group of 1,450 vaccinated and 16 in a group of 736 placebo recipients) who developed mild symptoms during the brief trial. No child in the trial died or required hospitalization from COVID. Without any clinical outcomes of significance, no meaningful calculation of vaccine efficacy can be made.
Quote: The Pfizer vaccine fails any honest risk-benefit assessment in connection with its use in children ages 5 to 11. The FDA’s risk-benefit analysis of Pfizer’s mRNA vaccine in children ages 5 to 11 is shoddy. It used tortured logic (that would be rejected by any proper academic journal) in order to reach a predetermined result that is not based in science.
Quote: Initial results of the Pfizer trial with children under 5 showed no positive effects from the vaccine. Still, the FDA invited Pfizer to submit the vaccine for approval with the hope that a third booster shot, still untested, would show a benefit.
Quote: Rather than use the weekly average COVID-19 hospitalization rate since the start of the pandemic, the FDA’s risk-benefit assessment used an arbitrary average of the four weeks prior to September 11, 2021, resulting in a COVID-19 hospitalization rate of approximately 0.74 per 100,000 children (which is nearly double the average COVID-19 hospitalization rate of 0.4 per 100,000 children). This further skewed the FDA’s risk-benefit analysis in favor of vaccination.
Quote: In this analysis the harms vs benefits of the 2nd dose appear unfavorable for ages under 25. This is true even though: This analysis segregates by age only, ignoring gender, previous COVID-19 infection or health risk factors. It still uses May hospitalization rates as the baseline expectation for the next 4 months
Quote: Pfizer looked at the level of antibodies in the bloodwork of another study, this one involving people 16 to 25 years old, figured out the level of antibodies that seems to be protective in that population, then figured out how many kids ages 5 to 11 had similar levels of antibodies in their blood, and then came up with a number for how many cases, hospitalizations, ICU admissions, and deaths would be prevented by this shot in the 5 to 11 population in the future, based on the antibody levels and health outcomes from the 16 to 25 year old population. If your head hurts from that tortured logic, it should, because such chicanery is unprecedented in a risk-benefit analysis.
Quote: With the FDA’s audacity on full display to anyone paying attention, the agency instead chose to infer a prevention effect against hospitalization and death based on antibody levels that were suggestive of protection in 16- to 25-year-olds.
Quote: During the pandemic the CDC has developed a track record of promoting flawed studies to support their preconceived policy goals.
Quote: Pediatric hospitalization rates, while used as a marker of COVID-19 disease severity in children, can be inflated by the detection of mild or asymptomatic infection via universal screening.
Quote: According to the CDC’s own analysis, 45% of COVID-19 associated hospitalizations in adolescents reported to COVID-NET (which is the source for hospitalization data in this figure) have primary causes other than COVID-19.
Quote: Even as the CDC is discussing the known cardiac risks and heart inflammation affecting children and young adults following COVID-19 vaccination, a concerted effort is underway to coerce this same group to get the vaccine anyway.
Quote: FDA Commissioner Janet Woodcock, CDC director Rochelle Walensky and Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla have promised youngsters that COVID vaccination is their ticket to a renewed “sense of normalcy” and a “faster return to social activities.”
Quote: After correcting for the FDA’s underestimated myopericarditis rate and adjusting for natural immunity, we find that the risk of hospitalization from vaccine-related myopericarditis is greater than the number of COVID-19 hospitalizations prevented by vaccination.
Quote: Our government leaders made an implicit promise that the vaccination of adults and children would be the conduit by which our society would return to pre-pandemic freedoms.
Quote: Hospitals always run nearly full to maximize their “non-profits.” If they severity of the illness falls, they just admit less sick patients. This means however that using this as a fear monger tactic is inaccurate.
Quote: The Biden Administration, the FDA, and the CDC claim they “follow the science” and yet they violate their own standards and scientific norms in order to exaggerate the benefits and hide the harms from vaccines.
Quote: CDC has been … pushing a series of scientific results that are severely deficient, … uniquely timed to further political goals and objectives; as such, these papers appear more as propaganda than as science.
Quote: Tragically, it’s not only the CDC and FDA that have been captured by the drug industry and who are sacrificing public health, including the health of our children… Even the American Medical Association, which is supposed to lobby for physicians and medical students in the U.S. and promote medicine for the betterment of public health, has abandoned all semblance of ethics, transparency and honesty.
Quote: A tremendous number of government and private policies affecting kids are based on one number: 335. That is how many children under 18 have died with a Covid diagnosis code in their record, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Yet the CDC, which has 21,000 employees, hasn’t researched each death to find out whether Covid caused it or if it involved a pre-existing medical condition. Without these data, the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices decided in May that the benefits of two-dose vaccination outweigh the risks for all kids 12 to 15. I’ve written hundreds of peer-reviewed medical studies, and I can think of no journal editor who would accept the claim that 335 deaths resulted from a virus without data to indicate if the virus was incidental or causal, and without an analysis of relevant risk factors such as obesity.
Quote: Checking asymptomatic kids, the main purpose of it is essentially to close the school, to create a panic and close the school down.
Quote: CDC has repeatedly weaponized science–we need to stand against it, increase public accountability. Our health agencies need radical reform
Quote: Beyond the leaps of logic and apparent disinterest in scientific rigor — why would any medical regulatory body simply assume the same antibody levels in a 5-year-old and 25-year-old will result in the same risk of hospitalization or death from COVID without any evidence? — this unjustified assumption allowed Pfizer and the FDA to avoid taking the appropriate and necessary action: conducting a bigger and longer trial.
Quote: The CDC defines a case as a positive test for COVID-19. It doesn’t define a positive case as a person who’s sick. So, it’s really somewhat misleading.
Quote: The U.S. Food and Drug Administration relied on a critically flawed risk-benefit assessment to authorize emergency use of Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine for children 5-11 years of age.
Quote: VAERS is an underestimate…It’s not a perfect surveillance system. It’s a voluntary reporting surveillance system. And those kinds of surveillance systems are so easy for the doctor who sees a myocarditis to say, “Huh, this can’t be. I’ve never heard of this being linked to a vaccine. Never heard of it.”
Quote: Few doctors or nurses are aware the U.S. Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) even exists, so injury reports are not being filed…Most doctors and nurses don’t even know what VAERS is and even if they do, they chose not to report the incidents.
Quote: While all three authors of the @gbdeclaration faced targeted harassment, @SunetraGupta, one of the bravest people I know, faced the worst of it. That is what happens when the head of the NIH calls a scientist ‘fringe’ and calls for a propaganda war.
Quote: Demonizing people interested in better characterizing vaccine safety signals is not pro-vax; it is pro-ignorance and anti-science.
Quote: We have a modern-day McCarthyism whenever somebody questions COVID booster shots for kids.
Quote: But, what I see more and more, among the ranks of physicians and other professionals, is a growing minority on the other end of the spectrum. These are people who are quick to label legitimate scientific dialog as “anti-vax” or “dangerous misinformation.” In many cases, the speakers have little knowledge of the issues themselves. They couple this condemnation with a strong sense that they are “morally” correct, working to purge the world of dangerous anti-vax thinking. Ironically, they are further polarizing an already polarized debate, and worse, they are simply wrong.
“They” can’t be trusted: Fauci
Quote: Dr. Fauci failed to properly consider and weigh the disastrous effects lockdowns would have.. Americans will live with—and die from—this collateral damage for many years to come.
Quote: The evidence is in. Governors, journalists, scientists, university presidents, hospital administrators and business leaders can continue to follow Dr. Anthony Fauci or open their eyes. After 700,000-plus COVID deaths and the devastating effects of lockdowns, it is time to return to basic principles of public health.
Quote: In 1984, when Fauci was appointed director of NIAID, 11.8% of Americans had chronic disease, but this has risen sharply since. Fauci doesn’t talk about this public health failure — at least not publicly.
Quote: Lab leak: At this point, there is enough evidence to suggest a serious independent investigation into lab leak take place. You cannot conduct such an investigation when the sitting NIAID director is part of the inquiry. Francis Collins has stepped down as NIH director. Fauci should step down as NIAID director to permit others to independently audit grant funding for gain of function research.
Quote: Dr. Anthony Fauci lied to Congress about funding “Gain-of Function” research in Wuhan, China when he insisted that the U.S. “has not ever, and does not now fund gain-of-function research in the Wuhan Institute of Virology.”
Quote: Fresh questions are being raised about what American scientists and federal health officials knew about the origins of the coronavirus and whether conflicting evidence was suppressed and hidden from the public.
Quote: When Fauci panic mongered about the risk to kids from COVID in May 2020, he guaranteed that poor kids in blue states would be denied a real education for nearly a full year and a half.
Quote: Fauci has been painted as a hero throughout the pandemic, an image that is not only misleading but wildly inaccurate.
Quote: Despite having this knowledge, Fauci insisted people, including children, wear masks and that those who had already had COVID be vaccinated.
Quote: The moment he lied, it was over. Even Fauci’s most ardent fans will concede that Fauci lied. He lied about masking, per his own admission. Of course, he claims he did so to protect the mask supply for healthcare workers early in the pandemic. Indeed, if true, that would be a noble lie, and we can all understand why some might forgive him. But surely, we can also understand why many Americans would start to distrust him, as well? A leader in a national crisis has to speak to all Americans and lies make that impossible. An easy solution would be to resign and pass the baton to someone with a fresh reputation.
Quote: Fauci has spread the notion that he is untouchable, going so far as to tell MSNBC that an attack on him is an attack on science: “It’s very dangerous … because a lot of what you’re seeing as attacks on me quite frankly are attacks on science, because all of the things that I have spoken about consistently from the very beginning, have been fundamentally based on science.” Throughout the pandemic, “trusting the science” has become a cultural statement and propaganda tool, but one that’s far from what true science is all about.
Quote: Fauci orchestrated the disastrous American response to the COVID crisis with the U.S. racking up 20% of the world’s COVID deaths despite having only 4.2% of the global population. But, that wasn’t when he lied. The meta-lie is the idea that Fauci was initially deceitful about masking, but later told the truth. That is also a lie. The truth is that Fauci was initially honest about masking, and later, and to this date, lied about the evidence.
We are pro-vaccine but
Quote: I think the discussion we just had about the pediatric vaccine is actually quite pro-vaccine.
Quote: We doctors are pro-vaccine.
Quote: I’m pro-vaccine but…
Quote: We’re pro-vaccine but…

Denis Rancourt and “no virus”: COVID-19 symptoms were due psychological stress from the pandemic response!
Link
David Gorski on March 18, 2024
I’ve written before about how germ theory denial is a constant thread in the antivax movement. As scientifically unjustifiable as it is to claim that pathogenic microbes are not the cause of infectious diseases, you can probably see how it makes a sort of warped sense for antivaxxers to be attracted to such denial, if only for the simple reason that if microbes don’t cause disease then vaccines are obviously unnecessary and can thus only cause harm. Germ theory denial, however, doesn’t just undergird a significant chunk of antivax beliefs; it is a general underlying component behind much of alternative medicine as well—and has been for a long time. There is, however, a rather odd form of germ theory denial that doesn’t actually deny that there are infectious diseases. Rather, it denies the existence of viruses specifically.
“No virus”?
What “inspired” me—if you can call it that—to write this post was yet another common antivax claim, namely that vaccines kill millions of people. I came across this claim when I came across a January Substack post by Denis Rancourt, who was peeved that Tracy Beth Høeg, of all people, had, in an obvious use of a tactic favored by cranks ranging from Joe Mercola to Vinay Prasad to try to claim the mantle of science and “reasonableness” by attacking even more bonkers cranks, taken him to task for his estimate that COVID-19 vaccines had killed 17 million people. That led me to discover that Rancourt also denies that viruses exist in a Substack post by Paul Alexander citing a Substack post by someone named Franklin O’Kanu praising Rancourt for an interview he gave with Steve Kirsch in which Rancourt said:
Anthony Fauci will go down in the Roman Overlord’s Hall of Fame. For the past 30 years, he has convinced the world about the reality of viruses, from HIV to the coronavirus pandemic. He has taken something invisible, something unproven, and convinced the world to not only believe in it but to invest in it, ensuring every citizen received this new petrochemical shot.
In the same interview, Rancourt said:
I’m not convinced that viruses exist.
Rancourt is “not convinced that viruses exist”? That’s nice. I was particularly amused by O’Kanu’s descriptions of Rancourt and Kirsch:
Denis Rancourt a leading figure in the community known for his data-driven research, made a startling announcement during an interview with
Steve Kirsch, another prominent member of the truth movement. Rancourt stated that he could find no evidence to prove the existence of viruses.
This bold statement has sparked intense debate and discussion as I have touched on myself in my article, Lies Not Discussed Within The Truth Community. Even though in the video you see Kirsch’s immediate shift of focus, the implications of Rancourt’s declaration cannot be ignored.
“Data-driven research.” You keep using that term. I do not think it means what you think it means.
For those of a particularly masochistic personality bent, I provide a link to the Rumble interview. Know, however, that it is over two hours long, and even I couldn’t stand to listen to anywhere near the whole thing. Perhaps a few of you are made of sterner stuff than I.
It is rather amusing, though, how Rancourt’s assertion that “I’m not convinced that viruses exist” led even Steve Kirsch to rapidly change the subject, saying, “OK, OK, we’ve got to move on then.”
You can see the exchange favorably mentioned by a real die-hard virus denier here, a one-minute clip at the end of his Substack post. The main critical thing said about Rancourt is that it took him too long to reach this conclusion and that he hasn’t yet gone “all-in” on “no virus”:
I must also admit that for someone who is “new” to the topic he brings up some excellent points, countering Steve’s loaded questions with pinpoint precision. I clipped the most impressive part of his talk with Kirsch, which can be seen below (the full talk can also be seen here).
It must nevertheless be pointed out that Denis stills makes reference to an immune system as well as pathogens, and bacterial infections, but for someone to utter the words that “I don’t believe that viruses exist” it is a massive step in the right direction.
Who is Denis Rancourt, you might ask? You might have heard of him elsewhere, but, oddly enough, I’ve only mentioned him once before on SBM, and then only in the context of discussing why Steve Kirsch‘s ridiculously overblown claim a few months ago that COVID-19 vaccines had killed “only” 13 million people worldwide was such a steaming, stinking, load of fetid dingos’ kidneys and then only to say that it seems to be a law that antivaxxers must continually one-up each other regarding their estimates on how many people vaccines have supposedly killed or injured. Coming across Høeg’s rebuttal to Rancourt’s claim that COVID-19 vaccines had killed 17 million people led me down a deeper rabbit hole, however, and leading me to wonder, in retrospect, why I had never discussed him as the main topic of a full SBM post here before and had never even mentioned him over at my not-so-secret other blog.
Come with me down Denis Rancourt’s rabbit hole. The difference is that this rabbit hole is deadly.
Where did that rabbit hole lead, though? Come with me as I discuss a COVID-19 crank who, not satisfied with claiming that COVID-19 vaccines have killed 17 million people, but who also now denies that viruses—in particular SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19—even exist. Rancourt is far from the only person who claims this. In fact, as I will relate, amusingly he faced criticism from even more vociferous virus deniers that he was too slow to come to the correct “no virus” conclusion and that he still has reservations, not having totally embraced the idea.
Who is Denis Rancourt embraces “no virus”
Before I delve into Rancourt’s actual claims, I wanted to know who he is and what, if any, qualifications he has to pontificate on the science of viruses and the epidemiology of COVID-19 and vaccine injury. Unsurprisingly, I soon discovered that, although he is a scientist, he is not a scientist who would be expected to have significant expertise in virology, epidemiology, infectious diseases, or other areas related to COVID-19. It turns out that Denis Rancourt is a former professor of physics at the University of Ottawa. On his website, Rancourt states:
I currently write about medicine, COVID-19, individual health, climate change, geopolitics, civil rights, political theory, sociology … and I have also written over 100 peer-reviewed-journal articles in technical areas of science and technology.
I obtained BSc, MSc and PhD degrees in physics. I held post-doctoral research positions at prestigious institutions in France and The Netherlands, before being a physics professor and lead scientist at the University of Ottawa for 23 years.
I am an experienced self-represented litigant at several levels of court and in many administrative tribunals, in both Ontario and Quebec. I have been a volunteer Researcher with the Ontario Civil Liberties Association (ocla.ca) since 2014.
A quick perusal of his website provides ample evidence that Rancourt is a crank about more than just COVID-19 (although there are ample reasons just on his website to consider him a COVID-19 crank as well). For example, he’s a climate science denier who denies that human activity producing CO2 and other greenhouse gases is warming the planet, calling climate change a “gargantuan lie.”
Rancourt also conveniently neglects to mention why he is a “former professor of physics” and not still University of Ottawa faculty. It’s a rather odd history in which, back in 2009, Rancourt was fired for, well, let’s just look at this article:
The University of Ottawa has fired controversial physics professor Denis Rancourt.
He was suspended in December after he attracted national attention for his teaching methods, including giving a grade of A+ to every student in an advanced physics class.
Rancourt plans to grieve the dismissal with his union, which in turn will take it to court, he said.
Speaking from New York City where he was giving a lecture at New York University’s Frederic Ewen Academic Freedom Center, Rancourt said he got the news Wednesday in a letter delivered to his home by courier.
The university’s board of governors’ executive committee met Tuesday and issued the letter the next day.
The decision was ultimately upheld, but took years of litigation.
I won’t really comment much on this incident. It strikes me as rather odd, and I strongly suspect that there was more to it, given what’s in his Wikipedia entry. For example, there was an incident in which there were unauthorized people in his lab, but also Rancourt claims that the real reason for his firing was related to his political views with respect to the Israel-Palestine conflict and accused University of Ottawa president of being “a point-man of the Israel lobby at the University of Ottawa.
Whatever the conflict with the University of Ottawa that cost him his job, during the 15 years since his firing Rancourt has descended further and further into a rabbit hole pseudoscience, conspiracy theories, and crankery, with the rabbit hole having expanded greatly when the pandemic hit in 2020.
Which leads me to a 17-minute segment of Kirsch’s interview with Rancourt in which he lays down his reason for doubting viruses exist, refers to “so-called influenza,” and (sort of) qualifies it by doubting that you can make someone sick with a respiratory virus. (Maybe he’s just denying that respiratory viruses exist?) You can find this segment within this Substack post. (Sorry, I couldn’t find a way to embed it.) There is also another video right at the beginning Comparing the two is a good way to see Rancourt’s increasing radicalization with respect to the existence of viruses.
In the first clip (which is only 2:20), Rancourt says:
The thing about the viruses is, our work on all-cause mortality shows unambiguously that there was no new virulent pathogen. Nothing special happened that would have caused death. If they had done nothing and not declared a pandemic and just done business as usual there would not have been excess mortality, period. We proved that. We proved it because we showed that the data is inconsistent with all the ideas of a spread of a viral respiratory disease, OK? It’s contrary to that. And we showed that where there was excess mortality it was directly related to the nature of the assault against the population.
Alright, once you’ve shown that, why are we debating whether or not viruses exist, you know? In my view—and this is, people get really upset with me when I say this—it doesn’t matter. It’s not what they said. That’s not how health works, and that I consider that academic question if that invented nanoparticle exists and do the magical things that they say it does, and they have this virology and so experts in academics go on and on about it. I don’t care. I don’t care because it doesn’t produce results in the real world.
I feel that way about immunology. Immunologists go on and on about the immune system and all its many mechanisms, and how it works, and how you develop immunity, and all these kind of things. A lot of that is high level theory, and they’re not always admitting that they’re only seeing a small part of the whole system, and even if they are seeing a larger part they’re not really seeing how all the parts are integrated together into something that is as complex as a human body living in society. So they’re not anywhere near understanding at the molecular level that they’re claiming how recovery from a disease works or why you would get a disease or what the disease is…
[Sound dropped out for me here.]
Cue the sound of thousands of immunologists who know so much more about disease and immunology than Rancourt all facepalming in unison.
Here you see a common technique of antivaxxers and COVID-19 minimizers, just on steroids. Whereas COVID-19 minimizers like those behind, for example, the Great Barrington Declaration, basically claimed that the virus was not dangerous to the vast majority of people (and so we should have “let ‘er rip” with poorly defined “focused protection” to keep the supposedly tiny minority for whom the virus was dangerous “safe”), here Rancourt is claiming that there was “no new virulent pathogen.” The assumption at that point last year when he gave the article is, to me at least, that he believed that there was such a thing as a virulent pathogen. Or maybe he didn’t. He just “doesn’t care” whether viruses exist:
Almost a year later, and I don’t seem to have seen any “report” on the virus. Note, however, how Rancourt obfuscates regarding the various flavors of “no virus,” which include claims that the “virus was never isolated”; that it’s not infectious; or even that it doesn’t exist at all—or that there are no such things as viruses.
Hard core virus deniers were not amused:
I must admit some amusement at these memes. This is what happens when you try to appear “reasonable” by only partially embracing science denial like virus denial, presumably because you don’t want to associate with the real loons.
Don’t worry, though. As of last summer, Rancourt was moving in that direction:
Going back to the 17 minute video at the end of this Substack, which is a clip from the 2+ hour interview posted to Rumble six weeks ago, I note that Rancourt starts out by referring to the “so-called influenza.” He then moves on to liken the symptoms of COVID-19 to that of the flu and uses that to conclude, “I’m not personally convinced that there was something particularly new or special.”
After Steve Kirsch says he’s “going to push back” a little, Rancourt continues:
The other thing is, I have looked at the scientific literature and continue to research it for firm evidence that it has been demonstrated that you can spread a viral respiratory disease—in other words, that you can cause infection in a person using a virus—and I have not found any scientifically, OK?
It is, of course, very easy to fail to find evidence if you design your standards for what evidence you will accept to exclude evidence that scientists have accepted since viral respiratory diseases were discovered in the late 1800s, but, pray, do go on Mr. Rancourt:
For example, if you look at the work of Professor Sheldon Cohen, an American who spent his entire career trying to infect college age university students in the US when you were allowed to do that with what he thought was influenza… He was culturing the stuff and would put the fluid, either vaporized into their noses, or deposit it, or drop it in, or into their eyes, every way that he could… And what he found was—and this is really important—the people who got sick are the ones who had significant psychological stress in their life, and—these were the biggest factors that determined whether or not you were going to get sick—is psychological stress and social isolation. So the college students that didn’t have a big social network and were socially isolated and were stressed, they got sick, and the more isolated and the more stressed they were, the sicker they got.
Of course, this doesn’t demonstrate that viruses don’t exist or that you can’t infect someone with a respiratory virus. Quite the contrary! Rather, what it demonstrated is that one’s psychological health affects one’s susceptibility to infection with respiratory viruses. Indeed, here’s a 2006 paper by Cohen (who died in 2013) that looked at susceptibility to infection with influenza and rhinovirus as a function of positive emotional style (PES) in which he reported that high scores for PES were associated with lower susceptibility to becoming ill after a challenge with purified virus. Moreover, nothing in medicine is 100%, contrary to the way that Rancourt described it. The paper, for instance, demonstrated that 26.1% of low PES developed influenza symptoms, while 15.5% of high PES subjects did. That’s pretty impressive, a 40% decline in the chance of developing symptomatic influenza when exposed to purified virus, and, yes, the high PES subjects who did get sick had milder symptoms. This result suggests that emotional health is associated with a more effective immune system. It does not, as Rancourt implies, demonstrate that you can’t spread a respiratory virus and make someone sick. Again, quite the opposite, in fact! (Similar results were obtained with rhinovirus in this study.)
Rancourt also references the Rosenau experiment of 1918-1919 in which volunteers from the Navy were indeed isolated on an island, where Harvard professor Milton L. Rosenau attempted to give them the flu by various means or to force its spread by requiring the volunteers to stay together in close quarters. What Rancourt fails to note is that virology was very primitive at the time and at the time it was believed that a bacteria, known as the Pfeiffer bacillus, was used as the infectious agent in a tiny sample size. (It wasn’t confirmed that influenza was a viral disease until 1934.) There’s actually a good explanation on, of all places, Reddit why the Rosenau experiment didn’t yield any useful information, concluding that “the experiments were very poorly done by today’s standards, and it’s not surprising such sloppy work didn’t give them any insights.” Also in the thread were a number of references on how the transmissibility of influenza was established and how it needs to be done right. The point is that it is not nearly as easy as Rancourt, in his ignorance, seems to think it is to establish transmissibility, even back when the ethical standards for approving a challenge experiment were much more lax. Suffice to say, it can be done and has been done.
Amusingly, Kirsch—again, of all people—challenges Rancourt by bringing up the example of cruise ships in which one person gets sick from COVID and then, soon after, hundreds of people catch it, a surprisingly reasonable retort coming from someone like Kirsch. Rancourt’s retort? He claimed that it wasn’t the virus, but rather that the people were all “subject to the same conditions” and are “subjected to each other’s stress,” finishing, “You’ve got a bunch of old people locked on a ship. What do you think is going to happen?”
Alrighty then. Kirsch even goes on to “challenge” Rancourt by pointing out that SARS-CoV-2 is actually a virus that has been sequenced and is a novel respiratory pathogen, asking Rancourt, “Agree or disagree?” (You can predict the answer, right?) I have to admit that this next part of the interview led me to laugh out loud, as Rancourt airily dismisses the genetic sequencing methods as “highly unreliable,” “patchy,” and “fabricated.” Seriously, say what you will about sequencing DNA and RNA, but “highly unreliable” they are most definitely not. Indeed, with the advent of next generation sequencing and techniques to sequence whole genomes, the science of genomics and sequencing DNA is quite robust and, yes, reliable. As you might imagine, there’s nothing that I love more than a physicist airily dismissing a whole science that he clearly doesn’t understand. Seriously, just because you don’t understand a scientific technique doesn’t mean that it’s a bogus technique. At this point, Rancourt is reminding me of Paul Davies and Charles Lineweaver, two physicists who decided that they knew more about cancer than cancer biologists, resulting in them resurrecting a theory of cancer popular over a century ago that cancer biologists had ultimately abandoned because of its lack of explanatory power regarding cancer origins and development.
Rather than actually showing why he thinks SARS-CoV-2 sequencing is “unreliable,” Rancourt does a Gish gallop into talking about “variants of concern,” claiming they “never used to do this before COVID-19.” Oh, really? They’ve been doing it every year for influenza variants going back decades. It’s how vaccinologists try to predict which strains of influenza will be circulating in any given year and try to match that year’s vaccine to those strains. He even claims that there are “almost no” scientific papers demonstrating that this is even a thing. Again, oh really? Here’s a review article from 2021 about variants of concern discussing vaccine effectiveness against them. Here’s a study looking at Delta and Omicron that concludes that Delta was the most cytopathic and Omicron the fastest replicating. I could go on, but there are nearly 6,000 articles indexed in PubMed about or mentioning COVID-19 variants of concern. Nice of Rancourt to dismiss them all so easily by going on and on about how supposedly variants of concern are identified through short stretches of DNA and hundreds of sequences that are found apparently don’t count. Seriously the word is homology. You can relate genetic sequences to each other that are not identical and produce phylogenic trees of how evolutionarily related they are.
Rancourt claims to know a lot about “molecular science” and “how you measure things in science,” having taught spectroscopy, diffraction, microscopy and bragging about having had an electron microscope in his lab. Goody for him. That doesn’t mean he understands genomics, genetics, and DNA sequencing, his dismissal of the science of variants and DNA sequencing as being “garbage” with “no value whatsoever” notwithstanding, saying:
At this stage of my studies, I am not at all convinced that viruses, as a pandemic-causing agent, exist. I’m not convinced at all.
Kirsch actually pushes him, asking whether there was a novel pathogenic virus that appeared in 2020, and Rancourt says he “doesn’t see any evidence” for that or “any reason to postulate that.” Kirsch then tries to challenge him with anecdotal evidence, such as a paramedic who says he never noted SpO2 values (oxygen saturation measured by a pulse oximeter) as low as he had seen, and Rancourt doesn’t even know what that means, asking if it has something to do with “blood viscosity” and then later saying he doesn’t know what SpO2 measures. Basically, Rancourt is utterly ignorant of some very basic human physiology, the sort of thing taught in the first term of the first year when I was in medical school, but he feels competent to dismiss an entire branch of science? Seriously, man, if Steve “debate me, bro!” Kirsch has to explain to you what a pulse oximeter is and SpO2 is, and that a low, not a high, SpO2 is bad, you should be sufficiently ashamed to slink back into the rabbit hole you emerged from to spread what you found after having gone down it. I was cringing hard during this part of the 17 minute segment. By way of background, though, Kirsch was describing is a phenomenon called “happy hypoxia,” in which COVID-19 victims could look apparently fine and surprisingly not short of breath at alarmingly low oxygen saturations. Kirsch notes that this was a new phenomenon associated with COVID-19, which it was.
I can’t resist repeating again right here that Denis Rancourt doesn’t know what a pulse oximeter measures, why it’s important, or what SpO2 is, and in this interview has to be educated about such basic human physiology by Steve Kirsch! Dude, you need to put a paper bag over your head and just shut up. I can’t recall having cringed so hard in a long time.
How Denis Rancourt should respond to the shame of having had to be educated by Steve Kirsch about pulse oximetry.
So how does Rancourt respond? He pivots to saying that the factors with the biggest effect on human physiology are psychological stress and social isolation. That’s right. Those new clinical phenomenon observed by clinicians in those dark early and deadly days of the pandemic four years ago were all due to stress and psychology! Of course, this sounds a lot like a lot of other alternative medicine beliefs that I’ve written about before, such as German New Medicine and its bastard offspring Biologie Totale, which claims that cancer is due to suppressed psychological stress, just substituting societal stress, such as “lockdowns” and fear of the virus, for the suppressed psychological stress.
Indeed, Rancourt goes on and on and on about this for minutes, claiming that the respiratory system would be the one most affected by all this societal stress, which makes you susceptible to the bacteria already living on and in you. His evidence? People in poorer states died in higher numbers than in richer states. It never occurs to him that public health, access to healthcare, and other factors associated with poverty, such as living at high density, were likely contributors. He also claimed that the way we “stopped giving antibiotics” to people contributed because, supposedly, these same people got more antibiotic prescriptions and, without antibiotics, were more susceptible to bacterial infection. Apparently the concept of antibiotic resistance never occurred to him.
When that fails, Rancourt just says that he doesn’t believe what clinicians were telling people, as they too were apparently sheeple—in fairness, he doesn’t use the word, but it’s clearly what he meant—and believed all the government propaganda too.
Denis Rancourt is not alone
I had planned on writing more about Rancourt’s claim that COVID-19 vaccines killed 17 million, but I decided that this post had gotten long enough. Also, I’ve addressed one version of this “vaccine depopulation” claim promoted by Steve Kirsch, although Kirsch claimed “only” 13 million deaths from vaccines. Basically, all of these claims rely on unjustified extrapolation from a relatively small number to the world’s population. Perhaps I will return Rancourt’s version of this claim, either here or at my not-so-secret other blog in the near future. In the meantime, as I noted before, Rancourt is downright “reluctant” to say that viruses don’t exist compared to some.
For instance, let’s go back to Franklin O’Kanu, who describes the “consequences of a world without viruses”:
The implications of Rancourt’s statement are profound and far-reaching. If, as he asserts, there is no evidence to support the existence of viruses, then we must reevaluate much of what we have been told and accepted as truth. This statement, if true, has significant consequences for our society.
Consider the events of the past few years. Lives were disrupted, livelihoods threatened, and jobs lost due to a threat that, according to Rancourt, myself, and others, does not exist. Experimental procedures were administered in the name of health for a non-existent threat. The real-world implications of holding onto false ideas are severe and have caused untold suffering.
I personally know a physician who lost their father because he was put on antiviral medication. If Rancourt’s statement holds, did we need to start that antiviral medication? Do we need antiviral medications at all? The same question applies to vaccines, especially as Steve Kirsch has shown that vaccines can cause autism4.
These are the implications of an industry built on pseudoscience. The term “virus” translates to “poison,” and what we are witnessing is a poisoning of the mind. As I discuss in my article, it is possible to manifest symptoms of an infection, a so-called viral infection, through psychological stress.
In fairness, I will admit that, indeed, if there actually is no such thing as viruses (or at least respiratory viruses that can cause a pandemic), then, yes, that would be a radical finding that would totally change how we view medicine and health. The problem with O’Kanu’s assertion is that it is pure bullshit (if you’ll excuse my language). We have mountains of evidence for the existence of viruses dating back over a century, as well as mountains of evidence for what diseases they cause, how they can be prevented with vaccines, how they are transmitted, and even how some of them can be treated with antiviral medications. Rancourt and O’Kanu can deny all that evidence all they want and try to convince you that diseases that physicians and scientists attribute to viruses are really due to stress and social isolation, but even the examples they cite don’t support that idea. Remember, for example, that that influenza challenge experiment showed that high PES scores were associated with only a 40% decrease in the risk of becoming ill after an exposure to the virus. Rancourt talks as though it were 100% and that all you need to avoid becoming sick is to be psychologically healthy (or at least not stressed) and not socially isolated, in much the same way that quacks have long claimed that you have complete control over your health.
I realize that it’s hard to believe that now, in the 2020s, there are people who really believe that viruses don’t exist and that respiratory infectious diseases like COVID-19 and the flu are a result of psychological stress and social isolation manifesting themselves as various symptomology and increased risk of bacterial infection, but unfortunately these people exist, and some of them are fairly decent propagandists. Also, when you believe that viruses don’t exist or can’t hurt you, it becomes all too easy to falsely believe that vaccines are too harmful to justify their use—or even that they’ve killed millions of people.

Dr. Jerome Adams Was Right. They Wanted Them Infected. That’s a Fact.
“Many were fine with exposing kids (and school workers) to a deadly virus, with no vaccine or treatment, in the name of herd immunity. That’s a fact.”- Dr. Jerome Adams
Jonathan Howard on November 12, 2023
Link

“In 2020, the focus was mostly about using the kids as guinea pigs (ie subjecting them to a new virus) to achieve herd immunity.”
Dr. Jerome Adams, the Surgeon General in the Trump administration, recently caused a stir on social media by posting the following:
The pandemic school closure debate is now often framed as being solely about the kids. However, it’s important to acknowledge that in 2020, the focus was mostly about using the kids as guinea pigs (ie subjecting them to a new virus) to achieve herd immunity + faster reopening.
Dr. Adams also shared this page from his new book, Crisis and Chaos: Lessons from the Front Lines of the War Against COVID-19, regarding Dr. Scott Atlas, who served as a coronavirus advisor to President Trump in 2020:
Dr. Adams was not the only person who recalled Dr. Atlas’ proposal to use “kids as vectors to ensure viral spread in an attempt to reach herd immunity as quickly as possible so as to reopen the economy.”  According to a report from House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis titled The Atlas Dogma:
Dr. Atlas also used his newfound position of power to recruit herd immunity proponents to come to Washington, D.C., to meet with multiple senior Administration officials and, according to (CDC) Director Redfield, “convince people that herd immunity was going to save us, and this thing was going to go bye-bye.”
Former White House coronavirus response coordinator Dr. Deborah Birx similarly testified:
Dr. Atlas’ view was that anybody who was not going to have severe disease should be allowed to become infected.  I do believe that he thought that there was long-term protection from reinfection, but we didn’t know that. And so he really was trying to, and it was a team, it wasn’t just Dr. Atlas, there was a team of physicians and PhDs who strongly believed that the virus was innocent to the majority of the American people and somehow you could magically separate the 50 or 60 million vulnerable Americans from that infection at a high level.
“This quote from the former SG is simply untrue.”
Although he was merely relaying what he and many others heard directly from Dr. Atlas, furious commentators told Dr. Adams he was making this all up. They told Dr. Adams it was preposterous to claim that anyone actually wanted children to get infected to achieve herd immunity. Instead, they claimed Dr. Atlas was a benevolent soul, who merely felt the harms of remote learning outweighed the benefits of preventing COVID in children. One typically irate commentator said:
I’m sorry, Jerome, but this is just obscene framing. We have receipts. There were many people in this fight. The focus on reopening schools was NOT about using kids as guinea pigs. It was about looking at data from other countries and taking children’s needs into consideration.
Several doctors also berated Dr. Adams, saying that he was lying. Dr. Vinay Prasad said:
Totally dishonest. I watched most of @ScottAtlas_IT press conferences and, agree or disagree, he repeatedly said kids were at such low risk, they might as well go to school, and derive the massive benefit of education.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya similarly said:
This quote from the former SG is simply untrue. I spoke regularly with Scott Atlas in spring & summer 2020. His motivation derived from his understanding of the importance of schools for the well being of children and from the Swedish success in spring 2020 with open schools.
I’ll go one step further. It was evident to me at the time and now that the people who pushed lockdowns and school closures had no concern whatsoever about the well being of children, thinking of them primarily as vectors of disease to be suppressed rather than precious young people to be nurtured and cared for.
“When younger, healthier people get infected, that’s a good thing because that’s exactly the way that population immunity develops.”
So who is right here? Was Dr. Atlas a leader of a failed movement to purposely infect unvaccinated children to hasten the arrival of herd immunity, or was he a tireless warrior for education, who merely wanted precious young people to be nurtured and cared for? Fortunately, the words of Dr. Atlas provide an answer. Indeed, “we have receipts”.
In an article from April 2020 titled  The Data Is In — Stop The Panic And End The Total Isolation, Dr. Atlas wrote:
Fact 3: Vital population immunity is prevented by total isolation policies, prolonging the problem.
We know from decades of medical science that infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — antibodies — so that the infection is controlled throughout the population by “herd immunity.” Indeed, that is the main purpose of widespread immunization in other viral diseases — to assist with population immunity. In this virus, we know that medical care is not even necessary for the vast majority of people who are infected. It is so mild that half of infected people are asymptomatic, shown in early data from the Diamond Princess ship, and then in Iceland and Italy. That has been falsely portrayed as a problem requiring mass isolation. In fact, infected people without severe illness are the immediately available vehicle for establishing widespread immunity. By transmitting the virus to others in the low-risk group who then generate antibodies, they block the network of pathways toward the most vulnerable people, ultimately ending the threat. Extending whole-population isolation would directly prevent that widespread immunity from developing.
In another article from April 2020, titled Reentry After The Panic: Paying the Health Price of Extreme Isolation, Dr. Atlas said “We now need to reenter normal life” and lamented not “having a population protected by a naturally developed immunity.”  He wrote:
But a bigger price might now be paid from choosing extreme isolation. In the absence of immunization, society needs circulation of the virus, assuming high-risk people can be isolated. Infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — natural antibodies. Given the estimated contagiousness of COVID-19, about 60 percent of people in the community need to have antibodies to stop the spread by “herd immunity.” Remember, medical care is not necessary for the vast majority of people who are infected. We also infer from testing in Iceland and Vo, Italy, that half of infected people are asymptomatic. That has been misleadingly portrayed as a problem requiring mass isolation; those infected people are an important vehicle for establishing immunity by transmitting the virus to the low-risk group. Preliminary testing in Germany shows that perhaps 15 percent of people are immune; no doubt this varies greatly by region. It is very possible that whole-population isolation prevented natural herd immunity from developing.
Neither of these articles mentioned “schools”, “classroom”, or “education.”
During an interview with Tucker Carlson from June 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
We expected more cases with more social mingling… But the fact is the overwhelming majority of these cases are in younger healthier people. These people do not have a significant problem. They do not have the serious complications. They do not die. And so it’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases, but we don’t see deaths going up, and what that means is A: we’re are doing a better job of protecting the vulnerable, B: We’re in good shape here.
We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity, population immunity, when low-risk people, with no significant problem handling this virus, which is basically 99% of people get this, they become immunity and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people…Children have virtually zero risk of getting a serious complication, virtually a zero risk of dying…Children only rarely if ever transmit the disease.
During another Fox News interview from July 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
When younger, healthier people get the disease, they don’t have a problem with the disease. I’m not sure why that’s so difficult for everyone to acknowledge. These people getting the infection is not really a problem, and in fact, as we said months ago, when you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you’re prolonging the problem because you’re preventing population immunity. Low-risk groups getting the infection is not a problem.
During another interview from July 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
It doesn’t matter if younger, healthier people get infected. I don’t know how often that has to be said. They have nearly zero risk of a problem from this. When younger, healthier people get infected, that’s a good thing because that’s exactly the way that population immunity develops.
A Twitter account compiled several videos of Dr. Atlas making (and later denying) many similar statements. In one clip, Dr. Atlas said:
There’s a positive to having low-risk groups get infection.  What’s the positive?  This is how you develop population based immunity.  When I said this months ago, as did others, if we isolate every human being from social interaction, we are prolonging the problem, we are preventing population immunity from developing.  But we isolated, and this is what we called for, isolating and protecting the high-risk groups, once we do that successfully, we don’t care if younger, healthier people get the infection.
It’s true that Dr. Atlas also wrote articles discussing the potential harms of remote learning in 2020, though he used this as an opportunity to minimize pediatric COVID.  For example, he wrote that “only ten” children died of COVID in NYC during the first wave, though this was a large number of children to die in a short time in one city with the strictest mitigation measures in place.
However, Dr. Atlas’ belief that it was “positive”, “a good thing”, and “fantastic news” when young people contracted COVID explains why he didn’t just want children in school, he wanted them there unvaccinated, unmasked, and untested. Indeed, Dr. Atlas, who supposedly was only concerned about students losing “the massive benefit of education”, had nothing to say, as far as I know, when overwhelming COVID outbreaks shuttered schools or led to record-high absentee rates.
Dr. Atlas viewed schools as an opportunity to build “natural herd immunity” in children. He wanted them infected.
“Immunity is built through illness.”
Of course, Drs. Prasad and Bhattacharya should not be surprised by these quotes from Dr. Atlas. They too were leaders of the movement to infect unvaccinated children with SARS-CoV-2 to theoretically protect more vulnerable adults. It’s worth remembering their words as well.
In an article titled, Should We Let Children Catch Omicron, Dr. Prasad said:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life… Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
He favorably quoted computational biologist Dr. Francois Balloux who said:
I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.
Dr. Prasad urged his readers to accept pediatric COVID fatalities “as a matter of course”, writing:
While the death of any child is a tragedy, Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course.
“Immunity is built through illness,” Dr. Prasad concluded, though of course immunity can also be built through vaccines.
Dr. Bhattacharya, meanwhile, co-authored the influential Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), whose entire premise was that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity. It said:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk.
In the Frequently Asked Questions section, the GBD claimed that herd immunity would arrive in 3 to 6 months if only 250 million unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans were willing to simultaneously “build up immunity to the virus through natural infection”. It said:
For how long must high-risk individuals be careful and/or self-isolate?
When herd immunity is reached, they can live normally again with minimal risks. How long that takes depends on the strategy used. If age-wide lockdown measures are used to try and suppress the disease, it could take a year or two or three, making it very difficult for older people to protect themselves for that long. If focused protection is used, it will likely only take 3 to 6 months.
Like Dr. Atlas, Drs. Prasad and Bhattacharya have spread blatant misinformation, always minimizing COVID’s risk to children. They too have been tireless crusaders against vaccines, masks, COVID tests, and anything else that might limit COVID infections in children. They too were silent when COVID outbreaks closed schools.
They also wanted them infected.
“Many were fine with exposing kids (and school workers) to a deadly virus, with no vaccine or treatment, in the name of herd immunity. That’s a fact.”
The broader lesson here is that it’s crucial to remember the words doctors said, the policies they pushed, and the real-world consequences that resulted. This is especially the case now that they seek to rewrite history, denying they were ever part of a disastrous movement to infect tens of millions of unvaccinated children to achieve the mythical grail of herd immunity.
Dr. Adams ended his Twitter thread by saying:
My intent isn’t to attack Atlas or anyone else. It’s to remind us the context at the time for these policy debates, and the tradeoffs people don’t acknowledge or forget about in hindsight. Many were fine with exposing kids (and school workers) to a deadly virus, with no vaccine or treatment, in the name of herd immunity. That’s a fact.
He’s right. They wanted them infected. That’s a fact.

Verbicide: Language as a Pandemic Casualty
Natural infection is getting infected. It’s like water and H20.  It’s amazing that a doctor is trying to convince us otherwise.
Jonathan HowardonMarch 28, 2023
Link

In a previous article, I discussed Dr. Jay Bhattacharya’s preternatural ability to redefine words to suit his convenience.  When something he says ages poorly, as has happened throughout the pandemic, Dr. Bhattacharya simply claims words don’t mean exactly what they mean.  For example, at the start of the pandemic, Dr. Bhattacharya wrote an article titled Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? in which he claimed “projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.”  He further said:
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
When he was later faced with his eminently reasonable support of “shelter-in-place orders and quarantines” for a virus that could kill millions, Dr. Bhattacharya then claimed that,
But the extraordinary measures I advocated was not lockdown, but rather a rapid seroprevalence study and a focused protection approach.
So according to Dr. Bhattacharya, “shelter-in-place orders and quarantines” really mean a “rapid seroprevalence study and a focused protection approach.” I’ll come back to that “protection approach”.
A recent article in Vanity Fair titled Inside Ron DeSantis’s Plan to Ride Anti-vaxxism to the White House recently gave Dr. Bhattacharya an opportunity to practice more verbicide. The article, in which I am quoted (and my upcoming book We Want Them Infected mentioned), discussed Dr. Bhattacharya and said:
Immediately controversial, the let ’er rip strategy, as critics called it, came to the attention of President Trump via a radiologist named Scott Atlas, whom Trump had seen on Fox News and recruited as an adviser. Atlas, in turn, invited Bhattacharya and Ladapo, who was not yet Florida surgeon general, to meet Trump in the Oval Office. A Trump appointee within the Department of Health and Human Services famously characterized a herd immunity approach in an email to colleagues, writing of the healthy, “We want them infected.”
Dr. Bhattacharya was not pleased to be linked to those four words- we want them infected- and responded by saying:
Well, let’s revisit the document that made Dr. Bhattacharya famous, the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). It said:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk. We call this Focused Protection.
I don’t know about you, but asking “those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection” sure seems like he wanted them infected. In case there’s any doubt, Dr. Bhattacharya doubled down in an article titled The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young in which he absurdly argued that young people should remain unvaccinated because older people have more risk. “While anyone can get infected, the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young,” he said. He continued,
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
Indeed, the entire premise of the GBD was that unvaccinated young people would contract COVID and build-up a wall of herd immunity that would protect vulnerable people, all in just 3-6 months!
Though the GBD discouraged people from actively seeking out the virus, they felt not vulnerable people had a moral duty to live normally, ensuring they would inevitably and rapidly contract COVID. Other authors of the GBD were very open about all this. In July 2020, Dr. Sunetra Gupta said “We have to share the guilt. We have to share the responsibility. And we have to take on board certain risks ourselves in order to fulfill our obligations and to uphold the social contract.”
Dr. Martin Kulldorff said young people should think of themselves as soldiers, writing in August 2020:
Is it age discrimination when young people take the small risks needed to protect the older more vulnerable members of society? Yes, for sure, but prior generations took much larger risks. As a society we should appreciate young adults who help generate herd immunity by living normal lives and keeping society afloat. Thank you, thank you, thank you. When people throw misguided complaints at you, falsely claiming that you are endangering others, remember that the opposite is true. Also, think of your grandfather. While risking his life fighting in World War II, he had much worse things thrown at him…That weakness is the near inability of the virus to kill younger people. Hence, it is the young adults among us that must stand in the front line as we fight this enemy. If not, we will have many more casualties than necessary…
Covid-19 is a formidable enemy, and in any war, one must take advantage of the opponent’s weaknesses. That weakness is the near inability of the virus to kill younger people. Hence, it is the young adults among us that must stand in the front line as we fight this enemy.
According to the authors of the GBD, it wasn’t just acceptable for young, unvaccinated people to risk suffering and death to protect their grandparents, it was their moral obligation. They were soldiers on a mission to spread SARS-CoV-2  – a sort of Team COVID Army – and their duty required them to forgo vaccination for the sake of “natural immunity.” Young, healthy people who stayed home weren’t just selfish. They were to blame for prolonging the pandemic and causing “many more casualties than necessary.”
Yet today, Dr. Bhattacharya absurdly insists there is a marked difference between someone who “wants them infected” and someone who wants “those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection”?
Of course, there is no difference.
This is why Dr. Bhattacharya only complained about measures to control the virus. He never protested that inadequate measures were taken to control it, especially for young people. While he now denies he “wanted them infected”, he certainly didn’t want them protected, which is functionally no different than “wanting them infected”. It’s like telling a fertile young couple to have unprotected sex daily, but then furiously denying that you intended for anyone to get pregnant.
Even though he instructed others to “resume life as normal“, Dr. Bhattacharya wisely managed to avoid the virus until August 2021, after he had been vaccinated. During this time, he was working hard to make sure that others contracted COVID before they were vaccinated. Dr. Bhattacharya, who didn’t care for any COVID patients himself, worked tirelessly to ensure that young people gained immunity to the virus through natural infection rather than vaccination. Indeed, many young people heeded his advice to skip the vaccine in favor immunity to the virus through natural infection, some regretting their decision with their last breath.
Today, Dr. Bhattacharya should bask in his success rather than gaslight us further by pretending words don’t mean exactly what they mean. Of course, getting immunity to the virus through natural infection is getting infected. It’s amazing that Dr. Bhattacharya would try to convince us otherwise. Sadly, his success in getting people to listen to him is evidence of another pandemic casualty, the quaint notion that words have meanings.

The ultimate COVID-19 antivax conspiracy theory, courtesy of The Brownstone Institute and Jeffery Tucker
I’ve long argued that antivax beliefs, indeed all science denial, is conspiracy theory. Leave it to The Brownstone Institute’s Jeffery Tucker to make my point better for me than I ever could. Of course, Brownstone was always going to “go there.”
David Gorskion May 27, 2024
Link

It’s a holiday weekend here in the US (and, if I’m not mistaken, in the UK as well), and because of that I debated whether I should just take the weekend off, particularly given how rough the last couple of weeks were getting a grant application finished on Thursday evening. However, I am managing editor here and felt obligated. Also, I came across a post over at that “spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration” (a.k.a. the Brownstone Institute) by its founder Jeffrey Tucker that illustrated so well a point that I’ve long made that I felt that a shorter-than-Gorski-usual post was warranted this weekend. The Brownstone Institute article is entitled What Really Happened: Lockdown until Vaccination, and, wow, it is a doozy, even for the Brownstone Institute. You’ll get a flavor of what you’re about to read from the introduction:
Four years later, many people are investigating how our lives were completely upended by a pandemic response. Over my time on the case, I’ve heard countless theories. It was Big Tech, Big Pharma, Big Finance, the Green New Deal, the CCP, Depopulation, Get Trump, Mail-In Ballots, and so on.
There is evidence to back them all.
The problem with having so many pieces of evidence and so many theories is that people can too easily get thrown off track, going on wild goose chases. It’s too much to follow through consistently, and this allows the perpetrators to hide their deeds.
There you have it, right from the very first paragraph, a Greatest Hits Collection of pandemic and antivax conspiracy theories, and guess what? Tucker thinks there’s “evidence to back them all”! However, he cautions that there are just so many conspiracies that it’s easy to “get thrown off track” and go “on wild goose chases,” all the better to allow the “perpetrators to hide their deeds.” No doubt that very plethora of conspiracies is part of “Their” plan, as “They” do whatever it is They planned to do in order to accomplish whatever it is They had planned to accomplish, all at the expense of…you, of course. That’s because, as I’ve long argued, all antivaccine misinformation is basically a flavor of conspiracy theory, one that I dubbed a decade ago “the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement.”
Before I delve into the details of what Tucker thinks They are doing, let’s step back a moment and marvel at this evolution of the Brownstone Institute. I will admit right up front that the conspiracy theory laid out by Tucker is not even the most bonkers antivax conspiracy theory that I’ve ever encountered. For instance, Mike Adam’s “Oblivion Agenda” conspiracy theory that posited that COVID-19 was a bioweapon designed as part of a two-step plan hatched up by global elites and aliens—I kid you not!—to force humanity to be vaccinated in order to cause “depopulation,” all so that they could together profit off of the natural resources of earth. Amusingly, the Oblivion Agenda was a pandemic-era update to Adams’ older, similar “vaccine Holocaust” conspiracy theory from 2019. It’s not even as bonkers as Toby Rogers’ more recent COVID-19 vaccine conspiracy theory that would be as bonkers as Adams’ if only it had aliens in it.
Truth be told, there’s a lot of Toby Rogers’ conspiracy theory in Jeffrey Tucker’s conspiracy theory, and there could well be a reason for that. First, let’s take a look at some of the central elements of Rogers’ speculations:
What’s striking about Covid is that every step was designed to inflict maximum harm:
    • Splicing HIV into a coronavirus (who even comes up with an idea that sinister!?).
    • Blocking access to hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin.
    • Removing NAC from the shelves.
    • No early treatment.
    • Respirators that kill 90% of patients.
    • Seeding nursing homes with Covid+ patients.
    • Blanket “Do Not Resuscitate” orders for the disabled.
    • “15 days to flatten the curve” that slowed the rate of natural immunity.
    • Closing schools for two years.
    • Masks that reduce oxygen.
    • Shutting down gyms to reduce exercise.
    • Keeping liquor stores open while closing the churches that host AA meetings.
    • Closing hiking trails, beaches, and parks thus preventing people from getting vitamin D.
    • Remdesivir and Paxlovid that are expensive, useless, and deadly.
    • The most toxic and deadly vaccines in history on a new platform that will never work.
    • Billions of dollars spent on propaganda to convince people to accept every step of this nefarious plan.
    • Firings, censorship, and blacklisting of critical thinkers.
Actual science was always ignored. Every action by government for four years degraded the health of the public. Covid is a world war, launched by the ruling class, against humanity.
Two of the key elements of conspiratorial thinking are to see patterns in randomness and to attribute malign intent to this pattern, regardless of whether there is any evidence of malign intent or not; well, that, and to claim that the “truth” is being “suppressed,” as Rogers does in the last two bullet points. As for the rest, I’ve written about damned near all of those pieces of misinformation, such as the false claims that HIV was “spliced into” SARS-CoV-2. I don’t feel the need to address all those claims individually, as they are all nonsense, with the possible exception of the “flatten the curve” claim, which is not nonsense in the way that Rogers implies. (It’s nonsense in that in retrospect it should always have been obvious that a period of 15 days was never going to be sufficient to flatten the curve.) The point is that “they” (the “ruling class”) are not just malign; they actively wanted to kill millions of people, to launch a “world war” against all of humanity. Why? Who knows? As much as we might despise the ruling class, they are part of humanity too and can’t escape that.
Now, let’s look at Tucker’s conspiracy theory, where he starts by, in essence, claiming to apply Occam’s razor and then JAQing off:
For such situations, we can take recourse to Occam’s razor: the best explanation is the simplest one that explains the maximum number of facts. This is what I offer here.
Those in the know will be shocked by nothing herein. Those not in the know will be amazed at the audaciousness of the entire scheme. If it is true, there are surely documents and people who can confirm this. At least this model of thinking will assist in guiding thinking and research.
Of course, the “explanation” that Tucker offers is nowhere near the “simplest one that explains the maximum number of facts.” Also, conveniently enough, there is no “smoking gun” evidence, as Tucker appears to be readily admitting, saying that such documents must “surely” exist, along with people who can confirm his ramblings. It’s a shame that he can’t present any of them now, but that is the nature of conspiracy theories.
The first part (of three parts) of the conspiracy theory is, predictably enough, that SARS-CoV-2 was created, either intentionally or accidentally, but Frankenstein-like scientists engaged in dangerous “gain of function’ research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology:
First, in late 2019 and perhaps as early as October, higher-ups in the biodefense industry and perhaps people like Anthony Fauci and Jeremy Farrar of the UK became aware of a lab leak at a US-funded bioweapons lab in Wuhan. This is a place that does gain-of-function research to produce both the pathogen and the antidote, just like in the movies. It’s gone on for decades in possibly hundreds of labs but this leak looked pretty bad, one with a fast-transmitting virus believed to be of high lethality.
The civilians were not likely the first to know. Military and security higher-ups, the people actually working with clearances in the bioweapons industry, were the first to get the word. They gradually leaked it out to civilian sources.
So, yes, Tucker is claiming that SARS-CoV-2 was the result of bioweapons research in China, even though there is no evidence that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was ever a bioweapons laboratory. Moreover, as I noted in May 2021, the idea that SARS-CoV-2 originated in a “lab leak” had already clearly become a conspiracy theory. While it was still possible that the virus had emerged as part of a lab leak, there was no good evidence that it was anything other than of natural origin, the wild (and highly misleading) claims of HIV sequences inserted into SARS-CoV-2, furin cleavage sites, nucleotide sequences leftover from common lab plasmids, and other supposed “evidence” of human alteration and engineering applied to the nucleotide sequence of the virus notwithstanding. Moreover, evidence was trending (and continues to trend) in the direction that SARS-CoV-2 arose naturally and that its spillover into humans also occurred naturally, most likely at the Wuhan wet market. Basically, taking a look at the totality of the evidence, lab leak as an origin for the virus is, while not impossible, incredibly unlikely, but that hasn’t stopped conspiracy theorists, including a number of prominent legislators, from promoting the conspiracy theory as a way of attacking China and promoting doubt about science and vaccines.
Of course, to Tucker, the whole idea of zoonotic spillover at the Wuhan wet market as the origin of SARs-CoV-2 and the COVID-19 pandemic was a coverup by “Them” to shift blame from the Wuhan Institute of Virology:
That’s when the effort began to shift blame over to the wet markets in Wuhan and scientifically back the idea of natural origins. They had to work very fast, but the result was the famed “proximal origins” article, published in early February, which was backed up by a stream of NIH-funded scientists labeling the claim of lab origin as conspiracy theory. The media backed the claim with censorship of anyone saying otherwise.
Actually, that paper was a good synthesis of what was known at the time, based on the newly published nucleotide sequence of the novel coronavirus, the history of virology and pandemics, and observations related to where the first outbreaks occurred. It was imperfect, but, in retrospect, not wrong. While Tucker doesn’t go so far down the rabbit hole as to claim that the “lab leak” had been intentional, he does claim that “They” saw it as an opportunity to push mRNA vaccines:
So far so good, but there was still the problem of the virus itself. That’s where the antidote labeled a vaccine came into play. This effort began in January too: the opportunity to deploy mRNA technology. It had been stuck in research for some 20 years but had never gained regulatory approval through conventional means. But with a pandemic declared, and the fix relabelled as a military countermeasure, the entire regulatory apparatus could be bypassed, along with all indemnifications pushed through and even taxpayer funding.
The people behind the lab disaster would become heroes instead of villains.
How convenient. But how? I think you can guess what’s coming next:
Speed was always an issue. How can a vaccine be produced, distributed, and injected into the world’s population before the pandemic has already passed through the population, ending the same way as every other such episode in history, namely through exposure and resulting immunological upgrades?
If that happened, the vaccine would be superfluous and the pharma would miss their chance to demonstrate the wonders of a technological promise that had consumed them for twenty-plus years.
Got it? After the “lab leak” of SARS-CoV-2, “They” (big pharma, with the complicity of, presumably, the US government, medical profession, and public health apparatus) saw an opportunity for Profit with a capital “P,” by pushing mRNA vaccines. Why mRNA vaccines in particular? Tucker never really explains in any coherent manner other than that mRNA technology was “new.” Of course, mRNA technology wasn’t really that “new.” As Tucker readily admitted, it had been around for a couple of decades in development for various purposes, mostly cancer therapy but also as a novel vaccine platform. But apparently the profit motive was too strong, and “They” saw their opportunity.
According to Tucker, that’s where—you guessed it!—the “lockdowns” came in:
That’s where the lockdowns come in. Here is where the plan gets truly insidious. The idea was to come up with some way in which the antidote would gain the credit for having solved the pandemic that supposedly emerged from a wet market. The new technology would get the credit and then obtain generalized approval for a new form of health care that could be applied to myriad maladies in the future. Everyone would get rich. And Big Pharma and Fauci would be the heroes.
Apart from convincing Donald Trump to authorize the wrecking of his prized economy (which is a story unto itself), the vexing problem with the plan was timing. There was likely no way to get this released to the population for at least 9 months or perhaps more. It could be sooner in the future, perhaps 100 days, but the first time out would require more time.
It’s not that the planners were in denial of natural immunity. They were simply against depending on it or even tolerating it when they could test out a new product on the population.
Surprise! Surprise! Surely you knew that “natural immunity” would enter the picture soon. Tucker’s entire idea is that he and the three scientists who had served as his useful idiots to propose the Great Barrington Declaration had been right all along! You remember the Great Barrington Declaration, right? It was the Declaration issued by three scientists—Stanford’s Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, Harvard’s Dr. Martin Kulldorff, and Oxford’s Dr. Sunetra Gupta—under the auspices of the “free market” right wing organization where Jeffrey Tucker had been employed at the time (the American Institute for Economic Research) that proposed, in essence, letting COVID-19 rip among the “healthy” population while supposedly using “focused protection” to keep those most at risk of severe complications and death from COVID-19 safe. It was a profoundly eugenicist document, given that they provided no good concrete policies or strategies for “focused protection” and thus basically boiled down to letting the elderly and those with chronic health problems die of COVID-19 given that the risk to the young and healthy was so much lower. Even more risibly, the Great Barrington Declaration claimed that, if its approach were followed, “natural herd immunity” could be achieved in six months.
Of course, as Jonathan Howard and I have long discussed, the Great Barrington Declaration was always a pipe dream. The reasons were simple. First, “natural herd immunity” requires either lifelong immunity to a disease after infection or, at minimum, very long-lasting postinfection immunity, such as for measles. We knew right from the beginning that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, does not meet that criteria, as was pointed out in the John Snow Memorandum, which noted that coronaviruses generally do not produce long-lived post infection immunity. Even worse, coronaviruses are very good at evolving to evade immunity from prior infections, a characteristic that led to the Delta and Omicron waves. Also, the “vulnerable” population was estimated to be as high as 30%, meaning that protecting them could not be nearly as focused as the Great Barrington Declaration seemed to assume. As I said, this was a very eugenicist, “screw the weak” kind of document.
Note how Tucker’s narrative promotes him and the useful idiots whom he recruited to write the Great Barrington Declaration as the heroes by claiming that the reason for the “lockdowns” and all the public health interventions that so damaged the economies of so many nations was because “They” were in a race against natural herd immunity to get their vaccines out, the better to claim credit for ending the pandemic, instead of just letting nature take its course and letting the virus cull the weak and elderly, while just inconveniencing the young and healthy (except, of course, for what Tucker considered the inconsequential number of “young and healthy” who did die of the virus despite being young and healthy). As is the case in conspiracy theories, those positing them receive great ego gratification in portraying themselves as the heroes with “hidden knowledge.” He even makes it quite explicit:
The objective in this little game must be to preserve population-wide immunological naivete for the entire period. Exposure needed to be minimized to keep seroprevalence levels at their lowest possible point, perhaps no more than 10 or 20 percent and certainly below 50 percent. The only possible path here was to insist on as little human-to-human contact as possible.
Hence: lockdown. Forced human separation. Not just for two weeks. The protocol needed to be maintained for 9-11 months. Nothing like this had ever been attempted in human history, especially not on a global level. But maybe it would work, thanks to online commerce, work-from-home tools, and a properly panicked population that had not been through anything like this in many generations.
Thus did the plan commence. There were slogans: “flatten the curve,” “slow the spread,” and so on. They all amounted to the same thing: prolong the pain as long as possible to get ready for mass injections.
This is why people were told to stay inside. AA meetings had to be canceled. The gyms were closed. There could be no church services, concerts, weddings, or funerals. There had to be Plexiglas at all merchant locations. Restaurants had to close or be only at half capacity. This was the reason for the masking, a lame ritual but a good symbol of disease avoidance. The travel restrictions were the same. Media messaging would be to demonize all infections and raise constant panic about any exposure.
And, of course, this nefarious plot, not just science and evidence, was the reason for the hostile reaction to Tucker’s Great Barrington Declaration:
It’s also why there was such a hysterical reaction to the Great Barrington Declaration. The problem was not its opposition to lockdowns as such. The problem was this sentence: “all populations will eventually reach herd immunity – i.e. the point at which the rate of new infections is stable – and that this can be assisted by (but is not dependent upon) a vaccine.” Further, with full and immediate opening, “society as a whole enjoys the protection conferred upon the vulnerable by those who have built up herd immunity.”
Nope. Again, as I pointed out, the Great Barrington Declaration was built on dubious science and false assumptions. Moving on from just his hurt ego that it was mainly cranks and conspiracy theorists who promoted the Great Barrington Declaration, Tucker even makes it more explicit that everything was done in the service of making sure that the mRNA vaccines—and only the mRNA vaccines—would “save the day:
The goal of all of it was to keep natural immunity from ruining the chance for the mRNA shots to save the day. That is also why we could not have off-the-shelf therapeutics. There could be no Ivermectin or Hydroxychloroquine, not because they didn’t work but precisely because they did. The last thing the pandemic planners wanted was a cure that was not mRNA.
This is also why the J&J shot was taken off the market very quickly on the grounds that it was generating blood clots. It was not a mRNA shot. And it was in competition with the preferred technology so it had to be knocked out. So too with AstraZeneca, which was also not part of the mRNA platform.
Keep in mind the perversity here: the goal was not health but sickness as long as possible, to be cured by a new technology. That was always the game plan.
See what I mean? It wasn’t enough just for vaccines to “save the day.” It had to be the mRNA vaccines. Why? Again, it’s never made clear. Just because the mRNA vaccines were based on a “new” platform for vaccines that had been under development but had not yet produced a commercially viable product, vaccine or other class. Moreover, so pervasive was the plot, any effective therapeutic had to be “suppressed.” (Never mind that neither ivermectin nor hydroxychloroquine, nor any of the other dubious “protocols” to treat COVID-19 were ever demonstrated to be effective.)
Of course, like all good conspiracy theories, Tucker’s narrative has a germ of truth greatly distorted in it. There is no doubt that there was hope that vaccines could end the pandemic. However, one must remember that, in March 2020, there was no way of knowing that mRNA vaccines could be developed, tested in preclinical models, and then validated in large clinical trials in years, much less in nine months. Indeed, I remember how early in the pandemic many of us were lamenting that an effective vaccine was likely years away—or might never be developed! Tucker’s revisionist history is persuasive only in retrospect, because we know now that the vaccines received emergency use approval from the FDA in December 2020, a mere nine months after the World Health Organization had declared a pandemic. Moreover, Tucker neglects to note that “lockdowns,” as difficult as they were, didn’t last nearly long enough to accomplish what he claims.
That’s why I laughed out loud when I reached the end of Tucker’s post, in which he claims the “entire episode became history’s biggest grift” and then admitted “problems” with his hypothesis. Two are predictable, but this one made me laugh:
First, the lockdowns were nearly universal at the same time, not just in the US and UK. How would the motivations described above apply to nearly every country in the world?
Why indeed? It never occurs to Tucker that maybe—just maybe—it was because they were following longtime, established public health interventions and that maybe—just maybe—big pharma isn’t powerful enough to compel so many nations to impose “lockdowns.” Basically, while he admits that this is a hole in his conspiracy theory, Tucker just glosses over how the implausibility is. The other two, of course, are standard antivax talking points, such as his claim that “They” had to keep the seroprevalence as low as possible in order to make it look as though the vaccines saved the day and that “They” knew that the vaccines didn’t work, even though they did; they just didn’t prevent transmission as much as hoped. (It’s a standard antivax trope that if vaccines are not 100% effective in stopping transmission, they don’t work.)
I long knew that the Brownstone Institute would devolve into conspiracy theories. After all, the Brownstone Institute has been spreading antivax and right wing conspiracy theories ever since it was founded a couple of years ago by Tucker, who is a neo-Confederate activist who had helped organize the Great Barrington Declaration, that document advocating his eugenicist “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic to build up “natural herd immunity” as rapidly as possible by letting the virus circulate through the “healthy population” while claiming to have a strategy to “protect the vulnerable.” Never mind that they never actually had such a strategy other than platitudes used to browbeat public health officials and that “natural herd immunity” never would have worked as a strategy given how easily SARS-CoV-2 could evolve new variants to evade immunity from infection with previous variants.
I also suspect that there is a reason why Tucker’s conspiracy theory closely resembles Toby Rogers’ conspiracy theory. Rogers had presented it at the Brownstone Institute:
Last week I traveled to Connecticut to participate in a four-day writers’ retreat hosted by Jeffrey Tucker and the Brownstone Institute. It was amazing. Speakers presented on a topic or question for 15 minutes that was followed by a discussion for 15 minutes.
        ◦ Predictably, the Brownstone Institute has completed its “evolution” from a mere ideological “think tank” designed to spread the Great Barrington Declaration into a more all purpose conspiracy promotion machine. It was always going to be thus, given how all antivax is conspiracy theory. In Tucker’s case, just replace big pharma and the WHO for the CDC and amp up the stakes, and it’s the same conspiracy theory. I’m just waiting to see if Tucker will involve aliens in the plot.

Does the Mass Infection of Unvaccinated Young People Follow the “Basic Principles of Public Health”?
A pictorial refutation to a central claim of the Great Barrington Declaration.
Jonathan Howard on October 7, 2022
Link

The Great Barrington Declaration
The core premise behind the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was called “focused protection”. It was based on the fantastical notion that people could be easily divided into “vulnerable” and “invulnerable” categories and that the two groups could be completely walled off from each other for the duration of the pandemic. According to the GBD, once enough invulnerable people were infected, they would be immune to reinfection, the virus would vanish, and vulnerable people would emerge from isolation unscathed. As they confused their desires with reality, outside of vague, unworkable measures to “protect the vulnerable”, the authors of the GBD opposed any and all means to limit the virus, including vaccinating young people.
The GBD found a receptive audience in parts of the Trump administration, which adopted a “we want them infected” philosophy, and aside from advocating vaccines for children, the CDC had largely adopted their policies. A million deaths later, we are living in the world they envisioned, and if they are correct, we will have herd immunity by February 2023 at the latest. We’ll see.
“Basic principles of public health”
However, a frequent claim of the GBD authors is that the mass infection of unvaccinated children and young people merely represented a return to the “basic principles of public health”.
This is a bold claim. Is it true? Did public health officials purposefully infect people to contain past outbreaks? As some viruses are more dangerous to adults than children, exposing healthy people to viruses wasn’t entirely unreasonable in the pre-vaccine era so long as the first infection created robust, permanent immunity – which does not seem to be the case with COVID-19.
George Washington famously ordered his troops inoculated against smallpox using a procedure known as variolation. This was an ancient precursor to vaccination, in which people had smallpox injected into their skin. It was still risky, though much less risky than contracting smallpox naturally, and the discovery of the smallpox vaccine relegated this practice to the history books. Additionally, some parents would expose their children to chickenpox, as the disease is milder in children than adults. However, this was not a universally accepted practice even before the vaccine, and once a vaccine was available, only anti-vaxxers exposed their children to the virus. They were rightfully criticized for it. Children have the right to be protected against diseases that can hurt them. It’s a basic principle of public health that no child should suffer from a virus when a vaccine can limit these harms.
While there is some precedent for purposefully infecting people with viruses, this was done for the benefit of the individual, not to “protect the vulnerable”, and outside of fringe anti-vaxxers, such purposeful infections ended once vaccines became available. I’ve not seen the GBD authors use these particular examples as evidence supporting their position, nor could I find historical examples of public health officials exposing young people to a virus after a vaccine was available.
In fact, measures opposed by the GBD have been widespread in American history. For example, during a cholera outbreak in1866,
Sanitary efforts of the New York Board of Health in 1866, including inspections, immediate case reporting, complaint investigations, evacuations, and disinfection of possessions and living quarters, kept an outbreak of cholera to a small number of cases. “The mildness of the epidemic was no more a stroke of good fortune, observers agreed, but the result of careful planning and hard work by the new health board.” (Rosenberg, 1962) Cities without a public system for monitoring and combatting the disease fared far worse in the 1866 epidemic.
While these principles were not consistent with the GBD, their value was evident to people at the time. A book from 1919 titled Epidemics: How to Meet Them declared:
Science has made remarkable strides during the past century. The diseases which proved such a scourge in the past have been practically eliminated. It would be considered a disgrace to any civilized community to have an epidemic of smallpox, cholera, or yellow fever. We pride ourselves upon our success in eradicating these diseases.
Later, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of compulsory vaccination laws, and public health authorities would use measures opposed by the GBD to try to prevent polio. According to news reports:
In the summer of 1948, a polio outbreak in San Diego cancelled large gatherings, closed playgrounds, pools and camps, and delayed the opening of public schools in the region.
COVID-19 versus 1918 pandemic
However, the best comparison for COVID in modern times is clearly the 1918 flu pandemic, though a crucial difference was that the average age of death during that pandemic was 28 years. However, it was still a virus and people used public health measures opposed by the GBD to try to contain it. In in 2007, Drs. Richard J. Hatchett, Carter E. Mecher, and Marc Lipsitch examined 19 classes of nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) in 17 U.S. cities during the 1918 pandemic. They found:
Cities in which multiple interventions were implemented at an early phase of the epidemic had peak death rates ≈50% lower than those that did not and had less-steep epidemic curves. Cities in which multiple interventions were implemented at an early phase of the epidemic also showed a trend toward lower cumulative excess mortality, but the difference was smaller (≈20%) and less statistically significant than that for peak death rates. This finding was not unexpected, given that few cities maintained NPIs longer than 6 weeks in 1918. Early implementation of certain interventions, including closure of schools, churches, and theaters, was associated with lower peak death rates, but no single intervention showed an association with improved aggregate outcomes for the 1918 phase of the pandemic. These findings support the hypothesis that rapid implementation of multiple NPIs can significantly reduce influenza transmission, but that viral spread will be renewed upon relaxation of such measures.
So in 1918, doing the exact opposite of what the GBD suggested saved lives.
Additionally, I’ve collected images from then to provide a sense of what these NPIs were. It all looks very familiar. There were quarantines, masks everywhere on everyone, calls for ventilation, remote learning, and prohibitions of “nonessential crowds”. You’ll see everything the GBD has successfully fought against. There was even an anti-mask league and quack cures like Pluto Water. Of course, there were overflowing hospitals and mass graves too.
Though the GBD authors claim they represent the “basic principles of public health”, I was unable to find any evidence from any prior epidemics where public health authorities purposefully exposed unvaccinated children and young people to a dangerous pathogen after a vaccine was available, using them as human shields to “protect the vulnerable”. However, a very dangerous precedent has now been set. So, on the miniscule chance anyone is reading this during a pandemic a hundred years from now, please know that only anti-vaccine, laptop class doctors supported this idea. Those of us who actually treated COVID patients thought the “basic principles of public health” as espoused by the GBD did nothing but ensure our hospitals were overflowing with patients.

Should An Infectious Disease Epidemiologist Comment on Child Vaccination?
Yes!
Jonathan Howard on February 11, 2022
Link

Unkind, largely unqualified, and highly judgmental
My Twitter bio reads that I am “unkind, largely unqualified, and highly judgmental.” This colorful description comes courtesy of Professor Francis Balloux, the chair of computational biology at the University College London. I earned this opprobrium for saying that while there are many viruses (HPV, VZV, HBV, HIV, polio) with sequelae that emerge after the initial infection, I was generally not aware of such long-term side effects from vaccines. Professor Balloux disagreed, saying my comment was,
So extraordinarily uninformed in the context of COVID-19 that it belongs in the league of “SARS-CoV-2 has never been isolated”, “the vaccine alters your DNA”, “Omicron is a mutant hybrid between a coronavirus and rhinovirus” takes.
My position is that SARS-CoV-2 is a new virus and we have to be humble about the possibility of long-term consequences, especially compared to the vaccine. I want to error on the side of caution. If someone feels I am unkind, largely unqualified, and highly judgmental for this reason, I am prepared to live with their condemnation.
Beyond this, Professor Balloux said that I was “threatening” him when I announced my intention to write this essay. I wrote previously how histrionically labeling potential written criticism as “threatening” is itself an attempt to pre-emptively silence or discredit one’s critics. It can be very effective. Who wants to be seen as “threatening” a famous professor who has advised top government officials? Not me. I don’t ever want to be seeing as threatening anyone.
But everyone can relax. None of my previous essays contained any threats, and this one is no different. Rather, I’m just going to share my thoughts on a few of Professor Balloux’s tweets. That’s it.
“Healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later”
With this in mind, let’s examine the first of those tweets. It said:
I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.
“A disease can be endemic and both widespread and deadly”
First let’s talk about the use of the word “endemicity” here, because it sure seems as if Professor Balloux believes this is a very desirable goal. To my reading at least, he gives the impression that things might be much better if we can only “send SARCoV2 into endemicity”. Of course I hope this is true, but not every epidemiologist sees it this way. In a sobering essay called “COVID-19: Endemic Doesn’t Mean Harmless“, Dr. Aris Katzourakis, a professor who studies viral evolution and genomics at the University of Oxford, wrote:
The word ‘endemic’ has become one of the most misused of the pandemic. And many of the errant assumptions made encourage a misplaced complacency. It doesn’t mean that COVID-19 will come to a natural end.
To an epidemiologist, an endemic infection is one in which overall rates are static — not rising, not falling. More precisely, it means that the proportion of people who can get sick balances out the ‘basic reproduction number’ of the virus, the number of individuals that an infected individual would infect, assuming a population in which everyone could get sick. Yes, common colds are endemic. So are Lassa fever, malaria and polio. So was smallpox, until vaccines stamped it out.
In other words, a disease can be endemic and both widespread and deadly. Malaria killed more than 600,000 people in 2020. Ten million fell ill with tuberculosis that same year and 1.5 million died. Endemic certainly does not mean that evolution has somehow tamed a pathogen so that life simply returns to ‘normal’.
Basically, endemic COVID-19 might still be dangerous COVID-19, the way endemic measles infected, hospitalized, and even killed children every year before the vaccine.
“This makes no sense, and is hard to distinguish from anti-vaxxer rhetoric”
Next let’s examine Professor Balloux’s suggestion that to achieve endemicity “healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later”. This is false. Infants have the highest risk of dying of all children. In the USA, 200 infants died from COVID-19 compared to 87 deaths in children ages 1-4 years. Doctors who actually treat children know this. Dr. Pieter Peach said:
There are some exposures to viruses that are best delayed until someone isn’t an infant with small diameter, irritable airways, or until they or their siblings have had a chance to get vaccinated against them.
Telling parents that it’s always better to expose their children to the virus “ideally earlier than later” is dangerously wrong for this reason alone. We do not want parents to falsely think that babies are entirely spared by this virus, when in fact they are the most vulnerable. Scientists who communicate with the public under the guise of being an expert on a deadly virus should strive to be accurate and thorough, even if that means being less edgy on social media.
However, Professor Balloux’s broader point is obviously true – children generally fare much better with COVID-19 than adults. Although it’s frontloading the risk, it may be preferable for people to catch some viruses as children. While I don’t think parents ever had “polio parties”, my mom exposed me to chickenpox as a child, and I don’t think she’s a sociopath. This all may make some sense in a world without vaccines.
However, this is not the blessed world in which we live! My children were vaccinated against chickenpox. They were vaccinated against COVID-19. Professor Balloux’s comment might have been perfectly reasonable had he prefaced it by saying, “were I trying to protect children from COVID-19 in the year 1767, here’s what I’d do”.
Even though it’s 2022 and we have effective vaccines, Professor Balloux did not mention them, at least not initially. I was not the only one who noticed this curious omission in his statement that “healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later”. Many people pointed out that actually, healthy children don’t have to be exposed to the virus right now. They can be vaccinated first.
Dr. Stephen Griffin voiced this sentiment by saying:
No Francois, that is an appalling statement. You may have said this to provoke debate, but how can you seriously advocate putting children in harms way when there’s a safe and effective vaccine available? These are not numbers, these are children, including vulnerable kids.
He’s right.
Someone else commented:
The reason you can’t think of an acceptable way to convey this, is that it is not acceptable. It is also not standard epidemiology. We have safe and effective vaccines. This makes no sense, and is hard to distinguish from anti-vaxxer rhetoric.
He’s right too. I’ve read a ton of anti-vaxxer rhetoric. The notion that “healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later” would not seem at all out of place in an anti-vaccine essay. If you wanted to tweak Professor Balloux’s tweet to convince a friend it came from an anti-vaccine super crank like Dr. Joseph Mercola, what exactly would you change? Very little it seems. In fact, Dr. Mercola wrote that, “having healthy, unvaccinated children in the population is crucial to achieving herd immunity”. Of course, getting immunity to the virus by getting the virus is a bit like giving away all your money to ensure nobody ever robs you. It works, but…
“You may have failed to understand because you’re not an infectious disease epidemiologist. I didn’t comment on child vaccination.”
In response to his many critics, Professor Balloux said that his “point was not whether healthy children should be vaccinated against Covid or not”. He further explained to a critic that:
You may have failed to understand because you’re not an infectious disease epidemiologist. I didn’t comment on child vaccination. I just stated that SARSCoV2 becoming endemic would imply children being exposed, and earlier would be better than later given the age risk profile.
Well, I’m not an infectious disease epidemiologist either, so maybe I am failing to understand too, but this strikes me as an odd statement. Is there a secret oath of silence that forbids infectious disease epidemiologists from commenting on child vaccination? I doubt it, especially considering there is robust evidence that the vaccine can prevent rare, but catastrophic outcomes in adolescents. To me, discussing vaccines sounds like part of the core job description of infectious disease epidemiologists, especially when they communicate with the general public on social media.
Professor Balloux announced his intention to respond to my essay. I won’t say he is “threatening” me when he writes his rebuttal, “No, An Infectious Disease Epidemiologist Shouldn’t Comment on Child Vaccination“. I look forward to learning the reasons why an infectious disease epidemiologist should not comment on child vaccination when discussing a virus for which an effective vaccine exists. Maybe I’ll learn something.
“Vaccinating healthy ≤12 year olds makes hardly difference to them directly”
Assuming there is no infectious disease epidemiologist code of omertà regarding child vaccination, this raises an important question. Why would someone refuse to comment on child vaccination when an extremely effective vaccine exists? If a patient was diagnosed with a condition that carried a low, but non-zero risk of serious illness or even death, his doctor would be guilty of obvious malpractice if she neglected to tell him there was a safe and effective treatment. The negligence would be compounded if, when asked about that specific treatment, the doctor said it was unnecessary.
This brings me to the final tweet I will discuss. In response to a questioner who asked “with all due respect, why are we exposing them before vaccinating them?” Professor Balloux responded:
This is an interesting question. Vaccinating healthy ≤12 year olds makes hardly difference to them directly, however we look at it. It has some indirect impact on the dynamic of the pandemic, though. It all depends on what we hope to maximise/minimise.
This is an interesting question, but not for the reasons Professor Balloux thinks. The questioner was right. We are exposing many children to the virus before we are vaccinating them. Why are we doing this?
We are doing this because some influential people don’t care if children get the virus, while other influential people actively want children to get the virus. Professor Balloux was absolutely right when he said “It all depends on what we hope to maximise/minimise”. I very much want to minimize the number of children who encounter this virus before they are vaccinated. Other people very much want to maximize this number.
There is a bizarre and dangerous line of thought that it is beneficial for children to get COVID-19. As far as I know, this notion originated early in the pandemic when Dr. John Ioannidis lamented that children might avoid the virus saying, “school closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”.
According to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, 1,247 American children have died since Dr. Ioannidis made that statement, and over 100,000 children have been hospitalized, some of them very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU. There have been 6,851 cases of MIS-C. Up to 80% of these children require treatment in the ICU. MIS-C has killed 59 children. A great many people refuse to acknowledge these grim numbers, which would have been much higher had nothing been done to “diminish the chances of developing herd immunity” in children.
The movement to infect children was formalized in the pro-virus Great Barrington Declaration, which now opposes vaccinating children. Unfortunately, this group has been very successful. They can take a lot of credit for both low vaccination rates and high infection rates in children. Even today, after Omicron hospitalized a record number of sick children, the notion that the virus is beneficial for children still persists.
In an article called “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?”, Drs. Vinay Prasad and Allison Krug wrote “For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life”. They said that “even unvaccinated children generally do well after Covid-19 infection” and “Immunity is built through illness”. This article favorably quoted Professor Balloux’s tweet that advocated exposing healthy kids to the virus, ideally earlier than later. It did not urge parents to vaccinate their children, nor did it mention that 1,247 deceased children didn’t build immunity through illness. These type of articles never do, though the authors would bristle with disbelief if you suggested this position was in any way “anti-vaccine”.
Thankfully the idea that COVID-19 was beneficial for children carried no weight with American regulators when they issued their Emergency Use Authorization for pediatric vaccines. Unfortunately, things were different in the England. As I discussed previously, some members of the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation advocated using infected children as a means to “boost immunity in adults through exposure”. They said “natural infection in children could have substantial long-term benefits on COVID-19 in the England”. I meant it when I said there are people who believe it is beneficial for children to get COVID-19. In August 2021, Professor Balloux endorsed the JCVI’s decision not to vaccinate children, saying “I think the JCVI has probably been right to err on the side of caution”.
To be clear, the JCVI erred on the side of the virus, not on the side of caution. There is nothing cautious about letting a novel virus run rampant in children when an effective vaccine is available to them. Predictably, in October 2021, the headlines declared “Children Drive Britain’s Longest-Running Covid Surge“. Unvaccinated children are currently getting sick and missing school in England. Just like in the US, the virus, not fantasized lockdowns, disrupted schools, though cases are thankfully dropping fast here. Children in England suffered more this winter than any time during the entire pandemic.
Meanwhile, there is very preliminary evidence that, like many viruses, SARS-CoV-2 might lead to long term complications in some children after all, namely diabetes. We have a lot to learn about this virus. Doctors who actually treat sick children see it this way too. Their dedication to children strikes me as kind, extremely qualified, and not at all judgmental. To rule out the potential of prolonged COVID-19 symptoms in children is basically to call these doctors and their patients liars. Not all children feel 100% back to normal after having COVID-19, though most do.
Vaccinating children is erring on the side of caution
Anyone who wants to err on the side of caution would strongly advocate vaccinating children. The vaccine was safe and effective in preventing SARS-CoV-2 infection in children ages 5-11 years in the clinical trial, though it was not large enough to show that the vaccine prevented severe outcomes or to detect rare side effects. Not enough time has elapsed to collect and synthesize much real-world data regarding the efficacy of the vaccine in children this age. It took several months before that data emerged in adolescents, but there now are multiple studies showing the vaccine is effective in keeping them healthy and out of the hospital.
Those who communicate about children and COVID-19 should be extremely eager to share this vital information with the public. It’s really very easy to do.
    • Study 1: In hospitalized adolescents, “179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.”
    • Study 2: “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents.”
    • Study 3: “Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one was fully vaccinated.”
    • Study 4: Vaccine effectiveness “was 92% against SARS-CoV-2 infections irrespective of symptom status.”
    • Study 5: “97/102 children with MIS-C were unvaccinated. None of the 5 vaccinated MIS-C patients required respiratory or cardiovascular life support (invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or ECMO) compared to 38/97 unvaccinated MIS-C patients.”
    • Study 6: “In 33 adolescents with MIS-C eligible for vaccination, “0 had been fully vaccinated, 7 had received 1 dose.”
    • Study 7: “Of the case patients, 180 (40%) were admitted to the ICU, and 127 (29%) required life support; only 2 patients in the ICU had been fully vaccinated. The overall effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine against hospitalization for Covid-19 was 94%. The effectiveness was 98% against ICU admission and 98% against Covid-19 resulting in the receipt of life support. All 7 deaths occurred in patients who were unvaccinated.”
“Caution” isn’t always cautious
In case you just skimmed those studies, I’ll highlight that essentially all children who needed life support were unvaccinated, and all children who died were unvaccinated. It’s a scandal that so many contrarian doctors have pontificated profusely about the dangers of vaccinating children without even mentioning these studies exist. A lot of parents don’t know how effective these vaccines are at keeping children safe. Their pandemic sources only discuss one thing, and it’s not any of the seven studies above.
Data about the vaccine for younger children is emerging, and unsurprisingly it parallels data for adolescents. Pediatricians across the country are saying the same exact same thing – it is unvaccinated children who are being hospitalized with COVID-19. For example, a children’s hospital in Texas reported that “of all the pediatric COVID patients they admitted in January, 91% had not been vaccinated”. Of course, not enough children have been vaccinated, and that’s the problem.
During New York’s recent Omicron surge 91% of 5- to 11-year-olds who were hospitalized with COVID were unvaccinated (20% of the children that age were fully vaccinated overall). 54% of children admitted to the hospital had no comorbidities, and there were very few incidental admissions. Vaccinating these healthy children absolutely would have made a difference to them directly, and anyone who claims otherwise is wrong.
Moreover, the vaccine is incredibly safe in children under 12. After 8.7 million vaccine doses, there were just 11 verified myocarditis cases. 7 of these children have recovered and 4 were “recovering”. No child in the entire world has died from the vaccine as far as I know.
The vaccine has absolutely saved the lives of some healthy American children and prevented many more from being hospitalized. I suspect that when we look back at the decisions regulators made this pandemic, the generally slow pace in authorizing vaccines for children older will be seen as a mistake.
I recognize regulators have an impossible job. They’ll be second guessed by social media stars with no real-world responsibility no matter what they do. While regulators need to wait to ensure that vaccines are safe and effective, there is also a price for prolonged waiting. Children under 5 years can still not get vaccinated, though I am hopeful that we will soon see data showing the vaccine prevents COVID-19 in children this age.
Sadly, COVID-19 spread rapidly through children this winter, and the Omicron variant took a nasty toll on many young children this winter. Remember, 200 infants have died of COVID-19. The American Academy of Pediatrics added 21 children to its grim death tally this week alone, as it has basically every week for the past 6 months.
“Caution” isn’t always cautious.
The vaccine will make all the difference to some children
The claim that vaccinating “healthy ≤12 year olds makes hardly (any) difference to them directly” would be true if COVID-19 posed zero risk to healthy children or the vaccine were useless. Again, this is not the world in which we live. The vast majority of children do just fine with COVID-19, especially healthy children, but not all. Given that millions of children have been infected in the UK and USA, these rare harms have added up. It’s true that the vaccine won’t make a difference to most children.
But it will make all the difference to some children.
Many arguments against vaccinating children simply boil down to, the vaccine won’t save the lives of that many children, so there’s really no point. I don’t think that’s a very good argument, especially considering about 20% of COVID-19 deaths are in healthy children, and healthy, unvaccinated children have died of COVID-19 after the vaccine was available.
Standard anti-vaccine blather
Arguing that vaccines are unnecessary since the diseases they prevent harm only a very small percentage of children is standard anti-vaccine blather. In fact, I’d argue that the two central pillars of anti-vaccine ideology are that vaccines are dangerous while the diseases they prevent are benign. For example, Dr. Mercola stated in his anti-vaccine article that COVID-19 is a disease with “practically zero risk of dying from as a child or adolescent”.
Does this sound familiar? It will if you’ve read anything I’ve written here before. Every doctor I’ve criticized here previously has said essentially the same thing. Like Dr. Mercola, these doctors long ago chained themselves to the idea that “COVID is mild for children,” and even after 1,247 deaths and 100,000 hospitalizations, there’s nothing that can shake that belief.
It may be true that any individual child’s risk of dying of COVID-19 is “practically zero”, but there’s a world of difference between “practically zero” and actually zero when tens of millions of children get infected. 1,247 dead children is a tragically large number of dead children, which is why the doctors I’ve criticized never share that number. Neither does Dr. Mercola. Unbelievably, they all still insist on comparing it to the flu, a disease that killed 6 children during this year. We vaccinate children against the flu. Most of us don’t want any child to die because the missed a vaccine. This is not a very controversial opinion.
Moreover, the argument that vaccinating healthy children “makes hardly difference to them directly” could be said of many vaccine-preventable diseases. If all vaccines vanished tomorrow, most kids, especially healthy ones, wouldn’t die. The vast majority of kids who contracted measles, rubella, mumps, HPV, VZV, and even poliovirus did not suffer grave harms. Yet, once vaccines for these viruses because available, it became bog-standard infectious disease practice to give them to children, thankfully. These vaccines have spared much suffering for children and their families. So has the COVID-19 vaccine.
At this point, what difference is there really between someone who denies the value of other vaccines and someone who denies the value of just the COVID-19 vaccine? Not much that I can see. Other vaccines have a much longer safety profile and that matters, but COVID-19 is circulating right now. Millions of American children have gotten COVID-19 this year, compared to zero measles cases so far. If the parent of an unvaccinated child was only willing to get one vaccine for his child, the MMR or the COVID-19 vaccine, I’d suggest the COVID-19 vaccine in a heartbeat.
Fortunately, pediatric hospitalizations are declining from their peak, when just under 1,000 children were hospitalized daily. Still, a large number of children have yet to contract the virus, and it is never going away. We should do everything we can to protect children with the vaccine, not undermine this effort. It’s a tragedy that pediatric vaccination rates are so low.
“We should have zero tolerance for any school-aged child to develop severe COVID”
Of course infectious disease epidemiologists are allowed to talk about child vaccination. Most of them do. They’re the ones who don’t need to clarify that their ideas aren’t “eugenism”.
In contrast other people decide not to share information about the vaccine. It’s a choice they make. Sadly, when it comes to children, many people, who claim to value “nuance” and “centrism” refuse to share any bad news about the virus or any good news about the vaccine. As I discussed previously, there absolutely is a code of silence about the potential dangers of the virus and the successes of the vaccine for children. However, those who abide by this code are not infectious disease epidemiologists, but rather contrarian doctors and scientists who will never work in a pediatric ICU, taking care of an intubated child. Sick children seem to be an abstraction for them, numbers on government websites.
I disagree. As Dr. Carter Mecher told me:
Pediatric deaths deserve special mention. Talk to any parent who lost a child for any reason. I’m not sure that they ever fully recover from that grief. We have a word for who is left behind when a spouse dies. We have a word for who is left behind when a parent with children dies. But we have no word for a parent left behind when a child dies.
He’s right. Imagine how upsetting it would be to have lost a child to COVID-19 and to constantly encounter highly-visible doctors and scientists – who don’t treat sick children – relentlessly minimize the virus that killed her at every opportunity. Wouldn’t it just be easier to encourage parents to vaccinate their children than to come with bizarre rationalizations as to why 1200 = 6?
Sadly, it’s easy for some people to minimize young victims of COVID-19 as long as they remain an abstraction. This all changes when someone uses their exact language to minimize a virus that affected someone in their family. It’s a horrible thing to lose a loved one to a terrible disease like AIDS.
It’s also a horrible thing to lose a loved one to a terrible disease like COVID-19. Dr. Griffin was right when he said, “These are not numbers, these are children, including vulnerable kids”. These children were someone else’s sisters and brothers. According to news reports, the sister of Jorja Halliday, a teenager who died from COVID-19 “says she cries herself to sleep every night, as she described the shock of losing her older sibling”. She looks too young to curse.
It’s worth it to read about some of the deceased children and the regret their parents feel about not vaccinating them. Landon Woodson’s mother implored parents to “Please Please Get Vaccinated“, after her son, a healthy football player, died of COVID-19. Similarly, Hector Ramirez, whose unvaccinated 15-year-old-daughter Victoria died this summer, said:
I don’t want any other parent to go through what I did — seeing my daughter perfectly healthy one day, then following a week and a half, she’s gone.
According to news reports, “He didn’t get the shot for his daughter, and he regrets it”.
Teresa Sperry’s parents became vaccine advocates after their daughter, who was not yet eligible to be vaccinated, died of COVID-19. “The only way this makes sense to me is if it saves people”, Jeff Sperry said. “We’re trying to help others so they don’t have to go through this”. Imagine how they must feel to see prominent scientists on social media, divorced from patient care, constantly undermine their effort.
The vaccine would have made a big difference to Landon, Victoria, Teresa, and many of the 81 American children or the 16 English children who died of COVID-19 in the past month. Pediatricians who actually have real-world responsibility for sick children know this. Drs. Jennifer Lighter and Stephanie Ungar recently said,
While it is reassuring that severe illness is rare in children infected with SARS-CoV-2, it can still occur. We should have zero tolerance for any school-aged child to develop severe Covid, as vaccinations have made this scenario avoidable.
It is appalling this is a controversial statement considering the overwhelming evidence it is true.
Sometimes what people don’t tell you is much more revealing than what they do
COVID-19 is here to stay. Contrarian doctors who harbored fantasies that COVID-19 would melt away, obviating the need for pediatric vaccines now instead extol the virtues of “natural immunity.” I fully agree that very few children will escape exposure to this virus over the course of their lifetimes. However, in fortunate parts of the world, their parents have a choice. Their child can encounter the virus with a vaccine or without a vaccine. The vast majority of children will be fine either way thankfully, but not all. A child’s chance of avoiding a rare but devastating harm is much lower with the vaccine.
Doctors and scientists who communicate with the public about COVID-19 and children also have a choice. They can share this fact or they can refuse to do so.
        ◦ Sometimes what people don’t tell you is much more revealing than what they do.

Incorrect Numbers
Having made them myself, I completely understand that doctors can make errors. However, I can’t fathom why some of them don’t seem to care about correcting them, especially considering the health of children is at stake.
Jonathan Howard on December 3, 2021
Link

An incorrect number
On October 6th, journalist Apoorva Mandavilli wrote in The New York Times that 900,000 American children had been hospitalized with COVID-19. Although the exact number of pediatric hospitalizations isn’t clear, this number seemed implausibly high to me. I asked Ms. Mandavilli for the source of this number on Twitter, and she responded by saying “it was supposed to have some other numbers to say what percent are kids of this number”. Though it seems to have been a genuine mistake, Ms. Mandavilli received harsh, but fair, feedback, with one critic saying:
Beyond the false numbers, this is a serious violation of an important standard for a science professional: the criterion of reasonableness. In science, if you come up with a result that’s unreasonable, that doesn’t make sense in the real world, there’s something wrong, and you must rethink your conclusions. If Mandavilli were paying attention to her work, that 900,000 number should have jumped out as being impossibly high. But it didn’t.
Whatever the reason for her mistake, Ms. Mandavilli did what she had to do – she acknowledged and corrected the error. Anyone who reads her article moving forward will find accurate information, and they will learn that the article initially contained inaccurate information. This is how it should be.
Another incorrect number
With this in mind, let’s examine a recent article in The Wall Street Journal by Drs. Nicole Saphier and Marty Makary titled, “Should You Vaccinate Your 5-Year-Old?” Even though I agreed with its ultimate conclusion that “vaccinating a healthy child would take his extremely low risk of serious disease and drive it down even lower”, the article was full of the predictable omissions, distortions, and standard COVID-19 minimization tactics I’ve discussed multiple times previously. Beyond these familiar flaws, the article reported that 562 children ages 5-11 years had been hospitalized with COVID-19. This is false and was easily recognizable as such by anyone familiar with this topic.
The authors likely found this number from a CDC presentation on 11/2/2021 that reported numbers from COVID-NET.
As the fine print on the bottom of the slide says, “COVID-NET is a population-based surveillance system that collects data on laboratory-confirmed COVID-19-associated hospitalizations among children and adults through a network of over 250 acute-care hospitals in 14 states”. The CDC’s website informs us that “COVID-NET covers approximately 10 percent of the U.S. population”. In other words, the true number of hospitalizations for this age group is likely to be 10 times higher than what Drs. Saphier and Makary reported. Indeed, the same CDC presentation reported that over 8,300 children this age have been hospitalized. This number is 15 times higher than what Drs. Saphier and Makary reported. As about 1/3 of hospitalized children go to the ICU, the number of children hospitalized there alone is 5 times higher than the total number of hospitalizations reported by Drs. Saphier and Makary.
There are two ways to look at their error. On the one hand, this was an easy mistake to make. I know because I made the exact same mistake myself earlier this year on Twitter. At that time, I was starting to familiarize myself with pediatric data in preparation for my first article here, and I too missed the fine print on COVID-NET. We are only human, and the best of us will make an honest error from time to time.
On the other hand, this error shows that Drs. Saphier and Makary were willing to pontificate about the COVID-19 vaccine for children in a national newspaper even though they were completely unfamiliar with the basic facts and datasets on this topic. During the peak of the Delta wave, nearly 70 children (of all ages) were being hospitalized every day in just Florida alone. One could even say:
Beyond the false numbers, this is a serious violation of an important standard for a science professional: the criterion of reasonableness. In science, if you come up with a result that’s unreasonable, that doesn’t make sense in the real world, there’s something wrong, and you must rethink your conclusions. If Drs. Saphier and Makary were paying attention to their work, that 562 number should have jumped out as being impossibly low. But it didn’t.
That Drs. Saphier and Makary reported an incorrect number tells us they were just like me this spring; careless and ignorant of the subject matter. Readers of Science Based Medicine know this about Dr. Makary already (here and here), and I doubt it would be worth another article to make this point alone.
However, the fact that the error remains uncorrected in their article is worth discussing. Though Dr. Makary blocked me on Twitter for the sin of discussing his failed predication the US would reach herd immunity in April, several other people shared my discussion of his most recent error with him and Dr. Saphier. Of course I can’t be certain they saw the correction, but their response thus far has been to do nothing. The error still remains in the article. Though countless people have been falsely pacified about the dangers of COVID-19 to children as a result of their error, the authors seem perfectly content to let misinformation be spread far and wide under their names.
An unfortunate pattern
Sadly, this is just another example of an unfortunate pattern of highly-credentialed doctors from top medical schools making and then shrugging off gross factual errors. For example, Dr. Makary’s easily falsifiable claim from June that not a “single healthy child in the U.S.” died of COVID-19 also remains uncorrected in the article in which it appeared. On Twitter, Dr. Makary continues to claim that “Based on the data of kids w/ NO comorbid, an estimated 0-10 kids 5-11 have ever died of Covid.” While I agree that it is extremely rare for healthy children to die of COVID-19, all it takes is a simple Google search to find several news stories of healthy children ages 5-11 who died from the virus (Skylar Herbert, Tagan White, Unnamed Boy, Kimora Lynum, Wyatt Gibson, Zyrin Foots, Unnamed Child.) Certainty, not all such deaths were reported in the news .
As I wrote previously, it seems that Dr. Makary, a professor at a top medical school who claims he reviewed “the medical literature and news reports” and talked to “pediatricians across the country”, actually didn’t bother to do the most basic fact-checking when he claimed no healthy American child had died of COVID-19. Unfortunately Dr. Makary’s myth has been parroted by anti-vaxx propagandist Tucker Carlson and misinformed politicians. As the expression goes, a lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes.
Dr. Makary does not just spread misinformation about the virus. In an attempt to convince people the vaccine will kill as many healthy boys as the virus, Dr. Makary also claimed on Twitter that a study in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) reported the death of a boy from vaccine-related myocarditis, and that as a result, “Approx 15 would die from the vax 2nd dose“. This too is false, though it gained approval from the sort of people who feel vaccines are part of a depopulation agenda.
As anyone who took one minute to search the supplementary material knows, the person who died in this study was a 22-year-old young adult, not a young boy. The tragic death of this single adult almost certainly has no relevance to vaccinating young children who are generally much less prone to myocarditis. Experts in the subject matter also corrected this erroneous Tweet several times, yet Dr. Makary has not removed it. Tens if not hundreds of thousands of people have seen it, and most of them were completely unaware they were reading misinformation. Like all reports on this topic, the same study from the NEJM also said that 95% of the vaccine-related myocarditis cases were “mild,” though Dr. Makary predictably neglected to report this fact or even provide a link to the study so people could read it themselves.
For the sake of accuracy, tens of millions of teenagers have been vaccinated around the world, and I am aware of just one potential death of a 17-year-old who received the Moderna vaccine, which will not be given to children in the USA. The CDC investigated several deaths here in the US, and thus far, no adolescents are known to have died from the vaccine.
Professors should be held to the same standards as medical students
There are countless other examples of contrarian doctors making similar errors of basic facts this pandemic, and aside from a few healthcare workers who get frustrated on Twitter, the medical community mostly shrugs in response. The same way we’ve grown numb to 1,000 people dying of COVID-19 daily for months at a time, we’ve grown numb to misinformation being spread by supposed “experts” who have the privilege of communicating with the public. But we shouldn’t grow numb to 1,000 people dying daily of a vaccine-preventable disease, and we shouldn’t grow numb to professors from prominent medical schools making blatant errors in national newspapers and refusing to correct them. We should hold professors at top medical schools writing for a national audience to at least the same standards we have for medical students doing a case write-up.
Sadly, medical students are currently held to a higher standard than professors at top medical schools. Contrarian doctors will likely face no sanction for their errors. After all, if repeatedly misstating basic facts about children’s health in the middle of the worst pandemic in 100 years earns them no reprobation, what possibly could? Instead, they’ll keep getting rewarded with space in large newspapers and TV interviews/podcast invitations. They’ll likely continue to claim their errors are providing much needed “nuance“. They’ll likely continue to deride those who correct their errors, saying their critics are merely engaged in “groupthink” and “tribalism“. They’ll likely continue to claim they are the true victims of this pandemic, imagining that contrarian doctors with massive platforms are being “cancelled and intimidated for posing reasonable scientific ideas“. Most worryingly, they’ll likely keep spreading misinformation, always understating the harms of COVID-19 and always overstating the harms of the vaccine.
Meanwhile, some parents will not vaccinate their children, falsely believing the virus is safer than the vaccine for their child (it’s not). For example, Victoria Ramirez’s father said:
It’s something that’s going to be stuck with me for my whole life, thinking maybe I should have done that sooner. Maybe I could’ve done something to help prevent this.
Victoria died this summer of COVID-19. She was 15 and unvaccinated. Her father was right – something absolutely could have been done to help prevent this. Sadly Victoria was not alone. Multiple adolescents, including some with no underlying health issues, have died of COVID-19 after the vaccine was available to them (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here). Perhaps some of their parents would have chosen to vaccinate them had doctors with national platforms provided them with accurate and thorough information.
My correction
I immediately issued a correction when I realized that I had understated pediatric hospitalizations on Twitter. I was mortified that the 200 people who saw my Tweet would learn inaccurate information because of my carelessness. I deserve no accolades for this. Any reasonable person would do the same thing.
Hopefully, Drs. Saphier and Makary will read this and fix the error in their article. Hopefully, they will be more careful in the future. I mean this very seriously. A lot of people listen to them. I really want their audience to have thorough and accurate information. I’m not asking them to abase themselves or respond to me in any way. I’m only asking them to fix their error and try to do better in the future. I’d be genuinely happy to write an addendum to this article praising them for acknowledging and fixing their error.
        ◦ Having made them myself, I completely understand that doctors can make errors. However, I can’t fathom why some of them don’t seem to care, especially considering the health of children is at stake.

Our Current Medical Establishment Would Have Botched COVID, The Same Way They Are Botching Measles
Those of us who paid attention to their COVID wishcasting are not the least bit surprised that measles is killing and injuring children under their watch.
Jonathan Howard on April 25, 2025
Link
What would you have done?
Recently, an interviewer sympathetic to the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) listened to my criticisms of it and asked me: What would you have done? That question has me bothered me ever since.
Unlike the doctors I critique, I never claimed to be a pandemic guru with all the answers, and what I actually did is exactly what I would have done. There is no alternate version of me where I was the was mayor of NYC or the dictator of some country. What I actually did is much more interesting than fantasies about what I would have done. I worked in a hospital. I was in a vaccine trial. I corrected doctors’ misinformation. Moreover, just because someone says they would have done something doesn’t mean they actually would have done it. It’s trivially easy to write the words “I would have kept schools open” or “I would have protected the vulnerable.” Anyone can do it.
While obviously anyone can voice their opinion on how we could have better handled the pandemic, and it’s vital that we do that. However, the question “what would you have done?” conjures a parallel universe where words become reality, and both the virus and the public can be bent to one’s will.
Nonetheless, imagination time is fun, so here’s my answer:
I never would have let SAR-CoV-2 into the country. The moment the virus emerged in China, I would have sealed the border. If any COVID cases snuck in, I would isolate them before the virus could spread. I’d launch a massively successful vaccination campaign and ventilate indoor spaces. I’d create a culture where people stayed home when they were sick and where mask-wearing was not unusual. By keeping the virus out of the country, society could function normally, and people would remain healthy.
A reasonable person would not be impressed by this. They’d expect to see a detailed plan to keep COVID out of the country, and even then they would spot its many flaws.
Yet, many people did not demand such a plan from the GBD, although their proposal was as absurd as mine. They wanted 2/3 of the country live in a world of pure COVID and 1/3 of the country live in a world of zero COVID. They said this would end the pandemic in 3-6 months. Although though the virus shuttered schools and killed a record number of people when they ran the show in Florida, they claim that if only we had listened to them, everything would have been just fine.
Measles Surge in Southwest Is Now the Largest Single Outbreak Since 2000
While my plan of keeping the U.S. COVID-free is obviously superior to the GBD’s, I will receive zero credit for it. In contrast, the authors of the GBD and like-minded doctors received many accolades for merely saying what they would have done. However, recent events reveal just how absurd this adoration was.
Doctors who became celebrities for saying what they would have done, parlayed that game of make-believe into high positions in the Trump administration. They are the Medical Establishment now, and they no longer get to say what they would have done on Twitter and Fox News. They have real-world responsibility, and it’s a mess all around.
I don’t need to repeat all of the headlines of censorship and purges they are generating, but one thing they are doing is letting children suffer and die from vaccine-preventable diseases. Under our current Medical Establishment, the headlines read Measles Surge in Southwest Is Now the Largest Single Outbreak Since 2000, Texas Announces Second Measles Death in Unvaccinated Child, Texas Measles Outbreak Surpasses 600 Cases With Most Among Children, Teens, Two Infants Die of Whooping Cough in Louisiana as Cases Climb Nationally, and ‘Fighting to Breathe’: Whooping Cough Surges as Vaccination Rate Falters. We are just getting started. Another recent headline declared Millions of U.S. Measles Cases Forecast Over 25 Years if Shots Decline.
Despite these suffering children and the potential for many more to come, the Medical Establishment is focused on other topics. The article Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to Launch Autism Registry Using Private Health Records provides a preview of their creepy intentions, and in this unhinged screed, RFK Jr. says we need healthy kids for the military. What could go wrong?
Our Medical Establishment is trying to pull the COVID vaccine for children- FDA Commissioner Says Pulling COVID Vaccine For Children Will be ‘Welcomed’ Dr. Jay Bhattacharya wants to get rid of mRNA technology all together. They are also focused on fertility and testosterone levels in teenage boys. At this moment, these are their priorities.
Yes, measles is still the most contagious virus there is, but it should be easy to handle compared to COVID. We have a near-perfect vaccine, and most parents want it. Anti-vaxx disinformation is the only reason we are having measles outbreaks today, and explained by the article Measles Misinformation Is on the Rise — and Americans Are Hearing It, things are heading in the wrong direction. Allaying the fears of vaccine-hesitant parents should be a top priority for our Medical Establishment. That’s not happening.
The doctors who claimed they would have solved COVID are flailing with measles- amongst other things. Not only are the failing to correct anti-vaccine disinformation, they are making things worse. In one recent interview, Dr. Marty Makary, flanked by the Food Babe(!), twice refused to answer “YES!” when asked if parents should vaccinate their children against measles. In the video below, he said the bare minimum about the MMR. However, while saying “we have to be honest,” he minimized children dying of measles with the same noxious myths he used with COVID.
He said only vulnerable children are at risk of measles, he ignored its non-fatal outcomes, and absurdly implied parents are not given any choice regarding vaccines. He said that measles outbreaks are not unusual. He spread misinformation about the hepatitis B vaccine for no reason. He said that RFK Jr. had no responsibility for the current outbreak. He instead blamed “migrant communities” and unspecified “government misinformation” about COVID, even though the people who died of measles should have been vaccinated before the pandemic. This is yet another example of our FDA director endorsing time travel.
It’s also an example of deflection. The current Medical Establishment doesn’t want to take responsibility for what is happening under their leadership. Dr. Makary doesn’t want to acknowledge the obvious truth about his boss, a crank who lied about vaccines for 20-years and predictably botched this measles outbreak. While the current Medical Establishment got famous by blasting the previous Medical Establishment for their supposed dishonesty, they now seek to protect themselves above all else and distract from their ineptitude with odd ramblings on teenage hormones.
Stanford Doctor Jay Bhattacharya Calls Dr. Fauci ‘Number One Anti Vaxxer’
Despite their grand pronouncements, our current Medical Establishment wouldn’t have opened schools or protected the vulnerable when COVID was raging. Those were empty boasts. Right now, they are demonstrating their complete inability to keep people safe from a dangerous pathogens.
Yet, the problem isn’t just their incompetence, it’s their apathy. Our current Medical Establishment does not care about keeping people safe from dangerous viruses, though this is hardly breaking news. However, the strategy that catapulted them to their current positions, downplaying COVID on Fox News, isn’t going to work now that they are in charge. The media is paying attention to these interviews now and will scrutinize their false claims- FDA Head Falsely Claims no Scientists Laid Off, as Agency Shutters Food Safety Labs– something they were generally spared previously. They can’t just wish measles away. Even Megyn Kelly is asking about it. They will continue to be blamed for bad headlines about is meals, which is appropriate. It’s their job now to stop it, and the only way to do that is with vaccines.
Those of us on the outside have every right to treat our current Medical Establishment as harshly as they treated public health officials regarding COVID. Drs. Bhattacharya and Makary mocked them and depicted them as dishonest imbeciles for not saying that COVID vaccines were a perfect panacea or that natural immunity was this wonderful, powerful thing. We also have every right to hold them the highest standards. After all, they set high expectations by telling us all the amazing, incredible, wonderful things they would have done with COVID.
Obviously, our Medical Establishment does not deserve credit for these imagined “accomplishments”. Rather, they deserve to be judged for the real-world consequences of pandemic misinformation and everything that’s actually happening right now. Those of us who paid attention to their COVID fantasies are not the least bit surprised that they shrug as measles kills and injures children under their watch.
In contrast, I deserve praise and glory. Unlike our inept, bumbling Medical Establishment, I would have prevented this.

    • 

The Covid Amnesia Project and the Plot to Erase 2020
It’s up to those of us who experienced the pandemic in the real-world to make sure that what actually happened in 2020 isn’t deliberately erased by sheltered disinformation agents who experienced it all from their laptops. 
Jonathan Howard on March 27, 2026
Link

Earlier this month, the HHS sent the following Tweet:
There’s a lot to unpack there, and it reflects the consensus view of our current medical establishment, the leaders of the COVID amnesia project.
It’s true that streets were empty, schools were closed, and churches were locked in 2020, but there was an important reason why this was the case, which the HHS Tweet curiously omits. Although reality shouldn’t be up for debate, the question is what happened in 2020. Even though we all lived through it, our current medical establishment doesn’t want you to remember most of it.
They don’t want you to remember what they actually said in 2020, their farcical forecasts and pro-infection agenda. They don’t want you to remember they predicted COVID would kill 20,000 to 40,000 Americans, that it was less deadly than the flu. They don’t want you to remember that they were concerned about the economy in spring 2020. They don’t want you to remember they said that New York and Sweden had herd immunity in July 2020. They don’t want you to remember they claimed that immunity to COVID was durable, reinfections were rare, and herd immunity was inevitable. They don’t want you to remember the mere existence of their plan for herd immunity in 3-6 months via mass natural immunity. Even though this dominated the discourse in 2020, they’ll never mention it today.
Mostly, our current medical establishment, who never treated COVID patients themselves, doesn’t want you to remember the horrific scenes of mass death 6 years ago, the overflowing hospitals and morgues, the exhausted, overwhelmed medical personnel. They don’t want you to remember that COVID also killed and injured a lot of young people in 2020 and that this all would have been much worse had schools and churches been crowded, as they intended. Today, they won’t acknowledge recent headlines that COVID deaths may have been significantly undercounted in 2020. In fact, they never acknowledge COVID killed anyone at all. An honest remembrance of what the virus did when it was allowed to spread unchecked would ruin their revisionist narrative and is therefore strictly forbidden.
The scene behind my hospital in 2020
Though this revisionist history is both absurd and abhorrent, it is also revealing. While our medical establishment wants you to forget about the virus and its victims, they constantly seek to reinforce other memories of 2020. They are still trying to convince you the virus leaked from a lab, and they desperately want you to remember unpleasant mitigation measures. They want you to believe these measures were entirely optional, that the virus could have been ignored and its impact on churches and schools would have been negligible. As always, they blame the people whose job it was to control COVID in 2020 for the consequences of COVID. Although they can’t manage measles today, our current medical establishment wants you to believe that had they been in charge back then, we barely would have noticed the virus at all.
There’s a reason our medical establishment and their pathetic enablers don’t want anyone to forget 2020 altogether. They want to keep the rage alive. They recognize it was the key to their rise to power and that remains crucial to the continued cohesion of their movement. The MAHA coalition was built entirely on shared grievances regarding COVID, a sentiment powerful enough to unite otherwise disparate forces, professional anti-vaxxers and “pro-vaccine” EBM gurus from prestigious universities, to pick one example amongst many.
Keeping the MAHA coalition intact in 2026 requires that people still feel constant anger about 2020. But unfortunately for our medical establishment, only they still really care about lockdowns today. It just doesn’t have the same juice it did in 2020. Nearly everyone else moved on long ago and is currently focused on the ineptitude and maliciousness of MAHA (and MAGA).
No one can make the affirmative case that MAHA is succeeding and the movement itself is cracking apart, full of bitter infighting and high school drama. Doctors who rose to power fear-mongering about rare vaccine side effects, learned the hard way this wasn’t enough to maintain their power. The inherent instabilities of the MAHA coalition have been exposed, as has the incompetence of its leaders. Though they demanded that their predecessors magically wall off “vulnerable” people for months on end while COVID raged, when given a chance to prove their own competence, they can’t even fix shot-out windows at the CDC. The wheels are coming off, and trust is at an all-time low with them in charge. 
And though our current medical establishment instructed everyone else to stop talking about COVID years ago, they’ll never stop talking about it themselves. They’ll be droning on about lockdowns, vaccine mandates, and masked toddlers for years to come. 2020 was the highlight of their lives. They were sought after podcast guests who earned great accolades doing nothing more than throwing stones from the comfort of their offices.
Today, recollections of 2020 serve as a safe space for our medical establishment, a comfortable fantasy where they were beloved supermen more powerful than COVID. It’s a lot easier for them to play make-believe about those imagined glory days than to defend their actual job performance today.  It turns out, being the medical establishment is harder than Tweeting about the medical establishment. 
Meanwhile, it’s up to those of us who experienced the pandemic in the real-world to make sure that what actually happened in 2020 isn’t deliberately erased by sheltered disinformation agents who experienced it entirely from their laptops.


How Journalists Enable the COVID Amnesia Project
People need to know the past credibility of our medical leaders to accurately gauge their current credibility.
Jonathan Howard on May 14, 2026
Link

It’s pretty hackneyed to whine about “the media” these days. Obviously, there are plenty of excellent journalists, and my own writing would not be possible without their efforts. Nonetheless many of them have been complicit in the COVID Amnesia Project, whitewashing and sanitizing the atrocious track record of MAHA doctors, thus numbing the public to their current threat. Several recent, utterly typical examples are below:
    • Bhattacharya became one of the country’s most prominent critics of the government’s covid response during the pandemic, arguing against widespread lockdowns and other mitigation measures and accusing the CDC of relying on “pseudo science.”
    • Makary rose in conservative circles as a measured critic of pandemic-era health efforts and the failings of the traditional medical establishment.
    • Martin Kulldorff, a biostatistician and vaccine safety expert who rose in prominence during the pandemic as a critic of Covid restrictions and vaccine mandates…
    • Dr. Prasad… has also been described as a Covid contrarian, after complaining on podcasts and on his YouTube channel about public health measures that he deemed ill-informed by medical evidence.
To be clear, these are very important articles. We should all appreciate journalists who gave us the inside scoop on Dr. Marty Makary’s ouster and revealed how Kennedy and MAHA doctors are quietly attacking vaccines from within. Without them, we wouldn’t know such things. Moreover, their descriptions of MAHA doctors aren’t totally false. However, they are woefully incomplete and therefore fundamentally inaccurate, like describing OJ Simpson as a football player who had some disagreements with his wife. 
It’s obviously true that MAHA doctors criticized lockdowns and mandates, and today they are portrayed as only having opposed the pandemic’s most unpopular mitigation measures. They are depicted as reasonable, good-faith actors who merely wanted better “evidence.” However, there was an important reason why MAHA doctors criticized lockdowns and mandates, and most journalists don’t mention it.
In reality MAHA doctors wanted them infected in 2020, and they spread a deluge of disinformation to further this pro-infection objective. They were part of an international effort to mass infect unvaccinated young people in the misguided belief that natural immunity would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months. This is why MAHA doctors opposed lockdowns, mandates, and literally everything else that slowed the virus. Don’t take my word for it. Take theirs. They were very open about it at the time, and there’s no need to cover it up today.
I think it’s vital for journalists not to hide this sordid history from their readers, especially with several MAHA doctors still in power doing Kennedy’s bidding. People need context and background into who these doctors were- beyond their broad objections to lockdowns and mandates. People deserve to know their history. They didn’t arise out of nowhere, and it’s no surprise that doctors who spread disinformation about the COVID vaccine have extended these efforts to many other vaccines today. People need to know the past credibility of our medical leaders to accurately gauge their current credibility. Can we trust the doctors who told us not to worry about COVID in 2020 when they tell us not to worry about other viruses in 2026?
If journalists want to honestly inform their readers of what MAHA doctors said regarding COVID, I suggest they do what we do here at SBM and share their actual words. There’s an overwhelming number of Tweets, editorials, and YouTube videos for them to choose from. Accurate descriptions of MAHA doctors would then read:
    • Dr. Martin Kulldorff, who claimed the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would end the pandemic in 3-6 months…
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, who claimed that COVID’s risk kicked in at age 70 and pushed for unvaccinated people to “face the risk of the disease” in 2020…
    • Dr. Marty Makary, who claimed that most of the country had herd immunity to COVID in May 2021 and that immunity to it was “probably lifelong”…
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad, who likened COVID mitigations to Nazi Germany and called other doctors “motherfuckers” and “fucking morons” for supposedly minimizing rare, temporary vaccine side effects…
See, that’s not so hard, and it’s all true.


The COVID Amnesia Project: Erasing Your Free Will to Preserve the Fantasy of the Optional Pandemic
Countless millions of Americans prioritized their health and protecting their neighbors over an imagined return to normal in 2020. Our sacrifices deserve recognition and gratitude, not amnesia and revisionist history from sheltered political scientists.
Jonathan Howard on June 5, 2026
Link

“COVID-19 Has Killed Thousands of Young Americans”
Although 2020 wasn’t that long ago, it sure feels that way. However, it’s important to flashback and try to remember our mindset at the time, specifically how we felt about contracting COVID ourselves. Most of us didn’t want it.
By October 2020, when the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was written, we’d all been deluged with horrors of suffering and dying COVID patients from all over the world. We knew COVID could overwhelm hospitals and morgues, and the first installment of the COVID Amnesia Project discussed the efforts to erase that history.
Everyone knew that while older people had the highest risk, younger people were not invulnerable. Frontline doctors reported our experiences in 2020. In my only article that year, I wrote about seeing “patients as young as 23 die alone, with no one by their side”, though as early as April 2020, the Washington Post had published articles titled Hundreds Of Young Americans Have Now Been Killed By The Coronavirus, Data Shows and Young And Middle-Aged People, Barely Sick With Covid-19, Are Dying Of Strokes. By January 2021 the headlines would read COVID-19 Has Killed Thousands of Young Americans. This Is Not Just a Tragedy for The Elderly. COVID became the #1 disease killer for young adults and middle-aged people in 2021.
Source: CDC
We knew that children were not entirely spared by the virus. An article from May 2020 was titled Everything You Need To Know About A Mysterious Illness That Could Be Linked To Coronavirus In Children. It said:
Doctors are referring to the condition that has hospitalized dozens of children as “pediatric multisystem inflammatory syndrome,” and health officials believe it could be linked to coronavirus. Three children have died because of it in New York, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said Saturday.
COVID would go on to kill over 2,000 children, and at its worst, during the Omicron wave in January 2022, nearly 1,000 children were being hospitalized daily, some in the ICU.
All of this would have been much worse had people under age 60-70 abandoned all efforts to avoid the virus in 2020.
It was clear early on that COVID did not magically spare educators. A headline from NYC in May 2020 declared Coronavirus News: 30 Teachers Among 74 DOE Employees to Die of COVID-19. A teacher at my son’s school died. At least 451 active teachers had died by the end of 2022, a number that would have been much higher had they all contracted COVID in 2020.
Everyone also knew that death was not the only bad outcome from COVID. A lot of people got really sick, even though they didn’t die. A younger colleague of mine spent weeks unable to make it from her bed to the bathroom without gasping for air during her infection in April 2020. Her awful experience didn’t show up in any statistics or medical journal, but it wasn’t exceptional. It was no secret that COVID could be horrific even if it didn’t kill you, and most people reasonably wanted to avoid this suffering.
Even if they didn’t fear the virus themselves, normal people cared about their community and didn’t want to participate in a chain of transmission that might end up killing a stranger 10 infections later. There was immense social pressure to avoid spreading the virus in 2020, which made sense considering the worst wave of the pandemic was January 2021, when 3,000 Americans would die daily.
There was some good news. Everyone knew that vaccines were potentially on the way, and in December 2020, they arrived.
The bottom line is this- an honest remembrance of 2020 reveals that we all had every incentive to avoid COVID, and most of us wouldn’t have lived normally even if everything had been officially “open”. However, a goal of the COVID Amnesia Project is to make people forget this by implying that we would have been eager to fill up restaurants and classrooms if only wise politicians and public health leaders had directed us to do so. Everything could have been normal.
“The authors of the Declaration argued that for the low-risk majority, normal life should otherwise resume.”
A typical example comes from the revisionist history book In COVID’s Wake, written by two Princeton political scientists, architects of the COVID Amnesia Project who experienced the pandemic from their laptops. In my previous review of it, I criticized its authors for “treating proposals as accomplishments.” They wrote:
The authors of the Declaration argued that for the low-risk majority, normal life should otherwise resume. Schools and restaurants should reopen, and teaching should be in person (with special provision made for older or immunocompromised teachers and students).
It may not seem that way, but there’s a lot to unpack there. It’s true that the authors of the GBD “argued for” things to be normal on Twitter, podcasts, and Fox News. However, SBM readers know that’s no great accomplishment and what people “argued for” matters infinitely less than what actually happened.
What actually happened is that when SARS-CoV-2 was allowed to spread unchecked, children and teachers got sick, and schools couldn’t stay open. The virus forced people’s hands and gave them no choice. Nowhere escaped the pandemic untouched with life as normal, not even Sweden, and COVID continued to disrupt normal life in the U.S. well after leaders said, “everything’s open.” The headlines 15 Miami-Dade Educators Die From COVID-19 in 10 Days and School Closures Reported in Five Fl Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID came during Florida’s Delta wave when authors of the GBD helped run the show. The virus didn’t care that the GBD’s authors “argued for” for this not to happen, and neither should anyone else.
However, in addition to absolving SARS-CoV-2 of all blame, the illusion that normal life was possible in 2020 is entirely based on an absurd assumption- that the vast majority of people avoided COVID that year only because politicians and public health leaders instructed them to do so.
In the fantasy of an alternate pandemic, the sage authors of the GBD were in charge, and millions of Americans, who had devoted most of 2020 to avoiding COVID, would have suddenly been willing to contract it en masse once they received their marching orders in October. Parents would have sent their kids to school, and customers would have flocked to packed restaurants. Teachers would have seen the video below, and hearing they faced a “very modest risk,” would have been convinced to return to crowded classrooms. That’s how persuasive the authors of the GBD would have been. School bus drivers, chefs, waitresses and everyone else required to keep schools and restaurants functioning would have similarly abandoned their efforts to avoid COVID. Since they were “low risk”, life would have been blissfully normal. Of course, “special provisions for older or immunocompromised teachers and students” would have been miraculously created at a moment’s notice as the virus swirled around them. What could possibly go wrong?
This depiction of the pandemic as optional, an entirely avoidable catastrophe caused not by a deadly virus but by stupid people who made stupid choices is appealing at a child’s level. The imagined alternative- where competent leaders snapped their fingers, normal life resumed, and everybody lived happily ever after- is certainly much better than what we all actually lived through, as long as you were not elderly or immunocompromised. Such people did not get a voice in GBD’s vision.
However, not only does this fantasy erase SARS-CoV-2 from the equation, it erases how people felt regarding COVID in 2020 and their agency about it. It portrays people who tried to avoid COVID as easily manipulable lemmings who blindly followed orders, rather than rational individuals who made rational decisions with their own free will.
To be clear, the GBD and broader We Want Them Infected movement were very influential in convincing some people to live normally. The GBD told people under 60-70 they had essentially no risk from the virus, and that for the sake of herd immunity, they deserved gratitude for contracting it. Once vaccines arrived, they claimed that natural immunity was preferable to vaccine immunity. Many people were tricked by this, some of them paid dearly for it, and they are no longer around to tell us about the wisdom of their decision to live normally. Erasing their existence to maintain the fantasy of the optional pandemic is a core aim of the COVID Amnesia Project.
However, the obvious truth is that countless millions of Americans prioritized their health and protecting their neighbors over a fantasized return to normal in 2020. We made enormous sacrifices, and our collective efforts deserve recognition and gratitude, not amnesia and revisionist history. Instead of appreciating that people came together to limit a deadly virus, the COVID Amnesia Project blames their unwillingness to contract it for a lack of normalcy that year.
Resisting the COVID Amnesia Project requires honestly remembering what actually happened in 2020. Every country needed mandatory mitigations because even though a new virus killed a lot of people and overwhelmed cities, some people still didn’t care about it. They had other priorities and didn’t want the virus to be slowed down.
However, the vasty majority of people worked together to avoid a contagious virus entirely of their own volition in 2020. They didn’t need to be told what to do. This cooperation not only saved lives, but it also precluded a return to normal. We don’t have to pretend the authors of the GBD could have uttered some magical incantation that would have destroyed our respect for the virus, our autonomy, or our solidarity 6 years ago.


Since They Won’t Remind You, Here’s What Drs. John Ioannidis, Jay Bhattacharya, and Scott Atlas, Actually Said 6 Years Ago
The next time these doctors claim they were right, let’s remind them exactly what they claim to have been right about.
Jonathan Howard on April 11, 2026
Link

In a previous article titled The Covid Amnesia Project and the Plot to Erase 2020, I discussed the deliberate effort to erase the horrific scenes of 2020, the overflowing hospitals and morgues, led by doctors who now want you to believe we overreacted to COVID 6-years-ago. I also wrote that these doctors “don’t want you to remember what they actually said in 2020, their farcical forecasts and pro-infection agenda.”
Today, I will remind you. Unlike them, I think it is vital to resist pandemic revisionism and accurately remember what they actually said in the spring of 2020, especially because they now claim time has vindicated their pandemic vision, that they were basically right about everything.
Three doctors whose words are worth recalling all hail from Stanford University. Though none of the, treated COVID patients, they nonetheless greatly influenced our COVID response. Let’s honestly remember what they said in the spring of 2020.
Dr. John Ioannidis
On March 17, 2020, Dr. John Ioannidis wrote an essay titled A Fiasco in The Making? As The Coronavirus Pandemic Takes Hold, We Are Making Decisions Without Reliable Data. It said:
If we assume that case fatality rate among individuals infected by SARS-CoV-2 is 0.3% in the general population — a mid-range guess from my Diamond Princess analysis — and that 1% of the U.S. population gets infected (about 3.3 million people), this would translate to about 10,000 deaths. This sounds like a huge number, but it is buried within the noise of the estimate of deaths from “influenza-like illness.” If we had not known about a new virus out there, and had not checked individuals with PCR tests, the number of total deaths due to “influenza-like illness” would not seem unusual this year. At most, we might have casually noted that flu this season seems to be a bit worse than average. The media coverage would have been less than for an NBA game between the two most indifferent teams.
Though Dr. Ioannidis discounted “pessimistic scenarios” about the virus, he greatly worried about measures to it. He said:
One of the bottom lines is that we don’t know how long social distancing measures and lockdowns can be maintained without major consequences to the economy, society, and mental health. Unpredictable evolutions may ensue, including financial crisis, unrest, civil strife, war, and a meltdown of the social fabric. At a minimum, we need unbiased prevalence and incidence data for the evolving infectious load to guide decision-making.
In the most pessimistic scenario, which I do not espouse, if the new coronavirus infects 60% of the global population and 1% of the infected people die, that will translate into more than 40 million deaths globally, matching the 1918 influenza pandemic.
The vast majority of this hecatomb would be people with limited life expectancies. That’s in contrast to 1918, when many young people died.
The article also contained the seeds of the We Want Them Infected movement. It said:
 School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease.
Two days later, Dr. Ioannidis published a paper titled Coronavirus Disease 2019: The Harms of Exaggerated Information and Non-Evidence-Based Measures. In it, he wrote about “exaggerated pandemic estimates,” “exaggerated case fatality rate,” and “exaggerated exponential community spread.” He said a claim that 20%-60% of adults would be infected, was “substantially exaggerated.” He said, “China data are more compatible with close contact rather than wide community spread being the main mode of transmission,”  He said that, “Even if COVID-19 is not a 1918-recap in infection-related deaths, some coronavirus may match the 1918 pandemic in future seasons. Thus, we should learn and be better prepared.” He felt this coronavirus was a false alarm. He wrote that:
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
Then, on April 9, 2020, he gave an interview where he said:
If I were to make an informed estimate based on the limited testing data we have, I would say that covid-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA.
The USA reached 40,000 COVID deaths the next week.
Dr. Ioannidis also gave countless interviews like these 6-years-ago:
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
March 24, 2020 Dr. Jay Bhattacharya wrote an article with Dr. Eran Bendavid titled Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? It began with a much stronger justifications for lockdowns than anything I’ve ever written.
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
However, the article continued:
But there’s little evidence to confirm that premise—and projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.
Fear of Covid-19 is based on its high estimated case fatality rate—2% to 4% of people with confirmed Covid-19 have died, according to the World Health Organization and others. So if 100 million Americans ultimately get the disease, two million to four million could die. We believe that estimate is deeply flawed…
If our surmise of six million cases is accurate, that’s a mortality rate of 0.01%, assuming a two week lag between infection and death. This is one-tenth of the flu mortality rate of 0.1%. Such a low death rate would be cause for optimism.
This does not make Covid-19 a nonissue. The daily reports from Italy and across the U.S. show real struggles and overwhelmed health systems. But a 20,000- or 40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million.
If we’re right about the limited scale of the epidemic, then measures focused on older populations and hospitals are sensible… A universal quarantine may not be worth the costs it imposes on the economy, community and individual mental and physical health. We should undertake immediate steps to evaluate the empirical basis of the current lockdowns.
Dr. Bendavid would later have the integrity to admit the obvious, they were “way off.”
Dr. Scott Atlas
On March 26, 2020, Dr. Scott Altas wrote an article titled Widespread Isolation And Stopping All Human Interaction Will Not Contain the COVID-19 Pandemic. It said:
There is massive uncertainty, but using Ioannidis’ mid-range fatality rate, this virus could cause about 10,000 deaths in the United States overall, overall, a number that would not be extraordinary news in the total of flu-like deaths every season…
We know that up to 99% of positive cases have nothing beyond mild symptoms. A University of Oxford study estimated that fewer than 0.1% of infected cases have significant symptoms requiring medical care…
More importantly, whole-population isolation is not medically ideal and will lead to less effective elimination of the infection threat. Population immunity for every disease like this can only be achieved by letting people who are not at risk for anything serious, who are not immune-compromised and elderly (the vast majority of people), get exposed to it.
On April 13, 2020, Dr. Atlas wrote an article titled Reentry After the Panic: Paying the Health Price of Extreme Isolation:
With a world-wide sense of relief, progress continues in containing the COVID-19 pandemic. Projections have been revised downward for virtually every major negative consequence of the disease. Few doubt that the unprecedented isolation policies and near-total economic lockdowns adopted by most countries had a significant impact on reducing deaths from the virus. And aside from New York, where almost half of the entire country’s deaths and cases have occurred, the vast majority of American hospitals were not overwhelmed beyond capacity. All of this is terrific news.
But we will now pay a big price. Our policy of total isolation involved trade-offs and left a significant problem by endangering the resumption of normal activity…
But a bigger price might now be paid from choosing extreme isolation. In the absence of immunization, society needs circulation of the virus, assuming high-risk people can be isolated. Infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — natural antibodies. Given the estimated contagiousness of COVID-19, about 60 percent of people in the community need to have antibodies to stop the spread by “herd immunity.” Remember, medical care is not necessary for the vast majority of people who are infected.
On April 22, 2020 he expressed similar thoughts in an article titled The Data is in — Stop the Panic and End the Total Isolation. It said:
The tragedy of the COVID-19 pandemic appears to be entering the containment phase…The overwhelming majority of people do not have any significant risk of dying from COVID-19…
Vital population immunity is prevented by total isolation policies, prolonging the problem… Infected people without severe illness are the immediately available vehicle for establishing widespread immunity. By transmitting the virus to others in the low-risk group who then generate antibodies, they block the network of pathways toward the most vulnerable people, ultimately ending the threat. Extending whole-population isolation would directly prevent that widespread immunity from developing.
Dr. Atlas gave countless interviews like this:
The next time these doctors claim they were right, let’s remind them exactly what they claim to have been right about.


A Tale of Two Books: We Want Them Infected & In COVID’s Wake
I am not afraid to defend my book by discussing the real-world job performance of the MAHA/MAGA doctors featured in it. What about the authors of In COVID’s Wake?
Jonathan Howard on April 30, 2026
Link
“COVID policy—happened to be the subject I knew the least about.”
My book, We Want Them Infected, shared several key features with the book In COVID’s Wake. They both discussed our disastrous pandemic response and featured doctors who are now MAHA/MAGA royalty. That’s where the similarities end.
We Want Them Infected described the “insane situation” I witnessed working in Bellevue Hospital throughout the pandemic. It chronicled the harm done by pro-infection disinformation doctors in great detail and warned of their threat moving forward. 
In COVID’s Wake was written by two Princeton University political science professors, Stephen Macedo and Frances Lee, who experienced the pandemic from their laptops. They admitted they began their project from a place of ignorance. In one interview, Professor Macedo said:
I was planning to focus on abortion, immigration, and COVID. Of the three, COVID—and COVID policy—happened to be the subject I knew the least about.
It’s not clear if they sought input from any doctor who worked on a COVID unit to educate them about what the virus could do when it was allowed to spread uncontrolled, though this was hardly classified information.
They also admitted the purpose of their book was not to honestly critique our pandemic response, but rather to push an overtly political agenda. In the same interview Professor Macedo said:
I wanted to write a book on the current political moment and the highly polarized politics that we are involved in now. Specifically, about how progressives were not paying sufficient attention to conservative concerns on certain issues in a way that was undermining the strength of progressive arguments and positions.
Given their ignorance of the topic and stated desire to skewer “progressives” and promote “conservative concerns,” it’s no surprise that Macedo and Lee lauded the same pro-infection disinformation doctors I warned about, absurdly portraying them as oppressed pandemic superheroes. These doctors Tweeted they “would have” opened schools and protected the vulnerable, and that was good enough for Macedo and Lee. They were convinced. In their pundit fantasy world, opinions mean everything, actions mean nothing.
Columnist David Scharfenberg of The Boston Globe praised the book as “scathing,” saying that it “feels convincing — in no small part because Macedo and Lee are of the liberal, data-driven tribe they critique.“
Our books also elicited very different receptions. We Want Them Infected received a handful of reviews, all of them positive, and many nice online comments, for which I am grateful, but it wasn’t feted by major publications and elite opinion-makers. Such is life.
However, while my book didn’t receive voluminous press, it also didn’t generate any serious rebuttals. No one even tried. This is not to say the doctors I discussed ignored it. Several of them hurled a deluge of juvenile insults and dishonest straw man arguments at me, but they never pointed out anything wrong with anything I actually wrote.
Of course, that would be hard to do. After all, 25 pages of We Want Them Infected were just instances of these doctors declaring the pandemic over starting 6 years ago. (The audio section of that chapter is below). Most other sections followed a similar format. It’s hard to argue with my collection of accurate quotes, it turns out.
In contrast, In COVID’s Wake received a lot more attention than my book, and I am sure it sold many more copies. The sheltered pundit class, eager to stick it to those dastardly “progressives” and nurture those “conservative concerns,” fawned over it in their endless stream of opinion pieces and podcasts. According to the book’s Wikipedia page:
The book received widespread praise in the news media and among literary critics. The Economist listed the book among its best books of 2025, describing it as “insightful,” as did Compact, which described it as “the first comprehensive account of how liberal governance failed the Covid test,” and The New Yorker, which wrote that its “conclusions are chastening, clearly demonstrating the risks of enforcing a “consensus” and purging the countervailing views that make intellectual inquiry work.” The Wall Street Journal listed it as one of the top ten books of 2025. Columnist George Will of The Washington Post reviewed the book positively, saying that it was “dismaying, but also exhilarating… Macedo and Lee identify much broader and deeper cultural sicknesses. But their meticulous depictions and plausible explanations of the myriad institutional failures demonstrate social science at its finest.” Columnist David Scharfenberg of The Boston Globe praised the book as “scathing,” saying that it “feels convincing — in no small part because Macedo and Lee are of the liberal, data-driven tribe they critique.” The New Yorker staff writer Jessica Wintercompared it to the 2025 book An Abundance of Caution that criticized the policies of school closures during COVID in the United States, saying that it was “a similarly brutal COVID postmortem.” Financial Times columnist Edward Luce praised the book as “seminal,” saying that it helped explain the rise of the far-right in the 2020s and “should be compulsory reading across the spectrum.”
Paul Peterson, a professor of education at Harvard and Stanford’s Hoover Institution, wrote a glowing review titled COVID Crimes that said:
For a devout post-modernist, open discussion is subordinate to a single-minded pursuit of justice. Long a debating point within elite universities, post-modernism escaped, like a laboratory leak, into the real world of Covid politics at the beginning of this decade. To protect innocents from harm, our thoroughly post-modern masters silenced dissent and encouraged falsehoods. Public health officials took upon themselves the burden of convincing parents and politicians that schools must be closed, masks worn, and social distancing practiced—even when supporting evidence was thin at best. Those who objected were denied platforms in legacy and social media outlets.
As they tell this story in their new book, In Covid’s Wake, Princeton professors Stephen Macedo and Francis Lee hoist their flag to John Stuart Mill’s standard. A democratic republic that denies itself discourse about the central issue of the day risks becoming a tyranny of the majority, they argue. Suppression of dissent proved to be the worst of all Covid co-morbidities.
Over a million Americans died of COVID.
Unlike We Want Them Infect, however, In COVID’s Wake also received an avalanche of detailed, good faith criticism from people who knew what they were talking about. From accusations they misquoted people to claims “Lee and Macedo play fast and loose with statistics” there was no shortage of devastating takedowns of the book, including my own, though I’ve never seen its authors grapple with any of them.
“If the country had had more scientific leaders like Dr. Jay Bhattacharya—and more who were willing to listen to him—our policymaking could have been based more on evidence and less on hubris.”
It’s fair to say that beyond their shared subject matter, these two books were opposites in every way. We Want Them Infected sought to document and preserve the words of MAHA/MAGA doctors, while In COVID’s Wake sought to erase them and rewrite the history of the pandemic. 
Given this, it’s unsurprising that Macedo and Lee shared very different sentiments than I did when MAHA/MAGA was on the precipice of power in the fall of 2024. Like many others, I feared what Trump, Kennedy, and their band of medical misinformers would do with power. I knew their danger, and in my own podcasts and opinion pieces, I desperately tried to warn about them. 
Conversely, Macedo and Lee instructed us to embrace it all for our own good. In fall 2024, Kennedy premiered the movie Vaxxed III: Authorized to Kill, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya wrote a glowing endorsement of Kennedy, and Macedo and Lee wrote an article glorifying Dr. Bhattacharya titled Restoring Trust in Public Health, which blamed “educated elites” both for Trump’s return to power and a lack of trust in institutions. They said:
Educated elites bemoaning the return to power of Donald Trump would do well to ask how they contributed to this outcome. Trust in institutions is down, perhaps especially for those institutions charged with helping the public discern the truth. Observers often blame the “information ecosystem”—in particular, the internet—but elites have also undermined public faith by allowing science and the wider pursuit of truth to be politicized. The incoming administration presents the opportunity for a reset.
To that end, Trump should nominate Stanford University’s Dr. Jay Bhattacharya to lead the National Institutes of Health. Bhattacharya exemplifies qualities that were lacking in our nation’s scientific leadership during the pandemic. The ostracism and condemnation he faced for his dissenting views provides a vivid illustration of elite failures to live up to their own deepest values…
In reality, Dr. Bhattacharya didn’t just have “dissenting views.” He spread obviously fake statistics all the time and claimed the mass infection of unvaccinated people under age 60-70 would end the pandemic in 3-6 months. None of this bothered Macedo and Lee. They portrayed Dr. Bhattacharya as a visionary who cracked COVID’s code with his one-page online petition, the Great Barrington Declaration, a document written under the watchful eye of a pro-tobacco, child labor advocate.  They continued: 
If the country had had more scientific leaders like Dr. Jay Bhattacharya—and more who were willing to listen to him—our policymaking could have been based more on evidence and less on hubris. During the pandemic democracy’s “truth-seeking” institutions were infected by politics, partisanship, and dogmatism. What we need now is a strong dose of fresh thinking and institutional reform from experts prepared to challenge the reigning consensus and renew our commitment to the basic values of science and liberalism.
Excellent appointment! https://t.co/wqVLuVHdvu
— Stephen Macedo (@stephen_macedo) November 27, 2024
“The destruction that Kennedy has wrought in 1 year might take generations to repair, and there is little hope for US health and science while he remains at the helm.” 
Well, Macedo and Lee got exactly what they wanted. How’s that working out so far?
Enough time has passed that we can begin to answer that question, though it would take another dense tome to document the scientific sabotage of the past year alone. The Lancet weighed in with their essay Robert F Kennedy Jr: 1 Year of Failure, which said:
The destruction that Kennedy has wrought in 1 year might take generations to repair, and there is little hope for US health and science while he remains at the helm.
That’s probably true, and the star doctors of We Want Them Infected and In COVID’s Wake have been key instigators and perpetrators of all this. Though Dr. Bhattacharya boasted he “would have” perfectly handled COVID in 2020, when given the opportunity to prove his mettle in 2026, he can’t even fix a few shot-out windows at the CDC. Along with Dr. Martin Kulldorff, another pro-infection disinformation doctor glowingly profiled in In COVID’s Wake, he helped to decimate the CDC’s vaccine schedule. Under his watch, measles is spreading in ICE camps.
Though Dr. Bhattacharya claims science should be “apolitical,” he routinely speaks at right-wing propaganda events, such CPAC and Turning Point USA. He’s become the nation’s scientific censor-in-chief, eagerly implementing the MAGA/MAHA agenda at the institutions he leads. While scientists are reasonably wondering if they have a future in this country, Dr. Bhattacharya claims that it’s “ridiculous slander” to say that Trump is anything but a champion of science and confesses his literal “love” for the man.
This is who I warned about in We Want Them Infected. This is who Macedo and Lee claimed would “restore trust in public health”.
And thus we can see that whatever intentions the authors of In COVID’s Wake may have had, the book’s core function was to portray “progressives” as the true threat to science and to numb people the obvious threat of MAHA/MAGA doctors by providing a veneer of academic legitimacy to their pro-infection agenda and COVID Amnesia Project. Indeed today, MAHA/MAGA saboteurs routinely and explicitly use the type of pandemic revisionism promoted by Macedo and Lee as a pretext to justify their scientific vandalism and anti-vaxx agenda. Just watch.
As such, it’s no surprise that it wasn’t just reactionary centrist pundits who fawned over In COVID’s Wake in their opinion pieces and podcasts. Wikipedia had an entire section of the “widespread praise” the book received among right-wing and libertarian think tanks”. Though this crew hated my book- “they wanted us locked down forever“- In COVID’s Wake was a huge hit with these powerful people. It told them everything they wanted to hear, and it served a very useful purpose for them. It allowed them to launder their anti-science agenda through a series of “progressive” Princeton professors and “liberal” media outlets, The New Yorker, the New York Times, and PBS, who credulously promoted their revisionist history and petty grievances all in the name of polite discussion and civil debate.
Thus, we come to the final difference between me and Macedo and Lee. I still constantly discuss MAHA/MAGA doctors. I’ve never stopped chronicling their damage and sharing their words. Macedo and Lee, meanwhile, have magically morphed into quiet church mice. Though they were ubiquitous media stars not long ago, today they don’t seem to have anything to say about the powerful doctors they helped unleash on us all.
Why is that?
Professors Macedo and Lee are always welcome on my podcast for some polite discussion and civil debate about all of this. I also hope all the complicit publications and pundits who gave them softball interviews when their book came out, allowing them free reign to push MAHA/MAGA talking points, will invite them back to discuss how things are going with their heroes in power. And if they refuse, as I expect they will, I’ll be happy to take their place. I am not afraid to defend my book by discussing the real-world job performance of the MAHA/MAGA doctors featured in it.
    • 

An Open Letter to Professor Katy Milkman: Don’t Censor John Ioannidis, Jay Bhattacharya, and Emily Oster. Amplify Their Voices.
It’s vital that your conference attendees know the speakers’ past credibility to judge their current credibility. All you have to do is be honest.
Jonathan Howard on April 16, 2026
Link

Dear Professor Milkman,
You will soon be hosting a conference titled Workshop on Enhancing Scientific Integrity, which is sponsored by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Although the organization purports to be “driving progress for the benefit of society by providing independent, objective advice to advance science, engineering, and medicine,” the program nonetheless includes “fireside chats” with Dr. John Ioannidis, Professor Emily Oster, and Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, three individuals who became celebrities for their opinions on what other people should do when COVID raged.
On social media, you justified your invitations by saying:
Our goal in choosing speakers was to platform both popular and unpopular figures advocating for scientific reforms to spark productive conversations across divides! If this makes you angry, come engage in dialogue — that’s how we improve.
The purpose of this letter is to spark a productive conversations across a divide. I also have a simple, important, and genuine proposal.
By way of introduction, I am a doctor who has written extensively about the threat of MAHA/MAGA and COVID disinformation doctors, two of whom will be speaking at your conference. I am very familiar with these speakers and the harm they’ve caused. Along with many others, I’ve thoroughly recorded their words, extensively documented their disinformation, and desperately tried to warn of their danger. We’ve done the hard work for you, and it’s all very easy to find. As the conference host, it’s your responsibility to delve into the speakers’ history and have a thorough understanding of what they said. There is no excuse for you or anyone else to be unaware of their track record. Ignorance is a purposeful choice at this point. So is apathy.
This is not my first open letter to a conference host like you. I encourage you to read my previous letter, An Open Letter to the President of Stanford, Jonathan Levin: Don’t Censor Drs. Scott Atlas, John Ioannidis, Sunetra Gupta, Marty Makary, Monica Gandhi, Jay Bhattacharya, and Vinay Prasad. Amplify Their Voices. That letter referenced a conference very similar to yours that occurred at Stanford on October 4th, 2024, titled Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past.
My letter implored Jonathan Levin, the president of Stanford, who gave the introduction to the conference, to not censor his speakers. I asked him to simply be honest about what they said. That’s it. I provided him videos of things each speaker had said regarding COVID and encouraged him to show them to the audience. The videos are 100% unassailable evidence. Literally no one can argue with them, because no arguments are being made. They’re just history.
President Levin rejected my suggestion, however. He censored the speakers. He had a golden opportunity to reveal them for who they were to their faces using nothing but their own words, and he turned it down. That’s astounding. More than that, he had an obligation to alert people to their risk, and he refused. That’s disgraceful.
I’d love to hear him justify his indifference to reality. In a conference all about COVID, he ignored literally everything the speakers had said about COVID. None of it mattered to him. Not their obviously fake statistics, their farcical forecasts, their pro-infection agenda, nor their anti-vaccine disinformation. He didn’t care about it at all, and he hid it from the audience.
The speakers were also open political actors, and it’s no mystery whose side they were on. They had already spoken at political rallies and endorsed candidates. They treated doctors who worked in hospitals with contempt and vitriol. They hurled juvenile, unprofessional taunts and accusations at beleaguered scientists whose children (!) needed bodyguards. President Levin didn’t care about any of this either. He similarly refused to inform the conference attendees about the overtly political agenda and vile behavior of several of the speakers.
Incredibly, President Levin used his introduction to sanctimoniously scold critics of the conference. They needed to be put in their place. He absurdly said the purpose of the conference was to repair rifts and spur fresh thinking, and that its critics “seemed to reopen old and existing divisions.” Instead of pausing and humbly considering whether they had any valid points, he wagged his finger and blamed them- just like you did. Their actual arguments didn’t matter at all to him. His mind was totally closed.
In contrast, President Levin dishonestly portrayed the conference speakers as reliable, good-faith actors with valuable opinions to share. Today, several of the speakers he praised and elevated are MAHA/MAGA royalty. How are things going so far?
An editorial in The Lancet Robert F Kennedy Jr: 1 Year of Failure summed it up thusly.
The destruction that Kennedy has wrought in 1 year might take generations to repair, and there is little hope for US health and science while he remains at the helm.
This is all happening with doctors from the Stanford conference leading the way. They are the medical establishment now, and given his introduction to the conference, I’d also love to hear what President Levin thinks about their performance so far. Is he pleased with their purges, censorship, cancelled research, and anti-vaccine disinformation? How does he feel about unfixed bullet holes in windows at the CDC and measles spreading in ICE facilities? Can he be the first person to make the affirmative case that the NIH, CDC, and FDA are thriving under the leadership of doctors from his conference? Is it possible that just perhaps the conference’s critics were on to something 1.5 years ago?
At this point, Professor Milkman, I am going to repeat the same desperate, begging, plea that I made to President Levin. Don’t censor your speakers. However, you have a crucial advantage. You can learn from his failure. You can recognize that you too have a golden opportunity to simply reveal the truth about the speakers by doing nothing more than sharing their own words. Don’t pass it up. Given that your conference is titled Workshop on Enhancing Scientific Integrity, you should show a modicum of integrity yourself.
Best of all, this requires no work from you. It’s trivially easy to put together a montage of the speaker’s videos, which you can play to introduce them at your conference. They couldn’t possibly object to hearing their own words, and your audience will learn exactly what they said both regarding COVID and the current MAHA/MAGA regime. It’s vital that the attendees know the speakers’ past credibility to judge their current credibility, don’t you think? After all, even in 2026, Dr Bhattacharya literally “loves” Donald Trump. Don’t take my word for it. Just watch the video of him saying that, and make sure your audience sees it too.
The bottom line is this, Professor Milkman. None of us has to wonder what we “would do” in some imaginary sci-fi universe where powerful disinformation forces threatened science and medicine. That’s been happening for a long time, and what you actually did in the past few years is exactly what you “would do” in such a dystopia.
And though the danger of MAHA/MAGA doctors was obvious and out in the open, it was ignored and intentionally covered up, often by supposed “leaders” like President Levin, who were in the ideal position to have rung the alarm bell. When the MAHA/MAGA threat loomed in October 2024, he and countless others, rolled out the welcome mat to it, all disguised in a polite, but utterly disingenuous package of making “every effort to get people who disagree, even sharply, in dialogue with one another.“, as if this staged, performative conference “dialogue” was the highest value and ultimate goal, to which reality itself must subsumed. When powerful disinformation forces threatened science and medicine, that’s what he did.
Now that the speakers at the Stanford conference have power, things have deteriorated even further. Once again, what you are actually doing right now is exactly what you “would do” in a world where powerful disinformation forces threatened science and medicine.
You have a choice to make, and the right answer is obvious. However, if you choose to censor your speakers and refuse to inform your audience of their COVID disinformation and MAHA/MAGA activism, you’ll prove that none of that really matters to you, at least not in comparison to portraying yourself as someone who sparks productive conversations across divides! Like President Levin and many “esteemed professors” before you, you too will be deliberately covering up the truth and aiding the COVID Amnesia Project. Your productive conversation will be nothing but a safe space for powerful people who’ve already caused damage, and a golden opportunity for them to further dissemble and numb people to their risk.
And if that’s the choice you make, then your apathy and enabling will automatically and permanently become what you actually chose to do in April 2026 when powerful disinformation forces threatened science and medicine. You’ll be an accomplice. Everyone will know it, and no one will forget it.

JAY BHATTACHARYA

JAMA promotes the false equivalence of ‘focused protection’
On November 11 JAMA hosted a podcast with Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, one of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration. The discussion included factual inaccuracies and created a false equivalence between the fringe idea of ‘focused protection’ versus ongoing public health efforts to restrain community spread.
Mark Burkard on November 20, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: Filling in our empty Friday slot is a guest post from Dr. Mark Burkard. Welcome!]By all accounts the COVID-19 pandemic is spiraling out of control, particularly in the U.S. where daily cases top 150,000. The current patchwork of public health policies is insufficient to control the rapid rise, and many health systems and workers across the country are becoming rapidly overwhelmed.
On November 11 Dr. Howard Bauchner (the editor-in-chief of The Journal of the American Medical Association/JAMA, one of the preeminent U.S. medical journals) hosted a livestream video/podcast as part of a series, Conversations with Dr. Bauchner. The episode was titled “Herd Immunity as a Coronavirus Pandemic Strategy” and featured Jay Bhattacharya MD PhD (Stanford Professor of Medicine in Primary Care Outcomes and an expert in health economics), and Marc Lipsitch PhD (Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Professor in Epidemiology). The discussion was prompted by the conflicting views of Dr. Bhattacharya and Dr. Lipsitch.
Dr. Bhattacharya was an author and signatory of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), promoted by the libertarian Institute of Economic Research, previously covered on SBM.  The GBD proposes ‘focused protection’, described as allowing “those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk”. At the same time, it proposes the vulnerable should be protected, for example, in nursing homes by using “staff with acquired immunity and perform frequent PCR testing of other staff and all visitors”. Although it proposes focused protection of the vulnerable, it also advocates allowing the vulnerable the freedom to risk their lives: “people who are more at risk may participate if they wish, while society as a whole enjoys the protection conferred upon the vulnerable by those who have built up herd immunity”.
This proposal was met with disdain by most epidemiologists and public health authorities as impractical and dangerous. WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus characterized the proposal as “scientifically and ethically problematic”. Anthony Fauci, director of NIAID, described the proposal as “ridiculous” and “total nonsense”. Francis Collins, NIH Director, described the idea as a fringe view:
“What I worry about with this is it’s being presented as if it’s a major alternative view that’s held by large numbers of experts in the scientific community. That is not true,” National Institutes of Health Director Francis Collins told the Washington Post. “This is a fringe component of epidemiology. This is not mainstream science. It’s dangerous. It fits into the political views of certain parts of our confused political establishment,” he told the outlet.
Three Harvard medical students succinctly laid out the central problems with the proposal.
Yet the U.S. Government – which appears to be schizophrenically following this policy – held high-level meetings with the GBD authors, leading to promulgation of the idea and prompting mainstream epidemiologists to pen a counter-statement, the John Snow Memorandum. This document supports the prevailing consensus from public health authorities worldwide, that public health policies should seek to minimize community spread until a safe and effective vaccine is available, which will thereby minimize the exposure of high-risk populations. Despite the attempt to set the record straight, the John Snow Memorandum inadvertently created a false equivalence between the fringe approach and what is actually recommended by epidemiologists and public health officials.
Unfortunately, JAMA further bolstered this false equivalence through a mainstream-medical platform by publicly airing a joint discussion with Dr. Bhattacharya and Dr. Lipsitch for their countering points of view. Unfortunately, debates are poor vehicles for honest scientific discussions, as it is possible to misstate, mislead, and misdirect. Sure enough, Dr. Bhattacharya appeared to use these tactics to support ‘focused protection’, while the platform created the false impression that the GBD proposal is as legitimate alternative to public health efforts that seek to limit community spread.
Understated and misleading risks
In order for the focused protection proposed in GBD to be feasible, two things need to be done. First, it must be possible to easily identify low- versus high-risk individuals. Second, it needs to be possible to isolate high-risk individuals to enforce ‘focused protection’ in the setting of a highly infectious virus that is widespread in the low-risk individuals. Critics have pointed out that neither of these are feasible. How did Dr. Bhattacharya address this?
In his opening statement, Dr. Bhattacharya says that COVID-19 is deadly for “people who are older and for people who have certain chronic conditions”. He cites the survival as 95% for age 70 and older and 99.95% for those under 70. (It is clear he is referring to the infection fatality rate, or IFR, as he refers to seroprevalance studies). In general, the IFR for a disease is lower than the case-fatality rate, although both are difficult to estimate in real-time during an ongoing pandemic.
However, no estimates of risk sharply discriminate those 70 and older versus under age 70. For example, the CDC uses a range of estimates of the IFR for its planning scenarios, varying from 0.25-1% for age 50-69, and 2.8-9.3% for 70 years and older. Dr. Bhattacharya, it seems, has averaged IFR rates for younger age groups including 0-19 years and 20-49 years with those up to 69 years old in order to reach an estimated IFR of 0.05% under age 70. It seems unfair to average across all age groups and apply it to the 50-69 year old group, but this misleading argument is, in effect, necessary to claim that it is easy to discriminate high- versus low-risk individuals. Further, it is well known (and was acknowledged) that other medical conditions such as obesity and diabetes increase risk in younger individuals; it wasn’t clear whether these individuals were excluded from his ‘under 70 group’ but if so, again it is misleading to claim 99.95% survival for those under 70. This was not an auspicious start to the JAMA Conversation.
Even averaging the very young, the estimate of IFR of 0.05% for those < aged 70 doesn’t appear to fit with scientific sources. For example, the CDC estimates of the IFR are based on Hauser et al. Of note, one of the conclusions of Hauser et al. is that the IFR has major geographical differences that could arise from factors “including emergency preparedness and response and health service capacity”. When health systems are overwhelmed – as they are becoming in the U.S. today – the IFR is expected to escalate. Thus, it is odd that Dr. Bhattacharya can be so certain that there is 99.95% survival for those under 70.
A study recently published in The Lancet estimated the IFR of COVID-19 in spring 2020 in New York City. This study broke down IFR by age but the measures were much higher than those claimed by Dr. Bhattacharya – 14.2% aged 75 and older, versus 4.87% for aged 64-74, versus 0.939% aged 45-64. These are the results for all age ranges:
Here, the estimated IFR here is higher than 0.05% for all age groups except <25 years. It is hard to imagine that there are enough people <25 in this population such that the average for all those <70 years old would come out anywhere close to the 0.05% claimed by Dr. Bhattacharya, but even if that were the case, it would be very misleading to claim that everyone under 70 years old has very low risk, as clearly those close to 70 have a significantly higher risk. Perhaps Dr. Bhattacharya would argue that the data from NYC in the spring of 2020 are high estimates during a strained health crisis, and so the IFR would be lower now, given that health systems are not currently overwhelmed and that treatments have improved. Nevertheless, the claims of a 0.05% IFR for those aged less than 70 are at best misleading and at worst wrong.
So right in his opening statement, Dr. Bhattacharya has done three things. First, he has claimed a sharp discrimination of low- versus high-risk groups at age 70, which is misleading. Second, he has underestimated risk for people under age 70. Third, he inaccurately represents the IFR as a stable and well-known quantity. If it is necessary to mislead, misrepresent sources, and have greater certainty than warranted to support a point of view, perhaps that view should be reconsidered.
COVID-19 is about more than just deaths
We also haven’t discussed morbidity yet, the suffering caused by a disease that falls short of deaths. Dr. Bhattacharya dismisses concerns about the morbidity of COVID-19. The short-term morbidity for people who may not die includes hospitalizations and their complications. The long-term morbidity of COVID-19 is not yet clear. The topic of long haulers was brought up and then dismissed as having unknown incidence and duration. However, substantial long-term morbidity is at least possible as the SARS-Cov2 virus enters pulmonary and brain tissue, and causes cardiac dysfunction. Although the prevalence and extent of the long-term consequences are unclear, the clear short-term and probable long-term morbidity in a substantial fraction of infected individuals should give everyone pause. Dr. Bhattacharya appears completely dismissive of COVID-19 morbidity, and appears to argue that unknown risks should not impact policies, even when that risk will be incurred by tens of millions.
Dr. Bhattacharya overstates harms of lockdowns
Dr. Bhattacharya claims “Lockdowns have absolutely catastrophic effects on physical and mental health of populations” and “For people under 70 (or 60) the lockdown harms are worse than COVID-19”. No evidence is provided here, but the evidence that does exist suggests this is inaccurate or highly misleading.
If we are to compare mortality of lockdowns with the mortality of COVID-19, there is no contest – COVID-19 is far worse. For example, mortality in the U.S. tracks with the surges of COVID-19, and at least 2/3 of the excess deaths are directly attributable to COVID-19.  As an independent way of determining deaths from COVID-19 versus deaths from lockdowns, we could observe death rates in a location with a severe lockdown but relatively few cases – and we can make such an observation based on the experiences of Melbourne, Australia. From August through October in 2020, the city and surrounding state of Victoria had one of the most severe lockdowns in the world as they attempted to squelch a small outbreak before it exploded into the population. However, the severe lockdown was without a significant change in deaths compared to the previous year.
Critics of lockdowns claim they increase rates of suicide. Dr. Bhattacharya says “The CDC estimated in June that one in four young adults seriously considered suicide. One in four. You know, normally that’s something that’s on the order of 4% is now one in four”. This is misleading summary of the CDC MMWR report – the 4% appears to be the 2018 suicide ideation rate in all age groups, which increased to 10.7% – not 25% – in June 2020. The 25% cited apparently refers to the 18-24yo subgroup, which in 2018 was measured at 11.0% [pdf, Figure 58, p48]. Thus, the actual measured increase is 2.3-2.7 fold from 2018 baseline, much less than 6-fold escalation claimed by Dr. Bhattacharya. These data need to be interpreted with care due to the acknowledged methodologic differences in the 2018 and 2020 surveys. Nevertheless, the apparent increase in mental health impacts of the pandemic are of serious concern. But what caused this? June 2020 was notable for escalating COVID-19 cases and unrest across the country after prominent examples of racial injustice. In fact, stay-at-home orders had largely ended across the U.S. by June 2020. Thus Dr. Bhattacharya mis-cites the CDC report to claim a larger escalation in suicidal ideation than the data showed, and uncritically attributed the findings to lockdowns that largely ended prior to the survey timeframe. I am not arguing that we should ignore mental health issues – addressing them and escalating awareness can prevent adverse collateral impacts of the pandemic. However, Dr. Bhattacharya claimed the impact was worse than the data showed and attributed the outcome to lockdowns with undue certainty.
However, these data are about suicidal ideation; what is the impact of lockdown on actual suicide rates? Fortunately, during the pandemic there is no clear evidence that rates have been affected at all. For example, in the Victoria lockdown noted above, there was no reported increase in suicide rate [PDF]. In short, there is no evidence of higher suicide incidence due to lockdowns.
Another claimed mortality risk of lockdowns is the adverse impact on medical care. Dr. Bhattacharya said, “People stayed home. They’re more afraid of COVID than getting treated for heart attacks. That’s happened already with the lockdowns”. Again, Dr. Bhattacharya attributes failure to seek emergency care during the pandemic solely to lockdowns. However, hospitals were never closed to emergency care. People who failed to seek emergency care during lockdowns did so due to concerns about COVID-19 exposure and overwhelmed hospitals. These are likely to occur – and will be worse – if we permit widespread community spread of COVID-19 among the less vulnerable as he has proposed.
Morbidity of lockdowns is certainly likely. It can be distressing to restrict social activities, to mandate school closures, to cancel sports. However, the controversy stoked by the GBD is likely to fuel further restrictions and isolation for the many high-risk individuals who cannot safely enter community spaces. By proposing people ‘live their lives normally’, the number of cases and hospitalizations will definitely escalate even if the death rate remains low. They will particularly escalate in that the GBD proposes that high-risk individuals are allowed to take their chances if they wish to. The serious medical impacts of COVID-19 also contribute to distress. The serious medical issues, hospitalizations, visitor restrictions at nursing homes, all contribute to distress. It is not clear that lockdowns cause more morbidity and social disorder than an uncontrolled epidemic or the ‘focused protection’ that would disrupt millions of U.S. households.
In conclusion, Dr. Bhattacharya overestimates the speculative mortality and morbidity of lockdowns, while minimizing the known mortality of an escalating pandemic. Worse, he ignores that the pandemic is infectious – and therefore grows exponentially. Even if the mortality and morbidity of COVID-19 and lockdowns were, say, equal, the potential of future harm scales differently. Essentially, the harms of lockdown would scale linearly over time, but COVID-19 in a susceptible population grows exponentially.
Dr Bhattacharya fails to provide viable approach for ‘focused protection’
Dr. Bhattacharya claims that the vulnerable can be protected by ‘focused protection’ without controlling community spread. When asked how it would be logistically possible to segregate the vulnerable from the low risk in a country of 360 million, Dr. Bhattacharya again overstates the risks of and imperfections of lockdowns, which he claims have failed. Ironically, he says “any public health intervention needs to take into account the environment it actually is going to be implemented in, not pretend like we’re going to have it work perfectly”. So what is his more realistic proposal?
First, he describes enhancing protections at nursing homes: deploying rapid antigen tests of visitors, personal protective equipment, segregating those who are ill, and limiting staff rotations. Nursing homes have already implement many of these policies and due to inadequate testing, often simply disallow visitors. Nevertheless, many nursing homes have had major outbreaks due to the high transmissibility and prevalence of COVID-19, and to the presence of asymptomatic and presymptomatic individuals. There are an estimated 15,600 nursing homes in the U.S. What would it take to protect them all? Consider that rapid antigen testing of visitors has limited sensitivity and has thus failed in arguably the most highly guarded building in the U.S. – the White House – where it infected the President, aged 74. But Dr. Bhattacharya believes this can be done in all 15,600 nursing homes, without substantially new policies that would materially increase protection, in the setting of wide community spread of COVID-19.
But nursing homes are just one piece of the puzzle. An estimated 20% of U.S. households and 64 million people live in multigenerational homes. How does Dr. Bhattacharya propose to protect elders in this population? Well first, he blames lockdowns for creating multigenerational homes (strangely ignoring that the risk is mitigated with lower community contact). But after this tangent, he proposes creating alternate living arrangements, like hotels for the homeless, when the younger group are infected. Of course, this assumes they know they are infected which requires symptoms or frequent asymptomatic testing which has cost, turnaround-time, and sensitivity issues. It would seem to require a rapid-turnaround, 100%-sensitive test that is done in millions of households almost daily. The vague proposal appears unclear, impractical, and ignores the sensitivity issues that led to the White House COVID-19 breach despite routine rapid antigen testing of visitors.
How would Dr. Bhattacharya propose to deal with high-risk workers, such as those with diabetes? He says that a 63-year-old diabetic Costco clerk should have reasonable accommodation to work from home. He wants to give disability insurance to many. I agree – lowering the exposure of the working vulnerable and providing social support is admirable. However, such significant social support is not available in the U.S. today.  (Also, it is still unclear who he believes is at high risk, since we are now talking about people under 70 among whom he estimated the IFR of 0.05%).
Tragedy of the commons and libertarian viewpoint
As noted above, a pandemic spiraling out of control will exhaust the common medical resources, impacting all patients. Even if a small fraction of the infected die of COVID-19, the medical needs of the population will not be met adequately in the face of a COVID-19 surge. Others will die needlessly of cancer, heart attacks, strokes, trauma, and the inability to get care. Overwhelmed health systems can delay screenings and elective surgeries first, but this has its own impacts on future risk and quality of life. Even worse, the GBD proposes to allow high-risk individuals to ignore the limited ‘focused protection’ measures as it says “people who are more at risk may participate if they wish”. Since these groups will need more medical care, this policy would further serve to overwhelm the health care systems.
It is hard not to see Dr. Bhattacharya’s ideas as a fringe libertarian view, where the tragedy of the commons is not considered. First, Dr. Bhattacharya was a research fellow at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University’s conservative, at least partly libertarian, think tank. Second, Dr. Bhattacharya was lead investigator of the infamous Stanford seroprevalence study preprint, which erroneously overestimated the prevalence resulting in a minimized IFR estimate. Third, Dr. Bhattacharya followed up the seroprevalence preprint with an article in The Wall Street Journal, which used the conclusions to publicly disseminate his idea that risks of COVID-19 were overblown. Fourth, Dr. Bhattacharya went to the American Institute for Economic Research, a libertarian think tank in Great Barrington, MA where he co-authored the GBD. It appears that there may be a point of view guiding efforts to muster supportive data, rather than an effort to use data to guide policy.
Dr. Bhattacharya uses ambiguous definitions
At the end of the discussion, Dr. Bhattacharya and Dr. Lipsitch are asked what they mean by lockdown. Dr. Lipsitch indicates that the Stay-at-Home orders in many parts of the U.S. between March-May 2020 constituted lockdowns. Dr. Bhattacharya disagreed claiming that those were quarantines and that any restriction on activities – churches, restaurants, schools, arts – constitute lockdowns. However, this ambiguity serves mainly to obfuscate, since idiosyncratic definitions are not generally understood. Quarantine, in particular, has a medical definition in which individuals are isolated for a period after being known to have, or suspected of exposure to, an infectious disease. Lockdown is defined as confining individuals to a place due to an emergency, and is understood to be equivalent to stay-at-home orders. The ambiguity employed makes it difficult for interlocutors to pick up on the imprecision of applying harms measured during stay-at-home policies to the less-restrictive shutdown of high-risk public activities in parts of the country experiencing high COVID-19 activity. If one needs to ambiguate with idiosyncratic definitions to support a point of view, it is probably best to reconsider the point of view.
Real-world impact of the false and misleading claims from Stanford academics
Dr. Bhattacharya and the other GBD authors have failed to win over their scientific colleagues, infectious disease experts, and public health authorities. Because of a number of factual inaccuracies, false assumptions, ambiguity, and dismissal of practical matters discussed above, the ‘focused protection’ proposal is not considered serious by the bulk of knowledgeable experts who have examined it.
What, then, is the impact of publicly airing fringe views? If Dr. Bhattacharya and colleagues aired their views in scientific forums and peer-reviewed publications, these views could be vetted, examined, considered, criticized, and revised. Ultimately, portions of the view that are incorrect or unsupportable could be rejected, while accurate and promising facets – such as opening schools for young-aged children, or policies to keep at-risk workers safe – would gain traction and acceptance, influencing a cohesive public health policy. However, Dr. Bhattacharya and colleagues have sought the widest public dissemination of a wholesale fringe idea that does not convince the bulk of relevant experts. As above, the ideas appear to be based on misleading or inaccurate premises without a serious attempt to address the criticisms or practicality of ‘focused protection’. Unfortunately, this widespread promulgation of the GBD and related ideas has influenced the public, and allowed individuals to rationalize decisions to ignore public health rules and recommendations. Medical authorities such as Dr. Bhattacharya and JAMA publicly airing the GBD proposal undermines a united public health approach, and is potentially lethal – the public health equivalent of shouting ‘fire’ in a crowded theater.
Conclusion: A deadly false equivalence
JAMA has promoted the false equivalence of a fringe view and placed it publicly on social media. In a world where even Facebook and Twitter now fact check claims that impact public health, JAMA oddly failed to do so. As a result, a misleading and misplaced set of claims could lead many in the public to oppose or ignore public health policies, worsening the severity and impact of the pandemic. While it is of value to vigorously debate policies and interpretation of scientific evidence, JAMA has a responsibility to accurately portray scientific information on social media, to base discussions on facts and evidence, and to avoid allowing its platform to promulgate a false equivalence, particularly when doing so may adversely impact public health.

The tendentious libertarianism of the Great Barrington Declaration
Libertarian authors of the Great Barrington Declaration have branched out into criticisms of NIAID director Dr. Anthony Fauci. In keeping with their past activities, their criticisms are inaccurate and misleading.
Eric Kramer on January 22, 2022
Tweet

[Editor’s note: Today we present a guest post from Eric Kramer, an economist and lawyer whose interests include classical liberalism and libertarian approaches to political economy and who blogs at angrybearblog.com. Welcome!]
Martin Kulldorff and Jayanta Bhattacharya, two of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration, have a piece up at the Brownstone Institute (and Newsweek) that claims Anthony Fauci, the Director of NIAID “got major epidemiology and public health questions wrong”.
Dr. Fauci’s policy positions and public statements can and should be examined and criticized as part of an effort to learn from our experience with the present epidemic. Unfortunately, the Kulldorff and Bhattacharya piece is mostly libertarian misdirection and bluster, and it presents little reasoned discussion of the merits of Fauci’s decision making during the pandemic. Here I review some of their charges and their supporting arguments and treatment of evidence.
False claim #1: Natural immunity undercuts the case for vaccine mandates
Kulldorff and Bhattacharya claim that by “pushing vaccine mandates, Dr. Fauci ignores naturally acquired immunity among the COVID-recovered”.
The bare fact that virus-based immunity exists (because remember – the immune response is naturally generated by your immune system whether it comes from a virus or a vaccine) does not show that vaccine mandates are unjustified. At most, natural immunity might justify an exemption from vaccine mandates for those who have recovered from COVID-19. However, there are plausible arguments against such exemptions. Notably, if vaccines increase immunity for those who have recovered from COVID-19, then vaccination may be justified on standard utilitarian grounds even if, as Kulldorff and Bhattacharya claim, “natural immunity is stronger and longer lasting than vaccine-induced immunity”. This comparison is completely irrelevant if the question is whether those with natural immunity should get vaccinated; the correct comparison is between natural immunity and natural immunity plus vaccination. This is not a difficult point to grasp. In addition, we need to consider that it is easier to design and implement a universal mandate than a mandate with an exemption for those with natural immunity.
I am not saying that these considerations are necessarily decisive. There are reasons to support an exemption for those with natural immunity. But it is just nonsense to suggest that Fauci has committed an obvious, absurd error like denying the existence of natural immunity. Kulldorff has made this incoherent claim about vaccine mandates and natural immunity before.
False claim #2: Vaccine mandates for health care workers harms patients
It gets worse. Kulldorff and Bhattacharya go on to make this claim:
Under Fauci’s mandates, hospitals are firing heroic nurses who recovered from COVID they contracted while caring for patients. With their superior immunity, they can safely care for the oldest and frailest patients with even lower transmission risk than the vaccinated.
If you follow the link about firing heroic nurses, you will end up at the Foundation for Economic Education, a libertarian organization. There you will learn about a nurse named Jennifer Bridges who was one of 150 employees fired from Houston Methodist hospital for not complying with the hospital’s vaccine mandate. There is no indication in this article that she has natural immunity. In fact, if you click through to the source that FEE cites, you discover this:
The Houston Methodist employees who filed the lawsuit likened their situation to medical experiments performed on unwilling victims in Nazi concentration camps during World War II. U.S. District Judge Lynn Hughes called that comparison “reprehensible” and said claims made in the lawsuit that the vaccines are experimental and dangerous are false.
Now that’s heroism. In fact, Bridges claims to have recovered from Covid-19 in 2020 and that she has natural immunity, but she does not cite this as her reason for rejecting the vaccine. Instead, she “believes the vaccines are a sinister political weapon being wielded by elites to dismantle global democracy”.
Furthermore:
Bridges said Tuesday was also her first day at her new job at a company that sends nurses into people’s homes.
So this unvaccinated health care worker is going into the homes of people who presumably have serious medical problems. Perhaps she has natural immunity. One imagines her patients would be safer if she were vaccinated as well, but as we have seen Kulldorff and Bhattacharya fail to consider this possibility (instead they focus on the irrelevant claim that natural immunity is stronger than vaccine-induced immunity, rather than on the relevant issue, whether vaccination provides added immunity to people who have recovered from COVID-19).
False claim #3: Vaccine mandates are severely damaging labor markets and hospitals
Finally, note that Bridges is still working as a nurse, which casts doubt on the unsubstantiated claim by Kulldorff and Bhattacharya that the mandate is “causing tremendous disruption to labor markets and hampering the operation of many hospitals”. Since Bridges is currently employed as a nurse in Texas, the fact that she is not employed at Houston Methodist does not show that the overall supply of nurses in Texas has decreased at all.
So far, news reports do not suggest that vaccine mandates are causing major problems in labor markets. It seems that most employees in most workplaces end up choosing to get vaccinated. (I suspect that many of those who end up quitting and dropping out of the labor market are close to retirement anyway, so any reduction in the size of the workforce will be temporary as well as small.) This hardly proves that mandates are not justified, and they may cause real difficulties for some employers. But it is telling that opponents of mandates are resorting to hysterical and unfounded claims about labor market disruption to bolster their case. The main cause of staffing difficulties at hospitals appears to be the COVID-19 epidemic itself and vaccine mandates are a plausible response to this problem.
False claim #4: Fauci’s position on school closures was indefensible
Kulldorff and Bhattacharya argue that “Dr. Fauci’s advocacy for school closures may be the single biggest mistake of his career.”
It is certainly plausible to argue that some school closures in the United States were unjustified; possibly many were. However, if you follow the link Kulldorff and Bhattacharya supply, what you will find is a Substack post that shows Fauci approved of school closures for the first three months of the pandemic as a mitigation measure and because the risk to children from COVID-19 was unclear. You can argue that this was not the best possible advice given the information available at the time, but it was far from insane. At that point Fauci started to argue that closures should be used when transmission is high, that it was important to open schools, and that we would be better off closing bars to slow transmission and to keep schools open.
You can argue that Fauci’s advice was vague, or that schools should be kept open even when prevalence is high. But to suggest that Fauci was an unequivocal advocate of school closures is wrong, based on the anti-Fauci post that Kulldorff and Bhattacharya cite. And it is important to remember that schooling is largely a state and local issue, and it is far from clear that Fauci, a federal health official, bears much responsibility for school closures.
False claim #5: Fauci oversold masks and undersold ventilation
Kulldorff and Bhattacharya suggest that Fauci overstated the case for masks and understated the case for improved ventilation in schools:
The gold standard of medical research is randomized trials, and there have now been two on COVID masks for adults. For children, there is no solid scientific evidence that masks work. A Danish study found no statistically significant difference between masking and not masking when it came to coronavirus infection. In a study in Bangladesh, the 95 percent confidence interval showed that masks reduced transmission between 0 percent and 18 percent. Hence, masks are either of zero or limited benefit. There are many more critical pandemic measures that Dr. Fauci could have emphasized, such as better ventilation in schools and hiring nursing home staff with natural immunity.
There are two issues here: 1) the effectiveness of masking, and 2) whether Fauci put too much emphasis on masking relative to other possible pandemic responses, notably improved school ventilation, in his public communication.
On the effectiveness of masking, there is no justification for focusing only on the two studies Kulldorff and Bhattacharya cite, even though they are RCTs, rather than evaluating the available evidence in a holistic and open-minded way. RCTs have limitations, especially when it comes to evaluating a practice like masking. The Danish paper was a study of whether masks help protect wearers, but the main public health benefit of masks is that it helps protect other people. The Danish study simply did not measure that. The Bangladesh study also appears to have methodological problems. This does not mean it has no probative value, but given their clear limitations there is no justification for relying solely on these RCTs and ignoring other forms of evidence on the value of masking.
Did Fauci put too much emphasis on masking in his public communications? Should he have put more emphasis on improving ventilation in schools?
Kulldorff and Bhattacharya support their claim that Fauci should have emphasized improved ventilation by pointing to a popular article that extols the cognitive benefits of improved ventilation in schools, not the COVID-19 prevention benefits. Moreover, the main study cited in the article is not an RCT, it reaches a result that appears to be implausible, and it has been subject to serious criticism. Other studies mentioned in the article Kulldorff and Bhattacharya link to seem even more implausible – one reports a doubling of cognitive test scores in advanced green buildings. Sure.
I am entirely open to the idea that the federal government should have done more to help schools reopen safely, including by improving ventilation. But Kulldorff and Bhattacharya seem to evaluate evidence according to whether it helps them reach their desired conclusion, not by carefully considering how probative it is, and how much weight to assign to different studies and forms of evidence. Flawed RCTs that cast doubt on the value of masks are fine; a seriously flawed observational study that purports to show large cognitive benefits of ventilation is accepted uncritically as evidence for the value of ventilation against COVID-19.
Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that the federal government should have done more to help schools reopen safely, and that Fauci spent more time advocating for masking than for improved ventilation in schools. (Kulldorff and Bhattacharya present no evidence for this, but it seems plausible and perhaps it is true.)
This would not show that Fauci was wrong to support masking. In his media appearances, it seems reasonable for Fauci to emphasize things that all Americans can do to slow the spread of COVID-19. Perhaps Fauci advocated for improved school ventilation behind the scenes, in conversations with legislators or executive branch policymakers. This could have been a sensible approach.
Finally, Kulldorff and Bhattacharya simply assume, without argument, that schools would have reopened sooner if Fauci had spent more time talking about school ventilation in public. This is far from obviously true. If Fauci had publicly and repeatedly stressed the importance of improved ventilation, that might have led some schools to stay closed if they lacked the resources to improve their ventilation, even if they should have opened without new ventilation systems. We can argue about all this, but Kulldorff and Bhattacharya have not even made a coherent argument for the claim that Fauci seriously and clearly erred by focusing too much on masks and too little on ventilation, much less provided relevant evidence supporting this conclusion.
Conclusion: Kulldorff and Bhattacharya are using ideas to further a libertarian agenda, not to get at truth or find common ground
As I said earlier, it is perfectly reasonable to evaluate and criticize major policy decisions and public statements by public officials. Unfortunately, Kulldorff and Bhattacharya seem more interested in reaching libertarian conclusions than in learning lessons for the future or finding areas of common ground with people who do not share their libertarian values. They make arguments that are patently incoherent. They misrepresent evidence. They share links that do not support their argument.
        ◦ Unfortunately, this has been common throughout the pandemic on the libertarian right. The Brownstone Institute, where Kulldorff and Bhattacharya are both senior scholars, publishes essays that gaslight readers, twist evidence, and encourage vaccine hesitancy and distrust of public officials. Some essays it publishes are incoherent or unhinged. Kulldorff and Bhattacharya claim that their ideas enjoy wide support among academics, but that many are unwilling to admit this publicly to avoid stigma or retribution. I have no basis for evaluating this claim, but I suspect even academics who have some sympathy for their policy ideas would be hesitant to be associated with their tendentious arguments and ideologically-driven agenda.

Jay Bhattacharya: “If It’s True That The Novel Coronavirus Would Kill Millions Without Shelter-In-Place Orders and Quarantines, Then the Extraordinary Measures Being Carried Out in Cities and States Around the Country Are Surely Justified”
Dr. Bhattacharya doesn’t take the words of Dr. Bhattacharya seriously. So why should anybody else?
Jonathan Howard on January 28, 2022
Link

Hippocampal lesions
Probably the most famous single patient of the past 100 years was an unfortunate man named Henry Molaison, more commonly known by his initials HM. Mr. Molaison suffered from epilepsy, and in an attempt to cure him of the condition, surgeons removed both of his hippocampi. Mr. Molaison stopped having seizures but was tragically unable to form new memories for more than a few minutes. He lived over 50 years, but was forever stuck in 1953, when he had his operation.
I’ve never seen someone this permanently disabled, fortunately, but I’ve met multiple patients with identical deficits due to treatable or transient disorders, namely limbic encephalitis and transient global amnesia. It’s fascinating but unnerving to talk to people whose consciousness is fixed in a moment in time, unable to process that the world around them is changing. They keep saying the same thing over and over again and can’t retain any new information. It feels a bit like Bill Murray’s experience in Groundhog Day.
“…the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified”
With this is mind, let’s examine a statement made on March 20, 2020.
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
This eminently reasonable justification for lockdowns came from an article titled Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? by Drs. Eran Bendavid and Jay Bhattacharya. Dr. Bhattacharya is well known as one of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), which advocated that healthy, young people magically separate from older, vulnerable people to create herd immunity by getting infected with a virus that seems to mutate enough not to provide lasting immunity. I previously likened the sophistication of this plan to my childhood idea of eliminating crime by “locking up all the bad guys”.
Beyond this, Dr. Bhattacharya famously said that Florida “protected the vulnerable” in the summer of 2020. Six weeks later, the headlines declared “Florida breaks COVID-19 deaths record fifth week in a row“. He wrote self-pitying editorials in international newspapers claiming that he’d been muzzled. He said that vaccine mandates spread the virus. After COVID-19 killed hundreds of children and the flu just one child, Dr. Bhattacharya said that more children died from the flu. That statement is as honest as someone saying a cat weighs more than an elephant.
In an essay titled “The ill-advised push to vaccinate the young“, Dr. Bhattacharya and Dr. Martin Kulldorff, a co-author of the GBD, claimed that,
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
I’ve read this line 100 times, and I still find it jaw dropping. In the middle of the worst pandemic in 100 years, they feel it is more dangerous to vaccinate young adults and children than to vaccinate no one at all. That’s certainly a fringe idea, is it not? If a genie granted them the wish to vaccinate everyone in the world or no one at all, all indications are that they would choose to vaccinate no one at all. It’s no wonder congressmen and judges ridicule him and repeatedly deem his testimony unreliable.
Dr. Bhattacharya also said, “The emergency phase of the disease is over… We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.” I’d personally love it if COVID-19 occupied 1/200th of his attention. However, Dr. Bhattacharya clearly doesn’t think we should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people. COVID-19 is the only disease he speaks about, and he does so constantly.
Dr. Bhattacharya disagreeing with Dr. Bhattacharya will be a recurring theme of this essay.
“A 20,000-40,000-Death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million”
Dr. Bhattacharya’s early statement that lockdowns would be justified to save millions of lives seems uncontroversial today, and indeed most of us accepted lockdowns at that time to avoid hospitals being overwhelmed and to buy time for vaccines. However, Dr. Bhattacharya was not in favor of lockdowns when he made that statement.
Though he was clear that mass death would justify lockdowns, at the time he felt “there’s little evidence to confirm that premise” that COVID-19 could kill millions and that “projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.” He wrote that “if we’re right about the limited scale of the epidemic, then…A universal quarantine may not be worth the costs it imposes on the economy, community and individual mental and physical health.” Simply put, Dr. Bhattacharya was against lockdowns at the start of the pandemic because he didn’t feel COVID-19 would be that bad. He wrote, that “a 20,000-40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million”, and that early estimates of mass death were “deeply flawed.”
As the USA inexorably marches towards the devastating milestone of a million COVID-19 deaths, these early estimates don’t seem “deeply flawed” at all, especially considering that “extraordinary measures” were taken and that highly effective vaccines were widely available a year after the first wave. One might reasonably expect Dr. Bhattacharya to reflect on his early optimistic prediction and concede he was wrong about the “the limited scale of the epidemic”. One might further expect he would conclude that the “the extraordinary measures” taken at the start of the pandemic were indeed justified. After all, he wrote that the death of millions would warrant such measures and he was absolutely right about one thing – a million-death epidemic is a far more severe problem than one that kills 20,000-40,000.
However, as Dr. Bhattacharya is generally incapable of acknowledging basic facts much less admitting error, exactly one year after saying lockdowns were justified to prevent mass death, he pivoted and said that COVID-19 lockdowns were the “biggest public health mistake we’ve ever made…The harm to people is catastrophic“. In March 2021, he said “the lockdowns themselves impose great harm on people. Lockdowns are not a natural normal way to live”. Of course, there were no lockdowns when he made this statement, though he spoke about them in the present tense.
This is why I opened this essay discussing people with hippocampal injuries, frozen in time, unable to learn new information.
Lockdowns
Debating lockdowns today is kind of like debating prohibition. That era has long passed. No place in the USA has been locked down since the first few months of the pandemic, and the lockdowns here were much less stringent here than in many other countries. Even as the omicron variant spread widely, politicians from across the political spectrum resisted further lockdowns.
In an essay titled “We’re All Trying to Find the Guy Policing Our Behavior“, Alex Pareene described his normal family routine and noted that:
Elsewhere, Disney World was officially full on New Year’s Eve. For $107 I could book a flight to Bermuda this weekend. The Knicks lost at home yesterday; a fan was spotted at the game watching The Office on mute. Vietnamese restaurant Que Viet, a Minneapolis mainstay famous for the giant egg rolls on a stick it sells each year at the Minnesota State Fair, is opening a St. Paul location. The number one movie in the country is Scream.
It all seems very normal. It seems a bit uncannily normal, really, happening against a backdrop of hundreds and hundreds of thousands of new Covid-19 infections across the nation, and months of Americans dying by the thousands. And yet! To hear some people, this is a country where panicky scolds refuse to allow children to go back to school, or, in some vague sense, let people have their normal lives back.
He continued, “This is why I find the tenor of discussion around Covid-19 restrictions genuinely bewildering. There basically aren’t any.” He’s right.
It’s January 2022
Though lockdowns are a relic from the pandemic’s first days, Dr. Bhattacharya and his GBD coauthors still talk about lockdowns constantly. The whole sad spectacle is exactly what it’s like to talk to patients with hippocampal injuries.
Like them, Dr. Bhattacharya seems stuck in time, unable to process that the world has changed. His consciousness is fixed in March 2020, when politicians shuttered businesses and schools. He desperately wants them all open, and of course, most are. Yet, Dr. Bhattacharya seems blissfully unaware that nearly two years have passed, the lockdowns ended long ago, and that the virus will soon kill a million Americans, a situation for which he said lockdowns were “surely justified”. Even as late as October 2021, in an interview that mentioned lockdowns over 40 times, he said to help children we should “End the lockdown, because the lockdown is causing devastating harm for them“.
I have good news for Dr. Bhattacharya on that front. It’s January 2022.The lockdowns ended long ago. Politicians aren’t closing schools You can go to restaurants, concerts, museums, and basketball games. I’ve done all this right here in liberal New York City. Yet, not everything is open. The virus is closing schools, canceling concerts, and shutting down Broadway shows.
Not only is Dr. Bhattacharya stuck in March 2020, like patients with hippocampal injuries, he has not demonstrated that he can learn certain facts. As far I know, he’s never acknowledged that over 1,200 children have died of COVID-19 and that around 100,000 children have been hospitalized. He’s never recognized that the vaccine has proven extremely effective at preventing these rare but severe harms in adolescents. He seems unable to retain the fact that schools closed or used the National Guard as babysitters this winter because so many students and teachers contracted the virus, not because politicians closed schools. His “plan” to open schools by saying “open schools” was nothing more than empty virtue signaling given that he also undermined every effort to contain the virus in children.
I’d love for Dr. Bhattacharya to demonstrate the power of his hippocampi and share information on how the virus has hurt children and how the vaccine can protect them. He has a much larger platform than I do. However, for contrarian doctors, bad facts about the virus and good facts about the vaccine suffer the same ultimate fate as facts told to brain-injured patients. Though one group can’t remember them and the other group refuses to acknowledge them, they are never spoken.
Of course, Dr. Bhattacharya’s hippocampi are fully intact. He knows children are dying of COVID-19 every day. He knows the vaccine can prevent this. Dr. Bhattacharya simply chooses not to acknowledge these basic facts. He also knows nowhere in America has been locked down since the start of the pandemic. Repeatedly discussing distant lockdowns as if they are an ongoing threat is also a very purposeful decision on his part. The imagined specter of dreaded lockdowns serves as a boogeyman to disparage any and all means to limit COVID-19 infections in young people, including vaccines, masks, and testing. Any attempt to control the virus is labeled “draconian” by sheltered, histrionic doctors who don’t work in COVID-19 ICUs. Even a simple statement that children should get vaccinated will sometimes be met with accusations of “lockdowner” by the financial backers of the GBD.
The vaccine isn’t perfect, but it’s much safer than the virus for young people. If you’re confused why someone would try to obscure this important information, you’re not alone. I certainly don’t understand why so many doctors spread misinformation about a potentially life saving vaccine for children. But here’s how I’ve come to think about things.
Dr. Bhattacharya hopes that by linking effective, generally benign measures to control the virus to the most draconian, loathed measures, he can better achieve his fabled goal of “focused protection” through mass infection of children and young people. His constant protests against imagined lockdowns and his anti-vaccine position towards young people make perfect sense only when one remembers a disturbing fact – he wants young people to be infected with the virus. The whole premise of the GBD was that young people should “live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection”. It was clear that herd immunity “can be assisted by (but is not dependent upon) a vaccine”. In other words, for the vast majority of children and young people, this really was a “let er rip” strategy. There’s no pretending otherwise.
Effective vaccines are a direct challenge to his pro-virus ideology, and so he opposes vaccines for young people. In a statement that might have come from the mouth of Andrew Wakefield, Dr. Bhattacharya said,
I don’t think if there’s any good reason to vaccinate kids that young did for kids [sic], they face a vanishingly small risk from COVID itself, near zero from mortality from COVID… I think that it is a mistake to think about this as good for kids. It’s not good for kids.
Dr. Bhattacharya and other contrarian doctors can take a lot of credit for the fact that many parents fear the vaccine more than more than the virus. They’ve all spread many myths about COVID-19 and children, always minimizing the dangers of the virus and always overstating the dangers of the vaccine. The very real harms children have suffered are dismissed with obviously false statements that the flu has killed more children than COVID-19 and empty bromides that children have a “quite small” risk from COVID-19. I doubt that will be much comfort to the families of the 27 children who died just last week.
The GBD won
We are largely living in the world envisioned by the GBD. Except for the fact that millions of children are safely vaccinated, they basically won. The lockdowns ended long ago and pediatric infection rates are at an all time high. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, 1,150,543 children contracted the virus last week alone. Meanwhile, as Dr. Bhattacharya hoped, overall childhood vaccination rates are abysmal. The GBD authors have every right to take a victory lap. Infected children have been their goal all along. I’m serious about this. The GBD authors should be boasting that a record number of children are contracting the virus now. Everything they’ve worked for has led to this moment.
Yet, they’ve been curiously silent about their success. It seems they’re afraid that people also know that a record number of children are going to the hospital now. Some of these children are very sick, needing ICU-level care. One news report said:
“I sorry, Mommy. Mommy hugs, I scared. I don’t like it. Mommy!” Those were the last words 3-year-old Justin Lee Francis spoke to his mother, Yvonne, before he was sedated and put on a ventilator at Primary Children’s Hospital last week, when he was diagnosed with COVID-19, asthma, pneumonia and other illnesses.
Some children are dying, including those who were eligible to be vaccinated.
Dr. Bhattacharya and his GBD co-authors are smart enough to know normal people don’t view sick, dying children as a good thing. So instead of loudly taking credit for millions of infected children as they should, the authors of the GBD are consumed by self-pity, furious that those who prefer vaccines to the virus for children view them as “fringe“. They feel compelled to constantly defend what matters most to them, their reputations, often with comical results. If I ever feel the need to make a video saying a movement I started “is NOT Koch Funded Eugenics,” I will take a real hard look at what choices led me to that point in my life.
“The lockdowns just postponed the inevitable”
Even though it’s only of historical interest, an honest broker would approach the question of lockdowns differently than Dr. Bhattacharya. They would try to honestly understand their benefits and harms. Did lockdowns stop the spread of the virus? Did they save lives? What were their costs?
From my vantage point, lockdowns clearly saved lives, at least here in New York City. COVID-19 hit us like a bomb. Our first case was confirmed on March 1, 2020. When we locked down three weeks later, an average of 16 people were dying per day. Three weeks after that, 829 people were dying daily, and hospitals were deluged. Some hospitals needed forklifts to move the bodies and refrigerated trucks were needed to store the bodies. Every other disease vanished from the hospital.
Then, the deluge receded. The refrigerated trucks left. Gradually, the hospital returned to normal. By the middle of May, the daily death toll fell below 100 people daily, still a large number of people. Thanks to vaccines, viral-induced immunity, and our behavior, our ICUs were never again overwhelmed with COVID-19 patients even during the recent omicron surge. Something abruptly stopped the spread of the virus here, and those who feel the lockdowns deserve no credit are obligated to provide a better explanation. What does Dr. Bhattacharya think stopped the virus so suddenly in the spring of 2020 in New York City? I don’t think I’ve ever heard him try to answer that. But I could have easily missed it. The man has made an inordinate number of YouTube videos.
Much of the evidence that lockdowns slowed the virus is common sense, of course. The virus couldn’t easily spread when people were separated. Formal studies support the obvious observation that lockdowns saved lives. One study, found that “36,000 fewer people would have died if social distancing measures had been put in place across the U.S. just one week earlier”.
Dr. Bhattacharya knows all this of course, which is why he reasonably said shelter-in-place orders and quarantines would be justified for a virus that could kill millions. Dr. Kulldorff also recognizes that lockdowns slowed the spread of the virus, though he disparaged them by saying that “lockdowns just postponed the inevitable“. This seems true to me. I honestly think few of us will avoid the virus the rest of our lives. That’s just a sad fact. The lockdowns just postponed the inevitable for a lot of us.
But this is not a bad thing! Dr. Kulldorff and other pro-virus doctors overlook two obvious points; 1) all of medicine is just postponing the inevitable and 2) there is often great value in postponing the inevitable. Dr. Kulldorff confirms this anytime he puts on a seat belt. The same is true with COVID-19. Someone who encountered the virus after being triple-vaccinated was much better off than an unvaccinated person who encountered the virus during the first wave when hospitals were deluged. Unless doctors make no progress in treating COVID-19, someone who encounters the virus in 2030 will be better off than someone who encounters it today.
Dr. Bhattacharya clearly saw the value in postponing the inevitable. Even though he instructed others to “resume life as normal” early in the pandemic, he wisely managed to avoid the virus until August 2021, several months after he had been vaccinated. Healthcare workers who worked with COVID-19 patients instead of making YouTube videos were often not so lucky. Around the world 180,000 healthcare workers may have died of COVID-19, including several of my friends.
The city I love became a ghost town
Of course, recognizing that lockdowns slowed the spread of the virus doesn’t mean I liked them. My children’s schooling was totally interrupted, and the city I love became a ghost town. Once the initial COVID-19 surge abated, I had it relatively easy. I never missed a paycheck, and my kids are old enough to mostly take care of themselves. It was summer, not winter. We were able to move a lot of our lives outside. Outdoor dining has permanently changed the streets of New York City for the better. On warm nights, it’s like there’s an outdoor party. I’m mostly too old, but I like seeing young people outside enjoying themselves. Similarly, Central Park turned into a chapel with dozens of outside weddings. Many people adapted to the lockdown. We all tried to be resilient. Aside from the predictable anti-vaccine sociopaths, most people in New York City looked out for one another.
Still, this is the silver lining of a dark cloud. The economic and social harms of the lockdowns were very real for a lot of people, and they were not distributed evenly. I know I was among the very fortunate. I have many reasons to be grateful. Some healthcare workers were driven to despair by what they went through. Recognizing that the lockdown saved a lot of lives doesn’t mean I don’t realize they had serious costs, and if robust studies undercut my observations and the studies thus far, I will accept the results.
Repeatedly this pandemic, Dr. Bhattacharya has contradicted Dr. Bhattacharya
In contrast, Dr. Bhattacharya is not dedicated to a method of inquiry, but rather to a result. He started with the belief that lockdowns were useless and harmful, and now struggles to retrofit data to validate his initial premise. This is easy for him to do. Dr. Bhattacharya will never treat a young person with COVID-19, or any person with any disease for that matter. Like most contrarian doctors, he experienced the pandemic from behind a computer screen, completely sheltered from the consequences of his words. He had the privilege to oppose lockdowns when he thought COVID-19 would not cause mass death, and to oppose lockdowns after COVID-19 had already caused mass death, including the deaths of thousands of people younger than 30 years.
Did Dr. Bhattacharya forget his initial claim that “shelter-in-place orders and quarantines” would be “surely justified” if “the novel coronavirus would kill millions”? Of course not. His hippocampi work just fine. He remembers what he said. He just hopes you’ll forget. But my hippocampi remembered that early essay and the compelling case it made for lockdowns. Now, so will yours.
        ◦ I also noticed an interesting pattern. Repeatedly this pandemic, Dr. Bhattacharya has contradicted Dr. Bhattacharya. And given that Dr. Bhattacharya doesn’t take the ideas of Dr. Bhattacharya seriously, why should anybody else?

Jay Bhattacharya errs on excess mortality in New Zealand
Jay Bhattacharya claims that New Zealand COVID policy was “a grand failure” based on flawed logic and a misinterpretation of the data. He should retract.
Eric Kramer on September 12, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: With managing editor Dr. Gorski on a rare holiday this week, we have economist and lawyer Eric Kramer providing a guest post in his stead, with a complementary post to John Howard’s from Friday.]
Spiked recently published a critique of New Zealand’s zero COVID policy by Jay Bhattacharya, an author of the Great Barrington Declaration. Here is his conclusion:
Ultimately, New Zealand’s Zero Covid strategy was immoral, incoherent and a grand failure.
Bhattacharya’s most compelling argument is that the zero COVID policy led to an increase in non-COVID mortality that substantially offset the COVID deaths the policy averted. If this were true, it would indeed be a powerful criticism of New Zealand’s policy. However, the best available estimates suggest that excess non-COVID mortality in New Zealand was negative during the pandemic – fewer people died than we would have expected based on historical data. New Zealand’s COVID policy appears to have prevented thousands of COVID deaths, with no offsetting increase in non-COVID mortality.
Bhattacharya got this wrong for a simple reason: he did not attempt to compare COVID deaths averted to estimates of excess non-COVID mortality. Instead, he used statistical innuendo to create the impression that the policy backfired. He also seems to have been misled by a chart of excess deaths based on a biased methodology, a mistake that would have become apparent to him if he had bothered to compare excess non-COVID mortality to COVID deaths avoided.
COVID deaths and excess mortality in New Zealand
As Bhattacharya explains, New Zealand closed its borders to most international travelers early in 2020, and then used internal lockdowns on an as-needed basis to keep the prevalence of COVID low throughout most of the epidemic.
This policy response clearly prevented many COVID deaths. Through July 24, 2022, New Zealand recorded 1,455 COVID deaths. If it had opened its borders and allowed the virus to spread freely the number of deaths would have been much higher.
How much higher? If New Zealand had a COVID death rate equal to that of the United States, roughly 14,000 additional COVID deaths would have occurred. If we compare New Zealand to U.K. the result is similar; if we use the European Union average COVID death rate, 11,000 additional deaths would have occurred. This calculation is based on the difference in confirmed deaths per million as tallied in Our World in Data, as of July 24, 2022.
It is conceivable that the zero COVID policy could have led to an increase in non-COVID deaths that substantially or fully offset the COVID deaths avoided. To determine if this occurred, we need to compare actual mortality in New Zealand during the pandemic to mortality we would have expected based on recent historical experience. Our World in Data publishes three estimates of excess mortality; their preferred estimate is based on work by Karlinsky and Kobak, and it suggests that excess mortality through July 24, 2022 was negative: -1,104. Furthermore, the actual deaths used in this excess mortality calculation includes the 1,455 COVID deaths noted above, so non-COVID mortality appears to have been reduced by roughly 2,500 relative to pre-pandemic expectations. Karlinsky and Kobak suggest that the reduction in mortality in New Zealand is due to reduced influenza mortality caused by lockdowns and social distancing. Recent estimates of life expectancy (not yet peer reviewed) which account for changes in the age structure of the population show life expectancy decreasing in the United States and England/Wales during the pandemic, but increasing slightly in New Zealand. This tends to corroborate the estimate of negative excess mortality in New Zealand.
The upshot is that the zero COVID policy appears to have avoided something like 10,000 to 14,000 deaths, and it modestly reduced non-COVID mortality as well.
Bhattacharya’s analysis
Bhattacharya acknowledges that New Zealand’s policy prevented many COVID deaths, but he strongly implies that excess non-COVID mortality offset reduced mortality from COVID (my bold):
On the negative side of the ledger is the tremendous burden on the New Zealand population that has come from being isolated from the rest of the world for such a long time, and from the intermittent lockdowns the government imposed on the population. All-cause excess deaths – below baseline levels in 2020 – shot up in 2021 and in 2022. Some weeks, recorded death rates were at 32 per cent above the norm. New Zealand delayed and reduced COVID deaths at the expense of increasing deaths from other causes. And then, of course, there are the enormous economic, psychological and additional health costs of lockdown that the population will pay out for over the coming years.
Bhattacharya’s suggestion that excess non-COVID deaths offset COVID deaths avoided is not supported by the available evidence: it appears that excess non-COVID deaths were negative. Furthermore, Bhattacharya has no basis for making this apparently false claim, since he does not present estimates of either COVID deaths averted or excess non-COVID mortality.
Instead of comparing lives saved and lost due to zero COVID, Bhattacharya uses statistical innuendo to cast doubt on the efficacy of New Zealand’s approach to COVID.
Consider Bhattacharya’s statement that excess deaths “shot up” in 2021. Bhattacharya links to a graph that shows the percent deviation of the actual weekly death rate from the death rate that would be expected based on historical experience (so-called “p-scores”). The graph seems to show that excess mortality was positive in 2021. It turns out that this is probably not true; Bhattacharya has linked to the wrong set of estimates. I will return to this point below. But even taking the chart Bhattacharya cites at face value, it does not support his claim that the zero COVID policy backfired for several reasons. First, eyeballing a chart of p-scores does not tell us how many excess deaths occurred. A small increase in excess deaths would not significantly support the claim that excess deaths offset lives saved by the zero COVID policy. Second, Bhattacharya does not adjust excess mortality by removing COVID deaths. Third, Bhattacharya focuses on the increase in excess mortality from 2020 to 2021 (deaths “shot up”) but ignores the negative excess mortality that the chart suggests occurred in 2020.
Turning briefly to 2022, the same problems arise. It is true that excess mortality was positive in 2022 (even using the better set of estimates). However, to evaluate New Zealand’s policy we need to know how many excess non-COVID deaths occurred, so we need to start with total excess deaths and remove COVID deaths. It turns out that there were 1,669 excess deaths from January 2 through July 24 (using the preferred set of estimates). However, over this same period there were 1,406 COVID deaths (see here), so almost all the excess deaths in 2022 were from COVID, they were not non-COVID deaths inadvertently caused by the zero COVID policy.
The link Bhattacharya supplies to support his statement that excess deaths rose in 2022 takes us to an article about COVID deaths, not excess mortality, so it’s just there for decoration. (Remember that COVID deaths need to be removed from overall excess mortality before comparing to COVID deaths averted.) And Bhattacharya’s claim that excess death rates were “32 per cent above the norm” for “some weeks” in 2022 is true (putting aside the fact that he is using the wrong set of estimated p-scores), but he is just cherry picking the worst weekly numbers off a chart that bounces around considerably from week to week, and distracting attention from the real issue, which is whether excess non-COVID deaths were high enough to offset a substantial fraction of the COVID deaths averted.
Conflicting estimates of excess mortality
Our World in Data originally published excess mortality figures that used a simple average of historical mortality to estimate expected deaths during the pandemic. This methodology can lead to misleading results due to seasonality and changes in mortality due to population aging. For example, if mortality is rising due to population aging, using historical mortality rates can lead to inflated estimates of excess mortality. To address these problems, Karlinsky and Kobak changed their estimation method to adjust for seasonality and secular trends in mortality rates. Our World in Data now emphasizes these estimates, but it has continued to publish p-scores based on the old methodology; see the discussion here. Bhattacharya linked to a chart of p-scores based on the now-outdated estimation methodology. A set of p-scores based on the newer methodology is here, and it suggests that excess mortality remained negative in 2021, before becoming slightly positive in 2022.
Bhattacharya may have concluded that the zero COVID policy led to a substantial increase in non-COVID mortality because he was misled by the p-scores he saw. Recall that the p-score chart Bhattacharya links to seems to show that excess mortality was positive in 2021 as well as 2022. However, as I emphasized above, this p-score chart does not justify Bhattacharya’s criticism of New Zealand’s approach to COVID, because it does not tell us the number of excess non-COVID deaths and compare this number to an estimate of the number of COVID deaths averted (recall he never estimates this number). His discussion of excess mortality is just innuendo. Furthermore, if Bhattacharya had attempted to check if the apparent rise in non-COVID deaths suggested by the likely biased p-score estimates was large enough to offset the thousands of COVID deaths avoided, he would have quickly realized that there was a problem with the p-score data he cited, because Our World in Data only publishes counts of excess deaths based on the revised estimates that show negative excess mortality in 2021, which is inconsistent with the p-score series he cites.
A short restatement of the problem
Bhattacharya suggests that New Zealand’s zero COVID policy led to a substantial offsetting increase in non-COVID mortality. This is simply not supported by the available evidence. Zero COIVID saved a substantial number of lives, and it appears to have reduced non-COVID mortality as well, perhaps by reducing influenza deaths. On its face, the policy seems to have substantially reduced mortality.
Instead of doing a straightforward comparison of COVID deaths averted and excess non-COVID mortality, Bhattacharya pointed to estimated p-scores that appear to show that excess mortality was positive in 2021 and 2022. However, these estimates were based on a methodology that is believed to overstate excess mortality, and, more important, he failed to look up and report the number of estimated excess deaths, to remove COVID deaths, and to compare the number of excess non-COVID deaths to lives saved.
The fact that New Zealand’s policy appears to have saved thousands of lives does not prove that the zero COVID policy was justified, because it did have real costs, but Bhattacharya cannot declare the policy a failure without making a real effort to balance these costs against the very substantial number of lives saved.
Making the perfect the enemy of the good
Bhattacharya does point to some potentially valid criticisms of New Zealand’s response to COVID. He complains that the government rollout of vaccines was unnecessarily slow, and that the government erred by delaying the end of its zero COVID policy until most Kiwis were vaccinated, rather than opening up as soon as the most vulnerable people got their shots. It is also conceivable that excess mortality will rise in the future, and that some number of COVID deaths were merely delayed, not completely averted, possibilities that Bhattacharya gestures towards but does not seriously evaluate.
These are debatable points; for example, according to this article, several countries that successfully contained COVID, including New Zealand, intentionally delayed their vaccination programs to learn about adverse events from experience in other countries. This may have been a mistake, but Bhattacharya needs to argue for this, not just assert it.
Similarly, a reasonable person can argue that New Zealand should have ended its zero COVID policy earlier, after vaccinating its most vulnerable residents. But this is not self-evident. Even people at lower risk die from COVID; why not delay the reopening a month or two to get more people vaccinated? Rather than making an effort to estimate costs and lives saved, Bhattacharya claims that early reopening was justified because “[b]oosting with additional vaccine doses – especially in the Omicron era – also does not prevent infection”. However, the paper he cites does not support this conclusion, and in any event vaccination clearly prevents COVID deaths.
More fundamentally, even if we agree that the government mishandled some aspects of the pandemic response – and no doubt it did – that hardly justifies Bhattacharya’s confident declaration that the policy was “a grand failure”. This conclusion seems to reflect his strong commitment to avoiding lockdowns and achieving herd immunity as quickly as possible, not a careful consideration of what New Zealanders gained and lost from pursuing a zero COVID strategy.
Bhattacharya owes his readers a retraction
Throughout the pandemic, Bhattacharya has criticized the media and his professional colleagues for misleading the public about COVID. He can set an example by retracting his misleading essay on New Zealand’s COVID policy. Bhattacharya is certainly entitled to criticize New Zealand’s approach to COVID, but he is not entitled to use statistical innuendo to create the impression that New Zealand’s policy backfired and led to a substantial increase in non-COVID mortality when the data suggest this is false. He also should acknowledge that he cited estimates of excess mortality rates that many believe overstate excess deaths.

Did New Zealand Let Too Few People Die of COVID?
Doctors used to agree mass death was a bad thing. Not anymore.
Jonathan Howard on September 9, 2022
Link

In a previous article titled ‘Lockdowns “Postponed the Inevitable”. Is That a Bad Thing?‘, I noted that South Korea and New Zealand couldn’t keep the virus away forever, but by postponing large outbreaks until their population had been vaccinated, they suffered many fewer deaths per capita than the US and nearly every other country in the world. Over 800,000 Americans would be alive today if the US had their death rate. In that article, I asked if South Korea and New Zealand had damaged themselves by delaying outbreaks, or rather, would the US have benefitted had it tried a bit harder to suppress the virus.
I thought the answer was obvious, at least to anyone who feels mass death and suffering is a bad thing.
Not everyone agrees with my assessment. I am referring to an article written in August 2022 by Dr. Jay Bhattacharya titled “Zero Covid Has Cost New Zealand Dearly“. Because Dr. Bhattacharya wanted unvaccinated young people to contract COVID, New Zealand’s decision to protect all of its citizens represents the antithesis of his pro-virus stance. As such, Dr. Bhattacharya was always going start with his conclusions and then search for the evidence. Predictably, the article contains multiple flaws, which become clear in the article’s second sentence which states:
Covid cases in New Zealand have exploded, with cumulative cases per capita now exceeding US levels.
While the simple tally of cases in the US is an enormous underestimate that renders comparison meaningless, Dr. Bhattacharya acknowledges that New Zealand abandoned its Zero Covid strategy. New Zealand couldn’t close its borders and periodically lockdown forever, especially in the face of Omicron. But they chose to do so until most of their citizens were vaccinated. Though Dr. Bhattacharya rightly criticizes New Zealand for a slow vaccine roll-out, he recognizes that:
By February 2022, like other developed countries, New Zealand had successfully vaccinated a large proportion of its population, elderly and young, vulnerable and non-vulnerable alike.
Of course there is no group that is “non-vulnerable”. That’s a myth that promoted by doctors who experienced the pandemic entirely from their laptop. However, even Dr. Bhattacharya is forced to concede that:
New Zealand’s strategy delayed the inevitable spread of Covid throughout the population to a time after the development, testing and deployment of a vaccine capable of reducing the burden of severe Covid disease. Despite having experienced more Covid cases per capita throughout the pandemic than the US, New Zealand has a tiny proportion of the US’s Covid-attributable deaths per capita.
Dr. Bhattacharya was also forced to concede another uncomfortable point, writing that “All-cause excess deaths – below baseline levels in 2020 – shot up in 2021 and in 2022“. The link in Dr. Bhattacharya’s article produced the following graph, showing that countries that let the virus run wild had much greater excess mortality than New Zealand for nearly all of the pandemic. New Zealand’s largest increase mortality occurred only after they abandoned their COVID Zero strategy, but because most of their population was vaccinated by then, they fared much better than the US and UK.
Despite this, Dr. Bhattacharya does not feel that any of this really matters compared to the economy. This is why he didn’t tell his readers that 800,000 Americans would be alive today if the US had New Zealand’s COVID death rate. Instead, Dr. Bhattacharya’s readers will learn detailed statistics about New Zealand’s economy. He wrote,
There was economic damage as well during the Zero Covid period. New Zealand’s typically robust tourist industry collapsed as overseas visitors stopped coming. The New Zealand economy shrank by two per cent in 2020 despite Zero Covid, recovered to grow by 5.6 per cent in 2021, but shrank again in the first quarter of 2022 as Omicron cases spread throughout the nation. In July 2022, inflation reached 7.3 per cent, sharply reducing the purchasing power of New Zealanders.
I agree with him that lockdowns are bad for business, and I don’t want to trivialize their financial harms. I was sheltered from this the way he was sheltered from the care of COVID patients. However, countries that let the virus run rampant didn’t exactly have booming economies either. Millions of Americans lost their jobs, and the whole world is suffering from inflation today. It’s probably not good for offices, restaurants, and theaters when so many people are dying that morgue workers have to use forklifts to move bodies into giant refrigerated trucks, as happened here in New York City at the pandemic’s start. It’s also probably not good for business when workers get sick. A new study estimated that 4 million Americans are out of work due to long COVID, though Dr. Bhattacharya will be unlikely to acknowledge this unwanted fact. Of course, even if all of New Zealand’s economic woes were from their “Zero Covid period”, it’s not obvious to me this financial price was not counterbalanced by their citizens not dying.
Dr. Bhattacharya concluded:
Finally, New Zealand’s strategy relied entirely on the development and testing of a vaccine outside of its borders. Indeed, the vaccines could never have been tested in 2020 and 2021 within New Zealand because there were insufficient Covid cases to run a meaningful randomised trial. In effect, New Zealand relied on the fact that other countries did not adopt a Zero Covid policy to create conditions that permitted New Zealand to escape from the Zero Covid trap it embraced until spring 2022.
Ultimately, New Zealand’s Zero Covid strategy was immoral, incoherent and a grand failure.
In essence, Dr. Bhattacharya is saying, since the rest of the world suffered from COVID, New Zealand had no right to contain the virus. He feels New Zealand was “immoral” for not letting more of its citizens die of COVID.
I wonder how many New Zealanders feel their country’s COVID approach was “immoral, incoherent and a grand failure”. I wonder how Americans, especially those who lost a loved one, feel their country’s approach was “immoral, incoherent and a grand failure”.

I Didn’t Encourage the Spread of COVID. Was I Unethical?
No. I was not unethical.
Jonathan Howard on December 16, 2022
Link

In a previous article, I discussed whether or not it was bad that lockdowns delayed the spread of COVID in the spring of 2020. I argued it was good. I remember what it was like when forklifts were moving corpses into overflowing trucks. I also know that someone who gets COVID today, after being vaccinated and boosted, is much more likely to survive than someone who got it in March 2020, when hospitals were overwhelmed and we had no idea how to treat this new virus. Indeed a study published this week estimated that COVID vaccines saved 3.2 million lives, prevented 18.5 million hospitalizations, and saved $1.15 trillion in medical costs. So yes, I think it’s good that lockdowns delayed the spread of COVID.
Doctors who never treated COVID patients don’t see it this way. One of the authors of the anti-vaccine Great Barrington Declaration said this.
His co-author of the GBD, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, elaborated on this point, saying frontline healthcare workers violated medical ethics by trying to stop people from contracting a virus that could kill them. He said:
If you think about medicine as a vocation, you’re supposed to devote your well-being to the life a patient that you are caring for…lockdowns actually reversed that and said look, ‘you the population should suffer so that my job in medicine can be easier‘, so a reversal of the norms of medicine where medicine serves people, not people serve medicine. The fact that medicine, especially the leaders of medicine were so strongly in favor of the lockdowns is a violation of the ethics of the medical profession. It essentially transforms the doctor-patient relationship to one where the patient serves the doctor rather than the other way around.
When I think back to those pandemic’s first days, I remember deserted streets, but an overwhelmed hospital, where dozens of people died daily, including some who were young and healthy. There was nothing we could do to save them. We didn’t know when it would end and we saw some of our co-workers get really sick themselves. Despite this, Dr. Bhattacharya, who wisely avoided COVID until August 2021 after he was vaccinated, feels doctors should have looked at the suffering and death around us and honored the ethics of our profession by declaring: We need more people to get COVID right now.
Only a laptop class doctor, who experienced the pandemic from the safety of his couch, could say something this absurd.

Through The Looking Glass With Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and Humpty Dumpty agree, words have no meaning.
Jonathan Howard on March 11, 2022
Link

Have we completely abandoned the idea that words have meaning?
In a previous essay, I asked the following questions about the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), who routinely claim to be “censored” despite their enormous media footprint and direct access to and influence over our most powerful politicians.
How can “muzzled” people be so loud? How can “censored” people be so ubiquitous? How have the GBD authors simultaneously been able to influence the country’s most powerful leaders and also been deprived of a “fair hearing”? Aren’t “silenced” people, supposed to be, well, silent? Have we completely abandoned the idea that words have meaning?
I am now prepared to answer the last of these questions. Yes, some people have completely abandoned the idea that words have meaning.
“The extraordinary measures I advocated was not lockdown, but rather a rapid seroprevalence study and a focused protection approach”
To further explain, I will reference another previous essay in which I quoted from an article by Drs. Eran Bendavid and Jay Bhattacharya titled Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? published in March 2020. In particular, I quoted the following sentence they wrote and made it the title of my article.
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
Though this seems entirely straight forward, to provide further context for this statement, I added the following,
Though he was clear that mass death would justify lockdowns, at the time he felt “there’s little evidence to confirm that premise” that COVID-19 could kill millions and that “projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.” He wrote that “if we’re right about the limited scale of the epidemic, then…A universal quarantine may not be worth the costs it imposes on the economy, community and individual mental and physical health.” Simply put, Dr. Bhattacharya was against lockdowns at the start of the pandemic because he didn’t feel COVID-19 would be that bad. He wrote, that “a 20,000-40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million”, and that early estimates of mass death were “deeply flawed.”
Dr. Bhattacharya responds
Recently, Dr. Bhattacharya responded to an inquiry about my article on social media. The questioner asked if he indeed wrote that “If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.”
Dr. Bhattacharya’s response was rather revealing. He said that,
I wrote that sentence in the WSJ piece. But the extraordinary measures I advocated was not lockdown, but rather a rapid seroprevalence study and a focused protection approach. The people who keep that blog you show are lockdowners & have slandered me throughout the epidemic… They excel in taking quotes out of context and spinning false conspiracy stories about funding.
And there it is. Words have no meaning.
A sad pattern
This is pathetic, but hardly surprising. As is typical for contrarian doctors sheltered from the consequences of their words, Dr. Bhattacharya has a long pattern of such linguistic gymnastics.
    • After COVID-19 killed at least 349 children and the flu just one child, he said that “Very few healthy, young children died from this virus, more died from the flu last year.”
    • Though he claims to speak for “the working class” in opposition to “the laptop class”, he experienced the pandemic from behind a computer screen rather than a patient’s beside. I’d be happy to tell him a bit about what it’s been like. He can tell me what it’s like to star in YouTube videos.
    • Even though he instructed others to “resume life as normal“, he wisely managed to avoid the virus until August 2021, after he had been vaccinated.
    • Though he bristles at any suggestion he is anti-vaccine, he’s routinely opposes vaccinating children and helped influence Florida’s horrible decision to encourage healthy children to get the virus rather the vaccine. In an article called “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young” he even wrote, “The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.” All of this is, of course, anti-vaccine. If you don’t believe me, test yourself here.
    • Even though he constantly talks about COVID-19 and only COVID-19, he said in September 2021, “The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.”
    • He said that Florida had “protected the vulnerable” right before the Delta variant ripped through the state killing more people than ever before.
‘When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean–neither more nor less.”
If you feel you are in Through the Looking Glass, you’re not alone. In that absurd world, running allows one to remain stationary and moving away from something brings one closer to it. In Dr. Bhattacharya’s absurd world:
    • It is slander to accurately quote Dr. Bhattacharya.
    • Providing context for his quotes is “taking quotes out of context.”
    • “Shelter-in-place orders and quarantines” really mean “a rapid seroprevalence study and a focused protection approach”.
    • Being “muzzled” means private meetings with the President of the United States and the Governor of Florida, directly influencing their COVID response.
    • 1 is larger than 349.
    • Resuming “life as normal” means avoiding COVID for 1.5 years, until after he had been vaccinated.
    • Being “pro-vaccine” means vocally opposing vaccines.
    • “Treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people” means talking exclusively about COVID.
    • Protecting vulnerable people means they die in record numbers.
    • A member of the laptop class has authority to speak on behalf of doctors who work in hospitals, many of whom feel he’s made their job much harder.
In claiming words mean whatever he wants them to mean, Dr. Bhattacharya is channeling the character of Humpty Dumpty who had this memorable exchange with Alice.
‘…and that shows that there are three hundred and sixty-four days when you might get un-birthday presents––’
‘Certainly,’ said Alice.
‘And only one for birthday presents, you know. There’s glory for you!’
‘I don’t know what you mean by “glory”,’ Alice said.
‘Humpty Dumpty smiled contemptuously. ‘Of course you don’t–till I tell you. I meant “there’s a nice knock-down argument for you!”‘
‘But “glory” doesn’t mean “a nice knock-down argument”, Alice objected.
‘When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean–neither more nor less.’
‘The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean different things–that’s all.’
‘The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master–that’s all’
Alice was too much puzzled to say anything; so after a minute Humpty Dumpty began again. ‘They’ve a temper, some of them — particularly verbs: they’re the proudest — adjectives you can do anything with, but not verbs — however, I can manage the whole lot of them! Impenetrability! That’s what I say!’
‘Would you tell me please,’ said Alice, ‘what that means?’
‘Now you talk like a reasonable child,’ said Humpty Dumpty, looking very much pleased. ‘I meant by “impenetrability” that we’ve had enough of that subject, and it would be just as well if you’d mention what you mean to do next, as I suppose you don’t mean to stop here all the rest of your life.’
‘That’s a great deal to make one word mean,’ Alice said in a thoughtful tone.
‘When I make a word do a lot of work like that,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘I always pay it extra.’
This word-play is all very amusing when it comes from nonsensical characters in a work of fantasy.
It’s not so cute when it comes from a highly-credentialed scientist at a prestigious university who has greatly influenced our disastrous pandemic response. Words have meaning. People should say what they mean and mean what they say.

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Responds to Words I Never Said
My critics lack the courage to accurately quote me. That tells you everything about them and nothing about me.
Jonathan Howard on June 4, 2023
Link

Several people have been kind enough to read my book and write thoughtful reviews (Pandemic Accountability Index, Gunnar Hamann, Dr. Christopher Lane, Michael Hiltzik). Other people, who have yet to read it, weren’t so kind, or thoughtful. Two of my critics said the following:
In my book, I quote people like Mr. Tucker and Dr. Bhattacharya accurately and extensively, and it’s gratifying how many readers have commented on the thorough references. In fact, my book opens with this quote from Dr. Bhattacharya, which comes from a roundtable discussion with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis on July 26, 2021. He said:
We have protected the vulnerable—by vaccinating the older population, we have provided them with enormous protection against severe disease and death. That’s why you see, even as the cases have risen in Sweden in the past wave, or in the UK in this past wave, and in Florida in this past wave, the number of deaths have not risen proportionally. Why? Because we protected the vulnerable. The key thing to me is hospitalizations and deaths from COVID. While we’ve done an incredible job at decoupling the cases from the deaths, the public focus on cases at this point, I think, only serves to panic people without actually serving any other public health purpose.… I don’t think the delta variant changes the calculus or the evidence in any fundamental way.
In reality, the Delta variart changed the calculus and evidence in a very fundamental way, and this was obvious within days. Six weeks after Dr. Bhattacharya said the vulnerable had been protected, headlines declared “4 Kids Among Florida’s COVID Death Toll as State Sets Another Record for Fatalities“. Calling me “inane” doesn’t change any of this.
I explicitly call attention to importance of quotes in the book’s first chapter. I wrote:
Large portions of this book are merely quotes by contrarian doctors. Please read them carefully and judge for yourself whether they aged well or not. Also pay close attention to the tone and language these doctors use. Watch some of their YouTube videos. What words do they use to describe the virus? What words do they use to describe the vaccine and other measures to control COVID? Are they willing to share bad news about the virus? Are they willing to share good news about the vaccine?
Not only do these quotes bolster my arguments, it’s the only way to be fair to the people I discuss. Their words belong to them, even if the consequences belonged to others.
Predictably, my critics did not extend the same courtesy to me. They tried to make strangers’ words belong to me. Despite not quoting me at all, they claimed I believe:
    • Living your life is an irresponsible act
    • Sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act
    • In lockdowns with no logical endpoint
    • In lockdowns forever
    • The public should avoid COVID to protect doctors (discussed here)
    • That people should hide away forever
    • That people should be used as lab rats for iterative vaccine development
By putting absurd words into my mouth to argue against their own fantasies, Dr. Bhattacharya tricked his audience, while ducking what I actually wrote. This is what is so pernicious about these juvenile straw man arguments and immature insults. For example, although the Great Barrington Declaration still claims people can hide from the virus and herd immunity will arrive 3-6 months, Dr. Bhattacharya scolded me saying in his “rebuttal” by saying:
There is and was no way to hide away from the virus forever without harm to your physical, psychological, and economic health.
Dr. Bhattacharya isn’t refuting me. He’s catching up to me. Here’s what I wrote two years ago in an article advocating for pediatric vaccination:
It seems implausible a large percentage of unvaccinated young people will be able to avoid the virus for years to come. As such, I suspect that most everyone will gain immunity to COVID-19 eventually. It’s just a question of whether it’s through the vaccine or virus.
Meanwhile, here’s what Dr. Bhattacharya wrote two years ago in his anti-vaccine article “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
Dr. Bhattacharya felt vaccinating everyone would be “more dangerous” than vaccinating no one. Calling me “covidian” doesn’t make this age any better.
Worse than this, Dr. Bhattacharya now holds me responsible for words he wrote at the pandemic’s start, when he surmised that COVID had “one-tenth of the flu mortality rate of 0.1%”. I was busy in the hospital at the time and said very little. That’s why, despite his childish taunts of “lockdowner”, Dr. Bhattacharya can’t quote me as saying:
Over a million Americans are dead already, and millions more would have died had we let the virus run rampant before anyone was vaccinated. Calling me a “lockdowner” doesn’t change what Dr. Bhattacharya wrote.
I invite people to disagree with my words, so long as they are my words. Thus far however, my critics have lacked the courage to quote me at all. Sadly, Mr. Tucker and Dr. Bhattacharya have been so warped by the rewards of social media engagement from unquestioning strangers, they can only robotically repeat the exact same insults and canned responses to all of their critics. They no longer even pretend to engage on the substance of what I actually said- much of which is simply quoting what they actually said.
Their response tells you everything about them and nothing about me.

Prediction: Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Will Never Treat COVID as “One of 200 Diseases That Affect People”.
It’s interesting to ponder an alternate reality where doctors who said the pandemic ended long ago took their own advice.
Jonathan Howard on October 20, 2023
Link

Since September 4th, 2021 over 400,000 American have died of COVID. On that date, the Washington Post published an article titled “The Covid Endgame: Is the Pandemic Over Already? Or Are There Years To Go?.  It quoted Dr. Jay Bhattacharya who said:
The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.
Since that time, Dr. Bhattacharya has talked about the pandemic endlessly and exclusively, telling us the emergency phase of the disease is over and we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. This has been his consistent message since March 2020.  However, Dr. Bhattacharya has not modeled the behavior he demands from others. I have not witnessed his every utterance, but I can’t recall him ever talking about any of those other 199 diseases.
It’s interesting to ponder an alternate reality where Dr. Bhattacharya took his own advice and treated COVID as one of 200 diseases that affects people. Would he be repeatedly invited on Fox News to discuss migraines? Would the Brownstone Institute and Wall Street Journal publish his musings on idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis? Would he receive rewards for his discussions of glioblastomas? How much social media adulation would he receive for his thoughts on pancreatic cancer? Would podcasters invite him to discuss ALS? Would he be invited to testify in front of Congress about Crohn’s disease? Would he be asked to testify in courts regarding Parkinson’s disease? Would the Governor of Florida relentlessly promote his views on polycystic kidney disease? Would he be invited to the Oval Office to discuss psoriasis?
Wise people have learned to be very careful when making predictions this pandemic. But based on how I would answer these questions, I confidently predict Dr. Bhattacharya will never treat COVID as just one of 200 diseases that affects people.
I’ll happily update this essay if he proves me wrong.

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: “The Unspoken Root Idea Of His Is That The General Public Owed It To Doctors To Not Get COVID Because It Would Place Doctors At Risk Of Getting COVID. Of Course This Is An Inversion. “
Frontline healthcare workers are also part of the public. Our lives have value too.
Jonathan Howard on November 17, 2023
Link

“These deaths are a tragic loss”
The only surefire way to avoid dying of COVID is to avoid infection with SARS-CoV-2. One group of people that couldn’t avoid exposure was healthcare workers, who unsurprisingly had some of the highest death rates of any occupation, especially early in the pandemic. I knew several who died, as does anyone else who worked in a hospital at that time. According to one article from the World Health Organization:
Health and care workers are the foundation of health systems and the driving force to achieving universal health coverage and global health security. Their commitment and professionalism throughout the pandemic are evident to all: extraordinary people, performing extraordinary work.
However, too many of them have become infected, ill or died as a result of COVID-19.
WHO estimates that between 80,000 and 180,000 health and care workers could have died from COVID-19 in the period between January 2020 to May 2021, converging to a medium scenario of 115,500 deaths.
These deaths are a tragic loss. They are also an irreplaceable gap in the world’s pandemic response.
This is a surprisingly controversial statement. Not everyone agrees that “too many of them have become infected”.
“The unspoken root idea of his is that the general public owed it to doctors to not get COVID because it would place doctors at risk of getting COVID.”
With this in mind, let’s revisit a previous article in which I discussed Dr. Jay Bhattacharya’s “rebuttal” to my book, noting that it was nothing but straw man arguments. However, one of Dr. Bhattacharya’s pretend rebuttals deserves closer scrutiny. He wrote:
The unspoken root idea of his is that the general public owed it to doctors to not get COVID because it would place doctors at risk of getting COVID.  Of course this is an inversion.  Medical professionals serve the public, not the other way around.
I never said anything like this because such a statement would have been absurd, especially at the start of the pandemic. Unlike Dr. Bhattacharya, who made a YouTube video to discuss being called “fringe”, I know what hospitals were like during that first wave. We were bathed in SARS-CoV-2, often without adequate PPE. One article from April 2020 about Bellevue Hospital, where I work, correctly reported:
Nearly the entire hospital is one big COVID-19 unit, and even patients that aren’t in ICUs are extremely sick and often require intensive oversight.
Another 10,100, or 1,000 COVID patients would have overwhelmed our ability to care for them, but it wouldn’t have exposed us to more risk. Either Dr. Bhattacharya, who never treated a COVID patient himself, was ignorant of this sad reality or he can’t grasp the law of diminishing returns, a basic economic principle.
Unfortunately, this was not the first time Dr. Bhattacharya, who worked from his office this pandemic, claimed frontline healthcare workers were selfish and unethical. In a previous article, I discussed this quote of his:
If you think about medicine as a vocation, you’re supposed to devote your well-being to the life a patient that you are caring for…lockdowns actually reversed that and said look, ‘you the population should suffer so that my job in medicine can be easier‘, so a reversal of the norms of medicine where medicine serves people, not people serve medicine. The fact that medicine, especially the leaders of medicine were so strongly in favor of the lockdowns is a violation of the ethics of the medical profession. It essentially transforms the doctor-patient relationship to one where the patient serves the doctor rather than the other way around.
To summarize, Dr. Bhattacharya, who wisely dodged SARS-CoV-2 until after he was vaccinated, feels frontline healthcare workers who sought to slow the spread of the virus did so for two self-serving reasons: to lower their own “risk of getting COVID” and “so that my job in medicine can be easier”. Doctors who tried to stop the spread of COVID were violating medical ethics, according to a doctor who never saw anyone die from it.
“It’s not just about us, of course.”
Since Dr. Bhattacharya claims to have magically divined the “unspoken root idea” of my book without having read it, he’s unaware of what I actually wrote. Here’s what I wrote on this topic:
It’s obviously true that people who couldn’t stay home, like frontline healthcare workers, contracted COVID at a much higher rate than people who could isolate themselves. However, we wouldn’t have been better off had bankers contracted COVID during the first wave.
It’s not just about us, of course. Bus drivers wouldn’t have been better off if only more hedge fund managers contracted COVID in April 2020. Had the laptop class been infected all at the same time then, the catastrophe that befell us in New York City and elsewhere would have been much worse. Hospitals were deluged as it was and no one working in one bemoaned the fact that lockdowns protected the laptop class. We wanted everyone to be safe and would have been furious had we learned of young lawyers partying inside while mass death surrounded us. Even if they all turned out fine, we knew their infections would spill over into vulnerable people.
Indeed, a CDC report published in October 2020, just two days before Dr. Bhattacharya unleashed his disastrous plan to achieve herd immunity in 3-6 months through the mass infection of 250 million unvaccinated Americans found:
During June–August 2020, COVID-19 incidence was highest in persons aged 20–29 years, who accounted for >20% of all confirmed cases. Younger adults likely contribute to community transmission of COVID-19. Across the southern United States in June 2020, increases in percentage of positive SARS-CoV-2 test results among adults aged 20–39 years preceded increases among those aged ≥60 years by 4–15 days.
A more recent study of nearly 850,000 American households, found that 70% of COVID transmissions started with a child.
As a reminder, over 800 New Yorkers died of COVID on a single day during the pandemic’s peak in April 2020, and giant refrigerated trucks were needed throughout the city to store the corpses. Frontline healthcare workers who sought to limit COVID at that time weren’t reversing the doctor-patient relationship, nor were they violating the ethics of the medical profession. They were trying to prevent death and suffering. It’s that simple.
However, our attempts to stop the virus interfered with Dr. Bhattacharya’s stated mission to have the population “build up immunity to the virus through natural infection”.  As a result, we are his targets, and he must reframe our efforts to stop a deadly virus as an unethical combination of laziness and cowardice. Even though frontline healthcare workers have been threatened and attacked this pandemic, Dr. Bhattacharya vilifies us, not for the care we directly provided to COVID patients, but for nearly anything we did to try to limit the number of COVID patients.
Remember, they wanted them infected.
“The general public owed it to the general public to not get COVID.”
In the real world, viruses can go viral and hospitals can be overwhelmed. For this reason, the general public owed it to the general public to not get COVID, an obvious point that eluded Dr. Bhattacharya.
However, let’s indulge Dr. Bhattacharya’s absurd fantasy and imagine a fictional world where healthcare workers asked the public to avoid bars and parties only so they wouldn’t die of COVID. Would that have been inappropriate? Are our lives, and the lives of the people we live with, totally expendable? Are sick and dead healthcare workers good for the public during a raging pandemic?
Dr. Bhattacharya is right that healthcare workers serve the public, namely the patients directly under our care. We knew when we signed up that we might be exposed to deadly pathogens, and millions of healthcare workers around the world chose to work with COVID patients, risking injury and death to honor the ethics of our profession. However, we are also part of the public, and our lives have value too. Too many frontline healthcare workers died this pandemic, none of whom volunteered to be cannon fodder to fulfill Dr. Bhattacharya’s failed dream of herd immunity through the mass infection, even though our health was a sacrifice he seemed willing to make.
Kious Kelly was only 48 when he died of COVID in March 2020

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, April 2021: “The Central Problem Right Now I Think Is The Fear That People Still Feel About COVID.”
Link
Jonathan Howard on March 17, 2024
The central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID.
During a podcast with Dr. Zubin Damania (ZDoggMD) from April 2021, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya said:
I think that the central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID…I think that that, that we are so used to this fear that we’ve lived under for a year that we don’t know how to get out of it. There’s still this fear, how do we decondition it?…
I think it’s partly the fear, right? I think that it’s hard to let go of that. You’ve lived your, for a full year under it. It’s hard to let go. I’d say it’s, I mean in some ways you can understand it, right? It’s like we’ve been conditioned to be careful. And when the, when the danger is gone, we’re still careful.
Stop and think about that for moment. The central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID. Let’s flashback to spring 2021. Vaccines were being rolled out and cases were dropping. 560,000 Americans had already died of COVID in a year’s time and worse variants loomed. Hundreds of thousands of more would die of COVID in the next few years and many more would be seriously injured. Yet, according to Dr. Bhattacharya, the “central problem” at that time was that too many people still feared the virus.
As he had done since March 2020, when he postulated that COVID had “one-tenth of the flu mortality rate” and would kill 20,000-40,000 Americans, Dr. Bhattacharya used his status as a pandemic celebrity to relentlessly to pacify strangers about COVID’s risks in spring 2021. During a “roundtable” with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis from March 2021, he said:
Although people think about the disease as mainly just this deadly viral pneumonia that results in hospitalization and death. In fact, the vast majority of cases are relatively mild, asymptomatic, or with mild symptoms.
“We should not be particularly concerned about the variants that have arisen to date,” he said in another interview that month.
My writing features literally thousands of quotes like these- we should not be particularly concerned– from doctors, few of whom treated COVID patients, from every stage of the pandemic. Dr. Bhattacharya was just one of many doctors who made it his central mission to convince the public the “central problem” was that anyone still feared the virus. Since COVID had been “defanged”, as Dr. Bhattacharya put it on April 14, 2021, May 3, 2021, July 21, 2021, July 28, 2021, and January 6, 2022, these doctors claimed that only mitigations measures should be feared. They routinely mocked and pathologized anyone they deemed excessively cautious, which was basically anyone who wasn’t a senior citizen who took any precautions at all. Starting as early as April 2020, these “free-thinking” doctors took turns writing identical articles about how the danger was over and now was the time to stop “living in fear”.
Did they ever pause to wonder if everyone who heeded their reckless advice turned out OK? Not that I’ve ever seen.
“Oh no! Strangers are trying to avoid COVID!”
As a society we should appreciate young adults who help generate herd immunity by living normal lives and keeping society afloat. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
An entire chapter of my book (and this by Dr. David Gorksi) is devoted to how doctors shamed and stigmatized anyone who wanted to avoid COVID and how their mockery plagiarized pre-pandemic, anti-vaccine blather about “irrational measles fear“. In that chapter, I wrote the following:
It was never clear exactly why they were so irate that strangers didn’t want to eat in a restaurant or attend a concert without a mask. How did this affect them? They never showed an interest in anxiety disorders before, and today are bothered by only “coronaphobia” and nothing else. Yet when COVID was killing hundreds or even thousands of people every day, they treated it as a catastrophe whenever someone wanted to avoid it. Perhaps every cautious person was a reminder that the pandemic didn’t end in the spring of 2021, as they claimed it would.
This may be true, but it should have been very clear to me why so many of these doctors were so irate that strangers wanted to avoid COVID. The reason was staring me right in the face. From Dr. Bhattacharya’s sheltered vantage point, he was absolutely right that fear of COVID was the “central problem”, and it was vital that he “decondition it”. Remember, his “plan” for controlling the virus was this:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk.
Dr. Bhattacharya and other pro-infection doctors wanted hundreds of millions of unvaccinated Americans to “build up immunity to the virus through natural infection”, and they made no secret of it. Convincing politicians to abandon all mitigation measures outside of nursing homes was just half the battle. Dr. Bhattacharya and like-minded doctors also had to create a moral calm and convince the public to embrace “natural infection.” This, they claimed, was the path to achieving herd immunity in 3-6 months. Except for grandma, they said that widespread COVID avoidance would “directly prevent that widespread immunity from developing“, prolonging the pandemic. They needed to create an alternate reality where people believed “for younger populations under 70, it’s much milder,” as Dr. Bhattacharya put it in October 2020, before anyone was vaccinated.
And so, from the pandemic’s first days, pro-infection doctors with large, public platforms waged a concerted psychological campaign to numb people to COVID’s risk. They became defense attorneys for the virus, shielding it from allegations that it was dangerous or something to be avoided. They spoke about it only in the most tranquil, soothing terms:
    • The vast majority of cases are relatively mild, asymptomatic, or with mild symptoms.
    • Most of the population has minimal risk, in the range of dying while you’re driving from home to work and back.
    • The overwhelming majority of people do not have any significant risk of dying from COVID-19.
    • That weakness is the near inability of the virus to kill younger people.
    • The “vast majority” of people “don’t even realize that they have been infected, they are asymptomatic, they have no symptoms, or they have very mild symptoms that they would not even bother to do anything about.
Doctors inundated the public with this message. There are countless more examples.
As the pandemic progressed, doctors called natural immunity a “triumph“, repeatedly claimed it was over, overhyped vaccines as a perfect panacea, and ceaselessly fear mongered about every measure to limit COVID, even purely theoretical harms. They glorified unvaccinated young adults who eschewed precautions as brave warriors whose infections would end the pandemic. As Dr. Martin Kulldorff put it:
As a society we should appreciate young adults who help generate herd immunity by living normal lives and keeping society afloat. Thank you, thank you, thank you. When people throw misguided complaints at you, falsely claiming that you are endangering others, remember that the opposite is true.
In contrast, they portrayed those who sought to remain healthy as pathetic, disordered weaklings, afflicted by irrational panic, fear, and anxiety.
It only makes sense if you remember one thing, they wanted you infected.

Every Time Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Talks About COVID, He Proves He Was Totally Wrong About COVID
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya March 2020: “If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.”
Jonathan Howard on April 7, 2024
Link

If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya peaked really early. The first and perhaps wisest sentence he wrote this pandemic was this:
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
That eminently reasonable sentiment, completely justifying shelter-in-place orders and quarantines for a virus that would cause mass death if left unchecked, comes from his article Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say?, which was published on March 24, 2020.
However, Dr. Bhattacharya penned that robust defense of shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, a much stronger defense of these extraordinary measures than I ever made, to argue against them.
So why was Dr. Bhattacharya, who never treated a COVID patients himself, opposed to shelter-in-place orders and quarantines in March 2020? There can literally be only one reason- he didn’t think that millions were at risk from this “novel coronavirus”. Dr. Bhattacharya asked the question, is the coronavirus as deadly as they say? and answered it with a resounding “no.” Indeed, his article’s subtitle was “Current estimates about the Covid-19 fatality rate may be too high by orders of magnitude.”
Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? Current Estimates About the Covid-19 Fatality Rate May be Too High by Orders of Magnitude
Though Dr. Bhattacharya now claims the words shelter-in-place orders and quarantines don’t mean shelter-in-place orders and quarantines and that those who quote his article are “lying about the article“, I am going to do something that often annoys Dr. Bhattacharya and accurately quote Dr. Bhattacharya. Here’s what he wrote:
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified. But there’s little evidence to confirm that premise—and projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.
Fear of COVID-19 is based on its high estimated case fatality rate — 2% to 4% of people with confirmed. COVID-19 have died, according to the World Health Organization and others. So if 100 million Americans ultimately get the disease, 2 million to 4 million could die. We believe that estimate is deeply flawed…
If our surmise of six million cases is accurate, that’s a mortality rate of 0.01%, assuming a two week lag between infection and death. This is one-tenth of the flu mortality rate of 0.1%. Such a low death rate would be cause for optimism.
Dr. Bhattacharya noted that “a 20,000- or 40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million.”
His article concluded:
If we’re right about the limited scale of the epidemic, then measures focused on older populations and hospitals are sensible… A universal quarantine may not be worth the costs it imposes on the economy, community and individual mental and physical health. We should undertake immediate steps to evaluate the empirical basis of the current lockdowns.
A 20,000- or 40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million…If we’re right about the limited scale of the epidemic…
Dr. Bhattacharya was not wrong when he said that a low death rate, one-tenth of the flu mortality rate of 0.1%, would be “cause for optimism.” He was also not wrong when he said “a 20,000- or 40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million.”
However, COVID turned out to be kind of a big deal.
Even though vaccines arrived in record time, the virus infected nearly all of us, many of us many times. It killed over 1.1 million Americans, and 95,000 Americans died in January 2021 alone. While death was the only bad outcome Dr. Bhattacharya considered, the virus seriously injured millions of people without killing them. While things are much better now, the virus is still hurting people every day. Its grim toll would have been much worse had we let it spread widely in spring 2020, as many doctors proposed at the time.
Four years after predicting the epidemic would have a “limited scale”, Dr. Bhattacharya speaks constantly about COVID and only COVID. He wouldn’t be doing this if he had been right about “the limited scale of the epidemic”. Given the extraordinary magnitude of the epidemic, Dr. Bhattacharya will speak about it constantly for the foreseeable future. Every time he does so, he proves he was totally wrong about its “limited scale”. And given that he was totally wrong about this, then the extraordinary measures- the shelter-in-place orders and quarantines- were surely justified, according to Dr. Bhattacharya.

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: “An Infection Is A Severe Problem For Older Populations, and Also For People Who Have Certain Chronic Conditions. For Younger Populations Under 70, It’s Much Milder.”
A doctor who actually treated COVID patients said at the start of the pandemic, “Just because they are young doesn’t mean they aren’t vulnerable.”
Jonathan Howard on June 14, 2024
Link

For younger populations under 70, it’s much milder.
An article from October 30, 2020 titled Seeking Common Ground in ‘Herd Immunity’ Debate quoted anti-vaccine, misinformation doctor Jay Bhattacharya as saying:
An infection is a severe problem for older populations, and also for people who have certain chronic conditions. For younger populations under 70, it’s much milder.
You can watch him state his case in this video clip from November 2020:
The full video is here.
Just because they are young doesn’t mean they aren’t vulnerable.
Only a doctor who experienced the entire pandemic from his office would have made such an absurd statement, though COVID’s risk to young people, even those without medical conditions, was widely-publicized since the pandemic’s first days. Most famously, the heroic Chinese doctor who warned the world of COVID, Dr. Li Wenliang, died from it at age 34. As early as April 8th 2020, the Washington Post published an article titled Hundreds of Young Americans Have Now Been Killed by the Coronavirus, Data Shows. It began by saying:
Two weeks after her husband died alone in an intensive care unit in Fort Myers, Fla., Nicole Buchanan is quarantined at the home they shared with their 12-year-old daughter, wrestling not only with grief but also with why and how the coronavirus could steal someone so young and healthy.
“My husband didn’t have diabetes, he didn’t have asthma, he didn’t have high cholesterol. He didn’t have anything,” Buchanan said. “There’s just so much I’ll never know, that I’ll never get the answers to.”
Conrad Buchanan, who died at 39 on March 26 after battling the infection for nearly two weeks, was creative and goofy. A professional DJ, he could entertain huge crowds with his music. But at home, he was fond of singing Bob Marley’s “Three Little Birds” to his daughter, Skye. “He had an amazing sense of humor. He had a big laugh. He was so magnetic,” his 37-year-old widow said. “He was our universe.”
This article quoted a doctor who actually treated COVID patients as saying:
Just because they are young doesn’t mean they aren’t vulnerable.
Articles like this appeared regularly throughout the pandemic’s first year. An article titled Young and Middle-Aged People, Barely Sick With Covid-19, Are Dying of Strokes was also published in April 2020. An article from May 2020 titled 5-Year-Old Dies in New York City of Rare Illness Linked to Virus showed the virus could seriously hurt some young children too. Another article titled Dying Young: The Health Care Workers in Their 20s Killed by COVID-19 was published in August 2020. An article from November 2020 titled The Young Die As Well From COVID-19, Even As Many Engage In Denial quoted Dr. Nina Shapiro who said:
Those who are in terrific shape, are young and have no prior illness can, indeed, become critically illfrom COVID. Many have died and many will die.
By January 2021, the headlines read COVID-19 Has Killed Thousands Of Young Americans. This Is Not Just A Tragedy For The Elderly. COVID’s severe impact on some young people people was hardly some secret, and it’s important to remember there were real lives behind these dry statistics.
School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease.
Though when the virus was just a few months old, the proposition that COVID was benign for young people and that infecting them would lead to herd immunity was first formulated in March 2020 when Dr. John Ioannidis wrote:
School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease.
Foreshadowing Dr. Bhattacharya, Dr. Ioannidis said in an interview from April 2020 that the virus was benign for healthy people under age 65. He said:
For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk is completely negligible…it seems that these deaths are extremely exceptional, very unlikely.
You can watch him state his case in this video clip:
The full video is here.
The myth that COVID only threatened the elderly and infirm became the pandemic’s unquestionable central dogma for pro-infection doctors, and literally nothing the virus did could alter it- not Delta, not Omicron, nothing. I’ve never heard one of them say “Looking back, I underestimated COVID’s impact on people younger than age 70 and overestimated the value of natural immunity.” In fact, not only have these doctors never recognized that COVID could hurt some young people, many of them berated those of us who did nothing more than acknowledge this obvious truth. We were derided as “idiots” or scolded for supposedly behaving unprofessionally.
Throughout the pandemic, laptop class doctors who were sheltered from the consequences of their words, acted as if the virus was totally harmless for young people only because it was generally much worse for older people. For example, in their article, The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young from June 2021, Dr. Bhattacharya, along with Dr. Martin Kulldorff, wrote:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health. The COVID-19 vaccines have been one of the few bright spots during this pandemic. While anyone can get infected, the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young.
This is like saying sober drivers don’t need seat belts, because it’s more dangerous to drive drunk. Yet, this absurd “logic” shaped policy when it came to COVID, as did blatant falsehoods spread by doctors. For example, during the same interview posted above, Dr. Bhattacharya claimed more children had died of flu than COVID. In reality, the AAP reported 133 pediatric COVID fatalities by November 2020. There was a single pediatric flu death that flu season.
Dr. Bhattacharya claims that 1 is larger than 133
Though thousands of young people had already died of COVID by June 2021, when Drs. Bhattacharya and Kulldorff published their anti-vaccine article, the worst was yet to come. Worse variants arrived immediately after it was published, and COVID became a leading killer of young people in the second half of 2021. In fact, COVID was the number 1 or 2 killer of young adults age 35-44 for six months in a row, from August 2021 to January 2022. It was the number 2 killer of adults age 25-34 for 5 out of 6 months during that time, and a top 10 killer for people younger than this. In total, around 45,000 people age 44 or younger, many of them unvaccinated, have now died of COVID in the US.
COVID was the number 1 cause of death for people 45-54 in 2021, and it was worse still for people age 55-70. It was hardly shocking news when a 60-year-old died of COVID, even if they were healthy. Though pro-infection doctors never considered adverse outcomes other than death, countless more people under 70 survived COVID, but were seriously hurt by it. There would have been many more such tragedies had 200 million unvaccinated Americans under age 70 simultaneously contracted COVID in October 2020 as Drs. Bhattacharya and Kulldorff proposed.
“For younger populations under 70, it’s much milder.“
Source for this data
For younger populations under 70, it’s much milder?
Despite all that’s happened, I’ve never heard Dr. Bhattacharya revisit his sentiment from the fall of 2020. He seems to have forgotten it entirely, and his sycophantic interviewers are never brave enough remind him of it. However, I’d like to see him make the case today that he was right back then when he said “For younger populations under 70, it’s much milder“, and that this was a responsible message to convey to the public right before before vaccines arrived. If history is any guide, instead of having the integrity to defend his own words, Dr. Bhattacharya will only feel victimized when people quote Dr. Bhattacharya.

A “Biosafety” Organization Partnering With Dr. Jay Bhattacharya To Guard Against Viruses Is Like A Zebra Teaming Up With A Lion To Promote Vegetarianism
Biosafety Now is fine working with a pro-virus, misinformation doctor to prevent a potential pandemic. What about a doctor who worked with patients and countered misinformation during an actual pandemic?
Jonathan Howard on September 27, 2024
Link
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk.
In a previous article, I discussed scientists who believe that allegedly leaking SARS-CoV-2 from a lab was one of the greatest crimes in human history, but that purposefully spreading it was merely a forgivable oopsie. Specifically, I discussed the partnership between Biosafety Now, an organization that purports to be dedicated to preventing a potential pandemic, and Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, an anti-vaccine doctor who partnered with a pro-tobacco, child-labor advocate to deliberately spread SARS-CoV-2 during an actual pandemic. A “biosafety” organization partnering with Dr. Bhattacharya to guard against viruses is like a zebra teaming up with a lion to promote vegetarianism.
Dr. Bhattacharya, a member of the Board of Directors at Biosafety Now, identified two core problems with SARS-CoV-2:
     1.  It likely came from a lab
     2.  Not enough unvaccinated people contracted it
This makes no sense.
Dr. Bhattacharya cared about the origins of the virus, but not about its consequences, which he relentlessly minimized. In 2020, Dr. Bhattacharya claimed that immunity to COVID was durable and that the mass infection of unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” people would end the pandemic in 3-6 months. He wrote:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk.
Dr. Bhattacharya continued to encourage “natural infection” in this group even after vaccines were available and immune-evading variants arrived. Despite the tragic consequences of such anti-vaccine misinformation, some people are actively trying to make us forget all about it.
We should resist them.
Bhattacharya, Gupta, and Kulldorff are not merely wrong. They are charlatans and quacks who are dispensing deadly advice, and who need to be held accountable for their role in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
Dr. Richard Ebright, a molecular biologist at Rutgers University and founder of Biosafety Now, had strong feelings when Dr. Bhattacharya announced his plan to get rid of the virus by spreading the virus in 2020. Dr. Ebright said at the time:
Bhattacharya, Gupta, and Kulldorff are not merely wrong. They are charlatans and quacks who are dispensing deadly advice, and who need to be held accountable for their role in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths.
I’ve never said anything that harsh.
In our brief conversation about why he jettisoned his values to legitimatize and amplify a quack he blamed for hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths, Dr. Ebright told me:
My views on the @gbdeclaration have not changed, but my views on Bhattacharya have changed. His advice was wrong. Dead wrong. But it now is 2024 (not 2020), and the discussion at hand is how to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic (not how to respond to the last one).
Once Dr. Bhattacharya passed Dr. Ebright’s one essential test- he said SARS-CoV-2 leaked from a lab– literally everything else about him became irrelevant, including the fact that he was “dead wrong”. Obviously, Dr. Bhattacharya’s conjecture regarding the origins of SARS-CoV-2 doesn’t mean that he now has meaningful insights into how to actually make virology research safer. After all, he’s a health economist who didn’t really do anything during the pandemic, aside from spreading misinformation to promote his failed “plan” of herd immunity through mass infection on YouTube and Fox News. Apparently, this skill set is so unique and valuable in the field of biosafety, that no one should care that Dr. Bhattacharya tried to spread a deadly virus during an actual pandemic.
Although actually promoting biosafety requires cooperation from multiple stakeholders, Dr. Bhattacharya won’t bring people together to work for this common goal. He was intentionally divisive, insulting people who needed bodyguards. In addition to repelling the very people needed to promote biosafety, Dr. Bhattacharya does not enhance the credibility of Biosafety Now, nor does his presence inspire confidence in the judgement and sincerity of its leadership. From the start of the pandemic, Dr. Bhattacharya was very confident about this new virus- it was no big deal and it was all going away. Yet, every prediction he made turned out wrong. To pick one example amongst many, he said in March 2021:
The virus is seasonal and late fall/winter is its season. It is very unlikely, given that this is the case, that the virus will spread very widely during the summer months.
Six months later, the headlines from Florida, where Dr. Bhattacharya advised the governor on COVID, read In Florida, a Summer of Death and Resistance as the Coronavirus Rampaged.
Dr. Ebright no longer cares about any of this and he doesn’t think anyone else should either. I still care, however, and given that Dr. Bhattacharya was always wrong about the consequences of COVID, why should anyone trust him to be an honest broker about the origins of COVID? Why should anyone trust a biosafety organization that is totally indifferent to his failed forecasts and the real-world harm they caused, during an actual pandemic?
But it now is 2024 (not 2020), and the discussion at hand is how to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic (not how to respond to the last one).
Dr. Bhattacharya refuses to revisit his poor predictions and ensconces himself in a safe space to avoid anyone bold enough to remind him. He wants his misinformation to be deleted from history, and the folks from Biosafety Now are happy to encourage amnesia on his behalf. That’s what Dr. Ebright was trying to do when he said:
It now is 2024 (not 2020), and the discussion at hand is how to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic (not how to respond to the last one).
It may not seem this way, but there’s a lot to unpack there, especially considering that Dr. Ebright’s demand is part of larger movement where We Want Them Infected (WWTI) doctors seek to memory-hole SARS-CoV-2 and its victims.
In Dr. Ebright’s telling, 2020 is ancient history and as relevant to today as 1520. Dr. Ebright implied that while it’s vital to care about the first COVID infection, we should be indifferent to the billions of infections after that. He feel it’s inappropriate to remember the “charlatans and quacks” who spread “deadly advice,” even though the cost was “hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths“, as Dr. Ebright put it in October 2020.
In dismissing COVID as yesterday’s news, Dr. Ebright is saying that headlines such as Florida Delta Wave Cases Plunge, Leaving Record Deaths in Its Wake, no longer matter. Why would he do this? Because if that headline still matters, then Dr. Bhattacharya’s COVID misinformation still matters, and Biosafety Now would be an organization that promotes dangerous “charlatans and quacks”. Of course, that headline still matters, Dr. Bhattacharya’s COVID misinformation still matters, and Biosafety Now is absolutely an organization that promotes dangerous “charlatans and quacks”.
Moreover, Dr. Bhattacharya didn’t abruptly stop spreading misinformation in 2020 as Dr. Ebright implied. Dr. Bhattacharya spread misinformation about COVID in 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024. Pick a random article of his and he will say some version of “the pandemic is on its way out.” He started saying this in March 2020 and never stopped. Conversely, he never encouraged young people to take any precautions against COVID, not even an effective vaccine. Dr. Bhattacharya’s past COVID misinformation was not a deal-breaker for Dr. Ebright, and Dr. Bhattacharya’s current COVID misinformation isn’t a deal-breaker either. According to the folks at Biosafety Now, nothing Dr. Bhattacharya said or ever will say about an actual pandemic should matter at all.
Incredibly, Dr. Ebright makes these demands for the sake of protecting us against deadly viruses. Although COVID is still killing and injuring people every day, Dr. Ebright claims that to prevent the next pandemic, we are all required to forget the last pandemic. Dr. Ebright believes that anyone who still cares about COVID is impairing his work, somehow. Dr. Ebright claims the vital task of biosafety requires that Dr. Bhattacharya be shielded from criticism for his efforts to spread a virus during an actual pandemic.
Dr. Ebright is not alone in his demands for amnesia. WWTI doctors now claim every reaction to COVID was an overreaction and that mitigation measures were an avoidable choice. It’s only possible to believe such absurdities if one entirely deletes from memory what the virus could do when it was allowed to spread unchecked. There’s a reason why WWTI doctors never share headlines such as An Insane Situation’: Inside the Chaos at Bellevue Hospital or School Closures Reported in Five FL Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ in COVID. Like Dr. Ebright, WWTI doctors want the virus and its consequences forgotten entirely. At times, this requires them to totally deny that the plan for herd immunity via natural immunity even existed, even though they wrote it down, Tweeted it out, and spoke about it often on camera. I discussed this blatant negation of obvious reality in two prior articles (here and here), and you can watch an example here.
Notably, Dr. Ebright did not demand that Dr. Bhattacharya stop talking about “the last one”. It’s perfectly fine for him to drone on and on about lockdowns, even though they ended long ago, while the virus is still circulating widely. There’s an obvious reason why Dr. Ebright demands amnesia about Biosaftey Now members, but not from Biosafety Now members.
These images are 6 weeks apart. Read the article here.
Jay Speaks At RFK Jr.’s Vice President Announcement Rally
If indeed amnesia is a virtue and memory is a sin, then my soul is in trouble. I think that this largely explains Dr. Ebright’s infantile emotional outbursts towards myself and other doctors, like Dr. David Gorksi, who also refuse to forget. I mean really, what sin did I commit? Here’s what I’ve done since 2020:
    • Worked in a hospital and didn’t forget it
    • Volunteered for a vaccine-RCT
    • Published research on COVID
    • Exposed charlatans and quacks who dispensed deadly advice
Dr. Ebright must resent me for one of those things. Although Dr. Ebright feels that celebrity doctors who intentionally spread a virus should be forgiven and resurrected, he feels that doctors who experienced and can’t forget the consequences of an actual pandemic deserve only childish schoolyard taunts. Dr. Ebright, who never treated COVID patients, is done with 2020, and he feels that people who witnessed mass death that year should just get over it already.
Prof @Kevin_Fong giving the most devastating and moving testimony to the Covid Inquiry of visiting hospital intensive care units at the height of the second wave in late Dec 2020. The unimaginable scale of death, the trauma, the loss of hope. Please watch this 2min clip. pic.twitter.com/bt1MLkj9je
— Prof. Christina Pagel (@chrischirp) September 26, 2024
I can be snarky, and I don’t pull my punches. However much of my writing is simply a collection of quotes from WWTI doctors. I’ll provide several videos of Dr. Bhattacharya at the end of this article so all of us, especially everyone at Biosafety Now, can remember exactly what he said. I think it’s important and powerful to just let these doctors’ words speak for themselves. Who could anyone object to that?
Dr. Ebright objects to that. He believes that these videos should be entirely forgotten and that only people who are unable to read or reason still care about COVID. He has generously given Dr. Bhattacharya a “do-over” button and furiously demands that others honor his gift. Dr. Ebright unilaterally declared, “the discussion at hand is how to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic (not how to respond to the last one)“, and expects everyone else to just fall in line.
That’s quite a demand, and I reject it. I won’t tell him to stop talking about the lab leak, and he shouldn’t tell me to stop criticizing Dr. Bhattacharya. Even though it earns me scorn and contempt from people who never saw what the virus could do, I believe it’s important to keep an accurate record of doctors who purposefully tried to spread a virus during an actual pandemic. After all, 2020 wasn’t that long ago, COVID hurt a lot of people, and the virus is still here.
Moreover, much of this suffering was preventable. COVID was going to be bad no matter what, but Dr. Ebright was absolutely right that many thousands of people died because “charlatans and quacks” told them vaccines were more dangerous than the virus. Watch the video below to see who told them that. Dr. Ebright feels it’s wrong to remember that real people lost their lives because they listened to the doctor on TV, not the one in the hospital. When Dr. Ebright says “but it now is 2024 (not 2020)“, he’s not just covering for Dr. Bhattacharya, he is purposefully erasing COVID’s victims, past, present, and future.
Fox News is STILL pushing misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines. Dr. Jay Bhattacharya says that young men are at risk of getting myocarditis from the vaccine. This is true but he leaves out they are at MUCH higher risk of getting it from the disease. I provide receipts. pic.twitter.com/CHgSuFnY6g
— Decoding Fox News (@DecodingFoxNews) August 29, 2023
However, if we don’t remember what WWTI doctors said, they certainly won’t remind us. They are now furiously trying to rewrite history and rebrand themselves, absurdly claiming that all they ever wanted was children in school. Today, Dr. Bhattacharya hides that he advocated for herd immunity through mass infection and lobs immature personal attacks against anyone who reminds him pleas for “natural infection”. I am confident he won’t direct his audience to this article so they can hear what he had to say. Dr. Bhattacharya doesn’t really mind it when he’s censored.
Although this pro-infection discourse dominated the early part of the pandemic, today it is totally unmentionable amongst the same WWTI doctors who were responsible for it. Unfortunately, their project of deliberate amnesia is being aided by not just by supposed advocates of biosaftey like Dr. Ebright, but also by venerable newspapers such as the NY Times and venerable institutions such as Stanford and Johns Hopkins. These supposed bastions of truth are all complicit in the Great Forgetting.
While accurately remembering the past is worthwhile in its own right, we also need to learn from our mistakes. Though I often write about the first part of the pandemic, I intend for it to serve as a warning. It would be a huge mistake to censor what WWTI doctors said in 2020 or to consent to Dr. Ebright’s hippocampectomy. When the next virus inevitably arrives, whether from a lab or animal, WWTI doctors will invariably spread misinformation about it and resist efforts to contain it. Don’t take my word for it. Read this interview from last year.
Peter Robinson: All right, a few final questions, Jay. Holman Jenkins in “The Wall Street Journal,” quote: “The world inevitably will face new respiratory viruses. There seems to be no good reason nature would afflict us with a disease that spreads as easily as the flu or COVID and is significantly more deadly, but neither can that be ruled out.” Are we ready for the next pandemic?
Jay Bhattacharya: We’re gonna lock down again with the next pandemic, guaranteed. If the current configuration of power in public health and politics stands, we will respond by saying, “Look, the lockdown’s the only way,” and just as happened in 2020, it’ll be the laptop class that’ll benefit, and the poor and the vulnerable and children who will be harmed.
We should be prepared for this. Laptop class doctors like Dr. Bhattacharya have no problem creating extra patients for other doctors. With dangerous and deluded characters like Robert Kennedy Jr. potentially gaining power, the idea that we should voluntarily erase our COVID memories isn’t just noxious, it’s also foolish and dangerous.
Unfortunately, Mr. Kennedy has more public legitimacy now than ever because prominent professors at Stanford, UCSF, and Johns Hopkins have vouched for him. Claiming to be an apolitical public health expert, Dr. Bhattacharya even spoke at one of his rallies where he received a glowing introduction from Del Bigtree. It’s no surprise that legendary anti-vaxxers are enamored with Dr. Bhattacharya. He speaks their language.
Dr. Ebright and everyone at Biosafety Now is totally fine with all this. Even though Mr. Kennedy is currently promoting the propaganda movie Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill, Dr. Ebright is only upset that anyone would dare criticize Dr. Bhattacharya. It doesn’t bother him at all that a board member of Biosafety Now, whose purpose is to keep us safe from viruses, promotes America’s #1 anti-vaxxer. Dr. Ebright feels this too should be censored and forgotten.
Unlike Dr. Ebright, I would never legitimize a doctor who lauded a prominent anti-vaxxer who already has a body count of dead children. I genuinely care about limiting dangerous viruses, and I am very worried about the future. Not only are vaccine-rates dipping thanks to misinformation spread during COVID, we are much less prepared to handle a pandemic than we were in 2020. Quackery has been normalized in small, but influential parts of American medicine. Read about Dr. Joseph Ladapo if you think I am exaggerating.
Unfortunately, WWTI doctors also have unearned legitimacy because seemingly credible organizations with with catchy names, like Biosafety Now, vouched for them and deluged their critics with juvenile japes. When Dr. Bhattacharya histrionically claims that mitigation measures were an epic catastrophe and that vaccines for young people were a tragic mistake, more people will trust him thanks to Biosafety Now’s stamp of approval. If COVID-25 arrives, there’s no way the public would adhere to mitigation measures as they did in 2020. People have been instructed to forget COVID’s carnage and to trust anti-vaxx liars like Mr. Kennedy. They have been told outright to stop trusting public health, and as a result many people now believe that measures to contain a deadly virus are useless at best and a sign of impending Nazism at worst. By legitimizing Dr. Bhattacharya and his ilk, Biosafety Now is ensuring we are much less prepared to fight a future pandemic, as well as existing virus such as COVID and measles.
An organization that is supposedly dedicated to protecting us from deadly viruses is actually making us much more vulnerable to them. Either they don’t know this or they don’t care.
I will work with any person from any party and any background to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic.
Dr. Ebright also explained his willingness to partner with Dr. Bhattacharya by saying:
I will work with any person from any party and any background to prevent a next lab-generated pandemic. The importance and urgency of the objective over-ride partisan differences and ideological differences (as should be clear to any rational person).
Let’s put that to the test.
Dr. Ebright may be sincere here. It’s hard to imagine how his standards could be lower. To prevent a potential pandemic, he is willing to partner with a doctor, who during an actual pandemic, never saw patients and spread blatant anti-vaccine, pro-virus misinformation.
In contrast, I worked in a hospital and tried to counter the charlatans and quacks who dispensed deadly advice during that actual pandemic. I don’t think anyone from Biosafety Now can say that. So, will Dr. Ebright be willing to work with me? Like him, I want to keep the world safe from dangerous viruses. If Biosafety Now actually shares that goal, I’ll bring them a valuable perspective they currently lack (as should be clear to any rational person).
They’ll just have to tolerate the fact that I reject their demand for amnesia, and I have a strong feeling their dedication to biosafety doesn’t go that far.
Things Dr. Bhattacharya Said
    • There are links to videos, you need to go to the website to get them. 

If Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Saw What I Saw, He’d Realize That Being Called “Fringe” Isn’t So Bad After All
Dying of COVID is worse.
Jonathan Howard on October 4, 2024
Link
Lack of debates/ smearing scientists who disagreed
COVID killed 1.2 million Americans and injured millions more. It’s not over yet. It was going to be bad no matter what, but according one study estimated:
That at least 232,000 deaths could have been prevented among unvaccinated adults during the 15 months had they been vaccinated with at least a primary series.
None of this bothered pro-infection doctors. In his article Pubic Health Should Lose Your Trust, Dr. Vinay Prasad excoriated public health officials not because they failed to blunt COVID’s impact, but rather because they tried to hard to do so. He wrote:
Trust is justified based on how an organization or system performs. And the truth is, the entire public health apparatus, failed. In addition to that, leaders at FDA and NIH and CDC engaged in lies and propaganda. As such, they should lose your trust, and without serious reforms you should not return the trust of these organizations.
Those are harsh words. Dr. Prasad listed several reasons why not to trust public heath and none of them had to do with those 1.2 million deaths. His reasons were: natural immunity counts for nothing, masking efficacy, vaccine-myocarditis, Paxlovid, and one size fits all booster recs. All of these measures were intended to limit COVID’s damage, and whatever their flaws, none of them are as bad as dying of COVID. Yet these are the only things that concerned Dr. Prasad.
Lack of debates/ smearing scientists who disagreed
Indeed, Dr. Prasad’s top reason not to trust public health was this:
Lack of debates/ smearing scientists who disagreed
We were making unprecedented massive decisions and we had ~zero debates. Worse, any dissent was punished. Francis Collins, NIH director, famously emailed Anthony Fauci calling for a “quick and devastating” take down of the “fringe” epidemiologists who opposed lockdowns. This was unfortunate, but par for the course. During the pandemic major universities held ~0 debates on lockdowns, prolonged school closure, masking toddlers, visitor restrictions, and perpetual hospital masking.
It’s one thing to act in times of uncertainty. It is another thing to stifle dissent and dialog. In many ways talking with the “fringe” epidemiologists could have helped us. We might have reached a compromise, with schools opening sooner than they otherwise would.
Elsewhere, Dr. Prasad, who extolled the virtues of civil debate at the start of the pandemic, was even more emotional, calling Dr. Collins the “dumbest general on the planet.” He said:
You were the NIH Director. You could have had a series of Town Halls where you invited people like Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff and had an open discussion of the pros and cons. You could have put them on YouTube. You have the powers of the federal government. You held zero debates. You just went on TV and you said proclamation after proclamation…You never tried to minimize uncertainty. You never brought anyone to the table who might disagree with you. If you were a general in war, you would be the dumbest general on the planet. Because even a general in war wants someone at the table who says, ‘Hey, you think maybe we shouldn’t invade someone?..Let’s hear that argument.’
There needs to be a quick and devastating take down of its premises.
The incident that so enraged Dr. Prasad was an email written in October 2020 by Dr. Francis Collins, the director of the NIH, to three other people. Dr. Collins was reacting to the publication of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). In an email he intended for three people to see, he said:
As a reminder, the GBD advocated for the mass infection of unvaccinated youth, claiming this would end the pandemic in 3-6 months. I wrote recently about how pro-infection doctors are actively trying to make us forget this. For example, in Dr. Prasad’s telling, the authors of the GBD were only interested in “lockdowns, prolonged school closure, masking toddlers, visitor restrictions, and perpetual hospital masking.” He purposefully neglected to mention their affinity in 2020 for “natural infection.”
If I got together with a couple of my buddies and wrote a 1-page Declaration, I would not feel this action alone entitled me to an audience with our nation’s public health leaders to have them enact my policies. However, Dr. Prasad believes that our nation’s pubic health leaders were obligated to meet with and “compromise” with advocates of herd immunity through mass infection. After all, they wrote a Declaration under the watchful eye of a a pro-tobacco, child-labor advocate. Dr. Prasad feels that alone means the Declaration’s calls for “natural infection” had to be taken seriously and acted upon. He was upset that the authors of the GBD were called fringe.
Although Dr. Prasad accused Dr. Collins of calling for a “quick and devastating” take down of the “fringe” epidemiologists, this is not true. Rather Dr. Collins called for a “quick and devastating” take down of their premises. He disagreed with their ideas. He felt their approach to the pandemic was wrong and he thought a strongly-worded written rebuttal of these premises might be of value. That’s totally appropriate. Scientists strongly disagree with each other’s premises in writing all the time. There’s nothing wrong with that. The premises of the GBD are not sacrosanct and above criticism as Dr. Prasad implied. It’s not clear anything came of Dr. Collins’ email, but he was right- a written refutation of the premises of the GBD would have been useful.
Although Dr. Prasad said “we had ~ 0 debates” about pandemic policy, in reality you can listen to the following debates with authors of the GBD:
    • Herd Immunity as a Coronavirus Pandemic Strategy
    • Seeking Common Ground in ‘Herd Immunity’ Debate
    • Be It Resolved, COVID-19 Is Everywhere, It’s Time To Lift All Restrictions For Good. Guests Jay Bhattacharya And Jeremy Faust Debate
    • Social Media Censorship: Jay Bhattacharya vs. Kate Klonick,
    • Were COVID Lockdowns a Deadly Mistake? Jay Bhattacharya vs. Sten Vermund.
    • COVID Debate: Martin Kulldorff and Eric Topol
While other doctors were treating COVID patients, the authors of the GBD did little but debate. Of course, such debates are more about spectacle than finding scientific truth. The “winner” is usually the best performer. Yet, Dr. Prasad claims that if only Dr. Collins had arranged a debate with the authors of the GBD, a show for public entertainment, then millions of unvaccinated people would have been suddenly willing to embrace COVID infections in October 2020. Some of them might have. The authors of the GBD falsely claimed at the time that COVID wasn’t a threat to people under 65 or 70 years-old. COVID would become a leader killer of this age group immediately after that.
Contrary to Dr. Prasad’s telling, there was a great discussion and debate about the GBD that started in October 2020 and it’s never stopped. Though they now pretend they never said such things, pro-infection doctors claimed at that time that the best way to get rid of the virus was to spread the virus. This didn’t turn out very well.
In contrast, the devastating take-downs of the GBD from 2020 aged very well. It’s flaws were obvious. Critics of the GBD right knew infections in the young would invariably spread to the old, and that COVID wasn’t always mild for people under 70, as the authors of the GBD claimed. All of the criticism of the GBD from 2020 were spot on. Read the articles 5 Failings of the Great Barrington Declaration, The Great Barrington Declaration is an Ethical Nightmare, and The Great Barrington Declaration is Dangerous to see for yourself.
The article Focused Protection, Herd Immunity, and Other Deadly Delusions written in October 2020 by Gregg Gonsalves said:
And that vaunted herd immunity? Even in Sweden, the proportion of the population exposed to the virus has been relatively low. Swiss epidemiologist Christian Althaus put it succinctly in an interview last month when he said the idea that Sweden would reach herd immunity was “always sort of ridiculous.… This idea that, basically 50 percent, 60 percent, 70 percent of people get infected and then the problem is solved, that was never really based on scientific foundation…. It’s very unlikely that something like that can be achieved, and even if it could be achieved, it would come—at least in countries with a population demography like European countries or the US—with a huge cost.”
Again, this aged well. The premises of the pro-infection movement should have been rebutted more often in 2020. Fringe was a extremely benign description of their idea for herd immunity through mass infection.
Of course, the authors of the GBD were pandemic celebrities, despite never treating patients with COVID. They met with former President Trump and HHS Secretary Alex Azar. Dr. Scott Atlas admitted he brought their policies to the White House, and Trump gave them credit as well. They advised Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, and were celebrated by Elon Musk. The authors of the GBD were loud, famous, and influential. Their views were no secret.
Yet, Dr. Prasad describes their fate by saying “any dissent was punished.” Dr. Prasad feels that the authors of the GBD didn’t get enough attention, and he considers this one of the worst events of the pandemic. Dr. Prasad expects us to fell sorry for the author GBD. They were wronged.
At a Time When the U.S. Needed Covid-19 Dialogue Between Scientists, Francis Collins Moved to Shut it Down.
Yet, Dr. Collins’ simple request for a “quick and devastating” take down of the premises of the GBD became a highly significant moment of the pandemic for pro-infection doctors. Dr. Bhattacharya recorded a long video because he was called fringe in an e-mail, and talked about it endlessly on social media. He even posed with a t-shirt about it. Watch the video below to how seriously he discusses being called fringe in an email that was wouldn’t have come to light but for his own efforts to publicize it widely. He even mentioned it in his testimony before Congress.
Being called fringe was the touchstone moment of the pandemic for him, the same way watching a 23-year-old die of COVID in April 2020 was something I’ll never forget. Dr. Bhattacharya, who is is alive and well fortunately, feels that he’s been treated very unfairly and that we should feel very sorry for him. He centers his feelings, and wants others to be angry on his behalf. After all, if he can be called fringe in an email, the anyone could be called fringe in any email.
Now watch the video below to see the casual way Dr. Bhattacharya discussed teachers dying of COVID. These videos make quite the pairing, don’t they? Being called fringe was serious. Dying of COVID was not, just 1 in 500 teachers! I encourage you to read the article Over 1,000 Educators Died From COVID. Here’s the Story of One to get a sense of someone who suffered a fate worse than being called fringe. Unfortunately, the notion that indecorous statements against COVID minimizers were more consequential than death from COVID was not uncommon this pandemic, something I discussed in my article Might “Vitriolic Attacks” Against Emily Oster Rival COVID’s Carnage?
Certainly Dr. Prasad also showed much more concern over the word “fringe” than any of COVID’s young victims, whose deaths he causally dismissed.
Stanford University To Welcome Vaccine Skepticism, Epoch Times At Upcoming Health Policy Conference
This hypersensitivity of sheltered laptop class doctors like Dr. Bhattacharya may be comical, but it is not benign. First, it served as a distraction technique. Every moment discussing the word “fringe” is a moment not spent discussing the tragic real-world consequences of the GBD’s pro-infection policies.
Second, it sent a clear message to potential critics of pro-infection doctors.
Be very careful. If you’re not courteous and circumspect at every moment, even in emails, we’ll accused you of stifling “dissent and dialog.” If you slip and call someone “fringe”, that will be treated as public health failing #1.
Indeed, Dr. Prasad said that indecorous critics of the GBD were censors. He had previously written a long article about the “fringe” incident titled At a Time When the U.S. Needed Covid-19 Dialogue Between Scientists, Francis Collins Moved to Shut it Down. This is how Dr. Prasad described an email that called for a strongly-worded refutation of the premises of the GBD. That is a DARVO, and it shuts down dialogue between scientists.
Notably, Drs. Prasad and Bhattacharya do not extend to others the courtesy they demand from others. Dr. Prasad routinely called people “idiots” “STUPID“, a “bunch of fools” and “total morons“ when he disagreed with him. This juvenile banter was normal and commonplace for him. Dr. Bhattacharya meanwhile, wrote a long, fake “review” of my book, only to later admit he didn’t read it. He called Dr. Fauci silly names like America’s #1 anti-vaxxer. These doctors never engaged with their critics in good faith. They won’t invite their critics to speak at one of their conferences, even as they castigate Dr. Collins for not meeting with them. They feel they were owed meetings, but they don’t feel they owe anything to anyone. T
Their upcoming conference at Stanford features only doctors who felt too much was done to limit natural infection. It also features cranks like Jan Jekielek, a senior editor at The Epoch Times, and Alex Berenson, who is known as “pandemic’s wrongest man”. If I were to speak, I’d do nothing but play videos of these doctors from 2020 and 2021. Yet, that would never be allowed. So much for “discussion and debate.” Talk about stifling dissent and dialogue.
Doctors said many meany-pants things about me during the pandemic. Dr. Bhattacharya launched a volley of childish insults against me- “inane… unhinged”, “objectively anti vax, and “a man broken by an extended encounter between deeply held (but false) ideas about the way the world works and the way the world actually works“. Guess what! His slurs aren’t nearly as bad as dying of COVID.
COVID killed 1.2 million Americans and injured millions more. When I write about what went wrong this pandemic, I always focus on that. Others care about their feelings and the word “fringe.”

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya Was Nice to Someone During a Debate. That Doesn’t Erase the Consequences of His Misinformation.
This is what it looks like when doctors treat the pandemic as an intellectual parlor game.
Jonathan Howard on January 17, 2025
Link
Jay Bhattacharya Will Bring Transparency to NIH
Dr. Andrew Noymer is an epidemiologist and population health scientist who recognized COVID’s threat much earlier than most people and favored strong measures to contain it. However, Dr. Noymer believes that SARS-CoV-2 leaked from a lab and is a member of Biosafety Now. I previously discussed how members of this organization care deeply about infection #1, but are utterly indifferent to how the virus was handled after that.
Indeed, Biosafety Now has partnered with celebrity doctors such as Marty Makary and Jay Bhattacharya who have zero expertise in biosaftey, but instead spread copious COVID misinformation and advocated for herd immunity via mass infection. In the viewpoint of Biosafety Now, releasing the virus was a punishable crime, but misleading people about it and purposefully trying to infect people with it, even after vaccines were available, was a forgivable oopsie.
To justify this absurdity, Biosafety Now members demand amnesia and apathy about everything except that first infection, and they are full of insults and vitriol towards anyone who remembers and still cares. Dr. Noymer recently penned an article that reveals how this deliberate forgetfulness ensures we are less prepared to handle a future pandemic as well as existing viruses.
Dr. Noymer’s article was titled Jay Bhattacharya Will Bring Much-Needed Transparency to NIH, and this alone was problematic. Dr. Bhattacharya wasn’t transparent that the Great Barrington Declaration (GDB) was sponsored by a proud child labor advocate, for example. Furthermore, rather than admit his early pandemic pronouncements were erroneous, he’s tried to obscure them by claiming words have no meaning and that all he ever cared about was poor children. Dr. Bhattacharya was opaque and untrustworthy throughout the pandemic, and there’s no reason to think that will change once he gets to the NIH.
To his credit, Dr. Noymer recognized COVID’s toll. He correctly said:
The stakes could not be higher: COVID killed 15 million people worldwide in 2020 and hasn’t stopped killing, although thankfully at a lower rate more recently.
It’s true that hundreds of Americans are still dying of COVID every week. It’s also true that, except for those over 70, Dr. Bhattacharya relentlessly sought to numb people to this outcome, as well as to COVID’s non-fatal harms. Dr. Bhattacharya underestimated and minimized COVID starting in March 2020 and he never stopped. Dr. Noymer did not tell this to his readers.
Dr. Noymer also noted that he opposed Dr. Bhattacharya’s approach to COVID. He wrote:
Jay supported the Great Barrington Declaration, while I favored a more active and engaged public health response, broadly although not completely along the lines of what was actually done in the United States. At times our differences were fundamental, other times pragmatic. Nonetheless, the differences of opinion between Jay and me on this subject were deep.
That sugarcoats things. Dr. Bhattacharya didn’t just “support” the GBD. He wrote it. In it, he claimed that the mass infection of unvaccinated people under 60 would end in the pandemic in 3-6 months, and he pushed policies that furthered this goal leading to needless suffering. That’s not a hard sentiment to communicate, but beyond linking to the GBD, Dr. Noymer chose not to inform his readers of this either.
It’s notable that while I deluge with readers with videos and quotes of Dr. Bhattacharya, his defenders universally suppress what he said. Unlike them, I believe his words and policies, as well as their real-world consequences, should be amplified and remembered, not silenced and forgotten. This is especially the case considering he will likely soon yield great power. The images below are 6-weeks apart, and though there are countless more examples, this alone should make reasonable people wonder if Dr. Bhattacharya is really the person we want in charge should a new pandemic occur.
Read this article
Jay invited me to this conference
Dr. Noymer didn’t care about any of this. He was willing to overlook Dr. Bhattacharya’s misinformation and pro-infection agenda for two reasons. First, Dr. Bhattacharya endorsed the lab leak hypothesis. Dr. Noymer wrote:
The most important outstanding item on the COVID agenda is: Where did SARS-CoV-2 – the virus that causes COVID – come from?
In reality, the most important outstanding item on the COVID agenda is how we could have better protected people from it. Nothing about its origin impacts this. Whether it came from a lab or an animal wouldn’t affect a single word I’ve written about it or a single patient I saw with it, and normal people don’t want a new virus to emerge from either source.
However, nothing else mattered to Dr. Noymer. Because he agrees with Dr. Bhattacharya about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and wants to block vaccine-researchers like Dr. Peter Hotez from receiving NIH funding, he was willing to discard Dr. Bhattachayra’s entire pandemic record. Dr. Noymer thinks everyone else should join him in this intentional amnesia, and he was full of vulgar contempt for those of us who refused or can’t forget our COVID experience.
Dr. Bhattacharya’s second qualification to run the NIH was that he was nice to Dr. Noymer during a couple of debates. Dr. Noymer wrote:
I debated Jay over Zoom on the topic of pandemic response, so I am well aware of his views on COVID response, as he is of mine. Our debate was not archived but was roughly similar to the Munk Debate I did with Jay’s Stanford colleague, John Ioannidis, and the SoHo Forum debate I did with Jay’s Great Barrington collaborator, Martin Kulldorff. These discussions are dated now, but they still reflect deep intellectual rifts that were brought into sharp relief by COVID and the collective response to it.
What makes my endorsement of Jay all the more peculiar is that he and I still disagree on COVID response. I know because I had the chance to talk with Jay and others in October at a conference that he organized at Stanford, at which I served as a panelist. What’s more, Jay invited me to this conference knowing that his and my opinions on this subject continue to diverge. Here and in other examples, I have seen Jay’s commitment to hearing diverse and disagreeing viewpoints. Jay is not one to try to muzzle a dissenting opinion.
It’s dandy that these doctors, none of whom treated COVID patients, had friendly debates as the virus overwhelmed our morgues and hospitals. But why does that mean everyone else is obligated to memory hole the many times Dr. Bhattacharya declared the pandemic over? Why should we ignore his minimization of variants, fake statistics, or anti-vaccine misinformation? Is Dr. Bhattacharya’s pairing with Del Bigtree and ringing endorsement of RFK Jr. suddenly no big deal? Should the victims of misinformation be casually brushed aside because Dr. Bhattacharya was friendly to Dr. Andrew Noymer? Were these debates the highest value, more important than the causalities of the virus being debated?
I don’t think so. I previously discussed how these “debates” were mostly empty theater that deliberately obscured and legitimized misinformation by portraying it as a proper topic of disagreement. I also discussed that doctors who prioritized these performances above all else treated the pandemic as if it was just a parlor game, oblivious to the fact that their “deep intellectual rifts” were reflected in our sick, suffering patients.
While resisting pandemic amnesia is important it its own right, this isn’t just about the past. A new pandemic is possible. Incredibly, Dr. Noymer, who recognized that Dr. Bhattacharya’s approach to an actual pandemic was flawed and dangerous, nonetheless wants him in charge if there’s a future pandemic simply because he is “not one to try to muzzle a dissenting opinion.” What does Dr. Noymer imagine Dr. Bhattacharya would do during another pandemic? Does he think Dr. Bhattacharya would try to contain it or accurately inform the public about it? The answers are both obvious and deeply concerning to those of us who work in hospitals.
In contrast, Dr. Noymer didn’t even consider these questions. Apparently, the prospect of more self-congratulatory conferences, full of civil debate and polite discussion, is so enticing that he is eager to hand enormous power to someone he already knows will grossly mismanage a pandemic. As the bodies pile up, we can all look forward to more verbal jousting matches.
Covidian doctors
Meanwhile, outside of staged debates, I’ve yet to see Dr. Bhattacharya engage with “dissenting opinion” in a mature, thoughtful way. Instead of responding to substantive critiques, he tries to distract from them by claiming to be a victim and asking people to feel sorry for him. He reflexively calls all criticism “slander“, a “smear campaign” and “hit piece“. He hurls schoolyard taunts at his critics, deliberately misrepresents their points, and rather than stand up for his own words, he actively denies them. Articles such as For Bhattacharya, Free Speech Means Freedom To Defund Dissenters and  President Levin’s First Order of Business: Abandoning Academic Freedom make interesting points about Dr. Bhattacharya’s commitment to free and open debate.
This juvenile, spiteful tweet is just one example amongst many- read this from PAI– of how Dr. Bhattacharya behaves towards doctors who treat patients. Image the outrage it would generate if I tweeted something like that about Dr. Bhattacharya. By using such immature slurs and childish images, he is trying to drive a wedge between us and our patients, telling them that we are untrustworthy and that we, not the virus, are to blame for everything they didn’t like about the pandemic. Dr. Noymer doesn’t care about this either and instead depicted Dr. Bhattacharya as a scholarly gentleman who can “restore public trust.”
“I have seen Jay’s commitment to hearing diverse and disagreeing viewpoints.”
Dr. Bhattacharya believes SARS-CoV-2 came from a lab, and he was pleasant to Dr. Noymer during a debate. This does not obviate his atrocious pandemic record or mean he is qualified to lead the NIH. Pretending otherwise is just another form of pandemic revisionism, erasing doctors’ misinformation and erasing the consequences that misinformation- real people.
As serious threats loom and anti-vaccine cranks prepare to take over, amnesia and apathy about these tragedies are not virtues, and I am fully prepared to politely debate that with anyone.
    • 

The COVID Amnesia Project III:  The Plot to Erase Who Ordered Lockdowns in 2020
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya is fully of contempt and vitriol for doctors who worked in hospitals, but he literally “loves” lockdowners.
Jonathan Howard on April 23, 2026
Link

“The bigger problem is that lockdowners like Howard (an NYU doctor, I think), think that living your life is an irresponsible act.”
In my first two articles on the COVID Amnesia Project (CAP), I discussed deliberate efforts to erase both the horrific scenes of spring 2020 and the disinformation spread by We Want Them Infected (WWTI) doctors at that time.
With this in mind, let’s review my 2020 output, though there was very little of it. In February 2020 I Tweeted that I was “concerned” about COVID.  “This has the potential to be a worldwide disaster,” I said. Yet, I wrote just one article that year, in December, titled I’m A Neurologist Who Happily Volunteered for the AstraZeneca Vaccine Trials. Here’s What People Are Getting Wrong About the Process. That article described my experience in a vaccine RCT and what I witnessed in NYC hospitals 6 years ago. I wrote:
The hospital intercom was the busiest I’ve ever heard it, with calls for the “airway team” blaring throughout the hospital every five minutes it seemed. I saw patients as young as 23 die alone, with no one by their side.
However, I didn’t start writing about COVID in earnest until May 2021, as the last mitigations were vanishing. That article was about also vaccines. I never once “called for” lockdowns, mandates, or any other mitigation measure, not that it would have mattered had I had done so. For better or worse, I am just a lone doctor, not some powerful mover of world events. Politicians didn’t base their decisions off of my Tweets and blogs.
Despite this, in his fake “review” of WWTI, which he later admitted he never read, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya called me “inane,” “unhinged,” and wrote about my “covidian mindset.” He also wrote the following:
The bigger problem is that lockdowners like Howard (an NYU doctor, I think), think that living your life is an irresponsible act. Sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act. The implication is that unless you comply with his prescription — lockdown with no logical endpoint — you are irresponsible.
Although Dr. Bhattacharya had to let everyone know he was so important he couldn’t even be bothered to look up where I work, he was nonetheless certain I was a “lockdowner” and that my “prescription” was “lockdown with no logical endpoint.”
However, Dr. Bhattacharya’s juvenile insults reveal much more than his dishonest, unprofessional straw man arguments and utter inability to respond to WWTI, which merely documented his words. Such revisionist history is vital to the CAP, which seeks to memory-hole who was in charge in 2020 and the decisions those leaders made at the time.
“President Trump Has Extended His Stay-At-Home Guidelines”
Unlike Dr. Bhattacharya, we are mature, professional adults, and we can honestly remember who had power 6 years ago. It turns out, Donald Trump was president when the pandemic started, and the country locked down while he ran the show. The article President Trump Has Extended His Stay-At-Home Guidelines quoted him as saying:
The peak, the highest point of death rate, is likely to hit in two weeks. Nothing would be worse than declaring victory before the victory is won. The better you do, the faster this whole nightmare will end.
Trump later defended his stay-at-home guidance by saying:
We did all the right moves … If we didn’t do what we did, you would’ve had a million people die, maybe more. Maybe 2 million people die.
Mar 30, 2020
Similarly, Ron DeSantis was the governor of Florida in 2020, and after consulting with Trump, he ordered lockdowns there, not me or anyone else. According to the article Florida Governor Orders Statewide Lockdown:
Florida has now joined the list of states that are ordering residents to remain in their homes for all but essential activities to help stop the spread of the coronavirus. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis made the announcement at an afternoon briefing. It was just a few hours after he spoke to President Trump. DeSantis said he’s issuing an executive order that will direct “all Floridians to limit movements and personal interactions outside the home to only those necessary to obtain or provide essential services or essential activities.”
The duration and severity of DeSantis’s lockdowns have also fallen victim to the CAP. According to the article Ron Desantis Claims Florida Lockdowns Lasted Weeks, But Some Of His Own Orders Lasted Months:
And while DeSantis said state lockdowns existed for only a few weeks, the phased reopening of Florida lasted through most of the year. Schools remained closed for the remainder of the 2019-20 school year, and had social distancing requirements when the new school year started in the fall.
It wasn’t until early June, when a second phase of reopening occurred in most of the state, that bars, movie theaters and casinos could reopen. At that point, they still had to limit occupancy to 50% normal levels.
It was not until late September, five months after the lockdown started, that DeSantis preempted most restrictions on businesses. The state entered its Phase Three Reopening on Sept. 26, a step that had been delayed as Florida saw infections skyrocket over the summer.
But even at that point, DeSantis allowed local governments to limit restaurant capacity to 50%.
Even Dr. Bhattacharya’s career as a COVID pundit began with this sentence 6-year-ago:
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified.
I never said anything like that.
“Florida’s response to the pandemic was a tremendous success.”
Despite all this, Dr. Bhattacharya literally “loves” Trump today. He also campaigned for DeSantis and routinely praises his COVID policies. “Florida’s response to the pandemic was a tremendous success,” he said.
The reasons for Dr. Bhattacharya’s glowing embrace of these lockdowners are obvious- politics, power, and tribalism. He hitched his wagon to their stars, and so he needs to erase what they did in 2020.
More than this, Dr. Bhattacharya seeks to displace their actions on to us, his critics and doctors who worked in hospitals, unlike him. In order to spread doubt and anger, he smears us as “lockdowners” and “covidian doctors” in his online temper tantrums. In his telling, because we had the audacity to accurately report what happened when COVID spread uncontrolled, everything that people hated about the pandemic is entirely our fault. Meanwhile, Dr. Bhattacharya absolves the virus all guilt and the portrays the politicians who actually ordered lockdowns- his political benefactors- as heroic visionaries.
Fortunately, we can resist Dr. Bhattacharya’s revisionist fantasy and reject his attempts to recruit us into his CAP. The next time he blathers on about the unspeakable horrors of lockdowns, we can remember that he has nothing but praise and sweet nothings for the politicians who actually ordered them.


Science Based Satire:  My 2026 Interview with Jay Bhattacharya. It’s Still Lockdowns All the Way Down.
“The worst thing about lockdowns is that they are over, and everyone else moved on long ago.”
Jonathan Howard on January 29, 2026
Link

Question:  Why is the USA leaving the World Health Organization?
Answer:  The WHO issues a warning to countries to keep lockdowns in place until the epidemic is “under control”. Under this faulty guidance, the world should probably still be in lockdown.
Question:  How does leaving the WHO make the USA safer?
Answer:  The WHO recommends a set of stringent preconditions for lifting lockdown.
Question:  I’m confused.  In September 2021, you said “We should be treating COVID as one of 200 diseases that affect people.”  So why are you still relitigating COVID debates from spring 2020?
Answer:  According to the WHO, lockdowns are not decisions made by governments, but something that happens to people unless they obey. 
Question:  Well, if you want to talk about COVID errors, in April 2021 you said vaccinated people have “zero” risk of transmitting COVID.  Later, you said this was a “lie”.  Can you explain?
Answer: Lockdowns cause a form of psychological terror that guarantee they could never last just two weeks.
Question:  The Great Barrington Declaration claimed the mass infection of unvaccinated people would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months.  Do we have herd immunity to COVID today?
Answer: What is not understandable is the utter confidence that the WHO and public health leaders expressed in these ideas and lockdown policies to the public as the only way to protect the population, going so far as to call for censorship of contrary voices on social media and elsewhere.
Question: In May 2021 you said that we “kind of” already had herd immunity to COVID and that it was seasonal. They Delta variant arrived immediately after that. Were you right?
Answer: The stockpiled countermeasures developed under the old pandemic playbook offer a false sense of security and empower those who would impose lockdowns, mandates, and other such strategies.
Question:  Moving on to more current issues, in 2026 children are missing school not because of lockdowns, but because measles is spreading widely. What is your plan to get things under control? 
Answer:  Is it just me, or are all the WHO high officials and scientists who pushed the world into lockdown in 2020 now swearing up and down that they never recommended lockdown? I, for one, have no confidence that they would not recommend the world lock down again, given the chance.
Question:  Again, back to 2026, whooping cough is also spreading due to low vaccine rates.  What is your plan to control this?
Answer:  Lockdowns cannot suppress COVID spread or protect the vulnerable for long,
Question: Let’s talk about recent decisions you’ve made at the NIH. Why did you sign the memorandum, CDC Acts on Presidential Memorandum to Update Childhood Immunization Schedule, which decimated the vaccine schedule?  
Answer: I think ultimately lockdowns ended up killing more people than would’ve been killed had those lockdowns not happened.
Question: I am unclear why should unvaccinated children contract multiple diseases when safe and effective vaccines exist?
Answer:  The WHO mission to China in 2020 lauded the Chinese lockdown as a success, in effect endorsing the model for the rest of the world.
Question:  Many states, medical organizations, and individual doctors are completely ignoring your new vaccine guidance. Why did you lose trust and what is your plan to restore it?
Answer:  Lockdowns crush the lives and well-being of children, the poor, and the working class, and almost everyone other than the laptop class. 
Question: Why did you end research into mRNA vaccines?
Answer: The economic dislocations caused by the lockdowns certainly killed vast numbers of people.
Question:  How have you made Americans healthy again? Give me concrete examples.
Answer:  In the case of the covid crisis, the problems were confounded by a determined unwillingness of scientific and public health leaders to respond to data — in real time — that showed  that core assumptions underlying the lockdown strategy were wrong. 
Question:  You’ve been on at least 68 podcasts since becoming NIH director, earning the moniker “Podcast Jay”.  How do you respond to those who claim you are more concerned with making social media content than running the NIH?
Answer:  As covid prevalence rose in the fall, the Great Barrington Declaration strongly recommends against lockdowns. 
Question:  You claim to value education. Can you explain why you collaborated with a pro-tobacco, child-labor advocate to write the Great Barrington Declaration?
Answer:  But what you’re not allowed to do is assume that the thing you’re doing is going to work. Right? “I’m going to do a lockdown; that’ll solve the problem.” You’re also not allowed to assume that the thing that you’re doing will have no harms.
Question:  How is your search for the cause of autism going?
Answer:  If the WHO opposed lockdowns, where was the WHO condemnation of them in 2020 or 2021? Or of China’s lockdowns in 2022?
Question:  Even though you’ve done research into “racial disparities” you are now banning DEI. Can you define DEI and tell us who makes these decisions at the NIH?
Answer: I think the fundamental error is: People think that “well, the lockdowns sort of worked.”
Question: Citing incompetence and the politicization of science, multiple NIH scientists and administrators have quit in protest over your dismal leadership.  What is your response?
Answer:  So imagine that you’ve done this. You’ve recommended the lockdowns, you’ve recommended the school closures, you’ve recommended a set of measures that are going to harm the poor, you know are going to harm the children, but you’re doing it because you want to suppress the spread of this deadly disease that, in the back of your mind, maybe you think you might have been responsible for. Maybe you can’t admit that to yourself.
Question:  It’s trivially easy to find articles about your failed leadership at the NIH. Can you direct me to articles saying the NIH is thriving under your competent stewardship?
Answer:  A 2024 comprehensive meta-analysis of the econometric literature on the effectiveness of lockdowns to stop disease spread by Danish, Swedish and American authors find little evidence of lockdown efficacy.
Question:  You claim to support free speech, yet from Kevin Hall to Jeanne Marrazzo to Jenna Norton, NIH scientists and employees report being silenced and censored under your leadership. What is your response?
Answer: You’re not going to have another lockdown.
Question:  A recent article reported that the US government lost over 10,000 STEM Ph.D.s since Trump took office. What is your response?
Answer:  So in October 2020, when we wrote the Great Barrington Declaration, if you go read it, we actually have vaccines as one of the mechanisms of focused protection.  Again, I had this naïve view that if you have this countermeasure, you use it to protect older people, and then you lift lockdowns.
Question:  Dr. Walter Koroshetz is a widely admired director of the National Institute for Neurological Disorders and Stroke. Why did you decide to get rid of him, and if you didn’t make that decision, then who is running things at the NIH?
Answer:  I wouldn’t recommend a lockdown if another pandemic came along.
Question: You claim to regret how science became politicized. Why did you speak at the TPUSA conference?
Answer: The evidence was really clear. The lockdowns have failed to protect anybody from getting COVID and would cause some tremendous collateral (damage).
Question:  You claim to value scientific debate.  Have you invited any of your critics for a debate since becoming head of the NIH?
Answer:  They were immune to the folly and harms of lockdown!
Question:  What are your greatest achievements at the NIH thus far?
Answer:  Sweden, which never locked down, protected human life better than nearly every country on earth.
Question:  What are your upcoming plans for the NIH this year?
Answer:  Lockdowns protected the laptop class and hurt everyone else. 
Question: You are a core member of the Trump administration, and you’ll forever linked with everything he does.  Given this, what do you feel about what is going on in Minnesota right now?  
Answer: No one will defend the lockdowns anymore.
Question:  It’s 2026.  You are director of the NIH. What is your opinion about…
Answer:  Sorry to interrupt, but the answer is that lockdowns were the biggest public health disaster in history and it’s true I won’t ever recommend one!
Question:  I can see you still want to talk about lockdowns. What is the absolute worst thing about them?
Answer:  The worst thing about lockdowns is that they are over, and everyone else moved on long ago.


Welcome to the Resistance UCSF Doctors
The many doctors who are just now realizing that misinformation wasn’t “COVID hysteria nonsense” have a lot of catching up to do to understand how the forces they’ve legitimized the led to this moment.
Jonathan Howard on February 28, 2025
Link
Less money spent on the administration is more money to give out to actual scientists
As the article Trump White House Cites Fringe Doctor to Defend Research Cuts reported, Dr. Vinay Prasad was recently featured in a White House statement in which he denied a Washington Post story about cuts to the NIH. The statement said:
That is shameful and dishonest framing from the Post. Dr. Vinay Prasad, a Professor of Epidemiology and Biostatistics and Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, praised NIH’s announcement.
Dr. Prasad wrote: “Cutting indirects might even mean more science. Less money spent on the administration is more money to give out to actual scientists.”
However, when he’s not busy spreading Orwellian doublespeak, saying less money is more money, Dr. Prasad is busy celebrating cuts to researchers, as well as mass purges of scientists and the ascension of RFK Jr. Dr. Prasad, along with his friends and ideological compatriots Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and Marty Makary, are now the embodiment of the medical establishment, and their vision is being realized. They wanted RFK Jr. to “disrupt the US medical establishment” and that’s what he’s doing.
Anyone who either legitimized these doctors or defended them by baselessly smearing their critics contributed to this moment.
UCSF ‘Borders on Panic’ Facing Potential Trump Funding Slash
Not all of Dr. Prasad’s UCSF colleagues share his delight at the decimation of scientific research and the triumph of anti-vaxxers. Dr. Monica Gandhi, for example, recently said:
MEASLES: A child died from a vax-preventable disease in US. This is a national emergency. We are throwing the baby out with the bathwater (e.g. stop some USAID programs that are corrupt, not all; evaluate each vax in isolation- measles vax works; “burn it all down” will kill)
She”s right. This is a serious moment. She was also featured in articles titled Court Orders Don’t Calm UCSF Researchers’ Nerves and ‘Devastating’: Trump Research Funding Cuts Could Cost the Bay Area Billions. That last article reported that UCSF could lose $138 million annually, and it quoted Dr. Gandhi as saying:
People are acting like these schools are building palaces, but they’re supporting direct research by giving us the infrastructure. There’s just so much we would have lost, and that we could still lose.
People are acting like these schools are building palaces because her that’s what her UCSF colleague is telling them.
Another article, UCSF ‘Borders on Panic’ Facing Potential Trump Funding Slash, also quoted Dr. Gandhi. It said:
As the lead of the Center for AIDS Research at the University of California, San Francisco, Dr. Monica Gandhi is spending the month in a world of devastating “what-ifs.”
What would have happened if a federal judge had not, on Feb. 10, blocked the Trump administration’s order to slash billions in biomedical research funding from the National Institutes of Health? Monitoring the health of study participants in biomedical research funded by NIH would be gone. Clinical trials on patients would be stopped. Key services, like maintaining the lab equipment and keeping research data safe, would also vanish.
“All of that, as of Friday, is massively threatened,” Gandhi said.
That’s horrible, and I don’t blame her for panicking. However, I can’t help but wonder “what if” more doctors had cared about misinformation instead of spreading it.
Four years ago, Dr. Gandhi was telling us not to panic in interviews such as Pandemic Exit Interviews: Stop Panicking About The COVID-19 Variants, Says UCSF’s Monica Gandhi. She also recorded a podcast titled The End Of The Pandemic with Dr. Zubin Damania, “variants schmariants“, and The Motivation We Need to Reach the End of the COVID-19 Pandemic with Dr. Monica Gandhi with Dr. Prasad. Last summer, she shared a stage with Dr. Prasad, as well as Drs. Makary and Dr. Bhattacharya, during the infamous Stanford conference. When Dr. Bhattcharya was nominated to head the NIH, she said:
I can’t say I’m not nervous because our universities not only depend on this money, but it’s not the time to, stop HIV research. We have a lot of work to do. On the other hand, I think Dr. Bhattacharya is kind. He is gentle. He has had a complete reputation of being respectful of listening to others and I think that gives me a lot of hope about his leadership.
Hopefully, she is right, and Dr. Bhattacharya will arrive to save the day.
Meanwhile, seeking to enrage and emotionally manipulate his audience as usual, here’s what Dr. Prasad is saying about worried researchers like Dr. Gandhi:
I have no sympathy for academic researchers and their staff who do shit science and live off NIH grants. I am sorry. Never have. Never will. They do work that cannot be reproduced, just say the same empty slogans that are in vogue. During the pandemic they failed society and lied about the impact of school closure and the viral origins. I can’t believe we tax plumbers and bus drivers who do real work to fund this bullshit. It’s a welfare program for upper middle class kids. Recently they were saying even a single drink of wine kills you. They should be completely defunded for using low quality science to insert themselves in debates they don’t understand, or appreciate. It’s not even science. It’s propaganda that’s government-funded masquerading as science.
Charming stuff.
Dr. Howard said Dr. Bhattacharya “bungled basic facts” about the pandemic
Dr. Gandhi is not the only UCSF doctor to suddenly started caring about the consequences of misinformation in 2025. Dr. Eric Widera, who recently collaborated with Dr. Prasad, now laments that RFK Jr. is in power. He recently said:
Does he even know what doctors and nurses do. He sounds like your weird uncle at at Thanksgiving dinner telling you doctors will be replaced by (insert anything) in the next year.
It takes competence to fix something or make it better. Any fool can break it even further. RFK Jr. is in the latter group.
Dr. Widera was obviously correct, though RFK Jr. was confirmed by the Senate 2 weeks later.
Similarly, Dr. Anil Makam, who wrote an homage to anecdotal data in Dr. Prasad’s monetized misinformation Substack, is not happy about the fate of an NIH grant he submitted. He said:
I too am unhappy because of silence on why and how long & have an R01 (an NIH grant) that might be funded if council meets next week.
It’s awful that his hard work is stuck in limbo and may be lost forever.
However, not long ago these UCSF doctors berated me because I corrected the factual errors of our new medical establishment. They felt our future leaders deserved a space space where they are immune to criticism. Last fall, I was quoted in a New York Times article titled Trump Picks Stanford Physician Dr. Jay Bhattacharya to Head NIH. It said:
But Dr. Bhattacharya still provokes extremely strong feelings. Dr. Jonathan Howard… who treated patients at Bellevue Hospital at the height of the pandemic, has assailed Dr. Bhattacharya in a book, “We Want Them Infected.”
Dr. Howard said Dr. Bhattacharya “bungled basic facts” about the pandemic. In March 2020, for example, Dr. Bhattacharya suggested in a Wall Street Journal opinion essay that the pandemic was not as deadly as it was being made out to be, and that the death toll might top out at 40,000 Americans; in the end, 1.2 million died.
Dr. Bhattacharya responded on social media by calling Dr. Howard “unhinged” and his book “inane,” advising him to “take an epidemiology class if you don’t want to keep embarrassing yourself.”
Dr. Bhattacharya’s outburst had nothing to do with my “inane” book. After leaving his fake “review,” he later revealed he hadn’t read it. However, rather than lament Dr. Bhattacharya’s lack of maturity and professionalism, as well as his refusal/inability to engage with my ideas, Dr. Widera shared a screenshot from the NYT article and decided to hurl more schoolyard taunts at me. He even tagged Dr. Bhattacharya to make sure he knew that he was defending him against my transgression. He said:
Sensing blood in the kiddie pool, his colleague Dr. Makam added:
Elsewhere, Dr. Widera tried to discredit me by calling me “fringe”. He said I was merely a “loud voice on Twitter who by looking at his post history, mostly insults people,” though he provided no examples.
These content-free tirades from Bay Area doctors, including Dr. Bhattacharya, are not unusual and hardly worth writing about. But beyond the childishness, I want you to notice something more disturbing. Look again at what these UCSF doctors ignored:
Dr. Howard said Dr. Bhattacharya “bungled basic facts” about the pandemic. In March 2020, for example, Dr. Bhattacharya suggested in a Wall Street Journal opinion essay that the pandemic was not as deadly as it was being made out to be, and that the death toll might top out at 40,000 Americans; in the end, 1.2 million died.
I provided a simple but vital piece of information about Dr. Bhattacharya, and it was right there in the screenshot that Dr. Widera shared. I thought people should care that our incoming NIH director drastically underestimated COVID and never looked back. Yet, these UCSF doctors didn’t care a bit. Whether or not Dr. Bhattacharya bungled basic facts, which he did repeatedly, didn’t matter to them at all. Data and evidence were entirely irrelevant to them. They intentionally ignored the numbers I presented, and never thought, “Maybe it’s a problem that Dr. Bhattacharya and his ilk spread misinformation to numb people to a deadly virus“.
While Dr. Bhattacharya was on Fox News (he’s #7 on this list of their most “dishonest” doctors), I was working in the hospital. I didn’t predict 40,000 COVID deaths or spread fake statistics. I’ve been writing and warning about the anti-vaccine movement and RFK Jr. for years, even prior to the pandemic. And yet, these UCSF doctors treated me with contempt and scorn. They just insulted me and and accused me of just insulting people. In their telling, my 220 articles here and We Want Them Infected are thousands of pages of me calling doctors silly names. In reality, I never called Dr. Bhattacharya “unhinged” or “inane,” and I never left fake reviews of his work. I accurately quoted him and explained why I disagreed. These UCSF doctors felt that this was unacceptable, and that frontline doctors like myself lacked the qualifications to critique a laptop class, health economist like Dr. Bhattacharya.
And they did all this specifically to defend Dr. Bhattacharya, an anti-vaccine advocate of herd immunity via mass infection. More recently, Dr. Bhattacharya has called for mRNA vaccines to be removed from the market and validated core anti-vaccine beliefs as Walker Bragman reported in his article Trump Pick for NIH Director: Vaccines May Cause Autism, Alternative Schedules Okay. He also pushed for cuts to the NIH and openly championed RFK Jr., even speaking at one of his rallies with the dangerous anti-vaxx luminary Del Bigtree. That’s what these UCSF doctors are now upset about.
However, until now, these UCSF doctors were just fine with all this. They told the world Dr. Bhattacharya was reliable, while I was the “worst”. They sent a clear message that only a hysterical, fringe, unqualified, insulting psychiatrist would be concerned by the images below. According to UCSF doctors, indifference is the appropriate reaction when people suffer and die because of misinformation.
“COVID hysteria nonsense”
In reality, I wasn’t hysterical enough. RFK Jr., whom Drs. Prasad, Makary, and Bhattacharya all supported, has started his attack on vaccines and is spreading misinformation in the middle of a deadly measles outbreak. The same techniques these doctors developed to numb people to children dying of COVID- “breathless“- are now being employed with measles, and we are just getting started.
Though I underestimated the threat, I at least tried to warn people that normalizing misinformation was dangerous and that we should be serious about the threat. Indeed at the same moment UCSF doctors hurled their juvenile japes at me, I recorded a podcast titled RFK Jr.’s Anti-Vaccine Appointments: A Dangerous Future for Public Health, where I warned about much of what is happening now. These were easy predictions to make for those of us who cared and paid attention. I was nothing special. Countless others also sounded the alarm, only to be greeted with derision. There was nothing unique about my experience, which was benign compared to many others. No one harassed me on my doorstep.
However, while the infantile slurs were easy to brush off, the purposeful apathy was not. When medicine was under attack from within, these UCSF doctors shrugged and yawned. They causally dismissed our warnings as “hysterical” and said we were “insulting” people no matter what evidence we presented or what arguments we made. They made a grand, public display of ignoring data, even when it was right under their noses. They praised and amplified the forces they are currently whining about and simply did not care about misinformation until 2025. Their deliberate indifference vanished only when its consequences hit close to home and after it was too late.
To be clear, I 100% agree with the UCSF doctors’ fears about the impacts of these cuts. If I could push a magic button and restore their funding, I would. I welcome them to the resistance. However, the many doctors, not only as UCSF, who are just now realizing that misinformation wasn’t “COVID hysteria nonsense” have a lot of catching up to do to understand how the forces they’ve legitimized led to this moment. This didn’t happen all of a sudden, and there were countless opportunities to speak up along the way.
Fortunately, we at SBM can help. We cared deeply about misinformation, even when it didn’t directly affect us. It’s clear these UCSF doctors have never read anything we’ve written, and I suggest they start learning about what they’ve missed over the past 5 years.
    • 

Are Frontline Healthcare Workers The Laptop Class?
An examination of the claim that “Public health is for the laptop class”.
Jonathan Howard on June 17, 2022
Link

“Public health is for the laptop class”
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, one of the three authors of the Great Barrington Declaration, recently blocked me on Twitter. That is perfectly fine, and I do the same with people who annoy me. Though it’s important not to insulate yourself in a bubble, we all have the right to curate whom we allow in our lives.
Our final conversation began when he Tweeted that “Public health is for the laptop class”. Dr. Bhattacharya also linked to a video titled “The Catastrophic Failure of Lockdowns“, which was posted at The Epoch Times, a misinformation website linked with the new religious movement Falun Gong. You can’t make this stuff up. I stopped watching after about 30 seconds when he whinged because someone called him “fringe”. This seems to be the touchstone moment of the pandemic for him, the same way watching a healthy 23-year-old die during the first wave left a lasting impression on me.
While Dr. Bhattacharya’s Tweet didn’t specify which public health measures he opposes, as best as I can tell, the only such measure he supports is vaccinating older, vulnerable people. A core theme of his work is that aside from this, public health measures only help privileged people, whom he derides as the laptop class. To get an idea of who he means by the laptop class, picture a meticulously coiffed Stanford doctor who doesn’t see patients, but who has starred in a lot of YouTube videos. Someone who made a melodramatic production about asking his boss for a permission slip he never needed. Someone who’s worst experience this pandemic was being called “fringe”.
Maybe it’s because being called a name doesn’t sound all that bad, but Dr. Bhattacharya’s Tweet annoyed me. Nevertheless, I will agree with him on two points in this article. The first of these is that working class Americans who couldn’t isolate suffered much more than those who could. A recent study found that such workers died at 5 times the rate of wealthier Americans during 2020. As reported by a recent news article:
The staggering disparity was revealed in a study of roughly 69,000 U.S. coronavirus victims ages 25 to 64 who died in 2020.
Sadly, the virus didn’t know these younger workers were supposed to be “non-vulnerable”, as Dr. Bhattacharya claimed they were. It is a travesty more wasn’t done to protect them. However, instead of arguing for better protections for these workers, Dr. Bhattacharya’s solution to this disparity would have been to also expose “non-vulnerable” members of the laptop class. He apparently believes that bus drivers would have suffered less had more members of the laptop class also contracted COVID and that as morgues overflowed with bodies, only lockdowns kept the laptop class safe at home. I guess he thinks hedge fund managers wouldn’t have thought to isolate themselves.
Of course the laptop class didn’t need lockdowns to protect themselves. As Noah Louis-Ferdinand wrote,
An analysis from June of 2020 immediately looking back shows that mobility decreased massively before the lockdowns even started. There was no sharp decline once they set in, mobility increased throughout the lockdown, and it did not increase sharply once they were lifted. Similar graphs show a sharp mobility decline (albeit less steep) in Stockholm, Sweden right around the same time. Sweden never locked down.
If you doubt the privilege of the laptop class, consider that even though Dr. Bhattacharya instructed many others to “resume life as normal” before vaccines were available, he wisely managed to avoid the virus until August 2021 after he had been vaccinated.
Where do frontline healthcare workers fit into this rubric?
Beyond these issues, something important is missing in Dr. Bhattacharya’s claim that “Public health is for the laptop class”. Where do frontline healthcare workers fit into this rubric? The answer, of course, is we don’t. We are invisible to people like Dr. Bhattacharya. When frontline healthcare workers were loudly begging people to be more careful during the pandemic’s biggest surges, Dr. Bhattacharya was making self-pitying YouTube videos claiming he’d been “censored“. He’s never amplified the voices of frontline healthcare workers. When an emergency room doctor asked for his help, he declined (listen to this). Even though public health measures were found to have slowed the virus (here and here), the notion that they may have helped us didn’t occur to Dr. Bhattacharya. Beyond a perfunctory Tweet, we are invisible to him.
However, we didn’t feel public health measures were just for the laptop class. We wanted people to avoid the virus. Careless doctors had to apologize for their behavior, and a scene of young, wealthy people doing karaoke in a crowded bar in April 2020 would have infuriated us. We knew that a few of them could get really sick and they could easily pass the virus to a vulnerable person. As forklifts were needed to move corpses into giant refrigerated trucks, I didn’t hear anyone at my hospital lament that our jobs would be easier if only the laptop class was unrestrained by lockdowns so they too could get COVID. We knew that public health measures weren’t harmless, but they were needed to prevent our hospitals from being further overwhelmed.
Are frontline healthcare workers the laptop class?
So, does Dr. Bhattacharya think frontline healthcare workers are part of the laptop class? He certainly utters pleasant platitudes about us under duress. He told me:
The doctors and nurses who served at the front lines were heroes, many getting covid while taking care of patients. And then in 2021, public health turned on them with vaccine mandates. Many of these heroes were fired. Mr. Brain, please stop lying.
As with most things Dr. Bhattacharya says, this is false in pretty much every way. My name isn’t Mr. Brain, and very few of these “heroes” were fired. Most health systems lost 1-2% of their workforce due to vaccine-refusal, and I’m not aware of any evidence that this miniscule number was composed primarily of frontline doctors and nurses. Dr. Bhattacharya just made that part up.
It turns out that frontline heroes and their professional organizations supported vaccine mandates. They’ve existed our entire careers, and we are both used to and grateful for them. As Dr. Nicole Cifra put it:
None of my co-workers felt ‘turned on’ because of mandates. We felt supported.
I suspect frontline healthcare workers at Stanford feel the same way. Perhaps Dr. Bhattacharya can arrange a Zoom meeting with some of them.
“They definitely made my job harder and if anything, harmed my patients”
In contrast, I don’t know of any frontline heroes who felt supported by Dr. Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington Declaration. Do pediatric intensivists feel the authors of “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young” made life easier for them and their patients? I doubt it, especially considering over 1,000 children have died since that anti-vaccine essay was published exactly one year ago today.
I recently put my belief to the test when I asked on Twitter whether frontline healthcare workers felt supported by authors of the Great Barrington Declaration. “Are they your allies. Did they make your job easier? Did they help your patients?” I asked. I realize this is not a random sample, but exactly zero people answered that the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration supported them. They made it clear, often with colorful language, that it was sheltered, anti-vaccine doctors who “turned on” them. They felt their jobs would have been easier if doctors with enormous platforms were honest about the dangers of the virus and the benefits of the vaccine.
It’s sweet that Dr. Bhattacharya called us heroes, but this is just meaningless virtue signalling, a version of “thoughts and prayers”. If Dr. Bhattacharya wants to do something more for frontline heroes than utter empty words, he’d pause and listen. For example, pediatricians want their patients to be vaccinated. Dr. Bhattacharya hasn’t made a video with one of these heroes so they can share what it’s like to care for a sick child and present the evidence the vaccine can lessen these harms. Why not?
Instead of listening to frontline heroes, Dr. Bhattacharya has minimized the virus from the start and encouraged unvaccinated young people to contract it. This brings me to my second point of agreement with Dr. Bhattacharya. He was right that many healthcare workers contracted COVID while caring for patients. An estimated 115,000 of them died worldwide before the vaccine was available. However, as long as we weren’t “vulnerable”, this was what the Great Barrington Declaration was all about. Dr. Bhattacharya sympathizes with frontline heroes for getting a virus he hoped we would get. That’s weird, especially coming from someone who managed to avoid it for so long.
Though frontline heroes know that Dr. Bhattacharya and his ilk made their jobs much harder, even the most burnt-out healthcare worker knows others suffered more. We saw it all with our own eyes, not just from our laptops.

Laptop Class Doctors Think Doctors Who Treat Patients Are Lazy, Dumb, Cowardly, Sheep
Had laptop class doctors been willing to listen to doctors who worked on COVID units, they wouldn’t have said so many absurd things.
Jonathan Howard on November 22, 2024
Tweet

A Legend At A Brooklyn Hospital Dies Of Covid-19: ‘He Ran Into The Fire’
Being a frontline healthcare worker was just one of 10,000 ways in which people made crucial pandemic contributions. It was not a requirement to comment on COVID or a guarantee that the person had anything valuable to say. However, working on a COVID unit provided an essential perspective. Yet, several doctors who experienced the pandemic entirely from their laptop, disagreed. They felt that doctors who worked in hospitals were unqualified to comment on COVID.
Indeed, most We Want Them Infected (WWTI) doctors never treated COVID patients, and their ignorance was obvious in their every utterance. They completely disregarded frontline workers, and the phrase “no one who worked on a COVID unit would say anything like that” could appear after nearly quote I’ve shared from them. WWTI doctors were entirely incurious about what happened in hospitals while they were recording their YouTube videos and warning “against climate of fear on COVID”. They never said:
Since I don’t treat COVID patients, maybe I should pause and listen to doctors who do. They might have a perspective I lack.
Had WWTI doctors been willing to listen, they would have learned some valuable things. Most deaths occurred in older, sick people, but we all saw some young people die. Although death was the only negative consequence recognized by WWTI doctors, it was not COVID’s only bad outcome. Many people survived COVID, but were seriously injured by it. No one who worked on a COVID unit casually brushed aside what the virus could do with banal claims that “the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young.“
Mostly, WWTI doctors would have learned that SARS-CoV-2 was hard to contain. The virus invariably found people when it was left to spread unchecked, overwhelming hospitals and morgues. No one who saw what it could do was under any illusion that vulnerable people could have been sealed in a magic bubble, as WWTI doctors claimed.
Indeed, we saw COVID spread widely within the hospital. Countless healthcare workers contracted the virus, and the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that 115,000 of them died from COVID by May 2021. Dr. James Mahoney was one of them. He was on the verge of retirement when the pandemic hit, but refused to abandon his community. According to the article A Legend At A Brooklyn Hospital Dies Of Covid-19: ‘He Ran Into The Fire’
Mahoney was well-trained to treat Covid-19 patients. And public hospitals, already stretched thin, were bracing for an influx of patients. So he went “running into the fire”, Melvin said. Brooklyn has had 40,000 Covid-19 cases, and the virus hit black and Latino communities the hardest.
“The last time I saw him was at the beginning of the pandemic,” Cavanagh said. “I said, are we going to get through this? And he said, oh yeah, we’re going to get through this.”
But in early April, Mahoney started coughing and running a fever. On Easter Sunday, after Chisolm recovered, Mahoney’s family noticed on a video chat that he didn’t look well. The next day, he was admitted to his own hospital, SUNY Downstate.
At first, Mahoney seemed to be improving – he gave his family a thumbs up on FaceTime. Then his health deteriorated and he was transferred to NYU Langone for a higher level of care. He died on 27 April.
Physicians at SUNY Downstate said Mahoney’s death has left a hole in the institution after his three decades there. “He was what we call a ‘lifer’” at the hospital, said colleague Alex Hieu Ly.
Dr. Mahoney was 62 and had worked in the hospital for 30 years. Real-world heroes like him were totally irrelevant to WWTI doctors. They never mentioned or considered them at all.
I can’t breathe again. I really regret not getting my vaccine. If I can do it all over again I would do it in a heartbeat to save my life.
This lack of real-world responsibility also meant that WWTI doctors were sheltered from the consequences of their words. Although they said “the climate of fear on COVID is dangerous”, even before anyone was vaccinated, they never met people like Christian Cabrera who absorbed their message. According to the article, Father Dying Of Covid Regrets Not Getting Vaccine In Heartbreaking Texts:
Shortly before dying of Covid-19, a father in Los Angeles texted family members to express his regret over not getting vaccinated.
Christian Cabrera, 40, tested positive for the coronavirus around Christmas. Not long afterward, he was in an emergency room with pneumonia in both lungs.
“I can’t breathe again,” he texted his brother, according to KTLA. “I really regret not getting my vaccine. If I can do it all over again I would do it in a heartbeat to save my life. I’m fighting for my life here and I wish I [had] gotten vaccinated.”
This happened to many thousands of young people, and Dr. Abraar Karan, an infectious disease expert at Stanford, explained why no one who witnessed this would minimize the virus. He said:
One thing I guarantee you will notice if you pay attention, doctors who have cared for #COVID19 patients will never underestimate what this virus is capable of. The antivaxx, antimask pundits who have been tweeting from the safety of their home for the past two years often will.
I have yet to meet a fellow physician who has spent the majority of their time caring for these cases who would claim to know exactly what to expect from #SARSCoV2 — because we continue to be surprised. Surprised by people who die that shouldn’t. People who suffer for longer than we would expect. People who seem to get better & then suddenly turn for the worse. People who are doing poorly & who end up surviving.
Medicine humbles us as clinicians; this virus has too. Hearing non-clinicians downplay it after long days/weeks/months where we are working hard to try & save people’s lives Honestly- eventually you can’t help but feel like half of the people on here who claim to know what the right answer is or what’s “safe enough” are full of BS.
Because if you get sick, they won’t be responsible for it. They won’t be accountable to you, your family, your loved ones Your doctors will be at your bedside. Your antimask, antivaxx saviors will not. A common response I hear from sick patients once it’s too late — I wish I had listened.
He’s right
Most of our doctors are really sheep. They’re not thinking people, they’re told what to do, they just do it. Partly that’s just really weak, dumb.
Instead of being curious and willing to learn from people like Dr. Karan, WWTI doctors mocked and berated healthcare workers who shared their experience from the frontlines and urged caution based on what they saw. For example, Dr. Scott Atlas said about doctors who suggested masks and vaccines:
I would say right to them they are a disgrace, a complete disgrace. I know that sounds very harsh but I mean this is an example of a couple things. Number one, seems like most of our doctors are really sheep. They’re not thinking people, they’re told what to do, they just do it. Partly that’s just really weak, dumb. I’m not being very articulate this morning, I’m sorry, but you know it’s just I’m beside myself. Partly they’re just cowards.
We have a tremendous void in courage in our country. Doctors enjoy a position of huge prestige but more importantly, trust.
Elsewhere, Dr. Atlas blamed doctors who treated patients for the loss of trust in the medical profession. He said:
I mean, the medical community really failed, and we see the results of their failure. First of all, you know, they’re trusted. You know, you know, I mean, we’re doctors, people are intimidated by doctors, but also we occupy a special position of trust in society, almost blind trust.
People depend on you, you have to take that role very seriously, though, how do what do I mean by that? That means when somebody comes in and asks you a question, you don’t just spit out a memorized guideline, you you explain what the data is, if they want to know, you don’t you don’t persuade by coercion and pressure, you persuade by showing people the facts.
I mean, your role is to be the the the information giver not to coerce people and they really failed. And I have to say, you know, doctors, it’s a disgrace what they did and how little they know about the data, a disgrace, in my opinion, but you see it in the polling, you know, you realize that pre pandemic, the trust high trust in doctors, 71%.
Now, January 2024, from 71% have plummeted to trust doctors a lot. Now they had answers 40%. It’s it’s very maybe continuing to drop.
As a reminder, Dr. Atlas is a radiologist who became famous for his TV appearances. He predicted that COVID would kill 10,000 Americans and that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity. Today, he blames doctors who didn’t make these horrible predictions for the lack of trust in medicine.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya is an exemplar of the laptop class, who teamed up with a pro-tobacco, child labor advocate, to advocate for herd immunity through mass infection. Dr. Bhattacharya also attacked frontline doctors who tried to limit the virus or corrected his factual errors. In an interview in 2022, he said:
If you think about medicine as a vocation, you’re supposed to devote your well-being to the life a patient that you are caring for…lockdowns actually reversed that and said look, ‘you the population should suffer so that my job in medicine can be easier‘, so a reversal of the norms of medicine where medicine serves people, not people serve medicine. The fact that medicine, especially the leaders of medicine were so strongly in favor of the lockdowns is a violation of the ethics of the medical profession. It essentially transforms the doctor-patient relationship to one where the patient serves the doctor rather than the other way around.
Dr. Bhattacharya felt it was unethical for doctors to have tired to limit COVID, even though our morgues were overflowing. He felt doctors just wanted their own jobs to be easier. They were being selfish.
In 2023, he posted a fake “review” of We Want Them Infected, which he did not read. In it, he called me “inane” and “unhinged” and said:
(Free advice for you, Jonathan: maybe take an epidemiology class if you don’t want to keep embarrassing yourself in public further?)…
The unspoken root idea of his is that the general public owed it to doctors to not get covid because it would place doctors at risk of getting covid. Of course this is an inversion. Medical professionals serve the public, not the other way around.
Because he didn’t read my book, he didn’t address a single claim in it. Much of it is merely a collection of things he said, combined with headlines from the real-world. I don’t call him silly names.
Elsewhere he said about me:
I pity him,@surrealtruther. He seems like a man broken by an extended encounter between deeply held (but false) ideas about the way the world works and the way the world actually works.
Dr. Bhattacharya feels the kind of experience at gained by working Bellevue Hospital throughout the pandemic, teaches one nothing about how world actually works. Because I accurately quote him, I am a “broken man.”
On social media, Dr. Bhattacharya behaved childishly when discussing doctors who treat patients, calling them “covidian doctors.” Though his was normal and typical for him. He made disdainful comments about doctors who left X, precisely because of this sort of behavior.
Who needs it?
Doctors had enough of the smears, the schoolyard taunts, and the bad-faith engagement. They were tired of people like Dr. Bhattacharya blaming them and telling people not to trust them. It’s scary to think a sheltered health economist who behaves like this and who holds doctors in open contempt may be the head of the NIH next year.
Although many thousands of healthcare workers died of COVID, laptop class doctors felt doctors who worked in hospitals were lazy, dumb, cowardly, covidian sheep who didn’t understand how the world works. They felt doctors who treated COVID patients should have looked at the suffering and death that surrounded us and honored medical ethics by declaring- we need more people to get COVID. Moving forward, these doctors may be more powerful than ever, though they’ll always be safe from behind a laptop. We may soon discover what insults they’ll hurl at us when the next pandemic hits or, thanks to their efforts, measles and pertussis return.

Conspirituality: A Book Recommendation
Conspirituality is a must-read for anyone who seeks to understand the daunting task we face in repairing the damage done by disinformation doctors.
Jonathan Howard on July 28, 2023
Link

A disheartening conversation
Let me walk you through a disheartening conversation I recently had on Twitter. My interlocutor was a writer with a large social media following and a fan of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, an anti-vaccine doctor who did not treat COVID patients, but nevertheless felt that frontline doctors like myself were unethical for not encouraging its spread at the start of the pandemic. Our conversation began when this person said the following:
I have no idea why anyone would say this. Dr. Bhattacharya and I agree on a few points. We agree that COVID is dangerous for “vulnerable” people and that drastic measures to contain the virus harmed many people in important ways. However, beyond these utterly uncontroversial points, I’d be hard pressed to name one thing Dr. Bhattacharya has been “right about”. Though it would take an entire book to spell out just some of his errors, the two images below reveal both his poor pandemic prognostications and the tragic, real-world influence he had.
I’ve always wondered how anyone could claim that Dr. Bhattacharya was “pretty much right” about anything after this incident and dozens more like it. So I shared this image to Dr. Bhattacharya’s Twitter admirer. How would they resolve the cognitive dissonance these images might create? I soon had my answer.
In other words, don’t trust the death toll. (I’ve discussed the origin of this myth before.) Seeking to probe further, I shared this article, along with a reference to the famous line from 1984.
The article I posted, was by Dr. Jennifer Caputo-Seidler a hospitalist on the COVID unit at Tampa General Hospital and an assistant professor of medicine at the University of South Florida. Less than a month after Dr. Bhattacharya falsely claimed Florida had “protected the vulnerable”, she said:
As I write this, 13 of the hospital’s wards are now dedicated to caring for people with Covid-19.
It’s not just the number of patients that’s worse this time around. They are also sicker. I’ve gotten used to seeing a patient during morning rounds on minimal supplemental oxygen who ends up in the ICU before the day is over. I cared for one patient who, in 24 hours, went from being on a small amount of supplemental oxygen — 4 liters — to being on a ventilator. When even maximal ventilator support couldn’t provide him with the oxygen he needed, I called his wife and told her I didn’t think he would make it. She broke down on the phone and asked if we could arrange a call for their 9-year-old son to say goodbye to his dad.
I made eight similar phone calls that day.
However, according to my conversation partner, Dr. Caputo-Seidler also could not to be believed. Dr. Caputo-Seidler’s firsthand account was dismissed a mere “media-circulated anecdote”. My Twitter interlocutor said:
I was further told that death certificates couldn’t be trusted because doctors had “financial incentives” to put down COVID. (I’ve discussed the origin of this myth before.) They said:
In fact, I was informed we’ve been living in a Zero COVID world for nearly 3 years, one enforced by governments and media across the globe. My Twitter interlocutor wanted everyone to know they saw through the lies spread by doctors who worked in hospitals throughout the pandemic. They said:
There are no shortages of first hand accounts and videos of death and suffering throughout the pandemic from all over the world. All this happened not long ago. Yet, none of this moved my Twitter conversation partner. In fact, they were literally unpersuadable. What piece of information could I have possibly provided to change their mind? The official statistics couldn’t be believed. Governments and mass media couldn’t be believed. Doctors’ firsthand accounts couldn’t be believed. The only person who could be believed was someone who told her what she wanted to hear, namely Dr. Bhattacharya, a laptop class doctor who falsely pacified Floridians right before the Delta variant ripped through the state.
And we have to be clear about the problem here. The problem isn’t one of information. The problem is an issue of trust. What happened to make this person, and millions like them, so distrustful and impervious to evidence? How can we converse with people who summarily dismiss all unwanted information as lies and anecdotes, all the while absurdly insisting that we lived through 3 years of Zero COVID, a policy pushed by governments and “mass media” around the world? Why did people who ate organic food and did yoga in 2019, deny the pandemic and embrace QAnon a few years later?
A recommendation
I don’t have much to offer here, but I know who does – Derek Beres, Matthew Remski, and Julian Walker, the hosts of the podcast Conspirituality (I was a recent guest) and authors of the new book Conspirituality: How New Age Conspiracy Theories Became a Health Threat. Conspirituality discusses many of the same topics and disinformation agents as us here at SBM, however, they arrive from a completely different starting point. Beres, Remski, and Walker are not doctors, but instead were themselves immersed in wellness, yoga, and even cults for years. During the pandemic, they saw these spaces devolve into a cesspool of misinformation and right-wing oppression fantasies. Their reporting comes from the inside, and they describe their project thusly:
Conspirituality takes a deep dive into the troubling phenomenon of influencers who have curdled New Age spirituality and wellness with the politics of paranoia—peddling vaccine misinformation, tales of child trafficking, and wild conspiracy theories.
In the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, a disturbing social media trend emerged: a large number of yoga instructors and alt-health influencers were posting stories about a secretive global cabal bent on controlling the world’s population with a genocidal vaccine. Instagram feeds that had been serving up green smoothie recipes and Mary Oliver poems became firehoses of Fox News links, memes from 4chan, and prophecies of global transformation.
Since May 2020, Derek Beres, Matthew Remski and Julian Walker have used their Conspirituality podcast to expose countless facets of the intersection of alt-health practitioners with far-right conspiracy trolls. Now this expansive and revelatory book unpacks the follies, frauds, cons and cults that dominate the New Age and wellness spheres and betray the trust of people who seek genuine relief in this uncertain age.
With analytical rigor and irreverent humor, Conspirituality offers an antidote to our times, helping readers recognize wellness grifts, engage with loved ones who’ve fallen under the influence, and counter lies and distortions with insight and empathy.
And that’s exactly what they do.
Incredibly, their book manages to thread a very narrow needle. First of all, it names familiar names – Dr. Kelly Brogan, Sayer Ji, Dr. Christiane Northrup, and RFK Jr for example – and pulls no punches. It is unambiguously clear that lying grifters spread deadly disinformation to boost their egos and bank accounts. Conspirituality doesn’t just correct these gurus’ disinformation, but it also exposes the language, tone, and carefully cultivated images charismatic influencers use to seduce their audience into believing absurdities. Once you’ve heard the term “resting guru face”, you’ll see it everywhere.
However, Conspirituality also explores misinformation in wellness spaces not just to condemn it, but also to genuinely understand what drives otherwise reasonable people to embrace medical myths, even at the cost of their lives. It explores the historical roots of misinformation and describes how people like Helena Blavatsky, Rudolph Steiner, and fraudulent yoga gurus from long ago haunt us today (not literally). They are consciously careful never to punch down and blame or mock those fooled by misinformation. Instead, they share their stories compassionately, and explain why my Twitter conversation partner was primed to disbelieve any piece of information that disconfirmed their pandemic narrative. The authors of Conspirituality understand that doctors in sterile white coats in cold exam rooms with florescent lights are often no match for “holistic healers” in robes who claim to treat the “root cause” of disease with “natural” products, not drugs and surgeries.
Of course, mainstream medicine is not entirely blameless. In a typical passage, they write:
Conspirituality doctors do have a plausible critique to make of modern biomedicine. They are correct to note that its science and mechanisms are inaccessible to the understanding of laypeople. Research on COVID and vaccines is published in a language that requires expertise to decode. For that decoded knowledge to enter the public sphere, cultural trust in the expertise is required. In the medical sphere, this trust can easily be lost to highly visible abuses, such as when Merck concealed the cardiac risk of Vioxx. But it can also be lost through run‑of‑the-mill mistakes and neglect. The lab loses a test. The family doctor misses a key diagnostic moment. It is into these cracks that the conspiritualist answer leaps, offering a false sense of empowerment by pointing to spiritual solutions that, in fact, no one can understand in a scientific and replicable—this is also to say, democratic way. These are solutions that no one has full access to, that cannot be tested or falsified.
This is exactly right.
It’s clear that we all have a lot of work to do in regaining trust, and disinformation superspreaders have both an easier job and a huge head start. They also have more motivation. Skeptics debunk misinformation in our free time because we feel it’s important, not because our livelihoods depend on it. In contrast, conspirituality doctors need to spread fear, uncertainty and doubt to keep a roof, often a very nice roof, over their head. As they say in Conspirituality, “watch what they say and watch what they sell.”
Conspirituality is a must-read for anyone who seeks to understand the daunting task we face in repairing the damage they’ve done.

Dr. Martin Kulldorff, Who Posted Pictures of Guillotines and Promised Herd Immunity Would Arrive 3-6 Months After Lockdowns Ended, Fired for “Clinging to the Truth”.
“Science cannot survive in a society that does not value truth and strive to discover it.”
Jonathan Howard on March 12, 2024
Link
Dr. Martin Kulldorff, who claimed in October 2020 that the mass infection of hundreds of millions of unvaccinated Americans would lead to herd immunity in under 6-months, was recently fired from Harvard. Dr. Kulldorff, who said in April 2020, “Around 1/3 of ppl in Stockholm has now had COVID-19, and it is likely to be the first place to reach herd immunity,” said that he was fired for “clinging to the truth.”
In an article about his firing titled Harvard Tramples the Truth, Dr. Kulldorff, who in May 2020 said, “Daily reported COVID-19 cases has dropped to half in Stockholm, where herd immunity will arrive first,” said that:
The Harvard motto is Veritas, Latin for truth. But, as I discovered, truth can get you fired.
Dr. Kulldorff, who promised in December 2020 that once lockdowns ended, the “pandemic will then be naturally over in 3-6 months,” said:
Veritas has not been the guiding principle of Harvard leaders.
Dr. Kulldorff, who said in December 2021 that COVID, which killed hundreds of children, was less deadly “than the already low risk from the annual influenza,” which killed a 1 child, blasted Harvard saying:
That’s not the path to truth.
Dr. Kulldorff, who said in December 2021, “The pandemic ends when enough people have natural immunity after Covid recovery” added:
Harvard and the wider scientific community have much work to do to deserve and regain public trust.
Dr. Kulldorff, who said, “we have seen only a handful of reinfections…recovery from infection will provide lasting protection against reinfection” and that infected children “have strong natural immunity that protects them from covid infections as they get older” asked in his article:
What is science if we do not humbly pursue the truth?
Dr. Kulldorff, a pandemic celebrity who advised President Trump and Ron DeSantis despite never treating a single COVID patient, expressed pity for his fate, saying:
Having also been censored by LinkedIn, Facebook, and YouTube, I could not freely communicate as a scientist.
Dr. Kulldorff, who said, “Faucism and Fascism are not the same, but there are some similarities”, expressed great dismay that he was called a mean name -“fringe epidemiologist”- in a private email.
Dr. Kulldorff, who threatened besieged public health officials by posting a picture of a guillotine, extolled the virtue of “civilized debates” saying:
When scientists have different takes on topics of public importance, universities should organize open and civilized debates to pursue the truth.
Dr. Kulldorff, who compared children wearing masks to the Taliban’s brutal treatment of women, added:
The pursuit of truth requires academic freedom with open, passionate, and civilized scientific discourse, with zero tolerance for slander, bullying, or cancellation.
Dr. Kulldorff, who said in June 2021, “The pandemic is on its way out”, concluded his article by saying:
Science cannot survive in a society that does not value truth and strive to discover it.

A Tale of Two Interviews: Martin Kulldorff and James Baker
One science-based and the other wish-based

Lynn Shaffer on November 1, 2025
Link

It was the best of interviews, it was the worst of interviews. At times I was born aloft on the wings of enlightenment, other times I feared I would drown in a sludge of foolishness. On the one hand was belief, on the other, incredulity. In short, I felt the torment of whiplash, but I lived to tell the tale.
Martin Kulldorff has been in the news a lot, lately. ACIP’s not going well. Dr. Kulldorff expressed an uncharacteristic lack of supreme confidence in himself, saying “We are rookies.” Dr. Kulldorff annoys me and I rarely if ever agree with him. However, sometimes I take a step back and assess whether my thinking is too rigid or biased. So I searched for writings or an interview with Dr. Kulldorff where he could express himself without restriction and I would just “listen.”
Comparing apples to apples
I came across an interview he did on a podcast called ”The Common Bridge,” (see: Dr. Martin Kulldorff – TheCommonBridge.com ) which is hosted by Richard Helppie. I hadn’t heard of Richard Helppie or “The Common Bridge.” Mr. Helppie appears to live in Michigan and his website suggests he tries to be non-partisan. The date of the interview is unclear, but took place after the Great Barrington Declaration and before the COVID vaccines were out.
I read the interview’s transcript and Mr. Helppie was respectful toward Dr. Kulldorff, while also asking a few questions that might have been a little challenging. He gave Dr. Kulldorff a forum for expressing his views in an unfettered setting. The episode was named, “The Great Barrington Declaration.” It was an opportunity for Dr. Kulldorff to explain in more detail his approach to handling the COVID epidemic.
I came away from the interview still irritated with Dr. Kulldorff. He made various assertions that weren’t supported with solid evidence and a couple of his suggestions made me laugh out loud.
That exercise completed, I browsed Mr. Helppie’s website to see who else he has interviewed. An episode with a Dr. James R. Baker, titled, “Vaccines, Public Trust, and What We Got Wrong About COVID,” caught my eye. (see: Dr. James R. Baker, Jr. MD – TheCommonBridge.com ) I wondered if this was an interview with one of America’s Frontline Doctors or someone like that.
I pulled up the Dr. Baker transcript and read it. It took place between the time when the COVID vaccines first came out and before children were eligible for them. Dr. Baker is great! He is articulate and enlightening, and I found him credible.
What explained the difference?
Reading the two transcripts back-to-back made me think about why I was so much more accepting of Dr. Baker than of Dr. Kulldorff. With the written interviews I could review them and compare how they frame decision-making. Below are several aspects of the differences in their approach to problem-solving.
What is the Nature and Depth of the Speaker’s Expertise?
James R. Baker, Jr, MD, is an immunologist. This link gives his education and work experience (James R. Baker, Jr. – Banaszak Holl Group). Briefly, he graduated from the Loyola Stritch College of Medicine and did his residency and fellowship at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center. He has been a professor in the Division of Allergy and Clinical Immunology at the University of Michigan. Among other activities he has been a Co-Chair of the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology’s Vaccines and Biological Threats Committee, a board member of the Region V (Great Lakes) Regional Center of Excellence for Biodefense and Emerging Infectious Diseases and was on active duty with the U.S. Army for 14 years where he was involved in Biodefense.
Martin Kulldorff received his PhD in operations research from Cornell University with a concentration in applied probability and statistics. He has developed statistical methods for early identification of disease outbreaks and for geographical and hospital disease surveillance (SaTScan). His methods are also used by the Vaccine Safety Datalink to identify vaccine safety signals. He is a member of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Drug Safety and Risk Management Advisory Committee, was formerly on the Vaccine Safety Subgroup and was recently appointed chair of the CDC’s Advisory Council on Immunization Practices.
Since both interviews covered actions that should be taken to mitigate the COVID pandemic, Dr. Baker’s expertise is more relevant. Dr. Kulldorff’s expertise is strongest in the timing, location, and frequency of cases. This is important, but doesn’t necessarily tell us what should be done about it.
Does the Speaker Rely on Appeals to Authority?
During his interview Dr. Kulldorff, stated:
Because ever since the beginning [of the pandemic], what the media was talking about – the scientific consensus – were things that we did not agree with. And we have all worked in this area for a long time. Dr. Sunetra Gupta is, in my view, the world’s pre-eminent infectious disease epidemiologist. So somehow other people were listened to, instead of what I thought was the most prominent people.
Various criteria could be used to determine who is the most “pre-eminent” infectious disease epidemiologist. Dr. Kulldorff provided no other details about why he thought Dr. Gupta is the most pre-eminent. I googled “world’s most pre-eminent infectious disease epidemiologist” and searched the archives of an epidemiology newsletter I receive (Epidemiology Monitor). I didn’t get any hits on Dr. Gupta. This doesn’t mean Dr. Gupta isn’t an expert in epidemiology (although her PhD is in biology). It likely indicates the problem of using vague terms when making an assertion, or in using criteria based on what you “think.” Dr. Gupta is a theoretical epidemiologist in the Department of Biology at Oxford University (UK) who uses mathematical models to uncover patterns of diversity in the evolution of pathogens. She has done work in influenza vaccine development. She has also published five novels!
A contemporary name that did pop up under “world’s most pre-eminent infectious disease epidemiologist” is David Heymann, Professor of Infectious Disease Epidemiology at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. Dr. Heymann has experience in responding to outbreaks due to Ebola (1976), SARS (2003), swine flu (2009), MERS (2012), and COVID (2019), among others. He was also on the team that eliminated smallpox through vaccination. (I did not find any interviews or articles from Dr. Heymann where he advocated “focused protection” as a response to COVID-19 or any other pathogen.)
Dr. Baker did not use appeal to authority to support any of his statements. He did mention that he trained under Dr. Anthony Fauci. The context was that Dr. Baker felt that politics needed to be removed from decisions about managing the response to COVID. He referenced a statement Dr. Fauci had made, a.
I mean, Tony Fauci is one of my mentors, I trained under him 40 years ago, they made a statement the other day that he was particularly happy to see Republican senators supporting vaccination. You know, I mean, we can’t make this a Republican and Democratic thing.
Dr. Baker was willing to gently criticize one of his “authority figures.”
Dr. Baker also did not agree with some of the messages that came from the CDC, for example, he questioned the study that was done on 5000 people who attended an event in Provincetown, Massachusetts and which prompted a recommendation that vaccinated people should wear masks. Without getting into the weeds, he was skeptical of the results derived from PCR testing which: 1) doesn’t distinguish between live and dead virus; and 2) amplifies the genetic material 30 million times, making it hard to tell the significance of the finding.
Does the Speaker’s Expertise Expand Exponentially?
I think we all know the answer to this one. Dr. Kulldorff never rejects a label of expertise given to him. He’s a biostatistician, epidemiologist, infectious disease expert, vaccine safety expert, public health expert… you name it (although no one has called him an expert in self-awareness). I would be interested to hear what he has to say about statistical methods that identify the early signs of outbreaks. Other than that, I would need to hear from others with depth of knowledge and experience before accepting his positions on the other topics listed. I say this as someone who has worked for 30 years with physicians from various specialties. I’ve picked up a fair amount of clinical knowledge, but there is no way I should be diagnosing and treating patients.
Dr. Kulldorff:
Another thing is those people who are in their sixties, who are in the working age group, if they can work from home, yes, they should continue to work from home. But if they cannot, I think we have to help protect them so that they can take a sabbatical for three to six months while the transmission is high in society.
I did laugh at this statement. Sure, if you’re a grocery store worker, a truck driver, a nurse, a janitor, etc., just ask your employer for a sabbatical.
Dr. Kulldorff:
We also need to do less rotation of staff in nursing homes so that each doesn’t see too many patients.
Has Dr Kulldorff talked to any nursing home administrators about this? Because this does not sound feasible. (see: State Of The Sector: Nursing Home Labor Staffing Shortages Persist Despite Unprecedented Efforts To Attract More Staff )
The preceding examples show that it can be risky to claim expertise that you don’t have. As an aside, when asked, “To date, what have been the proudest achievements of your distinguished career?” Dr. Heyman replied, “I can’t claim any of those achievements myself because there were always teams involved.” (see: Interview: David Heymann CBE – European Medical Journal).
Dr. Baker’s discussion was very focused on vaccines and vaccine safety, COVID tests, and the circumstances under which masks work and who needs to wear a mask (answer = unvaccinated people). He really hammered on the benefits of getting vaccinated. “If you decide not to get vaccinated then wear a mask.” (a paraphrase) He didn’t say he was an epidemiologist or an expert in child development or mental health or business operations and he didn’t talk about those areas.
Does the Speaker Couch Their Arguments in Absolute Terms?
Dr. Kulldorff often states his positions definitively:
And herd immunity is not some strategy or something controversial because herd immunity is just scientific fact, scientific phenomena that’s proven, and that we will reach [it] sooner or later with this COVID-19, that’s unavoidable.
If true, it sounds like it’s going to be so far, far into the future that we can’t rely on it for near term decision making. Perhaps in a textbook example, with a closed population within a short period of time, herd immunity could be achieved if an infectious disease could penetrate it at a rapid rate. However, most epidemiologists are aware that people travel in and out of populations, children are born, people age, and immunity doesn’t always last. In dynamic populations like that there may be a high enough proportion of immunologically naive people that herd immunity is never achieved. The only disease to which the world has herd immunity is smallpox – achieved through vaccination. (Additionally, I pretty much ignore statements that include “it’s scientific fact.”)
…natural infection is always the best, most effective way to get immunity.
Statements from the previous paragraph apply here as well. What determines whether a strategy is “the best”? From a public health perspective vaccine-induced immunity is more predictable and easier to track (see: Vaccination and natural immunity: Advantages and risks as a matter of public health policy – PMC ) How much “better” is natural immunity than vaccination? Does Dr. Kulldorff feel it is worth it to expose himself to RSV, monkeypox, or tuberculosis so he can have the very best immunity that pathogens can provide?
Dr. Baker is consistent in saying, “based on the data we have now” or “the most recent data that has come out shows…” He states the context that he knows. For example, Richard Helppie asked him about gain of function research. Dr. Baker first noted his relevant experience in this area (he was in the military for 14 years where he was involved in biodefense). He explained what it is, i.e., “A purposeful attempt to engineer something to harm people, and do it in a more efficient way.” He said that one of the ways the U.S. tries to keep tabs on what other countries are doing is to fund some of their research. From what he had seen, the lab at Wuhan was not doing gain of function research, but rather research to better understand how viruses evolve in nature to become better at causing disease in humans. He followed that with, “Now, there may be things there that I’m not aware of.” He also said that nature is much better than humans at gain of function research: “…we were talking about worrying about Gain-of-function engineering, the most effective engineering in the world, is allowing the virus to replicate in hundreds of millions of people.”
Does the Speaker Use Anecdotes to Support Their Statements?
Regular readers of Science-Based Medicine know that anecdotes are not evidence. Dr. Kulldorff states,
I am a native of Sweden so I talked to my brother and sister there, and other people in Sweden, and life is fairly normal.
Presumably this was if you were under the age of 70. What part of Sweden do these people live in? Dr. Kulldorff grew up in Umeå, “close to the Arctic circle.” (see: Dr. Martin Kulldorff Joins Brownstone Institute as Senior Scientific Director ⋆ Brownstone Institute Brownstone Institute). Do his brother and sister live in an outlying town where life might be relatively normal? And surely an epidemiologist and statistician like Dr. Kulldorff would understand the importance of using proper techniques to obtain a representative sample of Swedish citizens. He didn’t select like-minded individuals to talk to, did he?
I didn’t find a similar narrative from Dr. Baker. The closest he came to one is,
…if I’m your doctor, or I’m your, your husband, or your brother, or whatever, I would tell you absolutely get vaccinated, because it’s the right thing to do.
Does the Speaker Make Statements That Make Your Brows Furrow?
My wrinkles will multiply if I read Dr. Kulldorff’s writings too frequently. We have already reviewed “Herd immunity is a scientific fact and unavoidable.” In another case, Dr. Kulldorff was arguing that children rarely transmit COVID to adults. He mentioned “…a very interesting study in Iceland, where they looked at genetics of the virus to see who is actually infecting who – and they found that while parents will often infect children, children will not infect parents very often.” (What about infecting other children, though?)
“Gerrymandering” approach
The context for this statement was Dr. Kulldorff’s assertion that schools should be open so that students could attend in person, and he wanted to demonstrate that teachers were not at risk. This was part of what I would call a “gerrymandering” approach where one starts with the desired conclusion, “Open schools for in person attendance” and then create the constellation of results that support it, i.e., “children don’t transmit COVID to teachers” and “COVID doesn’t make children sick.” The reference isn’t given but this study from Iceland (see: SARS-CoV-2 Infections in Icelandic Children: Close Follow-up of All Confirmed Cases in a Nationwide Study – PMC ) states that
Iceland had the good fortune of having developed very stringent control of infected patients through isolation and quarantine of exposed individuals as well as mass testing of the population—a factor likely to reduce community spread.
This might explain some of the results and certainly doesn’t translate well to the United States.
Dr. Baker’s discussion on the subject of opening schools:
You know, the best way to get everybody back to school and protect every teacher is have every teacher and every adult in those schools vaccinated, just like healthcare workers.
Dr. Kulldorff:
[COVID-19 is] much less dangerous than the annual flu for children.
Since Dr. Kulldorff was interviewed either at the end of 2020 or early in 2021, this time period is most relevant for evaluating this statement. Finding precise data on a comparison is rather difficult. According to CDC Wonder (https://wonder.cdc.gov, accessed 28Sep2025), annual U.S. death rates for the flu (2018-2023) and COVID (2020-2023) for four age groups are given below:
On this basis we would not conclude that COVID-19 is much less dangerous than the annual flu for children. And of course, this does not account for hospitalizations or long-term health consequences due to COVID.
Where did that come from?
Dr. Kulldorff also mentioned:
…a very interesting study from Toronto, Canada. Before the lockdown mortality was the same in all socio-economic groups, but then after lockdowns went in place, the highest socio-economic groups they flattened with the mortality, while the lower socio-economic groups continued to rise until it then eventually came down again because [of] increasing immunity.
Really? The same mortality rate across all socioeconomic groups? That would be unusual. We are not provided with a citation of the study to which Kulldorff refers. This report from Statistics Canada (see: Extent and socioeconomic correlates of small area variations in life expectancy in Canada and the United States ) suggests that life expectancy varied little among socioeconomic groups in Toronto between 2006-2016. Their methods appear to involve crude rates based on annual average death counts per census tract.
On the other hand, the age-standardized mortality rates in this report from Toronto Public Health (see: HSI: All-Cause Mortality and Life Expectancy ) show a clear increasing trend in mortality rate as income declines, over the period 2001-2010. I did not find a source that provided trends in age-standardized mortality rates by socioeconomic indicators in Toronto after the onset of the COVID pandemic (although I didn’t do an extensive search).
Regardless, Dr. Kulldorff’s point related to the above was this:
So we were actually, again in quotation marks, ‘successfully’ protecting the more privileged professional class, shifting the burden on the working class. So that was a ‘success’, and again, in quotation marks, because I think it’s a terrible outcome. So in the same way we can do what the Great Barrington Declaration is arguing for, we should do that separation – instead of by privilege versus working class – we should do it by age, because that’s where the risks are.
His argument for separating and protecting older people has a murky link to the socioeconomic disparities in COVID mortality he’s concerned about. Is he saying people who cannot work from home are all elderly? Or is he saying the “privileged” people who work from home should get off their asses and get back to the office? It seems that if we focus on “protecting the elderly,” the people under age 70 who cannot work from home will still be going to work outside the home and suffering “the burden on the working class.” And if the “privileged” people go back to the office, the people from the “working” classes will potentially have even more exposure to infected individuals.sw
I did not find any statements by Dr. Baker that made me wonder, “Where did that come from?”
Cherry-picking
I note another pattern that is specific to Dr. Kulldorff and not Dr. Baker: apparent cherry-picking of studies whose results fit his wishes. “There was an interesting study ….” I should also note that Dr. Kulldorff’s interview occurred prior to the availability of COVID vaccines, while Dr. Baker’s was afterwards. So it’s possible some of Dr. Kulldorff’s recommendations might have included getting vaccinated. On the other hand, his extolling of “natural immunity” does not assure us of this, nor does getting fired from Harvard for refusing to get vaccinated.
Dr. Baker would mention data that he had reviewed without giving details on the study or a citation. My feeling, and it is a feeling, was to believe him since he was so solid in the rest of his discussion. But it could be something to keep in mind.
Conclusions
So ends the tale of two interviews, one science-based and the other wish-based. Science-based thinking uses observations and the knowledge built by scientific methods to draw inferences. During Dr. Baker’s interview, he used the word “data” 14 times, often in reference to study data to which he had access. Dr. Kulldorff said “data” two times. (Mr. Helppie seems to have been a “control” because he used the word “data” five times during Dr. Baker’s interview and six times during Dr. Kulldorff’s interview.) The wish-based thinker starts with a favored outcome and pastes together a collage of arguments for it. “I wish schools could be open,” therefore, “children don’t get sick from COVID” and “children don’t transmit COVID to adults.”
A wish-based thinker never rejects a study that grants their wish. It’s like finding a pearl in an oyster or that perfect sweater on sale. The science-based thinker understands that studies do not grant wishes, they produce evidence, and the task before them is to evaluate the quality of that evidence. Is it coherent with the solid knowledge we already have? If not, it needs to be damn good evidence that is reproduced by other careful scientists. That’s something for the future and until then, the science-based thinker doesn’t act on it.
The best spin that could be placed on Dr. Kulldorff’s wish-based thinking is that it springs from an aspirational mindset. It would be nice if we didn’t have to close schools, or wear masks during a pandemic. It would be great if those of us who enjoy it could attend crowded social gatherings when a novel virus is spreading through a population. Physicians like Dr. Baker don’t roll the dice with people’s lives. The science-based knowledge and data they use produces the reliable predictions needed for choosing the best response. We can wish that another pandemic won’t come along. But science predicts otherwise, and my money is on science.


Why It’s Worthwhile to Debunk Shivambu
Richard Feynman famously said, “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool”. This is the most important lesson skepticism has to offer.
Jonathan Howard on December 17, 2021
Link

What is Shivambu?
An anti-vaccine doctor I trained with, Dr. Kelly Brogan, recently interviewed a man who claims he cured his cancer by drinking his own urine, a practice called Shivambu. Literally everything about this is sad and disgusting. Though she’s retired from the practice of medicine and is now a full-time guru/online marketer, such balderdash is standard fare for Dr. Brogan and her ilk. However, the point of this article is not to debunk Shivambu, but rather to explain why it may be worth someone’s time to do so.
Obviously, few people reading this article believe that drinking urine cures cancer, and those who believe such folly are unlikely to have their mind changed by it. So other than maybe convincing a few people that Shivambu is nonsense, why bother writing about it?
Several intelligent people have argued that sites like Science Based Medicine are essentially a waste of time (here and here). These critics feel that skeptics do little other than “bashing people outside your tribe, who ignore you.” They claim skeptics are simply “preaching to the converted”, and so accomplish nothing beyond making themselves feel superior. They feel that alternative medicine may be worth discussing only after mainstream medicine has fixed all its flaws and world peace is declared.
I don’t claim to speak on anyone’s behalf, but I think that when skeptics discuss something like Shivambu, their main aim often isn’t to debunk that specific nonsense. Rather, I think most skeptics have several larger goals in mind, and discussions of topics like Shivambu are merely a template for them to make their main points.
The lessons of skepticism part 1: People are seriously hurt and killed by alternative medicine all the time
Having said this, one reason to debunk Shivambu is to debunk Shivambu. Critics of skepticism often portray alternative medicine as ridiculous, but ultimately harmless. “What’s the harm if someone believes crystals ward off disease?” they ask.
While many alternative treatments are harmless, many others are not. People can be harmed directly by alternative therapies or because they used them in lieu of evidence-based treatments. For example, one study found that “After a median of 5 years, patients with breast or colorectal cancer were nearly five times as likely to die if they had used an alternative therapy as their initial treatment than if they had received conventional treatment.” As the pandemic has demonstrated, people are seriously hurt and killed by medical misinformation all the time. Just because war kills more people, doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to save lives in other ways, a flawed line of thought dubbed the fallacy of relative privation.
It’s good when doctors warn people about the dangers of bogus treatments. It’s good when doctors educate people about the benefits of evidence-based treatments. It’s astonishing that this is controversial.
The lessons of skepticism part 2: Some people are persuadable if they are given accurate information in a clear and thorough manner
Additionally, critics of skepticism often infantilize anyone who uses alternative medicine, scornfully treating them all as unreachable naïfs. One such podcasting oncologist said, “You can’t waste all your time arguing with people who do not accept evidence and rationality as a precondition to debate. You’re wasting your time…They’re (skeptics) are not actually successful in converting the minds of different people… You can spend your life arguing with them on all these issues, but you’re not going to achieve any traction.”
This bold claim was made without any evidence, and as tends to be the case with such claims, it is wrong. We can’t reach everyone, but some people are persuadable if they are presented with accurate information in a clear and thorough manner. Even though few Shivambu devotees would have their mind changed by an article here, some might! For example, there are multiple accounts of people deciding to vaccinate their children after learning the facts. It’s a big deal when people are steered away from quackery and towards evidence-based treatments. I am certain that Science Based Medicine has done just that. My friend Amanda said the following in response to this podcaster:
Any defense of skepticism could legitimately end here, and I imagine the long-time writers here would say stories like Amanda’s alone are worth all of their effort.
Beyond this, doctors routinely treat people who use alternative medicine and are wary of evidence-based treatments. Very few of them are as far down the rabbit-hole as Dr. Brogan, and many are open to facts. Doctors need to be able to relate to their patients and help them make wise decisions. We can do this only if we make some minimal effort to understand where they are coming from, especially during a pandemic where millions of people are refusing to be vaccinated. I am very familiar with anti-vaccine disinformation, and I’ve familiarized myself with techniques to help people who are skeptical about vaccines. Hopefully, I’ve helped my patients reject the myths they encounter online, some of them inspired by contrarian doctors I’ve discussed here before. Doctors who thought that learning about alternative medicine was beneath them are likely not as prepared to do this.
I fully agree that skeptics have to be thoughtful in how they discuss these issues. Exposing and mocking Dr. Brogan is appropriate. People need to know that doctors who actually care for patients view her as an object of ridicule. However mocking someone who is genuinely confused about alternative medicine isn’t going to help anyone. As Dr. Steve Novella wrote recently, “ordinary people who believe, use, and even spread false medical beliefs are victims. They do not deserve our condemnation, but our sympathy.” Given that some prominent doctors have spread misinformation, repeatedly minimizing the virus and hyping every vaccine side-effect, it’s not a surprise that many people are legitimately confused about whether or not the vaccine is beneficial for young people (it is). I also agree that skeptics need to be wary of amplifying pseudoscience that would have gone unnoticed otherwise. The best way to refute a lot of nonsense is to ignore it and let it quietly die on its own.
However, I wonder where people like Amanda would be if Dr. Brogan and other members of the Disinformation Dozen had their deluge of disinformation greeted with complete silence by the medical community. If ethical doctors said nothing, the countless grifters, frauds, and quacks would have the internet to themselves, completely unopposed by rational voices.
While this may not be the desired goal of skepticism’s critics, it is the obvious end point to their position. Either they don’t recognize this or don’t care about it. This too is astonishing.
The lessons of skepticism part 3: Skepticism is an allegiance to a method of inquiry rather than any answer
Ideally, a true skeptic would not start out trying to debunk Shivambu. Rather, a true skeptic would realize her preconceived notions could be wrong, even about something that seems as absurd as Shivambu. After all, stool transplants are now the standard of care for treatment-resistant C. difficile infections. As such, our true skeptic would first acknowledge her biases, and she would do her best to investigate Shivambu with an open mind. She’d examine the all the evidence, and she’d report her findings as fairly as possible. If new evidence emerges that contradicts her initial conclusions, she would acknowledge it and adjust her opinion accordingly.
Skepticism then is fundamentally about allegiance to a method of inquiry, not to any final answer. For example, my first article here argued that children should be vaccinated against COVID-19. My second article reported that incidental COVID-19 hospitalizations were common in children, and I’ve since discussed evidence that the pediatric death toll may be inflated, as well as vaccine-related myocarditis. Though the virus remains much more dangerous than the vaccine, these subsequent articles all weakened the case to vaccinate children. However that’s what the evidence showed, and so without any hesitation, I reported it as thoroughly and honestly as possible. I’ve done my best not to overstate the harms of the virus or understate flaws with the vaccine. As an all-around scold, I’ve called out people several times for overstating the harms of COVID-19 to children. I’ve written about my own errors (here and here). My loyalty is to a process, not a result
Because of this, I’ve defended people (here and here) who were not in my “tribe,” and I’ve argued with people who are in my “tribe”. I’m glad they argued back. Of course, skeptics bash quacks like Dr. Brogan, but they also disagree with each other all the time. For example, Dr. Gorski recently called out Richard Dawkins for embracing the lab leak theory based on a shoddy documentary. To the extent I have a “tribe,” it consists of people who are not afraid to thoughtfully call me out when they think I am wrong.
In contrast, pseudoscience vendors like Dr. Brogan start with the answer they want, and work backwards to find the “evidence.” She readily admits this, saying, “It’s time to decide what you believe. And make no mistake, it’s about belief, not about facts, not about science as the final objective.” Anyone and anything that threatens her desired beliefs is wished away as a conspiracy or ignored entirely. Because she defines what is true as what she wants to be true, not only will she never admit error, she essentially feels she’s incapable of being wrong to begin with. There’s literally no evidence or study that would lead Dr. Brogan to change her mind about Shivambu, vaccines, or basically anything at all. That’s a problem, but not one that is unique to Dr. Brogan.
The lessons of skepticism part 4: By understanding the flaws in alternative medicine we can identify flawed medical practices elsewhere
Having learned to evaluate the claims of alternative medicine, the skeptics’ next hope is that they can identify and avoid flawed medical practices elsewhere. Someone who can spot the defects in acupuncture studies published in prestigious medical journals will be prepared to spot defects in wide swaths of medicine. Skepticism’s methods work not just for critical appraisals of Shivambu, but also for problematic drug approvals, useless medical procedures, cancer screening, and flawed research methodologies. Skeptics discuss these topics often, despite what their uninformed critics may claim.
I think my exposure to skepticism, mainly reading Science Based Medicine, helped me be a more thoughtful doctor. For example, at the start of the pandemic, I had one demand when the medicine service asked me to run a COVID-19 team: I would not practice alternative medicine. As I wrote previously,
I also made sure that no patient on my team received any experimental treatments (such as hydroxychloroquine). Doing “nothing” is often very difficult for doctors, but is preferable to giving out unproven treatments unless patients are clearly dying or in a clinical trial.
Though they would have denied it, many doctors were practicing alternative medicine at that time. I understand why. COVID-19 was a horrifying new disease and we were desperate save lives. However, I recognized that doctors who used unproven treatments like hydroxychloroquine were no different than alternative medicine practitioners, and I wanted no part of that. Learning about the flaws in practices like Shivambu helped me make better choices for my patients – at least I hope so – and I suspect fewer doctors would have used dubious treatments early in the pandemic if they had a better understanding of alternative medicine.
The lessons of skepticism part 5: There is no such thing as a harmless alternative treatment
Another core goal of skepticism is to show that while any individual practice in alternative medicine may be harmless, the overall practice of science-denial is not harmless at all. There is a significant price to be paid when a large percentage of the population lacks the basic scientific knowledge and critical thinking skills needed to evaluate the claims of alternative medicine. The same distorted thinking that allows people to believe in Shivambu often leads them to reject evidence-based treatments such as vaccines, something called crank magnetism. The anti-vaccine movement cannot be disentangled from the seemingly benign treatments in alternative medicine. Believing in “harmless” things is harmless until it leads tens of millions of people to reject vaccines and embrace quack therapies in the middle of a raging pandemic.
As such, skeptics would argue that there’s really no such thing as a “harmless” alternative treatment. Anything that weakens people’s ability to think critically about medicine and health is dangerous. Indeed, wellness influencers who promoted crystal-healing and “clean-eating” in 2019 are comparing vaccines to the Holocaust today, an unholy union of noxious beliefs termed conspirituality.
Skeptics are not surprised by any of this, and many sounded the alarm prior to the pandemic. In a conversation from 2019, Dr. Mark Hoofnagle said, “Science communicators have been warning about the dangers of conspiracy theorists for decades now. AGW, antivax, evolution denial – all the same. Here we are. This is what it looks like when conspiracy theorists take over. They are the worst people.” I agreed and added that “the biggest danger to my kids isn’t the measles, but the thought process that leads people to reject the vaccine in the first place.” Little did we know.
In contrast, our pollyannaish podcasting oncologist actually thought not long ago that children’s “risk of covid will decline precipitously” after “all adults are vaccinated“. Only someone with a complete ignorance of the depths of anti-vaccine sentiment in the US would believe that adult vaccination rates would be high enough to obviate the need to vaccinate children. I was under no such illusions, even before the Delta (let alone omicron) variant arrived.
Rachel Moran, who studies medical misinformation, explained the scope of the problem well when she said,
Medical misinformation doesn’t just result in people making bad personal and community health choices, but it also divides communities and families, leaving an emotional toll. Misinformation narratives have real sticking power and impact people’s ability to make safe health choices.
She’s absolutely right. While there are complicated and varied reasons behind vaccine-refusal, at the end of the day, 1,000 Americans are dying daily because they declined a safe and effective vaccine against a deadly virus. Science denial is a leading cause of death right now, and children have died because their parents declined to have them vaccinated against COVID-19. Skepticism’s detractors survey this carnage and are mostly perturbed that someone might use an hour of their free time to debunk Shivambu.
Prior to the pandemic, several doctors mocked skeptics who discussed topics such as Shivambu. They felt it was a waste of time and easy to do, likening it to dunking on a 7-foot hoop. They felt that warning about bogus cancer cures took time away from more urgent, challenging tasks, such as dunking on bad studies on coffee, Dr. Oz and skeptics, I guess.
I fully agree with skepticism’s critics about one thing however; in one sense, it’s extremely easy to debunk Shivambu. A doctor whose priority is to flaunt his research prowess would not tackle this topic. It takes no special abilities to quickly discover the unsurprising fact that there is no evidence drinking one’s own urine cures cancer. I am certain my teenagers could do this.
However, I do not think my children would be able to communicate about Shivambu in a thoughtful manner to a newly diagnosed cancer patient who had stumbled on to Dr. Brogan’s interview. That’s an entirely different skill set. Moreover, my children would not be able to think deeply about the broader implications of Shivambu. They would not be curious as to why some smart people believe drinking urine cures cancer. They would not be able to place Shivambu into the wider context of the rampant science-denial and institutional mistrust in the world today. They would not be able to link Shivambu to 1,000 people dying everyday of a vaccine-preventable disease, to violence in the anti-vaccine movement, or to an anti-vaccine doctor being arrested for her role in the January 6th insurrection. They wouldn’t be able to see it as a symptom of the dangerous world of alternative facts that has enveloped much our culture, including doctors I’ve discussed before. They wouldn’t grasp that a fantasy world where drinking urine cures cancer is also a world where COVID-19 is a hoax that is cured by ivermectin and there’s no reason to get vaccinated.
It’s good that there are doctors who can see these connections and who care enough to push back against the misinformation that creates such delusions.
The lessons of skepticism part 6: We are all in danger of becoming 7-foot hoops
The skeptic’s final goal is to examine the cognitive flaws and distorted thinking that leads smart people to believe that drinking urine can cure cancer. Dr. Brogan went to MIT where she studied systems neuroscience. She then attended Cornell medical school and graduated NYU residency with me. She’s many things, but she’s not stupid, even though she’s come to believe really stupid things. The skeptic’s aim is therefore not to just understand what is wrong with Shivambu, but also to understand what is wrong with Dr. Brogan. And since we all have cognitive biases and blind spots, we need to understand what is wrong with Dr. Brogan to avoid becoming like Dr. Brogan.
Were skepticism’s detractors to read an article debunking Shivambu, they’d merely see it as an article debunking Shivambu and nothing else. I think these concrete-minded critics missed the larger points skeptics were trying to make, and as a result, they missed out on what skepticism has to offer. Put another way, people who think they’re above learning about 7-foot hoops are in danger of becoming 7-foot hoops.
However, skepticism teaches us that we are all in danger of becoming 7-foot hoops. Unfortunately, it’s easy to find examples of smart people who’ve suffered this fate. Just think about Dr. Oz or Dr. Joseph Ladapo. Pseudoscientific treatments are routinely offered by highly-educated doctors at prestigious medical centers, a sad phenomenon dubbed “quackademic medicine“. Doctors who were widely-admired vaccine advocates prior to the pandemic have since repeatedly minimized the virus and mocked those who, rightly, warned about its dangers, calling them prophets of “doom and fear”. Even brilliant Nobel Prize laureates have claimed that vitamin C was a magic cure-all, that HIV doesn’t cause AIDS, that Black people are less intelligent, that COVID-19 vaccines create new variants, and that COVID-19 was much less dangerous than it was made out to be. Like I said, really smart people can believe really stupid (and horrible) things.
Perhaps because they know they are smart, intelligent people may erroneously feel they are less vulnerable to biased thinking than everyone else. This is itself a bias, one that skeptics are keenly aware of. Almost all skeptics enjoy optical illusions and magic. They love learning how easily we can be fooled, and how we are often completely unaware of it. Dr. Novella called awareness of these vulnerabilities neuropsychological humility and defined it thusly:
Being a functional skeptic requires knowledge of all the various ways in which we deceive ourselves, the limits and flaws in human perception and memory, the inherent biases and fallacies in cognition, and the methods that can help mitigate all these flaws and biases.
Given that no one is immune from biased thinking, we all need to be open to the possibility that we could be wrong. Psychologist Adam Grant shared two wise thoughts on this theme recently.
The hallmark of an open mind is not letting your ideas become your identity. If you define yourself by your opinions, questioning them is a threat to your integrity. If you see yourself as a curious person or a lifelong learner, changing your mind is a moment of growth
It takes humility to consider information that contradicts your opinions. You’re willing to concede that you might be wrong. It takes curiosity to actively seek evidence that challenges your views. You’re eager to find out if you might be wrong.
He’s right. Just because I sanctimoniously boasted that “My loyalty is to a process, not a result” doesn’t mean I’m actually good at that process. I know I’ve fallen short at times.
We all need to be humble and listen to our well-meaning critics. Oftentimes only they can show us our errors. It’s a serious mistake to insulate yourself in an echo chamber of sycophants, dreaming you are persecuted whenever you are contradicted. Oddly enough, Dr. Brogan was on to something – it is very easy to let your beliefs replace facts and science, especially when these beliefs lead to financial rewards, TV appearances, and social media adulation. We all need to be continuously on guard against this.
Richard Feynman famously said, “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool.” This is the most important lesson skepticism has to offer.
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 1
Sadly, several contrarian doctors haven’t grasped skepticism’s lessons, and so they seem to have fallen into the same cognitive traps as Dr. Brogan. They have an almost petulant need to be different, no matter the evidence. One Twitter commentator wryly called this “obligate contrarianism: The need to be contradictory no matter what the mainstream stance is”.
They are hostile to criticism, claiming that anyone who challenges them is trying to “quiet” them. They conflate criticisms of their ideas with personal attacks, and so instead of engaging with those who disagree with them, they ask to be left alone. They brush off all who disagree with them with unsubstantiated accusations of “tribalism” and “groupthink.” They rarely, if ever, admit error, and most tolerate only fawning lickspittles on social media. They mock people who fear or warn of the virus, implying that life is passing them by or that they are addicted to doom and being on TV. Many have repeatedly declared the pandemic over, though they continue to talk about it constantly. They have a shared sense of grievance, believing they are the real victims of this pandemic because YouTube removed some of their videos – and boy do some of them make a lot of videos. At the risk of sounding like a conspiracy theorist myself, several have connections to shady right-wing think tanks.
Like Dr. Brogan, several contrarians started the pandemic with the belief that COVID-19’s harms were greatly exaggerated (here and here), and they’ve spent the past 20 months floundering to justify this initial, flawed premise. One contrarian has peddled identical conspiracy theories as Dr. Brogan, claiming that death certificates have been unreliable this pandemic (in direct contradiction to the evidence), and the COVID-19 death toll is inflated. He wants you to believe many people died with COVID-19, not from COVID-19 and that healthcare workers have perverse financial incentives to put COVID-19 on death certificates. Even worse than this, he repeatedly claimed, again in direct contradiction to the evidence, that doctors killed patients by intubating them too quickly. All this to avoid saying, “I underestimated COVID-19”.
He is not alone. Another noted early in the summer that “cases are FALLING PRECIPITOUSLY” and that for children, “COVID and MIS-C is plummeting with adult vaccination“. He used these numbers to justify his belief that children should not be vaccinated against COVID-19. When cases were at their nadir, he wrote a lengthy piece criticizing the CDC for using outdated numbers when modeling the benefits of the vaccine for adolescents. He called this a “noble lie”. However, when pediatric cases and hospitalizations spiked to their highest levels soon thereafter, he then said that hospitals “admit less sick patients” to for financial gain. Rather than admit that he too had underestimated the virus, he claimed the number of patients hospitalized with COVID-19 is an “inaccurate” metric and is instead merely a “fear monger tactic”. Beyond this, he fantasized that public health measures to contain a virus could one day lead to totalitarianism.
Dr. Brogan wouldn’t object to any of this. She believes the entire pandemic is a fear monger tactic for profit, and that totalitarianism has already arrived, saying COVID-19 was planned for the “entrapment of citizens worldwide.” Their combined message is: Don’t believe news reports of overwhelmed hospitals. Don’t believe what doctors in the trenches are saying. They are out to deceive and scare you for profit. Only I will tell you the truth. Purchase a subscription to my newsletter/online course or pay my speaking fees to gain access to my unique insights.
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 2
Nowhere is the overlap between contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan more complete, however, than their shared stance on the risk of COVID-19 to children and whether or not they should be protected against it. There’s no question these contrarian doctors have more in common with her than with the American Academy of Pediatrics, the CDC, and almost every practicing pediatrician in this regard. That says a lot considering Dr. Brogan is a germ-theory denier who does not believe HIV causes AIDS, that SARS-CoV-2 causes COVID-19, or that we are experiencing “a real medical pandemic“.
However, these contrarians and Dr. Brogan all agree that COVID-19 poses minimal-to-no threat to young people and measures to protect them against the virus will likely do more harm than good. They felt this spring that children should not get the COVID-19 vaccine. Once adolescents started getting vaccinated, they felt that “the US should suspend all vaccination in children under 18“. They agreed that “the downsides of masking young students are real“. They agreed that “Children should return to their normal lives this summer and in the upcoming school year, without masks and regardless of their vaccination status“. It’s no surprise that their ideas get favorably shared (here and here) by anti-vaccine cranks like RFK Jr., who posted an article by some of these doctors arguing against the Emergency Use Authorization of the COVID-19 vaccine for most children. Thank goodness no one with real power took that idea seriously.
Highly credentialed doctors from Stanford and Harvard penned Broganesque articles such as “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“. This article opened by saying:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
That’s right. These doctors believe the idea of nobody getting vaccinated is better for public health than the idea of everybody getting vaccinated. In the middle of the worst pandemic since 1918, these doctors feel that vaccine-advocates are a greater menace to public health than anti-vaxxers. I’m curious to know what they think the folks at Voices for Vaccines might do that would lead to over 1,000 Americans dying every day for months at a time. That’s the toll of the anti-vaccine movement at present. What great evil do they think Karen Ernst is capable of? She’s always seemed nice to me.
This article also claimed that mandating the vaccine for young people “threatens not only public health but also the future of science“. Elsewhere, one of the authors even spread the absurd myth that vaccine mandates will actually spread the virus. These histrionic, preposterous statements seem plagiarized from the most deranged anti-vaccine websites. Not surprisingly, Dr. Brogan also opposes ‘public health measures imposed in violation of bodily sovereignty (for example, mandated vaccination in exchange for “privileges” which may actually be inalienable rights)’.
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 3
By the time this article was published, hundreds of American children had already died of COVID-19 and many thousands more had been hospitalized. Though I agree that the virus poses an “extremely low” mortality risk for children, millions more children contracted the virus after this article was published, and so hundreds more children died, including some without underlying conditions. Young adults suffered even more. According to the CDC’s Covid Data Tracker, just under 6,000 Americans younger than 29 years have died of COVID-19 thus far, including over 1,000 children. All of these young people died from the virus, not the vaccine.
Tens of thousands more children and young adults have been hospitalized. Though they thankfully survived, many were very sick, needing ICU-level care and mechanical ventilation. Some pediatric COVID-19 survivors suffered strokes or encephalitis. Others needed lung transplants or amputations. Their lives will never be the same. 5,973 children have had MIS-C thus far, though this may be a substantial undercount. In one study, 80% of children with MIS-C went to the ICU and 20% needed mechanical ventilation. 52 children have died of MIS-C. Nearly all these tragedies occurred in unvaccinated people, many after the vaccine was widely available. Thankfully, these tragedies remain very rare. Almost all young people with COVID-19 will be fine.
Fortunately, the vaccine has proven highly effective in keeping adolescents alive and out of the hospital. Hospitals were deluged with children suffering from COVID-19, not side effects from the vaccine. One study found that “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents”. Another study of adolescents showed the efficacy of the vaccine in this age group. It found:
Among 179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.
There’s good news about vaccine-safety as well. Over 7 million doses have been given to children ages 5-11 years, including over 2 million second-doses, and there have been only 8 verified reports of myocarditis so far with 6 more cases under investigation.
In addition to this, evidence continues to accumulate that almost all young people with vaccine-myocarditis have a “mild” course and recover well. Dr. Dongngan T. Truong, who authored a large case series on the topic said “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly”, though he acknowledged “we are awaiting further studies to better understand the long-term outcomes of patients who have had COVID-19 vaccination-related myocarditis”. The Pfizer vaccine seems safer than the Moderna vaccine for young men, as does using a longer interval between the two vaccine doses. With this knowledge, it’s possible to take a low-risk event and make it even lower. I am aware of literally just one death of a young person (a 22-year-old) in the entire world from the mRNA vaccines. There’s no question that the vaccine is safer than the virus for young people.
Neither Dr. Brogan nor these contrarian doctors want you to know or even believe any of this. Since they only report information that bolsters their preconceived notions, they will never mention most of these facts. If you encounter accurate information elsewhere about pediatric hospitals being overwhelmed with COVID-19 cases, they’ll claim they the numbers are a “fear monger tactic”. If you believe the numbers, they’ll claim that COVID-19 can’t be that bad for kids because it’s worse elderly people (true, but irrelevant), that more children die of suicide (true, but irrelevant), that the flu is worse (false), and that it’s only children with leukemia who are dying (false and repellent). Others have “wondered” whether incompetent pediatricians were misdiagnosing RSV as COVID-19 (they weren’t). Several doctors simply spread wrong blatantly wrong numbers, always minimizing COVID-19’s impact on children, of course. I’ve even seen some contrarians claim that hundreds of dead children from COVID-19 can’t be that bad, because after all, there are 74 million kids in the USA.
What is so different about COVID-19 that makes it so easy for these doctors to brush off the deaths of children? Though almost all children with COVID-19 do well, enough of them have contracted the virus to make it a leading cause of pediatric deaths this year. These tragedies can now be prevented with a vaccine. Imagine if we could prevent suicides, accidents, and drownings with a vaccine. We’d do it, right? However, beyond magically isolating themselves from older people, these doctors don’t want most children to do anything to prevent COVID-19 – no masks, no vaccines, no testing, nothing. Meanwhile, the American Academy of Pediatrics keeps adding 2-3 deaths per day to its grim tally.
Imagine the outrage there’d be if a doctor tried to diminish the tragedies of pediatric cancer the way pediatric COVID-19 deaths are routinely minimized. Imagine if after the next school shooting some doctor pointed out that 99.999% of children won’t die this way, so we shouldn’t do anything to try to prevent these tragedies. Maybe more people need to read about the individual children who have died of COVID-19 (Skylar Herbert, Tagan White, Kimora Lynum, Wyatt Gibson, Zyrin Foots). These were real lives, cut tragically short, not just numbers in a CDC dataset. Their deaths shouldn’t be diminished just because their grandparents were statistically more likely to die. Again, what makes 1,000 pediatric COVID-19 deaths so uniquely tolerable, especially considering the only unique thing about them is they can be now prevented with a vaccine?
Though they claim to be “pro-vaccine“, it seems these contrarians will do anything to avoid acknowledging an obvious truth: COVID-19 can be a devastating, even fatal, disease for a very small percentage of young people, and the vaccine can prevent these tragic outcomes. In contrast, they are extremely eager to discuss vaccine side effects. One doctor even repeatedly mentioned post-vaccination fevers as a reason not to vaccinate children. Just a few short months ago, doctors were arguing in a still unpublished pre-print that the vaccine could cause more harm than the virus for adolescent boys. It’s likely that the number of times they’ve collectively mentioned vaccine-related myocarditis (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here) exceeds the number of children currently hospitalized with the condition. However, since vaccine-related myocarditis almost always has a very favorable clinical course, they are generally only willing to discuss the frequency at which this condition occurs. One doctor even used the death of that single 22-year-old to argue the vaccine could kill as many children as the virus. Studies showing the vaccine’s significant benefits for adolescents are, of course, completely unmentionable.
Because their loyalty is to a result, not a process, these doctors have consistently refused to enumerate the harms of the virus and the benefits of the vaccine. As a result, their writing on COVID-19 and children is uniformly uninformative and devoid of nuance, especially compared to the work of doctors familiar with skepticism and critical thinking. After the Delta variant hospitalized many thousands of children and killed hundreds of them, some contrarians belatedly altered their blanket opposition to vaccinating children, though they did so without acknowledging their previous stance and what role this vocal opposition might have had in creating significant vaccine-hesitancy in parents. However, as with Dr. Brogan, there’s literally no evidence or study that would lead these doctors to conclude it was a mistake to have left tens of millions of young people vulnerable to COVID-19.
After all, if the deaths of thousands of young people, including 1,000 children, doesn’t give them pause, what possibly could?
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 4
Though Dr. Brogan and these contrarians have little credibility in the medical community, like alternative treatments, they are not harmless. They have stellar credentials. They all have large audiences. People listen to what they say. They speak without a trace of doubt. They can easily speak in scientific jargon, misrepresenting information to make dangerous ideas sound reasonable to those who are ignorant of the facts.
Their conviction that it was preferable to leave young people vulnerable to COVID-19 convinced politicians like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis to let the virus rip through young people in his state. Dr. Brogan has had more impact at the local level in that state as she influences anti-vaccine schools in Miami. Thanks in part to their combined efforts, children’s hospitals were overwhelmed at the end of this summer. Some children died, including healthy teens who were eligible to be vaccinated. Their ideology also seems to have influenced the UK’s response to vaccinating children, with disastrous consequences I discussed previously.
The doctors are all generally sheltered from the consequences of their words. Dr. Brogan has never cared for a patient hospitalized with COVID-19, and neither have most contrarians. They’ll likely never see a young person gasping for air, regretting their decision not to get vaccinated. The pandemic exists entirely on a computer screen for most of them. Despite this, they remain defiantly proud of their efforts, calling Florida a “success“. It’s frightening to contemplate, but their influence may grow significantly if the political winds blow their way.
I was friendly with Dr. Brogan during her time at NYU. It wasn’t until after she graduated that she decided to reject “facts” and “science as the final objective”. I similarly admired some of these contrarian doctors before the pandemic. Like Dr. Brogan, they aren’t stupid. It’s certainly sad they’ve come to share many of her beliefs on COVID-19 and children. COVID-19 will fade into the background one day, and these contrarians will be remembered only for their poor predictions, vaccine fear mongering, and relentless minimization of virus that was benign for most young people, but because it was encouraged to spread so widely, managed to kill thousands of them and injure many thousands more.
        ◦ Who knows? Maybe they could have avoided this sad fate if only they hadn’t thought it was beneath them to debunk Shivambu.

Dr. Kelly Brogan Wakes Up to the “Ball Earth Hoax”. What Does This Reveal About Prominent Professors From Prominent Medical Schools?
What did I mean when I said Dr. Kelly Brogan “won the pandemic”?
Jonathan Howard on February 9, 2024
Link

In a previous essay, I discussed the term audience capture, which is defined as “a self-reinforcing feedback loop that involves telling one’s audience what they want to hear and getting rewarded for it”. I specifically discussed how pre-pandemic, anti-vaccine doctors were forced to follow their followers, leading them to take more extreme positions to maintain their relevance. I wrote:
Over the ensuing decade, I observed something interesting about the anti-vaccine movement. When I first encountered it, anti-vaccine influencers could gain attention by claiming vaccines caused autism. That was once cool and edgy. After a few years, however, this bogus claim was merely the price of entry into Anti-Vaxx World. Since there was nothing to be gained by merely saying vaccines caused autism, in order to gain attention, anti-vaccine influencers like Dr. Kelly Brogan were forced to blame vaccines for all manners of maladies, such as the “epidemic” of SIDS (even though SIDS rates have decreased markedly). Other anti-vaccine doctors compared vaccines to rape, and RFK Jr. compared vaccinations to the Holocaust. Attacking pediatricians became commonplace….
Simply saying vaccines cause autism just doesn’t cut it for anti-vaccine influencer in 2022 the way it did in 2000. In order to get continue to get clicks and customers, anti-vaccine doctors had to continually escalate their rhetoric and above all, never stop being controversial.
With this in mind, I decided to check in my old friend Dr. Kelly Brogan, a pre-pandemic, anti-vaccine celebrity and American Loon #1422. Events have forced her to take a rather dramatic turn in her unending quest to never stop being “controversial”. Not long ago, she posted the following:
I sat with Dr. Amandha Vollmer to discuss connected cosmology. We get into why waking up is hard to do and why the shape of the earth even matters
In the interview, Dr. Brogan denied germ theory and Dr. Amandha Vollmer, a naturopath, said:
The ball earth hoax is important. It means you can better understand this place, and stay away from the liars and hoaxers and conmen.
How nice of Dr. Vollmer, a self-described “alchemist” at YumNaturals Emporium, and Dr. Brogan, who sells her Vital Mind Reset course for $3,000 amongst other products, to warn us about liars and hoaxers and conmen.
So why is Dr. Brogan “waking up” to “the ball earth hoax” today? To answer this question, it is important to remember what used to qualified as “controversial”, what previously got her clicks and customers. Prior to the pandemic, she wrote an essay titled Vaccination: Your Body. Your Baby. Their Flu in which she said:
This better way embraces periodic sickness as part of comprehensive wellness. The only way to truly protect ourselves and our infants is through natural immunity bolstered by wild-type exposure in the community. Once you have a particular flu strain, when it comes around again, you will be uniquely protected, and you will pass on this protection to your newborn. There is no replacement for this.
Once upon a time, this was “controversial” and responsible doctors recognized that doctors who said such nonsense were “quacks.”
Things have changed.
Dr. Brogan wouldn’t be the least bit “controversial” writing that paragraph now. It’s utterly mundane and conventional. Today, that sentiment is expressed by prominent professors from prominent medical schools in the mainstream media. For example, during the pandemic, a UCSF professor wrote an article titled Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?, which hit many Broganesque notes. It said:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger… Immunity is built through illness.
This pro-virus advocacy even appeared in prominent medical journals. In 2021, doctors from Emory and Pennsylvania State University wrote in the BMJ: 
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood… This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
More examples of such mimicry abound.
    • The article The Flimsy Evidence Behind the CDC’s Push to Vaccinate Children, which was written during the pandemic by a professor at Johns Hopkins, sounded many of the same themes as Dr. Brogan’s pre-pandemic article, CDC: You’re Fired. Autism Coverup Exposed.
    • The article The Triumph of Natural Immunity, which was written during the pandemic by a professor at Harvard, sounded many of the same themes as Dr. Brogan’s pre-pandemic article, HPV Vaccine Maker’s Study Proves Natural HPV Infection Beneficial, Not Deadly.
    • The article Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect, Not Absolutism, which was written during the pandemic by a cardiologist at Medscape, sounded many of the same themes as Dr. Brogan’s pre-pandemic article, Could This be Driving the Epidemic of Sudden Infant Death (SIDS)?.
    • The article The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young, which was written during the pandemic by professors at Stanford and Harvard, sounded many of the same themes as Dr. Brogan’s pre-pandemic article, The New Gardasil: Is It Right For Your Daughter?
This is what I meant when I said on the Conspirituality Podcast that Dr. Brogan “won the pandemic.”
Had there been no pandemic, I am confident Dr. Brogan could have remained “controversial” spreading her familiar rubbish about the flu, measles, and HPV vaccines. I doubt she would feel compelled to wake up to “the ball earth hoax” today. However, there was a pandemic, doctors co-opted her message, and there’s nothing to be gained for someone like her to occupy the same space as prominent professors from prominent medical schools.
All this is worth thinking about, not because of what it reveals about Dr. Brogan, but rather because of what it reveals about prominent professors from prominent medical schools.

Why Are Sensible Medicine Doctors Indifferent to the Nonsense Comments of Sensible Medicine Commentators? As Instructed, I Consider the Dualities of Interest and Motivating Biases.
Sensible Medicine doctors often utter the words “do an RCT”. So why are their readers so ignorant about RCTs?
Jonathan Howard on January 28, 2024
Link
“Conflicts of interest are an ongoing threat to medical practice.”
In their must-read article, Subscription Science: How Crowdfunding Has Become a Conflict of Interest, Drs. Benjamin Mazer, Michael Rose wrote that “Conflicts of interest are an ongoing threat to medical practice.” They further noted that:
Digital platforms such as Patreon, Substack, YouTube, and Twitter allow fans to offer recurring payments to healthcare professionals who produce opinion articles, explanatory videos, and podcasts… Substack, an online newsletter platform, is increasingly used by physicians to write medical commentary, with some newsletters reaching 10s of thousands of subscribers. Substack estimates that 5-10% of readers will upgrade to a paid tier, and paid subscriptions on the service cost a minimum of $5 per month. Although $5 sounds negligible, consider a newsletter with 10,000 total subscribers, 1000 of whom pay a $5 monthly fee. After subtracting Substack’s 10% cut, a doctor could expect $54,000 in annual payments. If physicians accrue 5000 backers, they can expect $270,000 in revenue. This is greater than the $265,000 average salary of primary care physicians in the US.
“Is a ‘model’ more believable than a double blinded, randomized, placebo-controlled study, with an N of 80,000?“
With this in mind, let’s revisit an article titled Not the Way to Pull Vaccines Back from a “Dangerous Tipping Point by Dr. Adam Cifu, a “medical conservative” and founder of Sensible Medicine, a Substack with 75,000 subscribers and 3 payment models.
Becoming a “Founding Member” for $250 per year
To his credit, Dr. Cifu wrote, “I am convinced of the safety of the COVID vaccine and know that the initial series saved millions of lives.” Dr. Cifu linked to a modeling study that concluded:
From December 2020 through November 2022, we estimate that the COVID-19 vaccination program in the U.S. prevented more than 18.5 million additional hospitalizations and 3.2 million additional deaths. Without vaccination, there would have been nearly 120 million more COVID-19 infections. The vaccination program also saved the U.S. $1.15 trillion (Credible Interval: $1.10 trillion–$1.19 trillion) (data not shown) in medical costs that would otherwise have been incurred.
Of course, we’ll never know exactly how many lives the COVID vaccines saved. We don’t have an Earth 2.0 where we can rerun the pandemic without them, and thus we need modeling studies to estimate their benefit. This situation is obviously not unique to vaccines. Modeling studies are needed to estimate the benefits of seat belts, for example.
Unsurprisingly, Sensible Medicine readers were unimpressed with this modeling study. They have been taught to reject all studies unless they are randomized controlled trials (RCTs)- “observational data has been used to support vaccines, but is plagued by confounding” – or they show potential vaccine harms. Indeed, one of the most liked comments on Dr. Cifu’s article said:
“know that the initial series saved millions of lives”.
The study you linked to is a model that claims:
“U.S. has administered more than 655 million doses”, “U.S. prevented more than 18.5 million additional hospitalizations and 3.2 million additional deaths.”
Let’s do a back of the envelope calculation. 655,000,000/3,200,000 = 204.6. That’s one life saved for every 205 doses. 655,000,000/18,500,000 = 35. That’s one less hospitalization for every 35 doses.
Add the two clinical trials together (Moderna, Pfizer). ~80,000 doses. 80,000/205 = 390,
80,000/35 = 2285. This predicts that we should have seen about 390 more deaths and 2285 more hospitalizations in the placebo group of the combined studies– but we saw no statistically significant reduction of death or hospitalization in these studies.
What was significant in the Pfizer study: -29 severe Covid events, +112 severe vaccine events. Looks like a net loss to me.
Is a ‘model’ more believable than a double blinded, randomized, placebo-controlled study, with an N of 80,000?
“The numbers are already cooked,” added another typical Sensible Medicine commentator in agreement.
“The primary analysis will be performed when approximately 151 cases have been observed in the study”.
Is this commentator correct? No, he is not.
The Sensible Medicine commentator fundamentally misunderstood how the COVID vaccine RCTs were structured. Perhaps if this person had been reading Science Based Medicine instead, they’d already know the COVID vaccine RCTs were designed to end when a small number of people contracted COVID. According to the Moderna protocol, “The primary analysis will be performed when approximately 151 cases have been observed in the study”. The Pfizer protocol set “a target of 164 primary-endpoint cases of confirmed Covid-19”. The Sensible Medicine commentator would have been sensible had all 80,000 people in the RCTs contracted COVID, but by design the trials concluded before the virus was allowed to harm more than several hundred people, 347 as it turned out.
The results were pretty impressive.
    • In the Pfizer RCT, 21,720 people received the vaccine and 21,728 received placebo. There were 162 COVID cases in the placebo group and 8 in the vaccine group. There were 10 cases of severe COVID-19, 9 of which were in the placebo group, 1 the vaccine group.
    • In the Moderna RCT, there were 15,210 participants in the vaccine and placebo groups. Symptomatic COVID occurred in 185 participants in the placebo group and in 11 participants in the vaccine group. Severe COVID occurred in 30 participants, with one fatality, all in the placebo group.
Incredibly, according to this typical Sensible Medicine commentator, these results looked “like a net loss” for the vaccine.
“Motivating biases need not be considered nefarious, only considered.”
I am not responsible for the comments on my writing and neither is Dr. Cifu. However, the people who take the time to respond to us reflect on us in some way, and our response to them, or our decision not to respond, reflects on us entirely. Though it happens rarely and I don’t see everything, if I spotted a ridiculous comment like that on one of my articles, I’d damn well correct it, assuming one of our astute readers had not done so already. I don’t want my writing to be a vehicle for people to spread anti-vaccine nonsense about RCTs. Part of being pro-RCT is correcting misinformation about actual RCTs, especially in spaces where one has some control and authority.
In contrast, Sensible Medicine doctors said nothing. They’ve said “do an RCT” countless times, but can’t be bothered to educate their readers about the RCTs that have actually been done. Given their purported admiration for RCTs, don’t you think they have an obligation to teach their misinformed readers about the basics of how the actual COVID vaccine-RCTs were designed and how they should be interpreted?
I do.
It’s revealing they haven’t done so already. As Dr. David Gorksi and I have discussed many times (here, here, here, here) these doctors performatively fetishize RCTs not to advance actual RCTs or to educate their readers about RCTs, but rather to stoke anger and foster mistrust. The ignorance of their commentators shows the predictable result.
Beyond this, Sensible Medicine readers must pay a fee to comment. Not only does this business model foster an echo-chamber of groupthink, it also creates dualities of interest and and motivating biases for Sensible Medicine doctors. After all, correcting commentators risks offending paying customers, even those who spread blatant falsities about precious, glorious, hallowed RCTs.
It’s entirely possible this financial incentive plays no role in refusal of of Sensible Medicine doctors to call out nonsense from their commentators, especially considering their own copious misinformation. However, I’m perfectly willing to follow the wise instructions they provided in their foundational paper, The Case for Being a Medical Conservative:
Dualities of interest must be considered in determining the quality of evidence…The medical conservative, therefore, is pragmatic about human nature and the prevailing business model of medical science. To wit, content experts, professional societies, or journal editors who too harshly criticize an industry product jeopardize future funding. Motivating biases need not be considered nefarious, only considered.
If you think I’m wrong for considering these dualities of interest and motivating biases, let me know. Everyone is welcome to comment here, and it won’t cost you a penny.

“New school” antivax goes old school as Byram Bridle asks if COVID-19 vaccines will drive an “epidemic” of autism
Wakefield redux? Antivax scientist Byram Bridle just took the “new school” antivax movement old school by implying that COVID-19 vaccines might cause an “epidemic of autism.” Everything old is new again, sort of.
David Gorski on January 22, 2024
Tweet

Sometimes there are topics that just demand that I write about them. So it was over the weekend, as I was perusing my usual sources looking for suitable topics to write about today and found one that grabbed my attention to the point where I immediately knew that I had to abandon the topic that I had already tentatively chosen for today, putting it off for another day (or perhaps my not-so-secret other blog) and focusing on this. I will freely admit that part of the reason I knew I had to write about this was because it so clearly vindicated what for me had started out as a bit of a quip that I had started repeating in the early months after the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines from Pfizer and Moderna first rolled out in those heady days of early 2021, namely that the only reason antivaxxers weren’t claiming that COVID-19 vaccines could cause autism was because they were not being administered to young children. As the age range for the COVID-19 vaccines got younger and younger, I predicted that antivaxxers would soon be blaming them for autism, but that it might take a few years because autism spectrum disorders are usually not diagnosed until a child is around 3 years old and the characteristic behaviors start to manifest themselves to the point where the parents become concerned. Leave it to Byram Bridle to vindicate my prediction with a post over the weekend on his Substack entitled Will COVID-19 Shots Drive an Epidemic of Autism?, albeit not in the way that I expected. He did, however, echo a common variant of an old antivax claim that vaccines cause autism by adding the blurb If Yes, Those Who Coerced Pregnant Women to Take modRNA Shots Will Be Responsible For It.
It all very much reminded me of something I said on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, the other day:
Byram Bridle returns! (He never really went away)
You might remember Dr. Byram Bridle, associate professor and viral immunologist in the Department of Pathobiology in the Ontario Veterinary College at the University of Guelph, from the early days of the COVID-19 vaccine rollout nearly three years ago. I first wrote about him in June 2021, when he claimed to have “discovered” a “secret” Japanese study that showed that the Pfizer vaccine’s biodistribution included the ovaries (among other organs), ignoring the facts that the study was not “secret” and was a fairly standard biodistribution study in which huge doses of the vaccine were injected intravenously in mice in order to determine where the drug might go, no matter how small the quantities. (Remember, vaccines are not injected directly into the bloodstream, much less at doses anywhere near what the study used.)
At the time, I also took note of Dr. Bridle for videos like this:
Basically, Dr. Bridle (mis)represented himself as a “provaccine” scientist who made this startling admission (tellingly, quoted by Mike Adams):
In short, the conclusion is we made a big mistake. We didn’t realize it until now. We saw the spike protein was a great target antigen. We never knew the spike protein, itself, was a toxin and was a pathogenic protein. So, by vaccinating people, we are inadvertently inoculating them with a toxin, and in some people this gets into circulation. And when that happens in some people, it can cause damage, especially with the cardiovascular system. I don’t have time, but many other legitimate questions about the long-term safety there for this vaccine. For example, with accumulating in the ovaries, one of my questions is, “will we be rendering young people infertile, some of them infertile?” So, I’ll stop there.
Yep, it’s the “vaccines are going to sterilize our womenfolk” gambit all over again, an antivax gambit that started right around the time that COVID-19 vaccines were granted emergency use authorization (EUA) in December 2020. It’s a very old antivax trope that dates back decades, which is why I was not surprised to see it rear its ugly head again applied to the new mRNA-based vaccines. How old is it? Well, as a matter of coincidence, a peer-reviewed article co-authored by Tara Smith and me accepted for publication in Vaccine just hit the journal’s website late last week. (That’s the first good thing that’s happened to me in 2024.) In the article, we discuss how this trope goes back at least to the 1990s and why it’s a nonsensical conspiracy theory.
But back to Dr. Bridle, given that this time he is not fear mongering about COVID-19 vaccines “sterilizing the womenfolk.” During the last three years, he has diversified his antivax propaganda; for instance, by sarcastically fear mongering about mRNA in breast milk, credulously accusing “Them” of “suppressing” data supposedly showing that ivermectin works against COVID-19 (it doesn’t), parroting the antivax line about “adulteration” of mRNA-based vaccines with plasmid DNA (which is a big nothingburger), and showing up at all sorts of conspiracy theorist antivax conferences and panels. Basically, as much as he claims to be “not antivax,” by his words and actions Dr. Bridle has demonstrated himself to be very much antivax indeed, right up to amusingly whining about how provaccine scientists (like Timothy Caulfield) and advocates “won’t debate him.”
COVID-19 vaccines and autism?
Based on his history, it should come a surprise to no one that Dr. Bridle finds a study done in rats very persuasive support for the contention that prenatal exposure to COVID-19 vaccines will cause autism. It should also come as no surprise given the long history (some of which I myself have documented here) of antivax scientists doing dubious studies of vaccines or vaccine ingredients, like the mercury-containing preservative thimerosal back in the day when thimerosal-containing vaccines were demonized as The One True Vaccine Cause of Autism, at least here in the US. Dr. Bridle’s post also reminded me of a number studies cited by antivaxxers to claim that “immune activation” due to prenatal exposure to, say, Tdap vaccines during pregnancy can hugely increase the risk of autism in the child after birth. (They don’t.) So, right off the bat, we know that Dr. Bridle is resurrecting old antivax misinformation and just applying it to COVID-19 vaccines.
Let’s look at his “concerns” about the study before I discuss the study itself, to see how the study is being spun:
I just finished reading a peer-reviewed scientific article that has been electronically published ahead of the print version. The findings have caused me considerable concern. The paper is entitled “Prenatal Exposure to COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Induces Autism-Like Behaviors in Male Neonatal Rats: Insights into WNT and BDNF Signaling Perturbations“.
Of course, the findings caused Dr. Bridle “considerable concern.” He’s antivax, which leads him to this statement:
Sadly, we should have had this comprehensive understanding and then conducted a fully informed risk-benefit analysis before hundreds of thousands of pregnant women were inoculated. But, maybe that is just my crazy way of thinking.
Funny how antivaxxers will seize upon a single study in rats as reason for incredible concern and ignore the clinical data that we have from huge numbers of people vaccinated during pregnancy whose sum total has failed to find evidence adverse maternal or fetal effects from vaccinating pregnant individuals with the COVID-19 vaccine but has produced a growing body of data demonstrates the safety of such use. (There’s even data that the vaccine administered during pregnancy might provide some immunity to the baby as well.) Yeah, a single rat study is going to overturn all that clinical data, because…reasons.
Yes, Dr. Bridle airily dismisses all the existing evidence thusly:
The published studies looking at this have largely been flawed and biased. Ever-emerging evidence proves that the harms of the shots have been substantially underestimated in all people. The only question is by how much? Worse, the studies done during pregnancy have focused most heavily on the women, and less so on the babies. In many cases, babies were followed for only a hand-full of weeks following their birth. This is much too short. And evaluations of these babies have been overly superficial. A classic trick when it comes to the research and development of novel medical interventions is this: one can make a product appear quite safe if one does not look very hard for harms.
Got that? That’s standard antivax conspiracy patter claiming that the only reason “They” don’t find vaccine harms is because “They” don’t look very hard. I swear, I can’t even remember the first time I heard that antivax trope because it was so long ago, nor can I remember the number of times I’ve heard the conspiracy theory that “They” are “suppressing evidence” of harms that antivaxxers so desperately want to attribute to vaccines.
Let’s look at the study now.
COVID-19 vaccines and autism…in rats?
The study in question was published a couple of weeks ago in a journal that I’ve never heard of before, Neurochemical Research, and entitled Prenatal Exposure to COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Induces Autism-Like Behaviors in Male Neonatal Rats: Insights into WNT and BDNF Signaling Perturbations. The journal itself, I found, has a respectable impact factor for a specialty journal (4.4.14 in 2023-4); so it’s not the typical crap journal that I usually see these sorts of studies in. It’s also garnered an Altmetric score of 2,757 as of yesterday, which is very high, in the 99th percentile, and has been accessed 44K times. As for the investigators, I am not familiar with any of them, but they are Turkish and come from Izmir Katip Celebi University, Istinye University, Afyon Kocatepe University, and Demiroğlu Bilim University, and the first (and corresponding author) is someone named Mumin Alper Erdogan, who last October also published a study in Journal of Neuroimmune Pharmacology entitled Prenatal SARS-CoV-2 Spike Protein Exposure Induces Autism-Like Neurobehavioral Changes in Male Neonatal Rats.
This latter study is different in that Erdogan injected pregnant rats with either saline, large amount of aluminum hydroxide adjuvant (150 μg/kg, which is within the range commonly recommended for preclinical rodent models), or a large amounts of spike protein (40 μg/kg!) plus a large amount of aluminum adjuvant and then tested the litters of mice for various behavioral traits used as models of autistic behavior, as well as immune markers thought to be associated with autism. Again, I was struck at how large the dose of spike protein was, microgram quantities in rodents that only weighed around 220 g, compared to the typical 70,000 g adult male human. This study was sold as indicating that COVID-19 infection during pregnancy could increase the risk of autism in the offspring of the pregnancy, finding:
At P50, we conducted behavioral analyses on these mature animals and performed MR spectroscopy. Subsequently, all animals were sacrificed, and their brains were subject to biochemical and histological analysis. Our findings indicate that male rats exposed to the spike protein displayed a higher rate of impaired performance on behavioral studies, including the three-chamber social test, passive avoidance learning analysis, open field test, rotarod test, and novelty-induced cultivation behavior, indicative of autistic symptoms. Exposure to the spike protein (male) induced gliosis and neuronal cell death in the CA1-CA3 regions of the hippocampus and cerebellum. The spike protein-exposed male rats exhibited significantly greater levels of malondialdehyde (MDA), tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α), interleukin-17 (IL-17), nuclear factor kappa B (NF-κB), and lactate and lower levels of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) than the control group. Our study suggests a potential association between prenatal exposure to COVID-19 spike protein and neurodevelopmental problems, such as ASD. These findings highlight the importance of further research into the potential effects of the COVID-19 virus on embryonic and fetal development and the potential long-term consequences for neurodevelopment.
My first question, of course, was why there was no spike protein alone group, because such a group would help figure out whether the immune system needed to be more stimulated, as with an adjuvant, for this effect to be observed. Still, my eyebrow was raised when I read this passage:
In light of the growing body of research indicating a connection between SARS-CoV-2 infection and neurological symptoms, we conducted a study to examine the potential impact of a synthetic version of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein on the development of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in offspring born to mothers exposed to the protein during pregnancy.
And, later:
In light of the growing body of research indicating a connection between SARS-CoV-2 infection and neurological symptoms, we conducted a study to examine the potential impact of a synthetic version of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein on the development of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in offspring born to mothers exposed to the protein during pregnancy.
Why the synthetic version? Why not compare to viral infection itself? Why such huge doses? Maybe I’m overly suspicious, but I get the feeling that this study was done in order to lay the groundwork for doing the study being promoted by Dr. Bridle that purports to show a link between the vaccine and autism after prenatal exposure to the vaccine. However, I’ll just take the Erdogan and the authors at their word for the moment that their intent was to study the neuroinflammatory effects of spike protein from infection as a potential promoter of neurodevelopmental disorders like autism spectrum disorders. The reason? Motivation doesn’t matter. Results do. Also, relevance matters, and these studies, as you will see, are not particularly relevant to the questions to which Dr. Bridle thinks they are very relevant.
Let’s move on to the study that so “concerns” Dr. Bridle, who opines later in his post:
I have two boys, so I became very familiar with babies a bunch of years ago. Let’s face it, the bulk of a baby’s early life consists of crying, drinking/eating, pooping/peeing, and sleeping. There is simply not a lot to evaluate when it comes to harms to babies that would manifest as behavioural issues. It is not unusual for babies to seem unhappy and uncomfortable on a regular basis. In other words, one cannot be confident in declaring an absence of a disorder in newborns and even toddlers. For example, I have heard that failing to make eye contact can be a potential sign of autism in young children. Obviously, such an observation cannot be made in a baby; they don’t start making consistent and intentional eye contact for quite some time. So, be very careful when you hear people declaring that there is no evidence of harm to children born to mothers that received the COVID-19 shots. There simply has not been enough time to properly evaluate this.
I like to point out that signs of ASD are often detected in children less than two and can be detected in infants as young as age 6-12 months, sometimes even as young as 3 months. When it comes to ASDs, Dr. Bridle simply doesn’t know what he is talking about here. There is even evidence that signs of autism can be detected in utero as early as mid-gestation. A little humility is in order here. For instance, I know that I am not an expert in neuroscience, autism, or neurodevelopment. I do, however, know from my many years combatting antivaccine misinformation claiming that vaccines cause autism that the signs of autism are detectable much earlier than antivaxxers commonly argue.
Not that that stops Dr. Bridle:
If COVID-19 shots administered to pregnant women can cause neurological harms in their developing babies, including alterations that lead to things like autism, it is almost certain that these could not be identified within the first six weeks. Humans need to gain certain abilities to interact with the world around them before health care professionals can properly assess for evidence of complex disorders. My goodness, some harms aren’t noticed until adolescence if hormonal changes are required to unveil them. This means there is the potential for harms to babies born to mothers that were coerced into getting the COVID-19 shots that we are still unaware of.
No one ever said that we could evaluate in a mere six weeks whether COVID-19 vaccines affect pregnancy outcomes. Again, though, he doesn’t know what he’s talking about here. You don’t have to wait until adolescence to see the signs of ASDs! Again, in some cases, the signs of ASDs can be detected in infancy. His entire argument is just an excuse to invoke the “no long term safety studies” gambit beloved by antivaxxers.
Let’s get to the study, though.
It’s a fairly straightforward study design, although not necessarily a straightforward study. Erdogan’s justification is:
While the mRNA vaccines have exhibited exceptional efficacy in forestalling severe COVID-19 manifestations and curtailing viral transmission, it is of paramount importance to scrupulously investigate the potential neurological ramifications associated with the spike protein itself and with the immune response it induces [16, 17]. Gaining a comprehensive understanding of the implications of spike protein-induced neuroinflammation, along with its impact on synaptic plasticity and overall brain development, will bolster our knowledge of the long-term effects of COVID-19 infection and its vaccination [18].
In this study, our primary objective is to delve deeply into the existing literature and data concerning the potential relationship between COVID-19 mRNA vaccines, spike protein-mediated reactions, and the genesis of neurodevelopmental disorders, focusing on autism.
And:
Through a detailed analysis of these carefully selected parameters, we aim to provide a clearer picture of this pressing area of research and offer directions for subsequent investigations [19, 20].
Is it that pressing a direction of research, though? Is it really? Current clinical evidence in hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of pregnant humans and their offspring have not raised a safety signal of neurodevelopmental disorders linked to the vaccine.
Dr. Bridle cites a reference indicating that many cases of ASD are not diagnosed before the age of 3 and some are not diagnosed until age 5, which is true enough, but not entirely relevant, not that that stops Dr. Bridle:
Here is the problem: Children born to mothers that were coerced into taking COVID-19 shots have not yet reached the age of three. We must now wait another 1.5 years, at least, and likely two or more years to accrue data from enough children to determine whether harms have been caused.
Yes, but there are a lot of children born to those vaccinated against COVID-19 during pregnancy who are getting quite close to 3 years of age, and, again, there are even more who are two years old and still more who are 12 months old. There’s nothing magic about being three years old. It’s more like an average. Lots of children are diagnosed earlier than that, and lots are diagnosed later than that. Although it is still early, with COVID-19 vaccines having only been authorized during pregnancy less than three years ago US, it’s not so early that safety signals for neurodevelopmental disorders in children born after having been exposed to the vaccine in utero through vaccination during pregnancy would not be starting to appear. It’s also a shame, because Erdogan has also published some interesting work in areas in which I’m interested, such as the role of ion channels in cancer. (I wonder if I met him in London in 2015, when I gave a talk at a conference on that topic.)
So how was the study carried out? In brief:
Two cohorts of female rats were randomly assigned to the following treatment groups: Group 1 or the 0.9% NaCl Saline Group (n = 7) and Group 2 or the COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Group (n = 8). Throughout the experiment, the behavior and physical well-being of all animals were meticulously monitored daily. To facilitate the mating process, three female rats were cohabitated with a single male rat for a period spanning two to three days during the estrus phase. The presence of white vaginal plaque in the female rats was used as an indicator of successful mating. After this occurred, the male rats were removed from the enclosures.
After the mating, the rats were then treated thusly:
Rats belonging to Group 1 were administered 1 ml/kg of 0.9% NaCl saline intramuscularly on the thirteenth day of gestation. Simultaneously, rats in Group 2 received a dosage of 30 µg/Rat of the COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 intramuscularly on the same day of pregnancy.
Let me first note that this is the full human dose of the Pfizer vaccine administered to rats whose average weight was only 220 ± 10 g. I realize that most people outside of the US are familiar with metric, but for nonscientists understand in the US I’ll just say that this is the equivalent of ~7.8 oz, less than half a pound. I’ll also note that even Dr. Bridle was forced to recognize this problem and try to handwave it away:
Pregnant rats received the same dose as what is given to pregnant women. Some will try to argue that this represents, on a per body weight basis, a higher effective dose. It might, but we don’t have proof of this. How drugs work can vary across species. There are examples where tiny rodents like mice could tolerate doses of drugs that were toxic in people.
Of course, that argument goes both ways, too. Many are the effects seen in rodent models due to drugs or other toxins that do not translate to people, although that doesn’t stop Dr. Bridle from arguing:
This research was conducted in rats. Pre-clinical studies like these are used to predict what might happen in humans. Sometimes the predictions are close. Sometimes the phenomena do not translate into people at all. And sometimes things are worse in people.
He also tries to hand wave why things might be worse in people:
The authors assume that much of the toxicity to the rats is mediated by the spike protein that the modRNA shots get cells in the body to manufacture. However, what they fail to acknowledge is that rats express the low-affinity receptor for the spike protein, unlike humans that express the high-affinity receptor. This means that the spike can only bind weakly to rat cells, but strongly to human cells. As such, I suspect that most of the harm observed in the rats might have been due to inflammation mediated by the lipid nanoparticles and/or immune responses against the spike proteins. If the spike proteins could contribute to the toxicity, then matters could be much worse in hosts with cells expressing high-affinity receptors, which would include people.
This is what we in the biz like to call JAQing off, “just asking questions” designed to lead the listener towards, in this case, the antivax viewpoint being promoted on Dr. Bridle’s Substack posts that the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are dangerous during pregnancy (actually, that they’re just plain dangerous, regardless of pregnancy status, gender, race, age, etc.).
To continue in that theme, Dr. Bridle argues:
Further, the rats in this study were given a single dose, whereas pregnant women can receive up to two doses. The only way to know for sure is, unfortunately, to wait and see how the global human experiment pans out.
We’re already seeing that. The vaccines are safe and effective, albeit, thanks to mutation and the arrival of the Delta, Omicron, etc. variants and their ability to escape immunity from infection or vaccination against prior variants, they are less effective than they were three years ago.
Getting back to the study again, I note that there was no significant difference between the number of offspring per litter and no neonatal deaths among the litters in either group. Beginning on day 50 after birth (reset to day 1 for purposes of when the tests were administered), the rats born to Group 1 (controls) and Group 2 (vaccinated) were subjected to a number of behavioral tests:
Open Field Test: This initial assessment took place on Day 1. Serving as both a measure of general locomotor activity and anxiety, it also acclimated the rats to a testing environment. Novelty-Induced Rearing Behavior: On Day 4, the rats were evaluated for their vertical explorative behaviors in a novel setting. Three-chamber Sociability and Social Novelty Test: Administered on Day 7, this assessment provided insights into the rats’ sociability and their preference for social novelty. Their prior acclimation to the testing conditions by this point ensured accurate insights. Rotarod Test: On Day 10, the rats underwent this test to evaluate their motor skills and endurance. This physically demanding test was placed last in the sequence to minimize any fatigue or stress impacts on the outcomes of the earlier behavioral assessments.
One thing I noticed right away is something I frequently notice basic scientists failing to do when evaluating the results of rodent experiments, namely doing their observations under double-blind conditions, such that the evaluators do not know which group each rat being tested comes from. They state that they used an “artificial intelligence-based behaviour analysis system and software,” but the link to the system didn’t go anywhere yesterday. One can argue that some of the tests, such as the three-chamber test in which the rat decides between a chamber with no other rat and a “stranger” rat or between a chamber with a known rat and a “stranger” rat in which the test subject’s inclinations to be with one or the other are measured, don’t necessarily need to be double-blinded, but I will argue that all immunohistochemistry tests need to be double blind, even if a computer-aided counting system is used. The reason is that there is some subjectivity in all immunohistochemistry, and, in this case:
Systematic random sampling was employed to maintain uniformity across sections and minimize sampling bias. Counting was facilitated by an image analysis system (Image-Pro Express 1.4.5, Media Cybernetics, Inc., USA) to ensure accuracy and consistency. To ensure objectivity, neuronal counts were independently verified by two trained observers, with any discrepancies discussed and resolved to achieve a consensus count.
See why I think double-blinding would have been nice here?
In addition, several cytokines and immune system factors were measured by PCR from tissue harvested from the hippocampus of the rat brains.
In any event, key findings of the study included:
Differences in WNT gene expression and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) in vaccinated rats, both male and female.
A substantial decrease in neuronal counts in critical brain regions, indicating potential neurodegeneration or altered neurodevelopment
Male rats reportedly demonstrated “pronounced autism-like behaviors, characterized by a marked reduction in social interaction and repetitive patterns of behavior.”
Male rats also demonstrated impaired motor performance, evidenced by reduced coordination and agility.
Here’s Table 4, showing some of the difference:
Sex	Male Groups	Female Groups
Groups	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Male Group	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Female Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Female Group
Brain IL-17 level (pg/mg protein)	109.7 ± 6.9	112.09 ± 3.8	128.6 ± 4.5	118.9 ± 3.8
Brain BDNF level (pg/mg protein)	806.8 ± 33.4	680.7 ± 27.6 #	773.6 ± 25.4	628.9 ± 24.9 *
Brain TNF-alpha level (pg/mg protein)	94.6 ± 0.3	92.09 ± 4.4	111.3 ± 4.1	104.3 ± 4.5
Brain IL-1 level (pg/mg protein)	22.7 ± 1.01	19.6 ± 0.5	22.7 ± 0.4	21.9 ± 0.9
Results were presented as mean ± SEM. Statistical analyses were performed by one-way ANOVA. # p < 0.001, different from % 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group and * p < 0.001, different from % 0.9 NaCl Saline Female Group. For male rats, a significant decrease in brain BDNF levels was evident in the vaccinated group (F(1, 36) = 10.24, p < 0.001), suggesting a specific impact of the vaccine on neurotrophic factors. Similarly, for female rats, brain BDNF levels were significantly lower in the vaccinated group as compared to controls (F(1, 36) = 11.67, p < 0.001), reinforcing the potential influence of the vaccine on neurotrophic signaling
I am familiar with the role of WNT signaling (a molecular pathway that transmits extracellular signals to the nucleus to turn on and off sets of genes that modulate its effect) in cancer, but less so in the brain. The simple version is that WNT signaling is important in neurodevelopment and that impaired WNT signaling can result in various neural impairments, and some research implicates it in the development of ASDs. As for BDNF, it too is important in neurodevelopment, and there is research implicating abnormalities in BDNF signaling with ASDs.
Also, there was noted to be a difference in neuron counts in the hippocampus:
Sex	Male Groups	Female Groups
Groups	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Male Group	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Female Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Female Group
Neuronal Count CA1	71.8 ± 3.5	54.5 ± 1.3 #	68.5 ± 1.9	66.1 ± 0.8
Neuronal Count CA3	43.6 ± 1.7	30.2 ± 1.1 #	42.2 ± 1.3	39.1 ± 1.1
Purkinje Count Cerebellum	21.9 ± 1.4	13.5 ± 0.9 #	19.8 ± 0.6	18.3 ± 0.9
Results were presented as mean ± SEM. Statistical analyses were performed by one-way ANOVA. # p < 0.001, different from % 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group. For the male groups, significant decreases in neuronal counts were observed in the CA1 (F(1, 36) = 23.45, p < 0.001), CA3 (F(1, 36) = 28.37, p < 0.001), and Purkinje cell count in the cerebellum (F(1, 36) = 34.12, p < 0.001) regions, indicating a robust effect of the vaccine. Conversely, the female groups did not show significant differences between treated and control groups in the CA1 (F(1, 36) = 3.21, p = 0.081), CA3 (F(1, 36) = 4.78, p = 0.034), and Purkinje cell count in the cerebellum (F(1, 36) = 5.52, p = 0.024)
Let’s for a moment just accept these results as accurate, the way Dr. Bridle did. Let’s say that the findings of differences in cytokine profiles and neuronal counts between the offspring of vaccinated and unvaccinated rats, , as well as the behavioral differences observed, were accurately measured. What does this mean?
Before I answer that question, I can’t help but mention that I’m glad actually perused the references cited in the study and came across this reference, buried among multiple citations to support a claim:
Erdogan cited Stephanie Seneff and Peter McCullough? Uh-oh. Maybe I was too kind…
Yikes. And uh-oh…again:
No wonder Dr. Bridle likes this study. The authors have cited two of the worst antivax papers I’ve ever seen about COVID-19 vaccines whose authors include one of the worst “new school” antivaxxers (McCullough) and one of the worst “old school” antivaxxers (Seneff).
I take back what I said above when I questioned whether I was being too suspicious of this paper. When you cite two Stephanie Seneff papers, you deserve the suspicion that I had, and it isn’t surprising to me that Dr. Bridle likes this paper. If anything, I was probably not suspicious enough about Erdogan, particularly given the conclusion made by him and his coauthors:
Given the public health significance of understanding the effects of COVID-19 vaccination, especially during pregnancy, comprehensive studies are vital. These should weigh the benefits and potential risks of vaccination, focusing on ensuring optimal neurodevelopmental outcomes. Our findings underscore the importance of continued research in this domain to guarantee the safety and well-being of all individuals, especially those who are pregnant and their offspring.
In summary, this study provides valuable insights into the effects of the COVID-19 mRNA BNT162b2 vaccine on the WNT pathway and BDNF levels, particularly in relation to neurodevelopmental outcomes. The observed male-specific vulnerability and the convergence with existing literature support the involvement of these molecular pathways in neurodevelopmental disorders. However, further research is warranted to validate these findings in human populations and to unravel the complex mechanisms underlying the observed effects. The ultimate goal is to ensure the safety and well-being of individuals receiving COVID-19 vaccination, particularly during pregnancy, while minimizing potential risks to neurodevelopment.
More of a favorite antivax gambit, namely “we need more research.” It’s a gambit used no matter how massive the evidence base against an antivax claim is, such as the old claim that vaccines cause autism.
I deconstructed in depth that paper on G-quadruplexes nearly two years ago! As for the paper on “human genome integration,” I didn’t discuss that paper in particular, but did discuss many times how the claims that the mRNA vaccine can “integrate” into the genome is nonsense. No wonder Dr. Bridle and other antivaxxers like this study!
Relevance, ignored by antivaxxers like Dr. Bridle
The question one has to ask when confronted with a study like this is one of relevance to humans. Even Dr. Bridle recognizes this issue, as he spends considerable verbiage trying to dismiss criticisms based on whether this study is even relevant to what happens in humans while JAQing off in order to make you think that we must treat the results as relevant even though there are a lot of reasons not to, as well as a large amount of data from epidemiological studies of the use of COVID-19 vaccines during pregnancy.
Enter the pandemic’s wrongest man, Alex Berenson, echoing Dr. Bridle’s nonsense about this study:
Naturally, like Dr. Bridle, Mr. Berenson trumpeted this on his Substack in an article entitled URGENT: Giving mRNA Covid vaccines to pregnant rats caused brain changes and autism-like behavior in their young, a new study shows, with the conspiratorial tagline: Naturally, the disturbing finding – which was published in a respected, peer-reviewed journal last week – didn’t come from American scientists and a sarcastic conspiratorial comment in his post:
(Luckily Pfizer did a ton of work to make sure this wouldn’t be problem in humans. Oh, they didn’t? Hey, everyone makes mistakes.)
Again, it’s all about the fear and doubt about the vaccines and ignoring all the human evidence out there:
The study coved only about 40 rats, and it does not prove the vaccines cause autism or similar brain changes in the children of vaccinated pregnant women.
But it does show – again – that the jabs can cause powerful inflammatory and autoimmune responses with unknown consequences, and that their long-term risks have barely been studied.
Mr. Berenson is also ready with an excuse that antivaxxers have been making for two decades:
But neither governments nor vaccine companies have shown any inclination to do that work. And so even if autism diagnoses notably rise in the next few years, proving the mRNAs are responsible will be next to impossible.
Actually, it would be quite possible, in the very same way that doctors studied the vaccine schedule and tried to correlate it with autism diagnoses for the last 30 years and have failed to find a link. It’s just that antivaxxers won’t accept those results. They didn’t accept them for the childhood vaccine schedule, and they won’t accept them for COVID-19 vaccines.
Again, Mr. Berenson is JAQing off, just like Dr. Bridle. Again, it is very much unclear how relevant a model can be in which a dose of vaccine relative to animal body weight so much larger than what is administered to humans and the physiology of pregnancy is so different. One can also question how relevant the behavioral models are to human autism. For example, the three-chamber test has a definite drawback:
To test a mouse’s social interest, researchers place it in a cage that has two side chambers, one of which holds another mouse. Mice normally prefer to investigate the mouse rather than spend time in the empty space. Some of the autism mouse models spend as much or more time in the empty cage, which researchers take to be an indication of social deficits.
But this test relies on an artificial scenario, in which the new mouse is caged and cannot initiate social contact, says Paylor. Tellingly, the FMR1 and NLGN3 rat models both ignore social play, but act normally in the three-chamber test.
“Having a barrier between animals may completely alter the way animals normally interact, and certainly in young rats it prevents rough-and-tumble play behavior,” says Paylor.
I also note that the rats in the Erdogan study were not pups. They were 50 days old and had reached maturity, which is rather late to have been studying the rats. Indeed, one could question why the behavioral part of the study was even designed the way it was when there are rat models that can examine behaviors more relevant to ASDs. I get it. The three-chamber model used is fairly simple and straightforward, but it’s not particularly relevant, particularly not with mature rats.
I could go on and on and on, but I think one of the most telling things I noticed was the reappearance in the comments of Mr. Berenson’s post of an old “friend,” J.B. Handley, founder of Generation Rescue and old school “mercury in vaccines causes autism” leader who’s been fairly quiet for quite a few years. Amusingly, he’s annoyed at Mr. Berenson for previously not having been willing to consider this:
Alex: Your unwillingness, to date, to consider the childhood vaccine schedule’s role in the autism epidemic has been very frustrating for people like me who otherwise conisder you a hero. I hope this revalation helps you re-consider that somehow, magically, the childhood vaccines cause no problems…If you are looking for a mechanism of action, Cal Tech’s Paul Patterson proposed a very clear one more than a decade ago: immune activation events in the brains of babies during critical periods of brain formation. These simmering brain infections can be caused my many different antagonists, but man-made nanoparticle aluminum (the kind found in vaccines that isn’t found in nature) is an obvious culprit, becuase lymphocytes transport it to the brain and the body cant excrete it. There’s likely something similar happening with the mRNA shots that hit the brains of the baby rats, perhaps it’s the spike protein.
I was amused. Mr. Berenson is not sufficiently antivax for old-school antivaxxers, although apparently Dr. Bridle is.
As I wrote at the beginning this post, there is nothing new under the antivax sun. Every antivax claim made about COVID-19 vaccines has a precursor from the beforetime. Also, as I said above, it is nearly inevitable that “new school” antivaxxers who became antivax because of COVID-19 vaccines will over time become become just antivax. As it becomes clear that there is no increased risk of neurodevelopmental disorders like ASDs in children born to individuals vaccinated during pregnancy, the focus will shift (is likely already shifting) to blaming COVID-19 vaccines given to 6 month olds for autism. Same as it ever was.

Dr. Adam Cifu: “We Now Need to Accept That This is Here to Get Infected With Again and Again.”
If Dr. Adam Cifu were genuinely concerned about vaccine hesitancy, I would strongly encourage him to learn about the anti-vaccine movement. He’ll discover that it is fueled not by a lack of “robust data” on COVID boosters, but rather by exactly the sort of mistrust and anti-vaccine misinformation spread by his own blog and collaborators.
Jonathan Howard on January 20, 2024
Link
“Not the Way to Pull Vaccines Back from a “Dangerous Tipping Point”
In a previous article I mused on what it meant to be anti-vaccine and concluded:
The core that unites anti-vaccine thought is: 1) inappropriate minimization of the risk of the virus, and 2) inappropriate minimization of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine.
With this is mind, let’s visit an article titled Not the Way to Pull Vaccines Back from a “Dangerous Tipping Point by Dr. Adam Cifu, a “medical conservative” and founder of the monetized substack Sensible Medicine. Dr. Cifu himself mused on yet another article titled Is Vaccination Approaching a Dangerous Tipping Point. Not the Way to Pull Vaccines Back from a “Dangerous Tipping Point by Drs. Peter Marks and Robert Califf. Dr. Cifu, who described himself as “unabashedly pro-vaccine,” disagreed with their article, suggesting that we increase vaccine uptake with “honesty and transparency.”
Of course, no one who is “unabashedly pro-vaccine” and values “honesty and transparency” would associate themselves with Sensible Medicine.
As SBM readers know, we’ve documented countless instances of blatant factual errors and obfusciation from its authors. They always overstate risks of the vaccine and minimize the impact of the virus, leading them to treat rare, usually mild vaccine side effects, even abnormal lab values, as a fate worse than death from COVID. They’ve repeatedly declared the pandemic over for 3 years in a row, wildly overhyped vaccines in 2021, and now say only stupid people “still give a shit about COVID” or take precautions against it. They’ve spoken positively about infecting children with SARS-CoV-2 and said we should accept that some will die as a “matter of course.”
Beyond this, some Sensible Medicine doctors have partnered with anti-vaccine, pro-tobacco, child-labor advocates. They’ve defended anti-vaccine data-fraudster Dr. Joseph Ladapo and praised cranks like RFK Jr. They’ve likened public health measures to Nazism. They’ve publically mocked vaccine heroes like Dr. Peter Hotez, even though he received death threats and was threatened at home.
They’ve dunked not just on the COVID vaccine, but also the flu and chickenpox vaccines. Perhaps someone will have the fortitude to listen to Sensible Medicine x Vaccine Curious: Tracy Beth Høeg and Christine Stabell Benn Compare US & Danish COVID-19 Response and Child Vaccination Policy to let me know which other vaccines they trash. Both Drs. Høeg and Benn are members of Ron Desantis’s Orwellian “Public Health Integrity Committee“.
Like I said, no one who is “unabashedly pro-vaccine” and values “honesty and transparency” would associate themselves with Sensible Medicine.
“The proverbial elephant in the room, COVID boosters”
To be honest, I can’t recall a single Sensible Medicine article on vaccines where I thought “that was a well-argued, thorough presentation of the data which was devoid of factual errors.” Dr. Cifu’s article was no exception.
Dr. Cifu’s core objection was that “Marks and Califf choose to treat all vaccines the same”. He wrote:
Trying to convince all people that all vaccines are the same is probably the way to make people reasonably skeptical of some vaccine be unreasonably skeptical of them all.
Of course, no one treats all vaccines the same, and there are many vaccines (Yellow Fever, Cholera, Japanese Encephalitis, Ebola, Malaria, Anthrax, Typhoid) which are not suggested to Americans. However, Dr. Cifu’s straw man argument led him to embrace the absurd notion that the COVID vaccine is in competition with other vaccines. Without a shred of evidence, he blamed the “proverbial elephant in the room, COVID boosters” for an increase in overall vaccine hesitancy. Dr. Cifu wants us to imagine there are many parents who think: “I was going to give my kid the MMR, but after reviewing the data on COVID boosters, I changed my mind.” Apparently, Dr. Cifu is unaware that measles is surging in the UK now, even though their COVID booster policy is much more restrictive than the US.
To make his case, Dr. Cifu wrote the following:
Though I am convinced of the safety of the COVID vaccine and know that the initial series saved millions of lives. I, like many of my patients, have questions about the 7th, 8th, and 9th booster (I wish I was exaggerating). I have questions not because of unreasonable skepticism but because we just don’t have robust clinical data that allows me to tell my patients how much a vaccine, after an initial series, will help them…Now, don’t get me wrong, COVID remains serious business and we still losing 1500 people each (week) to “COVID related” deaths. We are also not without data that boosters help — I just can’t call it “robust data.”
What are the downsides of getting a 7th, 8th, and 9th booster, especially for older, vulnerable patients? Even though he acknowledges COVID vaccines are safe, Dr. Cifu doesn’t say. He knows his audience demands “robust data” only for vaccine benefits. Indeed, since the first booster came out in 2021, Sensible Medicine fans have been primed to mock and ridicule anyone who received more than the first two vaccine doses. Today, Dr. Cifu clearly implies-“I wish I was exaggerating“- there’s something wrong with someone who received multiple COVID vaccines. Seeking to encourage groupthink, one Sensible Medicine doctor even asked his readers to sign a pledge to refuse additional COVID vaccines. (As with the flu vaccine, it’s not clear the current COVID vaccines should be considered boosters, given how much the virus and the vaccine have changed.)
To be fair, I too have questions about the value of the 7th, 8th, and 9th COVID vaccines, and I do my best to acknowledge this uncertainty in my writing and with patients. Obviously, there are diminishing returns to additional vaccine doses, especially for young, healthy people who likely have contracted COVID several times by now. No one needs a weekly COVID vaccine. Moreover, new variants seem to change everything every few months.
However, unlike Sensible Medicine doctors, I wouldn’t publicly shame anyone, especially an older, vulnerable person, who has received their 7th, 8th, and 9th COVID vaccines. Immunity wanes quickly for this virus, and there’s nothing wrong with wanting to do safe, simple things to protect yourself from getting sick. It’s not kind for doctors to mock and shame people who want to avoid COVID or who have already been injured by it. After all, anyone who’s gotten that many vaccines has done something right. Specifically, they survived long enough to have received their the 7th, 8th, and 9th COVID vaccines.
The same can’t be said for many people who didn’t receive additional vaccines doses. According to one recent modeling study in The Lancet:
More than 7,000 hospital admissions and deaths in the UK could have been avoided in summer 2022 if people had received all their Covid jabs, research shows.
Another study estimated that:
Through June 30, 2022, the U.S. could have saved 29,000 lives among already vaccinated people by authorizing boosters sooner, and matching Israel’s uptake level and uptake speed.
Another pre-print estimated that in Europe:
Vaccines reduced deaths by 57% overall (CAT range: 15% to 75%), representing ∼1.4 million lives saved in those aged ≥25 years (range: 0.7 million to 2.6 million): 96% of lives saved were aged ≥60 years and 52% were aged ≥80 years; first boosters saved 51%, and 67% were saved during the Omicron period.
Dr. Cifu is right, not all vaccines are the same. If these modeling studies are close to correct, the COVID booster has been one of the most valuable vaccines.
“We are also not without data that boosters help“
As Dr. Cifu said, we are also not without data that boosters help. Indeed, there are many studies, including a randomized-controlled trial (RCT), which show COVID vaccines beyond the first two doses already helped many people, though they are not a panacea. Here are the booster studies I could find, excluding those that only measured antibody responses.
    • Barda (2021): Vaccine effectiveness evaluated at least 7 days after receipt of the third dose, compared with receiving only two doses at least 5 months ago, was estimated to be 93% (231 events for two doses vs 29 events for three doses; 95% CI 88–97) for admission to hospital, 92% (157 vs 17 events; 82–97) for severe disease, and 81% (44 vs seven events; 59–97) for COVID-19-related death.
    • Arbel (2021): Participants who received a booster at least 5 months after a second dose of BNT162b2 had 90% lower mortality due to Covid-19 than participants who did not receive a booster.
    • Bar-on (2021): Across the age groups studied, rates of confirmed Covid-19 and severe illness were substantially lower among participants who received a booster dose of the BNT162b2 vaccine than among those who did not.
    • Muhsen (2022): The results of this cohort study suggest that receipt of a fourth BNT162b2 dose conferred high protection against COVID-19 hospitalizations and deaths among long-term care facilities residents during a substantial Omicron variant surge, but protection was modest against infection.
    • Thompson (2022): During both Delta- and Omicron-predominant periods, receipt of a third vaccine dose was highly effective at preventing COVID-19–associated emergency department and urgent care encounters (94% and 82%, respectively) and preventing COVID-19–associated hospitalizations (94% and 90%, respectively).
    • Andrews (2022): Against hospitalization or death, absolute effectiveness of a BNT162b2 booster ranged from around 97% to 99% in all age groups irrespective of the primary course, with no evidence of waning up to 10 weeks.
    • Menni (2022): Vaccine effectiveness for booster doses in 0–3 months after BNT162b2 primary vaccination was higher than 92·5%, and effectiveness for heterologous boosters after ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 was at least 88·8%.
    • Abu-Raddad (2022): Booster effectiveness against Covid-19–related hospitalization and death due to omicron infection, as compared with the primary series, was 76.5% (95% CI, 55.9 to 87.5). BNT162b2 booster effectiveness against symptomatic infection with the delta (or B.1.617.2) variant, as compared with the primary series, was 86.1%
    • Moreira (2022): A third dose of the BNT162b2 vaccine administered a median of 10.8 months after the second dose provided 95.3% efficacy against Covid-19 as compared with two doses of the BNT162b2 vaccine during a median follow-up of 2.5 months.
    • Klein (2022): Two doses protect against COVID-19–associated emergency department and urgent care encounters among children and adolescents. However, vaccine effectiveness (VE) was lower during Omicron predominance and decreased with time since vaccination; a booster dose restored VE to 81% among adolescents aged 16–17 years. Overall, 2-dose VE against COVID-19–associated hospitalization was 73%–94%.
    • Regev-Yochay (2022): Vaccine efficacy was estimated to be higher for the prevention of symptomatic disease (43% for BNT162b2 and 31% for mRNA-1273)…Our data provide evidence that a fourth dose of mRNA vaccine is immunogenic, safe, and somewhat efficacious (primarily against symptomatic disease).
    • Mallah (2022): A booster dose of COVID-19 vaccine increases the protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection and COVID-19 severity in the general population and in comorbid patients.
    • Magen (2022): Relative vaccine effectiveness in days 7 to 30 after the fourth dose was estimated to be 45% (95% confidence interval [CI], 44 to 47) against polymerase-chain-reaction–confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection, 55% (95% CI, 53 to 58) against symptomatic Covid-19, 68% (95% CI, 59 to 74) against Covid-19–related hospitalization, 62% (95% CI, 50 to 74) against severe Covid-19, and 74% (95% CI, 50 to 90) against Covid-19–related death.
    • Adams (2022): During the first six months of 2022 in the US, booster doses of a covid-19 vaccine provided additional benefit beyond a primary vaccine series alone for preventing hospital admissions with omicron related covid-19.
    • Tenforde (2022): Bivalent booster doses provided additional protection against COVID-19–associated emergency department/urgent care encounters and hospitalizations in persons who previously received 2, 3, or 4 monovalent vaccine doses. Because of waning of monovalent vaccine-conferred immunity, relative effectiveness of bivalent vaccines was higher with increased time since the previous monovalent dose.
    • Tai (2022): This study found that in a young, healthy, highly vaccinated cohort frequently monitored for SARS-CoV-2, booster vaccination was associated with a significant reduction in incident infections during the Omicron wave.
    • Ng (2022): Estimated mRNA booster effectiveness against severe COVID-19 was 87.4% with no evidence of waning up to 6 months after boosting, while the estimated 3-dose inactivated SARS-CoV-2 booster effectiveness against severe COVID-19 was 69.6%. Booster mRNA vaccine protection against severe COVID-19 was estimated to be durable over 6 months.
    • Ridgway (2022): In a large US population, mRNA boosters were associated with decreased odds of hospitalization compared with the mRNA vaccine primary series alone, with the magnitude of the association attenuated with more time since the booster dose.
    • Lauring (2022): mRNA vaccines were found to be highly effective in preventing covid-19 associated hospital admissions related to the alpha, delta, and omicron variants, but three vaccine doses were required to achieve protection against omicron similar to the protection that two doses provided against the delta and alpha variants.
    • McConeghy (2022): In this cohort study of 10 949 residents of 202 community nursing homes and 4321 residents of 128 Veterans Health Administration community living centers, booster vaccination was associated with significant reductions in SARS-CoV-2 infections, hospitalizations, and the combined end point of hospitalizations or deaths.
    • Accorsi (2022): These findings suggest that vaccination with 3 doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine, compared with being unvaccinated and with receipt of 2 doses, was associated with protection against both the Omicron and Delta variants, although higher odds ratios for the association with Omicron infection suggest less protection for Omicron than for Delta.
    • Spitzer (2022): Among health care workers previously vaccinated with a 2-dose series of BNT162b2, administration of a booster dose compared with not receiving one was significantly associated with a lower rate of SARS-CoV-2 infection in short-term follow-up.
    • Kelly (2022): In a US cohort of patients receiving care at Veterans Health Administration facilities during a period of Delta and Omicron variant predominance, there was a low incidence of hospitalization with COVID-19 pneumonia or death following vaccination and booster with any of BNT162b2, mRNA-1273, or Ad26.COV2.S vaccines.
    • Surie (2022): Among immunocompetent adults aged ≥65 years hospitalized in the multistate IVY Network, a bivalent booster dose provided 73% additional protection against COVID-19 hospitalization compared with past monovalent mRNA vaccination only.
    • Fleming-Dutra (2022): Among children and adolescents, estimated vaccine effectiveness for 2 doses of BNT162b2 against symptomatic infection decreased rapidly, and among adolescents increased after a booster dose.
    • Grewal (2022): The findings suggest that compared with a third dose of mRNA covid-19 vaccine, a fourth dose improved protection against infection, symptomatic infection, and severe outcomes among long term care residents during an omicron dominant period. A fourth vaccine dose was associated with strong protection against severe outcomes in vaccinated residents compared with unvaccinated residents, although the duration of protection remains unknown.
    • McConeghy (2022): In a large cohort of nursing home residents, receipt of a second mRNA COVID-19 booster dose during circulation of SARS-CoV-2 Omicron subvariants was 74% effective at 60 days against severe COVID-19–related outcomes (including hospitalization or death) and 90% against death alone compared with receipt of a single booster dose.
    • Roberts (2022): COVID-19 vaccines were highly protective against infection and severe COVID-19 resulting in hospitalization, intensive care unit admission, or death. Administration of a booster dose significantly increased vaccine effectiveness against both outcomes.
    • Gazit (2022): A fourth dose of the BNT162b2 vaccine appears to have provided additional protection against both SARS-CoV-2 infection and severe covid-19 disease relative to three vaccine doses. However, relative effectiveness of the fourth dose against infection appears to wane sooner than that of the third dose.
    • Wei (2023): Overall vaccine effectiveness against death at 4 to 6 months after the third dose was greater than 90% for CoronaVac, BNT162b2, and the mixed vaccine schedule. While vaccines were generally estimated to be effective against severe outcomes caused by SARS-CoV-2 Omicron infection, this analysis found that protection in older patients was more likely to wane 6 months after the second dose. Hence, a booster dose is recommended for older patients to restore immunity.
    • Lundberg-Morris (2023): Vaccine effectiveness against post-covid-19 condition for one dose, two doses, and three or more doses was 21%, 59%, and 73%, respectively.
    • Finci (2023): Among Albanian healthcare workers, most of whom had been previously infected, COVID-19 booster dose offered improved VE during a period of Omicron BA.1 and BA.2 circulation.
    • Wong (2023): Among nursing home residents who were up to date with COVID-19 vaccination (most had received a bivalent vaccine), vaccine effectiveness against SARS-CoV-2 infection was 31.2%.
    • Klein (2023): BNT162b2 protected children and adolescents against mild to moderate and severe COVID-19. VE was lower during Omicron predominance including BA.4/BA.5, waned after dose 2 but increased after a monovalent booster.
    • Link-Gelles (2023): A bivalent mRNA booster dose provided additional protection against symptomatic XBB/XBB.1.5 infection for at least the first 3 months after vaccination in persons who had previously received 2–4 monovalent vaccine doses.
    • Andersson (2023): Heterologous booster schedules are associated with increased protection against severe, omicron related covid-19 outcomes compared with primary course schedules and homologous booster schedules.
    • Andersson (2023): Vaccination with bivalent BA.4-5 or BA.1 mRNA booster vaccines as a fourth dose was associated with reduced rates of covid-19 related hospital admission and death among adults aged ≥50 years.
    • Stecher (2023): Our results indicate an increased protective effect of a fourth dose against severe outcomes compared with a third dose, with decreasing effect with time since the last dose.
    • Link-Gelles (2023): In this case-control study of COVID-19 vaccines and illness, VE associated with protection against medically attended COVID-19 illness was lower with increasing time since last dose; estimated VE was higher after receipt of 1 or 2 booster doses compared with a primary series alone.
    • Lin (2023): Although the two bivalent vaccines were designed to target the BA.4–BA.5 subvariants, they were also associated with a lower risk of infection or severe infection with the BQ.1–BQ.1.1 and XBB–XBB.1.5 subvariants. The effectiveness was higher against hospitalization and death than against infection and waned gradually from its peak over time.
    • Lin (2023): Vaccine effectiveness against severe infection resulting in hospitalization or death was 24.9% (95% CI, 1.4 to 42.8) for one monovalent booster dose and 61.8% (95% CI, 48.2 to 71.8) for one bivalent booster dose.
    • Jang (2023): The 4-dose booster, irrespective of history of SARS-CoV-2 infection, was associated with higher protection against critical BA.5 infection, as shown in previous studies.
    • Lewis (2023): Vaccine booster doses increased protection against COVID-19 hospitalization compared with a primary series.
    • Tartof (2023): A BNT162b2 BA.4/5 bivalent booster restored protection against a range of COVID-19 outcomes, including against XBB-related sublineages, with the most substantial protection observed against hospital admission and critical illness.
    • Liu (2023): The effectiveness of boosters against mortality wanes with time but a booster still provides substantial residual protection six months after receipt. Increasing population hybrid immunity is likely to reduce observed vaccine effectiveness as the pandemic progresses but COVID-19 boosters continue to provide significant benefits in mortality reduction, particularly in high-risk populations such as those aged 65+ years and those resident in aged care facilities.
    • Hanberg (2023): A fourth dose of COVID-19 mRNA vaccine reduced the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection and severe COVID-19 among patients with systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases using DMARDs during the Omicron era.
    • Piekos (2023): COVID-19 vaccination protects against adverse maternal–fetal outcomes, with booster doses conferring additional protection.
    • Amir (2023): In adolescents aged 12–15 years, the booster dose decreased confirmed infection rates by 3.3 times (2.8–4.0) compared with in the internal control group.
    • Chemaitelly (2023): Boosters substantially reduced infection and severe COVID-19, particularly among individuals who were clinically vulnerable, affirming the public health value of booster vaccination.
    • Tartof (2023): The BNT162b2 XBB1.5-adapted vaccine provided significant additional protection against a range of COVID-19 outcomes during a period when XBB sub-lineages were predominant but JN.1 was also co-circulating and rapidly increasing in prevalence. Older versions of COVID-19 vaccines offered little, if any, additional protection compared to the unvaccinated, including against COVID-19 hospital admission, regardless of the number or type of prior doses received.
    • Jara (2023): The overall adjusted effectiveness of a second mRNA booster shot is 88.2% (95%CI, 86.2–89.9) against ICU admissions and 90.5% (95%CI 89.4–91.4) against death.
    • Payne (2024): During September 2022–March 2023, receipt of bivalent mRNA COVID-19 vaccine was 47% effective in preventing thromboembolic events among immunocompetent persons aged ≥65 years and 51% effective among adults aged ≥18 years with end stage renal disease (ESRD) receiving dialysis, compared with receipt of the original monovalent vaccines alone.
Systematic reviews meta-analyses:
    • Zhu (2022):The pooled results demonstrated a 71% (OR = 0.29, 95% CI = 0.17-0.48) reduction in SARS-CoV-2 infection rates among subjects who received a booster shot compared with those who did not receive a booster shot of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccine. In addition, this analysis emphasized that during the period when the Delta variant was predominant, subjects who received the booster shot showed an 82% (OR = 0.18, 95% CI = 0.13-0.25) reduction in infection rates. Moreover, during the period of dominance of the Omicron variant, subjects who received the booster vaccination displayed a 47% (OR = 0.53, 95% CI = 0.35-0.81) reduction in infection rates.
    • Au (2022): For people with delta or omicron related infection, a two dose regimen of an adenovirus vector vaccine with one dose of mRNA booster was 77% (42% to 91%) effective against asymptomatic or symptomatic covid-19 infections, and a three dose regimen of a mRNA vaccine was 93% (76% to 98%) effective against covid-19 related hospital admission.
    • Menegale (2023): Booster doses restored VE to levels comparable to those acquired soon after the administration of the primary cycle. However, 9 months after booster administration, VE against Omicron was lower than 30% against laboratory-confirmed infection and symptomatic disease.
    • Xu (2023): The risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection, the risk of admission to the ICU, and the risk of death were all higher in the non-booster group than those in the booster group.
    • Yang (2023): The efficacy of SARS-CoV-2 vaccines is higher for preventing severe infection and death than for preventing milder infection. Vaccine efficacy wanes over time but can be enhanced by a booster.
    • Xu (2023): Inactivated vaccine protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection was moderate, decreased significantly after 6 months following primary vaccination, and was restored by booster vaccination. VE against severe COVID-19 was greatest after boosting and did not decrease over time, sustained for over 6 months after the primary series, and more evidence is needed to assess the duration of booster VE. VE varied by variants, most notably against Omicron. It is necessary to ensure booster vaccination of everyone eligible for SARS-CoV-2 vaccines and continue monitoring virus evolution and VE.
    • European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (2023): Under the Omicron variant, effectiveness of EU-licensed COVID-19 vaccines in preventing any SARS-CoV-2 infection or mild disease is low and only short-lasting after primary immunization, but can be improved by booster vaccination. Vaccine effectiveness (VE) against severe COVID-19 remains high and is long-lasting, especially after receiving the booster vaccination.
    • Mohammed (2023): VE against severe Omicron infection following the primary course was 63.6% (95%CI: 57.5–69.7%) at three months, decreased to 49% (95%CI: 35.7–63.4%) within six months, and increased to 86% after the first or second booster dose.
Dr. Cifu linked to just one of these studies and then told his readers that a lack of data on COVID boosters in to blame for overall vaccine-hesistancy.
Do these real-world studies constitute “robust data”? Perhaps not. Observational studies can have many flaws, and it’s possible all these studies are “shit“, as one Sensible Medicine doctor put it.
Do I wish I could snap my fingers and will into existence a large RCT for every vaccine dose for every variant for every demographic group? Absolutely. That’s why I asked my readers to pledge not to skip the COVID vaccine, but rather to get involved in COVID RCTs. I believe in COVID vaccine-RCTs so much I was in one. My role was small, but it constitutes an infinitely larger real-world contribution than doctors who merely uttered the words “do an RCT” on YouTube videos.
Do I think more “robust data” on COVID boosters would quell anti-vaccine sentiment? Uh, no. Anyone who thinks that doesn’t know anything about the anti-vaccine movement.
“We now need to accept that this is here to get infected with again and again.”
In an ideal world of fantasy, there would be large RCTs to answer every clinical conundrum. However, in the real-world, especially in a pandemic where both the population and the virus change rapidly and constantly, doctors have to make decisions all the time without “robust data” from pristine RCTs to guide our every action. I would further argue that telling people to accept repeated COVID infections, especially without the protection of an updated vaccine, is absolutely a decision.
Yet, when it comes to repeated COVID infections, Dr. Cifu’s desire for “robust data” mysteriously vanishes. Indeed, he said to me in May 2022:
We now need to accept that this is here to get infected with again and again.
Another Sensible Medicine doctor said the same thing:
Repeat infections are inevitable. More the longer you live. Nothing can be done about it.
Of course, we do have robust data that repeat COVID infections have killed and injured many people around the world. While I counsel my patients about uncertainties regardings the vaccine, it’s also my obligation to counsel them about uncertainties regarding the virus. We’ll be learning about the consequences of our 7th, 8th, and 9th COVID infections for the rest of our lives. SARS-CoV-2 is still new, mutating virus, and it’s medically conservative to approach it with some respect and humility. We are still learning new things about old foes like measles and Epstein-Barr virus.
In contrast to the virus, additional COVID vaccines have mostly given people a sore arm. One study from 2023 found:
The use of bivalent mRNA vaccines as a fourth vaccine dose against covid-19 was not associated with an increased risk of 27 different adverse events in adults aged ≥50 years
I am confident that while many people suffered because they declined additional COVID vaccines, very few suffered from having received them. Despite this, Dr. Cifu is much more concerned by the possibility that someone might get a vaccine dose they don’t need, than by the certainty that people are missing doses they do need. This is especially absurd considering that COVID vaccine uptake has been “abysmal” recently, and 1,500 Americans are dying of COVID every week, as Dr. Cifu noted. Encouraging just one dose of the updated COVID vaccine, especially amongst vulnerable adults, is extremely low-hanging fruit, though this task is made harder by Sensible Medicine doctors. At least Dr. Cifu acknowledged COVID’s ongoing death toll and that boosters are “not without data.” However, no Sensible Medicine doctor would ever devote more than a sentence or two to these essential points. Most refuse to acknowledge them at all.
So much for “honesty and transparency.”
I wish I was exaggerating.
It bears repeating:
The core that unites anti-vaccine thought is: 1) inappropriate minimization of the risk of the virus, and 2) inappropriate minimization of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine.
Though Dr. Cifu boasted of his “pro-vaccine stance”, telling people to accept repeated COVID infections, while implying there’s something inappropriate about accepting repeated COVID vaccination strikes me as rather anti-vaccine. This is par the course for the “medical conservatives” at Sensible Medicine, and if Dr. Cifu were genuinely concerned about vaccine hesitancy, I would strongly encourage him to learn about the anti-vaccine movement. He’ll discover that it is fueled not by a lack of “robust data”, but rather by exactly the sort of anger, mistrust, and misinformation spread by his own blog and collaborators.
I wish I was exaggerating.

Dr. Lucy McBride: “As physicians, dispensing false hope is dangerous & unethical.”
The many sheltered physicians like Dr. Lucy McBride who confidently said herd immunity was at hand and fear of COVID was pathological are the last people who should be sanctimoniously sermonizing about the importance of trust in medicine.
Jonathan Howard on January 12, 2024
Link
Trust is the glue in patient care.”
Dr. Lucy McBride is a concierge primary care physician in Washington DC. While it’s not clear she’s ever treated a hospitalized COVID patient, she made an impressive number of media appearances during the pandemic, and in March 2022, she testified in front of the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology Subcommittee on Investigations and Oversight. Dr. McBride’s core message then was that “Trust is the glue in patient care.” She testified:
Today I want to talk about trust. As we move forward into the next phase of COVID-19 and inevitably face more waves and variants, I of course worry about the ongoing death and destruction from COVID. I worry about the social, emotional, and economic fallout of the virus and of the mitigations themselves. But at its core, I worry most about peoples’ confusion and resulting anxiety about not knowing who to trust in a global health crisis. Specifically, I worry about the risk that the erosion of trust in medicine and in public health poses to our individual and collective health.
This pandemic is about a virus; it’s also about information, messaging, and the contagion of mistrust. To build back better we must start with trust…Trust is born when doctors first acknowledge uncertainty—and then lean into things that are certain.
Fair enough. Having studied the anti-vaccine movement for over a decade, I fully agree that trust matters at least as much as knowledge, and trust in medicine is low right now. Dr. McBride was not wrong when she testified:
That vacuum of trust has been and continues to be filled with a cacophony of voices calling out from across a variety of platforms, from celebrities, media personalities, and internet influencers. Without a source of truth, people look to the showy salesmen and get easily tangled in webs of harmful medical advice.
“That vacuum of trust has been and continues to be filled with a cacophony of voices calling out from across a variety of platforms, from celebrities, media personalities, and internet influencers.”
“I’ve been yearning for an end to the pandemic. Now that it’s here, I’m a little afraid.“
With Dr. McBride’s warning of “harmful medical advice” from “media personalities and internet influencers” in mind, let’s review some of her pandemic record. Though many scientists doubted herd immunity to COVID was possible in the spring of 2021, Dr. McBride’s message at that time was that we were “post-pandemic”, that brand new vaccines rendered people essentially bulletproof against a brand new virus, and that variants were of no concern. She shared her optimism on social media, podcasts, television interviews, and editorials in widely-read publications such as The Washington Post and The Atlantic.
    • March 2, 2021: COVID-19 cases are dropping, but anxiety is everywhere.
    • March 9, 2021: I’ve been yearning for an end to the pandemic. Now that it’s here, I’m a little afraid…The pandemic will end. With dropping case rates and three incredible vaccines robustly protecting us from COVID-19, soon we’ll be able to relax the restrictions of pandemic life.
    • March 10, 2021: I see it every day: ambivalence & #anxiety about reentry. After a year of #trauma, it’s normal. Let’s name, normalize, & navigate it. I was honored to speak about #FONO & my @washingtonpost opinion piece on @Morning_Joe today!
“I’ve been yearning for an end to the pandemic. Now that it’s here, I’m a little afraid.”
    • March 16, 2021: Enjoyed talking with @ryanegorman of @iHeartRadio podcast about my @washingtonpost Op-Ed & how to safely and sanely navigate our post-pandemic transition to normalcy. I hope you take a listen!
    • March 26, 2021: Further evidence that the variants are infinitely less scary than the lack of nuanced messaging about them. So many of my vaccinated patients – particularly the elderly – are PARALYZED by fear of the variants.
    • April 3, 2021: Wired and tired after months of COVID-19 distress, it’s time to recover our mental health. To fully bounce back from COVID, we need a dose of reassurance and a plan for recovery. We need science under our feet and doctors at our back…The first steps toward post-pandemic health are seemingly simple yet vexingly hard for most of us…We have every reason to be hopeful. COVID-related deaths and hospitalizations are falling fast.
    • April 3, 2021: But as you know, once you’ve been vaccinated, your risk of death & severe disease essentially goes away. The risk is of getting milder illness. And even that risk goes down as herd immunity takes hold.
    • April 3, 2021: Post-pandemic health: To fully bounce back from #COVID, we need a dose of reassurance and a plan for recovery. We need science under our feet and doctors at our back.
    • April 3, 2021: The first steps toward post-pandemic health are seemingly simple yet vexingly hard for most of us…We have every reason to be hopeful. COVID-related deaths and hospitalizations are falling fast, and real world data confirms the stunning efficacy of our vaccines. The medical community has its hands on the science we need for reentry. To fully recoup from COVID, we now need our arms around our patients. The doctor is in; are you?
    • April 6, 2021: The risks of getting #COVID19 and transmitting #SARSCoV2 both drop significantly after #vaccination. Neither risk is zero (zero isn’t even on the menu). As we approach herd immunity, these risks will get even smaller than they already are.
    • April 19, 2021: I’ve been using the “off-ramp” analogy with patients — both for how restrictions should END & how we can expect our brains to adjust post-pandemic. There’s no on/off switch for either. #FactsNotFear #Nuance #Context
    • April 19, 2021: I’ve been using the “off-ramp” analogy with patients — both for how restrictions should END & how we can expect our brains to adjust post-pandemic. There’s no on/off switch for either.
    • April 21, 2021: I made these points on @MSNBC @Morning_Joe today: #vaccines 1) essentially take death/severe dz off table; 2) drop risk of #COVID19 to 0.0005% (@CDC data), 3) reduce transmission (94% per Israeli data), 4) are powerful against all current variants. #FactsNotFear#ThisIsOurShot
    • April 21, 2021 : Vaccines aren’t 100% effective (though these are close!), but we don’t need them to be 100% to gradually resume regular life as we head toward herd immunity.
    • April 22, 2021: My (humble) impression is this: nothing in life is risk-free. Certainly the risk of COVID transmission is higher w/ the circulating variants, but as we edge toward herd immunity, outdoor masking is less important (if at all) unless in a crowded space like a rally w/ shouting etc.
    • May 1, 2021: People need to know, for example, that the risk of two vaccinated people sickening one another with Covid-19 is vanishingly small…Vaccinated grandparents should be reassured, for example, that seeing their unvaccinated grandchildren poses very little risk to themselves and that, in general, the risks of Covid-19 in kids are small.
    • May 1, 2021: The #vaccines are so effective at preventing #COVID & reducing transmission it can be hard to believe. Remember when we thought we might never get a #vaccine? Well, here we are with a near-perfect vaccine. Reminder: perfect isn’t on the menu.
    • May 4, 2021: The reason you would need booster shots is if the virus mutates in a way that escapes the immune protection conferred by the vaccines. That has not happened yet. Nor do we expect that to happen, given how quickly we are crushing the curve and how robust we know the immune response to be from these vaccines. It’s just not anything that anybody should be worried about.
    • May 4, 2021: Why all the negative news about variants when it’s just not important?… If you’re in that tiny category of people that does get COVID after vaccination, you’re going to get a cold or a mild illness, most likely. Are there exceptions? Yes. But the vaccines are stunningly effective against the virus. They take death and severe disease off the table. They prevent transmission and they cover all the variants.
    • May 26, 2021: Parents need to role model confidence and optimism about the end of the pandemic.
    • May 26, 2021: As covid-19 cases continue to fall and vaccines demonstrate vigor against even the most concerning variants, it’s time to evaluate which pandemic restrictions are worth keeping in place…This low risk for children nearly vanishes as cases plummet. As we saw in Israel and Britain, vaccinating adults indirectly protects children. The same trend is evident here in the United States: Adult vaccination has lowered COVID-19 incidence among children by 50 percent in the past four weeks.
    • June 2, 2021: What I’m telling you is I’m following the science and seeing the very low risk that COVID-19 poses to kids, and it’s lower and lower every day. And then we also see that kids are really protected by the vaccination status of the staff, and faculty, and teachers at the schools. And so by the time fall rolls around, of course, depending on the local situation of COVID in the particular region we’re talking about, it just isn’t going to make sense for most schools to restrict kids. Now, there’s lots of nuance here, right? Because I don’t have a crystal ball and because could things change? Could case rates go up? They could. It’s just very, very unlikely. Again, if you look at the UK and Israel as the seniors and we’re the sophomores, we’re going to be in so much better shape even next week than we are today, and in the fall, it should be a lot different…the vaccines that we currently have are so stunningly effective against all of the circulating variants…worst case scenario, we need boosters and Pfizer and Moderna will crank them out.
All this from a doctor who said on April 16, 2021 “As physicians, dispensing false hope is dangerous & unethical.”
“I’m A Doctor Seeing Patients with Coronaphobia. Here’s What You Need to Know.”
While Dr. McBride announced we were “post-pandemic” as early as March 2021 and that variants were nothing to worry about, she was very concerned that strangers were trying too hard to avoid the virus. She had dozens of Tweets using the hashtag #FactsNotFear and encouraged her audience to “abandon irrational fear.”
She even used several new medical terms to pathologize cautious people, and Dr. David Gorski previously discussed how she parroted pre-pandemic anti-vaccine talking points about diseases such as measles. For example, in her article, “I’m A Doctor Seeing Patients with Coronaphobia. Here’s What You Need to Know” from March 2, 2021, she wrote:
“Coronaphobia” can be defined as an exaggerated fear of COVID-19 that is rooted in rational anxiety about the very real threat of COVID…Not dying is important (and is essentially guaranteed with COVID-19 vaccination); but what about living?…COVID-19 cases are dropping, but anxiety is everywhere.
A week later, Dr. McBride wrote an article titled “I’ve Been Yearning for an End to the Pandemic. Now That it’s Here, I’m a Little Afraid,” in which she coined yet another term- Fear of Normal- to further stigmatize people who didn’t agree that the pandemic was over. She elaborated on these articles in an interview from May 4, 2021:
I wrote an article for The Huffington Post about what I call “coronaphobia,” and I also wrote a piece for The Washington Post about what I call “fear of normal,” or FONO. What I’m seeing is an epidemic of unbridled fear that is basically the reverberations of the anxiety that we all experienced when the pandemic was happening in full force. As the pandemic comes under much better control, we need to shift our thinking and then our behaviors to reflect reality.
COVID has since injured millions of Americans, killing over 600,000 of them. Perhaps some might still be alive if they had a bit more coronaphobia, which has likely never appeared on a death certificate.
Once the Delta variant arrived, invalidating Dr. McBride’s optimistic declarations that we were edging “toward herd immunity”, she continued to be afraid of fear. In August 2021, as the Delta variant spiked pediatric hospitalizations, she authored an article titled “Fear of COVID-19 in Kids is Getting Ahead of the Data“, as if it were this was necessarily a bad thing. Pediatricians with actual responsibility for treating sick children weren’t so blasé. “This is different,” one said. “What we’re seeing now is previously healthy kids coming in with symptomatic infection.” Another said that “we’re not only seeing more children now with acute SARS-CoV2 in the hospital, we’re starting also to see an uptick of MISC – or Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children.” Less than a month after Dr. McBride published her essay, the CDC reported that Delta variant had caused a 5-fold increase in pediatric hospitalizations. Dr. McBride got her data, though it was too late for many children. They were the data.
Having used “coronaphobia” and “Fear of Normal” in 2021, Dr. McBride needed a new term to pathologize people in 2022. In March that year, she wrote an article titled “Dealing With ‘Post-PandemicStress’: A Doctor’s Guide”, in which she said:
It’s what some medical professionals, including myself, are calling “post-pandemic stress” whichis not an official diagnosis (nor does it mean that COVID is gone!) but is characterized by anxiety,mood instability, and mental exhaustion that is interfering with quality of life.
Fortunately, Dr. McBride knew the cure for “post-pandemic stress.” In May 2022, she said, “I’m finding that the ‘cure’ for some of my patients’ outsize fear of COVID is … COVID.”
“The risk of COVID-19 is really, really small in kids. It’s a smaller risk than the seasonal flu…If you’re under 11, the risk of getting COVID is teeny.”
Beyond this, Dr. McBride partnered with anti-vaccine doctors in January 2022 to found the group Urgency of Normal (read more here, here, here, here, here) which copied the Great Barrington Declaration by advocating “focused protection for the vulnerable” and spread misinformation to minimize COVID’s risk to children. For example, the Urgency of Normal sought to pacify parents by saying that “COVID is a flu-like risk to unvaccinated children“. They used several statistical gimmicks to make this false claim.
    • They compared COVID deaths when mitigation measures were in place to pre-pandemic flu deaths.
    • They compared the raw tally of COVID deaths to estimated flu deaths, which inflated the flu death toll relative to COVID.
    • They compared the infection fatality rate of COVID to the flu, while ignoring the essential fact that COVID is much more contagious than the flu.
    • They made factual errors, claiming that COVID had killed around 400 children, when it fact it had killed around 1,200.
The Urgency of Normal did all they could to obscure the basic fact that from April 2020 to January 2022, when the Urgency of Normal was formed, COVID killed around 1,200 children, while the flu killed 15. A single child died during the 2020-2021 flu season, when mitigation measures were most stringent, while COVID killed several hundred children during that time. However, that didn’t stop Dr. McBride from saying on May 4, 2021:
The risk of COVID-19 is really, really small in kids. It’s a smaller risk than the seasonal flu. We don’t close schools and mask kids in flu season. We have somehow as a society, quote-unquote, “tolerated” the fact that hundreds of kids die from the flu every year. This virus has generally spared children, particularly young children… If you’re under 11, the risk of getting COVID is teeny.
Not only was she wrong about the relative risks of COVID and the flu, schools occasionally closed for the flu before the pandemic, pediatricians vaccinated kids against the flu instead of “tolerating” their death, and babies have by far the highest COVID risk of all children.
The Urgency of Normal also did not mention that children could survive COVID, but be injured by it, and COVID hospitalized many more children than the flu as well. The flu hospitalized just 9 children ages 5-11 years-old in 2020-2021, while COVID hospitalized thousands of children that age during that time.
(Chart by Dr. Ben Weston from 2/3/2022. Flu data is available here.)
“The risk of COVID-19 is really, really small in kids. It’s a smaller risk than the seasonal flu…If you’re under 11, the risk of getting COVID is teeny.”
Though Dr. McBride refused to share these basic numbers, to her credit, she vaccinated her teen daughter and shared this publicly. However, she also said that because of rare cases of vaccine-induced myocarditis, which was already known to be mild in 95% of cases, “the risk/benefit ratio for healthy teen boys isn’t yet clear.” This aged almost as poorly as her declaration that we were “post-pandemic”, though again it was too late for some healthy teen boys.
The Urgency of Normal also exaggerated perceived harms of measures used to control the virus. According to one article on the Urgency of Normal:
Tyler Black, a child and adolescent psychiatrist and suicidologist at BC Children’s Hospital in Vancouver, hadn’t heard anything about the Urgency of Normal group or its “tool kit” until it came out. But when he saw it go up on Twitter, he was appalled. “Their document was so poor, with so many mistakes, that it required immediate public correction,” he said. He messaged some of the signers directly on Twitter, he said, and when no one responded, he went public, in a detailed Twitter thread that focused on his area of expertise: child mental health. Several other subject-area experts did the same, debunking comparisons to the flu and diving into the dismissal that many kids are fine. The central problem he saw was that the group claimed that masks harm children’s mental health and social development—something he’s seen no evidence for in his own work.
“It was really, really gross to see what they did with the mental health science. It’s a true perversion of what science communication is supposed to be,” Black said. “They had mis-cited the CDC—I’m not talking about they made a mistake, I’m talking about mis-citing. Academic misconduct.” The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention study found that there was no significant increase in child suicide, yet the group used that study to claim the opposite—an increase in suicide. After pushback, the authors edited the tool kit to remove that mention of suicide, he said, without noting what had been revised.
Dr. Black also added, “I consider it ghoulish to wield child suicide statistics inaccurately to make advocacy points.”
“I worry most about peoples’ confusion and resulting anxiety about not knowing who to trust in a global health crisis.”
Let’s return to Dr. McBride’s core concern- peoples’ confusion and resulting anxiety about not knowing who to trust in a global health crisis. I deeply share this concern. This is why I focus on the many sheltered doctors who minimized COVID with bogus statistics, confidently said herd immunity was at hand, that variants were “not anything that anybody should be worried about,” that vaccines were a panacea, and that fear of COVID was pathological.
Amazingly, even as headlines read “Why Are 1,500 Americans Still Dying From COVID Every Week?“, these doctors now feel entitled to lecture everyone else on the importance of trust. Imagine the audacity that takes. They should carefully review their own words. They are the last people who should sanctimoniously sermonize on the “vacuum of trust” in medicine.

The Failed “We Want Them Infected” Movement Is Trying to Rebrand Itself As The “All We Really Wanted Was Poor Kids in School” Movement.
Part 2: In 2020, pro-infection doctors said “It’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases.” Today, they performatively lament “learning loss for children, especially in poor families”. What happened to their assurances that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth will rapidly lead to herd immunity?
Jonathan Howard onApril 5, 2024
Link

It’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases
During an interview with Tucker Carlson from June 2020, Dr. Scott Atlas expressed delight that large numbers of people were contracting COVID. He said:
We expected more cases with more social mingling… But the fact is the overwhelming majority of these cases are in younger healthier people. These people do not have a significant problem. They do not have the serious complications. They do not die. And so it’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases, but we don’t see deaths going up, and what that means is A: we’re are doing a better job of protecting the vulnerable, B: We’re in good shape here.
We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity, population immunity, when low-risk people, with no significant problem handling this virus, which is basically 99% of people get this, they become immunity and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people.
This is straightforward enough. In 2020, before anyone was vaccinated, Dr. Atlas claimed the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity, protecting older, more vulnerable people. He formulated his policy of using sick young people as human shields in two essays from April 2020, back when the thought the pandemic was winding down and that it “would cause about 10,000 deaths.” Let’s recall what Dr. Atlas said about the virus back then.
In one essay titled The Data is in — Stop the Panic and End the Total Isolation he had very good news to share. He said:
The tragedy of the COVID-19 pandemic appears to be entering the containment phase…young adults and children in normal health have almost no risk of any serious illness from COVID-19….
Dr. Atlas saw a path out the pandemic. He thought we could rid ourselves of the virus by spreading the virus. As such, he objected to mitigation because not because he doubted their efficacy, but precisely because he was aware of their efficacy. He said:
We know from decades of medical science that infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — antibodies — so that the infection is controlled throughout the population by “herd immunity.” Indeed, that is the main purpose of widespread immunization in other viral diseases — to assist with population immunity. In this virus, we know that medical care is not even necessary for the vast majority of people who are infected. It is so mild that half of infected people are asymptomatic, shown in early data from the Diamond Princess ship, and then in Iceland and Italy. That has been falsely portrayed as a problem requiring mass isolation. In fact, infected people without severe illness are the immediately available vehicle for establishing widespread immunity. By transmitting the virus to others in the low-risk group who then generate antibodies, they block the network of pathways toward the most vulnerable people, ultimately ending the threat. Extending whole-population isolation would directly prevent that widespread immunity from developing.
In his other essay, Reentry After the Panic: Paying The Health Price of Extreme Isolation, he spoke of a “world-wide sense of relief” and said:
With a world-wide sense of relief, progress continues in containing the COVID-19 pandemic. Projections have been revised downward for virtually every major negative consequence of the disease. Few doubt that the unprecedented isolation policies and near-total economic lockdowns adopted by most countries had a significant impact on reducing deaths from the virus. And aside from New York, where almost half of the entire country’s deaths and cases have occurred, the vast majority of American hospitals were not overwhelmed beyond capacity. All of this is terrific news…
Doctors working in overwhelmed hospitals with overflowing morgues– an article about my hospital titled An Insane Situation’: Inside the Chaos at Bellevue Hospital was also published in April 2020- didn’t share his “world-wide sense of relief”. Though Dr. Atlas worried about missed health care for non-COVID conditions, he felt this was a secondary issue. The main problem, as he saw it, was that not enough people were getting infected, delaying the arrival of herd immunity. He said:
But a bigger price might now be paid from choosing extreme isolation. In the absence of immunization, society needs circulation of the virus, assuming high-risk people can be isolated. Infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — natural antibodies. Given the estimated contagiousness of COVID-19, about 60 percent of people in the community need to have antibodies to stop the spread by “herd immunity.” Remember, medical care is not necessary for the vast majority of people who are infected. We also infer from testing in Iceland and Vo, Italy, that half of infected people are asymptomatic. That has been misleadingly portrayed as a problem requiring mass isolation; those infected people are an important vehicle for establishing immunity by transmitting the virus to the low-risk group. Preliminary testing in Germany shows that perhaps 15 percent of people are immune; no doubt this varies greatly by region. It is very possible that whole-population isolation prevented natural herd immunity from developing.
Dr. Atlas spoke this way throughout the summer of 2020:
When you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you’re prolonging the problem because you’re preventing population immunity. Low-risk groups getting the infection is not a problem…
There’s a positive to having low-risk groups get infection. What’s the positive? This is how you develop population based immunity. When I said this months ago, as did others, if we isolate every human being from social interaction, we are prolonging the problem, we are preventing population immunity from developing…
It doesn’t matter if younger, healthier people get infected. I don’t know how often that has to be said. They have nearly zero risk of a problem from this. When younger, healthier people get infected, that’s a good thing because that’s exactly the way that population immunity develops.
There was nothing exceptional about any of this. I can provide many similar examples of doctors cheering infections in unvaccinated youth, saying this would lead to herd immunity in under 6-months. They professed great gratitude to those willing to get infected- thank you, thank you, thank you– and mocked those who disagreed this would lead to herd immunity. They didn’t just want children in school, they wanted them there unvaccinated and without any mitigation measures. The reason for this had nothing to do with their education. Indeed, many of these doctors teamed up with an unapologetic child-labor advocate to push their policy of mass infection. Like Dr. Atlas, they too claimed worst was behind us in spring 2020 and predicted that COVID would be much less impactful than the flu.
We all know happened next.
Learning loss for children, especially in poor families, is already showing up in reduced standardized-test scores.
Despite this, Dr. Atlas hasn’t slowed down a bit. As reality tragically obliterated his absurd predictions, he just soldiered bravely onward, seeking TV cameras and podcast microphones, always saying the worst was behind us and it was time to stop the “panic.” He’s never paused and publically reflected on how poorly his 2020 comments aged. Was there really a world-wide sense of relief in April 2020? What that really the “containment phase” of the pandemic? Was it really “fantastic news” when cases spiked in “low-risk” populations? Was that really the pathway to herd immunity?
Instead of having the integrity to ask these questions, doctors who massively underestimated the virus and claimed that spreading it would quickly eliminate it, amazingly now act as if their pronouncements from 2020 have been have been completely vindicated. Today, Dr. Atlas has the audacity to write articles titled Covid Lessons Learned, Four Years Later where he dramatically laments “learning loss for children, especially in poor families” and “lost faith in public-health institutions.” Other people made mistakes, according to Dr. Atlas.
But notice how much Dr. Atlas’ 2024 rhetoric differs from his April 2020 rhetoric. Dr. Atlas didn’t mention children from poor families in those April 2020 articles. He didn’t mention schools or education at all. Conversely, in 2024, he no longer says it’s “fantastic news that we have a lot of cases… because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity.”
Indeed, none of the doctors who now performatively bemoan “learning loss for children, especially in poor families” today, acknowledge they cheered the spread of the virus throughout 2020. None of them currently claim the only barrier to herd immunity is a few more infections in “low-risk” people, even though they said this throughout the first half of the pandemic. Their assured pronouncements that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would rapidly end the pandemic just vanished- poof- never to be mentioned again. The fact that reinfections are trivially common has not made them publicly re-evaluate their prior declarations of herd immunity or their adoring homages to the “power” and “triumph” of natural immunity. In fact, they issue absurd denials, saying they only cared about “the importance of schools for the well being of children“, if you remind them of their prior pleas for “natural immunity” to hasten herd immunity. They act like they never said it at all.
We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low-risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity.
But of course they said it many times. So today, when Dr. Atlas, a right-wing pandemic celebrity who never treated a COVID patient himself, writes self-serving, revisionist propaganda claiming he was a benevolent soul who only cared about “learning loss for children, especially in poor families”, it’s important to remember two things.
First, here’s what Dr. Atlas really believed in 2020. This is the policy he enacted during his time as President Trump’s COVID advisor:
With a world-wide sense of relief, progress continues in containing the COVID-19 pandemic…The tragedy of the COVID-19 pandemic appears to be entering the containment phase… It is very possible that whole-population isolation prevented natural herd immunity from developing… Young adults and children in normal health have almost no risk of any serious illness from COVID-19… They block the network of pathways toward the most vulnerable people, ultimately ending the threat…They become immune and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people….It’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases…We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low-risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity.
Second, Dr. Atlas was wrong about well, basically everything. Over a million Americans died since he said “the COVID-19 pandemic appears to be entering the containment phase”. The virus was not harmless for young people. It killed around 45,000 young adults and children, many of them “in normal health.” In fact, COVID was the number 1 or 2 killer of young adults for six months in a row, from August 2021 to January 2022, though of course death is not COVID’s only harm. Hundreds of thousands of children lost a parent of caregiver to the virus. These grim numbers all would have been much higher had unvaccinated young people been infected en masse in April 2020 as Dr. Atlas hoped. Finally, though we have oodles of “natural immunity”- the virus has infected most Americans- we do not have herd immunity.
“It’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases”
Though 2020 was both well-documented and not that long ago, the sheltered pro-infection doctors who molded our disastrous pandemic response are furiously scrambling to sanitize their history in it, absurdly casting themselves as selfless crusaders for poor children, rather than allies of the virus. And if we don’t remember what they actually said- We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low-risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity– they certainly won’t remind us. The failed We Want Them Infected movement is trying to rebrand itself as the All We Really Wanted Was Poor Kids In School movement.

Countering Geert Vanden Bossche’s dubious viral open letter warning against mass COVID-19 vaccination
Geert Vanden Bossche is a scientist who published an open letter warning of global catastrophe due to deadly variants of COVID-19 selected for by mass vaccination. His argument sounds a lot like an argument Andrew Wakefield once made for MMR. There’s even grift likely involved!
David Gorski on March 18, 2021
Link

[Editor’s note: Scott Gavura had circumstances pop up that prevented him from producing a post for today. As a result, I’m posting this. Some of you might have seen it already published elsewhere (although this is an edited/abridged version of the original post). If you haven’t, it’s new to you. A viral “open letter” by Geert Vanden Bossche has gone viral, and antivaxxers have been citing it as slam-dunk evidence that COVID-19 vaccination will lead to global catastrophe. As a result, I thought it worth providing this rebuttal and links to an even better rebuttal, to SBM readers in order to disseminate this information more widely. Enjoy!]
I’ve frequently discussed how in the age of the pandemic, at least in terms of antivaccine misinformation and pseudoscience, everything old is new again. Over the last several months, I’ve listed a number of examples of this phenomenon of antivaxxers recycling hoary tropes to apply them to COVID-19 vaccines; for example, claims that vaccines kill, cause infertility, cancer, autoimmune disorders, and Alzheimer’s disease, and are loaded with “toxins“, among several others, such as the claim that they “alter your DNA“. One such claim that I hadn’t yet seen is another favorite antivax claim, although admittedly it’s a rather niche claim in that you don’t hear it too often. Specifically, I’m referring to the abuse of evolutionary theory by antivaxxers to claim that vaccines select for more deadly variants of pathogenic viruses and bacteria, making mass vaccination programs dangerous or even potentially catastrophic. Such claims are generally an offshoot of another favorite antivaccine claim, namely that the diseases being vaccinated against are so innocuous that vaccinating against them is overkill and allowing infection and “natural herd immunity” to occur is better, a trope that has also been resurrected about COVID-19, a disease that’s killed well north of 500K people in just the US in a little over a year. This brings us to our topic, a misinformation-filled “open letter” by a scientist named Geert Vanden Bossche that went viral over the weekend. It’s been accompanied by a video interview posted to—where else?—antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense website. Reading the letter, what it reminded me, more than anything else, is an article that Andrew Wakefield wrote about the MMR vaccine and measles, published a few months before the pandemic hit. (Truly, those were simpler times.)
Dr. Vanden Bossche has publicized his letter on Twitter:
In this open letter I am appealing to the @WHO and all stakeholders involved, no matter their conviction, to immediately declare such action as THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY OF INTERNATIONAL CONCERN. Please read and share: https://t.co/0Fupw9JInP #COVID19 pic.twitter.com/I24mSjpVKM
— Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 6, 2021
More recently, he set up his own website to publicize his letter:
We've put together a website to gather all information, scientific documents and interviews I've posted on this public health emergency. We'll try to work on further translations and regular updates. https://t.co/DPYKE7kxmM
— Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 15, 2021
Along with science, maa-aan!
The science behind the catastrophic consequences of thoughtless human intervention in the Covid-19 pandemic. Read full document here: https://t.co/DPDFlg4U45 pic.twitter.com/TISexYqyTq
— Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 13, 2021
He’s also started making rounds on the podcast/vlog interview circuit:
You can watch yesterday's interview with Philip McMillan here: https://t.co/sx9fxpsyHg Thanks for all your support, we will need it. #COVID19 #openthedebate
— Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 7, 2021
Before I get to Vanden Bossche’s open letter and his “warning to the world” that mass vaccination with the current COVID-19 vaccines is likely to lead to a global catastrophe due to the proliferation of ever-more-transmissible COVID-19 variants (as if the COVID-19 pandemic itself hasn’t been a global catastrophe!), let’s just review what Wakefield claimed about the MMR vaccine back in 2019. Central to the concept in his article, published via the in-house journal of the American Association of Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), an organization I like to refer to as the John Birch Society of medical societies given its penchant for conspiracy theories and pseudoscience, was that the MMR vaccine, by selecting for more aggressive measles strains, could result in a “sixth extinction event”. (I kid you not.) He even entitled his nonsensical screed “The Sixth Extinction: Vaccine Immunity and Measles Mutants in a Virgin Soil“.
As I go through Dr. Vanden Bossche’s open letter, I’ll point out the similarities, while also noting differences when they occur. By the time I get through this, I suspect you’ll understand why the misinformation that Dr. Vanden Bossche is selling (and I use the word “selling” intentionally, as I suspect there’s grift involved) is nonsense and nothing more than repackaged antivax tropes.
Quoth Bossche: “I am all but an antivaxxer!”
Before he gets to his concerns, like anyone spreading antivaccine disinformation, whether as an antivaxxer or someone who’s misguided, Dr. Vanden Bossche, like RFK Jr., must proclaim himself so very firmly “not antivaccine“:
I am all but an antivaxxer. As a scientist I do not usually appeal to any platform of this kind to make a stand on vaccine-related topics. As a dedicated virologist and vaccine expert I only make an exception when health authorities allow vaccines to be administered in ways that threaten public health, most certainly when scientific evidence is being ignored. The present extremely critical situation forces me to spread this emergency call. As the unprecedented extent of human intervention in the Covid-19- pandemic is now at risk of resulting in a global catastrophe without equal, this call cannot sound loudly and strongly enough.
As stated, I am not against vaccination. On the contrary, I can assure you that each of the current vaccines have been designed, developed and manufactured by brilliant and competent scientists. However, this type of prophylactic vaccines [sic] are completely inappropriate, and even highly dangerous, when used in mass vaccination campaigns during a viral pandemic. Vaccinologists, scientists and clinicians are blinded by the positive short-term effects in individual patents, but don’t seem to bother about the disastrous consequences for global health. Unless I am scientifically proven wrong, it is difficult to understand how current human interventions will prevent circulating variants from turning into a wild monster. Racing against the clock, I am completing my scientfic [sic] manuscript, the publication of which is, unfortunately, likely to come too late given the ever increasing threat from rapidly spreading, highly infectious variants. This is why I decided to already post a summary of my findings as well as my keynote speech at the recent Vaccine Summit in Ohio on LinkedIn. Last Monday, I provided international health organizations, including the WHO, with my analysis of the current pandemic as based on scientifically informed insights in the immune biology of Covid-19.
Dr. Vanden Bossche has also taken to social media to air his concerns, and his message has been enthusiastically embraced by antivaxxers:
Let’s just say this. If you claim to be “not antivaccine” but your message is so attractive to a rabid antivaxxer and leader of the antivaccine movement like Del Bigtree that he spends an hour promoting it, you are either deluding yourself about being “not antivaccine,” or you’re a useful idiot for the antivaccine movement, possibly both.
Unfortunately, Dr. Vanden Bossche’s open letter has gone viral and is being spread on antivaccine social media everywhere as “slam dunk” evidence that COVID-19 vaccines will cause a global catastrophe by selecting for the evolution of highly transmissible and deadly variants of COVID-19 that will escape immunity due to vaccines. (I note that Dr. Vanden Bossche only set up his Twitter account two weeks ago and already has over 16K followers.) In any case, I got a particularly strong “brave maverick” vibe from this passage:
While there is no time to spare, I have not received any feedback thus far. Experts and politicians have remained silent while obviously still eager to talk about relaxing infection prevention rules and ‘springtime freedom’. My statements are based on nothing else but science. They shall only be contradicted by science. While one can barely make any incorrect scientific statements without being criticized by peers, it seems like the elite of scientists who are currently advising our world leaders prefer to stay silent. Sufficient scientific evidence has been brought to the table. Unfortunately, it remains untouched by those who have the power to act. How long can one ignore the problem when there is at present massive evidence that viral immune escape is now threatening humanity? We can hardly say we didn’t know – or were not warned.
There you have it, the lone scientific maverick who is the only one willing to speak out about against a “horror” being perpetrated by conventional medicine and science that “they” don’t want you to know about or discuss, a horror that’s so “urgent” that he must speak now. Not for him is the too-slow process of seeking feedback from fellow experts or publishing in the scientific literature (even on a pre-print server). Don’t you see? The situation is just too urgent! And Dr. Vanden Bossche’s concerns are based on Science! He reminds me of another doctor who spread misinformation about COVID-19 vaccination based on an unbending principle of immunology to justify his concerns, without any clinical or epidemiological evidence to support it. In any case, for someone who is so “not antivaccine”, Dr. Vanden Bossche sure is good at providing ammunition to the antivaccine movement.
So it’s not surprising that Dr. Vanden Bossche’s letter reminds me of Andrew Wakefield’s warning about the MMR vaccine. At this point, I will also mention that, because Ed Nirenberg produced an excellent rebuttal of Dr. Vanden Bossche’s mangling of immunology in his letter, I’ll stick more to my lane (mostly, anyway), although there will be some overlap. I will note that it is truly astounding how many statements that a supposed “expert” in immunology and vaccines can make that are just plain out-and-out wrong.
On COVID-19 vaccines, Dr. Vanden Bossche channels Andrew Wakefield’s MMR misinformation
Let’s compare Dr. Vanden Bossche’s letter to what Wakefield wrote back in 2019. Here’s the crux of his concern, in which he likens escape from vaccine immunity to antibiotic resistance:
THE key question is: why does nobody seem to bother about viral immune escape? Let me try to explain this by means of a more easily understood phenomenon: Antimicrobial resistance. One can easily extrapolate this scourge to resistance to our self-made ‘antiviral antibiotics’. Indeed, antibodies (Abs) produced by our own immune system can be considered self-made antiviral antibiotics, regardless of whether they are part of our innate immune system (so-called ‘natural’ Abs’) or elicited in response to specific pathogens (resulting in so-called ‘acquired’ Abs). Natural Abs are not germ-specific whereas acquired Abs are specifically directed at the invading pathogen. At birth, our innate immune system is ‘unexperienced’ but well-established. It protects us from a multitude of pathogens, thereby preventing these pathogens from causing disease. As the innate immune system cannot remember the pathogens it encountered (innate immunity has no so-called ‘immunological memory’), we can only continue to rely on it provided we keep it ‘trained’ well enough. Training is achieved by regular exposure to a myriad of environmental agents, including pathogens. However, as we age, we will increasingly face situations where our innate immunity (often called ‘the first line of immune defense’) is not strong enough to halt the pathogen at the portal of entry (mostly mucosal barriers like respiratory or intestinal epithelia). When this happens, the immune system has to rely on more specialized effectors of our immune system (i.e., antigen-specific Abs and T cells) to fight the pathogen. So, as we grow up, we increasingly mount pathogen-specific immunity, including highly specific Abs. As those have stronger affinity for the pathogen (e.g., virus) and can reach high concentrations, they can quite easily outcompete our natural Abs for binding to the pathogen/virus. It is precisely this type of highly specific, high affinity Abs that current Covid-19 vaccines are inducing. Of course, the noble purpose of these Abs is to protect us against Covid-19. So, why then should there be a major concern using these vaccines to fight Covid-19?
Well, similar to the rules applying to classical antimicrobial antibiotics, it is paramount that our self-made ‘antiviral antbiotcs’ [sic] are made available in sufficient concentration and are tailored at the specific features of our enemy. This is why in case of bacterial disease it is critical to not only chose the right type of antibiotic (based on the results from an antibiogram) but to also take the antibiotic for long enough (according to the prescription). Failure to comply with these requirements is at risk of granting microbes a chance to survive and hence, may cause the disease to fare [sic] up. A very similar mechanism may also apply to viruses, especially to viruses that can easily and rapidly mutate (which is, for example, the case with Coronaviruses); when the pressure exerted by the army’s (read: population’s) immune defense starts to threaten viral replication and transmission, the virus will take on another coat so that it can no longer be easily recognized and, therefore, attacked by the host immune system. The virus is now able to escape immunity (so-called: ‘immune escape’).
I have to point out that coronaviruses, in particular SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, do not mutate especially fast as RNA viruses go. This particular coronavirus happens to have a proofreading mechanism that results in a low mutation rate compared to that of a lot of other RNA viruses, such as, for example, the influenza virus. Seriously, as a “vaccine expert”, how is it that Dr. Vanden Bossche does not know this? Even so, concern about immune escape is one reason why Pfizer, BioNTech, and Moderna used the entire SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, rather than specific segments of it that might serve as antigens, so that the polyclonal antibody immune response generated would be broad and unlikely to be “escaped” with single mutations—or even multiple mutations. A recent review article suggests that immune escape by variants of SARS-CoV-2 is a possibility, but one that hasn’t been definitively observed or demonstrated yet:
So is there cause for concern? Clearly, variability in the spike glycoprotein can affect the efficiency of antibody neutralisation. The role of spike protein variability inT cell immunity is likely to be elucidated in experimental studies in the next few months; a priori, the enhanced repertoire of T cell epitopes makes the loss of cytotoxic activity or recognition improbable. But only ongoing clinical trials will show whether vaccinated individuals recognise SARS-CoV-2 variants differently, and whether mutations decrease vaccine protection in some vaccinated individuals. The ongoing phase 3 trial of an adenovirus-vectored spike-based vaccine (Johnson & Johnson, NCT04505722) in South Africa, where the 501Y.V2 (B.1.351) strain with the Glu484Lys substitution is rapidly replacing pre-existing variants,11 might provide an opportunity to examine this question. Ultimately, most vaccines are based on a recombinant spike protein sequence.
And, echoing what I’ve said before:
Thus if evidence emerges that particular variants do appear to influence vaccine efficacy, it should be possible to periodically reformulate the vaccines so that they better match the circulating strains.
Exactly. If there emerge SARS-CoV-2 variants that are less susceptible to the immunity produced by COVID-19 vaccines, the answer is to reformulate the vaccines!
Now, let’s compare the passage above to what Andrew Wakefield wrote about MMR and vaccines:
Antibiotic use has selected out multiply resistant, more dangerous, and more pathogenic strains of bacteria. This growing threat has led what many senior public health officials in the UK and the U.S. to describe as the “post-antibiotic apocalypse” and the “end of modern medicine.” It is estimated that 50,000 annual deaths occur in Europe and the U.S. from infections that “antibiotics have lost the power to treat.” So in fewer than 80 years, we have reached the point at which, for example, with prosthetic surgery, wards are being closed down, patients are being sent home, and operations are no longer possible, because once the prosthesis becomes infected with such bacteria, it is virtually impossible to get rid of them. Are vaccines destined for a similar fate? It’s a very interesting question. One answer is, why not? For vaccines, resistance equates to strains of the microbe, the virus, or the bacteria that can elude the imperfect immunity created by the vaccine.
See what I mean? Dr. Vanden Bossche is using an eerily similar argument about COVID-19 vaccines and SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, to the one used by Wakefield about MMR vaccine and measles. Actually, it’s not just eerily similar, it’s almost exactly the same, namely that immunity from vaccines is an evolutionary selective pressure just like the evolutionary selective pressure from antibiotics to which the organism can become resistant. In the case of antibiotics, it’s called developing antibiotic resistance; in the case of vaccines, it’s called immune escape. And it’s true. There is always concern that a virus or bacteria can mutate to a form such that the antibodies produced by a vaccine against it no longer bind to it, so that the vaccine-induced immune response no longer kills or neutralizes the pathogen.
Again, this is an argument antivaxxers have made dating back at least to the pertussis vaccine. It’s a common argument among antivaxxers that the reason we’re seeing more cases of pertussis in people who have been vaccinated against it is because pertussis is either “evolving resistance”, or because it is shifting to a different strain not covered by the vaccine. A certain friend of the blog has written about this (at least twice), as has Skeptical Raptor. You can read the links if you want to know more, but the short version is that the acellular pertussis vaccine works but its immunity wanes (as it does after natural infection); this can be corrected with additional booster shots. Also, as I said at the time, while it is possible that the B. pertussis bacteria is developing “resistance” to the vaccine through natural selection, the evidence that it is doing so struck me as weak and preliminary, just as the evidence claiming that SARS-CoV-2 is evolving to be “resistant” to current vaccines strikes me as weak and preliminary. After all, as Nirenberg and the review article I quoted above note, while it is true that variants of concern demonstrate reduced antibody neutralization, we do not as yet have an absolute correlate regarding how high an antibody level is required to be protective, making the practical meaning of this observation difficult to determine.
Nirenberg goes further and notes that the antibody titers induced by vaccines are MUCH higher than those seen after infection, and we see hallmarks of memory responses induced by these vaccines from even a single dose, suggesting that, even though there is a decrease in neutralization by vaccine-induced SARS-CoV-2 antibodies, that might not portend a loss in protection. (Indeed, thus far, it appears that this is the case.) Even if it were evolving resistance, once again, the answer would be to reformulate the vaccine in order to include the altered antigens, the same conclusion made when considering the possibility that B. pertussis was evolving resistance or that evolutionary drift was leading to the predominance of strains not covered by the vaccine. Again, the possibility that COVID-19 might be developing “resistance” to vaccines or “immune escape” is not a reason to halt the vaccination campaign. It’s a rationale for developing reformulated booster vaccines that cover variants not well covered by the currently-used COVID-19 vaccines.
In fact, I basically said the same thing in 2019 when writing about Andrew Wakefield’s invocation of the same argument regarding the MMR vaccine and measles variants. I noted then that there was no evidence that mass vaccination with MMR had produced variants of the measles vaccine resistant to the immunity produced by the vaccine, just as I note now that there is as yet no evidence that SARS-CoV-2 variants are resistant to the immunity produced by current COVID-19 vaccines.
Up to this point, at its core and leaving aside minor variations, Dr. Vanden Bossche’s argument about COVID-19 vaccines and COVID-19 is pretty close to exactly the same argument that Wakefield fallaciously made about MMR and measles. It’s at this point, though, that Dr. Vanden Bossche throws in a twist specific to COVID-19 in which he argues that undertaking a mass vaccination campaign during a pandemic is dangerous. Why? He claims that it’s because there’s so much coronavirus circulating and so many people might produce suboptimal levels of antibody to the virus that, as is the case when antibiotics are used at levels too low to eliminate bacteria and thereby result in strong evolutionary selection for resistant strains of bacteria, a mass vaccination program is doomed to result in resistant variants of coronavirus, particularly when the vaccination program has started out “targeted”:
As if this was not already heavily compromising innate immune defense in this population segment, there comes yet another force into play that will dramatically enhance morbidity and mortality rates in the younger age groups: MASS VACCINATION of the ELDERLY. The more extensively the later age group will be vaccinated and hence, protected, the more the virus is forced to continue causing disease in younger age groups. This is only going to be possible provided it escapes to the S-specific Abs that are momentarily raised in previously asymptomatically infected subjects. If the virus manages to do so, it can benefit from the (momentarily) suppressed innate immunity, thereby causing disease in an increasing number of these subjects and ensuring its own propagation. Selecting targeted mutations in the S protein is, therefore, the way to go in order for the virus to enhance its infectiousness in candidates that are prone to geting [sic] the disease because of a transient weakness of their innate immune defense.
This is a very confused argument. First of all, note how Dr. Vanden Bossche is conflating vaccine-induced immunity with natural immunity. He’s arguing that vaccinating the elderly protects them, but because the virus will therefore be “forced” to infect the young it will only be able to do so if it can somehow escape immunity to the antibodies to spike protein (S-specific Abs) transiently raised in asymptomatic subjects. (He bases this on the observation that in those infected with COVID-19 asymptomatically, S-specific Ab levels decline faster than in those with symptomatic infections.) He’s also conflating innate immune responses with specific immune responses induced by either infection or vaccination. I’ll refer you to Nirenberg’s demolition of Dr. Vanden Bossche’s nonsense about “innate immunity”, as he explains why it’s nonsense better than I can.
What I’ll do instead is to point out that Dr. Vanden Bossche, whether he realizes it or not, is supporting the “conventional argument” with respect to COVID-19 vaccination. Specifically, scientists have long been pointing out that, the more we let COVID-19 circulate, the more likely virus variants that can escape the immune response to the vaccine (and/or to natural infection) are to emerge, and they use this argument as a rationale for vaccinating as many people as possible as fast as possible, in order to slow that circulation of the virus to as low a rate as possible, thus reducing the opportunities for strains resistant to the vaccine and strains able to re-infect previously infected people to emerge. Basically, it’s a race against evolution to get as many people as possible vaccinated before the virus can evolve “resistance” to the vaccine, and we’re fortunate that, contrary to Bossche’s claim, SARs-CoV-2 does not mutate very fast for an RNA virus.
But wait, says Dr. Vanden Bossche. Mass vaccination will only work if the vaccine prevents or decreases transmission; i.e., if it is not “leaky” (although he doesn’t use the term). His argument is that the COVID-19 vaccine is “leaky”, that it does not prevent transmission, allowing the evolution of nasty variants in the absence of symptomatic disease. So-called “leaky” vaccines are vaccines that prevent disease, but do not appreciably slow transmission of the pathogen. An example of a “leaky” vaccine is the vaccine against Marek’s disease, highly contagious and deadly viral disease of chicken that is a major problem in the poultry industry, and Dr. Vanden Bossche relies on this precedent, as Nirenberg explains:
For a moment though, let’s entertain the notion that the vaccines are leaky. In general, you would have a hard time identifying any human vaccine that could be called leaky (though emerging findings regarding influenza vaccines give hints that there may be a leaky vaccine effect involved, given their excellent efficacy among children, who are critical vectors, I am not so convinced- though if we do grant that they are leaky, this only serves to undermine Bossche’s argument). The classic example of a leaky vaccine is actually the one for Marek’s disease, caused by a herpesvirus that infects chicken and causes lymphoma among other illnesses. It has been observed that over time Marek’s disease virus has become more virulent, and this has been attributed classically to a leaky vaccine effect.
As I noted when Andrew Wakefield explicitly used the example of Marek’s disease to claim that a “leaky” vaccine to MMR would cause a global catastrophe by selecting for deadly measles variants, yes, a leaky vaccine changes the selective pressure and permits the evolution of highly virulent strains because the virus retains the ability to continue to spread among vaccinated populations, leading to the vaccine selecting for the most virulent mutations. However, even if this phenomenon occurs with a human vaccine—it doesn’t, as far as we know—that’s an even more compelling reason to be vaccinated. After all, if a human vaccine lets deadlier versions of a disease flourish, that is all the more reason to be protected from those deadly strains. As any chicken farmer knows (or any veterinarian like Dr. Vanden Bossche should know), vaccinating against Marek’s disease has population health benefits in that it prevents mass death due to the disease, even if the vaccine can allow more virulent strains to evolve. Moreover, as Nirenberg points out, there is an increasing body of evidence that the COVID-19 vaccine is not “leaky”. Sure, we don’t yet have a firm grasp of how much the vaccine decreases transmission, but there is good emerging evidence that it does significantly decrease transmission. He also points out that there is new research challenging the previous dogma that “leaky” vaccines always select for more virulent strains of pathogen and cannot produce herd immunity.
Basically, Dr. Vanden Bossche’s open letter is a mess that directly channels Andrew Wakefield. As I like to say, if you ever write anything that channels Andrew Wakefield, you really should reconsider your life choices.
Who is Geert Vanden Bossche?
What’s particularly dangerous about Dr. Vanden Bossche’s misinformation is that, on the surface, he appears to be a vaccine expert, whom antivaxxers touting his open letter (and all the follow-up “science” he’s been Tweeting and posting to his website) have been describing as a “world’s expert” in vaccines. Before this open letter, I hadn’t recalled ever having heard of Dr. Vanden Bossche before, so I looked around. His LinkedIn profile lists several impressive positions, including Head of the Vaccine Development Office for the German Centre for Infection Research (for seven months, August 2017-February 2018); Chief Innovation & Scientific Officer for Univac, where he claimed to be an inventor of a new vaccine technology based on natural killer (NK) cells (2014-2016); and the managing director of VARECO, claiming to be a consultant about vaccine development (2012-present). He also states that he’s worked with GAVI: The Vaccine Alliance and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, although searching the websites, I could find no reference to him other than a report written by him and others to GAVI about progress on an Ebola vaccine. He does apparently have some history working on vaccines.
However, Dr. Vincent Iannelli asked the question, “Who is Geert Vanden Bossche?” too and is…unimpressed. And so am I. I searched PubMed for what I expected to be an extensive publication record on vaccines and found…eight publications, the most recent of which was from 1994 and none of which have anything to do with vaccines. However, Dr. Vanden Bossche’s claims to have worked with the Gates Foundation, GAVI, and other vaccine-related enterprises does seem to be legitimate, which makes me wonder: Has he gone crank or is he a grifter?
It’s here that his LinkedIn profile helps, specifically, his entry under Univac:
I founded Univac as [sic] inventor of a new vaccine technology which I subsequently further developed as CSO of the Company. The technology enables the development of universal vaccines educating the host immune system to redirect immune targeting away from canonical antigens to a widely divergent spectrum of vitally vulnerable pathogen-derived ‘self-mimicking’ antigens, irrespective of MHC polymorphism. Although ‘non-self’ and exposed on the surface of infected or pathologically altered cells, these antigens are not effectively recognised upon natural infection or disease.
This new type of vaccines harnesses the power of the immune system by unlocking the untapped potential of self-centered Natural Killer (NK) cells capable of recognising these unconventional antigens. The resulting type of immune response is unprecedented and licenses the host immune system to readily eliminate infection or to cure disease across a broad range of unrelated pathogens and/ or mammalian species. This sharply contrasts with conventional targeting of natural immune responses as induced by conventional vaccines.
Because of their fast (NK cells) and universally protective effect, Univac vaccines are uniquely suited to prevent pathogenic agents from escaping host immune responses as of an early stage of infection or immune-mediated disease. The technology obviates the need for traditional adjuvants, multiple boost injections or expensive manufacturing processes and is readily compatible with intradermal or mucosal administration. Hence, it also offers unprecedented advantages in terms of safety, convenience and cost-effectiveness.
And now, back to his open letter:
Paradoxically, the only intervention that could offer a perspective to end this pandemic (other than to let it run its disastrous course) is …VACCINATION. Of course, the type of vaccines to be used would be completely different from conventional vaccines in that they’re not inducing the usual suspects, i.e., B and T cells, but NK cells. There is, indeed, compelling scientific evidence that these cells play a key role in facilitating complete elimination of Covid-19 at an early stage of infection in asymptomatically infected subjects. NK cells are part of the cellular arm of our innate immune system and, alike [sic] natural Abs, they are capable of recognizing and attacking a broad and diversified spectrum of pathogenic agents. There is a sound scientific rationale to assume that it is possible to ‘prime’ NK cells in ways for them to recognize and kill Coronaviruses at large (include all their variants) at an early stage of infection. NK cells have increasingly been described to be endowed with the capacity to acquire immunological memory. By educating these cells in ways that enable them to durably recognize and target Coronavirus-infected cells, our immune system could be perfectly armed for a targeted atack to the universe of Coronaviruses prior to exposure. As NK cell-based immune defense provides sterilizing immunity and allows for broad spectrum and fast protection, it is reasonable to assume that harnessing our innate immune cells is going to be the only type of human intervention left to halt the dangerous spread of highly infectious Covid-19 variants.
If we, human beings, are committed to perpetuating our species, we have no choice lef [sic] but to eradicate these highly infectious viral variants. This will, indeed, require large vaccination campaigns. However, NK cell-based vaccines will primarily enable our natural immunity to be better prepared (memory!) and to induce herd immunity (which is exactly the opposite of what current Covid-19 vaccines do as those increasingly turn vaccine recipients into asymptomatic carriers who are shedding virus). So, there is not one second left for gears to be switched and to replace the current killer vaccines by life-saving vaccines.
As I suspected, Dr. Vanden Bossche is selling something. He’s selling his idea of a vaccine designed to activate natural killer cells. It’s hard for me not to believe that he’s grifting, and this demonization of existing COVID-19 vaccines based on speculative science and no strong data yet is a sales pitch. Come to think of it, the similarities between Dr. Vanden Bossche and Andrew Wakefield strike me as stronger than ever now, given that, as well documented by Brian Deer, Wakefield basically published his fraudulent science to support the claim that the MMR vaccine causes autism in order to make a market for his own single vaccine against the measles. Naturally grifters are going to use the same arguments, although I don’t see any fraud in Dr. Vanden Bossche, other than his scientifically risible arguments.
Amusingly, as I was looking this post over earlier this morning for a final edit, I saw that no less a grifter than RFK Jr. himself had published a “rebuttal” to Dr. Vanden Bossche’s open letter by someone named Rosemary Frei, “The ‘Not-So-Hidden Agenda’ Behind Bossche’s Concern Over COVID Mass Vaccination“. Noting how quickly Dr. Vanden Bossche’s letter was embraced by antivaxxers, Frei then writes:
But from my experience as a former long-time medical writer and journalist (1988-2016) — particularly a four-month stint with media-relations giant FleishmanHillard in 1994 (yes, I’ve worked for the dark side) — this has all the hallmarks of a drug-company astroturf campaign. It’s another step in the decades-long erasure of the fact that our sophisticated and highly effective immune systems work well and don’t need any assistance from the biomedical/pharmaceutical industry.
There’s abundant evidence that Vanden Bossche has a not-so-hidden agenda. For example, just before the three-minute mark in the video interview of Vanden Bossche by McMillan, Vanden Bossche indicates he’s a long-time vaccine developer. He adds he’s now focusing on vaccines that “educate the immune system in ways that are to some extent more efficient than we do right now with our conventional vaccines.” Clearly he’s got significant conflicts of interest. Therefore he has zero credibility when it comes to advising the public or anyone else about how to avoid negative effects of mass vaccination. However, Bigtree, Coleman and others don’t point out any of the red flags. Despite taking Vanden Bossche’s assertions extremely seriously, these high-profile alternative-media figures don’t even do basic due diligence such as looking into McMillan, who’s the man who interviewed Vanden Bossche, or the company McMillan is apparently affiliated with, Vejon Health.
It appears that Vejon Health is a dormant company, if it exists at all. Even more hilariously (and a bit uncomfortably) Frei is pretty spot on when she notes:
However, this is on very shaky ground. Because, among other things: 1) Neither in the original March 6 piece nor his March 13 follow-up does Vanden Bossche provide any direct, non-theoretical evidence that this is happening; 2) The ‘natural antibodies’ that are produced after encountering a pathogen are only a small part of a quick, effective and broad-based first-line immune-system defense — known as ‘innate’ or ‘passive’ immunity — which in fact largely comprises other components; and 3) Vanden Bossche downplays the effectiveness of the antibodies our bodies naturally produce as part of the second-line (‘adaptive’) part of the immune system that also has served us extremely well for millennia.
You know what? I think that grifters recognize fellow grifters, and Frei recognized that Dr. Vanden Bossche is stoking fear of existing COVID-19 vaccines to produce a sales rationale for his own NK-based vaccine, just as Andrew Wakefield stoked fear of the MMR in order to support his own measles vaccine. Truly, in the age of COVID-19, everything old is new again, and the antivaccine grift continues.

Dr. Scott Atlas: “To Me, It’s Unconscionable When a Society Uses its Children as Shields for Adults.” 
Does Dr. Scott Atlas *really* believe it’s unconscionable when a society uses its children as shields for adults?
Jonathan Howardon December 15, 2023
Link

“To me, it’s unconscionable when a society uses its children as shields for adults.”
To me, it’s unconscionable when a society uses its children as shields for adults.
That sentence could serve as a perfect summation of my writing, had it been about the virus. Amazingly however, it was about the vaccine. It comes from an interview titled Dr. Scott Atlas on Vaccine Mandates for Children, Natural Immunity & Florida’s COVID Surge, which was posted on the right-wing misinformation site The Epoch Times. Dr. Atlas’ full quote was:
I am absolutely pro-vaccine. But to me, it’s unconscionable when a society uses its children as shields for adults. So we are going to inject our children with an experimental drug that they don’t have a significant benefit from to shield ourselves?
Dr. Atlas shared a similar message on social media. “I am a shield for my children, they are not to be used for shields as me“, he said, about the vaccine. “What kind of society uses children as human shields for adults?“, he asked, about the vaccine.
“All 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.”
Though Dr. Atlas claims to be “absolutely pro-vaccine,” his statement is anti-vaccine to its core.
First, COVID vaccines were always used to directly protect children. Regulatory agencies and the American Academy of Pediatrics were crystal clear:
Vaccinating children will protect children’s health.
Two years ago, just after the COVID vaccine was approved for adolescents, I made a list of anti-vaccine “red flags”. One red flag was someone who:
Portrayed vaccination of young people primarily as a means to benefit adults by creating herd immunity.
I further explained:
Everyone is clear: young people should be vaccinated to protect themselves… it’s just a bonus that children might not lose their mom or dad because they’ve been vaccinated.
No one proposed vaccinating children primarily to benefit adults. However, some doctors who pushed for herd immunity through the mass infection of unvaccinated youth made this bogus claim to trick parents into thinking the vaccine would not benefit children and to absurdly portray themselves as the chief guardians of children’s health. Were these doctors to admit that the vaccine could directly benefit some children- which it has– it would force them to admit an uncomfortable truth: COVID can hurt some children, especially unvaccinated ones.
Second, COVID vaccines were given to adolescents only after hundreds of millions of adults had received them. They were studied in 6 pediatric randomized-controlled trials, which involved a total of nearly 25,000 children. They were not “experimental”, though this is a typical spooky anti-vaccine buzzword, along with “injected” and “drug”. Because Dr. Atlas can no longer be a cheerleader for herd immunity through mass infection, he seeks to emotionally manipulate parents into skipping the vaccine. Who wants to inject their child with an experimental drug? The images in the video were similarly crafted to prey on parents’ fears. Scientists need a hazmat suit to even handle the vaccine, apparently.
Third, the vaccine’s safety and efficacy have been closely monitored since its authorization. While it is not perfect, there are many studies from around the world that say things like this:
In hospitalized adolescents, “179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients…
Among hospitalized U.S. patients aged 12–18 years, vaccine effectiveness of 2 doses of Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine against COVID-19 hospitalization during June–September 2021, was 93%.
Dr. Atlas, who will never share such information, was wrong. Some children do have a have a significant benefit from the vaccine, and this was always the main reason to vaccinate them. No American child has died from the vaccine, as far as I know. Yet this is the “danger” that Dr. Atlas warned parents about.
“It’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases..they become immunity and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people.”
Let’s return to my agree of agreement with Dr. Atlas: To me, it’s unconscionable when a society uses its children as shields for adults. How well does Dr. Atlas apply his own standard to SARS-CoV-2, a virus that can rarely lead to grave, even fatal, outcomes in children, unlike the vaccine?
I previously presented many quotations from Dr. Atlas that reveal his enthusiasm for using children as shields for adults. To pick one example, in an interview with Tucker Carlson from June 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
We expected more cases with more social mingling… But the fact is the overwhelming majority of these cases are in younger healthier people. These people do not have a significant problem. They do not have the serious complications. They do not die. And so it’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases, but we don’t see deaths going up, and what that means is A: we’re are doing a better job of protecting the vulnerable, B: We’re in good shape here.
We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity, population immunity, when low-risk people, with no significant problem handling this virus, which is basically 99% of people get this, they become immunity and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people…Children have virtually zero risk of getting a serious complication, virtually a zero risk of dying…Children only rarely if ever transmit the disease.
Read that again: It’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases…We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity, population immunity…they become immunity and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people…Children have virtually zero risk of getting a serious complication, virtually a zero risk of dying.
Around 2,000 children have since died of COVID, and many thousands more have been injured. These numbers would have been much higher had 73 million unvaccinated children contracted COVID simultaneously at the start of the pandemic as Dr. Atlas suggested. Conversely, much of this could have been prevented had unvaccinated children not been purposefully and repeatedly exposed to SARS-CoV-2 to theoretically protect more vulnerable adults.
To me, it’s unconscionable when a society uses its children as shields for adults.
Does Dr. Atlas disagree?

Pandemic Revisionism: Doctors Who Defend Dr. Scott Atlas Are Afraid to Accurately Quote Dr. Scott Atlas. I’m Not.
“There is an ongoing, competitive process of writing the history of the pandemic.” This isn’t just about the past. It’s about the future.
Jonathan Howard on July 6, 2024
Link

There is an ongoing, competitive process of writing the history of the pandemic.
In a prior article about a cancelled talk of mine, I’ve Been Silenced, Censored, and Cancelled. The Reason Why Matters, a commentator named Squirrelelite said the following:
To step back just a bit in perspective, I think there is an unspoken narrative here. Something along the lines of, “why is Doctor Howard still writing all these articles about these same people? Isn’t that old news now?”
And I think the first is that there is an ongoing, competitive process of writing the history of the pandemic. What happened? How did it go? What did we do right? What went wrong? What should we do the next time? Some of this is happening in the usual scientific channels, where researchers continue to study the virus, how it affects the body and the vaccines and drugs we developed to prevent or treat it. But much of it is now happening in non-traditional channels, like substack articles, YouTube videos, Congressional hearings and even this blog.
And the many of the same people whom Dr Howard wrote about in his book are major participants in that process. So it’s important to look at what are they saying now? Does it make sense? How does it mesh with what they said previously?
The second element is the aspect of self-assessment that should happen when things get really messed up. Did I make any mistakes? Was there something I overlooked in my thinking or choices? What should I change to do better next time?… But these articles show that practically everyone on his list is doubling down on their positions, or at best trying to ignore them, while continuing to argue against public health measures.
That’s one of the most insightful comments I’ve received. There’s a lot to unpack there. Every word of it is right. There is an ongoing, competitive process of writing the history of the pandemic.
Though it is both recent and well-documented, many of my articles explicitly discuss attempts to blatantly rewrite the history of the pandemic:
    • The Failed “We Want Them Infected” Movement Is Trying to Rebrand Itself As The “All We Really Wanted Was Poor Kids in School” Movement
    • Dr. Jerome Adams Was Right. They Wanted Them Infected. That’s a Fact
    • Was New York’s Spring 2020 COVID Wave an Illusion?
    • Did Lockdowns Cause Cancer?
    • Was Closing Schools an Obvious and Colossal Mistake?
The core premise of pandemic revisionism is that mitigation measures were an avoidable decision, even though no country in the world, including Sweden, avoided them. Advocates of herd immunity through mass infection claim that “vulnerable” populations could have been totally shielded from the virus and that schools and businesses could have functioned largely without interruption if only politicians and public health leaders had made better choices. These doctors insist that everything would have been just fine in 2020 had we let 230 million unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans contract COVID simultaneously, though they won’t say this outright like they did in 2020. They blame lockdowns that ended long ago for nearly every bad thing that’s happened in the world since, while they portray they virus a harmless cold for everyone but grandma.
However, while pro-infection doctors insist they were right about everything, their 2024 rhetoric is very different from their 2020 rhetoric. They knew that mitigation measures prevented infections, and so their opposition to them has been consistent. That hasn’t changed. But they no longer talk about natural immunity as the surefire path to herd immunity. Instead, they claim that from the day COVID arrived, their only concern was the well-being of children and poor people.
Let me refresh everyone’s memory about what they actually said.
NEJM Posts A Perspective Saying Stanford Should Have Corrected Scott Atlas: Why? To Look Foolish? B/C Atlas Was Correct & His Critics Were Wrong.
But first, let’s discuss why your memory might need to be refreshed in the first place.
Though we should remember those nightmarish scenes from 2020, everyone wants to forget them and some doctors are eager to ease that process along. There is a movement to encourage collective amnesia about what the virus did when it was allowed to spread out of control. Some prolific pandemic pontificators never mention what happened when the virus washed over us 2020, and then again in 2021, and then again in 2022. They want us to believe we drastically overreacted at every point, and for that reason, they never mention headlines that implicate the virus, such as Shocking Video Shows The Bodies Of NYC Coronavirus Victims Being Forklifted Into A Refrigerated Truck Used As A Temporary Morgue or School Closures Reported In Five Florida Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID. Similarly, these doctors want us to forget what they actually said in 2020, and they lob juvenille insults at anyone who reminds them.
However, I think it’s important to remember what actually happened and what doctors actually said. COVID will not be the last pandemic, and we should not let its history be so easily erased by doctors who spread misinformation about it.
I was reminded of pandemic revisionism by observing the reaction to a recent editorial in the the NEJM titled Academic Freedom in America — In Support of Institutional Voices. which discussed Stanford’s response to Dr. Scott Atlas, an anti-vaccine neuroradiologist who advised President Trump and promoted “a policy of allowing the virus to spread to generate natural herd immunity.” Though 98 faculty members published a public letter that said Dr. Atlas spread “falsehoods and misrepresentations of science”, Stanford’s president at the time, Dr. Marc Tessier-Lavigne, explained his decision to practice self-censorship by saying:
The university must provide a place where faculty can engage in unconstrained, even heated debate. It is central to what we do, and the reason for our policy on academic freedom. That function of the university would be seriously eroded if we were to publicly take sides either to disavow or to support the specific positions of a faculty member engaged in such a debate. What we do support is the right of faculty members to express their views.
According to Dr. Atlas and his defenders, however, Stanford had no right to correct Dr. Atlas because he was right about everything. Dr. Martin Kulldorff, said, “Public health policy expert @ScottAtlas_IT was correct about the pandemic while the 98 @Stanford faculty and@EricTopol were wrong.” Dr. Tracy Hoeg similarly wrote, “I’m left wondering what exactly @ScottAtlas_IT got wrong.”
Dr. Vinay Prasad, an anti-vaccine, pro-infection doctor, even authored a rebuttal titled NEJM Posts A Perspective Saying Stanford Should Have Corrected Scott Atlas: Why? To Look Foolish? B/C Atlas Was Correct & His Critics Were Wrong. It began by saying:
During the COVID19 pandemic, Scott Atlas made many controversial statements. Community cloth masking doesn’t slow the spread of COVID19. Kids should be in school. Lockdowns have no evidence of efficacy. In other words, Atlas was pretty smart. Randomized data would later show conclusively cloth masking doesn’t work. School closure is now regarded as a catastrophic error, and even Anthony Fauci regrets how long they lasted…According to them Stanford should have issued statements saying that Atlas was wrong. Really? Why? To look foolish later? The idea in the commentary is laughable.
In Dr. Prasad’s telling of events, Dr. Atlas was a wise, kindhearted spirit who cared deeply about scientific evidence and education. According to Dr. Prasad, time has vindicated Dr. Atlas. Unsurprising, Dr. Atlas agreed. He said that he was “100% correct” about everything and that he was only concerned about the fate of the “children & the poor.”
Notably, Dr. Prasad refused to directly quote Dr. Atlas. I am not so timid.
Really? Let’s see.
We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity.
Given that Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim he was right, it’s important to remember exactly what they think he was right about.
According to the House Report, The Atlas Dogma:
Dr. Atlas reached out to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Administrator Seema Verma on March 21, 2020, arguing that the federal government’s pandemic response was “a massive overreaction” that was “inciting irrational fear” in Americans. Dr. Atlas estimated that the coronavirus “would cause about 10,000 deaths”—a number he claimed “would be unnoticed” in a normal flu season—and said, “The panic needs to be stopped.”
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
Dr. Atlas’s first article this pandemic, Rentry After The Panic: Paying The Health Price Of Extreme Isolation, was published on April 13th, 2020. In it, Dr. Atlas wrote:
With a world-wide sense of relief, progress continues in containing the COVID-19 pandemic. Projections have been revised downward for virtually every major negative consequence of the disease. Few doubt that the unprecedented isolation policies and near-total economic lockdowns adopted by most countries had a significant impact on reducing deaths from the virus. And aside from New York, where almost half of the entire country’s deaths and cases have occurred, the vast majority of American hospitals were not overwhelmed beyond capacity. All of this is terrific news….
But a bigger price might now be paid from choosing extreme isolation. In the absence of immunization, society needs circulation of the virus, assuming high-risk people can be isolated. Infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — natural antibodies. Given the estimated contagiousness of COVID-19, about 60 percent of people in the community need to have antibodies to stop the spread by “herd immunity”…But the near-total isolation of everyone and the lockdown on most health care unrelated to COVID-19 must end, because it is harmful to eradicating the disease…
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
Dr. Atlas also wrote another article in April 2020 titled The Data Is In — Stop The Panic And End The Total Isolation in which he said:
The tragedy of the COVID-19 pandemic appears to be entering the containment phase… We know from decades of medical science that infection itself allows people to generate an immune response — antibodies — so that the infection is controlled throughout the population by “herd immunity”… Infected people without severe illness are the immediately available vehicle for establishing widespread immunity. By transmitting the virus to others in the low-risk group who then generate antibodies, they block the network of pathways toward the most vulnerable people, ultimately ending the threat. Extending whole-population isolation would directly prevent that widespread immunity from developing.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
During an interview from April 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
We can allow a lot of people to get infected. Those who are not at risk to die or have a serious hospital-requiring illness, we should be fine with letting them get infected, generating immunity on their own, and the more immunity in the community, the better we can eradicate the threat of the virus, including the threat to people who are vulnerable. That’s what herd immunity is. That’s a basic principle.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
During an interview from June 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
We expected more cases with more social mingling… But the fact is the overwhelming majority of these cases are in younger healthier people. These people do not have a significant problem. They do not have the serious complications. They do not die. And so it’s fantastic news that we have a lot of cases, but we don’t see deaths going up, and what that means is A: we’re are doing a better job of protecting the vulnerable, B: We’re in good shape here.
We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity, population immunity, when low-risk people, with no significant problem handling this virus, which is basically 99% of people get this, they become immune and they block the pathway of connectivity of contagiousness for older sicker people…Children have virtually zero risk of getting a serious complication, virtually a zero risk of dying…Children only rarely if ever transmit the disease.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
Dr. Atlas celebrates the mass infection of unvaccinated youth. Full video is here.
During an interview from July 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
When younger, healthier people get the disease, they don’t have a problem with the disease. I’m not sure why that’s so difficult for everyone to acknowledge. These people getting the infection is not really a problem, and in fact, as we said months ago, when you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you’re prolonging the problem because you’re preventing population immunity. Low-risk groups getting the infection is not a problem.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
During an interview from July 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
It doesn’t matter if younger, healthier people get infected. I don’t know how often that has to be said. They have nearly zero risk of a problem from this. When younger, healthier people get infected, that’s a good thing because that’s exactly the way that population immunity develops.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
During Congressional testimony in September 2020, Dr. Atlas said:
Immunity to the infection is not solely determined by the percent of people who have antibodies. If you look at the research — and there’s been about 24 papers at least on the immunity from T-cells — that’s a different type of immunity than antibodies. And without being boring, the reality is that — according to the papers from Sweden, Singapore and elsewhere — there is cross-immunity, highly likely from other infections, and there is also T-cell immunity. And the combination of those makes the antibodies a small fraction of the people that have immunity. So the answer is no, it is not 90% of people that are susceptible to the infection.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
A Twitter account compiled several videos of Dr. Atlas making (and later denying) many similar statements. In one clip, Dr. Atlas said:
There’s a positive to having low-risk groups get infection. What’s the positive? This is how you develop population based immunity. When I said this months ago, as did others, if we isolate every human being from social interaction, we are prolonging the problem, we are preventing population immunity from developing. But we isolated, and this is what we called for, isolating and protecting the high-risk groups, once we do that successfully, we don’t care if younger, healthier people get the infection.
Dr. Atlas and his defenders claim this was correct. Stanford said nothing.
There’s a gross exaggeration of hospitalizations and deaths for COVID
Squirrelelite was right- there is an ongoing, competitive process of writing the history of the pandemic– and if we don’t remember exactly what pro-infection doctors said, they definitely won’t remind us.
Dr. Atlas was one of several Stanford doctors (Dr. John Ioannidis, Drs. Eran Bendavid and Jay Bhattacharya) who predicted that COVID’s 2020 death toll would be 10,000-40,000 people and that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity. Like Dr. Atlas, these doctors- none of whom treated COVID patients- now insist they were basically right about everything. Imagine predicting that the flu was going to be worse than COVID, and 1.1 million COVID deaths later, having the audacity to claim that the passage of time has validated your initial pandemic pronouncements. In fact, advocates of mass infection are aggrieved. Although they became pandemic celebrities, they claim to have been silenced, and they feel they are owed an apology. Since they can’t admit error, they claim there’s a conspiracy to hide the truth- COVID wasn’t that bad after all. In March 2022, for example, Dr. Atlas said, “there’s a gross exaggeration of hospitalizations and deaths for COVID.” Not even the deceased are spared pandemic revisionism.
Yet, despite claiming to have been vindicated, pro-infection doctors sound very different in 2024 compared to 2020. They no longer say “We like the fact that there’s a lot of cases in low- risk populations, because that’s exactly how we’re going to get herd immunity“. Why not? What changed? Though these sentiments dominated much of the discussion in 2020, they vanished soon after that- poof!
Proponents of mass infection now seek to erase their words from history and replace them with a fictional narrative where they were benevolent souls who were only concerned about children and poor people. They berate doctors who refuse to go along with their revisionism by accurately quoting them. My talk wasn’t cancelled because it was “political”, but rather because it remembered things that powerful people want us to forget.
As Squirrelelite recognized, this isn’t just about the past. It’s possible that pro-infection doctors will once again wield significant influence if political fortune swings their way. Thanks to their rhetoric, we are almost certainly less prepared to respond to a pandemic than we were in 2019. When COVID-29 emerges, there will be an existing infrastructure ready to oppose all measures to contain it, and much of the public will have been conditioned to loathe and distrust anyone who tries. Doctors who likened public health to Nazism and made videos titled Stop Trusting The Public Health Establishment have laid the groundwork for the future failure.
As such, it’s vital to both remember exactly what these doctors said, and to understand why they desperately want us to forget it. That’s why I keep writing “all these articles about these same people.” It’s not like Stanford is up to the task.
And in the future, if anyone actually wants to defend Dr. Atlas, they should to have the integrity to accurately quote Dr. Atlas. We all know that will never happen. Even Dr. Atlas is afraid to quote Dr. Atlas, and that should tell you something.

Dr. Scott Atlas: “I Never Read the Full Great Barrington Declaration Website and Everything”.
Dr. Scott Atlas said the Great Barrington Declaration was aligned with the advice he gave to the President of the United States. He also said he never read it.
Jonathan Howard on August 18, 2024
Link

Completely aligned with the President’s policy and everything that I have been advising him on.
As readers of SBM know, Dr. Scott Atlas was one of the pioneers and leading advocates of the We Want Them Infected movement. Though he now claims he only cared about children’s education, Dr. Atlas spent much of 2020 advocating for herd immunity through the mass infection of unvaccinated youth.
Dr. Scott Atlas proposes mass infection of unvaccinated youth to reach herd immunity, April 2020. Full video is here:
As readers of SBM also know, this failed plan was formalized in the Great Barrington Declaration, which was published in October 2020. Dr. Atlas was in routine communication with its authors and was powerful enough to arrange a “secret meeting” for them President Trump in August 2020. The day after the Great Barrington Declaration was published, Dr. Atlas arranged for its authors to meet with Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar. According to an article titled Trump Advisers Consult Scientists Pushing Disputed Herd Immunity Strategy:
The Trump administration’s health chief met Monday with a trio of scientists who back the controversial theory that the United States can quickly and safely achieve widespread immunity to the coronavirus by allowing it to spread unfettered among healthy people.
The meeting with Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, which also included Trump adviser Scott Atlas, is the latest example of administration officials — including the president himself — seeking out scientists whose contrarian views justify the government’s handling of a pandemic that has killed 210,000 people and infected nearly 7.5 million so far in the U.S.
“We heard strong reinforcement of the Trump Administration’s strategy of aggressively protecting the vulnerable while opening schools and the workplace,” Azar tweeted after his meeting with Harvard medical professor Martin Kulldorff, Stanford medical professor Jay Bhattacharya and Oxford epidemiologist Sunetra Gupta.
Mainstream medical and public health experts say that seeking widespread, or herd, immunity in the manner the scientists prescribe could result in the deaths of hundreds of thousands or even millions more U.S. residents.
The trio, who Azar described as “three distinguished infectious disease experts,” favors moving aggressively to reopen the economy while sidelining broad testing and other fundamental public health measures. “Three months, maybe six is sufficient time for enough immunity to accumulate … that the vulnerable could resume normal lives,” Gupta said Monday night in appearance on Laura Ingraham’s Fox News show.
That aligns with the “herd-immunity” strategy endorsed by Atlas, who Bhattacharya said was their “point of contact” for the meeting. Atlas, a neuroradiologist and senior fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, has emerged as a favored adviser to the president despite his lack of expertise in public health, infectious disease or epidemiology…
As a reminder, none of these doctors actually treated COVID patients.
Doctors who didn’t treat COVID patients, set policy for doctors who did treat COVID patients
Unsurprisingly, Dr. Atlas specifically credited the Great Barrington Declaration with influencing his approach to the pandemic. He said this shortly after it was signed:
The prolonged lockdowns must end, and I just want to point out that now this is really meshing quite precisely with a growing body of some of the world’s top epidemiologists and scientists who this past week signed something called the Great Barrington Declaration. Scientists led by people from Harvard, Stanford, and Oxford University, would-renown infectious disease and epidemiology scientists, have completely aligned with the President’s policy and with everything that I have been advising him on, and this really refutes this sort of strange narrative that this is purely politically based, that somehow the President doesn’t listen to the science. This is the science, this is what he’s been advised by me and others.
Indeed, this was the message Dr. Atlas had been communicating to the President, who was clearly paying attention. In the video from September 2020 below, the President credits Dr. Atlas and Stanford doctors for their advice on “herd mentality”. Based on what he was told, the President believed the virus would go away “very quickly” with a vaccine and that we were “rounding the corner”.
1 million Americans have since died of COVID.
I’ve never really read through everything in the Great Barrington Declaration.
However, in January 2022, during his testimony to the House Select Committee On Coronavirus Crisis, Dr. Atlas spoke very differently about the Great Barrington Declaration. Once it became clear their vision of herd immunity in 3-6 months was just a fantasy, Dr. Atlas testified “he wasn’t familiar with it at all.” He had this exchange:
Q. Do you view the Great Barrington declaration to outline the same strategy as the targeted protection strategy that we have been discussing throughout today?
A. Well, the Great Barrington, I don’t speak for what Great Barrington Declaration represents. I didn’t write it. I didn’t sign it and it didn’t exist when I arranged this meeting. So I wasn’t familiar with it at all. I didn’t even, know there was going to be any kind of declaration written, when I arranged this meeting. So I’m familiar with the broad parts of it that I just stated.
Q. Sitting here today, do you believe that it’s outlining the same general strategy that you referred to as targeted protection?
A. I think it’s outlining the general strategy of increasing the protection of the high-risk people and ending the harms of the lockdowns. So in that sense, yes.
Q. Are there any differences between the two?
A. I’m not — I don’t really — you know, like I say, I didn’t sign the Great Barrington Declaration. I haven’t really — I don’t know what’s the details of it. I never read the full Great Barrington Declaration website and everything.
Q. Did you review or provide any input on the Great Barrington Declaration prior to its release?
A. No. Like I said, I wasn’t even aware it was being written.
Q. Did you have any conversations about it at a broad level prior to its release?
A. No. In fact, I was never — I’m not even sure there was a known intent to write something. I don’t know what they were doing. I wasn’t involved, they being the group of people who were writing the Great Barrington Declaration.
Q. Sitting her today, can you recall if there’s anything that you disagree with in the Great Barrington Declaration?
A. Well, like I say, I haven’t read the detail of it. I’m not intimately familiar with every single detail. I’ve never really read through everything in the Great Barrington Declaration, but the general thrust of Great Barrington Declaration that I said already of increasing the protection of the high-risk people and reducing and getting rid of the massive harms of the lockdowns, those two things, I absolutely agree with.
So what was Dr. Atlas’s relationship with the Great Barrington Declaration? Dr. Atlas wants you to believe:
And I just want to point out that now this is really meshing quite precisely… with something called the Great Barrington Declaration… completely aligned with the President’s policy and with everything that I have been advising him on.
He also wants you to believe:
I haven’t really — I don’t know what’s the details of it. I never read the full Great Barrington Declaration website and everything… Well, like I say, I haven’t read the detail of it. I’m not intimately familiar with every single detail. I’ve never really read through everything in the Great Barrington Declaration.
Dr. Atlas was a key government advisor in 2020. He greatly influenced our pandemic response. And he claims that his advice to the President of the United States was based on a document- a very brief document- he didn’t even bother to read.

Open Letter to Pamela Paul of the New York Times: Watch Some Interviews With Dr. Marty Makary. They Are More Important Than Peanut Allergies.
I think some respected newspapers could do a better job of being honest with their readers about some pretty basic and pretty important things.
Jonathan HowardonSeptember 21, 2024
Link
The Medical Establishment Closes Ranks, and Patients Feel the Effects
Dear Ms. Paul,
I recently read your article title The Medical Establishment Closes Ranks, and Patients Feel the Effects. Your article was an homage to a Dr. Marty Makary. I am very familiar with Dr. Makary. You had nice things to say about him and his calls for medical professionals to abandon incorrect positions. You wrote about children peanut allergies and said:
This avoidable tragedy is one of several episodes of medical authorities sticking to erroneous positions despite countervailing evidence that Marty Makary, a surgeon and professor at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, examines in his new book, “Blind Spots: When Medicine Gets It Wrong, and What It Means for Our Health.”…
While these mistakes are appalling, more worrisome are the enduring root causes of those errors. Medical journals and conferences regularly reject presentations and articles that overturn conventional wisdom, even when that wisdom is based on flimsy underlying data. For political or practical reasons consensus is often prized over dissenting opinions.
“We’re seeing science used as political propaganda,” Makary told me when I spoke to him by phone. But, he argues, mistakes can’t be freely corrected or updated unless researchers are encouraged to pursue alternative research.
You told your readers that Dr. Makary’s book would educate them about medical authorities sticking to erroneous positions despite countervailing evidence
We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
That’s ironic.
Since 2021, there have been few better examples of someone sticking to erroneous positions despite countervailing evidence than Dr. Marty Makary himself. To pick one example amongst many, in February 2021, Dr. Makary authored the article We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April. Listen to what he had to say then.
Then in May 2021, Dr. Makary said he said he was right, that herd immunity had arrived. Just watch these videos from that time. The Delta and Omicron variants arrived by the end of the year.
Dr. Makary felt that herd humanity had arrived, because natural immunity was powerful. Of course, the power of natural immunity was that it already killed and injured millions of people in its first year, and it would go on to kill and injure many millions more. Nonetheless, Dr. Makary wrote articles such as Natural Immunity to Covid is Powerful. Policymakers Seem Afraid to Say So. This article said:
The emerging science suggests that natural immunity is as good as or better than vaccine-induced immunity.
Although vaccine-induced immunity was much safer than natural immunity, this was a major theme of Dr. Makary’s at that time. He said things such as “immunity is probably lifelong.” Just listen to this video. There are many more examples.
In another article from June 2021, just before the Delta variant arrived, called The Power of Natural Immunity, he said:
The news about the U.S. Covid pandemic is even better than you’ve heard… There’s ample scientific evidence that natural immunity is effective and durable, and public-health leaders should pay it heed.
He added:
With more than 8 in 10 adults protected from either contracting or transmitting the virus, it can’t readily propagate by jumping around in the population. In public health, we call that herd immunity, defined broadly on the Johns Hopkins Covid information webpage as “when most of a population is immune.” It’s not eradication, but it’s powerful.
Dr. Makary concluded:
It’s time to stop the fear mongering and level with the public. 
As I described previously, the arrival of the Delta and Omicron variants didn’t budge Dr. Makary a bit. Whatever the virus was doing, Dr. Makary was there to tell us the only problem with the virus was the fear that some people still had of it. Literally nothing the virus did impressed him after 2020.
Medical authorities sticking to erroneous positions despite countervailing evidence
Dr. Makary called the Omicron variant “good news” and “nature’s vaccine”. Just listen for yourself.
All of this is just a small sample of some of Dr. Makary’s pandemic pronouncements. He spread gross misinformation about COVID’s risk to children, as well as the vaccine’s risk to them. He wrote error-filled articles with titled such as The Flimsy Evidence Behind the CDC’s Push to Vaccinate Children. In the interview below Dr. Makary says that natural immunity is 27 times better than vaccine immunity, even though natural immunity killed 1.2 million Americans. Meanwhile Jim Jordan spins conspiracies about the COVID’s origins. Just watch. I can give you volumes of such material.
And yet, I have never seen Dr. Makary acknowledge he was wrong about any of this. Maybe he does so in his book, but I’ve not seen him write an article titled I Was Wrong About Herd Immunity or Natural Immunity Wasn’t So Powerful After All or As It Turns Out, the Delta and Omicron Variants Mattered.
Incredibly, despite his track record, you depicted Dr, Makary as an exemplar of a brave medical truth-teller, a maverick with integrity, a rightful correction to those dastardly “medical authorities” who stick to erroneous positions despite countervailing evidence.
With trust in science on the wane, conspiracy theories and misinformation proliferating and anti-vaxxers like Robert Kennedy Jr. setting a deranged example, this may not seem like the best time to criticize the medical profession. 
And it matters that you presented him this way in America’s most prominent newspaper. Your readers will think he is a heroic figure, yet they’ll be totally ignorant of his own words. Indeed none of the commentators I read seems to have any awareness of his pandemic predictions or his current activities.
And this is a more important story.
Doctors who minimized COVID, often with the express purpose of infecting unvaccinated people with it, are being platformed at conferences at prestigious institutions such as Stanford and Johns Hopkins, often in conjunction with right-wing politicians and business interests. I suggest you read the articles Johns Hopkins to Hold “Fringe,” Dark Money Heavy COVID Summit and New Scientist Group Calling For Pandemic Answers Has Ties to Right-Wing Dark Money by Walker Bragman. This article said:
Meanwhile, Dr. Marty Makary, a surgical oncologist, Johns Hopkins professor, and Norfolk Group member, made the rounds on conservative media as a critic of the federal pandemic response and a COVID minimizer before being tapped by Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin of Virginia as a COVID adviser last January.
Last month, in its “post-pandemic” roadmap, the Heritage Foundation, a prominent conservative think tank, highlighted Bhattacharya, Kulldorff, Høeg, and Makary. Like Hoover, the foundation has gotten funding from many prominent conservatives over the years including Kochs and the Waltons. In 2021, it received $15,000 from the Charles Koch Foundation, $8,000 from Stand Together Fellowships, and $361,000 from DonorsTrust.
Under these influences, an alternative narrative of the pandemic is being written where the We Want Them Infected Movement never existed, and the only problem with SARS-CoV-2 was that we ever tried to stop it. The conferences will censor important information about the speakers. None of the videos I’ve included here will be played at those conferences. This interview, for example, won’t be presented.
Despite your portrayal of him, it turns out that Dr. Makary is not some outsider who is speaking to medical authorities. He is a medical authority. He is an insider. However, he is more than a book author and professor at Johns Hopkins. He was a pandemic celebrity. He has a large social media following. He was a wrote many articles in the Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, and NY Post. He appeared on Fox News 142 times in a single year, according to the article The Dishonest Doctors Who Were Fox News’ Most Frequent Medical Guests in 2021. Dr. Makary was #2 on that list. He testified in front of Congress and advised Virginia Gov. Glen Youngkin. I haven’t done any of those things.
Dr. Makary may also have a future if Trump wins and Robert Kennedy Jr. gets to make some key appointments. Dr. Makary’s rhetoric pandemic record appealed to Mr. Kennedy at times. It’s an important story that the words of a professor from Johns Hopkins were useful to a dangerous and influential anti-vaxxer.
Your readers won’t know any of this.
MUST WATCH testimony by Dr. Marty Makary of Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. He accuses public health officials of “modern-day McCarthyism” + publishing studies not worthy of “a 7th-grade science experiment.”https://t.co/HkeXYlH7X8
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) December 17, 2021
In interview with @usnews, Dr. Makary said CDC’s relentless focus on vaccine-induced immunity and its “demonizing” of those who choose not to get the vaccine make the agency “the most slow, reactionary, political CDC in American history.”https://t.co/TIUDPUV3BI
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) August 9, 2021
Looking forward to Monday when I testify at a nonpartisan roundtable discussion with @SenRonJohnson on how we can Make America Healthy Again. #MAHA
You also quote Dr. Makary as saying:
Asking questions has become forbidden in some circles. But asking questions is not the problem, it’s the solution.
So I’ll ask why you hid all of this from your readers, especially since you claim to share a fear of mine? You wrote:
With trust in science on the wane, conspiracy theories and misinformation proliferating and anti-vaxxers like Robert Kennedy Jr. setting a deranged example, this may not seem like the best time to criticize the medical profession. 
I have also been very worried about this man and what he might do if he gets info power. I wrote two long articles this week (here and here) about the risk of Mr. Kennedy and the dangers of doctors normalizing him and sanewashing his record, as you did with Dr. Makary. You are right to be worried about Mr. Kennedy, though I wonder if you expressed your fear to signal to your readers that you are reasonable, that you oppose the real anti-vaxx loons, and Dr. Makary is not definitely one of those.
Because if you seriously think Mr. Kennedy is dangerous- and I seriously do- then you should rebuke anyone who normalizes and legitimizes him. You should tell your readers that Dr. Makary did not object when Mr. Kennedy amplified his voice. Dr. Kennedy has not done this to me, though I would be horrified and embarrassed if he did. I would immediately denounce it.
The ties are deeper than just a few Tweets. Dr. Makary is testifying with Mr. Kennedy and other such luminaries- remember Food Babe- at the Senate on Monday. He is doing so at the invitation of Senator Ron Johnson, another COVID conspiracy-theorist. According to the article Johnson Pushes Ivermectin and Vaccine Conspiracies Despite Federal Warning
Sen. Ron Johnson has made multiple podcast and radio appearances this week in which he pushes Ivermectin as a treatment for COVID-19 while fear mongering about vaccinations. And he’s continued to do so, even after clear warnings that his message is dangerous. 
This is who Dr. Makary associates with, though your readers won’t know it. You didn’t tell them. They believe that he is a brave truth-teller who stands up to “medical authorities”. We’ll find out soon if this is true. Will Dr. Makary can repudiate Mr. Kennedy and his anti-vaccine disinformation during their Senate testimony? Will Dr. Makary bring up children dead from measles in Samoa? I would.
I think you should write about that Senate hearing. Your readers deserve to know what Mr. Kennedy might do if he gains power and who he might bring with him. Having praised Dr. Makary as you did, it’s incumbent on you to inform your readers and accurately quote his pandemic record. Feel free to link to any of my videos. I am just asking you to be honest about who he is, and for some respected newspapers to do a better job of being honest with their readers about some basic things.
This is all much more important than peanut allergies.
Sincerely,
Jonathan Howard

STEVE KIRSCH

“Debate me, bro!”: Debate challenges by science deniers in the age of COVID-19
Quacks, science deniers, and conspiracy theorists love to challenge doctors, scientists, and science communicators to “live public debates” over the science they deny. I just say no, and you should say no too if you are in a position to receive such a challenge.
David Gorski on January 31, 2022
Link
Here at SBM, we don’t just discuss specific medical claims and the evidence that does or doesn’t support them, but I like to think that we go beyond just refuting misinformation with facts and science. In addition to that, we try to inoculate our readers with critical thinking skills by discussing the tactics of disinformation and misinformation. One of the most common tactics is to challenge a scientist or science advocate to a “live public debate” about the topic in question, whether it be the claim that vaccines cause autism (they don’t), whether HIV causes AIDS (it does), or regarding “integrative medicine” or “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). Regular readers no doubt can recount why quacks, cranks, pseudoscience-promoters, and conspiracy theorists have the advantage in these debates—”Gish gallop” anyone? —but there are other reasons why science deniers gravitate towards this particular tactic. Sometimes the motivations are dishonest, but more often they are not, being based instead on the false idea that such “debates” are a fair and democratic method to settle a question, whether there is a real scientific debate or not. (Almost always, there is not.) Given that I’ve been seeing a rash of challenges to a “debate” coming from COVID-19 contrarian and antivaccine social media personalities and doctors, I decided that now would be a good time to address this common tactic again, particularly given that I haven’t discussed it here since 2015 and a lot has changed, such as two years (and counting) of a pandemic that has turbocharged science denial around the world.

“Debate me, bro!” say Dr. Oz and Steve Kirsch
Regular readers of this blog know that I’m not a fan of “live public debates” with antivaxxers and quacks, and regular readers of my personal not-so-secret other blog know it even more, because I’ve written about it so many times there relative to here. Although I’ve recounted my reasons a number of times in the past, I do think that it’s worth writing about this topic again every so often, for the simple reason that it’s such a classic tactic of science deniers to demand a “debate” and then to accuse science advocates of cowardice if they decline. Why this particular topic bubbled up to the surface of my consciousness again is simple. Steve Kirsch has been repeatedly invoking this tactic again, even going so far as to justify why he prefers “live public debates” so much more. Meanwhile, Dr. Mehmet Oz (remember him?) has turned his spurious challenge to “debate” Anthony Fauci—”doctor to doctor,” yet!—into a central theme of his carpetbagging Senate campaign in Pennsylvania.
Dr. Oz has been issuing his “challenge” on Twitter for nearly three weeks now, complete with a poster:
https://t.co/se1QUYWWEU pic.twitter.com/QafZlEkxrR
— Dr. Mehmet Oz (@DrOz) January 22, 2022
Most of us who’ve followed Dr. Oz and his promotion of quackery going back to his days on The Oprah Winfrey Show as “America’s doctor”—or, as I coined the phrase, “America’s quack”—could only look on with a mix of amusement, contempt, and resignation (just look at the responses and quote Tweets if you don’t believe me) as Dr. Oz tried to milk this challenge to aid his fundraising campaign to win the Republican nomination for Pennsylvania Senator this year. Grifter that he is, Dr. Oz knows quite well that Dr. Fauci would never accept such a “challenge” and that he probably couldn’t accept such a challenge even if he wanted to given his high ranking position at the NIH. However, the marks from whom he’s trying to raise campaign cash don’t know that.
Meanwhile, a week and a half ago, Steve Kirsch, whom I last discussed in reference to his prodigious weaponization of the VAERS database on Substack to portray COVID-19 vaccines as deadly, published this challenge, “An Open Debate Challenge to the 270 “experts” who signed the Spotify letter challenging Robert Malone“. It was in response to an open letter to Spotify signed by 270 scientists and healthcare professionals about Joe Rogan, whose podcast has routinely platformed COVID-19 conspiracy theorists, antivaxxers, and disinformation promoters:
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, Joe Rogan has repeatedly spread misleading and false claims on his podcast, provoking distrust in science and medicine. He has discouraged vaccination in young people and children, incorrectly claimed that mRNA vaccines are “gene therapy,” promoted off-label use of ivermectin to treat COVID-19 (contrary to FDA warnings), and spread a number of unsubstantiated conspiracy theories. In episode #1757, Rogan hosted Dr. Robert Malone, who was suspended from Twitter for spreading misinformation about COVID-19. Dr. Malone used the JRE platform to further promote numerous baseless claims, including several falsehoodsabout COVID-19 vaccines and an unfounded theory that societal leaders have “hypnotized” the public. Many of these statements have already been discredited. Notably, Dr. Malone is one of two recent JRE guests who has compared pandemic policies to the Holocaust. These actions are not only objectionable and offensive, but also medically and culturally dangerous.
All of this is undeniably correct, which is why the letter concluded:
Mass-misinformation events of this scale have extraordinarily dangerous ramifications. As scientists, we face backlash and resistance as the public grows to distrust our research and expertise. As educators and science communicators, we are tasked with repairing the public’s damaged understanding of science and medicine. As physicians, we bear the arduous weight of a pandemic that has stretched our medical systems to their limits and only stands to be exacerbated by the anti-vaccination sentiment woven into this and other episodes of Rogan’s podcast.
This is not only a scientific or medical concern; it is a sociological issue of devastating proportions and Spotify is responsible for allowing this activity to thrive on its platform. We, the undersigned doctors, nurses, scientists, and educators thus call on Spotify to immediately establish a clear and public policy to moderate misinformation on its platform.
I would have signed this letter myself, had I known about it in time or had anyone asked me to, although I have seen reports that Rogan’s fans harassed some of the doctors who had signed the open letter, as Rogan’s fans tried to claim that the scientists, healthcare professionals, and educators who had signed the letter were trying to “cancel” Rogan because he’s a “threat to their quest for power”, going on to claim that “if the experts shut Rogan up, there’s no one with a large enough platform to challenge them”. I do have to admit to seeing the fact that someone with an audience as large as Rogan’s would be so threatened by such a relatively mild open letter and that his fans would go so ballistic over it as evidence that Rogan knows what he’s doing. That being said, let’s look at Kirsch’s response:
To the 270 scientists, medical professionals, professors, and science communicatorswho signed the letter to Spotify complaining about medical misinformation:
We challenge every Professor and medical doctor (MD) who signed the Open Letterto a live recorded Zoom debate at 10am PST on January 28, 2021 for 3 hours. The purpose is to identify and expose any misinformation on the Joe Rogan podcast cited in the letter (JRE #1757).
We are old fashioned. We think scientific agreements should be settled by open discussion between scientists and not assigned to unknown, unqualified, and unnamed censors who hide deep inside the bowels of high tech companies.
I hope you agree with that and will accept our offer to an old fashioned scientific debate.
He goes on:
We will supply 12 debaters from our team which includes people such as Robert Malone, Robert F. Kennedy, and others. We will also invite Joe Rogan to attend if he is available.
This response is obviously nonsensical on its surface. How would a “debate” involving even a fraction of the 270 professionals who signed the letter against 12 of Kirsch’s hand-picked antivaxxers, much less a debate on Zoom, even work? It would be an incoherent free-for-all, and no doubt Kirsch knows that. In fact, he is likely counting on it, and that no one can “win” such a debate. I also note that the “team” in his link includes 30 members, all of whom are promoters of COVID-19 disinformation. The link also reveals that this has been Kirsch’s schtick for a long time, as he adds after his list:
We will debate any qualified experts with comparable credentials in an open public fair debate to defend any of our viewpoints on vaccine safety, whether vaccines are a good idea, the efficacy of early treatments, whether ivermectin really works, why fluvoxamine should be used, whether masks work, etc.
The only problem is that NOBODY will debate us. They will claim privately that everything we say is false, yet they REFUSE to debate us in an open public debate.
We’ve asked the CDC, FDA, NIH, mainstream media talking heads, members of Congress, members of the medical community, etc. No takers.
I wonder why, particularly given the proposed “rules” of the “debate,” which might seem reasonable on the surface but would be guaranteed to produce a free-for-all, particularly Rule #6:
Control is given to each side for 6 minutes at a time. That side “has the floor” and can ask the other side questions, interrupt the person, etc. This is how it works in a Congressional hearing where the Members ask questions of the witness and can interrupt the witness at any time. The side in control can assign the “floor” to a single team member to use or control may be shared among multiple team members. The important feature is the side in control has full control and can interrupt the opposing side if they feel the questions are not being answered and the other side is running down the clock and not answering the question. There is no limit to the topics covered in the 6 minutes. We suggest one questioner and one topic for each 6 minute slot, but that is just a recommendation.
How much would you like to bet that Kirsch’s side would constantly interrupt the pro-science side and wouldn’t let them complete an argument? Amusingly, Kirsch is becoming increasingly desperate to rope someone into his “debate” that he’s now offering $1 million (or even saying they can name their price) to members of FDA and CDC committees in charge, respectively, of approving vaccines and making recommendations for which ones should be incorporated into the recommended vaccination schedule, how many doses, and at what ages. In this, he reminds me of Jock Doubleday, whose “challenge” offered large sums of money to vaccine advocates to drink all the vaccines in the schedule at one sitting, or RFK Jr.’s similar “challenge,” in which he offered $100,000 to anyone who could refute all the studies that he had amassed to show that vaccines cause autism.
On Saturday, Kirsch was echoing Dr. Oz’s bogus “challenge” to debate Dr. Fauci, just not with Dr. Oz. Rather, he shared a Change.org petition demanding that Dr. Fauci do a live TV debate with “opposing doctors,” because a Change.org petition is so likely to change Dr. Fauci’s mind. The panel of doctors from which Dr. Fauci could choose include a list of doctors, most of whom been featured on this blog at one time or another for promoting COVID-19 disinformation, including Drs. Peter McCullough, Ryan Cole, Harvey Risch, George Fareed, Pierre Kory, Richard Urso, Paul Marik, Aaron Kheriaty, Robert Malone, and David Wiseman.
Jarringly, the Change.org petition concludes:
Whether you are a fan of Dr. Fauci or not, everyone should sign. We should all want to make this happen in an effort to lay to rest all the divisive rhetoric invading our every day conversations. Please sign this petition and pass it along using the hashtag #MakeFauciDebate
I somehow suspect that, even if such a debate occurred, it would not even come close to laying to rest all the divisive rhetoric invading our everyday conversations.
There’s another example of a call for a “live public debate” in which the purpose of the “debate” is to let the COVID-19 minimizer and antivaxxer to start “just asking questions,” a.k.a. JAQing off with questions like, “Why would you not have procured sufficient quantities of HCQ, ivermectin, vitamin D and Zinc and mandate people take a proactive approach to prevent illness and to treat the ill?” and “Why have you completely disregarded the view of the 55,000 infectious disease epidemiologists and public health scientists that signed on to the Great Barrington Declaration”? The rest of the questions are of a similar sort, in which cranks ask questions based on refuted science in a “Have you stopped beating your wife?” manner.
Does all truth come from live public debate?
I can’t resist spoiling the answer to this question by saying right away that the answer is no, all truth does not come from “live public debate”. I won’t say that it’s always a bad idea for a science advocate to agree to a debate like the sort in the “challenges” by Dr. Oz and Steve Kirsch. After all, Steve Novella showed me how it’s done back in 2012 when he accepted a challenge of convenience to debate Dr. Julian Whitaker about vaccines at FreedomFest in Las Vegas in 2012. (The Amazing Meeting was being held the same weekend in Las Vegas so Steve and I were there already.) However, it turns out that Dr. Whitaker was very bad at the deceptive debate techniques that cranks use, but also Dr. Novella was very, very good at anticipating and responding to common antivaccine arguments. Even though Dr. Novella basically mopped the floor with Dr. Whitaker, I still had misgivings. These were the same misgivings that I had when Bill Nye appeared to have wiped the floor with creationist Ken Ham in a debate of science versus pseudoscience with respect to evolution, given that it has been credibly argued that the debate was, in actuality, a disaster for science and a huge win for Ham and creationism. Basically, I view these examples as only possible exceptions that prove the rule that scientists really shouldn’t debate cranks, and here’s why.
The main reasons that debating cranks is pointless at best, and counterproductive at worst, are well-known to most regular readers of SBM. Common “live public debate” formats favor science deniers because they are not bound by science or even the truth. They are free to Gish gallop to their heart’s content; that is, to “baffle them with a torrent of BS” that includes obscure studies, bad studies, studies that don’t support their points, and even irrelevant information that superficially to nonexperts appears to support their arguments. Unless a scientist or science communicator is not only very skilled at dealing with this technique but also very familiar with the deep well of studies ranging from the highly dubious to the good studies misrepresented by the science denier, it is easy to fall into the trap of trying to swat down each gallop in turn and have no time left to make an argument for science. Such “debates” also value glibness, rhetorical skill, and the debater’s charisma far more than facts, logic, reason, and science.
Even worse, contrary to politics and other areas where there is not necessarily a “right” or a “wrong” answer and the value of different ideas can be assessed through argumentation and debate, science does have actual right and wrong answers. Evolution is real. Vaccines do work and don’t cause autism. COVID-19 is deadly to a small percentage of the population that is large enough to have produced a death toll in the US approaching one million, and the vaccines do work to decrease transmission and dramatically decrease the chances of one becoming seriously ill and dying of the disease. mRNA-based vaccines do not “permanently alter your DNA”. “Debating” these issues in the sort of forums that Kirsch wants serves no purpose other than falsely elevating the status of cranks and the pseudoscience and conspiracy theories that they peddle to falsely appear to the public to be in the same ballpark as that of real scientists and valid scientific conclusions, even when those conclusions are not as certain as the conclusions that vaccines do not cause autism and evolution explains the diversity of life.
Because they cannot convince actual scientists and experts in the fields whose science they deny or in which they embrace pseudoscience with evidence and science, science deniers tend to look to the public or validation. Hence, they portray science as being decided more by a democratic process than scientific evidence that eventually persuades other scientists. That is why they appear to believe that science is decided in public debates and view the quite proper reluctance among scientists like myself and skeptics to engage cranks in such spectacles as “cowardice”. It is not, but cranks continue to labor under the delusion that science is somehow decided in such forums, which are a variant of a sort of argumentum ad populum, in which something is argued to be true because it is popular or, in a debate, an argument is thought to be closer to the truth because it is more popular; i.e., it sways more people than the opposing argument.
Science doesn’t work that way. It is decided on evidence presented at scientific conferences and peer-reviewed journals, where the real scientific debate plays out until it is temporarily settled and scientists come to a provisional consensus. That provisional consensus, of course, is always subject to change as new observations, data, and experimental results come to light, but it takes observations, data, and experimental results to change the consensus, not “live public debates”. Such “live public debates” are meant for one thing and one thing only: To sway public opinion to a viewpoint not supported by science, in the process elevating pseudoscience or the unproven to the same plane as the scientific consensus as a scientifically viable “alternative”.
If Steve Kirsch or his motley crew of quacks truly wanted to convince scientists of the validity of their claims, they would publish their data and do battle where scientists normally do battle, in the scientific literature and at scientific conferences, rather than issuing vacuous and deceptive “challenges” to scientists who refute their misinformation. “Live public debates” might sway a few souls when the odd hapless scientist or skeptic unprepared for the Gish gallop makes the mistake of going up against a smooth-talking crank, but the scientific consensus remains unchanged. Someone like Burzynski can change my mind and the minds of my fellow Skeptics™ regarding his use of antineoplastons to treat cancer. It just takes him publishing all the evidence from his completed phase 2 clinical trials instead of 42.5% of one. If we find the data compelling, we will start to rethink our positions.
All of this is why I generally decline challenges from cranks to “debate” and don’t care if they portray my refusal to “debate” them as cowardice. It’s been my policy going back to at least 2007, and I haven’t suffered for it. If a crank is really interested in a “debate”, sometimes I’ll proffer a counteroffer for a written debate on our blogs, with each of us linking to each other’s responses. Interestingly, no one has ever taken me up on that counteroffer. I wonder why.
Actually, I don’t. Steve Kirsch has apparently received such counteroffers before. In fact, hilariously, he’s been in an exchange with people who think that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19 either hasn’t been isolated or doesn’t even exist. He’s even doing it such a manner that, even though he’s a crank, he’s claiming the mantle of reasonableness by attacking even worse cranks. One of the virus deniers, Christine Massey, responded reiterating that the virus doesn’t exist. Kirsch, being Kirsch, couldn’t resist responding this way:
I responded to her open letter by offering up to a 5 hour zoom call with a few of my friends who do work in this area so we can settle the matter in one meeting. If she’s done early, we end early. I thought I was being generous with the time offered, but was accused of being disingenuous. The reason for 5 hours is having done this before on other topics, it takes hours, so I allow for plenty of time on both sides. Not offering sufficient time could be seen as “ducking” her challenge. She can bring as many people on her side as she wants but for something like this, I suggest a limit of 3 per side. If she wants less time, I’m fine with that!!! She can leave the room at any time if we are done early.
That’s right. Even on one of the rare occasions when Kirsch is on the right side of a scientific argument, he can’t resist by responding with a classic crank “debate me” gambit. Massey responded by saying that she would be happy to “engage in WRITING,” adding, “take it or leave it”. I laughed out loud at the reversal. Here the crankier crank was taking the role that I normally would have taken, insisting on a written debate with Kirsch, and he was having none of it. He did, however, perfectly explain why:
Insisting on a debate in writing is problematic:
     1.  it’s really easy to avoid answering questions
     2.  easy to change the topic and what we’ve seen in other instances is the responses get longer and longer and longer and go nowhere. I see this over and over.
     3.  it’s easy to fool people. For example, her open letter goes on and on. How many readers know enough to challenge her on each point? Very few.
Similarly, people like Waterloo Professor Gordon V. Cormack and UPenn Professor Jeffrey Morris are both afraid of live discussion on camera and insist on documents only.
Others are camera shy like those 270 so-called experts who want the Malone interview censored on Spotify. No response so far to my debate offer. Who’d have guessed? A written discussion with up to 270 people is impractical. Who will read the hundreds of pages of documents? Pretty much nobody.
I’ve played this game before and it never goes anywhere. I don’t think the folks I’d ask to do this would want to spend time writing papers to Christine. They don’t even have the time to prepare their own papers. Doing written documents is much more time consuming than talking because people spend the time to make it bulletproof.
Funny, but I always thought that taking the time to make your arguments as bulletproof as possible was a good thing, but apparently Kirsch disagrees. I also find it utterly hilarious that Kirsch insists on a five hour Zoom debate. Neither I nor most doctors or scientists whom I know have five-hour blocks of time free to devote to such a pointless exercise, but a lot of us do have time to write in short blocks.
You can see the projection going on here. Anyone who’s ever watched a political debate knows how pathetically easy it is to avoid answering questions; politicians generally answer the question with prepackaged talking points and, yes, change the topic until the discussion goes nowhere. Particularly ironic is Kirsch’s claim that it’s “easy to fool people” in a written debate. Actually, it’s far easier to fool people with rhetoric, Gish gallops, and emotional appeals in a live public debate. Indeed, I rather suspect that what Kirsch really means is that he doesn’t like that he can’t just keep badgering his debate opponent if he doesn’t like the responses he gets until the opponent either makes a mistake or starts showing signs of irritation or anger. Indeed, another post by Kirsch complaining about written debates, where he complains that written debates make it so that he ‘can’t get answers to simple “yes/no” questions’ pretty much tells me I’m right here.
I laughed even harder at this:
One of the commenters wrote this:
But when someone really knows their shit they would much rather handle it in a live conversation; it’s much more efficient (you don’t spend hours writing) and it reaches a wider audience, and that audience has the benefit of tone and body language to affirm (or negate) the veracity and substance of what is being said.
I agree with that.
Body language and tone have nothing to do with facts, science, and argument, and when someone who “really doesn’t know their shit” but is good at, well, bullshitting they would definitely rather handle disagreements in a live verbal debate because it’s easier to hide their lack of knowledge behind clever rhetoric. In contrast, someone who’s not a great public speaker (as in many scientists) might show nervousness and discomfort more over confrontation, even when in the right, than a smooth charismatic debater. Kirsch is basically agreeing that live public debates are about emotion, presentation, and showmanship, not science.
Just yesterday, Kirsch again reiterated why he prefers live debates. He starts out with why he doesn’t like written debates, basically expanding on what he said above. What made me laugh even more was that he referenced antivaxxer Del Bigtree’s asking the HHS 11 questions, as though trying to get information from a government bureaucracy for serious JAQing off questions is akin to, for example, a blog debate. In other words, he misrepresents something that is most definitely not a debate as being a debate. He then concludes:
This is the real reason why nobody supporting the vaccines wants a live debate: because with a written debate they can string things out forever.
RFK Jr. has been trying for 20 years to get someone qualified (Alan Dershowitz isn’t) to debate him live about vaccine safety. No takers.
The fact that RFK Jr. has been trying to get scientists to “debate him” for 20 years should tell you all you need to know about the value of such “debates”.
Steve Kirsch’s own experience should show why “live public debates” with cranks are useless
I’ll conclude by observing that Kirsch could learn from his own experience challenging Massey to debate whether SARS-CoV-2 exists or has been isolated. Going back to his lament over her refusal to do a five hour Zoom debate with his experts, he lists the reasons why he wants a live video debate:
I’m baffled as to why this is not a sufficient answer and this is precisely why interactive conversations work better than written requests and precisely why I wanted a video discussion. Christine will engage in video conversations with Tom Cotton, but not with people in the field who disagree with her. She doesn’t say why.
For Christine’s followers, it’s clear my answer won’t satisfy you. It seems clear to me at this point that no matter how much I write, it won’t satisfy you.
Perhaps you can convince Christine to accept the video discussion and we can clarify it then and we can finally resolve the issue. Otherwise, we will be going back and forth till the cows come home.
It likely has never occurred to Kirsch that a “live public debate” is no more likely to convince people on either side either, although I would chuckle heartily to see him or his “experts” try to respond to a Gish gallop.
Challenges to “live debates” from science deniers are challenges that scientists should, with only the rarest of exceptions, generally decline. Nothing good comes of them, as they are theater, not science. Their purpose is not even really to persuade anyone. Rather, it is to represent pseudoscience as being worthy of being on the same stage (or Zoom meeting) as science, quacks as worthy of having their beliefs presented as being of similar credibility to science-based medicine presented by real doctors, pseudoscientists as worthy of being considered equally with scientists, and conspiracy theorists as worthy of being considered equally with real experts in a field. They are a tool of propaganda and almost never a tool to get at valid science. That’s exactly why cranks love “live public debate” so much, even when faced with criticism from an even crankier crank, and, even better for them, these forums allow them to puff up their egos by convincing themselves that they’ve bested a real expert.
If that doesn’t demonstrate why scientists should politely decline such requests, I don’t know what will. To paraphrase Scott Weitzenhoffer, such debates are like trying to play chess with a pigeon; it knocks the pieces over, craps on the board, and flies back to its flock to claim victory. Depriving them of that opportunity not only drives them up the wall, but it prevents them from using you, as a scientist, physician, or science communicator as a tool to use to spread their misinformation.


Steve Kirsch: How “anti-COVID-19 vaccine” antivax often becomes radicalized and just plain antivaccine
Tech bro turned COVID-19 misinformation superspreader and antivaxxer Steve Kirsch has now fully embraced “old school” vaccine-autism conspiracy theories, demonstrating how anti-COVID-19 vaccine antivaxxers frequently become just antivaxxers.
David Gorski on June 5, 2023
Link

One consistent theme that I’ve been harping on since COVID-19 vaccines were granted emergency use authorization (EUA) by the FDA in December 2020, thus sparking a tsunami of antivaccine conspiracy mongering far beyond anything seen before the pandemic, it’s that everything old is new again in terms of the claims made by antivaxxers spreading misinformation. Basically, very old antivax tropes were rapidly repurposed to be wielded against the new COVID-19 vaccines, examples including:
    • Vaccines are harmful or even deadly (or even part of a “depopulation agenda“). Earlier this year, they even resurrected and repackaged an awful 12-year-old study that had falsely claimed that nations with more vaccines on their childhood schedule have higher infant mortality rates.
    • Vaccines “permanently alter your DNA“
    • Vaccines cause cancer
    • “Natural immunity” is better. (It isn’t.)
    • Vaccines don’t work
    • The virus isn’t deadly/is an artifact of testing/is misdiagnosed
    • The virus was made in a lab or leaked by a lab
    • Vaccines select for deadly variants, a claim first “pioneered” by Andrew Wakefield himself about the MMR and measles
    • Vaccines contain “fetal tissue” or “fetal DNA”
    • Vaccines cause Alzheimer’s disease or prion disease
    • Vaccines are full of horrible “toxins” (a.k.a. what I’ve been calling the “toxins gambit” since at least 2009)
    • Vaccines sterilize our womenfolk
I used to joke that the only reasons that antivaxxers weren’t claiming that COVID-19 vaccines caused autism—the dominant antivaccine claim since the 1990s—was because they hadn’t been approved for young children at the time. To be honest, I’m rather surprised that, now that COVID-19 vaccines are recommended for children as young as 6 months, this claim hasn’t become more of a thing, but maybe it’s just because there is so much other misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines. I anticipate that it will still eventually become a thing.
One other phenomenon that I soon started noticing was how “new school” antivaxxers, who had started out just anti-COVID-19 vaccination and justified their distrust of the mRNA vaccines because they were so new and had been “rushed” through development while expressing support for other, older, more established vaccines, were quickly becoming radicalized and increasingly indistinguishable from “old school” pre-COVID antivaxxers. In other words, “new school” antivaxxers were generalizing the “old school” antivax tropes repurposed to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about COVID-19 vaccines back to cover all vaccines. As I have said multiple times on Twitter, anti-COVID-19 vaccine antivaxxers were increasingly becoming just plain antivax.
This brings brings me to Steve Kirsch.
Steve Kirsch goes really old school antivax
What brought Steve Kirsch to my attention more recently have been a series of exchanges on Twitter, as well as a number of articles that he’s recently published on his Substack, including, but not limited to:
    • How can I be so sure that vaccines cause autism? I asked the ONE question that no autism researcher has EVER asked
    • The data is clear: the more vaccines you give your child, the more likely it is that they will develop chronic diseases including autism
    • You can prove that vaccines cause autism in one VAERS query
    • Proof: author of #1 paper showing no link between vaccines and autism is corrupt
    • Parent survey results: vaccines increase the risk of autism, autoimmune disorders, etc.
    • Vaccines cause autism
I could go on, as there are more such articles. Basically, you can tell from just the titles that Kirsch has gone all-in on “old school” antivax conspiracy theories about vaccines causing autism. He’s even latched onto the old “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory that formed the basis of Del Bigtree and Andrew Wakefield’s 2016 antivax propaganda film VAXXED and three weeks ago was really going to town with it on Twitter:
People like Matt Carey will try to gaslight you into believing that document destruction is normal and they discarded the highly statistically significant result on Black males because it was an outlier and was not in the original protocol. He's lying to you. The documents that…
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 18, 2023
Here's proof they did the subgroup analysis. It is required to report this in the DeStefano 2004 Pediatrics paper. The CDC has been lying to people for over 20 years. pic.twitter.com/A6K2aqIhFf
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 18, 2023
Truth be told, I hadn’t thought of the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory for years, even though it was a conspiracy theory whose birth I watched in real time beginning in August 2014. The long version of an explanation of the conspiracy theory and why the CDC whistleblower does not demonstrate that Andrew Wakefield was right after all can be found here. The CliffsNote version follows.
In August 2014 Andrew Wakefield released a video claiming that earlier MMR vaccination is associated with an increased risk of autism in African-American boys and that the CDC had spent the last decade covering up this link that had been found in a 2003 study but not reported properly. These charges are based the result of a “reanalysis” by Brian Hooker published in 2014 in Translational Neurodegeneration entitled Measles-mumps-rubella vaccination timing and autism among young African American boys: a reanalysis of CDC data. The study that Hooker had “reanalyzed” was from a study by DeStefano et al (and of which the “CDC whistleblower” William W. Thomas was a co-author) published in Pediatrics in 2004 entitled Age at first measles-mumps-rubella vaccination in children with autism and school-matched control subjects: a population-based study in metropolitan Atlanta. Note that Hooker’s paper was retracted in October 2014. This “reanalysis” was undertaken as a result of a CDC scientist, William Thompson, having privately expressed concerns to Hooker about in a series of phone calls in which he basically ranted about the study’s principal investigator and CDC leadership for not having done the “proper” analysis. Hooker recorded these phone calls without Thompson’s knowledge, and Wakefield found out about them, leading to a release of a video which described the “coverup” as being akin to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment and the eventual unmasking of the “CDC whistleblower.” Again, none of this, either Thompson’s claims or Hooker’s “reanalysis” of the DeStefano study showed that the MMR vaccine was associated with autism in black boys, but it all became the basis of VAXXED.
As I like to say, antivax conspiracy theories never die. They merely disappear for a while, evolve, and then rise again. I also sometimes like to quote Yoda again with respect to antivax pseudoscience and conspiracy theories, once you start down the dark path (of antivax), forever will it dominate your destiny—consume you it will. I’m watching quite a few “only COVID-19 vaccine” antivaxxers becoming just antivaxxers and being consumed by antivax misinformation. Steve Kirsch is arguably the most rabid of the bunch thus far, which is why I decided to write this post, particularly after learning through a series of exchanges with Kirsch on Twitter and by email that Kirsch had teamed up with Brian Hooker and James Lyons-Weiler, both prominent “old school” prepandemic antivaxxers.

Regular readers might remember Steve Kirsch as the tech bro turned antivaxxers who loves challenging critics of COVID-19 quackery and antivax misinformation to live public debates, a common tactic of all manner of cranks ranging from antivaxxers to creationists to climate science deniers and more. Before the pandemic Kirsch was one of two independent inventors of the optical mouse in the 1980s. After that, he started several companies, examples including the search engine Infoseek in the 1990s as well as Frame Technology Corp. (which was purchased by Adobe in 1995) and a company making a spam filter (Abaca) in 2005, becoming quite wealthy over the years. Relevant to COVID-19, early in the pandemic Kirsch founded the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF) in order to fund research into off-label treatments for COVID-19 using existing drugs already having FDA approval for other diseases. He donated $1 million himself and solicited donations from others. So far, not so bad, right? It actually wasn’t a bad idea. The problem, however, is that Kirsch didn’t seem to understand how clinical research works and what the failure rate is for testing repurposed drugs for pretty much anything, which made it unsurprising that things started going horribly wrong with Kirsch descending into COVID-19 misinformation and conspiracy theories, in the process becoming what the MIT Technology Review once called a “misinformation superspreader“:
With little government funding available for such work, Kirsch founded the Covid-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF), putting in $1 million of his own money and bringing in donations from Silicon Valley luminaries: the CETF website lists the foundations of Marc Benioff and Elon Musk as donors. Over the last 18 months, the fund has granted at least $4.5 million to researchers testing the covid-fighting powers of drugs that are already FDA-approved for other diseases.
That work has yielded one promising candidate, the antidepressant fluvoxamine; other CETF-funded efforts have been less successful. But that’s not a surprise, according to researchers who conducted them: the vast majority of trials for any drug end in failure.
What has alarmed many of the scientists associated with CETF, though, are Kirsch’s reactions to the work he’s funded—both successes and failures. He’s refused to accept the results of a hydroxychloroquine trial that showed the drug had no value in treating covid, for instance, instead blaming investigators for poor study design and statistical errors.
He’s also publicly railed against what he claims is a campaign against drugs like fluvoxamine and ivermectin. And, according to three members of CETF’s scientific advisory board, he put pressure on them to promote fluvoxamine for clinical use without conclusive data that it worked for covid.
We can see right away from this account how Kirsch reacts to disconfirming data: He denies it and doubles down, a pattern that we see in him over and over again. Moreover, since then he has only grown increasingly radical. Indeed, this part of the story really resonates because it is a clear precursor of how Kirsch became increasingly antivax. Eventually, CETF’s entire advisory board resigned, no longer wanting to be associated with him and becoming very tired of harangues by Kirsch demanding that they promote fluvoxamine based on a preliminary study, as CETF advisory board member and vice chair of research at the West Virginia University School of Medicine Judith Feinberg described:
But even she was drained by Kirsch’s constant attempts to override the data. “After one or two conversations like that, I got tired of arguing, so I started avoiding his calls,” she said.
To scientists, giving fluvoxamine a chance means running a large trial—not giving it to individual patients in the clinic, off-label and outside the context of active data collection and analysis. The board members I spoke to say they refused to publicly promote any drugs for off-label use and tried to explain to Kirsch that it’s incredibly common for exciting results from small trials to disappear in larger ones.
Avoiding his calls? After just a few email exchanges with him, I can totally sympathize with Dr. Feinberg.
Eventually, in 2021 Kirsch was promoting ivermectin as a miracle cure (with fluvoxamine) for COVID-19. By May 2021 he was that COVID-19 vaccines impair female fertility (they don’t), and by September 2021 he was falsely claiming that the mRNA vaccines kill more people than they save—150,000 killed by the vaccines—!using some truly risible arguments to claim that grew by May 2022 to a claim that mRNA vaccines have killed over a half a million people while only saving ~25,000.
In retrospect, I suppose that it should have been expected that Kirsch would eventually expand his antivaccine messaging against mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines to encompass all vaccines, but what surprised me somewhat were the enthusiasm with which he embraced them and how far down the rabbit hole he has gone to generate “evidence” to support his newfound total antivax stance. I mean, he’s even resurrected a variation of the Amish trope that was common in 2005, soon after I had first started my first Blogspot blog. It is a trope that I hadn’t thought of in a very long time, in which he claimed (falsely) that the Amish don’t vaccinated but that “only a handful” of them had died of COVID-19. (Regular readers might recall the false claim that there are “no autistic Amish” because they supposedly didn’t vaccinate.)
In which I am accused of “malicious manipulation” of data to support my agenda
In May, Steve Kirsch publicized what he called “the most important survey I’ve ever done.” It was a survey about vaccines and health problems suffered by children. He was soon touting its results on Twitter:
Mawson paper (4x): https://t.co/09jRiUwqn5
Hooker paper (5x): https://t.co/5TyyljoVMq
They both got it right. My much larger wider sample got the same numbers.
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 20, 2023
Whoa! If you are vaccinated, you are > 25X more likely to have an autoimmune disorder than the fully unvaccinated. I never knew that! Why don't doctors ever disclose that to their patients?? I'll publish the whole dataset tomorrow. Check it out… pic.twitter.com/oKEcUR92XY
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 20, 2023
The overall rate of autism among the CHILDREN of my followers (and NOT my followers) is 4.8% which is 1 in 21 kids. My followers are under-vaccinated, so my estimates are on the low side. The real number could be as high as 5.7% or 1 in every 18 kids. This is a train wreck. pic.twitter.com/vRARK1t6pK
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 20, 2023
A number of Twitter users, including myself, tried very hard to explain that an Internet survey run from the Substack of an antivax activist would be, by its very nature, so hopelessly biased that one could predict with near 100% certainty that it would inevitably show that vaccines were associated with autism, autoimmune disease, and a number of other conditions. We also tried to explain to Kirsch that Anthony Mawson’s survey was horribly designed, not evidence that vaccines caused autism, and retracted once. Hooker’s study was no better. So where does the accusation that I somehow “maliciously manipulated” the data in Kirsch’s study come from?
It started with a Tweet in which Kirsch tried to deny that his survey was biased:
I just tweeted a survey on autism. Just run that survey from your account. We’ll know in minutes. But you will be afraid to do that, right?
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 25, 2023
And:
I dare you to run this: https://t.co/fSY6I7aRZU
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 25, 2023
So I obliged him:
Silly Mr. Kirsch. He actually seems to think that my retweeting his silly survey will make it any less a silly, scientifically worthless survey. He's so cute that way; so I'll humor him, as I would a small child. https://t.co/t7KgQvNjM2 pic.twitter.com/0vvqoKcxYP
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) May 25, 2023
I was even brutally honest about the effect that I thought my retweeting his poll would have:
So swarm away! Answer even if you don't have a child with autism! It's what Mr. Kirsch apparently wants (or at least it's something he doesn't care about if you do it).😂
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) May 25, 2023
Which led to:
Is malicious data manipulation OK with you? https://t.co/7j4t9y7kos
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 26, 2023
And in his Substack Kirsch lamented:
The truth is now so bad for them that they have to stoop to malicious data manipulation techniques.
The truth is now so bad for them that they have to stoop to malicious data manipulation techniques.
I posted this poll and checked 51 minutes later on the votes and saw a 5:1 odds ratio that vaccines cause autism. This was nearly exactly as I predicted.
Then I suggested Gorski run his own poll.
I just checked on the poll 10 hours after I sent Gorski that message.
Which resulted in:
They flipped it from the vaccine causing autism to the vaccine being the magical cure for autism. This never happens in a poll unless it is being gamed.
Look at my poll now:
NOTE: This poll was deliberately manipulated to show the opposite of reality. Before manipulation it was 6:1 after:before. Now it is 1:2 the OTHER way. That sort of shift never happens unless they are attacking the poll. Obvious gaming because they don't want people to know the…
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) May 26, 2023
This is a stunning reversal from a 5:1 odds ratio (which later went to 6:1) to a 1:2 odds ratio. Basically, people who would normally have no child with autism lied and voted for the first choice so it showed the vaccines are now beneficial.
My polls weren’t gamed in the past.
Today, the opposition is now fielding armies of robot voters to manipulate the truth to support their narrative.
This shows you first hand how low these people will stoop in order to manipulate results that are counter narrative.
The only reaction that I could come up with besides a huge facepalm was: Be careful what you ask for. I also note that this is the one and only time that I’ve ever actually accepted a “challenge” from Mr. Kirsch, and it resulted in exactly what I knew would likely happen. After all, back in the day science advocates would routinely do the same thing to polls posted by creationists as a tactic to show how worthless Internet polls are as a source of actual evidence given how easily they can be influenced by where they are advertised. To be honest, even now, two weeks later, I have no idea if I had that much affect on Mr. Kirsch’s poll by myself. I was far from the only science advocate sharing it. Even so, instead of imbibing the correct lesson from this exercise, namely that his poll was biased and utterly worthless as a source of anything resembling reliable epidemiological data regarding vaccines, autism, and other health outcomes in children, Kirsch leapt to exactly the wrong explanation, namely that his poll had gotten the answer right the first time but had been corrupted by “malicious manipulation.” I’ll repeat again: If your Internet poll’s results can so easily be affected by where it is publicized, it is not a reliable source of objective information about the prevalence of a health condition or its relationship to any purported risk factors.
To top off this incident, Mr. Kirsch emailed me to ask me if I would look over his protocol in order to spot its flaws and improve it. My response was simple. I’d do it if it were a new protocol for which no data had yet been collected. However, if it was a protocol to “analyze” the “data” from his Internet survey above, then my answer would be no, because once data have been collected using a biased and scientifically worthless protocol there is no fixing it. Garbage in, garbage out. Mr. Kirsch never responded to my answer.
Steve Kirsch is now a font of old antivax misinformation
Over the last couple of months, Mr. Kirsch has become a veritable font of antivaccine misinformation of the old school “vaccines cause autism” variety. Skeptical Raptor and Dorit Reiss both addressed some of the most egregious misinformation that he’s been spewing (e.g., claims that vaccines aren’t tested against “true placebos,” a favorite old anti-HPV vaccine and even anti-MMR vaccine trope), but I’d like to conclude with one that he most recently published on his Substack, How can I be so sure that vaccines cause autism? I asked the ONE question that no autism researcher has EVER asked, with a blurb: I asked parents when they first noticed ASD behaviors in their child relative to the time of the NEAREST vaccination visit. The results were stunning.
Actually, they weren’t, but let’s quote Mr. Kirsch anyway:
If vaccines aren’t triggering autism, then the number of times a parent notices autistic behaviors BEFORE a wellness visit where a vaccine is given should be comparable to the number of times AFTER the visit.
I asked 642 parents who had previously reported having an autistic child in previous surveys to fill out my survey. I received 273 responses.
58 parents reported first seeing autistic behaviors within a month AFTER a vaccine appointment.
0 parents reported first seeing autistic behaviors within a month BEFORE a vaccine appointment.
This is stunning. It is highly unlikely you’ll get a disparity like this if vaccines aren’t triggering autism. It’s about the same as the chance of throwing a fair coin 58 times and getting all heads: 1 chance in 2.8e17 which is about as close to impossible as you will ever find in nature.
But the more stunning thing is that no autism researcher in the world has ever even thought to ask such a question. Ever.
Again, this is the same survey; so its results are, by its design, inherently hopelessly biased, unrepresentative of the general population, and scientifically worthless. Again, Kirsch’s audience clearly skews heavily antivax, perhaps with a smattering of science advocates like me who only read his drivel in order to stay informed about the latest antivaccine misinformation, and he is way too enamored of this single result. Why would this result be uninformative or even outright meaningless. The answer is simple: confirmation bias.
This is the problem with relying on anecdotes over data collected according to a protocol designed to be scientifically rigorous and thereby avoid bias as much as is humanly possible. Human memory is fallible, and, as was discussed on science and medicine blogs many times before back around 2007, parents tend to remember what conforms to their current beliefs and forget (or downplay in their memory) what does not. None of that stopped Kirsch from emailing me (and I had warned him that his emails were fair game for blogging after a certain date):
You look at the time the parent first noticed autistic behaviors relative to the most recent vaccination date.
It’s a 1:20 odds ratio for before:after! It’s really stunning.
Isn’t a shame NOBODY will do this???
It would expose the truth.
My response was simple and blunt:
Funny how you keep discovering antivax claims that were debunked a long time ago and then regurgitate them as though they were brand new.
Also, the vast majority of these claims of children “regressing” after vaccination are cases of confirmation bias. For a number of these cases, we have evidence that the child had been showing signs of ASD before the vaccines blamed by the parents for their regression. I recall one case where there was video evidence but can’t find the link right now, and Brian Hooker’s story is full of holes, as was discussed years and years ago by science communicators and advocates:
Double checking Brian Hooker’s story in VAXXED
Brian Hooker’s vaccine injury claim denied by NVICP
Sadly, truth be told, human memory is very fallible and malleable. It is quite common for parents to blame vaccines for their child’s regression or just autism even though the child had been showing signs of it before vaccination. Lest you think that it can’t be “coincidence,” it can, as was demonstrated in 2016, with an additional explanation why most anecdotes are worthless for proving causation:
Why are there so many reports of autism following vaccination? A mathematical assessment
5 reasons why anecdotes are totally worthless
Also, your “survey” is not a representative sample, as you yourself demonstrated when you challenged me to share it and my Twitter followers answers changed the results and eliminated the correlation. Dude, you are so bad at this it isn’t even funny anymore. It’s just pathetic.
If you think I’m too “nasty,” please remember that Kirsch has been intermittently emailing me for a while with his “challenges,” to the point where they have become tiresome and annoying.
How many times have we heard the story of a mother who is utterly convinced that her child’s regression started right after vaccines but then, when her story is more closely examined, that is found not to be the case? Another example came to mind after this email exchange. In the Autism Omnibus hearings, an expert examined videotapes of the child of one of the claimants (Michelle Cedillo) at ages 6-8 months submitted by the parents to prove that their child had been fine before vaccines. Sadly, the expert saw clear signs of autism in these videotapes, as well as signs of the parents adjusting their behavior to her. It is unsurprising that Kirsch was unaware of this background, as he is a newbie to the vaccine-autism conspiracy theory, but he really did embarrass himself acting as though he had discovered something new. No doubt he will react as other antivaxxers have reacted to such observations and accuse me of attacking parents as liars, when nothing could be further from the truth. Confirmation bias is a powerful force in human memory. We are all prone to it and all experience it. It takes active effort to counter it, which post of us do not do.
What happened to Steve Kirsch?
When I started this post, I had planned on going through a larger number of hoary antivax tropes from 15+ years ago that Kirsch has been digging out of the muck, wiping off, and selling them as new to the “new school” antivaxxers who make up most of his readership, but then I decided that it wasn’t necessary, particularly after Skeptical Raptor and Dorit Reiss had done it recently. Instead, relating this story led me to wonder: WTF happened to Steve Kirsch? Was he always like this and no one noticed, or did he somehow become this way?
The answer, I suspect, is a combination of both. Whenever asking why people fall so far down the rabbit hole of antivaccine misinformation, I often like to remind everyone that every human being is vulnerable to a similar tendency and to remind myself that it could happen to me, too, although it would likely be different conspiracy theories and pseudoscience given how long I have combatted antivax misinformation. Conspiracy theories appeal to us because they make us feel important and heroic; We are the chosen few with hidden knowledge facing “persecution” for spreading The Truth. It’s very much like religion that way.
In Kirsch’s case, although I can’t speak to what he was like before the pandemic, the indications were there very early on after COVID-19 hit and he started CETF. At the time, it was clear that he just wanted to help by encouraging research into repurposed drugs that might be useful against COVID-19, a not unreasonable strategy. What tripped him up, as is often the case, was a combination of ignorance and arrogance. His ignorance came from not knowing how often repurposed drugs fail rigorous clinical testing against a new disease even when it seems as though they should work, or, more pertinently, how often the ultimately fail after initial promising preliminary results (e.g., the case of fluvoxamine). His arrogance came in not listening to the actual experts who tried to caution him how often repurposed drugs fail validation in clinical trials and not to get to excited about initial promising results with fluvoxamine. That same arrogance led him not to accept negative clinical trials of hydroxychloroquine.
Indeed, even in 2021, when asked about his bucking the experts, Kirsch said:
“When you need to characterize me, you need to say that Steve Kirsch doesn’t go with majority votes on interpreting data,” he told me when I asked about his views on ivermectin, which he insists is a silver bullet against covid. “If you wanna find someone to debate me for ten thousand dollars, or a thousand dollars, I’m happy to do that, just for your benefit.”
These days, anyone who follows Kirsch on Twitter or reads his Substack knows that he’s been offering $5 million to or betting $5 million to challenge anyone who can prove to him that vaccines don’t cause autism, while challenging anyone who contradicts him to “debate” him and his antivax “experts.” It is a pathetic scene, really, but revealing. Kirsch appears to equate confidence in one’s views with correctness, which leads him to conclude that anyone who won’t debate him or accept his bets over evidence regarding vaccine safety must be wrong because they lack sufficient confidence in the science to accept his challenges.
Indeed, Richard Char, general counsel of M10, the latest company founded by Kirsch and one from which he ended up stepping down as CEO after his antivax advocacy had become a distraction, was quoted saying:
He is very smart, and knows that he is very smart, and sometimes he behaves like he thinks he’s the smartest guy in the room, whether he is or isn’t.
These days, I would say that Mr. Char is being too charitable. Mr. Kirsch is not coming across as very smart to me these days, even if he genuinely does believe he is saving the world. However, he clearly does believe he is the smartest guy in the room, which has apparently led him to think that he can master clinical trials, autism, vaccine science, epidemiology, and survey design by himself or with the help of a few crank scientists like Brian Hooker. Part of this might also be fueled by his experience as a cancer patient:
Saving the world has been a theme of Kirsch’s life for years. “There are two ways I’ve discovered that I may be able to save the world,” he told an IEEE Spectrum reporter in 2000. “One is to reduce the threat of nuclear war. Another is to identify an asteroid that is going to hit the planet.”
His efforts became more focused on medical research when, in 2007, he was diagnosed with a rare blood cancer. His foundation shifted focus to one goal—curing Steve Kirsch—by supporting one of the few scientists looking at the disease. After several failed attempts to stop the progression of his disease, he designed his own protocol for chemotherapy and doctor-shopped to find an oncologist who would give it to him. He’s now outlived his initial prognosis by several years.
Thus, a combination of wanting to save the world plus having apparently been right once—or, far more likely, just very lucky—about a medical issue appear to have led him to believe that he’s right now about early treatments for COVID-19 and mRNA-based vaccines, even though in this case he clearly is not. It’s a shame. Someone with his drive and apparent smarts could have done so much good. Instead, he’s contributing to fear and distrust of not just COVID-19 vaccines but now all vaccines, thus endangering the lives of everyone.
Indeed, just yesterday, he asked, Will you help me to redpill America? In the Substack post, he is asking:
Here’s something you can do right now that can really make a huge difference.
Call up your pediatrician and ask her to publish the 1 month autism before:after odds ratio for her practice on their Twitter feed like this: “Our 1 month AOR is 0:10.”
Nobody will know what that means except for us.
They can do it just for the most recent N patients that were diagnosed with autism where they choose N. So this can take as little as a few minutes of their time (e.g., N=5).
The one month before:after odds ratio is simply : .
Once these numbers are published, it’s all over.
And they cannot be punished for publishing truthful information as long as they make no further comment about it. Leave that to me.
He truly doesn’t seem to realize that this would be hopelessly biased because the only physicians likely to be willing to respond to his challenge as relayed to them by patients who read Kirsch’s blog are likely to be overwhelmingly antivax. He just refuses to believe that uncontrolled Internet polls and reporting campaigns like this are not valid methods for determining the prevalence of any condition or whether any purported risk factor for that condition might actually be causative.
He is simply too arrogant and ignorant to learn, and as a result instead of being remembered for to find early treatments for COVID-19 his legacy will be to be remembered as one of the more prominent and wild spreaders of conspiracy theories and misinformation about COVID-19 and vaccines.

Steve Kirsch and Brandolini’s law
The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.
Jonathan Howard on June 24, 2023
Link

Businessman Steve Kirsch has never cared for a patient with COVID. Although he has no real-world responsibility for the consequences of his words, he has become an outspoken anti-vaccine advocate, loudly opining on what he would do if he had such responsibility.
His most recent salvo occurred in the context of the kerfuffle involving debates in medicine. I told Mr. Kirsch that while I would not participate in a live debate, he or anyone else has had always been welcome to write a rebuttal to any of the 100 articles I’ve posted here. To his credit, Mr. Kirsch accepted my offer, and provided 9 reasons—a veritable Gish Gallop—as to why he feels unvaccinated children should suffer from COVID in perpetuity. In this article, I will only discuss Mr. Kirsch’s first claim, to show how he tricks his readers by omitting evidence that dis-confirms his anti-vaccine narrative.
Mr. Kirsch felt that an article of mine, which accurately reported the rate of vaccine-myocarditis (1 in 19,000 for males age 12-17) from a recent Korean study, understated its true frequency. He wrote:
The Thailand prospective study showed a 3.5% rate of myo/pericarditis in teens. So doesn’t the existence of that study, which is very inconsistent with the rates in the studies you cited, prove that your first sentence is false and misleading? And how can you be so certain your studies are better? The anecdotes I’m aware of are numerous and they all favor the Thailand study as the most accurate estimate of the rate of myocarditis post-vaccination.
It might not seem that way, but there’s a lot to unpack here.
The Thailand study referenced by Mr. Kirsch examined adolescents who received the second dose of the BNT162b2 mRNA vaccine. It found, “one case of myopericarditis, four cases of subclinical myocarditis, and two cases of pericarditis among 301 participants.” It further stated that “the clinical presentation of myopericarditis after vaccination was usually mild and temporary, with all cases fully recovering within 14 days.”
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers.
The clinical course of vaccine-myocarditis in the Thailand study is consistent with every other study thus far. The largest systematic review of adolescents and young adults summarized 23 studies involving 854 patients. It found “low incidence rate and largely favorable early outcomes of COVID-19 mRNA vaccine–associated myopericarditis in adolescents and young adults.” Even in those with abnormal cardiac imaging, a systematic review of 468 cases found that “all reported cases with abnormal cardiac MRI findings showed a favorable clinical course at the acute phase.” Another review of 276 cases reported that “Fortunately, most myocarditis cases associated with mRNA vaccines are mild in nature and do not have serious complications and require only a few days of hospital admission.” Another systematic review of 28 studies stated “the prognosis of this self-limiting condition is generally good.” As doctors have learned about the condition, they have altered their management of it. In a recent study from Canada, 56% of adolescents were sent home from the ER, while most others left after one day. Severe outcomes are possible, though they are exceedingly rare, with fulminant myocarditis being a literally 1 in a million event.
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers.
Unsurprisingly, doctors who care for sick children didn’t share Mr. Kirsch’s concern about “subclinical myocarditis”. Pediatric cardiologist Dr. Frank Han, who has actually cared for patients with vaccine-myocarditis and published a report on 63 patients with it, discussed the Thailand study previously on SBM. He wrote:
The definition of subclinical myocarditis is a patient with lab, imaging, or EKG findings consistent with myocarditis, but minimal or no symptoms (minimal chest pain, shortness of breath, or palpitations for example). The crowd that is most anti-COVID vaccination is very supportive of the finding of subclinical myocarditis in this article without considering its limitations. Cardiologists have formalized the criteria for myocarditis to avoid diagnosing every person with troponin in the blood with myocarditis. This would be misdiagnosis and, unnecessarily frighten the patient. I particularly emphasize – even if it is coming from me – a speaker who analyzes articles critically when they do not fit the speakers preconceived notions, and fails to analyze critically when the articles do match their preconceived notions, is presenting you with a biased and possibly deceptive assessment of the world.
Though Mr. Kirsch dismissed Dr. Han as an “expert” with only 3,000 Twitter followers, Dr. Han has real-world responsibility for sick children. Unlike Mr. Kirsch, Dr. Han knows troponin is a very sensitive test that by itself is not diagnostic of myocarditis. Indeed, a vigorous game of soccer can elevate troponin levels in children. Additionally, in a study of 61 patients with suspected vaccine-myocarditis who were sick enough to undergo a cardiac biopsy, 21 of them did not have myocarditis, showing the potential for over-diagnosis. Mr. Kirsch refused to share any of this information with his readers as it would undermine his claim that “the Thailand study as the most accurate estimate of the rate of myocarditis post-vaccination”. In fact, a recent meta-analysis of 15 studies calculated a rate of 1 in 15,000 for males age 12-17. I expect their methods were more rigorous than his “anecdotes”, which may explain why hospitals were deluged with sick children during the Delta and Omicron waves, but no hospital in the world had to open a vaccine-injury unit. (I shared more studies here).
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers.
It may be the case that I am minimizing “subclinical myocarditis.” However, if “subclinical myocarditis” from the vaccine is concerning, then the virus is much more worrisome. One study found elevated troponin in 7% of children who presented to the ER with COVID, double the rate found in the Thailand study. However, that study wisely concluded:
Routine troponin screening does not yield much information in previously healthy paediatric COVID-19 patients without any sign of myocardial dysfunction. Elevated troponin levels may be observed but it is mostly a sign of myocardial injury without detectable myocardial dysfunction in this group of patients.
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers.
Of course, the virus can often cause overt, clinical myocarditis in children. A study of nearly 60,000 children found that “myocarditis was the condition with the strongest association with SARS-CoV-2 infection.” A recent meta-analysis found the vaccine caused myocarditis at a lower rate than the virus. It found:
None of the incidences of myopericarditis pooled in the current study were higher than those after smallpox vaccinations and non-COVID-19 vaccinations, and all of them were significantly lower than those in adolescents aged 12–17 years after COVID-19 infection.
In contrast to nearly all cases of vaccine-myocarditis in adolescents, COVID can cause severe cardiac complications, especially in children with Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C), which has affected over 9,400 American children, causing 79 deaths. One report of 95 patients with MIS-C found elevated troponin levels in 71% of the patients, and 53% had myocarditis. 62% of these patients received vasopressor support, 80% were admitted to an ICU, and 2 died. Other studies have reported acute heart failure in children with MIS-C, and other common cardiac complications of myocarditis due to MIS-C include “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Cardiac arrhythmias have led “to hemodynamic collapse and need for ECMO support” in some children. Another study found that an elevated troponin level in children with COVID wasn’t always clinically benign. It found:
Out of 7 patients with high troponin levels, 3 (42.9%) of them were admitted to the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU), 2 (28.6%) required oxygen support, and 1 (14.3%) required a mechanical ventilator.
A study that compared classic myocarditis, myocarditis due to MIS-C and vaccine-myocarditis in children found that:
COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis generally had a milder clinical course, with a lower likelihood of cardiac dysfunction at presentation and more rapid recovery when present…COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis is mild, and patients typically have evidence of normal ventricular function recovery at discharge from the hospital.
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers, though of course, whether the vaccine or the virus causes more myocarditis is not the proper comparison, since COVID’s harrms are not limited to myocarditis and include strokes, seizures, amputations, long COVID, lung transplants, and death.
Even if one believes that “subclinical myocarditis” from the vaccine is worse than death from COVID, vaccine-myocarditis does not occur in children younger than 12. Anyone concerned with this side has no valid reason to oppose the vaccine in younger children, yet they always find a way. Around 12 million babies have been born since the start of the pandemic, and though they have the highest COVID risk by far of any children, none arrive with “natural immunity.”
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers.
Obviously, the risks of the vaccine have to be weighed against its benefits. While the vaccine is not a magic bullet, there’s copious evidence it has already protected many children from COVID’s worse harms.
Mr. Kirsch refused to share this information with his readers.
Studies Mr. Kirsch Refused to Share
Olson	In hospitalized adolescents, “179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.”
Delahoy	“Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents.”
Wanga	“Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one was fully vaccinated.”
Lutrick	Vaccine effectiveness “…was 92% against SARS-CoV-2 infections irrespective of symptom status.”
Zambrano	“Among critically ill MIS-C case-patients requiring life support, all were unvaccinated…97/102 children with MIS-C were unvaccinated. None of the 5 vaccinated MIS-C patients required respiratory or cardiovascular life support (invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or ECMO) compared to 38/97 unvaccinated MIS-C patients.”
Levy	“In 33 adolescents with MIS-C eligible for vaccination…0 had been fully vaccinated, 7 had received 1 dose.”
Olson	“Of the case patients, 180 (40%) were admitted to the ICU, and 127 (29%) required life support; only 2 patients in the ICU had been fully vaccinated. The overall effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine against hospitalization for Covid-19 was 94%. The effectiveness was 98% against ICU admission and 98% against Covid-19 resulting in the receipt of life support. All 7 deaths occurred in patients who were unvaccinated.”
Nygaard	“We identified 51 MIS-C cases among unvaccinated individuals and one in a fully vaccinated adolescent.”
Chang	“Reports of MIS-C after COVID-19 vaccination occurred in only 1 per million individuals aged 12–20 years who received one or more doses of a COVID-19 vaccine.”
Fleming-Dutra	Estimated booster dose effectiveness in adolescents 2 to 6.5 weeks after the booster was 71.1%.
Yousaf	“The overall reporting rate for MIS-C after vaccination 1·0 case per million individuals receiving one or more doses in this age group.”
Tan	Vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization was 83% in children ages 5-11.
Marks	“A higher proportion of unvaccinated adolescents (70.3%) than fully vaccinated adolescents (40.8%) had COVID-19 as a primary reason for admission. A significantly higher proportion of unvaccinated adolescents were admitted to the ICU (30.3%) than were those who were vaccinated (15.5%).”
Price	Vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization was 68% in children ages 5-11
Lin	Vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization was 88% in children ages 5-11, though this waned to 76% after several months. 7 children died, all unvaccinated.
Messiah	“Additional increased risk for persistent COVID symptoms >12 weeks included severe symptoms with initial infection, not being vaccinated and having unhealthy weight”
Cohen-Stavi	This observational study of effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine among children 5 to 11 years of age showed a vaccine effectiveness of 51% against documented SARS-CoV-2 infection and 48% against symptomatic Covid-19 at 7 to 21 days after the second dose.
Klein	Overall, 2-dose vaccine-effectiveness against COVID-19–associated hospitalization was 73%–94%.
Shi	During the period of Omicron predominance (December 19, 2021–February 28, 2022), COVID-19–associated hospitalization rates in children aged 5–11 years were approximately twice as high among unvaccinated as among vaccinated children. Non-Hispanic Black children represented the largest group of unvaccinated children. Thirty percent of hospitalized children had no underlying medical conditions, and 19% were admitted to an intensive care unit.
The larger lesson here is the wisdom of Brandolini’s law, which states:
The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.
I could (and might) go through the rest of Mr. Kirsch’s article, exposing its fake statistics, specious comparisons, and strategic omissions. However, my rebuttal here would not have been possible during a live “debate”, which explains why it’s a mistake to let performative anti-vaxxers turn children’s health into a disinformation display to satisfy their own need to be “heterodox”.

Steve Kirsch’s “mother of all revelations” about the “deadliness” of COVID-19 vaccines goes poof
On Thursday, Steve Kirsch gave his long-hyped talk about “record-level data” from New Zealand that supposedly demonstrates that COVID-19 vaccines have killed more than 10 million people worldwide. His “analysis” of illegally obtained data from a “whistleblower” was so ridden with false assumptions and rookie errors that even some antivaxxers couldn’t accept it.
David Gorski on December 4, 2023
Link

Last Thursday, tech bro turned rabidest of rabid antivaxxers Steve Kirsch finally gave a talk that he had been hyping for a couple of weeks as the “definitive” evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are not just deadly, but so deadly that, by his estimation, they’ve killed well over 13 million people. He also made a big deal of giving the talk at MIT in the auditorium that had been named after him before he had turned into a raving antivax conspiracy theorist peddling pseudoscience who has become so proud of his status as “misinformation superspreader” that he had a T-shirt made featuring that saying.

Before I delve into Mr. Kirsch’s massively flawed analysis and findings, let’s briefly take a look at the dataset used and how Mr. Kirsch apparently got his grubby little hands on it.
A New Zealand “whistleblower”
As is the case with many good antivax conspiracy theories that involve torturing an existing dataset until it “confesses” that vaccines kill, Mr. Kirsch’s “mother of all revelations” (MOAR) about COVID-19 vaccines involves a “whistleblower,” who apparently passed on record-level data from Te Whatu Ora (the agency that manages the provision of healthcare services in New Zealand under the Ministry of Health) tallying deaths in vaccinated people, along with COVID-19 vaccination dates. (He also uses the pseudonym of Winston Smith, the protagonist in George Orwell’s dystopian novel Nineteen Eight-Four, because of course he does.) Antivaxxers trumpeting the “whistleblower” also claim that he is a statistician, which, as you will see, he appears not to be, at least not one with epidemiological or clinical knowledge.
Steve Kirsch being Steve Kirsch, a true prolific misinformation spreader who can’t resist anything that brings attention to him, he was hyping this talk and these “revelations” in the lead-up to his talk, revealing quite a bit along the way, because apparently he just can’t help himself. For instance, he revealed that he had illegally obtained the data on November 9 from the whistleblower, whose identity he knew. Of course, he didn’t actually admit that the data had been illegally obtained, but after he had started hyping his talk a number of people told him and his cronies that obtaining record-level data with personally identifiable health information was illegal in New Zealand, the US, and many other countries. At one point on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, the “scientific advisor” of his antivax org Vaccine Safety Research Foundation (VSRF) even conceded with a metaphorical shrug of the shoulders that the data had been illegally obtained:
Last night the Director of Research for Steve Kirsch’s @VacSafety organization made a stunning admission when she stated his “record level data” was illegally obtained. pic.twitter.com/FQsSqzdYTS
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) November 21, 2023
Indeed, apparently Te Whatu Ora was sure enough that the privacy breach had been illegal that it rapidly launched an investigation, which resulted in the arrest of a 56-year-old man, who had appeared in a video on Rumble with NZ presenter Liz Gunn to reveal the data, on suspicion of a “mass privacy breach“:
Police have arrested a man in connection with a mass privacy breach of Covid-19 vaccination data.
It comes after Te Whatu Ora- Health New Zealand launched an employment investigation, accusing a health sector worker of spreading misinformation using government data about Covid-19 vaccines.
A 56-year-old man was arrested this afternoon in relation to the “unauthorised disclosure and misuse of data”, police said.
He is charged with accessing a computer system for dishonest purposes and will appear in Wellington District Court tomorrow.
NZ authorities note that the man “had no clinical background or expert vaccine knowledge,” which means that he might be a statistician, but according to his interview as reported by the Brownstone Institute:
Smith was in an unusual position as the database administrator for the payment system. ‘Because New Zealand is a small country, you can get away with one database administrator. I am in a unique position, and because New Zealand is a Tier 1 country with really good IT, I was able to manage and build this system.’
So he was a database administrator, not a statistician, and appears to have no relevant scientific or clinical knowledge of public health or epidemiology, but rather acted on all sorts of assumptions that spikes in daily death rates were “not natural” and “had to be man-made.” Indeed, according to Mr. Kirsch, “Winston Smith” is an Oracle database administrator for the payments database:
The NZMH whisteblower, Oracle database admin Barry Young, is a hero. He knew he would risk his life and could spend the rest of his life in jail, but he made the courageous move to expose the data for all to see. This is a highly commendable act of public service. He basically threw the rest of his life away in order to save the lives of others. Why else do you think he would do that? Nobody can explain it.
I love the naive assumption that, just because Barry Young risked his freedom to illegally download four million health records, that means there must be something to his suspicions and findings (and therefore to Mr. Kirsch’s “analysis”). No, just because Mr. Young apparently believed strongly enough that vaccines were killing large numbers of people in NZ that he risked prosecution and prison does not mean that he is correct in his belief. Strength of belief does not correlate with correctness of belief, even though a lot of people like Mr. Kirsch think that it does. (Actually, far too many people think that strength of belief correlates with correctness of belief.) Moreover, the revelation that Mr. Young is only a database administrator, and not just a database administrator. but apparently the payments database administrator, tells me all I need to know about his qualifications to judge what these data show: Zero.
According to the NZ authorities:
Earlier tonight, the ministry said the staff member had no clinical background or expert vaccine knowledge, and there was no evidence vaccination was responsible for “excess mortality in New Zealand”.
It’s alleged an individual downloaded a large amount of vaccine-related information, Te Whatu Ora chief executive Margie Apa said.
“The data, as published on an overseas site, appears to have been anonymised. Analysis of the released data is ongoing, but work so far has not found any National Health Index Numbers or personally identifiable information.”
Apa said an injunction had been used to have information taken down from an overseas website and cyber security specialists are continuing to scan extensively for any other places where the information may appear.
This was, of course, a completely expected reaction from a government agency after a computer breach and illegal download of a massive health department dataset, but, of course, Mr. Kirsch predictably saw it as more evidence of a “conspiracy” to “silence” him, particularly when Wasabi, the platform to which he had uploaded the illegal data, revoked his access to his account due to a TOS violation because of too much traffic (although it’s very likely that the New Zealand injunction also played a role in the decision):
Email to the CEO of Wasabi about my urgent situation was not returned.
Wasabi tech support isn’t answering any of my emails either.
The NZMH will do everything they can to stop this data from getting out because it reveals they are killing people with the vaccine.
What did Mr. Kirsch expect? He uploaded a dataset that, he knew, would likely result in a lot of traffic once he revealed on his Substack how to download it and that, he knew or should have known, had been illegally obtained. And, make no mistake, this was illegal. In the US, we refer to health information that has personally identifiable information in it as PHI (protected health information), and we have a law (HIPAA) that governs when such information may be shared and among whom. Suffice to say that anyone with access to PHI can’t just download and share it. Also note that “protected” doesn’t mean that the names have to be associated with the information; any form of personally identifiable information that might allow guessing whose information it is counts. Ever since HIPAA was passed, anyone in healthcare has had to go periodic mandatory training regarding patient data and not even inadvertently sharing it with entities who do not need it to provide healthcare services. Unsurprisingly, NZ has a similar health privacy law.
Of course NZ health authorities were going to act and seek to get an injunction against any private company hosting the data. If I thought Mr. Kirsch were sufficiently clever, I’d suspect that he had intentionally chosen a platform like Wasabi to host the dataset, knowing that once he publicized it health authorities in NZ would act to shut it down. Maybe he even knew that his talk would result in so many people downloading the dataset that bandwidth limits would likely be exceeded. (Hint: I doubt that he’s that clever.) I also note that, while perhaps Mr. Kirsch thought that anonymizing the dataset before releasing it into the wild would protect him and his “whistleblower,” that doesn’t matter. The original dataset, which he presumably possesses, still contains PHI, making its theft—yes, theft—a massive privacy breach, particularly when carried out by someone employed by Te Whatu Ora, which likely included in its employment contract conditions under which the employee was permitted to access the database.
Unsurprisingly, Mr. Kirsch is now bragging that he’s hosted the data on a “bulletproof” platform and that if “they try to take me down next time, they will regret it,” going on to say, “I actually hope they do; we’ll turn the tables on them.” Still, for a tech bro, Mr. Kirsch was either really stupid or more clever than we give him credit for. Given his history, I suspect the former.
In any event, before I move on to the dataset itself, let me just briefly point out that this whole shtick is very familiar. I very much get “CDC whistleblower” vibes from it. You remember the “CDC whistleblower,” don’t you? It was a scientist named William Thompson, who, while working for the CDC, decided that he disagreed with the analysis of a dataset examining whether there was any correlation between autism risk and vaccination with MMR (measles-mumps-rubella vaccine) and then started having phone conversations with an antivaxxer named Brian Hooker, apparently to vent. The result was a “reanalysis” of the dataset by Brian Hooker, a biochemical engineer turned incompetent epidemiologist who had at one point bragged about how he thought “simplicity” in statistical analyses was best and predictably found an increased risk of autism in African American boys due to MMR vaccination. (Of course, “simplicity” to antivaxxers means raw data analyses, without appropriate statistical adjustment for confounding factors.) The whole conspiracy theory was ultimately turned into an antivax epic in 2016, a pseudodocumentary by Andrew Wakefield and Del Bigtree entitled VAXXED. It’s an antivax conspiracy theory that persists to this day, promoted by—who else?—Steve Kirsch. One can’t help but wonder if his MOAR is nothing more than a pathetic attempt on his part to create his own CDC whistleblower.
But what about the dataset itself? Let’s, for the moment, ignore the illegal, unethical and immoral methods by which Mr. Kirsch got his sticky fingers on the dataset and just look at the dataset. Then we’ll move on to his talk.
The NZ dataset
The dataset stolen by the NZ Te Whatu Ora “whistleblower” and passed on to Mr. Kirsch consists health records from 12 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines. Specifically, according to Mr. Kirsch, it contains four million of these records from the the “Pay per dose” (PPD) program, the other eight million apparently not being from that program. Mr. Kirsch claims that whether “you got PPD or not is pretty random,” which sent up an immediate red flag to me regarding whether it is actually true or not that PPD was random or not. I could not ascertain that from my reading. However, I did immediately wonder. (Maybe one of our New Zealand readers could help me out.)
In addition, there are numerous other deficiencies that Mr. Kirsch was forced to admit but that, he claims, do not invalidate his analysis, for example:
    • There is a disproportionate amount of records for the doses, i.e., they are not in direct proportion to the total number of each dose, e.g., they are not 33% of each dose. Some doses are over-represented, some are under represented.
    • Many people will not have all their doses in this database, e.g., there may just be dose 3 data for someone.
In other words, it would appear that some people got some doses through PPD and others not through PPD, which would explain why only some doses were covered. Mr. Kirsch just glosses over this, claiming ridiculously:
The fact that the sampling was uneven doesn’t matter if you analyze it the way I did. The fact that doses are missing is also irrelevant. These are gaslighting arguments made by people who are incompetent to analyze this data.
To which I reacted:
Seriously, if you are going to assert that, for purposes of your analysis, incomplete records and uneven sampling in the dataset don’t matter, you really do need to show the receipts and mathematically prove that these deficiencies in the dataset don’t affect the results of your analysis. Epidemiologists do this all the time by doing multiple different analyses on datasets with missing records and/or uneven sampling, because there are statistical methods for dealing with uneven sampling and missing records that peer reviewers will expect to see if such analyses are to be published in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature. (It’s called sensitivity analysis, as in testing the sensitivity of the outcomes of the analysis to important assumptions made in doing the analysis.) Tellingly, Mr. Kirsch doesn’t even attempt to use them or mathematically justify his claim that these things don’t affect his analysis. He just asks you, with an overconfidence that bespeaks one of the most extreme examples of the Dunning-Kruger effect that I’ve ever seen, to “trust me on this,” so to speak.
Of course, there are other major deficiencies in the dataset, the key one being that the dataset includes only vaccinated people, when they were vaccinated and with what vaccine, as well as dates of death for those who died. We don’t know the baseline death rate in an unvaccinated cohort, which would almost certainly be much higher.
None of these deficiencies stops Mr. Kirsch, though. So let’s look at his analysis. His talk was posted to Rumble. (Where else?) His slides were posted to Google Documents and to his own website as a PDF. Feel free to watch it if you can handle the tsunami of Gish galloping misinformation.
Kirsch’s MOAR goes poof
Watching Mr. Kirsch talk for so long is rather painful. He uses entirely too many slides, and the aesthetics of his PowerPoint design reminds me, more than anything else, of late 1990s Time Cube. Let’s just say that I have a number of old antivax PowerPoint presentations that I saved from 15-20 years ago, and his reminded me a lot of them. But what about the substance? It’s also clear that Mr. Kirsch revels in his reputation as a “misinformation superspreader,” as his early slides claim that he’s written over 1,500 articles on COVID-19 (whoop-de-doo, I’ve probably written at least five times that number over the years on vaccines in general), before he whines:

Now let’s look at his key assumption, for which he provides no references, statistics, or math to justify:

Before I go on, let me just point out a very important principle. When you see a nonexpert analyze a dataset using methods that no expert uses to analyze the same type of dataset, be suspicious. It is, of course, possible that the nonexpert has stumbled onto an innovative way of analyzing data of this type. But is it likely? No, not really. It’s far more likely that he’s made a rookie mistake. Moreover, when the nonexpert doing the analysis is someone like Mr. Kirsch, who has a history of promoting the most outlandish antivax conspiracy theories, it’s far more likely that the nonexpert is doing nothing more than torturing the data until it confesses what he wants it to confess. Be even more suspicious that this is what is going on when, for example, the nonexpert, after stating his assumptions, doesn’t go straight into the data analysis but instead starts ranting at Moderna co-founder Robert Langer and claiming that as a board member of Moderna he has a responsibility to “stop the shots” and might be liable to prosecution under the PREP act. (That’s exactly what Mr. Kirsch did, referring to the vaccines as “kill shots.”)
Then he looks at another dataset for different vaccines, noting that his assumption is validated for the pneumococcal vaccine:

If you look at the original Substack upon which Mr. Kirsch bases this chart, you’ll note that there are data for unvaccinated people. You’ll also note that he hand waves away why the data are “confusing.” In any event, after Mr. Kirsch had published this analysis back in late February, a number of commenters pointed out that his results could be explained by the healthy vaccinee effect (people who are vaccinated tend to be the most at risk, as in older and less healthy, and those who are less healthy tend to self-select to be vaccinated regardless), seasonality (deaths tend to peak in winter, particularly among the elderly), and COVID-19 waves. It’s no surprise that Mr. Kirsch simply does the same thing with the New Zealand dataset.
But first, he has to cite anecdotes because:

My reaction was this:

Think I’m exaggerating? OK, then, let’s look at the next slide:

I discussed Mr. Bonnar’s “anecdote” and how implausibly unbelievable in the context of deconstructing Mr. Kirsch’s equally implausibly unbelievable claim that COVID-19 vaccines have killed 3.5 times more people than COVID-19. Mr. Kirsch sure does like to recycle his “greatest hits” of disinformation.
But, surely he must be about to get to his analysis of the NZ data, right? Sort of. First, he has to go on about getting the data on November 9 and then saying:

Actually, any dataset, “record-level” or otherwise, can be a “Rosetta Stone” for conspiracy mongers like Mr. Kirsch, who are determined enough to torture the dataset until it confesses what they want it to confess. That’s exactly what Mr. Kirsch does, but not before extrapolating wildly from his “findings” to claim that COVID-19 vaccines have killed over 13 million people worldwide, a false claim that he repeats later in his presentation with this slide:

I suppose that Mr. Kirsch thought that he was being a good showman in dragging out the presentation. Maybe he thought he was building suspense. To me, what he really did was make me fast forward through his talk because I was getting bored and frustrated that he wasn’t coming to the point. I know, I know, I’m sure it’s not entirely unlike some of my readers, who skim through until I get to the point. The difference is that I’m not entirely oblivious to the flaws in my communication style, the way that Mr. Kirsch appears to be when he decides to throw in some more slides from his bogus Medicare analysis, slides of other antivax “analyses” from other countries, and even slides about his utterly risible “survey” that led him to claim that COVID-19 vaccines have killed 3.5 times more people than COVID-19 into his talk before getting to what everyone wants to see, the NZ data.
Oh, there’s this:
As I’ve noted before, Dr. McCullough has not actually had his board certification revoked yet. I searched the ABIM website. You can search it too if you don’t believe me, but here’s my screenshot:

Finally, there was this:

I only include this because Mr. Kirsch mentioned me. There’s also just one problem here. He blocked me, and I blocked him back (because I always block back) months ago. This is purely performative. Also notice the number in the lower righthand corner. That’s the slide number. Now go back and count how many slides he included before getting to the point, his big “MOAR” of the NZ data. Yes, it’s a lot.
it’s 11 more slides before he gets to the actual data. Now, before I present the slides, let me note that there’s a bit of a trick here let’s see if you can spot it:
Then, Mr. Kirsch finally presents all ages:

First, let’s again revisit Mr. Kirsch’s assumption, which is that the death rate should be flat. I immediately wondered about that assumption, particularly in the middle of a pandemic in which a contagious respiratory virus is ripping through the population at various intervals and to which the elderly and those with chronic health conditions are most susceptible to severe disease and death. I had a conversation with Prof. Jeffrey Morris about this, but first lets see what this Professor of Public Health & Preventive Medicine; Biostats, Stats & Data Science at Penn had to say publicly on X/Twitter:
Steve Kirsch gave a presentation at MIT claiming that 1/1000 of those vaccinated with covid vaccines are killed by the vaccines using New Zealand data he obtained (which would imply >12,000 killed by vaccine among the >12m doses given in New Zealand to date, in a country that… pic.twitter.com/2qPTRnibDV
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) December 1, 2023
See this discussion as well: https://t.co/vRGnb10rRu
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) December 1, 2023
There was, of course, more:
And the overall explanation for there have been a lot more high death days in recent years is that there are a lot more old people, which is why deaths are up and the age standardised death rate is lower.(and eradicating viruses in 2020 caused a dip in deaths) pic.twitter.com/hStBQsbwn1
— David Hood (@Thoughtfulnz) November 30, 2023
I also like to refer to this graph from Our World In Data:

Let’s quote a key element of Prof. Morris’ discussion, given that you might not want to have to go to the X/Twitter website to see this and you might not even have an account anymore:
As I would emphasize, any genuine attempt to assess potential causal effects of vaccines requires consideration of controls and adjust for confounding and other sources of bias inherent to these observational data in the pandemic (as may published studies do), but it might be useful for some to consider looking at these data as a basic plausibility filter for assessing whether they think the excess deaths are primarily driven by vaccination or by covid.
BTW the waves of covid infection waves coincide closely with the vaccine deaths in the plot, so even if you question covid death attribution, these times are precisely the times when each place experienced a massive wave of confirmed covid infections.
Note: It should read after the correction of an unfortunate typo:
BTW the waves of covid infection waves coincide closely with the COVID deaths in the plot, so even if you question covid death attribution, these times are precisely the times when each place experienced a massive wave of confirmed covid infections.
Everything old is new again, as I like to say. Basically, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. “proved” that the CDC was “covering up” data supposedly showing that thimerosal-containing vaccines caused autism because appropriate adjustment of the analysis of the raw data for confounders made the effect go away. Ditto Brian Hooker “reanalyzing” the “CDC whistleblower” data. Basically, it’s a theme in antivax “reanalyses” of datasets like the Medicare and New Zealand datasets; they take raw results and fail to appropriately adjust for confounders. I’ve seen it again and again and again over the years. It’s a rookie mistake, and Mr. Kirsch falls for it like a day one rookie; either that, or he does it intentionally. (Take your pick.) In brief, Mr. Kirsch’s assumption that these curves should be absolutely flat in the middle of a pandemic is just that, an assumption. He does not adequately show that it is a justified assumption either, to put it mildly.
Even worse, Mr. Kirsch’s extrapolation is wildly inappropriate. Where do you think he got his claim that COVID-19 vaccines have killed over 13 million people? Ridiculously simple, although it’s really simply ridiculous. He extrapolated from his “estimate” from this dataset that COVID-19 vaccines kill one in a thousand people who receive them, to estimate that COVID-19 vaccines are responsible for 13 million dead worldwide and 675,000 in the US alone. Again, these are numbers so wildly implausible that they do not pass the smell test.
As Prof. Morris noted to me, the increase in death rate that Mr. Kirsch claims is everywhere in the data is, in actuality, only evident in the older age groups. Of course, the “all ages” death rate is driven primarily by the older age groups. There’s the trick! It’s the main one, but not the only one. In addition, Mr. Kirsch assumes that healthy vaccine effects “last exactly three weeks and not a moment longer,” which leads him to his erroneous assumption that any subsequent increase in deaths can only be explained by vaccine-caused deaths and no other factor. Prof. Morris also agreed with me that you can’t know the baseline death rate without having an unvaccinated control group, but he also educated me by pointing out this:
When you consider the actuarial baseline and the fact that 2020-2021 New Zealand had dramatically lower death rates than historical baseline, it seems like the long increase he sees (in the older groups), is not excess deaths but basically a return to baseline death rate.
In other words, it’s yet another confounder that Mr. Kirsch failed to consider, incompetent rookie epidemiologist and statistician that he is. He also misuses “proof by contradiction,” in which one exhaustively lists all the other possible explanations for an observation, until the “only one standing”—as Prof. Morris put it—must be true.
He also states erroneously:

Notably, he shows no documentation that this is, in fact, the “gold standard” for determining a safe and effective vaccine. (Also note the slide number. And people wonder why I was getting tired as I neared the end. Hint: He had more than 100 more slides to go, most of which included a lot of rants that are very old antivax tropes about how supposedly there is less autism in unvaccinated children and citing Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s false claim that vaccines are making this generation of children the “sickest generation.”) Truly, Mr. Kirsch’s crapfest of a talk was a shining example of a Gish gallop, a.k.a. firehosing and proof positive that Brandolini was an optimist. (Brandolini’s law, also called the Bullshit Asymmetry Principle, states that it takes an order of magnitude more energy to refute bullshit than it does to create it. I say it takes at least two, if not three, orders of magnitude more energy, as evidenced by my going through Mr. Kirsch’s talk and 285 slides, plus his Substack articles.)

Other antivaxxers react
One of the funny things about Mr. Kirsch’s talk was the reaction. Sure, credulous propagandist hacks at the Brownstone Institute took it at face value, because of course they did. However, Mr. Kirsch is so…out there…that the more “reasonable” antivaxxers—or at least the ones who either have a science background or desperately want to be perceived as “more reasonable” were a bit less enthusiastic.
For example:
Steve @ichudov was able to obtain the NZ database. He has been combing through it and has raised serious concerns with the quality of the raw data set. Red flags were first noted by @jikkyleaks followed by others chiming in with established qualifications whom you should…
— Betsy McDonel Herr, Ph.D. (@DrBMcDH) December 2, 2023
Let’s quote the whole thing, shall we:
Steve @ichudov was able to obtain the NZ database. He has been combing through it and has raised serious concerns with the quality of the raw data set. Red flags were first noted by @jikkyleaks followed by others chiming in with established qualifications whom you should recognize. At first look –too much missing data and anomalies. Too many discrepancies with other data points and facts we have about NZ. No wonder the host for the data set wants no one else looking under the hood, rather just uncritical acceptance of the so-called conclusions.
@NickHudsonCT explained having a prior opportunity to look at the NZ data and that project fizzling out because of problems–that event wasn’t disclosed to you apparently by the owner whistleblower. @USMortality thinks the data are so riddled with missing and problematic inconsistencies that it is rendered unanalyzable for purpose. @DowdEdward responded to the conversation indicating there may indeed be a scam underfoot. One aim potentially to undermine you, leaders in the movement. I suspect the focus on high rates of death purported to be associated with “vaccinator” is to shift blame from product to human error and thus muddy the waters of liability. NZ findings don’t match those of other recognized data analyses around the world showing the mRNA C19 product harms. There has never been a robust, large effect size for “vaccinator” that couldn’t be attributed to the confound of bad lots. Just occasional egregious human error cases, but not of this magnitude. There is no concordance offered between NZ lot ID#s and formal Pfizer batch #’s so no analysis has yet been offered showing the same pattern of AEs with bad lots. Why not? That would be straightforward and the pattern and scale of harms by lot known from VAERS and well documented by Craig Paardekooper at http://howbad.info should line up closely, match like fingerprints.
@sasha_latypova @hedleyrees
We don’t have that confirmation. We don’t have analyses that show the overall rate of death and AEs for the population and for age groups by total and number of shots as @denisrancourt excellent new world report lays out. Why wasn’t this sort of analysis performed? Let’s involve @JesslovesMJK @lawrie_dr and protect good doctors like @PierreKory @molsjames @drcole12 @richardursomd @P_McCulloughMD and @MdBreathe from being hurt by this likely psy op. We don’t have reports from NZ provided in a way that provides any sort of denominators. If the data set is legitimate it is poorly administered, full of holes. Perhaps due to widespread faults in monitoring and recording of events that would comprise the data set. Talk to other NZ experts on those processes. Let’s examine the hype and drama that preceded the rollout of the “findings.” A proper well-vetted set of analyses would go through a rational serious process of being reviewed by other experts in the open before being proclaimed the “Mother of All Revelations” and presented in parliament by legislators like @ABridgen
Winston’s demeanor and words are also highly suspect and caught the eye of many including those tagged here, and was my first tell. The full interview with Winston Smith was dripping with sniffly self-serving drama overkill and emotionally overplayed sensitivity to the plight of humanity. He is quite late to the party of outrage and has no believable excuse or response. It is a performance. No meaningful discussion of his real credentials, skills and experience. He is a database administrator but I see no evidence of skills as a statistician or analyst. He has worked with no one else by his own admission. By contrast @naomirwolf and her 2500 strong posse of experts worked months to sift through documents and data to produce interim and final reports. No one other than me has yet pointed out the highly strange clown world “coincidence” that Winston Smith is also a “fictional character and the protagonist of George Orwell’s dystopian 1949 novel Nineteen Eighty-Four…employed by Orwell as an everyman in the setting of the novel, a “central eye … [the reader] can readily identify with” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winston_Smith_(Nineteen_Eighty-Four) Dr. Malone @RWMaloneMD has been warning us about the advanced state of 5thGen warfare, and this entire event fits in with such a scheme from that playbook. @jjcouey has dubbed such shenanigans “Scooby Doo.”
@HopeRising19 has expressed concern along with @chrismartenson who commit to staying firm on sidelines with respect to buying the conclusions until further inspection and analysis takes place.
This is heartbreaking but fixable if the community works fast and together to self-correct. Take a breath, step back, and take a long second look. Work with Igor and a team of helpers (me included) and determine what really happened. What you discover at the end of that exploration may be much more useful to the world than what you think you found at the outset.
Jikkyleaks? She’s generally an antivaxxer at least as rabid as Mr. Kirsch is. As for Igor Chudov? Holy hell! He’s an antivaxxer whom, for reasons that I still don’t know, I’ve tolerated over in the comments section of my not-so-secret other blog. If these two are balking at Mr. Kirsch’s analysis, it must be bad. I am also very much amused at how so many antivaxxers think that Mr. Kirsch’s analysis is so bad that he fell for a “psyop” in which bad data were intentionally leaked in order to get someone like him to take the bait, do a bad analysis, and thereby discredit antivaxxers.
I mean, Igor Chudov even thinks it’s a psyop:
I do a lot of things. One of them is administering the database for Algebra.Com, a website with millions of monthly visitors and over a million of answered math questions.
So, I understand database administration. The story of a bona fide “leak” does not make sense to me. The data does not have the integrity that a full leaked data set would have.
This is supposed to be a payments database containing information for payments to vaccinators.
How can a payment database have such holes and missing data?
Was data selectively removed from the database before the leak?
How can batch IDs refer to multiple vaccines?
Did both the “whistleblower” and Liz Gunn honestly forget to check that these “deadly vaccine mass murder sites” are nursing homes?
Do the missing records of first vaccinations (doses 1-2) hide real vaccine deaths, making Liz Gunn go on about “deadly nursing homes” instead of looking at deaths actually caused by the COVID vaccine?
Was the “leak” a psyop and an intentional attempt to sow confusion, as it occurred with the old, pro-WEF, and vaccine-crazy NZ government still in place during the last days of it? This question is speculative, but something I would like to clarify.
I didn’t even get much into the claims by Mr. Kirsch that certain batches of vaccines were more “deadly” than others, because of many of the reasons above. I’m also amused by how Chudov thinks that maybe the holes in the database actually hide more COVID-19 vaccine deaths. I was laughing as I read his post. I also note with amusement that Mr. Kirsch, as he characteristically does, is desperately trying to persuade Mr. Chudov that he’s wrong.
As I read his post, I was predicting that, because Mr. Chudov is an antivax conspiracy theorist, he would eventually succumb to Mr. Kirsch’s blandishments and “come home.” In the meantime, though I found it utterly hilarious that antivaxxers were holding him up as some sort of expert on data integrity:
Yep. We know what they're up to. And now we know who facilitated it.
— Jikkyleaks 🐭 (@Jikkyleaks) December 3, 2023
Unsurprisingly…as I was writing this, a reader pointed out to me that Mr. Chudov was already backpedaling, and he did it even faster than I had expected, which is greatly satisfying, as it demonstrates to me that I do know the full depths of his antivax crankitude:
At this point, I believe that Barry Young was more likely to be sincere than insincere in his intentions and actions.
My previous questions and comments about Liz Gunn’s statements about nursing home deaths and data quality still apply, with one exception: the partial nature of the data is explained by the fact that some shots were not paid through the system that Barry Young was supposedly administering. (I hope more clarity emerges).
This clarification is vital since I questioned the sincerity of the person who possibly risked his life to disclose data.
I greatly hope that, after thorough analysis, the data will yield useful information!
Antivaxxers are so predictable. Also, once again, Mr. Young’s sincerity or lack of sincerity is completely irrelevant to whether the dataset is complete or incomplete, biased or unbiased, and, most importantly, whether his interpretation of it (and Mr. Kirsch’s “analysis” of it) show what antivaxxers claim.
Then there’s Norman Fenton, he of the p-hacking to find badness in COVID-19 vaccines fame (not to mention fame from his inability to distinguish postviral bacterial pneumonia from COVID-19), who notes about Mr. Kirsch’s claim of “deadly batches”:
What we can probably discount is the claim concerning batches with exceptionally high mortality rates. The claim that these batches were especially deadly due to the contents of the vaccine or its delivery is confounded by their very different age and time of vaccination profiles.
Of course, when you see one claim that is so easily dismissed, you have to wonder about all the other claims. Moreover, Prof. Fenton clearly very much wants to believe Mr. Kirsch’s findings, so much so that he says that there is evidence “of increased risk the more doses one gets” but is oblivious to obvious confounding that comes from the fact that those at a higher risk of death are more likely to get the later boosters. That means that an increased death rate associated with a higher number of boosters does not necessarily imply that increasing number of doses causing increased risk of death. (Hat tip again to Prof. Morris, who helped me clarify something that I suspected but couldn’t quite put my finger on.)
In any event, it frequently amuses me when the self-identified “reasonable” antivaxxers appear to recognize a nonsensical analysis when they see it but, because they want to believe its results so badly, just can’t quite bring themselves to call it what it is, nonsense. That’s Fenton. He’s calling Mr. Kirsch’s analysis crap without actually being blunt about calling it crap.
I, on the other hand, have no such compunction. I call ’em as I see ’em, and I call this crap. I don’t know if it’s crap because Mr. Kirsch is so incompetent or if he’s a bit more competent than he appears and dishonest instead of clueless. Take your pick. Moreover, just because antivaxxers are claiming that this whole thing might be a psyop doesn’t mean that it isn’t organized. Barry “Winston Smith” Young was clearly working with groups that wanted to weaponize the dataset:
Liz released the video against his wishes…https://t.co/RILO1sHUkC pic.twitter.com/Ydxe47VVb9
— Stoichastic (@Stoichastich) December 3, 2023
This actually reminds me of the whole “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory too. Remember that the “CDC whistleblower” William Thompson had been venting to Brian Hooker, who, apparently unable to resist chasing clout, had let Andrew Wakefield know that he was recording phone conversations with a CDC scientist. Andrew Wakefield, being Andrew Wakefield, couldn’t resist doing a brief video with clips from the phone conversations, thus blowing the lid off of the secrecy that Hooker had been keeping on his phone calls in the hopes of finding out still more information. Ultimately, Hooker decided to go all-in with Wakefield to publicize the “CDC whistleblower,” and, less than two years later, the saga produced the conspiracyfest of a pseudodocumentary VAXXED. I’m getting strong “CDC whistleblower” vibes, with Barry “Winston Smith” Young playing the role of William Thompson, whoever he had been working with playing the role of Brian Hooker, and, of course, Liz Gunn playing the role of Andrew Wakefield. It’s not perfect comparison, of course, because Mr. Young did apparently approach Mr. Kirsch, but you get the idea.
Conspiracy theorists tend to be proof positive of how difficult it is for any group of people to keep a secret, and Mr. Kirsch is just doing what antivaxxers have long done, “reanalyzing” a dataset based on incorrect assumptions and failing to correct for obvious confounders. To that tradition, he adds using a stolen dataset of uncertain provenance—remember, the CDC whistleblower’s dataset was the one ultimately used by the CDC to publish its results—whose acquisition involved a massive data breach and the violation of the privacy of millions of New Zealanders. Here’s hoping that Te Whatu Ora investigates fully, and we find out exactly how antivaxxers got their hands on such a dataset illegally and who besides Mr. Young was involved.

Can COVID Vaccines Travel in Space and Time?
Are COVID vaccines to blame for the return of polio?
Jonathan Howard on August 12, 2022
Link

Time-traveling nanopatticles
Before she was banned from Twitter, the anti-vaccine conspiracy theorist Naomi Wolf warned of
A new tech to deliver vaccines w nanopatticles that let you travel back in time.
While reasonable people reject time-travel, I’ve previously discussed contrarian doctors whose desperation to undermine unwanted COVID policies led them to agree with Ms. Wolf’s core premise. Most notably, Dr. Marty Makary accused the CDC of lowering their developmental milestones for young children due to masks, even though their new guidelines were based on a “broad literature search…conducted in March 2019”. Only time-traveling masks could justify his belief.
COVID vaccines and time-travel
The most recent example of a doctor embracing time-travel occurred courtesy of Dr. Vinay Prasad. Prior to the pandemic, Dr. Prasad mocked those of us who sought to counter anti-vaccine myths, likening our efforts to dunking of a 7-foot hoop. Despite his ignorance of the topic and disdain for those with such knowledge, Dr. Prasad has since anointed himself the Chief Defender of Routine Childhood Vaccination and claims to know more about the subject than pediatricians and vaccine-experts.
In his new role, Dr. Prasad believes that vaccine experts who voted unanimously to authorize COVID vaccines for young children and pediatricians who want to protect babies against the virus are endangering routine childhood vaccines. Unlike them, he feels the best way to encourage routine vaccines is to trash the COVID vaccine. Dr. Prasad’s commentary on the recent case of polio in Rockland County New York encapsulated his absurd position. Praising himself for his supposed clairvoyance, he said:
A singular focus on COVID and pushing covid shots in kids, who mostly had covid (based on weak evidence/ w low yield <5% parents <5 has resulted in neglect for routine childhood immunization, which is disastrous. Many of us saw this coming.
While Dr. Prasad is eager to blame pediatricians for the return of polio, he presented no evidence that their efforts to prevent babies from dying of COVID dissuaded routine childhood vaccination. This is because his belief is justified only if COVID vaccines can travel in space and time.
Anyone with basic knowledge of the current polio outbreak and the anti-vaccine movement knows why this is so. The current polio case occurred in an unvaccinated Orthodox Jewish 20-year-old man who contracted the virus outside the US. Had he been vaccinated on schedule, he would have received his last polio vaccine 15 years ago. At least Ms. Wolf has the courage to offer nanopatticles as an explanatory mechanism for how COVID vaccines could be blamed.
Unfortunately, this may not be the last polio case as wastewater samples show the outbreak is more widespread. While this may seem to lend credence Dr. Prasad’s hypothesis, the Orthodox community in Rockland Country has long been skeptical of vaccines, and prior to the pandemic, it was targeted by anti-vaccine activists. According to news reports from 2019:
Andrew Wakefield, Del Bigtree, and other prominent anti-vaccine advocates unleashed fear and toxic misinformation last night at a well-attended symposium in New York’s Rockland County. The area is currently grappling with one of the largest and longest-standing measles outbreaks in the country, mainly in its tight-knit, ultra-Orthodox Jewish community.
Dr. Wakefield and his ilk found a receptive audience in Rockland County, where low-vaccination rates triggered a measles outbreak that sickened several hundred children in 2018 and 2019. It came as no surprise to vaccine advocates that this is where polio found a vulnerable victim. Those of us who “saw this coming” before the pandemic, such as Dr. David Gorski, worked to bring attention to the problem and refute anti-vaccine nonsense. The Chief Defender of Routine Childhood Vaccination felt we were wasting our time.
Everything old is new again
Of course, vaccine advocates know that all of the arguments against COVID vaccines are simply recycled anti-vaccine talking points. As Dr. Gorski said, “everything old is new again“. He said that:
Proponents of science-based medicine have been warning us for decades about the sort of misinformation that’s now swamping us.
He’s right. In 2019, I connected with Dr. Blima Marcus, an Orthodox nurse practitioner and staunch vaccine-advocate who has faced threats and abuse for her important work. In response to the measles outbreak in 2019, she founded an organization called Engaging in Medical Education with Sensitivity, which published a 144-page informational booklet called Parents Informed and Educated, a response to anti-vaccine literature in her community.
In 2019, under the auspices of her organization, I attended a vaccine information session for the Orthodox community where I heard the same myths about the routine childhood vaccines that I now hear about the COVID vaccine. Some attendees thought all vaccines had “weak evidence” and objected there were no long-term studies of the entire vaccine schedule. Some claimed that vaccine-preventable diseases were harmless, and therefore vaccines were unnecessary. Some were convinced vaccine side effects were worse than the diseases they prevented and that “natural immunity” was preferable. This is exactly what contrarian doctors now say about pediatric COVID and the vaccine against it.
Unlike Dr. Prasad, Dr. Marcus understands the cause of anti-vaccine sentiment in her community. Unsurprisingly, she didn’t have much respect for his hypothesis. She told me,
Stating that public health guidance during COVID sewed [sic] enough mistrust to cause an infectious disease outbreak is ridiculous conjecture and completely negates the dozens of outbreaks that preceded COVID. Measles outbreaks in the US occurred in 2011, 2014, and 2018-2019. Mumps outbreaks occurred in 2006, 2009-2010, and annually from 2014 through 2020. There are still tens of thousands of cases of pertussis annually, often linked to unvaccinated counties and clusters.
Only time-travel can implicate COVID vaccines for many years of low vaccine rates in some Orthodox Jewish communities and similarly isolated groups (Amish, Somali-Americans, fundamentalist churches). Given Dr. Prasad’s interest in vaccines is both recent and shallow, I’d be very surprised if he knows any of this history.
COVID vaccines and action at a distance
Beyond this, polio has also been found in wastewater in London. As the UK initially refused to vaccinate children against COVID, a fact Dr. Prasad celebrated, this would imply that America’s “singular focus on COVID and pushing covid shots in kids” led to vaccine refusal 3,400 miles away. It’s also true that the pandemic disrupted routine vaccination programs, the same way it disrupted sports, concerts, and everything else. According to news reports:
In a new report published Friday, the World Health Organization and UNICEF said their figures show 25 million children last year failed to get vaccinated against diptheria [sic], tetanus and pertussis, a marker for childhood immunization coverage, continuing a downward trend that began in 2019.
Not only can pediatric COVID vaccines time-travel, apparently they also have action at a distance, decreasing pediatric vaccination rates across the globe. Of course, vaccine-refusal was a problem around the world prior to the pandemic, such that the World Health Organization considered it a top 10 threat to global health in 2019.
Fortunately the pandemic’s effect on routine childhood immunization has been modest thus far in the US. According to the CDC:
For the 2020–21 school year, coverage was approximately 94% for all required vaccines, approximately one percentage point lower than the previous school year. The exemption rate remained low at 2.2%.
While this is good news, we are at a precarious movement. The pandemic has given anti-vaxxers a platform and legitimacy they lacked previously. As Dr. Gorski wrote:
Since the pandemic has fueled the metastasis of antivax misinformation and conspiracy theories back onto childhood vaccines, the possibility of school vaccine mandates being repealed in some states looks terrifyingly possible.
I agree with Dr. Prasad’s newfound concern that the return of vaccine-preventable diseases is a frightening prospect, which is why I’ve been involved in this space for a decade. We all agree that one person crippled by polio is one person too many. However, I disagree with Dr. Prasad that it is acceptable to brush off over 100,000 pediatric COVID hospitalizations and 1,500 deaths simply because elderly people are at more risk. I don’t want any children to suffer or die from any virus for lack of a vaccine. The Chief Defender of Routine Childhood Vaccination feels I’m “off my rocker” for this reason.
Everything old is new again, except one thing
Though Dr. Gorski says that everything old is new again, one thing has changed. This pandemic, anti-vaxxers have been aided by highly-credentialed contrarian doctors who plagiarize their talking points. Arguments that would have marked a doctor as a “quack” – to quote Dr. Prasad – prior to the pandemic, now emanate from professors at prestigious medical schools. Their writing is often indistinguishable from uber-cranks like RFK Jr. (test yourself here), and it’s no surprise his website has favorably featured the musings of Drs. Prasad and Makary.
Unlike RFK Jr., these doctors have yet to realize that constantly casting unwarranted doubt on COVID vaccines probably isn’t the best way to encourage routine vaccination. For example, Dr. Prasad isn’t helping anything when he parrots standard anti-vaccine balderdash by saying:
Observational data has been used to support vaccines, but is plagued by confounding. That is because parents who vaccinate their kids are different from those who don’t. The same studies could show that driving a baby home from hospital in a Mercedes is better than a Ford.
Actual vaccine-advocates, like Dr. Marcus, know the best way to encourage vaccination is to be honest and straightforward about the risks/benefits of vaccines and the real dangers of the infections they prevent. This includes COVID. Despite their feigned concern over routine childhood vaccines, contrarian doctors, ignorant of the anti-vaccine movement and sheltered from the consequences of their words, are impeding this vital effort when they minimize pediatric COVID and disparage COVID vaccines by accusing them traveling in space and time.

VINAY PRASAD

1,200 is More Than 6
Don’t trust anyone who tries to convince you otherwise.
Jonathan Howard on February 5, 2022
Link

“If you are comparing IFRs and forgetting R0s, well…”
Epidemiologist Aris Katzourakis recently said,
If you are comparing IFRs and forgetting R0s, well…
To translate this into plain English, Dr. Katzourakis means that when describing the dangers of a virus to a population, two pieces of information are required. The first of these is the percentage of people who will die if they contract the virus, the infection fatality rate (IFR). The second is how contagious the disease is, the R0.
If I provided you with only one of these two metrics about a new virus, you might be able to tell me nothing about how many people would die were this virus to be unleashed on the world. How many people will die if a new virus has an IFR of 5%? No one can say. The answer depends entirely on how many people get it.
To give a real-world example, rabies kills essentially everyone who gets it. It has an IFR of 100%. However, since COVID-19 is infinitely easier to contract, it will kill hundreds of thousands of Americans this year, as it has for the past two years. In contrast, 5 Americans died of rabies in 2021, the highest number for a decade. I’d much rather get COVID-19 than rabies, but I’d be much safer if I were exposed to someone with rabies than COVID-19.
This is all very easy to understand. My children easily grasp these concepts.
Half the information
With this in mind, let’s examine a tweet by Dr. Vinay Prasad, a specialist in creating medical reversals, who not long ago assured us all that children didn’t need to be vaccinated against COVID-19 since their “risk of covid will decline precipitously” after “all adults are vaccinated“.
In this tweet, Dr. Prasad presented a graph showing that for children, the IFR for the flu is a bit higher than the IFR for COVID-19, though no one knows the exact IFR for either virus. I agree this is vital information. The vast majority of children with either disease will be fine. Parents should definitely vaccinate their kids against COVID-19 if they can, but they shouldn’t panic if their child contracts the virus.
But something is missing here. In that graph, COVID-19 looks not that much worse than the flu for elderly people. To understand why, I urge you to look at the original source for this graphic by John Burn-Murdoch.
It consists of two slides, with captions, below. Basically, he is saying that the original virus was more lethal than the virus we have circulating now, perhaps because it is intrinsically more mild compared to the original variant, but also because of better treatments and because many people are immune, both from the virus and the vaccine. The vaccine drastically increased the odds of someone surviving COVID-19. If few children were vaccinated, as would be the case had American regulators listened to Dr. Prasad, COVID-19 might still have an IFR identical to the flu. Additionally, this graph is just a snapshot in time. It would certainly have been different had it been made when the Delta variant was circulating. Who knows what the next variant has in store.
Moreover, this data is from England. While fewer children are vaccinated there compared to the USA, it also has a much lower pediatric obesity rates than many American states. Since obesity portends a poor outcome in children, American children are more vulnerable. The data cannot be extrapolated to children in Alabama or Texas. Finally, and tragically, the virus has already found and killed many of the sickest and most vulnerable people. The population that is available to the virus today is very different than at the start of the pandemic.
Dr. Prasad then implored journalists to share his truncated, out-of-context, graph in “every news story” about COVID-19 and children. He clearly wants his audience to believe that “For the unvaccinated child, COVID presents a health risk to children that is on par with the flu”. In a podcast from 2/2021 called “Should We Vaccinate Kids for COVID“, Dr. Prasad even said:
It is generally not controversial to argue that SARS-CoV-2 in kids is roughly, roughly the same as influenza, maybe even less severe than influenza, seasonal influenza in kids.
Of course, the IFR is exactly half of the information someone must know to understand how the two viruses have impacted children. It is generally not controversial to argue that a child with rabies is drastically more likely to die than a child with COVID-19. But that’s not a very useful thing to know in the middle of a pandemic, is it?
However, selectively omitting information to advance a grossly misleading narrative is Dr. Prasad’s speciality. I wrote about this previously saying:
Making factual errors is one way to understate the harms caused by COVID-19. Another way is to not mention these harms at all. Some doctors haven’t made blatant factual errors, as their arguments not to vaccinate children are essentially devoid of any facts at all. If ten data points are needed to understand the risks and benefits of the vaccine, they cherry pick the three that support their position.
I could have missed it, but I don’t think I’ve once seen Dr. Prasad simply acknowledge the total number of American children killed by COVID-19. In this instance, Dr. Prasad cherry-picked the fact that an individual child with COVID-19 has roughly the same low risk of dying as a child with the flu. But again something’s missing. Necessary information has been purposefully omitted.
What’s missing from Dr. Prasad’s repeated comparisons between COVID-19 and the flu is how many children have contracted these two viruses. What’s missing is how many children have been hospitalized with these two viruses. What’s missing is how many children have died from these two viruses. What’s missing is all that really matters.
When it comes to what really matters, the numbers couldn’t be clearer. That’s why Dr. Prasad refuses to share these numbers. COVID-19 is much more contagious than the flu and so mitigation measures that dented COVID-19 obliterated the flu. As the CDC states:
COVID-19 mitigation measures such as wearing face masks, staying home, hand washing, school closures, reduced travel, increased ventilation of indoor spaces, and physical distancing, likely contributed to the decline in 2020-2021 flu incidence, hospitalizations and deaths.
During the 2020-2021 flu season, a mere 9 children ages 5-11 years were hospitalized with the flu. Meanwhile, during this time COVID-19 hospitalized thousands of children this age, about 1/3 them needing ICU-level care. Since the start of the pandemic, over 1,200 children died of COVID-19, while 6 children died of the flu. Anyone who feels COVID-19 and the flu pose the same overall risk to children should write a rebuttal to my article called, “1,200 Equals 6”. (Since that sounds like a funny piece of satire and I wrote that article and will publish it tomorrow.)
Even considering pre-pandemic years, COVID-19 killed more children than most flu seasons. In 2021, with many mitigation measures still in place and millions of children safely vaccinated, the American Academy of Pediatrics added 556 children to its grim death tally. Importantly, there is no guarantee that this tally captures every pediatric COVID-19 fatality, especially since states like Texas and Alabama stopped reporting this data. In contrast, the CDC states that, since pediatric flu deaths became nationally notifiable in 2004, the death toll ranged from a low of 37 (2011-2012) to a high of 358 (the 2009-2010 H1N1 pandemic).
These numbers undercount the true toll of the flu, since not all deaths are reported to the CDC. For example, the CDC would later increase the estimate of deaths to 1,090 during the H1N1 pandemic. However, the AAP’s incomplete tally of pediatric COVID-19 deaths in 2021 exceeds the highest estimated number of pediatric flu deaths for 10 of the past 12 flu seasons, years for which there were no mitigation measures of course (2014-2015 estimated 803 deaths and 2012-2013 estimated 1,161 deaths).* There’s no way to spin these numbers. COVID-19 is deadlier for children than the flu.
If more parents knew this, perhaps pediatric vaccination rates would not be so abysmally low. Sadly, some doctors look at these low vaccination rates and don’t think its a problem at all. Some of them worked very hard to make this a reality. They don’t work with sick children.
Of course, when it comes to vaccines, it doesn’t matter whether COVID-19 or the flu is more dangerous for children. The only thing that matters is which is safer for children, the virus or the vaccine. For both flu and COVID-19, the vaccine is much safer than the virus. Those who truly advocate for children want them protected against any disease that could hospitalize or even rarely kill them. For COVID-19, essentially all children who need life support, develop severe MIS-C, or die are unvaccinated. We also have to be humble about the possibility of long-term side effects.
Similarly, with regards to the flu the CDC states that, “among reported pediatric deaths, about 80% of those children were not fully vaccinated”. Instead of playing word games with statistics to deceive people about the risk of COVID-19, doctors should be reminding people that children shouldn’t die from the flu either. Six dead children from the flu is six too many. As Dr. Daniel Freedman stated,
Those comparing COVID in children to flu in children really seem to forget that pediatricians were encouraging flu vaccines in kids for years before this pandemic. Protect eligible kids from both vaccine preventable diseases. Not complicated.
Some of us want zero children to die because they weren’t vaccinated. It’s astonishing that this is so controversial.
1,200 is much larger than 6
The American Academy of Pediatrics added 72 deaths to its COVID-19 death tally in the past month. This is over ten times the number of children who died of flu since the pandemic started. It should be controversial to argue that SARS-CoV-2 in kids is roughly, roughly the same as influenza, maybe even less severe than influenza, seasonal influenza in kids. It should be humiliating to argue that SARS-CoV-2 in kids is roughly, roughly the same as influenza, maybe even less severe than influenza, seasonal influenza in kids. Yet, many doctors still do.
When it comes to dead children, 1,200 is much larger than 6.
Don’t trust anyone who tries to convince you otherwise.
        ◦ Correction notice: The original version of this article stated that only once had the CDC’s pediatric flu death estimate exceeded the AAP’s COVID-19 death tally for 2021. In fact, the CDC’s estimated flu burden exceeded this during the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, as stated in the original article, but also in 2012-2013 and 2014-2015. Thank you to the reader who pointed this out. I regret the error.

1,200 Equals 6
A satirical rebuttal to an article titled “1,200 is More Than 6”.
Jonathan HowardonFebruary 6, 2022
Link
In his article “1,200 is More Than 6“, Dr. Howard wrote that “Some of us want zero children to die because they weren’t vaccinated.” Well, he’s entitled to his opinion, of course, but we should recognize this statement for what it is- his opinion. Reasonable people can disagree with it, and I certainly do. I don’t want zero children to die of a vaccine-preventable disease. As long as fewer children die from COVID-19 than older people, I’m fine with it.
Dr. Howard further argued that “When it comes to dead children, 1,200 is much larger than 6.” I disagree with this too, and instead stand with with doctors who recently wrote that “For the unvaccinated child, COVID presents a health risk to children that is on par with the flu.”
Let’s look at the numbers to understand why they’re right and Dr. Howard is wrong. Since the start of the pandemic, over 1,200 children died of COVID-19 while 6 children died of the flu.
At first glance, you may not think that 1,200 equals 6. This is because you are guilty of groupthink and tribalism. Don’t worry, you are not alone. This is true of most doctors who actually have real-world responsibility for treating sick children. Unlike doctors who work in pediatric ICUs, I have a more nuanced, centrist, alt-middle approach, which is why you should pay money to read my thoughts on Substack.
Imagine, for example, that you won $75,000,000 in a lottery. You’d be pretty happy, right? Would you be any happier if you won an extra $1,200? Would you feel that differently if you won $75,001,200 instead of $75,000,000? Of course not. $1,200 would a drop of water in your ocean of cash. You wouldn’t even notice it.
Well, it so happens there are 75,000,000 million children in the USA, and 74,998,800 of them haven’t died of COVID-19. With this added context, it’s clear that 1,200 dead children is not really that different than 6 dead children.
        ◦ And if two numbers aren’t that different, aren’t they basically the same?

The Road to Hitler is Paved with… Masks and Vaccines?
The next time a healthcare worker or educator is attacked by a “freedom-loving” anti-vaxxer, it’s reasonable to wonder who convinced the assailant that life-saving public health measures are in fact a ruse to pave the way for the next Hitler.
Warning: This article contains offensive images about the Holocaust and sexual assault
Jonathan Howard on October 22, 2021
Link

A controversial essay
Oncologist Dr. Vinay Prasad recently ignited a controversy by opining that public health measures to control a virus could one day lead to totalitarianism similar to what occurred in Nazi Germany. In his article, titled “How Democracy Ends: COVID19 Policy Shows a (Potential) Path to the End of America”, he warned that:
When democratically elected systems transform into totalitarian regimes, the transition is subtle, stepwise, and involves a combination of pre-planned as well as serendipitous events. Indeed, this was the case with Germany in the years 1929-1939, where Hitler was given a chance at governing, the president subsequently died, a key general resigned after a scandal and the pathway to the Fuhrer was inevitable.
The backlash was swift and fierce. The chairwoman of his department tweeted, “As a daughter in a family who has known Nazi horrors, I’m appalled by comparisons of this regime with pandemic response. Inflammatory, unhelpful to the discourse, ultimately harmful”. Medical ethicist Art Caplan said that:
The notion that public health will lead us to fascism due to efforts to control COVID is ludicrous, dangerous, and offensive. It’s anti-Semitic, anti-gay, anti-Romani people. It cheapens the deaths of those who died in camps for political objections, or in the case of Jehovah’s Witnesses, religious objections.
Dr. David Gorksi similarly excoriated Dr. Prasad by noting the author:
…consciously chose the example of Nazi Germany, no matter how inappropriate it was to his attempt to fear monger about a ‘future scenario’ in which a future President seizes power based on the example of COVID-19 responses. Either he did it just to be inflammatory, in which case he’s dishonest, or because he believes it to be an accurate historical comparison, in which case he’s an ignoramus of history.
Even doctors who defended Dr. Prasad against charges of anti-Semitism felt his article was “poorly conceived and executed.”
The dangers of ignoring 7-foot hoops
To criticisms that Dr. Prasad’s article was historically ignorant and offensive, I would add this: it’s potentially dangerous. This may seem overwrought to anyone who is unfamiliar with the anti-vaccine movement, a movement whose “success” can be seen in falling levels of routine childhood vaccinations and outbreaks of deadly diseases. Dr. Prasad has previously expressed disdain for doctors who counter medical misinformation, comparing it to dunking on a 7-foot hoop. As such, those of us who have long-believed that combating anti-vaccine misinformation was a worthwhile endeavor likely understand some important things about the anti-vaccine movement that he does not.
For example, Dr. Prasad’s “plan” to protect children this May was that to declare that the “Vast majority of kids recover quickly from SARS cov 2. And after all adults are vaccinated their risk of covid will decline precipitously. It’s ok to acknowledge that covid19 is not an emergency for kids”. As I was content to dunk on this 7-foot hoop, I pointed out this “plan” was nothing more than a naïve hope, something that was obvious to anyone with even passing knowledge of the anti-vaccine movement in the USA. Indeed shortly after Dr. Prasad announced his “plan”, adult vaccinations lagged, the Delta variant arrived, and cases, hospitalizations, and deaths in children spiked to their highest levels. Tragically, 252 children have died of COVID-19 in the USA since May, including healthy teens whose lives could have been saved by the vaccine, which is very effective in this age group. As far as I know, Dr. Prasad has neglected to inform his readers of these facts, though he’s always very eager to discuss vaccine myocarditis or rehash the trite argument (discussed here) that COVID-19 can’t be that bad for kids as long as more elderly people die.
The risks of specious comparisons between public health measures and fascism becomes clear when one appreciates the extent to which many anti-vaxxers believe they are grievously persecuted victims and that vaccines pose an existential threat. Some believe vaccines are part of a depopulation agenda, perhaps explaining why vaccines are routinely blamed for causing infertility, a claim promoted Dr. Christiane Northrup. Vaccines are frequently compared to genocide and the Holocaust. Images comparing vaccines to Nazism and vaccine advocates to Hitler are commonplace. Dr. Rashid Buttar said the vaccine was part of a “depopulation plan” and compared Dr. Anthony Fauci to Hitler, saying “the number of deaths caused by Fauci will exceed those of the Holocaust”. Robert F. Kennedy Jr. compared vaccines to the Holocaust and vaccine advocate Dr. Paul Offit to a Nazi war criminal. Now hapless educators are also getting threatened and likened to Nazis (watch this).
Many anti-vaxxers falsely believe that vaccines and vaccine mandates violate the Nuremberg Code, and some have even taken to wearing yellow Stars of David as a perverse symbol of their imagined persecution. Dr. Bob Sears made this horrific analogy in 2015. Given their eagerness to minimize the Holocaust, it’s not surprising that anti-Semitism is rife in the anti-vaccine movement. Comparisons between Nazism and vaccines are frequent enough that the Auschwitz Memorial felt compelled to respond thusly:
Instrumentalization of the tragedy of all people who between 1933-45 suffered, were humiliated, tortured & murdered by the hateful totalitarian regime of Nazi Germany to argue against vaccination that saves human lives is a sad symptom of moral and intellectual decline. https://t.co/BVwhi67SlI
— Auschwitz Memorial (@AuschwitzMuseum) July 20, 2021
Anti-vaxxers also are fond of comparing vaccination to rape, and memes glorifying violence against vaccinators are common. None of this is particularly extreme in anti-vaccine circles. It’s normal and has been so for many years. This material is shocking only to doctors who felt it was beneath them to pay attention.
The following illustration, which predates COVID-19, illustrates the raw paranoia behind much of the anti-vaccine mindset. (Note the “Zion” star on the officer’s uniform.)
This paranoia is nothing new, of course, and in fact, fears about vaccines even predate Edward Jenner, as anyone who knows the name Benjamin Jesty is aware.
Future fantasies versus current realities: Part 1
Though they often camouflage their agenda with seemingly unobjectionable calls for “bodily sovereignty“, “medical freedom“, or “parental rights“, there has always been a strong undercurrent of violent rhetoric in the anti-vaccine movement. Drs. David Gorski and Steve Novella have discussed this several times previously (here and here), and as the rhetoric has moved off social media and into the real world, it’s worthwhile to take stock of what actually has been happening on the ground recently. It’s not pretty. Exhausted healthcare workers have gone from heroes to literal punching bags.
    • Hundreds of public health officials have resigned or retired rather than face abuse and threats. According to news reports, “Some have become the target of far-right activists, conservative groups and anti-vaccination extremists who have coalesced around common goals: fighting mask orders, quarantines and contact tracing with protests, threats and personal attacks”. According to a survey from The New York Times, “Public health agencies have seen a staggering exodus of personnel, many exhausted and demoralized, in part because of abuse and threats”. They report “more than 500 top health officials who left their jobs in the past 19 months”.
    • Dr. Anthony Fauci needed “personal security from law enforcement at all times, including at his home”. According to news reports, “he and his family have required continued security in the face of harassment and death threats from people angry over his guidance on the coronavirus pandemic”. Dr. Peter Hotez has been doxxed and subject to coordinated campaigns of harassment for his vaccine advocacy. According to Dr. Hotez, the hate mail he received “was filled with all sorts of Nazi imagery, Nuremberg hangings and terrible, terrible stuff. It was pretty upsetting”. Prior to the pandemic, Dr. Richard Pan was assaulted in the street for advocating for vaccines. Dr. David Gorski has been the victim of harassment campaigns.
    • A Nature survey of 321 scientists found that “more than two-thirds of researchers reported negative experiences as a result of their media appearances or their social media comments, and 22% had received threats of physical or sexual violence. Some scientists said that their employer had received complaints about them, or that their home address had been revealed online. Six scientists said they were physically attacked”. Dr. Novella discussed this here.
    • Anti-vaxxers have protested outside hospitals in Canada and elsewhere. According to news reports, “A crowd rallying against vaccination for Covid-19 clogged the streets outside a Vancouver hospital this week, haranguing and, in one case, assaulting health care workers, slowing ambulances, delaying patients entering for treatment, and disturbing those recovering inside”.
    • Pro-fascist groups opposed to vaccines have staged violent rallies in Italy. This included storming an emergency room and attacking a nurse and police officers.
    • In Russia, an actor wore a yellow star at an awards ceremony and spoke of “waking up in a world where [COVID-19 vaccination] became an identification mark”. In France, “demonstrators carried signs evoking the Auschwitz death camp or South Africa’s apartheid regime”. Across the world, Jewish stars are used as a symbol of anti-vaxxer “persecution”.
    • In Australia, “Anti-vaccine and extreme right-wing groups have led violent rallies” and “Prominent fascists were among the crowd”. In Germany, an “anti-lockdown, anti-vaccine movement with links to the far right has recruited hundreds of children into a private online group”. Anti-vaccine protesters there yelled “Hands off our children”.
    • Anti-vaccine rallies have turned violent in Los Angeles and anti-vaxxers have disrupted vaccination sites there. They did the same thing in Georgia. In New York City, they attacked a COVID-19 testing station.
    • Prior to the pandemic, an anti-vaccine protester hurled blood in a menstrual cup at California lawmakers to protest vaccine mandates.
    • A man in Maryland killed his brother, a pharmacist, and sister-in-law because they were “killing people with the Covid shot”.
    • A principal in Arizona, was confronted by men carrying zip ties, and was threatened with a “citizen’s arrest” after the child of one of the men was told to quarantine because of a possible exposure to the virus. That principal received threats such as, “Next time it will be a barrel pointed at your Nazi face”.
    • According to news reports, “A parent in Northern California barged into his daughter’s elementary school and punched a teacher in the face over mask rules. At a school in Texas, a parent ripped a mask off a teacher’s face during a ‘Meet the Teacher’ event”.
    • In Georgia, “A customer who argued about wearing a face mask at a Georgia supermarket shot and killed a cashier on Monday and wounded a sheriff’s deputy who was providing security at the store”. This is an extreme example of a sadly common occurrence.
    • A pharmacist in Wisconsin destroyed COVID-19 vaccines as he believed that the “Covid-19 vaccine was not safe for people and could harm them and change their DNA”.
    • Doctors in Idaho “have been accused of killing patients by grieving family members who don’t believe COVID-19 is real”. A hospital spokesperson said, “Our health care workers are almost feeling like Vietnam veterans, scared to go into the community after a shift”. Hospitals are installing extra “panic buttons” to protect their workers from assaults.
    • According to news reports, “The Hawaii lieutenant governor watched in horror as protesters showed up outside his condo, yelled at him through bullhorns and beamed strobe lights into the building to harass him over vaccine requirements.”
    • In Canada, a man “…punched a nurse in the face multiple times, knocking her to the ground after she administered a Covid-19 vaccine to his wife without his permission”. Nurses have also been attacked in Guatemala by anti-vaccine residents of a village.
    • Anti-vaxxers have harassed children and their parents. In the UK, one yelled at a mother, “She’ll have immunity, you shouldn’t be getting the vaccine since you have natural immunity. You shouldn’t be using her as a lab rat”. In California an anti-vaxxer yelled at children walking to school, “They’re trying to rape our children with this poison. They’re going to rape their lives away”. Another compared masking to “child abuse”.
    • Several years ago, leading anti-vaxxer Del Bigtree said, “Do you think it’s a good idea to let the government own your baby’s body and right behind it your body? That is the end for me. Anyone who believes in the right to bear arms. To stand up against your government. I don’t know what you were saving that gun for then. I don’t know when you planned on using it if they were going to take control of your own body away. It’s now. Now’s the time”.
    • Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene suggested that citizens use their “Second Amendment rights,” to greet community members knocking on doors to encourage vaccination. Rep. Madison Cawthorn suggested that such vaccination campaigns could be a pretense to “take” people’s guns and Bibles.
    • Tucker Carlson said the Pentagon’s vaccine mandate was an attempt to weed out “men with high testosterone”, that it was anti-Christian, and that the military is “doing PR for Satanists”. He also said that “Buying a fake vaccination card is an act of desperation by decent, law-abiding Americans who have been forced into a corner by tyrants”.
    • Some people apparently believe that “COVID-19 vaccines are called Luciferase, have the patent number 060606 and come from a digital program called Inferno”. Republican officials in Florida and New Hampshire have likened the vaccine to Satanism as have several religious leaders in the US and Bolivia. The imagined connection between vaccines and Satan is also not new.
    • According to news reports, “Anti-vaccine demonstrations across Ohio in recent weeks are drawing extremists that include conspiracy theorists, white supremacists and people who misappropriate the Holocaust”. In Washington “anti-mask protesters that included the Proud Boys attempted to gain entry” to three schools, forcing them to lockdown.
    • In Los Angeles, “city leaders approved an ordinance Tuesday that would bar protests within 300 feet of the residence belonging to the person being targeted, a move that came following months of demonstrations outside the homes of public and elected officials”.
    • In Texas, “a man has been charged after allegedly threatening to gun down a Maryland doctor who urged the public to take the coronavirus vaccine”.
    • Countless school board meetings have been disrupted by anti-vaxxers, often linked with the Proud Boys and other right-wing extremist groups. According to news reports, “Drawing false equivalence between COVID regulations and Nazi fascism is popular among anti-vax, anti-mask groups, including some local teachers and school board members”.
    • In California, “A breast cancer patient says she was sprayed with bear mace, physically assaulted, and verbally abused outside a cancer treatment center in West Hollywood, Los Angeles by far-right activists who were angry over the clinic’s mandatory mask policy”.
    • Dr. Simone Gold, founder of the anti-vaccine group America’s Frontline Doctors, was arrested for her role in the 1/6 insurrection.
I could go on.
In contrast, I am aware of just a single instance of violence against an anti-vaxxer, when a Proud Boy was shot in the ankle during an anti-vaccine demonstration. Even in this instance, it’s not even clear he was shot because of his anti-vaccine views. As is appropriate in the USA, anti-vaxxers walk down the street as freely as those who volunteered to be in vaccine trials (like me). Anti-vaxxers may not be able to enter certain venues, and some have lost their job, which is significant, but vaccinators aren’t attacking people in the street, or injecting people against their will. Unvaccinated people aren’t being rounded up or branded or forced to wear distinguishing badges. In fact, public health experts are exquisitely concerned about protecting anti-vaxxers’ feelings, worrying that “shaming and blaming the unvaccinated could backfire”. There are constant reminders, including from Dr. Prasad, not to shame the unvaccinated.
Anti-vaxxers know they are in no real danger from a totalitarian police state, which is why, despite their noxious comparisons to Holocaust victims, they are not hiding like Anne Frank. Not only are they not cowering in fear, many anti-vaxxers feel emboldened to loudly and publicly threaten and attack anyone they don’t like. Jews were forced to wear yellow stars to make them to stand out. Anti-vaxxers are choosing to wear them as a pathetic means to draw attention to themselves. Their outrage theater isn’t just offensive, it’s also incredibly stupid.
Future fantasies versus current realities: Part 2
I’m not a historian, but the paranoia, threats, and street violence does seem eerily reminiscent of the violence that ushered in fascist regimes. As the above examples show, around the world anti-vaxxers long-associated with “wellness” and “natural health” are increasingly linked with QAnon adherents, white supremacists, and right-wing extremists – an unholy union termed conspirituality – to be part of a glorious crusade against “medical tyranny” (there’s a great podcast devoted to this topic). Anti-vaccination ideas are baked into right-wing white-nationalist movements. Simply put, the anti-vaccine movement has been red-pilled.
Even though it didn’t happen with previous pandemics, I suppose it’s conceivable that some dictator in the year 2090 will end American democracy under the pretense of trying to control a virus. But we need to be clear that right now democracy in America seems to be hanging on by a thread, and the “patriots” who violently tried to execute politicians and overturn the 2020 election are the same people who violently oppose vaccines, masks, and basically any attempt to control the virus. The men who tried to kidnap the governor of Michigan were members of a far-right paramilitary militia called the Wolverine Watchmen, not the Michigan branch of Voices for Vaccines.
When Dr. Prasad writes, “The key lesson of the coronavirus pandemic is not that the fall of democracy is inevitable, but rather that our policy preferences, and polarization, have set the stage for a series of events where it is possible democracy falls”, these people might only protest on grounds they’ve been plagiarized and that Dr. Prasad is late to the ballgame. They completely agree with his thesis that public health measures could lead to Hitler and have been saying as much for years. The right-wing, anti-vaxx media sphere is full of hysterical articles such as “Biden Announces New COVID Response, Including Vaccine Mandates, That Doubles Down on Totalitarian Tactics” and “Vaccine Mandates Are Totalitarian.” An anti-vaccine doctor claimed that vaccinating children against COVID-19 “violates human rights, Constitutional rights, bill of rights with extreme experimentation!” Every anti-vaxxer rally laments the supposed end of freedom in America due to vaccines and mandates.
Given that some anti-vaxxers really believe vaccines are a form of population control that will soon be forcibly injected into screaming babies by a Jewish police state, their aggressive behavior makes perfect sense. From their twisted viewpoint, resisting vaccination by any means necessary isn’t just permissible, it’s downright heroic. They are the good guys, standing up for innocent children against Big Pharma, the Deep State, and their nefarious “forced vaccination” agenda. Anti-vaxxers in California, Oregon, and Canada have compared their “resistance” to that of Civil Rights icon Rosa Parks. Anti-vaccine organizations honestly feel they are standing up for liberty and the American way against totalitarian public health measures.
This explains why, using typical Orwellian language, one such group claims to be “pro-informed consent, pro-democracy, pro-debate, pro-information exchange, pro-First Amendment, pro-science, pro-parental rights, pro-bodily sovereignty, and pro-conscientious decision-making”. Their supposed mission is to ensure that “America still stands for health freedom”. Another anti-vaccine, “health freedom” organization claims that “Government has the responsibility and duty to protect health freedom and to make no law or public policy abridging health freedom or its fundamental principles”. They warn that, “When health care options are eliminated through restrictive laws and regulations, choices are eliminated and access to health becomes meaningless”. Most anti-vaccine groups use this sort of melodramatic language, claiming that the road to Hitler is paved with masks and vaccines. This is bread and butter stuff for them. You can even buy an anti-vaxx sign that outlines the slippery slope to totalitarianism that could have been the template for Dr. Prasad’s essay.
All of this horribleness predates Dr. Prasad’s essay of course. But a highly-credentialed doctor with the imprimatur of a top medical school and a large platform isn’t helping anything when his oppression fantasy legitimizes the fears of paranoid, aggressive people, priming them to perceive themselves as victims of a police-state. Dr. Prasad isn’t making life easier for his embattled colleagues in the ER when he echoes anti-vaxx conspiracies by tweeting that hospitals “admit less sick patients” to maximize “their ‘non-profits'” and the number of patients hospitalized with COVID-19 is therefore a “fear monger tactic,” not a marker of a dangerous virus. As pediatricians face harassments and threats for suggesting masks, he criticized the American Academy of pediatrics by saying, “there is no organization left in America that actually seeks to defend the interests of children.”
Dr. Jennifer Gunter said Dr. Prasad’s article was “an audition to be the Surgeon General of QAnon”, and it’s possible he was trying to be purposefully provocative for attention and precious podcast invitations. However, as Dr. Prasad’s ignorance of 7-foot hoops is a source of great pride for him, he may have been genuinely caught off guard by the strong reaction his essay elicited from doctors who are familiar with and threatened by these low hoops. He may be blissfully unaware of the Holocaust minimization and anti-Semitism that is rampant in anti-vaccine circles. He may not know that some Jewish doctors have been targeted this pandemic. It’s painful for vaccine advocates who lost family in the Holocaust to be compared to Nazi executioners.
Personally, as a Jewish dunker of 7-foot hoops, I was less offended by his article than I was worried by how suspicious, volatile people may receive it. Even though he claimed it was merely warning about a future, hypothetical scenario, it’s extremely validating for anti-vaxxers when a respectable, mainstream physician parrots their message, confirming that their fears of totalitarianism are legitimate and grounded in reality. Some sincerely believe their brave advocacy is the only thing preventing the nightmarish scenario Dr. Prasad describes. Others believe Dr. Prasad’s totalitarian state has already arrived, and the time for peaceful protest has passed. Like him, they believe reports of people hospitalized with COVID-19 are nothing but a “fear monger tactic”. The fact that anti-vaccine propaganda has killed hundreds of thousands of Americans this year doesn’t bother anti-vaxxers a bit because they think the death toll is inflated too.
I fully agree with Dr. Prasad that democracy is fragile and we need to guard against totalitarianism. However, there’s no need to engage in fanciful speculation about imagined, future dangers to American democracy when it is gravely threatened right now by the very people who are likely to feel vindicated and even emboldened by his message. There are real-world consequences to fallacious comparisons between public health measures and Nazism, and these consequences will be borne by the people who interact with enraged citizens every day. Contrarian academics seemingly divorced from frontline patient care will continue their media appearances unabated, their main worry being that YouTube might “silence” them by removing one of their videos. In contrast, vaccine advocates with actual responsibilities need to worry if the angry protestors outside their home will stay outside. There are a lot of angry, dangerous people out there, and some have been inspired to commit horrific acts of violence by what they read online.
        ◦ Everyone is responsible for their own actions. But the next time an educator, public servant, or healthcare provider is threatened or attacked by a “freedom-loving” anti-vaxxer, it’s reasonable to wonder who convinced the assailant that masks and vaccines are in fact a ruse to pave the way for the next Hitler.

Doctors Must be Honest with Parents About Known Risks of COVID-19
Pediatricians know their job is to present accurate and thorough information so parents can make informed decisions. Contrarian doctors who write about COVID-19 should spend less time lecturing pediatricians and more time learning from them.
Jonathan Howard on November 13, 2021
Link

Dr. Vinay Prasad, an adult oncologist, recently ignited yet another social media kerfuffle with an article titled “Doctors Must be Honest with Parents About Unknown Risks of COVID-19 Emergency Vaccine”. Addressing experienced pediatricians as if they were first year medical students at best or dishonest charlatans at worst, he wrote that it is “vital that medical practitioners don’t exaggerate or embellish what is known in this moment”. In this article, he warned of vaccine-related myocarditis and quoted the highest reported rate (1 in 5,000) from an insurance company as if it were established fact, ignoring multiple studies that found much lower rates. However, the point of my article is not a point-by-point discussion of such flaws in Dr. Prasad’s article- science communicator Edward Nirenberg has already done this. Rather, while I agree with Dr. Prasad’s ultimate conclusion – “Most likely, vaccinating will end up being a benefit to kids” – the point of my article is to show that Dr. Prasad fails to meet the standards he set for other doctors when he makes statements such as, “It is also reasonable for a parent to decide to sit back and wait a bit for additional safety data to accumulate”.
Informed consent for the COVID-19 vaccine
To understand why, let’s examine the elements of informed consent and how this might apply to the COVID-19 vaccine for children. Informed consent requires patients be educated on several points:
    • The risks and side effects of the proposed treatment;
    • The benefits of the proposed treatment;
    • The alternatives to the treatment, including the risks, side effects, and benefits thereof; and
    • The risks of not receiving the proposed treatment.
I’ve discussed the vaccine with many young adults, and though I am not a pediatrician, I imagine my discussion with parents of young children would go something like this.
The good news is your child is almost certainly going to be fine no matter what. Still, I want to help you make the best decision. Since I don’t think too many children will be able to dodge the virus for the rest of their lives, the question we are facing is: Which is more dangerous to your child, the virus or the vaccine? Importantly, we docs don’t just suggest vaccines for no reason. I’ve never suggested anyone get the yellow fever, cholera, or the Ebola vaccine. These are fine vaccines, but your child has no risk from these diseases. So, there is no point in even risking a sore arm.
For COVID-19, however, the virus is clearly more dangerous than the vaccine. First let’s talk about the risks of the vaccine. The most common side effects are what you’d expect; a sore arm, fatigue, headaches, muscle pain, and a fever. These are unpleasant, but overall mild and temporary. The mRNA vaccines come with a risk of myocarditis after the second shot for young men. The exact frequency isn’t clear, but according to several studies, it’s somewhere between 1 in 7,000 to 1 in 10,000 boys after the second shot. It may be much less, perhaps 1 in 37,000, with Pfizer’s vaccine, which is the vaccine your child will receive, than Moderna’s vaccine.
Most people with myocarditis are hospitalized for a few days, mainly for observation. Almost all are treated with simple treatments. In one of the largest studies, 95% of cases the clinical course “was generally mild, with resolution of myocarditis in most cases”. According to the CDC, 77% of affected people have recovered so far, and hopefully the rest are on the way to recovery. Affected individuals are advised to abstain from vigorous activity for a few months and monitoring is ongoing to see if there are any long-term cardiac consequences from this. We will know more about this next year than we do now. The issue should not be trivialized, though pediatric cardiologists have written that on follow-up, these children’s “cardiac MRIs that look very, very reassuring”. I am unaware of any deaths in adolescents from this vaccine, and many millions of them have been vaccinated around the world.
In contrast, according to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, the virus has killed over 900 children in the USA so far, and while most had common medical comorbidities such as asthma and obesity, about 20% of children who die of COVID-19 are healthy. Still, the risk of a healthy child dying of COVID-19 is extremely low, likely less than 1 in 100,000, though no one knows the exact number. Death is the worst outcome, but not the only bad one. Tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized, some very sick, needing ICU-level care and intubation. Over 5,500 children have developed MIS-C, and most of these children go to the ICU. These children can have a severe myocarditis and even acute heart failure. 48 children have died from this. Though they don’t need to go to the hospital, many other children just feel sick and rotten for a while. We have to be humble about the possibility of long-term consequences that we cannot currently appreciate. The vast majority of children do just fine with COVID-19 thankfully, but not all. This is also true for many viruses – even polio – and your child likely received vaccines against them already.
Happily, the vaccine is very effective at preventing these rare, but catastrophic outcomes in adolescents. A CDC study found that “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents”. Another CDC study of hospitalized adolescents found that:
Among 179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.
Tragically, a number of unvaccinated teenagers have died of COVID-19 this summer after the vaccine was available to them. They and their parents did not know the risks of the virus and the benefits of the vaccine. These deaths were almost certainly preventable. Sadly, the same will be true for children ages 5-11 years who die moving forward. This is a very contagious virus that is spreading in many parts of the country now. Though rates are down from their peak, over 10,000 children are still getting COVID-19 every day in the USA.
Waiting for more safety data sounds nice, but while you wait, your child remains vulnerable. And this vaccine has been studied in children. The vaccine trial for younger children involved 2,268 children. The vaccine was 90.7% effective at preventing COVID-19. Overall, 3,100 children have received the vaccine as part of safety studies. The vaccine was safe in this study, though it was not large enough to detect rare side effects. As myocarditis is generally less common in young children compared to teenagers, vaccine experts are cautiously optimistic it will be less of an issue for them. Already, nearly a million children in the USA have received the vaccine. Vaccine experts voted unanimously to approve the vaccine, and every pediatrician I know was thrilled to vaccinate their own children as soon as possible.
I read many articles this summer of children’s hospitals being overwhelmed with children with COVID-19. I’ve never read any article about any hospital being overwhelmed with children suffering complications from the vaccine. The decision is yours, of course. We are on the same team here. We all just want to keep your child healthy and out of the hospital. The vaccine is the best way to do that. It’s a nice bonus that vaccinating your child will also help protect others and end the pandemic.
Doctors must be honest with parents about known risks of COVID-19
I am sure that pediatricians around the country are having some version of this talk countless times per day. They don’t need anyone to tell them how to do the most basic part of their job. They’ve been doing this for their entire careers. As one pediatrician said:
Every conversation I had yesterday (and there were dozens) re: covid vax & kids involved the discussion of risk, including myocarditis. For Vinay Prasad to imply this is not happening, & @usatodayopinion to publish it, is beyond infuriating. Shame on them. #tweetatrician pic.twitter.com/BDyjXiy5po
— snarky pediatrician 🟧🟦 (@snarkypeds) November 5, 2021
Pediatricians know their job is to present accurate and thorough information so parents can make informed decisions.
Perhaps then, instead of lecturing pediatricians and blocking them all on Twitter, Dr. Prasad should learn from them. After all, he is one of several contrarian doctors who has written extensively on COVID-19 and children while habitually neglecting to inform readers of crucial facts; namely that 900 children have died, that many thousands have been hospitalized, and that the vaccine works incredibly well at preventing severe illness in adolescents. These doctors, who assuredly consider themselves “pro-vaccine“, have no such reservations about repeatedly discussing vaccine myocarditis (here, here, here, here, here, here). In fact, it’s quite likely that the number of times they have discussed vaccine-related myocarditis exceeds the number of children currently hospitalized with the condition. Dr. Prasad was so concerned about vaccinated-related myocarditis he thought earlier this summer “that the US should suspend all vaccination in children under 18 and give only one dose of vaccine to men under 25”. The UK essentially adopted this policy, earning praise from Dr. Prasad for their “rationality & numeracy“. Shortly thereafter, the headlines predictably declared that “Children Drive Britain’s Longest-Running Covid Surge,” though Dr. Prasad hasn’t acknowledged this reality as far as I know.
Though he claims to support “language that empowers parents to take part in a shared decision-making discussion”, Dr. Prasad’s article did not enumerate how the virus has harmed children, nor did it inform readers that the vaccine can prevent these harms. I may have missed it, but I can’t recall any article by Dr. Prasad where he informs his readers of these basic facts. The closest he comes to acknowledging grave outcomes in children seems merely to rehash versions of the trite arguments that COVID-19 can’t be bad for kids because it’s worse elderly people (discussed here) and more children die of suicide (discussed here). Moreover, while Dr. Prasad’s article discusses the rate of vaccine-related myocarditis, it inexplicably neglects its generally favorable prognosis. Dr. Prasad wrote “it is absolutely essential that we communicate about this vaccine in an informative and nuanced way”. That sounds nice. So, where’s the information in his articles? Where’s the nuance?
Some people may argue that doctors writing for a general audience about children and the COVID-19 vaccine have different responsibilities from a doctor discussing the vaccine with a patient. I don’t see it this way. Any doctor with the privilege of writing in a major newspaper for an audience of millions has an obligation to be both accurate and thorough. As the principles of informed consent require, doctors should not just discuss the risks of the vaccine, but also the risks of the virus and the benefits of the vaccine. Leaving a child vulnerable to COVID-19 isn’t like driving drunk on a dark road at 120 MPH without a seatbelt. There’s no need to exaggerate the risk. But it’s not a risk-free proposition either. As he defends those who “decide to sit back and wait a bit for additional safety data”, I believe Dr. Prasad has an obligation to make it very clear what those risks are, especially considering 107,350 children contracted COVID-19 last week alone and 236 children have died in the past 3 months, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics. To paraphrase Dr. Prasad, doctors must be honest with parents about the known risks of COVID-19 and the known benefits of the vaccine.
This is incredibly easy to do of course. It only requires one paragraph and a writer who cares whether his readers are well-informed or not. Naturally, most doctors are thrilled to trumpet the studies showing the vaccine’s amazing success in keeping adolescents healthy and out of the hospital. Unfortunately, even though some parents are under the false impression that COVID-19 poses no risk to children, it’s clear some doctors don’t care about informing their readers. You don’t have to take my word for it, they readily admit this. As I discussed previously, one doctor even said that my concern was a “rather small nit to pick” and that providing readers with basic facts was a “waste of ink”. Perhaps they can write a rebuttal to this article and title it “In Defense of Omitting Facts”. It’s fine for a doctor to argue their viewpoint, of course, but writers who repeatedly exclude these facts should have their work read with this question in mind: “What information is the author omitting because it would undermine their argument?”
        ◦ Dr. Prasad wrote, “This is not the time for uninformative persuasion”. I couldn’t agree more. I hope doctors like him start to communicate about this vaccine in an informative and nuanced way.

Dr. Vinay Prasad: “Public Health’s (Mis)Truth Problem”
Dr. Vinay Prasad continues to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the government response to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.
Lynn Shaffer on February 27, 2022
Link

Oncologist Dr. Vinay Prasad is at it yet again in a recent article published in City Journal, promoting himself as the scientist-physician who shines a light on government incompetence and corruption as he leads us to a post-COVID promised land. City Journal, I discovered after writing this post, appears to be a conservative publication which “holds itself to the highest intellectual, journalistic, and literary standards, aiming to produce absorbing reading for intelligent and discerning readers.” I urge them to keep trying.
Prasad’s article (which is representative of his other articles found if you Google “Vinay Prasad masks” or “Vinay Prasad vaccine”) is titled “Public Health’s Truth Problem”, and the first paragraph outlines his over-arching theme that public health organizations are continually spreading “falsehoods” and “omitting uncomfortable truths” with long-term consequences to these institutions. He then starts several paragraphs with an italicized statement made by the CDC or FDA which he presents as a falsehood. Let’s review his assertions and whether they hold up.
“Any mask is better than no mask“
Last week, CDC director Rochelle Walensky asserted that any mask is better than no masks at all. This statement was factually incorrect when she said it. The only published cluster randomized trial of community cloth masking during Covid-19—performed in rural Bangladesh—found that surgical masks reduced the spread of Covid-19 among villages assigned to wear them, while cloth masks were no better than no masks at all regarding the primary endpoint of blood-test-confirmed Covid-19. In an umbrella review of masking that I coauthored, we found no good evidence to support cloth masking. Two days after Walensky’s statement, the CDC conceded that cloth masking was inferior to other masks. Notably, however, this is still misleading because cloth masking is not just less effective—it is entirely ineffective.
Prasad appears to suggest that “any mask is better than no mask” is logically inconsistent with “cloth masking was inferior to other masks,” or that the CDC flip-flopped by “conceding” the latter. However, the two conditions can co-exist.
Furthermore, Prasad’s interpretation of the Bangladesh trial’s results (“cloth masks were no better than no masks at all”) is incorrect. To interpret the results we look at the confidence interval for the adjusted prevalence ratio (aPR) for diagnosis of COVID-19. From the original article:
Although the point estimates for cloth masks suggests that they reduce risk, the confidence limits include both an effect size similar to surgical masks and no effect at all. (aPR = 0.94 [0.78,1.10]; control: 0.67%; treatment: 0.61%).
The shorthand way of interpreting the confidence interval (CI) is “we are 95% confident that the true adjusted prevalence ratio is within this range”, here from 0.78 to 1.10. The CI given allows for the possibility that cloth masks are better than (<1.0), the same as (equal to 1.0), or worse (>1.0) than wearing no mask at all. So it would be more accurate to say the trial was uninformative with respect to cloth masks vs. no masks. You cannot say “this trial demonstrates that cloth masks are no better than not wearing a mask.”
To expand on this further, consider that randomized trials ask specific questions, statistically and otherwise. The statistical plan and results of the study indicate that the investigators asked a “two-sided” question: Is there a difference between masking and not masking with respect to seropositivity? The null hypothesis (default position) is “the difference is zero” and the statistical methods are specific for this default position. By stating, “cloth masks were no better than no masks at all” Prasad is stating a one-sided question similar to that of non-inferiority (of no masks). With non-inferiority, you identify a small difference below which you think is unimportant with respect to differentiating the effects of cloth masks vs. no masking, then the null hypothesis or default position is “a difference of at least that much exists.” Different statistical methods are used to answer this one-sided question than are used for two-sided questions. In essence, you don’t get to change the hypothesis after the statistical analysis is done.
The beneficial effect of surgical masks was larger than it was for cloth masks, which is unsurprising. In the Bangladesh trial surgical masks had a statistically significant effect while the effect for cloth masks was not (although the point estimate was in the desired direction). Readers should be aware that, for whatever reason, the control (non-mask) positive seroprevalence rate for COVID-19 was higher in the surgical mask villages (0.81%) than in the cloth mask villages (0.67%). It is easier to show a statistically significant improvement when the baseline situation (SARS-CoV-2 infection) is more common or more severe than when it is rare or less severe, given the same number of people or villages. In addition, there were also fewer villages that received cloth masks than received surgical masks, and a smaller sample size also makes it more difficult to demonstrate statistical significance if there is a real but small effect. Therefore, the cloth masking comparison was somewhat handicapped compared to the surgical mask comparison and is another reason “cloth masks don’t work” cannot be accepted as “the truth”.
Also consider that in the Bangladesh trial, mask wearing was 13% in control villages and 42% in intervention villages. The issue may be that the intervention villages did not reach a threshold needed for cloth masks to be effective. This distinction – do masks work or is it that we can’t get people to wear them consistently and properly? – is important. If they don’t work, we abandon the idea. If they do, our efforts go towards facilitating proper mask wearing.
Another important consideration for the Bangladesh trial is the type of cloth masks provided:
We used high-quality surgical masks that had had a filtration efficiency of 95% (standard deviation [SD] = 1%); this is substantially higher than the filtration efficiency of the cloth masks we designed, which had a filtration efficiency of 37% (SD = 6%). These cloth masks had substantially higher filtration than common commercial 3-ply cotton masks, but lower than hybrid masks that use materials not commonly available for community members in low-resource settings.
Another article found that masks using cotton cloths of hybrid fabrics have higher filtration efficiency, i.e., over 90%. The authors of the Bangladesh trial have a reasonable rationale for testing the type of cloth mask that can be used in low resource settings. The problem is that Prasad lumped all cloth masks together with his “no better than no mask at all” remark – this is clearly an oversimplification. (I will defer a discussion as to whether we can extrapolate results obtained from rural villages in Bangladesh to cities and towns in high resource countries.)
Prasad mentions his review of masking studies where he stated that the quality of most studies was poor. If he was so hot on getting results from a high-quality randomized trial of mask wearing, why didn’t he design, fund and conduct one? Given his numerous commentaries and media appearances, he seems to have plenty of time for grant writing – except that any results from a trial of his would be compromised by his competing interests.
“You should wear an N95 mask“
Now the CDC has endorsed the use of N95 or equivalent masks in community settings, which it presents as the superior choice. Here, too, the evidence is misleading. First, a masking policy involves more than just the filtration properties of the material; it should consider both filtration and human behavior. Will people wear the mask appropriately?
Since he can’t argue that N95 masks are ineffective, he switches tactics to say that no one is going to wear them properly anyway, so there’s still no point to wearing a mask. If the real problem is we can never get people to wear masks properly, why did he spend time talking about how surgical masks work and cloth masks don’t?
Prasad doesn’t provide a reference for where CDC made this statement. Here is the statement in context. The CDC’s position early in the pandemic was that it was important to reserve the supply of N95 masks for health care personnel. More recently, the concern about the supply of N95 masks has decreased to the point where the CDC feels they can be used by people outside of healthcare. This is neither an arbitrary nor illogical change in position.
Prasad is misleading when he states that CDC says, “You should wear an N95 mask”. The actual CDC position is, and has been, “CDC continues to recommend that you wear the most protective mask you can, that fits well and that you will wear consistently“.
The virus changes, but our policies remain the same. Masking—even if it works—is not a permanent solution. It cannot work when you stop doing it. Recently, in a striking admission, Anthony Fauci confirmed not only that the virus will not be eliminated, but also that it will eventually infect us all. Even vaccination is not enough to entirely halt omicron breakthroughs. Thus, even if N95 masking delays the time to infection, we will eventually be infected. The question becomes: Is it worth it? We aren’t getting any younger, and at some point we will have to trust our immune systems (helped by vaccination) to fight off the virus. Is it worth it for a young person to delay exposure with an inconvenient and intrusive mask?
This appears to be Prasad’s attempt to dazzle people with gibberish:
    • We can’t wear masks forever. So forgettaboutit! Also, no one has said we will have to wear masks forever.
    • In the previous paragraph Prasad said that CDC changed their policy. Now he’s saying CDC policy doesn’t change.
    • Anthony Fauci predicted that the virus will not be eliminated. Why is this a “striking admission”? Because at one time, if everyone had collaborated to reduce viral transmission, it might have been possible to essentially stamp out the virus?
    • We are all doomed to be infected. Anthony Fauci said so. Even though he is a major spokesperson for a public health organization that regularly misleads us.
    • “We will have to trust our immune systems.” What? Prasad must have read that book that said all you need to do is send your wish into the universe.
“Is it worth it for a young person to delay exposure [by wearing a %$#!$@ mask]?” I find this philosophy of “let’s intentionally contract the disease” incomprehensible. Once again, Prasad demonstrates his lack of understanding that viruses can’t be penned like cattle. Second, as Dr. Howard has explained on SBM, some young people will become very ill with COVID-19. Even if they don’t die, they may have sequelae that last a long time. In a move I find baffling given his assertion that young people don’t suffer bad consequences from COVID-19, Prasad provides a link in a subsequent paragraph to an article where Paul Offit describes the heart wrenching suffering of children with severe COVID-19 illness.
“Kids suffer no harm from not seeing faces“
On August 12, 2021, after more than a year in which daycare providers routinely wore masks while caring for infants, the American Academy of Pediatrics tweeted: “Babies and young children study faces, so you may worry that having masked caregivers would harm children’s language development. There are no studies to support this concern”…The truth is, we don’t know. We are running an unprecedented experiment on our youth. We have never concealed faces from children in daycare for so many hours a day for so many years. Thus, we cannot be certain of the full effects.
Sometimes when I hear about the things we wring our hands over, it makes me appreciate how far humankind has come (at least for some fortunate countries). Generations ago, we feared the enemy would come to our village and hack our baby to death. Now, we worry about the possibility of a delay in language development.
My flippant comment aside, we should consider whether there are downsides to children not seeing adults’ faces, and how severe these effects might be. Then they must be compared to the problems of allowing COVID-19 to run through the community. First, if we don’t reduce transmission there will be staffing shortages of daycare workers. Second, since children spend time at home every day, it’s highly unlikely that young children are never seeing other people’s faces. Many parents have had to take their children out of daycare due to the pandemic, where kids are most likely seeing their parents’ faces.
If we want to stop wearing masks so that young children can see faces, this should motivate us to take actions that end the pandemic (masking, social distancing, vaccination) rather than offer up young people as a sort of “viral farm” whose crop eats us instead of the other way around.
“Vaccine policy must be one-size-fits-all“
First, consider boosters. The case for population-wide boosters, including for young, healthy adults, is tenuous and was contentious even among senior scientists. Marion Gruber and Phil Krause—the director and deputy director of the FDA—reportedly resigned over White House pressure to approve boosters for all…But substantial uncertainty persists that boosting a 20-year-old man will redound to his net health benefit. After two doses of mRNA vaccination, he will have a markedly reduced chance of hospitalization or death. He will also face a nonzero risk of myocarditis from a dose three. While a third dose may provide short-term protection against symptomatic disease, his disease would likely be mild anyway. We do not know with confidence that such a person should receive a booster. Recently, in light of these concerns, Paul Offit, director of the Vaccine Communication Center of Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, advised his own son not to receive a booster.
Prasad directly acknowledges that “the case for population-wide boosters … is tenuous and was contentious even among senior scientists.” “Contentious” and “tenuous” represent uncertainty and a case for both sides of an issue rather than “falsehoods” or “omitting uncomfortable truths.”
“…uncertainty persists that boosting a 20-year-old man will redound to his net health benefit.” Public Health 101: public health policies are aimed at maximizing the health of the population, not necessarily bringing the most benefit to specific individuals within that population. The latter is the role of medicine.
I love (not) the ominous connotation of “nonzero risk of myocarditis”. Others have already demonstrated that vaccine-induced myocarditis is very rare, treatable, less severe than myocarditis caused by SARS-CoV-2 infection, and the risk of vaccine-induced myocarditis does not justify foregoing vaccination. “Nonzero risk” is also not a useful concept and if you can only accept a “zero” risk, you have other issues (eating and drinking present a nonzero risk of choking).
Recently, the government made an unusual regulatory change. It had initially recommended boosters six months after the initial vaccination series for Moderna, but it has accelerated this timetable to five months. The FDA admitted that this decision was based on data submitted for the Pfizer vaccine after the initial Pfizer series. Thus the FDA used data from a different manufacturer, at a different dose, to make vaccine policy.
I’m not sure how worrisome this particular example is, but I can’t object to Prasad’s concern here. The FDA might not want to make a habit of this. However, this isn’t a “falsehood” or “omission of an uncomfortable truth”.
A theme that resonates throughout Prasad’s commentary is the idea that public health organizations should hold off on recommendations until multiple rigorous randomized trials are done or we otherwise have accumulated a lot of solid evidence behind them. Unfortunately, during an epidemic they simply don’t have that luxury. I can’t directly comment on the job that the CDC and FDA have done, mostly because once I got the message of “masking, social distancing, and vaccination” I didn’t micromanage it beyond that (except for wanting to get an mRNA vaccine). I wouldn’t be surprised if they made some mistakes or didn’t always communicate clearly. That’s not the same thing as systematically spreading falsehoods and omitting important facts. One should also keep in mind that public health organizations, whether national, state, or local, operate under the direction of politicians. It’s not unheard of for a public health organization to recommend “A” but it doesn’t happen because “A” is not politically expedient. In those situations, blaming the public health organization misses the point.
Recently, the CDC published an alarming study suggesting that children who get Covid-19 may develop diabetes at higher rates than normal. Yet the study was grievously flawed. It did not adjust for risk factors—being poor or overweight—that predispose to both diabetes and Covid-19. It also failed to note that the absolute risks were astonishingly low. One can’t help but wonder if the CDC promulgated a highly imperfect study to push vaccination in this age group.
It’s interesting to compare Prasad’s provocative language (“alarming”, “grievously flawed”, “astonishingly low”) with the dry language used by government employees. He seems to lean heavily on pushing people’s emotional hot buttons.
The CDC’s article is found in Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) and discusses both type I and type II diabetes. True, CDC did not control for BMI or other important confounders, most likely because they couldn’t with the data they had. The evidence presented is interesting, and the results do not tip the scales to accepting as settled the idea that COVID-19 causes diabetes in some pediatric patients. The study’s authors acknowledge this. Furthermore, Prasad omitted the fact that other investigators in different populations are making this same observation of new cases of diabetes following COVID-19, both in adults and children (the MMWR article provides the references for this).
The CDC’s recommendations are reasonable: “Monitoring for long-term consequences, including signs of new diabetes, following SARS-CoV-2 infection is important in this age group.” Although the absolute risk is low, it applies to millions of children and, if this association is causal, can affect people over most of their lives.
Conclusion: Prasad fails to demonstrate that public health is the source of misinformation
To recap:
    • “CDC flip-flopped and a RCT shows cloth masks don’t work” – wrong
    • “Now the CDC endorses N95 masks for the community but no one will wear them properly anyway” – not a falsehood or omission of an “uncomfortable fact,” but a misleading statement by Prasad
    • “The virus is changing but our policies don’t, don’t listen to Anthony Fauci but listen to him, we’re not getting any younger, we need to trust our immune systems” – gibberish
    • “Masks impair child language development” – vague, scary assertion made without supporting evidence by Prasad and not the CDC or FDA
    • “The case for boosters is contentious and tenuous” – perhaps, but this is not a falsehood or omission of uncomfortable truths
    • “The FDA made a recommendation for Moderna based on Pfizer data” – true, but not a falsehood or omission of uncomfortable truth
    • “The CDC published a poorly done study suggesting an association between incident diabetes and previous COVID-19 infection in children in order to promote vaccination in children” – CDC truthfully presented the data and its context, so essentially wrong; Prasad omitted an important piece of information and made an ominous-sounding assertion without supporting evidence
    • “Falsehoods and half-truths have consequences.” I hope they will for Vinay Prasad. Public health’s real truth problem is the mistruths he continues to spew.
And finally, “Yet, repeatedly, federal agencies and respected organizations push recommendations that are deeply uncertain, rely on fearmongering, or provide hollow reassurances.” I hear the word “fearmongering” a lot. It’s always followed by a different form of fearmongering. Prasad’s commentary gives the impression of a powerful entity either implementing a hidden agenda designed to control our every move or bungling every decision. You know what I’m afraid of? Choking to death over days or weeks in the hospital without getting a chance to say goodbye to my family. Did that fear originate from the government or big Pharma? No, it came from working in a hospital and talking with physicians who take care of patients with COVID-19..

Dr. Vinay Prasad echoes a common antivax trope that portrays concern about a deadly disease as irrational fear
Before the pandemic, antivaxxers likened concern about childhood diseases to mental illness. In the age of COVID-19, Dr. Vinay Prasad accuses medicine of “legitimizing” irrational anxiety and says we should treat COVID like the flu—with one telling omission. In a recent paid Substack, he doubles down and accuses physicians and scientists of anxiety disorders that “interfere with people’s lives”.
David Gorski on September 19, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: I have, for the first time in five years, taken two whole weeks off from both meatspace work and the blog (although I can’t seem to completely quit Twitter for two whole weeks, as some of you might have noticed). The reason? It’s my thirtieth wedding anniversary. (Last time was my 25th.) As a result, there is no new material today. I had thought of simply posting a “rerun” of one of my past SBM articles that I’m particularly proud of and consider a “classic,” but instead Dr. Prasad gave me an excuse to repost an article from my not-so-secret other blog published a couple of weeks ago. The excuse? A recent Substack by him titled “When scientists’ anxiety disorder interferes with other people’s lives“. It’s behind a paywall, but it might as well be the same article as the one that I deconstructed a couple of weeks ago by Dr. Prasad published on his less histrionic Substack Sensible Medicine titled “Legitimizing irrational anxiety is bad medicine“. In both cases, the message is the same. Doing anything more to avoid COVID-19 than we used to do against the flu in 2019 and before is “irrational” and evidence of an “anxiety disorder”, both among the public and scientists and physicians who have supposedly ‘imposed their anxiety disorder” on society. It’s an old antivax trope, namely that concern about infectious disease is evidence of excessive irrationality, fear, and even mental illness, such as an extreme anxiety disorder. Truly, Dr. Prasad is, at best, a useful idiot for antivax propagandists or, at worst, now officially antivaccine himself. I’ve also added a bit of text from the previous version, in order to address Dr. Prasad’s latest Substack (at least, what I as a nonsubscriber could read of it). So this post is actually updated!]
Those of us who had followed the antivaccine movement for a long time before the COVID-19 pandemic spread throughout the world in early 2020 have been routinely alarmed, amazed, and disappointed at how easily certain “COVID-19 contrarian doctors”—as some of us like to call those who have consistently minimized COVID-19 severity and opposed public health interventions such as “lockdowns” and mandates for masks and vaccines—have slipped into longstanding talking points and tropes of the antivaccine movement. These are often doctors who never, ever would have said anything even vaguely antivaccine before the pandemic but now routinely parrot “old school” antivaccine talking points, whether they realize them to be antivax or not. An example of just such a talking point is to portray people who actually take precautions against being infected by COVID-19 of being “irrational” or having “irrational” fear or anxiety. The fear and anxiety are acknowledged, but then immediately portrayed as less than rational or even as not rational at all.
Worse than that, these “COVID-19 contrarians” portray taking precautions to avoid COVID-19 as being more than just irrational, but outright pathological, with people who still wear N95 masks, for instance, being accused of “irrational anxiety” or “fear” just because they don’t want to be infected by a virus that has killed over a million people (and counting) in just the US alone and is still widely circulating in the population. This narrative is of a piece with longstanding antivaccine messaging that portrays vaccination programs driven primarily by irrational fear in order for the medical profession, big pharma, and government to exercise “control” over you. I’ve lost track of how many times I’ve read variations on this theme over the last two decades, which is why I took note of an article on a Substack called Sensible Medicine titled “Legitimizing irrational anxiety is bad medicine“. The author? Who else could it be but Dr. Vinay Prasad, the adult oncologist who fancies himself an expert in pediatrics, infectious disease, epidemiology, and virology? In his Substack, he argues that we should treat COVID-19 like the flu and do no more or less to protect ourselves against COVID-19 than we used to do for the flu—but with one telling omission.
Before I discuss his analogy (and telling omission), let’s look at his contempt for the “irrational”. If you don’t get the idea about how “irrational” the ever-eminent (in his own mind) Dr. Prasad thinks precautions against COVID-19 are now for most people, he nails it home with a subtitle:
Healthy middle age people carrying CO2 monitors need frank advice to stop.
Quite honestly, I had been unaware that CO2 monitors were a thing any more. Dr. Prasad mentions these monitors multiple times in his post, in particular citing photos of them on Twitter. So I did what my curiosity led me to do and searched Twitter for the term “CO2 monitor”. Most of what I found were Tweets advocating such monitors in rooms to indicate when ventilation is inadequate and therefore the risk of COVID-19 transmission in the room probably elevated. Yes, I found among the top Tweets people advocating such monitors, but they didn’t sound anywhere near as fearful and—dare I say?—irrational as Dr. Prasad leads his readers to believe.
For example:
I highly recommend getting a small CO2 monitor like the ones sold by @DonateMask. It has been very useful on my trip for gauging the risk of Covid-19 in different locations and it is much more affordable than an Aranet4 device. pic.twitter.com/bkbtODRWvY
— Karen K. Ho (@karenkho) September 4, 2022
This one amused me, mainly because it seems as though Dr. Prasad is making fun of Elon Musk:
The higher CO2 in the room, the more you’re breathing the air that someone else has already exhaled. Monitor CO2 level, it will help to minimize COVID-19 infection risk by warning you when the air quality deteriorates. #Aranet4 #COVIDisAirborne https://t.co/2eXkiUm3T8
— Aranet Home (@aranet_home) July 19, 2022
And there were stories like this:
Curbing COVID-19 in schools: Imperial scientists support CO2 monitor rollout | Imperial News https://t.co/wWshYC9saK
— Javier Balán, fsc (@javierbalan) September 4, 2022
My overall impression was that these people were not being irrational, just cautious, and that having better ventilation is a good thing, even leaving aside the question of how low your CO2 reading needs to be to decrease the risk of aerosol transmission of COVID-19 to very low levels. I can see one reason why Dr. Prasad might want to target such monitors as an example of “irrational” anxiety, though. Many of the Tweets advocating them tend to recommend them in schools in order to reduce transmission there, and Dr. Prasad and the Brownstone Institute for which he writes have been nothing if not unrelentingly hostile for a long time to masks (which are portrayed as horrifically harmful) and any other COVID-19 mitigations in schools, such as school closures and virtual learning.
Of course, the very title of Dr. Prasad’s little rant should tell you what I’m talking about when I point out that “COVID-19 contrarian” doctors often echo antivax talking points. There was a time when I used to give people like Dr. Prasad the benefit of the doubt and assume that they were clueless that the arguments they were making were not new and, prior to the pandemic, had been staples of antivaccine propaganda going back decades. Indeed, on several occasions, that benefit of the doubt led me to state emphatically and unequivocally that, no matter what I thought of him otherwise, I didn’t think that Dr. Prasad is was any way antivaccine. Nearly a year later, I can no longer say this about Dr. Prasad with nearly much confidence as I used to. As for the other “contrarians,” they have been told time and time again, with examples, that these talking points are old antivax tropes. They either refuse to believe or continue to use them anyway. Truly, the “new school” COVID-19 antivaxxers are coming more and more to resemble “old school” antivaxxers from days gone by.
The overall message of the post is simple: Anyone who is middle-aged or younger and relatively healthy shouldn’t worry about COVID-19 anymore, and if you continue to take precautions you’re a victim of “irrational anxiety” stoked by the public health infrastructure. In fact, Dr. Prasad suggests that you might even be mentally ill:
Medicine has always drawn a distinction between appropriate and inappropriate emotions. If someone experiences sadness, loss of appetite, and lack of desire to get out of bed, it is relevant if they just lost a spouse versus if this is simply Wednesday.
Similarly, if you take appropriate precautions when you climb Half Dome you are being reasonable, but if you refuse to climb 12 stairs out of fear of heights, you are not, and you might benefit from mental health care.
It’s time for medical professionals to advise young, middle age, healthy people to throw away your n95, leave your C02 monitor at home and get back to life. These are not proportionate responses. You are not acting reasonably. Someone needs to tell you.
See the narrative? If you are young to middle-aged and still insist on wearing an N95 in public, then Dr. Prasad thinks that you are, at best, being very irrational and, at worst, might even be suffering from mental illness. Why? Because to him there’s no sense in resisting any more. You can’t avoid it, and you’re supposedly so low risk that worrying about COVID-19 is irrational.
As I said, irrational:
Anyone who plans on being around for the next decade has only two things guaranteed: You will definitely get Covid19 and you will definitely pay taxes.
As of Sept 2022, everyone in America has had plenty of opportunity to be vaccinated if they wish. Among those who haven’t, rates of COVID-19 are sky high. Most have had and recovered from the virus, making their risk from reinfection low. Even those who’ve been vaccinated suffered breakthrough at astonishing rates. Finally, the virus itself has drifted towards less lethality.
Why bother trying to avoid getting a disease that, even if you accept Dr. Prasad’s estimation that it’s no longer any more deadly than the flu? I also can’t help but note the evolution in the antivax/COVID-19 minimization narrative from March 2020 with respect to influenza. Back then, the narrative was that COVID-19 was no worse than the flu. Funny how now, in 2022, Dr. Prasad’s narrative is that it’s “no worse than the flu” now that we have vaccines and boosters, even as he has resisted vaccine mandates for anyone who’s not elderly or so chronically ill that even he has to concede that they are high risk for severe COVID-19 and death.
In fact, let’s do a little compare and contrast. Here is Dr. Prasad now:
The IFR for Covid19 is now less than flu. Fear of long COVID is irrational. In so far as it exists, you have to accept it. In so far as it is overblown, you can ignore it. There is no good evidence boosters or Paxlovid or anything changes it. That evidence would require a clear consistent and reproducible definition. Good luck with that.
Over the next few years, COVID-19 will engulf everyone on Earth. Over the next few decades, it will engulf everyone many times over.
Given: you’re eventually going to get Covid19 and it’s less dangerous than flu, you should take all the same precautions you used to take for flu, but no more.
Here’s a little more of Dr. Prasad’s characterization of “irrational” fear—oh, and tribalism, because of course Dr. Prasad thinks it’s all “virtual signaling.” (Normally, I don’t make fun of typos, but I’ll make an exception for Dr. Prasad.) Anyhow:
At this moment in time, COVID19 is not a risk big enough to most people to justify behaving differently than you did pre-covid. When I see a healthy 20 year old wearing an n95 mask outside, I feel pity for them. They are the victim of irrational messaging, virtual signaling, tribalism, and possibly also fear and anxiety. We should encourage them to live normally, and relax.
Now let’s go back to 2020. I will quote a certain someone who said the following but whom I will not identify until after the quote. I emphasize that this quote does not come from Dr. Prasad. I am quoting this statement from June 2020 in order to illustrate how similar antivax messaging was then to Dr. Prasad’s messaging now. Also, I won’t reveal who said this until after you’ve had the chance to soak in the quote in all its condescendingly wrong glory:
What is the group that is really at risk? Let’s be honest about this and say something that might get me some trouble here, but let’s be honest. That group is very well known. It’s people over the age of 65—not just because you’re over the age of 65, but you’re sick with other diseases. You have heart disease. You have COPD. You have diabetes. You have issues, many of those issues coming from the fact that you didn’t treat your body very well while you were on this planet. And I want to talk about this for one minute as we close this down. That 0.26% are the most sick among us, and I have nothing against you. Go ahead and bubble wrap your house. Lock yourself in your basement. Go and do what’s necessary.
That’s not all, though:
So here’s what we do. Let’s go outside. Let’s take off our masks. We’re not on drugs, and we don’t need to be on drugs. Let’s catch this cold! Whether or not it’s just the 20% of us and maybe we’re not even in that category, let’s give it a college try to catch this cold, so that we can protect the pharmaceutical-dependent amongst us!
Of course, this quote comes from six months before the vaccines started rolling out. In any event, I have to ask: Don’t these two passages sound a lot alike? There’s the same “don’t worry, be happy” attitude, the same characterization of COVID-19 as not dangerous to people who aren’t old and sick already, the same minimization of COVID-19 (Dr. Prasad likening it to the flu and this latter person likening it to a bad cold), the same call to stop masking and not do anything that we didn’t do to protect ourselves from disease before the pandemic.
So who is the second person who two years ago was urging people to “catch this cold” while characterizing those who want people to take precautions as not just irrational but selfish as well? Regular readers know, as I’ve quoted him saying this a number of times since June 2020 as an example of an antivaxxer who denies the severity of COVID-19 and basically advocates that most people return to pre-COVID-19 behavior. That’s right. It’s longtime antivax influencer Del Bigtree, the man who had before the pandemic previously teamed up with Andrew Wakefield in order to produce an overwrought antivax movie VAXXED. Here’s a hint: If you find yourself sounding like Del Bigtree when it comes to COVID-19 mitigation measures, you really should take a long hard look at how you got to this point. Major soul searching is in order for you.
In fact, I can’t resist quoting another antivax influencer, Dr. Bob Sears, who posted this to his Facebook group about measles vaccines, back in the day when we were worried about measles outbreaks due to low vaccine uptake. The parents of some of his patients were concerned and contacting him. He basically washed his hands and told them to “chill out”:
Notice the same dismissive tone exhibited by Del Bigtree and Dr. Prasad, particularly the last part:
I love you all, and love caring for you all. But just chill out. Measles will never go away – it’s always going to be a very small risk. If you aren’t comfortable with that, get the vaccine. If you don’t want the vaccine, accept the risk.
Of course, I strongly suspect that Dr. Prasad knows exactly what he’s doing. He seeks out a small minority of people whose precautions against COVID-19 he considers ridiculously excessive and then does his best to portray them to be as “irrational” as possible, even though he has to massively exaggerate to do it:
Looking down at your Co2 monitor and snapping photos for twitter is no way to live. You need some frank advice: it’s time to stop, for your own sake and those around you.
Also, you’re worthless and weak.
Don’t worry, though. It’s not your fault (at least not entirely). Dr. Prasad assures you that you shouldn’t feel bad about your utter worthlessness and weakness in the face of the flu COVID-19, because your worthlessness and weakness in the face of COVID-19 aren’t your fault (at least, not entirely your fault). They’re largely the CDC’s fault—and that of the Democrats as well:
The CDC has done you a disservice. It has enabled people to act irrationally by pushing Paxlovid in people in whom it was not studied. It encouraged people to mask without ever generating data if the community recommendation worked, and worse: long after it made sense. It recently encouraged healthy 20 year olds to wear an n95— that is frankly bad advice. Any covid benefit dwarfed by the downsides of making a 20 year old think they are vulnerable and weak. The CDC may be doing this for political rather than medical reasons. It caters to the most irrational pole of one political party. Alternatively, the agency is filled with work from home people— who themselves could benefit from frank advice.
Got that, all you millennials? The CDC and the Democrats have turned you all into a bunch of wimps and crybabies! Come to think of it, now Dr. Prasad is sounding a lot like Tucker Carlson and all the far right wing pundits who are trying to portray caution in the face of a global pandemic as hopeless cowardice, all because they worship “strength” and masculinity and view collective action and action that doesn’t as undermining manliness…or something. Indeed, Dr. Prasad’s messaging is custom-designed to appeal to a certain…other…political leaning.
In fact, it’s worse than that. If you are still masking your children, particularly children in daycare, Dr. Prasad thinks you’re not just irrational, he thinks…well…let me just quote him, so that you don’t think I’m exaggerating:
You would never shield your face from an infant in daycare, for hour after hour, day after day. Doing that now is deranged. The potential downside far exceeds any potential upside.
That’s right! Those of you who want to protect daycare workers and small children with mask mandates aren’t just worthless and weak. You’re downright deranged! (What was that Dr. Prasad keeps lamenting about as far as rhetoric around COVID-19? “Loss of civility” and “obsessive criticism” of people like him? Yes, I’m calling him out for hypocrisy, but his hypocrisy is nothing new.)
And all you workers who have the temerity to hope for safe workplaces during a pandemic, Dr. Prasad has news for you, along with a heaping helping of contempt, slippery slope fallacy, and a dash of reductio ad absurdum aimed at academics:
You didn’t complain that your employer was trying to encourage people to show up to work, so they can justify paying them. Don’t do that now. It seem unreal that professors, who have been handsomely paid and never asked to take risk pre-vax, are refusing to work post-vax—- refusing to work in 2022. Will they refuse to work in 2030? The virus isn’t going anywhere.
It is, of course, no coincidence that Dr. Prasad is laying down the opprobrium particularly harshly on academics, given that academics have tended to be the ones most concerned about the pandemic and the least receptive to his style of “don’t worry, be happy” blandishments disguised as “sensible medicine”. His argument also serves the large corporations that are trying to force their workers to stop working virtually and come back to the office, whether it’s safe or not, which totally tracks with his association with the “free market” libertarian think tank the Brownstone Institute and a certain other ideology. I also can’t help but note that condescendingly and contemptuously lecturing and mocking people is a great way to persuade them…not. Dr. Prasad is barely middle-aged, but he sounds like a 70-year-old lecturing young people, whom he views as not as tough, smart, moral, or good as his generation was.
That’s probably why Dr. Prasad doesn’t limit his attacks to just academics, but also challenges his critics with another slippery slope attack, just stretching it all the way out to 2025 or even 2030:
Some may disagree with my prescription: If you do, you should articulate the reason. Do you really think you can avoid COVID-19 indefinitely? Are you going to carrying a CO2 monitor in 2025? How long will you continue this? Do you think it’s possible you’re acting irrationally?
The slippery slope fallacy is, of course, a logical fallacy and generally a bad argument in all but a rare handful of cases in which the path down the “slope” is actually clearly laid out and strongly supported. In this case, it’s just a convenient strategy to portray his critics and those whom he sees as “irrational” as cowards duped by the CDC. Reductio ad absurdum can be an effective rhetorical strategy, but it’s not an actual argument based on science and facts.
But what about long COVID, that constellation of baffling and often debilitating symptoms suffered by a disturbing percentage of people who have recovered from COVID-19? Glad you asked! Dr. Prasad thinks you’re irrational to fear that too:
Fear of long COVID is irrational. In so far as it exists, you have to accept it. In so far as it is overblown, you can ignore it. There is no good evidence boosters or Paxlovid or anything changes it. That evidence would require a clear consistent and reproducible definition. Good luck with that.
What a jerk! (I used a somewhat…stronger…word in the original version of this post and only toned it down to keep Dr. Novella happy.)
You know, a physician who dismisses patients’ symptoms with a jaunty “Good luck with that!” is not a physician I want to see caring for patients. Even those of us who consider chronic Lyme disease to be a fake diagnosis don’t dismiss patients that way. (Quite the opposite, in fact, no matter how much chronic Lyme quacks try to portray us otherwise.)
It’s not just young, presumably healthy, people, though. In his latest paid Substack, he goes on to blame physicians and scientists for letting their supposed anxiety disorders interfere with everyone else living their lives. I’ll quote what is readable without a subscription:
A key concept in psychiatry is that an idea or compulsion or personality trait can be acceptable if it doesn’t bother you, but becomes harmful and pathological when it interferes with your daily life. It’s ok to be obsessive, but it is obsessive compulsive disorder if it interferes with your day to day.
What word do we use to describe doctors, scientists and policy makers whose personal mental health issues affect their policy recommendations? The lives of others? If someone’s anxiety makes them more likely to support school closure, masking 2 year olds or lockdown, how should we consider them?
It is pathologic for anxiety to harm your own life, but I believe we enter the realm of catastrophe when personal mental health issues affect sweeping policy matters. Let’s consider some examples of vocal policy analysts (doctors, scientists, professors) who’s comments might be concerning.
That first paragraph sounds nearly identical to what Dr. Prasad said in his earlier Substack, doesn’t it? Notice how he now goes beyond just blaming anxiety and fear for COVID-19 precautions to claiming that physicians and scientists are all irrational blobs of fear and anxiety who can’t help but impose their fear and anxiety on society at large. In fact, he refers to their anxiety as pathological and says that they have “personal mental health issues”!
Back in May, I wrote about a similar sort of argument, in which Dr. Lucy McBride described what she referred to as “coronaphobia.” Here’s a link from Twitter:
And this is what Dr. McBride had said about her own article:
I’m finding that the “cure” for some of my patients’ outsize fear of COVID is … COVID.
“Coronaphobia” can be defined as an exaggerated fear of COVID that’s rooted in the rational anxiety of the very real threat of COVID.
(I wrote this a year ago.) 🧵https://t.co/c8Nhh1Brlr
— Lucy McBride, MD (@drlucymcbride) May 14, 2022
Basically, the message is the same: Stop being irrationally afraid and just catch COVID-19, already! As I said then writing about Dr. McBride and say now writing Dr. Prasad, it is not my intention to deny that there are people out there suffering from anxiety and depression due to the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic, some of whom might even require treatment. There are. What I am going to point out is how the messaging that Dr. McBride doubled down on a year after she had first promoted it was very similar to messaging that I’ve been encountering for many years coming from the antivaccine movement. Although Dr. McBride probably doesn’t realize it, she is echoing an old antivax trope that does exactly the same thing: Seeks to shame those who fear vaccine-preventable diseases. I listed examples going back years in my post about her article; so I won’t repeat them here.
I will, however, note that Dr. Prasad goes beyond Dr. McBride’s shaming of people with anxiety over the pandemic. Dr. McBride at least tried to sound empathetic discussing what she clearly viewed as “irrational” fears of her patients. (What is a phobia, after all, but overblown and irrational fear or anxiety?) Dr. Prasad is dismissive of those fears as “irrational,” stoked by the CDC, and arrogantly lectures those who still have concerns as being not just completely unrealistic but cowardly and paranoid—deranged, even! (“Given: you’re eventually going to get Covid19 and it’s less dangerous than flu.” So stop being such a cowardly wimp and “catch that cold”—I mean flu.)
On the other hand, I do want to be as charitable as possible, even after venting a bit about Dr. Prasad’s general jerkishness. That’s why I can’t help but wonder about one part of Dr. Prasad’s post: “…you should take all the same precautions you used to take for flu, but no more.”
Here’s what I mean: What were “all the same precautions” that we used to take for flu? According to Dr. Prasad they included this:
You definitely washed your hands in the winter back in 2019, and you should do that now. At the same time you don’t have to be excessive about it. You can do it like you did before, reasonably.
I sense that Dr. Prasad missed…something…in his description of the precautions we used to take against the flu before the pandemic. What specific precaution am I missing? Hmmm..
Oh, wait, I know!
Dr. Prasad forgot to mention yearly flu vaccines. I’m sure it must have been an oversight on his part. After all, before the pandemic, the CDC did recommend that everyone over the age of 6 months be vaccinated against the flu every year before the start of the flu season—and still recommends it! That was a key part of taking “all the same precautions you used to take for flu, but no more,” wasn’t it? Even Dr. Sears mentioned the measles vaccine! He just dismissed parents who were worried about measles by saying, in essence, that they should get their kids vaccinated if they’re worried. Odd, isn’t it, that Dr. Prasad didn’t at least say something like that along the lines of, “If you’re so worried about COVID-19, get vaccinated and boosted.” He didn’t. In that, he is actually worse than many pre-pandemic antivaxxers.
Indeed, by Dr. Prasad’s logic, then—ignoring all his dismissive rejection of masks and other nonpharmacologic interventions against COVID-19—we should at the very least also model our precautions against COVID-19 (which, like the flu, is here to stay according to the good doctor and we’ll just have to learn to live with it) on those that we routinely took against the flu before the pandemic, which was to get vaccinated every year, starting as an infant.
I have to assume—in the interests of the most charitable interpretation of Dr. Prasad’s post—then, that Dr. Prasad is recommending that everyone, starting at the age of six months, follow CDC recommendations for vaccination against COVID-19 as well—just as many of us did for vaccination against the flu—given that the CDC recommends vaccination against COVID-19 for everyone over the age of 6 months, a recommendation that is very much like its recommendation for the flu, minus the yearly vaccine. (At least the CDC isn’t recommending yearly COVID-19 boosters yet although such a recommendation in the future does appear likely.)
Again, I’m sure that it was just an inadvertent oversight that Dr. Prasad didn’t mention the vaccine, right? Surely he couldn’t mean that we should behave differently and not get vaccinated against COVID-19, could he? It was he who made the comparison and said that we should treat COVID-19 the same way that we treat the flu and take the same precautions for COVID-19 as the flu, not I. It must have been an error that he didn’t use this comparison to urge everyone to get vaccinated and boosted. It must have!
Anxiety over the pandemic is a real problem. I am by no means minimizing it, as there is a real pandemic anxiety syndrome that is accepted. Rather, I’m pointing out how Dr,. Prasad is actually minimizing it by intentionally conflating real anxiety disorders provoked by a once-in-a-century ongoing crisis with much more reasonable concerns. He’s also using a false comparison with the flu that completely leaves out one key element that many of us did every year to protect ourselves against it. Again, I’m done being charitable with Dr. Prasad. He knows exactly what he is doing, and what he is doing is no different than what the Brownstone Institute (with which he is affiliated) and Tucker Carlson are doing: Downplaying COVID-19 and exaggerating the risks of the vaccine, all while portraying a desire not to get the disease as irrational fear—or even actual pathology, such as a severe anxiety disorder.

Anti-Vaccine Doctors: “Kids Don’t Need the Vaccine Because They Are Less Likely to Acquire SARS-CoV-2 and Because Most Already Had COVID-19”
Those of us who thought about vaccines before the pandemic know perfectly well that anti-vaxxers start with their conclusions and work backwards to retrofit the “evidence.” Doctors who do the same shouldn’t be regarded any differently.
Jonathan Howard on June 30, 2023
Link

2021: “Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2”
The first data about the adolescent vaccine emerged on March 31, 2021, when Pfizer announced their vaccine was 100% effective in stopping COVID infections in a randomized-controlled trial. (The study was later published in the NEJM). By this time however, the campaign against the vaccine was already well underway, and few doctors worked harder to ensure unvaccinated children contracted COVID than adult oncologist Dr. Vinay Prasad.
In a Twitter thread from January 2021, he speculated that children wouldn’t need to be vaccinated as the pandemic seemed to be “abating”. He wrote:
Let me be perfectly clear: children DO NOT NEED a sars-cov-2 vaccine before they are permitted to return to normal activities, such as school and visiting loved ones…If the epidemic is abating, how can you justify giving 100 kids those AEs (adverse events), so that perhaps 1 or 2 or even 3 will be spared a case of covid that might be as mild as the AEs themselves?…Once adults, particularly older adults are vaccinated, and if *god willing* there is not vaccine escape, covid19 is over. We are going back to normal.
On February 3, 2021, he formalized his thoughts in an essay titled Kids Don’t Need Covid-19 Vaccines to Return to School, in which he gave “five reasons why schools can and should open at 100% capacity before a vaccine for those under age 16 is available.” In addition to fear mongering about mundane side-effects such as fevers and using obviously bogus statistics– “the vaccine might save one life for every 1 million kids who get it” – Dr. Prasad’s top reason for exposing unvaccinated children to the virus at that time was:
Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, than adults. Several meta-analyses confirm that in contract tracing studies, kids are approximately half as likely to acquire the virus as other household contacts with the same exposure.
In June 2021, he continued to tell parents that children didn’t need to be vaccinated because they could avoid the virus. He wrote:
Remember cases are FALLING PRECIPITOUSLY…The fraction of all cases that are adolescents is not the point. The raw number of adolescent cases is the point THAT IS FALLING…The actual numbers show both COVID and MIS-C is plummeting with adult vaccination.
The Delta variant arrived shortly after this, and headlines would soon read, “COVID Hospitalization Rate in Kids Rose 5x as Delta Variant Spread, CDC Says.” Unvaccinated teenagers died preventable deaths, and a CDC report found, “hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents.” The Omicron variant arrived shortly after this, and headlines would soon read “COVID Hospitalization for Young Children 5 Times Higher During Omicron Than Delta”. During New York City’s Omicron wave, 54% of hospitalized children had no underlying conditions, and again, unvaccinated children suffered the most. (I shared many more studies here).
2022: “Most kids already had COVID-19”
Dr. Prasad reacted to this sad news by continuing to advocate for the mass infection of unvaccinated children, though he discovered a completely new reason as to why. In July 2022, he participated in A Pro-Con Debate: Should Doctors Encourage Healthy Kids 11 and Under be Vaccinated Against COVID-19? which argued that “​​all kids, like all adults, will eventually get COVID-19.” Dr. Prasad’s top reason for exposing unvaccinated children to the virus then became:
Most kids already had COVID-19. CDC estimates 75% as of February, but this number is an underestimate, as millions have been infected since.
Dr. Prasad was against vaccinating children when he thought they were less likely to contract SARS-CoV-2, and he was against vaccinating children after they already had it, though he neglected to mention that 12 million babies, who have the highest risk of COVID by far, arrived during the pandemic without “natural” immunity.
And thus it becomes clear. Some doctors were always against vaccinating children, and no data was going to sway them. Whether cases were going up or down, the facts on the ground were used to support their unshakable, predetermined conclusion that unvaccinated children should contract COVID. Though they claim to “follow the evidence,” their minds were made up months before any evidence even existed.
Those of us who thought about these issues before the pandemic know perfectly well that anti-vaxxers start with their conclusions and work backwards to retrofit the “evidence.” Doctors who do the same shouldn’t be regarded any differently.

Are Vaccine-Advocates “Idiots”, Indifferent to the Death of a Mentally Ill Woman and Her Family?
Rather than face the real-world consequences of their anti-vaccine advocacy, it’s easier for contrarian doctors to fantasize that COVID’s youngest victims were mere figments of our imagination.
Jonathan Howard on February 14, 2023
Link

Something horrible recently happened in Michigan. According to a news report:
The bodies of Monica Cannady, 35, Kyle Milton, 9, and Malik Milton, 3, were found Jan. 15 in Pontiac after Cannady’s 10-year-old daughter went to a home near the field and told someone that her “family was dead in a field,” Oakland County Sheriff Michael Bouchard said earlier this month…
Cannady had been experiencing mental health issues and family members were trying to get her psychiatric care.
She “believed someone was trying to kill her and that everybody was in on it” before she and her children died, Sheriff Michael Bouchard told reporters Jan. 16.
Investigators said the family could have been outside in the cold for at least three days, despite having a home about a mile from where they were found.
The police were unable to locate this family in time, and a deputy resigned due to this failure.
This event was obviously a tragedy. However, I don’t think my advocacy on behalf of pediatric COVID vaccination is connected to their sad fate in any way. Dr. Vinay Prasad felt differently. He recently accused vaccine-advocates of forgetting her death and other “real lives that can be saved.”
Let’s dissect this Tweet. I fully agree the death of this family meant something broke down. This poor woman and her two children slipped through the cracks with devastating consequences. Though people are trying to address these problems, which cannot be solved with a simple vaccine, society failed this family.
However, the connection between this tragedy and “idiots on Twitter” isn’t clear. Is Dr. Prasad actually suggesting that if only doctors had not advocated for pediatric vaccination on Twitter, this family might still be alive? Such tragedies happened before the pandemic, and I’ve been treating patients like Ms. Cannady for 20 years. Not once has anyone said, “This patient would have been just fine, were it not for the Twitter posts of vaccine-advocates“.
Large numbers of Dr. Prasad’s Twitter audience won’t know this however. They mindlessly clicked in agreement as Dr. Prasad absurdly linked Ms. Cannady’s death to the social media habits of vaccine-advocates. When they encounter a vaccine-advocate in the future, they’ll then see a cruel soul, someone who is indifferent to the deaths of a mentally ill woman and her children. That’s what Dr. Prasad is hoping for, and it’s no surprise vaccine-advocates often deal with abuse online. Esteemed doctors at esteemed universities told them we were “idiots” after all.
These juvenile epithets are quite the reversal for Dr. Prasad. At the start of the pandemic he wrote an impassioned essay titled “Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should be Heard, Not Demonized” that extolled the value of civil debate. Dr. Prasad wrote:
We think it is important to hear, consider, and debate these views without ad hominem attacks or animus…Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics….
Calling someone an idiot is “chilling and silencing and dangerous.”
Today, Dr. Prasad gleefully demonizes anyone who lacks his enthusiasm for the repeated mass infection of unvaccinated children with a brand new virus than has already killed 2,000 of them and hospitalized over a hundred thousand. Not only are they “idiots”, he’s also said they are “STUPID“, a “bunch of fools” and “total morons“. Other times, he’s used psychiatric labels to denigrate and pathologize those with different views. He’s said such people are “delusional” and that “any strong advocate for kid covid vaccination is off their rocker.”
Some doctors felt so passionately that unvaccinated children should be repeatedly be exposed to SARS-CoV-2, that they greeted differing views with ad hominem attacks and animus.
Dr. Prasad’s embrace of immature insults, which he once deemed “even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19”, was not his most egregious medical reversal, however. Though today he argues against pediatric vaccination because most children already had COVID, in 2021 he felt unvaccinated children should remain vulnerable to COVID for the exact opposite reason. In an essay from February 2021, called “Kids Don’t Need Covid-19 Vaccines to Return to School”, Dr. Prasad wrote:
Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, than adults”.
Dr. Prasad continued to use this logic to argue against pediatric vaccination at that time. In June 2021, after the vaccine had been authorized for adolescents and just before the Delta variant arrived, Dr. Prasad said that cases were “FALLING PRECIPITOUSLY” as a reason not to vaccinate children. He continued:
The raw number of adolescent cases is the point THAT IS FALLING…The actual numbers show both COVID and MIS-C is plummeting with adult vaccination….Perhaps, <18 can should pause all mRNA vaccination, and we reassess if rise in cases in fall.
One thing that seemed to have no effect on Dr. Prasad’s opinion was a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study of the COVID vaccine in adolescents that was published in the NEJM. All 16 COVID cases occurred in placebo recipients. Many doctors embraced the overwhelming results from this RCT. Others ignored the results entirely.
And thus it becomes clear: Dr. Prasad was always going to be against vaccinating children no matter the course of the pandemic or the results of any feasible RCT. He was against the vaccine when he thought the pandemic was “abating“, and he was against the vaccine after COVID “already reached 96%” in children. Exactly one year after writing “Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2”, Dr. Prasad reversed himself by writing a pro-virus article titled “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?”. Many things changed during that time, but Dr. Prasad’s desire to have unvaccinated children contract SARS-CoV-2 remained constant and unshakable.
So much for following the evidence.
Indeed, nowhere in between writing “cases are FALLING PRECIPITOUSLY” and “most kids already had COVID-19” did Dr. Prasad pause and wonder if he was wrong to oppose pediatric vaccination. As the Delta and Omicron waves ripped through the pediatric population, especially in unvaccinated children, Dr. Prasad only continued to spread misinformation, saying it was “natural and healthy” when children got sick with COVID, for example. Instead of dropping everything to support parents with mental illness, as he demanded of vaccine-advocates, Dr. Prasad devoted countless hours making monetized content about a rare vaccine side-effect, which has a better prognosis than, say, death from COVID. How did these videos help Ms. Cannady and her family?
Videos that did nothing to help parents with mental illness
Dr. Prasad is not wrong that nearly all American children have contracted COVID by now. However, this does not mean that vaccine-advocates wasted their time. Many millions of children were able to be vaccinated before they were infected, and this made a huge difference to some of them. Over 20 studies from around the world have shown the vaccine has shown to be effective in preventing rare, but grave harms in children. Though efforts to slow the spread of the virus saved some children a great deal of suffering, we’ll never know who they were. The benefits of the vaccine are invisible in a crucial way, but this does not mean the children it saved are not “real lives”.
Additionally, nearly 3.7 million babies are born annually in the US. Though infants have the highest risk of dying of all children, they don’t arrive with “natural immunity”. Tragically, nearly 700 children under age 4 years have died of COVID already, and most doctors don’t want this number to grow larger. Moreover, we don’t know the consequences of repeat COVID infections in developing children. We can all hope for the best, but anyone who takes a conservative approach to medicine knows that hope is not a plan. There are already some concerning signs that COVID may not be as “healthy” for children as Dr. Prasad claimed.
I may be missing something. So hopefully, Dr. Prasad will write a rebuttal to my essay explaining why the Cannady family tragedy means we should accept unvaccinated babies dying of COVID, year after year, forevermore. However, I think our disagreements are even more fundamental than this. I may be an idiot, but I disagree with Prasad’s notion that the thousands of young, unvaccinated people who needlessly suffered or died of COVID were not “real lives” or that we should accept their deaths as “a matter of course.” Rather than face the real-world consequences of their anti-vaccine advocacy, it’s easier for certain doctors to fantasize that COVID’s youngest victims were mere figments of our imagination.
But, of course, they weren’t.
Dr. Prasad was right that some doctors forgot the very “real lives that can be saved” this pandemic. It wasn’t vaccine-advocates who forgot though.
A real life that could have been saved with a simple vaccine

Dr. Vinay Prasad fully embraces the antivax message of “do not comply”
COVID-19 “contrarians” like Dr. Vinay Prasad have long complained about being labelled “antivaccine,” which they view as unfair. Why, then, do they embrace antivax messages like “do not comply,” even if they don’t use the exact words?
David Gorski on September 11, 2023
Link
The last three and a half years, during which the COVID-19 pandemic arrived, have been highly educational to me. As much as I thought I knew in early 2020, as news stories about an outbreak of a mysterious infectious pneumonia in China that was found to be due to a novel coronavirus, I learned a lot watching in real time what happened. Although by 2020 I had given up my rather naïve belief from many years ago that mass death from a pandemic of a deadly virus for which a vaccine was developed would weaken the antivaccine movement, even I never anticipated how massively the pandemic and public health responses to it did exactly the opposite: Strengthen the antivaccine movement beyond anything it had ever achieved before and normalize antivaccine beliefs in our political discourse. By 2020, I had also come to understand how a combination of antivaccine messaging equating “resistance” to vaccine mandates (e.g., “do not comply,” which I will get to in a moment) had shifted the political center of gravity of the antivaccine movement sharply right over the preceding decade, but the pandemic taught me that the situation could get so much worse, with an increasing affinity between antivax beliefs and outright fascism. Perhaps most disturbing, I discovered that the pathway from having contrarian beliefs about public health to becoming a full-on pandemic conspiracy theorist antivaxxer was much shorter and easier than I had ever suspected, as I observed in my year-end post for 2020, later speculating why so many physicians are attracted to “contrarian” beliefs and then so easily slide from these beliefs deeper and deeper into conspiracy theory and science denial prodded by audience capture.
Enter Dr. Vinay Prasad. Again.
Almost as if on cue, as I was thinking about these things again last week, I saw a post by Dr. Vinay Prasad, this blog’s favorite formerly-respected rising star in academic medical oncology turned antivax-adjacent, if not fully antivax, COVID-19 “contrarian”, titled “Do not report COVID cases to schools & do not test yourself if you feel ill“, with a tagline, “Only non-violent resistance can halt irrational public health actors.” It reminded me so much of the “do not comply” messaging that had become such a centerpiece of antivaccine rhetoric before the pandemic and then even more so once COVID-19 vaccines arrived in late 2020 that I had to take a look. True, Dr. Prasad never actually uses the exact phrase “do not comply,” but he uses one so close to it that it might as well be “do not comply.” Indeed, his entire post is a call to resist all public health mandates with respect to COVID-19. Also remember this. Dr. Prasad has an MPH, a Master of Public Health degree. He has studied public health, which makes this post all the more disturbing, coming as it does from someone who should very much know better but no longer does.
Dr. Prasad begins by asking a rhetorical question:
I saw this post today. A school in MoCo, MD (DC beltway) has reimplemented n95 masking for kids. As a side note: there is no n95 mask for kids— as these masks have not been validated in children. In response, one commenter suggests the only solution is to no long report COVID cases to school. Is this a sensible strategy?
Oooh, scary! “They’re coming with masks for your kids” again! I would also point out that most of these antivax parents don’t keep their kids home when they have a cold, because, after all, it’s “just a cold” and “kids get colds.” Just for yucks, I perused the X feeds of @daniela127 and Clay Travis. She turns out to be the founder of a group called Keep NYC Schools Open and her feed is full of antimask and anti-“lockdown” rhetoric that makes me think she’s partying like it’s 2020 again. (Hint: There hasn’t been anything resembling a true “lockdown” in the US and by mid-2021 most states had given up on the COVID-19 mitigation measures that had been implemented.
Predictably, given that Dr. Prasad’s question is a rhetorical question and not a “Betteridge’s Law of Headlines“-sort of question, his answer is yes, no matter how much he has to twist evidence and deny reality:
It turns out the answer is yes. Consider the facts. There is no evidence to suggest community mask mandates slow the spread of COVID in adults. There is no evidence to show they slow the spread of COVID in kids, and the best regression discontinuity studies (Spain) show no effect. Finally, there is no *logic* to slow spread in 2023, given that COVID has already engulfed 90%++ of kids (per CDC’s own Ab screens), and will keep spreading throughout humanity for 10,000 years or until we destroy ourselves. We should no longer aspire to slow spread. No one has shown that improves any outcome.
What about long COVID in kids? There is nearly no evidence to show that this entity warrants concern, and no evidence that any of these measures improve kids quality of life.
“Nearly” is doing a lot of heavy lifting here with respect to “no evidence.” While it is true that existing evidence is not as clear as we like, it is not true that there is “nearly” no evidence. For example, this meta-analysis (the very highest form of evidence, according to evidence-based medicine fundamentalists like Dr. Prasad) from May 2023 concludes:
Nearly one quarter of pediatric survivors suffered multisystem long COVID, even at 1 year after infection. Ongoing monitoring, comprehensive prevention and intervention is warranted for pediatric survivors, especially for individuals with high risk factors.
This meta-analysis was based on 40 studies covering 12,424 individuals and noted that the prevalence of any persistent symptoms at one year was 26%, and that persistent symptoms at one year included “generalized symptoms,” as well as respiratory, neurologic, and psychiatric symptoms, with dyspnea (shortness of breath), and headache being the most widely reported specific symptoms. Now maybe the ever eminent, EBM fundamentalist Dr. Prasad doesn’t think that it’s a big deal that one-quarter of children who catch and recover from COVID-19 report persistent and sometimes debilitating symptoms, dismissing the evidence from studies finding these results as “nearly no evidence” but most pediatricians who actually have to deal with suffering children are not so dismissive. Also, note that I picked only one study, a meta-analysis, because it’s recent and synthesizes existing evidence. There are a number of others out there that Dr. Prasad dismisses as “nearly no evidence” that long COVID in children “warrants concern.” Basically, for Dr. Prasad’s message to resonate, it has to be coupled with a message that COVID-19 is no big deal to kids, that it’s basically harmless, and that kids should just naturally catch it. Does that message sound familiar too? It should. It’s the same false message that antivaxxers have been repeating about measles and other childhood vaccine-preventable diseases since time immemorial.
Again, remember that Dr. Prasad has an MPH. He should know better. Instead, he uses his degrees to persuade his audience that COVID-19 is no big deal. I also note that, even if 90% of children have had COVID-19, thanks to the evolution of the virus to evade postinfection immunity acquired from prior variants, disease due to the new variants can spread. One can argue about what is reasonable, science-based, and effective in terms of infection mitigation, but Dr. Prasad’s nihilistic “let everyone catch COVID-19 again and again and again” approach is none of these. Consistent with this is his dismissing any evidence that is not from a randomized controlled clinical trial in order to claim that there is “no evidence” that masks prevent community spread of COVID-19. There actually is evidence. We can argue about how strong the evidence for and against masking to prevent the spread of COVID-19 is, how to interpret evidence from conflicting studies, and when or if it’s enough to justify mask mandates, but it is simply dismissively incorrect to claim that there is “no evidence.” That is Dr. Prasad’s methodolatry talking, in which any evidence that does not come from a perfectly conducted randomized controlled clinical trial doesn’t count and is therefore dismissed as “no evidence.” One is tempted to say that Dr. Prasad is every bit as “deranged” in his methodolatry as he accuses the parents of Montgomery County, MD of being in terms of their supposedly unthinking allegiance to Anthony Fauci and masks.
Then, Dr. Prasad, being Dr. Prasad, does exactly what he complains about on social media. He goes negative and portrays parents who are still concerned about COVID-19 as deranged and in the thrall of religion-like views. In other words, he portrays them as fanatics in order to dismiss them:
Given these facts, the policy of the Rosemary Hill Elementary school is not just unjustified— it is harmful. Requiring children to wear a useless mask to prevent the unpreventable— is deranged thinking. Given the voting patterns of MoCo, it likely reflects the persistent derangement among liberal democrats that the mask was given to us by Moses when he descended the mountain.
Dr. Prasad has been promoting this message for quite a while now. Indeed, doing a quick search of this blog, I found that he was promoting exactly this message a year ago, when he portrayed ongoing concern about the harms of COVID-19 and a desire among many to avoid catching the disease if they possibly can as irrational anxiety and fear. At the time, I pointed out how this sort of portrayal of public health advocates as fearful and of catching an infectious disease as unavoidable—even inevitable (or, as Dr. Prasad puts it this time, “unpreventable”)—is exactly the same sort of narrative that antivaxxers have used for decades about measles and other vaccine-preventable diseases.
One wonders what Dr. Prasad thinks of antivaxxers who said exactly the same thing about measles back in the day, that it’s a “harmless childhood disease that is dangerous to only a very few, that it’s impossible to avoid getting it, that “natural immunity” is better. Dr. Prasad obstinately keeps claiming that he’s “not antivax,” but then goes and keeps repeating antivax messaging that was old when the pandemic hit in 2020. Either he’s ignorant about this messaging (possible, but no longer likely given how often people have tried to explain it to him), in denial that that is what he’s doing (possible), or doesn’t care (the most likely possibility).
Which brings us to Dr. Prasad’s embracing yet another in a long line of antivax messaging that he’s embraced.
Dr. Prasad embraces his inner antivaxxer by telling parents, “Do not comply.”
Predictably, after that lead, Dr. Prasad goes full anti-public health and antivax (because the two go together) by telling parents, “do not comply.” And, yikes! The things he tells them not to comply with:
The commenter suggests that the only option left for remaining sensible people is to not longer comply in the system that yields this outcome. Here are some practical suggestions:
     1.  If you child is sick— do not test that child for COVID.
     2.  When they look good enough for school, send them in.
     3.  If you are sick— do not test yourself for COVID. (after all, Paxlovid data almost surely doesn’t apply to you — new post coming).
     4.  If anyone is sick, do not tell your employer or school.
     5.  Stop reporting these illnesses, and encourage your colleagues to cease reporting.
     6.  Decline any further COVID19 vaccination, unless RCTs show benefit in your age group
     7.  Complain to your employer about any mandates or declination forms.
In my estimation— it is the only logical course left. The strategy makes sense. It’s time to go dark with all COVID data. If enough people don’t participate, the irrationality will stop. Eventually.
Again, remember that Dr. Prasad has an MPH. He has an advanced degree in public health! Yet, he’s telling his readers to stop complying with any request or mandate made by public health authorities, not only that, to go completely “dark” with respect to providing data to public health authorities that will help them deal with infectious diseases—or even track the prevalence of infectious diseases.
Moreover, I rather suspect that Dr. Prasad likes the reactions that his post engendered on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, such as:
Encouraging people not to test for COVID or notify others if they are positive is abhorrent.
— Jennifer Gunter (@DrJenGunter) September 8, 2023
And:
Seriously, this response seems rather appropriate:
Reminds me of when Donald Trump said if you want to lower COVID numbers, just stop testing.
— dragonmom (@TanaSW73) September 9, 2023
So is this approving comment after Dr. Prasad’s post:
Vinay’s so red-pilled now it’s awesome. I mean the original meaning, ie not trusting authority.
That about describes Dr. Prasad these days, a term that is frequently used by the far right and conspiracy theorists to describe those who were once believers in the “conventional” narrative but have since “taken the red pill” à la The Matrix and now supposedly know reality as it truly is. Of course, the obvious subtext to such an attitude is obvious. If you don’t bother testing, reporting, or collecting data on incidence (and, of course, the prevalence of long COVID), then COVID-19 is no longer a problem, other than the pesky deaths that it still causes among the vulnerable, which, I’m sure, Dr. Prasad will find a way to deny soon enough. It’s all basically a convenient strategy to turn denial of epidemiology and public health science into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
As for Clay Travis, although the vast majority of his feed is about sports, he also finds time to demonstrate how fully antimask he is:
This is why all the people who keep saying, “Why do you care?” about people in masks are so wrong. These mask zealots want to force you and your kids to wear them again. This is their goal. They must be ridiculed and defeated. We have to win this battle once and for all.
— Clay Travis (@ClayTravis) September 5, 2023
He’s also unhappy about high school football games being canceled due to spiking COVID-19 cases:
California high schools are canceling football games this weekend because of positive covid tests. Really. https://t.co/7omyuYREZB
— Clay Travis (@ClayTravis) September 8, 2023
He’s also approvingly amplifying Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivax lies:
One of the biggest legacies of all the government’s lies on the covid shot — & the masking, social distancing, lockdowns, school closures — is going to be a tremendous amount of distrust of government mandates going forward. Once I know you’ve lied to me, why should I trust you?
— Clay Travis (@ClayTravis) June 29, 2023
No wonder Dr. Prasad finds these people’s views attractive, given that he, too, has started echoing some of RFK Jr.’s antivax tropes, such as the “no saline placebo” trope and the demand for new randomized controlled clinical trials of all new vaccines versus saline placebos, even if doing such a trial would be unethical because it would require leaving the control group unprotected and treated according to less than the standard of care with respect to prevention of common infectious diseases. That is, of course, yet another longstanding antivax trope that Dr. Prasad has embraced, even as he labors under the delusion that he has not become at least antivax-adjacent, if not fully antivax.
“Do not comply”: Old antivax messaging embraced by Dr. Prasad and other COVID-19 contrarians
It turns out that there is no real mystery as to why this sort of messaging is being embraced by useful idiots for the antivax movement like Dr. Prasad. COVID-19 cases are increasing, leading, not unreasonably, to suggestions that maybe bringing back mask mandates (and vaccine mandates) is a good idea. I first saw it from Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, a physician who soon turned COVID-19 crank and antivaxxer but now writes things like—you guessed it!—Do not comply, in which he argues:
Furthermore, as the CDC again requires more testing in hospitals, schools and workplaces, cases counts will rise. Once that happens, we can expect more mask mandates on airplanes, trains and public spaces. These are hard to resist – we have to travel for work. We have vacations planned. We have places to go and we need to go into public buildings. How do we fight this?
You guessed it again! Do not comply! Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has also been using this phrase with respect to COVID-19 public health mitigations.
I wondered if any of the doctors who claim not to be antivaccine are aware of how much antivaxxers have used “do not comply” and/or “I do not comply” as messaging. This was a thing on Facebook in 2019 in response to California trying to close the loopholes in its school vaccine mandate:
Sound familiar? (I note that it has become more and more difficult to find the “do not comply” narrative in searches of time periods before 2020 given how overwhelming the narrative has become since the pandemic.) How about this:
In fact, the “do not comply” narrative goes way back, for instance, at least to the 1880s:
And, even if the words “I do not comply” aren’t there, the sentiment was expressed often by fans of Jenny McCarthy 15 years ago:
There are many variations of the “do not comply” narrative that portray the poor oppressed antivaxxer as a freedom fighter willing to kill, if necessary. I realize that Dr. Prasad said that “nonviolent” resistance is the way, but it’s just a hop, skip, and a jump to ditching the “nonviolent” part and many of his fans are not so fastidious.
Del Bigtree, for example, in 2016:
If we do not fight now, then there will be nothing left to fight for. And I think that is where everyone in this room, I pray you realize how important you are in this historic moment. We will never be stronger than we are right now. We will never be healthier than we are right now. Our children are looking like this, a generation of children, as we’ve said on The Doctors television show this is the first generation of children that will not live to be as old as their parents. Are we going to stand…are we going to sit down and take it? Or are we going to stand up and say: This is a historic moment, that my forefathers, those from Jefferson all the way to Martin Luther King, the moments where people stood up and something inside of them said I’m going to stand for freedom and I’m going to stand for it now. That is in our DNA. It is pumping through me, and I pray that you feel it pumping through you, because we must look back. Our grandchildren will look back and thank us for having stood up one more time and been the generation that said, “We the People of the United States of America stood for freedom, stand for freedom. We will die for freedom today.
OK, this is definitely overwrought but not quite violent rhetoric yet. It skirts the edge of violence but maintains a bit of plausible deniability with respect to accusations of inciting violence. Similarly, Dr. Prasad’s rhetoric is seeking to channel comparisons to nonviolent resistance like that advocated by Martin Luther King, Jr., just as Del Bigtree did here. In other words, he’s equating not reporting cases of a potentially deadly respiratory virus—indeed, actively resisting public health efforts to slow the spread of that respiratory virus—to nonviolent resistance to Jim Crow and racist government policies of the sort used by the civil rights movement decades ago.

Amusingly, as I was finishing this post yesterday, an antivaxxer by the name of Rick Stanley, who for some reason has included me on his email list, sent me a post by the pseudonymous COVID-19 crank and antivaxxer The Vigilant Fox entitled Happy ‘Do Not Comply’ Day, with the tagline, “Thanks for resisting.” To get an idea where Fox, who is less than knowledgeable about science but apparently vigilant for any conspiracy theory that he or she encounters, is coming from, the post includes a figure with the ten stages of genocide:

After ranting about a speech that President Joseph Biden gave two years ago in which he chastised the unvaccinated for prolonging the pandemic, the supposedly vigilant one wrote:
I realized I was witnessing Germany 2.0 unfolding before my very eyes and knew it had to be stopped before things got worse. I decided then that I could no longer be a spectator and started taking steps toward creating the account you see today, Vigilant News.
What ensued after Biden’s speech was one of the most hate-filled propaganda campaigns in human history. Here’s a look back at what they did to the noncompliant in the name of “health.”
One of the most hate-filled propaganda campaigns in human history? More so than the Nazi campaign against the Jews? Worse or as bad as the propaganda campaign in Rwanda against the Tutsis that led to genocide? Or the propaganda campaigns in Communist China during the Cultural Revolution that led to the deaths of millions? Seriously? The Fox certainly lacks…a sense of proportion. Seriously, he/she/it seems to view the cherry picked examples of the “horrors” visited upon the unvaccinated as equivalent to a second Holocaust. However, I do thank the Fox, whoever he/she/it is, for providing me with an example even more extreme than Del Bigtree’s equating antivaxxers to the Founding Fathers willing to die for freedom.
This is the rhetoric that Dr. Prasad is invoking.
I doubt that Dr. Prasad will take me seriously if he reads this. In fact, I suspect that he’ll find a reason to deny that he is sounding anything like Del Bigtree, but he is. Given his embrace of antivax rhetoric, arguments, and messaging with respect to not just COVID-19 vaccines but also RCTs of older vaccines, concern about disease being “irrational anxiety,” and victimhood whenever he is properly called out for his misinformation and opposition to public health, I’m finding it increasingly difficult not to label him as just plain antivax. Actually, it’s impossible. For whatever reasons, Dr. Prasad has joined the antivax movement. He’s joined the fantasy that he’s a brave freedom fighter combatting the encroaching tyranny of government and public health, when in reality he’s just a misinformation pusher who’s been captured by his audience and now must push increasingly outlandish misinformation and conspiracy theories about COVID-19 and vaccines in order to keep his Substack popular.

I Agree with Dr. Vinay Prasad: It’s Entirely Predictable That More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids
Dr. Prasad didn’t predict this sad outcome, he worked tirelessly to cause it. So did many other doctors.
Jonathan Howard on November 25, 2023
Link

“Entirely Predictable: More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids”
Measles, pertussis, and chickenpox are poised to make a comeback. According to a recent article titled CDC Data Shows Highest Level Yet Of Vaccine Exemptions For Kindergartners:
The percentage of kindergartners whose parents opted them out of state-required childhood vaccinations rose to the highest level yet during the 2022-2023 school year, according to federal data released Thursday. The numbers mark a continued drop in routine immunization that increases the risk for highly contagious diseases, such as measles, to spread.
Many doctors responded to this alarming news by advocating for vaccines.
Not Dr. Vinay Prasad, however. He saw yet another opportunity to trash the pediatric COVID vaccine, as he’s been doing regularly since January 2021, several months before there even was a pediatric COVID vaccine. According to Dr. Prasad, by seeking to limit COVID’s impact on children, the CDC itself is to blame for falling vaccine rates. In an article on his monetized, misinformation Substack titled Entirely Predictable: More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids, he wrote:
For many of us who have witnessed the CDC’s repeated blunders with kids COVID19 vaccines, this result is entirely predictable…I worried that the unyielding push to vaccinate kids with a COVID19 vaccine that has never shown reduction in severe disease or hospitalization in a randomized trial at any age, and certainly not against prevailing variants, was a huge mistake, and would lead the public to doubt all vaccines, rather than an embrace of all… Very soon, we will likely see real outbreaks of measles and other virus thought controlled by vaccination.
“I warned them,” Dr. Prasad boasted. Embracing extreme cancel culture, again, Dr. Prasad said, “Any employee responsible for masking 2 year olds or adding COVID19 vaccines to the pediatric schedule should be fired”.
“One common claim of the anti-vaccine movement is that vaccines have never been properly tested.”
Though Dr. Prasad’s readers won’t learn this, there were 6 randomized-controlled trials of the pediatric COVID vaccine, which involved nearly 25,000 children. There have since been dozens of observational studies from around the world showing it kept many children safe and out of the hospital. Dr. Prasad presented no data to support his claim that parents are declining the MMR because they feel the COVID vaccine RCTs were underpowered.
He just had a hunch.
I’ve studied the anti-vaccine movement for over a decade. Along with Dorit Reiss, I co-wrote a book chapter titled The Anti-Vaccine Movement: A Litany of Fallacy and Errors in 2018. We knew then that no matter how many studies are done on vaccines, anti-vaxxers will always claim they are insufficient. We wrote then:
This shifting of goalposts is also very evident when it comes to vaccine safety where impossible standards are often demanded. One common claim of the anti-vaccine movement is that vaccines have never been properly tested. Tens of thousands of studies exist on vaccines’ safety and effectiveness, and vaccines are, in fact, tested more thoroughly than most medications. But the anti-vaccine movement claims that these studies are invalid because the entire vaccine schedule has not been tested together over the entire human life span.
Based on my knowledge of the anti-vaccine movement, I doubt that vaccine-hesitant parents would be embracing the MMR today if only the RCTs of the pediatric COVID vaccine enrolled more children, as Dr. Prasad absurdly claimed.
The available data supports my position. If it were true that “the unyielding push to vaccinate kids with a COVID19 vaccine” led parents to reject other other vaccines, then Florida, which encouraged the mass infection of unvaccinated children with SARS-CoV-2, should have been spared a dip in its vaccination rates. However, according to an article from 2022 titled Florida School Immunization Rates Lowest in Over 10 Years:
Last year marked a more than 10-year low for Florida’s kindergarten and seventh-grade students completed all doses of required immunizations, according to a recent report form the state Department of Health.
Dr. Prasad did not blame Governor Ron DeSantis and his sidekick, anti-vaccine data-manipulator Dr. Joseph Ladapo, for falling vaccination rates in their state. In fact, he admires them for their “unyielding push” to have unvaccinated children contract COVID.
A similar story is playing out in the UK, which also had an “unyielding push” to have unvaccinated children contract COVID. A recent article titled ‘No No No. Avoid Them All’: Anti-Vaccine Conspiracies Spread As UK Cases Of Measles Increase shows how misinformation about the COVID vaccine bleeds into all vaccines. “Online anti-vaxxers, conflating Covid and MMR theories, are convincing parents against immunising their children,” it said.
In fact, according to Heidi Larson, the director of the Vaccine Confidence Project:
In 55 countries, there was a precipitous drop between 2015 and 2022 in the number of people who said that routine immunization is important for children.
According to an article on this worldwide drop:
Disinformation campaigns and hesitation about Covid vaccines have spilled over and eroded some of the traditional eagerness that parents had to get their children routine immunizations.
Can the CDC’s “unyielding push to vaccinate kids” be blamed for this? I don’t think so.
“It Is Natural To Be Infected Repeatedly With Respiratory Viruses— If We Got Fewer Infections What Would That Mean For Auto-Immunity For Cancer?”
So if the CDC is not to blame for falling vaccination rates around the world, what is? I too have a hunch as to why some parents are rejecting vaccines today: prominent doctors told them that viruses are beneficial for children and society at large.
Indeed, Dr. Prasad was a vocal cheerleader for infecting unvaccinated children with multiple viruses. I know I’ve shared these quotes previously, but in light of Dr. Prasad’s unearned victory lap, it’s worth doing so again. His facile arguments and emotionally manipulative language- the unyielding push to vaccinate kids – are like catnip to anti-vaxxers and identical to the content they produced before the pandemic.
In an article titled Should We Let Children Catch Omicron? he wrote that measures to protect children:
Are premised on the idea that America’s children must be shielded from exposure to Covid-19. What kids really need, however, is a return to normal. And when it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger.
“Immunity is built through illness,” he wrote.
Promoting the idea that unvaccinated children should be exposed to SARS-CoV-2 to benefit society, Dr. Prasad favorably quoted Dr. Francois Balloux who said:
I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.
He also favorably quoted a paper in The BMJ that said:
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood… This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
He urged readers to numb themselves to children lost to COVID, writing:
Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course, including drowning, vehicle accidents, and even cardiovascular disease.
This is exactly how anti-vaxxers minimized measles. This comes from an anti-vaccine article, Measles: The New Red Scare, on Greenmedinfo from 2019:
Before the advent of a measles vaccine, measles was generally considered a mild illness. Even the British Medical Journal remarked in 1959 at this particular medical practice that over a 10 year span there were few complications from measles and that all children recovered.
In the majority of children the whole episode has been well and truly over in a week . . . In this practice measles is considered as a relatively mild and inevitable childhood ailment that is best encountered any time from 3 to 7 years of age. Over the past 10 years there have been few serious complications at any age, and all children have made complete recoveries. As a result of this reasoning no special attempts have been made at prevention even in young infants in whom the disease has not been found to be especially serious…
In 1962, measles was sixth from the bottom for causes of death. You can look through the list of causes of death and find almost everything from “Birth Injuries” at 28,199 to “Ulcers” at 12,228 to “Asthma” at 4,896 were far higher than the 408 deaths attributed to “Measles” that year.
COVID was not the only vaccine-preventable disease Dr. Prasad lauded. He encouraged parents to think of unvaccinated, infected children as human shields and embraced long-standing anti-vaccine myths about chickenpox, writing:
Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
Of course, children are independent people who deserve to be protected against diseases. According to CDC estimates:
During the first 25 years,* the U.S. chickenpox vaccination program has prevented an estimated: 91 million cases. 238,000 hospitalizations, 2,000 deaths.
The UK finally seems poised to reverse their flawed stance.
In addition to COVID and chickenpox, Dr. Prasad spoke favorably of letting children contract a third potentially lethal virus, the flu. In an article titled “I Am Going to Mask Because I Want to Get Fewer Colds & Other Flawed Ideas,” Dr. Prasad wrote:
There is the arrogance that avoiding colds and flu is good for us. Of course it is the case that getting sick is unpleasant, but our knowledge of immunology and the body is so primitive we should not conclude that avoiding it is ‘good for us.’ We have no idea if that is true in the long run. It is natural to be infected repeatedly with respiratory viruses— if we got fewer infections what would that mean for auto-immunity for cancer? We have no idea if we would actually live longer or healthier lives trying to dodge seasonal runny noses and coughs.
Prior to the pandemic, anti-vaccine doctor turned homeopath, Suzanne Humphries, similarly spoke of the “benefits” of infecting unvaccinated children with “natural” viruses. In her article The Benefits of Having a Natural Measles Infection, she claimed that measles treats kidney disease and cancer. She asked a question very similar to Dr. Prasad’s: “Why not just let wild measles circulate and do the job nature intended at the time of life it was intended, which leads to 65 years of immunity and no need for life-span vaccination?”
Having essentially argued that parents should forgo vaccines and let three viruses, SARS-CoV-2, varicella-zoster, and influenza, “circulate and do the job nature intended at the time of life it was intended,” on what grounds would Dr. Prasad argue against someone who wanted to let measles, “circulate and do the job nature intended at the time of life it was intended”?
Of course, this is just half the story. In addition to hyping the potential “benefits” of being repeatedly infected with respiratory viruses, Dr. Prasad relentlessly fear mongered about rare, usually mild, vaccine side-effects, even treating mere abnormal lab values after vaccination as a fate worse than death from COVID.
Dr. Prasad has a few thoughts vaccine side effects
“Entirely Predictable: More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids”
To summarize, parents learned from Dr. Prasad that “immunity is built through illness” and that “for children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life”. “It is natural to be infected repeatedly with respiratory viruses,” he wrote, while suggesting that protecting children from potentially deadly viruses could trigger cancer and autoimmune disease later in life. “It is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger,” he said. “Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk,” he added. He told parents to stop trusting pediatricians and other opponents of mass infection. He accused public health experts of hiding the risks of vaccines, and said that anti-vaccine crank RFK Jr. would “flatten” them in a public debate.
Don’t trust the people telling you to vaccinate your child
So, is it really a mystery why parents who were inundated with a constant stream of pro-virus sophistry then rejected the MMR? Not to me. When a professor from a top medical school with a large media footprint parrots standard anti-vaccine blather and says those who disagree are untrustworthy “idiots” who are “off their rocker“, it’s entirely predictable: more parents don’t want routine vaccination for their kids.
Dr. Prasad didn’t predict this sad outcome, he worked tirelessly to cause it. So did many other doctors.

Dr. Vinay Prasad vs. a VAERS study finding more reports of vaccine injury in red states
Dr. Vinay Prasad attacks an epidemiological study published in JAMA Open Network reporting that people in red states are more likely to report vaccine injuries, claiming that a more rigorous study would “not be difficult,” when he knows that it would be very difficult.
David Gorsk ion April 8, 2024
Link

The Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) is a database run jointly by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Food and Drug Administration for reporting vaccine injuries whose major strength is the same as its major weakness. The major strength of VAERS is that anybody—and I do mean anybody—can report a suspected vaccine injury to it. You don’t have to be a physician or other health care provider to report a suspected vaccine injury, and, given what VAERS was designed for, that’s a good thing. That’s because VAERS was designed as an early warning system, a “canary in the coal mine,” if you will, to detect potential adverse events (AEs) from new and existing vaccines. What that design means, though, is that VAERS inherently cannot be used to accurately estimate the incidence or prevalence of specific injuries due to specific vaccines, because it is a passive surveillance system that relies on voluntary reporting. The idea is that VAERS is a hypothesis-generating, not a hypothesis-testing, system, because, given that anyone can report anything to VAERS, factors other than incidence or prevalence can hugely impact reporting to VAERS. VAERS is thus subject to the base rate fallacy, which occurs when cases or raw numbers of a phenomenon are examined without statistically correct consideration of the base rate or prior probability of that phenomenon being observed. That’s why any hypothesis generated by VAERS must be tested against more rigorous systems like the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment (CISA) project, or FDA’s Post-licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring System (PRISM), active reporting systems that actively monitor electronic health records for AEs after vaccination in order to identify potential signals. Usually the VSD is the database most commonly used to investigate safety signals found in VAERS.
Indeed, that’s why the greatest weakness of VAERS is that anybody can report anything to it. As we have discussed here time and time again, the main problem with using VAERS to estimate the frequency of AEs after vaccination is precisely that, in essence, anyone with access to the Internet, mail, or the telephone can report anything to VAERS, as was demonstrated by bloggers years and years ago when one autism advocate filed a report claiming that the flu vaccine had turned him into The Incredible Hulk and another claimed a vaccine had turned his daughter into Wonder Woman. Both reports were accepted. In fairness, ultimately someone from VAERS did contact these people to ask about the reports, and the reports were removed. However, had they refused, reports that vaccines might turn one into the Hulk or Wonder Woman might still be in the database. Another example that I like to cite is how in the 1990s and beyond, lawyers suing vaccine manufacturers for vaccine-induced autism (which is not a thing, given that the evidence overwhelmingly shows that vaccines do not increase the risk of autism) gamed VAERS by encouraging potential litigants to report their children’s autism to VAERS as a vaccine-related AE, as I first discussed in 2006. (Yes, you read that right! 2006! VAERS has been a favorite tool of antivaxxers to mine for deceptive associations going back at least two decades.)
Interestingly, the greatest weakness in VAERS, namely reporting biases and how much changes in reporting that can be affected by news, government campaigns to encourage reporting (e.g., the way the CDC gave instructions to vaccinees receiving COVID-19 vaccines on how to report to VAERS), misinformation, news reports, and disinformation, can also make it a source for preliminary research on factors that can affect the reporting of vaccine-related AEs to VAERS. This aspect of VAERS was in evidence in a study published a week and a half ago in JAMA Open Network, the open-access peer-reviewed journal run by JAMA. The study, by a group of investigators from the University of Pennsylvania and Washington University, was entitled Reports of COVID-19 Vaccine Adverse Events in Predominantly Republican vs Democratic States. Its findings made the news (of course) because they were rather provocative, albeit not unexpected, given how far to the right the political center of gravity of the antivaccine movement has shifted over the last 15 years, particularly during the pandemic. I’ll get into the details in a moment, including weaknesses of the study, but, in brief, examining 620,456 vaccine AEs reported to VAERS from adults 18 and older, investigators found that “the more states were inclined to vote Republican, the more likely their vaccine recipients or their clinicians reported COVID-19 vaccine AEs.”
Unsurprisingly, the study briefly made the news and the rounds on Easter weekend after it was published, although to me the news coverage was actually not very intense and relatively mild, with the few articles I saw about the study having bland titles like Reports of COVID-19 Vaccine Adverse Events in Predominantly Republican vs Democratic States and People in Republican-voting states more likely to report Covid-19 vaccine side effects, study says. It was apparently the news stories like these that drew the attention of someone whose bad COVID-19 takes have been a fairly frequent topic of this blog, Dr. Vinay Prasad, who took to his paid Substack to complain, Unhelpful, inflammatory Jama Network Open paper suggests that people in Red states dream up vaccine injuries and mixed in with a discussion of weaknesses of the study acknowledged by the authors a claim so utterly divorced from reality that it reminded me of a catchphrase that a certain YouTuber employs at some point in all his videos to comic effect, only with Dr. Prasad seemingly using it seriously.
Before I discuss the study and Dr. Prasad’s reaction to it, I will note that nowhere does Dr. Prasad take note of a different kind of reaction to it coming from antivaxxers, reactions from antivaxxers like Covid Vax Deaths Surge in Republican-Voting States, Study Finds, proclaiming. No, that’s not what this study found. It’s what the authors write in the introduction as part of their rationale for doing the study:
COVID-19 mortality has been higher in US jurisdictions that are more conservative in their party registration,1 voting history,2 or representation.3 These differences are likely explained, in part, by differences in vaccination rates. Counties voting for former President Donald Trump in the 2020 presidential election had substantially lower COVID-19 vaccination rates than counties voting for President Joe Biden.4,5
None of this is particularly controversial, but Dr. Prasad has apparently decided to echo antivax takes on this study:
Once you get past being insulted by “perceived” AEs and embarrassed for the authors’ clear partisan bias the reverse framing is immediately obvious. Add to this the methodological issues. How is this crap being published in a supposedly serious medical journal? Thanks you for…
— Jessica Adams (@RxRegA) April 3, 2024
Note the use of the phrase “dreamed up.” Nowhere in the study is it claimed that people in red states “dream up” vaccine injuries. I also note that antivaxxer Dr. Paul Alexander is very much impressed with Dr. Prasad’s take on the study, which is never a good sign if you think you are science-based, as Dr. Prasad does.
Let’s take a look at the study itself, which is fairly simple in design. Afterwards, we’ll look at Dr. Prasad’s mix of reasonable critiques with unreasonable critiques, to see what form of negative spin he puts on it.
Red, Blue, and VAERS
Getting back to the study, it’s of a fairly simple design. In brief, it is a cross-sectional study of reports to the VAERS database for injuries after COVID-19 vaccination that identified total of 620 456 AE reports (mean [SD] age of vaccine recipients, 51.8 [17.6] years; 435 797 reports from women [70.2%]; a vaccine recipient could potentially file more than one report, so reports are not necessarily from unique individuals) for COVID-19 vaccination. The time period examined was from 2020 to 2022, and the study looked at adults 18 years of age and older. As a control, the authors examined VAERS reports for injuries due to influenza vaccines. The results were broken down by state, with each state’s reporting of AEs after COVID-19 vaccination and after influenza vaccination (from 2019 to 2022) compared to the state’s voting record in the 2020 Presidential election, specifically the percentage of vote that went for the Republican candidate Donald Trump. These outcomes were then examined:
We separately examined 3 different outcomes: (1) rates of any AE among vaccine recipients, (2) rates of any severe AE among vaccine recipients, and (3) the proportion of AEs reported as severe. To account for baseline variation in VAERS reporting behavior across states, we also used each state’s AE reporting rate for the influenza vaccine (Figure 1).
As the authors put it in the introduction, they were using a major weakness of VAERS as a strength for purposes of their study:
However, what is a weakness in the VAERS in systematically capturing AEs is a strength in quantifying the perception of AEs and the motivation to report them. Without a plausible reason to believe that vaccine recipients and their clinicians in Republican-inclined states will objectively encounter different rates of vaccine AEs than those in Democrat-inclined states, or have different abilities to report them, differences in reporting of those AEs will reflect the product of how those AEs are perceived and the inclination to report them, either by the vaccine recipients or their clinicians.
In fairness, one might reasonably question whether there are objective reasons why people in red states might objectively encounter different rates of AEs after vaccination, but that isn’t really what Dr. Prasad does in his critique, as you will see. That quibble aside, the authors made adjustments for the male-female ratio and median age to “adjust for state-level heterogeneity in VAERS reporting unconnected to COVID-19 vaccination.” They also did a number of sensitivity analyses, to determine how robust their model was was and identify potential confounders:
In sensitivity analyses, we (1) stratified regressions by age groups or excluded the District of Columbia; (2) used hierarchical logistic regression with state-specific random effects as another approach to account for heterogeneity in the baseline VAERS reporting rate; (3) performed an individual-level analysis for the proportion of AEs reported as severe within VAERS reports, adjusting for individual age, sex, and history of medication or allergy; and (4) relaxed assumptions of linearity by using locally estimated scatterplot smoothing.10
The flowchart looked like this:
The results were quite striking:
We observed 620 456 AE reports (435 797 from women [70.2%]; mean [SD] age, 51.8 [17.7] years) associated with COVID-19 vaccination (Table 1). A vaccine recipient could potentially file more than 1 report, so reports are not necessarily from unique individuals. A 10% increase in state-level Republican voting was associated with increased odds of AE reports (odds ratio [OR], 1.05; 95% CI, 1.05-1.05; P < .001), severe AE reports (OR, 1.25; 95% CI, 1.24-1.26; P < .001), and the proportion of AEs reported as severe (OR, 1.21; 95% CI, 1.20-1.22; P < .001) (Table 2). These positive associations between political inclination and reports of COVID-19 vaccination AEs are shown in Figure 2 against no associations between political inclination and reports of influenza AEs. These findings were seen across all age strata in stratified analyses and in analyses excluding the District of Columbia (Table 2) and were sustained in sensitivity analyses (eTable 2 and the eFigure in Supplement 1; Figure 3).
Graphically, the results looked like this:
All these differences are rather striking, particularly the reports of severe AEs. Overall, the authors estimated, a 10% increase in state Republican voting was associated with a 5% increase in the odds that a COVID-19 vaccine AE would be reported to VAERS, a 25% increase in the odds that a severe AE would be reported, and a 21% increase in the odds that any reported AE would be severe.
Sensitivity analyses carried out to try to exclude other factors that might confound the analysis found that…
…individuals with other vaccines or history of medication or allergy do not show a significant association with political inclination, male recipients of the COVID-19 vaccine show a similar association with political inclination as female recipients, and older recipients of the COVID-19 vaccine show a stronger association with political inclination.
The results led the investigators to conclude:
This study found that the more states were inclined to vote Republican in the 2020 US presidential election, the more likely their vaccine recipients or clinicians were to report COVID-19 vaccine AEs. This association between political inclination and vaccine AE reporting was not seen for the influenza vaccine. The results are consistent with a relative overreporting of vaccine AEs among Republicans or a relative underreporting among Democrats.
Further noting:
The association between observation and belief runs both ways. The adage “seeing is believing” recognizes that our individual experiences inform our sense of truth, and “believing is seeing” recognizes that our preconceptions modulate what we experience in the first place. In finding that Republican-inclined states show higher COVID-19 AE reporting than Democrat-inclined states, this study suggests that Republicans are more likely to perceive or report those AEs and that Democrats are less likely to.
All of this is, of course, not unreasonable. Because VAERS is a passive reporting database, that means that what it is recording are AEs that the people reporting the AEs perceive as having been likely due to the vaccine. One only has to point to examples of people claiming that sudden cardiac deaths were due to COVID-19 vaccines, even when they occur weeks, months, or years after vaccination, to emphasize the point that perception affects reporting to VAERS. The same thing is true of cancer, with antivaxxers perceiving nearly any case of cancer occurring after vaccination with COVID-19 vaccines, be it days, weeks, months, or even a year later when the cancer is diagnosed, as being “turbo cancers” caused by the vaccines. If deaths and cancer can be incorrectly perceived as due to the vaccines, then of course lesser AEs will be even easier to have been incorrectly attributed to vaccines. Again, as the authors point out, this goes both ways. If you believe the vaccines are safe and effective, you might be less likely to attribute something that might be a real vaccine injury to the vaccines, a point that antivaxxers offended by this study miss.
The Prasad is outraged
Of course, nuance has never been Dr. Vinay Prasad’s strong suit, at least not when there is an audience to enrage and clicks to be had. He is outraged that this study found what it found:
How to rebuild trust? By doubling down on petty partisan politics, according to a new JAMA NO paper.
And then:
The article claims that people in Red states report more vaccine injuries than people in Blue states. It concludes that either Republicans are more likely to “perceive” injuries, or Dems less likely.
I’m not sure how this finding is “doubling down” on petty partisan politics. It seems that Dr. Prasad is more outraged by a single example of news coverage of the study in which Dr. Eric Topol in a STAT+ article:
Note how the text fades out. Dr. Prasad apparently doesn’t have a subscription to STAT+ and therefore didn’t read the whole article, which might or might not have included more from Dr. Topol. Unfortunately, neither do I; so I can’t check. However, I must agree that Dr. Topol’s not wrong in that, again, the political center of gravity of the antivaccine movement has shifted far to the right over the last decade, especially since the pandemic; moreover, we know that vaccine hesitancy and resistance tend to be higher in states with a high proportion of Republicans. Heck, economist turned incompetent antivax “epidemiologist,” Michigan State University Professor Mark Skidmore inadvertently found data suggesting, for instance, that political orientation greatly affects whether a person perceives a death as having been due to COVID-19 vaccines or not. Too bad he was so hellbent on deceptively spinning his survey data into “proving” that COVID-19 vaccines have killed hundreds of thousands of Americans.
Let’s get to the substance, such as it is, of Dr. Prasad’s criticism:
Let me explain why this is a poor choice. The factors that predict whether someone has an adverse event to influenza vaccine may not be the same as those that predict adverse events from covid shots. It could be that there are actually more covid vaccine injuries in one group than another— even though both had equal rates of influenza injuries.
Yes, but that’s not why the authors were using influenza vaccines as a control. They clearly thought that political orientation would have much less of an effect on whether a person perceived an AE as having been due to the vaccine than it would for COVID-19 vaccines. After all, flu vaccines have been around a long time, and most people, aside from antivaxxers and the vaccine-hesitant, view them rather benignly, or at least not with fear and loathing, based on messaging that is more prevalent on one side of the political spectrum than the other. Of course, Dr. Prasad likely knows this, but that doesn’t stop him from spinning a fantastical confounder with a dubious comparison:
Another way to think of it is, there can be two groups of people and you can balance them by the rate with which they get headaches from drinking wine, but one group can be more likely to get headaches from reading without glasses because more people in that group wear glasses. In other words, states with more republicans might be states with specific co-morbidities that predict COVID vaccine adverse side effects but not influenza vaccine side effects. We already know that COVID vaccine injuries do affect different groups (young men, for e.g.).
I note that the only example that Dr. Prasad can cite (young men being more likely to experience myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination) would have likely shown up in the sensitivity analyses based on age and gender. It didn’t. Absent that, all Dr. Prasad is doing is coming up with a hypothetical confounder that he can’t prove. After all, if he could, he would have cited specific conditions or demographic traits of different states—other than being young and male—that might have confounded these results.
Next up:
These data are ecological. It doesn’t prove that republicans themselves are more likely to report vaccine injuries. It would not be difficult to pair voting records with vaccine records at an individual patient level if the authors wished to do it right— another example of research laziness.
It is correct that this study is ecological and that ecological studies can find associations that don’t hold up to more rigorous analysis. The authors are very upfront about that, stating that it is one of the study’s weaknesses but also explaining why they think that the ecological design of the study was unlikely in this case to have produced a false positive correlation:
This study is limited by its ecological design.12 Both vaccine reporting and political voting occur at the level of individuals, but here they are measured at the level of states. Nevertheless, the only way the results might not support a relatively increased AE reporting rate among individual Republican-voting citizens is if Republican-voting citizens were less likely to report but far more likely than Democrat-voting citizens to be vaccinated in the first place or if, as the proportion of Republican-voting citizens in a state increased, the AE reporting rates among the progressively fewer Democrat-voting citizens increased at an even steeper rate. Neither possibility seems likely.
In particular, that latter explanation appears very unlikely.
Remember, though, how I referred to a catchphrase of a certain YouTuber whose videos I like? The part where Dr. Prasad blithely says that it “would not be difficult to pair voting records with vaccine records at an individual patient level if the authors wished to do it right— another example of research laziness” is what brought to mind that catchphrase about how “difficult” this task might be, because apparently Dr. Prasad thinks that it would be “super easy, barely an inconvenience.” By way of background, that catchphrase comes from YouTuber:
Super easy, barely an inconvenience is one of the main catchphrases of the series, Pitch Meetings always said by Screenwriter Guy. It is an on-running phrase used in nearly every episode whenever Studio Executive Guy thinks something would probably be difficult, to which the the guy giving the pitch responds that it would actually be “super easy, barely an inconvenience”, which pokes fun at the fact that the thing being referred to should probably be more difficult than it ends up being.
I could point to just how difficult getting institutional review board (IRB) approval for the sort of massive study that Dr. Prasad says “would not be difficult” would likely be, and I’m not even considering getting the funding to carry out such a combined epidemiological and social sciences study would be.
If you were to listen to Dr. Prasad, you’d think that pairing up voting records with over 600,000 VAERS records for COVID-19 vaccine AEs and political affiliation of individuals would be “super easy, barely an inconvenience” that only wasn’t done because the investigators who did this study were somehow too “lazy” to bothered. This is an insult to the investigators. After all, as scientists we all want to do the most rigorous studies that we can manage, but sometimes you have to do what is possible rather than ideal. This study appears to be about the best ecological study of this type that could be done, working within the realm of the feasible and what the authors likely had funding to accomplish. It’s basically the same deceptive technique that Dr. Prasad employs when he complains about there not being any randomized controlled clinical trials (RCTs) sufficiently “rigorous” for his liking. (Never mind that there is no elite RCT strike force.) It’s what I like to call methodolatry, or fundamentalist evidence-based medicine (EBM) that discounts any non-RCT as crap, regardless of ethics or feasibility of doing the desired “ideal” RCT. It’s the sort of fundamentalism that antivaxxers like RFK Jr. and his lawyer Aaron Siri have used to deceptively imply that the childhood vaccination schedule is somehow “unsafe” because not all vaccines have undergone RCTs versus a placebo control. (I discussed in great depth why this is nonsense here and described how such methodolatry and EBM fundamentalism have been weaponized against public health here.) Dr. Prasad fell for that argument on vaccines and here is doing a variation of the same thing with epidemiology, bemoaning a decent, achievable ecological study because it is not an in-depth, individual patient-record study.
It would actually be a difficult, massive undertaking. First, the VAERS report records would have to be de-anonymized, so that the investigators had names of the people making the VAERS reports. Then the authors would have to figure out who the actual patient injured was. (After all, family members, spouses, friends, and health care workers can make a report to VAERS.) They would then have to match over 600,000 names to voting records in 50 states. They’d also have to decide how they were going to assign political orientation, Democrat, Republican, or Independent, to each VAERS entry. In states in which voters have to declare a party affiliation when they register to vote, it might be fairly “easy” (but not “super easy, barely an inconvenience”). In other states, they might have to figure it out by looking at records for primary elections and seeing which ballots the people behind the VAERS entries selected. Michigan (where I am registered to vote), has an open primary and does not require one to declare a party when registering to vote. However, for any given primary election, you have to pick a Republican or Democratic primary ballot when you vote and can only vote for the primary candidates in that party. You can, however, pick the ballot for either party in any given primary, voting, for example, for Republican candidates in one primary and then the next primary picking a Democratic ballot and choosing among Democrats. For other states with open primaries it could be quite difficult to assign party affiliation to VAERS entries from the voting records, and assigning party would be impossible in states with open primaries that do not require voters to declare a party affiliation when they register to vote and allow voters to vote for both Democrats and Republicans in the primary. This latter group is pretty large.
Seriously, Dr. Prasad. WTF? “Not difficult”? Yes, in Michigan, for instance, you could find out which people reporting to VAERS chose a Republican or Democratic ballot for the Presidential primary, but it would hardly be “not difficult.” And that’s just one state. Every state has different laws and rules. Seriously, ask political scientists how “not difficult” it is to figure out the party affiliations of voters in all 50 states, and that doesn’t even count the question of people registered in one party voting in the other party’s primary in order to try to get a weaker candidate nominated.
Of course, I’m pretty sure that Dr. Prasad knows that it’s anything but “not difficult” to get access to the names of people in the VAERS AE entries, match them on an individual level to voting records in their state, and then correctly assign party affiliation to each one. I do, however, have to leave open the possibility that, as is the case when he says how “super easy, barely an inconvenience” it would be to do randomized controlled clinical trials of every little question related to COVID-19, such as masking, vaccines, social distancing, and “lockdowns.”
The bottom line
So, Dr. Prasad’s deceptive audience-captured attacks on it notwithstanding and the obstinate intentional misinterpretation of the results to say that Republicans “make up” vaccine injuries, what does this study tell us. Again, it is an ecological study and has all the limitations of such studies. On the other hand, it is consistent with a lot of what we know about the sociology of vaccine hesitancy in the age of COVID-19, namely that the demonization of the vaccines coming from the right does influence belief in those sharing political philosophy, with lower vaccination rates, for example, and more resistance to vaccine mandates. It is therefore not unreasonable to hypothesize that political orientation might affect perceptions of the cause of AEs that might be due to COVID-19 vaccination, and this study appears to confirm that hypothesis, with people in red states being more likely to report AEs associated with COVID-19 vaccines but not associated with flu vaccines. Further research will either support or contradict the finding of this study. That’s how science works. As of now, though, the study finds pretty much what, knowing what we knew before, we would have predicted it to find.
Dr. Prasad knows his audience though, having been thoroughly captured by it. That’s why he echoes their exact complaints about “misperception” and then adds these juicy bits of red meat:
The story is framed as Republicans are more likely to imagine injuries, but the truth is Dems might be more likely to brush them under the rug due to misplaced loyalty to our lord and savior St. Anthony of Fauci. Dems might suppress real injuries.
Our “lord and savior St. Anthony of Fauci”? Give me a break. If anyone wonders why I haven’t taken Dr. Prasad seriously for a very long time, the quote above should tell you why. He knows his audience and now completely caters to it. Whether he himself believes his antivax pandering anymore, only he can say, but for all practical purposes whether he believes it or not is irrelevant. His messaging is antivax even to the point where he credulously bought into one of RFK Jr.’s favorite old antivax tropes, undermined the childhood vaccination schedule. with EBM methodolatry, and echoed old antivax “do not comply” messaging, and that, unfortunately, is more than enough.

Dr. Vinay Prasad: It’s “Good” That Parents Who Want To Vaccinate Their Kids Against COVID Get Reported To Child Protective Services
Trying to limit pediatric COVID was literally the pandemic’s worst sin for pro-infection doctors, warranting severe punishment. This is how desperately they wanted them infected.
Jonathan Howard on April 14, 2024
Link

Any employee responsible for masking 2 year olds or adding COVID19 vaccines to the pediatric schedule should be fired.
In November 2023, Dr. Vinay Prasad, an anti-vaccine adult oncologist who has spread copious misinformation about pediatric COVID despite never treating a child sick with it, said CDC employees should be purged en masse for trying to prevent COVID in children. He wrote:
In order to regain trust, the CDC needs to be reorganized. First, any employee responsible for masking 2 year olds or adding COVID19 vaccines to the pediatric schedule should be fired…The CDC is failing every day; only drastic action can overcome the public doubt they have created by their own incompetence.
In a pandemic where over 1.1 million Americans died, including around 2,000 children, Dr. Prasad reserves his scorn and calls for “drastic action”, not for those who spewed fatal anti-vaccine disinformation, but rather for those who tried to limit pediatric COVID. He felt these CDC employees deserved a professional death sentence, the most extreme canceling possible.
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
Being fired is indeed a “drastic action,” much worse than having a single speech canceled, though predictably Dr. Prasad expressed outrage and self-pity that this happened to him- Why Was My Talk at a Medical Conference Canceled?. He feels that doctors who spread misinformation to further their goal of infecting unvaccinated children deserve a safe space where they are shielded from the slightest social opprobrium.
Indeed anti-vaccine doctors sought to shame their critics into silence by treating nearly all attempts to limit their misinformation as a full-on assault on the principle of open, civil discourse, which they claimed was more consequential than COVID itself. In April 2020, for example, along with another defender of misinformation, Dr. Jeffrey Flier, Dr. Prasad wrote a defense of Dr. John Ioannidis titled Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should be Heard, Not Demonized. It said:
When major decisions must be made amid high scientific uncertainty, as is the case with Covid-19, we can’t afford to silence or demonize professional colleagues with heterodox views. Even worse, we can’t allow questions of science, medicine, and public health to become captives of tribalized politics. Today, more than ever, we need vigorous academic debate…
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
Yet today, not only does Dr. Prasad routinely call people “idiots”, “STUPID“, a “bunch of fools” and “total morons“, he also says CDC employees who tried to protect children in ways he did not approve of, should lose their career and income.
Good. It’s a useless vaccine for kids.
Dr. Prasad’s retribution fantasy of mass firings at the CDC was not an isolated incident. I was reminded of it I saw this recent social media exchange:
While I am skeptical this “Swedish couple” thing actually happened, Dr. Prasad was happy to take it at face value. A victim of audience capture who must always be “controversial” to pander to his paid subscribers, Dr. Prasad said it was “good” that these parents, who only “asked for COVID vaccine for the child“, were reported to Child Protective Services (CPS).
What was good about it, exactly?
CPS gets involved when children are abused or neglected. Does Dr. Prasad feel this potentially-vaccinated child was in grave danger? Moreover, CPS can take “drastic action” to keep children safe. Does Dr. Prasad feel these parents should be “fired” too?
COVID-19 vaccine is strongly effective for children and adolescents during delta and omicron.
Since I can’t let anti-vaccine misinformation slide, I’ll add that Dr. Prasad was right about just one thing, pediatric vaccination rates are low. Pro-infection doctors were successful in infecting tens of millions of unvaccinated children, with tragic consequences for some of them.
However, Dr. Prasad was wrong about everything else. Though I’ve never seen him tell this to his readers, there were 6 pediatric randomized-controlled trials involving nearly 25,000 children. One of them found “the observed vaccine efficacy was 100%.” Not bad.
Unsurprisingly, dozens of observational studies from around the world have since shown the same thing, a vaccine that limits SARS-CoV-2 infections also limits rare but grave harms from SARS-CoV-2. When Dr. Prasad, who judges studies by their results not their methods, casually dismisses all of them as “flawed”, what he really means is, “Since I relentlessly encouraged unvaccinated children to get COVID, I don’t want these studies to be true.”
Read this study here.
Finally, although COVID killed and injured more American children than every other vaccine-preventable disease combined over the past 4-years, the COVID vaccine is not in competition with other vaccines. Quite the opposite actually. Countries that encouraged unvaccinated children to repeatedly contract COVID, as Dr. Prasad advocated, are experiencing “broader vaccine hesitancy” than the U.S. Is the CDC to blame for measles in the UK because they “pushed” the pediatric COVID vaccine?
We must be careful not to create a roadmap to this future with our policy choices today, perhaps we already have.
Beyond this, our readers may remember Dr. Prasad’s delusional dystopian fanfiction where he likened measures to stop people from dying of COVID to Nazi totalitarianism. In his article, How Democracy Ends, he concluded:
We must be careful not to create a roadmap to this future with our policy choices today, perhaps we already have.
Yet today, when led to believe that parents faced potentially devastating state sanction only because they asked for a COVID vaccine for their child, Dr. Prasad said this was:
Good.
And thus it becomes clear, whether it was CDC employees or parents, trying to limit pediatric COVID was literally the pandemic’s worst sin for pro-infection doctors, warranting severe punishment. This is how desperately they wanted them infected.

I Don’t Think Vaccine Side Effects Are Worse Than Death. Am I Off My Rocker?
Contrarian doctors frame data in a misleading way to trick you into thinking vaccine side-effects are worse than death. They call you psychotic if you disagree.
Jonathan Howard on July 23, 2022
Link

The framing effect
How we perceive numbers depends on how they are framed. We view a treatment that has an 20% chance of failure less favorably than one that has an 80% chance of success. Of course, there’s no difference between these treatments.
Quote 1
With this in mind, let’s examine two quotes by Dr. Vinay Prasad. The first of these was a tweet where he commented on vaccine-myocarditis. He said:
No one says “vaccine induced myocarditis is mostly mild” like someone who just saw a graph that 20% of people 37 weeks later have not fully recovered. We are talking healthy boys who are mostly getting a 2nd or 3rd dose here. Truly unacceptable.
While Dr. Prasad was correct that vaccine myocarditis usually occurs in teenage boys after their second-vaccine dose, he was wrong to say all affected boys were all healthy. Given the high obesity rates in the US, tens of millions of children have a risk factor for severe COVID. He was also wrong about the risk of the third shot, which is about 1 in 100,000. However, his “20% of people 37 weeks later”, taken from the graph below, was right.
According to the CDC, 80% of children who develop vaccine myocarditis fully-recover, while 20% of have persistent symptoms, most commonly anxiety/depression. Other symptoms include pain, fatigue, shortness of breath, and palpitations (slide 13). A very small number of children are more impaired. Hopefully they will recover fully over time, but it’s possible some may not. Additionally, affected children will have to be monitored over the long-term to evaluate for cardiac scarring. The CDC (slide 30) stated that ‘To our knowledge, there were no vaccine-associated myocarditis deaths in this group”, and Dr. Frank Han previously explained why such claims need to be carefully evaluated.
Let’s dive into these numbers a bit further with some back-of-the-envelope calculations. The incidence of vaccine-myocarditis, which I summarized here, is hard to pin down, as different studies from around the world have given different results. One preprint found a rate of 1 in 2,650 for adolescent boys, while another study found the rate was 1 in 52,300. One study from Denmark found no increased risk for males at all, while a meta-analysis pinned the rate at 1 in 7,000-20,000 with “low certainty”. Though the exact rate is not known, a reasonable estimate is that it occurs in 1 in 10,000 adolescent boys after their second Pfizer dose. Since 80% of children recover, the rate of an adolescent boy getting and not fully recovering from vaccine-myocarditis after 37 weeks is about 1 in 50,000.
According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, about 7.2 millions boys ages 12-17 have received two vaccine doses (slide 4). This translates to 720 cases of vaccine-myocarditis in boys this age in the US. 576 of them have “fully or probably recovered,” while 144 have “improved, but not fully recovered”. As perhaps 30,000 teenagers are getting their second shot on a weekly basis, this means there are 1-2 new cases of vaccine-myocarditis every week, though this number is plausibly zero if pediatricians are spacing out the two doses. As such, I am confident the number of times many doctors, including myself, have discussed this side effect greatly exceeds the number of children who are currently hospitalized with it.
Nonetheless, I’m on record as saying:
It’s serious anytime a young person gets admitted to the hospital, even if they leave after a few days feeling well, as most seem to do.
I stand by this, and I’ve always maintained that vaccine-myocarditis should not be trivialized.
Quote 2
Dr. Prasad’s second quote came from a podcast from 2/4/2021 where he argued against the Emergency Use Authorization for pediatric vaccines. He said:
So of all the people who’ve been infected the probability one would die, when we’re talking about ten-year-olds the estimates that are in this paper is something like 2 in 100,000. So that’s of 100,000 kids infected maybe 2 would pass away. And to put that in perspective, when you talk about people who are 80, it’s 7,500 times as much.
When Dr. Prasad made that statement, 227 children had died of COVID, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, which collected data from 43 states and NYC. That grim death tally now stands at 1,700 children, per the CDC. This means that 1 in 44,000 children have already died of COVID in the US. Considering that most but not all children have had COVID, or many had it after having been vaccinated, the true death rate for unvaccinated children is slightly higher than this. However, the risk is not the same for all children. Babies have the highest death risk by far. As such, Dr. Prasad’s estimate that 1 in 50,000 10-year-olds who get COVID will die of it sounds accurate to me. All children have an extremely low risk of dying thankfully. Of course, he’s also right that 80-year-olds have a much higher risk of dying.
So by my rough but reasonable estimates, the number of children killed by COVID (1,700) is 12 times larger than the number of children with persistent symptoms after vaccine-myocarditis (144). The number of adolescent boys killed by COVID (380) is 2.5 times larger than this. Of course death is not the only negative consequence of COVID. Beyond many millions of children feeling sick to varying degrees, the number of children hospitalized by the virus is about 200 times greater than the number hospitalized by vaccine-myocarditis. Some of these children are very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU. Given that the vaccine has been shown to limit these rare but severe outcomes in multiple studies, I have no doubt the vaccine has prevented much more suffering than it has caused.
That’s all that really matters and yet, it’s controversial.
Two interesting things and some advice
I now want to point out two interesting things. First, the risk of a child dying from COVID is basically the same as an adolescent boy getting and not fully recovering from vaccine-myocarditis. Second, Dr. Prasad, framed these two adverse outcomes very differently, and he’s done this the entire pandemic.
He mocked the idea that “vaccine induced myocarditis is mostly mild”, even though 80% of children recover. He said the 20% risk of persistent symptoms was “truly unacceptable”, even though this translates to about 1 in 50,000 adolescent boys. This rate of persistent side effects really bothered him. Me too. It’s terrible that some children might have been better off had they not been vaccinated. Even though the risk is super low, these children matter.
However, Dr. Prasad’s framing of pediatric fatalities was quite different. Did he deem 1 in 50,000 children dying of COVID as “truly unacceptable”? No, he did not. In fact, he felt this death rate needed “perspective”. He could have pointed out that in the pandemic’s first year, a single child died of the flu, while COVID killed over 200 children. However, this “perspective” would have made the pediatric death toll seem high, and Dr. Prasad doesn’t want to do that. This is why he’s literally devoted a dozen podcasts to vaccine side-effects, but none to children lost to COVID or the many studies showing the vaccine can benefit them.
When dealing with pediatric deaths, Dr. Prasad instead chose to minimize this risk by stressing that elderly people have it worse. He used the salesman’s trick I discussed previously, where a large, irrelevant number – in this case that elderly people have 7,500 times the risk – is juxtaposed against a child’s risk, to minimize the virus’s impact. The goal is to convince people it’s OK if a relatively small number of unvaccinated children suffer or die from COVID so long as grandma suffers more. This makes no sense, and is formally known as the fallacy of relative privation (discussed here and here).
While it’s true that elderly people have a much higher risk than children, reasonable people understand that a child’s risk is independent of how it affects older people. COVID wouldn’t suddenly be worse for children adults were spared. 1,700 children have died no matter what the virus did to grandma, and too many of them perished after the vaccine was available to them. Normal people think that’s sad and want zero children to suffer or die for lack of a vaccine.
Dr. Prasad seems to imagine zero children have suffered or died for lack of a vaccine, though of course some have. At times, he doesn’t even acknowledge children can die at all. I guess bringing up that COVID can do much more than cause myocarditis precludes honest and productive conversation? (Rogan was wrong.)
“Any strong advocate for kid covid vaccination is off their rocker. It really doesn’t matter. The risks are super low.”
To his credit, I suppose, Dr. Prasad dropped all the pretenses, and is no longer arguing that children don’t need the vaccine because COVID is going away, because the vaccine causes fevers, because grandma is at more risk, or any of the other spurious reasons he’s given in the past. Now he is now very open that children gravely affected by COVID really don’t matter. He recently said pediatric vaccine-advocates were psychotic, tweeting that,
Any strong advocate for kid covid vaccination is off their rocker. It really doesn’t matter. The risks are super low.
I had to check to make sure he really said that. The argument seems to be, “Kids don’t need the vaccine, just because“.
Everyone agrees with Dr. Prasad that the risks are super low. This is not a deep insight. But a super low event multiplied by many millions of infections adds up. This seems like a very simple concept to me, and I don’t think over 1,500 dead children in two years is nothing.
Do you?
The risk of a child getting shot is super low, but guns are the number one cause of death in children. Because the risk to any individual child is low, does this imply a child killed by a bullet “really doesn’t matter”? Does it mean that any “strong advocate” to reduce gun deaths in children is “off their rocker”? Should we have fences around pools and airbags in cars? Should anyone bother trying to save any child from anything? After all, the risk of that particular thing is probably super low.
Around 20,000 children die each year in the US. These are the real questions then:
    • Should we bother trying to stop 5% of the deaths?
    • If not, what is the magic number of dead children where we should suddenly start to care and say, “Hey, maybe we should try to stop this“?
I don’t know the answers, but 5% seems a big enough number to me, even though, yes, 95% of pediatric deaths are from some other cause.
Sadly, there is no vaccine for bullets, accidents, and suicides. I wish there were, though assuredly some doctors would oppose these imaginary vaccines because the risks they defend against are “super low”. However, of the leading causes of death in children, only COVID can have its already low risk lowered with 3 simple shots.
Why not use them? Why not help some children, even if that number isn’t that large? The vaccine reduces pediatric hospitalizations, though not perfectly. Arguing against the vaccine for this reason is the Nirvana fallacy, which is a standard anti-vaccine talking point.
We all get that only a few kids will really benefit from the vaccine. Again, this is not a deep insight. It astounds me that people think is a valid reason not to use the vaccine, yet, I hear it all the time.
“Wow, this quack is the head of an institute of an actual medical center?”
Prior to the pandemic, Dr. Prasad called a doctor a quack because he fear mongered about the flu vaccine. What exactly did that doctor say, I wonder, to make Dr. Prasad earn such a stern condemnation? Why has Dr. Prasad’s attitude shifted, even though COVID has killed more children this year than every vaccine-preventable disease combined.
If you’re against the COVID vaccine, then how would you argue with an anti-vaxxer who opposed the MMR, polio, and diphtheria vaccines? After all, the risk of those diseases for any individual child in American is super-duper low. “It really doesn’t matter“, the anti-vaxxer would say. And while these diseases are currently held at bay only by vaccines, the anti-vaxxer would be more right than someone who said COVID doesn’t really matter. COVID is the virus that is threatening American children right now. If a parent were only willing to give their baby just 1 vaccine this year, I’d suggest the COVID vaccine in a heartbeat.
What other reasonable choice is there?
“The US should suspend all vaccination in children under 18”
Additionally, I’d call Dr. Prasad a strong advocate of speaking out about vaccine-myocarditis. He opposed the initial authorization of the pediatric vaccine. Later, Dr. Prasad was so concerned about vaccinated-related myocarditis he thought last year “that the US should suspend all vaccination in children under 18 and give only one dose of vaccine to men under 25”. Imagine how much suffering was prevented because regulators with skin in the game paid this no heed. As stated above, Dr. Prasad has over dozen YouTube videos on the subject and he’s Tweeted about it constantly. He’s said things such as, “I don’t think people realize the damage continuing to push two doses in young men will do”. His name is associated with vaccine-myocarditis the way Michael Jordan is with basketball.
So why has he chosen to be such a strong advocate for something with a “super low” risk? If those advocating to keep children safe from COVID are “off their rocker”, what should be said about those who work to keep them safe from the vaccine? Does he think vaccine myocarditis is worse that death?
Dr. Prasad’s “really doesn’t matter” attitude contrasts very sharply with doctors who have real-world responsibility for sick children. Pediatricians have seen what the virus can do and they are alarmed at low vaccination rates. To pick one example amongst many, Dr. Mobeen Rathore, a Florida pediatrician said during that state’s Delta wave,
Kids do get sick. Kids do get hospitalized. Kids do get sick and go to the ICU get intubated, be on a ventilator and even be on ECMO which is a heart lung machine, sort of a last ditch effort to support these children. Unfortunately children do die. In fact many of you probably heard the news, there’s a 17-year-old who died in St. Johns County just in the last few days so I think we have to be very sure and understand that kids can get serious illness. And I can tell you that in the almost 18 months ending in June we had three deaths in our area in children. That’s one death every six months. And just in July and August we had four deaths in children so that’s two deaths a month.
I’d be surprised if there was a single pediatric ICU doctor in the US who shares Dr. Prasad’s nonchalance on this subject. Dr. Rathore, a pediatrician in an anti-vaccine state, Florida, recognizes:
This could result in some children dying.
“All children should be vaccinated,” he says. “This is the only way we’re going to get out of this morass of the pandemic”.
The advice
Now for the advice. Pay attention and read critically. Misleading framing is everywhere. When reading about COVID and children, try to be aware of how the author is framing the information they are sharing. This includes me, and I’ve worked carefully on framing in this article. Are you given raw numbers so you can form your own opinion about whether a harm is “rare”, “frequent”, “mild”, or “severe”? Or is the author trying to lead you in one direction with strategic omissions rhetorical sleight of hand? Are you being presented with an informative and nuanced perspective? Or are you instead reading the work of a sheltered contrarian doctor – and there are many – who frames data in an attempt to trick you into thinking vaccine side-effects are worse than death?

Moral outrage is not a good guide to pandemic policy reform. Vinay Prasad, please take note.
Vinay Prasad identifies some dubious problems in the government’s efforts to protect public health, and offers some questionable solutions.
Eric Kramer on June 30, 2022
Link

The American policy response to COVID left a great deal to be desired. Figuring out what went wrong and how to do better next time should be at the top of our list going forward. But getting reform right will be difficult if we succumb to the temptation to substitute the false clarity of moral outrage for the murkiness and ambiguity of careful policy analysis.
Vinay Prasad has an essay up on his substack and at the Brownstone Institute that illustrates the challenges here. I do not think all of his criticisms of COVID policy are wrong. But I do think he is led astray by moralistic wishful thinking about politics and policy. He swings back and forth between assuming everyone will agree with him about what should be done, and assuming that legalistic restrictions can magically prevent people from doing things that he thinks are wrong. His moral certainty prevents him from thinking about how to make progress in an imperfect world and how to deal constructively with people who disagree with him. More ominously, his disappointment that the world does not live up to his standards leads him to use rhetoric that encourages polarization and dissatisfaction with democratic political institutions. Prasad’s essay is worth examining closely for what it can teach us about COVID policy, and because it illuminates the dangers posed by moralistic political thinking more generally.
Three political fallacies
Let’s begin by reviewing three common political fallacies that will help us understand Prasad’s essay.
The “everyone would agree with me if they heard my arguments” fallacy
I know that X is bad, and most people would agree with me if they heard my reasoning.
As Friedrich Hayek observed in The Road to Serfdom, many people who disagree with each other believe that their views would prevail in an open debate: “…we all think that our personal order of values is not merely personal, but that in a free discussion among rational people we would convince others that ours is the right one”. Most of the people who think this are wrong all of the time, and all of them are wrong some of the time. This does not mean that debate and persuasion are unimportant, but it is a reminder of the inherent messiness of democratic politics.
The “people who are smart and good like me should be in charge” fallacy
Policy X is bad.Policymaker Y did X because Y is an idiot or a morally bad person.Therefore, the power to decide whether to do X should be taken from Y and given to policymaker Z, who is a wise and benevolent person, and who just so happens to agree with me.
There is no way to ensure that wise and good people are always in positions of power. There is no solution to the well-known political problem of “who will watch the watchers”. Hopefully voters will elect wise and good legislators and presidents, and hopefully these elected officials will put wise and good people in policymaking roles, but there is no way to ensure this. See: Trump, Donald.
This fallacy also assumes that bad policies get enacted because policymakers are bad or dumb, but sometimes bad policy gets made because decision makers are responding to democratic pressures, and if we replaced them with other policymakers the same pressures would remain.
The “there ought to be a law” fallacy
Someone did X. X was bad. Therefore, there ought to be a law against X, or X should be allowed only if the evidence for X is very strong.
Passing laws against doing bad things is, of course, sometimes justified. But limiting the discretion of government actors has costs as well as benefits. In many cases X will be good in some circumstances and bad in others. It is easy to overlook the value of flexibility when you are looking backwards at past failures. Requiring “strong evidence” for government action is far from obviously desirable, both because acting on imperfect information is sometimes justified, and because it leads to litigation and delays and forces courts to weigh in on scientific disputes. The best arrangement may be to direct policymakers to set policy based on the available evidence, to defer to their reasonable judgments, and then to try to persuade policymakers to use their power judiciously. This does not guarantee perfect decisions will be made (see the first fallacy above – persuasion often fails) but passing a law against X or requiring strong evidence is far from a magic bullet.
Vinay Prasad’s reform agenda
Now let’s review Prasad’s reform agenda.
First thing, let’s get rid of all the idiots!
Prasad begins as follows:
Just yesterday, I read that NYC public schools will remove the OUTDOOR mask mandate starting Monday. How Brave!
Let’s reflect on this for a moment. NYC school district has been requiring children wear masks OUTSIDE all this time. Years after we knew the virus almost never spreads outside. During recess when kids play, forced to wear a mask while exerting themselves. Wow!
Whoever made the policy is an idiot. No way around it. They are not fit for policymaking. They abused the power of government to coerce children (at incredibly low risk of bad outcomes) to wear a mask in a setting where the virus simply does not spread. In other words, they participated in something done in the name of public health, which actually made human beings worse off. Worse, they used coercive force to do it.
Let’s stipulate that making kids wear masks outside is unnecessary. This does not mean that the person who made this policy is “an idiot”. There may have been better reasons for the policy when it was first adopted. The problem, in this case, is that the policy remained in place longer than it should have (that is, after it became clear that outside transmission was rare).
Keeping policies in place past their “sell by” date is indeed a problem and figuring out why it happens is important. But it need not be because school administrators are “idiots”. For example, administrators may be aware that masking outside is unnecessary, but be under pressure from parents or teachers or other constituents to keep the rule in place. We live in a democracy, and public opinion matters. This is a feature of democracy, not a bug, even if sometimes it forces policymakers to make less-than-perfect decisions. Or perhaps policymakers have other more pressing problems to focus on. Or maybe there is something else going on. The point is, we know policymaking is imperfect, but to improve it we need to understand why it is imperfect and persuade those who we believe are wrong. Just calling people “idiots” is unlikely to be helpful.
Dumbing coercion down
Also, note how Prasad defines “coercion” down. In The Constitution of Liberty, Friedrich Hayek worried about giving administrators unreviewable power to tell people what to do or how to live. He especially worried about the power to single out individuals for harsh treatment. For example, Hayek worried about giving government bureaucrats the power to tell people where to work. This eliminates free choice of occupation, a fundamental right, and it is open to horrendous abuse: a system in which a bureaucrat can send you to cut trees in Siberia because you criticize the ruling party or were mean to him in grade school is not a good system.
These days, apparently, standards have changed, and making children wear masks outside is “coercive force”, even though wearing a mask is not like cutting trees in Siberia, and individual children are not being singled out for mask wearing. Defining coercion down in this way is useful if your goal is to generate maximum moral outrage. But moral outrage drives polarization, and it can distort our judgment: if X is an outrage, then surely there ought to be a law! Lo and behold…
There ought to be a law!
Post-COVID we need to seriously talk about setting restrictions. But not on people. We need to place restrictions on public health and things done in the name of public health. We cannot allow individuals who are poor at weighing risk and benefit and uncertainty to coerce human beings, disproportionately the young and powerless (waiters/ servers) to participate in interventions that have no data supporting them, for years on end.
OK, so Prasad is switching from masking students outside to closing restaurants. (I think. Maybe he believes it’s “coercive force” to make waiters wear masks.) But what is his point? It sounds like he’s saying that only people who are good at weighing costs and benefits should be allowed to impose any public health restrictions. How do we find such people? Is Prasad saying anything more than that policymakers should all agree with him about what constitutes sufficient justification for “coercive force”?
A digression on the thirst for revenge
Prasad continues:
Public health should be the subject of restrictions; a taste of its own medicine. Some of those restrictions should be placed on governments, but others on private actors who are appealing to public health. Here is what that might look like:
Note the thirst for revenge: public health needs “a taste of its own medicine”. This is common among libertarians who are outraged by COVID policy, but it’s a dangerous sentiment. Also, note how he personifies “public health”. As we will see, treating things that are not people as if they are people is not a route to clear thinking.
Magical thinking about evidence, sunset provisions, and fighting the last war
Prasad then makes some specific suggestions. Let’s look (numbering omitted):
In an emergency situation, if governments mandate or advise individual level behavioral interventions (e.g. masking), those entities should have generated robust data in 3 months (cluster RCTs) to demonstrate efficacy, or the intervention is automatically revoked. Some may argue 3 months is too short, but if it is truly a crisis warranting emergency proclamations, then you should see a signal in 3 months, and governments can expand sample size to ensure prompt results.
Prasad seems to be saying that guidance or restrictions on individual behavior can only be justified with a particular kind of evidence (RCTs), with a 3-month grace period for collecting RCT evidence.
It is far from clear that this requirement would be beneficial. The evidence taken as a whole can suggest that masking is valuable even if RCTs are not available or are inconclusive. Allowing agencies to act on non-RCT evidence with a 3-month sunset rule is not a magic bullet. It is not hard to imagine a trial of mask efficacy taking longer than 3 months to design, set up, run, and analyze. What happens if the government does a trial, but the analysis is contested, or if it does a handful of trials and they are suggestive but inconclusive? Or suppose the government does a cluster RCT of masks and the trial simply fails (it turns out the protocol was flawed, or it wasn’t followed, or the data was too noisy, or whatever). What then? Should the mask mandate be removed even if there is reasonable observational evidence for masks, or if masks seem likely to be effective given what we know about how disease is spread?
And what happens if the government just doesn’t do an RCT? Maybe a sunset rule will give government officials an incentive to do the RCTs that Prasad believes are needed. On the other hand, if the government does not do the required study, the sunset provision may end up punishing the public by eliminating a policy that is justified given the then-current imperfect state of knowledge.
Hindsight bias and the value of flexibility
Finally, it seems like Prasad is fighting the last war. He’s saying that the government in the next pandemic should do what he thinks it should have done in this pandemic, and if it tries to do something else it shouldn’t be allowed to do it. But if anything is certain, it is that the next pandemic will be different than the last pandemic. What if the next epidemic is more lethal than the current one, observational evidence suggests that masks save lives, the government fails to do an RCT, Congress is gridlocked, and a sunset provision forces the government to end mask mandates prematurely? Fighting the last war leads Prasad to undervalue administrative flexibility by directing his attention away from all the things that might happen in the future but did not happen in the past.
Deliberation is not a deus ex machina, and policy proposals need to be actual policies and apply to actual people
Prasad continues:
If a trial is positive that does not mean the policy continues forever, but must be debated (net benefit/ net harms/ tradeoffs) by the body politic.
Policy proposals need to be actual policies, and they need to apply to actual people. Deliberation is not a policy, and the “body politic” is not a person, or even a clearly identified group of people.
Here are some actual policies Prasad may have in mind when he insists on “debate” in the “body politic”. Maybe Prasad thinks administrative agencies should be required to justify emergency regulations to a court after 3 months by showing that the benefits exceed the costs, using only “robust” RCT evidence. We have already seen that regulations can be justified even if RCT evidence is lacking or inconclusive. And even if the evidence for a regulation is fairly strong, interest groups or political partisans may have an incentive to challenge the regulation in court. Requiring courts to take a “hard look” at the evidence base for regulations is highly controversial, because it leads to endless opportunities for legalistic maneuvering and forces courts to rule on questions they are not competent to evaluate. (If this is what Prasad is thinking, I would love to know which Supreme Court Justices he thinks are capable of assessing RCT evidence, and which interest groups he thinks will refrain from challenging a justified policy for private gain.)
Maybe Prasad thinks that Congress is the “body politic” and a sunset rule should be used to force Congress to debate and adopt agency regulations after 3 months. But as we have seen this is not obviously a good idea. It could easily result in the death of a good regulation due to gridlock or partisan sabotage.
Finally, Prasad may believe that the Supreme Court should require Congress to justify policies to the satisfaction of the Court by subjecting pandemic restrictions to “strict scrutiny“, rather than applying the more forgiving “rational basis” standard of review. We may be heading somewhere like this, with our emboldened conservative Justices arrogating more and more legislative power to themselves. Prasad may think this is a good idea, but to say the least he needs to argue for it, not just make grand statements about “debate” in the “body politic”.
Prasad may not have any of these actual concrete proposals in mind. As I noted above, Hayek warned in The Road to Serfdom that most of us believe that our ideas will prevail in a free exchange of ideas. Perhaps Prasad is falling into this trap. He may be just fantasizing about a perfect democracy in which free debate in the “body politic” leads everyone to magically agree with him.
Shifting authority from one decision maker to another does not ensure good decisions
In the United States, politics often involves shifting the locus of conflict from one political forum to another. You lose in Congress, you try to change state laws; you lose in the states, you go the Courts, etc. This often makes sense for people who care about an issue, but shifting decision making power does not ensure that the new policymakers are better than the old ones.
Prasad:
Private entities should be prohibited from mandating emergency drug products. Check out this tweet by my conversation partner— VPZD PODCAST— Zubin Daminia. Cal Academy is a museum in Golden Gate Park. Do they have any business nor ability to mandate boosters in adolescents? [Note: apparently the museum does not mandate boosters. Whatever. Ed.] No, it is absurd. Two senior officials with the FDA— Gruber and Krause- resigned over this decision. Paul Offit and Luciano Boro and others have been publicly critical of boosters for young people, and Cal Academy mandates it? Cal Academy is not qualified to make this decision.
The same is true for daycares and private schools that have already mandated kids vax 5 to 11. Should random private individuals be permitted to coerce vaccination under Emergency Use Authorization (EUA)? I believe restrictions must be put in place to prevent them from doing such a thing. Perhaps it should be explicit that it is illegal to coerce any medical product under EUA status. This would stop Cal Academy and private schools.
The same is true for boosters. Colleges should be prohibited from mandating medical products under the auspices of EUA. What is going on right now on college campuses is astonishing foolishness.
Prasad believes that the FDA made a mistake when it approved boosters for young people. He may be right; as he notes there was disagreement among experts on this, both in this country and internationally. But his proposed “solution” is far from obviously justified. If a vaccine booster is safe and effective and reduces infection and transmission, why shouldn’t private entities be able to mandate it, even if it is under an EUA? Of course, private schools are not experts and they may defer to experts when the experts are wrong. But there is no way to ensure that experts will always agree with Prasad, and there is no way to ensure that schools will always do what Prasad thinks they should do.
Rights are not a deus ex machina
Invoking “rights” is a form of the “there ought to be a law” fallacy. Prasad:
Hospital patients deserve a bill of rights. Prohibitions on visitation, particularly of children or older people; especially near the end of life were cruel and disgusting. Even long after PPE was adequate— into 2022— these rules continued. Patients need a bill of rights, and hospitals should face severe restrictions on their ability to ban visitors. To my knowledge the US has not— like Hong Kong— separated a baby from her parents, but our rules are unjust.
It is certainly arguable that visitation rules at hospitals should have been more lenient. Maybe patients should have a bill of rights. But what rights exactly? Will there be any exceptions or discretion? Will the same rules apply in a community hospital in rural Tennessee and a teaching hospital in Boston? Will the rules apply during a pandemic? Will they apply when hospitals are overwhelmed? One imagines there will be exceptions, especially in pandemics and other emergencies. But then it is not clear what having a “bill of rights” will accomplish.
And what about enforcement? Can a patient who gets ticked-off run to federal district court and get an emergency injunction directing the hospital to allow a visit? How many patients will be aware of this right and prepared to exercise it when their loved one is dying on a ventilator? Will there be a hearing? Will the hearing be ex parte? Will there be witnesses? Can aggrieved patients get damages? Should class actions be allowed?
I don’t know the right solution here, but it’s not obvious that what we need is more “rights” and more lawsuits. Remember that we have a non-legal option: we can focus on changing hearts and minds of public health officials and hospital administrators, rather than assuming that every bad thing in the world requires a legal solution.
Prasad continues in the same vein:
Do people have the right to return to their home country? Read this excellent article about Australians trapped in India. This is an important issue.
Arguing for less restrictive travel policy is fine. I happen to believe that Australia and New Zealand should have made more of an effort to allow people trapped abroad to return home (with appropriate quarantine upon arrival). But Prasad seems to have in mind a legal solution, a solution involving “rights”. Again, there ought to be a law. But it’s far from clear that a legal solution would be desirable.
Here is what I have said about this previously:
It is possible to argue that any limitation of basic rights is authoritarian and unacceptable. Alex Tabarrok suggests here that Australia is an authoritarian state because it has suspended the right to travel, which is a basic human right enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
The problem with this argument is that rights are not and simply cannot be absolute. The real world is messy and full of tradeoffs. Rights often conflict with each other and with the duty of government to promote the public welfare. The right to a fair trial can conflict with the right to a free press. The right to a free press can conflict with the right not to have your reputation attacked. Criminal and civil due process rights are limited in every country on earth because process is expensive, and as a result giving people lots of process conflicts with the duty of government to promote the general welfare. Every legal system in the world recognizes that rights must be limited when they conflict with each other or the general welfare. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights states clearly that the rights it enumerates – including the right to travel – can be restricted to promote the general welfare.
Of course we can argue about how the balance between different rights and the public welfare should be struck in particular cases, but to declare Australia an authoritarian state because it has restricted the right to travel is over the top. Liberal democracies can and must put reasonable limits on rights. Serious questions would indeed be raised if the right to travel was being withheld to punish enemies of the government or to burden socially disfavored groups…
Prasad is on a roll, and he continues by arguing for a “bill of rights” for students:
Who decides if schools should close? Schools are too important to permit local decision makers to close them for years on end. In the USA, this happened along partisan lines, with the most progressive cities punishing children the most. There has to be some bill of rights for kids to prevent this from happening. Schools might need to close in rare circumstances in the future, but this should be done only in extraordinary times, and no one can justify closing schools only in Democratic cities. Kids need a real champion, and it is not the AAP.
I am sympathetic to arguments that school closures lasted much too long. But not everyone agreed. The question is what those of us who favored earlier opening of schools should do.
Prasad as usual reaches for a legal solution. But what is his proposal? Is he proposing an amendment to the Constitution (“bill of rights for kids”)? Or does he think that our national Congress should pass a law regulating local school policies concerning public health? Or does he think we need some conservative judicial activism here? All of these proposals have serious drawbacks, it is not obvious that any of them would be an improvement over just muddling through and letting people bitch and moan in standard democratic fashion. Prasad can bitch and moan too. He should just stop pretending that there is some deus ex machina legal solution that will magically ensure that only policies he likes will be adopted.
And obviously “kids need a real champion” is not a policy, it’s just magical thinking. Prasad is tacitly imagining a world in which some all-powerful policymaker exists who – mirabile dictu! – just so happens to agree with him.
Moral outrage, legalistic fantasies, and distrust
Prasad concludes as follows:
These are just a few examples of where governments or institutions have overreached in the name of public health, but there are many more. Post Covid, the group that needs to face the strongest restrictions is public health itself. We must carefully remove the power we have granted public health, which has often been misused.
Yes, governments have overreached in some ways in response to COVID. Prasad’s impulse is to respond by reducing the ability of the government to act. But many of the worst COVID policy failures were failures of the government to act: to invest enough in the development and production of vaccines and treatments, to produce enough high-quality masks, to do enough testing and surveillance, to authorize first-doses-first and partial doses in the spring of 2021, etc. It is far from obvious that placing new restrictions on government is the right orientation for reformers.
Prasad has strong views about policy failures during the COVID epidemic and he is angry at his public health colleagues. But even if he is right about what the main policy failures were – a point which could certainly be disputed – just saying we need “restrictions” on “public health” is not a serious proposal. Instead, it’s the kind of error people make when they let moral outrage substitute for careful policy analysis, when they focus on past mistakes and fantasize about a world in which everyone agrees with them about what should be done, and when they fail to think carefully about the very real limitations of democratic government and of legalistic solutions to perceived problems.
Finally, Prasad is not only concerned about past failures, he is deliberately fanning the flames of moral outrage. He does this by making morally inflammatory charges (“coercive force”) and by pretending that the right thing to do was abundantly clear to any smart and decent person. This is the formula for polarization and distrust: if policymakers do things that any idiot can see are despotic, how can we trust them? And it is polarization and distrust above all else that will make it hard for us to do better in the next pandemic.

Dr. Vinay Prasad Pretends to Admit Error: I Was Optimistic That Vaccination Would Halt the Spread of the Virus—I Was Wrong. 
While admitting error is never easy and should always be applauded, the first step is to honestly admit error.
Jonathan Howard on May 11, 2024
Link

I was optimistic that vaccination would halt the spread of the virus—I was wrong.
Dr. Vinay Prasad is a pro-infection, anti-vaccine doctor who has spread copious misinformation about measures to limit COVID, particularly with regards to children. He’s treated vaccine side effects as a fate worse than death, and vaccines experts say his musings on the topic “are based on a litany of false premises and cherry picked information.” A lot of people rightfully don’t trust him, and having heard what he’s said, they don’t want to hear any more.
Yet, in an article from October 2023 titled Why Was My Talk at a Medical Conference Canceled?, Dr. Prasad was eager to portray himself as someone who invites criticism, despite blocking every critic on social media. There’s even a hashtag- #BlockedByVinay. However, Dr. Prasad said that he was a scientist who could change his mind and admit error. He wrote:
I invite my critics to disagree with me on any of my positions and to change my mind. Like any good scientist, I have changed my mind over the course of Covid… I was optimistic that vaccination would halt the spread of the virus—I was wrong.
Though transmission was not an outcome in the randomized-controlled trials (RCTs) of the vaccines, many people were optimistic that they would halt the spread of the virus in early 2021. Indeed, that’s exactly what I said in April 2021:
I’m very very optimistic vaccines will cut transmission of disease. I’m not certain of it. This is why I wear a mask still in public and when treating covid patients.
There’s an infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone.
However, Dr. Prasad did not share my cautious optimism. He sounded quite differently at the time. Although the vaccines and virus were both brand new, he expressed great confidence that vaccines would tame the pandemic and perfectly protect vulnerable people. For example, on February 16, 2021 he said:
We know the vaccine is 100% effective against protecting against bad outcomes for grandparent. (Author note: this was false at the time).
Then on May 13, 2021 he said:
For somebody who’s already been fully vaccinated, they can wear the mask out of solidarity or in a symbolic sense, but their wearing a mask indoors is not benefiting anyone else. There’s an infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone.
However, I find the exchange below to be the most interesting.
It is highly likely that receipt of vaccination and a 14-day asymptomatic period afterward results in both personal protection and reduced likelihood of ongoing viral propagation.
Let’s be clear what was happened here. Dr. Prasad scolded the “media” and used a laughing emoji to mock those who expressed “bizarre pessimism” that vaccines slowed transmission. When Dr. Jeremy Faust asked for “actual data before guessing”, Dr. Prasad said this was “irrationally pessimistic to say ‘I don’t know’” because the pre-test probability was exceedingly high that a vaccine that prevented SARS-CoV-2 infection would also slow SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Dr. Prasad then linked to an article of his from January 2021, just one month after vaccine campaigns started, titled Throw Away Your Mask After COVID Vaccination? in which he said:
The truth is I wear a cloth mask and I quite like it.
However, even though he liked his cloth mask, he felt vaccines rendered it unnecessary. He said:
The efficacy of the two mRNA vaccines is superb, offering 95% reduction in the rate of acquisition of symptomatic COVID-19 in randomized trials. That is a remarkable result. But the key statistic here is one step beyond the vaccine efficacy. If you get two doses of the vaccine, and if you remain asymptomatic 14 days after the second dose, what is the probability you will develop COVID-19? For Moderna, the answer is there is a 99.92% chance that you won’t….
That risk is in part driven by symptomatic infections which are exceedingly rare after second doses. Risk of spreading is diminished by the brisk immune response that occurs after symptomatic infection once someone is vaccinated… In short, it is highly likely that receipt of vaccination and a 14-day asymptomatic period afterward results in both personal protection and reduced likelihood of ongoing viral propagation…
People need to know that there is light at the end of the tunnel because there is.
Of course, Dr. Prasad didn’t present any actual data that the vaccines impacted transmission, just an argument that because the vaccine prevented SARS-CoV-2 infection, it was therefore highly-likely that it would reduce transmission. Although the vaccine RCTs didn’t assess transmission, he nonetheless felt justified making a reasonable inference. He said in essence, “Sure, we don’t have RCT-level evidence, but it’s OK so use some common sense.”
Fair enough.
Indeed, it was highly likely that if a vaccine prevented SARS-CoV-2 infections, it would also limit the spread of SARS-CoV-2. Unlike most of his pandemic punditry, Dr. Prasad wasn’t entirely wrong here. Although a vaccinated person obviously doesn’t have an “infinitesimally low probability” of transmitting the virus as Dr. Prasad claimed, the vaccine’s impact on transmission has never been zero. It’s always been safer to be around vaccinated rather than unvaccinated people. Of course, everything we know about this comes from observational studies, not RCTs.
However, it was also reasonable for Dr. Faust and myself to take a medically conservative approach in early 2021. Like Dr. Prasad, we were very confident the vaccine slowed transmission. We all agreed that it was OK to use common sense, that we didn’t need an RCT to believe reasonable things. But given what we’d seen the virus do in its first year and that the vaccines were brand new, we also didn’t want to spike the football too early. It wasn’t wrong to wait for more time and actual data to emerge before joining Dr. Prasad in declaring the vaccines were a near-perfect panacea against severe disease and viral transmission.
We all know what happened next.
The company never ran an adequately powered RCT
The evidence supporting the pediatric vaccine today is much more robust than the “evidence” that vaccines prevented transmission in January 2021.
There were 6 successful RCTs of the pediatric COVID vaccine involving nearly 25,000 children. One of them found “the observed vaccine efficacy was 100%.” Many observational studies have since shown its benefit, particularly at preventing rare, but grave outcomes. Yet, Dr. Prasad rejects it all. He has an entirely different standard of evidence.
Read this article
Indeed, Dr. Prasad is not willing to say that was highly likely that if a vaccine prevented SARS-CoV-2 infections in children, it would also limit rare, but grave outcomes from SARS-CoV-2. He claims this is an absurd position, and is full of vitriol for those who believe it, calling them “idiots“. He no longer says it’s “irrationally pessimistic to say ‘I don’t know’“. The pre-test probability gets thrown in the trash.
Instead, Dr. Prasad, who has never advanced an actual RCT as far as I know, claims the “the company never ran an adequately powered RCT”. For Dr. Prasad, the RCTs were too small and the observational studies, at least those that support the, vaccine are all fatally “confounded”. He casually dismisses literally every study that supports the pediatric COVID vaccine- several dozen of them– and claims we have no idea whether or not it kept kids safe and out of the hospital.
So what changed? Why was Dr. Prasad willing to make a reasonable inference when it came to the vaccine’s impact on transmission, but not on its ability to limit severe disease in children. Did he completely and abruptly revamp his approach to evaluating medical evidence?
Of course not.
In early 2021, Dr. Prasad wanted vaccines to stop the pandemic and so he did not require an RCT, or any data at all, before claiming they prevented transmission. In contrast, Dr. Prasad strenuously argued that unvaccinated children should contract COVID, even months before there was a pediatric COVID vaccine, and so he does not want the vaccine to benefit children. That would force him to confront an unpleasant thought- doctors’ efforts to purposefully infect unvaccinated children had tragic consequences for some of them.
Read about Kennedy Stonum
To avoid this discomfort, not only does Dr. Prasad have an entirely different standard of evidence for pediatric vaccines, he also has an impossibly high standard. He claims that only an RCT of many thousands of children, which would have to be repeated from scratch for every variant or tweak to the vaccine, could demonstrate its value. Of course, by the time such a massive RCT could be completed, Dr. Prasad would then claim it was obsolete. Though Dr. Prasad said that he “invites critics to disagree with me on any of my positions and to change my mind“, like the old anti-vaxx gimmick of demanding an RCT of the entire vaccine schedule, he’s conveniently set it up so that the only evidence that could change his mind is unobtainable evidence.
More than this, Dr. Prasad makes an additional leap and claims that absent pristine evidence from massive RCTs, the default should be not use the vaccine and to let unvaccinated children contract a potentially fatal virus, the exact opposite of it’s “irrationally pessimistic to say ‘I don’t know’“. He is much more concerned by the possibility of a child receiving a vaccine they don’t need, than by the possibility of a child missing out on a vaccine they do need.
Of course, when observational studies, even a VAERS dumpster dive, purport to show the vaccine’s imperfections, Dr. Prasad lauds them as a “bombshell.” Again, this is because Dr. Prasad accepts or rejects studies based on their results, not their methods, and he wants these studies to be true.
It was abundantly clear that the vaccines trials did not include transmission as a primary or secondary endpoint. And thus could not comment.
Today, Dr. Prasad, a master of creating medical reversals, saying, “it was abundantly clear that the vaccines trials did not include transmission as a primary or secondary endpoint. And thus could not comment,” he calls for investigations into those this in 2021. So the next time he merely “calls for” an RCT of this or that, ask yourself if he’s applying his standards of evidence consistently, or if he’s again saying “RCTs for thee, but not for me” because his goal is minimize COVID and to sow mistrust, not advance actual medical research.
And while admitting error is never easy and should always be applauded, the first step is to honestly admit error. Dr. Prasad didn’t express optimism that the vaccine would halt the spread of the virus, he expressed certainty. If Dr. Prasad ever chooses to “admit” error again, I suggest he share this Tweet from February 18, 2021:
If Dr. Prasad has the integrity to actually share his own words, his readers will know exactly what he was wrong about. They will also know that for the past three years he’s said anyone who disagreed with his COVID minimization was “completely off, and just another squeeze of fear.”
Nearly 700,000 Americans have since died of COVID since Dr. Prasad said that. Sadly, these “fear mongers” were right much more often than him.
And today, many of them don’t want to hear Dr. Prasad, not because they’re afraid of his oh-so controversial opinions, but rather because they see no value in being subjected to his mocking misinformation. They know he has inconsistent and contradictory standards of evidence based on what he does and does not want to be true. They’d rather listen to someone who is willing to adjust their ideology to match the data, rather than to someone who transparently massages the data to suit his ideology.
Can you blame them?

Dr. Vinay Prasad Opposed The Pediatric COVID Vaccine Before There Was A Pediatric COVID Vaccine
Dr. Vinay Prasad started treating vaccine side effects as a fate worse than death in January 2021, before there was a COVID vaccine for children.
Jonathan Howard on August 25, 2024
Link

Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?
As readers of SBM know, Dr. Vinay Prasad has advocated for the mass infection of unvaccinated children to theoretically shield more vulnerable adults. He’s also treated rare, usually mild, vaccine side effects, even mere abnormal lab values in kids who feel fine, with more gravitas than literal death from COVID.
Abnormal lab values are treated with more gravitas than dead children
Even when the Delta wave was generating headlines such as Every Day, Hundreds of Kids Are Getting Hospitalized With Covid-19, Dr. Prasad casually dismissed the COVID’s impact on children. Watch the video below and compare how he discussed children hospitalized with COVID versus how he discussed “subclinical myocarditis”. Actual harms were brushed off, while theoretical harms were treated very seriously. There was never a moment when Dr. Prasad seriously acknowledged that COVID hurt some children. In fact, he published his pro-infection essay, Should We Let Children Catch Omicron? in February 2022, after the Omicron variant ripped through the pediatric population, generating headlines such as A Fifth of All US Child Covid Deaths Occurred During Omicron Surge.
Dr. Prasad claims that he arrives at his conclusions because he follows the evidence, data, and the science.
Theoretical harms from the vaccine are treated more seriously than real harms from COVID
If the epidemic is abating
However, many people who claim to follow the evidence, data, and the science had their minds made up about the COVID vaccine before there was a COVID vaccine. According to one study:
Major anti-vaccine groups were sowing seeds of doubt on Facebook weeks before the US government launched its vaccine development program ‘Operation Warp Speed’. Early anti-vaccine misinformation campaigns outpaced public health messaging and hampered the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines.
Like them, Dr. Prasad began his crusade against the pediatric COVID vaccine before there was a pediatric COVID vaccine. The data from the randomized-controlled trial (RCT) in adolescents was released in March 2021 via a company press release. This study was published in the NEJM in May 2021, and all 16 COVID cases occurred in the placebo group.
Yet, before this data was available, Dr. Prasad had strong thoughts on the matter. He laid out his thoughts in a Twitter thread from January 2021. He said:
Let me be perfectly clear: children DO NOT NEED a sars-cov-2 vaccine before they are permitted to return to normal activities, such as school and visiting loved ones. Any claims to the contrary are demoralizing and counter to common sense and medicine…
The virus meanwhile, is *thank god* not that bad for most healthy kids, on par with seasonal influenza. Evern the rate of mail-inflammatory syndrome is low.–although you wouldn’t know that from the breathless news coverage and tweets.
Third, who even says the vaccine will offer a favorable risk benefit profile in kids? If the vaccine offers AEs similar to pfizer and moderna dose 2 in adults, I think it will be a huge debate if childhood vaccination is indicated.
If the epidemic is abating, how can you justify giving 100 kids those AEs so that perhaps 1 or 2 or even 3 will be spared a case of Covid that might be as mild as the AEs themselves.
One has to think of the cumulative days a kid is resting in bed, vaccination might outweigh the benefits in low age. Moreover, as death is feelingly rare in kids, as is MISC, are we going to power the trials for this outcome. I doubt we will say anything conclusive…
One adults, particularly older adults are vaccinated, and if *god willing* there is not vaccine escape, covid19 is over. We are going back to normal.
Let me be perfectly clear: children DO NOT NEED a sars-cov-2 vaccine before they are permitted to return to normal activities, such as school and visiting loved ones.Any claims to the contrary are demoralizing and counter to common sense and medicineHere is why [thread]
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) January 13, 2021
Dr. Prasda then formalized his thoughts in an essay the next month titled Kids Don’t Need Covid-19 Vaccines to Return to School. He argued that children were less likely to get COVID. He said:
Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, than adults.
Dr. Prasad spread fake statistics- the vaccine might save one life for every 1 million kids who get it– and even though COVID had killed over 200 children by that point in the pandemic and the flu just one child, Dr. Prasad said:
For them it is a respiratory pathogen with a rate of harm that is comparable to other, annual respiratory pathogens like influenza.
Though Dr. Prasad refused to inform his readers about COVID’s non-fatal harms to children, he wasn’t so nonchalant about the vaccine. He started planting seeds of doubt about its value, speculating it would cause “severe headaches requiring analgesics and interfering with daily living” and a fever lasting “for more than a day.” Even at this early date, Dr. Prasad was treating vaccine side effects as more concerning than death from COVID.
In a podcast with Dr. Zubin Damania (ZDoggMD) from that month, Dr. Prasad rightly acknowledged that there was no data about the pediatric COVID vaccine. However, this lack of data didn’t stop him from claiming the vaccine would cause more harm than good. He repeated his false claim that COVID only killed 1 in a million children and expressed great concern about post-vaccination fevers and muscle aches. While COVID’s non-fatal harms were again neglected, Dr. Prasad felt parents should take unpleasant, though mundane vaccine side-effects very seriously.
“We don’t have the data yet.”
Omicron and Children: Pediatric Hospitals in Parts of U.S. Filling Up Fast
Though Dr. Prasad thought that vaccinating adults would protect children and obviate the need to vaccinate them in the spring of 2021, things didn’t turn out that way. Yet, he hasn’t altered his opinions a bit. Even though babies aren’t born with natural immunity, Dr. Prasad remains as committed as ever to the mass infection of unvaccinated children. Successful RCTs of the pediatric vaccine didn’t alter his opinion. Dozens of observational studies showing the vaccine limited rare, but grave harms in children didn’t alter his opinion. Variants that spiked the pediatric death toll and filled up pediatric hospitals didn’t alter his opinion.
Dr. Prasad has never deviated from the position he took in January 2021, when there was no data about the pediatric COVID vaccine and he thought COVID was going away. Remember this the next time he claims to be following the evidence, data, and the science.

A Simple Challenge For Drs. Vinay Prasad and Tracy Hoeg: Denounce Robert Kennedy Jr. For Promoting The Movie Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill
If Drs. Vinay Prasad and Tracy Hoeg want to prove they actually care about routine vaccines, they can do what the should have done a long time ago and openly and unequivocally denounce Mr. Kennedy and his fire hose of anti-vaxx disinformation.
Jonathan Howard on September 20, 2024
Link
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases
In several previous articles, I argued that providing parents with accurate information about the pediatric COVID vaccine would boost confidence in all vaccines. Other doctors disagreed. Though they provided zero evidence, they felt that only way to protect routine vaccination, was to to let unvaccinated children repeatedly contract SARS-CoV-2. In their article The CDC Is Breaking Trust in Childhood Vaccination, Drs. Leslie Bienen and Tracy Høeg wrote that:
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases…The general trust deficit is more troubling than skepticism toward this particular vaccine, because it could conceivably drive down uptake of other childhood vaccines that we know are more important to children’s health, such as those against measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
In a nearly identical article titled Covid Vaccines Shouldn’t Be ‘Routine’ for Kids Dr. Vinay Prasad fretted that:
The CDC’s latest guidelines could wind up lowering vaccination rates for truly dangerous diseases, like polio and measles.
To be clear, no American child has died of polio in my lifetime and measles last killed American children, 9 of them, in 1991. COVID meanwhile killed over 150 children in January 2021 alone. Neither Drs. Prasad nor Hoeg treated children hospitalized with COVID, and it’s worthwhile to listen to pediatricians who did. An article from September 2021 titled Every Day, Hundreds of Kids Are Getting Hospitalized With Covid-19 said:
“What we’re seeing now is extremely concerning,” said Dr. Edith Bracho-Sanchez, associate professor of pediatrics at Columbia University Irving Medical Center. “This virus is really going for the people who are not vaccinated. And among those people are children who don’t qualify for the vaccine and children and teens who qualify but are choosing not to get it.”
Another article from that month titled UF Health Medical Leaders Express Concern Over Increased Rate of COVID Child Deaths, said:
Dr. Mobeen Rathore, a leading pediatrician dealing with infectious disease at both UF Health and Wolfson Children’s Hospital, confirmed during Tuesday’s call that the death of a teen in St. Johns County recently was a result of COVID. And he said some kids are getting very sick. As of Tuesday, there are 14 kids at Wolfson being treated for COVID with five in the ICU. Three new child cases were admitted to the hospital on Monday.
“Kids do get sick. Kids do get hospitalized. Kids do get sick and go to the ICU get intubated, be on a ventilator and even be on ECMO which is a heart lung machine, sort of a last ditch effort to support these children. Unfortunately children do die. In fact many of you probably heard the news, there’s a 17-year-old who died in St. Johns County just in the last few days so I think we have to be very sure and understand that kids can get serious illness. And I can tell you that in the almost 18 months ending in June we had three deaths in our area in children. That’s one death every six months. And just in July and August we had four deaths in children so that’s two deaths a month.”
Rathore said in most cases, children who become sick with COVID do recover, both those who end up in the ICU are having severe problems with both their hearts and lungs. They’re damaged by the virus, and as we have learned, some don’t survive.
“Protecting our children is the most important thing we can do,” Rathore said. “I hope the future generations remember us as people who protected their children and not a group of people who put their children at risk.”
COVID hospitalized 234,000 children so far, and according to the AAP:
The largest peak was in winter 2022 during the omicron surge, with 6,527 child hospitalizations the week of Jan. 15.
Nonetheless, for the express purpose of encouraging apathy about SARS-COV-2, the virus that hospitalized 6,527 children in one week, Dr. Prasad voiced great concern about polio and measles, which infected 339 Americans combined, killing none of them, during that time period. Dr. Prasad’s article continued:
In an effort to encourage Covid-19 vaccination, the CDC may wind up lowering vaccination rates for polio and measles. Why? Because by adding Covid-19 shots to the schedule, the CDC is tacitly implying that this new vaccine is as important to kids as the combination MMR one. This is absolutely false. Measles can be a devastating childhood illness, but vaccination provides durable, sterilizing immunity. When vaccination rates are high, measles outbreaks can be averted.
Elsewhere Dr. Prasad’s said:
A singular focus on COVID and pushing covid shots in kids, who mostly had covid (based on weak evidence/ w low yield <5% parents <5) has resulted in neglect for routine childhood immunization, which is disastrous. Many of us saw this coming.
Dr. Prasad was right about measles. However, COVID can also be a devastating childhood illness, as anyone who has internet access knows.
In these articles and Tweets, Drs. Prasad and Hoeg expressed great concern about the potential return of measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib). They warned that these diseases could be dangerous, and said that the vaccine against them are safe and effective. I completely agree.
However, Drs. Prasad and Hoeg claimed the COVID vaccine stood in the way of routine vaccination, and the CDC was to blame for suggesting it. According to Drs. Prasad and Hoeg, anyone who really wanted to protect children against polio and measles wouldn’t just advocate for those vaccines. Rather, they would advocate for the mass infection of unvaccinated children with SARS-CoV-2. In their telling, Drs. Prasad and Hoeg are the real vaccine-champions, while doctors who advocate for the pediatric COVID vaccine are “zealots”, indifferent to measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
Polio and measles matter so much, we need to let unvaccinated children contract COVID.
Since the pandemic, vaccine hesitancy over the mRNA “jab” spread to other vaccines
In my discussion of these sentiments, I argued the COVID vaccine wasn’t in competition with other vaccines any more than eating healthy is in competition with exercise. There is no reason children cannot receive the polio, measles, and COVID vaccines. I also noted that arguments against the COVID vaccine perfectly paralleled anti-vaccine arguments against other vaccines. Much of my writing has been devoted to showing the identical language used by “old school” and “new school” anti-vaccine doctors. By spreading misinformation about the COVID vaccine and deliberately fostering mistrust in those who suggest it, these “new school” anti-vaccine doctors are actively undermine confidence in all vaccines. They don’t seem to care at all.
The facts on the ground support the commonsense notion that misinformation about COVID vaccines invariably seeps into other vaccines. A recent report by KFF called, Vaccine Misinformation Spreads as Children Head Back to School said:
This edition highlights vaccine hesitancy and misinformation around MMR (measles, mumps, and rubella) vaccines as children return to school and measles cases resurge in parts of the U.S. We also examine emerging narratives around COVID-19 vaccine misinformation following the FDA approval of COVID-19 boosters and false claims linking mpox to the vaccines. Additionally, a review of recent research explores strategies to combat MMR vaccine hesitancy…
As students return to school, state health departments have urged families to make sure their children are up to date on recommended vaccinations. Without these immunizations, children risk contracting preventable diseases such as measles, which has seen a resurgence in several states. However, a KFF analysis highlights that routine immunization rates for kindergarteners have not returned to pre-pandemic levels, in part due to vaccine hesitancy fueled by misinformation and partisan politics. Persistent false claims include the debunked link between vaccines and autism, which has falsely led some to believe that vaccines are more harmful than the diseases they prevent. These claims downplay the severity of measles and dismiss it as rare or harmless. They also commonly suggest delaying or skipping vaccines for children to avoid unfounded risks, despite the CDC’s evidence-based schedule. These misleading narratives erode public confidence in vaccines, fueling larger and faster outbreaks.
Again, it’s worthwhile to listen pediatricians. They are vastly more trustworthy than social media stars with a political agenda. According to recent article titled Pediatricians ‘Exhausted’ as Vaccinations Drop in DeSantis’ Florida:
The vaccination rate of Florida kindergarteners has fallen to 90.6%, the lowest in over a decade, and concerned pediatricians say they are exhausted trying to combat anti-vax information – including from the state government. “It’s gotten difficult to manage,” said Dr. Lisa Gwynn, a Miami pediatrician and medical director for a mobile clinic that serves uninsured children…Since the pandemic, vaccine hesitancy over the mRNA “jab” spread to other vaccines, pediatricians say, who add that it’s becoming difficult to practice in the state.
That link leads to the minutes of a Florida pediatric society which said:
Dr. Mirza said that the drop in immunization rates is appalling and creates problems for the residency program when assigning residents for their primary care experiences advocacy. She wished that those at the State government level had an opportunity to visit a developing could see polio or see someone with SSPE because they had measles as a child, to really understand the power of vaccination.
Dr. Mirza is absolutely right, and Florida has already helped spread measles this year, as detailed in the article Measles Spread to at Least 3 Other States After Trips to Florida.
Florida has always been “affirmatively against” COVID vaccines for children, and its Surgeon General is anti-vaxx to the core, as detailed recently by Dr. David Gorski. If Drs. Prasad and Hoeg were right, then Florida’s measles and polio vaccine rates would be just fine, and concerned pediatricians wouldn’t be saying they are exhausted trying to combat anti-vaxx information – including from the state government. Meanwhile, I can’t recall any pediatrician saying “families in my practice were eager to vaccinate their kid against measles, right up until the moment I provided accurate information about the COVID vaccine.”
The UK also provides a similar cautionary example. They too were slow to vaccinate children, with some members of the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation suggesting that “natural infection in children could have substantial long-term benefits on COVID-19 in the UK”. Drs. Prasad and Hoeg felt this was the right decision, however the UK was rewarded with headlines such as Children Drive Britain’s Longest-Running Covid Surge in 2021. The UK did not foster a culture of vaccinating children against viruses that can harm them, and today the headlines read Child Dies of Measles and Almost 2,500 People Infected. Again, this would not be happening if Drs. Prasad and Hoeg were right.
However, Drs. Prasad and Hoeg weren’t just totally wrong about how to protect routine childhood vaccines, they were also phony and disingenuous regarding their concern about them. They feigned concern about measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib) to portray themselves doctors who sincerely care about vaccines. If measles returns, it will be the fault of people like me, not them. They warned us- “many of us saw this coming.”
Despite their professed concern about these diseases, Drs. Prasad and Hoeg weren’t vaccine-advocates in before the pandemic, and no one seriously believed they developed a sudden, genuine concern about them for a couple months in 2022. Everyone knew they were just grasping for more silly reasons to let unvaccinated children repeatedly contract COVID. This was their obvious goal, and they produced an overwhelming amount of material encouraging pediatric COVID infections, even before there was a pediatric COVID vaccine. This was genuine and deeply held belief.
In contrast, they never mentioned routine vaccines unless they were dunking on the pediatric COVID vaccine. Dr. Hoeg only mentioned measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib) when she was dunking on the pediatric COVID vaccine. Dr. Prasad only wrote “Measles can be a devastating childhood illness, but vaccination provides durable, sterilizing immunity” when he was dunking on the pediatric COVID vaccine. Indeed, although routine vaccines are under assault today, they make no effort to defend them. Instead of sounding the alarm bell, they speak positively about natural immunity, speculating that viruses might prevent cancer and autoimmune disease, which is exactly what anti-vaccine doctors spoke said measles before the pandemic.
My friend @RobertKennedyJr
Another obvious indication of their insincerity was that Drs. Prasad and Hoeg praised Robert Kennedy Jr. on multiple occasions. My previous article on the pathetic phenomenon of doctors sanewashing Mr. Kennedy discussed this in depth, but it’s worth repeating two key points.
First, the same doctors who were very concerned about the impact of the COVID vaccine on routine vaccination, had zero concern about Mr. Kennedy’s impact on routine vaccination. In fact, they complimented and legitimized him. Sure, they “sometimes disagree” with him, but in their telling, Mr. Kennedy is basically a reasonable guy who makes valid points and whose judgment we should trust.
Since Dr. Hoeg wants to know what she got wrong, I would say she is wrong to “like” someone whose anti-vaccine disinformation led to 83 measles deaths in Samoa, most of them children. I am friends with people who strive to provide accurate information about viruses and vaccines. They haven’t made millions of dollars lying about vaccines, and so they don’t have the blood of children on their hands.
Like Dr. Hoeg, Dr. Prasad was also eager to sanewash Mr. Kennedy. If you have not done so already, watch this video of Dr. Prasad saying Mr. Kennedy was right about his “core concern”, which was about the “corrupting influence of money”, while disparaging vaccine-hero Dr. Peter Hotez.
This was a theme. Dr. Prasad often mocked vaccine-advocates, calling them “idiots” and claiming they are guilty of “malpractice“, while using aggressive wresting metaphors to praise and elevate Mr. Kennedy, who takes testosterone and poses shirtless.
Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill
The second thing to remember is that Mr. Kennedy is a dishonest and deluded anti-vaxxer. His organization recently produced and is now promoting the movie Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill, to pick one example amongst many. He is doing this at a time when measles is poised to make comeback and confidence in vaccines is dropping, especially in the MAGA demographic Mr. Kennedy now loudly endorses. According to a survey by KFF:
Republicans and Republican-leaning independents who support the MAGA movement are less likely than their non-MAGA counterparts to express confidence in the safety of COVID-19 vaccines (29% vs. 44%), respiratory syncytial virus, or RSV, vaccines (41% vs. 61%), and flu vaccines (53% vs. 74%).
Though I confess I haven’t and won’t see this Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill, it’s obviously the rankest, vilest anti-vaxx propaganda, featuring “Deadly protocols. Tragic outcomes. Powerful testimonies“. Mr. Kennedy has been deliberately lying about vaccines for decades. He then lies about lying. As Dr. Paul Offit said:
What, exactly, has Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. accomplished? Using the platform of a famous name, he has chosen to lie about vaccines and vaccine safety, no doubt putting children in harm’s way.
Mr. Kennedy is more dangerous than ever as described by the article Alarm Grows Over Possible RFK Jr. Role at HHS if Trump Wins. However, despite their professed concern about routine vaccinations, this is who Drs. Prasad and Hoeg befriend and publicly promote.
“RFK Jr would flatten most public health experts in debate”
A COVID Silver Lining? More Parents Than Ever Questioning ‘Routine’ Childhood Vaccines.
For nearly 15 years, I have been arguing that measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib) are dangerous and the vaccines against them vital. Myself and many others have been warning about the dangers of the anti-vaccine movement for a long time. Although I doubt he knows who I am, I am very familiar with Mr. Kennedy and his tactics. I know how valuable it is for him to have credentialed “pro-vaccine” doctors repeating his talking points and elevating his reputation.
Despite our differences, Mr. Kennedy and I both grasp something Drs. Prasad and Hoeg do not- confidence in the COVID vaccine goes hand-in-hand with confidence in routine vaccines. In fact, Mr. Kennedy published the article A COVID Silver Lining? More Parents Than Ever Questioning ‘Routine’ Childhood Vaccines, which said:
Children and teen vaccination rates began plummeting with the onset of the pandemic, and as concerns surfaced around the safety of COVID-19 vaccines, some parents also began questioning the need for the long list of other vaccines recommended by public health officials…
In the U.S., children’s and teen’s vaccination rates plummeted dramatically, falling that year by as much as 91% depending on the age group, including a noticeably lower uptake of diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis vaccines (DTaP or DTP), meningitis shots and human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines.
I never thought I’d say this about an article on Mr. Kennedy’s site, but this isn’t wrong. I find this terrifying. Mr. Kennedy, however, senses an opportunity. He is doing all he can to leverage distrust of COVID vaccines to destroy confidence in all vaccines. That’s the purpose of Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill. Mr. Kennedy already has a body count, and he’s not satisfied yet.
Beyond their harm to vaccines, paranoid, hateful movies like Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill are dangerous for another reason. They are why vaccine-advocates like Dr. Hotez get antisemitic death threats and stalked at home by enraged anti-vaxxers. Yet, instead of bemoaning the lack of civil discourse as he did in April 2020 when defending the Dr. John Ioannidis’ misinformation, Dr. Prasad is eager to pour fuel on that fire, likening public health to Nazism and suggesting that Dr. Hotez’s support for mitigation measures means he was indifferent to child sexual abuse. Despite writing that neglect for routine childhood immunization would be disastrous, this is how Dr. Prasad treats a doctor who has dedicated his life and taken great personal risk to defend routine childhood immunization.
Measles can be a devastating childhood illness, but vaccination provides durable, sterilizing immunity
Although Drs. Prasad and Hoeg claimed to be very concerned about measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib), it’s obvious they couldn’t care less about these diseases. Their “concern” was just a performance, just more bad faith engagement, just another sad example of doctors treating the pandemic as spectacle. They just wanted another excuse to dunk on the pediatric COVID vaccine.
If Drs. Prasad and Hoeg want to prove they actually care about routine vaccines, they can do what they should have done a long time ago and openly and unequivocally denounce Mr. Kennedy and his fire hose of repulsive anti-vaxx disinformation. They can remind people that measles can be a devastating childhood illness, but vaccination provides durable, sterilizing immunity. They can tell their audience to completely reject anyone, including Mr. Kennedy, who spreads dangerous disinformation about routine childhood immunizations. They can do all this without trashing the COVID vaccine or praising Mr. Kennedy for being right about his “core concern”, which has little to do with money, and everything to do with leaving children vulnerable to measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
And this is the easiest challenge imaginable. It’s like dunking on a hoop that’s fallen on the ground, especially for doctors who publicly declared themselves to be very concerned about the fate of routine childhood immunization. As a doctor who actually who cares about vaccines, I will never turn down an opportunity to advocate for vaccines or repudiate Mr. Kennedy. Anyone can contact me anytime for a quote. He’s more dangerous now than ever, and I’ll add, many of us saw this coming.
Presently, Drs. Prasad’s and Hoeg’s comments on Mr. Kennedy send a clear message- they don’t care at all about his odious anti-vaxx disinformation. Any doctor who says nothing when Mr. Kennedy positively amplifies their voice, is totally indifferent to the fate of routine childhood immunization. Any doctor who isn’t willing to clearly condemn and disavow the most prominent and influential anti-vaxxer in the U.S., obviously does not care a bit about preventing measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
And if you’re a doctor who has repeatedly praised Mr. Kennedy, but you’re afraid that honestly criticizing him would damage your brand and repel your paying customers, I hope you reflect on the choices you made that to led your destination. This is who you are now- a doctor who pretends to care about vaccines while refusing to bluntly condemn the man behind Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill.
Is this really who you wanted to be?

Making Up Reasons to Let Unvaccinated Kids Get COVID: Pediatricians Will Run Out of Time and Measles Will Return
Doctors who claimed that only enormous RCTs for every variant could demonstrate the COVID vaccine’s benefits, were fine just casually inventing reasons not to use it.
Jonathan Howard on July 26, 2024
Link

Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2. Most kids already had COVID-19.
Dr. Vinay Prasad is very good at coming up with very bad reasons as to why unvaccinated children should contract COVID. In his essay Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?, published when COVID was sending nearly 1,000 children to the hospital every day, Dr. Prasad argued that infected children should be used as human shields to protect more vulnerable adults. He said it was “natural and healthy” for children to get sick, and that we should accept that COVID will kill some of them “as a matter of course“. Elsewhere, he treated theoretical vaccine harms, even abnormal lab values, more seriously than actual COVID harms.
In a previous article, I discussed how he used two opposite data points to reach the same conclusion. In winter 2021, before there was any data about the pediatric COVID vaccine, he argued against it because:
Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, than adults.
In 2022, however, argued against the vaccine because:
Most kids already had COVID-19.
Whether cases were going up, down, left or right, Dr. Prasad’s conclusion was always going to be the same: unvaccinated children should get COVID.
Doctors’ time is limited
At times, Dr. Prasad got very creative and simply invented reasons to support his predetermined beliefs. In a “debate” on his monetized Substack, Dr. Prasad argued that vaccinating children against COVID would lower measles vaccination rates. He said:
Third, and finally, doctors’ time is limited. Routine childhood vaccine rates are slipping. Contrary to COVID-19 shots, the measles vaccine is sterilizing and high rates are needed to halt spread. Doctors must realize that pro-vax does not mean zealotry, but evidence first… To the proposition: Should doctors encourage healthy kids (11 and under) to be vaccinated against COVID-19?
I say, “No, Save your breath for routine vaccination”
Though he obviously didn’t intend for anyone to do so, it’s worthwhile to seriously think about his concern, as it shows how doctors who claim to value “data and evidence” were willing to make just make stuff up to advance their anti-vaccine agenda.
Even though babies, who have the highest COVID risk of all children, can be vaccinated against COVID at 6-months and they don’t receive the MMR until they are 12-months, Dr. Prasad imagined a scenario where pediatricians will be unable to vaccinate them against measles because their discussions on the COVID vaccine will run out the clock. In his dystopian vision, time will expire, pediatricians will walk out the door, and children will leave the office without any vaccines. Moreover, he suspects this won’t be a rare occurrence. He implies it will happen so often that we will lose herd immunity for measles. That’s how powerful and dangerous the pediatric COVID vaccine is, according to Dr. Prasad.
Dr. Prasad is right that routine vaccination rates are slipping, but he did not provide any evidence that time limitations imposed by the COVID vaccine are to blame. He just conjured it out of thin air. I queried several pediatricians and they all agreed- the COVID vaccine does not impair their ability to vaccinate children against measles. Pediatrician Dr. Christopher Hickie told me this about Dr. Prasad’s hypothesis:
Pediatricians can and routinely do promote all approved vaccines–it’s not the time crunch he baselessly imagines it to be, and I don’t know of anyone in pediatrics who thinks time is an excuse not to encourage COVID-19 vaccination.
While Dr. Prasad claims that only enormous RCTs for every variant can demonstrate the COVID vaccine’s benefits, he was fine just casually inventing reasons not to use it. Ho hum, I’ll just say pediatricians don’t have the time and we’ll lose herd immunity to measles.
Unfortunately, this was just one example of a larger trend where doctors required impossible standards of evidence for things they didn’t want to be true and no standards at all for things they wanted to be true. Whether they were extolling the The Triumph of Natural Immunity or declaring that COVID was mild for people under age 70, doctors were very comfortable just making things up. It happened all the time.
The agenda-driven disinformation that has been pushed out relative to Covid vaccines fed the fire of distrust and skepticism that is really sort of the new pandemic of hesitancy for routine vaccines.
I was deeply familiar with the anti-vaccine movement before the pandemic. I know that parents don’t refuse vaccines because pediatricians run out of time. Rather, they don’t trust what the pediatrician has to say. The anti-vaccine movement is fueled entirely by mistrust, and doctors who told the public You’re Right Not To Trust Public Health poured fuel on that fire. That’s why Dr. Prasad became a hero to anti-vaccine luminaries like American Loon #204 Robert Kennedy Jr. and American Loon #131 Barbara Loe Fisher. He speaks their language.
Unsurprisingly, Dr. Prasad has never advocated for the MMR outside of dunking on the COVID vaccine. His concern about children missing this vaccine is entirely vacuous and performative. He’s only ever been concerned that a child might receive the COVID vaccine. He wanted to prevent that at all costs.
In contrast, I advocated for vaccines long before the pandemic. Based on my experience, I have argued that confidence in the COVID vaccine will go hand in hand with confidence in other vaccines. To understand why, one only needs to read the very article that Dr. Prasad linked to- Routine Childhood Vaccinations in the U.S. Slipped During the Pandemic. It said that experts attribute falling vaccination rates to a “groundswell of resistance to Covid-19 shots spilling into unease about other vaccines.” It said:
Pediatricians said in interviews that those issues had also collided with growing levels of anti-vaccine misinformation aimed at the coronavirus shots, which they said had prompted more resistance to ordinary vaccines, too.
“There’s a greater proportion of parents who are questioning routine vaccines,” said Dr. Jason V. Terk, a pediatrician practicing in a suburb of Dallas who also acts as a spokesman for the American Academy of Pediatrics.
“The experience of the pandemic, and the agenda-driven disinformation that has been pushed out relative to Covid vaccines,” he added, had “fed the fire of distrust and skepticism that is really sort of the new pandemic of hesitancy for routine vaccines.”
The article also quoted a pediatrician who said:
All the rumblings about vaccines for kids and the misinformation that was going on at the time — that sort of amplified that particular segment of families, where ‘I’m distrustful of the flu vaccine and then I’m also distrustful of the Covid vaccine and maybe I’m starting to be distrustful of vaccines in general.’
In other words, pediatricians on the ground blame people like Dr. Prasad, an adult oncologist, for making their job more difficult and their patients more vulnerable.
Indeed, the available data supports the intuitive notion that confidence in the COVID vaccine is linked to confidence in all vaccines. Areas that discouraged the pediatric COVID vaccine are seeing their overall vaccination rates decline. There have been large measles and pertussis outbreaks in the the UK, for example, which was slow to vaccinate children against COVID.
More children died per year in the first three years of COVID-19 than died per year from measles in the years right before measles vaccination
Dr. Hickie also told me this:
And since he brought measles into his side of the debate, Prasad should realize more children died per year in the first three years of COVID-19 than died per year from measles in the years right before measles vaccination. I am glad Prasad wasn’t around in the early 1960’s to cast doubt on the measles vaccine rollout since several hundred children a year dying because they went unvaccinated against COVID-19 during the pandemic doesn’t seem to bother him one bit.
He’s right. COVID hospitalized 234,000 children during the first 4 years of pandemic. During that time, there were just 338 measles cases in the entire country. COVID killed 179 children the first 2 months of 2022. Measles last killed American children in 1990-1991, when 9 children died. Dr. Prasad is only concerned about the virus that killed 0 children the past 30 years.
However, like Dr. Prasad, I also want you to use your imagination and envision a world where the COVID and MMR vaccines aren’t in competition, but rather where pediatricians can make the case for both vaccines simultaneously. Here’s what they might say:
Measles and COVID are different, as are the vaccines against them. However, the underlying logic as to why children should receive them is identical. Most children with COVID do well. Most children with measles do well. However, for a small number of children, these viruses will be devastating, even fatal. It’s not healthy for developing children to be infected with either virus, and we can’t always predict which children are at risk.
The vaccines aren’t perfect. No vaccine is perfectly safe or perfectly effective. However, they are much safer than the virus for both COVID and measles. There is no logical reason to be for one of these vaccines, yet against the other. My children are vaccinated against COVID, measles, and any pathogen that threatens them. Here’s a handout I made with the studies that back up these comments. I’ll be happy to answer any questions you may have.
See, that didn’t take any time at all.

Dr. Adam Cifu Should Recognize, Dr. Vinay Prasad Will Never Admit Measures to Limit Viruses “Work”
Opponents of birth control don’t object to condoms because they think they don’t work, and Dr. Vinay Prasad doesn’t object to masks because he thinks they don’t work.
Jonathan Howard on August 1, 2024
Link

The truth is I wear a cloth mask and I quite like it
Prior to the pandemic, Drs. Adam Cifu and Vinay Prasad wrote an excellent book called Ending Medical Reversal. During the pandemic, Dr. Prasad created medical reversals. For example, in May 2021 he said:
For somebody who’s already been fully vaccinated, they can wear the mask out of solidarity or in a symbolic sense, but their wearing a mask indoors is not benefiting anyone else. There’s an infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone.
The next year he said:
This was not Dr. Prasad’s only medical reversal involving masks. In January 2021, he wrote an article titled Throw Away Your Mask After COVID Vaccination? in which he said:
The truth is I wear a cloth mask and I quite like it.
Although, Dr. Prasad quite liked wearing a cloth mask in 2020, since then he has staged a relentless crusade against masks, vaccines, and all other measures to limit viruses. His core opposition to these measures isn’t that they don’t “work”, although he will often frame it that way.
Vinay Prasad is Wrong About Masking
Many of my prior articles have discussed the techniques he Dr. Prasad uses to spread misinformation. I’ve discussed how he judges studies by whether he likes their results and how he omits unwanted information to mislead his readers. Until recently, Dr. Cifu hasn’t cared about Dr. Prasad’s medical reversals. He’s only been bothered that anyone would dare point them out. So it was with interest that I read Dr. Cifu’s recent article Vinay Prasad is Wrong About Masking, which picked up on many of the themes I’ve documented previously.
Both Drs. Cifu and Prasad wrote about a study in the BMJ titled Personal Protective Effect of Wearing Surgical Face Masks in Public Spaces on Self-Reported Respiratory Symptoms in Adults: Pragmatic Randomised Superiority Trial. This was a randomized-controlled trial (RCT) in Norway from 2/10/2023 to 4/27/2023 that concluded:
Wearing a surgical face mask in public spaces over 14 days reduces the risk of self-reported symptoms consistent with a respiratory infection, compared with not wearing a surgical face mask.
The benefit was small, the absolute risk difference was only 3.2% (3,300 fewer infections per 100,000 people). However most people who still mask today wear n95 respirators, which are “are significantly more effective than medical or cloth masks” according to one recent review. Moreover, this study did not show the value of masking for an individual who is dedicated to wearing one, as Dr. Cifu stated, but rather to a group of people randomized to wear one in public spaces for just 14-days, in Norway, in early 2023. RCTs of interventions measure how well the intervention works and how well a group of people can adhere to that intervention. An intervention that is effective for an individual if used properly, is ineffective for a community if almost no one uses it. As Professor Raywat Deonandan put it:
The military never did any RCTs to prove that gas masks work in the battlefield. They relied on lab testing. That’s because they could depend on near perfect user compliance. That’s what RCTs for engineering interventions really measure: compliance.
It turns out that most people in this RCT didn’t wear a mask in public for 14-days. Among participants in the intervention arm, only 25% reported always wearing a mask, and 53% ate in a restaurant. Given that most people couldn’t wear a mask in public just for 14-days, even as part of a study, this implies masks were effective for the minority of people who consistently wore them.
The main reason why people didn’t like wearing masks was interesting. They didn’t like being treated as social pariahs. The study found:
The most reported adverse effects were unpleasant comments from other people.
Dr. David Gorksi and I’ve previously discussed how Dr. Prasad and other doctors shamed and pathologized strangers for wearing masks or taking any steps to avoid COVID at all. I don’t know if they had an influence in Norway, but this mockery contributed to a culture where people felt uncomfortable wearing masks in public.
Just saw someone in San Francisco wearing a surgical mask outside, and push the crosswalk button with their foot. At some point, we might have to discuss irrational phobia of unavoidable microbes, and the degree to which it was perpetuated by public health.
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) November 6, 2023
This study does not prove masks work
As he’s done throughout the pandemic, Dr. Prasad rejected this RCT because he didn’t like what it found. He wrote an article titled A New Mask Randomized Trial Shows That Masks Work? in which he predictably answered:
This study does not prove masks work.
There will never be a study that will lead Dr. Prasad to conclude masks or any other mitigation measure “works”.
In his critique of Dr. Prasad, Dr. Cifu echoed a prior criticism of mine about how Dr. Prasad obscures unwanted information. Dr. Cifu wrote:
You’ll notice that I actually link to the paper here. Something not done by my colleague. Suspicious…
He also accused Dr. Prasad of “moving of the goalpost” and contradicting what he used to believe. Dr. Cifu wrote that:
Dr. Prasad made exactly the opposite argument on page 137-138 of Ending Medical Reversal when we discussed data supporting Tamiflu.
Others also noticed that Dr. Prasad reversed himself regarding medical reversals. They found this “super disappointing.”
2021 Vinay Prasad: RCT everything2015 Vinay Prasad in his own damn book: There are lots of times you can't do RCTs for many reasons (unethical, too expensive, impractical)Super disappointing. Absolutely loved his book and concept of medical reversal. pic.twitter.com/sqqnUPl3CF
— Graham Walker, MD (@grahamwalker) January 19, 2022
Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.
However, Dr. Cifu also wrote this:
If you go into this article convinced that masking is worthless, you can dismiss the results as Vinay did.
This reveals that while Dr. Cifu is belatedly catching onto some of the rhetorical techniques Dr. Prasad uses to mislead his readers, he has yet to grasp Dr. Prasad’s fundamental philosophy regarding most viruses. Dr. Cifu wrote his article based on the quaint assumption that doctors agree it is generally good to avoid pathogens that can make us and our children sick.
Dr. Prasad disagrees. Don’t take my word for it. Just read Dr. Prasad’s own words. His article Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?, written with Allison Krug just after the pandemic’s deadliest month for children, said:
Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger… For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life… Exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future… Immunity is built through illness.
He proposed using sick, unvaccinated children as human shields to theoretically protect more vulnerable adults. He said:
Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
There are safe and effective vaccines for both chickenpox and shingles, both of which can be dangerous and unpleasant. Children don’t have to get infected to theoretically serve as human shields for adults.
This article favorably quoted Professor Francois Balloux who said:
I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.
He similarly quoted an editorial in the BMJ that said:
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood… This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
This article advocated removing masks and all other mitigations precisely because this would “allow” children to get sick. It said:
Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.
I Am Going to Mask Because I Want to Get Fewer Colds & Other Flawed Ideas
In another essay, titled I Am Going to Mask Because I Want to Get Fewer Colds & Other Flawed Ideas, Dr. Prasad shamed and ridiculed anyone who wanted to stay healthy. He said the best way to avoid feeling sick was to get sick. He said:
We may even feel worse when we get sick having lost some cross immunity the longer we postpone things.
He warned of dire consequences of stopping viruses, fearing that worse variants might arise if we didn’t give them opportunities to infect us. He wrote:
That would only mean we are selecting for fitter viruses. Viruses that can spread with less and less breath.
He speculated that preventing infections could cause cancer and autoimmune disease, even though viruses can cause cancer and autoimmune disease. He wrote:
There is the arrogance that avoiding colds and flu is good for us. Of course it is the case that getting sick is unpleasant, but our knowledge of immunology and the body is so primitive we should not conclude that avoiding it is ‘good for us.’ We have no idea if that is true in the long run. It is natural to be infected repeatedly with respiratory viruses— if we got fewer infections what would that mean for auto-immunity for cancer? We have no idea if we would actually live longer or healthier lives trying to dodge seasonal runny noses and coughs.
Sickness was health. Parody accounts picked up on this.
Go On.The More Sick You Get,The Healthier You Will Be. pic.twitter.com/8tD5wTjxHs
— The Vertlartnic (@TheVertlartnic) July 29, 2024
We Reckon Another Two Maybe Three Infections And You’ll Be Totally Well. Maybe Four. Five Tops. pic.twitter.com/mNUpVrFmdb
— The Vertlartnic (@TheVertlartnic) April 14, 2023
Of course, no one is trying to dodge seasonal runny noses and coughs, though Dr. Prasad framed it that way to make people appear hysterical. As everyone knows, some people are trying to dodge SARS‑CoV‑2, the virus that killed over 1.1 million Americans and injured millions more. Currently it is impacting the Olympics and generating headlines like this from Dr. Prasad’s hometown newspaper: California is Still Getting Crushed by COVID. When Will it End?
There’s obviously no evidence that people who are trying to avoid COVID are endangering their health, though doctors who claimed to value data and evidence were just perfectly willing to just spitball out loud that maybe, perhaps COVID-avoiders would one day get cancer and autoimmune disease as a consequence of their behavior.
In contrast, there is evidence that repeat COVID infections are not always the harmless colds they are made out to be. One recent study found:
That severe infections from the virus that causes COVID-19 tend to foreshadow similar severity of infection the next time a person contracts the disease… About 27% of those with severe cases, defined as receiving hospital care for a coronavirus infection, also received hospital care for a reinfection. 
I have never seen Dr. Prasad express the slightest hint of concern that repeat COVID infections may have any consequence, another example of a trend I discussed previously where doctors treated theoretical harms with more gravity than actual harms from COVID.
Beyond this, Dr. Prasad was very perturbed that a tiny fraction of people tried to avoid COVID. He felt they were ridiculous, blameworthy, and deserving of scorn. His article concluded:
Covid19 did infect neurons— just not in the way people think. A tiny fraction of people can’t get back to normal. They are suffering from long pandemic. They still entertain magical thinking. It would be tolerable if they didn’t continue to try to interfere with the lives of others. But they can’t help themselves. It’s important to remind them that they may also be deeply incorrect.
Imagine being this upset that a very small number of strangers tried to avoid a virus.
The Benefits of Having a Natural Measles Infection
None of these arguments were new. I was very familiar with them. The idea that viruses protect against other disease is actually an old bit of anti-vaccine magical thinking. Anti-vaccine doctors regularly spoke about the “benefits” of measles and HPV before the pandemic. This was rightly called quackery before 2020. To pick one example amongst many, American Loon #783 Dr. Suzanne Humphries wrote an article titled The Benefits of Having a Natural Measles Infection, which claimed that measles treats kidney disease and cancer. She said:
A look into the medical literature of the past shows us that wild measles may indeed have afforded immunologic advantages to those infected… Why not just let wild measles circulate and do the job nature intended at the time of life it was intended, which leads to 65 years of immunity and no need for life-span vaccination? And probably reduces the chance of developing cancer during later life.
Compare that to what Dr. Prasad said.
"I am going to mask each winter because I don't want to get a cold" is a type of arrogance.It assumes that it works, and more importantly that it is– in the long run- good for youThose assumptions may be wronghttps://t.co/K1DCLXIhLo
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) October 1, 2022
Like @VPrasadMDMPH, I believe avoiding getting sick is not necessarily good for your health
Opponents of birth control don’t object to condoms because they think they are worthless, and pro-infection doctors don’t object to mitigation measures because they think they are worthless. As I wrote previously, Pro-Infection Doctors Didn’t Honestly Question Whether Mitigation Measures Slowed COVID. They Sought To Undermine Them Precisely Because They Slowed COVID. Though Dr. Prasad has created many medical reversals, they’ve all been in the service of his one unwavering belief: viral infections should be encouraged in most people and measures that limit them aren’t worthless, they’re bad by definition. That’s why even if a 100 flawless RCTs showed masks drastically slash infections, Dr. Prasad wouldn’t say they “work.”
In the worldview of We Want Them Infected doctors, avoiding getting sick is not necessarily good for your health. As such, measures that “work” are those that let viruses infect unvaccinated children and young people. Before doctors can have dialogue about whether masks or other mitigation measures “work”, they need to have a shared understanding of that word. In a rebuttal to Dr. Cifu titled Adam Cifu is Wrong About Masking Dr. Prasad said:
Maybe it’s a good thing to get colds, and avoiding them is silly. 
Hopefully, Dr. Cifu will explore that in a future article about his colleague.
This is an excellent debate. I appreciated Dr. Cifu's critique, but I share Dr. Prasad's concern with the study methods. Like @VPrasadMDMPH, I believe avoiding getting sick is not necessarily good for your health.Adam Cifu is Wrong About Masking https://t.co/JASicMyv3D
— Allison Krug MPH (@KrugAlli) July 29, 2024
Avoiding getting sick is not necessarily good for your health.

Dr. Vinay Prasad: “I Don’t Believe in Forgiveness Because in My Opinion These Pieces of Shit Are Still Lying.”
Mass purges and prosecutions of scientists have happened before. We shouldn’t pretend they can’t happen here.
Jonathan Howard on November 10, 2024
Link
2020: Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
In April 2020, Drs. Vinay Prasad and Jeffrey Flier wrote an article titled Scientists Who Express Different Views On COVID-19 Should Be Heard, Not Demonized, which was was about people who said mean things to Dr. John Ioannidis. They wrote:
When major decisions must be made amid high scientific uncertainty, as is the case with Covid-19, we can’t afford to silence or demonize professional colleagues with heterodox views. Even worse, we can’t allow questions of science, medicine, and public health to become captives of tribalized politics. Today, more than ever, we need vigorous academic debate…
That’s why we believe that the bar to stifling or ignoring academics who are willing to debate their alternative positions in public and in good faith must be very high. Since different states and nations are already making distinct choices, there exist many natural experiments to identify what helped, what hurt, and what in the end didn’t matter.
They recognized it was a time of uncertainty and that no one would get everything right. They said:
When the dust settles, few if any scientists — no matter where they work and whatever their academic titles — will have been 100% correct about the effects of Covid-19 and our responses to it. Acknowledging this fact does not require policy paralysis by local and national governments, which must take decisive action despite uncertainty. But admitting this truth requires willingness to listen to and consider ideas, even many that most initially consider totally wrong.
They concluded:
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics. The tensions between the two policy poles of rapidly and systematically reopening society versus maximizing sheltering in place and social isolation must not be reduced to Republican and Democratic talking points, even as many media outlets promote such simplistic narratives.
These critical decisions should be influenced by scientific insights independent of political philosophies and party affiliations. They must be freely debated in the academic world without insult or malice to those with differing view
As the morgues were overflowing with corpses of COVID’s victims, Drs. Prasad and Flier were worried about Dr. Ioannidis’ feelings. On social media, Dr. Prasad even said it was “chilling and silencing and dangerous” to call Dr. Ioannidis an “idiot.” The stakes were very high and the situation was very precarious. One stray word could do a lot of damage.

2024: You fucking liar
A lot’s happened since then. Here is what Dr. Prasad sounds like today.
Dr. Damania: What do you think should be done, Vinay, because there’s this there’s two camps on this like let’s forgive and have a Reconciliation about all this and move on and forget it Why are we beating the dead horse and others who say but if we do that when the next you know Marlberg pandemic or whatever comes Or bird flu the same shit’s gonna happen.
Dr. Prasad: Yeah, I don’t believe in forgiveness because in my opinion these pieces of shit are still lying I mean like if you want forgiveness the first thing you have to say is what you actually did wrong And they’re still fucking like this well based on the best information we had that the time cloth masking two -year-olds was a sensible No, it wasn’t you fucking liar.
Curiously, Dr. Flier hasn’t said anything about this as far as I know, even as he continues to find my tone offensive because I disagreed with him.
This vitriol and hyperbole was routine for Dr. Prasad. He said public health officials were part of a “totalitarian regime” that “used the power of the police state,” and he routinely said things like this:
Public health wasn’t always a dystopian hellscape intent on using police and military power to maximize compliance with interventions that are based on 0 RCTs. But it is now!
Dr. Prasad called for criminal prosecutions. On social media, he posted a picture of a mask along with the following message:
I saw a 4 year old wearing this outside today The makers of this should be prosecuted. There is no evidence it is certified to this standard in children of this age. The use of this in a child is disgusting. An adult mental illness that hurts kids. CDC and AAP failed.
Dr. Prasad called for mass purges of scientists. After the election, he complained about masking children and posted the following:
I would fire at least ~10000 people (1/4) in the CDC and everyone who touched this decision or didn’t stop it. Anyone working from home should go, as well.
10,000 people should not lose their jobs because children wore masks at the start of the pandemic, but the sad truth is, they might.
Although Dr. Prasad depicted himself as a sober medical scholar, his rageful comments were intentionally crafted to provoke his audience. His appeals to raw emotion were very effective. Here are some of the replies to Dr. Prasad’s post:
    • Closing schools… injecting experimental products in children.. They need to be arrested first. Then, you can fire them.
    • My presumption based on these agencies’ decisions so far is that they are filled top to bottom with politically possessed, self righteous, Quacks. I’d love at least 2/3 of them gone! I bet 90% of the real work is probably done by 10% of the employees there.
    • Masking toddlers was state sanctioned child abuse. The risk benefit analysis is obvious risk, implausible benefit.
    • Only 1/4?? I’d close the place down & rehire based on their progress during COVID..ie did they challenge/speak out, if so then yes you’re on track to having smart people in situ who also have integrity. You can’t put a price on that!
    • I agree . . . we need a decisive leader at CDC who is willing to hold the institution, and its people, accountable for that colossal failure in judgment.
    • Fire anyone who obscured the reality of Antigenic Sin, innate/adaptive immunity, risk stratification and mRNA safety signals. Reinstate everyone with backpay who were fired due to the unethical, unconstitutional injection mandate.
    • I hope you can contribute in an official role to Make Science Great Again!
These spiteful calls for revenge were a normal, everyday occurrence on the social media feeds of We Want Them Infected doctors. This is what they were aiming for. These people won’t cooperate when the next pandemic hits.
Dr. Prasad has traveled a long distance in a short time, though he is just one of many doctors calling for drastic actions against scientists. Dr. Richard Ebright, a so-called “biosafety” advocate who teams up with anti-vaccine advocates of herd immunity through mass infection, is also calling for scientists to be jailed. His partner Dr. Bryce Nickels hopes to enjoy the spectacle of even more Congressional investigations. Dr. Ebright has testified there before. He is politically connected. These hearings are highly problematic, as Dr. Allison Neitzel explained in her article Don’t Let House Republicans Rewrite Trump’s Pandemic History.
My Pronouns are Prosecute/Fauci
This is all happening at a moment when political fortune has shifted greatly in a very short time. Robert Kennedy Jr. might be running the show soon. He wrote a book titled The Wuhan Cover-Up: And the Terrifying Bioweapons Arms Race. According to it’s description on Amazon:
The Wuhan Cover-Up pulls back the curtain on how the US government’s increase in biosecurity spending after the 2001 terror attacks set in motion a plan to transform the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), under the direction of Dr. Anthony Fauci, into a de facto Defense Department agency… The Wuhan Cover-Up unveils a global conspiracy of epic proportion and lethal consequence.
This stuff is mainstream. Kennedy’s other book is called The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health. Though it is from 2021, it is currently an Amazon #1 bestseller with nearly 26,000 reviews. David Burke wrote a meticulous rebuttal titled In Defense of Fauci. It has 1 review and is ranked #2,127,824 on the sales list.
Meanwhile, anti-vaxxers openly pine for Nuremberg trials and headlines like this exist- Anthony Fauci Says He Still Needs A Security Detail After Ron Desantis Threatened To ‘Grab That Little Elf And Chuck Him Across The Potomac’. Powerful politicians made no secret of whom they blame and their desire for revenge. Elon Musk even Tweeted, “My pronouns are Prosecute/Fauci.”
Doctors amplified this message, yet it hasn’t generated much alarm. Perhaps it should. It’s not hard to think of examples of historical examples of heroic scientists who were treated like villains for political purposes by angry mobs. Even if the risk of this actually happening here is low, we should not pretend it’s zero.
This is all certainly much more chilling and silencing and dangerous than someone calling Dr. Ioannidis an “idiot” because he predicted the flu would be worse than COVID and that 40,000 Americans would die from it.
Del Bigtree makes threats.

Defenders of Dr. Vinay Prasad’s Vulgar, Vengeful Vitriol Have No Right to Sanctimoniously Scold Anyone About Decorum
Defenders of Dr. Vinay Prasad fake a concern about tone to intimidate critics and create a safe space for his misinformation.
Jonathan Howard on January 31, 2025
Link
It is important to hear, consider, and debate these views without ad hominem attacks or animus
On April 27, 2020, Drs. Jeffrey Flier and Vinay Prasad wrote a defense of “independent thinkers, like John Ioannidis” titled Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should Be Heard, Not Demonized. Though the virus was just a few months old, Dr. Ioannidis had already made many confident claims about it. In a paper Coronavirus Disease 2019: The Harms Of Exaggerated Information And Non-Evidence-Based Measures published on March 19th, 2020, he spoke of “exaggerated pandemic estimates” and said:
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
Then, on April 9, 2020, he said:
If I were to make an informed estimate based on the limited testing data we have, I would say that covid-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA.
Though this death tally would be surpassed in only 8 days, Drs. Flier and and Prasad weren’t concerned that his absurd predictions might cause some people to underestimate a very dangerous virus. Instead, as hospitals and morgues overflowed, they worried that critics might hurt Dr. Ioannidis’ feelings and deprive him of the platform to which he was entitled. They wrote:
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics. The tensions between the two policy poles of rapidly and systematically reopening society versus maximizing sheltering in place and social isolation must not be reduced to Republican and Democratic talking points, even as many media outlets promote such simplistic narratives. These critical decisions should be influenced by scientific insights independent of political philosophies and party affiliations. They must be freely debated in the academic world without insult or malice to those with differing views…
At the same time, academics must be able to express a broad range of interpretations and opinions… We think it is important to hear, consider, and debate these views without ad hominem attacks or animus… We believe that the bar to stifling or ignoring academics who are willing to debate their alternative positions in public and in good faith must be very high.
A lot’s happened since then. COVID kill 1.2 million Americans. A president who botched the pandemic, aside from the vaccine he now rejects, is back in power. Scientists are censored and research is threatened. Scientists need bodyguards and vaccine-heroes get accosted at home. Hospitals are sending instructions about what to do if ICE agents show up. Viruses still don’t care about our manners or politics. New threats loom, and old foes like measles and pertussis are poised to return. Cranks are on the verge of power, and many people can’t tell fact from fiction thanks to doctors like Dr. Ioannidis, who is now starring in self-congratulatory movies.
I don’t believe in forgiveness because these pieces of shit are still lying
Meanwhile, Dr. Prasad no longer speaks of the need to debate “views without ad hominem attacks or animus”. Instead, he seeks to provoke and anger his audience with emotionally manipulative, inflammatory language. Watch these two videos, which are normal for Dr. Prasad. He is full of insult and malice to those with differing views.
Yet, even in this dangerous moment, many doctors are totally fine with this. They collaborate with Dr. Prasad and praise his work. His vulgar, vengeful vitriol doesn’t bother them at all. They laugh at it. Did you notice the reaction of the other doctors in the videos. They said nothing when he called people “idiots,” “despicable”, “STUPID“, a “bunch of fools” and “total morons“. They were quiet when he weaponized mental illness to pathologize and humiliate people. They were not bothered by his pro-RFK Jr. propaganda and his blatant anti-vaccine misinformation. They didn’t care that he viciously attacked the exact scientists who needed bodyguards and were stalked at home. Their silence and mirth sent a clear message- this is all fine and OK.
The best thing the new admin can do is flush Peter, pro school closure, pro toddler masking, Hotez's number down the toilet. pic.twitter.com/GHswQDpezt
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) November 25, 2024
Tone is important
Yet, Dr. Prasad’s defenders, who were often his business partners, pretended to be very concerned about the tone of his critics. Our manners were treated with more gravity than Dr. Prasad’s misinformation. As the Delta variant raged and just months after I started to refute Dr. Prasad’s misinformation here at SBM, suddenly his defenders cared about my decorum. That’s what mattered to them. They wanted to discuss my tone and only my tone. Apparently, I “yelled”, though no examples were provided and none ever will be. I am confident in the quality of my arguments, I don’t have paying customers to pander to, and I actually believe in civil discussion. As such, I don’t need to talk like Dr. Prasad.
What tone is appropriate when doctors here promote ideas that doctors are killing patients through inappropriate intubations and getting $ to put Covid on the death certificate? I mean these are qanon memes. https://t.co/h1kXzBnV9D
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) September 20, 2021
This is more than just about a few silly Tweets. While tone policing is obviously phony and insincere, it serves several functions that are important to understand not just how we got to this point, but also to make sure we are not distracted by them moving forward.
First, tone policing shields certain doctors from criticism. The Very Serious Doctors who complain about tone, don’t care about tone. It’s an act and performance. Instead, they care about content, and they feign concerns about tone as a cover. Dr. Prasad’s tone police seek to create a safe space where his feelings are given top priority. Anyone who dares to correct his misinformation will invariably be told they are acting inappropriately no matter what they say. By framing their criticisms with regards to civility, the tone police seek to silence critics and make them feel like they are walking on eggshells. If I correct Dr. Prasad’s misinformation, will people say I am attacking him and behaving unprofessionally?
Second, tone-policing is a deliberate distraction. Every moment discussing civility is a moment not spent discussing science and data. Even today as Dr. Prasad cheers mass censorship, purges, and ruined careers- you got to break some eggs to make an omelette– his tone police treat the manners of his critics as the primary value. They claim that it is not “productive” to discuss the gutting of our scientific agencies and that Dr. Prasad should be able to encourage their degredation without the slightest hint of disapproval. Imagine telling someone else how to spend their time or that what’s happening at the NIH is unimportant. Dr. Mark is also rightly pointing out that Dr. Prasad is not personally affected by the policies he promotes. The headline- National Science Foundation Suspends Salary Payments, Leaving Researchers Unable to Pay Their Bills– doesn’t affect Dr. Prasad’s revenue streams. He’s not going to be one of the eggs that gets broken.
I’m assuming Vinay has blocked you. Which means you have an anonymous account that you use to screen shot his tweet and then post on your account to make fun of him. Spend your time doing something more productive or just go after me.
— Aaron Goodman – “Papa Heme” (@AaronGoodman33) January 24, 2025
Finally, the tone police seek to preemptively discredit anyone who corrects Dr. Prasad’s misinformation, while deliberately avoiding the substance and merits of their arguments. Of course, unlike Dr. Prasad, these critics are honest about the dangers of RFK Jr. Yet, Dr. Prasad’s defenders portrayed them as shrill, unprofessional, and not worth listening to. The message this sends is unmistakable.
Dr. Mark: Honestly calls out RFK's anti-vaxx disinformation

Dr. Prasad: Deceives people about RFK's anti-vaxx disinformation at his monetized Substacks

Those are the facts, https://t.co/jDpOUMPimY pic.twitter.com/IMVkrgeJgk
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) January 25, 2025
As with disingenuous exhortations that certain doctors should not blend politics and medicine, the tone police apply their high standards of decorum only to certain doctors. These certain doctors must be the epitome of decorousness and sobriety with their every utterance. They “cared” about Dr. Nick Mark taking a screenshot of Dr. Prasad’s to make a valid point, but said nothing when Dr. Prasad acted like toddler while taking a screenshot of Dr. Peter Hotez. Imagine their faux outrage if I called someone a “lying piece of shit” or a “fucking moron”.
In contrast, Dr. Prasad and other advocates of mass infection can say whatever they want. Different rules apply to different people. The issue is not just their hypocrisy, it’s how obvious and transparent it all is. Everyone is in on the game. This open hypocrisy send a clear message- the standards we set for those you don’t apply to us and everyone knows it. The hypocrisy is the point. If Dr. Prasad’s defenders want to prove me wrong, they can publicly call on him to stop “yelling.” We all know that will never happen.
But let’s not let anyone succeed in their mission to distract us. Let’s keep focused on where we are today. These are the headlines. Chaos Erupts in US Science as Trump’s Team Declares Freeze on Federal Grants, Alsobrooks Grills Kennedy On Belief That Black Americans Should Get Different Vaccine Schedules, and Trump Removes Anthony Fauci’s Federal Security Detail. We need to be clear-eyed about all this, and looking back, I think those of us who rightly warned of the dangers of medical misinformation should have “yelled” a bit more forcefully actually. And while manners were not the most important thing in 2021 or right now, you’ll never catch me talking like Dr. Prasad or associating myself with someone who does.
Tone is important after all.
    • 

I Confess My Sins: I Was Too Slow and Timid to Call Out Propaganda For What It Is.
As Lysenkoism 2.0 looms, those of us who have warning about this for years are not to blame for the problems we write about, and we have nothing to apologize for.
Jonathan Howard on February 7, 2025
Link
It’s bad when doctors spread misinformation.
Dr. Jonathan Storey recently asked me in the comments here:
I was REALLY hoping to get to the root of your medical philosophy.
I replied:
It’s bad when doctors spread misinformation.
Though Dr. Storey rejected my answer, it’s the truth. While he’s welcome to read my neurology textbooks and my book on cognitive biases in medicine to get a broader view, in my writing at SBM, that’s “the root of my medical philosophy”. Though I think every SBM regular would say the same thing, I am not a just stenographer who regurgitates raw data. I aim not just to inform people, but also to warn them- Reader Beware– about the dangers of replacing fact with fiction. Some people don’t get it.
For example, in this moment, with all that’s happening, Dr. Storey was very concerned that I was too mean to Dr. Adam Cifu simply because he profits from a blog that spreads blatant pro-RFK Jr. propaganda. Dr. Storey further anointed himself as my priest and repeatedly demanded that I publicly confess my sins to him. He wrote:
Will you prove yourself capable of making a concession, admitting an error, or publicly changing your mind about something?
Of course, I’ve already done that. I’ve misstated a couple numbers in my articles. Unlike the doctors I discuss, I’ve always acknowledged the error, corrected it, and thanked the person who pointed it out. However, my biggest error, by far, was to continually and repeatedly underestimate the anti-vaccine movement. I also wrote about this error in We Want Them Infected. I said:
I greatly underestimated the strength and durability of anti-vaccine myths. I thought once anti-vaxxers saw their family and friends die of COVID, they would prefer a needle to a coffin. Instead, many doubled down on their denial, claiming COVID is harmless with their last breath…
I also underestimated the appeal of the anti-vaccine movement, which has grown this pandemic, sweeping up previously respectable doctors and scientists in its path. I’ve been writing about the spread of anti-vaccine beliefs in mainstream medicine since the spring of 2021. I started writing after I read an editorial by Drs. Vinay Prasad, Stefan Baral. and Wesley Pegden, a mathematician, titled “COVID Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization,” which was published in the BMJ. Its central thesis was that “severe outcomes or death associated with COVID-19 infection is very low for children, undermining the appropriateness of an emergency use authorization for child COVID-19 vaccines.”
Even though around 450 children had died of COVID and tens of thousands more had been hospitalized by the time the BMJ editorial was published, it neglected to mention any of these sad facts. It also did not mention a Pfizer press release that the vaccine was 100% effective in preventing pediatric COVID in a randomized controlled trial. This trial data was published in The New England Journal of Medicine two months later. The article in the BMJ had but a single reference, about the swine flu debacle of 1976. Aside from this, it was entirely fact-free.
Indeed my first article here at SBM was a rebuttal to Dr. Vinay Prasad’s fact-free article. My response presented loads of data in a neutral manner, and I think it aged quite well, with one exception. At the time, I thought that Dr. Prasad and his co-authors were operating in good faith and could be persuaded by such evidence. I was innocent, foolish, naive, and wrong. Dr. Prasad was launching his career as an anti-vaccine advocate. I should have said so in my first essay.
I recently submitted the final draft of the sequel to WWTI, a book titled Everyone Else is Lying to You, which explains about how doctors who spread COVID misinformation weaponized doubt to rewrite the history of the pandemic and seize power. However, in that book I acknowledge that I again greatly underestimated the anti-vaccine movement. I have been refuting their myths and warning about their dangers for 15 years. I know what these people are like, but I never imagined that dishonest anti-vaxxers with a body count would win.
I would fire ~10,000 people in the CDC
And they are winning. RFK Jr. appears to be headed towards Senate confirmation after Republican Senators, including Dr. Bill Cassidy, placed politics above health. Misinformation doctors like Marty Makary and Jay Bhattacharya are poised to join him. Our public health agencies have gone dormant with no end in sight. Scientists have been silenced, research has been upended, and purges of scientists are promised. Data has been removed for political reasons, and words are being banned from scientific publications. The image below comes straight out of an Orwell novel, but it’s where we are right now. Politics has entered the exam room. Abortion is illegal for countless millions of women and my medical school, caving to political pressure, stopped accepting new young transgender patients.
Worse yet, we are just getting started. Who knows where things will be in 4 years? I have documented medical misinformation not only because resisting pandemic revisionism is valuable in its own right, but also because the threat is ongoing. The same doctors who spent years telling you not to worry about COVID are now telling you not to worry about anything that’s happening now.
Dr. Prasad, for example, says everything is just fine. There was censorship when the Biden administration asked Twitter to de-prioritize a couple of Tweets, but everything the Trump administration is doing is business as normal. There’s nothing to see here. In Dr. Prasad’s fantasy, top CDC officials would be completely safe saying that Trump and Musk are dangerous and incompetent fools, as long as they do so in their “personal capacity”. Those magic words will spare them the wrath of DOGE and Project 2025.
Notice too that even though thousands of meetings have been canceled and researchers silenced, Dr. Prasad is concerned about social media posts. In his world, Tweets and YouTube videos matter more than headlines like this.
Dr. Prasad has also been a cheerleader for RFK Jr., absolving him of responsibility in Samoa, but also future measles outbreaks. Dr. Prasad claims that he is the key to restoring confidence in vaccines
Though Dr. Prasad faked concern about routine vaccines to argue against the COVID vaccine, today he cheers the censorship of vaccine data. Paving the way for RFK Jr. to install anti-vaxx cranks, Dr. Prasad says dedicated scientists at the ACIP are “a mediocre group of scientists” because they objected to his plan to mass infect unvaccinated children with COVID.
Indeed, Dr. Prasad is eager to see mass firings of scientists. Toddlers wore masks after all.
He recognizes that people are going to get hurt and promises more tears to come. He’s right about that. The headlines read White House Preparing Order to Cut Thousands of Federal Health Workers His a wink emoji is someone else’s income and career.
Dr. Prasad was not motivated by evidence and data regarding COVID and he won’t be moving forward either. Though he markets himself as a “physician and medical scholar” who bases his “opinions on a sober assessment of available evidence,” he is a businessman and political actor at this point. He’s chained himself to the RFK-Trump-Musk trifecta and he will cheer and sanewash everything they do. Even as the headlines read, Musk Targets CDC, just watch as Dr. Prasad, an oncologist, interprets the Constitution to explain why Musk’s current role in our government is just fine. It will be interesting to see how Dr. Prasad justifies RFK Jr.’s inevitable attack on the HPV vaccine.
Excessive dogmatism extends to both sides
But the problem isn’t just Dr. Prasad. It’s the cadre of doctors who normalize it all by treating him as a fundamentally rational actor, rather than a propagandist who emotionally manipulates his audience to advance his political objects. Dr. Prasad’s business partners at Sensible Medicine will continue to “debate” him, falsely implying that he arrives at his positions via a reasonable process that should be subject to reasonable discussion. Even if they say they disagree with him, his calls for censorship and purges aren’t a deal-breaker for them. They are OK with it all.
Meanwhile, doctors in the comments here at SBM demanded that I ignore Dr. Prasad’s rageful threats and instead write my 20th article, and once again explain why Dr. Prasad was wrong to treat vaccine side effects as a fate worse they death. They too treat Dr. Prasad and his ilk as fundamentally good-faith, rational actors, who simply have not been presented the data. Why haven’t I shown him? They blamed me for sharing his words and made statements such as:
    • Excessive dogmatism extends to both sides.
    • I believe he (Prasad) is capable of changing his mind when presented with high-quality data. This makes him quite different than the “quacks” and “antivaxxers” that are profiled on this site as well.
    • I think the answer is more data, not more argument.
    • The SBM site is performing its own version of “policing” by cherry-picking clips and statements rather than tackling the steel-manned version of potential disagreement.
    • The authors here seem very eager to start each article with a littany of self-referencing links that bring up the contrarian’s prior misdeeds and outakes from hundreds of hours of podcast episodes. The majority of articles (I don’t think I’m exaggerating) focus on the “people” rather than their ideas. The “tone” here feels cancel-culture-ish, with there being an eagerness to dismiss one’s entire body of work after making a misstep (or mulitple missteps).
Let’s be clear about my writing here. I thought parents should vaccinate their kids against COVID, and I presented many long lists of studies to back that up. I also thought doctors should communicate accurate information and that it was dangerous to reframe clear misinformation as “independent thinking”. Today, I oppose RFK Jr. and abhor purges and censorship. That’s it. Like I said, it’s bad when doctors spread misinformation.
In contrast, Dr. Prasad spread obviously fake data to mass infect unvaccinated children with a new, mutating virus. Today, he supports RFK Jr. and applauds purges and censorship, often with vulgar, vengeful language designed to inflame and provoke his paying customers. I am blunt, but I never swear at people or call them schoolyard taunts. I never called for anyone to be fired or canceled in any way. I’ve kept my political views mostly to myself.
Yet, according to some doctors, my detailed explanations as to why children should get vaccinated are no different than Dr. Prasad’s vindictive calls to censor and purge scientists, even as that is actually happening today in the real world.
Both sides!
Read this article
It’s dangerous and absurd to “steel man” Dr. Prasad’s calls to censor and fire scientists or to engage with the fantasy that “more data” will change his mind. I presented him with data all the time. Not once did he engage with it. That’s his perfect right, but it reveals that lack of “high quality data” was never the problem. Doctors spreading misinformation to further their political agenda was always the problem, along with those who claimed this misinformation was just innocent “missteps” without real-world consequences.
We need to be be clear-eyed about the threat moving forward, though it probably too late. The willful blindness of the medical community to the rot within helped bring us to this dangerous moment. As Lysenkoism 2.0 gears up, doctors who say “excessive dogmatism extends to both sides” have fundamentally misunderstood the dangers as well as the entire purpose of SBM. It’s all gone over their head. Dr. Storey had even previously e-mailed the SBM crew and requested:
A small bit of self-reflection on how we are about to end up with RFK Jr leading the HHS.
In reality, those of us who have warned about the anti-vaccine movement for years have nothing to apologize for and aren’t responsible for anything that happens next. We are not to blame for the problems we write about or the words of the doctors we quote. Whatever my sins, there are only two worth confessing. I was too slow to recognize that some people just wanted to taking a wrecking ball to everything, and I was too timid to call out propaganda for what it is.
I should have been doing that from my first article here.


Dr. Vinay Prasad Embraces Policy-Based Evidence Making
Policy-based evidence making means working back from a predefined policy to produce underpinning evidence.
Jonathan Howard on February 22, 2025
Link

Unlike myself, Dr. Vinay Prasad did nothing to advance an actual COVID randomized-controlled trial (RCT) as far as I know. Instead, of making any real-world contribution, he created long lists of RCTs that he expected other doctors to do. In his vision, it was a significant accomplishment to make podcasts and “call for” for them to do RTCs.
In a previous article titled Doctors Who Performatively Fetishized RCTs Aren’t Out to Advance Medical Research, But Rather to Sow Doubt & Mistrust, I described how Dr. Prasad created these lists for one reason, to undermine mitigation measures he opposed. It was trivially easy to take an unwanted measure and claim that it was of no value because it hadn’t proven itself via an RCT. Obviously RCTs are not the only way to learn about the world, and when these measures did prove themselves via RCTs, such as the pediatric and booster vaccines, Dr. Prasad said these studies were too small or out of date.
Dr. Prasad started with his conclusions and always found some reason to discard unwanted data and to disparage those who disagreed as actively opposed to high-quality evidence. Indeed he opposed the pediatric COVID vaccine months before there was a pediatric COVID vaccine and called its supporters “idiots“. Conversely, Dr. Prasad never demanded RCTs to push policies he preferred, namely repeatably exposing unvaccinated children to SARS-CoV-2.
Though Dr. Prasad still starts with his conclusions, things are very different now. Dr. Prasad’s ideological allies are in power or soon will be. As such, Dr. Prasad is done creating lists of endless RCTs for them to do. He has a very different task for them today. He openly wants “researchers” to work backwards to produce non-randomized “evidence” specifically to confirm his prior beliefs and advance his political objectives. In his article Jay Bhattacharya is a Superb Pick for NIH Director he tasked Dr. Bhattacharya with performing just one RCT regarding NIH grants, and said:
Jay Bhattacharya will create a portfolio of funding to investigate the harms of lockdowns, school closures, vaccine mandates, and other unproven draconian COVID19 measures. This will create a lasting body of scholarship which will deter future public health tyrants.
That’s an amazing thing to write. Dr. Prasad doesn’t want to build a fair and objective body of scholarship to help guide future public health leaders. Dr. Prasad is done pretending that science is an objective method to investigate the world. To him, it is a weapon. With his typical emotionally manipulative language, he wants the NIH to “investigate… unproven draconian COVID19 measures” for the singular purpose of deterring future public health “tyrants.” The term for this bastardization of science is policy-based evidence making. According to Wikipedia:
Policy-based evidence making is a pejorative term which refers to the commissioning of research in order to support a policy which has already been decided upon. It is the converse of evidence-based policy making.
As the name suggests, policy-based evidence making means working back from a predefined policy to produce underpinning evidence. Working from a conclusion to provide only supporting evidence is an approach which contradicts most interpretations of the scientific method; however, it should be distinguished from research into the effects of a policy where such research may provide either supporting or opposing evidence.
Unfortunately, Dr. Prasad is probably correct that Dr. Bhattacharya’s will “investigate” COVID measures, and we all know what he will “discover”. They are both political actors who disguise themselves as neutral scientists, and Dr. Prasad’s surprisingly honest admission leaves no doubt about that. The era of policy-based evidence making making is upon on, and we should all be on guard against it.

    • 

Dr. Vinay Prasad Said He Would Deliver New COVID Vaccine RCTs. He Failed and Should STFU.
It turns out that Tweeting about RCTs 100+ times is a lot easier than delivering even a single RCT.
Jonathan Howard on April 5, 2026
Link

“I must have tweeted 100+ times the need for randomized data for all these pandemic questions”
Few disinformation doctors used methodolatry, the disingenuous deification of randomized-controlled trials (RCTs), more effectively than Dr. Vinay Prasad. He often said his philosophy was “RCT or STFU for all” and falsely portrayed anyone who recognized the practical and ethical limitations of RCTs as actively opposed to them. For example, in his article The Scientists Who Undermine Randomized Trials he said:
There have been several examples of scientists trying to undermine randomized trials— arguing they are not possible, not practical, or not useful. All of these arguments are false.
Of course, no one was trying to undermine RCTs.
Dr. Prasad was extremely proud of himself not because he conducted RCTs, but rather because he “called for” them. “I must have tweeted 100+ times the need for randomized data for all these pandemic questions”, he boasted, though he was probably right about that number. In his telling, dreaming up RCTs on social media was hard, actually doing them was easy, and prior FDA leaders were too stupid to figure this out. “I want them to admit they didn’t run any studies even though people told them to,” he said in the profane video below. People told them!
In reality, Dr. Prasad’s predecessors didn’t need him to tell them anything. Even as COVID raged in 2020, they delivered multiple successful RCTs in under a year via Operation Warp Speed. Nonetheless, Dr. Prasad said they were lying “pieces of shit,” underserving of forgiveness for their supposed failures in this regards.
“I want them to admit they didn’t run any studies even though people told them to.”
I previously discussed that Dr. Prasad glorified RCTs not to genuinely advance medical research, but rather to cast fear and doubt on unwanted COVID mitigations. I also noted that “having an idea for an RCT is infinitely easier than actually doing an RCT“, though Dr. Prasad is hardly unique in recognizing their value. I volunteered for a COVID vaccine RCT myself and encouraged SBM readers to enroll in them if given the opportunity.
Dr. Prasad never did this.
RCTs require trusting volunteers, and Dr. Prasad spread doubt. He gave his audience every reason to avoid RCTs, especially regarding COVID vaccines. He ignored RCTs that showed the vaccine worked and repeatedly told people to stop talking about COVID years ago. He treated rare vaccine side effects as a fate worse than death, mocked people who wanted COVID vaccines, and spread mistrust about the companies and scientists who conducted such research. He literally wrote articles titled Public Health Should Lose Your Trust. It was doctors like him who undermined RCTs.
“Pfizer, BioNTech Halt US COVID Vaccine Study After Recruitment Struggles”
Once in power, however, Dr. Prasad claimed things would change. He would finally deliver new RCTs of the COVID vaccine, and trust would be restored. While his moronic, incompetent predecessors had failed, Dr. Prasad said he had instructed companies to “generate data for the American people and doctors, who quite frankly don’t know what to do.” Once again, Dr. Prasad “called for” other people to do RCTs, though this time not as a pundit on Twitter, but as a public servant with responsibility for making sure these trials got done.
Recruiting for RCTs is never easy, and many trials, including past COVID trials failed to meet their goal. Enrolling subjects in new vaccine RCTs was always going to be especially challenging. Anti-vaxxers would never enroll in a trial where there was a 50% chance they would get a vaccine, while pro-vaxxers would never enroll in a trial where there was a 50% chance they would get a placebo. Most people don’t think about COVID vaccines at all.
Despite this, I never saw Dr. Prasad promote these new RCTs. Although he had a massive platform as the FDA’s chief vaccine regulator, he never used his voice to boost enrollment.
It’s no surprise that today under his “leadership,” the headlines read Pfizer, BioNTech Halt US COVID Vaccine Study After Recruitment Struggles. The article said:
Vaccine makers Pfizer and BioNTech halted a large U.S. trial of their updated COVID-19 ​vaccine in healthy adults aged 50 to 64, saying enrollment in the trials had been too low to generate the needed data…
The target enrollment was roughly ⁠25,000 to 30,000 participants.
“This study is not ending as a result of any safety or benefit-risk concerns. We intend to stop the study due to slow enrollment and therefore the inability ​to generate relevant post-marketing data,” the companies said…
“This is a very difficult population to recruit,” said one executive at a contract research organization involved in the trial, who spoke on the condition of anonymity.
“Even when ​patients are willing to participate in COVID ​studies, more than 80% fail at pre-screening ⁠because they don’t meet the health criteria. It’s been a real challenge to enroll enough patients, particularly given the scale of these trials,” the executive said.

“It’s been a real challenge to enroll enough patients.” Does that surprise anyone?
But let’s be clear what happened here. Dr. Prasad rose to power by weaponizing a trial design, using RCTs to spread anger and mistrust about anyone whose job it was to stop people from dying of COVID. While he promised things would be better under his leadership, when given opportunity to prove his mettle in the real-world, he failed. It turns out that Tweeting about RCTs 100+ times is a lot easier than delivering even a single RCT. As such, we can all expect and demand that Dr. Prasad STFU once he leaves the FDA.


Dr. Vinay Prasad’s Latest Evidence the COVID Vaccine Killed Kids: “Trust Me, Bro.”
Dr. Vinay Prasad expected us to believe obviously absurd things. There’s no reason to trust him or care about what he says today.
Jonathan Howard on August 29, 2026
Link

“Would it be best if we just stopped talking about COVID19?”
In an essay from January 2024 titled Should We Just Stop Talking about COVID19? Dr. Vinay Prasad asked:
Would it be best if we just stopped talking about COVID19?
Yes, Vinay, it would be best if you stopped talking about COVID19.
Unfortunately, Dr. Prasad did not hold himself to the standards he set for others back then. He never does. Now that he is done podcasting at the FDA and back to podcasting at UCSF, Dr. Prasad is desperate to recapture his glory days of 2020/2021, where he could gain paid subscribers by droning on about Fauci, mandates, and toddlers wearing masks.
None of this matters, however. No one should care about Dr. Prasad’s hot takes on anything ever again. He had his chance to translate his opinions into action at the FDA, and he flamed out in dramatic fashion. Podcasting is easier than doing, it turns out, and Dr. Prasad’s only value now is as a cautionary tale for medical students. I plan to write about him rarely in the future, and I think we should all agree to ignore his current rage bait, such as his video How to Judge Anthony Fauci: Fauci Diaries and Pleading the 5th. Who cares what Dr. Prasad thinks about Fauci’s diary? Not me.
While Dr. Prasad’s future should be complete irrelevancy, it’s vital to remember his past. He spread copious COVID disinformation and his incompetence/malevolence at the FDA hurt real people. That should never be forgotten, and it’s understandable why he’d rather talk about 2021 than defend his own track record, which includes endorsing Kennedy and Trump.
Let’s not forget we are talking about the author of Sabotaging RFK Jr’s Confirmation Will Increase Vaccine Hesitancy here. He wrote that at the same moment Kennedy was promoting the movie Vaxxed 3: Authorized to Kill. Dr. Prasad expected us to believe obviously absurd things like this, and there’s no reason to trust him today. Meanwhile, I was writing articles at the time titled Trusting RFK Jr. to Research Vaccines is Like Trusting a Hungry Python to Babysit a Kitten and Robert Kennedy Jr. & His Doctor Friends May Just Be Getting Started. You can read our work and decide for yourself who was telling the truth two years ago.
However, Dr. Prasad recently returned to one of his safe spaces, the COVID disinformation publication Reason, and this interview is worth discussing. It reveals his strategy to rewrite his dismal tenure at the FDA and that once again the COVID Amnesia Project is seamlessly morphing into the MAHA Amnesia Project.
Both must be fiercely resisted.
“Public Health in This Country Is So Broken”
Dr. Prasad’s interview was titled Public Health in This Country Is So Broken. As measles spreads and lettuce sends people to the hospital thanks to the MAHA/MAGA regime he enabled, he’s obviously not wrong.
However, Dr. Prasad wants everyone to know that none of this is his fault. How convenient! Dr. Prasad was eager to blame 2020 for what’s happening in 2026 and absolve his former bosses for anything that is happening under their abysmal leadership. He had this embarrassing exchange:
There have been a number of measles outbreaks. Do you attribute that to sort of either a loosening of vaccine policy or just a general skepticism, rising skepticism toward vaccines?
I think it’s difficult to attribute. People like to attribute it to what Bobby Kennedy has done, but surely, in order to have the outbreak now, people have to forgo measles vaccines in years prior. And it’s also going on in Canada. So I don’t know how he jumped across the border and did it.
I mean, the truth is there is a growing distrust of establishment medicine. It was precipitated by the pandemic, and it probably is also precipitated by, you know, fringe anti-vaccine voices, and they’ve shattered confidence in the measles vaccines. And so, you know, there’s lower uptake of the measles vaccines. There’s going to be measles outbreaks. To blame it on one person doesn’t make sense to me.
According to Dr. Prasad, fringe anti-vaccine voices exist, and they are to blame for measles, but Kennedy isn’t such a voice. We are further being asked to believe that Kennedy’s 20-year history of anti-vaxx disinformation got magically erased the moment he was sworn in, and his current anti-vaxx disinformation- he claimed the MMR kills kids while in office last year- remains magically restricted to the USA. Dr. Prasad is seemingly unaware that information can jump borders.
This is the wisdom and integrity he brings to the table, and the article U.S. Vaccine Rhetoric Blamed For B.C. Vaccination Rates As Measles Cases Rise revealed the obvious truth. It quoted a provincial health minister as saying:
There’s too many bad actors on social media that just do whatever they do for clicks and spread lies about the need and the opportunities that come with vaccination. We know that the U.S. administration is also spreading misinformation that help spread the deadly virus like measles, so due to these falsehoods, childhood vaccinations are decreasing and the rates of measles are unfortunately increasing.
Indeed MAHA/MAGA doctors like Dr. Prasad aren’t just to blame for measles in the USA, but anywhere Kennedy’s disinformation has an impact.
Dr. Prasad was also asked about his infamous “leaked” memo from November 2025, which claimed the COVID vaccine killed at least 10 children. I wrote at the time that “my mind is open” to whatever evidence he might provide, and I meant it. I said:
Maybe the FDA leaders will surprise me and do something they’ve not done the entire pandemic. If they produce high quality evidence, which is authored by reliable, apolitical FDA professionals and widely accepted by trusted experts, then I will accept it, exactly as I accepted the J&J vaccine killed some people. I will be critical of the FDA officials who missed this important signal. My loyalty is to a process, not an outcome.
However, Dr. Prasad refused to provide a shred of evidence while at the FDA, and the report was only made public after he left office via a document dump from conspiracy theorist Senator Ron Johnson. The report found 0 deaths were definitively linked to the vaccine, while 2 were probable, and 5 were possible. 12 former FDA commissioners also weighed in in NEJM. According to one article:
The commissioners added that all the cases of death that could have been related to vaccination were previously reported to the agency as well as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. FDA staff, after careful review, “drew different conclusions,” they wrote.
As a reminder, Dr. Prasad opposed the pediatric COVID vaccine in early 2021, months before there was a pediatric COVID vaccine, back when he was certain the pandemic was “abating”. Though he claims to be motivated by evidence and data alone, his mind was firmly made up long before there was evidence or data, and he’s never looked back.
Predictably, he’s never acknowledged the dozens of studies, both randomized-controlled trials and observational studies, which demonstrate the vaccine’s benefits for children. The most recent addition to this list was a study of 3.6 million teens and young adults that found:
Myocarditis, pericarditis, and all-cause mortality were consistently more frequent after SARS-CoV-2 infection than after BNT162b2 vaccination.
COVID’s harms are not restricted to myocarditis/pericarditis, unlike the vaccine, though even this is now a just historical issue.
To maintain the illusion that he was right the whole time 5 years-ago, that unvaccinated “healthy” children should repeatedly contract COVID, Dr. Prasad now claims that he was the victim of a grand cover-up. Anti-vaxxers need such conspiracies the way fish require water.
According to Dr. Prasad, his former underlings at the FDA, the same people who loudly sounded the alarm bells about rare blood clots with the J&J vaccine in the spring of 2021, conspired against him to hide kids killed by the COVID vaccine. The Reason interview said:
“They changed the report. I had a draft report with 10 [likely deaths]. They changed it after the media publicity of my letter,” says Prasad, who believes the data were altered for “political or professional” reasons.
Sure, Vinay.
Dr. Prasad’s new standard of evidence is “trust me, bro,” though fortunately only his Sensible Medicine business partners still do. He chose to hook up with Kennedy, and now both his is credibility and relevance are totally gone.
Unlike the COVID Amnesia Project, which had great success, the MAHA Amnesia Project is failing.


What’s the Opposite of a Vaccine Selfie?
Healthcare workers know they are trusted professionals, and most take that responsibility seriously when sharing their vaccination choices with the public. What term should be used for doctors who use their social media clout to influence others to skip an important vaccine dose?
Jonathan Howard on July 1, 2022
Link

Vaccine Selfies
When vaccines arrived, many healthcare workers posted pictures of themselves getting vaccinated. There were two reasons for this. First, many people were ecstatic about finally being protected against the virus after many months of seeing what it could do. People like to share their joy.
Second, like Dr. Jonas Salk giving his son the polio vaccine, they hoped to convey to others their confidence in the vaccine. Writing about the power of images to shape the vaccine narrative, Dr. Brit Trogen said:
For decades, anti-vaccine groups have relied on the power of personal narratives to bolster claims of vaccine danger. Vaccine selfies, accompanied by captions offering moving anecdotes or thoughtful reasoning, provide a fitting and necessary counterargument. Collectively, these images might strike a chord with the nonmedical public in a way that data-driven discussions of vaccine efficacy and infection rates cannot.
Recent research confirms this is true. A paper titled “Communicating Doctors’ Consensus Persistently Increases COVID-19 Vaccinations” showed that there was a “persistent increase in vaccine uptake” when people learn that nearly all doctors support them. Healthcare workers know they are trusted professionals, and most take that responsibility very seriously when sharing their vaccination choices with the public.
Omicron and boosters
With this in mind, let’s turn to a recent article in The New York Times titled “During the Omicron Wave, Death Rates Soared for Older People“. According to the article:
Almost as many Americans 65 and older died in four months of the Omicron surge as did in six months of the Delta wave, even though the Delta variant, for any one person, tended to cause more severe illness.
The reasons for this were the contagiousness of Omicron combined with waning of the first two vaccine doses and low booster rates. While we all hoped otherwise, there was never any guarantee that two doses of the COVID vaccine would provide years of robust protection against a rapidly mutating virus. Doctors with basic knowledge of the subject know that vaccine doses are occasionally added or subtracted as experts learn more about how immunity evolves over time. Changes in the vaccine schedule, even for old vaccines, are not unprecedented, and many vaccines require multiple doses. Children receive 4 doses of the polio vaccine for example, and they receive the DTaP at 2, 4, and 6 months, 15-18 months, 4-6 years, and 11-12 years. Few vaccine experts were shocked that the COVID vaccine needed a booster, especially given how rapidly it mutates.
There is now clear evidence from large studies in different countries (England, UK, Qatar, Israel, Israel, Israel, Israel, USA, USA) showing that boosters are extremely effective at limiting severe disease. The evidence of benefit is apparent even in teenagers (here and here). The first two doses are still the most important, but there’s no question that the booster saves lives and prevents suffering, especially for older people. The third dose should just be called the third dose, not a booster. Getting millions of Americans this dose is very low-hanging fruit for those who aim to prevent hospitalizations and save lives. Approximately 33% of Americans older than 65 have not received it.
“Unmasked, unboosted and unrepentant”
I can’t help but wonder if one small reason booster rates aren’t higher is that influential doctors staged a dramatic production of not receiving it themselves. Consider, for example, a podcast from 12/4/2021 called “Omicron Panic, Natural Immunity, Fluvoxamine, & More“, with three familiar names, Drs. Vinay Prasad, Marty Makary, and Zubin Damania (AKA ZDoggMD).
In this podcast, these doctors made a display of sitting close together in a podcast booth and boisterously boasted about not having been boosted. The transcript reads as follows:
– [Marty] Are you guys boosted being that close or is this an unboosted contact?
– [Zubin] We’re unmasked, unboosted and unrepentant, Marty.
– [Marty] Well, I’m an unboosted male. That’s my preferred pronoun, by the way.
– [Zubin] Oh, is that your pronoun? An unboosted male? Yes, my pronouns are it, they, those and currently unboosted because I got Moderna, which apparently kicks ass….
[Vinay] …I haven’t gotten my booster yet and-
– [Marty] You mean this week you haven’t gotten, ’cause you do weekly boosters, I’m sure.
– [Vinay] Well, eventually, we’re all gonna have to keep boosting.
– [Marty] Yeah, boosting.
– [Zubin] You know, my vaccine card looks like one of those like frequent flyer like coffee cards where they punch the hole, like I boosted here and boosted here and boosted here and when I get 10 boosters, Fauci sends me a Fauci bobblehead that says I am the science.
– [Marty] I’m getting my booster sent with the GNC nutrition vitamins.
– [Vinay] They had the same evidence, you know.
Dr. Makary, who elsewhere called the Omicron variant “nature’s vaccine,” and “omi-cold“, claimed that the booster’s only benefit was that it would lower the hospitalization rate from 1 in 26,000 to 1 in 260,000 in people older than age 65. He said that the “the average age of a breakthrough death is 80,” to which Dr. Damania would reply:
And if you look at a population of 80-year-olds, their time to death in general is not that long.
What was known then?
When this podcast aired, there was already clear evidence the third dose was beneficial. Though the results were only available as a press release, an RCT of 10,000 people showed that a booster was safe and 95% effective at preventing COVID. It has since been published, and it doesn’t take a genius to imagine a vaccine dose that lowered infection rates would also lessen severe disease.
The results from a large observational study were also available when this podcast aired. It found:
Vaccine effectiveness evaluated at least 7 days after receipt of the third dose, compared with receiving only two doses at least 5 months ago, was estimated to be 93% (231 events for two doses vs 29 events for three doses; 95% CI 88–97) for admission to hospital, 92% (157 vs 17 events; 82–97) for severe disease, and 81% (44 vs seven events; 59–97) for COVID-19-related death.
Not only was there clear evidence the boosters were beneficial in December 2021, a new variant that evaded our immune system was on the horizon. The Omicron variant didn’t just sicken older Americans, it also caused unprecedented illness in children, especially unvaccinated ones. One study found:
Nearly 90% of the 397 children hospitalized during Omicron’s predominance had not gotten COVID-19 shots. Cumulatively, the hospitalization rate was more than two times higher among the unvaccinated. About 30% of the children hospitalized had no underlying conditions, and about 20% required time in the intensive care unit (ICU).
Despite this, these doctors framed concern about Omicron as a “panic” and made it clear they saw no need to subject themselves to a third shot, a dose that proved to be incredibly safe.
This was merely a continuation of a pattern for these doctors, especially with regards to vaccinating young people. They objected to the first dose. They objected to the second dose. Of course, they were going to object to the third dose. It’s just a very predictable riff on the classic “too many, too soon” trope, the unofficial slogan of the anti-vaccine movement. For good measure, they were also wrong to fetishize so-called “natural immunity” and wrong about the benefits of vaccination after infection (here, here, and here). Minimizing the vaccine’s benefits while fixating on rare, usually mild side effects is just what they do when they’re not busy saying the pandemic is over. It’s almost as if a diabolical deity is creating new variants specifically to make their Pollyannaish predictions age poorly (here, here, and here).
What is the opposite of a “vaccine selfie”?
Perhaps there was a case to be made in December 2021 that the risk of boosters outweighed the benefits. But these doctors didn’t make that case. A sober discussion wouldn’t have made good theater. Instead, they had to let everyone know they were unmasked, unboosted, and unrepentant. They couldn’t just privately decide to skip the booster and keep that information to themselves. They had to turn their petulant defiance into a public spectacle.
I strongly encourage you to watch the video itself. These doctors thought it was really funny to model risky behavior and announce their booster refusal just as Omicron was taking off. Unless you were an elderly person with cancer, if you were concerned about waning immunity and wanted to protect yourself with a booster, you were a joke to these doctors, an object of ridicule. I previously wrote about their tendency to shame and mock people whom they feel try too hard to avoid the virus. Notably, Dr. Damania strikes a much more conciliatory approach when he when he invites strangers to send him money, saying people should be “super kind and thoughtful to each other“.
Doctors who shared photos of themselves receiving the COVID vaccine were said to be posting “vaccine-selfies”. What term should be used for doctors who use their social media clout to influence others to skip a crucial vaccine dose?

Dr. Jeffrey Flier: Those Who Express Different Views on Health Equity Should Be Demonized, Not Heard
Perhaps if sheltered doctors cared more about health inequities, they wouldn’t have treated a dangerous virus as nothing more than topic for an abstract, salon-style debate.
Jonathan Howard on May 7, 2024
Link

What I saw was truly outrageous, requiring serious inquiry by the dean and the accrediting body
The Washington Free Beacon’s tagline is: Covering the enemies of freedom, the way the mainstream narrative won’t. Its Wikipedia page says it was:
Launched on February 7, 2012, as a project of the Center for American Freedom, a conservative advocacy group modeled on the liberal Center for American Progress. The website is financially backed by Paul Singer, an American billionaire hedge fund manager and Republican donor.
According to a recent article there titled ‘Pedagogical Malpractice’: Inside UCLA Medical School’s Mandatory ‘Health Equity’ Class:
Jeffrey Flier, the former dean of Harvard Medical School and one of the world’s foremost experts on obesity, said the curriculum “promotes extensive and dangerous misinformation.”
UCLA “has centered this required course on a socialist/Marxist ideology that is totally inappropriate,” said Flier, who reviewed the full syllabus and several of the assigned readings. “As a longstanding medical educator, I found this course truly shocking.”
One required reading lists “anti-capitalist politics” as a principle of “disability justice” and attacks the evils of “ableist heteropatriarchal capitalism.” Others decry “racial capitalism,” attack “growth-centered economic theories,” and call for “moving beyond capitalism for our health.”
On Twitter, Dr. Flier promoted this article and said:
Pedagogical malpractice at @UCLA medical school. I was prepared to see some questionable things in the mandatory “Health Equity” course, but what I saw was truly outrageous, requiring serious inquiry by the dean and the accrediting body.
Scientists who express different views on Covid-19 should be heard, not demonized
Dr. Flier didn’t always encourage such antagonism about those who held “different views”. At the start of the pandemic, along with Dr. Vinay Prasad, he wrote an essay titled: Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should Be Heard, Not Demonized which said:
We can’t allow questions of science, medicine, and public health to become captives of tribalized politics. Today, more than ever, we need vigorous academic debate… We believe that the bar to stifling or ignoring academics who are willing to debate their alternative positions in public and in good faith must be very high… These critical decisions should be influenced by scientific insights independent of political philosophies and party affiliations. They must be freely debated in the academic world without insult or malice to those with differing views
Dr. Flier’s article was primarily a defense of Dr. John Ioannidis, who at the time said:
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
Yet, as COVID, not the flu, overflowed morgues in NYC and elsewhere, Dr. Flier felt this was just a “different view” that should not be rejected outright, but instead should be rewarded with “vigorous academic debate”. His article concluded:
Scientific consensus is important, but it isn’t uncommon when some of the most important voices turn out to be those of independent thinkers, like John Ioannidis, whose views were initially doubted. That’s not an argument for prematurely accepting his contestable views, but it is a sound argument for keeping him, and others like him, at the table.
Dr. Flier felt it was important that certain privileged individuals not be subject to upsetting words, and on more than one occasion said such verbal unpleasantries posed a “risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19”. As a reminder, tens of millions of people died of COVID. Thankfully, Dr. Ioannidis and Emily Oster seem to be doing just fine.
In contrast, when it comes to health equity courses, Dr. Flier is ready with the insult and malice. He’s prepared to bypass vigorous academic debate and skip right to a serious inquiry by the dean and the accrediting body. He doesn’t seem to feel he has anything to learn from listening to others on the topic. His attitude is basically, Those Who Express Different Views on Healthy Equity Should Be Demonized, Not Heard.
A serious inquiry from powerful figures would, of course, intimidate and silence those being investigated. Dr. Flier seems to perceive certain ideas as so dangerous and powerful, that he doesn’t trust medical students to even be exposed to them, as if reading an essay about socialist/Marxist ideology would instantly convert UCLA medical students (stop and think about who is admitted into UCLA medical school) into socialist and Marxists. He portrays these students – the most outstanding among their peers – as delicate, highly-impressionable students need a safe space to shield them from different ideas- and the people who hold them. In reality, the handful of students who actually do the reading aren’t being exposed to these ideas for the first time and they are perfectly capable of processing the information on its merits.
Like nearly every other medical professional, I’ve never encountered the words “ableist heteropatriarchal capitalism” before, and I don’t envision a future where such rhetoric becomes a routine part of hospital life. After all, the article that mentioned “ableist heteropatriarchal capitalism”, Disability Justice – a Working Draft– written in 2015 on a blog called Sins Invalid. It has a total of 11 comments. I am not sure if it had any real-world impact. Yet, Dr. Flier believes it threatens the core of medicine today.
A Phony Invitation for “Discussion and Debate”
However, my purpose here is not to defend the curriculum at UCLA, but rather to show that health inequities are real, consequential, and often glossed over by those not impacted by them. Indeed, the causal way Dr. Flier approached pandemic tragedies shows why it’s crucial for medical students to learn about this topic.
In a previous essay titled A Phony Invitation for “Discussion and Debate” I discussed this Tweet of Dr. Flier’s:
Dr. Flier then linked to an article titled Covid Vaccines Shouldn’t Be ‘Routine’ for Kids by Dr. Vinay Prasad, a pro-infection, anti-vaccine doctor whose misinformation has been discussed here many times previously. Naturally, the arguments Dr. Prasad made to let millions of unvaccinated children contract a potentially deadly virus when a strongly effective vaccine was was available were not “quite reasonable”, as Dr. Flier claimed. They were, in fact, absurd.
Read this article
Covid Death Rate Among White Children Nearly Three Times Higher Than Black Kids
While Dr. Flier still refuses to discuss or debate this topic with me, one wonders whether he would have treated pediatric COVID with a smidgeon of gravity, as something more than pseudo-academic exercise, had his community been more impacted by COVID. Would he have issued fake invitations to discuss and debate farcical arguments against a strongly effective vaccine if the headlines read: Covid Death Rate Among White Children Nearly Three Times Higher Than Black Kids or White Children Disproportionately Impacted by Severe COVID-19 and Related Illness, Data Reveals?
Obviously, we’ll never know. We only know what happened in this world. And in this world the headlines read: Covid Death Rate Among Black Children Nearly Three Times Higher Than White Kids and Children of Color Disproportionately Impacted by Severe COVID-19 and Related Illness, Data Reveals.
While it’s absolutely true that health equities can be taught better, they also need to be taken more seriously. Absurdities in the curriculum is not a valid reason to dismiss the entire project. However, some privileged doctors were so intent on creating a moral panic about these occasional absurdities that they never paused to humbly consider whether they might have something to learn about the topic. Maybe if they had been a bit more open and curious about the impact of health inequities, and a bit less focused on performative virtue-signalling, they wouldn’t have dismissed pediatric COVID so casually.
Indeed, Dr. Flier is not at all perturbed by doctors who spread “extensive and dangerous misinformation” regarding vaccines. In fact, he promotes and amplifies these voices. Instead, he is truly outraged by an overly-woke curriculum. In a pandemic where unvaccinated children suffered needlessly, he feels this curriculum needs an investigation at the highest level.
While I won’t argue that future doctors need to be warned about “ableist heteropatriarchal capitalism”, it’s vital that they learn that there are significant inequities in how COVID- and many other health issues- impact various communities. Because also in this world, some doctors treated a dangerous virus as nothing more than topic for an abstract, salon-style debate, as if there were no real-world consequences to withholding a strongly effective from children as the virus swirled around them.
Sadly, there were real-world consequences. Real children- mostly children of color– suffered grave, preventable harms because doctors, sheltered from the consequences of their words, misinformed their parents about the risks of COVID and the value of the vaccine. This was a bigger problem than medical students reading an essay about “ableist heteropatriarchal capitalism”. This was truly outrageous and it shouldn’t really be up for “discussion and debate.”

Woke Washing the Pandemic: If You Really Were Progressive, You’d Want Them Infected
Genuine concern is consistent concern.
Jonathan Howard on May 3, 2024
Link

Others use woke washing as a way to make their brand look good without doing anything concrete.
Woke washing is defined as:
The act of using social justice themes in marketing campaigns to create a positive image for a company without taking any meaningful action. This practice has become increasingly popular as companies try to capitalize on the growing trends of purpose-driven consumerism. While some companies may genuinely support social justice causes, others use woke washing as a way to make their brand look good without doing anything concrete.
Throughout 2020 and 2021, she gained attention on Twitter and in the media as a critic of K-12 school closure…Since leaving Levi’s, Sey has been a contributing author to the Brownstone Institute, a think tank that opposes various measures against COVID-19, including masking and vaccine mandates
With this is mind, let’s meet Ms. Jennifer Sey. According to her Wikipedia page:
Jennifer Anne Sey (born 1969) is an American author, business executive, and retired artistic gymnast… Following her gymnastics career, Sey entered the business world. She developed a social media following due to her views around school closings during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Wikipedia has this to say about her COVID views:
In February 2022, Sey resigned from Levi’s after nearly 23 years at the company, over disputes with management. Sey claims the resignation was in regard to her views on school closures during the COVID-19 pandemic. Throughout 2020 and 2021, she gained attention on Twitter and in the media as a critic of K-12 school closure.
Ms. Sey wrote a book describing her transition from Levi’s executive to Twitter virologist titled Levi’s Unbuttoned: The Woke Mob Took My Job but Gave Me My Voice. According to the Amazon description, Ms. Sey “had led the company’s initiatives on gay rights, women’s reproductive rights, or gun control.” Yet:
When she refused to blindly follow the narrative on the government response to COVID-19, her previously loyal “woke” community turned on her.
This feeling of betrayal and abandonment from her liberal community is a frequent theme of Ms. Sey’s and a part of her origin story. One way she builds credibility is to portray herself as someone who stayed true to liberal values, in contrast to those who tried to slow the virus. One typical interview contains this exchange:
Q: You were a Democrat for 30 years. You now say you’re politically homeless. How does that feel, and how do you respond to those who say that you must be a Republican now because you’re not a Democrat?
A: I think the Democratic Party has severely underestimated how many people like me there are: lifelong Democrats who watched as their basic rights just to move freely and send their kids to school were taken away for over a year, which seems to me the most undemocratic thing I can fathom. I didn’t register as a Republican. I have issues with both sides. The idea that if you talk to someone then you automatically hold all of their beliefs is ludicrous. And that kind of defines this moment for me.
Q: What do you think people most get wrong about you?
A: That I’ve somehow been red-pilled and now I’m this alt-right, QAnon conspiracy theorist. I very logically challenged and questioned policies that have now been proven to be incredibly harmful. I stayed true to what I thought the Democratic Party stood for. I don’t think I’ve changed.
Yet, Ms. Sey’s Wikipedia page also says this:
Since leaving Levi’s, Sey has been a contributing author to the Brownstone Institute, a think tank that opposes various measures against COVID-19, including masking and vaccine mandates, and has written columns for the New York Post about the “woke mob” and cancel culture. In February 2023, Sey compared COVID-19 health precautions to sexual abuse.
The Joyful Warriors of Moms for Liberty
Indeed, Ms. Sey is friendly with Mr. Jeffrey Tucker, the founder of the anti-vaccine misinformation group the Brownstone Institute and sponsor of the Great Barrington Declaration, which promised that herd immunity would arrive in 3-6 months if 250 million unvaccinated Americans contracted COVID simultaneously in the fall of 2020. Beyond promoting the mass infection of unvaccinated youth with a virus that killed thousands of them, Mr. Tucker has also encouraged children to smoke and is an unapologetic advocate for child labor, as detailed in his essay Let the Kids Work.
Ms. Sey appears to be totally fine with all of this.
In an article titled Leaked Brownstone Institute Emails Reveal Support for Child Labor, Underage Smoking Walker Bragman reported:
What the emails do show, however, is Brownstone founder Jeffrey Tucker and several Brownstone contributors, including one of the institute’s 2023 fellows, discussing the merits of “the good old days” when children smoked tobacco and performed labor. The group lamented how young people today don’t share their values and are allegedly coddled and entitled.
In the course of the conversation, Tucker admitted to supporting “youth” cigarette smoking and labor. At one point, he confessed that he had even provided his high schooler son with cigarettes to get him away from marijuana. Later in the conversation, Tucker wrote that he would “fully [repeal] the 1936 ‘child labor’ law,” because “it is cruel and robs kids of a good life.”
“I got around the law with a job at 12 (tuning church organs),” he wrote. “But these days, it is much more difficult. We condemn the kids to a life of desk sitting, only allowing them remunerative work at the age of 16 just when they have packed their schedules full of other useless stuff. So you have people entering the workforce at the age of 24 never having been in a job. They immediately sue their employers for discrimination or whatever”…
Meanwhile, self-described “open schools mom”Jennifer Sey, a former top Levi Strauss executive who parted ways with the company over disagreements about her online advocacy against school closures and mask mandates, which she argued were causing undue harm to children, complimented Tucker’s pro-child labor article.
“Jeffrey—I like that you mention gymnastics as evidence of young people liking danger. It’s true!” Sey wrote. “Sadly not so much anymore. They want safe spaces. Disagreement is violence. I wish I hadn’t broken so many bones and landed on my head so many times but at least I’m not a wimp. I can endure physical and psychic pain stoically.”
“Ah the good old days,” she quipped. “Next I’ll be shouting ‘get off my lawn!’”
Ms. Sey’s contributions to the Brownstone Institute include articles such as The Joyful Warriors of Moms for Liberty, which glorifies the book-banning hate group that targets LGBTQ people and people of color. Today, Ms. Sey counts proponent of the Great Replacement theory Tucker Carlson as a friend and is the founder a clothing line, XX-XY Athletics, which is dedicated to opposing transgender athletes.
All this from a woman who claims she “stayed true to what I thought the Democratic Party stood for”.
Marginalized groups- LGBTI+ people, sex workers, drug users & homeless were disproportionately impacted by Covid regulations
Hopefully it will not be controversial to say that whatever noble actions Ms. Sey may have taken in the past, she is hardly a paragon of progressive thought today. Indeed, she made a video titled Wokeism Is a Costume Elites Wear to Pretend They Care About Social Justice. Yet, under very specific circumstances during the pandemic, Ms. Sey, who is an elite, was eager to cosplay as a woke social justice warrior. Version 1 of Ms. Sey railed against the woke mob on Tucker Carlson, while her alter ego, Version 2, performatively lamented the pandemic’s effects on marginalized groups- though only when it came to mitigation measures, never the virus.
Version 2 of Ms. Sey claimed to be very concerned about discrimination against Black and Latino children- only when it came to COVID vaccines.
Version 2 of Ms. Sey claimed to be very concerned about teen suicide- only when she could use it to spread fake statistics about pediatric COVID or spread misinformation that suicides were a direct effect of remote learning.
Misinformation alert: The pediatric death rate was not 1 in a million.
“There was no clear guidance. It was just, ‘Trust us, send the kids back, and it’ll be okay.’”
Though I’ve not seen Ms. Sey amplify these voices, it’s worth reading articles such as Why Black Parents Aren’t Joining the Push to Reopen Schools and Some Families of Color Remain Wary of Returning to Classrooms as New School Year Begins to learn what Black or Latino parents actually had to say in. It turns out that vaccine mandates were Ms. Sey’s chief concern, not theirs. One of these articles reported:
“At the same time that people were talking about reopening, we were seeing [COVID-19] case numbers go up astronomically,” she recalled. “There was no clear guidance. It was just, ‘Trust us, send the kids back, and it’ll be okay.’” When Anderson queried other Black families to see how they were feeling, she discovered she was not alone.
Research bears this out. According to one article:
Research showed that about two-thirds of Black, Hispanic and Asian parents nationally needed masking, teacher vaccinations, regular testing and most of all classroom ventilation to feel their youngest school-age child would be safe learning in person. White parents were much less worried, with just 32 percent needing masking requirements and 35 percent citing testing.
Another article from May 2021 titled What’s Behind The Racial Divide On School Reopening? reported:
According to the mid-February wave of the University of Southern California’s Understanding America survey, nearly 60 percent of both Black and Hispanic parents said they preferred for their children to continue learning remotely, compared to fewer than 30 percent of white parents. In New York, Chicago, and Washington, D.C., white families have opted into in-person education at much higher rates than their Black counterparts when schools partially reopened.
Though they didn’t learn it from Ms. Sey, these parents were well aware that the virus impacted their communities first and hardest. They were wise enough not to blindly trust privileged voices from outside their community who insisted their children had no risk and should return to school with zero protections.
Read about Sklyar here
Covid Death Rate Among Black Children Nearly Three Times Higher Than White Kids
To be clear, Ms. Sey was not wrong that the pandemic, like pretty much everything else, disproportionately affected marginalized groups. However, was the founder of XX-XY Athletics really distraught that COVID mitigation measures greatly impacted LGBTI+ people?
I may have missed it, but since COVID arrived, I’ve not seen her champion LGBTI+ people, sex workers, drug users & homeless people apart from her objections to mitigation measures. I never saw her propose that these marginalized groups receive extra assistance and resources during the pandemic.
Ms. Sey’s grave worry about teen suicide was entirely limited to when schools had remote learning. She Tweeted about suicide 21 times in 2021. Schools are now open, and she hasn’t Tweeted about suicide once in 2024. She certainly never shared articles titled Teen Suicide Plummeted During Covid-19 School Closures, New Study Finds.
I never saw her lament when schools closed due to overwhelming COVID outbreaks. Though she had plenty of opportunities, I never saw her share stories like this one from Texas in 9/2021- At Least 45 Districts Shut Down In-Person Classes Due To Covid-19 Cases. It said:
Caseloads have left districts scrambling when many have said they have fewer tools at their disposal to combat the spread of the virus.
Despite her concern over Black children, she never shared articles such as Covid Death Rate Among Black Children Nearly Three Times Higher Than White Kids. I never saw her mourn the loss of a Black or Latino child who died of COVID. In fact, she repeatedly minimized pediatric COVID, even after it was clear children of color suffered the most. The headline below and her Tweet, minimizing literal death for children, were just two weeks apart.
Ms. Sey’s minimization of literal death from COVID was part of a pattern that started even before anyone was vaccinated. The fact that mitigation measures successfully protected children in 2020 was used as “evidence” they were not needed at all. In contrast to literal death, Ms. Sey, who claimed she had “nothing against vaccines”, predictably was on high alert to scold anyone whom she felt minimized a rare, usually mild vaccine-side effect.
We should take a moment to thank essential workers who actually got Covid & contributed to herd immunity
So why was Ms. Sey very concerned about social justice issues only when it came to COVID mitigations, and why was her solution only to remove those mitigations?
Obviously, genuine concern is consistent concern.
Indeed, Ms. Sey was genuinely concerned about mitigation measures, and so Versions 1 and 2 of Ms. Sey consistently agreed on just one thing- mitigation measures needed to go. In contrast, only Version 2 of cared about marginalized groups, and even then the concern was in regards to how they might be affected by vaccine mandates, as if this was the biggest threat they faced. Indeed, notice how differently Ms. Sey discussed literal death from COVID compared to how she discussed the potential harms of vaccine mandates.
Obviously, this highly-selective “concern” had everything to do with Ms. Sey’s disdain for COVID mitigations and nothing to do with any sincere concern for marginalized groups. Basically, Ms. Sey woke-washed the pandemic. Like a corporation putting up a rainbow flag, she was trying to make her “brand look good without doing anything concrete”.
She was hardly unique in this regards. Like Ms. Sey, many pro-infection doctors similarly code-switched between two identifies. Version 1 went on Fox News to advocate for herd immunity through mass infection. After this failed miserably, Version 2 emerged, to retroactively claim the sole motivation for removing mitigations was a benevolent concern for “learning loss for children, especially in poor families” and the “essential working class“. If you have not done so already, please read my articles The Failed “We Want Them Infected” Movement Is Trying to Rebrand Itself As The “All We Really Wanted Was Poor Kids in School” Movement and Dr. Jerome Adams Was Right. They Wanted Them Infected. That’s a Fact. Like Ms. Sey, these doctors’ “concern” about marginalized groups and teen suicide existed only in relation to their opposition to COVID mitigations. To this day, they frequently lament remote schooling that ended years ago, but are utterly silent about more recent headlines that read Third Teen Worker Killed In Industrial Accident As States Try To Loosen Child Labor Laws.
Of course, it’s not clear who deputized Ms. Sey to be the voice of marginalized groups when it came to COVID policy. I never saw any Black or Latino people claim to speak on behalf of wealthy, White business executives like her. However, many highly-privileged people, sheltered from the consequences of their words, felt perfectly entitled to speak on behalf of Black and Latino parents, even as they contradicted the policy preferences of a majority of them. These people of privilege simply anointed themselves as spokespeople for marginalized groups to further their goal of herd immunity through mass infection. They then disregarded the impact of the virus in those marginalized groups. They valiantly defended Black and Latino children against vaccine mandates, while simultaneously blowing off the virus, the thing that killed and sickened many of them. This did not go unnoticed.
While such concern over marginalized groups was disingenuous virtue signalling, it nonetheless served a broader purpose. By co-opting progressive issues and rhetoric, people like Ms. Sey sought to give a permission structure for those who wanted to think of themselves as liberal to resist mitigation measures. In fact, Ms. Sey told them it was their obligation to do so. Though the goal was to let the virus rip for the sake of herd immunity, the framing was one of social justice. Publicly feigning concern over marginalized groups was also a way of calling progressives hypocrites for rejecting the philosophy of mass infection. By claiming to truly represent liberal values, Ms. Sey became a valuable ambassador for the We Want Them Infected movement who said in essence:
If you were really concerned about marginalized groups, you’d opposed COVID mitigations. If you were really concerned about Black and Latino people in public spaces, you’d oppose vaccine mandates. If you were really concerned about teen suicide, you’d open schools months before any children were vaccinated. If you really were progressive, you’d want them infected.
Jennifer Sey Keeps Getting Canceled for Speaking Up
Although anti-public health outfits now celebrate Ms. Sey with nonsense articles titled Jennifer Sey Keeps Getting Canceled for Speaking Up, the truth is that like many “silenced” voices, Ms. Sey became a mini-celebrity during the pandemic. She has been discussed on NPR, MSNBC, Fox News, The NY Post, and The NY Times, even though all she really did was quit her job. Sadly, in many circles she’s more famous than people who actual accomplished things during the pandemic, like Katalin Karikó. It’s clear however, that Ms. Sey knows how to attract an audience, and even those of us who wanted to vaccinate children instead of infect them can’t deny that she’s been very effective at getting her message out. The mitigation measures she opposed are long gone. She got everything she wanted- except for herd immunity, of course.
Today, however, instead of taking a victory lap, Ms. Sey wants everyone to know she’s a victim because words hurt her feelings. She describes herself thusly:
I couldn’t remain silent when the lockdowns were cruelly imposed on children during covid. And for the crime of saying I believe public school kids deserve to be able to go to school during the pandemic, like the kids in private schools, I was dragged, demonized and smeared.
Ms. Sey is also soliciting donations to fund a film she is making about school closures during the pandemic. And yet, as child labor laws loosen around the country, this self-proclaimed regular mom who boasts of “advocating for open public schools, disproportionately attended by low income, black and brown students“, is happy to team up with a wealthy libertarian who specifically calls for kids to dropout of public schools so they can smoke cigarettes during their break from working at Walmart and Chick-fil-A.
Make of that what you will.

Is it “Natural and Healthy” When Children Get Sick With COVID?
The notion that society and children benefit when they contract vaccine-preventable diseases used to be relegated to the fringes of the anti-vaccine movement. It is now embraced by doctors at prestigious universities.
Jonathan Howard on August 26, 2022
Tweet

Almost “everything old is new again”
A frequent theme at Science Based Medicine is that when it comes to minimizing COVID and spreading misinformation about vaccines, “everything old is new again“. Every argument made in favor of leaving children vulnerable to COVID is a recycled anti-vaccine talking point. It’s all very familiar to those of us who’ve been immersed in the anti-vaccine movement.
What’s new is who is making these arguments and how influential they’ve been.
“Getting sick is not a bad thing”
With this is mind, let’s examine of the more absurd pre-pandemic beliefs about vaccine-preventable diseases, namely that they are beneficial for children. A typical example comes courtesy of Dr. Jennifer Margulis, an author who describes herself by saying “I am not anti-vaccine, I am pro-questions”. She is, of course, anti-vaccine. But it goes beyond that. In a documentary called The Vaccine War, she said:
Why are we giving children so many vaccines? They get four times the number of vaccines than I got when I was child growing up in the ’70s. As a parent, I would rather see my child get a natural illness and contract that the way that illnesses have been contracted for at least 200,000 years that homo sapiens has been around. I’m not afraid of my children getting chicken pox. There are reasons that children get sick. Getting sick is not a bad thing.
This is not just anti-vaccine, but pro-virus. It is also wrong. Children do not benefit from getting sick with chickenpox. While very few children suffer serious consequences from chickenpox, it killed about 100 people per year before the vaccine and hospitalized 10,500 more. Moreover, children who contract chickenpox are at risk for shingles, a painful, and potentially devastating disorder that can cause blindness and cardiovascular disease. Church bells didn’t ring for the chickenpox vaccine they way they did for the polio vaccine, but it’s good that fewer children suffer thanks to this vaccine.
“For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life”
Now, let’s examine one of the pandemic’s more absurd essays, “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?“, by Drs. Vinay Prasad and Allison Krug. Doctors with real-world responsibility for sick children, unlike Drs. Prasad and Krug, would answer with a resounding “NO”, especially before children have been vaccinated. After all, before he inexplicably turned completely against the pediatric COVID vaccine, even Dr. Prasad conceded that “Vaccines protect against severe disease and side-effects such as MIS-C“. He was absolutely right, and while the vaccine isn’t perfect, this is exactly why pediatricians are eager to vaccinate their patients.
Though Omicron was milder per child, Omicron hospitalized 5-times more children than the Delta variant because it was so much more contagious. Over 900 children per day were hospitalized during its peak in January 2022. Some pediatric hospitals were overwhelmed, schools closed due to sick staff, and about 20% of pediatric deaths occurred during the winter Omicron wave. Drs. Vinay and Krug published their article on February 2nd, 2022 after most of this had occurred, and played word-games by writing that the “Omicron variant resulted in 66% fewer hospitalisations than [Delta] in a study of children younger than 5 years.”
However, beyond this sophistry, the article by Drs. Prasad and Krug contained very familiar sentiments. They wrote that measures to protect children:
Are premised on the idea that America’s children must be shielded from exposure to Covid-19. What kids really need, however, is a return to normal. And when it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…
Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger.
“Immunity is built through illness,” they said.
This is not just anti-vaccine, but pro-virus. It is also wrong. Immunity is built through vaccines as well as illness, and there’s no evidence immunity to COVID lasts a lifetime. Most importantly, it’s not “healthy” when children get sick with COVID.
Image credit xkcd.com
It’s good when children get sick: Societal benefits
Pro-virus arguments take two forms: sick children are good for society and sickness benefits individual children. Prior to the pandemic, these ideas were relegated to the fringe of the anti-vaccine movement, though they are now promoted by highly-credentialed doctors at prestigious universities with access to powerful politicians.
The idea that children should get sick to protect vulnerable adult precedes COVID, and is one of the main arguments anti-vaxxers used against the chickenpox vaccine. According to this twisted logic, children with chickenpox provide an “immune boost” to adults, who are then less likely to get shingles. For this reason, it’s good when unvaccinated children contract chickenpox. This is, of course, completely false, and even if it were true, infecting children to protect adults is a moral abomination. Children have the right to be protected against diseases that can harm them.
Not everyone sees it this way. Drs. Prasad and Krug embraced this anti-vaccine myth saying:
Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
Promoting the idea that sick children should be used as human shields for COVID as well, they favorably quoted Dr. Francois Balloux who said:
I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.
They also favorably quoted a paper in The BMJ that said:
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood… This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
The notion that there are societal benefits when children get sick with COVID was the entire basis behind the Great Barrington Declaration, and members of the UK’s Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation felt “that natural infection in children could have substantial long-term benefits on COVID-19 in the UK”.
Dr. John Ioannidis also wrote about the benefits of sick, unvaccinated children. At the start of the pandemic, he lamented that “school closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”. He later wrote an article titled “COVID-19 in Children and University Students“. After presenting an argument for vaccinating young people based on “indirect benefits to other age groups and society at large,” he said:
However, the opposite arguments also exist, e.g. vaccinating the youngest age strata may shift infection to higher ages with high fatality especially as many elderly people in many countries are still not vaccinated and some vaccinated elderly have insufficient immune responses. Vaccinated people may still transmit the virus; given that vaccinations make infections milder/asymptomatic and people markedly increase exposures after vaccination (a risk compensatory behavior), vulnerable people may be exposed more frequently to vaccinated infected youth who are unaware of their infection.
Via this strange reasoning, the fact that “vaccinations make infections milder/asymptomatic” is a strike against the vaccine. It’s not enough for children to merely contract the virus, in order to protect elderly people, they must also feel really sick.
There’s no evidence for any of this. Even though the CDC published data this February that 75% of children have contracted COVID, the oft-promised herd immunity has yet to arrive. Meanwhile, the only “substantial long-term benefits” the UK got for their high rates of pediatric “natural immunity” were headlines that read, “Children Drive Britain’s Longest-Running Covid Surge” and “Twice as Many People Died With Covid in UK This Summer Compared With 2021“. Moreover, not all children are “spared serious disease”.
It’s good when children get sick- individual benefits
Beyond this, anti-vaccine doctors have long claimed that getting sick is good for individual children. In his book Vaccines, Autoimmunity, and the Changing Nature of Childhood Illness, Dr. Thomas Cowan, who blamed 5G for COVID and recently surrendered his medical license, said:
We (modern doctors) have forgotten (or never learned) that acute disease—disease that is typically self-limiting and usually accompanied by fever, rash, and pus—is the primary way the body rids itself of unwanted toxins or other substances.
Dr. Sherri Tenpenny, who claimed that COVID vaccines magnetize people, said:
We’ve got to stop calling chickenpox and measles diseases, because they’re not. They’re infections, and infections come and go in a week to ten days, and leave behind a lifetime of immunity. A disease is something that comes and stays, and frequently can’t be cured. So when you vaccinate to avoid an infection, what you potentially are doing is causing a disease.
Dr. Kelly Brogan and Sayer Ji wrote an article titled “HPV Vaccine Maker’s Study Proves Natural HPV Infection Beneficial, Not Deadly” in which they argued that the best way to prevent complications from HPV infections was to get infected with HPV. They wrote:
Given the possibility that HPV infection itself confers protection against HPV reinfection and its more serious health implications (e.g. CIN1+), and that the HPV vaccine may not offer the same level of protection that our inborn adaptive immune responses to natural HPV infection does, we should pause to question the dominant HPV memes circulating out there – via the CDC, the pediatricians, the mainstream media – that proffer HPV is a ‘vaccine-preventable’ disease that we are morally and socially obligated to engage ‘preventively’ through vaccinating every susceptible adolescent on the planet. This fear-borne meme driving the herd to vaccinate against HPV—and everything else —is at least as infectious as the very virus they falsely promise their bivalent and quadrivalent vaccines will defeat.
This makes as much sense as shaving your hair off to keep from going bald, but it’s how many doctors now talk about pediatric COVID.
Dr. Suzanne Humphries wrote an article titled “The Benefits of Having a Natural Measles Infection“, which claimed that measles treats kidney disease and cancer. “Why not just let wild measles circulate and do the job nature intended at the time of life it was intended, which leads to 65 years of immunity and no need for life-span vaccination?”, she asked. How would the authors of “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?” answer this question, I wonder? Many “pro-vaccine” doctors merely substitute “measles” for “COVID” in that sentence, and demand this be taken seriously.
There’s even a children’s book celebrating measles. The blurb on the pro-virus book Melanie’s Marvelous Measles says,
Melanie’s Marvelous Measles was written to educate children on the benefits of having measles and how you can heal from them naturally and successfully. Often today, we are being bombarded with messages from vested interests to fear all diseases in order for someone to sell some potion or vaccine, when, in fact, history shows that in industrialised countries, these diseases are quite benign and, according to natural health sources, beneficial to the body.
The idea that vaccine-preventable diseases are “natural and healthy” appeals to many people. Unsurprisingly, parents who have been mislead by pro-virus doctors occasionally seek out diseases for their children, even after vaccines were available. According to a news report from 2019
Gov. Matt Bevin of Kentucky said this week that he and his wife made sure all nine of their children got chickenpox. “Every single one of my kids had the chickenpox,” Mr. Bevin said in an interview on Tuesday with a radio station in Bowling Green, Ky. “They got the chickenpox on purpose because we found a neighbor that had it and I went and made sure every one of my kids was exposed to it, and they got it. They had it as children. They were miserable for a few days, and they all turned out fine.”
A report on a recent measles outbreak was titled “Low Vaccination Rates and ‘Measles Parties’ Fueled 2019 Measles Outbreak in NYC“.
Reasonable doctors used to discourage parents from exposing their unvaccinated children to such viruses. Before the pandemic, only anti-vaccine quacks would extol the benefits of sick children. Things are very different now.
What are the benefits of children feeling sick from COVID?
It’s true that diseases like COVID and chickenpox are more benign for children than adults. In a fantasy world where natural immunity leads to permanent immunity and vaccines didn’t exist, exposing children to these viruses may be defensible. Moreover, no one would suggest that it would be healthy for a child to grow up in a completely sterile environment. However, there’s no evidence that any particular vaccine-preventable disease -not chickenpox, not measles, not HPV, not COVID- is beneficial for children, nor is there evidence that it’s beneficial when children feel sick and rotten.
And this brings us back to the statement by Drs. Prasad and Krug. They wrote about letting children get Omicron and said, “For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life”. They haven’t written Carla’s Crazy Cool COVID yet, but it’s probably just a matter of time. At least traditional anti-vaxxers have the courage to claim that sick children are lowering their cancer risk or ridding themselves of “unwanted toxins or other substances”. Drs. Prasad and Krug merely say getting sick is part of a “natural and healthy life” without saying what is so beneficial about the whole process.
Like Ms. Margulis, Drs. Prasad and Krug want their readers to believe that just because something is natural, it must also be healthy. This is a very effective marketing technique, famously expressed by Gwyneth Paltrow who said “I don’t think anything that is natural can be bad for you”. While the immune response triggered by both the vaccine and the virus is completely natural, the idea that viruses are beneficial because they are “natural” and vaccines are dangerous because they are “unnatural” is one of the central tenets of the anti-vaccine movement. Perhaps if Dr. Prasad hadn’t thought it was beneath him to learn about the naturalistic fallacy in relation to vaccines, he might not sound exactly like Ms. Margulis and other anti-vaccine doctors today.
Moreover, like Ms. Margulis, Drs. Prasad and Krug chose to say being “sick” was natural and healthy. I hate having a sore throat, muscle aches, a headache, and fever. Don’t you? In an article about “COVID centrist” doctors such as Dr. Prasad, Lydia Greene wrote,
Often an antivaxxer will just look at mortality rates and completely gloss over morbidity associated with vaccine preventable disease. These “centrist” doctors do the very same thing. My 3 year old caught covid before being vaccinated. He developed viral conjunctivitis, GI pain, ear infection, and pneumonia. He did not die. Although without medical intervention his mortality risk would have definitely been substantially higher. His vaccinated family had a much milder disease course by comparison. According to these centrists, I should not have vaccinated his siblings for covid at all. After what we went through with my youngest who is a healthy and energetic young boy, I beg to differ. Vaccines prevent suffering regardless of age. I am so glad the rest of us were vaccinated for covid, and when it did become available for my youngest, I jumped at the opportunity.
Most children don’t get seriously ill from COVID, but if the vaccine can limit these symptoms for some of them – and the vaccine can lower SARS-CoV-2 infections – that’s not a bad thing, is it? After all, Dr. Prasad, who has different standards for harms caused by the virus versus those caused by the vaccine, used such symptoms to argue against the pediatric vaccine, saying it could cause:
About maybe 14,000 kids suffering grade three fevers, and maybe 880 suffering grade four fevers, which is more than one day. And I guess when you add in the myalgia, when you add in the arthralgia, when you add in the sort of headache, the fogginess, all these things, I mean, I think you have a tough sell.
Of course, COVID can cause all of this and much more. Over 140,000 children have been sick enough to need hospital-level care, some intubated in the ICU. We have to be humble about the possibility of long-term sequelae. Neurological complications are not rare in hospitalized children. Moreover, the virus killed over 1,750 children. Getting sick and recovering wasn’t part of a natural and healthy life for them, and this number would have been lower had more children been vaccinated.
Just because something is natural, doesn’t mean it’s healthy. Doctors should know this already.J Howard

Dr. Sunetra Gupta Versus Dr. Sunetra Gupta
WWTI doctors’ cared only about infecting unvaccinated children with SAR-CoV-2, and they were willing to blatantly contradict themselves and make things up achieve this goal.
Jonathan Howard on October 18, 2024
Link
Dr. Sunetra Gupta on SARS-CoV-2
An article from September 2020 titled Let Children Be Exposed To Viruses, Says Professor Gupta said:
Professor Sunetra Gupta, who has been a leading critic of the cost of lockdown, says she welcomes the return of schools as children “if anything… would benefit from being exposed to this and other seasonal coronaviruses”.
Gupta, who is a professor of theoretical epidemiology at Oxford, told The Londoner that alongside huge social and educational benefits, the “evidence is mounting that early exposure to these various coronaviruses is what enables people to survive them”.
Dr. Gupta, an infectious disease epidemiologist and professor of theoretical epidemiology at the University of Oxford, just made that up. The virus was less than a year old when she said this. There was no mounting “evidence” that early exposure to SARS-CoV-2 was beneficial for children, though there was evidence that it was dangerous for some of them.
The next month, Dr. Gupta would partner with a pro-tobacco child labor advocate and two other pro-infection doctors who also made things up to write the Great Barrington Declaration. As SBM readers know, the GBD advocated for the mass infection of unvaccinated youth to hasten the arrival of herd immunity and shield more vulnerable adults. Because Dr. Gupta sought out TV cameras while doctors were busy treating COVID patients, there are many opportunities to hear her in her own words. You can watch her proposal to use unvaccinated children as human shields.
Even though SARS-CoV-2 was brand new, Dr. Gupta felt comfortable with her plan to get rid of the virus by spreading the virus for two reasons. Firstly, she was convinced that immunity to it was durable and long-lasting.
Second, she felt that the pandemic was “on its way out” in May 2020 and that the infection fatality rate (IFR) was close to 1 in 10,000. This low IFR which was mathematically impossible at the time. Dr. Gupta just made it up.
Things didn’t work out that way, unfortunately.
Dr. Sunetra Gupta on the COVID vaccine
However, when it came to the vaccine, Dr. Gupta felt very differently. The same standards did not apply. Dr. Gupta’s first objection to the vaccine was practical. Continuing her habit of just making things up, she falsely said children have didn’t “any risk at all”. Even though the vaccine has already protected children from rare but severe harms, Dr. Gupta felt we shouldn’t use it because the immunity it created wasn’t long-lasting.
Dr. Gupta’s second objection to the vaccine was ethical. Even though everyone was clear that the pediatric COVID vaccine was to protect children against COVID, Dr. Gupta pretended otherwise, saying it was unethical to vaccinate children to shield more vulnerable adults.
So let’s be clear what happened here. With SAR-CoV-2, Dr. Gupta claimed that her plan of herd immunity through mass infection was both wise and ethical. She thought it was appropriate to infect unvaccinated children with a novel virus so they could theoretically serve as human shields for more vulnerable adults. Without a shred of evidence, indeed before it was possible to have such evidence, she claimed that immunity to SAR-CoV-2 was long-lasting, that the pandemic was ending, and COVID posed no risk to children anyways. Although the virus killed and injured some children without creating robust, durable immunity, Dr. Gupta continues to defend her plan to repeatedly infect them with it.
In contrast, even though the vaccine protected children, Dr. Gupta felt it was unethical and unwise to use it. With the vaccine and only with the vaccine, Dr. Gupta worried about waning immunity. With the vaccine and only with the vaccine, Dr. Gupta felt it was wrong to use give it to children to protect more vulnerable adults
Unfortunately, Dr. Gupta versus Dr. Gupta was not an isolated incident. Many doctors spoke one way about SAR-CoV-2 and entirely differently about the vaccine against it. Many of my articles have discussed doctors who treated rare, mild vaccine side-effects as a fate worse than death, for example. Like Dr. Gupta, other pro-infection doctor similarly contradicted themselves. In 2020, Dr. Scott Atlas eagerly cheered infections in unvaccinated young people believing it would hasten the arrival of herd immunity. Later, he became an actor and got “choked up” over the notion, which existed only in his imagination, that anyone would vaccinate young people primarily to shield more vulnerable adults. You can watch his dramatic performance below, combined with an earlier video of him celebrating COVID infections in unvaccinated youth.
Dr. Scott Atlas versus Scott Dr. Atlas
Clearly, consistency and intellectual integrity were not priorities for pro-infection doctors. They repeatedly spread fake numbers, and they didn’t care. They made farcical forecasts that failed to come to fruition. and they didn’t care. They spoke one way about the virus and entirely differently about the vaccine, and they didn’t care. This is because these doctors’ cared only about infecting unvaccinated children with SAR-CoV-2, and they were willing to blatantly contradict themselves and say anything to achieve this goal.

JOHN IOANNIDIS

What the heck happened to John Ioannidis?
John Ioannidis is one of the most published and influential scientists in the world, someone whose skewering of bad medical research we at SBM have frequently lauded over the years. Then the COVID-19 pandemic hit. Since then, Prof. Ioannidis has been publishing dubious studies that minimize the dangers of the coronavirus, shown up in the media to decry “lockdowns,” and, most recently, “punched down”, attacking a graduate student for having criticized him. What happened? Did Prof. Ioannidis change, or was he always like this and I just didn’t see it? Either way, he’s a cautionary tale of how even science watchdogs can fall prey to hubris.
David Gorski on March 29, 2021
Link

I’ve been meaning to write this post for months now, but have hesitated. Up until yesterday, that hesitation has always led to my abandoning the post and choosing a different topic. The reason for my hesitation is that the topic of this post happens to be a scientist whom, before the COVID-19 pandemic hit, I had long admired and whom, as a result of his publications, statements, and activities during the pandemic, I no longer do. I am, of course, referring to John Ioannidis, who first made a splash over 15 years ago, when he published what remains his most famous article, “Why Most Published Research Findings Are False”, leading me (and others) to point out how cranks and quacks have misused and abused Ioannidis’ work to “prove” that science is so unreliable that their quackery or antivaccine pseudoscience should be taken seriously. As you’ve probably already guessed, it was all nonsense. Over the years, Prof. Ioannidis’ work has inspired posts by nearly all of the bloggers who’ve been regulars here at SBM, including topics discussed in his papers such as:
    • How popularity of a scientific topic might lead to more unreliable research
    • The life cycle of translational research and how long it takes to go from idea in cell culture or a test tube to an actual treatment
    • How often seemingly important findings in science don’t hold up in subsequent studies
    • How everything we eat does and doesn’t cause cancer
Don’t get me wrong here. I don’t always agree with Ioannidis; for instance, I think he did exaggerate how often research is “wrong” and, in addition, took major issue with his argument that the NIH is so conservative that only the very “safest” projects are funded and that the “brave maverick scientists” who see “bolts out of the blue” to make great leaps in science tend not to be NIH funded. I’ll return to this particular paper at the end of the post, because now, in retrospect, I see it as a harbinger of Ioannidis’ activities during the COVID-19 pandemic that I missed at the time. Had I been more attuned now to what I had noticed then, it might have led me to be less surprised by Ioannidis’ behavior, in which he’s consistently downplayed the deadliness of COVID-19 and, in doing so, engaged in the same sort of scientific sloppiness that he had become known for skewering in other investigators. I’ll enumerate in more depth in a moment, but before I do please indulge me as I do a little exercise.
A little exercise, for perspective on COVID-19
I realize it’s hard to do now that, as of yesterday, the estimated toll in the US alone from COVID-19 is over 560,000 dead from close to 31 million cases; worldwide it’s nearly 2.8 million deaths out of 128 million cases, with all of those numbers almost certainly being significant undercounts of the true toll. Still, try to envision the situation a year ago. At that time, COVID-19 had only recently arrived in the US, the death toll was still “only” approximately 36,000 worldwide, and by the middle of March in the US there had only been 68 dead due to the disease. Try to envision the world many months before the peak of the latest surge in January, at which time as many as 4,000 people were dying each day in the US of COVID-19.
Before I take you back to those days, there is one useful exercise I like to do to provide perspective. Not unlike the one I did with Marty Makary’s claim that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US in order to show the extreme implausibility of his estimate, it’s just a quick check based on simple math and knowledge of basic statistics alone. (Unsurprisingly, Makary of late has joined the COVID-19 minimization crew, specifically claiming that we will have herd immunity by April, which, last check for me, is only three days away, with my own state of Michigan appearing to be in the middle of a new surge driven by more transmissible variants of the virus.) The entire population of the US is approximately 330 million people. That means that in a little over a year COVID-19 has killed approximately 0.17% of the entire population of the US, or one out of every 589 people. That’s an enormous toll. To give you even more perspective, let’s look at the five leading causes of death in the US every year. At number one, heart disease claims approximately 660,000 Americans a year, while cancer claims 600,000; accidents, 173,000; respiratory disease, 157,000; and strokes, 150,000. COVID-19 was easily the third leading cause of death in 2020 in the US, despite not exacting a large toll until three months into the year. It wasn’t even close.
Next, just as an intellectual exercise, assume that every single American has been infected with COVID-19. If that were true, then that would mean that the “hard” lower bound of the infection fatality rate (IFR) for SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes the disease, is currently approximately 0.17%. (IFR is the fatality rate of all infections, including asymptomatic infections. The case fatality rate, or CFR, represents the fatality rate among people diagnosed with a disease.) Of course, nowhere near 100% of Americans have been infected. Now, if you accept as accurate published estimates that, as of yesterday, 31 million Americans have been infected with COVID-19 (again, it’s almost certainly a massive undercount), that would lead to an estimate of 1.8% as the upper bound of the IFR for COVID-19 in the US. Yes, that is a greater than ten-fold range, and the IFR is certainly much lower than 1.8%, but, again, we definitely have an absolute lower bound for the IFR of 0.17%, which is only continuing to grow, as we are still losing roughly 1,000 people a day to the virus. Thus the IFR is certainly at least double, if not triple 0.17% or more. And, yes, I know that IFR can change as the pandemic progresses. People who might have survived when hospitals were not overrun die when they are, for instance. However, simple statistics can show that claims that COVID-19 is “no more deadly than the flu” are utter nonsense.
So why did I just go through this exercise? Hang on, and you’ll see.
Enter John Ioannidis at the dawn of the pandemic
So why have I, after having procrastinated so much over writing this post, finally pulled the trigger and written it? It came in the context of a recent Twitter discussion about “silencing” of academics who advocate contrarian views about the pandemic and a new paper by Prof. Ioannidis published on Friday. An example of one thread that I saw last week follows:
2/n You know the arguments I mean. They usually go something like "[x famous academic] is being horribly silenced/faced the modern inquisition!"
And they usually come off as, well, nonsense
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) March 26, 2021
And, later:
8/n I mean, Professor Ioannidis is, by all accounts, a lovely guy and a very dedicated researcher
But he's also enormously famous, and clearly in no danger of being "silenced" in any way any time soon
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) March 26, 2021
Which led a friend of the blog, who wrote an excellent book about critical thinking in medicine (reviewed by Harriet Hall) to bring up an example:
Two screenshots below:
The first from the stat news editorial defending JPAI.
The second a quote from JPAI.
Draw your own conclusions. pic.twitter.com/2RwHQV50Pa
— Jonathan Howard (@JHowardBrainMD) March 26, 2021
And, a couple of weeks before:
No. But you are defending a guy who did. Had we taken it seriously last year, maybe we could have tamed it. But so many were mislead into thinking it was no big deal. Those responsible for convincing the public it was a mild threat have no right to complain about lockdowns now. pic.twitter.com/o8nREq8KXa
— Jonathan Howard (@JHowardBrainMD) March 10, 2021
Which brings us back to John Ioannidis. Let’s go through a bit of background first.
Back in April 2020, Ioannidis was co-author of a much-criticized study, COVID-19 Antibody Seroprevalence in Santa Clara County, California. The study was originally published on the pre-print server medRxiv, which by then had become the go-to outlet to publish COVID-19 research before it had been fully peer-reviewed and made it into even the E-pub-ahead-of-print sections of journals. The reason at the time for using preprint servers, which have not been as prominent a year into the pandemic as they were then, was that SARS-CoV-2 and the pandemic were so new and the science was moving so fast that waiting for new papers to go through peer review before they saw the light of day seemed way too slow for the situation.
Ironically, this brings up a point and prediction made by Ioannidis over a year ago with which I most heartily agreed (and continue to agree), namely that governments and public health officials were making decisions without good data. There is no doubt that this was true then (and, to a lesser extent, remains true now). Even a year later, after a tsunami of COVID-19 studies, the science remains more confusing than we would like. Ioannidis also predicted a “once-in-a-century” data fiasco. Even though that was a pretty easy prediction in the early days of the pandemic, you have to give it to the man. He was right. It’s just ironic that Prof. Ioannidis ended up substantially contributing to the data fiasco.
It started when Ioannidis wrote:
If we assume that case fatality rate among individuals infected by SARS-CoV-2 is 0.3% in the general population — a mid-range guess from my Diamond Princess analysis — and that 1% of the U.S. population gets infected (about 3.3 million people), this would translate to about 10,000 deaths. This sounds like a huge number, but it is buried within the noise of the estimate of deaths from “influenza-like illness.” If we had not known about a new virus out there, and had not checked individuals with PCR tests, the number of total deaths due to “influenza-like illness” would not seem unusual this year. At most, we might have casually noted that flu this season seems to be a bit worse than average. The media coverage would have been less than for an NBA game between the two most indifferent teams.
Some worry that the 68 deaths from Covid-19 in the U.S. as of March 16 will increase exponentially to 680, 6,800, 68,000, 680,000 … along with similar catastrophic patterns around the globe. Is that a realistic scenario, or bad science fiction? How can we tell at what point such a curve might stop?
The wag in me can’t help but note that, as of today, the figure of 680,000 deaths used by Prof. Ioannidis as an appeal to ridicule of overblown warnings about COVID-19 death tolls is currently easily the closest to the death toll that we are, unfortunately, likely to see in the US before the pandemic is finally over. Hindsight aside, though, Ioannidis did have a point. If a disease spreads exponentially through an immunologically naïve population, how do you know where it will stop? He just guessed wrong, so very wrong! Normally, there would be no shame in being wrong in such an estimate. Lots of eminent scientists underestimated or overestimated COVID-19 in those very early days of the pandemic. In the fog of uncertainty over a new virus and the potential extent of its spread, coupled with how viruses can spread exponentially, it was very easy for even the best to be off by a factor of ten or even 50. It’s what Ioannidis did subsequently that became the problem. This began a month later, when Ioannidis and colleagues published his most (in)famous COVID-19 study.
Ioannidis’ study (which wasn’t published in The International Journal of Epidemiology until a month ago) examined the prevalence of antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 virus and estimated that between 2.5% and 4.2% of the residents of Santa Clara County had been infected with coronavirus as of early April 2020. That estimate was drastically larger, 50- to 85-fold larger, than had been estimated up to that point using swab testing. Of course, at the time there was a severe shortage of COVID-19 tests, which meant that the true prevalence of antibodies to the virus was likely considerably higher than the official counts at the time, but as much as 85-fold higher? Using this seroprevalence, Ioannidis and his colleagues concluded that the IFR of COVID-19 was around 0.17% (interval: 0.12%-0.2%), only somewhat higher than seasonal influenza at 0.1%. Predictably, this helped feed the narrative at the time that “COVID-19 is not much worse than the flu”, a narrative that still continues to this day.
Even at the time, even in the context of the extreme uncertainty of the early months of the pandemic, that figure seemed implausible, as Geoffrey Barber of WIRED noted not long after the study had been published and hit the national news, using mathematical reasoning similar to that of my little exercise above:
Skeptics have noted that the conclusions seem at odds with some basic math. In New York City, where more than 10,000 people, or about 0.1 percent of the population, have already died from Covid-19, this estimated fatality rate would mean nearly everyone in the city has already been infected. That’s unlikely, since the number of new cases, and deaths, is still mounting, fast. Others pointed to the Stanford group’s unusual use of Facebook recruitment, which may have drawn in people who were sick in February or March and couldn’t get a swab test to confirm it—the situation for a lot of people in Santa Clara County, an early Covid-19 hot zone where tests were initially scarce. That could have led to an oversampling of people who had antibodies to the virus. Others, noting that only 50 out of the 3,330 people tested, or 1.5 percent, actually tested positive, quibbled with the methods used to weight the sample, which skewed heavily white and female.
Others harshly criticized the study’s methodology, pointing out that, given the false positive rate of the then-existing antibody tests and how Ioannidis and crew had not taken the false positive rate into account properly, the study’s results could just as easily been consistent with close to zero infections in Santa Clara County during the time period of the study. Basically, critics pointed out that, due to the low prevalence of COVID-19 in April 2020, the small number of individuals included in the study, and what was known about the specificity of the COVID-19 antibody test, Ioannidis and his co-investigators could not rule out the possibility that the positive test results they got could all have been false positives.
It gets worse:
When the Stanford team — Drs. Jayanta Bhattacharya, John Ioannidis and Eran Bendavid — released the first draft of their Santa Clara County-based preprint, the news was stunning. The nation’s first study of its type, it found that the virus was astoundingly 50 to 85 times more prevalent than presumed. But that meant the death rate was far lower.
Yet the project raised eyebrows from the start.
Even before they started collecting data, the researchers openly questioned “stay at home” orders. Ioannidis wrote a provocative article arguing that if COVID-19 is less deadly, widespread restrictions “may be totally irrational.” A Wall Street Journal editorial by Bhattacharya and Bendavid was entitled “Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say?” Bhattacharya revisited that theme in the Hoover Institution and Fox Nation program “Questioning Conventional Wisdom.”
When their preprint was published, its conclusions backed the trio’s policy arguments – and it was saddled with statistical problems.
It failed to describe key calculations and made at least five material mistakes, according to Will Fithian, assistant professor in UC Berkeley’s Department of Statistics. The population-weighted intervals in a table were miscalculated. The authors plugged the wrong interval into a formula. They made two math errors in executing that formula. And, misreading their test kit’s manufacturer insert, they used the wrong numbers for the antibody test’s specificity.
Oh, did I forget to mention that one of the future authors of the Great Barrington Declaration was a colleague of Ioannidis and co-author of the study? (More on that later.) True, Ioannidis and company did revise and republish the study in late April, but the revised study still estimated that the prevalence of COVID-19 in Santa Clara County at the low end of the original range, which was plenty high. Worse, in the interim, Ioannidis had shown up on Fox News, CNN, and a number of other media outlets promoting his team’s results and using them to cast doubt on the effectiveness of public health interventions and “lockdowns” to slow the spread of the virus.
Then there was this story in Buzzfeed News in July:
Stanford University scientist John Ioannidis has declared in study after study that the coronavirus is not that big of a threat, emboldening opponents of economic shutdowns — and infuriating critics who see fundamental errors in his work.
But even before the epidemiologist had any of that data in hand, he and an elite group of scientists tried to convince President Donald Trump that locking down the country would be the real danger.
In late March, as COVID-19 cases overran hospitals overseas, Ioannidis tried to organize a meeting at the White House where he and a small band of colleagues would caution the president against “shutting down the country for [a] very long time and jeopardizing so many lives in doing this,” according to a statement Ioannidis submitted on the group’s behalf. Their goal, the statement said, was “to both save more lives and avoid serious damage to the US economy using the most reliable data.”
Although the meeting did not happen, Ioannidis believed their message had reached the right people. Within a day of him sending it to the White House, Trump announced that he wanted the country reopened by Easter. “I think our ideas have inflitrated [sic] the White House regardless,” Ioannidis told his collaborators on March 28, in one of dozens of emails that BuzzFeed News obtained through public records requests.
As an aside, I can’t help but point out that, ironically, one member of this group was Dr. David Katz, an “integrative medicine” doctor formerly at Yale whose name should be familiar to longtime readers of this blog for his advocacy of a “more fluid concept of evidence than many of us have imbibed from our medical educations” that he uses to justify using homeopathy.
Dr. Katz aside, early in the pandemic, Prof. Ioannidis published shoddy research on COVID-19 that had raised the suspicion of having been politically motivated, or at the very least Prof. Ioannidis gave the impression of not having been as rigorous in his science as he had long demanded of other scientists. Then he got even worse and started to repeat COVID-19 conspiracy theories, such as the one that claims that COVID-19 death tolls are inflated by inappropriately blaming deaths on COVID-19 that were really due to comorbidities:
He claims- without evidence- that doctors are inflating covid deaths, filling out death certificates wrong. This is one of the most upsetting conspiracies about the pandemic. pic.twitter.com/6gcondnhMU
— Jonathan Howard (@JHowardBrainMD) March 28, 2021
This is what I like to refer to as the “6% gambit,” as the most extreme version of this conspiracy theory is that only 6% of the deaths attributed to COVID-19 were really due to COVID-19. It’s a conspiracy theory that relies on the person believing it having no clue how death certificates are normally filled out.
Why did Prof. Ioannidis consistently minimize COVID-19? Perhaps it was due to hubris, but it could also (or alternatively) been due to his political blindspots. Even so, I’d still say that there is no real shame in being wrong, if only one admits it frankly and tries to correct oneself. Unfortunately, with Prof. Ioannidis, that didn’t happen. Quite the opposite, in fact, as you will see.
“I never said that I knew that the death toll was going to be 10,000”
If there’s one characteristic Prof. Ioannidis has demonstrated during the pandemic, it’s that, whenever his COVID-19 prognostications are criticized or attacked, he tends to deny that he had made them and/or double down on similar arguments. For example, Dr. Howard (mentioned above), loves to compare these two statements:
Please. Ioannidis has underestimated Covid every step of the way and when his errors were pointed out he denied his own words. The scientific American authors similarly distorted his own words. 1/2 pic.twitter.com/XkhzHxJ17W
— Jonathan Howard (@JHowardBrainMD) March 24, 2021
This comes from an interview that Prof. Ioannidis did in Medscape in July, by which point there had been 132,000 deaths in the US:
You’ve criticized models for using faulty data in projecting the death toll. When the lockdown started there were only 60 deaths in the US. You projected 10,000 deaths using an IFR computed from infected passengers on Diamond princess cruise ship. Yet today there more than 132,000 deaths — the figure would likely have been even higher were it not for the social distancing/ lockdown we employed on March 16. Though the mortality numbers are still much lower than the doomsday predictions of Imperial college, they do make your projections overly optimistic.
I never said that I knew that the death toll was going to be “10,000 deaths in the US”. How could I, in a piece where the message was “we don’t know”! The 10,000 deaths in the US projection was meant to be in the most optimistic range of the spectrum and in the same piece I also described the most pessimistic end of the spectrum, 40 million deaths. The point I wanted to emphasize was the huge uncertainty.
Not exactly. First, Prof. Ioannidis was mixing apples and oranges here. His prediction of 10,000 deaths was for the US alone, while that 40 million estimate was for the entire world under a worst case scenario. More importantly, any fair reading of Prof. Ioannidis’ previous article should make it clear that he clearly favored the lowest end of his estimates. In fact, let’s look at his “worst case scenario” estimate in context:
In the most pessimistic scenario, which I do not espouse, if the new coronavirus infects 60% of the global population and 1% of the infected people die, that will translate into more than 40 million deaths globally, matching the 1918 influenza pandemic.
The vast majority of this hecatomb would be people with limited life expectancies. That’s in contrast to 1918, when many young people died.
One can only hope that, much like in 1918, life will continue. Conversely, with lockdowns of months, if not years, life largely stops, short-term and long-term consequences are entirely unknown, and billions, not just millions, of lives may be eventually at stake.
If we decide to jump off the cliff, we need some data to inform us about the rationale of such an action and the chances of landing somewhere safe.
Notice how he explicitly stated that he did not espouse that estimate. Also notice how he immediately pivoted to—you guessed it!—another comparison to the flu, emphasizing how COVID-19 tends to kill the old, not the young, and speculating about the “costs” of “lockdowns”. I also can’t help but note that we already have nearly three million deaths out of nearly 130 million cases worldwide. That’s a death rate of well over 1%. Even if the IFR is under 1%, we’d better hope that nowhere near 50-60% of the global population becomes infected.
Unfortunately, even now, in March 2021, Prof. Ioannidis appears to be sticking to his guns. He just published a paper arguing that the IFR from COVID-19 is actually 0.15%. Worse, he’s used the opportunity to settle scores with—of all people—a graduate student who has a large following on Twitter and has been highly critical of Prof. Ioannidis’ studies.
As a professor of biology named Carl Bergstrom noted:
In his latest paper about COVID infection fatality rates, John Ioannidis does not address the critiques from @GidMK, but instead engages in the most egregious gatekeeping that I have ever seen in a scientific paper. pic.twitter.com/P08sFIovD6
— Carl T. Bergstrom (@CT_Bergstrom) March 28, 2021
The condescension and hypocrisy here is mind-boggling. pic.twitter.com/ppaLt4nt9T
— Carl T. Bergstrom (@CT_Bergstrom) March 28, 2021
Anyway, you can read it for yourself. It's published in the journal for which Ioannidis previously served as Editor in Chief. https://t.co/oN8wFaKCbm
Therein John claims the IFR for COVID is 0.15%.
By official counts, 0.166% of the US population has already died of COVID. pic.twitter.com/NhEI15BhhI
— Carl T. Bergstrom (@CT_Bergstrom) March 28, 2021
Prof. Ioannidis’ study was published in The European Journal of Clinical Investigation on Friday, and, to be honest, strikes me more as score-settling than a dispassionate review article. In particular, Prof. Ioannidis seems preoccupied with settling a score with Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, who in December published with Lea Merone in The International Journal of Infectious Diseases a systematic review and meta-analysis of COVID-19 IFRs that estimated an overall IFR of 0.68% (95% confidence interval 0.53%–0.82%), with a range from 0.17% to 1.7%. From my reading, it was a solid meta-analysis and review.
This is how Prof. Ioannidis responded in his new paper. I’m quoting such a long passage because, quite simply, I could not believe my eyes as I read this. This long attack is in an actual scientific paper, and it took up more than a page of the submitted manuscript:
The evaluations by ICCRT4 and Meyerowitz-Katz1 have multiple flaws as well as eligibility, design, and analytical choices that consistently lead to higher IFR estimates. This raises questions of technical competence and/or bias.
In multiple main media interviews and quotes Meyerowitz-Katz is presented professionally as an “epidemiologist”, but apparently he has not received yet a PhD degree as of this writing and he is still a student at the University of Woolongong in Australia. Neither he nor his co-author of the evaluation (apparently another PhD student) had published any peer-reviewed systematic review or meta-analysis on any topic prior to the pandemic. By the end of 2019, Meyerowitz-Katz had published 2 PubMed-indexed papers (both on diabetes) that had received 2 citations and 1 selfcitation in Scopus. Meyerowitz-Katz is very active also in Twitter through an account called Health Nerd (56,800 tweets as of January 19, 2021). The Twitter account has interesting, smart content with strong advocacy, often supporting worthy causes. The same account has also been generating tweetorial content reviewing various COVID-19 papers, including many critical/highly negative comments on my papers, e.g. on the IFR evaluation.5 For fairness, readers may consult these Twitter criticisms of Meyerowitz-Katz and of another prolific Twitter critic with highly similar views as Meyerowitz-Katz (Atomsk’s Sanakan [64,200 tweets as of January 19, 2021], self-described as “Christian; Science, Denialism Debunked, Philosophy, Manga, Death Metal, Pokémon, Immunology FTW; Fan of Bradford Hill + Richard Joyce”, also supporting several worthy causes, e.g. debunking denialism). The tweetorials have been posted in Pubpeer (https://pubpeer.com/publications/C2A5DD4ED8B5A0B13F63A47FEC143A). Comparison against the present manuscript may hopefully help knowledgeable readers generate an informed opinion as to the merits of arguments raised. I don’t have a personal Twitter account, but was alerted to the negative tweetorials by Meyerowitz-Katz several months ago. At that time, the name of the Twitter account owner was not obviously visible (the photo showed an unrecognizable figure with big glasses and a cat), but Meyerowitz-Katz seemed to use the Twitter account prolifically to promote his own work and criticize work contradicting his work. The identity of the Health Nerd Twitter account has become transparent now, since the owner has added a photo of him (wearing a T-shirt that writes “Trust me, I am an epidemiologist”). The identity of the reverberating Atomsk’s Sanakan Twitter account is still unclear (to me at least) and its relationship to Meyerowitz-Katz, if any, is unknown.
Overall, one potential explanation is that the flaws of the Meyerowitz-Katz evaluation may simply reflect lack of experience and technical expertise of otherwise well-intentioned and smart authors with a heightened sense of advocacy during a serious pandemic that represents undoubtedly a major crisis. It is well-known that most published systematic reviews and meta-analyses in the literature have substantial flaws anyhow. For students performing their first evidence synthesis ever, choosing a topic that requires advanced expertise due to unusual cross-design features, difficult methodological challenges and convoluted and often erratic data, a highly-flawed final product should not be surprising. Perusal of the voluminous Twitter comments of Health Nerd similarly demonstrates immediately the wonderful enthusiasm, but also lack of adequate expertise required to conduct such analyses in any rigorous way. Nevertheless, it is worrisome that trustworthy media like Scientific American and The Guardian have espoused Meyerowitz-Katz’s views and serious organizations may guide their planning based on a flawed paper. Meyerowitz-Katz is a columnist also at the American Council on Science and Health (https://www.acsh.org/profile/gideon-meyerowitz-katz), a pro-industry advocacy group. He reports no conflicts of interest.
I will note here that I’ve criticized ACSH on multiple occasions as being industry-associated astroturf, but this last attack by Prof. Ioannidis goes far beyond the pale. Yes, Meyerowitz-Katz is indeed listed on the ACSH website, but he also only wrote one article for the organization (on Red Bull and energy drinks, of all things), and that article is over three years old. This has to be the most egregious ad hominem that I’ve ever seen, and particularly odd given that industry or business bias would tend to lead one to minimize COVID-19, the better to attack public health interventions that interfere with re-opening businesses. As for the rest, I’ll let Prof. Ioannidis’ own words speak for themselves and wonder how such a prolonged attack on a graduate student by an eminent professor ever got through peer-review. Indeed, I’ve never seen such an attack in a peer-reviewed journal article ever, and I’m not alone:
My jaw is on the floor. I’ve never seen this kind of ad hominem in an academic paper ever, and it’s from a scientist who has so disgraced himself in this pandemic—and in this very paper with mathematically impossible claims—that the hubris is all the more mind-blowing. https://t.co/zGJISOyMeA
— Tara Haelle (@tarahaelle) March 28, 2021
I've seen a lot of "good ol' boys" BS in scientific publishing, but this may be the worst. Not only a bad paper, but it completely punches down at grad students who previously criticized the work. This never would have been published if it didn't have a Big Name attached. https://t.co/wgVBZZgHll
— Dr. Tara C. Smith (@aetiology) March 28, 2021
I have only just started reviewing papers.But if I saw this this, I would advise the author(s) to immediately remove it. Ad hominem and gatekeeping have no place in scientific journals, regardless of how ‘famous’ the author is. https://t.co/kNcEBk5eMI
— Alastair McAlpine, MD (@AlastairMcA30) March 28, 2021
Then it was pointed out to me. Prof. Ioannidis was Editor-in-Chief of The European Journal of Clinical Investigation from 2010-2019. Moreover, unlike most articles of this type, Prof. Ioannidis is the sole author.
One of the targets of Prof. Ioannidis’ ire spent an entire Tweetorial dissecting the distortions in the article. It’s long, but I find its arguments compelling. To summarize, Atomsks Sanakan points out (and documents) that Prof. Ioannidis has a history of cherry picking studies with non-representative samples because studies using representative samples tend to result in an estimate of an IFR higher than his and incompatible with his message. Reading Prof. Ioannidis’ screed disguised as a review article, I couldn’t help but be frustrated at Prof. Ioannidis’ relative lack of detail in the methodology, in which, after a discussion of the search strategy used to locate review articles and a description of the data extracted from each one, he says simply, “Based on the above, the eligible evaluations were compared against each other with focus on features that may lead to bias and trying to decipher the direction of each bias.” What? What were the criteria to identify “features that may lead to bias”? Whenever that is done in studies, generally more than one person are required to evaluate for bias.
Prof. Ioannidis’ attack is rather ironic given that he himself repeatedly accuses his critics, in particular Meyerowitz-Katz, of “cherry picking” data, a phrase that I’ve never seen in an academic paper before, just as I had never seen a whole page in a manuscript devoted to attacking a graduate student and his Twitter account, while darkly insinuating undisclosed conflicts of interest. I also found this line of attack pretty ironic given that the question of undisclosed conflicts of interest has been credibly raised with respect to Prof. Ioannidis himself. Moreover, the level of rigor in this review article would, if it had been written by someone else, likely have earned Prof. Ioannidis’ justified ire.
The reaction to Prof. Ioannidis’ personal attacks on a graduate student, to his “punching down”, have been swift and intense:
Stanford Prof John Ioannidis responded to criticism of his fringe Covid views by trying to discredit a grad student in a scientific journal. So damaging to science as a whole & learning environment of Stanford in particular.@GidMK himself put it best.https://t.co/I6UrCmxt3Y https://t.co/K1Yl6QX3wO pic.twitter.com/bQWVXxppMj
— Mallory Harris (@malar0ne) March 28, 2021
Absolutely disgraceful academic behavior by Ioannidis towards @GidMK. His lack of precision is clearly seen in his misspelling of Woolongong (sic). https://t.co/vtUUIiDzI4
— Greg Dore (@GregDore2) March 28, 2021
If you’re one of the world’s most famous professors, as Ioannidis is, in a tenured position at Stanford, & you are literally attacking the *physical appearance* of a graduate student, it’s probably a sign that the merits of your scientific arguments are just weak sauce. https://t.co/QIOKXrB6vH
— Prof. Gavin Yamey MD MPH (@GYamey) March 28, 2021
“But peer review is awesome—peer-reviewed journals make sure papers are rigorous & of the highest standards”
Um, in a new paper in a peer-reviewed journal, a world famous professor attacks a graduate student for not having a PhD, wearing big glasses & having a cat.
Peer review!
— Prof. Gavin Yamey MD MPH (@GYamey) March 28, 2021
This is one step above calling him a dumb dumb stupid head who smells bad.
— Jonathan Howard (@JHowardBrainMD) March 28, 2021
Peak desperation: Tenured Stanford professor defends his point by insulting & humiliating a grad student. https://t.co/rAffL4yNm8
— Amy Maxmen, PhD (@amymaxmen) March 28, 2021
Yeah, it is stunning. Particularly ironic to see the Ionnaidis supporters, who previously called for civility, continue to support him despite these inexcusable attacks
— Dan Freedman, DO (@dfreedman7) March 28, 2021
That last one really got me, given how defenders of Prof. Ioannidis decried criticism of his writings, studies, and appearances in the media as “public shaming” (Jeanne Lenzer and Shannon Brownlee, who also decried the “COVID science wars”, portraying Ioannidis as being “silenced”) and the intensity of the attacks as turning scientific disagreements into politics, as Dr. Vinay Prasad did. (Remember him?) Oddly enough, I have yet to see any of Prof. Ioannidis’ defenders take him to task for his own lack of civility in “punching down” on a graduate student.
The bottom line is that it’s not a good look for a world-famous scientist who publishes for the World Health Organization, has over a thousand publications listed in PubMed, and regularly shows up on cable news networks as an expert, to launch such a personal screed against a graduate student. Truly, Meyerowitz-Katz’s criticisms of his work must have gotten under Ioannidis’ skin something awful. The whole article reeks of, “How dare a graduate student with a Twitter account question me?”
It makes me wonder how he might react if this post were to come to his attention and annoy him sufficiently. Given that I have maybe 1/20 the number of publications that he does and have had much, much less of an effect on science than he has, I’m almost certainly beneath his notice. On the other hand, Meyerowitz-Katz is a graduate student and had only published one research paper and a whole bunch of Tweets criticizing Prof. Ioannidis’ work, and that clearly got under his skin to the point where Ioannidis used his pull at a journal to publish a hit piece on Meyerowitz-Katz.
John Ioannidis: Brave maverick
As much as I used to admire him, since the pandemic hit John Ioannidis has consistently disappointed me to an extreme degree. In the last year, my disappointment with Prof. Ioannidis has gotten to the point where it’s hard for me to avoid lumping him with the COVID-19 minimizers/deniers like those who published and continue to promote the Great Barrington Declaration, one of whom was his co-author on his infamous Santa Clara seroprevalence study. The Great Barrington Declaration, boiled down to its essence, asserted that COVID-19 is not dangerous to the vast majority of the population, leading its writers and signatories to conclude that governments should, in essence, let SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes the disease, run rampant through the population in order to achieve “natural herd immunity”, while putting in place measures designed to protect only those viewed as “at risk”, such as the elderly and those with significant co-morbidities. (Note that, at the time the Declaration was published, there was as yet no safe and effective vaccine against COVID-19, while now there are at least four.) Of course, as many noted, it is not possible to protect the vulnerable if COVID-19 is rampaging unchecked throughout the rest of the population. Also, as I noted when I wrote about it, the Great Barrington Declaration was the product of the American Institute for Economic Research, a right-wing, climate science-denying think tank, which recruited three ideologically—shall we say?—amenable scientists to sign on as authors of the declaration, which was basically, as I put it, “eugenics-adjacent” and full of misinformation and half-truths.
Moreover, I’m not the only one who’s now soured on Prof. Ioannidis. For example, Scientific American columnist John Horgan, someone with whom both Steve Novella and I have had disagreements based on his downplaying of skepticism in medicine with respect to homeopathy:
Optimism has also distorted my view of the coronavirus. Last March, I took heart from warnings by Stanford epidemiologist John Ioannidis that we might be overestimating the deadliness of the virus and hence overreacting to it. He predicted that the U.S. death toll might reach only 10,000 people, lower than the average annual toll of seasonal flu. I wanted Ioannidis to be right, and his analysis seemed plausible to me, but his prediction turned out to be wrong by more than an order of magnitude.
Horgan didn’t go quite far enough in his criticisms for my taste, but such is life.
Then there’s Alex Rubinsteyn:
“What a weird turn to see John Ioannidis pushing one of sloppiest studies in the deluge of Covid-19 papers,” Alex Rubinsteyn, an assistant professor of computational medicine and genetics at the University of North Carolina School of Medicine, wrote on Twitter. “If he weren’t an author I would expect [the study] to show up in one of his talks as a particularly potent cocktail of bad research practices.”
Then, of course, there are all the scientists on Twitter criticizing Prof. Ioannidis. In fairness, one has to acknowledge that there are things Prof. Ioannidis has argued that have some merit. His estimates of IFR were closer to the mark than some of the very high estimates early in the pandemic, but they were still off considerably in the other direction. He was not wrong about the poor quality of so much of the data and research on COVID-19; it’s just, in an amazing feat of lacking self-awareness, he himself contributed to it as well.
This brings me back to that discussion of Ioannidis’ paper claiming that the NIH is too conservative and that only conservative, “safe” science is funded. It was more than that, though. He claimed that the scientists on NIH study sections were no better than scientists not on NIH study sections. Before I get to that, though, I note that Ioannidis’ cardinal sin since the pandemic started is not to have been wrong, even repeatedly so. It’s been his extreme arrogance:
Instead, Ioannidis sounded sure of himself. He was right; the others had it wrong. He called out other research teams by name—Johns Hopkins, Imperial College London—to berate their findings as “astronomically wrong,” and “constantly dialed back to match reality.” Here he was, about to come out with an exciting and important finding—if he were right, it could change almost everything about how we deal with this virus—and he seemed unworried by the possibility that something might be amiss with the project.
If anyone should understand how the pressure to contribute to the science of the crisis might lead to flawed work and exaggerated claims, it ought to be Ioannidis, arguably the world’s most famous epidemiologist. Who knows? Perhaps like so many of us, he’s just stressed out by the whole damned thing. Maybe he’s just off his game.
The article from which this quote came dates back to May 2020. Now, eleven months later with the benefit of hindsight, I don’t think you can say that Ioannidis was “off his game”. With his attack on a graduate student, he’s continued to double down and, in fact, has even gone further than Freedman had previously described. That is what brings me back to my previous discussion of his article about those “safe” scientists at the NIH, with a funding process that he’d characterized as “conformity” and “mediocrity”. I wrote this over eight years ago:
In the end, as much as I admire Ioannidis, I think he’s off-base here. It’s not that I don’t agree that the NIH should try to find ways to fund more innovative research. However, Ioannidis’ approach to quantifying the problem seems to suffer from flaws in its very conception. In light of that, I can’t resist revisiting the discussion in my last post on the question of riskiness versus safety in research, and that’s a simple question: What’s the evidence that funding more risky research will result in better research and more treatments? We have lots of anecdotes of scientists whose ideas were later found to be validated and potentially game-changing who couldn’t get NIH funding, but how often does this really happen? As I’ve pointed out before, the vast majority of “wild” ideas are considered “wild” precisely because they are new and there is little good support for them. Once evidence accumulates to support them, they are no longer considered quite so “wild.” We know today that the scientists whose anecdotes of woe describing the depredations of the NIH were indeed onto something. How many more proposed ideas that seemed innovative at the time but ultimately went nowhere?
And my conclusion:
However, the assumption underlying Ioannidis’s analysis seems to be that there must be “bolts out of the blue” discovered by brilliant brave maverick scientists. It’s all very Randian at its heart. However, science is a collaborative enterprise, in which each scientist builds incrementally on the work of his or her predecessors. Bolts out of the blue are a good thing, but we can’t count on them, nor has anyone demonstrated that they are more likely to occur if the NIH funds “riskier research.” It’s equally likely that the end result would be a lot more dud research.
Maybe the problem with Prof. Ioannidis was there all along, and I just didn’t see it until the pandemic amplified it for all to see. He seems, dating back at least to 2012, have had the belief that conventional science is too “safe” and “conformist,” perhaps with a bit of a self-image of himself as being the “brave maverick doctor” or iconoclast. Maybe that’s why, during the pandemic, he was so easily drawn to being a “rebel” or a “contrarian,” whose findings bucked the existing consensus, and maybe that’s why he can’t give that up. After all, it’s happened to greater scientists than he. Moreover, Prof. Ioannidis seems to be an excellent cautionary tale at how being a critic doesn’t necessarily mean that you can do what’s being criticized that well. He’s very good at finding the flaws in studies, but his studies during the pandemic demonstrate that, when designing studies of his own, he’s prone to every bias and flaw that he criticizes in others.
In any event, I should go back and read some of Prof. Ioannidis’ old work in light of what I know about him now, with the realization that the pandemic has done me a favor. I wonder what I might find.

Intubations and Accusations: Doctors were “just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”
It’s problematic when a paragon of evidence-based medicine claims vaccines spread disease and amplifies internet rumors that doctors killed COVID-19 patients through premature intubations.
Jonathan Howard on September 19, 2021
Tweet

My first article on famed Stanford epidemiologist Dr. John Ioannidis discussed his flawed fatality calculations that required over 100% of New York City’s population to be infected with the virus, as well as his claim (later promoted by QAnon accounts) that death certificates couldn’t be trusted, as many COVID-19 victims were dying with the virus not from the virus. Looking back on my pleonastic article and the myriad of false claims I discussed, one has stuck in my mind more than the others. In that article, I noted Dr. Ioannidis’s appearance on the Plenary Session Podcast where he said (at 1:37:25) that “a lot of lives” were lost early in the pandemic in part because of doctors “not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation, just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”. Dr. Ioannidis did not provide any evidence for this claim, nor did the podcast host, who agreed with him.
The notion that COVID-19 patients were dying of premature intubations and not from the virus was never anything more than an internet rumor. There was never any evidence that doctors were “just going crazy” intubating patients, leading to their demise. In fact, a meta-analysis of 12 studies found “The synthesized evidence of almost 9000 patients suggests that timing of intubation may have no effect on mortality and morbidity of critically ill patients with COVID-19”. Though this meta-analysis was published after Dr. Ioannidis made his accusation, all 12 studies it reviewed were published beforehand. A subsequent study unsurprisingly found that intubated patients died at a higher rate, but “there was not a significant association between mortality and timing of intubation (within 48 hours of triage vs later in hospital course), when restricting only to intubated patients”. Another subsequent study even found improved survival rates in COVID-19 patients who were intubated early.
Perhaps because it was said as an aside during a podcast, I don’t think this false claim got the scrutiny it deserved. But let’s be clear: a paragon of evidence-based medicine publicly accused frontline doctors of killing a large number of their patients. He not only did so without any evidence, but in direct contradiction to the evidence available at the time. As I’ve discussed before, there are real-world consequences when people believe false information. Dr. Alison Pittard, an intensivist from the UK, said patients were refusing ventilators because,
They think if they do not go on a ventilator, they have got a better chance of surviving, because once they go on a ventilator they are going to die irrespective. And of course that is not correct because if you are faced with a patient who needs to go on a ventilator … if they don’t go on a ventilator then the chances are that they will die. So, that is almost saying there is a 100% chance of dying. Whereas if they go on a ventilator then they will have a 40% chance of dying.
Vaccinating young people may expose the elderly?
With this in mind, I was particularly dismayed to read a bizarre article by Dr. Ioannidis titled “COVID-19 in Children and University Students“. After presenting an argument for vaccinating young people based on “indirect benefits to other age groups and society at large,” he wrote the following,
However, the opposite arguments also exist, e.g. vaccinating the youngest age strata may shift infection to higher ages with high fatality especially as many elderly people in many countries are still not vaccinated and some vaccinated elderly have insufficient immune responses. Vaccinated people may still transmit the virus; given that vaccinations make infections milder/asymptomatic and people markedly increase exposures after vaccination (a risk compensatory behavior), vulnerable people may be exposed more frequently to vaccinated infected youth who are unaware of their infection.
That’s right, Dr. Ioannidis gives credence to the notion that vaccinating young people will spread the disease to vulnerable elderly people. He’s suggests this may occur in an imaginary country where young people are vaccinated, elderly people are unvaccinated, and these vulnerable adults are incapable of realizing they are still vulnerable. He referenced no real-world data to support this extraordinary claim, but rather his own “model” from a prior paper. Naturally, when discussing models that show benefits of the vaccine, he warns that “modeling projections of benefits are occasionally helpful, but also precarious”. To Dr. Ioannidis, models are useful when they suggest vaccine harms, but “precarious” when they show vaccine benefits.
It’s true that vaccinated people can still spread the disease. But the idea that vaccinating young people will cause more disease in vulnerable old people is nothing more than a new twist on an old anti-vaccine trope that vaccinated people “shed” the disease. Just because this claim is now being presented by someone with stellar academic credentials in a medical journal doesn’t mean we shouldn’t recognize it for what it is. Of course, unvaccinated young people can still spread the virus before they show symptoms. Unvaccinated people with COVID-19 have a higher viral load than vaccinated people with breakthrough infections. As such, unvaccinated people with COVID-19 are theoretically more likely to spread the virus.
Dr. Ioannidis is also giving credence the idea, promoted by signers of the Great Barrington Declaration, that it’s preferable to let young people get the virus than to get vaccinated. Via his strange reasoning, the fact that “vaccinations make infections milder/asymptomatic” is a strike against the vaccine. It’s not enough for children to merely contract the virus, they also need to know it. In order to protect elderly people, children need to feel sick. This is not the first time Dr. Ioannidis lamented measures that would prevent infections in children. At the start of the pandemic, he warned that “school closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”.
Well, schools are open now, and sadly many children in this age group haven’t been “spared serious disease“. Most young people do fine with the virus, thankfully, but when tens of millions of them get sick, rare harms add up. Dr. Ioannidis’s own paper showed that hundreds of children and thousands of young adults have died from COVID-19 in the US, though of course he suggests these numbers are inflated. Why does he think this? In an article from July 2021, he stated that:
Death certificates have always been inaccurate, but COVID-19 maximizes the challenge of prioritizing multiple comorbidities… In many other countries, death certificates are even more unreliable. Some financial incentives may promote coding for COVID-19.
That’s right, Dr. Ioannidis continues to promote the QAnon meme that the death toll is inflated because death certificates can’t be trusted. In fact, death certificates have generally been very reliable this pandemic and the CDC estimates deaths have been underreported this pandemic. In addition to repeating previously debunked claims, this time Dr. Ioannidis adds a nasty twist by suggesting that people who fill out death certificates have a financial incentive to put down COVID-19. His reference for this extraordinary claim was an article from India, which merely noted that the families of frontline workers who die of the virus on duty can receive financial compensation. This paper contains no evidence that anyone is falsifying death certificates for money. Again, Dr. Ioannidis is doing nothing more than amplifying mere internet rumors. In so doing, he joins Donald Trump who said, “Our doctors get more money if somebody dies from COVID. You know that, right? I mean, our doctors are very smart people. So what they do is they say, ‘I’m sorry, but, you know, everybody dies of COVID.'” Again, just because Dr. Ioannidis does this in a medical journal using formal diction doesn’t mean we should treat his words any differently than those of former President Trump.
While death is the worst outcome from COVID-19, it is not the only bad outcome. Tens of thousands more children and young people have been hospitalized, some very sick, intubated in the ICU, though Dr. Ioannidis of course also suggests these numbers are inflated. Happily, the vaccines can prevent hospitalizations in young people. A recent study by the CDC found that unvaccinated adolescents are hospitalized 10 times more often than vaccinated ones. Additionally, the CDC has tallied 4,661 cases of MIS-C, and children with this disease are often very sick, needing ICU-level care. Many thousands more children and young adults may have long-COVID, an entity we are still learning about.
Every doctor who is pro-vaccine should be very clear: The vaccine isn’t perfect, but it’s much safer for young people than the virus. We vaccinate young people to protect them, and we don’t need models to know the vaccine works. Unvaccinated teens have died this summer after the vaccine was available to them. It’s just a bonus that vaccinated children might not lose their mom or dad.
More claims of “improper mechanical ventilation strategies”
While Dr. Ioannidis’s notion that vaccinating children may lead to more disease in vulnerable adults is comical, what he said next isn’t so funny. Dr. Ioannidis said that the “future infection fatality rate may decrease with better protection of vulnerable children, more effective treatments, and avoidance of harmful treatments (e.g. improper mechanical ventilation strategies.)” In other words, Dr. Ioannidis expects that fewer kids will die from rushed intubations moving forward. No reference is given for this claim, as conspiracy theory sites that push this idea can’t be referenced.
Once again, an inflammatory accusation is being lobbed against frontline doctors not just without any evidence, but in direct contradiction to all of the available evidence. The fatality rate for children hasn’t decreased. Children are dying now at the same low rate as before. However, more children are getting infected now, so more children are dying now. About 500 children have died so far this pandemic in the US. The American Academy of Pediatrics added 102 deaths to its tally since July 29th, over 20% of the total pediatric deaths in the past 5 weeks. Despite what Dr. Ioannidis says, none of them died because they were intubated too early.
        ◦ Sadly, highly-credentialed experts from prestigious universities making false claims in a public forum is now a routine part of this pandemic. Like the high daily death tolls, we’ve become numb to things that would have appalled us previously. Nonetheless, I still believe that academics divorced from patient care should be held to account when they falsely claim that overwhelmed frontline doctors killed their patients and then imply they put COVID-19 on the death certificates for money.

John Ioannidis and the Carl Sagan effect in science communication about COVID-19
We have been critical about John Ioannidis over a number of his statements about the COVID-19 pandemic. Now he’s done it again, producing a poor-quality paper whose unwritten assumptions suggest that the Carl Sagan effect, in which scientists are penalized professionally by their peers for becoming popular science communicators, still holds considerable sway in science and medicine.
David Gorski on December 13, 2021
Link

Last week, I noted the publication of an article by John Ioannidis, Alangoya Tezel, and Reshma Jagsi that caught my interest in BMJ Open, the BMJ’s open-access journal. Titled, Overall and COVID-19-specific citation impact of highly visible COVID-19 media experts: bibliometric analysis. To boil the paper down to its essence, Ioannidis examined the citation impact in the scientific literature of “highly visible COVID-19 media experts” in the US, Denmark, Greece, and Switzerland and concluded that most were not highly cited overall and few had published much on COVID-19 in particular. It’s a terrible analysis for the simple reason that its premise is flawed to the point where the results are in essence meaningless, as I will explain. However, I did see this article as a good launching off point, a “teachable moment” if you will, to discuss science communication in the age of the deadliest global pandemic in over a century. Ioannidis was once one of my scientific heroes but since COVID-19 hit has disabused me of any previous hero worship, likely forever, although, truth be told, I had intermittently been unimpressed with his takes dating back years. In any event, this paper, published in late October but only seemingly finding an audience on social media last week (which is how I became aware of it) illustrates a problem that all of us who try to communicate science and medicine to the public face.
The Carl Sagan effect
To understand the flaw in the premise behind Ioannidis’ paper, I have to look back at a bit of history. There has long been a disconnect between those who actually do science and those who try to communicate science and medicine to the general public. The prototypical example that those of us who do science communication, either as a sideline (as I do) or professionally, is Carl Sagan. There was even a term for it: The Sagan effect, which is basically the perception that popular, famous scientists who engage in public discourse on TV and in the media—Sagan died too young just as the Internet was rising in the mid-1990s and long before social media consumed our information landscape—are not as good in science as those scientists who do not engage in science communication with the public. One example of the “Sagan effect” that is frequently discussed was the failure of his nomination to the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) in 1991, despite his being backed by prominent Nobel Laureates and analyses of his academic output having been shown to compare favorably with those of some of the most productive contemporaneous NAS members.
Basically, historically, the vast majority of scientists have looked down their noses at scientists who try to engage with the public in popular media. I can cite my own personal experience over a blogging “career” that is approaching two decades. Many are the times over the years that I’ve been subjected to sarcastic little digs—and worse!—from scientists questioning why I bother. Indeed, when I first started blogging, I used a pseudonym. True, on my not-so-super-secret other blog, I still use that pseudonym (mainly because I like it), but my real name is right there in the “About” section. The reason back then was that I was worried about how my newfound hobby would be perceived by my bosses and fellow surgeon-scientists. When Steve Novella asked me to join this blog as one of the founding members after I had been blogging on my own for nearly three years, I jumped at the chance because (1) it was Steve Novella asking me and (2) I had lost my fear of writing under my real name and jumped at the chance. True, I kept my other blog going under the pseudonym, but my real name is so easy to find—it’s on the blog!—that I sometimes use it as an “intelligence test” for trolls who try to dismiss me as just an “anonymous blogger”. If they can’t find my real name in the “About” section of my blog, they’re either dishonest or stupid—or both.
It’s not just scientists, either. You might recall that a few months before the pandemic, a rising star in medical oncology, Dr. Vinay Prasad, launched a broadside against physician-skeptics who analyzed and debunked pseudoscience, quackery, and bad science for public consumption, and then doubled down on it almost exactly a year ago today. His contempt for the exercise of science communication in this sphere was palpable. Basically, his idea was that if we weren’t doing what he was doing (clinical trial analysis) we were wasting our intellects. I won’t belabor his criticisms and why they were so off base, as Steve and I both responded. I will also point out that much of Dr. Prasad’s criticism of science communication has been topic-specific. Ironically, he himself has built up a rather prolific public communication infrastructure of podcasts, social media, and legacy media appearances. Unfortunately, he has also devolved into spreading misinformation and accusing supporters of mask and vaccine mandates as starting us down the slippery-slope to Nazi-style fascism.
It is undoubtedly true that this dismissive attitude towards science communication has been changing over the 17(!) years that I have been blogging regularly, even more so in the last decade or so since the rise of social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and, more recently, Tik Tok. Lots of scientists, particularly younger scientists, are engaging in science communication on social media, sometimes quite entertainingly, and the stigma against such activity—and, make no mistake, it has been a stigma—has been fading. However, Ioannidis demonstrates that it is not yet gone. I also can’t help but wonder if this entire exercise is a response to some of the harsh criticism he’s received for his numerous bad takes on the COVID-19 pandemic.
The Carl Sagan effect, as a study by John Ioannidis
Ioannidis’ study is an example of the Carl Sagan effect manifested in the unwritten but obvious assumptions behind the study. In brief, Ioannidis seems to assume that if you are communicating science to the public through the media, you are not likely to be as good a scientist, with his study being, in essence, a plea for more “high-powered” scientists with lots of relevant publications and citations on COVID-19 to make themselves available to the media and for the media to recruit more such scientists to comment on COVID-19. There are…a lot of flaws. Indeed, Ioannidis’ bibliometrics study is pretty bad and seems to have an agenda behind it that readers might not be aware of if they are unaware of Ioannidis’ history since the pandemic started. Let’s circle back and see what I mean.
Ioannidis begins:
The COVID-19 pandemic has been accompanied by an unprecedented infodemic in the news and social media.1 2 Media coverage has been intensive, continuous, massive and heated and has involved a very large number of alleged experts. The involvement of knowledgeable scholars in the public discussion and dissemination of information on such a monumental crisis is clearly welcome and indispensable. However, how knowledgeable are the experts recruited by media?
Knowledge and expertise are difficult to appraise with full objectivity. Weinstein3 argued that there are two kinds of experts, those who are recognised as experts based on what they know (epistemic expertise) and those who are worthy of being called experts based on what they do (performative expertise). According to this classification, an epistemic expert is a person who is capable of providing strong justification for a range of claims in a domain, while performative expertise characterises a person who is able to perform a skill well according to the rules and virtues of a practice.3 Performative experts may not necessarily be contributors to the scientific literature themselves, but may still know their job well and have extensive practical experience. It is very difficult, however, to appraise in a standardised manner and with consistency and quantitative metrics such performative expertise. Conversely, epistemic experts are likely to be contributors to the scientific literature and their level of contribution and impact in the science of their field is a key hallmark of their expertise. What can be readily appraised in a non-subjective fashion is the publication and citation track record of scientists who appear in news media as experts. One can use objective data to quantify the citation impact of the published work of these scientists across science throughout their career, as well as the specific impact that they are having with their scientific publications about COVID-19. While publications and citations do have limitations (as all bibliometric metrics), they are objective, readily quantifiable and offer useful information about scientific impact. Here we aimed to evaluate the overall and COVID-19-specific citation impact of the most highly visible COVID-19 experts in the USA, Denmark, Greece and Switzerland. We also paid particular attention to probing the representation of women among highly visible COVID-19 experts, as it has been previously suggested that women are under-represented among COVID-19 experts in the USA.4
I found it odd that Ioannidis starts out by citing someone named B. D. Weinstein. I briefly did a double-take, thinking that he might have cited Brett Weinstein, who, as you likely know, is an evolutionary biologist who has become one of the most prolific promoters of COVID-19 misinformation, particularly in his credulous cheerleading for the repurposed anti-helminthic drug ivermectin to treat COVID-19, a drug that almost certainly does not work and whose medical literature is hopelessly contaminated with fraudulent studies. Then I figured out that this was Bruce Weinstein. (I realize I digress, but given the mental image I couldn’t help myself.) My weird brain trick about the name Weinstein aside, Ioannidis seems to be grudgingly admitting that it’s possible to be a “performative expert” with experience extensive enough to be a reliable source of information on a topic without having contributed to the scientific literature, but you can tell from what comes next that he’s not enthusiastically endorsing such expertise. So what does he do next? He quickly pivots to his analysis, which involves in essence trying to tear down media “COVID-19 experts” by showing that most of them aren’t what he would consider high-powered contributors to the scientific literature on COVID-19. Reading this introduction, I can’t help but wonder if in Ioannidis’ construct critical care and emergency room doctors on the actual front lines aren’t “expert” enough for the media to contact.
Or:
Much of their work is also never published, or if it is it's not in an academic format, so not only are they not in the media but they don't appear in the scientific literature either. And yet, they're the people on the ground who have done most of the actul work on COVID-19
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) December 8, 2021
I will also point out that a handful of such doctors have been among the most prolific promoters of COVID-19 disinformation, but I also note that, by Ioannidis’ metric, an utter crank like Peter McCullough would seem very credible just by the number of COVID-19 publications he boasts of.
Another huge problem rapidly rears its ugly head in the methods section. For example, one question I immediately asked when I first read the abstract to this paper was: Why did Ioannidis choose these three countries other than the US? I can understand choosing the US if you’re based in the US (as Ioannidis is) and because it’s the biggest producer of scientific studies and media. I can understand choosing Greece, given Ioannidis’ Greek ancestry (although one wonders if Ioannidis chose Greece because he has served as a media expert appearing in interviews there). But why Denmark and Switzerland? Why not the UK, France, China, Japan, Australia, or other countries like that? The whole set of methodology seems…odd, particularly the lack of description of the definition of “visible” as applied to media scientists and the acceptance of seemingly any old definition from the sources tapped:
We examined bibliometric indicators of top media experts in the USA, Switzerland, Greece and Denmark. These are countries for which we could identify pre-existing lists of experts who had prominent visibility in media. These lists are typically not published in the peer-reviewed scientific literature (with the exception of the US list that was previously generated and published by members of our team),4 but in media news items in different countries, thus defying the possibility for efficient systematic searches. We therefore asked our colleagues at the Meta-Research Innovation Center at Stanford (and affiliated colleagues who come from different countries if they were aware of any such publicised lists. We accepted these lists regardless of how visibility had been defined in these surveys.
For the USA, we examined the scientific citation impact of all scientists who had appeared between 18 May and 19 June 2020 during prime-time programming on three popular American cable news networks: Fox News Network, CNN and MSNBC. Details on the data collection and selection for the US list and features of the sample have been previously described.4 Of the 220 people who appeared during these programmes, 76 were scientists (47 physicians and 29 PhDs).
For European countries, searches for visible experts were made by local organisations in each country and they pertain to national media visibility. For Denmark, we found a news article that listed the 50 experts who had the highest number of appearances in media during 2020 (television, radio, newspapers).5 For Greece, we found a news article that listed the 12 COVID-19 experts who had the highest television exposure based on measured time of television appearances.6 For Switzerland, the Swiss Media Database (SMD) captures appearances in media in Switzerland. We could find information from a news article7 on the two most commonly appearing names of COVID-19 experts in SMD between mid-January and June 2020.
Also odd are the very specific time periods examined, all early in the pandemic. For instance, for the US, why did Ioannidis choose to look at a one-month period early in the pandemic? Also odd was the choice of the “top 2%” cutoff when examining whether scientists were at the top of their fields, but then I realized that Ioannidis was just mining a database he had already created. I’m with Carl Bergstrom here, when he noted:
It is indeed a stunningly lazy exercise in bibliometrics, given the small sample size and the self-referential repurposing of a database that Ioannidis’ group created for a different reason before the pandemic. Before I realized that, I was asking as I read: Why not top 5%? Or top 10%? Or even top 25%? Ioannidis’ handwaving justification in the discussion just betrays the laziness that Dr. Bergstrom noted:
First, we should acknowledge that citation metrics are far from being perfect measures of epistemic expertise. Moreover, we focused on using already existing data on the 2% top-cited scientists across each scientific discipline, and we could not examine whether scientists who were not in the top 2% of these pre-existing lists might be in the top 3% or in the bottom 5% of citation impact. Obviously, many scientists may still have considerable epistemic expertise even if they are not strictly in the top 2% of citation indicators.
Could not? No, Ioannidis chose not to go beyond his database, because looking at a larger sample would have required additional work beyond just mining an existing database created by his own research group. Lazy indeed.
There’s also another issue other than the misguided assumption that somehow being in the top 2% of researchers based on publications in the peer-reviewed literature and citations of one’s publications correlates with effective science communication, knowledge of public policy, and practical experience. Ioannidis’ analysis is very, very simplistic with respect to COVID-19 expertise, breaking publication records down to “COVID-19-related” and everything else. However, a molecular virologist working on the mechanisms of SARS-CoV-2 infection would not be a good choice to comment on mask or vaccine mandates, just as a public health expert would not be a good choice to comment on the finer points of the immune response to the disease or to explain, for instance, why the spike protein made by mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines is not “deadly” and does not shed, as antivaxxers frequently claim. The list goes on.
Moving on, let’s look at Ioannidis’ findings:
We assessed 76 COVID-19 experts who were highly visible in US prime-time cable news, and 50, 12 and 2 highly visible experts in media in Denmark, Greece and Switzerland, respectively. Of those, 23/76, 10/50, 2/12 and 0/2 were among the top 2% of overall citation impact among scientists in the same discipline worldwide. Moreover, 37/76, 15/50, 7/12 and 2/2 had published anything on COVID-19 that was indexed in Scopus as of 30 August 2021. Only 18/76, 6/50, 2/12 and 0/2 of the highly visible COVID-19 media experts were women. 55 scientists in the USA, 5 in Denmark, 64 in Greece and 56 in Switzerland had a higher citation impact for their COVID-19 work than any of the evaluated highly visible media COVID-19 experts in the respective country; 10/55, 2/5, 22/64 and 14/56 of them were women.
I will right here, right now, point out the one useful observation in Ioannidis’ paper, namely the paucity of scientists who are women and also prominent in the media. That’s the single useful piece of information he has provided here, and he’s right that the media and scientists need to do something to diversify their pool of experts. The rest? Not so much. He is also correct to note that racial minorities are likely to have been underrepresented, although I have a hard time believing his claim that he “could not assess the racial background of media experts”. Seriously? Has Ioannidis never heard of Google? Many of these experts likely have Wikipedia entries, and, if they don’t, by his very design, we know that they have appeared in media reports on multiple occasions. He could have had his minions just look up those media reports and see if they could glean the racial background of these scientists! Certainly, it might not have been possible in some cases, but in most it likely would have. Bergstrom is correct. This analysis is lazy.
Here’s the funny part. Ioannidis seems to recognize the problem at the heart of his analysis:
The best or the most cited scientists should not necessarily be the ones who appear the most frequently in media. Some of the experts whom we analysed have accumulated a track record of massive media engagements that require an enormous commitment of time and psyche. Many highly competitive, excellent scientists would find it difficult or even impossible to pursue their scholarly work and have an intense media presence at the same time. Moreover, especially for COVID-19, polarisation, politics and an environment of conspiracy, mistrust, and public unrest and rage may have disincentivised many leading scientists from engaging with media. Women and minorities may feel even more disincentivised in this environment.
Nevertheless, communication with the wider public is an important mission of science, medicine and public health. Information on COVID-19 in media has been shown to be of questionable quality.1 2 Its quantity is clearly immense. The vast majority is produced and disseminated by people without any scientific training and with little or no self-reflection on their inadequacy to judge complex and rapidly evolving scientific concepts. It may be impossible to diminish the bulk of information, but at a minimum its quality should be improved. Engaging qualified experts may be critical in this regard.
While Ioannidis is correct to note that political polarization, conspiracy theories, and harsh rhetoric have likely disincentivized some scientists from engaging with the media and that such engagement can take a massive commitment of time, effort, and psyche that could detract from the time that they can do science (just ask Dr. Peter Hotez, if you don’t believe me), I couldn’t help but wonder: Why, then, is he seemingly arguing that more scientists with high publication citation metrics should engage with the media and implying that the situation now is so bad because so many of the scientists who do media appearances aren’t in the top 2% measured by citation metrics? It makes no sense. I would also argue that some of what he found was actually quite reassuring. 23/76 media experts in the US during that one-month time period were in the top 2% of their fields? That’s over 30%, which I’d characterize as awesome! Ten out of 50 in Denmark? That’s pretty darned impressive, too! Two of twelve in Greece? I’d say that’s fairly impressive, as well. In all of those countries, a highly disproportionate percentage of scientists engaging with the media were, by Ioannidis’ metrics, in the top 2% of their fields!
The assumption at the heart of this paper, namely that a high rank in terms of scientific publications and citation scores should correlate with more effective public communication is entirely off-base, as is the very simplistic breakdown of expertise into “COVID-19” compared to everything else. It also blew up multiple irony meters to see Ioannidis urge science communicators to engage “qualified experts” to improve the quality of science communication, when he seems not to have done so on so many occasions.
I hesitated to suggest this, but upon reflection decided that I had to. There appears to be another subtext here, one that is suggested by Ioannidis’ competing interest statement at the end:
JPI has given some COVID-19 media interviews (a hundredfold less compared with some of the listed experts) that have resulted in smearing, hate emails, threats, censoring, hostile behaviour, harassment and a life-threatening experience for a family member. He is among the top-cited scientists in both the overall and COVID-19-specific citation databases used in the presented analyses. In his Stanford web page, he admits that despite being ‘among the 10 scientists worldwide who are currently the most commonly cited; when contrasted against my vast ignorance, these values offer excellent proof that citation metrics can be horribly unreliable’. RJ is also listed among the top-cited scientists in the overall citation database.
Let me just preface my comments here by saying quite unequivocally that having experienced harassment, death threats, and the like myself, I will always say that this is not acceptable, no matter how much I might disagree with the person experiencing them, period. That being said, I have to address part of his statement not relating to threats of violence, noting how Ioannidis has strategically placed it in a list that includes hate email, threats, harassment, and the like. No one—and I mean no one—is “censoring” Ioannidis. No one. Harsh criticism of bad takes is not “censorship”. After all, he is one of the most famous, most published and widely cited scientists in the world (if not the most), and media outlets are likely clamoring for him to give interviews, even as Scientific American published a defense of him against the “overreaction” to his work and predictions. Early in the pandemic, he had the ear of the Trump administration and lobbied to get it to listen to his ideas on the pandemic:
His self-deprecating self-characterization aside, notice how Ioannidis makes damned sure that you know that he is in the top 2% and included in the analysis. In context, that self-deprecation comes across as a front for an assertion of his authority on COVID-19.
A hidden agenda?
Dr. Ioannidis has clearly been very much stung by the harsh criticism of his statements made to the media during the pandemic, and, make no mistake, he has laid down some doozies, beginning very early in the pandemic with his infamous lowball estimate for deaths from COVID-19 that he said could be “buried within the noise of the estimate of deaths from ‘influenza-like illness'” or how “at most we might have casually noted that flu this season seems to be a bit worse than average”.
As we here at SBM have said time and time again, there’s no shame in making such an off-base estimate if you acknowledge your error and correct it as new information comes in. Ioannidis has been remarkably resistant to that. Worse, Ioannidis lashed out in an article in a peer-reviewed journal that for which he had recently served as editor at a graduate student who had had the temerity to publish results that conflicted with Ioannidis’ results and for having criticized Ioannidis on social media. It was the most egregious example of “punching down” that I had seen in a long time. Then there was Ioannidis’ repeated credulous repetitions of conspiracy theories, such as the one based on a misinterpretation of how death certificates are filled out claiming that people die “with COVID-19” far more often than they die “of COVID-19”:
I mean, even the Indian paper that is cited to support this point argues that the main issue is MISSING COVID-19 deaths, not improperly recording more deaths than actually occurred pic.twitter.com/vhY9CAxIrA
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) December 8, 2021
Worse, he repeated as fact a claim from early in the pandemic that doctors were killing people by being too fast to intubate them. It was, in essence, a conspiracy theory. Let’s just put it this way. When a scientist as famous as John Ioannidis starts repeating misinformation like this, people are going to believe it, and he’s going to face harsh criticism that is much deserved (and not “censorship”).
The Sagan Effect still exists
In the quarter century since Carl Sagan’s untimely passing, a great deal of progress has been made in terms of erasing the stigma that exists against scientists who engage with the public to communicate about science and its findings. However, the unspoken assumption behind Ioannidis’ publication tells us that there’s still a long way to go. The problem appears to be an attitude that science communication is something that’s so easy and trivial that anyone can do it.
Also there is no measure of the "claim to expertise" – just being willing to communicate via the media is not a claim of expertise.
— Matt Nurse (@matt_nurse) December 8, 2021
This is the assumption in the paper that grated me the most. Communication isn’t a throw-away thing anyone can just “do” when they feel like it. It’s a discipline & set of skills unto itself. Most can learn the skills, but they aren’t trivial.
— Tara Haelle #ReadBannedBooks (@tarahaelle) December 8, 2021
I can attest to the observation that the skills needed for science communication aren’t trivial. I didn’t do a formal training program and picked the skill up as I went along, and I’m always aware of that and my shortcomings. (Sometimes, I cringe when I read some of my old writing from early in my blogging “career”.) There’s a catchphrase from the second Dirty Harry movie Magnum Force in which Dirty Harry observes, “A man’s got to know his limitations.” I know mine. I’m very good at blogging and Twitter, pretty decent at public speaking and podcast/radio appearances, and not so great at TV or anything involving video. (I really need to work to get better at that.) What I’m saying is that not only is science communication a set of skills that most scientists can learn but are not trivial to master, but that there are subsets of science communication for different media. I’d have to say that Ioannidis really either hasn’t heard, has ignored, or doesn’t care about this saying about knowing one’s limitations.
I haven’t even gotten into the other mistaken assumptions behind Ioannidis’ analysis:
There are other problematic assumptions here. 1) being a great scientist doesn’t make one a great science communicator. 2) citation impact is a problematic measure of expertise. 3) bandwidth is finite: spend it on the science or on cable TV? The former is a reasonable choice. Etc
— Tara Haelle #ReadBannedBooks (@tarahaelle) December 8, 2021
In the end, as much as those of us who devote time to science communication would like to think otherwise, the Sagan effect still exists. True, it’s not nearly as harsh as it was 30 years ago, but it’s still there, and papers like this one by Ioannidis are evidence of that. The ironic and depressing thing is that the “antiscience” communicators, such as Dr. Mehmet Oz, COVID-19 contrarians, and antivaxxers like Del Bigtree, are often very effective communicators, and we really need more skilled science communicators if we’re to have a chance of countering their disinformation. Once again, Ioannidis isn’t helping.
Worse, there is an ironic aspect to this whole affair:
he is now contributing to the problem he identified….full circle.
— R Marcucio (@mcfunny) December 8, 2021
        ◦ Sadly, Ioannidis has indeed come full circle. He first became famous because of his paper about how most scientific findings turn out to be wrong, and now he’s contributing to the very problem that he identified.

John Ioannidis uses the Kardashian Index to attack critics of the Great Barrington Declaration
This isn’t a title that I ever thought I’d use or a post that I ever thought I’d write, but John Ioannidis has really done it. He’s incompetently used the Kardashian index to attack John Snow Memorandum signatories and argue that the Great Barrington Declaration signatories, who argue for a “natural herd immunity” approach to the COVID-19 pandemic, are the underdogs who haven’t been listened to.
David Gorski on February 14, 2022
Link

If there are certain titles and sentences that I never expected to use for a blog post and certain sentences that I never, ever expected to write as part of a blog post, near the very top of the list has to be anything resembling “John Ioannidis uses the Kardashian Index to attack critics of the Great Barrington Declaration”. Has to be. It’s a sentence and title so off-the-wall that, even in the most fevered flight of ideas that sometimes run through my fragile eggshell mind as I contemplate what I’m about to write in this and my personal blog, I could never have strung these words and thoughts together unaided unless I had actually seen John Ioannidis publish a paper in which he did, indeed, weaponize the Kardashian Index in order to attack the signatories of the John Snow Memorandum, which, to my utter disbelief, really happened last week in the form of a paper authored by John Ioannidis and no one else published in BMJ Open Access titled ‘Citation impact and social media visibility of Great Barrington and John Snow signatories for COVID-19 strategy“.
I’ll stop right here for a second to reassure readers that I fully realize that those who don’t know who John Ioannidis is and are not familiar with the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), the John Snow Memorandum (JSM), or, for that matter, the Kardashian Index (K-index) are very likely scratching their heads right now wondering whether Gorski has gotten a little too much into the single malt scotch. That is entirely understandable, but I assure you that I was stone cold sober when I wrote this. (Actually, I have to wonder if Ioannidis was sober when he wrote his paper!) However, because of the bizarreness of the paper that I’m about to discuss, before I delve into it I will now take a moment to try bring everyone up to speed, so that you can all understand why the paper is a combination of bonkers and awful, not to mention a continuation of Ioannidis’ ongoing assault on science communicators with a significant social media presence who have criticized him. Regular readers, however, will likely be familiar with at least two things, though. First, we here at Science-Based Medicine have written a fair amount about the GBD and John Ioannidis. Some might even be familiar with the John Snow Memorandum, a response by public health scientists to the GBD. As for the Kardashian index, that seems to have started as a joke, leading me to wonder why someone like John Ioannidis would take it seriously enough to write a paper like this about it. In any event, before I get to the paper, here’s some relevant background. If you’re familiar with this, feel free to skim or skip the next couple of sections, but I think that it will still be worthwhile for even those familiar with all these terms and the background to review them, because doing so will really help put this paper into context.
John Ioannidis versus science communicators
As I alluded to above, John Ioannidis has for a while been more or less at war with science communicators who have criticized him. Of course, given his reputation and his pivot to questionable takes on COVID-19, he is a huge target. How did we get here? First, part of the reason Ioannidis is such a huge target is because he is a physician-scientist at Stanford University—Professor of Medicine and Epidemiology and Population Health—who is also one of the most published scientists in the world (if not the most published living scientist), with well over 1,000 peer-reviewed papers indexed in PubMed as of yesterday and eleven papers already in 2022. (By comparison, I have one co-authored paper in 2022 thus far, and that’s just because it took longer to be published than expected, pushing its publication date to a week ago.) As I’ve said many times, John Ioannidis was at one time a personal scientific hero and, I daresay, a hero of SBM bloggers in general. Pre-pandemic, we featured general laudatory commentary about a number of his papers, including papers about bad epidemiology regarding diet and cancer risk, the life cycle of translational research, whether popularity leads to unreliability in science, problems with reproducibility in science, and the reliability of scientific findings, all of which contributes to the puzzlement many of us at SBM have expressed over Ioannidis’ evolution into a COVID-19 contrarian who has been wrong about so much about the pandemic and has even credulously regurgitated outright conspiracy theories about it. Maybe, however, this development should not have been such a surprise. Let’s see why.
Ioannidis is most famous for having written the 2005 paper “Why Most Published Research Findings Are False“, which investigated why so much of what is published in the biomedical literature later turns out to be incorrect. It is, of course, a paper whose findings have been endlessly misused by cranks, quacks, antivaxxers, science deniers, and conspiracy theorists to claim that most science is false or “at best a coin flip’s worth of certainty” (and therefore their pseudoscience and quackery should be taken seriously as being correct), but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t a worthwhile endeavor. Those of us who support science- and evidence-based medicine recognized it as simply trying to quantify something that we had long intuitively known, namely that one should never take any single paper as the be-all and end-all, that we should base our medicine on a confluence of mutually supporting evidence, because the initial papers published on a topic, the “bleeding edge” sorts of papers if you will, often are later shown to be mistaken. Indeed, there’s even now a term for it, the “decline effect,” or, as I like to call it, science correcting itself, even if the process is often messy and slow.
Even pre-pandemic, though, I found myself not as enthusiastic about several of Ioannidis’ takes on issues. The first time I found myself seriously at odds with an Ioannidis study was in 2012, when he tried to argue (badly) that the NIH funding crisis is completely broken and favors “conformity” and “mediocrity”. If you want the full explanation, read this and, for background, this, but the CliffsNotes version is simple. He operated from the unproven assumption that funding more “risky” research would lead to more scientific breakthroughs and also assumed that publication indices are the be-all and end-all of scientific importance. (This is a recurring theme throughout his career that has contributed to his COVID-19 issues.) Consistent with this sort of disagreement, I also thought that Ioannidis exaggerated when he claimed there was a “reproducibility crisis” in biomedical science, although my disagreement wasn’t as sharp as it was about Ioannidis’ apparent dismissal of the NIH funding process as being a bunch of sheep rewarding only “safe” scientific proposals with funding. Then there was the time when Ioannidis argued that evidence-based medicine (EBM) was being “hijacked” by industry while totally ignoring how pseudoscientific “integrative medicine” and “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) had taken advantage of the huge blind spot of EBM with respect to scientific plausibility to “integrate” quackery with medicine.
Then came the COVID-19 pandemic.
Since the pandemic hit, Ioannidis has arguably been one of the most prolific producers in the scientific literature of articles that downplay the severity of the pandemic, many based on methodolatry. Examples abound and have been documented mainly by Jonathan Howard and myself, the most egregious example being when Ioannidis credulously repeated a conspiracy theory from early in the pandemic claiming that doctors were intubating COVID-19 patients willy-nilly who didn’t really need intubation, thereby killing them. Less egregious (but still quite egregious) examples include downplaying the death toll from the pandemic by misrepresenting how death certificates are filled out to claim that it was comorbidities killing patients rather than COVID-19 and that COVID-19 mortality statistics were therefore hugely exaggerated (another conspiracy theory); downplaying the impact of the pandemic on hospitals; and publishing articles that overestimated the prevalence of COVID-19 and underestimated its infection fatality rate (IFR), among other things.
As Ioannidis started to receive something he wasn’t used to, namely large amounts of harsh (and, to my mind, justified) criticism for his conclusions, he started firing back with scientific papers that indulged in what can only be described as ad hominem attacks. For example, in one paper he indulged in the most gratuitous ad hominem attack I’ve ever seen in a scientific paper against a graduate student named Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, who had published an article that found an IFR far higher than Ioannidis had estimated. More recently, I discussed Ioannidis in the context of the Carl Sagan effect, in which scientists who take the time to engage with the public to communicate science tend to be viewed by many of their peers as inferior scientists, based on a stunningly lazy exercise in bibliometrics in which Ioannidis concluded that science communicators who are interviewed in the media are not, by and large, members of the top 2% of scientists in terms of bibliometric metrics. It was as big a “Well, duh!” conclusion as I’ve ever seen, given that there’s no evidence that effective science communication correlates with the publication metrics that Ioannidis used and served more as yet another attack on his critics on social media than anything else.
This latest paper by Ioannidis takes his lashing out at critics to the next level, but to understand why and how, you need to understand the conflict between the GBD and the John Snow Memorandum and why it is not surprising that Ioannidis has clearly allied himself with the signatories of the GBD against their critics and has used an even more ridiculous and lazy analysis to do it.
The Great Barrington Declaration and the John Snow Memorandum
Regular readers will likely recall that the Great Barrington Declaration is a statement that arose out of a weekend conference in early October 2020 held in Great Barrington, MA at the headquarters of the American Institute for Economic Research, a free market right wing think tank. This Declaration was written and signed by academics favoring a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, basically a “let ‘er rip” strategy in order to hasten reaching “natural herd immunity”, with a poorly defined—actually, almost completely undefined—strategy of “focused protection” to protect the groups most vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19, such as the elderly, those with serious co-morbid chronic medical conditions (e.g., type II diabetes and heart disease), all so that society could “reopen” and life could go “back to normal”.
In response to the GBD, a group of public health scientists and physicians published the John Snow Memorandum. This memorandum was named in tribute to John Snow, the 19th century English physician who was one of the founders of modern epidemiology, for his finding that the source of a cholera outbreak in London was a public water pump on Broad Street, leading authorities to remove the pump handle, an action that ended the outbreak. In essence, the JSM countered the GBD by arguing for continuing traditional public health measures (masking, social distancing, etc.) to minimize death and suffering from COVID-19 by slowing its the spread at least until safe and effective vaccines and therapeutics became available. Again, remember that this was before COVID-19 vaccines were available to the public and that at the time these vaccines were still in clinical trials. The memorandum noted, correctly even in October 2020:
The arrival of a second wave and the realisation of the challenges ahead has led to renewed interest in a so-called herd immunity approach, which suggests allowing a large uncontrolled outbreak in the low-risk population while protecting the vulnerable. Proponents suggest this would lead to the development of infection-acquired population immunity in the low-risk population, which will eventually protect the vulnerable. This is a dangerous fallacy unsupported by scientific evidence.
Any pandemic management strategy relying upon immunity from natural infections for COVID-19 is flawed. Uncontrolled transmission in younger people risks significant morbidity(3) and mortality across the whole population. In addition to the human cost, this would impact the workforce as a whole and overwhelm the ability of healthcare systems to provide acute and routine care.
Furthermore, there is no evidence for lasting protective immunity to SARS-CoV-2 following natural infection(4) and the endemic transmission that would be the consequence of waning immunity would present a risk to vulnerable populations for the indefinite future. Such a strategy would not end the COVID-19 pandemic but result in recurrent epidemics, as was the case with numerous infectious diseases before the advent of vaccination.
Indeed, the signatories of the GBD, Martin Kuldorff of Harvard University, Jay Bhattacharya of Stanford University, and Sunetra Gupta of Oxford University, have always seemed—shall we say?—unconcerned that, as a practical matter, it is impossible to protect the vulnerable when a highly contagious respiratory virus is spreading unchecked through the “healthy” population. (After all, who takes care of the vulnerable?) Moreover, as was noted even then, for “natural herd immunity” even to be achievable, immunity after infection must be durable, preferably lifelong. Unfortunately, if there’s one thing that the rise of variants such as Delta and Omicron, the latter of which has been particularly prone to reinfect those previously infected with prior variants of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, has shown us, it’s that post-infection immunity (i.e., “natural immunity”) is nowhere near durable enough for such a strategy, given the propensity of this coronavirus to produce variants that can evade immunity from previous infections and waning immunity from vaccination. It is for those reasons that, when I originally wrote about the GBD, I described it as eugenicist in that it basically uses the observation that young people are far less likely to suffer severe disease and die from the disease as an excuse to argue, in essence, “Screw the elderly” and “let COVID-19 rip” in order to achieve “natural herd immunity”. This was especially true given that the GBD was published and promoted before there were safe and effective vaccines available against COVID-19.
Now that there are safe and effective vaccines against COVID-19, even if since the rise of the Delta and Omicron SARS-CoV-2 variants they are no longer as effective as they once were because these variants can evade both post-infection and vaccine-induced immunity to some extent, emphasizing “natural immunity” as somehow being “superior” to vaccine-induced immunity is even more dangerous because it’s clearly not. If the rise of the Delta and Omicron variants, which are transmissible even in the vaccinated, hasn’t demonstrated that to you, I don’t know what will. That’s why it’s particularly disturbing—albeit not particularly surprising—that the Brownstone Institute, founded by former AIER Editorial Director Jeffrey Tucker—who was “in the room where it happened” as the GBD was drafted, describes his new institute as the “spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration,” and recruited Kulldorff as its scientific director—has pivoted to spreading antivaccine misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines, even going so far as to compare vaccine mandates to the “othering” that lead to the Holocaust, slavery, and Rwandan genocide and the public health response to COVID-19 to the Chinese Cultural Revolution, all while its signatories claim to have been “silenced“.
Meanwhile, the GBD was hugely influential, with its signatories seemingly having had easy access to the Trump Administration in the US and the Johnson Administration in the UK, whose policies then essentially aligned with the Declaration, as well as leaders like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, who appointed a GBD devotee and member of the crank organization America’s Frontline Doctors to head up Florida’s public health apparatus and declared that a single positive COVID-19 antibody test proves lifelong immunity and no need for a COVID-19 vaccine ever. Even now, GBD signatories, allies, and flacks falsely argue that “natural immunity” undercuts the case for vaccine mandates, which, according to them, harm patients when required for healthcare workers and damage labor markets. Even after Joe Biden became US President, in this country the GBD remains enormously influential, and it’s hard to miss the rapid push to eliminate mask mandates and block vaccine mandates as having been influenced by it.
Enter John Ioannidis, using bad methodology and a joke of an index to argue that in reality the dominant narrative is not the GBD.
The Kardashian Index: Serious, satire, or a bit of both?
I had always ignored the Kardashian Index (or K-index), viewing it as more of a joke than anything valuable. It was originally proposed in 2014 by Neil Hall in a BMC Genome Biology publication entitled The Kardashian index: a measure of discrepant social media profile for scientists and named after Kim Kardashian, a celebrity who in my estimation is famous mainly for being famous (which was the point of the name) and compares the number of followers a scientist has on Twitter to the number of citations they have for their peer-reviewed work. The idea, clearly, was to denigrate scientists with a large social media presence as not being good scientists. Hall even said so:
While her Wikipedia entry describes her as a successful businesswoman [[2]], this is due most likely to her fame generating considerable income through brand endorsements. So you could say that her celebrity buys success, which buys greater celebrity. Her fame has meant that comments by Kardashian on issues such as Syria have been widely reported in the press [[3]]. Sadly, her interjection on the crisis has not yet led to a let-up in the violence.
I am concerned that phenomena similar to that of Kim Kardashian may also exist in the scientific community. I think it is possible that there are individuals who are famous for being famous (or, to put it in science jargon, renowned for being renowned). We are all aware that certain people are seemingly invited as keynote speakers, not because of their contributions to the published literature but because of who they are. In the age of social media there are people who have high-profile scientific blogs or twitter feeds but have not actually published many peer-reviewed papers of significance; in essence, scientists who are seen as leaders in their field simply because of their notoriety. I was recently involved in a discussion where it was suggested that someone should be invited to speak at a meeting ‘because they will tweet about it and more people will come’. If that is not the research community equivalent of buying a Kardashian endorsement I don’t know what is.
I don’t blame Kim Kardashian or her science equivalents for exploiting their fame, who wouldn’t? However, I think it’s time that we develop a metric that will clearly indicate if a scientist has an overblown public profile so that we can adjust our expectations of them accordingly.
Of course, Hall is on record recently as saying that he had always intended the K-index to be satire mocking the preoccupation with metrics measuring citations, even protesting that there are a number of “tells”. I’ll be honest. Most of his “tells” weren’t super obvious to me as I reread the paper. (Maybe that’s on me. Maybe not. Maybe I’m one of those old farts who didn’t “get it”.)
Let’s at least quote Hall, though:
It’s a dig at metrics not Kardashians. It’s like taking a quiz to see what character from Game of Thrones you are and finding out you’re Joffrey Baratheon. It doesn’t matter – it’s not a real test. Thankfully
— Neil Hall (@neilhall_uk) February 11, 2022
Only if they haven’t read the paper! the tells that the entire premise is satire could not be made more obvious. But is has had a ~180 citations so maybe I should have tried harder
— Neil Hall (@neilhall_uk) February 11, 2022
I suppose the description of picking a “randomish selection of 40 scientists” to examine and that he had “intended to collect more data but it took a long time and I therefore decided 40 would be enough to make a point” were likely two of his “tells,” but in retrospect I have a hard time not coming to the conclusion that this whole exercise, satire or not, backfired rather spectacularly. If the K-index is satire, it’s perhaps a bit too opaque a satire, as certainly Ioannidis appears not to have seen it as satire; either that, or Ioannidis’ use of the K-index is satire that’s even more opaque and less recognizable as satire than the original paper.
I did take one of Hall’s recommendations to heart, however:
I propose that all scientists calculate their own K-index on an annual basis and include it in their Twitter profile. Not only does this help others decide how much weight they should give to someone’s 140 character wisdom, it can also be an incentive – if your K-index gets above 5, then it’s time to get off Twitter and write those papers.
In the interests of full of transparency, I will note that my own K-index, calculated yesterday using Hall’s original formula, varies depending on how I calculate it. The K-index is “calculated as the ratio of Twitter followers divided by 43.3C0.32, where C is the total citations received in one’s career”. Hall came up with that denominator when he fitted a curve to a graph of the number of Twitter followers versus number of citations as a means of estimating how many Twitter followers a scientist should have based on his citations. (Remember, he only used 40 nonrandomly chosen scientists.) In any event, if I use Google Scholar’s estimate of my citations (which, as you will see, Ioannidis says that he does in his paper) my K-index is 104; if I use Web of Knowledge metrics, it’s even higher, at 118. I guess that makes me a “science Kardashian”. Do I care? Not really, given that I have over 69K Twitter followers and Hall’s silly metric says that I should only have 585-664 followers. Instead, I view my Twitter follower count as overachieving on Twitter rather than evidence of underachieving in science!

That Ioannidis would, apparently more or less seriously, use such an utterly ridiculous “old man yells at a cloud” metric (that was likely intended to mock the very sort of exercise he uses it to indulge in) to strike back at critics of the GBD and, not coincidentally, of him, boggles the mind. On the other hand, Ioannidis does not have a Twitter account, making his K-index by definition zero, making me think that his entire conclusion from the K-index is that scientists should not have Twitter accounts. I also note that young scientists, who, being relatively new scientists, likely haven’t amassed a lot of publications and citations yet, could easily have a really high K-index with just a modest number of Twitter followers. That’s how ratios work. Does Ioannidis not understand this?
I wasn’t alone in thinking this:
This paper is really something else. The part of me that loves science is grossed out. But the part of me that loves Real Housewives drama is entertained. The commitment to pettiness is exquisite.
— Natalie E. Dean, PhD (@nataliexdean) February 11, 2022
The Kardashian index has always struck me as the quintessential academic version of old people shaking their fists at the sky https://t.co/VCdn7OOl3R
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) February 11, 2022
So now, finally, let’s look at what Ioannidis did. I realize that some of you must be wondering why I took so long to get to this. You’ll just have to trust me that knowing the background is very important, and I hope that after you conclude this section you’ll agree.
Ioannidis versus the John Snow Memorandum
You can tell from the introduction of Ioannidis’ paper that he’s really cheesed about how the GBD and its signatories and supporters have been portrayed negatively, and he definitely vents:
The optimal approach to the COVID-19 pandemic has been an issue of major debate. Scientists have expressed different perspectives and many of them have also been organised to sign documents that outline overarching strategies. Two major schools of thought are represented by the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD)1 and the John Snow Memorandum (JSM)2 3 that were released with a short time difference in the fall of 2020. Each of them had a core team of original signatories and over time signatures were collected for many thousands of additional scientists, physicians and (in the case of GBD) also citizens.4 A careful inspection is necessary to understand the differences (but also potential common points) of the two strategies.4 5 The communication of these strategies to the wider public through media and social media has often created confusion and tension. The communication includes what endorsing scientists state and how opponents describe the opposite strategy. Oversimplification, use of strawman arguments, and allusions of conflicts, political endorsements and ad hominem attacks can create an explosive landscape.4–9
I like that part about ad hominem attacks, given Ioannidis’ previous “punching down” ad hominems against Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz and my perception that this entire article is basically an exercise in ad hominems marshaled to discredit JSM signatories. Maybe his irritation at criticism is part of the reason he treated a likely satirical index with the utter seriousness of a funeral director arranging a memorial service. Nowhere in his paper did I find any indication whatsoever that Ioannidis recognized the ridiculousness of the K-index or that it was likely intended as satire directed at the very sort of bibliometric analyses that he routinely does.
Pray continue, though, Dr. Ioannidis:
It is often stated in social media and media, by JSM proponents in particular, that JSM is by far the dominant strategy and that very few scientists with strong credentials endorse GBD.6–9 GBD proponents are often characterised as fringe, arrogant and wrong by their opponents.6–9 However, are these views justified based on objective evidence on scientific impact or they reflect mostly perceptions created by social media and their uptake also by media?
Here, an analysis is being performed to try to evaluate the scientific impact and the social media visibility of the key signatories who have led the two strategies. Scientific impact is very difficult to evaluate in all its dimensions and no single number exists that can measure scientific excellence and scholarship. However, one can use citation metrics to objectively quantify the impact of a scientist’s work in terms of how often it is used in the scientific literature. Adjustments for coauthorship patterns, relative contributions and scientific field need to be accounted for.10 Concurrently, an additional analysis evaluated the social media visibility of signatories, as denoted by Twitter followers.
Surely Dr. Ioannidis must realize that there are social media platforms other than Twitter. What about Instagram and YouTube, for instance? Or Facebook? Or Tik Tok. (If Twitter irritates Ioannidis so much, Tik Tok will likely break his mind. Maybe it’s best that he never look at Tik Tok.) Also, notice how he’s trying to argue that the JSM narrative doesn’t really dominate in public health science but only appears to dominate because of the social media presences of its signatories. And how does he propose to prove that? First, he looks at H-index metrics for the key signatories of both documents. H-index is a commonly used measure of publication productivity and citation metrics. Mine, for instance, is 26. Using the same methodology, Ioannidis’ H-index is 162. (To be honest, I thought that the discrepancy would be an order of magnitude larger.) Then he goes to Twitter and starts calculating the K-index for the signatories.
Ioannidis is sloppy from the start. He states that he uses the Google Scholar citation index for this reason:
The original publication14 defining the index used citations from Google Scholar. However, given that many signatories did not have Google Scholar pages and Google Scholar citations may be more erratic, Scopus citations (including self-citations) as of 2 April 2021 were used instead. Scopus citation counts may be slightly or modestly lower than Google Scholar citations, and this may lead to slightly higher K-index estimates, but the difference is probably small.
I went back and reread Hall’s original paper proposing the K-index, referenced by Ioannidis. Hall only mentions Google once in the context of Kim Kardashian being the most searched-for person on Google in 2014. In fact, Hall did not use Google Scholar at all, but rather stated explicitly: “I used Web of Knowledge to get citation metrics on these individuals.” So already, I sense some…manipulation and cherry picking here. Did Ioannidis try using Hall’s original formula and find something that didn’t fit with his narrative? One wonders, one does.
Actually, one doesn’t, given how Ioannidis picks the signatories he looks at:
The two documents were retrieved online.1–3 For the main analysis, the 47 original key signatories of the GBD who were listed on its original release online, and the 34 original key signatories who authored the first release of the JSM in a correspondence item published in the Lancet3 were considered for in-depth citation analysis.
He also takes care to use his previous database, the one that he used to denigrate scientists with a media and social media presence, to look at the top 2% of scientists in terms of his citation index. In any event, he’s unable to show that the original Great Barrington Declaration signatories are significantly “better” by these metrics than the original JSM signatories, concluding:
Among the 47 original key signatories of GBD, 20, 19 and 21, respectively, were among the top-cited authors for their career impact, their recent single-year (2019) impact or either. Among the 34 original key signatories of JSM, 11, 14 and 15, respectively, were among the top-cited authors for their career impact, their recent single year (2019) or either. The percentage of top-cited scientists is modestly higher for GBD than for JSM, but the difference is not beyond chance (p>0.10 for all three definitions).
He had a similar lack of luck when it came to comparing how many scientists were among the “top 2%” for each group. Then he produced what has to be one of the most ridiculous figures I’ve ever seen (and the only figure in the paper), showing the Twitter counts:

He then notes:
Only 4/47 GBD signatories versus 17/34 JSM signatories had over 30 000 Twitter followers (3/47 vs 10/34 for signatories with over 50 000 Twitter followers). Twitter and citation data, and inferred Kardashian K-indices for the scientists with >50,000 followers appear in table 2. The values of K-index in these scientists were extraordinarily high (363–2569).
An updated search for Twitter accounts and followers on 25 November 2021 found that 22/47 key GBD signatories versus 34/34 key JSM signatories had a retrievable Twitter account (p<0.001). The median number of followers was 0 vs 34 600 (p<0.001). The number of key signatories with >50 000 followers was 13 vs 4.
If I were a peer reviewer for this article, I would have noted that Ioannidis got it wrong describing Hall’s original methodology (such as it was) and appears to have cherry picked an index that he’s more comfortable with. Even accepting that his findings described a reasonable comparison (which they don’t), I’d ask: So what? There’s no evidence that social media presence does or should correlate with citation metrics in the peer-reviewed literature. I’d even point out that, if you look at Table 2, which includes signatories with more than 50K Twitter followers, some of the GBD signatories have K-indices much higher than even mine calculated using Google Scholar; e.g., Martin Kulldorff (363), Michael Levitt 451), and Karol Sikora (2,569).
Of course, if I were a reviewer, normally I would expect to see my peer review of the manuscript published. Why? Because BMJ Open Access also publishes the peer review reports of the papers it publishes, all in the name of transparency. Yet in this one case, a paper written by John Ioannidis as single author (and single author papers are also unusual), it has been observed:
BMJ responded:
A “technical error”? Why is it that I find this explanation rather…convenient.
Whether the failure to post the peer reviews was an honest mistake or something less innocent, Ioannidis’ discussion section made me laugh out loud at a number of points. Running through his commentary is the apparent idea that the number of Twitter followers is a valid metric for influence, coupled with the implicit Carl Sagan effect-like assumption that GBD signatories are better scientists because they don’t have as large a social media presence. For instance, get a load of this backhanded compliment:
The key JSM signatories have a very large number of followers in highly active personal Twitter accounts. The most visible Twitter owners include some of the most cited scientists in the analysed cohorts (Trisha Greenhalgh, Marc Lipsitch, Florian Krammer, Rochelle Walensky, Michael Levitt, Martin Kulldorff, Jay Bhattacharya) and others who have little or no impact in the scientific literature, but are highly remarkable and laudable for their enthusiastic activism (eg, Dominic Pimenta).
You can almost sense Ioannidis patting Dr. Pimenta on the head in a condescending fashion.
Amazingly, Ioannidis then cites Hall’s original paper, a paper that the Ioannidis of 2014 would likely have dismissed as a joke (which it is) as though it were serious scholarship:
Previous work that introduced the Kardashian K-index stated that K-index values above 5 suggest an overemphasis of social media versus scientific literature presence and called such researchers ‘Science Kardashians’.14 This characterisation has not caught up with evolutions in the last few years. Many signatories, especially of JSM, have extraordinarily high K-index, with values in the hundreds and thousands. However, one should account that the volume of Twitter users and followers has increased markedly since the K-index was first proposed, even before the COVID-19 pandemic and even for specialists in disciplines that are not very likely to attract massive social media interest (eg, urology).15 As COVID-19 has attracted tremendous social media attention, Kardashian K-indices are skyrocketing. While no past data were available for the number of followers of the analysed scientists pre-COVID, anecdotal experience suggests that many, if not most, saw their followers increase tremendously during the pandemic. Substantial increases were documented even in the short 7-month interval between April and November 2021.
The massive advent of social media contributes to a rampant infodemic16–18 with massive misinformation circulating. If knowledgeable scientists can have strong social media presence, massively communicating accurate information to followers, the effect may be highly beneficial. Conversely, if scientists themselves are affected by the same problems (misinformation, animosity, loss of decorum and disinhibition, among others)19 20 when they communicate in social media, the consequences may be negative.
Ioannidis, predictably, ignores his own role in contributing to this “infodemic”. He also finally reveals what’s really at the heart of this “paper”. After acknowledging that he had only sampled a small number of other signatories of both documents and that “both citation indices and Twitter followers have limitations in face validity and construct validity as measures of impact”, he nonetheless pivots to claim victimhood for GBD signatories and their narrative:
Acknowledging these caveats, the data suggest that the massive superiority of JSM over GBD in terms of Twitter firepower may have helped shape the narrative that it is the dominant strategy pursued by a vast majority of knowledgeable scientists. This narrative is clearly contradicted by the citation data. The Twitter superiority may also cause, and/or reinforce also superiority in news coverage. In a darker vein, it may also be responsible for some bad publicity that GBD has received, for example, as evidenced by plain Google searches online or searches in Wikipedia pages for GBD, its key signatories or even for other scientists who may espouse some GBD features, for example, scepticism regarding the risk-benefit of prolonged lockdowns. Smearing, even vandalisation, is prominent for many such Wikipedia pages or other social media and media coverage of these scientists. This creates a situation where scientific debate becomes vitriolic, and censoring (including self-censoring) may become prominent. Perusal of the Twitter content of JSM signatories and their op-eds suggests that some may have sadly contributed to GBD vilification.24
In addition, although Ioannidis is mostly correct that the narrative in the media has generally portrayed JSM as the scientific consensus, he fails to recognize that the reason for this dominance is more because JSM has been far closer to the scientific consensus in public health than the GBD, always a minority fringe viewpoint, ever was, rather than anything having to do with Twitter activity of JSM signatories. Indeed, Tim Caulfield and colleagues have argued that what predominated in the media regarding “natural herd immunity” strategies was more false balance than anything else, and I find that argument persuasive, particularly given the effectiveness of organizations like AIER and its offspring the Brownstone Institute.
Ioannidis also casts GBD signatories and supporters as victims, with a bit of what borders on conspiracy mongering:
A major point of attack has been alleged conflicts of interest. However, GBD leaders have repeatedly denied conflicts of interest (see also the site of GBD1). Key JSM signatories appropriately and laudably disclosed upfront all potential conflicts of interest in their original letter publication in the Lancet; the long list is available in public.3 Based on this list, it is possible that JSM leaders have more conflicts than GBD leaders, but the social media superiority of JSM controls also the narrative surrounding conflicts. A similar vitriolic attack has been launched against the American Institute of Economic Research that offered the venue for hosting the launch of GBD.24 Experimental studies show that mentioning conflicts may have the same degree of negative impact as attacks on the empirical basis of the science claims; allegations of conflict of interest are as influential as allegations of outright fraud, when the value of scientific evidence is appraised.25 Non-scientists’ trust is eroded by allusions of conflicts of interest, while it is not affected much by perception of scientific (in)competence (which is also impossible for a non-expert to appraise).25 26 In good faith, reporting of potential conflicts of interest should be encouraged and transparency maximised. However, spurious allegations of hidden agendas and conflicts should not become a weapon for invalidating one or the other document. While exceptions may exist, probably the vast majority of scientists who signed either document simply had good intentions towards helping in a major crisis.
I find it interesting that nowhere does Ioannidis appear to cite the document that, to AIER and GBD signatories, is one of the “vitriolic attacks” against them, namely the article I co-authored with Gavin Yamey (one of the JSM signatories) last spring, in which we documented how right wing forces and think tanks were promoting a GBD narrative and how influential that narrative had been to governments. Indeed, Ioannidis himself was promoting a GBD-like argument against “lockdowns” with his friend Bhattacharya to the Trump administration months before there was even a GBD, and Trump’s COVID-19 czar Dr. Scott Atlas even acknowledged him for it on Tucker Carlson’s Fox News show a month ago. Meanwhile, I’m hard-pressed to find any JSM signatories having been invited to have such close contact with the Trump or Johnson administrations.
Interestingly, Martin Kulldorff and Jay Bhattacharya, both GBD signatories, with Kulldorff being the person who was first enticed by AIER to get the other GBD signatories together for the Great Barrington conference that spawned the GBD, are quite capable of some serious vitriol themselves, for example:
Slander and lies have been hallmarks of attacks on the @gbdeclaration.
This is because lockdown proponents have weak arguments. Their lockdown love has hurt millions via collateral damage & benefited only the laptop class to which many of them belong.https://t.co/M3P9b5BBy4
— Jay Bhattacharya (@DrJBhattacharya) October 12, 2021
Kulldorff himself loves to dismiss doctors critical of the GBD as “laptop class”, claiming false solidarity with working class people who didn’t have the option of working from home during the pandemic, which Kulldorff no doubt did. Kulldorff also has a penchant for referring to his opponents as being a cult:
It is an article of faith contrary to scientific evidence that recovery from COVID does not provide long lasting immunity. Hence, if you have had COVID and do not want to abide by vaccine mandates, you can claim a religious exception for not belonging to the Covidian church.
— Martin Kulldorff (@MartinKulldorff) July 6, 2021
“Covidian church”? (I suppose I should be grateful that Kulldorff refrained form using “Branch Covidian”, a favorite of antivaxxers to describe scientists.) Kulldorff does know, doesn’t he, that referring to scientific findings as religion and scientists you don’t like as cult members is exactly the same thing that antivaxxers love to do. Similarly, Kulldorff and Bhattacharya, the latter a good friend of Ioannidis’, have accused critics of the GBD of being “part of the mob”, egoists “making the poor suffer for their egos”, and so deluded that they “know lockdowns don’t help but they continue”.
Just last week, a Stanford University medical student named Santiago Sanchez challenged GBD signatory Dr. Bhattacharya. I think it’s worth citing some of the Tweets:
I don't know who you are, but you're very bad at mind reading. I think Fauci's decisions during the pandemic (and maybe before) have led to countless unnecessary deaths. https://t.co/CtN27XTTt4
— Jay Bhattacharya (@DrJBhattacharya) February 11, 2022
Also worth mentioning that Jay has spent a good deal of his time lobbying in courts all over the country to overturn mask mandates, and broadcast a petition against Stanford mandating boosters for students which has mostly been signed and circulated among ppl not at the uni.
— santiago (@santiagokique) February 7, 2022
Jay himself does not shy from personally attacking scientists or sicking right-wing culture warriors against members of the community. https://t.co/NZUXbvWNg8
— santiago (@santiagokique) February 7, 2022
Not only did Bhattacharya sic his Twitter followers on Sanchez, but, suspiciously, a “charity” affiliate of the GBD known as Collateral Global Charity called him a snake. When criticized harshly for it, whoever runs its Twitter account deleted the original Tweet and then unconvincingly claimed that it had been hacked:
A “charity” affiliate of the GBD called me a snake, deleted, and claimed they were hacked. Very normal behavior. pic.twitter.com/IUWsvt5ulI
— santiago (@santiagokique) February 13, 2022
One wonders if the ever-so-civil Ioannidis, who decries any form of ad hominem and nastiness in his search for only the purest possible scientific discourse has had a little chat with his good buddy Jay Bhattacharya and his other friends at the GBD about how bad it looks to “punch down” this way. I won’t even go into how Bhattacharya also challenged Santiago to a debate moderated by—I kid you not!—Dr. Vinay Prasad.
On second thought, I can’t resist:
I couldn’t resist giving this intrepid medical student, whom I admire for his bravery in standing up to a famous professor at his medical school, a little advice about not debating cranks, using my SBM post from a couple of weeks ago:
It’s not and don’t do it. @DrJBhattacharya knows that the power differential alone makes such a “debate” propaganda, not a scientific debate. https://t.co/PIoanGrDWt
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) February 13, 2022
I’ll stop now, because I know that some of you don’t like a lot of embedded Tweets, but I think that in this case it is more than justified to feature them. In addition, I realize that this is a bit of a tu quoque fallacy to bring this up, but on the other hand the hypocrisy of GBD signatories and advocates never ceases to astound me. Indeed, Ioannidis’ paper can be viewed in this context as a rather obvious ploy to portray JSM signatories as social media prima donnas, as unserious “science Kardashians”, and he’s so intent on such an ad hominem attack that he appears to have completely missed the point about the K-index and took it as a serious metric supported by research; that is, unless he has written a satire so incredibly subtle that no one can detect the satire.
I’ll conclude by asking about John Ioannidis the same thing that I ask about every scientist and physician whom before the pandemic I had considered reasonable or even someone to be admired for their scientific and medical rigor: Did something about them change, or where they always like this and I just didn’t see it? For someone like Dr. Vinay Prasad, I think that the answer is the latter explanation. In the case of John Ioannidis, I still don’t know. Everyone with whom I’ve interacted who knows him says he’s such a supportive, honorable, and nice man. A paper like his K-index paper, however, is not consistent with such a characterization, and that’s why more and more I’m leaning towards the latter explanation for his behavior and scientific takes since the pandemic hit. Whatever the reason, I’ll conclude once again that, sadly, Ioannidis appears to have come full circle. He first became famous because of his paper about how most scientific findings turn out to be wrong, and now he’s contributing to the very problem that he identified.
And now he’s gone beyond that and led me to write a sentence that I never in my wildest dreams would have imagined and actually use it as a title of a blog post.

Intubations and Accusations Part 2
A famous economist once said, “When the facts change, I change my mind”. Others take the opposite approach and attempt to alter the facts to preserve their beliefs. Read their work with this in mind.
Jonathan Howard on February 23, 2022
Link

A review
In a previous essay I wrote the following about Dr. John Ioannidis:
On a podcast (at 1:37:25), Dr. Ioannidis said, “There is an effect of what we did, mostly wrong, in the first wave”. To be clear, Dr. Ioannidis is not referring to himself when he said, “what we did, mostly wrong,” but rather to doctors who treated patients with a completely new virus early in the pandemic. Had he been referring to himself, I suspect he would not have laughed when he said this. He then said that “a lot of lives” were lost at that time in part because of doctors “not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation, just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”.
In a subsequent essay I reported on a similar accusation made by Dr. Ioannidis, this time in one of his publications.
Dr. Ioannidis said that the “future infection fatality rate may decrease with better protection of vulnerable children, more effective treatments, and avoidance of harmful treatments (e.g. improper mechanical ventilation strategies.)” In other words, Dr. Ioannidis expects that fewer kids will die from rushed intubations moving forward. No reference is given for this claim, as conspiracy theory sites that push this idea can’t be referenced.
Dr. Ioannidis was wrong about all this. As I explained,
Not only is there no evidence that doctors were “just going crazy” intubating patients, leading to their demise, in fact, a meta-analysis of 12 studies found “The synthesized evidence of almost 9,000 patients suggests that timing of intubation may have no effect on mortality and morbidity of critically ill patients with COVID-19”. This suggests that early intubation of critically ill COVID-19 patients may not be necessary, but it doesn’t kill them. This meta-analysis was published after Dr. Ioannidis made his accusation, but all 12 studies it reviewed were published beforehand.
I further reported on another study that even found improved survival rates in COVID-19 patients who were intubated early and noted that this is not a trivial academic debate.
There are real-world consequences when people believe false information. Dr. Alison Pittard, an intensivist from the UK, said patients were refusing ventilators because,
“They think if they do not go on a ventilator, they have got a better chance of surviving, because once they go on a ventilator they are going to die irrespective. And of course that is not correct because if you are faced with a patient who needs to go on a ventilator … if they don’t go on a ventilator then the chances are that they will die. So, that is almost saying there is a 100% chance of dying. Whereas if they go on a ventilator then they will have a 40% chance of dying.”
An update
Dr. Ioannidis encountered my criticisms in an essay by Dr. David Gorski and responded to him thusly in a discussion in The BMJ:
Later, I do mention that probably we had more deaths because of not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation. This statement is also correct. The paper cited by Gorski is examining early versus late intubations and actually concludes that “these results might justify a wait-and-see approach, which may lead to fewer intubations”.
So who is right here? After all, we are all referencing the same paper to support our conclusions.
Here are the complete conclusions of the meta-analysis, which I accurately reported in my essay:
The synthesized evidence of almost 9000 patients suggests that timing of intubation may have no effect on mortality and morbidity of critically ill patients with COVID-19. These results might justify a wait-and-see approach, which may lead to fewer intubations. Relevant guidelines may therefore need to be updated.
So let’s be clear what happened here. As Dr. Gorski explained, Dr. Ioannidis doubled down on his claim that “probably we had more deaths because of not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation”. To bolster this extremely serious accusation against overwhelmed frontline doctors at the start of the pandemic, Dr. Ioannidis selectively quoted a sentence from a paper whose key finding was “The synthesized evidence suggests that timing of intubation may have no effect on mortality and morbidity of critically ill patients with COVID-19”.
A famous economist once said, “When the facts change, I change my mind”. Unfortunately, other people try to change the facts to preserve their beliefs.
Read their work with this in mind.

Misinformation is Censorship
It’s impossible to have a meaningful conversation with a misinformed interlocutor- and there are many- who insists COVID is just the flu, it poses a “negligible” risk to a healthy person younger than 65, and the pandemic ended long ago.
Jonathan Howard on December 30, 2022
Link

Dr. John Ioaniddis, April 2020
This post isn’t about Dr. John Ioaniddis, but I’ll start with an optimistic prediction he made on April 9, 2020. Dr. Ioannidis said:
If I were to make an informed estimate based on the limited testing data we have, I would say that covid-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA.
By April 9, 2020, 21,993 Americans had already died of COVID, and COVID’s death toll that day was 1,921 people. Dr. Ioannidis was predicting that only 18,000 more people would die of COVID “this season”, and he did so on a day when 799 people died in New York State alone, breaking the record for daily COVID deaths for the third straight day. Over 7,000 New Yorkers had died already. Unless COVID vanished instantly, Dr. Ioannidis’ prediction would age poorly within a week.
Indeed, by April 17, 2020, America’s COVID death toll was 39,581, and 2,197 people died that day. Though his prediction of 40,000 deaths was falsified in 8 days, Dr. Ioannidis was unfazed. In fact, on the very day his prediction was proven wrong, he gave an interview in which he continued to minimize the virus. He said that based on a flawed Santa Clara antibody study:
We realize that the number of infected people is somewhere between 50 and 85 times more compared to what we thought, compared to what had been documented. Immediately, that means that the infection fatality rate, the chance of dying, the probability of dying, if you are infected, diminishes by 50-85 fold, because the denominator in the calculation becomes 50-85 fold bigger. If you take these numbers into account, they suggest that the infection fatality rate for this new coronavirus is likely to be in the same ballpark as seasonal influenza…
Our data suggests that COVID-19 has an infection fatality rate that is in the same ballpark as seasonal influenza. It suggests that even though this is a very serious problem, we should not fear. It suggests that we have solid ground to have optimism about the possibility of eventually reopening our society and gaining back our lives…We have data now that the infection fatality rate is much, much lower, compared to our original expectations and fears. I think that there is no reason to fear.
Dr. Ioannidis thought that hospitals were being overrun with the worried well. He said:
I think that in many of these places, unfortunately, we saw many people going to the hospital probably under a sense of fear and threat and panic, and we had the environment heavily contaminated, generating hospital chains of infection and therefore infecting lots of people who were very susceptible, and who would do very poorly if, on top of whatever they had, they also got COVID-19 infection.
No one who worked in a COVID hotspot at that time ever said anything that absurd. Healthcare workers used war analogies to describe what was happening. One traveling nurse, who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, estimated that he saw 3,000 people die of COVID, saying “War doesn’t even compare to this…I would rather die, any other way of dying, than dying with coronavirus”. A doctor at Elmhurst Hospital in Queens said:
If you watch a war movie to see people shooting from all over, that’s what this almost felt like. One thing after the next after next, you can’t even catch up with what has to happen.
Three days later, on April 20th, 2020, Dr. Ioannidis appeared on a Fox News program hosted by right-wing firebrand Mark Levin. Dr. Ioannidis said the risk of dying from COVID was high for elderly people, especially those in nursing homes, and for those with serious underlying conditions. Though 46,000 Americans were now dead, Dr. Ioannidis continued to minimize the virus for everyone else. He said “most of the population has minimal risk, in the range of dying while you’re driving from home to work and back”. He said the infection fatality rate is “probably in the range of 1 in a 1,000”. Mr. Levin repeated the good news by saying, “You say one in a thousand. You’re saying well under 1%, is that one-tenth of 1% of the population that actually has the virus will pass away as a result of the virus, or in connection to the virus”.
New York City had already recorded over 10,000 COVID deaths the week before this interview. If 10,000 people had already died and if only 1 in a 1,000 people died overall, this would require 10 million New Yorkers to have been infected, when only 8.3 million people live there. Given that a million Americans have now died of COVID, an infection fatality rate of 1 in 1,000 would require 1 billion infections, triple the population of the entire country.
So by April 20th, 2020, Dr. Ioannidis had already had one optimistic prediction obliterated in 8 days, and his response was to calculate an infection fatality rate so low, it required that over 100% of New Yorkers had already contracted COVID. 
“Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should be Heard, Not Demonized”
With this in mind, let’s revisit an article that was published on April 27, 2020, titled “Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should be Heard, Not Demonized” By Drs. Vinay Prasad and Jeffrey S. Flier, the Higginson Professor of Physiology and Medicine, Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor, and Former Dean of the Faculty of Medicine (2007- 2016). Their article said:
When major decisions must be made amid high scientific uncertainty, as is the case with Covid-19, we can’t afford to silence or demonize professional colleagues with heterodox views. Even worse, we can’t allow questions of science, medicine, and public health to become captives of tribalized politics. Today, more than ever, we need vigorous academic debate.
To be clear, Americans have no obligation to take every scientist’s idea seriously. Misinformation about Covid-19 is abundant. From snake-oil cures to conspiracy theories about the origin of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes the disease, the internet is awash with baseless, often harmful ideas. We denounce these: Some ideas and people can and should be dismissed.
Although their article appeared after 60,000 Americans had died of COVID, 20,000 more than Dr. Ioannidis predicted, Drs. Prasad and Flier said we had an obligation to take his every idea seriously. Dr. Ioannidis’ view that COVID was “in the same ballpark as seasonal influenza” was not to be dismissed. They said he was an “independent thinker” expressing “heterodox views”. Their article concluded:
Scientific consensus is important, but it isn’t uncommon when some of the most important voices turn out to be those of independent thinkers, like John Ioannidis, whose views were initially doubted. That’s not an argument for prematurely accepting his contestable views, but it is a sound argument for keeping him, and others like him, at the table.
According to Drs. Prasad and Flier, Dr. Ioannidis was just expressing “heterodox views” when he continued to minimize COVID on the very day its death toll exceeded his prediction of 40,000 deaths. Dr. Ioannidis was just being an “independent thinker” when he calculated that 120% of New Yorkers contracted COVID by April 2020. Though the internet is “awash with baseless, often harmful ideas,” a world-famous scientist from Stanford can never have anything to do with that. Anyone who argues otherwise is trying to squash “vigorous academic debate”.
Though I disagree, I will reiterate a point that both myself and Dr. David Gorski have stated previously: Threats and vulgarities against scientists and doctors are always horrific and indefensible. 
“Herd immunity was going to save us, and this thing was going to go bye-bye”
However, for the most part, Drs. Prasad and Flier have reason to celebrate. If we fantasize that Dr. Ioannidis’ critics were actually was trying to “silence” him in April 2020, they failed miserably. He was a loud, ubiquitous, and influential presence, especially at that time. According to one news article from December 2020, “He had appeared at least 18 times on major cable news networks, repeatedly questioning the severity of the pandemic.” Stephanie Lee further reported that Dr. Ioannidis’ optimistic predictions:
Caught the eye of many conservative commentators, from Ann Coulter to Fox News personality Lisa Boothe. Bret Stephens cited it in a New York Times columntitled “It’s Dangerous to Be Ruled by Fear.” It also circulated among West Wing aides, Bloomberg reported.
Dr. Ioannidis has continued to be interviewed by the media and on podcasts since. While the market for doctors predicting the end of the pandemic has since become saturated, Dr. Ioannidis continues to make his opinions known. One article from March 2022 said, “John Ioannidis: ‘Public Health Officials Need to Declare the End of the Pandemic.'” Of course, this is what he’s said the entire pandemic, not just in niche academic conferences and journals, but in interviews seen by many millions of people.
Dr. Ioannidis also got his seat at the table. Dr. Scott Atlas, an anti-vaccine doctor who served as President Trump’s COVID advisor took his ideas to the top, and this started early on. On March 20, 2020, Dr. Atlas sent an email to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Administrator Seema Verma in which he the “virus would cause about 10,000 deaths.” He claimed this number “would be unnoticed” in a normal flu season. The House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis revealed the unsurprising news that Dr. Atlas took these words directly from Dr. Ioannidis, who was saying exactly this at the time.
Once he arrived at the White House, Dr. Atlas worked only “to convince people that herd immunity was going to save us, and this thing was going to go bye-bye” according to the CDC Director Robert Redfield. I urge you to read The Altas Dogma, the damning report by the House Select Subcommittee, detailing the real-world consequences of Dr. Atlas’ misinformation. Here’s an excerpt:
Dr. Atlas also used his newfound position of power to recruit herd immunity proponents to come to Washington, D.C., to meet with multiple senior Administration officials and, according to Director Redfield, “convince people that herd immunity was going to save us, and this thing was going to go bye-bye.” In August 2020, Dr. Atlas successfully arranged for three herd immunity proponents to meet with President Trump and Vice President Mike Pence to discuss their views on the pandemic response—which went forward despite Dr. Birx expressing concerns to the Vice President’s Chief of Staff Marc Short and other senior officials and refusing to attend. In October 2020, Dr. Atlas coordinated a meeting between HHS Secretary Alex Azar and the authors of the discredited “Great Barrington Declaration,” which advocated for the herd immunity strategy that Dr. Atlas was actively promoting. Secretary Azar issued a tweet after the meeting recognizing that the approach articulated by the Great Barrington Declaration authors was a “strong reinforcement” of the Trump Administration’s ongoing response strategy.
Dr. Atlas openly credited Dr. Ioannidis in a recent article ironically titled “When Will Academia Account for Its Covid Failures?”. Dr. Atlas wrote: 
Virtually every scientific point I made exactly matched those of Jay Bhattacharya and John Ioannidis, both Stanford professors of medicine, including the risk for children, spread from children, focused protection, postinfection immunity, masks, and the harm from school closures and lockdowns.
Drs. Prasad and Flier got their wish. Dr. Ioannidis turned out to be one of the “most important voices” this pandemic. Dr. Atlas later wrote he was in touch with Dr. Ioannidis frequently during his tenure in the Trump administration. The idea that “herd immunity was going to save us, and this thing was going to go bye-bye” became policy. Countless millions of Americans believed this too. You can judge the results.
“Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19”
Drs. Prasad and Flier also wrote:
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
Dr. Flier recently revisited his article and said he “wouldn’t change a word.” I would. COVID killed over a million Americans and sickened many millions more. Nothing was more toxic and deadly than the virus, and only someone sheltered from it horrors could claim otherwise.
But misinformation was one of the main reasons COVID was so toxic and deadly. Tens of millions of Americans falsely believed the virus posed no risk to them, the pandemic was over, the death toll was inflated, that death certificates couldn’t be trusted, and that doctors killed patients through premature intubations. They learned this all from a respected scientist, aided by respected supporters who told them his absurd predictions and impossible calculations were actually the words of a “heterodox” scientist, and “independent thinker”. Is it any wonder why so many Americans refused a COVID vaccine?
The constant bleating about “silencing heterodox thinkers” overlooks many obvious things. Not only were these “silenced” doctors very loud and very influential, they were wrong and they were obviously wrong. Society faces a toxic and deadly risk when patently absurd ideas get reframed as “heterodox”. Society faces a toxic and deadly risk when those who espouse patently absurd ideas are seated at the head of at the table. Society faces a toxic and deadly risk when a respected scientist who easily speaks in scientific jargon can say damn near anything and still have esteemed members of the medical establishment rally to his defense. Society faces a toxic and deadly risk when strident critics are falsely labeled censors.
No one wants to be called a censor, and ironically, mislabeling one’s critics as “censors” is a very effective way to censor one’s critics.
Of course, no one wants unorthodox beliefs to be labeled as “misinformation.” We need to leave room for people to have good faith disagreements without being smeared as “anti-vaccine” or “anti-science.” We need to be open to outliers and mavericks. The inspirational story of Dr. Katalin Kariko, the unappreciated scientist whose work paved the way for mRNA vaccines, shows why this is so. No doctor should be fearful to challenge medical dogma, so long as they have evidence and are willing to admit error if their pet theory doesn’t pan out. (Dr. Ioannidis is now making cringeworthy, self-congratulatory movies about how right he was. “Death is a beautiful woman that you can be in love with but you don’t want to meet,” he said.)
However, “vigorous academic debate” requires some semblance of a shared reality, and basic facts are not up for “debate”. It’s impossible to have a meaningful conversation with a misinformed interlocutor- and there are many- who insists COVID is just the flu, it poses a “negligible” risk to healthy people younger than 65, and the pandemic ended long ago.
Nasty words to a secure, famous scientist are just nasty words.
Misinformation is censorship.

“This Would Translate to About 10,000 Deaths” Reflections From the Start of the Pandemic
Jonathan Howard on March 17, 2022
Link

“This would translate to about 10,000 deaths”
Two years ago, Dr. John Ioannidis wrote an essay in STAT titled “A Fiasco in The Making? As The Coronavirus Pandemic Takes Hold, We Are Making Decisions Without Reliable Data.” It contained the following paragraph:
If we assume that case fatality rate among individuals infected by SARS-CoV-2 is 0.3% in the general population — a mid-range guess from my Diamond Princess analysis — and that 1% of the U.S. population gets infected (about 3.3 million people), this would translate to about 10,000 deaths. This sounds like a huge number, but it is buried within the noise of the estimate of deaths from “influenza-like illness.” If we had not known about a new virus out there, and had not checked individuals with PCR tests, the number of total deaths due to “influenza-like illness” would not seem unusual this year. At most, we might have casually noted that flu this season seems to be a bit worse than average. The media coverage would have been less than for an NBA game between the two most indifferent teams.
This all seems pretty straightforward. Dr. Ioannidis calculated a case fatality rate with the limited information that was available at that time, and assumed 1% of the US would get infected. Combining these metrics, he calculated about 10,000 people would die. He thought we if we didn’t test for it, we might not notice the virus at all. He felt that “at most we might have casually noted” its impact, and that overall it would be as significant as a dull basketball game.
This clearly reflected his thinking at the time. In a paper, published two days later, March 19th, 2020, he wrote about “exaggerated pandemic estimates,” “exaggerated case fatality rate,” and “exaggerated exponential community spread.” He said a claim that 20%-60% of adults would be infected, was “substantially exaggerated.” He said, “China data are more compatible with close contact rather than wide community spread being the main mode of transmission,” He said that, “Even if COVID-19 is not a 1918-recap in infection-related deaths, some coronavirus may match the 1918 pandemic in future seasons. Thus, we should learn and be better prepared.” He felt this coronavirus was a false alarm. He wrote that,
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
Some problems
But there were some problems. Dr. Hilda Bastian, noticed flaws in his estimation that 0.3% of people who contract COVID will die, writing “the 0.3% CFR seems likely to be too low, too.” Two years later, 0.3% Americans have died of COVID, proving Dr. Bastian’s criticism was correct.
Dr. Bastian also said that “The 1% rate of people infected, however, is likely to be very wide off the mark. It’s far lower than the infection rate on the Diamond Princess (which was more like 20%).” Others noticed this as well. One commentator on STAT news wrote,
In the same article that you use the Diamond Princess cruise ship as a case study for fatality rates, you estimate that 1% of the U.S population might be infected. The Diamond Princess cruise ship saw nearly 25% of the ship’s passengers infected. Perhaps multiply your “lost in the noise” 10,000 influenza-like deaths by 20+.
Another prescient commentator wrote,
The contagion factor of this virus is far greater than influenza- so if you don’t take measures to slow the spread you get a higher death rate because you can’t treat all the sick at once.
The tip of the iceberg
Indeed, a few weeks later, Dr. Ioannidis would partially adopt this position and completely reverse his his assumption that 1% of the US would contract COVID. Based on a controversial antibody study, he estimated the virus was 50-85 times more common than he previously thought. He now felt the virus was “very common” and that the number of known COVID cases was merely the “tip of the iceberg“.
Paradoxically, this was a comforting thought. If large numbers of people had been infected without even knowing about it, it meant COVID’s impact would be much less severe than feared. As he said in an interview, it would mean the “probability of dying if you are infected diminishes by 50-85 fold.” Dr. Ioannidis felt that most people had no or mild symptoms and that this was a cause for “optimism” about reopening society. He called COVID a “common and mild infection” for most people. He said “the infection fatality rate for this new coronavirus was likely to be in the same ballpark as the seasonal influenza.” He said that “For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk (of death) is completely negligible…these deaths are extremely exceptional.” He would later say “For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%.”
This was exactly what we all wanted to hear! If the virus was already widespread, it meant that we were closer to the middle, or even the end of the pandemic than to its start. Indeed, Dr. Ioannidis felt there was a good chance the pandemic was close to over, saying on April 17, 2020:
Acknowledging for the fact that the epidemic is still evolving, and we cannot be sure whether we will hit even higher peaks in the future, although this doesn’t seem to be the case, at least for the European countries, and it seems to be that even in the US, in most states we’re very close to the peak, if not past the peak, the risk is something that should be manageable as opposed to the panic and horror stories that are circulating about.
He expressed a similar sentiment in August 2020 in an article ironically titled “Forecasting for COVID-19 has Failed” saying,
However, very few hospitals were eventually stressed and only for a couple of weeks. Most hospitals maintained largely empty wards, expecting tsunamis that never came… Tragically, many health systems faced major adverse consequences, not by COVID-19 cases overload, but for very different reasons.
Whether he was assuming that only 1% of the population would get COVID-19 or that it was already widespread, Dr. Ioannidis’s message was clear: though COVID-19 can devastate older, ill people, for almost everyone else, it’s as dangerous as driving to work and back, to borrow his analogy. Its overall impact would be as seismic as a February contest between the Orlando Magic and Sacramento Kings.
COVID-19: Bigger than an NBA game
Unfortunately, COVID-19 turned out to be bigger than a basketball game. When asked about his “10,000 deaths” statement four months later, Dr. Ioannidis said the following:
I never said that I knew that the death toll was going to be “10,000 deaths in the US”. How could I, in a piece where the message was “we don’t know”! The 10,000 deaths in the US projection was meant to be in the most optimistic range of the spectrum and in the same piece I also described the most pessimistic end of the spectrum, 40 million deaths. The point I wanted to emphasize was the huge uncertainty.
Dr. Ioannidis said his critics were guilty of “the 10,000 strawman”, and wrote,
Another gross distortion propagated in social media is that the op-ed had supposedly predicted that only 10,000 deaths will happen in the USA as a result of the pandemic. The key message of the op-ed was that we lack reliable data, that is, we do not know. The self-contradicting misinterpretation as “we don’t know, but actually we do know that 10,000 deaths will happen” is impossible. The op-ed discussed two extreme scenarios to highlight the tremendous uncertainty absent reliable data: an overtly optimistic scenario of only 10,000 deaths in the US and an overtly pessimistic scenario of 40,000,000 deaths.
How accurate is all this? I agree Dr. Ioannidis never said he “knew” the death toll was going to be 10,000. However, any fair reading of his article in STAT, as well as everything else he said at the time, shows that he felt the danger of COVID was greatly exaggerated.
For example, he wrote “This year’s coronavirus outbreak is clearly unprecedented in amount of attention received,” not in the threat it posed. He said that other coronaviruses receive scant attention and it is “only this year that every single case and every single death gets red alert broadcasting in the news.” In contrast, he felt measures to control the virus were much more likely to harm than help, saying they were like “an elephant being attacked by a house cat. Frustrated and trying to avoid the cat, the elephant accidentally jumps off a cliff and dies.” He warned of “financial crisis, unrest, civil strife, war, and a meltdown of the social fabric” as a result of lockdowns. He lamented that children might avoid the virus saying, “school closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”. Over 1,000 children have died since, a number that would have been much higher had the virus been allowed to rip through schools..
The notion that the virus might shutter schools and businesses didn’t occur to him. The refrigerated trucks outside my hospital weren’t very good for business, I imagine. They were there because the morgue couldn’t store all the dead bodies.
Despite this, Dr. Ioannidis would have us believe his STAT article presented two equally plausible scenarios, one overtly optimistic and one overtly pessimistic, and that he merely said we need to collect more data to determine which of these is more likely. It’s possible that Dr. Ioannidis meant for his “10,000 deaths” statement to be “the most optimistic range of the spectrum”, but that’s not what he wrote. It seems Dr. Ioannidis feels it’s a “strawman” or a “gross distortion” to quote the paragraph that opened this article and believe he was sincere when he wrote it.
“The most pessimistic scenario, which I do not espouse”
It’s worthwhile to further examine his claim that “In the STAT article, I discussed two hypothetical extremes for illustrative purposes, one with just 10,000 deaths in the USA and another with 50 million deaths worldwide.” In his STAT article, he said,
In the most pessimistic scenario, which I do not espouse, if the new coronavirus infects 60% of the global population and 1% of the infected people die, that will translate into more than 40 million deaths globally, matching the 1918 influenza pandemic.
Elsewhere he wrote “Some fear an analogy to the 1918 influenza pandemic that killed 20-40 million people.”
So yes, Dr. Ioannidis did discuss pessimistic scenarios, but only to say that he did not believe them, though other people did. If I said “I don’t think aliens are real, though some people do” I would not use my statement that “aliens are real” to claim I accepted the possibility of aliens existence if they landed tomorrow. Yet, this is exactly what Dr. Ioannidis is doing. He discussed the overtly pessimistic scenario only as a foil for his own belief that the threat from COVID was greatly exaggerated.
While he expanded on the most “optimistic scenario”, saying it would matter as much as an “NBA game between the two most indifferent teams,” he never elaborated on the potential consequences of the pessimistic scenario. Why would he? He thought these pessimistic scenarios were “completely off, just an astronomical error,” as he told a Fox News interviewer in April 2020.
“There were additional contributing reasons.”
Importantly, Dr. Ioannidis has acknowledged error, and it’s worth examining this too. In his article in the International Journal of Forecasting Dr. Ioannidis revisited another prediction he made, this one during an interview on April 9th 2020 where he said, “If I were to make an informed estimate based on the limited testing data we have, I would say that COVID-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA.” Dr. Ioannidis admitted this prediction was “so wrong” and he called himself a “fool” for having made it.
However, Dr. Ioannidis’s explanation as to why he was so wrong is telling. The problem, as he sees it, wasn’t that he underestimated COVID. Rather, he lists these “additional contributing reasons”:
When I made that tentative quote, I had not considered the impact of the new case definition of COVID-19 and of COVID-19 becoming a notifiable disease, despite being aware of the Italian experience where almost all counted “COVID-19 deaths” also had other concomitant causes of death/comorbidities. “COVID-19 death” now includes not only “deaths by COVID-19” and “deaths with COVID-19”, but even deaths “without COVID-19 documented”. Moreover, I had not taken seriously into account weekend reporting delays in death counts. Worse, COVID-19 had already started devastating nursing homes in the USA by then, but the nursing home data were mostly unavailable. I could not imagine that despite the Italian and Washington state experience, nursing homes were still unprotected. Had I known that nursing homes were even having COVID-19 patients massively transferred to them, I would have escalated my foolish quote several fold.
The notion that COVID deaths were significantly inflated is a dangerous falsehood, and in fact, deaths due to COVID are more likely to be undercounted. Later, Dr. Ioannidis would blame doctors for the high death toll, falsely claiming that “a lot of lives” were lost early in the pandemic due to premature intubations and because “financial incentives may promote coding for COVID-19.”
It’s certainly true that nursing homes were poorly managed early in the pandemic. Most notoriously, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo issued a disastrous order on March 25, 2020 that no “resident shall be denied re-admission or admission to the NH [nursing home] solely based on a confirmed or suspected diagnosis of COVID-19.” However, Dr. Ioannidis apparently expected that every nursing home and care facility would both recognize the danger posed by COVID and implement measures to hermetically seal off vulnerable residents in a few weeks’ time. Sadly, but predictably, many were unable to do that.
“Make a complete ass of yourself”
Very few predictions from the start of the pandemic aged well. Other smart people also underestimated COVID. Dr. Paul Offit, one of the world’s foremost authorities on vaccines and viruses, said in an interview on March 2nd 2020, “I can’t imagine, frankly, that it would cause even one-tenth of the damage that influenza causes every year in the United States.” Reflecting back on his erroneous prediction Dr. Offit joked, “If you’re going to be wrong, be wrong in front of millions of people. Make a complete ass of yourself.”
We need people who are willing to buck the scientific consensus and think outside-the-box. There is no shame in being wrong, only in refusing to admit error. Dr. Offit underestimated COVID and he admitted this. His initial flawed prediction is worth remembering only because it stands as a model of how scientists should behave when they are wrong in a public forum. He didn’t later claim his erroneous prediction was his most “optimistic” one. He didn’t blame nursing home directors. He didn’t claim COVID deaths were inflated. He didn’t claim doctors killed their patients and then filled out death certificates inappropriately.
Dr. Offit remains a widely-respected scientist. There’s a lesson there.

Dr. John Ioannidis: “The Biggest Mistakes I am Sure Are Mine.”
Part 3: Dr. John Ioannidis said his biggest mistake was the he “underestimated how much power politics and media and powers outside of science, could have on science.” Really? 
Jonathan Howard on April 19, 2024
Link

I wish I had been wrong on this point. Unfortunately, I am afraid I might have been correct.
In July 2022, Dr. John Ioannidis had the following exchange with Dr. Vinay Prasad, who sought to discredit and silence his critics by reframing mere disagreements as “vicious attacks”:
Dr. Prasad: Early in the pandemic you were viciously attacked for expressing a policy viewpoint and intuition that is different from others. In a number of ways your core thesis was: in an effort— well intentioned—to control the coronavirus, we may inflict great damage on ourselves. That lesson appears to be borne out in a number of historical and recent events. How do you judge you original intuition?
Dr. Ioannidis: I wish I had been wrong on this point. Unfortunately, I am afraid I might have been correct.
Knowing that Dr. Ioannidis feels his “original intuition” has been vindicated, let’s turn to his discussion of his “biggest mistake.”
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
Though Dr. Ioannidis never treated a COVID patient, this didn’t stop him from making a self-congratulatory movie titled Out to See. In it, he made the following statement:
The biggest mistakes I am sure are mine.
Though Dr. Ioannidis laughed with an aura of faux humility when he said this, indicating he didn’t believe it, I won’t argue with him about it. While there’s a lot of competition, it’s hard to think of another scientist who was so wrong, early, so consistently, and so publicly.
To pick one example amongst many, I suggest reading his paper Coronavirus Disease 2019: The Harms of Exaggerated Information and Non-Evidence-Based Measures which was published on March 19, 2020. Though COVID had claimed its first American victim just a month prior, Dr. Ioannidis was very confident about this very new virus.
He wrote about “exaggerated pandemic estimates”, “exaggerated case fatality rate”, and “exaggerated exponential community spread.” He said a claim that 20%-60% of adults would be infected, was “substantially exaggerated.” He said, “China data are more compatible with close contact rather than wide community spread being the main mode of transmission.” He said that, “Even if COVID-19 is not a 1918-recap in infection-related deaths, some coronavirus may match the 1918 pandemic in future seasons. Thus, we should learn and be better prepared.” He felt this coronavirus was a false alarm. He wrote:
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
In reality, the CDC estimates that 51,000 Americans died of flu during the 2019-2023 flu seasons. COVID, meanwhile, killed 95,000 Americans in January 2021 alone.
Most of the population has minimal risk, in the range of dying while you’re driving from home to work and back.
If I had written that paper, I’d hope I’d say “I underestimated COVID” if I were to discuss my biggest mistake. This would especially be the case if I spread such sanguine sentiments widely in the media, including many YouTube videos and the programs of Fox News firebrands Mark Levin and Laura Ingraham. Indeed, an article about Dr. Ioannidis from December 2020 said:
He had appeared at least 18 times on major cable news networks, repeatedly questioning the severity of the pandemic.
During some of these appearances, Dr. Ioannidis told viewers to distrust everything they’d heard so far. In his appearance with Mr. Levin on April 2020, for example, he said that “the evidence we had early in the pandemic was utterly unreliable.” He said predictions of mass death were “completely off, it is just an astronomical error.” Dr. Ioannidis then told viewers he had newer and better data. This data was what most of us wanted to hear: except for older, vulnerable people, COVID was a nothingburger. According to Dr. Ioannidis, “the vast majority” of people:
Don’t even realize that they have been infected, they are asymptomatic, they have no symptoms, or they have very mild symptoms that they would not even bother to do anything about.
He said the risk of dying from COVID was high for elderly people, especially those in nursing homes and those with serious underlying diseases, but “most of the population has minimal risk, in the range of dying while you’re driving from home to work and back.” Dr. Ioannidis told Mr. Levin that the infection fatality rate is “probably in the range of 1 in a 1,000.” Mr. Levin repeated the good news by saying, “You say one in a thousand. You’re saying well under 1%, is that one-tenth of 1% of the population that actually has the virus will pass away as a result of the virus, or in connection to the virus.” Dr. Ioannidis did not consider that people could survive COVID, but be injured by it.
Dr. Ioannidis also suggested that “99% of people” who did succumb to the virus were “people would have died anyhow.” He said:
Because for the data that we have more mature and detailed information, like the data from Italy that has already through the peak of their epidemic wave, we realize that 99% of people who die with this virus have other reasons as well to die. On average, they have close to three other reasons to die. On average they are 80-years-old with other comorbidities, as we say, and there’s quite some debate on whether these people would have died anyhow, if not immediately, you know, perhaps in a few days or in a few weeks or a few months. In our country we see a fairly similar picture.
You should really watch the whole video.
On CNN, he called COVID a “common and mild infection” for most people. In another interview from April 2020, he said:
I would say that covid-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA.
The USA would surpass 40,000 deaths 8-days later.
In an interview on YouTube he said “the infection fatality rate for this new coronavirus was likely to be in the same ballpark as seasonal influenza.” He said “For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk is completely negligible…these deaths are extremely exceptional.” He would later say “For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%.”
In contrast, Dr. Ioannidis was very concerned about about measures to contain the virus. He warned they could lead to “financial crisis, unrest, civil strife, war, and a meltdown of the social fabric” and said:
I think the devastation can be extreme and it can be far worse than anything coronavirus can do.
As a reminder, the bodies of COVID victims were filling up giant refrigerated trucks throughout New York City at the time. “It was almost like a war,” said one doctor who actually saw what the virus could do.
A million Americans have died since of COVID, including 45,000 people younger than 45. In fact, COVID was the number 1 or 2 killer of young adults age 35-44 for six months in a row, from August 2021 to January 2022. It was the number 2 killer of adults age 25-34 for 5 out of 6 months during that time, and a top 10 killer for people younger than this. COVID’s grim toll would have been much higher had we let it spread freely amongst hundreds of millions of unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans in 2020 as some doctors suggested.
Meanwhile, Dr. Ioannidis reflects back at these 2020 comments and concludes:
I wish I had been wrong on this point. Unfortunately, I am afraid I might have been correct.
I think our ideas have inflitrated [sic] the White House regardless
In addition to spreading this optimistic message widely in the media, Dr. Ioannidis sought to directly influence politicians as well. According to the reporting of Stephanie Lee:
In late March, as COVID-19 cases overran hospitals overseas, Ioannidis tried to organize a meeting at the White House where he and a small band of colleagues would caution the president against “shutting down the country for [a] very long time and jeopardizing so many lives in doing this,” according to a statement Ioannidis submitted on the group’s behalf. Their goal, the statement said, was “to both save more lives and avoid serious damage to the US economy using the most reliable data.”
Although the meeting did not happen, Ioannidis believed their message had reached the right people. Within a day of him sending it to the White House, Trump announced that he wanted the country reopened by Easter. “I think our ideas have inflitrated [sic] the White House regardless,” Ioannidis told his collaborators on March 28, in one of dozens of emails that BuzzFeed News obtained through public records requests.
Later, pro-infection, anti-vaccine doctor Scott Atlas revealed that he had “near daily discussions” with Dr. Ioannidis during his tenure as Trump’s COVID advisor, and that Dr. Ioannidis “kept reassuring me that my interpretations of the data was accurate and insisted I persevere”. Dr. Atlas persevered, unfortunately, though his interpretations of the data were not accurate.
I underestimated how much power politics and media and powers outside of science, could have on science.
Despite this inglorious track record, Dr. Ioannidis did not say “I underestimated COVID” when reflecting on his “biggest mistake”. Instead, he said his “biggest mistake” was that he underestimated something else. He said:
So I think that science is about mistakes, it’s about making mistakes, but trying to realize them and compare them with what might be better evidence and hopefully correct them as quickly as possible. And I think my biggest mistake, and I think that others can probably think about their mistakes, is that I underestimated how much power politics and media and powers outside of science, could have on science. I think that I had no clue and no preparation for this invasion of science.
I think that war on science, science surrendered immediately and the whole country of science was torn apart among people with very different ideologies and partisan beliefs with strong opinions, with power struggles, with the thirst for power and dominance and conflicts and that’s something that I have not witnessed before and I was not prepared for that and I think that I did my best, but I was close to ridiculously poorly prepared for that.
I think my preparation had been for debates with other scientists with a few scientists who might be knowledgeable in the field or are interested, and sometimes very interested and are fighting for the truth, which is of course evasive for all of us, but I was not prepared to have to fight with all of these powers that had nothing to do with science. That’s something that I feel a complete idiot about.
So let’s be clear what happened here. Dr. Ioannidis became a mini-celebrity by engaging with “politics and media and powers outside of science”, always telling them COVID’s risk was “exaggerated”. Later, after it was clear COVID’s risk was substantial, he said his “biggest mistake” was not that he underestimated the virus, but rather that he had “not prepared to have to fight with all of these powers that had nothing to do with science“. Even though Fox News firebrands Mark Levin and Laura Ingraham would spread blatant COVID misinformation to millions, Dr. Ioannidis bemoaned the influence of these “powers outside of science” as if were merely an innocent observer who played no role in legitimizing and amplifying them.
Of course, it’s not clear who Dr. Ioannidis was talking about when he said he’s had to “fight with all of these powers that had nothing to do with science.” Does he consider himself a crusader in the battle against pandemic misinformation? Were his critics all crass opportunists, motivated by “different ideologies and partisan beliefs with strong opinions, with power struggles, with the thirst for power and dominance and conflicts“? Was Dr. Ioannidis just a pure-of-heart scientist, “fighting for the truth”, totally uninvolved in “politics and media”? Is he a victim in the “war on science?” Should we feel sorry for him?
“I underestimated how much power politics and media and powers outside of science, could have on science.”
In one of those moments that breaks the irony meter, Dr. Ioannidis lodged his complaints about “powers outside of science” in a vanity documentary, one that featured no “debates with other scientists,” but rather him talking and nobody else. In fact, while he is happy to take softball questions lobbed by misinformation-spreading sycophants like Dr. Prasad, I can’t think of a single time that Dr. Ioannidis has taken questions from someone brave enough to remind him of what he actually said in 2020.
COVID-19 has killed thousands of young Americans. This is not just a tragedy for the elderly.
COVID will not be the last pandemic, and we all learned the hard way the incredible damage that politics and media and powers outside of science can cause. As someone who has written extensively about the normalization of the anti-vaccine movement in medicine, I do not disagree with Dr. Ioannidis when he said:
I think that war on science, science surrendered immediately.
While I rightly anticipated a deluge of COVID misinformation, I too greatly underestimated the “war on science.” Never in my wildest dreams did I imagine that prestigious doctors from prestigious medical schools, sheltered from the consequences of their words, would deluge the media and politicians with pro-virus, anti-vaccine misinformation in the middle of a deadly pandemic. That was my biggest mistake and something that I feel a complete idiot about.
Let’s hope future scientists are better prepared than we were for “this invasion of science”. While Dr. Ioannidis and I may feel like complete idiots for underestimating these powers, don’t shed a tear for us. Sure, we have been subject to “vicious attacks”, but we are alive and healthy. We are blessed and fortunate. Save your sympathy for those whose biggest mistake was believing confident scientists on TV who assured them their risk was “completely negligible.”

“Panel stacking”: John Ioannidis versus a Delphi consensus statement on COVID-19
My former science idol John Ioannidis has published a paper citing a Delphi consensus statement on COVID-19 as evidence that the scientific community is “biased” against his anti-“lockdown” pro-virus views. His descent continues apace.
David Gorski on June 24, 2024
Tweet

As I was deciding what to write this week, I couldn’t help but come across references on social media to a recent paper by John Ioannidis and over 60 other coauthors that basically bemoans how “they” apparently “stacked the deck” when doing a Delphi consensus statement regarding scientifically recommended approaches to the COVID-19 pandemic:
Panel stacking is a threat to consensus statement validityOur large multinational collaboration led by @KasperKepp and John Ioannidis (Univ. Stanford) is out! Happy to contribute to this important work. J. Clin. Epidemiol. https://t.co/VRHrN5C2eH #coronavirus #covid #covid_19
— Manuel Schabus (@ManuelSchabus) June 22, 2024
I was intrigued and had to take a look. First, however, let’s look at a bit of background on how I went from an admirer of John Ioannidis to one of his harshest critics. His accusation of “stacking” consensus panels with horrible (to him) public health scientists who advocate for reducing COVID-19 transmission in addition to using vaccination to minimize disease and death is definitely of a piece with what he’s published and advocated since the pandemic that ended up in my profound disillusionment with him.
From admiration to disillusionment: John Ioannidis
Longtime readers will know that, once upon a time in a different, more innocent era many years ago, I considered science meta-researcher and critic John Ioannidis to be one of my medical and scientific idols. Consistent with that, I wrote (mostly) glowingly—albeit not without a few quibbles—about some of his most famous and influential papers, my posts having titles like:
    • The cranks pile on John Ioannidis’ work on the reliability of science
    • How popularity of a scientific topic might lead to more unreliable research
    • The life cycle of translational research and how long it takes to go from idea in cell culture or a test tube to an actual treatment
    • How often seemingly important findings in science don’t hold up in subsequent studies
    • How everything we eat does and doesn’t cause cancer
Since the pandemic, however, my opinion—and that of a lot of Ioannidis’ former admirers—turned sour. Why? Early in the pandemic Ioannidis was quick to embrace “natural herd immunity” approaches to COVID-19 that later became the basis of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), which called for a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic to achieve “natural herd immunity” in six months by letting the young and health just get COVID and using “focused protection” to keep those at high risk of death and complications from COVID safe. It’s a tactic that never would have worked—and didn’t work—and was profoundly eugenicist at its heart. Although he was not an author—indeed, in fairness he refused to sign it, although not based on disagreeing with the GBD’s premise but because of his opposition to “signing petitions” as a means of settling “questions of scientific fact”—his call early in the pandemic for what sure sounded like a variation on the idea of “focused protection” was all over the GBD. He was also a co-author, along with GBD co-author Jay Bhattacharya of the infamous Santa Clara seroprevalence study that misleadingly claimed that over 80 times more people had been exposed to COVID-19 than previously thought (and therefore the infection fatality rate, or IFR, was way lower than was being claimed, meaning COVID was not nearly as dangerous as claimed and therefore all those public health interventions were unnecessary). Before that, he had published what is now in hindsight a ludicrous estimate in STAT that COVID-19 would likely kill 10,000 Americans. (He was off only by a factor of more than 100.) Then there was the time that Ioannidis made the vile evidence-free accusation that ICU doctors were inadvertently killing COVID patients by intubating them willy-nilly when they really didn’t need mechanical ventilation. And don’t even get me started on Ioannidis’ infamous “Kardashian index” paper, in which he smeared scientific critics and opponents of the GBD as “science Kardashians” using risibly bad methodology based on what was originally published as a satirical index to comment on scientists with more social media influence than influence in the scientific literature.
The first indication of the direction that Ioannidis could go—at least the first indication to me—was what I perceived as his relatively poorly supported argument that the NIH is so conservative that only the very “safest” projects are funded and that the “brave maverick scientists” who see “bolts out of the blue” to make great leaps in science tend not to be NIH funded. Such a view tends to be common among “brave maverick” doctors and scientists who view the slow accretion of evidence that makes up most scientific discovery as too timid and “safe.” Another indication was when he bemoaned the “hijacking” of evidence-based medicine (EBM) by industry. Basically, he took a common criticism of EBM and then added methodolatry (the worship of the randomized controlled trial as the only valid means of clinical investigation) to exaggerate the problem. At the time, I didn’t think much of these papers in terms of anything truly worrisome about Ioannidis’ takes, as they were mostly within the mainstream, just prone to a bit of EBM methodolatry and an overestimation of the general importance of “bold” brave maverick ideas in science.
If those were the only areas where I disagreed with John Ioannidis, I’d probably still be an admirer. Unfortunately, by April 2020, Ioannidis was already relishing his status as a brave maverick with respect to COVID-19 public health interventions. Things haven’t gotten any better, as he still hasn’t apologized or admitted how wrong he was regarding the “science Kardashian” paper. rident attacking “lockdowns,” social distancing, and even vaccines as tools to control COVID-19.
“Natural herd immunity” advocates versus the Delphi consensus statement
Let’s take a look at his latest output. I can’t help but preface a discussion of the “consensus panel stacking” paper with a sarcastic Twitter comment:
Many of the names on this author list have been objectively incorrect going back to early 2020. They cannot be part of a scientific “consensus,” because their stated views were immediately debunked by mountains of dead and disabled bodies. Try to do better next time.
— Pandemic 𓅃 Index (@pan_accindex) June 23, 2024
Also:
A group of authors consistently wrong on the pandemic advocate against consensus guidelines "stacked" with experts who have been consistently correct.
— Mike Hoerger, PhD MSCR MBA (@michael_hoerger) June 23, 2024
And:
The list of names is long. The respectability is short.https://t.co/ABHXgM3Qb7 pic.twitter.com/Xvf4BiuEKf
— Lazarus Long (@LazarusLong13) June 22, 2024
I didn’t know who Irene Petersen is, but it didn’t take me long to find out that she was an advocate of “speeding up the pandemic” to reach “natural herd immunity. Yes, it’s hard not to note a fair amount of projection in this paper. The authors all appear to be people who have been quite strident advocating for GBD-like approaches to the pandemic. Also, did they really need 66 authors on this thing? That rather strikes me as “stacking the deck” in much the same way that they accuse Delphi of doing.
Authors aside, let’s take a look at the paper itself. Ioannidis’ paper basically boils down to dissatisfaction with a Delphi consensus statement published in Nature in 2022 that made a large number of recommendations for the optimal approach to the pandemic. Now, don’t get me wrong. I’ve been critical of Delphi consensus statements myself. Indeed, I once wrote a rather scathing take on just such a consensus statement written to support the quackery that is “naturopathic oncology” that really did stack the panel given that its experts were all naturopathic oncologists, leading me to refer to the whole effort as “applying the Delphi Method to nonsense.” Let’s just say that that is not what happened with the Delphi consensus statement being attacked by John Ioannidis and cronies, although they seemed to dislike the results of the COVID-19 Delphi consensus statement almost as much as I detested the results of the naturopathic oncology Delphi consensus statement.
As is often the case before such papers go off the rails, the introduction starts with fairly reasonable statements as background, things that no one can really find too objectionable:
Consensus statements can be very influential in medicine and public health. Some of these statements use systematic evidence synthesis but others fail on this front. Many consensus statements use panels of experts to deduce perceived consensus through Delphi processes. We argue that stacking of panel members towards one particular position or narrative is a major threat, especially in absence of systematic evidence review. Stacking may involve financial conflicts of interest, but non-financial conflicts of strong advocacy can also cause major bias.
In fairness, I’ve long argued that advocacy conflicts of interest (COIs) are just as important—possibly even more so—compared to financial COIs, because they can definitely produce bias. So I looked at the COI statements of all the authors, almost none of whom provided a statement of their involvement with advocacy groups. For example, Ioannidis’ statement only says:
John P.A. Ioannidis has published in the scientific literature both before (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/eci.13162) and during the pandemic (https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4048) articles that are skeptical about the value of vote counting and signature collections for deciding scientific issues.
Notice the very tight definition of an advocacy COI here, in which the only thing that Ioannidis deems relevant is his having argued against the “value of vote counting and signature collections for deciding scientific issues,” not all the times that he’s argued for GBD-like “natural herd immunity” approaches to the pandemic and his numerous media appearances making such arguments. Similarly, some of the authors of this paper are very biased against public health approaches used to try to mitigate the pandemic; for example, Francois Balloux has over the last four years stated that PPE was prolonging the pandemic, SARS-CoV-2 was “no risk” to children, long COVID disability “doesn’t matter,” and the virus came from a lab. A deep dive on the other authors (Petersen, again!) would likely find similar statements very much outside the scientific consensus, but with 66 authors I think I’ll move on now. I’m only surprised that Ioannidis didn’t recruit Vinay Prasad for this paper.
How many times was John Ioannidis on Fox News and other media outlets in 2020?
After all, Ioannidis is a man who appeared in the media seemingly innumerable times in 2020 to promote ideas including that COVID-19 is not as dangerous as portrayed and that a GBD-like “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, with protection of those most at risk for death and complications from the coronavirus, was the optimal path out of the pandemic. Indeed, in retrospect, I don’t think it’s wrong to say that Ioannidis was the intellectual father of the GBD, given that he was criticizing “lockdowns” and voicing similar ideas to the GBD as early as March 2020 and continued to do so throughout the first year of the pandemic. (Yeah, that was the same essay when he estimated that COVID-19 might kill as many as 10,000 in the US.) It’s not just that, though. Unlike the vast majority of scientists the “silenced” John Ioannidis also had extensive contact with high ranking Trump administration officials, including his coronavirus czar Scott Atlas, during that horrific first spring and summer of the pandemic to advocate against lockdowns and for a very GBD-like approach:
John Ioannidis & his colleague Jay Bhattacharya, author of the Great Barrington Declaration, had a near daily call with Trump’s coronavirus czarYet they say they were “silenced”Perhaps if they had been allowed 2 calls per day with Team Trump, they would not be complaining! 😉 https://t.co/Q5btNWPKI2
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) March 7, 2022
It’s not just Ioannidis, though. Another author, Michael Levitt, advised PANDATA, an organization dedicated to promoting an agenda similar to the GBD, although in fairness he did say in his disclosure that he had signed the GBD. And don’t get me started on Francois Balloux or Stefan Baral, neither of whom reacted well to being accurately quoted in Jonathan Howard’s book We Want Them Infected. Political advocacy, almost none of it reported in this paper as a COI, is what a lot of the authors of this paper have been about. Apparently to them, it’s transparency in terms of disclosure of potential ideological and advocacy COIs for thee, but not for me. If that weren’t the case, Ioannidis would have mentioned his longstanding advocacy for approaches that conflict with “lockdowns,” especially his advocacy of “natural herd immunity” approaches. Ditto most of the other authors and their advocacy and associations with anti-“lockdown” organizations; e.g., Michael Levitt. That’s author stacking, if not consensus stacking.
But wait, a critic (of me) might say, aren’t you just lobbing an ad hominem attack against the authors of the paper? Sort of, but I do it with what I view as a purpose and strong justification. The entire premise of the paper is that the Delphi consensus statement panel was “stacked” with advocates of scientific positions that Ioannidis and cronies don’t like. Fair’s fair in pointing out that he’s basically done the same thing in the paper voicing his criticism, stacking his author list with people who agree with him and have long expressed criticism and opposition to conventional public health approaches to the pandemic. Indeed, in that context, his criticism that 35% of the panel members for the Delphi consensus statement might have been “zero COVID” advocates is rather ironic, given the—shall we say?—lack of diversity with regard to scientific opinions regarding COVID-19 in Ioannidis’ author list. I’m half tempted to cite Ioannidis’ suggestion about consensus statements that even “when they are right, the recommendations are more likely to be incomplete and partial.” I suggest that Ioannidis’ criticism of the Delphi recommendations would be more credible if he had included more diversity of opinion among his authors. (What’s good for the goose…)
As far as the actual paper, one main recommendation of the Delphi panel that seemed to provoke this attack disguised as an objective analysis was, as Pandemic Accountability Index sarcastically noted:
You buried the lede. They’re pissy about the Delphi paper making the “vaccines-plus” argument instead of a mass infection, “let them die” approach that these viral sycophants got. pic.twitter.com/MoJjSpTKwJ
— Pandemic 𓅃 Index (@pan_accindex) June 23, 2024
It’s basically the same motivation that led Ioannidis to attack as “science Kardashians” the signatories of the John Snow Memorandum, which criticized the GBD and advocated for more conventional approaches to the pandemic while pointing out, based on known science, why a “natural herd immunity” approach wouldn’t work and would lead to millions of potentially preventable deaths.
Of course, the conclusions of any paper like this will be very much influenced by the assumptions behind it and the methodology, which led me to look very much askance at this statement:
We present descriptive statistics and avoid statistical testing of hypotheses given the exploratory nature of the evaluation.
Well, then, I guess I’ll treat the findings with all the seriousness that they deserve, given the lack of statistical testing. One can’t help but note how these EBM fundamentalists insist on ever increasingly more rigorous randomized clinical trials to address questions for which they don’t like the current answer but are happy to use “descriptive statistics” or even an intentionally satirical publication index like the Kardashian Index as though it had any real validity when they have an ideological ax to grind and want to attack their scientific opponents. This seems to be a recurring theme among people like Ioannidis: RCTs for thee but not for me, if lesser methodology lets me prove what I want to prove.
The other assumption that one has to consider is: What constitutes a “zero COVID” approach or advocacy group? Let’s take a look:
We found that panel selection favoured the inclusion of advocates of SARS-CoV-2 elimination (“Zero-COVID”) perspectives. Zero-COVID was a minority position in 2021 even in the mild version of being feasible in “some” regions (e.g., New Zealand),16 but the groups identified here advocated in Europe and North America, where the policy was less feasible. Zero-COVID was widely abandoned by 202217 and eventually broadly recognised as unattainable.18
At least 14 of 40 (35%) core members of the Nature consensus and at least another 59 panelists are explicitly named in influential and highly visible Zero-COVID advocacy/activism efforts in North America and Europe (Box 1: References R1-R11, Figure 1, Supplementary Table 1). Thus, at least 20% of named panelists (73/367; 19 panelists did not wish their names revealed) engaged in such strong advocacy/activism.
The 367 named panelists include 9/25 (36%) signatories of a highly publicised Zero-COVID open letter,[R1] 3/8 (38%) signatories of a Lancet letter supporting elimination,[R2] 36/132 signatories (26%) of the World Health Network (WHN),[R3] 41/108 (38%) signatories of the Vaccines Plus advocacy letter,[R4] 7/19 (37%) full members of Independent Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies 451 (indieSAGE),[R5] 14/47 (30%) WHN members or experts-advisors,[R6] 5/79 (6%) OzSAGE members,[R7] 3/14 (21%) NOCOVID members,[R8] 5/8 (63%) End Coronavirus advisors[R9], 9/13 (69%) authors of another elimination viewpoint[R10] and 3/17 (18%) ZeroCOVID-US members[R11]. Large overlap emerged in membership across these efforts, typical of advocacy activities.
Ioannidis even made a figure:
I note that, for most of the statements, the number of panel members is quite small. Two stand out, with lots of Delphi panelists having signed on, as indicated by a field of red. So I tried to look some of these references up. Unfortunately, they were listed as references in the Supplementary Methods and Data section, and I could not find a link to this section anywhere. (WTF, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology?) Or maybe it’s my Wayne State access. Whatever the reason, no link to the Supplementary section(s) shows up. So I searched The Lancet for anything containing World Health Network and COVID, which yielded two references, one on mass testing (which didn’t really advocate anything resembling zero COVID) and this reference, The World Health Network: a global citizens’ initiative. It doesn’t seem so unreasonable to me in the context of 2021, even if it ultimately turned out, thanks to efforts of activists and right wing think tanks promoting GBD-like approaches, zero COVID did become impossible by 2022:
Elimination means bringing cases down to sufficiently low numbers so that no community transmission occurs for extended periods of time. Outbreaks might occur but will be rapidly detected and controlled. Despite the manifest success of this approach, many governments rejected it outright, and after repeated lockdowns and substantial losses to life and economy, these governments now speak of learning to live with the virus. Many governments’ responses have been shaped by false dichotomies, pitting public health against the economy and collective wellbeing against individual liberty.1,2,3 Effective responses have been hampered by vested interests,4 rampant and organised misinformation, short-term thinking, and resistance to important facts, including airborne transmission, the role of children and schools in transmission, and the value of facemasks and ventilation. Exceptionalism (ie, a belief that the consequence of similar policies will somehow be different in a given context), the refusal to learn from experiences of other countries, and the failure to adopt the precautionary principle (ie, taking action in the face of uncertainty to prevent harm, such as the use of masks to prevent the spread of an airborne pathogen) led to the same avoidable errors being repeated in different countries. Even the arrival of effective vaccines, which are traditionally the basis of elimination, has not changed the thinking of many governments that ongoing community transmission with inevitable consequences of death and disability for many people should be accepted. Additionally, the reliance on vaccination alone as the main response strategy to the pandemic without controlling transmission risks the emergence of dangerous escape variants.5
To. put it bluntly, Ioannidis and his coauthors don’t like the idea that governments should do something to try to control the spread of COVID-19 and not try to rely on vaccination alone to control the pandemic. In particular they really, really, really hate the rejection of the idea that we should just let the virus spread, which was, after all, the entire idea behind the GBD. Unsurprisingly, they also don’t like the accurate criticism of the way activists promoting a GBD-like agenda had promoted false dichotomies “pitting public health against the economy” and “public well being against individual liberty.” That’s the very core of GBD-like arguments, to prioritize “freedom” and the economy over public health, even to the point of portraying something as innocuous as mask mandates in indoor public spaces as some sort of existential threat to freedom and democracy.
As for the “vaccines-plus” letter, which I found in The BMJ published in January 2022, I would argue that a lot of what was in the letter sounds quite prescient now, for example:
Some countries view infection as a net harm and pursue strategies ranging from suppression to elimination.2 They seek to sustain low infection rates through a combination of vaccination, public health measures, and financial support measures (vaccines-plus). Other countries implemented mitigation strategies that aim to prevent health systems from being overwhelmed by building population immunity through a combination of infection and vaccination. These countries rely on a vaccines-only approach and seem willing to tolerate high levels of infection provided their healthcare systems can cope.
They even note:
While vaccination greatly reduces risks of serious illness and death, long covid remains a concern.12, 13 Disruption to education as a result of staff and student sickness, and/or repeated lockdowns due to failure to control the virus, are likely to have a lasting impact on the wellbeing and prospects of the next generation.14
That sure sounds as though they wanted to keep schools open as much as possible, in marked contrast to GBD attacks on public health claiming that they wanted to keep schools closed indefinitely, if not foreverSo they weren’t cheerleaders for “lockdowns.” Moreover, their suggestions were anything but radical, contrary to how Ioannidis portrays them. They included such “radical zero COVID” measures as:
     1.  Unequivocally declare SARS-CoV-2 an airborne pathogen and stress the implications for preventing transmission.
     2.  Promote the use of high-quality face masks for indoor gatherings and other high-transmission settings.
     3.  Advise on effective ventilation and filtration of air.
     4.  Set criteria for imposing or relaxing measures to reduce covid-19 spread based on levels of transmission in the community.
     5.  Support urgent measures to achieve global vaccine equity, including vaccine sharing, suspension of vaccine patents, removal of barriers to technology transfer, and establish regional production centres to create a plentiful local supply of high-quality vaccines everywhere.
Those horrible “zero COVID” fanatics! How dare they? How dare they even suggest that they were worthy to be part of a Delphi consensus panel on COVID-19!
Ioannidis also seems to have a bug up his butt about members of IndieSAGE; so I looked up its website. They appear to be a bunch of “radicals” too (at least to Ioannidis. For example, here is their 7-point plan for COVID-19 mitigation published in The BMJ in 2022:
     1.  Clear and consistent messaging concerning covid risk and risk mitigation, reinforced by public statements by those in positions of authority;
     2.  Increased efforts to promote vaccine uptake, among all age groups, and with particular emphasis on groups among whom uptake has been low, in particular ethnic minority communities. This should be coupled with a clear long term plan to address waning immunity and immune escape by new variants;
     3.  Installing and/or upgrading ventilation/air filtration in all public buildings, with schools an urgent priority over the summer holidays;
     4.  Provision of free lateral flow tests to enable everyone to follow existing public health guidelines;
     5.  Financial and other support for all workers to self-isolate if infected;
     6.  Systematic promotion of the use of FFP2/FFP3 masks in indoor public spaces and public transport when infection rates are high;
     7.  Increased support for the equitable global provision of vaccines and anti-virals.
The horror…the horror…
Funny, but these two plans look very similar to the “vaccines-plus” strategy and not at all radical. (I note that pro-GBD groups like the Brownstone Institute and American Institute for Economic research really hate the idea of financial support to workers so that they can take time off to self-isolate if the become infected.) I’m getting the feeling that what Ioannidis and his fellow travelers object to are anything that smack of trying to slow the spread of the virus through traditional public health interventions. Seriously, nowhere in these two statements do I see anything that doesn’t follow longstanding known public health practices for an infectious viral disease that is transmitted through the air.
The real problem
Again, there’s really almost nothing objectionable from a public health or medical science standpoint in the Delphi consensus statement that Ioannidis attacks or in the letters to which he tries to yoke Delphi panel members to as evidence of such extreme bias that they hopelessly tainted None of this stops Ioannidis from stating:
The problem with stacked consensus statements and recommendations is not only the increased risk of being wrong. Even when they are right, the recommendations are more likely to be incomplete and partial, as they may prioritise narratives that preoccupy the advocates. This diminishes or even eliminates other important perspectives. Choices of language, phrasing, statements, and recommendations become lopsided. Illustratively, in the COVID-19 consensus example dissected above, the lengthy 41 statements and 57 recommendations12 never mention the words “randomised”, “lockdown”, “closures”, “isolation”, “loneliness”, “learning loss”, “poverty”, “depression”, “hunger”, “cost-benefit”, “tradeoff”, “censorship” or “mandate”. They mention the word “harm” once, in statement STMT3.1, which does not discuss harms to individuals, groups, or communities themselves, but highlights “risk of harm to others” to endorse government mandatory policies.12 “Education” or “schools” are never mentioned and “educational” and “schooling policies” are only mentioned in recommendation REC4.6: “Prevention of SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the workplace, educational institutions and centers of commerce should remain a high priority”… “remote work/schooling policies”.12 “Mental” (health) is mentioned only for children and healthcare workers. “Evidence-based” is mentioned only twice: STMT2.1 admits lack of evidence-based standards and STMT6.8 is dismissive of the evidence-based medicine paradigm.12
Pot. Kettle. Black. Ioannidis just doesn’t like the consensus statement, which you can read for yourself and see if you think it is as bad as he portrays. Let’s look, for instance, at what STMT6.8 actually says:
The incorporation of research paradigms from diverse disciplines has greater potential to end COVID-19 as a public health threat than reliance on a single research paradigm (for example, evidence-based medicine).
You know what? Whatever else the consensus statement says, STMT6.8 is absolutely spot-on correct! Ioannidis is just engaging in methodolatry again, in which randomized controlled clinical trials are worshiped as the only valid method of clinical investigation and any question for which RCTs might not be the best tool (or might even be unethical) is forever dismissed as “low quality” evidence. This statement only recognizes that, for public health, RCTs are often either not feasible, not ethical, or just plain not enough.
Let’s see what STMT3.1 says:
When the risk of harm to others is sufficiently severe, governments may determine that the right of all individuals to good health overrides the autonomy of any one individual to choose not to be vaccinated.
One can certainly argue over mandatory vaccination policies, but it’s rather funny to me how Ioannidis doesn’t mention the statement that immediately follows:
Individual medical autonomy acknowledges that individuals who have decision-making capacity have the right to make decisions regarding vaccination, even when their decisions contradict their healthcare providers’ recommendations.
This is rather difficult to argue with, even for someone like Ioannidis. What about REC4.6? It says:
Prevention of SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the workplace, educational institutions and centres of commerce should remain a high priority, reflected in public health guidance and supported through multiple social measures and structural interventions (for example, remote work/schooling policies, ventilation, air filtration, facemask wearing).
I’m going to have to say this again:
Seriously, what was wrong about arguing that prevention of SARS-CoV-2 transmission in public places should remain a high priority and should be supported? Nothing; that is, unless you, as Jonathan put it in his book, want them infected.
I can’t help but note this REC4.2, which is so radical that even Ioannidis can’t disagree:
Measures that are no longer scientifically valid for COVID-19 prevention should be immediately removed from COVID-19 guidance and policy.
Those zealots! How dare they suggest…wait. Isn’t this what a consensus panel should be recommending, that outmoded science be discarded in favor of new rigorous findings?
In the end, what Kepp, Ioannidis, and the 64 other authors object to is that their view was not and is still not mainstream in public health sciences, hence the attempt to portray the Delphi consensus statement as being so hopelessly biased with zero COVID advocates as not to be trusted. Indeed, 20-35% “zero COVID” advocates (if you can even call them that based on what I described above) doesn’t seem too out of line for a document that was developed in 2022. Although they don’t say it explicitly (even though it is completely obvious that this is what they are saying), what Kepp, Ioannidis, et al object to is that GBD advocates didn’t have equal representation with public health officials who advocated for an approach involving trying to contain—or even eliminate—the virus. What they basically want is affirmative action for scientists continuing to advocate an approach that was scientifically discredited almost as soon as the GBD was proposed. In that, they remind me of creationists who want a “seat at the table” at evolutionary biology or antivaxxers who object that they are not included in consensus panels formulating recommendations for the vaccine schedule.
Indeed, I would argue that Ioannidis is starting to become downright conspiratorial in this approach, in essence using some very dubious arguments to suggest that the consensus panels that produced pandemic recommendations that didn’t jibe with GBD-like lack of interventions must have been “stacked” in order to assure predetermined recommendations that “They” wanted. In fairness, one has to concede a grain of truth, but, as “brave mavericks” often do, Kepp, Ioannidis, et al are taking that grain of truth and going off the rails with it to portray their view as unjustly ignored. Indeed, it is very true that it is possible to stack a consensus panel and that “stacked” panels are a bad thing. The problem comes when, having lost the scientific debate fair and square, you decide to portray a panel that ended up supporting current scientific consensus as hopelessly in the pocket of either big pharma or ideology, even as you stack your author list with people who are far less intellectually diverse with respect to the relevant scientific questions than the panel that you’re criticizing as “stacked.” It’s definitely a step down the road towards conspiracy mongering, if not actually outright conspiracy mongering.
Moreover, you’ll excuse me if I suspect that there is another purpose to this paper, given what I found on social media from its first author:
When many global evidence experts approached @Nature with concerns over evidence use & undeclared advocate stacking, the comment was rejected without peer-review, thus not alerting the scientific community on a topic of major importance -but JCE now publishing. @Magda_Skipper
— Kasper Planeta Kepp (@KasperKepp) June 18, 2024
This sounds to me as though some or all of the authors likely “complained” to the editors of Nature about “undisclosed COIs”—note how Kepp tagged Nature‘s editor-in-chief in his post, a not at all subtle move—about the supposed perceived “undisclosed COIs” of the members of the Delphi consensus panel and ended up deciding to put their complaints into a paper and use it to pressure Nature editors.
Nice journal, ya got there, Dr. Skipper…
This led me to think: You know what? What’s good for the goose is good for the gander! Fair’s fair. Let’s do the same thing to Kepp, Ioannidis, et al and write to the editors of the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, Andrea C. Tricco, PhD, MSc and David I. Tovey, FRCGP (contact information page here), and request that they require some…changes…to Ioannidis’ manuscript before it is finalized, specifically, a listing of every advocacy group related to COVID-19 that every author has ever been associated with and any political advocacy related to COVID-19 in which they’ve engaged. As I said, if that’s what they seem to want from Nature, fair’s fair. Surely neither Kepp, Ioannidis, Levitt, nor any of the other authors of this op-ed disguised as a study could object to this, given that it’s what they’ve demanded in their paper of the panel members who put together the Delphi consensus statement!
Finally, I must concede that there are a number of valid criticisms to be made of the Delphi method to develop consensus statements, but Ioannidis doesn’t make any of them, at least not of the actual methodology other than vague complaints about transparency of methodology. Rather, he focuses mainly on the who, not the how, with an ad hominem attack seeking to portray the members of this Delphi consensus panel as hopelessly biased, based on their advocacy of decidedly nonradical positions, which he goes to desperate lengths to falsely portray as wildly outside the mainstream even as he tries to insinuate that GBD-like positions belong in the mainstream. (They don’t, at least not anymore—that is, if they ever did.) The paper might not be as risibly awful as Ioannidis’ “science Kardashians” paper, but it’s plenty bad nonetheless and likely not the end of what I’m going to have to write about in the future, either here or elsewhere. The fall of Ioannidis continues apace, and it is very depressing to watch. It is, however, educational, in that it reinforces the lesson that no one is immune to descending into crankery.

Dr. John Ioannidis: Yet Another Doctor Who Treats Theoretical Death From The Vaccine With More Gravity Than Actual Death From COVID
Actual death is worse than theoretical death. This didn’t used to be controversial in medicine.
Jonathan Howard on July 21, 2024
Link

Maybe that will happen and then that would be the first event that someone would just drop dead on the floor
At the start of the pandemic Dr. John Ioannidis predicted COVID would kill 40,000 Americans this “season”. As the death toll blasted past this number, Dr. Ioannidis gave an interview titled The Bearer of Good Coronavirus News, in which he bemoaned the “panic-driven, horror-driven, death-reality-show type of situation” with regards to the virus. He felt very differently about measures to contain it. He warned mitigation measures could lead to “financial crisis, unrest, civil strife, war, and a meltdown of the social fabric“. As COVID was overflowing morgues and hospitals, Dr. Ioannidis worried about theoretical harms from measures to contain it.
A pattern was established.
In 2022, Dr. Ioannidis starred in a documentary titled Out to See, where he shared his thoughts on the pandemic. At one point, Dr. Ioannidis mused on vaccine side effects and how they are more common than we think. “Side effects are always under reported,” he said. Neglecting surveillance systems such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink and data from outside the US, he falsely said, “it’s up to people and physicians and practitioners to report the events.” He also said this:
If you have, for example, myocarditis, but you don’t have some symptoms, even though you may have a problem with your heart muscle, then you don’t really report it because you never felt it. And could that person die at some point? Yes. One in, who knows, a million or 100,000. Maybe that will happen and then that would be the first event that someone would just drop dead on the floor. So the rest will not be captured.
The full video is here.
YIKES! That’s sounds really scary. Echoing themes from the anti-vaccine propaganda documentary Died Suddenly, Dr. Ioannidis suggests the vaccine might cause people, even those who felt totally fine after getting it, “to just drop dead on the floor” and that such events would not be “captured”. The producer of Died Suddenly voiced similar sentiments. He said:
We absolutely know 100% what is going on. They want to cover it up. The doctors are dying, and they’re dying from these stupid shots.
Fortunately, the prognosis of vaccine myocarditis is almost always favorable- patients with vaccine‐related myocarditis had prompt resolution of symptoms and improvement of cardiac function– and this was known when Dr. Ioannidis made his movie. It’s possible there may be long term consequences, but presently, this is all theoretical. There is no evidence people are dropping dead from it, as the article from 2024 COVID Vax Not Linked to Sudden Deaths in Young Adults explained.
Of course, this won’t stop anti-vaccine advocates from blaming the vaccine for sudden cardiac deaths moving forward. That seed has been planted already and several “pro-vaccine” doctors acted as gardeners by openly treating theoretical harms from the vaccine as more concerning than actual death from COVID.
Don’t fear the thing that may kill you, respect the thing that certainly won’t
For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying conditions, the risk of completely negligible.
Indeed, Dr. Ioannidis wasn’t always so concerned about rare events, including literal death. In an interview from April 17th, 2020, he said this about the virus:
The risk for people who are less than 65 and have no underlying conditions is extremely, extremely tiny. These people account for less than 1%….for someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk is completely negligible…It seems that these deaths are extremely exceptional, very unlikely.
Elsewhere, Dr. Ioannidis claimed that “For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%”.
Full video is here
Dr. Ioannidis did not consider adverse COVID outcomes other than death, nor did he worry that COVID-myocarditis, which is more common and severe than vaccine-myocarditis, might one day cause people to “just drop dead on the floor.” In fact, at the start of the pandemic, Dr. Ioannidis felt there might be a cost to preventing COVID in young people, and it had nothing to do with education. He said:
School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease.
To my knowledge, this was the first time anyone suggested mass infection as a means of ushering in herd immunity. This would later become policy in many places.
Just because they are young doesn’t mean they aren’t vulnerable
Even by this early point in the pandemic, however, it was known that COVID posed some risk to healthy young people. Most famously, the heroic doctor who tried to warn the world of COVID, Li Wenliang, died from it age 34. News reports soon began to report more tragedies. The article Hundreds of Young Americans Have Now Been Killed by the Coronavirus, Data Shows was published on April 8, 2020, the week before Dr. Ioannidis gave his interview. It began by saying:
Two weeks after her husband died alone in an intensive care unit in Fort Myers, Fla., Nicole Buchanan is quarantined at the home they shared with their 12-year-old daughter, wrestling not only with grief but also with why and how the coronavirus could steal someone so young and healthy.
“My husband didn’t have diabetes, he didn’t have asthma, he didn’t have high cholesterol. He didn’t have anything,” Buchanan said. “There’s just so much I’ll never know, that I’ll never get the answers to.”
Conrad Buchanan, who died at 39 on March 26 after battling the infection for nearly two weeks, was creative and goofy.
The article extensively quoted a doctor who actually treated COVID patients, unlike Dr. Ioannidis.
Shawn Evans, attending emergency physician and director of resuscitation at Scripps Memorial Hospital La Jolla, said he and other doctors on the front lines of the epidemic have been “humbled” by how many young people have been hospitalized and ended up in the ICU during the outbreak. “
This is nothing like we had predicted based on the data from these other countries,” Evans, who estimated roughly half the covid-19 patients in his ICU have been under 50, said in an interview… “Young people who are otherwise fit can tolerate this longer, but at the expense of their heart and their pulmonary functions,” said Evans… He said younger patients he has seen tend to come in later, after battling the disease at home for longer. But for those who take a tragic turn, it often happens quickly. “When they do deteriorate, they do so much more dramatically,” he said.
What has profoundly struck Evans and his colleagues is the seeming randomness of the type of young people who are unable to fight off the disease. “A very fit 30-year-old triathlete is just as vulnerable as a chess-playing 45-year-old who gets no exercise,” he said. “We just don’t know who it is that this virus carries the master key to.”
But he does have a message for any young people still under the impression that covid-19 is a disease that seriously threatens only the elderly and infirm. “Just because they are young doesn’t mean they aren’t vulnerable,” he said.
No one who worked in a hospital at that time would agree with Dr. Ioannidis that COVID was harmless for young and middle age people. I previously described seeing a healthy 23-year-old die as the most memorable moment of the pandemic for me. He died on April 9, 2020.
“For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%”
Though Dr. Ioannidis said “for people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%”, a small percentage of a large number is a large number. COVID killed thousands of young people in 2020, when most people were trying to avoid the virus, and it became a top killer of young people in 2021. Its toll would have been much worse had unvaccinated young people been willing to contract COVID en masse in 2020 as pro-infection doctors suggested.
Source: CDC
So let’s be clear what happened here. With theoretical harms from the vaccine, Dr. Ioannidis warned that “maybe… someone would just drop dead on the floor.” However, with actual harms from the virus, Dr. Ioannidis said for healthy people under age 65, “the risk is completely negligible“and that “for people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%“.
He was hardly unique in this regards. Unfortunately, Dr. Ioannidis was just one of several influential doctors who treated theoretical harms from the vaccine, even abnormal lab values in children who feel fine, with more gravitas and concern than actual deaths from COVID.
Abnormal lab values are treated seriously. Actual dead children are not.
COVID hospitalized 234,000 children this pandemic. Subclinical myocarditis is an abnormal lab value in a child who feels fine. Watch the video below. Actual COVID harms to children were casually shrugged off because the virus was worse for older people. In contrast, theoretical vaccine harms from the vaccine were treated with the utmost concern.
This happened all the time.
Source video 1: Boosters, Masking Kids, Vaccine Mandates Source video 2: Subclinical Myocarditis – NEW Report
In reality, actual death is worse than theoretical death, and this didn’t used to be controversial in medicine.

An Absurd Thought Experiment
How would you have reacted on 1/1/2020 if a doctor claimed that a virus that killed zero children was “truly dangerous” compared to one that kill 2,000?
Jonathan Howard on May 9, 2023
Tweet

I want you to mentally transport yourself back to 1/1/2020. Imagine if someone told you then about two viruses and their impact on American children over the previous three years.
Virus A:
    • Infected nearly every child
    • Killed over 2,000 children
    • Hospitalized around 190,000 children and sent many thousands of them the ICU, some sick enough to need mechanical ventilation
    • Caused lingering effects., which can be significant, in some children
Virus B:
    • Infected zero children
How would you have reacted on 1/1/2020 if a doctor from a prestigious medical school claimed that virus B was “truly dangerous” for children, though virus A was not. Further, how would you have reacted had they also argued that because virus B was more dangerous that virus A, we should let unvaccinated children contract virus A, even though there is an effective vaccine for virus A?
That’s exactly how you should react today.
(Misinformation Alert: The COVID vaccines are not in a competition with the MMR/polio vaccines.)
Of course, there were real-world consequences to telling parents virus B was “truly dangerous”, while virus A was not. The pandemic was much more than just an absurdist thought experiment, even though some sheltered doctors treated it as such.

“What Exactly Did the Virus do to All These People?” Reflections on Ted Nugent, Mel Q, Kelly Brogan, and John Ioannidis
The notion that many people are dying with SARS-CoV-2 not from SARS-CoV-2 has hindered our ability to contain to the virus. Whether the source is QAnon influencers or a highly credentialed scientists, we must push back on narratives that are used to minimize the danger of COVID-19.
Jonathan Howard on June 18, 2021
Link

The Claim: “A Positive Test For Coronavirus Does Not Mean Necessarily That This Virus Is Always Primarily Responsible For A Patient’s Demise”
Consider the following statement by right-wing rocker Ted Nugent:
They claim five hundred thousand people have died from COVID-19. Bullshit. I believe that medical examiners in all 50 states have gone, ‘I put down on the death certificate that he died of asphyxiation, but they made me put COVID.’ ‘Well, this guy was stabbed to death, but they made me put down COVID.’ ‘This guy was run over by a tandem gravel truck doing a four-wheel drift and the crows be pecking at your flesh, but they made me put down COVID-19.’
Implying that doctors have significantly inflated COVID-19 deaths without compelling evidence is an inflammatory charge. It would completely upend our understanding of the pandemic if it were true. It’s relatively easy to recognize Mr. Nugent as an ill-informed conspiracy-theorist. No journal editor would invite him to present his views in an article. Were Mr. Nugent, who after his COVID-19 diagnosis said he’s “never been so scared in all my life,” to make this claim in a medical seminar, he would rightly be jeered off the stage.
So, what is the proper reaction when a highly credentialed scientist makes nearly identical claims, only in the formal, cautious diction of scientific discourse? I am referring to Dr. John Ioannidis, a professor of epidemiology and population health at Stanford University. I greatly admired Dr. Ioannidis prior to the pandemic and quoted him favorably several times in my previous work. So, I really mean it when I say writing this article gives me no pleasure. I feel very uncomfortable and vulnerable, to be honest.
But let me share his words from an interview given in April 2020:
There is some contentious issue about what exactly should count as a COVID-19 death. For example, in the last few days (in New York City) we have seen a very large number of probable COVID-19 deaths being added to the figures, and these are deaths where we have not documented with laboratory testing the presence of the virus, so they are pretty presumptive in terms of whether these are deaths that were caused by COVID-19, COVID-19 was present, but not really a key player in the demise of the patient. So, I think we need to wait and see some mature data on what exactly the contribution of the virus has been in different deaths that we have documented. In Italy, where we have some more mature data, we see that close to 99% of people have underlying diseases, actually in most cases multiple underlying diseases and underlying causes that could also have led them to death. In the US, it seems to be less, but we would need to get some more in-depth analysis of what exactly is killing these people and how.
In the same interview he said the following:
So, the data in Italy suggest that it’s very difficult to differentiate between deaths by SARS-CoV-2 and deaths with SARS-CoV-2. Since we had close to 99% of people dying have other causes that may have contributed to their demise, it’s very difficult to dissociate and say that these people specifically died because they were infected. It’s very likely that many of them would have died anyhow, if not immediately within a very short period of time, because of these other causes of death that they had. I think this is an ongoing debate…
Countries use very different systems of recording deaths, and we know, not just from the COVID-19 era, but also from the past, that filling out death certificates can be very tricky. We know that death certificates often are pretty inaccurate, and if you create an environment where people believe that this is the cause of death, that is really the most prominent at the moment, they may subconsciously or unconsciously prefer to list COVID-19 as a major cause of death in the certificate, even though it may be less significant contributor if not an innocent bystander in some cases. This is very difficult to tell at the moment because, as you realize, the battle is still ongoing. But at some point, we need to go back and check very carefully and try to understand what exactly did the virus do to all these people.
If we do that, we will also be able to estimate how many years of life were really lost, because it’s not just the number of deaths, it’s the number of person-years lost that matters the most. If you have someone who is young and healthy and has no other problems and suddenly dies in their twenties, this is a very large number of person-years lost compared to someone who is very old and has multiple reasons to die, and is already dying from something else and you just happen to find a PCR positive test for SARS-CoV-2 in a nasal swab. The number of person-years lost is very small and you’re not even sure that SARS-CoV-2 really did contribute to their death substantially.
Dr. Ioannidis first expressed this sentiment early in the pandemic, writing on March 17th, 2020 that “A positive test for coronavirus does not mean necessarily that this virus is always primarily responsible for a patient’s demise”. Though this belief has since become widespread, this is the earliest instance I found of someone asserting that the virus might not to blame when someone dies after contracting it. The idea that many people are dying with the virus, not from the virus, remained a feature of his interviews and publications. It’s worth quoting Dr. Ioannidis’s statements in full:
    • Now, your point that we’re literally counting, as opposed to estimating, deaths from coronavirus is correct. But I’ll push back that this may not yield mortality figures as accurately as people think. Because of the attention on coronavirus, we’re better at knowing that a deceased person had coronavirus than had the flu. This means we’re good at knowing when someone died with coronavirus — but not necessarily that they died from the infection. We assume that dying with coronavirus is dying from coronavirus. (Medscape)
    • So, this is also an open question. Because for the data that we have more mature and detailed information, like the data from Italy that has already through the peak of their epidemic wave, we realize that 99% of people who die with this virus have other reasons as well to die. On average, they have close to three other reasons to die. On average they are 80-years-old with other comorbidities, as we say, and there’s quite some debate on whether these people would have died anyhow, if not immediately, you know, perhaps in a few days or in a few weeks or a few months. In our country we see a fairly similar picture. We see that people who are disadvantaged, poor people, creating even further inequality in the population through COVID-19, seem to be very hard hit. We see that the age of death on average is a little bit lower compared to European countries, in the range of 73 or 74-years-old, and we see again lots of comorbidities in people who die with COVID-19. It’s very hard to say how many of these people would have died anyhow and how much is the direct contribution of the virus. These data are evolving, but if anything they suggest that the burden of disease as we call it, the number of person-years lost, how many years of life are being lost, is much less than even what the number of deaths would suggest. This is not to minimize the problem. It is a serious problem. (Fox; start listening at 5:05)
    • COVID-19 has become a notifiable disease, so it is readily recorded in death certificates. What we do know, however, is that the vast majority of people who die with a COVID-19 label have at least one and typically many other comorbidities. This means that often they have other reasons that would lead them to death. The relative contribution of COVID-19 needs very careful audit and evaluation of medical records. (Greek Reporter)
    • Finally, a major question that should be answered is the causal contribution of SARS-CoV-2 infection to related deaths. It is difficult to differentiate between deaths with SARS-CoV-2 infection and deaths caused by SARS-CoV-2 infection because the vast majority of patients who have died had 1 or more other major pathologies (98.8% with at least 1 comorbidity, and 48.6% having 3 or more diseases) that contributed to their death. (JAMA Internal Medicine)
    • When I made that tentative quote (estimating that COVID-19 will cause fewer than 40,000 deaths in the US), I had not considered the impact of the new case definition of COVID-19 and of COVID-19 becoming a notifiable disease despite being aware of the Italian experience where almost all counted “COVID-19 deaths” also had other concomitant causes of death/comorbidities. “COVID-19 death” now includes not only “deaths by COVID-19” and “deaths with COVID-19”, but even deaths “without COVID-19 documented”. (Int J Forecast)
    • The number of COVID-19 deaths can be both undercounted and overcounted, and the relative ratio of over- and under-counting varies across different locations. In most European countries and the USA it is more likely to be overcounted, especially if we are talking about “deaths by COVID-19″…For COVID-19 we are in early days, and we need to be careful to dissociate deaths from COVID-19 versus deaths that happened because of the disruption induced by lockdown. (Greek Reporter)
    • Another observation that has emerged is that many of these people (in Italy) probably would have had very limited life expectancy in the absence of that infection, and it still remains to be decided how many of these infections are deaths with SARS-CoV-2 versus deaths by SARS-CoV-2, meaning that the virus has the key influence on the outcome rather than just giving a final kick or participating among many other factors in shaping the outcome, but these people having multiple other reasons that they would have a very poor endpoint and eventually die, many of them. (Daily Motion; start listening at 18:45)
Likely there are other instances where he expressed similar sentiments of which I am currently unaware.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence
It’s a truism that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. As evidence for his claim that “A positive test for coronavirus does not mean necessarily that this virus is always primarily responsible for a patient’s demise”, Dr. Ioannidis cited “an autopsy series that tested for respiratory viruses in specimens from 57 elderly persons who died during the 2016 to 2017 influenza season”. The study found that “influenza viruses were detected in 18% of the specimens, while any kind of respiratory virus was found in 47%”. Oddly, the embedded link does not lead to this study, but rather to a study from 2013 of other coronavirus infections in living people. This paper concluded that, “Coronavirus infections in the elderly are frequent, likely causing substantial medical disease burden”, something we all know too well today. Perhaps Dr. Ioannidis has provided additional evidence elsewhere (he’s written a lot this pandemic and I haven’t read it all), though this is all I could find. If he chooses to write a paper on this topic in the future, I will read it with interest. It should not be off-limits for discussion.
Until he writes more however, it seems that the only evidence Dr. Ioannidis provides to support his extraordinary claim is a study showing that respiratory viruses were commonly found during 57 autopsies five years ago. But it does not follow from this study that a new, different virus, namely SARS-CoV-2, is an “innocent bystander” in many deaths of people today. If it did, it would be essentially impossible to attribute a large number of deaths to a new respiratory virus ever again. I wrote Dr. Ioannidis asking if he had any further evidence for his claim and whether he had altered his opinion at all, but I did not receive a reply.
Three areas of agreement: The vast majority of covid-19 deaths occur in older people who “have other reasons as well to die”
Let me share three areas of agreement.
First, it is true that most COVID-19 deaths occur in older people who “have other reasons as well to die”. According to the CDC, “For over 5% of these deaths, COVID-19 was the only cause mentioned on the death certificate. For deaths with conditions or causes in addition to COVID-19, on average, there were 4.0 additional conditions or causes per death”. This can make it difficult, in very limited circumstances, to tell when someone dies with the virus or from the virus. During the pandemic’s peak in New York City, when morgues were overwhelmed, Dr. Oxiris Barbot, the commissioner of the city’s Department of Health said that “Any patient who has had a positive coronavirus test and then later dies — whether at home or in a hospital — is being counted as a coronavirus death”. Based on this broad definition, some deaths with incidental SARS-CoV-2 infection are assuredly included in the official statistics in the US.
Governmental agencies are of course aware of this problem, and many clearly care about getting the numbers right. The UK, for example, initially counted anyone who died at any time after a positive test, regardless of cause, as a death due to COVID-19. After restricting this time period to 28-days, they reduced their death toll by 12%. Multiple American states have also lowered (or raised) their tallies when appropriate. According to a statement from one California county that lowered its death totals,
It is important to accurately report deaths due to Covid-19 so that residents and health officials have a more precise understanding of the impact of the pandemic and response actions in our community. Using the older definition of Covid-19 deaths, a resident who had Covid-19 but died due to another cause, like a car accident this person would be included in the total number of reported COVID-19 deaths for Alameda County. Under the updated definition of COVID-19 deaths, this person would not be included in the total because COVID-19 was not a contributing factor in the death.
It’s good that governments care about reporting accurate data and are willing to lower their tallies when appropriate.
Though there’s no evidence the number is large, assuredly the COVID-19 death tallies include some individuals who contracted SARS-CoV-2 and died of a disease that would have killed them regardless of this infection. However, Dr. Ioannidis’s statement that “It’s very likely that many of them would have died anyhow, if not immediately within a very short period of time, because of these other causes of death that they had” doesn’t follow from this. Most frail 95-year-olds who are alive today will still be alive in one month. That’s how we get 96 and 97-year-olds. Most people with hypertension, diabetes, obesity, and hyperlipidemia won’t die in the next month. Though they shorten lifespans, they are considered chronic diseases precisely because people usually live with them for many years and decades. Moreover, when people with these conditions die of natural causes, their death certificates will almost always list multiple co-morbidities. How could they not? As Dr. Scott Braunstein said:
Any clinician who has had experience deciding on what to list as cause of death on a death certificate, as I have had to do for the past 15-plus years, understands that the diagnoses chosen involve a great deal of discretion and judgement. In most cases, there are multiple contributing diagnoses, and it is common practice to list more than one factor. Underlying diabetes or coronary artery disease are common diseases that contribute to mortality, even when the immediate trigger for death was pneumonia, influenza, or some other infectious process.
Mel Q: “94% had 2-3 other serious illnesses & the overwhelming majority were of advanced age”
Though Dr. Ioannidis may have been the first to claim that “It’s very likely that many of them would have died anyhow, if not immediately within a very short period of time, because of these other causes of death that they had”, he was definitely not the last to do so. With the help of a retweet from Donald Trump, a viral conspiracy emerged in the summer of 2020 when QAnon influencer Mel Q claimed the CDC had “quietly updated the Covid number to admit that only 6% of all the 153,504 deaths recorded actually died of Covid”, since “the other 94% had 2-3 other serious illnesses & the overwhelming majority were of advanced age”.

Mel Q’s tweet sounds very familiar. One wonders if it was inspired by one Dr. Ioannidis’s prior statements. It is, after all, virtually identical to several of his remarks I shared previously. To pick just one, he questioned the virus’s toll by saying:
Because for the data that we have more mature and detailed information, like the data from Italy that has already through the peak of their epidemic wave, we realize that 99% of people who die with this virus have other reasons as well to die. On average, they have close to three other reasons to die. On average they are 80 years old with other comorbidities, as we say, and there’s quite some debate on whether these people would have died anyhow, if not immediately, you know, perhaps in a few days or in a few weeks or a few months.
It’s remarkable to realize there’s a fundamental agreement between Drs. Ioannidis and QAnon influencer Mel Q about core issues this pandemic. Since most COVID-19 victims are elderly people with medical co-morbidities, both agree something besides the virus likely killed many of them or if the virus did kill them, it only shortened their lifespan by a few months at most.
Of course, undercounting deaths is a problem too and American states have added deaths to their tallies as well to try to address this problem. COVID-19 can kill patients after 28-days, and early in the pandemic doctors may have been reluctant to attribute a death to COVID-19 when people died without being tested for the virus. Undercounting deaths is likely a much more substantial problem than overcounting, as I will discuss.
Three areas of agreement: Some patients who are listed as having died of COVID-19 are categorized “without COVID-19 documented”
Second, Dr. Ioannidis is correct that some patients who are listed as having died of COVID-19 are categorized “without COVID-19 documented”. But this isn’t as a big a problem as it sounds. Though it soon became widely available in the US, early in the pandemic, testing was available for only a small fraction of patients. It was almost never available for people who died at home. It is still not widely available in many parts of the world. However, this does not necessarily mean doctors are wrong to categorize certain deaths as due COVID-19 without testing.
Like many viruses, SARS-CoV-2 produces a characteristic set of signs and symptoms. In the words of Dr. David Oliver, “Doctors treating patients with COVID-19 over the past 12 months recognise a very different clinical syndrome in the sickest patients and a tide of cases of a kind, severity, and clinical course that we have not seen before”. Indeed, this novelty is what allowed the heroic Chinese ophthalmologist Dr. Li Wenliang, who tragically died from the virus himself, to recognize a new disease in the first place.
Doctors are right to put COVID-19 as the cause of death when someone who lives where the virus is circulating, develops classic COVID-19 symptoms, and then dies while gasping for air. This is true even if that person was not tested for SARS-CoV-2, though of course confirming the diagnosis with a test is ideal. As the CDC stated in its death certificate guidelines, “Ideally, testing for COVID–19 should be conducted, but it is acceptable to report COVID–19 on a death certificate without this confirmation if the circumstances are compelling within a reasonable degree of certainty”.
The argument that a positive test is required to diagnosis COVID-19 implies that the disease cannot exist without the test, which would be nice if it were true. It’s the same logic employed by Donald Trump when he said, “Cases are up because we have the best testing in the world and we have the most testing”. Of course, people contracted and died of viruses before testing was invented and even before people knew what viruses were.
Three areas of agreement: Filling out death certificates can be “tricky” at times
Third, Dr. Ioannidis is right that filling out death certificates can be “tricky” at times, though the situation is not nearly as dire as depicted. To understand how death certificates work, let’s consider a woman with a brain tumor who has a seizure while driving and gets into a nasty car crash. She undergoes several surgeries and seems to be making a good recovery. However, she later develops a wound infection and dies. Did she die of the wound infection, the car crash, a seizure, or her brain tumor? Of course, all of these contributed to her demise. Death certificates account for this complexity, allowing clinicians to select several causes of death in an ordered manner. According to the CDC,
The cause-of-death section consists of two parts. Part I is for reporting a chain of events leading directly to death, with the immediate cause of death (the final disease, injury, or complication directly causing death) on Line a and the underlying cause of death (the disease or injury that initiated the chain of morbid events that led directly and inevitably to death) on the lowest used line. Part II is for reporting all other significant diseases, conditions, or injuries that contributed to death but which did not result in the underlying cause of death given in Part I. The cause-of-death information should be YOUR best medical OPINION…When a number of conditions resulted in death, the physician should choose the single sequence that, in his or her opinion, best describes the process leading to death.

Additionally, the CDC put out specific guidelines to help standardize death certificates during this pandemic, and as stated previously, multiple states have lowered their death tallies in accordance with these guidelines.
Doctors who actually fill out death certificates are much less troubled by this process than Dr. Ioannidis. As Dr. Zubin Damania (AKA ZDoggMD) said:
Any medical professional who fills out death certificates understands how it’s done. You list the main cause of death and then anything that contributes. So the certificate can have multiple things on it. You can have things that were preexisting like diabetes, high blood pressure, obesity, and then you can have the main disease, like COVID-19, and then things that led to the main visit, like respiratory failure, respiratory arrest, cardiac arrest, heart failure, adult respiratory distress syndrome, and you list all those things on the document.
It’s true though that there’s a degree of subjectivity when determining the chain of events leading directly to death. Two doctors may not report the same chain of events in the exact same way for every death certificate. Though Part II of the death certificate allows doctors to distinguish between a patient with terminal cancer who happens to test positive for SARS-CoV-2 and those who actually die of COVID-19, some errors have certainly been made. But this doesn’t mean that doctors are largely unable to determine who dies from COVID-19 and who dies with incidental SARS-CoV-2 infection as Dr. Ioannidis suggested.
Doctors were “just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”
Dr. Ioannidis’s statement that “death certificates often are pretty inaccurate” and that those who fill them out “may subconsciously or unconsciously prefer to list COVID-19 as a major cause of death in the certificate, even though it may be less significant contributor if not an innocent bystander in some cases” is a shocking, unsupported indictment of the basic competence of doctors around the world. Dr. Ioannidis believes that when their patients died, doctors were often not capable or sophisticated enough to know what really killed them. He feels doctors were unable to reliably distinguish between someone who died from COVID-19 and someone who was on their deathbed for another reason when they happened to test positive for SARS-CoV-2.
I suspect Dr. Ioannidis would say he has the upmost respect for doctors working in the trenches with COVID-19 patients and would likely vigorously deny any intention to attack their competence, but it’s not really possible to read his statement any other way. Unfortunately, this was not his sole salvo on frontline doctors. On a podcast (at 1:37:25), Dr. Ioannidis said, “There is an effect of what we did, mostly wrong, in the first wave”. To be clear, Dr. Ioannidis is not referring to himself when he said, “what we did, mostly wrong,” but rather to doctors who treated patients with a completely new virus early in the pandemic. Had he been referring to himself, I suspect he would not have laughed when he said this. He then said that “a lot of lives” were lost at that time in part because of doctors “not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation, just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”. Dr. Ioannidis did not provide any evidence for this claim, nor did the podcast host, who agreed with him. Neither this charge, nor his claim about death certificates is likely to be true, as I will discuss.
People who worked on COVID-19 units have every right to feel legitimately proud of their work
New York’s COVID-19 surge was a painful, but inspiring time. We tried to keep the oldest doctors out of harm’s way, but almost everyone else was eager to help out. Pediatricians worked with seniors and gynecologists worked with men. Medical schools graduated students several months early so they could care for COVID-19 patients. I urge everyone to read about their experience. Medical students who were earlier in their training were properly shielded from patients. Instead, they reviewed patients’ charts and called families to keep them informed about their loved ones. The news was oftentimes not good. Other students helped make plastic face shields. Our city was saved by doctors and nurses (mostly nurses) who traveled from all around the country to help. I heard deep southern accents at the hospital that I normally hear only from tourists in Times Square. The city cheered for us every night at 7PM, even though many of us didn’t really feel we deserved it.
COVID-19 hit New York like a tsunami, one we could see coming a couple weeks before it arrived due to the experiences in Italy and Spain. I don’t know if it exists, but I had pre-traumatic stress disorder, as I was plagued by nightmares of mass death just before COVID-19 arrived. I started taking a medication to help me sleep for the first time in my life. It was just a terrifying time. We now know that PPE works very well. Working with COVID-19 patients was safer than eating in the workroom with colleagues. But we didn’t know that back then, and PPE was often in short supply. Early on, some healthcare workers had to improvise and use everyday items to try protect themselves. We all had to wear a single-use N95 mask for a week or longer. We of course worried about getting sick ourselves or bringing the virus home to our loved ones. The experience made many healthcare workers reconsider their careers. Consumed by fear and grief, some took their own lives. I know too many doctors who contracted COVID-19 to count. Some were really sick for weeks. Over 3,600 healthcare workers died in the US. I knew three of them. Some of them were very young.
Additionally, COVID-19 was a brand-new disease, and we had no idea how to treat it. As an attending doctor I had to make some really tough decisions, but even during a pandemic, much of the work was done at a computer or delegated to younger doctors. Residents, interns, nurses, EMTs, respiratory techs, pharmacists, custodial, kitchen, and maintenance staff were the true heroes of the pandemic. They kept the hospital running and the patients well-cared for day and night for months at a time. There were people whose sole job was to bring dead bodies to the overflowing morgue. I can’t imagine how they managed to do this every day. Our hospital director kept everyone calm with his cool demeanor during daily briefings, even when he was informing us that a dozen more critically ill patients were on their way. The administration and countless others toiled behind the scenes to ensure the hospital was properly staffed and we had the PPE we needed. I’m certain we saved many lives, though we all wish we could have done more.
The countless brave people who worked on COVID-19 units have every right to feel legitimately proud of their work.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, part 2
Of course, doctors aren’t perfect, and sometimes we need to hear tough feedback, even during a pandemic in which we are “healthcare heroes”. Dr. Ioannidis’s meta-analysis of hydroxychloroquine trials is an example of such feedback, even if it doesn’t support his claim that the medication killed 100,000 people globally as it says nothing about how many people received the medication. I’m glad that I refused to give this, or other unproven therapies, to my COVID-19 patients outside of a clinical trial. In fact, the only demand I, a neurologist treating a respiratory virus, made upon agreeing to take over a COVID-19 team was that none of my patients would receive unproven medications. Understandably though, many desperate doctors wanted to do something for their patients even if it lacked evidence, a defensible strategy only for those patients who were certainly going to die otherwise. Unfortunately, it is certain that some of these “heroic” efforts seriously harmed and even killed some patients. Evidence-based criticisms must be welcomed in the spirit of preventing similar errors in the future.
In contrast, criticisms without evidence, and especially those that are contrary to the evidence, must be exposed and rejected. This applies to Dr. Ioannidis’s charges that doctors killed many patients through inappropriate intubations and then filled out their death certificates incorrectly. Not only is there no evidence that doctors were “just going crazy” intubating patients, leading to their demise, in fact, a meta-analysis of 12 studies found “The synthesized evidence of almost 9000 patients suggests that timing of intubation may have no effect on mortality and morbidity of critically ill patients with COVID-19”. This suggests that early intubation of critically ill COVID-19 patients may not be necessary, but it doesn’t kill them. This meta-analysis was published after Dr. Ioannidis made his accusation, but all 12 studies it reviewed were published beforehand. Not only is there no evidence that doctors “subconsciously or unconsciously” preferred to list COVID-19 on death certificates, in fact, death certificates have proven to be very reliable this pandemic, as I discuss below. Again, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. This is especially true for an influential scientist with a large megaphone making substantial allegations in public against frontline doctors in the middle of a pandemic.
COVID-19 deaths are not drastically inflated: Studies of death certificates
Christopher Hitchens famously said, “What can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence”. It would be perfectly legitimate to dismiss many of Dr. Ioannidis’s statements on these grounds alone. However, I will present two refutations to the claim that SARS-CoV-2 is an incidental infection in many COVID-19 deaths – studies of death certificates and common sense. Let’s start with studies of death certificates.
Studies of death certificates confirm the unsurprising news that most people who are said to have died of COVID-19 actually died of COVID-19. According to the CDC:
Among death certificates from calendar year 2020 listing COVID-19 and at least one other co-occurring diagnosis, the documentation is consistent with these deaths being attributable to COVID-19. Specifically, in 97% of 357,133 death certificates with COVID-19 and at least one other diagnosis, the documented chain-of-event and significant contributing conditions were consistent with those reported in clinical and epidemiologic studies to occur among patients with severe COVID-19–associated outcomes. Only 5.5% of death certificates had COVID-19 without any other conditions listed.
It’s good that the CDC was willing to investigate death certificates to ensure their accuracy, even if QAnon supporters misinterpreted the results. It’s good that 97% of death certificates of COVID-19 victims are “consistent with these deaths being attributable to COVID-19”. Dr. Ioannidis said, “We know that death certificates often are pretty inaccurate”. If he has evidence that death certificates have often been filled out inaccurately this pandemic, I have been unable to find it. Until he provides it, during this pandemic at least, we know that that death certificates often are pretty accurate.
COVID-19 deaths are not drastically inflated: Common sense
Now let’s look at the common sense refutation. Last year during the surge in New York City, every hospital in the city was overflowing with COVID-19 patients. Children’s hospitals cared for adult patients. Ambulances came from all over the country, and their sirens wailed constantly throughout the strangely quiet city streets. Field hospitals were set up in several places and a massive naval hospital, the USNS Comfort arrived, though it only treated 182 patients due to strict admission criteria. Every day, dozens of the sickest patients were transferred to Bellevue Hospital, where I worked, from other city hospitals that were overwhelmed with COVID-19 cases. Though we came very close, Bellevue never totally ran out of space, as many people died every day. Every fifteen minutes the overhead pager would summon the “airway team” to a different room. I would often arrive in the morning to learn that half of the people I left the evening before had died or been transferred to the ICU overnight.
The ICU itself was an eerie place. This is where I started out working, though truthfully I was only marginally more helpful than a medical student. Our incredible facilities staff managed to install ventilation in every room in a very short amount of time. IV poles were placed outside the rooms to minimize exposure to staff. Almost all the patients were Black or Hispanic. Some were Asian. Very few were White. Guards from the Department of Corrections kept watch over dying inmates. There were always two patients in a room meant for one. There were just bodies of motionless people, intubated, sedated, and alone. Some lived. Some died. I would occasionally gaze out a window to glimpse the abandoned, crumbling Renwick Smallpox Hospital on Roosevelt Island, reminding myself that humanity had defeated viruses before.
Overall, I saw more people die in a few weeks than I had in the past decade, if not my entire career. One of the first was a man who worked as a carpenter at Bellevue for several decades, though he retired before I arrived. As the city morgues became overwhelmed, massive, refrigerated trucks were parked behind my hospital to store the bodies. Overall, 135 such trucks were used in New York City. Even that was not enough. According to news reports, “Shelves were placed in the trailers, doubling their capacity, as funeral directors ran out of storage room. Cemeteries and crematories could not handle the load”. One hospital used a forklift to move all the dead bodies. Finding space to bury the bodies was difficult, a problem faced by many countries. As one nurse, Eileen Diaz, said, “It was just complete chaos. It was like a medical war zone”.
I saw plenty of middle-aged people die and several younger people die. The youngest person I saw die was only 23 years old. He was able to breathe, but was completely obtunded, unable to speak or move. Several days before his death, I made him suffer by placing a nasogastric tube so he could be fed. We didn’t know he would die, and of course he needed nutrition. I still think about that a lot. I wonder what kind of person he was and what his future might have held. His aunt said that he was a loner, and it makes me sad that few people might have mourned his passing. He wasn’t in touch with his mother who had substance abuse issues, I was told. I promised myself to remember his name and I think about him from time to time. I’ve often wondered if I should call his aunt to see how she is doing and tell her that I still remember her nephew. She was an EMT and knew she gave him the virus. I hope she doesn’t blame herself.
While most victims had chronic, underlying conditions, it’s ludicrous to expect a large percentage of them would have died “immediately” or “perhaps in a few days or in a few weeks or a few months” had they not contracted COVID-19, as Dr. Ioannidis suggested. The virus was not an “innocent bystander” for these patients. They were not “already dying from something else” when we just happened “to find a PCR positive test for SARS-CoV-2 in a nasal swab”. The virus did not just give a “final kick” to people who were days or weeks away from dying of other causes.
When Dr. Ioannidis said that “you’re not even sure that SARS-CoV-2 really did contribute to their death substantially”, he could only have been referring to the fortunate people who experienced COVID-19 exclusively as an online event. Clinicians who spent substantial time working with hospitalized COVID-19 patients were all pretty sure what killed our patients – it was the virus. He also said, “It’s very hard to say how many of these people would have died anyhow and how much is the direct contribution of the virus”. He’s wrong. It was very easy to say how many of our patients would have “died anyhow”. Virtually none of them would have “died anyhow”. It was also very easy to say “how much is the direct contribution of the virus”. The virus was directly responsible for killing our patients. He also wrong when he said, “the number of person-years lost, how many years of life are being lost, is much less than even what the number of deaths would suggest”. Doctors who actually work with COVID-19 patients know many victims have their lives shorted by several decades. If you doubt this, ask one of these doctors. They will all say the same thing.
Research supports what they will tell you. One study from April 2021 calculated the virus had stolen 3.9 million years of life away from Americans, and the average COVID-19 victim lost over 9 years of life. Another study from October 2020 calculated that the virus had stolen 2.5 million years of potential life in the US. Just under half of these years were taken from people younger than 65 years. As the paper’s author Dr. Stephen J. Elledge said, “COVID-19 has wiped out millions of years of productive, active, and happy existence”. They were not all 95-year-olds with advanced cancer only days away from dying when they happened to test positive for SARS-CoV-2. In the words of Dr. Utibe Essien, “These are everyday people who are dying. They’re losing time with their kids, their grandkids, their opportunities to build their futures”.
Deaths spiked not just in hospitals, but in homes as well. According to news reports, “About 120 morgue workers and soldiers from the U.S. Army, the National Guard and the Air National Guard are working in shifts around the clock, driving rented vans around the city to pick up the bodies of as many as 280 people a day who have died at home and have probably not been part of the official death count”. According to the New York City Fire Department, “In the first five days of April, 1,125 people were pronounced dead in their homes or on the street in New York City, more than eight times the deaths recorded during the same period in 2019”. While not all of these were COVID-19 victims, many certainly were. None of them died because of doctors “just going crazy” intubating them. Quite possibly some could have lived had they made it to the hospital.

Indeed, many more patients were discharged home, thanks in part to the care they received. The condition of these survivors varied widely. Some left without symptoms and were seemingly back to normal. Some left in the middle of their disease course, as they had somewhere to go or simply didn’t want to be in the hospital. We tried desperately to make them stay, especially if they were homeless, but we couldn’t force them to do anything. I wonder how many of these patients were willing and able to isolate themselves. Some older patients had been extremely delirious, paranoid and hallucinating. Many did not speak English and it was a struggle to communicate with them. It must have been terrifying when we approached with our faces hidden by masks and goggles. Many survivors had been intubated and bedbound for months. They survived but were quite debilitated, barely able to move after experiencing prolonged immobility. With the focus on deaths, these survivors often get overlooked. I wonder how they are doing now.
While the surge in New York City was earlier and perhaps more intense than elsewhere, our experience wasn’t particularly unique. When the refrigerated trucks left New York, they were needed in other states. Children’s hospitals elsewhere opened their doors to adults. We all remember headlines such as “Coronavirus Kills 70 Veterans at Massachusetts Care Home”. Spain had to convert an ice rink into a morgue, and coffins piled up in Italian churches. In India, “Hundreds of corpses have been found floating in the (Ganges) river or buried in the sand of its banks”. Scenes of innumerable funeral pyres there are unforgettable. In Ecuador, bodies were simply left in the street. Variations of these scenes played out all over the world.
With this in mind, we can now revisit Dr. Ioannidis’s claim that “it’s very likely that many of them would have died anyhow, if not immediately within a very short period of time, because of these other causes of death that they had”. There are not normally refrigerated trucks behind my hospital to store dead bodies – indeed they are gone now. Pediatricians don’t normally treat seniors, and gynecologists don’t normally treat men. Medical schools don’t normally graduate students early to work on overflowing hospital wards. The overhead “airway team” pager doesn’t normally go off dozens of times per day at my hospital. Dozens of people don’t normally die in a single nursing home in the span of several days. The military is not normally needed to retrieve dead bodies from homes. It’s not normally a challenge to find space to bury dead bodies. Skating rinks in Spain and rivers in India are not normally full of dead bodies. Bodies aren’t normally left in the streets of Ecuador. Something abnormal happened. There’s only one conclusion; it’s very likely almost none of them would have died anyhow, if not immediately within a very short period of time, because of these other causes of death that they had.
Challenging questions arise
These horrific scenes raise challenging questions for some people. Having established that many more people died than usual, one must blame either the virus or the methods used to control it. If the virus was often just an “innocent bystander”, or if a meaningful number of people died “because of the disruption induced by lockdown,” then:
    • Why did the deaths peak just three short weeks after the lockdown started in New York City?
    • What was the exact mechanism of death for all these people?
    • Why did the deceased all have nearly identical symptoms, radiographs, and lab values?
    • Why did they die in such a similar manner?
    • Why did people who were able to isolate rarely die?
    • Why did the deaths decline precipitously as the lockdown dragged on, instead of rising further in New York City?
    • Why did the deaths come in waves, as with previous pandemics?

    • Why have deaths fallen so dramatically, though primarily in vaccinated people or in areas with very high vaccine uptake?
    • Why were places like New Zealand, which had “7 weeks of what was essentially a national stay-at-home order” spared these horrific scenes?
    • If New York City had locked down in 2019 as part of a bizarre experiment, does anyone really think these nightmarish scenes of death would have occurred in a just three weeks? If so, what exactly would kill all these people in such a short period of time?
COVID-19 deaths might be underestimated
We’ll never know the true death toll of COVID-19. Importantly, undercounting deaths is likely a much more significant problem than overcounting deaths, even for the US. Undercounting was particularly a problem early in the pandemic when healthcare systems were overwhelmed, large numbers of people died at home, and testing was scarce or nonexistent. Doctors may have been reluctant to attribute deaths to COVID-19 under these circumstances. As one funeral home director said about the death certificates of likely COVID-19 victims, “I’ve seen it many times where the doctors will just leave it off. They’re exhausted, they’re busy, and they have a funeral director hounding them”. Looking at excess deaths compared to years past may give a better estimation of the true toll of COVID-19.
Undercounting deaths still remains a significant problem in much of the world. As Dr. Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz wrote,
We probably aren’t overcounting deaths on a global scale by very much. While there are almost certainly some deaths that are being inappropriately counted as being caused by Covid-19 that were really due to something else, the number is probably enormously outweighed by undercounting. It’s plausible that the true global toll of Covid-19 is 10% lower than we think, but it’s quite likely to be 50% higher or more. Given the data from some developing nations, it’s entirely possible that there are millions of uncounted Covid-19 deaths.
Scientists who express evidence-based views on COVID-19 should be heard, not demonized
Much has been written during this pandemic about whether or not nasty words directed toward Dr. Ioannidis have silenced important debate. Surely, some of the threats he says he and his family have received are horrifically inappropriate. We should all condemn this unequivocally.
But debating public policy requires some semblance of shared facts. You couldn’t debate me on the best way to capture the Loch Ness monster, since I reject the creature’s existence in the first place. Creating unwarranted doubt around basic facts similarly precludes meaningful debate about COVID-19. How can contentious issues such as masks, vaccines, and school closures be reasonably discussed when many people are falsely convinced the COVID-19 death toll is greatly inflated? They can’t.
Indeed, anti-mask protesters have harassed public officials and hapless store employees. Anti-vaxxers have shut down vaccination sites and even destroyed vaccines. Many public health officials have resigned after relentless harassment campaigns and threats. Dr. Anthony Fauci and his family need bodyguards for their protection. Though the widespread acceptance of COVID-19 myths has silenced debate much more than any mean tweet directed towards Dr. Ioannidis, many of those who vigorously opposed the supposed “silencing” of Dr. Ioannidis are themselves strangely silent about all of this.
Dr. Ioannidis has said how much he deplores this. I completely believe him. It also would all have happened if he had not said a word. Highly influential leaders of the anti-vaccine movement, such as Dr. Kelly Brogan have also cast doubt on the accuracy of death certificates and the overall toll of COVID-19. In one video she said:
There are other theories about what’s going on that have nothing to do with a virus spreading. That literally suggests, there is potentially no such thing as a coronavirus. There is a tremendous lack of vigilance around the declaration of cause of death in hospitals… ‘Cardiorespiratory collapse’ was the phrase I was encouraged and taught to put on a death certificate if we didn’t immediately know the cause of death.
She additionally posited that fear was killing people, not a virus. As a germ-theory denier, Dr. Brogan doesn’t believe viruses cause disease at all. She said the pandemic was part of a psychological operation to “link our passports with our vaccination records and the restriction of travel being the new normal” to establish “totalitarian governmental control not unlike the divide-and-conquer dehumanization agendas that preceded the Holocaust”. I am not making this up, the way she is making up how she was taught to improperly fill out death certificates. This article is quite a read. Dr. Brogan and other members of the so-called “Disinformation Dozen” have greatly undermined the response to COVID-19 by convincing large numbers of people the virus isn’t dangerous.
As with Mel Q, it is remarkable to realize there’s a fundamental agreement between Drs. Ioannidis and Brogan about core issues this pandemic. They both feel the virus’s toll “is much less than even what the number of deaths would suggest”, as Drs. Ioannidis put it, and death certificates that say otherwise cannot be trusted. As critic Eliza Wells said about one of these two doctors, in order to believe their “claim that numbers are vastly exaggerated you would have to accept that medical health professionals around the world are misreporting the number of deaths attributable to COVID-19. You would also have to believe that they are incompetent, manipulated or lying — perhaps all three”. Was Ms. Wells referring to Dr. Ioannidis or Dr. Brogan when she wrote this passage? It quite reasonably could be either of them, though the answer is Dr. Brogan. Notably, I was unable to find any examples of Dr. Brogan blaming doctors for killing their patients as a result of their “not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation”.
Twitter COVID-contrarians
Misinformation also abounds on Twitter, where Dr. Ioannidis does not have an account. There is a predictable group of COVID-contrarians who garner attention and followers through their “controversial hot takes”. They reflexively oppose the scientific consensus in predictable, trite ways. Being unique matters more to them than being right, it often seems. Their followers call them “brave” and “independent”. It must be very gratifying. I don’t get that feedback on Twitter. Several contrarians declared the pandemic over in the US several months ago. They then inexplicably continue to tweet and write about an event they feel has ended. Some contrarians will say they are 100% pro-vaccine and then provide specious arguments for why they feel adolescents should not be vaccinated. Others push outright vaccine misinformation. The border between these two isn’t always clear.
Twitter has banned the accounts of some of the worst offenders, though many others remain. To the contrarians, Dr. Ioannidis is a brave truth-teller who is rarely if ever wrong. Dr. Ioannidis’s mathematically implausible claims (discussed below) are spun as someone who just thinks “differently” about trade-offs. Despite the extensive quotations I’ve shared, contrarians will likely deny he ever minimized the virus. The fact that he called the virus a “serious problem” will likely be used to excuse everything else he said. They will claim that he was “just asking questions,” a rhetorical trick known as JAQing off. They’ll point to others who overestimated COVID-19, which of course, has no relevance to Dr. Ioannidis’s underestimation of the disease.
This essay will likely upset contrarians, though my criticisms of Dr. Ioannidis are much milder than those he causally lobbed against doctors who treated patients during the deluge of the first wave. Hopefully my criticisms have the advantage of being backed by evidence. Contrarians will say I’m guilty of “tribal politics” and “groupthink,” which are schoolyard taunts, not actual arguments. They will likely substitute tone-policing for meaningful argument. Predictably someone reading this article will latch on to a phrase they feel is inappropriate or they will complain about the overall “nasty tone”, rather than deal with the substance of my criticisms. Notably, few of these contrarians actually worked with COVID-19 patients. Most are utterly divorced from the consequences of their words. It all seems to be a game to them, a way to build their brand.
“The evidence we had early in the pandemic was utterly unreliable”
Sadly, it’s not a game. There are real-world consequences when influential scientists minimize the pandemic, undermining the credibility of doctors and public health officials without compelling evidence. To better understand this, let’s examine Dr. Ioannidis’s appearance on a Fox News program hosted by right-wing firebrand Mark Levin from April 20th, 2020.
At the start of the interview, Dr. Ioannidis tells Mr. Levin that, “the evidence we had early in the pandemic was utterly unreliable”. Mathematical models of 2.5 million Americans dying, are called “completely off, it is just an astronomical error”. I am not certain, but can only imagine this was a reference to epidemiologist Neil Ferguson whose model predicted COVID-19 would kill 2.2 million Americans. Importantly, this number applied only “in the (unlikely) absence of any control measures or spontaneous changes in individual behaviour”, something Dr. Ioannidis did not mention. By CDC estimates, about 34% of the US has had COVID-19 and about 600,000 people have died. It’s entirely plausible that close to 2 million Americans would have died had the virus been allowed to rip throughout the population unchecked, completely overwhelming medical systems. In retrospect, Professor Ferguson’s model doesn’t seem like an “astronomical error” to me.
Having told the viewer to distrust everything they’ve heard about COVID-19 so far, Dr. Ioannidis then claimed to have newer and better data. This data was incredibly good news. It was what we all wanted to hear: COVID-19 isn’t that bad. According to Dr. Ioannidis, the risk of dying from COVID-19 is high for elderly people, especially those in nursing homes, and for those with serious underlying diseases, but “most of the population has minimal risk, in the range of dying while you’re driving from home to work and back”. He said the infection fatality rate is “probably in the range of 1 in a 1,000”. Mr. Levin repeats the good news by saying, “You say one in a thousand. You’re saying well under 1%, is that one-tenth of 1% of the population that actually has the virus will pass away as a result of the virus, or in connection to the virus”. Dr. Ioannidis responds in a now familiar way by saying “This is as open question…99% of people (in Italy) who die with this virus have other reasons as well to die”.
Sadly, more than 1 in a 1,000 people who contract COVID-19 will die from it. In fact, by some estimates, the 1 in a 1,000-fatality rate is accurate only for 25-year-olds. Given the current death toll in the US, a fatality rate of 1 in 1,000 would require 600 million total infections, though only 328 million people live here.
Elsewhere, Dr. Ioannidis claimed that “For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%”. In fact, approximately 25,000 Americans younger than age 45-years have died of COVID-19 thus far. This includes at least 452 children, perhaps more. One study, spanning the first 5 months of the pandemic, found 11,899 more Americans ages 25-44 years died than expected, with 4,535 (38%) of the deaths due to COVID-19. Many of the other excess deaths were likely due to “an insufficient amount of COVID-19 detection and reporting in this age group”. The death toll for children and young people has been worse outside the US. As a healthy 45-year-old, I did not consider my pre-vaccine risk of dying from COVID-19 to be “almost 0%”.
In yet another interview he said, “For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk is completely negligible…it seems that these deaths are extremely exceptional”. Different people have different definitions of a risk that is “completely negligible”. To me, my risk of being swallowed by a whale is “completely negligible”. In contrast, healthy people younger than 65 die of COVID-19 every day. The fact that these tragedies make up a relatively small percentage of the total COVID-19 deaths can obscure the fact that the total number is not trivial, especially considering the number of years of life lost when a young person dies. Younger people have been especially affected in less resource-rich parts of the world. According to Dr. Carissa F. Etienne, “In Brazil, mortality rates have doubled among those younger than 39, quadrupled among those in their 40s and tripled for those in their 50s between December 2020 and March 2021”. Young, healthy people also suffered greatly during India’s still-ongoing wave.
Dr. Ioannidis also said on Fox News that “the vast majority” of people “don’t even realize that they have been infected, they are asymptomatic, they have no symptoms, or they have very mild symptoms that they would not even bother to do anything about”. In fact, one meta-analysis found that only 16% of cases are asymptomatic. Another found that only 20% of cases are asymptomatic. Moreover, studies of asymptomatic individuals found that about 80% of them eventually develop symptoms. Many are best labeled as pre-symptomatic. Clearly, the vast majority of people feel sick and do realize they have been infected.
10 Million infections people in a city with 8.3 million people?
I recognize most of the statements I have quoted are from relatively early in the pandemic, though several are from well after the pandemic’s first wave. As late as June 27th, 2020 Dr. Ioannidis claimed that deaths in the US and Europe were “more likely to be overcounted” and warning that “we need to be careful to dissociate deaths from COVID-19 versus deaths that happened because of the disruption induced by lockdown”. I also recognize it is not entirely fair to judge comments from the spring of 2020 with knowledge from the spring of 2021, as some now retroactively judge doctors who worked during the pandemic’s first wave. However, even at the time he made them, many of Dr. Ioannidis’s claims were mathematically implausible or downright impossible. New York City had already recorded over 10,000 COVID-19 deaths the week before he gave the Fox News interview, though Dr. Ioannidis likely did not accept this number as is included 3,700 people who presumably died of the virus without having been tested for it. If 10,000 people had already died and if only 1 in a 1,000 people died overall, as he claimed, this would require 10 million New Yorkers to have been infected, when only 8.3 million people live there.
Even excluding the 3,700 deaths who weren’t tested for the virus, a death rate of 1 in a 1,000 requires 75% of New York City to have been infected by mid-April 2020. Dr. Ioannidis’s may very well have thought this many New Yorkers had been infected given his belief that the vast majority of people have no or minimal symptoms. Currently, over 33,330 people have died in New York City from COVID-19. Dr. Ioannidis’s death rate of 1 in a 1,000 requires 33 million infections in New York City, which is four times its population and equal to the populations of New York State, Massachusetts, and New Jersey combined. This is not an isolated incident. Several times during the pandemic Dr. Ioannidis has calculated fatality rates that require more people to be infected in a given area than actually live in that area, assuming one accepts the death tolls as accurate of course.
What “really caused” 2.6 million COVID-19 deaths?
Dr. Ioannidis was not the only smart person to underestimate COVID-19 initially. There is no shame in having done this. There was a lot we didn’t know early in the pandemic, and many statements from that time look awful a year later. I, for example, tweeted out a study in March 2020 casting doubt on the benefits of masks. Though my “audience” is a fraction that of Dr. Ioannidis, this was a mistake, one of many I’ve made. I acknowledged my mistake, which wasn’t hard to do. Many others have since acknowledged their errors, and I admire them for this. Infectious-disease expert Dr. Paul Offit, for example, predicted on March 2nd, 2020 that COVID-19 would cause less than “one-tenth of the damage that influenza causes every year in the United States”. He later acknowledged his error saying, “If you’re going to be wrong, be wrong in front of millions of people. Make a complete ass of yourself”.
While Dr. Ioannidis readily admits error on behalf of frontline doctors, he has not returned to Fox News, or anywhere else, to correct these early statements as far as I know. The only time I have seen him admit error is when he revisited a prediction of his “that COVID-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA”. However, even in this article, from August 25th, 2020, he cited “additional contributing reasons” as to why his prediction was off. According to Dr. Ioannidis, the real problem was how COVID-19 deaths came to be counted. Note the use of scare quotes in his explanation below:
When I made that tentative quote, I had not considered the impact of the new case definition of COVID-19 and of COVID-19 becoming a notifiable disease despite being aware of the Italian experience where almost all counted “COVID-19 deaths” also had other concomitant causes of death/comorbidities. “COVID-19 death” now includes not only “deaths by COVID-19″ and” deaths with COVID-19″, but even deaths “without COVID-19 documented”.
To be fair, more recently Dr. Ioannidis appears to have quietly, but dramatically, shifted his position and now seemingly accepts that millions of people have actually died from the virus, but with some key caveats. In a talk from March 2021, he listed the following reasons as “what really caused” 2.6 million COVID-19 deaths:

From doctors to politicians who supported “foolish blind lockdowns” to nursing home directors to COVID-19 victims themselves, Dr. Ioannidis clearly feels there’s a lot of blame to go around. Almost everyone is to blame it seems, except influential scientists who repeatedly minimized a deadly virus on widely watched outlets such as Fox News.
“THE U.S. DID NOT SURPASS 200,000 COVID-19 DEATHS”
However, influential scientists minimizing a deadly virus in public forums likely had an effect, one that makes previously perplexing behavior quite understandable. Anti-mask protesters really believed warnings about COVID-19 were “completely off, just an astronomical error”. Those who harassed public health officials really believed the chance of dying was “completely negligible” or “almost 0%” for everyone but grandma. Those who mocked social distancing guidelines really believed the “vast majority” of people “don’t even realize that they have been infected”. Anti-vaxxers really believe “death certificates often are pretty inaccurate”. And why wouldn’t they really believe these things? They heard it all from a highly-respected scientist, from a highly-respected university, who spoke with great conviction as he told them just what they wanted to hear. Indeed, Dr. Ioannidis’s interviewer on Fox News, Mr. Levin, would later promote Mel G’s conspiracy that COVID-19 deaths are inflated by tweeting, “THE U.S. DID NOT SURPASS 200,000 COVID-19 DEATHS”. This is how debate is silenced.
Unfortunately, false beliefs travel around the world with the click of a button, and the US has become a main exporter of these myths. According to one survey:
Among the most widely believed Covid conspiracies is that the death rate of the virus, which according to the Johns Hopkins University tracker has so far killed nearly 1.1 million people worldwide, has been “deliberately and greatly exaggerated”. Nearly 60% of respondents in Nigeria said this was definitely or probably true, along with more than 40% in Greece, South Africa, Poland and Mexico. About 38% of Americans, 36% of Hungarians, 30% of Italians and 28% of Germans felt the same.
The widespread acceptance of this belief will likely be a huge barrier to controlling the virus. To again quote Dr. David Oliver, “Every time we see or hear such mistruths we need to combat them and call them out. They are used to play down the seriousness and consequences of covid-19 and undermine health protection efforts”. I agree.
What exactly did the virus do to all these people?
Dr. Ioannidis said, “at some point we need to go back and check very carefully and try to understand what exactly did the virus do to all these people”. We can begin doing that now. Around the world, the virus has killed nearly 4 million people, likely many millions more, and sickened many hundreds of millions of people. In the US, the virus has killed 600,000 people, hospitalized 5.6 million, and sickened over 100 million more according to CDC estimates. Along with the Civil War and the 1918 epidemic, COVID-19 is one of the top three greatest mass casualty events in American history. Some survivors have been severely debilitated. We will be learning about the potential long-term consequences of COVID-19 for years. It’s not over yet.
Though access is still a problem for some people, overall, the vaccine roll-out in the US greatly exceeded my expectations. I never imagined that very safe and very effective vaccines would be freely and widely available for almost every American over 12-years-old well before the summer. Yet, many people have resisted. Many states have resorted to offering all sorts of incentives to convince people to get vaccinated. In 24 states, 40% or less of the population is fully vaccinated. I suspect Fox News is very popular in these states. Predictably, COVID-19 continues to sicken people in these areas. According to a New York Times database, in parts of Tennessee, “where only 20 percent of people are fully vaccinated, there has been an almost 700 percent increase in hospitalizations for Covid-19 over the past two weeks”.
Doctors and scientists have an obligation to choose their words very carefully when engaging with the public about a deadly virus and to openly correct the errors we all will inevitably make. It bears repeating; there are real-world consequences of promoting the idea that many people died with the virus, not from the virus. When an American dies of COVID-19 today – and hundreds are still dying daily – it is probable the decedent passed up an opportunity to be vaccinated.
Perhaps this person heard the threat from COVID-19 was greatly exaggerated. Perhaps this person was told doctors falsely hyped the threat or even killed patients through their “crazy,” inappropriate intubations. As such, these doctors couldn’t be trusted when they suggested vaccination or warned against quack cures. I hear versions of this frequently with my patients. Astonishingly, according to one article about an overwhelmed hospital in Canada, staff “are routinely hearing from sick and unvaccinated patients who believe the pandemic is a hoax — some remaining defiant even on the brink of death”. What is the source of these beliefs, for which people are willing to sacrifice their lives? Likely the source is people like Ted Nugent, Mel Q, and Dr. Kelly Brogan.
All of this makes me sadder than you can possibly imagine.

Doctors Respond to Being Quoted: “I Don’t Think You Realize How Silly You Look Right Now”
“They resorted to ad hominem attacks and dug a deeper hole for themselves.”
Jonathan Howard on September 2, 2023
Link

Most doctors whose ideas I have discussed have ignored me. That is their perfect right. I am not entitled to a response from anyone. However, several doctors, namely Drs. Joseph Fraiman, Vinay Prasad, Francois Balloux, Stefan Baral, and Jay Bhattacharya, have responded to the data I presented in the linked articles and my book. As much of my writing is simply accurate quotes, I will continue that practice and allow you to form your own opinion as to the validity of their criticisms.
Dr. Joseph Fraiman:
Hi @19joho your book “we want them infected” I’m one of the handful of people who bought it,….wow it is really bad. It’s painful to read the words of a self-proclaiming scientist so out of touch with reality who has no idea how out of touch he is.
Were you surprised your book sales have been so poor?
Your tweets were getting so much attention, you maybe got fooled given your tweets were artificially throttled up for extra viewing by being pro-government narrative and pro- pharma (they used to get to push that Twitter throttle and de-throttle.). But sadly for you they can’t throttle up book sales.
It is shocking you don’t realize, but most Americans now know they were lied to by our government and scientists like you. They know lockdowns hurt more than they helped, those school closing you supported destroyed our children, as did the worthless masking you supported. Also most realize the vaccine is worthless at best & are upset, they got fooled into taking it. Your track record for pandemic recommendations has been 100% harmful.
I’m sure your book isnt selling. Most Americans have learned better, despite being fed the government propaganda you gladly parroted the last couple of years.
Your book is a going to live in history as testament to the thoughtless and harmful government recommendations scientist’s embarrassing didn’t oppose for fear of losing their jobs and some like your self stupidly supported.
You book is being judged poorly today by nearly all Americans (your book sales are the example) but even worse you will be judged more harshly by generations to come. As now nearly all realize the ideas you promoted were wrong and harmful, yet you could not see this and published a book doubling down on your own hubris…I actually feel bad for you, as I don’t think you realize how silly you look right now.
Dr. Vinay Prasad:
Joseph you can’t indulge someone just trying to make money from selling a book🤣.
Professor Francois Balloux:
I’ve been frequently ‘harassed’ on social media including by @medpagetoday contributors. @19Joho is the worst. He’s deeply dishonest, unhinged and vile. Then, I appreciate it’s just part and parcel of his grift and he’s got a book to flog. The two people who wrote proper hit pieces about me are @19Joho and @AlexBerenson. This may look like ‘horseshoe theory’, but it’s actually easier to explain by greed. Both were prepared to cause major damage to childhood vaccination programmes to push sales of their shite books…His behaviour was bit of a mystery to me, until I realised he was trying to cash in on a Covid book. Then it all started to make sense….
Here you are already, shouty as always. Intellectually, I rank you on the level of antivaxx cranks such as such Wakefield, Yeadon, Berenson and Malone, and you’re equally damaging vaccine stewardship with your dogmatic idiocy.
Dr. Stefan Baral:
In fairness Dr Howard is just hawking his book so can’t blame the man for trying to line his pockets during a pandemic when he saw so many of his friends doing the same… But what he does have is nine truly terrible books on Amazon. The man clearly doesn’t earn enough wherever he works and I sincerely hope it’s all been worth it…It won’t since no one cares enough to actually worry about a person like him. But I do feel pity for how sad his life must be and do wish him better days ahead.
Twitters biggest book-selling schmuck…
Just asked you to leave me alone…still praying that happen one day.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya:
I wasn’t going to comment on the inane Jonathan Howard (@19joho) book on the pandemic, but I ran across an unhinged claim by him that illustrates perfectly a certain covidian mindset that is too perfect to pass up….
The only way out of this bind, I guess, is to extol the virtue of lockdown. Let’s also leave aside his deep lack of understanding of the idea of herd immunity, which is a biological fact and the endpoint of any strategy we follow, whether lockdowns, focused protection, or let-it-rip. California and NY followed lockdowns, and everyone got infected anyway!
(Free advice for you, Jonathan: maybe take an epidemiology class if you don’t want to keep embarrassing yourself in public further?) The bigger problem is that lockdowners like Howard (an NYU doctor, I think), think that living your life is an irresponsible act. Sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act. The implication is that unless you comply with his prescription — lockdown with no logical endpoint — you are irresponsible.
But he’s wrong. Living your life is not irresponsible. Absent tremendous laptop class privilege, there is and was no way to hide away from the virus forever without harm to your physical, psychological, and economic health. The unspoken root idea of his is that the general public owed it to doctors to not get covid because it would place doctors at risk of getting covid. Of course this is an inversion. Medical professionals serve the public, not the other way around.
After sharing his extensive commentary (previously discussed here and here), Dr. Bhattacharya revealed something entirely unsurprising about my book- he had not read it. This may explain why his and other doctors’ reaction was very different from those who had. Indeed, one person who actually read it said:
So far, on social media, these contrarians can only respond to this book with ad hominem attacks and not much else. After all, Dr. Howard quoted their own words and their words are the only evidence needed to condemn their work.
Another person who actually read it had this to say:
Anyone not convinced by his book hasn’t read it. I read the book and examined the recent Twitter responses from the main people JH alludes to. I can honestly say they have failed to refute him on a single point. They resorted to ad hominem attacks and dug a deeper hole for themselves.
Of course, you should read any of my articles here and judge all this for yourself.

Quoth quacks, “The medical consensus has changed before, making my quackery science!”
Brave maverick doctors (i.e., quacks) have long tried to portray themselves as “innovators” challenging an ossified medical consensus for the good of patients. This tradition continues among COVID-19 quacks, in particular the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance and its founders.
David Gorski on August 28, 2023
Links

If there’s one thing that I came to understand over my two-plus decades of critically evaluating the claims of “brave maverick doctors,” the vast majority of whom are really just quacks, it’s that quacks hate the very concept of scientific and medical consensus. Indeed, long ago I pointed out that hostility towards the very concept of scientific consensus is a red flag, a very good indicator that the person expressing such hostility is a science denier (or quack, if it’s a physician). Moreover, although I concede that anyone has the “right” to “challenge” a scientific consensus, the bigger problem in the age of social media is recognizing when someone doing the challenging has the necessary expertise to make a scientifically robust challenge, compared to the vast majority of such “challenges,” which are made by pseudoexperts in different fields who think they have the necessary expertise but do not or by lay people who don’t even have the basic expertise necessary. Unsurprisingly, we have seen this phenomenon play out in a world stage since COVID-19 was first declared a pandemic three and a half years ago. However, even though seeing pseudoexperts about COVID-19 and mRNA vaccines flourish during the pandemic did not surprise me, I will admit, though, that even I was somewhat surprised at the sheer scale and influence of the phenomenon and how much it bled into mainstream politics and culture this time.
As I was thinking about this last week, I remembered a Substack post that I had encountered recently that reminded me of a common technique of pseudoexperts and quacks challenging scientific and medical consensuses, namely to conflate their misinformation with “innovation” and the normal evolution of scientific and medical consensuses. The post appeared—because of course it did—on the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care (FLCCC) Alliance Substack a couple of weeks ago and is entitled 25 Times Medical Consensus Had To Be Rethought, with its blurb giving the game away:
These examples are a reminder of the need for ongoing research, humility, and the willingness to challenge established beliefs for the sake of patient care.
Far be it from me to argue against “ongoing research, humility, and the willingness to change established beliefs for the sake of patient care,” but you can see the game right away: to deceptively conflate the quackery promoted by FLCCC doctors with normal medical innovation, while equating critics of the FLCCC and its quackery with the doctors who, for example, refused to believe the 19th century findings of Ignaz Semmelweis, who linked lack of handwashing by obstetricians with puerperal fever that killed newborns and attacked him for his findings. (Hint: FLCCC is not Semmelweis.) Remember, FLCCC is a conspiracy-mongering bunch of grifting quacks promoting disproven “repurposed” treatments for COVID-19, such as ivermectin, hydroxychloroquine, and the grab bag of supplements and other repurposed drugs in their “early treatment protocols.” Indeed, two of FLCCC’s founders, Dr. Pierre Kory and Dr. Paul Marik recently reported that the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) had informed them that its Credentials and Certification Committee had recommended rescinding their board certifications, portraying the ABIM’s action as “persecution” by a corrupt organization.
Clearly, this Substack post on medical consensuses is part of the FLCCC’s campaign in response to the ABIM decision to portray its founders not as the quacks they are but rather as “brave maverick doctors” successfully challenging the medical consensus on COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines. Unsurprisingly, the FLCCC spins a conspiratorial narrative that portrays quacks (like its very own Drs. Kory and Marik) as “innovators” and the scientific consensus as corrupt and riddled with conflicts of interest, often controlled by whatever “enemy” dominates the conspiracy theory; in the case of COVID-19 and antivax narratives, it’s usually—but not always—big pharma.
The false narrative equating FLCCC quackery to challenges to the scientific consensus
Right from the very beginning the Substack entry by FLCCC, the anonymous authors make it very clear what the FLCCC is about by proclaiming:
There’s been much debate lately about the value of medical consensus.
“What matters is consensus!” astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson excitedly told Del Bigtree, on a recent episode of The Highwire. He seemed to be arguing that medical or scientific “consensus” is more important than the knowledge and experience of individual scientists.
Medical certification and licensing boards also claim that individual healthcare providers who share information that is contrary to “consensus-driven scientific evidence” are misinformation spreaders who cause so much potential harm that their certifications or licenses should be revoked.
I discussed that episode of The Highwire myself not long after it was posted, pointing out that it was a huge mistake on Neil deGrasse Tyson’s part to agree to “debate” Del Bigtree. On the show Bigtree did his best to portray the scientific consensus about COVID-19 as not just wrong but disastrously wrong and existing solely to shut down “dissent,” while proclaiming how the cranks will someday be vindicated by overcoming the “consensus. However, as large a mistake as I thought it was for deGrasse Tyson to appear on Bigtree’s quackfest of a podcast, one thing that I thought deGrasse Tyson got right was his discussion of what a scientific consensus is and why it’s important, regardless of how much Bigtree tried to twist the narrative. (Unsurprisingly, Dr. Paul Marik was one of the “brave maverick” doctors listed as bucking the “consensus.”
Antivaxxers tried to cherry pick a single quote from Bigtree—”the individual scientist doesn’t matter”—that, taken out of context, can be misinterpreted as dismissing scientists who report findings that question the current scientific consensus. In fact, NDT spent considerable time explaining how and when an individual scientist does and doesn’t matter with respect to scientific consensus, in particular how hard it is to tell when an individual scientist’s finding that calls consensus into question is just an outlier or when it might be the first indication of an “emerging truth.” Personally, whenever cranks like the FLCCC question scientific consensus as a concept, I point out that a scientific theory is nothing more than the best existing scientific consensus concerning a particular area or question in science; e.g., the Theory of Relativity, the Theory of Evolution, etc. Back in the days when I used to write about evolution a lot, this explanation used to serve as a two-fer, too, because it effectively defangs the dismissal of evolution as “just a theory.” As I also like to point out, how you question a scientific consensus matters at least as much as the specific questioning. “Questions” about the scientific consensus from groups like FLCCC are often based on misrepresentations of what the consensus actually is, bolstered by cherry picked science, conspiracy theories, and poor reasoning.
As for the ABIM recommending revoking the medical license of two of FLCCC’s biggest quacks, Drs. Paul Marik and Pierre Kory, I wrote my detailed take three weeks ago. TL;DR version: It is appropriate for a certifying board like the ABIM to revoke the board certifications of doctors like these, but they should do it not just for spreading dangerous medical misinformation during a pandemic (the stated reason) but for practicing quackery, which I argue that Drs. Kory and Marik do, particularly given that spreading medical misinformation nearly always goes hand-in-hand with practicing actual quackery.
The FLCCC then predictably moves on to a common quack argument:
While some might argue in favor of the merits of consensus in providing timely guidance, it is important to correct for the many potential biases, beliefs, preferences, and conflicts of interest that could lead to subjective consensus decisions, and to ensure that consensus-based recommendations reflect the views of a heterogenous and diverse group of experts.
How can it be a consensus when all sides of an issue have not been considered and differing views are being censored? What about all the out-of-the-box thinkers in history who have challenged conventional thinking and moved the needle forward for all humankind?
Consensus is, in fact, a perfect cover for conflicts of interest like ties to pharmaceutical companies, medical device manufacturers, or other commercial entities, which compromise the integrity and impartiality of the consensus process. Or, some experts may be more inclined to favor consensus recommendations aligned with the interests of their research funding sources. Others may have intellectual biases based on long-standing beliefs or theories they are hesitant to challenge.
Perhaps, but that doesn’t justify pseudoscience and quackery. Again, quacks love to cite problems and shortcomings in how scientific consensus develop and evolve in order to give the appearance that these deficiencies imply that their quackery is a valid “challenge” to the consensus. Not that that stops FLCCC from doubling down:
And what about all the times in medical history when consensus beliefs were proven wrong, and patients were harmed in the process because the establishment clung to a flawed premise?
Once a consensus is reached, there is often resistance to updating recommendations based on new and emerging evidence, which leads to guidelines becoming quickly outdated and not reflecting the latest advances in science. Studies have shown that even after claims have been disproven in the medical literature, they often persist for years and even decades before they retreat from use.
Dr. David Sackett, considered one of the ‘fathers’ of evidence-based medicine, once had this advice for medical students:
“Half of what you’ll learn in medical school will be shown to be either dead wrong or out of date within five years of your graduation; the trouble is that nobody can tell you which half – so the most important thing to learn is how to learn on your own.”
I’ve heard this quote before, and, quite frankly, have always thought it to be a gross exaggeration. Medical science does evolve, but not quite that rapidly. I like to cite my own specialty, breast cancer surgery, to point out that, yes, the surgical treatment of breast cancer is very different than it was when I graduated from medical school over three decades ago, but it actually took decades for those changes to manifest themselves. For example, five years after I graduated from medical school, the treatment was basically the same. Ten years on, for the evaluation of whether breast cancer had spread to the axillary lymph nodes under the arm or not, the use of sentinel lymph node biopsy (a technique that involves removing only one or a few targeted lymph nodes under the arm) instead of axillary dissection (in which all the lymph nodes under the arm are removed) was being tested clinical trials. By 15 years after graduation, the sentinel lymph node biopsy had largely replaced axillary dissection for axillary staging, although it wasn’t until well over 20 years after I had graduated from medical school that the NSABP-32 randomized controlled clinical trial was finally published and nailed down definitively the equivalence between the two techniques in terms of outcomes. In other words, medical practices most definitely do evolve in response to evidence, but most medicine doesn’t change nearly as quickly as Sackett claimed.
That’s not to say that change doesn’t sometimes happen rapidly. One example is chemotherapy for a type of breast cancer called “triple negative” (lacking estrogen and progesterone receptors and not expressing an oncogene called HER2), which had remained largely the same for decades. As a result of the reporting of the KEYNOTE-522 RCT in 2020, the standard of care changed very quickly to incorporate immunotherapy with chemotherapy, and now pretty much all patients with triple negative breast cancer receive immunotherapy as well as a variation of old chemotherapy regimens, with greatly improved results. (No doubt conspiracy theorists will blame big pharma, given that Merck Sharp & Dohme funded the study.)
The point is that it’s way more complicated than Sackett’s all too easy adage makes it seem. Some medical practices evolve slowly or even not at all. (After all, if a treatment works and no one has found anything better yet, why change?) Others evolve slowly, while a few change rapidly in response to evidence like the KEYNOTE-522 trial. Quacks love to imply that the rapid evolution of some medical practices is how all medicine evolves, all while portraying their quackery as being on the “cutting edge” that hidebound doctors, resist because they are blinded by habit and comfort with current consensus, as well as—of course!—conflicts of interest (i.e., they are pharma shills), and that is exactly what FLCCC is doing here.
The post concludes with a list of 25 times the “medical consensus had to be revisited,” repeating again that the list is a “reminder of the need for ongoing research, humility, and the willingness to challenge established beliefs in the pursuit of patient-centered healthcare.” I respond again that no one—I mean, no one—opposes the “need for ongoing research, humility, and the willingness to challenge established beliefs in the pursuit of patient-centered healthcare,” with perhaps the exception of arrogant quacks like Dr. Kory who proclaim themselves humble but then have the unfettered arrogance to think that they have come up with a highly effective treatment for a disease that no one else could develop or demonstrate to be effective. In fact, what we supporters of SBM oppose is quackery being misrepresented as “innovation.” As for the 25 times the consensus “changed,” the list represents a combination of legitimate examples described more or less correctly, legitimate examples described in a highly biased and misleading way, and dubious examples. Some of the legitimate, rather blandly described, examples include changes in cancer screening guidelines (e.g., PSA testing and mammography), changes in the definition of the blood pressure levels that constitute hypertension, high dose chemotherapy and bone marrow transplantation for breast cancer, the use of aspirin for primary prevention of cardiovascular disease, and routine opioid use for chronic pain. Neglected by Dr. Kory is the historical fact that the vast majority of these changes in medical consensus were driven not by “brave maverick” doctors like him, but by the slow, iterative accumulation of evidence from basic science and/or clinical observations and trials.
Some of the examples in the list are clearly meant to “poison the well” by equating distortions of medical history frequently cited by quacks as being the same as legitimate changes in the medical consensus.
One particularly dubious example is #5 (“Smoking and health risks”):
For much of the 20th century, the tobacco industry worked tirelessly to cast doubt on the harmful effects of smoking, while medical professionals were slow to recognize the dangers. Smoking was initially endorsed and even advertised as a harmless or health-enhancing habit. It wasn’t until landmark studies, such as the 1964 Surgeon General’s Report, that smoking was unequivocally linked to lung cancer, heart disease, and a myriad of other health issues. The battle against tobacco use highlighted the dangers of delaying action due to industry influence and the importance of evidence-based decision-making in public health.
It is true that the tobacco industry did indeed “work tirelessly to cast doubt on the harmful effects of smoking,” but, as most cranks do, FLCCC conflates advertising that used models or actors playing doctors who endorsed smoking as, at minimum, harmless or even beneficial with the actual medical consensus. In reality, by the 1930s, medical science was noticing the harmful effects of smoking, and the scientific findings linking smoking to lung cancer predated the 1964 Surgeon General’s report by at least two decades. As documented in Robert Proctor’s book The Nazi War on Cancer (a book I highly recommend), in fact Nazi scientists had found evidence strongly linking smoking to lung cancer by the early 1940s, a finding confirmed in the early 1950s in studies by Sir Richard Doll and Sir Austin Bradford Hill showing a massively increased risk of lung cancer associated with smoking, to be followed by studies linking smoking to bladder and other cancers as well as cardiovascular disease. Indeed, the Surgeon General’s report in 1964 was a decade behind the science, which is one thing that could be criticized.
While I agree with the observation that the tobacco industry’s decades-long campaign against emerging scientific findings that increasingly found severely detrimental health effects attributable to tobacco use “highlighted the dangers of delaying action due to industry influence and the importance of evidence-based decision-making in public health,” I also point out that what the FLCCC is doing is more akin to what the tobacco company did than what Doll, Bradford Hill, and the Surgeon general did: Promote misinformation, bad science, and pseudoscience to cast doubt on scientific findings. In other words, FLCCC and its allied brave maverick doctors are not the heroes in this comparison.
Another questionable example is #1, thalidomide:
In the late 1950s and early 1960s, thalidomide, a sedative, and anti-nausea medication, was widely prescribed to pregnant women to alleviate morning sickness. Regrettably, it was believed to be safe for use during pregnancy, even though some animal studies indicated potential risks. Tragically, thousands of babies were born with severe limb deformities, known as phocomelia, because their mothers took thalidomide during pregnancy. This devastating outcome exposed the flaws in the medical consensus of the time and led to the establishment of stricter drug safety regulations.
There was never an actual medical “consensus” in the late 1950s and early 1960s about thalidomide. If anything, thalidomide is another cautionary tale about the dangers of marketing and physicians jumping on a medical bandwagon before there was adequate evidence. Indeed, while thalidomide was approved for use in Europe, it was never approved in the US at this time, largely thanks to the FDA doing its job by raising concerns about safety signals in the studies submitted by the manufacturer in its application for funding raised by the FDA scientist, Dr. Frances Oldham Kelsey, reviewing the application for FDA approval. She (and the FDA) held firm in spite of huge pressure brought to bear on them over the course of a couple of years by the drug’s manufacturer William S. Merrell Company of Cincinnati, which had applied to market thalidomide under the trade name Kevadon. For having “prevented a major tragedy of birth deformities” (which she undoubtedly had), Dr. Kelsey was awarded the Distinguished Civilian Service Medal, the nation’s highest federal civilian service award, by President John F. Kennedy in 1962. It was an award that she richly deserved. Indeed, she didn’t retire until 2005, and in 2010 she was the first recipient of an FDA awardnamed after her and continues to be awarded annually. When she finally passed away in 2015 at the ripe old age of 101, the tributes rolled in for her role in standing up for drug safety and preventing the thalidomide catastrophe from spreading from Europe to the US.
As a result of the thalidomide scandal, Congress passed the Kefauver-Harris Drug Amendments to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. These amendments required that drug companies not just show safety, as had been the case prior to the amendments, before their drugs could be FDA-approved, but also to provide substantial evidence of effectiveness for the product’s intended use. That evidence had to be in the form of adequate and well-controlled clinical trials, which at the time was considered a revolutionary requirement. (Believe it or not, no requirement for high quality clinical trials as a condition of drug approval existed before 1962.) This led to the current system of phase I, II, III, and IV clinical trials in force today. The amendments also included a requirement for informed consent of study subjects and codified good manufacturing processes, as well as the requirement that adverse events be reported. This has been, with some tweaking over the years, the law of the land regarding how the FDA approves drugs for specific indications. Again, the thalidomide scandal is far more of an example of the bad things that can happen when doctors and various regulatory agencies let actors promoting persuade doctors to start using inadequately tested treatments.
Lest you fail to get the message, there’s also #7 on the FLCCC list, bloodletting:
Bloodletting, the practice of deliberately withdrawing blood from a patient, was a widely accepted medical treatment for various illnesses in ancient times and throughout the Middle Ages. It was believed to restore the balance of bodily humors. However, with advancements in medical knowledge, the practice was eventually recognized as ineffective and potentially harmful, leading to its abandonment.
Got it? The medical consensus is just like bloodletting, a practice rooted in prescientific vitalism that persisted for millennia until the rise of scientific medicine in the 19th century finally all too slowly eradicated it. It’s hard not to note parallels between what the FLCCC advocates and bloodletting, namely the use of the personal anecdotal experience of physicians as all the evidence necessary to justify the use of a treatment, even though science shows how misleading personal anecdotal experience can be, given human cognitive tendencies such as confirmation bias and selective memory, as well as how regression to the mean can make an ineffective treatments like reiki and homeopathy appear effective.
I swear, I’m rather surprised that the FLCCC had the restraint not to include Ignaz Semmelweis’ observations and the reaction of the 19th century European medical establishment to them on its list. As I mentioned above, that is among the favorite examples cited by quacks.
“Brave mavericks” vs. the scientific consensus
Quacks like the FLCCC love to represent the medical consensus about the diagnosis and treatment of whatever disease is targeted by their quackery as a an inflexible, almost totalitarian, set of edicts that is designed far less to guide physicians in treating patients based on the most comprehensive synthesis of existing scientific and clinical evidence than to “censor,” “silence,” and “cancel” brave “mavericks” like them. Moreover, most medical consensuses express sufficient uncertainty that there is often a fairly wide latitude for doctors to choose different science-based treatments (or combinations of science-based treatments), and doctors as a group tend to be fairly reluctant to label even obvious quackery as quackery. As Dr. Val Jones wrote back in 2008, when it comes to a lot of quackery, most doctors tend to be “shruggies.” They recognize unscientific and pseudoscientific medical practices as bad, but tend to shrug their shoulders about them as in, “What can I do?” As a group we’re way too willing to give each other the benefit of the doubt when it comes to promoting dangerous misinformation, something we’ve complained about here on SBM since the very beginning. As I like to say, if you practice so far outside of the medical consensus as to be accused of quackery and spreading dangerous misinformation, you are very far afield indeed from a rather wide, fairly loose set of generally science-based principles governing the treatment of the disease for which your quackery is intended. This was even more true in the early stages of the pandemic, when much less was known about COVID-19, including what might or might not be effective treatments.
I also like to point out that it is true that medicine and the medical consensus evolve—and that’s a good thing! If medicine didn’t evolve we might still be doing radical mastectomies for breast cancer, for instance. It might not happen as fast as we would like, and certainly the whole process is far messier than might be optimal, but medicine does ultimately evolve to embrace practices and treatments supported by emerging scientific evidence. It is also true that medicine is sometimes slow to change in response to evidence. That slowness does not mean that it is scientifically justified to adopt practices like FLCCC’s early treatment protocols and demonization of COVID-19 vaccination, just as the lack of effective treatments for deadly brain cancers like diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG) is justification supporting the use of Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski’s antineoplaston quackery.
There is also an element of projection in these narratives. Quacks portray the supporters of medical consensuses as unthinkingly dogmatic and riddled with conflicts of interest, both ideological and financial. Those same quacks often profit handsomely from their quackery, with the FLCCC having constructed a whole business model based on their unproven protocols. Indeed, Dr. Kory himself, in a rant about his potential decertification in which he portrays the ABIM as his enemy, rife with financial conflicts of interest and acting to protect rigid medical dogma, basically admitted as much, albeit not directly:
There is only one silver lining here. One – the impending loss of my certifications does not affect me materially because I have a private fee-based practice due to my need for complete autonomy and lack of restrictions in empirically treating the vaccine injured with various repurposed and alternative therapeutics. I thus cannot and will not accept insurance, and secondly, my academic career is over – no longer will I ever enter back into the system of medicine.
See what I mean? Why should Dr. Kory worry about board certification when he’s raking it in hand over fist from his private cash (or credit card) on the barrelhead medical practice. The only thing he needs to practice is a state medical license, and unfortunately that appears not to be in any jeopardy at all, his carefully cultivated narrative of being a “persecuted” visionary notwithstanding. Moreover, Dr. Kory’s conflict of interest is perhaps more blatant than even doctors taking cash to speak for big pharma in that he has not only a financial interest in his quackery, but an emotional one as well in which he views himself as a superhero fighting medical orthodoxy in order to save lives, which is as good a time to remind you of some of the merch he sells in addition to the FLCCC protocol:
Dr. Kory as Superman?
Cringe…
Basically, the FLCCC narrative is the same as that of quacks everywhere, one that portrays the quacks as heroic scientific visionaries persecuted by small-minded doctors riddled with ethical and financial conflicts of evidence because only they are willing to challenge medical and scientific consensus in order to help patients. It’s a classic conspiracy theory narrative, in which nefarious forces and their minions (in this case, doctors who support the scientific consensus and recognize quackery like that of the FLCCC when they see it) are doing evil and trying to “persecute” and “silence” the heroic doctors who have hidden knowledge about what is really going on, all in order to “cancel them.”
Same as it ever was—unfortunately.

“I know you are, but what am I?” Dr. Aseem Malhotra rails against COVID-19 “misinformation”
Projection is a common defense mechanism used by those spreading health misinformation and disinformation. Last week Dr. Aseem Malhotra published part 2 of a plan to cure “the pandemic of misinformation on COVID-19 mRNA vaccines through real evidence-based medicine”. Unsurprisingly, it was chock full of antivaccine misinformation. It’s a real “I know you are, but what am I?” exercise in disinformation.
David Gorsk ion October 3, 2022
Tweet

I must admit that, as the weekend rolled around and I realized that I had to come up with a post for Monday, there were so many things going on last week that it was truly difficult for me to decide what to write about, ranging from COVID-19-related misinformation to topics that I haven’t much written about since the pandemic hit, such as run-of-the-mill cancer quackery. However, as I sat down to write yesterday, one article continued to stand out, even though it was published nearly a week ago. It’s an article by Dr. Aseem Malhotra, which was spread widely on social media as some sort of “slam dunk” evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are awful. I think that what kept drawing me to it is his obvious attempt to reverse the narrative, as evidenced by the title of the article, “Curing the pandemic of misinformation on COVID-19 mRNA vaccines through real evidence-based medicine – Part 2“. (I apparently missed part one in June, which is here. I can only speculate that either I was distracted or the first part didn’t make as big a splash as the second.)
So let’s look at these papers, how they are being used as antivax disinformation, and the numerous errors of fact, omission, and interpretation in them.
Dr. Malhotra “repents”
Last week on Twitter, Dr. Malhotra portrayed his most recent paper as “the most important announcement of my life and career thus far”:
The most important announcement of my life and career so far. Please watch, listen and share with family and friends. I reached these sobering conclusions reluctantly. To read the free full open access peer reviewed medical journal articles visit https://t.co/9IMbUlAAQ9 pic.twitter.com/sYxJJjeh9S
— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) September 28, 2022
I suppose that one could make an argument that writing something that completely destroys what’s left of one’s professional reputation could arguably called “the most important announcement of my life and career thus far”, but I’d add that this importance is actually not a change that is good.
This brings me to another reason that led me to stick with this topic, which was how Dr. Malhotra’s article, based on the video above—which was full of Dr. Malhotra posturing as being so very, very “regretful” in having come to the conclusion that COVID-19 vaccines are “not completely safe”, have “unprecedented harms”, and “need to be suspended until all the raw data has been released for independent analysis” (whatever “independent” means to him)—was being spun by the usual suspects, in particular the “spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration” known as the Brownstone Institute, which didn’t take long after its founding to pivot from promoting a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic in a futile bid to reach “natural herd immunity” and thus get business up and running faster, to spreading the vilest kind of antivax disinformation about COVID-19 vaccines, complete with Holocaust references and calls for “justice” disguised as retribution that echo the “Nuremberg 2.0” trope embraced by COVID-19 minimizers and antivaxxers, an antivax trope that long predates the pandemic. Just this weekend, Daniel Klein posted an article there titled “The Regret, Repentance, and Redemption of Dr. Aseem Malhotra“. Of course, everybody (including science communicators, truth be told) loves a “conversion” story, in which someone who advocated for the position they oppose radically changes his position to agree with them, such as a pro-vaccine advocate becoming an antivaxxer (like Dr. Malhotra) and, admittedly, an antivaxxer who becomes pro-vaccine. It’s therefore no surprise that a Brownstone Institute flack would spin Dr. Malhotra’s papers this way:
Back when the vaccines were being rolled out, the eminent UK cardiologist, Dr. Aseem Malhotra encouraged people to accept them. He was trying to overcome “vaccine hesitancy”—see for example here in November 2020 and here in February 2021.
Personal loss led to a change. Sadly, his father suffered cardiac arrest and died in July 2021. As told here, here, and here, though a cardiologist with an enormous Twitter following, Dr. Malhorta could not explain the post-mortem findings and started down medical-research rabbit holes he’d not gone down before.
Now, Malhotra says the Covid vaxes (or, at least, the mRNA vaxes) are not known to be safe and calls vax mandates and passports “unethical, coercive, and misinformed”—see the video here and here. Vax rollouts, he says, “must stop immediately.”
I note that the citations regarding Dr. Malhotra’s conversion link to known COVID-19 contrarian, minimizer, and antivax sources, such as Ivor Cummins (a.k.a. “The Fat Emperor,” who first came to my attention for promoting the “casedemic” conspiracy theory about COVID-19 PCR testing), Steve Kirsch, and (!) The Epoch Times. This is not a good sign. Nor is it a good sign that his video is being shared widely by people like Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, a man who has become one of the foremost promoters of COVID-19 and antivaccine misinformation since the pandemic began and now resembles “old-school” antivaxxers. Even worse is that Dr. Malhotra’s “scientific review” is now being amplified by the quack tycoon who before the pandemic had already built a net worth north of $100 million selling quackery and antivax propaganda, Joe Mercola, on his Substack, where he repeats the antivaccine tropes in Dr. Malhotra’s papers quite fluidly, given that they’ve all been parroted before on his website and he knows them well.
This should tell you nearly all of what you need to know about Dr. Malhotra’s “two-part scientific review,” not that that will stop me from explaining in detail why this “review” is a fake scientific review weaponized as disinformation.
To Dr. Malhotra’s credit, it is true that back in 2020 he was, in fact, strongly advocating for COVID-19 vaccines, for example, in November 2020, just as the Pfizer vaccine was coming up for consideration by the FDA for an emergency use authorization (EUA) and by the regulatory authorities in the UK for use there:
Vaccines are the safest of ALL drugs. Far safer than any other drug people are taking on a regular including most people over 50 taking at least one prescription. The vaccine safety concerns are totally disproportionate to the reality https://t.co/XI4Stmybug
— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) November 25, 2020
Which was definitely correct, as was this, in February 2021:
'We need to understand where this vaccine hesitancy is coming from.'@DrAseemMalhotra explains that 'rational concerns' need to be understood 'in order to move forward in a better way.'
He says 'trust needs to be restored' and that 'vaccines by far are the safest.' pic.twitter.com/3gU6Z54SLU
— Good Morning Britain (@GMB) February 5, 2021
Now he’s concluding in his papers that the vaccine is more dangerous than the disease, first in a less concrete statement made in June, in which he echoes a common antivax fallacy known as the “appeal to informed consent“, which I now like to refer to as the appeal to “misinformed refusal“, a tactic used by antivaxxers going back to before I even started paying attention to the antivaccine movement:
It cannot be said that the consent to receive these agents was fully informed, as is required ethically and legally. A pause and reappraisal of global vaccination policies for COVID-19 is long overdue.
Sound familiar? To reiterate, it’s an obvious appeal to what I used to call “misinformed consent” but now refer to it by what I consider to be a more accurate term, “misinformed refusal.”
Then, last week, Dr. Malhotra wrote:
There is a strong scientific, ethical and moral case to be made that the current COVID vaccine administration must stop until all the raw data has been subjected to fully independent scrutiny. Looking to the future the medical and public health professions must recognise these failings and eschew the tainted dollar of the medical-industrial complex. It will take a lot of time and effort to rebuild trust in these institutions, but the health – of both humanity and the medical profession – depends on it.
This is a similar tact to the one taken by Peter Doshi, who has since February 2021 (when he originated the myth that the clinical trials really only showed the mRNA vaccines to have been 19% effective, which has since evolved into myth that they were only 12% effective) has been demanding to see the “original data” for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccine trials, up to the point last month in which he published an antivax “reanalysis” of the available data from the trials to try to paint an extremely misleading picture of the vaccine being more harmful than COVID-19.
Then there’s the issue of the journal in which these two articles were published, The Journal of Insulin Resistance, which is described as:
The Journal of Insulin Resistance is a peer-reviewed, clinically oriented open access journal covering advances in disorders related to insulin resistance. Articles will focus on pathophysiology, prevention, management and advancing therapy for different patient populations with insulin resistance and related disorders, including obesity, metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, non-alcoholic steato-hepatitis, Alzheimer’s dementia, sexual dysfunction, amongst others.
The journal will feature original research with a broad biomedical approach from bench to bedside, including basic research and clinical case studies, as well as review articles and editorials. Content will be of interest to an academic and clinician-based audience i.e., medical practitioners, clinical educators, dietitians, nutritionists, nurse practitioners, pharmacists, and other health care professionals. Submissions in English (full article) will be considered for publication.
Was there anything about immunology, infectious disease, coronaviruses, public health, or anything similar? Funny, but I must have missed it. In fact, as Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz has pointed out, very little has been published in this “journal” since 2016, and at least half of it was published by members of the editorial board, all of which raises red flags for this being an ideology journal disguised as a medical journal:
4/n Of the 31 non-correction papers published, by my count 16 are authored by editors of the journal, including the new opinion piece(s) by Dr. Malhotra. The journal also has not published an issue since 2019.
That is…unusual, to say the least pic.twitter.com/QUdIwDkl4K
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) September 27, 2022
Finally, there’s Dr. Aseem Malhotra himself. Although he didn’t go full antivax until relatively recently, Dr. Malhotra was never what one could reasonably describe as a defender of science-based medicine. He has long promoted dietary advice that was…debatable…having published The Pioppi Diet, a book that “earned” the “honor” of being named one of “Top 5 worst celeb diets to avoid in 2018” by the British Dietetic Association, which noted how the diet was patterned after the Mediterranean diet but with a low carb agenda. In essence, the Pioppi diet was a tarted-up version of the Mediterranean diet that “recommends a higher fat diet than the traditional Mediterranean one” and notes that “adherents are encouraged to eat lots of vegetables, nuts, legumes, and fish and discouraged from eating red meat, starchy carbs, and sweetened treats.” It also encourages 24-hour fasting. Dr. Malhotra has also very much been in the anti-processed sugar camp, having characterized sugar as “enemy number one in the Western diet“. He has also channeled Peter Gøtzsche in arguing that modern medicine does more harm than good treating chronic conditions with medications and claiming that “too much medicine can kill you“. Of course, as I’ve said before, it is not in itself unreasonable to criticize too much medical intervention, particularly medical intervention of questionable value, but to me a brief perusal of Dr. Malhotra’s oeuvre gave off a seriously disturbing vibe that medicine doesn’t do any good for chronic illnesses. Unsurprisingly, he is also a statin denialist, even having gone so far as to suggest that stopping statins might save more lives and that statins probably don’t benefit anyone.
Consistent with this bent, Dr. Malhotra made the news early in the pandemic when he attacked Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust for accepting a gift of 1,500 Krispy Kreme doughnuts sent to the staff as a gift for their work in dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK. Also consistent with his tendency to ascribe super immune-producing effects to diet alone, later in 2020 Dr. Malhotra published a book titled The 21-Day Immunity Plan: How to Rapidly Improve Your Metabolic Health and Resilience to Fight Infection, in which he “excoriated the mainstream media for their failure to notice the role nutrition has in the outcome of Covid-19 cases. Obesity, diabetes, and other metabolic diseases led to increased hospitalization rates, overwhelming the NHS.” Basically, his claim was that it is possible to rapidly—in 21 days!—reverse the sorts of metabolic disorders (e.g., type II diabetes and obesity) that render large swaths of the population particularly vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19. At the time, I was…skeptical. Given that background, it really shouldn’t be that big surprise that Dr. Malhotra’s gone antivax, particularly given statements like this:
Dr. Aseem Malhotra : The best vaccine against Coronavirus is optimising metabolic health https://t.co/mWbew8aaER
— Dr. Jason Fung (@drjasonfung) August 28, 2020
I will cut Dr. Malhotra a little slack given that when his book was published there were as yet no COVID-19 vaccines available. But just a little. Also, I’ve observed over the years that there’s a strong attraction to antivax pseudoscience among people who promote overblown claims for what diet can do for your health.
“I know you are, but what am I?” (Round One)
As I said at the beginning, one of the favorite tactics of quacks, cranks, and antivaxxers is projection: To accuse their critics of what they themselves are guilty of, and both of Dr. Malhotra’s articles are prime examples of this tactic, starting right from the title, in which he claims the mantle of evidence-based medicine for himself against what he characterizes as “misinformation” coming from health authorities and the conventional press. Interestingly, Dr. Malhotra barely uses the word “misinformation” in his first article, but uses it much more frequently in his second article, as though he were doubling down on his first assertion. I was going to leave the first article mostly alone, except that it contains an explanation of what might have pushed Dr. Malhotra over from just questionable on COVID-19 and vaccines to full antivax.
The articles are both odd ducks, too, not being written in a true “scientific review article” format. The first review is billed as a “narrative review of the evidence from randomised trials and real world data of the COVID mRNA products with special emphasis on BionTech/Pfizer vaccine”, while the second review is claimed to be a “narrative review of both current and historical driving factors that underpin the pandemic of medical misinformation”. Of course, given that Dr. Malhotra is on the editorial board of this faux journal, it’s unlikely that either of his “review articles” underwent anything resembling actual peer review. In reality, these articles are no more than opinion pieces representing Dr. Malhotra’s views, backed up by cherry-picked low-quality evidence.
It is interesting to note that in the first article, Dr. Malhotra describes why he changed his mind about COVID-19 vaccines. First, he burnishes his seeming pro-vaccine credentials by noting that he was one of the first to get the Pfizer vaccine at the end of January 2021. (By comparison, I leapt at the chance to get the Pfizer vaccine and actually got my first dose in mid-December 2020), going on to write:
Although I knew my individual risk was small from COVID-19 at age 43 with optimal metabolic health, the main reason I took the jab was to prevent transmission of the virus to my vulnerable patients. During early 2021, I was both surprised and concerned by a number of my vaccine-hesitant patients and people in my social network who were asking me to comment on what I regarded at the time as merely ‘anti-vax’ propaganda.
I was asked to appear on Good Morning Britain after a previously vaccine-hesitant film director Gurinder Chadha, Order of the British Empire (OBE), who was also interviewed, explained that I convinced her to take the jab.
This was all well and good, but then:
But a very unexpected and extremely harrowing personal tragedy was to happen a few months later that would be the start of my own journey into what would ultimately prove to be a revelatory and eye-opening experience so profound that after six months of critically appraising the data myself, speaking to eminent scientists involved in COVID-19 research, vaccine safety and development, and two investigative medical journalists, I have slowly and reluctantly concluded that contrary to my own initial dogmatic beliefs, Pfizer’s mRNA vaccine is far from being as safe and effective as we first thought. This critical appraisal is based upon the analytical framework for practicing and teaching evidence-based medicine, specifically utilising individual clinical expertise and/or experience with use of the best available evidence and taking into consideration patient preferences and values.
Unfortunately, personal tragedy appears to have been the impetus that led Dr. Malhotra (farther) astray:
On 26 July 2021, my father, Dr Kailash Chand OBE, former deputy chair of the British Medical Association (BMA) and its honorary vice president (who had also taken both doses of the Pfizer mRNA vaccine six months earlier) suffered a cardiac arrest at home after experiencing chest pain. A subsequent inquiry revealed that a significant ambulance delay likely contributed to his death.3 But his post-mortem findings are what I found particularly shocking and inexplicable. Two of his three major arteries had severe blockages: 90% blockage in his left anterior descending artery and a 75% blockage in his right coronary. Given that he was an extremely fit and active 73-year-old man, having walked an average of 10–15 000 steps/day during the whole of lockdown, this was a shock to everyone who knew him, but most of all to me. I knew his medical history and lifestyle habits in great detail. My father who had been a keen sportsman all his life, was fitter than the overwhelming majority of men his age. Since the previous heart scans (a few years earlier, which had revealed no significant problems with perfect blood flow throughout his arteries and only mild furring), he had quit sugar, lost belly fat, reduced the dose of his blood pressure pills, started regular meditation, reversed his prediabetes and even massively dropped his blood triglycerides, significantly improving his cholesterol profile.
Dr. Malhotra has my sympathy for losing a parent, but not so much that I won’t push back against his story as related. I note that it is indeed nearly always a major blow when a parent dies, even more so when that parent is relatively young (and early 70s these days is relatively young) and was thought to be in “perfect” health. The natural reaction is to look for reasons why he died so suddenly. Given Dr. Malhotra’s leaning in terms of medicine, it’s not surprising that he soon landed on vaccines as a potential cause, just as parents who lose a child to sudden infant death syndrome all too frequently do:
I couldn’t explain his post-mortem findings, especially as there was no evidence of an actual heart attack but with severe blockages. This was precisely my own special area of research. That is, how to delay progression of heart disease and even potentially reverse it. In fact, in my own clinic, I successfully prescribe a lifestyle protocol to my patients on the best available evidence on how to achieve this. I’ve even co-authored a high-impact peer-reviewed paper with two internationally reputed cardiologists (both editors of medical journals) on shifting the paradigm on how to most effectively prevent heart disease through lifestyle changes.4 We emphasised the fact that coronary artery disease is a chronic inflammatory condition that is exacerbated by insulin resistance. Then, in November 2021, I was made aware of a peer-reviewed abstract published in Circulation, with concerning findings. In over 500 middle-aged patients under regular follow up, using a predictive score model based on inflammatory markers that are strongly correlated with risk of heart attack, the mRNA vaccine was associated with significantly increasing the risk of a coronary event within five years from 11% pre-mRNA vaccine to 25% 2–10 weeks post mRNA vaccine. An early and relevant criticism of the validity of the findings was that there was no control group, but nevertheless, even if partially correct, that would mean that there would be a large acceleration in progression of coronary artery disease, and more importantly heart attack risk, within months of taking the jab.5 I wondered whether my father’s Pfizer vaccination, which he received six months earlier, could have contributed to his unexplained premature death and so I began to critically appraise the data.
One can’t help but note that Dr. Chand died six months after he had received the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. Similarly, one also can’t help but note that one can have significant underlying heart disease and still appear to be just fine—fit, even!—until the heart disease progresses to a level where compensatory mechanisms can no longer prevent complications. I can see how such a death so close to home could shake Dr. Malhotra’s belief system of diet and lifestyle über alles as panaceas for good health. After all, if his father, who led the “right lifestyle” and walked 10,000-15,000 steps a day could succumb to coronary artery disease, then perhaps Dr. Malhotra’s faith in diet and exercise alone as panaceas against heart disease were misplaced or, at the very least, excessive.
As often is the case with those who believe in something very strongly, rather than question his existing belief systems, Dr. Malhotra appears to have started looking for “other” causes for his father’s sudden death. I can only speculate, but, given his apparent belief in diet as the be-all and end-all of cardiovascular (and general) health, my guess is that in his grief he was even more susceptible than he might have been to the blandishments of the antivaccine movement and that susceptibility ultimately led to his going down the rabbit hole of antivaccine misinformation and conspiracy theories bolstered by bad science. I will note that the reference to which he refers was an abstract of a particularly useless study by a physician associated with Goop, who used an unvalidated test for “inflammatory markers” after vaccination that showed nothing, as described by pediatric cardiologist Dr. Frank Han here and myself elsewhere. Citing very weak science is not a good look for a someone proclaiming himself as pushing back against “misinformation” promoted by the medical profession and claiming the mantle of evidence-based medicine. Also, as Dr. Han has pointed out, atherosclerosis takes years, not months, to develop. As someone who early in his career, before becoming interested in cancer, studied vascular smooth muscle cells and their role in atherosclerosis and restenosis after coronary angioplasty, I will reemphasize that point.
Later in the same article, Dr. Malhotra cites four cardiac arrests observed in the Pfizer trial. After admitting that these “figures were small in absolute terms and did not reach statistical significance in the trial, suggesting that it may just be coincidence”, he nonetheless claims that “without further studies it was not possible to rule out this being a genuinely causal relationship (especially without access to the raw data), in which case it could have the effect of causing a surge in cardiac arrests once the vaccine was rolled out to tens of millions of people across the globe”. While that is true enough, to conclude that some obvious adverse event due to the vaccines has been missed for nearly two years one has to ignore all the safety studies carried out since first millions, then tens of millions, then hundreds of millions, and then billions of doses of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines were administered throughout the world.
As just a taste of these data, it’s noted that the UK has not noted an increase in mortality from ischemic heart disease since the vaccines rolled out:
Data from ICU admission also correlates. H/t @Poppyjuice pic.twitter.com/oEriO6ff0K
— PaedsHaemDoc 🗿 (@dr_barrett) September 26, 2022
Dr. Malhotra then goes on to cite a number of low quality sources. Consistent with this, Dr. Malhotra uses a number of common antivax techniques to make COVID-19 vaccines look as ineffective and risky as possible. For example, echoing the “number needed to treat” (NNT), a frequent measure of how many people need to be treated to prevent a single adverse event or death, Dr. Malhotra cites the “number needed to vaccinate” to prevent one death due to COVID-19 in various age groups, which he estimates to be 10,000 for people in their 40s. However, the source he cites is not even a scientific article but a blog post, as Meyerowitz-Katz notes:
7/n This is then followed by a complete misrepresentation of absolute vs relative risks for vaccines. I've explained why this is inappropriate before https://t.co/9rv55Eaheh pic.twitter.com/nlCaqRmrOm
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) September 27, 2022
One also notes that vaccines by their very nature necessitate vaccinating a relatively large number of people in order to avoid one death from the disease vaccinated against:
this by itself is not a reason to protest the MMR, DTaP, and other classical childhood vaccines. A door is not too small only because you looked at it side-on.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 27, 2022
That is, of course, why the safety bar is so much higher for vaccines than other medications. They are administered to a presumably healthy population in order to prevent an infectious disease, not to a population ill with a disease in order to treat that disease.
Similarly, emphasizing absolute versus relative risk is another favorite tactic of those seeking to downplay the benefits of vaccinating. Come to think of it, emphasizing death as the only endpoint worth looking at, rather than considering severe non-death adverse outcomes, is another favorite tactic of antivaxxers. We do, after all, vaccinate to prevent not just death, but disease and serious complications. Another claim that he makes is that we should look at all-cause mortality after vaccination but are not doing that. Of course, we actually are, and the UK (where Dr. Malhotra is based) has those data, as noted by Vicki Male:
You've hit on a point that I meant to mention, but forgot about. We do have all-cause death statistics for vaccinated vs unvaccinated in the UK. Unvaccinated people are more likely to die of all causes (Table 1).https://t.co/x50AGg9FWQ
— Viki Male (@VikiLovesFACS) September 26, 2022
Dr. Malhotra also cites Maryanne Demasi, claiming that she had shown that the original mRNA vaccine trials had failed to account for serious harms. (Unsurprisingly, Demasi now writes for the Brownstone Institute, which is how I remembered who she was, even though I don’t recall having written about her before.) He exaggerates the risk of myocarditis relative to the potential benefit of the vaccine in young adults and children, a topic that we’ve covered a number of times here, and cites reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS), exhibiting a lack of understanding of how VAERS works and acting as though all the reports were caused by the vaccines. Hilariously, he tries to make his spin seem more credible by noting that “knowingly filing a false VAERS report is a violation of Federal law punishable by fine and imprisonment”. (So what?) He then misrepresents a paper in Scientific Reports as having been published in Nature—Scientific Reports is Nature Publishing Group’s open access journal and nowhere near as prestigious as Nature itself—claiming an increase in cardiac deaths due to the rollout of the vaccines. If I give him the benefit of the doubt, this was poor scholarship. If I don’t, this is using an antivaccine technique in which any article published in a Nature Publishing Group journal, no matter how lowly, is misrepresented as having been published in Nature.
The misrepresentation of the journal aside, this was a flawed and highly problematic study, as described here. Based on a cherry picked citing of low-quality data, Dr. Malhotra concludes that “it remains a real possibility that my father’s sudden cardiac death was related to the vaccine” and a “pause and reappraisal of vaccination Policies for COVID-19 is long overdue”.
“I know you are, but what am I?” (Round Two)
Dr. Malhotra’s second article is of more interest to me, because in it he tries to flip the script and accuse those fighting misinformation of actually spreading it. Indeed, that’s the message he starts his article with, accusing health authorities of horrific missteps:
What has become clear with regard to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) vaccines is that we have a pandemic of misinformed doctors and a misinformed and unwittingly harmed public. Coercively mandating these COVID-19 vaccinations (most certainly not an evidence-based policy) has been a particularly egregious mis-step, especially in the light of clear indicators suggesting that the use of these pharmaceutical interventions – especially in younger age groups – should have been suspended. Such policies continue to undermine the principles of ethical evidence-based medical practice and informed consent, to the detriment of optimising patient outcomes.
He cites a 2017 Perspective paper by John Ioannidis that, in retrospect after Prof. Ioannidis’ plunge from grace with respect to evidence-based medicine and his abuse of his position to get very low quality ideology-driven papers published since the pandemic hit, seems less impressive now than I might have considered it five years ago.
Ironically, the drivers and “sins” that lead to misinformation spreading as described by Prof. Ioannidis and cited by Dr. Malhotra now are not inaccurate.
First the drivers:
    • Much published medical research is not reliable or is of uncertain reliability, offers no benefit to patients or is not useful for decision makers;
    • Most healthcare professionals are not aware of this problem;
    • Even if they are aware of this problem, most healthcare professionals lack the skills necessary to evaluate the reliability and usefulness of medical evidence; and
    • Patients and families frequently lack relevant, accurate medical evidence and skilled guidance at the time of medical decision making.
And the “sins,” from a book Better Doctors, Better Patients, Better Decisions, edited by Gerd Gigerenzer and J.A. Muir Gray:
    • Biased funding of research (that’s research that’s funded because it’s likely to be profitable, not beneficial for patients)
    • Biased reporting in medical journals
    • Biased reporting in the media
    • Biased patient pamphlets
    • Commercial conflicts of interest
    • Defensive medicine
    • An inability of doctors to understand and communicate health statistics
Unfortunately, in the age of the pandemic, most of these problems just don’t apply in the way that Dr. Malhotra thinks that they do. For instance, COVID-19 cranks (like Dr. Malhotra) take advantage of the low quality and reliability of a lot of medical research to contribute even more to that low reliability by publishing propaganda in journals like The Journal of Insulin Resistance. Indeed, I once called this phenomenon scientific review articles weaponized as disinformation, a label that describes Dr. Malhotra’s two part “narrative review” quite well.
Looking back at both articles, it’s clear to me that the first article was intended to sow doubt about COVID-19 vaccines through the use of a compelling anecdote about his father followed by cherry-picked data. As much as I might feel sorry for Dr. Malhotra because of his loss, I cannot allow that feeling to prevent my directly addressing his misuse of the anecdote of his father’s death to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines. The second article is more of a generalized antivaccine rant that uses tried and untrue techniques that try to paint big pharma and government regulatory entities as so completely corrupt (as well as ideology- and profit-driven) that they ignore evidence of harm.
He even cites common antivax tropes, such as the claim that the FDA wanted 55 years to release the data on the Pfizer clinical trial of its vaccines:
It is against this backdrop that transparency advocates sued the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to gain access to the data upon which the Pfizer (BNT162b2) vaccine was granted emergency use authorisation.31 The FDA wanted a US Federal court judge to allow the agency 55 years to release this data. 32 Why would the FDA – ‘which is responsible for the oversight of more than $2.7 trillion in consumption of food, medical products, and tobacco’33 – do this? Secrecy should never surround any public health intervention.
In fact, the reason why the FDA estimated that it would take from 55-75 years to release all the requested documents is not due to nefarious intent, but rather because of the sheer mass of documents requested (which require redaction of patient-identifiable information, as well as business and trade secrets) and the resources that it has available for FOIA requests. Here’s a hint: When you’re recycling antivax talking points promoted by, for example, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., you might want to rethink what has led you to this point.
Dr. Malhotra then goes on to rail against what he sees as the causes of this supposed debacle of COVID-19 vaccines: financial interests of big pharma, “biased” reporting, and, of course, “censorship” of debate. He even approvingly cites Dr. Robert Malone. I kid you not:
The BBC, though seemingly not directly influenced by industry interests, has traditionally been seen by some as the UK’s most trusted media source. Its coverage of issues surrounding COVID-19 has in my view (possibly through additional government pressure) been extremely poor and – specifically on issues surrounding the vaccine – grossly negligent. During a recent report on tennis player Novak Djokovic explaining his decision to not take the vaccine until he has more information on its benefits and harms, a reporter asked the question ‘how much more information does he need?’. The reporter failed to mention the fact that Djokovic has had COVID-19 and that evidence suggests that natural immunity offers significant protection against reinfection and severe disease, and that systemic side effects are almost threefold more likely in those with natural immunity who subsequently get vaccinated. Furthermore, the BBC falsely framed a guest on popular podcast host Joe Rogan, Dr Robert Malone, as a ‘known anti-vaxxer, who is against vaccinating kids’, failing to mention that Dr Malone is a co-inventor of the very technology that led to the vaccine, has spent 20 years in vaccine development at US government level and was one the first to actually receive two shots of the Moderna jab. The BBC also strangely failed to cover perhaps one of the most significant stories of the pandemic published in one of the most respected and influential medical journals in the world: An investigation by the BMJ revealed evidence of poor practices at a contract research company involved in Pfizer’s pivotal COVID-19 vaccine trial. A regional director employed at one of the trial sites in Texas, US, documented evidence that Pfizer falsified data, unblinded patients, employed inadequately controlled vaccinators and was slow to follow up on adverse events. The very same day that she emailed her complaint to the FDA she was fired from her position. 51 She subsequently commenced litigation under whistle-blower legislation for fraud against Pfizer on behalf of the American Government (and the people of the US). Pfizer’s motion to dismiss the case (which apparently did not sway the judge) was based on the fact that the FDA had not acted on her (or any other) complaints, hence the allegations were not material to the Government.
I would respond that “natural immunity” isn’t nearly the magical mystical force that Dr. Malhotra represents it to be. After all, if it were, there wouldn’t be claims that you could be reinfected within three weeks, and the Delta wave wouldn’t have resulted in so many reinfections of people who had had the original strain, nor would the Omicron wave have resulted in so many reinfections of people who had had Delta or the original strain. Second, Dr. Malone is antivax, period. He’s even starting to embrace more “traditional” pre-pandemic antivax views. The BBC’s characterization of him was accurate. Finally, that story cited by Dr. Malhotra was a shoddy piece of “investigative journalism” by conspiracy theorist Paul Thacker, whose many shortcomings I have discussed in depth more than once.
And, of course, Dr. Malhotra blames social media platforms for spreading “misinformation”:
Social media platforms continue to be guilty of spreading misinformation. Their business model that focusses on increasing engagement at any cost makes society increasingly lose access to the truth and worsens our capacity for empathy as individuals, sowing even greater division and hostility. The so-called ‘fact checkers’ have censored anything that challenges the prevailing mainstream narrative (the establishment is trustworthy, and the vaccines are completely safe). They even labelled the BMJ‘s investigation into potential fraud in Pfizer’s pivotal trial as misinformation and stopped users sharing the story on their platform. A letter from the journal’s current and former editor in chief to Mark Zuckerberg calls into question the integrity of Facebook’s fact checkers:
[R]ather than investing a proportion of Meta’s substantial profits to help ensure the accuracy of medical information shared through social media, you apparently delegated responsibility to people incompetent in carrying out this crucial task.53 (p. 1)
Again, Paul Thacker’s “investigation” was trash, as I discussed on SBM. Moreover, as I wrote elsewhere, the editors of The BMJ did not exactly cover themselves in glory when they wrote that open letter, given that they basically did not refute any of the fact checking that showed quite clearly how shoddily-reported Thacker’s “bombshell” was.
Dr. Malhotra also can’t help but ride his favorite hobby horse, his claim that you can optimize your “metabolic health” in 21 days to make yourself magically immune to severe complications from COVID-19:
The government and medical authorities should have made it a priority to emphasise the importance of eliminating ultra-processed foods and low-quality carbohydrates to reduce risk. They could have made the public aware that reversal of metabolic syndrome has been shown to occur in up to 50% of patients – independent of weight loss – within four weeks of dietary changes alone.61
Of course, Dr. Malhotra has never been able to show anything resembling robust data that this reversal decreases these patients’ risk of severe disease and death from COVID-19. Don’t get me wrong; no one is arguing that weight loss and diet changes don’t improve health or decrease the risk of chronic diseases. What I question is Dr. Malhotra’s claims that “metabolic optimization” is some sort of magic bullet against COVID-19, to the point where, in the middle of a pandemic, the government should have made it a priority over measures designed to slow the spread of the disease and, after vaccines were made available, to get as many people vaccinated as possible.
Certainly, nothing Dr. Malhotra has written justifies this hyperbole:
The profession must explain that optimising metabolic health will give patients the best chance for ensuring they are not just resilient to infection but reducing their risk of chronic disease including heart disease, cancer and dementia.
The time has come to stop misleading evidence flowing downstream into media reporting and clinical decision making and resulting in unethical and unscientific policy decisions. It’s time for real evidence-based medicine (Box 464).
The irony is, of course, that Dr. Malhotra claims the mantle of “real evidence-based medicine”, even as he cites low quality studies and invokes conspiracy theories to imply that COVID-19 vaccines likely do more harm than good and demand access to the full raw data from the Pfizer and Moderna clinical trials, while ignoring all the real-world evidence evaluating safety and efficacy since. I’ll repeat a simple observation and conclusion that I made four weeks ago. It’s been nearly two years since the randomized clinical trial (RCT) results for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines were first reported. Both of these trials involved only ~43K and ~30K participants, respectively. Even large randomized clinical trials used to approve drugs and vaccines miss less common adverse events (AEs), including serious AEs (SAEs). That’s why we do post-marketing surveillance studies, particularly for vaccines. Less common AEs sometimes don’t show up until after a vaccine is rolled out and distribution goes from a population of tens of thousands to administration to millions, tens of millions, hundreds of millions, and even billions, as has happened with the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 mRNA vaccines over the last many months.
In other words, if you are truly interested in the actual real-world safety and efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines right here, right now, in October 2022, then the original RCT data are not the best data to use to estimate rates of adverse events. After all, nearly 13 billion doses of all the COVID-19 vaccines have been administered since then, and numerous countries have safety and efficacy data. That’s why I consider Dr. Malhotra’s call for the raw data at the end to be arrogant and performative:
We must use this as an opportunity to transform the system to produce better doctors, better decision making, healthier patients and restore trust in medicine and public health. Until all the raw data on the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines have been independently analysed, any claims purporting that they confer a net benefit to humankind cannot be considered to be evidence-based.
First off, what does Dr. Malhotra mean by an “independent” analysis? Who would qualify? Which investigators or organizations would he trust as sufficiently “independent” that they would not be unduly influenced by the nefarious machinations of big pharma? More importantly, though, as I’ve said before, there’s one reason, and one reason only, that scientists might want a “reanalysis” of data from a completed and long ago published clinical trial, and that’s if they suspect some sort of serious flaw in the RCT design or how the RCT was carried out. They might even suspect outright fraud. Clearly, that’s what Dr. Malhotra is implying, joining Peter Doshi in his conspiracy mongering. Let’s just put it this way. Even if there were serious problems with the original clinical trials that would call their results into question (not likely, but not impossible), they are almost irrelevant now for the determination of whether the vaccines are safe and effective in October 2022, particularly given the rise of the Delta and now Omicron variants, which did not exist in the summer and fall of 2020, when the clinical trials of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines were being carried out.
Dr. Malhotra’s article is projection, pure and simple, or, as I put it: “I know you are, but what am I?” He’s accusing conventional medical authorities, big pharma, and social media companies of spreading medical misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines by using the very techniques of misinformation that he claims to decry, such as cherry-picked studies and conspiracy theories, to do it. I know you are, but what am I, indeed.

The Aseem Malhotra lecture isn’t what you think it is
In November 2022, Dr. Aseem Malhotra gave a lecture that was more about advancing a narrative than explaining the science.
Frank Han on December 3, 2022
Link

For those audience members unfamiliar with Dr. Aseem Malhotra (who has been discussed previously on SBM, he is a British cardiologist who is currently conducting a campaign with like-minded people to halt the administration of COVID-19 vaccines in England and end all British COVID vaccination mandates. Once upon a time, he did support COVID immunization, but his views completely turned around once his father died of an apparent cardiac arrest at home. Though the cardiac arrest was compounded by an ambulance delay, Dr. Malhotra now describes this event as a vaccine injury. He is sincerely convinced that mRNA immunization has brought much more cardiac harm to the population than is being discussed in public, and that this harm was what killed his father. He is currently spending most of his publicly visible time asking for all COVID immunization to be halted. As a professional with similar training, I want to emphasize that the normal procedure for bringing forth a new biologic mechanism, practice guideline, or surgical technique, is to first conduct pre-clinical experiments to determine whether your idea is correct, then gradually move towards human clinical trials. For example, the surgical techniques for heart surgery on babies evolved over time to become the extremely safe techniques that are in use today in modern surgical suites. At multiple levels, surgeons and cardiologists argued over the best thing to do, and patients are safer during congenital heart surgery because of these debates. Russell Blalock, Helen Taussig, and Vivien Thomas were genuine pioneers in my field who helped invent the very first pediatric heart surgery (against steep opposition and dogma).
Very similar procedures have been followed for the mRNA immunizations. Multiple universities and research teams have been studying their safety and effectiveness since their release and have produced the necessary studies to substantiate their hypotheses. Those same universities and teams have used the same research and techniques to validate the major side effects. Dr. Malhotra, during his public appearances, has repeatedly claimed that people were experiencing unreported, deadly or nearly deadly cardiac events after mRNA immunization. His secondary claim is that there has not been sufficient research conducted specifically on this issue. Both of his core points are presented in the near absence of adequate evidence we normally expect from a practicing cardiologist. As of the writing of this article, he has made no verifiable efforts to corral together the research group, research funding, or multi-center collaboration to produce the basic science, clinical science, or epidemiological research to show that his beliefs are backed with peer-reviewed evidence (which is what the rest of us have done).
The lecture he delivered to the Friends House in Euston in November 2022 illustrates most of his major talking points. He uses a tactic widely employed by the antivax community, which is to weave in kernels of truth with outright falsehoods, which makes the task of deciphering his lecture for the non-medically trained reader much more difficult. His core motivation, in his own words, is to campaign against all forms of mRNA immunization after the death of his father, and he appears to be on a worldwide tour trying to share his point of view. The secondary message in his lecture revolves around descriptions of physician bias and his perceived lack of ability of physicians to review the medical literature.
Below is a list of 20 of his main talking points, and a discussion of the issues with his claims.
Claim 1: There is excessive physician bias due to pharmaceutical funding
Pharmaceutical companies are in one sense, a necessary evil in the medical ecosystem. The most basic reason for this is time. If physicians only saw patients, they can’t invent medications. Somebody’s got to do it. Physicians need to be seeing and diagnosing patients, but while some physicians (MD-PhD for example) are capable of doing new drug research, the research is extremely time intensive and not all physicians have all the skills or time necessary to discover a new antibody or new medication. Do some physicians interact with pharmaceutical representatives? Sure, and I will freely mention that cardiology training programs often have associations with companies that provide the devices or medicines prescribed by cardiologists. To address this widely recognized potential for conflicts of interest (COI), academic medical centers have several levels of safeguards to limit any undue influence. For example, Vanderbilt University lists how to determine if an employee has a conflict of interest and how to report it to the appropriate party, with equivalent systems throughout medical training and practice. Punishments in academic settings for failing to disclose such conflicts are actually quite severe. Also, patients in both England and the United States have the ability to search online for a particular physician, PA, or advance practice nurse and identify any reported financial conflicts of interest prior to any appointment. For British citizens, this website is helpful, and this is the equivalent for Americans. If you don’t like the conflicts of interest you are seeing, you can just walk away, and you can ask for a cheaper alternative if you think the medicine recommended is too expensive. I’ll freely disclose my financial conflicts of interest – a few restaurant meals from cardiology fellowship training days. I still don’t prescribe the medicines sold by the companies that provided the meals to myself and my fellow trainees because I don’t see the conditions those medications were used for. A blanket statement that “too many” or “all” physicians have an important COI is just inaccurate. It would be quite dangerous, for example, to refuse care for life-threatening heart failure because of a belief that too many hospital cardiologists are tainted by pharmaceutical funding. Generalizing Dr. Malhotra’s claim to this situation would literally put someone’s life in danger. Solution? I don’t actually know how to permanently stop pharmaceutical funding. One of the root causes here is that companies, led by CEOs, are always looking to profit.
Claim 2: Dr. John Ioannidis deserves the same acclaim as professor Stephen Hawking
Stephen Hawking, may he rest in peace, was a legend of an astrophysicist who studied in England. He is also partially famous because of his amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, which forced him to communicate with a machine. He gave us many breakthroughs in the world of astrophysics, and one of the behaviors of black holes is named after him (Hawking radiation).
John Ioannidis is a physician-scientist who graduated from a Greek medical school, whose specialty currently is data-based analysis of medical research (discussed many times on SBM). A lot of his claim to fame arose from his essay “Why most published research findings are false” (addressed by Dr. Novella here), which delineates how researchers from a wide spectrum of scientific disciplines aren’t doing all they could to design the most rigorous experiments. It was actually very beneficial for him to point out our fields’ intellectual blind spots and conflicts with the pharmaceutical industry. Unfortunately, when COVID came along his focus and opinions took a turn. He tried to criticize graduate student Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz in public without trying to address the substance of Meyerowitz-Katz’ arguments, and instead reverted to a variety of ad hominem attacks (including saying it is bad thing that a graduate student hasn’t published a similar volume of papers as Dr. Ioannidis). He underestimated the COVID infection fatality rate even early in the pandemic by trying to slip in non-representative samples. And then there was the Kardashian index paper. He has at this point, made multiple factual errors in his reporting of the COVID pandemic while failing to either realize or acknowledge he has done so. One of the occupational hazards of academic research is being wrong, but usually academic staff admit it. Doubling down is not a particularly ethical plan of action.
Professor Hawking on the other hand left a legacy of trying to help more graduate students choose physics. He worked very hard to advance his field. He did not let his disability degrade his will to survive. He has publicly admitted one of his mistakes and owned up to it.
Overall, conflating these two scholars is questionable at best, particularly given their very different fields of expertise, different attitudes towards trainees, and different attitudes towards changing direction once the empirical evidence changes.
Claim 3: Pharmaceutical companies engage in misconduct
This is something antivax people and provax people could get together on and jointly support – I don’t mind if the pharmaceutical companies get harsher penalties for getting things wrong (and especially when they are outright dishonest). Physicians get as frustrated as anyone else when things like the Vioxx scandal happen. However, it is not advisable to live in paranoia and think every medicine available is a pharma scandal just waiting to be discovered. Big pharma behaving badly does not mean all of their products are inherently harmful.
Claim 4: There is excessive mortality due to side effects of medications
A form of iatrogenic harm (caused by the treatment rather than the disease), this is a genuine problem in medicine and the scale/scope of the problem is an area of active debate. Some things in medicine, like the physics of the heart, are not up for debate; medication side effects should be researched and discussed. It is not accurate to imply that physicians are letting this issue fall by the wayside and actively ignore it. Physicians are trained to try and sort out side effects when starting medications, and recruit the assistance of the pharmacist when necessary to try to reduce the harms of individual and combined medications. Computerized medicine entry systems try to automatically alert physicians to major side effects. Some areas of medicine are devoted specifically to this problem. As is typical, people hostile to traditional medicine love to distort this out of context, so here is some context. A practical guide from Duke University demonstrates some of the efforts (and specific ways) healthcare systems and workers are trying to reduce iatrogenic harms of medications.
Claim 5: 800 000 patients may have died after taking beta blockers, therefore one should be highly skeptical of all cardiac medications
The context here is that in 2014, the European Society of Cardiology recommended patients with coronary artery disease or those who had suffered a heart attack take beta blockers after surgeries that did not involve the heart. The thinking was to decrease demand on the heart in order to avoid postoperative heart attacks in those who came to the hospital with pre-existing heart disease. However, subsequent investigations found that some patients did in fact suffer severe side effects from this approach. The person who recommended this practice was a physician by the name of Don Poldermans, who was later academically punished when his conflicts of interest were discovered (you can see the links with other points raised by Dr. Malhotra). The European Heart Journal, which published the work, quickly responded and retracted the article. Furthermore, the actual figure of 800 000 deaths may itself be an overestimate. If one delves more deeply into the research that claims to have demonstrated beta blockers harm patients, an experienced cardiologist would quickly see that the beta blocker doses used were likely too high. Current cardiology guidelines in both Europe and the United States recommend efforts to minimize perioperative risk in patients with heart disease, where one of the ways this can be accomplished is by using lower doses of beta blockers, in moderation. It would be seriously incorrect to conclude that this research means patients should “be scared of all the beta blockers all the time”. It would also be seriously incorrect to avoid mentioning all the checks and balances that resulted in the correction of the beta blocker policy.
Claim 6: Physicians should bear much more responsibility for overmedication and poor patient lifestyle
I challenge any audience member to find me a physician who directly recommended an unhealthy lifestyle to a patient. Some medical conditions like seizures, do not have simple cures, and require daily medication (another oversimplification by Dr Malhotra). It is not the patients fault that they may need daily medication. In clinical practice, the actual action of helping a patient achieve a more healthy lifestyle involves figuring out what the patient is willing to do, identifying any relevant socioeconomic barriers, deciding on an initial action plan, and engaging in followup. It is a long and complicated process, and anyone who has tried to quit smoking, lose weight, or exercise more, will have personal experience in how difficult it can be to make changes like these. Sometimes we can’t have a full and complete discussion, purely because of time. Would I like to teach someone how to cook a Middle Eastern fattoush? Sure! But I can’t necessarily do this for every appointment I have with a patient. One would assume a cardiologist like Dr. Malhotra would be aware of all the socioeconomic barriers to achieving a healthier lifestyle, but in the lecture he chose to gloss over those things and replace it with physician bashing. Not helpful. One should absolutely try to lead a healthier lifestyle, and many physicians are ready to help! However, it is not as simple as just flipping a switch. Leading a healthier lifestyle should be the default choice, and one does not need to purchase the services of a cardiologist to do this. In the United States, a registered dietician is an example of a healthcare professional who can help improve eating habits.
Claim 7: Absolute risk reduction is the ideal way to describe immunization benefit, not relative risk reduction, and this is intentional exaggeration of vaccine benefits
Insisting on reporting only the absolute risk reduction of disease harms due to vaccines is an old antivax tactic because the absolute risk reduction is mathematically always a smaller number than the relative risk reduction, and this supports the antivaccine narrative better. However, it is just two different ways of presenting the same outcome (amount of people who had less disease due to immunization). I won’t delve into the detailed mathematics, but take a real life example – let’s say you want to compare the number of apples in the refrigerator on one day versus another day. You have 20 apples to begin with, and you eat two. You’ll end up with 18 apples, but this can be expressed as either a 2 apple reduction, or a 10% reduction in apples. Its just two different perspectives. Two is smaller than ten, but one number is not intrinsically more conspiratorial than the other. If you require a discussion on this before you will consider vaccination, bring the journal article to the office visit! Just be prepared to conduct this discussion over more than one visit, because it takes time. Also, not all patients care for informed consent involving individual analysis of journal articles. While this topic may be new to many antivaccine activists, immunization epidemiology has always used the RRR. A big reason this is the case is because it does not depend on the amount of the pathogen in circulation.
Claim 8: Citizens all over the world are overmedicated with cardiac medications, so one should take all efforts to stop cholesterol lowering medication
Coronary stents are placed due heart attacks, or preventatively when one or more arteries of the heart become dangerously narrow. While the narrowing is physically relieved by the stent, issues with clotting, inflammation, and cellular dysfunction are not, and addressing these issues generally requires long-term medications. If there were a one-stop-shop mechanism to switch off that dysfunction with one pill, one time, that would be awesome, and I would reach for it. There is no such pill at the moment. Coronary artery disease is a mixture of high cholesterol, abnormal function of, and abnormal inflammation in, the arteries of the heart. However, removing medications entirely goes against shelves and shelves of research. The abnormal molecular processes do not stop just because you had a heart stent. One could tweak the medicines to be as few as possible, but taking them all away is highly dangerous. If you want to show that your favorite supplement is better than statin, do the experiment! It is not acceptable to just proclaim you are going to stop statins just because of your belief system. In addition, there are several genetic factors that predispose people to high cholesterol that will place patients at risk of an early heart attack, and all the red rice yeast in the world won’t bring their cholesterol down to a safe level.
Claim 9: Obesity – it’s the patient’s fault!
It was not necessary to delve into patient blaming in the lecture. There are multiple metabolic, socioeconomic, genetic, and medical causes of obesity that have their own entire fields of medicine that study them. This is not one simplistic issue. Obesity is rising in many countries, however it takes a systematic approach to help each individual patient.
Claim 10: Hospitals serving fast foods is making the problem worse
Here I completely agree with Dr. Malhotra – get fast food out of the hospitals! Hospitals should set a good example to their patients, and support healthy lifestyles as much as possible.
Claim 11: Steven Gundry’s PULS abstract demonstrates that mRNA immunization causes coronary artery harm
Steven Gundry is a former cardiac surgeon who has turned to providing a private outpatient concierge practice. I discussed how he tried to use a coronary inflammation test known as “PULS” to measure heart artery inflammation in patients after COVID vaccination. While his hypothesis and intentions were reasonable, he designed a study with none of the usual statistical controls and safeguards expected of such a study, based on a test that had not been validated in the population that it was used on. This is not acceptable and should not have been praised by Dr. Malhotra. In cardiology we frequently use tests and medicines outside their original design specifications (such as digoxin in pediatric heart failure), however this is not done in the complete absence of peer-reviewed evidence. The PULS test was designed to test heart artery inflammation but it has never been validated to assess the impacts of immunization. If one undertakes an injection designed to active the immune system, one should expect to find lab test results reflective of that. At minimum, Dr. Gundry would need to repeat the test with a control group, which wasn’t even done in the original abstract. If Dr. Malhotra and colleagues sincerely think the entire world failed to catch vaccine-accelerated coronary atherosclerosis, coronary hypersensitivity, myocarditis, and dilated cardiomypathy, do the study to show that we all missed it! Solely proclaiming this is true does not make it true.
Claim 12: Dr. Clare Craig, anti-COVID-19 vaccination activist, reviewed Dr. Malhotra’s article in the Journal of Insulin Resistance, therefore his claims are more credible
Dr. Craig is a British pathologist who is one of the members of the UK HART (Health Advisory and Recovery Team) group, an organization who has one stated goal of abolishing all COVID vaccinations. She is hostile to COVID immunization, but uses articles that debunk her point to try to prove her point. She is tied to the idea that COVID vaccinations cause COVID (which is biologically not possible). She thinks people can’t die of COVID, which is a hard no. She thinks the elderly don’t catch COVID, which is another hard no. If she is the person you are consulting to strengthen your position, that suggests your position is not a good one.
Claim 13: There is an unexpected association of COVID with less heart disease
Not only does this claim by Dr. Malhotra go against the weight of the evidence (much of which is independent of Pfizer and Moderna), it is cherrypicking one sentence in a single article and hoping the reader doesn’t pay attention to the next sentence which says this result was likely affected by sampling bias. While such a tactic may work in a courtroom, it does not work in the court of scientific peer review. Dr. Malhotra also completely ignores the overall conclusion of the article, which is very clear and consistent with the results of other research groups (a pretty good sign that their work is good).This is a man who preaches research integrity in one breath, and attempts to distort an article in the very next. Sleight of hand is not cool.
Claim 14: There should be more praise for the analyses of Peter Doshi that show immunization harm
Doshi has been a frequent subject of articles at SBM. He has produced many re-analyses to try and show that vaccines are harmful, but he had to use statistical trickery to reach these conclusions. Reanalyzing statistics until they show the point you prefer is not an activity that credible and unbiased researchers do. One technique used in Doshi’s articles is discussed here.
Claim 15: The Israeli heart attack study shows a significant rise in heart attacks after COVID immunization
A research group analyzed emergency telephone calls to Israel’s National Emergency Medical services and found an association between 16-39 year olds and calls for cardiac arrest and possible heart attacks. This has been trumpeted as evidence for heart harms related to COVID-19 vaccines, however remember that the myocarditis issue in teen boys and young men has been well characterized now. If you don’t want to get vaccinated due to this, please at least consider all the multi-organ system issues that COVID can create. One big issue in drawing sweeping conclusions from that study is that there was no effort to look at final diagnosis codes through chart review – so everything from congenital heart disease to aortic dissection could have been included. It should not have to be said, that COVID immunizations cannot cause a heart defect that you were born with. I do advise anyone with chest pain after COVID immunization to seek immediate medical attention, however the study cited is not capable of demonstrating changes in the rate of heart attacks after COVID immunization.
Claim 16: Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo’s Department of Health study demonstrates immunization harm
That is a hard no. This anonymous “study” (discussed on SBM) released by the Florida Surgeon General is actually contradicted by the data they used in the study. If they had actually performed a proper risk-benefit analysis, the study would have clearly shown the benefits of vaccination. Instead, it only described risks of vaccination – which we already know and have adjusted for. If Dr. Ladapo had performed even the briefest moment of reflection, he would have realized this, but he is only interested in supporting his narrative.
Claim 17: Disease-derived immunity is consistently superior to immunization-derived immunity
This is repeatedly oversimplified as “natural immunity is better”. Here is the opinion of someone actually trained in the subject, with all the necessary nuance and complexity. Some people who are infected don’t even gain any immunity! The correlates of protection are an active area of ongoing research. Based upon the research of the Crotty lab, a combination of immunity gained by infection plus immunization is superior to either alone. One of the core issues is that SARS-COV-2, like its cousin coronaviruses, changes very quickly due to the genome having not particularly good error checking. As a result, many proteins on the viral surface change, and the immune system may have difficulty recognizing the altered viruses. This is the reason that even hybrid immunity is not a brick wall against future infection. Researchers like Professor Akiko Iwasaki are attempting to lead efforts to improve COVID immunizations for exactly this reason.
Claim 18: COVID-19 immunization adverse events are under-reported and deserve more care/ recognition
I have yet to witness Dr. Malhotra engaging in the medical care of anyone genuinely afflicted by a COVID-19 immunization adverse event, but I hear a lot of talk about supporting charities. There seems to be no obvious publicly available information demonstrating that these charities actually funded peer-reviewed COVID immunization injury research. I would be happy to be advised otherwise on this claim. Can he show us that he really “walks the walk” and can cure someone of tinnitus, neuropathy, or postvaccination myocarditis/pericarditis caused (or allegedly caused) by the COVID-19 vaccines? There are multiple streams of evidence, such as this one, that show claims of increased adverse events are actually showing a lack of understanding (and sometimes misrepresentation) of the data. Programs like the NVIC in America provide recognition and support to patients for whom there is actual evidence supporting the claim they were injured by a vaccine (more thoughtful discussion of this topic can be found on Dorit Reiss’ blog). However, this needs to be based on reasonable evidence showing a consistent link between vaccination and adverse outcomes – not a series of presentations in the Euston Friends House. An example of a research group of pediatric cardiologists who is showing genuine support to patients who sustained post-vaccination myocarditis is here, to contrast the vast difference in signalling support versus actually providing it. Those cardiologists actually saw patients, performed MRIs, did multi-center research, and helped patients recover from myocarditis. No similar research is known to have been produced by Malhotra and his colleagues.
Claim 19: Bill Gates should focus on non-communicable diseases
Even a very simple fact check would reveal that the Bill Gates Foundation is already funding research in this arena.
Claim 20: Aseem Malhotra’s father’s death is highly suspicious evidence that all mRNA immunizations are causing harm
Dr. Malhotra’s father, Dr. Kailash Chand, was a physician himself. He was also a patient known to have significant coronary artery disease and was at risk of heart attacks. His death due to cardiac arrest was reported at the BBC, and was explicitly described by Dr. Malhotra as likely being related to the ambulance delay (a genuine problem in the British NHS at the moment that deserves its own article). However, Dr. Malhotra is now trying to spin this as a vaccine injury. If someone thinks the vaccination is causing heart attacks, myocarditis, or sudden heart artery narrowing several months after the date of the immunization, do the research! If he thinks there is undiagnosed sudden coronary inflammation or accelerated atherosclerosis, do the research to see if this is the case! We at least need to see an animal study/ basic science study, and if this experiment supports the idea, then it should be followed by a human study. Physicians have never been allowed to make hypotheses and present them as truth in the absence of experimental evidence. In addition, due to his opposition to statin medication Dr. Malhotra also explicitly talked his dad out of taking medications after heart stent procedures to relieve a coronary narrowing, which goes against the shelves of research mentioned above. The precise medications that were meant to relieve heart artery inflammation and reduce possible clots were removed in a patient who probably really needed them. Dr. Malhotra even said on TV that he does not understand why a “healthy guy” was found to have coronary artery disease on autopsy. A piece of information that cardiology trainees learn early on is that older citizens have a relatively high prevalence of heart artery narrowings of varying degrees, much more so than in children. Silent heart attacks and heart attacks with no warning are a significant ongoing issue in the world of cardiology.
If the belief is that the immunization associated SARS-CoV-2 spike protein is causing hypercoagulability, show us some immunofluorescence proving that vaccine spike is there! Show us an abnormal thromboelastograph in real patients with the clots you believe are there! Show us a T-cell or cytokine assay revealing a previously unknown behavior of the immune system! Physicians have never been permitted to declare that something is true “just because”. We have never been permitted to stop short of a systematic analysis, like what Dr Ryan Cole did with the thrombi described in the “Died Suddenly” video. Cardiologists expect other cardiologists to provide a biologically plausible mechanism or defend their claims with clinical research. That’s how we’ve produced all the other evidence-based guidelines that currently serve patients. The rules of how to advance medicine don’t provide special treatment only to certain cardiologists.
Conclusion: Dr. Malhotra’s claims are not based on good evidence
Dr. Malhotra’s claims generally lack strong evidence to support them. They seem to be based on pre-existing beliefs and a narrative he is trying to advance, not the peer-reviewed literature. This is why the quality of evidence provided to the end-user is extraordinarily important. For all these reasons, please, please take the lecture, and all his future presentations on the same topic, with a grain of sodium-free salt substitute.

Unsafe and Ineffective: Aseem Malhotra
British consulting cardiologist Dr. Aseem Malhotra has become the latest darling of the COVID-19 minimization and antivaccine movement in the UK. Previously known for anti-statin views and advocacy of the Pioppi diet who pivoted to more dangerous misinformation during the pandemic.
Jonathan Laxton on May 21, 2023
Link

A new anti-vaccine darling has emerged from the United Kingdom. Dr Aseem Malhotra, a British consulting cardiologist with unconventional views (putting it politely) on the basic science around heart disease, has become the latest crank to promote disinformation around the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. His unscientific views on cholesterol treatment with statins, promotion of the Pioppi diet and overemphasis on the benefit of lifestyle change in managing heart disease have been discussed previously on Science-Based Medicine. Now, I discuss lifestyle change with all my patients, which is beneficial. However, like everything in medicine, it is not a perfect intervention, and an approach that requires medications plus lifestyle intervention is often necessary to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease. Even this combined approach is not perfect. People will still develop cardiovascular disease after trying to optimise all the known risk factors (although at a lower rate than if they did not take preventative measures).
Self-promotion and official corrections
Malhotra has brought one primary skill to the anti-vax community: prolific self-promotion. This characteristic has resulted in several incidents where official organisations had to correct grandiose claims by Malhotra and reaffirm that they do not support his views. For example, Aseem Malhotra received a “Champion of Preventative Medicine” award at an international medical graduate (IMG) dinner. During the event, he posed for a picture with the Chair of the British Medical Association (BMA) at the time Chaand Nagpaul. Aseem then posted the following Tweet:
The above Tweet clearly implies the British Medical Association gave him the award. This event resulted in the BMA having to issue a Tweet and perform an enquiry into the event. The most telling quote from the enquiry was, “A sense of politeness and being ‘put on the spot’ were major factors in Chaand being pictured with Aseem Malhotra.” That is hardly a glaring endorsement. Both the BMA and Dr Nagpaul also sent Tweets confirming that they did not endorse Malhotra’s views:
The second event occurred in South Africa, which produced one of the most humorous marketing mistakes of all time:
Putting your picture under the heading “Unsafe and Ineffective” without clarifying the meaning in the subheading is quite a mistake. In true Malhotra fashion, he then Tweeted that he gave a well-received speech in the South African Parliament when it was delivered in a meeting room in the Western Cape Provincial Parliament at the invitation of the Deputy Speaker of the provincial assembly.
My favourite self-promoting Tweet from Malhotra has to be the anonymous letter of support he received from an “American cardiologist,” who apparently writes his letters using the King’s English. I cannot prove he wrote it himself, but my suspicions are high.
mRNA vaccines and heart attacks
I want to address his primary claim, which he also recently pushed on the Joe Rogan Experience podcast: COVID-19 mRNA vaccines cause ischaemic heart disease (heart attacks and strokes). He has boldly proclaimed, “It’s my duty as a cardiologist to urgently inform every Dr, patient & member of the public that the mRNA product is a likely contributory factor in all unexpected cardiac arrest, heart attacks, strokes, cardiac arrhythmia & heart failure since 2021 until proven otherwise.” Malhotra had included in this claim the death of a 15-year-old girl who died from complications of COVID-19 before she received any vaccine doses.
Linking cardiovascular disease to vaccines is a significant score for anti-vaxxers. Among the leading causes of death worldwide, the first is ischaemic heart disease, and the second is stroke. This means that most people will know someone in their social circle who has suffered from one of these conditions, and if anti-vaxxers can link it to the COVID-19 vaccines, they can fuel mass vaccine hesitancy. Their anti-vax following will also come up with numerous personal anecdotes about people experiencing these common conditions following a COVID-19 vaccine. Malhotra recently appeared on a BBC News segment about statins, which is unusual because no major cardiology organisation (including the American Heart Association, Canadian Cardiovascular Society, NICE, and European Society of Cardiology) supports his views on the medication. He is not a “leading expert” in the area; he is just proficient at self-promotion. He took this opportunity to hijack the interview claiming that the excess cardiac deaths occurring in the United Kingdom were due to the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. The BBC was apparently unaware of his recent anti-vax activity on Twitter, and they were unprepared for this claim, requiring them to apologise and correct the segment in writing.
Malhotra’s flawed evidence linking mRNA vaccines and heart attacks
I would like to closely examine the evidence forwarded by Aseem Malhotra to back this very bold claim and then consider evidence to the contrary. It is also important to note an essential distinction for lay readers. The mRNA vaccine has been associated with rare cases of myocarditis, which is inflammation of the muscle in the heart, and severe forms of myocarditis (especially viral myocarditis) can result in cardiac arrhythmias and sudden cardiac deaths. It is also important to mention that vaccine-induced myocarditis (VIM) is not as severe as other forms of myocarditis and has not been strongly associated with arrhythmias or sudden cardiac death in most people who experience it. Studies in The BMJ and Nature Medicine have demonstrated the course of VIM is much more benign than viral myocarditis. However, Malhotra is not referring to this form of heart disease when discussing ischaemic heart disease (heart attacks). This involves blockage of blood flow supplying the heart muscle and is a common cause of heart disease, especially in high-income countries.

On his most recent appearance on the Joe Rogan Experience, Malhotra repeats the claim that myocarditis is not associated with COVID-19 infection based on this study from Israel. However, as the study title states, they looked at the POST-COVID (emphasis added) period and excluded the first ten days after infection from their analysis. The authors also clearly state that “it has recently been reported that the incidence of myocarditis and pericarditis is increased in COVID-19 patients during the acute illness.” One has to wonder if Malhotra actually read the article. It also appears the ICD-10 code I140.9 (acute myocarditis, unspecified) was included, but I140.0 (infective myocarditis) was not. Myocarditis from COVID-19 infection would be classified as I140.0.
Malhotra lays out his arguments in his narrative review paper published in the Journal of Insulin Resistance, a journal with an impact factor of “error,” of which Malhotra is one of the editors. He has added further arguments on Twitter through a “lecture event” in the United Kingdom and, most recently, the Joe Rogan Experience.
Anecdotes
He begins his argument with an anti-vax perennial favourite: an anecdote. Tragically, Aseem Malhotra’s father died from ischaemic heart disease in the fall of 2022. Initially, Malhotra blamed a 30-minute delay in the ambulance arrival for the bad outcome, which likely contributed to his father’s death. The British Heart Foundation identified this problem as contributing to increased cardiac deaths in the United Kingdom.
An autopsy showed that his 73-year-old father had a 90% and 75% blockage in two coronary arteries supplying blood to the heart. His father had been living a healthy lifestyle and was previously asymptomatic. Given Malhotra’s strong beliefs about lifestyle almost completely preventing coronary artery disease, he began looking for other reasons for this tragedy. He settled on the two doses of the Pfizer COVID-19 mRNA vaccine his father had received six months prior. Now, I have to sympathise with Malhotra, a sudden loss of a loved one can be devastating, especially when a system failure, such as an ambulance delay, may have contributed. If this had not been a close family member, as a cardiologist, he would have known that many patients who die of cardiovascular disease can be asymptomatic up to the fatal event. He would also recognise that coronary artery disease in a 73-year-old male is not unusual, especially given that there is increased risk in populations of South Asian descent. It is also biologically implausible that exposure to the vaccine could result in significant narrowing in his father’s coronary arteries in just six months. “Accelerated atherosclerosis”, resulting from cocaine use or systemic inflammatory disease (like lupus or rheumatoid arthritis), occurs over 2-3 years. The most rapid development of atherosclerosis occurs post-heart transplant, but there is no known mechanism by which a vaccine could result in this type of damage.
Cherry-picking
After discussing this anecdote, he moves on to another favourite anti-vax past-time: picking cherries. He starts with a conference abstract from Steven Gundry, a GOOP-associated cardiothoracic surgeon who believes specific proteins in plants (lectins) are the “root cause” of many diseases despite mountains of evidence to the contrary. Gundry’s website is reminiscent of his supplement-pushing cardiac surgery colleague, Mehmet Oz. This abstract, heavily criticised by experts, including me and SBM-contributor Frank Han, had an expression of concern added to it and had to be extensively rewritten. Gundry has been using a “PULS” score, a mixture of 9 biomarkers, to try and better classify the risk of developing cardiovascular disease in addition to the traditional risk factors (smoking, diabetes, lack of physical activity, male sex, dyslipidaemia and obesity). It is critical to note that this test has not been fully validated and is currently not recommended by any major cardiovascular society. The initial study on this score used it on databases and found it could reclassify 43% of “intermediate risk” patients as “high risk”. It is not diagnostic of the presence of coronary artery disease. The abstract measured the PULS score 3-5 months before a COVID-19 vaccine and then 2-10 weeks following the second dose and found increases in the score primarily due to elevated IL-16, sFas and HGF suggesting an increase in calculated 5-year risk of cardiovascular disease from 11 to 25%.

Many things are wrong with this analysis. You will notice that this test includes inflammatory markers, which could increase from an immune response to a vaccine. To test this correctly, you want to do the same measurement before and after other vaccines. You would also like to repeat the test in several months to see if the changes were temporary (once the inflammatory response subsided). It would also be informative to perform the test after a COVID-19 infection (or any other viral infection). You would also want to follow the patients to see if there was an increased incidence of cardiovascular disease. The significance of the findings of this abstract is very unclear (which is doctor talk for meaningless). It certainly is not good evidence of an increased risk of heart attacks after the COVID-19 vaccines.
“Re-analysis” (and p-hacking)
He then turns to another favourite anti-vax pastime: re-analysing data from original Pfizer clinical trial, from 2 years (and countless variants) ago. To be more specific, data from the 6-month follow-up study from the phase 2–3 portion of the Pfizer trial. He goes into the Supplementary Appendix to point out a non-significant four-vaccine versus one placebo cardiac arrest in trial participants. While ischaemic heart disease is a common cause of cardiac arrest, many other conditions (including COVID-19) can result in this type of death. I also found it very interesting that he ignored the fact that “myocardial infarction” (the medical term for “heart attack”) occurred in 2 people in the placebo and none in the vaccine group. Does this mean the Pfizer vaccine prevents heart attacks? Of course not; it is non-significant, much like the difference in cardiac arrests.
Later in the paper, he cites another re-analysis of the mRNA vaccine clinical trial data for Pfizer and Moderna by Fraiman, Doshi, et al., who p-hacked an interim analysis to support the claim that serious adverse events significantly outnumber the benefit of preventing COVID-19 hospitalisation. The issues with this paper have been comprehensively discussed by Orac, Dr Susan Oliver, and Dr Jonathan Howard. Still, in brief, it downplays the benefits of vaccination and over-counts adverse events. In his BBC interview, Malhotra claims that most adverse events of special interest (AESIs) in the paper were “cardiac”, but the study’s tables clearly show that less than half of the AESIs for both vaccines were cardiac-related.
Next, he forwards a study from Scientific Reports (a less-prestigious subsidiary of Nature) about ambulance calls for cardiac arrest in Israel that attempts to correlate it to vaccine doses. The study has been given an expression of concern due to its many methodological issues. The authors tried correlating peak ambulance calls for cardiac arrests in people younger than 40 with peak vaccine doses in Israel. However, the diagram is a mess, as outlined by Dr Susan Oliver, including using different scales to make a visual correlation (red arrows), showing a decrease in heart attacks before the peak of the second dose (blue arrow) and comparing two different rolling averages (5-week for acute coronary syndrome calls and 3-week for vaccine doses and COVID cases; purple arrow). You will also notice in the top figure that the calls for ambulances go up and down randomly throughout the chart. The fact that a peak almost lined up with a peak in vaccine doses is not compelling evidence of a cause-and-effect relationship. The authors did not have access to the individual’s vaccination status in the ambulance or the final diagnosis, so they could not determine if it was actually a heart attack.
After the release of this study, the Israeli Ministry of Health looked into the numbers further and published them in a presentation (in Hebrew). In the figure translated below, 43% of the people were unvaccinated, 18% did not require transport to the hospital, 52% were diagnosed with non-specific non-cardiac chest pain, and only 6% were hospitalised with a heart issue. This breakdown demonstrates the weakness of correlational studies as evidence of causation.’
Misattribution of causality
Malhotra’s next line of evidence is a report by the British Heart Foundation on 30,000 excess cardiac deaths in the United Kingdom since the pandemic began. The report is quite explicit on what it attributes these excess deaths to, including missed doctors’ appointments in which classic risk factors would be identified and managed, longer wait times for specialist appointments and cardiac investigations/procedures, and delays in ambulances transporting people with acute cardiac events to hospital. What was not on that list? COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. However, this does not stop Malhotra from claiming they are a significant contributing cause. Malhotra is seemingly unaware of the Office of National Statistics (ONS) data showing that most excess ischaemic heart disease deaths occurred in 2020. This was before the COVID-19 vaccines were even available. As I will demonstrate in the second part, COVID-19 has also been associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular events, likely contributing to the large spikes in 2020.
Misrepresenting animal studies
The final line of evidence I’ve seen from Malhotra is this laboratory study on Syrian Hamsters using the viral spike protein, which found endothelial damage. This study used 146,000 times the spike protein found in the blood after humans’ first dose of the Moderna vaccine. This spike protein was not stabilised like the spike protein in the mRNA vaccine, which cannot interact as effectively with the ACE2 receptor (this interaction mediates many of the harmful effects described for the spike protein in the literature). Edward Nirenberg has addressed this study at length previously.
Evidence for: A summary
Malhotra’s claim of “until proven otherwise” requires remarkable evidence to be valid. Let us summarise the evidence he has provided:
    • A tragic anecdote of his elderly father’s death from coronary artery disease with a biologically implausible timeframe after vaccination.
    • Changes in a non-validated score of unclear significance have not been investigated properly by the authors.
    • A non-significant difference in cardiac arrests in the original Pfizer trial, while ignoring fewer “myocardial infarctions” in the vaccine group.
    • Claims from an unnecessary “re-analysis” of the Pfizer and Moderna trials did not show that most adverse events are cardiac.
    • Correlation between ambulance calls and vaccine doses, which further analysis shows are unrelated.
    • Misrepresentation of a report from the British Heart Foundation with his claims unsupported by ONS data.
    • A laboratory study which overdosed Syrian hamsters with viral (not vaccine) spike protein.
Now, to be fair in accusing him of picking cherries, there may be further evidence he has not presented to support his position. Has he excluded significant evidence that does not support his conclusions? Let’s look at what he left out.
Evidence against Malhotra’s claims
Given ischaemic heart disease is so common and a leading killer worldwide, multiple large studies have assessed whether the COVID-19 vaccines are associated with an increased risk of heart attacks.
Pfizer was required to conduct a post-marketing real-world trial for the vaccine’s safety and efficacy, which is reported in multiple Clalit Health Services Studies (Clalit is a major Israeli not-for-profit health services organization). The safety study included 844,828 patients and examined the difference between those infected with SARS-CoV-2 and those that received the vaccine. The risk ratio for myocardial infarction (heart attack) was non-significant for the vaccine and elevated for COVID-19 infection.

Now, this is a pharma-backed study, but luckily, it is not the only study examining this question. Drug company-backed studies should not be automatically dismissed, just read very carefully to see if there is bias in the methods or conclusions and seek out corroborating evidence (which we have).
A group from France also looked at a large population of 3.9 million people over 75 years old and compared the risk of acute myocardial infarction 14 days after receiving the vaccine to their baseline time period. This method assumes heart attacks occur randomly and relatively evenly over time and is trying to detect an increased rate two weeks after exposure to the vaccine. You can see in the table that after both the first (RR 0.97; 0.88-1.06) and second (1.04; 0.93-1.16) vaccination, there was no significantly increased rate of acute myocardial infarctions (heart attacks).
This same group repeated this analysis on 46.5 million people under 75 years old and found similar results. There was no increase in acute myocardial infarction following either dose of both the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines.
The FDA also conducted a study in the CMS database, which includes adults over 65 years old who are covered by Medicare in the United States. This is a good population to examine, and this database does not rely on self-reporting like VAERS but catalogues payments made and the associated diagnostic codes. An initial signal for acute myocardial infarction was no longer significant when adjusted for monthly variations in background rates.
3.3. Signal evaluation
None of the prespecified data quality assurance checks, including claims duplication and unusual variability in claim accrual, raised data quality concerns (Table S9). Primary findings for signal robustness and signal characterization analyses are summarized in Table 3 . Adjustment for monthly variation in the background rates resulted in statistically non-significant associations for AMI, DIC, and ITP following BNT162b2 vaccination. With background rates from the flu-vaccinated population as the historical comparator, DIC and ITP no longer met the signal threshold, while signals for AMI (RR = 1.41) and PE (RR = 1.48) remained. When rates during the peri-COVID period were used as the historical comparator, PE and DIC no longer met the signal threshold. We conducted an additional ad hoc sensitivity analysis for PE. When PE events were restricted to the inpatient setting, the statistical signal remained (RR = 2.17).
So, evidence from multiple large, well-conducted observational studies on millions of people has found no association between ischaemic heart disease and COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. Much of Malhotra’s argument rests on increased rates of ischaemic heart disease over the last three years and a weak (pretty much non-existent) correlation to country-level vaccination rates. I’ve already demonstrated that the association with COVID-19 vaccines is not convincing, but are there alternate reasons for increases in ischaemic heart disease? As the British Heart Foundation noted, disruptions in routine and cardiovascular care, delays in treatment and testing, and limited resources being redirected to the care of COVID-19 patients have likely contributed. Studies in the United States have shown increased delayed patient presentations with STEMI (ST-elevation myocardial infarction). This is the most severe form of heart attack caused by blockage of one or more coronary arteries and requires time-sensitive interventions to reduce the risk of death. When something disrupts the ability to provide timely care for a STEMI, more people will die of this form of heart attack. Studies also demonstrated that the coexistence of COVID-19 infection and STEMI increased mortality compared to those without COVID-19 infection. These were patients without a concurrent diagnosis of COVID-19 and only included data up to September 2020 (no COVID vaccines available). A meta-analysis showed that these delays resulted in increased mortality, especially in low- to middle-income countries. Studies found similar results in the United Kingdom and England. For patients with non-STEMI heart attacks (unstable angina/NSTEMI), presentation and definitive treatment delays were much worse than STEMIs resulting in increased mortality in 2020. The BMJ noted this decline in treating acute myocardial infarctions and called for urgent action to prevent interruptions in cardiac care in early 2020.
However, further evidence shows a much stronger association between COVID-19 infection and ischaemic heart disease. A study of over four million individuals in The Lancet, which excluded vaccinated individuals, found that COVID-19 was associated with a significantly increased risk of ischaemic heart disease HR 2.81 (2.48-3.19), cardiac arrest HR 1.75 (1.53-2.01) and cardiac-related mortality HR 1.60 (1.51-1.70).
An American cohort study of 153,760 individuals published in Nature found elevated rates of acute coronary syndrome, myocardial infarction, angina and ischaemic heart disease up to 12 months after infection with COVID-19.
Another study in The BMJ found an increased rate of myocardial infarction and ischaemic heart disease in patients hospitalised with COVID-19. This study also demonstrated increased risk of ischaemic heart disease in patients admitted “with” and not “from” COVID-19 (see the bottom-right box for cases with a secondary COVID-19 diagnosis):

Malhotra ignores the 35x increase in all-cause death and 4-5x increased rate of cardiovascular disease and ischaemic heart disease to focus on a surprising “reduction” in myocardial infarctions in the non-hospitalised group (top-right in the image above), but ignores the 10x increase in all-cause mortality in this group. This study clearly explains this surprising finding is due to selection bias. If you had a heart attack, you would be hospitalised for it and wind up in the “cases hospitalised with secondary COVID-19 diagnosis” cohort. This is more classic Malhotra cherry-picking at its finest. Un-ironically, he goes on during this lecture to discuss how he is helping people to interpret studies properly.
What about COVID-19 and heart attacks?
So, if we are going to explain elevated rates and deaths due to ischaemic heart disease, it is surprising that Malhotra, a cardiologist, would land on the mRNA vaccines and ignore COVID-19 infection. Now, keen readers may notice an apparent contradiction in my presented data. If I said it is “biologically implausible” for atherosclerosis to develop within 6 months of a COVID-19 vaccine, why would I then argue increased ischaemic heart disease events after COVID-19? This is an excellent question, and the answer is that atherosclerosis is not the sole mechanism that can cause a heart attack. COVID-19 infection is often found to cause a “type 2 myocardial infarction” when the coronary arteries have pre-existing narrowing that does not cause problems when the heart is pumping under normal circumstances. When the patient becomes very sick, and there is a large demand for increased heart pumping, arterial narrowing prevents the blood flow from meeting this increased demand. The severe inflammation induced by COVID-19 can also result in spasms in the coronary arteries as well as the formation of blood clots at the site of pre-existing atherosclerotic plaques. The mRNA vaccines do not have any of these mechanisms. You may remember from Malhotra’s account of the autopsy results there was no mention of a clot or widespread cardiac damage that would be found in these scenarios.
There is also a cohort study out of Korea on almost 600,000 participants which showed that vaccinated people had a significantly decreased rate of myocardial infarction with COVID-19 infection compared to the unvaccinated.

COVID-19 vaccination and death
Probably the most concerning outcomes of cardiovascular disease is death. Several studies have also examined death rates following COVID-19 vaccination and the results are very reassuring. A self-control case series (SCCS) out of the United Kingdom examined 3,807 deaths that occurred in young people (under 30 years-old). They found no increase in cardiac deaths following either dose of the mRNA vaccines. This evidence strongly argues against claimed increases in heart attacks amongst vaccinated young people.
This is corroborated by an ironic source, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the Florida Surgeon General. Ladapo also opposed vaccinating young people and attempted his own SCCS that he claimed “showed increased cardiac mortality in young males”. In actuality, the analysis had a dose-based analysis that confirmed that there was, in fact, no increase risk of cardiac death (but was deleted by Ladapo right before publication).
A group in Australia also examined cardiac arrest data and found no increase associated with COVID-19 vaccination. They appropriately divided the study by vaccination status, which provides much stronger evidence of association if one was present. Most anti-vaxxers will present trends in deaths or heart disease without breaking them down by vaccine status, then claim the vaccine must be the cause.

When you examine the data properly, such as this study did, the anti-vax argument breaks down completely. Dr. Susan Oliver has also provided an excellent discussion of this paper. You can see there is no change in cardiac arrests (blue) after the vaccination program was initiated and no significant increase in cardiac events in vaccinated versus unvaccinated young people.
Conclusion: False until proven otherwise
So, let me now summarise my evidence against Malhotra’s claims:
    • Large cohort studies performed on tens of millions of people who received the mRNA vaccines demonstrating no association with increased rates of ischaemic heart disease
    • Interruptions in cardiac care resulted in increased cardiac deaths (as opposed to the mRNA vaccines)
    • Studies on millions of patients demonstrating increased rates of ischaemic heart disease in those infected with COVID-19
    • A smaller study suggesting vaccination actually reduces the risk of ischaemic heart disease following COVID-19 infection
    • Multiple large studies showing no increased risk of cardiac death following COVID-19 mRNA vaccination
Now, balance that against Malhotra’s abstract on a non-validated blood test of unclear significance, questionable re-analyses of preliminary clinical trial data, a non-existent correlation between ambulance calls and vaccine doses, an increased rate of excess cardiac deaths in England which primarily occurred pre-vaccination, and a laboratory study where Syrian hamsters were overdosed with viral spike protein. Which do you find more compelling? After my review of all the data (and not just cherry-picked subsets) I conclude that there is no association between ischaemic heart disease and mRNA vaccines. I would also be as bold to say that any claim made by Aseem Malhotra about COVID vaccines should be presumed false until proven otherwise.

Minimizing COVID Via Pseudo-Profound Bullshit
Some COVID-minimizers use “seemingly impressive assertions that are presented as true and meaningful but are actually vacuous” to fool people into thinking they are receiving profound, secret knowledge. It’s actually just bullshit.
Jonathan Howard on September 23, 2022
Link

Pseudo-profound bullshit
Of the many techniques used to minimize the pandemic and endanger those try to limit its harms, I’ve not yet discussed pseudo-profound bullshit. This term was coined several years ago by researchers who defined it as,
Seemingly impressive assertions that are presented as true and meaningful but are actually vacuous.
Such statements consist of ‘…buzzwords randomly organized into statements with syntactic structure but no discernible meaning (e.g., “Wholeness quiets infinite phenomena”)’. According to their study:
Those more receptive to bullshit are less reflective, lower in cognitive ability (i.e., verbal and fluid intelligence, numeracy), are more prone to ontological confusions and conspiratorial ideation, are more likely to hold religious and paranormal beliefs, and are more likely to endorse complementary and alternative medicine.
Charlatans who employ pseudo-profound bullshit don’t want anyone to think about what they say. They don’t mean to be taken literally. Rather, their empty words are a form of manipulative poetry, used to lull people into a thoughtless trance, trigger emotions, and convince people they’ve been given unique access to some secret knowledge. Pseudo-profound bullshit is also designed to inspire awe in the pseudo-profound bullshitter, who is desperate to be perceived as more enlightened than everyone else.
“Fauci pushed lock downs to cover up a lab leak for which he was personally responsible.”
With this in mind, let’s meet Mr. Jeffrey Tucker, who may be familiar to readers of SBM as the founder of the Brownstone Institute, the “spiritual child” of the pro-virus Great Barrington Declaration. The Brownstone Institute has evolved into one of the pandemic’s chief spreaders of anti-vaccine conspiracies. It features doctors who are divorced from patient care, and aims to ensure that doctors who have real-world responsibilities never run out of patients. Mr. Tucker, whose past ties to White supremacist organizations made the news recently, reminded me of pseudo-profound bullshit when I read this Tweet.
What to make of this? It’s absurd at every level, and all it takes is two functioning neurons to realize this. Even if one accepts that Dr. Fauci was “personally responsible” for a lab leak and pushed for lockdowns to cover his error, many questions remain.
    • Why did Dr. Fauci issue a dire, and correct warning in March 2020 that “things will get worse”? Wouldn’t the “there’s nothing to see here” approach taken Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and John Ioannidis be the natural response for someone trying to cover a grievous lab leak?
    • Did the entire world lockdown just to protect Dr. Fauci?
    • Why were lockdowns so lax, outside of China?
    • Why did they last only a few weeks or months?
    • Why did they not return when discussions of the lab leak gained widespread media attention in 2021?
    • Why can’t the all-powerful Dr. Fauci take down a mere Tweet that completely exposes his sinister deeds?
    • Most importantly, how exactly were lockdowns supposed to “cover-up” Dr. Fauci’s actions? It’s not 1850 where people need to meet in the town square to exchange ideas. The internet has been unsurprisingly abuzz with conspiracies this pandemic, and telling people to stay home doesn’t exactly seem like the best strategy to squelch such ideas.
I suppose a more generous reading of Mr. Tucker’s Tweet is that Dr. Fauci pushed lockdowns hoping to stop the virus, thus covering up his error. This interpretation implies that either Dr. Fauci controlled lockdowns across the entire world, or he believed he could “cover-up” his error by having the USA alone lockdown, as if no one would notice the virus ravaging the rest of the world. Again, two functioning neurons is all it takes to realize how ludicrous this all is. However, this generous reading also raises an obvious question. The accusation seems to be that Dr. Fauci knew he accidently released a deadly virus on the world and didn’t run away from his error. Isn’t that a good thing? If a future scientist accidentally unleashes a deadly virus, they’d better do everything they can to stop it before over 15 million people die.
The sad truth is this – some people are so stunted they can’t imagine Dr. Fauci pushed for lockdowns because he knew forklifts were needed to dump bodies into giant trucks and he thought lockdowns would save lives.
The more I read Mr. Tucker’s Tweet, the more questions I had, and the more my head started to spin. And then it hit me, this is no accident. Mr. Tucker is spewing pseudo-profound bullshit. His words are “seemingly impressive assertions that are presented as true and meaningful but are actually vacuous”. Obviously, it’s possible to grasp the germ of a point Mr. Tucker is making, Fauci = Bad. However, a moment’s thought exposes his Tweet as blathering balderdash, and like any pseudo-profound bullshitter, Mr. Tucker doesn’t want anyone to think. Logic and reason are his enemies. I was not the only person to notice this.
It’s quite likely Mr. Tucker was caught off guard by this question, “How did (or would) lock downs cover up a lab leak?”. Like all pseudo-profound bullshitters, he did not intend for anyone to actually take him seriously. I doubt he takes himself seriously. Though he routinely claims to have uncovered plots carried out by people of unfathomable evil and competence, he never seems to fear his own safety after revealing their nefarious deeds or wonder why they can’t remove a simple tweet exploding their plot.
Instead, Mr. Tucker is engaged in vengeful performance art, designed to bypass rationality and proceed directly to raw emotions. As with most of the garbled gobbledygook published by the Brownstone Institute, he aims to frighten and infuriate people, while at the same time lulling them into that pseudo-profound bullshit trance where their senses are dulled and they can be fooled into thinking they are receiving deep, forbidden knowledge. Mr. Tucker even embraced the conspiracy that doctors killed patients through excessive intubations. That a meta-analysis of 12 studies found “The synthesized evidence of almost 9,000 patients suggests that timing of intubation may have no effect on mortality and morbidity of critically ill patients with COVID-19” is irrelevant.
Even though it’s utter hogwash, Mr. Tucker is offering his audience something very valuable; one-stop-shopping for all their pandemic scapegoating needs. He desperately wants people to think of themselves as victims and Dr. Fauci and frontline doctors as the instrument of their suffering. The fact that he makes no sense and spouts nonsense in direct contradiction to the evidence, isn’t a bug, it’s a feature. Deluging people with illogical incoherence is a purposeful strategy, an effective marketing technique practiced by propagandists around the world. If Mr. Tucker wants to prove me wrong, he can expand on his Tweet and answer the questions I posed with a well-reasoned, factually accurate article. There’s a first time for everything, I suppose.
Like many pseudo-profound bullshitters, Mr. Tucker even opens with a conversion story. “I used to feel enough clarity on issues to know for sure that crazy was not correct” he says. Mr. Tucker feels he’s more enlightened than he was in the past and certainly more enlightened than the blind sheep who have yet to see the truth about Dr. Fauci. Pseudo-profound bullshitters always believe they’ve figured out something secret and important that has eluded everyone else, and they always feel compelled share their seismic self-regard with as many strangers as possible. These people really care about their reputation, and it’s no surprise Mr. Tucker has made a lot of YouTube videos.
You can spot this sort of pseudo-profound bullshit everywhere if you keep an eye out for it. The formula is pretty basic. It’s a simple matter of stringing together spooky pandemic buzzwords in grammatically correct sentences. Pfizer needs vaccine mandates because catastrophic Fauci-lockdowns destroyed freedom. I came up that that in an instant.
However, unlike claims that “we all vibrate with the harmonic resonance of the infinite universe”, Mr. Tucker’s sort of pseudo-profound bullshit is not benign babble. Many people think they know much more about this virus than the doctors and scientists who’ve battled it daily for over two years. Many of these people died because they didn’t get vaccinated. Meanwhile, Dr. Fauci and his children have needed security details because of death threats, and burnt-out healthcare workers want to leave medicine. I previously described the irony of competent professionals quitting not despite “Objectivists” like Mr. Tucker, but precisely because of their misinformation and unsubtle calls for violence. Mr. Tucker, of course, is completely sheltered from the consequences of his words. Beyond clicks, likes, and shares, he has no skin in this game.
“The world is rudderless.”
It’s hard for many people to imagine that an event as impactful as COVID could have originated in a humble market via mundane human actions, even though this what the evidence clearly suggests. This uncertainty has created the perfect opening for conspiracy theorists and their pseudo-profound bullshit. Many people find it comforting to believe that an extremely powerful and malevolent actor is entirely responsible for global maladies. At least then someone is in control, and someone can be blamed. As the writer Alan Moore observed, for those of us who reject such bullshit, the truth can be far more frightening.

An Impossible, Unethical Study of Dubious Value That’s Not Meant to be Taken Seriously
Everyone knows it would be impossible to run an RCT of a million children in the middle of a raging pandemic Doctors who suggest such a thing don’t expect you to take them seriously.
Jonathan Howard on July 10, 2022
Link

With rates of severe disease now much lower in children than at the start of the pandemic—due to higher levels of natural immunity and lower rates of severe disease caused by omicron—trials would have needed to enroll hundreds of thousands of children, if not over a million, in order to detect a significant impact of the pediatric vaccine against severe disease. Vaccine companies could have conducted such time-consuming and costly trials, especially if there had been interest in international collaboration. But there was no economic incentive to do so, and every economic incentive not to: Speed, not providing meaningful information to parents and physicians about safety and efficacy, was the priority of U.S. regulatory agencies.
That paragraph comes from an ironically article called “The CDC Is Breaking Trust in Childhood Vaccination” Drs. Leslie Bienen and Tracy Hoeg. The article states:
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases.
The authors lament that the pediatric randomized-controlled trials (RCTs):
Did not assess protection from severe disease, hospitalization, or multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), important outcomes that parents worry about.
Dr. Hoeg, a sports medicine physician, has been discussed previously on SBM for her VAERS dumpster-dive and suggestion that pediatricians weren’t competent enough to distinguish RSV from COVID. Meanwhile Dr. Bienen, a veterinarian and faculty member at the Portland State University School of Public Health, co-authored an article last year titled “The Reassuring Data on the Delta Variant” with Dr. Monica Gandhi. This article falsely claimed that “places that had higher percentages of the Delta variant had lower ratios of hospitalized people to COVID cases”.
Three areas of agreement
While their previous work aged extremely poorly, and the numerous factual errors in their most recent article were exposed by vaccine-advocates (here, here, and here), I will begin with three areas of agreement with Drs. Bienen and Hoeg.
First, I agree that since that severe COVID is mercifully rare in young children, it would take an expensive, time-consuming trial of hundreds of thousands of children, if not over a million, in order to detect a significant impact of the pediatric vaccine against severe disease.
Second, I too have been critical of the CDC in several articles here, writing:
The CDC’s failure to report clear and accurate data about how COVID-19 is affecting children has opened the door to those who wish to minimize its impact by spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt.
The article by Drs. Bienen and Hoeg is a perfect example of this, and to the extent the CDC is breaking trust in childhood vaccination, they have willing accomplices in contrarian doctors who eagerly amplify every data mishap to minimize COVID’s impact on children.
Third, it’s true that many unvaccinated children have “natural immunity” to COVID. Dr. Hoeg worked hard to make this a reality by spreading rumors about the safety of COVID vaccines and falsely minimizing the virus. Though her most recent article claims “rates of severe disease now much lower in children than at the start of the pandemic”, nearly 300 children are being hospitalized every day, almost matching the Delta peak from last year. Dr. Hoeg has influenced powerful people. She was prominent member of a panel that led to The Florida Department of Health recommending against vaccinating healthy children.
Methodolatry part 1: An impossible, unethical study
With this is mind, I disagree with Drs. Bienen and Hoeg that it is possible or necessary to conduct an RCT of a million children before vaccinating them. I think they know this too.
In my previous article on methodolatry, the inappropriate worship of RCTs alone, I voiced the surprisingly controversial belief that it is much easier to casually request a million-child RCT than to actually run such an RCT. I also described the anti-vaccine technique of demanding impossible RCTs, both to cast doubt on the validity of existing studies and to disparage scientists who actually do this research. “If only lazy scientists enrolled millions of children in a simple RCT of the entire vaccine-schedule lasting the entire human lifespan looking at every possible outcome, my fears about vaccines would be assuaged“, they say in effect.
Drs. Bienen and Hoeg are scarcely different. Though they claim that a trial of a million children would be possible due to unspecified “advances in recruitment methods”, it’s easier said than done to enroll subjects in an RCT during a pandemic. These supposed “advances in recruitment methods” didn’t help an RCT of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin run by the NIH. It closed after enrolling just 20 patients, or 1% of their goal. I am sure that trial, like the one fantasized by Drs. Bienen and Hoeg, looked great on paper.
Parents are not afraid of COVID the way they were polio. Currently, only 300,000 children younger than 5-years have been vaccinated against COVID in the US. Their hypothetical RCT calls for vaccinating more children than will likely receive the vaccine this year. Think how ridiculous that is. Nonetheless, Drs. Bienen and Hoeg tell their readers that triple this number of children could be enrolled in an RCT, despite their steady and successful campaign to amplify the vaccine’s imperfections and minimize its benefits. Their most recent article, for example, cherry-picked one study from Hong Kong which reported the highest-rate of vaccine-myocarditis by far. It also did not discuss the favorable prognosis of this condition for nearly all children.
Of course, such an RCT would require a massive outreach program and trial infrastructure, with an enormous number of highly-trained coordinators. It would take many years to complete. To get a sense of the logistics involved in vaccine-trials, I encourage you to peruse the 460-page protocol for one of the pediatric vaccine RTCs of just 2,300 children. These trials are extremely complex, and there are many opportunities for things to go wrong. As Drs. Bienen and Hoeg point out, the Pfizer pediatric RCT of 4,500 children had many children drop out before receiving all three vaccine doses. The inevitable hiccups that would occur in study of a million children would be gleefully used as fodder by those who fear monger about vaccines.
Not only would running a million-child RCT would be impossible in a reasonable time-frame, it would also be unethical to allow unvaccinated children to suffer grave harms from the virus. This is why scientists with actual skin in the game unanimously voted to authorize these vaccines:
All 21 members of the FDA’s Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee voted “yes” in response to the question: “Based on the totality of scientific evidence available, do the benefits of the Moderna COVID-19 Vaccine when administered as a 2-dose series (25 micrograms each dose) outweigh its risks for use in infants and children 6 months through 5 years of age?”
Had regulators demanded RCTs of a million older children before authorizing vaccines, many more would have suffered, and some would have died before these trials concluded. Doctors who blithely call for such trials are only revealing their ignorance of how RCTs really work and how seriously COVID has impacted some children. However, calling for impossible, unethical RCTs while denigrating the smaller, though still valuable RCTs that have already been done is the entire gimmick for contrarian doctors who spread fear and doubt about vaccination.
Methodolatry part 2: An impossible, unethical study of dubious value
Even if the impossible trial proposed by Drs. Bienen and Hoeg were possible, there’s no reason to believe the extra knowledge it might provide would justify the costs of waiting. Let’s start with what is already known based on RCTs, thus far reported only in company press releases, conducted during the Omicron wave.
    • Pfizer: Pfizer vaccinated 1,678 children ages 6-months to under 5-years in its RCT and found that after a third dose the vaccine was 80.3% effective in preventing symptomatic infection.
    • Moderna: Modera enrolled 6,700 children under 6-years old in its RCT and found the vaccine was 51% effective against symptomatic infection among children ages 6-months to 2-years, and 37% effective among those 2 to 5 years.
While it’s true these studies were small and the vaccine’s protection against symptomatic COVID was middling, as is true for every age group with Omicron, the CDC stated that the vaccines “are expected to provide higher protection against severe disease” in the youngest children. This is a very reasonable supposition. There is robust evidence from observational studies that the vaccine protects all older children against severe disease. As such, it’s not a great stretch to imagine it will similarly protect younger children. We’ll see.
Moreover, the vaccine was safe in the RCTs for younger children, and vaccine myocarditis, which is almost always mild, occurs in about 1 in 400,000 boys ages 5-11 years. While it’s possible a new side effect might emerge in younger children, we already know a lot about these vaccines, despite what Drs. Bienen and Hoeg want their readers to believe. Millions of older children have already been safely vaccinated.
The risks of repeatedly exposing unvaccinated children to COVID seem much greater than the risks of vaccinating them. While all doctors want pristine science, making decisions with less-than-perfect evidence is an everyday part of medicine, and leaving unvaccinated children vulnerable to COVID is absolutely a medical decision. Basically everything I’ve done in my career derives from a less sturdy evidence base than an RCT of a million people. Curiously, it’s only with pediatric COVID vaccination that “pro-vaccine” doctors demand such a large trial. I’ve not seen Dr. Hoeg call for a million-person RCT, or any studies at all, for the treatments she profits from.
Methodolatry part 3: An impossible, unethical study of dubious value that’s not meant to be taken seriously
How and where would a million-child RCT actually be done? How long would it take? Given how quickly the virus spreads and changes, would the results have any utility by the time the study was over? Have they done power calculations to see if meaningful information could be obtained from a smaller study? Should pediatric vaccines be taken off the market until a larger study is done, even if that is many years into the future? What would be the consequences of leaving unvaccinated children vulnerable during this time?
None of the doctors who’ve proposed a million-child RCT seem to have given a moment’s thought to these important questions. They’ve not written a 400-page protocol, or even a 4-page protocol, for their proposed RCT. This is because they don’t expect anyone to actually take them seriously. They know the regulators and pharma executives they criticize have no intention of starting an RCT of a million children, and they have no interest starting such a trial themselves. They know they are calling for an impossible study. And thus the contrivance becomes clear. A million-child RCT is nothing more than a rhetorical device that plays on their readers’ emotions and signals, “this vaccine isn’t necessary, and it hasn’t really been tested“.
While a million-child RCT with years of follow-up would be super duper, we are allowed to believe reasonable things in the absence of massive trials when children’s’ lives are at stake in the middle of a rapidly shifting pandemic. There is a real cost to leaving children vulnerable to an ever-changing virus, which is why pediatricians who actually treat sick children are eager to vaccinate their patients. According to the COVID Data tracker, over 500 children younger than 5-years have died of COVID thus far, and thousands more have been hospitalized, some intubated in the ICU. Hopefully vaccines will limit these numbers moving forward, even though contrarian doctors have done their best to limit their use by pretending that impossible, unethical studies of dubious value would be feasible if only drug companies weren’t so greedy.
Unsurprisingly, neither Dr. Bienen nor Dr. Hoeg has run any RCT of any size themselves. Unsurprisingly, neither of them cares for sick children. Instead, they are part of a cadre of sheltered doctors whose main contribution this pandemic has been to sit on the sidelines, while being omnipresent in the media, making unserious declarations that that amount to, “here’s what I would do if I had any real-world responsibility“. Remember that the next time they demand someone else do an RCT of a million children.

Peter Gøtzsche teams with an antivaxxer to exaggerate the harms of COVID-19 vaccines
Peter Gøtzsche, formerly leader of the Nordic Cochrane Center, has teamed with Maryanne Demasi to write a systematic review of the “harms” of COVID-19 vaccination. Besides accepting the highly dubious methodology behind one study, their preprint is yet another example of how EBM can be corrupted to promote antivax ideas.
David Gorsk on April 3, 2023
Link

When last I wrote about Peter Gøtzsche, it was a year before the COVID-19 pandemic hit and in the context of his having agreed to speak on the ethics of vaccine mandates alongside antivaccine “luminaries” like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Toni Bark, and Mary Holland at a conference organized by Physicians for Informed Consent, a prominent antivaccine physicians group. It didn’t take long before Gøtzsche was sufficiently embarrassed by the criticism directed his way to back out, claiming that he had been unaware that PIC was rabidly antivaccine. In the wake of the incident, he also later also complained bitterly that he wasn’t antivaccine—because of course he did!—and that he had hoped to persuade some of the attendees of the safety of the MMR vaccine. Portraying himself as misunderstood and unfairly attacked, Prof. Gøtzsche actually claimed that he had wanted to educate and persuade the attendees of the conference. I concluded at the time that he was either hopelessly ignorant and naïve or disingenuous, because his opposition to vaccine mandates not only aligned very closely with standard antivax opposition to vaccine mandates but used the same sort of language. The charitable interpretation at the time was that Prof. Gøtzsche didn’t understand that groups like PIC don’t mean the same thing that physicians and bioethicists do when they use the term “informed consent” in the context of vaccines (or any other medical intervention, for that matter). Let’s just say that there’s a reason why I call what they promote what I used to call “misinformed consent” but now refer to, more appropriately, as “misinformed refusal.”
I bring this part of Prof. Gøtzsche’s history up because late last week I noticed an article on the Brownstone Institute website by Maryanne Demasi touting a systematic review article by him entitled Serious Harms of the Covid-19 Vaccine: A Systematic Review. Apparently this is the second version of this systematic review posted to the MedRxiv preprint server, the first version having been posted in December and apparently unnoticed by me. I also mention that Maryanne Demasi is not a physician, although she apparently does have a PhD in rheumatology and did work for a decade at the Royal Adelaide Hospital in Australia as a research scientist. After that, she was a TV presenter for a number of years, during which she became known as a statin denier, who falsely claimed that cholesterol and saturated fats do not contribute to heart disease and that therefore statins are ineffective in lowering the risk of cardiovascular disease—and dangerous, to boot. More recently Demasi has aligned herself firmly with the antivaccine movement. She now contributes regularly to the Brownstone Institute and is frequently cited by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s minions at Children’s Health Defense. Her Substack is full of antivax content, including the usual antivax tropes about COVID-19 and masks, and she is a big fan of Dr. Asseem Malhotra.
Seeing this new systematic review as a preprint and noting that Prof. Gøtzsche had teamed up with an antivaccine and anti-statin activist, whose most recent shtick has been to claim that the original clinical trials of the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines did not account for serious harms, to write it, I had to wonder yet again: What is it about being a guru of evidence-based medicine (EBM) that predisposes to contrarian takes? Part of the reason I wondered this again is because, unlike some of the other EBM “gurus” (e.g., Drs. John Ioannidis and Vinay Prasad) who took a heel turn into COVID-19 contrarianism and antivax-adjacent positions, Prof. Gøtzsche has been on this path for a long time, dating back to years before the pandemic. If there were any EBM guru who could have been most easily predicted at the outset of the pandemic to go COVID-19 contrarian, it has to be Peter Gøtzsche, and his teaming up with Maryanne Demasi is just the latest indicator of that.
First, though, let’s take a look at the review itself, which is, again, only a preprint and remains as yet unpublished in a peer-reviewed journal.
The return of the revenge of “SAEs of special interest”
Reading the review article, I was immediately struck by this statement in the abstract:
We included 18 systematic reviews, 14 randomised trials, and 34 other studies with a control group. Most studies were of poor quality. A systematic review of regulatory data on the two pivotal trials of the mRNA vaccines found significantly more SAEs of special interest with the vaccines compared to placebo, and the excess risk was considerably larger than the benefit, the risk of hospitalisation.
Does that last part sound familiar? It should. It’s the claimed finding that was making the rounds on antivax social media last fall about “serious adverse events of special interest” from a “reanalysis” of the Pfizer and Moderna clinical trial data by Joseph Fraiman and Peter Doshi—yes, that Peter Doshi, the same one who originated what I like to call an antivax “slasher stat” claiming that the vaccines weren’t really 95% effective but only 19% effective—plus other coauthors submitted to the FDA to gain emergency use approval (EUA) for their mRNA-based vaccines. What were these “SAEs of special interest”? I’ll refer you to my original long discussion of what was wrong with the paper and how Fraiman, Doshi, et al had used “SAEs of special interest” to compare apples to oranges and falsely conclude that the risk of hospitalization from the vaccine was higher than it was from COVID-19. I’ll also refer you to Dr. Susan Oliver’s discussion of the study and its data dredging when it was still a preprint last summer:
And David Grimes’ Twitter thread:
..and you know what makes it so much worse? Even AFTER they tortured the data, they didn't even get a decent confession. Look at this table in their paper: the hazard ratios cross unity in almost every case. This is fancy statistics speak for "no effect was observed" pic.twitter.com/XYu4obR9cy
— Dr David Robert Grimes (@drg1985) September 2, 2022
Again, you can explore the previous links if you want the details, but the TL;DR version is simple. The study was deeply misleading based on its data dredging combined with misleading comparisons that included counting multiple adverse events in the same patient multiple times, further combined with a low enough risk of COVID-19 in the two populations at the time of the randomized controlled trials to allow for a low rate of hospitalization when normalized to the entire population in the control group. At the time, I also characterized it as nothing less than antivax misinformation disguised as a “reanalysis” of the original Pfizer and Moderna trials that didn’t even show what it claimed to have shown, namely that the trials were somehow designed and written in such a way as to hide lots of adverse events.
Now let’s see how Gøtzsche and Demasi incorporate this trial, which is obviously what they were talking about in the abstract, into their systematic review:
The most methodologically rigorous, reliable, and relevant research paper we retrieved was a systematic review conducted by researchers from USA, Spain, and Australia of regulatory data on the two pivotal randomised trials of the mRNA vaccines, one from Pfizer and one from Moderna.17
The review analysed SAEs in general and SAEs of special interest (AESI) according to two lists for the Brighton Collaboration criteria adopted by the WHO. The trials were expected to follow participants for two years. However, within weeks of the FDA emergency use authorisation, the sponsors began to unblind the participants and offered the vaccine to those in the placebo group.17 Therefore, the authors used the interim datasets that were the basis for the emergency authorisation, covering about four months after the trials commenced.
The authors included SAEs results tables from the websites of the FDA and Health Canada. Based on blinded tables, two clinicians judged independently whether an SAE was also an AESI. To account for multiple SAEs occurring in the same patient, a standard adjustment was used to widen the confidence intervals.
The “most methodologically rigorous, reliable, and relevant research paper”? You keep using that long term. I do not think it means what you think it means.

In the discussion, Gøtzsche and Demasi even doubled down on this characterization of the Fraiman/Doshi reanalysis:
By far the most reliable study we identified was the systematic review that used regulatory data from the two pivotal randomised trials of the mRNA vaccines and restricted the observation period to reduce the contamination caused by offering the vaccine to patients in the placebo group.17 The researchers put their findings into perspective by comparing them with hospitalisations. The excess risk of SAEs of special interest was considerably larger than the reduced risk of hospitalisation, 10.1 vs 2.3 per 10,000 vaccinated people for Pfizer’s vaccine, and 15.1 vs 6.4 for Moderna’s vaccine. Even after the researchers adjusted for multiple events in the same patient in a sensitivity analysis, the risk was larger.
Yes, once again, I emphasize that Gøtzsche and Demasi are referring to the awful Fraiman/Doshi antivax propaganda paper full of misleading comparisons and data dredging that was so bad that it should never have been published but somehow managed to fool the editors and peer reviewers of Vaccine and representing it as the best evidence available. While it doesn’t surprise me in the least that Demasi would mischaracterize this study as the best evidence available, Gøtzsche should know better but apparently no longer does. In fact, I would argue that the very fact that they characterized this study as so high quality and emphasized it so much in their review is almost enough reason to reject their entire systematic review as hopelessly biased, but there are other indicators of how biased and misleading their review is as well.
From obvious antivax propaganda to more subtle antivax propaganda
Another indicator that this systematic review is antivax propaganda besides its emphasis of a misleading review article as, apparently, the best current synthesis of evidence available, is to compare the first version of the review to the second version and look for changes. The reason is that the second version is likely what Demasi and Gøtzsche came up with in response to peer review of the first version. An example comes up right in the abstract. Compare the conclusion in the abstract version 1 to the conclusion in version 2.
Here’s the conclusion from the abstract of version 1:
Serious and severe harms of the COVID-19 vaccines have been ignored or downplayed, and sometimes been deliberately excluded by the study sponsors in high impact medical journals. This area needs further study. Authorities have recommended virtually everyone get vaccinated and receive booster doses. They fail to consider that the balance between benefits and harms becomes negative in low-risk groups such as children and people who have already acquired natural immunity.
However, this is the conclusion from the abstract of version 2:
Further randomised trials are needed. Authorities have recommended populationwide COVID-19 vaccination and booster doses. They do not consider that the balance between benefits and harms becomes negative in low-risk groups such as children and people who have already recovered from COVID-19 infection.
That conclusion in the abstract of version 1 is a pretty inflammatory conclusion, wouldn’t you say? (I wonder why it was changed for version 2.) In the first version, Gøtzsche and Demasi are basically stating as a conclusion that “they”—the pharmaceutical companies, regulatory agencies, etc., I guess—have been “ignoring,” “downplaying,” and even outright hiding “serious and severe harms” due to COVID-19 vaccines. It’s basically a conspiracy theory that is unproven. Why do I say that? For one thing, they reference a blog post by Maryanne Demasi to argue that adverse events in COVID-19 vaccine trials were “underreported” based on a 2016 review suggesting that adverse events were underreported in RCTs, without actually showing that the COVID-19 RCTs used to gain regulatory approval actually did underreport adverse events. In her blog post, she also relied on anecdotes and the usual antivax misinterpretation of reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database, where she also noted:
SAEs have been systematically eliminated from the pivotal trials.8 In the Pfizer and AstraZeneca vaccine trials, participants were given digital apps to record adverse events remotely, but the apps only allowed the participants to record what the company deemed as “expected” events. If they developed thrombosis, myocarditis, Guillain-Barré Syndrome, transverse myelitis, or other serious neurological events, there was no option for them to record it on the app.
Brianne Dressen, a participant in an AstraZeneca trial, became disabled after her first injection.8 She is still disabled today, but there is no mention of this in the trial report in New England Journal of Medicine.36 As Dressen was concerned about the lack of reporting of her serious adverse event (and others) in the trial’s publication, she wrote to Dr Eric Rubin, editor in chief of the journal, and asked for the inaccuracies to be corrected and demanded complete reporting of the results. Rubin refused to correct the inaccurate data in his journal. The full email exchange has been made public.8
Of course, at the time of the original RCTs, it had not yet emerged that myocarditis might be a risk from COVID-19 vaccines, making it therefore unsurprising that those events would not be included on the app, and, of course, the app was not the only method used to catalog adverse events. Another interesting thing that became apparent to me is that Ms. Dressen is reported to have been hospitalized, but in neither Demasi’s blog post nor the email exchange referenced in her post could I find what her disabling SAE claimed to have been due to the AstraZeneca vaccine actually was, beyond a “cascade of neurological symptoms” only vaguely described the videos referenced.
While I have little doubt that Ms. Dressen suffered, there is really no good evidence other than her belief that something nefarious happened or that she had been incorrectly excluded from from the reported results ultimately published or that AstraZeneca and the New England Journal of Medicine had somehow conspired to cover up SAEs from the vaccine. Even if you take her personal story at face value, it is one case and Demasi and Gøtzsche do not present any good evidence to suggest that her story is generalizable or common. Moreover, the passage from version 1 cited above about Brianne Dressen remains in version 2 word-for-word.
So, too, does this anecdote remain the same between versions:
When Pfizer had recruited 12-15 year olds for its mRNA vaccine trial, the published data in New England Journal of Medicine stated that there were “no serious vaccine-related adverse events.”46 One of the participants, however, was 13 year old Maddie De Garay who suffered a serious adverse reaction following her second injection, which left her in a wheelchair and fed by a nasogastric tube.10 She was referred to hospital for a full assessment and a doctor diagnosed her with a “functional disorder.” This doctor decided she had a pre-disposition to hysteria, and she was referred to a mental health facility. Professor and psychiatrist David Healy subsequently conducted a thorough review of her medical records, including an interview with her family, and found no such history of pre-existing conditions or mental illness.
Notice any commonalities, besides the narrative that the pharmaceutical companies somehow covered up SAEs? Both stories are anecdotes told from only one side. In the case of Maddie De Garay, the family has never presented any evidence that Maddie was diagnosed as harmed by a Covid-19 vaccine, and her story has been widely used in advertising by an antivaccine group run by Steve Kirsch. As is often the case, reading what advocates write about Maddie’s case does not allow even a good guess as to whether a claim of causation from the vaccine is plausible, and the information available is consistent with a diagnosis of functional disorder, not vaccine injury. In Dressen’s case, the story is not nearly as clearcut as it is being portrayed, although there are some scientists who speculate that her symptoms could be a rare case of long COVID being caused by vaccines rather than COVID-19. Both stories are being promoted by David Healy, a psychiatrist who, even a brief perusal of his blog and publication list reveals, is at least as anti-pharma as Peter Gøtzsche is, and, remember, Gøtzsche likes to compare pharmaceutical companies unfavorably to the mafia. Is this a reason to doubt his accounts regarding De Garay and Dressen? No, but it is a good reason to have a healthy dose of skepticism, particularly given the comparison he makes in this blog post:
So relentless was the focus on Scientologists that it became close to impossible for anyone to liaise with anyone who had any Scientology connections or even to think Prozac might cause problems without being branded as a Scientologist.
Anti-Vaxxers are the new Scientologists, liaison with whom will cause an instant loss of credibility.
Locating all our problems in 1990 in a fringe cult, leaving the rest of society to proceed with business as normal, did not seem such a hazardous thing to do. Now however we are extraordinarily polarized. The seeds of this polarization can be seen in the Prozac story. The most extreme polarization now centres on health issues, with people dividing into bioliberals and bioconservatives.
The middle ground has vanished. It is not possible to establish a middle ground even for those who are pro-vaccine but who have been injured by the vaccine.
How many times have we heard antivaxxers say things like this? Also, it’s not a good look for someone who claims to be pro-vaccine to be making such comparisons.
As for the rest, the key “findings” of this review include:
    • “Many of the studies we reviewed were of very poor quality and published in journals that failed to identify fundamental errors.” [Like Vaccine, which failed to identify the fundamental errors in the Fraiman/Doshi review? Sorry, couldn’t resist.]
    • “To date, the most methodologically rigorous systematic review of SAEs was conducted by Fraiman et al, which re-analysed trial data from two pivotal randomised trials of the mRNA vaccines (Pfizer & Moderna), including SAEs from the websites of the FDA and Health Canada. The risk of an SAE following vaccination exceeded the risk of hospitalisation from covid-19.”” [See the discussion above.]
    • “The adenovirus vector vaccines increased the risk of venous thrombosis and thrombocytopenia. (Authorities have responded by suspending the use of AstraZeneca’s vaccine across many European countries, and in the US, regulators have advised restricted use of Janssen’s vaccine).” [This is one of the few accurate findings, and we were writing about how the adenovirus-based vaccines appear to predispose to a rare clotting disorder—in 2021.]
    • “The mRNA-based vaccines increased the risk of myocarditis, with a mortality of about 1-2 per 200 cases. It was more common in younger males. [This leaves out the important context that myocarditis is uncommon from the mRNA vaccines, with an incidence of 0.0035%, and that the risk of death from COVID-19 induced myocarditis, which is much more common after the disease than the vaccine, is much higher.]
    • “We found evidence of serious neurological harms, including Bell’s palsy, Guillain-Barré syndrome, myasthenic disorder and stroke, which are likely due to an autoimmune reaction from mRNA and adenoviral vector vaccines.”” [I was personally puzzled by this one, because many of the studies cited in the review found no association with COVID-19 vaccines or even lower risk of neurologic sequelae after vaccination. Just read the relevant section if you don’t believe me.]
    • Drug regulators and other authorities have been very slow in following up signals of serious harms. [No, the COVID-19 vaccines have been arguably the most intensively monitored and studied vaccines in history.]
    • Severe harms, i.e. those that prevent daily activities, were underreported in the randomised trials. [This was not proven anywhere in the review other than anecdotally.]
    • Severe harms were very common in studies of fully vaccinated people receiving boosters (3rd dose), and in a study of vaccination of previously infected people (i.e. those with naturally acquired immunity).
That last one is worth discussing as well. The authors rely on one study to conclude that fully vaccinated people suffered severe harms after COVID-19 vaccination:
In an Israeli study, Pfizer’s vaccine was given to 78 people with a previous COVID-19 infection and to 177 matched controls.74 Some numbers and percentages are erroneous. Emergency department visit or hospitalisation was required for 5 (6%) vs 1 patients (0.6%). Even though the authors showed in a table that this difference was statistically significant (P = 0.01), they concluded that the vaccine was safe in people with previous infection. This is not correct. Hospitalisation is a serious harm, and harms occurred ten times as often if the patients had been infected earlier, suggesting that those with acquired immunity are at higher risk of experiencing SAEs post vaccination.
A much more recent review found much lower numbers:
Within 1 week of receipt of the first vaccine dose, a higher percentage of previously infected individual experienced AEs capable of interfering with daily activities compared with those with no history of COVID-19 infection (range, 12%-16% vs 3%-12%, respectively).
The percentage of individuals who experienced severe AEs requiring emergency department admission or hospitalization following vaccination also was increased among those who were vs were not previously infected with COVID-19 (range, 0.6%-0.7% vs 0.2%-0.5%).
May I suggest that Demasi and Gøtzsche update these figures to include this March 2023 review in the third version of their preprint?
Similarly, the claim that boosters (third dose) are so much more likely to cause SAEs is not well supported by the literature cited, and the authors dismiss studies that contradict their predetermined finding thusly:
In a US study of Pfizer’s vaccine, conducted by Pfizer, patients were randomised to receive a third dose or placebo.43 After a third dose, 16 of 5,055 patients had an SAE on the vaccine and 24 of 5,020 on placebo. The study was published in New England Journal of Medicine, and 24 of the 32 authors were from Pfizer or hired by Pfizer.
In other words, don’t believe a safety study because it was done by the pharmaceutical company. While I very much view studies done by pharmaceutical companies with more skepticism than those done by others investigators, I don’t use the fact that they were done by pharmaceutical companies as a reason to dismiss them out of hand, which is what is clearly implied here by Demasi and Gøtzsche. Similarly, when Demasi and Gøtzsche claim that “systematic reviews of randomised trials should be the most reliable source of evidence, but serious harms are vastly underreported, if reported at all, in published drug trials,” leading them to assert that, “underreporting seems to be particularly pronounced in vaccine trials.10,11,84 For the COVID-19 vaccines,” the only evidence that they reference are Gøtzsche’s books Deadly medicines and organised crime: How big pharma has corrupted health care and Vaccines: truth, lies, and controversy (and not even a specific chapter in either book!), Demasi’s blog post, and an article by Gøtzsche for his Institute for Scientific Freedom entitled The Chinese virus: Killed millions and scientific freedom. None of these are peer-reviewed scientific publications. Also, while it is true that the pharmaceutical industry has engaged in some unethical practices and covered up adverse event data, it is not enough to point to that history and say that it did happen with COVID-19 vaccines. You need to actually show that it did, something not done in this review.
Peter Gøtzsche: Medical maverick gone antivaccine (at least anti-COVID vaccine)
At this point, I’m not surprised that Prof. Gøtzsche would have teamed up with an antivaccine “journalist” with a history of statin denial to publish a “review” article claiming that SAEs from COVID-19 vaccines have been systematically “covered up” by, apparently, a cabal consisting of pharmaceutical companies manufacturing the vaccines and regulatory agencies tasked with approving the vaccines. As I noted in 2019, he was already well down that path, his opposition to vaccine mandates being, as it is for so many physicians and scientists who go antivax (heck, for anyone previously not antivax who goes antivax), a major factor that leads to susceptibility to believing and then spreading antivaccine misinformation. As I like to say, “Come for the parental rights and freedom from mandates, stay for the antivax conspiracy theories.” It’s an old story that long predates COVID-19.
Moreover, Prof. Gøtzsche had been continuing down that pathway before the pandemic. It wasn’t just his agreeing to speak at a conference organized by antivaxxers and then being shamed into backing out, as he did in early 2019. Before that, he had been fired as director of Nordic Cochrane Center after having published an unjustified and badly reasoned attack on the Cochrane Collaboration’s meta-analysis of the safety and efficacy of the human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccines, an attack that has been referred to (correctly, in my opinion) as a “hatchet job” that basically included a favorite anti-HPV trope about the use of saline placebo controls instead of adjuvant-containing placebo and another common antivaccine trope about the use of “surrogates” for cervical cancer, called cervical intraepithelial neoplasms (CIN).
It was also around the time that Prof. Gøtzsche was embarrassing himself by accepting and then backing out of an invitation to speak at an antivaccine conference alongside RFK Jr. that he formed his Institute for Scientific Freedom, where you can find interspersed with reasonable criticisms of the science used to develop and approve pharmaceuticals, a lot of antipsychiatry rhetoric and, yes, the promotion of COVID-19 minimization and “lab leak” conspiracy theories, and antivax misinformation like the review that he wrote with Demasi. There’s even an article entitled Should I get chemotherapy for cancer? Probably not, in which he concludes that, “from testicular cancer and lymphomas, I cannot imagine any cancer that would make me accept chemotherapy should I get cancer.” I’d suggest that if Prof. Gøtzsche ever gets colon cancer that is node-positive and successfully resected, he should take chemotherapy. Ditto for rectal cancer. Indeed, the last article is so appallingly awful that I’m keeping it in my back pocket as a topic if I ever need one, as it ignores the difference between primary and adjuvant chemotherapy, as well as a number of cancers for which chemotherapy has definitively been demonstrated to have survival benefits, such as in breast and colorectal cancer.
Earlier this year, I asked why the EBM paradigm seems to predispose to COVID-19 contrarianism. At the time, I speculated that, at least in part, it likely has something to do with how EBM values randomized controlled clinical trials above all other forms of evidence, even when RCTs are not the most appropriate methodology to examine a scientific question. In conclusion, revisiting the case of Peter Gøtzsche, I have to wonder if there is another reason that is indirectly related to the EBM paradigm, specifically experience with how much chicanery goes on in pharmaceutical company sponsored RCTs leading some EBM gurus, like Peter Gøtzsche, to go beyond a healthy skepticism of pharmaceutical companies and their RCTs into complete nihilism and cynicism that lead them to reject almost out of hand any pharmaceutical company-funded study. After all, if you genuinely think that pharmaceutical companies are worse than the mafia, as Prof. Gøtzsche has repeatedly stated and compare them to the mob, as he did in the title of one of his books, then how can you ever believe anything reported by pharmaceutical companies? This is the vibe that I get from Prof. Gøtzsche, along with an attitude that I frequently find in Cochrane and EBM gurus who don’t actually do clinical trials themselves, namely a lack of understanding of how RCTs have to be balanced with what is practical and ethical, how there must be clinical equipoise before an RCT can be considered ethical, and how, if an RCT is not practical or ethical, you simply have to accept other forms of evidence. Unfortunately, EBM considers anything below RCT evidence to be “weak.”
On the other hand, what does it mean if you say something like this:
Rather than relying solely on randomized controlled trials, he says, “observational studies and case reports can be very important for finding harms.”
In other words: RCTs above all for efficacy, but case reports and observational studies, the “lesser forms” of evidence are fine for finding “vaccine injury.” And antivaxxers pick up on this double standard, as they did at the first meeting of the Institute for Scientific Freedom four years ago:
The fact that Gøtzsche had inadvertently organized a kind of impromptu anti-vaccination convention became clear during the first Q&A, after the fourth or fifth successive question about vaccines. One questioner asked Peter Aaby — who conducts vaccine research in Africa — why, given the apparent abundance of studies showing that measles is actually good for you, we don’t try and study what happens when you give certain African children large doses of Vitamin C instead of “injecting them full of toxins” (i.e., giving them the measles vaccine).
“Could I perhaps ask also for questions about … not vaccines?” Gøtzsche asked eventually.
The next questioner promptly took the mic and said they had a question about vaccines.
“Please, please, please talk about something else now!” said Gøtzsche.
“I just want to say that the BCG part of tuberculosis, which is in the BCG vaccine, was never on the schedule in the U.S., and tuberculosis was the number two killer in — ”
“But please, excuse me, this is still — ”
The woman talked over him, so Gøtzsche raised his voice to match: “I ask you very kindly to not ask a question about vaccines at this point in time.”
I still chuckle when I read that account.
I like to contrast the sort of attitude shown by Prof. Gøtzsche to that of someone like, for instance, Ben Goldacre, who is very skeptical and suspicious of pharmaceutical companies but does not devolve into nihilism and such cynicism that he rejects everything they do. One can argue where the line should fall that divides healthy skepticism from cynicism and nihilism with respect to pharmaceutical companies and RCTs, but, wherever that line is drawn, I am now certain that Prof. Gøtzsche is now very much on the wrong side of it. After all, if you’re willing to team up with an antivaxxer like Maryanne Demasi, who brags that her blog post questioning if SAEs were being “downplayed or excluded” was the “impetus” for the review article you do with her, you have abandoned any right to complain when I—or others—start to wonder if you are antivaccine.

Apples, Oranges, and How Not to Analyze a Vaccine RCT
The evidence is overwhelming that COVID vaccines keep people alive and out of the hospital. Only someone who starts with the conclusion that vaccines don’t work and then works backwards to find the evidence could claim otherwise.
Jonathan Howard on July 4, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: Dr. Gorski decided to take the Fourth of July off and will return next week. Thankfully, Dr. Howard was happy to step in with this post.]
Dr. Peter Doshi, an associate professor of pharmaceutical health services research, is familiar to readers of SBM as someone who starts with the premise that vaccines are unsafe and ineffective, and then works backwards to find the evidence. His most recent attempt (along with Joseph Fraiman and other coauthors) to torture data to support his preconceived conclusions was a preprint titled “Serious Adverse Events of Special Interest Following mRNA Vaccination in Randomized Trials“. This paper analyzed both the Pfizer and Moderna RCTs, and predictably concluded:
The excess risk of serious adverse events of special interest surpassed the risk reduction for COVID-19 hospitalization relative to the placebo group in both Pfizer and Moderna trials.
That sounds bad, and sheltered virus-advocates were happy to spread this message far and wide (here and here).
At first glance, simply tallying the harms suffered by those in the vaccine and placebo groups sounds like a reasonable approach. But is it? Well, it all depends on how those harms are counted and for how long they are counted.
Dr. Susan Oliver, a scientist who studies nanomedicine at The University of New South Wales, made a short, must-watch video exposing the statistically chicanery Dr. Doshi used to reach his conclusions. Dr. David Gorski also discussed Dr. Doshi’s tricks here. Both Drs. Oliver and Gorski noticed that in determining “how these harms are counted”, Dr. Doshi ensured that the potential harms of the vaccine were inflated relative to harms of the virus. A single person who had gastroenteritis and abdominal pain after vaccination was counted as having two adverse events, while someone who was hospitalized with COVID, was counted once, even if they experienced a multitude of grave complications as a result.
Beyond this, Drs. Oliver and Gorski identified an even bigger problem. They realized Dr. Doshi’s entire paper was an exercise in comparing apples to oranges. To understand why, let’s briefly review the key results of the original COVID vaccine RCTs from the end of 2020.
    • In the Pfizer RCT, 21,720 people received the vaccine and 21,728 received placebo. There were 162 COVID cases in the placebo group and 8 in the vaccine group. There were 10 cases of severe COVID-19, 9 of which were in the placebo group, 1 the vaccine group.
    • In the Moderna RCT, there were 15,210 participants in the vaccine and placebo groups. Symptomatic COVID occurred in 185 participants in the placebo group and in 11 participants in the vaccine group. Severe COVID occurred in 30 participants, with one fatality, all in the placebo group.
We must now acknowledge two key points. First, depending on how quickly a virus spreads, the benefits of a vaccine can take many months, even decades to accumulate. Second, nearly all vaccine harms occur right after vaccination. Someone who analyzed the RCTs after one week would find the vaccine caused a bunch of people to feel unwell, while preventing zero cases of COVID. In all vaccine RCTs, the harms are frontloaded, while the benefits accrue gradually over time. Just look at those famous graphs from the COVID RCTs to see how obvious this is. Every month, the benefits from the vaccine became larger and larger – and the trial only lasted several months. In contrast, I can confidently state that few new vaccine harms were being reported at the trial’s end.
As a result, to adequately capture the vaccine’s benefits, an RCT would have to last the entire pandemic. As more and more people were exposed to the virus, the vaccine’s benefits relative to placebo would grow and grow, even considering that vaccine efficacy wanes. Had the trial lasted two years, there would be many more cases of severe COVID, especially in the unvaccinated cohort. As Dr. Oliver pointed out, an alternative to a pandemic-long RCT would be a challenge trial. Purposefully exposing participants to the virus would also create the apples to apples comparison Dr. Doshi pretends he has.
The raw numbers from the RCTs expose another problem with Dr. Doshi’s paper. The number of participants who received the vaccine was much larger than the number of participants who were exposed to the virus. In these two trials, there were 74,000 participants, 36,930 of them received a vaccine, while only 347 of them had COVID. The vaccine had many more opportunities than the virus to make people feel rotten during the RCT.
This was no accident. The RCTs were designed to end when a certain number of people contracted COVID. According to the Moderna protocol, “The primary analysis will be performed when approximately 151 cases have been observed in the study”. The Pfizer protocol set “a target of 164 primary-endpoint cases of confirmed Covid-19”. So by design, the trials concluded before the virus was allowed to harm more than several hundred people.
Notably, nearly all of those harmed by the virus received placebo. Like all subsequent studies, the RCTs showed that COVID was dangerous and the vaccine very effective at curtailing it’s dangers. There were 40 cases of severe COVID, all but one in the placebo cohort. That’s a pretty big deal considering that many more of those 74,000 trial participants have contracted COVID by now. Once this protection against severe COVID was known, it would have been unethical to continue the trials and allow people to remain unvaccinated. The trials had to end there.
When Dr. Doshi claims his “results show an excess risk of serious adverse events of special interest greater than the reduction in COVID-19 hospitalizations in both Pfizer and Moderna trials”, he doesn’t acknowledge these studies were terminated precisely because those hospitalizations began to accumulate. The trials were designed to stop once a small number of people got COVID, and Dr. Doshi spins this to claim COVID wasn’t much of a threat. These trials didn’t prove COVID wasn’t a threat. Rather they ended so rapidly precisely because COVID was a threat. Dr. Doshi and his many co-authors have cause and effect completely backwards.
Their “finding” was an entirely unsurprising, if not inevitable outcome from the way these trials were designed. There were never going to be more than several hundred people to be harmed by COVID in these studies. Dr. Doshi’s study would be of value only if the virus ceased to be a threat or the vaccine ceased to be of any benefit as soon as the RCT ended. Of course, even this fantasy would require that he tally the harms in a balanced way.
We all know what happened once the RCTs ended, and this has great bearing on Dr. Doshi’s preconceived conclusions. First, the virus spread everywhere. In the RCTs, there were 100 vaccinated people for every person who had COVID. That ratio is very different now, and this renders Dr. Doshi’s method of counting harms completely obsolete. Second, worse variants arrived, and these too nullify Dr. Doshi’s tallying method. If these RCTs were done when Delta was circulating, there would have been more than 40 cases of severe COVID, mostly in the unvaccinated group. This is because while vaccine efficacy against symptomatic infection drastically waned, the vaccine retained much of its benefit at preventing severe outcomes, especially when augmented by a third dose.
This technique of minimizing vaccine benefits by only focusing on RCTs of relatively short duration is well-known to vaccine-advocates. In my previous article on methodolatry, the inappropriate worship of RCTs alone, I described how anti-vaxxers are fond of pointing out that the HPV vaccine has never been shown to prevent cancer in an RCT. They’re right. But it was never a great leap to speculate that a vaccine that prevented HPV infection and pre-cancerous lesions in an RCT would eventually be shown to prevent HPV-related cancers. Indeed, there is now overwhelming evidence from observational studies this is the case.
Given this, honest brokers do not limit themselves to RCTs when evaluating vaccines. While observational studies are subject to more bias and cannot conclusively determine causality, unlike most RCTs, they can evaluate large numbers of people for long periods of time. As a result, they can reveal many things that RCTs can’t. We’ve learned much more about these vaccines from observational studies and billions of doses over two years than from the RCTs, where only 36,930 people received a vaccine, and only 366 people contracted COVID.
Anti-vaxxers are perfectly content to promote observational data, so long as it purports to reveal vaccines’ flaws. Notably, Dr. Doshi cited non-RCT data, including a VAERS dumpster dive, to highlight rare vaccine side-effects. In contrast, observational data is unmentionable to anti-vaxxers when it shows vaccine are safe and effective. Dr. Doshi neglected to reference a single non-RCT showing the vaccine’s benefits in his paper.
There is no shortage of such studies. The evidence is overwhelming that COVID vaccines are very safe and they keep people alive and out of the hospital. Only someone who starts with the conclusion that vaccines don’t work and then works backwards to find the evidence could claim otherwise.

Statistical Shenanigans?
The manufacturers of Covid-19 vaccines say they are 95% effective. Peter Doshi re-examined the evidence and estimates they are only 19-29% effective. This pre-print of an as-yet unpublished re-analysis raises many questions but doesn’t support the claims being made on antivaccine sites.
Harriet Hall on July 5, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: This is another analysis of the Fraiman & Doshi study discussed yesterday by Dr. Howard.]

A correspondent asked for my opinion about a study that he said has been appearing widely on COVID-19 vaccine disinformation sites with claims that it proves that the vaccines are not safe or that it shows there is “a 300% greater chance of landing in the hospital from the vaccine than from Covid itself”. I read the study. In the first place, I don’t think it showed any such thing. In the second place, there were several things about the study that made me distrust it:
    • It had not yet been peer-reviewed
    • It cited data from VAERS as if it were a trustworthy, meaningful source, which it isn’t; adverse events are listed on VAERS with no evidence that they were caused by the vaccine
    • It failed to mention the huge body of other evidence that overwhelmingly supports the efficacy and safety of the vaccines after extensive real-world experience (over 200 million doses administered in the US alone); an unbiased review of the scientific evidence must look at the entire body of published evidence rather than choosing one or a few studies that support one’s beliefs
    • Statistics can be manipulated and misinterpreted; if you don’t like the results you got, you can torture the data and pretty much make it confess to anything
AESI and the Brighton Collaboration
The study is titled “Serious adverse events of special interest following mRNA vaccination in randomized trials”. I questioned why some adverse events would be “of special interest”. The term “special interest” comes from a priority list developed by the Brighton Collaboration and endorsed by the World Health Organization (WHO).
As they explain, the Safety Platform for Emergency vACcines (SPEAC) Project generated a priority list of potential adverse events of special interest (AESI) for safety monitoring based on one or more of the following criteria:
     1.  Known association with immunization or a specific vaccine platform
     2.  Occurrence during wild-type disease as a result of viral replication and/or immunopathogenesis
     3.  Theoretical association based on animal models
Wait, what? A “theoretical association based on animal models”? Is that a reasonable criterion or mere speculation and opinion? What constitutes “special interest”?
I found the study difficult to read and very confusing. It presented no new data. The authors simply reviewed the studies that the vaccine manufacturers had submitted to the FDA when they applied for emergency use authorization (EUA). They tried to identify the adverse effects reported in those studies that were listed as adverse effects of special interest (AESI) in the report of the Brighton Collaboration. If I understand correctly, they did a re-count. The manufacturers had counted the number of individuals who had had adverse effects, but an individual could have more than one AESI so the authors of this study counted each AESI as a separate event.
By their revised accounting:
Pfizer and Moderna mRNA COVID-19 vaccines were associated with an increased risk of serious adverse events of special interest, with an absolute risk increase of 10.1 and 15.1 per 10,000 vaccinated over placebo baselines of 17.6 and 42.2 (95% CI -0.4 to 20.6 and -3.6 to 33.8), respectively. Combined, the mRNA vaccines were associated with an absolute risk increase of serious adverse events of special interest of 12.5 per 10,000 (95% CI 2.1 to 22.9). The excess risk of serious adverse events of special interest surpassed the risk reduction for COVID-19 hospitalization relative to the placebo group in both Pfizer and Moderna trials (2.3 and 6.4 per 10,000 participants, respectively).
Apparently the Covid vaccine disinformation folks interpreted this to mean the vaccines are unsafe and you are 300% more likely to be hospitalized if you are vaccinated. In my opinion, that represents poor reading comprehension and motivated reasoning.
Peter Doshi
One of the authors, Peter Doshi, is a senior editor at the British Medical Journal (BMJ) and an associate professor of pharmaceutical health services research at the University of Maryland School of Pharmacy. He has long been calling for independence and transparency in COVID-19 vaccine-related decision making, for instance here. He questions the trustworthiness and meaningfulness of the reported efficacy results of the mRNA vaccines.
I agree with Doshi that independence and transparency are essential in scientific research, and that the raw data should be released. He has raised several valid concerns about the manufacturers’ methodologies that cry out for more investigation. I am willing to accept that the reported 95% efficacy results are wrong, but I suspect that Doshi’s estimates of 19% and 29% efficacy are also wrong, maybe even wronger.
This is serious stuff. A pandemic is a public health emergency. Without effective treatment, people will die. The public must have access to accurate information. Releasing raw data from the trials would be a step in the right direction. Doshi is right about that.
Conclusion: The waters are muddier
I’m afraid this new study confuses the issue rather than clarifying it. Someone is engaging in shenanigans with statistics. Is it the vaccine manufacturers? Is it the authors of this new study? Neither? Both? I leave it to you to decide. I’m not a statistician. I hope people more knowledgeable about statistics will chime in with their informed opinions.

Antivaccine leader Del Bigtree on COVID-19: “Let’s catch this cold!” Why antivaxxers and coronavirus conspiracy theorists are often one in the same.
Last week, antivaccine activist Del Bigtree posted a rant denying the severity of COVID-19, blaming the chronically ill for having made themselves vulnerable to severe disease through their lifestyle choices, and urging the young and healthy to “catch this cold”. His rant shows exactly why COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and antivaxxers have such an affinity for each other and have teamed up to resist public health initiatives.
David Gorski on June 22, 2020
Link

One of the happy delusions that many in the science-based community (including, at least somewhat, myself) and mainstream press have held over the years that has been punctured by the arrival of COVID-19 is that one main reason that antivaccine beliefs persist is that we’ve forgotten the toll that the diseases against which we vaccinate. If, for instance, measles returned with a vengeance, or haemophilus influenza type B, or polio, antivaxxers would see the error of their ways, and resistance to vaccination would diminish. How many times have you heard this argument? How many times have I suggested this? It’s a comforting thought. However, truth be told, it is also one that makes us, as science advocates, feel a bit smug and confident. That’s not to say that there isn’t a grain of truth in this idea, particularly for the vaccine-hesitant, but for hard-core antivaxxers, it has been a comforting myth. But why is it a myth? It seems so obvious, so rational, to think that the return of deadly diseases would knock some sense into antivaxxers’ heads. So why have antivaxxers aligned themselves with COVID-19 deniers and conspiracy theorists in the most emphatic way possible, with a number of COVID-19 lockdown protests being organized by antivaxxers? Let me provide some perspective as someone who’s been following the antivaccine movement for nearly two decades and writing about it regularly for over 15 years. I will admit that these are my observations, and that there isn’t a lot of research, but perhaps I can provide some ideas for actual research and action.
Before I go on, I feel obligated to point out that the evidence that this idea that, if only antivaxxers could see the pain, suffering, and death caused by infectious diseases, antivaxxers would come to their senses, was revealed fairly clearly to be a myth long before COVID-19 hit the US earlier this year. As I described a little over a year ago, you have to do is to look at the reaction of antivaxxers to the numerous measles outbreaks that have occurred over the last decade in areas of low uptake of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine. (As an aside, in this age of the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s hard for me not to be almost nostalgic for times when measles outbreaks were one of my main concerns. That’s not to downplay the severity of measles. Anyone who’s read my work, either here on this blog or over at my not-so-super-secret other blog should know that I do not downplay the severity of measles.) I could mention how antivaxxers reacted to the measles outbreaks among Somali immigrants in Minnesota, a reaction that involved denial of their culpability for fear mongering about MMR as a cause of autism and of the severity of measles. Basically, they doubled down on their antivaccine propaganda. Measles in Samoa? The same thing. Antivaccine “thought leader” Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. wrote a pseudoscience- and misinformation-filled letter to the Samoan Prime Minister, while antivaccine activists doubled down promoting fear mongering about MMR. Meanwhile, across the US, in response to the measles outbreak in Brooklyn, antivaxxers denied responsibility, even though they had promoted fear mongering about MMR. Basically, if you’re surprised that antivaxxers have allied themselves with COVID-19 deniers, you haven’t been paying attention. The unholy alliance between antivaxxers and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists is a natural fit.
I’ve alluded to the affinity between antivaxxers and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists before, but at the time I focused on how both of their ideologies are rooted in conspiracy theories, such as the notion that 5G somehow predisposes to (or even causes) COVID-19, that glyphosate predisposes people to COVID-19, that COVID-19 was created in a laboratory and is a “plandemic” designed to provide a pretext for authoritarian control, or that the flu vaccine predisposes people to COVID-19. Basically, COVID-19 has been a magnet for medical conspiracy theories, which is why antivaxxers have launched a pre-emptive disinformation campaign on a COVID-19 vaccine that does not yet exist.
Hostility towards public health
So, what is the other commonality between antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers and conspiracy theorists? Think about it, and I suspect you’ll come up with the same answer I did: An unrelenting hostility towards public health. This hostility towards public health interventions manifests itself with a refusal to take responsibility to do anything that decreases the risk of COVID-19 transmission. Think about it. For example, how many times have we seen antivaxxers denying the very concept of herd immunity, at least due to vaccines? (They like to claim that “natural herd immunity,” gained through a large percentage of the population getting a disease, is far superior, even though such immunity cannot be achieved without mass suffering from a large percentage of the population getting an infectious disease and might not even be a thing.) Here’s another way of putting it: How many times have you heard antivaxxers making the argument that, if vaccines work, you shouldn’t be worried about their unvaccinated children? How often have you heard them reject any responsibility whatsoever for any children other than their own, dismissing the concerns of parents of children with cancer or other conditions that leave them immunosuppressed and unable to take certain vaccines? Some of you might even recall antivaxxers dismissing vaccines as important and then saying they’d just quarantine in the event of an outbreak. Contrast that to what antivaxxers are doing now, protesting against lockdowns, refusing to wear masks, refusing to abide by social distancing, and, in essence, claiming that COVID-19 is no big deal.
Del Bigtree: “Let’s catch this cold!”
Last week, a prominent antivaxxer, Del Bigtree, whom you will likely remember as the genius behind the antivaccine propaganda film disguised as a documentary, VAXXED, demonstrated this hostility towards reasonable public health interventions in a segment from his online video show, The Highwire With Del Bigtree posted on June 19.
Here’s the video as posted to Facebook:
And here’s a version of the video as posted by The Real Truther, with a fascinating counterpoint at the end:
Watch #antivax charlatan @delbigtree of @HighWireTalk:
• Blame #COVID19 victims for their own deaths• Encourage everyone to not wear masks• Claim #COVID is as harmless as "the common cold"• Encourage people to intentionally catch the virus https://t.co/nc28vZxe90
— TheReal Truther (@thereal_truther) June 19, 2020
Also on YouTube:
It occurred to me as I watched this video that there’s one other characteristic that antivaxxers share with COVID-19 deniers: Victim blaming and an utter lack of concern for those with chronic health problems. (In the case of antivaxxers, there is one exception. They do care about children whose chronic health problems they think they can blame on vaccines, but from my perspective they only care about them insofar as they can use them to blame vaccines for autism, autoimmune diseases, sudden infant death syndrome, diabetes, and the myriad chronic health conditions that have led antivaxxers like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to falsely claim that today’s generation is the “sickest generation“, all due to vaccines.) Look at the title of Bigtree’s video, WE NEED TO CATCH THAT COLD!
Bigtree starts out by claiming that COVID-19 has a “death rate” of 0.26%. (One notes that he doesn’t cite a source.) Even if that is true, he seems oblivious to the law of large numbers and unconcerned that, if one million people catch the disease, that means 2,600 dead and that if 100 million people catch the disease (as could happen) that means 260,000 dead. He then goes on to claim that it might only be one-fifth that, again, without citing the evidence. He then goes into a despicable diatribe, which, in case Bigtree memory-holes his rant, I am transcribing extensively because it is a near-perfect distillation of antivaccine “thinking” and the “screw the old and infirm” attitude that many COVID-19 deniers express:
What is the group that is really at risk? Let’s be honest about this and say something that might get me some trouble here, but let’s be honest. That group is very well known. It’s people over the age of 65—not just because you’re over the age of 65, but you’re sick with other diseases. You have heart disease. You have COPD. You have diabetes. You have issues, many of those issues coming from the fact that you didn’t treat your body very well while you were on this planet. And I want to talk about this for one minute as we close this down. That 0.26% are the most sick among us, and I have nothing against you. Go ahead and bubble wrap your house. Lock yourself in your basement. Go and do what’s necessary.
But here’s the problem. When you were my age, you were most likely eating food and fast food and Doritos and drinking Coca-Cola, which you’ll never find in my home. You were eating that all the time. You probably were drinking a lot of alcoholic beverages and really liked to party and enjoyed your cigarettes and said to yourself, “You know what? It’s more about the quality of my life right now. I don’t care if I live to be 100 years old. I want to enjoy my life right now. I like the finer things in life. I like good rich food. I like smoking a cigarette once in a while. I like to drink my drinks.” And you know what? Good on you! That’s the United States of America. No problem, that, some of my best friends think like that. It’s great, and they’re fun to hang out with. That’s perfectly OK.
But here’s what’s not OK. When you reach that point in your life where now your arteries are starting to clog up, your body is shutting down, and the alcohol is eating up your liver, and you have diabetes, or you have multiple COPD, you have asthma, you can’t breathe, all the cigarette smoking has finally caught up with you, you have heart disease because of the way you decided to live your life in the moment, here’s what you are now. You are pharmaceutical-dependent. You did that to yourself, not me. You decided that the moment mattered, and now you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent, which is really what that 0.26% is, and that’s OK too. Thank God there’s drugs out there! There’s drugs that allow you to eat the Philly cheesesteak even though your body knows it hates it, but, go ahead, take the Prilosec. What difference does it make? Drug yourself! Drug yourself! Get through the day! Don’t exercise! Maybe just attach an electrode and see if a little electricity to the stomach will give you the abs you want.
Come on! Grow up! You made choices! And now that you’re pharmaceutically dependent, here’s what you don’t get to do. You don’t get to say I have to take a drug to protect you. That’s what this is. You don’t get to say I have to wear a mask and suck in my own CO2 to protect you. You don’t get to say I have to lock myself in a basement and destroy my career and take away my own ability to feed children because you are pharmaceutical dependent. You lived your life. You made your choice. And thank God we live in the United States of America so you don’t have to worry about grocery police standing outside a grocery store saying, “Really? You really need four liters of Coca-Cola? You really need four bags of Doritos or Chitos or Fritos or whatever the heck it is, little cupcakes with synthetic icing on them? You really need all that?” Because we could go there. We could go there. If we’re really going to get into each other’s schiznit, that’s what we could do.
Or could we live and let live? Eat all the Twinkies you want! Drink all the bourbon you want, and smoke as many cigarettes as you want, and when you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent I will go ahead and say thank God the drug companies are there for you, but you do not get to make me pharmaceutical-dependent. You do not get to put me in the way of Heidi Larson, who wants to eradicate natural health and natural immunity and make us all pharmaceutical dependent.
Heidi Larson, for those of you who don’t know who she is, is the director of the Vaccine Confidence Project, a group dedicated to combatting vaccine hesitancy. When last we saw her elsewhere, she had put her foot in her mouth most spectacularly by ignorantly discounting how much education about immunology and vaccines a typical physician in training receives, which leads me to just what the heck Bigtree means by “pharmaceutical dependent”. After all, you might think that no one is telling him he has to take a medication to protect others. All he’s being asked to do is to wear a facemask when in public around other people, to abide by social distancing guidelines, and to wash his hands and/or use hand sanitizer frequently. These are hardly onerous requests; yet they’ve produced an extreme backlash. Think about it though. What Bigtree is doing when he says, “You do not get to make me pharmaceutical-dependent” is that he is signaling to his followers that he is preemptively refusing a coronavirus vaccine before one has even been approved by the FDA. Of course, he’s also refusing to wear a mask and social distance—I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt that he’s not refusing to wash his damned hands—but primarily he’s saying he refuses to be vaccinated against coronavirus once there is a vaccine. Larson’s job at the WHO is to develop strategies to increase public confidence in vaccines and combat vaccine hesitancy and antivaccine views. That’s why Bigtree mentioned her.
At this point, let me emphasize how extremely judgmental Bigtree is in this video, his disclaimers of “Good on ya!” and “It’s OK!” to those with chronic diseases notwithstanding. He’s contemptuously blaming people with chronic diseases for being chronically ill. There is, of course, a small kernel of truth buried in his rant in that, yes, lifestyle matters when it comes to chronic disease. Smoking does hugely predispose you to lung and cardiovascular diseases, for example. Overeating does predispose to obesity, although it is way more complicated than Bigtree’s version of it, which, boiled down to its essence, demonizes those with obesity as fat slobs who lived their youth and middle age overindulging without a care in the world for what their “choices” are doing to their body. Those who’ve struggled with weight problems know that you can’t just flip a switch and bring your weight under control, just as those who’ve become addicted to, for example, alcohol or tobacco, can’t just flip a switch and stop drinking and smoking, even though they know their addictions are having adverse effects on their health. He also seems unconcerned that COVID-19 could well lead to more deaths from cancer, due to delays in treatment. One wonders if he views nearly all cancer as preventable when it is not.
This sort of attitude is very typical of antivaxxers and is born of how much antivaxxers believe in alternative medicine and “natural” treatments. It’s also, I’ve noticed, very typical of COVID-19 deniers, many of whose attitude seems to be, “Screw the old and chronically ill, I need to golf and get a haircut!” Indeed, this attitude started to take root fairly early in the pandemic, when a number of politicians of a certain political bent (you know which one) argued in essence that we need to sacrifice grandpa and grandma in order to save the economy. Fortunately, this is not an attitude shared by most Americans, although it is de facto policy in too many parts of the country.
I once coined a term, the central dogma of alternative medicine, to describe the belief that we have near-total control over our health through lifestyle, such as diet, activity, exercise, and a Secret-like belief that wishing makes it so. Antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers share that mystical, magical belief system in which they are healthy entirely because of their choices, and they (and their children) are not at risk of horrible outcomes due to infectious disease because of their choices. It never occurs to them that age is a major risk factor for death from COVID-19 and that people can’t do anything about how old they were when the pandemic hit. Similarly, it never seems to trouble antivaxxers like Bigtree or COVID-19 deniers, the vast majority of whom are white and at least middle class if not affluent, that COVID-19 has exacted a much worse toll on African-Americans and other people of color, who are far more likely to suffer severe disease and die. (Yes, I’m going there.)
Bigtree goes way farther than that, though. He goes deep into the realm of very dangerous advice. After laying down an obvious lie in which he states that he does “care about his pharmaceutical-dependent friends”, and says that the only thing he can do for them (other than hoping for a “vaccine unicorn”) is to catch “what is just a common cold”. Of course, COVID-19 is far worse than “just a common cold”. The common cold doesn’t kill 120,000 Americans in less than four months and nearly a half a million worldwide in six months. It just doesn’t. Influenza hasn’t done anything like that in over 100 years!
Bigtree goes on to claim that for over 97% of us COVID-19 is so mild that you won’t get a fever or even know that you have it, claiming “it’s a common cold for 99.74% of us”. This is a gross exaggeration. The rate of asymptomatic COVID-19 has been notoriously tricky to estimate, given that often there’s no longitudinal testing to see if those who are asymptomatic when tested go on to develop symptoms. In reality, the percentage of cases of COVID-19 that remain asymptomatic is probably 30-50%, and these people with asymptomatic infection can still transmit the disease. Also, there is a growing body of evidence showing that masks do decrease the rate of transmission of COVID-19 to other people, as I discussed a couple of weeks ago. Since then, there’s even more evidence suggesting that masks work to prevent the spread of COVID-19
None of this stops Bigtree from saying:
So here’s what we do. Let’s go outside. Let’s take off our masks. We’re not on drugs, and we don’t need to be on drugs. Let’s catch this cold! Whether or not it’s just the 20% of us and maybe we’re not even in that category, let’s give it a college try to catch this cold, so that we can protect the pharmaceutical-dependent amongst us!
At this point it’s hard not to retort: You first, Mr. Bigtree. I’m sure one of your fans out there has COVID-19 right now and would be willing to hang out with their hero in a small, enclosed room for hours and cough in your face as much as it takes for you to acquire SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. What are you waiting for? Do it for the “pharmaceutical-dependent”! Lead by example! Record yourself on video doing it!
I’m being sarcastic, of course. I would never wish COVID-19 on anyone, not even someone as odious and harmful to public health as Bigtree. I note that Bigtree just turned 50, so he’s entering the age range of elevated risk. Whether Bigtree believes it or not, if he were actually foolish enough to take my sarcastic advice, I’d actually feel terrible if he turned out to be one of the minority who develop disease severe enough to require hospitalization, even worse if he were among the smaller minority who end up needing mechanical ventilation, and worse still if he were one of the probably fewer than 1% who die of COVID-19.
Perhaps the best retort, though, is what The Real Truther did in editing Bigtree’s video. During the last minute and a half or so of The Real Truther’s version, there are shown a series of photographs of people who were young (or, at most, middle aged) and otherwise healthy who died of COVID-19, the youngest of whom was 22. He also added a soundtrack of somber piano music. Brilliant. And in case that’s enough, SFGate published a story recounting the damage done to young people who have survived severe COVID-19, including kidney failure requiring dialysis, shortness of breath that persists for many weeks, the need for chronic oxygen, multiple relapses, and other complications.
The consequences are potentially dire
As I’ve documented for a long time, antivaxxers are hostile to the very idea of public health, other than letting nature take its course and producing “natural herd immunity” at a horrific cost in terms of suffering and death. If you don’t believe me, consider how in recent years they have manifested their hostility towards public health interventions not just in the form of resistance to school vaccine mandates, but in proposing laws and regulations that would make it more difficult for local health authorities to prevent and respond to outbreaks even leaving aside the issue of vaccines. For instance, in my own state, antivaccine-sympathetic legislators proposed a law that would have made it much more difficult to remove vulnerable unvaccinated students from school in the middle of an outbreak and removed a lot of flexibility to respond to outbreaks. More recently, a chickenpox outbreak at a high school in my state revealed that antivaxxers were not being entirely truthful when they claimed they’d comply with reasonable self-quarantine orders, as parents protested the order to keep their children at home. Meanwhile, antivaxxers have joined COVID-19 conspiracy theorists in portraying contact tracing and quarantine as “subjugation.”
That rhetoric is having terrifying consequences, too, as public health workers have come under attack, with harassment and threats, leading an alarming number of them to resign to protect themselves and their families or to be fired for standing up for public health:
Emily Brown was stretched thin.
As the director of the Rio Grande County Public Health Department in rural Colorado, she was working 12- and 14-hour days, struggling to respond to the pandemic with only five full-time employees for more than 11,000 residents. Case counts were rising.
She was already at odds with county commissioners, who were pushing to loosen public health restrictions in late May, against her advice. She had previously clashed with them over data releases and control and had haggled over a variance regarding reopening businesses.
But she reasoned that standing up for public health principles was worth it, even if she risked losing the job that allowed her to live close to her hometown and help her parents with their farm.
Then came the Facebook post: a photo of her and other health officials with comments about their weight and references to “armed citizens” and “bodies swinging from trees.”
It’s not just harassment and political resistance. Being overworked and stretched thin because of how inadequate many states’ public health infrastructure was before the pandemic play a role too. A week and a half ago, Ohio health director Dr. Amy Acton, who had made national news for her science-based approach to COVID-19 and public health, resigned, due to a burnout from overwork and dealing with protesters and resistance, for example:
Acton’s experience was no different. Protesters, some armed, showed up at her home in the Columbus suburbs several times. Her neighbors counter-protested in her front yard and put up “Dr. Amy Acton Fan Club” yard signs. Acton was given security detail, an unusual step for a cabinet member.
It’s hard to blame Dr. Acton for deciding that she couldn’t take it anymore. Nationwide, a number of health directors have either retired, quit, or been fired in the face of harassment, resistance, and the unhappiness of politicians:
This isn’t just happening in California. Ohio’s state health director, Amy Acton, resigned last week after facing legal challenges to her authority and protests in front of her home. Wisconsin state health director Jeanne Ayers was asked to resign in early May, at a time when COVID-19 cases in the state had surpassed 10,000, and top officials would not say why.
“Things have gotten ugly,” said one Northern California health officer who asked not to be named over personal safety concerns. “The health officers are kind of in this position where everything that everyone is angry about is the health officer’s fault.”
The official described death threats received by email and on social media as well as protesters showing up to their home. “It … makes you feel that there is nowhere that’s safe.”
No one argues that there isn’t a difficult tradeoff to be made between public health and economic interests. However, the hostility towards public health interventions goes beyond anger at the economic consequences of lockdowns. Wearing masks and contact tracing, with targeted quarantines, are thought to be our best options to be able to emerge from lockdowns and revive the economy, and yet the unholy alliance of antivaxxers and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists feverishly resist these measures, too.
        ◦ Truly, it should surprise no one that antivaxxers have joined COVID-19 deniers in their conspiracy theories or that they loudly proclaim opposition and resistance to any COVID-19 vaccine, even though a COVID-19 vaccine is many months, if not years, away. When you boil it down, both groups share a profound resistance to taking the least bit of responsibility for anyone but themselves and a tendency to blame the victim. They fail to understand that personal health can’t be separated from public health. It’s no wonder that the US has had more cases and deaths from COVID-19 than any other country in the world.

J.B. Handley’s unthinking person’s guide to the COVID-19 pandemic
J.B. Handley was the founder of the antivaccine group Generation Rescue. Unfortunately, in the era of COVID-19 he’s started peddling pseudoscience related to the pandemic. Some things never change.
David Gorski on June 15, 2020
Link

One of the more bizarre things that have happened related to the COVID-19 pandemic is the way that antivaccine activists have formed an unholy alliance with COVID-19 conspiracy theorists. On the other hand, it might seem bizarre to those not familiar with antivaccine pseudoscience, but it actually makes perfect sense to those of us who have been following the antivaccine movement for a long time, for the simple reason that all antivaccine pseudoscience is based on conspiracy theories. So it isn’t much of a surprise that someone I’ve been following for a very long time (16 years!) has gone all-in on COVID-19 conspiracy theories. I’m referring to J.B. Handley, the man who, with his wife, founded Generation Rescue, an antivaccine group dedicated to the now refuted hypothesis that mercury in vaccines causes autism. When last we met him three years ago, he was once again attacking vaccine science and spewing his usual antivaccine misinformation. Before that, he was known for misogynistic attacks on female journalists writing about antivaxxers and attacks against defenders of science in general. These days, he’s posting his pseudoscience on the website of Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivaccine group Children’s Health Defense in an article entitled “LOCKDOWN LUNACY: The Thinking Person’s Guide.” It’s useful to examine, because it’s basically a cornucopia of COVID-19 misinformation, disinformation, and conspiracy theories.
Handley’s article is constructed based on what he calls “facts.” As is so frequently the case with articles of this sort, his sixteen “facts” are a mixture of facts (deceptively presented), nonsense, and “sort-of” facts that are partially true, all used to cast doubt on the conventional narrative about COVID-19. All of them are basically cherry picked claims. Before I dig in, let me just mention something about J.B. Handley. He is not a scientist of any sort. He’s a businessman who co-founded and co-managed Swander Pace Capital, a private equity firm, until retiring in early 2014. He has no background in science, immunology, autism, infectious disease, vaccines, or, of course, COVID-19. Moreover, he’s known for his admiration of antivaccine icon Andrew Wakefield, whom he likens to “Nelson Mandela and Jesus Christ rolled up into one.” None of that stops him from engaging in his usual nonsense of the sort that I’ve been commenting on since 2005. So, with that history in mind, let’s dig in. Here’s his first “fact”:
Fact #1: The Infection Fatality Rate for COVID-19 is somewhere between 0.07-0.20%, in line with seasonal flu.
The Infection Fatality Rate math of ANY new virus ALWAYS declines over time as more data becomes available, as any virologist could tell you. In the early days of COVID-19 where we only had data from China, there was a fear that the IFR could be as high as 3.4%, which would indeed be cataclysmic. On April 17th, the first study was published from Stanford researchers that should have ended all lockdowns immediately, as the scientists reported that their research “implies that the infection is much more widespread than indicated by the number of confirmed cases” and pegged the IFR between 0.12-0.2%. The researchers also speculated that the final IFR, as more data emerged, would likely “be lower.” For context, seasonal flu has an IFR of 0.1%. Smallpox? 30%.
Here, I like to cite Carl T. Bergstrom, a professor of biology, whose Twitter feed is essential reading (if you’re on Twitter) in this era of COVID-19. He notes that this claim is false, both in its estimate of how low the COVID-19 infection fatality rate is and on what the infection fatality rate is of typical seasonal flu. For instance, Handley cites John Ioannidis’ much-criticized (and rightfully so) seroprevalence study carried out in Santa Clara County, California that claimed to have found that the number of people who’d been infected with SARS-CoV-2 in the California county of Santa Clara was 50 to 85 times higher than previously thought, elevated numbers that suggested that the vast majority of COVID-19 were milder than previously thought and that the infection fatality rate was much lower than previously thought. The problems with this study are summarized here, here, and here, but the bottom line is that it examined a biased sample. As Bergstrom notes, the best estimates range of the infection fatality rate of COVID-19 range from 0.5% to 1.5%:
Unsurprisingly, Handley also cites Dr. Scott Atlas, a Fellow at the Hoover Institution of Stanford University, a well-known conservative think tank known for downplaying the severity of COVID-19 and opposing lockdowns as a strategy to slow the spread of COVID-19. One notes that Dr. Atlas is a neuroradiologist and has no particular expertise in infectious disease or epidemiology. His entire shtick is to argue that COVID-19 is no big deal, that the risk of dying from it is so low that radical measures to stop it are not indicated.
Next up:
Fact #2: The risk of dying from COVID-19 is much higher than the average IFR for older people and those with co-morbidities, and much lower than the average IFR for younger healthy people, and nearing zero for children
This is true, but the proper response to this is: So What? Handley basically uses these data to argue that it’s only old people who are dying; so closing schools makes no sense. There is an argument to be made that, because children are much less likely to become severely ill from COVID, school closures should be reconsidered, there is still a lot of uncertainty in this area. He cherry picks a single study suggesting that schools in Ireland are not a driver of COVID-19 spread, and runs with it. At least he concedes that older teachers and school employees might have something to fear.
Handley goes on:
Fact #3: People infected with COVID-19 who are asymptomatic (which is most people) do NOT spread COVID-19
As is Handley’s usual practice, he cherry picks a single case and a single study. There is actually abundant evidence that presymptomatic or asymptomatic individuals can spread COVID-19. For example, Eric Topol and Daniel Oran reviewed the evidence by examining a number of cohorts with COVID-19, finding that, yes, around 40% of COVID-19 cases are asymptomatic but also finding that asymptomatic patients can drive transmission:
Asymptomatic persons seem to account for approximately 40% to 45% of SARS-CoV-2 infections, and they can transmit the virus to others for an extended period, perhaps longer than 14 days. Asymptomatic infection may be associated with subclinical lung abnormalities, as detected by computed tomography. Because of the high risk for silent spread by asymptomatic persons, it is imperative that testing programs include those without symptoms. To supplement conventional diagnostic testing, which is constrained by capacity, cost, and its one-off nature, innovative tactics for public health surveillance, such as crowdsourcing digital wearable data and monitoring sewage sludge, might be helpful.
While it’s not entirely clear if completely asymptomatic COVID-19 patients who never develop symptoms transmit COVID-19 less frequently than presymptomatic people (those who ultimately do go on to develop symptoms), there is little doubt that asymptomatic people, whether they do or don’t go on to develop symptoms, do transmit COVID-19.
Next up:
Fact #4: Emerging science shows no spread of COVID-19 in the community (shopping, restaurants, barbers, etc.)
I laughed at this one. “Emerging” science shows no such thing. Handley’s claim is based on interviews with a single German scientist in Business Insider and RTL Today. As Bergstrom notes, Handley confuses the absence of evidence for the evidence of absence, noting that community spread while shopping or doing other activities out in public is much harder to track down via contact tracing methodology than spread among co-workers, family members, and the like, because there is no easy way to figure out who was in the store or other facility at the same time and connect spread that way. We also know that spread by respiratory droplets is important, which supports the spread of the disease whenever humans are in close contact.
Handley then goes on to lie:
Fact #5: Published science shows COVID-19 is NOT spread outdoors.
In a study titled “Indoor transmission of SARS-CoV-2” and published on April 2, 2020, scientists studied outbreaks of 3 or more people in 320 separate towns in China over a five-week period beginning in January 2020 trying to determine where outbreaks started: in the home, workplace, outside, etc.? What’d they discover? Almost 80% of outbreaks happened in the home environment. The rest happened in crowded buses and trains. But what about outdoors? The scientists wrote:
All identified outbreaks of three or more cases occurred in an indoor environment, which confirms that sharing indoor space is a major SARS-CoV-2 infection risk.
Actually, the very study cited demonstrated that transmission outdoors is actually possible. Also, not surprisingly, Handley ignores studies that do show outdoor transmission of coronavirus. One such study (caution: on a preprint server) estimates that the chance of transmission of COVID-19 in a closed environment is 18.7 times greater compared to an open-air environment (95% confidence interval. It’s probably true that transmission is considerably less likely outdoors, but it’s nonsense to claim that COVID-19 is not spread outdoors.
“Fact #6” amuses me, given the topic of last week’s post:
Fact #6: Science shows masks are ineffective to halt the spread of COVID-19, and The WHO recommends they should only be worn by healthy people if treating or living with someone with a COVID-19 infection.
And:
Fact #7: There’s no science to support the magic of a six-foot barrier.
I covered both of these issues in detail last week. Masks work. Social distancing of 1-2 meters works. I don’t feel a compelling need to cover the same ground again here. Handley is, as is usual for him, full of crap on this issue. He even repeats old World Health Organization recommendations as though they were new. In fairness to Handley, the WHO hadn’t updated its recommendations when it was originally written, but oddly enough, he hasn’t mentioned that the WHO has changed its recommendations on wearing masks to recommend that people over 60 and people with underlying medical conditions should wear a medical-grade mask when they’re in public and cannot socially distance, while the general public should wear a three-layer fabric mask in those situations.
Next up:
Fact #8: The idea of locking down an entire society had never been done and has no supportable science, only theoretical modeling.
And:
Fact #10: The data shows that lockdowns have NOT had an impact on the course of the disease.
This is one of those claims that’s sort of true, but misleading. We haven’t faced a pandemic like that of COVID-19. I’m particularly amused, though, how Handley cites the WHO as not having a total lockdown on its list of pandemic mitigation measures as late as 2019. He cites a report entitled Non-pharmaceutical public health measures for mitigating the risk and impact of epidemic and pandemic influenza. He even reproduces this table:
Under “extraordinary measures”, workplace measures and closures are listed, as are internal travel restrictions. Those are basically the building blocks of our current lockdown. Unsurprisingly, Handley can’t help but blame it on the Chinese:
Obvious question: if there was no science to support a lockdown and we’d never actually done one before and many in public health said it would be a terrible idea, why did it happen? There’s really two answers as best I can tell. The first answer is that the World Health Organization, early on in the pandemic, chose to praise the Chinese response of locking down Hubei Province, which effectively served to legitimize the practice, despite the extreme limitations of data available to anyone about the Chinese lockdown’s actual effectiveness.
One can argue whether lockdowns go too far, but recent studies in Nature (ignored by Handley, of course) suggest that pandemic lockdowns are responsible for dramatically decreasing community transmission of coronavirus and having prevented tens of millions of infections and having saved millions of lives. In fairness, these studies were released after Handley’s article was published, but, again, Handley has updated his article but only with cherry picked material that (he thinks) supports his viewpoint. Oddly enough, he hasn’t updated it with these studies.
Handley also cites a report that COVID-19 was circulating widely in the US many months earlier than previously thought. This claim is not supported by molecular biology and has not been confirmed.
Handley also relies on a report from that noted institution with expertise in infectious disease and epidemiology, J.P. Morgan. Unsurprisingly, being a finance man himself, he thinks that this is a reason to take it seriously:
I’m going to start with a source that you might consider unusual, the global bank JP Morgan. Of all the facts I have covered, this one about the ineffectiveness of lockdowns has become the most politicized, because it’s being used to begin playing the blame game. JP Morgan, on the other hand, creates their analysis to do something very nonpartisan: make money. Their analysts crunch data to see which economies are likely to restart first, and you shouldn’t be surprised at this point to discover three things: 1) the least damaged economies are the ones that did the lest [sic] onerous lockdowns, 2) lifting lockdowns has had no negative impact on deaths or hospitalizations, and 3) lifting lockdowns had not increased viral transmission. Reading the JP Morgan conclusions is profoundly depressing, because here in the U.S. many communities are STILL being put through many different lockdown mandates, despite overwhelming evidence to their ineffectiveness. Consider this chart from JP Morgan that shows “that many countries saw their infection rates fall rather than rise again when they ended their lockdowns – suggesting that the virus may have its own ‘dynamics’ which are ‘unrelated’ to the emergency measures.”
Yes, because J.P. Morgan is out to make money, Handley considers its views more credible than those of scientists. Never mind that the report wasn’t public. Never mind that the data used to come up with the conclusions were never made public. Never mind that the report was not peer-reviewed. Personally, I like this retort the best:
Now, let’s go back to…
Fact #9: The epidemic models of COVID-19 have been disastrously wrong, and both the people and the practice of modeling has a terrible history
While many disease models have been used during the COVID-19 pandemic, two have been particularly influential in the public policy of lockdowns: Imperial College (UK) and the IHME (Washington, USA). They’ve both proven to be unmitigated disasters.
Handley attacks Neil Ferguson for previous estimates that turned out (to him, at least) to be overestimates, such as for Mad Cow Disease, but it’s rather bizarre. Ferguson’s estimate had a huge error range, and the actual number of deaths from the disease fell in that range. You can argue that such huge uncertainty in the estimates make the estimates rather useless, but Ferguson wasn’t exactly wrong. Handley also cherry picks the worst case scenarios estimated by Ferguson for deaths from bird flu in 2005 and H1N1 in 2009 and concludes that, because the ultimate numbers of deaths were far lower than worst case scenarios, that Ferguson is not to be trusted.
In any event, the Imperial College model for COVID-19 did indeed estimate that there would be 2.2 million US deaths if the pandemic proceeded to herd immunity uncontrolled and 1.1 million US deaths if it went through to herd immunity with controls in place. Bergstrom notes that we’ve put massively intrusive controls in place but have had nearly 120,000 deaths anyway, while only around 5% of the population has been infected. At that rate, if 50% of the population goes on to be infected, we could easily top one million deaths.
Handley also attacks the IHME model, which has a lot of problems, correctly pointing out that it performed poorly. However, as Bergstrom notes, the model actually underestimated the number of US deaths.
Onwards:
Fact #11: Florida locked down late, opened early, and is doing fine, despite predictions of doom.
At the risk of relying too heavily on Bergstrom:
Next up:
Fact #12: New York’s above average death rate appears to be driven by a fatal policy error combined with aggressive intubations.
This is partially true. It is true that COVID-19 took a huge toll in nursing homes in New York. However, the bit about “aggressive intubations” is a misrepresentation of a controversy in how to manage COVID-19 patients requiring mechanical ventilation that turned into a conspiracy theory that “ventilators are killing COVID-19 patients”. Basically, way back in early April (which, these days, seems like ancient history), an emergency medicine doc named Dr. Cameron Kyle-Sidell produced a YouTube video in which he questioned how ventilators were being used to treat COVID-19 patients. His concerns were mainly that doctors were too fast to place patients on a ventilator and that they were using ventilator settings for acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). One of the key characteristics of ARDS is that the lungs become noncompliant (stiff) as part of the inflammatory process that impairs their ability to exchange oxygen. Consequently, high ventilatory pressures are often needed, specifically positive end expiratory pressure (PEEP), the pressure at the end of expiration, which helps keep the alveoli (air sacs) open.
Although Dr. Kyle-Sidell’s video was treated as though it were a shocking revelation that proved that doctors don’t know what they’re doing when it comes to treating COVID-19, in reality what he was saying wasn’t anything that radical at all. It also seemed to reveal an ignorance of how COVID-19 was actually being treated in ICUs at the time. Dr. Rohin Francis wrote a great article on MedPage Today entitled “The Great Ventilator Fiasco of COVID-19“, where he noted that the “very core principle of ventilating a patient is to reduce oxygen and pressure being delivered as much as possible. ITU [intensive treatment unit] nurses are experts at doing exactly this and it’s been an absolute fundamental of management for decades.” Basically, Handley doesn’t know what he’s talking about here and is mixing a legitimate criticism of New York’s handling of nursing home cases of COVID-19 with nonsense about ventilators killing patients.
Next up:
Fact #13: Public health officials and disease epidemiologists do NOT consider the other negative societal consequences of lockdowns.
I’m with Carl Bergstrom here. This one is straight up nonsense. Public health officials frequently consider these issues, but they do so in the context of modeling disease.
Handley can’t stop, though:
Fact #14: There is a predictive model for the viral arc of COVID-19, it’s called Farr’s Law, and it was discovered over 100 years ago.
Farr’s law basically states that the number of cases per day in viral outbreaks follow a bell-shaped curve. The problem is that Farr’s law isn’t always accurate. For instance, using Farr’s law to predict the the size of the AIDS epidemic resulted in a massive underestimation of the true scope of the epidemic. It also turns out that the IMHE model that Handley attacked used Farr’s law to model the size of the COVID-19 outbreak in the US and failed badly by underestimating it.
Next up, a prediction, not a fact:
Fact #15: The lockdowns will cause more death and destruction than COVID-19 ever did.
This is a common talking point among COVID-19 deniers. Of course, the correct comparison is not the current lockdown versus the pre-COVID-19 pandemic situation, but rather what would have happened if there were no lockdown and coronavirus were allowed to run unchecked through the US population. Unsurprisingly, Handley cherry picks quotes from some lockdown opponents that don’t take into account how much reduced economic activity there likely would have been due to behavioral changes among Americans in the setting of an uncontrolled pandemic.
Finally:
Fact #16: All these phased re-openings are utter nonsense with no science to support them, but they will all be declared a success.
This, too, is a prediction and not a fact. It remains to be seen if this will be true. He continues:
Yup, still waiting for your Phase 1 or Phase 2 re-opening? Trust me, whomever conjured up your state’s plan is quite literally making things up as they go along. And, given the extreme range of plans taking place—even in neighboring counties—the odds that they have ANYTHING to do with the arc of the virus is exactly ZERO, but you already knew that if you read this far. The good news is they will ALL succeed, because we never needed to lockdown in the first place—MISSION ACCOMPLISHED.
I’ll give Handley some credit. For some states, he’s not entirely wrong. That doesn’t excuse the mass of nonsense that preceded his last “prediction”. On the other hand, he is wrong when it comes to many states, including my own state of Michigan.
        ◦ I first “met” J.B. Handley over 15 years ago, when he was the founder of Generation Rescue, an organization that promoted the discredited idea that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in several childhood vaccines caused autism. It’s the same organization that Jenny McCarthy went on to become president of. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that in the era of COVID-19 he’s still promoting pseudoscience.

Did Lockdowns Cause Cancer?
Attempts to rewrite pandemic history must be resisted.
Jonathan Howard on December 2, 2022
Link

I firmly believe that COVID was really bad in many places in the spring of 2020. I also believe that even if politicians took no measures to contain the virus, there’s no way life could have been normal at that time.
This is a surprisingly controversial belief. Today, some people claim that COVID’s first wave wasn’t bad at all. They say that had we only identified “the vulnerable” and hermetically sealed them in a bubble, the rest of us could have continued life normally. However, we were prevented from doing so by overly-cautious politicians with their “brutal Government lockdown propaganda” and “fear-based messaging”.
This sort of revisionist history takes two forms. The first of these is outright denial. In a previous essay, I discussed an article by Dr. Jessica Hockett, an educational psychologist, titled “More Questions About Spring 2020 Covid in New York City Hospitals“, which was posted at the anti-vaccine site, The Brownstone Institute. From the comfort of her living room, Dr. Hockett examined hospital data and absurdly concluded that tens of thousands of healthcare workers hallucinated New York’s spring 2020 COVID wave. My discussion of Dr. Hockett’s article concluded:
Asking for “evidence” that New York City got hit hard by COVID makes as much sense as asking for “evidence” that New York City exists in the first place. George Orwell understood this all very well: “The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”
(A more detailed rebuttal by Drs. Eric Burnett and Jonathan Laxton was posted here yesterday).
Another of my articles discussed a more subtle, pernicious aspect of COVID denial, namely that schools could have easily remained open the entire pandemic. Those who make this argument might not outright deny that places like New York City were hit hard by COVID, but they nonetheless pretend that schools could have stayed open with minimal consequences for teachers, students, and their families. As an adult doctor, not an education expert, I don’t feel qualified to comment on the wisdom or folly of school closures, and so my article on this subject concluded:
Maybe closing schools was an obvious and colossal mistake. However, those who make this claim should honestly grapple with what would have happened had nothing been done rather than indulge an absurd, revisionist fantasy that everything would have been fine and dandy.
A new entry into the rapidly-growing canon of COVID revisionist history comes courtesy of Dr. Karol Sikora, who is described thusly on Wikipedia:
Karol Sikora is a British physician specialising in oncology, who has been described as a leading world authority on cancer. He was a founder and medical director of Rutherford Health, a company that provided proton therapy services, and is Director of Medical Oncology at the Bahamas Cancer Centre. He is currently Professor of Medicine at the University of Buckingham, and a partner in and dean of Buckingham’s medical school.
While Dr. Sikora sounds like an impressive figure, not everyone is so enamored. After Dr. Sikora signed the Great Barrington Declaration, which claimed the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity in under 6 months, Dr. Rupert Beale, a group leader at the Francis Crick Institute in London, said:
There’s a lot of other people who have also signed it and guess what, it’s the usual suspects. It’s Karol Sikora who knows nothing about this whatsoever but who is endlessly self-promoting.
Dr. Sikora’s provocative, angry essay was titled “The Lockdown Cancer Wave Has Only Just Begun: Advocates for harsh Covid measures are finally waking up to their actions“. It was published at UnHerd, which previously published doctors’ absurd, pro-virus claims that it is “healthy and natural” for children to get sick with COVID. Dr. Sikora’s essay said:
The underreported story of the entire pandemic is excess deaths — not from Covid, but from other health conditions which were so brutally pushed to one side. There have been huge rises in the number of people dying from causes unrelated to the virus, accelerating throughout the year and showing no signs of slowing down.
To begin with, it was driven by diabetes, cardiac issues and a handful of other concerns — but recently the number of people dying from cancer is starting to increase considerably above what is expected. Will this continue? Nobody can say for sure, but I suspect it will for many years to come.
When I outlined the scale of the cancer crisis previously on Twitter, various voices took great pleasure in pointing out that cancer deaths weren’t rising — I don’t hear from them anymore. Indeed, many of the more vocal lockdown commentators are actively drawing attention to the problem now.
Cancer is slow, but it’s relentless. An undiagnosed tumour won’t cause severe complications in days or weeks. But if it’s left untreated for a year or two then the odds of survival drop precipitously. I fear that those lockdown delays are now starting to bite.
NHS Digital states that in 2020 there were 288,753 new cancer diagnoses — that is 38,421 fewer than in 2019. Full statistics for 2021 aren’t available yet, but it’s fair to assume that it would be a similar number again. A recent report estimated that across Europe the number was a gargantuan one million fewer diagnoses — it really is scandalous. Yet no public outcry, no emergency press conferences, no outrageous scaremongering tactics. Why is that?
Proponents of harder and longer lockdowns will go to great lengths to deny the impact that lockdown and associated fear-based messaging had on these numbers. There is a concerted effort to whitewash the health consequences of relentless restrictions, but that stain is not easy to remove.
Those of us with clearer memories will recall the one overriding instruction we were all given — ‘stay home’. And that’s exactly what millions of seriously ill people did, regardless of the state of their own health. Just look at the excess death figures in private homes right from the start of the pandemic in March 2020 — sky-high every single week. Tens of thousands of people stayed and died at home. That’s a sorry fact…
Lockdown policies were a choice. Intense fear-based messaging was a choice; essentially locking people in their homes was a choice; failing to give attention to anything that wasn’t Covid was a choice.
It wasn’t our lockdown or absolutely nothing. There was a better, more balanced way. This isn’t hindsight: plenty of us said so at the time, in the face of appalling personal attacks and abuse.
Cancer services in Britain are in a truly horrific place and I sincerely appreciate that the causes are complex, ranging from brutal Government lockdown propaganda to a severely stretched workforce. However, attempts to rewrite pandemic history must be resisted — lockdowns and associated choices had an unforgivable impact on cancer patients with an immeasurable amount of suffering as a result. I fear it has only just begun.
This all sounds really bad, and absolutely no one says lockdowns were harmless. I lived through one of the strictest ones in the US, though I recognized that I was privileged. I was not a small business owner or a single parent with small children who suddenly had no daycare. Moreover, no one says that delayed care for diseases other than COVID was harmless. Many important things had to be postponed. However, it’s important to seriously consider the counterfactual, something Dr. Sikora chose not to do. What actually would have happened if politicians had allowed hospitals to remain open for cancer screening in the spring of 2020?
I can answer that question for New York City. Exactly zero people would have been screened for cancer at the start of the pandemic.
Before I explain my answer, let me state a clear point of agreement with Dr. Sikora – attempts to rewrite pandemic history must be resisted. So let’s revisit some history from the spring of 2020. One article said, “‘We Ran Out of Space’: Bodies Pile Up as N.Y. Struggles to Bury Its Dead: The Coronavirus Crisis is Overwhelming New York’s System for Burying the Dead” and another declared “‘Somebody’s Got To Do It’: Forklift Driver Moves Bodies of Coronavirus Victims“. Yet another read, “Rikers Island Inmates Offered $6 Per Hour to Dig Mass Graves as COVID-19 Deaths Rise” and “New York City Deploys 45 Mobile Morgues as Virus Strains Funeral Homes.” Dr. Sikora was right that deaths spiked not just in hospitals, but in homes as well. According to the New York City Fire Department, “In the first five days of April, 1,125 people were pronounced dead in their homes or on the street in New York City, more than eight times the deaths recorded during the same period in 2019”. While not all of these were COVID victims, many certainly were. Dr. Sikora chose not to tell this to his readers.
Of course, none of this was a secret. New Yorkers, and indeed the whole world, read these headlines and saw the gruesome images. We heard sirens wailing constantly throughout the day and night. Many of us knew people who died or were severely ill with COVID. Over 800 residents of New York City were dying daily during the peak and over 43,000 have died so far. Few New Yorkers were under the illusion that SARS-CoV-2 was a mild or easily-avoided virus, and “those of us with clearer memories” will never forget it.
Despite what Dr. Sikora claims, it wasn’t just “brutal Government lockdown propaganda” that kept people at home at the pandemic’s start. It was reality. And though New York City was hit hard and early, our experience didn’t turn out to be some extreme anomaly, sadly. Similar headlines of mass death appeared throughout the world at various points in the pandemic. New York City wasn’t the only place where cancer screenings had to be halted. Even today, pediatric hospitals are shutting down elective procedures due to overwhelming number of sick children, not because governments are forcing them to. Of course, some people blame lockdowns for children getting sick with flu and RSV too. Lockdowns, it seems, will be blamed for every malady that befalls humanity for the foreseeable future.
So, what actually would have happened if politicians had allowed hospitals to remain open for cancer screening throughout the pandemic? How many New Yorkers, both old enough to be eligible for cancer screening and health-conscious enough to care about it, would have thought in April 2020 “I can’t delay my colonoscopy by a few months!!!“? We’ll never know for sure, but I doubt this is a large number of people we’re talking about here.
Did you social distance at the start of the pandemic? If you did, was your only reason because the government mandated it? Were you just following the law? Would you have gone to dinner parties or crowded karaoke bars had they been open? Probably not. Data supports the unsurprising notion that people changed their behavior independent of government measures at the start of the pandemic. As Noah Louis-Ferdinand wrote:
Mobility data—combining Google’s archive of location histories and GPS data from millions of cell phones—suggests not much. An analysis from June of 2020 immediately looking back shows that mobility decreased massively before the lockdowns even started. There was no sharp decline once they set in, mobility increased throughout the lockdown, and it did not increase sharply once they were lifted. Similar graphs show a sharp mobility decline (albeit less steep) in Stockholm, Sweden right around the same time. Sweden never locked down.
However, even if we indulge the fantasy that large numbers of older New Yorkers would have been eager to stay on track with their cancer screenings in the spring of 2020, who would have been available to treat these patients? The COVID tsunami was an all-hand-on-deck moment. Pediatricians cared for seniors and gynecologists cared for men. Medical students graduated early to help out. Healthcare workers arrived from all over the country. “It was like a medical war zone”, said one traveling nurse. A doctor at Elmhurst Hospital in Queens said:
If you watch a war movie to see people shooting from all over, that’s what this almost felt like. One thing after the next after next, you can’t even catch up with what has to happen.
Many healthcare workers got really sick with COVID themselves. Some died. Others, overcome with grief and powerlessness, took their own lives. Steeped in self-pity regarding the “appalling personal attacks and abuse” he faced being part of a successful campaign to have millions of unvaccinated children contract COVID, Dr. Sikora seems to be blissfully unaware of any of this.
He should read about it. He may be surprised to learn that when COVID overwhelmed our city, there were no spare anesthesiologist to sedate people for colonoscopies. Surgeons and the entire operating room staff weren’t available to treat patients with suspicious mammograms. No one was available for anything except COVID. Hospitals were forced to cancel everything that wasn’t completely emergent. They didn’t do this just because politicians mandated it. They did this because they were overflowing with sick, dying COVID patients. There was quite literally no space for anyone else. Hospitals didn’t cancel lucrative tests and procedures because they suddenly stopped caring about money. They had no choice. I doubt any hospital in the country was able to maintain business as usual throughout the entire pandemic, regardless of their government’s policy.
The news from the UK was no better. Their refusal to vaccinate children led to headlines such as: “Girl, 15, died ‘astonishingly quickly’ on day she was due to receive her Covid vaccine” and “Children Drive Britain’s Longest-Running Covid Surge” from October 2021, before the Omicron variant arrived.
This virus was to blame for all of this. It was capable of shutting down cities around the world.
Despite this, Dr. Sikora convinced many of his readers that routine hospital care would have run smoothly if only politicians had not interfered with their “brutal Government lockdown propaganda” and “fear-based messaging”. Maybe he’s right. Maybe older New Yorkers would have breezily strolled past refrigerated trucks overflowing with corpses of their friends and relatives and into crowded waiting rooms so their mammogram wouldn’t be delayed by a few months. Maybe hospitals would have pulled healthcare workers off overflowing COVID units to perform routine cancer screenings, if only had politicians only allowed it. However I am again forced to conclude that those who make such claims should honestly grapple with what would have happened had nothing been done, rather than indulge an absurd, revisionist fantasy that everything would have been fine and dandy.
After all, attempts to rewrite pandemic history must be resisted, right?

Examining COVID-19 misinformation propagated by US physicians
A new paper documents COVID-19 medical misinformation shared by US physicians on social media
Scott Gavura on August 17, 2023
Link

As of August 2023, the COVID-19 pandemic has led to over 100 million confirmed cases and over 1.1 million deaths in the United States, causing meaningful declines in overall life expectancy for Americans. In those that survived an infection, the physical and mental consequences caused by post-COVID Conditions (e.g., “Long COVID”) is difficult to quantify but is estimated in the tens of millions of Americans. While vaccines have been shown to reduce the risk of severe disease, hospitalization and death, uptake of the vaccine has been modest in the United States, with 69.2% completing the primary vaccine series and only 15.5% receiving the bivalent booster to date.
Reasons for individual decisions related to COVID-19 have been discussed here and elsewhere, and include government recommendations (that changed during the pandemic), general mistrust/distrust of health organizations or institutions, and even political beliefs, as Mark Crislip discussed earlier this week.
COVID-19 misinformation is false, inaccurate, or misleading information as evaluated against the best available evidence, while disinformation has a deliberately malicious and harmful purpose. Both misinformation and disinformation about COVID-19 are commonly found on social media, despite promises from the major platforms during the pandemic to better control its dissemination. Physician-propagated misinformation and disinformation during a public health emergency may have an outsized impact, given they are typically considered to be credible sources of health information. While there seems to be support for disciplining physicians who intentionally share misinformation, little action has been taken against physicians to date, as David Gorski has discussed previously.
In a paper published on August 15, 2023, Sahana Sule and colleagues describe the types of COVID-19 misinformation propagated by American physicians after the vaccine became available, the characteristics of these physicians, and the platforms used to spread this information.
The study
This was a mixed-methods study, combining qualitative (context and meaning analysis) and quantitative (statistical) research methods in a single paper. It looked at information communicated online between January 1, 2021 and May 1, 2022. The authors defined COVID-19 misinformation as assertions unsupported by, or contradicting US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidance on COVID-19 prevention and treatment during the period assessed, or contradicting the existing state of scientific evidence for any topics not covered by the CDC. For example. They classified all inaccurate information as misinformation, based on their stated inability to infer intent.
The researchers searched social media platforms in late spring 2022 to identify media containing misinformation. Included were US-based physicians (posting and self-identifying as either an MD or DO) who were unlicensed or licensed to practice. Search terms included “COVID,” “vaccine,” “doctor” or “physician,” “ineffective,” “pharmaceutical,” “medication,” “ivermectin,” “hydroxychloroquine,” and “purchase” “COVID misinformation,” “doctor” or “physician,” and/or “conspiracy theory.” Platforms searched were Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, Parler, TikTok, The New York Times, and National Public Radio. The researchers noted,
Due to the large volume and repetitiveness of Tweets, Twitter searches focused initially on America’s Frontline Doctors’ Twitter profile because of the volume of COVID-19 misinformation in its Tweets,19 its large following, and the potential for physicians propagating misinformation to follow the page. Followers of the America’s Frontline Doctors’ page with an MD or DO in their header were traced on Twitter and other platforms as well.
The information collected included:
    • The following information was collected from each source: physician’s name
    • medical specialty
    • state(s) in which they were currently or had been licensed
    • whether their license to practice was active, had lapsed, or been revoked based on state medical board site searches
    • when the misinformation was posted (if available)
    • the source
    • the number of followers the physician had (if the source was a social media platform)
Misinformation was classified as follows:
    • medication
    • vaccine
    • mask/distancing
    • other unsubstantiated or false claims
In addition to descriptive statistics on the misinformation, the researchers examined the nature of the misinformation itself, identifying themes, subthemes, and supporting quotes.
Findings: A lot of misinformation propagated by physicians
A total of 52 US physicians were identified as disseminating COVID-19 misinformation. All but 2 were or had been licensed to practice medicine in the US; the others were researchers.Most specialties were represented:
I am not sure what the authors mean by “Allopathic Medicine” as a specialty, as the term is a pejorative used against conventional (science-based) medicine. Most (44/50) physicians (88.0%) held an active license in at least 1 state; three (6.0%) did not have an active license, four (8.0%) had had a license suspended or revoked, and one (2.0%) had active licenses in 2 states and revoked/suspended licenses in 2 other states. Nearly one-third of physicians (16 of 52) were affiliated with groups with a history of propagating medical misinformation, such as America’s Frontline Doctors. I am not sure what other groups the authors may have included other than AFD.
Over one-third of physicians posted misinformation on five or more different social media platforms, and over three-quarters appeared on five or more third-party online platforms. Not surprisingly, Twitter was the most used platform with 37 of 52 using this platform, to audiences with a median size of 67,400 followers:
Misinformation themes
If you’ve been reading this blog since early 2020, the themes identified will not surprise you at all. They included:
    • Claiming vaccines were unsafe and/or ineffective: Discouraging vaccination was common by these physicians, who promoted fear and distrust while encouraging reliance on “natural immunity”. They also made unfounded claims about vaccine harms, including myocarditis misinformation.
    • Promoting unapproved medications for prevention or treatment, such as ivermectin or hydroxychloroquine.
    • Disputing mask-wearing effectiveness, portraying masks in a negative light, and making unsubstantiated claims about effectiveness or harms, e.g., the “harms” to children and the purported problems with mask mandates in schools.
    • Other misinformation, including unsubstantiated claims (e.g., virus origin (“Plandemic“), the withholding of information by governments and public health agencies, the behavior of pharmaceutical companies) and other conspiracy theories.
The physicians aren’t named in this paper, but you may be able to identify some strictly from the quotes and specialty.
Action needed by state medical boards and academic institutions
Much has now been written (even a book!) about the medical professionals who spread misinformation about the SARS-CoV-2, virus, COVID-19 infections, and the pandemic. This paper from Sule and colleagues provides a snapshot and analysis of medical doctors sharing misleading and even completely incorrect information during a public health crisis. Regrettably, COVID-19 misinformation, like all misinformation, seems to be subject to Brandolini’s law, which states:
The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.
Importantly, this paper doesn’t examine the motivations of the physicians who have spread COVID-19 misinformation. Is it all a grift? Audience capture? Is a consequence of the decades-long effort to encourage magical thinking and the acceptance of “complementary and alternative medicine” into conventional medicine, leading to acceptance of “different ways of thinking” and the rejection of science-based medicine?
Others at this blog have done a better and much more thorough job examining and questioning the motivations behind these actions. And while studies like these are helpful to permanently document the misinformation propagated by health care professionals, what’s needed is action – and consequences. State medical regulatory boards owe a duty to protect the public. However, disciplinary action is rare, and regulators seem unwilling to enforce a standard of care, which may be influenced by legislative pressure. Institutions that may employ these physicians should also be examining the information that has been communicated by these individuals and evaluating the public health consequences (and reputational risk) of this misinformation. Regrettably, without any consequences, it seems reasonable to expect the dissemination of medical misinformation from physicians to continue.

Sensible Medicine: Medical Misinformation and Medical Groupthink From the Medical Establishment
We all have biases, including in-group loyalty. It’s often easy to see such bias in others, though nearly impossible to see in oneself. As such, it’s both normal and dangerous to imagine that only those who disagree with you are vulnerable to groupthink, while you are perfect beacon of independent, rational thought- along with everyone who agrees with you.
Jonathan Howard on August 11, 2023
Link

Sensible Medicine is a monetized Subtstack that spreads overt anti-vaccine misinformation. Though the doctors who run it claim to be “medical conservatives”, they mostly took a medically radical approach to a new, mutating virus, treating it as an overhyped, predictable entity from the pandemic’s earliest days. As the pandemic progressed, they repeatedly declared it over and encouraged the mass infection of unvaccinated youth by spreading blatantly bogus statistics and treating abnormal lab values after vaccination as a fate worse than death from COVID. A recent article there by Dr. Marty Makary gives us an opportunity to delve into their more pernicious misinformation techniques.
Dr. Makary’s article was ironically titled Does Anyone Still Care About Data? Though it was about new treatments for Alzheimer’s disease, it contained the following paragraph:
America’s Lost Art—the Critical Appraisal of Research
We witnessed similar medical groupthink during Covid. Throughout the pandemic, the medical establishment never talked about Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor—obesity. Instead, they had a singular, albeit important, pharmaceutical solution. They indiscriminately told everyone to get multiple vaccine doses, regardless of whether a person already had high levels of Covid antibodies from natural immunity, or if a healthy young male already had three vaccine doses. During Covid we saw naked allegiance to political figures, regardless of the data. Doctors and the public alike were quick to cite studies to support their ideas, even if the methodological quality would not meet entry criteria for a 7th grade science fair contest. Conversely, research that did not support a forgone conclusion was downplayed, ignored, or censored.
It may not seem that way, but there’s a lot to unpack there. It’s full of misinformation, and every accusation is a confession. Its aim is to create mistrust and resentment, not to inform and educate. Get comfortable and we’ll examine it one piece at a time. I apologize for the fact that:
The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.
“We witnessed similar medical groupthink during Covid.”
First note that Dr. Makary wrote in the past tense, about events “during Covid”, as if the virus is gone. Of course, this is false. While hospitals and morgues haven’t been overwhelmed in a long time, SARS-CoV-2 is infecting, injuring, and killing people every day. Dr. Makary, who still discusses the pandemic constantly, has been predicting the end of the pandemic since at least December 2020 when he said, “we may only need to get an additional 20% of the population immunized by February or March to really hit those 70% herd immunity levels.” He’s never wavered from this position. In February 2021 he penned as essay titled “We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April,” and another the next month titled “Herd Immunity Is Near, Despite Fauci’s Denial“. In May 2021, he said he was right, claiming that “most of the country is at herd immunity”. He wrote articles in the NY Post that month titled, “Risk of COVID is Now Very Low — It’s Time to Stop Living in Fear: Doctor” and “Don’t Buy the Fearmongering: The COVID-19 Threat is Waning“. Dr. Makary later referred to the Omicron variant as “omi-cold” and “nature’s vaccine.” Anyone who cared about data knew that Dr. Makary was wrong about all this.
Does anyone still care about data?
Dr. Makary also sets the stage by signaling that he’s a brave, maverick doctor, while his critics are sheep, incapable of independent thought, just “groupthink”. There’s a grain of truth here. Though we at SBM are not afraid to disagree with each other in public, we all have biases, including in-group loyalty. It’s often trivial to see such bias in others, though nearly impossible to see in oneself. As such, it’s both easy and dangerous to imagine that only those who disagree with you are afflicted by groupthink, while you are perfect beacon of independent, rational thought- along with everyone who agrees with you.
Though the doctors behind Sensible Medicine portray themselves as immune to “groupthink”, they largely marched in lockstep during the pandemic, objecting to most measures to control COVID and minimize its dangers. To pick one example amongst many, they were united in their belief that the pandemic was ending in early 2021, and that ridicule was an appropriate response to anyone who disagreed. Their sarcastic mockery occurred even during the pandemic’s deadliest month, January 2021, while over 3,000 Americans were dying of COVID daily, and even on what turned out to be the literal peak of the deadliest wave, January 16, 2021. Over 700,000 Americans have since died of COVID.
Medical groupthink during COVID
When herd immunity failed to arrive, Sensible Medicine doctors only further encouraged groupthink by repeatedly shaming and pathologizing the small number of nonconformists who take measures to avoid repeated infections. When the Omicron variant emerged, Dr. Makary was fearful of a “wave of fear”, saying it could fuel a “pandemic of lunacy”. Dr. Prasad, who started the pandemic saying personal attacks were “worse than COVID”, similarly weaponized mental illness to stigmatize cautious people. In June 2023 he said:
Medhi Hasan is an idiot. Of course we have to learn to live with covid. Everyone is living with it. That is precisely what happened. No one gives a shit about COVID anymore & no one sane is taking any precautions. It even bores me & I know fully how wrong the establishment was.
Talk about groupthink.
Dr. Prasad, who also still discusses the pandemic constantly, even formalized his dedication to groupthink by asking his followers to publicly pledge to refuse more COVID vaccines. A request for a written, public display of conformity is a classic influencer technique, described by Robert Cialdini who said:
Commitments are most effective in changing a person’s self-image and future behavior when they are active, public, and effortful.
Medical groupthink during COVID
“Throughout the pandemic, the medical establishment never talked about Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor—obesity.”
Next, Dr. Makary signals that he’s an outsider, and therefore not responsible for our pandemic disaster in any way. Parroting Dr. Prasad, who said “I know fully how wrong the establishment was”, Dr. Makary also wants his audience to believe he’s not part of the “establishment”. I’m with you, not them.
Talk about groupthink.
Of course, this is false. Dr. Makary is the Mark Ravitch Chair in Gastrointestinal Surgery at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, and teaches public health policy as Professor of Surgery and Public Health at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. In 2018, he was elected to the National Academy of Medicine. He was well-known before the pandemic, particularly for his claim, debunked by Dr. Prasad, that medical error is the third leading cause of death. He has 234,000 Twitter followers, and was a ubiquitous media presence this pandemic. He was on Fox News hundreds of times, declaring the end of the pandemic and spreading anti-vaccine misinformation. According to an article from Media Matters from December 2021 about these appearances:
Makary has been described as “a darling of the anti-vaxxers” for contradicting current vaccine consensus among medical professionals. Makary has also written that there is “no compelling case” for vaccinating “healthy” children and claimed that he is “not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date” – discounting all cases that involved disabled children with underlying health conditions.
Despite Makary making numerous false predictions (saying, for example, that the United States would reach herd immunity by April) and being called out by other public experts for downplaying the risk of infectious disease, Fox regularly invited him back on-air in 2021 to undermine public health efforts:
    • In March on The Story with Martha MacCallum, Makary predicted there was low risk of new variants causing COVID-19 surges, and on Your World with Neil Cavuto, he accused public health experts of “cry[ing] wolf” over the threat of new variants.
    • In June on America Reports, Makary went so far as to complain that discussion of new variants is “fearmongering” to “manipulate people to get vaccinated,” saying, “I’m for vaccines, but this has turned into a tool to try to coax people into it.”
    • In June on Special Report, Makary claimed it’s time to “move on and live a normal life” comparing COVID-19 cases to influenza: “right now we’re about at 150th the daily cases of a regular seasonal flu in the middle of that flu season. So people have a distorted perception of risk.” According to Makary’s own employer, Johns Hopkins, COVID-19 has a mortality rate 10 times higher that of the flu.
    • On Your World with Neil Cavuto in November, Makary undermined efforts to vaccinate children, saying kids with natural immunity should not be vaccinated. He went on to fearmonger about potential side effects of vaccinations.
    • On Fox News Primetime in November, Makary claimed to be pro-vaccine but said he stands against “obsolete” vaccine mandates, especially for children. Makary falsely asserted that “public health officials have brushed under the rug the fact that kids have died from the vaccine, it’s rare” citing myocarditis occurrences in young boys. (However the real risk of myocarditis is from COVID-19, not vaccines, and most people who develop myocarditis recover quickly.)
Dr. Markary was also the editor of Medpage Today and spread his misinformation message in the Wall Street Journal, New York Post, and Washington Post. He testified before Congress on more than one occasion and had private audiences with Republican congressional doctors. He was the COVID advisor to the Governor of Virginia. You can even hire him to speak for $20,000-$30,000.
He is definition of the medical establishment.
Medical groupthink from the medical establishment
Having falsely told his readers he’s not part of the “establishment”, Dr. Makary then claims they “never talked about Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor—obesity”. Of course, this is false. The CDC listed “Severe obesity (body mass index [BMI] of 40 or higher)” as a risk factor for severe COVID as early as April 2, 2020 and they later published studies on the subject got that widespread media attention. They said:
As clinicians develop care plans for COVID-19 patients, they should consider the risk for severe outcomes in patients with higher BMIs, especially for those with severe obesity.
They were not alone. As early as March 2020, Dr. Anthony Fauci said:
It’s so clear that the overwhelming weight of serious disease and mortality is on those who are elderly and those with a serious comorbidity: heart disease, chronic lung disease, diabetes, obesity, respiratory difficulties.
He elaborated in 2021, saying:
The other thing I believe, is that obese people, particularly morbidly obese people, have a much higher rate of the other underlying comorbidities, which get a serious outcome. That’s diabetes, hypertension, heart disease—the incidents in a morbidly obese person of those other diseases is much higher than the general population.
Similarly, Dr. Francis Collins, the former director of the NIH, said in June 2020:
We also know that chronic illnesses play a role in who’s going to have a severe case. Certainly hypertension and diabetes and obesity are in there as well.
In fact, a simple Google search returned around 100 articles by the “establishment” on obesity and COVID from throughout the pandemic. My university published an article on April 16, 2020 titled “The New York Times: Obesity Associated with Severe Coronavirus Disease, Especially in Young Adults“. One from Dr. Makary’s university on June 1, 2020 was titled “Obesity a Major Risk Factor for COVID-19 Hospitalizations.” Harvard, Yale, Stanford, UCSF, The University of Chicago, and dozens of other medical schools wrote about obesity and COVID. So did the American Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Heart Association, the Endocrine Society, and numerous other medical organizations. Major newspapers discussed it. I also discussed obesity as a risk factor for severe disease in children, noting that nearly all who perished from the virus were robbed of decades of life. It’s hard to find examples of the “establishment” who completely ignored the relationship between obesity and COVID
“Throughout the pandemic, the medical establishment never talked about Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor—obesity.”
Maybe the “establishment” should have talked about obesity more- Dr. Makary has just seven Tweets on the topic, the first from December 2020, the last from May 2022 -but it wasn’t exactly a top classified secret that it posed a risk for severe COVID. Nonetheless, Dr. Makary imagines that a large number of obese people were totally unaware of this risk, and that many of them could have have lost weight, if only the “establishment” had been more vocal on the topic. One overweight friend reacted to Dr. Makary by telling me:
Do people really think fat people don’t know they are fat and would instantly be thin just because some doctors says, “Oh, you should lose weight”?
People do actually think that, and it’s absurd. Many of my patients are overweight. They are not ignorant of obesity’s health risks, and nearly all tried everything for years to lose weight. While weight-loss is crucial and possible for many people, it’s not easy or instant for anyone, and a bit more encouragement from the “establishment” was not the secret sauce anyone was missing. Protecting obese people, who could not lose weight instantly three years ago is one reason we went to such lengths to control the the virus. 42% of Americans are obese, their lives are not expendable, and the “establishment” could not have reversed obesity on a dime in March 2020. If Dr. Makary disagrees, then he should explain why he failed to cure obesity in Virginia during his stint as that state’s COVID advisor.
And let’s pause and look what Dr. Makary has communicated in just two short sentences. He’s signaled that COVID is over, denigrated his critics as the “establishment”, and claimed they were incapable of independent thought. He absurdly implied that obese people were ignorant of their condition, and that “Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor” could have been drastically improved if not for the apathy of the “establishment”. Moreover, he disrespected his readers by spreading easily-refutable misinformation, claiming that “Throughout the pandemic, the medical establishment never talked about Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor—obesity.” Throughout the pandemic! Never! Either Dr. Makary didn’t bother with basic fact checking or he didn’t care that he was spreading a blatant falsity. However, his goal wasn’t to communicate accurate information. Like most Sensible Medicine writers, his aim was to trigger anger and groupthink.
Throughout the pandemic! Never!
Of course, legitimate criticisms of the “establishment” are necessary and vital, and we here at SBM don’t shy away from criticizing medical boards, regulatory agencies, academic fraud, problematic drug approvals, as well as many individual “leaders” of American medicine. Some of the best work in this area comes from those truly outside the medical establishment, such as the Death Panel Podcast. However, while mistakes were made and some bad faith actors purposefully undermined all efforts to contain the virus, the vast majority of public health officials were people you’ve never heard of, working on the ground, doing the best they could to save lives in an unprecedented situation. Whatever their errors, it wasn’t easy to have real-world responsibility during the pandemic. As the bodies piled up, tough decisions had to be made in real-time with incomplete information. The right answers weren’t always obvious. This was everyone’s first pandemic and SARS-CoV-2 was a new virus, after all.
Moreover, public health agencies hadn’t been showered with cash and resources prior to the pandemic. Quite the opposite, actually. Public health officials couldn’t have done everything that’s now being demanded of them. When morgues were overflowing, they didn’t have the resources to launch a nationwide obesity awareness campaign.
However, asinine claims that the “establishment” could have tackled obesity in March 2020 have a broader purpose. They are part of a larger movement to rewrite history and minimize the enormous challenges the “establishment” faced at the pandemic’s start. Of course, this is just another way to minimize COVID itself. Some influential people want everyone to forget that refrigerated trucks were needed to store dead bodies outside my hospital. Doctors who greatly underestimated the virus at the start and who never treated COVID patients themselves, now seek to absolve their calamitous errors by blaming the “establishment” for not fixing every societal ill in March 2020. It’s no big deal that I said we’d have herd immunity by April. People just needed to stop being fat, and the establishment is to blame for that, not me. Unsurprisingly, the original COVID minimizer Dr. John Ioannidis, pioneered this deflection technique in 2021, creating a list of what “really caused” millions of COVID deaths. In 2023, Dr. Makary parroted his exact language, calling obesity a “modifiable risk factor” to similarly imply it “really caused” many COVID deaths.
Talk about groupthink.
Dr. John Ioannidis on what “really caused” COVID deaths
With the “establishment” and obese people there to take the blame, these doctors then seek to convince us that all measures to control the virus were an overreaction, a position many of them formulated in March 2020, when they thought fewer than 40,000 Americans would die. For example, demonstrating yet more groupthink by parroting the doctors behind the Great Barrington Declaration, Dr. Prasad said in March 2022:
Masks, distance, lockdown, test often don’t work, if they work, only delay the inevitable great harm.
Of course it’s unambiguously good that measures to control the virus delayed the inevitable and allowed countless millions of people to avoid it until after they were vaccinated and medical care had improved. The vaccines aren’t perfect, but a fully vaccinated person who contracts COVID today has much better odds of a good outcome than someone who contracted it in April 2020 when hospitals were deluged and we had no idea how to treat it. According to one modeling study:
From December 2020 through November 2022, we estimate that the COVID-19 vaccination program in the U.S. prevented more than 18.5 million additional hospitalizations and 3.2 million additional deaths.
An obesity awareness campaign wouldn’t have had this impact.
In lieu of legitimate criticisms of the “establishment”, Sensible Medicine makes blatantly false statements about them and makes very difficult, even impossible tasks sound trivial. They want their readers to believe the “establishment” could have done nearly anything, but they were too stupid or apathetic to do many easy and obvious things. This too has a broader purpose. Their main goal is to get people to stop trusting the public health “establishment”, and you don’t have to take my word for it.
Unfortunately, Sensible Medicine is very successful in getting their audience to stop trusting the public health “establishment.” One commentator on Dr. Makary’s article said:
So sad. Medical community has gone crazy – and evil – since covid pandemic emerged.
This unbridled rage is par for the course for the grossly misinformed readers of Sensible Medicine, and that really matters. I encourage you to read the comments on an article titled “A Public Health Worker Looks Back at the Pandemic and How We Reacted to It,” by Matthew Brignall, a public health worker who was brave enough to work on the ground during during the pandemic and even braver to share his experience on Sensible Medicine. He wrote:
State and local health policies suppressed the spread of COVID-19 until we could develop an effective vaccine and get it into the arms of the most vulnerable people.
His reward for making sensible statements on Sensible Medicine was hundreds of comments calling him a “biofascist scum” and someone who helped “usher in tyranny around the globe.” Dr. Adam Cifu, a founder of Sensible Medicine, knew his readership and tried to prepare him for the backlash, but even Mr. Brignall was taken aback by the fury and groupthink, saying:
To be fair, Adam warned me, and I chose not to turn off the comments. But yeah, that shit was a cesspool. I think it is instructive to see how quickly the internet goes to lynch mob when the opinion is challenging.
Indeed, Sensible Medicine excels at creating a cesspool of resentment. I previously discussed an article there that lambasted the “establishment” for not doing an absurd, utterly impossible randomized-controlled trial (RCT) of hospital visitation policies at the pandemic’s start. Predictably, their readers, consumed by groupthink, responded not by agreeing to volunteer for future RCTs, but by sharing their fury and retribution fantasies against the “establishment”. “It was a purposeful dictate designed to wreck humanity,” said one. “These people need to be held accountable”, said another. “It was criminal in my mind”, said another. Another said:
To the MD that wouldn’t let her go “home” on her birthday, may he be forever riddled with guilt. May he suffer the loss of a loved one in the same manner. May he die alone.
Charming stuff. Meanwhile, Dr. Cifu, who was very concerned about the “tone” of those who corrected the factual errors of his Sensible Medicine colleagues, also appeared in the comments and said to its author, “Wonderful. Thank you so much Ben“.
All of this anger and mistrust had consequences in the real-world, and none of it was “wonderful”. RCTs require volunteers who trust clinical trialists, AKA the “establishment”. I was in a vaccine RCT and because I actually want them to be successful, I always spoke positively about them. In my first article this pandemic, I discussed my experience and said:
Having argued for years that vaccines are properly tested, I jumped at the chance to participate in a vaccine trial myself. I’ve always believed that people who participate in medical research are doing a noble thing. If no one volunteered for such research, medicine would never advance.
In contrast, I don’t recall a Sensible Medicine doctor ever promoting an actual RCT or encouraging their audience to enroll in one. However, advancing actual RCTs is not their goal, which is a shame. Some very simple RCTs couldn’t even get off the ground due to low enrollment. It turns out that actually doing an RCT is a lot harder than writing “do an RCT”, and podcasting doctors who excoriated the “establishment” for not doing RCTs of everything, made it harder for anyone to do an RCT of anything.
Beyond this, many public health officials, AKA the “establishment”, were threatened, harassed, and attacked during the pandemic, leading many to quit. One public healthcare worker sent me the following message:
To shield themselves from similar vitriol, Sensible Medicine doctors falsely portray themselves as outsiders, wryly observing the “groupthink” of the “establishment” from a distance. Though they absolutely are part of the “establishment”, they don’t consider it their job to solve obesity, run an RCT, or seemingly do much of anything, besides commenting from the sidelines, blaming others for not doing everything they imagined. “If only they’d listened to me, things would have been just fine,” they say in articles that should be titled “What I Would Have Done“.
Of course, none of us have to wonder what we would have done this pandemic. What you actually did is exactly what you would have done.
“Instead, they had a singular, albeit important, pharmaceutical solution.”
Having poisoned the well against the “establishment”, Dr. Makary then pivots to his standard anti-vaccine blather. According to Dr. Makary, the brainless drones who chose not to cure obesity, had a “singular” focus on vaccines. This is partially true. Dr. Fauci, an avid jogger himself, encouraged exercise in the summer of 2020. He also took a medically conservative approach to the vaccines, saying in February 2021:
But even if you’re one of the lucky few to have gotten a Covid-19 shot, it will be important to continue wearing a face covering until researchers can determine whether the vaccines prevent people from spreading the virus to others who aren’t vaccinated.
However, for over a year, the “establishment” has abandoned all measures to control the virus, aside from their singular focus on vaccines. Put another way, the “establishment” adopted essentially all the positions of Sensible Medicine doctors, who are, of course, the “establishment”. Indeed, it was the doctors at Sensible Medicine who had a “singular” focus on vaccines, claiming they obviated other measures to contain the virus almost immediately after they came out. Dr. Markary said in March 2021:
If anyone hears of a person hospitalized or dead from Covid-19 after full vaccination, please let me know. The data show that vaccines confer near perfect protection against death and hospitalization from Covid. Can’t we be honest about that?
Dr. John Mandrola said in March 2021, “The pandemic is essentially done….The vaccine squelches severe cases.” Later that year he said, “Have the vaccines not transformed SARSCOV2 into just another regular respiratory virus?” Though he later said such comments were the “worst misinformation” Dr. Prasad said in January 2021:
You will be less infectious, dramatically less infectious, less of a threat to others after vaccination. Of course, no surprise, that’s why we’re vaccinating, right?
In February 2021, just after the deadliest month of the pandemic, Dr. Prasad mocked the New York Times for suggesting that vaccines alone might not end the pandemic. “It was just completely off, and just another squeeze of fear,” he said. That same month he said, “we know the vaccine is 100% effective against protecting against bad outcomes for grandparent,” and in May that year, he claimed:
For somebody who’s already been fully vaccinated, they can wear the mask out of solidarity or in a symbolic sense, but their wearing a mask indoors is not benefiting anyone else. There’s an infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone.
This was pure groupthink from establishment doctors who rejected medical conservatism and now blame the “establishment” for their words. Thankfully, I avoided this groupthink and rejected a singular focus on vaccines. In April 2021, I said,
Im very very optimistic vaccines will cut transmission of disease. I’m not certain of it. This is why I wear a mask still in public and when treating covid patients.
A singular focus on vaccines
Notice too how Dr. Makary calls vaccines a “pharmaceutical solution”. While this obviously isn’t wrong, this framing was a conscious choice to spread fear and doubt. If you think I’m overstating the case, consider the subtitle of an essay of his that spread misinformation about the COVID vaccine in pregnancy:
The Agency (CDC) did exactly what big Pharma wanted, using groupthink instead of insisting on data for their recommendations.
That sentence could appear on anti-antivaccine site about any vaccine. It’s standard anti-vaxx balderdash. It’s no secret that many Americans distrust the pharmaceutical industry, often with good reason. However, by telling people vaccines = pharma, Dr. Makary sought to reinforce this negative association for his readers. It worked. One of his commentators said:
Pharma won’t allow lifestyle change to trump sales, so we can’t depend on them. Many health organizations make $ only when there are patients, so we won’t see preventatives from whole organizations. Thank god for individuals who ignore the business model and want to help individual patients.
Dr. Makary could have said vaccines are an “immunological solution” and presented the copious evidence they reduced grave outcomes. But having greatly oversold them in 2021, Sensible Medicine doctors are loathe to frame them in a positive light today. Of course, by decreasing hospitalizations, COVID vaccines saved the healthcare system enormous sums of money, including a large amount spent on pharmaceutical products. Those of us are actually opposed to mere “pharmaceutical solutions” to COVID, embraced vaccines while being honest about their flaws. At least Dr. Makary conceded vaccines are “important”.
“They indiscriminately told everyone to get multiple vaccine doses, regardless of whether a person already had high levels of Covid antibodies from natural immunity, or if a healthy young male already had three vaccine doses.”
Dr. Makary then claims “they indiscriminately told everyone to get multiple vaccine doses”. Of course, this is false. You may feel the “establishment” should have left more unvaccinated people vulnerable to the virus, but they didn’t come to their policies on a whim. The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) had multiple lengthy, public meetings to review the data and discuss every vaccine dose. In fact, the “establishment” disagreed on boosters initially. In September 2021, CDC director Dr. Rochelle Walensky overruled the ACIP, which had voted 9-6 against suggesting boosters to health care workers and other frontline workers. Several vaccine regulators voiced their opposition in the Washington Post and ultimately resigned in protest, something Dr. Makary celebrated on social media.
So much for groupthink.
Moreover, many people felt the “establishment” dragged its feet in authorizing pediatric vaccines. There was a real price to paid for “precaution”. Of course, unless the “establishment” ran a massive RCT for every tweek to the vaccine, Sensible Medicine doctors would always accuse them of acting “indiscriminately”, as if only the vaccine posed a threat, never the virus.
The belief that the virus was essentially harmless for all but the most vulnerable people may explain why Sensible Medicine doctors indiscriminately told everyone to contract it multiple times. Even though no RCT shows this is safe, Dr. Prasad said in 2023, “Repeat infections are inevitable. More the longer you live. Nothing can be done about it.” Dr. Cifu expressed the exact same sentiment in May 2022, saying:
We now need to accept that this is here to get infected with again and again.
Talk about groupthink.
Notice as well that Dr. Makary views “antibodies from natural immunity” as a valid reason to forego vaccination. Sounding like a pre-pandemic anti-vaxxer gushing over measles, Dr. Makary acted like cheerleader for SARS-CoV-2 much of the pandemic – “natural immunity wins again“- claiming that vaccines and “natural immunity” would usher in herd immunity by April 2021. Even after this prediction failed miserably and immune-evading variants arrived, he continued to lament that “policymakers” did not glorify “natural immunity”. “It’s okay to have an incorrect scientific hypothesis. But when new data proves it wrong, you have to adapt”, he wrote, scolding people who didn’t claim herd immunity arrived in May 2021.
Of course, the power of “natural immunity” was that it killed over a million Americans. “Natural immunity” injured millions more, and isn’t as powerful as hoped for these survivors. Moreover, there is evidence that vaccination after infection was beneficial at limiting hospital admissions and severe disease. Sensible Medicine readers won’t know this.
Beyond this, Dr. Makary implies there’s something nefarious about “multiple vaccine doses”, though he doesn’t say what that is. Of course, most vaccines require multiple doses. Children receive four polio vaccinations by the time they are six. They receive five doses of the DTaP vaccine by this age. The flu vaccine is given annually. Does Dr. Makary blame the “establishment” for this?
Though it would have been great, there was never any guarantee that the first two COVID doses would provide lifelong protection against a new, mutating virus. However, even if the “establishment” ended up suggesting a vaccine dose to someone who didn’t need it, they had to make recommendations with less-than-perfect data in the middle of a rapidly changing pandemic. That’s medicine. It’s a fantasy to imagine that we will always have a tidy RCT to resolve every question. The risks will not always be perfectly known and letting children, especially unvaccinated ones, repeatedly get COVID is an example of an unknown risk.
Nonetheless, it’s true that some people got a vaccine dose they probably didn’t need. However, Dr. Makary didn’t explain why, in a pandemic where 1.1 million Americans died and millions more were injured, this was such a cause for concern. Why was it really so disastrous if a healthy young male chose to get a 4th dose? I’ve discussed the risks of the vaccine many times previously, and while tragic, catastrophic reactions, including deaths, have occurred, they are literally less than one in a million events. In contrast, a study from May 2022, estimated that nearly 319,000 deaths could have been prevented if all American adults had gotten vaccinated. Dr. Makary did not bemoan the fate of the people who suffered needlessly because they refused a vaccine dose they did need- including the first booster and bivalent booster– and the deceased are not here to extol the power of “natural immunity”.
The power of “natural immunity”
“During Covid we saw naked allegiance to political figures, regardless of the data.”
Dr. Makary was not wrong about this, nor was he the only Sensible Medicine doctor to portray himself as floating above the political fray. Dr. Prasad and Dr. Jeffrey Flier shared a similar concern at the start of the pandemic in an essay titled “Scientists Who Express Different Views on Covid-19 Should be Heard, not Demonized“. This authors said they were “concerned with personal attacks and general disparaging comments” and concluded.
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
In an article titled “Politics and Medicine is a Bad Idea” Dr. Mandrola similarly warned of the dangers of mixing politics and medicine. He said, “our medical training provides us no expertise on policy”. “There are many downsides when healthcare professionals overstep our expertise.” he added.
Talk about groupthink.
Dr. Mandrola ended his essay by saying:
We should remain like a neutral judge. Always. The people can decide the best policy.
Despite this clear, unambiguous conclusion, Dr. Mandrola did not mention his Sensible Medicine colleague Dr. Prasad. This is not for lack of opportunities. Dr. Prasad, an adult oncologist whose medical training provided him no expertise on policy, repeatedly compared school closures to the Iraq War and wrote over 50 pugilistic Tweets on the evils of teachers unions. When schools in Philadelphia closed a Friday due to poor air quality from forest fires, he said:
I really hope that in return for your repeated failure to do what is right for children we move to a voucher system that crushes your failed district and destroys your union system that always places adult interests over children.
The schools reopened Monday.
Dr. Prasad also frequently villainized “Democratic cities”, “left wing politics” “NYTimes reporters” “liberal cities” and “Fauci” . One of many emotive Tweets attacking “dems” said:
Dems have become the corporatist party. Pfizer basically writes EUA orders based on mice data. At the worst moment of the pandemic Dems abandoned kids, esp poor minority kids to side with teachers unions. Instead of hearing criticism, they preferred to censor Twitter & YouTube.
Though I won’t say that his behavior was “more toxic and deadly than Covid-19”, Dr. Prasad also revelled in demonizing scientists who expressed different views. He said that RFK Jr, a presidential candidate and anti-vaccine crank with a body count, would “destroy”, “flatten” and “obliterate” Dr. Peter Hotez, a highly-respected vaccine scientist who received anti-semitic death threats and was harassed at home for wisely refusing to perform a verbal joust with RFK Jr. on a podcast.
Talk about the conduct of science becoming indistinguishable from politics.
The conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
RFK Jr. was not the only anti-vaccine politician to receive praise from Dr. Prasad. In May 2023 he said that:
DeSantis Florida had the best COVID-19 policy in the United States. Balancing competing risks and freedom.
The data argues otherwise. A recent article titled The Steep Cost of Ron DeSantis’s Vaccine Turnabout shows how anti-vaccine doctors with naked allegiance to political figures ignored the data, costing thousands of young Floridians their lives. It said:
At the same time, though, the governor was embracing more extreme views, including those of Dr. Scott W. Atlas, a Stanford neuroradiologist with no expertise in infectious diseases. Dr. Atlas was a frequent commentator on Fox News when Mr. Trump named him to his Covid task force in August 2020.
Both he and Dr. Bhattacharya argued that people who were not at risk of severe consequences should not face Covid restrictions. If they were infected, they would develop natural immunity, which would eventually build up in the population and cause the virus to fade away, they said….
Dr. Atlas, however, argued that the virus was not dangerous to an overwhelming majority of Americans. Both he and Dr. Bhattacharya said the Covid death rate for everyone under 70 was very low. Dr. Atlas claimed that children had “virtually zero” risk of death. Neither man responded to requests for comment…
While Florida was an early leader in the share of over-65 residents who were vaccinated, it had fallen to the middle of the pack by the end of July 2021. When it came to younger residents, Florida lagged behind the national average in every age group.
That left the state particularly vulnerable when the Delta variant hit that month. Floridians died at a higher rate, adjusted for age, than residents of almost any other state during the Delta wave, according to the Times analysis. With less than 7 percent of the nation’s population, Florida accounted for 14 percent of deaths between the start of July and the end of October.
Of the 23,000 Floridians who died, 9,000 were younger than 65. Despite the governor’s insistence at the time that “our entire vulnerable population has basically been vaccinated,” a vast majority of the 23,000 were either unvaccinated or had not yet completed the two-dose regimen.
The two images below, just six weeks apart, summarize the largely preventable tragedy well.
DeSantis Florida had the best COVID-19 policy in the United States
The unchecked spread of the virus also meant many schools couldn’t stay open in Florida. “It’s just not sustainable when you don’t have the people to run the school,” said one principal. Another superintendent said during the Delta wave:
COVID numbers are currently on the climb and having an impact on students, teachers, and on the support staff on whom we rely so heavily – particularly our food service workers and bus drivers.
This is the state and governor that Dr. Prasad said had “best COVID-19 policy in the United States”.
Dr. Prasad even defended the Surgeon General of Florida, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, saying his critics of his anti-vaccine data fraud were “stupid.” “Ladapo is closer to correct than his critics”, he said about a doctor who altered data to make the vaccine appear more dangerous than the virus.
Talk about naked allegiance to political figures, regardless of the data.
Naked allegiance to political figures regardless of the data
“Doctors and the public alike were quick to cite studies to support their ideas, even if the methodological quality would not meet entry criteria for a 7th grade science fair contest.”
Dr. Makary then laments that “Doctors and the public alike were quick to cite studies to support their ideas, even if the methodological quality would not meet entry criteria for a 7th grade science fair contest.” Again, he’s not wrong. Many bad studies were published this pandemic, and Sensible Medicine doctors were eager to amplify those that supported their ideas. For example, Drs. Prasad and Makary both promoted a horrible, retracted anti-mask study written by anti-vaccine activists, and Dr. Makary’s enthusiastic Tweet about it remains uncorrected to this day. He said:
Kids need fresh air! A new JAMA study describes consequences of elevated carbon dioxide levels in kids and hypercapnia from inhaled air from the dead space a mask creates.
Dr. Makary did more than amplify bad studies that supported his ideas, he authored one himself. In an editorial tilted “Think Twice Before Giving the COVID Vax to Healthy Kids“, Dr, Makary said:
In reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date. My research team at Johns Hopkins partnered with FAIR health to study pediatric COVID-19 deaths using approximately half of the nation’s health insurance data. We found that 100% of pediatric COVID-19 deaths were in children with a pre-existing condition, solidifying the case to vaccinate any child with a comorbidity.
Dr. Makary’s report was titled “Risk Factors for COVID-19 Mortality among Privately Insured Patients: A Claims Data Analysis”. It was published as a “white paper,” not in a medical journal. Though he claimed it was a study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths”, the words “child,” “children,” and “pediatrics” do not appear in it, though there is a discussion of Alzheimer’s disease in relation to COVID. The paper reported on 2,753 people who died of COVID from April 1, 2020, through August 31, 2020. Of these, 0.11% deaths occurred in children under 18-years. This means Dr. Makary’s supposed study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths” reported on just three deceased children. It presented no data about them beyond noting they were under age 18 years and had some underlying condition.
Would a 7th-grader at a science fair use a sample size of three to claim that zero healthy children had died of COVID in the entire country? If they did, they’d be wrong. Sadly, healthy children had died of COVID when Dr. Makary made his false claim, something a 7th grader could have easily discovered with a simple Google search.
Of course, the lives of vulnerable children are not less valuable than healthy ones.
“Conversely, research that did not support a forgone conclusion was downplayed, ignored, or censored”.
Dr. Makary was not wrong to say that “research that did not support a forgone conclusion was downplayed, ignored”. I’ve written previously (here, here, and here) on how Sensible Medicine writers cherry-pick information to minimize COVID’s impact on children, as well as to fear monger about the vaccine and hide its benefits. I previously said
If ten data points are needed to understand the risks and benefits of the vaccine, they cherry pick the three that support their position.
Indeed, most Sensible Medicine doctors started with the conclusion that unvaccinated children should contract COVID, and worked backwards to selectively present the “evidence” only that supported their mass infection. To my knowledge, Dr. Makary has never shared any of the dozens of studies showing the vaccine has helped limit rare, but grave harms in children. Sensible Medicine doctors pretend these studies do not exist.
Dr. Makary ends with conspiracies, though he does not say which research was “censored”. In fact, his paragraph didn’t contain a single link to support any of his claims. However, in March 2022, he complained that the “establishment” rejected his findings on obesity and COVID. He said:
Unfortunately a lot of medical journals were heavily curating the establishment narrative. Our Hopkins study showing obesity was a major risk factor for Covid mortality was ready for publication in July 2020 but was rejected at 7 medical journals over a 1.5 year period.
What does Dr. Makary think the “establishment” has to gain by covering up a link between obesity and severe COVID. Why does he think the editors of multiple medical journals agree to suppress such an important finding?
If indeed the “establishment” did seek to “curate” medical journals to hide this link, they did a poor job of it. In addition to the articles I linked to previously, on April 1, 2020 the editors of the journal Obesity wrote an editorial titled “COVID 19 and the Patient with Obesity – The Editors Speak Out” in which they said:
Persons with obesity around the world are already at high risk for severe complications of COVID-19, by virtue of the increased risk of the chronic diseases that obesity drives.
The New York Times wrote an article in April 2020 titled “Obesity Linked to Severe Coronavirus Disease, Especially for Younger Patients” that referenced research at NYU. It said:
One of the largest U.S. studies to identify obesity as a prominent risk factor analyzed data from more than 4,000 Covid-19 patients who sought care at NYU Langone Health between March 1 and April 2.
It also discussed:
Another NYU Langone study, which focused on patients under the age of 60, found that those with obesity were twice as likely to be hospitalized and were at even higher risk of requiring critical care.
In fact, by July 2020, enough data had accumulated that to allow for an review on the topic titled “The Potential Impacts of Obesity on COVID-19“. By this early date, the author was able to reference several papers and conclude:
Obesity has been found to be a strong independent risk factor for hospitalisation in COVID-19, and to cause or exacerbate a variety of comorbidities which have been proven to be associated with increased morbidity and mortality among COVID-19 patients.
In September 2020, Science published an article titled “Why COVID-19 is More Deadly in People with Obesity—Even if They’re Young“. It quoted a doctor who said:
These were otherwise healthy, hard-working people. Their major risk factor for getting this sick was obesity.
Maybe seven medical journals rejected Dr. Makary’s paper for reasons that had nothing to do with censoring the link between obesity and COVID.
Let’s return to the title of Dr. Makary’s article, Does Anyone Still Care About Data? Many people do, and Sensible Medicine doctors taunt them by robotically levelling the same juvenile accusation of “groupthink”. This, of course, is just medical groupthink from the medical establishment.
And if the doctors behind Sensible Medicine want to prove me wrong, they have my blessing to publish this essay on their site.
Medical groupthink from the medical establishment.

When Doctors Have Different Standards of Evidence for the Virus and the Vaccine
817,000 Americans had already died of COVID by December 23, 2021, and 244,000 more would die the next year. Millions more survived, but were injured. These numbers could have been lower if doctors had not become defense attorneys for SARS‑CoV‑2 and prosecutors against the vaccine, and instead applied similar standards of evidence to both.
Jonathan HowardonJuly 4, 2023
Linke
21: The Vaccine
On December 23rd, 2021, Fox News viewers were treated to the following image, featuring Dr. Marty Makary, who predicted herd immunity would arrive eight months prior.
(h/t Noah Louis-Ferdinand)
Predictably, this was false.
Though the results were only available as a press release at the time, a randomized-controlled trial of 10,000 people showed that a booster was safe and 95% effective at preventing COVID compared to two doses. This study has since been published, and it doesn’t take a genius to predict a vaccine dose that lowered infection rates would also lessen severe disease. The results from a large observational study were also available at the time. It found:
Vaccine effectiveness evaluated at least 7 days after receipt of the third dose, compared with receiving only two doses at least 5 months ago, was estimated to be 93% (231 events for two doses vs 29 events for three doses; 95% CI 88–97) for admission to hospital, 92% (157 vs 17 events; 82–97) for severe disease, and 81% (44 vs seven events; 59–97) for COVID-19-related death.
Despite this, Dr. Makaray told his viewers were told there was “no scientific data supporting COVID booster shots”. Democrats were mocked and pathologized as “booster addicts”.
December 2021: The Virus
What was Dr. Makary saying about the Omicron variant at this time? He was very confident about this brand new variant. He did not need more “scientific data.” As he did in May 2021, prior to the arrival of the Delta variant, he said there was no reason to fear Omicron.
He called it “omi-cold“. He said:
We’re seeing this massive new wave of fear that is fueling our second pandemic after COVID-19, which is a pandemic of lunacy, which is omicron. Now I call it omi-cold. If you look at the epidemiological data, the epicenter is now way down from omicron. The hospitals had some hospitalizations, not much. They were short. They averaged two and a half days instead of eight days. But a study just came out of the University of Hong Kong telling us that omicron does not invade the lung tissue that’s deep in the respiratory tract. It stays superficial in the nose and bronchus. So that’s why we’re seeing a common cold-like illness. This new scientific data from the lab explains the epidemiological data and the bedside observation of doctors that this is far more mild… and that’s why I call it omi-cold.
Predictably, this was false.
A recent study found the Omicron variant was as dangerous as the original virus, at least for unvaccinated people. It concluded, “Omicron has comparable intrinsic severity to the ancestral Wuhan strain although the effective severity is substantially lower in Omicron cases due to vaccination.” This may be why a news headline from May 2022 said During the Omicron Wave, Death Rates Soared for Older People.
The Omicron variant didn’t just sicken the elderly, it also caused unprecedented illness in children. Because of its contagiousness, hospitalizations for young children were five times higher with Omicron than with Delta. Predictably, unvaccinated children suffered the most. One study found:
Nearly 90% of the 397 children hospitalized during Omicron’s predominance had not gotten COVID-19 shots. Cumulatively, the hospitalization rate was more than two times higher among the unvaccinated. About 30% of the children hospitalized had no underlying conditions, and about 20% required time in the intensive care unit (ICU).
The Omicron variant wasn’t “omi-cold” for them.
He called it “nature’s vaccine“. He said.
We also got another very promising study that answered the open question, ‘does Omicron immunity cross over to Delta?’ and it was found that it gives four times the immunity against Delta. So, it does answer the question – will Omicron displace Delta? – the answer appears to be yes. So for much of the world that will not have access to a vaccine, Omicron will be nature’s vaccine. We can recognize that there is an end in sight to this particular variant as Omicron sweeps across many countries.
Predictably, this was false.
A study of 541 people with two or more infections found the average interval between infections was 229 days. Reinfections were more common with the Omicron variant, and some people were reinfected with “nature’s vaccine” in 45 days.
Different Standards
And that’s how it has been throughout the pandemic. Vocal doctors, sheltered from the consequences of their words, required pristine evidence to praise the vaccine. Meanwhile, they needed no evidence at all to falsely reassure their audience the virus was benign and herd immunity was just around the corner.
817,000 Americans had already died of COVID by December 23, 2021, and 244,000 more would die the next year. Millions more survived, but were injured. These numbers could have been lower if doctors not become defense attorneys for SARS‑CoV‑2 and prosecutors against the vaccine, and instead applied similar standards of evidence to both.

It Was Misinformation When I Said Vaccines Are 100% Effective at Preventing Bad Outcomes & Will End the Pandemic
Jonathan Howard on April 25, 2023
Link

In 2019, Drs. John Mandrola, Adam Cifu, Vinay Prasad, and Andrew Foy wrote an article titled The Case for Being a Medical Conservative. They wrote that the “choice of the term ‘medical conservative’ does not imply a political philosophy.” Instead, they recognized “that many developments promoted as medical advances offer, at best, marginal benefits”. The crux of their article was that:
The medical conservative adopts new therapies when the benefit is clear and the evidence strong and unbiased.
In a previous article titled Medical “Conservatives” Are Medical Radicals, I expressed my broad agreement with this philosophy, while noting that its authors fell short of it by taking a medically radical approach towards SARS-CoV-2 itself.
Additionally, though most of my articles advocate for COVID vaccines, I tried to take a medically conservative approach towards them. I’ve never hidden their blemishes, and I hope I never oversold them as a perfect panacea, especially considering how new they are and how new this virus is. I didn’t feel I could adequately predict their efficacy over the long term. For example, in a Twitter discussion on 4/3/2021, I said.
I’m very very optimistic vaccines will cut transmission of disease. I’m not certain of it. This is why I wear a mask still in public and when treating covid patients.
At the time, I didn’t think we had “strong and unbiased” evidence that the vaccines perfectly halted transmission. Though I was very optimistic, the situation called for caution and humility. As it turns out, the vaccines are far from useless in limiting transmission, though this changed depending on the variant, but they are obviously not an invincible wall either.
Other doctors felt differently in the spring of 2021. They were certain that vaccines halted transmission and offered perfect protection against infections and severe COVID. They suggested that the combination of vaccine-induced and “natural” immunity meant we should stop even trying to predict the course of the pandemic – “enough with these models” – and they tried to shame into silence anyone who still warned of the virus. For example, in April 2021 Dr. Vinay Prasad said that the “media’s breathless coverage of MIS-C and variants has been a disservice”. The Delta and Omicron variants would arrive soon thereafter.
(From May 2021)
Like many people, I am not innocent when it comes to overly optimistic predictions in the spring of 2021. Millions of people were getting vaccinated, and the vaccines were highly effective against the circulating SARS-CoV-2 strains. Meanwhile, COVID cases were plunging and variants were mere theoretical worries. It was an optimistic time and we have to be careful to avoid the hindsight bias. However, I tried to not let my enthusiasm get ahead of the evidence. I never claimed that vaccines offered 100% protection against bad outcomes or that they were certain to end the pandemic. In fact, I wrote in May 2021:
I hope this ages poorly, but given the large numbers of unvaccinated adults, COVID-19 is likely to remain a threat to American children for the foreseeable future, especially in regions of low-vaccine uptake. Many scientists doubt that the US will achieve the vaccination numbers needed for herd immunity.
Sadly, that didn’t age poorly. As such, I don’t feel hypocritical in criticizing medical “conservatives”, who abandoned their own principles, oversold vaccines, and misled people into thinking the virus had been forever tamed, when in fact the worst was yet to come.
However, the harshest criticism of these pollyannaish prognosticators is below.
(Fact Check: Dr. Prasad is cherry-picking the highest rates of vaccine myocarditis and not discussing its clinical course.)

Naked Emperors and Laptop Class Doctors
The authors of this statement are anti-vaccine: “The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.”
Jonathan Howard on May 26, 2022
Link
In previous article, I explored what it means to be pro- and anti-vaccine. In that article, I said that:
We need to leave room for people to have good faith disagreements and questions without inappropriately smearing them as “anti-vaxxers”.
I stand by this. Someone who questioned the value of pediatric vaccines a year ago wasn’t necessarily anti-vaccine. Though I disagreed with them, reasonable people thought the worst was over and there was scant information on the real-world efficacy of vaccines for children. Today, there are still grey areas. Would a healthy 14 year-old boy who had COVID in the summer of 2021 and then received two vaccine doses benefit from a third dose? I can’t point to any data to say he would, and I wouldn’t call someone an anti-vaxxer who felt this child didn’t need a booster.
Additionally, many lay people have heard from reputable doctors that COVID poses no risks to children and that the vaccine hasn’t been properly tested. We can’t expect the average person to be aware of the many studies showing the vaccine is beneficial for children. Confused parents are not anti-vaxxers, even if they were misled by them.
However, there’s a point at which vaccine-advocates can fail to call a spade a spade in the name of decorum. As I’ve discussed previously, several doctors from prestigious universities have encouraged unvaccinated children to contract COVID, and they’ve been extremely successful in their mission. They steadfastly refuse to acknowledge the robust evidence that COVID vaccines can keep children safe and out of the hospital. Their missives arguing against pediatric vaccination are a toxic blend of misinformation and a fetishization of infection-derived immunity.
Despite this, myself and others have tiptoed around calling them anti-vaccine. To maintain the farce that they are pro-vaccine, we’ve said they are echoing anti-vaccine talking points, even if they might not be anti-vaccine themselves.
These doctors certainly claim that they are extremely pro-vaccine. After all, they support the polio vaccine, and believe that older, vulnerable people should people get vaccinated against COVID. They wield this “reasonableness” as a shield against accusations of being anti-vaccine. “I’m not one of those people who thinks COVID is a 5G hoax by Bill Gates and the lizard people” they signal to their audience.
This may be true, but they’re not that different either. Not only have they helped legitimize such cranks, but they’ve penned articles titled “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“, which opened by saying,
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
It’s clear, that when it comes to protecting children against COVID, there’s no daylight between these doctors and Dr. Andrew Wakefield. In fact, their ability to seem reasonable allowed them to influence our pandemic response more than the “real anti-vaxxers”. If you think you can tell distinguish these doctors’ screeds from those of “real anti-vaxxers,” I invite you to challenge yourself here.
Of course, spreading misinformation about pediatric COVID is cost-free for these doctors. Sick children are mere abstractions for them. They’ve experienced the pandemic entirely from their laptops, not from a hospital. They are completely shielded from the consequences of their words and had to construct absurd oppression fantasies to mislead their audience into thinking they’ve suffered too. Though, to be fair, YouTube removed a video they made.
Doctors who do nothing but fear monger about the vaccine and advocate for unvaccinated children to contract COVID are anti-vaccine full stop. I’m done pretending otherwise. There is no virtue in pretending naked emperors are actually clothed in fine garments. Similarly, there is no virtue in sugar-coating these doctors’ anti-vaccine statements simply because they have impressive credentials and can speak in measured, scientific jargon. If you feel they can still be called pro-vaccine, ask yourself this: what more would they have to do be labeled anti-vaccine?
Those of us who are familiar with the anti-vaccine movement know the answer is “nothing”.

The Pro-Vaccine Test
When it comes to children and COVID-19, certain doctors seem unwilling to acknowledge negative information about the virus and positive information about the vaccine. Can they pass the pro-vaccine test?
Jonathan Howard on September 10, 2021
Link

On June 22nd, 2021 well-known anti-vaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. published an article titled “Children’s Health Defense and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Protest Efforts to Vaccinate Underage Children Without Parental Knowledge or Consent.” It said the following:
    • Even as the CDC is discussing the known cardiac risks and heart inflammation affecting children and young adults following COVID-19 vaccination, a concerted effort is underway to coerce this same group to get the vaccine anyway.
    • According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, children comprised only 0.00%-0.23% of all COVID-19 deaths, and eight states reported zero child deaths. When children do get the disease, they’ll likely have lifelong immunity.
    • The CDC reports that children are less likely to develop severe illness or die from Covid-19 and are more likely to be asymptomatic or show mild systems. And there are lower rates of infection among children compared with adults. CHD demands that CDC provide the reasoning behind these perplexing recommendations. Why would a vaccine be recommended that perhaps carries more risk to children’s health than the actual disease, and which has no long term safety data to support its use?
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is a well-known anti-vaccine propagandist and a member of the “Disinformation Dozen“. It’s pretty easy to label just about anything he says as anti-vaccine misinformation. It’s true that only a small percentage of children who contract COVID-19 get gravely ill and that adults are affected much more severely. A child I love recently got COVID-19 at school and brought it home to his little sister. I wasn’t worried about them, and they were barely sick. However, millions of American children have contracted the virus, and rare outcomes can add up. Hundreds of children have died and tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized. As it would undermine his agenda, Mr. Kennedy and other anti-vaccine activists don’t want you to know this. While vaccine-induced myocarditis is real, vaccines cause myocarditis less often than the virus and vaccine myocarditis is generally less severe. The vaccine can prevent devastating outcomes and deaths in adolescents. As is often the case with anti-vaxxers, Mr. Kennedy deceives by omission, leaving out facts that would cast the virus in a negative light or the vaccine in a positive light.
Unfortunately, many doctors with stellar academic credentials who consider themselves pro-vaccine, have similarly opposed vaccinating children using identical talking points as Mr. Kennedy. As with Mr. Kennedy’s article, the totality of how COVID-19 has harmed children is brushed off with meaningless bromides that “the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young”. This is true, but utterly irrelevant as to whether or not the vaccine can protect them from a virus with potentially grave consequences.
What then is the fundamental difference between these doctors and Mr. Kennedy, at least as far as children are concerned?
What does it mean to be pro-vaccine?
To me, being pro-vaccine means taking into account all of the relevant data to make a fair, accurate risk-benefit calculation about a vaccine. I clearly believe adolescents should be vaccinated against COVID-19. My case would be strengthened were I to maximize the harms of the virus and minimize the harms of the vaccine. However, the overwhelming majority of kids with COVID-19 will be just fine. Severe outcomes occur at a very low rate for children, thankfully. I’ve said this in every article I’ve written on this topic. Similarly, I’ve written about vaccine myocarditis as fairly as possible and have said every time that it should not be trivialized. Though most vaccines are overwhelming safe and effective, their imperfections cannot be ignored or wished away.
Being pro-vaccine does not mean blindly suggesting all vaccines. I’ll never need to order the Ebola vaccine, for example. Certainly, before the Delta variant arrived – when it seemed that Covid might fade away and vaccine myocarditis was just popping up – it was not entirely unreasonable to question the vaccine’s risk/benefit ratio in healthy, teenage boys. Not every concern about the COVID-19 vaccine in children is necessarily anti-vaccine. The risk/benefit ratio differs depending on whether that child is in Florida or New Zealand and whether the child has previously contracted COVID-19 or not. We need to leave room for people to have good faith disagreements and questions without inappropriately smearing them as “anti-vaxxers”.
Though it’s fair for people to ask questions about the COVID-19 vaccine, this is true only if they’re genuinely prepared to accept the answers. Right now, the virus is causing more damage to children than ever before in the US, and there have been no catastrophic vaccine outcomes in adolescents. As I have discussed previously, the data clearly shows that the virus is more dangerous than the vaccine for adolescents, especially given that a record number of children – 250,000 – who contracted the virus last week alone in the US. This is a reality that some “pro-vaccine” doctors are determined to ignore, even though they happily commented when pediatric cases were at their low point several months ago.
What does it mean to be anti-vaccine?
Obviously there is no clear-cut criteria for who is anti-vaccine, and there is a very wide spectrum of beliefs in the anti-vaccine movement. Some people proudly announce they are anti-vaxxers, while other notorious spreaders of anti-vaccine misinformation, including Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., adamantly reject this label. To me, the core that unites anti-vaccine thought is: 1) inappropriate minimization of the risk of the virus, and 2) inappropriate minimization of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine
Given the way the virus is harming children at present, arguments against vaccinating them must use one or more of the following techniques: gross errors of fact, blatant omissions of relevant data, or insinuations that negative data can’t be trusted, e.g. “COVID-19 isn’t really that bad for children”. Highly credentialed doctors from prestigious universities have used all of these techniques in some form to bolster their argument that not all children should be vaccinated against COVID-19. All of their errors and omissions downplay the dangers of the virus or the safety/efficacy of the vaccine – never the reverse. These are not just errors then, they are systematic biases. (I discussed this all in detail here.)
Won’t somebody please think of the children who didn’t die of COVID-19?
In addition to the errors, omissions, and insinuations, there’s one other technique used to minimize how COVID-19 has harmed children. I’ll call it the “think of all the children who didn’t die” gambit. It’s not wrong. The vast majority of children were not killed by COVID-19. However, this is true of everything that kills children, including cancer, suicide, accidents, and school shootings. If you wouldn’t minimize these tragedies by pointing out that there are 75 million children who didn’t die this way, then you probably shouldn’t do that with COVID-19 either. No child is supposed to die. Hundreds of children are not supposed to die. Imagine if you lost a child and someone responded this way.
The pro-vaccine test
So how can you tell if a doctor is actually pro-vaccine? I propose a simple test. Here are 5 facts about the virus and 5 facts about the vaccine for children and adolescents.
Five facts about the virus
        ◦ COVID-19 can kill children: Between 486-521 children (depending on which CDC website one uses) have died from the virus in America, including adolescents and children and with no underlying conditions who were eligible to be vaccinated. Sadly, more children are dying now than ever before. Since the start of July, The American Academy of Pediatrics added over 100 deaths to their tally. A newborn just died in Florida.
        ◦ COVID-19 has hospitalized many children: Tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized due to COVID-19. More children are being infected than ever before, and therefore more children are being hospitalized now than ever before. Currently, 367 children are being hospitalized every day with COVID-19. This number has been going straight up for awhile now, and I fear it will be awhile before it starts to come down again. Though most children stay just a few days, up to 33% of these need ICU-level care and 6-10% need intubation. According to the CDC, “During March 1, 2020–August 14, 2021, the cumulative incidence of COVID-19–associated hospitalizations was 49.7 per 100,000 children and adolescents”. 1 in 2,000 children in the US have been hospitalized over the course of this pandemic, and cases are higher now for children than ever before.
        ◦ Long-COVID may not be rare: There are more questions than answers about long COVID-19 in children, but one recent study from England found that infected children were twice as likely than uninfected children to report multiple symptoms such as headache and “unusual tiredness” 15 weeks later. Other studies found a lower rate, perhaps 2%, but this adds up to a large number of very sick children when multiplied by the millions of children who contracted the virus. This is a new virus and we have to be humble about its potential long-term side effects. Even the majority of children who turn out just fine were often very sick and uncomfortable for several days at a minimum.
        ◦ COVID-19 causes myocarditis: A CDC study found that 1 in 754 children with COVID-19 younger than 16 years developed myocarditis, while the rate for their uninfected peers was 1 in 28,000. The risk of myocarditis for children under 16 years was 37 times higher for children infected with COVID-19
        ◦ COVID-19-related myocarditis can be severe: Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) can cause severe myocarditis , and there have been at least 4,661 cases in the US, possibly many more. Studies have reported coronary artery aneurysms and acute heart failure in children with MIS-C. Other common cardiac complications of myocarditis due to MIS-C include “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Cardiac arrhythmias have led “to hemodynamic collapse and need for ECMO support” in some children
Five facts about the vaccine
    • Vaccine myocarditis is less severe: Vaccine myocarditis is much less severe than viral myocarditis. Short-term outcomes in vaccine myocarditis from multiple case series and government agencies in different countries have been consistently favorable. Most individuals are hospitalized, but almost all leave the hospital in just a few days after receiving simple treatments. No child has needed to be intubated as far as I know. About 75% are symptom-free after follow-up. Nonetheless, long-term monitoring is needed, and the condition should not be trivialized.
    • Vaccine myocarditis is not common: The exact rate of vaccine myocarditis is not clear. It is not rare, but it is not common either. Israel initially reported a rate of 1:3,000-6,000 young men. Since that time, two vaccine safety databases maintained by the CDC (here and here) report a give a rate of about 1:13,500 for teenage men after their second shot. Data from Ontario showed a rate of 1 in 11,000 for males age 12-17 after their second dose. Another large study of people age 12-39 years using safety surveillance data from Vaccine Safety Datalink put the rate at much less than this, about 1 in 79,000. No pediatric hospital has been deluged by children suffering from vaccine-myocarditis. The same cannot be said for the virus.
    • The Vaccine worked in trials: The vaccine successfully prevented adolescents from getting COVID-19 in clinical trials (Pfizer, Moderna). In these trials, a total of 20 COVID-19 cases were observed, none in vaccinated adolescents.
    • The vaccine is working in the real world: A recent study by the CDC found that unvaccinated children are hospitalized 10 times more often than vaccinated ones. Most countries with abundant supply are vaccinating adolescents.
    • No vaccine deaths: According to the CDC, nearly 9 million American adolescents have been vaccinated, and none are known to have died from the vaccine.
The CDC summarized the risks and benefits of the COVID-19 for 16 and 17-year-olds as follows.
Pro-vaccine doctors shouldn’t just be willing to share some at least version of these facts, they should do so eagerly whenever they discuss the topic. Many parents and young people remain ignorant of this information. Only 32% of adolescents are fully vaccinated in the US. The consequences have been severe for some of them. Some children would likely still be alive right now if these facts were more widely known. One father, whose 15-year-old died said:
It’s something that’s going to be stuck with me for my whole life, thinking maybe I should have done that sooner. Maybe I could’ve done something to help prevent this. I don’t want any other parent to go through what I did — seeing my daughter perfectly healthy one day then following a week and a half, she’s gone.
More preventable tragedies await. I feel it’s important to actually read about some of these children occasionally to remind yourself they are more than just statistics on a CDC website. These are young people robbed of their entire life. Yet, astonishingly, several doctors have written multiple articles or produced long Twitter threads on the topic of COVID-19 vaccines for children without acknowledging these basic facts. For some, these facts are just unmentionable.
Passing the pro-vaccine test should be extremely easy. It only requires someone to acknowledge and share basic facts when opining on children and the vaccine. As a bonus, sharing these facts will help prevent significant suffering for a significant number of children. I mean honestly, this is an extremely low bar. Yet, I know several doctors who will fail the pro-vaccine test. Even as they extol the virtues of honestly discussing the risks and the benefits of the vaccine, they will refuse to share these core facts.
        ◦ By what measure can they be considered pro-vaccine?

A “not antivaccine” antivax pediatrician asks how we will know a COVID-19 vaccine is safe and effective
Dr. Liz Mumper is associated with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivax organization Children’s Health Defense. She recently gave a presentation asking: How will we know that a COVID vaccine is safe? It’s a presentation that provides an excellent example of how to identify if someone is antivaccine.
David Gorski on March 1, 2021
Link

Recently, I’ve seen a presentation by a pediatrician named Dr. Liz Mumper being promoted by antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and his antivaccine organization Children’s Health Defense entitled “How will we know that a COVID vaccine is safe?” It’s a great example of antivaccine propaganda disguised as “concerns” that are portrayed as seemingly reasonable but fall apart upon closer inspection. Before I get to that closer inspection of the video itself, however, let me explain how Dr. Mumper’s video is a perfect teaching tool to help identify antivaccine propaganda, particularly in the way that it basically answers the question with antivaccine talking points and an impossible standard.
“Antivax”: I know it when I see it
Whenever I’m asked what I mean when I refer to someone as “antivaccine”, “antivax”, or an “antivaxxer”, I tend to use two responses. The first is that I’ll often joke that being antivaccine is a lot like pornography. I know it when I see it. Basically, I’m channeling US Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart’s famous quip about hard-core pornography in Jacobellis v. Ohio. And it’s true. I do know antivaccine rhetoric when I see it without mentally having to check off a bunch of boxes in a list of criteria for what constitutes antivaccine conspiracy mongering and pseudoscience. However, that’s often very unsatisfying to those who haven’t followed the antivaccine movement for a long time. That’s where I like to use another test.
When I encounter someone whom I suspect of being antivaccine (especially if they deny being antivax and claim to be promoting vaccine safety), I like to ask a simple question. My line of questioning usually goes something like this: “You say you’re not ‘antivaccine,’ and I’ll accept that for the moment. Presumably, though, your not being ‘antivaccine’ means that you accept that there actually do exist vaccines that are sufficiently safe and effective for you to take yourself or for you to recommend in general to children (in the case of childhood vaccines) or adults. So tell me: Which vaccines do you consider sufficiently safe and effective to recommend in general?”
On rare occasions, the person suspected of being antivaccine will list off a vaccine or two, but only on rare occasions. When that happens, it doesn’t necessarily mean that the person is not antivaccine, but it’s a start. Some people, for instance, are afraid of only one or two vaccines (such as the COVID-19 vaccine). They might just be vaccine hesitant, rather than antivaccine, and then just hesitant about a small subset of vaccines at that. They can potentially be reasoned with, unless their fear of that one vaccine or handful of vaccines is too rooted in conspiracy theory.
More frequently, the answer to the question will either be crickets or a skillful dance around the question, in which conspiracies about big pharma will be referenced or a vaccine or two will be mentioned, but with so many caveats that the “endorsement” of that vaccine is functionally not an endorsement at all. Alternatively, the response will involve placing so many conditions, often impossible conditions, upon the endorsement of a vaccine or vaccines as to make it clear that there’s no way that person would ever recommend any vaccine. Sometimes the response is of the form, “I’m not ‘antivaccine,’ but current vaccines are completely unacceptable and unsafe”. I’ll quote an example from our old pal, scientist-turned-antivaccine-crank James Lyons-Weiler, in which he stated:
Mind you, I am not anti-vaccine. Ask any hard-core anti-vaxxer who has debated the issues with me. They get frustrated at my eternal hope that vaccines might be made safer. Or that biomarkers might be found to screen for those most at risk at serious adverse events. I do have issues with denial of informed consent, and in the bias that exists both in the conduct of “science” on vaccine science, in the interpretation of the “science” on vaccine safety, and the absolute bias in the media against any reasonable discussion of whether any vaccine is responsible for any adverse event.
Notice how Lyons-Weiler tried to distinguish himself from “hard-core antivaxxers” and then launched into unreasonable reasons that he considers vaccines unsafe, including the persecution complex so beloved of antivaxxers that you “can’t discuss” whether a given vaccine causes an adverse event. (Funny, The CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization practices, a.k.a. ACIP, would beg to differ, as would the FDA, which routinely asks exactly that question during the approval process of every vaccine and medicine. It’s making claims for adverse events caused by vaccines that are unsupported by the evidence and spreading conspiracy theories that generally garner the unfavorable reactions that Lyons-Weiler is complaining about, not doing science-based analyses about specific adverse events and specific vaccines.)
Then Lyons-Weiler, as antivaxxers nearly always do, gave the game away:
Let me state this as clearly as possible: as currently formulated, vaccines are filthy, nasty vials of toxic sludge that every American citizen and parent should be able to refuse for any reason. Doctors are not qualified to and should not be put in the position to “vet” whether any individuals’ claim to a religious exemption is “valid”; they certainly are not trained on comparative theology in medical school, and they cannot know the hearts and minds of individuals who do not want to collaborate with the past evils of abortion by injecting products made with and containing proteins and DNA from aborted fetal cells and tumor cell lines. I defend religious exemptions, and I am an evolutionary biologist!
So Lyons-Weiler also stated that vaccines are “filthy, nasty vials of toxic sludge”. That sounds rather…antivaccine, doesn’t it? Or is it just me? You get the idea. Simple, innocent probing questions directed at a suspected antivaxxer proclaiming that he’s “not antivaccine” will almost always reveal the truth. Dr. Mumper’s article is much like this, as I will show.
“I’m not antivaccine, but COVID-19 vaccines can never be safe”
Now let’s get into Dr. Mumper’s article, “How Will We Know That a COVID-19 Vaccine is Safe?” The video, sadly, is still on YouTube:
I thought YouTube and Google were cracking down on antivaccine disinformation. How is it that Children’s Health Defense still has a YouTube channel and can still post videos like this? In any case, you don’t have to watch it. Helpfully, there is a transcript, for those of you so inclined, and the PowerPoint presentation is in a PDF file. Also, RFK Jr. gives the game away with this introduction:
Dr. Mumper carefully provides detailed answers to two questions often asked by the public: “What does a safe and effective vaccine look like?” and “How will we know that a COVID-19 vaccine is safe?” She reviews many of the reasons why vaccines, as they are currently produced, are not safe, and explains that every year there are tens of thousands of adverse events, many of them resulting in serious conditions or even death.
Even if Dr. Mumper’s panoply of antivaccine disinformation were actually good science (which, obviously, it isn’t), I can’t help but point out that over a half a million are dead of COVID-19 in just over a year in just the US alone, with millions sickened and untold numbers of survivors suffering complications of the disease. Of course, Dr. Mumper is a longtime antivaccine activist. She’s the President and CEO of The Rimland Center and a Scientific Advisory Committee Member for RFK Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense. Longtimers might remember that Bernard Rimland formed the Autism Research Institute in 1967 and became the inspiration for Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!) doctors, who all advocated “autism biomed” treatments for autism, the vast majority of which were quackery and much of which was based on the false idea that vaccines cause autism. Dr. Mumper has also been featured on SBM before, albeit a long time ago, when she promoted a plan that (she claimed) prevented nearly all autism in children. Unsurprisingly, lack of vaccines was a prominent feature.
As for the presentation itself, Mumper begins by citing how many people are reluctant to accept COVID-19 vaccines, pointing to “lockdowns” (they aren’t really that; they’re barely restrictions in many cases) as overreactions, and then blaming fear for the rush to a COVID-19 vaccine:
But why would we put all of our eggs in one basket? Why would we assume that a vaccine developed at Warp Speed is the only way to save ourselves? A public health crisis that’s unfolding with global implications should bring forth collaborative strategies to pull our collective wisdom. Now, the amygdala is a part of our brain that is ruled by fear and emotion, it’s considered the reptilian part of the brain, this very primitive response. So instant access to bad news 24/7 can have the effect of making us live in fear.
Neuroscience long ago has shown that when we are fearful, our ability to make rational decisions is compromised. We have trouble processing nuanced information. We are more likely to follow others blindly than to assess the data and make decisions for ourselves and our families. So the hijacking of the amygdala by fear, obviously a hand coming out of the grave or the scary clown face are images that would disturb most people. However, now, if we’re living in fear, the other images like the hand being presented for a handshake or the cute guy’s smile might seem threatening to some people because they’re worried about the contagion of COVID.
And here are the slides accompanying this part of the talk:
Got that? The reason we’re rushing ahead with vaccinating as many people as possible can’t possibly be because millions are being sickened by SARS-CoV-2 and hundreds of thousands have died in just a year. It has to be fear. (Heck, Dr. Mumper even included a photo of a zombie hand pushing through the dirt of a grave!) Of course, sometimes, fear is not an entirely irrational response to danger, and COVID-19 represents danger. In any event, one might perceive that we’re “putting all our eggs in one basket”, but if that’s the case it’s more because of a failure to use other methods to stop the spread of the virus.
Next up:
Yes, this is the ever-popular antivaccine gambit that I like to refer to as “vaccines didn’t save us”. It’s a highly intellectually dishonest antivaccine trope in which antivaxxers point to the declining mortality rate from vaccine-preventable diseases before the vaccines were introduced as evidence that “vaccines didn’t save us”. We’ve done detailed rebuttals before (for example here), and Steve Novella rebutted this very same trope when he debated Dr. Julian Whitaker (with Leslie Manookian as moderator!) at FreedomFest in Las Vegas in 2012. You know, thinking of that incident, I can’t resist posting this photo again:
Memories. Earning the ire of a quack like Dr. Whitaker always brings back happy memories. But let’s continue. I’m not going to go into the weeds of every antivaccine trope in Dr. Mumper’s presentation because we at SBM have refuted them all before. (I’ll provide links where appropriate.) I’m more interested in what someone like Dr. Mumper thinks would be an acceptably safe vaccine.
An antivaxxer’s vision of what a “perfect” vaccine would look like
So let’s get into the list of Dr. Mumper’s criteria for a vaccine that’s acceptably safe and effective as applied to COVID-19. Before I get into them, I can’t help but point out that not only do the current candidate COVID-19 vaccines meet many of these criteria, but that close to all vaccines do, other than a couple of ringers. For example, here’s the Criterion #1, which does not start her argument well:
The vaccine would be tested against a true placebo, inert saline, which is salt water. So unlike drugs, which have to be tested against a true placebo, vaccines fall under the category of biologics and are not tested against a true saline placebo. As an example, Merck’s HPV vaccine was tested against an aluminum adjuvant that can trigger auto-immunity. This clinical impact of this is actually very significant since aluminum is a known neurotoxin and a known trigger for auto-immunity, having aluminum in the new vaccine and in the placebo would wash out the differences in auto-immune or neurologic disease between the two groups. The one that got the vaccine and the one that got the aluminum placebo.
The “no true placebo” trope is an antivaccine lie that can be very easily refuted by simply searching PubMed for “vaccine clinical trial placebo”, which brings up thousands of references. Dr. Vincent Iannelli has written several articles about vaccines being tested against saline controls and loves to list examples of double-blind saline placebo-controlled clinical trials of vaccines. Personally, I like pointing out how the claim by antivaxxers that the MMR was never tested against a saline placebo is utter hogwash. I also like pointing out that this requirement by antivaxxers is red herring dependent on an utter lack of understanding of clinical trial design, as sometimes the best placebo control is not something completely inert, like saline, nor is the use of solutions that contain everything but the vaccine antigen as a placebo control somehow unethical or scientifically unsound.
I’ll jump to Criterion #4:
Number four, vaccines should be free of mercury, aluminum and nano-metals. At Children’s Health Defense, we have over 240 studies showing that mercury is not safe. Due to safety concerns, the public health service did remove mercury for most vaccines starting in 1999 and most were phased out by 2003, 2004 but mercury is still present in many flu vaccines. Aluminum is a known neurotoxin, which is used as an adjuvant to induce immune responses in lots of vaccines.
Of course, there has been no more than trace mercury in childhood vaccines for nearly 20 years now, and since then aluminum has become the new mercury to antivaxxers, with repeated attempts using bad science by them to demonstrate that aluminum adjuvants are unsafe. They aren’t. Basically, aluminum is the new mercury to antivaxxers, and you know what’s funny? Neither the Pfizer/BioNTech nor the Moderna vaccines currently being used contain either of them.
Now, Criterion #7 (yes, I’m jumping around to the criteria that don’t even apply to COVID-19 vaccines before I get to the ones that might):
Number seven, vaccines should be free of human DNA and aborted human fetal tissue. So there’s a human fetal cell line dating back to the 1960s that’s been used in vaccines for many years. An Italian study identified the presence of a complete abnormal human genome of a male fetus in the MMRV vaccine, which is measles, mumps, rubella combined with chicken pox, a vaccine I have never used because of such concerns. And I invite you to go to the Children’s Health Defense website and check out the paper.
That Italian study is so risibly bad as to evoke nothing but laughter and disgust from me. As for the rest, even that most anti-abortion of religions, the Roman Catholic Church, has stated that vaccines used from cell lines derived from aborted fetuses in the 1960s is acceptable, albeit not ideal, because the “evil” (in its view) is so remote from the cell lines as they exist now that the “extreme good” of vaccination outweighs it. Also, current COVID-19 vaccines are not manufactured using these cell lines, which are used for other vaccines for which virus stock needs to be grown in order to make them, although some research that led to their development did use such cells. Also, the Roman Catholic Church said that it’s acceptable to use these COVID-19 vaccines. I’ll finish by mentioning that vaccines using these cell lines have saved millions of lives and prevented billions of cases of sickness.
Now let’s backtrack and cover the rest. I’m going to save Criterion #2 for last because it’s a claim that antivaxxers have long made for all vaccines. Let’s start by taking on Criterion #3 instead:
Number three, experimental mRNA and DNA gene technologies should undergo years of testing before being used on consumers, mRNA vaccines have actually been used to target specific types of cancer. And if that works well for that patient, that’s fantastic. But the initial studies on COVID mRNA vaccines were done on extremely healthy patients. And since the vaccine is currently being prioritized for the most vulnerable, including the elderly, it’s crucial to assess safety for those in various states of health. And this theoretically is happening as the trials progress to phase three. mRNA vaccines have an intrinsic inflammatory effect, which could lead to auto-immune events.
Both Moderna and Pfizer and BioNTech are using mRNA technology in their vaccines. And these techniques have not been used and approved in the context of widespread use as is being contemplated now. In 1990, the first report of a successful use of In Vitro transcribed mRNA in animals was published. At that time, concerns were raised about the inherent instability of mRNA and the high innate immunogenicity of mRNA vaccines which can be a double-edged sword.
There’s been a lot of progress since then but mRNA that comes from outside a person is inherently immunostimulatory because your body recognizes that is foreign. Another concern that I have is that, in order for mRNA vaccines to penetrate into the cell membrane, they have to essentially penetrate by lipid layer, the two layers of fat that surround all our cell membranes. And this can be done through electrical measures or by using carrier proteins. And my question is, do we really wanna poke holes in our cell membrane?
It is true that mRNA can be immunostimulatory, but that’s actually a problem for mRNA-based vaccine design more than a concern about the vaccine because that immune stimulation could result in an mRNA vaccine being less effective. Moreover, naked mRNA is very unstable in aqueous solution and rapidly broken down if it’s left out in the extracellular fluid. Of course, the mRNA is encapsulated in lipid nanoparticles and thus largely shielded from the immune system, but Pfizer and Moderna have also made modifications to the mRNA to make it less unstable and decrease the immunogenicity of the raw mRNA. Moreover, the autoimmune condition stimulated by mRNA was observed only in mice and could be prevented with a simple modification to the mRNA.
As for the development of mRNA vaccines, Dr. Mumper tries to make it sound as though this is some sort of radical new technology, even as she cites an animal study from 1990 using mRNA to make a protein product in animals. The bottom line is that mRNA vaccines have been under development for at least a couple of decades, and it was serendipity that the technology was ready for prime time at around about the time the COVID-19 pandemic hit and got out of control. I’ve seen a number of scientists saying that if the pandemic had hit five years ago, the technology would not have been ready. In any event, this technology is not gene therapy, nor will it reprogram your DNA. It’s actually a highly useful way to be able to make and update a vaccine very rapidly, with many advantages, including high potency, capacity for rapid development, and potential for low-cost manufacture. Indeed, as new SARS-CoV-2 variants that might be less susceptible to the vaccine proliferate, the ability to update COVID-19 vaccines by simply packaging the mRNA for the new variants in the lipid nanoparticles will become paramount.
Let’s move on to Criterion #5:
Number five, vaccines should be free of adjuvants that are proven to be dangerous. This includes, but it’s not limited to squalene, aluminum and polyethylene glycol. So an adjuvant is a substance that’s deliberately added to a vaccine in order to stimulate the immune system to make a strong immune response. So squalene is one of many adjuvants that are used and it was found to be harmful in certain people by inducing, for example, auto-immune conditions or narcolepsy which is falling asleep suddenly literally while you’re on your feet sometimes. Polyethylene glycol is another adjuvant that can trigger serious auto-immune responses and anaphylaxis in certain individuals.
There is indeed PEG in the lipid nanoparticles of the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccines. PEG is a very commonly used ingredient in a number of applications, including, for example, toothpaste, ice cream, and osmotic laxatives of the type used for colon prep for colonoscopy. It’s also been used in a variety of medications. Since I’m a cancer doctor, I’ll point to liposomal doxorubicin, which has a PEG layer around a doxorubicin-containing liposome and has been used for a quarter of a century with fewer side effects than doxorubicin. It has a long safety record. In fact, serious allergic reactions to PEG are quite rare. Indeed, a recent study found that anaphylactic reactions to COVID-19 vaccines containing PEG are rare, 4.7 cases/million doses for the Pfizer vaccine and 2.5 cases/million doses for the Moderna vaccine, well within the range seen for other vaccines and very uncommon, with no deaths reported. As for squalene, none of the currently used vaccines under emergency use approval (EUA) contains squalene. There are five candidate vaccines that do (GlaxoSmithKline, Clover Biopharmaceuticals, Seqirus/University of Queensland/CSL, Medicago Inc. and Farmacologós veterinarios SAC/Universidad Peruana Cayetana Heredia). Thus far, none of these have received an EUA from the US. The Johnson & Johnson vaccine did just receive an EUA, but the GSK vaccine has not. Indeed, a reformulated version of the GSK vaccine is still in clinical trials and is not expected to be widely deployed until late this year at the earliest. In actuality, the reason not to be excited about squalene-containing COVID-19 vaccines is not because squalene is dangerous, but rather because its main source is still sharks and a massive need for squalene could endanger shark populations.
Next up, Criterion #6:
Number six, the vaccine should be free of avian, bovine, porcine, monkey and mouse viruses. So essentially many vaccines are produced in animal serums and can be contaminated with retrovirus. One such virus is known as simian virus 40 which has been shown to be associated with cancer. So in the new millennia, we have better methods for producing vaccines. And again, we need to keep safety foremost in our minds. It’s notable that SARS-CoV-2 or COVID-19 is an animal virus that allegedly originated in bats.
Here we go again. This is yet another old antivaccine trope repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines, namely that SV40 contaminating the polio vaccine has resulted in an epidemic of cancer. It hasn’t. More importantly, the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines are entirely synthetic. The mRNA is synthesized, as are the lipid nanoparticles. There are no viruses and no cells in which there could be viral contamination. That bit about SARS-CoV-2 having originated in bats is, of course, a speculative distraction.
Criterion #8 is straight out of QAnon:
Number eight, vaccine should be free of bio chips and nano-technology agents. So it’s important to know that bio-chips and nano-technology agents can be introduced into the body through vaccines. This would allow communication between a person’s biology physiology or psychology and outside technology. This is a new frontier but you need to know that it is being examined by tech companies as well as by the defense advanced research projects agency. I’m not saying this will be done with COVID vaccines as Yogi Berra said, it’s tough to make predictions especially about the future, but we need to have our eyes wide open so that those of us who have backgrounds in history and sociology and theology and the humanities and medicine can temper the momentum of big tech as these options are explored.
None of the current COVID-19 vaccines in use or nearing use contain biochips or nanotechnology. Here, Dr. Mumper is just delving into the deeper realms of antivaccine conspiracy theories. I will give her credit for not mentioning Bill Gates in her talk, although she did on slide #32, where she mentioned “hydrogel” as well. This nonsense has been discussed before; so I’ll move on, except to chuckle at how Dr. Mumper includes a slide that claims that these chips are unlikely to be listed as ingredients and that “independent” testing would be needed to verify that COVID-19 vaccines don’t have them.
Criterion #9 is not entirely unreasonable but it is also exaggerated:
Number nine, the liability protection provided to vaccine makers actually creates a perverse incentive to rush the vaccine and potentially downplay safety concerns. So at Children’s Health Defense, we argue that vaccine makers need to bear responsibility and financial liability for ensuring that their products are safe. Again, many people are not aware that vaccine injuries and deaths do occur. And again, that the consumers of vaccines paid over $4.4 billion to compensate the vaccine injured.
This is the usual trope about the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP). When taken in context in the over 30 years that the program has existed, the payouts have not been that particularly large. It is true that vaccines that haven’t been approved by the FDA are not even subject to the NVICP but rather to the Countermeasures Injury Compensation program, which is a lot less generous, and that’s not an unreasonable concern. (Vaccine advocates want COVID-19 vaccines to be covered under NVICP.) It’s funny that Dr. Mumper didn’t even seem to understand this.
Finally, back to #7, showing that everything old about vaccines is new again for COVID-19 vaccines:
A safe vaccine would be tested long enough to track adverse events. And then post approval surveillance would be conducted to measure the long-term effects. So many vaccines are just monitored for side effects for two to five days or maybe a week. And auto-immune neurodevelopmental and chronic conditions would take much longer than that to manifest. As an example, Merck’s hepatitis B vaccine, which was given to one day old infants was only safety tested for five days.
So here’s my question. Newborn babies, mostly eat and sleep. So how effective can we be at assessing if they are experiencing side effects in such a short period of time? As somebody who has studied vaccines for many years and I’ve read every single vaccine insert of every single vaccine, I’m not as worried about the short-term effects, the redness, the swelling, all those signs that show that the body has recognized the shot as foreign and is reacting to it. I’m much more concerned about potential long-term effects on brain inflammation or auto-immunity, for example.
This is an oldie but not goody from antivaxxers, the claim that we don’t monitor vaccines for adverse events. Dr. Mumper even trots out the common antivax claim that less than 1% of adverse reactions ever get reported to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database, which is, quite simply, not true and based on a single study. Also, VAERS is not the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring, as I’ve explained more times than I can remember. Moreover, it is simply not true that there aren’t any long-term term safety studies of vaccines, as Dr. Mumper claims. There are. As for the COVID-19 vaccines, there is an intense safety monitoring program that is unprecedented in its intensity to track potential adverse events.
To back up her claim that vaccines cause chronic health problems, Dr. Mumper even trots out RFK Jr.’s claim that the current generation of children is the “sickest generation” (because of mostly vaccines and a few other things), a claim that is, quite simply, not true and, even if it were, not because of vaccines. Of course, Dr. Mumper believes this and also believes that we can “boost our immune system” to deal with COVID-19 by using vitamins C and D, taking zinc, avoiding “pro-inflammatory foods”, and other things unlikely to make a difference.
As for her solutions:
So the six steps that we advocate; vaccines should be subjective [sic] to scientifically rigorous approval processes. We need to remove conflicts of interest so that those involved in the vaccine approval process are not going to directly or indirectly benefit from approving a vaccine. We need acknowledgement from both medical and public health authorities that vaccine injury exists and that they will take this seriously and take steps to investigate the causes of vaccine injuries.
Actually, we have all these things. Vaccines are subject to scientifically rigorous approval processes, and there is a very strict conflict of interest policy for members of the ACIP. The very existence of the NVICP is an admission that vaccine injury can happen. Antivaxxers just don’t like that it doesn’t “acknowledge” potential “injuries” from vaccines that are not backed up by scientific evidence showing that they occur. The unprecedented vaccine safety monitoring effort with the rollout of the new COVID-19 vaccines tells us that the government takes vaccine safety very seriously indeed.
Then:
We need systems that can actually measure the safety of vaccines and their adverse events after the vaccine is deployed. So the existing systems that we have, VAERS which is the vaccine adverse event reporting system and VSD, which is the vaccine safety data link, these need to be automated and updated. Government needs to support fully-informed consent. And this does involve potentially the individual right to refuse vaccination, obviously, a topic for much debate. We at Children’s Health Defense welcome civil debate among people who disagree. Number six, government-granted immunity for vaccine makers needs to be rescinded. We need to restore some liability for people who are profiting from vaccines. At Children’s Health Defense, we are working with like-minded organizations around the globe to push for these safety changes and for vaccine safety reform.
She forgot the other vaccine safety monitoring systems, and, I note, has failed to cite anything wrong with the VSD. As for “fully informed consent,” what antivaxxers mean by that is, in actuality, what I like to refer to as “misinformed refusal“, in which all the fantasy-inspired fake “adverse reactions” to vaccines are presented to people before they receive them as if they were supported by science. As for “liability”, vaccine manufacturers can be sued if Vaccine Court rules against the complainant, and they pay a tax on every vaccine to fund the court. These are all common antivaccine myths about the NVICP and the Vaccine Court. Indeed, it’s easier to prevail in Vaccine Court than in civil court, and the Vaccine Court even pays reasonable legal and court costs for the complainant, win or lose.
What have we learned today?
I started out this post by pointing out how people who claim they are “not antivaccine” can be identified as antivaccine. The reason I did that is because RFK Jr. is well known for not only proclaiming himself “not antivaccine” but “fiercely pro-vaccine” and stating that Children’s Health Defense is “not antivaccine”. Dr. Mumper herself uses a variant of the claim that she’s “not antivaccine” but rather a “vaccine safety advocate” when she says late in the presentation:
Many of us want a safer vaccination program for all vaccines and for all people. This is common to us, whether you identify as pro-vaccine or have concerns about safety of vaccines, which by the way does not make one an anti-vaxxer. We need to know that we’re developing the health of our children as best we can. So we could work together and make us safer vaccine program. Children’s Health Defense has been looking at this for years, and we have a lot of resources.
This is exactly the phenomenon I described at the beginning. An antivaxxer denies being “antivaccine” and proclaims herself as being “for safer vaccines”. Then, when I look at her requirements for a safe COVID-19 vaccine, I quickly find that she has constructed them such that they either (1) do not apply to COVID-19 vaccines; (2) have been met by COVID-19 vaccines (and, by the way, other vaccines); or (3) are either deceptive or impossible standards. Worse, while justifying her standards, Dr. Mumper regurgitates a number of common antivaccine tropes and lies. So what do we call a person and organization that proclaim themselves “not antivaccine” but basically creates impossible standards that have to be met before they will agree that a vaccine is safe and effective?
I think you know the word. Certainly, I know it when I see it.

RFK Jr.: A fart-filled argument gives way to an antisemitic conspiracy theory that COVID-19 is an “ethnically targeted” bioweapon
Last week, RFK Jr. endured hilariously bad press about an NYC press event at which two of his supporters argued over climate change, one with lots of farts. However, the fart jokes soon gave way to darker side of the event, a Q&A in which RFK Jr. shared an antisemitic conspiracy theory claiming that COVID-19 might have been “targeted” against Caucasians and Blacks, while sparing Jews and the Chinese. Antivaxxers leapt to his defense, but one wonders if the”respectable” doctors who “like RFK Jr.” have learned their lesson yet.
David Gorski on July 17, 2023
Link

By any measure one might like to use, the last few days have been rough for longtime antivax activist turned Democratic Presidential candidate, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., and it couldn’t have happened to a nicer guy. It should be no surprise to anyone familiar with RFK Jr. just how far into the bonkers conspiracy theories he went. (At least, other than timing, it wasn’t a surprise to me, given that I’ve covered his antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories since 2005.) I also can’t help but do a double-take at how fast a funny story about a fart-filled argument at an RFK Jr. press event turned dark, with reports later in the week relating how RFK Jr. had echoed an antisemitic and racist conspiracy theory about how COVID-19 might have been “ethnically targeted” at Caucasians and Blacks, while sparing Ashkenazi Jews and the Chinese. The whiplash I got from the story led me to think of certain prominent COVID-19 contrarians who had defended RFK Jr., one of whom amplified one of his old antivax tropes, and another of whom expressed how she “liked him” and whether they had learned any lessons about him.
It started with a Page Six report by Mara Siegler that, I must admit, made me chuckle out loud as I read it, starting with the title, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. press dinner explodes in war of words and farting. Seriously, the six-year-old in every person can’t help but laugh at the introduction:
Camelot it ain’t.
Page Six regrets to report that a press dinner to boost Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s presidential campaign descended into a foul bout of screaming and polemic farting Tuesday night.
I’m sorry, but that introduction is just objectively funny—”polemic farting”!—not to mention incredibly fitting for the entire misbegotten endeavor that is RFK Jr.’s campaign. Unfortunately, as you will soon see, the hilarity was soon superseded by reports of what RFK Jr. said at the Q&A held at the event, in which he trotted out a pseudoscientific conspiracy theory about COVID-19 possibly being “ethnically targeted” that is more blatantly antisemitic than I have heard from him before, in which he echoed a very old racist conspiracy theory repurposed for the COVID-19 pandemic. Before I get to the nasty bonkers, though, forgive me if I indulge myself a bit in looking at the funny bonkers, because it encapsulates the level of ridiculousness that RFK Jr.’s conspiracy theories embrace.
The gaseous exchange apparently began when the host of the event, Doug Dechert, screamed “The climate hoax!” at the top of his lungs. This roused and enraged “octogenarian art critic” Anthony Haden-Guest, who was apparently a friend of Dechert, to start yelling at him, “calling him variously ‘f–king insane’ and ‘insignificant.’” Then things got even weirder:
Here, it seems, Dechert sensed the need for a new rhetorical tack, and let rip a loud, prolonged fart while yelling, as if to underscore his point, “I’m farting!”
The room, which included a handful of journalists as well as Kennedy’s campaign manager, former Rep. Dennis Kucinich, was stunned, seemingly unsure about whether Dechert was farting at Haden-Guest personally or at the very notion of global warming.
(Regrettably, we may assure readers that there was no room for doubt that the climate changed in the immediate environs of the dinner table.)
We are, however, assured that:
The candidate maintained a steady composure in the face of the crisis.
Imagine my relief.
The stock photo of the candidate chosen for this particular story was perfect, too:

Normally, a story like this would provoke a round of social media guffawing that would soon fade into the background noise. After all, almost everyone loves to make fart jokes at one time or another, and it is rare that a story like this is published that provides such an—shall we say?—irresistibly pungent opportunity to do so. Unfortunately, the pungency changed from that of farts to the foul stench of antisemitic pseudoscientific conspiracy theories.
“Ethnically targeted” COVID-19?
As the fart jokes were fading away like Dechert’s rectal emissions, unfortunately the stench changed to something far worse than just that of flatulence, no matter how prolonged or epic. By Saturday, the NY Post had published a story featuring video of the Q&A at the event, and let’s just say that it was…something:
Democratic presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. dished out wild COVID-19 conspiracy theories this week during a press event at an Upper East Side restaurant, claiming the bug was a genetically engineered bioweapon that may have been “ethnically targeted” to spare Ashkenazi Jews and Chinese people.
Kennedy floated the idea during a question-and-answer portion of raucous booze and fart-filled dinner at Tony’s Di Napoli on East 63d Street.
“COVID-19. There is an argument that it is ethnically targeted. COVID-19 attacks certain races disproportionately,” Kennedy said. “COVID-19 is targeted to attack Caucasians and black people. The people who are most immune are Ashkenazi Jews and Chinese.”
“We don’t know whether it was deliberately targeted or not but there are papers out there that show the racial or ethnic differential and impact,” Kennedy hedged.
Lest you miss the message:
In between bites of linguini and clam sauce, Kennedy, 69, warned of more dire biological weapons in the pipeline with a “50% infection fatality rate” that would make COVID-19 “look like a walk in the park.”
“We do know that the Chinese are spending hundreds of millions of dollars developing ethnic bioweapons and we are developing ethnic bioweapons,” he claimed. “They’re collecting Russian DNA. They’re collecting Chinese DNA so we can target people by race.”
My first reaction to this outburst, besides my usual horror at how openly racist and antisemitic it was, was a bit of confusion. After all, RFK Jr. actually seemed here to be acknowledging that COVID-19 can be deadly, by saying that there were “biological weapons” that are much worse. But if COVID-19 is just a cold that kills only the elderly and infirm, then why would RFK Jr. have used it as a comparison to the supposedly even worse bioweapons that are in the pipeline? My next thought was: Why was anyone surprised that RFK Jr. said something like this? He’s been making similar claims for quite a while now, most recently in June:
On Newsmax, RFK Jr. claims that "the Chinese are developing ethnic bioweapons … that are designed to attack people of certain racial types" pic.twitter.com/BynWB5nkRF
— aliciasadowski (@aliciasadowski6) June 20, 2023
My last thought was, given how RFK Jr. has been touting his upcoming appearance at the Republican-controlled House Select Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government next week, whether or not any members of the committee will hammer him over his remarks last week about an “ethnically targeted” bioweapon. I hope so. (Maybe the committee chair, Rep. Jim Jordan, will quietly disinvite RFK Jr. in embarrassment, but I doubt it.) Let’s just put it this way; When an antivaxxer like Marianne Williamson is calling your conspiracy “sinister and unfounded,” that really is something.
As an aside, I can’t help but mention that the NY Post, being the NY Post, couldn’t resist adding:
There has been a growing consensus among US intelligence agencies that COVID-19 was man-made and escaped from a lab in Wuhan, China — but there is no evidence it was designed to spare certain religious groups or ethnicities, and Kennedy offered no studies to support his claims.
Lab leak conspiracy theorists touted this report as slam-dunk evidence that the US intelligence community had concluded that COVID-19 was man-made and had escaped from a lab in Wuhan, but in reality it cited very low quality evidence, nothing that changes the current scientific consensus that COVID-19 most likely arose from a zoonotic overflow event or makes current lab leak claims sound any less like conspiracy theories. Even the latest version of the report cited does not support lab leak as the origin of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Indeed, the Post misrepresented the report, which states quite clearly that almost “all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically engineered” and most “agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted.”
Unsurprisingly, as soon as news about his remarks had begun to spread, leading to widespread (and deserved) denunciations, RFK Jr. took to Twitter to try to deny that he had said what, in fact, he had said:
The @nypost story is mistaken. I have never, ever suggested that the COVID-19 virus was targeted to spare Jews. I accurately pointed out — during an off-the-record conversation — that the U.S. and other governments are developing ethnically targeted bioweapons and that a 2021…
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) July 15, 2023
Here’s the complete quote, for those of you who don’t have Twitter accounts:
The @nypost story is mistaken. I have never, ever suggested that the COVID-19 virus was targeted to spare Jews. I accurately pointed out — during an off-the-record conversation — that the U.S. and other governments are developing ethnically targeted bioweapons and that a 2021 study of the COVID-19 virus shows that COVID-19 appears to disproportionately affect certain races since the furin cleave docking site is most compatible with Blacks and Caucasians and least compatible with ethnic Chinese, Finns, and Ashkenazi Jews. In that sense, it serves as a kind of proof of concept for ethnically targeted bioweapons. I do not believe and never implied that the ethnic effect was deliberately engineered. That study is here: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32664879/
I note that the above study is actually old, dating back to July 2020, and was largely speculative. We know a lot more about SARS-CoV-2 and how it interacts with the ACE-2 receptor now than we did then. In addition, sure, RFK Jr. never actually outright claimed that SARS-CoV-2 was targeted against “Caucasians and Blacks” and designed to spare Ashkenazi Jews and Chinese people. He merely insinuated it by JAQing off, a well-known technique to couch claims in a manner that allows a modicum of plausible deniability.
RFK Jr. also complained about being quoted “off-the-record.” Poor baby:
This cynical maneuver is consistent with the mainstream media playbook to discredit me as a crank — and by association, to discredit revelations of genuine corruption and collusion.
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) July 15, 2023
Actually, RFK Jr. discredits himself as a crank just fine all by himself by saying things like this and then pivoting to reveal that he’s gone all-in on lab leak conspiracy theories:
As I describe in my new book, “The Wuhan Cover-Up,” ethnically targeted bioweapons are real, and history makes clear there is no population who should be more concerned about a thing like that than people of Jewish and African descent. #Kennedy24
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) July 15, 2023
Even worse, though, it turns out that his insinuation about COVID-19 being a “bioweapon” designed to target “Caucasians and Blacks” is actually Russian propaganda:
Here’s more on that: https://t.co/iEjaKD8oi6
— Caroline Orr Bueno, Ph.D (@RVAwonk) July 15, 2023
Not only did this conspiracy theory have political origins, but it isn’t even correct about COVID-19 sparing Chinese and Ashkenazi Jews, as people on Twitter were quick to point out:
“Chinese New Yorkers… had the highest mortality rate of all racial & ethnic groups…. mortality rate of 35.7%, compared to 25.5% for all Asian Americans & 23.7% for Black New Yorkers…. abt 1.5 times more likely to die from #Covid19 than white patients.”https://t.co/5eE6wozWv9
— Dr. Richard Pan 🇺🇸 (@DrPanMD) July 15, 2023
They also made fun of his defense:
2/ The best part is his defense. I didn’t say the Jews and Chinese were behind covid. That’s crazy. I just meant the government is creating ethnically targeted bio weapons to exterminate us. All totally normal. pic.twitter.com/eRnXyTq57t
— Josh Marshall (@joshtpm) July 15, 2023
Unfortunately, that didn’t stop him from taking to Twitter again to invoke the old “some of my best friends are Jews” defense that all antisemites use:

All of this conspiracy mongering, however, also ignores the reasons that Blacks, for example, suffered disproportionately from COVID-19, which were largely socioeconomic. As you will see, the antisemitic conspiracy theory that there are “bioweapons” designed to spare Jews and “ethnically target” other races dates back to long before the Russian invasion of Ukraine or Russian disinformation on social media, however.
The return of the “ethnobomb”!
As soon as I read about RFK Jr.’s insinuation, a memory came back to me. Does anyone remember the “ethnobomb”? I do, and a quick Google search reminded me a bit more of what the conspiracy theory of the “ethnobomb” claimed. For example, here’s a Salon.com story from 1998 written in response to a Sunday Times story, Israel planning ‘ethnic’ bomb as Saddam caves in, entitled Debunking the “ethno-bomb”:
American biological warfare experts are reacting skeptically to a report that Israel is working on a biological weapon that could infect and kill Arabs but not Jews.
The top secret Israeli “ethno-bomb” project is the product of medical research that has identified distinctive genes carried by some Arabs, particularly Iraqis, according to a report last month in the London Sunday Times. The project’s aim is to manufacture a genetically engineered bacterium or virus that would kill certain Arab ethnic groups, the paper said.
The notion that the Jewish state is developing a bomb targeting people by “race” outraged some members of Israel’s parliament. But ethics and morality aside, American experts are skeptical that such a weapon is possible today.
Does any of this sound familiar? I will briefly mention here that I wish these COVID-19 conspiracy theorists could get their stories straight. Is it SARS-CoV-2 that’s the “ethnically targeted” bioweapon, or is it, as this conspiracy theorist claims, the COVID-19 vaccines that are the “ethnobomb” that these stories claimed that Israel was developing a quarter century ago?
Remember, though, that this report is nearly 25 years old. It was five years before the first complete human genome sequence determined by the Human Genome Project was published. One could wonder: Is such a weapon, which was likely impossible then, possible now given what we know now that we didn’t know then? Certainly, antivaxxer John Leake, who co-authors a blog with fellow antivaxxer Dr. Peter McCullough, really wants you to think so, so that you don’t think that RFK Jr. is peddling antisemitic conspiracy theories. I love how he includes the complete quote by RFK Jr. in order to try to argue that the press had quote mined it to make you think that he didn’t claim that SARS-CoV-2 was a targeted bioweapon when clearly he JAQed off in order to suggest that, yes, SARS-CoV-2 is a targeted bioweapon that spares Chinese and people of Ashkenazi Jewish descent:
We need to talk about bioweapons. …. We have spent hundreds of millions of dollars into ethnically targeted microbes. The Chinese have done the same thing. In fact, COVID-19, there is an argument that it is ethnically targeted. COVID-19 attacks certain races disproportionately.
How else is one to interpret what RFK Jr. said in the first part of RFK Jr.’s quote that I reproduce above, other than that RFK Jr. was strongly suggesting —at least!—that SARS-CoV-2 might be a targeted bioweapon? Leake also laments that the “presidential candidate’s allegedly outrageous remarks were captured in a video (apparently shot clandestinely) of him sitting at a dining table, talking to his companions about the frequently observed and documented fact that some ethnic groups appear to be more susceptible to severe COVID-19 illness than others,” as if it were some sort of heinous violation of a Presidential candidate’s privacy to video his remarks at a press event, only to conclude that, if “RFK, Jr. can be fairly criticized for any of his remarks, it is that some of his statements could be interpreted as jumping to conclusions.”
But what evidence does Leake actually cite? First, he notes:
What are we to make of this statement? Let’s start with his assertion that the United States and China are investing in developing ethnically target bioweapons. A quick search of the literature revealed several recent reports in which American and Chinese officials accuse each other of developing racially targeted bioweapons.
The Coming Threat of a Genetically Engineered ‘Ethnic Bioweapon, The National Review, April 10, 2023.
Pentagon Making Race-Specific Bioweapons to Target Citizens, China Says, Newsweek, May 11, 2023.
Could you make a genetically targeted weapon? The Guardian, 28 October 2004.
I read all three articles, and let’s just say that the evidence cited is very thin gruel indeed, mostly speculative and consisting of unsubstantiated accusations. The National Review article, for instance quotes one source
The 2017 edition of Science of Military Strategy (战略学), a textbook published by the PLA’s National Defense University that is considered to be relatively authoritative, debuted a section about biology as a domain of military struggle, similarly mentioning the potential for new kinds of biological warfare to include “specific ethnic genetic attacks.”
The second article reports that the Chinese have accused the US of working on ethnically targeted bioweapons aimed at the Chinese, with even less evidence.
While this report suggests that the Chinese could actually be working on “ethnically targeted” bioweapons, every time I consider such a claim, I also consider the extreme implausibility of it all, not so much because it is impossible to target certain genes to make a putative “bioweapon” more likely to target one ethnic group over another, but because any such bioweapon would be so incredibly “leaky” as to be too dangerous to deploy. Biologically and genetically, humans, both individually and at the population level, are far more similar than they are different, and most differences in the frequency of different alleles (variants) of a gene are between different ethnic populations are nowhere near absolute. It is rare for an allele to be present in 0% of one ethnic group compared to 100% in another. Even if such an ethnically targeted bioweapon that is designed to latch onto an allele that is more common in one ethnic group than another were developed, it would almost certainly soon start affecting the attacker as well. Once spreading in one population, there is little to stop it spreading in another, even if that population is less susceptible.
One of the articles even outright says this:
Others say the concerns are exaggerated. “Trying to find a weapon that affects quite a few of one ethnic group and none of another ethnic group is just not going to happen,” says David Goldstein, who studies population genetics at University College London. “Because all groups are quite similar you will never get something that is highly selective. The best you would probably do is something that kills 20% of one group and 28% of another.”
The groups in question are also far broader than those associated with ethnic conflict. Geneticists can only distinguish between people with ancestry traced to regions such as Europe, Sub-Saharan Africa and East Asia.
Precisely. Again, it cannot be emphasized enough that human beings are more alike biologically and genetically than we are different. Different allele frequencies in different populations are almost never black and white, 0% in one population and 100% in another. Don’t get me wrong. I am not arguing that somewhere in the bowels of the Pentagon or the Chinese military the possibility of ethnically targeted bioweapons has never been considered or even seriously investigated. After all, if you’ve ever read Jon Ronson’s book The Men Who Stare at Goats, you know that the Pentagon has pursued some truly bizarre ideas, and I have little doubt that the same is probably true of the fringes of the Chinese and Israeli military—likely of all major militaries. However, again, one would suspect that the fringe dwellers championing such ideas would be countered by actual biochemists, geneticists, and virologists who know that, while it might be theoretically possible to target an allele or aspect of biology that is more frequent in one ethnic group than another, unless the difference is huge and the allele actually targetable compared to other alleles of the same gene, the specificity that would be mandatory for such a bioweapon not to boomerang back on its creators, Frankenstein monster-like, is just not there. Moreover, even if there were such an allele that could be so specifically targeted, COVID-19 has taught us the power of evolution. Inevitably, the bioweapon would mutate once released into the wild, and very likely a variant that could target its creators would arise.
Indeed, let me just cite one study that conspiracy theorists are citing:
We identified three novel nonsynonymous variants predicted to alter ACE2 function, and showed that three variants (p.K26R, p. H378R, p. Y515N) alter receptor affinity for the viral Spike (S) protein. Variant p. N720D, more prevalent in the European population (p < 0.001), potentially increases viral entry by affecting the ACE2-TMPRSS2 complex. The spectrum of genetic variants in ACE2 may inform risk stratification of COVID-19 patients and could partially explain the differences in disease susceptibility and severity among different ethnic groups.
The spectrum of genetic variants of ACE-2 could “partially explain the differences in disease susceptibility and severity between different ethnic groups”? This is hardly the sort of observation that would make a SARS-CoV-2 “targeted bioweapon” based on ethnic/racial differences in the distribution of ACE2 alleles possible.
Will this be a bridge too far for RFK Jr. stans among the COVID-19 minimization crowd?
As hilariously appropriate as I found the the link between a fart-filled argument and the news of RFK Jr.’s racist and antisemitic conspiracy theory to be, at the same time I was a bit more disturbed than I normally would have been. The reason is simple. Thanks to RFK Jr.’s bid for the Democratic Presidential nomination, he is enjoying something of a moment. As you might expect, he’s basking in more publicity and attention than he likely has ever had, even 18 years ago when he first came out as an antivaxxer. Moreover, he’s been normalizing a lot of old antivax tropes, which has pulled the “new school” anti-COVID-19 vaccine antivaxxers more into “old school” antivax misinformation.
For example, last month Drs. Vinay Prasad and Tracy Beth Høeg were showing a fair amount of attraction to many of RFK Jr.’s ideas:
Doctors helped normalize this man.
(We met briefly in nyc @SykesCharlie) pic.twitter.com/fxhPO8XNq2
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) July 15, 2023
Let’s just say that a lot of people let Dr. Høeg know what she got wrong. In fairness, she didn’t agree that MMR causes autism and was puzzled by RFK Jr.’s misleading half-truth of a claim that most childhood vaccines have never been subjected to a saline placebo-controlled clinical trial. As for Dr. Prasad, you might remember that it didn’t take him long to start sucking up to RFK Jr. and Joe Rogan in the wake of their challenge to Dr. Peter Hotez to “debate” RFK Jr. on Rogan’s podcast. In a Substack post entitled Take RFK Jr seriously: what RFK Jr. gets right and wrong, Dr. Prasad revealed that he agreed with RFK Jr. on almost everything, dismissing his disagreements thusly:
RFK Jr holds views I disagree with. Mostly because I think he has not made a strong or sufficient case. Yet, I’m am willing to compromise on some of these issues, and I can devise a study that we will both agree upon that will adjudicate the question. If I were to speak with him, I would suggest that we agree to run these proposed studies, and let’s let that result settle the question. I strongly suspect he’s going to be incorrect about several things he believes. But I do think the best way to disarm his concerns is to sit down and agree upon the study that will settle the question. I think insulting him is very unlikely to be fruitful, yet that is the preferred media tactic.
“Views I disagree with”? “Because he has not made a strong or sufficient case”? How about views that are utterly bonkers, based as they are in pseudoscience, bad antivax science, and conspiracy theories? Views for which there is no reasonable science-based case, like vaccines causing autism? And that was a month before RFK Jr. made the news for repeating racist and antisemitic conspiracy theories. I’m sure an unethical randomized controlled trial or two of existing childhood vaccines would take care of RFK Jr.’s “concerns.” (Sarcasm alert!)
Seriously, though, to some people (like Dr. Prasad), RFK Jr.’s more—shall we say?—problematic views can be waved aside:
The news media keeps labeling RFK Jr as a conspiracy theorist and a charlatan, but that is a colossal mistake. He is somebody who on many issues is saying something deeply true. On other issues, I think he is off the mark. One of those is his views on wifi. Another is his views on early childhood immunization with MMR and DTAP. He has not made a strong enough case that the harms of these programs outweigh the massive benefits. I understand why many doctors are critical of his statements on these topics.
“He has not made a strong enough case that the harms of these programs outweigh the massive benefits”? “I understand why many doctors are critical of his statements on these topics”? Other than that, how did you like the play, Mrs. Lincoln?
Also, let’s just say that perusing both Dr. Høeg’s and Dr. Prasad’s Twitter feeds failed to yield any mention of what they surely must know about, namely RFK Jr.’s invocation of an antisemitic conspiracy theory. One wonders if they still think it’s a mistake to label RFK Jr. a conspiracy theorist and a charlatan. Maybe they’ll tell us at some point.
I like to say that antisemitism is the ur-conspiracy theory of our society, thanks to over a millennium of conspiracy theories like the Blood Libel, which posits that Jews murder Christian children for their blood, which they were then said to use to bake their matzos for Passover rituals (note the similarity to Qanon conspiracy theories about pedophiles and adenochrome); poisoning the well, a conspiracy theory that rose during the Black Death in which it was claimed that Jews had literally poisoned the wells, resulting in the plague; and the various conspiracy theories in which Jews are powerful malevolent players who own all the banks and control all the finances behind the scenes. It should therefore come as no surprise that nearly all—if not all—conspiracy theories sooner or later ultimately devolve into antisemitism. (Similarly, given the longstanding history of anti-Asian bigotry in this country, it shouldn’t be surprising that a racist anti-Chinese conspiracy theory tags along for the ride with the antisemitism.) Antivaccine conspiracy theories are no different. Just look at a lot of the imagery and language used by antivaxxers to invoke George Soros, characterize big pharma, and to portray the medical profession (which, of course, has large number of Jews in it). Remember the idea of “purebloods” embraced by some antivaxxers, which echoes outright Nazi ideas of “purity.”
Here are a few examples:
Subtle!
A pre pandemic example.
In case you don’t recognize him, this is George Soros.
Also, don’t get me started on how eagerly antivaxxers coopted a symbol of Jewish “othering” and suffering during the Holocaust, the Yellow Star of David, which the Nazis used forced Jews in Germany and their occupied territories to wear in order to be easily identifiable as Jews. They do it to falsely portray themselves as “oppressed,” and it’s not for nothing that I’ve argued that the misuse of such symbols is a form of Holocaust denial.
It therefore should not be a surprise at all that RFK Jr. has “gone there” and repeated an antisemitic conspiracy theory. Indeed, Yair Rosenberg just published a rather accurate article on The Most Shocking Aspect of RFK Jr.’s Antisemitism: “What’s surprising isn’t that Kennedy voiced an anti-Jewish conspiracy, but that it took this long.”
Rosenberg notes:
Here is just a small sampling of what Kennedy believes: that radiation from wireless internet causes cancer; that chemicals in the water supply are producing gender dysphoria; that the CIA killed both his father and his uncle, President John F. Kennedy; that antidepressants cause today’s mass shootings; that George W. Bush stole the 2004 presidential election; and that your phone’s 5G connection is part of a plot “to harvest our data and control our behavior.”
Seen in the context of Kennedy’s career, what’s surprising is not his foray into anti-Semitism but that it took him this long to arrive here.
Again, as I said above, antisemitism is the ur-conspiracy theory of our civilization, at least in much of what is called “Western Civilization.” Rosenberg notes elsewhere:
Anti-Semitism is arguably the world’s oldest and most durable conspiracy theory. It presents Jews as the string-pulling puppet masters behind the world’s political, economic, and social problems. For those seeking simple solutions to life’s complexities, this outlook offers a ready-made explanation—and enemy. Anyone seeking a single source for society’s travails may start with run-of-the-mill conspiracy theories but will soon end up parroting anti-Jewish ideas.
I’m known for saying on Twitter, scratch an antivaxxer, and quite often you’ll find an antisemite, and Rosenberg explains why this is true:
That Kennedy would ultimately echo the anti-Semitic assumptions of his conspiratorial cohort was inevitable. Indeed, he is far from the first traveler on the well-trodden path from conspiracism to outright anti-Semitism. In recent years, individuals as diverse as Marjorie Taylor Greene, Kyrie Irving, and Elon Musk have graduated from garden-variety conspiracy theories to anti-Jewish arguments. Even the content of Kennedy’s COVID-19 conjecture isn’t original: Jews have been blamed for spreading plagues for centuries, most famously during Europe’s Black Death.
Or, as he puts it, RFK Jr.’s “conspiratorial compass ensured that he would eventually arrive at this destination, because it points in only one direction.” Nor is this the first time that RFK Jr. has winked and nodded at antisemites. For example, eight years ago he was cozying up with Minister Farrakhan of the Nation of Islam:
Robert Kennedy Jr. met with me about a vaccine that is designed to affect Black males [VIDEO] http://t.co/vIBozDkOo4 pic.twitter.com/OKoFgNg9cj
— THE HONORABLE MINISTER LOUIS FARRAKHAN (@LouisFarrakhan) June 27, 2015
On my not-so-super-secret other blog, I described how in 2015 RFK Jr. was seen a number of times at antivax demonstrations and rallies with prominent Nation of Islam figures. At one rally, the Fruit of Islam (the Nation of Islam’s security detail) provided security for him. It gets even weirder. If you’re not up-to-date in your knowledge of the Nation of Islam, you might not be aware that it is now tightly associated with the Church of Scientology, to the point where the two have almost merged. Instrumental to this was Nation of Islam Minister Tony Muhammad, who was also a fixture at all the antivax rallies supported and attended by the Nation of Islam in 2015. Unfortunately, the Nation of Islam is known for its antisemitism. For example, the Minister Farrakhan has called Jews “satanic” and “blood suckers,” engaged in Holocaust denial, and at various has accused them of controlling the economy, basically the usual antisemitic tropes.
All of this brings me back to some simple questions. Perhaps Dr. Prasad can tell us if he thinks that RFK Jr.’s conspiracy mongering about COVID-19 being a potential “bioweapon” targeted at Blacks and Caucasians that spares Ashkenazi Jews would qualify him as a “conspiracy theorist and a charlatan.” While he’s at it, maybe he can tell us if RFK Jr.’s belief that COVID-19 might have been an ethnically targeted bioweapon is just one other minor opinion about which he disagrees. Maybe Dr. Høeg can tell us if she still “likes RFK Jr.” Inquiring minds want to know! Will the stench of his ideas drive them away as much as the stench of Mr. Dechert’s choice of bodily discharge as rhetorical flourish did beforehand? Maybe, but I bet that they’ll just try to quietly disassociate themselves from RFK Jr., rather than admit that they had been taken in.
I’ve expressed my concern that RFK Jr.’s run for the Presidency is normalizing antivax misinformation and conspiracy theories, to the point that the more “reasonable”-seeming wing of the COVID-19 misinformation machine, like Drs. Prasad and Høeg, have been attracted to many of his antivax conspiracy theories because they sound, if not reasonable, at least not totally bonkers if you don’t know the background and how strongly and how many times they’ve been debunked over the years. Personally, I keep hoping that his “Chinese-Jewish bioweapon” conspiracy theory is an inflection point, a point where the political and medical class members who find his less bonkers proclamations about regulatory capture, for example, attractive realize that he is nothing more than an all-purpose conspiracy theorist, little different from Alex Jones or Mike Adams, except that he’s a Kennedy. On the other hand, if his HIV/AIDS denial didn’t accomplish that, I’m not sure that his semi-plausibly deniable proclamations about COVID-19 being an “ethnically targeted” bioweapon designed to spare Chinese and Ashkenazi Jewish people will chase them away.
And the Overton window for antivax conspiracy theories continues to shift more and more into conspiracy-land.

We Want Them Infected Doctors Sanewashed Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Will He Reward Them With Appointments at the CDC, FDA, and NIH?
Maybe this isn’t a drill.
Jonathan Howard on September 14, 2024
Link

Donald J. Trump plans to name his former rival, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as chair of a presidential transition team
According to a recent news report:
Donald J. Trump plans to name his former rival, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and Tulsi Gabbard, a one-time Democrat, as honorary co-chairs of a presidential transition team that will help him select the policies and personnel of any second Trump administration, according to a campaign senior adviser.
That’s terrifying. I don’t know what being the honorary co-chair of a presidential transition team means, but these people are all on the same team now and they have announced their grand plans. There is no mystery about what they plan to do if their team wins the election. They’ve told us very clearly.
But first, let’s be really clear-eyed about who Mr. Kennedy is. As readers of SBM certainly know, from chemtrails to germ-theory denial to rank anti-vaccine quackery, Mr. Kennedy has been a fire hose of dangerous, deluded nonsense for decades. Here are some of his “greatest hits” as complied by GLADD:
—Made false claims that COVID-19 was “ethnically targeted” to attack certain ethnic groups while sparing Ashkenazi Jews and Chinese people, a conspiracy theory that drew accusations of antisemitism and racism.
—Told Joe Rogan that Wi-Fi causes cancer and “leaky brain.”
—Falsely linked vaccines to various medical conditions, including the scientifically discredited belief that vaccines for children cause autism. Kennedy advertised misleading information about vaccine ingredients and circulated retracted studies linking vaccines to various medical conditions.
—At an anti-vaccine rally in Washington, D.C., compared vaccination records to the persecution of Jews by the Nazis. He said, “Even in Hitler Germany [sic], you could, you could cross the Alps into Switzerland. You could hide in an attic, like Anne Frank did… I visited, in 1962, East Germany with my father and met people who had climbed the wall and escaped, so it was possible. Many died, true, but it was possible.” In fact, Frank and some 6 million other Jews were murdered by Nazis. Frank and her family hid in an attic in the Netherlands, not Germany, before she was caught and was sent to a concentration camp, where she died.
—Falsely told Louisiana lawmakers in 2021 that the coronavirus vaccine was the “deadliest vaccine ever made.”
—His nonprofit organization Children’s Health Defense was removed from Facebook and Instagram for repeatedly violating guidelines by spreading medical misinformation.
—Claimed that chemicals in our water are causing kids to be transgender. He told anti-trans conspiracy theorist Jordan Peterson that kids are “swimming through a soup of toxic chemicals,” including atrazine, a common herbicide, and that, “A lot of the problems we see in kids, and particularly boys, it’s probably underappreciated that how much of that is coming from chemical exposures, including a lot of the sexual dysphoria that we’re seeing.” There is no evidence to indicate that the herbicide causes gender dysphoria in humans. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says, “Most people are not exposed to atrazine on a regular basis.”
—Suggested that poppers, not HIV, causes AIDS and that, “But for [Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Anthony] Fauci, it was really important to call it a virus because that made it an infectious disease, and it allowed him to take control of it.”
—Falsely and repeatedly endorsed the idea that mass shootings have increased because of heightened use of antidepressants.
This is just a small sample of Mr. Kennedy’s dangerous disinformation. Most tragically, his visit to anti-vaccine activists in Samoa in 2019 resulted in a measles outbreak that sickened 5,700 people and killed 83 of them, mostly young children. He has never expressed the slightest bit of remorse for this tragedy and has tried to cover up his role in it. These deaths should should be mentioned every time Mr. Kennedy’s name comes up.
Mr. Kennedy also has a sordid personal life, and while normally this would not be worth mentioning, it reveals fundamental defects in his character. Mr. Kennedy has hurt and taken advantage of people close to him. His own family has disavowed him. He’s not a caring or humble person.
He is a transparent fraud. He rails against the “Democratic elites” despite being a Kennedy. His presidential campaign was entirely designed to help president Trump as explained by the article ‘Whole Thing Is an Epic Fraud’: RFK Jr. Official Admits Goal Is to Elect Trump. Everyone knew this, as explained by the article RFK’s Voters Know They’re Not Electing the Next President. They’re With Him Anyway. After a judge kicked him off the ballot in NY for lying about his residence, he responded by saying “the Democrats are showing contempt for democracy.” Mr. Kennedy is now doing all he can to get Trump elected, and no reasonable person ever thought he had any other goal.
He tries to spread fear and doubt about institutions and the entire concept of public health. He publishes articles such as Are Public Health Authorities the Authors of Fake Measles News?, The Vaccine Program: Betrayal of Public Trust & Institutional Corruption, Why Won’t the CDC Do Proper Safety Trials on Childhood Vaccines? Follow the Money, and CDC Lies About, and Media Repeats, Risk of Dying from Measles. Mr. Kennedy wants his audience angry, scared, and full of mistrust.
He takes testosterone and likely has neurocysticercosis. He promotes quack COVID cures. He is American Loon #204 and one of the Disinformation Dozen. He does weird things with dead animals. He feels victimized and unappreciated. He is paranoid and aggrieved as explained by the article RFK Jr. Is Even Crazier Than You Might Think. He published a statement titled: RFK Jr.: We Need Disclosure On UFOs. He published an article ‘Our Country Is Under Attack’: RFK Jr. Speaks on CIA and Totalitarianism that began:
In his speech — described by the Ron Paul Institute as “a compelling indictment of the mad push to total control” — Kennedy said the techniques used by government officials during the COVID pandemic to “edge people into subservience” come straight out of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) manuals he researched for his book, “American Values.”
He is grandiose and enamored with himself. He’s cast himself in the role of the brave hero, and is eager to slay his enemies. He brazenly lies about vaccines and his anti-vaccine advocacy. He is utterly shameless. He doesn’t flinch when his lies are revealed on national TV.
Mr. Kennedy vs. Mr. Kennedy
Mr. Kennedy is not a good person. He is deeply unwell. He is a dishonest, dangerous crank who made millions by spreading the rankest pseudoscience during the pandemic. The ridiculousness of his exploits with dead bears and whales obscures the grave threat he poses. His buffoonery is a distraction from his danger. As my favorite podcaster said, a clown with a flamethrower still has a flamethrower. Children are already dead as a result of his disinformation. If it weren’t for his famous last name, you’d move far away from him if you heard him ranting in the park. No ethical or serious person, especially a doctor, would praise or legitimize him.
We’re working with Kennedy and we’ll take on corruption at the FDA, the CDC, World Health Organization AND other institutions of ‘Public Health’ that are dominated by corporate power
This is not the first dance between former President Trump and Mr. Kennedy. In 2017 they discussed having Mr. Kennedy chair a “commission on vaccine safety and scientific integrity”. That didn’t happen thankfully. So maybe their current relationship is just bluster too. But it might not be. Trump spread nonsense about vaccines long before he became president, and he reiterated his beliefs during a recent phone call with with Mr. Kennedy. He said:
A vaccination that is like 38 different vaccines and it looks like it’s meant for a horse, not a, you know, 10-pound or 20-pound baby… then you see the baby all of a sudden starting to change radically. I’ve seen it too many times. And then you hear that it doesn’t have an impact, right?
The only time Trump received jeers from his followers was when he suggested they get the COVID vaccine. Having learned to hide his presidency’s greatest success, Trump now earns applause by repeatedly vowing not to give “one penny” to schools with vaccine mandates. He also seems very serious about partnering with Mr. Kennedy this time around. He recently touted their relationship by saying:
We’re working with Kennedy and we’ll take on corruption at the FDA, the CDC, World Health Organization AND other institutions of ‘Public Health’ that are dominated by corporate power and dominated really by China.
There you go. Those are the plans.
Mr. Kennedy sure feels emboldened. Continuing their tradition of publishing nonsense, the Wall Street Journal recently ran his editorial Trump Can Make America Healthy Again, and unsurprisingly, Make America Health Again merch is available for purchase. Dr. David Gorksi discussed this here on Monday. I am sure Mr. Kennedy has big ideas for what he might do and whom he might bring aboard if he’s handed the keys to America’s health castle. According to one news report:
HHS oversees 13 separate agencies, and Kennedy has long argued they are in desperate need of reform. In campaign speeches, news interviews, podcasts and other public forums, he has described wanting to gut the scientific agencies in charge of science and health policy, such as the NIH, FDA and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. He told NBC News last year that the agencies have become “sock puppets” for the industries they regulate, and he wants to replace the scientists and government officials with people who align with his views and aren’t burdened by conflicts of interest.
There you go again. Those are the plans.
It’s quite possible that Mr. Kennedy who wants to “gut the scientific agencies in charge of science and health policy” will play a key role in staffing these agencies next year. Undermining confidence in vaccines will likely be his top priority. Anti-vaxxers are ecstatic at the possibilities. This is the moment they’ve been waiting for. Meanwhile, public health is endangered, prominent scientists need bodyguards, vaccine rates are slipping, and measles is spreading, exactly they intended.
Buckle up, ‘Vaccine Murderers’…“We’re working with @RobertKennedyJr…and we’ll take on corruption at the FDA, the CDC, World Health Organization AND other institutions of ‘Public Health’ that are dominated by corporate power…” -President Donald Trump. pic.twitter.com/IbSN7XsgVI
— Liz Churchill (@liz_churchill10) September 7, 2024
I am Professor Jay Bhattacharya and I am a scientific dissident
Despite the grave toll of his anti-vaccine disinformation, both before and during the pandemic, most doctors have chosen silence with regards to Mr. Kennedy. Others however, chose a different path. They have been eager to amplify and legitimize his quackery. They labored to make Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Mercury and Autism Relationship Confirmed in Longitudinal Study, seem normal. They told their audience that he had important insights and strong core values. They said he was someone we should listen to and take seriously.
These doctors shared a common goal with Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy. They all desperately wanted unvaccinated children to contract dangerous viruses, and they forged a bond and mutual admiration over this. Even though Mr. Kennedy published the article Vaccines Can Spread Diseases Through Shedding, these doctors’ pandemic pronouncements were often completely interchangeable with his. I once made a quiz showing this to be a case, and I should have been clearer that I did so because I was horrified and alarmed that the words of “respectable” doctors were indistinguishable from those of Mr. Kennedy, who published the article New Study: Gardasil HPV Vaccine Contains Chemical Used in Biological Warfare.
Obviously, I have no inside information, but one person who is likely on Mr. Kennedy’s radar were he to gain power is Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, an anti-vaccine, pro-infection doctor who made YouTube videos minimizing COVID while other doctors were busy treating patients with it. Dr. Bhattacharya and Mr. Kennedy, who published New Data Shows DNA From Aborted Fetal Cell Lines in Vaccines, said very similar things about the pediatric COVID vaccine. Mr. Kennedy published the article Top Ten Reasons Not to Let Your Child Get a COVID Shot, while Dr. Bhattacharya authored the article The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young. Both articles appeared in June 2021, just before the Delta wave spiked pediatric hospitalizations and killed teens who were eligible for the vaccine.
Dr. Bhattacharya has made no secret of political beliefs. He became a pandemic celebrity through his willingness to partner with a pro-tobacco, child labor advocate who had ties to Neo-Confederate groups. He sued the Biden administration (he lost). He’s testified in Congress at the invitation of Republican Congressmen. He helped Ron DeSantis launch his failed campaign, and he played a similar roll during Mr. Kennedy’s failed campaign. Although Mr, Kennedy published the article ‘Dissolving Illusions’: 225 Years of Lies and Cover-Ups Behind Vaccines, Dr. Bhattacharya spoke at the announcement of his VP candidate, Nicole Shanahan, who is currently promoting a podcast called “COUNCIL of the CANCELED” with the founder of the modern anti-vaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield. These are the people Dr. Bhattacharya celebrates and promotes.
After receiving a glowing introduction from anti-vaccine luminary Del Bigtree, Dr. Bhattacharya lavished praise on Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Vaccines Contain Dangerous Ingredients. Small Doses Can be Unhealthy. Disease is a Product of Genetics and Environment. While speaking at a political rally for Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Read the Fine Print: Vaccine Package Inserts Reveal Hundreds of Medical Conditions Linked to Vaccines, Dr. Bhattacharya portrayed himself as “neutral” public health expert who was a victim this pandemic. Dr. Bhattacharya called himself a “scientific dissident” who had been censored by the “Orwellian Ministry of Truth”. Even though COVID 1.2 million Americans and injured millions more, Dr. Bhattacharya felt the real problem was that he didn’t receive enough attention. He spoke passionately about “Twitter files and court cases” and praised Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Vaccine Rhetoric v. Reality — Keeping Vaccination’s Unflattering Track Record Secret, as a champion for free speech.
Dr. Bhattacharya also mentioned the Great Barrington Declaration in his speech, but neglected to tell the audience that it called for the simultaneous mass infection of 250 million unvaccinated people just two months before vaccines arrived, claiming it would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months.
The corrupting influence of money
Dr. Vinay Prasad, another anti-vaccine doctor who said it was “reckless” to limit COVID in children, also made no secret of his political leanings. He is an avowed enemy of the “public health establishment”, likening it to Nazism. Even though Mr. Kennedy published the article Natural Measles Immunity — Better Protection and More Long-Term Benefits Than Vaccines, Dr. Prasad spoke glowingly of him on multiple occasions and defended him against allegations that the was a conspiracy theorist. Dr. Prasad said it was wrong to “insult” Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Vaccines and Autism—Is the Science Really Settled?. Instead of criticizing Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Vaccine Injury Touches Families Throughout the U.S., Dr. Prasad also said said we should:
Give credence to what his root concerns are, which is really the concern of the corrupting influence of money. That’s really his root concern.
Though Dr. Prasad, who monetized much of his COVID output, has made a grand public display of concern about falling vaccination rates, the fact that Mr. Kennedy published the article Vaccines Do Not Deserve The Credit For Reducing Contagious Diseases wasn’t a deal-breaker for him. While Dr. Prasad said that doctors who suggested the pediatric COVID vaccine were “idiots”, he was full of praise for Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Vaccine Boom, Population Bust: Study Queries Link Between HPV Vaccine and Soaring Infertility. In reality, the HPV vaccine prevents multiple different types of cancers and it does not cause infertility. Yet, Mr. Kennedy’s crusade against a vaccine that prevents cancer was a non-issue for Dr. Prasad, an oncologist. In fact, not only was Dr. Prasad willing to overlook the fact that Mr. Kennedy published the article Unvaccinated Children Have Much Lower Rates of Chronic Illness, he was willing to overlook Mr. Kennedy’s actual body count. Samoa is far away, 2019 was a long time ago, and 83 people killed by an entirely preventable virus, most of them children, isn’t really a big deal, I guess.
Beyond being unperturbed by the toll of Mr. Kennedy’s anti-vaccine disinformation, Dr. Prasad has adopted many of his techniques. Like Mr. Kennedy, Dr. Prasad frets mightily about rare, mild vaccine side-effects, even mere abnormal lab values, while extolling the virtues of viruses and casually brushing aside literal death from them. That’s how the Kennedy-Samoa connection can be overlooked.
Ho hum, just 19 dead kids in a single month
RFK will flatten most public health experts in a debate
Stop and think about the message this all sends, especially at a time when the ideas of Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Mercury Toxicity: Highly Toxic, Cumulative and Still in Vaccines, are spreading along with measles, predictably. Prestigious doctors from prestigious universities with large media footprints cozied up to and legitimized the biggest stars of the anti-vaccine movement during a pandemic. They told their audience to trust Mr. Kennedy, who in turn provided material like this to their audience, Vaccine Mandates for Everyone, Everywhere—A Globally Coordinated Agenda. And thus, their audience is now purely anti-vaccine.
These doctors told millions of Americans that Mr. Kennedy, who published the article CDC’s Latest Tuskegee Experiment African American Autism and Vaccines, is more reliable than Dr. Peter Hotez, a besieged vaccine-expert who developed a patent-free COVID vaccine and wrote a book about his daughter’s autism that debunked pernicious anti-vaccine myths. They said that Mr. Kennedy, who published the article CDC Scientist Still Maintains Agency Forced Researchers To Lie About Safety Of Mercury Based Vaccines, was correct about his “root concerns”. Even though Mr. Kennedy published the article Don’t Fall for the CDC’s Outlandish Lies About Thimerosal, they said absurdly said his root concerns were about “the corrupting influence of money.” The fact that Mr. Kennedy published the article Worse than Nothing—How Ineffective Vaccines Enhance Disease was besides the point.
Image source
In fact, Dr. Prasad said that Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Read the Fine Print: Vaccine Package Inserts Reveal Hundreds of Medical Conditions Linked to Vaccines, would “flatten” “obliterate” and “destroy” a vaccine-advocate in a purely imaginary debate. While it’s absurd to believe that a verbal wrestling match between cranks and scholars on Joe Rogan’s podcast would reveal scientific truths, Dr. Prasad told his audience that Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy, is vastly more trustworthy than the local pediatrician, the “establishment figure”, recommending vital vaccines. Dr. Prasad does this all with profane language and juvenile, demeaning insults to signal to his followers that he’s edgy and controversial.
The pandemic as spectacle
To make matters worse, these prestigious doctors from prestigious universities doctors pitched themselves to the public as paragons of EBM. While other doctors were sloppy, they were rigorous. While other doctors abandoned science and evidence during the pandemic, they held firm. They feel it was abomination that not every aspect of the COVID vaccine was studied via a massive RCT for every demographic group and for every variant. They have scorn and contempt for anyone who disagrees with their methodolatry.
However, these demands for highest standards of evidence were only applied to unwanted measures to limit COVID’s harms. Indeed Mr. Kennedy, who published the article MMR Vaccine’s Poison Pill: Mumps After Puberty, Reduced Testosterone and Sperm Counts, got a free pass. Because these doctors shared Mr. Kennedy’s larger goal of infecting unvaccinated children with SARS-CoV-2, they didn’t hold him to any standards at all. Although Mr. Kennedy published the article Mercury, Vaccines and the CDC’s Worst Nightmare, their attitude towards him was “sure, Kennedy is wrong about a few things, but he’s basically OK and trustworthy.”
The term for this is sanewashing, which is defined as:
Attempting to downplay a person or idea’s radicality to make it more palatable to the general public.
That’s a trendy new term, but it fits perfectly here. These doctors portrayed Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Japan Leads the Way: No Vaccine Mandates and No MMR Vaccine = Healthier Children, as a fundamentally rational man with rational concerns about real problems. They also portrayed him as a hero.
Though these doctors absurdly claimed the COVID vaccine would ruin confidence in routine vaccines, their positive relationship with Mr. Kennedy, who published the article It’s Been 10 Years Since a Whistleblower Exposed the CDC’s Cover-up of the Link Between Vaccines and Autism. The Agency Has Done Nothing, shows they were perfectly willing to lend the legitimacy of their universities to throw all vaccines under the bus. Falling vaccine rates are the obvious consequence of prominent doctors normalizing Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Kids, Vaccines and Autism: Will a New Legal Strategy End the Decades-long Battle for Truth and Justice?.
That’s how badly they wanted them infected.
Dr. Vinay Prasad sanewashes Mr. Kennedy and says he would “mop the floor” in a debate with vaccine-hero Dr. Peter Hotez
Media, Health Officials Should ‘Just Tell the Truth’ About COVID Shots for Kids, Physician Says
The affection was mutual. Mr. Kennedy reciprocated by bolstering pro-infection doctors. They shared a similar disdain towards limiting dangerous viruses. Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Measles Vaccine Narrative Is Collapsing, has also published multiple articles by and about Dr. Prasad, for example. Mr. Kennedy is a big fan. One typical article was titled, Media, Health Officials Should ‘Just Tell the Truth’ About COVID Shots for Kids, Physician Says. It’s tagline read:
Vinay Prasad, M.D., MPH, in a video released this week called out what he said were the “lies and exaggerations” about COVID-19 vaccines and kids being spread by media and public health officials.
This sort of article, where a brave, maverick, truth-telling, “pro-vaccine” doctor destroys the “official narrative”, has long been a staple of anti-vaccine propaganda. Check out the articles How a Pro-Vaccine Doctor Reopened Debate About Link to Autism and How a Respected Pediatrician Lost His Medical License — Because He Supported Informed Consent to see what I mean. Another example is the article Government Spending Millions on ‘Cognitive Vaccines’ to ‘Protect’ Public From ‘Fringe’ Viewpoints which said:
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, Eric Weinstein, Ph.D., Nicole Shanahan and Mike Benz, on Wednesday discussed how government-funded “cognitive vaccines” and corporate interests are stifling dissent and undermining public trust in science, media and democracy.
You won’t find any such articles about me on Mr. Kennedy’s website or anywhere else.
Mr. Kennedy, who published the article ‘Laughable’: Experts Rip CDC Report Claiming Childhood Vaccines Saved 1.1 Million Lives, also recently amplified the voice of pro-infection radiologist Dr. Scott Atlas who said:
What we as a society did to children… I could just burst into tears right now. It’s so awful. We broke the social contract we have as people by harming our children as a society and injecting, for instance, experimental drugs into children that have side effects, many of which are uncertain for a disease that those children, healthy children, did not have a significant risk from, to use them as shields? I mean, this is almost unspeakable.
As a reminder, no one proposed vaccinating children as shields and the pediatric COVID vaccine is not an “experimental drug.” It was studied in 6 RCTs, and everyone was clear its purpose was to directly protect children, even healthy ones, from a potentially dangerous virus. It’s done that. While Dr. Atlas made a performance of nearly “bursting into tears” over something that only happened in his imagination, in the real-world, Dr. Atlas proposed using unvaccinated children as shields with this potentially dangerous virus. He thought it was “fantastic” when they were infected with it because he thought it would lead to herd immunity. Around 2,000 are now dead, and 234,000 were hospitalized. Some have long COVID.This would have been much worse had we listened to pro-infection doctors at the start of the pandemic.
In other words, Dr. Atlas fits in perfectly with Mr. Kennedy. I would be mortified if Mr. Kennedy shared my message in a positive way. These doctors never protested his attention, however. Like Mr. Kennedy, Dr. Atlas now brazenly distorts his pandemic record, claiming he never said what he said and that all he ever cared about was education. 
Dr. Scott Atlas vs. Dr. Scott Atlas
Of course, former President Trump is familiar with these doctors as well. He worked with them and publicly praised their calamitous “plan” for herd immunity through mass infection. I am sure he won’t object to Mr. Kennedy appointing them to powerful positions in his administration. The connections between them are very deep.
“Dr. Atlas and other Stanford doctors”
Maybe this isn’t a drill
While it would be vital to remember the role pro-infection doctors played in our disastrous pandemic response no matter what, it’s especially important at this moment to resist pandemic revisionism and call-out those who actively encourage amnesia and apathy about it. These doctors’ repeated factual errors, farcical forecasts and glowing homages to “natural immunity” didn’t convince them quietly slink away into obscurity as normal people might do. Quite the opposite. While other doctors continue to treat sick patients, they continue to hit the lecture circuit, hiding their pro-virus philosophy, bemoaning their “cancellation”, and overtly blending medicine with business interests and right-wing politics, as discussed here by Dr. Allison Neitzel and here by Walker Bragman.
It’s possible Mr. Kennedy will staff the CDC, FDA, and NIH with pro-infection doctors. Yet, this doesn’t seem to worry most people. The most common response has been silence. Since Mr. Kennedy is so absurd himself, the idea of him really getting power at these institutions is also treated as absurd, as if there’s a 0% chance of it actually happening because someone else will step in to save the day.
Hopefully!
However, hope is not a plan and while prestigious doctors from prestigious universities feel emboldened to speak out on behalf of Mr. Kennedy, I can’t recall any professional organization that’s been brave enough to speak out against him. Similarly, medical school deans say nothing when their professors validate Mr. Kennedy, who promotes movies such as Vaxxed III: Authorized to Kill. These “leaders” are so afraid of being called “censors” that they censor themselves and treat anti-vaccine misinformation as a reasonable topic for “discussion and debate“, even as their universities become inexorably linked with disinformation and quackery under their watch.
Of course defending medicine against the normalization of Mr. Kennedy, who published the article Weeding Out Vaccine Toxins: MMR, Glyphosate, and the Health of a Generation, is not silencing anyone. It’s just calling out dangerous nonsense for what it is.
Some editorial writers have recognized the threat, but how many blunt news stories been written about the potential implications of handing enormous power to an anti-vaccine crank? Mr. Kennedy published articles such as Measles Vaccination and Autism: The Inexcusable Suppression of a Long-Documented Link, What Polio Vaccine Injury Looks Like, Decades Later, and 25 Reasons to Avoid the Gardasil Vaccine. Will the CDC be publishing this material in 2025? Will its website remove all evidence that measles, polio, and HPV can be dangerous and the vaccines against them effective? Will there be mass purges of scientists at these institutions? Will CDC employees who try to stop a virus be labeled an “extremist”? Will people silence themselves to avoid being fired under this punitive new regime? Will any journalist ask Mr. Kennedy these questions?
Agreed @VPrasadMDMPH! It’s time to fire President Biden’s COVID-19 advisors and replace them with “pragmatists, realists and centrists — not extremists.” https://t.co/q76c9aAr9r
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) November 6, 2022
Some of us have been sounding alarm bells about Mr. Kennedy and his dangerous movement for years. We’ve noticed with horror as his one-fringe anti-vaccine ideology has become sanitized and normalized by a group of small, but influential doctors with stellar credentials and academic appointments. I write about them not just to resist their pandemic revisionism, but also to sound alarm bells about institutional decay and its implications for the future. It would have been bizarre and inappropriate for a doctor to have embraced Mr. Kennedy in 2019, and it should remain that way today. That’s literally all I am saying.
I also want people to notice how our standards have changed. At least Andrew Wakefield got struck off for his anti-vaccine data fraud. In contrast, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, who called the COVID vaccines “the Antichrist of all products” on Steven Bannon’s podcast, might be rewarded for his anti-vaccine data fraud with an appointment as the next CDC director.
What was once intolerable, is now tolerated, and we may be at the beginning of these doctors’ story. While they want their words to be erased and forgotten, I do not want them censored and silenced. I’ve worked to keep an accurate record of what they said and to amplify their voices as loudly as possible. I’m certainly not the only one doing this, but isn’t it time for other, more prominent people and institutions to say something? It’s possible that Mr. Kennedy will soon elevate several We Want Them Infected doctors to positions of great authority. For this reason, we must remember what they said, the policies they pushed, and the suffering that resulted. We should all should be clear-eyed about the potential consequences of them gaining power.
Maybe this isn’t a drill.
Oh FFS, if one more person tweets about Vinay Prasad’s “excellent” take on RFK Jr. I am going to lose my sh*t.We are in the f*cking upside down!!!! pic.twitter.com/nftao7gLOI
— snarky pediatrician 🟧🟦 (@snarkypeds) June 21, 2023

Yet another example of how “new school” anti-COVID vaccine antivaxxers have become just antivaxxers now
Dr. Pierre Kory and the pseudomous Substacker known as A Midwestern Doctor provide two more examples of how “anti-COVID” antivax has now become just antivax.
David Gorski on June 3, 2024
Link
Ever since the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines were first granted emergency use approval (EUA) by the FDA in early December 2020—and, truth be told, even before that—I knew that the antivaccine movement would latch onto them and do its best to stoke fear, uncertainty, and doubt about their safety and efficacy. This was not a difficult prediction to make of course, given that that’s what antivaxxers have always done with a new vaccine, the most recent example being vaccines against human papilloma virus (HPV), such as Gardasil, which, as soon as it was approved by the FDA, ran into a buzzsaw of antivax misinformation, including false claims that the vaccine was causing sterility or, even worse, killing adolescent girls and young women. There was a time when I though that maybe—just maybe—it would be somewhat different with COVID-19 vaccines, given that we were in the middle of a global pandemic that had, in the US alone, already killed roughly 300,000 people by the time the vaccines started rolling out (and went on to produce a death toll of over a million). I soon realized that even my mild optimism had been way, way too optimistic. Antivax misinformation and lies about COVID-19 vaccines flowed rapidly and in vast quantities on social media and certain ideologically slanted old media outlets, including misinformation that the new vaccines caused sterility, “turbo cancer,” death, “permanent” alteration to your DNA, neurologic injury, and many more problems, all while not working.
One thing I saw as these antivaccine myths about COVID-19 vaccine proliferated was that there was now a new breed of antivaxxer, or more appropriately, anti-COVID-19 vaccine activists. These were people, a disturbing number of them physicians, nurses, and other health care professionals, who believably stated that they were never “antivax” before. Rather, it was the “newness” of the lipid nanoparticle- and mRNA-based technology (never mind that it wasn’t that new but had just never been successfully used to make a vaccine that had been widely used in humans) and the speed with which the vaccine had been designed, tested, and rolled out that had made them suspicious of these vaccines by Moderna and Pfizer, and then a little later the adenovirus-based vaccines by Johnson & Johnson and AstraZeneca. It was a reasonable-sounding gambit, and, for most of these “new school” antivaxxers, very likely true at the time. However, if there’s one thing that the pandemic has taught me, it’s that, once you start believing antivax misinformation about one vaccine, you become much more susceptible to antivax misinformation about all vaccines. In other words, in retrospect I now realize that it was inevitable that many of these “anti-COVID-19 vaccine antivaxxers” would become just antivaxxers, which is exactly what happened.
I was reminded of this by a post on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, by a familiar name, someone who has been featured on this blog and my not-so-super-secret other blog a number of times, Pierre Kory:
Vaccines still don't cause autism, Pierre. The data is pretty definitive.
— Jonathan Laxton MD, FRCPC 🐈🐱🐈‍⬛ (@dr_jon_l) June 1, 2024
You’ll also recognized that the post being shared by Dr. Kory is by an anonymous doctor who goes by the ‘nym A Midwestern Doctor, whose has gone deep down the rabbit hole of antivax misinformation and pseudoscience. Indeed, the article linked to by Dr. Kory is nearly a year old, which at first gave me pause, leading me to hesitate about whether I wanted to discuss an article from summer 2023. Then I decided, “What the heck?” Also, given that “A Midwestern Doctor” (whom I now consider A Midwestern Quack) has provided copious examples of their antivax quackery to choose from and, sadly, is not alone among physicians in that. The only thing left making me hesitate is that AMD/AMQ is as verbose—or even more so—than yours truly, making taking on one of their articles difficult mainly from a logistical standpoint and the sheer firehose of misinformation, pseudoscience, quackery (even COVID-19 vaccine shedding!), and conspiracy theories that he is capable of spewing. No wonder quacks, antivaxxers, and conspiracy theorists are so unduly impressed by them.
No wonder AMD/AMQ is afraid to let people know their real name and who they really are, even to the point that I noticed in an interview AMD/AMQ did with Rav Arora, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya’s podcast collaborator” Arora referred to AMD/AMQ by the dreaded singular “they” and “their” pronouns, whose use is generally detested mightily by those holding the ideologies generally associated with COVID-19 era antivax movement. I will be forthright here and mention that I strongly suspect that AMD/AMQ is male, given the writing style, but will maintain the use of the singular “they” because—who knows?—AMD might be nonbinary. (But I doubt it.) It doesn’t really matter anyway what gender AMD/AMQ is; they’re just plain wrong, as in antivax wrong. I only mention the pronoun thing because it amuses me to see AMD/AMQ using the singular “they” to further obfuscate their identity, given how Arora and Bhattacharya prominently mention transgender care in their Substack blurb as one of the areas of medicine that has “been wholly corrupted by one monolithic consensus that has proven to bear many costs on our society,” while AMD/AMQ has written a whole long piece of nonsense about gender and gender-affirming care that I’ve been meaning to address. Maybe next week.
A dive into the deep end of old vaccine-autism nonsense
We likely all recall that Pierre Kory is one of the co-founders of the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC Alliance) who got his start by promoting various “early treatment protocols” for COVID-19 that included ivermectin, hydroxychloroquine, and other drugs now known to be ineffective but rapidly turned antivax, to the point that by December 2022 he Tweeted (it was still Twitter then):
Pro-vaccine propaganda has been immensely successful for many decades and ended up literally defining the field of Pediatrics. The idea that vaccines are the backbone of historic improvements in population health is built on myths. 🧵
— Pierre Kory, MD MPA (@PierreKory) December 25, 2022
I stand by this statement and will do so to my grave. If I had young children today, not one would get even a single childhood vaccine. Thank you Twitter for allowing me to publicly state my data-driven & highly researched interpretation of vaccine (non) science. 🧵
— Pierre Kory, MD MPA (@PierreKory) December 25, 2022
This is, of course, the very definition of antivaccine.
No wonder Kory was impressed by AMD/AMQ’s—oh, hell, I’m just going to call him A Midwestern Quack (AMQ) from now on—article, which began:
One of the most challenging things for me throughout my time in the medical field has been watching children become neurologically damaged by vaccines, and the widespread blindness of the medical profession to this issue. Unfortunately, because so much money has been spent to engineer the societal belief that vaccines do not cause autism, anyone that asserts otherwise is immediately subject to widespread ridicule, to the point it’s mostly a lost cause to convince medical professionals vaccines aren’t always safe. In many cases, the only thing that can open their eyes is their own child being severely injured.
This is, of course, something that could have been written by pretty much any antivax pediatrician or physician of another specialty 20 years ago. Heck, Andrew Wakefield probably wrote something similar on many occasions. Moreover, note the conspiracy theory: “The Man” is covering up the evidence that vaccines cause autism, and as a result the entire medical profession—except for the “englighted” few (like AMQ), who “know.”
It’s also never a good sign when someone like AMQ quotes someone like Steve Kirsch, the tech bro turned rabid antivaxxer and COVID-19 conspiracy theorist:
Recently Steve Kirsch started looking at that question, and in an attempt to bring attention to the issue, raised three very important points:
     1.  Contrary to popular belief, there is actually a great deal of compelling evidence linking vaccines to autism. For example, regressive autism always develops shortly after vaccination—but never before, something that cannot happen unless one causes the other. Likewise, there is a significant amount of evidence correlating vaccine uptake with autism rates.
     2.  There is presently no accepted explanation for what is causing the explosion of autism we are facing.
     3.  The explosion of autism is one of the costliest diseases facing our country, so decades of hand waiving that has insisted there’s no scientifically valid explanation for this explosion doesn’t cut it.
Each of these points is classic antivax misinformation of the most rudimentary variety, in particular #2, a topic that I’ve written about a number of times before. The CliffsNotes version is that a combination of widening of the diagnostic criteria in the 1990s, coupled with increased awareness and screening, has resulted in a large increase in autism spectrum diagnoses. The long version is here, for those who are interested, as well as here and here. #1, of course, is the usual citation of a litany of low-quality evidence, often published by antivax scientists, in which the quantity of publications that supposedly support a vaccine-autism link is emphasized over the much higher quality of publications that do not. It’s an old antivax trope.
It is this trope that leads AMQ to cite a list of 224 studies that supposedly support the idea that vaccines, including the COVID-19 vaccine of course, cause autism. A number of them are ones that I’ve written about before, such as the very first one on the list, whose deficiencies I wrote about in great detail after Byram Bridle had promoted the study as slam-dunk evidence. As I noted at the time, funny how antivaxxers will seize on single studies in rats to support their beliefs. Also, one reason that I wrote about the study when it came out earlier this year is because it was validated for my longstanding prediction that, sooner or later, antivaxxers would blame COVID-19 vaccines for autism, with the only reason they hadn’t being that the vaccines weren’t recommended for infants 6 months of age and older until relatively recently. I also have to express amusement at this statement by AMQ:
Of these, I believe the final book provides the most concise (but detailed)‚ summary of those mechanisms.
The book cited? This one:
J.B. Handley? Founder of Generation Rescue, one of the oldest antivax orgs out there, the one that managed to recruit Jenny McCarthy to be its figurehead back in the day (~2008-2012 or so)? This is some seriously “old school” antivax propaganda, of the sort that I’ve been debunking for nearly 20 years on my not-so-secret other blog and here since 2008.
Unsurprisingly, many of the studies cited have nothing to do with vaccines, but rather the immunological changes and abnormalities associated with autism. However, in the antivax mind, any potential immune component to any condition means that vaccines can cause it. For example, get a load of this line of “reasoning” (if you can call it that):
Much of the research on the link between vaccines and autism has focused on the following areas:
     1.  Immune activating events being repeatedly correlated with an increased likelihood of developing neurological developmental disorders like autism.
     2.  Increased blood levels of inflammatory cytokines (e.g., “Plasma levels of IL-1β, IL-6 and IL-8 were increased in children with ASD and correlated with regressive autism, as well as impaired communication and aberrant behavior”). Autistic individuals also appear to have a predisposition to developing inflammatory immune responses.
     3.  Vaccinations creating inflammation in the brain and inflammation in the brain being linked to autism. This neurological inflammation is often chronically active in the brains of autistic individuals and appears to be most specifically linked to aluminum and the measles virus component of the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine. For example, the vaccine measles virus was observed to correlate to the production of autoantibodies to brain tissue, increases levels of measles antibodies were found to be significantly higher in autistic children (but not antibodies to mumps or rubella), and live measles viruses were found in immune cells of autistic children with inflammatory bowel disorders. The strongest case for the link between the measles vaccine virus and autism came from the discovery that vaccines with the measles component have triggered severe brain injury and death but those with only the mumps or rubella components have not.
     4.  Enlarged brains are also often associated with autism (likely due to that inflammation). This swelling may play a key role in the pathology of autism and explain why certain individuals are more susceptible to it.
The reference in #2 is a 13-year-old study says nothing about vaccination or vaccines (it doesn’t even mention them), being relatively small (223 subjects total) observational study that examined immune parameters in patients with autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders compared to age-matched neurotypical children. Of course, automatically to antivaxxers “increased cytokine levels” = “vaccines done it.” The same is true for the other articles cited, although, amusingly, one of the articles cited is a Wakefield paper, albeit not his original 1998 fraudulent case series. It is, however, one of the papers in which Wakefield’s use of PCR to detect measles virus sequence was so incompetent that an actual PCR expert, Stephen Bustin, totally schooled Wakefield repeatedly for almost certainly having detected sequences from contaminating plasmids in the laboratory, not actual measles virus sequences from the vaccine, for reasons that I’ll briefly quote:
Absence of transparency: the key publication shows no data; hence an expert reader cannot evaluate the reliability of its conclusions
Unreliable techniques and protocols: analysis of the qPCR data was incorrect
Disregard for controls: obvious evidence of extensive contamination was disregarded
Lack of reproducibility: the data could not be duplicated by several independent investigators
His conclusion was:
The only conclusion possible is that the assays were detecting contaminating DNA. Since MeV is an RNA-only virus and never exists in DNA form, these data must be ignored and it it is my opinion that the authors should withdraw this publication from the peer-reviewed literature.
Seriously, AMQ, citing any Wakefield paper in which he used PCR to detect measles virus is a fool’s errand given the sloppiness of the PCR procedures used by him and his collaborators and his general incompetence. Come to think of it, citing any study by Wakefield is a fool’s errand, unless you’re citing it as an example of scientific fraud or incompetence—or both. Seriously, AMQ, you really do need to learn to read studies critically, rather than as an antivaxxer.
Of course, the rest of AMQ’s list consists of antivax claims about vaccines and autism that will be very familiar to longtime readers, such as citing aluminum adjuvants as the cause of autism. He even cites the utterly awful paper by Christopher Exley that claimed to find elevated levels of aluminum in the postmortem brains of autistic children, which, of course, I deconstructed when it was first published online. He also cited another Exley paper and a rat paper, neither of which show that aluminum adjuvants cause autism.
A cornucopia of “old school” antivax claims
Of course, AMQ had way, way more than this, given their penchant for even-longer-than-Gorski-length diatribes. That’s why some more of their antivax tropes trotted out, besides appeals to “ongoing inflammation” and others mentioned above out included:
    • The claim that the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in childhood vaccines until over 20 years ago caused autism. Nope, and we knew this at least 16 years ago. At least AMQ notes that “despite vaccine mercury being mostly pulled from market, autism has increased rather than decreased since thiomersal (mercury) was pulled,” even after stating that there was “quite a bit of research that substantiated this link.” (Hint: There wasn’t.)
    • “Too many too soon,” a favorite claim of antivaxxers that somehow the baby’s immune system was overloaded by “too many” vaccines given—you guessed it!—too soon. That’s yet another long-debunked antivax trope, one of Jenny McCarthy’s favorites.
    • Appeals to the “gut microbiome. (Shades of Andy Wakefield!) This is a longstanding antivax trope that likely confuses correlation with causation, given a recent study that suggests that changes in gut microbiome observed in autistic children are more likely due to restricted eating or picky eating. (Yes, I know that antivaxxers harp on the erratum, but the investigators showed that the error noticed did not affect their conclusions.)
    • Cell danger response. This is basically the whole claim that vaccines cause mitochondrial dysfunction that causes autism, just rebranded. Basically, AMQ co-opts a phenomenon known as the cell danger response. Perusing PubMed, I see that this concept seems to be primarily associated with University of California Professor Robert K. Naviaux and seems not to have gained much traction in the scientific literature given the paucity of publications on it, most of which are by him. Alternative medicine practitioners, however, seem to love the idea that a chronically activated cell danger response in the mitochondria is the cause of all chronic disease. Cell danger response is rather a “theory of everything” that perhaps I should examine in more detail in a future post, as it might or might not have some value. The claims arising from the idea that I’ve read thus far, however, seem suspiciously grandiose, as though by treating cell danger response we can treat all chronic disease. In other words, from what I’ve read about it, “cell danger response” seems to accommodate basically any mitochondrial quackery, whether that was Prof. Naviaux’s intent or not.
    • Zeta potential collapse. I note that AMQ seems to like to point to this, as they did when discussing how COVID-19 vaccines. As I said at the time, zeta potential is a measure of the magnitude of the electrostatic or charge repulsion/attraction between particles, a variable used in optimizing waste water treatment processes in which size, density, and charge of particles to be removed are considered. Zeta potential is also used in optimizing drug delivery systems and in enhancing hemagglutination, but, contrary to AMD’s handwaving, there is no evidence that it has anything to do with “shed” spike protein from vaccines causing hypercoagulability of the blood. Here, as previously, AMQ is doing some highly speculative handwaving linking it to vaccines supposedly causing autism. Moreover, antivax quack Andrew Moulden is apparently the first person to have proposed zeta potential as a “mechanism” for “vaccine-induced autism.” Of note, Moulden in an example of everything old being new again given how much antivaxxers like to link COVID-19 vaccines to clotting, originally proposed that autism was due to “microvascular strokes” caused by vaccines. As I pointed out in 2008, even if childhood vaccines did cause “microvascular strokes” (which they don’t), there is no evidence that the etiology of autism has anything to do with such microvascular strokes.
I could go on, but you get the idea. Let’s just say that AMQ goes on to write something that, again, Andrew Wakefield might have written after he had branched out from MMR vaccines as the cause of autism to more general antivax claims about vaccines and autism:
Autism is one critical example, as the severe regressive cases caused by vaccination represent the visible extremes of the injury while far more moderate neurological injuries from vaccines also occur throughout the population (including less severe forms of autism—hence why it now is termed “autism spectrum disorder”). For example, many of the same mechanisms that cause autism, when instead allowed to work over a slower period are the most likely causes of Alzheimer’s disease (e.g., elevated aluminum concentrations are also found in those brains). Likewise, one of the common tragic COVID-19 vaccine injuries is rapid cognitive decline in elderly individuals following their vaccination, which is then typically written off as Alzheimer’s and never further investigated.
Like autism, many effective treatments exist for Alzheimer’s disease (e.g., treating the CDR or restoring fluid circulation to the brain), but since none of them revolve around utilizing lucrative drugs, they have all been swept under the rug. It is my sincere hope that the need to address the severe consequences of the COVID-19 vaccines throughout the population will make the world be open to looking at the much broader consequences of the vaccination program and what can be done to heal the ever-increasing damage it has inflicted upon society.
Longtime readers will recognize everything in this paragraph as nothing new, in particular the false claim that vaccines cause Alzheimer’s disease, a claim that I first wrote about way back in 2005, when Bill Maher trotted the claim out on his show.
COVID-19 vaccine skeptics are just antivax now
When the first “not antivax” doctors and people claiming to be just “skeptical” of only COVID-19 vaccines appeared, it didn’t seem that unreasonable that these people really weren’t antivax, just suspicious of a new vaccine. Unfortunately, as I pointed out, when it comes to antivaccine claims there was (and is) nothing new under the sun, which explains why every fear mongering claim about COVID-19 vaccines has antecedents in antivax claims about all vaccines. True, some of those old antivax claims took on seemingly new, more alarming forms. For example, the old claim that vaccines kill turned into the “died suddenly” conspiracy theory positing that COVID-19 vaccines were causing young healthy athletes (like the Buffalo Bills’ Damar Hamlin) to drop dead of cardiac arrests, just as the claim that vaccines cause cancer morphed into the much scarier claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause not just cancer, but “turbo cancers,” a form of cancer found in younger people that is so much nastier and more aggressive than regular run-of-the-mill cancers. Eventually, as I mentioned above, even the hoary old claim that vaccines cause autism was repurposed to include COVID-19 vaccines.
Indeed, one particularly depressing old antivax claim is that those who are not “vulnerable” to severe complications of COVID-19 (especially children) don’t need to be vaccinated because the disease is “harmless” to them. A number of docs embraced this viewpoint, even though exactly the same argument could be made about (and before the pandemic was being made by antivaxxers about), for example, the measles vaccine given the number of children who died of measles every year before the vaccine, which was very similar, adjusted for population growth, to the number of children who died of COVID-19, with COVID-19 now being a major cause of death among children.
In retrospect, it should be no surprise that suspicion of COVID-19 vaccines that led some people to become “antivax” but “only about the COVID-19 vaccines” was an enticing gateway to becoming just generally antivax. I might have harped on Pierre Kory and AMQ in this post, but we’ve seen it happen to so many physicians, including Drs. Drew Pinsky, who’s been captured by his audience and now features the vilest antivax quacks on his show; Vinay Prasad, whose evidence-based medicine fundamentalism has led him down the path to becoming antivax, even to the point of embracing Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s deceptive trope about childhood vaccines supposedly not having been tested in saline placebo-controlled randomized clinical trials; Peter McCullough, who’s become an out-and-out antivax quack selling bogus supplements to treat “spike protein toxicity”; and many others. One wonders if they all would have slid so easily down the rabbit hole of antivax misinformation, pseudoscience, quackery, and conspiracy theories if only they had been inoculated with knowledge that none of the antivax tropes applied to COVID-19 are new. They might have then recognized them when they saw them, as I immediately did as they came up.
Or maybe I’m being too optimistic again. Clearly a quack like AMQ is beyond reaching and probably would have gone antivax regardless. Maybe, though, someone like Vinay Prasad would not have. It’s impossible to know.

Why Should We Trust Journalist David Zweig Regarding COVID and Schools When He Pals Around With Proud Child-Labor Advocates?
David Zweig is welcome on my podcast with Dr. Wendy Orent to answer that question.
Jonathan Howard on July 10, 2026
Link

“Zweig has made a name for himself as a COVID contrarian adopting positions that have brought him into alignment with powerful business interests and the political right”
In his article, Elon Musk’s New Twitter Files Reporter Has Ties to Great Barrington Declaration, Walker Bragman had this to say about journalist David Zweig:
In recent years, Zweig has made a name for himself as a COVID contrarian adopting positions that have brought him into alignment with powerful business interests and the political right, which have been waging a war on public health measures. He even assisted a libertarian think tank with ties to billionaire industrialist Charles Koch in the promotion of The Great Barrington Declaration, a controversial open letter proposing a herd immunity strategy based around mass infection and minimal government intervention. The ideas in the document helped inform the disastrous U.S. COVID response, which has seen limited governmental action and staggeringly high death and long COVID numbers.
Indeed, Mr. Zweig produced a steady stream of content that minimized COVID’s risk to children and fear mongered about any and all efforts to limit the disease. In a pandemic where over 1.2 million Americans died, Mr. Zweig used his voice to mourn the fate of a few Tweets and to support MAHA/MAGA disinformation doctors who proposed using infected children as human shields to achieve herd immunity. Examples of his brilliance, which were published in The Atlantic and New York Magazine, include:
    • Twitter’s Rigging the Covid Debate
    • How and Why the Reality of Covid was Censored
    • The CDC’s Flawed Case for Wearing Masks in School
    • Inside the Schools Open Full Time Right Now What the Data Really Tells Us About Covid-19 Transmission and Safety in the Classroom
    • Why Spending Time with Kids Might Actually Help Protect You from Covid
    • The Science of Masking Kids at School Remains Uncertain
    • New Research Suggests Number of Kids Hospitalized for Covid Is Overcounted
    • Experts: CDC’s Summer-Camp Rules are ‘Cruel’ and ‘Irrational’
    • Why Public Schools Shouldn’t Offer a Remote Option This Fall
    • Our Most Reliable Pandemic Number is Losing Meaning, a New Study Suggests that Almost Half of Those Hospitalized with Covid-19 Have Mild or Asymptomatic Cases.
    • Is the Second Shot Giving Young Men a Dangerous Heart Condition?
That last article, from June 2021, discussed cases of vaccine myocarditis from Israel, but it didn’t link to the actual report, and it neglected to mention that “95% are considered to be mild cases.”
It also spread blatantly fake information. Although by that point in the pandemic COVID had killed at least 316 children and the flu 10 children, Mr. Zweig wrote, “Pediatric mortality is on par with or less than that from influenza in recent seasons.” This is the honesty and integrity he brought to his writing. While only a single child died of flu that season, the Delta and Omicron arrived immediately after this, spiking pediatric hospitalizations and deaths, especially in unvaccinated children.
Mr. Zweig didn’t care enough to write about any of this, however. He had weightier issues on his mind, and bigger problems to solve. Just read his article Putting Students Behind Plexiglass Isn’t Making Them Safer to see what I mean.
“An Abundance of Caution: American Schools, the Virus, and a Story of Bad Decisions”
Mr. Zweig’s magnum opus was a book titled An Abundance of Caution: American Schools, the Virus, and a Story of Bad Decisions. According to its Amazon description:
An Abundance of Caution is a devastating account of the decision-making process behind one of the worst American policy failures in a century—the extended closures of public schools during the pandemic. In fascinating and meticulously reported detail, David Zweig shows how some of the most trusted members of society—from Pulitzer Prize–winning journalists to eminent health officials—repeatedly made fundamental errors in their assessment and presentation of evidence. As a result, for the first time in modern American history, millions of healthy children did not set foot in a classroom for more than a year.

The story of American schools during the pandemic serves as a prism through which to approach fundamental questions about why and how individuals, bureaucracies, governments, and societies act as they do in times of crisis and uncertainty. Ultimately, this book is not about COVID; it’s about a country ill-equipped to act sensibly under duress.
As SBM readers will recognize, Mr. Zweig is selling the fantasy of the optional pandemic. From his sheltered perspective, school closures were entirely caused by “bad decisions,” not a novel, deadly virus, and wise MAHA/MAGA doctors simply would have decided to keep schools open, as if that’s all it took.
Given that MAHA/MAGA doctors can’t stop measles now, we can discard the fantasy that they would have solved COVID back then. As I argued previously, unless Mr. Zweig can be the first person to make the affirmative case that these doctors have demonstrated great competence in power today, we can automatically discard his counterfactual fan fiction where they were in charge in 2020, and everything turned out just fine.
The obvious truth is that 2020 would have been a worse disaster had advocates of herd immunity via mass infection been in charge. In NYC alone, 74 Dept. of Education employees, including 30 teachers, died in the pandemic’s first two months. Yet, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya was predictably unmoved by this suffering. Mr. Zweig pressed Dr. Bhattacharya about COVID’s risk to teachers at the signing of the Great Barrington Declaration. Dr. Bhattacharya said a 1 in 500 risk of death was “very moderate.” Teachers’ health was a sacrifice these men were willing to make, and hundreds of active teachers would end up dying from COVID.
Although Dr. Bhattacharya also breezily dismissed all of COVID’s non-fatal harms, death was not COVID’s only harm it turns out. According to one article on Long COVID in educators:
Ruthanne Grajeda, a paraprofessional who helps teachers at a school for behaviorally challenged students in Wyoming, is one of them. She spent three weeks in the ICU, another nine days in a regular hospital room, and three weeks in a rehab center after contracting COVID last September.
Nearly eight months later, she’s still having trouble breathing at times, and has to carry an oxygen tank with her when she leaves the house. She’s been working part-time at her school ever since.
Dead and sick teachers can’t teach. Many more would have perished and suffered had we let the virus rip throughout schools before anyone was vaccinated as the Great Barrington Declaration proposed, and that wouldn’t have been good for children and their education.
SBM readers will also know that we don’t have to speculate about any of this. We already know what happened to education when MAHA/MAGA doctors helped run the show in Florida. It’s almost as if healthy students learning from healthy teachers wasn’t their top priority after all. Here’s what they delivered:
    • School Closures Reported In Five Florida Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID, August 2021
    • 15 Miami-Dade Public School Staff Members Die of COVID In Just 10 Days, September 2021
    • Child Covid Deaths More Than Doubled in Florida as Kids Returned to the Classroom, September 2021
    • Florida Reading Scores Fall to Last in the Nation, Report Says, May 2026
Predictably, Mr. Zweig didn’t care about any of this either. As always, unwanted news is unmentionable news, and an honest accounting of what happened in schools when the virus was allowed to spread unchecked wouldn’t just undermine his entire pandemic output, but also his core goal of spreading doubt and mistrust about “eminent health officials.”
Even today, Mr. Zweig continues to peddle the fantasy of the optional pandemic and exalt MAHA/MAGA doctors in right-wing agitprop. He was featured in the WSJ’s new “documentary” The Lockdown Dissidents, a masterpiece of the COVID Amnesia Project. In it, Mr. Zweig again likened COVID to a “normal flu season,” and even after a year of glaring malevolence and incompetence from MAHA/MAGA doctors, Mr. Zweig still claims it was an impressive achievement that they “called for” schools to be open in a 1-page Great Declaration in 2020.
However today, Mr. Zweig is no longer fluffing so-called “dissidents.” Rather, he is using his voice to support the people responsible for today’s grim STEM headlines, the doctors who literally confess their “love” for Trump and claim that Kennedy is devoted to the “scientific method“, the men with great power right now. As Mr. Bragman recognized, this is what he always did.
“An Abundance of Bias: New COVID School Closures Book Rewrites History.”
While I lacked the fortitude to read Mr. Zweig’s book, my brilliant podcast co-host, Dr. Wendy Orent, made a great sacrifice and wrote a scathing review titled An Abundance of Bias: New COVID School Closures Book Rewrites History. She wrote:
“I love research,” David Zweig says in the introduction to An Abundance of Caution: American Schools, the Virus, and a Story of Bad Decisions.” That love isn’t evident in his book. At a time when the so-called “legacy media” are chastised for trying for too much balance, for struggling to maintain an appearance of even-handedness, Zweig discards any pretense to objectivity. He detests school closings, so much so he’s devoted an entire book to it. This long and highly repetitive text ranges in tone from apparently sober discussion to a protracted wail. But evidence-free, light on statistics, absent any other viewpoints, and not infrequently wrong, all his arguments amount to the same thing: Zweig is angry that schools closed during the early months of the pandemic. And he wants to make sure you know it…
It is quite remarkable that Zweig, writing an indignant history of Covid-induced school closings in America, chooses to utterly ignore the most child-hungry variants of all, Omicron and all its descendants. The word Omicron does not appear in the entire 464-page book.
​Zweig ends his book with a lament for the years of lost childhood, lost to school closings, fanaticism, masks, flickering screens, six-foot rules, forced isolation, forced inactivity. No one will say these were happy years for the world’s children. But children are resilient, a term Zweig hates. He doesn’t believe it. He thinks the harms are permanent, that the damage will follow these injured children forever.
You should read the whole thing. Her review was so good, Matthew G. Saroff wrote a review of her review titled The Joy of a Savage Book Review in which he said:
Wendy Orent has a deliciously, and wholly justifiably, nasty review of David Zweig’s new book on school lockdowns during the height of the Covid pandemic.
If you don’t know who David Zweig is, he’s not only a big supporter of the psychopathic Great Barrington Declaration, he was at the official rollout of the declaration because of his close ties to the principals behind that document.
“David Zweig is what used to be known as an honest reporter with no agenda whatsoever other than to find out stuff. That’s it. Nothing more. “
Unsurprisingly, Mr. Zweig’s pandemic output was very appealing to the organizer of the Great Barrington Declaration, MAHA power-broker Mr. Jeffrey Tucker, who praised him thusly on social media:
David Zweig is what used to be known as an honest reporter with no agenda whatsoever other than to find out stuff. That’s it. Nothing more. He had the decency to show up to the meeting with hard questions, period. In fact, his questions were honest but very, I would say, hard hitting, to the point that I thought he went way too far. The scientists didn’t mind at all of course. Truly, he has a reporter’s mind and just wanted to know what was what.
Elsewhere, Mr. Tucker said he was “grateful for David Zweig’s Abundance of Caution” because it “carefully chronicles the excuses for not opening schools from the beginning, almost day by day, and explodes every myth along the way.” “The reader develops utter confidence in the writer because you know he is ready to go where the evidence leads,” Mr. Tucker concluded. “It’s a great method of doing real journalism, and surely this author ranks among the greatest living practitioners.”
Mr. Zweig even spoke about his book at the Brownstone Institute, an anti-vaxx conspiracy organization founded by Mr. Tucker, who himself promotes rank right-wing conspiracies every day. The Brownstone Institute’s promotion for Mr. Zweig fawned over him:
The famed supper club at a fabulous venue (the real Chinese stuff) with friends of the Brownstone Institute, featuring reporter and famed author David Zweig, whose bestselling book is An Abundance of Caution, on school closures but also the hellscape of the whole Covid period.
Come early for cocktails and meet Brownstone Institute friends, scholars, writers, and benefactors, and celebrate victories and discuss challenges ahead. The food is wonderful and the discussion brilliant. Casual and fun, even if some people come in fancier clothing.
This month we are deeply honored to host David Zweig, a curious and scrupulous journalist whose book is an amazing documentary history of our times. Sweeping and precise, the author is one of the few brave journalists in the country actually to attend the Great Barrington Declaration event…in person!
He has worked on this book for five years, interviewing countless scientists, writers, anonymous bureaucrats, and publishers, all with the driving purpose of trying to figure out what the heck happened to cause this disaster. All the while, he maintained an emotional distance that only a spirit of incredulity grants. The result is spectacular, a page turner that deals with a deeply painful topic but somehow ends up providing an emotional release.
The early reviews have been over the top, almost as if the country had been waiting for such a book. We are thrilled to hear from him and hear his story of the research and writing, and have him engage with our wonderful community on the meaning of it all.
Conversely, Mr. Tucker raged about We Want Them Infected writing:
Here it is, a demonstration of the worst-possible presumption: they wanted us locked down forever, in an endless state of immunological naïveté and used as experimental rats for iterative vaccine development.
“There are plenty of things I could say about your very active role in this and you know very well what they are,” Mr. Tucker said to me in a threatening way. Although all I did was work in a hospital and write a lot, perhaps Mr. Tucker imagines I ordered lockdowns and wants to guillotine me.
“If kids were allowed to work and compulsory school attendance was abolished, the jobs of choice would be at Chick-Fil-A and WalMart. And they would be fantastic jobs too.”
I was deeply relieved by Mr. Tucker’s furious, incoherent, drivel about my book because he is, amongst many other things, an outspoken child labor advocate. Unlike Mr. Zweig, who never mentions Mr. Tucker when discussing the Great Barrington Declaration, I have no problem sharing his words. You should watch Mr. Tucker’s video with the School Sucks Podcast and read his article Let the Kids’ Work, which said:
If kids were allowed to work and compulsory school attendance was abolished, the jobs of choice would be at Chick-Fil-A and WalMart. And they would be fantastic jobs too, instilling in young people a work ethic, which is the inner drive to succeed, and an awareness of attitudes that make enterprise work for all. It would give them skills and discipline that build character, and help them become part of a professional network.
Mr. Tucker still feels this way. Mr. Bragman wrote an article titled Leaked Brownstone Institute Emails Reveal Support for Child Labor, Underage Smoking, which quoted Mr. Tucker as saying that he would “fully repeal the 1936 ‘child labor’ law,” because “it is cruel and robs kids of a good life.” Once again, it’s almost as if healthy students learning from healthy teachers wasn’t his top priority after all.
“Florida Governor Signs Law Easing Hourly Work Restrictions on Minors”
As someone who values education, I would be deeply embarrassed and profoundly ashamed if Mr. Tucker raved about my writing and invited me to speak. In some bizarro universe where that happened however, my talk would be titled Tiny Coffins: The Legacy of the Brownstone Institute.
In contrast, Mr. Zweig had no problem speaking to a star of the School Sucks Podcast about his book on the importance of schools, and he was willing to do so at a moment when the headlines read Florida Governor Signs Law Easing Hourly Work Restrictions on Minors. That’s what COVID education superstar Ron DeSantis has been up to, and he’s not alone. According to a recent article titled Child Labor Violations Rise in US – As Republicans Still Roll Back Protection:
The number of child labor violations has risen fivefold in the last 10 years, but Republicans across the US are continuing to propose and pass legislation that rolls back protections or regulations for workers under the age of 18.
Republicans in Nebraska, Indiana and West Virginia have successfully passed legislation in 2026 rolling back child labor regulations, with legislation led by Republicans pending in other states, including Florida, Missouri and Virginia.
The efforts to roll back child labor protections at the state level, with the ultimate goal of eroding federal standards, were outlined in Project 2025, the rightwing Heritage Foundation thinktank’s controversial blueprint for more conservative government.
Since 2021, 30 states have proposed legislation that would roll back child labor protections and regulations, with 17 states enacting rollbacks
While Mr. Zweig is eager to relitigate ancient battles from 2020, if he is bothered by the current assaults on education- and there are many assaults on education now- he’s kept his thoughts to himself. Once again, I asked ChatGPT which said:

Based on the public record I could find, I could not find any instance where journalist David Zweig has explicitly condemned child labor or written about it as a topic. His recent journalism has focused primarily on COVID-19 policy, especially school closures and their effects on children.
The most likely explanation for Mr. Zweig’s indifference is that while his children’s schools were affected by COVID, no one expects them to drop out of school and work at retail stores and fast-food restaurants. That’s for other people’s children.
He also knows that an honest acknowledgment of the dismal performance of our MAHA/MAGA doctors would undermine everything he said about them regarding COVID. Once again, unwanted news is unmentionable news, and while he worried about the futility of plexiglass regarding COVID, when it comes to our current medical establishment, ChatGPT tells us:

Based on David Zweig’s public record through mid-2026, I could not find evidence that he has publicly criticized the MAHA movement itself, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., or the physicians most closely associated with MAHA in any significant or sustained way.
Whatever one thinks about COVID and schools, it’s all in the past. The fight to protect education moves on, and while it is not the main focus of our podcast, Wendy and I have been clear- we don’t think children should drop out of school to work at Walmart and Chic-Fil-A. Anyone who genuinely cares about education wouldn’t criticize us in any way 2026, even if we disagree about 2020.
Given that Mr. Zweig was happy to speak to unapologetic child labor advocates, surely, he should be eager to come on our podcast to loudly denounce them. We will have plenty of polite and civil questions for him to be sure. He can explain why he said that 316 COVID deaths equaled 10 flu deaths. He can tell us why he didn’t even mention the Omicron variant in his book, even though it sent nearly 1,000 children to the hospital every day during its peak and generated headlines such as- COVID Hammers NYC School Attendance Among Students and Teachers. We’d love to hear him make the case that the We Want Them Infected/MAHA doctors he portrayed as pandemic superheroes, have proven their mettle when it comes to handling dangerous viruses, restoring trust, and protecting free speech now that they have power.
But mostly we just want to listen, patiently and without interruption, as he explains in great detail why he has a shred of credibility as a champion of education regarding COVID, when he’s happy to partner up with proud child labor advocates at a time when child labor laws are being rolled back across the country.
Our minds are open, and we have so much to learn from his wisdom and nuance.

MAHA and the Triumph of Feelings Based Medicine
According to Dr. Marty Makary, vaccines and medications are indicated or not, based on “stories” and how he “feels.” 
Jonathan Howard on October 10, 2025
Link
The Covid-19 vaccine was associated with decreased risks of these outcomes across prespecified subgroups
A recent observational study titled Association of 2024–2025 Covid-19 Vaccine with Covid-19 Outcomes in U.S. Veterans confirmed the findings of every other previous study on the COVID vaccine- it is far from perfect, but much better than nothing. It found the vaccine was:
    • 29.3% against Covid-19–associated emergency department visits
    • 39.2% against Covid-19–associated hospitalizations
    • 64.0% against Covid-19–associated deaths
It also found that:
The Covid-19 vaccine was associated with decreased risks of these outcomes across prespecified subgroups defined according to age (<65 years, 65 to 75 years, and >75 years), the presence or absence of major coexisting conditions, and immunocompetence status.
Although the absolute risk reductions were small, considering the vaccine’s harms are a sore arm, the overall benefits are clear, especially on a population level.
I don’t feel like I need it
Our medical establishment doesn’t feel that way, however. Their years-long fetish to repeatedly infect unvaccinated people with SARS-CoV-2 remains undiminished. In a recent interview, the head of the FDA, Dr. Marty Makary said that he does not “feel” he needs the COVID booster and falsely said it does not limit COVID’s harms.
In another interview, Dr. Makary said that he “knew” of three people who died after getting the vaccine and predictably botched basic facts about side effects, claiming the rate of vaccine myocarditis was 1 in 2,600, even though data he published showed the rate was in 37,000 only for males aged 12-24. Even then it remains a “generally short-lasting phenomena with favourable clinically course” Dr. Makary also said the previous administration operated “blindfolded” by “rubber stamping COVID boosters.” Dr. Makary said that future COVID vaccines need “updated clinical trials.”
Incredible stories
However, when it comes to entirely unproven treatments, namely leucovorin for autism, Dr. Makary is willing to laud and approve it based on “incredible stories” alone.  The research so far is underwhelming, the largest trial having just 80 subjects apparently, and some of the researchers themselves have problematic backgrounds and conflicts of interest.
So, according to Dr. Makary, vaccines and medications are indicated or not, based on “stories” and how he “feels.”  There is no semblance of a coherent approach to his decision-making. He is guided by vibes alone.
A doctor’s going to prescribe this and we’re going to collect data on how effective this is.
He’s not alone. That’s our entire medical establishment now. According to one news report:
In an interview with Brian Kilmeade on Fox News radio, Oz indicated that type of data will come, eventually. 
“We’re going to give it. Marty’s changing the label” to allow the drug to be covered by Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program, Oz said. “A doctor’s going to prescribe this and we’re going to collect data on how effective this is.”
This approach to medicine- decide first gather data later- isn’t benign. According to the article Chaos, Confusion, and Conspiracies: Inside a Facebook Group for RFK Jr.’s Autism ‘Cure’
A Facebook group set up to share information about leucovorin has been spammed by affiliate links and supplement companies trying to shame parents of autistic kids. In the days and hours after the announcement, tens of thousands of parents of autistic children joined a Facebook group, first set up in May, to share information about the drug.
The Leucovorin for Autism group was flooded with chaos, confusion, and conspiracy theories, according to a WIRED review, with parents, pediatricians, nurses, and affiliate marketers seeking to fill the void of information left by the Trump administration.
Meanwhile, the boss of them, RFK Jr. all is just spouting nonsense off the top of his addled head, saying “children who are circumcised early have double the rate of autism. It’s highly likely because they are given Tylenol.” He is also admitting that they are doing research not to discover the truth about Tylenol and autism, but rather they are “doing the studies to make the proof.”
It’s not surprising that the headlines today read Trust In Federal Health Leadership Is Failing Under RFK Jr., New Poll Finds.  Every day another group calls on him to resign. When MAHA doctors mindlessly repeat the phrase “gold standard science and common sense” they are not fooling anyone anymore.  Feelings Based Medicine has triumphed and the American people are figuring that out at the expense of their health.


Praise for Dr. Monica Gandhi
Ideally, leaders of American medicine would have had the courage to correct misinformation spread by their fellow doctors. At a bare minimum, they didn’t have to lavish praise on a doctor who repeatedly polluted our COVID landscape with obvious misinformation and falsely pacified people the worst was over, when in fact the worst was yet to come.
Jonathan Howard on July 14, 2023
Link

On July 11th, Dr. Monica Gandhi published her book titled Endemic: A Post-Pandemic Playbook. The book is summarized on Amazon thusly:
Endemic squarely reckons with our present condition: attempting to comprehend and live with a new respiratory disease and face the coming variants and next pandemic with reason, science, understanding, courage, and compassion. It does not shy from rigorous scrutiny, and it pulls no punches about where we have been, where we find ourselves now, and how we ought to manage the virus in the coming years. “Endemic” refers to the features of a virus that make it either eradicable or controllable. SARS-CoV-2’s features make it non-eradicable. However, if we use tools we already have, living with an endemic virus is possible and does not have to be disruptive to society.
This book is a clarion call for reason while also assessing the story, science, and politics thus far with its hits and misses, and providing a roadmap for the future of COVID-19 variants and future epidemic crises. Dr. Gandhi’s 10-point plan is the center of this book and will serve to guide us today and into our future. Her roadmap includes:
    • The expansion of equitable vaccine distribution
    • Easing restrictions
    • Emphasizing harm reduction over coercive or punitive measures
    • Encouraging outdoor activities
    • Avoiding school closures
    • Understanding the long-term economic and psychological consequences of sustained lockdowns
    • Eliminating ineffective measures
    • Reassessing testing policies and practices
    • Increasing access to outpatient therapies and prophylactics
    • Focusing on better preparation for future pandemics
Dr. Gandhi brings her unique blend of professional history, training and experience, academic authority, and role as expert commentator for general audiences to bear. Endemic is well-researched, clearly reasoned, accessible, and absolutely essential for readers who are confused by inconsistent mandates and policies—and who want to be prepared for the future.
Dr. Gandhi certainly has impressive credentials. According to her biography on Amazon:
Monica Gandhi, M.D. is Professor of Medicine and Associate Division Chief of the Division of HIV, Infectious Diseases, and Global Medicine at UCSF/ San Francisco General Hospital. She also serves as the Director of the UCSF Center for AIDS Research and the Medical director of the HIV Clinic at SFGH (“Ward 86”). Dr. Gandhi completed her M.D. at Harvard Medical School and then came to UCSF in 1996 for residency training in Internal Medicine. After her residency, Dr. Gandhi completed a fellowship in Infectious Diseases and a postdoctoral fellowship at the Center for AIDS Prevention Studies, both at UCSF. She also obtained a master’s in public health from the University of California, Berkeley in 2001 with a focus on Epidemiology and Biostatistics. Dr. Gandhi is arguably among the most distinguished infectious disease experts practicing today as well as being one of the few women with such a recognized platform. She supervises many predoctoral students, fellows, residents, and faculty at UCSF and has co-authored or contributed to 18 scholarly books. She is overseeing 11 ongoing research awards and grants from the NIH and the NIAID.
Dr. Gandhi has also been a ubiquitous media presence during the pandemic. Her Amazon biography continues:
Dr. Gandhi has received dozens of awards, spoken at hundreds of conferences, keynoting many, held a handful of prestigious leadership positions, performed thousands of hours of public service, and served as a mentor and advisor to women in global health research studies. During the COVID-19 pandemic, she has contributed more than 20 original, peer-reviewed research articles and written more than 40 editorial and opinion pieces for media outlets including The New York Times, NPR, NBC News, BBC, Atlantic, Washington Post, New Yorker, Los Angeles Times, San Francisco Chronicle, The Guardian, Vox News, WIRED, and more.
I don’t intend to read Dr. Gandhi’s book, though I am sure there’s much that I would agree with. Though she initially said, “It’s simple math. We don’t need to vaccinate those under 11 to get to herd immunity”, she eventually wrote an passionate defense of pediatric COVID vaccination, for example. It’s also likely she will discuss uncontroversial blunders, such as the CDC’s botched tests at the start and the tragedy of those who died due to anti-vaccine misinformation. Who could argue with her call to encourage outdoor activities?
However, these potential areas of agreement aside, Dr. Gandhi unleashed a firehose of poor predictions and bogus statistics throughout the pandemic, always minimizing the virus, of course. If you are unfamiliar with her overwhelming litany of pollyannaish prognostications, repeated declarations of herd immunity, and mocking those who disagreed- “I genuinely with all my heart apologize for anyone who continues to try to scare you about variants“- I suggest you familiarize yourself here: Pandemic Accountability Index, Mehdi Hasan, me, and me again.
It’s possible that Dr. Gandhi’s book will actually “pull no punches” and address her own errors, though an honest accounting would take several lengthy chapters, trust me. However, no matter what her book says, its most troubling part is loudly displayed on its Amazon page- the adulation it received from prominent figures in American medicine. Here are their tributes, interspersed with a very small sample of Dr. Gandhi’s false forecasts and the cumulative death toll on that date:
Throughout the pandemic, I often turned to the compassionate and clearheaded voice of Dr. Monica Gandhi. Drawing on her experience from the frontlines of HIV, she was able to make meaning from mountains of data and deftly balance an approach that helped keep people safe while reducing harm. Now, eyes cast to the future, she outlines a thoughtful and reasoned plan to help prepare for the next pandemic.”–Sanjay Gupta, M.D., CNN chief medical correspondent and #1 New York Times bestselling author of Keep Sharp and World War C
(508,332 deaths)
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. Monica Gandhi has emerged as a unique voice, passionately arguing for an approach that balances the threat of the virus and the harms of mitigation strategies. In this timely, lucid, and well-referenced book, Gandhi lays out the lessons of the pandemic – lessons that should be heeded as we manage the continued threat of Covid and plan for the next pandemic. An essential addition to the Covid lexicon.” —Robert Wachter, M.D., Chair, Department of Medicine, UCSF and New York Times bestselling author of The Digital Doctor
(508,332 deaths)
As we look back on the years 2020-2022 and forward to the coming decades, Dr. Monica Gandhi’s bold work will be among the few go-to analyses helping to set the stage for the long-term playbook we can rely on in future epidemics.”–Emily Oster, New York Times bestselling author of Cribsheet and Professor of Economics, Brown University
(558,187 deaths)
A heartfelt and urgently needed exploration of the success and mistakes of the COVID-19 response. This vivid account from a doctor and mother on the frontlines of the pandemic can help us all do better in the endemic period we are now entering–still so surrounded by uncertainty. Here is a sane and reliable guide to a better future.” — Chris Beyrer MD, MPH, Director, Duke Global Health Institute
(577,163 deaths)
Dr. Monica Gandhi’s work in global HIV gives her a long view of equity in antiretroviral treatment and prevention access. She is also an active infectious diseases clinician. This provided her with a unique, pragmatic view of the COVID-19 pandemic in terms of the need for global vaccine and treatment equity, as well as universal healthcare access coverage.”– Eric Goosby, M.D., former Global AIDS Ambassador under President Obama
(596,666 deaths)
As a specialist who has been on the forefront of the HIV/AIDS epidemic, Dr. Gandhi is no stranger to the fear, stigma, discrimination, and uncertainty a new disease can create. Her book provides assurance and clarity as she reflects on the lessons learned from the HIV response and discusses what went right and what went wrong in our response to the COVD-19 pandemic and how to prepare for the next public health emergency.”–Carlos del Rio, M.D., Professor of Medicine, Emory University School of Medicine; President, Infectious Diseases Society of America
(596,666 deaths)
For years, Dr. Gandhi has been a faithful and diligent force on the HIV/AIDS front line, especially in terms of global equity. She has now turned her years of expertise into an invaluable tool—a handbook—for future medical crises.”–Ingrid Katz, M.D., Professor of Medicine, Harvard Medical School and Faculty Director, Harvard Global Health Institute
(604,789 deaths)
Dr. Gandhi has been a star presence in the medical community for many years, particularly in the fight against HIV/AIDS. As we face the future of epidemics both in the U.S. and abroad, it’s people like Dr. Gandhi who we can rely on to show us a clear path forward. With this book, Dr. Gandhi provides a solid map.”–Jeffrey Flier, M.D., former Dean, Harvard Medical School
(693,996 deaths)
And this is how medicine circles the wagons to protect its own and rewrite the history of the pandemic.
To be clear, I don’t think Dr. Gandhi should be be “silenced” or personally attacked in any way. However, in a better world, leaders of American medicine would have matched the courage shown by some medical students and simply corrected misinformation spread by their fellow doctors. At a bare minimum, they could have said nothing. They had no obligation to lavish praise on someone who repeatedly polluted our COVID landscape with obvious falsities- “children are not more susceptible to the delta variant, they’re threefold less likely to get any infection with any variant with any ancestral strain, and they’re half as likely to spread it“- and falsely pacified people the worst was over, when in fact the worst was just around the corner.
Sadly, “post-pandemic playbooks” of denialism and revisionist history are more likely to hold sway than mine.
(1,134,000 deaths)

When an antivax physician “dies suddenly”: The case of Dr. Rashid Buttar
Last month, Dr. Rashid Buttar, a prominent antivax “integrative medicine” practitioner, died suddenly. Because he hadn’t been vaccinated, antivaxxers struggled mightily to reconcile his death with their conspiracy theory about COVID-19 vaccines killing thousands “suddenly.” It turns out, however, that that Dr. Buttar had not been a well man since 2016 and was as much a victim of quackery as his patients had been.
David Gorsk on June 19, 2023
Link

A month ago, I was surprised to learn that Dr. Rashid Buttar had passed away, having seen chatter about it on social media that was ultimately confirmed by Sayer Ji on Twitter:
Starting at the one hour mark, Dr Buttar shared what lead to his steep health decline in Jan of this year: https://t.co/wU7YIOt2A9
— Sayer Ji (@sayerjigmi) May 20, 2023
As many of you might remember, Sayer Ji has been featured on this blog before. He was husband to Dr. Kelly Brogan, the anti-psychiatry, antivax physician and germ theory denier who rose to greater prominence after the COVID-19 pandemic hit, to the point where she was named one of the Disinformation Dozen. The two of them ultimately divorced, but both continued down their previous paths of spreading misinformation. In any event, I must admit to my shock over seeing that Sayer Ji announce the death of fellow “Disinformation Dozen” member Dr. Rashid Buttar.
As you will see (and can probably glean just from the Tweet and the linked video), Dr. Buttar’s story is a bit more complicated than the portrayal of a perfectly healthy fifty-something year old man having “died suddenly.”” Truth be told, I had had no idea that Dr. Buttar had been sick, and, as always, empathize with his family and friends, regardless of what he had done during his life. Also, I hadn’t realized that he was actually younger than I am, and it always bothers me to see people my age or younger die prematurely. As you will see, the story is about what antivaxxers claimed about Dr. Buttar’s health history after he had died compared to what his health history, as discoverable on social media and prior publications, actually was. Of course, it’s no shock that antivaxxers struggled mightily to blame his death on COVID-19 vaccination, even though they admitted that, as an antivaxxer, Dr. Buttar had never been vaccinated.
Any time one of their own dies suddenly or suffers a nonlethal health problem that they normally attribute to vaccines, antivaxxers have a problem: How do they explain it in the context of their conspiracy theory and misinformation about vaccines? Do they take a tragic event like the death of one of their unvaccinated antivax friends as potential disconfirming evidence, as a reason to question their narrative? I think you know the answer to that question. They find ways to double down, no matter how much they have to contort reality to do it.
So let’s compare the antivax narrative surrounding what happened to Dr. Buttar to what most likely happened. This discussion has been helped immensely by my discovery, thanks to Dr. Stephen Barrett, of an account found in an online book by “investigative medical journalist and esteemed health influencer Jonathan Otto entitled POISONED: A Deep Dive into the Mass Bioweapon & Envenomation Agenda, which promises, among other things, to tell you “the uncensored story of the late Dr. Rashid Buttar tragic story.””
Who was Dr. Rashid Buttar?
Before I get into the story of Dr. Buttar’s death, let me briefly recount the story of his life, specifically his longstanding role as one of the influential practitioners of “integrative medicine” quackery in the US. To be honest, I hadn’t paid much attention to Dr. Buttar in a while. The last time I mentioned him was last fall, when he was featured in a post about the ongoing assault by antivaxxers and promoters of unproven (and disproven) attacks on science-based medical regulation as an example of how promoters of quackery had been chipping away at science-based regulation of medical practice. Way back in 2007, Dr. Rashid Buttar made the news for calling the North Carolina Medical Board a “rabid dog” when it tried to discipline him for “unprofessional conduct” related to his cancer and antivaccine autism quackery. Let me just go back and quote what Dr. Buttar said in 2007, quoted by The Charlotte Observer and other newspapers:
Here was the sort of quackery that Dr. Buttar practiced up until his demise last month:
But Buttar believes most patients with cancer also have high levels of heavy metals, such as mercury, and other toxins, such as pesticides, because of environmental exposure. “Chelation works for the right things,” he said. “It’s not a panacea. But it works phenomenally well for chronic disease.” Buttar’s practice also has two hyperbaric oxygen chambers — and more on the way. The treatment, which floods the body with oxygen, is commonly used to accelerate wound healing. But Buttar uses it to fight cancer because, he says, cancer cells can’t thrive in an oxygen-rich environment. He acknowledges most of his treatments have not been proven by standard means, such as controlled clinical trials. But he said they have been effective in his practice over 10 years.
The story noted that Dr. Buttar’s therapy for cancer patients ranged from $40,000-60,000 for two months, and, of course, he didn’t take insurance. (Like Sayer Ji and his ex-wife, Buttar, too, was also one of the “Disinformation Dozen“.) As I noted at the time, unfortunately, Dr. Buttar’s practice and his war against the North Carolina Medical Board (which he basically won). Basically, he got a slap on the wrist, being temporarily restricted from treating cancer patients and children. The medical board did not do what was really warranted, strip him of his medical license, or, as I described what I thought that he deserved at the time in 2008, ‘having his medical license stripped from him, cut up in front of his face, and then the fragments ritually burned.” I stand by those words 15 years later.
Truth be told, I’ve been writing about Dr. Buttar intermittently since 2005, when I first discussed his use of chelation therapy to treat autism. As you might recall, chelation therapy uses what are called chelators, chemicals that bind to metals to better solubilize them and (supposedly) be excreted in the urine. As you might recall, one of the mainstays of autism biomed quackery back then was the use of chelation therapy to remove the mercury from the thimerosal preservative that had been in several childhood vaccines until around 2002 and was blamed for causing autism. Like many quack remedies, chelation therapy is an all-purpose treatment, falsely claimed to be useful for treating cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s disease, autism, and even cancer. It is also not a benign treatment. Calcium and magnesium are metals that can be chelated too. If their levels drop too low, it can cause cardiac arrhythmias and arrest, and autistic children have died as a result.
What made Dr. Buttar unique back then, so that he stood out from all the other antivax autism biomed quacks, was his “transdermal chelation therapy,” or, as we used to call it, Buttar’s butter. Of course, even if you accept that chelation therapy has any value whatsoever for treating anything other than acute toxicity due to excessive blood levels of certain heavy metals, there was no evidence that Buttar’s butter could even be absorbed through the skin, much less chelate anything. That was probably a good thing because, even if Buttar’s butter was utterly ineffective at treating autism, at least, unlike the case for intravenous chelation therapy, Buttar’s butter couldn’t kill anyone.
Those were seemingly simpler days. Dr. Buttar was definitely a cancer and autism quack, but he was also a significant “pioneer” of what became an all-too-common and distressing tactic among quacks since COVID-19: Attacking state medical boards and any other medical authority trying to rein in quacks and misinformation. His was the template that COVID-19 disinformation spreading doctors followed. Most people combatting disinformation now don’t appreciate just how influential Dr. Buttar was in terms of taking the war straight to state medical boards. The only one who did it more publicly was cancer quack Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, but Dr. Rashid Buttar was the one who actually got North Carolina state law altered to make it more quack-friendly by mobilizing public support to neuter the North Carolina Medical Board and prevent it from disciplining doctors who practice quackery associated with “integrative medicine.” This is what I meant when I said that Dr. Buttar had basically won his battle with the North Carolina State Medical Board. He lost what was in retrospect a relatively minor battle, having been restricted from treating children and cancer patients, but went on to win the war by getting North Carolina law changed.
Those are some of the reasons why he was so widely admired among antivaxxers like Sayer Ji:
It is with sadness, yet great appreciation, that we pay tribute to my friend and colleague Dr. Rashid Buttar, who passed away on May 18th.
Rashid was a fearless and tireless advocate of health freedom and speaking truth to power, and he had an immense impact on helping the world understand the power of their bodies to heal, from literally anything.
We were less than a month awayfrom his 5th Annual Advanced Medicine Conference, which we are now uncertain will proceed.
Naturally, from an antivax perspective and given Dr. Buttar’s stature and relatively young age (57) at the time of his death, he couldn’t possibly have just died of heart disease. He had to have been killed.
“COVID-19 accines killed Dr. Buttar!” (Even though he was never vaccinated against COVID-19)
The conspiracy theories started flying fast and furious as soon as news of Dr. Buttar’s death was confirmed, starting with Sayer Ji himself in his tribute, starting with misrepresenting the Disinformation Dozen list as a “digital hit list”:
Given that Rashid was put on a digital hit list, along side me, cynically named the “disinformation dozen,” we had a special bond and interest in discussing the many ways we could continue to preserve health freedom, free speech, natural medicine, and ultimately bring the world into a healthier, happier, and more beautiful phase of evolution.
I will cherish these conversations, and Rashid’s incredibly sincere spirit, and know that while his life has been cut short, he helped make this world a safer, better place for us all through his good works.
Due to rumors circulating and the many questions I have received as to the cause of his passing, I wish to share the last publicly recorded discussion we had, where Rashid wanted the world to know the details surrounding the sudden decline of his health.
For the record, Rashid reached out to me on Feb. 18th, and explained that only a few weeks before, he was in the ICU for 6 days, with a diagnosis of both stroke and myocarditis, with symptoms and biomarkers consistent with adverse effects from the mRNA jabs (which he did not have). As you will see in the video, he believed that he was experiencing the result of shedding (aka, “self-amplifying” properties) from the transgenic mRNA jabs.
Rashid shares his story starting at the hour marker of an interview I conducted on March 13th with Dr. Joel Bohemier, Rashid, Ty Bollinger (another “hit list” member) and titled The Censorship Industrial Establishment Exposed.
Quack tycoon Joe Mercola’s girlfriend Erin Elizabeth was quick to add to the conspiracy mongering about Dr. Buttar’s death:
By the way he explains he was poisoned after the CNN interview. Rest in peace. https://t.co/97sZDYuGhs
— Erin Elizabeth Health Nut News 🙌 (@unhealthytruth) May 20, 2023
This is very consistent with what Erin Elizabeth does. She has long been peddling a conspiracy theory in which “They” (big pharma, of course) are hiring hit men to kill “holistic doctors” like Dr. Buttar for assassination, starting with Jeffrey Bradstreet (who killed himself), continuing to Nicholas Gonzalez (who died of an obvious heart attack), including other physicians who committed suicide, and ultimately totaling over 80 “holistic practitioners” whose deaths she blamed on pharma, whether the deaths were even plausibly suspicious. So of course she thinks that someone killed Dr. Buttar.
So did Dr. Paul Alexander, who wasted no time posting one of his long rambling Substack titles Was Buttar killed? ‘Dr Rashid Buttar died in mysterious circumstances just days after claiming he had been poisoned following a controversial interview with CNN about his Covid pandemic disinformation, in which he asked:
Covid conspiracy doctor claimed he was ‘poisoned after interview’ just days before death; IMO, I don’t put anything past the ‘dark unseen hand’, those behind COVID fraud; where is his autopsy?
Note the element added to the conspiracy theory, that Dr. Buttar had been “poisoned” after a CNN interview and that’s what accounted for his decline in health in 2023. Stew Peters, the most prominent purveyor of the “died suddenly” conspiracy theory claiming that COVID-19 vaccines are causing young healthy people—even elite athletes!—to drop dead suddenly due to blood clots, a message spread with his conspiracyfest of a movie disguised as a documentary, Died Suddenly, was quick out of the gate with his own take on the conspiracy theory that big pharma (or someone) “got” Dr. Buttar to “shut him up,” conspiracies that he promoted in this video three days after the announcement of Dr. Buttar’s death:
Right at the beginning of the video, Peters noted that Buttar was one of the believers in the “snake venom theory,” the “belief that COVID-19 was caused by snake venom rather than the virus” and that COVID-19 vaccines contain snake venom as well. You can almost hear the cognitive dissonance in his voice as he points out that the week before Buttar had “died suddenly,” adding that he knew that Dr. Buttar hadn’t been vaccinated and asking what could explain possibly explain his sudden death. And it is true that Buttar claimed that he had been “poisoned” by “200x what’s in the vaccine.” How this happened, he didn’t say. Peters then went on about the existence of CIA assassination techniques that make deaths look like heart attacks. Next up was an interview with Dr. Tau Braun, a quack whom I had never heard before (and whom I might have to look into more in the future), who repeated the narrative that whatever landed Dr. Buttar in the ICU for six days in January must have been poison and claiming that, when a man says he has been poisoned, he’s probably been poisoned. A South African, he referenced targeted assassinations during apartheid as having “shaped him” so that he believes that Buttar had been killed, whether by the CIA or someone else. He even repeated Sayer Ji’s claim that the Center for Countering Digital Hate, by placing Dr. Buttar on its Disinformation Dozen list, had actually put him on a hit list.
Again, because the false notion that healthy-appearing people (whether they were actually healthy, as Dr. Buttar appeared to be, or not, as Dr. Buttar was) almost never “died suddenly” before COVID-19 vaccines, Braun simply could not accept the possibility that Buttar had died of natural causes. So to Braun, Buttar must have been intentionally poisoned or, alternatively, “shedding” of spike protein (which is the same thing as the snake venom that COVID-19 supposedly is, according to this conspiracy theory) must have been the cause of his illness and demise. I’ve written about antivax resurrection of the old shedding trope to claim that those vaccinated with COVID-19 vaccines “shed” spike protein that can make others sick; more specifically, I’ve written about what utter nonsense the idea that the vaccinated “shed” COVID-19 spike protein is from a scientific standpoint. Braun even goes on to say that this toxin, conveniently enough for his narrative, is now “everywhere,” thanks to the vaccine, meaning that you can’t avoid it.
You know what does make a lot of spike protein? COVID-19 infection, that’s what!. It can also cause the body to release more virus (toxin, if you will, just to be sarcastic) that makes others sick. Of course, if this “toxin” is everywhere as Braun claims, then no one can avoid it and everyone needs quackery to “detox” themselves, including—surprise!—EDTA, which is a common chelator used by autism biomed quacks back in the day. At the end of the interview, Peters couldn’t resist interjecting that any doctors still giving COVID-19 shots are actively killing their patients, because of course he couldn’t. When Braun started claiming that the spike protein induces the body to produce “other toxins, and those toxins can leave the body and make other sick,” I almost lost it. Stochastic shedding, I guess.
In any event, you get the idea. Dr. Buttar had been antivaccine for decades before his death. I’ve been writing about his antivaccine quackery since 2005. So what really happened? I’ll try to integrate what happened from all the sources of which I’m aware.
Dr. Buttar: Ill since at least 2015
I’ll start at the beginning, using Jonathan Otto’s account, specifically the chapter in his e-book about Dr. Buttar’s story. By way of background, I knew this from accounts that I was able to read in the aftermath of Dr. Buttar’s death, before I learned of Otto’s ebook. Going back to the video referenced by Sayer Ji, Buttar noted that he had first felt ill in September 2022 at the Reawaken America tour, where he started feeling short of breath on stage, to the point where he couldn’t “properly give” his presentations and fell back on showing videos. Buttar then relates how he then also developed increasing swelling of his legs that got worse, lasted several days, resolved, and then came back. On Thanksgiving, he couldn’t get his boots on, and between Thanksgiving and January he put on 50 lbs of edema fluid. He said that by the time he was admitted to the hospital he couldn’t lie flat and still breathe and even had to stand up to breathe. These are absolutely classic symptoms of congestive heart failure, so much so that we teach them to first and second year medical students as part of cardiac physiology and pathophysiology.
Dr. Buttar was (ostensibly) a physician. He knew—or should have known—all of this. What was he doing during the months that he was putting on so much water weight and finding it increasingly difficult to breathe without being in an upright position? Why did he not see a doctor, particularly a cardiologist but at least an internist or family practice doc? He mentioned that he had thought about taking a diuretic, but apparently he never did. Did it not occur to him that his symptoms seemed consistent with right-sided heart failure, possibly biventricular failure? In any case, while he was in the ICU the doctors alternated between dosing him with Lasix and Bumex, two powerful diuretics, and got a lot of fluid off of him. He also then related having a mid-thalamic stroke confirmed by MRI that resolved. By the time he was released from the hospital, according to his account he had lost 60 lbs of fluid and then went on to lose nearly 20 lbs more after going home. At just before 1:09, he related having had elevated troponin levels, which he said were consistent with myocarditis and symptoms consistent with pericarditis. Ultimately, after his discharge from the ICU and hospital in January, Buttar blamed his illness on “secondary inoculation” by the COVID-19 vaccine shedding; indeed, he doubled down, claiming that the goal was to get half the population vaccinated, after which shedding would expose the rest of the population to the vaccines’s spike protein “toxin.” He concluded that he thinks “that’s what happened to me.” Because, of course it couldn’t possibly just have been heart disease.
Now add to the account above an early passage from his story in Otto’s ebook:
It was 6 days before I was scheduled to meet with Bryan, and I was getting ready to fly out to Spokane, Washington, for a speaking engagement. Actually, it was a Reawaken America tour. And I remember having a conversation with Clay Clark because the air quality there, normal is between 60 to a 100. As it gets up higher, it’s bad air quality.
A 100 is supposed to be the worst air quality. And the air quality in Spokane was 150. And I was having problems with breathing at that point, and I didn’t know what it was. I’ve got an underlying cardiac disposition, had a rapid CT angiography done back in 2015 that showed I had a 75 and a 95% occlusion, which didn’t make any sense because I’ve had all sorts of preventive treatments.
And the year before, I competed at the world championships in martial arts. So I’m competing at the world level in 2014 and 2015. I can’t walk a quarter of a mile without stopping 5 times because I’m getting short of breath and having chest pain. So I had this predisposition, and I’d been doing things to get that back, and I had. I was starting to sprint again.
Bryan is Bryan Ardis, a retired chiropractor and one of the purveyors of the conspiracy theory that COVID-19 is due to “envenomation,” not the SARS-CoV-2 virus, and that remdesivir is what kills COVID-19 patients, not COVID. Where did he get this idea?
Hilariously:
But the linchpin for his whole nonsensical theory is a 2017 episode of a network TV drama called “The Blacklist.”
After laying the groundwork for about half-an-hour, the video shows a clip from an episode of NBC’s “The Blacklist” in which the main character is poisoned with snake venom in a beverage.
“When I saw this, I knew,” Ardis says of watching the show, which originally aired in 2017 — almost three years before the outbreak of COVID-19. It’s now available on Netflix. “I knew I was right, I knew I was supposed to see that, because it was confirmation to me that other people knew this was planned all along, which, we’ve known this was a plan.”
One of the well-worn conspiracy theories that Ardis relies on here claims that the pandemic was planned in advance by nefarious actors — one of the most viral versions of this theory was presented in a pair of videos from 2020 called “Plandemic,” each of which we’ve written about.
As much as I’ve enjoyed James Spader’s scenery chewing portraying the fictional crime lord turned FBI informer Raymond “Red” Reddington in The Blacklist over the years, the show’s plotlines are often patently ridiculous (albeit in a very entertaining way), and obviously no source for anything resembling reliable medical information. That “Dr.” Ardis would admit that his inspiration for the idea that COVID-19 is “envenomation” tells you all you need to know about him.
Of course, Buttar’s account in Otto’s book sure doesn’t sound like that of a man who was the picture of health before he was exposed to the dreaded spike protein, which is ubiquitous and can’t be avoided thanks to the machinations of the evil big pharma cabal’s efforts to vaccinate the entire population, or who had been “poisoned” after an appearance on CNN several months ago. It sounds like a man in denial, who couldn’t believe that he had gone in a relatively short period of time from competing at a high level in the martial arts to not being able to walk a quarter of a mile without getting short of breath. He had clearly had significant heart disease diagnosed in 2015, four years before the pandemic and at least five years before COVID-19 vaccines! He admitted that he couldn’t walk more than a quarter of a mile without getting short of breath, which is not great. Even worse, though:
And so when this event was coming up, it was no different than the last 6 years. Since 2016, this has been going on. So it’s not like it’s anything new. But I was a little concerned because now the shortness of breath, over that last 6 years even though I had that cardiac history, over the last 4 years, I hadn’t had any shortness of breath or over the last 4 1/2 years, I hadn’t had any shortness of breath. I’d get the chest pain pretty regularly, but I wouldn’t get shortness of breath.
Now I was having shortness of breath. And I was having shortness of breath that was suffocating, where I felt like I was drowning. And it was slowly building up. And then I had this chronic cough. I had a rattling in my chest at nighttime. I felt like I was wheezing, but it wasn’t wheezing.
So anyway, there were all these little symptomologies that were going on. And so, I had my plane booked, and the next day I left to go there. And fortunately the event was outdoors. And fortunately, there was a nice wind blowing, and there was no issues with the quality of air that I felt, but I was short of breath when I was on stage. In fact, I even played more videos because I was a little short of breath.
To any physician, this sure sounds like an exacerbation of chronic heart disease and worsening congestive heart failure. What had Dr. Buttar been doing the last six years before the Reawaken America last September, given that by his own account he had had a critical occlusion of at least one of his coronary arteries, an occlusion that would normally mandate intervention? He’s fairly vague, saying only that he was “not oriented towards a pharmaceutical side.” Of course, CT-angiography is not the gold standard test to quantify the degree of coronary artery occlusion. However, in someone who is symptomatic—chest pain!—with such a test, further investigation would be mandated, and most likely cardiologists would recommend an angioplasty of the occluded vessels with stenting at minimum, a coronary artery bypass operation if too many vessels have a high degree of occlusion to stent. Again, Dr. Buttar was trained as a physician and was an ER doc for several years. He must have known this.
I facepalmed even more as I read how Dr. Buttar, experiencing not just chest pain but intermittent “suffocating” shortness of breath that made him feel as though he were “drowning,” dithered about whether to see a doctor and made plans to meet up with Ardis during the rest of his tour. Then, on the day he was going to see Ardis one afternoon when they were in the same city, this happened:
Well, I’ll tell you, when I walked out to the car to meet him, it was difficult for me to walk. And I felt like, to show you how serious it was for me, I felt like if I went to Bryan, I would be doing him a disservice because I was going to die in his house. And why would I do that, because then how is he going to be able to explain that? It would be a disservice for me to go there.
But I also knew if I went to a hospital, again, I was an ER doc for 7 years. I’m ACLS, ATTLS, Advanced Trauma Life Support, Advanced Cardiac Life Support, Pediatric Advanced Life Support, instructor certified. I teach doctors what to do and those things. And I knew that, if I go there, they’re not going to know what to do because I didn’t know what was going on. But I literally had a dilemma that made me stand outside the car trying to decide, do I go to the ER or do I go to Bryan?
It was like 2, 3 minutes, I just stood there. And I even remember thinking it was warm. There was a breeze blowing. I was right underneath a tree. The car’s parked. And it was a beautiful setting. And I just even thought maybe I should just go sit in the park because I really thought I was going to go. I had talked with my kids, I talked with Dr. Ashton, but never said anything to them. None of them knew. I made a call to an attorney to make sure that I had some semblance of a will, but I really felt that I was sliding. I could feel the life ebbing out of me. And I didn’t know why. I didn’t understand why.
So Dr. Buttar felt so weak and short of breath that he thought he’d die in Ardis’s house if he went there. In fact, he thought he was dying as he sat in his car, to the point where he made a call to his attorney to make sure his will was in order? I also couldn’t help but marvel at the cognitive dissonance. Buttar was ATLS and ACLS trained, instructor certified even? And he thought that ER docs wouldn’t know what to do with him if he showed up in their facility? Of course they would! From his own story, he almost certainly had severe congestive heart failure. They’d admit him to the ICU for supportive care, begin diuresing him to get the fluid off, evaluate his heart, and recommend further interventions.
He went to see Ardis instead. No, seriously. That’s what he did:
But he has said that to me since. And I’ve thought about those words since. And he said to me that there is no place on this planet that I would rather have you at right now than here in my living room. And he did some energetic testing. I won’t go into the details of all the stuff he did, but he did some energetic testing. And he told me that I had a poison in my heart. And I said, “A poison? You mean like a toxin?” He says, “No. A poison.”
And he told me at that time, he goes, “I don’t know what it is.” That’s what he told me. He goes, “But you’ve got a poison in your heart.” And then he told me, “There’s 4 chambers to the heart.” And so that everybody knows as the 2 atriums that are the receiving areas of the heart that receive the blood. And then the blood goes from those 2 atriums into the 2 ventricles, and the 2 ventricles pump the blood out to the rest of the body. And the 2 chambers that pump the blood out to the body are the ventricles. The ventricles are the right and left ventricle.
Ardis also told him:
And so the 2 atriums, on a scale of 0 to 12, the right atrium was functioning at a 3 on a scale of 0 to 12, with 12 being the best. And the left atrium was at a 4 on a scale of 0 to 12, with 12 being the best. And the ventricles, which are arguably the more important chambers of the heart, because they’re responsible for pumping blood either through the lungs or through the body, were both functioning at a 0 on a scale of 0 to 12, with 12 being the best. I mean, they weren’t functioning.
I was going to give Ardis credit for recognizing that Dr. Buttar was in a bad way until he claimed that his ventricles weren’t functioning at all. There’s a term for when the ventricles don’t function at all: Cardiac arrest. Dr. Buttar would not be conscious, much less talking, if his ventricles were truly “both functioning at a 0 on a scale of 0 to 12, with 12 being the best.” He’d be dead or on the way to being dead within minutes.
Thanks to Otto’s book, I also now know what Dr. Buttar was doing between the time he first noticed his “suffocating” shortness of breath at Reawaken America until he was admitted to the hospital for a six day ICU stay four months later: A whole lot of quackery. As he put on more and more edema fluid due to his congestive heart failure and possibly kidney failure, to the point where his feet “really ballooned, massively ballooned, became volleyball sized.” He even claimed that he couldn’t be having congestive heart failure because the edema was non-pitting. (Pitting edema is edema where, if you push the skin with a finger, will “pit”; i.e., leave an impression that takes a while to fill back in.) And while he’s correct that pitting edema is far more associated with congestive heart failure, in particular right-sided congestive heart failure, and non-pitting edema with other conditions, edema of this magnitude is a real problem. It could be lymphatic. It could be chronic venous insufficiency, which can cause impressive nonpitting edema. It could be myxedema from hypothyroidism.
Instead of going down the differential of pitting vs. nonpitting edema, putting it into context with all his other symptoms of congestive heart failure, and getting real medical care, Dr. Buttar listened to the chiroquack:
But by that time things were already better. So why was I having all this swelling in my feet? But think about it. If the body’s got a poison, if the heart’s trying to get rid of a poison, it’s going to try to pump it the furthest away from the heart that it possibly can, the furthest away from the brain. It’s going to try to shunt it to the furthest extremities it possibly can.
And so it sent it all to the most distal area of the body, which was the feet. And the kidneys couldn’t keep up with it. And because the kidneys, again, kidneys have their own, think of it as sensors or receptors. So if something’s going to come through the kidneys that’s going to damage the kidneys, the kidneys are going to slow down their functioning because they don’t want to get damaged. And they’re trying to handle the toxicity load or the poison load or whatever that’s trying to clear. But it’s also not going to handle more than what the kidneys can handle.
And so it was almost like it was pooling in my feet and in my legs and in my thighs because it was too much for the body to clear at that time. The kidneys couldn’t handle it, so it was clearing it as it could. And what’s interesting is that once it was cleared, I thought everything was fine.
In the meantime, he was doing “energetic healing,” medication, various woo prescribed to him by Ardis. He also underwent some sort of electrodermal testing that led him to be told:
And then I had another friend of mine, Dr. Group, had a test done for me and finds that I have a snake venom. I have a 2nd snake venom, I have a 3rd snake venom, I have an ant venom, and I have a spider venom. So it’s the polypus. I think that’s how you pronounce it. Spider, a wood ant venom, and then I had cobra venom, sorry, no, I had a rattlesnake venom and copperhead venom. And then later we found that I had cobra venom, too. But that’s what the test found. And I’m like, “What the hell? How did I get this stuff?”
He also noted how his symptoms were waxing and waning and that he was also taking a diuretic. He seems to have taken a diuretic for a while, until his symptoms got better, at which point he stopped it. Then—surprise! surprise!—eventually his symptoms would return.
I will say at this point that this interview recorded in Otto’s book must have occurred before mid-January, which is when Dr. Buttar wound up in the ICU, because no mention is made of that. He did, however, give a lengthy account of how he had come to conclude that, despite his never having been vaccinated against COVID-19, it must still have been the vaccines. First, he relates how he learned of 113 people who were having the same symptoms as he was (“shortness of breath, feeling of drowning, swelling in the legs, a dry, hacky cough”) but had not been vaccinated, which, among other things, convinced him that it must have been the shedding of spike protein from the vaccinated that had made him ill. (Never mind that he had had at the time a six or seven year history of diagnosed coronary artery disease.) As a result, Dr. Buttar concluded:
But it’s there, and it’s been orchestrated to be disseminated in a manner that is everywhere. There’s going to be no place that’s safe, unless you’re in a bunker underground 300 feet with an independent filtered water source and an independent filtered air source. It could be also be just through contact, and that’s been also postulated. Just things that we’re touching.
And:
People that have gotten exposed to shedding, which means that you don’t get the vaccine itself, but you’re in close proximity to other people that have gotten the so-called vaccine, the messenger RNA modified genetic experimentation that is introducing this spike protein into you. So people that have been close proximity with other people are experiencing symptomology that’s similar. And that’s because they’ve gotten what they call the shedding. The shedding is exposure of that spike protein that they have been exposed to. That’s exactly what happened to me because I haven’t had the jab, and I’d refused to take the jab, but I have had 2 specific exposures.
Which led Dr. Buttar to conclude:
And the 2nd time was when I gave a CNN interview, and they’d given me some water to drink. And I remember as I’m guzzling down the water, I’m thinking to myself, was that lid already open? I remember thinking I’m paranoid. And I got sick right after that; within half an hour I started getting sick.
So those are the 2 times that I could have been targeted or poisoned, if you will. Or it could have been just because I was sitting in a plane in close proximity to other people that had the vaccine or in some other type of public space. So I don’t know how I’d gotten it, but many people have experienced this viral shedding. And we call it viral shedding because nobody knew, really, what it was, but it’s actually shedding off this spike protein following the normal phenomena of viral shedding. But this is actually the spike protein that’s shedding, not a virus that’s shedding. And that spike protein is, again, that synthetic analog of these various types of poisons. Once they get into your system, then they are designed by design to elicit a response in the system. It’s targeting the heart cells, it’s targeting the cells of the reproductive system. So testicles in males and the ovaries in females, they have found an increased preponderance of the spike protein accumulating in those areas.
Sadly, a far more likely explanation for Dr. Buttar’s illness is that he had developed congestive heart failure, most likely from chronic ischemia due to cardiovascular disease, and that’s what caused him to develop the edema and difficulty breathing. He might also have had some venous insufficiency or other reason for his edema to be nonpitting. Who knows? Alternatively, maybe he had a silent myocardial infarction (or one with only mild symptoms that he ignored) and developed progressive heart failure afteward. He might even have had COVID-19, which caused a case of myocarditis. Again, who knows? The story as related by him and his followers lacks sufficient detail to allow for more than educated speculation about what happened to him. Basically, being in the ICU with congestive heart failure, for whatever reason, tells me that (1) you are not healthy, regardless of how healthy you think you are, and (2) you are at high risk of sudden cardiac death, which is very likely what happened to Dr. Buttar. Again, we can’t know for sure. Even adding the account in Otto’s book to the videos that I’ve examined, there is insufficient detail in all these accounts, even taken together, to make a more definitive assessment.
Quacks can be victims of their own quackery
The “died suddenly” conspiracy theory demands that healthy people cannot just “die suddenly” and that only the COVID-19 vaccine is causing people to “die suddenly” (even though there has been, for example, a small but consistent incidence of sudden arrhythmic deaths for a very long time, a phenomenon first described in the 1970s). When someone who is unvaccinated—particularly as famous an antivaxxer as Dr. Buttar—dies suddenly, antivaxxers cannot accept that it might have just been due to natural causes. It had to be due to something else, in this case COVID-19 vaccines. Of course, this presents a problem in the case of someone like Dr. Buttar, who because of his antivaccine views had never been vaccinated against COVID-19. Yet he died of what looks for all the world like heart disease. After all, a man who had been competed in martial arts and apparently been in robust health until 2014-2015, all while living the optimal healthy lifestyle and consuming the optimal healthy diet as an “integrative” and “natural” health practitioner, couldn’t possibly just develop heart disease in his early 50s, could he? No! That never happens, at least not according to the alternative medicine narrative. Unfortunately it can and, all too often, does happen. Diet and exercise decrease, but far from eliminate, one’s risk of developing heart disease.
Indeed, Dr. Buttar himself couldn’t accept that maybe he had just gotten sick, most likely as a result of genetics and/or bad luck. (Obviously, to him it couldn’t possibly have been due to lifestyle or diet, because as an “integrative medicine” physician he must have been living the ultimate healthy lifestyle.) Instead, he had to find a way to blame vaccine “shedding” for his illness. After all, he was unvaccinated and couldn’t possibly have had congestive heart failure and a small stroke without COVID-19 vaccines somehow having been responsible. In fairness, as far as I’ve been able to ascertain, before his death Dr. Buttar seemed not to believe that he had been “targeted” for assassination, but rather that he had been exposed to “shed” spike protein during the CNN interview or on an airplane. The even more outlandish conspiracy theories about a “hit” appear to have arisen more after his death. Because the antivaccine movement is at its heart a conspiracy theory like all science denial, people like Stew Peters and Erin Johnson were quick to spin conspiracy theories about the CIA and/or big pharma hit squads having “poisoned” him with the “toxin” from the vaccine. Of course, I have to ask here: If everyone who’s been vaccinated sheds spike protein, why would they ever have had to bother? No one ever said that conspiracy theories had to be consistent.
To conspiracy theorists like the late Dr. Buttar, the COVID-19 vaccine is the source of all evil, the weapon by which “They” are poisoning everyone for nefarious purposes of “control,” “depopulation,” or whatever combination of evil ends that the cranks dream up. Because he had kept himself “pure” by not getting the vaccine, Dr. Buttar simply could not accept getting seriously ill with heart disease for the same reasons that we are all prone to becoming seriously ill with heart disease. Consistent with the antivaccine movement, indeed the entire alternative medicine movement, being a cult of purity, he had to blame it on “contamination” or “poisoning” from an external source and toxin, the toxin being, of course, the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, a conspiracy theory that he used before his sudden death to explain why he had been suffering chest pain and shortness of breath since 2016, the latter of which worsened in September 2022 to become “suffocating” shortness of breath. Then, during all that time, but particularly since September 2022, instead of seeking out science-based medicine to treat what was clearly worsening heart disease and bouts of congestive heart failure, Dr. Buttar relied on quacks like him (plus a little diuretic every now and then) to treat himself, even though just from what we know from his videos and Otto’s book about his longstanding heart disease and bouts of congestive heart failure, physicians can say that Dr. Buttar was at a high risk for sudden cardiac death, most likely due to a myocardial infarction.
Then, of course, after his death, Dr. Buttar’s fans had to find a way to turn his having “died suddenly” into not just an incidental exposure to “shed” spike protein but to a targeted assassination. Again, this is not unexpected. He also treated a life-threatening illness with a whole lot of the same quackery to which he had in practice subjected his patients over the last couple of decades. While it is true that he accepted science-based medicine (albeit, from his descriptions, with a number of caveats) in the ICU for six days in January, he appears not to have followed through afterward with a needed outpatient course of care to control his disease. If he had, he might well still be alive today. Antivax is, at its heart, a conspiracy theory, and grief will bring out its more paranoid elements. Unfortunately for him and his family, it turns out that Dr. Buttar was just as much a victim of his own quackery as his patients have been over the last quarter century.

A Letter to My Critics: To Refute Me, Stand Up For Your Own Words
Calling me a “lockerdowner” generates likes and retweets from “free-thinkers”, but it doesn’t refute anything I wrote. Since you obviously need help, I’d like to give you a clear roadmap to refute my ideas. All you have to do is stand up for your own words and make the affirmative case that the purposeful infection of unvaccinated children and young adults was wise and a net positive.
Jonathan HowardonJune 16, 2023
Link

To My Critics,
In a previous article, I exposed the futility of your attempt to rebut my writing using straw man arguments and juvenile japes. Calling me a “lockerdowner” generates likes and retweets from “free-thinkers”, but it doesn’t refute anything I wrote. As you seem confused, I’d like to give you a clear roadmap to refute me. It shouldn’t be that hard. All you have to do is stand up for your own words and make the affirmative case that the purposeful infection of unvaccinated children and young adults was wise and a net positive this pandemic.
Let’s start at the beginning. In March 2020, you penned an essay titled “Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say?” in which you surmised that COVID had “one-tenth of the flu mortality rate of 0.1%”. You wrote “about the limited scale of the epidemic” and said that “a 20,000- or 40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million.” To refute me, defend your statements. Prove that you were right about the limited scale of the epidemic.
As the pandemic progressed, you were certain that herd immunity would arrive and everyone could live normally with minimal risks just 3-6 months after restrictions were removed. The passage below comes directly from the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), which was published in October 2020. To refute me, make the case that had we only used “focused protection” on that date, then herd immunity would have arrived by April 2021 at the latest. You must argue that we never would have heard of Delta, Omicron, or any variant because we’d have herd immunity.
You need to further make the affirmative case that the purposeful infection of unvaccinated youth remained wise even after a vaccine arrived in December 2020, just two short months after you published your plan to infect hundreds of millions of unvaccinated Americans. Days after vaccinations began that month, you continued to advocate for the mass infection of unvaccinated young people, promising that the pandemic would be “naturally over in 3-6 months” once they all were infected. Tell me you were right about this.
Throughout the pandemic, you continued to make the case that young people should forgo the vaccine in favor of “natural immunity”. In an article you published in June 2021 titled, “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young” you wrote that:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
Convince me that you were right about this, that it would have been “more dangerous” to vaccinate every one than to vaccinate no one.
Further, you must argue that it was a good idea to glorify the virus in articles such as The Triumph of Natural Immunity. That article expressed a lot of confidence about a brand new virus. Like a clairvoyant, you wrote that children “have strong natural immunity that protects them from covid infections as they get older”. To refute me, prove that repeat COVID infections are rare or benign. Explain how we can be certain repeat infections will have no consequence for developing children. Remind me again why you ignored any COVID outcome beyond death in your Declaration, as if all survivors recovered fully. Convince me that the mass infection of unvaccinated babies, who aren’t born with natural immunity and who have the highest COVID risk, should continue in perpetuity.
You must also claim you were right when you said “we should not be particularly concerned about the variants” shortly before the Delta and Omicron variants arrived. Defend your statement in April 2021 that, “the central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID.” I thought the virus was the “central problem” at that time. You need to make the case that fear of COVID was worse than COVID, even though more Americans died of COVID after your comment than before it.
Of course, you must use accurate numbers in your rebuttal, which hasn’t been your strong suit this pandemic. Don’t bother trying to trick me by claiming only 1 in a million children die of COVID or that more children died of the flu. We both know I’ll spot and expose your fake statistics, as I have throughout the pandemic. You also need to avoid specious arguments. You previously argued that we should let some unvaccinated children suffer from COVID because the virus is more dangerous for older people. We both know I won’t find this convincing. It’s also a waste to try to convince me rare vaccine side-effects are a fate worse than death for children.
Perhaps most importantly, tell me what we need to do now to end the pandemic. You said that if we had “focused protection, as outlined in the Great Barrington Declaration, the pandemic would have been over now”. How can we do “focused protection” right now to achieve herd immunity? What pandemic restrictions must end so the pandemic can be over in 3-6 months? How many more unvaccinated children must contract COVID for the pandemic to end?
And if you once again to tell me, yet again, that the pandemic is over, then please act like it. You said in September 2021 that “we should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people”. Please do that. Model the behavior you expect from others.
Nothing would be a stronger rebuke of my writing than for you to stop talking about the pandemic.

Might “Vitriolic Attacks” Against Emily Oster Rival COVID’s Carnage?
To advocates of Feelings Based Medicine, there is no difference between criticizing someone’s ideas and attacking them personally.
Jonathan Howard on May 19, 2023
Link

I’ll begin by repeating a universally held and oft-expressed belief here at SBM: vulgarities and threats are never an acceptable part of scientific discourse.
One person who has likely received such abuse is economics professor Emily Oster, particularly after she published an article in The Atlantic in March 2021 titled “Your Unvaccinated Kid Is Like a Vaccinated Grandma.” “Children are not at high risk for COVID-19,” she wrote. They are “naturally protected,” she added. “Being a child is a really great vaccine.”
One person to rally to Dr. Oster’s defense at the time was Dr. Jeffrey S. Flier, the Higginson Professor of Physiology and Medicine, Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor, and Former Dean of the Faculty of Medicine (2007- 2016). He said:
Of course, it’s not clear exactly to which “vitriolic attacks” Dr. Flier was referring. Some people on Twitter said her article was “stupid” and “evil”. Beyond this, Professor Oster certainly has been the subject of stern criticism. Peste Magazine awarded her the “Achievement in Public Health Disservice by a Non-Public Health Professional“, and I strongly encourage you to read this article titled “Motivated Reasoning: Emily Oster’s COVID Narratives and the Attack on Public Education” by Drs. Abigail Cartus and Justin Feldman. They wrote:
Oster’s influence on the discourse around COVID in schools is difficult to overstate. She has been quoted in hundreds of articles about school pandemic precautions and interviewed as a guest on dozens of news shows. Officials from both parties have used her work as justification for lifting public health measures. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis cited her study while announcing an executive order banning school mask mandates, while CDC Director Rochelle Walenksy referenced Oster’s research in anticipation of relaxing classroom social distancing guidelines. Oster also co-authored an influential school reopening guidance document that was released in early 2021.
Would Dr. Flier consider these articles a “vitriolic attack”? Quite possibly he would.
Of course, strident criticisms are not “vitriolic attacks”. They are part of a healthy discussion and debate, something Dr. Flier claims to value. Too often, harsh but fair critiques are falsely labeled “vitriolic attacks” in an attempt to shame the critic into silence and shift the conversation away from those who spread misinformation. The pandemic has birthed a sad sort of sanctimonious scold, who scrupulously avoids substantive discourse, and says in essence: sure, doctors said herd immunity arrived two years ago and spread anti-vaccine misinformation, but the REAL problem is you hurt their feelings and you should stop it. To these advocates of Feelings Based Medicine, criticizing someone’s ideas is attacking them personally, and the “wellness” of anti-vaccine doctors is priority #1.
And thus we come to the most eye-catching part of Dr. Flier’s Tweet. He also wrote that “vitriolic attacks against her reflect a moral sickness that may rival COVID19 in its ultimate harm so far.” This is not the first time he’s argued that words are violence and delicate professors need a safe space. At the start of the pandemic, along with Dr. Vinay Prasad, he penned a defense of Dr. John Ioannidis, another influential and incorrect voice, which said:
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics.
Though Dr. Prasad now frequently calls vaccine-advocates “idiots”, “stupid”, and “mentally ill“, they wrote at the time, “We think it is important to hear, consider, and debate these views without ad hominem attacks or animus.”
Though I share their objection to “ad hominem attacks or animus”, let’s compare this to COVID’s toll so far. One study found:
Although reported COVID-19 deaths between Jan 1, 2020, and Dec 31, 2021, totalled 5·94 million worldwide, we estimate that 18·2 million (95% uncertainty interval 17·1–19·6) people died worldwide because of the COVID-19 pandemic (as measured by excess mortality) over that period.
That estimate is only from the first two years of the pandemic, and it doesn’t take into account the countless millions of people who survived COVID, but were injured by it. That all sounds a whole lot worse than even the most vitriolic attack towards Professor Oster or anyone else ever in the history of the world, does it not? What breach in decorum could one day rival COVID?
I suppose Dr. Flier is imagining some future dystopia where a plucky, contrarian economist holds the key to solving a global catastrophe via an article in The Atlantic, but is instead threatened into silence, with resultant mass death and suffering. In this imagined future, dueling scientists- motivated only by politics and tribalism- hurl juvenile taunts at each other, rather than engage in polite, civil discourse about science and data. In one sense, this sounds like an absurd movie plot. However, in another sense this is exactly what happened much of the pandemic, especially to the mostly anonymous healthcare workers on the ground.
    • Hundreds of public health officials have resigned or retired rather than face abuse and threats. According to news reports, “Some have become the target of far-right activists, conservative groups and anti-vaccination extremists who have coalesced around common goals: fighting mask orders, quarantines and contact tracing with protests, threats and personal attacks”. According to a survey from The New York Times, “Public health agencies have seen a staggering exodus of personnel, many exhausted and demoralized, in part because of abuse and threats”. They report “more than 500 top health officials who left their jobs in the past 19 months”.
    • Dr. Anthony Fauci needed “personal security from law enforcement at all times, including at his home”. According to news reports, “he and his family have required continued security in the face of harassment and death threats from people angry over his guidance on the coronavirus pandemic”. Dr. Peter Hotez has been doxxed and subject to coordinated campaigns of harassment for his vaccine advocacy. According to Dr. Hotez, the hate mail he received “was filled with all sorts of Nazi imagery, Nuremberg hangings and terrible, terrible stuff. It was pretty upsetting”. Prior to the pandemic, Dr. Richard Pan was assaulted in the street for advocating for vaccines. Dr. David Gorski has been the victim of harassment campaigns.
    • A Nature survey of 321 scientists found that “more than two-thirds of researchers reported negative experiences as a result of their media appearances or their social media comments, and 22% had received threats of physical or sexual violence. Some scientists said that their employer had received complaints about them, or that their home address had been revealed online. Six scientists said they were physically attacked”. Dr. Novella discussed this here.
    • According to one article titled “At the Peak of the Pandemic, Health Care Workers Were Heroes. Now, They’re Getting Threats“:
Doctors and nurses at a Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, hospital have been accused of killing patients by grieving family members who don’t believe COVID-19 is real, said hospital spokeswoman Caiti Bobbitt. Others have been the subject of hurtful rumors spread by people angry about the pandemic. “Our health care workers are almost feeling like Vietnam veterans, scared to go into the community after a shift,” Bobbitt said.
Over Labor Day weekend in Colorado, a passerby threw an unidentified liquid at a nurse working at a mobile vaccine clinic in suburban Denver. Another person in a pickup truck ran over and destroyed signs put up around the clinic’s tent.
This is but a very small sample (more examples here) of actual vitriolic attacks this pandemic, and it’s quite possible that Professor Oster was on the receiving end of some of this deplorable conduct. Dr. Flier would be absolutely right to call this a moral sickness. However, as awful as this was, the healthcare workers who’ve actually been silenced are those who died from COVID. Their voices are completely absent from “areas of discussion/debate in areas of ongoing uncertainty”.
In contrast, Professor Oster has been a ubiquitous and consequential presence throughout, despite never caring for a COVID patient herself. So while I am sure that she’s been the victim of indefensible vitriolic attacks, it’s curious that Dr. Flier chose her to warn against an imagined nightmare when our present is exactly what he seems to fear- tens of millions of people are dead and countless millions more injured. Children were orphaned. Schools and businesses were shuttered. The pandemic deeply affected the life of every human on the planet. Meanwhile, threatened scientists are on the run while anti-vaccine doctors who manipulate data are promoted to high places and defended by the likes of Dr. Prasad.
Incredibly, Dr. Flier feels that “vitriolic attacks” against Professor Oster “reflect a moral sickness that may rival” all of that.
Maybe it’s because I’ve worked in a New York City hospital throughout the pandemic, but I’m not too worried that vitriolic attacks against a famous, sheltered economist will soon rival COVID’s carnage. To be honest, I can’t even conceive of a “vitriolic attack” that compares to tens of millions of dead people, especially considering so many of them should still be alive. The Delta and Omicron variants arrived shortly after Professor Oster published her article in the spring of 2021, proving that being a child wasn’t always a really great vaccine. However, even before this, there was already evidence that not all children were “naturally protected”. Sadly, the fact that we did an OK job of protecting children early in the pandemic was used as “evidence” they didn’t need protecting at all.
It’s not a “vitriolic attack” to point any of this out to Professor Oster- though assuredly, someone who pretends to value “debate and discussion”, will frame it that way in the hopes of dissuading me and anyone else from making pointed criticisms in the future.

Neil deGrasse Tyson makes the unforced error of “debating” antivax propagandist Del Bigtree on The Highwire
Last week, astrophysicist and famed science communicator Neil deGrasse Tyson appeared on The Highwire, an antivax video podcast, to “debate” its host, antivax propagandist Del Bigtree. This incident demonstrates quite well why it is almost never a good idea for a scientist to agree to “debate” science deniers.
David Gorski on April 10, 2023
Link

Those who’ve sent me videos to debunk or comment on know this about me: I rarely watch videos, especially from cranks. If the video is longer than about five or ten minutes, your chances of getting me to watch and comment on it are damned near close to zero (and they’re not so great even if the video is short). The reason is simple and all about me. I find videos to be a highly inefficient way to imbibe information and, when it comes to blogging, an even more inefficient use of my time given that I might have to spend an extra one or even two hours watching the video, stopping to transcribe relevant parts, and the whole thing always ends up taking a lot more time than just doing one of my regular blog posts, which already takes up a lot of time given my tendency towards verbosity. That’s not to say that I don’t occasionally make exceptions to this rule, in particular for antivaccine propaganda movies like VAXXED and The Greater Good, for cancer quackery movies like The Beautiful Truth or the documentary by Eric Merola about Stanislaw Burzynski plus its sequel (and even laetrile!), or even movies about how COVID-19 is a “plandemic.” However, I tend to make fairly rare exceptions to my rule for notable pieces of propaganda that allow me to illustrate larger points.
Which brings me to Neil deGrasse Tyson (whose name will be abbreviated NDT, from here on out, so that I don’t have to type it a million times and screw up hitting the shift key).
Neil deGrasse Tyson is, of course, an astrophysicist and longtime director of the Hayden Planetarium at the Rose Center for Earth and Space in New York City. However, he is better known as one of the most famous science communicators, if not the most famous science communicator, in the world. It is not an exaggeration to say that he is arguably the Carl Sagan of this generation, a connection that was cemented when he hosted the 2014 updated version—or, if you prefer, a sequel—of Cosmos the groundbreaking 1980 PBS documentary series about space, physics, geology, and the history of life on Earth originally hosted by Carl Sagan. In other words, NDT is a science rock star, a bona fide celebrity, who appears frequently as a guest on various television shows to promote science and the scientific perspective. I even met him once in the green room at The Amazing Meeting 9 in 2011 and was utterly starstruck—because of course I was.
All this is why I was so shocked and alarmed to see this on Wednesday afternoon:
TOMORROW on 'The HighWire!'
Two Universes Collide when @DelBigtree and Celebrity Astrophysicist Neil DeGrasse Tyson come together to discuss Science, The Scientific Method, Misinformation, COVID, and much more…
Don't miss this!
Tomorrow, April 6th, 11AM Pacific / 2PM ET… pic.twitter.com/Go1iHKsP7w
— The HighWire (@HighWireTalk) April 5, 2023
That’s right. The most famous science communicator in the world had agreed to appear on the podcast of one of the most influential and rabid antivaccine activists and propagandists in the world. Regular readers know what my reaction would be, but for those who are not, let’s just say that alarm would be a mild description of my reaction, and right then, right there, I knew that I would have to make an exception to my usual rule about videos, even though I knew that watching Bigtree’s hypercaffeinated, sometimes unctuous, and utterly overconfident televangelist-like schtick would be painful. The reason? Basically, everyone knows that it is my position that it is almost always a really bad idea for science communicators, scientists, physicians, and actual experts to agree to appear in “debates” with science deniers like Del Bigtree, much less in what turned out to be a segment lasting over one hour and 45 minutes. There’s a saying about debating cranks that’s applicable: Debating someone like Del Bigtree is like playing chess with a pigeon. The pigeon will knock over the pieces, shit on the board, and then strut and preen as if he had won the match.
I’ll explain in more detail near the end of the post why I have argued over the years that it is almost always a bad idea, a no-win proposition, to debate cranks, but the TL;DR version is because (1) you can’t have an honest scientific debate—or any evidence- and reason-based debate—with bad faith actors like Bigtree, who can distort, Gish gallop (or firehose), and misrepresent data and science to their heart’s content in such a way that even the most skilled disinformation debunkers will be hard pressed to keep up and, more importantly because (2) the crank controls the narrative, which makes it incredibly unlikely that you will persuade anyone in the audience and, worse, you will be used as a propaganda tool by the host to demonstrate that his positions are worthy of being heard on the same platform as him, side by side. Also, no matter how much you might have science, evidence, and facts on your side, in a televised debate format like this it often doesn’t matter. Again, the science advocate is the foil that the propagandist uses to spin his propaganda. This is not a real debate, and it is the incredibly rare person who can go “into the lions’ den,” so to speak, successfully. Such people are so rare, in fact, that their existence does not change my general position that “debates” of this sort are useful only to science-deniers as a means of promoting their message and falsely elevating their status. If you don’t think that NDT’s status didn’t rub off on Bigtree, at least a little bit, because NDT had been willing to appear on his podcast, think again.
When the show featuring the “debate” between NDT and Del Bigtree finally hit the web late Thursday, I knew that Bigtree, at least, believed he had accomplished his mission just from the introduction to the segment, in which Bigtree was even more hypercaffeinated and chipper than usual, even saying how “pumped” he was.
So how did this debate come about?
Right at the beginning of last Thursday’s episode of The Highwire, Bigtree related how in January he had seen NDT appear on a podcast with Patrick Bet-David, where the topic of COVID-19 vaccines had come up. Truth be told, I had never heard of Bet-David before—really!—but it was obvious immediately to me that he is an antivaxxer of the libertarian variety, as this Tweet demonstrates:
The point is, the more blind trust you put in your government, the more they’ll use your naïveté to force their agenda on you.
Google “typical vaccine development timeline”.👇🏽 pic.twitter.com/rKfNxU0iLi
— Patrick Bet-David (@patrickbetdavid) December 24, 2022
And, indeed, in the segment featured on Bigtree’s show The Highwire, Bet-David basically ranted about how horrible “mandates” are, what an affront to “freedom” they are, even going so far as to liken them to forcing women to get abortions—a telling analogy. NDT reasonably—but futilely—responded that a woman who undergoes an abortion does not endanger those around her and how it’s “not [just] about you,” but about others and the social contract. It was an argument that was like waving the proverbial cape in front of the bull to Bigtree, as antivaxxers have rejected the idea of any sort of social contract with respect to infectious diseases since, well, long before I started paying attention to them. Indeed, before the pandemic they routinely used to go ballistic over that very same argument whenever it was used to support, for example, measles vaccine mandates in schools—or any school vaccine mandate of any kind, for that matter.
Bigtree also featured NDT saying this to Bet-David, using it as an introduction to how he “challenged” NDT to a “debate” of this sort, after which they could “go have a beer”:
I’m in conversation with you. Let’s call it a debate. We know—you and I know—walking into that room that either I’m right and you’re wrong, you’re right and I’m wrong, or we’re both wrong. We know that in advance. So we start having the conversation. “Well, what about these data?” “Well what about these data?” Well, I think those data are flawed and here’s why.” “Well, how about this?” Yes, that’s a debate. But you know how that debate ends? It ends where, you know, we need this new dataset to resolve this difference. Now let’s go have a beer.
Then, Bigtree aired his response from January, which was to go on about how he’s “debated” all these people but still was able to remain friendly with them, citing Alan Dershowitz, of all people. After that, he concluded, “Neil, I’m all about getting a beer. Let’s do it. But first I’m asking you to come on The Highwire, and let’s have a real debate.”
I’m afraid I facepalmed here, if only because in most “debates” the participants do not actually “know” ahead of time that one of them is wrong or the other one right. Quite the contrary! In general, unless this is high school debate club-style debate, both participants generally believe that they are right and their opponent wrong—in the case of Del Bigtree, fanatically so! He is so certain that he is correct about vaccines that his antivax views are more akin to a religious “truth”—I use the term because NDT discussed the different kind of “truths,” including religious “truths”—than to a position that he came to through a careful consideration of science. Moreover, there is no new dataset that could ever get Del Bigtree—or anyone like him—to change his mind and decide that vaccines are safe and effective after all. (He produced VAXXED with Andrew Wakefield, who directed it, fer cryin’ out loud!)
Seriously, in February 2020, Bigtree even quote-Tweeted NDT about COVID-19 vaccines, previewing examples of the sorts of disinformation that antivaxxers would weaponize against COVID-19 vaccines—and doing it over nine months before the vaccines were granted emergency use approval by the FDA:
@neiltyson ask us after establishing safety with a placebo trial long enough to rule out severe autoimmune disease and prove it doesn’t cause “original antigenic sin” or “linked epitope suppression” like DTaP that is creating “asymptomatic carriers” who cause pertussis outbreaks. https://t.co/dbkoRZ5Myr
— Del Bigtree (@delbigtree) February 26, 2020
No, seriously. How many times have we heard antivax talking points like this since the vaccines rolled out in December 2020? In fact, as you will see, near the end of the debate Bigtree even trotted out the bit about vaccines supposedly creating asymptomatic carriers! In any event, Bigtree related how he had Tweeted out his challenge to NDT, which apparently got NDT’s attention, and, through a “group of friends,” the two hashed out how the debate would occur. NDT then did the debate on Wednesday when, apparently, he was in town. Bigtree, predictably, crows about how “yes, I do ask some hard questions,” one specifically, “Why are you putting out and executive producing a movie that seeks to put me and people like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. in a bad light?” I can’t speak for NDT, but if it were me, I’d answer simply: Because you are both antivax propagandists, leaders of the antivax movement, who endangered children before the pandemic and now endanger everyone. NDT, of course, was more civil.
I also can’t help but wonder if NDT naively thought that he was going to be able to get antivaxxers to see his documentary, A Shot in the Arm, which features Drs. Anthony Fauci, Paul Offit, and Peter Hotez, as well as vaccine advocates Karen Ernst and Blima Marcus and does indeed feature critical takes on Del Bigtree and RFK, Jr. Maybe he even thought the movie might move some of Bigtree’s audience. Unfortunately, I have not had a chance to see the movie, which has not been released yet and appears to be only available through sponsored screenings by groups. The film has a good pedigree, having been produced and directed by Academy Award nominee Scott Hamilton Kennedy, who had previously produced a documentary about GMOs, Food Evolution, featuring NDT as narrator. I can’t help but wonder if NDT’s involvement with A Shot in the Arm, combined with a naive faith that the way to counter misinformation is to provide good information, led him to be susceptible to Bigtree’s challenge and blandishments. Also, one can’t help but also note that, even though NDT is undoubtedly a brilliant guy, vaccines and infectious disease are not his areas of expertise.
To quote Del Bigtree, though, “But first…”
Context matters
I finished the last section with “but first” because the Bigtree-NDT “debate” is the very last segment in Bigtree’s show. Indeed, The Highwire usually runs around three hours (another reason why I rarely can stand to watch even a significant portion of an episode), and, even though the “debate” runs 1:48, that’s still less than two-thirds of the show’s runtime. Of course, this lengthy amount of time allows Bigtree to set up the “debate” with multiple briefer segments promoting typical antivax propaganda, including a segment about a “wave” of vaccine reactions in Australia, one on how Sweden supposedly had “gotten COVID right” (not exactly), one on how apparently Americans are “souring” on COVID-19 vaccines, and a segment featuring an interview with Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the Surgeon-General in Florida who was a member of the quack group America’s Frontline Doctors that promoted hydroxychloroquine in 2020 and who has since abused his position to claim that children don’t need to be vaccinated against COVID-19 and to promote a highly deceptive anonymous study by the Florida Department of Health that portrays COVID-19 vaccines as more dangerous than COVID-19 in the young. I was, of course, amused at how Dr. Ladapo, who is now an antivax rock star himself, found himself playing second fiddle to NDT on Bigtree’s show. However, it is also alarming at how often an actual doctor in charge of an entire large state’s public health apparatus appears on antivax podcasts. Prepandemic, this is something I never imagined that I’d ever see, but here we are.
What I am getting at here is that, however the debate between Bigtree and NDT were to turn out, Bigtree had expertly set it up with segments promoting antivax disinformation, the key message being that the “consensus” about COVID-19 had been not just wrong but disastrously wrong. (It’s almost as if Bigtree knew that NDT would appeal to scientific consensus a lot, which he, in fact, did!) If I were one to advise NDT (an arrogant dream on my part, I know, but let me run with it for a moment), I would, after advising him not to do it, have advised him that, if he were bound and determined to ignore my advice not to do it, he should at least make sure that the debate was a standalone video, not just part of Bigtree’s weekly three hour podcast. Why? Because context matters, and the context set up by Bigtree was that there is a real debate to be had about vaccines, worse, a debate on antivax terms, complete with antivax propaganda segments with some of the usual characters before NDT’s segment aired. Moreover, unlike Bigtree, who had clearly done his research on the arguments that NDT uses in favor of COVID-19 vaccines, NDT gave no appearance of having done much, if any, homework about the sorts of bogus arguments and conspiracy theories that Del Bigtree routinely employs, other than Bigtree’s tendency to appeal to his own “experts” (the brave maverick quacks who support the sorts of antivax conspiracy theories that he spreads and the more reputable doctors who became “COVID-19 contrarians”).
The debate, such as it was
The segment featuring the “debate” between NDT and Del Bigtree is nearly two hours long, which means that I’m mostly only going to be able to relate my impressions, citing specific quotes and segments that led me to that impression, as transcribing too much would have taken way more time than I had. Even doing just that, this post ended up being considerably longer than even an average Gorski post. (You know what that means.) I will also say that NDT actually did acquit himself about as well as any nonexpert could be expected to, given the gaps in his knowledge. Even so, I found the whole debate frustrating, because, absent those gaps (particularly his lack of detailed background knowledge about specific “brave maverick” doctors and scientists cited by Bigtree), NDT could have been better able to push back more effectively against Bigtree. If you question my impressions, I’m afraid that you’ll have to suffer as I did and watch for yourself. I will, however, point out an interesting thing. There is one five minute excerpt from the debate that antivaxxers are sharing far and wide on social media that I found quite cringey:
Physics was settled science in the late 1800s.
— Mike Iscovitz (@Fox26Mike) April 8, 2023
I included a response to the Tweet because it’s one of the key messages behind all forms of science denial, namely that the scientific consensus exists to shut down dissent and that the cranks will someday be vindicated nonetheless by overcoming the “consensus.” Indeed, the segment starts with Bigtree putting up an image of what he calls “top ranking medical professionals” who were supposedly “silenced”:

Unsurprisingly, three of these doctors (Martin Kulldorff, Jay Bhattacharya, and Sunetra Gupta) were the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), a statement issued in October 2020—before there were COVID-19 vaccines available—at the headquarters of the libertarian “free market” think tank American Institute for Economic Research (AIER). It was a statement that advocated a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic, with a poorly defined to undefined strategy of “focused protection” for the elderly and those whose chronic medical conditions put them at high risk for serious disease and death from COVID. It was a strategy that, even then, epidemiologists knew wouldn’t work, and since then the rise of SARS-CoV-2 variants like Delta and Omicron able to evade “natural immunity” due to infection with earlier variants has demonstrated conclusively that the “natural herd immunity” advocated by the GBD was never achievable. Since then, Martin Kulldorff served as “scientific advisor” for the Brownstone Institute, the “spiritual child of the GBD,” which pivoted right away to promoting antivaccine disinformation. With Bhattacharya, Kulldorff has also promoted inflammatory messages echoing the “Nuremberg 2.0” retribution that antivaxxers have long wanted with respect to public health officials. While it is true that these three were all respected researchers before the GBD, since then they have aligned themselves definitively on the side of COVID-19 and antivax conspiracy theorists.
Another scientist on the graphic, Dr. John Ioannidis, was indeed considered a titan in medical research before the pandemic. We used to cite him regularly. Unfortunately, since COVID-19, Dr. Ioannidis has become a pathetic shell of his former self, a parody reduced to unironically using the satirical “Kardashian index” to portray signatories of the John Snow Memorandum—which countered the GBD by arguing that “natural herd immunity” is not achievable any time soon, if ever, for COVID-19—as unserious social media celebrities with no real scientific impact where it counts, in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature. (As it turns out, the John Snow signatories were right, and the GBD ones were wrong.)
As for the rest, I laughed. They are all what we sarcastically now call “contrarian” doctors or “medical apostates” with respect to COVID-19 and, increasingly, everything else. Dr. Robert Malone, for example, is now inarguably an antivax conspiracy theorist who started claiming around the time COVID-19 vaccines were being tested to be the true “inventor of mRNA vaccines” and soon after the vaccines were released started showing up at antivax events and roundtables, to the point where he has become indistinguishable from “old school” antivaxxers and was never a “top ranking” medical scientist. Ditto Dr. Paul Marik, who has promoted ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, as well as antivax conspiracy theories. Ditto Geert Vanden Bossche too, who repackaged Andrew Wakefield’s old claim that measles vaccines would select for ever more virulent variants to apply to COVID-19 vaccines. While it is true that he at least shows some discomfort at the rabid antivax fanbase that he’s attracted, he, too, is now indistinguishable from old-school antivaxxers. In brief, while a few of these doctors did indeed have excellent scientific reputations before the pandemic and one (Dr. Ioannidis) was even a superstar, most did not, and all of them have become “contrarians” promoting COVID-19 and/or antivax disinformation to varying degrees.
I will give NDT credit for pointing out how these doctors do not represent the scientific consensus , “titles don’t matter here,” whenever a doctor like that cites his university or training pedigree it’s almost always to give the undeserved appearance of credibility to his declarations that contradict the current scientific consensus. He was correct! I also liked how he pointed out how he could find an astrophysicist who claims to have been visited by aliens, although I would ask: Could he also find one who is a flat earther? That to me is a better astrophysics analogy for these “contrarian doctors” and COVID-19 vaccines. Where NDT also stumbled was in not pressing Bigtree, who bragged that he had had many of these doctors on his show, about how much he pressed them for data. How much did he question their take? (Answer: Not at all, because he used them to promote his antivax message.) I would also have pointed out that Bigtree was full of you know what when he claimed that these people were “censored” and kept from talking to people in Washington. Drs. Bhattacharya and Kulldorff, for instance, had extensive contacts with the Trump administration in 2020 and even got to meet with President Trump in the friggin’ Oval Office during the dark days of that first pandemic summer. Admittedly, NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins did strongly say in an email that the GBD needed to be countered, but no one at the top echelons of the Trump administration listened, while lots of high-ranking officials in the US, the UK, and other countries did listen to the GBD signatories.
All of this led Bigtree to declare:
We had a medical consensus around a product that we knew nothing about and a medical consensus around a virus that they told us they knew nothing about.
Unsurprisingly, Bigtree also portrayed these scientists as being “on the ground,” even though none of the GBD signatories were “on the ground,” nor were Drs. Malone, Ioannidis, Vanden Bossche, or McCullough, and the one who sort of was (Kory) was promoting hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin. In any event, hostility towards the very concept of consensus is, of course, the central message of science deniers, the claim that there is no such thing as a scientific consensus and there can never be a scientific consensus. Indeed, in response to NDT’s appearance on The Highwire, antivax former scientist James Lyons-Weiler falsely attacked NDT’s emphasis on scientific consensus as an argumentum ad populum (which it’s not), using this straw man argument:
If, as deGrasse Tyson claimed, “The individual scientist doesn’t matter”, then Einstein’s singular work should not have been influential.
And if science is determined by consensus (which it’s not), then it’s “game over” once everyone agrees on something? We can lock up all the labs, and go home? We’re done? The best any human civilization will ever achieve is now?
At this point, that’s not just fallacious, it’s hubris.
It is obvious in context that when NDT said that the “individual scientist doesn’t matter” he didn’t mean it the way that James Lyons-Weiler implied. Rather, NDT spent considerable time trying to explain how and when an individual scientist does and doesn’t matter, in particular how hard it is to tell when an individual scientist’s finding that calls the consensus into question is just an outlier or when it might be the first indication of an “emerging truth.” Unfortunately, even though NDT was correct, saying it in such a blunt manner provided the perfect soundbite for antivaxxers to use to claim that “consensus” is nothing more than a tool of The Man to silence dissent, which is exactly what Bigtree did. One way that I like to explain it that I wish NDT had used is to point out that a scientific theory is nothing more than the best existing scientific consensus about a particular area or question in science; e.g., the Theory of Relativity, the Theory of Evolution, etc. Back in the days when I used to write about evolution a lot, this explanation used to serve as a two-fer, too, because it effectively defangs the dismissal of evolution as “just a theory.” Of course, I must point out that most of the scientists cited by Bigtree (e.g., Malone, Vanden Bossche) don’t publish much about COVID-19 in decent journals, and almost none of them have published about COVID-19 vaccines. What they are saying isn’t even based on good evidence that they personally have produced through study and experimentation! To sum it up, denying the very concept of a scientific consensus about anything is same message that climate science denier Michael Crichton promoted when he once said that “work of science has nothing whatever to do with consensus.” He was wrong then as science has everything to do with developing a consensus that, of course, can be challenged with evidence, and Bigtree is wrong now.
Unsurprisingly, just like Lyons-Weiler, Bigtree also tried to claim that all of these brave maverick doctors and scientists actually turned out to be right, because claiming “vindication” now (or predicting future vindication) after their having been “censored” is a powerful message, which is why this clip concludes with Bigtree saying:
…all that being said, in the end, what I am standing for is that there’s no challenge being allowed, that the NIH, when it’s telling us that it’s objectively looking at a virus that they were telling us they don’t know much about, is pushing out top people in their field who were trying to get to the table, who are just saying there’s something you’re not looking at. This, and when you want to talk about a problem of not funding to do that study again, how about not allowing into the room people with great perspectives.
Interestingly, NDT’s response was cut off right there, because the above was the central message that Bigtree had promoted successfully and that NDT unsuccessfully tried to push back against, largely because he doesn’t know the full background of these “brave mavericks.” That is why this five minute segment, less than 5% of the debate, is what antivaxxers are sharing all over social media.
But what about the rest?
The rest of the debate
At the very beginning of the debate segment, Bigtree set up what was to come with a montage of NDT clips from other shows, including, tellingly given the messaging about consensus, an appearance on The Daily Show in which Jon Stewart joked about how he had “destroyed” Pluto as a planet and in which he discussed the scientific method and how rivals might do better experiments that either confirm or refute his results, particularly the part where NDT discusses how science is true whether you believe its findings or not. That being said, the interview (or debate or whatever you want to call it) started out benignly and even to NDT’s initial advantage. That’s because NDT has long excelled at discussing science and the scientific method in general, particularly the idealized version of how science works, and that’s what he did. For example, I like how NDT pointed out that the scientific method, boiled down to its essence, is to do whatever it takes to avoid being fooled into thinking that something is true when it isn’t or that something is not true when it is, which is quite the opposite of how cranks like Bigtree operate. He also pointed out later how it’s really hard for politics to bias the findings of astrophysics compared to some other sciences. While it’s good that NDT understands this, I rather suspect that his position as an astrophysicist might partially blind him to just how much politics can facilitate the denial of medical sciences, be the science vaccines, cancer therapy, or, for that matter any medical intervention.
Even so, I give NDT major props regarding how he answered Bigtree’s introductory question about what NDT wanted people to know about the scientific method. Specifically, NDT correctly described how the human mind is “embarrassingly” unable to deal with probability, after which he discussed how the mathematics of probability and statistics did not develop until more sophisticated branches of mathematics had been developed (e.g., calculus), and asked why? He pointed out how probability is not a natural way for the human mind to think, and he was absolutely right. He pointed out how feelings often trump statistical data and how we are social creatures who respond more strongly to anecdotes than we do to dispassionate data, using the example of how often advertising uses testimonials. He even included an amusing anecdote about how a meeting of physicists in Las Vegas had resulted in the lowest casino take ever for a meeting. (I do wonder if the story is apocryphal.) Then he used this observation to point out how it’s understanding (more specifically, misunderstanding) statistical analyses of probability in science are where human perception gets us into trouble.
This exchange also gave Bigtree an excuse to flatter NDT by praising him for how he had managed to get people to care about scientific findings with emotion, to which NDT also responded well when he pointed out how there’s peril to his using emotion to persuade about simple objective scientific findings about the cosmos has peril in that people react to such language skeptically, assuming that the speaker is just expressing an opinion. He also discussed “personal truths” (mainly religious) and how convincing someone of such “truths” requires an act of persuasion and can result in conflict, sometimes violent. NDT was also correct about “political truth” in the form of propaganda, and how repetition persuades people to believe a statement to be true and the Internet can turbocharge that process. (Ironically, Bigtree is a master of this form of “truth.”) Let me also just point out that I don’t like the use of the word “truth” with respect to science, but I have to go with the terminology that NDT chose to use in this show.
This then led to NDT contrasting these with “objective truth,” which exists outside of what people want to believe, and how the methods of science bring us to these “objective truths.” He pointed out the difference between one scientist’s finding and the consensus, as well as how media celebrates findings that don’t jibe with the consensus, as well as how scientific findings evolve to produce what NDT calls an “emergent truth.” It’s as good a description as any of how scientific consensuses evolve, and it led to NDT trying to describe how one differentiates a one-off finding from a harbinger of an emergent truth, which led to a discussion of Pluto, how it had been discovered, and why its status had been changed from a planet to that of a dwarf planet. NDT also discussed how Newton’s laws (which, as he pointed out, got us to the moon) failed at extreme velocities and accelerations, leading to the Theory of Relativity, a great example of how new theories encompass old theories. In this case, the predictions of the Theory of Relativity collapses to Newton’s laws when velocities are so small that the relativistic contribution can be approximated as zero. I could see immediately where Bigtree was going with this, but I wondered as I watched whether NDT did, as Bigtree says that he totally agrees with NDT thus far, “but””…
The “but” is Bigtree’s invocation of bias and the levels of funding needed to do science. In brief, Bigtree tried to portray scientists as being hopelessly biased and in the thrall of their funding sources, as well as susceptible to laudatory news coverage, mentioning that he and NDT agree that there are human beings and egos involved in deciding how to fund science. This led to a discussion in which NDT correctly noted that a scientific consensus is not just an “opinion” or an average of opinions, but rather a summary or average of what scientific data and results are finding. He was also correct regarding how findings at the fringe of the scientific consensus and what is known will, if sufficient evidence arises, become incorporated into the scientific consensus. In other words, a brave maverick scientist can be correct, but he has to prove it.
Here we get to the mouth of Bigtree’s trap, in which he repeated three common quotes beloved of antivaxxers and science deniers. First up was a quote from Richard Horton, longtime editor of The Lancet, who said that most scientific findings are wrong and that science had turned into darkness. (As an aside, this made me cringe, because Horton was editor of The Lancet a quarter of a century ago, when Andrew Wakefield published his bogus and fraudulent case series linking vaccines to autism that launched the modern antivax movement. It then took nearly 13 years and an investigation by journalist Brian Deer to push Horton to retract Wakefield’s study.) Next up is a quote by BMJ editor Richard Smith, who referred to peer review as a “sacred cow” that should be slaughtered. Finally, of course, was the favorite quote of former NEJM editor Marcia Angell’s quote about how it is “no longer possible to believe much of the clinical research that is published.” Predictably, Bigtree then invoked pharma funding and influence on biomedical research.
This is also where NDT started to get into significant trouble. First, he argued that peer review is “broken” in that there is no money to fund studies replicating new findings. This is sort of correct in that doing a straight study attempting to do nothing more than replicate a new finding has never been considered particularly interesting or high priority for funding. It is even true that some scientists have bemoaned a “replication crisis.” (Of note, I have argued that the “replication crisis” is a in actuality problem, not a crisis.) What is perhaps not as necessary in astrophysics, however, as it is in biomedical sciences, is how generally a scientist has to replicate previous results as the first step necessary before he can build on them. In other words, if another scientist wants to explore the implications of another scientist’s result and thereby build on that result, that scientist first has to be able to replicate the result. I’ve discussed this very issue a number of times, in particular a problem replicating the work of a a very famous scientist came up during my early work as a fellow. In brief, we couldn’t replicate Dr. Judah Folkman‘s work on the angiogenesis inhibitors angiostatin and endostatin. Ultimately, we worked it out, with Dr. Folkman’s help. Unfortunately, NDT’s view of “broken peer review” is a simplistic (not simple) version of the real problems with peer review in the biomedical sciences. I would also point out that it is unethical to repeat a randomized clinical trial with a positive result because it would involve knowingly randomizing a group of patients to a treatment that existing evidence has shown to be inferior. Clearly, astrophysicist that he is, NDT is not aware of the concept of clinical equipoise, which is a precondition for any randomized clinical trial to be considered ethical. Similarly, large epidemiological studies are very complex and expensive. It is poor use of resources, not to mention utterly impractical, to repeat such studies just for the sake of repeating them. Ethics is a huge issue in determining which RCTs can be done, something that is not true of most astrophysics.
At this point, Bigtree attacked, invoking the documentary that NDT had executive produced and its fundraising page, which features a picture of him and cites a Hollywood Reporter article about the documentary, using them to claim that the film is biased against him and RFK Jr. Hilariously, he then attacked a massive straw man, claiming that his documentary VAXXED never “proved” that the MMR causes autism (no one I’m aware of ever said that it did), nor was it his intent to do so. According to his telling he showed that there was a “whistleblower” with “ten thousand documents” showing that there had been a coverup of changes in the design of a scientific study that had found no link between the MMR vaccine and autism. None of this is true, as I have explained more times than I can remember. (Search this blog and my not-so-secret other blog for “CDC whistleblower” if you don’t believe me.) If NDT had been familiar with Bigtree’s background, he would have been able to say, “Stop right there!” and refute—or at least strongly push back against—Bigtree’s VAXXED conspiracy theory, also known as the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory, something I’ve been doing since 2014 when it first arose. He didn’t, though, because he didn’t know. All he could do was to demur that he isn’t a physician and doesn’t know enough to comment on the specific allegations. That was a problem, a big problem. If you think you can go into one of these “debates” and prevail, you’d damned well be familiar with the conspiracy theories that your opponent will likely employ, because propagandists like Bigtree will use them against you. NDT failed here.
Similarly, NDT distressingly fell into another of Bigtree’s traps, in which he likened vaccines to a drug like penicillin by pointing out that a small number of people can have deadly reactions to penicillin and therefore will not benefit and that mandates for penicillin would do harm. It’s a bad analogy because penicillin is generally used to treat, not prevent disease. The analogy did allow Bigtree to entice NDT to basically agree with him that would be great if there were a test to see who would be harmed by vaccines, leading Bigtree to suggest that antibody titers indicating “natural immunity” from previous infection might be a good test to determine who doesn’t need vaccines. Bigtree then pivoted to common false antivax claims about the Disneyland measles outbreak, including the false claim that a huge number of cases were due to measles vaccine failure and that 38% of cases were due to the strain of measles used in the MMR vaccine, which was wrong, very wrong. NDT was flummoxed. He shouldn’t have been, given that his film dealt with the Disneyland measles outbreak. But he was. He didn’t know the basics and was apparently unaware of these common false antivax claims.
NDT was somewhat better prepared for the antivax claim that the Pfizer vaccine was never tested for its ability to prevent transmission, which is true but irrelevant given that the endpoint was to determine if it could prevent severe disease and that most vaccines are not initially tested for their ability to prevent transmission. Also, there have been a number of studies since then that showed that the vaccine does prevent transmission, albeit imperfectly. Bigtree also made the blanket claim that “natural immunity” is always superior to vaccine-induced immunity in terms of strength and duration, which utterly flummoxed NDT again, leaving him to weakly say that he is “an astrophysicist,” not a physician. Similarly, he had no good answer to Bigtree’s false claim that the vaccine is “more dangerous to the social contract” because it turns everyone into asymptomatic carriers. Indeed, Bigtree’s rhetoric in this part of the debate was perfect example of how imperfect prevention of transmission equals “the vaccine doesn’t stop transmission at all,” an example of the very failure of understanding probability that NDT emphasized throughout the interview. It was basically concrete, either-or thinking. NDT could have countered by saying that the vaccines are imperfect at preventing transmission, but even partial protection would, on a strictly probabilistic level, still mean that there is benefit to vaccinating as many people as possible.
These failures led Bigtree to be able to rant on and off about how most of the problem is “waning immunity” to vaccines, not to antivaxxers, and how waning immunity is not discussed. (It’s actually discussed extensively, both in the medical literature and the lay press, not to mention how obsessively antivaxxers harp on it.) He cited a Brownstone Institute article on how the infection fatality rate of COVID-19 is so low, as well as John Ioannidis’s studies lowballing the IFR of COVID-19. In doing so, he ignored the number of people who are hospitalized from the virus or become very sick from it, as antivaxxers always do. He claimed that COVID-19 fatality rates are “just the flu,” on which, if he had been better prepared, NDT would have been able to call bullshit, but did not. Instead he said that Bigtree needed to have the conversation with a medical professional, not an astrophysicist.
Cue the five minute segment discussed earlier, which ignored NDT’s response in which he basically said, “Just because an expert does not agree with the consensus does not mean that the expert is correct,” which, I will concede, is an perfectly valid response to Bigtree’s appeal to brave maverick doctors. He also notes that there is no better YouTube clickbait than someone saying “everything scientists thought about this was wrong.” All of this is correct, but not likely to persuade anyone in Bigtree’s audience. Similarly, after a rant by Bigtree about the NIH getting a $400 million “catch up payment” from Moderna for its vaccine, making the NIH hopelessly biased in his view, NDT gets Bigtree to admit that he personally has “skin in the game.” However, instead of hammering home that point, the comment passes so briefly, with Bigtree making the admission as almost an aside, that it leaves no impression. Again, that’s lack of preparation and familiarity with his opponent.
It also left another opening for Bigtree to appeal to shared values with NDT, before suggesting that they should both want a dataset to answer the “concerns” that Bigtree and RFK Jr. have raised about measles vaccines and other vaccines. He also argued that the consensus “ignores” the people who are being “vaccine-injured.” At this point, NDT came so very, very close to doing what needed to be done in that he briefly mocked Bigtree for his “irresistible clickbait” of saying that the entire system is wrong but he (and his small band of contrarians) have The Truth. He should have, at that point, made it explicit that what he was accusing Bigtree of was conspiracy mongering and hammered that point home again and again, instead of falling for yet another of Bigtree’s traps, in which Bigtree asked NDT whether any pharmaceutical product can cause harm. The answer, of course (as Bigtree knew when he asked the question), has to be yes. The question is, of course, what is the risk-benefit ratio for any single pharmaceutical, specifically the vaccines. This led Bigtree to propose a study that we “need” based on “common ground.”
Longtime readers could certainly have predicted what was coming next, namely a call for a “vaccinated/unvaccinated” study, a longtime demand of the antivaccine movement going back at least two decades. This time around, Bigtree suggested using the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) database. In response to NDT’s suggestion that if he wanted to do such a study he should submit a proposal, Bigtree claimed that he and RFK Jr. had done so and that the CDC already had its own proposal. According to Bigtree, the CDD said it would never do this study. I must admit that even I was unclear about what Bigtree was talking about here. I think that it could well be this lawsuit, although I am not sure. Let’s just put it this way. If Bigtree finally managed to bring up a piece of disinformation with which I’m not familiar, imagine how bad the situation was for NDT in real time.
[Note added after publication: A commenter has informed me that most likely Bigtree is referring to the time in 2017 when he and RFK Jr. met with NIH Director Francis Collins to demand a “vaccinated/unvaccinated” study. I note that RFK Jr.’s article and letter about it is, as is typical for him, full of distortions. In it, RFK Jr. tries to argue that the NIH concern that there weren’t enough unvaccinated children in the VSD was invalid without providing actual statistical justification to make that claim while referencing a 2013 study that actually justified the NIH concern that healthcare seeking behavior is very different among the unvaccinated compared to those who vaccinate according to the CDC recommended schedule. Particularly amusing to me was RFK Jr.’s claim that the VSD is not readily available to outside researchers. It is, but you have to follow the rules, among which is that you must have a protocol that has been approved by a valid institutional board (IRB). Also, the CDC is cautious after the notorious incident when antivax “researchers” Mark and David Geier were clueless about SAS and stymied by a command line interface and then later tried to merge databases from the VSD in a manner that could have compromised patient confidentiality and that violated their IRB approval. Let’s just say that I figured it was probably something like this, and the rest of the article is full of common antivax tropes of the time.]
In any event, NDT, most likely correctly, inferred based on what Bigtree said that the reason for the CDC’s declining to do the requested study was that there were probably confounding factors among the unvaccinated that they hadn’t figured out how to account for. Here’s where NDT came the closest to actually saying that Bigtree is a conspiracy monger by suggesting that either the study authors couldn’t convince some peer reviewers or that some “diabolical force” is keeping it from happening, that Bigtree was claiming a “coverup.” I suspect that NDT was getting tired at this point and had started to realize the mistake that he had made when he had agreed to this debate. Unfortunately, we could have used a lot more of this sort of bluntness and calling out of conspiracy mongering earlier in the debate. It was, once again, too little too late.
Overall, Bigtree consistently got away during the entire interview with portraying himself (and the brave maverick scientists) as just someone who is just “trying to bring balance” to the discussion of vaccines and COVID-19 and provide information and “great viewpoints” from his “experts” that are being “suppressed,” “censored,” and “canceled.” The best he could do was to point out Bigtree’s bias, which led Bigtree to magnanimously concede that “we all have biases.” Left unsaid was the obvious conclusion that there is a huge difference between the magnitude and types of biases exhibited by the Del Bigtrees of the world compared to the magnitude and types of biases exhibited by the NDTs of the world. In fairness, NDT did make reasonable points about how messaging about vaccines should include statistics and measures of uncertainty. Of course, what he did not appear to understand is how people like Bigtree are all about magnifying uncertainty to the point where nothing can be knowable and their conspiracy theories are credible. They always spin statistics and probabilities to make vaccines look as bad as they can. If you’re not prepared to deal with that, you will not be very effective countering antivax propaganda. Unfortunately, overall NDT’s record in this debate was highly mixed.
Why debates like this are a bad idea
On the one hand, I don’t want to be too hard on NDT. He did probably acquit himself better than I had feared. On the other hand, he misses the entire meta-context, namely that his appearance on the show of a science denier and outright conspiracy theorist like Del Bigtree, whom I’ve been writing about since I first encountered him in 2016. Surely NDT must have known this, having executive produced a movie in which Bigtree featured prominently. He must have or should have known that Bigtree is a skilled sophist and propagandist. Maybe he did, but if he did he sure seemed unprepared for Bigtree’s Gish galloping, flattery, conspiracy theories (other than in generalities), and misrepresentations.
At the very end, Bigtree suggested—surprise!—a live public debate between three scientists on the “provaccine side” and three scientists on the “vaccine skeptic” antivaccine side moderated by NDT, a nice bit of extra flattery there in that Bigtree preceded this proposal by saying he couldn’t imagine a better person to moderate such a debate. I will also give NDT credit for answering by saying that Bigtree or his brave maverick scientists should write up a proposal for a research project whose results would “make you happy,” to write up a list of experiments and studies that he would like to see. In fact, I’d go one step beyond NDT and suggest that Bigtree and his cronies not just write up study proposals for studies that he thinks should be done, but to post them on his website so that real scientists, clinical trialists, epidemiologists, vaccinologists, autism experts, and infectious disease doctors could evaluate it. (I predict that he won’t do this.) It depressed me that this sort of pushback from NDT had to wait until near the very end of the debate. Ditto NDT asking Bigtree if there is a threshold for lethality from a virus that would lead him to support vaccine mandates, a question that Bigtree danced around by saying he would be “open to that conversation.” Unfortunately, when Bigtree claimed again that COVID-19 lethality is “right in line with the flu” NDT didn’t know enough to respond, “Bullshit!” Because bullshit that claim is.
In conclusion, I will say again that it is not always a bad idea for a science advocate to agree to a debate like the sort in the “challenges” by Dr. Oz and Steve Kirsch. After all, Steve Novella showed me how it’s done back in 2012 when he accepted a challenge of convenience to debate Dr. Julian Whitaker about vaccines at FreedomFest in Las Vegas in 2012. (The Amazing Meeting was being held the same weekend in Las Vegas so Steve and I were there already.) However, it turns out that Dr. Whitaker was very bad at the deceptive debate techniques that cranks use, but also Dr. Novella was very, very good at anticipating and responding to common antivaccine arguments. Even though Dr. Novella basically mopped the floor with Dr. Whitaker, I still had misgivings. These were the same misgivings that I had when Bill Nye appeared to have wiped the floor with creationist Ken Ham in a debate of science versus pseudoscience with respect to evolution, given that it has been credibly argued that the debate was, in actuality, a disaster for science and a huge win for Ham and creationism. Basically, I view these examples as only possible exceptions that prove the rule that scientists really shouldn’t debate cranks. Unfortunately, NDT’s debate is not another example of such an exception.
Indeed, the main reasons that debating cranks is pointless at best, and counterproductive at worst, are well-known to most regular readers of SBM. This debate revealed a lot of those problems. Even though NDT did fairly well at some points, at other points I was cringing mightily because he clearly didn’t know necessary background information that would have allowed him to push back against Bigtree far more effectively. Common “live public debate” formats favor science deniers because they are not bound by science or even the truth. They are free to Gish gallop to their heart’s content; that is, to “baffle them with a torrent of BS” that includes obscure studies, bad studies, studies that don’t support their points, and even irrelevant information that superficially to nonexperts appears to support their arguments. Unless a scientist or science communicator is not only very skilled at dealing with this technique but also very familiar with the deep well of studies ranging from the highly dubious to the good studies misrepresented by the science denier, it is easy to fall into the trap of trying to swat down each gallop in turn and have no time left to make an argument for science. In fact, NDT fell into a different trap. Specifically, when he didn’t know the background behind a claim made by Bigtree, he would either let that claim slide uncontested, giving the impression that he accepted it as accurate, or he would fall back on the “I’m an astrophysicist, not a physician or medical scientist” gambit, which has the same effect.
I also suspect that NDT fell into a different trap as well, that of excess civility. Most of his missteps were in the first three quarters of the “debate.” It was only near the end, when he was looking a bit tired and more than a little exasperated—just look at his face when Bigtree speculates that the vaccines could be found to be more deadly than the disease—that NDT started actually landing some points and calling Bigtree out as the conspiracy theorist that he is and telling him, in essence, to “put up or shot up” with respect to the sort of data that might convince him that vaccines are safe and effective. Even then, it was too little, too late, and right before the end he had nothing when Bigtree started trotting out misinformation about Sweden and how supposedly the least vaccinated countries (e.g. in Africa) supposedly did much better than the most vaccinated countries and then demur that Bigtree should get a “consensus” doctor on his show to do a “debate.” It saddened me, because Bigtree appears to have succeeded at his stated aim of portraying himself as “not a radical” and not a science denier.
As much as I like and admire NDT, I fear that in this case he screwed up. The old Spider-Man adage goes, “With great power there must also come—great responsibility” (often shortened to, “With great power comes great responsibility”). The same is true of fame, particularly if one uses his fame to promote education and science. NDT is arguably the most famous science communicator in the world. By appearing side-by-side with Bigtree, NDT has allowed one of the most influential antivaxxers in the world weaponize his fame against vaccines and science, and then bring out two beers for him to share with NDT.
And then, immediately after wrapping the segment with NDT, Bigtree added on a plug for facilitated communication for autism, which is still pure quackery. Sadly, this felt very appropriate.

A Phony Invitation for “Discussion and Debate”
Phony calls for “discussion and debate” about vaccinating children create the illusion that discussion and debate hasn’t already occurred.
Jonathan HowardonApril 16, 2023
Link

Not long ago, Dr. Jeffrey S. Flier, the Higginson Professor of Physiology and Medicine, Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor, and Former Dean of the Faculty of Medicine (2007- 2016) posted a provocative Tweet.
Dr. Flier linked to an article by Dr. Vinay Prasad, whose anti-vaccine misinformation has been discussed here many times previously. Dr. Prasad’s article said:
We don’t need to read beyond this to have enough material for robust discussion and debate.
    • First, should the COVID vaccine be part of the routine vaccination schedule for kids? I sure think so. Babies have the highest risk of all children and they don’t arrive with natural immunity. Over 750 children younger than 4-years have died of COVID and many thousands more have been hospitalized, some needing intubation in the ICU. (Dr. Prasad didn’t mention any of these sad facts in his article.) Meanwhile, there is evidence the vaccine is safe and effective for our youngest children. As such, I think all infants should be vaccinated when they are eligible. I think zero children should suffer or die for lack of a COVID vaccine. Does Dr. Flier have a different number that he’d like to defend in a debate?
    • Second, Dr. Prasad claimed that polio and measles are “truly dangerous” for children while COVID is not. It may be true that an individual child with polio or measles is at more risk than a child with COVID, but SARS-CoV-2 is what has been infecting children for the past three years, in case you haven’t noticed. More American children died of COVID many weeks of the pandemic than died of measles and polio combined my entire life. While over 2,000 children have died of COVID, a number that would have been much higher had none been vaccinated, no children died from measles or polio during the pandemic. In fact, measles last killed American children in 1990-1991, when 9 died, and no American children have died of polio in my lifetime. As such, I think that COVID has been more dangerous for children than measles and polio for the past three years. Of course, all three viruses are “truly dangerous” for children, and I believe all children should receive all recommended vaccines. Dr. Flier is welcome to argue the viruses that killed zero children are “truly dangerous” compared to the one that killed 2,000 children and that we should only vaccinate children against the viruses that killed zero children. He said this was “quite reasonable”.
    • Third, Dr. Prasad claims that encouraging the COVID vaccine will decrease uptake in the MMR and polio vaccines. I disagree. I’ve been studying and writing about the anti-vaccine movement long before the pandemic, and I am confident that misinformation about the COVID vaccine will decrease confidence in all vaccines. There’s already data from Florida showing this to be the case. Anti-vaxxers know this as well, and they spot an opportunity. This is why they amplify the words of Dr. Prasad, who said pediatric vaccine advocates were “off their rocker” and indifferent to tragedies of the mentally ill. After all, if these cruel, psychotic doctors can’t be trusted when they recommend the COVID vaccine, how can they be trusted when they suggest other vaccines? Dr. Flier is welcome to argue that the polio/MMR vaccines are in competition with the COVID vaccine and there can only be one winner.
I previously responded to Dr. Flier that I would be happy to discuss and debate these topics with him. In fact, I’d be happy to discuss and debate any aspect of Dr. Prasad’s article he chooses. Nothing in it made the case that it’s safer for babies to contract COVID than get vaccinated. Yet, even though Dr. Flier said we had a “responsibility” to do “discuss and debate” Dr. Prasad’s sophistry, I didn’t hear back from him. If that changes, I will post an update here.
However, if Dr. Flier continues to run away from his own invitation to discuss and debate whether or not unvaccinated babies should be left vulnerable SARS-CoV-2, let’s be clear about what his Tweet actually was- an empty, performative gesture that allowed him to signal he was “heterodox”, which itself spread misinformation in two important ways.
First, Dr. Flier’s Tweet spread the illusion there’s been no discussion and debate about vaccinating children. This is absurd. Many people have been discussing and debating this, even before vaccines were even available for children. I’ve written volumes on this topic. Moreover, just days before Dr. Flier’s Tweet, the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices held one of many public meetings regarding the pediatric COVID vaccine. They discussed. They debated. Either Dr. Flier was totally unaware of this, or he feigned ignorance to convince people that proper discussion and debate hadn’t taken place prior to Dr. Prasad’s article.
Of course, vaccines weren’t authorized for children willy-nilly. There were 6 pediatric RCTs (5 of which have been published in NEJM) involving nearly 25,000 children, and the safety/efficacy of the vaccine has been monitored closely in the real-world ever since in many dozens of studies. If anything, regulators acted with excessive “caution” before authorizing vaccines for children. There was a real price to be paid for leaving so many children vulnerable to the Delta and Omicron variants. We’ll be learning about the consequences of repeated infections in developing children for the rest of our careers.
Second, Dr. Flier’s Tweet misled some readers into thinking there was still genuine scientific disagreement about whether unvaccinated children should get COVID or not. There’s not. Pediatricians from his own medical school have done an excellent job explaining why. Dr. Kristin Moffitt for example, told her readers the basic facts Dr. Prasad aims to obscure. She wrote in November 2021:
While children continue to be much less likely than adults — especially adults 65 and older — to get severely ill from COVID-19, some children do get very sick. Thousands of children 5 to 11 have been hospitalized or need ICU-level support to recover from this infection. Almost 150 children in this age range have died from COVID-19. Additionally, over 5,000 cases of a serious inflammatory condition known as MIS-C that can follow COVID-19 infection have been reported. The majority of cases of MIS-C have occurred in children in this age range.
Unlike Dr. Prasad, Dr. Moffitt also informed her readers that in the randomized-controlled trial of the vaccine for this age group. She write, “Out of 19 documented cases, most had received the placebo shots. Estimates suggest the efficacy rate of the vaccine is 90%”. There are now over 20 studies showing the vaccine has already protected many children from COVID’s worst harms. They all say things like this:
Of the case patients, 180 (40%) were admitted to the ICU, and 127 (29%) required life support; only 2 patients in the ICU had been fully vaccinated. The overall effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine against hospitalization for Covid-19 was 94%. The effectiveness was 98% against ICU admission and 98% against Covid-19 resulting in the receipt of life support. All 7 deaths occurred in patients who were unvaccinated.
Another article from Harvard said:
“I hear parents say, oh, my kid had COVID last year,” said co-senior investigator Adrienne Randolph, HMS professor of anaesthesia and of pediatrics at Boston Children’s. “But we found that antibodies children produced during prior infections don’t neutralize omicron. This means that unvaccinated children are still susceptible to omicron”…
“With the emergence of omicron, vaccination offers children and teens better protection against COVID-19,” said Randolph.
It’s true that anti-vaccine data manipulators like Dr. Joseph Ladapo and the sheltered, contrarian doctors who defend his fraud have confused parents by creating the pretense of widespread disagreement amongst doctors. However pediatricians– the doctors who actually care for sick children- are in near uniform agreement on the matter. Perhaps Dr. Flier should talk with someone like Dr. Moffitt or Dr. Randolph before promoting anti-vaccine misinformation in the future. I’d even go as far as to say it’s his responsibility.

Debating How to Debate Instead of Actually Debating
Every moment spent debating who can say what to whom and how and where they should say it, is time not spent talking about doctors who repeatedly underestimated the virus and successfully campaigned to ensure tens of millions of children and young adults contracted it before they were vaccinated.
Jonathan Howard on July 30, 2022
Link

In a previous essay I discussed the use of tone-policing by contrarian doctors:
Focusing on their critics’ manners, they seek to divert the spotlight from their repeated underestimation of the virus and successful campaign to ensure tens of millions of children and young adults contracted it before they were vaccinated.
I was reminded of diverted spotlights when I saw an article Drs. Vinay Prasad and John Ioannidis titled “Constructive and Obsessive Criticism in Science“. It lamented harassment and scientific bullying with “ad hominem aspects” saying:
Typical behaviors include: repetitive and persistent comments (including sealioning), lengthy commentaries/tweetorials/responses often longer than the original work, strong degree of moralizing, distortion of the underlying work, argumentum ad populum, calls to suspend/censor/retract the work of the author, guilt by association, reputational tarnishing, large gains in followers specifically through attacks, finding and positing sensitive personal information, anonymity or pseudonymity, social media campaigning, and unusual ratio of criticism to pursuit of one’s research agenda.
They wrote that “Ignoring obsessive critics may be the most effective way to cut their blood line.”
The article was widely discussed on social media, and while no one could disagree with its opposition to personal attacks, many people found its message insufferably ironic coming from these particular authors. Dr. David Gorski wrote a detailed explanation of why this was so.
However, I’d like to point out to Drs. Prasad and Ioannidis, that we at SBM have written criticism that is harsh, but free of personal insults and calls to “suspend/censor/retract” any work. We don’t call vaccine-advocates “off their rocker“, nor do we humiliate and demean our critics in medical journals by calculating their Kardashian index.
I am certainly guilty of writing lengthy counters to baseless claims that frontline doctors killed a large number of patients via premature intubation, or filled out death certificates inappropriately. Did I do something wrong? Drs. Prasad and Ioannidis think so. They object to “responses often longer than the original work”. They want critics to be pithy.
Regardless of their length, I hope and believe our critiques at SBM are all about substance and science. That’s what really matters, after all. Here’s a sample of some of our disagreements with these two doctors.
    • Did large numbers of people die with COVID not from COVID? No.
    • Is the death toll inflated because doctors were too quick to intubate people at the pandemic’s start? No.
    • Is the death toll inflated because doctors filled out death certificates inappropriately – even fraudulently? No.
    • Did over 100% of NYC residents contract COVID during its first wave? No.
    • Is there evidence masks impair child language development? No.
    • Is the risk of death “completely negligible” for healthy people under age 65? No.
    • Is the flu as bad as COVID for kids? No.
    • Did the pandemic end in 2020? No. Did this pandemic end this spring? No.
    • Will masks and vaccines lead to the next Hitler? No.
    • Is debunking dangerous medical myths a waste of time? No.
    • Did most hospitals maintain largely empty wards? No.
    • Should doctors have mocked people who wanted a booster before Omicron ripped through the population? No.
    • Did the pandemic kill just 10,000 Americans? No. Did the pandemic kill just 40,000 Americans? No.
    • Will vaccinating children kill elderly people? No.
    • Should children remain unvaccinated because COVID kills more older people or because more children die of suicide? No.
    • Should we let babies get COVID? No.
    • Should every public health measure be studied in a massive randomized-controlled trial in the middle of a raging pandemic? No.
    • Were claims that 20%-60% of adults would be infected “substantially exaggerated”? No
    • Is it appropriate for a senior scientist to discuss the physical appearance of a junior scientist who disagrees with him? No.
    • Are vaccine side-effects worse than death for children? No.
    • Were we overestimating COVID infections by 50-80 fold at the start of the pandemic? No.
    • Is it acceptable to truncate graphs and omit key information to mislead readers? No and no.
There’s no shortage of thoughtful criticisms of Drs. Prasad and Ioannidis. However, to the best of my knowledge, they have mostly pretended this material doesn’t exist. In their latest article, they didn’t point out any errors they felt their critics may have made. This article was all about the form and style of their critics, not about facts and science. Maybe their next collaboration can be a response to any of the dozens of the substantive criticisms of their work. There’s a first time for everything.
Obviously, no one owes us anything. Drs. Prasad and Ioannidis have every right to ignore the “obsessive critics” at SBM. But this neglect appears to be their policy towards all constructive criticism. They rarely, if ever, engage with anyone who is willing to challenge them on their past statements. Despite their professed love for discussion and debate, they seem only willing to be queried by interviewers – often each other – who lavish them with praise, lob softball questions, and let questionable claims go unchallenged. For example, when Dr. Ioannidis said his “original intuition” about our pandemic response “might have been correct”, I would have asked a few follow-up questions about the passage below. Dr. Prasad did not.
But notice how the spotlight has been diverted. Drs. Prasad and Ioannidis want their critics on the defensive, a technique known as DARVO. Suddenly, everyone is debating how to debate, instead of actually debating. And every moment spent debating who can say what to whom and how and where they should say it, is time not spent talking about doctors who repeatedly underestimated the virus and successfully campaigned to ensure tens of millions of children and young adults contracted it before they were vaccinated.
I wonder why Drs. Prasad and Ioannidis don’t want to engage with their critics on these topics?

Loud Silenced Doctors
When the history of this pandemic is written, contrarian doctors divorced from patient care won’t be seen as its principal victims because YouTube removed their video, because someone called them “fringe”, or because someone put up posters reminding them of words they said.
Jonathan Howard on December 19, 2021
Link

A potential point of agreement
Supporters and opponents of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) are unlikely to agree on many things. I hope one area of agreement may be the following: The authors of the GBD are not invisible, muffled mystery men and women. People who pay attention to COVID-19 policy know their names, and we know what they believe.
In fact, these individuals are rather omnipresent figures in the COVID-19 media landscape. They have been on many large podcasts. They have given many TV interviews. They have been interviewed by and written many editorials in large newspapers. They’ve been profiled by The New York Times and Medpage Today. They have a large presence on social media. They have made a truly remarkable number of YouTube videos (Dr. Jay Bahattacharya, Dr. Sunetra Gupta, Dr. Marin Kulldorff), some of which have been seen by millions of people. They have testified before Congress and in courts regarding COVID-19 policy. Some have gained new funding sources or found new employment in right-wing think tanks. They’ve met with and influenced powerful politicians, such as Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. They held a “medical experts roundtable” at President Trump’s White House. Dr. Gupta met with and influenced UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson. Journalists rightly say they’ve become “famous voices” this pandemic.
Like I said, we know who the authors of the GBD are, and we know what they believe. Most importantly, we know how they’ve shaped our COVID-19 response.
“The question is whether the mainstream was right or wrong to try to muzzle them”
With this in mind, let’s consider the following passage from an article by Dr. Peter M. Sandman titled “8 Things US Pandemic Communicators Still Get Wrong.” He wrote:
There have been several patterns of fake consensus vis-à-vis COVID. The most dangerous is shutting up the dissenters, or bashing them so badly that potential followers shy away and they can’t get a fair hearing. The maltreatment of the Great Barrington Declaration authors comes to mind. The question isn’t whether they were right or wrong to oppose last year’s lockdowns; the question is whether the mainstream was right or wrong to try to muzzle them. Wrong, I think. Badly wrong.
This is a curious passage, though one the authors of the GBD would agree with. They’ve been on far-reaching podcasts claiming they’ve been “censored”. They’ve said the same thing on national TV programs. They’ve written editorials in international newspapers claiming they’ve been “muzzled.” They lament attempts to “censor and silence scientists” to their hundreds of thousands of Twitter followers. They even opened an Academy for Science and Freedom at Hillsdale College to counter “the silencing and censoring of scientists“.
This all raises some interesting questions. How can “muzzled” people be so loud? How can “censored” people be so ubiquitous? How have the GBD authors simultaneously been able to influence the country’s most powerful leaders and also been deprived of a “fair hearing”? Aren’t “silenced” people, supposed to be, well, silent? Have we completely abandoned the idea that words have meaning?
It seems the closest these individuals have come to being silenced is when YouTube removed a video of a “roundtable” discussion they had with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. Maybe YouTube, a private company, shouldn’t have done this. It’s likely that removing the video amplified it’s reach (the Streisand effect), something the GBD authors almost certainly know. They certainly spoken about this video’s removal quite often. It seems to be a seminal moment of the pandemic for them, the same way seeing a 23-year-old die very early in the pandemic was for me.
Consider though that this video showed these individuals as they were setting COVID-19 policy for a state with 21.5 million people. Complaining about its removal is kind of like a lottery winner moaning that someone discarded the envelope that delivered his $20 million check. However, with hundreds of thousands of Americans already dead and hundreds of thousands of Americans still to die, it was the fate of this doomed YouTube video that really upset them. In a hissy fit of histrionics, Dr. Scott Atlas, said about this video:
There’s nothing more dangerous than being able to censor what is said in a country, because then you are simply not ever going to even hear the truth. And you are entering into a phase of countries that we used to criticize severely like the USSR, like communist China…I mean, this is almost the end of our civilization if we have this sort of censorship, I’m afraid.
Certainly, Dr. Atlas didn’t give the impression that academic freedom was actually a high priority for him when he threatened to sue his detractors at Stanford University, demanding they retract a letter criticizing him. However, I can’t put it any better than one Twitter commentator who wryly noted,
Criticism is not “silencing”
This lone YouTube video aside, it’s clear that Dr. Sandman and the authors of the GBD are conflating criticism with “silencing”. It’s a reflex for some people with enormous platforms to say they are being personally attacked or silenced when anyone quarrels with their ideas. Dr. Oz recently accused his critics of trying to “cancel me because of my strong conservative values“. Dr. Marty Makary, a ubiquitous media presence (book him yourself for $20,000 – $25,000) and superspreader of misinformation, wrote that “America’s self-anointed virus experts and social-media giants are silencing doctors with contrarian views“. Though it seems she’s been on podcasts and in the national media predicting the end of the pandemic for months on end, Dr. Monica Gandhi similarly lamented “The level of censorship and lack of tolerance for nuanced scientific discourse during this pandemic”.
If these individuals really consider themselves “silenced” this pandemic, does this mean that in their ideal world they would have made even more YouTube videos and been on more podcasts? It boggles the mind.
The Princess, the Pea, and the GBD
The attitude of the authors of the GBD towards criticism reminds me of the fairy tale “The Princess and the Pea“, in which a delicate princess slept poorly because a single pea with placed under a tower of mattresses. Except when it comes to young people dying of COVID-19, these are all very sensitive people.
For example, Dr. Gupta wrote a long article complaining that people used words she disliked when describing her ideas. She said,
Depressingly, our critics have also taken to ridiculing the Great Barrington Declaration as ‘fringe’ and ‘dangerous’.
But ‘fringe’ is a ridiculous word, implying that only mainstream science matters. If that were the case, science would stagnate. And dismissing us as ‘dangerous’ is equally unhelpful, not least because it is an inflammatory, emotional term charged with implications of irresponsibility. When it is hurled around by people with influence, it becomes toxic.
If my goal were to spare Dr. Gupta’s feelings, which substitutes for “fringe” and “dangerous” could I use to describe the notion that mass infection of young people is a desired outcome? I can think of many words, but few of them are more polite than these. After all, according to the CDC’s Covid Data Tracker, just under 6,000 Americans younger than 29 years have died of COVID-19 thus far, including over 1,000 children. Tens of thousands more children were sick enough to be hospitalized, some intubated in the ICU. The vaccine has been proven very effective in preventing these tragedies. “Dangerous” and “fringe” seem like fair words to describe those who encourage young people to contract the virus and oppose vaccinating children against it. However, out of respect for Dr. Gupta feelings, I will try to describe these ideas as “perilous” and “peripheral” from now on.
Similarly, Dr. Bhattacharya recently posted an email sent by NIH director Dr. Francis Collins who noted that the GBD authors had met with leading government officials in the Trump administration and requested a “quick and devastating takedown of its (the GBD) premises”. Dr. Bhattacharya called this a “propaganda attack by my own government“, and instead claimed to want “discussion and engagement”. What form might this discussion take if he feels it’s “a propaganda attack” when a public health official merely contemplates criticizing the premises of the GBD? Like I said, it’s a reflex for some people to say they are being personally attacked or silenced when anyone quarrels with their ideas. It’s almost as if Dr. Bhattacharya doesn’t really want “discussion and engagement” about the premises of the GBD unless his interlocutor is lavishing him with praise.
All of this this hypersensitivity to criticism is especially striking considering that the supposed attempts to “silence” the GBD authors and other COVID-19 contrarians have failed so miserably. It’s gotten to the point where if someone claims they have been “silenced,” I can generally make two predictions about them: 1) they’ve repeatedly underestimated and spread false information about COVID-19, and 2) they have a massive platform to loudly lament having been “silenced.”
Threatened, silenced doctors
There are some important exceptions to this. Dr. Li Wenliang, the Chinese ophthalmologist who bravely warned the world of COVID-19, was punished for speaking about the disease that would soon kill him. Dr. Nancy Messonnier and Dr. Rick Bright were silenced by the Trump administration for accurately stating the risks of COVID-19. In contrast to Dr. Bhattacharya, Dr. Jeffrey Goldhagen, a pediatrician at the University of Florida, was prohibited from testifying in a lawsuit regarding mask mandates in that state. Certainly, there are other people who were silenced, but we don’t know about them because they were actually silenced.
Additionally, the threats against prominent figures like Dr. Peter Hotez are outrageous and unacceptable. These vile behaviors are absolutely attempts to silence people, and a recent Nature survey showed that threats against scientists have become commonplace this pandemic. Countless health officials have quit their jobs because of abuse and harassment. This loss of expertise means we may be less prepared for a pandemic now than we were two years ago. As Dr. Gorski recently wrote about threats against Dr. John Ioannidis:
Let me just preface my comments here by saying quite unequivocally that having experienced harassment, death threats, and the like myself, I will always say that this is not acceptable, no matter how much I might disagree with the person experiencing them, period.
Amen.
However, some of the behavior that has been labeled as “threatening” doesn’t seem to rise to quite this level. For example, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya said that he felt threatened when posters were placed around his campus. These posters showed two images; a tweet sent on 8/1/2021 by Florida Governor Ron DeSantis with Dr. Bhattacharya saying “We protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population” and a graph of the massive spike in deaths in Florida that immediately followed this tweet. According to news reports, Dr. Bhattacharya felt “the poster campaign has been part of a larger attempt to keep him quiet.” At the risk of being accused of trying to silence Dr. Bhattacharya, I reproduced these images below.
Dr. Bhattacharya seems to have an odd relationship with the words of Dr. Bhattacharya. If he feels his own words can be paired with basic facts to silence or threaten him, maybe he should consider the real problem is with his words, not with anyone who shares them. I won’t say you are trying to threaten or silence me if you quote me and amplify my voice.
I think it’s important to share the words of people like Dr. Bhattacharya, and I plan to do this in my next article. I promise my aim is to discuss his thoughts on COVID-19, not to threaten or silence him. Moreover, even if I had this inappropriate goal, who really thinks that I, or anyone else, could actually accomplish it? Did the students who put up these posters really think he would be shamed into silence? If this was their plan, they utterly failed. Indeed, shortly after declaring Florida had protected vulnerable people, Dr. Bhattacharya said:
The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.
Maybe one day Dr. Bhattacharya will heed his own advice and treat COVID-19 as one of 200 diseases that affects people. I am willing to risk being accused of trying to “silence” him by admitting I look forward to that day.
Who is being silenced?
Ironically, all these melodramatic accusations of “silencing” are themselves likely to have a chilling effect on scientific discourse. I can understand why some people are reluctant to criticize the authors of the GDB. When well-funded, powerful professors with massive media exposure liken their critics to censors for the sin of posting their own words, this may frighten and silence anyone who dares to disagree with them in the future. When words like “dangerous” and “fringe” are said to be so “toxic” they stifle “coronavirus debate“, critics may feel the need to walk on eggshells to avoid offending the delicate sensibilities of those they disagree with. When potential criticisms of the premises of the GBD are labeled “propaganda attacks”, critics may decide it’s safer to say nothing. I’ve even seen contrarian doctors with large platforms pre-emptively lament that their hot takes will get them “cancelled” as a means of staving off criticism. After all, who wants to be accused of “censoring”, “harassing”, or “cancelling” someone else? It’s a cute trick.
Even though it’s a trick, it can be effective. A journalist who merely considered writing about doctors she felt had minimized the virus quashed her own article in part because an internet mob accused her of organising a “harassment campaign.” To her detractors, critical reporting equals harassment, and sacrosanct doctors are immune from criticism no matter how many facts they’ve mangled or how many times they declared the pandemic over. In the end, only this journalist was silenced by a “noxious harassment campaign“. Will the folks at the Hillsdale College Academy for Science and Freedom extend an invitation to her to rectify this outrage? I think we know the answer to that. Additionally, histrionic claims of censorship diminish the sacrifice of people like Drs. Wenliang, Messonnier, and Bright who actually paid a steep price for their candor. Acknowledging unpleasant truths sometimes requires bravery.
I hope some other people will be brave enough to acknowledge a few obvious truths. Silenced people are silent, and when the history of this pandemic is written, contrarian doctors divorced from patient care won’t be seen as its principal victims because YouTube removed their video, because someone called them “fringe,” or because someone put up posters reminding them of words they said.
        ◦ Doctors who actually worked with COVID-19 patients know that others suffered much more.

Silent Silenced Doctors
The healthcare workers who died from COVID have been silenced. 
Jonathan Howard on March 14, 2023
Link

In a previous essay titled “Loud Silenced Doctors”, I wrote the following about the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration:
They’ve been on far-reaching podcasts claiming they’ve been “censored”. They’ve said the same thing on national TV programs. They’ve written editorials in international newspapers claiming they’ve been “muzzled.” They lament attempts to “censor and silence scientists” to their hundreds of thousands of Twitter followers. They even opened an Academy for Science and Freedom at Hillsdale College to counter “the silencing and censoring of scientists”
Of course, the three authors of the Great Barrington Declaration haven’t been silenced. Sure YouTube removed one of their many videos, which seemed to be the touchstone moment of the pandemic for them, along with being called “fringe“. But these insults aside, the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration have become celebrities of sorts. They given many interviews. They’ve writing many editorials. They have large social media followings. Their many admirers frequently regret they weren’t given more attention. They’ve testified before Congress and in courts. They’ve advised President Trump and Ron DeSantis. Everyone who follows the pandemic closely knows who they are and what they believe. It takes effort to avoid them.
Moreover, nearly all of their favored pandemic policies have been reality for a long time now. Aside from many millions of children being vaccinated prior to being infected, they got what they wanted.
However, it occurred to me that one group of doctors has been silenced this pandemic. We no longer hear from them at all, and few of us know their names. They are defined by their absence and so we are unaware they are missing. These are doctors- and nurses, pharmacists, and all vital healthcare workers- who died from COVID. It takes effort to notice them.
A memorial to Bellevue Hospital employees who died of COVID’s first wave
I wonder what they would say if they could speak to us today.
What would they say about the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration- who weren’t there on the front lines with them- who now feel too much was done to stop the virus at the start of the pandemic? What would they think about doctors who spread blatant misinformation, always minimizing the risks of COVID? How would they feel about doctors who advised young people not to “live in fear from coronavirus” and mocked those who did? How would they feel about doctors who discouraged vaccination while fetishizing “natural immunity.” How would they feel about doctors who treated rare vaccine side effects as a fate worse than death?
Nearly all healthcare workers killed by COVID would still be alive today if not for the virus. I think I have a good idea what they would say if they could speak to us today. I doubt they would speak too highly of sheltered doctors who extol the Triumph of Natural Immunity, callously forgetting the doctors for whom natural immunity was a death sentence.
Of course, we’ll never know. Silenced doctors are tragically silent.

Supposedly Silenced Scientists and Dr. Rick Bright
Contrarian doctors don’t want discussion and debate. That’s why they ignore silenced scientists like Dr. Rick Bright.
Jonathan Howard on May 5, 2022
Link

Contrarians doctors and supposedly silenced scientists
A common trope by contrarian doctors (CDs) has been to lament the supposed silencing of “heterodox” scientists (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here). The format of this peculiar genre is generally quite predictable. First, one or more supposedly silenced scientists (SSS) are identified, though many CDs are also SSSs. Next, the SSS is praised for courageously bucking the orthodoxy on COVID. The SSS is said to be nuanced and able to recognize trade-offs that elude the myopic fools who feel the virus shouldn’t be allowed to run rampant amongst unvaccinated children and young adults.
Next, critics of the SSS are said to have an inappropriate tone, thus putting these critics on the defensive. The critics are not considered appropriately deferential to the SSS, or they’ve ignored the SSS entirely, depriving them of a massive platform to which they feel entitled. The critics themselves are mocked. CDs have said their critics do nothing but debunk cupping and homeopathy. While this describes no one, debunking rank pseudoscience can be useful. CDs have even mocked their critic’s appearances in scientific publications.
Any substantive criticism of the SSS is ignored entirely. None of that matters here.
The SSSs themselves share two important traits. First, they’ve been wrong about basically everything.
    • They repeatedly underestimated COVID, saying it would only kill a fraction of the number of people who’ve died.
    • They’ve repeatedly declared the pandemic over. They tell everyone else to move on, while they discuss COVID constantly.
    • They repeatedly misstated basic facts, always understating the toll of the virus. In so doing, they have created many enduring myths with significant real-world consequences.
    • They’ve argued against any and all measures to prevent children from getting the virus, including vaccines, masks, and testing. Several SSSs have even encouraged children to get the virus instead of the vaccine, though they bristle at any suggestion they are anything but “pro-vaccine”.
Second, despite their vocal protests, no SSS was silenced. In fact, many have become relatively famous and have left an enormous media footprint. They’ve greatly influenced our pandemic response, and several have advised powerful politicians, including the President of the United States and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. While some have faced utterly unacceptable threats, which we have all decried here at SBM, they mostly had to endure being called “fringe,” and the removal of a Tweet or two. Everyone knows who they are and what they believe. They’ve actually been quite loud.
What these defenses of SSSs are saying in essence is that it doesn’t matter that an influential scientist with a large platform repeatedly declared the pandemic over or convinced powerful politicians that unvaccinated children should contracted COVID. What really matters is that people were indecorous towards the SSS or they did not lavish the SSS with enough attention. Science and facts about the greatest mass death event in American history matter less than proper decorum towards those who helped spread the virus.
Dr. Rick Bright, an actually silenced scientist
While defenses of SSSs are generally ridiculous for these reasons alone, it’s notable that those who fancy themselves advocates for “discussion and debate” haven’t bothered to defend Dr. Rick Bright. As you may remember, Dr. Bright is an immunologist and vaccine researcher who headed the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA) from 2016 to 2020. Early in the pandemic, he filed a whistleblower complaint claiming that the Trump administration “ignored his early warnings about the COVID-19 pandemic and illegally retaliated against him by ousting him from his role and demoting him to a position at the National Institutes of Health”. Likely other scientists learned from his fate and decided to keep quiet. We don’t know about them, because they were actually silenced.
In contrast to the SSSs who told Fox News viewers the pandemic threat was greatly exaggerated and that many people were dying with COVID not of COVID, Dr. Bright was clear-eyed about the danger, warning in May 2020 that:
Our window of opportunity is closing. If we fail to develop a national coordinated response, based in science, I fear the pandemic will get far worse and be prolonged, causing unprecedented illness and fatalities. Without clear planning and implementation of the steps that I and other experts have outlined, 2020 will be darkest winter in modern history.
Dr. Bright, who would sadly lose his own mother to the virus, has continued to be a staunch supporter of basing our response in science and evidence. His priority is to be honest and fair, not to be edgy or to gain paid subscribers to his Substack.
So why haven’t CDs mounted a robust defense of Dr. Bright? I suspect they neglect him entirely because from their vantage point, he has three fatal flaws:
    • His dire predictions were perfectly accurate.
    • He has staunchly advocated for vaccines, including for children, and for other common sense measures to control the virus.
    • He suffered significant consequences for his candor.
As such, Dr. Bright doesn’t fit into the elaborate oppression fantasies of CDs. Had he been wrong about everything and suffered the deletion of a YouTube video, he certainly would have achieved SSS status.
And thus the gimmick becomes clear. CDs don’t really care about scientists who have actually been silenced. Instead, by focusing on their critics’ manners, they seek to divert the spotlight from their repeated underestimation of the virus and successful campaign to ensure tens of millions of children and young adults contracted it before they were vaccinated. Every second talking about manners is time not spent talking about how some children have suffered and how the vaccine can limit these harms. CDs want to maintain an echo chamber where they indulge the illusion they are victims of peons who dare to correct their misinformation, sometimes with impolite language.
They don’t want discussion. They don’t want debate.
They’re welcome to invite Dr. Bright to one of their podcasts to prove me wrong.

I’ve Been Silenced, Censored, and Cancelled. The Reason Why Matters.
When conference organizers told me not to make my talk “political”, they were really saying there were certain people and ideas I wasn’t allowed to criticize. I didn’t get it at the time. I get it now.
Jonathan Howard on June 16, 2024
Link 
Few genres of medical writing are more pathetic than the “I was cancelled” essay, especially because these pitiful pieces are almost always written by loud, famous, influential doctors who never treated a patient with COVID, but instead spread copious misinformation about it. These doctors have been on large podcasts claiming they’ve been “censored”. They’ve said the same thing on national TV programs. They wrote editorials in major newspapers claiming they’ve been “muzzled.” They lament attempts to “censor and silence scientists” to their hundreds of thousands of Twitter followers. They even opened an Academy for Science and Freedom at Hillsdale College to counter “the silencing and censoring of scientists“. These sheltered doctors have based their identity on being “cancelled” and they share their profound grievance at every opportunity. Their attitude seems to be:
Sure, I said flu was worse than COVID and 1,100,000 Americans are now dead, but the real tragedy is YouTube removed one of my videos.
This misdirection technique serves a valuable purpose. It removes the spotlight from the enormous harm caused by medical misinformation and shifts if to the “suffering” of the “cancelled” doctor. It’s exactly like that amazing Lisa Kudrow skit and this bit by Jonathan Stewart.
Of course, any doctor whining about being “cancelled” in 2024 has every reason to be grateful. They made it to 2024. The doctors who have truly been silenced are those who died of COVID. We’ll never hear from them again.
So it is with some trepidation that I submit my entry into the “I was cancelled” category. However, it’s 100% true. I’ve been silenced, censored, and cancelled. I am writing about it not to bemoan my fate, but rather because of what my cancellation reveals about the sad state of our pandemic discourse.
I’m going to be vague about the details because I don’t blame the people who cancelled me, and I don’t want them to receive negative attention. In fact, I sympathize with their predicament. However, I was scheduled to speak about the We Want Them Infected movement and the normalization of anti-vaccine misinformation in medicine at a conference this spring. As SBM readers might predict, nearly every slide was a statement from a pro-infection doctor. However, my collection of accurate quotes was deemed “too political” by the conference hosts and my invitation was rescinded. They did not want to “rock the boat.” “Those who seek controversy will always find it”, I was told.
The conference was sponsored by an on-the-ground vaccine advocacy group in a red state. These are good people doing crucial work with little fanfare and thanks. Unlike the doctors I write about, they did not become famous during the pandemic. They are not social media stars and they didn’t advise presidents and governors. They did not spread blatant misinformation or formulate a disastrous “plan” to infect 200 millions of unvaccinated Americans. Their interest in vaccines is sincere and predates COVID. Most of the talks were on important, but rather vanilla topics, such as best practices regarding the HPV vaccine and vaccine storage/handling. These people are doers not talkers, and I admire them very much.
Yet, they cancelled my talk, noting that a powerful politician in their state was a close ally of a certain presidential candidate who has resumed making threats against vaccines. I don’t think this powerful politician or any outsider actively intervened to disinvite me, though I guess it’s possible. Rather, I think the conference hosts feared my talk might bring unwanted attention to their organization. The fact that I quoted and disagreed with doctors who aimed to infect unvaccinated people under age 70 with a potentially dangerous virus made me toxic. They curated the content of a scientific conference because they didn’t want to incur the wrath of any politician, and many of the the doctors I planned on quoting had connections to several prominent politicians. The conference hosts were scared.
And who can blame them.
Threats and attacks against such organizations peaked during the pandemic, and this vitriol was actively encouraged by several pro-infection doctors I was going to speak about. They compared public health to Nazism, posted threatening pictures of guillotines, likened “Faucism and Fascism“, and worse. This obviously didn’t foster a climate of open scientific discussion, to put it mildly.
Likening public health measures to Nazism isn’t just ahistorical and offensive, it’s dangerous. When prominent doctors tell the public that measures to control a deadly virus might lead to the next Hitler, some people are going to look for signs that this is already happening, and a subset of those will find them. In a world where anti-vaxxers wore yellow stars to symbolize their “persecution”, some people have the potential to be violent and aggressive when they are told Nazism is at their doorstep. Indeed, threats and abuse forced many public health workers to quit during the pandemic. Top public health leaders needed bodyguards, while vaccine-heroes received death threats and were harassed at home. My cancelled talk is nothing compared to what these people went through.
However, I never saw any evidence that pro-infection doctors cared about any of this, and instead they are openly proud of spreading mistrust about the entire concept of public health. Despite their feigned admiration for “open discussion and debate”, I doubt they will rally to my defense. After all, the cancellation of a talk like mine was an entirely predicable consequence of their unyielding push to demonize anyone who pointed out the many flaws, both practical and ethical, in their “plan” to reach herd immunity via the mass infection of unvaccinated youth. The conference hosts didn’t want to be called Nazis.
Dr. Paul Alexander, who said “we want them infected”, joyfully fantasizes about mass executions of vaccine-advocates
The conference hosts were gracious and clearly felt bad about the situation. While I wasn’t happy about their decision- I was really looking forward to speaking- I understood it completely. Their organization is doing difficult but vital work to maintain confidence in vaccines in their state, and the last thing they needed was to have this mission undermined. I would have felt beyond horrible had my talk caused them trouble and made their job harder. I want people to hear what I have to say, but not at the expense of vaccines. My talk wasn’t worth risking their vaccine-outreach.
But why should accurately quoting people be risky at all?
Misinformation doctors were “censored” for spreading absurdities, claiming that a virus that infected 0 American children in the past 45 years was “truly dangerous” compared to a virus that infected nearly every American child, killed 2,000 of them and hospitalized many thousands more, to pick one example amongst many. In contrast, I was censored for simply reporting that doctors spread such absurdities. My entire talk was a collection of quotes. I don’t think a single slide was “political”. Yet, it was deemed potentially dangerous and cancelled.
When the conference hosts told me at the outset not to make my talk “political”, they were really saying there were certain people and certain ideas I wasn’t allowed to criticize. I didn’t get that at the time. I get it now.

Did I Lie About My Conference Invitation? How Bad Faith Engagement Functions As A Distraction and Silencing Technique.
It’s important to honestly and explicitly call out bad faith engagement for what it is and recognize how it functions as a common, but powerful rhetorical device.
Jonathan Howard on June 25, 2024
Link

If you are available and willing, we would love to have you attend and speak to our conference participants
In a recent article titled I’ve Been Silenced, Censored, and Cancelled. The Reason Why Matters, I discussed a cancelled speech of mine. In my article, I wrote that I was scheduled to speak about the We Want Them Infected movement and the normalization of anti-vaccine misinformation in American medicine, however “my invitation was rescinded”. I wrote that because that’s what happened. Here is the invitation I received.
Unfortunately, that invitation was rescinded 2 weeks before the conference. During a phone call, the conference hosts named a prominent politician in their state and said they didn’t want to anger anyone in their orbit. I offered to modify parts of my talk and received the email below, which I accurately reported in my article.
I didn’t feel the need to share these screenshots in my original article. I assumed my readers trusted me not to have made the whole thing up. I was wrong about that.
They presumably did not invite you to speak
Amazingly, a critic of mine acted as if he had secret, inside information about this conference and why I was not speaking at it. He shared his special insights into what really happened. According to my critic, I wasn’t cancelled at all. He said:
I can think of a number of very good reasons why the conference organizers thought your material was not a good fit for such a conference. They presumably did not invite you to speak, since it is not clear what else they could have expected of you.
Had I not been invited to speak, specifically about about the anti-vaccine movement, my entire article would have a sham. My critic implied I was fraud, imposter, charlatan, mountebank, and con artist. “Ho hum. I’ll just say Howard lied about the whole thing”, he said in essence.
Unfortunately, he was not alone in blithely tossing around very serious allegations about events he couldn’t possibly have known anything about. Strangers routinely accused me of fabricating key aspects of my pandemic experience. I’ve been told many times that I “never treated a COVID patient” or that I “never produced any research” on COVID. This is just what happens if you advocate for vaccines. People will lie about you, even if you are a child. It’s a law of nature.
These baseless allegations were just a small subset of the bad faith engagement that permeated our pandemic discourse, though none of this was new. This is exactly how antivaxxers behaved toward those of us who advocated for the HPV and MMR vaccines before the pandemic. We were used to it and had groups where we shared the insults and vitriol we received. The only thing that changed is how pervasive bad faith engagement has become and how it’s become normalized in certain segments of medicine.
Prior SBM articles have discussed other bad faith tactics, namely straw man arguments, tone-trolling, and shill accusations/juvenile insults– a lot of juvenile insults. My critics’ rebuttal to my writing, including many doctors, can be summarized thusly:
Dr. Howard is a money-obsessed, B-list grifter and schmuck who rudely yells at people so he can defend school closures, forcibly vaccinate kids, and lockdown people forever so they can be used as experimental lab rats. Also, no one cares about him, and he has a sad life.
This is the intellectual firepower they brought to the discussion.
What unites these bad faith actors is their total refusal to engage with the substance of what I actually write. That doesn’t matter to them a bit. The studies, data, and evidence I share are entirely irrelevant to them, and so they never respond with data, science, and evidence.
Straw man arguments: The inane thesis of Howard’s book, a turgid lament that had medics/scientists been less complacent, no one would have gotten infected.
Instead of having the integrity to grapple with the content of writing, my critics used straw man arguments to discredit me. Put another way, they lied.
Doctors penned lengthy “reviews” of my book, only to reveal they hadn’t read a page of it. I wouldn’t write a fake review of a book I hadn’t read. My critics did this sort of thing routinely. They tried to associate me with unpopular policies, falsely claiming I defended and advocated for school closures, when all I did was accurately report that overwhelming COVID outbreaks closed schools. My suggestion that parents vaccinate their kids was dishonestly reframed as a demand that kids should be “forced to be vaxxed” without “giving parents some choice in the matter.” Doctors depicted me as a brute who wanted to rip kids from their parents’ arms so they would be vaccinated against their will. This of course, was nothing new.
A pre-pandemic anti-vaxx meme
One doctor criticized my work by saying:
I think it’s wonderfully optimistic to think had it not been for Drs. X, Y, Z everything would have gone swimmingly.
That makes me sounds like an idiot. Maybe someone can ask him where I said that “had it not been for Drs. X, Y, Z everything would have gone swimmingly.” I’d love to hear his answer.
According to another doctor:
The inane thesis of Howard’s book, a turgid lament that had medics/scientists been less complacent, no one would have gotten infected.
That makes me sounds like a moron. Maybe someone can ask him which page of my inane, turgid book said “had medics/scientists been less complacent, no one would have gotten infected.” I’d love to hear his answer.
Another doctor said:
The bigger problem is that lockdowners like Howard (an NYU doctor, I think), think that living your life is an irresponsible act. Sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act. The implication is that unless you comply with his prescription — lockdown with no logical endpoint — you are irresponsible.
Which argument of mine was this doctor refuting? No one knows, and his fans didn’t care, even though it was obvious he didn’t read my book before penning his fake review of it. If this doctor (a Stanford health economist, I think), actually read my book before “refuting” it, he wouldn’t have had to wonder aloud where I work. As people who read my book know, I discussed my experience at Bellevue Hospital during the pandemic. One honest reviewer wrote:
An Associate Professor of Neurology and Psychiatry at New York University and Chief of Neurology at Bellevue Hospital, Howard is a regular contributor to Science Based Medicine and an expert debunker of medical misinformation and intentional disinformation. As important, he was also an active contributor to New York’s frontline response to COVID’s first wave, when up to 800 people citywide died daily of the virus, field hospitals were rapidly assembled, and healthcare workers and frontline responders were nightly cheered for risking infection and death while caring for the gravely ill.
I do my best to fully and accurately quote the people I disagree with, and I always provide links and references so readers can check my work. In contrast, my critics never extend me the same courtesy. They never fully and accurately quote me. However, by putting their words in my mouth, they made me sound like a total moron at best and an authoritarian monster at worst- which was the entire point.
Straw man arguments were bad faith engagement.
Tone trolling: I might suggest you reflect on that for a minute.
Instead of having the integrity to grapple with the content of writing, my critics scolded me for perceived tonal improprieties.
My critics purported to perturbed by unspecified breaches in my decorum- I might suggest you reflect on that for a minute… Tone is important.It is hard to engage when you feel like you’re being yelled at. However, these Very Serious Doctors rebuked me for the express purpose of defending doctors who spread anti-vaccine misinformation and called vaccine-advocates “idiots“, “STUPID“, a “bunch of fools” and “total morons“. My decorum-obsessed critics weren’t bothered by any of that.
Of course, those who fretted mightily about my tone never cared about my content. The substance of what I said was entirely irrelevant. Doctors who declared the pandemic over in 2021 were fine, as were doctors who treated rare vaccine side-effects as a fate worse than death. But my tone!!!– that was worthy of their commentary. In a pandemic where 1,100,000 Americans died, some people just didn’t like my vibes, and they had to let everyone know about it.
Certain accounts were obsessed with me, tagging me daily, desperate for my attention. One anonymous stalker account repeatedly lied about my COVID experience and claimed that literally any criticism I made of certain doctors was a “personal attack“. This account celebrated my speech being cancelled. My critics didn’t object to those who posted threatening pictures of guillotines. However, they objected to me criticizing those who posted threatening pictures of a guillotines. “Wouldn’t even waste my time reading that schlock. Your better than that“, I was told. In other words, advocates of mass infection should be free to post threatening pictures of a guillotines undisturbed by the likes of me.
It turns out that “tone is important” for some doctors, not for others. All I did was disagree with doctors who wanted to infect children instead of vaccinate them. Imagine if I routinely called people “idiots“. Imagine if I posted a threatening picture of a guillotine.
Imagine if I did this.
Of course, this entirely selective concern about tone sent messages. The message to people like me was- Be careful. We’ll call you unprofessional, hysterical, or as bad as COVID if you criticize our misinformation-spreading friends. Tone trolling was used to shut down and preemptively discredit unwanted voices and to shield other voices from stringent criticism.
And it was all so transparently phony. Though they claimed to be against cancel culture, none of them cared that my speech was cancelled. It was OK to silence some doctors, I guess. Those who were very concerned about my tone never had my back when the insults flew my way. In fact, they collaborated with people who engaged with me juvenile insults. They were totally silent when people lied about my COVID experience and called me “vile” and “despicable”. This silence sent a message to my most hostile and dishonest critics- fire away.
Tone trolling was bad faith engagement.
Good question. The answer is bad faith engagement.
Shill accusations/juvenile insults: No one cares enough to actually worry about a person like him. But I do feel pity for how sad his life must be.
Instead of having the integrity to grapple with the content of writing, my critics used juvenile insults and shill accusations to discredit me.
Doctors called me “deeply dishonest, unhinged and vile” and dozens of other similar slurs. A scientist who treated 0 COVID patients, said I lacked “domain expertise” and was “unqualified” to discuss the pandemic. I’ve worked at Bellevue Hospital throughout the pandemic, and saw what the virus could do when it was left to spread unchecked. To my critics, most of whom saw 0 COVID patients, this experience left me unqualified to disagree with them when they predicted the pandemic would end in the middle of 2021. My great familiarity with anti-vaccine rhetoric was similarly of no value. I lacked some magical credential- domain expertise– and so the content of what I said could be summarily dismissed.
Another doctor said:
No one cares enough to actually worry about a person like him. But I do feel pity for how sad his life must be and do wish him better days ahead.
My first article here at SBM shared copious data explaining why I disagreed with this doctor about vaccinating children. That’s the feedback I got. As one defender of mine pointed out:
Again this doesn’t address the content of the book or contain any substantive criticism made about the way the subjects of the book have conducted themselves.
The fact that I earned a couple of dollars each time someone bought my book was used as prima facie evidence the entire thing was useless. This was not an argument against my book, but rather against the entire concept of books. My critics called me a “book-selling schmuck” and “B-list grifter“. They said I was just “trying to line his pockets” and “the man clearly doesn’t earn enough wherever he works“. My bibliophobic critics believe writing a book is shameful, but also that a dense tome on the pandemic is a surefire pathway to wealth and fortune. It’s hard to know which of these is more absurd. The charge that I was motivated by money alone was even leveled against me- you can’t indulge someone just trying to make money from selling a book– by a doctor wrote wrote several books himself. This doctor also earns orders of magnitude more money from his Substack, Twitter, and YouTube subscribers. These lucrative income sources never bothered my critics, nor did they care that I have 170 articles here for free.
Shill accusations and juvenile insults were bad faith engagement.
Wait, you’re sending me to a Jonathan Howard essay? I didn’t realize that you were a troll, Debunk.
What really infuriated my critics is that I accurately quoted them and explained why I disagree. That’s it. My writing is devoted to vaccine-advocacy, calling out obvious absurdities, and not forgetting what people actually said early in the pandemic. They find this totally unacceptable. One doctor was even infuriated by an article that extensively quoted him- Wait, you’re sending me to a Jonathan Howard essay?. A compilation of own words deeply offended him.
Hoping to to stave off future critiques, my critics pretend that mere disagreement is “bullying” and “harassment“. Judge for yourself. Doctors who never saw what the virus could do act as if they are the pandemic’s true victims, not those tricked by COVID minimization and anti-vaccine misinformation. They say I am wrong about everything, but can’t be bothered to say exactly why. Only businessman Steve Kirsch even tried. It didn’t go well for him, but at least he made the effort.
My book has made many doctors angry, but not so angry that they were able to write a serious refutation of even a single page. Instead, doctors provided feedback like this:
Hi
@19joho your book “we want them infected” I’m one of the handful of people who bought it,….wow it is really bad. It’s painful to read the words of a self-proclaiming scientist so out of touch with reality who has no idea how out of touch he is.
Were you surprised your book sales have been so poor? Your tweets were getting so much attention, you maybe got fooled given your tweets were artificially throttled up for extra viewing by being pro-government narrative and pro- pharma (they used to get to push that Twitter throttle and de-throttle.).
But sadly for you they can’t throttle up book sales. It is shocking you don’t realize, but most Americans now know they were lied to by our government and scientists like you. They know lockdowns hurt more than they helped, those school closing you supported destroyed our children, as did the worthless masking you supported.
Also most realize the vaccine is worthless at best & are upset, they got fooled into taking it. Your track record for pandemic recommendations has been 100% harmful. I’m sure your book isnt selling. Most Americans have learned better, despite being fed the government propaganda you gladly parroted the last couple of years.
Your book is a going to live in history as testament to the thoughtless and harmful government recommendations scientist’s embarrassing didn’t oppose for fear of losing their jobs and some like your self stupidly supported. You book is being judged poorly today by nearly all Americans (your book sales are the example) but even worse you will be judged more harshly by generations to come.
As now nearly all realize the ideas you promoted were wrong and harmful, yet you could not see this and published a book doubling down on your own hubris…I actually feel bad for you, as I don’t think you realize how silly you look right now.
And yet, that bit of rambling incoherence remains the most thoughtful refutation of my book from a doctor mentioned in it. Anyone is welcome to write a serious review of my book- my actual book- telling me everything I got wrong. Yet, no one has. Why not? I’ve been told many times that I’m wrong, but never exactly what I am wrong about. Notably, my critics refuse to do the one thing that would actually refute me- make the affirmative case too many young people were vaccinated and that the plan to mass infection of unvaccinated young and middle-aged people to reach herd immunity in 3-6 months was a good idea. I’d like to see one of them try, and I mean that seriously. Is anyone willing to argue that the pandemic would have unfolded better had hundreds of millions of unvaccinated Americans contracted COVID simultaneously in 2020? I previously asked my critics to simply to stand up for their own words and they refused.
To be clear, most of the doctors I’ve criticized ignore me. This is not bad faith engagement and this article is not about them. No one owes me their time. However, doctors who wrote lengthy refutations of my book without having read it couldn’t be bothered to engage with anything I actually wrote.
The total absence of good faith engagement was another form of bad faith engagement.
Correction Notice
Of course not all criticism is made in bad faith, and when someone spots an error in my work, I acknowledge it, fix it and thank them. I’m definitely not perfect in this regards, but it’s important to listen to people who disagree in good faith. Unfortunately, the deluge of bad faith engagement often made it impossible to tell who was engaging in good faith. Bad faith engagement muddied the waters and made people feel attacked and untrusting.
My full article is here.
LOOK OVER THERE!
Don’t feel bad for me though. Many others had it much worse. Other doctors needed bodyguards and vaccine heroes like Dr. Peter Hotez were stalked at home by anti-vaxxers. Dr. Gorski was recently smeared by a quack who falsely linked him to pedophile Jeffrey Epstein. Any doctor who publicly rejected the philosophy of mass infection was rewarded with a deluge of bad faith engagement. Countless doctors- especially those from less privileged demographics- could write upsetting summaries of their pandemic experience. Mine was hardly special and not particularly bad.
However, it’s important to honestly and explicitly call out bad faith engagement for what it is and recognize how it functions as a common, but powerful rhetorical device.
First, it is a distraction technique, a way to avoid engaging with the substance of what someone actually says. I wrote about my cancelled talk because I felt it was highly problematic that a scientific conference was curated for overtly political reasons. The person who “presumed” I faked my invitation was trying to distract my readers from this. Those who call me “the worst” do so to distract from the data and studies I presented in my discussion of their pandemic punditry. “Sure I advocated infecting millions of unvaccinated kids, but LOOK OVER THERE“.
Second, bad faith engagement is a silencing technique. As I said, any doctor who publicly rejected the philosophy of mass infection was rewarded with a deluge of bad faith engagement. The same doctor who said I harassed him because I disagreed with him, also repeatedly tried to get my attention on Twitter to call me “deeply dishonest, unhinged and vile” and many other similar slurs. This apparently, was not harassment. The same anonymous account who said Dr. Gorksi and I were “famous for their vicious attacks on scientists” without ever providing a single example, also repeatedly tried to get my attention on Twitter to call me “despicable” and spread blatant lies about my COVID experience. This apparently, was not a vicious attack. To gain insight into this technique, read the article How Narcissists Use DARVO to Avoid Accountability.
DARVO
It’s obvious why many doctors want no part of this. Who wants to be straw-manned and tone-trolled for pushing back against anti-vaccine misinformation? Who wants to disagree with famous doctors when you’ll be accused of “harassment” and often tagged in their Tweets to make sure you’ll be deluged with vitriol from their loyal Twitter followers? When I log in next, there will likely be another batch of immature slurs waiting for me. Had I kept quiet about vaccines and related topics, this wouldn’t be happening. No one would be lying about me- you’ve never treated a COVID patient. But I spoke up and here we are.
Notably, all of the doctors who engaged with me in bad faith on Twitter remain active there. However, many other doctors find Twitter unusable because of the overwhelming bad faith engagement, and I’ve largely stopped criticizing several doctors simply because I grew tired of being called “vile” and “despicable”.
Bad faith engagement wears people down. Bad faith engagement works.
The only winning move is not to play
I also hope someone can learn from my experience. I should have realized it long ago, but I am now convinced the only proper response to bad faith engagement is to expose it and then ignore it. The computer in WarGames was right:
The only winning move is not to play.
And indeed, the pandemic was nothing more than a game for some people, a spectacle. Though I used to take the bait, I’ve learned the hard way there’s no reason to converse with people who are willing to casually say patently dishonest things- they presumably did not invite you to speak… you’ve never treated a COVID patient… you wanted to close schools and forcibly vaccinate kids… you think no one would have gotten infected. These people have revealed themselves for who they are, and by even denying their asinine allegations, one engages with them on their terms, a totally pointless endeavor. If bad faith actors cared about the truth, they wouldn’t lie in the first place. If bad faith actors cared about meaningful discussion, they would be capable of something more than childish insults.
Certainly, none of them altered their behavior when their bad faith was exposed. None of them have ever said to me, “I feel horrible that I accused you of lying about your COVID experience. I am sorry.” Most commonly, they act aggrieved and victimized when anyone calls them out. They accuse me of lying about where I worked during the pandemic and call me a “bully” in the same breath. Imagine that. “I lied about you. You owe me an apology,” they say. That’s how my critics will react to this article. Just watch.
The only winning move is not to play.
Several SBM commentators came to my defense – I always appreciated the many people who did so- but they were sucked into my critic’s vortex of distraction. Instead of discussing the reason my talk was cancelled, which should concern everybody, my defenders were trying to prove that it was cancelled at all. My critic’s baseless accusation- they presumably did not invite you to speak– wasted some people’s time. I don’t want that to happen again.
I too have wasted oodles of precious time trying to convince bad faith actors that I was not lying about some aspect of my pandemic work- it took time to post the invitation I was accused of faking- and that wasted effort is exactly what bad faith actors wants.
I sincerely apologize if I engaged with anyone in bad faith. I also sincerely regret the many times I was sucked into that vortex of distraction. It won’t happen again. I’m done with all that and I can’t recommend it highly enough. As I previously wrote:
Every moment spent debating who can say what to whom and how and where they should say it, is time not spent talking about doctors who repeatedly underestimated the virus and successfully campaigned to ensure tens of millions of children and young adults contracted it before they were vaccinated.
That’s where our focus should be, and I’m perfectly happy to have a good faith discussion about this with anyone, even doctors who disagree with me. Most of them just don’t want to.

The Free Press Is A New Media Company Founded By Bari Weiss And Built On The Ideals That Once Were The Bedrock Of Great Journalism: Honesty, Doggedness, And Fierce Independence
Jonathan HowardonOctober 25, 2024
Link
With their oh-so-controversial opinions, We Want Them Infected (WWTI) doctors became the darlings of the “heterodox” media, where they blended their medical credentials and political beliefs. Though these outlets claim to value diversity of viewpoints and independent thought, they all published the same doctors who said the same things, while refusing to platform anyone who might correct their misinformation.
The Free Press advises its readers to “think for yourself” and describes itself by saying:
The Free Press is a new media company founded by Bari Weiss and built on the ideals that once were the bedrock of great journalism: honesty, doggedness, and fierce independence. We publish investigative stories and provocative commentary about the world as it actually is—with the quality once expected from the legacy press, but the fearlessness of the new.
In reality, the Free Press published “provocative commentary” from misinformation doctors and thus prevented its readers from thinking at all. It produced content like this:
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: The Government Censored Me and Other Scientists. We Fought Back—and Won
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: Free Speech on Trial
    • Dr. Marty Makary: Dr. Fauci’s Legacy
    • Drs. Tracy Høeg and Marty Makary: U.S. Public Health Agencies Aren’t ‘Following the Science,’
    • Dr. Marty Makary: Officials Say, Universities’ Covid Policies Defy Science and Reason,
    • Drs. Vinay Prasad, Stefan Baral, Lucy McBride: Bringing Sanity to the Omicron Chaos, Talking To Three Doctors Who Have Been Islands Of Reason In A Sea Of Confusion.
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: Let Djokovic Play
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: We Have a Tripledemic. Not of Disease, But of Fear,
    • Drs. Vinay Prasad and John Mandrola: The Epidemic of #DiedSuddenly
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: How to Save Science From Covid Politics
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: What RFK Jr. Gets Right—and What He Gets Wrong,
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: Vinay Prasad: Why Was My Talk at a Medical Conference Canceled?
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: Covid Vaccines Shouldn’t Be ‘Routine’ for Kids.
That last article spread fake statistics, claiming that polio, which killed zero American children in my entire life, was dangerous for children while COVID was not. This is what Ms. Weiss called “the world as it actually is.”
When The Herd Takes Off In One Direction, What Do You Do? Unherd Is For People Who Dare To Think For Themselves.
UnHerd, run by British journalist Freddie Sayers, is another publication that encourages people to “think for themselves”. Their motto is:
When the herd takes off in one direction, what do you do? UnHerd is for people who dare to think for themselves.
Apparently, if you disagreed with the mass infection of unvaccinated youth to reach herd immunity, you were incapable of thinking for yourself. However, by platforming WWTI doctors, UnHerd prevented its audience from thinking at all. Here are some examples:
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: Ron Desantis Was The Last Hope Of A Covid Reckoning His Scientific Approach Stood Out From Candidates Of Both Parties
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: What I Discovered At Twitter HQ
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: Boris Johnson Is Still In Denial About Lockdowns The Uk Covid Inquiry Is Shamefully Avoiding The Biggest Lesson Of 2020
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: I Stand by the Great Barrington Declaration
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: Study Into mRNA Vaccine Death Rates Sends ‘Danger Signals’ A New Study Reveals Disparities In All-Cause Mortality Between Mrna And Adenovirus Vaccines
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: New Pfizer Data Kills The Case For Universal Child Covid Vaccines The Real-World Trial In New York Yielded Disappointing Results
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: Why Have Scientists Stopped Taking Risks?
    • Dr. Martin Kulldorff: What Johan Giesecke Missed Out My Fellow Swedish Epidemiologist Forgot To Mention Some Important Points
    • Dr. Martin Kulldorff: Martin Kulldorff: Lessons From Sweden For The Next Pandemic
    • Dr. Martin Kulldorff: Lockdown Sceptic Forced Out Of Harvard
    • Dr. Martin Kulldorff: Fired By Harvard For Getting Covid Right
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: We Need To Talk About The Vaccines
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: Don’t Panic About Unvaccinated Kids
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta:Covid Experts: There Is Another Way
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta: Was I Wrong About The Covid Infection Fatality Rate? I Was Mocked At The Time, But New Data Supports My Thinking
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta: Sunetra Gupta: Covid-19 Is On The Way Out
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta: Sunetra Gupta: Have My Covid Hypotheses Held Up? My Analysis Was Optimistic, But Not Outrageously So
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta: Matt Hancock Is Wrong About Herd Immunity
That last article said:
The development of immunity through natural infection is a common feature of many pathogens, and it is reasonable to assume that Covid-19 does not have any tricks up its sleeve to prevent this from happening.
Persuasion: Determined To Defend Free Speech And Free Inquiry Against All Its Enemies
Persuasion, run by former Atlantic journalist Yasha Mounk, says it is “determined to defend free speech and free inquiry against all its enemies.” In reality, it inhibited free inquiry by promoting several WWTI doctors. In July 2021, it published an interview with “three public health professionals” titled What We Got Wrong (and Right) About COVID-19. It contained familiar poor predictions and pro-infection rhetoric:
    • Dr. Monica Gandhi:I think that the public health emergency is over. And what that means is that hospitals are in no way overwhelmed… Children under 14 years old are threefold less likely to get the virus than adults. If they get exposed, they are one-half as likely as adults to spread it…When there are low case rates in your community, the risk of your unvaccinated child getting COVID-19 is very low, too. Population immunity means children are so much less likely to be exposed to the virus…There’s a principle in infectious disease that if you avoid all infections, what’s called your microbiome—your degree of diversity of how you respond to other pathogens—is decreased, and it’s actually very important to have some exposure to mild pathogens. I personally want to get some colds. So I won’t be wearing a mask unless someone makes me.
    • Dr. Stefan Baral: I agree that it is important, particularly youth with their developing immune systems, to be exposed to different pathogens when they’re young and healthy. It’s amazing that this idea has become controversial, but it has. I similarly am not going to wear a mask unless somebody forces me.
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: I think the worst is over…I hate to say it, but the moment Donald Trump said he was for schools reopening, I think a lot of people turned their brains off, and they opposed it totally to thwart him. And I think that is one of the worst things that has happened.
The Delta variant peaked the next month leading to record death in several states and hospitalizing more children than ever before. The virus also forced schools to close, not just in Democratic bastions but also in Kentucky, Florida, Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, Mississippi, Alabama, South Carolina, Tennessee, Missouri, and West Virginia. According to Dr. Prasad, schools only closed because liberals turned off their brains to “thwart” Trump.
Mr. Mounk wasn’t bothered by the misinformation he had previously presented to his readers, and rather than revisit these doctors’ failed predictions, he published an interview in 2024 titled Vinay Prasad on What Went Wrong With COVID, which quoted him as saying:
Of course, in the United States, we used the power of the police state to enforce lockdowns. And that I think was a bad policy decision that was not in line with prior public health guidance. It was learned from a totalitarian regime.
At least some of the commentators were able to think for themselves, with one person saying:
I can’t understand why, when Prasad repeatedly said there was no justification to close schools because children were not endangered by the virus, Yascha did not point out the obvious fact that schools don’t only have children; they have many adults: teachers, administrators, and other staff. This leads me to the conclusion that this is a fundamentally unserious conversation.
Reason: Free Minds and Free Markets
Reason Magazine is a libertarian magazine whose motto is “Free Minds and Free Markets.” However, Reason inhibited free thinking by publishing misinformation from WWTI doctors. Some examples include:
    • Anthony Fauci, The Man Who Thought He Was Science, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
    • Facing Fauci’s Fury: Q&A With Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
    • Jay Bhattacharya On Covid, Social Media Censorship, And Trump Vs. Biden
    • Why Did Harvard Fire Martin Kulldorff?
    • Were The Lockdowns A Mistake? A Soho Forum Debate With Dr. Marty Makary
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: Stop Trusting The Public Health Establishment
    • How Politics Corrupted Science: Dr. Vinay Prasad On Covid
    • The CDC’s Changing Vaccine Story (Vinay Prasad Analyzes Walensky Statements)
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: The Vaccine Mandates Were Medically Unethical
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: You’re Right Not To Trust Public Health
“Trust is justified based on how an organization or system performs,” Dr. Prasad said in that last interview. “And the truth is, the entire public health apparatus, failed.”
Tablet: A Jewish Magazine About The World
Table Magazine describes itself as “a Jewish magazine about the world.” In reality, it misinformed its readers about the world. Some examples include:
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad: The Cult of Masked Schoolchildren
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad:How the CDC Abandoned Science
    • Dr. Mary Makary: Was the COVID Vaccine Safe for Pregnant Women?
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya: How Stanford Failed the Academic Freedom Test
    • Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff: The COVID Wars
    • By Clayton Fox, about Drs. Martin Kulldorff, Jay Bhattacharya, Marty Makary, Vinay Prasad, and Sunetra Gupta: The Dissidents
    • Drs. Leslie Bienen and Tracy Beth Høeg: The CDC Is Breaking Trust in Childhood Vaccination
Even though COVID killed and hospitalized more American children than all other vaccine-preventable diseases combined, that last article said:
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases
None of these outlets has ever looked back and reflected on how these articles aged. This is how the “heterodox” press, which claims to be about “free thinking” and “diversity of viewpoints”, promoted groupthink and conformity amongst its audience while misinforming them about basic facts and preventing them from thinking for themselves. They have my permission to publish this article if they want to prove me wrong.

Minimizing COVID Via Postmodernism
An exploration of how, under the guise of “reason”, doctors who desperate to be different no matter the evidence have embraced the position that there are no aspects of reality that are objective and that feelings matter more than facts.
Jonathan Howard on July 24, 2022
Link

Postmodernism
According to the Encyclopedia Britannica:
Postmodernists deny that there are aspects of reality that are objective; that there are statements about reality that are objectively true or false; that it is possible to have knowledge of such statements (objective knowledge); that it is possible for human beings to know some things with certainty; and that there are objective, or absolute, moral values. Reality, knowledge, and value are constructed by discourses; hence they can vary with them. This means that the discourse of modern science, when considered apart from the evidential standards internal to it, has no greater purchase on the truth than do alternative perspectives.
A more concise description comes from Moe Szyslak of The Simpsons who said postmodern art is “weird for the sake of weird“, which echoes my previous description of contrarian doctors and their “almost petulant need to be different, no matter the evidence”. This essay will explore how, under the guise of “reason”, doctors, desperate to be different no matter the evidence, have embraced the position that there are no aspects of reality that are objective and that feelings matter more than facts.
The flu versus COVID for children: Part 1
With this in mind, let’s revisit a disagreement I’ve had with several doctors about which disease is worse for children, COVID or the flu.
It is not controversial to say that normal life ended when the pandemic began. Everything but hospitals shut down, and we all started wearing masks. Even though nearly all government-mandated restrictions vanished long ago, many people have yet to resume their pre-pandemic lives. It is further not controversial to argue that human behavior affects the spread of viruses. A lone hermit in the woods will never contract or spread COVID, while fans of crowded, indoor karaoke bars will have encountered the virus many times by now, and likely spread it to many others as well. As such, the only apples-to-apples comparison between the flu and COVID is to examine their impact since the pandemic started.
Moreover, when discussing a virus’s impact on a population, we must consider two factors; how deadly it is and how contagious it is. While a child with COVID has the same very low risk of dying as a child with the flu, COVID is much more contagious, and so it affected more children. Had we allowed COVID to rip through unvaccinated children, as several doctors proposed, it would have harmed many more of them.
The numbers tell an unambiguous story.
Mitigation measures that dented COVID obliterated the flu. During the first year of the pandemic, influenza killed just 1 child. As things opened up, that number predictably rose, and the pediatric flu death toll now stands at 33 since the pandemic’s start. During this time, according to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, COVID has killed over 1,700 children. This ever-growing number would certainly be higher without the vaccine. During one week last year (12/16/21), the American Academy of Pediatrics added 38 children to its grim death tally, more than the flu killed in two years. Even looking at pre-pandemic years, COVID still extracted a higher toll on children than nearly every flu season.
Image credit: Dr. Jeremy Faust
Hospitalization numbers reinforce this point. The CDC reported that the flu hospitalized just 9 children ages 5-11 during the 2020/2021 flu season, while COVID hospitalized 8,300 children that age during this time (slides 14 and 28). Additionally, a recent study of 66 pediatric ICUs found,
The number of children admitted each quarter with a primary diagnosis of COVID-19 or MISC during the first 15 months of the pandemic was twice as high as that for influenza during the 2 years before the pandemic. Influenza outcomes were observed during a time with no unusual public health measures in place (2018 to early 2020), while those of SARS-CoV-2 occurred while masking, social distancing, and remote schooling occurred. Those measures were sufficient to markedly decrease critical illness from many respiratory viruses, including nearly eliminating influenza admissions to these PICUs. Without these measures in place for this largely unvaccinated population, SARS-CoV-2 would likely have led to a number of critically ill children several-fold higher than seen with prepandemic influenza as well as more deaths.
Around 140,000 children have been hospitalized with COVID, and as Noah Louis-Ferdinand explained, this can be very serious for some children. Though dire outcomes remain rare, they should not be glossed over. Moreover, the flu doesn’t cause MIS-C. While it has happily vanished for now, it has affected at least 8,639 children, and most affected children need ICU-level care. 70 children have died of MIS-C. We are still learning about long-COVID in children and we have to be humble about the possibility of long-term sequelae.
Of course, this discussion has zero relevance to vaccinating children. Normal people don’t want any child to suffer or die for lack of a vaccine. We should obviously vaccinate children against both viruses. Still, I looked at the numbers a year ago and concluded “COVID-19 is Deadlier Than the Flu for Children“. Nothing has happened since then to change my mind.
Everything about my belief is surprisingly controversial. Prominent and influential doctors believe the flu is worse than COVID and use this belief to argue against pediatric vaccination.
    • Vinay Prasad (2/4/2021): “It is generally not controversial to argue that SARS-CoV-2 in kids is roughly, roughly the same as influenza, maybe even less severe than influenza, seasonal influenza in kids… it’s far more deadly in older people than it is in younger people…”
    • Jay Bhattacharya (7/21/21): “They are, as you say, Steve, at very low risk for bad outcomes from this virus. Very few healthy, young children died from this virus, more died from the flu last year.”
    • Scott Atlas (9/22/2021): Children “die from the flu at a higher rate” than from COVID
    • Martin Kulldorff (12/17/21): Their Covid mortality risk is miniscule and less than the already low risk from the annual influenza, so the vaccine benefit for healthy children is very small.
    • John P.A. Ioannidis (March 28, 2022): “COVID-19 probably caused substantially fewer deaths in children and adolescents <20 years old (~20,000) versus 3 seasons of typical influenza.”
For reference, when Dr. Prasad made his comment, at least 227 children had died of COVID (slide 31), while one had died of the flu. COVID has been killing many more children than the flu since the start of the pandemic, though these doctors claim the opposite is true.
Against Scientific Gatekeeping: Three areas of agreement
Beyond this shared belief, these five doctors were all favorably mentioned in an article titled “Against Scientific Gatekeeping” by Dr. Jeffrey Singer, which was published at the Orwellian-titled Reason Magazine. His article reveals yet another tool in the vast arsenal available to COVID-minimizing doctors, namely the denial that there are aspects of reality that are objective.
As I often do, I will start with several areas of agreement. First, Dr. Singer stresses that science must be open to new ideas. So long as these ideas are supported by reason and evidence, I agree. As the saying goes, “It pays to keep an open mind, but not so open your brains fall out.” I previously expressed my admiration for Dr. Katalin Karikó, a scientist who toiled anonymously for years because she loved research. Though few saw its value until recently, her work led to the mRNA vaccines. Scientists like her need to be encouraged and supported.
Second, I agree that people who ask “legitimate questions and concerns about the vaccines”, should not be labeled “anti-vaxxers” or “COVID deniers”. Though we need to be on guard against bad-faith JAQing off, I’ve said exactly this, writing:
We need to leave room for people to have good faith disagreements and questions without inappropriately smearing them as “anti-vaxxers”.
Dr. Bhattacharya, for example, was wrong to call Dr. Fauci “the number one anti-vaxxer” because Dr. Fauci wisely didn’t tell people two vaccine doses rendered them permanently invulnerable to COVID.
Third, I agree with Dr. Singer when he said we need not tolerate nonsense. He said,
Openness to unconventional ideas has its limits. We don’t take flat‐earthers seriously. Nor should we lend credence to outlandish claims that COVID-19 vaccines cause infertility, implant people with microchips, or change their DNA.
I don’t think Dr. Singer really believes this though. His central thesis was that these five doctors are brave, heterodox thinkers who have been victims of an intolerant “priesthood” that previously suppressed pioneers such as Ignaz Semmelweis and Edward Jenner. You’ll recognize this bit of sophistry as the Galileo gambit.
According to Dr. Singer, the persecution of brave, maverick doctors continues unabated today at the hands of “an orthodoxy enforced by a priesthood”. As he put it:
Challenges to the priesthoods that claim to represent the “scientific consensus” have made them increasingly intolerant of new ideas… If anyone, expert or otherwise, questions the orthodoxy, they commit heresy. The result is groupthink, which undermines the scientific process.
He was upset that “gatekeepers”:
Dismissed epidemiologists as “fringe” when those specialists dared to question the conventional wisdom.
I’m no philosopher, but that sure sounds like postmodernism to me.
I’m sure Dr. Singer will furiously reject this comparison. But let’s be very clear about what he is saying. He believes that doctors who claim 33 is larger than 1,700 (or 1 is larger than 227) are simply expressing “new ideas” and questioning the “conventional wisdom”. He feels these doctors are many things, but wrong is not one of them.
In contrast, Dr. Singer believes that those who defend the idea that 1,700 is larger than 33 are merely “priests” hunting heretics. According to Dr. Singer, who specifically lambasted SBM and Dr. David Gorski (who responded here), we “undermine the scientific process” by our silly insistence that basic facts still matter. His essay is a wholesale a rejection of the belief “that there are statements about reality that are objectively true or false”. When it comes to doctors with stellar academic credentials, there is no truth, just opinions, and the only people who should be criticized are the “priests” who engage in “groupthink” by claiming that larger numbers are, well, larger.
Of course all cranks talk this way, especially those who claim that COVID vaccines cause infertility, implant people with microchips, and change their DNA. They too feel they are just expressing “new ideas” and questioning the “conventional wisdom”. They too claim to have been “exiled by the medical establishment” for their courage and independent thought. They too bring up Semmelweis, and they are certain history will enshrine them in the pantheon of misunderstood genius. This is such a trite genre.
“The carnage is unspeakable.”
And what exactly does Dr. Singer feel these “priests” are guilty of? Did we at SBM prevent these doctors from influencing politicians or stop them from making YouTube videos? Did we issue thinly veiled threats that people we disagree with should be decapitated? Of course not. Most of us here at SBM are frontline healthcare workers, and we know members of our profession have been harassed and attacked during this pandemic. Violence against healthcare workers horrifies us, and Dr. Gorski and myself have both expressed disgust at threats against Dr. Ioannidis. Other doctors, sheltered from the consequences of their words, get a kick of adding fuel to this fire. Yet, Dr. Singer feels these doctors must be protected from SBM.
You see, we’ve criticized these doctors with words, and Dr. Singer feels we shouldn’t have done this. He was very bothered by one of Dr. Gorski’s articles titled “The Great Barrington Declaration: COVID-19 Deniers Follow the Path Laid Down by Creationists, HIV/AIDS Denialists, and Climate Science Deniers“. Dr. Singer didn’t specify any areas of disagreement or flaws with this article. He just didn’t like the title. That’s it! He was offended on principle that anyone had the audacity to strongly and openly disagree with well-known doctors merely because they wanted unvaccinated children to get COVID. Dr. Singer’s criticism of SBM was literally devoid of content.
And now we learn what these priests guilty of. They are guilty of speaking in a tone that Dr. Singer deems indecorous. (I discussed this deflection technique here.) According to Dr. Singer, Dr. Ioannidis was “pilloried by the medical science priesthood and its supporters in the media”, while Dr. Prasad “was subjected to personal attacks by peers.” Dr. Singer was upset that Ioannidis’ work was called a “black mark” and that NIH Director Francis Collins wanted a published “take down” of the “premises” of the Great Barrington Declaration.
Dr. Singer feels these “premises” are sacrosanct and that famous, contrarian doctors should be immune from strenuous, public criticism no matter what they say. It doesn’t seem to bother him that unvaccinated children have died of COVID or that healthcare workers have been attacked by misinformed patients. Instead, he feels the real tragedy is that doctors who posted pictures of guillotines and advocated exposing unvaccinated children to the virus were called “fringe” by other doctors in a private e-mail. Our words hurt their feelings.
Dr. Singer doesn’t seem to have much respect for the fortitude of the doctors he defends. He is clearly worried about their delicate sensibilities and feels the entire world should be their safe space, where everyone gets a participation trophy. I disagree. Doctors who publicly voice “heterodox” opinions have no right to immunity from “personal attacks by peers”, especially since those supposed “personal attacks” nearly always consist of substantive criticism.
Our disagreements with these doctors are never personal
Of course, our disagreements with these doctors are never personal, and they extend well beyond whether or not the flu is worse than COVID for children.
    • Did large numbers of people die with COVID not from COVID? No.
    • Is the death toll inflated because doctors were too quick to intubate people at the pandemic’s start? No.
    • Is the death toll inflated because doctors filled out death certificates inappropriately – even fraudulently? No.
    • Did over 100% of NYC residents contract COVID during its first wave? No.
    • Do the words “shelter-in-place orders and quarantines” really mean “a rapid seroprevalence study and a focused protection approach”? No.
    • Is the risk of death “completely negligible” for healthy people under age 65? No.
    • Did the pandemic end in 2020? No. Did the pandemic end in 2021? No. Did this pandemic end this spring? No.
    • Did Florida protect “the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population” right before the Delta wave ripped through the state? No.
    • Is amplifying someone’s words silencing them? No.
    • Would “focused protection” have actually worked? No.
    • Will masks and vaccines lead to the next Hitler? No.
    • Did most hospitals maintain largely empty wards? No.
    • Should doctors have mocked people who wanted a booster before Omicron ripped through the population? No.
    • Did the pandemic kill just 10,000 Americans? No. Did the pandemic kill just 40,000 Americans? No. Did the pandemic kill 20,000-40,000 Americans? No.
    • Will vaccinating children kill elderly people? No.
    • Should unvaccinated children get COVID because old people are more vulnerable? No.
    • Should every public health measure be studied in a massive randomized-controlled trial in the middle of a raging pandemic? No.
    • Will children’s “risk of covid will decline precipitously” after “all adults are vaccinated”? No.
    • Should doctors legitimize anti-vaccine conspiracy theorists? No.
    • Were claims that 20%-60% of adults would be infected “substantially exaggerated”? No.
    • Were many frontline healthcare workers fired due to vaccine mandates? No.
    • Is it appropriate for a senior scientist to discuss the physical appearance of a young scientist who disagrees with him? No.
    • Did the US achieve herd immunity 3-6 months after the lockdowns ended? No.
    • Are vaccine side-effects worse than death for children? No.
    • Are frontline healthcare workers the “laptop class”? No.
    • Is it acceptable to truncate graphs and omit key information to mislead readers? No and No.
    • Should doctors spread anti-vaccine myths abroad? No.
Though Dr. Singer’s article was devoid of substantive criticism, that’s not true of our work. Myself and many others have written volumes detailing our disagreements with these doctors. Dr. Singer ignored all of it. He was either ignorant of these criticisms or he purposefully avoided them to spare himself the effort of having refute them. He’s so enamored with his simplistic heroes and villains narrative that he never considers the “priests” may have valid criticisms of the “heretics”. It’s easier to mindlessly throw around juvenile jeers of “groupthink” than do the hard work of trying to understand and engage with one’s critics and their ideas.
“For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.”
As SBM readers know, my articles have detailed how these doctors minimize COVID’s impact on children. In addition to claiming it’s less harmful than the flu, they’ve often portrayed pediatric COVID as beneficial, both for society at large and for individual children. Dr. Ioannidis lamented that children might avoid infection by saying, “School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”. Similarly, in an article titled “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?“, Dr. Prasad wrote that “For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life”. Meanwhile, in the real world, because it was so contagious, Omicron killed and hospitalized more children than ever before.
Given their overtly pro-virus proclivities, it’s no surprise these doctors have repeatedly denigrated the benefits and exaggerated the risks of pediatric vaccination. Several are unabashedly anti-vaccine for young people. In one such article titled “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“, Drs. Kulldorff and Bhattacharya wrote:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
Over 1,000 children have died since that jaw-dropping sentence was written last year, and tens of thousands more have been hospitalized. In this article, they absurdly argued that children should be left vulnerable to COVID since it’s more dangerous for grandma. They said:
While anyone can get infected, the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young.
The vaccine isn’t perfect, but it has proven effective in multiple studies at limiting severe outcomes. Though these doctors have written tomes on pediatric COVID themselves, you’ll generally not learn any positive news about the vaccine from them. Instead, like anti-vaxxers demanding a randomized trial of the entire vaccine schedule, they lament that the vaccine wasn’t studied in impossible, unethical trials of hundreds of thousands of children.
This reveals another of Dr. Singer’s errors. These doctors aren’t expressing “new ideas” at all. Those of us who are familiar the anti-vaccine movement know their sort of blather predates even Edward Jenner. As Dr. Gorski discussed in his article “Everything Old is New Again“, we’ve heard this all many times before. The only thing that’s new is Dr. Singer’s demand that anti-vaccine doctors be spared from criticism.
It didn’t used to be this way. Prior to the pandemic, a doctor who suggested children get the measles and bashed the MMR vaccine would be rightly lumped in with frauds like Dr. Andrew Wakefield. For example, after a doctor fear mongered about a vaccine for a less dangerous virus, the flu, Dr. Prasad appropriately said:
Wow, this quack is the head of an institute of an actual medical center?
Fast forward to 2022, and Dr. Prasad now feels that for a deadlier virus:
Any strong advocate for kid covid vaccination is off their rocker. It really doesn’t matter. The risks are super low.
This is not challenging the “conventional wisdom”. As the pre-pandemic Dr. Prasad would have realized, calling vaccine advocates psychotic and saying “it really doesn’t matter” that some children are severely affected by COVID is anti-vaccine. Only someone who denies “there are objective, or absolute, moral values” could pretend otherwise.
“We want them infected”
Beyond this, Dr. Singer has odd notions of “gatekeepers” and “heretics”. He’s right that we at SBM reflect the medical consensus regarding vaccination. Only a few heretics, with no real-world responsibility for sick children, see the data and are “heterodox” enough to conclude, “Since 33 is larger than 1,700, unvaccinated kids should get COVID “.
In contrast, doctors who actually treat sick children know the virus has devastated some of them. They’re also familiar with the research showing the vaccine can limit these rare harms, and so they want to protect their patients. If Dr. Singer feels we at SBM are “priests”, “gatekeepers”, or whatever because we support pediatricians, we’ll just have to live with his condemnation. I’ll sleep just fine knowing Dr. Prasad thinks I am “off my rocker” because I want zero children to suffer or die for lack of a vaccine.
Though these heretics are a small minority, this does not mean they are not themselves gatekeepers. They’ve had a big megaphone and a lot of influence. These “silenced” doctors helped set COVID policy for the entire country for much of the pandemic. The Trump administration largely embraced their “herd immunity through mass infection” approach. One science adviser there reflected this when he said:
Infants, kids, teens, young people, young adults, middle aged with no conditions etc. have zero to little risk….so we use them to develop herd…we want them infected…
Their desire to get “them infected” continues today in Florida, whose Department of Health is now explicitly anti-vaccine. They’ve also testified in courts and before Congress, where their testimony has been rightly deemed unreliable (here and here). They are routinely published and favorably quoted in the international media, reassuring everyone COVID’s threat is overblown and the pandemic is over. A few have been on Fox News delivering this same message since the start of the pandemic. Several have large social media followings, and they’ve all made a ton of widely-seen YouTube videos. They’ve been everywhere this pandemic- except hospitals.
Not only are they celebrities, their ideas won. Pediatric vaccination rates are abysmal – just 2% of young children have been vaccinated. While this alarms doctors who care for sick children, it’s exactly what these doctors wanted. As pediatric hospitalizations rise to match the peak of the Delta wave last summer, Dr. Singer should congratulate them on their success.
In contrast, my articles supporting pediatric vaccination get read by several thousand people, perhaps, and my requests to speak at their conferences have been ignored. I’ve not advised presidents, and I can’t just call up Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. I doubt Reason Magazine, which claims to be dedicated to “free minds”, will amplify this article, though they have my permission to publish it. Saying this modest website has been a “gatekeeper” for these ubiquitous, powerful doctors is as silly as saying 33 is larger than 1,700.
But what else is Dr. Singer’s article other than a postmodern homage to dangerous silliness? Though he says we need not give “credence to outlandish claims”, he demands we do exactly this. His entire article is dedicated to the premise that “reality, knowledge, and value are constructed by discourses”, and therefore, we must not call outlandish claims outlandish so long as they originate from an “icon of the movement for evidence-based medicine”.
He’s wrong. No one gets a free pass.
We have no obligation to give credence to outlandish claims just because they come highly-credentialed doctors with who have “published and critically reviewed hundreds of medical research papers”. We shouldn’t give credence to outlandish claims that the pandemic ended last year, or the year before that. We shouldn’t give credence to outlandish claims that the key to Magical Herd Immunity Land is to let COVID run rampant in unvaccinated children. We shouldn’t give credence to the outlandish claim that children should remain unvaccinated because older people are at more risk. We shouldn’t give credence to the outlandish claim that it’s beneficial when unvaccinated children contract a virus that has killed 1,700 and hospitalized 140,000 of them. It’s not “groupthink” to argue that children have the right to be protected against a potentially dangerous virus. It’s basic medical ethics, and only someone who treats “reality” as a mental construct could claim otherwise.
The flu versus COVID for children: Part 2
Though I’ve read these doctors’ confident and authoritative statements that the flu is worse for children than COVID, I’ve not seen a detailed defense of this claim, nor have I seen it explained why this belief implies that “COVID was overblown“, as opposed to “We never should have let so many children die of the flu.” Even before the pandemic, I felt it was shameful that we casually accepted so many pediatric flu deaths, especially when an effective vaccine is available.
I think these doctors are just wrong to say the flu is overall worse for children than COVID. I also think they know they have a hard case to make. This is why they never – and I mean never – simply state the number of children who have been killed by each virus since the pandemic again. They have the good sense to know most people believe that a virus that kills 1,700 children is worse than one that kills 33.
I have no problem sharing facts and defending my ideas. That’s why I wrote “COVID-19 is Deadlier Than the Flu for Children” in the first place. However, I don’t think my premises are sacred, and given the suffering I’ve seen, I won’t melt if someone calls me “fringe”. So, I’d really love for one of these doctors to write an article titled “The Flu is Deadlier Than COVID-19 for Children“, as long as it includes these two essential numbers – 33 and 1,700 – and explains why doctors should tolerate even a single unvaccinated child dying from either virus.
Since Dr. Singer thinks it’s wrong to call these doctors wrong, he should write that article. He’s got a start already.

Once a Doctor Has Minimized Literal Death for Young People, Should We Value Their Opinion on Any Topic Less Consequential Than Literal Death?
Is potential death worse than real death?
Jonathan Howard on April 28, 2024
Link

“No, young adults should not live in fear from coronavirus.”
I can’t stop thinking about the essay No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus by Drs. John Mandrola and Andrew Foy, two so-called “medical conservatives”. It was written on December 29th, 2020 in response to a research letter titled All-Cause Excess Mortality and COVID-19–Related Mortality Among US Adults Aged 25-44 Years, March-July 2020, which found that 4,535 COVID deaths were recorded among young adults during the pandemic’s first 5-months.
Many people were sad that 4,535 young people had died from COVID in such a short time, especially considering there had been just 4.49 million confirmed cases of COVID by the end of July 2020.
Full article here
These “medical conservatives”, however, were unperturbed by thousands of dead young people. They castigated those who were concerned, decrying their “fearsome messaging.” “The infection fatality rate for young adults is quite low,” they said reassuringly. They sought to numb their readers by encouraging them to focus on the tens of millions of young adults who hadn’t died of COVID, while ignoring that the vast majority of them had yet to contract it. They wrote:
We offer four reasons why this study and OpEd do not support the claim that young adults should live in fear from the virus…
An excess of 12,000 deaths sounds bad, but Professor Don Boudreaux, from George Mason University, has noted that there are nearly 88 million people in this age group. Thus, the individual risk for a person this age is found by dividing 4,560 (the number dead from COVID19 in this study) by 88 million. This equates to a 0.0052% risk of dying from COVID19.
Of course, anything that kills young people can be made to sound trivial by dividing it by 88 million. The individual risk of dying at all is low for young people.
The authors were very concerned that young people might overestimate their risk of COVID and try too hard to avoid it. They pointed out that “COVID19 deaths in this age group are much less common than opioid overdose deaths” and therefore concluded that “fear of death” was not a valid reason for young people to try to avoid the virus (fallacy of relative privation). They did not consider adverse COVID outcomes other than death, even though serious injuries had been widely-reported in young people since the start of the pandemic.
However, despite knowing that COVID killed 4,535 young adults in just 5-months and that only a relatively small percentage had been infected, these doctors told them their “fear of death” was misplaced. Moreover, they chose to convey this incautious message at the start of the pandemic’s deadliest wave- COVID killed 95,000 Americans in January 2021- and two months earlier, a CDC report found that infections in young people invariably spill out into the wider community. It found:
Younger adults likely contribute to community transmission of COVID-19. Across the southern United States in June 2020, increases in percentage of positive SARS-CoV-2 test results among adults aged 20–39 years preceded increases among those aged ≥60 years by 4–15 days.
On the bright side, vaccination campaigns had started just two weeks before these “medical conservatives” wrote their article. Millions of Americans would be vaccinated over the next few months.
It’s hard to think of a worse time for respected doctors to have told young people they need not “fear” the virus.
“COVID-19 is a leading cause of death in children and young people in the US.”
A lot has happened since then.
The Delta and Omicron variants arrived within a year, and COVID became a leading cause of death for young people. In fact, COVID was the number 1 or 2 killer of young adults age 35-44 for six months in a row, from August 2021 to January 2022. It was the number 2 killer of adults age 25-34 for 5 out of 6 months during that time, and a top 10 killer for people younger than this. In total, around 45,000 people age 44 or younger, many of them unvaccinated, have now died of COVID in the US.
It’s worth remembering there were real lives behind these statistics. The mother of Dr. Adeline Fagan, a 28-year-old doctor who died of COVID, said:
To those who don’t believe, tell them to call me. Because I have pictures of Adeline gasping for air, of being chalk-white, turning blue in the mouth and being hooked up to every possible machine known to mankind. It has wrecked our lives. It has permanently put a hole not only in my heart, my husband’s heart, but our children’s. Her siblings. They will never be the same.
The mother of Michael Lang said:
Eighteen years old and his future ahead of him. That part of it is hard to wrap our brains around — that he won’t be with us any longer.
Michael, who died of COVID-myocarditis, “had no preexisting conditions and had never been in the hospital prior to COVID-19.”
Full article here
Countless other young people survived COVID, but were gravely injured by it. Claire “Clurby” Bridges, a 21-year-old aspiring model, lost both of her legs to COVID. Al Brown, a healthy 31-year-old man needed a heart transplant. Jose Luis Chavez, a 17-year-old, needed a double lung transplant. Lucas Denault, a high-school senior, had his life turned upside down by Long COVID.
Of course, all this was reflects what actually happened. There would have been many more such tragedies had hundreds of millions of young people, none of whom were vaccinated in December 2020, lived with zero fear of COVID, as “medical conservatives” instructed them.
Source: CDC
“Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect.”
Despite COVID becoming a leading killer of young people, these doctors have not updated their article from 2020. As such, we can assume they still feel they were wise to have advised unvaccinated young people not to fear the virus. Presumably, they still feel that COVID’s cumulative toll on this population remains firmly in the category of “things that should not be feared.” 45,000 dead young people, many of whom might still be alive had doctors communicated the importance of getting vaccinated, is not yet high enough to meet their threshold for something anyone should worry about.
Yet, for some inexplicable reason, these doctors- and there are many like them- feel perfectly entitled to pontificate about risks that fall well short of their own threshold of concern. Incredibly, the same doctor who wrote No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus also wrote an error-filled article titled Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect, just 6-months later. He wanted his readers to “respect” the thing that wouldn’t kill them, but not to “fear” the thing that might. He wrote:
Calling myocarditis mild reminds me of the saying about minor surgery. Minor surgery is surgery on someone else; mild myocarditis is something that happens to other folks’ kids. Humans have only one heart; inflaming it at a young age is not a small thing.
But why isn’t it a small thing? I mean really, what’s the worst that could happen- someone might die? Is potential death worse than literal death? Some doctors think so, as long as the vaccine is to blame.
However, it seems to me that once a doctor has minimized literal death for young people, they’ve forfeited their right to be taken seriously when they sanctimoniously demand we “respect” a rare, usually mild vaccine-side effect. Indeed, once a doctor has minimized a disease that killed 45,000 young people and seriously injured many more, they’ve forfeited their right to be taken seriously when they opine on any topic less consequential than this.
Full article here.

A Salesman’s Trick, Ignoring R0, Shaming, Conspiracy, Premature Declaration, Strategic Omission, and Fanciful Fiction
I can’t stop thinking of a recent analysis that estimated over 300,000 Americans might be alive today had all adults been vaccinated. How did we get here?
Jonathan Howard on June 3, 2022
Link

How did we get here?
I can’t stop thinking about a recent analysis that found over 300,000 Americans might be alive today had all adults been vaccinated. Even though I predicted “a deluge of misinformation about the Covid vaccines”, I never thought things would be this bad.
How did we get here?
While much of the blame lies at the feet of the Disinformation Dozen and other traditional anti-vaxxers, many people have been falsely pacified about COVID by credentialed academics who have claimed since the start of the pandemic that the virus was never that big of a deal. My previous articles have examined several techniques these COVID minimizers use to mislead their readers. These include:
    • A salesman’s trick: Using a number that is larger than the COVID death toll to minimize that death toll.
    • Ignoring R0: Focusing on the infection fatality rate of COVID while ignoring how contagious it is.
    • Shaming: Shaming people who try not to get COVID or who are bothered by its death toll.
    • Conspiracy: Claiming the COVID death toll can’t be trusted.
    • Premature declaration: Acting as if the pandemic is over.
    • Strategic omission: Omitting key facts that are needed to understand some aspect of the pandemic.
    • Fanciful fiction: Just making stuff up.
I recently discovered a fascinating paragraph from an article that managed the difficult task of weaving all of these together in a few sentences, though it’s got an even bigger problem I’ll discuss at the end. I think it provides a clue for how things got this bad.
A failed prediction?
With this in mind, let’s meet Dr. Richard M. Salsman an Assistant Research Professor of Political Science at Duke University and a senior fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), which funded the Great Barrington Declaration, a movement dedicated to infecting unvaccinated children with COVID. He’s also a Senior Scholar at The Atlas Society, an organization that amplifies influential dishonest anti-vaxxers while shunning vaccine advocates.
On December 20th, 2020, Dr. Salsman posted an article titled “Yes, Follow the Science – in Every Field“. To bolster his premise COVID was overblown and lockdowns were unnecessary, he wrote the following:
Last March, prior to the imposition of harsh lockdowns, the same New York Times reported that public health policy on Covid-19 was being driven by the work of British epidemiologist Neil Ferguson at Imperial College of London – thereafter to be exposed as a quack. Even assuming masks and social distancing, his team of fifty epidemiologists projected that in 2020 the U.K. would see 510,000 deaths from Covid-19 while the U.S. would suffer 2.2. million.
The facts? The science? How good was the Ferguson prediction? Let us see. So far, deaths have totaled only 65,520 in the U.K. (14% of Ferguson’s projection) and 307,642 in the U.S. (13% of his projection). Not even the global total of Covid-19 deaths has reached 2 million (it is now only 1.65 million, a mere 0.021% of the global population). For those less than 70 years old who get Covid-19, the survival rate is quite high (99.94%). For this, dozens of the world’s major economies have been shuttered…
Yikes. Based on this, Dr. Ferguson certainly does look like a quack, especially considering many governments based their initial pandemic response, including harsh lockdowns, on his dire predictions. Dr. Salsman was unsparing in his criticism of those who he felt overreacted to COVID saying,
The art of deception is practiced by control freaks, charlatans, and groupthinkers.
He concluded that “For such people, crises are to be welcomed, if necessary, even concocted”.
There’s a lot to unpack in these few sentences
It might not seem so at first glance, but there’s a lot to unpack in these few sentences. It’s all there – a salesman’s trick, ignoring R0, shaming, a conspiracy, a premature declaration, a strategic omission, and fanciful fiction – and it’s all designed to make you think COVID is no big deal.
Let start with the salesman’s trick. A savvy salesman who aims to sell you a $40,000 car will first show you one that costs $80,000. He hopes that by comparison, $40,000 won’t sound like a lot of money. Dr. Salsman would make a good car salesman. Notice how he is careful to first introduce you to the possibility of 2.2 million deaths. Only after this horrific number is anchored in your mind does he reveal the actual number. He wants you to look at 307,642 deaths and think, “That’s not so bad. It’s only 13% of 2.2 million. I can’t believe they made such a fuss about nothing.” Dr. Salsman turned Dr. Ferguson’s prediction into a unit of measurement, which is pretty ridiculous when you think about it. He could have easily introduced you to a prediction that only 10,000 people would die. He could have informed you that the real death toll was 3,000% higher than this. But this would make the death toll seem large, and a COVID minimizer wants to avoid this at all costs.
Dr. Salsman is also careful to present only the high survival rate for people under age 70. While I agree this is a vital statistic to understand how a virus impacts a society, we also need know how contagious it is, the R0. Rabies, a deadly virus with a low R0, killed 5 Americans in 2021. In contrast, hundreds of millions of Americans contracted COVID. By ignoring the R0, Dr. Salsman is obscuring that a small percentage of a big number is still a big number. As things stand now, COVID has killed 212,000 people under age 65, including 1,500 children.
Of course, rational people know 307,642 deaths is 307,642 deaths, no matter who predicted what at the pandemic’s start. They also know that 212,000 deaths are 212,000 deaths, no matter the percentage of infected people who die. Normal people think it’s sad that so many people died in such a short time. In contrast, Dr. Salsman thinks that only “control freaks, charlatans, and groupthinkers” would feel such sorrow. If you are bothered by hundreds of thousands of deaths, Dr. Salsman feels there is something wrong with you. You are the type of person who trusts quacks and welcomes COVID. There’s the shaming.
He also suggests that perhaps you “even concocted” the pandemic. There’s the conspiracy. What in the world does he mean that the pandemic was “concocted”? It’s not clear, but he’s obviously winking at the QAnon folks who enjoy movies such as Plandemic: The Hidden Agenda Behind Covid-19. People who believe the pandemic was “concocted” have remained unvaccinated and attacked doctors when the virus inevitably sickened them. They’ve predictably died in droves, some denying the virus’s danger with their last breath. Dr. Salsman didn’t treat any of them.
The premature declaration is obvious. After enumerating the COVID death toll, Dr. Salsman said, “For this, dozens of the world’s major economies have been shuttered.” Dr. Salsman didn’t consider that people would continue to die after his article was published. It also didn’t occur to him that the death toll might have been much worse had no measures been taken against the virus. Homer Simpson displayed a similar lack of imagination when he scolded Marge by saying, “Well, you bought all those smoke alarms, and we haven’t had a single fire.”
Sadly however, the pandemic didn’t end on December 20th, 2020. Many more people died after Dr. Salsman wrote his article than before it, even though it was published as vaccination campaigns were starting. Since then, an unsurprising pattern has emerged. People in some countries are able to visit their elderly relatives in their homes, not at their graves. They realize they took strenuous precautions “for this”.
Next, let’s discuss the strategic omission and fanciful fiction. It turns out there’s something very important Dr. Salsman didn’t tell us. To find out what he left out, we must read Dr. Ferguson’s actual paper, not just the New York Times account. The results section of that paper say:
In the (unlikely) absence of any control measures or spontaneous changes in individual behaviour… we would predict approximately 510,000 deaths in GB and 2.2 million in the US, not accounting for the potential negative effects of health systems being overwhelmed on mortality.
There’s the strategic omission, and it changes everything. Dr. Ferguson’s grave projection was based on the (unlikely) possibility that no one did anything at all, and it didn’t even take into account the possibility that hospitals would be overwhelmed, which of course they would have been. Either Dr. Salsman didn’t know this or he didn’t want you to know this, revealing either the ignorance or deceitfulness that unifies those who’ve found it fun and profitable to minimize COVID.
Given that it was based “unmitigated epidemic”, Dr. Ferguson’s projection didn’t assume “masks and social distancing” as Dr. Salsman claimed. His paper didn’t even mention masks, and it assumed no social distancing. Dr. Salsman just made that stuff up to trick you. There’s the fanciful fiction.
The last problem
I agree with Dr. Salsman that the art of deception is practiced by control freaks, charlatans, and groupthinkers, and his article proves this point well. The distortions it contains are impossible for the average reader to detect. I read the above excerpt from Dr. Salsman’s article many times before I put it all together, and every article I read by sheltered minimizers is riddled with such sophistry. This is what happens when writers start with a conclusion and work backwards to retrofit the “evidence”.
Our pandemic experience would have unfolded the same had Dr. Salsman not penned this particular unscientific homage to science. It was just another drop in the ocean of COVID misinformation. But it explains why millions of people thought COVID was a joke and failed to protect themselves. Smart people with fancy titles told them that scientists who warned of its dangers were quacks.
300,000 people would still be alive had all Americans adults been vaccinated, or as Dr. Salsman would put it, just 13% of Dr. Ferguson’s projection. 700,000 Americans have died since Dr. Salsman wrote his article, or as he would put it, just 32% of Dr. Ferguson’s projection. A million Americans have now died of COVID, and the global death toll now stands officially at 6.3 million, though the real number may be more than double this. Like all such utterances by COVID minimizers, just think how poorly Dr. Salsman’s article aged.
If he disagrees with me, I invite him to write a rebuttal to my essay arguing that a million dead Americans don’t matter because it is still less than 50% of what Dr. Ferguson projected. He can write a companion piece arguing that 12 million global COVID deaths don’t matter because it’s such a small fraction of the global population. I’d honestly love to read these articles.
And this brings us to the last and biggest problem – Dr. Salsman might take me up on my offer. Not everyone agrees that individuals matter. He might actually believe that millions of souls lost to COVID don’t matter because hey, the world’s got a lot of people in it. He’s never seen anyone die of COVID, and he doesn’t seem to care that so many did. This problem is unrelated to facts and science. It’s a problem of values. Even in the (unlikely) scenario that Dr. Salsman’s article had not been riddled with basic factual errors, there’s something jarring about how he speaks of those who died of COVID. Read this again.
So far, deaths have totaled only 65,520 in the U.K. (14% of Ferguson’s projection) and 307,642 in the U.S. (13% of his projection).
Imagine sitting at a laptop, typing that sentence, and attaching your name to it. Who uses the word “only” to describe hundreds of thousands of dead Americans in less than a year’s time?
Someone who is an answer to my question, how did we get here?
That’s who.

Contrarian Doctors: The Pandemic is Over, Again
I can’t help but wonder if one of the reasons the pandemic isn’t over yet, is because contrarian doctors repeatedly said it was.
Jonathan Howard on November 19, 2021
Link

Dr. Hall’s question and my own flawed predictions
Earlier this summer, Dr. Harriet Hall received a “surprising email saying the pandemic has been over for months.” “Where did that idea come from?” she asked. Before I try to answer her question, let me revisit my own history with premature optimism in two prior articles on this site.June 4, 2021:
Barring a nasty variant, the worst is over for America and its children. Cases and deaths are falling. It’s beautiful. Thanks to vaccines and the virus itself, there’s enough immunity that COVID-19 will never overwhelm an American city again… However, COVID-19 is not gone, and it probably never will be. Vaccine uptake remains depressingly low in large swaths of the country. Millions of children have been vaccinated, but most are not and many never will be. COVID-19 remains nearly as dangerous as ever for the unvaccinated.
July 25, 2021:
We will almost certainly never have months in a row where over 1,000 Americans die daily. Again with the caveat that a nasty variant could change everything, I am confident the worst is over for the US as a whole, at least for vaccinated people.
In these articles, I was careful to note that the virus remained as dangerous as ever for the unvaccinated and that new variants could change everything. Still, I was very wrong about some big things. Sadly, over 1,000 people a day have been dying in the USA for a while, and some cities were overwhelmed with COVID-19. Though my own optimistic predictions definitely don’t deserve an A+, I also don’t think anyone reading my articles would have concluded the pandemic was over. I certainly hope no one thought that.
The pandemic is over?
Having acknowledged my own flawed forecasts, let’s explore the origins of the myth that the pandemic is over. In preparation for this article, I put out a Twitter request for instances where people, specifically those with scientific credentials, declared the pandemic was over. I received several replies implicating COVID-19 denialists and minimizers of all sorts from around the world. Since I am an American doctor, I will focus my discussion on my country and my profession.
Clearly, much of blame lies at the feet of the people like Drs. Kelly Brogan and Christiane Northrup, who are part of the Disinformation Dozen and are responsible for a large amount of misinformation this pandemic. These luminaries of the anti-vaccine movement often deny that viruses cause illness to begin with and therefore never acknowledged the pandemic ever started. This was all predictable. However, what I did not anticipate was the steady stream of so-called contrarian doctors with stellar credentials and academic appointments who essentially declared the pandemic over several times already, clearly implied it was over by “just asking questions“, or minimized concerns over variants. A sampling of their statements are below, and I expect readers will share further examples in the comments.
Dr. John Ioannidis
    • April 17, 2020:
Acknowledging for the fact that the epidemic is still evolving, and we cannot be sure whether we will hit even higher peaks in the future, although this doesn’t seem to be the case, at least for the European countries, and it seems to be that even in the US, in most states we’re very close to the peak, if not past the peak, the risk is something that should be manageable as opposed to the panic and horror stories that are circulating about.
    • August 25, 2020:
However, very few hospitals were eventually stressed and only for a couple of weeks. Most hospitals maintained largely empty wards, expecting tsunamis that never came… Tragically, many health systems faced major adverse consequences, not by COVID-19 cases overload, but for very different reasons.
Dr. Marty Makary
    • December 22, 2020:
There’s a false construct out there. There’s a recommendation that we need to get every American immunized in order to get a handle on the pandemic. There reality is that about 25-50% of Americans have already had the infection and have some natural immunity…So we may only need to get an additional 20% of the population immunized by say February or March to really hit those 70% herd immunity levels.
    • February 18, 2021:
At the current trajectory, I expect Covid will be mostly gone by April, allowing Americans to resume normal life.
    • May 4, 2021:
In February, I projected that “based on the current trajectory” we’d see significant population immunity take hold in April from the combination of vaccinated and natural immunity. While most states are now witnessing the strong suppression of the epidemic today, other states will get there in May. But herd immunity is not a finish line. In that article, I maintained that “coronavirus will be here for decades to come.” The question is, at what point is it no longer a major public-health threat? For most states, it’s now.
    • May 21, 2021:
COVID cases are collapsing in front of our eyes… Projections for the coming weeks and months are even more favorable. That’s because roughly 80% to 85% of adults are now immune — more than 6 in 10 adults are now vaccinated and more than half of unvaccinated adults have natural immunity from prior infection. In public health, when a virus has trouble jumping around because more than 8 in 10 adults in a community are blocking its transmission, we call that herd immunity.
    • June 8, 2021:
With more than 8 in 10 adults protected from either contracting or transmitting the virus, it can’t readily propagate by jumping around in the population. In public health, we call that herd immunity, defined broadly on the Johns Hopkins Covid information webpage as “when most of a population is immune.” It’s not eradication, but it’s powerful.
    • June 8, 2021:
There’s a lot of good news out there, and I think that people need to hear that good news right now. People have an entirely distorted perception of risk. (People) need to be careful if they’re unvaccinated and not had the infection, but we need to move on at some point.
Dr. John Mandrola
    • May 1, 2020:
I recoil against the idea that moderation of distancing measures in places in the US and Sweden is akin to human sacrifice. That sort of hyperbole and fear-mongering in medicine always leads to bad decisions. Also, no US hospital is now unprepared. It’s May, not March 9.
    • March 10, 2021:
The pandemic is essentially done. Human life has to be more than avoiding one pathogen. Millions have natural immunity. The pandemic (of bad disease) is nearly over.
    • March 11, 2021:
I wish I had wrote “almost done here in the US.” Frustration with fear-mongering got the best of me.
    • June 11, 2021:
It appears to me that we have crushed COVID by simply vaccinating susceptible adults. Why not wait for more data before extending these novel therapies to young people?
    • July 29, 2021:
If you were vaccinated and had mild to moderate URI symptoms, why on earth would you get a COVID test? Have the vaccines not transformed SARSCOV2 into just another regular respiratory virus?
Dr. Monica Gandhi
    • February 22, 2021:
I started in April, 2020 and I hope I can stop it in April, 2021. I think that may be a little soon, but we will get to herd immunity and it will all fall away. It will all fall away. All this anguish, all this yelling at each other, all this politicization, all this depression, it will fall away.
    • February 23, 2021:
Interviewer question, “Do you believe we’re truly near the end?” Dr. Gandhi, “Yes. I truly believe we’re panicking way too much about the variants.”
    • March 4, 2021:
I genuinely with all my heart apologize for anyone who continues to try to scare you about variants; we have been through so much already. This is not like coming down from another surge; this time we have the increasing protection from vaccines as cases/hospitalizations drop. Honestly, it makes me so sad. Like the public has not been terrorized already by the reality of this virus. The decreasing cases and hospitalizations in places where vaccination is occurring quickly (variants notwithstanding) is the only reality we need to understand now.
    • May 26, 2021:
Children should return to their normal lives this summer and in the upcoming school year, without masks and regardless of their vaccination status. Overall, the risk to children is too low to justify the remaining restrictions they face…This low risk for children nearly vanishes as cases plummet. As we saw in Israel and Britain, vaccinating adults indirectly protects children. The same trend is evident here in the United States: Adult vaccination has lowered covid-19 incidence among children by 50 percent in the past four weeks.
    • Jun 8, 2021:
June 15th is when we’re (California) going to be done…get to herd immunity. He’s (Governor Newsome) going to have to open up more without masks. All of that will show us as we mingle, the cases aren’t going up….that we have enough of the population being immune.
    • June 23, 2021:
Know we are all delta variant right now but look- plummeting cases since April 14 when we passed 40% 1st dose, cases continue to go down, deaths reached <300, this is the impact of vaccines on the US epidemic. Instead of doom, celebration that we have means to end epidemic in US.
    • June 24, 2021:
Children are not more susceptible to the delta variant, they’re threefold less likely to get any infection with any variant with any ancestral strain, and they’re half as likely to spread it. And they can mask on the plane, as they should. You yourself are completely protected against the delta variant, and you should go and enjoy your summer. It’s been a hard time, and people should have their summer. Delta variant, delta shmariant.
    • July 15, 2021:
As the virus that causes Covid-19 evolves and mutates, the same concerns pop up about whether the variant evades vaccines, makes people sicker than the old versions, and increases transmissibility. What we know about the Delta variant is reassuring.
    • July 15, 2021:
1st step is to show hospitalizations not increasing in kids with delta.
    • September 4, 2021:
I truly, truly think we are in the endgame. The cases will start plummeting in mid- to late September and by mid-October, we will be in a manageable place, where the virus is a concern for health professionals, but not really for the general public.
Dr. Michael Levitt
    • July 25, 2020:
US COVID19 will be done in 4 weeks with a total reported death below 170,000. How will we know it is over? Like for Europe, when all cause excess deaths are at normal level for week. Reported COVID19 deaths may continue after 25 Aug. & reported cases will, but it will be over.
    • August 1, 2021:
With no move in added reported COVID19 deaths & Delta Variant CFR from UK of 0.14%, it seems that FL (Florida) is likely to be fine.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya*
    • July 21, 2021
The disease has been defanged. We actually should be declaring victory. We have done a fantastic job. We have developed a vaccine that has essentially turned this pandemic into something much milder.
    • July 26, 2021:
I don’t think the delta variant changes the calculus or the evidence in any fundamental way… In Florida in this past wave, the number of deaths have not risen proportionally. Why? Because we protected the vulnerable.
    • September 4, 2021:
The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.
Some caveats
I recognize it may appear unseemly to dredge up these failed predictions, and I don’t do so to rub salt in anybody’s wounds. I am sure these predictions reflected genuinely held beliefs (though not always it seems). Like me, these contrarians were mostly careful to note that unvaccinated people – at least older adults – were still in great danger. Moreover, several of them acknowledged (here, here, and here) the obvious reality that their predictions were flawed. Certainly, some people will think these statements of regret mean these predictions should now be completely off limits for further discussion. While I commend these doctors for admitting error, which is not easy to do, these retractions often came many months later and rarely garnered the same attention as the initial flawed forecast.
We also need to be wary of the hindsight bias, our unconscious tendency to judge predictions as wise or foolish after the facts are known. Early in the pandemic, several antibody studies suggested the virus was much more widespread than previously thought. Though it can be hard to put ourselves in the same mindset at that time, it may not have been completely outlandish then to think the pandemic might be a short-lasting event. Similarly, a prediction in the spring of 2021 that variants wouldn’t be of concern may have been reasonable given the information that was known then. At that time, we thought that vaccines virtually eliminated the spread of the virus, and millions of people were getting vaccinated every day. The end of spring and early summer, when I made my overly-optimistic projections, was a time of great optimism in the USA. A lot of us thought the worst was over and the fall could be close to normal. Additionally, other people overestimated the virus at times, though some who were derided as prophets “of doom and fear” by contrarians for predicting 800,000 deaths in the US have been sadly proven right.
Not every flawed prediction indicates a character flaw or unscientific thinking, of course. After all, I am sure some people reading this sanitized their groceries and mail last year, something that seems like a silly ritual today. The only people whose reputations remain unblemished are those wise individuals who heeded the aphorism, “It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt”.
Not isolated errors
With these caveats in mind, it’s important to recognize that these flawed predictions were not isolated errors. All these contrarians suggested the pandemic was over more than once, and their continued message will likely be: the pandemic is over, again. Even as I was preparing this essay, one wrote an article titled “It’s Time to Contemplate the End of the Crisis“, which began by saying “Americans should be asking ourselves what else needs to happen before we can declare an end to the crisis phase of the pandemic”. I found much of this article plausible, and the author may be right – I desperately hope so – but it’s exactly what she’s been saying for most of this year.
Currently, cases are gradually inching up again after a decline from Delta’s large summer spike. 114,000 people contracted COVID-19 on 11/17/2021, and over 1,000 Americans are still dying of COVID-19 every day. These figures absolutely would have been considered a crisis prior to the current pandemic – especially considering safe and effective vaccines are now widely available. The pandemic has warped our sense of what we consider tolerable.
It’s not yet time to contemplate the end of the crisis, and this illustrates an interesting phenomenon this pandemic. In the same way that the anyone accused of “doom” by contrarians has almost always been vindicated in the end, contrarians’ predictions that we’ve reached herd immunity and sarcastic requests to wait “two more weeks” (here and here), have often turned out to be reliable indicators of when cases would start soaring again. This is not just limited to the US, as several of these contrarians claimed India had reached herd immunity (here, here, and here) right before the virus devastated that country. As Dr. Andreas Backhaus quipped about the Great Barrington Declaration and one of it’s authors, Dr. Sunetra Gupta,
I thought about writing a paper that estimates how long it takes for a country or region to suffer from a severe COVID19 outbreak after the GBD crew said that it had already reached herd immunity. One might call this new relationship the “Gupta predictor”.
Erroneous predictions, COVID-19 minimization, vaccine misinformation: a package deal
In addition to false forecasts, these contrarians also have also falsely minimized the dangers of the virus for young people, saying things like:
    • Young have almost no risk.
Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from #COVID19
Children incur almost no risk from virus.
I love this vaccine, but before we give an intervention to a kid who has almost no risk, I think we should use the precautionary principle.
For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%.
For someone who is less than 65 and has no underlying diseases, the risk is completely negligible…it seems that these deaths are extremely exceptional.
There are still so few hospitalizations, because younger people who get the Delta variant don’t get sick that need to be in the hospital.
For younger populations under 70, it’s much milder.
Children and young adults are very low risk for severe disease, about one in a million chance of death for a child under 19 from COVID.
Children are not more susceptible to the delta variant, they’re threefold less likely to get any infection with any variant with any ancestral strain.
The need to let young people interact with each other, both for social reasons and for herd immunity, makes perfectly good common sense. I think there should have been more of that.
In reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date.
The risk to children is greater from influenza than #COVID19.
COVID-19 is less of a threat to children than… the common flu.
The statements are all nonsense. Children under age 19 have a higher than a one in a million chance of dying of COVID-19. The Delta variant was not threefold less contagious for children. Healthy children have absolutely died from COVID-19 in the US. A five-second Google search is all it takes to find multiple news reports of such tragedies, and all children including those with comorbidities matter. COVID-19 is much more dangerous than the flu for children. With mitigation measures in place, COVID-19 killed hundreds of children and sent many thousands to the hospital. Meanwhile, the flu killed just one child and hospitalized just 9 children between the ages of 5-11 years.
According to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, the virus has killed 4,624 young adults ages 18-30 years and 923 children younger than this thus far. Tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized, some very sick, needing ICU-level care and intubation. Over 5,500 children have developed MIS-C, most of these children go to the ICU, and 48 children have died from it. The vast majority of young people do well with COVID-19, thankfully. However, prior to the pandemic, no reasonable person would have said a virus that did this much damage posed “almost no risk” to children and young adults. It bears repeating, the pandemic has warped our sense of what’s tolerable.
Not surprisingly, many of these contrarians have also downplayed the benefits and hyped the flaws of vaccines for young people. One contrarian claimed that the vaccine trial for adolescents didn’t measure “clinical outcomes…because so few kids get sick with COVID-19”. This is false. In reality, the trial measured whether or not children got COVID-19. The vaccine worked. Sixteen children who received the placebo got the disease, while zero children who received the vaccine got the disease. Real-world data demonstrates the vaccine’s amazing efficacy in keeping adolescents alive and out of the hospital. This contrarian has yet to share this good news, though he eagerly Tweeted about vaccine-related myocarditis the entire summer and authored a “howler” paper on the subject that has yet to be published. Another contrarian oddly warned that “too many boosters will exhaust immune system”. Another contrarian suggested that vaccinating young people could spread the disease to older people, while yet another said that vaccine mandates could lead to “More COVID spread b/c vax does not stop infection”. That’s right, these contrarians think vaccinating people will lead to more COVID-19.
Declarations that the pandemic is over and false statements minimizing both the dangers of the virus and the efficacy of the vaccine for young people are generally a package deal with contrarians. (Notably, Dr. Monica Gandhi recently wrote an excellent essay on vaccinating children.) Moreover, I’ve not seen any contrarian overestimate the virus in any way. All of this indicates their flawed predictions were not merely the errors of people caught off guard by a tricky new virus. Rather, these are individuals who have been consistently biased in underestimating the virus, usually since the pandemic’s first days.
An answer to Dr. Hall’s question
As these contrarians all have had very large platforms since the pandemic’s first days, their biases get passed around. Their writing is published in major news outlets, and their ceaseless media appearances are spread widely on social media where commentators routinely praise their “relentless optimism and positivity“. They say what we all want to hear, a phenomenon termed hopium. So now we have an answer to Dr. Hall’s inquiry that kicked off this essay: esteemed members of our profession repeatedly spread the myth that the pandemic was over.
There are consequences
Sadly, repeated declarations the pandemic had ended and that young people have no risk from the virus have not been without consequences. Most likely, some people adjusted their behavior accordingly, perhaps declining vaccination against a virus they believed posed no threat to them. One contrarian said in October 2020 that his goal was to “oppose fear mongering, faux certainty“, and other contrarians made a video that same month about “How to Stop Living in Fear” of a deadly virus. As a result, some people likely stopped being afraid of a deadly virus. The same likely happened this May when one contrarian authored an article titled “Risk Of COVID Is Now Very Low — It’s Time To Stop Living In Fear”. Under the direct influence of several contrarians, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis spread the message at the start of August that “vulnerable” people were protected and made terrible policy decisions based on this flawed premise. Later that month, Florida suffered a record average of 227 COVID-19 deaths per day and 17,200 people were hospitalized on a single day. Moreover, in the number of COVID-related child deaths more than doubled in August. Nearly 70 children per day were being hospitalized during the recent peak, and some were sick enough to need life support. This all happened after a safe and effective vaccine was available to anyone over age 12. Vulnerable people were not protected, they were very purposefully exposed.
It wasn’t just Florida. The news this summer was full of stories of regretful people from all over the country who wished they had been a bit more fearful of COVID-19. One 45-year-old man who spent 45 days in the hospital after declining the vaccine said, “If I would have known six months ago that this could be possible, this would have been a no-brainer. But I honestly didn’t think I was at any risk. That is the naïve portion on my end”. While contrarian doctors are by no means responsible for vaccine-refusal, their narrative that those who warned about the virus, especially the Delta variant, were just “fear mongering” certainly didn’t help anything. Graveyards have plenty of people who didn’t fear the virus. Over 1,000 Americans are joining them every day. Fear is unpleasant, but it’s not useless, and as Loretta Torrago said, “The best way to reduce *fear* is by reducing *danger*”. This is exactly right. And the best way to reduce danger would have been to get people to take COVID-19 seriously, not to tell young people they have no risk and the pandemic is over anyways.
As they do not work with COVID-19 patients, aside from criticism on social media, these contrarians have been largely sheltered from the consequences of their poor predictions and COVID-19 minimization. Notably, I’ve not seen a doctor who has significant real-world responsibility for treating COVID-19 patients declare the pandemic was over. I am not the only person to notice this. Dr. Taylor Nichols said “It’s always the physicians who never actually have to take care of COVID patients with the absolute worst takes on this. No real world responsibility and all of the real world hubris”. Similarly, Dr. Abraar Karan said:
One thing I guarantee you will notice if you pay attention, Doctors who have cared for COVID-19 patients will never underestimate what this virus is capable of… I have yet to meet a fellow physician who has spent the majority of their time caring for these cases who would claim to know exactly what to expect from SARS-CoV-2, because we continue to be surprised.
Though these contrarians don’t care for COVID-19 patients, they have little trouble criticizing the exhausted frontline healthcare workers who warned about the virus, even though most of their warning were prescient and accurate. Despite frequent calls for “trust“, “humility“, and “debate“, these contrarians routinely excoriate those who disagree with them, accusing them of having “addiction to doom and gloom“, and “perhaps an addiction to being on TV or in the paper“. It gets worse. One wondered in a since-deleted Tweet if “those pushing that children younger than 12 will need to be immunized to have school/full life have any connections with vaccine companies”. Another said this May that those who warned of variants were “fear-mongering” and those who doubt the US had reached herd immunity “want the pandemic to stretch out longer“. Another suggested, in direct contradiction to the evidence, that frontline doctors killed COVID-19 patients through inappropriate intubations and then filled out their death certificates fraudulently as “Some financial incentives may promote coding for COVID-19”. Another suggested just before the devastating winter wave in the US that those worried about this outcome were promoting “fear” to “gain followers during the pandemic“. Another said that Dr. Anthony Fauci is “probably the number one anti-vaxxer” because he encouraged people to be cautious after they had been vaccinated.
Though my criticisms of these contrarians may seem harsh, they pale in comparison to their suggestions that those who rightly warned about COVID-19 did so for social media clout, because they “want” the pandemic extended, because of an “addiction” to gloom and TV appearances, or because of perverse financial incentives. I’ve don’t think I’ve ever questioned anyone’s motives this way, and hopefully my criticisms have the advantage of being grounded in reality.
If you think the pandemic is over, act like it
Despite their pleas to “move on” and treat “covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people”, these contrarians continue to speak about COVID-19 all the time, proving that COVID-19 is not just still here, but worthy of their constant attention. Every article they write, every Tweet they send, and every interview they give on the subject refutes their previous predictions that the pandemic is “essentially done”. If they feel otherwise, they should act like it and stop talking about COVID-19.
One day, perhaps soon, COVID-19 will fade into the background. I expect some of these contrarians will then say “I told you so“. Until then, I can’t help but wonder if one of the reasons the pandemic isn’t over yet, is because contrarian doctors repeatedly said it was.
        ◦ *An earlier version misattributed a quote about variants to Dr. Jay Bhattacharya when it was from a different Dr. Bhattacharya. The quote has been removed. I apologize for the error and am grateful it was pointed out to me.

Contrarian Doctors, The Pandemic is Over Again, Again
I predicted last year that contrarian doctor would continue to say “the pandemic is over”. How did this prediction hold up?
Jonathan Howard on August 21, 2022
Link

Contrarian Doctors: The Pandemic is Over, Again
On November 19, 2021, I published an article titled “Contrarian Doctors: The Pandemic is Over, Again” in which I reviewed the overly optimistic predictions of several doctors, including myself. I noted that declarations that the pandemic is over have often turned out to be reliable indicators of when cases would start soaring again, and I made a few additional predictions. Namely, I predicted that the continued message of contrarian doctors would likely be “the pandemic is over, again” and that if COVID faded away, “some of these contrarians will then say ‘I told you so’“.
Enough time has passed to see how well my predictions aged.
Dr. Marty Makary
Dr. Marty Makary, who predicted herd immunity in April 2021 and then declared he was right in May 2021, has since sounded like a PR agent for the virus. He said the Omicron variant was “nature’s vaccine“, and that “We can recognize that there is an end in sight to this particular variant as Omicron sweeps across many countries.”
As Omicron loomed, Dr. Makary laughed at people who wanted a booster and called it “omi-cold” saying,
We’re seeing this massive new wave of fear that is fueling our second pandemic after COVID-19, which is a pandemic of lunacy, which is omicron. Now I call it omi-cold.
In reality, more children were hospitalized and died during the Omicron wave than ever before, and according to an article in the New York Times titled “During the Omicron Wave, Death Rates Soared for Older People“,
Almost as many Americans 65 and older died in four months of the Omicron surge as did in six months of the Delta wave, even though the Delta variant, for any one person, tended to cause more severe illness.
Even though he said on June 8, 2021 that everyone else needs to “move on at some point”, Dr. Makary talks about no topic other than COVID, often to fear monger about the pediatric vaccine.
Dr. Monica Gandhi
Dr. Monica Gandhi renewed her annual tradition of minimizing the virus on Dr. Zubin Damania’s (AKA ZDogg) podcast. In 2020 they recorded “How to Stop Living in Fear of COVID” in which Dr. Damania said “the fear that’s driving this pandemic has been heartbreaking to see.” In 2021 they recorded “The End of the Pandemic” where listeners heard that “A UCSF infectious disease doctor is convinced this pandemic is ending, and sooner than you think.” Drs. Gandhi and Damania shared a belly laugh then, mocking variants by saying “variants shmariants“. Their 2022 installment was titled “Living with COVID“.
This most recent podcast declared, “We now have all the necessary tools to end the COVID ’emergency’ phase.” Dr. Gandhi has said this many times before. To pick one example, in her essay “It’s Time to Contemplate the End of the Crisis“, which was published on November 3, 2021, she wrote,
Americans should be asking ourselves what else needs to happen before we can declare an end to the crisis phase of the pandemic. Although the coronavirus’s course remains unpredictable—and bad surprises are still possible—the Delta-variant surge that started in early July ushered in what may have been the final major wave of disease in the United States.
The essay concluded that,
The U.S. still has more progress to make, but the reality is that the coronavirus is encountering fewer and fewer Americans who are defenseless against it.
Drs. Gandhi and Damania have both been saying this for most of the pandemic, and Dr. Monica Gandhi Day was celebrated on June 15, 2021 with declarations that “population immunity protects unvax”.
I appreciate journalist Medhi Hasan who confronted Dr. Gandhi with her poor predictions. During this interview, she said “I will try not to make any more predictions“. Dr. Gandhi continues to talk about COVID frequently, but also discusses other infectious diseases.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
On March 20, 2022 Dr. Jay Bhattacharya wrote an article titled “Two Years Later, Be Honest About What Worked and What Didn’t”. This article didn’t mention false declarations the pandemic was over as something that “didn’t work.” He instead declared the pandemic over again, saying,
The pandemic, however, is drawing to a close as government after government has accepted the fact that the virus is here to stay forever, joining the 200 or so other pathogens that cause diseases in humans and the other circulating human coronaviruses.
He copied that from something he wrote on September 4, 2021, just before the Omicron wave hit. He said at that time,
The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.
Several months before this, on July 21, 2021, just before the Delta wave hit, he said,
The disease has been defanged. We actually should be declaring victory.
Though he justified lockdowns, Dr. Bhattacharya never really acknowledged the virus was a threat in the first place, writing on March 24, 2020,
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified. But there’s little evidence to confirm that premise—and projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.
Despite telling everyone else to treat COVID as merely one of 200 disease, Dr. Bhattacharya only discusses COVID.
Dr. John Ioanniddis
On March 28, 2022, Dr. John Ioanniddis published a pieced called “The End of the COVID-19 Pandemic“. In this article, he recognized that “‘normal’ may still correspond to higher death count”, but he felt these deaths should not interfere with anything. He said that these deaths “should not be mistaken as a continued pandemic phase.” He said attempts to control the virus “should not disrupt life” and that,
Public health authorities should call the end of the pandemic. This does not mean that the problem is inappropriately minimized or forgotten, but that our communities move on with life.
Dr. Ioannidis’s has said exactly this the entire pandemic. He started minimizing the virus as early as March 19th, 2020, when he wrote about “exaggerated pandemic estimates”, “exaggerated case fatality rate”, and “exaggerated exponential community spread.” He said a claim that 20%-60% of adults would be infected, was “substantially exaggerated.” He said that, “Even if COVID-19 is not a 1918-recap in infection-related deaths, some coronavirus may match the 1918 pandemic in future seasons. Thus, we should learn and be better prepared.” He wrote that,
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
He started to declare the end of the pandemic as early as April 2020 when he said,
Acknowledging for the fact that the epidemic is still evolving, and we cannot be sure whether we will hit even higher peaks in the future, although this doesn’t seem to be the case, at least for the European countries, and it seems to be that even in the US, in most states we’re very close to the peak, if not past the peak, the risk is something that should be manageable as opposed to the panic and horror stories that are circulating about.
Dr. Ioannidis predicted on April 9th 2020 that “COVID-19 will result in fewer than 40,000 deaths this season in the USA,” and in an ironically titled article called “Forecasting for COVID-19 has Failed“, which was published on August 25, 2020, he wrote
However, very few hospitals were eventually stressed and only for a couple of weeks. Most hospitals maintained largely empty wards, expecting tsunamis that never came… Tragically, many health systems faced major adverse consequences, not by COVID-19 cases overload, but for very different reasons.
Of course, the tsunamis would come in several in waves after this.
Despite this track record, when asked this summer about his “original intuition” that measures to control the virus would cause more harm than the virus itself, Dr. Ioannidis responded,
I wish I had been wrong on this point. Unfortunately, I am afraid I might have been correct.
Dr. John Mandrola
Meanwhile, though he said that “I no longer think publicly re vaccines or COVID NPIs”, Dr. John Mandrola recently commented on doctors’ observations that incidental COVID infections are common in hospitalized patients and said “See…I told you“. “We now have a diff disease,” he said.
This echoes what he’s said the entire pandemic. He said on May 1, 2020 that “no US hospital is now unprepared. It’s May, not March 9”. On March 10, 2021 he said,
The pandemic is essentially done. Human life has to be more than avoiding one pathogen. Millions have natural immunity. The pandemic (of bad disease) is nearly over. Ky has vaccinated about 1 in 3 older people. CT has done even better. The vaccine squelches severe cases Millions have natural immunity. Young have almost no risk The pandemic (of bad disease) is nearly over. And this is a really worthy cause of celebration!!!!!!
He said on June 11, 2021, “It appears to me that we have crushed COVID by simply vaccinating susceptible adults”, and on July 29, 2021 said,
If you were vaccinated and had mild to moderate URI symptoms, why on earth would you get a COVID test? Have the vaccines not transformed SARSCOV2 into just another regular respiratory virus?
Dr. Mandrola repeatedly said those who warned of the virus in 2020 and 2021 were “fear-mongering“, and implied they were doing so for social media clout. While Dr. Mandrola has admirably expressed regret for some of these sentiments, if I had such a track record, I hope I’d lack the temerity to say “See…I told you” when repeating these sentiments.
Another prediction
And I am again prepared to make another prediction. The continued message of contrarian doctors will likely be, “the pandemic is over, again“, and whether or not COVID fades away, they will say “I told you so“. A year from now, I predict I will be able to write as essay titled “Contrarian Doctors, The Pandemic is Over Again, Again, Again”.

The Hypocrisy Is The Point. Doctors Who Said Not To Mix Politics & Medicine.
Hypocritical articles on politics and medicine weren’t really about politics and medicine, they were a message- the standards we set for you, don’t apply to us and everyone knows it.
Jonathan Howard on August 8, 2024
Link

Taking a stand on a political matter is fine for persons, but it is not fine for clinicians or scientists.
In a previous article titled Medical Conservatives: Mixing Politics and Medicine is a Bad Idea, If I Disagree with Your Politics, I discussed an article by Dr. John Mandrola, a so-called “medical conservative”, titled Politics and Medicine is a Bad Idea. In his article, Dr. Mandrola reprimanded doctors and advised them to engage in self-censorship when it came to political issues. He wrote:
As private citizens, we can and should have ideas on policy. But our medical training provides us no expertise on policy.
Dr. Mandrola provided three examples where he felt doctors should keep their thoughts private: nuclear war, the environment, and gun violence. He wrote:
There are many downsides when healthcare professionals overstep our expertise. Spending time on things that have no bearing on learning and practicing the craft of medicine or public health distracts people from their actual job. People who get sick depend on their clinician to be trained in health and disease, not climate or nuclear policy. There is only so much time. Why not spend it on being better at helping sick people…
Another downside of these forays into policy is the possibility of reducing trust—which is already at a low level. Climate, gun, and nuclear issues are inherently political. Taking a stand on a political matter is fine for persons, but it is not fine for clinicians or scientists.
Recently, Dr. Mandrola decided the day the Democratic VP candidate was announced and celebrated was an appropriate occasion for him to repeat his calls for physician self-censorship on social media. He said:
It’s going to be difficult in the coming weeks but I think clinicians should try hard to stay apolitical in the public sphere. We owe it to our patients.
Of course, a doctor who sends an enthusiastic political tweet while waiting for the hospital elevator, is not betraying the patients she will soon be rounding on.
Dr. Mandrola was not the only “medical conservative” who, instead of getting better at helping sick people, spent time scolding doctors for voicing their opinions. At the start of the pandemic, Drs. Vinay Prasad and Jeffrey Flier wrote an essay titled Scientists Who Express Different Views On Covid-19 Should Be Heard, Not Demonized, whose purpose was to shield Dr. John Ioannidis’s misinformation from stringent criticism. Likening mean words to a virus that was overflowing morgues, Drs. Prasad and Flier wrote:
Society faces a risk even more toxic and deadly than Covid-19: that the conduct of science becomes indistinguishable from politics. The tensions between the two policy poles of rapidly and systematically reopening society versus maximizing sheltering in place and social isolation must not be reduced to Republican and Democratic talking points, even as many media outlets promote such simplistic narratives.
These critical decisions should be influenced by scientific insights independent of political philosophies and party affiliations. They must be freely debated in the academic world without insult or malice to those with differing views.
Dr. Prasad would later write an article titled When Doctors Become Political – The 2016 Shift in he warned that “science and medicine must avoid naked partisan politics.” He wrote:
I worry that this problem is larger today than ever before. More and more questions are becoming political… And at top universities, the politics is uni-directional. Most of the faculty and students are liberal, and the goals of the left are increasingly becoming the goals of medicine… School closure of course hurt poor, minority kids. A good liberal should have opposed it. But because Trump wanted schools open, liberals had to go the other direction. They have destroyed a generation of kids. Teachers unions and the democratic nominee worked to keep schools closed in 2020 and beyond. The harms are yet to be fully tallied.
He concluded:
Science and medicine must aspire to be less political and aspire for better evidence. If we continue in this direction, we are doomed. Sadly, many are along for the ride.
Dr. Prasad wasn’t wrong when he wrote “many are along for the ride”.
POLITICIANS ARE LITERALLY TRYING TO SEND DOCTORS TO PRISON FOR PROVIDING STANDARD OF CARE MEDICAL TREATMENTS. WHY ON EARTH ARE WE SUPPOSED TO NOT HAVE AN OPINION.
In my discussion of these sentiments, I agreed that doctors, especially those with large platforms, should be thoughtful when voicing political opinions, however, medical school graduates do not forfeit their right to speak their mind on issues that affect their lives and the lives of their patients. Noting that politics invaded medicine, Dr. Ashley Winter had this response to Dr. Mandrola.
Politicians decided to insert themselves in the doctor patient relationship and we need to speak up until we get them the hell out of it. And no, when a patient is in front of me in a care setting I never initiate political discussions. But in the public sphere you better believe this is our lane. POLITICIANS ARE LITERALLY TRYING TO SEND DOCTORS TO PRISON FOR PROVIDING STANDARD OF CARE MEDICAL TREATMENTS. WHY ON EARTH ARE WE SUPPOSED TO NOT HAVE AN OPINION.
Of course, Dr. Mandrola feels it’s fine for doctors to have strong opinions. He just wants people like Dr. Winter to keep their thoughts to themselves. He literally doesn’t want to hear from people like her. Even though Dr. Winter is not being alarmist-Abortion Ruling Keeps Texas Doctors Afraid of Prosecution– Dr. Mandrola suggests doctors who share their thoughts on this topic and its relevance to the presidential election are unprofessional and letting down their patients.
My article also noted that the sanctimonious admonishments of Drs. Mandrola, Prasad, and Flier were directed only at certain doctors who expressed certain opinions. This is because Drs. Mandrola, Prasad, and Flier don’t really believe that mixing politics and medicine is a bad idea. Their protestations were just an act, a show, a performance, more bad faith engagement.
In fact, Drs. Mandrola, Prasad, and Flier were happy to mix politics and medicine, often with insult and malice towards those with differing views- idiot, STUPID, bunch of fools, total morons. Dr. Prasad, for example, made a political video for a libertarian organization titled You’re Right Not To Trust Public Health and has over 50 rageful Tweets directed at teacher’s unions. I’ve been much more private about my political beliefs than this.
“Science and medicine must avoid naked partisan politics.”
It is unfortunate and ironic that my Republican colleagues selected Dr. Bhattacharya as a witness for our COVID-19 misinformation hearing when he himself is a purveyor of COVID-19 misinformation.
Drs. Mandrola, Prasad were also totally silent when certain doctors mixed politics and medicine. This silence was notable.
Indeed, many We Want Them Infected doctors mixed politics and medicine openly and freely since the start of the pandemic. Scientists, namely Dr. Ioannidis himself, tried to influence politicians as early as March 2020, as Stephenie Lee documented in her article An Elite Group Of Scientists Tried To Warn Trump Against Lockdowns In March. Remember, in March 2020, Dr. Ioannidis was writing sentences like this:
If only part of resources mobilized to implement extreme measures for COVID-19 had been invested towards enhancing influenza vaccination uptake, tens of thousands of influenza deaths might have been averted.
At the same time that Drs. Prasad and Flier were chastising Dr. Ioannidis’ critics for supposedly mixing politics and medicine, Dr. Ioannidis himself was directly reaching out to politicians to deliver his misinformation message and advance his favored policies.
Imagine that.
He was not alone in trying to influence politicians at that time. According to the House Report, The Atlas Dogma:
Dr. Scott Atlas began attempting to influence federal pandemic policy soon after the start of the coronavirus crisis. New evidence obtained by the Select Subcommittee shows that Dr. Atlas reached out to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Administrator Seema Verma on March 21, 2020, arguing that the federal government’s pandemic response was “a massive overreaction” that was “inciting irrational fear” in Americans. Dr. Atlas estimated that the coronavirus “would cause about 10,000 deaths”—a number he claimed “would be unnoticed” in a normal flu season—and said, “The panic needs to be stopped.”
This outreach was undeniably effective. It paved the way for We Want Them Infected doctors to directly influence political matters at the highest level.
“Taking a stand on a political matter is fine for persons, but it is not fine for clinicians or scientists.”
As the pandemic progressed, several We Want Them Infected doctors teamed up with a libertarian, pro-tobacco, child-labor advocate to advance their political objectives. Some formally endorsed and openly campaigned for certain politicians, while blasting other politicians. You don’t have to wonder about which politicians they cheered for and which they blasted.
“Science and medicine must aspire to be less political”
We Want Them Infected doctors cheered for certain policies and blasted other policies. You don’t have to wonder about which policies they cheered for and which they blasted. Several We Want Them Infected doctors became celebrities in the right-wing media, blending their medical and political opinions on Fox News, in the Wall Street Journal, and in discussions at the Cato Institute. They were involved in lawsuits against Democratic politicians. They lost. They testified in courts (getting mocked by judges in the process) to advance their political agenda. They testified before both the Senate and House (getting mocked by congressmen in the process), to advance their political agenda. One congressman wisely said:
It is unfortunate and ironic that my Republican colleagues selected Dr. Bhattacharya as a witness for our COVID-19 misinformation hearing when he himself is a purveyor of COVID-19 misinformation.
Drs. Marty Makary, Maryin Kulldorff, and Jay Bhattacharya take a stand on a political matters
Dr. Tracy Hoeg takes a stand on a political matters
Many We Wanted Them Infected doctors did more than just voice their political opinions. Some, including Dr. Prasad, formed advocacy groups, such as the Urgency of Normal, which provided an “advocacy toolkit” so parents could lobby for policies that permitted the mass infection of unvaccinated children. They got everything they wanted. It’s been years since communities tried to control the virus.
Other We Wanted Them Infected doctors directed policy in key places. They served as formal advisors to powerful politicians, such as Donald Trump, Ron DeSantis, and Glen Youngkin, who enacted their policies, often with tragic consequences that were obvious to doctors who actually worked in hospitals. This seamless blending of politics and medicine was not just limited to the US. The failed We Want Them Infected movement was international, and we might be at the beginning of this story. It is likely some of these doctors might again be appointed to positions of influence if political winds go in their favor.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with doctors advising politicians, of course. In fact, politicians need input from doctors, preferably those who actually treat sick people, when dealing with medical issues. However, these politicians and We Want Them Infected doctors also shared a political agenda. Indeed, We Want Infected Doctors, who resented being called “fringe” in private emails, had nothing to say when their favored politicians generated headlines like this:
Anthony Fauci Says He Still Needs a Security Detail After Ron DeSantis Threatened To ‘Grab That Little Elf and Chuck Him Across The Potomac’
We Wanted Them Infected doctors were hardly neutral scientists, simply reporting the facts so the people could decide the best policy. They happily took stands on political matters. In fact, for several of them, their political activism dwarfed their scientific output. These weren’t doctors who occasionally dabbled in politics. They were political activists who occasionally dabbled in medicine. While other doctors treated COVID patients, they functioned as lobbyists for the virus, defending it against allegations it was dangerous or something to be avoided.
Thanks For Reading David
Yet, they got a free pass.
Drs. Mandrola, Prasad, and Flier either said nothing or lavished praised on these doctors. This is because Drs. Mandrola, Prasad, and Flier agreed with the politics of We Want Them Infected doctors, and so they didn’t care when they took a stand on a political matters. The rules didn’t apply to them. The naked political activism of We Want Them Infected doctors was deemed normal and appropriate, unlike doctors who merely discussed gun violence or sternly criticized Dr. Ioannidis’ misinformation. Those doctors deserved to be publicly scolded.
Doctors who sincerely believe medicine should be separate from politics apply their standards equally and consistently. Drs. Mandrola, Prasad, and Flier do not. Their disingenuous admonitions not to mix politics and medicine were nothing more than a tactic to shame and silence unwanted voices and preemptively discredit unwanted opinions, all by doctors who claim to value “free and open debate.”
And this was not an isolated incident. It was just a small part of a large pattern I’ve discussed many times previously.
    • Doctors who scolded you for supposedly minimizing rare, generally mild vaccine-side effects, also scolded you for worrying about literal death from COVID.
    • Doctors said a low rate of myocarditis from the vaccine was “deeply concerning”, also said a high rate of myocarditis from the virus “good news”.
    • Doctors who claimed only large RCTs could demonstrate vaccine benefits, lauded a VAERs dumpster dive that purported to show vaccine harms.
    • Doctors who advocated for the open disclosure of financial conflicts of interest, hid their own.
    • Doctors who demanded the utmost civility when they were critiqued, routinely engaged in juvenile name-calling, blatant dishonesty, and even veiled threats when they criticized others.
    • Doctors who declared that vaccines were perfect and herd immunity had arrived in spring 2021, later said this was the “worst misinformation” and blamed others for a loss of trust in medicine.
    • Doctors who said only stupid people talked about COVID, still talk about it constantly.
    • Doctors who warned against the “panic-driven, horror-driven, death-reality-show type of situation” with regards to the virus, warned that measures to contain it could lead to “financial crisis, unrest, civil strife, war, and a meltdown of the social fabric“.
    • Doctors who spread pro-infection, anti-vaccine misinformation with regards to COVID, performatively lamented the loss of confidence in routine vaccinations.
    • Doctors who rejected using children as “shields” when it came to the vaccine, which no one proposed in the first place, embraced using children as shields when it came to the virus.
Rules and standards were for thee, not for me.
But the bigger issue wasn’t just these doctors’ hypocrisy, it’s how obvious and transparent it all was. They made no effort to hide it. Dr. Prasad’s essay, which concluded science and medicine must aspire to be less political, also said liberals, the left, teachers unions, and the democratic nominee destroyed a generation of kids. A whole generation of kids- destroyed!
“Science and medicine must aspire to be less political”
These doctors also didn’t care when their hypocrisy was exposed. That was an occasion to make a joke. They knew they exempted themselves from the standards they set for others, their audience knew it, and they knew their audience knew it. Everyone was in on the game. And thus it becomes clear, hypocritical articles on politics and medicine weren’t about politics and medicine at all, they were a message- the standards we set for you don’t apply to us, and everyone knows it.
The hypocrisy was the point.

Ayn Rand, Objectivists, and COVID
Healthcare workers are leaving medicine after coming under attack due to the type of disinformation spread by Objectivists. That’s ironic.
Jonathan Howard on May 22, 2022
Link
Ayn Rand and the pandemic
Like many young people, I was a fan of Ayn Rand and her philosophy of Objectivism. I even attend several Objectivist conferences in college. Though I ended any formal association with her movement decades ago, and I’ve come to disagree with her about many things, I still consider her influence a net positive on my thinking.
First and foremost, I credit her with introducing me to the ideal of independent, critical thinking. Rand posits that there is an objective reality we can learn about through science and reason. She was a staunch atheist who rejected all forms of mysticism and groupthink. As she put it,
A is A. Facts are facts, independent of any consciousness. No amount of passionate wishing, desperate longing or hopeful pleading can alter the facts. Nor will ignoring or evading the facts erase them: the facts remain, immutable.
I agree, and this ethos clearly influenced my previous defense of skepticism. Things aren’t true just because we want them to be true, and I’ve written previously about the dangers of hopium and confirmation bias. Most of our pandemic woes are due to deniers who refuse to accept that A is A about an unthinking virus. The dangerous belief that its harms can wished away has been a core theme of my writing here.
Rand also believed that people have the absolute right to protection from physical aggression from any source. She vigorously defended abortion as a “moral right” and believed that people could do whatever they wanted with their bodies as long as their actions don’t directly impact anyone else. As the saying goes, your liberty to swing your fist ends just where my nose begins.
To this end, she had some interesting thoughts about vaccines and contagious diseases. There’s no question she would favor allowing private entities to establish whatever rules they wanted regarding vaccines. Indeed a recent Objectivist conference wisely required either proof of vaccination or a negative test prior to attendance. However, Rand was against the government forcibly vaccinating people, at least for a vaccine that perfectly prevented the disease. In this hypothetical scenario, no one’s choice would impact anyone else. She said:
Now, requiring inoculation against disease: should this be a job for the government? Most definitely not and there is a very simple answer for it. If it is medically proved that a certain inoculation is in fact practical and desirable, those who want it will take that inoculation. Now if some people do not see it that way—do not agree or don’t want to take it, only they will be in danger since all the other people will be inoculated. Those who do not go along, if they are wrong in this case, will merely catch the disease. They will not be a danger to anyone else and nobody has the right to force them to do anything for their own good against their own judgement. They will merely be ill then, but they could not infect others.
Of course, no vaccine is perfect, and the idea that the unvaccinated pose no risk to the vaccinated is one of the oldest anti-vaccine tropes out there. In the real world, this issue is more complicated.
However, in another sense, this issue is actually quite simple. No one was “required” to get a vaccine this pandemic. Some people had to make some tough choices, but no one was strapped down and vaccinated by government goons. This only happens in the fevered imaginations of delusional anti-vaxxers, desperate to portray themselves as oppressed victims.
As far as I know, the government used force to vaccinate people only once in my lifetime, when several children were vaccinated against measles over 30 years ago. I’m confident Rand would have supported this action, as nine unvaccinated children had already died. She would have recognized that children aren’t property, and the government can intervene when their caretakers seriously jeopardize their health. As she put it, “a child is an individual, and has the rights inherent in the nature of a human individual”. Amen.
Rand also had interesting thoughts on non-pharmaceutical interventions. She said,
The next question in regard to quarantine is somewhat different, because in the state of, sense of a quarantine, if someone has a contagious disease, against which there is no inoculation, then the government will have the right to require quarantine. What is the principle here? It’s to protect those people who are not ill, to protect the people who, to prevent the people who are ill from passing on their illness to others. Here you are dealing with a demonstrable physical damage.
Remember that in all issues of protecting someone from physical damage, before a government can properly act, there has to be a scientific, objective demonstration of an actual physical danger. If it is demonstrated, then the government can act to protect those who are not yet ill from contacting the disease, in other words to quarantine the people who are ill is not an interference with their rights, it is merely preventing them from doing physical damage to others.
Again, this seems eminently reasonable. The locked TB ward outside my office never bothered me, and I’ve never heard any Objectivist complain about it either, though of course this drastic measure would be unenforceable for a disease like COVID. These are the most draconian public health measures. People can be locked on a hospital ward for as long as two years and be forced to make medications for TB. Rand justified such measures to prevent people from spreading deadly diseases.
Beyond this, her novels championed creators who were often loathed not because they were incompetent or dishonest, but because they were brilliant, dedicated, and independent. Rand’s heroes were people of action who created and discovered things that improved all of our lives. The Wikipedia entry on The Fountainhead describes its protagonist as “…an intransigent young architect, who battles against conventional standards and refuses to compromise with an architectural establishment unwilling to accept innovation”. I think my distaste for doctors who spread dangerous medical myths and refuse to correct basic errors in their writing can be traced back to this intransigent young architect.
It’s hard to think of a better Randian hero this pandemic than Dr. Katalin Karikó, a scientist who toiled anonymously for years because she loved her job. “You are not going to work — you are going to have fun” her husband would say to her. Though her work was ignored for years, she knew its value, and now the entire world knows as well. Her research led to the mRNA vaccines, and she has saved countless lives. One news report described her thusly:
By all accounts intense and single-minded, Dr. Karikó lives for “the bench” — the spot in the lab where she works. She cares little for fame. “The bench is there, the science is good,” she shrugged in a recent interview. “Who cares?”
This is exactly what a Randian hero would say and do, and heroic women were central to Rand’s novels.
In contrast, Rand’s villains created nothing and sought to destroy those with a spark of independence and greatness. One such villain stated his mission was to:
Kill his capacity to recognise greatness or to achieve it. Great men can’t be ruled. We don’t want any great men. Don’t deny conception of greatness. Destroy it from within. The great is the rare, the difficult, the exceptional.
It’s harder to think of a better Randian villain this pandemic than someone who spreads disinformation about vaccines, knowing they will never have to deal with the consequences. These people can’t create or do anything themselves. Instead, they seek to undermine the work of scientists like Dr. Karikó in order to promote their own political and social agenda.
A Rand villain, jealous that his perceived genius is unappreciated by the masses, would seek to take down a widely-admired scientist by calling him the “number one anti-vaxxer”, for example. He would promote himself relentlessly in the media and have a preternatural sense of victimhood. He would be “mocked for claiming he carried papers giving him permission to go to work throughout the COVID-19 pandemic”. The removal of a YouTube video would enrage a Randian villain, and being called “fringe” would send him running to a TV camera to bemoan his sad fate.
In contrast, these insults would be a speck of dust to Dr. Karikó. “Who cares?” she’d say. She’d never consider herself a victim in a pandemic where one million Americans died. People like are her are too busy trying to stop the virus and save lives.
Objectivists and the pandemic
Given Rand’s devotion to rationality, her belief the government can take steps “to prevent the people who are ill from passing on their illness to others”, and her admiration for scientists, one might expect Objectivists to express reasonable positions on the pandemic. I never expected them to be cheerleaders for lockdowns, though of course the lockdowns had no cheerleaders. However, I expected them to have a nuanced view of the subject during a time when nearly 1,000 New Yorkers were dying every day. At a bare minimum, I expected them to strongly encourage vaccination, including for children. After all, over 1,500 children have died of COVID, and the vaccine has proven to be very effective in preventing these dire outcomes. Vaccinating children is the rational thing to do. It’s not even a close call.
A is A, right?
Indeed some Objectivists have written very reasonable essays this pandemic, with one writer noting that “no one has the right to infect other people with a dangerous disease” and warning against “fake news, conspiracy theories, and the like”. He asked to give gratitude,
First and foremost, the doctors, nurses, and others in health care who are working overtime and at risk to deal with the rise in Covid-19 patients.
I knew the author of that essay and I admired him a lot. This wise and compassionate essay aged incredibly well I think, which is very rare for early pandemic thoughts.
This aside, it sadly seems whenever a Rand acolyte discusses COVID, it’s mostly fake news, conspiracy theories, and the like. For example, consider the relationship between Objectivists and the Brownstone Institute, the successor to the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). There is a strong alliance between Objectivists and those sheltered doctors who fetishize “natural immunity”, encourage unvaccinated young people to catch the virus, and both spread and legitimize rank anti-vaccine disinformation. These are the people who surveyed scenes of forklifts dumping dead bodies into refrigerated trucks in NYC and concluded that too many people were trying to avoid the virus.
Really.
Even as the virus shutters schools (including private ones), restaurants, flights, and performances, they continue to oppose any and all measures to control it. While Rand would have found it problematic that the virus disrupted businesses this way, they refuse to even acknowledge this sad reality. For some people, unwanted facts are unmentionable facts. They prefer a Fantasyland where it’s still 2020, and they can be heroes, demanding we end the lockdowns right now!
Unsurprisingly, the Brownstone Institute has also been a main driver of anti-vaccine disinformation this pandemic (here, here, here, here). There are doctors who treat facts as completely mutable by pretending the virus poses no real threat to young people, and you can find them at the Brownstone Institute. They are already spewing predictable garbage about vaccines, Bill Gates, Dr. Fauci, and monkeypox. It’s no surprise their work is positively received on the website run by anti-vaccine supercrank RFK Jr. They’re not really that different.
A is not A at the Brownstone Institute. The people who work there aren’t Howard Roarks.
Despite this, the founder of the Brownstone Institute has been welcome at The Atlas Society, an organization that purports to advance the ideas of Ayn Rand. The Atlas Society also published propaganda praising the pro-virus, anti-vaccine, fabulists behind the GBD and calling their critics “alarmist”. This article warned of “the political hysteria about the virus”. Hundreds of thousands of Americans have died since its publication, and COVID is a leading medical cause of death in young adults.
Like I said, A is not A.
Unlike Rand, the founder of the Brownstone Institute does not feel “the government can act to protect those who are not yet ill from contacting the disease”. In fact, he pays doctors who convinced politicians to purposefully infect unvaccinated children and young people, with devastating consequences for many of them. In one of his articles at the Atlas Society, he spread pure anti-vaccine balderdash while boldly anointing himself as a spokesman for healthcare workers – like me – who actually worked on COVID units. Fantasizing that he could speak on our behalf, he said:
They know that nothing beats acquired immunity via exposure. Especially with a coronavirus with a changing profile, a vaccine cannot compare. That is precisely what 100% of the studies have shown since that time. And yet here we have governments imposing the shot on people who took the risk, gained the immunities, and now refuse to take another and potentially more deadly risk from the vaccine that operates not like vaccines of old.
Had he actually spent any time with us, he would have known we did all we could to avoid acquired immunity via exposure. Too many healthcare workers suffered and died because they were unable to do so, including friends of mine. Of course, there is now evidence that viral-induced immunity is far from perfect and that vaccines can lower the reinfection rate in previously infected people.
Doctors saw what the virus could do, we read the studies on the vaccines, and most of us ran to get vaccinated as soon as we could. Nearly 100% of doctors are vaccinated against COVID, and one typical news headline from December 2020 captured our emotions by saying, “Healthcare Workers Cry Tears of Joy as Coronavirus Vaccinations Ramp Up: ‘It Feels Great'”. No healthcare worker cried tears of joy for acquired immunity via exposure, and only a complete ignoramus or liar would imply otherwise. Either way, A isn’t A.
We’ve spent the past year pleading with our patients to get vaccinated and caring for those who were misled into thinking that nothing beats acquired immunity via exposure. Some of these people begged for the vaccine after it was too late. I wonder what concrete steps the founder of the Brownstone Institute took to reap the benefits of acquired immunity via exposure before he was vaccinated? Whatever the answer, it’s clear we’re not exactly dealing with a Dr. Karikó here.
Objectivists versus Ayn Rand
So why is it that many Objectivists – though not all – simultaneously embraced disinformation and undermined heroic scientists whose brilliance saved lives? I’m not entirely sure. However, I suspect many of them aren’t motivated by ideas and values as much as a desire to be contrarian. For some people, like my teenage son, nothing matters more than feeling different and special. Being a “free-thinker” means nothing more than doing the opposite of whatever “they” suggest.
If desperate public health officials use restrictions as a last resort, they will reflexively oppose those measures, even though Rand justified them, the morgues were literally overflowing with bodies down the street from where she lived, and there’s solid evidence they saved lives. If doctors tell young people to get vaccinated, they will reflexively oppose vaccination, even though many unvaccinated children have died of COVID. And on it goes.
It’s possible that Rand would have been a crank during this pandemic. Many people I admired surprised me by rejecting the notion that A is A. “It’s just the flu and it’s all going away”, they said since day #1. So what follows may be wishful thinking but I’d like to believe that if Rand were here today, she’d recognize A is A. Her first mission would be to write a lengthy tribute to Dr. Karikó. Since they no longer seem to admire women like Dr. Karikó, no Objectivist has done this as far as I know. In fact, many have worked to undermine the fruits of her research. Rand would of course be horrified to learn that a virus killed a million Americans, many thousands of them after a vaccine was available. The worst thing she imagined was a power outage in NYC.
She would have deplored the abuse of healthcare workers at the hands of people who were tricked – by articles on the Atlas Society – into thinking that the virus was only dangerous for old, sick people in nursing homes. An expert on violence against healthcare workers recognized that “violence is one of the repercussions” of those who “downplayed the seriousness” of the virus.
Rand would also understand that this COVID denialism is a major reason why so many healthcare workers are leaving the field right now. As one nurse said:
We want to be rooting for our patients. But anyone I know who’s working in COVID has zero compassion remaining, especially for people who chose not to get the vaccine.
Rand would have agreed with Dr. Sheetal Rao when she said “Physicians are some of the most resilient people out there. When this group of people starts leaving en masse, something is very wrong.” After all, resilient people leaving their jobs after being attacked for their virtues is the central theme of Atlas Shrugged, the novel she considered her masterpiece. Though he’s not a major character, a doctor was one of the heroes in that book. Rand clearly had a great respect the profession.
Today, healthcare workers are shrugging due to the consequences of disinformation spread by Objectivists. That’s ironic.
I’m confident that Rand would be mortified to learn her name was associated with prevaricators who spread fake numbers to minimize a deadly virus and discourage parents from vaccinating their children. She would have abhorred anyone who trashed the genius of Dr. Karikó in favor of a virus by saying “nothing beats acquired immunity via exposure”. You see, there’s no consistency with these Objectivists. It’s just malignant contrarianism and groupthink from a collective of talkers who’ve spent the past two years safe behind laptops and in front of cameras. Their disinformation ensured that doctors, who actually worked this pandemic, had a steady supply of gravely ill patients, many of whom who rewarded their knowledge and skill with hate and violence.
Ayn Rand would have seen right through these people.
And though she helped me do the same, I’m glad I left that hive mind a long time ago.

Is Discussing the Consequences of Anti-Vaccine Disinformation Fun?
Healthcare workers should not engage with people who treat us like game pieces for their amusement. I won’t do it again.
Jonathan Howard on May 30, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: Dr. Gorski is on vacation this week, and Dr. Howard has agreed to cover. Dr. Gorski will return to his usual slot next week.]
“They pontificate on the virus as if were a game”
A core theme of my writing is that people who spread disinformation about COVID are protected from the consequences of their words. I previously noted this distance allows them to “pontificate on the virus as if were a game, a brand-building opportunity”. In contrast, someone who works in an ICU will have more patients if they successfully discourage vaccination in young people. Of course, an ICU doctor may be wrong, and a random internet commentator may be right. Evidence matters, not credentials. But healthcare workers have skin-in-the game, and that counts for something.
Objectivists and COVID Part 2
With this in mind, let’s revisit my article about Objectivists and COVID. I’ve since discovered that some Objectivists have said some wise things. For example, Ben Bayer, a fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute, wrote a staunch pro-vaccine article in which he said:
The biggest sign that many vaccine refusers care too little about their own interests isn’t their attitude toward their health or the well-being of others. It’s their attitude toward the truth. It’s actually pretty dubious that many vaccine refusers think that Covid is dangerous but simply don’t care enough to protect their or their loved ones’ health against it. Many don’t want to get vaccinated because they really believe that Covid is not a serious threat compared to the risks of the vaccine in the first place. This is actually the deepest root of the moral problem.
Because of their beliefs, vaccine refusers don’t see that they’re recklessly letting their guard down against a serious threat. Because of their belief, they even mount crusades to convince others to join them.
Exactly. Disinformation has significant real-world consequences for our patients.
He also penned an homage to healthcare workers titled “If You’re a Doctor or Nurse, Don’t Feel Guilty for Quitting” in which he sympathized with burnt-out healers for the abuse they’ve suffered at the hands of “belligerent” unvaccinated patients. He said to such workers:
If you can’t find a way to make the joy of solving medical problems overcome the pain of being treated with disrespect, you shouldn’t blame yourself if you want to quit. I, for one, won’t blame you if you do quit out of righteous indignation for being treated like chattel. I still hope you don’t quit: many others and I may need your help. But you don’t owe it to us.
Exactly. Disinformation has significant real-world consequences for us.
Mr. Bayer gets it. This is not a game.
Objectivists and COVID Part 3
Not everyone gets it.
In retrospect, my prior article understated the degree to which other Objectivists advanced the myth that “Covid is not a serious threat compared to the risks of the vaccine”. I previously discussed the symbiosis between the Atlas Society, which claims to value rationality, and the Brownstone Institute, which has spread copious amounts of anti-vaxx rubbish, sanctified “natural immunity“, and issued oblique threats to behead people they disagree with. This article, which was also posted at the Atlas Society sans guillotine, lamented that
Pfizer and people like Anthony Fauci are demanding 3rd and now 4th shots. Shots without end, always with the promise that the next one will achieve the goal.
It’s no surprise its author is favorably featured on the website of anti-vaccine supercrank RFK Jr.
Beyond this, the Atlas Society also amplified radiologist Dr. Scott Atlas (read this), writer Dr. Naomi Wolf (read this), and who knows which other superspreaders of anti-vaccine disinformation. These are the people the Atlas Society legitimizes and amplifies during a pandemic.
Denying reality never ends well
Clinging to my teenage hope that leaders of the Atlas Society might actually care about rationality, I shared my previous article with Dr. Stephen Hicks a philosophy professor and Senior Scholar there. “Maybe he’s unaware of who his organization is promoting? Maybe he’ll want to learn more. Maybe he’ll care and even try do something about it.”
Reader, I actually believed that about him and a few other people there for some stupid reason. That’s how naïve I can be.
Dr. Hicks did disappoint, and though he did so in eminently predictable ways, his responses contain an important lesson: denying reality never ends well. Indeed, Dr. Hicks first attempted to deny reality by saying that “I (and pretty much everyone I associate with) am pro-vaccines and anti-mandates.” Even if they rushed to get vaccinated themselves, no one who is “pro-vaccine” would provide a friendly, warm forum for influential and outspoken anti-vaxxers to disseminate their disinformation.
After being presented with evidence the Atlas Society has done exactly this, Dr. Hicks rapidly pivoted to a new position that can be summarized as: Yes, we provide a friendly, warm forum for these people and that’s good. He claimed that though he is pro-vaccine, “Any intellectually honest organization *debates* complex issues”.
Apparently Dr. Hicks believes it’s a “complex issue” whether or not young people should left vulnerable to a virus that has killed thousands of them when a safe and effective vaccine exists. After all, several honored Atlas Society interviewees believe that unvaccinated young people should be exposed to the virus, and they’ve been very successful in their mission with inevitable results. Like I said, denying reality never ends well, even though it’s often not the denialists who pays the price.
Moreover, Dr. Hicks feels this “complex issue” should be decided via a debate. He thinks that anti-vaxxers and doctors who treat COVID patients should duke it out in a performance of sorts, where who is right and who is wrong is determined by who puts on the best show. Did the flu really kill more children than COVID, as scholars at the Brownstone Institute often claim? Only a debate can settle which number is really higher, 25 or 1,500. May the most polished speaker win.
Of course, Dr. Hicks completely misrepresented what the Atlas Society actually does. They don’t sponsor *debates* with anti-vaxxers. That would require them to provide a friendly, warm forum to a knowledgeable vaccine-advocate, something they’ve not done as best as I can tell. I doubt they even know any. Instead, they hand dishonest anti-vaxxers a microphone to answer softball questions from a sycophantic interviewer who selects her guests because they’ll say exactly what she wants to hear: COVID’s threat is overblown and those who try to limit it are stupid and corrupt.
That’s why she doesn’t push back when her guests say wild and wacky things.
For example, what happened when Dr. Wolf said that thanks to Bill Gates and pharma, we were no longer free to say “the pandemic is over“? Nothing. What happened when she likened current “anti-vaccination discrimination” to the historical evils of racism, sexism, and anti-Semitism? Nothing. What happened when Dr. Atlas falsely claimed the Delta variant was “less lethal” and that “high-risk people are the ones who die from the Delta variant, not anybody else“? Nothing. What happened when he said that children “die from the flu at a higher rate” than from COVID? Nothing. What happened when he fear-mongered about boosters and opposed vaccinating children by saying, “when people have a low-risk for an illness, I don’t understand the case for giving them a vaccine“? Nothing.
In the interviewer’s defense, she likely didn’t know that Dr. Atlas was both making stuff up and plagiarizing Dr. Andrew Wakefield’s cult, merely substituting COVID for measles. She may not have known that his brand of COVID denialism is exactly why healthcare workers have been attacked and why many are quitting. However, she should have known that Dr. Atlas would spread disinformation to further his goal of infecting unvaccinated young people.
Like, what else would he do?
He doesn’t hide his intentions. Early in the pandemic, he said, “Those who are not at risk to die or have a serious hospital-requiring illness, we should be fine with letting them get infected.” Even though effective vaccines are now available, he continues to worship at the altar of so-called “natural immunity”. To pick one example, he said:
To me, it’s unconscionable that a society uses its children as shields for adults. Children do not have a significant risk from this illness… Are we [as] a society, a civilization … going to inject our children with an experimental drug that they don’t have a significant benefit from, to shield ourselves?
Dr. Atlas believes that if he says “children do not have a significant risk from this illness” enough times that means it’s true. He can’t grasp the simple fact that some children do have a significant risk from this illness, and so we vaccinate children to protect children. Again, this is who the Atlas Society legitimizes and amplifies in the middle of a pandemic. Doctors who treat sick kids and provide accurate information are excluded from this echo chamber.
Thanks to the Atlas Society, some people now believe that more dangerous variants are “less lethal”, that 25 is more than 1,500, and that it’s a good when unvaccinated young people contract COVID. This is information pollution, and like someone blowing an air horn during a concert, it destroys our ability to debate complex issues. While debates in medicine are important and healthy, a precondition for any meaningful discussion is a shared commitment to honesty and reality. One can’t debate the optimal interval for vaccine doses with a prevaricator who denies the virus impacts young people at all.
And let’s be clear about a few obvious things regarding vaccines for young people. It doesn’t matter whether the flu or COVID is worse. It doesn’t matter that most kids will be fine, that other things kill more kids, or that old people have a much higher risk. None of these factoids is an argument against vaccinating children, though that hasn’t stopped writers at the Brownstone Institute from using them. Normal people don’t want any young person to suffer or die from a vaccine-preventable disease. Of course, young people should be vaccinated against COVID. This is not a complex issue. It is a very simple issue, and doctors with skin in the game should not “debate” very simple issues with sheltered fabulists whose deceptions have ensured their ICUs were stuffed with “low-risk” patients.
Trying to have it both ways, Dr. Hicks said it was “immoral to lie about vaccines” but also that “We need to celebrate our generation’s gadflies”. You’ll recognize that bit of sophistry as the Galileo gambit. Naturally, Dr. Hicks wasn’t saying we need to celebrate gadflies who are brilliant vaccine-scientists. The Atlas Society undermines these people.
Dr. Hicks was also much more concerned about decorum towards anti-vaccine “gadflies” than the immoral lies they spread. He was very worried that anti-vaxxers were “denied civility“, a predictable deflection technique used by those who seek to shutdown debate by focusing on manners, not substance. It’s just not nice to call someone a liar, I suppose, even when they claim 25 is larger than 1,500. In fact, we should “celebrate” such people, even when their disinformation leads to doctors getting punched in the face.
Using a meme of himself, Dr. Hicks implied that those who refute anti-vaxxers are akin to Nazi and Soviet “disinformation boards” and that not amplifying anti-vaxxers was akin to “censorship“, another predictable deflection technique. If someone feels I’m the next Goebbels because I think it’s a bad idea to “debate” the premise that 25 is larger than 1,500, then that’s a criticism I’ll have to learn to live with.
At least I’ve never called scientists I disagree with evil, corrupt, and criminal. I never said they were backpedaling and confessing “to get ahead of the indictments“. Dr. Wolf said all that and more that during her interview with the Atlas Society. Elsewhere, she claimed Dr. Fauci works for Israel, not Americans, something that could be straight out of a Nazi disinformation board actually. More recently, in an article at the Brownstone Institute of course, she revealed her fantasy “to shave people’s heads and march them through the town square.” She spoke about the need for Nuremberg Trials for America’s “quislings and collaborators,” noting that “There is a reason treason is a capital offense”.
Again, this is who the Atlas Society legitimizes and amplifies in the middle of a pandemic.
Unfortunately, Dr. Wolf’s message resonates with a lot of angry, armed people. As a result, terrified public health officials have censored themselves by quitting en masse. Dr. Fauci has needed “personal security from law enforcement at all times, including at his home”. So have his daughters. If you’re wondering about a source for such hatred towards Dr. Fauci, I suggest reading the article “Who Will Be Held Responsible for this Devastation?” on the Atlas Society webpage. It said that “The carnage” of lockdowns and vaccine mandates “is unspeakable and will last a generation or two or more” and asked “Who is left to blame?”
The most likely candidate here is Fauci himself. But I can already tell you his excuse. He never signed a single order. His fingerprints are on no legislation.
Anyone who actually cares about civility and opposes censorship knows that cranks who incite credible threats against scientists need to be exposed and marginalized, not amplified and celebrated.
Dr. Hicks further engaged in bothsideism by asking, “How do we tally the costs/benefits of mistakes and lying on both sides?” Apparently he sees little difference between Dr. Peter Hotez, who has received countless, vile threats for his vaccine-advocacy, and the anti-vaxxers who make and occasionally act on such threats. According to Dr. Hotez, the hate mail he received “was filled with all sorts of Nazi imagery, Nuremberg hangings and terrible, terrible stuff. It was pretty upsetting”. I wonder if any of the people who messaged Dr. Hotez heard Dr. Wolf call him a “conflicted” pharma shill during her interview with the Atlas Society.
Both sides, you see.
As a last resort, Dr. Hicks nursed grievances, saying he was a victim of a “guilt-by-association“. To paraphrase an assertion he made on multiple occasions: I never said anything about time-traveling via vaccine nanopatticles. So why should I be held accountable as a senior leader of an organization that legitimizes people who say such things?
Is this how Howard Roark would react if lazy workers with poor craftsmanship used the shoddiest materials to construct one of his buildings? As it crumpled to the ground, would he say, “Hey, don’t look at me, bro. I just made the drawings”?
I don’t think so.
Healthcare workers should not engage with people who treat us like game pieces for their amusement
These deflection techniques are very familiar to regular readers of SBM. However, it was what Dr. Hicks said at the end of the conversation that inspired this essay. Reflecting on the discussion, he said the whole thing was just a “mostly fun Twitter thread on Covid” and that he “mostly enjoyed the wide-ranging discussion today”.
And there is it. It was just a game the whole time.
Indeed, the pandemic has been little more than a game and brand-building opportunity for amoral disinformation groups and the grifters they promote. Having been informed that over 300,000 Americans died due to the type of anti-vaccine disinformation his organization legitimizes, Dr. Hicks could only reflect on how entertaining the whole spectacle was. The greatest mass death event in American history is just an intellectual puzzle, discussed in a state of purposeful ignorance regarding the real damage caused by some of its players.
Multiple people tried to impress upon Dr. Hicks that this wasn’t just a conversation about which superpower is best. Despite our efforts, like all the people I write about, Dr. Hicks never showed any recognition that flesh-and-blood people, including children, have suffered as a consequences of anti-vaccine disinformation. I discussed previously how some contrarian doctors even shame those who dare to acknowledge any individual child lost to COVID.
In contrast, I believe that individuals matter, and so I’ve made a point of recognizing them, including doctors who were friends and teachers of mine. I make an effort not treat people as mere numbers on a government website. Speakers at the Atlas Society do that.
Though the experience was “mostly fun” for Dr. Hicks, I don’t think anyone else felt that way, especially the healthcare workers. They are burnt-out and checking-out as they are fed up with having to mop up the mess created by disinformation superspreaders. They are tired of sheltered talkers treating their lives and the lives of their patients as mere pawns on a chessboard, whose value must be weighed against the harms of offending delicate anti-vaxxers. I previously noted the irony of competent people quitting their jobs not despite Objectivists, but because of them. (Not you, Mr. Bayer).
At least I learned something valuable: It’s a waste of time to engage with someone who treats healthcare workers like game pieces for their intellectual entertainment. I won’t do it again. I certainly didn’t have “fun” talking with Dr. Hicks. Not only did I grasp the stakes involved, but I was also frustrated that he was willing to “debate” anything except the only thing that mattered: Is it ethical to legitimize and amplify only dishonest anti-vaccine voices in a pandemic where over 1 million Americans have died?
I don’t think it is.
Though I won’t interact with Dr. Hicks on social media, I’m always open to different perspectives. So, I really hope he pens a rebuttal to my piece titled: Those Who Believe in Time-Traveling via Vaccines With Nanopatticles and Other Essential Pandemic Voices. You see, I don’t believe in time-traveling via vaccines with nanopatticles, my essays don’t have pictures of guillotines, and I’ve treated many COVID patients. If these character flaws aren’t disqualifying, I’d be thrilled to give a talk at the Atlas Society titled “This is What Ayn Rand Warned About”.
And while it’s unlikely they’ll platform someone who’s willing to stand alone against a group, I’m glad that Dr. Hicks and one of his critics found some common ground.

“Coronaphobia”: How antivaxxers and pandemic minimizers pathologize fear of disease
Over the weekend, Dr. Lucy McBride, a concierge medicine doctor who has become famous as a pandemic minimizer and one of the drivers of “Urgency of Normal”, Tweeted an article that she had written over a year ago about “coronaphobia”. Whether she understands it or not, this is a very old antivax trope: To pathologize fear of infectious disease as mental illness.
David Gorski on May 16, 2022
Link

I like to think that I’m plugged into social media, at least about the topics that I care about, such as medicine, quackery, vaccines, and, for the last couple of years, COVID-19. Occasionally, however, I realize that I’m not, which is what happened when I saw this Tweet from outspoken Yale epidemiologist Gregg Gonsalves Tweeted a link to an article by Dr. Lucy McBride:
I went to read the article, published in The Huffington Post and titled “I’m A Doctor Seeing Patients With Coronaphobia. Here’s What You Need To Know“. I noticed something odd immediately, namely the date (March 2, 2021, over 14 months ago). So I responded:
For whatever reason, an awful article by @drlucymcbride about "coronaphobia" from March 2021 has resurfaced on social media to make the rounds. The depressing thing is that this article could have been written today, which is perhaps why it's making the rounds again. https://t.co/YKmmVopMNx
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) May 15, 2022
This led several to point out to me that the reason this awful article was making the rounds again, over a year after it was first published, was because Dr. McBride herself had Tweeted it again on Saturday, in essence doubling down on her year-old words:
I’m finding that the “cure” for some of my patients’ outsize fear of COVID is … COVID.
“Coronaphobia” can be defined as an exaggerated fear of COVID that’s rooted in the rational anxiety of the very real threat of COVID.
(I wrote this a year ago.) 🧵https://t.co/c8Nhh1Brlr
— Lucy McBride, MD (@drlucymcbride) May 14, 2022
So basically, Dr. Social Media hadn’t noticed that Dr. McBride herself was responsible for the reappearance of her old article. Mea culpa.
I also was pointed to another article by her that was published in The Washington Post only a week later titled “I’ve been yearning for an end to the pandemic. Now that it’s here, I’m a little afraid“. One can’t help but note how, just as Dr. Marty Makary prematurely (and very confidently) declared that the pandemic would be over in April 2021 due to natural herd immunity and so many other contrarian physicians kept predicting throughout 2020-21, Dr. McBride’s expression of being “afraid” now that the end of the pandemic was imminent (in March 2021!) has not aged very well. More importantly, her labeling her patients afraid of the virus as having “coronaphobia” or, in the WaPo article “fear of normal” (or FONO), has also not aged very well. It was also particularly vile in its time because by the beginning of March 2021, most of her patients had not been vaccinated, but, as Gonsalves noted:
Remember, the EUA for the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine was issued in December. After that, healthcare and other frontline workers were first in line for the vaccine, followed by those over 65, and then the rest of the population. March 2021 was less than three months after the first frontline workers started receiving their first dose of the Pfizer vaccine, and most of the US population was still not vaccinated.
The reappearance of this article provided me with a convenient excuse to address yet another example of how, during the pandemic, everything old is new again and antivaccine talking points keep popping up again and again from pandemic minimizers and COVID-19 contrarians like Dr. McBride. In this case, it’s the pathologizing of the fear of infectious disease, representing it as an anxiety disorder, specifically a phobia, that might even need treatment. In other words, if you are afraid of COVID, you might be mentally ill.
It is not my intention to deny that there are people out there suffering from anxiety and depression due to the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic, some of whom might even require treatment. There are. What I am going to point out is how the messaging that Dr. McBride is doubling down on a year after she first promoted it is very similar to messaging that I’ve been encountering for many years coming from the antivaccine movement. Although Dr. McBride probably doesn’t realize it, she is echoing an old antivax trope that does exactly the same thing: Seeks to shame those who fear vaccine-preventable diseases. She denies up and down that that’s what she’s doing. For instance, in her HuffPo article, she wrote:
When anxiety takes on a life of its own — that is, when the cognitive, emotional, physical and behavioral manifestations of anxiety are rooted in reality but out of proportion to the actual threat — it’s time to see a doctor. After all, mental health isn’t something that we can opt out of like we can a feature on our iPhone.
Not coincidentally, her message was (and apparently still is) that anything that she doesn’t consider to be a rational fear is potentially pathological, a phobia, and her messaging has been consistent about this. As Jonathan Howard mentioned in February, her public appearances at least since those editorials have been all about minimizing the threat of COVID-19 and “helping” patients deal with their “anxiety” (coronaphobia in the HuffPo article, FONO in the WaPo article).

Let’s go back to a time before the pandemic, as much as that seems like ancient history now.
“It’s just a childhood illness”
I realize that I’ve referenced this before, but it’s time to do so again. Back before the pandemic, when fear of the MMR vaccine and thimerosal-containing vaccines, rather than COVID-19 vaccines, was the main terror being stoked by the antivaccine movement, I liked to divide antivaccine messaging into two broad categories. (There are more, obviously, but for purposes of messaging about vaccines and the pathogens targeted by the vaccines, there are two.) The first was to portray the vaccine as dangerous and/or ineffective, and the second was to portray the disease being vaccinated against as not dangerous—or even normal, a necessary experience to achieve that vaunted “natural immunity“. (Never mind that measles is actually more dangerous than had been commonly thought.) Obviously, as I’ve written many times before, these same two messages are being applied to COVID-19 and the vaccines against it, but back in the day these messages were mainly about measles, chickenpox, mumps, and other childhood illnesses.
Indeed, back in the day (e.g., in 2015), I used to refer to what I liked to call the Brady Bunch gambit, in which old sitcoms from the 1950s and 1960s where kids getting measles was played for laughs, with measles portrayed as “just a childhood illness that we all got”, were weaponized to argue that measles isn’t dangerous. I named the gambit after an episode of the classic sitcom The Brady Bunch that antivaxxers were widely referencing. The episode first aired in 1969 and featured hijinks that ensued when all the Brady kids caught the measles in rapid succession, a situation that was mostly handled humorously. It’s worth noting that this 52 year old Brady Bunch episode also features “natural immunity”. When Mike Brady (the father) and Alice (the maid) catch the measles near the end of the episode, it is revealed that they had never had measles as kids but that Mike’s wife Carol had and was therefore immune to it as an adult.
The reality was, of course, different from the fuzzy-headed nostalgic thinking of comedy writers in the 1960s, all of whom likely suffered from survivorship bias; i.e., that they had the measles and it wasn’t so bad for them, which led them to believe that it wasn’t bad for anyone. In fact—as I like to point out—according to the CDC, before the vaccine, 48,000 people a year were hospitalized for the measles; 4,000 developed measles-associated encephalitis; and 400 to 500 people died. By any stretch of the imagination that was a significant public health problem, and the introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963, followed by the MMR in 1971, made it much less so. As Dr. John Snyder reminded us nearly 13 years ago in his response to Dr. Sears making the same arguments in his vaccine book that touted an “alternative vaccination schedule”, measles is not a benign disease, regardless of what popular culture thought of it 50 or 60 years ago. (More recent data show that a severe complication of measles, subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), is more common than we used to think.) Meanwhile, over 13 years ago, Dr. Sears was claiming that “the risk of fatality from measles is “as close to zero as you can get without actually being zero”, or “one in many thousands”, in other words practically a rounding error.
Measles “phobia”
While it is obvious how such tropes might contribute to a message that you should be more afraid of the MMR vaccine (which, antivaxxers proclaimed, caused autism), let’s show some examples more directly related to Dr. McBride’s argument. For example, in 2017 in the comments section of an antivaccine blog that I’ve often referred to as a “wretched hive of scum and antivaccine quackery”, a pro-vaccine commenter named Curt Watkins (an allergist and immunologist who had apparently made the mistake of thinking that he could persuade anyone on this blog) pointed out that measles is dangerous and can kill children. He then realized the futility but still left the door open:
I guess I’m tilting at windmills by posting here, but it really gets my goat when someone claims that measles is this benign illness, shrugging off a one in 3,000 (or 1 in 10,000) case fatality rate for developed countries. In the third world the fatality rate is far higher. I challenge you to find a pediatrician with pre-vaccine experience and ask them about treating measles. If anyone cares to argue that measles is not occasionally a very serious disease, then I would be happy to engage in a discussion. I’ll check back.
A commenter named Grace Green promptly portrayed Dr. Watkins as having a phobia:
Curt Watkins, I’m very sorry for your phobia of risk-taking. I have survived measles, mumps. rubella, chickenpox and even scarlet fever! I must have been at much greater risk walking out of my front door, as a slate could have fallen on my head, and as for getting into a vehicle, the risk is huge. Come to think of it, most accidents happen in the home, so it’s not even safe to stay there! I have on the other hand lived with “mild” vaccine injury for 64 years, and it’s total misery, prevented me from working, or socializing. So I’ve seen both sides of this debate, including my sons having measles, chickenpox (twice) and whooping cough. People who haven’t had these experiences are being lead astray by fear-mongering into needlessly poisoning their children. The writers here are simply trying to warn others, from our own experiences.
The idea, of course, is that if you’re “irrationally” afraid of something as normal and not dangerous as measles, you must have a phobia, while the antivaxxer is, by comparison, the one who is rationally and carefully weighing risks and benefits. Indeed, another antivaxxer explicitly says this:
From the 1950 Merck manual on Diseases:
Prognosis
Measles usually is a benign infection with a low mortality rate and one attack apparently confers lifelong immunity. However, the disease may be followed, particularly in infants, by bronchopneumonia and other bacterial infections which may be fatal. Postmeaslcs encephalitis, which also may be fatal, occurs only about once in 1,200 to 1,500 cas
Benign doesn’t imply innocuous. Most parents I know who have elected by informed consent to decline the MMR vaccine, have an alternative medical philosophy in place on how they would support a child’s immune system, as they succumb to measles and other infections.
I must admit that I laughed, because benign actually does imply innocuous. If a disease is not innocuous, then how can it be benign?
Another common antivax message was that the fear of measles was due to physicians, public health officials, and the media “hyping” the fear and exaggerating the danger, for instance, in this antivaccine article, A Very Brady Measles, which invoked the Brady Bunch gambit:
Things are so different today. Illness is a bad word. What used to be called a common childhood disease is now viewed as impending doom. Fevers, rashes and sicknesses that last longer than a few hours are treated like the plague. Anything that can be passed from one person to another is a death sentence. These types of exaggerations fill many news stories.
And:
Catching a disease can be scary. But as we saw in the clip, the Bradys survived the measles in America. In that clip, we’re given a peek at how a TV family, likely modeled after hundreds of real-life families, treated and managed the measles with common sense. Instead falling for scare tactics and being filled with doom and gloom, we saw that the parents used good judgment. We saw that the kids rode out the illness. They rested, they got better, and they survived. And God love her, Alice did too.
Sure, in a fictional idealized late 1960s suburban Los Angeles upper middle class white neighborhood, the kids all did fine when they got the measles, as did the two adults who had somehow never had it. Unfortunately, such was not the case for many thousands of others every year before the vaccine, at which time approximately 500 per year would die.
Dr. Bob Sears and Dr. Lucy McBride: Compare and contrast
It wasn’t just antivaxxers, either. It was some physicians, too, who portrayed the fear of measles as irrational and stoked by the media. For example, in 2014, Dr. Bob Sears, author of The Vaccine Book: Making the Right Decision for Your Child, which was the original “alternative vaccine schedule” for antivaxxers, actually complained about parents asking him if they should be worried about measles, to the point where he got a bit…testy and basically told his patients’ parents to stop bothering him with their panicked questions about measles:
No doubt that Dr. McBride, should she even see this, will bristle at the comparison. She, after all, has advocated that adults be vaccinated. On the other hand, she also helped to found the “Urgency of Normal” astroturf effort to open up schools, in which she argued:
In addition to ending mask mandates in schools, she [Dr. McBride] told me, she wants required quarantines to end, as well as testing for asymptomatic children. “The problem right now is we’re isolating and quarantining healthy kids,” she said, arguing that the decision to quarantine a child who is exposed to the virus should be up to parents and pediatricians. (Public health experts have told me this policy would likely lead to further spread, since people are highly infectious before they ever show symptoms. This could be particularly problematic if masks are not required in classrooms.)
In fairness, though, Dr. Sears comes off as a prat complaining about his patients’ parents—whose children, of course, were mostly unvaccinated because, after all, this was Dr. Sears’ practice—being too fearful and anxious about measles outbreaks, to the point of being dismissive in the final part of his Facebook post above:
This year there will be more than usual, the way it’s looking so far, but it’s not a reason to panic. Make your choice – do vaccine, or don’t do the vaccine.
So, when SHOULD someone worry? If an actual direct exposure has occurred from a known case, then you might be at risk. This doesn’t mean a case in the county in which you live: it means that you’ve actually been in the same room with someone who has had measles. Or, at the most, maybe the same building. But transmission almost always requires close proximity (same room). There have been a handful of cases over the decades in which someone sitting across a stadium has caught it, but that is almost unheard of. You have to be in the same room, people. If THAT happens, call me. If not, then just relax and go about your life as usual.
IF we see more cases, I’ll let you know. Actually, just to give you a heads up, we probably WILL see a few more cases. But virtually all measles outbreaks are limited to 10 to 20 cases in any given county. So, the chance that any one of your unvaccinated children is going to be a case is very very very very very small. I love you all, and love caring for you all. But just chill out. Measles will never go away – it’s always going to be a very small risk. If you aren’t comfortable with that, get the vaccine. If you don’t want the vaccine, accept the risk.
Even eight years later, one can’t help but observe the reason why most measles outbreaks were small back then. Can you guess what it was? Obviously, it was because of generally high vaccine uptake in the communities in which the outbreaks occurred that tended to limit such outbreaks to the pockets of unvaccinated children living there.
From the perspective of 2022 compared to 2014, Dr. Sears’ message actually still sounds more than a little like the message that Dr. McBride and other COVID-19 pandemic minimizers have been promoting: COVID-19 will never go away. It’s on you how much risk you’re willing to accept. Vaccinate and mask if you’re worried, but don’t expect anyone else to do the same (or even to isolate if exposed or be quarantined if symptomatic). Chill out.
The only real difference is that Dr. McBride takes the narrative that people are afraid because of the media and government promoting fear-based messages, and kicks it up a notch by implying that a lot of this is “coronaphobia”, namely an actual, potentially diagnosable phobia, and, even worse, suggesting that the “cure” for this “coronaphobia” is to actually catch COVID-19, although she rapidly pivoted to deny that:
… and to recognize the very real physical, emotional, and behavioral effects that anxiety-laden headlines/messaging can have on people, particularly those who are *already* vulnerable to fear & anxiety.
COVID is an ongoing, real threat. And some degree of anxiety is normal..
— Lucy McBride, MD (@drlucymcbride) May 14, 2022
And to argue that we should “name” this fear and anxiety, while cynically invoking Mental Health Awareness Month:
The challenge is *calibrating* our public health & personal responses to C19 to the level of actual risk…to protect against C10 & the harms of living in a constant state of fear.
It’s #MentalHealthAwarenessMonth
Instead of dismissing ppl w anxiety about COVID, let’s name it.
— Lucy McBride, MD (@drlucymcbride) May 14, 2022
Again, let me emphasize that there is little doubt that the pandemic has caused or exacerbated a lot of anxiety and depression. Also, to be fair, Dr. McBride is correct that some anxiety over a potentially deadly illness circulating through the population is normal and expected. However, by “naming” this anxiety (as she puts it) and calling it “coronaphobia” she is, contrary to what she thinks she’s doing, not making things easier. She’s pathologizing this anxiety while providing no real solution other than her anti-anxiety regimen that she describes:
To mitigate the expected anxiety — rational or irrational — we assemble a kit of coping tools. I commonly recommend breathing techniques, guided meditation, regular exercise, prioritizing sleep and spending time in nature, all of which tamp down stress hormones.
All of this is well and good, but also the sorts of things one would expect a concierge doctor practicing in an affluent DC neighborhood who doesn’t have any contracts with health insurance companies or maintain Medicare assignment to tell not just her patients who have anxiety over COVID-19 but the worried well. There’s also a degree of privilege here, in that her well-off patients can do these sorts of things far more easily than those who are less privileged and well-off.
At the same time, Dr. McBride, whether she realizes it or not or will admit it or not, regularly parrots longstanding antivaccine messaging about childhood diseases like measles:
    • The disease is not dangerous to children (and most adults).
    • The medical, public health, and media response are overblown and fueling panic.
    • Fear of the disease is an anxiety disorder, a phobia, that is now doing more harm than the disease (and was doing more harm a year ago).
    • People should vaccinate or not depending on their perception of risk.
    • Isolation after exposure is unnecessary and an overreaction.
    • No quarantines.
    • No mandates of any kind, mask or vaccine.
I will, however, admit that, unlike Dr. Bob, she’s smart enough to be self-deprecating, for instance, describing her accepting her first invitation to a gathering thusly:
With a mix of reticence and relief, I click “RSVP YES!” to my colleagues’ party and take my first step toward reentry. The next step? Buttoning my pants.
She also goes out of her way to claim that the reason she’s bringing up mental health issues and describing pandemic anxiety as “coronaphobia” is because of her incredible empathy for her patients:
I feel particularly sad for my more anxious elderly patients who, bc of age, are indeed at highest risk for serious outcomes from C19 and who suffer from social isolation. Obviously my job is to help ppl manage risk but C19 is only one threat to their health & wellbeing.
— Lucy McBride, MD (@drlucymcbride) May 14, 2022
Dr. Gonsalves had an excellent response:
All of which is true, but hasn’t stopped Dr. McBride from self-deprecatingly portraying herself as just “trying to work it all out”:
And instead of shaming ppl for living their lives w a different risk tolerance than our own, let’s give each other a little latitude & grace.
This is not a sermon.😆
I’m trying to take my own advice as I help others navigate the art & science of living with risk all around us.
— Lucy McBride, MD (@drlucymcbride) May 14, 2022
Also, I can’t help but cite something that antivaxxer Del Bigtree Tweeted over two years ago, before vaccines and when the virus was new:
Don’t miss The HighWire tomorrow!#CoronaPhobia #Top10 #DershowitzDebate #DelvsDersh #Covid19Vaccine #Coronavirus #Covid19 #WednesdayWisdom pic.twitter.com/EfWb3aIjsw
— The HighWire (@HighWireTalk) May 20, 2020
I also would argue that “coronaphobia” is not unlike what Bigtree said in another context, either.
The problem is that, regardless of what Dr. McBride actually says to her own patients in the privacy of her clinic exam rooms, her public utterances do amount to a shaming of those who remain, often with very good reason (e.g., chronic health conditions), fearful of COVID-19 as having unreasonable fears out of proportion to reality; i.e., an anxiety disorder, a phobia. Certainly, her “coronaphobia” label contributes to that shaming:
The mockery of patients. The assumption that fear is fear for themselves. The refusal to see the larger problem: climate change and the future pandemics it predicts. Show me someone who diagnoses Coronaphobia, & I'll show you someone who doesn't think beyond their own nose.
— Loretta Torrago (@Loretta_Torrago) May 15, 2022
I’ll conclude, as I do too often, by simply reiterating that in the age of the pandemic everything old is new again. Every antivaccine and disease minimizing/denying narrative and trope that I have seen thus far about COVID-19 existed long before the pandemic in one form or another. To this I will add the observation that in the age of the pandemic it has been disturbing to see how many doctors who consider themselves so very reasonable, science-based, and even—dare I say it?—provaccine have found those pre-COVID-19 narratives compelling. Implying that those who have an overwrought fear of a vaccine-preventable disease must have a diagnosable mental health condition, such as an anxiety disorder like a phobia, is just another example.

They Have Names, Part 2
“We share their names because their name is part of their story.”
Jonathan Howard on April 10, 2022
Link

My Position
In a previous essay, I argued that though it must be done very thoughtfully, it is important to share the stories of children who died of COVID. One reason to share these stories is they are true. We should remember these were actual children, not just statistics on a government website.
Additionally, parents may be motivated to vaccinate their children after learning that they are not entirely immune to catastrophic outcomes from the virus. Vaccine advocates have long known the power of pictures and narrative to influence vaccination choices- unfortunately so have dishonest anti-vaxxers. As vaccine-advocate Gregory Travis said, the March of Dimes “plastered pictures of kids in iron lungs everywhere as a way to raise awareness of the impact of polio in children It was powerful and it led directly to an effective vaccine.”
Moreover, recent research showed that “that highlighting factual information about the dangers of communicable diseases can positively impact people’s attitudes to vaccination.” Barring a giant media conspiracy, the news stories of children who die of COVID are all factual. Pediatric vaccination rates are abysmally low, largely because too many parents believe the virus doesn’t impact children at all. Some people don’t want parents to know that the virus can seriously hurt a small percentage of children and that the vaccine is effective at keeping them safe and out of the hospital.
My position, and that of many other doctors, is that sharing stories of deceased children is worthwhile for the sake of keeping more children healthy and alive.
A Different Position
Not everyone sees it this way. Dr. Shamez Ladhani, a pediatrician in the UK who has fear-mongered about the vaccine, said,
Maybe it’s just me, but as a parent and paediatrician, I think putting up the names & pictures of children who may or may not have died of #Covid19 on social media is crass & undignified. I did not include the link to those tweets out of respect for the children & their families
First of all, let’s take note of some interesting framing here. Dr. Ladhani says that people are sharing “names & pictures of children who may or may not have died of COVID19.” He is saying that some children purported to have died of COVID actually died of other causes. Does he have evidence he has that this is happening on a frequent basis? What exactly does he think is killing these children?
Additionally, Dr. Ladhani said that sharing news stories of children who die of COVID is “crass & undignified.” Does he feel it is crass and undignified to share stories of children who die of cancer or violence? Is it crass and undignified to share stories of adults who died of COVID?
Unfortunately, the UK was one of the last countries with abundant supply to vaccinate its children. The vaccine was made available to children ages 5-11 years just last month. It’s not clear what this extra waiting bought for the UK, beyond mass infection of its children and subsequent closing of its schools.
Though it’s hard to believe, I described previously how mass pediatric infections were a desired outcome by influential people there. For example, a sociologist advising the UK vaccine regulators, Robert Dingwall, said that school closures may, “have an immediate cost in terms of depriving children of the opportunity to acquire immunity to the infection”. He also said, “Given the low risk of Covid for most teenagers, it is not immoral to think that they may be better protected by natural immunity generated through infection than by asking them to take the possible risk of a vaccine”.
Perhaps this is why some people now don’t want to hear about children who died of COVID and why they suggest that something other than the virus is killing them.
Teresa Sperry
One parent who lost her child to COVID saw Dr. Ladhani’s Tweet and disagreed with him. Teresa Sperry was a 10-year old girl from Virginia who died of COVID last year, before she was eligible to be vaccinated. According to her mother, Nicole Sperry, “She loved dancing, singing, drawing, playing in the rain.” She was likely exposed at school as apparently “her classroom job was to take sick classmates to the nurse’s office.” According to a news article about the family.
Last week, the Sperry family, with the help from the Glaser Progress Foundation from Seattle, created the Our Missing Stars foundation.
“Just being able to carry on her compassion for other people, that’s the driving force,” Sperry said.
“We definitely started with our intention of being able to honor Teresa, and not just her, but recognizing hopefully other children that have died from COVID and MIS-C.”
A video on the foundation’s Facebook page shows their commitment to their daughter’s memory and the memory of others.
“COVID took her within five days. The only way this makes sense is if my daughter saves people. I don’t want other people feeling this,” Jeff Sperry said.
The mission of the organization they found is: “Preventing unnecessary deaths by encouraging others to get vaccinated.”
Nicole Sperry
Ms. Sperry saw Dr. Ladhani’s social media post and sought to counter the narrative that sharing the existence of her child and her manner of death was “crass & undignified.” She responded to him by saying,
As a parent of 1 of the children that have died from covid, Im proud her name Teresa is shared. Ive heard from many people that they NOW take covid seriously hearing her story. Same w/children w/cancer or diabetes. We share their names because their name is part of their story.
Jeff and Nicole Sperry don’t want another child to suffer or die for want of a vaccine. It’s astonishing that this desire is controversial.

An Open Letter to ZDoggMD
I hope you’ll agree with me that the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media should have no trouble sharing all of the facts about COVID-19 and children on a very frequent basis.
Jonathan Howard on January 21, 2022
Link

Dear. ZDoggMD,
During a recent social media kerfuffle, you referred to yourself as “arguably the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media“. Indeed, you’ve hosted credible individuals like Dr. Paul Offit who spoke eloquently on the dangers COVID-19 poses to children and how the vaccine can prevent these harms. You posted a video of your own daughter getting vaccinated. I’m glad she’s safe, and this video certainly helped others decide to vaccinate their children. I thought this video you made on vaccinating kids was fair, and your discussion of vaccine myths was mostly reasonable. You say that you’ve helped convince many skeptical people to get vaccinated. I am sure this is true. This is amazing and we all benefit from these successes.
You also stated that “we ultimately want the same thing: the best health for the most people”. With this in mind, I compiled several facts about the vaccine, virus, and children that every doctor who advocates for vaccines should share as widely as possible. Not all of the facts about the virus are catastrophic and not all facts about the vaccine are positive. I think we agree that nuance and balance are important. In compiling this information, I don’t mean to imply that you haven’t shared any of it. You absolutely have shared a lot of it, particularly information about how the virus has harmed children.
Facts about children and COVID-19
    • Almost all kids will be fine: The vast majority of kids with COVID-19 will be fine. A child who contracts COVID-19 has an extremely low risk of dying. That the virus mostly spares children from severe disease is the only good thing I can say about it.
    • The virus can kill some children: While it’s true that a child who contracts COVID-19 has an extremely low risk of dying, millions of children have contracted the virus and rare harms have added up. According to the CDC’s COVID-19 data tracker, the virus has killed 1,131 children so far, most of them in the past 6 months. About 1 in 65,000 children in America have already died of COVID-19, and 2-3 children die of COVID-19 every day. This includes teenagers who were eligible to be vaccinated and some children without underlying conditions. The most common underlying conditions in children who die from COVID-19 are obesity and asthma. These children were robbed of many decades of life.
    • COVID-19 has hospitalized many children: Though death is the worst outcome from COVID-19, it is not the only bad one. Accurate numbers are hard to come by, but around 100,000 children have been hospitalized due to COVID-19. This means that about 1 in 740 American children have been hospitalized with COVID-19. More children are being infected than ever before, and therefore more children are being hospitalized now than ever before. Currently, 904 children are being hospitalized every day with COVID-19, an enormous number even accounting for incidental infections. During New York City’s recent omicron surge, 54% of hospitalized children had no comorbidities, and 70% were symptomatic. Just 2.1% of admissions were incidental infections from trauma. Though most children stay just a few days, with past variants, up to 33% of them need ICU-level care and 6-10% need intubation. Very rarely, children have needed amputations or lung transplants. Fortunately, frontline pediatricians say that the omicron variant is milder than the delta variant, however the greatly increased number of infections means that rare harms are still accumulating. These rare but severe harms are why it is misleading to simply compare the rates of myocarditis between the virus and the vaccine. The virus can do a lot more than cause myocarditis.
    • COVID-19-related myocarditis can be severe: Additionally, multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) can cause severe myocarditis, and there have been at least 6,431 cases in the US, possibly many more. 55 children have died from this. Studies have reported coronary artery aneurysms and acute heart failure in children with MIS-C. Other common cardiac complications of myocarditis due to MIS-C include “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Cardiac arrhythmias have led “to hemodynamic collapse and need for ECMO support” in some children. This doesn’t happen with the vaccine.
    • We have a lot to learn about long COVID: We don’t know everything about long-COVID in children. However, some children are sick for a long time, and we have to be humble about the potential long-term complications from a new virus.
    • Kids have lost their parents: According to reports, “the number of kids who have lost a parent or in-home caretaker is an estimated 167,000.”
Facts about the vaccine: Efficacy
There is robust real-world evidence that the vaccine can keep adolescents healthy, alive, and out of the hospital. All pro-vaccine doctors should share this information as often as possible.
    • Study 1: In hospitalized adolescents, “179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.”
    • Study 2: “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents.”
    • Study 3: “Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one was fully vaccinated.”
    • Study 4: Vaccine effectiveness “…was 92% against SARS-CoV-2 infections irrespective of symptom status.”
    • Study 5: “97/102 children with MIS-C were unvaccinated. None of the 5 vaccinated MIS-C patients required respiratory or cardiovascular life support (invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or ECMO) compared to 38/97 unvaccinated MIS-C patients.”
    • Study 6: “In 33 adolescents with MIS-C eligible for vaccination…0 had been fully vaccinated, 7 had received 1 dose.”
    • Study 7: “Of the case patients, 180 (40%) were admitted to the ICU, and 127 (29%) required life support; only 2 patients in the ICU had been fully vaccinated. The overall effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine against hospitalization for Covid-19 was 94%. The effectiveness was 98% against ICU admission and 98% against Covid-19 resulting in the receipt of life support. All 7 deaths occurred in patients who were unvaccinated.”
An important caveat is that the vaccine may be less effective against omicron and future variants. However, the majority of children ages 5 and older who were admitted to the hospital during NYC’s omicron surge were unvaccinated.
Facts about the vaccine: Safety
    • Vaccine myocarditis frequency: The rate of vaccine myocarditis varies widely from one study to another, but it is primarily a concern for adolescent boys after their second vaccine dose. One study from Hong Kong found a rate of 1 in 2,700 for male adolescents after their second shot, while one study from Denmark found no increased rate at all in young men from the Pfizer vaccine. Most studies find a rate in between these two extremes. This article summarizes the available studies well and overall, a rate of about 1 in 7,000 adolescent boys after their second shot with the Pfizer vaccine seems a reasonable estimate to me. The Pfizer vaccine, which is what children receive, is safer than the Moderna vaccine, and a long interval between the two doses lowers the risk. The risk for younger children and from boosters is much lower than this. As very few adolescents are getting their second shot currently, I am confident that the number of times each of us has discussed this topic exceeds the number of children currently hospitalized with it.
    • Vaccine myocarditis severity: While its exact rate isn’t clear, an extremely consistent finding is that vaccine myocarditis is much less severe than viral myocarditis. This is often overlooked by those who merely compare the rates of the two conditions and neglect that the virus can cause much more than myocarditis. Short-term outcomes in vaccine-myocarditis from multiple case series and government agencies in different countries have been consistently favorable. All studies on this topic report that “most vaccine-associated myocarditis events have been mild and self-limiting” and “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly“. Most individuals are hospitalized, but almost all leave in just a few days after receiving simple treatments. In the entire world, no child has needed to be intubated as far as I know and none have died. Most, though not all, are symptom-free after follow-up. Experts in the subject universally agree that “we do not have any conceivable danger signal that would outweigh the benefit of vaccination“. As one person wryly put it, “Every hospital has a covid ward. No hospital has a vaccine injury ward.” Nonetheless, long-term monitoring for potential cardiac scarring is needed, and we both agree the condition should not be minimized.
I would not consider you “arguably the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media” when it comes to children
Having acknowledged the many positive contributions you’ve made to children this pandemic, let me explain why I would not consider you “arguably the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media” when it comes to children. In fact, your podcasts have spread a great deal of misinformation about COVID-19 and children. Meanwhile, vital information remains unmentioned.
For example, I apologize if missed it (you have a lot of material), but I’ve not heard you mention any of the studies showing vaccines protect adolescents. Two of these studies preceded videos (here and here) you made on vaccinating children, but you did not mention them. Why not? Your audience will certainly know the vaccine can cause myocarditis. This is entirely appropriate of course, and I’ve written several detailed, nuanced articles on this topic where I argued that “vaccine-myocarditis should not be trivialized”. However, your audience will not know the vaccine is extremely effective at preventing rare, but catastrophic outcomes in adolescents. Don’t you think parents should know this information?
I’d really love to be proven wrong, but it’s hard to imagine there will ever be a segment on your podcast with Dr. Vinay Prasad called “7 Real-World Studies Showing the Vaccine Works in Adolescents”. This is astonishing when you think about it. Shouldn’t the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media be willing to share accurate information about the vaccine for children at every opportunity? Shouldn’t the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media have shared these important results multiple times already? I suspect if these studies showed the vaccine failed to protect adolescents, you and Dr. Prasad would have discussed them as often as vaccine-myocarditis, which is to say all the time. This approach doesn’t seem “nuanced” or “alt-middle” to me.
Additionally, you’ve made problematic statements about children and COVID-19. In a podcast from 4/2021, you questioned whether school closings were justified by saying,
Even though this thing has killed less than you know, or, or about as many as flu would kill in a normal year in kids, I say hardly any. I mean, again, it’s not, that’s not that’s not compassionate to the people who’ve lost children. Right?
I’ve never argued for closing schools, but I recognize this is an extremely misleading comparison and inappropriate way for “the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media to speak” about dead children. When you said this, over 300 children had died of COVID-19, a number that would have been significantly higher without mitigation measures. Anti-vaxxers would agree with you, but I don’t think 300 dead children is “hardly any”. We don’t talk about children who die in school shootings this way. Of course, we routinely vaccinate children for diseases that killed fewer children than this.
It’s true that at that point COVID-19 had killed about the same number of children as a bad flu season, a disease for which we vaccinate children. However, it makes no sense to compare the death tolls of the two viruses in this way. Mitigation measures that dented COVID-19 obliterated the flu. During the same time period when COVID-19 killed 300 children, 1 child died of the flu. Though your guests often claim otherwise, anyone who can count knows that COVID-19 is much deadlier for children than the flu. However, since they heard misinformation, your listeners will be misinformed. This is a pattern, as I will discuss.
You’ve repeatedly platformed guests who spread blatantly false information about covid-19 and children
Beyond this, you’ve repeatedly platformed guests who spread blatantly false information about COVID-19 and children, always minimizing the dangers of the virus and always overstating harms of the vaccine. I’m not talking about doctors who reasonably have different opinions about grey areas, such as the need for boosters in young people or vaccine mandates.
Rather, many of your guests simply get the most basic facts wrong over and over again or selectively omit information to advance a grossly misleading narrative. It’s been horrifying but fascinating to witness in real time how myths about COVID-19 and children get created in the closed media echo chamber of contrarian doctors and then widely disseminated on Fox News and The Wall Street Journal, influencing policy for large parts of the country with tragic consequences. These myths get cleverly branded as “nuance”, and those who seek to provide accurate information are accused of “groupthink“.
For example, Dr. Marty Makary claimed on your podcast that there’s “never been a documented case of an entirely healthy kid dying of COVID“. He referenced his “analysis with FAIR Health” to claim no healthy child had died of COVID-19. In his analysis, 3 children, all with underlying conditions, died of COVID-19. Based on these 3 children, Dr. Markary informed your listeners that “there was not a single healthy kid who’d died”. He neglected to mention that his “analysis” reported on fewer than 1% of the pediatric deaths at that time.
It’s clearly extremely rare for a healthy child to die of COVID-19, but several had by the time Dr. Makary made his false claim (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here). A five-second Google search was all it took to learn he was spreading misinformation to your audience. Moreover, in a study of 121 decedents under 21 years, about 25% were healthy, information that was available when Dr. Markary made his false claim. Though you and I both know that the most common underlying conditions in children who die of COVID-19 are obesity and asthma, Dr. Makary wants people to believe only children with devastating conditions such as leukemia die from COVID-19. Who knew your prior discussion with him about “COVID-19 Fake News” was actually a preview of coming attractions?
Additionally, in a podcast from 2/2021 called “Should We Vaccinate Kids for COVID“, Dr. Prasad spread misinformation, saying “it is generally not controversial to argue that SARS-CoV-2 in kids is roughly, roughly the same as influenza, maybe even less severe than influenza, seasonal influenza in kids”. At least 227 children had died of COVID-19 when he said this, while 1 child died of the flu during this time. In the past two years, COVID-19 killed over 1,100 children while the flu killed 4 children. In the same time period when COVID-19 hospitalized over 8,300 children ages 5-11, the flu hospitalized just 9 children this age. So no, COVID-19 is not “maybe even less severe than influenza” for children, but your listeners will think that it is.
Dr. Prasad further said that the risk of a child dying of COVID was “about one in a million” and “let’s say to save that one life, you gotta inoculate a million kids with vaccination to save one life”. As at least 227 children had died of COVID-19 when he said this, a death rate of 1 in a million would necessitate 227 million pediatric infections. In reality, there are just 74 million children in the USA. Unless 300% of American children had contracted COVID-19 by this time last year, this too is false.
Your guests have labored to create fear, uncertainly, and doubt about vaccinating children
In addition to downplaying the severity of COVID-19 for children, many of your guests have labored to create fear, uncertainly, and doubt about vaccinating children. Unsurprisingly, Dr, Makary spread misinformation about the vaccine, tweeting on 11/2021 the false information that no healthy child ages 5-11 died of COVID-19 and that he expected “15 would die from the vax 2nd dose“. This was absurd anti-vaccine nonsense, but a lot of people trust him. Subsequent data showed the vaccine has proven extremely safe in this age group, with 11 verified myocarditis cases after 8.7 million vaccine doses. 7 of these children have recovered and 4 were “recovering.” No children died. Have you shared this important information yet?
As you know, Dr. Prasad opposed the Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for children. He claimed in May 2021 that an EUA for children was not needed since “after all adults are vaccinated” COVID-19 would no longer threaten children. As I pointed out at the time, Dr. Prasad wildly overestimated vaccine uptake in adults and irresponsibly neglected the possibility of new variants. I have previously criticized his writing on COVID-19 and children for its gross omissions of key facts and lack of nuance. Dr. Prasad even suggested on your podcast “Should We Vaccinated Kids for COVID“, that fevers after vaccination were legitimate points against the pediatric EUA. You largely agreed saying, “Imagine you do this to hundreds of thousands of children. Just by sheer happenstance, you’re gonna have a certain number of complications, just in terms of febrile complications”.
Fortunately regulators with skin in the game used accurate numbers, didn’t panic about post-vaccination fevers, and wisely issued an EUA for children. Had they taken Dr. Prasad’s advice, no healthy child under the age of 16 would be vaccinated today. Your daughter, my son, and their entire classroom would all be unvaccinated. Could schools stay open then? Of course not. They are having a hard time already.
Another of your guests, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, explicitly opposes vaccinating children against COVID-19. He’s been very clear that “I don’t think if there’s any good reason to vaccinate kids that young did for kids, they face a vanishingly small risk from COVID itself, near zero from mortality from COVID…I think that it is a mistake to think about this, as good for kids. It’s not good for kids.” How is this at all different from something that Andrew Wakefield might say about vaccinating children? It’s not, of course.
It gets worse. In an article titled, “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“, he wrote,
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
In the middle of the worst pandemic in 100 years, he feels it is “more dangerous for public health” to vaccinate everyone than to vaccinate no one. This is astonishing. He actively wants children infected saying “those who are at minimal risk of death” should “live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection”. It’s no wonder congressmen and judges ridicule him and repeatedly deem his testimony unreliable.
In contrast, you handed him a microphone multiple times and portrayed him a sympathetic victim, saying he had been “censored“. Though he wants children to get the virus not the vaccine, you lavished him with praise, telling him “You’re fearless, you’re compassionate, you’re rational”. That’s how I feel about frontline pediatricians taking care of a sick children in the ICU now or begging misinformed parents to vaccinate their child in the clinic. Maybe it’s becoming clear why I don’t think of you as “the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media” when it comes to children.
Predictably, Dr. Bhattacharya used the platform you gave him to spread misinformation. He claimed that “early in the epidemic and we’re killing patients with ventilators”. Who is this “we” he is talking about I wonder? He’s never come close to treating a COVID-19 patient, or any patient for that matter. Despite his spectator status, he’s happy to spread baseless conspiracy theories about doctors who actually have real-world responsibility for treating COVID-19. As I discussed previously, not only is there no evidence that doctors killed patients through aggressive intubations, it directly contradicts all the available evidence. Your listeners won’t know that. The notion the people died from ventilators not COVID-19 was just an internet rumor, though a dangerous one given the violence against healthcare workers today.
Moreover, even though 300 children had died of COVID-19 and tens of thousands had been hospitalized when you interviewed Dr. Bhattacharya in April 2021, he merely said children’s “risk of COVID is quite small”. There’s a reason so few of your guests are willing to enumerate how COVID-19 has harmed children. They aren’t stupid. They know normal people won’t think of hundreds of dead children and tens of thousands of hospitalized children as something to brush off.
So instead of simply stating the facts, they dance around them by saying “the risk of suicide in non-COVID times is typically 10 times higher“. What does this have to do with whether children should be vaccinated against COVID-19? Absolutely nothing. I discussed previously why these factoids are useless distractions designed to pacify people about the danger COVID-19 poses to children. It’s true that COVID-19 has killed 10 times the number of children that die in bike accidents each year. But this is not an argument in favor of vaccinating children against COVID-19, is it?
Unsurprisingly, Dr. Bhattacharya also warned against vaccinating children on your podcast, saying “there’s a chance they’re gonna miss two days of school because they have headache, fever and muscle aches from the vaccine”. You basically agreed saying “you’re assuming all the risks with none of the benefits, if the risk is minuscule.” It apparently didn’t occur to either of you that children could get vaccinated on a Friday or that they might miss school (or worse) because they contracted COVID-19.
You and your guests have repeatedly declared the pandemic over
Additionally, you and your guests have repeatedly declared the pandemic over. In May 2021, you discussed Dr. Makary’s infamous prediction of herd immunity by April 2021 by telling him:
You were pretty much right about everything, ’cause cases have plummeted, natural immunity does contribute, and probably the left was like, “Oh, who is this fascist going on Fox News, “saying that this thing’s over?”
It turns out “the left” was right about Dr. Makary’s ridiculous prediction, and he’s been pretty much wrong about many things. Would the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media mock the virus by saying “variants, shmariants“? You did that several times. Who can forget you laughing about “variants, shmariants” along with Dr. Monica Gandhi in a podcast called “The End of the Pandemic” from 2/2021? You warned then not about the virus, but about a “contagion of panic and fear”.
You mocked a young couple you saw on a plane for “wearing two masks, a full goggles, like they’re flying a plane”. You said this cautious behavior was a “pet peeve” of yours and that young, healthy people “need to be out doing their thing. Instead, they’re hiding behind two face shields”. These passengers bothered you so much, you mocked them on a subsequent podcast, saying they were “wearing like hazmat suits on a plane…What are you doing? I mean, it looks cool, but not really.” You spoke passionately against “shaming parents for not getting their kids vaccinated”. I agree. But you’re clearly OK shaming certain people, namely young people who are trying hard to avoid the virus. Do you feel they are doing something wrong?
Dr. Prasad seems to feel that way. At the literal peak of death for the entire pandemic, during the winter wave of 2021, on a day when 3,322 Americans died, he sarcastically tweeted,
I want to write a children’s book about a bear who didn’t want to leave home till it was perfectly safe. He never left and life passed him by.
Hundreds of thousands of Americans have died since he sent that mocking tweet. I guess you could say life passed them by.
After the delta variant ravaged India, you said in May 2021 that “everybody’s wetting their pants about it” and that the variant “isn’t driving a lot of that poor outcome”. You continued, “Hope is accurate. It’s not like we’re slinging a lie”. Though the death rate remained low, the delta variant would go on to kill hundreds of American children, including unvaccinated teens who were eligible to be vaccinated. Hope, sadly, is not always accurate. The virus has proven it doesn’t listen to contrarian doctors who claim we’ve reached herd immunity month after month and that we need to stop “living in fear“.
The idea that anyone who tries to avoid the virus is “living in fear” is a common theme for contrarian doctors. I’ll confess, I’ve never understood it. Fear can be an awful feeling. I had nightmares right before COVID-19 hit NYC, and I had to take medication to sleep for the first time ever. I was spared the worst of it, but in nearby hospitals they had to use forklifts to move the dead bodies. I hope the people who had to do that are doing OK. Some healthcare workers, especially nurses who’ve travelled from one hotspot to the next, have seen thousands of people die this pandemic. One of them said, “War doesn’t even compare to this“. Maybe you should have one of them as a guest. Someone who has actually treated a lot of COVID-19 patients would certainly bring a new perspective to your podcast.
No one likes being afraid of course, but few of us would be alive today without the capacity to feel fear. We neurologists know that people who lose their amygdalae don’t function too well in the world. Though fear it unpleasant, it is useful and necessary. There have been legitimate reasons for people – even young, healthy ones – to be afraid this pandemic. Getting a “mild” case of COVID-19 can be a really miserable experience.
Moreover, as my friend Loretta said, the best way to reduce fear is to reduce danger. Maybe if more people feared the virus, the headlines wouldn’t read “U.S. sets fresh records for Covid hospitalizations and cases with 1.5 million new infections“. Maybe the pandemic would be closer to over. Soon, 1 out of every 300 Americans will have died from the virus.
You don’t see it this way it seems. You and Dr. Gandhi even made a podcast in 10/2020 titled “How to Stop Living in Fear of COVID” where you said “the fear that’s driving this pandemic has been heartbreaking to see”. I wonder how many of your listeners decided to stop fearing the virus. I wonder what happened to them and their families. (Notably, Dr. Monica Gandhi wrote an excellent essay on vaccinating children.)
Your guests have credibility partly because they are your guests, and you once had a well-deserved reputation as a vaccine-advocate who didn’t tolerate anti-vaccine nonsense
You are not responsible for what your guests say, of course. However, you are responsible for who is on your show and how your respond to them. As few of your guests work with sick children, they are shielded from the consequences of their words, as are you. They’ll never work in an overwhelmed pediatric hospital, and, except for Dr. Offit, doctors who actually work with sick children are unlikely to be on your program to encourage pediatric vaccination. Why is that?
It seems odd to me that you haven’t had multiple pediatricians on to speak about what they are seeing in the hospital right now. I am sure there are plenty of wonderful pediatricians who would be happy to be on your show. As an adult neurologist/psychiatrist, I know I’d learn a ton from listening to you talk to them. Like nearly all of your guests, I have no idea what it is actually like to care for a child in the ICU. I bet your listeners know even less.
Since you and your guests advocate for adult vaccination, I know you’ll perceive this letter as “friendly fire”. I sent you a draft of this letter to make sure there were no glaring inaccuracies, and you made it clear that I should instead focus on the “actual anti-vaxxers.” I hope it’s clear by now that countering anti-vaccine misinformation is exactly why I am writing this letter. If Dr. Bhattacharya is not an “actual anti-vaxxer” when it comes to children and COVID-19, then who is?
If you doubt me, just listen to the “actual anti-vaxxers”. They often see your guests as allies. One journalist accurately described Dr. Makary as the “darling of the anti-vaxxers“. Anti-vaccine super-crank RFK Jr. has amplified Dr. Prasad and Dr. Makary. He can recognize doctors who he feels validate his message. Anti-vaxxers eagerly support your guests on social media, and that matters. In contrast, doctors who seek to provide accurate information are blocked en masse. It seems your guests don’t really value discussion and debate. I guess they just need a safe space.
The fact that your guests are not “actually anti-vaxxers” makes them appear more credible when they discourage vaccinating children. Their misinformation is much more pernicious than obviously ridiculous anti-vaxxer balderdash. Since they are not saying COVID-19 is a 5G hoax by Bill Gates to microchip us all, their misinformation is much harder for the average person to recognize. But telling parents more children died from the flu last year than COVID-19 or that the vaccine will likely kill as many children as the virus is absolutely misinformation. Most people can easily spot anti-vaccine quacks. In contrast, your guests have credibility partly because they are your guests, and you once had a well-deserved reputation as a vaccine-advocate who didn’t tolerate anti-vaccine nonsense.
Now, instead of refuting this nonsense, you’ve legitimized and amplified those who spread it. Your listeners think they are getting “nuance,” and that only you and your “fearless” guests will level with them about the vaccine’s imperfections. In reality, much of the time your listeners heard incomplete information and misinformation. Reasonable people can differ about various policies, such as mandates for children. But such debate requires that people come to the table equipped with the same facts. Your guests have made that an impossibility.
Furthermore, I believe your guests, with their impressive credentials, supreme confidence, and enormous media reach, bear as much responsibility for truly abysmal pediatric COVID-19 vaccination rates as the “actual anti-vaxxers”. It’s no wonder just 18% of children ages 5-11 are fully vaccinated against COVID-19. Their misinformed parents think COVID-19 “less severe than influenza” or that healthy children have zero risk from the virus. The only thing they know about the vaccine is that it can cause myocarditis.
COVID-19 will fade into the background one day. However, sick children will be your guests’ lasting legacy. And since sick children (and sick teachers) lead to closed schools and disrupted learning, this too will be their legacy. Your guests often utter the words “schools must be open“. This empty mantra is a form of virtue signalling for them. However, they’ve opposed every method of limiting spread of the virus in schools, and the results have been entirely predictable, both for children and their schools. Essentially every article I’ve written here has advocated for vaccinating children. I wanted to do more than say “schools must be open”. I actually wanted schools to be open and safe.
The biggest advocate for vaccination on social media should strive to share accurate, thorough information about covid-19, vaccines, and children
You’ve lamented “tribalism” before, and I am sure you know that sharing complete, accurate information about the virus and the vaccine will put you at odds with most of your guests. They don’t want your audience to know that 1,131 children (is that hardly any?) have died in the USA and that nearly 100,000 more have been hospitalized, some intubated in the ICU. They don’t want your audience to know anything about the vaccines, except that it can cause myocarditis, that it can cause myocarditis, and that it can cause myocarditis.
You’ve previously not shown much of an openness to criticism or other opinions. You mocked a doctor whose prediction of mass death turned out to be spot on, calling him a “prophet of doom and fear”. You seem aghast that your history of pro-vaccine activism does not immunize you against criticism today. You reflexively portray yourself as a victim, claiming you are being “cancelled” or “banned” when anyone disagrees with you. You mock your critics by saying “the Gorksi tribe showing up doing the usual pronoun dance at me“. You’re convinced that basically everyone besides you is “so ineffective, because they’re more keen to score social media points by taking down one of their own that to actually get the job done of convincing people to vaccinate“.
I suspect either you or your fans will dismiss this entire article as a “take down”. I promise I don’t intend it that way. No one likes being criticized. I sure don’t. Our natural reaction is to view our critics as ill-informed or malevolent. However only they can show us our errors and make us better.
You are a gifted speaker with a large audience, drastically larger than mine will ever be. Your fans can even buy merch at the ZDoggMD fan shop or join the “ZPAC Supporter Tribe“. There’s no JoHo apparel for sale, yet. You’ve shared a lot of solid, valuable information on vaccines and children. You are conscious to let people know that your child was vaccinated. I’m 100% positive you’ve convinced many parents to vaccinate their children against COVID-19. I hope my articles have convinced a few.
I’ve written critical articles about many other doctors here, but I’ve never written to them. They’ve never shown they care a lick about being thorough and accurate. I think you do. So, I hope you’ll agree with me that the biggest advocate for vaccination on social media should strive to share accurate, thorough information about COVID-19, vaccines, and children. The stakes are high, and the consequences of misinformation are real. Hector Ramirez, whose unvaccinated 15-year-old-daughter died of COVID-19 this summer, said:
I don’t want any other parent to go through what I did — seeing my daughter perfectly healthy one day, then following a week and a half, she’s gone.
According to news reports, “He didn’t get the shot for his daughter, and he regrets it”. Her death was preventable with a simple vaccine. Hundreds of children will die similar deaths this year. We should try to change that.
        ◦ I say this all as someone who doesn’t even have pronouns in my Twitter bio.

Joe Mercola: An antivaccine quack tycoon pivots effortlessly to profit from spreading COVID-19 misinformation
Joe Mercola is a physician whose nearly quarter-century of promoting quackery and antivaccine misinformation has garnered him a net worth north of $100 million. It is therefore not surprising that in the age of the pandemic, he has pivoted to fatten his bottom line promoting misinformation and conspiracy theories about COVID-19 and the COVID vaccines.
David Gorski on July 26, 2021
Link

I’ve written about Joseph Mercola, DO on a number of occasions over the years, dating back to before I ever joined this blog, first as a contributor and then as an editor. Out of curiosity, as I was writing this post I tried to identify the first time I ever wrote about Mercola. It turns out that it was quite long ago in 2005, at a point when my very first blog was just over six months old. At the time, Mercola was—surprise! surprise!—comparing school vaccine mandates to the Holocaust. Interestingly, the link to the original article that I discussed then now forwards to an article from 2009 that includes no mention of the Holocaust, and when I tried to find the original article at Archive.org, it turns out that the original link has been excluded from the almighty Wayback Machine. (It’s almost as though he was embarrassed by his use of the analogy, although it was useful to be reminded that the misuse and abuse of Holocaust was commonplace among antivaxxers even 19 years ago, years before my post.) As for this blog, I was interested to note that Harriet Hall has the honor of being the first SBM blogger to have mentioned Mercola, back in 2008, although past contributor Dr. Joe Albietz was the first to make Mercola’s antivaccine misinformation the main topic of an SBM post back in 2009, later providing nine good reasons to completely ignore him, even as he and Barbara Loe Fisher were starting “Vaccine Awareness Week” in 2010 to spread misinformation about “vaccine injury”.
Sadly, Mercola hasn’t been ignored, as The New York Times reported over the weekend in an article by Sheera Frenkel titled “The Most Influential Spreader of Coronavirus Misinformation Online“. It seems that every couple of years the mainstream media notices what an influential quack Mercola is; so I thought I’d take a look at the article with the benefit of a long history of having observed Mercola’s activities.
A superspreader of medical misinformation
I bring this bit of history up for a simple reason, to remind our readers that my SBM colleagues and I have been writing about this particular quack for a long time. We’re very familiar with him. Indeed, I can’t help but note that, since the COVID-19 pandemic hit, Mercola has unfortunately been a frequent topic of this blog because he has been one of the most prolific sources (if not the most prolific source) of COVID-19 misinformation, antimask conspiracy theories, and antivaccine fear mongering. Indeed, early in the pandemic, we noted his role in spreading COVID-19 conspiracy theories and how, by even May 2020 he had made a name as one of the “superspreaders” of COVID-19 misinformation and false claims about COVID-19. Indeed, last fall Mercola spread the false claim that the influenza vaccine increases one’s risk of falling ill with COVID-19, all in order to spread fear of the flu vaccine. In retrospect, this amuses me, because it wasn’t long before Mercola embraced the “casedemic” conspiracy theory that claimed that PCR tests for SARS-CoV-2 (the coronavirus that causes COVID-19) is overly sensitive, making most positive tests false positive tests—and, also, according to him COVID-19 is not deadly, except to the elderly. It rather made me wonder why he would be concerned if the flu vaccine really did increase the risk of COVID-19 if COVID-19 is just a “harmless” disease. (I guess that consistency is not a requirement for the claims of quacks and antivaxxers.)
Since even before COVID-19 vaccines were granted emergency use authorizations (EUAs) by the FDA in December, Mercola has turned his sights on them and, with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., become one of the most prolific and widely read sources of misinformation and fear mongering about the vaccines. For example, as the mRNA-based vaccines were being considered for EUA, Mercola promoted the false idea that these vaccines can “permanently alter your DNA“, even going so far as to publish an article titled “Will New COVID Vaccine Make You Transhuman?” (which, by the way, was published in September 2020). Quickly following after that were a raft of articles on Mercola’s site falsely claiming that COVID-19 vaccines cause miscarriages and make women infertile, were not really “vaccines” but “medical devices” or “experimental gene therapy” that was “hacking the software of life“, or even cause mass death resulting in “depopulation“. Unsurprisingly, as he was demonizing COVID-19 vaccines, Mercola also promoted unproven treatments for COVID-19 like ivermectin, while peddling conspiracy theories claiming that the “suppression” of ivermectin as a COVID-19 treatment was the “biggest crime committed during the vaccine heist“. All of this doesn’t even consider all the other health misinformation that Mercola has promoted over the years, including cancer misinformation and quackery (including a promotional article about Tullio Simoncini, a quack who claims that all cancer is a fungus), “detox” nonsense, and tanning beds that supposedly reduce the risk of skin cancer, among naturopathy, homeopathy, and his online store of unproven supplements.
The truly depressing part is that over the last two decades Mercola has become fabulously wealthy publishing health misinformation. Indeed, I once referred to him as a “quack tycoon“, because his “natural health” empire had, as of 2017, garnered him a personal net worth in excess of $100 million. When I called Mercola a “quack tycoon”, I had last written about his online health empire in 2012 (under the title Quackery pays) in response to a previous news story about his links to the antivaccine movement. At that time, I drily noted that Mercola was “rich, as in filthy rich, as in ‘rolling in the dough rich, as in ‘raking it in hand-over-fist rich,’ adding that after all, “he had a spare $1 million lying around to give away to the NVIC and various other quackery-promoting groups.”
So what has the NYT found Mercola to be up to recently that we haven’t covered on SBM? In particular, I was interested in his grift: How much money has he made from promoting misinformation about the pandemic?
The quack tycoon profits from COVID-19 misinformation
The NYT article starts out with an example of something that we discussed about Mercola:
The article that appeared online on Feb. 9 began with a seemingly innocuous question about the legal definition of vaccines. Then over its next 3,400 words, it declared coronavirus vaccines were “a medical fraud” and said the injections did not prevent infections, provide immunity or stop transmission of the disease.
Instead, the article claimed, the shots “alter your genetic coding, turning you into a viral protein factory that has no off-switch.”
Its assertions were easily disprovable. No matter. Over the next few hours, the article was translated from English into Spanish and Polish. It appeared on dozens of blogs and was picked up by anti-vaccination activists, who repeated the false claims online. The article also made its way to Facebook, where it reached 400,000 people, according to data from CrowdTangle, a Facebook-owned tool.
The entire effort traced back to one person: Joseph Mercola.
Interestingly, as I researched this post, I found that some of the articles, like Mercola’s ancient article likening vaccine mandates to a “silent Holocaust”, have been removed from his website, the URLs redirected to less offensive articles. For example, one article I discussed titled ‘How COVID-19 “vaccines” may destroy the lives of millions’ now redirects to an article titled ‘Why I’m Removing All Articles Related to Vitamins D, C, Zinc and COVID-19‘. (As was the case for the “vaccine Holocaust article,” Mercola excluded the original article here from archiving by the Wayback Machine at Archive.org. It’s almost as though he wants to memory hole his history. Scratch that. There’s no “almost” about it.) In the newer article, Mercola claims that “threats have now become very personal and have intensified to the point I can no longer preserve much of the information and research I’ve provided to you thus far”, spinning a conspiracy theory in which Bill Gates and big pharma have supposedly weaponized “terrorist experts to attack” him, painting himself as a brave hero who held up as long as he could but finally had to remove the offending information from his website. Of course, I can’t help but point out that since early May Mercola has easily replaced the old COVID-19 misinformation with a whole lot of new (and regurgitated) COVID-19 misinformation. Apparently the grand conspiracy didn’t “silence” him for long.
And, again, it’s all about the grift:
An internet-savvy entrepreneur who employs dozens, Dr. Mercola has published over 600 articles on Facebook that cast doubt on Covid-19 vaccines since the pandemic began, reaching a far larger audience than other vaccine skeptics, an analysis by The New York Times found. His claims have been widely echoed on Twitter, Instagram and YouTube.
The activity has earned Dr. Mercola, a natural health proponent with an Everyman demeanor, the dubious distinction of the top spot in the “Disinformation Dozen,” a list of 12 people responsible for sharing 65 percent of all anti-vaccine messaging on social media, said the nonprofit Center for Countering Digital Hate. Others on the list include Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a longtime anti-vaccine activist, and Erin Elizabeth, the founder of the website Health Nut News, who is also Dr. Mercola’s girlfriend.
“Mercola is the pioneer of the anti-vaccine movement,” said Kolina Koltai, a researcher at the University of Washington who studies online conspiracy theories. “He’s a master of capitalizing on periods of uncertainty, like the pandemic, to grow his movement.”
Erin Elizabeth, of course, is the woman who’s promoted for several years a conspiracy theory in which “they” (whoever “they” are, be it pharma, government, or whatever) are murdering natural health practitioners, starting with autism quack Jeffrey Bradstreet in 2015, whose suicide was recast as a murder by a pharma hit squad, continuing with cancer quack Nicholas Gonzalez, whose death by heart attack was portrayed as something more sinister, and moving on to a whole lot of other alternative medicine practitioners and an antivax pediatrician. The last time I checked for my talk at NECSS in 2019, the apparent death toll from these murders was over 80. She’s no slouch at spreading antivaccine misinformation, quackery, and conspiracy theories herself. Between the two of them, the quack power couple of Joe Mercola and Erin Elizabeth make up one-sixth of the “disinformation dozen” listed earlier this year for their spreading of COVID-19 misinformation.
Meanwhile, Mercola carefully crafted a more “moderate” position on vaccines in which his antivaccine rhetoric is not as hard core as that of many other antivaccine activists:
But while Ms. Elizabeth and others are overtly anti-vaccine, Dr. Mercola has appeared more approachable because he takes less radical positions than his peers, Ms. Koltai said. “He takes away from the idea that an anti-vaccination activist is a fringe person,” she said.
Those of you who’ve been following SBM for a while will note, however, that this more “moderate” persona was thrown out the door when COVID-19 hit, with Mercola amplifying apocalyptic claims by people like Geert Vanden Bossche and others claiming that COVID-19 vaccines are a tool for “depopulation” and social control.
But how did Mercola get to his current status?
The rise of a quack tycoon
Perhaps the most comprehensive account of the rise of Joe Mercola comes from two sources: Bryan Smith in 2012 writing “Dr. Mercola: Visionary or Quack?” for Chicago Magazine (back before Mercola moved from the suburbs of Chicago to the more quack-friendly environs of Florida) and a 2019 Washington Post article by Neena Satija and Lena Sun titled “A major funder of the anti-vaccine movement has made millions selling natural health products“. How did Mercola get his start? Smith reported:
In 1997, as a way to share what he had found that would be “useful and helpful,” he started Mercola.com. It proved a hit. But because it didn’t charge for content or accept ads, it was also a money drain. In the first three years, Mercola estimates that he spent half a million dollars on the site. To keep it afloat, he says, “I had three options: to get paid subscribers; to sell information, which I didn’t want to do; or to sell products, which is what I wound up doing. . . . The purpose for selling items is to have a revenue stream so we can pay our staff to provide information to educate the public and make a difference and fund [our] initiatives.”
The success of the site gave a significant boost to his practice, Mercola says: “I had people flying in from all over the world. It always puzzled me: when people came in, I wouldn’t tell them anything different than I had written on the site. They could have just as easily looked it up for free. But they had to hear it from me.” (Mercola stopped practicing medicine six years ago to focus on the website.)
Yes, Mercola is approaching a quarter of a century of promoting quackery. In any event, as I said at the time, I’m sure the website probably was costing Mercola a fair amount of money back then, given that bandwidth was not as cheap in the 1990s. On the other hand, once you start selling products to support your bandwidth and website production expenses, the next logical step is for the website to turn into a marketing tool, such that its primary purpose shifts from informational to selling product. That’s exactly what appears to have happened with Mercola, and it made him incredibly wealthy—sure, not Jeff Bezos/Bill Gates-level billionaire wealthy, but then $100 million isn’t exactly chickenfeed, either.
I also noted how Mercola apparently deludes himself that the purpose of selling products was to support the website. That might have been true initially, but it’s very clear from his history that selling products soon became the main purpose of the website. After all, he wouldn’t have gotten to a net worth north of $100 million if had been selling only enough products to support the cost of bandwidth, maintaining a website and an online store, and paying writers for content that he didn’t write himself. He had to have been selling a lot of product at a generous markup, and even then most successful businesses aren’t nearly that profitable. Indeed, Satija and Sun reported in the Washington Post, by the time Mercola stopped seeing patients for good in 2009 his various online businesses were generating $3 million a month. By then, Mercola was already well on his way to being the quack tycoon he is today.
As Frenkel reports in The NYT:
As his popularity grew, Dr. Mercola began a cycle. It starts with making unproven and sometimes far-fetched health claims, such as that spring mattresses amplify harmful radiation, and then selling products online — from vitamin supplements to organic yogurt — that he promotes as alternative treatments.
To buttress the operation, he set up companies like Mercola.com Health Resources and Mercola Consulting Services. These entities have offices in Florida and the Philippines with teams of employees. Using this infrastructure, Dr. Mercola has seized on news moments to rapidly publish blog posts, newsletters and videos in nearly a dozen languages to a network of websites and social media.
It is all very deliberate and, unfortunately, savvy marketing:
Dr. Mercola has a keen understanding of what makes something go viral online, said two former employees, who declined to be identified because they had signed nondisclosure agreements. He routinely does A/B testing, they said, in which many versions of the same content are published to see what spreads fastest online.
I’ve long suspected as much, given the carefully chosen clickbait headlines and blurbs, coupled with certain repeated phrases, in Mercola’s articles. His website reeks of peak SEO, as do his articles. Of course, two years ago, when Google adjusted its search algorithms to deprioritize content considered unreliable, Mercola’s website traffic took a major hit, plunging (according to him) 99% in June 2019. Predictably, this lead to more of Mercola portraying himself as a victim of “censorship” with the usual conspiracy mongering.
The denials
Like most quacks who come under fire for their quackery and whom the FDA has targeted more than once over the years, Mercola is very good at playing the persecuted victim. As Frenkel reports in The NYT:
In an email, Dr. Mercola said it was “quite peculiar to me that I am named as the #1 superspreader of misinformation.” Some of his Facebook posts were only liked by hundreds of people, he said, so he didn’t understand “how the relatively small number of shares could possibly cause such calamity to Biden’s multibillion dollar vaccination campaign.”
The efforts against him are political, Dr. Mercola added, and he accused the White House of “illegal censorship by colluding with social media companies.”
This is, by the way, the new line I’ve seen coming from antivaccine activists, namely that, because Facebook and other social media companies consult, among other experts, experts at the CDC, NIH, and FDA, they are supposedly now acting as an arm of the government, thus meaning that the “censorship” by social media companies is actually that of the government, meaning that the First Amendment should protect them. It’s a dubious argument at best.
You can see the narrative, of course. It’s the same narrative favored of quacks the world over. Any attempt to prevent them from spreading misinformation or to counter the misinformation that they do spread is portrayed as “censorship” or even “cancel culture”.
Meanwhile, the main article on Mercola’s website yesterday was titled “How the Plague of Corruption Is Killing Mankind“. In it, he claims that the “blood supply and vaccines have been tainted with disease-causing retroviruses for more than three decades, and the U.S. government has been hiding it the entire time” and that “‘long-haul COVID’ is the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein activating endogenous HERVW and recombining with XMRVs, — introduced via vaccinations,” among other conspiracy theories, including Andrew Kaufmann’s claim (previously discussed) that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, “has never been identified” and that SARS-CoV-2 is actually a cloned monkey virus spread by “injection” of vaccines. (That’s a new one on me. I guess he must be abandoning the “lab leak” idea of how SARS-CoV-2 got started. Again, quack claims and pseudoscience don’t have to be consistent, I guess.)
The bottom line
Joe Mercola is arguably the most successful quack tycoon of all time. He is more effective in spreading health and vaccine misinformation than almost anyone else, likely because of his ruthless attention to marketing and SEO. In the past, that meant trying to seem more “reasonable” and “moderate” about vaccines. Unfortunately, in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, “moderate” doesn’t sell as well, and, savvy entrepreneur that he is, Mercola has changed with the times and gone for more histrionic and radical misinformation. Unfortunately, despite the efforts of social media companies to prevent it, his strategy seems to be working.
If it ever stops working, I’d be willing to bet that he’ll “memory hole” the offending posts yet again.

I Won’t Call Dr. Paul Offit an Anti-Vaxxer
Future data will clarify the risks and benefits of a booster in young people. I am confident Dr. Offit will accept it and report it as fairly as possible. That’s what makes him completely different from contrarian doctors.
Jonathan Howard on January 23, 2022
Link

“Now Just Waiting for the @ScienceBasedMed Crowd to Call Paul Offit an Anti-Vaxxer”
Dr. Paul Offit, the director of the Vaccine Education Center at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, has been a long-time hero to vaccine advocates such as myself. He is dedicated to children and science. He is an accomplished scientist, having invented the rotavirus vaccine. He is a prolific public communicator and has endured hatred and threats for his advocacy. He is a real nice guy who I’ve met several times.
He’s also not infallible. At the very start of the pandemic he predicted that COVID-19 would cause less than “one-tenth of the damage that influenza causes every year in the United States”. With humility and humor, he soon acknowledged his error saying, “If you’re going to be wrong, be wrong in front of millions of people. Make a complete ass of yourself”. This differentiates him from several other people who also underestimated the virus at that time. It is why I still trust him.
Today however, Dr. Offit shares something in common with many of the contrarian doctors I’ve criticized previously. They all feel young, healthy people, males in particular, would not benefit from a booster vaccine (here and here). Dr. Offit advised his own young son not to get a booster as “he believes that his son is well protected against serious illness with two shots, so a third just isn’t necessary”. This prompted one doctor and critic of our site to say:
Now just waiting for the @ScienceBasedMed crowd to call Paul Offit an anti-vaxxer. Wait for it…
To boost or not to boost
I’ve had little to say about boosters, especially for healthy young people. There’s certainly evidence (here, here, here) that boosters can reduce severe illness in older people. However, young, healthy people were at low risk to begin with, and two vaccine doses still offer powerful protection against severe illness. One recent study, prior to the arrival of the omicron variant, found that the vaccine was 94% effective at preventing hospitalizations in adolescents.
There is evidence from Israel that a third dose can further lower the infection risk for young people, and a recent preprint from there showed waning efficacy of the vaccine in adolescents. According to real-world data from Israel, “among 16–29 year olds, the rate ratio for infection in the non-boosted group vs boosted group was 17.2”. Among 22,441 infections in non-boosted people age 16-29 years, 10 were “severe”, though fortunately there were no deaths. A 1 in 2,441 risk of severe COVID-19 in non-boosted young people isn’t negligible. It’s certainly higher than the rate of vaccine-myocarditis. Moreover a booster would presumably help lower transmission of the virus.
However, I’m unaware of any evidence that boosters reduce the risk of severe disease for young, healthy people or children. World Health Organization Chief Scientist, Dr. Soumya Swaminathan, recently said “there’s no evidence right now” that suggests healthy children and adolescents need booster shots.
Moreover, the risk from the third vaccine dose is very small, below the already low risk posed by the second shot. According to data from the CDC, in just under 1 million people age 16-24 years who received a booster, there were just 4 confirmed myocarditis cases, all recovered, with 9 cases still under review. Data from Israel showed the third dose causes myocarditis in 1 in 15,000 males age 16-19 years. Moreover, researchers on vaccine-related myocarditis say that while long-term monitoring is needed, “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly”. So giving a booster to young males carries a very low risk of a condition that is almost always mild and transient.
At present, there is no definitive right answer. However, I am sympathetic to regulators who have to make difficult decisions with incomplete information in a rapidly shifting pandemic. They’ll be second guessed by those with no real-world responsibility no matter what they do.
Some doctors have requested a randomized-controlled trial of boosters. This could provide the clearest information, but the results wouldn’t be available until 2023, and new variants may render those results obsolete. Moreover, a randomized-controlled trial would not provide meaningful information on rare outcomes, such as myocarditis, which can only be detected once tens or hundreds of thousands of people have been vaccinated. The randomized-controlled trials of the first-two vaccine doses tell us much less about the vaccine than real-world data from hundreds of millions of doses.
The good news is that twice-vaccinated, healthy young males will almost certainly be fine regardless. Given all the attention this topic has gotten, the overall stakes seem pretty low, though it’s certainly grossly inequitable that healthy teens in some countries can get a third shot before vulnerable adults elsewhere can get their first dose.
I don’t know what the right answer is regarding boosters for young, healthy males, but since I couldn’t ship his dose elsewhere, I voted with my feet and got my healthy teenage son a booster. I am more fearful of waning protection from his first two doses, a new variant, or him spreading the virus than I am of a third vaccine dose. I am hopeful that this will be his last shot, but if it turns out we all need a periodic booster, this doesn’t seem that bad to me, especially compared to what the virus can do.
Beyond putting on a performance during the injection that the pharmacist called “my most memorable today,” my son was fine. However, this third dose was almost certainly much less of a benefit to him than the first two. Moreover, the risk wasn’t completely zero, and I understand why Dr. Offit disagrees with my decision. His past prudence against reintroducing the smallpox vaccine after 9/11 turned out to be the right call.
Dr. Offit versus contrarian doctors
Unlike the contrarian doctors I’ve criticized before, Dr. Offit is worth listening to when he advises against boosting healthy, young males. Dr. Offit doesn’t make blatant factual errors in national media, repeatedly overstating harms from the vaccine and understating harms of the virus. He hasn’t spent the past year trashing the first two vaccine doses for kids. He never told parents that an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for kids was unnecessary since the virus was going away. He never wrote an editorial objecting to the EUA for children or tweeted that “It is clear that the second dose brings WAY more hospitalizations from myocarditis than can possibly be prevented”. Unlike contrarians, he’s not against all boosters. In fact, he said, “I’m not opposed to booster dosing. What I think we need to make clearer is why we’re boosting.”
Dr. Offit has not catastrophized (or minimized) vaccine side effects. He noted that vaccine-myocarditis “is often transient, lasting 2 or 3 days, and resolves on its own for the most part or can be treated with anti-inflammatories”. He’s right. He made a video informing parents that the risks of the virus were much greater than the risk of vaccine-myocarditis.
He has consistently advocated for vaccinating children with the first two doses, while contrarian doctors objected to vaccinating children at all. He said in October 2021:
Now, at least the last few weeks, you’d have 200,000 cases in children a week, or 250,000 cases a week, 2,000 hospitalizations a week. And I was just on service at Children’s Hospital Philadelphia last week, and I can tell you, we had our share, representing the national average, of an increased number of children with SARS-CoV-2, some of whom were in the intensive care unit, and one of whom was on ECMO, meaning extracorporeal membrane oxygenator, the heart lung machine, and is fighting for her life. So it is, certainly the answer to the question can children suffer this disease, yes. Can they be hospitalized and go to the intensive care unit? Yes. Can they die? Yes, more than 500 children have died. So if you can prevent this vaccine, I’m sorry. If you can prevent this disease safely and effectively, then prevent it.
He then said in November 2021:
Make no mistake—COVID-19 is a childhood illness. When SARS-CoV-2 entered the United States early in 2020, children accounted for fewer than 3% of cases; today, they account for more than 25%. More than 6 million US children have been infected with SARS-CoV-2, including 2 million between the ages of 5 and 11. At the end of October 2021, about 100,000 children per week were infected. Of the tens of thousands of children who have been hospitalized, about one-third had no preexisting medical conditions, and many have required the intensive care unit. Almost 700 children have died from COVID-19, placing SARS-CoV-2 infection among the top 10 causes of death in US children. No children have died from vaccination.
These paragraphs summarize half the articles I’ve written on this site, and this is exactly the information that doctors who write about children and COVID-19 should communicate to the public. In contrast, contrarian doctors have never simply stated the facts like this. When it comes to children, contrarian doctors will almost never share information that casts the virus in a bad light or the vaccine in a good light. Thanks to myths spread by contrarian doctors, many parents think the flu is worse for children or that the death rate is 1 in a million.
Unlike them, Dr. Offit doesn’t hide the fact that over 1,100 American children have died of COVID-19 and that tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized with it. He fairly reports the evidence and the evidence is clear: the vaccine is not perfect, but it is much safer for children than the virus (study 1, study 2, study 3, study 4, study 5, study 6, study 7). Anti-vaccine cranks like RFK Jr. will never favorably share anything by Dr. Offit, though RFK Jr. will favorably share the work (here and here) of contrarian doctors. Anti-vaxxers still loathe Dr. Offit, which is perhaps the strongest signal that someone is both credible and well-intentioned.
When contrarian doctors discuss Dr. Offit’s opposition to the booster, oddly feeling it validates them in some way, they conveniently neglect his main point that it’s more important to try to get unvaccinated children their first two vaccine doses. Dr. Offit has treated sick, unvaccinated children in the hospital. They haven’t.
I am confident that if contrarian doctors had used their large platforms and influence to echo Dr. Offit’s beliefs instead of trying to undermine them, there would be many fewer unvaccinated children, there would be many more healthy children, and schools would have an easier time staying open. However, at various times, contrarian doctors have portrayed all doses of the vaccine as unnecessary or more dangerous than the virus for children. They objected to the first dose. They objected to the second dose. Of course, they were going to object to the third dose. It’s just what they do. It’s really all very predictable and boring.
But just because it’s predictable and boring doesn’t mean it is without consequence. Child vaccination rates are abysmal. Just 17% of children ages 5-11 and 54% of children ages 12-17 are fully vaccinated against COVID-19. Meanwhile, pediatric infections and hospitalizations are at their all time high, though fortunately, omicron seems milder than delta for children.
Children would be much better off if contrarian doctors with large platforms had shared Dr. Offit’s urgency to vaccinate children instead of constantly fear mongering about the first two doses of the vaccine.
Anyone who is waiting for this site to call Dr. Offit an anti-vaxxer will be waiting for a very long time
Dr. Offit’s current position may not pan out, but, unlike several other doctors, it stems from a thoughtful evaluation of the risks/benefits, not reflexive contrarianism. Dr. Offit has been thinking about these issues his entire career. Unlike doctors who’ve disagreed with him about the first two doses, he didn’t just become a pediatric vaccine “expert” in the past 6 months. He deserves to be taken seriously. As I wrote previously:
We need to leave room for people to have good faith disagreements and questions without inappropriately smearing them as “anti-vaxxers”.
Future data will clarify the risks and benefits of a booster in young people as it has for older people. When this data emerges, I will do my best to accept it and report it as fairly as possible. I am confident Dr. Offit will do the same.
That’s what makes him completely different from contrarian doctors who have yet to acknowledge the copious evidence the first two vaccine doses protect children.
        ◦ It’s also why anyone who is waiting for me to call him an anti-vaxxer will be waiting for a very long time.

COVID-19 conspiracy theories: Vaccines and 5G (along with Bill Gates) are responsible!
The COVID-19 pandemic will almost certainly wind up being by far the worst pandemic we have experienced in a century. Given a huge pandemic with tragic death tolls, it’s not surprising that conspiracy theories are popping up. Here, we look at two of the most common kinds of COVID-19 conspiracy theories. One blames 5G. The other blames—of course!—the flu vaccine.
David Gorski on April 6, 2020
Link

I’ve spent the last three weeks writing about nothing but the COVID-19 pandemic, first about what we know in a post that, a mere three weeks later, seems hopelessly dated given how rapidly events have been moving, and then two posts about the evidence—or, more accurately, the lack of evidence—supporting the use of chloroquine, hydroxychloroquine, and azithromycin to treat COVID-19 patients, even as Dr. Mehmet Oz, President Trump, and a whole bevy of Fox News pundits promoted these drugs as a “game changer.” Although I alluded to conspiracy theories about COVID-19 in previous posts, I had wanted to discuss some of the most prominent ones out there. Of course, the frenzy over hydroxychloroquine created a variant of the perennial and ever-popular conspiracy theory that “There’s a cure for a deadly disease out there that “they” don’t want you to know about” because “they” can’t make money off of it or have a eugenics program, or whatever. Just substitute the word “COVID-19” for, say, “cancer,” and you’ve heard this one before. More interesting to me is the reaction of the antivaccine movement and other quacks to COVID-19. I thought I’d take this opportunity to take the pulse of the crankosphere, so to speak.
Quoth antivaxxers: The flu vaccine makes you more susceptible to coronavirus
It was utterly predictable that antivaxxers would find a way to incorporate COVID-19 into their conspiracy theories about vaccines. Obviously, antivaccine websites and social media accounts everywhere are promoting the idea that the government will use the COVID-19 pandemic as a pretext to institute forced vaccination once a coronavirus vaccine is finally developed:
On Friday, just after Governor Greg Abbott declared a statewide emergency in response to the coronavirus, Sarah posted a worried plea on a local anti-vaccine Facebook group. She worried that the declaration gives the government the right to “force vaccinations” on unwilling Texans.
“If they fast-track some vaccine for coronavirus, how are all of us going to defend ourselves?” she asked. “I’ll let them vaccinate my daughter over my dead body.”
Other members of the group, Tarrant County Crunchy Mamas, chimed in.
“Hide in the floors like they hid the Jews from the Nazis,” one suggested. “Hide them in our gun safe (yes, it’s a big safe and yes, we love our guns),” said another.
Yes, antivaxxers sure do love their Nazi analogies!

None of this is particularly surprising, as antivaxxers recycle this very same conspiracy theory every time there is an outbreak or pandemic. They did it during the 2009-2010 H1N1 pandemic, and they did it again during the Ebola outbreaks of 2014. I wasn’t paying attention as much at the time, but I’m almost certain they trotted out this conspiracy theory during the 2002-2003 SARS epidemic too. Even the conspiracy theory that Bill Gates created SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus strain that causes COVID-19 has been circulating at least since January, because, you know, Bill Gates created H1N1 and Ebola, too. (That’s sarcasm, of course.)
Of more interest to me is a very specific claim that’s been going around antivaccine social media circles:
HOLY SH*T Flu Vaccine Increases Coronavirus Risk 36% New Military Study Says https://t.co/xM7rBYJXwK
— Matt Couch (@RealMattCouch) March 30, 2020
Matt Couch describes himself as a “Christian, Father of 2, Investigator, Founder The DC Patriot & America First Media Group, Razorback, Truth Slinger,” and has over 300K followers on Twitter. There are a lot of Tweets like this one:
And this one:
The claim that the flu vaccine increases the risk of COVID-19 infection dates back at least to late January, when the first variant of this conspiracy theory surfaced. In brief, the conspiracy theory noted that China had ordered more influenza vaccines than in previous years, misinterpreted scientific papers on a phenomenon known as viral interference (I’ll explain momentarily what that is), and claimed that the flu vaccine makes one more susceptible to SARS-CoV-2, which is why the outbreak managed to grow so large in Wuhan.
This version of the conspiracy theory is based primarily on a single paper published earlier this year. The article claiming that the flu vaccine makes you 36% more likely to develop COVID-19 that’s been the most widely shared, as far as I can tell, was an article posted to DisabledVeterans.org on March 11 by someone named Benjamin Krause entitled “Flu Vaccine Increases Coronavirus Risk 36% Says Military Study“:
A recent military study shows military personnel evaluated who received the flu vaccine were at 36 percent increased risk for coronavirus with varied benefit in preventing some strains of the flu.
“Examining noninfluenza viruses specifically, the odds of both coronavirus and human metapneumovirus in vaccinated individuals were significantly higher when compared to unvaccinated individuals (OR = 1.36 and 1.51, respectively) (Table 5).”
And more on this:
The column to focus on is “OR” in Table 5.
Coronavirus is 1.36 meaning 36% higher risk.
The influenza virus overall is 0.57 meaning the risk of contracting the flu was reduced overall. Three variants of flu did not receive a statistically significant reduction in risk.
Three of 8 evaluations noted a statistically insignificant benefit for the flu shot. Meanwhile, shot takers were at increased risk for coronavirus of 36%. I would bet $1 that this year, many Americans would likely rethink taking the vaccine with that bit of information.
Of course, the first thing to note is that the coronavirus in this study of viral interference was obviously not SARS-CoV-2. This study was carried out years before the emergence of COVID-19. No, the coronavirus examined in this study were your usual run-of-the-mill wimpy coronaviruses that can cause the common cold and that many of us have detectable in our nasopharyngeal passages just because these viruses are everywhere. True, Krause does at one point mention that this study is “pre-COVID-19,” but it would still be easy for the reader to believe that the study has implications for SARS-CoV-2 when it does not. SARS coronaviruses have notable structural differences compared to the common and nonvirulent strains of coronavirus; that’s why they’re so much more lethal.
Before I deconstruct why the claim made by Krause is unjustified and unmitigated nonsense, who is Benjamin Krause? I had never heard of him before in antivaccine circles, but he bills himself as “a lawyer, investigative reporter and award-winning veterans advocate. He is author of the guide Voc Rehab Survival Guide for Veterans and chief editor of DisabledVeterans.org and notes writing credits in “national publications as an authority on Department of Veterans Affairs policy such as Bloomberg News, Foreign Policy Magazine, Washington Times, Fox News, CBS, NBC, Star Tribune and more.” One thing I can say for sure about him, whatever expertise he might have in these areas, he’s clueless about science and medicine.
So what is being claimed here? The study being misused and abused by antivaxxers is this one by Greg G. Wolfe at the Armed Forces Health Surveillance Branch Air Force Satellite, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio and entitled “Influenza vaccination and respiratory virus interference among Department of Defense personnel during the 2017–2018 influenza season“. The idea of viral interference is described in the introduction:
While influenza vaccination offers protection against influenza, natural influenza infection may reduce the risk of non-influenza respiratory viruses by providing temporary, non-specific immunity against these viruses [7], [8]. On the other hand, recently published studies have described the phenomenon of vaccine-associated virus interference; that is, vaccinated individuals may be at increased risk for other respiratory viruses because they do not receive the non-specific immunity associated with natural infection [7], [8], [9], [10]. There has been limited evidence that the influenza vaccine may actually be associated with the virus interference process [8], [11]. Other studies have found no association between influenza vaccination and increased respiratory virus risk [10], [12].
The purpose of this study is to add to the general knowledge of influenza vaccine-related virus interference by comparing rates of non-influenza respiratory viruses to negative laboratory tests, and comparing vaccination status of influenza positive cases to controls among Department of Defense (DoD) personnel. The DoD provides a unique population for vaccination studies as mandatory vaccination against influenza is required by the DoD for all Active Duty and Reserve Component personnel [13]. This study aims to examine the relationship between specific respiratory viruses and influenza vaccination.
Wolfe took advantage of the Department of Defense Global Respiratory Pathogen Surveillance Program (DoDGRS), DoD-wide program established by the Global Emerging Infections Surveillance and Response System (GEIS). It started as an influenza-only program but during the 2013-2014 flu season the program added respiratory Film Array for flu negative samples and began identifying other respiratory pathogen. These specimens are now tested with a multiplex PCR panel for these pathogens: adenovirus, Chlamydia pneumonia, coronavirus, human bocavirus, human metapnumovirus, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, parainfluenza, respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), rhinovirus/enterovirus, and co-infections.
All personnel submitting a respiratory specimen to DoDGRS for the 2017-2018 flu season, and those who tested positive for only Chlamydia pneumoniae and/or Mycoplasma pneumoniae were excluded because these illnesses are bacteriological in nature. People with influenza and non-influenza co-infections were excluded because they couldn’t be uniquely classified as influenza or non-influenza, as were people whose vaccination status couldn’t be confirmed. Finally, subjects who were ill before receiving vaccination were excluded as their vaccination status would be considered be unrelated to their illness.
Let’s go to the findings:
We compared vaccination status of 2880 people with non-influenza respiratory viruses to 3240 people with pan-negative results. Comparing vaccinated to non-vaccinated patients, the adjusted odds ratio for non-flu viruses was 0.97 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.86, 1.09; p = 0.60). Additionally, the vaccination status of 3349 cases of influenza were compared to three different control groups: all controls (N = 6120), non-influenza positive controls (N = 2880), and pan-negative controls (N = 3240). The adjusted ORs for the comparisons among the three control groups did not vary much (range: 0.46–0.51).
And:
Receipt of influenza vaccination was not associated with virus interference among our population. Examining virus interference by specific respiratory viruses showed mixed results. Vaccine derived virus interference was significantly associated with coronavirus and human metapneumovirus; however, significant protection with vaccination was associated not only with most influenza viruses, but also parainfluenza, RSV, and non-influenza virus coinfections.
Let me repeat that: Receipt of influenza vaccination was not associated with virus interference among our population. In other words, this is a negative study. The authors did not observe viral interference.
Then, in the conclusion:
The overall results of the study showed little to no evidence supporting the association of virus interference and influenza vaccination. Individual respiratory virus results were mixed, and some rebutted virus interference.
So how did antivaxxers come to the mistaken cherry picked conclusion that this study showed that, due to viral interference, the seasonal flu vaccine increases your risk of getting coronavirus by 36%, thus creating an antivax meme? It comes down to this table:
Table 5. Respiratory viruses and odds ratios by vaccination status.
Virus	Vaccinated (%)	Not Vaccinated (%)	OR (95% CI)	P-Value
Influenza	2050 (31.3)	1299 (44.4)	0.57 (0.52, 0.63)	<0.01
Influenza A	1256 (19.2)	741 (25.3)	0.70 (0.63, 0.78)	<0.01
Influenza A H1N1	225 (3.4)	227 (7.8)	0.42 (0.35, 0.51)	<0.01
Influenza A H3N2	1023 (15.6)	512 (17.5)	0.88 (0.78, 0.98)	0.02
Influenza B	662 (10.1)	474 (16.2)	0.58 (0.51, 0.66)	<0.01
Influenza B Victoria	7 (0.1)	8 (0.3)	0.39 (0.14, 1.08)	0.07
Influenza B Yamagata	85 (1.3)	77 (2.6)	0.49 (0.36, 0.67)	<0.01
Influenza Coinfection	9 (0.1)	9 (0.3)	0.45 (0.18, 1.13)	0.09
Non-Influenza Virus	2050 (31.3)	830 (28.3)	1.15 (1.05, 1.27)	<0.01
Adenovirus	144 (2.2)	78 (2.7)	0.82 (0.62, 1.09)	0.17
Coronavirus	507 (7.8)	170 (5.8)	1.36 (1.14, 1.63)	<0.01
Human Bocavirus	69 (1.1)	34 (1.2)	0.91 (0.60, 1.37)	0.64
Human Metapneumovirus	335 (5.1)	101 (3.5)	1.51 (1.20, 1.90)	<0.01
No Pathogen Detected	2441 (37.3)	799 (27.3)	1.59 (1.44, 1.75)	<0.01
Parainfluenza	139 (2.1)	92 (3.1)	0.67 (0.51, 0.87)	<0.01
RSV	369 (5.6)	202 (6.9)	0.81 (0.68, 0.96)	0.02
Rhinovirus/Enterovirus	875 (13.4)	400 (13.7)	0.98 (0.86, 1.11)	0.71
Non-Influenza Virus Coinfection	225 (3.4)	138 (4.7)	0.72 (0.58, 0.89)	<0.01
And this cherry-picked passage:
The odds of testing positive for individual respiratory viruses by vaccination status were also examined (Table 5). The influenza vaccine was sufficient at protecting all influenza virus results tested for at a significant level except two (Influenza B Victoria and Influenza coinfections) (Table 5). Both Influenza B Victoria and Influenza coinfections had reduced odds in the vaccinated cohort, but not at significant levels (Table 5). Examining non-influenza viruses specifically, the odds of both coronavirus and human metapneumovirus in vaccinated individuals were significantly higher when compared to unvaccinated individuals (OR = 1.36 and 1.51, respectively) (Table 5). Conversely, all other non-influenza respiratory viruses had decreased odds in the vaccinated population, including significantly decreased odds ratios in vaccinated people with parainfluenza, RSV, and non-influenza virus coinfections (Table 5). Additionally, the odds ratio in the no pathogen detected cohort was significantly higher in vaccinated versus unvaccinated individuals (OR = 1.51) (Table 5).
This what we’re almost certainly seeing: Noise. With the odds ratio of influenza virus significantly decreased (the odds ratios range from 0.39 to 0.88, depending on the specific influenza strain), the rest of the various viruses detected fluctuated around an odds ratio of 1.0 (no difference). Indeed, most of the non-influenza viruses tested for (6/8) demonstrated odds ratios lower than 1.0 (range: 0.67-1.51). Only coronavirus and human metapneumovirus showed odds ratios of more than 1.0 (1.36 and 1.51, respectively). Moreover, the odds ratio of having no pathogen at all detected in the group receiving the flu vaccine was 1.59 (95% CI 1.44-1.75), meaning that those who had the flu vaccine were 59% more likely not to have any respiratory virus detectable at all. Taken together, these findings are highly suggestive of nothing more than statistical noise. Basically, antivaxxers are citing what is, in essence, a negative study.
As I’ve mentioned before, I also can’t help but be amused by the inconsistency of antivaxxers. The flu vaccine is one of our less effective vaccines, a vaccine whose efficacy varies widely from season to season because an educated guess has to be made several months in advance every year as to which influenza strains will be the most common that season. Antivaxxers love to claim that the flu vaccine doesn’t work, that it’s completely ineffective. But if the flu vaccine doesn’t work, there isn’t even a chance that it could cause interference with other viruses. Antivaxxers really need to make up their minds.
Bill Gates and 5G
Late last week, I became aware of arguably the most bizarre antivaccine conspiracy theory around, courtesy of Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.:
There’s an awful lot to unpack here. For those who don’t have Facebook accounts, here’s the full text:
Is this the future for Amerika?
This video shows why Big Telecom loves #coronavirus. The quarantine has facilitated the unobstructed #5G rollout and has effectively ended the opportunity for mass public protests which were our best hope for derailing the 5G robber barons from microwaving our country and destroying nature. The Telecom Titans now have an open road, willing politicians and a compliant population sufficiently frightened, beleaguered, broke and submissive to relinquish their constitutional freedoms and welcome the surveillance state.
5G has little to do with improving service to individuals. It has everything to do with #BigTech data mining, surveillance and social control. If we don’t stop them, they will engineer a massive transfer of wealth and sovereignty away from our citizens into the hands of Big Telecom, Big Tech (Microsoft, Facebook, Google) #BigPharma, the military/intelligence apparatus and the ruling plutocrats.
Chief among these is Bill Gates with his sinister anti-American tracking system (ID2020), his suspiciously coincidental October 2019 Coronavirus War Game simulations (Gates passed out adorable coronavirus themed stuffed animals to all the high level participants), his pandemic documentary on #Netflix, his autocratic control of Anthony Fauci and the WHO (for which he is the top funder), his coronavirus #vaccine patents and his barely disguised — let’s be honest — giddy-delight at the quarantine that is impoverishing his countrymen and crushing their will to resist his tyrannical “reforms.”
Gates wants us to cede all power to his “benevolent” dictatorship —including power over our bodies, our health and our children. Gates is the nerdy kid with the magnifying glass. The rest of us are ants getting torched in his global science experiment.
So, according to RFK Jr., the response to the COVID-19 pandemic is being used to end opposition to the rollout of 5G, which is supposedly also a power grab to allow states to vastly increase their power over the populace. Of course, the latter concern isn’t entirely unjustified in that it is not unreasonable to be concerned that increased power to track the motion and contacts of citizens is a power that can be abused, but notice how this reasonable concern is buried in a tsunami of standard New World Order conspiracy mongering.
I had never heard of ID2020 before, and a brief search brought me to the ID2020 website. Basically, ID2020 is an initiative founded by an alliance made up of Microsoft, the Rockefeller Foundation, Accenture, IDEO.ORG, and Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance (uh-oh). Other partners include various nonprofits and corporations. What RFK Jr. describes as Orwellian actually doesn’t sound that Orwellian at all if you read the ID2020 manifesto, starting out with the assertion that the “ability to prove one’s identity is a fundamental and universal human right” and that individuals “need a trusted, verifiable way to prove who they are, both in the physical world and online.” The manifesto recognizes that such a digital identity could be abused and asserts that “individuals must have control over their own digital identities, including how personal data is collected, used, and shared” and that “privacy, portability, and persistence are necessary for digital identity to meaningfully empower and protect individuals.” Overall, it’s an interesting concept, but it sure doesn’t sound nearly as totalitarian as RFK Jr. paints it.
As for the “wargame,” What RFK Jr. is referring to is the Event 201 simulation, carried out by Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security with the World Economic Forum and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. It really is frightening, looking at the criminally incompetent response of the federal government thus far to the pandemic, to think that, a mere couple of months before the first case arrived in the US in January, such an exercise was carried out:
Late in the summer of 2019, a virus makes the leap from pigs in South America to the farmers who come into close and regular contact with them. It begins as a slow burn in Brazil; by October, it is gaining momentum and becomes known to the world.
The virus is called CAPS, a coronavirus, like SARS and MERS, that has never been seen before. It causes pneumonia and acute respiratory distress — in the most severe cases, liquid fills the lungs until breathing becomes labored or impossible.
A further mutation allows the virus to jump from person to person. From densely packed urban areas, the virus spreads, hanging in the very air we breathe. From its epicenter in Brazil, it spreads across the world.
A Pandemic Response Board is formed, made up of business leaders, public health experts, and representatives from the Centers for Disease Control. The Board is intended to coordinate the public and private plans for stopping — and surviving — the pandemic.
In their 18-month struggle against CAPS, 65 million people will die.
CAPS isn’t a real virus (yet), and this is not the world we live in — but it is, perhaps, the world next door. A few farsighted experts and executives are determined to be ready, in case the neighbors drop by to say hello.
Unfortunately, the lessons of such exercises appear to have been lost on our President, who was denying that COVID-19 was much of a threat until early March.
5G: The “trigger” for coronavirus?
Unsurprisingly, to antivaxxers it’s not just about using the pandemic as a pretext to crush opposition to the rollout of 5G. To some of them, it’s about 5G itself. 5G, of course, is nothing more than the latest mobile phone/communication protocol, dubbed fifth generation, which is currently being rolled out around the country. Its advantages are many, in particular peak Internet transmission rates theoretically as fast as 20 Gbps and very low latency. The protocol also allows for a dramatic increase in bandwidth. The key drawback to 5G is that the reach of its fastest signal is limited, meaning that many more towers will be required to cover areas currently covered by 4G. It is likely to take several years for the entire existing 4G cellular network to be upgraded to 5G.
There have been many conspiracy theories about 5G ever since plans to upgrade cellular networks to use it first started to circulate. Think of these conspiracy theories as the usual ones about cell phone radiation or Wi-Fi radiation causing cancer and numerous other health issues – but on steroids. Radio waves of the frequency used in Wi-Fi and cellular transmissions don’t cause any of the health problems cranks attribute to them, of course, and we’ve written about them many times right here on this blog.
This particular version of the conspiracy theory is quite imaginative, coming from James Grundvig of Vaxxter:
On the first weekend of spring, images emerged from Italy, showing similar scenes of horror. Scenes that were eerily reminiscent of Wuhan: people walking down the street, collapsing dead without any external force. Dozens of such videos and photos showed the fallen people spread eagle, flat on their backs, face down on sidewalks. Lifeless. No blood splatter. Outside of one similar case in New York City, no other place in the world has produced such anomalies.
Why?
What causes people, who appear to be fit, to keel over without a seizure or to tremble suddenly? What is the underlying cause? And what makes Wuhan and Northern Italy different than other parts of the world? So different that COVID-19 kills people with no apparent explanation?
It sounds like a scene from one of my all time favorite “end of civilization” movies, The Omega Man starring Charlton Heston, a movie that featured scenes of people dropping dead on the streets from the plague that wiped out most of civilization.
Grundvig is not the only one making this claim:
5G causes coronavirus because it’s sucking the oxygen out of your lungs, according to a video being spread on Facebook. I want to 😂 but the fact people believe this bullshit is genuinely scary pic.twitter.com/kY3g5MJtu9
— Tom Warren (@tomwarren) March 3, 2020
“5G absorbs oxygen”? What the heck is this woman even claiming? Does she realize how utterly scientifically ignorant she sounds? Radio wave radiation doesn’t “absorb” oxygen. Maybe she means that oxygen absorbs 5G? So what if it does? Radio wave radiation is nowhere near strong enough to break chemical bonds.
Of course, I couldn’t find evidence that this claim of people dropping dead in the streets of Wuhan and northern Italy is even true. I found this story about a man found dead on the streets of Wuhan, but no indication that this was a widespread phenomenon. In Wuhan, at least, its origin was probably a video that claimed to show bodies on the streets of Wuhan, victims of COVID-19, waiting to be picked up that turned out to be showing homeless people sleeping on the streets in Shenzhen, a city in China over 600 miles away from Wuhan. There were also stories of a man who took videos of corpses in a hospital in Wuhan and posted them to social media. There was also a story in a British tabloid about a man found collapsed on the street in Rome who was picked up by rescue workers in hazmat suits, plus stories of the army being called in to transport corpses because the local morgues were so overwhelmed.
Given the title of this section, I bet you can guess the reason that will be given:
In 2018, China’s Ministry of Industry and Information Technology selected Wuhan as a pilot city for the “Made in China 2025” plan. The overarching goal aimed at the industrial city of 11 million to become the world’s Internet of Things mecca. The goal? A 5G smart city that would connect homes, offices, hospitals, factories, and autonomous vehicles via a digital fabric.
Renowned for its factories and severe pollution, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) envisioned elevating Wuhan as the global smart city of the future. All of the commands, controls, data sharing, and data flowing through artificial intelligence systems would showcase China as the preeminent digital leader of the world.
At the center of the plan, the Chinese telecom syndicate of ZTE, Huawei, Hubei Mobile, and China Unicom began to transform Wuhan into a giant 5G “hot spot” for wireless technology. The 5G launch in the Hubei capital city culminated with the October 2019 Military World Games. Wuhan activated 20% of its 10,000 5G base stations, and the rest by the end of the year. With the hottest 5G pilot city on the planet, the CCP planned to leverage the publicity to attract more foreign investment and lure international businesses to prop up China’s flagging economy.
And, of course:
Milan in Northern Italy is the 5G capital of Europe. Iran, where suspected millions have been infected, has installed 5G deployments. And sure enough, the three Princess line cruise ships—Diamond, Grand, and now Ruby—had GEO and MEO satellites beaming 5G down to the ships as they travel via a Medallion Net receiver system last autumn.
But what about South Korea, which has been a leader in 5G deployment, with 85 of its cities connected by this February. Surely that’s a problem with this “theory,” one would think. Come on, you know better! Of course antivaxxers can explain away how few cases compared to many other countries South Korea has had thus far:
Although South Korea is a wirelessly connected nation, it doesn’t have the number of cases like other places in the world that does. Yet, its third and fourth coronavirus clusters were in 5G-hot gymnasium and hospital.
That’s a mighty long reach there. Grundvig should play for the NBA.
Of course, the big question is: How? How does 5G cause people with COVID-19 to drop dead? According to Grundvig, it’s all due to the 60 GHz, which is absorbed by oxygen:
Hakusui noted that 60GHz was the true radiofrequency that would allow for reliable transmission of data, due to its “98 percent oxygen absorption” rate. This allows the invisible signals to travel from point A and B, and back again on the same path. Super-efficient and a technological milestone.
And:
The problem is for every breath we breathe, our blood transports oxygen throughout the core, extremities, to the vital organs, heart, and brain.
If 5G at 60 GHz frequency zips through the air, absorbing most of the oxygen, disrupting the electrons that bind 02 molecules that, combined with a hydrogen atom, form water vapor, what is that frequency doing to blood cells, which consist primarily of water and carry the oxygen?
Do the disruption of the body’s biorhythm, breathing, and oxygen distribution begin to explain what happens to the people who dropped dead?
No. No they don’t. That Grundvig would make this connection shows his utter ignorance of physics. Radio waves, by their very nature, don’t possess the energy necessary to disrupt chemical bonds like the bond holding two oxygen atoms together. They can’t “disrupt the electrons that bind O2 molecules.”
There have generally been two varieties of 5G/coronavirus conspiracy theories. One type claims 5G can suppress the immune system, thus making people more susceptible to catching the virus. The other posits that the virus can somehow be transmitted through the use of 5G technology. There’s no evidence for the first type, and the second type is physically impossible. A variant of the second type of conspiracy theory stating that SARS-CoV-2 viruses somehow “talk to each other” in deciding which host to infect (they don’t) and that 5G somehow facilitates that, based on a very dubious 2011 paper that suggested that bacteria may produce electromagnetic signals to communicate with other bacteria. I guess that we can now add a third type, a kind that says that 5G somehow makes COVID-19 more deadly, in this case by somehow messing with oxygen molecules and the oxygen atoms in the water in your body. It’s utter nonsense. Unfortunately, people believe this one. Woody Harrelson has been posting 5G conspiracy theories on Instagram, for instance:
I regret to inform you Woody Harrelson is posting 5G coronavirus conspiracy theories on Instagram.
The video also isn’t “the Chinese taking 5G antennas down,” it’s from the Hong Kong protests. pic.twitter.com/y4RpOMJi9T
— Ryan Broderick (@broderick) April 2, 2020




View this post on Instagram








Alot of my friends have been talking about the negative effects of 5G My friend camilla seems this to me today and though I haven’t fully vetted it I find it very interesting
A post shared by Woody Harrelson (@woodyharrelson) on Apr 1, 2020 at 11:05am PDT




View this post on Instagram








Meanwhile the Chinese are bringing 5g antennas down
A post shared by Woody Harrelson (@woodyharrelson) on Apr 1, 2020 at 11:13am PDT
Meanwhile, in England, 5G towers are being set on fire.
Conspiracy theories kill
It was perhaps inevitable that antivaxxers and various other conspiracy theorists would merge their favorite conspiracy theories with conspiracy theories about the COVID-19 pandemic in order to blame their favorite “evil” for the pandemic. So, of course, antivaxxers are going to find a way to blame vaccines somehow for either causing, facilitating, or worsening the pandemic. Failing that, they claim that the pandemic is a pretext to institute what they dread most of all: forced vaccination. Of course, the conspiracy theorists who believe cell phone and Wi-Fi radiation is deadly are going to find a way to blame the latest variant of their conspiracy theory, namely that 5G represents a unique health threat, to “explain” the COVID-19 pandemic. Personally, I can’t wait to see the first conspiracy theory that combines all three, COVID-19, 5G, and vaccines. I’m sure someone’s already thought of it; I just haven’t found it yet.
Although antivaccine conspiracy theories are always potentially dangerous, as they scare people away from vaccinating and facilitate the spread of potentially deadly diseases, under normal circumstances 5G conspiracy theories cause less problems. In a pandemic, though, these conspiracy theories spread like wildfire and can influence how people respond to public health directives designed to slow the spread of the coronavirus. Even worse, antivaccine conspiracy theories could well result in resistance to being vaccinated once a vaccine is finally developed for COVID-19. In a very real way, misinformation and disinformation endangers our health. And that doesn’t even consider the many bogus health claims and examples of quackery being touted to treat the disease.


The Opinion Class: Practicing Focused Protection From Reality
A class of sheltered COVID pundits are eager to conjure an alternate history where we let the virus spread in 2020 and everything turned out just fine.
Jonathan Howard on July 13, 2025
Link
More than once, someone has asked me what I would have done had I been in charge of our COVID response, as if there were some alternative universe where I was in supreme leader who could bend both the populace and virus to my will. Since we are playing make-believe, I now answer that I would have kept SARS-CoV-2 out of the country altogether.  
No one has been impressed by my “plan”. However, anyone who points its flaws is ceding an important point- the real-world matters. Theoretically, my plan is perfect. If we sealed the border in January 2020, we could have lived normally and opened up after everyone was vaccinated, saving lives and obviating the need for mitigation measures. It would have been the best of both worlds.
Unfortunately, we cannot gift ourselves magic powers to translate our desires into reality.  Just because I claim I “would have” kept the virus out of the country doesn’t mean actually I would have kept the virus out of the country, and I deserve no credit for my absurd “plan.”
Yet, a whole class of COVID pundits, the opinion class, are eager to conjure an entirely imagined, alternate history where we let the virus spread in 2020 and conveniently, everything turned out just fine. In their fantasy, schools, business, and restaurants remained open. Some kids and young adults got the sniffles, but vulnerable people were protected, trust in public health remained high, and the pandemic fizzled away. There were no problems at all. You know who these pundits are. They are very serious thinkers who claim to consider trade-offs in a unique and nuanced way. They are all over very serious newspapers, magazines, and podcasts, rewriting the history of the pandemic.  
They do this in two ways.  First, they seek to memory-hole the horrific scenes of 2020 and beyond.  Pundits will never remind their readers of overflowing morgues when the virus was left to spread unchecked.  They’ll never discuss young lives lost to COVID or those lost to anti-vaccine disinformation. Pundits never discuss COVID’s non-fatal harms. Only the harms of mitigation measures, both real and imagined, matter to pundits. Even though it’s been years since we tried to control COVID, that’s all pundits talk about today.
Second, pundits gift magical powers to We Want Them Infected doctors. The idea of focused protection, creating a million impenetrable bubbles, is no more realistic than my idea of creating one giant impenetrable bubble. Yet, this doesn’t matter to COVID pundits. WWTI doctors claim they “would have” done amazing things, and pundits praised them as if they had actually done them. Pundits occupied a world of complete fantasy and imagination.
Pundits spent the pandemic sharing their opinions from behind a laptop. That’s it.  That’s all they did.  Aside from maintaining their audience, they had no real-world responsibility for anything. This allowed them to treat their opinions as obvious- schools should be open– without a care in the world about what it actually took to open schools. Those of us who cared about what educators had to say knew it was often impossible to keep schools open when the virus raged. COVID was to blame, even in Sweden.
Yet, the opinion class didn’t care a bit. They never let unpleasant realities intrude into their imagined utopia.  They never reached out to people with real-world responsibility to hear about their experience and the challenges they faced. It never occurred to pundits that they might have something to learn from actual workers. Pundits sealed them themselves in a bubble and only talked to other pundits. They practiced focused protection from reality and anyone who might inform them of it.
In the vision of the opinion class, imagining a policy in a Tweet or newspaper editorial was the impressive part.  Translating that policy into the real world was the easy part. The opinion class always made it seem that people with real-world responsibility had a choice when it came to unwanted mitigation measures, that the virus never forced anyone’s hand.  They made it all sound so easy, as they heaped scorn and contempt on their anointed villains- teachers, doctors, public health workers, literally anyone who actually had to deal with the virus.
Pundits wrote articles unoriginal, interchangeable articles such as How Public Health Discredited Itself and How The Coronavirus Sparked An Epidemic Of Intellectual Malpractice, which absolved SAR-CoV-2 of all responsibility and displaced its harms on to the people who had to handle it. According to the opinion class, these workers weren’t well-intentioned people who made some mistakes as a new, mutating virus swamped their hospitals and morgues. Rather, they were “ambitious social engineers” who used to pandemic to gain “prestige, power, and funding.”
It makes perfect sense that the opinion class glorified WWTI doctors. These doctors also spent the pandemic on podcasts and TV “calling for” other people to do things and boasting of their wonderful, though entirely hypothetical achievements. They treated zero COVID patients, and what actually happened in schools and hospitals didn’t matter at all to them.  WWTI doctors never acknowledged headlines from Florida’s Delta wave, Florida Morgues ‘Out of Space for Bodies’, Oxygen Crunch in Hospitals and School Closures Reported In Five Fl Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID, when they helped run the show.  Unwanted facts could be wished way, and those who reported them were blamed for them.
The opinion class ignored or glossed over the deluge of disinformation spread by WWTI doctors.  It didn’t bother pundits that WWTI doctors botched simple statistics, repeatedly declared the pandemic over, and treated vaccine side-effects as a fate worse than death.  Their predictions of powerful, lifetime “natural” immunity and under 40,000 COVID deaths don’t concern pundits at all.  Pundits often spread blatant disinformation themselves. No, a child’s risk of dying from COVID wasn’t lower than the risk of dying from the flu in 2020, though pundits claim otherwise. Instead of caring about basic facts, pundits treated WWTI doctors as oppressed victims because they lost a YouTube video and some Tweets. According to pundits, WWTI doctors were “smeared,” and even with everything that’s happening right now, we should center their feelings above all else.
Pundits never discuss the plan for herd immunity via natural immunity in 3-6 months or its origins at the hands of a proud child-labor advocate.  Though this pro-infection rhetoric dominated the discourse in 2020, pundits seek to replace it with a fantasy where WWTI doctors simply cared about education for underprivileged children.  Several pundits applauded this plan to use infected children as human shields at the time- you should be exposing yourself to the virus in order to promote herd immunity– and today, they refuse to revisit their words or acknowledge the existence of videos like this.
However, it’s not 2020 anymore. Only sheltered pundits whine about lockdowns today, and we no longer have to evaluate WWTI doctors by their entirely imagined accomplishments.  Some of them have actual responsibility for the first time. They told us they would have done amazing and wonderful things with regards to COVID, but they have a real-world track record now. How are things going at the NIH, FDA, and ACIP? How is the overall state of science and medicine under their leadership?  Were WWTI doctors right about RFK Jr. being the savior of vaccines? Is America becoming healthy again? 
And suddenly the opinion class gets real quiet. They have nothing to say about their role in enabling all of that and they never will.


“We Want Them Infected” – My Book is Done!
Prior to the pandemic, the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security ranked the U.S. as the first out of 195 countries on their pandemic preparedness. What went wrong?
Jonathan Howard on April 21, 2023
Link

Prior to the pandemic, the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security ranked the U.S. as the first out of 195 countries on their pandemic preparedness. Reality would soon prove otherwise. Despite the arrival of effective vaccines in record time, a million Americans died of COVID in two years, and many millions more were severely injured by it.
What went wrong?
For the past two years here at Science Based Medicine, I have been documenting one answer to that question: Americans were deluged with misinformation spread by high-credentialed doctors and scientists at our most esteemed universities. I have since organized and curated my thoughts into a book titled “We Want Them Infected“, which is now available from Redhawk Publications (and Amazon). In it, I document how doctors underestimated COVID from the pandemic’s first days and later spread baseless conspiracies that the death toll was inflated to avoid admitting error. I discuss the purposeful program to infect unvaccinated young people with a new virus that would prove fatal for some of them, and I document how the anti-vaccine movement has infiltrated mainstream American medicine. Much of this was led by a man who wrote a pro-child labor article titled “Let the Kids Work” and who had ties to overtly racist organizations.
I don’t intend this book to be comforting.
Below are my introduction, the foreword by Michael Lewis (I was on his podcast), the table of contents, some nice things people I admire said about the book, and a huge “thank you” to Drs. David Gorksi and Steve Novella for giving me a voice here.
Introduction
The title of this book is astonishing. We want them infected. Those four words come not from some random crackpot, but from Dr. Paul Alexander, an epidemiologist and official in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services during the Trump administration. On July 4, 2020, before anyone had been vaccinated, he said:
Infants, kids, teens ,young people, young adults, middle aged with no conditions etc. have zero to little risk….so we use them to develop herd…we want them infected….
In the middle of a raging pandemic, with a new, poorly understood virus that was capable of overwhelming hospitals and morgues, Dr. Alexander wanted it to spread rapidly amongst hundreds of millions of unvaccinated, young Americans.
He was not alone. Doctors and scientists from our most prestigious universities convinced millions of Americans that COVID was only dangerous for the elderly and infirm They influenced powerful politicians, who also wanted the virus to spread widely. While overwhelmed frontline doctors begged the public to avoid the virus, other doctors, completely sheltered from the consequences of their words, worked to undermine these efforts.
Though they spoke in euphemisms, unlike Dr. Alexander, they too supported the mass infection of unvaccinated children and young adults. To achieve their goal, they spoke about SARS-CoV-2 using the same glowing terms anti-vaxxers speak about measles or HPV. The arrival of vaccines did nothing to dampen their enthusiasm to spread the virus. In fact, doctors led a successful campaign to undermine pediatric vaccination. The anti-vaccine movement is now mainstream.
In this book, I will toggle back and forth between an imaginary world, where the pandemic ended many times, and the real world where COVID remains the third leading cause of death in the U.S. In the imaginary world, COVID only threatened the old and infirm. In the real world, tens of thousands of children and young adults were seriously harmed or killed by COVID. In the imaginary world, pediatric vaccines were dangerous and useless. In the real world, the vaccines are imperfect, but much safer than the virus for children. In the imaginary world, all it took to protect nursing homes and open schools was to say “protect nursing homes” and “open schools”. In the real world, this was impossible when the virus was allowed to spread freely. In the imaginary world, contrarian doctors were silenced and suppressed. In the real world, they were very loud and very influential.
All this had real world costs, though not everyone paid the price.
Over a million people are now dead in the country that had been previously ranked first out of 195 countries on its pandemic preparedness. It’s not over yet.
Foreword
The problem with pandemics is that people want to forget them. One year a million Americans are killed by a deadly new virus; the next everyone else is back rooting for the Georgia Bulldogs. The impulse to move on from this particular kind of tragedy is more than a little odd. The United States contains less than five per cent of the world’s population and experienced more than twenty percent of its Covid deaths. If we don’t spend time figuring out why we did such a poor job of protecting ourselves against the last deadly pathogen, how will we protect ourselves any better from the next? Beneath the impulse, I think, is a kind of fatalism–a feeling that there was never much we could have done to save ourselves. That all those people who died were going to die no matter how the rest of us behaved, and so why worry very much about how we behaved?
Now here comes Jonathan Howard to tell us why. A neurologist and psychiatrist in New York City, Dr. Howard served on the front lines in Covid’s first wave. He witnessed a lot of preventable death and suffering. And then he watched, with growing incredulity, as influential scientists attempted to deny or minimize what he had seen with his own two eyes. As members of his own profession violated its deepest principles—and were rewarded with fame and political influence. Dr. Howard wrote a series of compelling essays about his experience—which is how I first learned of his existence. His writing was the first I’d seen that explored how and why a handful of prominent doctors and scientists staked out a position hostile to evidence-based medicine, and got a lot of people killed.
Now Dr. Howard has expanded those essays into this book. It’s an important book, for a couple of reasons. It shows how much damage can be caused, in a society that has trouble figuring out who is and who is not an expert, by a corrupt or phony expert. It also hints at what we might do, to prevent that damage from happening all over again. I urge you to read it.
Michael Lewis, author of Moneyball, The Big Short, The Blind Side, and The Premonition
Table of Contents
    • Chapter 1: “We have protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population”A discussion of pre-pandemic anti-vaccine doctors and how influential, contrarian doctors and scientists made their ideology mainstream.
    • Chapter 2: “It was an unimaginable hell to be quite honest”A recollection of my experience working at Bellevue Hospital during the pandemic.
    • Chapter 3: “This would translate into about 10,000 deaths”Dr. John Ioannidis and how his repeated, public downplaying of the risks of the virus at the pandemic’s start, helped to create enduring myths, with tragic, real-world consequences
    • Chapter 4 “What can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence”A refutation to the many myths spread by Dr. Ioannidis and other contrarian doctors. Doctors who worked with COVID patients know, our patients died from COVID, not with COVID.
    • Chapter 5: “By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.”The Great Barrington Declaration and proposal of herd immunity through mass infection of unvaccinated youth. It never would have worked, and it never was intended to.
    • Chapter 6: “Infants, kids, teens, young people, young adults, middle aged with no conditions, etc. have zero to little risk. …so we use them to develop herd…we want them infected. …”How the idea of mass infection influenced both state and federal actions in regard to the pandemic.
    • Chapter 7: “We’ll have herd immunity by April.”How doctors repeatedly spread the myth that herd immunity was at hand, the pandemic was over, and variants were nothing to worry about.
    • Chapter 8: “The fear that’s driving this pandemic has been heartbreaking to see.”A discussion of how doctors not only mocked and shamed anyone who tried to avoid the virus but also used histrionic language to fear monger about methods to control it.
    • Chapter 9: “Any strong advocate for kid COVID vaccination is off their rocker”A review of pediatric COVID and over 25 anti-vaccine myths spread by doctors. The anti-vaccine movement is now mainstream.
    • Conclusion: “Every time we see or hear such mistruths we need to combat them and call them out”Doctors have an obligation to police misinformation in their profession.
Praise For We Want Them Infected
One of the untold stories of the COVID pandemic in the US is the role of medical and public health professionals in spreading disinformation, pushing for policies that exacerbate the virus’ spread, and drive people away from important interventions, particularly vaccines, which blunt the deadly effects of SARSCOV2. Because of professional courtesy, solidarity or just sheer cowardice, many inside the professions have refused to take on these frauds, egomaniacs, purveyors of sickness and suffering in white coats. Jonathan Howard’s book We Want Them Infected, though, names names. In painstaking detail, he builds an indictment of these men and women who have blood on their hands, abusing the trust of millions to peddle lies and falsehoods. This book is one for the ages, making it hard to sweep the complicity of these individuals with the virus under the carpet, leaving a record for the future, a cautionary tale for all of us.
Gregg Gonsalves, PhD, Associate Professor, Yale School of Public Health, Associate Professor (adjunct), Yale Law School
The legacy of the COVID-19 pandemic will haunt our nation (United States) for many years. This is true not only because of the horrific toll of more than one million American deaths, and those who lost loved ones, but also several failed public health policies that contributed to America’s suffering. In “We Want Them Infected” Dr. Howard tells a dark story of how spurious concepts of herd immunity may have contributed to the spread of COVID-19 in the United States (and perhaps globally). His book provides important information about how we might limit the death and destruction of future virus pandemics.
Dr. Peter Hotez, MD, PhD, DSc (hon), FASTMH, FAAP, Texas Children’s Hospital: Endowed Chair of Tropical Pediatrics | Co-Director, Texas Children’s Hospital Center for Vaccine Development , Baylor College of Medicine: Dean, National School of Tropical Medicine | Professor, Departments of Pediatrics, Molecular Virology & Microbiology | Health Policy Scholar, Rice University, Baker Institute Fellow in Disease & Poverty, Texas A&M University, Faculty-Senior Fellow, Hagler Inst for Advanced Study & Scowcroft Institute of Intl Affairs
The Hippocratic Oath enjoins us to “first do no harm”. Yet, throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, some very prominent doctors have done immense harm. While others were struggling to understand the virus and save lives, a few were spreading what we describe as disinformation, but might equally call lies. By aligning with populist politicians they undermined public health responses and cost many lives. Everyone who has suffered from Covid-19, losing friends and relatives or experiencing Long COVID, or who cared for them, owes a debt of gratitude to Jonathan Howard. By cataloging in detail the ways in which the words and actions of those who, for whatever reason, distorted the science, he must surely have destroyed any remaining credibility they possess.
Dr. Martin McKee, President, British Medical Association, Professor of European public health at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
A comprehensive and sober fact-checking of a disturbing phenomenon: the rise of the COVID contrarian doctor. We Want Them Infected deconstructs the revisionist history and failed predictions of the physicians repeatedly caught prioritizing wishful thinking over data. Dr. Howard has kept the receipts that show these contrarian doctors’ crystal balls are badly broken.
Jonathan Jarry, MSc, Science Communicator for McGill University’s Office for Science and Society
Jonathan Howard’s important book sheds light on a crucial issue: how previously mainstream doctors became mouthpieces of misinformation, promoting claims as false as those of anti-vaccine activists, and making controlling COVID-19 that much harder. The book is gripping, hard to put down, full of evidence and the personal experience of frontline doctors, and thoroughly explains both the problems with the doctors’ claims and the way they affected the fight against the virus. It is a valuable addition to understanding how misinformation spread during the pandemic, and I would encourage policymakers, doctors, and academics to read and share it.
Dorit Reiss, Professor of Law and the James Edgar Hervey ’50 Chair of Litigation at UC Hastings College of Law. 
Acknowledgements
This book would not exist without Drs. David Gorski and Steven Novella. I am enormously thankful to them for trusting me with a regular spot at Science Based Medicine. I had no idea I had so much to say, and they recognized that before I did. I am also thankful for all they’ve taught me over the years about the importance of critical thinking in medicine. We can all learn something by thinking about why smart people fall for fads like cupping. Dr. Gorski is mentioned frequently in this book, but I could have credited him with some insight on nearly every page. He’s been doing this for decades and taught me everything I needed to know to write it. Many people disappointed me during this pandemic. Drs. Gorski and Novella did not.

The Videos THEY Don’t Want You to See. A Silenced, Censored Doctor Speaks Out.
Everyone Else is Lying to You: The Documentary
Jonathan Howard on September 19, 2025
Link
Don’t worry. This is not another self-pitying article about the fate of my YouTube channel. Rather, this is about something much more important, the contents of my YouTube channel. It dismayed me that the loss of my videos garnered media attention, while the videos themselves. I had accumulated hundreds of clips of our medical establishment saying obviously false and dangerous things. Yet, it mostly generated yawns and shrugs. Maybe if more people had cared, things would be different today.
COVID killed 1.2 million Americans and it injured millions more. It’s not over yet. Meanwhile, a vaccine saved millions of lives. Despite this, Kennedy and his coterie of disinformation doctors are in charge and taking a wrecking ball to things.
How did this happen?
That’s the question I try to answer in my new book, Everyone Else is Lying to You, which tells the story of how We Want Them Infected doctors, aided by institutional cowardice, weaponized doubt to rewrite the history of the pandemic and elevate themselves to power. In it, I instruct readers to watch the videos of WWTI doctors. I want people to know exactly what these doctors said in their own words. The loss of my YouTube channel made me realize I had an opportunity to facilitate that
To that end, I have collected and curated many of my censored videos to reveal the propaganda techniques of WWTI doctors and demonstrate how disinformation that began in spring 2020 led directly to this sad moment. Here are the individual chapters:
    • Introduction: A bit about me and a the Cliff Notes version of the entire project.
    • Fire the People Responsible: People who stoked rage over COVID mitigations are now in power, where they are are now using the anger they generated as a pretext to take a wrecking ball to things today. WWTI doctors are enabling Kennedy in everything he does.
    • Videos I Can’t Show You: It’s important to note what is absent from these videos.
    • We Want Them Infected: The purposeful mass infection of unvaccinated people under age 60-70 to end the pandemic in 3-6 months dominated the discourse in 2020. Today, there is a successful movement to deny this all ever happened and portray WWTI doctors as selfless souls who cared only about poor children and the working class.
    • Stop Trusting Public Health: Deliberate messages of doubt and mistrust, permeate every utterance of WWTI doctors.
    • We’ve Had More Flu Deaths: WWTI doctors botched basic facts all the time, always minimizing the harms of COVID or exaggerating the harms of measures to control it.
    • The Power of Natural Immunity: WWTI doctors spoke about SARS-CoV-2 in very positive, glowing terms. They were upset that others didn’t join them in heaping praise on the virus.
    • We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April: WWTI doctors declared herd immunity had arrived countless times.
    • How to Stop Living in Fear of COVID: WWTI doctors treated fear of COVID as a significant problem, on both a societal and individual level. With COVID we were told to be calm, measured, and rational.
    • Worse Than COVID: WWTI doctors portrayed mitigation measures as catastrophic disaster of epic proportions. They opposed mitigation measures precisely because they delayed infections and that without mitigations, we would have barely would have noticed the virus. Life could have gone on as normal.
    • No One Knows: WWTI doctors treated theoretical risks of vaccines more seriously than real harms of COVID, including literal death.
    • It’s Their Virus: Doctors who lamented the lack of infections, treated infection #1 as a deliberate catastrophe, to spread doubt and anger about those who tried to control it.
    • Pretty Much Zero: WWTI doctors massively overhyped vaccines in the first 6 months of 2021, claiming they were 100% effective, blocked transmission, and would end the pandemic.
    • Poor Children: WWTI doctors feigned concern about social justice issues, but only with regards to COVID mitigations.
    • I am a Scientific Dissident: Despite being famous and influential, WWTI doctors centered their grievances and perceived victimhood. They treated the loss of a YouTube video as more consequential than the loss of a young life.
    • We Would Have: WWTI doctors inhabited a fantasy world where they boasted of entirely imagined accomplishments and heaped praise on themselves because they “proposed” things. Their real-world track record is one of abject failure.
    • Those Pieces of Shit are Still Lying: Despite claiming to be neutral scientists, WWTI doctors used emotion to mock and infuriate people.
    • Total Eradication: WWTI doctors used dishonest straw man arguments to spread doubt and mistrust.
    • Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past: Institutions were silent or enabled their WWTI doctors. They are now paying the price.
    • Sabotaging RFK Jr’s Confirmation Will Increase Vaccine Hesitancy: To achieve political power, WWTI doctors elevated cranks and quacks.
Here is the complete documentary. I hope you find it useful.
    • 

LONG COVID

Long COVID
Medical experts are just starting to bring long COVID into focus, but there is still much we don’t know.
Steven Novella on April 28, 2021
Link

Part of the challenge of the COVID-19 pandemic is (to borrow a commonly used metaphor) we are building the plane as we are flying it. We entered the pandemic with zero knowledge of SARS-CoV-2 and the infection it causes, and have been learning as we go. It is a testament to our modern institutions of science that we have come so far in just 17 months.
One of the features of COVID-19 that has emerged over time is being called “long COVID” – when chronic symptoms persist after the infection itself has resolved. Right now we are in the phase of this medical condition of just gathering data, and hoping that some patterns emerge. But we still know very little about this complication. Most of the published literature on long COVID is case reports – front line observations that may lead to hypotheses that can later be tested. A recent review of these reports summarized the results:
Fatigue, cough, chest tightness, breathlessness, palpitations, myalgia and difficulty to focus are symptoms reported in long COVID. It could be related to organ damage, post viral syndrome, post-critical care syndrome and others.
From these symptoms it seems that the brain, heart, and lungs are the most affected organs. It could be that all organs are equally affected, but these are the ones that cause chronic noticeable symptoms. As neurologists are one of the specialists to whom these patients might be referred for evaluation, I have started to see long COVID patients myself. Fatigue and “brain fog” are the most common symptoms of those patients referred to me. The cognitive symptoms are extremely similar to patients who have post-concussive syndrome or traumatic brain injury. I have also seen patients over the years who survived a serious brain infection, and they too are similar.
What this means is that these symptoms are non-specific. They don’t point to a particular part of the brain or to a particular mechanism of injury. They may simply reflect the fact that the brain has undergone some diffuse stress and has not yet recovered. For brain injury the mechanism is most likely “diffuse axonal injury” – the connections among brain cells have been partially disrupted. This means the brain has a harder time communicating with itself, which further means that those tasks which require heavy brain processing power are the most affected. People with TBI therefore have a hard time multi-tasking and concentrating, and they cannot keep up with changing or complex sensory input. Sometimes they feel like they just don’t have complete control over their movements, so things that used to be easy, like walking, are now challenging.
The cardiac and pulmonary symptoms are likewise nonspecific – breathlessness could be many things. Therefore researchers have many clues to track down. There is some reason to suspect that the virus itself, particularly the spike protein that allows it to infect cells, causes cellular damage. However, the body’s immune response is also part of the equation. This is perhaps why steroids are one of the most effective treatments for severe COVID – it suppresses the host’s immune respond to limit resulting damage.
Post-infectious syndromes are not uncommon – a severe long term infection can takes its toll on the body. Some people never recover back to their prior baseline. There is also no specific treatment, which is limited to symptom management and trying to generically optimize recovery. We are in the same situation with long COVID, giving sufferers what amounts to supportive care (physical therapy, speech therapy, and breathing exercises) and so called “tincture of time”. For this reason I don’t suspect we will find any specific treatment for long COVID anytime soon.
Research is likely to help in predicting who is most likely to get it, and perhaps in treatments during the active infection that will reduce the chance of developing long COVID. For now just treating the infection itself is our best bet.
We are starting to see the scope of long COVID. An NHS survey in the UK from April 2020 to March 2021 found that 25% of patients from 35-69 years old complained of chronic symptoms more than 5 weeks following the presumed date of infection onset. This is not a small problem. It is important to include long COVID when we consider the toll of this pandemic. Much reporting focuses on the death toll, which of course is the worst outcome, but when considering the burden of an illness we need to include morbidity with mortality. Long COVID means millions of people will be affected, with lost productivity and increased health-care costs. Any “cost-benefit” analysis of steps taken to mitigate the pandemic needs to include long COVID in the equation.
It is also imperative for the medical community to pay close attention to long COVID – to find out as much as we can, and optimize management as much as possible. The situation is ripe for exploitation by the existing quack infrastructure. Pretty soon every existing snake oil treatment will become a treatment for long COVID and people who never even had COVID will be diagnosed with it to explain their symptoms and justify the snake oil. Victims of long COVID will then just be harmed again, extracting their time, energy, and limited funds and perhaps even exposing them to harmful interventions. Symptoms of long COVID tend to wax and wane, with good days and weeks and bad stretches of time – a setup for placebo effects to give the illusion that any intervention works. It’s coming, I have no doubt, and we’ll just have to stay on top of it as much as possible.

Update on Long COVID
Recent evidence suggests the burden of long COVID is significant.
Steven Novella on March 30, 2022
Tweet

Scientists are still grappling with the full implications of the COVID-19 pandemic. One of the challenges is that the SARS-CoV2 virus continues to mutate and produce new strains, so studying the virus and its effects is a moving target. The relatively high rate of hospitalizations and deaths are of course extremely concerning, and what is frequently offered as the primary reason to get vaccinated. However it is now well-established that infection with COVID-19 can also produce so-called “long COVID” with chronic symptoms that persist long after the acute infection.
The technical term for long COVID is post-acute sequelae of COVID-19 (PASC). These are any of a long list of symptoms that persist after the acute infection has completely resolved. The symptoms are an indication that COVID is a systemic infection, not just a pulmonary infection. The largest study to date of PASC showed:
Among COVID-19 survivors (mean [SD] age: 46.3 [19.8], 55.6% female), 57.00% had one or more long-COVID feature recorded during the whole 6-month period (i.e., including the acute phase), and 36.55% between 3 and 6 months. The incidence of each feature was: abnormal breathing (18.71% in the 1- to 180-day period; 7.94% in the 90- to180-day period), fatigue/malaise (12.82%; 5.87%), chest/throat pain (12.60%; 5.71%), headache (8.67%; 4.63%), other pain (11.60%; 7.19%), abdominal symptoms (15.58%; 8.29%), myalgia (3.24%; 1.54%), cognitive symptoms (7.88%; 3.95%), and anxiety/depression (22.82%; 15.49%).
More recent studies provide further reasons for concern. A paper presented at this year’s European Congress of Clinical Microbiology & Infectious Diseases (ECCMID) suggests that long COVID symptoms may be different for different variants of the virus. This is a study of hospitalized patients, so we would expect a higher incidence of long COVID, and that is what they found:
At least three-quarters 325/428 (76%) of patients reported at least one persistent symptom. The most common reported symptoms were shortness of breath (157/428; 37%) and chronic fatigue (156/428; 36%) followed by sleep problems (68/428; 16%), visual problems (55/428; 13%), and brain fog (54/428; 13%).
Further the researchers found that when they divided the patient into those infected while the original variant of the virus was dominant were different than when the alpha variant was dominant. The later alpha variant was associated with a greater incidence of brain fog, myalgia, fatigue, anxiety, and depression, with a lower incidence of loss of smell (anosmia), altered taste, and decreased hearing. It remains to be seen what effect the Delta and Omicron variants had on long COVID.
More concerning is a recent study published in Nature looking at brain scans in patients before and after infection with COVID. The study takes advantage of the UK Biobank, which collects data on subjects including brain scans and health questionnaires. This is an extremely useful resource because it combines the benefits of large numbers of subjects with detailed information. In this case the database provided brain scan before being infected with COVID, something that would otherwise not be available in large numbers of subjects. When comparing those infected with COVID vs those not infected the researchers found:
(i) greater reduction in grey matter thickness and tissue-contrast in the orbitofrontal cortex and parahippocampal gyrus, (ii) greater changes in markers of tissue damage in regions functionally-connected to the primary olfactory cortex, and (iii) greater reduction in global brain size.
These differences were present even after removing those subjects who were hospitalized, so they can be see even with relatively mild COVID. The authors also point out that the areas most affected were in the limbic region, which includes olfactory sense – smell. This suggests that the virus may be entering the brain through the nasal passages and the olfactory nerve, which makes sense. However, effects were not limited to these regions and were present globally.
This result is extremely concerning. Of course, all of the data I have been discussing is observational. That is the only kind of data we will have on the clinical effects of COVID because we obviously cannot randomize subjects to be infected with COVID. But it is easy enough to control for premorbid conditions and other variables, and the large numbers make the data fairly robust. In the case of reduced brain volume, we also don’t know what the long-term effects will be. After 1-2 years, for example, will brain volumes return to baseline? We also need further research to correlate these anatomic findings with specific clinical outcomes, such as cognitive function on standardized neuropsychological testing.
The data we have so far, however, strongly indicates that long COVID is extremely common in those who contract COVID, persisting for at least 3-6 months in about a third of all those infected. The risk of long COVID is greater for those with more severe infections and in vulnerable populations, but they can occur even with mild infections in those who are young and healthy at baseline. Further, long COVID is not merely a subjective persistence of symptoms but can be tied to biological changes in organs, most notably the brain.
All this means that the long-term health burden of the COVID-19 pandemic may be far greater than is currently apparent. A full accounting of the health care costs and long-term disability will takes years to fully appreciate, but early indications are that they are likely to be substantial.
When calculating the risk vs benefit of interventions, such as vaccines and mask mandates, we cannot look only at hospitalizations and deaths. We also need to consider what the long-term burden of long COVID is likely to be. At the very least this is one more reason for everyone to get fully vaccinated and boosted.

More on Long COVID
Steven Novella onAugust 21, 2024
Link
It’s interesting to follow the scientific exploration of a new clinical entity in real time. It reveals a lot about how medical science works, and how scientists nibble away at complex problems. This is partly why I have been closely following the story of long COVID as it has unfolded over the last few years. I also see patients with long COVID so it’s important to my clinical practice as well.
Long COVID, technically known as postacute sequelae of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection (PASC), is a host of symptoms that persist after active infection with SARS-CoV-2 has completely resolved. It is estimated that between 5 and 30% of people who had a COVID infection have some symptoms of Long COVID, which can persist for weeks, or even months or years after the infection. The high range of estimates is due to the heterogeneous nature of the syndrome – what counts as Long COVID? Also, there is great variability is how the syndrome is reported and diagnosed.
There are many potential symptoms, but the most common are fatigue, brain fog, weakness, dizziness, tremor, and GI symptoms. We know that COVID is a multi-system disease (not just respiratory), so it makes sense that many different organ systems can be involved in long COVID. But this does make diagnosis and investigating potential causes difficult. It also lead many early patients to be dismissed as psychogenic, but recognition of long COVID is now standard.
There is still a long list of potential causes of long COVID, including: direct or indirect invasion of the virus into the brain, immune dysregulation, hormonal disturbances, elevated cytokine levels due to immune reaction leading to chronic inflammation, direct tissue damage to other organs, and persistent low-grade infection. Persistent, latent, or reactivation of viral activity has also been proposed. Over the last few years research has been trending toward immune dysregulation, but that is not fully established. It’s likely that there are different causes in different people.
A recent study, for example, has shows that antigens left behind by COVID infection changes the response to cortisol, especially in the brain. This may cause an exaggerated inflammatory stress response.
Diagnosis remains tricky because so far no clinically useful biomarker has been identified. Biomarkers are changes in a measurable parameter (like a blood test of physiological measure) that correlates with existence of an identifiable clinical syndrome. For example, high blood sugar is a marker for diabetes mellitus, and can be used to establish the diagnosis. Long COVID has no such biomarker.
This does not call Long COVID into question, as many recognized clinical entities lack biomarkers (such as migraines). Biomarkers are also especially difficult to establish when the clinical entity is multifactorial or includes many related phenomena. Long COVID, in other words, is likely to be more than one thing – different organ systems being affected by the COVID infection in different ways.
There is also a bidirectional relationship between biomarkers and understanding the pathophysiology of a clinical syndrome. If we identify a biomarker, that is a clue as to what is causes the symptoms. And if we understood what is causing one or more symptoms that would suggest a potential biomarker to look at. So far we have established neither definitively, so we are still in the exploration phase.
Regardless of our early stage of understanding of long COVID, can it be treated? Yes and no. A recent systematic review of treatments for long COVID found six published trials showing significant improvement of long COVID symptoms with specific treatments. However, these treatments were all symptom-based, not targeting any potential etiology. In other words, if you treat fatigue with stimulants or headaches with analgesics, they may work, but that tells us nothing about the causes of the fatigue or headaches.
The review also found that we are in the early stages of this research, with very heterogeneous results. They conclude: “Further standardization of the diagnostic criteria, inclusion of participants with concomitant chronic cardiometabolic diseases and standardization of outcomes will be essential in future clinical trials.”
Over the last four years we have seen long COVID go from a clinical observation, often dismissed as psychogenic, to a recognized syndrome that has a huge impact of patient quality of life and ability to function. COVID is a systemic serious infectious disease, and it is no surprise that it potentially leads to post-infectious symptoms (something that is very common with serious systemic infections). We are starting to zero in on potential causes, at least part of which seems to be immune dysregulation following infection. Treatments so far are symptomatic, but can be very helpful and improve quality of life.
But there is a lot of research to be done, and a lot of reporting as this interesting scientific story continues to unfold.

The search for long COVID treatments
What are current treatments for long COVID, and are they effective?
Scott Gavura on April 28, 2022
Link


With the availability of vaccines and new treatments against COVID-19, the risk of serious outcomes, like death, is significantly lower than it was two years ago. Add in the elimination of most public health restrictions and it may feel like we’re closer to the “end” of the pandemic (however defined) than the beginning. But overlooked among the falling fatality statistics and high (apparent) recovery rates from COVID-19 is the recognition that “long haul COVID” or just “long COVID” may be a long-term consequence of a COVID infection for millions.
We now know that almost 60% of the US population (including 75% of children and adolescents) has been infected with COVID-19 (as of February 2022). Last month Steven Novella gave a detailed update on the incidence and prevalence of long COVID. Today I want to review some of the treatments that are being studied for the treatment of long COVID.
Is there a definition of “long” COVID?
The acute effects of COVID-19 infections typically last up to 4 weeks. In most cases, symptoms are fully resolved by 12 weeks. A working definition for long COVID (or post-acute sequelae of COVID-19 (PASC)) would be signs and symptoms that persist or develop after the acute effects of a COVID-19 infection. The UK’s National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) uses the term post-COVID 19 syndrome and gives the following definition:
Signs and symptoms that develop during or after an infection consistent with COVID‑19, continue for more than 12 weeks and are not explained by an alternative diagnosis. It usually presents with clusters of symptoms, often overlapping, which can fluctuate and change over time and can affect any system in the body. Post‑COVID‑19 syndrome may be considered before 12 weeks while the possibility of an alternative underlying disease is also being assessed.
In addition to the clinical case definitions, the term ‘long COVID’ is commonly used to describe signs and symptoms that continue or develop after acute COVID‑19. It includes both ongoing symptomatic COVID‑19 (from 4 to 12 weeks) and post‑COVID‑19 syndrome (12 weeks or more).
Steven Novella nicely summarized the largest study (to date) of PASC, which noted:
Among COVID-19 survivors (mean [SD] age: 46.3 [19.8], 55.6% female), 57.00% had one or more long-COVID feature recorded during the whole 6-month period (i.e., including the acute phase), and 36.55% between 3 and 6 months. The incidence of each feature was: abnormal breathing (18.71% in the 1- to 180-day period; 7.94% in the 90- to180-day period), fatigue/malaise (12.82%; 5.87%), chest/throat pain (12.60%; 5.71%), headache (8.67%; 4.63%), other pain (11.60%; 7.19%), abdominal symptoms (15.58%; 8.29%), myalgia (3.24%; 1.54%), cognitive symptoms (7.88%; 3.95%), and anxiety/depression (22.82%; 15.49%).
Steve also highlighted evidence suggesting that the different variants may be causing different long COVID symptoms.
Since the initial identification of long COVID, our knowledge base has progressed, and what it suggests is concerning. Long COVID is common, and may last for several months in about one-third of those infected. Long COVID is possible even after mild infections, and in people who have no underlying health conditions. Brain imaging confirms that COVID causes objective changes. Whether or not those changes are permanent is unclear. The symptoms reported can be wide-ranging, and include:
Respiratory symptoms
    • Breathlessness
    • Cough
Cardiovascular symptoms
    • Chest tightness
    • Chest pain
    • Palpitations
Generalised symptoms
    • Fatigue
    • Fever
    • Pain
Neurological symptoms
    • Cognitive impairment (‘brain fog’, loss of concentration or memory issues)
    • Headache
    • Sleep disturbance
    • Peripheral neuropathy symptoms (pins and needles and numbness)
    • Dizziness
    • Delirium (in older populations)
    • Mobility impairment
    • Visual disturbance
Gastrointestinal symptoms
    • Abdominal pain
    • Nausea and vomiting
    • Diarrhoea
    • Weight loss and reduced appetite
Musculoskeletal symptoms
    • Joint pain
    • Muscle pain
Ear, nose and throat symptoms
    • Tinnitus
    • Earache
    • Sore throat
    • Dizziness
    • Loss of taste and/or smell
    • Nasal congestion
Dermatological symptoms
    • Skin rashes
    • Hair loss
Psychological/psychiatric symptoms
    • Symptoms of depression
    • Symptoms of anxiety
    • Symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder
This BMJ illustration demonstrates how COVID is not simply a respiratory disease:

Therapies for long COVID
Assessment of patients with prolonged symptoms after a COVID-19 infection will consider past medical history, and will include standard blood work investigations. Imaging like X-rays may also be done, if there are respiratory issues. Evaluations will be guided by signs and symptoms, and should be conducted to rule out serious/life-threatening complications as well as to determine (if possible) the relationship to a COVID-19 infection. Unfortunately, no specific laboratory test can clearly distinguish long COVID from other conditions.
In most cases, self-management is appropriate and recommended. Self-monitoring at home may be appropriate for many, and could includes symptom diaries and measures like pulse oximetry and blood pressure, as appropriate. Given the variety of long COVID symptoms, management will be targeted based on findings. In some cases, multi-specialist referral and interprofessional assessment and rehabilitation programs may be appropriate. Therapies can include, but are not limited to:
Dietary Changes – There are no specific dietary changes shown to benefit long COVID. However, poor diet is a possible consequence of long COVID if sufferers feel terrible. The UK Dieticians Association recommends a balanced diet that supplies a variety of vitamins, minerals, protein, carbohydrates, fluid and fibre to help with recovery. For those suffering from a lost of smell or taste, the organization AbScent provides some tips on smell training and general resources on the recovery of taste and smell.
There is no evidence that specific supplements of vitamins (e.g., vitamin C, vitamin D, niacin/vitamin B3) or minerals can help with long COVID. As has been discussed numerous times on this blog, large doses of individual vitamins or minerals are not innocuous, but a standard multivitamin may be helpful in supporting nutrition when diets are poor.
There is some interest in a low histamine diet for long COVID. There is little evidence to support the benefits of a low histamine diet or an “anti-inflammatory diet” more generally, although this is an area of research, and anecdotal reports suggest that some find these diets beneficial.
Shortness of breath is commonly reported in long COVID. This tends to improve, but slowly. Breathing exercises may be prescribed and medication is sometimes necessary. Chest pain and discomfort can be a symptom of more serious conditions as well as long COVID. Anti-inflammatory drugs are occasionally appropriate, but have their own side effects. Persistent cough following COVID-19 is managed similarly to other post-viral cough conditions. Over-the-counter cough suppressants are not-well supported by evidence but may be helpful to some. Inhaled drugs, like the ones used to treat asthma, may also be used.
Long COVID fatigue can range from mild to severe. There is detailed guidance produced by the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation to inform treatment planning. It advocates an individualized and structured return-to-activity program with the goal of restoring activity and improving quality of life. A wide range of supplements have been suggested for fatigue, including omega fatty acids, vitamins, coenzyme Q10, and herbs such as ginseng and echinacea. Most of these products have been discussed more extensively in other posts on this blog, and there is little to no evidence they offer meaningful benefits. There is also an array of prescription drugs that have been suggested for long COVID based on experiences in the ME/CFS/chronic fatigue/SEID community. There is very limited evidence to support these products in either population. The same can be said for acupuncture for the treatment of fatigue, or any other long-COVID syndrome.
More research really is required
Treatment approaches to long COVID must be personalized to address the signs and symptoms of each case, as well as each patient’s preferences. While we are over two years into the pandemic, research into long COVID is just in its infancy. Given the number of people that will experience long COVID, and the potential cumulative disability in the population, the consequence of the pandemic will likely be felt for years, if not decades..

A Bit of Good News: Kids Appear to Have Lower Risk of Post-COVID Conditions Than Previously Thought
Based on a recently published study using improved criteria for determining long term COVID-related health problems, it looks like kids are less likely to be negatively impacted than previously thought.
Clay Jones on January 5, 2024
Link

A little over a year ago, the AAP discussed the potential for the development of “post-COVID-19 conditions” in children in the release of guidance on follow-up care after infection with the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Post-COVID conditions, using CDC guidance, was defined as “physical and mental health consequences experienced by some patients that remained present for 4 or more weeks following a SARS-CoV-2 infection.” They further clarified that some children developed more significant and longer lasting complaints that impaired their quality of life, which fell into the category of post-acute sequelae of COVID (PASC):
The World Health Organization (WHO) recently developed a consensus definition of pediatric PASC, which is defined as the presence of one or more new, persistent physical symptoms, which may fluctuate and relapse, that lasts at least 12 weeks after confirmed initial SARS-CoV-2 infection and impairs daily function.
This part is confusing. The WHO had not, in fact, developed a definition of pediatric PASC at that time. The WHO has actually never used that term, instead choosing post-COVID condition (PCC), which they defined only for adults in 2021. It wasn’t until February of 2023 that the WHO finally released an updated definition specific to children, but nobody is perfect.
As I will get to shortly, the WHO definition of pediatric PCC would end up being a bit different from what was stated in the AAP guidance and mistakenly labelled as PASC. It appears that the AAP jumbled up the current (at the time) adult WHO definition of PCC with definitions of PASC used by other organizations, because the WHO didn’t put so much focus on impairment of daily function. It would, however, when eventually releasing a pediatric focused definition in 2023, include the fact that this is a typical component of PCC.
The NIH uses PASC as their preferred term. The CDC uses it as a subset of PCC. So any hardcore nationalists reading this in ‘Merica right now can go with that if they want. Personally I’m sticking with PCC because it feels right, and science cares about my feelings. Other individuals, groups, and professional organizations use a variety of terms to describe bad stuff that happens to some people after acute COVID-19, such as long COVID, long-haul COVID, chronic COVID, late sequelae of COVID-19, post-acute COVID-19, and post-acute sequelae of SARS-CoV-2 infection. Naturally because of the heterogeneity in terms, among other issues, data on prevalence has been a bit all over the place, especially in children.
As with adults suffering with post-COVID conditions, PASC, or whatever you want to call it this week, a wide variety of complaints and conditions affecting several body systems have been documented in children. Common symptoms are fatigue, headache, distorted sense of smell, abdominal pain, muscle aches, post-exertional malaise, and rashes. The list also includes mental health disturbances, impaired sleep, and even potentially life-threatening thromboembolic events such as pulmonary embolism. Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children, a severe inflammatory response to recent SARS-CoV-2 infection resulting in organ dysfunction or shock, is technically a post-COVID condition but generally discussed separately as there is specific testing used for diagnosis and it tends to occur within 2 to 4 weeks of acute COVID-19.
In September of 2022, data was limited and the reported incidence of PCC in children ranged from 2% to 66%. A large meta-analysis published around that time had found that 25% of children continued to have symptoms one month after the initial infection and other studies investigating pediatric PASC determined a prevalence of 2% to 5% at 90 days. Using adult WHO criteria, the AAP estimated that PASC (again, not what WHO actually calls it) might impact anywhere from 2% to even 10% of kids. But in general, attempts to determine accurate numbers was hampered by differing definitions, populations, and study methods.
But what about now? Have we learned anything in the past 15 months or so? Authors of a Canadian paper recently published in JAMA Pediatrics set out to update our understanding:
To address the aforementioned limitations and to standardize pediatric PCC definitions, the World Health Organization (WHO) adopted a consensus definition that added several qualifiers, notably, that symptoms have an onset within 3 months of the infection, persist for a minimum of 2 months, and limit everyday function and ascertainment of developmental milestones. Use of this definition has the potential to advance our understanding of PCC in children. Thus, we sought to quantify the prevalence of PCC at 6 and 12 months after acute infection and to characterize symptoms among children evaluated in pediatric EDs across Canada using the WHO definition.
Even this requires the introduction of a little nuance. The WHO pediatric PCC criteria doesn’t state that limitation of everyday function or in meeting developmental milestones is absolutely required. According to the published clinical case definition, participants in the expert panel agreed that though symptoms should generally have a negative effect on daily function/development, this is challenging when caring for young children who rely on their caregivers to communicate for them. Ultimately, such a distinction must be made on a case by case basis.
Here is the exact breakdown straight from the WHO:
Post COVID-19 condition in children and adolescents occurs in individuals with a history of confirmed or probable SARS-CoV-2 infection, when experiencing symptoms lasting at least 2 months which initially occurred within 3 months of acute COVID-19.
Current evidence suggests that symptoms more frequently reported in children and adolescents with post-COVID-19 condition compared with controls are fatigue, altered smell/anosmia and anxiety. Other symptoms have also been reported.
Symptoms generally have an impact on everyday functioning such as changes in eating habits, physical activity, behaviour, academic performance, social functions (interactions with friends, peers, family) and developmental milestones.
Symptoms may be new onset following initial recovery from an acute COVID-19episode or persist from the initial illness. They may also fluctuate or relapse over time.
Workup may reveal additional diagnoses, but this does not exclude the diagnosis of post COVID-19condition.
This can be applied to children of all ages, with age-specific symptoms and impact on everyday function taken into consideration.
The study was prospective and involved subjects who required testing for SARS-CoV-2 infection at 14 Canadian pediatric emergency departments between the Summer of 2020 and early 2022. Data was collected during the initial ED visit and at 14 days in order to determine eligibility, and then at 90 days (if enrolled) in order to determine a diagnosis of PCC. At 6 and 12 months after the initial ED visit, caregivers answered questions on PCC symptoms and overall health/quality of life.
The authors chose persistence of PCC diagnosis (if diagnosed at 90 days) using the WHO definition at 6 and 12 months following COVID-19 diagnosis as the primary outcome. As secondary outcomes, they chose quality of life measurements using two approaches, a validated pediatric inventory tool and a 0- to 100-point scale. As a third secondary outcome, they looked at PCC symptom profiles at 12 months.
At the end of recruitment, 7,421 patients were screened with 7,263 deemed eligible for the study. Of these, 1,454 were SARS-CoV-2 positive and 5,809 were negative. Of these, 5,147 (1,152+, 3,995-) were evaluated at 6 months and 5,563 (1,192+, 4,371-) at 12 months. Most were young, with a median age of subjects of 2 years.
At 6 months, based on symptoms and quality of life changes meeting WHO criteria, 0.52% of children who had COVID-19 initially were diagnosed with PCC compared to 0.10% of those in the control group. At 12 months, 0.67% and 0.16% of children testing positive and negative at their initial ED visit respectively ended up meeting criteria for PCC. Furthermore, quality of life measurements at 6 and 12 months were equivalent (98.4 and 98.8) regardless of initial testing status.
It appears that chronic and severe COVID-related problems are less likely to impact children than previous reports estimated, which is good news. And this is a study that went to further lengths to focus in on clinically meaningful PCC than previous attempts, which likely lumped together PCC with milder presentations. The authors do point out, however, that these results may not generalize to older children and adolescents since the bulk of subjects were less than 8 years old. Also there were no methods used to determine any negative developmental impacts after COVID-19 in study subjects, so it is possible that PCC was underestimated in infants.
Though quality of life scores were essentially equivalent in both groups at 6 and 12 months, the study did find that there was a significant differences in caregiver perception of their child’s overall health at the 12-month mark. 24% of children with COVID-19 were felt to have worse overall health compared to 15% of those who tested negative initially. The authors point out that this particular assessment is more subjective than the tool used to measure quality of life and was potentially biased by specific beliefs within families.
As with all studies, there were some issues that potentially limit our ability to draw conclusions from this study. In addition to losing roughly 30% of subjects to follow up and the reliance on caregiver rather than direct patient report, which is obviously difficult with young children, the authors point out a few more interesting issues:
We did not perform antibody testing to confirm the absence of SARS-CoV-2 infection during the study period in control participants, and thus control group contamination could have occurred, which would minimize our ability to detect between-group differences. This is an important consideration as just over one-half of unvaccinated children had SARS-CoV-2 spike antibodies indicative of infection and/or vaccination following the peak of the Omicron wave. Additionally, as illness severity may be different among children with SARS-CoV-2 who visit the ED and those who do not, generalizing our findings to the latter population should be performed with caution. However, as illness severity is associated with PCC, children not requiring ED evaluation likely have a lowerPCC prevalence than we report.
Despite these limitations, I think this study still provides some reassurance to young patients and their families. Chronic debilitating health problems related to infection with SARS-CoV-2, while not impossible, do appear to be uncommon in children, particularly infants and toddlers. This shouldn’t be interpreted as a support for avoiding proven means of reducing the risk of acute infection, however. Proper precautions and vaccinations are still important tools in our toolbox.

Long COVID: Alternative medicine sees a business opportunity
With vaccines transforming the risk and consequences of a COVID infection, the health burden of “long COVID” may become a lasting consequence of the pandemic. Alternative medicine senses a business opportunity.
Scott Gavura on July 22, 2021
Link

Overlooked among the fatality statistics and recovery rates from COVID-19 is the appearance of what has been called “long haul COVID” or just “long COVID”, a constellation of disabling, debilitating symptoms. And with the emergence of safe, effective vaccines transforming the risk and consequences of a COVID infection, the health burden of “long COVID” may become a lasting consequence of the pandemic. Regrettably, some see long COVID not as something to study, understand and treat, but as a potentially new group to be marketed to.
Alternative medicine is a recurring topic at this blog, and over the years and through hundreds of posts, contributors have documented that the practices and providers don’t actually make any meaningful contributions to overall health and medicine. The pandemic has highlighted just how little complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) had to offer – there are no CAM treatments or interventions that can effectively prevent or treat a SARS-CoV-2 infection. This may have contributed to COVID-19 denialism among some providers, which unsurprisingly became anti-COVID-vaccine stances as vaccines were developed, approved, and launched. Antivaccine stances should have been expected, given that many CAM practices have deep roots in antivaccine denialism.
But with vaccines demonstrably transforming the course of the pandemic, and expected to provide a pathway to a post-pandemic world, some in the CAM ecosystem appear to be pivoting. And that is not to acknowledge safe and effective COVID-19 vaccines, but claim that CAM can benefit patients that continue to suffer, long after the initial COVID-19 infection has resolved.
A brief overview of long COVID
The acute effects of COVID-19 infections typically last up to 4 weeks. In most cases, symptoms are fully resolved by 12 weeks. As of the time of writing, the evidence base for long COVID is limited, but quickly evolving. A working definition for long COVID would be signs and symptoms that persist or develop after the acute effects of a COVID-19 infection. The UK’s National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) considers long COVID to include symptomatic COVID infections (4-12 weeks) and post-COVID syndrome (12 weeks +).
Currently there is no agreed-upon clinical definition of long COVID, and no established standard of care. This complicates diagnosis and management. Treatment guidelines that have been developed are constantly being revised based on new information and as many health systems gradually shift from providing acute treatment to helping COVID patients fully recover. The World Health Organization has developed a post-COVID case report form to collect information in a standardized way on long COVID.
Many symptoms have been attributed to long COVID. Steven Novella discussed long COVID in a post in April 2021, noting that it seems to predominantly affect the brain, heart, and lungs. Cognitive changes, such as “brain fog”, confusion, and memory losses, are reported more commonly. Exercise ability and tolerance is often impaired, and accompanied by fatigue and breathlessness. Less common physical symptoms attributed to long COVID include persistent inability to smell (anosmia), dry eyes/mouth, joint pain, headache, insomnia, taste disturbances, and gastrointestinal effects. In some cases, people report they are unable to perform their usual activities of daily living, or resume their pre-COVID lifestyle or activities.
Investigative approaches are not standardized owing to the wide range of symptoms that have been reported, but can include blood tests, imaging, exercise tolerance tests, and other investigations that can also rule out other possible causes. Management approaches are similarly personalized, and include the treatment of specific symptoms (as appropriate), self-management tools, and support group and services, depending on the severity of the impairment. Estimates of the prevalence of long COVID vary – one survey suggests that 10% of those that have been infected with SARS-CoV-2 have gone on to develop long COVID. If accurate, this puts the prevalence of long COVID in the millions.
Outpatient recovery units are being established to help patients recover from long COVID. These may be staffed with health professionals from a variety of medical disciplines, like neurology, pulmonary medicine, and rehabilitative medicine who can offer a “one stop” center for assessment and ongoing treatment. Based on the limited information collected to date, recovery time do not seem predictable based on the course of the COVID-19 infection. Even those with mild illnesses that did not require hospitalization may report long COVID symptoms that persist for months.
Long COVID: An ideal target for alternative medicine
Non-specific symptoms, unclear diagnostic criteria, a variable course of illness, and a lack of demonstrably-effective treatments is a perfect recipe for frustration with conventional medicine. It’s also the perfect breeding ground for quackery and other forms of alternative medicine, where therapies rely mainly on placebo effects, and practitioners tend to have absolute certainty about the effectiveness of their treatments. The marketing to those with long COVID has already begun.
The bellwether of quackery, Gwyneth Paltrow, announced in early 2021 that she had been treating her long COVID symptoms of fatigue and “brain fog” with a combination of the keto diet and fasting. She used the revelation to promote a bunch of GOOP products that she feels are helping her, including an “infrared sauna blanket”, vitamin supplements, and (of course) a “detoxifying superpowder”.
The homeopathic community also sees COVID-19 as an opportunity, as noted in a recent editorial:
During its 200 years, homeopathy has more than once shown its efficacy in combating epidemics, from the use of Belladonna in an outbreak of scarlet fever in 1799 by its founder Samuel Hahnemann to modern times. There is documented homeopathic control of a leptospirosis epidemic in Cuba in 2007 to 2008, Chikungunya fever in India, and prevention of dengue fever in some areas of Brazil, to mention a few. Successful homeopathic interventions as both treatment and prophylaxis in other epidemics are documented in the homeopathy medical literature.
This historical perspective raises several urgent contemporary questions. Why is homeopathy not more widely known and respected? Why is no official agency urging homeopathy societies around the world to intervene, soliciting their help in combating COVID-19? Why are these organizations recording the growing death toll with apparent equanimity, while a potentially effective, inexpensive, and virtually adverse-effect-free treatment is available?
It is worth noting briefly why homeopathy is not a respected practice, and no official agencies are seeking input from homeopaths. There is zero evidence that homeopathy can treat any medical condition, infectious or otherwise. The treatments are literally sugar pills, making homeopathy the air guitar of alternative medicine.
Another area where we are already seeing confident claims are the practitioners of “integrative medicine” and its sub-specialty, “functional medicine”. IM and FM are similar in that that they combine reasonable science-based advice (adequate sleep, a healthy diet, etc.) and integrate unproven therapy and quackery like acupuncture, homeopathy, chiropractic, and naturopathy. FM goes further and offers “personalized” prescriptions and advice based on reams of laboratory tests. Importantly, FM practitioners can essentially justify any therapy and any treatment based on what practitioners describe as “biochemical individuality”. Whether it’s IM or FM, there is no clear standard of care, and no systematic collection and use of evidence. As two practitioners noted in an article on long COVID, published in the American Journal of Medicine,
Integrative medicine offers an approach to treating patients even before clinical trials are available, using established principles. It looks for the underlying mechanisms of a disease process, such as inflammation, and uses lifestyle modifications to address these (including nutrition, stress management, and reduced environmental exposures). Integrative medicine provides strategies to relieve symptoms such as fatigue and depression by extrapolating from treatment of these conditions due to causes other than COVID-19. It has an important role to play in this pandemic and can help a multitude of people restore their health and well-being.
Finally, with travel re-opening around the world, we are witnessing the appearance of long-COVID wellness resorts. From Thailand to Spain to Austria to Germany, spas and resorts are pivoting their wellness offerings to target long COVID patients with foot baths, reflexology, IV drips, bowel cleansing, fasting, and if you’re daring, a paste of turmeric, galangal and kaffir lime that is placed on your chest and ignited.
Conclusion: Long-COVID patients need real science, not quackery
To support patients with long COVID, we urgently need more research and more support for patients. If long COVID debilitates people to the extent that they cannot effectively work, this creates an enormous burden to families, health systems, and governments. The NIH has launched an initiative to study long COVID. The UK’s National Health Service has developed specific resources for long COVID sufferers as well. We need more of this, quickly. Ultimately, our understanding and treatment of long COVID will progress only with rigorous study, collaboration among professionals, and the application of science-based treatments.

VACCINE

Pfizer’s COVID Vaccine
Here is everything you need to know about the recently announced COVID vaccine from Pfizer and BioNTech.
Steven Novella on November 11, 2020
Link

Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic there has been discussion of the prospects of a vaccine targeting the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes the illness. Research quickly got underway in numerous pharmaceutical companies around the world, some building on earlier research involving SARS-CoV-1. By the late Spring and early Summer the experts were saying that, if all goes well, we might expect approval for an effective vaccine by 2021. In August I wrote here, “I am hopeful that one of the vaccines in development will legitimately cross the finish line by the end of the year”.
We are not quite there yet, but if the preliminary evidence announced recently by Pfizer and BioNTech holds up, then we could get an emergency use authorization (EUA) from the FDA sometime in December. So what is the status of this vaccine?
This is exciting news for a reason that is likely to get overshadowed by its application to the pandemic – this is an mRNA vaccine. If it gets approved it would be the first mRNA vaccine in use. The technology first appeared in the literature in 1990, so this has been in development for 30 years. There were many hurdles to overcome, but they eventually were solved.
Vaccines work by introducing material into the body that will provoke a specific adaptive immune response. This could be an attenuated virus, a killed virus, or a viral protein, for example. An mRNA vaccine works by introducing messenger RNA, the genetic material that is used to make (translate) proteins. The technology was developed so that the introduced mRNA is taken up by cells and used to make viral proteins, which then provoke the desired immune response. Why not just inject the proteins themselves? You can, but mRNA has several advantages, including that it can be mass-produced more quickly and cheaply than a protein-based vaccine. If this vaccine works and gets approval it may usher in a new era of vaccine production that could have benefit far beyond the current pandemic.
Regarding the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine specifically, we only have early results and these have not yet been peer reviewed, so we are dependent on what the companies are telling us. The phase 3 trial involves almost 44,000 volunteers so far, half of which were given the vaccine and the other half a placebo (a saline injection without any active ingredient). Each group receives two doses about 28 days apart. Then the researchers just wait and see how many people in each group contract COVID. They can also track the severity of the illness and the outcomes in those who do get sick, and of course they will track any potential side effects from the vaccine itself. The companies now report that 94 of the study participants have contracted COVID-19, with 90% fewer cases in the vaccine group compared to the control group.
A 90% efficacy would be great, if this holds up when the final data is analyzed and reviewed. Expectations were that the FDA would consider approving a vaccine if it had at least 50% efficacy, so this is high above that low bar. The fact that two doses are required is unfortunate, because it means two doses have to be manufactured and distributed for each person protected, and in the real world many people don’t show up for the second dose. But this is not a deal-killer, just less than optimal. Early reports indicate that the side effects are a little worse than the flu vaccine, mostly irritation at the injection site and fevers.
In negotiations with the FDA it was decided that they would consider EUA only after 50% of all study participants have been followed for a minimum of 2 months, which will happen by the end of November. This is to ensure that enough people have been followed for long enough to monitor for serious side effects. Of course, this will not capture all the potential side effects that can emerge when the vaccine is given to millions or even billions of people, but it is a reasonable process to balance risk vs benefit. Then after release, if that happens, there will be continued monitoring as is standard procedure.
Pfizer says it will be able to produce 50 million doses by the end of 2020 (enough for 25 million people) and another 1.3 billion doses in 2021. If the FDA grants an EUA after looking at the data, then by the end of the year the vaccine can start distribution to high risk individuals and those most likely to catch and spread the virus, such as front-line workers. From there the vaccine can be released to the general population. The UK-based Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) has issued the following guidelines on who gets it first:
    • Older adults in a care home and care home workers
    • All those aged 80 and over and health and social care workers, though they may move up the list
    • Anyone 75 and over
    • People aged 70 and over
    • All those aged 65 and over
    • High-risk adults under 65
    • Moderate-risk adults under 65
    • All those aged 60 and over
    • All those 55 and over
    • All those aged 50 and over
    • The rest of the population, with priority yet to be determined.
Pfizer is an American company but with an international footprint, and BioNTech is a German company. Which countries get the vaccine first will largely depend on regulatory approval. It is likely the FDA will be the first to grant an EUA, but the companies will also seek approval from the European Medicines Agency (EMA) and the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) in the UK. Given all this it is hard to say exactly how the vaccine will be distributed internationally, but it is likely that many if not most Americans and Europeans could be vaccinated by the end of 2021. And of course there are many other vaccines in the works around the world and it is likely that several will become available over the next year.
All told, this is very good news. An effective vaccine will definitely have a positive impact on the pandemic, and will likely be a game-changer. Hopefully the preliminary data will hold up, and no serious side effects will emerge. It should also not be missed that this was the fastest that a vaccine has been developed and (hopefully) soon to be approved in history, and that this vaccine is the first of a new vaccine technology that also promises to be a significant advance.

Moderna’s COVID Vaccine
Preliminary results have been announced for a second mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine, with even better results.
Steven Novella on November 18, 2020
Link

One week ago I discussed the announcement of preliminary results for a COVID-19 vaccine announced by Pfizer and BioNTech. Since then Moderna, a biotechnology company based in Cambridge, MA, also announced preliminary results from their phase 3 vaccine trial – showing almost 95% effectiveness in preventing the disease. This is great news. Let’s go over the company, the vaccine, and the data.
Moderna was founded in 2010 as a biotechnology company dedicated to mRNA (messenger RNA) technology. So far they have not marketed a single therapeutic or vaccine, so if they get approval for their mRNA COVID vaccine that will be their first. They developed the vaccine with a grant from the US government’s Warp Speed initiative (unlike Pfizer who had the resources to fund their own research). The development of each of these vaccines cost over two billion dollars.
Like the Pfizer vaccine, the Moderna vaccine (called mRNA-1273) is also based on mRNA technology. The mRNA is a single strand of genetic material that is copied from the DNA of a gene in the nucleus. It then travels outside the nucleus to the cytoplasm where it connects to the ribosome, which reads the genetic instructions from the mRNA in order to assemble the protein for which it codes. The concept behind an mRNA vaccine is that mRNA that codes for a viral protein is injected with carriers to get it into cells. The cells then make viral proteins from the mRNA, and those proteins provoke an immune response that will target the virus.
There are currently 17 mRNA SARS-CoV-2 vaccines in development, included the two discussed here. The advantages of mRNA vaccines are that they are considered safer than DNA vaccines, they can be targeted more specifically than whole virus vaccines, and they are safer than attenuated virus vaccines because there is no risk of infection. They can also be manufactured more quickly than other vaccine types because we have the technology to rapidly replicate mRNA. If approved, these will be the first mRNA vaccines approved by the FDA.
The company previously reported results of their Phase 1 trial, showing that the vaccine produced antibodies in healthy controls, and these antibodies are capable of neutralizing the virus. The Phase 2 trial confirmed dosing and safety. The Phase 3 trial, which is the one that tests efficacy, enrolled over 30,000 healthy volunteers, half receiving two doses of the vaccine and half getting placebo. They then followed the groups until 95 total subjects contracted COVID-19. The trial reached this endpoint more quickly than projected, simply because of the Fall surge in COVID-19 cases. They now report their preliminary results.
The vaccine group had 94.5% fewer cases of COVID-19 than the placebo group. This is slightly better than the Pfizer vaccine which reported 90% efficacy. Both results are fantastic – Fauci and other experts wanted at least 50% efficacy and were hoping for something in the range of 75%, so this exceeds even optimistic expectations. Further, the placebo group on the Moderna trial had 11 cases of severe COVID, while the vaccine group had zero. This could just be a manifestation of the fact that there were fewer cases overall in the vaccine group, but the hope is it means that even if those who are vaccinated still get the disease, it will not be severe. This, of course, will further save lives and reduce strain on hospital resources.
Both vaccines require two doses 28 days apart. This is not optimal for two reasons – it means you have to produce, distribute, and administer two doses for each person protected. This will slow down the rate of vaccinating the public. Further, generally there is lower full compliance with multi-dose vaccines. Some people will simply not show up for their second dose. A single dose, based on the Phase 1 data, still produces some antibody protection, but not the level of protection seen in the Phase 3 trial.
There is also one significant advantage to the Moderna vaccine over the Pfizer vaccine. The Pfizer vaccine needs to be stored at -70° Celsius. This is extremely cold – colder than standard and even most specialized freezers. But this is not a dealbreaker and not as bad as it may sound. The same was true of the Ebola vaccine which had to be distributed in Africa. Fortunately, dry ice will do the trick. Pfizer will be able, they say, to distribute the vaccine in dry ice containers that are good for three weeks. Longer than that will require special freezers. This is a challenge for the supply chain, but doable. Once unfrozen the vaccine will last for several days in a refrigerator, while it is being distributed. This means that a facility will have to distribute all the vaccine it is sent within a few days, and if they don’t use it in that time frame the vaccine doses are wasted.
The Moderna vaccine can be stored at -20° Celsius, which is standard freezer temperature. This will make distribution and on-site storage much easier. Also, the vaccine is good for six months at -20°C, and is good for 30 days at refrigerator temperature. This will make things much easier for the clinics and hospital distributing the vaccine. Of course, these figures are extrapolated from the data we have. In order to know for sure that the vaccine is good after 6 months frozen, you would have to freeze it for six months then test it. There obviously has not been enough time for this to happen.
None of this means that the Moderna vaccine will be used instead of the Pfizer vaccine – the two are likely to be used in a complementary fashion. First, we need to manufacture as much vaccine as quickly as possible. Now we have double (roughly) the manufacturing capability. Pfizer predicts 1.2 billion doses by the end of 2021, and Modern predicts they can make an additional 1 billion doses of their vaccine. This will get vaccine to more people quicker.
The different temperature requirements also can be used in a complementary fashion. The Pfizer vaccine can preferentially go to large population centers where the doses are likely to be used up quickly. The Moderna vaccine is better suited to rural or low population density areas where it may need to be stored for longer before use.
Both vaccines also have a good safety profile so far. They have the usual vaccine side effects such as irritation at the vaccine site, fatigue, fever, and aches. So far no serious adverse events that would doom the vaccine. The FDA wants at least two months of safety follow up for at least half of the subjects enrolled in each trial, and this will happen by the end of November. Then the FDA will review the data and consider granting an emergency use authorization (EUA). Final approval will come later after the trials are complete. This means the companies will be able to start manufacturing and distributing millions of doses by the end of the year. Significant vaccination of the general population will likely not happen until the Spring of 2021, with life returning to normal by the Winter of 2021 if all goes well.

Possible Universal Coronavirus Vaccine
New research potentially points the way to a universal coronavirus vaccine and other applications.
Steven Novella on July 6, 2022
Link

If you look at the big picture, humanity seems to be losing its struggle with the betacoronaviruses (the subset of coronaviruses that infect humans). Over the last 20 years there have been three incursions of these viruses into the human population – SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and SARS-CoV-2. The latest spillover event resulted in a massive pandemic that dramatically affected the whole world. SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, is still ongoing, evolving new variants to evade our immunity from prior infections and vaccines. As we will see below, however, we may have a new weapon in this war.
The latest variants, BA.4 and BA.5, are subvariants of Omicron, and appear to be spreading. It is now in fashion to observe that while we may be done with this pandemic, it’s not done with us. The vaccines have provided an effective weapon against COVID, but existing vaccines produce immunity that wanes after six months and are less effective against the newer variants. Many people have already received their second booster, and it won’t be long before we need a third.
In addition to maintaining vigilance against spreading the virus, one approach to keep the pandemic at least manageable is to update the vaccines, targeting them against the newer variants. I think most people have already accepted the fact that SARS-CoV-2 is here to stay, like influenza, and we will all have to get our annual COVID vaccines. Hopefully they will be annual; so far it appears we need to get boosted every six months. We’re all just hoping there is a cumulative immunity, and tracking the newer variants will produce longer-lasting immunity.
There is another theoretical approach, however – developing a universal betacoronavirus vaccine. If we can do this, such a vaccine would not only protect against current and future variants of COVID, it would protect against the next potential spillover event (SARS-CoV-3, or perhaps MERS-CoV-2). But universal vaccines have proven technologically tricky to develop. We have been researching for years, for example, a universal flu vaccine, but have yet to approve one. The problem is that viruses are clever. They hide their conserved bits, the important structures that all variants have in common, and cover them with highly variables proteins that constantly mutate and create new variants. But they can’t do this perfectly because often those conserved proteins are functional – they need, for example, to bind to receptors on human cells in order to invade and do their thing.
The coronavirus family derives its name from the crown of spike proteins that are the business end of the virus. These spike proteins are what allow the coronaviruses to invade cells, and existing vaccines target one or more spike proteins. But these spike proteins can also mutate, causing new variants that not only evade existing immunity (whether from prior infection or vaccines) but can alter how infectious and deadly the viruses are.
A newly published study presents a potential new technology that might result in a universal betacoronavirus vaccine – not just effective against all variants of SARS-CoV-2, but perhaps against all related viruses. Pamela Bjorkman from Caltech and her team created a nanoparticle they refer to as a cage protein. The cage is a platform on which other proteins can be attached, including spike proteins from coronaviruses. They created two versions of the nanoparticle. The first contains receptor binding domains (RBDs) from the spike proteins of SARS-CoV-2. This is the homotypic particle, because all the proteins are from the same virus.
They also made what they are calling mosaic-8, which contains 60 RBD particles from 8 different betacoronaviruses. They then injected mice with either a naked cage protein as a control, a vaccine made from the homotypic nanoparticle, or another from the mosaic-8. The mosaic-8 specifically did not contain any RBDs from SARS-CoV. After first determining that the vaccines produced antibodies, they then challenged the mice with infection from SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2. The mice injected with the naked cage protein all died. Those injected with the homotypic vaccine were protected against SARS-CoV-2 but not against SARS-CoV, and those injected with the mosaic-8 vaccine were protected against both viruses.
It is important to emphasize that the mosaic-8 vaccine protected against SARS-CoV even though it did not contain any RBDs specific to that species of virus. Armed with that preliminary data, they then tested the vaccines in non-human primates, with the same results. They are now planning for a phase-I study in humans.
What the researchers hope this means is that the mosaic-8 approach, by targeting enough RBDs from a variety of betacoronaviruses, will target enough important sections of the spike proteins that they will have affinity for any betacoronavirus that can infect humans, regardless of species or variant. Again, viruses can mutate and change their proteins, but they cannot change them too much or they will lose their ability to infect human cells and propagate. It’s likely that different strains may shuffle around different variants of the spike proteins, but there are some key RBDs that any infectious strain must have. By targeting enough of the RBDs the viruses simply have no where to hide.
Translation to humans from animal studies is not guaranteed, so we have to wait until we see the results of human trials to know how well this approach will work. It seems theoretically sound, and the early data is encouraging. Perhaps we will need to develop future versions that target more than 8 RBDs. We may need a mosaic-10 or mosaic-12. Or perhaps eight is enough (sorry, couldn’t resist).
This platform may have applications beyond coronaviruses. If this all works well it may spawn a new vaccine technology, just like the mRNA vaccines did, that give us a powerful tool against current and future pandemics. Vaccines that target multiple proteins, creating antibodies with cross reactivity, produce a much more effective immune response, and may get us to the ultimate goal of universal coverage. This approach might get us to that universal flu vaccine we have been seeking, or at least a giant step closer. HIV is another virus that likes to hide by spawning variants.
It is also clear that we are now living in a world where epidemics and pandemics, especially from zoonotic viruses that spill over from animal reservoirs, are becoming increasingly common. The COVID-19 pandemic is not an anomaly or a once-in-a-century event. It is a wake up call. Fortunately we have the infrastructure of scientific research to combat these pandemics. We may, however, lack the political and social infrastructure to adequately deal with them, despite having the technology.

Nasal Spray Vaccine for SARS-CoV-2
A nasal spray boost may enhance the effectiveness of vaccine defense against COVID.
Steven Novella on February 9, 2022
Link

We are at the beginning of the third year of the COVID-19 pandemic, and while we might nurse some optimism that we are seeing the light at the end of the tunnel, the fact it we still don’t know how long this pandemic will last. Also, experts have essentially abandoned the notion of eradicating the virus, and it now seems extremely likely that COVID will simply be another endemic infection that we will have to deal with, like the flu. Further still, while masking and social distancing are effective, they have their downsides and are not optimal as indefinite strategies to minimize infections.
You know where this is heading – vaccines are by far the best tool we have to beat this pandemic into submission. This, of course, is why vaccine misinformation and vaccine hesitancy are so frustrating. Those who refuse to get vaccinated hurt themselves, hurt everyone else, and are doing it for reasons that are demonstrably false. Aggressive public education and countering misinformation is therefore a critical component to our pandemic intervention strategy.
Meanwhile, it is also helpful to continue to improve vaccine technology, and writing about it can help spread confidence in the vaccines. I wrote recently about the fact that those who had a COVID infection and also get boosted have “super immunity” with ten times the antibody titers and either one alone. Vaccine producers, like Pfizer, are also updating their vaccines to better cover emerging variants. And now researchers are also developing a potential nasal spray COVID vaccine.
The vaccine is remarkably simple, it is just the spike protein of the SARS-CoV-2 virus. That’s it, no adjuvants or other ingredients. The study, which is in preprint, was in mice, in which they compared two groups. One group received only one dose of Comirnaty (the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 mRNA vaccine). The second group received the same one dose of Comirnaty, and then 14 days later received a nasal spray of the spike protein. Both groups were then exposed to SARS-CoV-2. In the first group, without the nasal spray, 80% of the exposed mice died. In the second group, with the nasal spray, none of the exposed mice died. That’s a pretty dramatic result.
The concept of the nasal spray booster is what the researchers are calling “Prime and Spike”. The idea is that you first prime the immune system with a parenteral vaccine. Then you expose that primed immune system to the spike protein in the respiratory tract through the nasal spray. This causes the memory B cells produced by the initial vaccine dose to produce a robust antibody response to the spike protein. The researchers did not test the nasal spray by itself, but that was not the idea of the treatment in any case.
Because COVID is a respiratory illness, in most people the virus enters their system through breathing, the nose, mouth, and lungs. The mucosa of our respiratory tract, which has its own antibodies, is the first line of defense against this route of entry into the body. The nasal spray, therefore, boosts this first line of defense, so that the virus never has a chance to gain entry or establish a foothold.
Obviously this approach needs to be studied in people. Given our experience with the mRNA vaccines, however, there is very good reason to think this nasal spray approach will be extremely safe. The results of this preliminary study are encouraging and suggest the “Prime and Spike” approach may be an effective way to further boost the effectiveness of the existing vaccines. We also need to see if the nasal boost will extend the duration of vaccine protection. A nasal spray may also have fewer side effects, and may garner less hesitancy than an injection. It would be interesting to see how effective the spray is on its own, as it may become a less-than-optimal but better-than-nothing alternative to the jabs.
Following up a vaccine routine with a nasal spray may seem tedious, but it is a small price to pay for the resulting immunity. This is now the world we are living in, given the human population, the density of our cities, our proximity with animal reservoirs of infectious agents, and our global interconnectivity. Unless we want to significantly change one or more of those factors, we will be dealing with frequent pandemics for the foreseeable future. In the last few decades we have had pandemics of HIV, SARS, MERS, and Swine Flu. COVID is only the latest. We have also had the largest outbreaks of serious illness like Ebola. We dodged a bullet with that one – if it had spread into a major city, we could have had another pandemic on our hands. There is one thing for certain, the next pandemic is coming.
Vaccines are our best defense against infectious disease, and we should be grateful for advancing vaccine technology. We simply have to accept that they are going to be an important part of our future. The good news is – they work, and are generally safe. They have the best benefit-to-risk ratio and cost-effectiveness of any medical intervention we have developed.
        ◦ It’s too early to say if the spike protein nasal spray will become part of the COVID vaccine routine, but it may. In addition to Pfizer, Moderna also announced it is about to start trials of an Omicron version of their vaccine. They are also working on a combined influenza-SARS-CoV-2 booster vaccine. It is very likely that we will need COVID boosters indefinitely in the future to maintain and update our immunity, but perhaps we can still just get the annual “flu” vaccine, which will include the latest variants of SARS-CoV-2. Perhaps then we have to pick up the nasal spray from the pharmacy and take that two weeks later. We have to look at this as routine health maintenance, like getting a checkup annually or going to the dentist every six months.

Vaccine safety monitoring in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic
Last year, the Trump administration essentially disbanded the National Vaccine Program Office, folding it into an office focused on infectious diseases. Then the COVID-19 pandemic hit. What does this mean for monitoring the safety of the soon-to-be-approved COVID-19 vaccines?
David Gorski on October 26, 2020
Link

Vaccine safety has long been a major topic on this blog for a number of reasons, not the least of which is to counter the longstanding efforts of the antivaccine movement to cast doubt on vaccine safety. Many health problems have been falsely linked vaccines such as MMR (and, previously, the thimerosal preservative that used to be in several childhood vaccines) and autism, or demonstrably incorrect claims that vaccines predispose babies to sudden infant death syndrome, or autoimmune disease, or infertility and premature ovarian failure in females, or obesity, and a whole host of other conditions, diseases, and problems up to and including cancer and death. It doesn’t matter that vaccines are effective and among the safest of medical interventions. (They have to be, given that they are administered to mass populations of children and adults without disease in order to prevent disease.) Indeed, the benefits of some vaccines go beyond even the diseases that they prevent, diseases that are more dangerous than most people appreciate, such as in the case of the measles vaccine. Most people are unaware of the multiple layers of systems monitoring vaccine safety and the National Vaccine Program Office (NVPO), the closing or “reorganization” of which has led me to great concern for the monitoring of COVID-19 vaccine safety.
Unfortunately, the success of the antivaccine movement in spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines on social media before social media companies started to crack down (and even after) has led to enough vaccine hesitancy that in a number of areas vaccine uptake has fallen to levels that endanger community immunity (formerly—and, sadly, still sometimes—referred to as herd immunity). Remember last year, when measles outbreaks due to decreasing MMR vaccination rates in various parts of the countries were a major concern, a problem that first burst into the US public consciousness after the Disneyland measles outbreak nearly six years ago? Soon after the pandemic hit, antivaxxers allied themselves with COVID-19 deniers, antimask and anti-lockdown protesters, and all manner of cranks and conspiracy theorists who have flourished during the pandemic and, for example, blamed the flu vaccine for increased susceptibility to COVID-19. This alliance is tight, up to and including the utterly bonkers conspiracy theory QAnon, which believes that President Donald Trump is battling a “deep state” group of Satanic pedophiles who harvest the blood of children for adrenochrome. (Don’t ask.) So it should come as no surprise that, as early as May (and earlier, ancient history in the timeline of the pandemic), antivaxxers started a preemptive disinformation war to cast doubt on any COVID-19 vaccines that will emerge from an unprecedented research effort. The Trump administration didn’t help, either. By naming its COVID-19 vaccine program “Operation Warp Speed,” it not only stoked doubt about whether any new vaccine would be adequately tested for safety, it made even staunch pro-vaccine advocates like me uncomfortable, as the Trump administration politicized the FDA and CDC to the point where I asked if we could trust them any more and, as Jann Bellamy wrote last week, the Government Accountability Office is investigating.
So I was not pleased when I read what happened in terms of vaccine safety monitoring last year.
Trump gutted the National Vaccine Program Office
It was with dismay that I read a story in The New York Times on Friday by Carl Zimmer reporting that last year the Trump Administration shut down a key office responsible for coordinating government programs monitoring vaccine safety and folded it into an office focused on infectious diseases. Noting that the first coronavirus vaccines will likely be approved next year, if not even earlier, and rolled out to millions of people in the US, Zimmer observes:
As the first coronavirus vaccines arrive in the coming year, government researchers will face a monumental challenge: monitoring the health of hundreds of millions of Americans to ensure the vaccines don’t cause harm.
Purely by chance, thousands of vaccinated people will have heart attacks, strokes and other illnesses shortly after the injections. Sorting out whether the vaccines had anything to do with their ailments will be a thorny problem, requiring a vast, coordinated effort by state and federal agencies, hospitals, drug makers and insurers to discern patterns in a flood of data. Findings will need to be clearly communicated to a distrustful public swamped with disinformation.
This has, of course, always been the most difficult issue when it comes to monitoring vaccine safety. People are pattern-seeking animals. We’re extremely good at noticing patterns and creating meaning or inferring causation from those patterns, even if the meanings or causations inferred are completely false. One commonly used example to illustrate this point is that if you ate some wild berries and then sickened, it would likely be beneficial to see the link between eating berries and illness, and then to avoid those berries in the future, even if the berries were not, in fact, the cause of the illness. Another commonly used example is early humans on the savannah. Rustling of the grass might indicate that a predator is near and be an indication to flee or get ready to fight, or it might be just the wind. Rapidly concluding that the rustle in the grass is a dangerous predator when it is actually just the wind doesn’t cost much, but believing that a dangerous predator is just the wind could easily mean that the early human ends up in the belly of a lion. The bottom line is that there likely was selective pressure in evolution against dismissing patterns (or for seeing them), whether they mean what we think they mean or not.
This pattern-seeking behavior is not well-suited to a task like evaluating drug safety. Many of us will conclude, after taking a drug or receiving a vaccine, that anything bad that happens soon afterward was likely caused by the drug or the vaccine, even when it is far more likely that it was random chance (i.e., coincidence), and nothing more. Such is the case with vaccines and autism. The ages during which children receive a lot of vaccines just happens to correspond to the ages where parents most frequently first start noticing the signs of autism spectrum disorders, as can be shown by an estimate of how many cases of autism we would expect to see diagnosed within one week or even 30 days of receiving vaccines. The numbers are much larger than most people would guess. Basically, our brains appear to be hard-wired to find patterns, and we have a hard time accepting that coincidence is very common. That’s why we need data and epidemiology to separate coincidence from actual correlation above what we would expect by random chance alone. It’s also why vaccine safety monitoring systems are so important.
Of course, I began expressing concerns about the likely problems President Trump would cause for science, especially drug approval and safety, beginning even before he took office and then during the first 100 days, such as his including two ultra-libertarians who thought that the FDA should only require evidence of safety and not efficacy before approving a drug, one of whom thought that voluntary reporting systems and the free market alone would be enough to assure the safety of drugs and devices, like a “Yelp” or “Uber” for pharmaceuticals, in his short list for candidates for FDA Commissioner. The third was a bona fide pharma shill, Scott Gottlieb. He was the “least bad” of the three and ultimately became FDA Commissioner. Surprisingly, he was generally not too bad, but unfortunately he only lasted a couple of years.
In any event, the Trump administration is focused on getting COVID-19 vaccines to market, but seems a lot less concerned about what comes next, such as how to distribute the vaccines rapidly and equitably, and how to monitor their longer term safety:
The next job will be to monitor the safety of vaccines once they’re in widespread use. But the administration last year quietly disbanded the office with the expertise for exactly this job, merging it into an office focused on infectious diseases. Its elimination has left that long-term safety effort for coronavirus vaccines fragmented among federal agencies, with no central leadership, experts say.
“We’re behind the eight ball,” said Daniel Salmon, who served as the director of vaccine safety in that office from 2007 to 2012, overseeing coordination during the H1N1 flu pandemic in 2009. “We don’t even know who’s in charge.”
An H.H.S. spokesperson said that the vaccine office was not shuttered. “The office was not ‘closed,’ but was merged with the Office of Infectious Disease and HIV/AIDS Policy and was strengthened,” the spokesperson said in a statement. “All the functions continue in this new organizational structure.”
In a brief statement, a different spokesperson said that Operation Warp Speed was working closely with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention “to synchronize the IT systems” involved in monitoring vaccine safety data.
I’ll get into those IT systems in a minute, as I’ve written about them on multiple occasions. First, however, I note that the Office of Infectious Disease and HIV/AIDS Policy (OIDP) is an office in the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) itself, not the CDC or FDA. A quick search of the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org reveals that the crawl of the web page listing the National Vaccine Program Office (NVPO) as part of OIDP is dated June 11, 2019, implying that the reorganization occurred sometime fairly soon before that. Searching for the NVPO further back on the Wayback Machine revealed web pages (i.e., this version from 2004) with much more robust links. Apparently the NVPO does have a Twitter feed, and it’s retweeting denials by Admiral Brett Giroir, Assistant Secretary for Health:
Irresponsible "journalism" https://t.co/SKCv4iHBcI. The office is NOT closed, but merged with the Infectious Disease Office & strengthened. All functions continue. #NVAC is ACTIVELY meeting, involved, regularly charged, and engaged in #COVID19 vaccine efforts including safety.
— ADM Rachel Levine (@HHS_ASH) October 23, 2020
But is this true? Given the record of this administration compared to Carl Zimmer’s record as a journalist, I’d be far more inclined to believe Zimmer than Adm. Giroir, to be honest. But first, let’s look at the vaccine safety monitoring systems in place as they were pre-pandemic.
Beyond VAERS…
Antivaxxers love to portray the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) as the be-all and end-all of the databases monitoring vaccine safety. The reason is that VAERS is unique among US vaccine safety reporting systems in that it is a passive surveillance system. It relies on people to submit reports of adverse reactions to vaccines; it doesn’t actively look for them, as active surveillance systems do. Moreover, anyone can submit a report to VAERS, and they do, including parents of autistic children seeking compensation for their children’s autism as being due to “vaccine injury”. Indeed, I long ago discussed how lawyers game VAERS for their litigation, reporting lots of cases of autism as supposedly an “adverse reaction” to vaccines. It’s one reason why those of us who’ve been following the antivaccine movement like to refer to the bad “scientific studies” published by antivaccine physicians and scientists that use VAERS as their data source as “dumpster diving“, for example, this one claiming to find a link between the H1N1 vaccine and miscarriages or one of the earliest examples, Mark and David Geier’s epically bad study trying to link thimerosal-containing vaccines to autism. Meanwhile, in 2006 Jim Laidler infamously reported to VAERS that the flu vaccine had turned him into The Incredible Hulk, and VAERS accepted the report. True, someone did contact him to question it. If Laidler hadn’t been honest, he could have insisted that the report remain, and it would have.
Why would anyone set up a system like VAERS, which is co-managed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)? First, you must understand that VAERS isn’t intended to give an accurate estimate of the frequency of various adverse events after vaccination. Rather, it was always intended to serve as an early warning system, a “canary in the coalmine”, so to speak. Consequently, even though antivaxxers like to harp on how passive surveillance systems generally capture only a small fraction of adverse reactions, one thing VAERS does do is capture severe reactions. Practically no one is going to report an adverse reaction like a sore arm or transient fever to VAERS, but you know damned well they’ll report more serious ones, such as a seizure. The problem is that the natural human tendency to seek patterns, coupled with the way antivaccine lawyers game VAERS by having their clients report all sorts of spurious “adverse events” to the database after vaccination, means that VAERS is a very noisy, distorted, and unreliable database. Still, it has its place if you understand its intended purpose. That purpose, contrary to what antivaxxers would have you believe, is not as the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety surveillance. It is primarily a hypothesis-generating, not hypothesis-testing, system when it comes to questions related to vaccine safety. To test the correlations found in VAERS requires different systems, systems such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD).
Antivaxxers sometimes mention VSD, but often labor under the delusion that it is not an automatic surveillance system. It is:
The Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) is a collaborative project between CDC’s Immunization Safety Office and eight health care organizations. The VSD started in 1990 and continues today in order to monitor safety of vaccines and conduct studies about rare and serious adverse events following immunization.
The VSD uses electronic health data from each participating site. This includes information on vaccines: the kind of vaccine given to each patient, date of vaccination, and other vaccinations given on the same day. The VSD also uses information on medical illnesses that have been diagnosed at doctors’ offices, urgent care visits, emergency department visits, and hospital stays. The VSD conducts vaccine safety studies based on questions or concerns raised from the medical literature and reports to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). When there are new vaccines that have been recommended for use in the United States or if there are changes in how a vaccine is recommended, the VSD will monitor the safety of these vaccines.
So VSD is run by the CDC, meaning that it’s not part of this reorganization or shuttering or folding of NVPO into OIDP. Its strengths include being an active surveillance system that contains very granular data, given its tight affiliation with Kaiser Permanente in California, its Rapid Cycle Analysis (RCA), which allows it to identify adverse events following vaccination in near real time, and its data sharing and collaboration with other scientists outside of the CDC and the involved health care organizations. As an aside, it was an attempt to merge datasets from the VSD in a manner that would compromise the privacy of patients whose data were in the datasets that got antivaxxers Mark and David Geier into trouble so long ago.
Then, there are two active surveillance systems that cover vaccines. First, there is the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment (CISA) project, in which the CDC partners with several large academic medical centers and Kaiser Permanente Northern California to study vaccine safety:
CISA addresses vaccine safety issues, conducts high quality clinical research, and assesses complex clinical adverse events following vaccination. CISA facilitates CDC’s collaboration with vaccine safety experts at leading academic medical centers and strengthens national capacity for vaccine safety monitoring. The CISA Project provides consultation to US clinicians who have vaccine safety questions about a specific patient residing in the US. In addition, CISA provides consultation to US healthcare providers and public health partners on vaccine safety issues, and reviews clinical adverse events following immunization (AEFI) involving the US-licensed vaccines.
Second, there is FDA’s Post-licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring System (PRISM):
The word “prism” might make you think of a triangular piece of glass that separates white light into a rainbow of colors.
But at FDA, it means a powerful, computer-based system that separates critical bits of information from vast streams of healthcare data in order to investigate adverse events and determine if there is a connection to a specific vaccine. And while the FDA prism–called Post-licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring System (PRISM)—might not have such a colorful name, it’s a bright light in the agency’s continual efforts to identify adverse effects in a timely manner.
PRISM is a cooperative effort between FDA’s Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research and its partners in the health care and medical insurance communities. It analyzes health insurance claims data from four national healthcare plans: Aetna, HealthCore (Wellpoint), Humana, and OptumInsight (United Healthcare).
And:
PRISM is one component of FDA’s Sentinel Initiative, which monitors the safety of a variety of FDA-regulated medical products by examining information in electronic healthcare databases.
Sentinel performs what is called “active” surveillance, as opposed to “passive” surveillance. Passive FDA surveillance systems depend on industry, consumers, patients, and healthcare professionals to recognize and report suspected adverse events to an FDA web site, such as the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). This means that FDA might not become aware of potential problems related to a licensed product for months.
Unlike passive surveillance, Sentinel’s active surveillance lets FDA initiate its own studies using existing electronic healthcare data in a timely manner. Sentinel also lets FDA evaluate safety issues in targeted groups, such as children, or to evaluate specific conditions (e.g., heart attacks) that are not usually reported as possible adverse events of medical products through passive reporting systems.
In summary, VSD uses real medical records, while PRISM and CISA are active surveillance systems. Contrary to what antivaxxers claim, there are at least four systems to monitor vaccine safety, two of which are active surveillance systems. Unfortunately, PRISM is no longer being used to its potential, as Zimmer reports.
What does the transfer of NVPO to OIDP mean?
Reading Zimmer’s article profoundly depressed me, because it just demonstrated to me yet again how little this administration cares for science. In particular, Zimmer mentioned the effective use of PRISM as a potential casualty of the transfer of NVPO to OIDP. First, Zimmer describes how PRISM came about:
In 1990, the C.D.C. set up a new way to track vaccines that didn’t depend on people coming forward. The agency worked with health care organizations to get updates on people’s medical conditions. That system now covers 12 million people. Researchers can use it to look for clusters of symptoms that arise in people who get the same vaccine.
When the H1N1 flu hit in 2009, Dr. Salmon recognized that these methods didn’t track enough people to quickly pick up rare symptoms. He reached out to researchers at Harvard to build a new system, which came to be known as PRISM. Ten states supplied vaccination records, and five health insurance companies shared anonymous information about 38 million members. PRISM then connected the two databases to track insurance claims in the wake of vaccination. “That really gave us a ton of data,” Dr. Salmon said.
The researchers could come up with a background rate of a host of medical conditions. If the H1N1 vaccine was linked to cases that matched the background rate, they could dismiss the symptoms as ordinary. Only if they rose above the background rate would they be considered unusual and warrant a closer look.
As Zimmer notes, the vast majority of reports turned out not to be correlated with vaccines, citing the example of some vaccinated people developing Bell’s palsy and how researchers were able to exclude vaccines as a cause within two weeks using PRISM. Now, for reasons that are unclear, PRISM appears to be no longer used to look for rare vaccine adverse events, the FDA using it only to monitor drug safety now:
The other systems can provide safety information much faster, but they’re small compared with the PRISM system, which now covers about 60 million people. The F.D.A. still uses PRISM for drug safety research, but not for vaccines. Dr. Salmon is baffled that the agency hasn’t tapped into it again. “Why would you not use that?” he asked. (An agency spokeswoman said it might use PRISM in the future should the need arise.)
Worse, though, is that there now appears to be a lack of coordination once provided by NVPO now that it has been folded into OIDP:
But Dr. Nicole Lurie, who was assistant secretary for preparedness and response at H.H.S. during the 2009 pandemic, said the loss of the vaccine safety office was especially costly once the coronavirus pandemic hit. “The coordinated leadership for stuff like this would likely come from the National Vaccine Program Office,” she said.
Dr. Lurie, now an adviser at the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovation, has been waiting along with other researchers, month after month, for coordinated leadership to emerge from the federal government on long-term vaccine safety. “There are a whole bunch of people who were really concerned about this,” she said.
An F.D.A. official who declined to be identified said that in the absence of the National Vaccine Program Office, F.D.A. and C.D.C. staff members were relying on relationships they had built across the agencies, meeting regularly to discuss their separate projects.
That leaderless effort concerns Dr. Lurie. “There’s no sort of active coordination to bring all the information together,” she said.
Given the track record of the Trump administration, I fear that scientists intensely interested in vaccine safety will have to wait a long time for coordinated leadership. If there’s one thing that is clear about this administration, even among those who support it, it’s that coordinated leadership really isn’t something it’s particularly good at.
Meanwhile, on Thursday an expert from the CDC and one from the FDA gave presentations about monitoring systems at the FDA’s vaccine advisory committee, describing one that will use smartphone apps to monitor health care workers and other essential workers after vaccination, with another looking at a database of insurance claims and electronic health records, with a third looking at data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid data to track people over 65 for adverse events after vaccination. None of these are as comprehensive as PRISM.
From my perspective, it’s hard for me to tell how much of this latest development in which the role of a key office for vaccine safety monitoring has apparently been much diminished in a “reorganization” (or whatever you want to call it) is due to incompetence or the hyperpoliticization of agencies that were intended to be apolitical. Could administration spokespeople claiming that NVPO is just as relevant and active as ever be correct? Who knows? I suppose it’s possible, but the statements of so many public health experts expressing alarm definitely give me pause.
Here’s what worries me, regardless of who wins the election. By the time COVID-19 vaccines are rolled out and distributed next year (at the earliest), the HHS, CDC, and FDA will have been “reorganized” and stripped of so much expertise through a brain drain resulting from the demoralization caused by so much incompetence and political interference that it will be very difficult for the CDC and FDA to monitor the safety of the new vaccines effectively. Even if Joe Biden wins, he can’t do anything before January 20, 2021, and it will take many months, if not several years to reverse the damage. As hard as it is to believe now, one day the pandemic will end. After that (no, even now) we have to worry about all the other routine vaccines, in particular how much confidence in vaccines will have eroded due to a distrust of the COVID-19 vaccine, the general incompetence and hostility to regulation of the current administration, and the unholy union of COVID-19 deniers, antivaxxers, and QAnon conspiracy theorists.

To unblind or not to unblind? That is the question about clinical trials of COVID-19 vaccines
Antivaccine alternative health tycoon Joe Mercola claims that the unblinding of participants in the clinical trials of Moderna and Pfizer COVID-19 vaccines was intended to “blow up the trials” and undermine the science, making it impossible ever to identify long term adverse events. What he’s really doing is deceptively oversimplifying complex ethical and scientific issues surrounding these trials in the middle of a deadly pandemic, all in the service of his grift.
David Gorski on April 26, 2021
Link

One longstanding tactic of the antivaccine movement has been the oversimplification of complex questions of science and ethics in such a way as to imply nefarious intent on the part of vaccine manufacturers, public health officials, physicians, and vaccine advocates. The idea, of course, is that somehow we are all “sabotaging” the science in order to cover up evidence of massive harm due to vaccines. This tactic has, in particular, been weaponized in the era of the COVID-19 pandemic, largely because of uncertainty in the science and the fast pace of scientific discovery. More importantly, the fast pace of vaccine development has left open a door to this tactic of oversimplification. An excellent example of this tactic comes in the form of an article published by one of the foremost promoters of antivaccine disinformation and COVID-19 quackery and crankery, “alternative health” tycoon Joe Mercola. His talking point comes in the form of an article entitled “Vaccine Makers Destroy COVID Vaccine Safety Studies”.
How are vaccine manufacturers supposedly threatening to accomplish this evil end? Simple, it’s by sabotaging clinical trials and/or denying antivaxxers The One True Vaccine Safety Study that they insist to be absolutely essential. Before I discuss Mercola’s article, though, I think it’s useful to discuss how this antivaccine trope existed before COVID-19. Then, I’ll discuss how Mercola, as antivaxxers so frequently do, takes what is really a very complicated question of science, clinical trials, and ethics, and oversimplifies it in order to feed a conspiracy theory.
In brief, he’s trying to argue that the ethical imperative to “unblind” subjects in COVID-19 vaccine clinical trials or to convert currently ongoing trials into a crossover design (I’ll explain what that is later) come not from an earnest discussion of the complex ethics of clinical trials during a pandemic balancing the potential for harm to clinical trial subjects against the need for the most rigorous clinical trial design, but rather the intent to sabotage the science in order to prevent the finding of any potential adverse effects from COVID-19 vaccines. This question was rarely considered (but not unheard of) before the pandemic, mainly because the risks involved in not unblinding participants in clinical trials as to who received the placebo control and who received the vaccine was much lower. In other words, whether or not to unblind vaccine clinical trial participants and give the control group the actual vaccine was much less commonly a major issue. In the middle of a global pandemic, in which remaining unvaccinated against COVID-19 carries much more risk and more consequences, the science and ethics are not nearly as clear as Mercola would have you believe, as I will discuss. First, let’s see what Mercola is claiming.
Mercola oversimplifies massively, in order to deceive
So what is the third variant of the “No True Clinical Trial” gambit that “Dr.” Mercola is using? Last week, I saw him claiming that we’ll “never know” if COVID-19 vaccines are safe because of the “sabotage” of the clinical trials by Pfizer and Moderna:
While reports of side effects from COVID-19 gene therapies, including life-threatening effects and deaths, continue to climb at breakneck speed,1 a one-sided narrative of safety and effectiveness permeates mainstream media and medical news.
These “vaccines” are so safe and so effective, according to this narrative, that keeping control groups intact for long-term study and comparison of outcomes is now being derided as “unethical,” despite the fact that there is absolutely no non-fraudulent data to support their perverse assertions. Truly, what we’re watching is the active destruction of basic medical science in a surreal dystopian nightmare.
First of all, no, the vaccines are not “gene therapy”. They are vaccines. I will concede, though, that we’re in a surreal dystopian nightmare, but not for the reasons Mercola claims. Instead, it’s because so many people are denying science in a manner that can facilitate the spread of a deadly disease in the middle of a pandemic that has claimed the lives of millions already and is threatening to cause the total collapse of health care systems in countries such as Brazil and India.
In any event, I’ve discussed these reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database before multiple times, specifically how they are being weaponized by antivaxxers, particularly Mercola himself, to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (and loathing) about COVID-19 vaccines by implying causation of death and destruction where none has been demonstrated.
My goodness! How on earth are nefarious pharmaceutical companies accomplishing this evil trick to sell governments hundreds of millions of doses of their product without safety testing? Glad you asked! Mercola is more than happy to explain. I’ll quote at length, so that antivaxxers can’t say that I’m taking him out of context:
Consider this report in JAMA by Rita Rubin, senior writer for JAMA medical news and perspectives, for example.2 According to Rubin, the launch of “two highly efficacious” COVID-19 vaccines has “spurred debate about the ethics, let alone the feasibility, of continuing or launching blinded, placebo-controlled trials …”
Rubin recounts how Moderna representatives told a Food and Drug Administration advisory panel that rather than letting thousands of vaccine doses to go to waste, they planned to offer them to trial participants who had received placebo.
Pfizer representatives made a similar announcement to the advisory panel. According to a news analysis published in The BMJ,3 the FDA and U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention are both onboard with this plan, as is the World Health Organization.4
In the JAMA report by Rubin, Moncref Slaoui, Ph.D., chief scientific adviser for Operation Warp Speed, is quoted saying he thinks “it’s very important that we unblind the trial at once and offer the placebo group vaccines” because trial participants “should be rewarded” for their participation.
All of these statements violate the very basics of what a safety trial needs, which is a control group against which you can compare the effects of the drug or vaccine in question over the long term. I find it inconceivable that unblinding is even a consideration at this point, seeing how the core studies have not even concluded yet. The only purpose of this unblinding is to conceal the fraud that these vaccines are safe.
This is the key passage of Mercola’s article. As you can see, the hubris is epic, the arrogance of ignorance incredible. Here is a person who has never designed (or even participated in the design of) a clinical trial, much less a massive vaccine trial. I’d be willing to bet that he’s never even enrolled a single patient on a legitimate clinical trial himself. Never mind all that! Mercola nonetheless considers himself qualified to expound on the ethics of vaccine clinical trials.
So is it “unethical” to unblind clinical trial participants after a vaccine trial? Will it forever sabotage the science behind COVID-19 vaccines? Let’s just say that the answer is much more complicated than Mercola describes. As antivaxxers do, Mercola has selectively quoted experts to make it seem as though it is clearly unscientific and unethical not to unblind the studies and give the vaccine to the clinical trial participants who received the placebo control. What he ignores is the unprecedented nature of the situation we are in with respect to COVID-19 vaccines and the pandemic.
To unblind or not to unblind…?
Let me describe the dilemma faced by scientists in a manner different than how Mercola describes it, which is to portray unblinding as a nefarious attempt to undermine science in the name of ethics. It is not. In fact, the question of whether it’s even ethical to do randomized placebo-controlled clinical trials of vaccines for serious diseases that affect large numbers of people dates back at least to Jonas Salk, as Carl Zimmer and Noah Weiland noted in a December New York Times article:
Yet the prospect of giving people something useless in the face of a life-threatening disease has always been fraught. Even Jonas Salk balked at the idea of giving people placebos when researchers designed a trial to test his new polio vaccine in 1953.
“I would feel that every child who is injected with a placebo and becomes paralyzed will do so at my hands,” he complained. The study, Dr. Salk declared, “would make Hippocrates turn over in his grave.”
But Dr. Salk lost that fight, and the placebo-controlled trial went forward. It clearly demonstrated that the polio vaccine was safe and effective. Only when the trial was over did the children who received the placebo get the vaccine — along with millions of other children.
Given the stakes of the Covid-19 pandemic, the F.D.A. has agreed to consider a faster, but limited approval, known as an emergency use authorization, based on early results from clinical trials. The agency said in new vaccine guidelines published in October that such an authorization would not necessarily be grounds for unblinding a trial.
Yet the problem with unblinding such clinical trials is, as a February JAMA article described it, the possibility of “blowing up” trials, or, as the WHO put it:
Conversely, there was concern that observational data obtained from nonrandomized studies after vaccine deployment could yield unreliable answers. Observational studies are subject to substantial biases and are much less amenable to unambiguous interpretation. Their limitations are of particular concern during this public health emergency, because vaccinated and unvaccinated people will differ in their risk of exposure to infection and of serious disease, partly because of fluctuating attack rates and because during early phases of vaccine deployment, vaccinees may well be at particular risk of infection. In these circumstances, even carefully analyzed observational studies can yield misleading answers about safety and efficacy.2,3 In addition, unrelated events that occur by chance after vaccination may be incorrectly attributed to the vaccine, and such anecdotes may be deliberately promulgated by groups opposed to vaccination.
You know, I can’t help but emphasize that last part, in which premature unblinding might lead to unrelated adverse events that occur after vaccination being attributed to the vaccine. The problems with unblinding cut both ways, and Mercola ought to be salivating over the possibility of attributing any and every adverse event to the vaccine, but no one said consistency was a feature of antivax rhetoric.
Leaving these issues aside, try to imagine that you are a clinical trial participant in one of the major vaccine trials, be it for the Moderna, Pfizer/BioNTech, AstraZeneca, Johnson & Johnson, or the Novavax vaccines. The initial clinical trial results have been announced and demonstrate that the vaccine is highly effective in preventing COVID-19 with no major safety concerns. As a result, the vaccine has been issued an emergency use authorization (EUA) and is now being deployed widely, first being administered to high-risk individuals and now being administered to almost any adult who wants it. Thus far, hundreds of millions of people have received a dose. Now imagine that you strongly suspect that you were in the placebo control arm. Wouldn’t you really want to know which group you were in and, if you were in the placebo group, be given the opportunity to receive the real vaccine? Imagine, now, that you are the scientist in charge of this clinical trial and ask yourself: Is it ethical to keep the tens of thousands of people in the placebo arm of your clinical trial in the dark and leave them susceptible to COVID-19, as millions of people are receiving the vaccine from the clinical trial that they had agreed to participate in?
Just think about this dilemma for a minute. An intellectually honest person will quickly realize that the answer is not simple or obvious. It involves the balancing of the ethical imperative to minimize harm to the individuals in the clinical trial versus the scientific imperative to complete the trial to make the science as rigorous as possible. Not unblinding and allowing the control group participants to “cross over” to the vaccine arm leaves them susceptible to a potentially deadly disease against which millions are being vaccinated (as millions have died and thousands are dying of it each day) against using the very same vaccine in the clinical trial these people agreed to participate in. On the other hand, unblinding them and allowing them to receive the vaccine could make data on any longer term effects of the vaccines much harder to interpret. Imagine you’re in charge of this massive clinical trial. What do you do? Again, it’s not an easy or straightforward question. Before you answer, consider two other issues, one of which was cited by Mercola from a MedPageToday article on self-unblinding of participants in the Novavax trial:
On social media, participants in Novavax’s ongoing trial have been hotly debating whether it’s a good idea — or ethical — to unblind themselves by taking commercially available antibody tests. Many say they’ve already done so and used the results to help them decide whether to drop out and get a definitely active vaccine.
And:
The self-unblinding of participants spells trouble even if they stay in the trial, geneticist and cardiologist Elizabeth McNally, MD, PhD, of Northwestern University, told MedPage Today.
“The purpose of blinding the participants is so that they don’t change their behavior and decide to take more risks in terms of getting COVID,” she said. “We know vaccination will cause some people to take more risks. For example, it’s possible that vaccinated people are less likely to wear a mask and not social distance. If one group of people is more likely to get COVID than the placebo group, this will skew the results. It could make the vaccine look less effective than it is.”
Goodman, the Stanford University epidemiologist, said that those who unblind themselves via antibody tests “undermine the contributions of fellow trial participants and make this behavior seem acceptable by violating the trust within the trial, potentially weakening the ability to do other trials in a scientifically valid way as well.”
Mercola portrays this concern about “self-unblinding” not as due to concern about the scientific rigor of the clinical trial but rather being due to nefarious intent (of course):
So, whether vaccine scientists agree with unblinding or not, unblinding really only has to do with whether it will skew results in their favor.
Trial participants unblinding themselves might make the vaccine appear less effective if they alter their behavior as a consequence, whereas vaccine makers unblinding the entire control group will allow them to hide side effects, even if participants alter their behavior.
Actually, it’s a question of what people will do now that the cat is out of the bag and the horse has left the stable, so to speak, and multiple antibody tests are available. It is, after all, human nature to be curious. It is also not about “hiding adverse events” to unblind the entire control group. It’s about balancing potential harms of leaving them vulnerable to COVID-19 versus the scientific rigor of letting the trial run to its planned end. (I’ll discuss that more in a moment.)
That’s not all, though. Before you answer the question of whether unblinding is a good idea or not, consider also that more and more doses of multiple vaccines have become available, meaning that clinical trial participants who suspect they received placebo could easily just go and get vaccinated with one of the other vaccines—or even the vaccine whose clinical trial they participated in! Ask yourself if it is ethical to require those participants to remain in the dark and unvaccinated in the context of nearly 300 million doses of, for example, the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines alone having been distributed in the US.
Moreover, it’s not as though there isn’t substantial literature on the ethics and science of unblinding clinical trials. It is an issue that is not at all unique to vaccine clinical trials but occurs in clinical trials of, for example, new anticancer drugs. If you really want to get into the weeds of the issue of unblinding, here’s a video of an interview between the Editor-in-Chief of JAMA Journal of Ethics and Steven Goodman, MD, MHS, PhD, Associate Dean of Clinical and Translational Research and Professor of Medicine and of Epidemiology and Population Health at Stanford School of Medicine from January 27. Mercola selectively quoted Goodman in his article, but if you go to the interview, you will find that the issues involve far more than whether the two groups in a COVID-19 vaccine trial will behave the same with respect to risky activity:
If you watch the 22-minute video you’ll quickly see just how complex the issues involved are. Indeed, just look at how Dr. Goodman hesitates when asked what the implications of the decisions by Pfizer and Moderna to unblind the clinical trial participants in their trials. He also notes that there is a data monitoring committee that follows the data in real time. Indeed, these committees are the reason why some clinical trials are ended early, and it can go both ways. Such trials can be ended early because the treatment arm does a lot better than the control or because it does a lot worse. Either way, when the data safety monitoring committee finds a clear difference between the groups in a clinical trial, there is an ethical dilemma: Stop the trial and potentially knowingly harm one group or continue the trial to get the most rigorous science. Often, it is considered unethical to continue a study once a clear difference is noted, because there is no longer clinical equipoise, which I’ve discussed before. Stated briefly, for purposes of clinical trials, clinical equipoise demands that at the time a clinical trial is being carried out there be a state of genuine scientific uncertainty in the medical community over which of the drugs or treatments being tested is more efficacious and safer, an issue that pops up fairly frequently in clinical trials of cancer therapeutics.
Echoing what I said above, Dr. Goodman also points out that the question of whether to unblind or not is only a question in the context of a global pandemic. Under normal circumstances, there would be little pressure or ethical imperative to unblind a vaccine trial because the risk to the control group would be very small. In the case of COVID-19 trials, what information might we lose by unblinding? As Dr. Goodman recounts, we could lose information on how long the protection from the vaccine lasts. We could also lose information regarding which groups respond the best to the vaccine. The World Health Organization stated in a New England Journal of Medicine Perspective piece in January:
After relatively short follow-up in phase 3 trials, even when vaccine efficacy appears to be high, reliable information will still be needed on longer-term safety and duration of protection. Other information gaps will include more comprehensive assessments of short-term safety, knowledge of whether waning of vaccine-induced protection may lead to vaccine-enhanced disease if a vaccinee becomes infected on exposure to SARS-CoV-2, information on protection against clinically severe forms of Covid-19, and knowledge of any associations between the degree of protection and the recipient’s age or coexisting conditions. Even after the first vaccines become available, it will still be important to evaluate additional vaccines to meet worldwide needs.1
There’s another aspect to this problem as well, as Goodman also points out. Once the vaccine is offered outside of a clinical trial there is no way to prevent participants in the trial from “walking away from the trial” and getting vaccinated, thus adding a practical element to the dilemma of what to do, in addition to the ethical and scientific elements. Why is that?
One of the bedrock features of ethics in clinical trials is voluntariness. Participants must voluntarily agree to participate without any coercion. In addition, they must always be free to leave the trial at any time for any reason. Good clinical trial investigators try to design their trials in a manner that minimizes this “dropout” rate or at least tries to make sure that any dropouts are distributed as equally between all arms of the study as feasible. Who when designing COVID-19 vaccine trials many months ago could have anticipated that the vaccines would demonstrate themselves to be so effective so early and that governments would issue EUAs to distribute many millions of doses in a short period of time? Basically no one. Again, this is an unprecedented situation with respect to vaccine clinical trials that Mercola is massively oversimplifying and using to impute nefarious intent to the clinical trialists, the vaccine manufacturers, and the regulatory agencies that allowed these vaccines to be distributed.
That brings up yet another concern. Once there are a number of vaccines that haven’t been full approved yet but are available under various emergency use authorizations to combat the pandemic, will it even be ethical or possible to do true placebo-controlled randomized clinical trials of new vaccine candidates? After all, again, clinical equipoise demands that there be genuine uncertainty about which is better, placebo or experimental treatment, and that equipoise will be gone once governments have decided that these vaccines are sufficiently safe and effective to use on a large scale in the context of a pandemic killing millions. Given the realities on the ground, it is likely that most new vaccines from here on out will have to be tested against an existing vaccine, as we do now for new vaccines against diseases for which there is already a vaccine. The idea is to demonstrate that the new vaccine is at least as effective and safe as the old vaccine.
There’s one last wrinkle to consider before you answer. The question doesn’t have to be, “To unblind or not to unblind?” There also exists a compromise: The crossover trial. It’s a compromise that leaves participants blinded but has both groups ultimately getting the vaccine. Goodman discusses it, and Hilda Bastian wrote an excellent blog post about it on her PLoS blog Absolutely Maybe.
To cross over or not to cross over…?
So what is a crossover trial? It turns out that crossover trials are quite common in oncology clinical trials. For example, in this trial patients in the placebo group whose cancers progressed could “cross over” to the treatment arm. Some trials are designed so that cross-over is automatic and the only way that the groups in the trial differ is in what order they receive experimental drug or placebo.
Unlike Pfizer and Moderna, Novavax has done just this:
Novavax has added crossover arms to late-phase clinical trials of its COVID-19 vaccine. The action will enable participants in the placebo cohorts of the original trials to get vaccinated without unblinding the studies.
Participants in the 15,000-subject U.K. trial and 30,000-subject U.S.-Mexico study, which is yet to post data, will be offered the chance to get an additional round of injections. People who originally got a placebo will get two doses of the vaccine, and people who originally got the vaccine will receive two doses of placebo.
Novavax has taken a different approach to the South African phase 2b, where the prevalence of the B.1.351 variant contributed to weaker efficacy data than in the U.K. Placebo participants will still get the vaccine, but subjects in the original vaccine arm will also get a booster dose of NVX-CoV2373.
The design of the South African crossover trial will enable Novavax to evaluate whether an additional dose of its vaccine improves protection against B.1.351. The variant makes up a far smaller proportion of all COVID-19 cases in the U.K. and U.S.
Across all three trials, Novavax will conduct the crossover stages without unblinding the studies. The approach enables Novavax to address the ethical concern about leaving people unprotected during a pandemic while retaining the ability to assess efficacy. Novavax plans to follow participants for up to two years to assess the durability of protection. Participants have the option to become unblinded and receive a vaccine through their national immunization campaigns.
Here is a diagram, borrowed from Hilda Bastian’s article:
Interestingly, Mercola doesn’t even mention the possibility of cross-over studies. To him it’s all “to unblind or not to unblind,” without any other options, because, as usual, he selectively cites articles and studies to make it look as though the decision to unblind the Pfizer and Moderna clinical trial participants is all about hiding adverse events, not about making a defensible decision that others might disagree with regarding how most fairly to balance the risk of harm to the placebo group in the clinical trials versus the potential loss of finer grain information that would come from keeping the groups blinded for the full length of the trial coupled with the likely increasing rate of self-unblinding or dropouts the longer the trial remained unblinded.
There is a problem with a cross-over trial, though, as discussed by Hilda Bastian:
Now, this has real limits. And it’s not what you expect from vaccine trials. It’s done for treatments with effects that fade away – “wash out” – before you cross over. Turns out, vaccine crossover trials are not completely unheard of, though. I quickly found a couple from the 1990s – one tested a single-dose live cholera vaccine against placebo, and the other assessed the effects of influenza vaccination on asthma symptoms. Still, the scale of this – and the information we’re relying on them for – makes the first Covid vaccine crossover trial a real landmark.
She also notes, however:
I first saw this possibility discussed in early December last year, in a New York Times article by Carl Zimmer and Noah Weiland. Anthony Fauci proposed it as a way to get large-scale randomized data on how long immunity lasted, without leaving people on only placebos. The idea was if the group that was vaccinated earlier starting to get Covid-19 while the later-vaccinated group didn’t, you’d get the signal that immunity in the first group was waning. (Immunity is expected to wane, because immunity to coronaviruses generally does – though it’s not guaranteed, of course.)
(Yes, that’s the same article that I cited to point out Jonas Salk’s misgivings about a randomized trial of the polio vaccine.)
Bastian also cites Goodman:
A few days later, statistician Steven Goodman presented on this – peer review, really – at an FDA meeting discussing it. Here’s what we could learn from a Covid vaccine trial crossing over to crossover:
    • Large-scale data on duration of immunity (as already mentioned);
    • More data will be gathered on subgroups of people, like elderly people and racial/ethnic groups;
    • There are very few vaccinated people who got Covid-19 in the early results – with more, the theoretical risk that some could experience what’s called vaccine associated enhanced respiratory disease (VAERD or VAED) could be better assessed;
    • Assessing the impact of boosters on people who already in a trial and ready to go would be quicker and easier; and
    • More vaccinated people who got Covid-19 would help with the across-trials exercise of trying to establish correlates of immunity – we need to know if you can detect a difference in laboratory tests between the vaccinated people who were protected and those who still got sick (called “breakthrough cases”).
She also notes that, in addition to the Novavax trial, a 30,000 subject phase 3 clinical trial of a COVID-19 vaccine by the Canadian company, Medicago is a cross-over trial, while a French company, Valneva, is reportedly considering it, when their inactivated vaccine gets to phase 3.
The bottom line is that whether or not to unblind studies of COVID-19 vaccines and/or convert them to a cross-over design is a devilishly difficult question, given the uncertainties and the practicalities of doing so versus continuing until the completion of the trials. From my perspective, I highly doubt that it is any longer feasible to keep from doing one or the other with existing trials, at least for very much longer.
Mercola: Oversimplifying incredibly complex ethical and scientific questions and misrepresenting science to spread fear
Given all that information, now what would you do if you were a participant in one of these clinical trials? If you were a scientist running such a trial? The question isn’t as easy as Mercola would have you believe, is it?
This is especially true given how antivaxxers, especially Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. but also Mercola himself have weaponized reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database in order to strongly imply causation by vaccines of adverse events where none has been demonstrated. Remember, Mercola and his fellow antivaxxers are not about nuance, except when it can be twisted to spread fear about vaccines. That’s why they have no compunction about taking a complex issue like this and simplifying it beyond the recognition of reasonable scientists.
Don’t believe me? As is usual for him, Mercola just couldn’t help himself. He gives the game away in the very same article by saying this about reports of adverse reactions to VAERS:
Keep in mind that we still do not know the percentage of adverse effects being reported. Is it between 1%12 and 10%13 as past inquiries into VAERS reporting have shown, or is it higher?
If only 10% are reported, we may be looking at 23,420 deaths, but if it is as low as 1%, it jumps to more than 230,000 deaths. We will never know because there are major attempts to suppress this information, as we have already witnessed with the deaths of sport celebrities Hank Aaron and Marvin Hagler, both of whom died shortly after COVID vaccinations.
Regardless, it’s hard to justify even a single death of an otherwise healthy individual, seeing how the survival rate for COVID-19 across all age groups is 99.74%. If you’re younger than 40, your survival rate is 99.99%.14
First, as Dr. Vincent Iannelli has noted, it is completely untrue that “only 1%” of adverse events are reported to VAERS. That’s a cherry picked couple of studies there! In fact, I can’t help but counter by pointing out how VAERS data for the Johnson & Johnson vaccine led to the real time detection of an adverse event that was literally one in a million and led to a week and a half “pause” in the use of the vaccine while the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) evaluated the data, a pause that was lifted on Friday. If VAERS underreporting were as extreme as claimed by Mercola, detecting such a rare form of adverse event would have been impossible. It’s also about as innumerate and fantasy-inspired as can be to imagine that there could have been 230,000 people in four months dying after receiving a COVID-19 vaccine and nobody noticed (or the government “covered it up”), as that is almost as many as the number of people who died of COVID-19 itself in the same four month period since the first vaccine (the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine) was authorized. He then does his best to minimize the seriousness of COVID-19 by listing only the fatality rate and ignoring the hospitalization rate and the rate of having long term serious sequelae from the infection.
Then he pivots to the quackery:
If you’re concerned about vaccine side effects, please understand there are several prevention strategies and treatments readily available that have been shown to be highly effective, which means the need for a vaccine in the first place is nearly moot.
For example, nebulized hydrogen peroxide with iodine, which I’ve written about in previous articles, works very well. For a refresher, see “How Nebulized Peroxide Helps Against Respiratory Infections.” Other treatments include hydroxychloroquine with zinc, ivermectin and the iMASK and MATH+ protocols, which you can learn more about in the linked articles.
No, there’s no evidence that nebulized peroxide works, nor is there any good evidence that hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, or zinc works, no matter how much quacks try to convince you otherwise. It does amuse me, however, how Mercola just can’t help but pivot to the grift, which he then doubles down on:
In closing, if you got the vaccine and now regret it, you may be able to address your symptoms using the same strategies you’d use to treat actual SARS-CoV-2 infection.
I’ve written many articles over the past year detailing simple strategies to improve your immune system, and with a healthy immune system, you’ll get through COVID-19 without incident. Below, I’ll summarize some of the strategies you can use both to prevent COVID-19 and address any side effects you may encounter from the vaccine.
    • Eat a “clean,” ideally organic diet. Avoid processed foods of all kinds, especially vegetable oils, as they are loaded with damaging omega-6 linoleic acid that wrecks your mitochondrial function. Linoleic acid has been shown to increase mortality from COVID-19.
    • Consider nutritional ketosis and a time-restricted eating window of six to eight hours with no food at least three hours before bed. These strategies will help you optimize your metabolic machinery and mitochondrial function.
    • Implement a detoxification program to get rid of heavy metals and glyphosate. This is important as these toxins contribute to inflammation. To improve detoxification, I recommend activating your natural glutathione production with molecular hydrogen tablets.
    • A simple way to block glyphosate uptake is to take glycine. Approximately 3 grams, about half a teaspoon, a few times a day should be sufficient, along with an organic diet, so that you’re not adding more glyphosate with each meal.
    • Maintain a neutral pH to improve the resiliency of your immune system. You want your pH to be right around 7, which you can measure with an inexpensive urine strip. The lower your pH, the more acidic you are. A simple way to raise your pH if it’s too acidic (and most people are) is to take one-fourth teaspoon of sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) or potassium bicarbonate in water a few times a day.
Again, none of these interventions work, in particular the “detoxification” and the baking soda. Sure, it won’t hurt to eat an organic diet and minimize processed foods, but there’s no good evidence that doing so will prevent or treat COVID-19.
When considering anything Mercola writes, remember two things. It’s all about the quackery and the grift. Always. In this article, he started out with a clever ploy, to oversimplify the complex issues behind the ethics and science of clinical trials in a way to cast doubt on the efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines and the motives of the vaccine manufacturers, who are portrayed as trying to “betray science”. If he had been able to restrain himself a bit when it comes to pushing quackery and conspiracy theories, he might have been much more effective and not so obviously given the game away. He wants to sell his book on COVID-19, though, and so can’t help but make the grift behind his fear mongering obvious.

Antivaxxers launch a preemptive disinformation war against a COVID-19 vaccine that doesn’t yet exist
We don’t yet have a vaccine against COVID-19, but that hasn’t stopped the antivaccine movement from launching a preemptive disinformation war on social media against it. Unfortunately, as a recent study demonstrates, on Facebook at least, they have been so successful that it is possible that antivaccine messaging will surpass pro-vaccine messaging on FB within a decade.
David Gorski on May 25, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: Today is a holiday in the U.S.; so I decided to revise and update a recent post that you might have seen elsewhere last week. This version is a bit longer and includes information that popped up this weekend. I’ll be back with all original material next Monday.]
It’s hard for me to believe that I’ve now been writing about the antivaccine movement on a regular basis for the last 15 years. In fact, it blows my mind that the first big splash I made writing about antivaccine conspiracy theories dates back to June 2005, when I took on the utterly awful article simultaneously published in Rolling Stone and Salon.com, “Deadly Immunity“. The article was by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and was basically a conspiracy theory that claimed that the CDC “knew” that the mercury-containing preservative thimerosal, which was in several childhood vaccines until 2002, caused autism but that it “covered up” the data showing it at a conference in 2000 held at the Simpsonwood Conference Center near Atlanta. It was the first example I had ever encountered of what I now like to call the “central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement“. Little did I know then that the conspiracy theory of “they knew, but covered it up” was (and is) the primary structure of nearly all antivaccine conspiracy theories. Now that thimerosal has been gone from vaccines for 18 years it’s been supplanted by the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory (featured in the 2016 conspiracy film disguised as a documentary VAXXED ), in which a senior CDC scientist supposedly admitted that the CDC “knew” that vaccines cause autism but manipulated data in one of its studies to cover up the link. Plus ça change…
This leads me to the question of a COVID-19 vaccine. Most scientists with direct knowledge of vaccine development agree that the projections that we’ll have a vaccine for this new coronavirus within 12-18 months (much less by the end of the year, as was recently promised) are incredibly, even unrealistically, optimistic. Although there has been an unprecedented international effort to develop a safe and effective vaccine, as yet we only have candidates, a few of which are at the very beginning of clinical testing. Predictably, as they do during every pandemic and major epidemic, such as H1N1, Ebola, and Zika virus, antivaxxers are spinning conspiracy theories about how the COVID-19 pandemic is a “Plandemic” or a plot to force everyone to be vaccinated, complete with Bill Gates conspiracy theories and claims that there will be microchips in the new COVID-19 vaccine. The conspiracy mongering and pre-emptive push by antivaxxers to discredit a coronavirus vaccine are so blatant that they made the mainstream media last week, for example in this op-ed by Kevin Roose for the New York Times:
The other night, midway through watching a clip from “Plandemic” — a documentary that went viral on social media last week, spreading baseless lies and debunked nonsense about the coronavirus to millions of Americans overnight — I had a terrifying thought:
What if we get a Covid-19 vaccine and half the country refuses to take it?
It occurred to me that all the misinformation we’ve seen so far — the false rumors that 5G cellphone towers fuel the coronavirus, that drinking bleach or injecting UV rays can cure it, that Dr. Anthony Fauci is part of an anti-Trump conspiracy — may be just the warm-up act for a much bigger information war when an effective vaccine becomes available to the public. This war could pit public health officials and politicians against an anti-vaccination movement that floods social media with misinformation, conspiracy theories and propaganda aimed at convincing people that the vaccine is a menace rather than a lifesaving, economy-rescuing miracle.
Scariest of all? It could actually work.
He’s not wrong.
Roose goes on to point out that the antivaccine movement is far better at social media messaging than most public health advocates:
I’ve been following the anti-vaccine community on and off for years, watching its members operate in private Facebook groups and Instagram accounts, and have found that they are much more organized and strategic than many of their critics believe. They are savvy media manipulators, effective communicators and experienced at exploiting the weaknesses of social media platforms. (Just one example: Shortly after Facebook and YouTube began taking down copies of “Plandemic” for violating their rules, I saw people in anti-vaccine groups editing it in subtle ways to evade the platforms’ automated enforcement software and reposting it.)In short, the anti-vaxxers have been practicing for this. And I’m worried that they will be unusually effective in sowing doubts about a Covid-19 vaccine for several reasons.
I’ve been following the antivaccine movement for even longer, I’ll wager, and I know that Roose is correct here. It wasn’t always true, though, that the antivaccine movement was media- and social media-savvy. Indeed, early on I used to make fun of the cluelessness of antivaccine advocates on using blogs (Twitter and Facebook were only in their infancy). Then, when they made their first major forays onto Twitter to try to promote the “CDC whistleblower” antivaccine conspiracy theory, I made fun of the ham-handedness of it all. That was nearly six years ago, and six years have made a big difference. Antivaxxers now have media-savvy con men like Del Bigtree fronting for them, generating content, spreading conspiracy theories, and hyping controversy.
If you want an idea of how much more skilled antivaxxers have become, consider Plandemic, the video featuring disgraced scientist Judy Mikovits and the mother of all COVID-19 conspiracy theories. I’ve said all along that the video going viral was a planned event, and it turns out that I was correct. The ever-astute Anna Merlan discovered that an ex-Google employee and QAnon believer named Zach Vorhies conceived and executed a plan to make the video go viral, and it worked. She also reported that Vorhies has ties to the antivaccine movement, including Del Bigtree and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., having appeared on The Highwire With Del Bigtree as the “Google whistleblower” who, apparently, revealed Google’s nefarious plans to alter its search algorithms to deprioritize antivaccine misinformation. It was Vorhies, in fact, who introduced Mikovits to Mikki Willis, the filmmaker who produced the video and served as her interviewer.
To give you an idea what a disadvantage science communicators are now at, there was a study published in Nature by investigators at George Washington University, Michigan State University, Los Alamos National Laboratory, and the University of Miami. The study mapped the conversation about vaccines on Facebook during the 2019 measles outbreaks and compared provaccine pages and groups to antivaccine pages and groups. The authors found a complex landscape involving nearly 100 million users “partitioned into highly dynamic, interconnected clusters across cities, countries, continents and languages.” Key findings included that there were nearly three times as many active antivaccine communities as pro-vaccine communities but that, although the pro-vaccine communities tended to have more followers/members, the antivaccine pages were growing faster.
Here’s where the problem lies. The pro-vaccine groups tended to be peripheral and homogeneous. Of course, it’s kind of hard for them not to be homogeneous, given that the key messages pro-vaccine groups want to promote is that vaccines are safe and effective, they prevent deadly disease, and they do not cause all the health problems attributed to them by antivaccine groups. The antivaccine groups, in contrast, interacted with way more groups. The authors proposed seven reasons why antivaccine misinformation has spread so much:
     1.  Although smaller numerically, antivaccine clusters tend to become more central within the networks mapped compared to provaccine clusters. The antivaccine clusters become entangled with a large number of undecideds, while pro-vaccine clusters tend to be more peripheral, thus remaining ignorant of the conflict and gaining the wrong impression that they are winning.
     2.  Contrary to the view of “undecideds,” it turns out that the undecided individuals are not passive, but active, producing the highest growth of new out-links and becoming entangled with antivaccine clusters.
     3.  Antivaccine individuals form more than twice as many clusters as provaccine individuals, providing a larger number of sites for engagement than provaccine populations and a much better ability for antivaccine networks to become central.
     4.  Antivaccine clusters aren’t just about vaccines. They provide a number of potentially attractive narratives that “blend topics such as safety concerns, conspiracy theories and alternative health and medicine, and also now the cause and cure of the COVID-19 virus.”
     5.  Antivaccine clusters showed the highest growth during the measles outbreak of 2019, while pro-vaccine clusters showed the lowest growth.
     6.  Medium-sized anti-vaccination clusters grow the most. Whereas larger anti-vaccination clusters take up the attention of the pro-vaccination population, these smaller clusters can expand without being noticed.
     7.  Geography is a favorable factor for the anti-vaccination population. Anti-vaccination clusters either self-locate within cities, states or countries, or remain global.
Roose further adds about the study:
The researchers found that Facebook pages pushing accurate pro-vaccine information were mostly clustered in an insular group, while the anti-vaccine pages treated vaccine resistance as a kind of political campaign, and used different messages to reach different types of undecided “voters.” A page promoting holistic health remedies might start seeding doubts about vaccines among liberal yoga moms, while a page promoting resistance to government-mandated vaccines might appeal to conservatives and libertarians.
This is, of course, the sort of thing that those of us who’ve been following the antivaccine movement have known for a long time, which is one reason why we’ve been so vocal about the links between “integrative medicine” and alternative medicine and antivaccine views.
The depressing theoretical prediction from this modeling is that, if current trends continue, antivaccine support on Facebook will become dominant in a little more than a decade. Obviously, this is just one model, but its findings otherwise are fairly consistent with other research on the spreading of misinformation on social networks.
Unfortunately, as Roose further notes it’s also true that a new coronavirus vaccine, whenever it is developed, will be a perfect target for antivaccine conspiracy theories. For one thing, vaccine candidates are being rushed through development at an unprecedented pace, and vaccine candidates are likely to be fast-tracked through the regulatory approval process. This observation has led even pro-vaccine advocates express concern that, given all the haste, corners might be cut and safety testing might be deficient. Heck, I’ve worried about the same thing, knowing that any serious adverse events showing up later that were missed in the clinical trials leading to approval of the vaccine will be used to discredit not just a coronavirus vaccine, but all vaccines. Antivaxxers will use any such debacle to claim that all vaccines are inadequately tested and therefore unsafe. Moreover, organizations demonized by the antivaccine movement will be the ones promoting the vaccines, organizations such as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, the CDC, and the World Health Organization, will be at the center of the distribution of any new vaccine. If you know anything about the antivaccine movement, you know that the conspiracy theories will practically write themselves, because the groundwork has already been laid. Various existing conspiracy theories will be combined in different combinations, with new misinformation sprinkled in, to sow fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines.
Then, of course, there will be mandates. It’s a virtual certainty that, once a vaccine is approved, it will be added to the list of vaccines that children will be required to have had in order to attend school. It’ll also almost certainly be added to the vaccines required for most health care workers, which already includes influenza and DTaP vaccines. It might even be required for international travel. If there’s one thing that antivaxxers are good at, it’s weaponizing “health freedom” and “parental rights” arguments to attract right wing anti-regulation small government conservatives, as I’ve described many times. That’s the reason why the antivaccine movement has increasingly found a home in the Republican Party over the last several years, or, at the very least, the Republican Party has demonstrated itself all-too-willing to pander to antivaccine conspiracy theories for votes, as was observed during the second GOP Presidential Debate of the 2016 election cycle, when the most telling part about vaccines was how Ben Carson reversed his previous strong stand in favor of mandates to “go all squishy” on them.
Just this weekend, Sarah Zhang wrote in The Atlantic:
There is no COVID-19 vaccine, but there are already COVID-19 vaccine conspiracies. Even as vaccines for the disease caused by SARS-CoV-2 are being held up as the last hope for a return to normalcy, misinformation about them is spreading. A more fraught scenario for science communication is hard to imagine: a novel vaccine, probably fast-tracked, in the middle of a highly politicized and badly mishandled pandemic.
“I was initially optimistic that, when people felt the need for a COVID-19 vaccine, the anti-vaccination movement would undergo a period of retreat,” says Peter Hotez, a vaccine scientist at Baylor College of Medicine, who has himself become a frequent target of vaccine skeptics. “It’s actually had the effect of reinvigorating the anti-vaccine movement.”
I admire Dr. Hotez to death, but until recently he really was quite naïve about the antivaccine movement, as are many doctors and scientists. I even fell into that category several years ago, thinking that vaccines are the victims of their own success and that, because we don’t see the mass suffering now due to the diseases we now vaccinate against, the return of such an infectious disease (or diseases) would lead antivaxxers to reassess. However, this reaction of the antivaccine movement to COVID-19 should have been very predictable, just based on the experience from last year. As we saw then, with the return of measles in so many places due to low uptake of the MMR vaccine, the antivaccine movement was unmoved. In fact, it doubled down. Del Bigtree, for instance, taped a yellow Star of David to his shirt saying unvaccinated, thus comparing himself and antivaxxers to Jews during the Holocaust, about as offensive analogy as I can think of. Other antivaxxers likened their movement to the civil rights movement, a similarly offensive analogy.
Despite the image of antivaxxers being hippy dippy, granola crunching lefties, in fact, antivaccine views are roughly equally prevalent on the political right and the left, and this has been true for a long time. However, over the last decade (and in particular since the passage of SB 277 in California to outlaw nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates), increasingly the antivaccine movement has been appealing to the right more than the left through the use of conservative-friendly rhetoric of “freedom”, “parental rights”, and the portrayal of school vaccine mandates as overweening government overreach. What was once a bipartisan consensus on the value of school vaccine mandates has been becoming increasingly politicized.
While it is true that there are certainly still left wing antivaxxers, the most prominent of which are Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Marianne Williamson, right now, in 2020, the loudest antivaccine voices are nearly all on the right. It was thus at least somewhat predictable that in the era of lockdowns to slow the spread of COVID-19 antivaxxers would ally themselves increasingly with right wing anti-lockdown protesters, and, unfortunately, that is what has happened, as I noted right here over a month ago.
Unfortunately, as Zhang and Hotez note, we haven’t exactly made it hard for the COVID-19 denier/antivaccine alliance:
Hotez points to a number of recent missteps that have given vaccine skeptics ammunition: unrealistically rosy timelines for a vaccine; the appointment of a former pharma executive with $12.4 million worth of vaccine-company stock options to lead the White House’s new vaccine initiative (he is now divesting); even the name of the Trump administration’s vaccine initiative itself, Operation Warp Speed. “A ridiculous metaphor,” Hotez says, “that plays right into the hands of the anti-vaccine lobby” by emphasizing swiftness rather than safety.
The terrible thing about the name “Operation Warp Speed” and the rush for a COVID-19 vaccine is that it produces very reasonable concerns that we’re going to fast, that there are incentives to cut corners, that the FDA will fast track the vaccine at the expense of safety in a manner even worse than how it’s fast-tracked cancer drugs that are expensive and produce no benefit in terms of absolute survival based on surrogate markers. In fact, many of those warning against sacrificing safety for speed are pro-vaccine advocates like Dr. Hotez and, yes, me.
One thing’s for sure. Whenever a COVID-19 vaccine is finally approved, there will be a disinformation campaign launched by antivaxxers the likes of which we’ve never seen before. We need to prepare.

Recycling old antivax tropes as “bioethics”-based arguments against COVID-19 vaccination for children
A recently published article in Bioethics makes ethical arguments against vaccinating children against COVID-19. If you change the word “COVID-19” to measles, chickenpox, or rotavirus (or others), this article could have been published on one of the higher-brow antivax websites in 2010. Antivax arguments never change; they’re just continually recycled.
David Gorski on March 28, 2022
Link

Regular readers might be getting tired of my pointing out how there’s nothing new under the antivax sun in terms of deceptive arguments, conspiracy theories, and tropes designed to argue against vaccinating. However, the COVID-19 pandemic introduced these talking points to a much large audience than had ever seen them before so I considered it my duty to educate our readers and to point out that none of the antivaccine misinformation that has hit us like a tsunami since COVID-19 vaccines first entered large clinical trials in the summer of 2020 is anything new. It just seems new if you haven’t seen it before. Examples include, of course, misinformation claiming that the vaccine kills based on misinterpretation of the VAERS database; that it sterilizes our womenfolk; that it “sheds” and endangers the unvaccinated; and that it causes cancer, none of which are anything new. Even the claim that it “permanently alters your DNA”, although it might appear like a new talking point based on the fact that Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines were the first successful translations of mRNA technology into a clinical product, if you look really hard, is not a new claim. (Transhumanism, anyone?) As Charles Pierce likes to say, history is so cool. In this case, though, I’d add: It’s only cool and useful if you know about it and can use it to counter the pernicious misinformation about vaccines of the sort published by, for example, The Wall Street Journal and deconstructed by Jonathan Howard yesterday.
Last week the journal Bioethics published another example of how everything old is new again in the form of an article titled “Against COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children“. It might as well have been titled “Against vaccination of healthy children”, because pretty much every one of the arguments presented could be used to argue against long-accepted childhood vaccines that have been mandated as a prerequisite for school enrollment in the US for decades. I’ll explain in a moment, but, given that this is presented as piece of serious scholarship, I wondered who was behind it. It turned out to be from a last-year graduate student named Steven R. Kraaijeveld at Wageningen University, the Netherlands, and Associate Fellow at the Research Consortium on the Ethics of Socially Disruptive Technologies. It’s noted in the Biographies section that his “PhD dissertation is on the ethics of vaccination. His research focuses on philosophy and ethics of technology, medical ethics, public health ethics, and moral psychology.” After reading this article, I’d say that he needs to go back to the drawing board, particularly given the Tweets with which he bragged about his paper on Friday:
In short: We argue against both routine and mandatory COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children. We provide a series of objections to the three strongest arguments that might justify vaccinating healthy children, in order to show that none of them is tenable. 2/
— Steven R. Kraaijeveld (@srkraaijeveld) March 25, 2022
In the thread, as he lists his reasons for arguing against the “both routine and mandatory COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children” he brags about all the data that back up his ethical conclusions, after, of course regurgitating the “health freedom” and “parental rights” arguments that have long been a staple of antivaccine activists going back decades:
These are, broadly, the major arguments. For the data supporting the arguments, please see the paper itself (which includes over 100 footnotes, most containing multiple references to the relevant studies). end/
— Steven R. Kraaijeveld (@srkraaijeveld) March 25, 2022
Mr. Kraaijeveld’s co-authors include Rachel Gur-Arie, PhD, MS, Hecht-Levi Postdoctoral Fellow in Ethics and Infectious Disease at the Berman Institute of Bioethics at Johns Hopkins University, and Euzebiusz Jamrozik, MD, PhD, practicing Internal Medicine Physician and fellow in Ethics and Infectious Diseases at Ethox and the Wellcome Centre for Ethics and Humanities at the University of Oxford, as well as Head of the Monash-WHO Collaborating Centre for bioethics at the Monash Bioethics Centre. You’d think that at least Dr. Jamrozik would be aware of the antivaccine tropes being recycled in this graduate student’s paper, but apparently not. I’ve found that, depressingly, a lot of academics who actually work on infectious diseases and vaccines are blissfully unaware of common antivaccine tropes, which leads them to regurgitate them inadvertently in a much more palatable, academic-seeming form. This is what this paper does.

The recycling begins
In fairness, I will give the authors a modicum of credit in that they seem to realize that their arguments could be used to argue against other childhood vaccines. They even say so in the introduction, claiming that they’ll show you why the arguments in favor of routine vaccination of children against COVID-19, arguments that they find compelling for other childhood vaccines, don’t hold up for COVID-19 vaccines. In fact, as I’ll show, the arguments they make against the key pillars of the case for vaccinating children against COVID-19 could just as easily be deployed against many, if not most, childhood vaccines currently in use and long accepted.
Kraaijeveld notes:
This article presents an analysis of the ethics of vaccinating healthy children against COVID-19 by responding to the strongest arguments that might favor such an approach.5 In particular, we present three arguments that might justify routine6 COVID-19 vaccination of children, based on (a) an argument from paternalism, (b) an argument from indirect protection and altruism, and (c) an argument from the global public health aim of COVID-19 eradication.7 We offer a series of objections to each respective argument to show that, given the best available data, none of them is tenable. These arguments, which might be compelling for childhood vaccination against other diseases and in different circumstances,8 do not appear to hold in the case of COVID-19 with the currently available vaccines. Given the present state of affairs and all things considered, COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children is ethically unjustified.
If one accepts our conclusion that routine vaccination of healthy children against COVID-19 is ethically unjustified, then it follows that coercion, which is an ethically problematic issue in itself, is even less warranted. Nonetheless, mandatory vaccination of healthy children against COVID-19 is already being considered—and, in some places, implemented—as a way of increasing vaccine uptake.9 We therefore also provide two objections specifically against making COVID-19 vaccination mandatory for children, which center on additional ethical concerns about overriding the autonomy of parents and legal guardians and of children who are capable of making autonomous decisions. If vaccinating healthy children against COVID-19 is ethically problematic, then coercing vaccination is even less acceptable—but even if vaccinating healthy children against COVID-19 should at some future point be considered more defensible (e.g., should a much more favorable cost–benefit analysis emerge), important ethical objections against coercive mandates will still remain.
As I said before, Mr. Kraaijeveld is recycling the “health freedom” and “parental rights” arguments that portray any attempt to require vaccines for children before entering public school or daycare facilities as an unacceptable fascistic assault of freedom. It’s a very old antivaccine argument that takes a reasonable debate about the limits of what can be mandated in the service of public health and turns it into a Manichean view that portrays any sort of mandate or even mild coercion as evil. One has only to look at the “Defeat the Mandates” rally held in Washington, DC in January (with a repeat scheduled for Los Angeles in April) to see this argument taken to an extreme.

Let’s look at Mr. Kraaijeveld’s main arguments one by one.
“Paternalism”: Same as it ever was
Mr. Kraaijeveld begins by characterizing the appeal to paternalism thusly:
The first argument in favor of childhood vaccination for COVID-19 derives from paternalistic considerations and holds that routine vaccination of healthy children is justified because it is in the best interests of the would-be vaccinated children. The argument from paternalism suggests that COVID-19 vaccination will, all things considered, benefit children the most (or cause them the least harm). Given that routine vaccination is the most effective way to ensure vaccine uptake, it is therefore justified for the sake of the health and well-being of children themselves.
Unsurprisingly, his objections are twofold:
     1.  Low risk of COVID-19 morbidity and mortality to children
     2.  Known risks and unknown long-term vaccine safety profile for children
Both Dr. Howard and I have been repeating for months now how these claims are not only wrong, but echo the same claims made by antivaxxers about the MMR vaccine. Whenever the argument that we shouldn’t vaccinate children against COVID-19 because the disease isn’t that dangerous to children (i.e., quite literally, “doesn’t kill that many children”), I’m reminded of the appeal to the Brady Bunch commonly repeated by antivaxxers in 2015. I’ll discuss that more in a moment, but first let’s see what Mr. Kraaijeveld actually argues:
According to the best available data, healthy children are at a much lower risk of severe illness from COVID-19 and are less susceptible to infection than older adults.10 In contrast to many other vaccine-preventable diseases, healthy children are at low risk of severe COVID-19 infection, morbidity, and mortality.11 Hospitalization of children with COVID-19 is rare, although emerging data suggest that children with severe underlying comorbidities are at higher risk.12 Deaths among healthy children due to COVID-19 are very rare; for example, a large study in Germany found no deaths among children aged 5–11 without comorbidities.13 We agree with the assessment that COVID-19 is not a pediatric public health emergency.14
That last citation (#14) is to an article by Drs. Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral published in May 2021 arguing that COVID vaccines for children should not receive emergency use authorization. Dr. Howard recently discussed that article and its many flaws in great detail in follow-up to his original discussion of the article last year, which means I don’t have to now. Read the articles for the details, but, in brief, Pegden et al. presented a case that made COVID-19 appear essentially harmless to “healthy” children (much as antivaxxers had long claimed that measles, chickenpox, and the like are essentially harmless to “healthy” children for years before) while leaving out information about how effective the vaccines were in children. Let’s just echo what Dr. Howard said by listing again some of his key bullet points (remember, this was May 2021 and lots more children have been hospitalized and died since then in the US):
    • 482-582 children have died of COVID-19 in the US.
    • A non-trivial percentage of children who contract COVID-19 will need to be hospitalized.
    • One-third of hospitalized children require ICU level, care and 6% require invasive mechanical ventilation.
    • Over half of children hospitalized with COVID-19 had no underlying health condition.
    • 19% of American children are obese and therefore “high-risk.”
    • COVID-19 may cause long-term complications in children.
    • Tens of thousands of children have lost a parent due to COVID-19.
    • Millions of teenagers older than 16-years have been safely vaccinated so far.
    • A highly successful trial of the COVID-19 vaccine has been completed in adolescents. (Another successful trial has also been completed, with preliminary data just released).
    • Further vaccine trials (and presumed approvals) are proceeding in a purposeful, stepwise fashion by age.
    • Vaccine side-effects almost never emerge after two months. (This is relevant to the second part of Mr. Kraaijeveld’s argument.)
That sounds serious to me, and, remember, the Pegden et al. article was published almost 11 months ago, and, as our very own Dr. Howard pointed out, there was definitely some cherry picking going on here:
The German study you cite was pre delta and pre omicron. You hide that fact. Why?
You don’t mention American studies that about 20% of deaths are in healthy kids.
Beautiful paper on how to present data to mislead people. Healthy kids have died after the vaccine was available. pic.twitter.com/yZJhNitewZ
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) March 26, 2022
And also, others pointed out how cherry picked Mr. Kraaijeveld’s citations were:
here's a direct link to the website. https://t.co/s32Ol9HbDx
— Kevin Ault (@kevinault) March 27, 2022
Actually, it wasn’t just cherry picking; it was misrepresentation, too:
First screenshot is from your article. Second screenshot is actual data.
Seems like you guys need to take a course in medical ethics, or perhaps understanding basic math/statistics.
Because you’re deficient in one of these it seems. pic.twitter.com/dibkKABfJV
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) March 26, 2022
I’d also suggest that Mr. Kraaijeveld look at who is leaping to his defense. Personally, I’d be embarrassed if I had people like this defending me:
This is not the dunk you think it is.
“Hospitalizations” is not the same thing as “outcomes.”
— Non Excidet (@NordicYank) March 26, 2022
If you want to see how bad Mr. Kraaijeveld’s arguments are, look no further than this passage:
Overall, the burden of COVID-19 in children appears to be similar to or lower than that of typical seasonal influenza in the winter (unlike the much higher disease burden of COVID-19 in adults).16 In 2020, 198 children aged <17 officially died of COVID-19 in the United States.17 In 2021, with Delta being the predominant variant, that number increased to 378,18 which is comparable to the official number of children aged <17 who died in the 2018–2019 influenza season in the United States (i.e., 372).19
Notice how every time the claim is made that COVID-19 is much less deadly (or at least no more deadly) than the flu in children (even, as I note, routine yearly vaccination against the flu is recommended for children), it’s always the 2018-2019 flu season that’s cited, Always. Of course, that was the last complete flu season before the pandemic, which means that citing it is citing a season with zero mitigations of the likes that the pandemic brought us. There were no mask mandates, no business shutdowns, no virtual schooling, and no social distancing. It’s an intellectually dishonest comparison of apples to oranges worthy of antivaccine activists (which is why Mr. Kraaijeveld really shouldn’t have used it), and, as Dr. Howard put it, 1,200 is more than six. Basically, in the same environment, with mask mandates and mitigations, COVID-19 was much more deadly to children than the flu. Mr. Kraaijeveld’s argument boils down to the same argument antivaxxers make, namely that routine (or even mandated) vaccination of children against COVID-19 is unnecessary because it’s more or less harmless to “healthy” children and “not that many children” die of it. Again, it used to be accepted that children aren’t supposed to die if we can reasonably prevent it (which we can with COVID-19 vaccines), but arguments like Mr. Kraaijeveld’s amount to a shrugging of the shoulders over a level of child death that used to be considered unthinkable, even though 20% of COVID-19 deaths occur in children with no underlying conditions. Some ethics!
This brings us back to the Brady Bunch.
I last discussed the Brady Bunch gambit…two weeks ago. It was basically an antivax trope pioneered several years ago by antivaxxers about the measles. They’d point to a 1969 episode of the classic sitcom The Brady Bunch in which all six kids (and, ultimately, Mike and Alice, who, it turns out, had never had the measles as children) caught the measles. The whole situation was played for laughs, with the kids happily staying home and playing games, the only evidence that they were ill being phony-looking red spots on their faces and limbs. It wasn’t just The Brady Bunch either. Even though it’s only two weeks since I last cited it, here’s a 2014 YouTube video that was making the rounds then:
You get the idea, I think. I consider Mr. Kraaijeveld’s paper to be an academic version of the Brady Bunch gambit, which is why I’ll take this opportunity to point out yet again that according to the CDC, before the vaccine, 48,000 people a year were hospitalized for the measles; 4,000 developed measles-associated encephalitis; and 400 to 500 died. By any stretch of the imagination that was a significant public health problem, and the introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963, followed by the MMR in 1971, made it much less so, bringing measles under such control that it became very uncommon and deaths from it rare. As Dr. John Snyder reminded us nearly 13 years ago in his response to Dr. Sears making the same arguments in his vaccine book that touted an “alternative vaccination schedule”, measles is not a benign disease, regardless of what popular culture thought of it 50 or 60 years ago. (More recent data show that a severe complication of measles, subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), is more common than we used to think.) Meanwhile, over 13 years ago Dr. Sears was claiming that the risk of fatality from measles is “as close to zero as you can get without actually being zero”. Sound familiar? This is basically the same argument that Mr. Kraaijeveld is making for COVID-19, which has killed over 1,300 children in the US since the pandemic hit, arguably more than the average yearly toll of measles before the vaccine.
Mr. Kraaijeveld also invokes another common antivax argument:
Furthermore, post-infection immunity has been found to be at least as effective as vaccination at protecting against disease due to reinfection with COVID-19.24 An increasingly large body of evidence suggests that immunity after previous severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection is at least as robust as vaccine-induced immunity.25 Childhood exposure to SARS-CoV-2, which, as previously discussed, is generally associated with mild viral illness, may offer protection against more severe illness in adulthood.26 To date, hundreds of millions of children have already been infected with COVID-19. For children with immunity from previous infection, the potential benefits of vaccination are likely to be lower than for children without immunity…
I’ll give Mr. Kraaijeveld credit for using the preferred term “post-infection immunity” rather than “natural immunity”, but this, too, is an old antivax argument, namely that “natural immunity” is better than (or at least as good as) vaccine-induced immunity. It’s an argument that I first encountered over 20 years ago, which was when I first started taking a serious interest in the antivaccine movement. Sometimes it got really ridiculous too. Does anyone remember the book Melanie’s Marvelous Measles 11 years ago? It was a children’s book that argued that measles was not only not harmful but that it was good for children because it built “natural immunity.” Indeed, its blurb read:
This book takes children aged 4 – 10 years on a journey of discovering about the ineffectiveness of vaccinations, while teaching them to embrace childhood disease, heal if they get a disease, and build their immune systems naturally.
Actually, measles is worse than we thought in that it causes “immune amnesia” that suppresses immune memory and makes one susceptible to other infections for 2-3 years. You know why “natural immunity” isn’t better than vaccine-induced immunity? It’s because achieving “natural immunity” requires that one actually suffer through the disease and risk its complications, up to and including death.
COVID-19 cases & deaths are both currently & historically comparable, & in many cases worse, than they are for many other diseases for which we already vaccinate children because we feel the risk is unacceptable.
This paper should be thrown in the trash. Period. pic.twitter.com/0qLCU3x1Zc
— Cam the Cat (@Claude__Cat) March 26, 2022
I like to ask everyone, including Mr. Kraaijeveld, who argues against routine vaccination of children against COVID-19 because it isn’t that dangerous to them: Why aren’t you arguing against routine vaccination against measles? The death toll among children due to COVID-19 over the last two years (>1,300) translates to a higher yearly death toll than the measles produced in the years right before the vaccine. What about chickenpox, which used to kill “only” around 100 children a year before the vaccine? Why aren’t you arguing against the varicella vaccine?
Oh, that’s right. It’s because the COVID-19 vaccine is supposedly so much more “dangerous”:
The case for vaccinating healthy children against COVID-19 for their own sake is undermined by uncertainty; that is, by the currently poorly characterized potential for rare, harmful outcomes associated with the vaccines in children. Public safety data from the Pfizer-BioNTech clinical trials in children included 2,260 participants aged 12 to 15, of which 1,131 received the vaccine.37 In addition to a small sample size, the trial follow up period was of short duration; therefore, no reliable data presently exist for rare or longer-term vaccine-related harms.38 Though common adverse events occurring less than 6 months after vaccination may be ruled out, the risks of rare or delayed adverse outcomes can simply not yet be evaluated.39 Should vaccine harms occur, they will be revealed in the general pediatric population only after thousands or millions of children are already vaccinated, which would also risk seriously undermining vaccine confidence. The restriction of AstraZeneca vaccines to older age groups due to blood clotting events early on in the COVID-19 vaccination rollout, as well as reports of increased rates of vaccine-related myocarditis among younger age groups illustrates that rare risks are sometimes more common in younger age groups and might sometimes outweigh benefits in children.40 Severe cardiac manifestations such as myocarditis and pericarditis are now recognized as rare risks of the COVID-19 vaccines.41 Myocarditis-induced deaths following COVID-19 vaccination have been documented in adolescents as well as in adults.42
This is a classic antivax argument, namely that the vaccine is more dangerous than the disease. Of course, if the vaccine truly is more dangerous than the disease, then that is a compelling argument. However, as we’ve discussed many times (particularly Dr. Howard), this is not the case with COVID-19 vaccines. Even the cases of two adolescent deaths after vaccination cited by Mr. Kraaijeveld are not nearly as clearcut as portrayed, as pediatric cardiologist Dr. Frank Han discussed, noting that dilation of the heart (found in one boy) doesn’t occur within days and the autopsy findings were missing some key pieces of information that would definitively suggest the vaccine as the cause.
The speculation about potential “long term effects” is also a common antivaccine trope. Antivaxxers, failing to be able to make the case that routine childhood vaccines are more dangerous than the diseases that they vaccinated against, often pivot to handwaving about unknown (and undescribed and unproven) “long term” effects. Before COVID-19, those “long term” adverse events were autism, autoimmune disease, cancer (still a favorite for COVID-19 vaccines), and pretty much every major chronic illness. (Indeed, antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. came up with the false claim that the current generation of children is the “sickest generation“, largely due to—you guessed it!—vaccines.) The last time I dealt with the claim of “long term” adverse events (i.e., greater than a few weeks to six months after vaccination), I noted that they were very rare, so rare that Paul Thacker, for instance, had to do incredible contortions to find very rare cases that occurred only in the special case of immunosuppressed children and cite narcolepsy after the H1N1 vaccine Pandemrix, which actually occurred within weeks after vaccination—hardly “long term”.
So this section is basically one antivax argument that the “vaccine is more dangerous than the disease.” It’s not; so Mr. Kraaijeveld’s ethical argument falls apart. Next up, he appeals to a lack of sterilizing immunity.
Sterilizing immunity
The next arguments for vaccination against COVID-19 that Mr. Kraaijeveld takes are all based on the observation that COVID-19 vaccines do not produce “sterilizing immunity”; i.e., they do not completely prevent infection and transmission, although he does concede that they are quite effective at preventing severe disease, hospitalization, and death. Based on this observation (primarily), he takes on the argument from indirect protection and altruism and the argument from global eradication. I’ll start with the latter first, because in its service he makes an argument that caused me, literally—and I do mean literally—to facepalm as I read it. Specifically, he objects to claims that ongoing transmission will:
    • lead to the evolution of viral variants that are more harmful, perhaps also for children;
    • make the virus more likely to evolve to evade vaccine-derived immunity; and/or
    • ceteris paribus make the long-term cost-effectiveness of eradication more favorable than control
Mr. Kraaijeveld objects to the first argument by pointing out that evolutionary fitness of an infectious virus is determined more by increased transmissibility rather than virulence, which is true as far as it goes, although he cites a 2020 paper making the argument that there was not yet evidence of SARS-CoV-2 variants with increased transmissibility. (Those would arrive a few months later in the form of the Delta and Omicron variants, the Delta variant being more transmissible than the original Wuhan strain and the Omicron variant being more transmissible than the Delta variant.) However—and here’s where the facepalm came in as I read—that is actually a strong argument for doing everything reasonable, especially vaccination, to decrease the level of transmission to as low a level as is feasible, in order to decrease the likelihood of more transmissible variants arising. Again, as people making these arguments always seem to do, Mr. Kraaijeveld is falling prey to the Nirvana fallacy, in which an imperfect intervention is portrayed as a useless one. When someone like this argues that COVID-19 vaccines “do not prevent infection or transmission”, it implies that the vaccines don’t prevent infection or transmission at all, which is nonsense. Of course they do; they’re just not 100% effective (or, since the rise of Delta and Omicron even close to it).) The way to look at it is that the vaccines are “less good” at preventing infection and transmission than they are at preventing serious disease and death, not that they don’t prevent transmission or infection at all.
What flows from Mr. Kraaijeveld’s Nirvana fallacy is predictable. He argues, as I mentioned above, that mass vaccination of children will not contribute to preventing the development of more “harmful” variants. I note that, even as he observes that virulence and transmissibility are often incorrectly conflated, Mr. Kraaijeveld himself seems to be doing the same thing as he in essence argues against a straw man of the real argument, that decreasing transmission is useful in terms of controlling the disease, even if the vaccines don’t produce anything near sterilizing immunity. He also argues:
The notion that unbridled transmission would make the virus more likely to escape vaccine-derived immunity makes the eradication argument either self-defeating or incredibly costly. Aside from the fact that current vaccines do not prevent infection or transmission, if certain variants really are highly efficient at evading vaccine-derived immunity—or, worse still, if more variants continuously evolve to evade vaccines more efficiently—then attempts at eradication through global vaccination, and the strong evolutionary selection pressures this entails, will be met with diminishing returns for the costs of such a program.
It’s also rather funny how Mr. Kraaijeveld fails to note that these new variants are also pretty good at evading post-infection “natural” immunity as well—possibly even as good as they are at evading vaccine-induced immunity—to the point where it’s increasingly being concluded that, while it’s better to prevent COVID-19 with vaccination, if you do get it “hybrid immunity” (a combination of infection-induced and vaccine-induced immunity from getting the vaccine after you’ve recovered) is better at preventing the disease than either alone. I also note that there are few areas in the world where the vaccination rate among adults (much less among children) is anywhere near high enough to result in significant selection for variants that evade the immune response; what we are seeing is primarily a selection for increased transmissibility due to wide and largely uncontrolled circulation of the coronavirus among large populations.
Mr. Kraaijeveld also argues that children are not a major driver of COVID-19 transmission, thus making vaccinating “healthy” children pointless, because, according to him, COVID-19 is not dangerous to “healthy” children. One notes that there is more cherry picking here, given that all the studies he cites are pre-Delta and pre-Omicron. Moreover, more recent studies showing that mask mandates significantly decreased transmission suggest that schools are not as insignificant a source of COVID-19 circulation as Mr. Kraaijeveld would argue.
“Defeat the mandates!”
The last part of Mr. Kraaijeveld’s paper opposes any sort of mandates for COVID-19 vaccines for children that are straight from the antivax playbook. First, the appeal to “parental rights”:
Mandates for children to be vaccinated against COVID-19 would limit and, depending on their nature, even override the autonomy of parents and guardians to make decisions about the health of their children. This requires ethical justification as such, but it demands stronger justification in proportion to the level of coercion that mandates would involve.100 When mandates are in place, the actors who make decisions for the health and well-being of children de facto become governments and public health officials rather than parents, although less coercive measures (e.g., small fines) might allow some parents to opt out and thereby retain decisional autonomy.101
I have to wonder right here if Mr. Kraaijeveld understands how mandates work for children, in the US at least. Here, the mandate is that children require certain vaccines to attend school, but there is no legal penalty for not vaccinating one’s children other than not being allowed to enroll them in school. Certainly, there are no fines, and it’s pretty rare that parents are investigated by child protective services for not vaccinating their children. (Usually, such investigations involve far more than just not vaccinating.) He also seems unaware that most states allow religious and philosophical exemptions to these mandates, in addition to medical exemptions. In the US, at least, the “coercion” that he decries isn’t much in the way of coercion at all, which makes me wonder why he doesn’t think that, in the US at least, mandating COVID-19 vaccines for school is acceptable. Oh, wait. As discussed above, he echoes—unknowingly, I hope, but possibly knowingly I fear—antivaccine talking points about them, such as the claims that COVID-19 doesn’t harm “healthy” children, that the vaccine is more dangerous than the disease, that it doesn’t produce “sterilizing immunity” and is therefore useless in contributing to herd immunity, and other arguments.
He also goes straight into Great Barrington Declaration/Urgency of Normal territory of “focused protection”:
For COVID-19, vaccines are safe and effective in higher-risk groups, including older adults and the immunocompromised,59 and significantly reduce the risk of severe illness even when vaccinated groups are exposed to substantial community transmission.60 While there are some people for whom the current COVID-19 vaccines are contraindicated (e.g., those with severe allergies), this group appears to be small.61 It is therefore not the case that vulnerable groups cannot protect themselves, which would make routine vaccination of less vulnerable groups—children, in this case—more compelling. Moreover, as argued above, children are not major drivers of COVID-19 transmission. As such, there is no strong ethical justification for COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children for the sake of vulnerable groups.
This is, in essence, the same argument that Great Barrington Declaration authors make about all interventions to prevent the spread of COVID-19—including masks, “lockdowns,” and vaccines—namely that it’s possible to protect the “vulnerable” (“focused protection”) and that no intervention should be permitted that is not completely voluntary. Unsurprisingly, consistent with this Mr. Kraaijeveld is apparently not a fan of nonpharmaceutical interventions, such as masks and “lockdowns,” to slow the spread of COVID-19 either, viewing them as ethically problematic as well.
Same as it ever was
To summarize, Mr. Kraaijeveld argues that, because current COVID-19 vaccines do not produce sterilizing immunity, herd immunity is not achievable, and vaccinating children doesn’t protect others, nor would vaccinating them prevent the evolution of more harmful and/or immune-evading variants, and, as a result, vaccinating children is not ethically supportable, and vaccine mandates of any kind for COVID-19 are completely unjustifiable from an ethical standpoint. Of course, he fails to mention that most vaccines do not produce sterilizing immunity. It’s not as though this hadn’t been discussed at the time the vaccines were being rolled out or that scientists hadn’t recognized that COVID-19 vaccines were unlikely to produce true sterilizing immunity. It’s just plain incorrect to argue that you have to have sterilizing immunity for a vaccine to contribute to herd immunity or even the elimination of a disease. For example, the smallpox vaccine did not produce sterilizing immunity; yet, as has been observed, it was crucial in eradicating smallpox. Neither the Salk (inactivated) nor the Sabin (live attenuated) polio vaccine produces sterilizing immunity, but the global eradication of polio is within reach, thanks to the vaccines:
Actually the primary purpose of a vaccine is to prevent disease.
Neither the Salk (inactivated) nor the Sabin (live attenuated) polio vaccines produce sterilizing immunity. They both are very effective at preventing the disease paralytic poliomyelitis, not poliovirus infection. https://t.co/Km2smLCiuW
— Dr. Angela Rasmussen (@angie_rasmussen) January 6, 2022
Also, while we’re on the topic of polio, it turns out that the same appeal to the “disease doesn’t kill that many children” argument can be made for polio:
Just a few things:
1. Polio is 95% true asymptomatic (950 of 1000 who contract polio NEVER knew they had). It has an IFR 1/10th that of COVID.2. Both Polio and Measles were de-facto eradicated by their respective vaccines pic.twitter.com/SOi0ELrS30
— Gregory Travis. Make schools #DavosSafe (@greg_travis) November 30, 2020
One wonders whether Mr. Kraaijeveld similarly questions whether routine polio vaccination is advisable, as well. Just as most of his arguments could be used against routine measles vaccination, similarly most of them could also be used against polio.
Or rotavirus:
The case of rotavirus—which causes severe vomiting and watery diarrhea and is especially dangerous to infants and young children—is fairly straightforward. Vaccination limits, but does not stop, the pathogen from replicating. As such, it does not protect against mild disease. By reducing an infected person’s viral load, however, it decreases transmission, providing substantial indirect protection. According to the Centers for Disease Control, four to 10 years after the 2006 introduction of a rotavirus vaccine in the U.S., the number of positive tests for the disease fell by as much as 74 to 90 percent.
I mean…
Whelp based on this let’s let whooping cough and polio rip through the pediatric population. I mean pertussis, tetanus, diphtheria vaccination doesn’t provide sterilizing immunity. IPV does not provide sterilizing immunity and less than 1% infected with polio die. /s
— CWebb0412 (@webb0412) March 26, 2022
In other words, it is not a prerequisite that COVID-19 vaccines prevent transmission completely for them to be very valuable in curbing the pandemic. Moreover, newer generations of COVID-19 vaccines might actually be able to achieve sterilizing immunity. I also note that it has long been a favorite antivaccine argument to cite one vaccine in particular that doesn’t provide sterilizing immunity, specifically the pertussis vaccine, whose immunity also wanes with time, like that from COVID-19 vaccines.
While issues of freedom and parental rights are issues of ethics and law about which there will always be some subjectivity based on differing belief systems and about which reasonable people can disagree, accurate science and data are required to have reasonable debates about how much the state should be allowed to infringe upon individual freedom and autonomy as well as parental rights. By massively downplaying the severity of COVID-19 in children in a manner that is, quite frankly, eugenicist in its emphasis on the disease supposedly being pretty close harmless to healthy children—not to mention based on cherry picked data primarily from before the Delta and Omicron surges—and exaggerating the dangers of the vaccine, Mr. Kraaijeveld, whether he realizes it or not or will admit it or not, tilts the playing field in favor of his arguments in the same intellectually dishonest manner that antivaxxers have long done. He even recycles their arguments, as the way his appeal to the lack of sterilizing immunity due to COVID-19 vaccination and his claim that COVID-19 is close to harmless to most “healthy children,” both of which are old antivaccine claims used for a number of vaccines in the past, but particularly MMR, rotavirus, and varicella.
All of these reasons are why I now eagerly await Mr. Kraaijeveld’s next bioethical treatise arguing that we should not routinely vaccinate children against measles because the disease doesn’t kill that many kids and that we shouldn’t vaccinate against polio, pertussis, and most other childhood diseases because the vaccines don’t produce sterilizing immunity and therefore cannot produce herd immunity or contribute to the elimination of the disease. After all, if he’s going to recycle, he should go all-in and recycle everything.
Meanwhile, people who like Mr. Kraaijeveld’s message will go all Humpty Dumpty about words and argue that an article titled “Against COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children” is not actually arguing against vaccinating children against COVID-19:
It's amazing how contrarians can claim an article entitled "[a]gainst COVID-19 vaccination of healthy children" and which explicitly argues against routine COVID-19 vaccination for "healthy" kids, isn't actually arguing against vaccination.
Up is Down.https://t.co/nH24CgNiqC pic.twitter.com/KwBaFPAPpu
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) March 26, 2022
Same as it ever was.
Same As It Ever Was David Byrne GIFfrom Same As It Ever Was GIFs

Yes, the FDA really HAS given full approval to the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine
After the FDA announcement a week ago that Comirnaty, the COVID-19 mRNA vaccine developed by BioNTech and Pfizer, had been approved, it took less than a day for antivaxxers to spin a conspiracy theory claiming that the FDA hadn’t really approved the Pfizer vaccine at all and that Comirnaty wasn’t available, all to protect Pfizer from liability. It’s a superficially plausible conspiracy theory that falls apart upon closer inspection.
David Gorski on August 30, 2021
Link

One week ago today, the FDA granted full approval to Comirnaty, the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine developed by BioNTech and Pfizer, and there was much rejoicing. One reason for the rejoicing was the belief, widespread among health authorities, that one thing holding many back from getting vaccinated against COVID-19 was the knowledge of how the three COVID-19 vaccines currently available in the US (made by Pfizer/BioNTech, Moderna, and Johnson & Johnson) had been distributed under an emergency use authorization (EUA). Because this was less than full FDA approval in that it is a mechanism which permits the FDA to “allow the use of unapproved medical products, or unapproved uses of approved medical products in an emergency to diagnose, treat, or prevent serious or life-threatening diseases or conditions when certain statutory criteria have been met, including that there are no adequate, approved, and available alternatives”, so the thinking goes, many vaccine-hesitant didn’t trust the vaccines but would trust them once the FDA formally approved them, as Steve Novella discussed last week. To some extent, this might be true, although I rather suspect that the number of vaccine-hesitant who will be persuaded by full FDA approval of Comirnaty to get the shot will be relatively small compared to what was hoped for. I also know that full FDA approval won’t sway antivaxxers in the least.
Indeed, it was almost as though antivaxxers were ready with a line of propaganda about Comirnaty and the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine. Just to be transparent, I will note that I wrote about this last week for my not-so-super-secret other blog, but this bit of misinformation has gone viral to the point where I thought it very much worthwhile to cover it for Science-Based Medicine as well. Obviously, there will be overlaps between my previous post and what I’m writing now, but there have also been developments since last week that weren’t covered, and as a result this post is substantially different from the previous one. (Also, if you don’t read my other blog, this will be all new to you anyway.) Moreover, since I wrote that post, I think I’ve found an element from FDA messaging that left the door open to a new conspiracy theory that builds on this one. As I’ve said before, I do grudgingly almost have to hand it to antivaxxers. No matter how often their misinformation based on bad science, pseudoscience, and conspiracy theories is debunked with science, evidence, events, and reason, they’re always ready with a Talking Point B (and C and D and E) to replace the debunked talking point with a new one. In this case, after Comirnaty had been approved on Monday, antivaxxers came up with this conspiracy theory by Tuesday.
But what is this conspiracy theory? Follow me down the rabbit hole.
“The FDA pulled a bait and switch”
Although the sources that led me to this particular conspiracy theory were articles posted by Tuesday, I’ll begin with a Tweet from antivax “thought leader” Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.:
Here's my latest with @NassMeryl… Buried in fine print of Monday's approval by FDA of Pfizer Comirnaty COVID vaccine are 2 critical facts that affect whether vaccine can be mandated + whether Pfizer can be held liable for injuries.https://t.co/QtpHufCKDI
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) August 25, 2021
The article linked to claims:
The press reported that vaccine mandates are now legal for military, healthcare workers, college students and employees in many industries. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio has now requiredthe vaccine for all teachers and school staff. The Pentagon is proceeding with its mandate for all military service members.
But there are several bizarre aspects to the FDA approval that will prove confusing to those not familiar with the pervasiveness of the FDA’s regulatory capture, or the depths of the agency’s cynicism.
First, the FDA acknowledges that while Pfizer has “insufficient stocks” of the newly licensed Comirnaty vaccine available, there is “a significant amount” of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID vaccine — produced under Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) — still available for use.
The FDA decrees that the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine under the EUA should remain unlicensed but can be used “interchangeably” (page 2, footnote 8) with the newly licensed Comirnaty product.
So what does that particular footnote in the FDA letter say? Let’s quote it:
The licensed vaccine has the same formulation as the EUA-authorized vaccine and the products can be used interchangeably to provide the vaccination series without presenting any safety or effectiveness concerns. The products are legally distinct with certain differences that do not impact safety or effectiveness.
So the licensed vaccine (Comirnaty) has the same formulation as BNT162b2, the designation for the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine that has been distributed since December under an EUA. However, for reasons not described in the FDA letter, the FDA says that the two are “legally distinct,” and there is the phrase that’s launched a major conspiracy theory among antivaxxers.
RFK Jr. and Meryl Nass continue:
Second, the FDA pointed out that the licensed Pfizer Comirnaty vaccine and the existing, EUA Pfizer vaccine are “legally distinct,” but proclaims that their differences do not “impact safety or effectiveness.”
There is a huge real-world difference between products approved under EUA compared with those the FDA has fully licensed.
EUA products are experimental under U.S. law. Both the Nuremberg Code and federal regulations provide that no one can force a human being to participate in this experiment. Under 21 U.S. Code Sec.360bbb-3(e)(1)(A)(ii)(III), “authorization for medical products for use in emergencies,” it is unlawful to deny someone a job or an education because they refuse to be an experimental subject. Instead, potential recipients have an absolute right to refuse EUA vaccines.
U.S. laws, however, permit employers and schools to require students and workers to take licensed vaccines.
I’ve pointed out, here and elsewhere, many times before that the “Nuremberg Code gambit” is nothing more than a convenient way of comparing vaccine advocates and those favoring vaccine mandates to Nazis. First, it deceptively conflates a legal definition of “experimental” or “investigational” (basically any drug or biological that hasn’t yet received full FDA approval) with a scientific definition of “experimental”. The way I like to show the deception is to point out that a product that has gone through phase 1, 2, and 3 testing involving tens of thousands of subjects, over 300 million doses of which have been administered with an excellent record of safety and effectiveness in just the US alone, is not, by any reasonable scientific definition, “experimental” any more. It’s just not yet FDA-approved. Moreover, the “Nuremberg Code gambit” intentionally ignores more recent statements of ethics regarding human subjects research, such as the Belmont Report in the 1970s and the Declaration of Helsinki, which was most recently updated in 2018. Why would antivaxxers ignore a more recent and comprehensive statement on the ethics of human subjects research in favor of a 75 year old code that, while historically very important, is not the current standard? Isn’t it obvious? The more recent reports don’t involve a judgment against Nazis, and antivaxxers are about nothing if they aren’t about comparing doctors to Nazis and vaccine mandates to the Holocaust.
You can see the conspiracy theory here. To sum up its essence, antivaxxers are claiming that the FDA did a “bait and switch,” approving Comirnaty, the Pfizer vaccine given a trade name while leaving BNT162b2, the designation of the vaccine that had been granted an EUA under the same EUA, all in order to not just give the “appearance” that COVID-19 vaccine mandates are now legal but to allow the old BNT162b2 not to have to be covered under the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986, the law that created the Vaccine Court and mandates that all claims of vaccine injury go through the Vaccine Court first before they can go through regular federal courts.
Of course, antivaxxers frequently forget to mention that the Vaccine Court is rather lax. The Vaccine Court was designed, if anything, to err on the side of paying out, as the Daubert standard for admissibility of expert witnesses isn’t always enforced, leading sometimes to “expert” witnesses who would never be allowed in regular courts. Speculation is permitted, and all that is required to potentially win a settlement is a “biologically plausible” mechanism, rather than a scientifically demonstrated mechanism. Also, it’s a civil court, and the standard of evidence for compensation is what some have called “50% and a whisker”. Moreover, compensation is automatic for so-called “table injuries” (known injuries that science attributed to vaccines listed on the Vaccine Injury Table). Indeed, I frequently suspect that what drives so much of the antivax hatred towards the Vaccine Court is not just that it has rejected claims of causation of autism by vaccines, but from trial lawyers. Even though they can get a lucrative steady paycheck billing their hourly rates while representing families taking their case to the Vaccine Court, trial lawyers who want to sue vaccine manufacturers for fantastical “vaccine injuries” will never get a massive contingency fee percentage of a huge headline-making award.
In any event, UC-Hastings law professor Dorit Reiss has explained that vaccines issued under an EUA are probably not covered by the NCVIA of 1986 and the Vaccine Court, but under a much more restrictive system:
In essence, COVID-19 vaccines manufacturers, distributors, and administrators are currently almost completely exempt from liability because the vaccines – and other COVID-19 products – are under a Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP) declaration.
The only exception – the only situation where you can sue these actors – is if you can show they engaged in “willful misconduct”.
The conditions are rather restrictive, too. The vaccine maker must have acted:
    • intentionally to achieve a wrongful purpose;
    • knowingly without legal or factual justification; and
    • in disregard of a known or obvious risk that is so great as to make it highly probable that the harm will outweigh the benefit.
Reiss further notes:
People harmed by a vaccine covered by the declaration may turn for compensation to the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program – which is hard to use.
So there you have the conspiracy theory in a nutshell. Ironically, RFK Jr.’s version of the conspiracy theory is the least wild one.
Robert Malone and Greg Hunter crank the conspiracy up to 11
Although I don’t know for sure, I think that this particular conspiracy theory originated with Dr. Robert Malone. Perhaps you’ve heard of him. He’s a scientist who’s made a name for himself in crank circles by claiming to be the “inventor of mRNA vaccines”. He isn’t, as far as I can tell, although that doesn’t stop him from ranting about how his contributions to the vaccine are “being erased from Wikipedia” for going against orthodoxy on COVID-19 and mRNA vaccines against the disease. Amusingly, it appears that his wife got busted editing his Wikipedia entry under the ‘nym Glasspool1 and that there were a lot of other suspicious edits to his entry, leading Wikipedia editors to take action to put the kibosh on this attempt to use Wikipedia for self-promotion.
In any event, the first instance of this conspiracy theory that I saw was published last Tuesday on Greg Hunter’s USA Watchdog as a post titled “FDA Lied–Vax Not Approved Still Experimental“:
The big news the FDA had given “full approval” to the Pfizer CV19 vaccine is a HUGE lie. The FDA has granted approval to some future vaccine called “Comirnaty.” (FDA approved the biologics license application (BLA) submitted by BioNTech Manufacturing GmbH for COMIRNATY (COVID-19 Vaccine, mRNA). (Here’s the letter from the FDA to Pfizer) You cannot get Comirnaty now because it does not exist. Who knows when, in the future, they will manufacture it so you can get this vax. What you can get is the same old experimental Pfizer vaccine that is under Emergency Use Authorization (EUA). All the FDA did was extend the EUA for the crap they were already injecting. This is the vaccine that is available for the forced mandates to civilians and military alike. It’s a total experimental vaccine, and they lied to the public and said it was “fully approved” and “safe and effective.” In a letter to Pfizer on Monday, the FDA said, “. . . the EUA will remain in place for the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine for the previously-authorized indication and uses. . .” There it is in black and white from the criminal Nuremberg Code violating liars at the FDA.
Don’ take my word for it. Dr. Robert Malone, inventor of the mRNA (that is found in the so-called vaccines), says there are “two vaccines.” Today, Dr. Malone explained what the FDA did on Steve Bannon’s “War Room.” There was one approval for a future vaccine, and one extension of the Emergency Use Authorization for the vaccine being used now. There is little doubt this will continue to be used for all the upcoming mandates. Is this a huge lie to trick the public into taking the experimental shot? I say yes.
Unsurprisingly, Hunter (whom I had, oddly enough, never heard of before encountering this article) invoked the Nuremberg Code gambit, because of course he did. Unlike RFK Jr., though, Hunter completely ignored the footnote in the FDA letter stating that Comirnaty and BNT162b2 have the same formulation and can be used interchangeably, and instead went right for this rather confusing passage:
On August 23, 2021, having concluded that revising this EUA is appropriate to protect the public health or safety under section 564(g)(2) of the Act, FDA is reissuing the August 12, 2021 letter of authorization in its entirety with revisions incorporated to clarify that the EUA will remain in place for the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine for the previously-authorized indication and uses, and to authorize use of COMIRNATY (COVID-19 Vaccine, mRNA) under this EUA for certain uses that are not included in the approved BLA. In addition, the Fact Sheet for Healthcare Providers Administering Vaccine (Vaccination Providers) was revised to provide updates on expiration dating of the authorized Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine and to update language regarding warnings and precautions related to myocarditis and pericarditis. The Fact Sheet for Recipients and Caregivers was updated as the Vaccine Information Fact Sheet for Recipients and Caregivers, which comprises the Fact Sheet for the authorized Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine and information about the FDA-licensed vaccine, COMIRNATY (COVID- 19 Vaccine, mRNA).
So what does this mean? The language about Comirnaty is, as is often the case, confusing legalese and jargon. First of all, what this means is that, while Comirnaty is now fully FDA-approved for use in people age 16 and older to prevent COVID-19, its use in those aged 12-15 will continue to fall under an updated EUA rather than full FDA approval, just as the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine’s use has since the EUA was issued for this indication in May. The reason is simple. Approval of a biologics license application (BLA) requires more follow-up data than an EUA, and insufficient time has passed since the clinical trial upon which the FDA based its May EUA that authorized use of the Pfizer vaccine in children aged 12-15 was concluded. As the FDA put it in a press release, the vaccine will be “available under emergency use authorization (EUA), including for individuals 12 through 15 years of age and for the administration of a third dose in certain immunocompromised individuals” and that the BLA was granted under “Priority Review“.
If you have the stomach for it, here is the video of Malone’s claims (four minutes out of a much longer interview):
And here is Greg Hunter’s rant:
Hunter takes Malone’s conspiracy theory and runs with it, cranking the conspiracy up to 11 by claiming that, besides the FDA’s extension of the EUA on the Pfizer vaccine (now called Comirnaty) for indications not covered in the BLA (children age 12-15 years and the third dose for immunosuppressed people), the FDA also extended the EUA for existing stocks of vaccines, leading Hunter to rant that it’s a “huge lie” that the Pfizer vaccine has been “fully approved.” Not only that, but he claims that Comirnaty doesn’t exist yet:
While they did approve the biologics license, the BLA submitted by BioNTech manufacturing for Comirnaty, they didn’t approve the Pfizer vaccine, what we already have…And…Comirnaty, you can’t get that now. That’s not out for a few years. So what did they do? Oh, here’s what they really did.
Before I go on, though, I can’t help but point out that Comirnaty is indeed available and being used in Europe under that very name, making Malone’s point seem rather silly:
None of this, of course, deters Hunter. Hunter then quotes the part in the passage above about the FDA “reissuing the August 12, 2021 letter of authorization in its entirety with revisions incorporated to clarify that the EUA will remain in place for the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine for the previously-authorized indication and uses, and to authorize use of COMIRNATY (COVID-19 Vaccine, mRNA) under this EUA for certain uses that are not included in the approved BLA.” He then goes on to rant:
Can you get the Comirnaty now? Can you get that now? No, that’s the only license they gave. You can’t get that right now. What you can get is what’s in the emergency use authorization. That’s what they’re going to inject everyone with. You can’t get the new approved vaccine. It’s not been created yet, and it’s only for the BioNTech manufacturing of Comirnaty. I believe that’s how you say it. It doesn’t matter; you can’t get it for a couple of years. What you can get is the crap they’ve already been injecting into us, and they’ve extended the emergency use violation, meaning that when you have the Pentagon mandating vaccinations and mandating for state and federal workers they’re mandating the forced participation in an experimental drug trial—and a dangerous one at that. Shame on you, FDA, for lying! You didn’t give full approval for the crap that they’re going to use in the next couple of years.
It’s not just Hunter, either, who picked up this conspiracy theory and ran with it. For example, Robert Barnes, a conservative lawyer who has worked for Alex Jones and has been a regular contributor to Jones’ conspiracy website Infowars, Tweeted:
There is no *available* FDA approved licensed vaccine. Here's what is happening. If FDA approved & licensed COVID19 vaccine, it would have to revoke the EUA vaccines & subject the vaccine maker to more liability risk. So it only approved a future vaccine that isn't "available".
— Robert Barnes (@barnes_law) August 25, 2021
Again, this doesn’t make sense, given that Comirnaty is clearly already available in Europe, at least. Indeed, when RFK Jr. sounds less out there than you do, you really should rethink, but rethinking is not what conspiracy theorists do. Instead, they double down. Where RFK Jr. only says that the FDA has stated that supplies of Comirnaty are simply constrained right now and that the FDA is taking advantage of this to allow the old vaccine to continue to be distributed under the EUA and thereby supposedly escape falling under the NCVIA of 1986, Malone and Hunter go far beyond that and much deeper into the rabbit hole of conspiracy mongering by saying that this was intentional all along.
But what’s really going on?
The FDA’s action, explained
Last Thursday (after I had written the first version of this post in which I expressed a bit of puzzlement over why the FDA would have chosen this route), Aaron Blake wrote an excellent explainer for The Washington Post titled “Vaccine conspiracy theorists become even more desperate after full FDA authorization“. (That is, of course, a great title and very accurate.) Blake, as I did, notes first about the claim that the FDA never really approved the Pfizer vaccine:
It’s a claim many of the most prominent vaccine skeptics you might have heard of are pushing with increasing gusto. It’s just not something that, according to experts, actually lines up with the FDA’s announcement.
Some of these claims are rather inscrutable. But they boil down to the idea that the FDA has engaged in a bait-and-switch. While it fully approved the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine that will be marketed under the name Comirnaty, the FDA also extended the emergency-use authorization for the same vaccine under the existing name.
Some have gone so far as to ignore the former and claim this was strictly about extending the emergency-use authorization (EUA). But most of it involves suggesting the full authorization provides a pretext for mandating the emergency-use version (which some wrongly suggest is different). Others have wrongly claimed that if this was truly a real, full authorization, the EUAs would have to be voided — so the fact that they aren’t means it isn’t a full authorization.
Blake then cites a different footnote that I should have cited:
Although COMIRNATY (COVID-19 Vaccine, mRNA) is approved to prevent COVID-19 in individuals 16 years of age and older, there is not sufficient approved vaccine available for distribution to this population in its entirety at the time of reissuance of this EUA. Additionally, there are no products that are approved to prevent COVID-19 in individuals age 12 through 15, or that are approved to provide an additional dose to the immunocompromised population described in this EUA.
This is actually quite clear and I should have noticed it in my first version. There isn’t enough Comirnaty to take care of the entire population that needs to be vaccinated. That is a very different claim than saying that Comirnaty is not available and even more different than the claim made by Hunter and others that it won’t be available until 2023, which appears to have come out of thin air. (At least, if there is a basis for it, I haven’t been able to find it in nearly a week.)
Blake then goes on to explain why the FDA acted as it did, pointing to another claim by antivax conspiracy theorists that came out of thin air:
As for the idea that they simply wouldn’t be allowed to continue the EUAs if they truly had a fully approved version? That comes out of thin air. The FDA is allowed to continue with EUAs even if a fully approved treatment is available, as long as there isn’t an “adequate” amount of the fully approved treatment available. (The above footnote is appended to the FDA using this precise language.)
What’s more, the full authorization doesn’t include some groups in the EUAs, such as those between 12 and 15 years of age — meaning those groups won’t yet have access to the fully authorized version.
“That language gives FDA a tremendous amount of flexibility to continue to issue EUAs, or to retain existing EUAs, even after one or more products are approved,” said Patricia J. Zettler, a former FDA attorney and law professor at Ohio State University. “For example, remdesivir is fully approved for the treatment of covid-19 requiring hospitalization, but there remains an EUA for the product for pediatric patients outside the scope of the approval.”
Zettler added: “There is nothing suspicious going on here; this is just regulatory language explaining why a legal standard is met.”
In other words, the FDA phrased its letter as it did in order to explain that it was meeting the standard of the law. Basically, even though Comirnaty is available now, it’s not available in sufficient supply to meet current need, and the FDA is allowed to continue the EUA for BNT162b2 until supplies of Comirnaty are sufficient. Also, by law, the FDA couldn’t yet approve BNT162b2 for the other uses covered by its EUAs, namely children 12-15 years old and third “booster” doses for people with weakened immune systems for whatever reason, be it disease, cancer chemotherapy, or whatever.
If you want a more step-by-step explanation, I found a great Twitter thread explaining the situation:
I also like how he finishes thusly, one might say…insolently:
Truly, I couldn’t do better myself, other than to reference this particular post on Robert Malone. You’ll excuse me if I couldn’t resist, but, whatever role Malone might have played in developing lipid nanoparticle-encapsulated mRNA as a means of getting cells to make a desired protein, right here, right now, in 2021 he has become a full-on conspiracy crank.
A wrinkle
I will conclude by circling back to a rather cryptic comment that I made near the beginning of this post about a “key element behind the FDA messaging” that might explain more fully why there might have been a legal difference between Comirnaty and BNT162b2. Amazingly (to me, anyway) Robert Malone didn’t pick up on it, nor did any other antivaxxers other than one:
So they are saying Comirnaty has "optimized codons to improve antigen expression" while the "V8" formulation that was used on the animals during the trial does not contain that.
This is one I found intriguing, but not entirely sure it is a cause for immediate concern.
— Ms. Jones 🐼🐾🇺🇸 (@MsPandaJones) August 25, 2021
Again, I hesitate to bring this up because doing so risks giving antivaxxers another talking point. On the other hand, it’s always better to be proactive, so that if one of the bigger antivax social media influencers picks up on this a refutation will be ready.
First, though, what does this mean?
As I’ve explained before, in brief, DNA replicates from a DNA template and results in a double-stranded molecule that is very stable, as it has complementary sequences that tightly bind to each other in a sequence-specific fashion. This DNA template is unwound by enzymes that use the template to make RNA strands, which are single-stranded, which is then used by a ribosome to make protein out of amino acids. Again, to put it simply, each nucleotide equals one letter of the code; each three-nucleotide sequence (codon) equals one “word” that translates to an amino acid. Given that there are four nucleotides, there are 64 possible codons. Since there are only 20 amino acids, that means that most amino acids are encoded by more than one combination of nucleotides or more than one codon, leaving aside codons that code for “start” and “stop”; i.e., the genetic code is redundant.
What this regulatory statement seems to be saying is that Comirnaty, while using an mRNA sequence that produces exactly the same amino acid sequence for the SARS-COV2 spike protein using “optimized codons.” It turns out that the use of certain codons can be more efficient at producing the desired protein than the use of others; again, even though the codons used might be different, the amino acid sequence, and thus the protein produced, is exactly the same. What isn’t entirely clear to me is when the decision to use the optimized codons referred to was made. There is an article I found dating back to May 2020 that states:
Nucleoside modified mRNA (modRNA) candidate encoding an optimized SARS-CoV-2 full-length spike protein antigen. COMIRNATY is the lead candidate of the Pfizer/BioNTech BNT162 program, which includes another modRNA candidate that encodes an optimized SARS-CoV-2 receptor-binding domain (RBD) antigen antigen; a uridine containing mRNA (uRNA) candidate; and a candidate using self-amplifying mRNA (saRNA). The other candidates are known as BNT162a1, BNT162b1, and BNT162c2.
This article uses Comirnaty and BNT162b2 interchangeably, using the term “COMIRNATY® (BNT162b2)” in the title. Moreover, the entry in Drugbank states:
The Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine (also known as BNT162b2, Tozinameran, and Comirnaty), is one of four advanced mRNA-based vaccines developed through “Project Lightspeed,” a joint program between Pfizer and BioNTech.
And this makes it clear that Comirnaty and BNT162b2 are one in the same vaccine:
On July 1, 2020, the manuscript describing the preliminary clinical data for BNT162 was available online for scientific peer-review for potential publication.
On July 27, 2020, the Companies advanced nucleoside-modRNA candidate BNT162b2, which encodes an optimized SARS-CoV-2 full-length spike glycoprotein, at a 30µg dose level, in a 2-dose regimen, into Phase 2/3 study of up to 30,000 participants aged 18 – 85 years, and is expected to include approximately 120 sites globally.
And this report in USA Today:
The Food and Drug Administration issued full authorization Monday for the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine. Soon, millions of Americans will face a confusing, difficult task: How in the heck do you pronounce Comirnaty?
That’s the brand name for the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine. It’s pronounced “co-MER-na-tee” according to Scott Piergrossi, president of creative for the Brand Institute, which crafted the name.
It’s a little easier to say than BNT162b2, the research name of the vaccine while it was first being studied, but not much.
I predict that other antivaxxers will make an attempt to quote mine that part of the FDA letter to imply that Comirnaty is chemically different than BNT162b2, but it’s not. BNT162b2 is Comirnaty, and Comirnaty is just the trade name for BNT162b2. Not that that will stop conspiracy theorists.
The bottom line
The conspiracy theories being spread by the likes of Robert Malone, RFK Jr., and Greg Hunter (among many other antivaxxers and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists) falsely claiming that the FDA never really approved the Pfizer vaccine with a full BLA are just that—conspiracy theories. They’re predicated on a misunderstanding or intentional misrepresentation—take your pick—of EUAs versus full FDA approvals, such as the BLA issued for Comirnaty. From what I’ve been able to gather, legally the FDA, if it wanted to keep the Pfizer vaccine available to children aged 12-15 and to keep allowing immunosuppressed people to receive a third “booster” dose of the vaccine, it had to act the way that it did. Moreover, although the Pfizer BioNTech vaccines under two names (Comirnaty or BNT162b2 or just the “Pfizer vaccine”) are legally distinct, they have the same formulation. They are the same vaccine.
        ◦ Unfortunately, this conspiracy theory sounds very convincing. It even had me scratching my head for a while; that is, until I started doing some digging. The bottom line is that the FDA and press are not lying. The Pfizer vaccine is fully FDA-approved.

Vaccines Don’t Save Lives
Fostering basic critical thinking skills and countering medical misinformation is a vital undertaking.
Jonathan Howard on May 20, 2022
Link

“I wish we had somehow seen that coming”
Okay, I apologize for the clickbait headline. But it’s true. Vaccines don’t save lives, vaccination does. A vaccine rotting in a freezer doesn’t help anyone, and sadly, millions of vaccine doses have done just that. The consequences have been horrific. A recent analysis estimated that over 300,000 lives could have been saved had every eligible adult been vaccinated in the USA. Misinformation is one of the leading causes of death and suffering in America today.
The researchers behind this analysis diagnosed the problem astutely.
“The vaccine rollout has been both a remarkable success and a remarkable failure,” says Stefanie Friedhoff, a professor at the Brown School of Public Health, and one of the analysis’s authors. It was a success, she says, in the sense that “the United States was first in getting those vaccines developed and making doses available at high numbers quickly to the public.”
A lot of money and energy was invested in the logistics of the rollout – the supply side of the equation. Much less was invested in encouraging vaccine demand, she says.
“We did not start early on with information campaigns about why vaccines are important – what do they do for us?” she says. “We underestimated dramatically the investment it would take to get people familiarized with vaccines because, by and large, we haven’t had a deadly disease like this, so people have become estranged from the important impact of vaccination.”
She’s right. Our public health leaders also recognized the problem of misinformation, including from doctors, though only after it was much too late. According to one news article:
Outgoing NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins reflects about what could have been done differently in the nation’s battle against COVID-19. He tells Ali Velshi that vaccine hesitancy was drastically underestimated in the rush to get a viable vaccine approved. 66 million Americans remain unvaccinated, leading to more daily deaths, says Collins. “I wish we had somehow seen that coming and come up with some kind of a myth-buster approach.”
Not everyone was so naïve
So, who could possible have predicted this?
Well, not everyone was so naïve. Some people saw “that coming”. Evidence for this comes from the start of the pandemic when a doctor asked on Twitter, “So, are there still anti-vaxxers out there?” Our own Dr. David Gorski replied, “Yes. A lot of them. They’re forming an unholy alliance with #COVID19 deniers.” Dr. Gorski also linked to an article he had written titled, “COVID-19 Pandemic Deniers and the Antivaccine Movement: An Unholy Alliance.” In this article, Dr. Gorski said:
I fear that this alliance between COVID-19 cranks with the antivaccine movement, with its cross-fertilization of rhetoric and tactics, particularly when fueled by funding and support from various political groups pushing to “reopen America”, has the potential to make the pandemic so much worse than it had to be.
Though this is exactly what happened, I suspect that if Dr. Gorski were to be asked about this article now, he would likely say he underestimated the problem. He even expressed a faint glimmer of hope that the pandemic might marginalize the anti-vaccine movement. Instead, anti-vaccine beliefs are now baked into large swaths of American society, and the consequences of this are bound to extend beyond COVID.
Of course, pretty much everyone underestimated how much damage misinformation would cause this pandemic. Even those of us who correctly predicted a “deluge of misinformation about the Covid vaccines” were caught off guard, both by the scope of the misinformation and especially its source. It wasn’t just the usual quacks and cranks who claimed that COVID was overblown and that vaccination, especially for children, was either unnecessary or harmful. This message was relentlessly pushed by influential doctors at Harvard, UCSF, Johns Hopkins, and Stanford, none of who actually treated a sick child this pandemic.
I urge you to read Dr. Gorski’s article and compare it to those written by contrarian doctors at that time. Their early articles claimed the virus was much less deadly than feared and speculated that it might kill 10,000 Americans. They lamented that, “School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease”. That’s right, they felt that uninfected children were a problem, and even though the virus has since killed 1,500 children and hospitalized many thousands more, they haven’t deviated from this message.
Imagine that.
Sadly, these doctors greatly influenced our pandemic response. The Trump administration echoed their “plan” to reach herd immunity through mass infection, and Florida adopted anti-vaccine policies based on their misinformation. At the individual level, millions of people refused vaccination because they were falsely pacified about the dangers of the virus. According to one leader of a public health outreach organization in West Virginia, her pleas for vaccination “were overpowered by national voices denying the seriousness of COVID-19 or saying that herd immunity was imminent”.
Readers of SBM will be very familiar with national voices who denied the seriousness of COVID-19 and said that herd immunity was imminent. Bold declarations that “For people younger than 45, the infection fatality rate is almost 0%” and that “We’ll have herd immunity by April” had real-world consequences it turns out, though of course the doctors who made these erroneous pronouncements were sheltered from them. I urge you to read some stories of people, including many young people, who regret not getting vaccinated because they didn’t think COVID would be a big deal for someone like them. For example, according to one news report,
Tamra Demello had been begging her son Tyler Gilreath to get the COVID-19 vaccine for months. And for months, the 20-year-old resisted getting the shot, telling his mother he was young, healthy and didn’t have any pre-existing conditions, and therefore he didn’t need the vaccine’s protection.
As you can imagine, Tyler died from COVID as have thousands of other youngsters who thought they were invulnerable to the virus.
Unfortunately, it seems that many people prefer to listen to doctors who tell them what they want to hear, and some doctors are perfectly content to make wildly optimistic predictions for access and exposure. They know there will be coveted TV interviews and open doors to politicians’ offices as long as they keep saying only elderly people have any risk, herd immunity has arrived, and we don’t need to worry about variants. They’ve said exactly this for at least the past year.
In contrast, Dr. Gorski’s prescient warning went largely unheeded, a recurring theme this pandemic.
“The key is not to change the mind of current anti-vaxxers, but to educate the next generation”
Though no one anticipated the problem of misinformation would be this bad, some of us have been sounding the alarm bell about medical quackery for years. We knew that even seemingly harmless practices like cupping can’t be disentangled from more pernicious medical misinformation, nor can they be separated from broader disinformation movements. There are no vaccine advocates amongst QAnon adherents.
I also responded to the doctor who asked if “there still anti-vaxxers out there” by saying,
A virus reeking havoc on the world won’t affect any dedicated anti-vaxxer. Think about it this way- there’s no combination of words you can say to convince me chocolate tastes bad. The key is not to change the mind of current anti-vaxxers, but to educate the next generation.
I stand by this. Though we can’t reach the most fervent anti-vaxxers, we can reach many people and hopefully limit the next generation of anti-vaxxers. One of the chief lessons of the pandemic is that fostering basic critical thinking skills and countering medical misinformation is not a waste of time. It fact, it’s a vital undertaking.
After all, vaccines don’t save lives, vaccination does.
Some of us knew this already, and many thousands of Americans might be alive today if more people had understood this fact.

When Will We Need a COVID Vaccine Booster?
COVID vaccine boosters are not needed yet, but scientists are following the data.
Steven Novella on July 14, 2021
Link

As the first crop of people to be fully vaccinated are reaching the 6 month mark, the question is increasingly coming up regarding if and when we should get a third booster shot. There is some mixed messaging in the media, which is partly due to the fact that there is no definitive answer so far. But let’s review where we are.
There are two reasons why a booster shot might be helpful or even necessary to maintain immunity. The first is that immunity often wanes after vaccination. Immunity is not always fully maintained for a lifetime. The second is that as new variants arise they may not be as well covered by existing vaccines, and so boosters can be formulated to cover emerging variants. Do either of these factors require a booster to maintain adequate immunity, and if so for which vaccines? The short answer is – not yet, but we may be getting close.
Evidence for maintaining immunity so far is good. There are basic ways to measure immunity. One is to look for markers of immunity in the body, such as measuring circulating antibodies or B-cell function. The other (more direct way) is to measure the risk of contracting COVID-19. A study published in Nature in June 2021 found that B-cell markers of immunity persist at high levels in people who received either mRNA vaccine (Pfizer or Moderna) after 12 weeks, concluding:
Our studies demonstrate that SARS-CoV-2 mRNA-based vaccination of humans induces a persistent germinal centre B cell response, which enables the generation of robust humoral immunity.
A study published in The NEJM in June looked at antibody levels in people following the second dose of the Moderna vaccine. They found persistent neutralizing antibodies at 6 months. They also estimated the half-life of the antibodies by looking at the curves over time. Using two different methods they estimated the half-life of neutralizing antibodies to be 69 and 173 days. 
Antibodies appear to persist for at least 6 months, and may remain for much longer beyond that, but how long does the actual protection last? In April Pfizer published data that indicates those fully vaccinated with the Pfizer vaccine had 91.3% efficacy after six months, with 100% protection from severe disease (as defined by the CDC). This data led the Pfizer CEO to announce that their vaccine is good for at least six months, but they cannot guarantee protection after that. That is not the same as saying it does not provide protection, only that we don’t yet have data beyond six months.
What about emerging variants, such as the delta variant? The good news is that the existing vaccines appear to cover this variant. They are especially effective at preventing serious disease resulting in hospitalization or death. However, there is some early data to indicate that they are not as effective.
For example, a study from the UK found that one dose of the Pfizer vaccine was only 34% effective against the delta variant, and 84% after two doses. This contrasts to 80% and 95% respectively for older variants. Data is similar with other variants. For example, this NEJM study finds that overall protection from the beta variant is 20% less than the protection indicated in the clinical trials, but protection from severe illness and hospitalization remained at 90%.
For the existing variants, therefore, total protection from infection is reduced, but protection from severe illness remains high. This is good news for those who are vaccinated, but suggests the current vaccines may be less able to prevent spread of the newer variants of COVID. This is concerning as new waves of infection are spreading around the globe.
What is the bottom line of all this? One lesson is obvious – get fully vaccinated. For the 2-dose mRNA vaccines, one dose is better than nothing but it is not enough. As new deadlier and more contagious variants are spreading, one thing is extremely clear from all the data, the vaccines protect very well against severe disease, including hospitalization and death.
Regarding booster shots, a recent joint CDC/FDA statement sums it up accurate. The evidence so far indicates that vaccine boosters are not necessary at this time. They are continuing to monitor the effectiveness of the vaccines going forward.
The WHO has a different perspective, although this is more politics than science. Two days ago the Director-General criticized plans by vaccine producers to produce booster shots.
“We’re making conscious choices right now not to protect those in most need,” Tedros said in Geneva.
He is concerned about wealthy countries topping off their COVID immunity while poorer nations have not yet received their first dose. While this is a valid point, the two priorities are not mutually exclusive. Developing new versions of the vaccines to cover emerging variants will help everyone, as it will help reduce the duration of this pandemic. We should do this while stepping up efforts to vaccinate the world, and when newer versions of the vaccines become available those updated vaccines should be the ones distributed. So again, everyone can potentially benefit from developing vaccines that cover emerging variants.
We also have to keep in mind that as newer variants, such as the delta variant, become dominant, we will eventually see variants of those variants. The virus will slowly mutate away from the existing vaccines, and we will have to keep up.
In terms of waning immunity, that needs to be followed, but the data we have so far indicates it should be good for at least a year. We obviously won’t know for sure until we get a year out from the first people to be fully vaccinated. So while scientists are not yet willing to say anything definitive, the expectation is that an annual booster shot is likely. This will extend high levels of immunity, and can cover new variants as they emerge. This will likely mean that we will all get our annual COVID shot along with our annual flu shot, which is very practical.
But official recommendations will have to wait until we get one year data.

Third Dose Prevents Infection
The evidence is in. Booster shots work.
Steven Novella on November 3, 2021
Link

We seem to be on the other side of the delta wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, but the pandemic overall is far from over. The world has just surpassed 5 million dead from the illness, although the true number, especially if we consider all downstream consequences, is likely much higher. We have probably not seen the last of new variants. Expert opinion seems to be moving in the direction that it is likely COVID-19 will become endemic, like the flu, and that we will have to deal with chronically.
The good news, of course, is that we have many highly effective vaccines. This good news is mitigated by irrational anti-vaccine propaganda, and we will have to keep up the fight against that as well. There is also a little bit of a debate about how necessary a third dose or booster shot is, and if countries with early vaccination programs should be prioritizing boosters or getting the rest of the world vaccinated. The official US position is that we will do both, with a pledge of 1 billion doses donated in 2022.
Some recent evidence helps inform this decision, confirming the effectiveness of a third dose for those vaccines that originally required two doses. One study, published recently in The Lancet, is the largest observational study of vaccine effectiveness for COVID-19 to date. The study is based on a large public dataset from Israel, which was one of the earliest countries to achieve high levels of vaccination. The study had two arms, those who had received a third dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine at least 7 days prior, and those who had received only two doses with the second dose at least 5 months prior. Each arm had 728,321 demographically matched individuals. The observational period, from July 30, 2020 to Sept. 23, 2021, was during a wave dominated by the delta variant.
The study found that, compared to those who received two doses, there was a 93% decrease in infections, a 95% decrease in hospitalizations, a 92% decrease in severe disease, and an 81% decrease in COVID-related deaths. The study also included a population-level evaluation. They found that 7-10 days following each age group becoming eligible for a third dose, infection rates began to drop in that age group. This is overall impressive vaccine efficacy, and remarkable when compared to those with only two doses at least five months earlier. This is strong evidence in favor of giving a third dose.
Another study out of Oxford, currently in preprint, looked at rates of transmission with both the alpha variant and delta variant following two doses of either the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine or the AstraZeneca vaccine. This is a retrospective cohort study looking at contact tracing for those with positive tests for COVID-19, comparing the fully vaccinated (two doses) with unvaccinated individuals. They found that the Pfizer vaccine reduced transmission of the alpha variant with an odds ratio of 0.18, while AstraZeneca had an odds ratio of 0.37. For the delta variant the numbers were 0.35 and 0.64 respectively.
Therefore, both vaccines reduced the chances of spreading COVID-19 (not just getting it), although not as much for the delta variant. They also found that this risk reduction waned over time, giving more evidence in support of a third dose.
Until recently scientists for organizations like the CDC were saying that the evidence for the need of a third dose is “weak”. Early evidence was based entirely on antibody titers, with studies showing that these titers do decrease over time from completion of vaccination. However, it was not clear whether these declining antibody levels would translate to decreased clinical effectiveness. Of course, it was both highly plausible and anticipated that titers and immunity would correlate, but scientists were being honest in saying that we did not know for sure. This was also happening during the most recent wave of the pandemic dominated by the delta variant. In the face of spiking case numbers and waning antibody numbers, many countries opted for booster shots.
Now we have good data that this calculated expense paid off. Giving a third dose or booster shot of any of the COVID-19 vaccines reduces the risk of getting infected, getting a severe illness, being hospitalized, and dying. Further, it reduces the chance of passing the illness along to contacts, probably from reduced viral loads (although this does not explain all of the reduction in risk of transmission). In light of this there is now a very strong case to be made for offering booster shots, and anyone eligible should avail themselves of the extra immunity.
The benefits are both individual and societal. The individual benefits are obvious from the numbers above – reduced risk of dying is a huge benefit. But even for those who would not have died, severe illness and hospitalization results in significant morbidity and the possibility of long COVID with significant reduction in quality of life and productivity.
Further, getting fully vaccinated clearly protects those around you. The flip side of this is that failing to get vaccinated puts your family and friends at unnecessary risk. At the societal level, reducing transmission and infection rates is the best way of bringing this pandemic under control (even if it does become endemic). Reduced infections will reduce the probability of new variants emerging, that could spawn entirely new waves of illness. Reducing hospitalizations has a profound effect on the use of hospital resources, including front-line workers. This is one of the hard-to-quantify results of the pandemic, those who suffered because they could not get their elective surgery, or who avoided the ER or could not get an ICU bed because of COVID patients.
        ◦ In the middle of a pandemic like COVID, individual decisions affect everyone.

Vaccines Vaccines and more Vaccines
COVID vaccines are dominating the health news, and with good reason.
Steven Novella on August 25, 2021
Link

Vaccines are dominating the health news recently and with good reason. We are now more than a year and a half into the worst pandemic in a century. By now vaccines should be shutting down COVID-19 and life should be returning to normal, but instead we are in the middle of one of the worst waves yet. The delta variant is running rampant, even in countries that previously managed the pandemic well. Children are increasingly being affected, and researchers are learning more about the long term health effects of SARS-CoV-2. Experts warn the virus is likely to become endemic. What happened?
There are now 112 different COVID vaccines either available or in clinical development. There are a further 184 vaccines in pre-clinical development. Science, in short, has done its job. Two of the vaccines available in the US, Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna, are incredibly safe and effective, with few serious side effects and efficacy in the 90-95% range. Companies are collectively cranking out billions of doses. Worldwide 24.8% of all people have been fully vaccinated, with 32.9% receiving at least one dose. Almost 34 million doses are being administered daily.
But this is not the whole picture. Despite the success of scientific researchers, politically and socially we have collectively failed. Only 1.4% of those living in poor countries have received even one dose of vaccine. This allows the virus to spread and new variants to emerge. Meanwhile, in some wealthy countries, vaccine doses are expiring on the shelves because of vaccine hesitancy. Refusal to get vaccinated, even at this stage of the pandemic, results from massive anti-vaccine misinformation spreading online, and the fact that the vaccines and COVID in general have been politicized by one major political party. Trump himself was booed by some of his own fans when he mildly recommended getting vaccinated, and quickly backpedaled.
Here are a few items of vaccine news and controversies we are dealing with currently.
Booster Shots
Since the beginning of the vaccine campaign the looming question has been – how long with immunity last (from infection or vaccination) and when will booster shots be necessary. For some vaccines that answer is now emerging. In one UK study they found that immunity from Pfizer and AstraZeneca vaccines began waning over six months. Moderna announced that immunity from its vaccine holds through six months, but they feel that boosters will become necessary in order to maintain efficacy against the delta variant.
This is the concerning combination – waning immunity and rising variants not fully covered by the vaccine. As a result, in a joint statement released by the CDC, US health experts say they plan to start offering booster shots this Fall. Those who are immunocompromised can already receive a third dose. Moderna has studied their own booster shot and report that it is effective against the delta variant.
I should note that even with waning immunity, the vaccines all protect against severe illness. Almost all hospitalized patients with COVID are unvaccinated. But there are increased breakthrough milder symptomatic infections, and this allows the virus to spread.
Meanwhile the World Health Organization is warning against booster shots. They argue that all doses should be going to the unvaccinated before anyone receives a booster. They have a fair point, both from a perspective of justice and also practicality. New variants emerging in poor countries can spread around the world. In response, in that CDC statement, US health officials pledge:
“We will also continue to expand our efforts to increase the supply of vaccines for other countries, building further on the more than 600 million doses we have already committed to donate globally.”
India Approves First DNA Vaccine
Recently India approved a new vaccine for COVID, and the first DNA vaccine approved for humans. The vaccine is called ZyCoV-D, it is a three-dose vaccine, and it reported provides 66% protection from symptomatic infection. This is India’s second approved vaccine, and they plan on producing 120 million doses per year.
DNA vaccines are similar to the mRNA vaccines in that they introduce genetic instructions to make the COVID spike protein, which will then provoke an immune response. But there are some differences. DNA is introduced as a plasmid and, unlike the mRNA vaccines, the plasmid must get to the nucleus of the cell. This has been a limiting factor in the past. DNA vaccines work well in animals, but so far have not worked well in humans because of this limitation. As a result the immunity produced, while good, is not as strong as the mRNA vaccines. The ZyCoV-D vaccine also requires three doses.
But the vaccine has one significant advantage – it keeps well at much higher temperatures, only requiring -2 to 8 degrees C for storage. It will also keep for three months at room temperature. This compares favorably to Pfizer (-80 to -60 degrees C) and Moderna (-25 to -15 degrees C). The vaccine has also been tested favorably in 12-18 year-olds. Finally the vaccine is being offered with a needle-less injection. A fine stream of water injects the plasmid through the skin where it can be absorbed by the cells. This DNA COVID vaccine is not likely to be a revolution in vaccines, and overall the mRNA technology seems superior. But it is noteworthy that this is the first human DNA vaccine, and the advantage of not needing a cold-chain for distribution might prove useful in some locations.
Vaccine Hesitancy and Mandates
In a bit of good news, the FDA has given full approval to the Pfizer vaccine for COVID. It is anticipated the Moderna’s approval is close behind (they were a bit slower in submitting all the necessary paperwork). There is also pressure to extend approval for all three US vaccine to the pediatric population, especially as the delta variant seems to be more infectious and serious in children.
FDA approval removes one of the objections that many vaccine-hesitant individuals cite as the reason for not getting the vaccine. While this excuse was never valid (often it was stated that the vaccines were experimental, but this was not true), it is expected that the approval will result in millions more people getting vaccinated. Vaccine uptake is also betting a boost (pun intended) from the severity of the delta variant. Some people are finally getting more scared of COVID than the vaccine (which they should be).
The controversy of the day is now this – to what extent should we mandate vaccines? In my opinion, mandating vaccinations is completely ethical and justified. We have done this already for decades, with children requiring vaccination to attend school. What it typically meant by a vaccine “mandate” (and what I personally endorse) is not forced vaccination, but rather granting privileges based on vaccine status. Essentially, if you don’t want to get a vaccine to protect against COVID that is your right, but society has the right to exclude you from activities that put others at risk as a result of your decision. You don’t have the right to infect other people.
In a practical sense, this would make the lives of the unvaccinated more difficult and inconvenient. Getting on a plane, going to a movie theater or other mass gathering, and going to school should all require proof of vaccination. Insurance companies would also be justified in charging a premium for those who can get vaccinated but choose not to. In essence, vaccine refusers are making the lives of everyone else less convenient and more expensive, and that burden should be turned back around on them as much as possible.
I would also note that refusing to get vaccinated (without a legitimate medical excuse) is objectively wrong. The benefits of getting vaccinated outweigh the risks by orders of magnitude, and refusers justify their decision with demonstrable misinformation. This is not a matter of opinion – their facts are wrong.
At this point we likely need a federal law, to override those states that outlaw vaccine mandates for schools or private companies. We tried to beat this pandemic with purely voluntary vaccination, and we failed. Vaccine mandates are now our best choice.

COVID Vaccines Probably Prevent Spread
The evidence is preliminary, but it looks like the COVID vaccines do reduce the risk of spread of SARS-CoV-2.
Steven Novella on March 10, 2021
Link
The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) recently published their updated recommendations for precautions by people who are fully vaccinated against COVID-19. They needed to review available data on the efficacy of the available vaccines in the US – Pfizer and Moderna; J&J is just coming out. Their recommendations are welcome news to those who are fully vaccinated, which means you have received your second dose of vaccine more than two weeks ago (it take up to two weeks for the antibodies to fully form).
Their recommendations are, in non-health care settings, and for those who are not at high risk:
    • Visit with other fully vaccinated people indoors without wearing masks or physical distancing
    • Visit with unvaccinated people from a single household who are at low risk for severe COVID-19 disease indoors without wearing masks or physical distancing
    • Refrain from quarantine and testing following a known exposure if asymptomatic
Hopefully this will be further incentive for those on the fence to get vaccinated. This is a concrete manifestation of the ability of the vaccines to return life to something close to pre-pandemic normal. But – what took the CDC so long to make these recommendations? Could these not have been made once the vaccines were given emergency use authorization based on evidence of safety and efficacy? The delay is mostly because the evidence of efficacy only looked at the prevention of illness, not the prevention of being an asymptomatic carrier of the virus. Theoretically, someone who is fully vaccinated and protected about 95% from getting sick with COVID-19 could still catch the virus and pass it on to someone else, without even having any symptoms. The CDC wanted independent evidence that the vaccines also prevent spread.
What is the a-prior likelihood that the vaccines reduce spread? Pretty high. These vaccines work by provoking an antibody response that will attack the virus before it has a chance to produce a serious infection. Efficacy is therefore tied to reduced viral load, which in turn will affect how much virus is shed by infected individuals, and therefore how contagious they are. The real question is – how much do the vaccines reduce spread? It would be surprising if they didn’t reduce spread at all. But it is theoretically possible that they do not reduce spread sufficiently to change pandemic recommendations for mask wearing and social distancing.
Studies for the H1N1 flu vaccine, for example, show that they reduce shedding of virus and delay but do not completely eliminate transmission to unvaccinated subjects.
How does this impact herd immunity? The more the vaccines prevent spread, the easier it will be to achieve herd immunity, the point at which the virus can no longer spread through a population because there are not enough susceptible hosts. Vaccines do not need to completely prevent spread to produce herd immunity, but this will affect the percentage of the population that needs to be vaccinated before herd immunity is achieved.
With these unknowns, the CDC was being cautious in keeping full pandemic precautions in place until we had sufficient data on the effects of the vaccines in the real world. They also were waiting for the total new infections to drop significantly before backing off on precautions. What is the current evidence for the ability of the COVID-19 vaccines to prevent spread?
In the original studies used to show efficacy of the Moderna vaccine, they also gathered secondary data on the prevention of asymptomatic infections. They found:
Amongst baseline negative participants, 14 in the vaccine group and 38 in the placebo group had evidence of SARS-CoV-2 infection at the second dose without evidence of COVID-19 symptoms. There were approximately 2/3 fewer swabs that were positive in the vaccine group as compared to the placebo group at the pre-dose 2 timepoint, suggesting that some asymptomatic infections start to be prevented after the first dose.
That is a 2/3 reduction in positive nasal swabs for SARS-CoV-2 after the first dose, which means the protection is likely to be much higher after the second dose. This is solid evidence that the Moderna vaccine reduces the risk not only of the disease but asymptomatic infection, and therefore spread.
There are also two studies of the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine after release. In a UK study involving hospital workers they did not look at reported symptomatic disease but data from nasal swabs using a PCR test for viral infection.
A single dose of BNT162b2 vaccine demonstrated vaccine effectiveness of 72% (95% CI 58-86) 21 days after first dose and 86% (95% CI 76-97) seven days after two doses in the antibody negative cohort.
Therefore that 86% reduction after the second dose includes a reduction in asymptomatic cases, and therefore this is a reduction in the total number of people who can spread the virus, not just those who report symptoms. There is also an Israeli study, reported but not yet published, which found:
Meanwhile, a press released on a pre-published, not-yet-peer-reviewed paper from the Israeli Health Ministry and Pfizer found that the vaccine appeared to reduce all coronavirus infections—including asymptomatic infections—by 89.4% and symptomatic infections by 93.7%.
This same study found that viral loads decreased after vaccine doses. None of this is surprising – the vaccines are working as predicted by their mechanism of action. Again, the only question was a matter of degree. We now have solid but preliminary evidence that the first two vaccines released in the US not only prevent disease, they also significantly prevent spread. But of course, researchers want more data. This is a critical question, and will guide future recommendations for pandemic prevention and our understanding of what it will take to achieve herd immunity.
As has been said throughout this pandemic – we are building the plane as we are flying it. This is a novel coronavirus, these are new vaccines, and we are learning as we are going. Gathering data in the world (not just the lab) in real time is critical, but it takes time to gather and analyze data. Meanwhile we need recommendations. It is understandable, then, that the CDC erred on the side of caution in relaxing their recommendations for the fully vaccinated, but the data now supports them. They will also continue to monitor the pandemic and evidence of vaccine efficacy in preventing spread and update their recommendations accordingly.
There is reason for optimism, however. The vaccine are extremely effective in preventing death, hospitalization, and symptomatic illness. They now also appear to be effective in preventing asymptomatic spread, but certainly more data will be useful. This bodes well for the potential of the vaccines to achieve herd immunity, as long as there is sufficient vaccine uptake. In a way, the scientists have done their job and now it is up to the public to do theirs.
We are also in a race against time to get this pandemic under control before new variants emerge that can evade existing vaccines. There is a real risk that COVID-19 might become endemic in the human population, or that we will need periodic vaccine updates to cover new strains. We may have a window of opportunity to prevent that if we get as many people vaccinated as quickly as possible, and maintain pandemic precautions until it is truly safe to relax them.

The Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine doesn’t prevent transmission: Antivax disinformation goes viral again
Last week, antivaxxers were all over social media after Tucker Carlson touted a “revelation” that the phase 3 clinical trial used to support licensure of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine didn’t examine its ability to block transmission as meaning that its inability to block transmission had been “covered up”. It wasn’t, and antivaxxers are ignoring everything we’ve learned over the last two years to make the claim that vaccines “don’t prevent transmission”.
David Gorski on October 17, 2022
Link

Last week there appeared to have been large increase in antivaccine activity on social media, in particular Twitter. I know this mainly because others whom I follow mentioned it, and a certain talking point kept bubbling up to the surface about the Pfizer clinical trial not having tested for the ability of its COVID-19 vaccine to prevent transmission of SARS-CoV-2, which was somehow some sort of horrific oversight that invalidates everything about the vaccine. The whole thing appears to have bubbled up after Rob Roos, a member of the European Parliament, started agitating about vaccine mandates based on this:
🚨 BREAKING:
In COVID hearing, #Pfizer director admits: #vaccine was never tested on preventing transmission.
"Get vaccinated for others" was always a lie.
The only purpose of the #COVID passport: forcing people to get vaccinated.
The world needs to know. Share this video! ⤵️ pic.twitter.com/su1WqgB4dO
— Rob Roos MEP 🇳🇱 (@Rob_Roos) October 11, 2022
It didn’t take long the usual amplifiers of antivaccine misinformation in the media to run with this, including Tucker Carlson:
Dutch MP of the European Parlement, Rob Roos, at the Tucker Carlson Show:
"Pfizer admits the Cov¡d vaccine's ability to prevent transmission was never tested"https://t.co/AfXHYwNtws pic.twitter.com/JSRP8zDccF
— Leander (@LeanderWoltinge) October 12, 2022
Antivaxxers were off to the races after this, trumpeting the “revelation” that Pfizer never tested its vaccine to determine if it prevented transmission in its phase 3 clinical trials used by the FDA to issue an emergency use authorization (EUA) for the vaccine in December 2020 and how that failure means that vaccine mandates were always illegitimate right for the beginning.
Antivaxxers and a tsunami of messaging over the last week
Before I explain why this particular line of antivax disinformation is, well, disinformation, I thought I’d include some examples of how it was being spun other than the Tweets above. I’ll start with the antivax and COVID-19 conspiracy site The Epoch Times by way of Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.:
A Pfizer executive said Monday that neither she nor other Pfizer officials knew whether its COVID-19 vaccine would stop transmission before entering the market last year.
Member of the European Parliament, Rob Roos, asked during a session:
Was the Pfizer COVID vaccine tested on stopping the transmission of the virus before it entered the market? Did we know about stopping immunization before it entered the market?
Pfizer’s Janine Small, president of international developed markets, said in response:
No … You know, we had to … really move at the speed of science to know what is taking place in the market.
Roos, of the Netherlands, argued in a Twitter video Monday that following Small’s comments to him, millions of people around the world were duped by pharmaceutical companies and governments.
“Millions of people worldwide felt forced to get vaccinated because of the myth that ‘you do it for others,'” Roos said. “Now, this turned out to be a cheap lie” and “should be exposed,” he added.
Meanwhile, the usual suspects were posting apocalyptic Substacks, for instance Paul Alexander (who, as an advisor to Health and Human Services assistant secretary for public affairs Michael Caputo, noted in a summer 2020 email advocating a Great Barrington Declaration-like “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, “we want them infected“) wrote a post titled “Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche and Dr. Paul Elias Alexander discuss Pfizer’s failure to test COVID vaccines for transmission, the need for population chemoprophylaxis, and recommendations for the vaccinated“. (I like how Alexander uses his full name, including middle name. Who does that?) Regular readers will remember that Geert Vanden Bossche is a veterinarian who made a name for himself fear mongering about mass vaccination during a pandemic in March 2021 because—or so he claimed—imperfect vaccines would drive the emergence of “escape mutants” that could evade prior immunity due to vaccination, ignoring observations that it is the number of people being infected, far more than vaccination, that leads to the emergence of variants that could evade prior immunity, and that these variants could evade prior immunity due to vaccines or previous infection, not just vaccines.
Unsurprisingly, Alexander went on to use that “failure” to start “just asking questions” (a.k.a. JAQing off) about the vaccine, writing “Pfizer (and Moderna) & FDA, the UNHOLIST of alliances, corrupted to the very core, did not test if the COVID gene injection stopped transmission? What else did they not test for? Dr. Koops weighs in“:
Pfizer and Moderna also:
-did not test whether there were any serious drug interactions with other commonly used medicines/vaccines.
-did not test whether there were genetic mutations in the host
-did not test whether the “vaccine” became systemic or stayed restricted to the injection site
-did not test whether “boosters” were actually beneficial (they simply stated that as the initial protocol as a two dose protocol without any data to support it)
-did not test whether the “non-active” ingredients caused any problems (these were not normal excipients-some of the placebo arm data suggests that these were also causing problems)
-did not test whether the “vaccine” was transmissible from the recipient
-did not test as to metabolic elimination of the vaccine from the host, i.e. how long does it remain active in the host
-proposed a product specification that would essentially allow for almost anything to pass
-did not account (i.e. screen) for a rather pronounced natural immunity already in the population
-conducted most of their studies outside of the US in countries that have been known for questionable clinical studies (Brazil in particular)
-had virtually no stability data
One notes that we’ve addressed a number of these claims before; so I will not address them again, except to note a couple of common tropes. As for “natural immunity already in the population”, remember that the Pfizer vaccine was tested in the summer and fall of 2020, before a huge percentage of the population had become infected. Similarly, the mRNA-based vaccines produced by Pfizer and Moderna do not “permanently alter your DNA,” contrary to Alexander’s other claim.
Elsewhere, “health freedom groups” trumpeted “We tried to warn you“, while James Lyons-Weiler proclaimed, “Knowledge About Lack of Protection Against Transmission is Old, Not New“. Indeed it’s not, as we will show (and as even The Epoch Times article acknowledged), nor is it shocking. Lyons-Weiler tries to spin this as:
The admission by a Pfizer exec has set social media ablaze with shock. That’s what you get when you suppress inconvenient truths. Now the flawed policies must be reversed or rescinded.
That’s right! Antivaxxers are treating this “revelation” as some sort of shocking “new” news when its not, and Lyons-Weiler tries to say that the reason they’re doing this is because there was a conspiracy to cover up this “inconvenient truth”. But was there? (I think you know the answer to that.)
Before I get to that question, I’ll note that this isn’t all the antivax content, not by a long shot, seemingly coordinated to amplify the message that the approval of the Pfizer vaccine was illegitimate because it never tested for the ability of the vaccine to prevent transmission. There were, of course, many videos, because there are always antivax videos, from the usual suspects. For example, over at Rumble, Alexander interviewed Vanden Bossche about the same thing, with largely the same claims. COVID vaccine transmission. Meanwhile, John Campbell (whom we’ve met before spreading misinformation about COVID-19 and monkeypox and someone whose misinformation we at SBM should really have discussed more often) treats this “revelation” as something new that had been hidden for nearly two years, introducing his story with the exchange between Robert Roos and Janine Small, Pfizer’s president of international developed markets before describing the revelation as a “breaking international scandal”—and, near the end of his video, a “complete and utter scandal”—that Pfizer did not know whether its vaccine stopped transmission before rollout:
Around 1:27 he goes on about how:
…at the time I remember representatives of the UK government who’ve now been made into Dames and Knights and all sorts of things emphatically telling us that everything that was normally done in any clinical trial was done during these trials. They gave us their word about this, and let’s hope that this doesn’t turn out to be less than accurate.
Susan Oliver did a nice job of deconstructing Campbell’s disinformation, as usual, but I’ll discuss some of it with my spin as well, as my purpose in writing this post is not so much to point out why this whole “shocked” line of hysteria is nothing new and based on intentionally deceptive spin and outright lies, but to look at the history as well, which makes me perfectly happy to point you to sources in addition to my scintillating words to deal with this particular antivax propaganda:
Let’s dig in. First, I think it’s important to address a seemingly simple but poorly understood question: What is the purpose of a vaccine?
The purpose(s) of a vaccine
So what are the purposes of a vaccine, anyway? I say “purposes” because vaccines don’t have just one purpose. First and foremost, the main purpose of a vaccine is to prevent people from becoming seriously ill due to disease caused by a pathogenic microorganism such as a virus or bacterium, period. If a vaccine doesn’t do that, it’s a pretty useless vaccine, particularly in the middle of a pandemic that by late 2020 had killed over a quarter of a million people in the US alone. Ideally, the second purpose of a vaccine is to prevent infection and transmission; i.e., to prevent the pathogenic organism from getting established in a vaccinated host human in the first place and to render that person unable to spread the pathogen to others. This phenomenon is called “sterilizing immunity” and means that the immunity produced by a vaccine is so effective that the virus cannot replicate in the vaccinated individual sufficiently to gain a foothold and cause infection, much less be transmissible by that person to others.
Most vaccines that prevent severe disease also prevent transmission to at least some extent, even if far from being able to produce sterilizing immunity, and vaccines that aren’t very good at preventing infection and transmission, even if they are good at preventing severe illness, are referred to as “leaky”. I discussed this concept in a fair amount of detail when I discussed Geert Vanden Bossche’s claim that, because COVID-19 vaccines are “leaky”, they select for nasty variants in the presence of mild or asymptomatic disease in the vaccinated. I also mentioned how this particular claim is not new among antivaxxers, citing the example of long-time antivaccine activist and scientific fraudster Andrew Wakefield, who made exactly the same claim for the measles vaccine, fear mongering about a sixth “mass extinction” because of the MMR vaccine.
Ironically, I also cited an article published in Scientific American in January 2021 titled “Vaccines Need Not Completely Stop COVID Transmission to Curb the Pandemic“, when the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines were starting to roll out to populations other than healthcare workers and very high risk individuals, that explained that quite a few vaccines that we commonly recommend are not perfect at preventing transmission. It was an excellent article that’s worth revisiting one more time before I discuss the Pfizer clinical trial.
Here’s the key point:
Although many vaccines widely used today (against measles, for example) produce very effective sterilizing immunity, others, such as the hepatitis B vaccine, do not. With these vaccines, an individual’s immune system is trained to prevent illness, yet the pathogen can persist in that person’s body, potentially allowing them to infect others. A lack of sterilizing immunity means that the pathogen can continue to circulate in a population, where it may cause illness in unvaccinated and vulnerable people or evolve to evade our immune responses, Bowdish explains.
And another example:
The case of rotavirus—which causes severe vomiting and watery diarrhea and is especially dangerous to infants and young children—is fairly straightforward. Vaccination limits, but does not stop, the pathogen from replicating. As such, it does not protect against mild disease. By reducing an infected person’s viral load, however, it decreases transmission, providing substantial indirect protection. According to the Centers for Disease Control, four to 10 years after the 2006 introduction of a rotavirus vaccine in the U.S., the number of positive tests for the disease fell by as much as 74 to 90 percent.
Another favorite example frequently cited by antivaxxers before the pandemic is pertussis, because the vaccine doesn’t produce sterilizing immunity:
For example, vaccines against Bordetella pertussis, the primary bacterium that causes whooping cough, or pertussis, do a great job of preventing illness but do not entirely clear the pathogen. Rather, as B. pertussis replicates in the upper respiratory tract, vaccine-induced antibodies apply pressure via natural selection to weed out bacteria whose disease-causing genes are turned on. Because these same genes are responsible for the parts of the microorganisms that are targeted by antibodies, bacteria that keep them turned off evade the immune response and hang out undetected in the upper respiratory tract, Bowdish explains. This becomes a problem when someone with a naive immune system, such as an infant, contracts the pathogen. In the absence of antibodies, B. pertussis‘s disease-causing genes become activated again, causing illness. Nevertheless, the introduction of pertussis vaccines in the 1940s cut annual U.S. cases from more than 100,000 to fewer than 10,000 by 1965. In the 1980s cases began slowly climbing again as parents increasingly refused to vaccinate their children. Today there is renewed focus on reducing the chance of exposure and getting antibodies to infants by immunizing pregnant women and new mothers.
I’ve noted many times that antivaccine “thinking” about vaccines tends to be very black and white. Either the vaccine is 100% effective, or it’s useless crap; the vaccine is either 100% safe, or it’s deadly enough to cause a “vaccine holocaust“; either the vaccine prevents transmission 100% or it “doesn’t stop transmission” at all! Again, in medicine, as in life, nothing is 100% certain except that each and every one of us will one day die, and efficacy for any intervention exists on a spectrum. That’s why, in general, even a nonsterilizing vaccine can be very, very useful. Indeed, in December 2020, even a completely nonsterilizing vaccine that didn’t prevent transmission at all but was effective at preventing severe disease would have helped to prevent enormous numbers of people ending up in the ICU and/or grave.
Before any antivaxxer cries, “Straw man!” out there, I do realize that the main point of this particular conspiracy theory about Pfizer not having tested its vaccine for its ability to prevent transmission is not to claim that it doesn’t prevent severe disease (although, to be sure, antivaxxers do that a lot too) but to call into question the legitimacy of its approval by the UK and EUA in the US, in particular to claim that COVID-19 vaccine mandates were based on no data. I’ll get to that in a minute, but first let’s look at the actual Pfizer trial.
The Pfizer trial
As Susan Oliver (and many others) noted, the results of the phase 3 clinical trial of the Pfizer BNT162b2 mRNA-based vaccine were published in The New England Journal of Medicine on December 31, 2020. It’s right there in the paper’s methods section:
The first primary end point was the efficacy of BNT162b2 against confirmed Covid-19 with onset at least 7 days after the second dose in participants who had been without serologic or virologic evidence of SARS-CoV-2 infection up to 7 days after the second dose; the second primary end point was efficacy in participants with and participants without evidence of prior infection. Confirmed Covid-19 was defined according to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) criteria as the presence of at least one of the following symptoms: fever, new or increased cough, new or increased shortness of breath, chills, new or increased muscle pain, new loss of taste or smell, sore throat, diarrhea, or vomiting, combined with a respiratory specimen obtained during the symptomatic period or within 4 days before or after it that was positive for SARS-CoV-2 by nucleic acid amplification–based testing, either at the central laboratory or at a local testing facility (using a protocol-defined acceptable test).
Major secondary end points included the efficacy of BNT162b2 against severe Covid-19. Severe Covid-19 is defined by the FDA as confirmed Covid-19 with one of the following additional features: clinical signs at rest that are indicative of severe systemic illness; respiratory failure; evidence of shock; significant acute renal, hepatic, or neurologic dysfunction; admission to an intensive care unit; or death. Details are provided in the protocol.
In other words, the primary endpoint for efficacy was clinical, symptomatic disease confirmed by laboratory testing, and the secondary endpoints were efficacy against severe disease, not transmission or asymptomatic infection. Again, it’s all right there in the methods.
It was also in the FDA press release dated December 11, 2020:
At this time, data are not available to make a determination about how long the vaccine will provide protection, nor is there evidence that the vaccine prevents transmission of SARS-CoV-2 from person to person.
Interestingly, the Epoch Times article cited by RFK Jr. specifically quotes the above statement:
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration wrote in late 2020 that there was no data available to determine whether the vaccine would prevent transmission and for how long it would protect against transmission of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes COVID-19.
“At this time, data are not available to make a determination about how long the vaccine will provide protection, nor is there evidence that the vaccine prevents transmission of SARS-CoV-2 from person to person,” the agency specifically noted.
Meanwhile, Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla, around the same time, said his firm was “not certain” if those who receive its mRNA vaccine will be able to transmit COVID-19 to other people.
“I think this is something that needs to be examined. We are not certain about that right now,” Bourla told NBC News in December 2020 in response to a question about transmissibility.
And in a UK guidance document dated June 8, 2021 (thanks to Dr. Oliver without whom I probably wouldn’t have found this one):
Clinical trial evidence demonstrates that the vaccine reduces clinically severe infection and severe disease. The impact of the vaccine on preventing transmission remains unknown and individuals who have been vaccinated may still carry and be able to transmit the virus. We advise anyone who has been vaccinated to continue to observe national lockdown restrictions and engage with asymptomatic LFD and PCR testing if appropriate
Meanwhile, in January 2021, scientists were noting:
Current estimates of the level of effective population immunity for interruption of transmission is ~60–70%, but vaccination coverage required by a partially effective vaccine to interrupt transmission might be higher. With 8 billion people to vaccinate with a two-dose regimen, we might need 10–11 billion doses to interrupt transmission.
In other words, the vaccines were not being sold as a panacea, at least not by the scientific community.
But wait! Antivaxxers will say that this was all buried in clinical trial methods, FDA press releases, and government guidance documents that no one reads! That’s how “they” covered it up! Unfortunately, it’s not hard to find contemporaneous examples of press reporting that did no such thing. For instance, this Washington Post article explained that the trial didn’t look at the ability of the vaccine to prevent transmission:
Major questions that remain unanswered about the vaccine include how long the protection will last and whether the vaccines prevent people who are infected despite vaccination from spreading the disease.
The trial showed no evidence that immunity subsided during the two months after the second dose, but more data will need to be gathered to assess whether protection tapers off. The reviewers called for further study of whether people, particularly those with asymptomatic infections, spread the disease. Epidemiologists have worried about a worst-case scenario in which people who are vaccinated stop wearing masks but may become asymptomatically infected and spread the disease.
“It is possible that if efficacy against asymptomatic infection were lower than efficacy against symptomatic infection, asymptomatic cases in combination with reduced mask-wearing and social distancing could result in significant continued transmission,” the review states.
In other words, it was not kept a secret that, in December 2020 at least, we did not yet know how well (or even if) the Pfizer vaccine could prevent transmission of SARS-CoV-2 because that’s not what the clinical trial was designed to do. Nor, contrary to claims from antivaxxers like Campbell, do most phase 3 trials for vaccines examine transmission as an endpoint to be used for licensure, as Susan Oliver explains in her video, citing trials of various measles and HPV vaccines. To that I’ll add some other vaccine trials, including this one of a rotavirus vaccine in which prevention of transmission was not an endpoint or clinical trials of Rotateq, for which—again!—prevention of transmission was not an endpoint.
Dr. Oliver also very nicely hoisted Campbell on his own petard, including a video from May 2021 (which was before he’d become an antivaxxer), in which he demonstrated that not only did he know why the complaint that the Pfizer trial didn’t assess the ability of its vaccine to block transmission but cited a result from the paper suggesting that the vaccine likely was very effective in actually—you guessed it—blocking transmission:
Best part of @DrSusanOliver1's new video is she found a clip from May 2021 of John Campbell from before he was an antivaxxer demonstrating he knows exactly why the current talking point he's pretending to be outraged about is stupid.
(at 6:55)https://t.co/ZGzT150Kka
— bad_stats 🕜💵🖨️🕣 (@thebadstats) October 15, 2022
Again, the purpose of clinical trials of vaccines is to determine if the vaccine is safe and effective at protecting the recipient against the disease targeted. You might reasonably ask why vaccines are usually not tested for their ability to prevent transmission in phase 3 trials. The answer is fairly simple and two-fold. First, again, the primary purpose of a vaccine is to prevent disease and death from infectious microorganisms. Everything else, including prevention of transmission, is gravy. Second, study designs to identify interruption of pathogen transmission are different than for determining efficacy and safety, which is why they are best carried out during post-licensing surveillance, not during the randomized controlled phase 3 trial for licensure:
Conversely, RCTs might underestimate the protective effect of vaccines at the population level. This would occur if the COVID-19 vaccine, in addition to conferring direct protection to individuals, reduces transmission of COVID-19 between individuals, providing protection to unvaccinated individuals and enhanced protection of vaccinated individuals in contact with vaccinated individuals. Vaccine-induced herd protection, which might be crucial to the public health value of a vaccine, will be missed when trials are individually randomized and analyses fail to take account of the geographical distribution of individuals in the population. Table 1 provides a summary of estimates of the basic reproduction number, herd immunity, efficacy and effectiveness for several vaccine-preventable diseases. The definition of effectiveness might vary by study.
In general, “effectiveness” includes the ability of the vaccine to prevent infection and transmission:
Collection of effectiveness data and understanding indirect protective effects of vaccination will allow countries to make rational plans for maintaining herd protection
Remember, all of this was published around the time the vaccines were introduced and shortly after.
Another bit of antivaccine messaging around the Pfizer trials seeks to impute nefarious intent as Pfizer went from earlier stage clinical trials to its phase 3 trial. Sadly, some of this misinformation showed up in the comments of my not-so-super-secret other blog:
Pfizer’s phase-1/2 trial did indeed study antibodies which is the best gauge for assessing transmission. Binding antibodies was reported for the 45 subjects but crucial neutralizing antibodies was only assesed [sic] for only seven subjects with Pfizer promising that data was forthcoming. I don’t believe it ever got reported before they eventually switched to assessing whether the vaccine prevented symptoms for the phase-3 trial.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32785213/
And then, in another comment of my not-so-secret other blog:
Further to my comment above and speaking of shifting goalposts, the mother of all goalposts shifts occurred when Pfizer moved from studying efficacy of its vaccine by its immunogenicity profile in phase-1/2 to assessing symptoms in phase-3. This goalposts shift went largely unnoticed; drowned out by the thunderous fanfare and jubilation that proceeded the phase-3 trial news that the vaccine was 95% effective at preventing symptoms. And, perhaps the shift would’ve remained inconsequential if the vaccine hadn’t now proven to be ineffective at stopping shit.
Let it be known that it’s not just a case of Pfizer not assessing whether its vaccine is effective at stopping transmission, but them deliberately choosing this.
First, this commenter didn’t bother to scroll down and see under “Similar articles” this follow-up article in which antibody levels and T-cell responses were reported. Second, only someone who has no clue how clinical trials proceed from preliminary to phase 3 could write something this ignorant. The purpose of phase 1 trials of vaccines is to assess gross safety; i.e., that the vaccine doesn’t cause any obvious toxicity detectable in a relatively small number of patients. In other words, it’s looking for obvious and serious safety signals before larger trials are done, usually also with correlative studies of the vaccine’s ability to provoke an antibody response to the antigen. Phase 2 trials look at a larger number of patients and are focused on looking for signals of efficacy (in the case of vaccines, immunogenicity) and more safety data. However, by the time you get to the phase 3 trial, what a regulator really wants to know before approving a vaccine is whether the immunogenicity detected in earlier phase trials actually translates into prevention of disease. That’s where the rubber hits the road. If the immune response and antibodies detected in phase 1 and 2 trials don’t translate into a significant prevention of disease, then the vaccine is indeed useless. So, yes, Pfizer did deliberately choose not to assess interruption of viral transmission and likely did so in consultation with the FDA, which frequently advises companies on what it needs to see in the clinical trials carried out to support the approval of an investigational drug or vaccine.
Do COVID-19 vaccines prevent transmission?
The antivax propaganda message of ‘the clinical trials used as the basis for an EUA of the Pfizer vaccine never examined whether the vaccine can prevent transmission’ reminds me of Peter Doshi’s obsession—shared by many antivaxxers—with the original clinical trials used to license the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines. How? This line of disinformation intentionally completely ignores what we have learned during the nearly two years since the publication of the results of those phase 3 clinical trials in favor of falsely portraying the phase 3 trials as the be-all and end-all of what we know about the efficacy of the vaccines in preventing transmission, rather than as a starting point sufficiently robust to issue an EUA for the vaccines. It is true that we knew little or nothing then about how effective the Pfizer vaccine was in preventing onward transmission of the coronavirus, but It’s not as though we haven’t learned anything since then regarding whether the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines (as well as the other existing COVID-19 vaccines) are able to prevent transmission. Quite the contrary. There are literally dozens of studies of just the Pfizer vaccine (originally named BNT162b2) alone for the primary course and for boosters for the original strain of SARS-CoV-2 as well as the Delta—and now Omicron—strains. These are all ignored by antivaxxers promoting this narrative.
Susan Oliver cited two of these studies, including an early one that I used to cite last year from April 2021 that showed that, among healthcare workers in England, the vaccine was very effective in preventing both symptomatic and asymptomatic infection and a more recent one from Denmark that demonstrates that vaccination does reduce transmission, even with the more recent immune-evading variants Omicron BA.1 and BA.2.
It is, unfortunately, quite true that vaccines are less effective at preventing transmission of the Delta and Omicron variants, which is not unexpected given that these strains have evolved changes in the protein sequence of their spike proteins that make antibodies produced by the vaccine less effective in neutralizing the virus. For instance, this study from Belgian used contact tracing to estimate vaccine effectiveness against transmission (VET) for the original SARS-CoV-2 strains and Delta variants:
VET-estimates were higher for mRNA-vaccines, over 90%, compared to viral vector vaccines: 66% and 80% for Ad26COV2.S and ChAdOx1 respectively (Alpha, 0-50 days after vaccination). Delta was associated with a 40% increase in odds of transmission and a decrease of VEs (72-64%) and especially of VEi (71-46% for BNT162b2). Infection-acquired and hybrid immunity were less affected by Delta. Waning further reduced VET-estimates: from 81% to 63% for BNT162b2 (Delta, 150-200 days after vaccination). We observed lower initial VEi in the age group 65-84 years (32% vs 46% in the age group 45-64 years for BNT162b2) and faster waning. Hybrid immunity waned slower than vaccine-induced immunity.
There is also good evidence that mRNA-based vaccines against COVID-19 can prevent transmission among children and even in high-risk situations, such as among the residents of nursing homes and long-term care facilities. Additional evidence suggests that the VET fell for the Delta variants. For Omicron variants, particularly the BA.4 and BA.5 variants, there is less evidence published given that the variant took off a year ago and it takes many months to do these kind of epidemiological studies, but there is still a growing body of evidence (for example, this) that Omicron variants can evade prior immune responses from vaccines and from infection with previous SARS-CoV-2 variants, but that does not mean that the vaccines “don’t prevent transmission,” but rather that they still do prevent transmission, just not nearly as effectively as they did for the original strain against which they were designed to protect. (There’s that black-and-white thinking again characterizing a vaccine that is only partially effective against preventing transmission as “not preventing transmission” at all.) That is not surprising and is why updated vaccines will be important in the future, particularly given that Omicron has demonstrated itself to be able to evade “natural immunity” due to prior infection with a previous strain of SARS-CoV-2, such as Delta or the original strain that emerged from Wuhan.
Why is this message being resurrected now?
Again, there is nothing new here. Indeed, Dr. Allison Neitzel of the Counter Disinformation Project led me in her weekend roundup to a whole Tweet thread documenting how long antivaxxers have been hitting this particular fake criticism noting what a short memory antivaxxers have:
pic.twitter.com/Q5mkOwvRmW
— John Bye (@_johnbye) October 14, 2022
pic.twitter.com/ETXnX4lW4n
— John Bye (@_johnbye) October 14, 2022
pic.twitter.com/cFcwath7AG
— John Bye (@_johnbye) October 14, 2022
pic.twitter.com/e1E3mdJ2VB
— John Bye (@_johnbye) October 14, 2022
I could go on, but you can follow the whole thread for more. Some of the Tweets date back to December 2020, making this one of the oldest COVID-19 antivax talking points there is.
All of this leads me to wonder: Why are antivaxxers resurrecting this particular message now? The best reason I can come up with is that it’s opportunistic. Rob Roos thought he got a “gotcha moment” from a Pfizer executive, which caught the attention of Tucker Carlson’s producers, which led to him appearing on Tucker Carlson’s Fox News show last week, which amplified the message by providing convenient suspicious-looking (and misleading) clips that antivaxxers could share on social media and that antivax influencers like Paul Alexander could share on their Substacks, RFK Jr. could amplify on his website, and vloggers like John Campbell could make viral videos about. Add to that the human tendency towards black-and-white, either-or thinking in which, instead of existing on a continuum, people tend to conclude that a vaccine is either effective or not, safe or not, and you have a perfect storm of antivax propaganda, particularly when a conspiracy theory is suggested in which Pfizer and the government “covered up” the lack of data on forward transmission in the phase 3 clinical trial, all in order to enforce vaccine mandates as protecting others. The interesting thing is that the Moderna phase 3 trial for its vaccine (mRNA-1273) used a very similar design to Pfizer’s phase 3 trial and also did not examine virus transmission as an endpoint, but I’m not seeing this claim applied to that vaccine. This further suggests the opportunistic nature of this particular outbreak of viral disinformation.
Dr. Neitzel suggests politics as the reason, and she could have a point:
That all the usual characters have jumped on this at the same time feels like an effort to build on the escalation in previous weeks. In the US this appears to be an effort to mobilise the anti-vax base in preparation for the mid-term elections next month when many disinformation doctors are standing for office.
We see far-right groups in Canada and Europe seeking to capitalise on this while in the UK Richard Tice’s Brexit Party has transformed into the sceptic Reform Party which is seeking to benefit from the chaos within the Conservative Party. Several other parties like the far-right English Democrats and Heritage Party which are working with disinformation groups are trying to do the same.
Whether she’s correct or not, I note that none of this is new. Those of us who’ve followed antivaccine messaging for a long time have seen it all before, be it with the pertussis vaccine or even with the measles vaccine, for the latter of which apparently 95% efficacy at preventing infection is not good enough for antivaxxers to accept that it works. The pandemic has vastly amplified the voice and reach of antivaxxers promoting such conspiracy theories. Each antivax narrative like this one in which Pfizer and the FDA supposedly “hid” the fact that the phase 3 clinical trials for the Pfizer vaccine didn’t test for its ability to prevent transmission pops up, disappears, and then pops up again elsewhere, resulting in an endless and frustrating game of Whac-A-Mole for those dealing with disinformation. That’s the idea. There is no doubt that this kerfuffle will fade, only to be resurrected again when a piece of news makes it convenient for antivax disinformation peddlers like Roos to resurrect it. That’s why, increasingly, I am coming to think that prebunking the form of antivax disinformation will be more important going forward than just trying to whack each mole as it pops up.

The “12% efficacy” myth from the “Pfizer data dump”: The latest slasher stat about COVID-19 vaccines
Last week, a claim that Pfizer’s own documents demonstrate that the efficacy of its COVID-19 vaccine was only 12% (not the 95% reported) went viral. This is a slasher stat, so-named because it is not new and, like the killers in slasher movie series, even when it appears to be dead it always appears in another installment of the misinformation franchise to kill again.
David Gorski on May 9, 2022
Link

Every so often, there arises a myth that can be expressed as a sound bite. The most effective ones during the pandemic are associated with a statistic or a percentage that is passed around as though it were a fact. In August 2020, for example, as the death toll from COVID-19 was climbing, there arose a myth that “only 6%” of the reported deaths due to COVID-19 were actually due to COVID-19, with the rest being people who died “with COVID-19,” not “of COVID-19.” It was an utter distortion of CDC statistics at the time, but it was highly effective. Indeed, it became what I like to refer to as a “zombie stat,” a bite-sized piece of viral disinformation that, no matter how many times it’s debunked, keeps rising from the dead, although maybe I should refer to it as a “slasher” stat, because, like Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers and a host of supernatural slashers, every time it appears to be dead it always reappears in the next installation of the franchise, often in a different and more powerful form (for example, Jason didn’t even don his iconic hockey goalie mask until the third installment of Friday the 13th). Even now, early two years later, I still see this slasher statistic popping up again and again and again to kill again.
It is important to point out that slasher stats aren’t unique to the pandemic, nor are they even just restricted to conspiracy theorists and science deniers—although often that’s where they begin before finding their way into more “respectable” discourse. Before the pandemic, for example, there was the bogus statistic that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US, a figure that was wildly inflated in 2016 when it first really took off and, with new data since then, has become more and more detached from reality. Yet it persists and has so permeated the public discourse that it pops up everywhere as fact, including TV shows like The Resident and at the end of Peacock’s docudrama Dr. Death—even in medical news sources like STAT. Ironically, the academic most responsible for popularizing this myth in 2016 (although versions of the myth had percolated in the quack underground for years before that, such as Gary Null’s Death by Medicine) was Dr. Marty Makary, a surgical oncologist at Johns Hopkins University who has since become a leading COVID-19 minimizer, opponent of public health interventions, and general misinformation spreader, who most famously predicted in early 2021 that we’d have “herd immunity by April.” It’s over a year later now. How’d that prediction work out? Now he’s doing his damnedest to spread misinformation to frighten parents from vaccinating children against COVID-19.
A viral slasher stat from the “Pfizer data dump”?
There’s a new slasher stat in town, and I suspect that we will keep seeing it for a long time. It’s a claim that you might have been seeing all over social media that the efficacy of Pfizer’s mRNA-based vaccine BNT162b2 (now called Comirnaty) was not 95% as reported, but “only 12%”, a figure supposedly based on Pfizer’s own clinical trial documents. You can see how that would be a bombshell! An efficacy of 12% would be really weak and would not have met the FDA’s requirement for at least 50% efficacy to garner an emergency use approval (EUA). It would be serious news! It even has hashtags on Twitter now: #pfizergate, #pfizerdocuments and #pfizerdatadump, among others.
Here are a few examples from Twitter:
Pfizer knew their "vaccine" had 12% efficacy for 7 days and about 1% after that. They also knew it harmed fetuses of pregnant mothers. Where are all the "experts" who pushed this indiscriminately on humanity? #Pfizer #pfizerdatadump #pfizerdocuments #PfizerDump
— Steadfastly 🇺🇲 (@Byron_Bailey) May 4, 2022
The Pfizer vaccine is 12% effective.
THE PFIZER VACCINE IS 12% EFFECTIVE!!#Pfizer #pfizerdocuments #Pfizerdata #PfizerGate #pfizerdatadump #VaccineInjured #VaccineSideEffects #VaccineDeaths
— lisa_lem8 (@Lem8Lisa) May 4, 2022
Nah, just about your health people.. No absorbent profit to see for such a needed life saving gene therapy with 12%efficacy as per #pfizerdocuments #PfizerDump #PfizerGate https://t.co/0HjbZMiLmg
— T (@Tmoneybandit) May 4, 2022
Dear Isreal, you have a problem.They only used Pfizer. 🙄
Many countries including South Africa made #Pfizer their number 1 choice!
12% efficacy is just a complete failure.#pfizerdocuments#pfizerdatadump#PfizerGate https://t.co/7iNtFxEoFU
— Krypton King🔰🇿🇦 (@KryptonKing3) May 5, 2022
The origin of this claim appears to come from the Pfizer documents currently being hosted by an antivaccine group called Public Health and Medical Professionals for Transparency (PHMPT). Listed among the members you’ll see some familiar names from the COVID-19 antivaccine propaganda effort (e.g., Paul Alexander, Peter McCullough, Aaron Kheriaty, and Harvey Risch) and a number of seemingly respectable academics who should know better (e.g., Peter Aaby). The website has a hilariously disingenuous disclaimer, too:
This nonprofit, made up of public health professionals, medical professionals, scientists, and journalists exists solely to obtain and disseminate the data relied upon by the FDA to license COVID-19 vaccines. The organization takes no position on the data other than that it should be made publicly available to allow independent experts to conduct their own review and analyses. Any data received will be made public on this website.
These documents come primarily from court filings based on a FOIA request for all the documents related to Pfizer’s clinical trial from PHMPT itself, which, in combination with all the COVID-19 denialists and minimizers who formed the organization, makes their claim that they “take no position on the data” disingenuous in the extreme:
The agency released 55,000 pages of COVID-19 vaccine review documents last Tuesday, following a loss in court months earlier that forced it to expedite its process to make the information available to the public. In a January court order, U.S. District Judge Mark Pittman of the Northern District of Texas required the FDA to release around 12,000 documents immediately, and then 55,000 pages a month until all documents are released — totaling more than 300,000 pages.
The nonprofit that won the case, Public Health and Medical Professionals for Transparency, sued the FDA last September, claiming that the agency denied its request to expedite the release of COVID-19 vaccine review documents via the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). In a November joint status report, the FDA proposed releasing around 500 pages of the documents each month — which would fulfill the organization’s FOIA request in about 55 to 75 years.
The agency must redact confidential business and trade secret information from Pfizer and BioNTech, as well as any private information on patients in the clinical trial. In its proposal for a 55-year timeline, the FDA noted that the branch that would handle the request has only 10 employees, and is currently processing around 400 other FOIA requests.
This issue led to many antivaccine conspiracy theories claiming that ignored all the valid issues preventing the release of such a large document stash and claiming that Pfizer was going to be allowed to sit on the clinical trial data for its vaccine for 75 years. I’ll just cite one example that appeared on Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Children Health Defense website claiming Pfizer, FDA Hid Data Showing Clinical Trials Failed, Says Former BlackRock Advisor and Pfizer, FDA Lose Bid to Further Delay Release of COVID Vaccine Safety Data. Ironically, the latter article notes that the order required the release of:
    • 10,000 pages apiece, due on or before March 1 and April 1, 2022.
    • 80,000 pages apiece, to be produced on or before May 2, June 1 and July 1, 2022.
    • 70,000 pages to be produced on or before Aug. 1, 2022.
    • 55,000 pages per month, on or before the first business day of each month thereafter, until the release of the documents has been completed.
Per the court order, last week, Pfizer released 80,000 more pages, and, unsurprisingly, COVID-19 conspiracy theorists went to work trying to cherry pick anything that they thought they could use, as predicted in the article I just cited:
“There’s a risk of cherry picking and taking things out of context,” Zalewski said. “Just because you will have all the data in front of you, that doesn’t mean you’ll reach any different conclusions.”
I expect that we’ll see more slasher stats arising and going viral in June, July, and August, and probably every month thereafter until all 300,000 pages are released, to be hosted PHMPT’s website, as antivaxxers and conspiracy theorists, who have the time go to over tens of thousands of pages of documents rapidly in order to cherry pick and take out of context various figures, do their work. Let’s just start with this one, though, since it’s everywhere.
I can’t take anywhere near sole credit for deconstructing this slasher stat alone. Dr. Jeffrey Morris and Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz have provided excellent detailed deconstructions that I draw on:
My new piece is on one of the most fascinating complete myths about COVID-19 vaccines. The Pfizer vaccine, it turns out, is indeed 95% and not 12% effective as the new conspiracy theory claims https://t.co/fA2etUOYou
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) May 7, 2022
Here is a blog post detailing the points in this thread:https://t.co/qRthQ0rwg7
If there is other documentation for this VE=12% claim that I am missing please post below.
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) May 5, 2022
However, I will also note that the origin of a claim very similar to this is much older than the latest Pfizer “data dump”. It dates back to January 2021 and appeared in The BMJ, courtesy of BMJ associate editor and antivaccine-adjacent propagandist Peter Doshi, which is when I first discussed it elsewhere, as did others, such as Skeptical Raptor and John Skylar. Spoiler alert: Although Doshi came up with a figure of 19% efficacy, the latest claim of 12% efficacy is based on “reasoning” (if you can call it that) very reminiscent of Doshi’s “analysis,” which is why I place a significant part of the blame on The BMJ for this latest slasher stat (I discuss Doshi in greater detail below). Let’s take a look.

A slasher myth is (re)born!
We know the claim that the Pfizer documents “really” showed that its vaccine was only 12% effective in preventing COVID-19, but it’s not as straightforward to determine when and how that claim arose after it went so viral. Both Dr. Morris and I stumbled across a post on Substack (of course!) by someone named Sonia Elijah titled “Was Pfizer’s 95% vaccine efficacy fraudulent all along?“, my having come across it in the last Tweet that I cited above. I had never heard of her before this so I thought it worth mentioning her self-description on her Substack:
I’ve written many in-depth investigative reports for TCW, Defending Freedom on: SAGE’s covert coup; the many scandals of the PCR Tests; school closures and anti-lockdown protests around the world. My ground breaking exposé uncovered the many scandals involving the Innova lateral flow test used by NHS Test & Trace, which the UK government spent £4 billion on.
I also write for one of the world’s leading biomedical research sites, Trial Site News, which published my revelatory investigative series: Are the Scientific Journals Censoring the Science? My reports uncovered the major conflicts of interest, malfeasance and shocking acts of censorship, perpetrated by the scientific journals.
Trial Site News is not exactly a writing credit that I’d be proud of, given that it’s one of the biggest conspiracy sites out there and has leaned heavily into antivaccine conspiracy theories since the pandemic hit, having popped up as a culprit amplifying misinformation and conspiracy theories in a number of SBM posts.
The funny thing is, though, this piece of misinformation predates the latest Pfizer document release, as Elijah’s post is dated April 3; so it can’t have originated from the 80,000 pages of documents released last week. I suspect that somehow Jason Gardiner didn’t bother to look at the date of Elijah’s Substack post when he Tweeted this on May 1 (either that, or he didn’t care where the stat came from):
Unfortunately, Gardiner has nearly 143K Twitter followers, which facilitated his claim to go viral very rapidly. Even more disconnected from reality, the document on which Elijah bases her “analysis” was released to the public in December 2020 ahead of the FDA VRBAC meeting to decide on whether to issue an EUA for BNT162b2:
Incidentally, this document was transparently released to the public the week before the FDA VRBPAC meeting in December 2020 deciding the EUA, so is not a new revelation from this 80k page document dump this week.
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) May 5, 2022
What Elijah appears to have done is to combine a conspiracy theory from early in the pandemic about PCR tests that led pandemic deniers and minimizers to refer to the pandemic as a “casedemic” (Indeed, Joe Mercola himself, among many others, promoted this idea.) that claimed that, because so many counts were used, the PCR test used to diagnose COVID-19 infection was producing so many false positives that weren’t actual cases of disease that in reality we were seeing a “casedemic”. As I put it at the time, “casedemic” was simply a new name for a previous COVID-19 denier trope, that increased testing explains the pandemic and that COVID-19 is not dangerous that appears to have been coined by Ivor Cummins, another COVID-19 minimizer. Personally, I’m not going to spend much time on “casedemic” given that I wrote about it nearly two years ago, and there are other contemporaneous deconstructions to which I can refer you, such as the one by Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz and Ian Mackay. I also can’t help but cite a Tweet from November 2020 to reiterate this:
Well in the denialist parallel universe, no one ever dies of Covid. They either die "with", or it's a "false positive".Never mind that largely Covid-free countries like AUS or NZ use the same testing methods and report ~0.1% *total* positives.
— Klaus Hentrich 🇺🇦 (@KHInnovation) November 20, 2020
But back to the 12% efficacy slasher stat and why it’s deceptive.
The “only 12% efficacy” gambit
So how did the “only 12% efficacy” gambit arise? Let’s look at Sonia Elijah’s “reasoning” (such as it is). You’ll find that it is very similar to Peter Doshi’s “reasoning” (such as it was) in early 2021, even if it arrives at a slightly different—but also low—false estimate for the efficacy of Pfizer’s vaccine. I emphasize again that her “estimate” appears to have nothing to do with the latest Pfizer release of 80K pages of documents. (If there’s something I’m missing, please point it out and I’ll add an addendum to this post.)
First, she cites the “casedemic” narrative to which she contributed, but she does it devoid of actually showing concretely how her assumption that PCR tests massively overdiagnose COVID-19, leading to a huge decline in the efficacy of the vaccine:
Firstly, it’s worth pointing out that Pfizer used a ‘central laboratory‘ (see page 13 of the document) of its choice, to confirm COVID-19 cases using a PCR test. ‘If, at any time, a participant develops acute respiratory illness, an illness visit occurs. Assessments for illness visits include a nasal (mid-turbinate) swab, which is tested at a central laboratory using a reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) test.’
I’ve previously written an in-depth investigative report on the PCR test. The cycle threshold (CT) value used, greatly impacts the outcome of a test.
According to a study by Jaafar et al., the authors found that when running PCR tests with 35 cycles or more – the accuracy dropped to 3%, meaning up to 97 % of positive results could be false positives.
There is no information given on the CT value used at this ‘central laboratory.’
This claim is so divorced from reality (not to mention a total misrepresentation of the study cited) that I think I’ll just quote Meyerowitz-Katz:
Now, the author of the Substack post does not agree. They argue that, because PCR tests at high cycle thresholds do not always culture live virus, that the tests are highly unreliable and that “up to 97 % of positive results could be false positives” depending on how Pfizer ran their analysis.
However, this is a very basic misunderstanding of how these tests work. The issue is that PCR tests are too accurate, rather than not accurate enough. PCR is incredibly sensitive to any viral RNA picked up, and so may identify people even if they’ve already cleared the Covid-19 infection. Indeed, the paper cited by the author of the Substack post says exactly this — if you run PCRs at a high cycle threshold, you will capture people who no longer have live virus in their body.
But this isn’t a false positive by any medical definition — those with a high cycle threshold count but no live virus culture were almost always either recently infected with Covid-19 or are recuperating from an infection. In other words, they currently have Covid-19 or have very recently had the disease. It’s possible for PCRs to throw up false positives, but in most places the specificity of the test is far above 99.9%, meaning fewer than 1 in 1,000 people who don’t have Covid-19 will test positive to the disease on PCR.
I’ll also refer you to my old “casedemic” post here on SBM for more detail on why this claim is nonsense, for those who are interested, as well as Dr. Morris’ excellent post, in which he notes that the only way an “analysis” (and I do use the term loosely) such as this might be appropriate is if the false positive rate is very much greater than 90%, even as he cites a PCR false positive rate of 4%, citing an FDA report for the actual PCR test used for the Pfizer clinical trial. I’ll also point out that the linking of her claims about the massive numbers of false positives from PCR tests for COVID-19 as a reason why the vaccine efficacy (VE) rate for the Pfizer vaccine was “only 12%” in its clinical trial is basically pure speculation, with no concrete evidence for her claim about PCR tests or to link her claim with the new, lower estimate she pulls out of her nether regions for the VE for the Pfizer vaccine.
In fact, if the false positive rate of the PCR test was as ridiculously high as Elijah claims, then we would not expect there to have been so many “suspected but not confirmed” cases of COVID-19 compared to actual cases that tested positive by PCR for COVID-19. Quite the contrary! We’d have expected a large percentage of those suspected cases to have been incorrectly “confirmed” by false positive PCR tests. Her linking of the “casedemic” lie about PCR tests for COVID-19 and her claim of vastly decreased vaccine efficacy compared to what Pfizer calculated are not even internally consistent! It’s true that a lot more positives would decrease the apparent VE by adding large numbers to both the numerator and denominator, thus making a smaller fractional decrease, but that’s not what appears to have happened here, given the small number of subjects with suspected COVID-19 who actually did test positive for the virus by PCR.
So let’s get to the rancid meat of Elijah’s claim:
On page 24 of the document, the results showing 95% VE (vaccine efficacy) for the vaccine can be found below.
The 95% VE (vaccine efficacy) arises from the 8 confirmed Covid cases from the vaccinated group (from at least 7 days after Dose 2) compared to 162 from the placebo group. These two data points are essentially what Pfizer hang their hat on to prove their vaccine was a success! This is the data that the FDA and other regulatory bodies around the world relied upon to grant EUA (Emergency Use Authorisation) for the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine and for billions of doses to be shipped around the world with some countries enforcing highly controversial draconian vaccine mandates.
A key section buried within this document, which alludes to possibly the real VE at that time, is the following damning data below (found on page 42).
These were people showing actual symptoms. If you calculate the VE from these numbers, it’s a staggeringly low 12%!
VE is calculated by dividing the difference between the case numbers in the placebo and vaccine groups, by the case number in the placebo group x 100 = VE of 12 %
It is correct that, if there were 1,594 COVID-19 cases in vaccine arm and 1,816 in placebo arm, then the VE would be 12%. However, this is not the correct calculation. For one thing, no one expected a vaccine against COVID-19 to prevent all coughs, fevers, sniffles, and other symptoms of upper respiratory viruses. Even though COVID-19 was racing through the population, there were still a lot of other upper respiratory infections going around. More importantly, as both Meyerowitz-Katz and Dr. Morris have pointed out, this calculation is based on a complete misreading of the clinical trial!
If one looks at the protocol, which is publicly accessible on the Pfizer website hosted on the FDA website, you’ll find no mention of a category of COVID-19 cases that are “suspected but unconfirmed.” There is, however, such a category listed in the FDA briefing documents, meaning that it was a description that Pfizer came up with after the trial had been run and the initial data analysis carried out. Here’s the thing. First, given that there were over 30,000 subjects it was deemed too expensive to do weekly PCR tests on all subjects; so the trial was designed to detect the ability of the vaccine to prevent symptomatic disease. That’s why the section on COVID-19 surveillance for clinical trial subjects (Section 8.13) states that subjects should contact their clinical trial site immediately and participate in an in-person or telehealth visit as soon as possible if they experience any of the following symptoms of COVID-19 (and, other than loss of sense of smell and taste, common symptoms of other respiratory viruses): fever, new or increased cough, new or increased shortness of breath, chills, new or increased muscle pain, new loss of sense of taste/smell, sore throat, diarrhea, or vomiting.
Then, the protocol dictates:
If the visit is conducted in person, obtain a nasal (midturbinate) swab (collected by site staff). Alternatively, if conducted by telehealth, instruct the participant to self-collect a nasal (midturbinate) swab and ship for assessment at the central laboratory.
In other words, the Pfizer clinical trial protocol required investigation of these suspected cases of COVID=19 to determine whether or not the symptoms being experienced by the clinical trial participants were actually due to COVID-19. Those whose PCR test was positive then became “confirmed COVID-19 cases” that were included in the primary efficacy analysis. Those whose PCR test was negative (or if done multiple times, repeatedly negative) were not COVID-19 cases. Nor should they have been counted as such!
Or, as Meyerowitz-Katz put it:
The positive tests are where we get the 8 positives and 162 negatives that the true vaccine efficacy of 95% is based on, while 3,410 tested negative on PCR and were considered “suspected but unconfirmed”. What this actually means is that these people did not have a Covid-19 infection.
Or, as Dr. Morris put it:
So these 3410 “suspected but unconfirmed” cases were people who any symptom mentioned in the list, which of course could come from many causes not just COVID-19 infections, for whom they went in for a SARS-CoV-2 PCR test, and their test result was negative.
Since obviously the SARS-CoV-2 vaccine was not intended to prevent all coughs, fevers, chills, sore throats, muscle pain, shortness of breath, vomiting, etc., from any cause, it would be ridiculous to include all reports of such common symptoms as COVID-19 cases for the purpose of computing Vaccine Efficacy.
I’ll put it even more simply than either Meyerowitz-Katz or Dr. Morris put it. Trying to include these “suspected but not confirmed” cases of COVID-19 (e.g., not COVID-19) in the analysis was a transparent attempt by Sonia Elijah to dilute the effect of the vaccine by lumping in a bunch of cases that the vaccine could never have impacted in both the vaccine and placebo groups, thereby making the new “apparent” VE for the vaccine artificially low. Again, the vaccine could not and should not have been expected to prevent respiratory illnesses, but that’s what one has to expect to believe the estimate of 12% for VE. It is a claim that is just plain wrong, and it isn’t even a close call.
In fact, the only reason why someone like Elijah can make this claim seem convincing is the rather odd choice Pfizer made writing the protocol not to explicitly label as “negative” or “not having COVID-19” the suspected cases whose COVID-19 PCR test was negative. As is often the case, the least bit of ambiguity in wording can be exploited by conspiracy theorists and disinformation peddlers, and that’s what appears to have happened here.
Also:
BTW, in 2021 numerous rigorous population-level studies adjusting for confounders validated these ~90% VE numbers even as Alpha and Delta variants emerged (before waning and Omicron — that is another story) pic.twitter.com/KYax3DeLUE
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) May 9, 2022
It’s not as though Pfizer data were the only data supporting a VE of 90%, although unfortunately the rise of the Delta and Omicron variants did result in considerably lower VE.
Everything old is new again!
At this point, you might be wondering why I titled the last section “A slasher myth is (re)born“. The reason is simple. Elijah’s “analysis” isn’t even new. A version of it first appeared in January 2021, shortly after the Pfizer briefing documents had been released. It appeared, shockingly enough, in an eminent British biomedical journal, The BMJ, written by one of its associate editors Peter Doshi titled “Pfizer and Moderna’s “95% effective” vaccines—we need more details and the raw data“. Dr. Morris correctly mentions that Elijah’s “reasoning” very much resembles Doshi’s “reasoning” 16 months ago, but didn’t go into detail, preferring instead to cite his contemporaneous deconstruction of Doshi.
Let’s go back and see what Doshi wrote then:
All attention has focused on the dramatic efficacy results: Pfizer reported 170 PCR confirmed covid-19 cases, split 8 to 162 between vaccine and placebo groups. But these numbers were dwarfed by a category of disease called “suspected covid-19″—those with symptomatic covid-19 that were not PCR confirmed. According to FDA’s report on Pfizer’s vaccine, there were “3410 total cases of suspected, but unconfirmed covid-19 in the overall study population, 1594 occurred in the vaccine group vs. 1816 in the placebo group.”
With 20 times more suspected than confirmed cases, this category of disease cannot be ignored simply because there was no positive PCR test result. Indeed this makes it all the more urgent to understand. A rough estimate of vaccine efficacy against developing covid-19 symptoms, with or without a positive PCR test result, would be a relative risk reduction of 19% (see footnote)—far below the 50% effectiveness threshold for authorization set by regulators. Even after removing cases occurring within 7 days of vaccination (409 on Pfizer’s vaccine vs. 287 on placebo), which should include the majority of symptoms due to short-term vaccine reactogenicity, vaccine efficacy remains low: 29% (see footnote).
Sound familiar? It should, which is why Sonia Elijah’s claim immediately sounded very familiar to me when I encountered it, given that it used basically the same “reasoning” as Doshi but came up with a slightly different estimate. Let’s compare and contrast.
Elijah used a very simple equation based on 1,594 “suspected but not confirmed” COVID-19 cases occurring in the vaccine group vs. 1,816 in the placebo group, calculating that the “true VE” should equal 1 – 1594/1816 x 100% = 0.122 or 12.2%. Note that she didn’t include the actual PCR positive cases in her calculations.
Doshi, on the other hand, did, stating that the “true” VE should equal 1 – (8+1594)/(162+1816) = 0.19 or 19%. In actuality, if indeed the “suspected” cases of COVID-19 should have been included in the calculation, Doshi actually did the calculation correctly, and Elijah screwed it up, basing her calculation solely on the “suspected but not confirmed” cases and ignoring all the confirmed cases. Both are totally wrong, though, because their calculations were based on a misreading of the clinical trial data and protocol. It’s just that Elijah was “more wrong” than Doshi and, not surprisingly, ended up with an even lower apparent VE than Doshi did. Both used exactly the same rationale, just different numbers.
Doshi also went on to answer this very criticism of his estimate in a “clarification” by likening COVID-19 to influenza and citing a Cochrane review for flu vaccines that included an analysis of their efficacy against influenza-like illnesses. In it, he used a rationale exactly the opposite of Elijah’s though. Instead of pointing to false positive PCR tests, he claimed a high false negative rate for the PCR tests. (Can these people make up their minds? Is the test generating lots of false positives or missing too much disease?) However, even according to Doshi, it would have required a huge false negative rate to have had such a dramatic impact on the calculated VE.
It’s hard not to suspect that Elijah saw Doshi’s BMJ commentary from January and decided to try to replicate it, but just botched the calculation. One might even wonder if she liked her result of 12% VE because it was lower than Doshi’s estimate of 19%.
What have we learned?
You probably wondered why I wrote early in this post that I blame The BMJ, at least in part, for the “only 12% efficacy” gambit about the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. It’s now a viral slasher antivaccine lie. The reason should now be apparent. The BMJ published an article that used exactly the same massively flawed rationale to downplay the efficacy of the Pfizer vaccine that antivaxxers are using now. Worse, it continues to employ the author of that commentary, Peter Doshi, as an associate editor. Doshi has used that platform to publish dubious editorials calling the safety and efficacy of not just COVID-19 vaccines, but a number of other vaccines, into question. Sixteen months ago, he published an article that made exactly the same specious argument that is now resurfaced on an antivaccine site and started spreading virally through antivaccine conspiracy social media. He just came up with a different number than Elijah did because he did the calculation right and she didn’t, but his “reasoning” was every bit as wrong as Elijah’s was. Indeed, one wonders if Elijah was inspired by Doshi’s article.
Worse, The BMJ hired Doshi despite his long history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement since at least 2009, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines, as well as having signed a petition in 2006 “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS. It continues to employ him even after he’s fallen for a conspiracy theory that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database was being made inaccessible to suppress report. That’s not all, though, he’s also served as an expert witness for the plaintiffs in antivaccine leader Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s lawsuit against the University of California’s influenza vaccine mandates.
He’s only gotten worse in the COVID-19 pandemic. For example, he has used his title as a BMJ editor when taking part in a “roundtable” organized by Sen. Ron Johnson to go dumpster diving in VAERS to find “vaccine injuries” due to COVID-19 vaccines, whether the injuries were caused by them or not. In his testimony, Doshi denied that COVID-19 at the time (November 2021) was a “pandemic of the unvaccinated”, citing a report from July from the UK that most hospitalizations are among the fully vaccinated. It turned out that this report was in error, substituting “vaccinated” for “unvaccinated” and the majority of hospitalizations were among the unvaccinated, even though they made up only 31% of the population at the time. He even cited cherry-picked tables to claim that the vaccine wasn’t saving lives in what was basically an updated rehash of the nonsense he had peddled a few months earlier in which he claimed that there was “no biodistribution data” for COVID-19 vaccines and made a number of other negative false claims about the vaccines (also deconstructed by Dr. Hilda Bastian). In a truly risible moment, he even cited the Merriam-Webster definition of “antivaxxer” as opposed to those supposedly opposed to vaccine mandates to argue that he and his fellow COVID-19 contrarians were “not antivaccine” and that large numbers of people would qualify as “antivaccine”. He even parroted the antivaccine talking point that mRNA vaccines are not really vaccines and therefore shouldn’t be mandated like vaccines.
In other words, an antivax Twitter user might have come up with the clever idea of linking Pfizer’s release of 80K pages of documents last week to a post from April by Sonia Elijah to imply that the “Pfizer data dump” held the previously hidden revelation that the “real VE” of Pfizer’s vaccine was really only 12% when, unless I’m missing something—and let me know if I did miss something—they contain nothing of the sort. However, the idea behind the lie that Pfizer’s own documents show that its COVID-19 vaccine is only 12% effective came from Peter Doshi, who remains employed by The BMJ despite his antivaccine activities. It is a really powerful slasher lie, too, as evidence doesn’t kill it for long. One wonders how many more times it will show up in the future. Thinking about that question, I can only think in horror of how many installments there are in the Friday the 13th, Nightmare on Elm Street, Halloween, Chucky, and Scream horror franchises.
We’re talking about many times going on for years and years and years, and we have The BMJ, at least in part, to thank for this antivaccine slasher lie that will likely never die.

Three New Studies Show the COVID Vaccines Are Very Safe for Children
Three new studies tell us what we already knew- vaccine isn’t perfect, but it’s far safer than the virus for children. 
Jonathan Howard on June 11, 2023
Link

Two recent studies reaffirmed the safety of the COVID vaccine for toddlers and infants, who have the highest COVID risk of all children. One study examined data from over 245,000 vaccine doses. It evaluated 23 safety outcomes, including myocarditis, pericarditis, and seizures and “did not detect a safety signal for any outcome during the 21 days after vaccination”. Another study examined 550,000 third vaccine doses given to children under 5 years. 8 serious adverse reactions were reported, though none were related to the vaccine.
Anyone concerned with vaccine-myocarditis has no reason to oppose the COVID vaccine in children under age 12.
A third study from Korea provided mostly reassuring news about vaccine-myocarditis in adolescents age 12-17. Out of 2,076,259 adolescents, there were just 78 cases of vaccine-myocarditis (1 in 26,500). The rate peaked at 1 in 19,000 for males. The authors wrote the condition was “was rare and showed relatively favorable clinical course” for 80% of patients. However, unlike other studies, 20% of patients had a severe reaction. Though severe myocarditis was rare- it affected 15 of the 2.1 million adolescents (1 in 138,000)- these children’s experiences should not be trivialized. Two teenagers had fulminant myocarditis, which must have been terrifying and horrible, though they both recovered from this literally one-in-a-million event. All 78 adolescents will have to be monitored over the long term. Fortunately, no adolescents died. (Further data on 42 million adults, including 21 who tragically died, is briefly presented here.)
Of course, the risks of the vaccine have to be balanced against the benefits of the vaccine and the risks of the virus, which hasn’t been as benign for all Korean children. Like everywhere else, grave outcomes are mercifully rare. However, an article from September 2022 reported that 46 Korean children died of COVID, 91% of whom were unvaccinated. One headline from August 2022 said, “Korea Reports 4 Deaths From Covid-19 Among Kids in July Alone“. Of course, death is not the only bad outcome from COVID. In one study of 753 Korean children who were hospitalized with COVID, 69% had no underlying conditions and 99.5% were unvaccinated. More Korean children would have suffered and died without the vaccine.
Overall, these three studies are entirely consistent with every study published thus far. The vaccine isn’t perfect, but it’s far safer than the virus for children. Previously, it would not have been controversial to argue that death is worse than a rare, usually “favorable” vaccine side-effect, or even a severe one.
Today, this belief makes me a very polarizing figure.

Was an Article Titled “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization” About Vaccinating Children?
Yes, it was.
Jonathan Howard on January 7, 2022
Link

A review
My first article for Science Based Medicine was a rebuttal to a paper published in The BMJ titled “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization” by Drs. Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral. Its central thesis was that “the likelihood of severe outcomes or death associated with COVID-19 infection is very low for children, undermining the appropriateness of an emergency use authorization for child COVID-19 vaccines”. Dr. Prasad further elaborated on Twitter by saying that,
Vast majority of kids recover quickly from SARS cov 2. And after all adults are vaccinated their risk of covid will decline precipitously. It’s ok to acknowledge that covid19 is not an emergency for kids.
I had multiple critiques of this article, namely that it completely glossed over how COVID-19 had harmed children, that it ignored the possibility of new variants, and that it didn’t mention the FDA had established stringent criteria for approving a vaccine under an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA). However, my core criticism was that the difference between an EUA and full FDA approval was nothing more than waiting several months after the pediatric trials concluded, something the BMJ article didn’t explain. Since most vaccine side effects emerge shortly after vaccination, I felt this waiting period alone would be of little value. As I wrote previously,
Their paper did not call for more or larger studies in children (which nobody would oppose), but rather a regulatory framework whose additional safety measure is waiting four additional months. In order for this delay to be of value, one would have to posit there is a significant vaccine side effect that is both unique to children and that it will only emerge between 2-6 months after vaccination at a high enough frequency that it will be detected under the limited structure of a clinical trial.
What’s changed: COVID-19
Since our respective articles were published in May 2021, new variants have more than doubled the pediatric death toll. The virus has killed over 550 American children since May, including healthy adolescents who were eligible to be vaccinated. Tens of thousands more children were hospitalized, some intubated in the ICU. Currently, more children are being hospitalized than ever before, almost all of them unvaccinated. 951 children with COVID-19 were admitted to the hospital on a single day this week, a huge number even factoring in incidental hospitalizations. Thousands more children contracted multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), and most of these children need ICU-level care. 55 children have died from MIS-C.
What’s changed: The vaccine
Meanwhile, strong evidence emerged that the vaccine was extremely effective at preventing SARS-CoV-2 infections and keeping children alive and out of the hospital, a result that should have surprised no one. Five CDC studies examined the vaccine’s efficacy in adolescents. They found that:
    • Study 1: In hospitalized adolescents, “179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.”
    • Study 2: “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents.”
    • Study 3: “Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one was fully vaccinated.”
    • Study 4: Vaccine effectiveness “was 92% against SARS-CoV-2 infections irrespective of symptom status.”
    • Study 5: “97/102 children with MIS-C were unvaccinated. None of the 5 vaccinated MIS-C patients required respiratory or cardiovascular life support (invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or ECMO) compared to 38/97 unvaccinated MIS-C patients.”
Vaccine-related myocarditis emerged as a side effect in adolescent boys, but at a low-enough frequency (about 1 in 7,000) that only a massive trial that likely would have taken years to complete could have detected it. As this side effect occurs several days after vaccination, the waiting period proposed in the BMJ article would have been useless in detecting it. Moreover, researchers on vaccine-related myocarditis say that while long-term monitoring is needed, “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly”. Over 90% of adolescents and children with this condition have had their symptoms resolve, and the average hospital stay is two days. I know of no child in the entire world who has died from the vaccine, and tens of millions of children have been vaccinated in the USA alone. (The CDC is investigating one death of someone who was diagnosed with myocarditis after they died, but I do not know any details, including the age of the decedent.)
“The piece was not about vaccinating young kids”
With this in mind, it is interesting to see how the three authors of the BMJ paper have discussed it subsequently. On Twitter, Dr. Baral responded to critics by saying, “With all due respect, all we called for is the ACIP to meet and discuss. The piece was not about vaccinating young kids as compared to going through due diligence in deciding whether to vaccinate young children”. Dr. Pedgen agreed, saying, “The accusation doesn’t even seem to be that we argued against vaccinating kids (which we didn’t).” In an article for the Brownstone Institute, Dr. Prasad said,
In May of 2021, Wes Pegden, Stef Baral and I argued in the BMJ that kids vaccination should proceed via biological licensing agreement pathway and not the emergency use authorization. Because these risks were so low, we must demand robust evidence and large trials to show that the potential benefits of vaccination outweigh potential harms… We wanted large randomized trials.
If Dr. Prasad “wanted large randomized trials” at that time, why didn’t he say so in the BMJ article? As I previously stated, that request would have been hard to oppose.
Similarly, despite Dr. Baral’s subsequent claim that all his article called for was a meeting of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), his article did not even mention the ACIP. Of course, the ACIP was always going to meet and discuss the EUA for both adolescents and younger children.
Dr. Pedgen may be technically correct that his article did not explicitly argue “against vaccinating kids”. However, its entire point was to oppose the regulatory framework that was a necessary prerequisite to most children being vaccinated. So what’s the difference? It’s like telling my son he can use my car, refusing to give him the keys, and then feigning disbelief when he asks why I won’t let him drive. Dr. Mark W. Kline, a pediatrician who has seen children die of COVID-19, put it well when he responded to two of these authors by saying,
I’m sure you’re good at what you do, but the academic and semantic rationalizations you are offering up are typical of someone who doesn’t have to live with real-world consequences of their opinions and decisions. Just admit that you came to a flawed conclusion. No big deal.
If the BMJ article’s purpose was not to “argue against vaccinating kids,” what then was it arguing for, beyond empty platitudes such as “due diligence” and “robust evidence”? Moreover, even though the results had only been reported in a press release at that time, there was solid evidence that the adolescent vaccine trial was very successful. The press release stated “18 cases of COVID-19 were observed in the placebo group (n=1,129) versus none in the vaccinated group (n=1,131)” and the vaccine “was well tolerated”. Of course, the FDA had access to all this information and referenced it in their EUA announcement, noting that “the vaccine was 100% effective in preventing COVID-19” in adolescents.
I understand skepticism towards company press releases, but the existence of this trial was not even mentioned in the BMJ article. I believe that those who demand “robust evidence” should make some minimal effort to educate their readers about the evidence that currently exists. My article acknowledged this trial. My article acknowledged new variants could arrive that might significantly impact children. My article, unlike the BMJ article, also acknowledged that even before the arrival of these nasty variants, hundreds of children had died of COVID-19 and many thousands had been hospitalized. Overall, over 1,000 American children have died of COVID-19. You can read every article by some prolific writers on pediatric COVID-19 this pandemic and not learn this basic number.
The EUA was appropriate
The virus can really hurt some children, and the vaccine can prevent these rare, but grave harms. We have solid proof now of this now, but this was entirely predictable from what was known back then. It’s no surprise that the vast majority of deceased and hospitalized children since then have been unvaccinated. This is why I felt the EUA was appropriate for adolescents and younger children.
Currently, the COVID-19 vaccine is fully approved only for people 16 years and older. Pfizer filed for full FDA approval for children older than 12 years just last month, a process will likely take several months. Full FDA approval for younger children is many more months away. Children under 5 years cannot be vaccinated at all.
        ◦ If regulators had adopted the policy proposed in the BMJ article, no EUA would have been issued for most children, and so few children younger than 16 years would be vaccinated today. If Drs. Pegden, Prasad, and Baral, don’t feel they came to a “flawed conclusion,” they should acknowledge this obvious fact, recognize its implications, and proudly defend it as a desired outcome instead of claiming an article titled “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization” had nothing to do with vaccinating children.

An Open Letter to Dr. Stefan Baral: Let’s Revisit Your Article “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization.”
“I value criticism and my collaborations are based on the ability to openly criticize other’s ideas as a means of finding the ‘right’ answer.”
Jonathan Howard on June 28, 2024
Link

I value criticism and my collaborations are based on the ability to openly criticize other’s ideas as a means of finding the “right” answer.
Dear Dr. Baral,
My first and most recent article here at SBM were very different, but they both quoted you extensively. I was reminded of this symmetry of when I saw two comments you made on social media this week, both of which were very reasonable.
In the first comment you wrote:
At the beginning of covid, I was worried that academics personally attacking other academics with whom they didn’t agree would undermine the respect for academia and ultimately the power of evidence in driving policy.
You were right to be worried about personal attacks that undermine the respect for academia and ultimately the power of evidence in driving policy.
I expressed similar sentiments in my most recent article, Did I Lie About My Conference Invitation? How Bad Faith Engagement Functions As A Distraction and Silencing Technique. In that article, I showed that some doctors substituted straw man arguments, tone-trolling, and shill accusations/juvenile insults for civil debate of my ideas. I sincerely apologize for times when I did not engage in good faith. There were occasions when I should have elevated the discourse, but did not. I’ll do my best not to let that happen again. However, my core argument was that bad faith engagement serves to both silence potential critics and distract from more substantive discussion of facts, data, and science. We both agree this is where the focus should be. So let’s leave pettiness behind and get to it.
In the second comment you wrote:
I value criticism and my collaborations are based on the ability to openly criticize other’s ideas as a means of finding the “right” answer.
I couldn’t agree more. We should be able to receive good faith criticism and openly criticize other’s ideas. That’s what I did with my first article here, Should COVID-19 Vaccines Be Administered to Children Under an Emergency Use Authorization?, which discussed your article Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization. Both of our articles were published in May 2021, and I strongly encourage readers to pause and read them. Given that we both value criticism and the ability to openly criticize other’s ideas, I think now would be a good time to look back and see how our respective articles have fared.
Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization
I’ve defended your article. I am on record as having said you wrote it in good faith, though I strongly disagreed with it. My response was written in good faith. I was blunt, but there were no personal attacks, and I’ve only ever discussed your ideas. Here’s how my article began:
An article entitled “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization” was recently published in The BMJ by Drs. Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral. The central thesis of the argument is that “severe outcomes or death associated with COVID-19 infection is very low for children, undermining the appropriateness of an emergency use authorization for child COVID-19 vaccines”. They express a concern that under an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA), “the risk of rare adverse events remains and, if the benefit achieved by an intervention is insufficient, any serious, yet rare, adverse effects can prove to be the lasting legacy of a regulatory decision”. The article contained several crucial omissions that I believe undermine their conclusion.
That opening paragraph established a pattern for my writing. I linked to your article, and though your position was obvious from the title alone, I directly quoted your key ideas fully and fairly. I’ve never purposefully misrepresented anyone’s ideas in any way. If you feel I’ve done that, please let me know exactly where so I can fix it and apologize, though I’m pleased that you haven’t yet identified anywhere where you feel I’ve done this. Straw-man arguments are bad faith engagement.
Having fairly presented your ideas, I then explained why I disagreed with them. Specifically, I identified your article’s many “crucial omissions”. Your article contained a just single link, about the 1976 swine flu debacle. However, it didn’t contain a single statistic about how COVID had impacted children to that point, nor did it mention that a successful pediatric vaccine RCT had been reported via a company press release. (The paper, showing the vaccine was 100% effective for adolescents, was published in the NEJM a few weeks later.)
Your article also didn’t explain the difference between an EUA and full vaccine approval or why that added regulatory designation would be so valuable. The difference turns out just to be waiting longer. That’s it. Given that vaccine side-effects almost always emerge shortly after the vaccine itself, that waiting period did not seem to be of any value, and it wouldn’t have identified the rare, usually mild vaccine-side effects that did emerge.
My article was a lengthy piece- an unfortunate pattern- that tried to fill in these gaps. I felt that any discussion of vaccinating children should include some basic facts. I argued that while COVID had obviously been worse for adults, that did not mean it had been entirely benign for children. Just under 500 children died during the pandemic’s first year, and many thousands more had been hospitalized. COVID’s harms to children were comparable to many other vaccine-preventable diseases, though unlike those diseases, COVID did its damage with strict mitigation measures in place. As I acknowledged, your article said that “emergency use authorizations should be considered for children at genuinely high risk of serious complications,” however according to the most recent data, half of hospitalized children have no underlying conditions, and 18% of these were admitted to the ICU. COVID is not serious for most children thankfully, but it can be really bad for some of them.
In addition to presenting these basic facts, I explained the difference between an EUA and full vaccine approval, I discussed the successful pediatric vaccine RCT, and I also wrote the following:
It is not inconceivable that a COVID-19 variant could significantly affect children and spread widely before we could widely vaccinate children. Precaution against the unknown works in both directions.
For these reasons, I concluded that the EUA for children was appropriate. Fortunately, FDA regulators felt the same way and the EUA was issued on the same day I published my article, May 10, 2021. As a result, millions of children were vaccinated before they were infected.
I think this was a good thing.
COVID-19 Vaccine Is Strongly Effective For Children And Adolescents During Delta And Omicron
A lot has changed since we wrote our articles in May 2021.
At the risk of sounding immodest, I think my article aged very well, and I’ve defended it’s core ideas dozens of times here at SBM, in my book, and in podcasts. I’ve continued to do my best to fully enumerate COVID’s impact on children, which greatly worsened after May 2021. Though not everyone worried about them, the variants I feared arrived, sadly. One typical headline from December 2021 said Pediatric Hospitalizations Up 395% In NYC Amid COVID-19 Surge.
These variants also closed down schools across the country, not just in areas governed by timid liberals (Florida, Arkansas, Idaho, Texas, Oklahoma, Kentucky , Alabama, Georgia, Wyoming, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina, North Dakota, Tennessee, Kansas, West Virginia, Missouri, Louisiana, Mississippi). Even when schools were “open”, that didn’t mean children were learning in them. One typical headline from January 2022 read COVID Hammers NYC School Attendance Among Students And Teachers. Of course, by merely reporting that this happened, I am not “defending”, it as has been alleged. I didn’t want the virus to impact education. I wanted healthy kids learning from healthy teachers, and I suspect this would have happened more often if children had been vaccinated.
We obviously know a lot more about the vaccine than we did in May 2021. There have been many dozens of studies on its safety and efficacy, and I’ve also done my best to present this data fully and fairly many times. The evidence is overwhelmingly clear that while the vaccine is not a panacea, it has protected a meaningful number of children from real harm.
The vaccine did not receive full FDA approval for adolescents until July 2022, and it is still only available to younger children under an EUA. I am confident that more children would have suffered and missed school had the vaccine been unavailable to children during this time.
However, I expect you will disagree with me about all this, and I really want to understand why.
Read this article
I 100% stand by what we wrote
Several months after you wrote your article in the BMJ, you said “I 100% stand by what we wrote“. Yet, I have not seen you explain why in any detail, as I have with my original article. What do you think would have happened had their been no EUA for the pediatric vaccine, and why do you think this outcome would have been preferable to what actually happened?
My success rate in asking people, even those who claim to love debate and discussion, to defend their ideas is zero. In fact, people often get very angry at me for reminding them of their ideas. However, in the spirit of finding the “right” answer, I invite you to explore this hypothetical scenario and make the case that the EUA was a mistake. Although you later claimed that your article was “not about vaccinating young kids“, it’s inarguable that had regulators heeded your advice, the vaccine would have been unavailable to nearly all children when the Delta and Omicron variants arrived. It seems to me that your article, which was titled Covid Vaccines For Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization, was very much about vaccinating children. As such, I hope you can make the case that the EUA hurt them, that too many of them were vaccinated, and that the pandemic would have unfolded better for children and their education if the vaccine was available to only a small subset of them when these worse variants emerged.
Like you, I value criticism, and I hope you will openly criticize my ideas as a means of finding the “right” answer. I’ve lamented the near total absence of good faith criticism of my ideas. Where is it? So in addition to making the affirmative case the the EUA was a mistake, I hope you’ll let me know exactly what I got wrong in my article. I hope that you’ll extensively quote from it- or anything I’ve written- to show exactly which of my ideas aged poorly. If you discover any factual errors, please let me know so I can correct them. Don’t worry about hurting my feelings. As long as you quote my ideas fully and accurately, while reporting the science and data fully and accurately, I won’t call you silly names or question your motivations.
Of course, you could also argue that looking back, the EUA was appropriate after all. That option is available to you, and no one should criticize you if you exercise it.
As I wrote, ignoring me is not bad faith engagement. However, since this is not the path you’ve chosen, I hope you’ll engage with my ideas in good faith. That’s what I’ve done.
I look forward to learning from you.
Jonathan
.

Should COVID-19 vaccines be administered to children under an emergency use authorization?
Recently, Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral argued in The BMJ that “COVID-19 vaccines for children should not get emergency use authorization”. Their argument is lacking, and they left out a number of relevant facts.
Jonathan Howard on May 10, 2021
Link
An article entitled “Covid Vaccines for Children Should Not Get Emergency Use Authorization” was recently published in The BMJ by Drs. Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral. The central thesis of the argument is that “severe outcomes or death associated with COVID-19 infection is very low for children, undermining the appropriateness of an emergency use authorization for child COVID-19 vaccines”. They express a concern that under an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA), “the risk of rare adverse events remains and, if the benefit achieved by an intervention is insufficient, any serious, yet rare, adverse effects can prove to be the lasting legacy of a regulatory decision”. The article contained several crucial omissions that I believe undermine their conclusion.
Is COVID-19 low risk for children?
First, let’s examine the statement that the risk COVID poses to children is “very low”. While the risk to children is many orders of magnitude lower than the risk to older adults, the risk is not zero. One study of 7,780 pediatric patients recorded 7 deaths (0.09%), though the actual death rate is almost certainly less than this. With millions of children contracting COVID-19, even rare harms add up. According to covkidproject.org, as of March 28, 2021, 582 children have died in the US of COVID-19. I will note that other sources with different methodologies have found a lower death toll. According to the CDC, 482 children have died. Regardless of the exact number, it is fair to say that essentially, a child dies of COVID-19 every day in the US. These were lives cut tragically short and each child leaves behind a grieving family.
Of course, death is the most severe, but not the only adverse outcome of contracting COVID-19. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, “Children were 1.2%-3.1% of total reported hospitalizations, and between 0.1%-1.9% of all child COVID-19 cases resulted in hospitalization”. A CDC report found that among 69,700 laboratory-confirmed cases of COVID-19 in children younger than 20 years, the hospitalization rate was 2.5-4.1%. Another study of 20,714 children with COVID-19 found that 2,430 (11.7%) were hospitalized.
Unfortunately, finding reliable data for the total number of children hospitalized this pandemic is difficult. Some sources account only for cases who were confirmed positive for COVID-19, while others try to estimate the actual number. Additionally, many states do not provide the age distribution of hospitalizations, and the age cut-off for children is not the same in each state. According to one CDC website, by December 2020, prior to the pandemic’s peak, nearly 192,000 children younger than 17-years had been hospitalized for COVID-19. According to other sources, even the CDC, the number of hospitalized children is substantially lower, perhaps 30,000 children were hospitalized in 2020. Regardless of the actual number, a non-trivial percentage of children who contract COVID-19 will need to be hospitalized.
Importantly, some of these children can be quite sick with multisystem inflammatory syndrome (discussed by Clay Jones). In fact, in one study, 33% of children admitted to the hospital need ICU-level care and 6% required invasive mechanical ventilation. 58% of the hospitalized children had no underlying medical condition. The most common underlying condition was obesity, which is present in 19.3% of American children. Hispanic children were hospitalized eight times more often than White children, and Black children were hospitalized five times more often than White children.
Moreover COVID-19 is a new disease, and we must consider that there may be long-term complications. Although the vast majority of people who contract the disease seem to fully recover, not all do. This is true for children as well. According to one study from Italy, “more than half of children aged between 6 and 16 years old who contract the virus have at least one symptom lasting more than 120 days, with 42.6 percent impaired by these symptoms during daily activities.” Some children haven’t recovered their ability to smell and taste. Time will tell if they ever will. Interestingly, many with “long-COVID” report feeling much better after being vaccinated, an area for further investigation.
Is COVID-19 an emergency for children? (Is it an emergency for teenagers over 16 years, who have already been vaccinated by the millions?) These are obviously subjective questions. However, none of these concrete harms to children were presented in the article by Drs. Pegden et al. They presented the risk to children simply as being “very low”.
Reasonable people may disagree about whether COVID-19 constitutes an emergency for children, however real harms of COVID-19 to children should have been presented to give the reader an informed view. Based on reaction to the article on Twitter, many readers erroneously believe COVID-19 is essentially completely harmless for children or much less dangerous than other vaccine-preventable diseases. In fact, the direct toll that COVID-19 has taken on children, even with much of normal life suspended, exceeds that of several other vaccine-preventable diseases (such as the flu, chickenpox, and even measles), before vaccines for these diseases were available.
Additionally, a recent study estimated that 43,000 American children lost a parent to COVID-19. While it is not clear how many of these adults contracted the disease from their child, it safe to speculate that some did. Parental loss was not mentioned in the article by Drs. Pegden et al.
How about the vaccines?
Second, let’s examine the vaccines, specifically the mRNA vaccines, which are most likely to be approved for children. I don’t think it is an exaggeration to say that these vaccines are the greatest scientific achievement of my lifetime. Drs. Pegden et al. agree, writing “the rapid development of highly effective COVID-19 vaccines is a triumph of science”. Hundreds of millions of doses of these vaccines have been administered so far, including millions of doses to teenagers 16 years and older, without a hitch so far.
Most importantly, the vaccine has been studied in a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study in children ages 12-15 years. The results were overwhelmingly positive. According to the press release from Pfizer, “The trial enrolled 2,260 adolescents 12 to 15 years of age in the United States. In the trial, 18 cases of COVID-19 were observed in the placebo group (n=1,129) versus none in the vaccinated group (n=1,131).” The press release further notes that the vaccine “was well tolerated, with side effects generally consistent with those observed in participants 16 to 25 years of age.” Children in this trial will continue to be monitored for two years.
This successful trial was not mentioned by Drs. Pegden et al.
It seems reasonable to expect that an article on the pediatric COVID-19 vaccine would at least mention a successful Phase 3 study on the vaccine in children, with the caveats that 1) it’s a press release and 2) that the full results have not yet been published. Notably, this follows the pattern for the vaccine trials in adult populations, where the full results were not published until after the EUA was issued. Of course, as with the EUA for adults, FDA regulators will rely on reams of trial data in deciding whether or not to authorize the vaccine for children, not just a press release.
Though the numbers are small, Israel has also vaccinated at least 600 children ages 12-15 years without problems. Additionally, Moderna also reported success with a randomized trial of 3,235 subjects. According to the company, its vaccine was 96% effective for adolescents ages 12-17 years and there were no serious safety concerns. This data was announced on May 6th, the day before the publication by Drs. Pegden et al., and was certainly too late to be included in their paper. Assuming the formal publications support this data (it would be a major scandal if they didn’t), this should add confidence that the vaccines are rigorously studied in children, and the results are very positive thus far. Canadian health official recently authorized the vaccine writing, “After completing a thorough and independent scientific review of the evidence, the Department has determined that this vaccine is safe and effective at preventing COVID-19 when used in children between 12 and 15 years of age.”
Further studies on younger children just started, and if all goes well, vaccines may be issued under an EUA for children ages 2-11 years by September 2021. The order of the trials and vaccine approval by age were set up this way purposefully. If the vaccine is safe and effective in 16 and 17-year-old children, as has been the case thus far, then there is every expectation this true 14 and 15-year-olds. Similarly, if real-world experience shows the vaccine is safe in 12 and 13-year-olds, it is not unreasonable to assume that it will be safe in children a few years younger than this, though of course independent studies are being done in these age groups. The system seems to be working. Pediatric trials have been halted for viral vector vaccines due to the rare risk of blood clots in young adults. This conscious ordering of vaccine-trials and likely authorization was not mentioned by Drs. Pegden et al.
Instead of discussing the successful trial of the COVID-19 vaccine in children and the logic underlying subsequent trials, the authors devote space to discussing the 1976 swine-flu vaccine fiasco which led to several cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome. Indeed, the only reference in their article was about this vaccine mishap, which they intended to serve as a warning about unintended consequences regarding vaccines. In fact, the vast majority of vaccine side effects, which are rare to begin with, occur less than two-months after vaccination, a crucial time frame as I will discuss. Though there have been tragic mishaps in the past, the overall history of vaccines should inspire great confidence in their safety. That vaccine effects almost never emerge after two-months was not discussed by Drs. Pegden et al.
While it is true that unexpected vaccine side effects might emerge, it is more likely that COVID-19 might do something unexpected. In Brazil, for example, 1,300 babies have died of COVID-19, though the reasons are likely multifactorial. It is not inconceivable that a COVID-19 variant could significantly affect children and spread widely before we could widely vaccinate children. Precaution against the unknown works in both directions.
An Emergency Use Authorization versus a license
Now let’s examine what is perhaps the core of the argument by Drs. Pegden et al. To be clear, they claim they are not against children being vaccinated against COVID-19. Rather, they are against most children being vaccinated under an EUA. They instead feel that “a wide rollout of child COVID-19 vaccines should follow the standard regulatory process as for most children”. They do say, “emergency use authorizations should be considered for children at genuinely high risk of serious complications from infection”. Recall however, that 58% of hospitalized children had no identified risk factor and about 15 million American children have obesity as a risk factor.
So, what is the difference, then between an EUA and the “standard regulatory process”? I honestly wasn’t sure, and the article by Drs. Pegden et al. does not discuss the difference at all. Since the article does not describe these core features of the regulatory program for COVID-19 vaccines, their readers may be left with the misimpression that a vaccine authorized for children under an EUA has not been rigorously tested in children. Based on reaction to the article on Twitter, this was certainly the case for many readers. Surveys already show that parents are reluctant to vaccinate their children, and articles implying that an EUA is significantly inferior to full FDA approval may further vaccine-hesitancy.
Importantly, the criteria for an EUA for a vaccine are appropriately stringent. Firstly, there has to be a determination “that there is an actual or significant potential for a domestic emergency.” On March 13, 2020, there was a Presidential declaration of a national emergency due to COVID-19. After an emergency is declared, the FDA can issue an EUA for a product under these conditions:
    • the product may be effective in diagnosing, treating, or preventing such disease or condition, based on the totality of the available scientific evidence;
    • the known and potential benefits of the product outweigh its known and potential risks; and
    • there is no adequate, approved, and available alternative to the product.
As far as I know, the regulations say nothing about differentiating between emergencies in different populations, such as children and adults. From a regulatory perspective, either there is an emergency or there isn’t.
With regard to the vaccine against COVID-19, the FDA put out a 24-page guideline specifying the manufacturing and testing criteria that must be met for a vaccine to receive an EUA. According to the FDA, “the issuance of an EUA would require a determination by FDA that the vaccine’s benefits outweigh its risks based on data from at least one well-designed Phase 3 clinical trial that demonstrates the vaccine’s safety and efficacy in a clear and compelling manner”. This guideline is not mentioned by Drs. Pegden et al.
FDA briefing documents are publicly available for each of the three COVID-19 vaccines authorized for adults under an EUA. They are 53-62 pages of dense data. The FDA explains its decision for each vaccine in an equally lengthy decision memorandum. Clearly, these documents are the product of substantial research and effort. These documents are not mentioned by Drs. Pegden et al.
Similarly, there is 24-page guideline specifying the manufacturing and testing criteria that must be met for a vaccine to receive licensure. This guideline is not mentioned by Drs. Pegden et al. The key difference between an EUA and full FDA-approval is the amount of time that has passed after the trials have been completed. Since the vast majority of vaccine side-effects occur shortly after vaccination, an EUA requires waiting two-months after completion of the full vaccination in the clinical trial. According to the FDA guideline:
Data from Phase 3 studies should include a median follow-up duration of at least two months after completion of the full vaccination regimen to help provide adequate information to assess a vaccine’s benefit-risk profile, including: adverse events; cases of severe COVID-19 disease among study subjects; and cases of COVID-19 occurring during the timeframe when adaptive (rather than innate) and memory immune responses to the vaccine would be responsible for a protective effect.
In contrast, when companies apply for full FDA approval</a, “Safety assessments throughout clinical development should include…Serious and other medically attended adverse events in all study participants for at least 6 months after completion of all study vaccinations”.
So, the key difference between an EUA and full FDA approval seems to be waiting two months versus six months after the completion of a Phase 3 trial. No extra testing is required, though assuredly the FDA will consider real-world data from the hundreds of millions of people who have received the vaccine under an EUA. Pfizer just submitted an application for full FDA approval in adults last week, nearly six months after they were granted an EUA. This process is expected to take several months. The full FDA approval is not based any new studies from those that led to the EUA. As a company executive explained, “We are pleased to work with U.S. regulators to seek approval of our COVID-19 vaccine based on our pivotal Phase 3 trial and follow-up data”. In order to get FDA approval, “Pfizer-BioNTech will have to comply with a key requirement: providing follow-up data six months after vaccinations.”
What happens if we wait?
Were we to wait for full FDA approval for children, it is unlikely that any child would be vaccinated before 2022. Despite the reduced risk of hospitalization and death from COVID-19 in children, such a delay poses unacceptable risk to the unvaccinated and under-vaccinated in the wider community, and would assure that the pandemic, and the potential for development of escape variants, stays with us that much longer. Schools may be less likely to open in the fall if fearful teachers resist returning to classrooms full of unvaccinated children.
To repeat, Drs. Pegden et al. argue that most children should be vaccinated only after the vaccine is approved by “standard regulatory process”. Their paper did not call for more or larger studies in children (which nobody would oppose), but rather a regulatory framework whose additional safety measure is waiting four additional months. In order for this delay to be of value, one would have to posit there is a significant vaccine side effect that is both unique to children and that it will only emerge between 2-6 months after vaccination at a high enough frequency that it will be detected under the limited structure of a clinical trial.
It is implausible that a full FDA approval would be substantially more likely to detect “rare adverse events” than the already stringent regulatory framework of an EUA, especially considering about 2 million teenagers older than 16 years have already been safely vaccinated thus far. On Twitter, Dr. Baral effectively conceded this point, writing that it is “unlikely to see major A/E (adverse events) in the trial” and that one “will only see rare outcomes with scale”. So what real advantage does the “standard regulatory process” confer over an EUA? Nothing that I can think of. Perhaps I am unaware of other safety features of the “standard regulatory process” that would make the vaccine meaningfully safer for children over an EUA. If these exist, the article does not say what they might be. Perhaps they find the 24-page FDA guideline for vaccine licensure deficient in some way? If so, they do not say.
A reasonable concern of the authors is that “controversy surrounding mass child vaccination under emergency use authorizations could feed vaccine hesitancy in the United States at a time when public attitudes towards vaccination are critical.” The authors are rightly fearful that adverse events in children would undermine confidence not just in the COVID-19 vaccine, but all vaccines.
Unfortunately, those of us who are familiar with the anti-vaccine movement know what is about to happen. Millions of children ages 12-15 years will soon be vaccinated against COVID-19. Horrible, improbable things will happen to a few of them. The media will write emotionally powerful stories about some these children. Parents of these children will implore others “not to make the same mistake I did”. The anti-vaccine movement will amplify and distort these tragedies to implicate the vaccine, though of course we must always keep an open-mind and consider that the vaccine is responsible. Anti-vaccine activists will claim the COVID-19 vaccines were “rushed” and “not properly studied”. Parents will be frightened. Of course, this has been the pattern with nearly every vaccine for years before COVID-19 emerged.
Drs. Pegden et al. would have us believe that this situation can be mitigated if only trial participants were followed for several additional months and the vaccine granted full FDA approval. Considering that the highly-studied, 50-year-old MMR vaccine is still inappropriately blamed for a wide assortment of maladies, it is implausible that a few more months of safety data and a different regulatory approval label would meaningfully refute anti-vaccine rhetoric and calm anxious parents.
A final point made by Drs. Pegden et al. is that given the high-efficacy of the COVID-19 vaccine, “future trajectories of hospitalizations and deaths will largely be determined by vaccination rates in adults”. In other words, high vaccine-uptake in adults will likely crush COVID-19 and obviate the need to vaccinate children. I certainly hope so, and data from highly-vaccinated countries such as Israel and the UK is very encouraging. Indeed the departing chief of the UK vaccine task force recently predicted that “sometime in August, we will have no circulating virus in the UK”.
However, currently in the US, our vaccine picture for adults is decidedly mixed. Our vaccine curve peaked in mid-April and vaccine-uptake is highly variable from one location to another. Only 33% of the population is fully vaccinated, and no state has over 50% of its citizens fully vaccinated. Maine is leading the way with 44.4%. Fourteen states have fully vaccinated less than 30% of their citizens. Even with these low numbers, states are currently turning down more shipments of vaccines as demand wanes. The low vaccination rates in many parts of the country were not mentioned by Drs. Pegden et al.
I hope this ages poorly, but given the large numbers of unvaccinated adults, COVID-19 is likely to remain a threat to American children for the foreseeable future, especially in regions of low-vaccine uptake. Many scientists doubt that the US will achieve the vaccination numbers needed for herd immunity. Given this, every opportunity to immunize a person against COVID-19 is an opportunity to protect individuals, prevent outbreaks, and exponential spread of the virus.Perhaps the most valid objection to vaccinating children in the US, one not addressed in the article, is that the pandemic is still raging in other parts of the world where vaccine-supply is highly limited. I am entirely sympathetic to the idea that it is unethical to vaccinate American children, while in most countries of the world, highly vulnerable adults remain unprotected. However, for political reasons, no country is going to be shipping large amounts of vaccine to other countries for the time being. As such, any vaccine unused by American children will sit unused in refrigerators for the foreseeable future.
Conclusion: It’s about what isn’t said
To summarize, the article by Drs. Pegden et al. does not mention that:
    • 482-582 children have died of COVID-19 in the US.
    • A non-trivial percentage of children who contract COVID-19 will need to be hospitalized.
    • One-third of hospitalized children require ICU level, care and 6% require invasive mechanical ventilation.
    • Over half of children hospitalized with COVID-19 had no underlying health condition.
    • 19% of American children are obese and therefore “high-risk.”
    • COVID-19 may cause long-term complications in children.
    • Tens of thousands of children have lost a parent due to COVID-19.
    • Millions of teenagers older than 16-years have been safely vaccinated so far.
    • A highly successful trial of the COVID-19 vaccine has been completed in adolescents. (Another successful trial has also been completed, with preliminary data just released).
    • Further vaccine trials (and presumed approvals) are proceeding in a purposeful, stepwise fashion by age.
    • An EUA for a COVID-19 vaccine requires a two-month waiting period and data “from at least one well-designed Phase 3 clinical trial that demonstrates the vaccine’s safety and efficacy in a clear and compelling manner.”
    • Vaccine side-effects almost never emerge after two months.
    • The core difference between an EUA and full FDA-approval is four additional months of observation after already-completed trials.
    • Vaccine rates in the US are unlikely to be high enough to achieve herd immunity, especially in certain regions.
The article by Drs. Pegden et al. does mention that:
    • The swine-flu vaccine caused Guillain-Barré syndrome in 1976.
Given these omissions, the authors fail to make that their case that an EUA is inappropriate for children or that waiting for a full FDA approval would add substantial safety benefit. Of course, I concede that unexpected adverse events might occur uniquely in children. Issuing an EUA is a calculated risk and that risk is not zero. That is why the stepwise approach being used and post-marketing surveillance are so crucial. Calls for extra “scrutiny” and “caution” sound nice, but they are just empty Pablum unless paired with concrete safety recommendations.
Fundamentally, the decision to vaccinate children is an all-or-nothing decision. There is no way to gently ease into a vaccination campaign in the middle of a pandemic. Either millions of children will be vaccinated over a short time frame or they won’t be. Given the obesity rates in America, even vaccinating children with a risk factor for severe outcome, as proposed, would potentially mean that millions of children would be vaccinated in a short time frame, the exact scenario the authors wish to avoid.
Millions of children have contracted already COVID-19 in the US. Millions more remain vulnerable. Were the vaccine to be delayed for the purposes of obtaining a different regulatory label the additional safety information would be extremely marginal. Although the overall rate would be low relative to adults, during this delay, many children would get sick, some would die, some would be hospitalized or suffer a long-term complication. Others would lose a parent. A safe and effective vaccine can prevent many of these tragedies. We should use it now for children older than 12 years and later for younger children, if supported by positive results from Phase 3 studies in this population.

New Study – mRNA Vaccines Safe
After more than 298 million doses give, the side effects of the mRNA vaccines are minimal and transient.
Steven Novella on March 9, 2022
Link

As we often discuss on SBM (most recently yesterday), clinical decision-making often follows a risk vs benefit model. For each medical intervention we need to consider both the risks and benefits of that intervention compared to other alternatives, including doing nothing. That is what we would consider an analytical approach, looking at all the data quantitatively. However, the typical human intuitive approach is to just consider the risks of the one intervention being considered. We tend to be risk-averse, and more averse to active risks than passive risks (from doing something rather than from not doing something).
Vaccines in general have perhaps the overall best risk vs benefit ratio of any type of medical intervention. The benefits can be profound and multi-layered, making one highly resistant to serious illness, and reducing the risk of spread and the emergence of new variants. A successful vaccine program can even eliminate an infectious illness from a community and in some cases (like smallpox) eradicate it from the world. The risks, meanwhile, are statistically minimal – but they are not zero.
Vaccine hesitancy remains a problem, however, mostly fueled by misinformation which is effective because people are risk averse. Fortunately it’s possible to gather massive data sets regarding most vaccines because they are a public health measure and are therefore given to many people. Getting vaccinated is also a recorded event and so it’s possible to track for correlations.
In late 2020, about a year into the COVID pandemic, two mRNA vaccines were introduced, Pfizer and Moderna. This is not an entirely new technology, but these were the first mRNA-based vaccines. They were both given emergency use authorization (EUA) based upon large clinical trials with tens of thousands of subjects followed over 3-6 months. Because we were (and are) in the middle of a serious pandemic the vaccines were rolled out based on this EUA prior to going through the full approval process, which took another 8-9 months. Some were concerned that a new type of vaccine was being rushed into people’s arms without adequate testing. This was never a legitimate concern – the research had been completed prior to the EUA and the delay to full authorization was merely due to red tape. Also, vaccine side effects typically emerge within 3 months of getting vaccinated, so while no one could ever promise zero risk, we could make a rational risk vs benefit assessment. These are highly effective vaccines with minimal risks.
Now, however, we have the benefit of being more than a year into the COVID vaccine program. More than 298 million doses of mRNA vaccines have been given in the US alone, and this represents a massive collection of data we can use to monitor the safety of these vaccines. That is just what a recently published study in The Lancet does. They look at two reporting systems, VAERS and v-safe. VAERS is the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System which is a passive system, people choose to report their vaccine side effects. V-safe, on the other hand, is a voluntary but active monitoring system, where people are sent texts and reminded to use an app to report their side effects in the days following a vaccine dose. Here is the quick summary of what they found:
VAERS processed 340 522 reports: 313 499 (92·1%) were non-serious, 22 527 (6·6%) were serious (non-death), and 4496 (1·3%) were deaths. Over half of 7 914 583 v-safe participants self-reported local and systemic reactogenicity, more frequently after dose two (4 068 447 [71·7%] of 5 674 420 participants for local reactogenicity and 4 018 920 [70·8%] for systemic) than after dose one (4 644 989 [68·6%] of 6 775 515 participants for local reactogenicity and 3 573 429 [52·7%] for systemic).
After nearly 300 million doses give there were 340,522 reported side effects in VAERS, but the vast majority of these (92.1%) were mild. There were 22,527 side effects that were considered serious, but these were mostly transient. Further, there were no new phenomena revealed in this data. We already knew about the rare side effect of myocarditis and rare serious allergic reactions. I wrote previously about the myocarditis side effect, which is rare and transitory. Anaphylaxis is also rare (0.025%) and all subjects recovered.
What about those 4,496 deaths? The anti-vaccine cranks have spread a lot of fear about those deaths, falsely assuming that they were caused by the vaccine. Of course, this is a correlation only. What we need to ask is – what would be the background death rate of the same population over a six month period? It turns out it would be exactly the same. Most of those deaths were in the older population (>60) who have a higher background mortality. The study detected no signal at all of any bump or change in the background mortality rate. The mRNA vaccines, put simply, do not increase the risk of death.
It is also worth pointing out that this data, again from over 298 million doses, was very similar to the data found in the clinical trials used to obtain EUA. What was new since then was the data on myocarditis and anaphylaxis, because these adverse events were too rare to pick up in the initial trials. But these side effects were known about before this current study, which did not detect any new risk signals.
What all this means is that the mRNA vaccines are extremely safe. Most people can expect a day or two of uncomfortable symptoms, but transient and not serious. Meanwhile, COVID itself is a serious illness. The risks from getting COVID, even if you are not in a vulnerable population, are orders of magnitude greater than the risks of the vaccine. The risk vs benefit analysis here is a no-brainer. Get vaccinated.

The FDA’s Proposed “Black Box” Warning for COVID-19 Vaccines
The real hazard is not the vaccines, but the warning itself
Henry Miller on December 23, 2025
Link

During my 15 years at the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as a medical reviewer of drugs and vaccines, Special Assistant to the Commissioner, and founding director of the Office of Biotechnology, I developed great respect for the Agency. Many of the professionals boasted deep expertise in their arcane fields of science, medicine, and regulation, and had been there for many years. Sometimes, I thought approvals were granted more slowly than necessary, but generally, appropriate caution and integrity dictated decisions that could affect the health and safety of millions of Americans.
Over the past year, all that has changed. Huge numbers of staff have been fired or resigned, and appointees to leadership posts have been inconceivably poor choices—unqualified; lacking respect for science and public health; being guided by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s unhinged, unscientific views; and making decisions that will undermine public health.
The worst may be yet to come.
For more than half a century, the FDA’s “black box” warning on drug labels has served as the agency’s strongest regulatory signal—a red flag reserved for medicines that carry a clear, serious, and well-established risk of death or irreversible harm. Opioids earn black boxes because they kill tens of thousands of Americans each year through addiction and overdose. ACAM2000, a live-virus smallpox and mpox vaccine used only in tightly controlled settings, carries one because of well-documented risks of myocarditis, encephalitis, and death. Isotretinoin (Accutane) bears one because it causes catastrophic birth defects if taken during pregnancy. Here is the black box warning on the label of Zyprexa, which is used to treat schizophrenia and bipolar disorder:
Against that backdrop, the reported plan by the FDA to impose a black box warning on COVID-19 vaccines is not merely misguided—it would constitute professional malfeasance that risks undermining one of the greatest public-health achievements of the past century.
No evidence
According to multiple reports, the proposal is being driven internally by Dr. Vinay Prasad, the rude, misguided FDA’s chief medical and scientific officer and director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER), with the approval of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a long-time vaccine critic. The plan has shocked outside experts because, quite simply, there is no evidentiary basis for it.
Following a tsunami of outrage from the scientific and medical communities about the negative impacts on public health that such a move would cause, FDA Commissioner Marty Makary backed down, saying on December 15th that there were no plans for it at this time. Many FDA-watchers, including this author, are unconvinced.
What a Black Box Warning Is—and What It Is Not
A black-box warning is not a neutral informational update. It is the FDA’s most aggressive regulatory communication via product labeling, intended to alert clinicians and patients to risks so grave that they may outweigh a product’s benefits or require extreme restrictions on its use.
When a black box appears at the top of a drug label, it sends a blunt message: This product can kill you or cause devastating harm.
The FDA does not use this tool lightly—or at least, it is not supposed to. Black box warnings typically follow copious amounts of accumulated data, clear causal links, and extensive public review. They are often accompanied by advisory committee meetings, safety communications, and transparent analyses explaining why the warning is justified.
None of that appears to be happening here.
As Harvard regulatory expert Dr. Aaron Kesselheim has noted, black box decisions usually involve a discernible process: public notification, advisory committee review, and open discussion of the evidence. In this case, there has been no advisory committee, no publicly released analysis, and no explanation of what new data—if any—justify elevating COVID-19 vaccines into the FDA’s most dangerous category.
The Safety Record the FDA Is Ignoring
The irony is difficult to miss. COVID-19 vaccines are among the most intensively studied medical products ever deployed.
Before authorization, they were tested in randomized, placebo-controlled trials involving roughly 75,000 participants. After authorization, they were administered to hundreds of millions of Americans and more than 13 billion people worldwide, with safety monitored through multiple overlapping systems: clinical trials, active surveillance networks, national registries, and pharmacovigilance programs across more than 90 countries.
A recently published update confirmed the long-term safety of the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines:
In this national cohort study of 28 million individuals [in France], the results found no increased risk of 4-year all-cause mortality in individuals aged 18 to 59 years vaccinated against COVID-19, further supporting the safety of the mRNA vaccines that are widely used worldwide.
The results are unequivocal. Serious adverse events are rare. Catastrophic outcomes are rarer, almost nonexistent.
Risk must always be balanced against benefits. One modeling study estimated that in the first year alone, COVID-19 vaccines averted nearly 20 million deaths worldwide. In the United States, they dramatically reduced hospitalizations, intensive care admissions, and deaths across every adult age group. More recently, CDC data show that during the 2024–25 respiratory virus season, vaccinated children had a substantially lower risk of COVID-related emergency department and urgent-care visits.
Against this overwhelming benefit, what is the alleged risk that justifies a black box?
Myocarditis: A Known Risk, Already Addressed
The administration has repeatedly pointed to myocarditis—heart inflammation—as a concern. But myocarditis associated with mRNA COVID-19 vaccines is neither common nor often serious.
It was detected early, investigated intensively, and transparently communicated by the CDC and FDA years ago. The risk was found to be highest in adolescent and young adult males, typically after the second dose given at a short interval following the first. Most cases were mild and resolved quickly with conservative treatment. Critically, U.S. surveillance has found no confirmed myocarditis-related deaths or heart transplants linked to mRNA vaccination in adolescents or young adults. [link?]
Moreover, the risk has declined substantially as dosing intervals were lengthened—a change made precisely because the regulatory system was functioning as intended.
These facts are already reflected in current labeling. In May, the FDA expanded existing warnings in prescribing information for Pfizer and Moderna COVID vaccines to note that the observed risk of myocarditis and pericarditis has been highest in males aged 12 through 24.
That is how safety regulation is supposed to work: proportionate, evidence-based, and responsive. A black box warning would represent a quantum leap beyond that—suggesting risks comparable to opioids or teratogenic drugs—without any comparable evidence.
Claims Without Data: A Regulatory Red Flag
The most alarming aspect of the proposal may be how little information has been provided to justify it.
In a late-November memo to CBER staff, Dr. Prasad claimed that FDA scientists had “found that at least 10 children have died after and because of receiving COVID-19 vaccination.” No ages. No medical histories. No vaccine brands. No timelines. No causal analyses. No public data.
That is not how vaccine safety science works.
As Dr. Fiona Havers, a former CDC epidemiologist who resigned over political interference, has emphasized, vaccines—like all medical interventions—can be temporally associated with rare adverse events. Determining causality requires detailed clinical review, background rate comparisons, and transparent methods. None of that has been shared.
Fear-mongering, plain and simple
To raise the specter of pediatric deaths while withholding evidence is not caution. It is fear-mongering, which has become an alarmingly familiar trademark of Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s HHS agencies.
Even more troubling, these claims are being amplified in an environment in which anti-vaccine organizations are openly pressuring regulators. Earlier this month, Children’s Health Defense—the nonprofit formerly led by HHS Secretary Kennedy—filed a citizen petition urging the FDA to revoke COVID-19 vaccine licenses altogether, arguing they are “misbranded.” That claim has been repeatedly rejected by courts, scientists, and regulators.
Process Abandoned, Politics Ascendant
The FDA’s legitimacy rests on one core principle: Decisions are made through transparent, evidence-based processes insulated from political pressure.
That principle is now in jeopardy.
Dr. Prasad himself is a controversial figure, known long before joining the FDA for outspoken criticism of COVID-19 vaccines and public health measures. His tumultuous tenure—appointment, resignation under pressure, and rapid reinstatement—has raised serious concerns about independence and governance within the agency. He has asked subordinates who disagree with him to tender their resignations.
The result, as one former federal health official put it, is “death by a thousand cuts”: a steady drip-drip-drip of messaging that exaggerates vaccine risks, minimizes benefits, and erodes public trust. Claims that vaccines are riskier when given together, that the day-of-birth dose of Hepatitis B vaccine should be delayed, or that children receive “too many” vaccines with “dangerous ingredients,” directly contradict decades of immunology and epidemiology.
A black box warning would be yet another life-threatening cut.
The Predictable Consequences
We do not need to speculate about what will happen if COVID-19 vaccines receive a black box warning. We have decades of evidence on how such warnings affect behavior: They reduce prescribing and deter patients from being vaccinated. Sometimes they are appropriate; sometimes they overshoot, leading to unintended harm. In psychiatry, for example, poorly communicated warnings have been associated with reduced treatment and worse outcomes.
Applied to COVID-19 vaccines, the consequences would be stark. Uptake would fall. Hesitant parents would opt out. Clinicians would face legal and ethical uncertainty. And preventable hospitalizations and deaths would rise—especially among older adults, immunocompromised people, and unvaccinated children.
As Dr. Angela Rasmussen, a virologist and co-editor-in-chief of the journal Vaccine, has noted, a black box warning signals that a product is inherently dangerous. That message would be broadcast not only to U.S. patients, but globally—handing anti-vaccine movements a powerful new talking point, stamped with FDA authority.
A Warning About the FDA Itself
Most alarming of all is what this episode signals about the FDA’s future.
If black box warnings can be imposed without transparent data, without advisory committee review, and without clear causal evidence—based instead on ideological opposition to a product—then no vaccine, and no drug, is safe from politicized regulation.
That would mark a fundamental break with the consensus that built the FDA into a world-class drug regulator.
It is bitterly ironic that this assault is occurring under an administration that inherits Operation Warp Speed—an unprecedented scientific and logistical success that delivered safe, effective vaccines in record time. What was once touted, correctly, as a triumph of American innovation and regulation is now being discredited by the very government that once claimed credit for it.
The Ethical Failure
Public-health communication carries moral weight. Governments have an obligation to convey risks accurately, proportionately, and in context. To emphasize speculative harms while ignoring documented benefits is not neutrality—it is distortion. It violates the ethical duty to protect the public with honest, complete information.
Rare adverse events should be studied. Signals should be investigated. But the bar for a black box warning is—and must remain—extraordinarily high.
On the evidence available, that bar has not been met. Not remotely.
A Line That Must Not Be Crossed
If the FDA proceeds with a black box warning for COVID-19 vaccines without releasing its data, convening independent experts, and demonstrating a clear, causal, life-threatening risk that outweighs enormous benefits, it will not be acting as a scientific regulator. It will be acting as a political instrument.
The cost will not be measured in headlines or lawsuits. It will be measured in missed vaccinations, overflowing hospitals, an increased burden of long COVID, and lives lost needlessly.
The real hazard is not the vaccines, but the warning itself.
    • 

Novavax: It’s the vaccine that scares antivaxxers, not moth DNA or any ingredient in any vaccine
The Novavax COVID-19 vaccine was recently granted emergency use approval by the FDA. Company executives and some public health officials have expressed hope that this recombinant protein-based vaccine will be more palatable to the vaccine-hesitant than existing vaccines using new (and therefore scarier) mRNA and adenovirus platforms. The reaction to the use of moth cells to produce the Novavax vaccine shows that It’s the vaccine, not any platform or ingredient.
David Gorski on July 25, 2022
Link

In stoking fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about vaccines, antivaxxers frequently try to induce disgust and revulsion. There have been many examples of this technique over the years, such as trying to portray vaccines as laden with horrific toxins (such as formaldehyde and mercury), ranting about the use of “monkey cells” or cells from other animals to make them, and claiming that they contain “fetal tissue” (or cells or DNA), with Mike Adams, for instance, going so far as to portray vaccines as child sacrifice in which doctors are “injecting the child with foreign DNA extracted from other children sacrificed at abortion centers”. (I can always count on Adams to provide me with examples of the most over-the-top version of any antivax tropes that I wish to discuss.) Over the years, I’ve seen antivaxxers demonize mercury, aluminum adjuvants, all manner of vaccine ingredients (as long as they can be made to sound scary to people without much knowledge of chemistry), technologies used to make the vaccines, and basically anything about vaccines that can make vaccines seem “dirty,” “contaminated,” and dangerous. The latest example bubbled up over the last couple of weeks over the Novavax COVID-19 vaccine, which was granted emergency use approval (EUA) earlier this month, which was soon portrayed in a similar light, with special attention being paid to the moth cells used to produce the protein antigen for the vaccine and, to a lesser extent, the choice of adjuvant for the vaccine.
Antivaxxers versus mRNA- and adenovirus based COVID-19 vaccines
Before discussing the misinformation about Novavax, I will briefly—for me!—recount how the latest version of antivax rhetoric portraying vaccines as toxin-laden and horrific had already been successfully employed against existing COVID-19 vaccines. In this case, the key tool that antivaxxers have used to spread FUD about COVID-19 vaccines has been the newness of the technologies used to develop them. Although introducing mRNA into muscle cells in order to provide them with the template to make a specific protein—in the case of COVID-19 vaccines, the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, which stimulates an immune response that also targets the virus—is an old technology, dating back more than three decades, the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA-based vaccines represent the first successful use of mRNA encased in lipid nanoparticles as a vaccine administered to hundreds of millions of people. This has led to the repurposing of old antivax fear mongering about how vaccines “alter your DNA” or are “transhumanism” to result in antivax claims about COVID-19 vaccines that they “permanently alter your DNA“—contaminating it with that deadly spike protein!—and, like attenuated live virus vaccines, lead to “shedding“. The same fears were expressed about the adenovirus-based COVID-19 vaccines, like Johnson & Johnson‘s. None of this is true and, as is almost always the case, the claims were based on distortions, misunderstandings, and misrepresentations of research and biology. However, such misinformation can seem believable to those without the background in molecular biology to recognize it as the BS that it is, which brings me to the Novavax COVID-19 vaccine.
The FDA grants an EUA for Novavax, and antivaxxers react
The Novavax COVID-19 vaccine was granted emergency use approval (EUA) a couple of weeks ago. This particular vaccine has long been viewed with hope because, instead of being an mRNA-based vaccine (like Pfizer and Moderna vaccines) or a viral vector-based vaccine (like the Johnson & Johnson vaccine), Novavax is a subunit protein vaccine. For instance, this article about the EUA in Politico noted:
The vaccine, a two-dose series administered three weeks apart, is manufactured using a lab-made spike protein produced in insect cells and an adjuvant obtained from the bark of a tree native to Chile, offering a different and older vaccine technology than is used in the messenger RNA vaccines and Johnson & Johnson shot. It is authorized for people ages 18 and older as a primary series, meaning the shot is intended for the roughly 10 percent of adults who have not yet received a Covid-19 vaccine.
Novavax executives have said they hope the shot will see uptake in individuals who have expressed hesitancy toward other Covid-19 vaccines or are allergic to components of the others’ ingredients.
“Today’s authorization offers adults in the United States who have not yet received a Covid-19 vaccine another option that meets the FDA’s rigorous standards for safety, effectiveness and manufacturing quality needed to support emergency use authorization,” FDA Commissioner Robert Califf said in a statement.
While I welcome new vaccines against COVID-19 (and Novavax appears to be a decent one), I’ve long been very skeptical of the Pollyannish hope expressed by public health officials and Novavax executives that this vaccine will somehow so reassure the vaccine-hesitant that they’ll finally—finally!—after more than a year and a half get vaccinated against COVID-19 because an “old school” vaccine that’s just protein and an adjuvant has been made available. Unfortunately, the history of the antivaccine movement and antivax fear mongering should have made it obvious that this would not happen. I expect that there might be some people for whom Novavax could possibly be the final development that reassures them enough to be vaccinated, but, as anyone who’s dealt with the antivaccine movement knows, it’s probably going to be a small number, nowhere near enough to have the seemingly “game changing” effect that I’ve seen predicted on occasion, for example:
I think everyone that’s already been vaccinated has been waiting for this option so we can all laugh at those that finding new excuses not to vaccinate
— SJGotUSA (@simon_gordon_) July 14, 2022
I’m not going to be as sarcastic as the person who responded to Dr. Griffin, but he’s correct. Only those utterly unaware of the history of the antivaccine movement could think that the introduction of Novavax will have an effect on vaccine hesitancy other than at the margins.
Those who follow my not-so-super-secret other blog will realize that I’ve already written about Novavax and the fear mongering that’s started about it. (Actually, the fear mongering started in 2020, when the project was first announced.) Although there will be overlap between this post and what I wrote last week, over the weekend I had an idea for a take that I wish I had included; so I’m going to discuss that take here. Also, I found out more about a certain purveyor of antivax misinformation and wanted to include that as well. So there’s overlap, but there’s also a lot more.
First, though, let’s recount what happened soon after the news that Novavax had been granted an EUA broke. Company executives and some public health officials had expressed hope that this recombinant protein-based vaccine will be more palatable to the vaccine-hesitant than existing vaccines using new (and therefore scarier) mRNA and adenovirus platforms, but the reaction to two aspects of the vaccine demonstrated that, for antivaxxers, it’s the vaccine, not any platform or ingredient, that’s scary, and unfortunately they have become very skilled at transmitting that fear to the vaccine-hesitant. This is a long-standing technique that needs to be addressed.
How Novavax is using baculovirus and moth cells
Before I discuss the antivaccine misinformation being used to stoke FUD about Novavax, I’ll start by describing the technology that is actually used to make the Novavax vaccine. Oddly enough, I found a good source for this on an antivax website, specifically the official website of Barbara Loe Fisher’s National Vaccine Information Center, where they posted a link to an old Washington Post video about Novavax under the title “How the Novavax Coronavirus Vaccine Uses Moth Cells“. I’ll include the video and a link to the original WaPo article for your information:
The video notes that the use of moth cells is nothing more than another technique to produce large quantities of recombinant protein to be used as the antigen in a vaccine, further pointing out that recombinant proteins produced by various techniques (like the use of baculovirus in moth cells) have long been used as antigens in vaccines against diseases like influenza, human papilloma virus (HPV) infection, and hepatitis B. Referring back to the Pollyannish optimism about such “old school” vaccines, I can’t help but mention that, of course, we’ve long known that antivaxxers never, ever, ever portray vaccines like these using recombinant proteins as their antigens as toxic ineffective sludge, right? I think you know the answer to that question if you’ve been reading this blog.
Of course, the baculovirus/insect cell expression system is nothing new. Baculovirus is a viral vector (like adenovirus, lentivirus, and a lot of other viruses commonly used in molecular biology) that’s long been recognized as a versatile system for expressing recombinant proteins in the lab. It’s mainly used to infect insect cells and, like other viral vectors, induce them to produce whatever protein is encoded by the DNA sequence inserted into them. Baculovirus-insect cell systems as a means of generating recombinant protein used to be fairly tedious in that it was difficult to engineer the virus and to isolate the proteins produced from the cells, but a lot of advancements in biochemistry and technology have made it much more feasible to use this system to generate the large amounts of high-quality recombinant protein needed to manufacture a vaccine like Novavax. Baculovirus systems are also in wide use in research for purposes like cell-based assays, gene function studies, and, of course, production of recombinant proteins. As an aside, one other advantage of baculovirus and insect cells is that they allow for the generation of recombinant protein at a much lower temperature. Mammalian cells are generally grown at 37°C; insect cells are often grown at 27°C. One way to look at the baculovirus-“moth cell” system is that it’s just another method for using viruses to produce recombinant proteins in eukaryotic cells.
In brief, this is how Novavax scientists make their vaccine:
     1.  Scientists selected the desired genes that code for the desired antigen, in this case as for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein.
     2.  They then put the genes into a baculovirus, an insect virus.
     3.  The baculovirus infects moth cells and replicates inside them.
     4.  These moth cells manufacture lots of spike protein.
     5.  The spike protein is then extracted and purified for use in the Novavax vaccine.
Again, one notes that baculovirus/insect cell expression systems have long been used to produce the protein antigen used in influenza vaccines. Indeed, a review article from 2006 shows the various methods by which baculovirus systems can be used to produce vaccines:

As you can see, the baculovirus expression system is indeed versatile, which is why baculovirus expression systems have been used to make vaccines for nearly two decades. Like all such systems, it has its advantages and disadvantages, one disadvantage being that it doesn’t always attach the right sugars to glycoproteins because insects don’t always attach the same sugars to their glycoproteins as mammals, but in many cases it can be an excellent choice to use to express recombinant protein. In the case being discussed, Novavax scientists inserted the genetic sequence encoding the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein into a baculovirus vector and then used this vector to infect ovary cells from the fall armyworm moth to produce large quantities of antigen for their vaccine. The scientific name for the species is Spodoptera frugiperda, which is why the cell line used with this particular baculovirus system is called Sf9. This cell line is a derivative of a cell line that has been around since the 1970s.
Novavax: Moth cells and DNA!
I’ll begin with the misinformation about Novavax based on the portrayal of the baculovirus/Sf9 expression system as “moth cells” that contaminate the vaccine with “moth DNA”. After the announcement of the EUA for Novavax, in a counterpoint to Dr. Griffin’s optimism it didn’t take long for me to start encountering Tweets like these:
so novavax uses GE moth cells which produce antibodies and will be better tolerated, but what are they fed? mRNA so not making real viral antibodies (no-one has been able to do that) you also get genetically engineered cell products but no passive immunity
— jay tay science (@JTayScience) July 16, 2022
This one was actually not quite so bad, simply claiming that Novavax is “genetically engineered” (and therefore presumably “unnatural”) and falsely stating that it won’t result in the production of “real viral antibodies” (whatever he means by that).
Others were a bit more…”critical”:
I’ll discuss the moth DNA angle in more detail shortly and conclude by comparing it to an example that more than a decade ago I used to write about quite a bit. In the meantime, let’s move on to this one:
Let’s just say that that video is…quite something. For one thing, if the blurb for the video is any indication, Dr. Jane Ruby appears not to know the difference between DNA and mRNA. Also, WTF? Ruby refers to Novavax as a “deadly moth DNA spike protein”? What did she do? Throw a bunch of random antivax words into a blender? In any case, Dr. Ruby has not been featured on SBM before, although she was once mentioned as being part of a lineup of speakers targeting the Orthodox Jewish community in Brooklyn with COVID-19 misinformation. Elsewhere, I note that she is one of the prime sources of the myth that COVID-19 vaccines cause “self-assembling” clots with “nanowires” that kill; she also promotes the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines are laden with graphene oxide.
Who is Dr. Ruby, though? Here’s what she claims on her website:
Dr. Jane Ruby is a medical professional and a pharmaceutical drug development expert with over 20 years of experience in regulatory processes for drug approval with the FDA and the EMA. She is also a published international health economist who has appeared on numerous TV and radio shows across America. Dr. Ruby worked on the human research studies to launch some of the most famous compounds in the world in Depression, Alzheimer’s disease, Addiction, and Cardio-pulmonary diseases.
If all that’s true (doubtful), where did Dr. Ruby go so wrong that she would spew such idiocy as in the video? It’s a hopeless question, I guess, given the long and depressing litany of health care professionals with advanced degrees who have become COVID-19 misinformation grifters since the pandemic started, a litany that includes, among many others, Peter McCullough, Robert Malone, Simone Gold, Stella Immanuel, the entire cast of the quack group America’s Frontline Doctors, and more doctors than I care to list here. However, as we will see later, Dr. Ruby is not actually a physician at all.
I must confess that I really struggled to get through the whole 18 minutes of Dr. Ruby’s video, because there was so much repetitive antivax nonsense in it that it actually made my brain, which has nearly 25 years of experience dealing with nonsense like this, hurt. Early in the video, Dr. Ruby mentions that she’s gotten lots of emails and questions about Novavax from people who refuse to take mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines who ask her if they should take Novavax instead, given that it’s not an mRNA vaccine, but rather a potentially more “acceptable” recombinant protein-based vaccine. On the surface, this would seem to support the idea that Novavax might entice those afraid of new mRNA technology in vaccines to accept an “old school” vaccine. It doesn’t. Predictably, Dr. Ruby’s answer is not only just a “No,” but an “Oh, hell no!” After that, she starts listing every antivax trope you can imagine about the vaccine, starting out by claiming that Novavax is no more a “vaccine” than the Pfizer or Moderna vaccines, which, as you’ll recall, were falsely characterized as “gene therapy” and not vaccines.
After I finished facepalming over Dr. Ruby’s claim that Novavax uses the same mRNA technology as the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, I was curious how someone claiming to knowledgeable about COVID-19 could say something so utterly at odds with molecular biology. So I kept watching. To explain what she means, Dr. Ruby references this illustration. I took a screenshot:

I just kept facepalming. Dr. Ruby went on and on and on about how supposedly Novavax is using “synthetic” codes for proteins “never before seen in nature”—she even uses the term “in silico”—to “stimulate moths” to make billions of copies of the “toxic spike protein” that they then extract noting that your body isn’t making the evil toxic spike protein (as is the case in mRNA vaccines) but that the moth cells are. This explanation, while technically correct (barely) deceptively conflates the use of a baculovirus containing the specific cDNA code to serve as the template for moth cells to make spike protein, which is later extracted, isolated, and used to make a more traditional protein-based vaccine, and the mRNA technology that induces the cells of the recipient of the vaccine to produce spike protein. Yes, mRNA serves as the final template for protein manufacture in both systems, but it’s not as though the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines involve harvesting cells from your deltoid muscle and isolating the spike protein being made by them due to the mRNA vaccine. This explanation is so deeply stupid that there are only two possible explanations. Either Dr. Ruby is deeply ignorant of some very basic molecular biology that was basic three decades ago when I first studied biochemistry and molecular biology, or she’s lying, knowing that her audience is deeply ignorant of very basic molecular biology. Take your pick. (I suspect the latter, but will concede that the former is quite possible.)
Dr. Ruby also describes how the spike protein is isolated with “moth DNA” that’s included in the nanoparticles, so that you still have a problem with a “genetic code that is going to embed in your cells and God knows what it’s going to create from the moths” and then you have “directly injected billions of these toxic spike proteins”, which will supposedly wreak havoc in your body, including causing infertility.
Dr. Ruby goes beyond that, though. In her world, apparently, those rendered infertile by Novavax will be the lucky ones. Why? Well, let her explain, as I suggest that I deserve hazard pay for taking the time to transcribe this passage:
If you are lucky enough to conceive—and this goes for all of these shots—the next generation through recombination of mom and dad’s genetic material can have offspring that will suffer and be damaged and freak—freak manifestations. We don’t even know what those are going to look like yet. So stop looking at Novavax as a possible safer alternative. To what? To tyranny? To a sick, psychopathic cabal that wants to damage God-given DNA forever and say, “Wooo, we’re better than God”?
She expands on this theme in other videos, such as “Ask Dr. Jane: If The Jab Changes Your DNA, Will It Show In Your Offspring“, but I will spare you the pain. (I couldn’t get through the video, even though it’s only 12 minutes long, because it was so bad that it made my brain hurt.)
This is very much like the idea of “purebloods” that antivaxxers co-opted from the Harry Potter novels, the idea being that, like the magical purebloods in the story, who are untainted by “muggle” (nonmagical) blood, those who are unvaccinated have “pure blood”. As I’ve long pointed out, a huge part of alternative medicine relies on the concept that “contamination” (these days more frequently referred to as “toxins”) cause most, if not all, disease, and various “detoxification” regimens that make up so much of alternative medicine (and, not coincidentally, the basis of many treatments for many conditions—like autism—that antivaxxers used to attribute to vaccines) have more in common with religious purification rituals than they do with science or medicine. The concept is so pervasive in antivax circles that sometimes antivaxxers would rather risk death than “contamination”. For example, Del Bigtree came dangerously close to death from bleeding hemorrhoids because he refused a transfusion with “vaccinated blood”. (I kid you not. Read the details if you don’t believe me.)
This concept of “purity” versus “contamination” (implied to be with evil) also has a lot to do with the idea that “natural immunity” to a disease and has so infected the discourse over COVID-19 vaccines that one of my go-to video clips when discussing this topic is of Brigadier General Jack D. Ripper from one of my favorite movies of all time, Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb explaining how fluoridation is a Communist plot to “sap and impurify” the “precious bodily fluids” of real Americans, mainly because anti-fluoridation, antivaccine, and anti-GMO pseudoscience all tap into the alternative medicine fear of “contamination” as a cause of ill health and “purity of essence” (again, from Dr. Strangelove) as key to good health. In this case, Dr. Ruby is portraying the vaccines as tampering with God-given purity and setting humans up as “better than God”.
In a truly facepalm-worth bit, Dr. Ruby then goes on to claim that Novavax “uses the mRNA technology” and that “it doesn’t make it safer and it doesn’t make it better” than mRNA vaccines, while repeating yet again that Novavax is “not a vaccine.” Rather, to Dr. Ruby, Novavax is a “toxic poison designed to change your DNA forever”, which, she notes, is the “long game” and the “endgame.” She then disingenuously claims that she’s not trying to “scare you”, just to scare you out of taking any more shots.
Then she moves on to the adjuvant, because of course she does.
“Deadly tree bark toxins”
Consistent with old antivax narratives, Dr. Ruby also complains about the use of “lipid nanoparticles” in the vaccine, just like the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines do! Specifically, she refers to the use of “tree bark toxins” as an adjuvant, as it turns out that, instead of using the aluminum-containing adjuvants that many older vaccines do, the Novavax vaccine uses a lipid adjuvant. This is a theme that has arisen about Novavax in antivaxland. Here’s an example from Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense claiming that the “nanoparticle adjuvant” (which Novavax calls “Matrix-M”) is horrifically harmful:
Nevertheless, in pre-COVID-19 studies of experimental vaccines containing Novavax’s Matrix-M, researchers waxed enthusiastic about the nanoparticle-based adjuvant’s “significant” and “potent” action — including its strong “immunostimulatory properties” even without any accompanying antigen.
And, where nanoparticles are concerned, the Novavax COVID-19 shot actually delivers a double whammy, combining Matrix-M with genetically engineered spike protein nanoparticles.
As Novavax explains it (for some reason putting the word “adjuvant” in quotes), “The spike protein is the ‘signal,’ but … we want your immune system to hear that signal loud and clear [and] that signal boost comes from our Matrix-M ‘adjuvant.'”
Matrix-M has been around a long time; for instance, here’s a study from a decade ago showing its immunostimulatory properties. Adjuvants, of course, have long been used to increase the immune reaction triggered by an antigen in a vaccine, thus allowing the use of much less protein; the most commonly used adjuvant is, as most of you know, aluminum. (And we all now that antivaxxers trust aluminum adjuvants, right? Just kidding! They hate aluminum adjuvants as much as they hate mRNA in vaccines!)
Where, however, did the bit about “tree bark” come from? It turns out that Matrix-M is a natural product, specifically a saponin derived from the soapbark tree (Quillaja saponaria), so-named because its bark contains saponins, which can be made into soap.
As noted in this study:
Saponins, particularly those obtained from Quillaja saponaria Molina, are known potent adjuvants and Quillaja saponins (QS) have for long been used in animal vaccines. Saponin-based adjuvants can be formulated in different ways; in free form [2], with aluminium hydroxide [3], in ISCOMs (immunostimulating complex) [4] or in ISCOM-Matrix/Matrix structures [5]. QS constitute a heterogeneous mixture of related but different chemical structures with various immunostimulatory activities, safety profiles and particle forming properties. By purification of the QS raw material, distinctive fractions with different characteristics can be defined.
The ISCOM, a potent adjuvant formulation first described in 1984 by Morein and co-workers [4], consist of stable complexes composed of saponin, cholesterol, phospholipid and incorporated antigen(s). The hallmarks of the ISCOM technology are the dose-sparing potential [6], induction of high and long-lasting antibody titers and potent T cell responses [7]. However, later it was shown that antigen incorporation is not critical for these immune properties. Antigen and empty ISCOMs i.e. ISCOM-Matrix/Matrix could simply be mixed with sustained vaccine efficacy [5]. In this study we use a novel adjuvant formulation based on two different Matrix particles made from two separate purified fractions of saponins, yielding Matrix-A™ and Matrix-C™ [8]. These Matrix particles, approximately 40 nm large, are subsequently mixed at defined ratios to get the Matrix-M™ adjuvant.
And there you have it! The dreaded nanoparticles! Recall how antivaxxers fear mongered about the lipid nanoparticles used in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines to encapsulate the mRNAs used and assist their entry into cells. Again, fear mongering about lipid nanoparticles is nothing more than the “toxins” gambit reborn and retooled for COVID-19 vaccines, sometimes with some truly off-the-wall versions. Given that Matrix-M is a form of lipid nanoparticle as well, the antivax attacks on the Novavax COVID-19 are very predictable. You’d think that antivaxxers, being all about “natural immunity” and “natural medicine”, would be more accepting of an adjuvant that is a natural product, the story of whose repurposing and sustainable production is actually quite fascinating.
Dr. Ruby spends several minutes basically saying the same sorts of things that RFK Jr.’s minions said, while bragging that “no one else” is warning about Matrix-M, even though RFK Jr. is spreading the same misinformation about it. In any case, the claim that vaccines cause autoimmune disorders, by whatever proposed mechanism (whether sort of plausible or completely fantastical), is an old antivax trope. In this case, RFK Jr. references antiphospholipid syndrome (APS), an autoimmune disorder characterized by recurring blood clots as well as fetal loss, fetal growth retardation and other obstetric complications. I might have to address this “hypothesis” (if you can call it that) in more detail in the future, as the same claims pop up over the lipid nanoparticles used in mRNA-based vaccines. Until then, I’ll just refer you to Yehuda Shoenfeld and ASIA as examples of how the false claim that vaccines have caused a massive increase in incidence of autoimmune disease started and persists.
And, of course, to Dr. Ruby and other antivaxxers like RFK Jr., because Novavax uses lipid nanoparticles, even though they are quite different from the lipid nanoparticles used by Pfizer and Moderna to encapsulate their vaccines, the Novavax vaccine must also cause infertility and all the other bad things that antivaxxers have been falsely blaming on lipid nanoparticles since the mRNA-based vaccines were first approved for use.
After suffering through her video, I started wondering: Who the heck is Dr. Ruby? The last time I wrote about this over at my not-so-super-secret other blog I didn’t really look too hard into this. I assumed that she was just some physician who used to work for pharmaceutical companies who somehow got into COVID-19 disinformation grift. While I was correct that Dr. Ruby is into disinformation grift, I was wrong to assume that she is a physician. I rather suspect that’s the whole point behind her shtick, as you will see.
Who is “Dr. Ruby”?
A search of PubMed for Dr. Ruby does show that at one point she worked for Medical Affairs at Endo Pharmaceuticals Inc. in Malvern, PA. She does appear to have 23 publications dating back to the 1990s, although most of them appear to be about outcomes of opioid treatment or concerning healthcare costs, not, as she claims, clinical trials of groundbreaking drugs. (If she did indeed do such work, it isn’t reflected in her PubMed record.) She also appears to have worked at various times for other pharmaceutical companies (SK Life Science, Pear Pharmaceuticals, Indivior, and Forest Laboratories, which is now Allergan) in HEOR (health economics and outcomes research). Before that she was a nurse and nurse practitioner/advanced practice nurse, not a physician, having gotten a masters in nursing at the University of Rochester. Now don’t get me wrong. I love NPs. I’ve defended them on many occasions against outlandish attacks by my fellow physicians. However, “Dr. Ruby” does not appear to have a doctorate even in nursing. What she does have are a PhD in psychology from Kennedy Western University in Psychology and a Doctor of Education (EdD) from the University of Rochester, as well as masters degrees in nursing and International Health Economics. One can’t help but conclude that Dr. Ruby is definitely trying to give the impression that she is a physician, complete with her frequently appearing with a stethoscope and lab coat. I’d be willing to bet that her audience thinks she’s a physician. She isn’t, and if her CV is any indication she hasn’t even practiced nursing for over 20 years.
These days, Dr. Ruby lists as her position President at Ruby Health Consulting – HEOR (again!), and, of course, she has her own show hosted on the Stew Peters Network, for which she made the video above. Just a perusal of this show, which is on Rumble, of course, shows that it’s a full-on right wing conspiracy and medical misinformation show. Don’t believe me? Just peruse the list of videos for yourself. Also, note how her sponsors include lots of companies marketing quackery and supplements, including her own “superfoods” line of products.
Again, one of the hallmarks of science denial is fake experts, often with credential inflation, and that’s what we have here. Not only does it appear that it’s been over two decades since Ruby has practiced nursing, advanced practice or otherwise, but there’s nothing that I’ve been able to find about Ruby’s history to suggest that she has any special expertise in the relevant fields of infectious disease, virology, molecular biology, epidemiology, immunology, or, well, any field relevant to commenting authoritatively on the safety and efficacy of vaccines other than—maybe, judging from her publication record—a bit of epidemiology in unrelated fields.
Her “credentials,” such as they are, do appear to be unfortunately more than adequate to provide a veneer of scientific expertise good enough to fool her audience.
It’s always the vaccines. Always.
None of the reaction to Novavax is a surprise to any of us who’ve been combatting antivaccine misinformation for a long time. It was entirely predictable that antivaxxers would latch onto the use of a moth cell line to portray the vaccine as “dirty”, foreign, and “contaminated”. As I like to point out, the idea that the animal used in the process of making vaccines dates back all the way to Edward Jenner’s time, as shown in this classic cartoon from the early 1800s portraying the fear of antivaxxers that the “cow pock” used to vaccinate against smallpox would turn people into cows:

Going back to the NVIC article citing the WaPo article with the video describing the use of moth cells to make spike protein. In the comments, a commenter named Pam observed:
I am not an entomologist but I do garden a lot and see many moths. Since the video only talked about proteins and mRNA, I wanted to know more about what moths can do to a human in general. Moths are of the paraphyletic group meaning many have a common ancestor. Does that suggest what affects one species genetically may affect other species? Not sure. Did they say what species of moth they used in the Novavax? I did some online research and found some moth caterpillar species cause lepidopterism (caterpillar dermatitis) if touched. Lymantria dispar, the spongy moth (has black and red spots in caterpillar stage) carries the NPV (spongy moth virus). Could this NPV make its way into moth vaccines? Would make a great sci-fi novel plot–every vaccinated person grows antennae and makes coccoons [sic]. The comment about “Mothman cometh” brought all sorts of sci-fi musings to mind. Have not gotten a vaccine since 2006 and won’t be wanting ANY soon. Adjuvants are on my no-list since the allergist said this may be what I react badly to when getting a vaccine. Being out in natural settings with Nature is wonderful. Science should stop messing with the genetic make-up of any living being. Sometimes the cure is worse than the disease.


Is Pam joking about Novavax turning its recipients into moths? My interpretation is that she was only partially joking. She is, however, echoing a very old antivax trope, namely the idea that vaccines somehow change your very essence to be more like the vaccine. In the 1800s, it was cows because cow pox lesions were used to vaccinate against smallpox. Now? It’s moths. The NVIC article, of course, is nothing new, just a resurrection of the same fear mongering about moth cells that had been going on ever since antivaxxers had discovered that spike protein to be used to manufacture Novavax was to be produced using a Baculovirus system and moth cells.
There are other examples, of course. For instance, you might remember how about a decade ago antivaxxers were making a big deal out of the use of monkey kidney cells to produce polio virus for the oral polio vaccine in the late 1950s and early 1960s, which Mike Adams, for instance, described as vaccines “routinely” containing “hidden cancer viruses derived from diseased monkeys”. While it is true that the oral polio vaccine was contaminated with a monkey cancer virus (SV40) during that time period, even though there is no good evidence that this contamination resulted in an increase in cancer.
A more direct predecessor to the claim that moth DNA from Novavax will somehow corrupt your DNA to the point that your offspring afterwards will be “freaks” is less obvious. The claim that moth DNA from Novavax will somehow wreak havoc in your body is very much of a piece with old antivax claims that the HPV vaccine will “contaminate” your DNA with stray fragments of DNA leftover from the production of other vaccines could “permanently alter your DNA” and wreak havoc in your body. For instance, one favorite antivax talking point before the pandemic was that there was sufficient resemblance between nucleotide sequences in HPV and some human genes that when HPV sequence got into human cells, it could result in “molecular mimicry” that would target the recipients for attack by the immune system and produce autoimmunity. (There’s no good evidence that this actually happens, as the amount of HPV DNA in HPV vaccines is truly minuscule.)
Another favorite antivax “mechanism” for vaccine-induced harm was the concept that human DNA from the cell lines (you know, those awful “fetal cells”) could get into cells in the central nervous system, recombine with the DNA in those cells, and produce proteins that the immune system “saw” as “altered self”, resulting in an autoimmune reaction that “damaged” the brain to cause autism. This particular idea provoked a lot of laughter among molecular biologists because of how antivax reporter Sharyl Attkisson (who’s since gone on to become an all-purpose conspiracy “reporter”) quoted the author of an antivax review article proposing this idea thusly:
Why could human DNA potentially cause brain damage? The way Ratajczak explained it to me: “Because it’s human DNA and recipients are humans, there’s homologous recombinaltion tiniker. That DNA is incorporated into the host DNA. Now it’s changed, altered self and body kills it. Where is this most expressed? The neurons of the brain. Now you have body killing the brain cells and it’s an ongoing inflammation. It doesn’t stop, it continues through the life of that individual.”
“Homologous recombinaltion tiniker” instead of homologous recombination (the actual process by which very similar pieces of DNA can integrate themselves into a genome) will never not be funny to me. It’s an idea that persists until today and has been applied to fear mongering about mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines. As much as the misspelling echoes through a very specific segment of those who oppose antivax disinformation even 11 years later, it’s the same idea, that vaccines somehow “contaminate you”.
Then there are adjuvants. It was easily predictable that any adjuvant used in a COVID-19 vaccine would be targeted by antivaxxers to be portrayed as horrific sludge that will kill you or, failing that, cause autoimmune disease. After all, aluminum adjuvants have long been a target of antivaxxers, who falsely describe it as “poison” that kills.
Of course, fear mongering about adjuvants, moth cells and DNA, fetal cells and DNA, HPV DNA, spike mRNA, lipid nanoparticles, and other vaccine ingredients, is just a subset of a larger antivaccine narrative, one that I like to refer to as the “toxins gambit“. It’s a narrative that seeks to portray vaccines as so riddled with horrific toxins and awful substances—aborted babies!—that you’d be crazy to inject them into your body. Two decades ago it was the mercury in the thimerosal preservative used in several childhood vaccines that was falsely blamed for autism, with evidence continuing to accumulate showing no link. Then it was the formaldehyde used to inactivate viruses used in vaccines – never mind that the body makes formaldehyde as a byproduct of metabolism and that the amount in vaccines is much smaller than the small amount that the body routinely makes. Then there’s the claim that there’s antifreeze in vaccines. There’s not. This claim was based on the confusion between ethylene glycol (which is in antifreeze) and polyethylene glycol (PEG), a polymer used in many topical and medical products. Basically, PEGylated drugs have been around a very long time.
I could go on and on, but I think that I’ve described enough examples. You get the idea. For antivaxxers, it’s all about the vaccines, not the ingredients, the adjuvants, the cells used to produce the antigen, or the platform used to make the vaccine. Prove that one of these is safe, and they’ll move the goalposts, effortlessly shifting to another. You could produce a vaccine that’s nothing other than protein antigen and buffered saline, and antivaxxers would find a way to blame the antigen and/or the saline. That’s because it’s vaccines and vaccination that frighten antivaxxers. The rest is just window dressing, made-up reasons antivaxxers find to justify their fears. Unfortunately, these antivaxxers then transmit those fears to those predisposed to distrust pharmaceutical companies, doctors, drugs, and all that is associated with them.
We have little choice but to play Whack-A-Mole to refute fear mongering about individual vaccine ingredients, but we shouldn’t forget that these are just distractions from the real issue: Vaccination itself. A common narrative among antivaxxers is that vaccines are “disease matter” injected “unnaturally” into the body. It is a potent narrative designed to cause revulsion, and it’s unfortunately very effective at that. It’s also the narrative that we most need to overcome far more than obviously ridiculous claims about “moth DNA” turning people into insects. It doesn’t matter if it’s recombinant protein and not whole virus that is used. It doesn’t matter if the antigen is produced by injected mRNA or just injected as protein. It’s the vaccines. It’s always been the vaccines. It will always be the vaccines.

The Effectiveness of COVID Vaccines

Steven Novella on October 22, 2025
Link

One of the common themes of SBM is that medical evidence can be very complex. In order to come to any robust conclusion about what the science says on any question you need to do a careful and thorough evaluation of all the relevant evidence, including plausibility as well as observational and experimental clinical evidence. Essentially we want to look at the question from every angle and make the best inference possible to the most likely answer.
What you cannot do is look at a single study, in the absence of any other context, and come to a firm conclusion about what the study says. You can sort-of do this with large rigorous clinical trials, but that is only because those trials sit on top of a mound of other research which tell us how to interpret that study, and told us how to design that study in the first place.
Despite this complex reality, the media and pundits will happily tout any individual study that makes good click-bait or appears to support their ideological stance or their partisan team. This means that SBM and other responsible science communicators have the endless task of trying to put those individual studies into a deeper context. It’s definitely a finger-in-the-dike situation, and worse, it takes much more effort explain all the complexity of a study than to just tout its apparent bottom-line finding. So we also try to give people the tools to at least understand how misleading individual studies can be.
With that background, there is a study going around with claims that the COVID vaccines increase the risk of contracting COVID. To be clear, the authors are not claiming this, and the study does not show this, but there are some unexpected and quirky results that superficially can be presented this way. Here is the quote from the results that people are focusing on: “The risk of COVID-19 also increased with time since the most recent prior COVID-19 episode and with the number of vaccine doses previously received.”
This is not a misquote or taken out-of-context – this is an accurate reflection of the data. The problem is with the interpretation of this result. This was an observational study, and as I have to endlessly point out, observational studies are not controlled and are therefore subject to confounding factors. It is extremely common for unusual confounding factors to rear their head in observational studies, resulting in counterintuitive results. The medical literature is rife with such studies – they don’t mean anything until the result is replicated and diced-and-sliced every way possible. Even then, it may take decades in some cases to hunt down and identify the confounding factor giving the quirky result.
What the study actually showed is that being vaccinated correlated with a lower risk of being diagnosed with COVID. They found: “The estimated vaccine effectiveness was 29% (95% confidence interval, 21%–37%), 20% (6%–31%), and 4% (−12% to 18%), during the BA.4/5-, BQ-, and XBB-dominant phases, respectively.” What they concluded was that the effectiveness at this time is modest and depends heavily on the strains of the virus that are dominant at the time. That was the point of the study – as the virus mutates, are the vaccines maintaining their effectiveness. As every expert in the world predicted, as the virus mutates the vaccine will become less well targeted. This is why boosters are necessary, as with the flu vaccine, to track the current dominant strain. What this study means is that perhaps we need to update the vaccine more frequently and better track this virus as it mutates.
So – if the vaccine reduces the chance of being infected, how is it possible that increased number of doses results in a greater chance of being infected? This makes no mechanistic sense. This result screams confounding factor. At this point we can only speculate what factors might be at work, and then perhaps do follow up studies to test those hypotheses. The authors speculate: “It is possible that the association of number of prior vaccine doses with increased risk of infection may have been confounded by time since last prior exposure to SARS-CoV-2.”
But there are many other possible confounding factors. People could take tests at home without ever being registered as infected. There could be many behavioral difference between those choosing to get vaccinated and those who do not. Perhaps, for example, being at high risk for infection causes people to take every booster shot. Also we need to keep in mind the overall infection rate was low, 8.7%. This means that small confounding effects could affect the outcome.
One major limiting factor of this study, in my opinion, is that it looked at infection but not markers of severity of infection. This is tricky because there are many things that affect whether or not someone who is infected gets diagnosed and documented. The door for confounding factors is wide open. It is far better, for an observational study, to use hard outcomes that are easier to track, such as ER visits, hospitalizations, and death. These are not free from confounding factors, but should be much less than mere infection status.
For example, here is a study from this month in the NEJM, which found:
“At 6 months of follow-up, the estimated vaccine effectiveness was 29.3% (95% confidence interval [CI], 19.1 to 39.2) against Covid-19–associated emergency department visits (risk difference per 10,000 persons, 18.3; 95% CI, 10.8 to 27.6), 39.2% (95% CI, 21.6 to 54.5) against Covid-19–associated hospitalizations (risk difference per 10,000 persons, 7.5; 95% CI, 3.4 to 13.0), and 64.0% (95% CI, 23.0 to 85.8) against Covid-19–associated deaths (risk difference per 10,000 persons, 2.2; 95% CI, 0.5 to 6.9).”
That’s a 29.3% reduction in ER visits, 39.2% reduction in hospitalizations, and a 64% reduction in COVID related deaths. These outcomes are easier to quantify, and are much more clinically relevant. It has also become clear over time that the vaccines are much better at preventing infections from being severe than preventing infection at all.
But of course, this is also a single study, so let’s look at a recent systematic review of 284 articles. They found that: “All the approved vaccines were found safe and efficacious but mRNA-based vaccines were found to be more efficacious against SARS-CoV-2 than other platforms.”
We can say with confidence, based on hundreds of studies, including the initial placebo-controlled trials, that the approved COVID vaccines are effective against COVID. They are better with strains that they track more closely. They are also better at reducing severe illness than completely preventing infection. But in every way – they are safe and effective.


Russian and Other COVID Vaccines
Russia’s approval of a COVID-19 vaccine is premature and counterproductive.
Steven Novella on August 12, 2020
Link

Recently Russia announced that they have approved the first vaccine for COVID-19, which they are calling Sputnik V. The reference to the first artificial satellite, arguably the most famous scientific and technical “win” for the former Soviet Union, reveals the propaganda angle of this approval (although it was pretty clear even without the name, which was a bit of overkill). The scientific community, however, does not seem as impressed as Putin would like, and this episode just revives concerns that the race to develop a vaccine for COVID-19 is coming at the expense of safety.
Scientific data was not released for Sputnik V, so we only have Russia’s overview to go by. They claim that clinical trials for the vaccine were started in mid-June, and that the vaccine produces “stable immunity”. I find these two statements to be contradictory. So at most we have two months of data, but most likely six weeks. After six weeks you can only determine that the vaccine produces antibodies for six weeks, which is not very long. Even if antibody titers are “stable” and not decreasing in that time, there is no guarantee they won’t plummet after 10 weeks or 16 weeks.
Further, the study only involved 76 participants. By all accounts this was a modest phase II clinical trial, used to determine safety and show that a clinical benefit is plausible. It is not a definitive efficacy trial, however – you cannot use this data to conclude that the vaccine works. Phase III clinical trials, with thousands or even tens of thousands of participants, are needed for that.
What we need is to give thousands of study participants the vaccine, and thousands more a dummy vaccine, and then observe them for at least several months to see how many of them contract COVID-19. Along the way their antibody and infection status would need to be objectively measured. To say that the vaccine works, we would need to see that those in the treatment group were significantly less likely to contract COVID-19 than the placebo group. You, of course, cannot get that data in six weeks with 76 participants.
The type of vaccine used is a live attenuated adenovirus, a virus that causes the common cold, modified with the spike proteins of SARS-CoV-2, so as to provoke immunity against that virus. Other vaccines in development use a similar approach.
Sputnik V is not further along in development than many other vaccines – Putin just decided to jump the gun and approve the vaccine prior to phase III testing. For example, a vaccine in development by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) and Moderna, Inc. of Cambridge, Massachusetts has also already completed a phase II trial (actually still ongoing but they published interim results) showing high levels of neutralizing antibodies, and good safety data. This is an mRNA vaccine. The data shows a better result from two doses 28 days apart than a single dose. They are now entering phase III clinical trials. Other vaccines are at a similar stage of research.
A good phase III clinical trial is going to take at least several months. Normally they would take years. The total time to develop vaccines is often 10-15 years, and so developing a COVID-19 vaccine essentially in one year is extremely expedited. What are the legitimate concerns this speedy development process raises?
Much of the time it takes to develop a new vaccine is due to regulatory inefficiency, not the science itself. So a lot of time can be removed simply by giving the highest priority to expedited review and approval along the way. There is also much you can do to speed up the science simply by throwing lots of resources at the process. If you have lots of labs and scientists with adequate funding researching a vaccine, it can happen quickly. Vaccine technology already exists, we are not starting from scratch. The research is mostly a matter of applying this proven technology to a new virus.
There are still a lot of unknowns, however. Every virus is different, and it has proven challenging to develop vaccines to other coronaviruses, such as SARS-CoV-1. We need to know, of course, that vaccines are safe – they don’t provoke a harmful immune activity. In rare circumstances, a vaccine response can even make infection more likely. The immune system is complex, and we cannot totally predict how it will response to our interventions. We need clinical trials to determine the net effect.
We also don’t know how effective the antibodies produced by a vaccine will be. Do they actually prevent infection, reduce the severity if infection occurs, and/or reduce the spread of the virus? And we need to know how to dose the vaccine and how long effective immunity lasts. Some vaccines require two, or even three doses, and some require frequent revaccination.
Of course, figuring all this out requires time. We cannot know that immunity lasts for a year, for example, until we have followed subjects for a year (which last time I checked, takes at least a year).
All of this has to be weighed against the fact that we are still in the grips of a pandemic. There is a risk vs. benefit calculation we have to make in expediting vaccine development. But there is a sweet spot – developing a vaccine as quickly as we can without significantly compromising safety or efficacy. By all account, Western companies who are developing vaccines are in the sweet spot, they are being transparent with their data, and they are being conservative with their claims (all markers of good science).
I am hopeful that one of the vaccines in development will legitimately cross the finish line by the end of the year (not just be prematurely declared victorious). But then we have to ramp up production and distribution. That is another factor to consider – we don’t want to waste time and resources producing millions or billions of doses of a vaccine that doesn’t work well, or produces only short-lived immunity. Diverting production and distribution resources to a vaccine that ultimately does not produce herd immunity will only delay rolling out a more effective vaccine.
There is also a public perception angle to all this. An effective vaccine campaign will require public buy-in (in non-totalitarian countries). Prematurely approving a vaccine for propaganda purposes is counterproductive to public perception. This will only stoke fears that the vaccine is being “rushed” (rather than properly expedited).
The ultimate goal is achieving sufficient herd immunity that the pandemic comes under control (whatever that eventually looks like). We want to get there as quickly as possible. It is increasingly looking like we will not get there without a vaccine, so this effort is critical. This is a time to double-down on science – which means we need good science, including transparency, rigorous methodology, honest interpretation of data, and not making claims that go beyond the evidence. Scientists and governments need to be honest with the world about the state of this pandemic and our efforts to fight it.
The Sputnik V episode, in this light, is extremely counterproductive. It does highlight the inherent contradiction between the needs of legitimate science and the culture of totalitarian societies. The two don’t mix.

COVID Vaccine Hesitancy
While many hope for a vaccine to help end the pandemic, vaccine hesitancy remains distressingly high.
Steven Novella on October 21, 2020
Link

We are entering what seems to be the third peak of the pandemic, or perhaps it’s the second wave after a double-peaked first wave. In any case, 220,000 people have died of the virus in the US alone, with about 60,000 new cases per day. Worldwide there are almost 400,000 new cases per day, and the curve is still going up. We can’t just extrapolate current trends into the future, because things can change. The pandemic can be somewhat unpredictable. But the data does not reveal any imminent end. We are still very much in the middle of this pandemic, and may not even be over the hump.
As I discussed recently, natural herd immunity is not going to end this, and we don’t want to take that path in any case. There was some hope that aggressive measures, such as social distancing and mask-wearing, might allow the pandemic to wash over us while minimizing the death and disease, but this virus is tenacious. When societies open back up or relax these measures, the pandemic comes right back. That doesn’t mean they don’t work – they flatten the curve, as intended, relieving stress on the medical infrastructure and buying us time.
The world seems ready to end this pandemic and get back to some semblance of what previously passed for normal, but that doesn’t mean we can just pretend it’s over. At this point it seems clear that our best hope is an effective vaccine. Right now there are 11 vaccines in advanced “Phase 3” clinical trials. Six have limited approval, but zero have approval for full use. The first vaccine to get full approval may make it over the finish line by the end of this year, or at least early next year, but it will likely take a full year to get widespread distribution. That is – if everything works out well. This is a tricky virus, with a complicated immune response, and so there are no guarantees.
Given the situation we are collectively in, you would think that the world would be clamoring for a vaccine. Make no mistake – many people and countries are. But given that this is our best hope out of this pandemic hell, it is amazing that large numbers of people are resistant to taking a vaccine when it comes out. A recent Axios poll of Americans found that the percentage of the public “likely to get the first generation COVID-19 vaccine as soon as it is available” is only 39%. This number has also been dropping recently, down from 47% in August.
A recent global survey found:
Of these, 71.5% of participants reported that they would be very or somewhat likely to take a COVID-19 vaccine, and 61.4% reported that they would accept their employer’s recommendation to do so. Differences in acceptance rates ranged from almost 90% (in China) to less than 55% (in Russia). Respondents reporting higher levels of trust in information from government sources were more likely to accept a vaccine and take their employer’s advice to do so.
Further,
In the U.S., 76% of respondents answered positively, 11% were negative, and 13% had no opinion.
Surveys like this can be tricky – how questions are phrased and the options offered can have a huge impact on the answer. A positive response in this survey was “somewhat” or “completely” agree with getting a vaccine, while negative was either complete refusal or hesitancy. It’s hard to predict what percentage of the public will actually get a vaccine once it’s out, but these figures do give us a glimpse. A lot will depend on the specifics of the vaccine, how it is approved, and how it is presented to the public. It also remains to be seen what level of acceptance will be necessary for herd immunity. If it is high, this level of vaccine hesitancy may be critical.
What I think all this points to is the need for any society to attend to its scientific literacy and critical thinking hygiene. We have allowed an anti-vaccine movement to simmer in our midst. We have allowed anti-science and conspiracy mongering sentiments to flourish, and we have allowed “alternative medicine” to take root in our institutions. These all erode the public understanding of science, public critical thinking skills, and trust in the institutions that underlie the scientific enterprise. There is no simple cause or solution to this chronic problem – we have literally written thousands of essays on this topic, and I cannot summarize them all here. I mostly want to point out that something like vulnerability to a deadly pandemic gets added to the list of “what’s the harm” when we talk about tolerance of pseudoscience, especially in medicine.
We also have to confront the fact that we elected a flagrantly anti-science president, who is, as I write this, fighting with and denigrating his own experts on dealing with the pandemic. Further, I first wrote in 2012 that Trump was an “anti-vaccine crank”. At the time I characterized him as a “celebrity” – but now he is the president. He only seems to have changed his tune on vaccines now that he thinks it will save him from his failed management of the pandemic.
Even worse, when the FDA came out with their guidelines on safely approving a COVID-19 vaccine, Trump and the White House pushed back on their guidelines, threatening to overrule them. This was a transparent attempt to politicize the process, rushing it through before election day. The FDA is already balancing safety with an emergency approval process; pushing them to rush further to meet a political timeline was disastrous. Eventually the Trump administration blinked, while the FDA stood firm, and their original recommendations will stand.
But all of this has had a negative effect of public confidence in the approval process. The public already knows that vaccines are being rushed through the scientific process. This is appropriate, as we are in the middle of a deadly pandemic. Everything in medicine is a risk vs. benefit calculation, and we simply cannot take years to approve a vaccine for SARS-CoV-2. But the public needs to also know that every care is being taken, so that the accelerated vaccine development process will be as safe as possible. In fact, in response to perceived government pressure, the pharmaceutical industry has responded with a pledge to not rush the process or to ask for approval before the scientific evidence is ready. The fact that such a pledge was even necessary speaks to the perception that governments are putting their thumbs on the scale.
We need to not only quickly develop a safe and effective vaccine, and then quickly manufacture and distribute this vaccine, we also need to do it in such a way that public confidence in the outcome is high. It will not help us if we push out a vaccine and not enough people agree to get it.
But we are also paying the price for decades of allowing conspiracy theories and anti-science to rot our public perception of and trust in scientific institutions. This is exactly why the scientific community must pay attention to such things. They need to understand and confront pseudoscience, which should be an integral part of academia, along with promoting the public understanding of science. The pandemic is just one of many ways in which the failure to do so can have dire consequences.

Deciding between a vaccine and…an infection?
A handy comparison of COVID-19 vaccines compared to COVID-19 infections.
Scott Gavura on December 10, 2020
Link

With the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine approval in the United Kingdom last week, and yesterday, in Canada, widespread vaccination programs are now ramping up in Europe and North America. It is worth noting (marveling, really) that we now have an authorized vaccine for a novel virus that was isolated less than a year ago. And so far, the data that have emerged on the efficacy of the major vaccine candidates has been impressive, far exceeding the modest expectations that many of us had when vaccination trials were launched several months ago.
Even before the pandemic there was a small but vocal anti-vaccine community, something that we at SBM have written about regularly since the blog’s inception. COVID-19 has paradoxically not silenced this group, but has accelerated and arguably grown their rhetoric to the point where widespread hesitancy to a COVID-19 vaccine has been reported in some countries. Amazingly, there are even those who still seem to believe that drugs like hydroxychloroquine are better than vaccination, because…vaccination is bad, apparently. And then there are those, like at least one US Senator, who seems to imply that a case of COVID-19 may actually be preferable to a vaccine. It’s like the measles parties, 2021 edition.
Concerns about vaccination may not be as uncommon as you might think, even when COVID-19 is killing thousands every day. With that in mind I developed a short table that might help the uncertain decide between the vaccine, getting a COVID-19 infection, and for the handful of people that still think it’s a useful COVID-19 therapy, hydroxychloroquine.
	The Vaccine (e.g., Pfizer-BioNTech)	A COVID-19 Infection	Hydroxychloroquine
Active ingredient	nucleoside-modified messenger RNA (modRNA) encoding the viral spike glycoprotein (S) of SARS-CoV-2	The SARS-CoV-2 virus	Hydroxychloroquine sulfate
Other ingredients	Lipids (to encase the RNA)
ALC-0315 = (4-hydroxybutyl)azanediyl)bis (hexane-6,1-diyl)bis(2-hexyldecanoate),
ALC-0159 = 2-[(polyethylene glycol)-2000]-N,N-ditetradecylacetamide
1,2-distearoyl-syn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPSC)
cholesterol
Salts (to balance the pH of the injection)
potassium chloride
monobasic potassium phosphate
sodium chloride
dibasic sodium phosphate dihydrate
Other
sucrose (to protect the nanoparticles in the frozen state)	None	Depends on brand, as generics are available.
One brand notes: Croscarmellose sodium, magnesium stearate, colloidal silicon dioxide, microcrystalline cellulose, hydroxypropyl cellulose, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, polyethylene glycol, and titanium dioxide.
Preservatives	None	None	None
Been around since	2020	2019	1955
How many have received it	Over 40,000 in the clinical trial (over 20,000 received the vaccine)	As of December 9, 2020, approximately 68.7 million.	Based on the six trials I previously reviewed, 6,853 patients in RCTs, of which 2,619 received hydroxychloroquine. Before the COVID-19 claims appeared, it has a long history of use. Most COVID-19 use has been outside a clinical trial.
Clinical effects	The chart from Pfizer’s briefing to the FDA is very impressive, where you can see (click to embiggen) efficacy appearing after only 14 days. Red line: cases in those that received placebo. Blue line: cases in vaccine recipients.	Varies from mild asymptomatic infection to severe disease with high mortality. Mortality rates vary by age, country, the presence of other diseases, etc. In the United States, the current case fatality rate is estimated at 1.9%.	Effective treatment for rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, and to prevent and treat malaria. Ineffective treatment for COVID-19.
Immunity efficacy (COVID-19)	Vaccine efficacy is estimated at 95% based on trial data reported to date.	N/A	None. All randomized controlled trials to date have shown no efficacy to prevent or treat COVID-19 infections.
Safety:
Short-term side effects	Few differences between the vaccine and control group with exception of injection site reactions (pain, etc). Some severe immune reactions have been reported in the United Kingdom in two people with a history of severe reactions – this will need to be continued to be monitored.	Most people experience mild symptoms. Some will progress to severe disease and some of these patients become critically ill. Most people recover after 2-6 weeks.	Headache, nausea and vomiting, allergic reactions, hepatic problems, hair loss.
Long-term side effects	Still being evaluated. Most side effects of vaccines appear in the first 60 days (the data that we have to date) but very rare side effects may not be identified until the vaccine is administered to many millions of people.	The long term effects of COVID-19 infections may linger for weeks to months in some people. COVID-19 infections can damage the heart, lungs, and brain. Some complications are irreversible. Fatigue is most commonly reported, followed by cough, headache and body ache. Prolonged illness is possible, even in those without underlying medical conditions. In a group called “long haulers”, full recovery is uncertain.	Long list of effects including retinopathy and retinal toxicity, cardiomyopathy, skin reactions, neuromuscular effects, and other effects, some of which can be fatal.
Risk of Recurrence	Unclear. Most of the cases in the vaccine group occurred in the two weeks after administration of the first shot, which is the time when an immune response would be developing. The duration of the immune response remains unclear and will become apparent over time and with follow-up of the current clinical trials. However, it is possible that immunity from the vaccine will be long-lasting.	Unclear. Most of those infected with COVID-19 produce antibodies against the virus. Some seemingly rare cases of re-infection have been documented but the actual incidence remains unknown (but is probably very low). How long natural immunity will last is unclear.	Confers no protection against COVID-19.
Cost	Most health systems will be providing vaccines to citizens at no cost.	Free	A one-month supply should cost less than $30.
Conclusion: The SARS-CoV-2 vaccine could end the pandemic
Evidence that has emerged on the Pfizer-BioNTech and also the Moderna vaccine give us good reason to be cautiously optimistic, perhaps for the first time in this pandemic. The fact that both of these vaccines show such high rates of efficacy is reassuring: Immunization of populations against this disease appears possible. These are the earliest days with these vaccines, however and there is a long road ahead of safety monitoring and follow-up as these vaccines are offered to thousands, and then millions of people. We will also see additional trials report and additional vaccines move forward for regulatory approval. It is absolutely possible that there will be some adverse events identified that we haven’t seen yet. It is also very likely that vaccines will be blamed for events that are completely unrelated to the vaccine itself. But the alternative is killing thousands of people per day and injuring countless others, just in the United States alone, in a trend that continues to worsen with no end in sight. This is the largest logistical and immunization event of its kind in history. And we need it now.

Christian Elliot’s “18 Reasons I Won’t Be Getting a Covid Vaccine”: Viral antivaccine misinformation
Christian Elliot is a self-proclaimed “natural health nerd” and entrepreneur who recently published 18 reasons why he wouldn’t take the COVID-19 vaccine. Unfortunately, it’s viral disinformation based on conspiracy theories, bad science, pseudoscience, and nonsense.
David Gorski on April 19, 2021
Link

As a general practice, I tend to be reluctant to do point-by-point rebuttals of listicles published by antivaxxers, quacks, conspiracy theorists, and other cranks, not so much because it isn’t worthwhile to do so, but generally because, the longer the listicle, the longer the rebuttal. Worse, these disinformation vehicles tend to be written in such a way that each rebuttal tends to take a lot of verbiage, ballooning the rebuttal to levels of verbosity that to make even me hesitate. Still, enough readers have sent me a post by someone named Christian Elliot that appeared last week on Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivaccine website Children’s Health Defense entitled “18 Reasons I Won’t Be Getting a COVID Vaccine”. Apparently, he originally published it on his own website, Deconstructing Conventional, a week and a half before that. Somehow I missed it when it first showed up, but it apparently took a week or two to go seriously viral, and now I’m seeing both versions everywhere, posted by antivaxxers as though they were Gospel about COVID-19 vaccines. In fact, Mr. Elliot’s listicle is nothing more than a “greatest hits” of antivaccine tropes, both general and specific to COVID-19 vaccines, all gathered in one handy place for antivaxxers to share. No wonder his post went viral.
I also note rather amusingly how Mr. Elliot tries to tone police right off the bat, before he even gets into his litany of antivaccine disinformation:
THREE GROUND RULES FOR DISCUSSION
If you care to engage on this topic with me, excellent.
Here are the rules…
I am more than happy to correspond with you if…
     1.  You are respectful and treat me the way you would want to be treated.
     2.  You ask genuinely thoughtful questions about what makes sense to you.
     3.  You make your points using sound logic and don’t hide behind links or the word “science.” In other words, make a kind, level-headed argument (links welcome), but don’t just post a link and say “read the science.” That’s intellectually lazy.
If you do respond, and you break any of those rules, your comments will be ignored/deleted.
With that out of the way, let me say this…
I don’t know everything, but so far no one has been able to answer the objections below.
First of all, I’m guessing that if he sees this post Mr. Elliot will use my referring to him as an antivaxxer (which, given the way he parrots easily debunked antivax tropes, he undoubtedly is) as a convenient excuse to ignore this post. Second I will not be constrained by #3. Given that the tropes Mr. Elliot lays down are so common (and some so old) that we’ve written about them here (and I’ve written about them elsewhere), what I will do is try to provide a brief “CliffsNotes” version of why the item is misinformation, but include in the text relevant links to detailed deconstructions for those who are interested in learning more. If Mr. Elliot doesn’t like it, I don’t care. My purpose is to provide a link for vaccine advocates to use to quickly refute Mr. Elliot’s disinformation.
Before I dive in for real, there’s one other thing. Never having heard of Mr. Elliot before, I had to see just who this guy is. He’s in his 40s and describes himself as a “natural health nerd” (not a good sign) who has managed “to take my brain that loves strategy, complexity, and finding angles other people miss, and combine those skills into something people pay me for”. He also describes himself at 27 as thinking his “best health was behind him” but who 17 years later is “one of the fittest people I know…and showing no signs of slowing down”. He also states, “I stay as objective as I can, but I’m not afraid to pick a fight when I see bad approaches that don’t help people solve problems”. Well, if you spread antivaccine disinformation about safe and effective vaccines in the middle of a pandemic, I will be more than happy to “pick a fight” with you to counter your antivaccine propaganda, particularly when you spread germ theory denial, as shown in his posts, “Why I’m Not Afraid of Germs…Including the Corona Virus” and “The Impracticality of Fearing Germs” (the latter of which advocates useless preventatives for COVID-19, such as hydroxychloroquine and zinc and repeats the lie that most people die “with” COVID-19 than “of” COVID-19). They’re basically just rehashes of common germ theory denial tropes invoking “terrain theory”, the old hypothesis that germs are not the primary cause of disease but rather can only cause disease when the “terrain” (the body) allows it. Germ theory denial has long been a major strain in alternative medicine “thought” (such as it is); it’s attractive because it allows people to think that they can make themselves virtually immune to infectious disease if they just eat the right foods, use the right supplements, and live the right lifestyle. You’d think that a global pandemic that’s killed 3 million people worldwide so far, with the death toll in the US approaching 600K, would quash germ theory denial, but unfortunately it is still thriving in the age of COVID-19, and Mr. Elliot is just one more example of that unfortunate phenomenon.
Now, let’s dig in. The first is a hoary old antivax trope that seemed ancient even before I even started paying much attention to the antivaccine movement:
#1: VACCINE MAKERS ARE IMMUNE FROM LIABILITY
The only industry in the world that bears no liability for injuries or deaths resulting from their products, are vaccine makers.
First established in 1986 with the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act, and reinforced by the PREP Act, vaccine makers cannot be sued, even if they are shown to be negligent.
This is a half-truth that antivaxxers just love. It’s a half-truth in that, yes, the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986 did require that claims for vaccine injury go through a special “Vaccine Court”, setting up a system called the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP or VICP), with the compensation fund funded by a tax on each dose of vaccine. However, the reason for this act was that there were so many dubious lawsuits being filed in the wake of the scare over the DPT vaccine in the 1980s that there was a real fear that vaccine manufacturers would simply stop supplying vaccines to the US due to liability concerns. Moreover, as I’ve discussed many times, the Vaccine Court is actually an easier court for complainants than standard civil court. The standards of evidence are, as has been described, 50% and a feather, the court allows “theories of causation” that no regular court would allow, and there are certain “table injuries” known to be caused by vaccines for which compensation is automatic. Even better for complainants, win or lose, the Court pays reasonable court costs. Moreover, if complainants fail, they can still take their case to federal civil court. The law only mandates that they first go through the Vaccine Court.
I also like to point out that lawyers really, really, really hate the Vaccine Court, not because its evidentiary standards are as easy can be for a court, but because they want really big payouts (and their nice cut of those payouts) and are willing to lose a bunch of cases if they can, every so often, hit the jackpot. Certainly, they seem prefer gambling in hopes of a huge judgment or settlement to working on cases that guarantee they’ll be paid for their billable hours and expenses. (How boring.) Also, even though it tends to give parents the benefit of the doubt and allow somewhat more questionable injuries to be compensated than a regular civil court would, the Vaccine Court does generally do a pretty good job (occasional exceptions aside) of sticking to the science. That means it doesn’t compensate for “vaccine-induced autism”, because there is no good scientific evidence that vaccines can cause autism.
I also can’t help but note that Mr. Elliot is ignorant, too. I’d be more concerned that COVID-19 vaccines, because they are not yet fully FDA approved and are being distributed under an emergency use authorization (EUA), aren’t even covered by the NCVIA, but rather a more restrictive system. Mr. Elliot did mention the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP), but apparently didn’t really know its significance, and vaccine advocates actually want COVID-19 vaccines to be under the VICP.
Next up:
#2: THE CHECKERED PAST OF THE VACCINE COMPANIES
The four major companies who are making these covid vaccines are/have either:
     1.  Never brought a vaccine to market before covid (Moderna and Johnson & Johnson).
     2.  Are serial felons (Pfizer, and Astra Zeneca).
     3.  Are both (Johnson & Johnson).
Moderna had been trying to “Modernize our RNA” (thus the company name)–for years, but had never successfully brought ANY product to market–how nice for them to get a major cash infusion from the government to keep trying.
In fact, all major vaccine makers (save Moderna) have paid out tens of billions of dollars in damages for other products they brought to market when they knew those products would cause injuries and death–see Vioxx, Bextra, Celebrex, Thalidomide, and Opioids as a few examples.
I’ve had my problems with Moderna and its overenthusiastic promotion of its mRNA technology, but it’s actually ended up doing much better than I had expected. In any event, Mr. Elliot asks: “Given the free pass from liability, and the checkered past of these companies, why would we assume that all their vaccines are safe and made completely above board?”
First, I note my response to #1. These companies do not have a “free pass”. Second, no one denies that pharmaceutical companies have, from time to time, not been the best companies in the world. Yes, some of them have paid large judgments and settlements, albeit not for vaccines. However, Mr. Elliot intentionally ignores the fact that the vaccine safety monitoring system in place for COVID-19 vaccines is, because of the unprecedented level of the crisis and the release of so many millions of doses of vaccine in such a short period of time before full FDA approval, quite remarkable in how well it’s doing. Adverse events are regularly reported (and regularly weaponized by antivaxxers like Mr. Elliot, even when they are incredibly unlikely to have been caused by the vaccine), and the safety monitoring system has picked up adverse events that are literally one-in-a-million, such as cerebral venous sinus thromboses, with the FDA acting on them rapidly to issue a pause in the use of the vaccine associated with the adverse events. It is not as though we are, as Mr. Elliot seems to be implying, just trusting the word of pharmaceutical companies and vaccine manufacturers. They are under intense scrutiny, not just by government regulatory agencies but by the press, and even in normal times there are multiple vaccine safety monitoring systems, one passive and multiple active.
Moreover, all the current vaccines for which the FDA has issued EUAs have completed phase 1, 2, and 3 clinical trials, with the number of patients in the phase 3 trials numbering in the many tens of thousands total between the vaccines. These vaccines are very likely ultimately to receive full FDA approval; it’s just that, in the middle of a pandemic, there hasn’t been enough time to complete the full monitoring process. Meanwhile, it’s not as though the FDA and government oversight agencies haven’t kept an eye on vaccine makers and their claims, such as when AstraZeneca got slapped down for issuing efficacy estimates for its vaccine based on outdated data.
As for the lack of experience in vaccine development cited by Mr. Elliot for Johnson & Johnson and Moderna, yes, Moderna is a startup, but J&J is a very large pharmaceutical company that’s been around for a long time and has developed and manufactured a huge number of pharmaceutical and medical device products.
I’ll finish here by noting that Mr. Elliot repeats the claim that the J&J vaccine “contains tissues from aborted fetal cells”. No, it does not, and the claim that vaccines contain “tissues” from aborted fetuses or contain “aborted fetal cells” is a common antivax trope based on the use of cell lines derived from fetuses aborted 50 or 60 years ago to make virus stock for vaccine manufacturing. Even the Catholic Church states that these vaccines are acceptable for Catholics to use, and it has said the same about COVID-19 vaccines.
On to #3:
#3: THE UGLY HISTORY OF ATTEMPTS TO MAKE CORONAVIRUS VACCINES
Excerpt:
When that happened, an unexplained phenomenon called Antibody Dependent Enhancement (ADE) also known as Vaccine Enhanced Disease (VED) occurred where the immune system produced a “cytokine storm” (i.e. overwhelmingly attacked the body), and the children/animals died.
Here’s the lingering issue…
The vaccine makers have no data to suggest their rushed vaccines have overcome that problem.
In other words, never before has any attempt to make a coronavirus vaccine been successful, nor has the gene-therapy technology that is mRNA “vaccines” been safely brought to market, but hey, since they had billions of dollars in government funding, I’m sure they figured that out.
I note that Mr. Elliot is using another favorite antivaccine distortion, namely that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are “gene therapy”. It is true that, early on in the development of COVID-19 vaccines, there were concerns, based on the issues listed by Mr. Elliot, that the phenomenon on antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE) might preclude the development of COVID-19 vaccines. These issues had stymied the development of vaccines against the original SARS and MERS coronaviruses, after all. However, as I like to say, it is now April 2021, not April 2020, and we have lots of data, both from the phase 3 clinical trials of the currently authorized vaccines and from 190 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines administered in the US alone that demonstrate this does not happen at a rate detectable by the same vaccine safety monitoring system that has detected one-in-a-million adverse events after COVID-19 vaccines. Mr. Elliot also ignored later science that showed that ADE is a problem mainly in vaccines that do not produce high enough levels of neutralizing antibody. And, again, hundreds of millions of doses of vaccine have been administered worldwide, and this problem has simply not been observed.
It’s actually a very common antivaccine tactic to focus on a potential problem with a vaccine considered early on in its development and then to ignore all the subsequent science that shows the problem not to have been observed, and Mr. Elliot doubles down on this nonsense in #4 before moving on:
#4: THE “DATA GAPS” SUBMITTED TO THE FDA BY THE VACCINE MAKERS
When vaccine makers submitted their papers to the FDA for the Emergency Use Authorization (Note: An EUA is not the same as a full FDA approval), among the many “Data Gaps” they reported was that they have nothing in their trials to suggest they overcame that pesky problem of Vaccine Enhanced Disease.
They simply don’t know–i.e. they have no idea if the vaccines they’ve made will also produce the same cytokine storm (and deaths) as previous attempts at such products.
Again, no such problems were observed in the phase 3 clinical trials, and, again, Mr. Elliot ignores the data after hundreds of millions of doses of vaccine that show that this is not a problem. I guess if you tell the big lie often enough…
Mr. Elliot also bemoans the lack of data on this:
If that’s not alarming enough, here are other gaps in the data–i.e. there is no data to suggest safety or efficacy regarding:
    • Anyone younger than age 18 or older than age 55
    • Pregnant or lactating mothers
    • Auto-immune conditions
    • Immunocompromised individuals
    • No data on transmission of covid
    • No data on preventing mortality from covid
    • No data on duration of protection from covid
Hard to believe right?
I’m seeing a pattern here. Yes, there was or no data on these issues at the time of the EUA submission. However, to say there is “no data” now, in April 2021, is extremely dishonest and ignores all the experience and safety monitoring after millions upon millions of doses. For instance, evidence is mounting that these vaccines do prevent transmission and mortality, and we know that the protection lasts at least six months, and likely much longer. We also know that vaccine-induced immunity is probably more potent than the immunity that comes after natural infection. Meanwhile, the hundreds of millions of doses have not turned up safety signals in the individuals about which Mr. Elliot is so very, very concerned. I also find it odd that lack of data on people younger than age 18 or older than 55, in pregnant or lactating mothers, or people with autoimmune conditions or immunocompromised individuals would be a deterrent to Mr. Elliot receiving the vaccine. He’s none of those things, right?
Then, Mr. Elliot brings this up:
#5: “No Access to the Raw Data from the Trials”
Specifically:
Would you like to see the raw data that produced the “90% and 95% effective” claims touted in the news?
Me too…
But they won’t let us see that data.
As pointed out in the BMJ, something about the Pfizer and Moderna efficacy claims smells really funny.
There were “3,410 total cases of suspected, but unconfirmed covid-19 in the overall study population, 1,594 occurred in the vaccine group vs. 1,816 in the placebo group.”
Wait…what?
Yes, Mr. Elliot is channeling The BMJ‘s antivaccine associate editor Peter Doshi, whose affiliation with The BMJ continues to do damage when he writes deceptive blog posts like the one cited by Mr. Elliot. Mr. Doshi’s claims are deceptive, as John Skylar notes:
Before you read that, I want to emphasize that Dr. Doshi is just wrong. He claims that the clinical trials for the vaccines contained a design flaw that has made them miss a large number of cases of COVID-19. Specifically, he believes it is inappropriate that they measured only confirmed cases of COVID-19 rather than looking at suspected cases of COVID-19. His argument is that if you look at suspected cases, you see a vaccine efficacy of only about 19%, where looking at confirmed cases gives an efficacy of 95%.
The thing is, this analysis is wildly flawed. Dr. Doshi conveniently ignores the fact that many of the suspected cases turned out to be negative for SARS-CoV-2 infection. So many, in fact, that it would suggest that PCR tests only correctly detect 5% of tested cases. We know this isn’t the case.
While it is probable that some positive cases were missed, it is unlikely that this is a very substantial number.
It turns out that removing these cases has no material effect on the efficacy estimates.
To be honest, I’m slightly torn here, as I noted at the time. Yes, access to raw data is desirable. Transparency is generally a good thing in science. However, in the case of any clinical trial, be it for a COVID-19 vaccine or any other drug, the question is: “When?” In general, clinical trial raw data are not made public at least until after the clinical trial is completed, sometimes not at all, our trust being placed in government regulatory agencies to evaluate the trial data. Maybe that should change as a result of the pandemic. Be that as it may, Peter Doshi’s demands for “transparency” struck me as very self-serving in that there are a huge contingent of people like him (and Mr. Elliot) out there, waiting to go through the clinical trial raw data with a fine tooth comb looking for even the smallest anomalies (of which there will always be at least a few in any large clinical trial, given that human beings are not perfect and no clinical trial is perfect) that they can use to sow fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the vaccines, whether justified or not. None of this changes my assessment of #5 as deceptive and, even if valid, superseded by much more recent data.
On to #6:
#6: NO LONG-TERM SAFETY TESTING
Obviously, with products that have only been on the market a few months, we have no long-term safety data.
In other words, we have no idea what this product will do in the body months or years from now–for ANY population.
Given all the risks above (risks that ALL pharmaceutical products have), would it not be prudent to wait to see if the worst-case scenarios have indeed been avoided?
This is yet another common antivaccine trope that’s been used about vaccines as long as I can remember, even long before the pandemic. It’s tempting just to respond that, to antivaxxers, no amount of “long term safety testing” is ever enough to convince them that a vaccine is safe. That being said, in fairness I must note that it is true that these vaccines have only been distributed for four months and were developed in less than a year, even as I note that the technologies behind the vaccines (mRNA-based and adenovirus-based) had been in development for a couple of decades before that. I note that anti-GMO “journalist” Paul Thacker made similar claims about “no long term testing” and, when called on it, really had to stretch to find any examples whatsoever of long-term side effects from vaccines, whose adverse reactions, when they occur, usually occur within a few weeks. Let’s just say that the examples chosen were rare and in special cases, such as immunocompromised patients. Given the data we have now, the highly unlikely possibility of rare late side effects cropping up months from now is not a reason, in the middle of a pandemic, to avoid a vaccine against a disease that is killing millions and disabling even more. Basically, this is a variation of a favorite antivaccine trope, the Nirvana fallacy, in which it is argued that if a vaccine isn’t perfectly safe and perfectly effective it’s crap.
And the antivaccine tropes continue:
#7: NO INFORMED CONSENT
What most who are taking the vaccine don’t know is that because these products are still in clinical trials, anyone who gets the shot is now part of the clinical trial.
They are part of the experiment.
Those (like me) who do not take it, are part of the control group.
Time will tell how this experiment works out.
This is utter BS. When the vaccines were given EUAs, there were data from tens of thousands of clinical trial participants. We now have data from close to 200 million people who have received the vaccines. We know a lot now about these vaccines, and more and more data are being published every week. Basically, Mr. Elliot is parroting a version of a favorite antivaccine tactic, one I like to call “misinformed refusal” (as opposed to informed consent), in which the uncertainties and harms are grossly exaggerated based on misinterpretation of science, bad science, pseudoscience, and just plain lies, and the benefits dramatically downplayed or denied.
Of course, part of the exaggeration of the uncertainties comes from:
#8: UNDER-REPORTING OF ADVERSE REACTIONS AND DEATH
According to a study done by Harvard (at the commission of our own government), less than 1% of all adverse reactions to vaccines are actually submitted to the National Vaccine Adverse Events Reports System (VAERS) – read page 6 at the link above.
While the problems with VAERS have not been fixed (as you can read about in this letter to the CDC), at the time of this writing VAERS reports over 2,200 deaths from the current covid vaccines, as well as close to 60,000 adverse reactions.
VAERS data released today showed 50,861 reports of adverse events following COVID vaccines, including 2,249 deaths and 7,726 serious injuries between Dec. 14, 2020 and March 26, 2021.
And those numbers don’t include (what is currently) 578 cases of Bell’s Palsy.
If those numbers are still only 1% of the total adverse reactions (or .8 to 2% of what this study published recently in the JAMA found), you can do the math, but that equates to somewhere around 110,000 to 220,000 deaths from the vaccines to date, and a ridiculous number of adverse reactions.
First of all, no, it is quite simply not true that “only 1%” of adverse reactions are reported to VAERS. That’s a study frequently cherry picked by antivaxxers. Moreover, VAERS is not the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring anyway; there are multiple and redundant active monitoring systems as well. Also, as a passive reporting system, is prone to gaming by lawyers and antivaxxers, who love to imply causation from what might or might not even be correlation. I’ve written about how antivaxxers have, like Mr. Elliot, been weaponizing VAERS reports against COVID-19 vaccines by implying what are almost certainly coincidences are, in fact, caused by the vaccine. (And, no, Bell’s palsy was almost certainly not caused by the vaccine.)
Seriously, if your cherry picking of studies and “analysis” of the VAERS database lead you to conclude that there are as many as 220,000 unreported deaths after COVID-19 vaccination that no one’s detected, you are as innumerate as those who claim that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US.
#9: THE VACCINES DO NOT STOP TRANSMISSION OR INFECTION
This is getting repetitive, isn’t it? (Antivax listicles like this frequently do.)
Again, Mr. Elliot is focusing only on the clinical trial results showing that the vaccines were very good at preventing symptomatic disease from COVID-19; they were not designed to demonstrate whether they stopped transmission or infection. As before, Mr. Elliot is ignoring data that has been published since the EUAs were granted for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines that demonstrate that the vaccines do appear to prevent infection and reduce asymptomatic transmission. Are you seeing a pattern in Mr. Elliot’s disinformation? I am. Here’s a hint to Mr. Elliot. It is April 2021, NOT November 2020. Do try to keep up with the literature. (He won’t, of course.)
And…the slam dunk:
#10: PEOPLE ARE CATCHING COVID AFTER BEING FULLY VACCINATED
Talk about a bummer.
You get vaccinated and you still catch covid.
This one is so dumb that it’s hard for me to write much about it without getting really sarcastic. Of course there are people who catch COVID-19 after being fully vaccinated. No vaccine is 100% effective; so we always knew that this would happen. Again, this is the Nirvana fallacy, in which antivaxxers suggest that if a vaccine isn’t 100% effective it’s crap. What we do know is that the vaccines are very effective, much more so than scientists had hoped. It turns out that such “breakthrough cases” are rare, but, of course, when hundreds of millions are receiving the vaccine, millions are falling ill with COVID-19, there will be some breakthrough cases. This isn’t Nirvana, and the vaccines aren’t perfect. They are, however, very, very good. I also note that this is the same sort of gambit that antivaxxers have used since time immemorial about measles, for instance, claiming that if there are vaccinated children who get the measles that must mean that the vaccine doesn’t work.
Next up:
#11: THE OVERALL DEATH RATE FROM COVID
According to the CDC’s own numbers, covid has a 99.74% survival rate.
Why would I take a risk on a product, that doesn’t stop infection or transmission, to help me overcome a cold that has a .26% chance of killing me–actually in my age range is has about a .1% chance of killing me (and .01% chance of killing my kids), but let’s not split hairs here.
One wonders if Mr. Elliot would get on an airplane if there were “only” a 0.26% (or 0.1%) of its crashing and killing him. I suspect that he wouldn’t. In any event, we don’t yet know the true fatality rate, but the case fatality rate (the death rate among people diagnosed with COVID-19) in the US could be as high as 2%. The infection fatality rate, of course, is considerably lower, because that includes all asymptomatic infections. He’s also doing the usual selfish thing that younger antivaxxers do and ignoring the much, much higher infection and case fatality rate among the elderly. Determining the “true” numbers is challenging, given the changes in the level of screening and diagnosis over time, as well as how the actual CFR and IFR can vary with time and location, but we do know that COVID-19 is much more lethal than influenza. Naturally, Mr. Elliot assumes that he won’t be on the unlucky end of those statistics, because, as his germ theory denial leads him to believe, he is so much more healthy than you.
Then:
#12: THE BLOATED COVID DEATH NUMBERS
Something smells really funny about this one.
Never before in the history of death certificates has our own government changed how deaths are reported.
Why now, are we reporting everyone who dies with covid in their body, as having died of covid, rather than the co-morbidities that actually took their life?
Until covid, all coronaviruses (common colds) were never listed as the primary cause of death when someone died of heart disease, cancer, diabetes, auto-immune conditions, or any other major co-morbidity.
The disease was listed as the cause of death, and a confounding factor like flu or pneumonia was listed on a separate line.
Again, the idea that most people die “with” COVID-19 rather than “of” COVID-19 is a conspiracy theory that arose last summer. Indeed, I had a name for it: the 6% gambit. It’s the claim that “only 6%” of death certificates show COVID-19 as the sole cause of death because “only 6%” don’t also list comorbidities too, such as heart disease. Again, this is utter nonsense based on a misunderstanding of how death certificates are filled out, in which the primary cause of death might be, for instance, cardiac arrest, but the condition that ultimately led to that cardiac arrest was COVID-19. Or it could be pneumonia as the immediate cause of death, with the pneumonia having been a sequelae of—you guessed it—COVID-19. (If you want a more detailed explanation, here you go.)
The lies don’t stop, though:
#13: FAUCI AND SIX OTHERS AT NIAID OWN PATENTS IN THE MODERNA VACCINE
Thanks to the Bayh-Dole Act, government workers are allowed to file patents on any research they do using tax payer funding.
Tony Fauci owns over 1,000 patents (see this video for more details), including patents being used on the Moderna vaccine…which he approved government funding for.
In fact, the NIH (which NIAID is part of) claims joint ownership of Moderna’s vaccine.
Does anyone else see this as a MAJOR conflict of interest, or criminal even?
The source of this claim seems to be Naomi Wolf, who, as anyone who’s encountered her Tweets on Twitter knows, has gone full antivaccine and COVID-19 crank. Indeed, the video was published on Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s website. As for Anthony Fauci owning patents on the Moderna vaccine, my response was: WTF? I did a patent search on Fauci, and his name does turn up on 38 patents, none of them related to COVID-19 vaccines. Some are related to treatments for HIV, and it is those that conspiracy theorists have zeroed in on by combining them with the bogus conspiracy theory that there are HIV sequences in the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein used as the antigen in the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines. This is a distortion in that there are short sequences that resemble sequences found in the HIV coding sequence, but the matches are so short as to be insignificant. Lots of genes have similar levels of matching. Some antivaxxers have even falsely claimed that COVID-19 vaccines increase susceptibility to HIV.
As for the NIH claiming joint ownership of the Moderna vaccine, that is true, but doesn’t mean what Mr. Elliot claims it does. Here is a statement from the NIH on the matter:
NIAID scientists created stabilized coronavirus spike proteins for the development of vaccines against coronaviruses, including SARS-CoV-2. Recognizing the importance of these novel immunogens, NIAID has sought patents to preserve the government’s rights to these inventions and to provide incentive for commercial partners to invest the capital and resources needed to advance their development, commercialization, and public use as vaccines.
NIAID has adopted a non-exclusive licensing approach for these patent rights in order to allow multiple vaccine developers to utilize these immunogens in their proprietary vaccine platforms. The mRNA vaccine candidate resulting from NIAID’s collaboration with Moderna, embodied in the material transferred to UNC, is an example of this approach: the stabilized spike protein developed by NIAID investigators is expressed from Moderna’s proprietary mRNA vaccine platform. Responsibility for obtaining regulatory approval of the mRNA vaccine candidate, a product produced and formulated by Moderna, rests with Moderna.
Federal employees listed as inventors on these patent applications assigned their rights to the US government. Accordingly, should the USPTO and other national patent authorities grant the patents, the US government will hold ownership interest in the patents.
According to NIH Director Francis Collins in an interview last May at the Economic Club of Washington, as quoted by Axios:
The bottom line: Many experts anticipate a coronavirus vaccine, once proven safe and effective, would be made as widely available as possible, and that developers aren’t likely to seek big profits from it. Partial federal ownership could be a backstop if those assumptions don’t bear out, but NIH isn’t keen on stepping on industry’s toes.
    • “Talking to the companies, I don’t hear any of them say they think this [vaccine] is a money-maker,” Collins said during his Economic Club interview. “I think they want to recoup their costs and maybe make a tiny percentage of increase of profit over that, like single digits percentage-wise, but that’s it. Nobody sees this as a way to make billions of dollars.”
The bottom line is that Fauci does not profit from COVID-19 vaccines, be they the Moderna vaccine or others. He doesn’t own patents on them, and even if he did, as a government employee, he would have signed away the rights to the federal government.
Then there’s this distortion:
#14: FAUCI IS ON THE HOT SEAT FOR ILLEGAL GAIN-OF-FUNCTION RESEARCH
What is “Gain-of-Function” research?
It’s where scientists attempt to make viruses gain functions–i.e. make them more transmissible and deadlier.
Sounds at least a touch unethical, right?
How could that possibly be helpful?
Our government agreed, and banned the practice.
So what did the Fauci-led NIAID do?
They pivoted and outsourced the gain-of-function research (in coronaviruses no less) to China–to the tune of a $600K grant.
You can see more details, including the important timeline of these events in this fantastically well-researched documentary.
The “fantastically well-researched documentary”? It’s Plandemic 2 (or, as I like to call it: Plandemic 2: Electric Boogaloo), the sequel to Plandemic, the first COVID-19 conspiracy video to go viral last May featuring antivaccine activist turned COVID-19 conspiracy theorist Judy Mikovits. Basically, the idea behind the two “documentaries” was that the pandemic was a “plandemic”, planned by global elites. It was also the origin of the conspiracy theory that Fauci helped promote “gain-of-function” to make viruses more deadly.
Again, this conspiracy theory shows a shocking ignorance of how NIH grants are funded. As director of the National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), Fauci doesn’t dole out the grant money himself. Grant applications go through the standard study section process, where a panel of scientists evaluates the merit of grant applications and then scores them with a priority score, with low scores being better. The lowest scoring grants are then funded at the institute level until the money runs out. The grant at the heart of this conspiracy theory was indeed for $600,000, and its principal investigator was Peter Daszak, a well-respected virologist. It was not a new grant, but rather year six of a grant that had been funded since 2014. I looked at the RePORTER entry for the grant. The Budget for 2019-2020 was $538,926 direct costs plus $123,054 for indirect costs for a total year six budget of $661,980.
One thing you need to understand about NIH grants is that there are two kinds of renewals, competing and noncompeting renewals. The NIH views, for example, a six year grant as six one-year grants. Each of the one-year segments after the first year are known as noncompeting renewals, because they don’t have to compete with other grant applications. At the end of the grant period, if the investigators want to renew, they have to submit a competing renewal application and go back to the study section. The point is that a noncompeting renewal is nearly automatic, as long as adequate progress is demonstrated. A competing renewal is not, and this grant was clearly renewed in 2020, because its project end date is listed as June 30, 2025. This is also the grant that was taken away early in the pandemic:
On April 24, the National Institutes of Health terminated a grant for a research project on bat-borne coronaviruses after it was criticized by President Trump and a number of Republican lawmakers. While the grant was held by EcoHealth Alliance, a global environmental health research organization based in New York, it attracted negative attention because part of it supported collaborative activities with the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in China.
WIV houses a lab equipped to study the most dangerous class of pathogens, and a number of pundits and politicians are now suggesting it accidentally released SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. Though thinly supported, the idea is fueling efforts to focus blame for the COVID-19 pandemic on the Chinese government. Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR), in particular, has cited suspicions about WIV and the actions of Chinese leaders during the pandemic as justifying a hardline stance, which he said this week could include cutting off student visas in technical fields.
So, yes, this grant to Ecohealth Alliance, headed by Peter Daszak, was a collaborative grant with Chinese researchers, but Fauci had nothing to do with granting it, and it was political pressure based on conspiracy mongering that led to its being taken away last April and then reinstated, but with onerous conditions in August. In any event, the grant was to look for bat coronaviruses at high risk to “cross over” into human populations. The origin of the conspiracy theory was described in this Nature article:
A favorite version of the laboratory-origin stories relies on the fact that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered for gain-of-function studies that were also previously performed with bat SARS-like coronaviruses to understand cross-species transmission risk (Nat. Med. 21, 1508–1513; 2015). The irony is that those gain-of-function studies provided valuable information about the biology of SARS-CoV-2. Gain-of-function research is also subject to intense scrutiny and governmental oversight, precisely because of the high risk involved in conducting it safely; thus, it is extremely unlikely that gain-of-function research on hard-to-obtain coronaviruses (such as bat SARS-like coronaviruses) could occur under the radar. Moreover, there is an extensive history of pathogen emergence by natural means: most novel viral pathogens that have caused epidemics or pandemics in the human population have emerged naturally from a wildlife reservoir. Therefore, the overwhelming conclusion is that this virus, too, found its way into a human host through a series of unhappy accidental encounters with animals.
And:
In April 2020, we witnessed firsthand how misinformation about the virus’ origins can destroy research when President Trump ordered the National Institutes of Health to strip the EcoHealth Alliance of a grant that involved close collaboration with researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The NIH justified the cancellation by saying the research, which investigated bat SARS-like coronaviruses circulating in China and zoonotic spillover, did not align with NIH priorities, which strains credulity. This work produced some of the strongest corroborating evidence that SARS-CoV-2 is a naturally emergent pathogen, as serological surveys demonstrated that people living in close proximity to colonies of bats had antibodies to bat SARS-like coronaviruses. The NIH has since set impossible conditions for restoring the grant, ensuring that this research will never resume.
The bottom line: There’s not much behind this conspiracy theory, and it’s a conspiracy theory that was jumped on by Republican politicians and used first to fear monger about the grant and then to scuttle it, all while trying to blame China by implying that SARS-CoV-2 was bioengineered in a Wuhan lab. Never mind that sequencing of the virus demonstrated conclusively a long time ago that it was not made in a lab.
Next up:
#15: THE VIRUS CONTINUES TO MUTATE
Not only does the virus (like all viruses) continue to mutate, but according to world-renowned vaccine developer Geert Vanden Bossche (who you’ll meet below if you don’t know him) it’s mutating about every 10 hours.
How in the world are we going to keep creating vaccines to keep up with that level of mutation?
We’re not.
And, since it’s related, I’ll list #17:
#17: THE WORLD’S LEADING VACCINOLOGIST IS SOUNDING THE ALARM…
Here is what may be the biggest reason this covid vaccine doesn’t make sense to me.
When someone who is very pro-vaccine, who has spent his entire professional career overseeing the development of vaccines, is shouting from the mountaintops that we have a major problem, I think the man should be heard.
I already discussed this one in detail too. The reason that variants are arising is because so many people are being infected; in other words, there’s so much variation for evolution to work on because it’s running rampant. Moreover, Geert Vanden Bossche is hardly “world-renowned”. Far from it. He hasn’t published much in a long time.
His idea that vaccination will fuel the rise of ever more deadly COVID-19 mutants is very similar to Andrew Wakefield’s claim a year before that mass vaccination against measles would fuel the rise of ever more deadly measles variants that would ultimately lead to mass extinction. (I kid you not.) In any event, as I discussed coronaviruses actually don’t mutate as quickly as most RNA viruses, and the selective pressure of vaccination on viruses is not the same as the selective pressure of antibiotics on bacteria. In any event, like Wakefield, Vanden Bossche has a competing vaccine idea for COVID-19, and pausing COVID-19 vaccination would simply let the virus circulate longer and more widely, providing grist for even more variants than are emerging now.
Then of course there’s “censorship”:
#16: CENSORSHIP…AND THE COMPLETE ABSENCE OF SCIENTIFIC DEBATE
I can’t help but get snarky here, so humor me.
How did you enjoy all those nationally and globally-televised, robust debates put on by public health officials, and broadcast simultaneously on every major news station?
I laughed when I read this. It’s basically a clear that this is an appeal to false balance. He’s trying to equate efforts to stamp down disinformation on social media with “censorship”, as cranks often do. In fact, there has been a lot of debate in the scientific community.
And finally:
#18: I ALREADY HAD COVID
I didn’t enjoy it.
It was a nasty cold for two days:
    • Unrelenting butt/low-back aches
    • Very low energy.
    • Low-grade fever.
It was weird not being able to smell anything for a couple days.
A week later, coffee still tasted a little “off.”
But I survived.
Now it appears (as it always has) that I have beautiful, natural, life-long immunity…
…not something likely to wear off in a few months if I get the vaccine.
In my body, and my household, covid is over.
In fact, now that I’ve had it, there is evidence the covid vaccine might actually be more dangerous for me.
It’s certainly possible that Mr. Elliot has had COVID-19. His symptoms were certainly consistent with it. However, without serology he can’t be sure that he actually had COVID-19. Even if he did have COVID-19, it’s not clear that his immunity is lifelong (in fact, very likely it is not), and, given the emergence of new variants, we have already seen examples of people who have been reinfected. It seems rare, but we don’t know how rare. More importantly, if the virus does in fact “continue to mutate,” as Mr. Elliot maintains, and actually does produce variants that can evade immunity, then “natural immunity” won’t help him. More importantly, the CDC does recommend that you should be vaccinated even if you’ve had COVID, because vaccine-induced immunity is less variable than “natural immunity” and there is emerging evidence that it might provide better protection against emerging variants.
And, no, citing Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. claiming that getting the vaccine after having had COVID-19 is dangerous is not a good argument, particularly when he cites someone like Hooman Norchashm, a physician who’s claimed not to be antivaccine but has been promoting the idea that it is very dangerous to be vaccinated against COVID-19 if you have an asymptomatic infection or if you’ve recently had it before. It’s not.
He concludes:
Agree or disagree with me; I’ll treat you no differently.
You’re a human just as worthy of love and respect as anyone else.
For that I salute you, and I truly wish you all the best.
I hope you found this helpful.
If so, feel free to share.
If not, feel free to (kindly) let me know what didn’t make sense to you and I’d be happy to hear your thoughts too.
Stay curious and stay humble.
Too bad Mr. Elliot, although he might be “curious”, is anything but humble. Certainly he isn’t humble enough to realize when he is in over his head, as his “COVID-19 antivax greatest hits” compendium demonstrates. He’s using his gene therapy denial coupled with his antivaccine views coupled with his entrepreneurial bent to spread COVID-19 disinformation. Sadly, it’s worked. His article has had over 2.6 million views just on his website alone, not counting its republication on RFK Jr.’s website.
ADDENDUM: There is an excellent refutation of these antivaccine tropes over at Snopes.com. Some are more detailed than mine; some are less detailed. As is often the case, my take is a bit different. Just view Snopes.com’s refutation and mine as…complementary, with, as can’t be avoided in a case like this, a fair amount of overlap.

A Race Against Vaccine Hesitancy
The vaccine program is in a race against the emergence of new strains of the virus. Vaccine hesitancy may be the margin of victory or failure.
Steven Novella on February 10, 2021
Link

We are in a race against time. SARS-CoV-2 is evolving, as viruses do, creating thousands of strains as the virus continues to move through the human population. Epidemics and pandemics are great opportunities for viruses to evolve. Most of the strains identified are behaviorally roughly identical to the original strain, but a few have now been identified that are better at transmitting themselves from host to host. These strains are quickly dominating.
The UK strain known as B.1.1.7 rapidly spreads through countries where it gets introduced. It has been found in the US and epidemiologists predict that by late March it will dominate and we will likely see a new COVID-19 surge. There is also a Brazil variant and a South African variant. All three variants share some mutations on their spike proteins, although they appear to have emerged independently. While they spread more easily, none appear to be more deadly. The South African variant, however, may be resistant to existing vaccines.
This is a major problem of allowing viral pandemics to simmer – eventually new strains will emerge that are more infectious, more deadly, or resistant to treatments or vaccines.
On the other hand, we now have several effective vaccines. Over 42 million doses have been distributed in the US, almost 10% of the population. A massive vaccination program is under way, with a goal of 1 million doses given per day. However, some experts feel the goal should be more like 2 million per day, if not more. This is the race – can we get to herd immunity before we get another surge (and we’re still not over the last surge) from a new and more infectious strain?
Herd immunity (or “community immunity” as some prefer, but I fear we are stuck with the herd) is achieved when enough people are immune to infection that an infecting organism cannot find enough receptive hosts to perpetuate itself through a population. In other words – it cannot spread, and so the infection burns itself out. If you maintain herd immunity long enough you may even eliminate the organism so that it is no longer endemic in a population (although there still may be outbreaks if reintroduced from other populations). If there are no non-human reservoirs, a disease may in fact be eradicated completely, like smallpox and (hopefully) polio soon as well.
Coronaviruses have non-human reservoirs, so we will have to live with them, but aggressive herd immunity can prevent epidemics and pandemics. The only way to get there is through a successful vaccination program. Unfortunately, the initial rollout in the US was underwhelming, and we lost precious time.
Now that the logistics of the vaccine program seem to be on track, the other variable in this race is how receptive the population will be to the vaccines. In a recent survey vaccine hesitancy was high:
COVID-19 vaccination intentions were weak, with 14.8% of respondents being unlikely to get vaccinated and another 23.0% unsure.
That means only 62% said they were likely to get the vaccine. We don’t know for sure where the herd immunity level will be, but something around 85% is a good guess. It could be higher. This means we have to convince essentially everyone in the “unsure” group to get vaccinated, assuming the “unlikely” group are more anti-vaxxers than merely vaccine hesitant.
Factors that influence vaccine acceptance include:
In a multiple linear regression, significant predictors of vaccination intent were general vaccine knowledge (β = 0.311, p < .001), rejection of vaccine conspiracies (β = −0.117, p = .003), perceived severity of COVID-19 (β = 0.273, p < .001).
Other favorable factors include being male, income > $120k, being a Democrat, and not watching Fox News or relying on social media for information. Of note, this survey was in the English speaking population only, and there is evidence that the Hispanic population has greater vaccine hesitancy due to a lack of trust in the government.
These numbers are also similar worldwide.
I have encountered vaccine hesitancy among my own patients, and they are mainly based in fear spawned by rumors they “heard somewhere”. One patient worryingly reported that they heard “someone died three weeks after getting the vaccine”. Given that over 42 million people (mostly elderly) have been vaccinated, that is a statistical certainty. But there are no deaths attributed to either COVID vaccine. Reviews of deaths occurring shortly after a vaccine dose find the numbers are consistent with the background number of all-cause mortality. Further, no individual case seems to be related to the vaccine.
But it is far easier to scare people with anecdotes than to reassure them with data. This is why the anti-vaxxers have an easy task – they do not have to produce compelling data or even a cogent argument. They can spew abject nonsense. All they have to do is generate unreasonable fear through rumor and innuendo.
There is a light in the survey data, however. General vaccine knowledge did predict vaccine acceptance. It may be true that vaccine knowledge may simply be a marker for other things, like scientific knowledge in general, trust in institutions, or using reliable sources of information. But it also seems likely that it is an independent factor related to vaccine uptake. That’s good news because this is a modifiable factor, improved through education. This is the “knowledge deficit model”, which likely does not apply to conspiracy-theorist anti-vaxxers, but may apply to the misinformed vaccine hesitant. Hopefully that is the only group we need to get to herd immunity.
Therefore, as part of the massive vaccine distribution effort underway, we need an equally massive vaccine education effort. That could be the margin of victory in this race against emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants.
We also need to keep in mind that worse is likely to come. There will be further new strains of SARS-CoV-2. There will be new viruses and at some point we will face the next pandemic. A rapid and effective vaccine program is our best defense. This makes not only education but fighting anti-vaxxers, and more generally countering conspiracy theories and anti-science, critically important.

The Causes of Vaccine Hesitancy
The vaccine hesitant are now the front lines of the battle to contain COVID.
Steven Novella on May 19, 2021
Link

The race to achieve herd immunity in the US is stumbling due to decreased demand to get vaccinated. As I discussed three months ago, we are at a precarious moment in this pandemic. While it feels like things are returning somewhat back to normal, especially with the relaxation of the mask wearing and social distancing recommendations from the CDC, worldwide we are still in the middle of a large wave of cases. Cases in the US have dropped sharply from our recent large wave, but are still at numbers similar to last Spring.
But there are still locations in the world, such as India, being overwhelmed by new cases. This creates the opportunity for new variants of SARS-CoV 2 to emerge. If a variant emerges that is resistant to the current vaccines, then the vaccine program may essentially be reset. The best way to avoid this outcome is to achieve herd immunity, when enough people are resistant to infection that the disease cannot freely spread. We do not yet know for sure what that number is, but estimates are between 70-90%.
Right now in the US 47.7% of the population has received at least one dose of vaccine. This is good, and is likely contributing to the dropping case numbers. But it’s not enough. The rate of vaccinations is also dropping off, raising concerns that we may never achieve herd immunity. The decrease in demand is being driven by so-called “vaccine hesitancy” but this is a diverse groups with varying views. A recent survey clarifies the breakdown of this group, and suggest strategies for getting past the 70% mark.
Based on these results (actually taken from two surveys, 12/21/20 to 1/4/21 and 3/18/21 to 3/25/21) we can break people down first into three groups – vaccine enthusiasts (those who are already vaccinated or definitely plan to get vaccinated), vaccine hesitant (unsure but persuadable), and anti-vaxxers (the survey uses the term “skeptics” but this is not appropriate). The vaccine hesitant group is further broken down into three subgroups: the watchful (those who are waiting to see how everything goes), the cost-anxious (those with resource barriers like time or money to vaccination), and the system distrusters (those distrustful of the medical establishment, but not necessarily anti-vaccine).
The first survey found:
    • Enthusiasts: 40%
    • Hesitant: 43%
        ◦ Watchful: 20%
        ◦ Cost-anxious: 14%
        ◦ System distruster: 9%
    • Anti-vaxxers: 17%
The second survey found:
    • Enthusiasts: 62%
    • Hesitant: 22%
        ◦ Watchful: 6%
        ◦ Cost-anxious: 9%
        ◦ System distruster: 7%
    • Anti-vaxxers: 16%
As predicted, the dedicated anti-vaxxers are largely unmovable. Those in this group believe at least one conspiracy theory about COVID and/or the vaccines, such as the notion that COVID is entirely a hoax, it’s just another virus of no special concern, everyone is going to get it anyway so let it happen, the vaccines are unsafe or unproven, or they are a conspiracy to inject everyone with microchips or at least to control the population. We have extensively documented here (mostly David Gorski) the various lies, distortions, and conspiracy theories that the anti-vaxxers have been spreading. It is probably realistic to consider the 16% of anti-vaxxers to be a hard ceiling on vaccinations, unless truly draconian methods are imposed, which is unlikely to happen.
All of the focus, therefore, is on the middle group – the vaccine hesitant but persuadable. Already that group has dropped from 43 to 22%. If we want to get to 70% vaccinated we need to drop that group by half again, and if we want a buffer at 80% (which may be where herd immunity is) we will need to convince almost everyone in this group.
In this group the watchful dropped the most, which makes sense as millions of people received the vaccine. There have been no issues with the mRNA vaccines, which are most of the doses given. Time, almost by definition, will eat away at this group. The cost-anxious can be dealt with pragmatically, by making the vaccine free and as easy to get as possible. This may also involve encouraging employers to make it easy for their employees to get time off for the vaccine without penalty.
Surveys, however, are not a magic mirror into someone’s personal thoughts and feelings. People might say on a survey that they are waiting to see, or are concerned about cost, when really they have other concerns they are not willing or are too embarrassed to say. If you heard that Bill Gates is putting microchips in the vaccine it might be easier to just say you are concerned about cost.
The system distrusters will be the hardest group to crack. The survey did break down the categories by race, and it was no surprise that black (31-18%) and LatinX (11-11%) were higher than whites (2-4%). This hesitancy is more culturally and historically based, and as many have pointed out the black community in the US has good reason to be cautious about the medical system. I do think times have changed since Tuskegee and the medical profession has gone a long way toward earning back that trust, but historical memory runs deep.
So where do we go from here? We need to get the vaccine hesitant group down into the single digits. No one has the magic answer but we do have information to guide our approach. First, education and outreach is critical. The facts of the situation are really quite clear – the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines are incredibly safe and effective. COVID is a deadly illness, and even for those who survive there is the risk of long COVID or significant morbidity. You don’t want COVID. It’s not just a bad flu. The risk vs. benefit vastly favors getting the vaccine, even in low risk groups because the vaccine risk is so low. There is also the benefit of protecting the people around you. And further, there is the benefit of reducing the pandemic, and allowing society to get back to normal. If you want things to go back to normal (or at least close) then get vaccinated.
There is also the fact that those who are vaccinated have fewer restrictions. They don’t have to wear masks in public, for example. This is now being based on the honor system, however, and there is a bit of a debate about whether or not to require proof of vaccination in certain circumstances. Would this help or hurt?
Education can also help the system distrusters. While there are still racial disparities in medicine, systemic racism and ethical violations are no longer deliberately tolerated. Outreach to specific communities, by trusted members of those communities, is likely to be essential to further reduce hesitancy.
The anti-vaxxers are likely to remain unpersuadable, but their misinformation needs to be vigorously countered. I also do think that social media platforms need to look carefully at their algorithms to ensure they are not promoting anti-vaccine misinformation and dangerous conspiracy theories. They have been, and this is partly their mess, so they should help clean it up.

Everything old is new again
Since the pandemic hit, I’ve frequently said things like, “Everything old is new again”, referring to the antivaccine movement in the age of COVID-19. As 2022 dawned, I thought I’d expand a bit on what I mean. Is there a term for déjà vu, but what I’m seeing now is amplified a thousand-fold? Proponents of science-based medicine have been warning us for decades about the sort of misinformation that’s now swamping us. Why did no one listen?
David Gorski on January 3, 2022
Link

As I approached what I should write about for the first post of 2022 for Science-Based Medicine, I debated between addressing a topic or piece of misinformation that I had neglected due to having taken a week off or writing about something more “meta”. (No, not the metaverse or Facebook’s crappy new name!) As the week wore on, and my wife and I were confronted directly by the lack of testing for COVID-19 for ourselves (don’t ask), followed by spending New Years Eve in the emergency room with a family member (don’t ask), I found that my psychic energy—if you’ll excuse me using that term—just wasn’t up to a detailed takedown of anything. So meta it is!
This brings me to something I saw before the holidays on Twitter about retiring NIH director Francis Collins that irritated me so much that I had thought of changing my plans to take last Monday off. Fortunately, I didn’t, which allowed me to contemplate it more and my anger to recede. That doesn’t change my level of frustration, but I figured I’d lead 2022 with it.
Here’s what I mean:
Dr. Collins, asked if there's anything he wishes NIH had done: "maybe we under-invested in research in human behavior..I never imagined a year ago that there would be 60 million people who refused/declined to get the vaccine because of misinformation & disinformation" @NewsHour
— Judy Woodruff (@JudyWoodruff) December 20, 2021
At the time, Dr. Collins had been on a farewell tour since having announced that he would be stepping down as NIH Director. Annoyingly, at nearly every stop he repeated his regret at how he (and NIH) had long failed to appreciate how potent health and antivaccine misinformation and conspiracy theories were and how badly they would impede public health efforts to slow the spread of COVID-19 before vaccines were available and to vaccinate the populace. This led to a number of articles like:
    • Science misinformation alarms Francis Collins as he leaves top NIH job (Science)
    • Outgoing NIH director implores Fox News viewers to stay focused on the real ‘enemy’ (NPR)
    • NIH director: ‘Conspiracies are winning here’ (Washington Post)
    • NIH director Dr. Francis Collins urges Christians to look for truth about COVID-19 vaccines, not conspiracy theories and misinformation (Tennesseean)
Let’s examine the problem with Dr. Collins’ take.
The problem with Dr. Collins (and the rest of the public health apparatus prepandemic)
Let’s begin with what appear to be the most shared quotes from Dr. Collins regarding medical misinformation, aside from his using his status as a religious man to urge evangelicals to reject vaccine- and COVID-19-related misinformation:
You’ve watched science and politics collide for years. Do you believe politicization of science has grown worse?
It is much worse. And it’s a reflection of the fact that polarization is much worse — and tribalism is much worse. We’re in a really bad place. If science happens to produce a result that a political perspective doesn’t like, then science has to be attacked. That’s exactly what we see now happening, to the detriment of getting the facts out there.
What role does the NIH have in pushing back against misinformation about science?
This has turned out to be a much more severe situation than I would have imagined a year ago. I wish we had more insights from behavioural social science research into how this has come to pass, and why it could have gotten so completely widespread. I want to call this out as one of my most major concerns as I stepped down from the NIH, of looking at the situation in our nation. Somewhere along the way, our political hyperpolarization began having a lot of really dangerous consequences, where in many instances we seem to have lost a sense of how to tell the difference between a fact and an opinion — or some Facebook post that’s, frankly, a lie. That’s truly dangerous. That’s another epidemic that is not going to go away even if we triumph over COVID-19. We need to figure out what happened here, and how to bring ourselves back to a place where our nation has a more stable future.
In another interview:
You have called it “bizarre” that politics influences precautions like mask-wearing. Can you talk more about divisiveness and disinformation around science?
We have two epidemics. One is caused by the virus that causes COVID-19. The other is an epidemic of misinformation and distrust about science.
People’s conclusions about almost everything seem to be driven by what their ‘tribe’ says is right. Objective facts often get overruled by the latest political statement or the conspiracy that just popped up on Facebook.
Estimates are that more than 100,000 Americans have died in 2021 unnecessarily because of misinformation campaigns that discouraged people from taking advantage of lifesaving vaccines.
We need all those who have the ability to sift through evidence to work tirelessly to get accurate information out to the public. It can’t just be coming from the government or scientists, because sadly we’re now considered a little bit suspect. It also needs to come from community leaders.
And politicians who have been some of the worst offenders in spreading misinformation need to recognize that history is going to judge them harshly.
This is a common view among those completely out of touch with what’s been happening “on the ground”, so to speak: Who could possibly have predicted what’s happened in the last two years? The retort of a lot of us who’ve been at this a while is: Who couldn’t have? I will admit that even I didn’t foresee things getting quite as bad as they have, but I was at least in the ballpark, writing about the first coronavirus conspiracy theory I encountered, way back in January 2020, before COVID-19 even had a final name, much less had become a pandemic. In the meantime, we were pointing out how COVID-19 was a golden opportunity for quackery and conspiracy theories.
I couldn’t help but get a little peeved and Tweet:
We even warned them how antivaxxers would do it, too, for example by weaponizing #VAERS reports to falsely portray #CovidVaccine as deadly. How did we know? Easy. Antivaxxers have been doing exactly this for at least a quarter of a century! 2/
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) December 21, 2021
I generally like Collins, but damn… 4/4
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) December 21, 2021
And friend of SBM Dr. Mark Hoofnagle noted:
There were a lot of similar responses from groups that promoted vaccination and countered antivaccine misinformation long before the pandemic.
Elite physicians and scientists like Dr. Collins also tend to assume that it’s so bad now solely because of political polarization. While political polarization is quite bad right now, those of us who have dealt with medical misinformation of this sort for decades know that it is not, strictly speaking, political polarization that is responsible for the tsunami of COVID-19 misinformation, although certainly it contributes. While I’m glad that someone of Collins’ stature is finally recognizing that misinformation and disinformation about health, in particular vaccines and COVID-19, are having a horrific effect and leading to unnecessary death and suffering, I can’t help but be frustrated over the long delay.
As my colleagues, who before the pandemic struggled to believe how (or dismissed the even the possibility that) people could believe the bizarre things about disease, medicine, and vaccines that we had been documenting for decades, were having their noses rubbed into the very bizarre things that people believe about disease, medicine, and vaccines, some of us had a hard time not rolling our eyes. I realize that saying “I told you so!” was probably not the most productive reaction in the world, but I hope you’ll forgive me that lapse and stay with me as I recount a little history and look at what might be done now and in the future.
“Shruggies” and even outright hostility
We at SBM, as well as a lot of other physicians, scientist, and others, have been warning about the malign effects of medical misinformation, pseudoscience, and conspiracy theories for decades, but few in authority listened or took the threat seriously. Why is this? And, more importantly, now that COVID-19 has awakened large number of physicians, public health officials, and scientists to the threat posed by medical and scientific misinformation of the sort that SBM has been combatting since 2008 and some SBM bloggers for even longer, how can we maintain that appreciation and momentum after the pandemic finally recedes into history?
Longtime readers might remember that during the first year of SBM’s existence one of our regular bloggers, Dr. Val Jones, coined a pithy term to describe the attitude held by most physicians towards antivaccine and medical misinformation: “Shruggies“, a term that she defined thusly:
Shruggie (noun): a person who doesn’t care about the science versus pseudoscience debate. When presented with descriptions of exaggerated or fraudulent health claims or practices, their response is to shrug. Shruggies are fairly inert, they will not argue the merits (or lack thereof) of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) or pseudoscience in general. They simply aren’t all that interested in the discussion, and are somewhat puzzled by those who are.
She then went on to describe how she used to be a “shruggie” herself, but had come to appreciate the danger of medical misinformation, pseudoscience, and conspiracy theories, hence her willingness to join SBM as a blogger for a while before moving on (as most of our bloggers eventually do, sooner or later).
Unfortunately, there’s another attitude that’s also not at all uncommon among physicians, particularly academic physicians. It’s an attitude that goes beyond indifference into outright contempt for science communication aimed at correcting medical misinformation. The core of this attitude is based on the assumption that no one but crackpots would ever believe ridiculous things like homeopathy and antivaccine conspiracy theories and that it’s somehow “beneath” the oh-so-massive intellects of physicians, particularly academic physicians, to “waste” part of our supposedly-considerable brain power to debunk. To them, instead we should devote our incredible intellects and talents not to such dirty, plebeian concerns, such as alternative medicine and antivaccine misinformation, but rather to clinical trials, the depredations of big pharma, and topics like the question of overdiagnosis and mammography, a topic that I’ve covered a lot over the years.
Perhaps the best example of this attitude came from an oncologist named Dr. Vinay Prasad, who a couple of months before the pandemic mocked me and others who spend a lot of time deconstructing medical misinformation as being akin to LeBron James “dunking on a 7′ hoop”, the implication being that deconstructing medical misinformation (such as Goop’s jade eggs) is as easy to a physician as dunking on a short hoop would be to a basketball star.
Here’s a representative Tweet clearly directed at me (and hence deleted):
Again, a lot of us had a hard time not rolling our eyes at the whole line of attack, even as this occurred roughly a month before the very first cases of deadly pneumonia due to a new coronavirus were observed in Wuhan, China:
However, he continues to make some mistakes. He suggests in the podcast that skeptics tackle mammograms. When shown leading skeptics have done this, his response was silence.
2https://t.co/I5BYByzeAL
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) November 2, 2019
I won’t say a lot more about this, other than to refer you to responses to Dr. Prasad by Steve Novella and myself, written a year ago, when inexplicably Dr. Prasad decided to double down on his Twitter attacks, which had not aged very well given that a deadly pandemic had appeared within months of his “7′ hoop” Tweets and was immediately followed a veritable tsunami of deadly misinformation, in the form of a MedPage Today article.
It isn’t just doctors, either, who discount the importance of “soft targets”. A few years ago, Scientific American columnist John Horgan made much the same arguments about skepticism in general, not just skepticism of dubious medical claims. I hasten to add right here that there are certainly legitimate criticisms of the skeptic movement and what topics that it tends to expend the most energy on, but Mr. Horgan wasn’t about that. He basically framed skepticism, much as Dr. Prasad did later, as attacking “soft targets” like homeopathy and Bigfoot and ignoring “hard targets” like cancer and world peace. (I’m not exaggerating.) As I put it at the time, his entire argument could be summed up as, “Soft targets” = What you care about. “Hard targets” = what I care about. (Very much like Dr. Prasad, actually.) Again, Steve Novella agreed, characterizing Mr. Horgan’s take as “superficial to the point of being wrong” and betraying “utter ignorance about what skeptics discuss and what our actual position is on the examples he gives”.
I can’t help but mention before moving on to the next section how…interesting…it is that it didn’t take long after the pandemic hit before Dr. Prasad was issuing highly dubious hot takes on the COVID-19 pandemic and has become one of the foremost members of a group that we at SBM like to refer to as “COVID-19 contrarians”, doctors who tend to minimize the danger of COVID, exaggerate the risks of COVID-19 vaccines, and downplay (or sometimes even deny) the efficacy of public health interventions, such as masking and vaccines. As a result, he’s been featured on SBM several times, particularly by our newest member, Jonathan Howard. Examples include the time Dr. Prasad made bad arguments against an emergency use authorization (EUA) for COVID-19 vaccines in children, downplayed the risks of COVID-19 in children, praised an utterly incompetent study that “dumpster dived” into the VAERS database, and more. Indeed, Dr. Prasad even went so far as to characterize mask, social distancing, and vaccine mandates as the first steps on the road to fascism, basically going full Godwin, so to speak.
Dr. Prasad might represent one piece of anecdotal evidence, but his turn rather suggests that perhaps it would have served him better not to be so disparaging and full of contempt towards the efforts of us humble skeptics promoting science-based medicine and refuting misinformation. However, he is just a part of the problem.
Social media = fake news multiplied
Over the holiday break, I read a book by Jason Stanley, the Jacob Urowsky Professor of Philosophy at Yale University, entitled How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them. I highly recommend the book, but hasten to point out that it is not my purpose to discuss actual fascism (much) in this post; that is, in contrast to Dr. Prasad’s misguided attempts to portray COVID-19 control measures as incipient fascism or, at the very least, a slippery slope towards the death of US democracy. Rather, one chapter very much caught my attention in light of the pandemic and the problem of disinformation and misinformation about COVID-19. In his book, Professor Stanley takes pains to point out that there is nothing new about “fake news”, referring to examples from history in which fake news was used to foment violence. For example, after World War I, mass hysteria was provoked by fake news stories about mass rape of German women by African troops serving with the French troops who were occupying the Rhineland. Noting the similarity between how fake news spread in history, Prof. Stanley notes about newer examples of fake news in the social media era:
The fact that all of this eerily mirrors the spread of the German propaganda campaign in the 1920s of the “Black Horror on the Rhine” should dissuade us from adopting the view, currently in vogue, that this sort of “fake news” is a consequence of the modern revolution in social media.
The point, of course, is that “fake news” is nothing new. Nor, of course, are rumors, stories of dubious provenance, and conspiracy theories. These have been with us ever since humans developed language and used for nefarious ends. What is new is that social media allows this sort of misinformation a rapid global reach that it could not achieve before, or, even if it did, would take months or years to do. Worse, social media companies labored too long under the delusion that “bad speech” (such as medical misinformation and conspiracy theories) could be driven out and countered by “good speech” based on data, science, and reason. Particularly disingenuous is that these companies knew that their algorithms are designed to amplify material that provokes “engagement” (shares, responses, etc.). What is most likely to encourage such “engagement”? Obviously, it’s material that angers, frightens, or otherwise provokes strong emotion, which is why misinformation- and conspiracy theory-laden content tends to spread very rapidly compared to any sort of science-based countering. What that means is that information that the ever-so-eminent Dr. Prasad would consider “ridiculous” or beneath his engaging with, can almost instantaneously spread to all corners of the earth with an Internet connection. While it is true that Facebook (excuse me, Meta), Twitter, and the rest are finally waking up to the danger, they appear unwilling to invest the resources necessary to take on the task of minimizing the spread of misinformation and conspiracy theories on their networks, often instead relying too much on algorithms that don’t work very well.
Bloggers, at least, have been warning about the problem of misinformation spreading for a long time. Back when I started my first blog on a snowy Saturday in December in 2004, part of my motivation (besides feeling that my efforts on Usenet were going nowhere and Usenet was a dying platform) was that I saw how fast medical misinformation was spreading on the Internet. Remember, too, that this was before Facebook had been made available to the general public, before Twitter, before the rise of YouTube, and before Instagram. Back then, blogs were the new “thing”, and I observed the rise and proliferation of a number of antivaccine blogs. Then, several years later, I noted the first fumbling efforts of antivaxxers to use Facebook and Twitter, efforts that, unfortunately albeit predictably, became much less fumbling and more adroit over time. Now, there is a veritable juggernaut of misinformation, a social media ecosystem in which quacks, antivaxxers, cranks, and grifters spread COVID-19 and antivax misinformation along with conspiracy theories and politically and ideologically motivated fake news in huge quantities.
Everything old is new again
I conclude with a bit of fantasy here. As I said before, I’ve been sarcastically saying that “everything old is new again” for at least a year now. In general, I’m referring to antivaccine misinformation, and nearly every time I discuss specific COVID-19 antivax propaganda claims, I like to mention how none of these claims is new. Here are some examples of specific false or misleading claims:
    • Vaccines are harmful or even deadly (or even part of a “depopulation agenda“)
    • Vaccines “permanently alter your DNA“
    • Vaccines cause cancer
    • “Natural immunity” is better. (It isn’t.)
    • Vaccines don’t work
    • The virus isn’t deadly/is an artifact of testing/is misdiagnosed
    • The virus was made in a lab or leaked by a lab
    • Vaccines select for deadly variants, a claim first “pioneered” by Andrew Wakefield himself about the MMR and measles
    • Vaccines contain “fetal tissue” or “fetal DNA”
    • Vaccines cause Alzheimer’s disease or prion disease
    • Vaccines are full of horrible “toxins” (a.k.a. what I’ve been calling the “toxins gambit” since at least 2009)
    • Vaccines sterilize our womenfolk
I sometimes joke that the only reason that antivaxxers haven’t yet claimed that COVID-19 vaccines cause autism is because they weren’t approved for use in young children yet. I’m sure that will change, if it hasn’t already, with the EUA for a COVID vaccine for children ages 5-12, and, if that doesn’t do it, this old trope will appear when the vaccines are approved for children under five.
Then there was the claim that there is Hydra vulgaris in the vaccines. (Hydras are tiny freshwater animals that can grow to about an inch in size.) I guess that maybe there is one new antivax claim under the sun about COVID-19 vaccines. I suppose that this one could be filed as a variation on a favorite antivax technique of looking at vaccines under the microscope and gasping at scary-looking things whose identity antivaxxers don’t know, which has been done before.
And what about the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database? My last post of 2021 discussed in detail the history of antivaxxers weaponizing VAERS, using its open nature and passive reporting design to paint a false portrait of vaccines as deadly—a new Holocaust, even!—causing autism, sterilizing our teenaged girls (Gardasil), and the like? Those of us familiar with the long history of antivaxxers weaponizing VAERS reports dating back to the 1990s were warning before the vaccines were released under an EUA over a year ago. Indeed, I was even writing about how VAERS was already being weaponized in December 2020, after I had received my first dose of the Pfizer vaccine.
Now here’s the fantasy.

Imagine, if you will, that those of us “dunking on a 7′ hoop” hadn’t been mostly ignored or viewed as wasting our time. Imagine that, before the pandemic, there had been an appreciation among our profession that it is worthwhile, as Jonathan Howard put it, to debunk the seemingly ridiculous because it often serves as the basis for much less “benign” misinformation and pseudoscience. Imagine that the NIH hadn’t served, through the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), as a base for promoting pseudoscience in medicine since the 1990s, now run by a true believer in woo. Imagine that quackery such as anthroposophic medicine, homeopathy, and naturopathy hadn’t infiltrated leading academic centers as quackery infiltrated major medical journals. Imagine that this infiltration hadn’t led a medical center like the Cleveland Clinic to tolerate an antivaccine doctor like Dr. Daniel Niedes for so long. Imagine that Dr. Collins had actually done what he now regrets not having done (and that Dr. Anthony Fauci had done it too), and dedicated considerable NIH resources over decades leading up to the pandemic to understanding medical misinformation and conspiracy theories. Imagine that they understood the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, the conspiracy theory on which all antivax conspiracy theories are based and of which all antivax conspiracy theories are but a variation? Let’s go even farther and imagine that it was understood how all science denial is a form of conspiracy theory, so that it could have been foreseen how rapidly antivaxxers would team up with “anti-lockdown” and “antimask” protesters. Imagine that science communicators were appreciated, with science communication being widely understood to be a discipline in itself, contrary to the case over the last 25 years since Carl Sagan died. Imagine that state medical boards recognized that being a physician is a privilege, not a right, and that using one’s stature as a physician to spread dangerous health and antivaccine misinformation is an offense worthy of suffering the penalty of having one’s medical license removed, rather than having to have been dragged into that realization only a few months ago.
Would it all have made a difference if all the elements of my fantasy had been in place in January 2020? Maybe not, but I’m quite sure that we would nonetheless have been in much better shape to deal with the pandemic and wouldn’t have seen the fumbling efforts against, for instance, the Great Barrington Declaration “natural herd immunity” strategy, whose premises Collins himself said required a “devastating published takedown” but was unable or unwilling to do.
The question, of course, is: Now that physicians and scientists have finally awakened to the threat of health misinformation, how do we keep them engaged now? In the future, how do we our professions from retreating back into “shruggie” complacency or even “dunking on a 7′ hoop” hostility to combating this misinformation after the pandemic finally fades into history?
        ◦ I don’t claim to know the answers now, but I have ideas that I hope to discuss in 2022, along with links between not just old antivaccine misinformation and COVID-19 misinformation, but how old alternative medicine beliefs undergird much of the misinformation we see. We at SBM will need help in advocating for science in medicine. Everything old might seem new again now, but it’s all just part of the longstanding problem of combatting irrational beliefs to which humans have always been prone.

A poorly framed article on COVID-19 vaccine injury in the New York Times
A poorly framed article on people who believe that COVID-19 vaccines injured them is being trumpeted by antivaxxers. Where the New York Times and its reporter Apoorva Mandavilli go wrong?
David Gorski on May 6, 2024
Link
Those of us who have been writing about medical misinformation, disinformation, and quackery are very familiar with a certain type of story or anecdote frequently presented by those who have lost faith in science-based medicine to argue for unproven and unscientific medical claims. One example is the person with a longstanding and often vague constellation of health symptoms that conventional medicine has not dealt with well and often cannot explain who becomes convinced that the cause is something like chronic Lyme disease, “adrenal fatigue” (as opposed to the real disease adrenal insufficiency), “electromagnetic sensitivity,” or any of the number of other fake diagnoses that quacks use to offer these patients hope when conventional medicine is struggling. Besides the inexplicable symptoms, a key component of these anecdotes is that “conventional” medical doctors are portrayed as, at best, ignoring their stories or, at worse, being dismissive of their symptoms and suffering, sometimes haughtily and even contemptuously so. (Worse, sometimes they are not exaggerating by much.) Before the pandemic, another common example of these sorts of stories consisted of parents—like Jenny McCarthy—who were utterly convinced that vaccines had been the cause of their child’s autism and treated even gentle attempts to persuade them that copious existing science does not support such a link angrily, as though doctors were denying their knowledge. Such stories, unsurprisingly, make for compelling human-interest stories and long before the pandemic sometimes tripped up journalists into giving too much credence to pseudoscientific diagnoses like CLD, vaccine-induced autism, and electromagnetic insufficiency, often based on the question, “What else could be causing these symptoms?”
Those of you who read the New York Times this weekend might sense where I’m going with this introduction, because featured prominently in the Sunday Times (but published on Friday) is an article by Apoorva Mandavilli that is being trumpeted by a number of antivaxxers as “vindication.” Entitled Thousands Believe Covid Vaccines Harmed Them. Is Anyone Listening? the story also sports the tagline, All vaccines have at least occasional side effects. But people who say they were injured by Covid vaccines believe their cases have been ignored. Of course, anyone who is familiar with Betteridge’s Law of Headlines knows that usually the answer to a question in the title of a news article is no, and, although this report doesn’t state a clear “no” as the answer to the question, it does clearly suggest that the answer is much closer to “no” than to “yes.”
Therein lies the first problem. This story is framed in the way that I’ve seen so many articles going back years and years about vaccine-induced autism, CLD, electromagnetic sensitivity,” and the like framed in the past: Primarily as a human-interest story about suffering people bravely trying to convince an uncaring establishment (be it medical or otherwise) of The Truth that no one wants to admit. In using this framing, Mandavilli and the NYT present stories and facts in a context designed to lead you to suspect that “They” are covering something up about COVID-19 vaccine injuries.
Before I go on, let me just emphasize that no one—and I mean no one—says that serious vaccine injuries don’t or can’t happen. Rather, science shows that, other than local reactions, fevers and chills, and other brief symptoms, severe adverse reactions to vaccines tend to be quite rare. Moreover, I have long said that those who suffer genuine vaccine injury should be recognized as having suffered such an injury and appropriately compensated. What Mandavilli’s article gets right is that, unlike the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, which applies to all FDA-approved vaccines, vaccines like like the COVID-19 vaccines, which were not fully FDA-approved but instead received an emergency use authorization (EUA) are covered by the far stingier Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program. For the CICP, the burden of proof is much higher than it is for the VICP, where the level of proof is the same as it is for civil lawsuits (50% and a feather, as some put it) and the rules are set up to make it easier for complainants to access the system, to the point of the VICP will reimburse complainants for their legal costs and reasonable costs of bringing cases before the Vaccine Court the special court set up to hear such cases. Moreover, VICP only requires that such cases be heard first by the Vaccine Court; if a claim is denied, federal courts are still available.
As Mandavilli notes about the CICP, in contrast:
The federal government has long run the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, designed to compensate people who suffer injuries after vaccination. Established more than three decades ago, the program sets no limit on the amounts awarded to people found to have been harmed.
But Covid vaccines are not covered by that fund because Congress has not made them subject to the excise tax that pays for it. Some lawmakers have introduced bills to make the change.
Instead, claims regarding Covid vaccines go to the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program. Intended for public health emergencies, this program has narrow criteria to pay out and sets a limit of $50,000, with stringent standards of proof.
It requires applicants to prove within a year of the injury that it was “the direct result” of getting the Covid vaccine, based on “compelling, reliable, valid, medical, and scientific evidence.”
The program had only four staff members at the beginning of the pandemic, and now has 35 people evaluating claims. Still, it has reviewed only a fraction of the 13,000 claims filed, and has paid out only a dozen.
Dr. Ilka Warshawsky, a 58-year-old pathologist, said she lost all hearing in her right ear after a Covid booster shot. But hearing loss is not a recognized side effect of Covid vaccination.
The compensation program for Covid vaccines sets a high bar for proof, she said, yet offers little information on how to meet it: “These adverse events can be debilitating and life-altering, and so it’s very upsetting that they’re not acknowledged or addressed.”
I doubt that there are any vaccine advocates who don’t agree that the CICP should be reformed and fully funded and that COVID-19 vaccine injuries should be treated like any other vaccine injury adjudicated under the VICP. Of course, as an aside, I can’t help but note that antivax lawyers have long hated the VICP and the Vaccine Court because, even though it’s a guaranteed payday for them, win or lose, in terms of hourly charges, these lawyers suing for “vaccine injury” want to play the lottery and risk not getting paid in hopes of getting a 30% contingency fee from multimillion dollar judgments. The reason I mention this is that antivaxxers might not be too thrilled if COVID-19 vaccine injury cases from before the vaccines were granted full FDA approval and were being administered under an EUA were shifted to the Vaccine Court. However, it would be much better for those who might have been injured by COVID-19 vaccines than the CICP. (Regular commenter and professor of law Dorit Reiss wrote about the CICP and its problems nearly three years ago at another blog, agreeing that, “Ideally, I would like to see COVID-19 vaccine liability moved to the routine compensation program.”)
Unfortunately, despite making some good points (another of which I will discuss later), the story frames the issue in such a way as to lead to an impression that those who might have suffered injury from COVID-19 vaccines are not being taken seriously. That impression permeates the framing of this article, which is bookended by the telling of a sad story.
Lead with the heart
Mandavilli’s story, as nearly all such stories seem to do, with a human interest story, an anecdote that in these sorts of stories is meant to put a human face on a problem and be representative of the problems being reported. In this case, it is a neuroscientist named Michelle Zimmerman, who suffered puzzling symptoms after receiving the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine. Remember that the J&J vaccine was not based on the mRNA technology used for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines that were administered to the vast majority of vaccinees, but, rather, was based on an adenoviral vector designed to express (make) the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein as the antigen:
Within minutes of getting the Johnson & Johnson Covid-19 vaccine, Michelle Zimmerman felt pain racing from her left arm up to her ear and down to her fingertips. Within days, she was unbearably sensitive to light and struggled to remember simple facts.
She was 37, with a Ph.D. in neuroscience, and until then could ride her bicycle 20 miles, teach a dance class and give a lecture on artificial intelligence, all in the same day. Now, more than three years later, she lives with her parents. Eventually diagnosed with brain damage, she cannot work, drive or even stand for long periods of time.
“When I let myself think about the devastation of what this has done to my life, and how much I’ve lost, sometimes it feels even too hard to comprehend,” said Dr. Zimmerman, who believes her injury is due to a contaminated vaccine batch.
The story is bookended with this followup on Dr. Zimmerman:
One of her therapists recently told her she might never be able to live independently again.
“That felt like a devastating blow,” Dr. Zimmerman said. “But I’m trying not to lose hope there will someday be a treatment and a way to cover it.”
In fairness, right after introducing Dr. Zimmerman, Mandavilla notes:
The Covid vaccines, a triumph of science and public health, are estimated to have prevented millions of hospitalizations and deaths. Yet even the best vaccines produce rare but serious side effects. And the Covid vaccines have been given to more than 270 million people in the United States, in nearly 677 million doses.
All of this is true, but when it is mentioned after an anecdote like that of Dr. Zimmerman, the framing comes across very much as, “Yes, but?”
Regardless, my heart goes out to Dr. Zimmerman and the others discussed in this story, as it does to all such patients suffering from a constellation of debilitating symptoms that her doctors can’t explain and have not been able to deal with well. I hope that she finds what is going on and a treatment that can get her as close as possible back to a normal life. As someone who late in life discovered physical fitness and, like her, can ride my bicycle over 20 miles, I just can’t imagine what it would be like to lose the ability to do that and so many other routine daily activities. That being said, this story suffers from just mentioning that she blames her symptoms on a contaminated batch of J&J vaccine without giving some context. I vaguely remembered a story about contaminated COVID-19 vaccines from early in the rollout, but didn’t remember any details. So I clicked on the link, which goes to a NYT story from three years ago entitled, The F.D.A. tells Johnson & Johnson that about 60 million doses made at a troubled plant cannot be used. What was the contamination? According to the story:
More than 100 million doses of Johnson & Johnson and at least 70 million doses of AstraZeneca were put on hold after Emergent discovered in March that its workers had contaminated a batch of Johnson & Johnson’s vaccine with a key ingredient used to produce AstraZeneca’s. Federal officials then ordered the plant to pause production, stripped Emergent of its responsibility to produce AstraZeneca’s vaccine and instructed Johnson & Johnson to assert direct control over the manufacturing of its vaccine there.
What was that “key ingredient”? The story didn’t say; so I tried to do some Googling. An article in Fierce Pharma wasn’t any more revealing, although it did make me wonder if any of the contaminated batches, whatever it was that they were contaminated with, ever made it out to be administered. The reason is that something described as a “key component” of the J&J vaccine and the AstraZeneca vaccine (another COVID-19 vaccine based on an adenoviral vector) were being manufactured in the same plant and somehow batches of the J&J vaccine had apparently been contaminated with this “key component” of the AstraZeneca vaccine. Since the two vaccines are very similar. Moreover, there were a number of investigations of the mixup at a subcontractor, Emergent BioSolutions, where the two vaccines were being manufactured, which showed that Emergent had had a history of red flags in terms of its quality control and manufacturing processes dating back to before it got the contracts to manufacture vaccines under the “Warp Speed” initiative, notably its role as a key supplier before the pandemic of anthrax vaccine for the Strategic National Stockpile. Moreover, from what I’ve read, it seems that what happened is that the contamination was actually of this key component of the J&J vaccine with that of the AstraZeneca vaccine.
I don’t want to dwell on this point other than to say first that it is incredibly unlikely that Dr. Zimmerman’s dose of J&J vaccine came from one of the contaminated batches given that the reporting I can find from the time indicates that the contamination was detected before the doses were shipped and that no doses of contaminated J&J vaccine ever reached the public. Second, even if Dr. Zimmerman did receive a contaminated dose it strains the imagination to come up with a mechanism by which such contamination would result in her constellation of medical symptoms, even if the cross contamination was the two adenoviral vectors making the spike protein, given that both were designed similarly. Finally, you would think that, instead of reporting only that Dr. Zimmerman thought her problems stemmed from a contaminated batch, Mandavilla would have mentioned some context and that apparently no contaminated batches ever reached the public. The story was more about an amount of that key ingredient, whatever it was, sufficient to manufacture many millions of doses of J&J vaccine having to be discarded and the sheer waste involved, rather than contaminated vaccine making it to the public.
As for Dr. Zimmerman, like a number of these patients, she has become a crusader, but much of what I found about her online didn’t help me understand much. For instance, this article didn’t really go into detail about her health problems but rather only mentions that it has been over 700 days since she had submitted her CICP claim and that she had no answers, nor did a BMJ Rapid Response by her help much either, other than that I basically agree that the CICP needs to do better. I also came across a long X/Twitter thread about the story in which Dr. Zimmerman describes some of the things she’s tried.
Here is a YouTube video of an interview that she did with Dr. Mobeen Syed, of whom I had never heard before. Perusing Dr. Syed’s social media, particularly his YouTube channel, led me to believe that he mixes useful, evidence-based tidbits with a lot of highly questionable medicine. Feel free to judge for yourself if you don’t believe me by perusing his YouTube channel. Suffice to say that I found a favorable interview with COVID-19 quack Dr. Paul Marik, founder of the crank or on his channel, among others, as well as a Substack linking to talks by him on COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” (which is not a thing). Moreover, the Substack algorithm seems to think that if I like Dr. Syed’s Substack I’ll like Substacks of the FLCCC Alliance and Dr. Pierre Kory. Overall, what I noticed was that his videos before the pandemic seem quite normal and reasonable, boring even, as lectures about medicine. After? Well, again, judge for yourself.
What saddened me is that in the interview, Dr. Zimmerman appears to have gone down the rabbit hole of thinking that she has mitochondrial injury and is undergoing tests for it. In fact, watching this video made me sad, because it’s clear that Dr. Zimmerman, in her desperation, is trying lots of different interventions, which range from the perhaps reasonable as a long shot to pure quackery, as you can see from these slides presented during the interview, which was published on May 12, 2023:
Whenever you see a constellation of symptoms like this, it is always difficult to come up with a unifying cause. It is also difficult to come up with a plausible biological mechanism by which a “contaminated” J&J adenoviral vaccine might have caused all this.
The treatments that she is undergoing are really where I feel for Dr. Zimmerman, who appears to have become the victim of at least some quacks:
It leapt right out at me from the second slide that Dr. Zimmerman is using nattokinase and serrapeptase. I haven’t written about the latter but have noted that nattokinase has become a favorite quack treatment sold by COVID antivax quack Dr. Peter McCullough‘s The Wellness Company to treat “COVID vaccine injury,” the main difference being that, instead of serrapeptase, TWC’s formula includes another enzyme, bromelain.
As for some of the others, hyperbaric oxygen is a catch-all treatment that a lot of dubious health practitioners use to treat, well, basically everything. It generally has very few and very defined indications, such as in helping to heal hypoxic wounds, but most of its other uses are not evidence-based. Photobiomodulation is a form of laser treatment that might—the operative word being might—have some uses and benefits but has in generally been massively oversold, as noted by Jonathan Jarry, who describes it as a ” razzle-dazzle of cold lasers and red lights being used to treat just about anything,” and Paul Ingraham, who notes that such laser-based therapy is a “classic example of premature hype about a futuristic, ‘high-tech,’ unproven therapy: clinical practice races way ahead of the science, which barely exists, and all the hopes are pinned on vague and unfalsifiable biological plausibility, and research that is rife with fancy-sounding ‘mechanism masturbation’ — wishful and fanciful speculation about how it works rather than focusing on whether or not it actually does.” (Damn, Paul. I’m going to have to remember that term, “mechanism masturbation.”)
Unfortunately, the term appears to apply to some of the mechanisms mentioned in the interview, involving platelet activation, mitochondria, and various other measures. Dr. Zimmerman appears to have gone from researcher to researcher, including long COVID researchers like David Putrino, who has described microclots in patients with long COVID, in a desperate search to find what is causing her symptoms and how to alleviate them, citing a number of papers that might or might not have anything to do with each other and table after table of her lab results. For example, she shows an image from her blood from the Putrino lab showing microclots, but my reading of Putrino’s research leads me to think that he’s not about “vaccine injury”:
All of the long COVID patients Putrino has tested have had microclots and hyperactivated platelets, which is something he doesn’t commonly see in people who have never had COVID or who have fully recovered. It’s this high level of microclots in long COVID patients that Putrino thinks might be the biomarker. One of the questions that remains is, if they continue to see this pattern on a bigger scale, is targeting and getting rid of these microclots an effective treatment?
It is, however, true that Dr. Putrino is a co-author on one descriptive analysis reporting a “post-vaccination syndrome” after COVID-19 vaccination with the Moderna of Pfizer vaccine. Participants had joined the online Yale Listen to Immune, Symptom and Treatment Experiences Now (LISTEN) Study from May 2022 to July 2023:
The five most common symptoms were exercise intolerance (71%), excessive fatigue (69%), numbness (63%), brain fog (63%), and neuropathy (63%). In the week before survey completion, participants reported feeling unease (93%), fearfulness (82%), and overwhelmed by worries (81%), as well as feelings of helplessness (80%), anxiety (76%), depression (76%), hopelessness (72%), and worthlessness (49%) at least once. Participants reported a median of 20 (IQR: 13 to 30) interventions to treat their condition.
Concluding:
In this study, individuals who reported PVS after covid-19 vaccination had low health status, high symptom burden, and high psychosocial stress despite trying many treatments. There is a need for continued investigation to understand and treat this condition.
This study, of course, doesn’t apply to Dr. Zimmerman because it didn’t look at J&J vaccines. However, one always wonders if there’s something there, and I have no problem with more research being done. I realize that it’s possible that, should Dr. Zimmerman come across this post, she, like other patients whom I’ve discussed in the past, might take this as an attack on her. It is not. She is a victim here. Whether she is a victim of the vaccine or not, I have not been able to decide, but she is definitely a victim.
Other anecdotes
Mandavilli’s story is not just about Dr. Zimmerman, of course. It also tells the story of four other people, most healthcare professionals including, unsurprisingly, Dr. Gregory Poland, who has been in the news before for having developed “life-altering” tinnitus after the second dose of “an mRNA vaccine,” whom I also wrote about a year ago. In Mandavilla’s reporting, he experienced it after the first dose, which conflicts with this 2022 interview in MedPage Today. Another doctor, Dr. Buddy Creech, who ironically enough led several Covid vaccine trials at Vanderbilt University, reported tinnitus and racing heart for about a week after each shot, noting, “It’s very similar to what I experienced during acute Covid, back in March of 2020.”
His inclusion in the NYT report led me to update my PubMed search, as the studies available at the time had been conflicting, to determine if more recent work had found a link between the mRNA vaccines and tinnitus. One recent retrospective study found an elevated risk, as did another study, although another study found that over 20% of people who suffer from COVID-19 can develop tinnitus, while yet another found that, although a significant number of patients suffered sudden sensorineural hearing loss (of which tinnitus is one type) after vaccination, the incidence was “comparable to the general otology patient population” and still another found no correlation, although the latter was a single institution study. I was forced to conclude that we still don’t know if COVID-19 vaccines can cause the sudden onset of tinnitus and that it’s difficult to attribute causation because it is a common diagnosis and would be expected to occur within fairly close temporal association with vaccination during a mass vaccination campaign as huge as the COVID vaccine campaign was.
Also:
Shaun Barcavage, 54, a nurse practitioner in New York City who has worked on clinical trials for H.I.V. and Covid, said that ever since his first Covid shot, merely standing up sent his heart racing — a symptom suggestive of postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, a neurological disorder that some studies have linked to both Covid and, much less often, vaccination.
He also experienced stinging pain in his eyes, mouth and genitals, which has abated, and tinnitus, which has not.
“I can’t get the government to help me,” Mr. Barcavage said of his fruitless pleas to federal agencies and elected representatives. “I am told I’m not real. I’m told I’m rare. I’m told I’m coincidence.”
And:
Renee France, 49, a physical therapist in Seattle, developed Bell’s palsy — a form of facial paralysis, usually temporary — and a dramatic rash that neatly bisected her face. Bell’s palsy is a known side effect of other vaccines, and it has been linked to Covid vaccination in some studies.
But Dr. France said doctors were dismissive of any connection to the Covid vaccines. The rash, a bout of shingles, debilitated her for three weeks, so Dr. France reported it to federal databases twice.
“I thought for sure someone would reach out, but no one ever did,” she said.
I note that POTS has long been claimed to be a side effect of HPV vaccines, despite the lack of evidence. As for Bell’s palsy, the evidence is rather conflicting as well, with some studies possibly showing a slightly elevated risk after vaccination, while another finds no elevated risk after vaccination but a definite elevated risk after COVID-19. Again, the problem is that these conditions appear to be also associated with COVID-19.
Overall, Mandavilli interviewed 30 people over the course of a year who said they had been harmed by COVID-19 vaccines, noting that they “described a variety of symptoms following vaccination, some neurological, some autoimmune, some cardiovascular.” What stood out to me is that that is an incredibly small number given the billions of doses of COVID-19 vaccinations given worldwide and the hundreds of millions in the US alone. Indeed, even the “thousands” mentioned in the article would be a very tiny number compared to the number of people vaccinated. The problem, as I’ve always said, is the law of large numbers. When you vaccinate 270 million people, side effects with even a tiny chance of happening, will start to occur in large numbers. Moreover, never let it be said that I dismiss vaccine injuries; what I have a problem with is the framing of this article as an uncaring CDC and medical profession basically ignoring the concerns of these patients.
That being said, we do have to do better. Mandavilli reports that her 30 interviewees “had been turned away by physicians, told their symptoms were psychosomatic, or labeled anti-vaccine by family and friends — despite the fact that they supported vaccines.” I hope that no physician had labeled any of them “antivaccine,” but some lay public are indeed too fast to do that. That being said, I have little doubt that some doctors don’t handle dealing with odd symptom complexes well, particularly when there is little evidence to guide them with respect to cause or treatment.
Active versus passive surveillance
I again have to concede that not all of the reporting in this story is bad. For instance, in the article Mandavilli points out problems that really do hamper our ability to definitively recognize vaccine injury:
Federal officials and independent scientists face a number of challenges in identifying potential vaccine side effects.
The nation’s fragmented health care system complicates detection of very rare side effects, a process that depends on an analysis of huge amounts of data. That’s a difficult task when a patient may be tested for Covid at Walgreens, get vaccinated at CVS, go to a local clinic for minor ailments and seek care at a hospital for serious conditions. Each place may rely on different health record systems.
There is no central repository of vaccine recipients, nor of medical records, and no easy to way to pool these data. Reports to the largest federal database of so-called adverse events can be made by anyone, about anything. It’s not even clear what officials should be looking for.
“I mean, you’re not going to find ‘brain fog’ in the medical record or claims data, and so then you’re not going to find a signal” that it may be linked to vaccination, Dr. Woodcock said. If such a side effect is not acknowledged by federal officials, “it’s because it doesn’t have a good research definition,” she added. “It isn’t, like, malevolence on their part.”
Much of this is true.
On the other hand, although the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) features prominently in the article, as it does on all articles about vaccine injury, suspected or real, and Mandavilli points out (as above) that anyone can make a report about anything, nowhere in the article are other vaccine safety monitoring systems mentioned except in passing. For example, I was gobsmacked that nowhere in this article was there even a mention of the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) or other vaccine safety reporting systems by name, although it was referred to:
Federal researchers also comb through databases that combine electronic health records and insurance claims on tens of millions of Americans. The scientists monitor the data for 23 conditions that may occur following Covid vaccination. Officials remain alert to others that may pop up, Dr. Daskalakis said.
Yes, the link above goes to a presentation from VSD data about COVID-19 vaccine safety, which is all well and good, but the percentage of people who click on most links is very small and those reading the article on a paper copy of the newspaper are not going to have even the option of getting that context. Overall, not naming the VSD when describing what it does and mentioning it almost in passing compared to VAERS leave the impression that VAERS is pretty much the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring in the US., which makes her comparison to other countries grate, at least to me, when I was reading this:
In some countries with centralized health care systems, officials have actively sought out reports of serious side effects of Covid vaccines and reached conclusions that U.S. health authorities have not.
In Hong Kong, the government analyzed centralized medical records of patients after vaccination and paid people to come forward with problems. The strategy identified “a lot of mild cases that other countries would not otherwise pick up,” said Ian Wong, a researcher at the University of Hong Kong who led the nation’s vaccine safety efforts.
That included the finding that in rare instances — about seven per million doses — the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine triggered a bout of shingles serious enough to require hospitalization.
The European Medicines Agency has linked the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines to facial paralysis, tingling sensations and numbness. The E.M.A. also counts tinnitus as a side effect of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine, although the American health agencies do not. There are more than 17,000 reports of tinnitus following Covid vaccination in VAERS.
Are the two linked? It’s not clear. As many as one in four adults has some form of tinnitus. Stress, anxiety, grief and aging can lead to the condition, as can infections like Covid itself and the flu.
There is no test or scan for tinnitus, and scientists cannot easily study it because the inner ear is tiny, delicate and encased in bone, said Dr. Konstantina Stankovic, an otolaryngologist at Stanford University.
It is potentially a fair point that VSD is a smaller system than those of a lot of other countries because we do not have a centralized healthcare system or a centralized database of medical records or vaccinations. That might be why these countries found associations that the US did not. Also, Hong Kong paid people to come forward with their stories? I’d be worried that the offer of payment in and of itself could distort the reporting. It also doesn’t help that the context for the story isn’t really given in the story itself, but rather in a sidebar story, Covid Vaccine Side Effects: 4 Takeaways From Our Investigation. I’ll comment on each one.
    • For most people, the benefits of Covid vaccines outweigh any risks. (Now she tells us.)
    • Federal surveillance has found some side effects but may miss others. (Well, yes, but that’s why we examine data from all over the world. Each country’s system of vaccine safety monitoring has its strengths and weaknesses. And she cites VAERS as the largest but again, as though it were the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring. It’s also true that the Israelis beat us detecting the signal for myocarditis from the mRNA vaccines, but we found the signal for blood clots from the AstraZeneca vaccines in a timely fashion.)
    • Proving vaccination led to an illness is complicated. (Yes, but the anecdotes sure do leave the impression that vaccination very likely caused the symptoms and conditions those interviewed are suffering from.)
    • Understanding the full range of side effects may take years. (No one ever said otherwise, although, again, nearly all adverse events from vaccines manifest themselves within a few weeks of vaccination at most.)
Finally, let’s just say that antivaxxers have noticed this article and viewed it about the way you’d predict:
We must remember: thousands and thousands more have NOT reported obvious vaccine injuries. I personally know several people who were immediately and severely injured in '21. Their Drs discouraged them to not report, and to not complain.One Dr "fired" my friend for even asking.
— Erich Hartmann (@erichhartmann) May 4, 2024
I was shocked to see this covered in the NYT yesterday. Some of my favorite quotes from the article:“I feel bad for those people,” said Dr. Woodcock, who became the F.D.A.’s acting commissioner in January 2021 as the vaccines were rolling out. “I believe their suffering should…
— Moms for RFK Jr (@moms4rfkjr) May 4, 2024
They can't hide it any longer. Yet @BillGates is still out there hawking new mRNA "vaccines" and getting glowing press.
— Norm D. (@ncd22124) May 4, 2024
They aren’t listening because they can’t see, hear or read it. People have likely already been censored for saying they suffered a vax injury.Thousands Believe Covid Vaccines Harmed Them. Is Anyone Listening? – The New York Times https://t.co/82iyhNnqit
— George Colli (@GeorgeColli) May 5, 2024
I stand corrected. The New York Times (probably before Chris Cuomo) recently came out on the #vaccine injuries and the gaslighting and censorship of their victims. https://t.co/W2H7akjFfY https://t.co/Ynkx0nP6QR
— jay sanchez (@jaysanchezdorta) May 4, 2024
I could go on and on and on, but you get the idea from the sample above and this article featured on Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivax org Children’s Health Defense:
Let’s just say that antivaxxers know an article that is echoing their longstanding messages, and when that article appears in the NYT they are going to do their utmost to spin it as vindication. While it is the duty of news organizations to hold authority to account for its failures and point out where systems like our vaccine safety monitoring system need reform and improvement, which this article does, it’s also important not to make it too easy for enemies of public health and vaccination to use your reporting for their own purposes, which is what the NYT did here. Its poor framing based on an all-too-familiar (and tired) trope of people with mysterious diseases who believe they know what caused them being supposedly ignored and vilified by conventional medicine undermined what could have been an excellent story about the massive shortcomings of the CICP and problems with our current vaccine safety monitoring program.
Worse, framing like this does nothing to help those who are really suffering, like Dr. Zimmerman.
ADDENDUM: Dr. Vincent Iannelli has commented on the NYT article. He is a bit more harsh than I was, to the point that I wonder if I went too easy on Mandravilli and her editors at the NYT. On the other hand, I do note that Alex Berenson is not pleased with Mandravilli’s article, calling it a “gaslighting masterpiece.”

Some Doctors Cared Much More About Sore Arms Than Cold Bodies
The campaign against boosters was just a small part of a pathetic, pandemic-long pattern where doctors expressed grave concern about the mildest harms of measures to limit COVID, even purely theoretical ones, while being totally indifferent to literally anything the virus could do, including the deaths of children and young adults.
Jonathan Howard on March 22, 2024
Link
Two possible mistakes
Every day, doctors have to make decisions without the benefit of a large randomized-controlled trial (RCT) to guide their every move. That’s a normal part of medicine.
Whenever I am conflicted about whether or not to start a treatment, I think about two possible mistakes I could make: I could give a patient a treatment they don’t need or I could withhold a treatment they do need. I then try to gauge both how consequential and how probable each mistake might be. For someone with a potentially dangerous condition that has a safe treatment, it’s better to overtreat several patients than to undertreat just one.
In a nationwide cohort of more than 1 million adults aged 65 years and older, no increased risk of 28 adverse events was observed following vaccination with a monovalent XBB.1.5-containing vaccine.
Let’s apply this thinking with the updated COVID vaccine. (It shouldn’t be called a booster, though I will do so for the sake of simplicity). There are two possible mistakes. You could give someone a booster they don’t need or you could withhold a booster from someone who needs it.
Right away, it’s obvious the risks are not symmetric. Beyond a sore arm and fever, harms from the booster are mercifully rare. Vaccine-myocarditis occurs mainly adolescent males (1 in 15,000 to 1 in 88,000) and is universally described as “mild” by the doctors who treat it. The booster seems totally safe for older people who need it the most. According to one study from February 2024:
In a nationwide cohort of more than 1 million adults aged 65 years and older, no increased risk of 28 adverse events was observed following vaccination with a monovalent XBB.1.5-containing vaccine.
In contrast, COVID continues to kill and disable people.
Withholding a needed booster, especially from an older, vulnerable person, is clearly more consequential than giving someone a booster they don’t need.
If the U.S. moved at a faster pace to approve it and get people boosted, an estimated 29,000 lives could have been saved.
Next, we need to know how probable it is that boosters reduce COVID’s harms. There was a RCT for the first booster, showing “95.3% efficacy against Covid-19 as compared with two doses”, though this impressive result didn’t stop some doctors from trashing this dose. As the pandemic progressed and knowledge accumulated, scientists reasonably concluded that it wasn’t necessary to start over at step 1 and do an RCT for every tweak to the vaccine. RCTs are slow, the virus spreads quickly, and there’s a real cost to waiting.
Of course, it wasn’t totally absurd to believe that a vaccine that generated a strong immune response against SARS-CoV-2 would also protect against COVID itself. Other vaccines have been approved based on immunogenicity without controversy, and one meta-analysis from March 2023 found:
Predicted neutralising antibody titres are strongly correlated with observed vaccine effectiveness against symptomatic and severe COVID-19
Indeed, nearly 60 observational studies (see below) as well as several systematic reviews and meta-analyses have shown that boosters limit COVID’s harms, though they are not a panacea and their benefit wanes quickly. Other studies have shown that boosters limit viral transmission.
Maybe it’s true that every one of these studies is “plagued by confounding” and totally useless, as some doctors claim. Maybe it’s just a statistical fluke that they all point in the same direction. If that’s the case, millions of people got sore arms for no reason and a small number of young men got “mild” myocarditis. That’s definitely not a good thing, but it’s a drop in the bucket compared to COVID’s toll.
But what if these studies were not entirely a statistical fluke? What if they were right, and the booster actually keeps some people alive and out of the hospital? It’s not absurd to believe this, is it? Then, it would be a huge mistake to deprive someone of a booster dose they needed. Indeed one modeling study estimated:
That through June 2022, if the U.S. moved at a faster pace to approve it and get people boosted, an estimated 29,000 lives could have been saved.
Looking at all the evidence, I am confident that more people suffered grave injuries from missing a needed dose than from getting an unneeded dose. That’s likely to be the case moving forward as well. COVID isn’t going anywhere, and while deaths are much lower than before, over 1,000 Americans are still dying of COVID every week, and many more are being injured by it. It seems neither terrible nor scientifically implausible to try blunt COVID’s harms with a periodic booster, even one that hasn’t proven its value in a large and lengthy RCT.
They are net harmful- due to AEs (adverse events) at time of injection.
Many doctors disagreed with this. They felt, unless every modification to the vaccine had proven its value via a massive RCT, then one could assume the vaccine did not work. These doctors could never show the vaccine was dangerous, especially for older people who needed it the most. It seems OK to get 217 vaccines. However, they felt the data supporting the vaccine just wasn’t robust enough, and from that, they took a massive leap and concluded we should just the virus repeatedly infect everyone. There was nothing we could do about it. We want them infected wasn’t just for young people anymore. It was for everyone.
For some, this was literally a religious belief. Data-trickster Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo recently issued a statement titled Florida State Surgeon General Calls for Halt in the Use of COVID-19 mRNA Vaccines. He also told Steve Bannon:
I think it probably does have some integration at some levels with the human genome because these vaccines are honestly—they’re the Antichrist of all products.
Other doctors fundamentally agreed with Dr. Ladapo. They ridiculed and shamed anyone, including older, vulnerable people, who wanted even the first booster, the one with RCT-data supporting it. One doctor, who previously claimed post-vaccination fevers- “we’re talking about grade three fevers!“- was a valid reason to let unvaccinated children contract COVID, gave sore arms as his key reason why we should let unboosted seniors contract COVID. He said:
They are net harmful- due to AEs (adverse events) at time of injection.
This doctor, seeking to encourage conformity and groupthink amongst his paying followers, even asked them to sign a pledge to refuse booster doses, a classic influencer technique.
Because of subsequent increasing incidence, more and more boosters were added to compensate for “waning immunity” and now children get 6 doses by 6 years old.
None of this was new.
As those of us who cared about vaccines before the pandemic know very well, anti-vaxxers have long claimed that mundane vaccine-side effects are worse than the diseases they prevent. For example, prior to the pandemic germ-theory denier Dr. Kelly Brogan discouraged the flu vaccine by writing:
Common side effects include symptoms like fatigue, fever, body and headaches (aka…the flu!)
Obviously, these side effects are not the same as getting the flu itself, which can kill children especially unvaccinated ones.
Additionally, anti-vaxxers have long tried to scare parents based on the number of vaccines children receive and literally nothing else. “Too many, too soon” is the unofficial slogan of the anti-vaccine movement. Anti-vaxxers think is clever to simply state the number of vaccine doses, often paired with a frightening image of syringes in a baby doll, as if that number alone is a strike against vaccines. For example, prior to the pandemic, Dr. Brogan encouraged parents to leave their children vulnerable to whooping cough by saying:
Because of subsequent increasing incidence, more and more boosters were added to compensate for “waning immunity” and now children get 6 doses by 6 years old.
She’s right that kids get the DTaP multiple times, but this is not a valid argument against this vaccine. It’s a scare tactic. Yet, respectable doctors copied Dr. Brogan’s rhetoric during the pandemic to spread doubt about the COVID booster- I, like many of my patients, have questions about the 7th, 8th, and 9th booster (I wish I was exaggerating). Of course, anyone who survived long enough to get their 9th booster is doing something right.
Getting COVID is inevitable. It is just another cold or flu like illness.
In a pandemic where over a million Americans died and millions more were injured- many of them unvaccinated or undervaccinated– some doctors, including a prominent vaccine hero, put forth enormous effort to discourage boosters. As an alphabet soup of immune-evading variants invalidated their 2021 declarations that the initial two vaccine doses would end the pandemic, these doctors responded not by humbly acknowledging they initially overhyped vaccines and underestimated the virus, but rather by trashing subsequent vaccine doses, even for older, vulnerable people.
This is where they spent their time and energy. This is how they chose to use their privileged voice as trusted doctors. This was the hill they were willing to die on.
There was nothing unique about the campaign against boosters, but it was very revealing. It was just a small part of a pathetic, pandemic-long pattern where doctors expressed grave concern about the mildest harms of measures to limit COVID, even mere abnormal lab values, while being totally indifferent to literally anything the virus could do, including the deaths of children and young adults.
Like the inexorable passage of time, some doctors treated the virus as a totally unmodifiable force – Repeat infections are inevitable. More the longer you live. Nothing can be done about it. Getting COVID is inevitable. It is just another cold or flu like illness. By claiming- falsely– that COVID was just another cold or flu and that “nothing” that could be done about it anyways, they gave themselves permission to breezily brush away its harms. Indeed, the same doctor who fretted mightily about “grade three fevers” in vaccinated children and “AEs at time of injection” also said we should accept children dying of COVID “as a matter of course” and there are zero “smart people who still give a shit about COVID.”
Put another way, some doctors cared much more about sore arms than cold bodies.
Observational Studies of the COVID Booster
    • Barda (2021): Vaccine effectiveness evaluated at least 7 days after receipt of the third dose, compared with receiving only two doses at least 5 months ago, was estimated to be 93% (231 events for two doses vs 29 events for three doses; 95% CI 88–97) for admission to hospital, 92% (157 vs 17 events; 82–97) for severe disease, and 81% (44 vs seven events; 59–97) for COVID-19-related death.
    • Arbel (2021): Participants who received a booster at least 5 months after a second dose of BNT162b2 had 90% lower mortality due to Covid-19 than participants who did not receive a booster.
    • Bar-on (2021): Across the age groups studied, rates of confirmed Covid-19 and severe illness were substantially lower among participants who received a booster dose of the BNT162b2 vaccine than among those who did not.
    • Muhsen (2022): The results of this cohort study suggest that receipt of a fourth BNT162b2 dose conferred high protection against COVID-19 hospitalizations and deaths among long-term care facilities residents during a substantial Omicron variant surge, but protection was modest against infection.
    • Thompson (2022): During both Delta- and Omicron-predominant periods, receipt of a third vaccine dose was highly effective at preventing COVID-19–associated emergency department and urgent care encounters (94% and 82%, respectively) and preventing COVID-19–associated hospitalizations (94% and 90%, respectively).
    • Andrews (2022): Against hospitalization or death, absolute effectiveness of a BNT162b2 booster ranged from around 97% to 99% in all age groups irrespective of the primary course, with no evidence of waning up to 10 weeks.
    • Menni (2022): Vaccine effectiveness for booster doses in 0–3 months after BNT162b2 primary vaccination was higher than 92·5%, and effectiveness for heterologous boosters after ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 was at least 88·8%.
    • Abu-Raddad (2022): Booster effectiveness against Covid-19–related hospitalization and death due to omicron infection, as compared with the primary series, was 76.5% (95% CI, 55.9 to 87.5). BNT162b2 booster effectiveness against symptomatic infection with the delta (or B.1.617.2) variant, as compared with the primary series, was 86.1%
    • Moreira (2022): A third dose of the BNT162b2 vaccine administered a median of 10.8 months after the second dose provided 95.3% efficacy against Covid-19 as compared with two doses of the BNT162b2 vaccine during a median follow-up of 2.5 months.
    • Klein (2022): Two doses protect against COVID-19–associated emergency department and urgent care encounters among children and adolescents. However, vaccine effectiveness (VE) was lower during Omicron predominance and decreased with time since vaccination; a booster dose restored VE to 81% among adolescents aged 16–17 years. Overall, 2-dose VE against COVID-19–associated hospitalization was 73%–94%.
    • Regev-Yochay (2022): Vaccine efficacy was estimated to be higher for the prevention of symptomatic disease (43% for BNT162b2 and 31% for mRNA-1273)…Our data provide evidence that a fourth dose of mRNA vaccine is immunogenic, safe, and somewhat efficacious (primarily against symptomatic disease).
    • Mallah (2022): A booster dose of COVID-19 vaccine increases the protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection and COVID-19 severity in the general population and in comorbid patients.
    • Magen (2022): Relative vaccine effectiveness in days 7 to 30 after the fourth dose was estimated to be 45% (95% confidence interval [CI], 44 to 47) against polymerase-chain-reaction–confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection, 55% (95% CI, 53 to 58) against symptomatic Covid-19, 68% (95% CI, 59 to 74) against Covid-19–related hospitalization, 62% (95% CI, 50 to 74) against severe Covid-19, and 74% (95% CI, 50 to 90) against Covid-19–related death.
    • Adams (2022): During the first six months of 2022 in the US, booster doses of a covid-19 vaccine provided additional benefit beyond a primary vaccine series alone for preventing hospital admissions with omicron related covid-19.
    • Tenforde (2022): Bivalent booster doses provided additional protection against COVID-19–associated emergency department/urgent care encounters and hospitalizations in persons who previously received 2, 3, or 4 monovalent vaccine doses. Because of waning of monovalent vaccine-conferred immunity, relative effectiveness of bivalent vaccines was higher with increased time since the previous monovalent dose.
    • Tai (2022): This study found that in a young, healthy, highly vaccinated cohort frequently monitored for SARS-CoV-2, booster vaccination was associated with a significant reduction in incident infections during the Omicron wave.
    • Ng (2022): Estimated mRNA booster effectiveness against severe COVID-19 was 87.4% with no evidence of waning up to 6 months after boosting, while the estimated 3-dose inactivated SARS-CoV-2 booster effectiveness against severe COVID-19 was 69.6%. Booster mRNA vaccine protection against severe COVID-19 was estimated to be durable over 6 months.
    • Ridgway (2022): In a large US population, mRNA boosters were associated with decreased odds of hospitalization compared with the mRNA vaccine primary series alone, with the magnitude of the association attenuated with more time since the booster dose.
    • Lauring (2022): mRNA vaccines were found to be highly effective in preventing covid-19 associated hospital admissions related to the alpha, delta, and omicron variants, but three vaccine doses were required to achieve protection against omicron similar to the protection that two doses provided against the delta and alpha variants.
    • McConeghy (2022): In this cohort study of 10 949 residents of 202 community nursing homes and 4321 residents of 128 Veterans Health Administration community living centers, booster vaccination was associated with significant reductions in SARS-CoV-2 infections, hospitalizations, and the combined end point of hospitalizations or deaths.
    • Accorsi (2022): These findings suggest that vaccination with 3 doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine, compared with being unvaccinated and with receipt of 2 doses, was associated with protection against both the Omicron and Delta variants, although higher odds ratios for the association with Omicron infection suggest less protection for Omicron than for Delta.
    • Spitzer (2022): Among health care workers previously vaccinated with a 2-dose series of BNT162b2, administration of a booster dose compared with not receiving one was significantly associated with a lower rate of SARS-CoV-2 infection in short-term follow-up.
    • Kelly (2022): In a US cohort of patients receiving care at Veterans Health Administration facilities during a period of Delta and Omicron variant predominance, there was a low incidence of hospitalization with COVID-19 pneumonia or death following vaccination and booster with any of BNT162b2, mRNA-1273, or Ad26.COV2.S vaccines.
    • Surie (2022): Among immunocompetent adults aged ≥65 years hospitalized in the multistate IVY Network, a bivalent booster dose provided 73% additional protection against COVID-19 hospitalization compared with past monovalent mRNA vaccination only.
    • Fleming-Dutra (2022): Among children and adolescents, estimated vaccine effectiveness for 2 doses of BNT162b2 against symptomatic infection decreased rapidly, and among adolescents increased after a booster dose.
    • Johnson (2022): IRRs and VE were higher among persons who were fully vaccinated and had received a booster dose than among fully vaccinated persons who had not received a booster dose for cases and deaths during the period of Delta predominance and for cases during the period of Omicron emergence in December. The added benefits of booster doses were especially prominent among persons aged 50–64 and ≥65 years.
    • Grewal (2022): The findings suggest that compared with a third dose of mRNA covid-19 vaccine, a fourth dose improved protection against infection, symptomatic infection, and severe outcomes among long term care residents during an omicron dominant period. A fourth vaccine dose was associated with strong protection against severe outcomes in vaccinated residents compared with unvaccinated residents, although the duration of protection remains unknown.
    • Danza (2022): During both Delta and Omicron predominance, incidence and hospitalization rates were highest among unvaccinated persons and lowest among vaccinated persons with a booster.
    • McConeghy (2022): In a large cohort of nursing home residents, receipt of a second mRNA COVID-19 booster dose during circulation of SARS-CoV-2 Omicron subvariants was 74% effective at 60 days against severe COVID-19–related outcomes (including hospitalization or death) and 90% against death alone compared with receipt of a single booster dose.
    • Roberts (2022): COVID-19 vaccines were highly protective against infection and severe COVID-19 resulting in hospitalization, intensive care unit admission, or death. Administration of a booster dose significantly increased vaccine effectiveness against both outcomes.
    • Gazit (2022): A fourth dose of the BNT162b2 vaccine appears to have provided additional protection against both SARS-CoV-2 infection and severe covid-19 disease relative to three vaccine doses. However, relative effectiveness of the fourth dose against infection appears to wane sooner than that of the third dose.
    • Wei (2023): Overall vaccine effectiveness against death at 4 to 6 months after the third dose was greater than 90% for CoronaVac, BNT162b2, and the mixed vaccine schedule. While vaccines were generally estimated to be effective against severe outcomes caused by SARS-CoV-2 Omicron infection, this analysis found that protection in older patients was more likely to wane 6 months after the second dose. Hence, a booster dose is recommended for older patients to restore immunity.
    • Lundberg-Morris (2023): Vaccine effectiveness against post-covid-19 condition for one dose, two doses, and three or more doses was 21%, 59%, and 73%, respectively.
    • Finci (2023): Among Albanian healthcare workers, most of whom had been previously infected, COVID-19 booster dose offered improved VE during a period of Omicron BA.1 and BA.2 circulation.
    • Wong (2023): Among nursing home residents who were up to date with COVID-19 vaccination (most had received a bivalent vaccine), vaccine effectiveness against SARS-CoV-2 infection was 31.2%.
    • Klein (2023): BNT162b2 protected children and adolescents against mild to moderate and severe COVID-19. VE was lower during Omicron predominance including BA.4/BA.5, waned after dose 2 but increased after a monovalent booster.
    • Link-Gelles (2023): A bivalent mRNA booster dose provided additional protection against symptomatic XBB/XBB.1.5 infection for at least the first 3 months after vaccination in persons who had previously received 2–4 monovalent vaccine doses.
    • Andersson (2023): Heterologous booster schedules are associated with increased protection against severe, omicron related covid-19 outcomes compared with primary course schedules and homologous booster schedules.
    • Andersson (2023): Vaccination with bivalent BA.4-5 or BA.1 mRNA booster vaccines as a fourth dose was associated with reduced rates of covid-19 related hospital admission and death among adults aged ≥50 years.
    • Stecher (2023): Our results indicate an increased protective effect of a fourth dose against severe outcomes compared with a third dose, with decreasing effect with time since the last dose.
    • Link-Gelles (2023): In this case-control study of COVID-19 vaccines and illness, VE associated with protection against medically attended COVID-19 illness was lower with increasing time since last dose; estimated VE was higher after receipt of 1 or 2 booster doses compared with a primary series alone.
    • Lin (2023): Although the two bivalent vaccines were designed to target the BA.4–BA.5 subvariants, they were also associated with a lower risk of infection or severe infection with the BQ.1–BQ.1.1 and XBB–XBB.1.5 subvariants. The effectiveness was higher against hospitalization and death than against infection and waned gradually from its peak over time.
    • Lin (2023): Vaccine effectiveness against severe infection resulting in hospitalization or death was 24.9% (95% CI, 1.4 to 42.8) for one monovalent booster dose and 61.8% (95% CI, 48.2 to 71.8) for one bivalent booster dose.
    • Jang (2023): The 4-dose booster, irrespective of history of SARS-CoV-2 infection, was associated with higher protection against critical BA.5 infection, as shown in previous studies.
    • Arbel (2023): Participants who received a bivalent mRNA booster vaccine dose had lower rates of hospitalisation due to COVID-19 than participants who did not receive a bivalent booster vaccination, for up to 120 days after vaccination. These findings highlight the importance of bivalent mRNA booster vaccination in populations at high risk of severe COVID-19
    • Lewis (2023): Vaccine booster doses increased protection against COVID-19 hospitalization compared with a primary series.
    • Tartof (2023): A BNT162b2 BA.4/5 bivalent booster restored protection against a range of COVID-19 outcomes, including against XBB-related sublineages, with the most substantial protection observed against hospital admission and critical illness.
    • Liu (2023): The effectiveness of boosters against mortality wanes with time but a booster still provides substantial residual protection six months after receipt. Increasing population hybrid immunity is likely to reduce observed vaccine effectiveness as the pandemic progresses but COVID-19 boosters continue to provide significant benefits in mortality reduction, particularly in high-risk populations such as those aged 65+ years and those resident in aged care facilities.
    • Hanberg (2023): A fourth dose of COVID-19 mRNA vaccine reduced the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection and severe COVID-19 among patients with systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases using DMARDs during the Omicron era.
    • Piekos (2023): COVID-19 vaccination protects against adverse maternal–fetal outcomes, with booster doses conferring additional protection.
    • Amir (2023): In adolescents aged 12–15 years, the booster dose decreased confirmed infection rates by 3.3 times (2.8–4.0) compared with in the internal control group.
    • Chemaitelly (2023): Boosters substantially reduced infection and severe COVID-19, particularly among individuals who were clinically vulnerable, affirming the public health value of booster vaccination.
    • Tartof (2023): The BNT162b2 XBB1.5-adapted vaccine provided significant additional protection against a range of COVID-19 outcomes during a period when XBB sub-lineages were predominant but JN.1 was also co-circulating and rapidly increasing in prevalence. Older versions of COVID-19 vaccines offered little, if any, additional protection compared to the unvaccinated, including against COVID-19 hospital admission, regardless of the number or type of prior doses received.
    • Jara (2023): The overall adjusted effectiveness of a second mRNA booster shot is 88.2% (95%CI, 86.2–89.9) against ICU admissions and 90.5% (95%CI 89.4–91.4) against death.
    • Payne (2024): During September 2022–March 2023, receipt of bivalent mRNA COVID-19 vaccine was 47% effective in preventing thromboembolic events among immunocompetent persons aged ≥65 years and 51% effective among adults aged ≥18 years with end stage renal disease (ESRD) receiving dialysis, compared with receipt of the original monovalent vaccines alone.
    • The HDR UK COALESCE Consortium (2024): Undervaccination was associated with an elevated risk of severe COVID-19 outcomes.
    • Decuir (2024): Receipt of an updated COVID-19 vaccine dose provided increased protection against COVID-19–associated emergency department and urgent care encounters and hospitalization compared with no receipt of an updated vaccine dose among immunocompetent U.S. adults during a period of multiple cocirculating SARS-CoV-2 Omicron lineages.
    • Lam (2024): Completely vaccinated and patients with booster dose of vaccines did not incur significant higher risk of health consequences from 271 and 91 days of infection onwards, respectively, whilst un-vaccinated and incompletely vaccinated patients continued to incur a greater risk of clinical sequelae for up to a year following SARS-CoV-2 infection.
    • Link-Gelles (2024): Receipt of updated COVID-19 vaccine provided approximately 54% increased protection against symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection compared with no receipt of updated vaccine. Vaccination provides protection against JN.1 and other circulating lineages.
Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
    • Zhu (2022):The pooled results demonstrated a 71% (OR = 0.29, 95% CI = 0.17-0.48) reduction in SARS-CoV-2 infection rates among subjects who received a booster shot compared with those who did not receive a booster shot of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccine. In addition, this analysis emphasized that during the period when the Delta variant was predominant, subjects who received the booster shot showed an 82% (OR = 0.18, 95% CI = 0.13-0.25) reduction in infection rates. Moreover, during the period of dominance of the Omicron variant, subjects who received the booster vaccination displayed a 47% (OR = 0.53, 95% CI = 0.35-0.81) reduction in infection rates.
    • Au (2022): For people with delta or omicron related infection, a two dose regimen of an adenovirus vector vaccine with one dose of mRNA booster was 77% (42% to 91%) effective against asymptomatic or symptomatic covid-19 infections, and a three dose regimen of a mRNA vaccine was 93% (76% to 98%) effective against covid-19 related hospital admission.
    • Menegale (2023): Booster doses restored VE to levels comparable to those acquired soon after the administration of the primary cycle. However, 9 months after booster administration, VE against Omicron was lower than 30% against laboratory-confirmed infection and symptomatic disease.
    • Xu (2023): The risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection, the risk of admission to the ICU, and the risk of death were all higher in the non-booster group than those in the booster group.
    • Yang (2023): The efficacy of SARS-CoV-2 vaccines is higher for preventing severe infection and death than for preventing milder infection. Vaccine efficacy wanes over time but can be enhanced by a booster.
    • Xu (2023): Inactivated vaccine protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection was moderate, decreased significantly after 6 months following primary vaccination, and was restored by booster vaccination. VE against severe COVID-19 was greatest after boosting and did not decrease over time, sustained for over 6 months after the primary series, and more evidence is needed to assess the duration of booster VE. VE varied by variants, most notably against Omicron. It is necessary to ensure booster vaccination of everyone eligible for SARS-CoV-2 vaccines and continue monitoring virus evolution and VE.
    • European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (2023): Under the Omicron variant, effectiveness of EU-licensed COVID-19 vaccines in preventing any SARS-CoV-2 infection or mild disease is low and only short-lasting after primary immunization, but can be improved by booster vaccination. Vaccine effectiveness (VE) against severe COVID-19 remains high and is long-lasting, especially after receiving the booster vaccination.
    • Mohammed (2023): VE against severe Omicron infection following the primary course was 63.6% (95%CI: 57.5–69.7%) at three months, decreased to 49% (95%CI: 35.7–63.4%) within six months, and increased to 86% after the first or second booster dose.
    • Rahman (2023): The boosters provided substantial protection against severe COVID-19 outcomes for at least 6 months, although the duration of protection remains uncertain, suggesting the need for a booster dose within 6 months of the third-dose or fourth-dose vaccination.

Doctors on Measles: “NEVER Listen to the Anti-Vax Cult When They Say This ‘Natural’ Disease is Harmless”. Doctors on COVID: 😂
Measles and COVID are different, of course, but they are not categorically different. With both viruses, unvaccinated children suffer the most. Yet, doctors who rightly said “measles can be a devastating childhood illness” also said it was “breathless fear-mongering” to acknowledge that COVID can also be a devastating childhood illness.
Jonathan Howardon September 22, 2023
Link

Measles: The New Red Scare
In 2019, an article titled “Measles: The New Red Scare” revealed several key anti-vaccine techniques. It ridiculed parents who wanted to protect their children against measles, saying they fell into an “emotional fear-based primal mental algorithm”. It asked its readers to “to step back from the hysteria”, and minimized measles deaths in children by arguing that hardly any died prior to the vaccine. It said:
In fact, if we look at all the causes of death from the United States Vital Statistics in 1962, we see that measles accounted for 0.02% of deaths that year…In 1962, measles was sixth from the bottom for causes of death. You can look through the list of causes of death and find almost everything from “Birth Injuries” at 28,199 to “Ulcers” at 12,228 to “Asthma” at 4,896 were far higher than the 408 deaths attributed to “Measles” that year.
These are standard an anti-vaccine sleight of hand tricks. Through mockery and irrelevant comparisons, anti-vaxxers have one revolting goal: to make you yawn at dead children.
Of course, it’s appropriate for parents to fear measles, and the only numbers that matters are these:
Before the measles vaccination program started in 1963, an estimated 3 to 4 million people got measles each year in the United States, of which 500,000 were reported. Among reported cases, 400 to 500 died, 48,000 were hospitalized, and 1,000 developed encephalitis.
That is a huge number of dead and suffering children, not hardly any. Happily, the measles vaccine wiped that all way. Though the future may be grim, at least for now, American children aren’t dying of measles. That’s a good thing. As vaccine-advocate Noah Louis-Ferdinand said:
One of the great achievements of US public health is that almost all kids reach adultment. Thats like a whole generation of heartbreak made very rare. So when we have the opportuntiy to reduce it *even further* with a vaccine, you take it.
You don’t say, “eh that’s not that many.”
Doctors and measles
When it comes to measles, every reasonable doctor agrees with Mr. Louis-Ferdinand. Dr. Vinay Prasad recently wrote, “Measles can be a devastating childhood illness”, and he is absolutely right. Indeed, before the pandemic, normal doctors were rightly bothered when children suffered needlessly from measles, or any other vaccine-preventable illness for that matter. Measles outbreaks got international attention, because they were easily preventable, and they revealed a broader truth about the potential of misinformation to cause real suffering.
In 2019, for example, anti-vaccine activists fueled a measles outbreak in Samoa causing 83 deaths, mostly in young children. In December that year, Dr. Zubin Damania (ZDoggMD) recorded a podcast titled Deadly Samoan Measles Outbreak, What Can We Learn? In it, he rightfully pushed back again the idea that we should accept children dying from measles simply because hardly any died. He said:
The tragedy of measles deaths in Samoa is a stark warning: NEVER listen to the anti-vax cult when they say this “natural” disease is harmless.
He pitched the episode on Twitter by saying:
Measles outbreak in Samoa, 60 dead (mostly children under 4), and the antivaxxers will say measles is a safe and natural childhood rite of passage.
Like Dr. Prasad, Dr. Damania was absolutely correct about all this. Measles is not harmless just because it is natural and the preventable deaths of children should not be brushed off just because hardly any died. No reasonable doctor argued with Drs. Prasad or Damania or accused them of “breathless fear mongering” for telling the truth about measles. It used to be normal for doctors to be upset when several hundred unvaccinated kids contracted measles, even though none died, thankfully. In fact, prior to the pandemic, normal doctors agreed that even a single child dying of a vaccine-preventable disease was a big deal. Only quacks shamed parents for “fearing” measles or argued that we should let it kill and maim children today, because more died of asthma in 1962.
Doctors and COVID
Things are very different with SARS-CoV-2.
In April 2021, two months after recording The End of the Pandemic with Dr. Monica Gandhi, Dr. Damania recorded Focused Protected for COVID with Dr. Jay Bhattacharya. Dr. Bhattacharya is an anti-vaccine misinformation doctor who never treated COVID patients, but claimed herd immunity would arrive in 3-6 months if only 250 million unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans contracted COVID simultaneously in October 2020. In this podcast, Dr. Damania heaped praise on Dr. Bhattacharya for his plan of mass infection of unvaccinated youth saying, “You’re fearless, you’re compassionate, you’re rational.” He also said:
Even though this thing (COVID) has killed less than you know, or, or about as many as flu would kill in a normal year in kids, I say hardly any.
By this point in the pandemic, the American Academy of Pediatrics reported 297 pediatric deaths – hardly any according to Dr. Damania. Millions more children had yet to be infected, and around 2,000 children have now died of COVID. As with measles, COVID can injure children without killing them. Nearly 200,000 children have been hospitalized with COVID, and some were very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU. Rarely, children have strokes, or required amputations or lung transplants. Nearly 10,000 children suffered from MIS-C, and most of these children go to the ICU. 79 children died from MIS-C. Other children are gravely impacted by Long COVID. All of this would have been much worse had we allowed 73 million unvaccinated children to simultaneously contract COVID as many doctors proposed.
Measles once exacted a nearly identical toll on children, and COVID’s pediatric impact greatly exceeded that of many other diseases for which we vaccinate children. Of course, it doesn’t matter exactly where COVID ranks on the list of deadliest viruses. Multiple pathogens can hurt children, and it’s entirely appropriate to protect children against all diseases that pose a risk to them. Before the pandemic, it wasn’t controversial to use vaccines to save the lives of hardly any children.
COVID’s pediatric death toll, compared to other vaccine-preventable diseases
How things have changed
And let’s review how much things have changed. During the pandemic, many doctors underwent a dramatic transformation, where justified anger about suffering children was replaced by a casual indifference and mockery, only because a different virus was injuring and killing children. In 2019, Dr. Damania was rightly enraged by children dying of measles, even though hardly any died, just a few dozen. In 2021, however, he said hundreds of dead children was hardly any, only because COVID was the cause.
Dr. Prasad, who said “Measles can be a devastating childhood illness”, routinely minimizes COVID using the same mockery and rhetorical chicanery as the author of “Measles: The New Red Scare“. He’s argued that unvaccinated children should contract COVID because more die of suicide, for example, and routinely belittles those who disagree, accusing them of “breathless fear mongering”. He implied that children killed by COVID aren’t “real lives” and that we should accept their deaths “as a matter of course“. He’s mocked Andrew Wakefield, while mocking those who exposed anti-vaccine data fraudster, Dr. Joseph Ladapo.
Other doctors wrote articles titled The Triumph of Natural Immunity and Tweeted “natural immunity wins again“. They said young people should not fear literal death from COVID, because only 4,560 young people died in the pandemic’s first 5 months – hardly any. These same doctors said rare vaccine side-effects, which are milder than, say, literal death, demanded “respect“. They advocated the mass infection of unvaccinated youth, and some treated the consequences as a joke.
Before the pandemic, a doctor who called vaccine-advocates “idiots” or used a laughing emoji to discuss children sickened by measles would have rightfully been a pariah in the medical community. Today, they get promotions.
Today, a virus that sickens and kills children is 😂
Most children with COVID do well. Most children with measles do well, as anti-vaxxers point out frequently. The COVID vaccine is not perfect. The measles vaccine is not perfect, as anti-vaxxers point out frequently. Measles and COVID are different, of course, but they are not categorically different. With both viruses, unvaccinated children suffer the most. The COVID vaccine is not as effective as the measles vaccine, sadly, but this is not a reason to not use it. These vaccines are not in competition with each other, and the COVID vaccine has already spared a meaningful number of children from rare, but grave harms. A recent study of children under 5-years, those with the highest risk by far, found:
That children who received two or three doses of the updated COVID-19 vaccine were 70% less likely to wind up in the ER or urgent care due to COVID and 60% less likely to see their doctor compared to unvaccinated kids.
Dozens of other studies show similar results. There’s no clear difference I can see between a doctor who spreads misinformation about measles and one who spreads misinformation about COVID.
Unfortunately, many doctors made it a core mission to discourage pediatric vaccination – for COVID, not measles. We all agree, only a quack would encourage parents to leave their children vulnerable to a dangerous disease like measles. However, these doctors acted as if there were a core, fundamental difference between a child killed by measles and one killed by COVID. One would be a grave tragedy, while the other “breathless fear-mongering”.
In reality, the only difference between a child killed by measles and one killed by COVID, is that children killed measles don’t exist in the US. Blessedly, measles has not killed an American child in over 30 years. That’s not true for COVID. Tragically, there are children who would still be alive had they been vaccinated against COVID. Am I “off my rocker” because I think that’s sad and want to prevent similar tragedies in the future? Or is it strange that doctors feign concern about viruses that killed zero children for the express purpose of leaving them vulnerable to a virus that killed 2,000 children?
Viruses that killed 0 children are “truly dangerous” compared to the one that killed 2,000 children.
Why I care
I write about this topic so often, because I fondly remember the days – not long ago! – when all reasonable doctors told parents, “NEVER listen to the anti-vax cult when they say this ‘natural’ disease is harmless”. I remember when it was normal for doctors to be upset by any unvaccinated child suffering from any vaccine-preventable disease. I haven’t changed a bit. I still feel this way, even though this belief now makes me the object of scorn and contempt from some of my fellow doctors. On a personal level, it’s dizzying to be called a “book-selling schmuck” and similar juvenile japes simply because I still believe what all reasonable doctors once believed: we should use vaccines to save children from grave harms, even if it’s hardly any children.
I write about doctors who now plagiarize anti-vaccine talking points to infect children with SARS-CoV-2, not just because I disagree with them, but because I admired many of them a great deal. I didn’t expect better from quacks. However, I expected better from them. I suspect their pre-pandemic selves would agree. During his 2021 podcast, the 2019 version of Dr. Damania made a momentary return and asked about his own “hardly any” comment:
I mean, again, it’s not, that’s not that’s not compassionate to the people who’ve lost children. Right?
Right.
Doctors would have cared, had she died of measles

Oxford-AstraZeneca Vaccine Safety
Reports of blood clots after receiving the AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine are very likely just background events.
Steven Novella on March 17, 2021
Link

The pandemic has now entered a phase where it is largely a battle between the virus and the various vaccines that effectively produce immunity to the virus. We have an ambitious program, with many vaccines and millions of people being vaccinated every day. As a consequence in those countries with high vaccine uptake, the infection rate is starting to decrease, although worry of new strains emerging remains.
As millions get the jab, safety is also being monitored closely. These are all new vaccines, and although they appear highly safe when tested in tens of thousands of people, less common risks can emerge when you give any vaccine to tens of millions of people. So far, the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines being used in the US have shown no concerning signs of significant side effects. The same is mostly true for the AstraZeneca vaccine being widely used in the European Union, except for recent case reports of blood clots occurring in some people who received the vaccine. This has led to a controversy over whether the vaccine is safe and whether or not to suspend its use.
Denmark has already suspended use of the AstraZeneca vaccine, followed quickly by Norway, Iceland, Germany, France, Italy, Cyprus, Spain, Latvia and Sweden. The UK continues to use the vaccine without pause. What does the current science have to say about this controversy?
AstraZeneca reports that: “across the EU and the United Kingdom there had been 15 events of deep-vein thrombosis (DVT) – a blood clot in a vein – and 22 events of pulmonary embolism.”
Of course, the big question is – is this causation or mere correlation? With millions of people getting vaccinated, all of the usual life events are going to continue to occur, and some people will get sick, have events, and even die soon after getting the vaccine just by chance alone, without any causal link to the vaccine. This is the background noise that experts monitoring the safety of the vaccines, or any medical intervention, have to deal with.
The way to tell if there is a causal link to the vaccine is to compare the observed rate of events with the expected background rate, and make a statistical comparison. A probability of a link can then be calculated. The World Health Organization (WHO) has done this, and concluded that there is no evidence of a link between these cases and the vaccine. The UK’s Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency has come to the same conclusion.
To give an idea of why, DVTs alone occur in about 80 people per 100,000 per year. If, say, we consider the background rate in 10 million people that’s 8,000 per year, or 307 in any two week period. The numbers being reported for various kinds of blood clots are still at these background rates, or even lower – especially given that those getting the vaccines first are in high risk groups who have a higher background rate of blood clots than the general population. In other words, there is no signal peaking up above the noise.
So far we are only talking about risk (which is low to none) but we can also take another approach to this – risk vs benefit. We could ask, for example, even in the worst case scenario that every single reported blood clot after receiving the AstraZeneca vaccine were caused by the vaccine, would that risk be greater than the benefits of getting the vaccine (or the risks of not getting the vaccine)? Interestingly, COVID itself can rarely cause blood clots, so we can directly compare the total risk of getting blood clots from COVID and the vaccine in vaccinated vs unvaccinated people. There, too, the risk of the vaccine is less than the risk of COVID – less than the risk of not getting vaccinated.
And keep in mind – that is the worst case scenario, which is almost certainly not true. It would mean that none of the reported blood clots were background events, which is statistically highly unlikely.
Unfortunately, people are risk averse, and we are more afraid of directly causing harm than allowing harm to occur by not taking action, even if the end result is just as bad. This is why public messaging on this question has to be clear. Scientists, however, communicate in a technical style that is more precise, but can be confusing to the public, even making it sound like there is a risk when there isn’t.
The countries who have suspended use of the vaccine have been highly criticized for their decision, given that it is not supported by the science. These background events are going to crop up when millions of people are being given a medical intervention and being closely monitored. Suspending the vaccine seems like an overreaction, given the data, with likely real-world consequences. These decisions have likely caused more deaths than they hoped to prevent. That is the reality of a deadly pandemic – public health decisions can be critical, and mistakes in judgement have a death toll attached to them.
The experts are all in agreement here – the reported events are likely background events not related to the vaccine, and in any case the benefits of getting vaccinated still vastly outweigh any potential risks. The countries who have suspended the vaccine should reverse course and resume vaccinating their people.

Did the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine cause a fatal case of ITP?
Last week, a post by Heidi Neckelmann, the wife of Miami obstetrician Dr. Gregory Michael describing his death from idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) 16 days after being vaccinated with the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine went viral. Unsurprisingly, in her grief she blamed the vaccine for her husband’s death from a rare autoimmune condition that destroys platelets and causes bleeding. Unfortunately, Dr. Michael’s tragic death underlines the difficulty distinguishing coincidence from causation when evaluating adverse events after vaccination.
David Gorski on January 11, 2021
Link

Three weeks ago, I wrote about how the roll out of COVID-19 vaccines under the FDA’s emergency use authorization (EUA) for the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna RNA-based vaccines would very likely result in a tsunami of confusion of correlation with causation to blame the vaccines on all manner of seeming “adverse events,” whether the adverse events were caused by the vaccine or not. I used the specific examples of syncope and Bell’s palsy, the former of which is a common reaction to needlesticks of many kinds (including all vaccinations) and the latter of which was almost certainly not related to vaccination against COVID-19, also explaining how the law of large numbers will mean that there will certainly be a lot of health issues manifesting themselves sometime soon after vaccination just by coincidence alone, up to and including death. (The same principle applies to claims that vaccines cause autism.) Elsewhere, I predicted:
The point is that there will be all sorts of scary stories about COVID-19 vaccines in the coming weeks and months, and a lot of people will have reactions similar to mine. Again, most symptoms other than the sort that I experienced will turn out not to be due to the vaccine. I also have another prediction. There will be people who get COVID-19 right after having the vaccine, and antivaxxers will claim that the vaccine caused it, just as they sometimes claim that the flu vaccine causes the flu. There will also be people who happen to die within a month of getting the vaccine, particularly when the vaccine rolls out to elderly general population, due to the simple law of large numbers and the fact that on any given month far more elderly people die than young people. Look for antivaxxers to spin these coincidences as “definite proof” that the COVID-19 vaccine kills, just the way they’ve done for vaccines and sudden infant death syndrome (which is not caused by vaccines) and for the HPV vaccine and deaths of teenaged girls.
Dr. Vincent Iannelli agrees.
The first such story has started circulating in the antivaccine nooks and crannies of social media, but it’s also being flogged by the usual British tabloids.
Dr. Gregory Michael, the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine, and ITP: What happened?
Here’s the first story of a death after vaccination against COVID-19 that sounds plausible on the surface that allows me to revisit this issue because, unlike the cases of people who are, for example, hit by a car within two weeks of vaccination, we can’t just dismiss it a priori:
A Florida doctor has died several weeks after receiving a COVID-19 vaccine, although it’s not yet clear whether his death Monday was related to the shot he received on Dec. 18.
Dr. Gregory Michael, 56, an OB-GYN at Mount Sinai Medical Center in Miami Beach, died after suffering a hemorrhagic stroke apparently resulting from a lack of platelets.
Miami medical examiners are investigating his death, the Florida Department of Health said in a statement.
“The CDC and FDA are responsible for reviewing COVID-19 vaccine safety data and presenting that information for federal recommendations on vaccine administration,” communications director Jason Mahon said in an email. “The state will continue to provide all available information to the CDC as they lead this investigation.”
The USA TODAY story cited above was actually fairly cautious in its telling of the story of Dr. Michael’s tragic death due to idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP), also known as immune thrombocytopenic purpura. ITP is a condition in which there is an immune reaction against platelets, which are responsible for clotting, leading to a decrease in their number to the point where bleeding can occur. Most often that bleeding takes the form of “petechiae”, or tiny bruise-like markings on the skin, but in rare cases ITP can lead to dangerously low numbers of platelets, levels at which the risk of spontaneous bleeding in the brain and other organs becomes very high. It’s called “idiopathic” because its causes are unknown or not well understood. (As I like to say, “idiopathic” basically means “we don’t know the cause.”)
The story further noted that ITP is rare and that in extremely rare cases, the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine has been linked to thrombocytopenia in children, according to a 2003 study. The story also noted that ITP “can also be caused by cancer, anemia, heavy drinking, viruses, some genetic conditions, toxic chemicals and medications such as diuretics and the rarely used antibiotic chloramphenicol”. (More on the general risk of ITP after vaccination later.)
Unfortunately, pouring gasoline on the flame was, in her understandable grief, Dr. Michael’s wife Heidi Neckelmann, who wrote a Facebook post that rapidly went viral, particularly in antivaccine circles:
The love of my life, my husband Gregory Michael MD an Obstetrician that had his office in Mount Sinai Medical Center in…
Posted by Heidi Neckelmann on Tuesday, January 5, 2021
It’s impossible not to feel enormous sympathy and empathy Ms. Neckelmann. I can only try to imagine what she is going through now, particularly given that her husband was within a couple of years of my age. Stories like this always make me wonder how I’d react to the unexpected and rather rapid death of my wife. Be that as it may, Ms. Neckelman’s post led to sensationalistic headlines, like this one from (who else?) The Daily Mail:
And:
Heidi Neckelmann says obstetrician Gregory Michael, 56 – her ‘best friend’ and partner of 28 years – was active, healthy and had no pre-existing conditions before getting the jab on December 18.
However he died from a stroke Sunday morning after suddenly developing a rare autoimmune illness that causes the body to destroy its own platelets, the tiny fragments that help blood to clot.
Distraught Heidi, 58, thinks the groundbreaking Pfizer-BioNtech vaccine may have somehow been the trigger.
‘In my mind his death was 100 percent linked to the vaccine. There is no other explanation,’ she told DailyMail.com, fighting back tears.
‘He was in very good health. He didn’t smoke, he drank alcohol once in a while but only socially. He worked out, we had kayaks, he was a deep sea fisherman.
‘They tested him for everything you can imagine afterwards, even cancer, and there was absolutely nothing else wrong with him.’
Pfizer told DailyMail.com Wednesday that it was aware of Dr. Michael’s ‘highly unusual’ death and was investigating further.
However a spokesman cautioned: ‘We don’t believe at this time that there is any direct connection to the vaccine.’
The Daily Mail story, as sensationalistic as it is, does provide us with more information that Ms. Neckelmann’s Facebook post:
Dad-of-one Gregory suffered no immediate reaction to the injection but three days later he was taking a shower and noticed petechiae – spots of red that indicate bleeding beneath the skin – on his feet and hands.
When he checked himself into Mount Sinai Medical Center in Miami Beach, the hospital where he works and had the groundbreaking vaccine, medics discovered he was suffering from an acute lack of platelets.
‘All the blood results came back normal except for the platelets which came back as zero,’ Heidi said.
‘At first they thought it must be a mistake. So they did the test again and this time did a manual count which is supposed to be more accurate. This time it showed just one platelet.
‘He felt 100 percent, he was normal, energetic, happy. But they said you cannot go home, this is incredibly dangerous, you could suffer a brain bleed and die.’
Ultimately, Dr. Michael was diagnosed with ITP, and here’s what ultimately happened:
After two weeks of infusions and experimental treatments that failed to raise Gregory’s platelet count, doctors decided they had no choice.
However he died from a hemorrhagic stroke – when blood from an artery bleeds into the brain – before he could undergo the surgery.
‘They gave him medicine. They gave him an incredible amount of platelet infusions, I’m told all the platelets in Miami Dade County,’ Heidi said.
‘But no matter what they did, nothing helped. The blood tests came back with zero platelets every time.
What the story means by “had no choice” was the surgical treatment of ITP, namely splenectomy, or removal of the spleen. Surgeons were understandably reluctant to operate on a patient whose platelet count was so low as to be almost undetectable, given the extreme risk of bleeding. Dr. Michael apparently died before he could be operated on, as risky as surgery would be.
ITP: Causes and treatment
As I mentioned above, ITP is an autoimmune condition that results in platelet destruction in the spleen. Again, as I said before, “idiopathic” means basically “we don’t know what causes it.” There are also two forms of ITP, acute and chronic, with the acute form occurring mainly in children and the chronic form occurring in adults:
Acute ITP generally lasts less than 6 months. It mainly occurs in children—both boys and girls—and is the most common type of ITP. Acute ITP often occurs after a viral infection.
Chronic ITP lasts 6 months or longer and mostly affects adults. However, some teenagers and children do get this type of ITP. Chronic ITP affects women two to three times more often than men.
Treatment depends on the severity of bleeding and the platelet count. In mild cases, treatment may not be needed.
Another aspect of ITP is that it is usually not life-threatening. Acute ITP is often self-limited, and it’s rare for ITP in adults to be so resistant to treatment as Dr. Michael’s case:
For most children and adults, ITP isn’t a serious or life-threatening condition.
Acute ITP in children often goes away on its own within a few weeks or months and doesn’t return. In 80 percent of children who have ITP, the platelet count returns to normal within 6 to 12 months. Treatment may not be needed.
For a small number of children, ITP doesn’t go away on its own and may require further medical or surgical treatment.
Chronic ITP varies from person to person and can last for many years. Even people who have severe forms of chronic ITP can live for decades. Most people who have chronic ITP can stop treatment at some point and maintain a safe platelet count.
The most common symptoms of ITP include, of course, the petechiae and purpura mentioned before (small lesions on the skin due to bleeding under the skin), plus any or all of the following:
    • bruising easily
    • spontaneous nosebleeds
    • bleeding from the gums (for example, during dental work)
    • blood in the urine
    • blood in the stool
    • abnormally heavy menstruation
    • prolonged bleeding from cuts
    • profuse bleeding during surgery
There are a number of conditions that have been associated with the development of ITP:
    • Viral infections (including chickenpox, parvovirus, hepatitis C, Epstein-Barr, and HIV)
    • Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)
    • Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL)
    • Drug-induced immune thrombocytopenia
    • Sepsis, a severe bacterial infection in your blood
    • Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori), a bacteria that can live in your digestive system
Also, medications can increase the risk of ITP:
    • Certain drugs for heart problems, seizures, and infections
    • Heparin, a blood thinner used to prevent blood clots
The treatments for ITP depend upon the type and severity. As mentioned above, sometimes ITP doesn’t even require treatment and can be managed expectantly by checking platelet counts regularly to make sure the patient’s platelet count is not declining or are even increasing back towards normal. Unsurprisingly, the first line of treatment, however, is corticosteroids, ranging from oral prednisone in less severe cases to intravenous dexamethasone or methylprednisolone in more severe cases in which the platelet count is so low as to risk bleeding.
In case of emergency, platelet transfusions are used, but this is usually not the first choice because the new platelets are usually chewed up by the autoimmune response just as fast as the patient’s own platelets. Thus, platelet infusions are generally not used except in emergencies when bleeding is occurring or platelet counts are as low as Dr. Michael’s were. Either way, platelet transfusions are not a long-term treatment for ITP, as they can only temporarily increase the number of functional platelets.
There are also other drugs that can be used, non-steroid immunosuppressants such as mycophenolate mofetil and azathioprine, or even the chemotherapy agent vincristine. Intravenous immunoglobulin can also sometimes be effective at decreasing the rate at which macrophages (an immune cell) destroy antibody-tagged platelets. Like platelet transfusions, though, intravenous immunoglobulin usually only transiently increases platelet counts and is usually only used in cases where steroids don’t work and bleeding is either occurring or feared to be imminent. In cases of refractory ITP, thrombopoietin receptor agonists (drugs that stimulate the receptor) can stimulate the bone marrow to make more platelets. Another treatment includes rituximab (Rituxan), a monoclonal antibody against the protein CD20, which is found on the surface of B-cells. When rituximab binds to CD20, it causes B-cell death and is used against blood cancers and autoimmune diseases.
Finally, there’s surgery. Every general surgeon knows about ITP, because it is general surgeons who are called upon to do a splenectomy in patients whose ITP is refractory to other treatments. The reason that splenectomy works is because platelets with antibodies bound to them are taken up by macrophages in the spleen. Splenectomy can result in durable remission of ITP in up to 80% of patients, but, again, it’s generally risky because of the elevated risk of bleeding in the sorts of patients for whom the operation is generally reserved, namely those with refractory severe ITP.
It’s also important to note again that severe bleeding due to ITP of the sort suffered by Dr. Michael is rare.
Does vaccination against COVID-19 cause ITP?
The study cited in the USA TODAY story estimated the attributable risk of developing ITP after MMR vaccination to be 1 in 25,000 vaccinations, which strikes me as rather high. After all, a risk of ITP that high should produce a much more noticeable incidence of ITP. Be that as it may, another later study noted that bleeding episodes were uncommon among these patients, that the ITP associated with MMR disappeared within a month in 74% patients and only persisted beyond 6 months in only 10%. And, again, this was observed in children, not adults.
Dr. Iannelli notes that ITP is rare and that there is only one vaccine for which there is a documented association, the MMR vaccine. True, ITP is listed on the Gardasil package insert as a possible adverse reaction, but, as Dr. Iannelli goes on to explain further, later studies have shown no association, and the risk of getting ITP after an actual measles infection is considerably higher than the risk of ITP after the MMR vaccine, thus leading him to point out that “worry about ITP is a not a good reason to skip or delay getting vaccinated”.
This brings us, after this long detour into the weeds of what ITP is, what can trigger it, and how it’s treated, back to the question of COVID-19 vaccination and ITP, the question at the heart of the sad story of Dr. Michael’s sudden development of ITP refractory to treatment that claimed his life within two weeks of diagnosis. Dr. Iannelli further notes that the annual incidence rate of ITP is estimated to be 3.3 per 100,000 adults/year. Given that there are over 200 million adults in the US, this would lead to an estimate of around 16 adults per day being diagnosed with ITP. That means that, in any given three day period (chosen because Dr. Michael’s wife reported that her husband’s symptoms began three days after he was vaccinated with the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID vaccine), one would expect approximately 48 adults to be diagnosed with ITP. As the COVID-19 vaccines roll out, it’s going to become more and more likely that these people will receive their diagnosis within a couple of weeks of having been vaccinated against COVID-19. It’s thus probably more likely than not that Dr. Michael’s diagnosis so soon after vaccination is a coincidence.
It must, however, be acknowledged that it is possible that COVID-19 vaccination might have caused Dr. Michael’s severe ITP. The problem then becomes determining whether his tragic outcome was a coincidence or due to the vaccine. Unfortunately, Dr. Michael’s case is, at present, a single anecdote, making it impossible to demonstrate causation. Certainly, the clinical trials for neither the Pfizer/BioNTech nor the Moderna COVID-19 vaccines detected any signal for ITP in the form of bleeding, low platelet counts, or the like within two months of vaccination. Indeed, one of the deaths in the placebo group for the Pfizer vaccine was due to a hemorrhagic stroke. Given that there were approximately 44,000 subjects in the Pfizer/BioNTech trial with not a single patient showing signs if ITP, we can reasonably conclude that, even if the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine increases the risk of ITP or causes ITP, the risk must be very, very low.
What might lead scientists to think that there is an actual association between vaccination with the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID vaccine and ITP? Again, Dr. Iannelli suggests one possible metric for judging whether ITP really is associated with this vaccine:
But how can you know for sure?
Experts will look for safety signals and will make sure that the incidence of ITP and other conditions doesn’t rise above historical rates. For example, if all of a sudden we notice that the incidence of ITP rises to 6 or 9 per 100,000 adults/year after getting a vaccine, then that would be a signal that there could be a problem. A few media reports likely aren’t though.
Given how low the annual incidence of ITP is at baseline taken in context with the fact that there will be tens of millions of adults vaccinated with the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine this year, we would expect to see a significant increase in the annual incidence of ITP if this vaccine did actually increase the risk of ITP. For more on how, when studying adverse events after vaccination, scientists differentiate coincidence from actual association that might be causal, here’s a good primer.
But what if there really is an association between the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID vaccine and ITP? Even in the case that there is such an association, we know that, for the phase 3 clinical trial to have missed it, the incidence of post-COVID vaccination ITP must be very, very low. That would imply that, even if there is such an association, it is far safer to get the vaccine than it is to take the risk of catching COVID-19 – and, again, this is just one story. We do not know if Dr. Michael’s case, as tragic as it is, even indicates potential causation. Again, you can’t tell that from just one case, however dramatic and tragic. It is, however, not implausible that ITP might occur after vaccination against COVID-19 given that a recent review of the literature found 45 cases of new onset ITP after COVID-19 infection. Three turned out to be exacerbations of preexisting ITP and were excluded, but the review also reported one fatality due to intracranial hemorrhage, the same complication that took Dr. Michael’s life. It was also noted that severe bleeding due to ITP after COVID-19 infection was rare and that diagnosing ITP in the setting of COVID-19 infection is challenging due to the common incidence of clotting disorders and diffuse intravascular coagulation (DIC), which can also cause platelet depletion. Clearly more study is needed, and one anecdote isn’t enough to draw any conclusions.
It’s also entirely understandable that Heidi Neckelmann would believe that it was the COVID-19 vaccine that killed her husband. Humans are, as I like to say, pattern-seeking creatures. It’s hard-wired into us to search for causes whenever something horrible happens, and we usually find one, whether it is the true cause or not. As bad as I feel for her, I just wish that Ms. Neckelmann hadn’t in her grief leapt to the conclusion that it was definitely the COVID-19 vaccine that had caused her husband’s death from ITP and trumpeted his story as a warning to the world, so that his death wouldn’t be “in vain.” Her Facebook post handed the antivaccine movement and COVID-19 cranks a powerful propaganda weapon. Again, I think I understand why she did it, but really wish she hadn’t. Her post is already doing damage to efforts to persuade people to accept COVID-19 vaccines, as antivaccine groups gleefully spread this story far and wide.

Johnson & Johnson Vaccine and Blood Clots
Reports of blood clots with the J&J vaccine are very similar to AstraZeneca, with a similar dilemma.
Steven Novella on April 14, 2021
Link

We have been reporting on the incidence of rare blood clots following the AstraZeneca vaccine in Europe. And now we have to report, just one week later, on a very similar situation with the Johnson & Johnson (J&J) COVID vaccine. In a joint statement from the CDC and FDA, they recommended pausing use of the J&J vaccine until reports of blood clots can be investigated. The situation is somewhat different now from one month ago with the AstraZeneca vaccine, but the dilemma is similar.
In a joint statement the CDC and FDA report:
As of April 12, more than 6.8 million doses of the Johnson & Johnson (Janssen ) vaccine have been administered in the U.S. CDC and FDA are reviewing data involving six reported U.S. cases of a rare and severe type of blood clot in individuals after receiving the J&J vaccine. In these cases, a type of blood clot called cerebral venous sinus thrombosis (CVST) was seen in combination with low levels of blood platelets (thrombocytopenia). All six cases occurred among women between the ages of 18 and 48, and symptoms occurred 6 to 13 days after vaccination.
This is very similar to the AstraZeneca cases – CVST associated with low platelets (a blood component that initiates clotting) mostly in younger women. The incidence here is a little less than one case per million vaccines, which is extremely rare, and only one death out of nearly 7 million. It’s difficult to estimate how many COVID deaths were prevented by these same vaccines, but it is at least in the thousands.
These reports presented a dilemma for the CDC and FDA. On the one hand, these are rare side effects, dwarfed by the benefits of the vaccine in the middle of a surge of a deadly pandemic, when we are in a race against the emergence and spread of more infectious variants. Also, recommending a pause in the J&J vaccine could increase vaccine hesitancy overall, including of the two mRNA vaccines (Pfizer and Moderna) that have so far had no serious side effects.
Arguing for the pause is the fact that these cases are similar to the AstraZeneca cases, and both of these vaccines are modified adenovirus vaccines (again, very different from the mRNA vaccines). AstraZeneca is a chimpanzee adenovirus and J&J is a human adenovirus, so they are different viruses, but the technology is similar. Further – the association with low platelets could suggest an autoimmune etiology, which is plausible following a vaccine. In fact a recent study published in The New England Journal of Medicine finds evidence for an autoimmune cause:
Vaccination with ChAdOx1 nCov-19 can result in the rare development of immune thrombotic thrombocytopenia mediated by platelet-activating antibodies against PF4, which clinically mimics autoimmune heparin-induced thrombocytopenia.
They were also concerned with getting the word out to physicians as quickly as possible to be on the lookout for this syndrome, which needs to be treated differently than ordinary blood clots. And they wanted people who recently received the J&J vaccine to be on the lookout for any symptoms that might indicate CVST – severe headaches, confusion, dizziness, trouble speaking or difficulty understanding speech, numbness or weakness in the face/arm/leg, trouble seeing, trouble walking, loss of balance or coordination.
Finally they were concerned about the appearance of transparency, and that failure to act might sap confidence in the overall vaccine program. So they acted out of what they called “an abundance of caution”. They also did not ban use of the vaccine and the FDA did not revoke emergency use authorization. They simply recommended pausing use, and let the states decide how best to implement that recommendation.
The recommendation has attracted both praise and criticism. This is because they were dealing with a no-win scenario, especially when it comes to public perception and concerns about vaccine hesitancy. Whether they acted or not, the antivaccine forces on social media would exploit the situation to provoke as much fear and doubt about the vaccines in general as they can. There is no decision that would prevent this, so you might as well do what is best scientifically and then just explain the decision as best you can.
The scientific calculus is all risk vs benefit, and here the situation is very different from the AstraZeneca vaccine, which is critical to Europe’s vaccine strategy, especially in poorer countries. In the US most delivered vaccines are either Pfizer or Moderna, with J&J representing only 5%. Further, there are enough of the other two vaccines to meet demand and the ability to administer vaccines (enough for more than 3 million doses a day), so pausing or even eliminating J&J may have an insignificant effect on the vaccine program and not delay at all the date by which everyone who wants a vaccine will have it.
This is especially true after the Baltimore facility had to throw out a batch containing roughly 15 million doses of J&J vaccine because of contamination. Supplies of the vaccine were already short because of this.
This incident should, if anything, increase confidence in the vaccine program. There is an effective monitoring system that is capturing even very rare side effects from the vaccines. The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines have been out longer than J&J with many more doses given, and neither has been linked to any severe side effects. There is therefore extremely reassuring evidence for the safety of these vaccines, which also have extremely high efficacy.
The adenovirus vaccines are also safe and effective, but it increasingly seems like they can trigger a rare (about one in a million) autoimmune reaction in women less than 50. The medical community needs to know about this, how to recognize and treat it properly, and the general public needs to know in order to be vigilant about early symptoms. But the dilemma remains – in the middle of the COVID pandemic these vaccines will save thousands of lives for every one they take, and if we are careful we may be able to avoid any vaccine-related deaths. But we also know the public mostly does not make rational decisions based on math, and are more likely to avoid causing harm even if that passively allows a far greater harm to occur.
There are some compromises that could help. Giving the vaccine only to demographics that are not at high risk for blood clots, and not giving it to groups that are at risk for the clots but at lower risk from COVID. In the US the CDC and FDA are quickly reviewing the data and we will likely get more recommendations and actions soon. We are fortunate in that we have two other highly effective vaccines, and it seems plausible we can phase out the J&J vaccine with little impact. If necessary it can also be reserved just for populations at apparently low or no risk of developing the blood clots.
The situation is also another stark reminder of the persistent dangers to the public health of allowing gross medical misinformation to spread without consequences. Misinformation is a deeper pandemic, one which is much harder to treat.

Update on AstraZeneca Vaccine and Blood Clots
A link between the AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine and a rare type of blood clots is now more likely, but the benefits of vaccination still outweigh the risks.
Steven Novella on April 7, 2021
Link

Three weeks ago I discussed very preliminary reports of blot clots observed in people receiving the AstraZeneca vaccine, resulting in 13 countries suspending use of the vaccine. Since then the data has been tracked very carefully, and our understanding of the potential risk has evolved, but no definitive answer yet exists. It’s a great example of how scientists tackle such questions in real time, and the difficulty that epidemiological questions can sometimes present.
Initially the concern was the observation of various types of blood clots in the week following receiving the AstraZeneca vaccine for COVID-19. An initial review found that the total number of reported blood clots was within the expected range for the background occurrence. There was also no evidence for a specific link to the vaccine. In any case, the absolute numbers were so low that even if every observed blood clot was caused by the vaccine more lives would be lost by delaying vaccination.
But attention has shifted to one specific type of blood clot, cerebral venous sinus thromboses (CVST). This is a clot that forms in the veins that drain blood from the brain. If serious enough these clots can be fatal. Further, early reports suggest these clots are occurring more in people under 55 years old and more in women. Perhaps most intriguing (and concerning) is the fact that CVST in these patients has been associated with a low platelet count. This could be a sign of an inflammatory auto-immune process, something that can be triggered by a vaccine.
A preprint non-peer-reviewed paper discusses 9 cases showing low platelets with CVST and concluded that these cases are probably “vaccine induced”. However, expert reaction to this paper has been largely negative, indicating that the data is too slim and the research quality too low to draw any conclusions.
One critical aspect of a possible link between the AstraZeneca vaccine (to be clear, there is no concern about blood clots in other COVID vaccines) and CVST is the question – what is the background rate of these clots? It might seem that this should be an easy question to answer, but it isn’t. These are rare events, and so even a difference in reporting of a few cases can dramatically affect the statistics. Further, it is possible, even likely, that COVID itself increases the risk of blood clots, and so the background rate during the pandemic may be significantly higher. The BBC reports:
Germany’s Paul Ehrlich Institute has reported 31 cerebral venous sinus thromboses and nine deaths out of 2.7 million people vaccinated there.
The most recent UK data reported 30 clots linked with low platelet counts and seven deaths out of 18 million people vaccinated.
The European Medicines Agency, which has assessed data from around the world, estimates there is around a one in 100,000 risk of a CVST in people under the age of 60 who have been given the AstraZeneca vaccine.
The estimated background rate varies from 2 to 16 per million people per year. But this number, again, may be higher during the pandemic. While the EMA did not conclude that there was any specific demographic group at risk, most of the cases are in women under 55. This population may have a higher background risk of CVST also.
Amidst this uncertainty, however, the EMA has signaled it will officially report today or tomorrow that they are now ready to conclude that there is a link between the AstraZeneca vaccine and an increased risk of CVST in people under 55. However, they also stress that the benefits of getting the vaccine (the risk of not getting it) is greater than this risk of rare blood clots. That is turning out to be a hard sell, and many people are forgoing the vaccine because of this possible risk.
There are a few points worth emphasizing here. First, we do not know what the ultimate answer is, in terms of if there a genuine increased risk, in which populations, and due to what specific mechanism? Each step of the way scientists are giving the best answer possible based on the currently available evidence, which includes a wide range of uncertainty.
In normal times, the precautionary principle would prevail in such cases. However, during a pandemic the risk of delaying the vaccine will definitely lead to otherwise preventable deaths. If you are dead, it doesn’t matter if you were killed by COVID or a rare vaccine side effect. So we should take whichever course leads to the fewest deaths, which is clearly on the side of getting the vaccine, even in the worst-case scenario in terms of risk of CVST.
An obvious question is – can’t people just take other vaccines that don’t have this risk? Again, in normal times that might be the case, but not in the middle of a pandemic. In Europe COVID is experiencing another surge, likely caused in part by the emergence of new variants, and perhaps also by prematurely relaxing preventive measures and pandemic fatigue. The AstraZeneca vaccine is a critical part of Europe’s strategy to vaccinate its population as quickly as possible. It is also cheaper and easier to administer than other vaccines, and so is critically important to poorer countries. You can also argue that worldwide we are in a race against the emergence of new and deadlier variants, and any delay in vaccination can have significant repercussions. A global risk vs benefit approach is needed here.
Some countries are compromising, and not giving the vaccine to those under 55 or 50, while still giving it to older populations who apparently do not have the higher risk. If the risk is truly only higher in women, than the excluded population can be narrowed further. This still may not optimize risk vs benefit, but it is better than a global ban.
What we need now is more research to learn as much about this possible link as we can, mitigate if possible, and maximize benefit to risk in the face of a still-raging deadly pandemic.s

A clot too far: An embalmer dissects antivax misinformation about blood clots in Died Suddenly
Two weeks ago, COVID-19 conspiracy theorist Stew Peters released an antivax pseudodocumentary, Died Suddenly, whose main claim is that COVID-19 vaccines cause clots that have caused a massive wave of people to “die suddenly”. Key to its narrative are embalmers claiming that they are seeing more clots in the bodies they are embalming than ever before. SBM has recruited Benjamin Schmidt, an experienced embalmer, to dissect their claims.
Benjamin Schmidt on December 5, 2022
Link
In my twelve years of funeral service, one thing I have learned to be true; embalmers love a good clot story, and I find myself to be no exception to this. Seven years as an instructor of embalming and restorative art have given me an advantage in that I have more people sharing their clot stories with me. If you gave me ten minutes, it would be easy for me to come up with messages from people who have sent me pictures of large clots they have pulled from the veins of deceased humans during the embalming process. Consider it our version of ASMR in the same way that some people enjoy Dr. Pimple Popper. While I deigned to watch more of the antivaccine “documentary” Died Suddenly than I had to (e.g., all of it), I did, however, enjoy the final sequence in the film in which an embalmer named Richard Hirschman pulled large clots from the veins and arteries of the deceased person being embalmed. So when Dr. Gorski unexpectedly asked me to write a review of the film from an embalmer’s perspective (his more general review of the film from a science-based perspective can be found here), I was happy to do so.
A person might ask: Why is the scene in Died Suddenly featuring the removal of clots from bodies so appealing to embalmers? The answer is simple: The removal of clots of all shapes and sizes is a hallmark of an embalming going well and is exactly what we would expect and hope to see. This is particularly illustrated when Hirschman is shown removing a clot from the jugular vein and there is a burst of embalming solution behind it shown briefly before the camera stops filming. Every embalmer loves to see this because that’s how we know that our embalming solution will have a clear path into the arteries and capillaries. Yes, we embalmers love a good clot story, however it seems that the clot story in Died Suddenly is now being used to repackage many of the same old antivaccination tropes we have heard before.
To the untrained eye, the embalming sequence shown near the end of the movie can indeed appear odd. Because of the secretive nature of funeral service and our reverence for the dead, there aren’t a lot of embalming videos available in general, and even fewer are available to the public. In our culture, a precaution we take when using pictures and videos of people’s loved ones for educational purposes is getting written permission to take photographs of deceased people. It sometimes is the bullet points found on funeral homes’ embalming authorization forms. True, the use of the footage does not have to be specific when an embalmer obtains such permission, and it is unknown if Mr. Hirschman got that permission for this film. Most funeral homes bristle at the idea of bringing this up to grieving families, so it typically is not done unless you are making it part of your embalming case report or working with an embalmer who creates educational content for other embalmers. This is illustrated by Mr. Hirschman’s timidness about asking for permission to film at the funeral home, so instead he chooses to surprise them at the last minute with the camera crew. So please allow me to provide some insight for you into what we are seeing during this sequence that starts around 50 minutes in. I will also warn readers that this discussion features screenshots from Died Suddenly that might be disturbing to some.

What is going on in this prep room?
After being told none of the footage has been altered, we are immediately treated to a scene of a dimly lit (and possibly foggy) embalming room (also called a prep room) where Mr. Hirschman is portrayed as headed to a final showdown with a deceased person waiting for him on a table. This scene appears to contain footage of two different people on tables. The sequence that includes Mr. Hirschman—I am not even convinced this is him and not an actor—does appear to have a table used for embalming with a body on it. The second shot clearly shows the body wrapped differently and not a table used for embalming (see screenshot above). Embalming tables have trenches around the sides to catch and direct any liquids on the tables (as seen in the shot including “Mr. Hirschman”), this one does not. So much for unaltered footage.

Also, as an aside, for someone who is so concerned with public health, “Mr. Hirschman” needs to examine his own here, as he is decidedly not dressed in the OSHA recommended personal protective equipment prescribed for embalmers when they are preparing a body.
The first shot is of him pulling clots out of the iliac artery, claiming “this is not normal”. This claim is patently false. First, unless an embalmer is injecting an autopsied case, they are not using the iliac artery, but the external iliac artery or the femoral artery because these are superficial to the surface of the skin, which allows for easy access. This is an important distinction, because it is in this area is that the external iliac turns into the femoral artery as it crosses the inguinal ligament heading towards the leg. This area is a common site of significant atherosclerosis (the hardening of arteries), which slows blood and can capture clots. In fact, if Mr. Hirschman had picked up his embalming book during mortuary school, he would have recognized that we specifically teach that this is a danger area for clots and arterial blockages. When these are encountered, the embalmer might be required to access the femoral (or iliac) artery to inject the leg with embalming solution. It is extremely common to have to raise (the term we use for accessing the vascular system through an incision) more than one artery to complete an embalming, particularly to get better distribution and diffusion of solution to the legs. It is true that many embalmings begin with injection and drainage from the common carotid artery and the jugular vein in the neck, but it is not unusual for an embalmer to start with the femoral/iliac artery as the primary injection site. Since we see both in this sequence and because of potential editing, it is hard to know in what order he did the injection.

We are then treated to a montage of piles of blood clots. Again, this does not appear to be unusual. The difference here, is that clots have been collected for dramatic effect, when typically, most of these would just be washed down the drain during the embalming process, particularly the gelatinous red portion.


Next, after narration from an embalmer named Nicky Rupright King, we return to the prep room where Mr. Hirschman is removing a clot from the jugular vein followed by the burst of embalming solution I mentioned earlier. He says, “That’s a monster!”—indeed it is a good-sized clot—and there is the explosion of embalming solution from the buildup of pressure behind it. I personally breathed a sigh of relief for him because I have done exactly this countless times and taken it as sign that the tide of my embalming was going to turn for the better. Further, the instrument he is using to remove the clot is known as an “angular forceps”, and in embalming we use this specifically because of its ability to grasp and remove large clots! If he did indeed start injection with the external iliac before the common carotid, the injection directed superiorly would have pushed any clots in the body up to his point of drainage in the jugular. We don’t see him doing the actual injection in the footage because there is an absence of an arterial tube (the device inserted into an artery for injection of embalming solution) but we can infer its presence based on the embalming solution and the buildup of pressure in the shot of the common carotid/jugular vein. It is also possible that he was injecting the solution into the iliac artery and draining from the jugular, which is a technique called “split injection” (injection from one site and drainage from another). Drainage from the jugular is common because it diverts clots from being lodged in the head and causing swelling in the features.

The clots themselves
So now that you have a better picture of the embalming process and how it works, we ask ourselves, “where can the clots be coming from?” We embalmers have very simple categories we place postmortem clots into:
    • Currant jelly clots: Blood clots that contain all the blood elements coagulated in an evenly mixed mass.
    • Chicken fat clots: Blood clots that contains all the blood elements with the red and the white cells separated into distinct layers.
    • White fibrin clots: Blood clots that lack red blood cells, often found in the right atrium of the heart.
    • Sludge: Coagulated blood elements that have stuck together (also known as postmortem coagula).
I know that these are some very scientific sounding names and can be overwhelming to some when reading them, but the descriptions help. Also keep in mind that all these clots can exist at the same time in the same body. The consistency of the clots will vary as well, based on the following factors:
    • Moisture content of the body. After a person dies, water moves towards the ground, because you know, gravity. This is called hypostasis, and livor mortis (the red discoloration from the settling of blood) is the outcome. When this happens, the formed elements and blood proteins separate out as gravity continues its work. If a person was dehydrated when they died, theses clots will solidify sooner, and vice versa if they had a higher moisture content. What little case analysis I was able to do while watching this video, this person seems to be of normal moisture content.
    • Time. The more time the body sits, there more solid the clots become based on the separation of moisture. As I mentioned, an indicator of the movement of moisture is livor mortis, and it is not unusual for it to appear very soon after death, and I will explain why in a moment. Based on the angles of the video, I could not determine the movement of moisture based on the appearance of livor mortis.
    • Agonal period. The agonal period is the process of death right before the actual death. If a person is ill, their body process will slow, including their circulation, meaning that the blood can pool in places while the person is still alive due to low blood pressure and perfusion. This is known as agonal hypostasis and is common in people who have been in long term care such as a nursing home, home care, or hospice. Therefore, as I mentioned, livor mortis can appear soon after death in some cases. Based on the case analysis in the video here, I cannot determine the changes during the person’s agonal period.
    • Refrigeration. Cooling a body does a few things in the short term and even more in the long term. In the short term, it can allow for blood to remain in a liquid state and separate from the formed elements. Air movement over the surface of the body also causes dehydration. In the long term, oils and proteins of the body coagulate. Based on what I gleaned from the conversation about the person being embalmed, I believe that if this person was refrigerated, it was for a short time.
While I cannot definitively do any type of case analysis based on what is in the video, I do believe that it is fair to say that many of the 118 bodies Mr. Hirschman has claimed to have tracked and presented for evidence have been affected by one of the clot creating factors listed above.
So, now that we have an idea of how to categorize clots, let’s take a look at what types of clots we can see. First, remember that clots look weird even to us (hence part of why embalmers love clot stories). To the uncalibrated eye, it can be difficult to define them exactly. The other thing is that we must remember that all the different categories of clots can exist in the same body simultaneously. In the sequence where Mr. Hirschman is removing the clot from the iliac it would appear consistent with a currant jelly clot or maybe a chicken fat clot where the white portion is covered with other parts of the blood. The clot clusters in the blood clot montage, are clearly a mixture of chicken fat clots and sludge. Also, in the film Hirschman discusses a doctor’s concern over “microclots” and describes the drainage as dirty or sandy. The image we are shown of this is exactly what you would expect to see during an embalming. Later, he swirls the “dirty” blood in a vial. In fact, I would be concerned if I didn’t see this during an embalming, because it indicates the removal of postmortem coagula from the smaller arteries and capillaries.


The “monster clot” from the jugular vein could be a chicken fat clot where the red portion has sloughed off due to the pressure build up and the extraction of it from the vein. We can see evidence of it surrounding the incision. It could also be a white fibrin clot as a properly placed angular forceps enters the right atrium of the heart via the jugular vein, as this is the center for drainage in a deceased human.
Effects of the embalming process
We also need to consider the effect of the embalming process on the clots themselves. A repeated discussion of the clots describes them as “rubbery,” and this is reiterated again when a crew member feels one of the clots Mr. Hirschman dangles for all to see. This comes as zero surprise to any embalmer because that is exactly what embalmed tissue feels like. One of the functions of formaldehyde is to coagulate protein, and this is what produces the rubbery feel. In fact, embalming chemical companies add modifying chemicals to their products in order to reduce this texture.

The whopping one sample that has been analyzed by Mike Adams using inductively coupled plasma–mass spectrometer (ICP-MS) came back with these results:
    • The clot lacks the metals such as calcium and magnesium normally found in blood.
    • The clot had a high concentration of chloride.
Again, had Adams or anyone taken the time to open an embalming textbook, they would have had their answers. Embalming fluids used for arterial injection frequently contain the metal chelator EDTA and other anticoagulants whose specific purpose is to strip metals from the blood. Calcium is responsible for the blood clotting reaction even after death, so we have preservative fluids with anticoagulants built in or added to the embalming solution separately to promote drainage and reduce clotting. If Mr. Hirschman was expecting to find clots, it is likely he would have chosen fluids that would aid him in their removal, because his goal after all is to have a well-embalmed body. As for the chloride, again simple explanation; many prep room cleaners, including bleach, contain chlorides. If the clots came into contact with a surface (the embalming table for example) they would be contaminated by the cleaning agent. We also need to consider the physics of embalming as well, embalming machines vary in their pressure and rate of flow combinations, and embalmers like to manipulate these settings as they go.
If Mr. Hirschman was expecting clots, he would have been changing these settings to prevent swelling but loosen the clots at the same time. The general rule for this is low pressure, low rate of flow. There is another thing we should not overlook here; as a seasoned embalmer, I have no doubt that Mr. Hirschman is really good at extracting clots. Developing this technique over time to keep clots intact as you remove them is in an embalmer’s best interest to clear arteries and veins, as necessary.
The claims about the clots
Before I conclude, I would like to examine the claims about the clots through the qualifications of an embalmer and as I see it, there are three; there is a rise in clots, the clots are unusual, and the clots are caused by the COVID vaccine. So let us look at them one by one:
There is a rise in clots.
It is impossible to tell, at least from the information presented in Died Suddenly. As far as I know, there is not a database of all reported clots that creates statistics for us to reference. Plus, as you can imagine, it would be really hard for us to accurately gauge the number of clots in all the dead people in the entire world, especially considering that most of the people do not get embalmed and are not examined by a coroner or medical examiner. If there is one, I would love to see it. As early as summer 2020, we were told that a side effect of COVID-19 was clots, so if there is a rise in clots, there’s a reasonable explanation.
The clots are unusual.
As I have explained, every clot is unique, and the variations of clots are based on all the factors I listed. There is a way we could gain more information about the conditions when the clots were produced and that is if Mr. Hirschman were to release his embalming case reports for review. A typical embalming case report has demographic information such as gender and age as well as any antemortem and postmortem conditions such as medical devices found, signs of moisture content, livor mortis, etc. It would also tell us what embalming fluids he used and the concentration of formaldehyde his embalming solution was. He already has a catalog of his cases, and each sample bottle was labeled with the number, so if he allowed us to analyze his embalming case reports for each one, we would have more information. However, based on the images I have seen, particularly the image in the film’s thumbnail of the clots on the blue glove, there is nothing unusual about them at all.
The clots are caused by COVID-19 vaccines.
There is no compelling evidence of this, and Mr. Hirschman’s own study does not lead us in this direction. He has confirmed 16 of these bodies are vaccinated, but the vaccination status of the other 102 remains unknown. As we see looking over his shoulder on his computer, he has logged a lot of bodies that have clots in them. This makes sense to me because lots of bodies have clots in them. One of the issues never really addressed here is whether we are to assume all of the clots found in a person are caused by the vaccine, or only some of them. How does Mr. Hirschman determine this? Also, more confusing is how Mr. Hirschman has even confirmed the 16 he claims he has verified. At the beginning of the movie, he is identified as a “trade embalmer”. A trade embalmer is a person who goes from funeral home to funeral home embalming bodies as an independent contractor. They rarely, if ever, have any contact with the families directly, unless of course they also transport the person from the place of death and the family is present. Laws on who can transport a body from the place of death vary from state to state and in Alabama, no specific license for this is required. My guess is that the funeral homes hire a transfer service or have a driver who is paid minimum wage for this purpose if they are not sending one of their own funeral directors as a representative. It would not be considered good etiquette to ask a grieving widow at that time if her husband was vaccinated. So, this means that he is likely getting this information second hand from people at the funeral homes that hire him.
Now the scope of work that Mr. Hirschman and the trade embalmers does vary depending on what services they offer a funeral home, however, based on what we saw in the film we can assume that embalming is his main duty because he was called by a funeral home, went to the funeral home, and then walked like some kind of warrior towards a dead body for a showdown. What should also be noted here is that if a person dies a natural death, the embalmer typically does not know their cause of death at the time of their embalming. Because decomposition begins at the moment of death we try to embalm as soon as possible. It may take several days for a doctor to complete a death certificate, indicating the cause of death. So, as you can imagine, the idea that we would know a person’s vaccine history is almost unheard of. Case in point, it was also unknown to us as the viewers of Mr. Hirschman’s embalming if the person that was being embalmed was indeed vaccinated. This means all the “whoa babying” he was doing over the clots during the embalming, might have been on a person who was not vaccinated. In general, this is all anecdotal evidence causing the embalmers to jump to conclusions and make claims they are not qualified to make. We do not have training in the collection or the testing of blood, and as evidenced by the corruption of the one sample sent to Mike Adam’s laboratory, Mr. Hirschman specifically does not have this training.
To me, Mr. Hirschman demonstrates the qualities of a good embalmer but a terrible scientist. Instead of jumping to conclusions based on his own confirmation bias, he should have opened one of the embalming textbooks available to him because that would explain a lot of what’s going on here. It is an old trope in our industry that when a new embalmer begins at a funeral home, they are told by the embalmers training them, “Forget what you learned in school. I will teach you everything you need to know”. There is a culture of hubris and argument from authority that is entrenched in funeral service, and it is on full display here. The assumption that the embalmers make in this film that they have any qualifications to make the claims they are is laughable. I say this with added confidence because I know for a fact that I had the same education as one of the embalmers featured in this film and then went on to teach embalming at the same school we both went to! In short, if you find yourself taking medical advice from embalmers, you are likely to find yourself on their table soon after.
NOTICE: The thoughts and opinions expressed in this post belong to Ben Schmidt alone and are not necessarily representative of any organizations he is affiliated with.
References
Mayer, R. (2012). Embalming history, theory, and practice, 5th Ed. McGraw Hill: New York.Strub, C., Frederick, L.G., (1989). The principals and practices of embalming, Professional Training Schools: Dallas

COVID-19 pandemic deniers and the antivaccine movement: An unholy alliance
Deniers of the severity of COVID-19 as a disease and pandemic have increasingly teamed up with the antivaccine movement, emulating their rhetoric, conspiracy theories, and tactics. The effect on public health is likely to be disastrous.
David Gorski on April 20, 2020
Link

I realize that, since the COVID-19 pandemic began, I’ve written about little or nothing else besides COVID-19 and associated conspiracy theories. I suppose that at some point I will need to write about something else, but nothing going on in the world of medicine compels me as much as the pandemic right now; so I’m going to ride with it at least this week. Maybe by next week, I’ll be so sick of writing about the pandemic that I’ll write about something that almost seems quaint, like homeopathy. (Oh, crap, the homeopaths are recommending their quackery to prevent and treat COVID-19. I just can’t escape!)
One aspect of the COVID-19 pandemic that I haven’t really written much about much yet is the developing unholy alliance between COVID-19 deniers (who peddle in conspiracy theories and falsely claim that the disease isn’t that bad and/or that the lockdowns and social distancing are not—or no longer—necessary and should be lifted to alleviate the catastrophic damage to our economy that mitigation efforts have unavoidably caused), and the antivaccine movement (which predictably peddles misinformation and conspiracy theories about how COVID-19 is being weaponized as a plot to impose forced universal vaccination—or even that the disease was created by Bill Gates for that very purpose, along with H1N1 influenza and Ebola!—or how the influenza vaccine supposedly makes one more susceptible to coronavirus; spoiler alert: It doesn’t). Although it might seem odd, those of us who’ve studied conspiracy theories for a long time almost immediately realized that an alliance between the antivaccine movement and COVID-19 deniers would entirely natural and expected it. Both groups of conspiracy theorist share an intense distrust of government, particularly the CDC and FDA. Both share an equally intense distrust of big pharma, while fetishizing individual freedom above all else, with antivaxxers invoking “health freedom” and “parental rights” and COVID-19 deniers invoking absolute bodily autonomy and the “right” to do whatever they want, including violating social distancing. Both groups’ beliefs are rooted in conspiracy theories, with the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement being that the government, big pharma, and the medical profession have evidence that vaccines cause autism and harm but are covering it up, and COVID-19 deniers’s beliefs based in one or more of several conspiracy theories (e.g., the virus is an escaped bioweapon; was created by Bill Gates to impose universal forced vaccination; isn’t nearly as bad as seasonal flu; and several more). Both have a tendency towards germ theory denial, laboring blissfully under the delusion that, because they are so “healthy,” because they live such exemplary lifestyles, exercise, and eat the “right” foods, it makes sense that COVID-19 deniers don’t think that COVID-19 is a threat to them or their loved ones, just as antivaxxers don’t think vaccine-preventable diseases are a threat to them and their loved ones either.
Finally, both groups share zero, or close to zero, sense of shared social responsibility for public health and selfishly emphasize their “rights” über alles. For example, take a look at this Tweet:
Always keeping it classy, antivaxxers. pic.twitter.com/6eOg9myIa5
— Dr. Tara C. Smith (@aetiology) April 18, 2020
COVID-19 deniers have also appropriated the offensive analogies of antivaxxers who now like to compare themselves to the “new civil rights movement,” with White House advisor Stephen Moore comparing protestors against lockdowns and social distancing to Rosa Parks.
COVID-19 deniers are also, in addition to their other conspiracy theories, appropriating the language of the antivaccine movement (“I do not consent”; “I do not comply”) in their message:
This is exactly the same attitude that antivaxxers often express, denying herd immunity, saying that it’s not their responsibility to protect others, asking why those who vaccinated worry about the unvaccinated if vaccines are so great? Both groups also minimize the danger by claiming that only the elderly and chronically ill are at risk for severe illness and death, which is not true. It is true that the elderly and chronically ill are at considerably higher risk of severe disease and death than the young, but the COVID-19 is nonetheless hospitalizing and claiming the lives of younger people at an alarming rate, including health care workers.
Meanwhile, this video shows antivaxxers using standard “V Is For Vaccines” signs sold by antivaccine organizer Josh Coleman:
#MAGA is a death cult. Austin Texas today: pic.twitter.com/6N4igXsx41
— Justin Hendrix (@justinhendrix) April 18, 2020
I’ve been noticing this in more and more of these “Reopen America” protests.
So it should come as no surprise that antivaxxers are all-in with COVID-19 denial, as this article published last week in Undark by Catherine Gammon indicates:
In early March, Melissa Floyd, a self-described health freedom educator who co-hosts “The Vaccine Conversation” podcast, was forced to abruptly change plans. She and her co-host were supposed to pack up for a live multi-city tour. But the public health crisis borne from Covid-19 delayed the start of their tour for months.
Floyd and her co-host, Bob Sears, a California-based pediatrician who advocates a delayed vaccine schedule and skipping some vaccines, addressed the cancellation in a podcast episode, noting that they don’t have any personal fear of the virus. Our government agencies, Floyd said, “are talking about washing your hands, but why aren’t they talking about things you can do to boost your immune system like vitamin D? Why aren’t they talking about reducing sugar? Why aren’t they talking about eating fruits and vegetables and staying away from processed foods?
“I’ve not heard any footage,” Floyd continued, “that talks about how to make your body strong — it’s just wash your hands, use a mask and hopefully that vaccine will come out sooner rather than later.” (Floyd did not respond to an interview request from Undark.)
We’ve written about “Dr. Bob” Sears more times than I can remember on this blog, and I’ve written about him many times on my not-so-secret other blog. Basically, Dr. Bob has been prominent in opposing SB276 and any effort to tighten school vaccine mandates and clamp down on dubious personal belief exemptions and bogus medical exemptions, while having been sanctioned by the Medical Board of California. After SB276 passed, he was an early grifter selling his advice on the seminar circuit to antivaxxers on how to avoid the newly stringent school vaccine mandates and then later, or so it appeared to me, selling such mandates himself.
There’s also another commonality between COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers:
“It’s not as deadly as we’ve been told,” he said, adding later in the show: “This is really only a tragic situation for a small group of people that are immune-suppressed or elderly.” Similarly, on March 28, Sears posted on Facebook: “Elderly are vulnerable and need protection AND Covid is harmless to almost everyone else.”
Both statements are incorrect — there are numerous reports of young, healthy people in intensive care and on ventilators. But it’s a common tactic, says Reiss. “They focus on death, and they ignore hospitalization, and they’re going to say: look, it’s not going to kill you, you shouldn’t get the vaccine,” she says. “They do that with other diseases as well.” A recent Washington Post analysis found that hundreds of people under the age of 50 have also died from the coronavirus.
This is an apt observation. Just as antivaxxers focus on mortality and ignore morbidity from vaccine-preventable diseases to make disingenuous arguments claiming that “vaccines didn’t save us,” COVID-19 deniers focus on mortality and ignore the suffering caused. More importantly they ignore the possibility that, with no mitigation, hospitals will be overwhelmed with COVID-19 patients, leading to the inability to treat all patients optimally and thus triage, as well as deaths from other causes of people whose treatment suffers because hospitals are overwhelmed. Finally, the claim that COVID-19 is not dangerous to most people, other than the immunosuppressed or the chronically ill, is exactly the same thing antivaxxers say about vaccine-preventable diseases, like the measles or chickenpox, that they’re not serious diseases, that their “healthy children” don’t have to worry about them as more than an inconvenience, when such is certainly not the case.
Dr. Bob has also been peddling false dichotomies, a choice between a “ruined society” and more deaths:
The media label those who go out as Covidiots. Will they also label those who prefer we all die from a ruined society instead? Just to be fair.
Posted by Dr. Bob Sears on Wednesday, March 25, 2020
Of course, millions of deaths, which would be likely without mitigation, would ruin the economy even more thoroughly. Indeed, the very question of “opening the economy” safely is incredibly complex, and it’s doubtful that most people will feel safe going to, for example, movie theaters or anywhere with large numbers of people any time soon. Even more offensively, Dr. Bob is now accusing those supporting the current lockdown of hoping that nations using other approaches to fail “so we can prove we were right”:
Question: we are all waiting with baited breath to see if things work out for Sweden. I wonder, do our leaders hope…
Posted by Dr. Bob Sears on Wednesday, April 15, 2020
Sweden, as many know, is not under total lockdown. Its approach of making social distancing (mostly) voluntary rather than mandated and enforced is, to put it mildly, very controversial, and recent modeling has provided cause for concern, with one study (still on preprint) estimating that Sweden’s approach is likely to “result in a peak intensive-care load in May that exceeds pre-pandemic capacity by over 40-fold, with a median mortality of 96,000 (95% CI 52,000 to 183,000).” Whether that model will turn out to be accurate or if Sweden will manage to do far better than dire predictions like this remains to be seen. Although there are indications that its strategy could backfire, it might also work because 40% of Swedish households are single-person households without children. Of course, invoking Sweden demonstrates commonalities between COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers, namely cherry picking examples and oversimplifying and misrepresenting legitimate scientific controversies.
Yet another argument used by COVID-19 deniers “pioneered” by the antivaccine movement is that “natural” immunity or “natural herd immunity” is better than immunity from a vaccine:
And another common thread in anti-vaccine groups focuses on the belief that natural immunity — the kind you get from actually having a disease — is better than immunity from a vaccine. The logic, they argue, is that if natural disease is a healthy and normal process, people should just go ahead and get infected with a disease, which will eventually give them immunity and protect more people. “It’s an inferior immunity that vaccines provide, which is why we’ve seen second, third, fourth, fifth doses of vaccines, why everyone has to get a flu shot every single year,” Bigtree said on his March 26 show.
And:
In an interview, Bigtree elaborated, saying he’s not anti-vaccine for the right people. “I would never have a problem with any product if it was designed for the people that need it,” he said. “I do not agree with the principle that perfectly healthy people need to take a product to protect a very small percentage of sick people.”
This is of a piece with Andrew Wakefield’s profoundly deceptive argument showing his utter ignorance of evolutionary theory that “natural herd immunity” to measles led to the disease becoming less virulent as he predicted that there could be a “mass extinction” due to virulent measles strains evolving as a result of mass MMR vaccination. Of course, what COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers also share in common is a failure to realize that the price of “natural herd immunity” is mass suffering and way more death than herd immunity achieved with mass vaccination. Moreover, again, without mitigation, COVID-19 would likely cause death on a much more massive scale than it is causing now, a fact that neither COVID-19 deniers nor antivaxxers appear overly concerned about:
And it’s not just anti-vaccine groups promoting the idea that people should get sick. The Federalist, an American conservative online magazine, published a story on March 25 advocating a voluntary infection approach for Covid-19.
While it’s true that, in most cases, natural immunity can last longer than vaccine-induced immunity, public health experts say the risks of the former outweigh the risks of the latter for every recommended vaccine. Natural immunity, Ernst says, “protects people after a whole bunch of people get sick, and that’s not good.” Reiss adds that none of these denials or conspiracy theories are new — they’re classic beats in the anti-vaccination world: “They’ve been circulating around, but they’re just applying old beliefs to new contexts.” The new context matters, though — Covid-19 is a public health crisis on a level that hasn’t been seen in 100 years.
Precisely.
It’s not just the US either. Antivaxxers in Italy are peddling COVID-19 denial, for much the same reasons, as this Slate article notes:
One of the cornerstones of the anti-vaccine movement is the assumption that potential negative consequences of vaccinations could be greater than the risks of diseases they prevent. Mario Small, a professor of sociology at Harvard, also believes that one of the reasons why COVID-19 is unlikely to shake this conviction is the perception of the magnitude of the coronavirus, which cannot be compared to other diseases. “You can’t ignore the coffins and the deaths,” Small says, but it is likely that the anti-vaccine movement will approach this disease as different. “Part of the mentality for which you’ve made such strong commitment would be to find reasons why your beliefs are still consistent with reality.”
Giovanni—he has asked Slate to use only his first name—is a father of two in his mid-30s from the Emilia Romagna region. He is a strong opponent of mandatory vaccination, and his two small children were excluded from preschool when he and his partner refused to vaccinate them. He says he might be open to a coronavirus vaccine for himself when one become available. “There are different types of vaccines and different types of diseases. We don’t know enough about COVID-19 yet, but if one day a vaccine became mandatory I might do it to be able to work and travel. It’s soon to say.” What he is sure about is that the coronavirus has not made him change his mind about other vaccines. Giovanni also says that he is afraid this public health crisis will lead to a tightening of vaccination policies.
Meanwhile, there has been an interesting shift among antivaxxers teaming with COVID-19 deniers. Specifically, they’ve both embraced the promotion of the antimalarial and immunomodulatory drug hydroxychloroquine ± the antibiotic azithromycin as miracle cures for COVID-19 by French “brave maverick doctor” Didier Raoult, Donald Trump, Dr. Mehmet Oz, and Trump’s allies in the press. Del Bigtree has promoted hydroxychloroquine on his show, most recently last week:
Never mind that the evidence is most definitely trending in the direction of the conclusion that hydroxychloroquine ± azithromycin doesn’t work against COVID-19 but does cause significant side effects, “miracle cure” testimonials aside.
So have many other antivaxxers. Embracing drugs like this, which are not entirely benign drugs, producing serious side effects in some patients, seems to go against the hostility towards pharma that antivaxxers routinely exhibit. So why are they embracing these drugs? First, no one ever said that conspiracy theories had to be self-consistent. Second, if there’s an effective treatment, antivaxxers likely “reason”, then there will be less focus on a vaccine. It’s an angle that RFK Jr. has also taken. Third, these drugs are off-patent, making it possible for antivaxxers to use one of their favorite arguments in favor of “natural treatments,” namely that big pharma can’t make much money off of these drugs. Finally, as you can see above, Bigtree modified the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement (that the CDC “knew” vaccines cause autism but covered it up) to saying that the CDC “knew” that hydroxychloroquine is highly effective against COVID-19 but didn’t reveal it. I sense a theme here.
Finally, the propaganda and disinformation about COVID-19, whether it comes from antivaxxers, COVID-19 deniers, politicians, or celebrities, have had real world consequences. Last Wednesday, in Michigan, there was a large protest against Gov. Whitmer’s executive order to shelter in place in which thousands of people drove in front of the State Capitol Building in order to call for loosening of the restrictions. Dubbed “Operation Gridlock”, Operation Gridlock was organized by right wing groups funded by the DeVos family:
Notice how the protesters who got out of their cars were not social distancing much. Basically, this protest was a large COVID-19 incubator in which people from parts of Michigan not yet affected much by COVID-19 mingling with people from the hardest hit part of the state (the Detroit area) for several hours and then headed home to take coronavirus with them to every corner of the state. Areas of the state that have so far had few COVID-19 cases could well start to see their numbers climb dramatically in 2-4 weeks, as protestors return home and, likely, fail to social distance adequately once there.
Last week, there were similar protests in other states, such as Maryland, Texas, Ohio, Kentucky, Minnesota, Virginia, Utah, North Carolina, Idaho, and California, with a planned protest in Sacramento today. (Note added: Since I wrote this, I’ve learned that there were protests in several other states on Sunday.) Perusing news reports and photos in social media posts, I have identified antivaxxers in nearly every one of these protests, and antivaxxers heavily promoted the planned protest in Sacramento today on Facebook. Here’s an example:
Same anti-vaxxers that were protesting at the Capitol for #SB276 are the ones who are organizing the re-open CA protests. pic.twitter.com/IVGmyf6F7H
— Leftist Mom. Not a Bot 💁‍♀️ (she/her) 🌊 (@ProVaxx2) April 19, 2020
I fear that this alliance between COVID-19 cranks with the antivaccine movement, with its cross-fertilization of rhetoric and tactics, particularly when fueled by funding and support from various political groups pushing to “reopen America”, has the potential to make the pandemic so much worse than it had to be. The only bright side I can see is this. Although all but a handful of hard core antivaxxers will never change their opposition to vaccines, the pandemic might make the public less forgiving of these cranks:
Catherine Flores Martin, executive director for the California Immunization Coalition, says she is seeing a shift in people reacting to anti-vaccine posts on social media. And she thinks people are going to be a lot less forgiving of anti-vaccination beliefs in the future. “There will still be the believers, but I think other people are going to be a lot less tolerant of it now that people have seen how disease can impact their life. We have their attention.”
I hope that that’s one outcome, when this pandemic finally abates. There’s no guarantee, though, and I fear that it might not be.

Don’t use a COVID-19 vaccine, cry the antivaxxers, because of the horseshoe crab!
Antivaxxers are now urging vegans not to use a COVID-19 vaccine because blood from horseshoe crabs will be used in its manufacture. At its heart, this is no different than their weaponization of beliefs against other vaccine ingredients, except that it does use a germ of a good point that we should be looking for other ways to ensure that vaccines have no bacteria in them.
David Gorski on September 7, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: Today is a holiday; so I decided to take it (somewhat) easy and update a post from my not-so-secret other blog for today. If you don’t read that blog, it’s new to you. If you do, I changed the post up a bit so that it’s not entirely the same. Enjoy!]
I was trying to decide what to write about today and finding it rather difficult. Part of it might be because, in the States at least, it’s a long holiday weekend. Another part of the reason is that so many of the potential topics are so obvious, given the torrent of disinformation that last week brought about vaccines, COVID-19, and so many other medical topics. That being said, if there’s one thing I like to do, it’s to take on topics that no one else notices, which brings me to antivaxxers and horseshoe crabs.
Yes, horseshoe crabs.
Over at what I’ve long liked to refer to (along with The Huffington Post) as that “wretched hive of scum and antivaccine villainy”, Age of Autism (even though several other wretched hives of scum and antivaccine quackery have surpassed its wretchedness over the years), I came across this remarkable post urging vegans to be wary of any potential COVID-19 vaccine because of horseshoe crabs in a post entitled “Will Vegans Reject Covid Vaccine that Drains Horseshoe Crabs of Their Blood?“:
Note: Can you be a Vegan, a true Vegan who does not consume animal products, and take a COVID vaccine that calls for the ex-sanguination [sic] of horseshoe crabs? What’s the difference between the cruel existence of veal, and hooking horsehoe [sic] crabs to a machine that drains their 30% of their blood, if when they are returned “home,” many die? Is taking any product that knowingly harms animals hypocritical? If you have never seen horseshoe crabs in the wild, you should. We used to see them often on Cape Cod. They are mesmerizing, ancient creatures.
This isn’t a new tactic, either. Back in April, Sherri Tenpenny’s antivaccine website Vaxxter published an article with the title, “The Chilling Image Behind Every Vaccine“:
The image is startling. The sight of crabs being forced in clamps and bled out in what appears much like a lab from Blade Runner. The horseshoe crab is 300 million years old and that’s what haunts the image before you. That’s 200 million years older than dinosaurs. But even this sea creature isn’t likely to survive pharma’s wrath.
Horseshoe crabs are known for their unique blue blood. That blood will clot in the presence of specific bacterias, [sic] so pharma loves to use them to test out new medications, including vaccines.
Accompanying the article is an image similar to this one:
The reason the crabs’ blood is blue is because it uses copper in a protein called haemocyanin instead of iron in hemoglobin to bind oxygen. So there really is a precedent for certain races in Star Trek to be “blue-blooded”!
Elsewhere, more recently other alternative medicine and antivaccine sites have been taking up the cry, attempting to demonize any new COVID-19 vaccine (and, of course, vaccines in general) with the cry being taken up by blogs and websites such as The Vaccine Reaction and The Alternative Daily.
A regular reader might be wondering here: Why do pharmaceutical companies harvest the blood of horseshoe crabs to use for vaccines? In fact, I wondered that very thing and was rather amazed that I didn’t know about this particular practice, even after having written about vaccine safety issues for over 20 years. So this was a great learning opportunity for me to fill in a gap in my knowledge that I didn’t know that I had – and, hopefully, to fill in a gap that many SBM readers didn’t know they had either.
Here’s the explanation. There is a substance in the blood of horseshoe crabs, limulus amebocyte lysate, that can be used to detect endotoxin, a toxin that is a component of the bacterial wall of gram-negative bacteria. (Gram-negative or gram-positive refers to the ability of a species of bacteria to be stained with Gram stain.) Endotoxin is a lipopolysaccharide (LPS) consisting of lipid A and something called the O-polysaccharide, which allows bacteria to adhere to certain tissues and contributes to resistance to being engulfed by certain immune cells. The lipid A portion of LPS is the cause of the molecule’s endotoxin activity, as immune cells in humans and animals recognize it as an indicator of the presence of bacteria and activate an immune response to it, no previous exposure to endotoxin required. Thus, endotoxin can cause a robust inflammatory reaction and is the most potent contributor to septic shock in patients with gram-negative sepsis.
Which brings us to the reason why this extract from horseshoe crab blood is so important:
Due to the severe consequences of an infection, an injectable healthcare product such as a vaccine or intravenous solution must be sterile or free of live bacteria, but the manufacturing process to kill any bacteria can result in release of LPS or endotoxin into the product. Just as with a bacterial infection or sepsis, if sufficient endotoxin gets into our blood stream or spinal fluid we can develop fever, shock, and organ failure. In extreme cases, it can even result in death.
Therefore, injectables or implantables, products that come in contact with the blood stream or spinal fluid, are tested for sterility (the absence of live bacteria) as well as endotoxin. Testing for endotoxin helps assure product quality and safety.
So you can see why testing to make sure that endotoxin is eliminated from a vaccine, a medical device, or any injectable product is so important. How is this product used? An article from 2014 published in The Atlantic describes how. After waxing poetic about how horseshoe crab blood is blue, not red, the article goes on to describe how the blood is used to detect endotoxin:
The marvelous thing about horseshoe crab blood, though, isn’t the color. It’s a chemical found only in the amoebocytes of its blood cells that can detect mere traces of bacterial presence and trap them in inescapable clots.
To take advantage of this biological idiosyncrasy, pharmaceutical companies burst the cells that contain the chemical, called coagulogen. Then, they can use the coagulogen to detect contamination in any solution that might come into contact with blood. If there are dangerous bacterial endotoxins in the liquid—even at a concentration of one part per trillion—the horseshoe crab blood extract will go to work, turning the solution into what scientist Fred Bang, who co-discovered the substance, called a “gel.”
“This gel immobilized the bacteria but did not kill them,” Bang wrote in the 1956 paper announcing the substance. “The gel or clot was stable and tough and remained so for several weeks at room temperature.”
If there is no bacterial contamination, then the coagulation does not occur, and the solution can be considered free of bacteria. It’s a simple, nearly instantaneous test that goes by the name of the LAL, or Limulus amebocyte lysate, test (after the species name of the crab, Limulus polyphemus).
But why, you ask, did evolution endow the horseshoe crab with the ability to make coagulogen? The best guess is this. Horseshoe crabs live in a bacteria-rich environment near the shoreline, and their circulatory systems made the evolution of such a system advantageous. In 1956, a researcher named Fred Bang noted that when horseshoe crab blood comes into contact with endotoxin, cells called amebocytes clot and form a solid mass:
And that bacteria-rich habitat is why, Bang speculated, the crabs evolved their marvelous chemical defense. Their circulatory systems work more like a spider’s than like ours. If we inhale something bad, that thing has to find its way through our bodies and into our bloodstreams, fighting its way through our white blood cells along the way. But if bacteria find their way under a horseshoe crab’s exoskeleton, they can roam free to do damage.
“Large sinuses exist that allow blood direct contact with tissues,” the Woods Hole Marine Biological Laboratory’s history of the crab explains. “There are many wide open spaces and bacteria entering a crack in the shell of a horseshoe crab have easy access to large internal areas of the crab, a potentially deadly scenario.”
The coagulogen changes the wide-open terrain of the horseshoe crab’s circulatory system. When the crab blood cells sense invaders, they release granules of the chemical, which becomes a gooey physical barrier to the movement of the bacteria, preventing the spread of infection. The best metaphor might be the superpower of the X-Men’s Iceman, but instead of using cold to encase enemies, the horseshoe crab instead uses its remarkable chemistry.
A description of how Bang discovered limulus can be found here. In brief:
Bang was studying the circulation of blood using horseshoe crabs when he found that one of his crabs died as a result of a Vibrio bacterial infection. The infection caused a strange disease in which almost the entire blood volume of the crab clotted into a semi-solid mass. Other bacteria had not produced this sort of reaction at all. Bang began to investigate further and found that only gram-negative bacteria produced this reaction. Furthermore, heat-treated bacteria (dead bacteria) continued to produce the reaction so it wasn’t a pathological disease but something different.
Isn’t science cool? Isn’t evolution awesome? Imagine a chemical made by an organism that can react with another molecule at such low concentrations and basically immobilize it. Evolution’s done that for the humble horseshoe crab! And scientists figured out what the chemical is and how to use it to keep injectable medications and implantable devices safe.
Of course, like most antivaccine propaganda, there is a grain of a reasonable point buried in the spin and exaggeration, the main question being: Why do we still use horseshoe crab blood to obtain the necessary molecule? Why haven’t we been able to come up with a substitute or figure out a way to synthesize the chemical without bleeding millions of horseshoe crabs, resulting in the deaths of a not-insignificant number of them? After all, horseshoe crab blood is one of the most expensive resources in the world, costing around $60,000 per gallon (around $15,581 per liter, for the rest of the world). Worse, around 10-30% of the crabs don’t survive after bleeding, as the bleeding appears to make the bled animals more lethargic, slower, and less likely to follow the tides the way that their untouched counterparts do.
It turns out that there is a substitute. In 2016, a synthetic alternative to the use of horseshoe crab blood, recombinant factor C (rFC), was approved in Europe, and a handful of US drug companies also began using it, as was described in National Geographic in July in an article about how horseshoe crab blood will be critical to making a COVID-19 vaccine. The article also noted:
But on June 1, 2020, the American Pharmacopeia, which sets the scientific standards for drugs and other products in the U.S., declined to place rFC on equal footing with crab lysate, claiming that its safety is still unproven.
This is, of course, a valid issue from an environmental and ethical perspective. If the recombinant rFC is good enough for Europe, whose drug and medical device regulation is as stringent as that in the US, why isn’t it good enough for the US? In June, the Smithsonian reported:
Now, an influential United States group has abandoned plans to list a synthetic alternative, called recombinant Factor C (rFC), alongside the tried and true blue fluid, reports John Miller for Reuters. The move by medical standards group U.S. Pharmacopeia (USP) would have given rFC equal standing with crab blood, which has long been the industry standard for testing, per Reuters.
The gist of the USP’s rationale is that rFC requires more testing, and that the current crab-derived test has a 30-year track record of safe and effective use, reports the [New York] Times. Many expected the alternative test to be approved for widespread use as it was in Europe by the European Pharmacopeia, per the Times.
For drug makers in the U.S., using the synthetic alternative will require a kind of application designed to demonstrate that the non-standard test is up to snuff—a hurdle that makes companies less likely to abandon the animal-based test, reports Caroline Delbert for Popular Mechanics.
Certainly, it must be far less expensive and labor-intensive to manufacture the necessary component to detect endotoxin using recombinant methods than it is to bleed over a half million horseshoe crabs a year and then isolate the compound from the blood. Worse, as several articles noted, a combination of overharvesting and the bleeding is resulting in a decline in horseshoe crab populations, which are a vital food source for migratory birds and critical to the ocean ecosystem. It is a legitimate question to ask why we’re still isolating this vital compound in such a barbaric manner, but that’s not really what antivaxxers are about here. What they’re about here is spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt about any potential new COVID-19 vaccine that uses the LAL test to verify that it is free of bacteria and endotoxin. It’s about demonization, not education.
Hopefully, Delbert was correct in speculating at the end of her Popular Mechanics article:
Eli Lilly is a huge company with deep pockets, but it’s said outright that the extra and different regulations on rFC are discouraging other companies, per the Guardian. The USP decision is a further obstacle, but the USP has approved alternative testing regimens in the past, like the sterility testing that also affects injectable and biological drugs. If its complaint is a lack of data, then the more people who adopt the synthetic regimen, the more data will accumulate on their side.
And the sooner, the better.
This co-optation of the story of how horseshoe crab blood is used to make a test that can detect minute traces of endotoxin in injectable drugs and using that story to try to convince vegans not to vaccinate is just a variation on a theme of a technique that antivaxxers have been using since long before I started paying attention to these issues. They take a belief system and then find an ingredient or something about vaccines that they can use to try to convince those with that belief system that vaccines are against what they believe. Examples abound, mostly with religious beliefs. For example, antivaxxers have long tried to convince Muslims and Jews that the gelatin derived from pigs that is used in some vaccines makes vaccines irredeemably against their religions, even though Rabbis and Islamic scholars have long pointed out that there is a reasonable exception for vaccines. Indeed, Rabbis and Jewish medical experts actively encourage Jews to be vaccinated, and Islamic legal scholars have rejected the claim that the use of gelatin from “impure animals” is against Islam. Another example of how antivaxxers try to weaponize beliefs against vaccines is their persistent drumbeat of criticism of the use of cell lines derived from human fetuses in the 1960s to grow up stocks of virus to be used in the manufacture of vaccines in order to turn those with religious beliefs against abortion against vaccines, a phenomenon I’ve written about more times than I can remember. It doesn’t matter that vaccines made using these cell lines have saved millions of lives and prevented billions of cases of infectious disease, or that the Catholic Church itself has stated that their use is acceptable. Every year, it seems, antivaxxers find new and more ridiculous ways to try to weaponize antiabortion beliefs against vaccines.
The bottom line is that most antivaxxers are not vegan and that these antivaxxers don’t give a rodent’s posterior about horseshoe crabs. One also wonders whether they know or care about the implications of what they are saying. After all, it’s not just a COVID-19 vaccine that would use the LAL test to check for endotoxin that vegans would have to eschew if they accepted the “logic” of this antivaccine post by the wandering band of scientifically illiterate cranks at AoA. They would have to eschew nearly all IV fluids, injectable medications, implantable devices, and, yes, vaccines, given how widely the LAL test is used. They would, in fact, have to give up a large percentage of modern medicine.
On second thought, maybe antivaxxers do realize the implication of their arguments. Maybe that’s what they want. Or maybe there’s no “maybe” about it.

The efforts of antivaxxers to portray COVID-19 vaccines as harmful or even deadly continue apace…
As more and more COVID-19 vaccines find their way into more and more arms, there are reports of bad things happening to people after vaccination up to and including even death. As I’ve been predicting for a long time that they would, antivaxxers are now weaponizing these reports and anecdotes before they have even been investigated in order to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines and denying the frequency of coincidence.
David Gorski on January 18, 2021
Link

Think of this post as a continuation of a series related to COVID-19 vaccines. You might recall that, right before the holidays last December, I predicted an impending tsunami of adverse events (AEs) falsely attributed to COVID-19 vaccines that would be spread by the antivaccine movement as the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines found their way into more and more arms around the world and more and more bad things happened to people by coincidence soon after COVID-19 vaccination. I won’t take any credit for the prediction coming true, as anyone who’s followed the antivaccine movement for a while could have predicted it (and did). After all, every pre-pandemic antivaccine trope in the book had already been picked up, dusted off, and recycled for use with COVID-19. Examples abound, including the claim that the COVID-19 vaccine renders females infertile, permanently alters your DNA, causes autoimmune disease, or even kills. The only claim, it seems, not yet made by the antivaccine movement about COVID-19 vaccines is that they cause autism, but give them time – the vaccines are not approved for children yet. I fully expect that when young children start receiving the vaccines, antivaxxers will claim they cause autism just as they have for nearly every other vaccine.
To continue the series, I thought I’d survey how antivaxxers are spinning stories about possible adverse events after vaccination against COVID-19, as more and more vaccines are finding their way into more and more arms. As you might expect, antivaxxers are doing everything they can to use such stories to stoke fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the vaccine. Indeed, reading antivaccine social media and listening to antivaxxers about the vaccine rollout, I’m reminded of Bill Murray in Ghostbusters describing what was coming.
First, a brief update on the case I discussed last week.
Doctors, don’t give quotes like this to the press
Last week, I discussed the tragic case of an OB/GYN from Miami who died a little more than two weeks after receiving the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine and whose story went viral as a result of a Facebook post by his widow Heidi Neckelmann. What made the case of Dr. Gregory Michael so dramatic and unusual was that he developed lesions on his skin three days after vaccination and then went on to have a case of immune thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) so severe that it actually killed him. He died of a hemorrhagic stroke 16 days after vaccination.
At the time, I conceded that it is possible that Dr. Michael’s death could be related to the vaccine but also, as always, cautioned that it was impossible to tell from one anecdote whether there was an association between the vaccine and Dr. Gregory’s death. Also, given that there were tens of thousands of people in the phase III clinical trials that tested both the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, even if the vaccine did cause Dr. Michael’s ITP, we can safely conclude that this is a relatively rare issue, given that no signal that the vaccines might cause ITP was observed in the clinical trials. Obviously, the antivaccine movement was nowhere near as…cautious…as I was in my assessment. Predictably, they immediately leapt on the story as “proof” that the vaccine kills.
There isn’t really any new news since last week other than further reactions of the antivaccine movement. I haven’t been able to find any news of the investigations or whether the FDA or Pfizer have yet concluded if there might have been causation. Unfortunately, not all physicians quoted in the press have been as cautious.
In The New York Times last week:
Dr. Jerry L. Spivak, an expert on blood disorders at Johns Hopkins University, who was not involved in Dr. Michael’s care, said that based on Ms. Neckelmann’s description, “I think it is a medical certainty that the vaccine was related.”
“This is going to be very rare,” said Dr. Spivak, an emeritus professor of medicine. But he added, “It happened and it could happen again.”
Predictably, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivaccine group Children’s Health Defense, was all over it in an article entitled, “Johns Hopkins Scientist: ‘A Medical Certainty’ Pfizer Vaccine Caused Death of Florida Doctor“. They even used it to make this deceptive claim:
Redwood also pointed out that ITP has been reported to occur following exposure to drugs containing polyethylene glycol (PEG), a compound used in both the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines.
If you go to the actual study cited by antivaxxer Lynn Redwood, you’ll find that the drug was peg-interferon-alpha2a, in concert with ribavirin and telaprevir antiviral treatment and that Redwood failed to mention that ITP is a known issue with interferon treatment, with the PEG likely having nothing to do with the case of ITP reported.
My compulsion to mention even the little deceptions of antivaxxers aside, let me just say that I think it was highly irresponsible of Dr. Spivak to hand antivaxxers a veritable gift like a quote by him expressing such certainty. The antivax underground is running with it and likely will continue to do so.
The case of Dr. Michael, as tragic as it was, is only the beginning, though.
Does COVID-19 vaccination kill old people?
Regular readers here and anyone who follows me on Twitter knows that I’ve been predicting that, as the vaccines roll out to more and more people, starting with healthcare workers and nursing home residents and the elderly, there will be people who happen to die within a month of getting the vaccine. Sadly, the law of large numbers and the fact that on any given month far more elderly people die than young people make such occurrences inevitable. Look for antivaxxers to spin these coincidences as “definite proof” that the COVID-19 vaccine kills, just the way they’ve done for vaccines and sudden infant death syndrome (which is not caused by vaccines) and for the HPV vaccine and deaths of teenaged girls.
It’s happening now, with a very conscious effort to deny the possibility (likelihood, even, in the case of elderly nursing home patients.) that it is a coincidence that these people died relatively soon after receiving the vaccine. For example, on Twitter antivaccine physician Sherri Tenpenny is all over this story:
23 die in #Norway after receiving #Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine https://t.co/z9dKmB22LB
— Dr Sherri Tenpenny (@BusyDrT) January 16, 2021
However, to discuss this issue I return to RFK Jr.’s antivaccine group to show you an example, hot off the digital “presses” last Friday:
Norway health officials have “adjusted their advice” after reporting that 23 elderly people died shortly after receiving COVID-19 vaccines, according to the Associated Press (AP) and other media outlets.
Some officials told AP they’re “not alarmed” by the deaths and will continue to support the country’s vaccination program, though they will now recommended elderly patients consult their doctors before getting the vaccine.
The Norwegian Medicines Agency has so far assessed only 13 of the 23 reported deaths. All 13 occurred in people 80 or older living in nursing homes, and all were determined to be directly linked to the vaccine, the agency told Norway Today.
The agency didn’t disclose which vaccines were administered to those who died, but according to Bloomberg, the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, approved late last year in Norway, and Moderna’s vaccine, approved earlier this month, are the two being administered in the country.
So, basically Norway has reported the deaths of elderly patients after receiving vaccines. Let’s just say that RFK Jr. is…exaggerating…the certainty in the report by Norway’s health authorities. For example, that AP article cited by RFK Jr. reports the investigation this way:
The Norwegian Medicines Agency on Thursday reported a total of 29 people had suffered side effects, 13 of them fatal. All the deaths occurred among patients in nursing homes and all were over the age of 80.
The agency listed fever and nausea as side effects which “may have led to the deaths of some frail patients,” Sigurd Hortemo of the Norwegian Medicines Agency said in the body’s first report of the side effects.
More than 30,000 people have received the first shot of the Pfizer or Moderna coronavirus vaccine in the Scandinavian country since the end of December, according to official figures.
“We are not alarmed by this. It is quite clear that these vaccines have very little risk, with a small exception for the frailest patients,” Steinar Madsen, medical director with the agency, told Norwegian broadcaster NRK.
So what we are looking at are the oldest and frailest of patients, patients over the age of 80 whose health was so bad that they lived in nursing homes. Now let’s go to the source, an actual press release from Statens Legemiddelverk, or the Norwegian Medicines Agency, dated last Friday and entitled “Covid-19 vaccination associated with adverse drug reactions in elderly people who are frail“.
So let’s take a look a look at what is arguably the most relevant part of the press release:
The reports suggest that common adverse reactions to mRNA vaccines, such as fever and nausea, may have contributed to a fatal outcome in some frail patients, says Sigurd Hortemo, chief physician at the Norwegian Medicines Agency.
The large studies on Comirnaty (BioNTec/Pfizer) did not include patients with unstable or acute illness – and included few participants over 85 years of age. In Norway we are now vaccinating the elderly and people in nursing homes with serious underlying diseases, therefore it is expected that deaths close to the time vaccination may occur. In Norway, an average of 400 people die each week in nursing homes and long-term care facilities.
All deaths that occur within the first few days of vaccination are carefully assessed. We cannot rule out that adverse reactions to the vaccine occurring within the first days following vaccination (such as fever and nausea) may contribute to more serious course and fatal outcome in patients with severe underlying disease.
The Norwegian Medicines Agency and the National Institute of Public Health jointly assess all reports of suspected adverse reactions. As a result, the Norwegian Institute of Public Health has updated the covid-19 vaccination guide with more detailed advice on vaccinating the elderly who are frail.
So, to boil it down, these were frail, elderly residents of nursing homes. These are exactly the sort of patients who, as the medical cliché goes, can’t take a joke, meaning that insults that younger healthier patients would brush off with little effort can lead to the deaths of elderly patients. Basically, because of the careful effort to monitor for any signal of adverse events or harm from the new COVID-19 vaccines, the Norwegian Medicines Agency investigated and had to admit that they couldn’t rule out that the vaccines might have contributed to the deaths of these patients.
That being said, the fundamental problem remains. 400 of these elderly patients die every week in Norway because they are old, frail, and have multiple medical conditions. Layer on top of that a mass vaccination program, and it is a virtual certainty that some of these deaths will occur within close temporal proximity to vaccination, say less than a month—or even less than a week.
Then, if you go to the report itself [PDF]:
    • Patients in nursing homes represents a very frail group of elderly, and most of the patients have severe underlying diseases.
    • In Norway we have a “reporting culture” for vaccines ADRs where the normal procedure is to report all suspected adverse reactions for new vaccines. Healthcare professionals have a low threshold for reporting possible adverse reactions, even when the causal relationships appears very unclear.
    • The preferred and most used route of reporting is directly to the health authorities, not via the Marketing Authorisation Holders.
    • The Norwegian ADR registry is a national health registry, obliged to report statistics to the public.
    • At the highest political level the public has been promised full transparency of the reported ADRs of the covid-19 vaccines. The Norwegian Medicines Agency will publish weekly reports.
In other words, the Norwegian Medicines Agency is bending over backwards to be transparent and has a long history of encouraging the reporting of possible adverse events after vaccination even before the pandemic. Nothing new is happening, except that the Agency is adjusting its recommendations for mRNA COVID-19 vaccinations to take these observations into account, in what is an apparent abundance of caution:
It is the attending physician who, after an overall assessment and in consultation with the patient and any relatives, must decide whether the individual patient should be advised to take the vaccine.
Two factors must be included in this assessment. One is what life prospects the patient has, as many in nursing homes have short life prospects. The second is that for some of the most frail elderly, common side effects after vaccination – such as fever, malaise and poor appetite, can trigger a more serious course of the disease.
For the vast majority of people who are elderly and living with frailty, any side effects of the vaccine will more than be offset by a reduced risk of becoming seriously ill from covid-19. For those with the most serious frailty, however, even relatively mild vaccine side effects can have serious consequences. For those who have a very short remaining life, the benefit of the vaccine may be marginal or irrelevant. Therefore, for very frail patients (eg equivalent to Clinical Frailty Scale 8 or higher) and terminally ill patients, a careful weighing of benefit versus disadvantage of vaccination is recommended.
Again, we’re talking about the frailest and most fragile of patients here, the patients who “can’t take a joke”. They’re the ones for whom even mild expected side effects can be serious or deadly. In particular, it is useful to note, as Dr. Vincent Iannelli points out, that the Norwegian Medicines Agency has not reported more deaths than expected in the nursing home population since its COVID-19 vaccination campaign began, nor is Norway saying not to vaccinate the elderly. Rather, what it is saying is that the benefits of the vaccine in terms of not getting COVID-19 far outweigh the side effects for the vast majority of people, elderly people included, but that it might be wiser to forgo the vaccine in the cases of the very oldest and sickest patients and the terminally ill for whom even mild symptoms (such as side effects from a vaccine) can trigger a cascade of complications.
Particularly amusing is how antivaxxers are portraying a change in guidance for mRNA COVID-19 vaccination to give the attending physician more leeway and autonomy as something damning. After all, don’t they always champion “physician autonomy” when it comes to antivaccine doctors and their failure to vaccinate their patients? You know, if I didn’t know better, I’d think that it’s almost as though they aren’t operating in good faith. (Yes, that’s sarcasm.)
The bottom line is that the report of deaths after COVID-19 vaccination in elderly nursing home patients in Norway does not mean that the vaccine caused the deaths, although it is possible that symptoms from the vaccine might have contributed. Out of an abundance of transparency the Norwegian Medicines Agency made these reports public, and out of an abundance of caution it adjusted its recommendations for the vaccination of elderly nursing home patients. From a scientific and public health standpoint, this is a good thing, but no good deed goes unpunishe because, as I predicted that they would, antivaxxers are jumping all over these reports.
Denying coincidence
I’ve explained before how, to evaluate any claims of adverse events after vaccination, you have to understand what the background rate of that health issue is. If the background rate is high, then the likelihood of coincidence, in which that adverse event happens within a short time after vaccination by random chance alone even though it is not related to vaccination, is much higher. As an example, when discussing the issue of whether Bell’s palsy is related to COVID-19 vaccination, I brought up a calculation done on The Logic of Science demonstrating that, by random chance alone with vaccination being unrelated to autism, we would expect parents to notice the first signs of autism in 154 children within 24 hours of vaccination; 1,079 within a week, and 4,623 within 30 days. Careful epidemiology taking the background rate of autism diagnoses into account showed clearly that vaccines do not increase the risk of autism. The same sort of investigations will be required for COVID-19 vaccines to differentiate coincidence from true correlation and possible causation.
None of that stops antivaxxers, though. Again, on RFK Jr.’s website, there’s a post by him entitled “Death by Coincidence?” It is a lawyerly (of course) discussion trying to deny that such coincidence is common or even happens at all. He starts out by discussing the cases I just discussed of deaths among nursing home patients in Norway, scoffing:
These simple declarations — that deaths and injuries following vaccination are unrelated coincidences — are becoming a pattern.
Note the implication of nefarious intent on the part of public health officials, the FDA, physicians, and scientists. To RFK Jr., this is not scientific caution and recognition that coincidence is common when a common event (such as heart attacks in elderly patients) combines with a mass vaccination campaign. The law of large numbers guarantees that there a common event will happen after another common event by random chance alone a lot more frequently than the average person understands. (Another example that I like to use is being killed in a car crash, which is obviously not vaccine-related but shows up as an adverse event in many clinical trials because fatal car crashes are depressingly common.) Naturally, RFK Jr., in his effort to demonize COVID-19 vaccines, cannot accept that coincidence even happens at all—at least not with respect to anything bad happening to a person after vaccination.
That tactic is why RFK Jr. then sarcastically launches into a litany of anecdotes, including repeating the sad story of Dr. Michael’s death before listing reported deaths after COVID-19 vaccination occurring in Israel, Portugal, Switzerland, and Sweden. Of note, all of these patients, save one, a 41-year-old Portuguese nurse, were elderly, and ranged in age from 75-91. (Again, remember my prediction that, as COVID-19 vaccines were administered to millions of people over the age of 65, there would be reports of death simply because the elderly die at a much higher frequency during any given period of time than they young.) If you look at all the links, you’ll also soon see that the elderly people reportedly died of heart attacks, one of the most common causes of death in the elderly. All were already ill, and the 91-year-old Swiss man’s case was apparently publicized by a “coronavirus-skeptic doctor”, while in Israel one of the dead had had previous heart attacks. The 41 year old woman in Portugal was found dead two days after vaccination, and the government reported that an autopsy didn’t find any evidence of a link to the vaccine, although the Portuguese Ministry of Justice refused to divulge the cause of death, citing “secrecy of justice.” I wondered why the Ministry of Justice is involved, rather than the Ministry of Health; so I looked further. It turns out that the father insisted on an investigation because before her death she had been otherwise healthy.
Unsurprisingly, RFK Jr. then accuses the health establishment:
The routine of reflexively dismissing suspicious deaths and injuries as unrelated to vaccination not only calls into doubt the official data tallies on vaccine injuries, it also contrasts markedly with the habit among public health officials of authoritatively attributing every death to COVID-19 so long as the deceased tested positive for COVID within 60 days of death using a PCR test notorious for producing false positives.
In fact, the $48 billion COVID vaccine enterprise shares three defining features with every new vaccine introduced since 1986:
     1.  Systematic exaggeration of risk from the target disease. (Pharma calls this project “Disease Branding.”)
     2.  Systematic exaggeration of vaccine efficacy.
     3.  Systematically downplaying vaccine risks.
This is a case of what I like to call “reverse projection”, a favored tactic of cranks in which they accuse scientists refuting their misinformation of the opposite deceptions in which they engage. Indeed, the tactics of the antivaccine movement are exactly the opposite exaggerations RFK is accusing provaccine advocates of:
     1.  Systematic downplaying and outright denial of risk from infectious diseases vaccinated against.
     2.  Systematic downplaying and outright denial of vaccine efficacy.
     3.  Systematic exaggeration of vaccine risks (and making false claims of risks from vaccination that have not been proven or have even been disproven, such as claims that COVID-19 vaccines “reprogram your DNA” or cause female infertility).
Meanwhile, RFK Jr. claims conspiracy to hide deaths:
We don’t know the true risk of death from the vaccine since regulators have rendered virtually every death invisible by attributing them all to coincidence.
And:
But researchers are unlikely to see all of the safety signals if a badly designed surveillance system allows local health officials and company employees the discretion to dismiss any serious injury as unrelated.
This will be the tactic of antivaxxers going forward: Blame every death or bad thing that happens after vaccination against COVID-19 on the vaccine, whether that bad thing was likely to have been caused by the vaccine or not, and then dismiss the careful, rational, scientific statements of caution or, in obvious cases, statements about the low likelihood that the death or adverse event was related to the vaccine, as a “cover-up,” while mocking any claim that the bad thing might have happened by coincidence. This is both an unintentional and intentional tactic. It’s unintentional in that antivaxxers do have the mindset of denying coincidence when it comes to anything bad happening after a vaccine. If something bad happens after vaccination, to them it is always the vaccine’s fault. Always. It’s intentional in that lawyers like RFK Jr. know that humans are pattern-seeking animals and that they are very quick to believe that a bad thing that happens after vaccination must have been due to the vaccination. The post hoc ergo propter hoc logical fallacy is hardwired into our brains and takes an effort (and skepticism) to overcome. Antivaxxers take advantage of the fact that most humans think coincidence is very uncommon when it comes to bad things happening after vaccination. It isn’t. It’s common, which is what makes the epidemiology of determining whether a given vaccine increases the risk of a given adverse event or whether the adverse event seen after vaccination is due to coincidence, much more difficult.
I expect to see a lot more of this coming from antivaxxers this year, as millions upon millions of people receive the vaccine. In reality, given the millions of doses of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines already administered all over the world, the number of serious adverse events reported has thus far been quite small. You wouldn’t know it, though, from the story that RFK Jr. and his fellow antivaxxers are selling.

The efforts of antivaxxers to portray COVID-19 vaccines as harmful or even deadly continue apace (VAERS edition)
With the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines continuing apace, so are the efforts of antivaxxers to portray the vaccines as dangerous. This time around, they’ve resurrected the old antivaccine trick of deceptively misusing the VAERS database to imply causation from VAERS reports. That’s not how VAERS works, however.
David Gorski on February 1, 2021
Link

With the rollout of safe and effective vaccines against COVID-19 finally starting to result in tens of millions of people receiving the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines, with newer vaccines likely to be introduced in the coming months, the predictions that I (and many others) made months ago are coming to pass. I’m referring, of course, to antivaxxers resurrecting old antivaccine tropes, dusting them off, and updating them for the age of COVID. Examples abound, including antivaxxers claiming that COVID-19 vaccines cause female infertility, “reprogram your DNA“, are unnecessary because COVID-19 is not deadly, and even kill, particularly the elderly. Similarly, as expected, antivaxxers point to anecdotes of bad things happening to people after receiving the vaccine that are almost certainly coincidences and not related to the vaccine and are weaponizing them to spread fear. Certainly, it doesn’t help that there is at least one person who proclaims himself so very, very, very pro-vaccine is out there pointing to anecdotes to support his pet hypothesis that it’s dangerous to vaccinate people who have pre-existing COVID-19 antibodies. So I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised that antivaxxers are now weaponizing the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database to try to blame all manner of adverse events on vaccines, whether there is evidence of causation or not.
It should therefore be no surprise that antivaxxers are now using VAERS to try to portray COVID-19 vaccines as harmful or even deadly. Consider this part 2 of my post from two weeks ago, the VAERS edition. Unsurprisingly, it’s one of the usual suspects responsible, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. (RFK Jr.), in the form of a post in his antivaccine publication The Defender entitled “329 Deaths + 9,516 Other Injuries Reported Following COVID Vaccine, Latest CDC Data Show“. As I will show, antivaxxers are playing an old game with new vaccines.
VAERS and the antivaccine movement: A brief history
Those of you who’ve been reading this blog and my not-so-super-secret other blog should be familiar with VAERS, as it’s been discussed many times on both. Basically, VAERS is a passive reporting system, in which anyone can report suspected adverse events after any vaccination to be recorded in the database. Given that anyone can report any suspected adverse event, VAERS is intended to be an early warning system. Unfortunately, it is that very open nature of the system that has allowed it to be used and abused by antivaxxers to promote their false claims that vaccines cause so many adverse events and medical conditions.
Indeed, antivaxxers have long loved to portray VAERS as the be-all and end-all of the databases monitoring vaccine safety. The reason, to reiterate, is that VAERS is unique among US vaccine safety reporting systems in that it is a passive surveillance system. It relies on people to submit reports of adverse reactions to vaccines; it doesn’t actively look for them, as active surveillance systems do. Moreover, anyone can submit a report to VAERS, and they do, including parents of autistic children seeking compensation for their children’s autism as being due to “vaccine injury”. Indeed, I long ago discussed how lawyers have long gamed VAERS to support their litigation, reporting lots of cases of autism as supposedly an “adverse reaction” to vaccines. It’s not just vaccines and autism, either. The easily-abused nature of VAERS data is one huge reason why those of us who’ve been following the antivaccine movement a long time like to refer to the bad “scientific studies” published by antivaccine physicians and scientists that use VAERS as their data source as “dumpster diving“. Examples abound, including a study claiming to find a link between the H1N1 vaccine and miscarriages or one of the earliest examples that I ever encountered, Mark and David Geier’s epically bad study trying to link thimerosal-containing vaccines to autism. As an amusing aside, whenever I discuss VAERS, I like to recount the tale of how in 2006 Jim Laidler infamously reported to VAERS that the flu vaccine had turned him into The Incredible Hulk and VAERS accepted the report. True, someone did contact him to question it. If Laidler hadn’t been honest, he could have insisted that the report remain, and it would have.
You might wonder: Why would anyone set up a system like VAERS, which is co-managed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)? First, you must understand that, as I alluded to above, VAERS isn’t intended to give an accurate estimate of the frequency of various adverse events after vaccination. Rather, it was always intended to serve as an early warning system, a “canary in the coalmine”, so to speak. Consequently, even though antivaxxers like to harp on how passive surveillance systems generally capture only a small fraction of adverse reactions, one thing VAERS does do is capture severe reactions. Practically no one is going to report an adverse reaction like a sore arm or transient fever to VAERS, but you know damned well they’ll report more serious ones, such as a seizure. The problem is that the natural human tendency to seek patterns, coupled with the way antivaccine lawyers game VAERS by having their clients report all sorts of spurious “adverse events” to the database after vaccination, means that VAERS is a very noisy, distorted, and unreliable database.
Even VAERS cautions people about how to interpret its data:
When evaluating data from VAERS, it is important to note that for any reported event, no cause-and-effect relationship has been established. Reports of all possible associations between vaccines and adverse events (possible side effects) are filed in VAERS. Therefore, VAERS collects data on any adverse event following vaccination, be it coincidental or truly caused by a vaccine. The report of an adverse event to VAERS is not documentation that a vaccine caused the event.
And:
A report to VAERS generally does not prove that the identified vaccine(s) caused the adverse event described. It only confirms that the reported event occurred sometime after vaccine was given. No proof that the event was caused by the vaccine is required in order for VAERS to accept the report. VAERS accepts all reports without judging whether the event was caused by the vaccine.
Still, its limitations aside, VAERS has its place if you understand its intended purpose. That purpose, contrary to what antivaxxers would have you believe, is not as the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety surveillance. It is primarily a hypothesis-generating, not hypothesis-testing, system when it comes to questions related to vaccine safety. To test the correlations found in VAERS requires different systems, systems such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) or others, which are active safety monitoring databases in which investigators actively scan real medical records and insurance claims data to seek increases in frequencies of adverse events after vaccination and try to determine if there is a real association. So how are antivaxxers weaponizing VAERS? If you’ve been reading this blog a while, you can probably guess. Basically, in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, everything old is new again, and antivaxxers have used the same old playbook to misuse VAERS reports in the age of COVID-19.
RFK Jr. dumpster dives in VAERS
So let’s get back to RFK Jr. and his deceptive article by the “Children’s Health Defense Team”. That is, of course, the generic author that RFK Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense gives to articles in The Defender that could include almost anyone on the team, all of whom are antivaccine to the core and the vast majority of whom are not scientists. If you look at the CHD scientific advisory board, you’ll soon see that it’s a who’s-who of antivaccine cranks, including Richard Deth (what a blast from the past!) and Nobel Prize winner turned homeopathy believer, antivaxxer, autism quack, and now COVID-19 crank, Luc Montagnier. Whoever wrote this article is clearly not an expert, and this article is clearly meant to be disinformation, not science. Here’s what I mean:
As of Jan. 22, 329 deaths — a subset of 9,845 total adverse events — had been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) following COVID-19 vaccinations. VAERS is the primary mechanism for reporting adverse vaccine reactions in the U.S. Reports submitted to VAERS require further investigation before confirmation can be made that an adverse event was linked to a vaccine.
The reports, filed on the VAERS website between Dec. 14, 2020 and Jan. 22, describe outcomes ranging from “foaming at the mouth” to “massive heart attacks” to “did not recover.”
First, one should note how CHD does note that a VAERS entry does not demonstrate causation. Of course, that disclaimer is included, so that RFK Jr. and his merry band of antivax ideologues can claim to have been literally honest while following up their recounting of VAERS numbers with all sorts of statements implying that vaccines were causative for the adverse events listed before.
Of course, whenever you see these sorts of numbers, two questions should come straight to you mind right away. The first is: What’s the denominator? The second is: What is the baseline rate for such adverse events in the population studied?
First, the denominator, which CHD provides without using it appropriately:
According to the Washington Post, as of Jan. 29, 22 million people in the U.S. had received one or both doses of a COVID vaccine. So far, only the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines have been granted Emergency Use Authorization in the U.S. by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). By the FDA’s own definition, the vaccines are still considered experimental until fully licensed.
Noting further:
According to the VAERS data, of the 329 reported deaths, 285 were from the U.S., and 44 were from other countries. The average age of those who died was 76.5.
Later in the article, CHD starts listing all the anecdotes and other reports that antivaxxers have been flogging. The “Team” mentions Dr. Gregory Michaels and his death from immune thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP), which has not been shown to be related to the COVID-19 vaccine. They mention Dr. Jerry Spivak’s irresponsible quote in which he said that the thought “it is a medical certainty that the vaccine was related”. Then they invoke the “deaths in nursing homes in Norway” gambit. Never mind that, as I discussed, there was no evidence that these deaths, all of which were among very elderly nursing home residents, were caused by the vaccine and there was no evidence of an increase in the baseline mortality rate of nursing home residents in Norway, which averages around 400 per week.
The article then regurgitates RFK Jr.’s quote that he used to deny coincidence:
“Coincidence is turning out to be quite lethal to COVID vaccine recipients,” said Children’s Health Defense (CHD) Chairman Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. “If the clinical trials are good predictors, the rate of coincidence is likely to increase dramatically after the second shot.”
More on that last point in a moment.
First, let’s get back to the question of the denominator. What’s 285 divided by 22 million? (I realize that that 22 million figure includes an additional week of vaccinations and does not break down how many people had received one or both doses, but this is a “back-of-the-envelope”) calculation. The answer is 0.000015. That’s 1.3/100,000. The true number is likely slightly higher, given that the denominator includes one additional week of vaccinations administered compared to the VAERS figures, which only go until January 22, but, again, this is a back-of-the-envelope calculation, in which the orders of magnitude matter more than the precise figure.
This brings us to the second question: What’s the baseline rate?
Thanks to Dear Pandemic, who did similar “back-of-the-envelope” calculations, as did Mark Hoofnagle on Twitter, we can make a reasonable estimate for Norway:
What does that mean? Sadly, those over 80, especially those already frail enough to be a nursing home, already have high BASELINE mortality. A certain number of 80+ year old’s die every day. In “normal” times Norway typically sees 45 deaths among nursing residents each week.
More generally: The chance of dying in an average week for those over 80 is about 0.2%– or 1 in 500. Thus, if you vaccinated 40,000 80+ year old’s, you would expect about 80 deaths out of that group within one week *just by coincidence*. So even though 23 people dying shortly after a vaccine sounds scary, it’s not above what is expected.
This may sound similar to another argument that many COVID-19 deaths in older adults are deaths that would have happened anyway. This is true, and EXACTLY why scientists prefer to measure “EXCESS MORTALITY” to assess the true toll of the pandemic—which counts how many deaths from any cause there have been ABOVE AND BEYOND what is expected.
Spoiler alert: Excess mortality during the pandemic has been VERY high.
But that’s Norway. What about the US and VAERS? Here’s Seth Trueger:
how many Americans typically die per day? in 2019, about 2.85 million Americans dies, for an annual rate of 869.7 per 100k, or 2.38 per 100k per day
from @CDCgov WONDER:https://t.co/GYD3eRpJAE
— Seth Trueger (@MDaware) January 30, 2021
So, roughly the baseline death rate is roughly 2.4/100,000 per day. Again, these are “back-of-the-envelope” calculations, but they’re close enough to make the point. What has been reported to VAERS is less than the expected baseline death rate in the US for any given day pre-pandemic (the death figures used were for the year 2019). The time period for the VAERS report runs from December 14, 2020 (the first day COVID-19 vaccines were generally available) to January 22, 2021. That’s 40 days, if you count December 14, 2020. so we’d expect 96/100,000 deaths during that period.
Now, add this to the mix, for comparison:
how many people are dying of COVID in the US per day?
it varies but in the past 4 weeks, about 0.9-1 per 100k *per day* pic.twitter.com/NVz2MXmFIx
— Seth Trueger (@MDaware) January 30, 2021
Now let’s bring Mark Hoofnagle into it:
The bottom line is that 285 deaths after COVID-19 vaccination reported to VAERS in a timeframe of 40 days is actually a very small number. Based on the law of large numbers, in which very small percentages translate into a large number of actual cases or people, we would expect a lot more deaths within a couple of weeks after vaccination by random chance alone. Indeed, even if, as is estimated, only 10% of actual deaths after vaccination were reported to VAERS (which is the commonly listed level of underreporting for passive surveillance systems so frequently harped on by antivaxxers themselves, including RFK Jr.), that would still be roughly in the range of what we would expect to observe due to random chance alone (i.e., coincidence).
Of course, in this article, RFK Jr. claims that it’s not just 10% of adverse reactions that are reported to VAERS but rather that only 1% of adverse reactions after vaccination are ever reported to VAERS:
The clinical trials suggested that almost all the benefits of COVID vaccination and the vast majority of injuries were associated with the second dose.
While the VAERS database numbers are sobering, according to a U.S. Department of Health and Human Services study, the actual number of adverse events is likely significantly higher. VAERS is a passive surveillance system that relies on the willingness of individuals and professionals to submit reports voluntarily.
In December, CHD and Kennedy wrote to former FDA director, Dr. David Kessler, co-chair of the COVID-19 Advisory Board and President Biden’s version of Operation Warp Speed. Kennedy told Kessler that VAERS has been an abject failure, with fewer than 1% of adverse events ever reported.
It might be true that such a small percentage of adverse events is reported for self-limited minor events, such as sore arms, fever, nausea, and the like. But death? Does anyone think that deaths after COVID-19 vaccination are going to be underreported by a factor of 100? Deaths definitely get one’s attention and are far more likely to be reported than any other AE. As is stated on the VAERS website:
“Underreporting” is one of the main limitations of passive surveillance systems, including VAERS. The term, underreporting refers to the fact that VAERS receives reports for only a small fraction of actual adverse events. The degree of underreporting varies widely. As an example, a great many of the millions of vaccinations administered each year by injection cause soreness, but relatively few of these episodes lead to a VAERS report. Physicians and patients understand that minor side effects of vaccinations often include this kind of discomfort, as well as low fevers. On the other hand, more serious and unexpected medical events are probably more likely to be reported than minor ones, especially when they occur soon after vaccination, even if they may be coincidental and related to other causes.
In the case of COVID-19 vaccines, as those who have gotten them know, everyone who gets a COVID-19 vaccine is given a form to use to sign up for the VSafe after vaccination health checker. This is a system that sends regular text messages to those who’ve been vaccinated to ask them about side effects and in general how they feel. Links to VAERS are included. This, of course, is intended to increase reporting of adverse events to VAERS.
Unsurprisingly, RFK Jr. and CHD are full of…well, a brown stinky substance. As Dr. Vincent Iannelli points out:
Still, although reports to VAERS are underreported, they are almost certainly not underreported by as much as some folks believe.
Have you heard the claim that only 1% of serious vaccine reactions are reported to VAERS?
That’s not true.
That claim is based on an old study about drug reactions and was not specific to vaccines.
We also know that underreporting is less common for more severe adverse reactions than for those that are more mild. For example, one study found that up to 68% of cases of vaccine-associated poliomyelitis (a table injury) were reported to VAERS, while less than 1% of episodes of rash following the MMR vaccine were reported.
That’s not to say that only severe or serious adverse reactions should be reported.
But since VAERS watches “for unexpected or unusual patterns in adverse event reports,” it still works even if each and every side effect isn’t reported.
Basically, the “1% gambit” with respect to what percentage of adverse reactions are reported to VAERS has entered the realm of antivax talking points, as RFK Jr.’s article demonstrates. As with all antivax talking points, it’s meant to deceive.
As for that last part about VAERS having been an “abject failure,” to support that claim RFK Jr. cites this:
A critic familiar with VAERS’ shortcomings bluntly condemned VAERS in The BMJ as “nothing more than window dressing, and a part of U.S. authorities’ systematic effort to reassure/deceive us about vaccine safety.”
Unsurprisingly, RFK Jr. fails to mention that the BMJ “article” to which he refers is a BMJ Rapid Response, which is basically a comment section that is not peer-reviewed that cranks love to use to post their ramblings and then cite them as though they were legitimate articles in The BMJ. In this case, a retired pediatrician named Allan Cunningham rattled off a whole lot of antivaccine tropes about vaccines and autism and cites antivaccine-sympathetic BMJ editor Peter Doshi. In fact, the original article is by Peter Doshi and represents him falling for an antivaccine conspiracy theory that somehow VAERS was being made inaccessible to suppress reports. No, seriously, look at the stupidity on display here:
For over three weeks, the website of the US government Vaccination Adverse Reporting System (VAERS) has been inaccessible to most users. The website address, www.vaers.hhs.gov, is printed on the vaccine information statements (VISs), short documents listing the benefits and risks of vaccines that are required by law to be distributed with every vaccine dose administered in the US.1
But the website link leads anybody using the web browsers Chrome, Firefox, and some versions of Internet Explorer to a warning page. “Your connection is not private,” it says in large font on my screen (fig 1⇓). “Attackers might be trying to steal your information from www.vaers.hhs.gov (for example, passwords, messages, or credit cards).” The only browser that seems to consistently connect properly is Safari, used by only around a quarter of people accessing …
As Skeptical Raptor notes, it was due to a certificate error:
The problem is the SSL certificate was generated for vaers.hhs.gov but he is going to http://www.vaers.hhs.gov.
Because of this mismatch, the browser is rejecting it. HHS needs a certificate that covers both vaers.hhs.gov and http://www.vaers.hhs.gov. It is indeed a misconfiguration but it’s relatively minor.
The government is making a sincere effort to make sure their web sites are more secure, but sometimes they mess up…SSL certificates facilitate encryption of traffic between the user and web site. They also allow users to verify that they are connected to the real web site, rather than a hacker’s web site. The mismatch is causing the browser to think that the user is not going to the genuine site.
That one earned a much belated Godzilla facepalm:

Everything old is new again
One observation that I’ve made about how antivaxxers have joined the COVID-19 cranks and conspiracy theorists and started casting doubt on COVID-19 vaccines is that everything old is new again. The sorts of tactics antivaxxers are using now have surprised and befuddled a lot of pro-science advocates, mainly because so many of them have not been paying attention to the antivaccine movement, in particular its longstanding tactics and its basis in conspiracy theories. They also don’t understand how the antivaccine movement has always been about more than just vaccines. It’s basically against public health and any collective action to protect public health.
That’s why I’m going to take this opportunity to point out how, contrary to how one eminent academic oncologist like to put it, refuting antivaccine disinformation is anything but LeBron James “dunking on a 7′ hoop”. It’s a specific skill that requires deep knowledge of conspiracy theories and the specific tactic and tropes used by science denialists and conspiracy theorists like antivaxxers, coupled with a deep understanding of the scientific literature on vaccines. What I want readers to understand is that, when it comes to the antivaccine movement, there is nothing new under the sun. The misuse of VAERS to demonize COVID-19 vaccines is just another example of how old antivaccine tactics and tropes have been resurrected, dressed up, and updated to be deployed against COVID-19 vaccines.
The only old antivaccine lie or distortion that I haven’t seen used against COVID-19 vaccines yet is the claim that they cause autism or sudden infant death syndrome. I fully expect that, just as soon as a COVID-19 vaccine is approved for use in children, antivaxxers will start claiming that the vaccine causes autism and SIDS.
Then, with respect to antivaccine disinformation, truly everything old will be new again.

The Anti-Vaxxer Playbook to Destroy Confidence in COVID-19 Vaccines
Major anti-vaccination voices and organizations have coalesced around three key messages to keep people from accepting the COVID-19 vaccine. Their playbook has now been exposed.
Scott Gavura on January 21, 2021
Link
Over a decade ago, I partnered with some colleagues to establish a Facebook group that refuted misinformation about the H1N1 vaccine. It was a challenging, if futile task. At the time, public health agencies had little active engagement on social media. Few seemed to recognize the growing importance of “Web 2.0” (as it was called at the time) as a communications tool that could be used positively, but equally as a vector for spreading fear and sowing doubt. Frustrated with our experience, we made our way on to the agenda of a subsequent public health conference where we described the tactics and tropes of the anti-vaccine movement, and did our best to convince public health professionals to take social media, and the antivaccine movement, seriously. The anti-vaccine movement was highly organized and growing, and public health was not.
Looking at all that work in hindsight, it’s remarkable but also entirely predictable that we are in our current situation. But what I didn’t realize back in 2009 was how much social media companies stood to gain from the anti-vaccine movement. In January 2021 we are in the midst of a deadly pandemic that has already killed millions, and continues to kill thousands daily. Despite hospital intensive care units that are at capacity, there is ongoing disease denial and deliberate minimization of the harms of COVID-19 infections. There is limited but strident opposition to basic, simple public health measures, like distancing and masks. And despite newly-developed vaccines showing high rates of efficacy and good safety profiles, there is considerable and widespread vaccine hesitancy.
The Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) recently published a report, The Anti-Vaxx Playbook, that describes in detail how key members of the anti-vaccine movement are collaborating and partnering in new ways to exploit the COVID-19 pandemic, create consistent anti-vaccine messaging, and destroy confidence in vaccination. The report is based on observations from the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC)’s conference held online in 2020. Misleadingly titled “Protecting Health and Autonomy in the 21st Century“, this event brought together a long list of anti-vaccine advocates with the apparent goal of helping participants more effectively push back against science, evidence, and public health measures.
The problem
In early 2020 the CCDH put out a report entitled The Anti-Vaxx Industry which examined anti-vaccine social media, noting that 409 different English language anti-vaccine accounts had 58 million followers, with evidence that collectively, followers had grown approximately 19% since 2019. The COVID-19 pandemic has been a booming business opportunity for anti-vaxxers and social media alike. The CCDH named four different sub-communities of anti-vaxxers:
    • Campaigners are full-time, anti-vaccine professionals who may be seen as “experts”. They make a living based on promoting anti-vaccine sentiment and ideas. Their examples include: Informed Consent Action Network (Del Bigtree), Children’s Health Defence (Robert F. Kennedy Jr.), and the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC).
    • Entrepreneurs leverage and amplify vaccine fears to sell content, products and services. Examples include Rashid Buttar, Ty and Charlene Bollinger, David Wolfe, Judy Mikovits, and the biggest, Joseph Mercola.
    • Conspiracists focus on vaccines from a conspiracy angle, but vaccines are not their full-time focus. They may also be entrepreneurs. Examples they listed include Brian Rose, David Icke, and Patrick Bet-David.
    • Communities are groups that share anti-vaccine ideas and stories, usually in Facebook Groups. Examples include “Stop Mandatory Vaccination”, “Vaccine Re-education Discussion Forum”, “Vaccine Choices”, and many more hidden, private groups.
Certainly there is some overlap in these categories, and while I might quibble with their classifications, it’s worth acknowledging that anti-vaccine sentiment and rhetoric can be driven by a variety of motivations. While Facebook and other providers took some steps to address anti-vaccine sentiment after measles outbreaks in the US, the measures were largely ineffective in preventing its continued growth on the platforms. For example, Robert F. Kennedy Jr, who has touted COVID-related conspiracies since the beginning of the pandemic, has seen his Instagram following rise from 121,000 at the beginning of the pandemic to 792,000 today. He is just one example of the number of anti-vaccine advocates who have seen large increases in audience and reach. This type of growth is continuing largely unabated, probably because the CCDH has estimated that the anti-vaccine movement could be generating up to $1 billion in advertising revenue across the different platforms. Facilitating and spreading vaccine misinformation is highly profitable.
The master narrative
Despite the disparate group of individuals that are driving anti-vaccine sentiment, messaging has consolidated around a few key messages. NVIC’s virtual conference in October 2020 was accessible to anyone that registered, and CCDH attended. Prominent speakers included Barbara Loe Fisher (NVIC), Joseph Mercola, Del Bigtree, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Sherri Tenpenny, and Andrew Wakefield. CCDH noted that these speakers see COVID-19 as a historic opportunity:
A number of speakers at the NVIC conference presented the Covid pandemic as an historic opportunity to popularise anti-vaccine sentiment. Robert F. Kennedy Jr. told activists listening to the conference “All of the truths that we’ve been trying to broadcast for many, many years. There are people hearing it and the impact and those seeds are landing on very fertile ground.” The disgraced physician Andrew Wakefield echoed these sentiments, saying “The population who are aware of these issues has grown dramatically in the face of coronavirus, Covid-19. It is now an issue for discussion by everyone.” Other anti-vaxxers such as Sherri Tenpenny highlighted the Covid pandemic as an opportunity to build a wider movement with campaigners against masks and lockdowns: “We need everyone to get politically active, get behind this cause, get behind Hugs Over Masks, get behind MAD, Mothers Against Distancing, get behind the NVIC, the National Vaccine Information Center, get behind the things that we’re doing over at vaxxter.com, and Courses for Mastery, and our boot camp course that open enrolment is coming up again, the end of September. All the things that we’re doing, we need all hands on deck. We need everybody to release their fear from their brains, get rid of their masks, go hug people and absolutely say no. Wake up your community.”
There are three key messages identified by the CCDH that are overlapping and common across these different speakers. They are recurrent and you will see them, in some form, in almost all anti-COVID-19-vaccine messaging:
     1.  COVID-19 is not dangerous. Talking points: There are few deaths, and death reports are exaggerated. “It’s just the flu.” “It will just go away on its own.”
     2.  COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous. Talking points: “The vaccines were rushed.” “The vaccines are killing people.” “Natural” immunity is better. Other treatments (e.g., hydroxychloroquine) are safer and better. “Vaccines are toxic.” “Vaccines will change your DNA/destroy your immune system.” etc. etc.
     3.  Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted. Talking points: “It’s politics over health.” “It’s Big Pharma profits over health.” Vaccines are “too big to fail” and manufacturers are “not liable for injuries.” “Bill Gates! Bill Gates! Bill Gates!”
Adapting the Master Narrative
The Master Narrative is easily adaptable to target specific groups. The CCDH lists four, and describes how messaging is being modified to make the messaging more appealing:
Alternative health advocates
    • “COVID-19 is not dangerous” becomes “Alternative health products can prevent or treat COVID-19.” This is simply an extension of what we have documented repeatedly at this blog – the unending array of unproven or ineffective products touted as effective because someone has something to sell.
    • “The COVID-19 vaccine is dangerous” is translated to “Alternative health experts say the vaccine is dangerous.” Another recurrent topic on this blog, where we have documented the efforts of naturopaths, chiropractors, homeopaths and other providers who do not practice based on scientific standards. Some of these practitioners are repeating misinformation and leveraging their perceived credibility as “professionals”.
    • “Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted” becomes “Vaccine advocates suppress alternative health.” This is something that any health professional who advocates for science-based medicine hears all the time. By criticizing unproven or disproven remedies, we are dogmatic, not open to new ideas, and beholden to the pharma-industrial complex.
Conspiracy theorists
    • “COVID-19 is not dangerous” is translated to “COVID is a Scamdemic.” The message becomes: COVID-19 doesn’t exist, or has never been isolated. Or it’s all due to 5G.
    • “The COVID-19 vaccine is dangerous” is translated to “The vaccine is designed to control you or kill you.” Vaccination (this one at least) will apparently usher in some sort of totalitarian society. Microchips in the vaccines (really tiny ones) will track you and cause mind control.
    • “Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted” becomes “COVID is a Plandemic”. The pandemic was all intentional, to create the need for lockdowns and infringements on civil liberties. The vaccine will be used to kill millions as part of “The Great Reset” which will destroy the global economy.
Parents of young children
    • “COVID-19 is not dangerous” is translated to “Children are not at risk from COVID-19.” The rare but real harms to children from COVID-19 are ignored.
    • “The COVID-19 vaccine is dangerous” is translated to “Children could suffer lifelong illness.” Consistent with long-standing anti-vaccine messaging, the COVID-19 vaccine is already being linked, without any evidence, to possible long-term consequences like diabetes, lupus, and auto-immune diseases.
    • “Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted” becomes “Vaccine advocates are targeting children.” While no current COVID-19 vaccines are approved for children and children are not a priority group for vaccination, anti-vaccination advocates are targeting parents who are considering enrolling children in COVID-19 vaccine clinical trials.
Black and other ethnic or marginalized communities
    • “COVID-19 is not dangerous” is translated to “COVID-19 does not affect minorities.” Despite objective evidence to the contrary that has become more and more apparent over time, some anti-vaxxers have claimed that African-Americans are less likely to be infected or harmed by COVID-19.
    • “The COVID-19 vaccine is dangerous” is translated to “Vaccines are unsafe for minorities.” Rhetoric has criticized the poor representation of minorities in clinical trials, including vaccine clinical trials. Others have stated that the vaccine is an explicit attempt to kill minorities.
    • “Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted” becomes “Vaccine advocates are linked to historical and structural racism.” The very real mistreatment and abuse of minorities in medical experiments and clinical trials in the past is being stoked and highlighted to heighten suspicion of the motives of health professionals that advocate for COVID-19 vaccination.
Taking action and countering the master narrative: Don’t spread the virus
In a traditional communications format, like conventional media, it’s generally important to rebut and counter incorrect information, while guarding against being drawn into a false equivalence debate. Social media platforms, however, are driven entirely by algorithms that determine what you see, and are designed not to give you factual information, but to maximize your engagement and time on the platform. The CCDH recommends not engaging with misinformation being spread online, noting that engagement only helps its reach. Social medial with extreme and inflammatory content generate a lot of views, because they generate a lot of reactions. The old blogging maxim DNFTT (Do Not Feed the Troll) still holds.
Rather than responding to anti-vaccine sentiment on social media, the CCDH recommends private messaging and contact, especially when it’s someone you know. Sending a DM, they argue, may limit the spread of misinformation and may lead to better outcomes.
Finally, the CCDH recommends sharing science-based information and pro-vaccine messaging. If you’ve received your COVID-19 vaccine, share it online – like our own David Gorski did on Twitter. They sum it up as follows.
Vaccinating others against anti-vaccine messaging
To prevent the spread of misinformation, one approach is to vaccinate individuals against it. This is consistent with the idea of “pre-bunking” that David Gorski has discussed previously. Science advocates should focus on countering the anti-vaccine “master narrative” whenever possible. Messaging and approaches the CCDH recommends includes:
    • Tell the stories of those who have fallen ill through COVID-19 or from other vaccine-preventable diseases. Highlight how anti-vaccinationists target the parents of children who have been affected by these diseases.
    • Put a human face on the development of the vaccine, highlighting the individuals that helped develop these products. This may help counter conspiracy ideas about the motivation of those scientists.
    • Share clips and posts from recipients of the vaccine. This will reduce anxiety, especially for the early recipients.
    • Expose the anti-vax methods and their own playbook. Show how anti-vaxxers are manipulating messaging and social media. Highlight how grifters are profiting from their anti-vaccination positions. Point out the Master Narrative they are using.
    • Use different platforms: Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Twitter, Facebook: Identify influential message carriers to share pro-vaccine messages.
    • Create spaces for answering questions and addressing concerns: Make credible people accessible on social media to respond to questions.
Conclusion: A failure to act
The COVID-19 pandemic is the public health crisis of this generation. Despite the appearance of a brand new infectious disease – and within months, an effective vaccine, the anti-vaccine movement has built enough strength to potentially threaten our ability to bring this disease under control. These groups are highly organized, social-media savvy, and are coordinating effectively. Public health advocates and agencies are still playing a game of catch up and struggling to use social media effectively after more than a decade. The CCDH Anti-Vaxx Playbook is fascinating reading and highly recommended for anyone that wants to better understand the social media tactics of the anti-vaccine movement and become a more effective science, medicine, and vaccine advocate.

Syncope and Bell’s palsy: Distinguishing correlation from causation for adverse events observed after COVID-19 vaccination
The FDA has approved emergency use authorizations (EUAs) for two COVID-19 vaccines, and the largest mass vaccination program in history has begun. Look for antivaxxers to attribute reactions to the vaccine that the vaccine very likely didn’t cause. We’ll examine the example stories of vasovagal syncope and Bell’s palsy that were reported by the press last week.
David Gorski on December 21, 2020
Link

With emergency use approvals (EUAs) having been granted by the FDA to two mRNA vaccines against COVID-19, one manufactured by Pfizer/BioNTech and the other developed by Moderna, with more likely to follow in the coming months, we are on the cusp of what is likely to be the largest mass vaccination program in history. It’s a program that is likely to take many months to achieve even in wealthy “First World” countries, given the logistics of manufacturing, distributing, and administering vaccines, one of which requires an ultracold storage temperature. As vaccines roll out, first to tens of thousands and then to tens of millions, it is inevitable that there will be adverse reactions attributed to them. The question will then become: Did the vaccine cause the adverse reaction? You can bet that the antivaccine movement and the COVID-19 cranks will blame every adverse health event after administration of any of the COVID-19 vaccines that are just starting to find their way into the arms of frontline healthcare workers and the most vulnerable, and I’m worried that we in the science-based medicine community might not be sufficiently prepared for the tsunami of bad epidemiology that is to come.
What led me to think about this was this story:
A volunteer who signed up for Moderna’s coronavirus vaccine trial was struck by lightning 28 days after receiving the injection. That 72 year-old volunteer, whose name and gender have been withheld, met with the freak accident after getting an actual shot of Moderna’s vaccine, rather than the placedo [sic], during the second phase of the vaccine’s trials.
The bizarre incident was revealed in the US Food and Drug Administration’s written media briefing into the safety of Moderna’s new vaccine. Doctors diagnosed the lightning strike victim with arrhythmia – an irregular heart beat – believed to have been caused by the strike. No further updates have been provided on the volunteer’s condition.
The incident comprised one of three Serious Adverse Effects (SAEs) suffered by study participants who received the real vaccine – with all of those health scares deemed unrelated to the shot itself.
This led to a sarcastic comment that I couldn’t resist Tweeting:
It clearly must be the microchip😏
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) December 17, 2020
Others couldn’t resist, either:
I was hoping I'd at least get free music streaming from the microchip. Struck by lightning seems a bit extreme.
— The Captain (@connieinygk) December 17, 2020
How do we know the vaccine didn’t turn the guy into a lightening rod?
— Kyle Swanson, MD, FAANS (@kiswanson) December 18, 2020
But but but
The microchip attracted that lightning bolt! pic.twitter.com/eJXmmCENlv
— Steve Carroll DO MEd (@embasic) December 16, 2020
A 72yo that SURVIVED getting hit by lightning with just arrhythmia? I think that's a significant result. They should start touting it as PROTECTION from lightning strikes.
— Zarban (@DerekZarban) December 17, 2020
You get the idea.
Obviously, it’s utterly ridiculous to conclude that a vaccine can somehow make its recipient more likely to be the victim of a lighting strike or, to put it in simpler terms, that a vaccine will attract lightning. There’s no plausible scientific mechanism for a vaccine (or even an implanted microchip, if there were one in COVID-19 vaccines) to accomplish this. That’s why I and my fellow advocates of science-based medicine made jokes about it. It’s also why I chose to use this particular example to illustrate that most adverse events (AEs) in large clinical trials of vaccines involving tens of thousands of people are more likely to be coincidence than due to the vaccine. Other examples include people getting hit by cars, which happens in large clinical trials, events that are included in the AEs listed. The key problem in such clinical trials is to differentiate AEs that are likely to be due to the vaccine versus AEs that are not. Of course, antivaxxers either don’t understand this key distinction or willfully ignore it in the service of spreading disinformation, but I can see these sorts of stories doing harm in persuading people to accept COVID-19 vaccines.
What I’m going to do in this post is to look at a couple of AEs being attributed to COVID-19 vaccines and, hopefully, by discussing them, help you understand how to look at them. You know the press will hype them. You know antivaxxers will go wild over them. What I’m hoping to achieve in this post is to provide some of the tools for you to critically examine these claims. I’ll look at two claims and then circle back to review them in the context of determining causality. One occurred during the clinical trials, and one occurred after vaccination after the EUA.
Tiffany Dover and the case of vasovagal syncope
Tiffany Dover is a nurse who was caught on video fainting after having received the COVID-19 vaccine, leading to stories like this, from the ever-sensationalistic New York Post:
This is the scary a moment a nurse who had just received the coronavirus vaccine at a Tennessee hospital told reporters she was feeling dizzy and then fainted.
Nurse manager Tiffany Dover received the Pfizer-BioNTech jab at CHI Memorial Hospital in Chattanooga on Thursday and was giving a press briefing when she began to trail off, according to WTVC-9.
“All of my staff, you know, we are excited to get the vaccine. We are in the COVID unit, so therefore, you know, my team will be getting first chances to get the vaccine,” Dover said.
“And I know that it’s really … Sorry, I’m feeling really dizzy,” she continued.
One of the doctors behind her caught her as she passed out about 17 minutes after receiving the shot.
“It just hit me all of a sudden, I could feel it coming on. I felt a little disoriented, but I feel fine now, and the pain in my arm is gone,” Dover said after recovering.
Doctors said the episode was not related to the ingredients in the vaccine.
And here’s the video:
That story ran on Friday. By Saturday, antivaxxers were claiming that Tiffany Dover was in bad shape (or even dead) and that CHI Memorial Hospital and the CDC were covering it up:
OMFG! FAINTING NURSE DIEDTIFFANY DOVER IS DEADI saw that fainting nurse died, so I checked it out!This death record…
Posted by Kitty Lynn on Saturday, December 19, 2020
And:
I don't believe this.
Why doesn't #TiffanyDover, her family or her hospital respond to her death rumors for real?
Allegedly she was doing fine already shortly after the fainting incident, and she was so eager to be in public with her vaccination – why does she need privacy now? https://t.co/xQvP2nwRfn
— Andrea Gerák (@AndreaGerak) December 19, 2020
And, in case you’re wondering:
So what happened? Anyone in primary care, emergency medicine, or involved in any activity in medicine in which patient blood draws, injections, or vaccinations are involved knows that this was almost certainly nothing more than vasovagal syncope, a very common reaction to needlesticks. This phenomenon is not rare. It’s actually far from rare, so much so that the CDC has a webpage that discusses fainting after vaccination, which usually occurs within 15 minutes and can sometimes even happen before vaccination in response to just the sight of the needle. It’s the reason why people receiving vaccinations are usually observed for 15-30 minutes afterward. As the CDC notes:
Fainting can be triggered by many types of medical procedures. In fact, CDC has received reports of people fainting after nearly all vaccines. Fainting after getting a vaccine is most commonly reported after three vaccines given to adolescents: HPV, MCV4, and Tdap. Because the ingredients of these three vaccines are different, yet fainting is seen with all of them, scientists think that fainting is due to the vaccination process and not to the vaccines themselves. However, there is not yet a definite answer about whether an ingredient of the vaccines is responsible for the fainting or if adolescents are simply more likely than children or adults to experience fainting.
The CDC also has studied the issue before, for example, in this study undertaken because of reports of vasovagal syncope after vaccination with HPV vaccines, in which CDC investigators examined reports from the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). The CDC found:
A total of 463 reports of postvaccination syncope during January 1, 2005–July 31, 2007 (Figure), were identified among persons aged >5 years, compared with 203 reports during 2002–2004. The rate of reports for postvaccination syncope among persons aged >5 years were as follows: 0.30 reports per million doses distributed in 2002, 0.35 per million doses distributed in 2003, 0.28 per million doses distributed in 2004, 0.31 per million doses distributed in 2005, and 0.54 per million doses distributed in 2006.
Compared with reports received during 2002–2004, those received during 2005–2007 were more likely to involve females (61.1% versus 77.5%) or persons aged 11–18 years (47.3% versus 62.0%) (Table). In 292 (63.1%) of the 463 reports during 2005–2007, syncope was associated with at least one of the following recently approved and recommended adolescent vaccines: MCV4, Tdap, and HPV.
Thirty-three (7.1%) of the 463 postvaccination syncope reports during 2005–2007 were coded as serious (Table); the percentage was not substantially different from the corresponding 20 (9.9%) serious reports during the earlier comparison period. After clinical review, seven of the reports coded as serious were excluded because they were either not compatible with the diagnosis of syncope (n = 4) or did not meet the criteria of seriousness (n = 3); 26 reports of serious adverse events were analyzed further. The 26 patients ranged in age from 11 to 84 years (median: 18 years), and 20 (76.9%) were female. Similar to the findings for syncope reports overall, females aged 11–18 years accounted for the largest number of serious syncope reports (n = 11 [42.3%]). Among the 23 patients for whom times of vaccination and syncope onset were indicated, 12 (52.2%) occurred within 5 minutes of vaccination, and 16 (69.6%) occurred within 15 minutes. Ten of the 26 serious reports indicated that secondary injuries occurred after syncope, including head injuries (n = 9) after syncope-related falls and a motor-vehicle incident (n = 1) because the patient lost consciousness while driving. Seven (70.0%) of the 10 secondary injuries occurred within 15 minutes of vaccination.
Meanwhile, it turns out that the video was deceptively edited, leaving out how rapidly Dover recovered and how she explained right after recovering:
After getting the shot, Dover began to feel lightheaded and then passed out, which was shown in the news clip.
Shortly afterward, she explained to the TV reporter, “I have a history of having an overactive vagal response and, so, with that, if I have pain from anything — hang nail or I stub my toe — I can just pass out.”
Dover reported that she was “feeling fine” after her fainting episode. “The pain in my arm is very minimal, actually, but it doesn’t take much,” she said, estimating that she has fainted “six times in the last six weeks.”
The hospital issued a statement the following day quoting Dr. Jesse Tucker saying, “The fainting episode is not an adverse reaction to the vaccine, but related to her medical condition.”
An “overactive vagal response” basically means that nerves controlling heartbeat and blood pressure send the wrong signal — slowing the heart while expanding blood vessels — and blood pools in the legs, so the brain doesn’t get enough oxygen. This response is often triggered by pain and causes a person to faint.
It’s “quite common,” according to a description from Cedars-Sinai, which explained that the condition “most often affects children and young adults, but it can happen at any age.”
Pediatrician Dr. Vincent Iannelli has discussed the issue of fainting after vaccination in depth. He points out that the most common reports are of teens receiving adolescent vaccines, especially girls receiving Gardasil, but that the “CDC has received reports of people fainting after nearly all vaccine..” What amazes me, in fact, is that, a few days after mass vaccination of healthcare workers and nursing home residents and workers, we haven’t seen a whole lot of reports of syncope after COVID-19 vaccination and a lot of examples of healthcare workers being caught on camera fainting.
Pointing to a common phenomenon that generally doesn’t have anything to do with specific vaccines but the needle and the pain, and using it to demonize vaccines, is an old antivaccine trope. It became a particularly common and favorite technique after Gardasil was approved and so many adolescents started getting vaccinated, as syncope after vaccination appears to be more common in that age group by claiming that HPV vaccines cause postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS). Dr. Iannelli has also discussed POTS, quoting the CDC regarding whether HPV vaccination can cause POTS:
POTS is a condition that causes lightheadedness or fainting and a rapid increase in heartbeat upon standing. The cause is unknown, but doctors think POTS may be associated with a number of risk factors and syndromes, including: a recent viral illness, physical deconditioning, chronic fatigue syndrome and nervous system problems.
After citing a number of studies that fail to find evidence of correlation between vaccination and POTS, Dr. Iannelli further notes that the reason there appears to be a correlation between POTS and HPV vaccination that does not indicate causation is probably this:
But why has the focus been on the HPV vaccines?
It is an easy association to notice, after all POTS begins to occur right around when the HPV vaccines are given (teen years) and the HPV vaccines are given in many different countries. Most other vaccines that we give to teens in the United States, including Tdap and the meningococcal vaccines, aren’t as widely used in other countries.
But remember, POTS isn’t a new diagnosis. That anti-vaccine groups are latching onto it to scare parents away from vaccinating and protecting their kids is.
Again, I’m actually pleasantly surprised that there’s only been one high profile example of fainting after COVID-19 vaccination a few days into the vaccine rollout, but I expect to see a lot more of this as the vaccines find their way to more and more people. I also expect to see antivaxxers attempt to link the COVID-19 vaccine to POTS, the way they have with HPV vaccines.
But what about a less obvious example? I started with a ridiculously obvious example of confusing correlation of an AE after COVID-19 vaccination with causation, moved to a more plausible example, and now I’m going to discuss a still more plausible example that might be related to COVID-19 vaccination but, far more likely, is not.
Bell’s palsy and COVID-19 vaccination
Also last week were reports that there was an increased incidence of Bell’s palsy observed in the clinical trials used to gain the EUAs for the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna vaccines. Before I delve into these observations, let’s review what Bell’s palsy is. Bell’s palsy, also known as idiopathic facial paralysis is a type of facial paralysis in which the facial nerve on one side ceases to work correctly, resulting in muscle weakness or paralysis on that side of the face. It’s actually a surprisingly common condition, almost always self-limited, and resolves within a few weeks – but it can be, as you might imagine, quite striking and disturbing. Often, the symptoms of Bell’s palsy arise one or two weeks after an infection, such as a cold, ear infection, or eye infection. Symptoms usually appear fairly abruptly and are characterized by a droopy appearance to one side of the face, as you might see after a stroke. Rarely, Bell’s palsy can affect both sides of the face.
Other symptoms can include:
    • drooling
    • difficulty eating and drinking
    • an inability to make facial expressions, such as smiling or frowning
    • facial weakness
    • muscle twitches in the face
    • dry eye and mouth
    • headache
    • sensitivity to sound
    • irritation of the eye on the involved side
Even though Bell’s palsy is usually self-limited, it is important to distinguish it from other conditions that can cause unilateral facial paralysis, such as a stroke or brain tumor. In any event, the root cause is inflammation and/or compression of the seventh cranial nerve (facial nerve). The exact cause is not known, but in general it’s believed that it’s probably triggered by a viral infection. Some infections that have been associated with Bell’s palsy include:
    • herpes simplex, which causes cold sores and genital herpes
    • HIV/AIDS
    • sarcoidosis, which causes organ inflammation
    • herpes zoster virus, which causes chickenpox and shingles
    • Epstein-Barr virus, which causes mononucleosis
    • Lyme disease
Other risk factors for the condition include pregnancy, diabetes, family history, and lung infections. The treatment is expectant, waiting for the symptoms to resolve, but certain medications can help, including corticosteroids to decrease the inflammation, antiviral medications or antibiotics (if it’s thought that an infection caused the palsy), pain medications, and eye drops to keep the eye on the affected side from drying out because the eyelid can’t be closed all the way. Most affected individuals (75%) will recover within three to six months without treatment.
So now let’s get to the reports:
A 54-page staff report released Tuesday said there were four reported cases of Bell’s palsy among Moderna’s more than 30,000 clinical trial participants. Three of the participants who got Bell’s palsy also received the vaccine instead of a placebo shot. Pfizer’s trial similarly had four reported cases of Bell’s palsy out of some 43,000 participants. All four Bell’s palsy cases in Pfizer’s trial got the vaccine and not the placebo.
And:
Two of the cases of Bell’s palsy among Moderna’s vaccine group have since “resolved” while one was still ongoing at the time of the report, the FDA staff said. The vaccinated participants experienced the paralysis between 22 days and 32 days following inoculation, they said.
Wow! This sounds scary, doesn’t it? Actually, it’s not. How can I say that? Easy. All I have to do is to compare what is observed in the clinical trial with the background incidence of Bell’s palsy in the general population:
In the general population, having nothing to do with Covid-19 nor the Covid-19 vaccine, approximately 40,000 individuals develop Bell’s palsy annually in the United States, or approximately 1 in 10,000. In both groups of vaccine trial participants, the rate (1 in 10,000) was commensurate with the incidence of sudden facial paralysis in the general population.
It should also be noted that the claim that vaccines can cause Bell’s palsy is not new. A couple of years ago, über-quack Dr. Joe Mercola was peddling the myth that vaccines cause Bell’s palsy by citing a study that examined VAERS reports. Dr. Iannelli noted that none of the cases were verified to determine if the Bell’s palsy was real or actually caused by a vaccine. (That is, of course, a general problem with VAERS.) He also noted that there haven’t been any studies that find a convincing link between vaccination and Bell’s palsy other than an inactivated intranasal influenza vaccine that was only used in Switzerland during the 2000-01 flu season, was associated with an increased risk of Bell’s palsy. Other than that, though, there isn’t much of anything.
It’s very, very important when evaluating AEs after vaccination to be aware of the background rate of that particular condition in the general population not receiving the vaccine. In this case, the number of cases observed in the groups receiving the vaccine is actually lower than what we would expect to observe in the general population. What’s actually weird is how few cases were observed in the groups not receiving the vaccine. This indicates that this observed correlation is likely not causative. Obviously, patients need to be followed longer, to see if the incidence over a whole year ends up being worrisome, but at this point it appears unlikely that either the Pfizer/BioNTech or Moderna vaccines cause Bell’s palsy, at least based on the current clinical trials.
This is why the FDA has stated:
Our working hypothesis is this just was an imbalance in background rates like we’ve seen in other trials, but we’ll make sure that we’re going to actually query for that just to bring that question to close
That’s another important point. This observed correlation is not being swept under the rug, contrary to what antivaxxers claim. It’s not being denied. The FDA plans on monitoring the clinical trial recipients for Bell’s palsy and the people receiving the vaccine since the EUA. If there is a real correlation that might indicate causation, it will be found. To that I’d also add that, even if there is a real correlation, a one in ten thousand chance of what is almost always a self-limited condition is a small risk to take for protection against COVID-19, particularly among those who are more susceptible to severe diseases, such as the elderly and those with chronic health conditions.
Vaccines and autism
Let me bring home my message by briefly revisiting the most famous “AE” of all that is attributed to vaccines, autism. As regular readers know, there are many robust, well-designed studies involving a hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of children all over the world carried out using different methodologies that have utterly failed to find even a whiff of a hint of a signal indicating an association between vaccination and autism risk. None of this has ever stopped antivaxxers from invoking the ever-present anecdotes of parents who say their children showed the first signs of autism after vaccination. This is not good evidence. As has been pointed out to antivaxers many times over the years, a number of vaccines are administered during age range when autism symptoms first manifest themselves; so, given the millions of children vaccinated every year, by random chance alone a number of children will manifest their first symptoms of autism in fairly close temporal proximity to vaccination. There’s a lovely graphic over at The Logic of Science that shows a back-of-the-envelope calculation of how many children we would expect to exhibit symptoms of autism after vaccination by random chance alone, noting:
Also noted:
Additionally, we would actually expect the odds of a parent noticing the symptoms of autism to skyrocket shortly after a vaccine is administered. Many parents are very concerned about a vaccine harming their child, and, as a result, they will tend to watch their children very closely after vaccinating them (even if they don’t consciously realize that they are doing so). Thus, they are far more likely to notice an early sign of autism that they might have missed if they hadn’t been watching their children so closely. To give an analogy, after people buy a new car, they often start seeing that model and paint job everywhere, but that model isn’t actually any more abundant than it was before, it’s just that their brains notice it because they are thinking about it (consciously or subconsciously). Even so, you are far more likely to notice an early sign of autism if you are worried about it. So in actuality, my numbers are likely underestimates rather than overestimates.
Indeed. There is a lot of confirmation bias in these anecdotes as well, in which parents remember information that supports their current belief that vaccines caused their child’s autism and forget disconfirming information, particularly subtler symptoms that they might have noticed (or missed) before vaccination that are apparent on videos taken of the child before vaccination. This is human nature. We all do it unconsciously; the only difference between skeptics and everyone else is that we try to compensate for it. Truth be told, we don’t always succeed, because it takes effort to be aware when we’re falling prey to this particular human cognitive issue. That’s why the correct question is not whether there is an association between vaccination and autism, but rather whether there is an association between vaccination and autism that is greater than could be explained by random chance alone. The question has been studied time and time again and shows that there isn’t.
Still, human beings are pattern-seeking animals. This pattern-seeking behavior is not well-suited to a task like evaluating drug safety. Many of us will conclude, after taking a drug or receiving a vaccine, that anything bad that happens soon afterward was likely caused by the drug or the vaccine, even when it is far more likely that it was random chance (i.e., coincidence), and nothing more. Such is the case with vaccines and autism. The ages during which children receive a lot of vaccines just happens to correspond to the ages where parents most frequently first start noticing the signs of autism spectrum disorders. In the case of the rollout of the COVID-19 vaccines, this pattern-seeking behavior will lead many people, particularly those predisposed to believe that COVID-19 is no big deal or that vaccines are harmful and ineffective, to blame all manner of AEs that occur after vaccination on the COVID-19 vaccine. It’s true that some of those AEs might actually have been caused by the vaccine, but most of them will not have been. It will take careful study to figure out which AE falls into which category.
In the meantime, whenever you see breathless media reports of some horrific AE after COVID-19 vaccination or antivaxxers blaming the COVID-19 vaccine for this or that health problem, remember all these considerations and remain calm. Most of these AEs will not pan out as having been caused by the vaccine, but, frustratingly, it will likely require time for the FDA and public health authorities to work out which one is which.
My experience with side effects of the COVID-19 vaccine

Those who follow me on Twitter might be aware that I was fortunate enough to get my first dose of the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine on Friday afternoon. It went just fine, but I won’t lie. In my case, the vaccine did cause some side effects, although none of them were unexpected or dangerous. First, the vaccine made my shoulder more sore than most (but not all) vaccines I’ve had in the past. The only ones that were as bad were flu vaccines a couple of years in the past and the second dose of the Shingrix vaccine. Second, I experienced a fair amount of muscle aches on Saturday, but timely slugs of ibuprofen provided great relief. Finally, on Saturday afternoon and Sunday, I felt tired and a bit lethargic. Immediately after my stationary bike ride Saturday afternoon, I went upstairs to take a shower and afterward found myself horizontal on my bed. No, I didn’t pass out. I just felt tired and thought I’d lay down for a few minutes. That few minutes turned into a three and a half hour unplanned nap. I also had trouble sleeping Saturday night. By Sunday afternoon, however, I felt fine. Unfortunately, what this meant was that I didn’t accomplish nearly as much work over the weekend as I had planned to do.
Which brings me to what antivaxxers are doing now:
Yes, I suppose that by antivax standards, I had such a reaction to the COVID-19 vaccine. Similarly, since right now it’s mainly healthcare workers who are being vaccinated, a reaction that prevents them from working could be as mild as a fever. Since the pandemic began, healthcare facilities have been screening visitors and workers for symptoms and do temperature checks. If workers have a fever, they are not allowed to work. Basically, antivaxxers are portraying reactions like mine (and milder) as some sort of horrible “vaccine injury” when in fact they are common reactions after effective vaccines. In fact, they’re evidence that the vaccine is doing what it’s supposed to do, provoking an immune response.
Finally, I relate this experience not to frighten anyone out of getting the vaccine but to agree with those reminding people that vaccines, given that their purpose is to result in an immune response, can have effects like this. That is why some healthcare systems have staggered their COVID-19 vaccinations, so that there aren’t too many workers who can’t come to work the next day or two after vaccination. I’ve also heard from colleagues who had similar reactions, which are not really much different or more severe than many vaccines, but I’ve also hear from colleagues who’ve had little or no reaction. Personally, I view my reaction as evidence that the vaccine is working, and it’s good that I plan to have my second dose on a Friday too.
The point is that there will be all sorts of scary stories about COVID-19 vaccines in the coming weeks and months, and a lot of people will have reactions similar to mine. Again, most symptoms other than the sort that I experienced will turn out not to be due to the vaccine, and the benefits of getting vaccinated against COVID-19 far outweigh the very small risk, particularly in a pandemic. Don’t let antivaxxers and COVID-19 cranks frighten you to believe otherwise.
And remember, mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines will most definitely not permanently alter your DNA.

As 2021 shambles to a close, the misuse of VAERS by antivaxxers continues apace
Misuse of the VAERS database to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines has been a favorite technique of antivaxxers for decades. Unfortunately, 2021 was the year when this particular antivax trope was turbocharged, and public health messaging seemed powerless to counter it.
David Gorski on December 20, 2021
Link

Last year around this time, I wrote about how 2020 had been a year of physicians behaving badly—or perhaps I should say more badly than even before the pandemic, when they behaved plenty bad. Of course, we’ve long documented on this blog doctors and scientists behaving badly, be they quacks, antivaxxers, grifters, or cranks, but the arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic provided a golden opportunity for quackery to the point that “magic dirt” and nebulized hydrogen peroxide (for example) have been peddled as cures for COVID-19 and turbocharged antiscience conspiracy theories even more than they had been a year ago. As I sat down yesterday to consider what to write—too many possible topics, I fear!—I rapidly encountered a piece of misinformation about vaccines of the sort that has dominated 2021 and looks to continue to be a major antivaccine technique to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (a.k.a. FUD) about COVID-19 vaccines in 2022; so I thought I’d discuss it now. I had thought about saving this topic for a year-end post next week, but it’s on Joe Mercola’s website, which means that it will disappear by tomorrow. The reason is that a few months ago, in a pique about “censorship”, über-quack “Dr.” Mercola removed all the articles from his website and set all new articles to “expire” and disappear after 48 hours. (Mercola also set his robots.txt file to exclude all his articles from being archived by the almighty Wayback Machine over at Archive.org). So I thought I should write about Jessica Rose now, as she appears in an article from Sunday titled “What the VAERS Data Tell Us About COVID Jab Safety“.
VAERS, of course, stands for Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System. Misuse of VAERS by antivaxxers (and those who claim not to be antivaccine but frequently repeat the same sorts of tropes that antivaxxers do about COVID-19 vaccines) has been a frequent topic on this blog in 2021, and this interview with Jessica Rose illustrates the various techniques used by antivaxxers like Mercola (and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who has had a regular weekly “update” of VAERS reporting for several months now) and thus is worth writing about again, given that Jessica Rose appears to be a rising star in the antivaccine movement and a veritable font of antivaccine disinformation since she was mentioned in passing the first time in a post that I wrote a couple months ago about antivaxxers targeting Orthodox Jewish communities in Brooklyn with antivaccine disinformation and conspiracy theories.
Just who is Jessica Rose, anyway?
Given that I haven’t taken the time to deconstruct disinformation peddled by Jessica Rose, I thought it would be worth briefly looking into her background before looking into the VAERS misuse and conspiracy theories that she’s peddling. In Mercola’s article, he describes Rose thusly:
Jessica Rose, Ph.D., a research fellow at the Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge in Israel, has taken a deep-dive into the U.S. Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS), and in this interview she shares the details of what she’s finding.
In the transcript of the interview, Mercola is even more effusive:
And we’re going to be talking to Jessica Rose, who has an interesting panoply of amazing serendipities. And she has accumulated the skill set that is almost optimized for helping us understand what’s going on. She is a computational biologist. I don’t know what that means, but it sounds cool. And she has post-doc degrees in two of my absolute favorite fields. And if I had to get a Ph.D., I would get Ph.Ds. in these, is molecular biology and biochemistry. And then she also is a surfer. Even though she’s a native Canadian, she caught the bug and actually did her postgraduate training in Israel, where she was able to apply that bug to surfing and was going to go to Australia to surf, but we know what happened. The COVID hit, and she could not go. So now she had to come up with something else. And she decided, “Well, I’m going to be a programmer, I’m going to code.” So she picked an obscure program that actually I’ve never heard of until this. It’s called R, which I think is words for statistics and graphics. And so she used that. And she said, I’m going to work on the VAERS database, and boy oh boy, she’d been working at it. And she’s come up with the most amazing pieces of information that is out there. You are going to be deeply grateful for what she’s done the last two years if you’re listening this conversation. So with all that backstory, welcome, and thank you for joining us.
Talk about a self-refuting introduction. No, as a computational biologist, Rose does not have a “skill set almost optimized for helping us to understand what’s going on”. Let’s put it this way. Computational biology alone does not provide one with a skillset “optimized” to deal with the VAERS database. That would also require training in epidemiology, infectious disease, pharmacosurveillance, and a deep knowledge of how VAERS works, and not just the knowledge how to misuse the database to show what you want it to show about vaccines. Indeed, on her LinkedIn profile, Rose describes her skills thusly:
Experienced Postdoctoral Researcher with a demonstrated history of working in the higher education industry. Strong research professional skilled in Protein Purification, Longboarding, DNA Extraction, Cell Culture, X-ray crystallography, PCR, technical writing, Structural Biology software and a lot more.
That’s all well and good, but it’s as I expected. Her background is more in the sort of computational biology that looks at protein structures and bioinformatics related to DNA sequences than it is to the sort of mathematical and statistical skill set necessary to delve into VAERS with any credibility. A perusal of her curriculum vitae, which is included on the profile, confirms my assessment, particularly her publication record, which includes a lot of molecular biology and virology, but nothing in the way of epidemiology.
Even less auspicious still is that Rose now works for IPAK. You might recall IPAK as the Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge, a cringeworthy name that immediately makes one suspicious of its science. IPAK is a dubious “institute” set up by an antivaxxer about whom I’ve written a number of times here and elsewhere, James Lyons-Weiler. Before the pandemic, Lyons-Weiler was attacking studies showing that autism is primarily genetic, trying to argue that the MMR vaccine causes autism, and teaming up with antivaccine pediatrician Paul Thomas to publish bad studies about aluminum adjuvants. (Lyons-Weiler also teamed up with Thomas to do a typical “vaxxed/unvaxxed” study that purported to claim that unvaccinated children are healthier, which was—surprise! surprise!—retracted.) Since the pandemic, unsurprisingly Lyons-Weiler shifted quickly to COVID-19, claiming in January 2020 that the novel coronavirus that was raging through Wuhan at the time had been the result of a failed SARS vaccine, thus presaging the “lab leak” conspiracy theory by many months, and then, a few weeks later, claimed (mistakenly) hat he had “broken the coronavirus code“. Let’s just say that if you’re a good scientist doing good work, you would be highly unlikely ever to work for an “institute” like IPAK.
Still, it’s not enough simply to show that Jessica Rose lacks the qualifications to undertake the analyses she’s done and that she works for a disinformation institute that’s been spreading FUD about vaccines for years now. Let’s look at her claims and activity, the most famous of which is that COVID-19 vaccines are killing tens of thousands of people without being detected and that the government is covering it up.
Antivaxxers and VAERS
As antivaxxers always do, Mercola starts his article by talking up VAERS as the best vaccine safety monitoring system there is, as though it were the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety surveillance:
VAERS, despite flaws and drawbacks, is one of the greatest tools we have to evaluate vaccine safety. It was implemented as a consequence of the 1986 National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act. While vaccine companies were given blanket immunity against liability for adverse reactions under this law, VAERS was created to collect injury reports in a centralized database so that the post-marketing safety of childhood vaccines could be monitored.
The system was actually launched in 1990, so we have three decades’ worth of data to compare trends against. Granted, vaccine injuries are notoriously underreported. Investigations have found only 10%1 to as little as 1%2,3 of injuries are reported.
When it comes to the COVID jab specifically, calculations4 by Steve Kirsch, executive director of the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund, suggest injuries are underreported by a factor of 41. But despite that and other shortcomings, VAERS can still provide valuable information about a given vaccine.
I’ve discussed why the idea that VAERS is the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring is wrong on a number of occasions, but I always like to preface such remarks by simply noting something about discussions of VAERS by antivaxxers. Notice how antivaxxers always cite VAERS and only rarely, if ever, cite other, much better and more reliable, vaccine safety monitoring databases, such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment (CISA) project, or FDA’s Post-licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring System (PRISM) Antivaxxers also seem to like to represent VAERS simultaneously as the best system to find adverse events (AEs) from vaccines, even while also claiming it’s awful due to underreporting (as above), which means (to them) that all the horrible things in VAERS are really a lot more common than “they” want you to think.
VAERS is, of course, what is known as a passive reporting system in that it relies on doctors, nurses, healthcare workers, and, yes, people receiving vaccines (or their families) to report AEs after vaccines. As a system, it was never intended to provide an accurate estimate of the frequency of AEs related to vaccines, but rather to serve as an early warning system, a “canary in the coal mine”, if you will, for possible new vaccine-related AEs. In other words, VAERS is a hypothesis-generating, not a hypothesis testing, system, and its hypotheses are tested using better systems, like VSD, CISA, and PRISM. In contrast to VAERS, these systems are active reporting systems in that electronic health records are actively monitored for AEs after vaccination in order to identify potential signals; there is a lot less bias that way and a lot less potential for misreporting.
But back to VAERS. The main problem with using VAERS to estimate the frequency of AEs after vaccination is that, in essence, anyone with access to the Internet, mail, or the telephone can report anything to VAERS, as was demonstrated by bloggers years and years ago when one autism advocate filed a report claiming that the flu vaccine had turned him into The Incredible Hulk and another claimed a vaccine had turned his daughter into Wonder Woman. Both reports were accepted. In fairness, ultimately someone from VAERS did contact these people to ask about the reports, and the reports were removed. However, had they refused, reports that vaccines might turn one into the Hulk or Wonder Woman might still be in the database.
In any event, this particular criticism, that anyone can enter anything into VAERS, clearly rankles antivaxxers, as Mercola goes on to write:
A common attempt to explain away the VAERS data by so-called fact checkers is to say that it’s unreliable because anyone can file a report. This is pure hogwash. Yes, anyone can file a report, but there are penalties for filing a false report, and the filing is time-consuming and exacting. We can be quite certain there’s no over-reporting going on.
Note the implied straw man. No, no one is claims that VAERS is unreliable primarily because lots of people are reporting fake AEs such as being turned into fictional monsters and superheroes. Rather, we point out these examples merely as part of the discussion of how VAERS reports represent raw, unadjudicated data, with no ability to demonstrate causation. Antivaxxers leap to the assumption that any AE entered into VAERS must have been caused by the vaccine, but that is simply not the case. As I’ve discussed time and time again, raw VAERS data cannot establish causation, as, by its very nature, it cannot establish reliable estimates for the incidence of a given AE.
Moreover, contrary to Mercola’s claim that we can be “quite certain there’s no over-reporting going on”, we can actually be quite certain that VAERS has been gamed multiple times in its 30 year history. For instance, one of the earliest times I wrote about VAERS was in 2006, when I discussed a study that examined how vaccine litigation could influence VAERS reports. Using VAERS reports from 1990 to 2003, the study found “most case reports to VAERS that were related to overdose, neuropathy, and thimerosal were related to litigation”, as were “many cases” that were related to “autism and mental retardation”. Since we now know with a great degree of certainty that vaccination is unrelated to autism, neuropathy, and mental retardation, we know with a great deal of confidence that these reports represented, if not overreporting, misreporting of AEs not related to vaccination as though they were. The study concluded, “This review shows a previously undisclosed rise in the number of reports to the VAERS related to pending litigation for vaccine injury.” In other words, this is not a new problem with VAERS.
In the discussion, the authors noted:
The findings raise an important question about possible misuse of VAERS in the litigation process. When a study is being used to influence important public health decisions, it is important that reviewers and editors fully understand how the data were constructed and their source. Until now, no one has described the magnitude of litigation-related reporting and how these reports might potentially change the results of studies using VAERS data. Longitudinal studies using VAERS data should explicitly take into account changes in reporting sources like the one described in this article.
It is impossible to determine the effect of these reports on existing analyses because the existing literature does not describe carefully inclusion and exclusion criteria. For the conditions reviewed here, it is apparent that a large enough percentage of reports are being made related to litigation that failure to exclude these will seriously skew trends. This is important for vaccines that contain thimerosal, and specifically for the MMR vaccine because of the controversy surrounding its relationship to autism. It therefore is incumbent on the authors who use VAERS data to provide detailed methods sections that describe their inclusion and exclusion criteria. To that end, we are making our SAS code available to interested parties. It is not sufficient simply to reference extraction of the VAERS data set.
In fact, the authors concluded that their estimates of how many VAERS reports were related to litigation were likely conservative and underestimates, because the keywords used in their analysis to identify litigation-related cases were insufficient to the task. In other words, the authors almost certainly underascertained the cases they were looking for. Let’s just put it this way. There’s a reason why I (and many other science advocates) used to call studies that used unadjudicated raw VAERS reports to estimate changes in prevalence of AEs after vaccination “dumpster diving”. More recently, another study showed changes in reports to the VAERS database from California that appeared to be due to the passage of SB 277, the law that eliminated nonmedical “personal belief exemptions” to school vaccine mandates, concluding that the “recent changes in reporting patterns coincident with the introduction of SB277 may indicate that more parents are using VAERS to assist in applying for a medical exemption for their child”. In other words, VAERS reports are not nearly as reliable as Mercola (and Rose) want you to believe.
Does any of this sound familiar? Relying on just raw VAERS reports from the database is exactly the mistake that Tracy Høeg, John Mandrola, and Allison Krug teamed up with COVID-19 antimasker and antivaxxer Josh Stevenson to dumpster dive in VAERS to look for myocarditis cases and declared themselves to have been “silenced” when the torrent of criticism of their bad science rolled in.
Also, contrary to claims made by Jessica Rose, Steve Kirsch, Joe Mercola, and RFK Jr. (among many other antivaxxers), underreporting to VAERS is not rampant, at least not in the way they make it seem. It’s commonly claimed that only 1% of AEs are reported to VAERS, but that is a misleading statement. As Dr. Vincent Iannelli pointed out a couple of years ago, there is major underreporting for minor AEs, such as fever and pain at the injection site. Of course there is! If your child, for instance, has a fever for a day after a vaccine, are you going to bother to report it to VAERS? Probably not. However, if someone dies soon after a vaccine, you can be damned sure that it will very likely be reported, particularly given the government’s implementation of V-Safe, its text messaging system that follows up COVID-19 vaccination with text messages asking if you’ve had any symptoms since vaccination and reminding you to report them to VAERS if you did. In other words, the more serious the AE, the more likely it is to be reported to VAERS, particularly with the reminders people who opted into V-Safe have been receiving.
This doesn’t even take into consideration the innumeracy and sheer lack of plausibility behind Mercola and Rose’s claims. Mercola’s article states that underreporting of deaths due to COVID-19 vaccines ranges from between 31- and 100-fold, leading him to estimate in his article that the “actual death toll in the US could be anywhere from 278,500 to 898,600.”
On to Jessica Rose’s claims…
Just “play with VAERS” in Excel and R!
During the interview, Mercola discusses VAERS with Rose, asking her what she found. In response, she urges people to “do their own research” by, well, I’ll just quote her:
I implore everybody to do this … [VAERS] is very accessible. Just go to their website and download the CSV files. You can play with it in Excel, or use whatever is compatible with the CSV file. The OpenVAERS system is even easier to use.
There are three separate files that you can download for the domestic data set, which includes the individual’s data, the symptoms or adverse events that they reported (and it can be up to 15 different types), and the injection data …
You can merge them so that, as per [each] VAERS ID, you have a lot more information … That’s what I did. All you have to do is count the number of adverse events that have occurred in 2021. In the context of the COVID-19 products, exclude all the other vaccines to isolate the signal, and compare the number of adverse events to the total number of adverse events reported in every single year going back 30 years.
There’s absolutely zero comparison. The average number of adverse event reports for the past 10 years is ~39,000, and that includes the adverse event report data for all of the vaccines combined. There are a lot of them …
So we’re looking at about 39,000 total adverse events per year [on average for all vaccines], as opposed to 675,942 [adverse events post COVID jab] in the domestic dataset alone [Editor’s note: Please note that all data are as of the day of the interview and have not been updated prior to publication]. And this does not include the underreporting factor …
We see the same trend when we isolate standalone adverse events like death. There are over 10,000 [post COVID jab] deaths reported now in the domestic dataset alone, not including the underreporting factor, and in the previous 10 years, the average was 155 deaths for the entire year for all the products combined. This is over 6,000% increase in reporting for deaths.
This is exactly what you want: A whole bunch of people with no knowledge of epidemiology or, even more importantly, the limitations of VAERS “playing” with the whole VAERS dataset in Excel or, if they’re more sophisticated at computer programming, R. R, for those of you not familiar with it, is a programming language and free software environment for statistical computing and graphing the results. As you might imagine, learning to use R involves a bit of a learning curve, certainly more than Excel does.
Whatever one’s skill level, without knowledge of how VAERS works and what its raw data can be used for, you will fall victim to GIGO or “garbage in, garbage out” no matter how good you are with Excel or at statistical analysis using R. That is, of course, exactly what happened to Rose.
Weaponizing VAERS
At this point, let me just point out that before any of the COVID-19 vaccines started rolling out in the US under an emergency use authorization (EUA) a little over a year ago, those of us with long experience deconstructing antivaccine disinformation were warning that VAERS would be weaponized to portray COVID-19 vaccines as deadly. It was entirely to be expected based on the previous misuse of VAERS to falsely link vaccines to autism, premature ovarian insufficiency and infertility, death (including sudden infant death syndrome), and many other health outcomes that we know not to be related to vaccines. So why wouldn’t they do it with COVID-19 vaccines? They did, of course, and in terms of antivaccine disinformation 2021 has certainly been the year when the public, news media, and public health officials had their faces rubbed in what we had been describing before the pandemic and warning about as the vaccines rolled out.
The first time I noted the misuse of VAERS reports to portray COVID-19 vaccines as deadly. Before the Pfizer vaccine was issued an EUA, I was pointing out how lawyers game VAERS for their litigation and noted the bad “scientific studies” published by antivaccine physicians and scientists that use VAERS as their data source. By one year ago tomorrow, I was discussing reports of Bell’s palsy and syncope from the Moderna clinical trial and how VAERS would likely be used to amplify claims that these AEs were caused by the vaccine, sarcastically Tweeting at one point:
It clearly must be the microchip😏
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) December 17, 2020
By February 1, 2021 the first serious efforts by antivaxxers to misrepresent VAERS reports as showing that COVID-19 vaccines are deadly were manifesting themselves, and I discussed why they did not show this and were not evidence that COVID-19 vaccines were causing heart attacks and sudden death. At that point, there had been “only” 323 deaths and 9,845 AEs reported to VAERS. By May 2021, conspiracy theorists Michael Yeadon and Peter McCullough were helping Mercola use VAERS to spread the conspiracy theory that the vaccines were part of the “global depopulation” agenda, and by July a “holistic cardiologist” from my part of the country was joining in amplifying misinformation based on VAERS reports.
Enter the conspiracy theories…
As I’ve said many times, all science denial, especially antivaccine pseudoscience, is rooted in conspiracy theory. The central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement consists of a claim that “they” are trying to hide the “truth” about vaccines, the “they” usually being the CDC, FDA, the medical establishment, and, of course, big pharma. So, of course, there must be a conspiracy theory to claim why “they” are not taking the dire warnings of people like Jessica Rose seriously, and, of course, there is. The CDC is covering it up, obviously!
And:
While the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention outrageously deny that a single death can be attributed to the COVID jabs, it’s simply impossible to discount 19,532 deaths5 (8,986 in the U.S. territories alone6) reported as of November 26, 2021. As noted by Rose:
It’s not even statistically plausible to say that not one death out of 10,000 was caused [by the shot]. It’s not scientific to say that … Those people, not 100% of them would have died anyway? That’s not how life works.
Actually, it is. I’ve discussed on many occasions now the baseline rate of e.g. deaths, which Rose either doesn’t understand or refuses to accept. Let’s go all the way back to January to see what I mean, where I will, as I am wont to do, quote Mark Hoofnagle:
Remember, this was January, and Mark was estimating over 4K deaths near the time of COVID-19 vaccination by random chance alone.
Now that it’s been over a year since COVID-19 vaccines have rolled out, we can redo the estimates that I last did in July. Our World In Data estimates that in the US as of two days ago, 494 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines had been administered leading to 202 million people having been “fully vaccinated,” or 61% of the population. (I realize that the question of boosters complicates the definition of “fully vaccinated” now, but this is a back-of-the-envelope calculation designed to give a rough estimate.) The estimate for the baseline death rate that I used back then was roughly 2.4/100,000 per day, which means that for a population of 202 million we’d expect to see an average of ~4,848 deaths per day by random chance alone. Using one year as a rough number, we’d therefore expect to have seen around ~1.77 million deaths in this time period by random chance alone, and that doesn’t even count the increase in the baseline death rate due to deaths from actual COVID-19 that has occurred.
The sheer size of those numbers makes Rose’s appeal to incredulity sound really rather silly:
Jessica Rose: Nope. They are holding fast to their claim that not one of the adverse event reports of death in VAERS is because of the products. They’re holding fast. There are GPs and medical doctors and nurse practitioners who are also spouting this garbage. It’s not even statistically plausible to say that. Not one death out of the 10,000 something something were caused, it’s not scientific to say that. So actually, I’m happy when people say that because it’s really it’s going to be really easy to disprove. I think I already have. But showing causation with epidemiological or biological data, data is notoriously difficult, you can do it.
Dr. Mercola: Oh, right. I didn’t realize it was statistically possible. But well, you know it, probably do.
Jessica Rose: Yeah, you can use something called the Bradford Hill criteria, which is a set of 10 criteria that you should satisfy in order to show very strong evidence of causal relationship. And one of the most important of these is temporality, of course, because one thing has to come before the other. And the shorter the duration between those two, the higher the likelihood that there’s a causative effect. So when you’re talking about people, like percentages of people who died, having died within 24 hours of one of their jabs, let’s say you’re talking 50%. That’s kind of suspicious to me. Yeah. I’m glad you laughed, because it is funny, and they completely deny the causal effect. And I mean, yeah, it’s, it’s-
Dr. Mercola: Just a coincidence.
Actually, it almost certainly is “just a coincidence,” just as so many of the problems attributed to vaccines by antivaxxers misusing VAERs were long before the pandemic. My favorite example is a calculation once done over at The Logic of Science five years ago to estimate how many new diagnoses of autism would occur after certain periods of time after vaccination by random chance alone assuming no causation or correlation between vaccines and autism, concluding that, even if there is no relationship between vaccines and autism (and there isn’t such a relationship), every year we would expect to see 154 children showing the first signs of autism within a day of vaccination, 1,079 within a week, and 4,623 within a month. The same principle works here, but the numbers are much larger.
Basically, in a population this large receiving vaccines, due to the large baseline rate of deaths that occur every day, day in and day out, just because a certain small percentage of a large population will die of multiple causes every day one expects large numbers of deaths to occur after vaccination by random chance alone. One also does not expect underreporting of deaths, given V-Safe and long term findings that serious AEs after vaccination, of which death is obviously the most serious, are not underreported to VAERs by a factor of 20 or 100, as Mercola, Kirsch, and Rose claim.
It’s also rather hilarious how Mercola and Rose completely ignore the other Bradford-Hill criteria, such as plausibility, consistency, coherence between epidemiological and laboratory findings, biological gradient, and others, and cite temporality über alles. That is, of course, why raw VAERS reports are investigated and adjudicated before the CDC uses them in analyses, and even then the CDC then uses other databases, such as VSD, to test whether the safety signals identified in VAERS are reproducible using an active surveillance system.
Rose gets even worse, though. She cites an estimate by tech millionaire turned ivermectin pusher Steve Kirsch, a man who’s been falsely claiming that COVID-19 vaccines kill twice as many people as they save (wronger than wrong). Jeffrey Morris demolished (in extreme detail) Kirsch’s methodology used to arrive at his estimate of a 41-fold underreporting rate in detail so that I don’t have to. Let’s just say that Kirsch cherry picked studies and used inappropriate analyses, analogies, and comparisons to come up with this estimate, concluding about Kirsch’s underreporting rate (URR):
It is difficult to see the plausibility of Kirsch’s URR estimate of 41x given results from these 3 studies on myocarditis/pericarditis showing URR from 2.0x-2.7x, and the estimate of 41x from the selected anaphylaxis study contrasts with a study done in November 2020 for other vaccines showing UR of just 1.3x-8x, especially problematic for him based on his claim that reporting rates are similar now as pre-pandemic. To justify the high 41x level, he would need more compelling evidence beyond his current speculative statements on why the URR would be much higher, not lower, for deaths, and why the underreporting in 2021 would be so much higher than previous years.
If anything, given the institution of the V-Safe system and the huge publicity surrounding AEs after COVID-19 vaccination, we would expect the URR to be lower for COVID-19 vaccines than for vaccines in previous years, not higher, especially for the most severe AEs, such as death.
Rose then goes on to claim—of course!—that the nefarious CDC is “deleting” VAERS reports, particularly for children. This is a more difficult conspiracy theory to look at because there could be any of a number of reasons why VAERS ID entries are deleted. Even Rose admits that it could be because more than one report was filed for the same vaccine recipient (e.g., by the doctor and the parents) or for other reasons. A version of this conspiracy theory was going around a few months ago, and the CDC responded by explaining that some 6,000 VAERS reports had been removed from the database because they came from outside the US:
Curtis Gill, a CDC representative, told Reuters via email that the CDC is aware of an error which took place while data was being uploaded to the page.
“The error resulted in what appeared to be a large spike in the number of deaths reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) after COVID-19 vaccination,” Gill said. “It happened, accidentally, because of combining foreign and domestic reports, and has been corrected.”
I really wish that the CDC would be more proactive about such incidents. Instead of waiting until questions are asked about such anomalies in VAERS data, the CDC should announce when it corrects the data. That wouldn’t stop conspiracy theories like the ones Mercola and Rose are spreading, but it could help. Likely there are other legitimate reasons for reports to be removed, but if the CDC isn’t painfully aware that antivaxxers are monitoring VAERS for the purposes of anomaly hunting by now, I don’t know what else would nudge them to do more. Such removals, which before COVID-19 were just part of the normal maintenance of VAERS and rarely noticed or commented on, even by antivaxxers, are now grist for the conspiracy mill. No doubt Rose will deny that this is what she was looking at, but there’s also no doubt that the CDC can no longer do routine quality control of the VAERS database without a lot more transparency, as conspiracy mongers like her are watching for any anomaly that they can weaponize against COVID-19 vaccines.
VAERS: The best and worst system
It’s not at all surprising that Jessica Rose would be engaging in dumpster diving of the VAERS database. What was once a common, albeit rather niche, tactic of the antivaccine movement has in the age of the pandemic been weaponized to the point that I’ve spent considerable time and effort in 2021 dealing with antivaccine propaganda and conspiracy mongering related to VAERS in a way that I had never had to do before for previous vaccines, even if I have been writing about the antivaccine misuse of VAERS since 2005. In the age of COVID-19, VAERS has become a weapon because of its very nature that makes it perfect for this purpose to antivaxxers. It is a completely open database. Anyone can submit a report of an AE after vaccination to it. The complete VAERS dataset (scrubbed of personally identifiable information, such as names) can be downloaded and analyzed by anyone, even without a protocol approved by an institutional review board.
Let’s just say that there’s a reason that you almost never see antivaxxers like Jessica Rose and Joe Mercola citing the VSD, PRISM, and CISA results to promote their conspiracy theories. They’re active surveillance systems, and, far more often than not, analysis of their data fail to support the hypotheses generated by analyses of VAERS with respect to causation.
        ◦ I frequently repeat the refrains that there is nothing new under the sun when it comes to the antivaccine movement, nor are there any truly new antivaccine arguments or techniques of disinformation. Sure, the same old tropes have been tweaked a bit for COVID-19, but at their core they are no different than the same old tropes that antivaxxers have been using for years. I’m hard pressed to think of any better example than how the VAERS database has been misused and weaponized during 2021 to spread FUD about COVID-19 vaccines. Sadly, I don’t see the media or public health officials being all that much better at addressing this technique of disinformation than they were a year ago.

Why is anyone surprised that there are so many antivax physicians?
A new survey suggests that a disturbingly high percentage of physicians are either vaccine hesitant or actually antivaccine. Those of us who have been writing about the antivaccine movement know that this is not new, but it seems new to our colleagues who weren’t paying attention before the pandemic and assured themselves that the problem was just Andrew Wakefield. The question is: How bad is the situation now and what do we do about it as a profession?
David Gorski on April 18, 2022
Link

If there’s one thing about the COVID-19 pandemic that’s surprised pundits and my colleagues in the medical profession, it’s just how many vaccine-hesitant and outright antivaccine healthcare professionals there are out there. You would think that an antivax physician or nurse would be incredibly rare, but the pandemic has demonstrated that they are, unfortunately, far from rare. I’m not saying that the medical profession is dominated by antivaxxers, as in general vaccine acceptance is higher among physicians and nurses than among the general public. However, there is a much more sizable minority of physicians and nurses out there than my colleagues would have guessed whose views range from vaccine-hesitant to full-on antivax conspiracy theorist.
Here’s the thing. Contrary to what my colleagues (and, truth be told, most pundits) appear to think, a higher than totally rare prevalence of antivax beliefs among physicians is not new. While I have no doubt that antivax views among physicians and nurses have likely increased since the pandemic, given the politicization of COVID-19 vaccines, a politicization that is also not new. Vaccine mandates (and even support for routine vaccination) have become increasingly politicized. Beginning well over a decade ago, if not longer, what used to be one of the most nonpartisan and apolitical polices, school vaccine mandates, have become increasingly partisan, with resistance to school vaccine mandates of any kind becoming increasingly associated with the right and support for them with the left. Again, this predates the pandemic, although the watershed moment that turbocharged the politicization of school vaccine mandates was arguably SB 277, the law passed in California in 2015 after the Disneyland measles outbreak that eliminated nonmedical “personal belief exemptions” to school vaccine mandates. The law clearly worked in its intended purpose of decreasing the percentage of unvaccinated California schoolchildren, but it sparked a huge backlash that laid the groundwork for what we see today since the pandemic started. Pundits and my colleagues might be shocked by the increasing association of antivaxxers with the far right, but that started before the pandemic, with antivaxxers marching with far-right militias before the pandemic.
With that background in mind, late last week I was made aware of a new survey because Dr. Peter Hotez Tweeted about it:
What Proportion of Doctors Are Vaccine Hesitant? | Never thought I would need to call for better STEM education in US medical schools and residency programs… https://t.co/0h1wnsG7qW
— Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD (@PeterHotez) April 14, 2022
And my co-author Gavin Yamey appropriately noted:
My colleague Dr Lavanya Vasudevan (not on Twitter) studies vaccine hesitancy
She has shown that one of the most important drivers of vaccine confidence & uptake is whether trusted primary care doctors themselves support vaccination
This is disturbing https://t.co/7FMrpMBPK9
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) April 14, 2022
It is disturbing, but it’s not unexpected. At least, it wasn’t unexpected to me, and, I suspect, neither was it unexpected to those of us who have been paying attention to the antivaccine movement for a long time. Yet MedPage Today spun the story as hugely unexpected:
Levels of vaccine hesitancy among physicians may be higher than expected, with 1 in 10 primary care doctors not believing that vaccines are safe, according to a new survey.
Among 625 physicians, 10.1% did not agree that vaccines were safe; 9.3% did not agree that vaccines were effective; and 8.3% did not agree that they were important, Timothy Callaghan, PhD, of Texas A&M School of Public Health in College Station, and colleagues reported online in Vaccine.
The high proportion of hesitancy among primary care doctors “was certainly a surprise for us,” Callaghan told MedPage Today. “We thought it might be a very small proportion of physicians who hold hesitancy about vaccines given that we have lots of evidence of the safety and effectiveness of vaccines. However, once we dug into the data, we found that concerns about vaccines in general were far more widespread in the physician population than we might have expected.”
May I suggest, then, that given their level of surprise at the findings of their study that Dr. Callaghan and his colleagues haven’t been paying attention for at least the last decade? And he studied vaccine hesitancy before the pandemic? Dr. Callaghan’s very surprise reveals how oblivious large swaths of my profession have been to the problem of misinformation, disinformation, and the doctors who embrace the pseudoscience and even conspiracy theories fueling them. We were asking what to do about physicians who embrace and spread antivaccine conspiracy theories back in 2015.
It’s also not as though the antivaccine group Physicians for Informed Consent sprang into being two years ago. It’s been around since 2015. It’s not as though, for instance, the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS) just popped up in 2020. It was founded in 1943 and has been spreading antivaccine pseudoscience, such as claims that vaccines cause autism and sudden infant death syndrome, promotion of Lupron and chelation therapy to treat “mercury toxicity” due thimerosal-containing vaccines, and even that shaken baby syndrome is a “misdiagnosis” of vaccine injury, dating back to a long time before I first discovered them in 2006. Indeed, just before the pandemic, AAPS published an article by Andrew Wakefield claiming that measles vaccination will produce a “sixth mass extinction“, a claim that was repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines during the pandemic by Geert Vanden Bossche. Unsurprisingly, having been antivax for many years before the pandemic, AAPS has added misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines to the rest of its antivaccine conspiracy mongering.
I realize that before the pandemic colleagues like Dr. Callaghan might have comforted themselves with the belief that such views were so fringe as to be negligible, but I’d argue that two physicians (one of whom, Rand Paul, is outright antivax) pandering to antivaxxers during the 2016 Republican Presidential primaries and then President-Elect Donald Trump appointing an AAPS member to head the Department of Health and Human Services might have been a clue that such views, even before the pandemic, were not as uncommon among physicians as we would like to think.
So let’s get to the numbers
As annoying as I sometimes am with my penchant for saying, “I told you so,” I’m nonetheless glad that this incident prodded him to quantify the effect:
Indeed, the research project was inspired by Callaghan’s own experience with one of his doctors who was not vaccinated and tried to dissuade Callaghan from COVID vaccination.
“It wasn’t my primary care physician, but another one of my doctors realized that I studied issues related to vaccine hesitancy, and over the course of multiple visits, tried to convince me that COVID-19 vaccines weren’t safe and weren’t worth it,” Callaghan said. “It made me question whether this was a one-off, or if we have an actual issue on our hands.”
Ooh! Ooh! I could have told Dr. Callaghan before he did the survey!

(Sorry, couldn’t resist, even when my choice of meme reveals the era in which I grew up.)
Similarly, it’s not unexpected that antivaxxers would be crowing about this study:
2/2. continuous jabs? Here in Australia AHPRA threatened doctors if they spoke against the vaccines they would lose their licenses. Does that sound like a smart move? Now it's even weirder with the connection to snakes with this covid Plandemic.
— Mr Noteable (@MrNoteable) April 15, 2022
This is one time when both sides understand something about a problem. What physicians think about medical matters is important, because physicians are considered authorities in medical matters. So when physicians express doubt about vaccines and vaccine safety, it will have an effect. So when Dr. Callaghan bemoans how such a high percentage of primary care doctors expressing vaccine hesitancy and outright antivax views, he’s right. That is a big problem. When antivaxxers gloat about how high a percentage of primary care physicians (PCPs) express antivaccine and vaccine-hesitant views, they’re correct that it’s important in that it provides them a huge propaganda weapon. They are not, however, correct that this observation somehow validates their views.
So let’s look at the study itself, published in the journal Vaccine titled “Imperfect messengers? An analysis of vaccine confidence among primary care physicians“, which reports the results of a survey about COVID-19 vaccines. I will note one issue with the vaccine that might or might not be a major problem. The survey was carried out from May 14 to May 25, 2021, nearly a year ago, when the vaccines had been approved under an emergency use authorization (EUA) for adults and the Pfizer vaccine had just been approved under another EUA for ages 12-15. On the one hand, I can see how more doctors might have still been a bit hesitant then. On the other hand, I don’t think antivaccine sentiment has gotten better among the general public since then, and physicians, like it or not, do tend to be affected by what’s going on around them. I also can’t help but note just how much the push to vaccinate children has revealed outright antivax views among physicians who argue against the routine vaccination of children against COVID-19, some of whom (I’m talking to you, Urgency of Normal and Great Barrington Declaration physicians) parrot old antivaccine tropes about the virus not being dangerous to children and how “natural herd immunity” is more desirable than vaccine-induced immunity. My guess is that, were the same survey administered today, the results would be even worse than what’s reported now, which is that:
    • 10.1% of primary care physicians (PCPs) do not agree vaccines are safe.
    • 9.3% of PCPs do not agree that vaccines are effective.
    • 8.3% of PCPs do not agree that vaccines are important.
    • Physician confidence in COVID-19 vaccines varies across vaccines.
    • A troubling proportion of PCPs lack high levels of vaccine confidence.
An additional finding is that “only 5.2% (95% CI: 3.4, 6.9) of our sample of primary care physicians was unvaccinated as of May 2021, far lower than vaccine refusal rates for other types of health care workers, and the American public more generally [31]”. Again, I like to point out that being vaccinated does not mean that one isn’t antivaccine or vaccine-hesitant. Antivax leader Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., for instance, loves to point out how his children all received vaccines according to the CDC-recommended guidelines at the time, in response to which I like to point out that he didn’t “come out” as antivax until his youngest child had already passed through the age at which children receive the bulk of their vaccines. Another issue that any physician who had to see patients during the pandemic before there was a vaccine had to deal with was how much the fear of COVID-19 motivated us to get vaccinated as soon as the Pfizer vaccine became available to healthcare workers in December 2020. I hope that the investigators will follow up and see how many of these physicians accepted boosters since May 2021.
The authors recognize this, writing:
Of course, it is critical to recognize that the decision by physicians to vaccinate themselves may be impacted by factors beyond vaccine confidence including their high-risk work environments or the expectations of employers. For that reason, it is also important to analyze general physician confidence in vaccination and confidence in the safety of each COVID-19 vaccine as well.
Before addressing this question, let’s briefly look at the methods:
To understand vaccine confidence among primary care physicians, we developed and administered an original national survey to 737 physicians in the United States. The web-based survey was fielded from May 14 to May 25, 2021, using the survey research firm Dynata – a widely respected survey research firm regularly used in social science research [30], [31], [32], [33]. Dynata invited primary care physicians (identified via responses to an initial inventory survey) to participate in our survey from their large, online, opt-in sampling frame of potential survey participants. Of the 737 respondents identified as PCPs by Dynata who began the survey, 625 of [sic] also satisfied additional screeners that we imposed as a precondition for qualification in our study; i.e., by self-identifying as a PCP working in family medicine, internal medicine, or general practice. These 625 physicians serve as the sample for our analysis.
We provide a comparison of our sample with primary care physician population benchmarks in the appendix which demonstrates that our sample closely approximates the demographic characteristics of primary care physicians nationwide. Primary care physician population benchmarks from the Association of American Medical Colleges and Medscape suggest that our sample closely resembles the proportion of primary care physicians who are Hispanic or Asian and produces similar salary estimates. Small deviations are seen between our sample and population benchmarks for gender and race, with our sample slightly under-representing women and Black physicians. Critically however, these differences are small in magnitude. Limitations aside, our study provides the only national sample to date capable of analyzing primary care physician vaccine confidence.
So the authors made an effort to make sure that their survey group matches the demographics of primary care physicians.
I also notice that, when you dig into some of the weeds, there are some even more disturbing findings. While it’s true that 67.4% strongly agreed that “vaccines are safe” (a horribly low number for physicians) compared to 47.7% of the general public, the percentage of physicians who “strongly disagreed” that vaccines are safe was indistinguishable from that of the general public (4.8% versus 4.9%).
There were some even more disturbing results in the weeds, too:
    • More physicians “strongly disagreed” with the general statement “vaccines are effective” than among the general public (6.7% vs 2.1%).
    • More physicians “strongly disagreed” with the general statement “vaccines are important” than among the general public (5.8% vs. 2.3%).
These are small minorities of physicians, but damn!
Also, if you look at the numbers a bit differently, there are more warning signs:
    • The percentage of physicians who “strongly agree” or “somewhat agree” that “vaccines are safe” was 88.8%, compared to 72.1% of the general public. This is not as huge a difference as one might expect, and I note that the percentage of physicians who “somewhat agree” that “vaccines are safe” (21.4%) was nearly indistinguishable from the percentage of the general public who gave that answer (24.4%)—and lower.
    • The percentage of physicians who “strongly agree” or “somewhat agree” that “vaccines are effective” was 89.9%, compared to 84.4% among the general public, an even smaller difference.
    • The percentage of physicians who “strongly agree” or “somewhat agree” that “vaccines are important” was 89.7%, compared to 86.9% among the general public, an even smaller difference still.
The authors boiled it down thusly:
Two noteworthy patterns emerge from Table 1. First, as expected, primary care physicians are significantly more likely to agree that vaccines are safe and effective than the general public (significance denoted by the non-overlapping confidence intervals presented in the table, which indicate statistically significant differences between groups at the p
What accounts for these results, though? The authors did some modeling to try to answer that question. One factor that strongly influenced vaccine hesitancy among doctors was, unsurprisingly, political orientation:
In Model 1, which focuses on confidence in safety, we find that elevated levels of political conservatism are negatively and significantly associated with agreeing that vaccines are safe. We also find that these effects are substantively large. Holding all other covariates in Model 1 at their sample means, we find that while the predicted probability that extreme liberals strongly agree that vaccines are safe is 78%, the likelihood that extreme conservative PCPs feel the same way is just 59% – a 19% difference across the full range of the ideological spectrum.
And:
A similar pattern holds in Model 2, exploring physician beliefs that vaccines are effective. There, we found that holding all other variables at their means, extreme liberals were predicted to be 18% more likely than extreme conservatives to strongly agree that vaccines are effective. In addition, while the predicted probability that PCPs who had not had COVID-19 would strongly agree that vaccines are effective was 77%, it was only 64% for those who had.
Interestingly, political ideology did not impact agreement with the statement, “Vaccines are important”.
In any event, given the increasing ideological polarization, coupled with the observation that physicians tend to lean conservative in their politics compared to the general public, it is perhaps less surprising that so many physicians doubt the safety and efficacy of vaccines in general.
Another interesting result is that PCPs who had contracted COVID-19 were less likely to agree with all three statements (that vaccines are safe, effective, or important). Again, these are general statements, not statements aimed specifically at just COVID-19 vaccines. One has to wonder whether this result is explained by physicians who had COVID-19 and were fortunate enough not to have gotten too sick from it deciding they didn’t need to be vaccinated or whether physicians who were more of an ideological mindset to doubt vaccines before they got COVID-19 were also more likely to be less fastidious about taking precautions to avoid contracting the disease. After all, being antimask, antivax, and anti-COVID-19 interventions in general do tend to cluster.
What about COVID-19 vaccines specifically?
The authors did look at PCP attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccines specifically. At the time, there were three available in the US under EUA, manufactured by Pfizer, Moderna, or Johnson & Johnson (J&J):
Our analysis in Table 3 revealed that primary care physicians were significantly more confident in the safety of the mRNA vaccines of Moderna and Pfizer than in the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine. Specifically, we found that while 68.7% and 72.7% of primary care physicians were very confident in the safety of the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines respectively, only 32.1% of physicians were very confident in the safety of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine as of May 2021. When we include those who were in the ‘confident’ category as well, we found that over 90% of physicians were either ‘very confident’ or ‘confident’ in the mRNA vaccines but only 68.0% of physicians fell into those two categories for the Johnson & Johnson vaccine.
This result is, of course, likely to be very much a product of the time period when the survey was administered, given that the reports of serious complications due to a rare form of blood clot associated with the Astra-Zeneca vaccine, which was based on a very similar adenovirus platform to that used for the J&J vaccine, were very much in the news a year ago. (Has it really been that long?) Given that context, I would have been shocked if the results were different.
What to do?
It should not be a surprise that there exists a not-insignificant minority of physicians who do not believe that vaccines are safe and effective, although I will admit that I was a bit surprised that it was roughly one in ten. (I would have guessed a smaller—but not that much smaller—percentage, maybe as low as 5% but certainly no lower; i.e., a smaller but still far from insignificant minority.) Extrapolating, the authors note:
Combined, our results serve to complicate media narratives and governmental initiatives encouraging primary care physicians to serve as leading vaccine promotors. While a majority of doctors are well positioned to take on this role, a troubling proportion of physicians lack high levels of confidence both in vaccines in general and COVID-19 vaccines in particular. For example, if we take a conservative approach and remove those who ‘somewhat agree’ that vaccines are safe from the proportion of physicians that lack vaccine confidence and use the total number of PCPs from the AMA Masterfile as our baseline for PCPs nationwide, our findings still suggest that almost 25,000 primary care physicians nationwide could disagree with the basic belief that in general, vaccines are safe.
Also:
These findings suggest that we cannot take it for granted that all physicians are well positioned to serve as vaccine promotors and furthermore, that interventions may be needed to increase vaccine confidence among some physicians. This is particularly true because these physicians could have an outsized impact on public health, with a single physician lacking trust in vaccine safety capable of writing large numbers of medical exemptions from non-COVID-19 vaccination, reducing the effectiveness of vaccine mandates [46], [47].
Anyone who remembers the aftermath of SB 277 likely remembers how many physicians were willing to write bogus “medical exemptions” to school vaccine mandates. Indeed, antivax leaders, such as pediatrician “Dr. Bob” Sears, jumped on the grift bandwagon as the bill was nearing passage in the California legislature, and then more joined in, both as a matter of antivax ideology and profit potential. As a result “medical” exemptions to school vaccine mandates soared after passage of SB 277, which led to the necessity of SB 276, a bill designed to close the loophole that allowed doctors to be so prolific in writing such exemption letters. History might not repeat itself precisely, but it does rhyme, as they say.
There’s also a hole in this article in that it only examines PCPs. While it is true that, on an individual patient level, what the PCP says is enormously influential, on a societal level in essence any old doctor with an MD or DO after their name will do to promote both good information about vaccines and misinformation. After all, most of the COVID-19 contrarian physicians whom we’ve been lambasting for promoting COVID-19 misinformation are not PCPs. Dr. Vinay Prasad (who famously likened public health interventions against COVID, including vaccine mandates, to incipient fascism), for instance, is an oncologist, while Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg is a sports medicine doctor. A number of them (e.g., Drs. John Ioannidis, Joseph Ladapo, and Jay Bhattacharya) do not even practice medicine but are nonetheless extremely influential in spreading false messages that COVID-19 is not dangerous and the vaccines are more dangerous than the disease for young people and children; that the pandemic is over; that, consequently, mask and vaccine mandates in schools are unnecessary (Urgency of Normal); and that “natural herd immunity” is the way out of the pandemic (Great Barrington Declaration).
But what to do? In the conclusion of the paper, Callaghan et al. suggest:
Identifying appropriate interventions is an important direction for future research and could include improving virology and vaccine biology education in medical school or echoing existing approaches for the general public by identifying trusted individuals in physicians lives to improve their confidence in vaccines.
In MedPage Today, Dr. Callaghan expands on this idea:
While political affiliation did appear to play some role in beliefs, Callaghan noted a wider problem that might be at play. “There’s not that much training on vaccines and vaccinology … in medical school,” he said. “Most medical students aren’t exposed to in-depth discussions of virology to have those strong opinions.”
“And given the clouded information environment that surrounded COVID-19 in particular, and increasingly, vaccines in general, it remains possible that [physicians] are just relying on what they’re hearing in the news and the misinformation that’s out there, as opposed to best scientific evidence,” he said.
And finally:
Callaghan noted that “most physicians are well-positioned to serve as our leading vaccine promoters … With that said, 10% is a pretty big proportion to be hesitant. It suggests, for that 10%, we need to do some work in terms of education and potentially, intervention, to increase the level of confidence in that population of physicians so that we’re not at 90% in favor of promoting vaccination, but that it’s closer to 100%.”
Unfortunately, as was pointed out on Twitter:
Also:
The medical mind often stands no chance, against religious and political indoctrination!😕
— SGJ (@sgjdoc) April 15, 2022
We just moved from a rural town in Oklahoma-1 of the OBs touted ivermectin, our pedi refused to get vaccinated and told his patients covid would disappear after the election, an ER NP refused the vaccine too. Political ideology trumping medical knowledge is so sad.
— Claire Cloud (@ClaireCloud_) April 15, 2022
That is indeed the problem. It’s an aphorism that’s been attributed to various writers over the years that you can’t reason people out of a position that they didn’t reason themselves into“. Or, to cite Adam Savage, Calvin and Hobbes, and even Doctor Who people seem to live by another aphorism, “I reject your reality and substitute my own.”
As much as we physicians would like to view ourselves as immune to the effects of ideology, emotion, and belief that doesn’t flow from science and reason, we are not. Indeed, it is hubris on our part to think that we are less susceptible to unreason than anyone else, but that doesn’t stop us from thinking that. Worse still, because we as a group tend to think of ourselves as more reasonable and less susceptible to conspiracy theories, misinformation, and disinformation than the average person, when we do fall for them we tend to fall hard. Worse still, because we as a group tend to be highly intelligent, we tend to be very, very good at motivated reasoning indeed. Specifically, we are very skilled at asymmetrically seeking out evidence and arguments that support our pre-existing beliefs and finding flaw in evidence and arguments that challenge those beliefs, all while reassuring ourselves that our training as physicians means that our beliefs about medicine are all strictly based on science.
It’s also difficult not to note that physicians as a group have now long been primed to be more willing to accept magical thinking in the form of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), which is now more commonly referred to as “integrative medicine” or “integrative health” It’s an indoctrination process that over the last 30 years has led to a disturbingly high percentage of physicians accepting the validity of rank quackery, including acupuncture and homeopathy and the creation of expensive infrastructure to practice and “study” magic like homeopathy. This led to some embarrassment for a major academic medical center, the Cleveland Clinic, when its director of integrative medicine publicly went full-on antivax three full years before the pandemic hit.
If I sound pessimistic about the likelihood of reversing these attitudes, it’s because I am, at least in the short term. There’s another aphorism—a somewhat sarcastic one—that disproven treatments don’t really disappear from medicine until the last physicians who used them retire or die. Likely, the same will be true with vaccines and physicians doubting them. We can try to educate existing physicians with better science, and doing so likely won’t be entirely ineffective, but it can only go so far. We need to inculcate medical students with critical thinking skills and the ability to evaluate science, but even that is not enough. Medical students need to be taught to recognize misinformation, conspiracy theories, and disinformation, which is something they aren’t taught at all. (In fairness, neither are most college students, and then only if they seek out such learning.) It is true that medical school is arguably too late for this, but it’s the earliest point in physician education that we as a profession control.
Even more importantly, while I welcome physicians who were blissfully unaware of the problem of pseudoscience, quackery, and the disinformation and conspiracy theories used to support them, I also challenge them to actually try to do something about them. I can understand how, not paying attention before the pandemic, you were shocked to learn that about one in ten of your fellow physicians is vaccine-hesitant or even antivax. What I won’t be able to understand is if, now that you know, you don’t try to do anything about it.

Antivaxxers misuse the Defense Medical Epidemiology Database to demonize COVID-19 vaccines
Over the last couple of weeks, a claim that the Defense Medical Epidemiology Database (DMED) shows that COVID-19 vaccines have caused a massive increase in cancer, neurological, and cardiovascular diseases in military personnel has gone viral. A closer look shows that the increases are almost certainly spurious and due to underreporting in previous years.
David Gorski on February 7, 2022
Link

I’ve written about the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database many times, particularly how antivaxxers have weaponized its contents to falsely portray COVID-19 vaccines as deadly and, before the pandemic, to falsely link childhood vaccines with autism, infertility and premature ovarian insufficiency, sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), and more. It is a longstanding strategy that has been used by the antivaccine movement going back at least two decades. The reason for this is simple. As a passive reporting system into which anyone can enter any adverse event after vaccination (e.g., that a vaccine turned one into the Incredible Hulk), VAERS was never intended to provide an epidemiologically reliable estimate of the frequency of specific adverse reactions to vaccines. Rather it was intended to be a “canary in the coalmine”, a hypothesis-generating system in which increased reports of specific adverse events can raise safety signals that generate hypotheses. These hypotheses are then tested in more rigorous active reporting systems, such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink. Because of its nature, VAERS is subject to serious reporting bias, both under- and over-reporting depending on the specifics, and antivaxxers who incompetently analyze its contents (including sometimes even those who aren’t antivaccine) often fail to consider the underlying baseline rate of the various adverse events in the database. For example, the number of deaths reported after COVID-19 vaccination might seem alarmingly large until one takes into account how many people in the US die each and every day (over 3 million/year, or over 8,000/day), vaccination or no vaccination and estimates how many people would be expected to die sometime soon after a COVID-19 vaccination by random chance alone, particularly taking into account the various age groups.
Given that the shortcomings of VAERS are now much more widely known, I was wondering when the antivaccine movement would try to dumpster dive in a different health database to demonize COVID-19 vaccines. Just such an effort has started going viral on social media as a result of Sen. Ron Johnson’s (R-Wisc) “COVID-19: A Second Opinion” discussion panel, held the day after the antivaccine “Defeat the Mandates” rally in Washington, DC two weeks ago and featuring a rogues’ gallery of COVID-19 contrarians, cranks, minimizers, and antivaxxers promoting misinformation. During the panel, Ohio attorney Thomas Renz, a man associated with the COVID-19 misinformation group America’s Frontline Doctors and known for spreading antivaccine misinformation before the pandemic (e.g., among the orthodox Jewish community in New York) testified that there has been a dramatic three-fold increase in cancer among military personnel since the COVID-19 vaccines rolled out, citing three Department of Defense (DoD) “whistleblowers” that he represents, Drs. Samuel Sigoloff, Peter Chambers, and Theresa Long, who downloaded what’s characterized as a “massive trove of unclassified data” from the Defense Medical Epidemiology Database (DMED) and provided it in an Excel spreadsheet (because that’s how we love to analyze complex epidemiological data). This was not the only adverse event that the “whistleblowers” claimed to link to COVID-19 vaccines, either. In fact, I think I’ll just post this, which includes Sen. Johnson’s letter to the Secretary of Defense, which has gone viral on all social media platforms:
The specific claims that were made by Renz and his “whistleblowers” include that, since the COVID-19 vaccines have rolled out, there have been increases in these conditions:
    • Hypertension – 2,181% increase
    • Diseases of the nervous system – 1,048% increase
    • Malignant neoplasms of esophagus – 894% increase
    • Multiple sclerosis – 680% increase
    • Malignant neoplasms of digestive organs – 624% increase
    • Guillain-Barré syndrome – 551% increase
    • Breast cancer – 487% increase
    • Demyelinating – 487% increase
    • Malignant neoplasms of thyroid and other endocrine glands – 474% increase
    • Female infertility – 472% increase
    • Pulmonary embolism – 468% increase
    • Migraines – 452% increase
    • Ovarian dysfunction – 437% increase
    • Testicular cancer – 369% increase
    • Tachycardia – 302% increase
Unsurprisingly, the Renz Law website is touting these numbers and, of course, complete with any “whistleblower” complaint, there has to be a “coverup”:
Renz also informed me that some DMED data showing registered diagnoses of myocarditis had been removed from the database. Following the allegation that DMED data had been doctored, I immediately wrote to you on January 24 requesting that you preserve all records referring, relating, or reported to DMED. I have yet to hear whether you have complied with this request.
Unsurprisingly, this narrative is being promoted by those with a history of promoting antivaccine misinformation, such as Mike Adams, Steve Kirsch, and Dr. Robert Malone, as well as the entire COVID-19 conspiracy theory, antimask, and antivaccine media ecosystem, for example by The Blaze, the narrative being:
Three military doctors have presented queried data to Renz that shows a shocking and sudden spike in nearly every ICD code for common vaccine injuries in 2021.
In a declaration under penalty of perjury that Renz plans to use in federal court, Drs. Samuel Sigoloff, Peter Chambers, and Theresa Long — three military doctors — revealed that there has been a 300% increase in DMED codes registered for miscarriages in the military in 2021 over the five-year average. The five-year average was 1,499 codes for miscarriages per year. During the first 10 months of 2021, it was 4,182. As Renz explained to me in an interview with TheBlaze, these doctors queried the numbers for hundreds of codes from 2016 through 2020 to establish a baseline five-year average. These codes were generally for ailments and injuries that medical literature has established as being potential adverse effects of the vaccines.
Renz told me the numbers tended to be remarkably similar in all those preceding years, including in 2020, which was the first year of the pandemic but before the vaccines were distributed. But then in 2021, the numbers skyrocketed, and the 2021 data doesn’t even include the months of November and December. For example, some public health officials speculate that COVID itself places women at higher risk for miscarriages. But the number of miscarriage codes recorded in 2020 was actually slightly below the five-year average (1,477). However, they were not drastically below the average on any one category in a way that one can suggest it reflects lockdown-related decreases in doctor’s visits, which somehow led to an increase in 2021 diagnoses.
The database has all the ICD codes for both military hospital visits and ambulatory visits. The data presented by Renz so far is all from the query of ambulatory diagnosis data.
Let’s take a look. Some of these claims will be easy to deal with as highly unlikely to be related to vaccines. Others are a bit less obvious, but still likely spurious, particularly when you recall that, unlike VAERS, DMED was never even intended to look for adverse reactions to vaccines and that these “whistleblowers” simply looked at a timeline and assumed, as antivaxxers always do, that whatever changes they observed in the frequency of diagnoses must have been due to the vaccines. Never mind that there had been a pandemic raging for a year before these data.

What is DMED?
Having been unfamiliar with DMED, I had to educate myself regarding what this database is, and it wasn’t hard to find the DoD’s DMED factsheet:
The Armed Forces Health Surveillance Branch’s (AFHSB) Defense Medical Epidemiology Database (DMED) is a web-based tool to remotely query de-identified active component personnel and medical event data contained within the Defense Medical Surveillance System (DMSS). A newly released version of the database provides unprecedented access to tri-service epidemiologic data that allows users to query large amounts of data in a timely and efficient manner.
In brief, DMSS provides a health database for military personnel that is available to DoD physicians and healthcare personnel who wish to use it, with DMED providing remote access to a subset of that data:
DMSS contains up-to-date and historical data on diseases and medical events (e.g., hospitalizations, ambulatory visits, reportable diseases, immunizations, HIV tests, etc.) and longitudinal data relevant to personnel characteristics and deployments for all active and reserve component service members. DMED provides remote access to a subset of data contained within the DMSS (only data on active component service members). The DMED application provides a user-friendly interface through which users may perform queries regarding medical health care, including disease and injury rates and relative burdens of disease, for active component service members.
DMED provides access to four types of data: demographic, hospitalization, ambulatory and reportable events data.
DEMOGRAPHIC DATA include service, gender, age category, race, pay grade, and marital status.
HOSPITALIZATION DATA include information from DoD Medical Treatment Facilities (MTFs) and outsourced (non-DoD) hospitalization healthcare provided to active component service members. For each hospitalization of an active component service member, at the time of discharge, up to eight diagnoses are recorded (using standard diagnostic codes, International Classification of Diseases (ICD) 9th and 10th revision).
AMBULATORY DATA include information from MTFs and outsourced (non-DoD) ambulatory healthcare provided to active component service members. A maximum of four diagnoses using ICD-9 and ICD-10 codes are recorded for each ambulatory visit of an active component service member.
REPORTABLE EVENT DATA contain information on medical events that are required as defined in the Armed Forces Reportable Medical Events Guidelines and Case Definitions. These data are a subset of information provided by the Disease Reporting System Internet (DRSi).
In addition, DMSS uses various data sources:
DMSS is a relational database with multiple sources feeding information into tables containing information related to the health of U.S. Military Service members. These data sources include, but are not limited to: Defense Manpower Data Center (DMDC), Military Entrance Processing Command (MEPCOM), Defense Health Services System (DHSS), Defense Enrollment Eligibility Reporting System (DEERS), Armed Forces Medical Examiner System (AFMES), DRSi, Pharmacy Data Transaction Service (PDTS), Pharmacoeconomic Center (PEC), and Theater Medical Data Store (TMDS). The Armed Forces Health Surveillance Division (AFHSD) uses this system to generate their master line list of COVID-19 cases, which is shared with APHC, USAFSAM, and NMCPHC.
From my reading, DMED, which allows easy access to the subset of deidentified data from DMSS described above, is a rather odd beast, a front end to a larger database that is a hybrid of passive and active reporting systems in the military, such as the DRSi (passive, used for what the military calls “reportable medical events” or RMEs) and hospitalizations, clinic visits, and diagnosis codes (active), restricted only to current active-duty personnel. Also, most RMEs appear to be infectious diseases, as described in the Armed Forces Reportable Medical Events Guidelines and Case Definitions from before the pandemic. Unsurprisingly, though, antivaxxers touting this “whistleblower” describe DMED as the “best epidemiological database in the world.” (It ain’t.)
I’m going to look at the claims of these whistleblowers two ways. First, I’m going to take the observation at face value. Then I’m going to discuss the likelihood of underreporting. The best place to start is with cancer.
Cancer in DMED: A huge red flag for reporting issues
Given that I’m a cancer surgeon and researcher, you might expect that I would immediately focus on the claims about increases in cancer rates since the vaccines rolled out to the military. You’d be right, and this will be where I take the numbers at face value, at least initially. The cancer numbers alone made me seriously question whether there was a problem with the database for two very simple reasons. First, absent other explanations, cancer rates, while they can increase and decrease from year to year, never show incredibly rapid and dramatic changes, such as the increases ranging from 395% (testicular cancer) to 894% (esophageal cancer) reported by the “whistleblowers”. Indeed, the claimed 487% increase in breast cancer from year to year really got my attention, because such an increase can only be accounted for by reporting issues. For example, as I’ve discussed a number of times before, breast cancer has been relatively stable over the last 30 years, as mortality from breast cancer has been steadily falling, trends that continue based on the 2022 cancer statistics reported last month by the American Cancer Society.
That’s why I can’t take these numbers at face value. Even before I learned more, I concluded that something must be wrong with the database. I’ll show you what I mean. Just for comparison, let’s look at the graph for yearly cancer incidence rates from 1975 to 2018:

Notice that the largest spike in incidence for any cancer was for prostate, a 2.5-fold increase that occurred over 15 years due to the implementation of PSA screening and the overdiagnosis that resulted. Overdiagnosis is the discovery through screening of disease that would never have progressed in a patient’s lifetime to threaten their life, and PSA was great at detecting indolent prostate cancer that either doesn’t progress or progresses so slowly that the patient dies of something else before the cancer spreads.
Spikes in cancer incidence in just one year reported by Renz’s “whistleblowers” are, quite simply, completely implausible from a biologic standpoint. Why is that? Cancer is the culmination of a process that, in general, takes years, from the initial insult that resulted in cellular transformation to the development of a cancerous tumor detectable by symptoms, physical exam, or screening tests. Even if there had been a spike in these cancers from roughly four- to ten-fold in just one year (for an overall increase in total cancer diagnoses from 36,050 to 114,645 from 2020 to 2021), it could not possibly have been due to what Mike Adams, Thomas Renz, and his “whistleblowers” are claiming, namely COVID-19 vaccines, which only started rolling out to the military a year ago and were only mandated for all military personnel after the August 24 order by the Secretary of Defense. Of note, the data from the “whistleblowers” only includes 2021 data through October, with the Army, for instance, not reporting a 98% vaccination rate until mid-December. While those promoting this DMED data dump as smoking gun evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are causing an epidemic of cancer in the military love to point out that the numbers included for 2021 are incomplete, in actuality that incompleteness makes them even more improbable as evidence for COVID-19 vaccines causing cancer, at least. A far more probable explanation is some sort of underreporting in the years prior to 2021.
Alternatively, another potentially plausible explanation is this one:
…a whole bunch more people went to the doctor this year with COVID related issues and also managed to find early cancer diagnoses?
— Teacher and Adjunct Professor (@TurnedLawyer) February 6, 2022
Let’s just put it this way. Say that I was an antivax “whistleblower” who wanted to dumpster dive in a database, say the DMED database, in order to suggest that COVID-19 vaccines cause all sorts of health problems. Let’s say that I was also fortunate enough to come across a situation where there were huge single-year changes in the incidence of a number of diseases, as Renz’s “whistleblowers” were. Knowing cancer as I do, I would have left out the changes in cancer diagnoses, because such huge changes from year to year in cancer diagnoses are so biologically implausible as to bring into question everything else reported. Cancer biologists, doctors, and epidemiologists would immediately recognize that there has to be a reporting issue going on, because such massive increases in cancer incidence in a single year are always due to something like that and not to an environmental exposure, drug, or vaccine, again, because cancer does not develop that fast. If COVID-19 vaccines really did cause cancer, we would not expect to see it for at least a few years; we would not expect to see it in less than a year.
Don’t believe me? Check out this ASCO Post article by Dr. Robert Peter Gale, an oncologist, writing about cancers induced by ionizing radiation:
What do these data show? First, the risk of developing a radiation-induced cancer is dose-related—the higher the dose, the greater the probability a cancer in an A-bomb survivor was caused by radiation exposure. Second, the A-bomb data allow us to determine the briefest interval from radiation exposure to cancer diagnosis. For leukemias, this is about 2 years, and for solid cancers, about 10 years. These increased risks, especially those for solid cancers, were most easily detected after 30 years and remain over a person’s lifetime.
Again, the cancer data reported in the DMED data dump, even leaving aside that there is no correlation shown between COVID-19 vaccination and the diseases attributed to it given that COVID vaccination status was not included in the data downloaded, are the biggest “tell” that something other than a real effect due to COVID-19 vaccines (or anything else) is the explanation for such massive increases in cancer incidence in just one year. To believe that COVID-19 vaccines were responsible for this increase in cancer incidence among military personnel, one would be obligated to believe that COVID-19 vaccines are far more carcinogenic than ionizing radiation from atomic bombs. After all, the DMED data revealed increases in the incidence of solid tumors like esophageal and other GI cancers that were reported less than a year after the vaccines became available. Come to think of it, I didn’t see any mention of hematologic malignancies, like leukemias in this “whistleblower” report. Odd, isn’t it? The cancers that are known to appear the fastest after exposure to a powerful carcinogen like ionizing radiation don’t show up as having increased in incidence in this report. One wonders if there were some cherry picking, one does. After all, I’m sure that the data for hematologic malignancies must be in DMED. Why didn’t the “whistleblowers” download the data? Or maybe they did, and Renz left it off the Excel spreadsheet because was no change in incidence from 2020-2021.
Fortunately, like Dr. Ryan Cole before them (who also tried to link COVID-19 vaccines to increased cancer diagnoses while neglecting cancer biology and as a pathologist really should have known better), neither Renz nor Drs. Sigoloff, Chambers, and Long were smart enough to realize that the cancer numbers alone are huge red flags that something other than the COVID-19 vaccines likely explain the single year increases in all of these conditions. Even Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, who has gone full antivaccine lately, managed to ignore the extreme implausibility of attributing such a huge increase in cancers to COVID-19 vaccine mandates in the military, writing over the weekend:
Notably, we now have Dr. Pierre Kory warning about censoring of early COVID treatment options, and Dr. Ryan Cole raising alarms about an alarming trends in cancer diagnoses which coincide with the onset of mass COVID-19 genetic vaccination.
So, are there any large data sets supporting Dr. Cole’s concerns about cancer incidence, or for that matter my warning to parents about potential genetic vaccine-associated risks to brain, nervous system, heart, immune system, and reproductive systems in children and healthy young adults? Judging by the amount of invective and targeted character assassination attacks which Pierre, Ryan and I have had to endure, we must be raising completely unfounded concerns and spreading disinformation.
Actually, they all have been doing just that, spreading misinformation, but let’s move on.
Here’s the funny thing. Elsewhere in that same recent post, Dr. Malone wrote something that was—for him, at least—shockingly reasonable, in which he cautioned his readers:
Now these are basically raw data from the Defense Medical Epidemiological Database (DMED). For the detail oriented, this is the scrubbed and de-identified (HIPAA compliant) database derived from the Defense Medical Surveillance System (DMSS), which pulls directly from patient records and other US Department of Defense-related medical record information streams. These data were pulled with full chain-of-custody documentation based on various CPT codes that are related to known genetic COVID-19 vaccine side effects.
As raw data, this information needs to be reviewed with care and considered to be both rough and preliminary. For the uninitiated, there are major risks associated with reliance on large, raw (uncorrected) data sets for retrospective (backwards in time) data analyses. The key technical term here is “confounding variables“, but data entry errors (such as multiple entries for the same diagnostic event) or process changes can also introduce huge sources of bias into large data sets like this. With raw data, it is most useful to consider any data plotting to be sort of a first draft, useful for identifying potential trends or topics that deserve more detailed analysis.
Unfortunately, Dr. Malone couldn’t restrain himself from continuing:
But sometimes, when the observed effect size in the raw data is very large or potentially important, alarm bells start ringing even before full analysis is completed. And that seems to be the case with these data.
Actually, when the effect size is so huge as to be incredibly implausible from a biological standpoint, as the reported DMED data for overall cancer rates and the increases in various specific cancers reported are, such enormous observed effect sizes do cause alarm bells to start ringing, just not for the reasons that Dr. Malone cites. In such a case, alarm bells ring because there’s very likely something “off” or wrong with the dataset and suggest that the observed effect size is due to issues with reporting, rather than a real change in incidence rates.
Amusingly, Dr. Malone cites an observation from another antivaccine doctor that an “instructive test would be to check that we do not see a similar rise for conditions that could not plausibly exhibit a significant association with the vaccines, such as broken legs or burns.” Funny, isn’t it, that Renz’s “whistleblowers” didn’t do even that simple quality test. Come to think of it, why doesn’t Dr. Malone insist that they do this simple test?
If you are so inclined, you too can download the Excel spreadsheet from the Renz Law website. Interestingly, none of the conditions for which the “whistleblowers” downloaded data is a condition like the ones suggested by Dr. Malone as useful to look at as negative controls, and all of the conditions included show massive increases in incidence, which leads me to suspect cherry picking. In any event, as soon as I saw the one-year increases in cancer incidence ranging from 300% to nearly 1,000%, I knew that the explanation had to be either a reporting problem, the DMSS database itself or how it pulls data from the various other databases that feed it, or a bug in the algorithm by which DMED pulls data from the DMSS database in queries—had to be. The true incidence of cancer doesn’t increase so dramatically in less than a year. It had to be underreporting in years before or a bug in how data were pulled over to DMED. A cardinal rule of evaluating results of a database search is that if some of the results are clearly impossible, then you have to assume that the problem is with the database or the algorithm, not that the impossible results are real. Of course, Renz, being an antivax lawyer looking to make a name for himself bringing various dubious lawsuits against vaccine mandates and representing these “whistleblowers,” assumed the clearly highly implausible data were real and, as antivaxxers always do, assumed that the COVID-19 vaccines were the explanation. The “whistleblowing” doctors should have known better, at least about the cancer rates—no, seriously, people, how could you not have realized the utter implausibility of these results?—but I can only assume that they are antivax too.
The “coverup”
In the world of antivaccine conspiracy theories, there must always be some sort of “coverup”. All conspiracy theories involve a “coverup”, particularly antivaccine conspiracy theories. For example, the Simpsonwood conspiracy theory that claimed that the CDC met in 2000 to “cover up” and “massage” data showing that thimerosal in childhood vaccines had resulted in a massive increase in the prevalence of autism, and the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory behind the antivaccine propaganda film disguised as a documentary VAXXED postulated a CDC coverup of data showing that the MMR vaccine had resulted in a four-fold increase in autism among African-American boys. So it is with this conspiracy theory as well, with Steve Kirsch gloating:
The original DMED data appears to be very reliable. It is hard for anyone to make excuses for the increased rates in the DMED database quoted in this letter because the event types with increases are all confirmed in the VAERS database. Unlike VAERS, this database cannot be dismissed using hand-waving arguments. DMED is not a self-reported database where reporting rates are unknown. It is a fully reported database where all the reports are from healthcare providers. In short, if the vaccines are safe, the DMED data is hard to explain. For example, you can’t pin the rise in events in 2021 on COVID since total hospital event rates declined in 2020 (relative to 2019) in both the original and corrected results. Note: The DoD now claims the 2016-2020 data was wrong and issued corrected values (graph on the right):
And here’s the figure:

The Renz Law Firm goes even further, predictably, as these screenshots of its website yesterday show:

And then Kirsch goes on:
The DoD is in a panic about this leaking out. This data wasn’t ever supposed to leak out. The only reason it leaked out is due to the efforts of three whistleblowers inside the DoD. According to an insider I spoke to, the DoD has no idea how they are going to cover it up. The only thing they’ve done is claim the 2016-2020 data is underreported, but this doesn’t match reality as I explain below.
And, of course, the mainstream press is also in on the “coverup”:
Deliberate mainstream press cover-up. There is evidence that mainstream media reporters have been instructed not to cover this story or talk to Tom Renz. I verified this myself searching for articles about Renz in The New York Times and CNN. So you’ll only hear about it from alternative media. Think about it… this is one of the most explosive stories of the year (if not the decade) and the mainstream press isn’t covering it at all? What does that tell you? You don’t have to have a lot of critical thinking skills to figure that one out. It pretty much tells you everything you need to know: there is a massive cover up of adverse events.
And even these enormous increases are an “underestimate” of the true numbers, because of course they are:
It’s important to note that the soldiers are tough and don’t want anything on their medical records that could limit their responsibilities
The coverup is of course why, if you look at the actual Excel spreadsheet, you will see corrected numbers added, and, of course, to Kirsch it’s obviously a plot by the DoD to “cover up” the “injuries” from COVID-19 vaccines in the military. The amusing thing to me, though, is that, even though I don’t trust the military to be truthful any more than anyone else, from a biological, scientific, epidemiological, and medical perspective, underreporting during previous years is in actuality a far more plausible explanation for what is seen in the data downloaded by these “whistleblowers” and now being weaponized by antivaccine lawyers and propagandists than is a real increase in incidence of all these medical conditions due to COVID-19 vaccines.
The “coverup” then proceeds to get even worse and more egregious, with an article published by Politifact, which deemed the “whistleblower” claims to be false:
But Peter Graves, spokesperson for the Defense Health Agency’s Armed Forces Surveillance Division, told PolitiFact by email that “in response to concerns mentioned in news reports” the division reviewed data in the DMED “and found that the data was incorrect for the years 2016-2020.”
Officials compared numbers in the DMED with source data in the DMSS and found that the total number of medical diagnoses from those years “represented only a small fraction of actual medical diagnoses.” The 2021 numbers, however, were up-to-date, giving the “appearance of significant increased occurrence of all medical diagnoses in 2021 because of the underreported data for 2016-2020,” Graves said.
The DMED system has been taken offline to “identify and correct the root-cause of the data corruption,” Graves said.
Remember, DMED is more or less a subset of the DMSS in which the data have been deidentified; so it is the data in the DMSS that would be the complete dataset, not what’s seen in the DMED. That being said, it is rather disturbing that before 2021 there had apparently been some sort of problem with DMED such that what it pulled from the DMSS was only a fraction of the medical diagnoses there, but somehow whatever glitch caused that underreporting was fixed by 2021 but not for the years before. It’s an unforced error that was custom-made for conspiracy theorists and will likely make it impossible to convince many people that these data were full of underreporting before 2021, even though the cancer rates found were a huge red flag that something like this must have been occurring, leading Dr. Malone to opine:
Now for some reason, although this database has apparently been managed for years by the same NIH subcontractor, and has been included in the CDC datasets including those reviewed by the CDC’s COVID-19 Vaccine Safety Technical (VaST) Work Group, the geniuses that have been managing it have never identified any issues before the whistleblowers grabbed this download. Does not inspire confidence, no matter what the final “official” explanation becomes.
Unfortunately, a lot of people will find the seeming conspiracy to “cover up” the findings of the “whistleblowers” compelling. Truly, at best this was an unforced error on the part of the DoD.
A teachable moment
I can’t resist relating this DMED kerfuffle back to the primary mission of SBM. Longtime readers will recall that the founders of this blog originally proposed the idea that alternative medicine claims—indeed all medical claims—need to be considered through the lens of prior biological plausibility. That’s why, for example, we can dismiss homeopathy as impossible based on basic science considerations along, regardless of what bias- and error-prone clinical trials show. After all, as we have long pointed out, for homeopathy to be true, not only would huge swaths of what we know about physics, chemistry, and biochemistry have to be wrong, they’d have to be spectacularly wrong. While it is possible (just barely) for this to be true, it is up to homeopathy advocates to provide scientific evidence of sufficient quality and quantity to overthrow all the principles of physics and chemistry that homeopathy violates, not up to scientists to “prove them wrong”.
We can apply the same principle to the DMED data dump, which is marginally only somewhat less implausible than homeopathy. For the observed increases in cancer incidence reported by these feckless “whistleblowers” to be true increases, then not only would what huge swaths of what we know about cancer and carcinogenesis have to be wrong, but they’d have to be spectacularly wrong. You can safely ignore everything else reported in the data dump for the simple reason that what’s reported for cancer is so incredibly implausible that it has to be due to reporting error. That was true before the DoD issued that statement to Politifact and took the DMED offline to investigate, and it’s even more true now.
Add to that the fact that the man orchestrating the “whistleblower” report is a lawyer with a long history of suing for “vaccine injury” and promoting antivaccine misinformation and who filed a lawsuit on behalf of the COVID-19 minimizing group America’s Frontline Doctors alleging that the “true” number of deaths due to the COVID-19 vaccines is being “covered up” and has a history of misusing other databases to misleadingly claim that COVID-19 vaccines are causing tens of thousands of deaths, and you can be quite confident that the claims of these whistleblowers are not supported by any actual science or epidemiological evidence. This is doubly true given that the “whistleblowers” didn’t bother to do checks on their data so simple that even an antivaccine crank like Dr. Robert Malone recognized that they were important.
        ◦ Thus endeth this week’s teachable moment. I fear that it won’t register among those who most need it.

How antivaxxers weaponize vaccine safety studies to falsely portray vaccines as dangerous
Antivaxxers have weaponized a huge multinational vaccine safety study of 99 million patient records that found rare adverse events and concluded that the risks of COVID-19 vaccines outweigh the benefits. How? A combination of the Nirvana fallacy and spin.
David Gorski on February 26, 2024
Link

Earlier this month, a large multinational research group published a study in the journal Vaccine using the Global Vaccine Data Network (GVDN) to examine thirteen medical conditions that the group considered “adverse events of special interest” potentially associated with COVID-19 vaccination. In the study, they examined the records of more than 99 million vaccinated individuals in eight countries, with the intention of identifying higher-than-expected cases of one or more of these conditions after a COVID-19 vaccination. The vaccines investigated included the most commonly used vaccines, the mRNA-based vaccines distributed by Pfizer and Moderna, as well as nonreplicating adenovirus vector-based vaccines. and protein-based vaccines. The GVDN network includes Argentina, Australia – New South Wales, Australia – Victoria, Canada – British Columbia, Canada – Ontario, Denmark, Finland, France, New Zealand, and Scotland, and the healthcare data studied was comprised of either individual- or population-level data, depending on the availability in the study sites. Overall, it was a massive undertaking that also belies the frequent antivax lie that vaccines aren’t studied for safety and efficacy.
It’s also a good case study to show how antivaxxers spin even a study that shows—as this study did—specific vaccines to be quite safe, with only rare serious adverse events associated with them, into antivax propaganda used to fear monger about vaccines. The way they do this is through two tactics. One is to falsely portray the risk-benefit ratio of vaccines as unacceptable by falsely decreasing the denominator (the benefit) by claiming that the vaccines have little or no benefit. The other is through the Nirvana fallacy, in which any deviation from a perfectly safe vaccine with zero adverse events is used to portray the vaccine as hopelessly dangerous. In the two weeks since this study was published, I’ve seen antivaxxers doing both and therefore thought that a discussion of this study and the antivax reaction to it would be useful to our readers. The reality-based interpretation of the study is that it is yet more evidence that the benefits of COVID-19 vaccination far outweigh the tiny risks of serious adverse events. The antivax interpretation is, of course, that COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous, toxic sludge.
Let’s dig in.
99 million patient records, and this is all GVDN found
Given the size and the scope of the study, first let’s reproduce the chart showing which vaccines were studied:
Table 2. Total number of vaccinations by brand.
Vaccine platform	Vaccine brand	Total doses
Inactivated	Covilo or SARS-CoV-2 Vaccine (Vero Cell) [Sinopharm (Beijing)]	134,550
	Covaxin [Bharat Biotech]	1,660
	CoronaVac or Sinovac [Sinovac Biotech]	31,598
	Inactivated (Vero cell) [Sinopharm (Wuhan)]	623
Nucleic acid-based	Comirnaty or Riltozinameran or Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine Bivalent [Pfizer/BioNTech]	3,516,963
	Comirnaty or Tozinameran [Pfizer/BioNTech or Fosun-BioNTech]	183,677,660
	Comirnaty or Tozinameran Paediatric [Pfizer/BioNTech or Fosun-BioNTech]	2,439,086
	Spikevax bivalent Original/Omicron [Moderna]	2,750,476
	Elasomeran or Spikevax or TAK-919 Half Dose [Moderna or Takeda]	400,395
	Elasomeran or Spikevax or TAK-919 [Moderna or Takeda]	36,222,514
Protein-based	MVC-COV1901 [Medigen]	16
	Covovax or Nuvaxoid [Novavax or Serum Institute of India]	66,856
Non-replicating viral vector	Convidecia or Convidence [CanSino]	3,938
	Covishield or Vaxzevria [AstraZeneca or Serum Institute of India]	23,094,620
	Sputnik Light or Gam-COVID-Vac [Gamaleya Research Institute]	26
	Sputnik V [Gamaleya Research Institute]	84,460
	Janssen [Janssen/Johnson & Johnson]	1,137,505
In brief, a total of 183,559,462 doses of BNT162b2, 36,178,442 doses of mRNA-1273, and 23,093,399 doses of ChAdOx1 were administered across participating sites during the study period to a grand total of 99,068,901 vaccinated individuals. As for the study period, I’ll just quote the methods:
The study periods varied across countries, commencing on the date of the site-specific COVID-19 vaccination program rollout, and concluding at the end of data availability (Table 1). In general, the study periods spanned from December 2020 until August 2023. The shortest study period observed occurred in Australia – New South Wales, including 11 months from February 2021 to December 2021. Argentina had the longest study period, from December 2020 to August 2023, encompassing a total of 32 months.
The risk intervals used after each dose were 0–7 days, 8–21 days, 22–42 days, and 0–42 days. For each vaccination dose, day 0 was denoted the day of vaccine receipt. For this manuscript, we present results for the risk interval of 0–42 days only.
I can tell what antivaxxers will say right here, namely that the followup period was way too short. To that, I like to point out yet again that adverse events attributable to vaccination almost always occur shortly after vaccination, as in days to a couple of weeks. But what were these “adverse events of special interest” (AESI)? I’ve discussed the concept before in the context of a “reanalysis” of the original Pfizer randomized controlled clinical trial (RCT) data used to approve its vaccine and how this “reanalysis” was basically an exercise in extended data mining and p-hacking, or, as I like to call it, statistically torturing the data until they confess. In any event SAESIs were defined by the Brighton Collaborative, a group dedicated to vaccine safety and improving the scientific rigor of vaccine science. For purposes of the current study, the SAESIs chosen to be studied included these 13 conditions:
    • Myocarditis. This is inflammation of the heart muscle, regardless of cause.
    • Pericarditis. This is inflammation of the pericardial sac that surrounds the heart
    • Guillain-Barré syndrome. GBS is a rare rapid-onset autoimmune disorder in which the immune system attacks peripheral nerves, resulting in demyelination that causes muscle weakness and paralysis.
    • Transverse myelitis. This is inflammation of the spinal cord that can result in paralysis. Before the pandemic, antivaxxers tried to blame Gardasil for a case of transverse myelitis.
    • Bell’s palsy. This is idiopathic and almost always temporary paralysis of one side of the face due to loss of function of the facial nerve. This was one condition that was suspected very early on during the vaccination program.
    • Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis. This condition that involves inflammation of the brain and spinal cord, usually due to autoimmune disease.
    • Convulsions or seizures.
    • Cerebral venous sinus thrombosis. These are blood clots that form in the brain’s venous sinuses (that we’ve written about before).
    • Splanchnic vein thrombosis, blood clots that form in the splanchnic veins; i.e. the veins that supply the internal organs in the abdomen, such as intestines and liver.
    • Pulmonary embolism. These are blood clots that usually originate in the legs and travel to the lungs. Depending on how large they are, they can be life-threatening.
    • Thrombosis with thrombocytopenia syndrome. This is a condition in which blood clots form in large blood vessels and use up platelets, resulting in a low platelet count.
    • Thrombocytopenia, or low blood platelets.
    • Immune thrombocytopenia. This is an autoimmune disorder that leads to low blood platelets because the immune system attacks them.
Again, this subset of conditions was selected on the basis of safety signals in the safety data for COVID-19 from the much larger list published by the Brighton Collaborative. The followup came to 23,168,335 person-years of followup, with comparison made to the expected (background) rates for these conditions, which were obtained by participating sites using pre-COVID-19 vaccination healthcare data stratified by age and sex using data from 2015 to 2019 (2019–2020 for Denmark). A ratio of observed/expected (OE) was then calculated for each AESI.
So, what did the investigators find? I’ll summarize. An elevated observed/expected ratio was observed for the following key AESIs:
    • Gillain-Barré syndrome (2.49x elevated OE) following the first dose of the ChAdOx1 vaccine (replication-deficient adenovirus-based vaccine, AstraZeneca). This signal was not observed for the other vaccines.
    • Cerebral venous sinus thrombosis (3.23x elevated OE) following the first dose of the ChAdOx1 vaccine (replication-deficient adenovirus-based vaccine, AstraZeneca).
    • Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (3.78x elevated OE) following the first dose of mRNA-1273 vaccine (Moderna).
    • Pericarditis (6.9x elevated OE after a third dose of ChAdOx1-based vaccine); 1.7x and 2.6x elevated OE after the first and fourth doses of mRNA-1273 (Moderna). I note that the patter with the Moderna vaccine is rather odd (first and fourth dose, but no elevated risk otherwise), which suggests to me a possible spurious result. See table following this list.
    • Myocarditis was associated with the mRNA vaccines at all doses, confirming a lot of earlier findings, but less so with the adenovirus-based vaccines. See table below.
This might sound very scary, and indeed antivaxxers have even made a chart to make it look that way:
Nothing to see here. Move on. https://t.co/yvbgAl138u pic.twitter.com/6OOBvm72zj
— Craig Kelly (@CraigKellyPHON) February 21, 2024
Notice how they make the list as long as possible by breaking out risks after different doses and then include a scary graphic of a syringe and needle plus illustrations of SARS-CoV2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19.
Remember, though, that these are relative ratios and say nothing about the actual number of AESIs being examined. If you look at the absolute numbers, the results become a lot less scary. For example, After the first dose of the AstraZeneca vaccine, there was a 3.2x greater-than-expected risk of cerebral venous sinus thrombosis observed in 69 events, compared to an expected 21.That’s out of over 23 million doses of this vaccine. Similarly for Guillain-Barré syndrome, 76 events were expected, but 190 events were observed. That’s out of over 23 million doses of this vaccine. As for acute disseminated encephalomyelitis, seven cases were observed after vaccination with the Pfizer vaccine compared to the two cases that would be expected. That’s out of 183 million doses.
For example, the authors also found a possible safety signal for transverse myelitis and acute disseminated encephalomyelitis, but, again, look at the raw numbers. There were seven cases of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis after vaccination with the Pfizer vaccine (out of nearly 184 million doses), versus the expected number of two. In other words, these adverse events are quite rare. They might be elevated after vaccination but remain rare. I also like to point out that being able to detect single digit numbers of adverse events after 180+ million doses of vaccines rather puts the lie to claims by antivaxxers that we can’t detect rare adverse events.
There is another issue, as well. Remember the comparator: The populations in these countries from 2015 to 2019; i.e., the years immediately prepandemic. The question is whether the denominator (expected/background rate) was affected by the pandemic, and likely it was given this:
Meanwhile, the chances of having a neurological event after a Covid infection were up to 617-fold higher than following COVID vaccination, which suggests “the benefits of vaccination substantially outweigh the risks,” according to the Vaccine study researchers. The risk of developing myocarditis is higher post-Covid infection than after getting a Covid vaccine, according to Akiko Iwasaki, PhD, professor of Immunobiology at Yale University. Myocarditis risk after the second dose of a Covid vaccine is 35.9 per 100,000 people, compared to a 64.9 per 100,000 risk after Covid infection. The risk of developing Guillain-Barre syndrome after Covid infection was six times greater, and the risk of developing it after vaccination was 0.41 times greater than the control group, according to a 2023 study published in Neurology.
Consequently, although the elevated risk of various SAESIs associated with these vaccines appears to be significantly elevated (although still rare) after vaccination with certain COVID-19 vaccines, the elevated risk might be less than the investigators estimated if COVID-19 itself led to elevations in the rates of these conditions above baseline.
Of course, none of these considerations trouble antivaxxers, who immediately seized on the study to portray vaccines as deadly.
Steve Kirsch’s gonna Steve Kirsch: Or, how I learned to stop worrying and love any study that I can spin
You already saw how one antivaxxer on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, spun the results by leaving out absolute numbers and context. Leave it to everyone’s favorite tech bro turned rabid (and particularly stupid) antivaxxer, Steve Kirsch, to crank the fear mongering up to 11:
A new study of over 99 million vaccinated people has been highly promoted in the press with headlines like “Covid Vaccines Linked To Small Increase In Heart And Brain Disorders, Study Finds—But Risk From Infection Is Far Higher.”
I’m going to convince you that this is bullshit.
Oh, goody. Whenever Mr. Kirsch says something like this, I know that I’m about to be buried in a veritable pile of stinking, drippy diarrheal bullshit. He starts by referring to the chart made by the antivaxxer above and asking:
A safe vaccine would be indistinguishable from a placebo. Does this look safe to you?
See what I said about the Nirvana fallacy? No, Mr. Kirsch. No one in the public health community of scientists and physicians has ever said that a safe vaccine must have an adverse events profile indistinguishable from that due to placebo. That’s your invention, a massive straw man based on the Nirvana fallacy, in which anything less than perfect safety (zero adverse events) and perfect efficacy (100% effective in preventing not just disease but transmission) is viewed as a reason to reject the vaccine. Rather, a safe vaccine is one that is effective and has an acceptable adverse reaction profile in the context of the risk of harm to the population from the disease being vaccinated against.
As predicted, Mr. Kirsch also pulled out the ever-popular antivax appeal to “long term” safety:
They only looked for 42 days after the shots since everyone knows you can’t get adverse events after 42 days (I’m being sarcastic).
Actually, it’s pretty accurate to say that adverse events six or more weeks after vaccination are very, very rare indeed. I’ll just cite this article summarizing the question, as I like to do whenever antivaxxers drop this trope on me. If one wants to quibble, the article does acknowledge some adverse events up to eight weeks after vaccination, but Mr. Kirsch isn’t being that pedantic. For him, any time frame after vaccination chosen for examining adverse events would be too short because he is an antivaxxer and for antivaxxers no time frame is “long term enough” for any vaccine safety study.
Next up:
They didn’t evaluate mortality due to the shot since everyone knows the vaccines are safe and didn’t kill anyone (I’m being sarcastic).
Because, of course, Mr. Kirsch falsely believes that the vaccines have killed millions of people. Here’s the thing, though. First, this study was designed to look at AESIs based on the literature thus far about COVID-19 vaccine safety. If the vaccine were as deadly as Mr. Kirsch deludedly believes it to be, it would have shown up long ago, picked up by the vaccine safety monitoring systems in the US, Europe, Australia, Canada, etc. (Seriously, the level of utter fantasy-based thinking that it takes to believe that tens of millions of deaths would either not be noticed by these systems or would be covered up is truly difficult for science-based people to comprehend.) Here, he’s covering up the flimsiness of his critique with sarcasm.
Next up:
They found clearly increased risk of the various AESI, but the end conclusion is that the risks after COVID infection are far higher, so people should take the shots. This is unbelievable. I don’t know a single cardiologist whose business dropped after the COVID vaccines rolled out. Do you?
Actually, the study itself says almost nothing about the risks of the shots relative to the risks from COVID-19. Seriously. Go read it. I’ll wait. Mr. Kirsch is conflating an interview with Akiko Iwasaki, PhD, professor of Immunobiology at Yale University (which I quoted above) with the actual conclusions of the paper.
Here’s basically all the paper says about the risk-benefit ratio:
The safety signals identified in this study should be evaluated in the context of their rarity, severity, and clinical relevance. Moreover, overall risk–benefit evaluations of vaccination should take the risk associated with infection into account, as multiple studies demonstrated higher risk of developing the events under study, such as GBS, myocarditis, or ADEM, following SARS-CoV-2 infection than vaccination.
In other words, it’s saying that these safety signals should be contextualized in terms of their clinical relevance and the risk of these AESIs relative to the risk from the disease, not the definitive statement straw-manned by Mr. Kirsch. He also throws in an appeal to personal incredulity for good measure. Here’s a hint: Just because you can’t believe something doesn’t mean it’s not true. As for the bit about the cardiologist. That’s an appeal to personal anecdote and utterly meaningless. After all, no one is saying that myocarditis isn’t a risk after certain COVID-19 vaccines, and certainly no one is claiming that cardiologists have lost business since the vaccines rolled out. Yet that doesn’t stop Mr. Kirsch from repeating that same brain-dead line again later in his post.
And, of course, there’s the conspiracy theory in which “They” are “hiding” the “truth” from you:
As usual, they aren’t allowed to share the data so you have to take their word for it.
The reason they aren’t allowed to share the data is that the databases used contain individual-level health records with protected health information (PHI). Given how Mr. Kirsch has received a stolen database from New Zealand with PHI that he’s misused to claim that COVID-19 vaccines have killed 13 million people. He even threatened to release PHI from the stolen database that he has as a means of pressuring the New Zealand government. So, yes. I wouldn’t let Mr. Kirsch anywhere near PHI of any kind either. He’s proven himself to be utterly untrustworthy.
The rest of Mr. Kirsch’s diatribe consists mainly of him cherry picking a single study to claim that COVID-19 vaccines don’t work. (Remember, if there is no benefit to the vaccine, then any risk at all from it is unacceptable, which is why antivaxxers try their damnedest to deny any benefit at all from the vaccines or to argue that the benefit is so minimal as not to be worth even the rare adverse event.) He cites a dubious year-old analysis of the VAERS database from Josh Guetzkow, who has long been trying to portray antivax crankery as “suppressed.”
He then argues that, even if it is true that the risk of various adverse events is higher with COVID-19 than with the vaccine:
But even if that was true (which it isn’t), it doesn’t matter because, as I mentioned earlier, the vaccine doesn’t prevent you from getting COVID, so the vaccine is simply adding to the risk.
Again, Mr. Kirsch bases this assertion on one cherry picked study and then cites his own ridiculous Internet/Substack survey as though it were evidence of anything other than that his audience believes that COVID-19 vaccines cause horrific complications and an antivax propaganda film disguised as a documentary (and promoted by The Epoch Times), The Unseen Crisis. As is typical of such “documentaries,” it largely consists of anecdotes by people who blame COVID-19 vaccines for their various and sundry health problems and complaining that doctors wont’ believe them, interspersed with interviews with antivax quacks like Robert Malone, Peter McCullough, and others attributing all sorts of harms to the vaccines, whether there’s good evidence that those harms were caused by the vaccines or not. Mr. Kirsch notes that he’s in it, too, because of course he is.
He concludes by lying about the New Zealand data:
All my attempts at data transparency have been rejected. The health authorities have determined that you get better public health outcomes if you keep the public in the dark. So all my calls for data transparency fall on deaf ears. The best “ground truth” data we have is from the New Zealand data leak…and it clearly shows that the vaccine increases mortality. The critics acknowledge I’m right, but say that “it must be due to a confounder.” More on that coming up tomorrow.
No, as I’ve discussed, people keep telling Mr. Kirsch he’s wrong because his analysis was risibly incompetent and he could well have a biased sample from the overall database, among other problems. Kirsch is gonna Kirsch though; that is, he’ll never admit error but will instead repeatedly double down when his errors are pointed out.
Heads I win, tails you lose
In the end, this study and how antivaxxers have spun it is an excellent example of “Heads I win, tails you lose.” While the study puts the lie to the ideas that vaccines aren’t studied for safety, that we don’t carefully study potential adverse events from vaccination, and that we can’t detect rare events in vaccine safety studies, like all vaccine safety studies that acknowledge rare adverse events due to vaccination, it provides grist for the antivax propaganda mill. Again, if you assume, as antivaxxers do, that vaccines don’t work, then of course you’re going to conclude that the adverse event profile of any vaccine should be indistinguishable from placebo because if an intervention has no benefit then even one adverse event makes the risk-benefit ratio one divided by zero, or infinity. Similarly, if you don’t believe that the disease is dangerous (as antivaxxers try to portray COVID-19, then no adverse events are acceptable because you don’t need the vaccine. In any event, it is a fantasyland antivaxxers are living in, because no pharmaceutical product that is effective is 100% safe. In the real world we have to weigh risks versus benefits. In antivaccine world, only the risks matter, and no risk, no matter how small, is acceptable.
As I said before, it’s the Nirvana fallacy combined with trying to convince you that vaccines don’t work. No matter how safe a study demonstrates a given vaccine to be, as this study demonstrates the COVID-19 vaccine to be very safe but not perfectly safe, antivaxxers will spin it by emphasizing only the risk side of the equation. They used to do it long before the pandemic, and they do it with a vengeance now.

How antivaxxers weaponize vaccine safety studies to falsely portray vaccines as dangerous, part 2: The children
A few months ago, I wrote about how antivaxxers misrepresent vaccine safety studies to portray vaccines as dangerous, using a large study of outcomes in adults as an example.. They’re doing it again, but this time it’s a large study of COVID-19 vaccines in children.
David Gorski on June 17, 2024
Link

[Editor’s note: Sorry that this published about 12 hours later than normal. Somehow, I had the draft all done yesterday but forgot to set it to publish at the usual 3 AM time. Better late than never, hopefully.]
Back in February, I wrote about an incident demonstrating how antivaccine activists weaponize vaccine safety studies to falsely portray vaccines as more dangerous than the disease. The example that I used was a study published by a large multinational research group in the journal Vaccine using the Global Vaccine Data Network (GVDN) to examine thirteen medical conditions that the group considered “adverse events of special interest” (AESI) potentially associated with COVID-19 vaccination. The study involved examining the records of more than 99 million vaccinated individuals in eight countries, with the intention of identifying higher-than-expected cases of one or more AESIs after a COVID-19 vaccination, the investigation covering the most commonly used vaccines, the mRNA-based vaccines distributed by Pfizer and Moderna, as well as nonreplicating adenovirus vector-based vaccines. and protein-based vaccines. Overall, it was a massive undertaking that belied the frequent antivax lie that vaccines aren’t studied for safety and efficacy, but somehow antivaxxers tried to spin it as showing the vaccines to be horribly dangerous.
Unsurprisingly, they’re at it again.
How antivaxxers spin a vaccine safety study
Let’s take a look at the headlines and spin by antivaxxers, after which I’ll look at the study itself. First up, The Epoch Times, whose headline reads Elevated Risk of Epilepsy, Appendicitis in Children After COVID-19 Vaccination: Study and which begins:
Children who received the AstraZeneca or Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccines faced an elevated risk of epilepsy and appendicitis, according to a new study.
Pfizer recipients were also more likely to suffer from demyelinating disease or heart inflammation, researchers found.
Dr. Julia Hippisley-Cox, a professor of clinical epidemiology at the University of Oxford’s Nuffield Department of Primary Health Care Sciences, and colleagues obtained data from a national database on COVID-19 vaccination, mortality, hospital admissions, and COVID-19 infections. They wanted to look at the link between COVID-19 vaccines from AstraZeneca, Pfizer, and Moderna with 12 outcomes, including the heart inflammation condition called myocarditis.
Sounds alarming, right? Also notice that the article says nothing else about the other findings of the study, nor does it say anything about the magnitude of the increased incidence found, either relative or absolute, not to mention that it doesn’t say anything about the benefits also reported by the study. (Again, I’ll get to that in a moment.)
Unsurprisingly, one of Mike Adams’ minions, “Lance D. Johnson,” over at Natural News goes even further, with a headline Study finds increased risk of epilepsy, severe allergic shock, myocarditis and appendicitis in children injected with COVID-19 vaccines. The beginning of the post is a dump of antivax talking points thrown in with the cherry-picked, context-free findings of the study:
A recent study, analyzing records from over 5 million children, revealed that those who received either the AstraZeneca or Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccines faced increased risks of epilepsy and appendicitis. Additionally, recipients of the Pfizer vaccine showed higher probabilities of demyelinating disease and heart inflammation.
Dr. Anthony Fauci, the former Director of the National Institute of Allergy, and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), quickly recommended COVID-19 vaccines for children in the United States. In the UK, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) began distributing the vaccines to children as quickly as they could be approved.
As these so-called vaccines became available for younger age groups, public health leaders emphasized the importance of vaccinating children to not only safeguard their health but also to contribute to broader community immunity against COVID-19. Dr. Fauci’s recommendations were parroted by the “experts” at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the World Health Organization (WHO), which endorsed COVID-19 vaccination for children as young as six months old.
Today, the CDC has the COVID-19 vaccines on the childhood vaccine schedule, right along with 70+ doses contained in various combination vaccines that are now suspect in the chronic disease epidemic that is ravaging American children.
Notice that last bit, which is nothing more than a very old antivax talking point, in which antivaxxers count individual components of combination vaccines (e.g., MMR, which contains measles, mumps, and rubella vaccines, and DTaP, which contains diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis vaccines) as a vaccine and then adds up every dose recommended to come up with a number as high as they can, even if they have to distort, in order to make it seem as though children get an unreasonably large number of vaccines in their first 18 years of life. Never mind that this is a huge distortion and that there is no evidence that vaccines are responsible for a “chronic disease epidemic” among our children.
Unsurprisingly, the result of this sort of spin was a flurry of antivax postings on various social media pointing to the study as evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous for children:
Burn. In. Hell.#covid #vax #c19 https://t.co/bPpKWDBAct pic.twitter.com/4LAwabwsS1
— Stella X (@GreenEy3sOpen) May 31, 2024
Living in evil times…https://t.co/H2PACSHYq7 https://t.co/OIeXmozAGR
— Keith "ULTRA MAGA" #InfoWars (@KeithReuland) June 4, 2024
https://t.co/OhzQFIxLtS Risking your own life is one thing, but screwing up your kid's life because of your ignorance is criminal.
— Maya Chiy (@maya_chiy) June 2, 2024
I could go on, but you get the idea. The spin has been to portray this study as evidence that vaccines are more dangerous than the disease in children, just as antivaxxers did with the large safety study in adults published in February. Let’s take a look at the study itself.
What a study concludes vs. what antivaxxers say
As I approached this section of my post, I was half tempted just to cite this exchange:
Antovaxxers in 5….4…..3…….. "In only 5.1 million children? What about the rest? What about outcomes 10 years from now? Is it a placebo controlled double blind study?………"
— KayRay (@ktibus) May 28, 2024
Of course, me being me, you know that I just can’t stop there. So let’s look at the study by Copeland et al, entitled, Safety outcomes following COVID-19 vaccination and infection in 5.1 million children in England. One advantage—among many—of having a single payer government-funded health insurance plan that covers all citizens is that, unlike the case in the US where health records and databases are fragmented, there is generally a single database that can be mined for health outcomes like this. In this case, the investigators used the English National Immunisation Management Service (NIMS) database of COVID-19 vaccination, whose records are linked at the individual-level to national data for mortality, hospital admissions, and SARS-CoV-2 infection. Using this database:
We undertook a self-controlled case series design, originally developed to examine vaccine safety36,37, to investigate the association between COVID-19 vaccines available in the UK between 8th December 2020 and 7th August 2022 (BNT162b2, mRNA-1273 and ChAdOx1) and hospitalisation with the following pre-specified outcomes: myocarditis21,22, MIS-C38, immune thrombocytopenia (ITP)39, epilepsy40, acute pancreatitis41, acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM)42, Guillain-Barre syndrome43, appendicitis44, demyelinating disease6, myositis45, angioedema46 and anaphylaxis46. We also investigated the association of SARS-CoV-2 infection with these outcomes in children who had been vaccinated prior to infection compared to those who were unvaccinated at time of infection. We compared the incidence of hospitalisation from each outcome in the six weeks following vaccination or SARS-CoV-2 infection relative to the baseline period, and estimated the absolute risk as the excess number of events expected per million children exposed. We also conducted a matched cohort analysis using vaccinated and unvaccinated children included the QResearch primary care database to improve the robustness of the study.
Here’s a bit more on the methodology regarding outcomes of COVID-19 infection in vaccinated versus unvaccinated children:
The cohort included all children aged 5–17 years who had received at least one dose of BNT162b2, mRNA-1273 or ChAdOx1 vaccine or who had a positive SARS-CoV-2 test between 8th December 2020 and 7th August 2022. In each self-controlled case series analysis, we only included children who were admitted to hospital or died from the outcome during the study period and excluded children with a hospitalisation for the same outcome in the two years prior to 8th December 2020 and those who received other COVID-19 vaccine types. We also undertook an analysis in young adults aged 18–24 years as a comparison.
Personally, I think it’s informative to compare what Mike Adams’ minion says to what the study actually finds; this to me is the best way to show how deceptive the spin on the study is. First, however, I like to cite this infographic provided by the investigators that summarizes the findings in terms of excess incidents per million children for the prespecified adverse events examined:
Before I move on, I was curious about the appendicitis, which was hyped in the headlines of both Natural News and The Epoch Times as a risk found from the vaccine. If you read the abstract of the study and peruse the infographic, you’ll see that it’s not included as a major finding, which led me to suspect some picking of cherries, if you know what I mean. If you read the whole study, down to the discussion, you’ll find out why, as the authors conclude:
This study identified two strong safety signals in adolescents associated with the ChAdOX1 vaccine: appendicitis and epilepsy. A substantially increased risk of appendicitis was observed in adolescents following a second dose of ChAdOX1, with an additional 512 (95%CI 283–599) cases expected per million. This estimate is based on a small sample size as the ChAdOX1 vaccine was not approved for use in under-40s in the UK from April 20213,53. Additionally, the increased risk was not identified in the matched cohort study, suggesting the evidence from this study for a causal association between appendicitis and ChAdOX1 vaccination is weak. Appendicitis was highlighted as an outcome of interest for vaccine safety by the US Food and Drug Administration following a clinical trial of BNT162b2, which reported a higher number of appendicitis cases in the vaccine arm compared to the placebo arm44. However, subsequent evidence from observational studies and adverse event reporting databases is conflicting, limited to adults and primarily focusing on mRNA vaccines11,54,55.
Let’s look at Table 4 from the paper, which is one of the “money” tables in terms of summarizing findings:
In other words, the numbers were small, the 95% confidence intervals were wide, the elevated risk was only seen for the AstraZeneca vaccine in adolescents after a second dose, and the finding wasn’t consistent (the matched cohort study didn’t detect it), all of which is why the finding was mentioned and discussed but not highlighted. None of that stops Natural News:
Moreover, females who received AstraZeneca’s shot faced a significantly higher risk of hospitalization with epilepsy and appendicitis. The data on the Moderna vaccine was incomplete because the vaccine was not widely distributed to UK children.
Note the selectivity. But what about epilepsy, since that was examined too? Well, antivaxxers fail to mention this part of the analysis, in which the authors stated that they thought it unlikely that their observations indicated a causal effect:
We also observed a modest increased risk of hospitalisation with epilepsy in adolescents following a second dose of BNT162b2, with an additional 12 (95%CI 0-23) cases estimated per million exposed in 12–17-year-olds. However, a diagnosis of epilepsy is made over a period of time as it typically involves outpatient referral, a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan and an electroencephalogram47. Therefore, this reported increased risk of epilepsy is highly unlikely to reflect new-onset epilepsy triggered by the vaccine. A limitation of the data was that we were only able to exclude prior hospital admissions with epilepsy (or any of the pre-specified outcomes) in the two years preceding the study start date. Therefore, the increase in admissions reported here is more likely to reflect seizures in children with an already underlying diagnosis of epilepsy or other chronic neurological condition but who hadn’t been hospitalised in the previous two years, which we were unable to capture in our dataset, rather than new diagnoses.
And later:
Following a first dose of ChAdOX1, we observed a substantially increased risk of hospitalisation with epilepsy, particularly in females, with 813 (95%CI 44–1164) excess cases estimated per million female adolescents vaccinated with a first dose of ChAdOX1, but as discussed above, these are not likely to reflect new diagnoses of epilepsy. The small sample size (only 0.3% of adolescents received ChAdOX1 for the first dose) and resulting wide confidence interval for this estimate should be noted. We also found that there was a higher proportion of adolescents with a hospital admission for epilepsy in the two years prior to the study start date who received ChAdOX1 for the first dose (2.7%), compared to BNT162b2 (0.2%) and mRNA-1273 (0.6%). While these individuals were excluded from the analysis, it is indicative that a higher proportion of adolescents who received a ChAdOX1 vaccine were included in a priority group, such as those with a chronic neurological disease including epilepsy3, compared to those who received mRNA vaccines and that the majority of hospitalisations with epilepsy following ChAdOX1 were likely in adolescents with a pre-existing condition. We did not identify an increased risk of hospitalisation with epilepsy following vaccination with ChAdOX1 in the matched cohort study. Our findings, together with a recent study that found evidence for increased risk of cardiac death in young women following a first dose of non-mRNA vaccine56, suggest that further work would need to be done to ensure the safety of ChAdOX1 in young people if it were to be used in future vaccination programmes.
In other words, the increased risk of hospitalization with epilepsy or seizures might be associated with the vaccines, but is small and could well be restricted to children with pre-existing epilepsy, whether diagnosed or not. Moreover, as antivaxxers are won’t to do, even this small increased risk, if real, is not compared with the risk of the disease. Indeed, the number of excess cases of epilepsy after infection is higher (16 per million) than after vaccination (12 per million).
As for myocarditis, which is the one adverse event that is clearly associated with the mRNA vaccines in adolescents, the authors found:
In our cohort of > 2.8 million vaccinated adolescents aged 12–17 years, we estimated 3 (95%CI 0–5) and 5 (95%CI 3–6) excess cases of myocarditis per million exposed in the 1–42 days following a first and second dose of BNT162b2, respectively. We did not observe an increased risk of myocarditis following vaccination with mRNA-1273 in adolescent males or females as some previous studies have reported23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32. However, the mRNA-1273 vaccine was only given to a relatively small number of adolescents in England, primarily for the third booster dose, therefore the study was underpowered to detect statistically significant associations, except for very large effect sizes. As expected, we observed a substantially increased risk of myocarditis in the 1–42 days following almost all doses of both mRNA vaccines in young adults aged 18–24 years compared to the baseline period, consistent with other studies reporting an increased risk of myocarditis in young adult males following a second mRNA-1273 vaccine dose24,25,26. Importantly, however, there were no deaths following a diagnosis of myocarditis in under-18s, and our findings are likely to reflect self-limiting disease.
In other words, the authors’ findings are consistent with what we already know about myocarditis following vaccination; it’s generally mild and self-limited.
Now, let’s look at what the authors of the study concluded:
In summary, we found no strong evidence for increased risks of 12 pre-specified vaccine safety outcomes following COVID-19 vaccination in children aged 5–11 years and no new significant safety concerns in 12–17-year-olds following vaccination with mRNA vaccines recommended for use in these age groups in the UK by the JCVI. Additionally, in unvaccinated children we found increased risks of hospitalisation from seven adverse outcomes including MIS-C and myocarditis following SARS-CoV-2 infection that were either not observed, or were reduced, following vaccination. Overall, our findings support a favourable safety profile of COVID-19 vaccination using mRNA vaccines in children and young people aged 5-17 years.
I agree. This study is further evidence of a good safety profile for COVID-19 vaccines among children. Of course, if you’re an antivaxxer, there can only be one reason why the study authors conclude that the safety profile is favorable, and I bet you can guess what it is:
The authors of the study had previously served on various UK and Scottish Government COVID-19 advisory groups that recommended COVID-19 vaccines for children. The authors, funded by the National Institutes of Health, also enjoy financial ties to Moderna and AstraZeneca.
This could be the reason why the authors provided a perplexing conclusion to the study’s results. The authors said that their findings “support a favorable safety profile of COVID-19 vaccination using mRNA vaccines in children and young people aged 5-17 years.” This mockingly dangerous conclusion should put all their careers in jeopardy, considering that the study found an increase in hospitalizations because of the COVID-19 vaccines. The lead author, Dr. Julia Hippisley-Cox, did not comment on the study.
Of course, Mike Adams’ minion thinks that the only reason why the investigators who did this study concluded that the risk-benefit profile for COVID-19 vaccines is favorable in children must be because they are in the pay of big pharma. I did, however, briefly wonder if I should have looked at the COI statement at the end of the study before I poo-pooed Adams’ minion too much. So I did:
This research is funded by the NIHR School for Primary Care Research, Grant Reference Number 622. The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care. We acknowledge the contribution of EMIS practices who contribute to QResearch and EMIS Health and the Universities of Nottingham and Oxford for expertise in establishing, developing or supporting the QResearch database. This project involves data derived from anonymised patient-level information collected by the NHS. The SARS-CoV-2 test data were originally collated, maintained and quality assured by Public Health England (PHE) and transferred to NHS England during the study. Access to the data was therefore facilitated by NHS England. The Hospital Episode Statistics, Secondary Users Service (SUS-PLUS) datasets and civil registration data are used by permission from NHS England who retain the copyright in that data. NHS England and Public Health England bears no responsibility for the analysis or interpretation of the data. JHC is supported by an NIHR senior investigator award. NLM is supported by a British Heart Foundation Chair Award (CH/F/21/90010), Programme Grant (RG/20/10/34966) and Research Excellence Award (RE/18/5/34216). DPJH is supported by the Wellcome Trust (215621/Z/19/Z), Medical Research Foundation and UKDRI (principal funder UKRI Medical Research Council).
So this research was funded by a grant from the UK National Institute for Healthcare Research. If the authors have financial ties to the pharma companies and it wasn’t mentioned in the Acknowledgments section as a conflict of interest, that would be something, for sure, but thus far I haven’t been able to find evidence of Julia Hippisley-Cox or any of the other authors having financial ties with Moderna and AstraZeneca and will say outright that, if any of the authors do have such ties, they should have been disclosed in the Acknowledgments section.
My guess, though, is that these “ties” are the sorts of guilt-by-secondary association “ties” that antivaxxers love to use, such as when Mike Adams falsely accused me of being in the pocket of Sanofi-Aventis because I was doing research using a drug made by the company and my university had accepted research grants from Sanofi-Aventis. I will, however, accept correction if I missed something, unlike Mike Adams, who would double down.
        ◦ Antivaxxers like to claim that vaccine researchers don’t bother to look for adverse events due to vaccines, when in fact this study and the study that I discussed in February are very strong evidence that public health officials and vaccine researchers are very much interested in carefully assessing the risk-benefit profiles of vaccines, to the point of investing considerable resources to study outcomes in millions of adults and children. What antivaxxers really don’t like is that the results of these large studies consistently fail to support their fear mongering portraying vaccines as massively dangerous compared to the disease, and ineffective, to boot. They will weaponize any large study that carefully and honestly reports adverse events from vaccination, ignoring the magnitude of the risks (almost always very small) versus the benefit (significantly greater than the risks).

Echoes of measles outbreaks in 2019: Antivaxxers are targeting Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn with COVID-19 misinformation
About a year before the COVID-19 pandemic, large measles outbreaks among Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn and Rockland County were linked to misinformation targeted to their communities by antivaxxers. History is repeating itself with COVID-19.
David Gorski on November 1, 2021
Link

Let’s rewind to what now seems like ancient history, April 2019. It’s hard to believe that that was not even three years ago, but since the pandemic hit that time seems like an entirely different world. I realize that it seems almost quaint now in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, but back then the biggest concern with respect to infectious disease and vaccines was that measles was making a resurgence in multiple areas in the US. The reasons boiled down to the usual reasons for measles outbreaks: pockets of low vaccine uptake, fueled by vaccine hesitancy, which was fueled by antivaccine misinformation promoted by antivaxxers. Some of this misinformation was targeted at insular religious groups, like some communities of ultra-orthodox Jews, which led to my writing a post about how the situation was more complex than that. The picture being painted by the media at the time was that, for some reason, Orthodox Jewish communities were more susceptible to antivaccine misinformation and conspiracy mongering; in a post, I contrasted that to the fully enthusiastic and robust cooperation that the Orthodox Jewish community in the Detroit area gave to local public health officials, complete with vaccine drives and a full-throated endorsement of vaccination by the Council of Orthodox Rabbis of Greater Detroit, which urged Jews to vaccinate their children with MMR and that older adults whose immunity might have waned also receive the vaccine.

Unfortunately, efforts of antivaxxers to target insular communities like the Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn are nothing new. I’ve been writing about them a while, including a study of a measles outbreak in 2013 and how much it cost to contain. Worse, the efforts of antivaxxers like Del Bigtree and Larry Palevsky were bolstered by an antivaccine Rabbi named Hillel Handler, who invoked their religious authority to bolster the misinformation being spread by antivaxxers. Also, given the nature of the community, a lot of the misinformation was spread very much in an old school manner, by flyers and booklets, such as the ones spread by Parents Educating and Advocating for Children’s Health (PEACH).
Why did I start this post by recounting this unfortunate history? Simple. Past is prologue, and history repeats, as we’ve seen time and time again, or, as I like to put it, in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic and antivaxxers, everything old is new again. The same thing is happening now, in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic. Added to the list of previous players are new antivaxxers, quacks, and grifters who have risen to prominence over the last year and a half, like “the inventor of mRNA vaccines” Dr. Robert Malone, a man who thinks that he’s being “erased” from Wikipedia after his wife was caught editing his Wikipedia entry. This time, though, he’s been recruited to spread fear of COVID-19 vaccines, in particular the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, among the Orthodox Jews of Brooklyn and proudly announced his apparent “success” on Twitter the other day:
Apparently the testimony to the Hasidic Rabbinical court in New York City was useful, and a decision has been rendered.
SARS-CoV-2 vaccination is absolutely forbidden in children, and cautioned for adults.
I will post the hebrew and english versions when available.
— Robert W Malone, MD (@RWMaloneMD) October 29, 2021
Apparently, last week he’d been flown in by this group:
pic.twitter.com/rRalH5vg7A
— Robert W Malone, MD (@RWMaloneMD) October 27, 2021
They booked me into the TWA hotel at the JFK airport – it was awesome! That is also where the Connie airplane "resides" – for those wondering.https://t.co/PIt61CFL8K
— Robert W Malone, MD (@RWMaloneMD) October 27, 2021
First off, a number of Jews tell me that this Hasidic Rabbinical Council is at best sketchy, with no real authority other than the individual authority of the rabbis making it up. I don’t know, but they certainly have the air of a group trying to seem a lot more influential in their religion than they really are. (I’ll let any Orthodox Jews from Brooklyn or Borough Park comment, if any are reading, or just any Orthodox Jews.)
Indeed, on Twitter:
As a member of the Hasidic community, we have no idea who these Rabbis are or who this ‘Rabbinical Court’ is.
— Eli Wohl (@elimail) October 29, 2021
Given that I am not Jewish, much less an Orthodox Jew, much less a member of the particular community being targeted, I cannot knowledgeably comment on the group dynamics any more than I could in May 2019. I can, however, look at what happened then, what’s happening now, and how it’s being spun, and then make comparisons to similar incidents in the past, all while addressing some of the specific antivaccine claims.
First, however, an antivaxxer provided a useful translation:
Which led to comments like this, one from basically asking who the heck these rabbis even are:
I'm from NY, part of the Hassidic community. Do you know anything about them? I've never heard of them.
— Esther Mund (@esther_mund) October 29, 2021
There is no rabbinical court, which this isn’t from one anyway, that has any legal authority in America. GTFO
— Abe Seeman (@midtowner33) October 30, 2021
A Google Translation of the document tells me that the rabbis involved are not any that I’ve written about. (Surprisingly, Rabbi Handler appears not to have been involved, which, I suppose, is a blessing.)
So what’s going on? To me, it looks as though antivaxxers are partying like it’s 2019, but with even more potentially deadly consequences. Spreading antivaccine misinformation among the Orthodox Jewish communities now has the potential for orders of magnitude more death and suffering than targeting them for misinformation about measles vaccines in 2019 did.
Antivaccine misinformation in Brooklyn
Over the weekend, a reader of my not-so-secret other blog (and hopefully this one too) pointed me to this website, MACABIM. This is clearly the website of this “rabbinical council,” as you can see the “experts” recruited to “give testimony” regarding COVID-19 vaccines:
Physicians, Scientists, and Community Activists Standing for Truth, Medical Freedom, and G-d Awareness. We promote early, lifesaving treatment for corona, and oppose the injection and the vaccine mandates. We stand for free speech, freedom of information, informed consent, and transparency.
By the grace of G-dEmergency Rabbinical Court Meeting on the Corona InjectionsTuesday October 268 hours of expert testimony by:Dr. Geert Vanden BosscheDr. Peter McCulloughDr. Robert MaloneAttorney Thomas RenzDr. Jane RubyDr. Michael YeadonDr. Christiane NorthrupDr. Janci LindsayDr. Richard UrsoDr. Jessica RosePlus healthcare providers caring for victims and victims telling their own storieshttps://www.dropbox.com/s/2df6b5l0ttrrzjt/asifas%20c19%20ch.mp4?dl=0The Rabbis are putting out a statement in the wake of this testimony.
Also included is a link to a PDF of the same statement in Hebrew Tweeted out by Malone and others. So, yes, these are the right people, and this is the right website. I will admit that I didn’t watch the hours of video of the testimony provided in the Dropbox link above. As you will see, there really wasn’t a need to subject myself to all of it, because the website summarizes the findings and reports a “judgment,” and I could tell that much of the testimony was antivaccine misinformation that I’ve covered before.
Looking at that list of “experts,” I couldn’t help but be struck at just how many cranks there are, including several about whom I (and other SBM bloggers) have written. For instance, Dr. Christiane Northrup used to engage in thermography grift but, like so many quacks before her, has effortlessly pivoted to COVID-19 grift, to join the list of the “Disinformation Dozen“. Geert Vanden Bossche is known for promoting the unproven and untrue concept that a mass vaccination campaign against COVID-19 during a pandemic is a horrible idea that will lead to untold deaths through the selection of ever more virulent “escape mutant” variants, a discredited idea that very much resembles what the godfather of the modern antivaccine movement Andrew Wakefield once claimed about vaccination against measles a few months before SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, first reared its ugly head in Wuhan, China. Dr. Peter McCullough has also been featured here for his prediction of a “vaccine holocaust” in which COVID-19 vaccines lead to “depopulation“. It’s a claim driven by dumpster diving in the VAERS database to produce deceptively high estimates of death rates after COVID-19 vaccination that ignore the baseline rate of mortality that happens without vaccines. Let’s not forget Dr. Michael Yeadon, either. He’s the one falsely warning of mass infertility due to COVID-19 vaccination, as well as claiming that booster shots for COVID-19 vaccines will be our “death knell” through “depopulation“. Finally, of course, there’s Dr. Robert Malone, “inventor of mRNA vaccines”, whose wife Dr. Jill Glasspool Malone was busted editing his Wikipedia page in order to promote him as—you guessed it!—the “inventor of mRNA vaccines”. Oddly enough, for someone claiming to have invented the technology, Malone is unrelentingly negative about the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna vaccines. I suspect both grift and envy, but who knows?
As for the others, I’ve heard of some of them but never really written about them before. They are all—surprise! surprise!—COVID-19 minimizers and antivaxxers. Dr. Richard Urso (briefly mentioned on SBM here), for instance, is an ophthalmologist and member of “America’s Frontline Doctors”, who promoted the repurposed and unproven drug hydroxychloroquine as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19 back in the summer of 2020. These days, America’s Frontline Doctors have managed to have one of their own put in charge of public health in Florida as they continue to spread COVID-19 misinformation after having pivoted to promoting the COVID-19 “miracle cure” of 2021, ivermectin. (They’ve also sued over deaths from COVID-19 vaccines and been caught grifting by selling telehealth visits in which they sold ivermectin prescriptions.) Oddly enough, no one on SBM has written about Jane Ruby before. A few months ago, she promoted a false claim that the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine is “99.9% graphene oxide”, a claim so ridiculous that perhaps no one here thought it worth bothering with, but Politifact did. (So much disinformation, so little time.) As for Dr. Jancy Lindsay, although no one here has written about her specifically, we have written about the false claim that she promotes, namely that the spike protein used by COVID-19 vaccines as the antigen sufficiently resembles syncytin-1, a placental protein, as to result in an immune reaction against it that can cause miscarriages and infertility. As I have written, this claim is utter nonsense from a molecular biology standpoint. Dr. Jessica Rose, it appears, was a postdoctoral researcher in biology at the Israel Institute of Technology from 2016-20 but more recently has joined the COVID-19 minimization grift train, publishing bad studies that dumpster dive in VAERS for the COVID misinformation site trialsitenews.com and working with former scientist and antivaxxer James Lyons-Weiler for the Institute of Pure and Applied Knowledge (IPAK) to misuse VAERS to demonize COVID-19 vaccines. Finally, Thomas Renz is a formerly little-known attorney (who only became a licensed attorney months before the pandemic hit on his fifth attempt to pass the Ohio bar exam) who’s found a way to boost his standing by promoting COVID-19 misinformation and filing dubious lawsuits over COVID-19 vaccine mandates.
Again, not being Jewish or part of the community, I have a hard time commenting much on this “Rabbinical court in New York City” or its legitimacy (although it reeks of “magnified minority” and an appeal to a false authority), but I can call its document out for what it is: Antivaccine nonsense. After all, just look at this image on the website:

Each and every one of these “Top Ten Reasons Not To Get Vaccinated Against COVID-19” is either a lie, disinformation, or a distortion of science. First, though, let’s take a look at the statement from these rabbis.
The statement
I will use a translation forwarded to me by a reader, who informed me that the person doing the translating didn’t want to be identified in this blog:
A time of trouble for Jacob
We gathered here to discuss the new mRNA “vaccine” (including Adenoviral vector DNA), and we heard opinions from great experts in this field, as well as doctors who created mRNA treatment themselves whom have testified on their actions (ordinary doctors are not proficient in these matters, and are only biding the government HIN, CDC etc instructions, as known) and have showed us the great risks and damages related to this (vaccine), and also the government and pharmaceutical companies deny many of it and hide information and make is difficult to know the harsh results caused to those who’ve already taken this mRNA vaccine, and also try in many ways to prevent the publications of these damages in the Media, Internet etc.
We also heard testimonies from our brothers in Israel who were sick, and furthermore, also what was harming future generations (I assume they mean here than not only men, but also pregnant women were harmed). And the worst thing is that there are simple ways to treat this illness yet they forbid using these treatments, and did whatever they could to create fear instead of practicing medicine, while they know the treatments can help.
And now this mRNA was approved for children, even though the disease is not dangerous to them, and they want to obligate children in order for them to go to schools and yeshivas.
Therefore we come to speak our opinion by the holy bible:
     1.  By the Holy Torah, it is strictly forbidden to give or to encourage giving this mRNA vaccine to children, young men and women, even if it means they can’t travel overseas. We must protest against it. Whoever has the power to prevent it, must do so.
     2.  Many damages were caused to pregnant women (some say it’s due to the SM102 and some say it’s the “antibodies” who fight the “protein” or causing micro blood clots). Therefore they can’t get this mRNA, and same goes for any healthy person.
     3.  For elderly people, more information is needed (because data is hidden) but clearly there’s a breakthrough, meaning there’s no difference between those who got the mRNA and those who haven’t. On the other hand, elderly people are also at risk, and we heard about old men who died shortly after receiving the mRNAs. So we also advise not to take the vaccine, especially since there are other useful treatments. We found out, by a lawyer who handles such matters, that the data they publish is also false, for example a man who died of covid a few days after receiving the vaccine is considered “unvaccinated” and there are more examples. We need to do our best to find the true data.
     4.  We heard testimonies from our brothers in Israel and experts, that he who gets this mRNA vaccine and is close to pregnant women can cause harm ,and this is called “shedding” (they use it in animals, when they can’t vaccinate all animals, they vaccinate some and the shedding spreads it to other animals). So far we don’t know how long the shedding lasts, so he who got the mRNA must stay away from pregnant women for 2 weeks from getting the shot.
     5.  It is strictly forbidden to encourage or force or pressure anyone to get the mRNA.
This is just based on what we know now, but the experts want about what lies ahead. God have mercy on us.
As you can see from the statement, these antivax rabbis (and, make no mistake, that is what they are) believe several myths about mRNA vaccines commonly spread among the antivaccine movement, the first of which is that the COVID-19 vaccine is more dangerous to the young (and children) than the disease. (Portraying vaccines as more risky than the diseases they prevent has been a favorite antivaccine trope for a very long time; so it is not surprising that it’s been applied to COVID-19 vaccines.) This is, as Jonathan Howard has written (e.g., here, here, here, and here), false.
They also believe the myth that COVID-19 vaccines cause miscarriages and infertility, a myth based on a misunderstanding of molecular biology and the syncytin protein that would embarrass any but the most antivaccine grifting scientist, as I’ve been writing about, dating back to last December. They also believe in the antivaccine myth of “shedding.” It’s a myth that had to be tweaked from an old antivaccine myth that virus “shedding” from live-attenuated virus vaccines is a danger to the unvaccinated, because COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are not live-attenuated virus vaccines. So antivaxxers changed the “shedding” myth from fear mongering about “shed” virus from the vaccine to shed spike protein from the COVID-19 vaccine. It’s even more nonsensical than the previous myth, given that the amount of spike protein generated by the COVID vaccine is incredibly tiny and does not shed. Then there’s the myth that there are “miracle cures” for COVID-19 like ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, which obviate the need to vaccinate even the elderly, who are most likely to suffer severe disease and death from the coronavirus. There aren’t cures. Ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine don’t work. Finally, apparently the antivaccine lawyer consulted is spreading the false claim that COVID-19 deaths are overcounted and misattributed to the unvaccinated even when they occur in the vaccinated. The example above is risible even if accurate because it takes the vaccine more than a few days to generate immunity and the most likely explanation for such a death would be that the person had an undiagnosed case of COVID-19 at the time of vaccination.
Of course, these myths are just the ones in the statement issued by these rabbis. The “Top Ten” list is far more antivaccine and peddles the nastiest antivaccine myths. (Perhaps the rabbis wanted to seem “reasonable” in their statement.) Get a load of some of these claims! First, there’s the claim that the vaccine has killed tens of thousands of people, which, as I’ve written, is based on the very old antivaccine tactic of dumpster diving in the VAERS database for a purpose for which it was never intended. There’s the COVID-19 minimization that it “only” kills 0.3%, which, even if accurate, still ends up being a hell of a lot of people, coupled with the false claim that there are cures that can prevent even those few from dying. (The MACABIM website includes a link to Vladmir Zelenko’s quack protocol using zinc, hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, ivermectin, and a number of other unproven and disproven treatments.) There’s Geert Vanden Bossche’s false claim that the vaccine drives the emergence of ever more transmissible and lethal variants, which is not true. Actually, allowing the coronavirus to circulate unchecked in huge numbers of people is the best way to allow the emergence of such variants; vaccines will not produce nastier variants. Nor are vaccines completely ineffective at preventing the transmission of SARS-CoV-2. They’re nowhere near 100% effective, of course (no vaccine is 100% at preventing the spread of the virus it’s targeted against either), but they do decrease the frequency of transmission and certainly don’t facilitate transmission. As the CDC states:
The risk for SARS-CoV-2 infection in fully vaccinated people cannot be completely eliminated as long as there is continued community transmission of the virus. Early data suggest infections in fully vaccinated persons are more commonly observed with the Delta variant than with other SARS-CoV-2 variants. However, data show fully vaccinated persons are less likely than unvaccinated persons to acquire SARS-CoV-2, and infections with the Delta variant in fully vaccinated persons are associated with less severe clinical outcomes. Infections with the Delta variant in vaccinated persons potentially have reduced transmissibility than infections in unvaccinated persons, although additional studies are needed.
The “Top Ten” also includes the false claims that the vaccines don’t work (false) and the usual conspiracy theories that vaccine injuries are being “covered up”; doctors are being “censored”; and VAERS reports are only a fraction of the “true” incidence of deaths and injuries due to the vaccine. It’s basically a “top ten” list of COVID-19 antivax tropes.
Weaponization of religion by antivaxxers
I’ve been writing about how antivaxxers have been weaponizing religious beliefs to try to portray vaccines as disgusting or as against various religions. Given my Catholic upbringing, the most common variety of this claim that I write about is the longstanding effort by antivaxxers to demonize vaccines by tying them to abortion based on the use in vaccine development and manufacture of some cell lines derived from aborted fetuses decades ago. These false claims range from saying that there is “fetal tissue in vaccines” (there isn’t and never has been) to the claim that there is “fetal DNA” in them (there might be an infinitesimally tiny amount left over from manufacture) to just the homeopathy-like claim that any association in the past with cells from an aborted fetus renders vaccines evil. They’ve been doing it for a very long time and are continuing to use this hoary old trope now, even though no such cell lines are used in the manufacture of the mRNA vaccines. At other times, I’ve noted how antivaxxers have over the years portrayed vaccines as against the Jewish and Muslim faiths because some of them contain gelatin, a protein that can be derived from pigs. In actuality, Islamic legal scholars and Jewish authorities long ago rejected that claim.
What theses rabbis are doing is nothing different from Catholic Bishops who tried to demonize the COVID-19 vaccines over abortion. One might say that the targeting of the Orthodox Jewish community by antivaxxers like Del Bigtree in 2019 has, in the age of the pandemic, borne even nastier fruit than just causing measles outbreaks, which was bad enough at the time. This year, the same sort of misinformation is being spread, for example:
In January and February of this year, the city found leaflets aimed at the Orthodox Jewish community in Brooklyn that wrongly suggested the Covid-19 mRNA vaccines could change a person’s DNA and were only 0.5 percent effective.
Worse, as noted by Anna Merlan:
And even before COVID, we’ve seen this same pattern before much more recently: The suspicion and refusal of basic public health measures leading an increasingly strict government response, thus heightening the original underlying suspicion. In 2018 and 2019, two severe measles outbreaks among New York’s Orthodox Jewish communities, one in Brooklyn and one in Rockland County in upstate New York, led to a series of increasingly heightened government actions. But public health officials were battling against a disinformation campaign by Orthodox anti-vaccine activists, and when measles continued to spread, unvaccinated children were briefly banned from being in public in Rockland County March 2019. The ban was overturned by the New York State Supreme Court, but by then, bigger anti-vaccine activists had alighted on the state’s Orthodox community. (Anti-vaccine celebrity Del Bigtree, for instance, pinned a yellow Star of David on himself in a speech, and then sent out a press release to make sure no one had missed it.) While the measles outbreak subsided, anti-vaccine suspicions—fueled, in part, by the memory of the government restrictions—have continued, and remain a factor in how Orthodox communities have responded to COVID vaccines.
Worse, the targeting still continues:
An author of a research paper published last month about coronavirus in Haredi communities told the Jewish Telegraph Agency that “no value in the paper approaches herd immunity.”
About 19% of Borough Park’s population has had at least one dose of the COVID-19 vaccine, which is the second-lowest rate in the city behind the neighborhood of Edgemere/Far-Rockaway, Queens. Citywide, 34% of people have had at least one dose.
Meanwhile, one robocall circulating in the community warns not only of infertility supposedly caused by the vaccine, but also of heart attacks, “aneurysm, stroke, hemorrhage, paralysis, seizures, psychosis, anxiety, cognitive problems, digestive disorders” and a laundry list of other problems.
One petition circulating in the community asks parents to sign if they are opposed to distributing vaccines to children in schools.
And on WhatsApp Tuesday morning, users were sharing a video of a woman counting funeral and shiva notices in her inbox, as she said she had more to attend now than she did during the entirety of 2020, suggesting those deaths were caused by the vaccine.
As I mentioned, though, in actuality, just as Catholic authorities have urged Catholics to be vaccinated, Jewish authorities strongly urge Jews to be vaccinated as well, as I pointed out long ago and former SBM blogger Dr. Peter Lipson pointed out more recently:
Then there’s JOWMA, an organization that provides health education to the Jewish community and supports current and future Orthodox female physicians. The group maintains a page of COVID-19 resources tailored to Orthodox Jews whose “Top Ten Reasons to Get Vaccinated Against COVID-19” was parodied by the rabbis who issued that statement. Don’t believe me? Here’s JOWMA’s page:

I will conclude, as I have all too often concluded since the pandemic started, by simply pointing out that in the age of COVID-19 everything old is new again. The same old antivaccine lies are being updated, tarted up, and recycled for COVID-19. The same old tactic of weaponizing religious belief to falsely representing vaccines as against the tenets of various religions has been resurrected. The same strategy of crafting antivaccine messages to resonate in relatively insular communities like the Haredi has been repurposed for COVID-19, with the aid of antivaccine religious leaders.
I’m reminded of Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series of novels, specifically, its introduction:
The Wheel of Time turns, and Ages come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legend fades to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Age that gave it birth comes again.
        ◦ Antivaccine lies are a lot like that, with one big exception. It doesn’t take ages for them to fade and return again. I’ve been reminded of this nearly every day since the pandemic hit, and the targeting of Orthodox Jews in Borough Park, Brooklyn, and other areas with antivaccine propaganda is just the most recent example. Another difference, unfortunately, is that the last time these sorts of antivaccine lies were circulating widely and various tight-knit communities were targeted, a depressing number of my colleagues were not paying attention. Some even dismissed efforts to combat antivaccine misinformation as not worthwhile. I wonder if they still think that. I also wonder how quickly, once the pandemic finally abates, the lessons learned will “fade to myth” again before the wheel comes around yet again.

Died Suddenly: A tsunami of antivax misinformation and conspiracy theories
Everything old is new again when it comes to antivax tropes. Stew Peters’ antivax pseudodocumentary Died Suddenly resurrects the old antivax conspiracy that vaccines kill, the plan being to cause “depopulation” that will allow “global elites” to control the world. Dr. Gorski watched the whole movie so that you don’t have to.
David Gorski on December 5, 2022
Link

Two weeks ago, COVID-19 conspiracy theorist Stew Peters released an antivaccine pseudodocumentary on Rumble titled Died Suddenly. The central premise of the film is the old antivax claim that vaccines are a tool to promote “global depopulation,” with the film’s main narrative being that COVID-19 vaccines have over the last two years caused huge numbers of otherwise young and healthy people to “die suddenly” from massive clotting caused by the spike protein produced by mRNA vaccines. Key to supporting this narrative are several embalmers featured in the film— most prominently Richard Hirschman—who claim that they are seeing more and different clots of a highly unusual nature in the recently deceased than ever before, a claim bolstered by a renegade pathologist named Ryan Cole, who has been claiming that the vaccines are causing severe clotting disorders and cancer. I reviewed the film right before Thanksgiving at my not-so-super-secret other blog and left it at that, but one thing has bothered me since. While I was pretty sure at the time that the clots featured in the film—of which there were many images clearly designed to shock and disgust the lay audience for whom this movie was intended—were postmortem clots and nothing unusual, I didn’t have the expertise to be absolutely sure. So, over the last two weeks I’ve wanted to follow up on this post.
Enter Benjamin Schmidt, a licensed funeral director and embalmer who had also watched the film and emailed me about it because of my review over at my not-so-secret other blog. He informed me that he had watched the parts of the movie featuring clots being removed from the recently deceased and was amazed that any embalmer would portray them as anything other than common and normal postmortem clots that an embalmer entirely expects to see when preparing a body. Sensing an opportunity to publish a perspective on this viral propaganda film that I had not been able to find anywhere before except in snippets on Twitter and to educate our audience (and myself) in the process, I immediately tried to recruit him to write a review the parts of the movie featuring these clots from the perspective of an experienced and expert embalmer. To my delight, he readily agreed, and his guest post will be published later today.
But what about the rest of the film?
I decided that it would be of interest to our readers to make this a “two-fer” Monday and crosspost a revised and updated version of my pre-Thanksgiving Day review first, followed by Schmidt’s discussion. My review is more general review of the movie and its conspiracy theories about “depopulation“—complete with Bill Gates, of course—although there is overlap in discussion of the clots with Schmidt’s review, which can be found here.
In the meantime, let’s get started with my review.
“Depopulation” by vaccines: Everything old is new again
I realize that I sometimes repeat this to the point of annoyance, but it really does need to be repeated over and over: In the age of the pandemic, everything old is new again with respect to antivaccine disinformation. The most recent example is the claims that, thanks to COVID-19 vaccines, huge numbers of people have “died suddenly”, because the vaccines are designed to result in “depopulation” (which the “global elites” apparently want for reasons that are never made coherent). This particular conspiracy theory that’s trending now about COVID-19 vaccines is an echo—hell, a rehash—of old antivax conspiracy theories. The problem is that most people, who hadn’t been paying attention in years past, don’t realize this. Coming out in a couple of weeks is a book pushing a similar conspiracy theory, “Cause Unknown”: The Epidemic of Sudden Deaths in 2021 & 2022. It’s written by Ed Dowd, described as a “former Wall Street analyst and BlackRock portfolio manager”—because that’s who should be believed when he does amateur epidemiology, right?—who supposedly:
…examines the epidemic of sudden deaths in America. Throughout his stock picking career, he utilized pattern recognition to get ahead of his peers and the street before his bullish or bearish thesis became consensus. Early in 2021, he noticed a rise of news anecdotes about sudden deaths among very fit athletes and other seemingly healthy young people across the country. His question was simple: What changed in 2021?
I don’t know. What could possibly have changed in 2021, besides the amplification of Mr. Dowd’s confirmation bias? (Unsurprisingly, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and his antivax group Children’s Health Defense were involved in writing this book.) Also, when I want someone to analyze complex epidemiological data, my first pick would be a stock portfolio manager who thinks that “pattern recognition” in picking stocks translates to anything other than being misled in epidemiology. This book might require a more detailed post in the future if I can get a hold of a copy without actually having to see money go into the pockets of Dowd and RFK Jr. In the meantime, let’s move on to some historical background about antivax claims relevant to Died Suddenly.

Back in the day, when I was learning how to counter antivax disinformation, the “depopulation” claim often took the form of antivaxxers claiming that childhood vaccinations were killing children and causing a wave of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and that HPV vaccines (particularly Gardasil) were killing girls and young women. Nor are antivax “documentaries” making such claims new either. For example, I once described such a film entitled Sacrificial Virgins—antivaxxers aren’t subtle with their penchant for comparing vaccines to religion—that blamed Gardasil for killing young women, and the very first times I ever wrote about the antivax conspiracy theory that vaccines are causing “depopulation” was in reference to claims that Bill Gates wanted to use them for that purpose and when Jon Rappoport made the “depopulation” claim over a decade ago, linking it with germ theory denial. Other times, “depopulation” took the form of claims that vaccines—particularly Gardasil again, but also vaccines like the tetanus vaccine—are causing infertility (especially in women) and premature ovarian insufficiency, which would lead to a slower version of “depopulation”. Do any of these claims sound familiar in the age of COVID-19?
I’ve discussed variations the false idea that vaccines are part of a “depopulation agenda,” be it through mass death or causing infertility (or both). Perhaps the most ridiculous version of this conspiracy theory came from—who else?—Mike Adams, who before the pandemic had claimed that vaccines were bioweapons designed to depopulate the planet so that the global elite and aliens—yes, aliens!—could rule. Adams then renamed his “vaccine holocaust” as the Oblivion Agenda, in which COVID-19 vaccines took on the role of a bioweapon that will kill 90% of the global population and leave the survivors to be used by the global elite and their alien overlords as workers to exploit the earth’s resources. I kid you not. There are actual aliens in Adams’ antivax “depopulation” conspiracy theory!
With that background, let’s get to Died Suddenly, which very much approaches Mike Adams territory. Arguably, the only thing it lacks is aliens orchestrating the carnage.
Died Suddenly? More like “fainted suddenly”
Showing how Twitter has changed for the worse since Elon Musk took it over, the filmmakers were allowed to post the entire hour-plus video directly onto Twitter:
#DiedSuddenly WORLD PREMIER https://t.co/TIjFBCYomY
— DiedSuddenly (@DiedSuddenly_) November 21, 2022
And, of course, the documentary is on Rumble, for those who wish to subject themselves to it and/or verify anything (or everything) I describe:
Perhaps the best retort to the movie was this:
However unhinged its fans might or might not be, though, this movie promptly went viral, with links to the Rumble version of it being shared hither, thither, and yon, with several million shares on major social media platforms and Twitter users thinking that it was some sort of retort to me. I would also argue that it is worth looking at this movie in detail, because you need to understand that this is absolutely nothing new for antivaxxers. The idea that vaccines are deadly to the point of causing a new “holocaust” or “global depopulation” is a longstanding antivax conspiracy theory. The only people who should be surprised that it has been so effectively repurposed to produce a film like Died Suddenly are those who weren’t paying attention to the antivaccine movement. It’s understandable that most people were unaware of these sorts of antivax conspiracy theories, but unforgivable that apparently our public health leadership either was not or didn’t have messaging ready. In this post, I’ll discuss Died Suddenly and try to relate it to similar prepandemic antivax conspiracy theories.
Before that, however, I feel that I should mention that Stew Peters is a radio host and podcaster who runs the Stew Peters Network, a network of conspiracy blogs that promote conspiracy theories about COVID-19, vaccines, public health, politics, religion, and just about everything else. I first encountered him when he promoted claims by a nurse practitioner named Jane Ruby that COVID-19 vaccines were causing massive clots (that kill people), although she was—and still is—a regular on his network with standard COVID-19 disinformation, such as the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter your DNA”. His last film, Watch the Water, posited that COVID-19 vaccines are a synthetic version of “snake venom” and that evil forces are spreading via the vaccines, remdesivir, and drinking water to “make you a hybrid of Satan”. (I kid you not, and maybe invoking Satan is Peters’ version of Adams invoking aliens.) It’s almost as bonkers as anything Mike Adams has produced. Almost. (Think of Stew Peters as Del Bigtree with a wider range of conspiracy topics that he likes to fear monger about.)
From the advertising materials, it was very obvious right from the start that the conspiracy theory about COVID-19 vaccines supposedly causing fatal blood clots features prominently in Died Suddenly:

Prelude: The misinformation didn’t wait for the full movie to flow
Before Died Suddenly was even released, it was obvious just how bad it would be just from the social media promotional campaign that launched about a month before it hit Rumble. Indeed, the trailer alone was full of out-and-out misrepresentations, as noted in this story, which is worth discussing here because it shows that even the clips chosen for the trailer released in October made obviously false claims:
In the film’s trailer, footage of a basketball star collapsing on the court is cited as proof of the vaccine’s dangers. In reality, the footage is from 2020, long before the vaccine became available to the entire public.
As blog friend The Real Truther noted:
Another shot is a woman from Argentina passing out & falling into a moving train.
She fainted due to low blood pressure from not eating all day.
And she survived without any major injuries.
She didn't "die suddenly"https://t.co/yCWIRtB5HZ pic.twitter.com/Hr4bZOVxGi
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) October 29, 2022
Here are a couple of more examples from just the trailer alone:
Another shot shows comedian Heather McDonald fainting on stage, which she believed was from lack of eating & drinking that day.
She of course completely survived and didn't "die suddenly."https://t.co/mAMeYJ5rTO pic.twitter.com/SAzfIlJDi3
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) October 29, 2022
You get the idea. It’s an old antivax technique: Blame sudden deaths on vaccines, even if there was no sudden death or, as was often the case in the past, there was not even good evidence of correlation, much less causation. There had been a long run-up to Died Suddenly in the form of conspiracy theories about healthy younger doctors supposedly “dying suddenly” (because of the vaccine) and young people suffering Sudden Adult Death Syndrome, in which antivaxxers attributed a different name to the acronym SADS, which before the pandemic described a known but uncommon syndrome in which cardiac conduction abnormalities lead to Sudden Arrhythmic Death Syndrome. It’s a condition that I first started encountering papers describing nearly 20 years ago that was first described over 50 years ago, and 34 years ago the CDC dubbed it a “sudden unexplained death syndrome“. As antivaxxers used to blame SIDS on vaccines before the pandemic and exploit such tragic infant deaths to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about vaccines, in the age of the pandemic sudden tragic and unexpected cardiac arrests and deaths of young people have been exploited by antivaxxers, who falsely blame them on vaccines, and Died Suddenly does that in spades.
As I was looking at the trailer before the movie was even released to Rumble, I was thinking: If just the trailer contains so many obvious, easily refuted lies, what the heck is the movie like? I was afraid, very afraid. Still, I decided that I had to subject myself to this movie, which seemed much longer than its 68-minute runtime.
The things I do for you, my readers.
As I watched this, I was grateful that I had written posts about nearly every conspiracy theory that popped up in this movie as this post would have been close to book length if I had to deconstruct every single one of them in one blog post. Instead, I can just briefly discuss each one and then link to my much longer discussions published either here or at my not-so-super-secret other blog for interested readers who want more information.
Died Suddenly: Let the conspiracies flow!
It’s been a long time since I’ve subjected myself to such concentrated antivaccine propaganda as Died Suddenly. Even so, in making Died Suddenly, Stew Peters not-infrequently approaches Mike Adams territory. Don’t believe me? Just watch the first few minutes of the movie, which begins with warning in small white letters over a black background that the film is “not suitable for children”—actually, it’s not suitable for anyone with two neurons to rub together—set to the ominous tones of the Pink Floyd song Sheep. (Again, this film is not subtle.) The warning is then followed by a narrator intoning that there has been an “overwhelming and unexplainable increase in all-cause mortality” and deaths among 18-49 year olds, along with an increase in miscarriages and Bell’s palsy. (Again, antivaxxers are not known for their subtlety.)
Then the film cuts to an aerial shot of an SUV driving through the countryside and then zeros in on the middle-aged goateed man with glasses driving the truck filmed in extreme close-up from the side or behind as he pontificates about how there have been “anomalies” and “abnormalities” in the blood in people who died. As he drives, the man goes on to say that he feels as though he is seeing something that could be causing their deaths and that “no one will see what I see” (which is, of course, what all conspiracy theorists say). He then speculates that he first thought that perhaps COVID-19 had caused this; that is, until he claims to have realized that many of these people had never had COVID-19 but that—of course!—they had been vaccinated. My first guess was that this was Richard Hirschman, perhaps the most famous of the embalmers and funeral directors who have made misleading claims about finding huge clots in vaccinated people who died, his claims that they are “unnatural” having led people like Mike Adams and Jane Ruby to speculate wildly that the clots are “self-assembling nanostructures.”

Sure enough, later in the movie, the man reappears and is identified as Richard Hirschman. He’s portrayed looking at vials containing clots on a table with an odd statue of skeletons arrayed in “see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil” poses as he intones about carotid artery clots and clots from veins. I’m not going to discuss the segment featuring Hirschmann much, given that I’ve written about Hirschman’s conspiracy theories in depth and his inability to tell the difference between postmortem and antemortem clots. (Also, I don’t want to steal too much of Benjamin Schmidt’s thunder, although I do have to discuss these clots some.) That a series of other embalmers echo Hirschman’s conspiracy theories doesn’t persuade me in the least, the images of embalmers pulling clots out of corpses notwithstanding. One wonders if any of these embalmers had permission from the loved ones of the deceased portrayed in the movie to take video of the embalming process. I suspect not. Yet, at around 50:30 in the movie, there’s extensive video of an embalmer working on a body.
That diversion to further into the movie aside, next the film cuts to the opening credits just as the music swells and Roger Waters vocals kick in. As the credits roll, we’re treated to a montage of images ranging from Big Foot to UFOs, to Jeffrey Epstein, to President George Bush claiming “weapons of mass destruction” in Iraq, interspersed with images from the COVID-19 pandemic, such as children undergoing nasal swabs and recent news, such as an image of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. The montage even includes the killing of President John F. Kennedy’s assassin Lee Harvey Oswald by Jack Ruby while he was in police custody—more subtlety!—along with an image of Elvis Presley getting vaccinated against polio juxtaposed with President Joe Biden getting vaccinated against COVID-19. Amusingly, a shaky graphic of the words “conspiracy theory” precedes an image of Alex Jones followed by images of the World Trade Center Towers falling and astronauts driving the lunar rover on the Moon. (Truly, Peters checks all the conspiracy boxes.) I will, however, admit to some surprise at seeing a clip of Tom Hanks being interviewed on The Today Show about his movie Inferno and discussing Malthusian theory, triage, and overpopulation, which, as you might recall if you’ve seen the movie, feature prominently as part of the plot.
And the was just the first four minutes of the film!
Truly, Peters knows his audience, especially given that the Dan Brown novels whose movie adaptations star Hanks are some of the most amazing fictional conspiracy-fests I’ve ever seen. Unfortunately Peters can’t seem to tell the difference between fiction and reality.
Here come the clots, here come the clots!
What follows is a discussion of Malthusian theory about what happens when there are more people on the planet than the earth can support, including famines, plagues, and shortages. This segment is all very ominous, with frequent references to dire consequences of overpopulation portrayed through video clips of people ranging from Bill Maher to Bill Gates discussing the problem. Of course the clip of Gates featured is the (in)famous clip in which Gates points out that population growth can be slowed by providing better healthcare to developing poor countries, including vaccines. It’s a clip that antivaxxers love because they misrepresent it as Gates “confessing” in a TED Talk that vaccines are part of a global “depopulation” plot when in reality it’s just Gates repeating what has been obvious to public health scientists for decades, namely that populations with access to better health care—including vaccines—and more wealth tend to delay childbearing, not produce as many children, and therefore have populations that do not grow as fast, as is the case in older, more established wealthy countries such as the US and those in Europe.
Enter a funeral director named Chad Whisnat, whom, oddly enough, I had never heard of before this movie, going on about, “What does that mean?” with respect to decreasing the rate of population growth by 15% “using vaccines,” saying:
Well, common sense would tell you, if you have a man standing in front of you say … he’s going to reduce the world’s population by 10 or 15% using vaccines. What does that mean to you? It means somebody’s gonna die because you put a vaccine in them. It doesn’t mean you’re going to save people. That’s pretty much common sense in my brain.
Let’s just say that Whisnat’s “common sense” is not really “sense.” After all, it could also mean that the birthrate declines. I gathered right away that he must be one of those conspiracy mongering morticians who have been claiming that vaccines are killing people based on his anecdotal experience as a funeral home director.
Hilariously, Whisnat then invokes an “argument by Google” by voicing over a montage of Google searches how Googling “died suddenly” brings up a list of stories and web pages about people who—surprise! surprise!—died suddenly! (Google is nothing if not literal that way when you enter words into its search engine box.) There’s even what looks to me like a shot of Hank Aaron getting the vaccine. Of course, Aaron was 86 when he died; so his death two weeks after being vaccinated was almost certainly coincidence, and, indeed, was ultimately attributed to natural causes. That’s part of the conspiracy in these narratives, of course. “They” have to cover up the True Cause of Aaron’s death—and of all the deaths referenced in the film.
However, as Lead Stories noted over in October while discussing the trailer:
The montage flashes an article from October 16, 2022, headlined “Dad of two, 46, dies suddenly in his sleep.”
But the article makes no mention of a COVID vaccine. “Edward died in his sleep in the early hours of September 27, having spent some time in hospital while struggling with his mental health,” the article states.
Another article in the montage is headlined: “Actor’s sudden death aged 33,” but the piece itself explains that the actor died as a result of a “tragic fall” and does not mention vaccination.
Another article, the first-person essay of a mother who lost a son, is about his death in a car crash.
This segment then leads into Hirschman and his claims, repeated by several conspiracy mongering embalmers and funeral directors. Some shots obscure the faces and voices of these embalmers, because, of course, they are “afraid” to identify themselves. Personally, I myself could tell that most of the clots shown look like postmortem clots, and indeed Schmidt thinks the same thing, as he will explain in his followup to this post.
The whole segment starts around 8:10 and continues for several minutes, with several close-up images shown at around 14:20, with embalmer after embalmer saying that these clots can’t be normal. Of note, none of these embalmers could say whether the decedents whom they had embalmed had ever been vaccinated against COVID-19 or had had case of COVID-19, symptomatic, asymptomatic, or even fatal. In any event, Again, Schmidt will discuss this in more detail in his guest post.
Besides Schmidt however, there were people debunking this nonsense on Twitter:
Here's a larger version of the chicken fat and current jelly photo so you can really appreciate what they look like: pic.twitter.com/9voiMciUeF
— effie (@MorteSuiteVita) November 22, 2022
Chicken fat clots are made of plasma (the liquid part of blood), clotting factors, platelets, white blood cells- all parts of blood besides red blood cells, which are seen in current jelly clots. These components congeal & take on the shapes of the vessels- like Jello in a mold! pic.twitter.com/NcVQ1b0Avt
— effie (@MorteSuiteVita) November 22, 2022
100% of dead bodies have clots (not necessarily everywhere) but the video advances a hypothesis that this is not normal. White clots contain more vWF, collagen, and platelets than red blood cells (https://t.co/ZnjciNn0d5) .
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) November 22, 2022
Seriously, I see only two possibilities. Either these embalmers and some of the doctors parroting these claims about clots don’t understand the difference between postmortem and antemortem clots, or they do and are either deluded or lying—or even both. My take is that, depending on the specific person and specific clot being described, one or the other can be true.
In any event, by around 17:30, the film shifts to stories of young people who supposedly “died suddenly,” the film’s narrative being, of course, that it must have been the COVID-19 vaccines that caused these deaths. Again, almost none of these stories mention whether any of these people had actually ever been vaccinated, and this entire segment consists of, in essence, an appeal to personal incredulity. Just because these people are unaware that, for example, young people sometimes suffer sudden cardiac arrest with no prior warning, to the point that the syndrome was described in the 1970s and 1980s, does not mean that these people “died suddenly” because of COVID-19 vaccines.
During a montage of various “whistleblowers” testifying about people who “died suddenly”, there was a recounting of the claim that a military database had shown a huge increase in cancers since the vaccines had started being required for military personnel. I won’t discuss that one in much detail, given that I did so in great detail before in February other than to say this. It is biologically implausible in the extreme that we would see a huge increase in cancers less than two years after the vaccines rolled out because even after exposure to large doses of ionizing radiation from the atomic bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the earliest that cancers started appearing was two years later, and that was just leukemias. Solid cancers like colon and breast cancers, didn’t show up until ten years later. Of course, Dr. Ryan Cole, whose claims about COVID-19 vaccines and cancer I’ve discussed before, makes an appearance blathering about oncogenes and cancer biology that he clearly doesn’t understand while appealing to “nefarious actors” behind this plot, including, of course, Bill Gates. (I swear, Bill Gates is everywhere and does everything!)
Unsurprisingly, the film also invokes Event 201, an October 2019 exercise simulating a pandemic, to imply—no, to claim outright—that the subsequent coronavirus crisis was all part of a plan. It’s a conspiracy theory that dates back to the days of Plandemic and Plandemic 2, two conspiracy movies claiming that the pandemic was a plot to cause depopulation and impose absolute authoritarian rule. To bolster this claim, there’s a montage of provaccine messages and songs from podcasters and TV personalities like Stephen Colbert, followed by people claiming that they will “destroy your life” if you don’t take the vaccine and that we are in a “war,” followed by a montage of conspiracy images of glaciers melting, the World Trade Center collapsing, Sean Penn with Volodymyr Zelenskyy—what’s with the pro-Russian propaganda slipped in?—and more.
Then comes Steve Kirsch at about the halfway point, and I nearly had to stop watching. Kirsch is about as “out there” a COVID-19 conspiracy theorist and antivaxxer as there is, as evidenced by his claims in Died Suddenly that “no one wants to know what’s in the vaccines” and that “no mainstream media” reporter has ever asked “what’s in the vial,” which is nonsense so pure that I really, really questioned whether I could make it through the rest of the movie. You might remember Kirsch as the tech bro who went from somewhat reasonable to full-on COVID-19 conspiracy theorist who likes to challenge his critics and the critics of any of the cranks whose ideas he amplifies to five hour “debates,” to be recorded and posted to YouTube and Rumble. As antivax cranks have done for as long as I can remember, when real scientists ignore him or politely decline his offers, he portrays them as being too “cowardly” to “debate” him and his minions.
What follows is a montage of arguments by package insert, with the risible claim that there are still pages in the package inserts intentionally left blank. If that’s true, I couldn’t find them. Kirsch even invokes VAERS and his “promise” to pay any scientist $1 million to come on his show for a debate. Hilariously, he expresses anger that the CDC is ignoring him. Personally, given his history I’d ignore him too if I were a high-ranking CDC official or the chair of the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). Indeed, Kirsch clearly provided smartphone video to the filmmakers in a segment that portrays a police officer instructing him to leave the property of the chair of ACIP. It apparently never occurred to Peters or Kirsch that this footage of a police officer telling him to leave makes him look far more like a deranged stalker than a “citizen investigator” seeking accurate information. It really does! If you don’t believe me, watch it for yourself at around the 33:45 mark! Kirsch is even proud that he’s been labeled the “#1 superspreader” of COVID-19 misinformation, to the point where that’s how he’s identified in one shot!

It’s at about this point at the 45:00 mark that there’s the montage debunked above of security camera and smartphone videos showing people fainting, the implication being that they had all “died suddenly,” even though most had not. There were images of some people fainting near moving subway trains and falling into the trains or onto the tracks. Even if there were any fatalities in these images, these could just be cases of tragically bad timing and locations for people to be fainting. The montage goes on and on, with some people appearing to have seizures and some just fainting and falling. For none of these people is it demonstrated that they had had a COVID-19 vaccine anytime soon before the incident, and almost none of them actually died.
In fact, as this article shows, most of the people shown fainting in the montage collapsed for reasons unrelated to the vaccine; for example, some suffered syncope after not having eaten and drunk anything for a long time. Even more deceptive, at least two of the clips date to before COVID-19 vaccines were even available; for example, Florida Gators basketball star Keyontae Johnson, who fainted in the middle of a game on December 12, 2020, before the vaccines were even available. One clip even dates back to 2019, before the first cases of the novel coronavirus disease had even been reported in Wuhan, China, specifically Austrian journalist Rosa Lyon, who collapsed on her show. Apparently, the vaccine is so powerful that it can go back in time to kill people—or at least make them faint.
Then there’s this example, which is even worse, as it shows Peters and crew blatantly misrepresenting the cause of a child’s death to promote their ghoulish message:
I'm calling on @DiedSuddenly_ to immediately delete this tweet & apologize to the family of Jackson Mohr for exploiting his death for their anti-vaccine agenda.https://t.co/GOPeDR8oCR
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) November 28, 2022
Unfortunately, it’s long been known that 13-year-olds do sometimes “die suddenly” of no apparent cause. Such deaths almost always turn out to have been due to an undetected conduction abnormality of the heart. Now antivaxxers are ghoulishly weaponizing every such death they can find, regardless of whether there’s even any plausible link to COVID-19 vaccines or not.
The film also briefly features a number of speculative stories about people who died within days of being vaccinated—or even of people who just plain died, with no reference to whether they had been recently vaccinated or not—followed by a segment at 50:30 of embalmers working on actual cadavers, again, likely without permission from the family to feature their deceased loved ones in a movie. At one point, they claimed that they weren’t getting “any drainage” over a scene of a clot measuring a few inches (at most) in length being pulled out of a vein. Once the clot is out, fluid literally squirted out of the hole in the vein rather belying the claim that the clot was so extensive. I won’t say any more about this scene, because in his guest post our embalming expert Benjamin Schmidt discusses why this squirt of fluid was actually a good thing and indicated a good embalming.
At another point in this montage, there’s a clip of a beating heart, followed by a picture of the heart stopped and a surgeon incising the pulmonary artery to remove a clot. This is an operation called a saddle embolectomy, a seldom-required surgery to remove a pulmonary embolus (a blood clot that goes to the blood vessels of the lung and that can be fatal) that’s so large that it’s blocking the main pulmonary artery right where it divides into the right and left pulmonary arteries and compromising the heart’s function by blocking blood outflow to the lungs, hence the name “saddle embolus.” No mention is made of whether this patient had been vaccinated, nor is anything else said about him.

In fact, the video in that segment looked suspiciously familiar to several docs on Twitter, including Dr. Eric Burnett, who posted this brief video to Tik Tok and Twitter, in which he not only compares the images of clots from Died Suddenly to images of postmortem clots but also shows a clip from the YouTube video of a saddle embolectomy that the filmmakers appear to have misappropriated for their film and misrepresented as a clot caused by the vaccines:
For reference they have done autopsy studies on the very rare cases of vaccine induced thrombotic thrombocytopenia (VITT) which causes blood clots https://t.co/ttRO5MWALh
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) November 24, 2022
In case you’re curious, I found a YouTube video of a saddle embolectomy that appears to have been used by Peters and company. At first glance the video appeared to me to be at the very least incredibly similar to the video in Died Suddenly. (Unfortunately, the video’s settings don’t allow me to embed it here; so here’s the link.)
Later, it turned out that you can scratch “at the very least incredibly similar” and just say it’s the same video. The Real Truther did us all a solid and made it very clear that the Died Suddenly director appears almost certainly to have his footage of the clot removal directly from this YouTube video:
Hey @DiedSuddenly_ & @drcole12 can you explain why you used this youtube video from 2019 to "prove" the COVID vaccine is causing blood clots in 2022?https://t.co/aqqb8t7oEt
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) November 26, 2022
As an aside, it’s also amusing to point out that one of the “experts” in Died Suddenly, Dr. Ryan Cole, was very unhappy at Dr. Burnett’s debunking of his conspiracy theory about the vaccines causing clots and voiced his unhappiness on Steve Kirsch’s Substack. His “rebuttal” just boiled down to an appeal to authority—his own—coupled with, “Trust me, I’m an expert.” Certainly there was no evidence there. Moreover, Dr. Jonathan Laxton even points out a reason why embalmers might have been seeing more postmortem clots than they did normally prepandemic:
Somehow, this got removed from me feed 🤔. I'm addressing the clot claims in #DiedSuddenly pic.twitter.com/2Ud3VGrGgn
— Jonathan Laxton MD, FRCPC 🐈🐱🐈‍⬛ (@dr_jon_l) November 25, 2022
Why might there be more postmortem clots? The longer you store bodies, the more extensive the postmortem clotting of their blood. When the funeral industry was overwhelmed by COVID-19 death, bodies were stored longer before embalming and funeral.
I have to mention another segment with someone named Dr. Gene Posca, an internal medicine specialist, who is shown seeing someone named John, who is stated to have been “injured” by two doses of the Pfizer vaccine. His complaint was leg swelling from a deep venous thrombosis, which is described as “extremely rare.” (Hint: DVTs are not rare.) Dr. Posca did thermography on this patient to claim to show “heat” in the neck lymph node chains and in the involved leg, leading Dr. Posca to recommend bilateral Doppler ultrasounds. Here’s a hint for this quack: If you suspect DVT, just order the Doppler ultrasound. The thermography is completely unnecessary, as I wrote about when I once described another quack who advocates thermography for “clotting” from COVID-19 vaccines. It also turns out that Dr. Posca is an antivax conspiracy theorist who is based at the Cleveland Clinic Indian River Hospital in Florida who has testified before that the vaccines are a “dangerous and experimental drug” being imposed by “fascists from D.C.” and that their: “blitzkrieg against our freedom will continue.”
WTF, Cleveland Clinic? (Yes, Dr. Posca is based at a Cleveland Clinic hospital in Florida.)
Conspiracies everywhere
By the time I reached the end of Died Suddenly, I was exhausted, as it’s basically a repository of every conspiracy theory out there about COVID-19 vaccines causing clots, miscarriages, still births, and “sudden deaths.” It’s all anecdotes with no data. For instance, near the end of the movie, a nurse named Michelle Gershon claims that she is seeing more intrauterine fetal demises than ever before since the vaccines. Her statement is followed by video in which one of the embalmers claims that he had a “run of that” (still births) at his funeral home, with five of the six mothers having been vaccinated and the other having had remdesivir. (Cherry picking and confirmation bias, anyone?) Another of these embalmers notes—rather disgustingly to the lay person—that he has more “fetuses in the refrigerator” than he’s ever seen before. Then an OB/GYN named Dr. James A. Thorp claims that he’s seeing more “death and destruction”—no, I’m not misquoting—than he’s ever seen before on ultrasound.
This sequence is then followed by a highly deceptive graph:

Does anyone see the problem with this graph, even if the numbers on it accurate? (And I can’t find any evidence for a phenomenon like this elsewhere.) Look at where the uptick in still births begins! It starts in 2020. Note that COVID-19 vaccines did not even win an EUA, much less start rolling out, until December 2020, and they weren’t recommended for pregnant people until well into 2021. This graph is far more consistent with COVID-19 itself causing still births, not the vaccine. (Of course, this graph just looks made-up to me. So who knows what it actually shows?) The data that exist show that there is no detectable association between COVID-19 vaccination and still birth. In fact, if anything, COVID-19 vaccines reduce, not increase, the risk of still birth, with a meta-analysis finding that vaccination reduces the risk by 15%, likely due to the decreased risk of the vaccinated catching COVID-19. It also turns out that the story of the “whistleblower” nurse’s story originated in The Epoch Times, an antivax conspiracy site. It also turns out that Dr. Thorp is full of crap. If you doubt me on this, just look at this one claim by him:
‘Are you saying babies are having heart attacks in the womb?’
Dr James Thorpe ~ ‘YES’#DiedSuddenlydocumentary pic.twitter.com/X2WzDSeJia
— Janey (@_Janey_Jay) November 22, 2022
Let’s just say that fetuses having intrauterine heart attacks is not a thing.
None of this stops another interviewee from describing COVID-19 vaccines as this “evil that is destroying” infants and still another describing the vaccines as a “pure evil in this world”.
The grand finale of the movie features conspiracy theorists portraying the vaccine as a “bioweapon” being used to depopulate and control the world. This is followed by a stirring call to arms to fight back and a warning that if you don’t resist you are complicit in the atrocities and a counter of how many billions of doses of COVID-19 vaccines have been administered and more images of political leaders, entertainers, and celebrities urging people to get vaccinated and making fun of the unvaccinated, as Howard Stern once did.
Everything old is new again
The idea that vaccines are causing “depopulation” and killing young people is not new at all. I like to refer again to the antivax movie about Gardasil, Sacrificial Virgins. Oddly enough, though, the unfortunate young women who “died suddenly” whose deaths the filmmakers blamed on Gardasil presented more convincing anecdotal evidence than anything in Died Suddenly, and their stories were not all that convincing, given that their deaths all occurred weeks after the last of a series of three doses of Gardasil and only appeared related to the vaccine in the filmmakers’ imagination. Similarly, The Greater Good promoted, among other conspiracy theories, the same narrative, just for infants and children. Indeed, there are more examples of antivaxxers blaming vaccines for sudden death of infants, children, and young adults than I can easily recount, given that I’ve been at this for over two decades.
The odd thing is, as these films tend to go Died Suddenly is actually remarkably data-free. Don’t get me wrong. There aren’t good data to support the narrative of “depopulation” due to the vaccinated “dying suddenly,” but usually conspiracy theorists can find data that they can torture until there is a “confession”. That’s why I had expected way more graphs and appeals to “excess mortality” than I got. What this movie is turns out to feature are pretty much just interviews with conspiracy theorists, who cited cherry-picked anecdotes and their own selective memory to make their cases. Unfortunately, the moviemaking is pretty slick, and if you don’t recognize the blatantly fallacious arguments I can see how it might be persuasive to those predisposed to believe COVID-19 vaccines are harmful or even deadly.
After subjecting myself to Died Suddenly and the tsunami of firehosed misleading anecdotes and imagery it contains, I don’t know if I have the wherewithal to read Cause Unknown, although I hope that someone with some critical thinking skills will if it turns out that I can’t. What I do know is that this movie is pure disinformation in the way that it portrays COVID-19 vaccines as pure evil. What I can’t decide is whether it’s so over-the-top in its misinformation, disinformation, and outright lies that most people will recognize it for what it is or if its sheer level of bonkers will be a selling point, feature that attracts and persuades people. Certainly the fact that it’s been shared and viewed many millions of times suggests that it is having an effect.
NOTE: Please check out Benjamin Schmidt’s discussion of the segments of the film in which embalmers extract disgusting looking clots from recently deceased persons whom they are embalming. I learned some things from his discussion, and I think that you will too, in particular how what is shown in Died Suddenly is nothing unusual and entirely expected during typical embalmings. Also, enjoy this video deconstruction of Died Suddenly by Dr. Susan Oliver.

When antivax “died suddenly” conspiracy mongering vultures target a friend and colleague
After SBM suffered the unexpected loss of our co-founder Dr. Harriet Hall last week, we were angered and distressed to see antivaxxers saying that she had “died suddenly” because of COVID-19 vaccines. This dangerous narrative is even more painful when it targets a friend. Dr. Gorski tries to get past his initial anger and explain this dangerous conspiracy theory.
David Gorski on January 16, 2023
Link

After I got over the initial shock and sadness that hit me after I learned of the unexpected death of our friend and colleague Dr. Harriet Hall last week (Steve’s post about it here), I must confess that, as was the case with Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin’s on-field cardiac arrest that was most likely from commotio cordis, my next thought was how long it would be before antivaxxers started blaming her unexpected passing on COVID-19 vaccines. It did not take long after her husband had Tweeted news of her death using her account and the editor of her website and newsletter had sent out a mass email with the news before I started seeing Tweets with the “died suddenly” narrative that either blamed the vaccine outright or were “just asking questions” (a.k.a. JAQing off) about whether the vaccine caused or contributed to her death. Nearly as soon, an antivaxxer started sending me particularly vile emails, the most recent of which I received just yesterday before I started writing this.
These developments led me to the idea that perhaps I should write about this phenomenon one more time, both from the angle of having now experienced it personally plus a bit more about where it came from than I described the last time I wrote about it, thinking that this could be my tribute to her life. However, I did not want to cause Harriet’s family any pain in doing so, which is why I emailed her widow Kirk to describe what I was thinking about writing and to assure him that I would not do it—or would delay it several weeks—if he had any objections at all.
Here was his response:
I think a post like that is a great idea. The antivaxxers are a loathsome, despicable group who seem to be able to plumb the deepest levels of depravity to push their agenda. Harriet had been in delicate health for many years before the Covid-19 pandemic. Several years ago I took over all household chores after she experienced blackouts and fell in San Francisco and at SeaTac within a week. Recently Harriet’s doctor at Madigan Army Medical Center was having her worked up for possible congestive heart failure. A very recent echocardiogram (we have not received the full results) showed she had leakage in two of her heart valves. She also had a transient heart arrythmia which was of many years’ duration. Neither one of us have had Covid-19 and Harriet’s exposure to life outside the home had for the last several years, been limited to visits to her doctor and dentist.
From a personal standpoint, I will admit that I did not fully appreciate how poor Harriet’s health had been the last several years. I knew that she had had a number of health issues, and I do recall that Harriet did not attend NECSS in 2019 because she could not travel, making NECSS 2018 the last time I ever saw her in person. The bottom line is that, sadly, Harriet was 77 and in poor general health, putting her at high risk for a sudden cardiac event or a stroke. I also know that antivaxxers, when they learn of her health problems and cardiac risk, will likely quite happily respin their story to claim that vaccines killed her because she had had pre-existing heart disease. That is how ghoulish they are.
Elsewhere in his very personal email, Kirk also added:
You may use anything I have told you in this and other emails to fight against the disinformation being spread against Harriet and the Covid-19 vaccines.
Consider it done, Kirk.
Kirk also described what happened the night Harriet died, but I see no need to share these details other than that Harriet did indeed die suddenly and unexpectedly in her bed at around 10 PM PT on January 11, 2023.
Having been given permission by Kirk Hall, to whom I will be forever grateful for being wiling to let me write this, I then had to decide how best to handle this discussion. I will be including a couple of representative Tweets; that was an easy decision. However, I debated long and hard about whether to share the emails, given my usual policy of keeping emails private. However, I’ve always maintained at least two exceptions to this policy. Emails to me in my capacity as managing editor of SBM have always been fair game, although I rarely ever actually publish them. Similarly, emails that I find particularly loathsome have always also been fair game, and these were beyond particularly loathsome.
My purpose in publishing some excerpts will be two-fold. First, I was angry, and I want our readers to share my anger at these ghouls. Second, I want to use them as a jumping-off point to examine the whole “died suddenly” narrative again from a different perspective. If any of you don’t want to read these, please just try to scroll past quickly.
Let’s go back to Thursday afternoon.
The narrative attacks
It is with some difficulty that I go back to Thursday afternoon, when I first learned of Harriet’s passing. First, Steve and I got a brief email from Kirk (timestamp 1:23 PM ET January 12, read less than an hour later) informing us of what had happened. Not long after that, I got a mail from Ronald Jette (timestamp 2:31 PM), which I quoted in my post from later that day.
It wasn’t long before I saw Tweets like these:
And, later Thursday after I Tweeted a link to the first announcement:
I'd be lying if I said that I didn't expect this from antivaxxers when the news of Harriet Hall's passing hit, but I'd also be lying if I didn't also point out how vile and nasty these antivaxxers are. pic.twitter.com/nRJXHyGPb6
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 13, 2023
And then there were emails, this one particularly loathsome, which led to some loathsome responses:
It's only going to get worse if the number of people dying increases. People are going to be scared and angry and will blame those who pushed the vax and mandates, especially if children and young people are dying. pic.twitter.com/iV1LuLmITT
— Gus Flory (@GusFlory) January 14, 2023
Which led to responses like:
You are one of those people, dismissing the deaths and injuries of people those harmed by the “vaccine”. You try to be virtuous by using the term “anti-vaxxer” but you are just a hideous person who tries to close down a conversation about people that have been harmed.
— Ron Hutch (@ron_hutch) January 13, 2023
While others continued:
Stay Better 6 feet under
— stefano Ω (@SteYak54) January 14, 2023
To be expected given her condition.
Condition, being injected by an experimental gene therapy.
— Daniel Poschner (@PoschnerDaniel) January 14, 2023
“@nukeisraelnow”? “Dying and it is wonderful”? Stay classy, anonymous antisemitic troll. It was getting so bad that I contacted Kirk and suggested that he lock down Harriet’s social media accounts.
Meanwhile, “SD” continued to send me emails, this one Friday night:
It’s Sabbath tonight. Let’s pray for the branch Covidian who departed suddenly of commotio cordis in her sleep.She did a lot of damage to patients in her career. Lots of misinformation, lies, disinformation.We will never forgive, not forget.Live by the forced injections, die from the experimental injections.I’d say she had 5. Meaning an IQ of 100-120.It’s basically suicide by injection. Dose dependent.Or just plain stupidity. Lack of intellect. Lack of education.She ain’t coming back.Self-inflicted departure.She won’t be the last.Got a defibrillator?Good night.Talk tomorrow.Maybe not.

To which I responded…well, I didn’t. SD didn’t deserve a response, other than that I will never forgive and never forget and that I need to find a way to block his email address (or at least send it to spam or the trash without my ever seeing it). I did, however, say this elsewhere:
I might have to comment on this Monday. My tribute to Harriet might end up being a big "Fuck you!" to these ghoul antivaxxers. I could be wrong, but I like to think she'd have appreciated that.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 13, 2023
Harriet was a friend, but she was not a relative or, admittedly, a very close friend. As angry as “died suddenly” conspiracy mongering of the sort documented above made me, I can only imagine the hurt and anger that it causes grieving spouses, family members, and close friends. If I wanted to say something like what I Tweeted above, imagine how much more hurt, confused, and angry family members feel.
Not that they didn’t help me understand, albeit in the context of deaths from COVID-19 itself. However, the claim that COVID-19 didn’t kill people who died of the disease is related to the “died suddenly” (of vaccines) narrative:
A hint to keyboard warriors out there: stop commenting on the deaths of people you know nothing about. These thoughtless, horrible responses are just a sample. pic.twitter.com/P4h0iMxGVM
— HeyNurseKat’s Science Support Group (@HeyNurseKat) January 14, 2023
So how did the “died suddenly” conspiracy theory come about? I’ve discussed it before, but I would like to do so again, hopefully from a sufficiently different angle to make it informative to our readers and to serve as a fitting way to turn antivax conspiracy mongering about Harriet’s passing into a tribute. As Kirk (who knew her best) said, I suspect that she would have appreciated that, and once I saw that the “pandemic’s wrongest man,” Alex Berenson, had started “JAQing off” about Harriet’s death, I knew I had to write about it:
from her blog: https://t.co/f1C00zsBTc
— June Effin' Cleaver (@isuckatwife) January 13, 2023
Responding to Berenson with Harriet’s last article from Skeptical Inquirer (dated December 29!) was a brilliant move, which others did as well:
pic.twitter.com/bUG0msBElK
— Miss Conceptions 🤔 (@mconceptionz) January 13, 2023
Also, let me just point out that Berenson knew exactly what he was doing. His Tweet was a dog whistle to antivax activists pushing the “died suddenly” narrative in which he was “just asking questions” about whether science communicators were avoiding the word “suddenly” when discussing people who died suddenly and unexpectedly.
“Died Suddenly” is not new
I’ve written several times over the last couple of years since COVID-19 vaccines received emergency use approval (EUA) and mass vaccination campaigns began all over the world how it is not a new thing for antivaxxers to blame vaccines for sudden unexpected deaths. When I first started blogging (and before), a favorite antivax claim was to blame vaccines for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). That made sense from a “confusing correlation with causation” point of view, because SIDS is most common at an age when infants are receiving a number of vaccines in the childhood schedule. It was a false claim that vaccines cause sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), a Vaccine Court ruling notwithstanding. (This particular Vaccine Court ruling was ultimately struck down.) Another particularly despicable example from two decades ago was the Alan Yurko case, in which antivaxxers blamed vaccines for shaken baby syndrome. Let’s just say that the “Free Yurko” movement was a particularly disgusting and despicable example of this phenomenon, although more applicable to the context of the Damar Hamlin case, in which an injury caused by trauma is falsely attributed to vaccines.
Another prominent example of this “died suddenly” phenomenon before the pandemic was the antivax narrative around HPV vaccines, particularly Gardasil. I described this phenomenon in more detail last week, but think it’s worth briefly relating again before moving on to the origins of the COVID-19 “died suddenly” narrative. The first time I wrote about the specific claim that Gardasil is killing girls and young women was eight years ago, when The Toronto Star published a particularly execrable news report that suggested that the death of a 14-year-old girl named Annabelle Morin might have been due to Gardasil. I discussed in great detail why Morin’s tragic story was not evidence of causation (and didn’t even really strongly suggest possible causation). I also mentioned how antivaxxers had been blaming Morin’s sudden death in 2008 on Gardasil for at least three years when The Star article was published, her mother having encountered fear mongering about Gardasil on Joseph Mercola’s website, leading her to sue Merck over her death. Nor was Morin the only sudden death exploited by antivaxxers. For example, the death of 18-year-old Jasmine Renata, who was found dead in her bed six months after her last dose of the three-shot series of Gardasil in 2009, was exploited by antivaxxers, who convinced her mother that Gardasil, not any genetic conduction defect predisposing to SADS (sound familiar?), had killed her. Three years later, antivax scientist Christopher Shaw, who was known for also claiming that Gardasil causes premature ovarian insufficiency, testified at a New Zealand inquest that Gardasil had killed her, claiming to have found aluminum in her brain tissue that had been taken at autopsy, while another antivax pathologist, Dr. Sing Han Lee—think of him as a precursor to COVID-19 era antivax pathologist Dr. Ryan Cole—testified that there was foreign DNA from the HPV strain used in the vaccine in Rentata’s blood—bound to aluminum of course—and that that must have caused her death.
By 2018, the antivax group—more specifically the anti-Gardasil group—SANEVAX had made a series of YouTube videos entitled Sacrificial Virgins, which blamed Gardasil for the death of 19-year-old Jasmin Soriat, a German woman who in 2017 died in her sleep three weeks after receiving her second dose of Gardasil.
Which brings us to the pandemic. By now, readers of SBM are familiar with how the “died suddenly” conspiracy theory spawned some truly vile claims about Damar Hamlin, who, thankfully, appears to be on his way to a full recovery, and a conspiracy movie falsely blaming clots—supposedly caused by COVID-19 vaccines, of course!—for an epidemic of people who “died suddenly” and had huge, never-before-seen blood clots found upon embalming. Never mind that, as an embalmer educated us, such clots are common and expected, and these conspiracy mongers apparently can’t differentiate postmortem from premortem clots.
In any case, a Google Trends search for “died suddenly” doesn’t really show the term taking off until fall 2022, with a preceding blip a year before:
However, the essential narrative long predates fall 2022, as I will show. Finally, there are “flavors” or “variants”—if you will—of the “died suddenly” narrative. I dissected in detail the origins of the variant claiming that athletes are “dying suddenly” (of vaccines, of course) when I discussed the Damar Hamlin case, specifically how NewsBlaze founder Alan Gray, while probably not the originator of the claim, is arguably the foremost promoter of it—and has been since at least November 2021. Certainly, deceptive videos trying to link athlete deaths to COVID-19 vaccines were circulating by December 2021. Another is the false claim that 80 Canadian doctors have “died suddenly” (and supposedly mysteriously of causes “They” don’t want you to know about, namely vaccines), even though there is no evidence that vaccines caused their deaths.
Where did “died suddenly” come from?
One of the longest standing conspiracy theories about vaccines are being used by global “elites” in order to cause “depopulation”, all for nefarious purposes of profit and control. Utterly unsurprisingly, before the pandemic antivaxxers loved to compare vaccine mandates to the Holocaust and Nazi war crimes (with themselves as persecuted Jews). After the pandemic, there quickly arose conspiracy theories that the pandemic was planned, of course, as in “plandemic” designed to force people to get vaccines, whose purpose was really not to save lives but to cause “depopulation”. These sorts of conspiracy theories were being spun before COVID-19 vaccines had been granted an EUA—or even passed clinical trials, for example Mike Adams’ Oblivion Agenda.
It also came as no surprise that antivaxxers soon started weaponizing reports of death after COVID-19 vaccination made to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database, starting almost immediately. By summer 2021, the narrative had evolved to become an updated version of the hoary old antivax chestnut portraying vaccines as a “depopulation agenda“. Not coincidentally, one of the antivaxxers promoting the claim that vaccines are causing “depopulation” during the summer of 2021 was disgraced cardiologist Dr. Peter McCullough, who figured prominently in weaving the narrative that facilitated antivaxxers falsely blaming his cardiac arrest on vaccines. Indeed, by March 2021, less than three months after the vaccines first started rolling out, antivaxxers were linking any death that occurred after COVID-19 vaccination to the vaccines, whether there was a plausible case or not, a phenomenon that I had noticed less than two months after the vaccines received their EUAs and continued to write about. In fact, I even noticed as early as mid-February 2021 how Robert F. Kennedy Jr. had started falsely blaming COVID-19 vaccines for heart attacks and sudden cardiac deaths based on misinterpreted VAERS data, a narrative that continued through 2021 and to this day, antivaxxers even having co-opted an acronym SADS (sudden arrhythmic death syndrome) to “rebrand” it as “sudden adult death syndrome” (due to vaccines). These days, the narrative involves blaming vaccines, not the far more likely cause of COVID-19, for the large number of excess deaths recorded over the last couple of years.
While I have tried, both here and elsewhere, to weave together how the “died suddenly” narrative developed over the last couple of years, since Harriet died I’ve been thinking about a couple of other potential “accelerators” of the narrative, specifically two people who promoted this narrative beyond all others. One is Aseem Malhotra, whom you might have heard about recently co-opting his interview on the BBC, which was supposed to be about statins, to fear monger about COVID-19 vaccines:
Edging closer to 20 million views. Let’s keep going.
‘The truth is like a lion; you don’t have to defend it. Let it loose; it will defend itself’
🔥🔥🔥 https://t.co/FMIRlAxJVA
— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) January 16, 2023
Completely false. I’ve been the most vocal publishing papers & discussing in mainstream more than anyone in the world criticising statin over prescription over the years.They came to me last minute & junior BBC producer had no idea I’d mention mRNA.Spontaneous by me as had 7 min. https://t.co/7z8siQRF8I
— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) January 14, 2023
The other is Mark Crispin Miller, a Professor of Media, Culture, and Communication at New York University who has gone full antivax with respect to COVID-19 vaccines, as his Substack will clearly show you.
First, let’s start with Dr. Malhotra
The ultimate “died suddenly” anecdote
I’ve written about Dr. Malhotra a couple of times before, once early in the pandemic when he got all upset at the NHS for accepting a donation of Krispy Kreme donuts for frontline NHS workers because the thought it would make them more susceptible to COVID-19 and that the gift sent a bad message. He was—and still is—all about claiming that optimizing “metabolic health” would protect you against COVID-19. He even has a book written in 2020 claiming that a three week change in diet can greatly boost your resistance to the disease.
What I should have realized when I last wrote about him in the context of deconstructing a “review article” that he wrote blaming COVID-19 vaccines for cardiac disease is that his father was the ultimate “died suddenly” anecdote. Just look at what Dr. Malhotra wrote about his father’s sudden death in the first part of his review:
On 26 July 2021, my father, Dr Kailash Chand OBE, former deputy chair of the British Medical Association (BMA) and its honorary vice president (who had also taken both doses of the Pfizer mRNA vaccine six months earlier) suffered a cardiac arrest at home after experiencing chest pain. A subsequent inquiry revealed that a significant ambulance delay likely contributed to his death. But his post-mortem findings are what I found particularly shocking and inexplicable. Two of his three major arteries had severe blockages: 90% blockage in his left anterior descending artery and a 75% blockage in his right coronary. Given that he was an extremely fit and active 73-year-old man, having walked an average of 10–15 000 steps/day during the whole of lockdown, this was a shock to everyone who knew him, but most of all to me. I knew his medical history and lifestyle habits in great detail. My father who had been a keen sportsman all his life, was fitter than the overwhelming majority of men his age. Since the previous heart scans (a few years earlier, which had revealed no significant problems with perfect blood flow throughout his arteries and only mild furring), he had quit sugar, lost belly fat, reduced the dose of his blood pressure pills, started regular meditation, reversed his prediabetes and even massively dropped his blood triglycerides, significantly improving his cholesterol profile.
It didn’t take long, after the shock of losing his father suddenly, for Dr. Malhotra to blame vaccines:
I couldn’t explain his post-mortem findings, especially as there was no evidence of an actual heart attack but with severe blockages. This was precisely my own special area of research. That is, how to delay progression of heart disease and even potentially reverse it. In fact, in my own clinic, I successfully prescribe a lifestyle protocol to my patients on the best available evidence on how to achieve this. I’ve even co-authored a high-impact peer-reviewed paper with two internationally reputed cardiologists (both editors of medical journals) on shifting the paradigm on how to most effectively prevent heart disease through lifestyle changes. We emphasised the fact that coronary artery disease is a chronic inflammatory condition that is exacerbated by insulin resistance. Then, in November 2021, I was made aware of a peer-reviewed abstract published in Circulation, with concerning findings. In over 500 middle-aged patients under regular follow up, using a predictive score model based on inflammatory markers that are strongly correlated with risk of heart attack, the mRNA vaccine was associated with significantly increasing the risk of a coronary event within five years from 11% pre-mRNA vaccine to 25% 2–10 weeks post mRNA vaccine. An early and relevant criticism of the validity of the findings was that there was no control group, but nevertheless, even if partially correct, that would mean that there would be a large acceleration in progression of coronary artery disease, and more importantly heart attack risk, within months of taking the jab. I wondered whether my father’s Pfizer vaccination, which he received six months earlier, could have contributed to his unexplained premature death and so I began to critically appraise the data.
As much as I can sympathize with someone who has lost a father, other loved one, or friend in a sudden and unexpected manner and even understand how such a shock might lead him to look for causes, I cannot let that deter me from pointing out how bad this science is and how it has driven Dr. Malhotra to become one of the foremost promoters of the idea that COVID-19 vaccines are causing a wave of heart disease and sudden cardiac deaths.
I already discussed how bad the study cited above was; so I won’t do it again. What I will briefly discuss again is how, prepandemic, Dr. Malhotra’s “brand” and self-identity as a cardiologist were based on his advocacy of lifestyle and a vegan diet as being at least equal if not superior to statins and medications for slowing the progression of heart disease and even reversing it. It’s hard not to note that Dr. Chand died six months after receiving the Pfizer vaccine. More importantly, a person can have significant underlying heart disease and still appear to be just fine—very fit, even!—until the heart disease progresses to a level where compensatory mechanisms can no longer prevent complications. Again, I can see how his father’s sudden death could shake Dr. Malhotra’s belief system of diet and lifestyle as a panacea for good cardiac health. After all, if his father, who led the “right lifestyle” and walked 10,000-15,000 steps a day could succumb to coronary artery disease, then perhaps Dr. Malhotra’s faith in diet and exercise alone to ward off heart disease were misplaced or, at the very least, excessive.
Unfortunately, as is often is the case with those who believe in something very strongly, rather than question his existing belief systems, Dr. Malhotra clearly started looking for “other” causes for his father’s sudden death. I can only speculate, but, given his apparent belief in diet as the be-all and end-all of cardiovascular (and general) health, my guess is that in his grief he was even more susceptible than he might have been to the blandishments of the antivaccine movement and that susceptibility ultimately led to his going down the rabbit hole of antivaccine misinformation and conspiracy theories bolstered by bad science. Now he’s repeatedly made the news in recent months, thanks to his call for a stop to all vaccination with mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 because, according to him, they are causing a wave of sudden cardiac deaths.
“In memory of those who ‘died suddenly'”
Before I started noticing his contribution to the “died suddenly” narrative, I had never heard of Mark Crispin Miller before. His Substack describes him thusly:
Mark Crispin Miller is a Professor of Media, Culture, and Communication at New York University. He is the author of several books, including Boxed In: The Culture of TV (1988), The Bush Dyslexicon: Observations on a National Disorder (2001), Cruel and Unusual: Bush/Cheney’s New World Order (2004), and Fooled Again: The Real Case for Electoral Reform (2007). He is also the editor of Seeing Through Movies (1990), and Loser Take All: Election Fraud and the Subversion of Democracy, 2000-2008 (2008).
Miller’s essays and articles have appeared in many journals, magazines, and newspapers throughout the nation and the world, and he has given countless interviews worldwide, appearing in many documentaries, including Consuming Images (1989), The Merchants of Cool (2001), Orwell Rolls in His Grave (2003) and The True Cost (2015).
Miller is the editor of Forbidden Bookshelf, an e-book series that revives important works now out of print, most of which were variously killed at birth. Earlier he was the editor of two book series: Discovering America, published by the University of Texas Press, and, prior to that, Icons of America, published by Yale University Press.
What concerns me, however, is how he co-teaches a course on propaganda at New York University, Mass Persuasion and Propaganda (Course #MCC-UE 1014). After having read his blog, I very much worry that students at NYU will be hugely misinformed.
Be that as it may, if you peruse the list of posts in his archive, you will see a lot of them entitled “In memory of those who ‘died suddenly'” followed by locations and dates or other information. In fact, posts of this type make up by far the bulk of the posts on his Substack. Unfortunately, Substack search results don’t go very far back, making it hard to find the first time that he ever used this construction. I suspect that’s because a lot of his earlier posts are behind a paywall for subscribers.
Fortunately a series of Archive.org and Google searches led me to some observations. First, his Substack was started in June 2021. Second, right from the beginning he was ranting about “graphene” in vaccines. Third, he was ranting about the vaccine killing people as early as July 2021. By September 2021, he was blaming vaccines for the deaths of thousands in Trinidad and Tobago and sarcastically adding that “Black lives don’t matter” and blaming the deaths of famous people on vaccines. The first mention of “died suddenly” appears to have been in November 2021, when he wrote about a priest who “died suddenly” while getting the vaccine. I note that this tracks very closely with the approximate timeframe during which the specific use of “died suddenly” to describe athletes supposedly dying suddenly started to appear, which makes me think that Miller didn’t originate the phrase. Finally, the first “in memory of those who ‘died suddenly'” post that I could find was In memory of those who have “died suddenly” from February 1st to 7th, 2022. After that, it seemed to be a weekly thing but then expanded to a near daily feature. As an aside, not long after his “in memory of” posts started, Miller started parroting Russian propaganda about its invasion of Ukraine and suggesting that the war was a distraction from the “real war” (vaccines).
There are many other antivax sources who joined in, such as Steve Kirsch, but as you can see, the “died suddenly” narrative existed before antivaxxers had coined a the pithy sarcastic phrase “died suddenly” to blame sudden deaths on vaccines. I feature Dr. Malhotra mainly because he seems to be the saddest (given his father’s “died suddenly” story) but still most culpable example, because he is a cardiologist, and Mark Crispin Miller mainly because no one that I’ve yet been able to find has been as relentless at pushing the “died suddenly” narrative over the last year or so.
“Died Suddenly”? Sadly yes, but not of vaccines!
I’ve said a number of times that I now hate the way my brain works with respect to vaccines and deaths, referring to how one of my first thoughts after learning that someone had died unexpectedly—including, sadly, Harriet—is to ask how long before antivaxxers start blaming the death on vaccines. Even more sadly, it’s rarely very long at all if the person is the least bit famous—and sometimes even if the person isn’t. Unfortunately, I will probably be thinking that way until the day that I, too, die, either suddenly or not, after which antivaxxers will probably blame my death on vaccines, even if I meet my end being run over by a truck.
I will conclude with one final observation. This “died suddenly” phenomenon is not unique to vaccines and antivaxxers. It is, rather, a subset of a more general phenomenon in which those who deny science-based medicine blame deaths on the intervention or preventative, rather than the disease itself. Long before the pandemic, I was writing about how quacks and cranks would seize on the deaths of celebrities of cancer to blame chemotherapy, rather than their cancers, for having killed them. Examples are numerous (some catalogued here) and include David Bowie, Alan Rickman, Tony Snow, Farrah Fawcett, Elizabeth Edwards, Patrick Swayze (with a particularly despicable use of a photo showing how emaciated he was). Alternatively, they “lament” how a celebrity with cancer might have lived if only he had chosen (or stuck with) alternative medicine, such as Steve Jobs. The ghoulishness is a feature, not a bug, of the denial of medical science.
It is a denial that Harriet dedicated her post-Air Force life to combatting and that we here at SBM will continue to do. Antivaxxers can try to claim that vaccines killed Harriet all they want, but we know the truth, that unfortunately there are things medicine can’t always fix or prevent and that none of us gets out of here alive. All we can do is to use what time we have to do as much good as we can while we are still breathing, which is what Harriet tried to do. Ironically, by trying to add Harriet to their “died suddenly” conspiracy theory, antivaxxers gave her one last chance to help push back against quackery. I hope, but can never know, that she approves.


Has MSU economics professor Mark Skidmore been “exonerated” over his retracted paper claiming that COVID vaccines killed 278,000?
Tech bro turned antivax influencer Steve Kirsch is claiming that Michigan State University economist Mark Skidmore has been “exonerated” after having had a paper retracted claiming 278K deaths from COVID-19 vaccines in 2021 alone. In reality, Skidmore just republished a revised version of his retracted paper in an antivax journal after the MSU IRB failed miserably in its oversight duties.
David Gorski onO ctober 23, 2023
Link

If there’s one thing that I’ve learned over the last two decades dealing with antivax propaganda, it’s that bad papers written by antivax ideologues designed to promote a narrative that vaccines are dangerous and/or ineffective (but mostly dangerous) never die. Just take a look at the prototypical example of the modern antivaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield’s 1998 case series published in The Lancet that purported to show an association between the MMR vaccine and “autistic enterocolitis,” a finding that was also promoted from the beginning as a link between the MMR vaccine and autism. It took 12 years to get the paper retracted (as it should have been very quickly), with an investigation by journalist Brian Deer resulting in findings demonstrating scientific fraud. Unfortunately during that 12 years, Wakefield’s paper caused all manner of havoc stoking vaccine hesitancy in the UK and beyond. Even after retraction, it still has way more influence than any paper that bad and deserving of retraction should.
I could go on and on discussing antivax papers that somehow either never died, survived retraction, or reappeared in new journals after retraction—Anthony Mawson, anyone?—but this time around I want to discuss a retracted paper that has reappeared, leading tech bro turned ridiculously over-the-top antivax influencer Steve Kirsch to write a post over the weekend on his Substack entitled MSU Professor Mark Skidmore was exonerated by MSU; his landmark paper showing over 250,000 killed by the COVID vaccine is now back in the peer-reviewed literature. As you will see, this title is a mixture of one likely accurate piece of information that I will need to investigate further next week (about the IRB), a lie (that Skidmore’s study showed that as many as 278,000 people had been killed by COVID-19 vaccines), and a half-truth (that his awful “study” is back in the peer-reviewed literature).
First, let’s see what our antivax tech bro has to say, Predictably, he is crowing, because of course he is:
Mark Skidmore wrote a paper that showed that 217,000 Americans were killed in 2021 by the COVID vaccine.
The journal retracted the article and Mark’s university commenced a 7-month investigation into unethical behavior by Professor Skidmore.
Today, I’m pleased to announce that Professor Skidmore has been exonerated on all charges and his paper, with some helpful additions suggested by Dr. Susan Oliver (and her dog, Cindy), has now been published in another peer-reviewed journal.
Oh, dear. He’s dragging Dr. Oliver—and her dog Cindy!—into this and not me? It’s true that her video deconstructing Prof. Skidmore’s nonsense is an epic takedown of a really “stupid” paper (her words):
But, hey, Prof. Skidmore, Liberty Counsel, and Steve Kirsch, where’s the love for your humble SBM blogger too? After all, I wrote detailed deconstruction over at my not-so-secret other blog of why his paper was utter crap, why I thought that the IRB should have exercised better oversight, and why his “estimate” of over a quarter million people killed by COVID-19 vaccines was so risibly detached from data and reality. There’s a reason why I referred to his “study” as “antivax propaganda disguised as a survey.” (I’ll stop whining now, at least about this other than to assure Dr. Oliver that, no, even as bad as Prof. Skidmore’s paper is, it’s still not the worst antivax paper ever. I know. Unfortunately.)
Since I’ve never written about Prof. Skidmore or his study on SBM and the original retracted study was published nearly 10 months ago, I will have to take some time to repeat major criticisms here as I discuss the situation. I apologize in advance if the repetition annoys readers of both, but I do think it’s necessary and better than just referring readers to my previous post. Also, I want to document this fiasco on SBM.
There’s also something very telling in how this “exoneration” supposedly came about:
See this press release that Mark sent me.
The press release was drafted by the Liberty Counsel who was instrumental in defending Mark in the investigation by Michigan State University. If you want to support their work, please donate here.
Bottom line: After a 7-month ethics investigation, Michigan State University found that Mark did nothing wrong!
Note: What this really means is that they tried for 7 months to find something they could nail him on, and they failed.
Not exactly, as I will explain. Before I get to the issue of the MSU IRB, let me point out that a powerful right-wing advocacy group that is not just Christian dominionist but antivaccine and rabidly anti-LGBTQ+ promoted this study and defended Prof. Skidmore during the IRB investigation. Interesting. Let’s see what the Liberty Counsel press release dated October 17 claims:
Liberty Counsel recently helped exonerate a Michigan State University professor after he received allegations that he had used “unethical practices” during a published COVID-19 shot study. The study highlighted a correlation between the COVID shot and nearly 300,000 nationwide fatalities. The peer-reviewed journal BMC Infectious Diseases originally published the study in January 2023, but later retracted it amid the allegations. Despite the study’s retraction, it remains in the top one percent of shared research around the world.
Remember what I said about how bad antivax papers have an outsized influence on social media? That link shows that Skidmore’s paper still has an Altmetric score of 4,962, which is #2 most shared from all BMC Infectious Diseases papers, with Altmetrics noting:
Altmetric has tracked 24,654,416 research outputs across all sources so far. Compared to these this one has done particularly well and is in the 99th percentile: it’s in the top 5% of all research outputs ever tracked by Altmetric.
Depressing, but it shows how popular antivax papers are, and, of course, Steve Kirsch relentlessly flogged this incompetent paper when it was first published. Now let’s look at the BMC Infectious Diseases retraction notice:
The editors have retracted this article as concerns were raised regarding the validity of the conclusions drawn after publication. Post-publication peer review concluded that the methodology was inappropriate as it does not prove causal inference of mortality, and limitations of the study were not adequately described. Furthermore, there was no attempt to validate reported fatalities, and there are critical issues in the representativeness of the study population and the accuracy of data collection. Lastly, contrary to the statement in the article, the documentation provided by the author confirms that the study was exempt from ethics approval and therefore was not approved by the IRB of the Michigan State University Human Research Protection Program.
This, of course, is just a very brief version of what I wrote about the paper and of the many criticisms that others made about it starting as soon as it was published. I will, however, have to go into the issue of the Michigan State University institutional review board (IRB), as it demonstrates how clueless many IRBs are about antivax “science.”
To show you what I mean, let’s take a look at the gloating of the Liberty Counsel:
After a seven-month ethics investigation, Michigan State University’s Institutional Review Board (IRB) cleared Dr. Skidmore of any wrongdoing stating they did not find any “noncompliance” to their protocols within the study. Dr. Skidmore’s COVID shot study did not involve clinical work, but rather involved an online survey that posed little risk to human respondents. Due to his study being a survey only, the IRB at the onset of the research determined Dr. Skidmore’s study to be “exempt” from those clinical protocols and was cleared to proceed.
Later, I will then explain why this is a questionable finding that suggests a serious problem with university IRBs—a problem that is, unfortunately, more serious than even I had thought at the time. Finally:
While the original study remains retracted, the peer-reviewed journal Science, Public Health Policy & the Law recently published an updated version of the study titled, “COVID-19 Illness and Vaccination Experiences in Social Circles Affect COVID-19 Vaccination Decisions.” According to the study’s abstract, the primary goal was to identify what factors affect Americans in their decisions to get the COVID shot.
Does the journal Science, Public Health Policy & the Law sound familiar? It should. One thing lost in all the gloating by Steve Kirsch and the Liberty Counsel is that this particular journal is published by IPAK, as you can rapidly see by just glancing at the top of the first page of Prof. Skidmore’s revised paper. Then, take a look at the editorial board of this “journal”! It’s chock full of a veritable rogues’ gallery of antivaxxers, many of whom we’ve discussed before multiple times, including Russell Blaylock, Gayle DeLong, Brian Hooker, Mary Holland, Rick Jaffe (Stanislaw Burzynski‘s former attorney whom he stiffed for $250,000 in legal bills!), Anthony Mawson, Christopher Shaw, and Paul Thomas. (It’s a list that needs updating, because, sadly, Ms. DeLong passed away nearly two years ago.) Let’s just say that such a panoply of pseudoexperts, quacks, and pseudoscientists on the “journal’s” editorial board does not give me much confidence in its peer review. Basically, Prof. Skidmore, if he had any shame, would be super embarrassed by this, as his manuscript went from being retracted by a real journal to being published in a fake journal founded by an antivax pseudoscience that is used primarily to promote antivax pseudoscience.
What is IPAK, you ask? IPAK stands for the Institute of Pure and Applied Knowledge. If that name alone, even devoid of any knowledge of who is behind the “institute,” isn’t enough to send up huge red flags, then consider this. IPAK was founded by James Lyons-Weiler, an antivaxxer about whom I’ve written on many occasions dating back to before the pandemic, both here on SBM and over at my not-so-super-secret other blog. As you will see, while it is true that the survey appears to have been to “identify what factors affect Americans in their decisions to get the COVID shot,” Prof. Skidmore went way beyond that by taking the results of the survey and extrapolating them to estimate that COVID shots had killed over a quarter million people.
Let’s start with a discussion of what’s wrong with this paper, how Skidmore revised it, and why the new paper is no better than the old, all in the context of how, in my opinion, the IPAK “journal” where the revised manuscript found a new home is not a real scientific journal at all, but an antivax propaganda rag that isn’t even indexed by PubMed.
The first version was a “bait and switch” study using horrible methodology
In my original analysis of the first version of this survey published in BMC Infectious Diseases, I referred to the whole “study” as a “bait-and-switch” designed to promote an antivax narrative. Here’s why. On the surface, the primary aim of the original version of Prof. Skidmore’s survey seemed not at all unreasonable, as related in the original abstract:
The primary aim of this work is to identify the factors associated by American citizens with the decision to be vaccinated against COVID-19.
Nor was Prof. Skidmore’s methodology out of the ordinary—on the surface:
An online survey of COVID-19 health experiences was conducted. Information was collected regarding reasons for and against COVID-19 inoculations, experiences with COVID-19 illness and COVID-19 inoculations by survey respondents and their social circles. Logit regression analyses were carried out to identify factors influencing the likelihood of being vaccinated.
However, the true purpose of Prof. Skidmore’s survey rapidly became apparent, from what read to me like a tacked-on analysis:
In addition, the proportion of fatal events from COVID-19 vaccinations was estimated and compared with the data in the VAERS database.
As Scooby-Doo would, say, “Ruh-roh!” I sensed…an antivax assumption behind the survey, the same antivax assumption behind deceptive dumpster-diving into VAERS, namely that every report of a death or adverse event that occurs after vaccination must have been caused by vaccination.
And that appeared to be exactly the assumption that Prof. Skidmore had. First, let’s look at an entirely unsurprising finding of the original survey:
A total of 2840 participants completed the survey between December 18 and 23, 2021. 51% (1383 of 2840) of the participants were female and the mean age was 47 (95% CI 46.36–47.64) years. Those who knew someone who experienced a health problem from COVID-19 were more likely to be vaccinated (OR: 1.309, 95% CI 1.094–1.566), while those who knew someone who experienced a health problem following vaccination were less likely to be vaccinated (OR: 0.567, 95% CI 0.461–0.698). 34% (959 of 2840) reported that they knew at least one person who had experienced a significant health problem due to the COVID-19 illness. Similarly, 22% (612 of 2840) of respondents indicated that they knew at least one person who had experienced a severe health problem following COVID-19 vaccination.
As I noted at the time, it made intuitive sense that people who know someone who experienced a significant health issue after a bout with COVID-19 would be more likely to be vaccinated, while those who know someone who experienced a severe health issue after COVID-19 vaccination—whether that health problem was related to the vaccine or not, I hasten to add—would be less likely to be vaccinated. I conceded at the time that there might have been some utility in demonstrating this point about vaccine hesitancy yet again and perhaps attempting to quantify the effect. As I also said at the time, I had no problem with that sort of survey. What I did have a problem with is when such a survey was used as a jumping-off point to support conspiracy theories involving vaccine “depopulation” and “died suddenly” narratives. Here’s what I meant, again, quoting from the original version of the paper:
With these survey data, the total number of fatalities due to COVID-19 inoculation may be as high as 278,000 (95% CI 217,330–332,608) when fatalities that may have occurred regardless of inoculation are removed.
“Fatalities that may have occurred regardless of inoculation are removed”? How, pray tell, did Prof. Skidmore figure this out? Then there was the original conclusion:
Knowing someone who reported serious health issues either from COVID-19 or from COVID-19 vaccination are important factors for the decision to get vaccinated. The large difference in the possible number of fatalities due to COVID-19 vaccination that emerges from this survey and the available governmental data should be further investigated.
See what I meant at the time by a “bait-and-switch”? Prof. Skidmore started with what seemed to be a fairly reasonable conclusion (health issues among a person’s social circle after COVID-19 or COVID-19 vaccination influence will influence that person’s decision to get vaccinated) but then used unjustified extrapolation to buttress an antivax conclusion, namely that vaccines killed nearly 300K people. Prof. Skidmore then JAQed off about the supposed discrepancy between this estimate and government statements about the safety of the vaccines, using his JAQing off to call for an “investigation.” True, at the very end Prof. Skidmore conceded that there are “limitations with using a survey to collect COVID-19 health information, particularly for a politicized health issue” and respondents “often interpret events with bias due to perceptions based on history, beliefs, culture and family background.” (Well, duh.) Unfortunately, these limitations were only mentioned in a paragraph near the very end of the paper and did not dispel the overall narrative that this survey was evidence that COVID-19 vaccines had killed—as of the end of 2021, when the survey period ended—close to 300,000 people.
Regular readers know that the most significant limitations of the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database are that anyone can report anything and that correlation does not necessarily equal causation. That’s why antivaxxers have long loved to dumpster dive into the VAERS database and misrepresent every report as being slam dunk evidence that a given adverse event (AE) reported was definitely due to the vaccine that it happened after. As antivaxxers do with VAERS, Prof. Skidmore appeared to accept nearly every respondent’s report of a death from the vaccine as having been caused by the vaccine.
The first issue, though, was that a survey like this is just not a valid method to calculate a valid and accurate estimate of the number of deaths due to…well, almost any cause, regardless of the source of the survey subjects, in this case Dynata, a company that was billed as the “world’s largest first-party data platform” and having provided a sample that was “representative for the US American population.” Let’s assume for the moment that this claim is justified and the sample used was representative of the US population. Even in that case, Prof. Skidmore’s methodology that extrapolated from his survey results to claim such a high death toll from COVID-19 vaccines was completely bogus, given that deciding whether any given death is plausibly due to a vaccine is far from the straightforward determination that Prof. Skidmore apparently thinks it is. When someone in a person’s circle of relatives, friends, and acquaintances dies, generally that person will just take the family members’ word for what the cause of death was, regardless of whether the family member is correct or not about that cause of death. Prof. Skidmore even conceded as much reporting one of his original results, sort of:
Estimated nationwide COVID-19 vaccine fatalities based on the Democrat, Republican and Independent subsets are 109,564, 463,444 and 247,867, respectively. With the vaccinated and unvaccinated subgroups, estimated COVID-19 vaccine fatalities are 110,942 and 659,995.
There was actually a germ of an interesting observation here, namely that political and ideological orientation has a huge effect on whether a person attributes the death of a loved one, friend, or family member to COVID-19 vaccines.This observation, however, said absolutely nothing about whether that death of a loved one, friend, or family member was actually caused by COVID-19 vaccines. Indeed, the huge discrepancy in the numbers based on ideological groups should tell you in and of itself that these numbers were perceptions, not reality. In the hands of a researcher not hellbent on spinning these results into antivaccine disinformation, these results could have served as the preliminary data from which to develop interesting hypotheses to test in further studies. Prof. Skidmore is an economist, however, not a social scientist, and instead he used these numbers to argue that we should “investigate” the apparent discrepancy between these numbers and the government’s figures. In other words, he used them to bolster the antivax “died suddenly” conspiracy theory that claims the vaccines are killing huge numbers of people but “they” are “covering up” the evidence:
The ratio of COVID-19 vaccine deaths to COVID-19 illness deaths of the people respondents knew best who had health problems is 57/165 =0.345, whereas the ratio of vaccine-associated fatalities to COVID-19 fatalities from government sources is 8023/839,993 = 0.0096. The null hypothesis (H0) that the true ratio, X, is equal to the CDC ratio which is also equal to the survey ratio: X = CDC Ratio = Survey Ratio.
This hypothesis is tested using state-by-state VAERS data on reported COVID-19 vaccine-associated deaths and COVID-19 illness fatalities. The alternative hypothesis (Ha) is: X = CDC Ratio < Survey Ratio. The mean (u) and standard deviation (σ) of the ratio of vaccine fatalities to COVID-19 fatalities from the state-by-state data are u = 0.0136 and σ = 0.0111. The probability that the Survey Ratio > CDC Ratio = X is P(CDC Ratio > 0.345). With P(CDC Ratio > 0.345) = 0 and a Z-score = 28.86; the null hypothesis is rejected.
So science-y! So statistics-y! So wrong!
So basically, Prof. Skidmore, for reasons known only to him, tested a fantasy hypothesis that his estimate of how many deaths resulting from COVID-19 vaccines based on a survey that reflected the perceptions of the respondents and not actual medical reality, should match government statistics and declared the hypothesis falsified when the two numbers turned out to be very different from each other. Then he did the same thing with VAERS. Truly, this was fractal pseudoscience whose abuse of frequentist statistics was truly impressive.
I also noted at the time that Prof. Skidmore’s ideological bias was far from secret, citing his website Lighthouse Economics, where he maintains a personal blog. Just a brief perusal of his blog demonstrates that he’s a hard core antivaccine conspiracy theorist. If you don’t believe me, just peruse some of these entries for yourself, such as:
    • Technocrats-At-Work: Medical Profession Implements WHO’s Digital Diagnosis Code For The Unvaxxed
    • All Hell Breaks Loose: Elon Musk Tweets He Felt He Was Dying After Booster, Young Cousin Hospitalized With Myocarditis; Scott Adams Says Anti-Vaxxers Were Right, Protests Outside BBC, Fox News VP Dies
    • Africa Is Starkly Unvaccinated, and Starkly Unvanquished by COVID
    • MRNA Vaccine is a “Shotgun Blast” to Brain and Reproductive Organs
    • “Fully Vaccinated” 27 Year Old Model Dies Suddenly
You get the idea. Prof. Skidmore conducted his survey because he’s antivax.
More interestingly, the Funding section revealed to me that this entire survey had been funded by one person, Catherine Austin Fitts. At the time, I had never heard of Ms. Fitts; so Google was my friend. It didn’t take long to find out that she’s worked with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. before, with a Washington Post article noting:
The viral clip from “Planet Lockdown” depicts an interview with Catherine Austin Fitts, who served as assistant secretary of housing and urban development under President George H.W. Bush and has since worked in finance. Fitts, who has no background in medicine or public health, has worked with anti-vaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to promote unfounded claims about the pandemic and to oppose lockdown measures put in place to slow the spread of the virus.
So the original survey was carried by an antivaxxer using funding from an antivax conspiracy loon who’s worked with one of the longtime leaders of the antivaccine movement, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Moreover, the real purpose of Prof. Skidmore’s “research had been hidden in plain sight for nearly a year before the publication of the first version of his survey, as I discovered when I did some digging last January. Buried in a list of papers in a Steve Kirsch Substack entitled License to kill (and how to redpill patients) there’s a link to a paper published as a PDF on Prof. Skidmore’s site as a “working paper” entitled How Many People Died from the Covid-19 Inoculations? An Estimate Based on a Survey of the United States Population*. Interestingly, the primary and secondary aims listed in the “working paper” were identical to the aims in the retracted version originally published in BMC Infectious Diseases, but flipped. The primary aim in the old “working paper” dated February 28, 2022 was to examine “the potential fatalities and injuries from the COVID-19 inoculation using an online ‘Covid-19 Health Experiences Survey’ administered to a representative sample of the United States (US) population,” while almost as an afterthought Prof. Skidmore wrote that “I also analyze the factors that influence the likelihoods of being inoculated, experiencing an adverse event, and knowing someone who was injured by the COVID-19 inoculation.” (Emphasis mine.)
Looking at the original paper in light of this nearly year-old precursor (which quoted antivax luminaries like Sen. Ron Johnson and Informed Choice Australia—even the execrable Stephanie Seneff “review” article on vaccine harm), I remain even more convinced that the original paper was a total bait-and-switch and still think that Prof. Skidmore did the survey to come up with an inflated estimate for the number of COVID-19 vaccine “deaths” but also did an analysis of factors leading to COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy, which would be much more palatable to reviewers and thus more likely to be published in a peer-reviewed journal. He then shoehorned in the inflated, implausible, and unproven death estimates, whose successful publication in a reputable peer-reviewed journal was the realpurpose of this survey. The “working paper” version of the manuscript is a “greatest hits” collection of antivaccine tropes, distortions, and misinterpretations of scientific studies; the published version is cleaned up just enough to make it past peer review by people clearly not familiar with antivaccine disinformation but still keep the claim that COVID-19 vaccines caused 278,000 deaths in the final version, so that antivaxxers can point to it instead of the correlations between various responses and likelihood to accept the COVID-19 vaccine.
Now let’s take a look at the “revised” paper published by IPAK.
Second verse, same as the first (mostly)
The first thing I did examining the “revised” paper was to do a quicky text comparison of the abstracts of the two using BBEdit. It turns out that the abstracts are virtually identical, except for the format. Take out the headings and line breaks after each section from the retracted paper, and the text of the “revised” paper is identical to that of the original. Not a good sign. It is equally a bad sign that the entire introduction of the second version is virtually identical to that of the original version, other than referring to the CDC as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and differences in references cited in the more recent version. The second paragraphs of both introductions are identical, word-for word.
I did find some minor differences in the Methods section. For example, in the new manuscript Prof. Skidmore deleted a passage going on about how the CDC had supposedly changed the definition of COVID-19 deaths and was overcounting them, in essence a restatement of what I called the “only 6% gambit” from that claimed that “only” 6% of deaths attributed to COVID-19 were actually COVID deaths. It was a conspiracy theory that claimed that the CDC and others were misattributing deaths from other conditions to COVID-19. In addition, part of the passage deleted stated:
Additional analysis is conducted wherein CDC data on deaths per 100,000 people for pre-pandemic 2019 are used to calculate the expected number of fatalities by age group, which is subtracted from reported COVID-19 vaccine fatalities in the survey to obtain COVID-19 vaccine-related fatalities net of deaths that might have occurred regardless of vaccination status.
Apparently this analysis is not in the new version. More suspiciously, an entire section in the first version about how “severe” AEs were defined appears not to have made it to the new version. Basically, in the original version, a non-physician economist decided which AEs constituted potentially “severe” life-threatening AEs. In the new version, the criteria for severe AEs are much less clear, and Prof. Skidmore writes merely, “‘Severe’ and ‘less severe’ adverse events are calculated separately.”
Looking at the results in both papers shows…not much change. Other than format, Table I appears to be identical in both papers, as do Tables 2, 3, and 4. There is, however, a chart in the new version that was not included in the old, Figure 1:

To find out how Prof. Skidmore got this figure, you have to read the file named Supplementary Material 4, which contains a Microsoft Word file describing the methodology. It turns out that it’s basically the same nonsense that Prof. Skidmore did, just with more verbiage. Basically, he tries to estimate how many people would have “died anyway” not necessarily because of the vaccines by, well, let me just let him explain, so that you can facepalm at his “sensitivity analysis”:
It is possible that reported deaths following vaccination were not caused by vaccination but rather were coincident with vaccination. To address this issue, one could subtract deaths that might have occurred regardless of vaccination status. The phrasing of the survey question with regard to potential vaccine related health problems made it clear that health issues that emerged following vaccination should be reported. This suggests that it may be inappropriate to subtract deaths resulting from ongoing chronic conditions or other ongoing illnesses that would likely be known by respondent prior to vaccination. In other words, deaths that arise relatively quickly that might have occurred in tandem with vaccination but would have occurred regardless of vaccination status should be subtracted. According to Slovis, et al. (1), the five most common causes of sudden death are fatal arrhythmias, acute myocardial infarction, intracranial hemorrhage/massive stroke (cerebrovascular accident), massive pulmonary embolism and acute aortic catastrophe.
Available from the author upon request are the calculations for the reported Covid vaccine deaths from the survey along with the 2019 standardized mortality rates per 100,000 people for the top ten causes of death for each age group, which are obtained from the National Center for Health Statistics (2).
So basically, Prof. Skidmore assumes—and remember what they say happens when you “assume” anything—that any increase in “sudden” deaths over the “baseline” in 2019, as opposed to deaths from chronic diseases and conditions, that occurred after the vaccines rolled out,. were most likely due to the vaccines, assuming that people with chronic diseases who died relatively quickly would probably have “died anyway.” Maybe an epidemiologist will request the calculations. I know that Prof. Skidmore knows who I am and would be highly unlikely to provide me his calculations.
In the revised paper itself:
This evaluation is conducted under the assumption that the reported vaccine-related fatalities and injuries are caused by the COVID-19 vaccine but is now relaxed by reducing the number of reported fatalities by the deaths due to other causes that would be expected to have occurred anyway. Subtracting expected fatalities from “quick onset” conditions (diseases of the heart and cerebrovascular diseases) generates estimated nationwide COVID-19 vaccine fatalities of 205,737. If all expected fatalities except those from external causes are subtracted, estimated nationwide COVID-19 vaccine fatalities are 126,407. More detail on these calculations is provided in Supplementary Material 4.
And in Supplemental Material 4:
As shown in Figure 1 in the body of the article, expected fatalities exceed reported fatalities for the 65-74 and 74-85 age groups, but the other categories generate positive vaccine deaths after subtracting expected fatalities. Setting COVID-19 vaccine fatalities to zero for the 65-74 and over 74 age groups, and tallying net fatalities for the other age groups generates 39 vaccine-related fatalities. Applying the same method described in the article to calculate estimated nationwide vaccine-induced fatalities generates 205,737 fatalities. Subtracting expected fatalities from all causes generates negative net fatalities for the 55-64 age group as well. In this case, the sum of fatalities net of all expected fatalities is 25, which generates projected fatalities nationwide of about 126,407 fatalities.
Wait, what? I thought that the lower bound of the 95% confidence interval was 229,319!
In any case, surely you can see the problem with extrapolating in this fashion from 39 fatalities—or 25 fatalities or however many people who reported knowing someone who died after COVID-19 vaccination—even if they were truly related to COVID-19 vaccines, to produce an estimate in the hundreds of thousands of deaths. It’s the same essential problem with the first manuscript, and the second is no better. It’s the same analysis, with the same four tables, just with an additional tacked-on graph based on a meaningless extrapolation from small numbers. To put it more broadly, extrapolating the results of a survey with 2,840 respondents to a population of roughly 330 million is problematic enough, even if you leave aside the fact that what is being reported is perception, not reality.
Truly, the new and “revised” version of this “study” is, for all intents and purposes, nearly identical to the retracted study. Both are bad science. The only difference is that now the “study” is published in an appropriate journal, a fake journal with an editorial board full of antivaxxers sympathetic to bad “science” like this, letting Prof. Skidmore come to use invalid assumptions, unwarranted extrapolation, and general bad science to come to exactly the same conclusion as he did in his retracted paper, “The large difference in the possible number of fatalities due to COVID-19 vaccination that emerges from this survey and the available governmental data should be further investigated.”
But what about the IRB?
Now that we’ve established that Prof. Skidmore’s revised paper is just the same old rancid wine in a new skin, it’s important to address the second part of all of the crowing coming from Steve Kirsch, the Liberty Counsel, and, yes, James Lyons-Weiler himself over how Prof. Skidmore has been “exonerated” (and therefore you should believe his crappy paper just because the IRB didn’t find that he had done anything wrong and an antivaxxer was willing to publish his dreck in his fake journal). The Liberty Counsel, being a right-wing crank group run by lawyer and former pastor Mat Staver, couldn’t resist framing its victory thusly:
Since 2021, there have been several instances of publications retracting research that has identified possible causal links between COVID-19 shots and adverse reactions. In July 2023, Dr. Peter McCullough, an internist, epidemiologist, and one of the most published cardiologists in America with more than 1,000 peer-reviewed publications to his credit, was quickly censored within 24 hours after he published an article showing clear evidence that the COVID-19 shots were responsible for many deaths. Out of 325 autopsies from various global locations, the study revealed the COVID shots directly caused or significantly contributed to up to 74 percent of those deaths. The Lancet, which initially published the article, took less than 24 hours to remove it citing the study fell short of the journal’s “screening criteria” and that the study’s methods did not merit its conclusions.
Not mentioned is that Dr. McCullough is now a quack selling dubious supplements to treat COVID-19 and to “detoxify” you from the supposedly deadly spike protein made after vaccination with mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines and that both of those paper were pure dreck. I laughed out loud at this part, though:
Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, “The allegations against Dr. Mark Skidmore were baseless. Researchers with integrity like Dr. Skidmore are using rigorous scientific protocols to validate the dangers of the COVID-19 shots. Censoring scientific debate is reprehensible and our researchers need to be free to conduct proper science without fear of late
Again, to me such retractions are quality control, not “censorship,” although I remain continually frustrated how poor and slow that quality control is. Also, “rigorous scientific protocols”? You keep using that term. I do not think it means what you think it means, but, then, neither Mr. Staver nor Prof. Skidmore are physicians or scientists.
As for the MSU IRB, what happened? Liberty Counsel, before crowing about Prof. Skidmore’s “exoneration,” writes:
The study’s author, Dr. Mark Skidmore, is an economics, natural disasters, and pandemics researcher with more than 90 published papers. Liberty Counsel assisted him in reviewing the anonymous complaints and responding to the investigation to appropriately address all the concerns. In essence, the complaints alleged Dr. Skidmore did not follow the rigorous oversight procedures required for clinical studies. A “guilty” finding from the university on this type of complaint could have serious consequences for a researcher’s credibility and career, since clinical studies involving human subjects have strict oversight and protocols to ensure no harm comes to study participants.
That’s laying it on a bit thick. Prof. Skidmore is described on his MSU webpage as tenured Professor and Morris Chair in State and Local Government Finance and Policy, while currently serving as a resident fellow with the MSU Extension Center for Local Government Finance and Policy, as well as holding appointments in the Department of Agricultural, Food, and Resource Economics and Economics. His areas of expertise include public finance policy and the relationship between policy and economic development, with recent research areas including work on property taxation, regional development, and the economics of natural disasters. None of this betrays any evidence of work on pandemics before this. I perused his list of publications, and didn’t find anything related to pandemics other than this most recent paper.
First of all, I rather half-feared that the MSU IRB would fail to find any wrongdoing or failure. As I said while discussing the now-retracted first version of this manuscript, asking: How did this study manage to get approval from MSU’s IRB, anyway? My guess at the time was that the survey looked like a straightforward assessment of factors that affected people’s decision to be vaccinated against COVID-19, without any obvious indication how the authors would use the results to deceptively claim that close to 300,000 people had been killed by COVID-19 vaccines and then bolster a conspiracy that the government was somehow hiding this carnage. Again, the whole study struck me (and continues to strike me) as a bait-and-switch designed to get antivaccine disinformation published in a peer reviewed journal.
IRBs are tasked with ensuring the safety of human subjects in research, as well as with protecting their rights. The definition of “human research” is not always clear, however, when it comes to social sciences and surveys. It is true that many surveys fall into a human subjects research category that is exempt from detailed IRB oversight—but not exempt from all IRB oversight. For example, my guess is that Prof. Skidmore’s research most likely qualified for this exemption, which requires a limited IRB review:
Exempt 2(iii). LIMITED IRB REVIEW REQUIRED. Research involving the use of educational tests, survey procedures, interview procedures or observation of public behavior and information obtained is recorded by the investigator in such a manner that the identity of the human subjects can readily be ascertained and disclosure of the responses outside the research could reasonably place the subjects at risk.
This exemption requires a limited IRB review to make the determination that “[w]hen appropriate, there are adequate provisions to protect the privacy of subjects and to maintain the confidentiality of data.” That’s it.
If the IRB didn’t know about the antecedent “white paper” showing the true purpose of Prof. Skidmore’s survey as an instrument designed to estimate how many people had died from COVID-19 vaccinations, I’m sure that the survey probably looked benign enough to the IRB, just a tool to estimate vaccine hesitancy and relate it to different socioeconomic and societal characteristics. The only reason it needed limited review was because the identity of the human subjects might have been able to be ascertained. Also, the survey itself (in Supplemental Materials 1) describes the purpose of the research only as, “You are being asked to participate in this web-based survey in order to increase our understanding of the health experiences people have had during the COVID-19 crisis period.” Again, that sounds pretty benign, with no indication of what Prof. Skidmore was really going to do with the results.
If the failure of the MSU IRB to detect that this survey was really human subjects research in the form of a pseudo-epidemiological study was quite understandable two years ago, when the initial study was being reviewed, why is it that the IRB did not find any violations on the part of Prof. Skidmore once he had published his paper misusing the results to extrapolate in a completely invalid fashion from his survey a huge number deaths due to COVID-19 vaccines? After all, if the scope of a survey-study expands to become arguably human subjects research, then a good case can be made that the IRB should treat it as more of an epidemiological or clinical study.
So why did the IRB fail to act? One possible reason is that the subjects were drawn from a company, meaning that, although the company knew who the survey subjects were, Prof. Skidmore did not because the data were anonymized. (That’s one reason to use a company like Dynata.) Another possible reason is a common view that it’s not the job of the IRB to police bad science except when the poor quality of the science endangers the human subjects in the study. As a result, IRBs are less likely to intervene against bad science when the study is “just a survey” than when it is an actual clinical trial or clinical study with patients. Finally, one can’t discount the very real possibility that the university was afraid of litigation by the Liberty Counsel, which has very deep pockets, aggressive lawyers, and a propensity to sue, sue, sue, and found it easier just to let Prof. Skidmore off rather than face the wrath of the Liberty Counsel. Which of these, either alone or in combination, was the reason for the shameful dereliction of duty by the MSU IRB? I have no way of knowing. I just know that the MSU IRB failed miserably in this instance, even if it did so by following the letter of the law governing human research but ignoring its spirit.
I began this post by stating that the antivax narrative about the “exoneration” of Mark Skidmore is based on one possibly accurate piece of information, a lie, and a half-truth (that his awful “study” is back in the peer-reviewed literature). The likely accurate piece of information is that the MSU IRB did “exonerate” Prof. Skidmore of violating US regulations with respect to human subjects research. (Note that it did not “exonerate” his study on a scientific basis.) The lie is that Prof. Skidmore’s study is evidence that COVID-19 vaccines might have killed well over a quarter million people by the end of 2021, which was only a little more than a year after the vaccines had rolled out. The half-truth is that the study is back in the peer-reviewed literature. I’m sure that Science, Public Health Policy & the Law probably does do a form of “peer review,” but, if its editorial board full of antivaxxers is any indication, that peer review is perfunctory, low quality, and biased towards papers claiming to find nonexistent dangers du to vaccines. Also, the journal is not indexed by PubMed, for obvious reasons. In my opinion, it’s a fake scientific journal run by cranks.
Whether the MSU IRB failed or not, I do take some consolation in the utter humiliation of an antivax crank like Prof. Skidmore, except that he appears to be too shameless to care about how much his credibility outside of right wing antivax circles has likely been devastated. His paper was retracted by a real journal with a good reputation, and, MSU IRB “exoneration” notwithstanding, he was reduced to publishing it in a not very heavily revised form in a highly dubious journal that was founded by an antivaxxer and whose editorial board consists of the dregs of antivax “academics.” It is a fate that he richly deserves, although, again, I fear that he is far too shameless to appreciate just how far he has fallen. On the other hand, his cachet in the antivaccine movement has been bolstered because now not only does he have a narrative of having been “censored” when his original manuscript was retracted but he now has added a narrative of “exoneration,” even if it requires publishing in an antivax journal that, I daresay, before the pandemic he never would have considered, recognizing it for what it is.

COVID-19 vaccines versus “purity of essence”
Antivaxxers frequently make the false claim that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter your DNA”. These claims are really a concern about “impurifying” their “purity of essence”.
David Gorski on April 12, 2021
Link

One of my favorite movies of all time is the Stanley Kubrick film Dr. Stangelove or: How I Stopped Worrying and Learned to Love the Bomb. It is one of the greatest comedies of all time and arguably the greatest black comedy of all time. In brief, its plot concerns an unhinged purity-obsessed Air Force general named Gen. Jack D. Ripper (Kubrick obviously wasn’t aiming for subtlety), who manages to subvert chain of command and protocol and order the B-52 bomber wing under his command to launch a nuclear first strike against the Soviet Union. The film then follows the increasingly desperate (and darkly comical) efforts of the President, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and an RAF exchange officer under Gen. Ripper’s command to stop nuclear Armageddon, while showing the parallel efforts of the crew of one B-52 bomber to get through to its target, with Peter Sellers playing three roles (the President, the RAF officer, and Dr. Strangelove, the mysterious ex-Nazi scientist/advisor who personified the dark id behind the Cold War). I realize that it might be difficult for those too young to remember the Cold War, nuclear fallout shelters, and air raid drills to fully comprehend the terror that Kubrick was playing with in this film, but the film nonetheless holds up as an artifact of a period from decades during which mutually assured destruction was a fact of life and that destruction could have come about due to accident or something like what was portrayed in this film.
The reason I mention Dr. Strangelove in the context of a post about COVID-19 deniers and antivaxxers is because of the belief system of the main antagonist of the film, Gen. Jack D. Ripper, whom I’ve mentioned before on this blog at least a couple of times. In brief, the reason Ripper launched his first strike was so as not to permit, as he put it, “Communist infiltration, Communist indoctrination, Communist subversion, and the international Communist conspiracy to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids” (around 1:10):
His discussion with his RAF office Mandrake then amusingly goes into his obsession with his “purity of essence” and Ripper’s determination to deny women his “essence” during “the act of love”, as he puts it. Unsurprisingly (for the time), Gen. Ripper believed that the fluoridation of water was the mechanism by which Communists were accomplishing this nefarious aim to “impurify” Americans’ “precious bodily fluids”, as he explains while US troops are attacking his base as part of the government’s effort to try to stop the first strike:
Why would I discuss this belief system in the context of COVID-19 and antivaxxers? Simple. It’s because Gen. Ripper’s fear of “contamination” (or, as he puts it, “impurification”) of his “precious bodily fluids,” his obsession with “purity of essence” (the very term playing a large role in the plot), and his conspiracy theory that “they” are out to contaminate that purity in order to conquer you remind me very much of how antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers are discussing the pandemic and, of course, COVID-19 vaccines. I haven’t written about the topic of “toxins” and “detox” in the context of vaccines in a while, but given the advent of COVID-19 vaccines based on mRNA or adenoviral vectors, it felt like time to revisit this topic, specifically how belief in “purity of essence” and “contamination” of that essence, à la Gen. Ripper, drives antivaccine beliefs and rhetoric. That’s because, as I’ve discussed before, “contamination” and “detoxification” lie at the heart of unscientific alternative medicine beliefs that undergird much of antivaccine rhetoric. I’ll start with antivaccine rhetoric I used to encounter before the pandemic, and finish with the now oft-repeated lie that COVID-19 vaccines somehow “alter your DNA” (i.e., contaminate your purity of essence.)
The “occult archetype called vaccination”
The first time I really started thinking about this connection was nearly four years ago. At the time, I was becoming convinced that it is a fear of bodily “contamination” that harks back to ideas found in many religions that underlies a lot of antivaccine belief. Think about it. Where does the fear of “toxins” in vaccines come from? Vaccines are portrayed as “foreign”, as something “unnatural” that is “injected right into the bloodstream”. (Never mind that vaccines are not injected directly into the bloodstream.) To the antivaxxer, there is no difference between an intramuscular and an intravenous injection because to them both are equally “contaminating”. Both equally sap and impurify your precious bodily fluids. It’s also not a coincidence that many of the treatments for “vaccine-induced autism” or any other condition falsely attributed to vaccines are represented as “detoxification.” They are basically purges, to purge the “evil humors” that antivaxers believe vaccines to be packed full of. It’s not for nothing that I’ve not infrequently described alternative medicine “detoxification” as being akin to ritual purification of the sort found in many different religions. Think of chelation therapy and all the “detoxification” treatments used by autism quacks as basically an effort to restore the purity of the child’s precious bodily fluids. Moreover, given that these ideas of “contamination” of one’s “purity” are based in religion, it’s not surprising that antivaxxers would use highly religious imagery and language to describe vaccination.
It’s also not surprising that they would also engage in projection. One example that I still remember years later is an article by Jon Rappaport entitled “The Occult Archetype Called Vaccination“. In it, Rappaport took a germ of a semireasonable cultural/anthropological discussion of vaccination as a “rite of passage through danger, into the tribe and village, conferring a moral righteousness, presided over by a shaman” and goes straight off the deep end with it:
Some ancient rituals presented dangers. The child, on his way to becoming a man, would be sent out to live alone in the forest for a brief period and survive. Vaccination symbolizes this in a passive way: the injection of disease-viruses which might be harmful are transmuted into protective spirits in the body. The injection of toxic chemicals is a passageway into immunity. If a child is damaged in the process, the parents and the tribe consider it a tragic but acceptable risk, because on the whole the tribe and the village are protected against the evil spirits (viruses).
Notice the magical thinking Rappaport ascribes here. It’s pure mysticism and superstition that no one advocating vaccination actually believes. Does any vaccine advocate claim that vaccines are the injection of “disease matter” that is somehow magically transmuted into “protective spirits”? Or that vaccines are “toxic chemicals” injected as a “passageway to immunity”? It could work as a metaphor, of course, but that metaphor would, in a reasonable usage, be layered over the scientific and public health benefits of vaccination; moreover, the risks of vaccination are nowhere near as high as Rappaport implies. Also, Rappaport takes it far beyond that into the territory of fear and loathing, along with the rather obvious attempt to imply that vaccination is only about religious/mystical beliefs and ancient archetypes, rather than having just an element of tapping into those archetypes of a rite of passage involving a shaman.
Vaccines versus “purity of essence”
Rappaport’s rhetoric about vaccines in 2017 might come across as extreme, but it was mild compared to that of Mike Adams. I was reminded of this when I saw a recent post over at his Natural News website entitled ‘mRNA vaccines may cause your body to churn out PRIONS that “eat your brain” like Mad Cow Disease‘. Since I’ve already discussed in depth how utterly without a scientific basis the antivax claim that the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna mRNA vaccines will lead to prion diseases like Mad Cow Disease was, I won’t dwell on that part, other than to observe that Adams is rather behind the antivax times. (Really, that Classen article was published nearly two months ago.) Instead, I’ll point out how Adams uses rhetoric that COVID-19 vaccines will turn you into a “vaccine zombie”. This is, of course, not a new claim. The video Adams uses is a decade old at least:
Of course, the entire myth of the “zombie” is all about decomposition, putrefaction, and contamination with contagion, such that a zombie bite turns the person bitten into a zombie too. This sort of imagery is very intentional.
Four years ago, during a rant about Facebook’s efforts to slow the spread of antivaccine disinformation, Adams was likening vaccination to both contamination and violation of a most horrific kind:
Mark Zuckerberg isn’t accused of raping little children with his biology, but he controls the social media network that openly espouses the medical violation of childrens’ bodies with toxic injections — a form of “medical rape” that obscenely violates the American Medical Association’s medical ethics when mandated by coercive government (as has already happened in California with SB 277).
Further adding to the horrifying truth of what Zuckerberg and Facebook are really up to, many vaccines given to children in America today are made from the ground-up, homogenized, disease-inoculated organs of aborted black babies. These “human embryonic lung cell cultures” are openly listed as chicken pox vaccine ingredients by the CDC and vaccine manufacturers, all of whom also openly admit that vaccines are made from diseased animal organs such as African Green Monkey kidney cells. (MMR vaccines are also made from the tissue of aborted human babies.)
Regular readers will recognize the usual antivaccine claims, just with the hyperbole and ridiculousness dialed up to 11 and beyond. I’ve mentioned many times how antivaxxers like to make the false claim that vaccines are made from the “tissue of aborted babies,” ignoring the fact that cells isolated from a fetus in the 1960s and maintained in culture in dishes over 50 years are not the same thing as “tissue from aborted human babies”. (One also wonders where he got the idea that the original fetuses were Black, much less that their organs had been “inoculated with disease”.)
This is, of course, Mike Adams. We therefore expect that his writings will be full of distortions, misinformation, disinformation, lies, and conspiracy theories. That’s who he is. My point is not to refute individually each bizarre claim made by Adams in an article from 2017, given that I’ve refuted such claims individually more times than I can remember over the years, but rather to look at the language that he uses. Vaccines are portrayed as “dirty” and “contaminated”, “toxic injections” so bad that they are akin to “medical rape” (unfortunately another favorite metaphor antivaxxers like to use to describe vaccination and vaccine mandates).
Again, this is all religious, not scientific, imagery, and Adams goes even beyond stoking the fear of contamination. For example:
Today, Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook demand the ritualistic sacrifice of children to the “vaccine gods” as a way to appease their globalist controllers. Just like in the era of the Maya, children are especially prized for their innocence which is violated by puncturing the skin and injecting the child with foreign DNA extracted from other children sacrificed at abortion centers.
Quite literally, the dead children are liquefied and “fed” to other children, many of whom are maimed or killed by the toxic intervention (yes, this is how vaccines are manufactured). This is all carried out in the name of “science,” just as the Maya high priests carried out their sacrifices in the name of “cosmic powers.”
Leading to:
In summary, Mark Zuckerberg is a child-sacrificing, globalist ascension seeker whose rise to power must be accompanied by prescribing the mass “medical raping,” genetic violation and ritualistic deaths of children. In order to achieve that, Facebook must block websites that openly discuss factual vaccine ingredients, their horrifying aborted human baby origins and why they are added to vaccines in the first place (especially when many ingredients have nothing whatsoever to do with viral strains).
Again, notice the language, more than the actual substance (such as it is) of Adams’ claims. “Genetic violation.” “Medical raping.” The “horrifying aborted baby origins” of vaccines. It’s all about stirring revulsion and fear of contamination. It’s easy to laugh at the sheer ridiculous hyperbole of it all, but that would be a mistake, except perhaps to laugh only briefly. We have to take this sort of imagery seriously, because it taps into deep fears in human beings and it co-opts ancient language used by religions. The reason Gen. Ripper’s rants about Communists “sapping and impurifying our precious bodily fluids” with fluoridation were funny was because they were over the top, but also because they tapped into religious and superstitious beliefs about contamination and contagion that cultures have instilled in us for millennia.
That’s why I’d suggest that, if you want to understand the power of the antivaccine trope that portrays vaccines as “disease matter” or “injecting disease” (a metaphor that Bill Maher himself once used), the “toxins gambit” that describes vaccines as riddled with scary-sounding chemicals like formaldehyde, or the “fetal parts” gambit that tries to draw a link between the fetal cell lines used to grow virus stocks to make some vaccines to the grinding up of dead babies to use to make vaccines, think of in terms of Gen. Ripper. These are tropes designed to stoke fear of “contamination” of one’s precious bodily fluids at the very minimum. Some antivaccine tropes even suggest that vaccines will change your very essence, as you will see. Holy vaccine zombie, Batman!
Quoth RFK Jr.: COVID-19 vaccines will corrupt your very DNA!
I’ve already discussed on at least two occasions here how, contrary to what antivaxxers claim, mRNA vaccines do not alter your DNA, nor are they “gene therapy“, the implication behind this antivax claim, again, being that somehow these vaccines permanently alter your DNA. Of course, mRNA vaccines (and also DNA vaccines based on adenoviral vectors, like the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine) were explicitly designed from the beginning not to integrate into host DNA or otherwise alter that DNA. The mRNA in the vaccines never makes it into the nucleus and is never converted to DNA, both of which it would have to do in order to permanently integrate into one’s DNA. There is no plausible biological mechanism how mRNA from these vaccines could do that, as anyone who’s taken basic courses in molecular biology would know, which is why those of us who’ve done molecular biology since the 1990s laugh at these claims, which proliferate across social media:
My 3rd video on the vaccination: The purpose of the covid vax is to alter dna, in turn taking many people out of the awakening, slowing down the awakening. https://t.co/QM9C1it3IE #Vaccine
— G(od) No relation Sub My Substack (@Flaganatas) April 11, 2021
Also a vaccine that doesn’t prevent anything! It’s only purpose is to alter your DNA! COVID-19 is real as a disease! How it’s being treated, tested, diagnosed, and publicized is the HOAX, not the virus! That’s real! A real MAN-MADE virus!A man-made pandemic for control!
— Netuserms (@netuserms) April 9, 2021
The system is evil. They blatantly showing the rest of the world who their god is, Satan. This vaccine will alter human DNA into something we don't know. It's so sad to see and witness depopulation. We'll tell our kids how the evil @BillGates thought he was god, pathetic human
— #Dokotela out now #MbokodoDroppingSoon (@howardgomba) April 11, 2021
The Covid Vaccine Will Alter Our DNA with Nano-Technology pic.twitter.com/yi5MEIIQg9
— apj_jks_asiaprince (@cool_jks) April 10, 2021
Of course, Bill Gates has to figure in there somewhere.
Antivaxxers, though, are nothing if not inventive. Clearly the more “biologically savvy” among them understood that it was a pretty damning observation that there is no biological mechanism by which mRNA could possibly “permanently alter” your DNA, much less do so in a manner that would affect more than a very small number of cells. So a mechanism had to be invented. Unfortunately, as I briefly alluded to last week, there is a recent (and awful) study that was posted to a preprint server that antivaxxers have latched onto in order to say, “See! I told you! It is possible for mRNA vaccines to alter your DNA permanently!” It doesn’t, but explaining why takes some effort. I briefly did so last week. I will elaborate a bit more this week.
Let’s first look at how antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. describes the study in an article entitled “Could mRNA Vaccines Permanently Alter DNA? Recent Science Suggests They Might“. It’s subtitled “Research on SARS-CoV-2 RNA by scientists at Harvard and MIT has implications for how mRNA vaccines could permanently alter genomic DNA, according to Doug Corrigan, Ph.D., a biochemist-molecular biologist who says more research is needed.” Actually, no, they can’t, and, no, there isn’t, at least not this specific line of research. Let’s see what RFK Jr. says, first, and I’ll quote liberally:
Under ordinary circumstances, the body makes (“transcribes”) mRNA from the DNA in a cell’s nucleus. The mRNA then travels out of the nucleus into the cytoplasm, where it provides instructions about which proteins to make.
By comparison, mRNA vaccines send their chemically synthesized mRNA payload (bundled with spike protein-manufacturing instructions) directly into the cytoplasm.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and most mRNA vaccine scientists, the buck then stops there — mRNA vaccines “do not affect or interact with our DNA in any way,” the CDC says. The CDC asserts first, that the mRNA cannot enter the cell’s nucleus (where DNA resides), and second, that the cell — Mission-Impossible-style — “gets rid of the mRNA soon after it is finished using the instructions.”
A December preprint about SARS-CoV-2, by scientists at Harvard and Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), produced findings about wild coronavirus that raise questions about how viral RNA operates.
The scientists conducted the analysis because they were “puzzled by the fact that there is a respectable number of people who are testing positive for COVID-19 by PCR long after the infection was gone.”
Their key findings were as follows: SARS-CoV-2 RNAs “can be reverse transcribed in human cells,” “these DNA sequences can be integrated into the cell genome and subsequently be transcribed” (a phenomenon called “retro-integration”) — and there are viable cellular pathways to explain how this happens.
Again, no. The study did not show this. Notice the language, though. Notice how this finding is portrayed as “shattering” dogma. Doug Corrigan (who featured in last week’s discussion) even explicitly says:
According to Ph.D. biochemist and molecular biologist Dr. Doug Corrigan, these important findings (which run contrary to “current biological dogma”) belong to the category of “Things We Were Absolutely and Unequivocally Certain Couldn’t Happen Which Actually Happened.”
See! See! You conventional molecular biologists mocked us! But I’ll show you! (This is what I like to refer to as the fallacy of future vindication.) Basically, this “thing” that “actually happened” is that the RNA from SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, can be reverse transcribed into DNA, which then somehow integrate into the genome of human cells. What does this mean? Normally, DNA is “transcribed” into RNA by special enzymes that “read” the DNA sequence and create what’s called its reverse complement. You don’t need to understand exactly what that means, other than that it means that the information in the DNA has been transcribed into RNA, where it can then be translated in a protein complex called a ribosome into protein. Under normal circumstances, the reverse does not happen in mammalian cells. However, certain RNA viruses called retroviruses (like HIV) can “reverse transcribe” RNA into DNA. The enzyme necessary to do this, reverse transcriptase, is normally not found in mammalian cells; so the virus has to provide it. And, yes, as RFK Jr. and Corrigan note, retroviruses are common, with many sequences in the genome having derived from retroviruses that reverse transcribed part of their sequence into DNA, which then integrated into the genome. These sequences are called endogenous retroviruses (ERVs), which are inherited genetic elements closely resembling the DNA sequences formed following exogenous retrovirus infection. Sequences derived from ERVs make up at 8% to 10% of the human and mouse genomes and range from ancient sequences that predate mammalian divergence to elements that are currently still active.
Knowing this, of course, I can’t help but retort that, if something truly belongs to the category of “Things We Were Absolutely and Unequivocally Certain Couldn’t Happen Which Actually Happened,” then to prove the latter part you’d better have some seriously bulletproof evidence that this thing actually did happen. Basically, this is the Carl Sagan standard: Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence to back them up. He might have used it in the context of the paranormal, but it just as well applies to claims that go against everything we know about molecular biology. Make no mistake, the central claim of this preprint, namely that the RNA from SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, is somehow reverse transcribed into DNA and then finds its way into the nucleus to integrate with genomic DNA, is a truly extraordinary claim given that coronaviruses are not retroviruses like HIV and that endogenous human reverse transcription is very rare and limited, as described in depth here. Basically, only certain genetic elements in the genome can use reverse transcription to copy themselves elsewhere. It’s not as though a random coronavirus can hijack this mechanism for itself and plop its sequences somewhere in the human genome. To demonstrate that would require extraordinary evidence, particularly given that coronaviruses kill the cells they infect as they replicate.
Let’s just say that this preprint (still a preprint four months after having been published) doesn’t even come close to extraordinary evidence. Heck, it’s not even good ordinary evidence. Again, if you want the details, I refer you to this fine explanation by Ed Nirenberg. For one thing, the assumption that “persistently positive PCR” for COVID-19 must mean reverse transcription of the virus and integration is a leap. There are other mechanisms, such as the maintenance of a viral reservoir within an immunologically privileged site or immunological suppression. These are all mechanisms that have been observed in other viruses. As for the results themselves, Nirenberg makes a compelling case that the findings could well be due to an artifact of the methods used to look for viral sequences. I’ll also point out again now Nirenberg’s correct observations, as I did then, that, even if the authors had observed actual reverse transcription and integration into the genome, it would mean exactly nothing for RNA vaccines because:
    • The sequence would behave like a processed pseudogene, lacking any ability to recruit host transcription machinery and would sit in the genome, quiescent.
    • If the sequence somehow inserted downstream of a promoter sequence that could recruit transcription machinery, the cell would express spike protein, be recognized by the immune system, and then be killed.
    • If the sequence inserted itself into the middle of gene (specifically in the middle of an exon), you would get a mutant protein that had sequences from SARS-CoV-2 that would be processed by antigen-presenting machinery and trigger a T cell response that killed the cell.
None of this stops antivaxxers from latching onto this study as “proof” that mRNA vaccines really can “permanently alter” your DNA and then to go on to engage in all sorts of predictions based on speculation:
More thoughtful readers agreed with Corrigan that the paper raises important questions. For example, one reader stated that confirmatory evidence is lacking “to show that the spike protein only is expressed for a short amount of time (say 1-3 days) after vaccination,” adding, “We think that this is the case, but there is no evidence for that.”
In fact, just how long the vaccines’ synthetic mRNA — and thus the instructions for cells to keep manufacturing spike protein — persist inside the cells is an open question.
Ordinarily, RNA is a “notoriously fragile” and unstable molecule. According to scientists, “this fragility is true of the mRNA of any living thing, whether it belongs to a plant, bacteria, virus or human.”
But the synthetic mRNA in the COVID vaccines is a different story. In fact, the step that ultimately allowed scientists and vaccine manufacturers to resolve their decades-long mRNA vaccine impasse was when they figured out how to chemically modify mRNA to increase its stability and longevity — in other words, produce RNA “that hangs around in the cell much longer than viral RNA, or even RNA that our cell normally produces for normal protein production.”
This is a major exaggeration. While it is true that the mRNA used in the COVID-19 vaccines has been modified to have a longer half-life in the cells, it’s not as though it’s been made indestructible, as RFK Jr. and Corrigan seem to be implying. At best, the mRNA from these vaccines will not result in production of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein by the cells containing the vaccine RNA for more than 10-14 days. That’s longer than unmodified RNA, but not so long as to result in all the dire consequences speculated by antivaxxers. Again, it’s as though antivaxxers think that there aren’t extensive cell culture studies to estimate the half-life of the mRNAs made by these vaccines and correlative studies during the early stage clinical trials or that we don’t have years of data on how long modified RNAs hang around the cell.
Why, though? Why would scientists “ignore” this study and the warnings of antivaxxers? According to RFK Jr., it’s the money, of course, as he accuses scientists of the ‘the prospect of retro-integration of foreign DNA as a “conspiracy theory,'” No, scientists aren’t dismissing it as a conspiracy theory. They’re dismissing it as an incredibly unlikely phenomenon based on the totality of our knowledge of molecular biology, and this study is not the “extraordinary evidence” that would be required to make a convincing case for the extraordinary claim that our knowledge of molecular biology is so incorrect.
However, it’s needed to feed the contamination narrative. In fact, you’ll notice that RFK Jr. goes beyond just contamination, as RFK Jr. refers to “possibly multigenerational” risks. Yes, the genetic alteration claimed by antivaxxers is such that they further claim that they could be passed on to children, a claim that I’ve been seeing popping up more and more, even though the mRNA from COVID-19 vaccines does not enter germline cells that produce sperm in men and eggs in women, thus making it impossible for mRNA vaccines to be able to produce genetic alterations that are passed down to children even if they did produce genetic alterations in the first place.
Vaccines and “purity of essence”
Now you can see why I started by extolling the virtues of Dr. Strangelove as a movie. The character of Gen. Ripper, as ridiculous and frightening as he is, represents a very strong belief system among human beings, namely a belief in “purity of essence” and a fear, mostly inspired by longstanding religious or mystical views, that we must keep ourselves “pure”. Normally, that purity is spiritual, but that spiritual belief underlies a lot of the belief system underlying alternative medicine, which is why there is such an emphasis on “detoxification” and fear of “toxins” in the alternative treatments advocated. Indeed, I’ve likened “detoxification” to ritual purification on a number of occasions, because that’s what it is, at its core, and antivaccine beliefs often derive from or overlap with alternative medicine beliefs.
Indeed, such is the fear of “contamination” or “corruption” among antivaxxers that mRNA vaccines have been described as “transhumanism.” Transhumanism is a social, scientific, and philosophical movement devoted to the idea that humans can be enhanced by technology, be it biological, computer-based, or physical. The idea is that such technologies would augment or increase human perception, physical abilities, intelligence, and cognition, and also radically improve human health and extend human life spans. The ultimate outcome is thought to be the “singularity”, a time when computers become so advanced that artificial intelligence transcends human intelligence, potentially erasing the boundary between humanity and computers, even leading to the merging of humans and computers. For purposes of these vaccines, the “permanent alteration” of human DNA falsely ascribed to COVID-19 vaccines by antivaxxers is often portrayed as a form of transhumanism. However, the claim that vaccines are transhumanism predates mRNA vaccines. Indeed, the first time I encountered this claim was nine years ago, when I encountered Sayer Ji claiming that vaccines were transhumanism designed to subvert evolution. The basic idea is that vaccines make you no longer entirely human.
This fear of “contamination” due to DNA or RNA in vaccines is not new either. Does anyone remember “homologous recombinaltion tiniker“? That’s a mispelling of “homologous recombination” that became a longstanding joke among science advocates about an old antivaccine claim in which it was argued that DNA from the “fetal cells” used to manufacture some vaccines would get into the brain, undergo homologous recombination with our DNA, and produce “foreign” proteins that would result in autoimmunity and cause autism? (Apparently incredibly minute amounts of fetal DNA were so powerful that they can contaminate the entire nervous system.) Remember all the fear mongering about “DNA contamination” of the HPV vaccine detected by incredibly sensitive (and possibly false positive) PCR assays that caused “microcompetition” with endogenous DNA, leading to disease? All of these are variants of the fear of “contamination” by vaccines. It even goes so far that one antivaxxer claimed that there is a “genetic memory” of foreign substances the body encounters and that there is a limit to how much such material our body can handle before genetic alteration occurs! Yes, it sounds a bit like homeopathy.
Sometimes, antivaxxers even try to flip the script and project their views onto science advocates, as this antivaxxer did:
I’ve been chatting with an LQ commenter who messaged me the other day to say that vaccination is a ritual of cleansing. Those who partake are clean, and those who do not are unclean. Heck, you’re unclean for even questioning it, even if you did partake.
They see themselves as clean and pure and see us as vile and germ ridden.
Invoking “terrain theory,” the idea that once competed with germ theory but was supplanted by it and stated that germs didn’t cause disease but were rather a manifestation of a diseased “terrain”, another antivaxxer said:
As an analogy, flies don`t create garbage. But garbage attracts flies that breed maggots to create even more flies. Removing garbage is more effective than spraying toxic chemicals, which endanger human and animal life, around the house. Similarly, adding toxins to humans is not as effective as cleaning out the inner terrain.
“Purity of essence”, indeed.
Unfortunately, this emphasis on “purity” vs. “contamination” or “impurification” is strong in many cultures and religions. It is even stronger in alternative medicine, with treatments based on “detoxification” and preventatives based on avoiding unnamed “toxins” being such a huge component of such quackery. It’s no wonder it is also a strong strand in antivaccine beliefs and has been for a long time.
There is nothing new under the sun in antivaccine beliefs, as much as it might seem that way in the age of COVID-19.

COVID-19 vaccines versus “purity of essence,” revisited
Antivaxxers frequently make the false claim that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter your DNA”. These claims are really a concern about “impurifying” their “purity of essence” and have now gone into some truly disturbing territory, such as antivaxxers calling themselves “purebloods”.
David Gorski on November 22, 2021
Link

One point I’ve long made about so-called “alternative” medicine is how many of its precepts are more religious than rational or scientific in nature. In particular, a huge part of alternative medicine relies on the concept that “contamination” (these days more frequently referred to as “toxins”) cause most, if not all, disease. Indeed, nearly five years ago, I was discussing how the various “detoxification” regimens that make up so much of alternative medicine (and, not coincidentally, the basis of many treatments for many conditions—like autism—that antivaxxers used to attribute to vaccines) have more in common with religious ritual purification rituals than they do with science or medicine. This concept of “purity” versus “contamination” (implied to be with evil) also has a lot to do with the idea that “natural immunity” to a disease (which in reality should be called post-infection immunity given that vaccine-induced immunity is natural) and has infected the discourse over COVID-19 vaccines, so much so that one of my go-to video clips when discussing this topic is of Brigadier General Jack D. Ripper from one of my favorite movies of all time, Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb explaining how fluoridation is a Communist plot to “sap and impurify” the “precious bodily fluids” of real Americans, mainly because anti-fluoridation, antivaccine, and anti-GMO pseudoscience all tap into the alternative medicine fear of “contamination” as a cause of ill health and “purity of essence” (again, from Dr. Strangelove) as key to good health. Not coincidentally, concepts of “contamination” versus “purity” are also behind the fear stoked by antivaxxers that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter” your DNA, thus contaminating and corrupting it with evil (the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein).
There is, however, another, darker, side to this concept of “contamination” or “corruption” as a cause of illness and “purity” as an indication of health, and it’s a concept that’s been supercharged since the COVID-19 pandemic began. I realize that Mike Adams is always an easy target—some might argue that he’s too easy a target—but I often cite his website, Natural News, because it doesn’t say anything that other antivaxxers and quacks aren’t saying. Rather, it just takes what other antivaxxers are saying and cranks it up to 11.

The example comes from this article, Only PUREBLOODS will survive the vaccine / radiation holocaust being unleashed against humanity… the spike protein in vaccines causes genetic DISINTEGRATION:
Today’s podcast is a bombshell that needs to be understood by anyone hoping to survive the vaccine holocaust, because it’s really a “genetic bomb” against humanity.
The vaccine, by suppressing the natural DNA repair mechanism in the body — known as NHEJ, or Non-Homologous End Joining—makes people highly susceptible to devastating, cancerous mutations—even when exposed to very low levels of ionizing radiation such as sunlight exposure or mammography. With NHEJ suppressed by the spike protein, the body can no longer repair its damaged DNA, and cells mutate out of control, devastating the entire body and bringing about genetic disintegration of the organism.
The study documenting all this was published in the MDPI journal “Viruses” and was carried out by scientists at Stockholm University, Sweden:
I’ll discuss the cited study briefly in a moment. Suffice to say that, even if its in vitro cell culture findings were to pan out more generally, this study does not show anything of the sort and, in fact, is a rather crappy crappy study. I won’t explain why details here, but if you really want to know the gory details, you can read this deconstruction. (Since then, I’ve also realized that the authors of this study have no clue about how the immune system works.) It has, however, been embraced by antivaxxers to claim that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer.
As I said, though, Adams is just turning up to 11 the conspiracy noise of antivaxxers dating back months during the COVID-19 pandemic, which is just an echo of longstanding concepts in the natural health and antivaccine movement of “purity” versus “corruption” and “contamination”. (Indeed, it’s a very ancient concept that’s long been used to trace royal lineages and “pure” bloodlines.) When I first saw this concept being applied to COVID-19 vaccination, it quite quickly reminded me of all manner of fascist ideas about “purebloods” and “racial purity”. Indeed, a few months ago, when mainstream media first took note, the concept of unvaccinated “purebloods” was appearing on social media, in particular on Tik Tok, invoking concepts from the Harry Potter novels and movies:
The term “pureblood” doesn’t exactly have the best connotations. But now unvaccinated people on TikTok are, er, trying to reclaim the term as a way to tout their “superiority” over their jabbed fellow citizens.
The phrase was popularized by J.K. Rowling’s villain Lord Voldemort in the Harry Potter series as a way to distinguish between those with “pure” wizard ancestry and everyone else, drawing parallels with the Nazi doctrine of the “master race.” As a concept, basically, it’s been used to justify some of the worst crimes against humanity in history.
The new “pureblood” trend seems to have gotten a big boost from conservative TikToker influencer Lyndsey Marie in a post shared last week replete with hashtags like #harrypotter, #pureblood, and #unvaccinated.
“From now on, I refuse to be referred to as ‘unvaccinated,'” she declared. “I want everyone to now call me Pureblood.”
Here’s an example:
When I first encountered antivaxxers using this term from the fictional universe of Harry Potter, I was somewhat amused—while still being simultaneously appalled—at how utterly unconcerned they seemed (and continue to seem) how by embracing the whole concept of “purebloods” versus “mudbloods“, a highly derogatory term in the Harry Potter universe for a Muggle-born wizard or witch (Muggle meaning a person born to nonmagical parents and possessing no magical abilities) or “half-bloods“, a term denoting wizards or witches with Muggle parents or relatives in their recent lineage (e.g., grandparents, etc.) was not-so-subtly echoing Nazi ideology. After all, it’s not as though it wasn’t incredibly clear in the Harry Potter novels and movies that the magical “pureblood”/”mudblood” dichotomy was a very obvious metaphor for Nazi ideas about racial “purity” and superiority, with the Muggles being viewed by Voldemort and his followers as inferiors who were “contaminating” the pure wizard race, complete with a horror on the part of Voldemort at the thought of magical people mating with Muggles and having children that was every bit as strong as the disgust that Nazis expressed at Jews mixing with “pure Aryans”. In brief, there’s a reason why it was the villains, not the heroes, in the Harry Potter universe who so proudly used the term “pureblood” versus the disdainful term “mudblood”.
I’ve alluded to antivaxxers proudly co-opting the term “pureblood” before, but I want to explore in a bit more detail how “natural health” and antivaccine ideology naturally lead to such a term. In this, I have to disagree with Alan Levinovitz, associate professor of religious studies at James Madison University and author of Natural: How Faith in Nature’s Goodness Leads to Harmful Fads, Unjust Laws, and Flawed Science, when he argued:
Troubled observers have variously tied this term to the Harry Potter franchise (in which purebloods are Wizards untainted by muggle ancestry) and the eugenic Nazi fantasies of pure Aryan blood. But both comparisons miss the mark. The meaning of the hashtag is inseparable from vaccine refusers’ strong preference for “natural immunity,” a seemingly innocuous term that is actually a centerpiece of anti-vaccination ideology and ought to be abandoned immediately.
While Levinovitz is correct that the use of the term “pureblood” by antivaxxers does reflect a strong preference in antivax ideology for “natural immunity” (as I agreed when I quoted him), it also reflects an inherent acceptance of the concept (that predates Nazi-ism) of “purity of essence” and “pure blood” that to antivaxxers indicate health (and superiority) that must not be “contaminated” with anything as awful (to antivaxxers) as a vaccine. Similarly, if that “pure blood” is somehow contaminated, then it must somehow be “purified” (i.e., “decontaminated” or “detoxified”—or ritually purified) in order for one to reclaim a “natural” state of health and superiority, just as those who have sinned must, in some religions, atone through rituals designed to “purify” them.
I’ll discuss a couple of examples.
“Detoxification” of vaccines
A couple of weeks ago, I saw a story making the rounds about how, with COVID-19 vaccine mandates spreading, leading some antivaxxers to make the choice to be vaccinated or lose their jobs, some are scrambling to “undo” their vaccinations through “detoxification” treatments:
In a TikTok video that has garnered hundreds of thousands of views, Dr. Carrie Madej outlined the ingredients for a bath she said will “detox the vaxx” for people who have given into Covid-19 vaccine mandates.
The ingredients in the bath are mostly not harmful, although the supposed benefits attached to them are entirely fictional. Baking soda and epsom salts, she falsely claims, will provide a “radiation detox” to remove radiation Madej falsely believes is activated by the vaccine. Bentonite clay will add a “major pull of poison,” she says, based on a mistaken idea in anti-vaccine communities that toxins can be removed from the body with certain therapies.
Then, she recommends adding in one cup of borax, a cleaning agent that’s been banned as a food additive by the Food and Drug Administration, to “take nanotechnologies out of you.”
In reality, in addition to being potentially harmful as a skin and eye irritant, a borax “detox bath” will not remove the effects of the Covid vaccine from your body.
I first discussed Dr. Carrie Madej before (almost a year ago, believe it or not). Even among COVID-19 contrarians, deniers, cranks, and antivaxxers, she stands out. She’s on record as not just saying that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines will “permanently alter your DNA” but that they are, in fact transhumanism. You might recall that I also briefly discussed how transhumanism is social, scientific, and philosophical movement devoted to the idea that humans can be enhanced by technology, be it biological, computer-based, or physical. The idea is that such technologies would augment or increase human perception, physical abilities, intelligence, and cognition, and also radically improve human health and extend human life spans. Unsurprisingly, the movement’s adherents tend to be employed in technology, biotech, and academia, and there is a strong link between libertarianism and transhumanism. The ultimate outcome is thought to be the “singularity”, a time when computers become so advanced that artificial intelligence transcends human intelligence, potentially erasing the boundary between humanity and computers, even leading to the merging of humans and computers. I also pointed out how I’ve always looked a bit askance at transhumanism, because I have without a doubt encountered a lot of woo in the movement over the years.
Still, one can’t help but note a bit of disconnect here. If, as Madej claims, mRNA vaccines “alter your DNA” so much that they are “transhumanism” and can make you somehow different than human (to the point where she claimed that these vaccines could make one into a “genetically modified human”), then how on earth are a pleasant salt bath with Borax and consuming a bit of bentonite clay going to reverse that? If, as Madej was also claiming a year ago, mRNA vaccines actually insert tracking nanotechnology—which Madej has referred to as “branding”, as in “we’re all going to be branded” with this tech—into your bloodstream, a nice salt bath and consuming some clay are not going to get those pesky nanobots out of your bloodstream; that is, unless they can somehow leach them through the skin and lining of the gastrointestinal tract.
Of course, Borax baths and clay consumption are generally not likely to cause significant harm. The bath might be relaxing, and you’ll be clean afterwards, while the clay will just pass through your GI tract. Elsewhere, there are more potentially harmful suggestions, for instance at the website of an MD who also has an ND (and is therefore a naturopath), Valerie (Richey) Bazylewicz MD, ND of The Healthy Path clinic near Cincinnati. She has a post about “vaccine detoxification” that includes all the antivax tropes about vaccines containing “toxins” such as mercury (not in childhood vaccines for nearly 20 years), “aborted baby cells”, formaldehyde, antifreeze, alcohol (wait, you don’t drink wine or beer?), and more, warning, ominously:
All vaccines and covid shots contain many harmful substances such as mercury, thimerosal, aluminum, dangerous chemicals, polyethylene glycol and lipids (to help transport toxins into brain), etc. They are usually grown on cell lines from aborted fetal tissue. Also, animal cells contain species-specific virusesthat cause diseases in humans. The covid shots contain either manufactured mRNA (Pfizer and Moderna) or manufactured DNA with adenovirus (Johnson & Johnson, Astrazenica [sic]) that have never been studied in humans until now. Keep in mind that harmful components of vaccines can be removed with vaccination detoxification, but any changes to your DNA that may have occurred from the covid shot appear to be irreversible. 
She also repeats the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines are not, in fact, “real” vaccines but gene therapy:
Please note that the covid shots are not actually vaccines because they do not contain any covid virus as per the legal definition of vaccines. At this time, these shots are experimental for emergency use only; they are not FDA approved. Comirnaty was FDA approved, but it is not available anywhere. Thus, all covid shots available on the market now are not FDA approved; they are experimental and authorized for emergency use only.
All of the covid shots are designed to hijack your genetic machinery and even possibly change your DNA in order to produce spike proteins that cause the covid disease. In other words, they are turning you into a genetically modified organismor transhuman which produces the spike protein that actually gives you the disease that you think that you are preventing. And there is no shut off mechanism included in the shot.
I’ve discussed the false claim that mRNA- and adenovirus-based vaccines are not vaccines but “gene therapy” before, as well as the false claims that the available Pfizer vaccine is not the FDA-approved vaccine; that the vaccine gives you COVID; that tens of thousands have been killed by the vaccines; etc. It’s all nonsense, basically standard antivax talking points. But what is this “detox”?
So what is the “vaccine detox,” though? It’s really not very impressive and includes:
     1.  Eat a “healthy organic diet”.
     2.  Avoid “toxins”, which apparently include “fragrances (perfumes, beauty products, fabric softeners, cleaning products, room/car fresheners, etc), candles (beeswax candles are OK), automobile exhaust, unnecessary medications, and so much more”.
     3.  Use supplements from a company called Research Nutritionals, including Cytoquel, TriFortify Glutathione, C-RLA (Liposomal C & R-Lipoic Acid) Vanilla Caramel, ToxinPul, and MycoPul.
Particularly odd:
Make a paste with one or two opened capsule(s) of MycoPul (see above) and oil (such as coconut oil or olive oil) and then generously apply to the injection site immediately after the injection and cover with a large bandage. Reapply about every 6-8 hours for the next 3 days.
MycoPul includes:
    • Humic and Fulvic powder blend with trace minerals
    • Activated Charcoal
    • G-PUR® purified Zeolite (Clinoptilolite)
    • Microchitosan
    • Silica
Nope, there’s no evidence that any of this will work. As they say, once you’re vaccinated, you can’t “unring the bell,” so to speak. You’re vaccinated.
Unfortunately, again, none of this is new. It’s also not a coincidence that many of the treatments for “vaccine-induced autism” or any other condition falsely attributed to vaccines are represented as “detoxification”. They are basically purges, to purge the “evil humors” that antivaxers believe vaccines to be packed full of. It’s not for nothing that I’ve frequently described alternative medicine “detoxification” as being akin to ritual purification of the sort found in many different religions. Think of chelation therapy and all the “detoxification” treatments used by autism quacks as basically an effort to restore the purity of the child’s precious bodily fluids. It should thus not be surprising that COVID-19 treatments are no different.
Back in the day, I used to blog about quack treatments that fell under the rubric of what antivaxxers like to call “autism biomed”. Going back to the days before the pandemic when the main pseudoscientific unsupported claim made by antivaxxers was that childhood vaccines cause autism, there was a whole subset of quackery known as “autism biomed” that was based on “reversing” the effects of vaccines, specifically “vaccine-induced autism”. I’m not going to recount the abundant evidence that there is no detectable increase in autism risk associated with vaccines, such as the MMR vaccine, or with vaccine ingredients, such as the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in some childhood vaccines up until 20 years ago.
A major component of “autism biomed” involved “detoxification” of the “toxins”, be they mercury, formaldehyde (in some vaccines in tiny amounts), or whatever. For mercury, it involved chelation therapy, which was supposed to remove the mercury from vaccines and thereby reverse autism. For other “toxins”, there were all manner of “detoxification” protocols coupled with hormonal manipulations like the use of secretin. The results of “autism biomed” could at times be truly horrific, as exemplified by, for example, the case of Alex Spourdalakis. In reality, as I wrote 12 years ago, “autism biomed”, when you boil it all down, is uncontrolled and unethical experimentation on autistic children, complete with bogus medical tests practically guaranteed to demonstrate various forms of “toxicity” that are supposedly the “root cause” of autism.
Of course, these concepts are very much at the root of many varieties of alternative medicine as well.
Even more dangerous consequences
Part and parcel of the concept of “toxins” or “contamination” associated with COVID-19 vaccination is an antivaccine lie that I’ve been discussing for a long time, namely the idea that the “vaccinated” are so contaminated that they are a danger to others. In the past, it was the idea that those who had received attenuated live virus vaccines (like MMR) were shedding virus and giving measles to others. (The measles strain used in the MMR is much less dangerous than actual measles.) In the age of COVID-19, it’s the idea that, as Adams put it above, those who have received mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are “spike protein factories” for whom the spike protein is a deadly toxin and is also shed from the vaccinated in an almost magical miasma-like manner to make others around them sick. Never mind that the amount of spike protein made due to these vaccines is tiny and mostly localized to the injection site, and the amount of spike protein getting into the bloodstream is so tiny that a new assay had to be developed to detect it.
This has led to a number of absurd beliefs about the “contamination” of the vaccinated among antivaxxers. One is kind of funny, namely the meme that went around that “unvaccinated” sperm is superior to the sperm of the vaccinated, to the point where antivaxxers think that their sperm will skyrocket in value after the pandemic.
It’s easy to laugh at that idea, but less funny is the claim that vaccines will so contaminate our DNA that they will lead to mass death from cancer in the next few years. (Never mind that carcinogens, even potent ones, generally don’t result in cancer anywhere near that fast.) Even less funny is what happened to a rather famous antivaxxer in June, who basically could have died because he refused a transfusion with “vaccinated blood”. I’m referring to Del Bigtree, who in May was diagnosed with so much chronic blood loss from hemorrhoids that his hemoglobin (Hgb) level had fallen to 4.8 g/dL, a level that’s not life-threatening in and of itself if the blood loss was slow, but could easily become so with further blood loss. (In a male, normal is around 13-17 g/dL, depending on the lab, and a level of 4.8 g/dL leaves no room for error, so to speak, when it comes to further blood loss, even if subsequent blood loss is slow.) Bigtree was symptomatic, with lightheadedness and dizziness. Still, he refused a transfusion at first because he didn’t want any “vaccinated blood” (although he didn’t refuse a procedure to stop the bleeding). According to his story, he managed to get a sympathetic ER doctor to find a unit of “unvaccinated” blood, which he did accept, and then he flew to Mexico on a private jet paid for by his fans to get a transfusion at a quack cancer clinic in Mexico.
This concept has led to social media posts like this:
That's a good question. Due to producing too many red blood cells, I'm a literal blood factory and donate often. So if anyone needs unvaccinated B+ I'm here for em.
— Name Matters Not (@Impurebred1) June 4, 2021
“Unvaccinated blood will be the next bitcoin.”
— Jefe🇺🇸 (@JefeoftheHill) November 18, 2021
Regarding that last one, he might be right, but not in the way he thinks.
Even so, let’s circle back:
        ◦ Again, it really is all about the “purity.” That concept is at the root of a lot of alternative medicine, became a major thread in antivaccine pseudoscience. You can see how it so easily meshes with concepts of racial and genetic purity as well. Unfortunately, those very concepts are far more religious and ideological than scientific, and they have real world consequences. We just didn’t notice them so much before when “toxins”, “detoxification”, and “purity” were seemingly just the province of New Age gurus and alternative medicine. Now that it’s contributing to the claim that “natural immunity” is the only worthwhile immunity, that vaccines are hopelessly full of toxins (including genetic toxins), and fear of vaccines in the middle of a pandemic, we can’t ignore it any more.

The COVID-19 “Vaccine Holocaust”: The latest antivaccine messaging
The latest antivaccine disinformation consists of pointing to the large numbers of reports of death (and other adverse events) to the VAERS database. It’s nonsense.
David Gorski on May 10, 2021
Link

Months before emergency use authorizations (EUAs) were granted by the FDA for vaccines against COVID-19, starting with the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine and then continuing with the Moderna and Johnson & Johnson (J&J) vaccines, those of us who’ve been following and trying to counter the antivaccine movement predicted that antivaxxers would publicize and weaponize reports of death and adverse events after COVID-19 vaccines to give the impression that the vaccines are dangerous. By the end of January, our predictions had come true even more blatantly than I had expected, as I discussed this technique three months ago and why it is deceptive. The first time I had noted this technique of antivaccine messaging was actually as far back as December, when antivaxxers were publicizing reports of Bell’s palsy and syncope within days after the Pfizer vaccine had been released under an EUA. It’s a technique that continued with claims based on VAERS that COVID-19 vaccines cause heart attacks and sudden cardiac deaths, with these sorts of claims being central to messaging by antivaccine activist Del Bigtree. None of these reports demonstrated causation, but that didn’t stop antivaxxers from publicizing them. Then, when the FDA issued a pause for the J&J vaccine based on (at the time) one-in-a-million reports to VAERS of a rare type of blood clot, reports that the FDA and CDC took very seriously, antivaxxers predictably went wild over it, even though the risk-benefit ratio of the vaccine was still deemed to be favorable.
So why am I addressing this topic again? Simple. It’s a narrative that hasn’t gone away. Worse, it’s grown in the three months since I last wrote about it. At the extreme end of the antivax hysteria is, as one might expect, Mike Adams at NaturalNews.com proclaiming, “VACCINE HOLOCAUST now accelerating: VAERS data show nearly 4,000% increase in vaccine deaths in 2021 (so far) vs. the entire year of 2020“. (I’ll give Adams credit for understanding that the word “data” is plural.) Another example of this particular antivaccine messaging comes from a recent article in The Liberty Sentinel, “COVID vaccines killing huge numbers, warns leading doctor“. The doctor is someone I hadn’t actually heard of before, Dr. Peter McCullough. On the more “reasonable” end of this narrative (in actuality, “reasonable”-seeming from an antivaccine activist who tries his best to deny that he’s antivaccine and portray himself ), there’s Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s “freelance reporter” Megan Redshaw proclaiming on his antivaccine “news” site The Defender, “Reported Vaccine Injuries Continue to Climb, Pfizer Seeks Full Approval for COVID Vaccine“.
Vaccine deaths are up nearly 4,000% over the year before!
Before I discuss why this narrative is deceptive, it helps to give you a taste of it, first from Dr. McCullough:
Under normal circumstances, 50 deaths reported to the CDC’s VAERS surveillance system would result in a drug being taken off market immediately.
In the case of the COVID shots, however, thousands of deaths have already been reported, and yet the mass vaccination programs continue to be pushed.
Dr. McCullough, a professor of medicine who developed a globally acclaimed and highly successful COVID treatment protocol, also emphasized that there have been many unnecessary deaths as a result of policy decisions made at various levels of government.
Naturally, there’s a video, and naturally it’s on Rumble:
I was curious about the claim in the article that Dr. McCullough is the “doctor with the most citations in the National Library of Medicine on these topics”. Which topics, I wondered upon first reading that, a question that was answered by the last paragraph regarding his allegedly having developed a “globally acclaimed and highly successful COVID treatment protocol”. A quick PubMed search revealed that he does indeed have 38 publications related to COVID-19 in the peer-reviewed literature. That jogged my memory a bit. It turns out that Dr. McCullough is a consultant cardiologist and Vice Chief of Medicine at Baylor University Medical Center and Principal Faculty in internal medicine for the Texas A & M University Health Sciences Center. (More on him in a moment.)
Now let’s hear Mike Adams’ version of it. He starts out, as he often does, trying to seem reasonable:
According to government data published at VAERS.hhs.gov, just 82 people died in 2020 after being vaccinated. But so far in 2021, there are 3,317 deaths that have been reported following covid-19 vaccinations.
That’s an increase of nearly 4000%, and we’re barely into the second quarter of 2021 (versus the entire year of 2020).
Less than half of the US population has been vaccinated so far, which means as that number increases, the deaths will increase, too. If this trend continues, we are likely to see somewhere between 12,000, – 15,000 post-vaccine deaths reported to the VAERS system by the end of calendar 2021.
Then, as Adams nearly always does, he goes right off the deep end:
My well-educated guess is that right now, covid-19 vaccines have likely killed around 50,000 Americans. This puts the covid vaccine on par with the number of Americans killed in the entire Vietnam War. That makes sense because the vaccine industry is waging war on humanity, and by the time they’re done, they hope to exterminate billions.
This number is likely to exceed 250,000 by the end of this year, putting vaccine atrocities in the category of being, as Tucker Carlson said last night, “The single deadliest mass vaccination event in modern history.”
We are witnessing a vaccine holocaust being inflicted upon humanity, and no one is allowed to say that anyone has suffered any harm whatsoever from the vaccine. To do so gets you banned, blacklisted and smeared. If you happen to be particularly effective at telling the truth about this vaccine holocaust, you will be named, doxxed and targeted by a complicit media that now works as the propaganda enforcement arm of the medical mafia.
He also mischaracterizes an article by vaccine researcher and advocate Peter Hotez:
As I just wrote about yesterday, NATURE has published an article by a deranged pediatrician in Texas who is essentially demanding United Nations shock troops hunt down and silence all “anti-vaxxers” around the world, using “counteroffensive” measures and anti-terrorism enforcement squads armed with weapons.
Unsurprisingly, Dr. Hotez wrote nothing of the sort, as his article, “COVID vaccines: time to confront anti-vax aggression” clearly shows. Basically, Dr. Hotez advocated countering online antivaccine disinformation with a combination of cyber security, law enforcement, public education, and international relations. In response, Mike Adams launched a campaign of harassment against him, including publishing his work email address and phone numbers:
Online trolls take anti-vaxx hate speech to a new level, attacking Houston's Dr. Peter Hotez https://t.co/Tyr2dsvmbg
— Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD (@PeterHotez) May 8, 2021
Meanwhile, over at RFK Jr.’s antivaccine propaganda website:
The number of reports of injuries and deaths following COVID vaccines continues to rise, according to data released today by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The data comes directly from reports submitted to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS).
VAERS is the primary government-funded system for reporting adverse vaccine reactions in the U.S. Reports submitted to VAERS require further investigation before a causal relationship can be confirmed.
Every Friday, VAERS makes public all vaccine injury reports received as of a specified date, usually about a week prior to the release date. Today’s data show that between Dec. 14, 2020 and April 30, a total of 157,277 total adverse events were reported to VAERS, including 3,837 deaths — an increase of 293 over the previous week — and 16,014 serious injuries, up 2,467 since last week.
So let’s take a look at this claim. Unsurprisingly, the answers to this particular antivaccine talking point will be similar to the ones I gave before three months ago, but with a somewhat different emphasis.
Dr. Peter McCullough: An MD/MPH who promotes quackery and doesn’t know how VAERS works
Let’s start with Dr. McCullough’s video. There are a number of red flags. First, it’s noted on the Rumble page for his video that the website he “mentions is AAPSOnline.org.” Regular readers will remember AAPS as, basically, the John Birch Society of “medical societies,” basically an astroturf right wing science denialist organization disguised as a legitimate academic medical society that has a long history of promoting antivaccine misinformation (including providing a platform for Andrew Wakefield) and, now, COVID-19 disinformation, that basically loves Dr. McCullough’s protocol, which, of course, involves hydroxychloroquine, the Black Knight of COVID-19 treatments that evidence just can’t seem to kill. Unsurprisingly, he is presented as a Brave Maverick Doctor speaking Truth to power. Similarly unsurprisingly, he cannot cite any randomized double blind clinical trials (RCTs) to support his protocol, instead relying on the excuse that all Brave Maveric Doctors (like Stanislaw Burzynski) use that they “can’t” do the RCTs. In his case, it was because the pandemic hit so fast. Oddly enough, there have now been quite a few RCTs of various COVID-19 treatments proposed early in the pandemic, and equally unsurprisingly, the vast majority of them have been negative. Similarly, he excuses those studies showing that single drugs don’t work, saying that you have to use “multiple drugs” as in HIV. Of course, what he neglects to mention is that in general multidrug cocktails contain drugs each of which does have some single agent activity. You can’t just throw together drugs that don’t work and expect that they will work, and, as Dr. Vincent Iannelli explains, they don’t work.
Of course, what Dr. McCullough claims to have done is to “leverage” small clinical trials and observational studies; too bad he didn’t do the RCTs of his cocktail, which, given the rapidly fatal course of severe COVID-19, would, contrary to his claim, not take “years” to get results from. Finally like all Brave Mavericks, Dr. McCullough claims that the reason his protocol isn’t widely accepted and publicized isn’t because it doesn’t work, but rather because the press and government regulatory agencies are either ignoring or “suppressing” news of it, even as he cited a “home treatment guide” published by—you guessed it!—AAPS. Basically, his protocol includes one FDA-accepted drug, Regeneron’s monoclonal antibody cocktail that was issued an EUA, followed by vitamins (of course!), steroids (another drug that works) and—also of course!—hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, zinc, and azithromycin, none of which have been shown to work. Come to think of it, he’s very much like Stanislaw Burzynski, mixing the unproven with the weakly proven and claiming without evidence to have “saved thousands of lives” and claims he could have saved 50-85% of the lives lost to COVID-19. Again, there’s no solid evidence to support any of these claims. I will give him one point. He’s not entirely wrong that the US has decided to emphasize vaccination as the answer to the pandemic, but he also dismisses masking and social distancing as having been overemphasized.
Next up, Dr. McCullough resurrects a common trope about the COVID-19 vaccine clinical trials by pointing out the low percentage of patients who got COVID-19 in the trials, dismissing the trials because of that while ignoring that the studies had been powered with the expectation that a low percentage of participants would be diagnosed with COVID-19. Basically, in the video he’s rehashing the same dubious arguments made by Peter Doshi in January to claim that the actual efficacy of the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines is much lower than the clinical trials found. And, as antivaxxers often do, Dr. McCullough misunderstands VAERS.
He also invokes a comparison beloved of antivaxxers, the 1976 swine flu vaccine, which was associated with a rare incidence of Guillan-Barré syndrome, which is a canard. Basically, antivaxxers claim that the program was killed after 500 cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome and 25 deaths, except that the evidence of association with the vaccine was unclear and there was no transmission of H1N1, leading the CDC to end the program early. As noted by the CDC:
As of 1976, >50 “antecedent events” had been identified in temporal relationship to GBS, events that were considered as possible factors in its cause. The list included viral infections, injections, and “being struck by lightning.” Whether or not any of the antecedents had a causal relationship to GBS was, and remains, unclear. When cases of GBS were identified among recipients of the swine flu vaccines, they were, of course, well covered by the press. Because GBS cases are always present in the population, the necessary public health questions concerning the cases among vaccine recipients were “Is the number of cases of GBS among vaccine recipients higher than would be expected? And if so, are the increased cases the result of increased surveillance or a true increase?” Leading epidemiologists debated these points, but the consensus, based on the intensified surveillance for GBS (and other conditions) in recipients of the vaccines, was that the number of cases of GBS appeared to be an excess.
Had H1N1 influenza been transmitted at that time, the small apparent risk of GBS from immunization would have been eclipsed by the obvious immediate benefit of vaccine-induced protection against swine flu. However, in December 1976, with >40 million persons immunized and no evidence of H1N1 transmission, federal health officials decided that the possibility of an association of GBS with the vaccine, however small, necessitated stopping immunization, at least until the issue could be explored.
See the difference? In 1976, there was no transmission of H1N1 going on and a question of whether the H1N1 vaccine being used at the time had an association with Guillain-Barré syndrome. Under such circumstances, it was hard to argue for continuing the vaccination campaign. Fast forward 45 years, and we still have widespread community transmission of COVID-19, with the overall death toll approaching 600K in the US alone. It’s an entirely different situation.
Dr. McCullough is also shockingly ignorant of how VAERS works. He claims that only a health care worker can access the system and that a patient or a loved one has to contact a physician or health care worker to enter a report. That is completely wrong. Indeed, one of the complaints about VAERS is that anybody—and I do mean anybody—can enter a report. It is this openness that is simultaneously one of VAERS greatest strengths and weaknesses. It’s a weakness in that this openness allows for gaming of the system, as lawyers for parents seeking to sue vaccine manufacturers for autism as a “vaccine injury” did 15 years ago. Seriously, this is an error huge enough to make me wonder about everything else, in particular whether he got his MPH out of a cereal box. This guy has an MPH and doesn’t know (or didn’t bother to find out) how VAERS actually works and that there are other vaccine safety monitoring systems other than VAERS? The only reaction I can think of is:

Naturally, there’s a conspiracy theory to go along with Dr. McCullough’s claims. Citing his experience on data safety monitoring committees, Dr. McCullough claims that it would have been “impossible” for the FDA and CDC to evaluate the first 1,600 deaths reported to VAERS and conclude that they were unrelated to the vaccines. As a result, according to him, there was a “scrubbing” of reports of death to VAERS. You’d think that someone with an MPH would understand the concept of rapid cycling analysis, which allows near real-time surveillance of possible adverse events after vaccination (or other medical interventions). Naturally, according to him, this “scrubbing” is taking place with the collusion of the press, specifically the Trusted News Initiative, which is in reality a program to combat the spread of harmful antivaccine disinformation.
The list of bogus claims and errors only accelerates from there. I’ll deal mainly with the ones unique to him and then in the next section deal with the claims common to the “Vaccine Holocaust” narrative. Here are just a few of the many bits of misinformation and disinformation spread by Dr. McCullough:
    • He claims that a vaccine trial in Australia was stopped because participants developed false positive HIV tests because “parts of the [mRNA?] code that were attempted to be used in an Australian vaccine turned HIV tests positive.” It turns out that antibodies generated by the vaccine did lead to some false positive HIV results but no HIV was ever found to be present. The reason for this is that short sequences coding for peptides that resemble peptides in HIV proteins are very common in genes coding for various other proteins, including in genes found in coronaviruses. This is basically a claim similar to that made by Nobel Laureate Luc Montagnier, who should know better but apparently does not.
    • If you really don’t want to be viewed as antivaccine, you really shouldn’t misinterpret the Nuremberg Code, as Dr. McCullough did. Antivaxxers love to claim that vaccine mandates violate the Nuremberg Code because they “violate informed consent”. They do not.
    • He also states that 60-70% of new COVID-19 cases occur in people who have already been vaccinated against COVID-19. Wrong.
    • And, of course, Dr. McCullough believes that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, is an “engineered virus” that escaped from a lab, just as our Nobel Laureate turned antivaxxer and homeopathy believer Luc Montagnier does. There is no evidence that this virus was “engineered,” and this has been known for over a year now. This claim of a “plandemic” has been a conspiracy theory for a little over a year now, with claims of an “engineered” virus having arisen months before that.
You get the idea. Basically, Dr. McCullough should have stuck to cardiology and renal disease, the two areas for which he was known prior to the pandemic that led him, as he characterized it in the video, to completely reorient the focus of his academic career. I guess the opportunity for grift and conspiracy theories was too much for him to resist.
“Vaccine Holocaust,” or: How to frighten with large numbers
Let’s get back to a core claim in this narrative, namely that the number of deaths reported to VAERS since the mass vaccination campaign with COVID-19 vaccines began in mid-December means that the vaccines are causing a “vaccine holocaust”. Sure, Dr. McCullough didn’t use that word, but Mike Adams and others aren’t so reserved, and the article featuring the interview with Dr. McCullough was titled “COVID vaccine killing huge numbers, warns leading doctor“. The numbers used by different antivaxxers vary depending on the date of their publication and the dates of the specific VAERS reports they cite. The exact numbers aren’t as important as the understanding that antivaxxers are ignoring a very important aspect of any comparison like the “4,000% increase in deaths” narrative – a narrative found not just on NaturalNews.com, but on antivax social media and websites all over the internet.
So let me repeat what I said three months ago: Whenever you see these sorts of numbers, two questions should come straight to you mind right away. The first is: What’s the denominator? The second is: What is the baseline rate for such adverse events in the population studied? To that I would add a third question: How many deaths occur during the same span of time, absent the intervention? In other words, in a four and a half month period, how many people would normally be expected to die, regardless of the cause? Finally, if you want to get really granular, you can break it down by age. However, a simple, rough, “back of the envelope” calculation will suffice to show how innumerate antivaxxers are when they make this claim about VAERS. But before we do that, let’s take a look at another number. How many people have died of COVID-19 in the US in that same four and a half month period? According to Johns Hopkins, as of May 1, there were approximately 575,000 deaths recorded, compared with around 300,000 in mid-December, meaning that ~275,000 people have died of COVID-19 over the last 4 months.
So how many people die of all causes every year? The CDC states that the yearly number of deaths in the US in 2019 was 2,854,838, for a rate of 869.7 deaths per 100,000 population. In brief, less than 1% of the US population dies every year, and immediately before the pandemic around 7,821 people died each and every day. In a four and a half month period (137 days from December 14, 2020 to April 30, 2021), then, we’d expect there to be approximately 1.07 million deaths, or a rate of approximately 326 per 100,000 population. That’s a lot of deaths. Suddenly, the figure of ~4,000 deaths since mid-December reported to VAERS doesn’t seem like such a big number, does it?
Let’s continue, though. How many people got at least one dose of one of the vaccines during that time period? As of April 30, it was 144.9 million people. In any given random population of 144.9 million people in the US during a given four and a half month period, we’d expect to see ~472,374 deaths. Again, those are big numbers. If we divide by the 137 days encompassed by December 14, 2020 to April 30, 2021, then in such a population we would expect to see 3,448 deaths each and every day during that time period, leaving aside any other sources of excess death.
Of course, this is a “back of the envelope” calculation, and I know that the sharp readers out there will immediately point out that it can be misleading to average all these vaccines over the entire four and a half month period. After all, early in the period, relatively few vaccines were being administered compared to the latter part of the period, when the vaccination campaign had been ramped up to truly impressive levels, and then, more recently, falling off again as the average daily vaccination rate fell from its peak level. Naturally, as a result, one would expect that reports to VAERS would start out slowly, as vaccination started out slowly, and then accelerate as the pace of vaccination picked up. So let’s go back to RFK Jr.’s numbers, in particular this part:
Today’s data show that between Dec. 14, 2020 and April 30, a total of 157,277 total adverse events were reported to VAERS, including 3,837 deaths — an increase of 293 over the previous week — and 16,014 serious injuries, up 2,467 since last week.
I interpret this as meaning that, according to RFK Jr., there were 293 deaths reported to VAERS during the last week of April. That sounds like a large number, particularly when, averaged out, it translates to 41.9 deaths per day. But is it? How many people received COVID-19 vaccines that week? By subtracting the April 23 statistic from the April 30 statistic, I come up with 7.66 million people receiving a COVID-19 vaccine during the last week of April, or 1.1 million/day. How many deaths would we expect in a week in a population of 7.66 million in a week, based on the CDC’s pre-pandemic statistics? Using the aforementioned yearly incidence of death pre-pandemic of 868.7 per 100,000 in a year, we can say that in a population of that size there would be 66,619 deaths in a year, or 182.5 deaths per day or 1,278 deaths in a week.
However, this is not a random population. Remember who got priority for COVID-19 vaccines until very recently. First, there is as yet no COVID-19 vaccine approved or even with an EUA issued for children. The Pfizer vaccine’s EUA applies for people 16 years of age and older, while the EUA for the Moderna and J&J vaccines only applies to people 18 years of age and older. More importantly, the two main priority groups until recently were healthcare and frontline workers and older adults, starting with those 65 and older. If you look at the CDC statistics for death rates by age, you’ll see that death rates rise rapidly with age, which is no particular surprise to anyone. Of course death rates are highest among the elderly and low among the young. Unfortunately, that’s how nature works.
Think of it this way. Never before in the history of VAERS has there been a mass vaccination program like that for COVID-19. The population initially targeted vaccination was exactly the population that has the highest baseline death rate, meaning that by random chance alone we would expect to see a seemingly large number of deaths within days of vaccination.
But there’s yet another factor. Those who have received a COVID-19 vaccination know that all those who receive COVID-19 vaccines are given instructions to sign up for V-Safe, a monitoring system that works by text message. Basically, if you sign up for V-Safe, you will receive periodic text messages, starting as daily text messages that become less frequent over time. I note that, even though I completed my vaccination series in January, I still receive V-Safe texts periodically. This basically turns a passive surveillance system into a quasi-active surveillance system. And, remember, the more you look for something, the more you will find. Always.
The law of large numbers says that, whenever an intervention is administered to huge numbers of people, there will be large numbers of adverse events that happen after that intervention by random chance alone. The way scientists determine if there is a safety signal in those adverse events is by comparing them to the expected baseline rate of each adverse event. The bottom line is that, fear mongering articles by RFK Jr. and reports of a “vaccine Holocaust” to the contrary, there is no evidence of deaths above and beyond what one would expect based on known baseline rates of death in the US population. Although RFK Jr. might not be expected to know this, someone like Dr. McCullough, who has an MPH in addition to his MD, should really, really, really know better. That he promotes antivaccine disinformation based on fear mongering about reports to VAERS of deaths and adverse events tells me one of two things. Either his MPH education failed him, or he’s lying. Take your pick. As for Mike Adams, no one expects him to know anything other than grift and propaganda.
The law of large numbers plus intensive monitoring
I can’t resist ending, as I began this post, with simple observation.
Whenever large numbers are involved, it becomes all too easy to fear monger by pointing to numbers that appear large but, when compared to the baseline rate, are actually not that large at all. That is the entire basis of the latest antivaccine propaganda trope pointing to the seemingly huge number of deaths reported to the VAERS database.

“Depopulation” by COVID-19 vaccines?
COVID-19 and antivaccine conspiracy theorists like Joe Mercola, Michael Yeadon, and Peter McCullough are spreading the conspiracy theory that COVID-19 vaccines are intended as a tool for “global depopulation”. This is nothing more than an old antivaccine conspiracy theory repurposed for the pandemic. As ridiculous as it might seem, it is nonetheless very appealing to antivaxxers.
David Gorski on June 14, 2021
Link

As I’ve long been saying, when it comes to the COVID-19 pandemic, everything old is new again, at least with respect to the antivaccine movement. I listed a number of the tropes repurposed by antivaxxers for COVID-19 last week, including (but not limited to) misinformation claiming that COVID-19 vaccines are loaded with “toxins” (the lipid nanoparticles in the mRNA-based vaccines, given that they can’t contain aluminum, don’t you know?); blaming every death reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) database on vaccines, when VAERS is not designed to determine causation and we would expect a large baseline number of deaths in the time periods covered by random chance alone; claiming that vaccines cause Alzheimer’s and prion disease; blaming the vaccines for cancer; resurrecting the favorite old trope of “shedding” from the vaccinated in the most risible manner possible; invoking evolution to predict the selection of more deadly coronavirus variants that could wipe out humanity; warning that the vaccines can “permanently alter your DNA“; and that they make females infertile, the topic of last week’s post.
Last week, I saw another such trope, one I’ve seen many times before, dating back at least to the H1N1 pandemic in 2009. It comes to us courtesy of über-quack Dr. Joe Mercola, “Was the Whole Pandemic About the Vaccine?” It even featured someone we’ve met before, Peter McCullough, who’s known for pushing a narrative of a COVID-19 “vaccine holocaust.” The central message, of course, is that the pandemic is all about getting people to accept the vaccine, with Mercola asking, “Could it be that the whole COVID-19 pandemic was about the vaccine and getting a global mass vaccination campaign underway for population control purposes?” After touting Dr. McCullough as “one of the most courageous well credentialed academic physicians out there” who, “despite his impeccable credentials, he has been vilified for stating during the very beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic.” As you might recall, the main reason why Dr. McCullough has been “vilified” is because he’s been abusing his credentials to spread COVID-19 misinformation and conspiracy theories.
Conspiracy theories like this:
“All roads lead to the vaccine,” McCullough said in a recent interview (video above1,2), with stakeholders banking on countries mandating the vaccine worldwide. The first video above is a 16-minute outtake from a much longer interview, which is the second video.3
McCullough points out that a number of countries are already talking about making the as-yet unlicensed COVID-19 vaccine compulsory, meaning anyone and everyone can be forced to take it against their will. “That’s how bad stakeholders want vaccination,” McCullough says. “They do want a needle in every arm. But why?” That’s the million-dollar question right there.
Here’s the video, if you’re interested:
Does anyone remember Welcome Back, Kotter? (That’s how old I am.) I feel like going all Arnold Horshack right here:
That’s because I know the answer to McCullough’s question. Maybe—just maybe—”they” want to vaccinate everyone in order to bring about the end of a deadly pandemic that’s sickened 176 million and killed nearly 4 million worldwide, with 600,000 deaths in the US alone (which is likely an undercount). Just a random thought. After all, as long as the vaccination rate remains too low, there will be areas where the virus can spread again, causing localized outbreaks, in much the way measles showed up in areas of low MMR uptake pre-pandemic.
Of course, to people like Mercola and McCullough, it’s a conspiracy. Because of course it is.
Vaccine incentives
Over the last several weeks, the pace of vaccination in the US has slowed, increasingly governments and private companies have been offering incentives for vaccination. It is, of course, not surprising that the pace of vaccination would start to slow down after a fast start. After all, those who most want to be vaccinated were the ones who sought out the vaccine, even when it was not yet widely available and getting vaccinated still took some effort. Now that the vaccine supply has caught up with (and surpassed) demand, the task has become more difficult, and it’s not just antivaccine misinformation that’s the cause. The people remaining to receive the vaccine include the young (who might not think they need it), those without easy access to the vaccine such as the poor and those who have difficulty taking time off from work to get vaccinated and feel that they can’t afford to be sidelined by side effects, and, yes, the vaccine hesitant.
As a result, some states and businesses are offering incentives, which Mercola, being Mercola, sees as a conspiracy:
Recent weeks have seen a significant rise in all sorts of vaccination incentives in the U.S., from free doughnuts, cake,4 french fries, hot dogs and pizza,5 to arcade tokens,6 10-cent beer,7 free state park season passes,8 free Uber and Lyft rides,9 free marijuana10 and Cincinnati Reds baseball tickets,11 a chance to win a full scholarship12 and even $1 million13 and $5 million14 giveaways.
Below is a more complete list of incentives, posted on vaccines.gov.15 As you might expect, the million-dollar lotteries have proven to be a resounding success, credited with enticing millions of people to get their shots.16
As noted by Ohio’s first “Vax-a-Million” lottery winner,” the chance of a windfall was too great to resist. “I kept hemming and hawing about it, and I work all the time, and when the Vax-a-Million thing started I immediately went down there and got it. It pushed me over the edge,” he told a local paper.17
To say the vaccine push has an air of desperation about it would be a profoundly serious understatement.
I will admit to some…uneasiness…about some of the incentive programs, such as the million-plus dollar lottery. That being said, it does appear that the incentives are working to some extent, as recently the vaccination rate has started to recover after cratering a month ago, and it looks as though incentives are here to stay, at least until the vaccination rate hits a high enough point to forestall large outbreaks and renewed surges.
Unsurprisingly, Mercola repeats the gambit invoking the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database to claim that COVID-19 vaccines are deadly. I’ve already written about that particular deceptive ploy, most recently the last time I discussed McCullough, but also in January and in February. I even alluded to it as far back as December. So, uncharacteristically, I won’t go into that gambit (much) here, other than to mention that Mercola also trots out the lie that the vaccines are “experimental gene therapy“.
So what, according to Mercola and McCullough, is the real reason why authorities want high levels of vaccination against COVID-19? They want to “depopulate” the world. No, I’m not kidding:
Why is the vaccine pushed in this way? McCollough believes it’s a global goal to “mark” people, to get you into their vaccine database, which will eventually be turned into a tool for population control, courtesy of vaccine passports.
When we’re talking about population control, there are two distinct forms, and both may apply in this case. One form of population control is about controlling people through the ideology of utilitarianism, vaccine passports and a social credit system, all of which are tied together. Another form is actual depopulation.
Of course, this, too, is an old antivaccine conspiracy theory repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines. Indeed, I was writing about this nine years ago, at least, when antivaccine conspiracy theorist Jon Rappaport wrote essentially the same thing about the H1N1 vaccine, namely that it was a plot to depopulate the world. I’ll be referring back to Rappaport’s article after I look at Mercola and McCullough’s claims.
The “depopulation agendas”
Mercola argues that there is a “depopulation agenda” being promoted by—who else?—the global “elites.” Mercola first distinguishes between two forms of the “depopulation agenda.” The first is utilitarian and—of course!—includes Nazi comparisons:
Utilitarianism is based on a mathematical equation that some individuals can be sacrificed for the greater good of the majority. In other words, if some people are harmed by vaccines, it’s an acceptable loss because society as a whole may or will reap gains.
This discredited pseudo-ethic has repeatedly been used to justify horrific human rights abuses. The Third Reich, for example, employed the utilitarian rationale as an excuse to demonize and eliminate minorities judged to be a threat to the health, security and well-being of the State.35 Now, utilitarianism is being called upon yet again, under the false narrative that mankind as a whole is in peril unless everyone rolls the dice and gets vaccinated.
In the end, the idea is that vaccine refusers won’t be allowed to freely participate in society any longer. This is the disincentive or negative incentive, which is added on top of the positive incentives previously mentioned.
In particular, Mercola does not like so-called “vaccine passports”, which, I admit, is a term that I don’t like so much in that it refers not just to vaccination requirements to travel internationally but to all requirements for vaccination, including requirements that one show proof of COVID-19 vaccination before one can be hired for certain jobs, go to concerts, fly on an airplane, and more. There are legitimate concerns about “vaccine passports,” such as how they would impact minorities and the poor more because they have less access to the vaccine and how they would impact poor countries, where the vaccines are barely available yet.
That’s not what Mercola is about, however:
The point is, once you’re in this system, you’re under someone else’s control. If they say you have to get a booster shot, you have to comply — again and again — or risk losing basic human rights, such as the ability to buy and sell, travel or get an education.
Notably, Mercola doesn’t really explain how such “vaccine passport” systems result in “depopulation,” other than to engage in conspiracy mongering about how such a system might end up being like that of the Chinese government’s system, and China’s government is an authoritarian one. It’s the logical fallacy of the slippery slope argument, in which he invokes a “slippery slope” (without using the actual term), in which vaccine passports lead to something like the Chinese social credit system, in which people with low social credit scores “can’t travel on certain kinds of public transportation, can’t travel overseas, hold certain jobs, go to school or even get a loan.” How one leads to the other in democracies, Mercola doesn’t explain. That’s the point.
It’s also why he quickly pivots to an “active depopulation agenda”:
The other form of population control refers to actual depopulation. A primary problem the global elite have been trying to solve for a long time is that there are too many people consuming too much of the world’s perceived limited resources and polluting everything in the process. The answer, in their mind, is to reduce the global population.
While birth control and abortions are promoted to help with this, these strategies aren’t effective, or rapid, enough. They need a less fertile population and they need people to die sooner.
While many may not want to believe this could possibly be true, you have to remember that the intention is not to cause suffering per se. It’s a form of self-preservation, as their end goal is to concentrate all the world’s wealth into their own hands. Ultimately, that’s what the Great Reset is all about.
Mercola has invoked the “Great Reset” on several occasions. I’ve even mentioned these occasions a few times on this very blog, such as when he falsely claimed that COVID-19 is a “casedemic” created by overly-sensitive PCR tests for the virus producing many false positives, when he featured Michael Yeadon claiming that COVID-19 vaccines sterilize women, and when he falsely claimed that COVID-19 vaccines are “experimental gene therapy” that can “permanently alter your DNA“. Basically, the “Great Reset” is a conspiracy theory based on a poor choice of words by the World Economic Forum for a proposal that explored how countries might recover from the economic damage caused by the coronavirus pandemic. The conspiracy theory posits, in brief, that COVID-19 pandemic is being used as a pretext whose purpose is to “usher in a tech-driven dystopia free of democratic controls” and create a “new ‘social contract’ that ties you to it through an electronic ID linked to your bank account and health records, and a ‘social credit’ ID that will dictate every facet of your life”. Regardless of the merits of or problems with the World Economics Forum’s proposal itself, “Great Reset” is a horrible name for it. It’s almost as though the World Economic Forum wanted to provide the perfect fodder for conspiracy theorists!
In any event, I’ve written about Michael Yeadon before. He appears to be one of the originators (if not the originator) of the lie that COVID-19 vaccines cause miscarriages and female infertility that has since mutated and metastasized in various forms. Apparently, Yeadon was at one time a fairly high-ranking manager for Pfizer, although I’ve never been able to get a clear picture of what his actual job at Pfizer was. Whatever it was, Yeadon has used his previous affiliation with Pfizer to produce clickbait headlines like “Head of Pfizer Research: Covid Vaccine is Female Sterilization“.
This time around, Yeadon is claiming that booster shots for COVID-19 will be our “death knell”:
Of all the lies we’ve been told over the past year, the ones that worry and frighten Yeadon the most are the lies about virus variants and booster shots. In fact, he believes not buying into these lies may be key to your very survival.
“When your government scientists tell you that a variant that’s 0.3% different from SARS-CoV-2 could masquerade as a new virus and be a threat to your health, you should know, and I’m telling you, they are lying,” Yeadon says.
“If they’re lying — and they are — why is the pharmaceutical industry making top-up [booster] vaccines? … There’s absolutely no possible justification for their manufacture. And the world’s medicines regulators have said, ‘Because they are quite similar to the original vaccines … we won’t be asking them to do any clinical safety studies’ …
There’s no possible benign interpretation of this. I believe they’re going to be used to damage your health and possibly kill you. Seriously. I can see no sensible interpretation other than a serious attempt at mass depopulation.
This will provide the tools to do it, and plausible deniability. They’ll create another story about some sort of biological threat and you’ll line up and get your top-up vaccines [booster shots], and a few months or a year or so later, you’ll die of some peculiar inexplicable syndrome. And they won’t be able to associate it with the vaccines …
Given that this virus represents, at worst, a slightly bigger risk to the old and ill than influenza, and a smaller risk [than influenza] to almost everyone else … we didn’t need to do anything. [We didn’t need] lockdowns, masks, mass testing, vaccines.
“I can see no sensible interpretation other than a serious attempt at mass depopulation”? Seriously? I’m half tempted to post another copy of that Horshack clip, because I can see a very sensible reason for boosters. Given how widely the virus has circulated, natural mutation has produced a number of variants of concern that are more transmissible and possibly more deadly. It is known that the antibodies stimulated by current vaccines do not neutralize some of these variants as well as they do the original SARS-CoV-2, although fortunately they still neutralize them well enough to produce strong immunity. For now. The concern, of course, is that eventually there will arise COVID-19 variants that can escape the immunity due to the vaccines, coupled with the concern that vaccine-induced immunity might wane to the point where “booster shots” will be required. Nothing nefarious there. As for that bit about the variants “only” being 0.3% different from the original? It makes me want to ask Yeadon, “Seriously? Where did you get your PhD? Do you not know that small changes in nucleic acid sequence can be all that is necessary to produce significant alterations in protein function?”
There is only one response to a statement that ignorant:

Naturally, Yeadon also thinks that the “suppression” of “cures” for COVID-19 is based on the desire to push vaccines in order to depopulate the world:
Like Yeadon, McCullough has raised serious questions about the need for a vaccine. Evidence clearly shows there are highly effective treatments,37,38 yet they’ve been near-universally suppressed in favor of these experimental shots. Why? If it’s about protecting public health and saving lives, why would effective treatments be vilified?
As noted by McCullough during a roundtable discussion in the first of several U.S.-based tribunals on COVID-19,39 something very unusual happened in 2020. For the first time, doctors around the world were actively discouraged and prevented from saving their patients. There was “an enormous, complete, pervasive, steadfast suppression of any attempts to help patients with COVID-19,” he said, adding:
“We seem to somehow have developed a uniform game plan … to passively allow as much suffering hospitalization and death as possible, create enormous amounts of fear in our society, and then be prepared for mass vaccination.”
Unsurprisingly, Mercola and Yeadon are referencing McCullough’s “treatment protocol” for COVID-19 that involves basically throwing everything but the kitchen sink at patients. His protocol includes one FDA-accepted drug, Regeneron’s monoclonal antibody cocktail that was issued an EUA, followed by vitamins (of course!), steroids (another drug that works) and—also of course!—hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, zinc, and azithromycin, none of which have been shown to work, and McCullough claims that he “could have saved 50-85% of the lives lost to COVID-19”.
So, to tie it all together, according to Mercola, citing cranks, COVID-19 vaccination is a depopulation program designed to reduce the world population both through causing the institution of authoritarian control of the population and by the vaccines themselves plus booster shots directly causing female infertility, death, and chronic health problems. Quite the conspiracy! And they’re doing this because they need to reduce fertility and cause people to die sooner, the better to reduce the global population and leave the resources for the global elite.
H1N1 vaccines and “global depopulation”
This brings me back to Jon Rappaport and his article from 2012, “Germ theory and depopulation“. Personally, as a scientist, I could never understand what anyone would get out of depopulating the world, and any sort of infectious agent seems to be a very blunt, unreliable, dangerous, and likely ineffective method to achieve such an end, but let’s go back in time and see what Rappaport claimed. He believed that the H1N1 pandemic from three years before had been a “complete dud.” Personally, I was very thankful that the pandemic didn’t turn out to be nearly as severe as had been feared, but even at its level of severity it did cause a fair amount of havoc. Be that as it may, Rappoport claimed he knew what was really going on:
Swine flu was a PROPAGANDA OPERATION, plain and simple, aimed at scaring populations and driving them to get vaccines. That was the op. And it failed. In fact, the op was exposed (by yours truly and others) as a sham and a con. Millions of people online caught on. It was a devastating defeat for WHO, the CDC, and the medical cartel.
According to Rappoport, the H1N1 pandemic was a big cover, but a cover for what? Here’s where the germ theory denialism came in. Basically, his thought process (if you can call it “thought”) went along these lines: Germs don’t cause disease; so vaccines are unnecessary. But if vaccines are unnecessary, what, then, was their purpose during H1N1? Rappoport was happy to answer:
Let’s go deeper. In general, so-called contagious diseases are caused, not by germs, but by IMMUNE SYSTEMS THAT ARE TOO WEAK TO FIGHT OFF THOSE GERMS.
When we put the cart and the horse in proper alignment, things become clear. I fully realize this isn’t as sexy as talking about bio-engineered gene sequences in viruses, but the cart and horse must be understood.
GERMS ARE A COVER STORY.
What do they cover up?
The fact that immune systems are the more basic target for depopulation and debilitation of populations.
The reason I’m quoting Rappaport is simple. I just want to emphasize how Mercola’s claims that COVID-19 vaccination programs are in actuality a mass depopulation program are nothing new, just old wine in the new skin of COVID-19. This idea goes way, way back. Indeed, you might be familiar with how antivaxxers invoke Bill Gates as having said that vaccines were for “depopulation”, based on his remarks years ago about how vaccines can contribute to healthier societies and healthier societies tend to have slower population growth. Long before COVID-19, antivaxxers used that statement as “evidence” that Gates somehow wanted to use vaccines to depopulate the world. Since COVID-19 hit, they’ve quite predictably tarted up the same conspiracy theory for the pandemic. They’ve even misinterpreted concerns about low vaccine uptake among minorities and the targeting of such populations for more intensive outreach to increase their vaccination rates as evidence that not only is the agenda depopulation, but it’s eugenicist, the depopulation of “those people.”
In fact, sometimes the antivax claim that vaccines are intended for a “global depopulation agenda” get incredibly ridiculous, which is why I will conclude with what is the most ludicrous example I’ve ever found. I first encountered it a year ago. Unsurprisingly, it comes from Mike Adams and dates back to before the pandemic. It even has aliens (because any conspiracy theory can be made better if you add aliens).
In Adams’ “vaccine holocaust”, vaccines will have long latency, such that the vaccinated will spread a “bioengineered virus” around to all their family, friends, and coworkers. (Sound familiar? “Shedding”, anyone?) Months later, he envisioned people dropping dead in the streets of the virus like a scene out of the early 1970s post-apocalypse movie The Omega Man, at which point there will be calls for a second round of vaccinations, which will kill more people after an even shorter period of time, days to weeks.
But why? Why would “globalists” want to kill 90% of the population off? According to Adams, it would be to save the world. (Sound familiar?) In the meantime, the global elite will have developed AI and robots to do the work of all those billions of people dying off from their vaccine holocaust due to their vaccine bioweapon. Adams’ contempt for those who accept the science showing that vaccines are safe and effective came through, too. Multiple times, he stated that the “globalists” think that anyone who’s “stupid enough” to “line up to be injected with unknown substances” is “too stupid to be a part of the future of humanity”. He even called them “sheeple” at least once!
Here’s where the aliens come in. Adams claimed that the “globalists” have actually interacted with extraterrestrials more advanced than our civilization and have come to realize that earth must compete and expand with a cosmic economy. Thus the “globalists” needed to redirect resources into science, colonization technologies, and defense. Instead of spending to keep “useless eaters” alive, the “globalists” believe, according to Adams, that these resources need to be redirected to survive contact with advanced extraterrestrial civilizations, compete with extraterrestrials, and ultimately be part of a “cosmic ecosystem of intelligent beings”. I kid you not.
Adams even updated this alien conspiracy theory for COVID-19, calling it the “Oblivion Agenda” in which SARS-CoV-2 is that “bioweapon,” with a callback to The Day the Earth Stood Still, in which the aliens are telling the global elites that they have to do something, to prevent the earth from becoming hopelessly contaminated:
In the following 4-part lecture, I reveal why Earth has cosmic real estate value that’s recognized by all intelligent civilizations, and why Faster-Than-Light (FTL) travel technology is ubiquitous across the cosmos. Earth’s location in the Milky Way galaxy puts it right in the thick of traffic from other civilizations, who have obviously watched the rise of Homo Sapiens and have no doubt sounded alarm bells over the nuclear weapons testing that humans have been carrying out since 1945.
Setting off nukes on your own planet, by the way, is sort of a cosmic-scale way to announce to the universe, “We are here, and we are infinitely stupid. Someone please stop us before we destroy everything within reach.”
Even aliens, you see, can’t change the laws of physics. Radioisotopic half-lives are the same, everywhere in the cosmos, and they can’t be altered when anything short of nuclear fusion or fission reactors. Once you contaminate a planet with radiation, that planet is a biohazard for millennia, if not longer, and this holds true no matter what life form you might have in mind for occupying that planet.
Of course, the aliens also want to terraform the earth. Wait, what? “Terra” means “earth.” The earth is already “terraformed”!
You might well wonder why I concluded with Mike Adams’ version of the “vaccine depopulation” conspiracy theory, having already shown that such conspiracy theories are nothing new for the pandemic. The reason is simple. His version of the “vaccine depopulation” conspiracy theory might be the most “out there,” but it’s only marginally more ridiculous than the version being promoted by Joe Mercola, Michael Yeadon, and Peter McCullough because Mike Adams’ version includes aliens.
In reality, it is the antivaxxers’ whose agenda is far more likely to result in global depopulation. Vaccines are arguably the most effective medical intervention to prevent death and suffering ever devised by the human mind, having prevented billions of cases of disease and death over the history of their existence. Anyone who tries to frighten people out of taking advantage of vaccines, for both themselves and their children, is the true advocate of “depopulation.”

It was inevitable that antivaxxers would claim that COVID-19 vaccines make females infertile
Antivaxxers have been claiming that vaccines cause female infertility for as long as I can remember. So it’s not surprising that they are now claiming that COVID-19 vaccines will cause miscarriages or even make women infertile. Their assertion is based on a highly speculative and incredibly unlikely immunologic mechanism. Same as it ever was.
David Gorski on December 14, 2020
Link

One of the most common false claims made by the antivaccine movement is that a vaccine (or vaccines in general) somehow result in female infertility. Sure, antivaxxers will sometimes promote the idea that vaccines cause sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) or simply kill older children, but not nearly as often as they like to spread the persistent myth that vaccines somehow “sterilize” females. Examples abound and can be found around the world, for example, from the conspiracy theory promoted by Catholic bishops in Kenya that the tetanus vaccine is “racist population control” and that the false claim in Africa and the Philippines (among other places) that the polio vaccine can impair female fertility, while in some Muslim countries the campaign to eradicate polio has long been plagued by conspiracy theories that claim that the polio vaccine is laced with anti-fertility chemicals that would render their girls sterile before they even became women (and/or can also infect them with HIV) as part of a plot to depopulate the developing world. (Indeed, portraying vaccines as “eugenics” is a popular antivaccine trope.) Of course, the vaccine most commonly falsely cited by antivaxxers as causing female infertility is the HPV vaccine, particularly Gardasil, which is blamed without evidence for premature ovarian failure (now more commonly known as primary ovarian insufficiency), usually based on some hand waving misunderstanding of immunology attributing this “effect” to some vaguely defined autoimmune phenomenon. This claim that a specific vaccine (or vaccines) can cause infertility is what I like to refer to as a “slasher” lie, because, like the killers in 1980s slasher movies, who appear to have been finally killed at the end of one installment, these lies always manage to somehow survive to kill more teenagers in the next movie.
So it should come as no surprise that, with the rollout of the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine against COVID-19 under an FDA emergency use authorization (EUA), with the vaccine by Moderna very likely to follow very soon in distribution, this old slasher lie has found new life, this time in the form of the claim that these two vaccines cause—surprise! surprise!—female infertility! Like the HPV vaccine before, it even has an alleged former pharmaceutical company employee at a high level fear mongering about the vaccine. (More on the details of that in a moment.) Before I go on to discuss this new bit of antivaccine disinformation and the conspiracy theory associated with it, let me just make a quick observation about how the antivaccine movement treats the genders differently. Notice how the lies about vaccines somehow causing infertility are basically always lies claiming that they cause female infertility. I can’t recall even a single antivaccine claim that vaccines impair male fertility. This is despite experimental vaccines existing for both female and male contraception (the former relying on beta-HCG like an experimental tetanus vaccine, the latter targeting sperm). I’m guessing claims about male infertility have probably been made, but, if so, they are far surpassed in number, imagination, and intensity by the claims that this vaccine or that somehow “sterilizes” females. That antivaxxers like to portray the HPV vaccine as the “promiscuity vaccine” and their obsession with vaccines supposedly rendering their women infertile, leads me to the conclusion that there is a lot of misogyny behind the antivaccine movement.
Dubious experts demand a stop to a clinical trial on the basis of nonsense
Let’s get back to the conspiracy theory that the new COVID-19 mRNA-based vaccines will cause female infertility. I guess it’s just one small step from using a total misunderstanding of the totality of molecular biology to claim that such vaccines will “reprogram your DNA” to finding a dubious “mechanism” by which they will render women infertile, and certainly antivaxxers have taken that step, as shown by this recent article entitled “Head of Pfizer Research: Covid Vaccine is Female Sterilization“. Interestingly, the actual content of the article is not nearly as definitive as the clickbait headline, but does report how two men have spread the claim that the new COVID-19 vaccines might cause female infertility. Seeing that article and various others making the same claim as the Pfizer vaccine is being loaded into trucks from the Pfizer plant in my home state of Michigan and being transported all around the country, I thought it a good time to examine this dangerous new form of an old antivaccine trope.
First, let’s look at a little history and comparison. Remember how the demonization of Gardasil used to cite an OB-GYN named Diane Harper, who was frequently represented as running the clinical trials of Gardasil used to obtain FDA approval when, as far as I was ever able to glean, all she did was to serve as principal investigator at one of the sites (site PI) where patients were being enrolled in the study? (She also said that she supports HPV vaccination.) Here, the conspiracy theory goes beyond that. Whereas Harper merely made comments that antivaxxers could interpret as being critical of the efficacy and safety of HPV vaccination, here the scientist is actually spearheading the conspiracy theory. I’m referring to Dr. Michael Yeadon, who is portrayed as the former head of respiratory research at Pfizer, and is working with a German doctor named Wolfgang Wodarg. Less than two weeks ago the two filed a motion for administrative and regulatory action to the European Medicines Agency (EMA), the EU agency responsible for EU-wide drug approval, warning that the vaccine can attack placenta cells, causing female infertility. Interestingly, the link to the PDF of the letter in the original article no longer works, but someone saved an incomplete version of the letter here and I found the complete 43-page letter here.
The letter doesn’t ask the EMA to stop the phase 3 trials of BNT162, the name for BioNTech’s mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine developed with Pfizer just because it might cause infertility in females. There are a whole panoply of claims in the letter, some of which we’ve dealt with before. I won’t discuss them all, but I will briefly discuss Yeadon and Wodarg’s claim that the number of cycles for diagnosis of COVID-19 by PCR from nasal swab samples was set too high and therefore too sensitive. Because of the false positives, Yeadon and Wodarg claim that Sanger sequencing must be used to verify all the sequences. Sanger sequencing, for those not familiar with it, is an old method of sequencing DNA. In brief, Sanger sequencing was developed in 1977 by two-time Nobel Laureate Frederick Sanger and his colleagues. My first reaction upon reading the blog posts describing this particular demand was “WTF?” followed by: I know Sanger sequencing. I did Sanger sequencing when I was in graduate school back in the 1990s. My wife’s job when she worked at a biotech company back in the early 1990s was Sanger sequencing. It’s laborious and time consuming and requires a lot of starting material compared to PCR. (Does anyone remember how hard it was to pour sequencing gels?)
Then I got out of my time warp and realized that, of course, technology has marched on since the 1990s and Sanger sequencing can now be used in conjunction with various DNA sequencing machine technologies. Even so, what Yeadon and Wodarg propose is unnecessary and impractical:
All RT-qPCR-positive test results used to categorize patient as “COVID-19 cases” in the trials and used to qualify the trial’s endpoints should be verified by Sanger sequencing to confirm that the tested samples in fact contain a unique SARS-CoV-2 genomic RNA. Congruent with FDA and EMA requirements for a confirmed diagnosis of human papillomavirus (HPV) using PCR, the sequencing electropherogram must show a minimum of 100 contiguous bases matching the reference sequence with an Expected Value (E Value) <10-30 for the specific SARS-CoV-2 gene sequence based on a BLAST search of the GenBank database (aka NCBI Nucleotide database).
Basically, this, like the “casedemic” claim, is a strategy to cast doubt on the accuracy and utility of reverse transcriptase real-time PCR to diagnose COVID-19 infection. The point is, once you’ve optimized the PCR conditions and demonstrated again and again that the PCR product you are getting is, in fact, the nucleotide sequence your PCR primers were intended to target, it is wasteful and unnecessary to demonstrate that for each and every sample. Indeed, in general, such validation is only performed when there is reason to doubt that the PCR reaction is working correctly, as when the PCR product is the wrong size, for instance. I thus realized that the point of this particular demand was nothing more than to cast doubt on PCR diagnosis of COVID-19 and to add a lot of unnecessary time and expense to the diagnostic testing end of the clinical trial, particularly when one of the endpoints is also symptomatic disease.
I also can’t help but note, to conclude this section, that one of the Exhibits that Yeadon and Wodarg cites is written by Sin Hang Lee. Regular readers of this blog might remember that Lee is a pathologist who made a name for himself nearly a decade ago when he was hired by the antivaccine group SANE Vax to use ultra-sensitive nested PCR to find—gasp!—HPV DNA in Gardasil, a meaningless finding that antivaccine groups ran with, producing dubious claims of “microcompetition” by the DNA to cause autoimmune disease, including primary ovarian insufficiency, and even death, as when Dr. Lee teamed up with antivaccine “scientist” Christopher Shaw and used highly dubious PCR methodology to try to convince an inquest in New Zealand that DNA fragments from Gardasil had caused a young woman’s death. Truly, antivaccine cranks never go away. They just keep showing up in different forums arguing different nonsense.
Oh, no! The Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine is coming for our women!
Interestingly, the claim that the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine could potentially cause infertility is actually a small part of the overall petition, which spends far more verbiage on PCR, Sanger sequencing, and the not-unreasonable but thus far not observed concern about antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE) due to a vaccine, which has been a problem in the development of vaccines against Dengue Virus, Ebola Virus, HIV, RSV, and the family of coronaviruses. Basically, ADE is a phenomenon where a subject who has antibodies to a disease can mount a hyperactive immune response to it if challenged again. ADE has been observed in animal models of coronavirus vaccines in the past, for example, against SARS, but thus far not observed in humans in trials of vaccines directed against the spike protein of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Given the number of subjects thus far vaccinated, if ADE were a problem we’d expect to have seen it by now.
Let’s get to the key claim made by Yeadon and Wodarg regarding the COVID-19 vaccine and female infertility, as described in the original blog post that went viral and started the social media spread of this particular claim:
The vaccinations are expected to produce antibodies against spike proteins of SARS-CoV-2. However, spike proteins also contain syncytin-homologous proteins, which are essential for the formation of the placenta in mammals such as humans. It must be absolutely ruled out that a vaccine against SARS-CoV-2 could trigger an immune reaction against syncytin-1, as otherwise infertility of indefinite duration could result in vaccinated women.
From the petition itself:
Several vaccine candidates are expected to induce the formation of humoral antibodies against spike proteins of SARS-CoV-2. Syncytin-1 (see Gallaher, B., “Response to nCoV2019 Against Backdrop of Endogenous Retroviruses” – http://virological.org/t/response-to-ncov2019- against-backdrop-of-endogenous-retroviruses/396), which is derived from human endogenous retroviruses (HERV) and is responsible for the development of a placenta in mammals and humans and is therefore an essential prerequisite for a successful pregnancy, is also found in homologous form in the spike proteins of SARS viruses. There is no indication whether antibodies against spike proteins of SARS viruses would also act like anti-Syncytin-1 antibodies. However, if this were to be the case this would then also prevent the formation of a placenta which would result in vaccinated women essentially becoming infertile. To my knowledge, Pfizer/BioNTech has yet to release any samples of written materials provided to patients, so it is unclear what, if any, information regarding (potential) fertility-specific risks caused by antibodies is included.
According to section 10.4.2 of the Pfizer/BioNTech trial protocol, a woman of childbearing potential (WOCBP) is eligible to participate if she is not pregnant or breastfeeding, and is using an acceptable contraceptive method as described in the trial protocol during the intervention period (for a minimum of 28 days after the last dose of study intervention).
This means that it could take a relatively long time before a noticeable number of cases of postvaccination infertility could be observed.
Perhaps the most convincing counterargument to this is simple, but I will go beyond that to go into the weeds a bit. First, however, the simple counterargument:
Humans do have a protein called syncytin-1, which is critical in developing the placenta during pregnancy, Stockwell said in an email. “Theoretically, an immune response against this protein could cause increased risk of a failed pregnancy.”
But if the claims in the blog post were accurate, that would mean that pregnant women who catch COVID-19 would also become infertile, he said. No increased infertility or pregnancy loss has been observed in women with COVID-19.
Exactly. But what about the claim that syncytin-1 is so similar to the COVID-19 spike protein that a vaccine using the spike protein to provoke an immune response against SARS-CoV-2 would risk cross reacting with syncytin-1? Just as I was gearing up to do a bunch of BLAST searches against the Genbank database, as I did so many months ago when James Lyons-Weiler was making claims that SARS-CoV-2 (then called 2019-nCoV, so long ago was it) was created in a lab, I came across an excellent post by Edward Nirenberg, where, in order to answer the question of how much the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein resembles syncytin-1, he did the same BLAST searches I was gearing up to do. Basically, being the sometimes-lazy guy that I am, I thought: Why should I reinvent the wheel? I’ll just cite him instead! First, I’ll note that he also provided an excellent description of what syncytins are:
Did you know that the reason that eutherians (placental mammals) have a placenta is because of several retrovirus infections? They gave us proteins called syncytins, which form a structure called a syncytium or polykaryon (literally “many kernels,” where kernel is an old word for “nucleus”) if you’re fancy… syncytium is essentially one giant cell that contains the nuclei of many cells. Your muscle cells are syncytia (that’s the plural for syncytium), for example, and syncytia are common cytopathic effects one can observe when cell cultures are infected with some viruses. Genetic studies of mice in which syncytins are knocked out (mutations are introduced so that no functional protein is generated) show that syncytins are critical for the formation of a placenta, and in their absence it fails to form. In humans, there are two proteins responsible for this: syncytin-1 (present in every layer of the trophoblast, the outer layer of cells in the blastocyst, a very early point in the development of a mammal appearing between days 5 and 9) and syncytin-2 (found in cytotrophoblast cells). The placenta is required for pregnancy, and thus tampering with syncytins can result in infertility.
Nirenberg, like Stockwell quoted above, also notes that there is no evidence that COVID-19 infection predisposes to early pregnancy loss, and he even cites the peer-reviewed literature. Read more if you’re interested in that aspect. In the meantime, I’ll note that Nirenberg also points out vaccines using only the receptor-binding domain of the spike protein (Moderna) rather than the entire spike protein, shouldn’t have any sequence homology between syncytins and the spike protein, because the receptor-binding domain is not the region of the protein that mediates viral fusion. Expected results aside, it’s a simple matter to take the amino acid sequence of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and use the Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) to compare it to the proteins encoded by the human genome. Nirenberg did just that, and found that “no human sequences align, but there is exceptional homology with many other SARS-CoV-2 isolates”.
Amusingly, Nirenberg also notes that there is actually a nine amino acid sequence “with 66% sequence identity between syncytin-1 and SARS-CoV-2 spike, which somehow the author of this claim ignored, even though this would represent a (still untenable but nonetheless) greater risk for autoimmune disease than the short stretch of sequences present there,” further twisting the knife by noting that he mentions “this to point out the competence of the individual behind the claim only”. I do so love pointing out something a crank missed as evidence for his incompetence, and that’s what Nirenberg did.
My enjoyment aside, such a small stretch of sequence homology (similarity) tends to be missed on BLAST because it “does not represent a significant homology, and similarly, it’s not going to be a concern for your immune system.” Bending over backwards to be fair, Nirenberg further goes on to mention in an addendum that, yes, it’s possible that how proteins fold might represent a means of even small bits of the protein being similar enough to provoke a B-cell immune response through molecular mimicry, but then shoots that claim down:
BLAST does not allow for considerations of how proteins fold, and thus cannot model B cell epitopes effectively. A rigorous approach to the question of whether or not molecular mimicry were possible here is actually a fairly advanced bioinformatics project that might merit a publication because one would have to be able to model how the proteins folded in space to see if conformational epitopes were shared (in the case of B cells), where the endogenous antigen presentation machinery is likely to make cuts in processing the spike protein antigen, determine which epitopes would be immunodominant, compare this to known HLA alleles to see if there are specific binding clefts that fit putatively cross-reactive sequences very well to see if a genetic susceptibility exists (assuming a cross-reactive sequence is identified in the first place), and then you would eventually need in vivo validation that this is legitimate (but that comes after all the very heavy bioinformatics work).
So, why did I go with a BLAST search, knowing these deficiencies? Was I being willfully dishonest? Well, no. BLAST will miss very short identities, like the 8-12 amino acids needed to share a T cell epitope. However, if BLAST did identify a significant sequence identity, that could be cause for concern, it would be a good indicator for further investigation, and thus I felt it was a reasonable shortcut rather than undertaking the complex bioinformatics project I described above, taken together with the available epidemiologic data. I will add though that if a competent bioinformatician wants to undertake the previously aforementioned project, I would be happy to update this post with their findings and credit them fully. The presence of a shared (putative- as it’s not known that this sequence could even end up being presented by antigen-presentation machinery without much more complex analysis) T cell epitope alone does not allow for autoimmune disease- a litany of other conditions must be fulfilled before this can be seriously considered (we still have an extensive suite of immunologic tolerance mechanisms).
He further cites this excellent Twitter thread in which an immunologist named Andrew Croxford does an exercise in which he takes the peptide sequence of the spike protein and aligns it with random human protein sequences.
He puts a bow on the whole thread by pointing out the inconsistency in Yeadon and Wodarg’s “hypothesis” (if you can call it that):
Basically, the stretch of amino acid similarity between the spike protein of SARS-CoV-2 and syncytin-1 are too short to be of any immunologic consequence. Moreover:
This is completely bonkers. Even if the vaccine did contain Syncytin-1, which it does not-every single human expresses it anyway and is immune tolerant to it, and this would have 0 biological impact on them.
— Aris Katzourakis (@ArisKatzourakis) December 3, 2020
To summarize, I quote Edward Nirenberg’s “short version”:
Someone has claimed that the COVID-19 vaccines are going to cause infertility because of a shared amino acid sequence in the spike protein of SARS-CoV-2 and a placental protein, which will make the immune system attack both as it can’t tell the difference. The truth? This sequence is too short for the immune system to meaningfully confuse it with placental proteins. It’s sort of like saying that you are going to be confused with a criminal because you wear a commonly sold red bracelet that was also found on the criminal. It’s not realistic. If this were true, we would also expect COVID-19 to cause early pregnancy loss a significant amount of the time. The evidence available to us does not support that this is the case. There is no reasonable basis to believe that vaccines against COVID-19/SARS-CoV-2 will affect fertility.
Whenever I see disinformation like this, I’m always interested in who is spreading it.
Who are Michael Yeadon and Wolfgang Wodarg?
Having never heard of either member of this not-so-dynamic duo of physicians and scientists before, I naturally wondered who they were. Michael Yeadon was fairly easy to look into in that news stories mentioned, that, yes, he did work for Pfizer until 2011. His LinkedIn profile lists him as having had multiple titles at Pfizer:
    • Chief Scientific Officer (CSO), Allergy and Respiratory Research, 1995-2011
    • Vice President, Allergy & Respiratory Head, Research, 2005-2008
    • CSO and VP, Allergy & Respiratory Research Head, 2006-2011
I can’t help but also note that some of the news stories I read described trying to verify his previous employment at Pfizer but having failed.
It doesn’t matter, though. Let’s assume that Dr. Yeadon’s employment history with Pfizer is as he says. A simple search on his name reveals that this isn’t his first rodeo when it comes to dubious science. In fact, I didn’t notice the first time I saw the viral blog post, but Yeadon has been featured on über-quack Joe Mercola’s website before making false claims about COVID-19:
Like several other scientists, doctors and researchers, Yeadon has pointed out that there are no excess deaths due to COVID-19.2,3,4 According to Yeadon, who has analyzed the statistics, about 1,700 people die each day in the U.K. in any given year. Many of these deaths are now falsely attributed to COVID-19.
“I’m calling out the statistics, and even the claim that there is an ongoing pandemic, as false,” he said in a recent interview with British journalist Anna Brees (see video above). He challenges anyone who doesn’t believe him to seek out any database on total mortality. If you do that, you will find that the daily death count is “absolutely bang-on normal,” Yeadon said.
Like Hodkinson, Yeadon is concerned about the fact that the laws of immunology are being completely ignored — apparently in order to fit some hidden agenda.
While Yeadon is unwilling to guess at what might be behind the creation of these false narratives, or why scientific truth is being censored, others have linked together evidence pointing to the pandemic being used as an excuse for the redistribution of wealth and the technocratic takeover of the whole world under the banner of a “Great Reset.”
First, it’s not true that there isn’t a lot of excess mortality in the UK due to COVID-19. Second, it’s obvious that Yeadon is a card-carrying, full-blown conspiracy theorist. For those who haven’t heard of it, the “Great Reset” is a proposal by the World Economic Forum that’s launched a major conspiracy theory claiming that the COVID-19 pandemic is being used as a pretext whose purpose is to “usher in a tech-driven dystopia free of democratic controls” and create a “new ‘social contract’ that ties you to it through an electronic ID linked to your bank account and health records, and a ‘social credit’ ID that will dictate every facet of your life”. Regardless of the merits of or problems with the proposal itself, the “Great Reset” is a horrible name. It’s almost as though the World Economic Forum wanted to provide the perfect fodder for conspiracy theorists, and I’d love to talk to whoever thought that name was a good idea. (Anyone who pays attention to conspiracy theorists could have told them that the very name would turn into a conspiracy theory!) My irritation with a horrible name aside, it’s no wonder that Yeadon also features prominently in the “casedemic” conspiracy theory that claims that the count threshold for PCR testing for COVID-19 is intentionally being set too high (i.e., too sensitive) and that PCR testing can’t tell if you have COVID-19 and has been featured by Mercola on more than one occasion, never a good look if you are truly science-based. Indeed, if Yeadon were truly science-based in his concerns, he’d avoid Mercola like the quack plague that he is.
He’d also avoid the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), the right-wing propagandists disguised as a “think tank” behind the eugenics-adjacent Great Barrington Declaration that basically advocates letting COVID-19 rip through the “young and healthy” population (because, you know, it’s harmless to them) while using “focused protection” to protect the elderly and those vulnerable to severe disease due to their chronic illnesses. Never mind that it’s impossible to protect the elderly and vulnerable from a virus that’s spreading unchecked everywhere else. Unsurprisingly, Yeadon not only doesn’t avoid AIER – he’s appeared in a video for the group asking why health authorities won’t declare the pandemic to be over. No, seriously.
If you don’t believe that Yeadon is a COVID-19 denialist and conspiracy theorist, a quick perusal of his Twitter feed will disabuse you of that notion:
I got tired of finding such Tweets, and I only went back four days.
What about Wolfgang Wodarg? He’s a German physician and politician, a member of the Social Democratic Party, who was elected to the Bundestag in 1994 and remained there for 15 years. One thing I found very rapidly is that, whatever his qualifications otherwise, COVID-19 is not his first rodeo when it comes to bad science and denying severity of a pandemic. It turns out that he did a similar thing during the H1N1 pandemic of 2009-2010 when he testified at a hearing conducted by the Council of Europe’s Committee on Social, Health and Family Affairs. The theme? “False pandemics: a threat to health”. Yes, that’s right:
At today’s hearing, several committee members pressed the WHO and vaccine company officials on two main issues. They expressed deep suspicions that vaccine industry experts on WHO advisory groups improperly influenced the WHO’s assessment of the pandemic in order to financially benefit pharmaceutical companies. Council members also questioned the WHO official, Dr Keiji Fukuda, special advisor on pandemic influenza to the WHO director-general, about confusion surrounding consideration of severity in its definition of a pandemic, which was revised at about the time the novel H1N1 virus was identified.
Some government public health officials and influenza experts have strongly rejected Wodarg’s claims, defending vaccine stockpiling as a prudent public health response and calling the charges “preposterous.”
In his opening statement, Wodarg said he was skeptical about the threat of the H5N1 virus and the contracts that countries had in place with vaccine makers in the event of a pandemic. “WHO had the trigger,” he said, alluding to the pandemic plans of some countries that activate the contracts when the WHO declares the highest alert level. He speculated that vaccine makers are making a financial windfall from what he claims are more expensive patented and adjuvanted vaccines. He also argued that the billions that governments have spent on pandemic vaccines could be better spent on other health issues.
He charged that the change in pandemic definition “made it possible to turn a run-of-the-mill flu into a pandemic and translate into millions for vaccine for no good reason.”
Wodarg also claimed that adjuvanted vaccines used in Europe were not adequately tested, especially in children, and expressed doubts about the safety of cell-based pandemic vaccines.
Sound familiar? In 2010, Wodarg described H1N1 as a “run-of-the-mill flu” that the WHO and EU turned into a “pandemic”, all in order to produce huge profits for vaccine companies. In 2020, he’s describing COVID-19 as not nearly as prevalent or serious because of PCR false positives, something done—you guessed it!—to lead to huge profits for vaccine companies. Meanwhile, back in March, in a video in German with English subtitles, Wodarg was trying to convince people that COVID-19 was no more dangerous than the flu as he claimed that the virus “is not new” but merely another harmless coronavirus. He also referred to the pandemic as “alleged” and concluded, “The king is wearing no clothes”.
Same as it ever was. Cranks gonna crank, and quacks gonna quack. The sad thing is that this not-so-dynamic duo is stoking real fear that the new COVID-19 vaccines will make women infertile and is doing it based on speculative nonsense. Truly, antivaccine tropes never, ever die, which is why it was inevitable that the claim that COVID-19 vaccines will endanger female fertility would make an appearance before the vaccines were approved. Think of this as Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers appearing to die at the end of a movie, only to reappear in a subsequent installment of the series to kill again. Slasher lie, indeed.

“COVID-19 vaccines are going to sterilize our womenfolk,” Take 2
Antivaxxers have long claimed that vaccines, particularly HPV vaccines, can damage the ovaries and cause female infertility. That claim has been resurrected for COVID-19 vaccines. The first example relied on a dubious “similarity” between the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and a placental protein. This time, it’s the lipid nanoparticles attacking the ovaries, echoing very old claims about polysorbate-80. Truly, everything old is new again.
David Gorski on June 7, 2021
Link

Before there were safe and effective COVID-19 vaccines authorized for use, such as the vaccines by Pfizer/BioNTech, Moderna, and Johnson & Johnson here in the US, as well as AstraZeneca in Europe and elsewhere, those of us who have been countering the antivaccine movement for many years now were warning about the sorts of disinformation that antivaxxers would spread about them. We were largely correct, too, but I can’t really say that it took any particular brilliance or foresight to have been so correct. We simply knew that there is no truly new trope, pseudoscience, or disinformation in the antivaccine narratives and conspiracy theories; so all we did was to predict the repurposing of tried-and-not-true antivax lies.
And so it came to pass beginning as soon as the vaccines neared approval under an emergency use authorization (EUA) by the FDA that antivaxxers repurposed all their old tropes for COVID-19 vaccines, claiming that they were loaded with “toxins” (the lipid nanoparticles in the mRNA-based vaccines, given that they can’t contain aluminum, don’t you know?); blaming every death reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) database on vaccines, when VAERS is not designed to determine causation and we would expect a large baseline number of deaths in the time periods covered by random chance alone; claiming that vaccines cause Alzheimer’s and prion disease; blaming the vaccines for cancer; resurrecting the favorite old trope of “shedding” from the vaccinated in the most risible manner possible; invoking evolution to predict the selection of more deadly coronavirus variants that could wipe out humanity; warning that the vaccines can “permanently alter your DNA“; and that they make females infertile. I will admit that there were a couple of new ones, albeit variations on a theme. For instance, because of the new mRNA- and adenovirus-based technologies used to develop the current crop of vaccines, antivaxxers have falsely referred to them as “experimental gene therapy” rather than vaccines, and, because vaccination in the shoulder can lead to transient inflammation of the lymph nodes under the arm, which has led to some unnecessary biopsies after mammography for breast cancer screening, antivaxxers have tried to claim that the vaccines cause breast cancer. So I guess I should say that there’s almost nothing new under the sun.
This is why I was not particularly surprised to see the “toxins” gambit with respect to COVID-19 vaccines rear its ugly head again, in particular with respect to the lipid nanoparticles in the vaccines. I was, however, slightly impressed with how antivaxxers had combined it with the “vaccines cause sterilization” trope again. (Or maybe they were combining the “vaccines are sterilizing our women” trope with the toxins gambit. I guess it doesn’t matter that much which is the case.) Since I keep seeing the study that antivaxxers mangle coming up again and again and again on antivaccine social media, I decided that I had to address this new marriage of two antivaccine tropes. Let’s just say that they’re two crappy tastes that taste crappy together.
It begins, as is often the case, on Twitter
I first recall seeing the antivaccine narrative, claiming that lipid nanoparticles from COVID-19 vaccines accumulate in the ovaries and other tissues, showing up on Twitter from “Nurse Erin”:
There is evidence to suggest that the Covid mRNA-LNP (lipid nanoparticles) are adhering themselves to human organs (i.e. female ovaries). No long-term studies. You can never get unvaccinated. Leaked confidential study from Pfizer. https://t.co/NLGPFnjIz5 #knowledgeispower pic.twitter.com/q3qRM7JLBP
— NurseErin (@erin_bsn) May 30, 2021
Conspiracy theorists being conspiracy theorists, “Nurse Erin” says that the claim that lipid nanoparticles from the Pfizer vaccine “adhere” to the ovaries is based on a “leaked confidential” study from Pfizer (of course). It turns out that “Nurse Erin” is an antivaccine nurse named Erin Marie Olszewski, who caused a minor ruckus last summer after having worked as a traveling nurse during the first surge of the pandemic last spring. She wrote a book about it, Undercover Epicenter Nurse: How Fraud, Negligence, and Greed Led to Unnecessary Deaths at Elmhurst Hospital. (That longtime antivaccine activist J.B. Handley, who has more recently—and not unexpectedly—joined the COVID-19 conspiracy theory antimask grift train, wrote the foreword should tell you all you need to know about this book, as should the endorsement by Joe Mercola.) In it, Ms. Olszewski claimed that people who had tested negative for COVID-19 were being diagnosed as having COVID-19 anyway, put on ventilators, and “drugged up with sedatives”. In the process, besides spinning conspiracy theories, she also appears to have engaged in what sounds like a massive violation of HIPAA by videotaping medical records, and including them in a conspiracy video with minimal redaction. Unsurprisingly, doctors and nurses at Elmhurst understandably felt betrayed and took pains to debunk “Nurse Erin’s” disinformation.
In any event “Nurse Erin” appears to have gotten her “information” from here:
To be clear this is a Japanese study that was acquired from a group of doctors including Dr. Byram Bridle from the Japanese government.
The EMA report is public knowledge that was released in February of 2021 confirming accumulation in organs. https://t.co/SNu4TTGe4G
— fly (@dankdly111) May 30, 2021
So as a summary, my research has now revealed to me:1) They absolutely accumulate in organs2) They are highly inflammatory 3) Safety studies are suggesting the cause of side effects are primarily from the lipid nanoparticles4) There is no long term analysis on what happens pic.twitter.com/8HvRRHOdYB
— fly (@dankdly111) May 30, 2021
Amusingly, fly tried to appear “reasonable”:
Please chill out with the sterilization claims. We don't know for sure. The study points to no known effect of toxicity on ovaries.
My question is, lipid nanoparticles are highly inflammatory. So are we sure? How do we know for certain? I'm scared of the answer though. pic.twitter.com/N2GrUIKzCi
— fly (@dankdly111) May 30, 2021
But antivaxxers were having none of it:
Huiveringwekkende studie #mRNAvaccin nanodeeltjes
Japans onderzoek over #LipidNanoParticles (#LNPs) die de #mRNAcode bevatten, en na #vaccinatie op grote schaal door 't lichaam circuleren en hersenen, milt, dikke darm, hart, lever, longen etc. bereikenhttps://t.co/TTUftpMb1T
— ▪Doorn▪ (@top_grafisch) June 3, 2021
Which brings me to Byram Bridle, who, if the above Tweets are to be believed, is the person who “discovered” this “confidential” Japanese study. Before that, he had been spreading misinformation about the “deadly spike protein” produced by COVID-19 vaccines:
Dr Byram Bridle, Professor of Viral Immunolog: The spike protein in the covid vaccines is a very dangerous toxin. This 7 minute video can save your life, your childrens’ lives and your grandchildren’s lives.https://t.co/0kw7Ztv1q9
— Ossi Tiihonen 🇫🇮 (@OssiTiihonen) June 1, 2021
I’ll just refer you to my extensive discussion from two weeks ago of the studies being misrepresented by antivaxxers.
Enter Byram Bridle
While I saw narratives based on this same study showing up on Twitter a lot, leave it to Mike Adams to turn up the conspiracies to 11, with an article titled “Horrifying study reveals mRNA vaccine nanoparticles are circulated throughout the entire body: Brain, heart, liver, ovaries, testes and more“:
Not surprisingly, everything the establishment tells us about covid vaccines has been a calculated lie. One of the biggest and most treacherous lies is that “mRNA vaccine shots stay in the arm and don’t circulate nanoparticles around the body.” Now we know that is a complete lie, as new research conducted in Japan shows that Lipid NanoParticles (LNPs) containing the mRNA code are widely circulated around the body after vaccination, reaching the brain, spleen, large intestine, heart, liver, lungs and other organs.
The study paper, originally written in Japanese and auto-translated into English, can be found at this link on Natural News servers (PDF).
Labeled, “Pfizer confidential,” the study is known as a bio-distribution study that uses luciferase enzymes and radioisotope markers to accurately track the distribution of Pfizer’s mRNA LNPs across the body.
Of course, Adams also cites Dr. Bridle, who, as it turns out, is an associate professor and viral immunologist in the Department of Pathobiology in the Ontario Veterinary College at the University of Guelph, and apparently the main source of this new “variant” (sorry, couldn’t resist using the word) of the “toxins gambit.” (Dr. Bridle is a rather…appropriate…name for a faculty member at a veterinary college.) As you might guess, he is an antivaxxer, antimasker, and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and has made a number of false claims about vaccines dating back to the early days of the pandemic. He is also engaged by Elders Without Borders as an expert witness on behalf of Adam Skelly (owner of Adamson BBQ), and has testified against the effectiveness of masks, against lockdowns, and against the “experimental” vaccines (which he reasons are unnecessary with his proposed treatment – ivermectin).
Perhaps Bridle’s most famous quote was cited by Adams:
In short, the conclusion is we made a big mistake. We didn’t realize it until now. We saw the spike protein was a great target antigen. We never knew the spike protein, itself, was a toxin and was a pathogenic protein. So, by vaccinating people, we are inadvertently inoculating them with a toxin, and in some people this gets into circulation. And when that happens in some people, it can cause damage, especially with the cardiovascular system. I don’t have time, but many other legitimate questions about the long-term safety there for this vaccine. For example, with accumulating in the ovaries, one of my questions is, “will we be rendering young people infertile, some of them infertile?” So, I’ll stop there.
You’ll see the first part of that paragraph everywhere, usually represented as a “provaccine” scientist saying, “We made a big mistake.” Of course, the hilarious part is the huge mistake Bridle makes in the paragraph above, conflating lipid nanoparticles with the spike protein. (More on that later.)
Most relevant to this post, he has made claims that the spike protein made by vaccines:
    • Is horribly toxic. (Wrong.)
    • “Has implications for blood donation.” (Given the transient, infinitesimal amount of spike protein from the vaccine that gets into the circulation, wrong.)
    • Has “implications for infants that are suckling.” (No, spike protein made by vaccines is detectable transiently in the blood at levels that are at the lower limits of a very sensitive assay, and a number of studies show that the vaccine itself is not passed through breast milk.)
    • Causes gastrointestinal bleeding in infants consuming the breast milk of their vaccinated mothers, based on VAERS reports. (Again, anyone can submit a report of any adverse reaction to VAERS, and antivaxxers have been weaponizing those reports, implying causation where there is none—or even a real correlation.)
    • Endangers fertility. (Not true, as I discussed before. Spike does not resemble the placental protein syncytin, the previous “mechanism” invoked by antivaxxers when fear mongering about COVID-19 vaccines and fertility. The new “mechanism” of Dr. Bridle’s promoted by Ms. Olszewski will be addressed in the next section.)
One also notes, as is often the case for scientists who spread misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines, an undisclosed conflict of interest:
A second emphasis of the lab is the study of host responses to viruses. An area of focus is developing a better understanding of the mechanisms underlying virus-induced cytokine storms. Dr. Bridle’s research team has identified a critical role of signaling through the type I interferon receptor in the negative regulation of an extensive network of cytokines. Cytokine responses to viruses are often very different between females and males and the Bridle lab group is seeking to understand why. At the intersection of these two programs, is a research initiative aimed at modifying the research team’s optimized cancer vaccine platforms to target severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV)-2, which is the causative agent of the coronavirus disease identified at the end of 2019 (COVID-19). The long-term goal is to have a flexible technological platform to rapidly develop vaccines against highly pathogenic coronaviruses that may emerge in the future.
Yes, Dr. Bridle is trying to develop his own vaccine and treatments for COVID-19. Sound familiar? It should. For example, Geert Vanden Bossche, who is also spreading misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines, owns a company that is trying to develop a vaccine based on a technology to activate natural killer cells. This is a form of antivaccine grift that goes all the way back to Andrew Wakefield, who, as you might recall, had his own measles vaccine under development at the time he published his case series linking the MMR vaccine to autism in 1998. The idea seems to be to attack current vaccines as dangerous and ineffective, feeding the antivaccine movement, to pave the way for your own vaccine. Indeed, a year ago Dr. Bridle received a $230,000 grant from the provincial government to develop a vaccine using the very same spike protein that he’s been demonizing, although that might be the “big mistake” he has been confessing to.
About that biodistribution study
Now that I’ve established the origin of the antivaccine misuse of the biodistribution study, at least as closely as I can, let’s take a look at the claims of Ms. Olszewski, Mr. Adams, and Dr. Bridle themselves and compare them to the actual study, so helpfully stored at so many antivaccine websites. The original report is in Japanese, but there is what appears to be a machine-translated version available.
The first thing to note is that this biodistribution study is in rats, not humans. Wistar Han rats received a 50 μg dose of lipid nanoparticles labeled with 3H, which is radioactive. Radioactivity was measured in various organs at 0.25, 1, 2, 4, 8, 24, and 48 hours post-injection.
The second thing to note is that this study was only of the lipid nanoparticles, not the full vaccine containing the mRNA for the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. The dose used was 50 μg. The human vaccine contains 0.43 mg ALC-0315=(4-hydroxybutyl)azanediyl)bis(hexane-6,1-diyl)bis(2-hexyldecanoate), ALC-0159=0.05 mg 2[(polyethylene glycol)-2000]-N,N-ditetradecylacetamide, 0.09 mg 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3- phosphocholine, and 0.2 mg cholesterol. That is basically ~0.46 mg lipids or 460 μg. Let’s just round it up to 500 μg (0.5 mg). That’s approximately 10x the dose given to the rats. However, for the typical “70 kg” male, 0.5 mg represents a per-weight dose of 0.0071 mg/kg, or 7.1 μg/kg. Let’s compare to the rats, which generally weigh around 200 g (0.2 kg), give or take, at 8 weeks, which is the usual age rodents are used for experiments. That would translate to a per-weight dose of ~250 μg/kg. Even if you used much older rats, who can weigh as much as twice as much, that would still translate to a dose of 125 μg/kg. So we’re looking at a lipid nanoparticle does of ~18-35x higher (as a rough estimate) than the typical adult human dose. That’s not unexpected. Biodistribution studies frequently use much higher doses than the human dose, the better to be able to detect distribution in low uptake organs, which, it turns out, the ovaries are.
As pointed out by multiple sources, the peak accumulation in the ovaries was 0.095% (or less than 1:1,000 of the total dose of lipid nanoparticle):
🤦‍♂️ Antivaxxers don’t even bother to look at the links they cite. No, it’s not HUMAN ovaries, this was a RAT study! And less that 0.1% of the dose went there! 50% never even made it to tissues, 50% was at injection site, and then metabolized by liver. Brain peak was 0.02% (1/5000) https://t.co/lFJfZ7dc1v pic.twitter.com/MInLqrLx7J
— Yuri Deigin (@ydeigin) May 30, 2021
Not that this has deterred antivaxxers:
The paper Byram cited doesn't support his claim. That's pretty telling that a study cited to support his claims actually goes against those claims.
— Glen Pyle | #WomensHeartHealth ❤️‍🩹 (@glenpyle) May 30, 2021
Because, of course, it hasn’t.
At this point, I can’t help but also point out that there have been actual studies of COVID-19 vaccines and ovarian function. In one such study, for example, researchers studied women undergoing oocyte retrieval for in vitro fertilization. They found no detrimental effect on ovarian follicular function. Another study of women undergoing in vitro fertilization demonstrated that the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine has no detectable effect on the percentage of clinical pregnancies resulting from the procedure. Yet another study has shown that vaccination against COVID-19 has no effect on immunological tolerance of the fetus by the mother. Still another study failed to find any effect on embryo implantation rates between SARS-CoV-2 infection seropositive, SARS-CoV-2 vaccine seropositive, or seronegative women.
It is true that most of these studies are still on preprint servers and haven’t completed peer review yet to be published in a peer-reviewed journal, but the evidence thus far is strongly supportive of the conclusion that neither COVID-19 infection nor vaccination against COVID-19 has any effect on female fertility. While it is true that these studies all examine women undergoing in vitro fertilization procedures and the women who took part are thus not representative of all reproductive age women, these results are even worse for the claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause infertility. Why? Most of these women (surrogates and cases of male factor infertility excluded) undergo in vitro fertilization because of difficulty conceiving, and one would expect such women to be more, not less, susceptible to anything that might impact female fertility. And, as was pointed out by others, several female participants got pregnant during Pfizer’s phase 3 trial, and the only adverse pregnancy outcome was in the placebo group.
But what about the rest of the biodistribution?
As Yuri Deigin pointed out, only around 0.1% of the dose of lipid nanoparticles went to the ovaries. More importantly, 53% stayed at the injection site in the muscle, which is good, given that the whole point of an intramuscular injection is for the lipid nanoparticles to get the mRNA contained within into muscle cells near the injection cite, there to set up shop and provide the template for producing spike protein. Another “popular” site was the nearest lymph node basin, which explains why enlarged axillary lymph nodes (lymph nodes under the arm) have been observed in some women undergoing screening mammography too soon after vaccination, leading radiology and breast cancer specialists to tweak their mammography guidelines to minimize the chance of unnecessary axillary lymph node biopsies. At peak, only 0.02% made it to the brain.
Another thing about Dr. Bridle’s statements that bothered me as I read them. He has conflated spike protein with lipid nanoparticles, not just once, but repeatedly. For example, in this article:
“It’s the first time ever scientists have been privy to seeing where these messenger RNA [mRNA] vaccines go after vaccination,” Bridle explained. “Is it a safe assumption that it stays in the shoulder muscle? The short answer is: absolutely not. It’s very disconcerting.”
Bridle argues that unlike traditional vaccines that stay mostly in the vaccination site at the shoulder muscle, the Japanese study showed how the spike protein of the coronavirus enters the bloodstream and circulates around the body for several days after a person gets inoculated with the vaccine.
The spike protein then accumulates in organs and tissues such as the spleen, bone marrow, liver, adrenal glands, and in “quite high concentrations” in the ovaries.
No, the Japanese biodistribution study shows nothing of the sort. It only looked at where the lipid nanoparticles go. It is true that some of experiments looked at the distribution of lipid nanoparticles containing an mRNA coding for Luciferase, a protein that exhibits bioluminescence allowing for visualization where the mRNA ended up. One interesting finding is that, after an intravenous injection, the predominant organ where the lipids in the lipid nanoparticles (ALC-0315 and ALC-0159) end up is the liver. Both lipids are eliminated rapidly from the plasma by several logs, such that by 300 hours (12.5 days) after injection very little is detectable. In the liver, however, the ALC-0315 takes around six weeks to be eliminated from the liver. One wonders, one does, why antivaxxers aren’t going ballistic about this finding. Maybe it’s because, at the peak, the amount of lipid nanoparticles detected in the liver was only 18%. Who knows? Maybe it’s because saying that lipid nanoparticles cause female infertility is more scary than saying they take a while to be eliminated from the liver.
More tellingly, though, antivaxxers are portraying the Japanese biodistribution study as though it were some sort of “secret” document. (“Confidential”! Secret!) However, it has been public for some time. It’s been publicly available for several months on the Japanese Pharmaceutical and Medical Devices Agency website, and the European Medicines Agency assessment report on the Pfizer vaccine repeatedly references results from the study.
The bottom line is that there is no evidence that the lipid nanoparticles in the Pfizer vaccine (or any of the COVID-19 vaccines) accumulate at significant quantities in the ovaries, much less cause female infertility. This new claim is nothing more than a repackaging of the previous claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause miscarriages and female infertility because of the supposed resemblance of sequences in the spike protein and the placental syncytin protein causing the immune response from the vaccine to attack syncytin, which was a repackaging of old antivaccine claims that vaccines sterilize women. Spike protein does not sufficiently resemble syncytin to cause miscarriages and infertility, and the lipid nanoparticles in the vaccines do not accumulate in the ovaries, much less cause female infertility.
In fact, this new version of the “vaccines are going to sterilize our womenfolk” disinformation leads me to conclude that just as aluminum became the new mercury as the science became clear that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in some childhood vaccines does not cause autism, lipid nanoparticles are the new polysorbate-80. Does anyone remember polysorbate-80 (also called Tween-80) or Triton X-100, detergents and emulsifiers used in some pharmaceutical products? Antivaxxers used to blame polysorbate-80 found in Gardasil for premature ovarian failure and female infertility. I first wrote about it nearly 13 years ago!
Everything old is indeed new again, with antivaxxers easily repurposing lipid nanoparticles into the role previously held by emulsifiers as the “culprits” in vaccines sterilizing women, all with a dollop of the “toxins” gambit. I can only speculate what farcical molecular “mechanism” antivaxxers will think of next to blame COVID-19 vaccines for sterilizing our womenfolk.

The latest antivax false claim: mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 are not vaccines but “medical devices” or “gene therapy”
There’s a new antivaccine talking point in town, and it’s just as much disinformation as other antivaccine talking points. It’s the claim that mRNA COVID-19 vaccines are not really vaccines but “medical devices,” “gene therapy,” or “experimental biologics” and that they were falsely classified as vaccines in order to bypass safety testing. Here, we discuss why this claim is utter nonsense based on the highly deceptive use of terminology.
David Gorski on February 8, 2021
Link

I had been debating whether to write about something other than COVID-19 this week, given how thoroughly the pandemic has come to dominate the blog (at least my contributions), to the point where it seems that I write about little else. On the other hand, there’s a topic that’s been bugging me, a niggling annoying bit of antivaccine disinformation that I keep seeing as it pops up hither, thither, and yon in antivaccine social media and on antivax websites and blogs, to the point where I finally feel as though I have to break down and address it. Such is life.
What I’m referring to is the claim that I’ve been seeing that the existing COVID-19 vaccines developed by Moderna and by Pfizer/BioNTech and currently being distributed under an emergency use authorization (EUA) by the FDA are not, in fact, really “vaccines” at all. Why? Because they are not “traditional” vaccines based on killed organism, proteins, or weakened versions of pathogenic viruses, but mRNA-based vaccines. This claim tends to take on one of two flavors. The first is that mRNA vaccines are not “vaccines” but rather “medical devices”. This one is the easiest one to dispose of which is why I will deal with it first. The second is that mRNA vaccines are not “vaccines” at all, but rather “gene therapy”, which sounds more plausible if you don’t know molecular biology but is also very much incorrect. According to antivaxxers, the consequences of mRNA vaccines being “gene therapy” are horrible complications, specifically that they will “prematurely kill large amounts of the population and disable exponentially more”.
mRNA vaccines are a medical device, not a vaccine? Nope!
I first came across the claim that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are not really vaccines at all from a very familiar antivaccine propaganda blog that I’ve followed as part of my effort to stay on top of all the latest antivaccine talking points since its very inception, Age of Autism. It comes courtesy of an antivaccine quack named Dr. Ken Stoller and was posted a couple of weeks ago to the AoA website under the title, ‘Pfizer, Moderna et al Covid Products are Medical Devices Not “Vaccines”‘.
Who is Ken Stoller? Although I couldn’t find any instance of our having written about him here, I knew who he was and did find other mentions of him. Let’s just say that he’s been antivaccine for a long time, with the first time I remember ever having encountered him being in 2006. Sadly, he is a pediatrician (and regular readers know how much contempt I have for antivaccine pediatricians like “Dr. Bob” Sears and “Dr. Paul” Thomas). He even has his own Whale.to entry! (If you don’t know what that means, let’s just say that only the most…out there…cranks get the honor of their own Whale.to entry.) Dr. Stoller also got a mention when he was investigated by the San Francisco attorney’s office for issuing “medical exemptions” based on conditions not scientifically supported as valid reasons for a medical exemption to school vaccine mandates, because, well, in the age of SB 277, the California law passed in 2015 to eliminate personal belief exemptions and other nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates, antivax grifters gonna grift. Basically, although Dr. Stoller didn’t reach the heights of antivaccine exemption grift that, say, Dr. Tara Zandvliet did (she wrote one-third of all the medical exemptions in the entire San Diego Unified School District!), but he did write a lot of dubious “exemptions.” Apparently his legal case is still going on, as his lawyer Rick Jaffe (who, I note, was Stanislaw Burzynski’s lawyer) is still soliciting funds for his legal defense, while the antivaccine doctors group Physicians for Informed Consent has been supporting him.
Basically, Dr. Stoller is into all manner of autism quackery and pseudoscience, be it vaccines as a cause of autism, hyperbaric oxygen to treat autism (Dr. Stoller loves hyperbaric oxygen treatments, or HBOT), chelation therapy, and many others. And conspiracy theories. Naturally, he believes that “They” are keeping you from learning about the evidence that vaccines cause autism and that his quackery works to reverse it.
Unfortunately (or maybe fortunately), Dr. Stoller’s claims regarding COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are rather ridiculous even on the surface:
You are not antivax if you are against the COVID-19 injections
You are not anti-vax because the COIVD injections are not vaccines.
Yes, they are being called vaccines, but this is to bypass the regulatory requirements for a medical device.
This ‘vaccine’ is actually a medical device that has never been used in humans before and rushed to market without any appreciation for what it will do either in the short term or long term.
This injection is also being called a vaccine to gain more acceptance, because most people assume that all vaccines are safe and effective. That’s what the CDC tells us. So if it is a vaccine, it must be safe and effective for ending the pandemic.
I’m sorry, but Dr. Stoller’s claim is just plain silly. You don’t get to redefine terms to suit your narrative, try as you might. I’ll explain why he’s so off-base in a minute. First, I need to let him let out sufficient rope to hang himself—or at least to hang his argument, although I can’t help but note that he makes the claim that the short term adverse event rate is 80%. I don’t know where he got that number for the overall adverse event rate, but Moderna’s reported data, for example, would seem to…contradict…that number.
Actually, it’s very clear where Dr. Stoller got that number. He looked at reports of local reaction and pain at the injection site and—well, duh!—over 80% of people reported pain or swelling at the injection site. True, that’s an “adverse event”, but it’s an adverse event that nearly all vaccines produce. Minor pain and swelling at the injection site are to be expected and are considered minor adverse events. In fact, the rate of significant or non-minor adverse events has been very low for both vaccines. None of that stops Stoller from asking disingenuously, “But if the short-term adverse event rate is 80 percent, what is in store for the long term?” Oh, I don’t know. Maybe that all those sore shoulders will get better over several days.
Let’s dive into the “core” (if you can call it that) of Stoller’s claim, which, as many antivaxxers can’t resist, he can’t help but preface by comparing COVID-19 vaccination to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, but only a “billion-fold” worse:
While this is an over simplification, a vaccine, as defined by the CDC & FDA, is procedure that introduces into the body a foreign protein or weakened virus or bacteria and activates the immune system to make antibodies to same. In theory, to be effective, those antibodies actually have to perform in a useful manner.
If it works as advertised, a vaccine gets in your body and programs itself to attack the infection should it cross your path. It has to stimulate both immunity and disrupt transmission by definition, but the COVID-19 injection does not encourage your body to program your immune system. Instead, it is the program.
This mRNA injection bypasses that step and takes over the programming of our cells to make proteins it wants to make, which presumably will stop, prevent or modulate the infection in question – in this case the COVID-19 virus.
This is, of course, utter nonsense. Yes, in general vaccines can use either protein (or protein fragments) from a pathogenic organism, be it a virus, bacteria, or other organism that provoke an immune response that can protect against the whole organism when the body encounters it. Such proteins or protein fragments that can provoke a specific immune response are known as “antigens”. (The acellular pertussis vaccine is a good example of this form of vaccine.) One other major form of “traditional” vaccines against viruses (a “live-attenuated” vaccine) uses a weakened form of the pathogenic virus that can infect your cells but cannot cause the disease that the full-strength natural (or “wild type”) form of the virus can. The measles vaccine is a good example of this latter form.
Here’s how the CDC actually does define a vaccine, a definition that is easily found on the CDC website under Immunization: The Basics:
Vaccine: A product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease. Vaccines are usually administered through needle injections, but can also be administered by mouth or sprayed into the nose.
Vaccination: The act of introducing a vaccine into the body to produce immunity to a specific disease.
Immunization: A process by which a person becomes protected against a disease through vaccination. This term is often used interchangeably with vaccination or inoculation.
And here’s the FDA’s definition of a vaccine:
Vaccines work by mimicking the infectious bacteria or viruses that cause disease. Vaccination stimulates the body’s immune system to build up defenses against the infectious bacteria or virus (organism) without causing the disease. The parts of the infectious organism that the immune system recognizes are foreign to the body and are called antigens. Vaccination exposes the body to these antigens.
Some vaccines contain weakened versions of a bacteria or virus, other vaccines contain only part of the bacteria or virus. Some vaccines contain only the genetic material for a specific protein and direct the body to produce a small amount of that protein. The body’s immune system reacts defensively once it detects this protein.
After vaccination, the immune system is prepared to respond quickly and forcefully when the body encounters the real disease-causing organism.
See what I mean? The definition of “vaccine,” be it the FDA’s or the CDC’s definition, does not require that the compound injected be a protein or a weakened virus. The definition is far more general than that, and under the definition above the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech mRNA vaccines are without a doubt, well, vaccines, as they do exactly what the CDC definition of “vaccine” states: They are products that “stimulate a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease.” The fact that they do it using a method other than simply injecting protein isolated from the pathogenic microorganism or injecting or giving by mouth a weakened form of the pathogenic microorganism is completely irrelevant. That the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines use mRNA wrapped in lipid nanoparticles to introduce mRNA coding for a the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in order to induce a person’s own cells to make that protein and thereby stimulate the immune system to react against it does not make it any less of a vaccine than an “old-fashioned” vaccine like the whole-cell pertussis vaccine, which basically used killed whole bacteria.
To be honest, I feel kind of silly even having to explain this here on SBM, but I keep seeing this talking point, whether it comes from Dr. Stoller or is a variant of the same talking point showing up elsewhere in the antivaccine griftosophere. Worse, Dr. Stoller seems very confused. In brief, he can’t seem to make up his mind whether the current mRNA COVID-19 vaccines are a “medical device” or a “gene therapy” (or even just a “treatment”, rather than a vaccine). I’ll use his confusion as an introduction to the next section and an explanation of why the “gene therapy” trope is just that, a trope, as I pivot to an article by über-quack “natural health entrepreneur” Dr. Joe Mercola entitled “How COVID-19 ‘Vaccines’ May Destroy the Lives of Millions“. Before I do, though, I can’t help but suggest that COVID-19 vaccines will “destroy” those lives by preventing people from catching a potentially deadly disease that’s currently spreading like wildfire through a mostly immunologically-naïve population.
I also can’t help but address Dr. Stoller’s conclusion:
In truth this is a medical device, and it should undergo the safety evaluations any medical device needs to undergo.
Seriously, this is most definitely not what Dr. Stoller wants, and it’s clear that he has no clue about medical device regulation. Dr. Stoller is either unaware or lying about the longstanding problem that the approval process for medical devices is much more lax than it is for drugs, vaccines, and biologics. Indeed, this is such an issue that problems with the laxness in the standards for medical device approval have made the news rather frequently over the last few years. (Books have been written about this problem.) That’s because medical devices are regulated under a different law than drugs, vaccines, or biologics:
Devices are subject to weaker standards than drugs because they’re regulated under a different law. The Medical Device Amendments of 1976 was intended to encourage innovation while allowing for a range of review standards based on risk, according to legal expert Richard A. Merrill. An array of corporate lobbying has since prompted Congress to ease regulations and make it easier for devices to get the FDA’s OK (here’s one 2015 example).
Seriously, as conspiracy theories go, Dr. Stoller’s is even dumber than usual, particularly given how he seems to conflate gene therapy with biologics with medical devices.
COVID-19: A “gene therapy”? (Betteridge’s law of headlines applies)
Before I deal with Mercola, let me first conclude my discussion of Dr. Stoller’s rather clueless confusion. First, Dr. Stoller makes a simple, “Well, duh!” observation but frames it in such a manner as to make it seem terrifying if you don’t know molecular biology:
This mRNA injection bypasses that step and takes over the programming of our cells to make proteins it wants to make, which presumably will stop, prevent or modulate the infection in question – in this case the COVID-19 virus.
Yes, that is how mRNA vaccines work—sort of. mRNA vaccines do introduce a specific mRNA coding for the desired protein antigen into the recipient’s muscle cells; that much is true. The mRNA then serves as a template for the cell’s ribosomes to make that protein; that much is also true. I’ll also add here that there are other ways of achieving this same result, inducing the vaccine recipient’s own cells to make antigen. Putting the cDNA (the DNA with the gene for a protein) coding for the desired protein antigen in an adenovirus vector that can’t replicate is another method. (Indeed, that’s how the COVID-19 vaccine candidates from Johnson & Johnson and AstraZeneca work.)
Note, though, how Dr. Stoller, in his effort to portray mRNA vaccines as “therapy” (specifically a “gene therapy”), obfuscates by saying that the recombinant proteins made by the vaccines “presumably” will “stop, prevent or modulate the infection in question”. First, there’s no “presumably” about it; the mRNA vaccines work. Second, the goal is to prevent severe disease from the infection by provoking an immune response and providing “immune memory”, so that the immune system, when encountering SARS-CoV-2 again, will be able to rapidly ramp up a response to shut the virus down before it can cause disease. That’s how all vaccines designed to prevent viral diseases work! There’s nothing special about the COVID-19 vaccines in that aspect, Dr. Stoller’s risibly feverish effort to suggest otherwise notwithstanding. Note further how he tries to redefine prevention as “treatment”:
In actuality, all the COVID-19 injection does is provide a treatment to supposedly modulate the severity of the COVID-19 illness should you get it and become symptomatic.
In other words, it is a treatment – a genetic treatment that has never been used in humans before.
And if it is only a treatment that neither prevents infection nor transmission, in truth, it is no better than any of the other treatments floating around like Ivermection/Zinc/Vit D/HCQ/Vit C/ HBOT/ozone, etc.
Note the false equivalence. It is true that vaccines can be “treatments”. The rabies vaccine is a good example, as are various experimental vaccines against a variety of cancers. However, such vaccines are also preventatives. The rabies vaccine, when given before exposure to rabies, is prevention; when given after, it can be treatment designed to ramp up the immune system before the virus can take hold. Dr. Stoller is either ignorant of that distinction or cynically misrepresenting it because he knows that his antivax and COVID-19-denying followers don’t understand or know about it. (Take your pick.) More amusing to me is how he compares it to a variety of quack or unproven treatments for COVID-19, in order to downplay it. Wait, what? Don’t COVID-19 quacks think that all (or at least several) of the treatments disparaged by Dr. Stoller are very effective against COVID-19? It’s also odd that he didn’t mention dexamethasone, which is one treatment for COVID-19 that has been validated in randomized clinical trials, unlike the rest that he mentioned.
Or maybe not:
We do know that there are other treatments and if this were just called a ‘treatment’ people would ask how it stacks up to the other available treatments.
I would argue it is not even a biologic because it is so clearly gene manipulation – direct gene manipulation – something that has never ever taken place before in the history of mankind.
The problem with Dr. Stoller’s claim is that the mRNA vaccines are indeed vaccines by any reasonable definition. But what about “biologics”? According to the FDA, biologics “include a wide range of products such as vaccines, blood and blood components, allergenics, somatic cells, gene therapy, tissues, and recombinant therapeutic proteins.” Under that definition, sure, the mRNA vaccines are considered biologics, but so what? That doesn’t make them any less vaccines, as biologics can be vaccines; in fact, vaccines are, by definition, a form of biologic because they either contain biologic material (killed virus or bacteria, weakened virus, etc.) or, in the case of mRNA vaccines, recombinant nucleic acids designed to make protein. Dr. Stoller is again either ignorant or showing contempt for his reader. As for “gene manipulation”? Do I really have to get into that again? I guess I do, but I’ll wait until I deal with one last aspect of Stoller’s little rant, namely how Dr. Stoller sees conspiracies everywhere:
Obviously the COVID-19 injection is the treatment the so-called experts want you to have because not only are they so invested in it for economic and political reasons, but because it allows them to exercise even more control over the population, which is what this has been all about anyway.
I’m surprised he didn’t mention microchips in the vaccine, 5G, and Bill Gates, but whatever. I commend him for his restraint.
Unfortunately, a much louder voice is amplifying the same conspiracy theory, namely Joe Mercola. To do that, he cites Judy Mikovits. Does anyone remember Judy Mikovits? She was all the rage in COVID-19 conspiracy circles in May (which in the course of the COVID-19 pandemic seems like ancient history now) with her “plandemic” conspiracy theory that claimed that the pandemic was planned. That’s not a great look, but Mikovits does have a PhD and used to be a scientist; so that makes it easy for Mercola to portray her as an expert when in fact she is a pseudoexpert:
The COVID-19 vaccine really isn’t a vaccine in the medical definition of a vaccine. It does not improve your immune response to the infection, nor does not limit you from getting the infection. It’s really an experimental gene therapy that could prematurely kill large amounts of the population and disable exponentially more.
“I’m just beside myself with anger over this synthetic gene therapy, this chemical poison, and what they’re doing worldwide,” Mikovits says. “We’re already seeing deaths from this shot. It’s illegal. It shouldn’t be done. It should be stopped right now. It should have never been allowed to happen, yet we see it being forced on the most vulnerable populations.”
Indeed, news and social media reports suggest recipients are starting to drop like flies. Many die of unknown causes within days, sometimes hours of getting the first or second shot.
I won’t go into the bit about “dropping like flies” other than to point you to my previous discussions of how, when tens of millions of people are vaccinated in a short period of time, the law of large numbers dictates that there will deaths and bad things that happen to some of them unrelated to the vaccine by random chance alone and that the only way to tell if such events might be related to the vaccine include epidemiology to determine if there is an increase of such adverse reactions above the expected baseline and careful scientific investigation. Antivaxxers, of course, automatically assume that any death within a month of vaccination against COVID-19 must have been caused by the vaccine.
Mercola adds to the misinformation spread by Stoller by mischaracterizing the mRNA vaccines. First, he goes out of his way to portray them as “artificial” and “unnatural”:
The messenger RNA (mRNA) used in many COVID-19 vaccines are not natural. They’re synthetic. Since naturally produced mRNA rapidly degrades, it must be complexed with lipids or polymers to prevent this from happening. COVID-19 vaccines use PEGylated lipid nanoparticles, and PEG is known to cause anaphylaxis. Lipid nanoparticles may also cause other problems.
And:
However, if they call their drugs vaccines, they can bypass the safety studies. All of a sudden, they expect us to believe that all of these safety issues have been resolved? Another problem is related to how long the mRNA remains stable in your system. It’s encased in nanolipid to prevent it from degrading too rapidly, but what happens if the mRNA degrades too slowly, or not at all?
The idea behind mRNA vaccines is that by tricking your body into creating the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, your immune system will produce antibodies in response. But what happens when you turn your body into a viral protein factory, thus keeping antibody production activated on a continual basis with no ability to shut down?
And:
So, just how long will the synthetic RNA in COVID-19 vaccines be maintained within your body, causing your cells to produce this aberrant protein? Mikovits believes it will escape degradation for months, years, maybe even for life in some cases.
No, no, no, no, no!
Let’s start with the same talking point used by Stoller and parroted by Mercola, the claim that Moderna and Pfizer called their products “vaccines” in order to “bypass safety studies”? This is, quite simply, a lie. (I’m assuming that Mercola is not so ignorant or stupid not to know that what he is saying is incorrect, but I suppose I do have to concede the possibility that I’m giving him too much credit. Basically, he’s either ignorant or a liar. Judge for yourself and take your pick.) It is, of course, true that neither vaccine has obtained full FDA approval yet, having been allowed by the FDA to be distributed under an EUA because of the emergency of the pandemic, but it is not true that either vaccine “bypassed safety studies”. I mean, seriously: There were over 70,000 subjects in the phase 3 studies of the two vaccines that led to their approval under an EUA, producing scads and scads of safety data. Post-EUA pharmacovigilance monitoring of these vaccines is unprecedented in its intensity.
But what about the “synthetic” mRNA? Yes, the mRNA in both vaccines is indeed chemically modified. The reasons are simple, as I discussed before in my usual ridiculous level of detail. First, RNA is unstable, as Mercola mentioned. In regular aqueous solution (in this case, water with some buffer and salt) RNA rapidly degrades at room temperature (or even in the refrigerator) and can degrade too quickly even at -20°C. The second, and more important, reason is that mRNA has a short half-life in cells, normally on the order of hours or even minutes. (I used to measure mRNA half-life for the gene I cloned back in the 1990s, and it was regulated by stimuli that dramatically shortened or lengthened its half-life in the cell from four hours to around an hour hour.) Basically, the modification of the RNA in both vaccines is designed to make them more stable, but not infinitely stable, which is what Mikovits and Mercola are claiming. No biological molecule, modified or not, lasts forever, which is what the RNA would have to do to “turn your body into a viral protein factory, thus keeping antibody production activated on a continual basis with no ability to shut down”. Seriously, does Mercola know anything about molecular biology? Indeed, from Moderna, for example:
The delivered mRNA does not enter the cell nucleus or interact with the genome, is nonreplicating, and is expressed transiently. The estimated half-life for mRNA after injection is approximately 8 to 10 hours, before degradation by native RNases in the body, but the duration of effect also depends on the half-life of the expressed protein, which persists in the body for several days. mRNA vaccines have been used to induce immune responses against infectious pathogens such as cytomegalovirus (CMV), human metapneumovirus (hMPV) and parainfluenza virus type 3 (PIV3), Zika, and influenza virus.
Basically, with a half-life of ten hours, the mRNA will be completely gone within a few days and the protein completely gone after, at most, a few weeks. The Pfizer mRNA vaccine is similar. Again, does Mercola understand anything about basic molecular biology? Apparently not, or he’s lying.
Meanwhile, Mikovits adds to the deceptive fear mongering claiming that the mRNA vaccines are “permanent genetic alteration”:
So, taking a synthetic messenger RNA and making it thermostable — making it not break down — [is problematic]. We have lots of enzymes (RNAses and DNAses) that degrade free RNA and DNA because, again, those are danger signals to your immune system. They literally drive inflammatory diseases.
Now you’ve got PEG, PEGylated and polyethylene glycol, and a lipid nanoparticle that will allow it to enter every cell of the body and change the regulation of our own genes with this synthetic RNA, part of which actually is the message for the gene syncytin …
Syncytin is the endogenous gammaretrovirus envelope that’s encoded in the human genome … We know that if syncytin … is expressed aberrantly in the body, for instance in the brain, which these lipid nanoparticles will go into, then you’ve got multiple sclerosis.
The expression of that gene alone enrages microglia, literally inflames and dysregulates the communication between the brain microglia, which are critical for clearing toxins and pathogens in the brain and the communication with astrocytes.
And:
Making matters worse, the synthetic mRNA also has an HIV envelope expressed in it, which can cause immune dysregulation. “This is a nightmare,” Mikovits says. “I’m angry, as this should never be allowed.”
As we discussed in previous interviews, SARS-CoV-2 has been engineered in the lab with gain-of-function research that included introducing the HIV envelope into the spike protein.
Note that truly ignorant claim again about syncytin. I dealt with that one once before when I discussed why, contrary to antivaccine fear mongering, COVID-19 mRNA vaccines will not render women infertile. The Cliffs Notes version is that the mRNA for the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein used in these vaccines does not make a protein with amino acid sequences sufficiently similar to sequences in syncytin to provoke a crossreacting immune response to syncytin that could render women infertile or do any of the things claimed by Mikovits. Moreover, the claim that sequences from the gene encoding the HIV-1 envelope protein are in the COVID-19 spike protein is an antivax distortion. Basically, the amino acid sequences in the spike protein that antivaxxers call “HIV-1 envelope sequences” are in fact amino acid sequences so short that they are commonly found in many proteins, as I discussed a while back. mRNA vaccines making spike protein are not going to lead to “immune dysregulation” due “HIV-1 envelope” because it doesn’t express HIV-1 envelope. One wonders how Mikovits ever managed to do science back in the day before she became a conspiracy theorist and crank.
Then, of course, because antivaxxers will always go for the “toxins” gambit, Mercola and Mikovits are so very, very concerned about the polyethylene glycol (PEG) in the lipid nanoparticles that envelope the mRNA used in the vaccines:
Another common side effect from the vaccine we’re seeing is allergic reactions, including anaphylactic shock. A likely culprit in this is PEG, which an estimated 70% of Americans are allergic to. “These instantaneous effects are almost certainly the PEG and that lipid nano particle, the toxic particle that’s being injected,” Mikovits says.
In the longer term, she suspects we’ll see a significant uptick in migraines, tics, Parkinson’s disease, microvascular disorders, different cancers, including prostate cancer, severe pain syndromes like fibromyalgia and rheumatoid arthritis, bladder problems, kidney disease, psychosis, neurodegenerative diseases such as Lou Gehrig’s disease (ALS) and sleep disorders, including narcolepsy. In young children, autism-like symptoms are likely to develop as well, she thinks.
Yes, although PEG hasn’t been used in an approved vaccine before, it has for a long time been used in a number of products, including toothpastes, shampoos, and some drugs with a good safety record. Indeed, the claim above that 70% of Americans are allergic to PEG is utter BS on its surface because if that were true allergists would be swamped with a tsunami of patients with allergic reactions to a wide variety of common household products. It is true that PEG has come under suspicion as a possible cause of the small number of anaphylactic reactions observed after COVID-19 vaccination, as a recent report in Science notes:
Severe allergy-like reactions in at least eight people who received the COVID-19 vaccine produced by Pfizer and BioNTech over the past 2 weeks may be due to a compound in the packaging of the messenger RNA (mRNA) that forms the vaccine’s main ingredient, scientists say. A similar mRNA vaccine developed by Moderna, which was authorized for emergency use in the United States on Friday, also contains the compound, polyethylene glycol (PEG).
PEG has never been used before in an approved vaccine, but it is found in many drugs that have occasionally triggered anaphylaxis—a potentially life-threatening reaction that can cause rashes, a plummeting blood pressure, shortness of breath, and a fast heartbeat. Some allergists and immunologists believe a small number of people previously exposed to PEG may have high levels of antibodies against PEG, putting them at risk of an anaphylactic reaction to the vaccine.
Others are skeptical of the link. Still, the U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) was concerned enough to convene several meetings last week to discuss the allergic reactions with representatives of Pfizer and Moderna, independent scientists and physicians, and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
NIAID is also setting up a study in collaboration with FDA to analyze the response to the vaccine in people who have high levels of anti-PEG antibodies or have experienced severe allergic responses to drugs or vaccines before.
A report published ten days ago by the CDC notes:
During December 21, 2020–January 10, 2021, monitoring by the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System detected 10 cases of anaphylaxis after administration of a reported 4,041,396 first doses of Moderna COVID-19 vaccine (2.5 cases per million doses administered). In nine cases, onset occurred within 15 minutes of vaccination. No anaphylaxis-related deaths were reported.
And two weeks before that the CDC reported:
During December 14–23, 2020, monitoring by the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System detected 21 cases of anaphylaxis after administration of a reported 1,893,360 first doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine (11.1 cases per million doses); 71% of these occurred within 15 minutes of vaccination.
In other words, these reactions are rare, managed relatively easily, and not outside the range of what is normally observed after other, older vaccines. Moreover, the risk of anaphylaxis from the vaccine, which hasn’t killed anyone, is certainly far, far smaller than the risk of death from COVID-19, which has already killed over 450,000 people or 130/100,000 people in the US in just one year and hospitalized millions, or 417/100,000 people since the beginning of the pandemic.
As for the central claim of Mercola and Mikovits that these vaccines are “permanent genetic alterations” that “may last for life,” I will refer you back to what I wrote long ago about that claim showing why the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines will not “permanently alter your DNA“. Again, anyone who’s ever taken Molecular Biology 101 will understand why this is the case, but apparently Joe Mercola and Judy Mikovits either did not or are lying. Again, read their words and take your pick.
Nor are these vaccines “gene therapy”. According to the FDA:
Gene therapy is a technique that modifies a person’s genes to treat or cure disease. Gene therapies can work by several mechanisms:
    • Replacing a disease-causing gene with a healthy copy of the gene
    • Inactivating a disease-causing gene that is not functioning properly
    • Introducing a new or modified gene into the body to help treat a disease
Gene therapy products are being studied to treat diseases including cancer, genetic diseases, and infectious diseases.
And the types of gene therapy:
    • Plasmid DNA: Circular DNA molecules can be genetically engineered to carry therapeutic genes into human cells.
    • Viral vectors: Viruses have a natural ability to deliver genetic material into cells, and therefore some gene therapy products are derived from viruses. Once viruses have been modified to remove their ability to cause infectious disease, these modified viruses can be used as vectors (vehicles) to carry therapeutic genes into human cells.
    • Bacterial vectors: Bacteria can be modified to prevent them from causing infectious disease and then used as vectors (vehicles) to carry therapeutic genes into human tissues.
    • Human gene editing technology: The goals of gene editing are to disrupt harmful genes or to repair mutated genes.
    • Patient-derived cellular gene therapy products: Cells are removed from the patient, genetically modified (often using a viral vector) and then returned to the patient.
Oh, dear. mRNA is not any of those. The not-so-dynamic duo might make a better case that the J&J or AstraZeneca vaccines are “gene therapy”, but so what? Those vaccines will not “permanently alter” the DNA of the recipients’ cells either.
The bottom line is that grifting antivaxxers like Ken Stoller, Joe Mercola, and Judy Mikovits are using claims about COVID-19 vaccines that are grossly incorrect or obviously deceptive to spread fear and doubt about COVID-19 vaccines in the middle of a pandemic by combining new disinformation about COVID-19 vaccines with very old antivaccine tropes (i.e., false claims that vaccines will “permanently alter your DNA,” cause autoimmune disease, render women infertile, or in other ways be more dangerous than the disease) in order to frighten people. In doing so, they have blood on their hands because for every 100 people whom they frighten out of vaccinating and who as a result contract COVID-19, it’s likely that there will be one death.
ADDENDUM:
Unsurprisingly, the onslaught still continues today, except that in this case Vaxxter, the house organ of Barbara Loe Fisher’s hoary antivaccine organization with an Orwellian name—the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC)—published an article entitled Moderna, Pfizer Test mRNA Experimental Biologics on Children, because calling the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines “experimental biologics” and raising the specter of “experimentation” on children are so much scarier than referring to it as testing COVID-19 vaccines in children.

Lipid nanoparticles in COVID-19 vaccines: The new mercury to antivaxxers
When it comes to antivaccine misinformation and the COVID-19 pandemic, everything old is new again, at least if you haven’t been paying attention. This time around, it’s the resurrection of an old favorite antivaccine trope, the “toxins” gambit. Truly, lipid nanoparticles are the new mercury.
David Gorski on February 15, 2021
Link

I was recently interviewed by a local reporter regarding COVID-19 vaccination. Although I don’t know if anything I said will end up in the final story as published, one thing I thought worth recounting is something that I told her when she asked me if there was anything else I wanted to emphasize that hadn’t been covered. My response? I told her that, when it comes to the antivaccine movement, there is nothing new under the sun and that none of its propaganda and disinformation about COVID-19 vaccines is new. It’s the same old antivaccine misinformation, tropes, misrepresentations of science, and propaganda, just repackaged for COVID-19 vaccines. I’ve already written about a number of examples. The most frequently used example thus far has been to weaponize anecdotes of death after the vaccine that likely had nothing to do with the vaccine, much as, pre-pandemic, antivaxxers had weaponized anecdotes of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) after vaccination, all to demonize vaccines. Other examples include claiming that vaccines cause female infertility; that they “damage” or “alter” your DNA, or that COVID-19 is not dangerous (or isn’t even real at all) in much the same way antivaxxers used to claim that measles and other vaccine-preventable diseases aren’t dangerous (the implication being that vaccines are unnecessary). Then, of course, there is the ever-popular strategy of fear mongering about reports made to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) database, implying that they indicate causation. All techniques antivaxxers used extensively pre-pandemic. So it should be no surprise that antivaxxers are also using a variant of a longtime favorite trope, the “toxins gambit“, the claim that vaccines are loaded with horrible “toxins“, a variant being the claim that vaccines have “fetal cells” or “fetal DNA” in them and are thus horrifically contaminated. Heck, that last one has even been used by antivaxxers about COVID-19 vaccines!
Which brings me to lipid nanoparticles, which appear to be the new mercury in vaccines to antivaxxers.
Unsurprisingly, after having tried to misrepresent the mRNA-based vaccines developed and marketed by Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech as “gene therapy” or something that will corrupt your DNA, it’s no surprise that antivaxxers are now resurrecting a version of the “toxins gambit” to use against these same vaccines and that the target of the gambit are the lipid nanoparticles in the vaccines. Unsurprisingly, über-quack Joe Mercola last week decided to do what he does so frequently and summarize the latest COVID-19 conspiracy theories, this time the “toxins gambit” applied to the lipid nanoparticles, in the form of an article entitled “How Safe Are the Nanoparticles in Moderna’s Vaccine?” And Joe Mercola isn’t the only quack trying to demonize lipid nanoparticles.
A refresher on mRNA vaccines
I briefly discussed lipid nanoparticles when I discussed the antivaccine lie that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines will “alter” or “reprogram” your DNA. Even though we’ve discussed it several times, it’s worth discussing again how mRNA vaccines, such as those made by Moderna or Pfizer/BioNTech work, so that you don’t have to click on a lot of links. I’ll start with the basic idea.
The proteins and enzymes that make up cells and organisms are genetically encoded in DNA. DNA is made up of smaller building blocks called nucleotides attached to each other in a linear fashion and packaged in a double helix of two complementary strands wrapped around each other. Proteins are also made up of smaller building blocks, in this case amino acids. The genetic code translates nucleotide sequences into amino acid sequences, with a three nucleotide “word” (codon) specifying a specific amino acid. For purposes of this discussion, the details don’t matter, other than to understand that there is an intermediary between DNA and protein, and that intermediary is RNA. Messenger RNA (mRNA) is synthesized based on the DNA template in the nucleus, transported out of the nucleus, and then set upon by large protein complexes known as ribosomes, which build proteins based on the sequence encoded by the mRNA. The process is a bit more complex than that (for example, the initial RNA synthesized is often spliced into a shorter RNA before being translated into protein, and proteins often have modifications made after their synthesis), but these are the basics.
mRNA vaccines take advantage of this process. Traditional vaccines use killed pathogenic organisms or whole or fragments of proteins from the organism as antigens to provoke an immune response. The problem with this method is that it’s a lot more involved and time-consuming to manufacture the proteins or to grow up the organism then inactivate it to use in vaccines. There are many theoretical advantages to using mRNA instead. For one thing, it’s a lot easier to make large quantities of RNA than it is to make large quantities of protein. For another thing, if a new version of a vaccine is needed, it’s not difficult to just change the sequence of the RNA without altering the rest of the formulation, something that will likely become very important as the need arises to make new vaccines to combat the various variants of SARS-CoV-2 that are cropping up and might eventually evade the vaccine-based immunity. In brief, there’s a lot of advantage to using the recipient’s cells’ own machinery to manufacture the protein used as an antigen to provoke an immune response. In the case of the COVID-19 vaccine, both the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech versions of the vaccine use the mRNA encoding the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, the protein that the virus uses to get into cells.
There are, of course, problems to be overcome with mRNA vaccines. One is that RNA is unstable in aqueous solution, which is why the RNAs used are modified to make them more stable and also why the vaccines need to be stored at such ultralow temperatures, a characteristic that complicated the rollout because many sites didn’t have -80°C freezers to store the vaccines and such freezers cost thousands of dollars. (The -80°C freezer in my lab cost close to $10,000.) The other problem is getting the mRNA into the cells. That’s where the lipid nanoparticles come in.
Lipid nanoparticles
Lipid nanoparticles are small spherical particles made of lipids into which various “payloads” (in the case of the COVID-19 vaccines, mRNA encoding the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein) can be introduced. These particles are generally less than 100 nm in diameter and made up of—you guessed it—lipids. But what are lipids? Basically, mammalian cell membranes are made of phospholipids. Each lipid molecule in the membrane has two ends, a “head” and two tails. The “head” contains an ionic phosphate group that has affinity towards water and ions, while the two tails are long stretches of hydrocarbon molecule (just carbon and hydrogen) and is hydrophobic (insoluble in water). These molecules are referred to as amphiphilic (from the Greek αμφις, amphis: both and φιλíα, philia: love, friendship), having affinity for both water and hydrocarbons. Many molecules are amphiphilic, including detergents and soaps.

Molecules like this can form two kinds of structures, micelles or liposomes. In cells, these amphiphilic phospholipids form a two-layered structure, with the hydrophilic heads facing the aqueous solution and the two-tailed hydrophobic structures facing each other. These bilayers can form spheres, as illustrated below:


As a pseudonymous pharmaceutical scientist wrote:
If you have been preparing salad dressing with vegetable oil and vinegar, you likely notice that the oil droplets would aggregate together into one big slick, whereas you will notice a clear interface between the vinegar and the oil slick. This is because the lipids present in the vegetable oil will align their hydrophobic tails inside the droplet and expose their hydrophilic head outside to interact with the water molecules of the vinegar. This is what we call “micelles”. If you work hard enough, you can create structures called “liposomes” that are able to cage water and solutes within the oil slick, separating from the rest of the water of the vinegar by having a lipid layer.
Liposomes, when used for drug delivery, look like this representation:
So why use liposomes? In general, the reason to use liposomes to deliver drugs is to get a hydrophilic (water-loving, water-soluble) molecule through the lipid bilayer that makes up a cell and into the cell’s cytoplasm. mRNA, it turns out, is hydrophilic and easily dissolved in aqueous solution; so naturally when scientists started trying to use mRNA in vaccines a couple of decades ago liposomes were a natural choice as the delivery vehicle to get the mRNA to the cells. And, as I’ve alluded to before, antivaxxers are keen to blame all sorts of bad things on lipid nanoparticles. It’s basically a variant of the “toxins gambit” in which lipid nanoparticles are portrayed as being something potentially toxic and deadly.
Mercola and false comparisons
Now that I’ve briefly recounted what lipid nanoparticles are and why they’re used in the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccines, let’s take a look at the antivaccine disinformaton about them being spread by Joe Mercola:
Moderna and Pfizer are using lipid nanoparticles that contain polyethylene glycol (PEG)2 for this purpose. The mRNA is wrapped in lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) that carry it to your cells, and the LNPs are “PEGylated” — that is, chemically attached to PEG molecules to increase stability.
This experimental mRNA gene therapy and its lipid nanoparticle-based delivery system have never been approved for use in a vaccine or drug. This includes Pfizer’s and Moderna’s COVID-19 vaccines, which were only “authorized” for emergency use by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration — not “approved.”
Significant concerns have been raised over the technology, including the lipid nanoparticles, and Moderna actually abandoned it in 2017 after studies revealed a high rate of adverse effects.
That certainly sounds…ominous. Or does it? One of the references cited by Mercola is, unsurprisingly, an article published on Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s antivaccine website Children’s Health Defense, in which RFK Jr. quoted a statement by Moderna:
[T]here can be no assurance that our LNPs will not have undesired effects. Our LNPs could contribute, in whole or in part, to one or more of the following: immune reactions, infusion reactions, complement reactions, opsonation reactions, antibody reactions . . . or reactions to the PEG from some lipids or PEG otherwise associated with the LNP. Certain aspects of our investigational medicines may induce immune reactions from either the mRNA or the lipid as well as adverse reactions within liver pathways or degradation of the mRNA or the LNP, any of which could lead to significant adverse events in one or more of our clinical trials.
This SEC report was dated November 2018. I also note that this is the sort of cautious statement that any scientist would make before a treatment is actually tested in patients. The difference now is that lipid nanoparticles have now been received by tens of millions of patients without significant adverse events.
I also can’t help but note how Mercola is parroting what is seemingly the accepted antivaccine talking point, specifically referring to the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech mRNA-based vaccines as “experimental gene therapy”. No, it’s not gene therapy, and, after 70K+ subjects in the clinical trials leading to the FDA’s emergency use authorization (EUA), it’s no longer anything resembling “experimental.” These are just scare words used by the antivaccine movement to invoke doubt and fear regarding these vaccines.
Next up, let’s compare apples to oranges, Joe:
In 2016, Bancel had talked up another of the company’s up-and-coming products, a drug treatment for a rare disease called Crigler-Najjar syndrome. Those with Crigler-Najjar syndrome are missing a liver enzyme needed to break down bilirubin. Moderna’s experimental treatment used mRNA to encode for the missing enzyme, and was encased in LNPs as the delivery agent.
But, as STAT reported in 2017, the treatment was “indefinitely delayed” because it “never proved safe enough to test in humans.” According to STAT:
“… mRNA is a tricky technology. Several major pharmaceutical companies have tried and abandoned the idea, struggling to get mRNA into cells without triggering nasty side effects … The indefinite delay on the Crigler-Najjar project signals persistent and troubling safety concerns for any mRNA treatment that needs to be delivered in multiple doses …
… And for its chemists, those nanoparticles created a daunting challenge: Dose too little, and you don’t get enough enzyme to affect the disease; dose too much, and the drug is too toxic for patients … Moderna could not make its therapy work, former employees and collaborators said. The safe dose was too weak, and repeat injections of a dose strong enough to be effective had troubling effects on the liver in animal studies.”
Let’s look at what the STAT article cited also said. Remember that this article was published three years before the COVID-19 pandemic:
But the Crigler-Najjar treatment has been indefinitely delayed, an Alexion spokeswoman told STAT. It never proved safe enough to test in humans, according to several former Moderna employees and collaborators who worked closely on the project. Unable to press forward with that technology, Moderna has had to focus instead on developing a handful of vaccines, turning to a less lucrative field that might not justify the company’s nearly $5 billion valuation.
“It’s all vaccines right now, and vaccines are a loss-leader,” said one former Moderna manager. “Moderna right now is a multibillion-dollar vaccines company, and I don’t see how that holds up.”
Funny how Mercola didn’t mention this article’s implication that vaccines were not particularly profitable. After all, one of the primary false messages of antivaccine conspiracy theories is that it’s all about the money because vaccines are so insanely profitable.
Of course, comparing vaccines to gene therapy treatments for Crigler-Najjar syndrome is also deceptive. The reason is simple. Replacing an enzyme involved in a critical biochemical process is not the same thing as a vaccine. The targeting isn’t the same in terms of which cells need to produce the protein encoded by the mRNA, and vaccines don’t need nearly the same level of precision when it comes to the amount of protein produced. To be an effective vaccine, all that’s necessary is that there should be a sufficient amount of the protein being used as an antigen to provoke an immune response to “get the attention” of the immune system. The margin for error in reporting an enzyme that is lacking is far less forgiving than the margin for error in producing a protein as an antigen for a vaccine.
But the brain!
Then, of course, there’s the old antivaccine trick of claiming that vaccines cause “neuroinflammation.” First, however:
The mRNA vaccine triggers your body to produce antibodies against the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, and spike proteins in turn contain syncytin-homologous proteins that are essential for various functions in your body, including the formation of the placenta in pregnant women.
“Syncytin is the name given to the endogenous gamma retrovirus envelope,” Mikovits said, “and we know if it’s expressed overtly in the body in different places … for instance, in the brain, where these lipid nanoparticles will go, then you’ve got multiple sclerosis.”
Remember how I said that I wouldn’t just repeat a debunking of an antivaccine trope? I lied, sort of. The whole “syncytin” thing is merely a repackaging of the antivaccine claim that vaccines will make our women sterile. It’s nonsense.
Then there’s this:
The study’s authors suggested lipid nanoparticles like those in COVID-19 vaccines may be ideal for drug delivery systems because of their ability to bypass the blood brain barrier and “reach the target site due to their small size and ability to dodge the reticular endothelial system.”
I recently interviewed Judy Mikovits, Ph.D., a cellular and molecular biologist, and she agreed that LNPs can enter the brain and contribute to pathologic neuroinflammation, possibly leading to adverse effects like multiple sclerosis or ALS. Additionally, these LNPs carrying the mRNA last for long periods of time, forcing your cells to continuously produce the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. I encourage you to review my article and interview with Judy.
First off, no. Just no. As I discussed the last time I covered this topic, the mRNA molecules used by these vaccines don’t last long. They just don’t. Moreover, this is yet another example of antivaxxers trying to claim that vaccines cause “neuroinflammation,” no matter how tortured the rationale they have to use to do it.
Then there’s the dreaded PEG:
At least eight people have also had severe allergy-like reactions to Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine, prompting NIAID to convene several meetings to discuss the adverse events with officials from Pfizer and Moderna, along with the FDA and independent scientists.
Many suspect the PEG found in both Pfizer’s and Moderna’s vaccines might be the culprit causing allergic reactions and anaphylaxis. PEG has never been used in an approved vaccine, but is used in certain drugs known to cause anaphylaxis. According to Robert F. Kennedy Jr., “studies show that 1 in 7 Americans may unknowingly be at risk of experiencing an allergic reaction to PEG.”
He believes “everyone should be screened for anti-PEG antibodies before getting the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines,” adding that “It is unconscionable that, instead, the FDA and CDC are encouraging people to go ahead and risk a life-threatening anaphylactic reaction and just assume that someone will be on hand to save them.”
Too bad for antivaxxers that a recent study found that anaphylactic reactions to COVID-19 vaccines are rare, 4.7 cases/million doses for the Pfizer vaccine and 2.5 cases/million doses for the Moderna vaccine, well within the range seen for other vaccines and very uncommon, with no deaths reported.
“Toxins” here, “toxins” there, “toxins” everywhere, especially in vaccines
Certain antivaccine canards never die, no matter how many stakes you stick through their heart or how many silver bullets you shoot them with or how many headshots you’ve pumped into them (depending on whether your favorite metaphor is a vampire, werewolf, or zombie, of course). One such canard is what I like to call the “toxins gambit”. Over the years, we’ve seen it used by such antivaccine “luminaries” as Jenny McCarthy and many other antivaxxers. Basically, it consists of listing all sorts of scary-sounding ingredients that are found in vaccines and then trying to argue that vaccines are horrific cesspits of toxins because they contain trace amounts of formaldehyde, for example. It’s a truly stupid, brain dead gambit, but no matter how many times it’s slapped down, there will always be some ignorant antivaccinationist who will resurrect it. (It’s like a lot of antivaccine misinformation that way, actually, but even more so.)
Because the “toxins gambit” is such hoary old bit of antivaccine misinformation, it should surprise no one that it’s been resurrected, much like slashers like Jason, who, after seemingly having been killed at the end of the last movie, always find a way to come back to kill again in the next. Demonizing lipid nanoparticles in the most recent crop of vaccines is just its latest iteration.

The “deadly” coronavirus spike protein (according to antivaxxers)
Antivaxxers are citing three papers to support their claim that spike protein produced by COVID-19 vaccines is dangerous. Unsurprisingly and as usual, they’re misinterpreting the studies and misrepresenting their significance. COVID-19 vaccines are, in fact, very safe.
David Gorski on May 24, 2021
Link
Specific narratives of antivaccine misinformation about any given vaccine generally consist of a combination of a subset (or all) of the following elements. First, of course, the narrative must, as all antivaccine narratives do, include a conspiracy theory, such as efforts by “them” (e.g., the government, big pharma) are trying to keep “The Truth” about vaccines from the public. Second, that “truth” about the vaccine, according to antivaccine narratives, is that it is dangerous—and preferably ineffective as well. Examples are numerous, and regular readers of this blog are familiar with the harms that antivaxxers falsely attribute to vaccines; e.g., autism, autoimmune diseases, cancer, and even death. To support the narrative of harm from vaccines, antivaxxers routinely portray vaccines as laden with toxins and made with “aborted fetal tissue” and “fetal cells“. It’s not enough, though, for antivaxxers to portray vaccines as dangerous to just the people receiving them. They have to portray vaccines as dangerous to others who have not received them as well. Before COVID-19, antivaxxers tried to claim that the recently vaccinated were dangerous because they “shed” virus from the vaccine (this does happen but is not dangerous and cases of disease from vaccine shedding are exceedingly rare). Unsurprisingly, in a case of everything old being new again, antivaxxers have co-opted many of tried-and-not-true narratives and deployed them in the service of spreading fear about COVID-19 vaccines, including the claim that they are made with “fetal cells“, portraying the lipid nanoparticles in them as horrifically toxic, and the mRNA in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines as “experimental gene therapy” that “hacks the software of life“. They’ve even falsely claimed that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer, Alzheimer’s disease, and death. But what about shedding?
When COVID-19 vaccines based on mRNA technology were first introduced, I naively thought that antivaxxers would not be able to adapt the narrative of the vaccinated being a danger to the unvaccinated due to “shedding”, because the mRNA technology used by Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech induces cells in the recipient only to make a single protein from SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Similarly, COVID-19 vaccines based on adenovirus vectors, such as the AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson manufacture, simply use a different method to achieve the same goal: To produce the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and thereby produce an immune response. None of the current COVID-19 vaccines produces a full intact coronavirus, not even a weakened one, as live-attenuated virus vaccines, such as the measles vaccine, use a weakened version of the measles virus. To summarize, current COVID-19 vaccines neither contain coronavirus, killed or live-attenuated, nor can they produce a full virus. None of this science stopped antivaxxers from adopting their narrative of “shedding” from vaccines as being a danger to those around the vaccinated. They happily started portraying the spike protein as deadly and falsely claimed that the vaccinated were “shedding” spike protein, leading to illness, menstrual disturbances, and even miscarriages in those exposed.
Over the last month, there have been three new papers that have been making the rounds among antivaxxers as “scientific proof” that not only is the coronavirus spike protein highly toxic to the vaccinated but that it is produced by the vaccinated in amounts that can cause those toxic effects. I thought I’d take some time to take a look at them. The first two papers are often presented as “slam dunk” evidence that the coronavirus spike protein is toxic and deadly (and, therefore, the COVID-19 vaccines are deadly), while the last paper is presented as evidence that mRNA vaccines produce enough spike protein to poison recipients. Spoiler alert: None of these papers show what antivaxxers represent them as showing, especially the third one.
Spike proteins and pulmonary hypertension
The first of these papers was one that I first noticed nearly a month ago on Twitter, although the study was older than that, dating back to January:
I read this; about the spike protein; that the mRNA vaccines are supposed to make in the body; and that it could cause pulmonary hypertension. I hope it’s not that. https://t.co/NdZ6CLWm5A
— Simone (@simonevdm) March 11, 2021
And here’s the study, from Georgetown and the Ukraine, “SARS-CoV-2 Spike Protein Elicits Cell Signaling in Human Host Cells: Implications for Possible Consequences of COVID-19 Vaccines“.
It turns out that this “study” isn’t even a study at all. Rather, it’s more like a “news and views” or opinion piece, a review article if you’re feeling particularly generous. Moreover, it was published in Vaccines (Basel), an open access journal in the MDPI group of journals. Unsurprisingly, MDPI journals are pretty dubious, with MDPI having been listed on Beale’s list of predatory journals in 2013. It ultimately successfully appealed and was removed from the list. However, from my perspective, I do not consider MDPI journals as being high quality and would never publish in one.
But what about the paper itself? Let’s just say that I was quite…underwhelmed…by it. Indeed, rarely in my many years of reading scientific papers have I seen so few experiments cited in a review article do such heavy lifting to provide such weak evidence for a conclusion like the claim that the spike protein can cause pulmonary hypertension.
At its essence, pulmonary hypertension is high blood pressure in the lungs. The circulatory system is divided into two components, the pulmonary system, in which blood flows through the blood vessels in the lungs, picks up oxygen, and then flows to the systemic circulation (the rest of the body) to deliver that oxygen to the tissues. The pulmonary vascular system is a much lower pressure system than the systemic circulation, which is why the right ventricle, the chamber of the heart that pumps blood through the lungs, is less muscular than the left ventricle, which pumps blood through the rest of the body. In any event, pulmonary hypertension can be caused by a number of things, including some types of congenital heart disease, connective tissue disease, coronary artery disease, high blood pressure, liver disease (cirrhosis), blood clots to the lungs, and chronic lung diseases like emphysema. The sequelae of pulmonary hypertension can be severe, including right-sided heart failure, hemorrhage in the lung, clotting, pulmonary artery dissection, and more. Let’s just say that pulmonary hypertension can be very bad.
On what do these authors base their claim that spike protein can cause pulmonary hypertension? They cite the most tenuous of evidence, and not very much of it. For instance, The first study is nothing more than a cell culture study coupled with a postmortem study of lungs first published last August, in which the authors (who happened to be them—yes, they cited their own paper) combined observations to make the leap to speculation that spike protein alone can cause the problems seen in COVID-19. In the cell culture component, the authors treated the cells that line pulmonary arteries (pulmonary artery endothelial cells) and the smooth muscle that surrounds the endothelial cells with spike protein and found that spike protein can cause intracellular signaling in these cells of a sort associated with cell injury. They also examined postmortem lung tissues from patients who died of COVID-19 and found pulmonary vascular wall thickening, a hallmark of pulmonary arterial hypertension. That’s it. No, really, that’s it. To be fair, the authors did compare the lungs of patients who died of H1N1 influenza to those who died of COVID-19 and found that the pulmonary arteries were markedly thicker in the patients who died of COVID-19. It’s an interesting observation, but if there’s one thing that was observed early in the pandemic it’s that the ARDS (acute respiratory distress syndrome) caused by COVID-19 was like nothing critical care doctors had ever seen before.
There is no more, at least not from these authors. Sure, they do cite two other papers, one from 2005 showing that injecting mice with recombinant spike protein from SARS reduced the ACE2 expression and worsened acid-induced lung injury. The other paper is from December and reports that the full-length SARS-CoV-2 spike protein activated NF-κB (a signaling pathway I’m well familiar with) and AP-1 transcription factors as well as p38 and ERK mitogen-activated protein kinases. Again, you don’t need to know the details other than that these are survival and growth pathways, but also that this observation was not made in cells from the pulmonary vasculature, but rather from a cell line (A549) from the lungs and another (Huh7.5) from the liver. The relevance of this study to whether spike protein can cause pulmonary hypertension is questionable at best.
Now that’s it: One study by the authors, two observations, one involving spike protein and one involving actual viral infection, plus an old study of SARS spike protein. I say this because it needs to be emphasized that what the authors reported was in patients who died of infection with the whole virus, SARS-CoV-2. You have to separate the effects of full infection and the effect of spike protein alone, and the authors did not do this, other than as a prelude to speculation that spike protein alone might cause pulmonary hypertension. Even for “proof” commonly cited by antivaxxers, this was weak sauce.
The deadly spike protein, take two
About three weeks ago, antivaxxers started pointing to a study from the Salk Institute as yet more “proof” that the spike protein used in COVID-19 vaccines is toxic and deadly. For instance, behold Alex Berenson, the “pandemic’s wrongest man“, crowing about the study:
As smoking guns go, this study is high-caliber. @UCSanDiego and Chinese researchers showed that the #SARSCoV2 spike protein – the one the vaccines make you produce – can all by itself cause major damage to the walls of blood vessels. pic.twitter.com/Fk5DNZugzH
— Alex Berenson (@AlexBerenson) May 2, 2021
Sorry, here: https://t.co/I3r91vk0Wj
— Alex Berenson (@AlexBerenson) May 2, 2021
I was amused when I saw these Tweets to see Berenson use a term like “off-target effects” as if he actually knows what it means.
It turns out that this study on a preprint server has been published in Circulation Research. It also turns out—surprise! surprise!—to definitely not to be “smoking gun” evidence for Berenson’s claims. Unlike the case of many papers cherry picked by antivaxxers to support their claims, it’s not that the paper is horrible, either. It’s not. It’s pretty decent, actually, at least as a preliminary, primarily observational study. Even more amusing, in it the authors expressly describe how their work actually demonstrates why vaccines that use spike protein as the antigen are so effective, and the Salk Institute press release even includes a disclaimer that the spike proteins made in cells by SARS-CoV-2 “behave very differently than those safely encoded by vaccines”.
Let’s look at the paper itself. The first thing that those of you with access to the paper will notice is how short it is: Three pages, one figure. That’s because it’s not a full research paper, but rather a research letter. As a result, there’s no detailed Methods section, and the results are very briefly described (much too briefly, for my liking). To be honest, for some of the experiments, due to the brevity of the paper, I had a bit of a hard time making heads or tails of what, exactly, the investigators did. I’ll do my best trying to explain, however.
In brief, the researchers used a “pseudovirus” that was surrounded by a “crown” of spike protein, like the coronavirus, but did not contain actual virus, dubbed Pseu-Spike by the authors. What is a pseudovirus? A reasonable question. In brief, a pseudovirus is a construct that has the external proteins of the virus of interest. There are a variety of pseudoviruses now, as described in this article in The Scientist:
Among these, researchers turned to models of the pathogen such as pseudoviruses and chimeric viruses that can be studied safely in labs with lower biosafety level (BSL) clearance than required for studying the wildtype version, in an effort to expand the study of the novel coronavirus. Pseudoviruses don’t replicate, rendering them harmless, but by replacing their surface envelope proteins with those of SARS-CoV-2, researchers can glean insights into the ways the pathogen infects cells.
And:
Pseudoviruses were first developed in the 1960s, after scientists began studying a vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) isolated from cattle. In addition to replicating well in culture, they later learned that its surface protein, VSV-G, facilitates entry into all eukaryotic cells, making the virus a useful vector not only as a pseudovirus but as a ferry to deliver DNA into cells for therapeutic purposes. The first Ebola vaccine was developed using a VSV platform, and more recently, the virus has been engineered to seek out and destroy cancer cells.
HIV-based platforms, which came about in the 1980s, have since replaced VSV as the most common model for developing both pseudo- and chimeric viruses. Unlike VSV’s negative-strand RNA genome that must be transcribed once inside the cell, HIV’s positive-strand RNA genome can instantly begin translation, making pseudoviruses based on HIV faster to produce. HIV-based model viruses have now been used in many of the same applications as VSV, with scientists applying them to the study of diseases such as AIDS, SARS, MERS, and influenza.
Also, compared with natural virus, a pseudovirus can only infect cells in a single round, has broad host range, high titer, and is not easily inactivated by serum complement.
Unfortunately, it is not clear from the paper which of these platforms was used to produce the pseudovirus in the experiments or how that pseudovirus was developed and produced. This is the sort of information that a full-length research paper would describe in the Methods section and it’s important information for determining whether the pseudovirus used was likely to be a good model. In another issue with this paper, the authors also do not describe the “mock virus” that they used as a control or how it was constructed. As a result, I find it very difficult to interpret their results. In fairness, some of this confusion might be because I am not highly knowledgeable about this particular system and don’t have the background knowledge about methodology that the authors clearly assume that the reader possesses. On the other hand, in a paper this in a journal like Circulation Research, which is not a virology journal, and particularly given that this is a paper that was likely to make the news and be misused by antivaxxers after its release, explanatory details that allow scientists from other fields with knowledge of molecular biology (but who are not experts in this field) to understand what was done are critical. A Research Letter does not accomplish this.
My concerns aside, let’s look at the experiments. The authors took pseudovirus or mock virus and instilled it into the tracheas of Syrian hamsters, three animals per experimental group. Another aspect of this study caught my eye, namely the amount of virus used, 5 x 108 pfu. For those of you not knowing what “pfu” stands for, it stands for “plaque-forming units.” Basically it’s a measure of the number of viable virus particles, virus particles that can infect cells and cause a plaque on a confluent layer of cells. That’s half a billion particles, far, far more of a viral challenge than the amount of virus launching any “natural” infection by SARs-CoV-2.
Using what is a highly artificial system, the authors compared the levels of a whole slate of protein markers related to cell signaling and oxidative stress in the mock- and Pseu-Spike-treated hamsters, as well as the histology of the lungs. I won’t go into detail about all of the markers examined, but rather will step back to take a longer view because it is not important for a lay person to understand all the phosphorylation of this protein or ubiquitination of that protein measured. (It’s also easy to get lost in the weeds of a study like this.) As stated, the authors found signs of inflammation in the alveoli (air sacs) of the Pseu-Spike-treated lungs, including thickened walls and inflammatory cells. They measured the levels of various proteins they deemed relevant:
AMPK (AMP-activated protein kinase) phosphorylates ACE2 Ser-680, MDM2 (murine double minute 2) ubiquitinates ACE2 Lys-788, and crosstalk between AMPK and MDM2 determines the ACE2 level.4 In the damaged lungs, levels of pAMPK (phospho-AMPK), pACE2 (phospho-ACE2), and ACE2 decreased but those of MDM2 increased (Figure [B], i). Furthermore, complementary increased and decreased phosphorylation of eNOS (endothelial NO synthase) Thr-494 and Ser-1176 indicated impaired eNOS activity. These changes of pACE2, ACE2, MDM2 expression, and AMPK activity in endothelium were recapitulated by in vitro experiments using pulmonary arterial ECs infected with Pseu-Spike which was rescued by treatment with N-acetyl-L-cysteine, a reactive oxygen species inhibitor (Figure [B], ii).
Translation: Compared to mock virus, Pseu-Spike altered signaling due to the ACE2 receptor, which is not surprising given that it’s been known for a year now that spike protein latches onto the ACE2 receptor in order to get SARS-CoV-2 into the cell. As a result, there was a lower level of ACE2 in the hamster lung tissue treated with Pseu-Spike, although looking at the Western blots in Figure 1B I am not particularly impressed by the magnitude of the decrease in protein level.
Also observed in the Pseu-Spike-treated hamster lung was decreased activity of eNOS, an enzyme that generates nitric oxide, as well as damage to the mitochondria, the “power plants” of the cell. The authors also did the same experiments in cell culture alone using pulmonary vascular endothelial cells (the cells the line the inside of the arteries in the lung), reporting that they recapitulated their findings, although they used spike protein at a rather high concentration (4 μg/ml). They also tested whether similar changes occurred in vascular endothelial cells genetically engineered to make a more stable and less stable version of ACE2. They did, although this is only suggestive, not slam dunk evidence, that it is the spike protein-induced degradation of ACE2 that results in these intracellular changes. The authors also reported that in pulmonary arteries isolated from the hamsters vasodilation induced by a drug called nitroprusside was not affected by Pseu-Spike, but the vasodilation caused by acetylcholine was impaired. Nitroprusside works by breaking down in the presence of oxyhemoglobin to produce, among other things, nitric oxide, while acetylcholine binds to specific protein receptors on the cell surface.
To be honest, I’ve never been a fan of papers this short (e.g., some Nature or Science papers, which can be even shorter than this) because I can never quite figure out what the authors did; this is one of the rare cases of a paper that to me screams out for an online Supplemental Data and Supplemental Figures section, and I say this as someone who generally detests the trend in scientific publications to dump all sorts of data into supplemental sections.
Let’s, for the sake of argument, take the results at face value and assume that this study shows what the authors say it shows, namely that spike protein damages endothelium, “manifested by impaired mitochondrial function and eNOS activity”. and can cause oxidative stress that destabilizes the ACE2 receptor, leading to lower levels of the receptor. The authors themselves note that by decreasing the level of ACE2, spike protein could actually decrease the infectivity of SARs-CoV-2, given that the coronavirus needs to bind to ACE2 to get into cells, while speculating that the dysfunction of endothelial cells could result in endotheliitis, or inflammation of the endothelium that more than makes up for the decreased infectivity.
But here’s the kicker, taken right from the final paragraph of the paper:
Collectively, our results suggest that the S protein-exerted EC damage overrides the decreased virus infectivity. This conclusion suggests that vaccination-generated antibody and/or exogenous antibody against S protein not only protects the host from SARS-CoV-2 infectivity but also inhibits S protein imposed endothelial injury.
In other words, the vaccine could be protective not just against infection by SARS-CoV-2 but also against endothelial injury from the spike protein.
I just want to reiterate again that this is a contrived system. It’s far from a worthless system, as pseudovirus systems have value in studying the role of spike protein in the pathogenesis of COVID-19. However, given the crapton of pseudovirus used in this hamster model, I really question any relevance of this system to vaccine safety issues with respect to mRNA- or adenovirus-based vaccines that produce the spike protein as an antigen. Why? The mRNA or adenovirus from the vaccines does not distribute extensively given that it’s an intramuscular injection, and the spike protein is highly unlikely to attain concentrations in the circulation anywhere near the high levels produced by the model used in these experiments. Moreover, the spike protein from the vaccine is not attached in a crown-like array on a virus particle (or pseudovirus particle), but rather exists as naked single protein molecules, and, as has been described before, it’s unclear that in this form spike protein, compared to the “crown of spikes” that gives coronaviruses their name, is anywhere near as effective at causing these downstream effects in cells. Add to that the fact that mRNA, even the modified mRNA in the vaccine, doesn’t hang around very long and therefore doesn’t generate spike protein for very long. (Doubters should consider this: Why do the mRNA vaccines both require a second dose 3-4 weeks after the first dose if, as many antivaxxers claim, the vaccines crank out spike protein indefinitely?)
Indeed, one of the authors pointed out this very issue and took antivaxxers to task for misusing their study:
i’m going to give a full response asap. but quickly for the record:1) the (relatively) small amount of spike protein produced by the mRNA vaccine would not be nearly enough to do any damage2) i happily got the mRNA vaccine, FWIW3) i encourage everyone to get it
— Uri Manor 💔 (@manorlaboratory) May 2, 2021
a couple prelim responses to anti-vaxxers misrepresenting these findings (here: https://t.co/qMhHyNyRR1). tl;dr: mRNA vaccine is waaaaay safer than COVID19 and everyone should get it – I did and everyone in my family did as well! Our paper just shows this disease really sucks. https://t.co/1t6SuUXZ5B
— Uri Manor 💔 (@manorlaboratory) May 2, 2021
Since I first discovered this study, it’s just amused me how obvious it is that the antivaxxers citing this study have obviously not actually read the study itself, nor have they considered the background science and knowledge behind the study. They’ve just read the press release. What do you expect, though? They’re antivaxxers. This study by Uri Manor’s laboratory is interesting and potentially important because it begins to elucidate the role of the spike protein itself in the pathophysiology of SARS-CoV-2 infection and how the spike protein alone can cause damage, but it does not in any way suggest that spike protein made by a COVID-19 vaccine is in any way toxic at the concentrations it’s produced, much less that it’s in any way “shed” or that the “shed” spike protein can cause disease or miscarriages in the unvaccinated who encounter the vaccinated.
Which brings me to the last of the three studies, which was published late last week.
The deadly coronavirus spike protein produced by the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine?
On Friday, I started seeing a study popping up among antivaxxers. Unsurprisingly, the “pandemic’s wrongest man” was all over it on Friday. His ability to misinterpret studies and thereby spread prodigious amounts of COVID-19 disinformation is depressingly impressive:
Hey, remember how all the smart people told you the vaccines were supery-dupery safe because those nasty-ass (technical term) spike proteins they make would never actually leave the cells that make them?
Turns out that's… less than entirely accurate.https://t.co/JJKdmOB4fU
— Alex Berenson (@AlexBerenson) May 21, 2021
The study itself was published on May 20 in Clinical Infectious Diseases, the official journal of the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) as a brief report by Ogata et al, entitled “Circulating SARS-CoV-2 Vaccine Antigen Detected in the Plasma of mRNA-1273 Vaccine Recipients” and is the result of a collaboration between investigators at Harvard and the University of Montreal.
The study was very straightforward in design. In brief, investigators longitudinally studied blood samples from 13 participants who received two doses of mRNA-1273 (i.e., took samples at various time points after vaccination), Moderna’s mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine. I can sum up the findings from the abstract, namely that investigators were able to detect spike protein in the plasma of 11 of 13 participants in the trial as early as one day after vaccination. To do so, they used a very sensitive technique known as single molecule array (SIMOA) to detect intact spike protein and its S1 fragment produced by RNA-1273.
A brief discussion of the spike protein itself is in order. The spike (S) glycoprotein of SARS-CoV-2 binds angiotensin-converting enzyme-2 (ACE2) on host cells. Spike itself is processed by proteases (protein-cleaving enzymes) into S1 and S2 subunits that remain associated with each other. Upon binding to ACE2 by the spike protein, the protein changes conformation that leads to S1 shedding and the cleavage of S2 by host proteases. You don’t really need to know the details for purposes of understanding this study, other than that spike protein has an S1 and S2 subunit, and these subunits associate with each other in the same conformation as they were before protease cleavage. This is a diagram of the structure.

But what does the authors’ finding of spike protein in the plasma mean, if anything? Haven’t we always been reassured that the spike protein from the mRNA vaccines doesn’t get into the bloodstream and remains in cells and on the surface of the cells that produce the protein after vaccination? Isn’t this study, as antivaxxers like Berenson claim, a reason to be afraid of the Moderna vaccine, at least? The short answer to that last question is no. The longer answer follows.
We at SBM like to repeat Paracelus’ famous dictum, dosis sola facit venenum, or “only the dose makes the poison”. It’s a general principle of pharmacology and toxicology, namely that the dose determines the effect of a drug, or, more specifically, the concentration of any substance in the bloodstream or organs that it affects (which is related, of course, to the dose) is what matters in terms of its effects. As I like to say, even water can be toxic if too much is ingested. That’s why I’ll refer back to a common antivaccine trope for which I long ago coined a term, “the toxins gambit“. Pre-pandemic, antivaxxers would point to every scary-sounding chemical they could find in vaccines and try to use it as evidence that vaccines were laden with “toxins”. My favorite example is, of course, formaldehyde, which is used in the preparation of some vaccines in order to inactivate the virus used as an antigen, leaving detectable traces behind in the vaccines. I first discovered the “formaldehyde gambit” (a form of the “toxins gambit”) when it was used years ago by Dr. Jay Gordon. The short version of the refutation of the “formaldehyde gambit” is to cite Paracelus and point out that the amount of formaldehyde in any given vaccine is exceedingly small, considerably smaller than what an infant produces due to their own normal metabolism. Indeed, peak body burden of formaldehyde has been estimated to be less than 1% of endogenous formaldehyde.
The same thing applies to this study cited by Berenson, as you will see. Before I describe how much spike protein the investigators found in the plasma of these 13 study participants, let’s look at the concentrations used, for example, in the cell culture experiments done by Uri Manor’s group as described in the second paper I discussed: 4 μg/ml.
Now, let’s look at the “money figure” from the paper, the first three panels of Figure 1. The reason that the authors also did the assay to detect the viral nucleocapsid protein was because the vaccine does not result in production of this protein. It was thus a negative control; unless the subject is infected with SARS-CoV-2, nucleocapsid protein should be undetectable.
Here’s the figure:

Now take a look at the Y-axis, in particular, the units on the Y-axis: “pg/ml,” or picograms per ml. That’s 10-12 grams/milliliter. What was the concentration used by Manor’s lab again? Oh, yes, 4 micrograms/milliliter. One microgram is 10-6 grams, or one million-fold more than one picogram! Or, as Uri Manor put it:
Congrats to @OgataAlana on this important study. Many asked how much spike protein gets into circulation after vaccination. Turns out to average ~30-40 pg/mL for a few days then disappears.
FYI: This is ~100,000x less than used in our paper (4 ug/mL).https://t.co/k5AChClhI5 pic.twitter.com/xgzJ4RerYG
— Uri Manor 💔 (@manorlaboratory) May 21, 2021
Or, as Ogata et al write:
S1 antigen was detected as early as day one post vaccination and peak levels were detected on average five days after the first injection (Figure 1A). The mean S1 peak levels was 68 pg/mL ±21 pg/mL. S1 in all participants declined and became undetectable by day 14. No antigen was detected at day zero for 12 of 13 participants, as expected. However, one individual presented detectable S1 on day zero, possibly due to assay cross reactivity with other human coronaviruses or asymptomatic infection at the time of vaccination. Spike protein was detectable in three of 13 participants an average of 15 days after the first injection. The mean spike peak level was 62 pg/mL ± 13 pg/mL. After the second vaccine dose, no S1 or spike was detectable, and both antigens remained undetectable through day 56. For one individual (Participant #8), spike was detected at day 29, one day after the second injection and was undetectable two days later.
Let’s be generous. Let’s look at panel B and examine the highest concentration of spike protein detected, which looks by the graph to have been around 90 pg/ml. Now, for ease of calculation, let’s just round up to 100 pg/ml as the highest average peak plasma concentration of spike protein after vaccination. That would still be a 40,000-fold lower concentration than 4 μg/ml. As an aside, the authors also detected IgG and IgA antibodies to spike protein and a correlation between clearance of detectable SARS-CoV-2 protein and the production of IgG and IgA.
But why did Ogata et al detect any spike protein at all? After all, we know that the spike protein is not secreted from the cells in which it is made because it lacks an amino acid sequence, a so called “signal peptide sequence” that would lead to its secretion. We know that the spike protein as made using the mRNA sequence template is membrane-bound, meaning that it’s embedded in the membrane of the cells that make it. The authors speculate in the Discussion:
In this study, 11 participants exhibit S1 antigen in plasma after the first injection, while nucleocapsid concentrations are insignificant in all participants, confirming that the detected S1 originates from vaccination and not natural infection. The presence of S1 is likely due to the nature of the encoded mRNA-1273 spike protein, which contains a cleavable S1-S2 site and enables release of S1 from the spike trimer2. We hypothesize that release of S1 protein could result from cleavage via mammalian cell proteases or circulating proteases. We observe an increase in S1 over an initial period of one to five days, suggesting that mRNA translation begins immediately after vaccine inoculation. Interestingly, spike protein appears in three of thirteen participants on average eight days after S1 is produced.
Translation: There are enzymes that can cleave proteins (proteases), and it is possible that these proteases clipped off the S1 subunit from the spike proteins in the membrane.
Another possibility:
The Simoa antigen assays for the full spike protein are designed to require antibody binding to both the S1 and S2 subunits for detection, resulting in a cleaved spike protein to be undetectable. Additionally, spike protein concentrations in plasma of vaccinated participants may be below our assay limit of detection. We hypothesize that the cellular immune responses triggered by T-cell activation, which would occur days after the vaccination, lead to direct killing of cells presenting spike protein and an additional release of spike into the blood stream. The mechanisms underlying release of free S1 and the subsequent detection of the intact spike protein remain unclear and require further studies.
In other words, another possibility is that the immune system killing the cells producing spike protein could result in the release of enough spike protein to be detectable by this very sensitive assay. Indeed, the authors note that the detection of spike protein “has not yet been described in any vaccine study, likely due to limitations in assay sensitivity and timing assessment”. In other words, the authors’ assay is so sensitive that it’s detecting incredibly minute amounts of spike protein from the vaccine in the blood that previous studies could not detect, simply because they used insufficiently sensitive assays.
As I was writing this, I was informed that an old friend Ed Nirenberg had done a similar analysis and had actually done me one better by comparing this study to another study of spike protein that reported that spike protein could damage the blood-brain barrier. That study used a 10 nM (nanomolar) concentration of spike protein, which, using the molecular weight of spike protein and S1 subunit and found:
A 10 nM solution of these [spike protein and S1 subunit] would equate to 14,610,000 pg/mL and 7,650,000 pg/mL respectively which are respectively 146100 times and 76500 times more spike protein than is found in plasma of vaccinated people.
Ed further notes:
Ah but I hear you protesting- the experts lied! They said no spike circulating- clearly there’s spike circulating. Not exactly. For one thing, the data available until this point didn’t show evidence of spike circulating, and we have a tendency in shorthand to say that that means there is no spike because we can’t prove a negative. All assays have limits of detection (in this case it’s labelled). A 10 nM concentration is very small- and yet this is still about 100,000 times more spike than what we find in plasma. This assay is pretty special to be able to find anything reliably at this concentration and I would be skeptical of its accuracy at this level if not for the time points that these things are appearing. Also note that this isn’t evidence of spike protein being secreted by the cells that receive the mRNA, which was the key consideration behind such claims and indeed based on the tiny quantities noted, that doesn’t appear to be happening. The appearance of intact spike in the plasma of this admittedly small sample is very rare and transient.
Exactly. The amount of spike protein that was detected by SIMOA in this study is low, basically not much above the current limit of detection for this protein, and, more importantly, very transient. There was nothing nefarious in previous statements that spike protein from vaccines does not circulate in the bloodstream, nor was it a lie. Again, to echo Ed, the key concern was that the cells that took up the lipid nanoparticles containing the mRNA should not secrete the spike protein product, which could, theoretically at least, actually produce a significant plasma concentration.
On Twitter, Alana Olgata notes that she’d like to repeat this study with other COVID-19 vaccines, which is not unreasonable:
Yes. Completely agreed. Our goal to repeat these studies with other vaccines, especially J&J and OAZ. The challenge now is acquiring these samples as the vaccine roll out slows down and with high frequency sampling.
— Alana Ogata (@OgataAlana) May 21, 2021
No doubt antivaxxers will leap all over those papers when they are published.
The “deadly” spike protein and vaccine safety
As I stated near the beginning of this post, antivaxxers strive mightily, above all, to claim that vaccines are dangerous to those receiving them and those around the recipients, all with added conspiracy theories. It doesn’t matter how much they have to misinterpret or misrepresent scientific studies to do so. They’ll find a way to make their misrepresentations (or failure to put studies into proper context) sound like plausible evidence that vaccines are dangerous, and they’ve certainly been doing this with COVID-19 vaccines, starting with pointing to any study that finds a role for the spike protein alone in causing cell damage. Such studies are critical to the elucidation of the molecular mechanism by which SARS-CoV-2 infects cells, replicates itself, and causes so much damage to the lungs. It’s also important to note that target effects matter. Location matters. The main infection starts in the lungs, which is where the highest concentration of virus and therefore spike protein would be expected in the case of real infections. In the case of vaccination, the location is the muscle cells of the shoulder, and any spike protein that escapes is rapidly diluted in the bloodstream to the pg/ml range.
But what does Olgata’s finding for the Moderna mean regarding the safety of the vaccine? Basically nothing. The reason is simple. If there were a safety problem due to spike protein, after more than a quarter of a billion doses of vaccine administered in the US alone, there would have been safety signal by now, given the unprecedentedly intense vaccine safety surveillance effort that accompanied the rollout of these vaccines. Remember, this is a pharmacosurveillance effort that detected literally a one-in-a-million serious adverse event associated with vaccination with the Johnson & Johnson vaccine within a month and a half of its being distributed under an emergency use authorization. It beggars the imagination to suggest that, even if the transient appearance of spike protein after vaccination at a concentration of (at most) tens of picograms/ml were toxic, there would be no safety signal after so many doses. It’s even more ridiculous to propose that such a minuscule concentration of spike protein can be “shed” in quantities that could affect other people, given the incredibly low and transient concentration produced after vaccination.
Antivaxxers either don’t know or understand that themselves, or they know that the vast majority of people don’t know or understand that. All they need is a finding that any spike protein floats free in the bloodstream after vaccination, and they can use that finding to start an effective fear mongering campaign. That’s exactly what they are doing now.

No, the Moderna and Pfizer RNA vaccines for COVID-19 will not “permanently alter your DNA”
With the new mRNA vaccines developed by Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna likely to be available soon, antivaxxers have been ramping up the fear mongering. Their latest claim is that mRNA vaccines will “permanently alter your DNA” or even “make you transhuman.” Such claims rest on an utter ignorance of the totality of what we know about the biology of DNA, RNA, and how they encode proteins. Same as it ever was.
David Gorski on November 30, 2020
Link

This week, I wanted to cover something important that we haven’t covered before here at SBM. So I asked myself: What topic related to COVID-19 have we at SBM not covered yet that we really should have covered by now? Given that Steve has already covered the first two COVID-19 vaccines going to the FDA for approval and possible emergency use authorization (EUA), the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, it didn’t make sense for me to discuss COVID-19 vaccines again. Then it occurred to me. These two new vaccines that will likely soon be available, at least to “essential personnel” such as medical personnel treating COVID-19 patients anyway, share one thing in common. They are RNA vaccines. What also occurred to me is that there has been a persistent myth about RNA vaccines being promoted by the antivaccine movement. Perhaps you’ve seen it? Yes? No?
Perhaps you’ve seen memes like this:
Or this one:
Or this one:
Or this one:
You get the idea. One major theme of antivaccine disinformation related to potential RNA vaccines against COVID-19 is that the RNA used in the vaccine will somehow permanently “reprogram” your DNA in nefarious ways. It’s a claim that goes back at least to May, if not sooner, and arose as soon as antivaxxers became aware that one of the leading candidate vaccines against COVID-19 was Moderna’s RNA vaccine. After that, it soon became a standard talking point in the antivaccine movement’s pre-emptive disinformation war against COVID-19 vaccines. Why would anyone want to do this? Conspiracy theorists always have…reasons…of course. Some say that it’s to mark people. Some people say it’s to develop a technology that allows you to inject DNA directly into cells and reprogram them (Would that this were true! Such technologies would make gene therapy so much less difficult!) Often, antivaxxers conflate RNA with DNA and vice-versa, not realizing that, although both molecules contain genetic information needed for a cell to make protein, they are nonetheless very different in characteristics and behavior.
Of course, to experts the claim that RNA vaccines will somehow “reprogram” your DNA claims are utterly risible in the ignorance of basic biology and biochemistry necessary to make such unscientific claims. But to nonexperts, most of whom probably long ago forgot their basic biology (if they ever learned it at all), the concept of a vaccine that turns your own cells into little factories making part of a key protein from COVID-19 that provokes a protective immune response (more on the specifics later) can seem quite plausible—and scary. Of course, fear is exactly the intended purpose of the antivaccine disinformation claiming that RNA vaccines will somehow “reprogram” your DNA and permanently alter you genetically. (We do hope for one “permanent” alteration in our biology as a result of a COVID-19, though, namely immunity to SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Unfortunately, it’s not yet clear how long such immunity will last.) So let’s examine the claims being made and why you don’t have to fear RNA vaccines for COVID-19.
Before we do that, let’s look at what mRNA vaccines are, how they work, and what their advantages and disadvantages are compared to traditional vaccines.
mRNA vaccines
mRNA vaccines rely on something I’ve discussed before, namely the “central dogma” of molecular biology. I must admit, I’ve always hated the use of the word “dogma” associated with science, but no less a luminary than Francis Crick first stated it in 1958, and it has been restated over the years in various ways. Perhaps my favorite version of the central dogma was succinctly stated by Marshall Nirenberg in 1958 and has since been commonly paraphrased to say, “DNA makes RNA makes protein”, which about summed up all of molecular biology in five words. (Why I used the past tense in a moment.) In any event, for purposes of understanding RNA viruses, this is the main sequence that you need to understand:
Basically, DNA replicates from a DNA template and results in a double-stranded molecule that is very stable, as it has complementary sequences that tightly bind to each other in a sequence-specific fashion. This DNA template is unwound by enzymes that use the template to make RNA strands, which are single-stranded, which is then used by a ribosome to make protein out of amino acids. Again, to put it simply, each nucleotide equals one letter of the code; each three-nucleotide sequence (codon) equals one “word” that translates to an amino acid. Given that there are four nucleotides, there are 64 possible codons. Since there are only 20 amino acids, that means that most amino acids are encoded by more than one combination of nucleotides or more than one codon; i.e., the genetic code is redundant. Of course, it’s more complicated than that, as this diagram shows:
Here’s a little video that’s useful too:
For instance, messenger RNA (mRNA) doesn’t always start out fully formed. Often it’s made as a longer precursor molecule that is spliced to the final mRNA sequence before being transported out of the nucleus into the cytoplasm to be used to make protein.
In fact, it’s even more complicated than that. Remember how I used the past tense when I said that the central dogma summed up all of molecular biology? It did, but then we started finding exceptions to the central dogma, such as retroviruses and microRNAs that can regulate gene expression, for instance. You don’t really need to know the gory details of many of these, although I will mention a couple of relevant ones and refer you to a post that does go into the gory details, for anyone who’s really interested.
Exceptions aside, RNA vaccines consist mainly of, well, RNA. One problem with RNA vaccines is that RNA is an inherently unstable molecule. It is, after all, a messenger. It doesn’t need to persist any longer than the message needs to be made. In aqueous solution, RNA molecules rapidly degrade. Indeed, the instability of RNA is why public health experts have been concerned about distributing RNA vaccines. Both companies adopted a similar strategy in designing their mRNA to encode the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein with stabilizing mutations added to lock this surface protein into a form easily recognizable to the immune system and therefore make it a better antigen. Pfizer and Moderna also used modified nucleosides (the RNA equivalent to DNA nucleotides) that are more stable to make their RNAs, and placed their RNA within a lipid nanoparticle (LNP) delivery system in which LNPs fuse with the cell membrane to deliver the RNA to the cytoplasm. Nonetheless, there are huge differences in the temperatures at which these vaccines need to be stored to remain stable and active.
Here’s what I mean. The Pfizer vaccine (developed in partnership with a company called BioNTech) reportedly needs to be stored at -80°C. While I have a -80°C freezer in my laboratory (to store RNA samples, among other things), most physicians’ offices and clinics do not, because such freezers are large and very expensive compared to the more common refrigerators (which generally maintain a temperature of around 4°C) and standard freezers (which maintain a temperature of around -20°C). Even many hospitals do not have enough -80°C freezers to store large quantities of vaccine. Similarly, because of the temperature necessary to keep the vaccine stable and active, transporting the Pfizer vaccine presents logistical challenges, because the vaccine must be kept at -80°C or colder during the entire chain of transport. It can be done, using dry ice, of course, but it’s difficult, and one could easily imagine an impending dry ice shortage once such vaccines roll out. To this end, both companies have apparently used modified nucleotides to try to make their mRNA molecules more stable The Moderna vaccine, in contrast, can reportedly be stored at -20°C for up to six months, which is much more doable, as most standard freezers can reach this temperature. Even better, the Moderna vaccine will remain stable at standard refrigerator temperatures of 2° to 8°C (36° to 46°F) for up to 30 days and remains stable at room temperature for up to 12 hours. Why the difference? It’s hard to know for sure, as both companies are tight-lipped about the exact differences in their vaccines. A Moderna spokesperson explained to NPR:
Moderna spokesperson Colleen Hussey explained to NPR in an email that its vaccine doesn’t need to be kept so cold because of its particular “lipid nanoparticle properties and structure,” and because the company has learned from experience — it’s developed ten mRNA vaccine candidates already. “Now we don’t need [ultra-cold conditions] as the quality of product has improved and [it] doesn’t need to be highly frozen to avoid mRNA degradation,” Hussey explained.
In terms of safety and the reported immune response provoked by the two competing vaccines:
On the safety side, while both BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 were generally well tolerated by participants of phase 3 trials, with most side effects short-lived, the Moderna vaccine was linked to a greater incidence of severe adverse events such as a fatigue and muscle pain after the second shot. Experts speculate that the different dosages (30 micrograms for BNT162b2 versus 100 micrograms for mRNA-1273) could account for the different tolerability profiles.
The Pfizer/BioNtech vaccine might also have a slight edge when it comes to the immune response. In phase 1 trials, with both vaccines, humoral immunity was strong, with virus-neutralizing antibody titers generally surpassing those found in individuals who had recovered from natural infection. As for cellular immunity, both also induced CD4+ T-cell responses skewed toward T-helper type 1 cells. Yet, as reported, only the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine seemed to bring about any sort of cytotoxic CD8+ T cell response. Direct comparisons are difficult, however, as the two vaccine developers used different assays for profiling immune cells.
So basically the two vaccines are very similar in design and differ mainly in their required storage conditions.
Before I move on to explain why antivaxxers’ claims about mRNA vaccines are nothing but fear mongering, it’s useful to answer the question: Given all the challenges described above, why use mRNA vaccines at all? Why not make a more traditional vaccine, in which a protein (or proteins or fragments of key proteins) are made and used as antigens to provoke an immune response? Why go to the trouble of using mRNA vaccines to get the body’s own cells to make antigen? The answer is rather simple. RNA is easier and quicker to produce on a mass scale than more traditional protein-based vaccines. Moreover, compared to DNA vaccines (which could achieve the same thing, getting the body to produce the necessary protein antigen), RNA vaccines have a definite safety advantage over DNA vaccines:
Particularly compared with DNA as a therapeutic or more specifically as a vaccine, mRNA offers strong safety advantages.5 As the minimal genetic construct, it harbors only the elements directly required for expression of the encoded protein. Moreover, while recombination between single-stranded RNA molecules may occur in rare cases,6,7 mRNA does not interact with the genome. Thus, potentially detrimental genomic integration is excluded. Finally, this lack of genomic integration in combination with mRNA being non-replicative as well as metabolically decaying within a few days8 makes mRNA a merely transient carrier of information.
Remember that paragraph as I now move on to deconstruct an antivaccine claim regarding COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. The bottom line is that the mRNA used in RNA vaccines can’t integrate with your DNA, much less “reprogram” it.
Enter Dr. Carrie Madej and the “transhumanism” of COVID-19 vaccines
Although I’ve seen a lot of antivaxxers and COVID-19 deniers/minimizers out there sharing a lot of ridiculous memes falsely claiming that COVID-19 mRNA vaccines will somehow reprogram your DNA, one of the grand masters of this claim is a physician named Dr. Carrie Madej. I first encountered her in October and have been meaning to use her to illustrate how unscientific the claims about mRNA vaccines are, given how viral her videos and articles have gone. In particular, her website is Stop World Control, where you can find her video that went viral.
Here’s what Stop World Control says about Dr. Madej:
Dr Carrie Madej directed two large medical clinics in the state of Georgia, USA. Since her twenties she has been fascinated by vaccines and studied them ever since. Her in depth research led her to discover what the proposed technologies are for the new COVID-19 vaccines. What she is revealing is alarming.
This video is an in depth documentary that shows how these new vaccines can alter our DNA, turning us into hybrids. The plans are to connect humans to artificial intelligence and global control networks. This is the start of transhumanism, turning us into HUMANS 2.0.
“Study.” You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. Seriously, I bet that Dr. Madej “studies” vaccines in the same way that Mike Adams does, her being a physician notwithstanding.
I found out a bit more. Dr. Madej is an internist in McDonough, Georgia. She’s Medical Director of Phoenix Medical Group of Georgia, where she has a full time practice in Internal Medicine. Her Twitter feed is a wretched hive of scum, quackery, and conspiracy theories. Unsurprisingly, she is an antimasker, seems to buy into every major conspiracy theory about COVID-19 out there, and has appeared on The Alex Jones Show, antivaxxer Sherri Tenpenny’s show, and on Mike Adams’ show. She also gave a virtual speech to the gathering of antimaskers and COVID-19 lockdown protesters at Trafalgar Square in September. When I first encountered her last month, I thought it odd that I hadn’t heard of her before.
So what is “transhumanism“? However I describe it, I’m sure someone will object, but here goes anyway. Basically, it is a social, scientific, and philosophical movement devoted to the idea that humans can be enhanced by technology, be it biological, computer-based, or physical. The idea is that such technologies would augment or increase human perception, physical abilities, intelligence, and cognition, and also radically improve human health and extend human life spans. Unsurprisingly, the movement’s adherents tend to be employed in technology, biotech, and academia, and there is a strong link between libertarianism and transhumanism. The ultimate outcome is thought to be the “singularity“, a time when computers become so advanced that artificial intelligence transcends human intelligence, potentially erasing the boundary between humanity and computers, even leading to the merging of humans and computers. Personally, I’ve always looked a bit askance at transhumanism, because there is certainly a lot of woo in the movement. Moreover, transhumanists do tend to assume that the coming “singularity” will necessarily be a good thing. Science fiction, however, provides many potential counterexamples, SkyNet in the Terminator movies and the Borg in Star Trek being two of the most famous of them.
Science fiction dystopian views of transhumanism aside, I am not opposed on general principle to human-enhancing technologies. After all, what is medicine but an effort over many millennia to overcome the inherent biological weaknesses and defects in humans in order to extend lifespans and enhance the quality of life during those lifespans by preventing premature infirmity and death due to aging and external disease? True, there is a philosophical argument to be had over how much modification might be too much, but that’s not what a crank like Dr. Madej is about. Rather, just as antivaxxers have used the COVID-19 pandemic and President Trump’s “Operation Warp Speed” program to stoke fear that any new COVID-19 vaccine will be unsafe, having been rushed to approval too quickly with inadequate safety testing, and thereby to cast doubt on all vaccines, here antivaxxers are painting COVID-19 mRNA vaccines as incipient “transhumanism” in order to—you guessed it!—spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about all vaccines.
Unsurprisingly, über-quack Dr. Joe Mercola is all on board with this tactic, and it was his article “Will New COVID Vaccine Make You Transhuman?” that first brought my attention to Dr. Madej. Indeed, if you Google “Will COVID-19 vaccine make you transhuman?” you will rapidly find a lot of links reposting all or part of Mercola’s article, plus articles making the same sort of claim. I’m half tempted to respond to the question in the headlines of such articles with Betteridge’s Law of Headlines and just answer with a resounding “No!” but unfortunately more is required. In any case, let’s see Mercola’s take on Madej’s article:
Many of the COVID-19 vaccines currently being fast-tracked are not conventional vaccines. Their design is aimed at manipulating your very biology, and therefore have the potential to alter the biology of the entire human race.
Conventional vaccines train your body to recognize and respond to the proteins of a particular virus by injecting a small amount of the actual viral protein into your body, thereby triggering an immune response and the development of antibodies.
This is not what happens with an mRNA vaccine. The theory behind these vaccines is that when you inject the mRNA into your cells, it will stimulate your cells to manufacture their own viral protein. The mRNA COVID-19 vaccine will be the first of its kind. No mRNA vaccine has ever been licensed before. And, to add insult to injury, they’re forgoing all animal safety testing.
Alter the biology of the entire human race? Surely Dr. Mercola must know the central dogma of molecular biology? (Maybe he doesn’t.) Again, remember that paragraph I quoted before this section. mRNA like that found in the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna vaccines simply can’t alter your DNA. As for “reprogramming” human biology, one could argue that all vaccines do that. Some, such as the ones that can produce lifelong immunity to a vaccine-preventable disease, can do it permanently, by permanently altering the immune system to be able to recognize the relevant antigens when it encounters them again. This whole take is silly. Obviously, what Mercola and Madej are trying to scare readers with is the idea that somehow mRNA vaccines permanently alter your DNA, but, again, they can’t do that. They just can’t.
Madej also claims (and Mercola repeats):
The problem with all of this, Madej notes, is that they’re using a process called transfection — a process used to create genetically modified organisms. She points out that research has confirmed GMO foods are not as healthy as conventional unmodified foods. The question is, might we also become less healthy? “Vaccine manufacturers have stated that this will not alter our DNA, our genome,” Madej says.I say that is not true. Because if we use this process to make a genetically modified organism, why would it not do the same thing to a human? I don’t know why they’re saying that.
If you look at the definition of transfection, it will tell you that it can be a temporary change in the cell. And I think that is what the vaccine manufacturers are banking on.
Or, it’s a possibility for it to become stable, to be taken up into the genome, and to be so stable that it will start replicating when the genome replicates. Meaning it is now a permanent part of your genome. That’s a chance that we’re taking. It could be temporary, or it could be permanent.
Dr. Madej says this is not true. Well whoop-de-doo and la-dee-da! No, seriously. This is not a DNA vaccine. One more time, it is not possible for the RNA to “become stable” and be taken up into the genome. (Indeed, RNA viruses that can integrate into the genome rely on first being reverse transcribed into DNA, which can then be integrated into the genome.) Again, this is Molecular Biology 101. As for transfection, all that is, is a technique to introduce RNA or DNA into cells. That’s it! Most commonly it’s used to introduce plasmids (circular lengths of DNA containing genes of interest) into cells. Methods range from really old school ones that I used in graduate school 30 years ago, such as calcium phosphate precipitation (which is horrendously inefficient and usually only introduces the plasmid into single digit percentages of the cells) to various liposome-based methods, which are much more efficient and get the desired DNA into a larger percentage of the target cells. (These liposomes were similar to the ones being used by Moderna and Pfizer.) While it is true that the introduction of mRNA into a cell will produce a temporary change, namely that the cell’s ribosomes will start using the mRNA to make the desired protein, that temporary change is just that—temporary. It has nothing to do with altering the cell permanently, and as soon as the mRNA degrades naturally the cell will go back to normal. Seriously, Dr. Madej, molecular biologists are laughing at you.
There’s so much more in the video that I could unpack but won’t, in order to keep my focus on mRNA vaccines. I did let a little slip in regarding Dr. Madej’s claim that microneedles and a Hydrogel base will be used to inject the new vaccines; so I might as well briefly explain that she’s almost certainly referring to quantum dot tags, which are copper-based quantum dots embedded in biocompatible, micron-scale capsules. They’re tagged with a near-infrared dye that’s invisible, but the pattern they set can be read and interpreted by a customized smartphone. Contrary to Madej’s and Mercola’s claims, these are not permanent, as the currently estimated time during which they can be read is five years. Moreover, these quantum dot tags are not nearly as nefarious as Madej and Mercola make them sound. For one thing, knowing who’s already received a specific vaccine can protect that person from unnecessarily being advised to receive that vaccine again if there is uncertainty over whether they have ever had it. Also, this technology is a long way from being ready for prime time. It is, however, unsurprising that Madej and Mercola would weave a conspiracy theory about it; this is also likely the origin of the conspiracy theory about COVID-19 vaccines claiming that they will implant a chip, and some of the conspiracy theories about it go right into tinfoil hat territory, with one crank claiming, “This vaccine will not only “mark” you like a cattle, you will be injected with nano particules that will make a you a Perfect antenna for the 5G frequencies wich they will use to track you, make you feel and think anything they want” and Madej saying:
We’re gonna be branded. Each person will have their own ID. This reminds me of World War II. You know, it’s something to think about, being branded like a product in the store…So we’ll be branded. What can that be used for. There are lots of technologies out there, and that’s something we need to be concerned about.
Gee, that reference to World War II and branding wouldn’t be a reference to the Nazis tattooing prisoner identification numbers on the inmates in their concentration camps, would it? More importantly, neither the Moderna nor the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines use microneedles or quantum dot tags.
But back to Madej and Mercola’s other claims about RNA vaccines:
Getting back to the mRNA vaccines, time will tell just how hazardous they end up being. Clearly, if the changes end up being permanent, the chance of long-term side effects is much greater than if they end up being temporary.
In a worst-case scenario, whatever changes occur could even be generational. The problem is these issues won’t be readily apparent any time soon. In my view, this vaccine could easily turn into a global catastrophe the likes of which we’ve never experienced before.
We really should not be quick to dismiss the idea that these vaccines may cause permanent genetic changes, because we now have proof that even conventional vaccines have the ability to do that, and they don’t involve the insertion of synthetic RNA.
I love that first paragraph. It’s the very epitome of “just asking questions” (a.k.a. JAQing off), in which a crank claims just to be asking questions, never mind that the questions are based on pseudoscience, bad science, and claims that science doesn’t support. Moreover, this not-so-dynamic duo seem utterly oblivious to the difference between somatic cells and germ line cells. Alteration of the DNA in somatic cells (every cell in the body except for cells that make eggs in females and sperm in males) are not propagated to the next generation. Alterations of DNA in germline cells can be passed on to the next generation, but there’s no evidence that the mRNA in vaccines like the Moderna or Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines can permanently alter germline DNA – because these vaccines can’t alter any DNA in cells permanently in the way that Madej and Mercola claim.
But what are we to make of Mercola’s claim that “even conventional vaccines can alter DNA”? It’s nonsense, of course. Let’s look at Mercola’s example:
After the H1N1 swine flu of 2009, the ASO3-adjuvanted swine flu vaccine Pandemrix (a fast-tracked vaccine used in Europe but not in the U.S. during 2009-2010) was causally linked9 to childhood narcolepsy, which abruptly skyrocketed in several countries.
Children and teens in Finland, the U.K. and Sweden were among the hardest hit. Further analyses discerned a rise in narcolepsy among adults who received the vaccine as well, although the link wasn’t as obvious as that in children and adolescents.
A 2019 study16 reported finding a “novel association between Pandemrix-associated narcolepsy and the non-coding RNA gene GDNF-AS1″—a gene thought to regulate the production of glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor or GDNF, a protein that plays an important role in neuronal survival.
They also confirmed a strong association between vaccine-induced narcolepsy and a certain haplotype, suggesting “variation in genes related to immunity and neuronal survival may interact to increase the susceptibility to Pandemrix-induced narcolepsy in certain individuals.”
Steve Novella has discussed the issue of whether Pandemrix caused a spike in the incidence of narcolepsy in these countries. It’s important to note that this is a strange case. The association was only observed in specific countries and not in others (including the US) in which the vaccine does not appear to be a consistent or unique risk factor for narcolepsy in these populations. Overall, it was a confusing set of data to derive any clear picture of whether the H1N1 vaccine was a true risk factor. On the other hand, there are data suggesting that Pandemrix might trigger the production of antibodies that can also bind to a receptor in brain cells that help regulate sleepiness in genetically susceptible people. Basically, the whole situation is confusing, and it’s not clear if any of the H1N1 vaccines truly caused narcolepsy.
Also, the study cited by Mercola does not show that the H1N1 vaccine caused permanent genetic changes. The investigators did a genome-wide association study (GWAS), a type of study that frequently finds associations that do not hold up to scrutiny but can nonetheless be useful for hypothesis generation. What this study shows is an association between the haplotype and “vaccine-induced narcolepsy”, not that the H1N1 vaccine produced “permanent genetic changes”. Mercola is either grossly ignorant of basic molecular biology, or he’s lying, knowing that his audience doesn’t know the difference. Take your pick. (I know which option I pick.)
An new spin on an old antivaccine trope
The bottom line is that the fear mongering by Drs. Madej and Mercola is nothing new. The lie that vaccines somehow permanently alter your DNA is not a new one; the rise of mRNA-based vaccines simply makes it easier for antivaxxers to spin a convincing yarn making such false claims. Indeed, I saw the very same claim, namely that vaccines are transhumanism, eight years ago, when Sayer Ji wrote a hilariously silly piece claiming that vaccines are transhumanism in the service of subverting evolution because they interfere with how we have co-evolved with pathogens. (I certainly hope they interfere with our co-evolution with pathogens! That’s rather the point, I’d say!) A few years later, antivaxxer Sherri Tenpenny was making the same sort of nonsensical argument, but by then antivaxxers had started pointing to DNA vaccines as a hopelessly unnatural corruption of our genes. Throughout it all, antivaxxers were also making ridiculous claims about how trace amounts of contaminating DNA from the cell lines used to grow viral antigens for some vaccines can somehow get into the brain, express “non-self” proteins, and trigger an autoimmune response causing autism. Truly, to antivaxxers, DNA and RNA are magic!
When you come right down to it, this new spin on an old antivaccine trope is nothing more than an appeal to “nature” as being somehow always superior to anything humans can do. Indeed, Dr. Madej’s video is nothing new. Months before, a “natural healing consultant” named Dr. Andrew Kaufmann was featured in a video in which he made very similar claims, including that a future COVID-19 vaccine would provide a vessel to “inject genes” into humans, first by a procedure known as “electroporation”, in which an electric current “create[s] little holes in our cells that allow the DNA to go into our own cells” and then through the insertion of “foreign proteins that supposedly generate immunity”. Kaufman even concluded that such an mRNA vaccine, like the results of biotechnology in agriculture, will turn humans into “genetically modified organisms”.
Of course, as I mentioned before, biology is more complex than the central dogma, which was based on an understanding of molecular biology that is now 60 years old. That’s why I, as I enter the conclusion of this post, I will link to an article by Edward Nirenberg, which gets into the weeds of the exceptions to the central dogma as he refutes the nonsensical idea that mRNA vaccines permanently alter your DNA and concludes, quite reasonably:
There is no feasible means by which an mRNA vaccine could end up in the nucleus of a cell, nor prime a reverse transcription reaction, nor give you a mitochondrial disease.
There is no reasonable possibility based on the totality of our knowledge of cell biology, reverse transcriptases, human genetics, and the immune system that mRNA vaccines can affect your DNA.
We should await the detailed safety data, but, a priori, a segment of RNA encoding the spike protein RBD of SARS-CoV-2 with no replicative potential, and no ability to form whole virus, nor even whole ability to form an ENTIRE spike protein, should be expected to be a safe vaccine that isn’t going to cause these insane pie-in-the-sky science fiction scenarios.
If you are worried about the mRNA vaccines, then don’t get them. The data suggest that there will soon be other kinds of vaccines with good efficacy as well. I, however, am content to roll up my sleeves for one of them.
As I likely will be, once they are available.
On a final note, let me just conclude with a thought about the ridiculous claim that mRNA vaccines permanently alter your DNA or somehow make you “transhuman”. You have to remember that antivaxxers view vaccines as somehow “unnatural” to the point of altering what human beings are. They’ve been making that clear ever since I started paying attention to antivaccine pseudoscience two decades ago, and were doing so long before that. Of course, just because something is natural does not make it good, benign, or even just neutral. Nature is harsh, and the battle for survival brutal, and it’s completely “natural” for all manner of animals to be eaten by bigger, faster, and hungrier animals, and it’s just as natural for humans do die horrible deaths from infectious diseases. Indeed, just look at how horrible the deaths suffered by over 260K of my fellow Americans have been, and COVID-19 is entirely “natural”. Yet the mindset behind so much of “alternative” medicine and antivaccine views is that natural is always good and that anything synthetic should be viewed with extreme suspicion. (Come to think of it, that’s why COVID-19 denialists go to such enormous lengths to falsely portray SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes the disease, as somehow “unnatural” and bioengineered in a laboratory, with the pandemic being a “plandemic” initiated by global elites to control and subjugate the population.) It’s silly, because even “natural” nutrients and medicines are just as much chemicals as any synthetic nutrient or chemical. We have to judge whether such chemicals are harmful based on science and where the evidence leads us, not based on whether the chemical is “natural” or not. When considering claims about a novel disease such as COVID-19 and vaccines against it, we must also consider the totality of what we know about biology, especially molecular biology, and how a potential vaccine works in assessing the plausibility of alarmist claims about vaccines like those developed by Moderna and Pfizer. Claims that mRNA vaccines like these can “permanently alter your DNA” (or make you “transhuman”) fail miserably on that score.
Think of the claims about mRNA vaccines this way. They are very much of a piece with how quacks glom on to any new finding in molecular biology, particularly the way quacks have hijacked the new science of epigenetics to claim that you can use mind-body interventions to reprogram your own DNA. In quackworld, RNA and DNA are magic, and the disinformation about mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 reflects that belief in magic.

Antivaxxers, COVID-19 vaccines, and “hacking the software of life”
Antivaxxers and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists were always going to spin conspiracies about COVID-19 vaccines. Unfortunately, some scientists have made it so much easier for them by having likened mRNA vaccines to “hacking the software of life” and being unclear on what gene therapy is.
David Gorski on April 5, 2021
Link

Words matter.
If there’s one thing that I’ve learned over the years combatting science denial, quackery, and antivaccine propaganda and conspiracy theories, it’s that messaging is important. At no time in my life have I seen this more than now, in the middle of a pandemic, and I’d like to do something a little different from what I normally do here on SBM and discuss an example. It’s an example in which early messaging used years ago to promote and sell a promising new technology has been weaponized by antivaxxers and COVID-19 minimizers to demonize COVID-19 vaccines. You might recall a post of mine from two months ago, when I discussed how mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines by Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna are not “gene therapy”. Think of this as a follow-up looking at how that claim by antivaxxers came about.
Actually, there are three highly related claims that antivaxxers have been using to sow fear, uncertainty, and doubt about mRNA-based vaccines:
    • mRNA-based vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” (No, they don’t.)
    • mRNA-based vaccines are not vaccines, but “gene therapy” (No, they are not. They are vaccines.)
    • mRNA-based vaccines are like a “software update” for your body (A very bad analogy, as I will discuss below.)
As I discussed before, the claim that vaccines can “permanently alter your DNA” is not a new claim. Antivaxxers have been making this claim almost as long as I’ve been paying attention to the antivaccine movement and its disinformation. So it should come as no surprise that antivaxxers dusted off this hoary old disinformation chestnut to use on COVID-19 vaccines. There was no way that anyone could have stopped antivaxxers from making that claim. In contrast, the proliferation of disinformation that mRNA-based vaccines are “gene therapy” like “a software upgrade for your body” is largely a self-inflicted wound that derives from early hype over the new technology by Moderna. Don’t believe me? Take a look at this article by über-quack and “alternative health” entrepreneur Joe Mercola, entitled “COVID-19 Vaccines Likened to ‘Software Updates’ for Your Body“, where Mercola basically tells you where antivaxxers got these talking points from.
First, though, as an aside I can’t help but mention that, so prolific is Mercola’s empire of antivaccine and COVID-19 disinformation, that I could, if I so desired, devote my entire blog output, both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, to nothing other than countering Mercola’s misinformation, disinformation, distortions, and lies, and I would still not be able to keep up. The same could be said about antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s website Children’s Health Defense. Between the two of them, Mercola and RFK Jr. produce a veritable tsunami of antivax propaganda far beyond what science advocates can keep up with. That’s what we’re dealing with here, and they are far from alone.
Now let’s get into the details.
Quoth Mercola: Moderna said its vaccine is a “gene therapy product”
In this post, Mercola makes a number of claims, the first of which is that lipid nanoparticle-encapsulated mRNA has been described as “gene therapy” in filings by Moderna and that BioNTech’s SEC filing states that in the U.S. and Europe, mRNA therapies are classified as “gene therapy medicinal products”. And it’s true. Liposomal mRNA has been developed to be used as a gene therapy, but that’s not all it’s been developed and used for. Intent and method matter, which is no doubt why Mercola contorts himself and his words to deny that these vaccines function as “vaccines” in order to claim that they are “treatments”, all while weaving dark conspiracy theories (of course):
However, despite being a recognized form of gene therapy since its inception, vaccine makers are now frantically trying to deny that this mRNA technology is gene therapy. One reason for this, suggested by David Martin, Ph.D.,1 might be because as long as they’re considered “vaccines,” they will be shielded from liability.
Experimental gene therapies do not have financial liability shielding from the government, but pandemic vaccines do, even in the experimental stage, as long as the emergency use authorization is in effect. Another reason might be because they fear people won’t line up for experimental gene therapy. It has a very different connotation in people’s minds (as it should).
A third possibility is that they know full well that you cannot, ethically, mandate gene therapy in the way you can mandate vaccines. Mandatory public health measure directives are typically based on the idea that it’s acceptable for some individuals to be harmed as long as the measure benefits the collective.
Well, the COVID-19 “vaccines” are only designed to lessen symptoms of COVID-19. They do not prevent infection or spread, and since the vaccinated individual is the only one receiving a potential benefit, “the greater good” argument falls apart.
Who knows, there may be other factors at play that we’ve not realized as of yet, but whatever the reason, they really do not want you to think of these injections as gene therapy. They want you to accept them as any other conventional vaccine.
First of all, Mercola is a bit behind the times, data-wise. While it is true that the original clinical trials that resulted in the approval of these two vaccines could not determine if they prevented infection or transmission but only if they prevented COVID-19 disease (which, by the way, they were highly effective at doing), time hasn’t stood still, nor has science. A mere two days before Mercola posted the above, the CDC published a study of interim estimates of vaccine effectiveness among health care personnel, first responders, and other frontline workers. Guess what the conclusion was? The study found that the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines were, in fact, very effective at preventing infection. Nearly four thousand people were studied, and it was found that, under real-world conditions, mRNA vaccine effectiveness of full immunization (≥14 days after second dose) was 90% against SARS-CoV-2 infections regardless of symptom status (meaning that the vaccine prevented asymptomatic infection as well). Even better, vaccine effectiveness of partial immunization (≥14 days after first dose but before second dose) was 80%, meaning that just one dose of either of these vaccines likely still provides substantial protection against infection. Is the study perfect? Of course not. More data will be required. The study is, however, excellent evidence that both of these vaccines function as, to rub it in Mercola’s face, highly effective vaccines.
Why would this distinction matter, though, other than to fuel Mercola’s conspiracy theory that, if only these “gene therapy treatments” could be reclassified as vaccines, big pharma could profit? First, it’s useful to look at the FDA’s definition of gene therapy, given that the FDA is the agency that would have to approve and license any new “gene therapy”:
Human gene therapy seeks to modify or manipulate the expression of a gene or to alter the biological properties of living cells for therapeutic use 1.
Gene therapy is a technique that modifies a person’s genes to treat or cure disease. Gene therapies can work by several mechanisms:
    • Replacing a disease-causing gene with a healthy copy of the gene
    • Inactivating a disease-causing gene that is not functioning properly
    • Introducing a new or modified gene into the body to help treat a disease
    • Gene therapy products are being studied to treat diseases including cancer, genetic diseases, and infectious diseases.
There are a variety of types of gene therapy products, including:
    • Plasmid DNA: Circular DNA molecules can be genetically engineered to carry therapeutic genes into human cells.
    • Viral vectors: Viruses have a natural ability to deliver genetic material into cells, and therefore some gene therapy products are derived from viruses. Once viruses have been modified to remove their ability to cause infectious disease, these modified viruses can be used as vectors (vehicles) to carry therapeutic genes into human cells.
    • Bacterial vectors: Bacteria can be modified to prevent them from causing infectious disease and then used as vectors (vehicles) to carry therapeutic genes into human tissues.
    • Human gene editing technology: The goals of gene editing are to disrupt harmful genes or to repair mutated genes.
    • Patient-derived cellular gene therapy products: Cells are removed from the patient, genetically modified (often using a viral vector) and then returned to the patient.
In order to preempt anything Mercola might have claimed about this definition having been “changed” to accommodate Moderna and Pfizer’s vaccines, I used the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org to find a version of this page from June 2019. It’s basically the same. Nothing about mRNA is mentioned. Another reason why mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are not gene therapy is that gene therapy is designed to “treat a disorder by inserting a gene into a patient’s cells instead of using drugs or surgery”, either by replacing a mutated copy of the gene with a good copy, inactivating a gene that is making too much of its product or otherwise not functioning properly, or to induce cells to make a therapeutic protein. Here’s the thing. The SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, which is what the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines induce cells to make, is not a therapeutic protein. It does not treat or modulate disease. It is being used solely as an antigen to stimulate an immune response by the body against a viral protein, and only over the short term, long enough to stimulate that response.
So why did Moderna include this passage from the 2020 Moderna SEC filing, quoted by Mercola and every antivaxxer I’ve seen making this claim? Here’s what I mean:
Currently, mRNA is considered a gene therapy product by the FDA. Unlike certain gene therapies that irreversibly alter cell DNA and could act as a source of side effects, mRNA-based medicines are designed to not irreversibly change cell DNA; however, side effects observed in gene therapy could negatively impact the perception of mRNA medicines despite the differences in mechanism.
To be honest, I found that passage by Moderna to be a head-scratcher, because nowhere could I find evidence that the FDA considered mRNA products to be a “gene therapy product”, and even sources that discuss RNA-based products along with gene therapy tend to separate the two based on mechanism. On the other hand, I noted the care with which Moderna stated that mRNA vaccines might be considered a “gene therapy product,” not “gene therapy”. Here’s what I mean. What does “gene therapy” of any sort make? mRNA, that’s what, and that mRNA is then translated into protein. Thus, mRNA is the product of gene therapy, not the gene therapy itself, because mRNA doesn’t actually alter genes and DNA. (More on that later.)
Going through this, I rather suspect that this was done out of an abundance of caution, as evidenced by the next part of the paragraph in Moderna’s SEC filing:
In addition, because no product in which mRNA is the primary active ingredient has been approved, the regulatory pathway for approval is uncertain. The number and design of the clinical trials and preclinical studies required for the approval of these types of medicines have not been established, may be different from those required for gene therapy products, or may require safety testing like gene therapy products. Moreover, the length of time necessary to complete clinical trials and to submit an application for marketing approval for a final decision by a regulatory authority varies significantly from one pharmaceutical product to the next, and may be difficult to predict.
Unfortunately, this backfired in that it allowed Mercola and David Martin (who makes the same sort of claim and who was a big part of the Plandemic 2 conspiracy video and who’s made the false claim that mRNA-based vaccines are “legally gene therapy“) to run with this sort of stuff straight into conspiracytown:
Well, the pandemic allowed them to sneak mRNA gene therapy under the proverbial radar so that they don’t have to conduct more stringent gene therapy safety testing. Instead, they were handed the global population for the largest testing imaginable, and all without liability when something goes wrong — provided it’s viewed as a “vaccine,” that is.
Of course, I can’t be too hard on Moderna. Even in a global pandemic, how many corporations are sufficiently aware of how antivaxxers misuse and twist language to make sure not to use language like this? Moreover, this SEC filing is from June, which was still relatively early in the pandemic. The message that COVID-19 vaccines based on RNA would “alter your DNA” was not yet widespread because these vaccines were still in early clinical trials and there was much skepticism over whether they would ultimately turn out to be effective.
In any event, as I said before, intent matters, as does the specific gene product being coded for by the mRNA. The SARS-CoV-2 spike protein is neither a human gene, nor is it therapeutic. It’s intended only as an antigen to stimulate an immune response; making it part of a vaccine, not a “gene therapy”. This can’t be repeated often enough.
Of course, it should also be noted that Moderna did make a distinction between its vaccines and gene therapy, and even Mercola had to acknowledge that and try to tear it down. First, here’s Moderna’s SEC filing:
Gene therapy products have the effect of introducing new DNA and potentially irreversibly changing the DNA in a cell. In contrast, mRNA is highly unlikely to localize to the nucleus, integrate into the DNA, or otherwise make any permanent changes to cell DNA. Consequently, we expect that our investigational medicines will have a different potential side effect profile from gene therapies.
This explains why Mercola has to go so far as to invoke highly dubious and speculative science to claim that, no, really, mRNA from a vaccine can alter your DNA, and he gets rather ridiculous about it:
However, some doctors still worry that mRNA injections might be able to reverse-transcribe into your genes and alter your DNA on a permanent basis. One is Dr. Richard Urso, an ophthalmologist, who shared his concerns on a December 2020 episode of The Shepard Ambellas Show.3,4
He claimed the mRNA of retroviruses (which are part of our genome) have been shown to have the ability to transcribe into your DNA, and if it can do that, vaccine mRNA might be able to do this as well. According to Urso, if this turns out to be correct, the result of mRNA vaccination might be lifelong COVID-19.
This is pure handwaving, a claim that, because one type of virus, a retrovirus, can reverse transcribe its RNA to DNA and integrate that DNA into our genome, that must mean that a completely different type of virus that only shares the use of RNA as its genetic material. (A clear, simple explanation of how coronaviruses replicate can be found here.) It’s pure speculation. Even worse is the claim that, if the coding sequence for the spike protein were to be integrated into the human genome, it would result in lifelong COVID-19. As an aside, I can’t help but note that Dr. Urso is an ophthalmologist known for his promotion of hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19. He has no special expertise in molecular biology that I’ve been able to find. Indeed, his handwaving and his claim that an integrated gene for the spike protein would cause “lifelong” COVID-19 tells me that, without my even having to look him up.
Merola also quotes someone named Doug Corrigan, PhD, who does have a PhD in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, which is why he should know better than to cite a December study posted to the preprint server bioRxiv that claims to show that SARS-CoV-2 RNA can be reverse-transcribed and integrated into the human genome. First, as always, with preprint articles, I note that this has not gone through peer review, which makes me wonder why it’s still on bioRxiv nearly four months after it was posted. It might be worth a post going into more detail as to why this study’s conclusions are not supported by its experiments and data, but This Week In Virology spent much of a recent episode explaining why this study doesn’t show what its authors claim it shows, and Ed Nirenberg delved into the methodology to come to the same conclusions, noting:
A preprint has emerged claiming that there is evidence that SARS-CoV-2 is reverse transcribed and integrated into the human genome. None of the evidence it provides justifies such a conclusion, and it demonstrates a failure to understand fundamental aspects of coronavirus biology and frankly the limitations of the methods used to make that conclusion. Furthermore there even appears to be an attempt by the preprint authors to make their data more difficult to scrutinize because it is available only upon request and not included in the paper. Its findings, even if true (something I have significant doubts about), have no relevance for mRNA vaccines.
It is always a red flag to me when the authors don’t make their datasets from such experiments easily available, but I especially like where Nirenberg sums it up:
On the point of what this means for an mRNA vaccine: literally nothing. This paper has absolutely nothing to do with them. If you’re wondering what would happen if the RNA from a vaccine were accidentally picked up by this proposed mechanism and integrated into the host cell, any of the following scenarios:
    • The sequence would behave like a processed pseudogene, lacking any ability to recruit host transcription machinery and would sit in the genome, quiescent.
    • If the sequence somehow inserted downstream of a promoter sequence that could recruit transcription machinery, the cell would express spike protein, be recognized by the immune system, and then be killed.
    • If the sequence inserted itself into the middle of gene (specifically in the middle of an exon), you would get a mutant protein that had sequences from SARS-CoV-2 that would be processed by antigen-presenting machinery and trigger a T cell response that killed the cell.
But antivaxxers like Mercola have to latch on to this study because they can’t make the argument that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are a “gene therapy,” not a vaccine, if they can’t show even a ghost of a mechanism by which the RNA from such vaccines could alter cellular DNA.
“Hacking the software of life”: Salesmanship versus cranks
It might be a bit harsh of me to say that the “mRNA vaccines are gene therapy” narrative by antivaxxers is a self-inflicted wound. However, it is not at all harsh to point out how Moderna scientists and executives selling their technology provided antivaxxers with language that they could easily weaponize against COVID-19 vaccines. In particular, Mercola makes a lot of this 2017 talk by Dr. Tal Zaks, chief medical officer of Moderna, in which he likened mRNA vaccines to “hacking the software of life”:
I groaned as I read the transcript:
“We’ve been living this phenomenal digital scientific revolution, and I’m here today to tell you that we are actually hacking the software of life, and that it’s changing the way we think about prevention and treatment of disease,” Zaks said.
“In every cell there’s this thing called messenger RNA or mRNA for short, that transmits the critical information from the DNA in our genes to the protein, which is really the stuff we’re all made out of. This is the critical information that determines what the cell will actually do. So, we think of it as an operating system …
“So, if you could change that … if you could introduce a line of code, or change a line of code, it turns out that has profound implications for everything, from the flu to cancer …
“Imagine if instead of giving [the patient] the protein of a virus, we gave them the instructions on how to make the protein, how the body can make its own vaccine,” he said.
It’s even in the Moderna mission statement:
Recognizing the broad potential of mRNA science, we set out to create an mRNA technology platform that functions very much like an operating system on a computer. It is designed so that it can plug and play interchangeably with different programs. In our case, the “program” or “app” is our mRNA drug – the unique mRNA sequence that codes for a protein.
I really, really despise computer analogies for what are core molecular biology concepts, even as I can see why they’re attractive to tech entrepreneurs. In any event, see how fast this particular analogy has been weaponized by antivaxxers, leading to Leo Hohmann, for instance, writing posts like “Will you allow Big Pharma to install its ‘computer operating system’ into your body?” Just Google “Moderna hacking the software of life” and see what you come up with. You’ll see stuff like:
It gets worse, though, and Mercola gleefully takes advantage of Moderna’s loose analogies:
Zaks further differentiates conventional vaccines and mRNA vaccines by explaining that when using a conventional vaccine, you have viral protein floating around outside the cell, whereas the mRNA approach reprograms the cell to create that viral protein inside of itself.
“What’s more alarming?” he asks. “A stranger prowling the neighborhood, or somebody who just broke into your ground floor and tripped the alarm? That’s what happens with an mRNA vaccine. You’ve tripped the alarm wire and now the cell is dialing 911, it’s calling the police — at the same time that it’s making the protein, saying ‘That’s the bad guy.’ That’s how an mRNA vaccine works.”
Zaks also refers to the company’s mRNA shots as “information therapy,” which is just another way of saying gene therapy because mRNA is a carrier of genetic code. (For clarification, code in your natural mRNA matches your DNA, whereas vaccine mRNA has no equivalence inside your genome since it’s coming from the outside. Vaccine mRNA still carries “genetic code,” though, just not anything found in your body before.)
Zaks’ analogy to a prowler doesn’t even make a lot of sense biologically or as an analogy. He seems to be likening the RNA from a vaccine to being a “prowler” compared to the “prowler” of the virus outside of the cell. It’s no wonder that antivaxxers can so easily turn such language against COVID-19 vaccines, as it Zaks seems to be implying that the body is more alarmed by RNA in its cells than it is from foreign protein circulating in the body. As for “information therapy”, my only thought reading that dates back to the early 1980s: Gag me with a spoon.
Seriously, I wish Moderna would lose this particular analogy. It’s done (and continues to do) so much harm. I understand why it is attractive to view mRNA as “software”, but in reality it’s not. If you really wanted to pursue the analogy, I’d say that DNA is the software, mRNA is the compilation of that software, and the protein is the output, but even that’s a strained analogy. However you look at that analogy, though, it allows Mercola to pull off a favorite old antivaccine trope, one that was resurrected for COVID-19 vaccines, namely that vaccines are “transhumanism“, a claim by antivaxxers that I first noticed in 2012.
Seriously, look at Mercola run with this:
In true technocratic, transhumanist Fourth Industrial Revolution fashion, Zaks and other mRNA pushers view the body as your hardware, your genetic code as software and these mRNA injections as software updates. As noted by Patrick Wood in a recent Technocracy News article:15
“Pure and simple, this is unvarnished, raw transhumanism … Scientists think they can rewrite the genetic code [his words, not mine, for all you out there who still don’t believe these mRNA vaccines change the genetic code just because some ‘fact checker’ says they don’t], believing they can improve on a person’s God-given genetic makeup is entering dangerous territory …
These scientists truly believe that the human body is nothing more than a machine that can be hacked into and reordered according to some programmer’s instructions … Who’s to say they won’t correct one problem and create something far worse?”
And, of course, according to Mercola, transhumanism due to COVID-19 vaccines is part and parcel of the “Great Reset”, a conspiracy theory claiming that the pandemic was engineered by the global elites to allow for a “reset” in which they take control of the world economy. I can’t help but note that “the Great Reset” is another example of how poorly chosen words basically give conspiracy theorists a gift. “The Great Reset” really is a plan first proposed by the World Economic Forum exploring how countries might recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. I mean, seriously? Who thought of this term? Who at Moderna thought it would be a good idea to present their treatments as “hacking the software of life”, given all the negative connotations of hacking?
Again, words matter. While I can’t be too hard on Moderna for being cautious in its SEC filing and using language that reflected regulatory uncertainties of the time, I can blame Tal Zaks and the leadership of Moderna for using such easily weaponized analogies, such as “hacking the software of life” to sell its product to investors. I can blame the World Economic Forum for coming up with a term like the “Great Reset”. These words matter, and these words have been a gift to COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and a burden to those trying to counter disinformation.

The return of the revenge of “COVID-19 mRNA vaccines permanently alter your DNA” and “lab leak”
Claims that COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” or that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered in a lab were resurrected last week based on two dubious studies. No matter how many times you think these myths have been debunked, they always come back for another installment of the same misinformation franchise.
David Gorski on February 28, 2022
Link

As repetitive as I have been with respect to this, there is nothing new under the sun when it comes to antivaccine myths, misinformation, and disinformation, and that applies to COVID-19 vaccines. If public health officials and messengers had paid more attention to the tactics and tropes of the antivaccine movement, including its central conspiracy theory, maybe they would have been more prepared for the onslaught of antivaccine misinformation that was unleashed as the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines were undergoing clinical trials and when they were finally initially approved under an emergency use authorization (EUA) near the end of 2020. They didn’t, and here we are, which is why, having seen it before multiple times last year, I’m faced with the return of the revenge of the antivaccine lie that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” (they don’t, nor do they “hack the software of life“, nor are they really “gene therapy“) this time from Jessica Rose, who is affiliated with James Lyons-Weiler‘s antivaccine “institute” with the humble name of Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge (IPAK). Unfortunately, Saturday I saw this zombie lie resurrected yet again in the form of an article on Substack (where the cranks who’ve been banned from Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, etc. all go) by Rose titled “It does incorporate into human DNA. And it’s probably messing up embryogenesis“, subtitled, These injectable convid-1984 products are perfect bioweapons—either by design or accident. Who cares which. The outcome is the same.
Once more unto the breach, I guess! I suppose that while I’m here I should link to the two studies published last week and cited by Rose in her Substack to support her nonsensical claims that (1) the finding of a short nucleotide sequence in the spike protein mRNA sequence used in the Moderna vaccine is slam dunk evidence that SARS-CoV-2 was “engineered” and that the “lab leak” hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 is true and (2) that SARS-CoV-2 “permanently alters your DNA” by being reverse transcribed and integrated into the DNA in its recipient’s chromosomes. Let’s just say that neither Rose’s cited study from Lund University in Sweden about the supposed reverse transcription of the Pfizer/BioNTech mRNA-based vaccine into the DNA of human cells nor the study by Ambati et al about MSH3 homology support these hysterical claims.
Before I proceed, let’s just reiterate that the idea that vaccines can “permanently alter your DNA” is not new to mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, although the nature of these vaccines makes that claim easier for antivaxxers to sell as plausible to those not familiar with molecular biology. Indeed, if you really look carefully at it, the claim that vaccines somehow changes your DNA actually dates back to before scientists even understood DNA as the basis of heredity, as illustrated, for example, by this famous “Cow-Pock” cartoon from 1802 by satirist James Gillray about smallpox vaccine:

Savvy readers will notice how much a meme that was going around a year or so ago about the mRNA vaccines is very much of a piece with this 220-year-old cartoon:

Similarly, the idea that an “engineered virus,” whether intentionally released or accidentally “leaked” from a laboratory, caused the pandemic is the same conspiracy theory that arises during every epidemic and pandemic, from various influenza pandemics to AIDS to Ebola. Of course, in the age of sophisticated molecular biology and genetics, antivaxxers can always find a special case that seems to show that the impossible is actually possible, and Jessica Rose is just continuing in this antivax tradition of misusing science, as I’ll try to explain.
The “central dogma” of molecular biology, or: Why mRNA vaccines do not “alter” your DNA
Before I discuss the two studies and the claims being made about them not just by Jessica Rose but by a number of antivaxxers, let’s take a look at some basic biology and molecular biology, so that you understand why her claims are so beyond the ken. I realize that I’ve done this before, but it’s been a while; so instead of just including links to my previous discussions, I’ll include a brief explanation of something out of Biology 101, so that we’re all on the same page. If you know all of this, you can probably skip to the next section. If not, let’s proceed.
mRNA vaccines rely on the “central dogma” of molecular biology. As I’ve said many times before, I’ve always hated the use of the word “dogma” associated with science, but no less a luminary than Francis Crick first stated it in 1958, and it has been restated over the years in various ways. Perhaps my favorite version of the central dogma was succinctly stated by Marshall Nirenberg in 1958 and has since been commonly paraphrased to say, “DNA makes RNA makes protein”, which about summed up all of molecular biology in five words. (Why I used the past tense in a moment.) In any event, for purposes of understanding the very basics of RNA vaccines, this is the main sequence that you need to understand.
It’s true, of course, that DNA replicates from a DNA template and results in a double-stranded molecule that is very stable, as it has complementary sequences that tightly bind to each other in a sequence-specific fashion. This DNA template is unwound by enzymes that use the template to make RNA, which is single-stranded. That RNA—when used to code for a protein called a “messenger RNA” or “mRNA”—is then used by a ribosome to make protein out of amino acids. Again, to put it simply, each nucleotide equals one letter of the code; each three-nucleotide sequence (codon) equals one “word” that translates to an amino acid. Given that there are four nucleotides, there are 64 possible codons. Since there are only 20 amino acids, that means that most amino acids are encoded by more than one combination of nucleotides or more than one codon; i.e., the genetic code is redundant. Of course, as is the case with nearly everything in biology, it’s more complicated than that, as these diagrams show:


There are more complications to this seemingly simple scheme, of course. mRNA doesn’t always start out fully formed. Often it’s made as a longer precursor molecule, parts of which are spliced out by enzymes, to produce the final mRNA sequence before the mRNA molecule is used as a template to make protein. There are also other complexities that go beyond the central dogma, such as retroviruses, which make DNA using RNA templates, and microRNA, which can regulate gene expression by binding to specific sequences on mRNAs and blocking transcription and/or inducing the breakdown of the mRNA molecule, for instance. You don’t really need to know the gory details of these processes or others, though, except retroviruses, whose ability to “reverse the flow of information”, so to speak, by transcribing DNA off of an RNA template using an enzyme known as reverse transcriptase will be very relevant to the discussion of the Swedish paper. HIV is the retrovirus that is the most well-known because of its ability to cause AIDS.
Exceptions aside, RNA vaccines consist mainly of, well, RNA. One problem with RNA vaccines is that RNA is an inherently unstable molecule. It is, after all, a messenger. It doesn’t need to persist any longer than the message needs to be made. In aqueous solution, RNA molecules rapidly degrade. Indeed, the instability of RNA is why public health experts have been concerned about distributing RNA vaccines. Both Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna adopted a similar strategy in designing their mRNA to encode the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein with stabilizing mutations added to lock this surface protein into a form easily recognizable to the immune system and therefore make it a better antigen. Pfizer and Moderna also used modified nucleosides (the RNA equivalent to DNA nucleotides) that are more stable to make their RNAs, and placed their RNA within a lipid nanoparticle (LNP) delivery system in which LNPs fuse with the cell membrane to deliver the RNA to the cytoplasm.
Naked mRNA of kind used in the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna vaccines rely on a very simple mechanism in which the LNPs deliver the mRNA for the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein to muscle cells, which then use the mRNA as a template to make spike, which is then displayed on the surface of the cell to be recognized by the immune system. Some of the vaccine does manage to get to the regional lymph nodes, where they incite an immune reaction as well. This is part of the reason why COVID-19 vaccines have been found to produce false positives in mammography done too soon after vaccination by causing temporary enlargement of the lymph nodes under the arm, which is why mammography recommendations have changed to incorporate waiting at least six weeks after receiving an intramuscular COVID-19 vaccine in the deltoid muscle before undergoing screening mammography.
Before I go on, let me emphasize that, even though SARS-CoV-2 is an RNA virus, it is not the same thing as a retrovirus and the mRNA in LNPs is not the same thing as RNA in retroviruses. Whereas SARS-CoV-2, like most RNA-based viruses, uses an enzyme called an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) to make copies of its RNA genome from an RNA template, retroviruses use an enzyme called reverse transcriptase to produce a DNA copy of their genetic information, which can then integrate into the human genome. That’s why, in order to produce a suitably fear-mongering narrative, antivaxxers usually have to look very hard for highly unusual, artificial, or special case experiments. Guess what? Rose found them.
The dreaded “Cow-Pock” all over again
So let’s see what Jessica Rose wrote about these studies. Her message is, unsurprisingly, very much like that of antivaxxers 220 years ago:
I started to write this article yesterday but not one, but two papers of great interest to me have been published recently and require dissection and dissemination. They are entitled: “MSH3 Homology and Potential Recombination Link to SARS-CoV-2 Furin Cleavage Site” and “Intracellular Reverse Transcription of Pfizer BioNTech COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine BNT162b2 In Vitro in Human Liver Cell Line“, respectively.
Let me be clear here: These COVID-19 injectable products are perfect bioweapons – either by design or accident. Who cares which. The outcome is the same.
Regarding the first paper, Rose writes:
Background for future: MSH3 (MutS Homolog 3) is gene that encodes a protein that is responsible for maintaining the stability of our genomes and suppressing tumor formation. This protein is DNA mismatch repair (MMR) protein which means that it recognizes and repairs bad base (nucleotide) insertions, deletions and mis-incorporations that come about inherently as part of DNA recombination and replication as well as DNA repair. You might have heard me talk about this in some of my presentations in reference to the recently-published paper describing 2 enzymes characterized to be inhibited by the spike protein.
…we found that the spike protein localizes in the nucleus and inhibits DNA damage repair by impeding key DNA repair protein BRCA1 and 53BP1 recruitment to the damage site.
This more recent paper shows the presence of a 19 nucleotide-long sequence (19mer) that in fact, contains the sequence that encodes the furin-cleavage site of the SARS-nCoV-2 spike protein. In other fact, this 19mer has 100% sequence identity (100% query cover and matched identity anti-parallel complementarity 5′-3′) with patented sequences from as early as 2015. (I am checking on the link to MSH3.)1
Aha! There’s the conspiracy theory! (More on that later.) First, though, I’ll just note that this is far from the first time that I’ve seen the claim that COVID-19 vaccines somehow interfere with DNA repair. Last time around, it was the claim that the vaccine somehow interferes with a process known as non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) and thereby make those receiving it much more susceptible to cancer. That claim was deceptive. Indeed, the study was very poor quality and had no biological relevance to human cancer risk, although it did contribute to the fascist antivax claim that vaccines somehow “pollute” the blood, making the unvaccinated “purebloods“. Unsurprisingly, it’s exactly the paper Rose cited.
As for the second study, Rose is no less…off base:
Perhaps even more disturbing from a biological point of view, is something that many of us have hypothesized to be possible, has now been proven to be the case. Another new paper (link above) confirms that the Pfizer mRNA incorporates into human DNA. IN AS LITTLE AS 6 HOURS.
We detected high levels of BNT162b2 in Huh7 cells and changes in gene expression of long interspersed nuclear element-1 (LINE-1), which is an endogenous reverse transcriptase.
Huh is right.
Huh cells are ‘immortal’ liver tumor cells and grow ad-infinitum if you give them love. They are good for using in assays that involve viral propagation. LINE-1 is a reverse transcriptase that we carry and comprises ~17% of our genome! LINE-1 retrotransposons are necessarily active during embryogenesis are aberrantly active in tumorigenesis.
This claim, as has often been the case, rests on a kind of experiment that’s been done a number of times before to try to “prove” that the RNA virus SARS-CoV-2 can somehow mimic a retrovirus and insert its genetic sequence into the human genome, just like HIV. That’s why I’ll discuss this study first.
Artificial, thy name is this study
Before I discuss this study, let’s just reiterate that, for all the caveats and exceptions to the central dogma of molecular biology, for the vast majority of cases in normal mammalian cellular biology, information does not “flow backwards” from RNA to DNA. One of those exceptions, HIV and other retroviruses, requires two different enzymes to accomplish this “backwards” flow of genetic information. The first is the aforementioned reverse transcriptase, which “reverse transcribes” RNA sequences into DNA, destroying the RNA template in the process. However, that is not enough, as reverse transcriptase does not integrate the DNA strands thus produced into the human genome. A second enzyme is needed, a retroviral integrase. Integrases insert the double-stranded DNA produced by reverse transcriptase into the host’s chromosomal DNA; you can view this as a “point of no return,” after which the viral DNA becomes part of the host DNA, a form in which it is called a provirus, and a property of retroviruses that allow them to persist for so long in their hosts.
Retroviruses are not the only source of reverse transcriptase, as noted by Jessica Rose. Mammalian cells have very low levels of reverse transcriptase activity, so low that they’re usually not detectable under normal circumstances. One source is telomerase, which adds sequences known as telomere repeat sequences to the ends of chromosomes using an RNA template, to forestall the obligate chromosome shortening that occurs with each round of cellular replication. (Excessive telomerase activity is associated with the unlimited replicative potential of cancer.) Then there is LINE-1, mentioned by Rose and the focus of the paper.
LINE stands for long interspersed nuclear elements (LINEs). They are what are known as retrotransposons, also known as class 1 transposable elements or transposons via RNA intermediaries. Basically, retrotranposons can copy and paste themselves into different locations in the genome by making RNA and converting that RNA back into DNA through reverse transcription. Because it’s simple, I’ll “borrow” an illustration of how they work from Wikipedia:

You might reasonably be wondering at this point what LINE-1 could have to do with genetic sequences from the vaccine somehow getting into the human genome, thereby “permanently altering your DNA”. You’d be correct to wonder and likely would wonder even more if I told you that most LINEs in our genome are inactive and don’t make any functional enzyme and that they greatly prefer their own RNA and don’t randomly reverse transcribe just any old RNA. After all, retrotransposition (the process) requires that retrotransposons be able to replicate themselves and then paste the new copies elsewhere in the genome. It doesn’t matter that, as Rose points out, LINE-1 does make up approximately 17% of the human genome. Very little of it is active in normal physiology, although increased LINE-1 is associated with cancer, neuropsychiatric disorders, and retinal diseases. (I almost hated to say that because it gives antivaxxers ideas.)
So what does the second study cited by Rose claim? What did the investigators do? First, let’s look at the investigators’ rationale:
A recent study showed that SARS-CoV-2 RNAs can be reverse-transcribed and integrated into the genome of human cells [25]. This gives rise to the question of if this may also occur with BNT162b2, which encodes partial SARS-CoV-2 RNA. In pharmacokinetics data provided by Pfizer to European Medicines Agency (EMA), BNT162b2 biodistribution was studied in mice and rats by intra-muscular injection with radiolabeled LNP and luciferase modRNA. Radioactivity was detected in most tissues from the first time point (0.25 h), and results showed that the injection site and the liver were the major sites of distribution, with maximum concentrations observed at 8–48 h post-dose [26]. Furthermore, in animals that received the BNT162b2 injection, reversible hepatic effects were observed, including enlarged liver, vacuolation, increased gamma glutamyl transferase (γGT) levels, and increased levels of aspartate transaminase (AST) and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) [26]. Transient hepatic effects induced by LNP delivery systems have been reported previously [27,28,29,30], nevertheless, it has also been shown that the empty LNP without modRNA alone does not introduce any significant liver injury [27]. Therefore, in this study, we aim to examine the effect of BNT162b2 on a human liver cell line in vitro and investigate if BNT162b2 can be reverse transcribed into DNA through endogenous mechanisms.
This is thin gruel as a rationale. I note that I’ve discussed the cited study before, which involved the intravenous injection of a large amount of LNPs with a different mRNA than the vaccine’s spike protein mRNA, again an artificial design intended to make determination of the biodistribution of the LNPs possible given that in an intramuscular injection the vast majority of the mRNA remained at the injection site and in nearby lymph nodes.
I also note that it is not a new claim that SARS-CoV-2 itself is reverse transcribed in the infected cell to integrate with the host genome. This is a study from last summer that antivaxxers previously used to claim that, based on the supposed ability of SARS-CoV-2 to reverse transcribe, the vaccine could do the same. Let’s just say that this study was justifiably harshly criticized as not reproducible, very rare, and almost certainly artifacts of the experimental conditions used, given that appropriate controls weren’t used. To cite Ed Nirenberg again, no, SARS-CoV-2 is not reverse-transcribed to any significant extent, the publication of the study in PNAS notwithstanding.
I get the same vibes from this new study. So what did the authors do? They did indeed take Huh7 liver cells and expose them to the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine (BNT162b2), at 200,000 cells/well in 24-well plates. Then they did this:
BNT162b2 suspension was then added in cell culture media to reach final concentrations of 0.5, 1.0, or 2.0 μg/mL. Huh7 cells were incubated with or without BNT162b2 for 6, 24, and 48 h. Cells were washed thoroughly with PBS and harvested by trypsinization and stored in −80 °C until further use.
After 48 hours, the cells were harvested. RNA was extracted for PCR, and in other experiments genomic DNA was extracted from the cells. Of particular importance however, is that the segment of the nucleic acid for the spike protein that was amplified by PCR was this:
Why did they pick primers that amplified only this segment of the gene for spike protein? PCR efficiency drops off the longer the segment that is amplified, and a 444 base segment is actually rather long for quantitative real time PCR. In any event, this choice means that the only thing that can be said is that perhaps this segment of spike was reverse transcribed. Another thing to note is that a very high concentration of vaccine was used, microgram quantities for only 200,000 cells. That in and of itself is very artificial, but that’s not all that’s artificial. As Ed Nirenberg points out, Huh7 was derived from a liver cancer. Unsurprisingly, the Huh7 genome is, as is the case with many cancer-derived cell lines, really messed up.
He also notes that L-1 expression is substantially overexpressed in cancer (i.e., cancer cells have a lot more of it than normal cells).
In fact, cancer cell genomes substantially overexpress L1:https://t.co/uDDgSrly46
L1 expression is directly related to the cell's DNA damage response:https://t.co/LV9NCaQVX7
L1 levels are even being proposed as a biomarker to cancer screening:https://t.co/3Of4JFnqYV
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) February 26, 2022
In other words, the investigators stacked the deck by using a cell line that has a high level of LINE-1. If I were a peer reviewer for this study, I would have demanded that the investigators use a more genomically “normal” cell line. No cell line that is immortal—can propagate indefinitely—has a “normal” genome, but some have genomes that are less messed up than others. There are a number of respiratory cell lines, for instance, that could work, or what about simple primary cultures of vascular endothelial cells, such as HUVECs (human umbilical vein endothelial cells)? Why did they use only one cell line? In general, if you see a paper that uses only one cell line, be very, very skeptical, not just for COVID-19 but for any basic science studies.
So back to the paper. What did the authors find? Yes, they found that the vaccine, as expected, drove spike mRNA expression, leading to high levels in the cells, while not having much effect on LINE-1 expression, concluding that increased LINE-1 expression compared to control was observed at 6 h by 2.0 µg/mL BNT162b2, while lower BNT162b2 concentrations decreased LINE-1 expression at all time points. If you look at the figure, I call noise, because it doesn’t make a lot of physiologic sense that the lower vaccine concentrations would depress LINE-1 expression but lead to increased expression only at the 6 hour time point.

Hilariously, this chart is the very same one included in Rose’s article, but she fails to see its shortcoming. Amusingly, the authors used two-tailed Student’s t-tests to compare these differences, which is not the correct statistical test for multiple time-dependent comparisons, and the finding of this result is most consistent with noise. Had I been a peer reviewer, I would definitely have called out the statistics used.
But what about reverse-transcribed DNA for spike? Yes, the authors did detect that in the genomic DNA isolated from the cells. They even sequenced the amplified segment and found that it was the same spike sequence targeted by the PCR primers. Checkmate, scientists! Not quite, and the authors even add some weasel words:
In this study we present evidence that COVID-19 mRNA vaccine BNT162b2 is able to enter the human liver cell line Huh7 in vitro. BNT162b2 mRNA is reverse transcribed intracellularly into DNA as fast as 6 h after BNT162b2 exposure. A possible mechanism for reverse transcription is through endogenous reverse transcriptase LINE-1, and the nucleus protein distribution of LINE-1 is elevated by BNT162b2.
Note that this study most definitely did not show that this reverse transcription had anything to do with LINE-1, leaving the authors to speculate. They could have presented evidence that LINE-1 was responsible, perhaps by knocking it out to produce cells that don’t make it or using siRNA that targets the LINE-1 mRNA to decrease its level, and showing that that it blocked the reverse transcription of spike. They didn’t do that. So they speculate, and antivaxxers ignore that this is speculation to present it as a fact that SARS-CoV-2 is reverse transcribed through the reverse transcriptase activity of LINE-1.
Next:
Our study shows that BNT162b2 can be reverse transcribed to DNA in liver cell line Huh7, and this may give rise to the concern if BNT162b2-derived DNA may be integrated into the host genome and affect the integrity of genomic DNA, which may potentially mediate genotoxic side effects. At this stage, we do not know if DNA reverse transcribed from BNT162b2 is integrated into the cell genome. Further studies are needed to demonstrate the effect of BNT162b2 on genomic integrity, including whole genome sequencing of cells exposed to BNT162b2, as well as tissues from human subjects who received BNT162b2 vaccination.
This led to some epic handwaving:
The cell model that we used in this study is a carcinoma cell line, with active DNA replication which differs from non-dividing somatic cells. It has also been shown that Huh7 cells display significant different gene and protein expression including upregulated proteins involved in RNA metabolism [56]. However, cell proliferation is also active in several human tissues such as the bone marrow or basal layers of epithelia as well as during embryogenesis, and it is therefore necessary to examine the effect of BNT162b2 on genomic integrity under such conditions. Furthermore, effective retrotransposition of LINE-1 has also been reported in non-dividing and terminally differentiated cells, such as human neurons [57,58].
Sure thing, guys, but no. This is, as I said, just handwaving.
As Ed Nirenberg asks, why didn’t they bother to do the necessary follow-up experiments to determine if this DNA sequence is actually integrated into the genome? Come to think of it, why didn’t they do PCR of the entire spike sequence to show that the full length sequence had been reverse-transcribed? Or even just do PCR of different fragments from the spike sequence? It boggles the mind.
None of this stops Rose from going straight off the end of the plank of science to this conclusion:
LINE-1 retrotransposons are also involved during early embryonic development. Since LINE-1 expression levels are significantly increased then what effect is this over-expression having on embryogenesis?
We found that too much or too little LINE-1 expression caused development to come to a halt. This means that the precise timing and level of retrotransposon expression is critical for the development of the embryo.”
I need a walk. This article will be updated.
I can hardly wait for Rose’s “updates”, given how far she had to reach to find some rationale to take a highly artificial experiment that almost certainly doesn’t show that the mRNA for the SARS-CoV-2 spike used in COVID-19 vaccines is reverse transcribed under normal conditions, much less “integrated” into the genome of the cells in which it finds itself. I’m guessing that her “updates” will be as hilariously off base as her original post.
But what about the first study?
Moderna and the “lab leak”
The second paper cited by Rose turns out to be all about the “lab leak” conspiracy theories. It’s not about the more plausible variant of the “lab leak” concept (but still highly unlikely compared to a natural origin) in which a naturally occurring bat coronavirus somehow escaped the virology lab at Wuhan, thereby starting the pandemic, but rather the utter bonkers idea that SARS-CoV-2 is an “engineered” coronavirus that escaped the laboratory, thanks to “gain of function” research. Of course this version is a different twist on the same idea, specifically that the finding of a short DNA sequence from a larger sequence patented by Moderna years ago as part of its cancer research effort in the sequence in the spike protein mRNA used in the Moderna vaccine is slam-dunk evidence for the “lab leak” hypothesis. Let’s just say that it’s not.
The article is a perspective article, which means it’s basically the peer-reviewed scientific equivalent of an op-ed article. I also can’t help but wonder how the authors got something like this published on the basis of doing some BLAST searches of the Genbank database, something basically anyone with an Internet connection can do to see if nucleotide and protein sequences exist in all the ones reported to the database. I used to do BLAST searches all the time, and have even done a few going way, way back to the beginning of the pandemic, when James Lyons-Weiler tried to “prove” that there were sequences from a common plasmid in SARS-CoV-2, thus demonstrating that it was “engineered.” (Hint: He failed.)
The op-ed asserts:
A peculiar feature of the nucleotide sequence encoding the PRRA furin cleavage site in the SARS-CoV-2 S protein is its two consecutive CGG codons. This arginine codon is rare in coronaviruses: relative synonymous codon usage (RSCU) of CGG in pangolin CoV is 0, in bat CoV 0.08, in SARS-CoV 0.19, in MERS-CoV 0.25, and in SARS-CoV-2 0.299 (9).
A BLAST search for the 12-nucleotide insertion led us to a 100% reverse match in a proprietary sequence (SEQ ID11652, nt 2751-2733) found in the US patent 9,587,003 filed on Feb. 4, 2016 (10) (Figure 1). Examination of SEQ ID11652 revealed that the match extends beyond the 12-nucleotide insertion to a 19-nucleotide sequence: 5′-CTACGTGCCCGCCGAGGAG-3′ (nt 2733-2751 of SEQ ID11652), such that the resulting mRNA would have 3′- GAUGCACGGGCGGCUCCUC-5′, or equivalently 5′- CU CCU CGG CGG GCA CGU AG-3′ (nucleotides 23547-23565 in the SARS-CoV-2 genome, in which the four bold codons yield PRRA, amino acids 681–684 of its spike protein). This is very rare in the NCBI BLAST database.
The correlation between this SARS-CoV-2 sequence and the reverse complement of a proprietary mRNA sequence is of uncertain origin. Conventional biostatistical analysis indicates that the probability of this sequence randomly being present in a 30,000-nucleotide viral genome is 3.21 ×10−11 (Figure 2).
Wow. That sounds damning, doesn’t it?
Of course, those following various “lab leak” hypotheses for the origin of SARs-CoV-2 will immediately recognize the reference to the furin cleavage site. An interesting feature of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein is that it consists of two subunits and, between those two subunits, S1 and S2, sits a site where a human protein called furin cleaves the protein, resulting in the two functional subunits. In fact, you might even recognize the claim that the two successive CGG codons, coding for two arginine residues in the furin cleavage site, is a rare codon usage. Let’s just say that, in terms of the pandemic, this is a hoary old bit of SARS-CoV-2 conspiracy mongering dating back to very early in the pandemic and popularized by science writer-turned-COVID-19-conspiracy theorist Nicholas Wade. Moreover, the term “randomly present in a 30 kb viral genome” is doing a lot of heavy lifting, mainly because no one is saying that it’s random. Do the authors think that beta coronaviruses (of which SARS-CoV-2 is one) are made up of random sequences unrelated to each other? Of course not! They’re highly related.
Indeed, it has been pointed out just how off-base the probability argument is:
Lawrence Young, Ph.D., a virologist at the University of Warwick, said it was interesting but probably not significant enough to suggest the virus was manipulated in a laboratory. “We’re talking about a very, very, very small piece made up of 19 nucleotides. So it doesn’t mean very much to be frank, if you do these types of searches you can always find matches. Sometimes these things happen fortuitously, sometimes it’s the result of convergent evolution (when organisms evolve independently to have similar traits to adapt to their environment). It’s a quirky observation but I wouldn’t call it a smoking gun because it’s too small. It doesn’t get us any further with the debate about whether COVID was engineered.”
Simon Clarke, Ph.D., a microbiologist at Reading University, also questioned the one-in-three trillion statistics, saying, “There can only be a certain number of [genetic combinations within] furin cleavage sites. They function like a lock and key in the cell, and the two only fit together in a limited number of combinations. So it’s an interesting coincidence but this is surely entirely coincidental.”
If you’re a conspiracy theorist, of course, there is no such thing as a coincidence, at least if it’s about something you want to believe to be true. In any event, this is exactly correct. The wrong argument to make is how common such a 19 nucleotide sequence would occur randomly in a viral genome. You have to take into account function, which greatly constrains the sequences one can find, plus how short this sequence is, which makes it very much more likely that it did indeed occur by chance.
As I’ve discussed before, it turns out that a CGGCGG sequence is not all that uncommon. It has been found in other coronaviruses, for example, some isolates of MERS coronavirus. Furin cleavage sites are also found in a number of other coronaviruses, as discussed in this recent review article. Although uncommon, furin cleavage sites are not so uncommon in coronaviruses as to be any sort of strong evidence of laboratory manipulation. Moreover, there are known natural mechanisms by which such a sequence could have arisen, as has been discussed extensively on Twitter and elsewhere. But what about that 19-nucleotide sequence?
I will note, however, that the claim made in this op-ed is a rather interesting spin on the same old claims about the SARS-CoV-2 furin cleavage site in that I haven’t seen it before. In this case, the authors are claiming that this 19 nucleotide sequence found in MSH3, a DNA repair gene, is the very same sequence patented by Moderna seven years ago and found in the furin cleavage site of the spike sequence used in the Moderna vaccine, with the implication that SARS-CoV-2 was “engineered”:
The proprietary sequence SEQ ID11652, read in the forward direction, encodes a 100% amino acid match to the human mut S homolog 3 (MSH3) (9). MSH3 is a DNA mismatch repair protein (part of the MutS beta complex) (11). SEQ ID11652 is transcribed to a MSH3 mRNA that appears to be codon optimized for humans (12). We did not find the 19-nucleotide sequence CTCCTCGGCGGGCACGTAG in any eukaryotic or viral genomes except SARS-CoV-2 with 100% coverage and identity in the BLAST database (Supplementary Tables 1–3).
A claim that the authors make explicit:
The absence of CTCCTCGGCGGGCACGTAG from any eukaryotic or viral genome in the BLAST database makes recombination in an intermediate host an unlikely explanation for its presence in SARS-CoV-2.
Ergo, this sequence must have been “engineered”. Add to that the Moderna patent and checkmate, right? Not so much. For one thing, this sequence is the reverse complement of the sequence found on the furin cleavage site. What does that mean? It’s on the opposite strand, the strand that doesn’t code for protein. The authors do a lot of handwaving to try to explain this, mainly by claiming that “cells co-transfected with a SARS-like virus expressing RdRp could attach to this 19-nucleotide sequence (15) and permit integration of a fragment from the negative strand into the viral genome, including the FCS, despite being on the opposite strand of the open reading frame,” RdRp being the RNAse-dependent RNA polymerase mentioned early in this post. Perhaps, but this comes across to me more as an attempt to wave away the very substantive criticism that a sequence that isn’t the strand that codes for the actual protein.
Just for yucks, I did some BLAST searches myself, and after doing a number of them I concluded that this result was not easy to come by. I had to search the sequence patented by Moderna versus SARS-CoV-2 with the “loosest” parameters that allowed for the least degree of similarity; otherwise there were zero matches, largely because stricter parameters only find longer stretches of sequence similarity. That’s why I now rather suspect that the investigators searched the sequence for SARS-CoV-2 versus every sequence ever patented by Moderna, and the best they could come up with was this short 19 amino acid match, after which, even though it was the reverse complement and not even on the strand that codes for the protein, started searching other Moderna patents for the same 19mer and found a few more hits.
Making me even surer that this is random is Rose’s own further observations:
Most disturbing, however, is that HZ246785.1 was patented 7 years ago by MODERNA THERAPEUTICS (2015) and more recently by ModernaTX Inc (2017/2018). Other patents for this same 19mer were filed by CAMBIA (2015) and CureVac AG (2021). A shorter version with 89% query and 100% matched identity were found in patents filed by Monsanto Technology LLC (2016) and Metanomics GmbH (2015). Just noting some familiar names here. Not making any claims.
Then, thankfully, bioinformatician Moreno Colaiacovo provided a lengthy explanation dating back to December why there’s nothing to see here; so I’ll cite his brief discussion in its entirety:
When challenged, Colaiacovo noted:
And:
Think of it this way. Whoever initially found this 19 nucleotide sequence did a lot of work to find it. Yet, this is the best they could come up with as slam dunk “evidence” that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered by Moderna, to the point where they have to do serious contortions make such a short stretch seem nefarious? Another way to think of it is just how unlikely it is that this shared 19-mer is proof of some sort of engineering or that Moderna “knew” about SARS in 2016. Again think of how unlikely the implied necessary scenario would be: Somehow during an experiment cells transfected with the sequence in the patent were infected by a SARS-like virus, and then there was a recombination event that led to SARS-CoV-2 with a furin cleavage site containing that sequence—and not even on its coding strand, but on its reverse complement strand! This is reaching homeopathy-levels of implausibility.
Everything old is new again
As I like to say, in antivaxland, everything old is new again in the age of COVID-19. However, as the pandemic grinds on, entering its third year, even everything old that was new again when COVID-19 struck is becoming old. The idea that COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” has now spawned a number of—if you’ll excuse my use of the term—variants. So has the version of the “lab leak” hypothesis that asserts that SARS-CoV-2 was somehow “engineered”, this variant adding a conspiracy theory that implies that one of the manufacturers of the first successful COVID-19 vaccines must have somehow “known” the sequence of SARS-CoV-2 nearly four years before the pandemic. What Jessica Rose is promoting, aided and abetted by these awful studies published in bottom feeding journals, is simply helping to spread variants of these two conspiracy theories.

“The vaccinated are a danger to the unvaccinated because of shedding!”: The latest COVID-19 antivaccine disinformation
Antivaxxers are masters of projection, which is why the latest antivaccine disinformation about COVID-19 vaccines is that they lead the recipient to “shed” spike protein, which can can cause menstrual irregularities or even miscarriages in women who come into contact with the vaccinated and even make people very sick. This trope is nothing more than a clever repackaging of the old antivaccine distortions and exaggerations about viral shedding after vaccination with live attenuated virus vaccines. Truly, everything old is new again.
David Gorski on May 3, 2021
Link

There’s a new antivaccine trope going around. It’s one I wrote about before over at my not-so-secret other blog a couple of weeks ago, but it’s not going away. If anything, since I wrote about it the first time, it’s been spreading and mutating, producing variants not unlike the manner in which SARS-CoV-2 is mutating into new variants the more it spreads among its human hosts. So I thought I had better deal with this new antivaccine myth here on SBM, as it’s a perfect illustration of how antivaxxers have been revising and repurposing old antivaccine tropes to apply to COVID-19 vaccines, while producing—if you’ll excuse the term, as I can’t resist—variants of antivaccine tropes previously repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines. If you’ve read the previous post, there will obviously be a lot of overlap, but I hope to treat this new and mutating antivaccine trope from a broader perspective in this post; plus, I’ve updated it considerably.
The introduction out of the way, let me just ask: Have you heard about how “shedding” of spike protein from the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, such as the vaccines produced by Moderna or Pfizer/BioNTech, are making the unvaccinated sick and interfering with women’s menstrual cycles (or even causing miscarriages)? It’s producing some really bizarre social media posts:
This is fucking madness. Businesses saying vaccinated people need to only do curb side pick up to protect the women. pic.twitter.com/V4dEMfX1Ox
— Jennifer Gunter (@DrJenGunter) May 2, 2021
Rocky business bans COVID vaccine recipients from entering premesis https://t.co/xEmZ3RpMxv pic.twitter.com/j40DMQkT8A
— rdnewsNOW (@rdnewsNOW) April 21, 2021
“..not.. accepting new.. clients who have taken.. experimental vaccine.. decision.. made in consultation with our insurance.. health professionals.. unknown effects of.. mRNA.. VIRAL SHEDDING..” – CP Fitness – personal health training facility in Waco, Texas pic.twitter.com/Q45O1Iizm3
— Tristan Roetzel (@TristanRoetzel) April 24, 2021
Early evidence of 💉 shedding. Antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and RBD detected in saliva of mRNA-vaccine recipients | News-Medical. https://t.co/0SxQjdpXoN
— Jennifer Ann (@MJPeep555) April 19, 2021
"…the unknown health effects of the mRNA vaccines, as well as reported side effects such as viral shedding, seizures and death following the administration of these vaccines, are not covered by our liability.”https://t.co/MEIs7gudVk
— Dave Nestor (@DaveNestor22) April 14, 2021
MORE VACCINE SHEDDING REPORTS KEEP POPPING UP 💉🚫 pic.twitter.com/rIZA8FCVJ7
— AlottyJ 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🇬🇧 #GodIsLove #WeAreLove (@sarfsee) April 27, 2021
We've heard how the vaccine is disrupting the reproductive system but Dr. Palevsky goes one step further and talks about spike protein shedding. Check out his video.https://t.co/TobBtqKPc8
— Mr. Bill K. (@KieserBill) April 25, 2021
Apparently, even health care professionals, who really, really should know better, have fallen for this trope:
This has made me absolutely livid. An NDIS provider has suspended their services to vaccinated clients due to the incredibly wrong perception of 'viral shedding'.
IT'S NOT A LIVE VACCINE. IT DOES NOT SHED.
I am so ashamed of humanity right now. https://t.co/MlJJkibyDb
— Joel Hill (@krunchymoses) April 22, 2021
Worse, this trope has led at least one private school to place restrictions on teachers who are vaccinated before the end of the school year, as The New York Times reported last week, and even to threaten teachers who receive the vaccine over the summer:
“Even among our own population, we have at least three women with menstrual cycles impacted after having spent time with a vaccinated person,” she wrote, repeating a false claim that vaccinated people can somehow pass the vaccine to others and thereby affect their reproductive systems. (They can do neither.)In the letter, Ms. Centner gave employees three options:
    • Inform the school if they had already been vaccinated, so they could be kept physically distanced from students;
    • Let the school know if they get the vaccine before the end of the school year, “as we cannot allow recently vaccinated people to be near our students until more information is known”;
    • Wait until the school year is over to get vaccinated.
Teachers who get the vaccine over the summer will not be allowed to return, the letter said, until clinical trials on the vaccine are completed, and then only “if a position is still available at that time” — effectively making teachers’ employment contingent on avoiding the vaccine.
If you want to see how much harm this myth of COVID-19 vaccines “shedding” and making people ill is causing, it’s hard to imagine a worse scenario than that of the Centner Academy, where teachers are basically being threatened with losing their job if they get vaccinated against COVID-19.
I could go on and on and on with the Tweets and social media posts by people who think that COVID-19 vaccines cause “shedding” of spike protein that makes others sick, but I’ll stop here, other than to note that prominent spreaders of this antivaccine myth of “shedding” include Naomi Wolf, who has gone full COVID-19 denier/minimizer and antivaccine:
Well hundreds of women on this page say they are having bleeding/ clotting after vaccination or that they bleed oddly being AROUND vaccinated women. Unconfirmed, needs more investigation. But lots of reports. COVID-19 Vaccine Side Effects https://t.co/HyyI4WkaC1
— Dr Naomi Wolf (@naomirwolf) April 19, 2021
And an antivaccine pediatrician whom we’ve met before on this blog, Dr. Lawrence Palevsky, who lent his cachet as a pediatrician to the claim that people vaccinated against COVID-19 “shed” spike protein and make others ill. The antivaccine blog Age of Autism provided a link to his video and a transcript of the video.
What I’ll do in this post is to outline the claims about shedding, follow up with a bit of historical perspective on the claim (which is not new), and then explain why the claim is nonsense, with no evidence to support it. Finally, I’ll try to put the claim in a broader perspective of types of antivaccine messaging.
Three videos on shedding
To give you an idea of the nature of these claims, I will start by presenting three videos. The first two videos are “testimonials” warning people to “stay away” from people who have recently received a COVID-19 vaccine. The first of these is a woman claiming that reproductive-age women should stay away from people who have been recently vaccinated against COVID-19 because they are having “severe” menstrual side effects because…magical contagion? It’s not clear, but here she is:
In brief, this woman claims that women who are around other women who have had the COVID-19 vaccine are missing periods or having the “most excruciating periods of their lives” to the point where they are “bleeding so profusely that it is out of character”. How? Some sort of “shedding” of…something. She even claims that postmenopausal women have been “getting their periods back”, which, if true, would be alarming because postmenopausal bleeding can be a symptom of uterine cancer and is something gynecologists take very seriously indeed.
Unsurprisingly, the woman is a “wholistic reproductive doula”, and, amusingly, she says that this is not about conspiracy theories (even though she claims that “they” are trying to “sterilize us”) and that she is “standing up” for women. Also, “they” are coming for women’s health. But not just women, men, too, as she also claims that the COVID-19 is “dropping men’s sperm counts”. She’s also oh-so-empathetic to the point that she says that if you’ve had the vaccine you shouldn’t feel “shame or sadness”, even though she understands how “natural” that would be. How nice.
Next up is a woman named Nic Stinson, who runs that Truth UnMasked website:
Stinson claims that women and men who have come into close proximity to people who have had vaccines are complaining of problems. She blames it on “shedding,” not of weakened virus, as is the case with some attenuated live virus vaccines—more on that later—but of “shedding” of the spike protein due to “mRNA gene therapy” that is “altering the makeup of the human body.” (Yes, she’s using all the antivaccine tropes about the COVID-19 vaccine, including the distortion of fact that it’s “experimental gene therapy” that “permanently alters your DNA.” I guess she’s afraid of her precious bodily fluids being sapped and impurified.) In any event, she claims that the vaccinated are “shedding” spike protein from their breath, and that that’s making others who come into contact with them sick, causing reproductive problems, mass sterilization, and more. She also claims that exposure to vaccinated adults have resulted in ten year olds starting their periods or 11-year-olds having two periods in a month, as if that were horrifically abnormal. (My wife is a pediatric nurse practitioner. She tells me that it is not at all abnormal to start periods at age 10, and it’s quite common for a girl’s periods to be irregular right after menarche.) Stinson also reiterates the other claims of postmenopausal women starting their periods again and reproductive age women missing periods or having horrible periods, adding to that the claim that men whose wives have had the vaccine sometimes wake up covered in bruises.
I had never heard of Nic Stinson before, but a quick Google search quickly led me to her Twitter account and Instagram page, which reveals her to be antivax and antimask to the extreme, as well as, or so she claims, a nurse. Here are just a couple of examples:




View this post on Instagram










A post shared by Nic Stinson (@nicstinson)




View this post on Instagram










A post shared by Nic Stinson (@nicstinson)




View this post on Instagram










A post shared by Nic Stinson (@nicstinson)
Oh, goody. She’s repeating the claim that vaccines are “transhumanism“, and she’s not just antivaccine, but offensively and disgustingly ableist, to boot, not to mention homophobic and vindictive! She also seems to think that people who wear masks are pedophiles, too:
How do people like Nic Stinson become nurses? Nic Stinson appears to be Nicolle Wagner-Stinson, former Director of Nursing at a nursing home in Ilion, NY, who plead guilty to “covering up sexual abuse and neglect” there, in 2015.
And what is “vaccine shedding”, anyway?
First, let’s look at the claim, as described by Dr. Palevsky in his viral video. I choose this video as the version of the “shedding” claim to examine, because it contains all the common elements of this particular piece of disinformation that I’ve seen floating around social media and Dr. Palevsky seems to be one of the main originators of the claim.
Dr. Palevsky explains shedding…badly
Let’s move on to Dr. Palevesky’s video. As antivax pediatricians always do, Dr. Palevsky believes that, whatever the problem, real or imagined or made up, it really, really, really must be the vaccine. He even proposes a nonsensical mechanism, “shedding”:
I can’t help but “thank” the Laura Hayes at AoA for helpfully providing me a transcript, so that I don’t have to transcribe relevant passages myself—or even watch the entire video (and so that you, if you don’t want to, don’t have to actually watch the thing).
Let’s dig in:
When studies are done on injections that are thought to be vaccines, we sometimes need 7, 10, or even 15 years, to understand what the injection does to the body, and what it does to those around us.
How did Dr. Palevsky ever manage to graduate from medical school and get through a pediatrics residency? Seriously. How? No, we do not need that long to determine how vaccines affect us. In general, adverse events from vaccines generally occur fairly quickly, and, no, vaccines do not cause autism, autoimmune disease, diabetes, or all the other chronic illnesses that antivaxxers attribute to vaccines. Whenever you hear an antivaxxer opining about how we don’t know about “long term” effects of vaccines, this is what is meant, that we “don’t know” if the vaccine(s) can cause autism and other chronic conditions. We do, actually, to a very high degree of confidence. Vaccines don’t cause any of those things.
Next up, Dr. Palevsky further demonstrates his lack of understanding of biology, infectious disease, and immunology. Either that, or he has such contempt for his audience that he is knowingly misrepresenting the situation. Take your pick:
The other thing is that we are made to believe in the public eye that this is a vaccine against a viral infection. So, the entire world is thinking that this is a vaccine to protect us against SARS-COV2 infection. And when you have a vaccine that is supposed to be effective as a vaccine, you are supposed to have antibody immunity against the SARS-COV2 virus. And that has never been evaluated with these injections as to whether or not we have antibody immunity to a SARS-COV2 virus. Instead, what we have is the genetic information of what is believed to be a piece of the SARS-COV2 virus, and that piece is called the spike protein. And the technology that is being used is a technology to make this injection that has never been used in vaccine science or methodology before with any kind of success.
So, we are essentially taking the genetic instructions that make a synthetic spike protein, believed to be a part of the SARS-COV2 virus, and we are giving those sets of instructions into the body and asking the human body to take the genetic instructions of that spike protein and make more of it in our own machinery. And so this messenger RNA technology, which is what it is called, is delivering the genetic instructions for us to make the spike protein. And the problem is that no study has ever been done to test its safety. But, also, no study has been done to test whether we turn on the production of that spike protein, and ever turn it off.
Again, even though the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines were made in record time, the groundwork for their development was two decades in the making, as scientists have been developing this technology for SARS, MERS, and other coronaviruses, as well as for other viral diseases. Contrary to what antivaxxers like to claim or imply, mRNA vaccine technology did not just magically appear last spring as the pandemic took off. Indeed, it’s been said that, had COVID-19 hit us five years ago, the technology would not have been ready yet, and we wouldn’t have had a vaccine so quickly. As for the claim that “no study” has been done to test the safety of such vaccines, that’s just nonsense. No, it’s a lie. For the mRNA vaccines, there were phase 3 studies involving a total of over 70,000 subjects, and now that over 240 million doses of these vaccines have been administered in the US alone, the post-vaccination safety monitoring has been intense and found no serious safety signals for mRNA vaccines. Even in the case of the J&J and AstraZeneca vaccines, which do use the spike protein as the antigen but use replication-deficient adenovirus vectors to induce recipient cells to make spike protein, the monitoring system has found rare, literally one-in-a-million adverse events in basically real time, as discussed by Steve Novella and a certain friend of the blog.
Even more ignorant, though, Dr. Palevsky doesn’t seem to know that if you produce an effective immune response to a key protein of a virus (or even just a key portion of a key protein), as long as the protein or fragment of a protein used as an antigen was well-chosen, the immune response provoked by that antigen can attack the virus and prevent infection. That’s the whole idea of not using killed whole cell vaccines (in the case of bacterial diseases) or inactivated virus vaccines (in the case of viral diseases). That’s the whole attraction of using recombinant protein as a vaccine antigen. It’s much “cleaner” and easier to scale up.
Dr. Palevsky then disingenuously implies that, because spike protein has been associated with various toxicities from COVID-19, then it must be toxic if it is “shedding”:
And so spike protein in the naturally occurring SARS-COV2 viral infection has been shown to cause brain inflammation and neurological damage, heart attacks, lung disease, liver disease, kidney disease, and interacting with the male and female reproductive systems, along with affecting blood binding to oxygen and blood clotting. And so we know that the natural disease of SARS-COV2, because of the effects of the spike protein, is making people sick with all of these kinds of systemic illnesses. And so now we are taking that spike protein genetic instructions and we are asking our bodies to make more of that spike protein. And so by making more of that spike protein, we are essentially creating the symptoms and the illness of Covid 19, by giving people the potential to have brain damage and neurological damage, lung disease, liver disease, kidney disease, heart attacks, strokes, blood clotting issues, and impairments to male and female reproductive systems. And there is no study to show whether when the body starts manufacturing this synthetic spike protein, whether or not we ever turn off the production of that spike protein. And so that spike protein is known to be pretty damaging to the human tissue.
Yes, spike protein causes problems when it is being made in large quantities as part of a coronavirus infection. Vaccine safety monitoring of hundreds of millions of people after having received hundreds of millions of doses of these vaccines have failed to find any safety signal suggestive of any of the claims made by Palevsky. In addition, it’s just plain wrong to say that we don’t know how long the body keeps making spike protein after vaccination. The vaccines were designed such that the modified mRNA from the vaccine lasts longer than “natural” mRNA, but not indefinitely. Like all mRNAs, the mRNA for the spike protein used in COVID-19 vaccines degrades fairly quickly and goes away. As this article explains:
RNA is required for protein synthesis, does not integrate into the genome, is transiently expressed, is metabolized and eliminated by the natural mechanisms of the body and is therefore considered safe4,5,6,7. RNA-based prophylactic infectious-disease vaccines and RNA therapeutic agents have been shown to be safe and well-tolerated in clinical trials.
I’ve pointed out before that the vaccines do not induce your cells to produce spike protein for more than 10-14 days. Seriously, does Dr. Palevsky think that figuring out how long the mRNA persists and how long it can induce the production of spike protein wouldn’t have been among the first priorities in the preclinical development of an mRNA-based vaccine to COVID-19? Think of it this way: Why do the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna vaccines require a second dose at three and four weeks, respectively? If the mRNA from the vaccine keeps making spike protein indefinitely (or even forever), as antivaxxer “just asking questions” imply, then why would a second dose be required so soon after the first dose?
But, of course, Dr. Palevsky continues to “just ask questions”:
So we know that spike protein has been found in saliva, we know that it has been found in the anus, and so, we have to ask the question, is it found in the exhalation molecules that come out of our breath? Is it found in the skin when we sweat and we smell, do the spike proteins come out, and if so, does that impact other people with whom we come in contact?
Note how he cites no evidence that spike protein is being exhaled. Even though spike protein has been found in saliva and in the anus, this was in patients with COVID-19, not in vaccinated patients. But Dr. Palevsky is “just asking questions”! See:
And so what we have been seeing is a massive increase in those who have been given the injection of blood clotting problems, miscarriages, stillborns, infertility, strokes, heart attacks, autoimmune diseases, and death, just to name a few. And that’s in those who have been injected. So, certainly, there should be a suspicion when you see people around the injected people, who have not been injected, getting the typical symptoms of Covid, in addition to miscarriages, bleeding, irregular menstrual cycles, it should raise a very, very strong suspicion. So, certainly, there should be a suspicion when you see people around the injected people, who have not been injected, getting the typical symptoms of Covid, in addition to miscarriages, bleeding, irregular menstrual cycles, it should raise a very, very strong suspicion.
No. It should not. It might if this were an attenuated live virus vaccine, but it’s not. It’s a vaccine that just makes one protein from the virus, the spike protein, to which Dr. Palevsky seems to attribute magical properties, even as he invokes very bad molecular biology:
And the thing is that we are finding that the genetic instructions of the spike protein are not specific just to the SARS-COV2 virus. The genetic instructions of the spike protein are also similar to, or the same, as many proteins that exist in the body itself. And so, therefore, if we are going to produce an antibody against the genetic instructions of the spike protein, those antibodies are going to find every bit of protein tissue around the body that matches the genetic instructions of the spike protein. And that antibody to the spike protein genetic instructions is going to produce an attack on any of the proteins and tissues in the body that are similar or the same to the genetic instructions of the spike protein. So that is why you will see autoimmune diseases.
Somebody get Dr. Palevsky a college-level introductory molecular biology textbook! Why? He seems not to know the difference between “genetic instructions”, mRNA, and proteins. He seems to think that an immune response to an mRNA strand coding for a protein will attack the protein itself and any protein that looks like it, thus producing autoimmune disease. Truly, Dr. Palevsky needs a remedial course in basic biology and molecular biology. (Either that, or, again, he’s lying. Take your pick.)
He even invokes old antivaccine tropes about COVID-19 vaccines that I discussed long ago, such as the claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause miscarriages because of the similarity between parts of the spike protein and an important protein in the placenta called syncytin. (They do not, as the areas of similarity are far too short to result in an immune response against syncytin.) He even refers to an “article from the European literature” that says that the vaccines will “cause the body to make an antibody against the genetic instructions of the spike protein, we will also cause the body to make an antibody against the male and female reproductive systems because those proteins in the male and female reproductive systems had similar instructions to the spike protein”. Is he referring to Michael Yeadon, who apparently once worked for Pfizer but has become a COVID-19 crank? I suspect he is.
In any event, this whole claim that somehow those vaccinated against COVID-19 “shed” spike protein, which then screws up the menstrual cycles of women (or even causes miscarriages in pregnant women) who come into contact with the vaccinated is a clever “two-fer”, repackaging a combination of the myth of “shedding” with the hoary old trope among antivaxxers that vaccines cause female infertility, a trope that had been repackaged earlier, before someone thought of “shedding.”
But don’t listen to those scientists who dismissed these claims based on, essentially, everything we know about molecular biology and immunology telling us they are incredibly improbable. Listen to Dr. Palevsky dismiss these scientists instead:
And so the experts around the world did the following…when they heard this scientific concern, the experts around the world said, oh, but the amount of genetic instructions of the proteins in the male and female reproductive systems are so small in similarity to the genetic instructions of the spike protein, that it really shouldn’t make a difference. And, ladies and gentlemen, that is how we got the science that said there should be no concerns about infertility or miscarriages in men and women, respectively. There were no studies, just an opinion, that said the genetic instructions of the proteins on the male and female reproductive systems were such small similarities to the spike protein, that it shouldn’t matter. And, therefore, it didn’t matter. And so what we are seeing in women who get the injection, is a very large, hundreds of percent increase, in miscarriages and stillborns of their babies, all being reported to VAERS.
Yes, friends. Dr. Palevsky is speaking The Truth that “they” don’t want you to know about and dismiss without studying, pointing to anecdotal reports rather than rigorous epidemiological studies. He’s even going beyond that:
And now what we are seeing is women who are around others who have been injected are having the same experience, which has to raise the suspicion that not only does that messenger RNA make the body produce spike protein on an ongoing basis, but that spike protein is probably shedding out of the breath, the saliva, the skin, and who knows where else in the body it is being shed from.
As a thought experiment, let’s just assume for the moment that there is something to Dr. Palevsky’s speculations other than the ravings of a man who clearly needs to have his medical license taken away and be sent back to remedial basic biology, biochemistry, and molecular biology. Is he saying that spike protein is absorbed through the skin? That’s incredibly unlikely, given the keratinized epithelium that is pretty effective at keeping foreign proteins out, except when broken. Is he saying we’re breathing in spike protein? I suppose it’s possible, but a vaccinated person is not going to make anywhere near the amount of spike protein as someone with an active infection, much less exhale it in quantities that someone is likely to inhale in amounts sufficient to cause toxicity. The reason SARS-CoV-2 is infectious is because droplets containing the virus suspended in the air get inhaled and manage to take up shop in the respiratory tree, replicating and making a lot more virus. A protein alone can’t do that. More importantly, it’s not just the spike protein that makes you sick. In fact, the contribution of the spike protein, which is the protein that latches the virus onto cells so that it can infect them, is probably, in and of itself, a relatively small contributor to severe illness in COVID-19. Rather, it’s the virus, its replication in cells leading to massive cell death, and the immune response provoked by the virus in the context of infection that lead to the severe illness we see.
But Dr. Palevsky is “just asking (more) questions”:
Just the last point before you ask me the next question. That is only based on what we think we know is in these injections. But Dr. Tenpenny and I have discussed this on numerous occasions, that there is potential for other mRNA proteins being injected into the body that would cause the body to make all sorts of proteins that we may not be aware of.
“Other mRNA proteins”? Again, Dr. Palevsky, get thee hence to a molecular biology textbook! You’re conflating mRNA and protein. mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines can only induce the cells they come in contact with to make the protein for which the mRNA in the lipid nanoparticles codes. That’s it. This is nothing but a fallacious appeal to what is represented as “unknown” but really isn’t unknown at all! Again, either Dr. Palevsky needs a remedial course in molecular biology or he is lying. Take your pick.
To wrap up this section, I’ll note that I concentrated on the biology, but Dr. Vincent Iannelli has noted that there have been no safety signals to suggest that these vaccines affect menstruation or fertility. He also notes:
Consider Palevsky’s evidence example anecdote of the healthy people who he believes get sick from shedding. Isn’t it more likely that these folks, who you have to assume aren’t vaccinated, are just getting COVID-19?
After all, it isn’t the spike protein in COVID-19 that makes you sick. The spike protein simply helps the virus get into our cells. Once inside, the virus is translated into 29 different proteins, which are assembled into new viruses, and then infect more cells.
But when you get vaccinated, you just have the spike protein. There is no SARS-CoV-2 virus to take over cells, so even if this shedding somehow did happen, it wouldn’t cause any of the signs or symptoms of COVID-19 that Palevsky imagines.
Of course, the antivaccine claim of “shedding” from vaccines is nothing new. Antivaxxers have long claimed that outbreaks of measles are really caused by virus “shed” from the vaccinated. Steve Novella has addressed this claim before. I think it’s worth discussing shedding again, in order to contrast reality with antivaccine claims.
How shedding after a vaccine really works
Regular readers will know that a favorite antivaccine trope is to claim that live attenuated virus vaccines (vaccines using a weakened version of the virus that can’t cause disease) “shed” the virus and that that this attenuated virus is dangerous to those around them. This is a trope that existed long before the COVID-19 pandemic, and is being repurposed by antivaxxers now. Steve Novella has discussed viral shedding in the vaccinated as antivaxxers use it to spread fear of vaccines, but I’m going to go through it as well.
Basically, it’s the antivax answer to the observation that they are potential sources of infection and outbreaks. It’s projection in which they try to convince you that it is the recently vaccinated, not the unvaccinated, who are a danger to the unvaccinated and vaccinated alike. It’s long been very clear to me that the claim that children shed virus and are thus potential vectors for infection is important to antivaxxers because it allows them to portray others as equally, if not more so, the cause of outbreaks than their children, but is there anything to it? Regular readers can probably guess the answer to that question. The answer, of course, is that there’s far less to the issue of virus shedding than meets the eye. As I mentioned above, virus shedding can only occur with live virus vaccines, such as the rotovirus vaccine, oral polio virus vaccines (which are not really used in the US anymore because of a one in 2.7 million risk of paralysis from the vaccine strain of the virus), or intranasal flu vaccines.
There’s a difference between shedding and causing disease, however. For one thing, the strains of virus used in live attenuated virus vaccines are just that—attenuated. They’ve been weakened so that they don’t cause actual disease. Otherwise, using a live virus vaccine would be the same as giving the disease to the person vaccinated, which would rather sabotage the whole purpose of vaccination in the first place. The question, then, is whether secondary transmission (transmission of the vaccine strain virus to others who haven’t received it) is a major concern. The answer to that question is no, as these articles entitled “Secondary Transmission: The short and sweet about live virus vaccine shedding” and “Live Vaccines and Vaccine Shedding“, show.
We learn from the former article that these are the commonly given live virus vaccines:
    • MMR – the combination measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine
    • Vavivax – the varicella or chicken pox vaccine
    • rotavirus vaccines – including two oral vaccines, RotaTeq and Rotarix
    • Flumist – the nasal spray flu vaccine
    • oral polio vaccine – the original oral polio vaccine (sometimes called the Sabin vaccine). Again, this has been replaced in the United States by the inactivated polio vaccine (Salk vaccine)
We also know that:
    • the MMR vaccine doesn’t cause shedding, except that the rubella part of the vaccine may rarely shed into breastmilk (since rubella is typically a mild infection in children, this isn’t a reason to not be vaccinated if you are breastfeeding though). What about the rare case of a person developing measles after getting the MMR vaccine? In addition to being extremely rare, it would also be extremely rare for a person to transmit the vaccine virus to another person after developing measles in this way.
    • the chicken pox vaccine doesn’t cause shedding unless your child very rarely develops a vesicular rash after getting vaccinated. However, the risk is thought to be minimal and the CDC reports only 5 cases of transmission of varicella vaccine virus after immunization among over 55 million doses of vaccine.
    • the rotavirus vaccine only causes shedding in stool, so can be avoided with routine hygiene techniques, such as good hand washing, and if immunocompromised people avoid diaper changes, etc., for at least a week after a child gets a rotavirus vaccine
    • transmission of the live, nasal spray flu vaccine has not been found in several settings, including people with HIV infection, children getting chemotherapy, and immunocompromised people in health-care settings
In other words, the claim that virus shedding is a serious problem is yet another bit of antivaccine nonsense. It’s true that some pediatric cancer centers in the past used to caution the parents of immunosuppressed patients to keep their children separated from recently vaccinated children, but that was more out of an abundance of caution than anything else. Indeed, guidelines from the Immune Deficiency Foundation state:
Close contacts of patients with compromised immunity should not receive live oral poliovirus vaccine because they might shed the virus and infect a patient with compromised immunity. Close contacts can receive other standard vaccines because viral shedding is unlikely and these pose little risk of infection to a subject with compromised immunity.
Antivaxxers actually do (mostly) realize that none of the current COVID-19 vaccines use attenuated live SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, but they’re nothing if not clever. So, instead of “viral shedding,” as Dr. Palevsky does, they point to “shedding” of the spike protein as the “cause” of the vaccinated being somehow dangerous to the unvaccinated. Whereas there was a real, albeit oft exaggerated, concern about shedding from live attenuated virus vaccines, concern about those vaccinated against COVID-19 “shedding” spike protein and causing problems in others is ridiculous in the extreme, from a scientific standpoint, as I discussed. It is, however, yet another example of how everything old is new again and there are no antivax tropes about COVID-19 vaccines that were not antivaccine tropes about other vaccines before the pandemic.
Antivaxxers invent a response to criticism
The trope about shedding has now been officially around long enough that antivaxxers have come up with a response to the criticisms I’ve just made. As is often the case, it involves misinterpretation and cherry picking. Here’s what I mean, taken from Twitter:
Yes, antivaxxers are pointing to the clinical trial protocol for the Pfizer vaccine, specifically this passage:
8.3.5. Exposure During Pregnancy or Breastfeeding, and Occupational Exposure
Exposure to the study intervention under study during pregnancy or breastfeeding and occupational exposure are reportable to Pfizer Safety within 24 hours of investigator awareness.
8.3.5.1. Exposure During PregnancyAn EDP occurs if:
    • A female participant is found to be pregnant while receiving or after discontinuing study intervention.
    • A male participant who is receiving or has discontinued study intervention exposes a female partner prior to or around the time of conception.
    • A female is found to be pregnant while being exposed or having been exposed to study intervention due to environmental exposure. Below are examples of environmental exposure during pregnancy:
        ◦ A female family member or healthcare provider reports that she is pregnant after having been exposed to the study intervention by inhalation or skin contact.
        ◦ A male family member or healthcare provider who has been exposed to the study intervention by inhalation or skin contact then exposes his female partner prior to or around the time of conception.
Interestingly, I have yet to see any sort of reference to similar passages in the clinical trial protocol for the Moderna, J&J, or other COVID-19 vaccines, which is telling, particularly given how similar the Moderna vaccine is to the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine. Those who read clinical trial protocols all the time will recognize this as fairly standard verbiage found in many clinical trials of investigational agents. It must also be understood that the “study intervention” means the vaccine:
Moreover, the "study intervention" means the vaccine. These sentences refers to, for example, healthcare workers who might have dropped some of the vaccine on their skin. The protocol requires their data to be collected. The "study intervention" is not touching vaccinated people. pic.twitter.com/q4s9lN12la
— Bad COVID-19 Takes (@BadCOVID19Takes) April 29, 2021
This is the sort of data collected out of the proverbial “abundance of caution” and is not the “slam dunk” evidence that Pfizer “knew” that its vaccine could “shed” spike protein that antivaxxers think that it is. In fact, it’s not evidence at all that Pfizer “knew” about “shedding” of the spike protein! Indeed, antivaxxers pointing to this passage in the clinical trial protocol as evidence that “Pfizer knew” that spike protein shedding is a problem with its vaccine is evidence only of the extreme ignorance of antivaxxers to basics of clinical trial protocols.
Projection, thy name is antivaxxer!
If there’s one thing I’ve learned over the years, it’s that antivaxxers very much resent it when it is pointed out that they are nearly always the source of outbreaks. They interpret these observations as accusing them of being “dirty”—or, to borrow a religious term, given how much antivaxxers’ views tend to resemble religion—that they are “unclean.” Moreover, given how steeped in alternative medicine much of the antivaccine world is, along with the germ theory denial that permeates antivaccine beliefs, it’s not surprising that they believe, in essence, in miasmas or some sort of magical field radiated by the vaccinated that sickens the unvaccinated:
It boggles my mind that ppl believe a cutting edge mRNA vaccine can spread a miasma that affects "the weaker sex." What century are we in?
— Raven Mae (@MaeNena73) May 2, 2021
In the age of the pandemic, they resent it even more when it is pointed out to them that they are an impediment to vaccinating enough people to achieve herd immunity and get the pandemic under control. Before the pandemic, the claim that “shedding” from live attenuated virus vaccines was the real cause of outbreaks was a way to project criticism back onto vaccine advocates. Then, the shedding trope had the advantage of having a germ of truth to it, at least with respect to the polio vaccine, even though now recommendations do not preclude giving MMR, for example, to the family members of immunosuppressed people. In the age of the pandemic, the whole “shedding spike protein” meme is an attempt, either conscious or unconscious, to “turn the tables” on vaccine advocates and scientists and portray the vaccinated as the source of contagion, as Dr. Iannelli notes, citing an antivaxxer named Maureen McDonnell::
It’s almost like we need to turn the tables on vaccine recipients. I mean, people who aren’t getting vaccinated are typically considered, you know, the outsiders… we’re in the wrong for resisting vaccines, but in actuality, it could be that the vaccine recipients are the ones creating the problem.
I reiterate that it’s not “almost” like “turning the tables”. It is a conscious strategy to “turn the tables” and portray the vaccinated, not the unvaccinated, as being the danger. Don’t think that antivaxxers don’t know this and respond to it, for example:
I’ll conclude by repeating once again that, when it comes to antivaccine disinformation, there is nothing new under the sun. The talking point about COVID-19 vaccine recipients supposedly “shedding” spike protein and making people sick with it, not to mention messing with women’s fertility and menses, is nothing more than a resurrection of two very old antivaccine talking points that cleverly combines the antivaccine myth of vaccine “shedding” causing outbreaks with the other hoary antivaccine myth that vaccines sterilize women. It’s a talking point that relies on such tenuous basic science that I hereby sentence any physician or scientist who repeats the claimed scientific rationale for this lie to an immediate course in remedial biology and molecular biology. Finally, there is no clinical or epidemiological evidence to suggest that shedding of spike protein even happens at a high level, much less that it can sicken the unvaccinated, mess up women’s menses, cause miscarriages, and render men and women infertile. This is all disinformation designed to “turn the tables” and portray the vaccinated as the “contaminated” or the vector of illness, nothing more. Unfortunately, similar to the way that SARS-CoV-2 itself keeps producing more harmful variants the longer it circulates widely among the human population, this particular antivaccine meme is producing more harmful variants the longer it circulates.

Do mRNA vaccines produce harmful “junk proteins” that “gunk up” the cell and cause unintended “off-target” immune responses?
A new study is making the rounds in the antivax crankosphere. The study found that the modified mRNA used in the Pfizer vaccine can cause a frame shift (to be explained) that results in the production of proteins besides the intended spike protein. The findings are, as you probably guessed, a big nothingburger compared to how they are being spun.
David Gorski on December 11, 2023
Link

One unexpected consequence of the infodemic of misinformation and disinformation that has accompanied the COVID-19 pandemic is that it’s given me a chance to reacquaint myself with some molecular biology and genetics that I hadn’t been using nearly as much, thanks to a chance in my research focus several years ago. My lab used to do experiments studying microRNAs and how they regulate gene expression. I even studied how transcription factors regulate gene expression and did a dissection of the functional domains of a transcription factor, but over time I’ve moved towards projects that involve more cellular biology and repurposing drugs approved for other indications for use treating breast cancer. Thanks to antivaxxers, though, I now get the opportunity to go back to my scientific roots, as when James Lyons-Weiler tried to claim that he had found plasmid sequences in the (then) newly-published sequence of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, and that this was slam-dunk evidence that he had “cracked the coronavirus code” and proven that SARS-CoV-2 had been artificially engineered in a laboratory as the result a misadventure trying to produce a SARS vaccine. Let’s just say that a careful look at the actual sequences that he examined was not consistent with his conclusions. Then there were so many articles claiming that the mRNA vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” (they don’t) and that contaminating plasmid DNA with short sequences from the SV40 promoter from one of the plasmids used in the Pfizer manufacturing process were getting into the nucleus, inserting themselves into the genome, and causing insertional mutagenesis leading to cancer., (There’s no evidence that they do any of that.)
This brings me to just the latest example of the willful misinterpretation of molecular biology (along with some immunology).
Frameshifts and “junk proteins”: Let the fear mongering begin!
It was with quite a bit of interest that I started seeing articles on antivax Substacks hyping yet another dubious claim based on molecular biology designed to frighten people that somehow the modified mRNA used in the Pfizer vaccine was causing a frameshift (I’ll explain what that is in a moment) that led to the production of “random junk proteins” in addition to the intended protein product, the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, that result in “unintended consequences,” I knew I had to read the study that antivaxxers were hyping. This was even more true after I ventured onto X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, and found posts like these:
“Despite their widespread use, surprisingly little is known about how ribonucleotide modification affects protein synthesis, particularly for translation of therapeutic IVT mRNAs.”
Excerpt from peer reviewed study published in Nature https://t.co/4NgcYhZ6G0
— Godefroid Chapelle (@__gotcha) December 9, 2023
Explain how the recent discovery that the mRNA injections create not just the spike but multiple unintended and unfiled exotic proteins is not grounds for an immediate FDA level 3 recall? https://t.co/RCfoGD90md
— Coalmine Canary (@CoalmineCanary9) December 10, 2023
This! 👇👀🔥 Unvaxed and proud of it! https://t.co/cTMmLlbFa1 pic.twitter.com/SJcrG8HxcC
— Pops (@UPMHPM) December 7, 2023
Some scientists have tried to calle BS on all the conspiracy mongering, but to little avail.
No, the data says it is no safety risk. I bring a hypothesis that this is very similar to what happens normally and may even have beneficial effects.
— Marc Veldhoen (@Marc_Veld) December 9, 2023
Unfortunately, though, the misinformation has gone beyond just spreading on antivax Substack, X, and other social media. There are newspapers promoting it as well:
BREAKING News about COVID vaccine safety!A study just published in Nature reports that the mRNA shots cause the production of RANDOM, "nonsense" proteins in recipients one third of the time: https://t.co/O2NXjNRzIn
A Telegraph article for laymen is here: https://t.co/fgzXqnE7Hy
— Ned Nikolov, Ph.D. (@NikolovScience) December 8, 2023
The Telegraph, for instance, features this misleading headline, One in four who had Moderna or Pfizer Covid jabs experienced unintended immune response:
More than a quarter of people injected with mRNA Covid jabs suffered an unintended immune response created by a glitch in the way the vaccine was read by the body, a study has found.
No adverse effects were created by the error, data show, but Cambridge scientists found such vaccines were not perfect and sometimes led to nonsense proteins being made instead of the desired Covid “spike”, which mimics infection and leads to antibody production.
mRNA jabs, such as the ones created by Moderna and Pfizer, use a string of genetic material to tell the body to create a specific protein that safely imitates an infection.
In fairness, The Telegraph does include context from the scientists involved in this study, but there’s plenty in the story, like the above passage, for antivaxxers to latch onto—for example, the claim that one in four subjects suffer an “unintended immune response” is doing some very heavy lifting here, as you well see—even from the passage providing context:
In this scenario not only is the vaccine not making the right protein, it could lead to a rogue protein being produced.
There is no evidence of this occurring in the Covid jabs, the authors stress, and they say any trials on other mRNA therapeutics would detect any such problems in early stages.
The BBC was a bit more measured, using a more accurate headline, Covid study: mRNA vaccines could be fine-tuned:
The revolutionary messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) technology in some Covid vaccines given to millions of people could be fine-tuned for even greater accuracy, UK scientists say.
Genetic instructions in the jab could be tweaked to avoid a harmless tiny “slip” sometimes seen as the body reads the code, the Medical Research Council team suggest.

Existing mRNA vaccines are effective and safe, they say.
Future ones could fight more diseases.
Of course, antivaxxers were not even as circumspect as The Telegraph’s sensationalistic headline was when it came to fear mongering about this study’s results as showing that the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine makes “junk proteins” that cause unintended “off-target” immune responses, implying that these findings mean that the vaccine is hopelessly dangerous. For example, you might recognize Ivor Chudov from last week. He’s not a scientist and has zero background to have any clue what this study actually shows, but, just as it didn’t stop him from incompetently trying to analyze Steve Kirsch’s stolen data from New Zealand, his utter ignorance of molecular biology doesn’t stop him from writing things like Covid Vaccines Produce Random Junk Proteins Thanks to an “Invention” Which Coincidentally Won the Nobel Prize, in which, antivaxxers being antivaxxers, Chudov cranks up the fear mongering to 11:
Would you like to get a mystery shot, which would make your body produce random, garbage proteins for an indeterminate amount of time? Well, it turned out that mRNA Covid vaccines have precisely that effect!
And:
We are discussing one such surprise – the lost “bits” of genetic translation leading to garbage proteins produced by vaccinated bodies at random.
Noting that Katalin Kariko and Drew Weissman won the Nobel Prize for pioneering the use of pseudouridine in mRNA to make mRNA vaccines, Chudov then pulls a predictable antiscience trope out of his nether regions::
May I remind you of another 1949 Nobel Prize given to the inventor of lobotomy Egas Moniz?
Because of course he does, as this seems to be a common theme among antivaxxers commenting on this study. He also makes a rather dubious analogy:
I hope you agree that any technology that causes such random loss of “bits” is not good. Some lost bits can corrupt files and even lead to computer crashes, like the infamous “Blue Screen of Death” in Microsoft Windows.
It turns out that mRNA technologies introduce similar errors, as Mulroney et al. learned using experiments on mice and humans. Just as bits are lost in text, such frameshifting errors can cause garbage outputs to clog human bodies.
The problem, of course, is that is not quite what the study showed. (Actually, unsurprisingly, it is an antivax spin on a somewhat interesting result that is not exactly a new finding.) As I will discuss in a moment, the study did show that pseudouridine in the vaccine can result in a frameshift that causes the production of small amounts of proteins other than spike, but the finding turns out to be a huge nothingburger. However, to understand just what the heck this study does show, it’s necessary to delve back into some Molecular Biology 101-level information about how ribosomes translate the genetic code in mRNA into protein and what a frame shift during translation is.
What is a frameshift?
Let’s go back to the very basics again, as this is necessary to understand just what the heck a frameshift is. First, let’s review how the information in genes is transcribed into a different form, RNA, and then translated into protein. First, although I hate the term, let’s look at what is commonly called the “central dogma” of molecular biology, which describes the flow of information from genes to protein. (No less a luminary than Francis Crick first stated it in 1958, and it has been restated over the years in various ways.) Perhaps my favorite version of the central dogma was succinctly stated by Marshall Nirenberg in 1958 and has since been commonly paraphrased to say, “DNA makes RNA makes protein”, which about summed up all of molecular biology in five words. (Why I used the past tense in a moment.) In any event, for purposes of understanding RNA viruses, this is the main sequence that you need to understand. In any event, for purposes of understanding RNA viruses, this is the main sequence that you need to understand:

mRNA vaccines, of course, skip the DNA part, producing an mRNA molecule with all the information necessary for the cell to make the desired protein. But how is that information coded into the DNA and mRNA molecules? DNA and RNA are basically long polymers (chemical chains) made up of four different “bases.” You don’t need to know a lot of the specifics for purposes of this discussion, other than that they are coded A, C, and G in both RNA and DNA; the fourth one used is T in DNA and U (standing for, yes, the dreaded uracil) in RNA, with the two functioning basically the same in each molecule. (Chemists and molecular biologists, I’m simplifying for purposes of a mass audience; no nitpicking.) In the early 1960s, scientists used a clever strategy to work out the genetic code. In brief, they figured out that three nucleotides coded for one amino acid. (As DNA and RNA are chains of a limited number of different bases, proteins are chains made up of amino acids, of which there are 20 used to make the proteins in most organisms. Because, with four different bases, there are more potential combinations of bases in groups of three (64) than there are amino acids, the genetic code is said to be redundant, with most amino acids having more than one three-base “codon” to encode them, although there are special codons that signify the start or termination of translation, all of which were worked out decades ago.
The genetic code is frequently represented as a table like this, with the three letter codes for the amino acids being mapped to the various three-“letter” codon combinations::
Or as a circular diagram like this:

Confession: I included both versions because I think they’re cool.
So what is a frame shift? Think of it this way. To translate the genetic information in an RNA molecule into proteins, a protein complex known as a ribosome slides along the mRNA molecule, adding amino acids to the growing peptide (protein) chain according to its “reading” of the three-letter codons. However, as you can imagine, as accurate as the process of translation is, nothing in nature is absolutely perfect, and sometimes mistakes in translation are made. One type of mistake occurs when for some reason, the “read” of the mRNA template is shifted so that it’s off by a nucleotide base or two. (Note that a frame shift of three bases would bring the ribosome back onto the correct frame to read the rest of the mRNA sequence correctly, although it would result in the deletion or addition of one amino acid.)
I’m going to borrow this example from Wikipedia, because it’s fairly easy to understand:
In this example, the following sequence is a region of the human mitochondrial genome with the two overlapping genes MT-ATP8 and MT-ATP6. When read from the beginning, these codons make sense to a ribosome and can be translated into amino acids (AA) under the vertebrate mitochondrial code:
|Start|AAC GAA AAT CTG TTC GCT TCA ...
|Start|123 123 123 123 123 123 123 ...
| AA | N E N L F A S ...
However, let’s change the reading frame by starting one nucleotide downstream (effectively a “+1 frameshift” when considering the 0 position to be the initial position of A):
A|Start|ACG AAA ATC TGT TCG CTT CA...
-|Start|123 123 123 123 123 123 12...
| AA | T K I C S L ...
Now, because of this +1 frameshifting, the DNA sequence is read differently. The different codon reading frame therefore yields different amino acids.
In the case of a translating ribosome, a frameshift can either result in nonsense (a premature stop codon) after the frameshift, or the creation of a completely new protein after the frameshift. In the case where a frameshift results in nonsense, the NMD (nonsense-mediated mRNA decay) pathway may destroy the mRNA transcript, so frameshifting would serve as a method of regulating the expression level of the associated gene.[5]
Let me just note that frame shifts commonly result in a premature stop codon and, as a result, a much shorter protein, although sometimes the open reading frame (the sequence of RNA without a stop codon) can stretch for considerable length, leading to a much longer different protein being translated. Frame shifts can also occur as a result of a frame shift mutation, which involves the insertion of one or more nucleotides into the sequence of a gene, but that’s not what the paper was examining, as such mutations, being mutations, require modification of the actual nucleotide sequence coding for the proteins. The paper being promoted by antivaxxers concerns itself with frame shifts as a result of the ribosome that do not involve a change in the actual nucleotide sequence.
Now here’s the interesting thing. While it’s true that a ribosomal frame shift can occur as a random “mistake” in the ribosome’s reading of the mRNA sequence, that is far from the only mechanism by which ribosomal frame shifts occur. Indeed, such frame shifts are not uncommon, particularly in viral genomes. They can, for instance, allow for two different proteins to be coded from the same stretch of RNA, transcribed from DNA, thus getting more information out of a much shorter stretch of DNA. Indeed, the Wikipedia article on the topic includes a pretty decent lay summary several types of these naturally-occurring frameshifts, some caused by so-called “slippery sequences” that can make the ribosome “slip” and skip a nucleotide in its reading, with such sequences controlling the rate at which such frame shifting occurs. Also, the secondary structure (how the mRNA loops and folds on itself) can regulate the rate and chance of ribosomal frame shifting.
Can I just say that biology is so cool?
It’s even cooler than that, though. We’ve known a long time that frame shifting is important in coronaviruses and since at least 2005 that there is programmed ribosomal frame shifting in the original SARS viral genome. which makes it no surprise that programmed ribosomal frame shifting might occur SARS-CoV-2. In fact, we know that coronaviiruses require ribosomal frame shifting as part of its replication cycle and that “modified” mRNA bases are not “unnatural”:
This modification naturally occurs in our own ribosomal RNA. RNA has to be modified to prevent triggering of an antiviral immune response that would suppress production of the encoded protein (which would then prevent an effective antibody response):https://t.co/9CovU9rRNK
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
Again, biology is just that cool, and since virology is part of biology it’s so cool too. In fact, frame shifts are important in viruses other than SARS-CoV-2. For instance, as Ed Nirenberg explained while discussing this paper, sometimes the frame-shifted protein product can be as immunogenic (or even more so) than the regular protein product:
For example, it was recently shown that influenza can produce a unique protein product through a frameshift that is very strongly recognized by killer T cells: https://t.co/abJiGB9xjPThis resulting frameshifted product might have an important role in protection from flu.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
But, antivaxxers might ask, isn’t something (like adding pseudouridine to mRNA) that increases the likelihood of ribosomal frame shifting a bad thing? The answer is: It depends. It might be. Certainly, in therapeutics we strive to produce exactly the protein intended, no more, no less. However, that doesn’t mean that the findings of this study are evidence that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are “dunking up” your cells and causing all sorts of random harmful immune reactions, as antivaxxers are claiming. Now that you have some idea of what this form of frame shifting is and know that it’s also not the horribly “unnatural” thing that antivaxxers is trying to portray it as based on this study, let’s look at the study itself.
Pseudouridine and frame shifting in COVID-19 vaccines
Let’s circle back to the actual study, N1-methylpseudouridylation of mRNA causes +1 ribosomal frameshifting. The corresponding author is Anne Willis, who, along with first author Thomas Mulroney and several of the other authors, is based at the MRC Toxicology Unit, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK. Other authors are based at Oxford University, University College Dublin, University of Liverpool, University of Kent, and Mahidol University in Thailand. Early on, the authors note that the purpose of their study was to quantify how synthetic nucleotides might affect the fidelity of translation in order to use that information to design better mRNA therapeutics and vaccines, noting early on:
At present, it is unclear which modified ribonucleotides affect mRNA translation fidelity and existing studies are mostly limited to understanding misreading frequencies only at a given codon. Misreading of mRNA codons is also only one type of post-transcriptional mechanism that can alter a polypeptide sequence. So far, no study has investigated the fundamental question of whether modified ribonucleotides can affect the maintenance of the correct reading frame during translation of a synthetic transcript. Understanding these processes is critical to increase our knowledge of protein synthesis from modified mRNAs in general, but is also imperative for the robust design and evaluation of new mRNA-based therapeutics that make use of modified ribonucleotides within widely differing RNA sequences or therapeutic contexts.
Just for completeness’ sake, I like to point out that COVID-19 mRNA-based vaccines incorporate N1-methyl-pseudouridine, and that the discovery that the use of this modified base could greatly decrease the immune response to the mRNA itself as well as result in more robust protein production was critical to the development of current mRNA-based vaccine technology. Now let’s look at what Mulroney et al did.
First, they used a sequence unrelated to the spike sequence used to produce mRNA vaccines, namely a sequence designed to produce the enzyme luciferase. Luciferase is a hellaciously useful enzyme in molecular biology because when the appropriate reagents are provided it produces light by luminescence that can be quantified and is proportional to the amount of luciferase present. That’s why it’s often used as a “reporter gene” placed next to various promoters. In any event, the authors did something fairly clever. I’m not going to go into as much detail as Ed did, but basically they engineered a modified sequence for luciferase consisting of one part of it (the N-terminal domain, labeled NFluc for n-terminal firefly luciferase) that is noncatalytic, attached to CFluc, denoting the part of the protein that catalyzes the light-producing reaction. Now here’s the trick. The sequence is engineered such that the CFluc will be made only if there is a +1 frameshift. No frameshift, no light produced, as the protein will be nonfunctional. Here’s what the constructs look like, compared to wild type (WT, or naturally occurring) full length luciverase:

Basically, Fluc+1FS mRNAs are designed to produce catalytically inactive (truncated) NFluc when translated normally. Clever, right? Then, the investigators made two different versions of this construct, one with just regular mRNA bases (designated unmodified) and one with the 1-methyl-pseudouridine modification used in mRNA vaccines (designated 1-methylΨ, or m1Ψ. Several different other modified uridine bases were used as additional controls. The same thing was done with wild type luciferase:
Panel b shows the luciferase activity as a result of in vitro translation of the wild type luciferase sequence containing either unmodified uracil bases or the modifications listed. As you can see, the m1Ψ modification produces roughly comparable amounts of protein. Panel c, however, shows the same experiment done with Fluc+1FS, which resulted in luciferase activity only from in vitro translation using the m1Ψ-modified mRNA, with minimal activity produced by all the other groups. Panel d represents introducing Fluc+1FS into cells either unmodified or with the m1Ψ modification, and as you can see the m1Ψ-modified mRNA produced a lot more luciferase activity, indicating that the methyl-pseudouridine substitution increased the rate of frame shifting. Finally, e a Western blot, which shows two additional for the m1ψ mRNA, but also a large amount of the expected iin-frame product.
Ed notes:
This broadly agrees with work from 2015 that showed that there is markedly enhanced protein production from m1ψ RNA. https://t.co/nAXriufpAEThis is, fundamentally, the point of using the modification: you want faithful production of your protein inside actual cells.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
So, thus far this paper recapitulates what is already known about Ψ-modified mRNA but also describes increased frame shifting. Sounds bad, right? Well, maybe, or maybe not. In any case, the conclusions thus far are:
Incorporation of 1-methylΨ in Fluc+1FS mRNA significantly increased ribosomal +1 frameshifting to about 8% of the corresponding in-frame protein, which was not observed for other ribonucleotides (Fig. 1c). HeLa cells transfected with 1-methylΨ Fluc+1FS mRNA recapitulated the results from in vitro translation (Fig. 1d). On the basis of these observations, we concluded that IVT mRNA containing 1-methylΨ or 5-methylC exhibits similar translation efficiency to unmodified mRNA, but 1-methylΨ significantly increases ribosomal +1 frameshifting during mRNA translation.
The authors next asked if this phenomenon happens in COVID-19 vaccines. So they vaccinated mice with the Pfizer vaccine and with the Oxford/AZ vaccine, which is DNA-based, not mRNA-based, and therefore would not be expected to produce extraneous proteins due to frame shifts, and looked at T-cell mediated immune responses to spike protein and to the out-of-frame peptides predicted from the nucleotide sequence of spike. What they found was this:
The results are quite interesting. The mice did indeed show an immune response to out-of-frame peptides predicted to be produced by the Pfizer vaccine, while, as expected, the AZ vaccine produced no such response because it couldn’t produce the out-of-frame peptides. However, look at 2c. The Pfizer vaccine produced a greater immune response to the intended antigen, the SARS-CoV2 spike protein, than produced by the AZ vaccine.
Then they did the same thing in humans, examining responses in the peripheral blood monocytes (PBMCs) of 21 individuals vaccinated with BNT162b2 (Pfizer) and compared these responses to those of 20 individuals vaccinated with ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 (AZ):
Panel d assays T-cell immune response PBMCs (IFNγ ELISpot) harvested from human volunteers and stimulated with predicted out-of-frame spike peptides, while panel e shows the same response to in-frame spike peptides: total spike pool or spike S1 + S2 subpools (spike protein S1 and S2 regions). The bottom line is that frame shifting was observed in humans, but it varied between individuals…by a lot. The authors then went on to identify “slippery sites” within the mRNA that are prone to frame shifting and showed that abolishing these sites by mutating them to a different codon coding for the same amino acid could greatly decrease the rate of frame shifting.
Now, I know what antivaxxers are thinking: Maybe these individuals with a greater propensity for their ribosomes to frame shift are those “sensitive” to “vaccine injury” by this mechanism. When it comes to this sort of argument, I tend to agree with Ed Nirenberg (again) that these results have little or no bearing on the safety of the Pfizer vaccine (or the Moderna vaccine) for the reasons that he cites, including:
The sequences of Pfizer and Moderna differ significantly at the nucleotide level, but the nature of the responses and their safety profile is broadly similar, arguing against frameshift products in either case having a meaningful effect.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
This is very important. Even though the authors did not test the Moderna vaccine, we would expect that, if frame shifting impacted vaccine safety a lot, there would be a significant difference between the two vaccines based on their different nucleotide sequences. That’s not to say that these results don’t matter for future vaccine design. They do, as Ed points out:
The sequences of Pfizer and Moderna differ significantly at the nucleotide level, but the nature of the responses and their safety profile is broadly similar, arguing against frameshift products in either case having a meaningful effect.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
it’s not likely that it matters much here either way. The authors are (correctly) explicit here that there is no evidence of this contributing to any kind of safety issues with the mRNA vaccines.
Some clueless people claim that this somehow means there's a heightened…
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
In particular, because there is no autoimmune signature for the mRNA-based vaccines:
We in fact see that in stark contrast to COVID-19, there is no autoimmune signature for mRNA vaccines: https://t.co/3GrD9ohfBl
So, basically: a useful study but not good cause to worry about mRNA vaccines.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) December 6, 2023
And here is another reason why you shouldn’t worry about these results:
We know that, because authorities like the FDA and EMA have checked this, and independent scientists have done the same.https://t.co/1RCi7SaI4k
2/4
— Marc Veldhoen (@Marc_Veld) December 6, 2023
The sequence is, as always flanked by untranslated parts (UTRs) that are there for stability. And no, of course not, there are no other proteins coded behind this. That is made up. The frameshift itself causes parts to be mistranslated. Not proteins of any use. That is all.4/4 pic.twitter.com/GicE8khDxg
— Marc Veldhoen (@Marc_Veld) December 6, 2023
The protein will start with Spike, and at a few critical points may make a frameshift. This may add some extra amino acids but does not result in much, frequently hitting another translational stop codon, terminating any further protein production. pic.twitter.com/O4qDi2rLA4
— Marc Veldhoen (@Marc_Veld) December 7, 2023
Which is what I said at the beginning of this post—remember?—about how most frame shifts don’t result in much of a protein because it’s usually not too far from the frame shift to a stop codon that will truncate the frame shift peptide after a fairly short sequence. Yes, these short frame shift proteins can—and apparently do—provoke an immune response, but not one that has been demonstrated to cause harm, the ravings of antivaxxers notwithstanding.
Not that this stops antivaxxers like one whom we’ve met before, Joomi Kim, from ranting:
Technically it’s true that there are “no adverse outcomes reported” from the mistranslation of mRNA vaccines, but that’s because we don’t even know what that would look like. Does anyone walk into the ER and say “I experienced a ribosomal frameshift?”1
No one knows what that would look like, and the authors of the paper don’t either.
All the authors can say is that they didn’t see any obvious evidence of harm in the (8?) mice they vaccinated with the Pfizer vax. And even that is iffy: after all, they only looked at what happened to the mice in the short term.
There is only one appropriate reaction to that remark about having “experienced a ribosomal frameshift”:

Actually, we do know what such adverse outcomes would probably look like. It would likely look the same as any other errant immune reaction or autoimmune condition.
Unsurprisingly, Kim also pulls the pharma shill gambit:
We should also mention that it’s possible that some of the authors of this paper have some conflicts of interest:
Competing interests
T.E.M. and A.E.W. are inventors on a pending patent application (2305297.0) related to mRNA technology.
The funny thing is, I could argue coming from the opposite view that that such a financial conflict of interest could be a reason why they published findings that demonstrate what they believe to be a deficiency in its design, and then to mention their preferred solution. If I really wanted to be snarky, I could ask them why they didn’t think that Andrew Wakefield had a hopeless conflict of interest, given that when he published his case series he had under development a measles vaccine of his own. Of course, these authors are nothing like Wakefield, in particular because they are very up-front about what they are trying to accomplish:
Although there is no evidence that frameshifted products in humans generated from BNT162b2 vaccination are associated with adverse outcomes, for future use of mRNA technology it is important that mRNA sequence design is modified to reduce ribosome frameshifting events, as this may limit its future use for applications that require higher doses or more frequent dosing, such as the in vivo production of hormones. It is important to continue investigating therapeutic mRNA mistranslation and immunogenicity, as the evolution of antibody and cytolytic T cell responses against +1 frameshifted spike variants and peptides has not been systematically evaluated in humans and ELISpot responses obtained from pooled peptides may also underestimate T cell responses.
And:
Taken together, these data suggest that N1-methylpseudouridylation at defined mRNA sequences triggers ribosome +1 frameshifting; however, with appropriate mRNA sequence design, it is possible to ameliorate this issue.
Which, I note, would be a good thing. Probably. After all, remember that the Pfizer vaccine induced a stronger immune response than the DNA-based vaccine. What if this is in part due to its producing a small amount of frameshift peptides along with its spike protein? The good thing is that this line of research will answer that question, too; so we’ll know.
Finally:
Our mechanistic data are supported by previous observations of ribosomal frameshifting during translation of naturally occurring mRNAs, which implicate ribosome stalling and require ribosome slippery sequences for +1 frameshifting21,26,27,28,33,34. These findings are of particular importance to our fundamental understanding of how ribonucleotide modification affects mRNA translation, and for designing and optimizing future mRNA-based therapeutics to avoid mistranslation events that may decrease efficacy or increase toxicity.
Presumably, the mRNA products and vaccines for which the two main authors have filed a patent application use these findings to produce more effective—and hopefully even safer than the already very safe mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines—mRNA-based therapeutics and vaccines.
As for the antivaxxers pointing to this study as some sort of slam-dunk evidence of horrific biological and immune effects from small quantities of frameshift peptides generated by the Pfizer (and, presumably, Moderna) vaccines, all I can say is: Thanks for giving me the opportunity to delve into some pretty cool science that, regardless of where it ultimately goes, will likely help us design even better and safer future mRNA-based vaccines and therapeutics that you will hate and try to portray as deadly.

Can mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease or Alzheimer’s?
Antivax immunologist J. Bart Classen published a paper claiming that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines can cause prion disease leading to neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s dementia. What are prions, and can these vaccines cause prion disease? (Spoiler alert: The answer to the second question is almost certainly no. It’s speculation based on highly implausible biology.)
David Gorski on February 22, 2021
Link

Ever since the COVID-19 pandemic began and antivaxxers made common cause with COVID-19 cranks, deniers, and conspiracy theorists, I’ve been repeating a simple message: Everything old is new again. The pandemic has resulted in a lot of scientists and other people paying attention to the antivaccine movement in a way that they never have before. Many of these newbies have been amazed at some of the antivaccine misinformation and disinformation that have been spread about the new COVID-19 vaccines. False antivax claims about these vaccines include a veritable antivax “greatest hits” of pseudoscience, conspiracy theories, and distortions, a veritable playbook of claims that COVID-19 vaccines kill, cause miscarriages and/or infertility, cause autoimmune disease, “permanently alter your DNA“, are unnecessary because COVID-19 is not dangerous, that the number of cases are exaggerated, and that the vaccines are filled with “toxins” (in the case of the mRNA vaccines, the lipid nanoparticles used to encapsulate the mRNA coding for COVID-19 spike protein). Now two more famous antivax claims from the past are popping up in my social media feeds, and they are related. I’m referring to the false claim that the COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease and that they cause Alzheimer’s disease. We have “immunologist” Dr. J. Bart Classen to thank for this disinformation and antivaxxers like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. for spreading it.
First, let’s show how his claim is yet another example of my adage regarding disinformation about the COVID-19 vaccine that “everything old is new again”.
Vaccines and Alzheimer’s disease: A brief history
One of the earliest antivaccine claims that I ever dealt with was a rather specific claim about the influenza vaccine. I first encountered it when Bill Maher parroted it in an interview with Larry King on Larry King Live, way back in December 2005. (Yes, you read that correctly, 2005.) I think it’s useful to recount what Maher said in this exchange:
MAHER: I’m not into western medicine. That to me is a complete scare tactic. It just shows you, you can…
KING: You mean you don’t get a — you don’t get a flu shot?
MAHER: A flu shot is the worst thing you can do.
KING: Why?
MAHER: Because it’s got — it’s got mercury.
KING: It prevents flu.
MAHER: It doesn’t prevent. First of all, that’s…
KING: I haven’t had the flu in 25 years since I’ve been taking a flu shot.
MAHER: Well, I hate to tell you, Larry, but if you have a flu shot for more than five years in a row, there’s ten times the likelihood that you’ll get Alzheimer’s disease. I would stop getting your…
KING: What did you say?
MAHER: That went better in rehearsal but it was still good. Absolutely, no the defense against disease is to have a strong immune system. A flu shot just compromises your immune system.
Where did the claim that getting a flu shot more than five years in a row increases your risk of someday developing Alzheimer’s disease originate? While I’m not sure where the claim that the flu shot predisposes to Alzheimer’s disease truly originated, I’m pretty sure I know where the specific claim about five years’ worth of flu shots increasing the risk of Alzheimer’s disease by ten-fold came from. At the time, a search on that hoary old crank and conspiracy theory website Whale.to quickly revealed this gem from a conference held by the antivaccine group National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) in 1997:
According to Hugh Fudenberg, MD (http://members.aol.com/nitrf), the world’s leading immunogeneticist and 13th most quoted biologist of our times (nearly 850 papers in peer review journals), if an individual has had five consecutive flu shots between 1970 and 1980 (the years studied) his/her chances of getting Alzheimer’s Disease is ten times higher than if they had one, two or no shots. I asked Dr. Fudenberg why this was so and he said it was due to the mercury and aluminum that is in every flu shot (and most childhood shots). The gradual mercury and aluminum buildup in the brain causes cognitive dysfunction. Is that why Alzheimer’s is expected to quadruple? Notes: Recorded from Dr. Fudenberg’s speech at the NVIC International Vaccine Conference, Arlington, VA September, 1997. Quoted with permission. Alzheimer’s to quadruple statement is from John’s Hopkins Newsletter Nov 1998. —-Ted Koren, D. C. http://www.odyssee.net/~expodome/autism.htm#Top Koren Publications (800-537-3001).
A chiropractor. Of course, the presentation at NVIC had to be recorded by a chiropractor:

And here’s a more recent addition since 2005, dated 2006:
Vancouver neuroscientist Chris Shaw shows a link between the aluminum hydroxide used in vaccines, and symptoms associated with Parkinson’s, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS, or Lou Gehrig’s disease), and Alzheimer’s…..”This is suspicious,” he told the Georgia Straight in a phone interview from his lab near Heather Street and West 12th Avenue. “Either this [link] is known by industry and it was never made public, or industry was never made to do these studies by Health Canada. I’m not sure which is scarier.” Similar adjuvants are used in the following vaccines, according to Shaw’s paper: hepatitis A and B, and the Pentacel cocktail, which vaccinates against diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus, polio, and a type of meningitis….”No one in my lab wants to get vaccinated,” he said. “This totally creeped us out. We weren’t out there to poke holes in vaccines. But all of a sudden, oh my God—we’ve got neuron death!” —[Media 3/2006 Aluminium adjuvant] Vaccines show sinister side.
Over the years, I frequently saw the claim that the flu vaccine or aluminum adjuvants in flu vaccines cause Alzheimer’s disease popping up on antivaccine websites and social media. It has basically become an article of faith among antivaxxers that flu vaccine, if not aluminum adjuvants in vaccines in general, predispose to or even cause Alzheimer’s disease. As for Fudenberg, he was a real quack back in the day.
Here’s what I mean. Hugh Fudenberg was a collaborator and co-inventor with the disgraced antivaccine physician Andrew Wakefield, who committed research fraud in his “study” published in The Lancet in 1998 linking the MMR vaccine to autism and ultimately had his medical license revoked in the UK over his misconduct.
Dr. Fudenberg also happens to have been involved in some very dubious “treatments” for autism that led to some problems with his medical license. In November 1995, the South Carolina Medical Board concluded that Fudenberg was “guilty of engaging in dishonorable, unethical, or unprofessional conduct”, and he was fined $10,000 and ordered to surrender his license to prescribe controlled substances (narcotic drugs). His medical license was also placed on suspension. In March 1996, he was permitted to resume practice under terms of probation that did not permit him to prescribe any drugs. His medical license expired in January 2004; and in March 2004, he applied to have it reinstated. However, after a hearing in which the Board considered a neuropsychiatric report issued in 2003, Fudenberg agreed to remain in a “retired” status and withdrew his application for reactivation of his license.
Later, Dr. Fudenberg ran a nonprofit “research” organization called Neuro Immunotherapeutics Research Foundation that sold dubious remedies for autism. He also charged $750 per hour for “review of past medical records”, $750 per hour for “determining what new tests need to be ordered; ordering of new tests; evaluation of new tests”, and $750 per hour for “determining which therapy will work and which will not; discussing this with patient along with an in-depth study of past medical history to determine what makes a patient better or worse”. The specific dubious autism treatment with which Dr. Fudenberg was involved is the use of something called “transfer factor” to make a combined measles vaccine and autism “cure”. The method of making these so-called “transfer factors” is bizarre in the extreme and involves injecting mice with measles, extracting and processing white blood cells, injecting the result into pregnant goats, milking the goats after kid-birth and turning the product into capsules for autistic children. In a patent application (based in part on the infamous Lancet paper) obtained by Brian Deer, Wakefield represented a vaccine/therapy for “MMR-based” autism using transfer factor as potentially a “complete cure” for autism or for “alleviation of symptoms”.
And, to repeat, Fudenberg liked to claim that the flu vaccine causes Alzheimer’s disease, even though there is no evidence to support the hypothesis that the flu vaccine predisposes to autism; indeed, there is evidence for the opposite. (There’s even evidence in a mouse model that repeated vaccination against influenza is neuroprotective.)
But what about prion disease? And what are prion diseases, anyway?
Vaccines and prion disease
Before I discuss all these claims, I have to answer the question: What are prions? Prion diseases are more properly referred to as transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) and represent a rare form of progressive neurodegenerative disorders that can affect both humans and animals. The most famous prion diseases in animals are bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE, also known as “Mad Cow Disease”), scrapie, and chronic wasting disease; in humans, Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease (CJD) and kuru. These diseases have a long incubation period and produce in the brain characteristic spongiform changes associated with loss of neurons with no inflammatory response. The causative agents for these diseases are prions. According to the CDC:
The term “prions” refers to abnormal, pathogenic agents that are transmissible and are able to induce abnormal folding of specific normal cellular proteins called prion proteins that are found most abundantly in the brain. The functions of these normal prion proteins are still not completely understood. The abnormal folding of the prion proteins leads to brain damage and the characteristic signs and symptoms of the disease. Prion diseases are usually rapidly progressive and always fatal.
Basically, prions are believed to be misfolded proteins that can transmit their misfolded shape onto normal variants of the same protein. I don’t need to go into the details for you to understand the very basics of prion disease, other than to note that the protein that makes up prions (PrP) is found in many places in the body in healthy people and animals, and its normal function in biology and physiology is poorly understood.
The claim by antivaxxers that vaccines can result in prion disease is one that I’ve seen far less frequently than the claim that they cause Alzheimer’s disease, so much so that a review of SBM found that we’ve only touched on it briefly in John Snyder’s review of Dr. Bob Sears’ book touting his “alternative” vaccine schedule. The origin of the claim appears to derive from the observation that the media used to support the growth of some of the cell lines used to grow virus stock from which vaccines are made contains fetal bovine serum (FBS), a common ingredient in cell culture media. Antivaxxers use that observation to claim a risk of “prion contamination” of vaccines. Never mind that such contamination of a vaccine has never been demonstrated.
Like many antivaccine myths, the myth that vaccines might become contaminated with prions originates from a grain of truth. Decades ago, during the height of the mad cow disease outbreak in the UK, there was indeed concern about using FBS from British herds of cattle to manufacture vaccines. A news article in Nature from 2000 reported on the findings of an inquiry into Britain’s BSE epidemic and even specifically asked the question: “Were some CJD victims infected by vaccines?” The report basically concluded that the answer to that question was unknown, but:
The BSE inquiry’s report (see above) calls for vaccines to be investigated as a possible route of transmission. But it concedes that this will be hampered by the fact that “systematic records of the action taken in response to BSE in respect of individual medical products are lacking”.
And:
Alarmingly, vaccines produced after the point at which the BSE epidemic had been identified — possibly using British bovine material — were still in use as recently as November 1993. According to the inquiry’s report, the chief medical officer of the day, Donald Acheson, decided to phase out the existing stocks because new batches of vaccines take time to grow, and medical experts considered that the benefit of maintaining a continuous national immunization programme outweighed the risk of interrupting it.
An article in MPR from 2010 by pediatrician Dr. Gary S. Marshall, author of The Vaccine Handbook: A Practical Guide for Clinicians (The Purple Book), is more reassuring. Noting that the FDA convened a meeting in 2000 to discuss the very question of whether vaccines could transmit BSE, Dr. Marshall characterizes the conclusions of the FDA thusly:
Although the risk of transmission of vCJD to humans from such vaccines was considered theoretic and remote, the recommendation was made that vaccines use bovine materials originating from countries without endogenous MCD. Mathematical models suggest that the agent of MCD first entered cattle feed in the United Kingdom around 1980; since the vast majority of initial cases of vCJD were born well before then, childhood vaccines were not likely to be the cause.
And:
Maternal-fetal transmission of prions has never been documented in animals and fetal blood is not known to contain prions. Moreover, the fetal bovine serum used in vaccine manufacture is highly diluted and eventually removed from cells during purification of vaccine viruses. It should be pointed out as well that prions propagate in mammalian brain but not in cell culture.
And:
Final reassurance comes from the fact that transmission of prions occurs from eating the brains of infected animals or from directly inoculating preparations of brains of infected animals into the brains of experimental animals. Transmission of prions has not been documented after inoculation into the muscles or under the skin, which are the routes used for vaccination. Taken together, the chances that currently licensed vaccines contain prions and represent a risk to humans is essentially zero.
So, basically, although the claim that vaccines could transmit prions entered the antivaccine lexicon of disinformation in the 1990s, after billions upon billions of doses of vaccines for which the viral stock was grown in FBS-containing media, there remains no good evidence that vaccines have ever been contaminated with prions or ever caused a single case of prion disease in humans or animals.
Enter J. Bart Classen
You might wonder why I spent so much time going over the history of (and lack of evidence for) the claims that vaccines can cause Alzheimer’s disease or transmit prion diseases. My answer is simple and involves repeating my mantras with respect to the antivaccine movement and COVID-19. There is nothing new under the sun (in the antivaccine movement), and everything old is new again (when it comes to COVID-19 vaccines). Now that you know that there is no evidence to support these claims and that they are totally antivaccine disinformation, you know that J. Bart Classen’s claims about the COVID-19 vaccine are likely, similarly, to be nonsense. You can reflect back on the information I’ve imparted as I discuss Classen’s claims in a paper, even as I bring in the twist that Classen adds to try to make these claims seem plausible for the COVID-19 vaccine. Predictably, the twist is the claim that the mRNA in vaccines is what causes prion disease and results in Alzheimer’s disease.
So let’s look at the paper, which was published in an online journal, Microbiology & Infectious Diseases, and entitled “COVID-19 RNA Based Vaccines and the Risk of Prion Disease“. Unsurprisingly, it’s an open access journal not indexed in PubMed that’s published by SciVision Publishers, which shows up in Beall’s list of predatory publishers. Is this a predatory publisher? I don’t know, as there is apparently not strong agreement whether it should be classified as such, but the fact that it’s not indexed in PubMed certainly suggests that, at the very least, it’s not very likely to be a quality journal.
Deceptively, Classen writes this paper as though it were a real research paper, complete with hypothesis, experimental approach, results, and conclusions, starting with this fine bit of handwaving in the introduction:
The advent of new vaccine technology creates new potential mechanisms of vaccine adverse events. For example, the first killed polio vaccine actually caused polio in recipients because the up scaled manufacturing process did not effectively kill the polio virus before it was injected into patients. RNA based vaccines offers special risks of inducing specific adverse events. One such potential adverse event is prion based diseases caused by activation of intrinsic proteins to form prions. A wealth of knowledge has been published on a class of RNA binding proteins shown to [sic] participating in causing a number of neurological diseases including Alzheimer’s disease and ALS. TDP-43 and FUS are among the best studied of these proteins [2].
The Pfizer RNA based COVID-19 vaccine was approved by the US FDA under an emergency use authorization without long term safety data. Because of concerns about the safety of this vaccine a study was performed to determine if the vaccine could potentially induce prion based disease.
The first rule of reading an introduction like this is simple: Always look up the reference cited, in this case, this article. In this case, the article is a review article that looks at RNA binding proteins (not mRNAs or RNAs) that have prion-like domains found in neurodegenerative diseases:
Scouring the human genome with this algorithm enriches a select group of RNA-binding proteins harboring a canonical RNA recognition motif (RRM) and a putative prion domain. Indeed, of 210 human RRM-bearing proteins, 29 have a putative prion domain, and 12 of these are in the top 60 prion candidates in the entire genome. Startlingly, these RNA-binding prion candidates are inexorably emerging, one by one, in the pathology and genetics of devastating neurodegenerative disorders, including: amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), frontotemporal lobar degeneration with ubiquitin-positive inclusions (FTLD-U), Alzheimer’s disease and Huntington’s disease. For example, FUS and TDP-43, which rank 1st and 10th among RRM-bearing prion candidates, form cytoplasmic inclusions in the degenerating motor neurons of ALS patients and mutations in TDP-43 and FUS cause familial ALS.
So right off the bat, I know that Classen’s rationale for making the claim that the COVID-19 vaccine can induce prion disease is very weak. He’s pointing to RNA binding proteins, not mRNAs or RNAs, and he’s using that as a rationale to imply that a vaccine that contains only lipid nanoparticles and mRNA can cause prion disease. How, you might wonder, did he do this?
Let’s look at the methods section:
Pfizer’s RNA based vaccine against COVID-19 was evaluated for the potential to convert TDP-43 and or FUS to their prion based disease causing states. The vaccine RNA was analyzed for the presence of sequences that can activate TDP-43 and FUS. The interaction of the transcribed spike protein with its target was analyzed to determine if this action could also activate TDP-43 and FUS.
Wait, what?
How did Classen “evaluate the potential to convert TDP-43 and or FUS to their prion based disease causing states.” No, seriously, exactly how did he do that? He doesn’t say. Sure, he claims to have “analyzed” the mRNA sequence encoding the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein that was used in the Pfizer/BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine to induce cells to encode the protein to be used as the vaccine’s antigen, but he didn’t say how he did that. Classen appears to be leading readers to believe that he did some sort of bioinformatics analysis of the nucleotide sequence of the mRNA used in Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine, but details matter. Nowhere is there a figure showing the alignments of the sequences that he allegedly found that can “activate” TDP-43 and FUS. Nowhere in the paper is a description of the specific algorithms used to produce these claimed “alignments”. Nowhere is there a description of the methodology used or the analysis of the “goodness of fit” for the sequences that he claims to have identified that align with prion “activating” proteins. Nowhere is there a description of the controls, such as normal RNA sequences that contain the relevant sequences, which are common, so common as to be ubiquitous.
Instead, he engages in this bit of handwaving:
Analysis of the Pfizer vaccine against COVID-19 identified two potential risk factors for inducing prion disease is [sic] humans. The RNA sequence in the vaccine [3] contains sequences believed to induce TDP-43 and FUS to aggregate in their prion based conformation leading to the development of common neurodegerative diseases. In particular it has been shown that RNA sequences GGUA [4], UG rich sequences [5], UG tandem repeats [6], and G Quadruplex sequences [7], have increased affinity to bind TDP-43 and or FUS and may cause TDP-43 or FUS to take their pathologic configurations in the cytoplasm. In the current analysis a total of sixteen UG tandem repeats (ΨGΨG) were identified and additional UG (ΨG) rich sequences were identified. Two GGΨA sequences were found. G Quadruplex sequences are possibly present but sophisticated computer programs are needed to verify these.
Unfortunately, some of the papers cited by Classen show that what he is claiming, namely that the mRNA in the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine can induce TDP-43 and FUS to “go prion,” is basically impossible. For example, this paper points out that TDP-43 is an RBP that exists predominantly in the nucleus. As I pointed out the last time I took on the antivaccine claim that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines can “reprogram your DNA”, the mRNA from the vaccine never makes it into the nucleus. Guess what? FUS is a nuclear RBP as well!
So what we have here is a whole heck of a lot of speculation, with the finding of an obscure connection based on methodology that is not explained with anywhere near the level of rigor that a real molecular biologist or bioinformatics scientist would require to be convinced. Basically, Classen points to the mRNA sequence in the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine and finds sequences associated with the “prionization” of these proteins, while completely ignoring the known fact that these are nuclear proteins and that the mRNA in the COVID-19 vaccine remains in the cytoplasm. In fact, the whole idea that there are mRNAs that can behave like prions and induce misfolded proteins appears, if this recent review arguing for an expansion of the definition of prion is any indication, to be largely speculative and not yet firmly demonstrated at this time.
Amusingly, Classen can’t resist adding one more layer to his speculation:
The spike protein encoded by the vaccine binds angiotensin converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), an enzyme which contains zinc molecules [8]. The binding of spike protein to ACE2 has the potential to release the zinc molecule, an ion that causes TDP-43 to assume its pathologic prion transformation [9].
First, it’s a zinc ion that binds ACE2, not a “molecule”. “Dr.” Classen should really get some basic chemical terminology right if he wants to be taken seriously. Second, this is the purest speculation to claim that the spike protein will somehow result in the release of zinc from ACE2 that will then cause TDP-43 to “go prion”. Again, all you have to know to realize how much handwaving is involved here is to know that ACE2 is a cell surface receptor and TDP-43 is a nuclear protein. The two proteins aren’t even in the same compartment of the cell. Truly, Classen’s handwaving here is achieving sufficient velocity for him to lift off and fly like a bird!
Of course, in his discussion, Classen also can’t resist the JAQing off (if you don’t know what that means, click here) portion of his handwaving speculation:
Another related concern is that the Pfizer vaccine uses a unique RNA nucleoside 1-methyl-3′-pseudouridylyl (Ψ). According to FDA briefing documents, this nucleoside was chosen to reduce activation of the innate immune system [12]. RNA molecules containing this nucleoside will undoubtedly have altered binding [13]. Unfortunately, the effect on TDP-43, FUS and other RNA binding proteins is not published. The use of this nucleoside in a vaccine can potentially enhance the binding affinity of RNA sequences capable of causing TDP-43 and FUS to assume toxic configurations.
Again, none of this matters because these proteins are not even in the same cellular compartment that the COVID-19 vaccine mRNA enters. That’s not all, though. Prion diseases are diseases of the central nervous system. These vaccines are injected into the muscle, and, even if Classen’s ideas were anything other than speculation pulled out of his nether regions about highly tenuous and, yes, speculative associations, COVID-19 vaccines aren’t injected into the central nervous system.
Who is J. Bart Classen?
It turns out that he’s been a subject on this particular blog before, primarily as scientist who gave antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. ammunition for his false claim that vaccines are responsible for the obesity epidemic. According to Wikipedia, Dr. Classen received his MD from the University of Maryland, Baltimore in 1988 and also has an MBA from Columbia University. Unsurprisingly, he’s been quoted by Sharyl Attkisson, a reporter who’s become an antivaccine activist and conspiracy theorist in her own right. Classen’s website, Vaccines.net, is pretty rudimentary but does proclaim:
The content of this site is not intended to be anti-immunization but instead to promote the concept that the goal of immunization is to promote health not eradicate infections. It is hoped that through the collection and dissemination of information about the chronic effects of vaccines, safer immunization practices will become available for those who choose to be immunized.
There it is, the “I’m not ‘antivaccine’; I’m a pro-safe vaccine” gambit, beloved of antivaxxers going back at least to Jenny McCarthy 14 years ago. Naturally, after proclaiming himself a “vaccine safety advocate”, Dr. Classen then goes on to spout antivaccine misinformation:
There is growing evidence that immunization causes a large number of other chronic diseases including autism, diabetes, obesity, metabolic syndrome, autoimmune diseases, allergies, asthma, cancers, and Gulf War Syndrome. Data linking these diseases to vaccines includes human and animal data. In many cases, the increased risk of developing these diseases following immunization exceeds the risk of infectious complications prevented by immunization.
In other words, “I’m not antivaccine, but I believe that vaccines cause every disease under the sun and are riskier than infectious disease”. (Actually, that’s the very definition of being antivaccine.) It turns out that Classen originally made his name in the 1990s claiming that vaccines cause diabetes. Ultimately, he ended up forming an antivaccine company, Classen Immunotherapies, which is the organization that appears on his paper. Unsurprisingly, of late, Classen Immunotherapeutics has been proclaiming how “concerned” it has become about the “safety of vaccines for COVID-19” and how it “believes all the risks are not known and have not been discussed with the public”.
Just for amusement, I perused the list of publications on Classen’s website. Unsurprisingly, he believes the conspiracy theory that COVID-19 is a bioweapon that was initially spread clandestinely and a new one on me, namely that the 2019 epidemic of E-vaping acute lung injury was caused in part by COVID-19, never mind that the first case of COVID-19 wasn’t identified as a new disease in China until very late in 2019 and the disease didn’t become widespread outside of China until early 2020.
And now he thinks that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines can cause prion disease leading to neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s disease. With zero evidence to support his idea and very close to zero biological plausibility. Of course.
Variations on a theme
I return to my mantras about the antivaccine movement in the age of COVID-19: There is nothing new under the sun (in antivaccine circles), and everything old is new again (when it comes to antivaccine conspiracy theories and disinformation). Even the most obscure antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories are being resurrected, dusted off, tweaked a bit, and repurposed to use to attack COVID-19 vaccines. There doesn’t need to be any evidence or even biological plausibility, just science-y speculation that sounds impressive to people without a background in the relevant sciences. Classen’s claim that mRNA vaccines can cause prion disease leading to neurodegenerative disorders like Alzheimer’s disease is just another example of this.
With Classen’s claim, I’m hard pressed to think of an old antivaccine trope that hasn’t yet been weaponized against COVID-19 vaccines, with one exception. No one, to my knowledge, has yet claimed that COVID-19 vaccines cause autism. The reason for that omission is simple, however. As of today, no COVID-19 vaccine has been authorized for use in children. As soon as a COVID-19 vaccine is authorized or approved for use in children, antivaxxers will claim it causes autism. It’s coming. You know it is.

Prions. Why did it have to be prions? (Again.)
Prions. Why did it have to be prions? (Again.) The antivax trope that vaccines cause prion disease is an old one, and antivaxxers are trying desperately to resurrect it to apply to COVID-19 vaccines.
David Gorski on March 11, 2024
Link
Here’s yet another instance where I feel obligated to say something that I repeat so often that it might irritate some readers: Since COVID-19, with respect to antivaccine quackery, pseudoscience, and misinformation, everything old is new again. I realize that many of you find this to be such an obvious statement that my continual repeating of it might even irritate some of you. However, you have to understand that the vast majority of colleagues out there, having ranged from only knowing a few of the common antivax tropes (e.g., vaccines supposedly causing autism) to being utterly oblivious to antivaccine misinformation, keep acting surprised when they hear antivaxxers blame COVID-19 vaccines for things like prion disease.
Prion disease? Oh, yes, I’m very serious. Behold the “2nd Smartest Guy in the World” (2ndSGitW), which if true would tell me that humanity is stupid indeed! Fortunately, it is not true, and even allowing that 2ndSGitW is claiming that title ironically, the disconnect between the title and the nonsense that this pseudonymous blogger spews on Substack is nonetheless less jarring. Today’s example is UPDATE: Doctors Warn mRNA “Vaccines” Could Spur Epidemic of Prion Brain Diseases, which is indeed an actual update to a Substack post from a few days earlier that I had squirreled away in my folder of quackery for later attention, Doctors warn mRNA vaccines could spur epidemic of prion brain diseases. My reaction to this was akin to Indiana Jones’ reaction to falling into a nest of snakes:
“Prions. Why did it have to be prions?”
As I sat down to write about this, I debated about whether to describe what 2ndSGitW wrote first and then go back and describe just how old the whole antivax claim that vaccines cause prion disease, complete with examples, or vice-versa. Truth be told, I don’t know that one option is better than the other, but first let’s describe what prion disease is and how the idea that vaccines cause prion disease entered the antivax lexicon. This will help you understand the rationale used by antivaxxers like 2ndSGitW, but more importantly why the rationale and science are bogus.
Indeed, the “update” also solidifies the whole COVID-19 vaccines/prion connection as nothing more than yet another conspiracy theory held together with biobabble. Remember Star Trek’s technobabble, which was science-y sounding language that meant nothing used to lend plausibility to whatever magic was being done at the time? Biobabble is the same thing, just with biology, and antivaxxers and quacks use it all the time. Basically, it’s fancy-sounding biological babble that can impress the rubes but that scientists who know the actual science will immediately recognize as bullshit.
What are prions and prion diseases?
Boiled down to the simplest explanation, prion diseases are degenerative neurologic diseases caused by prions. Basically, prions are believed to be misfolded proteins that can transmit their misfolded shape onto normal variants of the same protein. I don’t need to go into the details for you to understand the very basics of prion disease, other than to note that the protein that makes up prions, the major prion protein (PrP) is found in many places in the body in healthy people and animals, and its normal function in biology and physiology is poorly understood. Most prions are malformed isoforms of PrP.
These diseases can affect animals and humans and can be transmitted in some cases to humans by consuming the meat from animals affected with the disease. Prion diseases are rare diseases, with only around 300 cases/year being reported on average in the US, and include congenital, sporadic, and acquired prion diseases. I think right here I’ll just quote the Johns Hopkins website:
    • CJD (Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease). A person can inherit this condition, in which case it’s called familial CJD. Sporadic CJD, on the other hand, develops suddenly without any known risk factors. Most cases of CJD are sporadic and tend to strike people around age 60. Acquired CJD is caused by exposure to infected tissue during a medical procedure, such as a cornea transplant. Symptoms of CJD (see below) quickly lead to severe disability and death. In most cases, death occurs within a year.
    • Variant CJD. This is an infectious type of the disease that is related to “mad cow disease.” Eating diseased meat may cause the disease in humans. The meat may cause normal human prion protein to develop abnormally. This type of the disease usually affects younger people.
    • Variably protease-sensitive prionopathy (VPSPr). This is also extremely rare, it is similar to CJD but the protein is less sensitive to digestion. It is more likely to strike people around age 70 who have a family history of dementia.
    • Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker disease (GSS). Extremely rare, but occurs at an earlier age, typically around age 40.
    • Kuru. This disease is seen in New Guinea. It’s caused by eating human brain tissue contaminated with infectious prions. Because of increased awareness about the disease and how it is transmitted, kuru is now rare.
    • Fatal insomnia (FI). Rare hereditary disorder causing difficulty sleeping. There is also a sporadic form of the disease that is not inherited.
These diseases are uniformly fatal, with no known effective treatment thus far. In livestock and wildlife, prion diseases such as scrapie (sheep), chronic wasting disease (deer, elk, moose), and mad cow disease (cattle) can spread by casual contact or contamination of feeds or the environment. Prions also can be infectious if inadvertently transferred from person to person by invasive medical procedures. Prion aggregates are very stable and thus resistant to denaturation by chemical and physical agents. Thus, they cannot be destroyed by ordinary disinfection or cooking, as they are resistant to proteases, heat, ionizing radiation, and formaldehyde treatments. Getting rid of prion contamination requires protein hydrolysis or reduction or destruction of protein tertiary structure so that it cannot provoke further misfolding of proteins. Examples include sodium hypochlorite, sodium hydroxide, and strongly acidic detergents.
Now that you know what prion diseases are, you can see why, despite their rarity, they are very scary and why outbreaks of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (“mad cow disease”) are treated so aggressively.
The claim by antivaxxers that vaccines can result in prion disease is one that I’ve seen far less frequently than the claim that they cause Alzheimer’s disease, so much so that a review of SBM found that we’ve only touched on it briefly in John Snyder’s review of Dr. Bob Sears’ book touting his “alternative” vaccine schedule. The origin of the claim appears to derive from the observation that the media used to support the growth of some of the cell lines used to grow virus stock from which vaccines are made contains fetal bovine serum (FBS), a common ingredient in cell culture media. Antivaxxers originally used that observation to claim a risk of “prion contamination” of vaccines. Never mind that such contamination of a vaccine with prions has never been documented or demonstrated.
Like many antivaccine myths, the myth that vaccines might become contaminated with prions originates from a tiny grain of possible truth. Decades ago, during the height of the mad cow disease outbreak in the UK, there was indeed concern about using FBS from British cattle to manufacture vaccines. A news article in Nature from 2000 reported on the findings of an inquiry into Britain’s BSE epidemic and even specifically asked the question: “Were some CJD victims infected by vaccines?” The report basically concluded that the answer to that question was unknown, but:
The BSE inquiry’s report (see above) calls for vaccines to be investigated as a possible route of transmission. But it concedes that this will be hampered by the fact that “systematic records of the action taken in response to BSE in respect of individual medical products are lacking”.
And:
Alarmingly, vaccines produced after the point at which the BSE epidemic had been identified — possibly using British bovine material — were still in use as recently as November 1993. According to the inquiry’s report, the chief medical officer of the day, Donald Acheson, decided to phase out the existing stocks because new batches of vaccines take time to grow, and medical experts considered that the benefit of maintaining a continuous national immunization programme outweighed the risk of interrupting it.
You can see how far back this idea goes, at least three decades.
An article in MPR from 2010 by pediatrician Dr. Gary S. Marshall, author of The Vaccine Handbook: A Practical Guide for Clinicians (The Purple Book), is more reassuring. Noting that the FDA convened a meeting in 2000 to discuss the very question of whether vaccines could transmit BSE, Dr. Marshall characterizes the conclusions of the FDA thusly:
Although the risk of transmission of vCJD to humans from such vaccines was considered theoretic and remote, the recommendation was made that vaccines use bovine materials originating from countries without endogenous MCD. Mathematical models suggest that the agent of MCD first entered cattle feed in the United Kingdom around 1980; since the vast majority of initial cases of vCJD were born well before then, childhood vaccines were not likely to be the cause.
And:
Maternal-fetal transmission of prions has never been documented in animals and fetal blood is not known to contain prions. Moreover, the fetal bovine serum used in vaccine manufacture is highly diluted and eventually removed from cells during purification of vaccine viruses. It should be pointed out as well that prions propagate in mammalian brain but not in cell culture.
And:
Final reassurance comes from the fact that transmission of prions occurs from eating the brains of infected animals or from directly inoculating preparations of brains of infected animals into the brains of experimental animals. Transmission of prions has not been documented after inoculation into the muscles or under the skin, which are the routes used for vaccination. Taken together, the chances that currently licensed vaccines contain prions and represent a risk to humans is essentially zero.
So, although the claim that vaccines transmit prions entered the antivaccine lexicon of disinformation in the 1990s nearly three decades before the pandemic hit and after billions upon billions of doses of vaccines for which the viral stock was grown in FBS-containing media, as COVID-19 spread throughout the world, there was no evidence that vaccines had ever been contaminated with prions or ever caused a single case of prion disease in humans or animals anywhere. It was a non-issue.
Of course, remember my mantra. Everything old is new again. When the pandemic hit and mRNA vaccines were rolled out in December 2020, it didn’t take long for the hoary old myth that vaccines cause prion disease to be rejiggered and applied to the “scary” new mRNA vaccines against COVID-19, as I discussed in February 2021, a mere two months after the mRNA vaccines were granted an emergency use authorization (EUA) by the FDA. That was when J. Bart Classen, the antivaxxer best known prepandemic for blaming vaccines for diabetes, latched onto the idea that the new mRNA vaccines and published a fake review article in a predatory journal that I deconstructed in detail three years ago.
If it hadn’t been three years since I wrote about this, I might not have bothered with 2ndSGitW’s blather, but I figured: What the heck? I wondered what, if anything, this anonymous Substack antivaxxer might have added to the antivax misinformation.
COVID-19 vaccines and prion disease?
Let’s start with the first article, published last week, Doctors warn mRNA vaccines could spur epidemic of prion brain diseases, which further claimed that “…prions can be transmitted to others, whether they have received the “vaccines” or not,” citing an old post by—you guessed it!—2ndSGitW entitled, New Data Confirms Injections Cause Previously Rare Creutzfeld Jacobs Disease – Misinformed & Biased Alex Berenson Claimed “Fringe Scientists” Do Not Have Proof: Here Is The Proof. My first reaction was amusement at the crank fight, given that Alex Berenson, the “pandemic’s wrongest man,” had apparently dismissed the claims that COVID-19 vaccines caused prion disease as the products of “fringe scientists” who didn’t have any evidence. Let’s just say that it’s rare that I agree with Alex Berenson, and if you embrace conspiracy theories that even Alex Berenson thinks are too out there to be believed you really need to reassess your title of “2nd Smartest Guy in the World.”
So what was 2ndSGitW’s rebuttal? A comment on Berenson’s Substack referencing a crank website run by Sid Belzberg and Adam Gaertner collecting cases of prion disease that it attributes to COVID-19 vaccines:
Last fall my colleagues Adam Gaertner and others posted this website for a few months.
https://prions.rip (we recently reactivated it). During those few months in the fall we got about 15,000 hits
We requested at the time that anyone who after the injection got serious neurological problems or their loved ones to submit a report to the site. We got 60 reports including 6 cases of diagnosed Creutzfeld Jacobs diseases. Normally this disease hits 1 in a 1,000,000 people. To get 6 cases you would need 6,000,000 hits to the site assuming everyone reports. The chances of getting 1 cases in 15000 hits is 1 in 66. To see 6 cases in 1 group of 15000 is 1/66^6. or 1 in 82,000,000,000 20 times more likely to win the powerball lottery!
We recently put the site back up and again ask if anyone has has serious neurological events post vax please post a report.https://prions.rip.
Among the “fringe scientists” that supported our hypothesis last year included the late Dr.Luc Montagnier Nobel laureate,
The amusing thing is that Berenson’s article was about a case report of a woman who developed CJD after vaccination and the conspiracy theory that this was being covered up. Berenson was actually more open to the idea than 2ndGitW and Sid Belzberg let on. True, he did characterize the idea thusly:
Even before Cohen’s case, in early 2021, some fringe scientists had conjectured the mRNA vaccines might risk causing or accelerating CJD or other brain diseases by triggering brain proteins to misfold. But their claims were theoretical and speculative and almost universally dismissed.
I note that that fringe scientist was J. Barton Classen, and the article was the very same one that I deconstructed in February 2021. In any event, just for yucks I looked to see what the Prions.rip website showed and got this:
I’m half tempted to purchase this domain.
Never one to be so easily stymied, I invoked the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org and found Prions.rip as it existed in August 2022. Quelle surprise, the website was selling a prion test and quack treatments for prion disease and included a link to report cases of prion disease that anyone thinks might be due to the vaccine. That’s some powerful evidence, 2ndSGitW!
So what is the new evidence presented in the 2ndSGitW’s article from a few days ago? Nothing, really, other than assertions like this, based on a link to an old post from the same Substack:
…the “vaccine” adverse events now extend to once unimagined ailments of horror show proportions whereby the genetically modified humans transmit dementia, Alzheimer’s Disease, and potentially many other diseases that were previously untransmittable.
I note that the claim that vaccines cause dementia like Alzheimer’s disease is also a very old claim that I discussed in detail along with the claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease. Indeed, the first time I ever encountered the claim that vaccines cause Alzheimer’s disease was when I saw Bill Maher make the claim on Real Time With Bill Maher in…2005. That’s when he claimed that influenza vaccines cause Alzheimer’s, with the risk increasing with the number of years you’re vaccinated against the flu. Truly, everything old is new again. Hilariously, the evidence that 2ndSGitW uses to imply that COVID-19 vaccines will cause dementia is an estimate of how much the prevalence of dementia will increase by 2050 in Europe. Of course, it never occurs to antivaxxers that, given that dementia and particularly Alzheimer’s disease are diseases of aging and the populations of developed countries are aging, we would expect to observe this very phenomenon over the next 25 years. Indeed, demographers have been warning about it for decades. Basically, citing a World Health Organization report concluding that the number of people with dementia is expected to increase from 55 million now to 78 million by 2030 and 139 million by 2050, 2ndSGitW dismisses this explanation thusly:
At least in this report “climate change” was not blamed for the surge in dementia.
More importantly, anything but the DEATHVAX™ is to be blamed.
And it would not be the global eugenics program that it is without the One World Government’s medical node the WHO being involved, and carefully “monitoring” this rise in dementia (and autism, cancer, SIDS, myocarditis, Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease and so on and so forth).
Expect that one day the truth will finally come out and charts like the above will have bars of State sanctioned “vaccine” schedules.
Do NOT comply.
OK, my bad. It was a conspiracy theory before the “update” in which 2ndSGitW goes on to speculate:
These mis-folded proteins of the “vaccinated” may infect others, and potentially cause a global Alzheimer’s Disease epidemic; thus, it would follow that captured governments would be able to control and ultimately depopulate or decarbonize large swaths of cognitively impaired societies with far greater ease.
Of course, the biggest problem with the impending surge in the number of people suffering from dementia is how to take care of them, which is incredibly expensive. The obvious conspiracy theory is that they’ll just be killed or allowed to die. However, I couldn’t help but think that there would be a lot more inexpensive and practical methods than giving large swaths of the population dementia with a vaccine, which is slow and expensive. That must be where the prion disease comes in, as prion diseases produce rapid neurologic deterioration. Even so, it’s usually months to years before the victim dies, and during that time the victim will need a lot of medical and custodial care. As depopulation conspiracies go, this one just doesn’t seem very…efficient. Or even practical.
In fairness, 2ndSGitW doesn’t just lay down the above conspiracy theory. He/she/it also proposes a new mechanism for how COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease. I bet that some of you with some knowledge of molecular biology might be able to guess what it is if you’ve been reading my posts over the last three months. Here’s what I mean:
A paper as far back as 2013 warned of the known action of mRNA “frame-shifted” spike proteins in promoting conditions known as “prion diseases” – and that they are “transmissible.”
The most common, Creutzfeld-Jakob disease, featured in the campaign to destroy live cattle, amidst fears that prions carried by animals could be transmitted to humans who consume them. This paper, over ten years old, found that the action of mRNA is a known cause of prion disease, which can result in “transmissible spongiform encepholopathy” from the slightest exposure to altered proteins.
“Frameshifting accounts quantitatively for the ætiology of prion disease. One per million frameshifted prions may be enough to cause disease. The HIV TAR-like element in the PRNP mRNA is likely an effector of frameshifting,” the paper explained.
A recent video featured U.K.-based Dr. Kevin McCairn explaining this mechanism. McCairn – who first raised the alarm over the dangers of prion disease in 2020 and is a former neuroscientist at the Korea Brain Research Institute – reveals that mRNA technology used in the COVID jabs is causing the same “frame shifting” that leads to harmful prions being produced.
Later:
He also asserts that these prions can be transmitted to others, whether they have received the “vaccines” or not.
“Mis-folded proteins caused by prions can impact every level organ and tissue system in the body…” McCairn said in the video published by Health Alliance Australia on February 19. “[They] bioaccumulate and are resistant to degradation, thereby building up in the environment.”
Wait, what? J. Bart Classen wasn’t the first crank to suggest that COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease? I guess that, even at this late stage, I can learn new things. I can also look up the paper cited by 2ndSGitW and easily see that it has basically nothing to do with mRNA vaccines or the spike protein. Rather, it is a theoretical paper, published in the Journal of Theoretical Biology, and does hypothesize that frame-shifting in PrP is part of the cause of prion disease, not frame shifting in spike proteins. Frame shifting occurs when the translation of mRNA to protein is “shifted” out of frame by starting at a different nucleotide and results in very different proteins that are often truncated because the frame shift introduces a stop codon. I wrote about this in a great deal of detail the first time around, if you’re interested, as well as why the fear mongering about small amount of frame shifting seen when mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines does not do all the horrible things that antivaxxers with molecular biology background try to claim that it does and how frame shifting occurs naturally…a lot.
None of this stops 2ndSGitW from citing…Kevin McKernan:
McKernan explained in a video with the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance the mechanism of “frameshifting,” which is claimed to lead to prion disease. This is the production of multiple proteins from the injected RNA, which he says manufactures the proteins which lead to rare diseases.
If you frameshift over the stop codons, you’re going to be making proteins that are spike-mito proteins. When I talk to a lot of the Long Vax patients I hear of all these things that remind me of my time in the mitochondrial disease sequencing space…
“Spike-mito” proteins? What does this even mean? I will give McKernan props, however, for echoing another favorite antivax trope from before the pandemic about how vaccines supposedly provoke mitochondrial disease. True, before the pandemic, that idea was that vaccines alter the redox chemistry in the cell and affect the mitochondria in a way that results in autism, but it was not unexpected that antivaxxers would try to use the same biobabble to blame vaccines for neurodegenerative diseases, such as prion diseases and dementia. I’ll also give 2ndSGitW props for using his/her/its fear mongering about prion diseases from COVID-19 vaccines to sell familiar quackery:
What may perhaps be the most effective prion-based disease treatment protocol is this Substack’s protocol which is based on the old Joe Tippens cancer treatment protocol…
Yes, that’s the protocol with fenbendazole, ivermectin, curcumin, and other things that 2ndSGitW has been promoting as a cure for cancer.
But what about 2ndSGitW’s latest update, published over the weekend?
I must admit that I was confused, because 2ndSGitW starts out with claiming that the vaccines cause VAIDS (vaccine AIDS), based on the nonsensical idea that very short nucleotide sequences in the mRNA of the vaccine that match sequences from HIV but are also very common because they are short sequences and short sequences are often found in many genes. It didn’t take me long to figure out how that came about, but first, he/she/it pivots to a conspiracy theory:
The overriding question that now remains is did the Intelligence Industrial Complex and their partners-in-crime like BigPharma, the UN, WEF, CFR, WHO, NIH, FDA, CDC, et al. know that their Modified mRNA “vaccines” would induce prion diseases.
Longtime readers of this Substack already know the answer to this crucial question.
Let us consider the following article from 2019 that was written by a trio of DoD/USSOCOM/DARPA scientists, more at biowarfare criminals conducting illegal research as paid for via grants stolen from taxes, in the Deep State journal Defence iQ entitled, Prions as Bioweapons?
The article cited was published by Defence IQ, “one of the world’s largest defence events and media organisations.” Basically, it lays out concerns how prions might be used as bioweapons, noting that recent “developments in prion research may enthuse weaponization of prion agents, and thereby pose threats to national security.” The article is very speculative and outright notes that “there are no known bioweapon programs that currently utilize prions and/or prion-based substances” while nonetheless encouraging “the US government and international regulators to focus on the current and near-term capabilities of prion research for employment in both kinetic and non-kinetic engagements.”
2ndSGitW also unironically quotes this passage:
For example, prion infections targeting meat markets, animal resources, and prompting public fear could disturb the relative capabilities of regional or global economic and socio-political competitors. The instigating actor/state could then offer viable alternative products or treatments to capitalize on the disruption, thereby establishing relative economic hegemony – and power – in these markets and perhaps on the world stage. If, and when combined with a well-executed misinformation campaign, such an approach could yield multi-domain, multi-dimensional effects that would be iterative, robust, and likely evoke durable consequences.
I’m sure it totally escapes 2ndSGitW that that’s not unlike what he/she/it and fellow COVID-19 antivax quacks are doing, spreading misinformation about COVID-19, even if they didn’t create it, and the offering what they think are “viable alternative products or treatments,” never mind that they aren’t viable in that they aren’t effective. Truly, every accusation is an admission.
Which brings us back to VAIDS:
Our three hacks were also most certainly familiar with an article from 2013 entitled, Frameshifted prion proteins as pathological agents: Quantitative considerations which established that, “The HIV TAR-like element in the PRNP mRNA is likely an effector of frameshifting.”
Which is why it came as little coincidence when genomics expert Kevin McKernan recently proved that the very same frameshifting is also induced by the Modified mRNA “vaccines.”
Which further establishes that VAIDS was always a known and expected side effect of these Modified mRNA poisons.
Which further proves that prion based diseases were a deliberate feature, and most definitely not a bug, of the various bioweapon GOF programs that illegitimate government agencies and their co-conspirators were illegally developing, and continue to do so.
So that’s how the conspiracy theorists close the loop and relate the vaccine, mRNA frameshifting, and the claim that the brief sequences from HIV had been intentionally introduced into SARS-CoV-2 (the coronavirus that causes COVID-19), the last of which was a conspiracy theory unfortunately embraced by Nobel Laureate Luc Montagnier as “evidence” that SARS-CoV-2 was not only the result of a “lab leak” but had been engineered as a bioweapon. I must say, this conspiracy theory that COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease unifies a number of other conspiracy theories about COVID-19, from the “VAIDS” conspiracy theory to the “lab leak” conspiracy theory. Impressive.
2ndSGitW even brings in the financial angle, citing projections that the market for prion disease treatment will increase by close to 50% by 2030, just six years away and then going straight for the pharma angle:
And is it any wonder then that the global(ist) prion disease treatment market chart ends in the UN’s climacteric year of their 2030 Agenda endgame? Because at the rate these “vaccine” adverse events are progressing, by 2030 large swaths of society will be afflicted with premature dementia and Alzheimer’s Disease, and thus these genetically modified patients will be that much easier to transition into their medically assisted “peaceful culling” democide.
But wait! There’s hope! Because yet again 2ndSGitW invokes the Tippens Protocol as the cure for the prion disease caused by the evil vaccines, because of course there’s grift involved in all this conspiracy mongering. Too bad there’s no evidence that any vaccine, much less COVID-19 vaccines, cause prion diseases. However, because everything old is new again (and reborn for the pandemic), antivaxxers are promoting the evidence-free claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause prion disease in support of each other’s grift selling fake cures for prion disease (not to mention cancer, COVID-19 itself, and every medical condition that they attribute to the vaccines and the evil pharmaceutical agenda).
Same as it ever was.
“Same as it ever was.’
And why did it have to be prions? Again?

Hypervaccination
What would happen if you were vaccinated 217 times against COVID?Let’s find out.
Steven Novella on March 6, 2024
Link
Just to be clear, we are not recommending this. But it is an interesting question – what would happen if someone were vaccinated multiple times, far exceeding standard recommendations, against SARS-CoV2? Well, The Lancet recently reported on a 62 year old gentleman who claims to have been vaccinated 217 times over the last two years. He acquired these vaccines privately for his own purposes. Public records were able to confirm 130 of these vaccinations (which were the mRNA vaccines), while he had personal records of 108 vaccinations with partial overlap.
The two obvious general questions (well, I guess other than why did he do it) are – was this hypervaccination safe, and did it provide extra protection? Let’s take the safety question first. The man, referred to as HIM in the Lancet article, reported no side effects. He did not appear to suffer any medical issues during this time. Also, “62 routine clinical chemistry parameters showed no abnormalities.”
This means that he did not suffer kidney or liver damage, did not experience significant muscle breakdown, and did not develop an auto-immune disease. We cannot rule out at this time a delayed effect or long term risk of hypervaccination with an mRNA vaccine against SARS-CoV2, but any serious side effect is unlikely if there is no sign of any issue after two years.
The researchers who were allowed to examine HIM were most interested, however, in what the effects of hypervaccination were on his immune response. Specifically, did this result in super-immunity, but also did hypervaccination cause exhaustion of his immune system through overstimulation?
On the first question they report:
“HIM’s serum neutralisation capacity was 5·4-fold and 11·5-fold higher compared with the control group vaccinees, for wildtype and Omicron B1.1.529 spike proteins, respectively.”
As expected, repeated vaccination did produce higher antibody levels to the spike proteins, which are the targets of vaccination. Of note, he had detectable levels of antibodies in his saliva, while the control group of vaccinees did not. He also showed higher absolute numbers of memory and effector T-cells. Therefore both humoral and cellular immunity were increased compared to those who followed standard vaccination.
One of the main questions for the researchers was whether or not HIMs immune system would have a decreased capacity to respond to a new antigen challenge (whether from infection or vaccination) because he had essentially exhausted his immune system from repeated vaccination. They had the opportunity to measure this, because HIM continued to receive further vaccinations during the study.
They found no evidence of immune exhaustion. His adaptive immune response appeared to be intact, without any qualitative change. He continued to have an increase in his antibody levels with further vaccination, although these were predictably modest.
It is also interesting to note that antibody testing showed that HIM was likely never infected with SARS-CoV2. Of course, in a single case we cannot attribute this causally to the vaccinations.
What does all of this tell us? We cannot really generalize from a single case like this, but it does show, at least in this one person, that multiple repeated vaccinations with an mRNA vaccine can be entirely safe. There isn’t necessarily any toxicity that kicks in at high doses at this level. Further, the mRNA COVID vaccines he received did not overstimulate or exhaust his immune system, which retained its ability to react to new challenges with intact adaptive immunity.
While again this one case cannot put these questions to bed, it is interesting evidence against many of the claims of anti-vaxxers, who have claimed without evidence that too many vaccines are dangerous and that they overwhelm the immune system.
These claims were never very plausible. Our immune systems are assailed on a daily basis with countless antigens (substances that cause an immune response). Even a complete vaccine schedule represents a tiny additional challenge – insignificant compared to the background workout our immune systems regularly experience. This case study is at least compatible with the standard scientific view, and did not present any surprises.
As an aside, this kind of evidence is frequently used in medicine – case studies or case series of individuals who had exposures that would be unethical to deliver deliberately. Sometimes people, for example, accidentally or deliberately overdose with a pharmaceutical, something we could never do to a person for a study. But it does provide the opportunity to gather data about such high doses. Almost all of our safety data with drugs in pregnancy comes from cases in which women were exposed before realizing they were pregnant, or who ignored standard advice.
So while we have to emphasize that no one is recommending hypervaccination and we cannot be confident that in the general population such hypervaccination is safe, HIM does provide some reassurance. Finally, we need to remember that medicine is always about risk vs benefit. The standard vaccine recommendation are based on this reasoning – how many vaccines are necessary to provide sufficient benefit? Beyond some point you get diminishing returns of benefit with increasing probability of risk. HIM was way past that point.

“I Don’t Know What’s in It”
Is not knowing what’s in a vaccine a valid reason to refuse it?
Harriet Hall on August 24, 2021
Link


A woman who was interviewed on the news explained why she refuses to accept a vaccine for Covid-19: “I don’t know what’s in it”.
At first glance, that sounds like a very reasonable stance. Surely it is foolish to ingest or inject something when you don’t know what you’re getting. If everyone followed that policy, there would be far fewer poisonings and far fewer overdoses of street drugs among addicts who found a new supplier and unwittingly got a much higher dose than they were used to. But it’s not as simple as knowing “what’s in it.” The devil is in the details.
Information about vaccines is readily available: how they were developed, and what’s in them. That woman was being willfully ignorant; she could know “what’s in it” but she doesn’t really want to know. Saying that is nothing but a rationale to support her irrational decision not to get vaccinated.
And even if she read the available information, would she understand it? We can’t all be perfectly knowledgeable about every possible subject. Most of us have to accept the word of experts and are quite willing to do so. Perhaps she distrusts vaccine experts or distrusts all scientists. Is that rational? Who would she trust? Someone who wrote something on the internet? A friend who has strong opinions but no scientific training? Her gut? How would knowing “what’s in it” help her decide whether to accept the vaccine?
The irony is that she can’t possibly have the same objections to everything. When she eats dinner at a friend’s house, does she demand to know what’s in the food before she tastes it? If she eats at a restaurant, does she ask about ingredients she is allergic to, or does she want to know everything that’s in the food? Does she take a dietary supplement? Does she realize that when supplements have been tested, they have frequently been found to be contaminated with everything from insect parts to prescription drugs? Does she take a multivitamin? How can she trust it contains what the label says? (It often has more or less than the label says). How can she determine whether taking it will benefit her health? Does she take a homeopathic remedy? Does she understand what the dilutions mean? Does she take drugs prescribed by her doctor? Does she know what’s in them? Has she accepted other vaccinations? Has she had a tetanus shot? Did she ask what was in it?
Conclusion: She’s just making up an excuse
Should we believe her? I don’t. People are all too often unaware of the real reasons they do things or believe things. They make up their minds first and later try to find reasons for their opinions that will sound plausible to others. I don’t believe that not knowing what’s in the vaccine is the real reason she’s refusing vaccination. I think it’s just an excuse, and not a very good one.

Closing the vaccine hesitancy gap
What tactics and strategies should be used to address COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy?
Scott Gavura on July 8, 2021
Link

With the supply of vaccines now outpacing vaccination rates in countries like the USA and Canada, achieving robust community (herd) immunity and reducing illness, hospitalizations and death will be dependent on achieving adequate uptake of the vaccine in the population. At time of writing, the Delta variant is the most important variant of concern, and it appears to be more transmissible and potentially capable of causing more severe disease. And while the currently-authorized vaccines still seem to be effective at reducing the severity of COVID-19 infections, hospitalization, and death, there is acknowledgement that as long as SARS-CoV-2 continues to circulate widely, the risk of more dangerous variants appearing will remain.
Many of those eligible for the vaccine have leapt at the chance to be vaccinated. Where I am in Ontario, Canada, the rollout has been a Hunger Games-like experience at times, with limited supply, overloaded booking systems and long queues at pop-up clinics. But despite the technical issues and delays, Canadians are embracing vaccination. Currently 78.2% of eligible Canadians (12 years and older) have receive their first dose, which is 68% of the entire Canadian population. These numbers now outpace the overall USA and compare favorably with some states (congratulations Vermont!) with even better uptake. But there are huge differences within regions and state-to-state. For all of New England’s success in vaccinating its population, there are states like Mississippi (one dose: 36.3%), Louisiana (38.7%) and Idaho (39.8%). Even in Canada, with its generally high uptake, a granular analysis of Toronto (75%+ first dose overall) shows the rate varies from 56%-83% (at time of writing) when you break down vaccination by neighborhood. The variation is even greater when looking at county-by-county vaccination rates in the USA, where even some “successful” states have regions with low uptake.
So what is driving the variation? The correlation with voting patterns, in the USA, is one factor that has been widely cited. But hesitancy and resistance is not new to vaccination, or even vaccination during a public health crisis. Smallpox spread through the city of Montreal in 1885, killing almost 2% of the population. This was 90 years after Edward Jenner had published his work on smallpox vaccination. While Montreal’s wealthier English-speaking population had embraced the vaccine and were largely untouched by this epidemic, the disease found 90% of its victims in the poorer French-speaking population. When the Board of Health eventually mandated smallpox vaccination, people rioted, attacking the police station and police. The Board of Health attributed the riots to lies told by vaccine opponents. And while smallpox was eventually eradicated from the earth, the same cannot be said for antivaccination sentiment.
Steven Novella has written several posts about vaccine hesitancy in the era of the COVID-19 pandemic. With the Delta variant expected to cause the most cases of COVID-19, and signs that it is already fueling another wave in regions with poor uptake, the summer and fall are shaping up to be a race between vaccination and Delta.
In one of Steve’s prior posts he discussed a survey which stratified the population into three groups:
    • Enthusiasts – those who are already vaccinated or plan to get vaccinated
    • Vaccine Hesitant – unsure, but persuadable, which were further sub-divided:
        ◦ watchful – waiting for now
        ◦ cost-anxious – those with resource barriers like time or money
        ◦ system distrusters – those that distrust the medical “establishment”, but not necessarily vaccines
    • Anti-Vaxxers – those that believe one or more conspiracy theories about vaccines or COVID-19. This group is likely to be largely unreachable and have reasoned themselves into a position where they will not accept the vaccine.
With vaccination rates in the USA dropping week over week since their April peak, which are similar to what we’re starting to see in Canada (albeit with a higher overall uptake), the focus now needs to change, acknowledging that there will remain a hard-core group of anti-vaxxers that will continue to refuse the vaccine. No amount of persuasion is expected to have an effect on this group.
The vaccine hesitant group is where efforts need to be focused – identifying them, understanding the barriers, and addressing them. Some strategies employed have included lotteries like those trialed in Ohio, which offered randomly selected individuals that had received a vaccine up to $1 million. While this tactic might be expected to be persuasive to some of the vaccine hesitant, an analysis of vaccine uptake suggests that this strategy was ineffective.
If we want to shrink that proportion of the population that is unvaccinated, then tactics will need to focus on these people who are hesitant, but convincible. And that means that delivery probably needs to shift from large vaccination centres, designed for high volumes of willing recipients, to targeted approaches that, if necessary, bring the vaccine to the recipient.
Addressing barriers seems like an obvious solution, but those barriers may vary and be hard to pinpoint. Time to access the vaccine is critical. Some people may be willing, but may not have found the time to get vaccinated or are worried about possibly needing to take time off because of side effects. A recent US survey noted that when employers offered employees paid time off to get vaccinated or recover from side effects, that uptake was higher.
Another barrier that can be very real is trypanophobia – fear of needles. Up to 10% of adults have a fear of needles, and that fear may be driving vaccination hesitancy. In response, some vaccination clinics offer different forms of accommodation which can include privacy and even an area to lie down after the vaccine has been administered.
Other barriers may include language, technology or trust. Here is where primary care physicians and health professionals like pharmacists have the advantage of a trusted relationship that can be leveraged. Confirming the availability of the vaccine, starting conversations with patients, and offering to share knowledge have the potential to be highly influential. I know that the independent pharmacist in my neighborhood is highly respected by his customers. He is proactively reaching out to his clients, confirming their vaccination status when they have their prescriptions refilled, and offering to work around their schedule to get them vaccinated. The same approach can be used by family doctors who can reach out to their patients and also confirm vaccination status with any appointment. The advantage of this approach is the opportunity for the professional to provide tailored advice relevant to that patient’s circumstances and health concerns.
Targeted discussions don’t have to just come from health professionals. Tara Smith recently outlined some tactics that can be used in your personal relationships with those that express hesitation:
    • Lead from a place of emotional connection – ensure they know you have their best interests at heart.
    • Put empathy front and center – Listen. Don’t judge or argue – no matter how difficult it may be. Gather information.
    • Use the “Four R’s” – Receive, Repeat, Respond, Refer.
    • Avoid easy-to-make mistakes – Condescension or impatience will derail the dialogue.
    • This is a marathon, not a sprint – a single conversation is unlikely to work. Success means a follow-up discussion.
If you want to try out your skills before your next awkward conversation with your vaccine-hesitant friend or family member, practice with the New York Times Chatbot.
Finally, some tactics may seem more like sticks than carrots, but they may also help prod the highly resistant into getting vaccinated. The extent to which employers and schools will require vaccination is only beginning to be be explored, now that vaccines have become more widely available. Not every employer will go as far as Houston Methodist’s approach, but workplaces are expected to grapple with this, especially for those returning to the traditional office. The same can be said for anyone that wants to travel – vaccine passports are coming and showing proof of vaccination when crossing an international border could be even more common than it already is.
Vaccines don’t work if they’re not administered. And while COVID-19 vaccines clearly provide personal protection to the recipient, we will all be safer if we can achieve robust vaccine uptake and reduce community spread of the disease. Closing the vaccine gap with the vaccine-hesitant is the challenge that is going to make or break the overall success of the COVID-19 vaccine campaign.

Chipping Away at Vaccine Hesitancy
How to persuade the remaining unvaccinated.
Steven Novella on September 22, 2021
Link

As the COVID pandemic continues to evolve it seems we are entering a phase that many are calling a “pandemic of the unvaccinated”. Recent data, for example, shows that people who are unvaccinated are:
7 times more likely to test positive for COVID-19 than vaccinated people49 times more likely to be hospitalized than vaccinated people32 times more likely to die from COVID-19 than vaccinated people.
These numbers vary by region, but are fairly representative. The Delta variant is partly responsible for the recent surge, but the COVID vaccines collectively continue to be about 80% effective against infection. We are now debating and studying who should get a booster when, in order to maximize vaccine effectiveness. About 55% of the US population is fully vaccinated, with 64% getting at least one dose. We probably need to hit 80% or more to have effective herd immunity. How do we get there?
The phenomenon of vaccine hesitancy is complicated. One factor that consistently emerges as a major cause is distrust of the government. These are now entrenched views, often tied to political and ideological identity. Generally speaking, information cannot counter distrust, because the information itself will not be trusted.
Fear of side effects is another major cause of hesitancy, but it may be difficult to disentangle this issue from lack of trust. In cases where trust is not the real underlying issue, fear of side effects can be effectively countered with information alone. People generally fear an immediate, tangible, and active harm (such as from getting a vaccine) more than a remote theoretical and passive harm (such as failing to prevent contraction of COVID). Rationally, we should just run the numbers and do a risk vs benefit analysis, but humans are only semi-rational. But information, especially from a trusted source like one’s personal doctor, can be effective in these cases.
Recent research focuses on a perhaps-neglected portion of those who are not vaccinated – people who generally believe that the vaccines are safe and effective but have still not been vaccinated. There are many potential reasons for this disconnect – people may simply be busy or too distracted, tend to procrastinate, or have practical barriers to getting vaccinated. This group may be the low-hanging fruit among the unvaccinated, and likely a better use of resources than trying to convince entrenched anti-vaxxers or partisan refusers.
The researchers leveraged the phenomenon of cognitive dissonance to see if they could impact the behavior of subjects in this group. They had the intervention group advocate for best practices in the pandemic, including getting vaccinated, wearing a mask, and social distancing. They then had them recall recent behavior where they failed to follow these best practices. The disconnect was meant to provoke a psychologically uncomfortable feeling that psychologists call cognitive dissonance. They then followed up a week later, along with subjects from three different control groups without dissonance. They report:
We found that dissonance participants complied more with guidelines and were more likely to seek vaccination than participants in three non-dissonance control conditions.
Implementing these findings may be challenging. The authors suggest, for example, using contests where participants would have to craft a pro-vaccine ad campaign, with prizes awarded for the winners. Perhaps ad companies can be engaged – they have a long history of leveraging psychological factors to change customer behavior (including exploiting cognitive dissonance).
The most important finding is perhaps the bigger picture that efforts to increase COVID vaccine uptake should focus on the persuadable and those who don’t need actual persuading, just a push in the right direction. Trying to convince the hard-core antivaxxers at this point is likely to have extremely low returns.
It also remains to be seen what the ceiling is on increasing vaccine uptake through persuasive methods alone, which leads into the debate over vaccine mandates. There are increasing calls for such mandates, and the debate seems to be shifting toward the details of how best to implement mandates, rather than if there should be any. Of course, no one is talking about or seriously considering forced vaccinations (which has never been a policy in the US), but there is a long history of vaccine mandates in many situations – to attend school, to travel, and for certain professions such as health care workers.
The idea is that being unvaccinated, while continuing to be an allowed personal choice, should be made as inconvenient as possible. Companies have the right to protect their workers by requiring vaccination (always, of course, with an exception for actual medical reasons). Professions have a duty to protect others by requiring their members to be vaccinated. Being in necessarily crowded close quarters (such as on a plane) is also a privilege that can come with proof of vaccination.
These are common sense public health policies. Protests based on the principle of personal freedom are not valid, because these are decisions that affect the personal freedom of others. No one has a right to speed on the highway, because it puts other drivers at risk. Smoking has largely been banned in public places because of its health effects on others.
        ◦ The bottom line is that there is a valid and consistent principle here that collectively society has the right to limit personal behavior in public spaces that affects public safety. No one has the right to put other people into harm’s way. People are also economically harmed by the ongoing damage the pandemic is doing to the economy, damage that is extended and increased by the unvaccinated. There is more than enough legal, historical, ethical, and logical justification for vaccine mandates, and no serious argument against them. They may also be necessary in order to achieve herd immunity.

Once again, The BMJ, wittingly or unwittingly, reinforces an antivax narrative
Last week The BMJ published an investigation alleging that the algorithm for spotting safety signals after COVID vaccination was flawed and that the FDA ignored it, amplifying an old antivax narrative. Again. WTF, BMJ?
David Gorski on September 21, 2026
Link

Et tu, BMJ? Again? Seriously?
It’s been nearly three years since I last asked: What the heck happened to The BMJ? As my frustration with this medical journal led me to sit down to write this post, I did think about entitling it the same thing but thought better of it, given that I’ve already used that title twice. Better to call what The BMJ just published last week what it is: Sensationalism custom-made for use (or, no doubt as the journalist would characterize it, misuse) by antivaxxers to spin a deceptive yarn in which, during the early months after the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines in the US began in December 2020, the CDC and FDA supposedly engaged in what is portrayed, in essence, as a cover-up or suppression of reports of adverse reactions due to COVID-19 vaccines—or just gross negligence. This narrative comes in the form of an article by David Willman entitled, US officials knew COVID vaccine safety system was flawed—but turned aside the FDA doctor who alerted them. It gets even better, because the tagline claims that “US officials embraced an algorithm for detecting signals of harm from mRNA COVID-19 vaccines that they knew was broken and suppressed efforts to fix it.”
Sounds pretty damning, doesn’t it? A close reading of the article, however, makes culpability much less clear and involves convoluted arguments over two different statistical models used for detecting an increase in specific adverse events after vaccination in a passive reporting system. Personally, too, I was rather puzzled by the seeming amazement that the vast majority of reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database in 2021 were about mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, for example:
I bet those of you who have been paying attention to the antivaccine narratives surrounding the rollout of the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines can even guess before reading the article which specific adverse event this article is primarily about. Yes, it’s (mostly) about myocarditis in young people, predominantly young men, associated with COVID-19 vaccination and how, supposedly, the US utterly failed in pharmacovigilance because it didn’t identify the safety signals as soon as some other countries (e.g., Israel) did. There’s actually an interesting story here if one wasn’t wedded to what comes across as an intentional cover-up, which is the narrative that antivaxxers are running with based on this story.
As a number of people have pointed out, the observation that the vast majority of reports to VAERS in 2021 were regarding COVID-19 vaccines should be no surprise. Before COVID-19 vaccines, few people knew of VAERS, which is a passive reporting system to which anyone can report any problem that occurs after any vaccination. In brief, VAERS is intended to function as an early warning system, a canary in the coal mine, so to speak, that can generate hypotheses regarding specific adverse events that occur after vaccination with specific vaccines. These hypotheses then need to be tested using more rigorous systems, as VAERS is prone to a lot of false positives and is easily misused by antivax “researchers.” We’ve discussed VAERS many times before and how misusing VAERS has long been a favorite strategy of antivaxxers to attribute all manner of maladies to vaccination. I’ve discussed the shortcomings of VAERS many, many times, both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, going back 20 years; so I’ll just refer you to a post I did as 2021 came to a close when I described how the misuse of VAERS by antivaxxers was continuing apace, and how an old antivax technique was turbocharged and weaponized within two months of the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines.
Beginning with the rollout of the COVID vaccines in December 2020, for the first time ever the CDC and FDA really publicized VAERS and used its bully pulpit to encourage the public to report adverse events. Of course, reporting of adverse events after COVID-19 vaccines skyrocketed, far surpassing any other reports, in particular given that millions and millions of doses were being administered as fast as the vaccines could be produced. They even created the V-Safe system, which periodically texted vaccinees for months after they were vaccinated to ask them if they were having any symptoms or problems. As Jeffrey Morris pointed out, “extraordinary public, medical and media scrutiny” produced “substantial stimulated reporting to VAERS” and healthcare professionals “had specific reporting requirements for adverse events following COVID vaccination.” He further observed that “the raw fact that COVID vaccines generated vastly more VAERS reports than previous vaccines does not by itself indicate that they caused vastly more adverse events,” the important thing being “whether particular events occurred disproportionately relative to vaccination exposure and appropriate comparators.” This massive increase in reporting in 2021 is an important factor in evaluating the two statistical methods Willman discusses in his article.
Speaking of the journalist, David Willman, under whose byline this story appears, is actually a legitimate investigative journalist. Just look at his Wikipedia entry if you don’t believe me. I can guess why he might have found a story about the alleged failure of the CDC to do appropriate analyses looking for safety signals for myocarditis attractive. Specifically, he won a Pulitzer Prize in Investigative Reporting in 2001 for his LA Times series reporting on seven FDA-approved drugs later withdrawn over safety issues and deaths. (Ironically, one of his articles notes that the too-fast approval of these drugs came about as a result of policies implemented to speed the approval of drugs and treatments for HIV/AIDS.)
However, as I read his BMJ article, I couldn’t help but notice my skeptical antennae starting to twitch fiercely. I was sensing the presence of another, unnamed player in this story. It turns out that my skeptical antennae didn’t let me down (at least not this time), because, right at the end of the article, in the Competing Interests section I read:
This account is adapted from an upcoming book about covid-19 and the vaccines, written by David Willman and Peter Doshi. Doshi is senior editor, The BMJ Investigations Unit.
Bingo! Why, I wondered, wasn’t Peter Doshi a co-author of this investigation? More importantly, for those of you not familiar with Peter Doshi and why he is important to The BMJ’s heel turn on vaccines over the last decade, let me step back and briefly discuss it. If you’re familiar with Doshi’s antivax antics, his role at The BMJ as a senior editor, and the antivax narratives he’s pushed, using the imprimatur of a respected medical journal to lend them credibility, you can safely skip the next section and move on to my discussion of Willman’s article itself. However, you might be interested in revisiting this story, because it’s a doozy that makes me wonder how a legitimate journalist like Willman not only collaborated with Doshi, but co-authored a whole book with him on COVID-19 vaccines! Given Doshi’s track record, I fear that I know exactly what this book will say, aside from this new “revelation,” which basically just seems to be a chapter from the upcoming book modified to fit in The BMJ’s format.
Peter Doshi: What happened to The BMJ
Whenever I lament what has happened to The BMJ, I always feel obligated to point out that The BMJ used to be almost unambiguously a good guy when it came to vaccines. After all, it was The BMJ that published investigative journalist Brian Deer’s articles recounting the strong evidence indicating that Wakefield’s case series published in The Lancet that linked the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to autism was based on fraud. That study launched the modern iteration of the antivaccine movement and is, as I like to say, the study that launched a thousand quackeries directed at autistic children to “cure” them of their “vaccine-induced autism.” The headline of Deer’s accompanying commentary after his account of how the “case against the MMR was fixed” even referred to Wakefield’s study as “Piltdown medicine“, after the infamous Piltdown Man fraud. No one played a bigger role in finally exposing Wakefield for the fraud that he was (and still is) than Brian Deer and The BMJ.
Fast forward to 2010, when our very own Mark Crislip noticed that Peter Doshi and Tom Jefferson published a dubious article (that he deconstructed as only he can) casting doubt on whether Tamiflu works. Interestingly, a few years later, in 2014, Peter Doshi became an associate editor at The BMJ when he was an assistant professor in the Department of Pharmaceutical Health Services Research (PHSR) at the University of Maryland School of Pharmacy. I’ve been unable to pin down exactly when Doshi was promoted to senior editor, but it was no later than 2021, which is when I first started noticing articles under his byline showing up that promoted antivax narratives.
As for me, I first noticed Doshi in 2009, when I noted that, as the H1N1 pandemic of 2009-2010 was bearing down on us, he had been scheduled to speak at an anti-vaccine conference hosted by the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC). Indeed, he had even been contacted about the nature of the conference and replied with the lamest of lame gambits, namely saying, “my speaking there does not imply endorsement.” After that, he was nothing if not consistent. While all the while continuing to claim that he’s “not antivaccine, he parroted more than a few antivaccine talking points himself while trying to portray himself as an authority on influenza and the flu vaccine. Through it all, when challenged, he’s played the “victim” card that people who are borderline antivaccine or antivaccine love to play, claiming that they are “just asking questions” and that anyone who “questions” vaccines is labeled, in a knee-jerk—and most unfair—fashion, “antivaccine.” In fact, Doshi’s borderline antivaccine stylings go back further than 2009, when a senior pseudonymous epidemiologist whose blog I used to read religiously back then chastised him for an “unhelpful” commentary in which Doshi had claimed that estimates for yearly influenza deaths were “grossly inflated.” The year was 2006.
It was during COVID-19, though, that Doshi let his antivax freak flag fly high. In February 2021, less than two months after the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine had started being distributed first to healthcare workers and those in high risk occupations, he published an article on The BMJ’s blog entitled, Pfizer and Moderna’s “95% effective” vaccines—we need more details and the raw data. In it, he pulled some statistical prestidigitation so transparent that even I could spot it, all to cast doubt on the validity of the randomized clinical trial showing the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines to be highly effective, while using his bogus “analysis” to suggest that the real efficacy of the vaccines was far lower. The utter deceptiveness of his analysis led me to wonder why The BMJ was still employing him, and Skeptical Raptor to note dryly that “BMJ is not a hotbed of anti-vaccine pseudoscience, except for the presence of Peter Doshi.” Indeed, Doshi is not a vaccinologist or infectious disease expert, nor is he an expert in clinical trials, something very apparent to anyone who is an expert who read his post and its misuse and misrepresentation of protocol violations. In fact, Doshi received his BA in anthropology from Brown University, an MA in East Asian studies from Harvard University, and a Ph.D. in history, anthropology, and science, technology, and society from MIT. Yet, somehow, he is senior editor at The BMJ.
In his original article, based on specious reasoning, Doshi estimated that the true efficacy of the vaccines was not over 90%, but was rather only 19%. I later pointed out how Doshi’s original “reanalysis” of the clinical trial data had given birth to what I call a “slasher myth” about COVID-19 vaccines, a term I coined for medical misinformation that, no matter how many times it appears to have been killed, always reappears, just as slashers who appear to die at the end of one movie are always shown to have survived somehow so that they can kill again in the sequel.
Let’s just reiterate that The BMJ hired Doshi despite his long history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement since at least 2009, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines, as well as having signed a petition in 2006 “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS. It continues to employ him even after he’s fallen for a conspiracy theory that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database was being made inaccessible to suppress reports. That’s not all, though; he’s also served as an expert witness for the plaintiffs in antivaccine leader Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s lawsuit against the University of California’s influenza vaccine mandates.
Finally, seeing that Doshi’s role above is listed as “senior editor BMJ Investigations,” another gross abuse of science and journalism published by The BMJ makes a lot more sense to me now. I’m referring, of course, to the November 2021 “exposé” of Ventavia, one of the companies contracted by Pfizer to run its clinical trial of its COVID-19 vaccine, alleging shoddy working conditions and unblinding of clinical trial subjects. (Hard to believe that that was nearly five years ago!) As I discussed in depth at the time, it was all either exaggerated or outright nonsense, wrapped in a big bright conspiracy theory bow, the sort of reporting far more suited for Alex Jones’ Infowars than for a legitimate news outlet or medical journal. None of this is a surprise coming from Paul Thacker, who is a conspiracy theorist and hack. Assuming Doshi was in charge of BMJ Investigations back then, it makes a whole heck of a lot of sense that The BMJ let someone like Thacker appear in its pages.
The charges
With that background and the (barely acknowledged and likely ghost) co-author Peter Doshi being involved in writing this article by David Willman, let’s take a look at what is actually charged. The depressing thing, as I mentioned above, is that there is a story here. The problem is that it is spun to make the motives of the officials at the CDC and FDA involved look as nefarious and negligent as possible, even though there is no evidence that that was the case.
to its choice of algorithm to use to monitor data from the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database. Worse, if you believe the narrative, the FDA officials refused to alter the algorithm. More specifically, the article seeks to damn the CDC for not using two algorithms to data-mine VAERS. Like most compelling exposé narratives, the story features a whistleblower who repeatedly brought up concerns but was either ignored or muzzled. Noting that at the time of the rollout of COVID-19 vaccine distribution in December 2020, the CDC had announced that it was going to be on the lookout for any harmful reactions attributable to the vaccine, Willman lays the groundwork:
Millions of people were to be vaccinated each week, and the CDC would rely on statistical “data mining” of the VAERS database to quickly identify any safety signals in need of further probing.
Two well recognised, separate algorithms were to be used. The first involved calculating “proportional reporting ratios” (PRRs), which sought to identify types of reactions reported to VAERS disproportionately or more frequently than background rates. The second data mining technique, called “empirical bayesian,” was to be provided by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which operated VAERS jointly with the CDC, and the two agencies planned to share and discuss results.1
I can’t help but note that I wanted to read the link referenced as #1, and I clicked on the link. It was a dead link. To me, that indicates some sloppiness here. So I consulted the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org, and was informed that the Internet Archive services were temporarily offline. Oh, well. It’s late Sunday night, and so I’ll check back tomorrow. In any case, this strategy seemed at least not unreasonable, and I noted that the two methods had their strengths and weaknesses, which I’ll get into more later. Suffice to say for now that both methods address the same question of disproportionality, specifically: Is a particular adverse event reported disproportionately more often for the vaccine under study relative to other vaccines, which are used as a reference? I’ll get into that more shortly.
First, what happened next? According to Willman:
But in a little noticed September 2022 letter, CDC director Rochelle Walensky said that the agency did not perform PRR analyses for signals until 2022. This was more than a year into the vaccine rollout and was intended, she wrote, “to corroborate” the FDA’s approach. Instead of using the PRR and empirical bayesian methods jointly during the pandemic, Walensky explained that both the CDC and FDA instead “chose to rely” on empirical bayesian, which she characterised as “a more robust technique.”
The BMJ, however, has found that the FDA’s algorithm was mathematically compromised by the deluge of covid vaccine adverse event reports—resulting in a near total loss of signal detection sensitivity for the new mRNA vaccines made by Pfizer and Moderna. Top FDA officials were warned internally of this problem in early 2021, and the official who headed its pharmacovigilance division for vaccines commented more than two years later to his CDC and FDA colleagues: “We were aware of this [data mining] limitation before and during the pandemic.” Government documents also show that CDC officials were informed during rollout of the vaccines—on multiple occasions.
Yet instead of fixing the safety deficiency—or shutting down the unreliable signal detection system—officials continued to rely on the FDA’s broken algorithm. The officials also cited the absence of signals when assuring clinicians and the public of the vaccines’ safety.
This sounds pretty damning too, doesn’t it? It gets even worse (or is made to sound even worse):
Yet instead of fixing the safety deficiency—or shutting down the unreliable signal detection system—officials continued to rely on the FDA’s broken algorithm. The officials also cited the absence of signals when assuring clinicians and the public of the vaccines’ safety.
At the FDA, managers went a step further by silencing the career drug safety officer who had repeatedly brought the deficiency to their attention and had offered an updated algorithm intended to fix it. As a result, Americans received unfounded assurances of the safety of the most widely used covid vaccines and were denied prompt warnings of potential harms, The BMJ’s investigation found.
There we have it, the necessary element of any good story like this, the “whistleblower” whose concerns were downplayed, ignored, or blown off and, even better, who suffered career consequences for telling The Truth. In this case, the whistleblower was a career FDA official:
The concern had made its way to Marks, FDA’s top official overseeing the covid vaccines, in early 2021. And it came from a career medical officer in the FDA’s centre for drugs, not vaccines: Ana Szarfman, a doctor with a PhD in microbiology and immunology. She worked for decades on drug safety data mining at the FDA and had a lead role in modernising the agency’s approach.67
Szarfman had built a years long professional association with an accomplished statistician, William DuMouchel, who devised the particular bayesian data mining algorithm that the FDA began using more than 15 years before the pandemic.6
So what was Szarfman’s concern? Here’s where the flood of reports deluging VAERS during 2021 comes in:
The BMJ can reveal that the FDA’s algorithm failed to signal a potential relationship between mRNA covid vaccination and myocarditis, pericarditis, Bell’s palsy, tinnitus, and other reported disorders owing to a flaw in the detection methodology—a flaw that senior officials declined to rectify.
The problem arose because, in the first year of the rollout, almost all the reports coming into VAERS—more than 90% of 1.1 million—were for the mRNA covid shots, dwarfing vaccines for all other diseases.4 This meant that analysing the safety of one vaccine, for example Pfizer’s product, involved comparing it to other vaccines, which were overwhelmingly limited to Moderna’s product. But if both mRNA vaccines elevated the risk of an adverse event like myocarditis in roughly equal amounts, the “observed” frequency and “expected” frequency would be similar, resulting in no automated alert.5 The statistical phenomenon is known as “masking.”
Here’s where I first started thinking: This isn’t a problem with the statistical method chosen. This sounds like a problem with the control group chosen. Why on earth would one include any of the COVID-19 vaccines in the control group of reports of adverse events in VAERS? Notice the framing here, namely that the PRR was an “unreliable” method compared to the Bayesian system, which is utter hogwash. Even I could tell that, but I had to rely on someone who knows a lot more about what he’s talking about when it comes to statistics than I do, namely Jeffrey Morris, who posted this analysis on Twitter.
First, I think it’s useful to quote Dr. Morris on the relative strengths/weaknesses of the two methods, PRR vs. Bayesian:
The empirical-Bayes method is not some fundamentally different or defective type of analysis. It builds on the same observed-versus-expected reporting framework, but uses shrinkage to stabilize estimates, particularly when counts are small, and provides a posterior distribution for the underlying reporting ratio that can be examined statistically. That shrinkage is generally a statistical advantage. My white paper discusses this relationship in detail.
An important difference is how a potential signal is flagged. The commonly used screened PRR rule is essentially an ad hoc threshold: PRR > 2, ChiSq>4, with at least 3 reports. In contrast, FDA used the more stringent empirical-Bayes criterion EB05 > 2: the lower 5th percentile of the posterior reporting-ratio distribution must exceed 2, which is equivalent to requiring greater than 95% posterior probability that the underlying reporting ratio exceeds twofold. Not surprisingly, those criteria have different operating characteristics. EB05 > 2 is substantially more conservative: it should produce fewer false-positive alerts, particularly for sparse data, but at the cost of lower sensitivity and potentially more false negatives.
Here’s a link to the white paper, if you want to go into the nitty-gritty of the details. To boil it down, the PRR method has a higher sensitivity with a lower specificity, meaning that it will detect more events above what is expected, but at the expense of specificity, meaning that a lot of those events will turn out not to have been due to the vaccines. The empirical Bayesian method, on the other hand, is more stringent. It will detect fewer events, but the events detected will be more likely to be “true” adverse reactions actually caused by the vaccine, which is why Dr. Morris emphasizes:
The much larger number of events flagged by the classical PRR rule therefore does not by itself demonstrate that PRR was the better method or that FDA’s Bayesian methodology was defective. To establish that, one would want to compare the sensitivity, specificity, false-positive rate, and false-negative rate of the competing rules under realistic reporting conditions. The article emphasizes the greater number of PRR alerts but does not provide that type of operating-characteristic analysis. FDA itself describes data-mining signals as hypotheses for investigation, not causal findings.
According to Willman’s report, in a meeting held on February 29, 2020, Szarfman included a presentation comparing her proposed algorithm based on using PRR to the algorithm based on empiric Bayesian methods being used, and, unsurprisingly, a lot more safety signals were flagged, as shown in this figure included in the Willman article:
Fig 1: FDA medical officer Ana Szarfman’s presentation on 29 February 2021 included a comparison of signal detection using the PRR (left) and empirical Bayesian (right) algorithms.
The heat map looks pretty convincing, doesn’t it? But what does it really mean? Any method that is more sensitive will produce more “hits” than a less sensitive method. Every algorithm of this sort has to balance sensitivity and specificity. Too much sensitivity, and there will be so many signals, many of which won’t pan out, that investigating them all will become impractical. Too much specificity, and, even though the signals that are found will have a much higher proportion of true positives, a lot of potentially important signals will be missed. How much sensitivity and specificity are needed relative to one another is a legitimate scientific question about which there can be legitimate scientific disagreement, but that’s not how this argument is portrayed here. The spin here is that Szarfman was good and right, and that Peter Marks and the FDA were wrong and negligent, if not outright villains for dismissing the brave whistleblower. I do note here that she appears to have been given a respectful hearing, being invited to present her findings to Peter Marks, who was then the director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER), the FDA center responsible for approving vaccines.
Moreover, as Dr. Vincent Iannelli points out, Szarfman found a bunch of signals for adverse events that COVID-19 vaccines don’t cause, in particular sudden death. According to Willman:
But by July 2021, Szarfman again sounded an alarm over a “strong signal” for “death and sudden death” that she said DuMouchel had identified using the updated algorithm. She shared the findings with a colleague, Richard Forshee, a deputy director for biostatistics and pharmacovigilance, who worked under Peter Marks. Forshee expressed his doubts about the analysis to Szarfman and wrote to Marks: “Ana Szarfman called me . . . She said that she and Bill DuMouchel had found an increased risk of mortality following covid-19 vaccination using data mining methods.
“I am very concerned that whatever association they think they have identified is spurious based on the way the covid-19 vaccination program prioritized individuals and the required and stimulated reporting we are seeing with the covid-19 vaccines. . . . Please let me know how you would like us to proceed.”
Eventually, Szarfman’s activities got the attention of Peter Marks again, leading him to write to the Director of the Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER):
On 15 September 2021, Marks wrote to his counterpart in the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER): “One of the CDER statisticians, Ana Szarfman, has decided on her own to do vaccine analyses using VAERS as part of her work at FDA. She is, however, not doing this in collaboration with our [vaccine centre] statisticians, and quite to the contrary, has been asked to cease and desist, because the strategy that she is using could create erroneous conflicts that feed in to anti-vaccination rhetoric. This is creating an issue . . . This issue came up previously during the pandemic and . . . it seemed to go away, but it is now back. Can we catch up about this sometime?”
Basically, it sounds as though Marks had finally become fed up, whether rightly or wrongly.
Now here’s the thing. As Dr. Morris points out (and so do I), it isn’t the empirical Bayesian algorithm that was the problem. It was the selection of the control group to include those vaccinated with one of the COVID-19 vaccines, which was not an inherent part of an empirical Bayesian analysis. The problem of masking was far more of an issue than the choice of specific algorithm. As Dr. Morris explains:
Second, there was a separate and legitimate problem with the particular reference distribution FDA used in its empirical-Bayes implementation. This is where the masking issue enters. FDA’s brand-specific analyses estimated expected reporting frequencies from the broader VAERS database. Because Pfizer and Moderna together accounted for an enormous fraction of COVID-era reports, an adverse event elevated similarly for both vaccines could raise the expected frequency against which each individual vaccine was compared. That can attenuate or eliminate a disproportionality signal. The published masking analysis demonstrates that this phenomenon can occur, and the newly released internal records indicate that FDA officials were aware of the issue.
But that is a problem with the construction of the comparison group, not evidence that empirical Bayes itself is an invalid method. Indeed, a conventional PRR calculated with the same poorly chosen reference set can suffer the same masking problem; the methodological literature demonstrates masking for both PRR and standard empirical-Bayes disproportionality methods.
And, left out of Willman’s report:
And importantly, CDC’s eventual PRR analysis did not use that same comparison. For its principal PRR analysis in 2022, CDC pooled Pfizer and Moderna together as the mRNA COVID-vaccine exposure and compared their adverse-event reporting proportions with those for non-COVID vaccines, using reports extending back to 2009. Thus Pfizer and Moderna could not mask one another in that pooled analysis. The dramatic difference between the number of FDA EB alerts and CDC PRR alerts therefore cannot cleanly be interpreted as “Bayesian method bad, PRR good”: both the flagging criterion and the reference population changed.
And, most importantly, Willman doesn’t mention at all that one of the biggest problems with using VAERS during a pandemic situation in which, for the first time ever, the public is being strongly encouraged to report adverse events to VAERS. These are two different situations: VAERS during “regular times,” in which relatively few people even know of the database and vaccination occurs at a reasonably constant rate from year to year, compared to VAERS during a pandemic and the rollout of a vaccine against the pandemic-causing organism, SARS-CoV-2, in which the public is being urged to report any suspected adverse event after vaccination to VAERS and there is even a new system, V-Safe, set up to remind people to report by sending text messages to people at specified time intervals ofter they receive a COVID-19 vaccine to ask them if they are experiencing any symptoms that might be attributable to the vaccine.
As Dr. Morris notes, VAERS is “susceptible to stimulated reporting, media attention, reporting requirements, and differences in the populations receiving different vaccines.” Indeed, I first wrote about this phenomenon over two decades ago, when a study was published that showed how vaccine litigation had affected reporting to VAERS. In brief, lawyers representing families suing pharmaceutical companies for their children’s autism based on the belief that vaccines had caused it. These attorneys encouraged parents to report their child’s autism to VAERS as an adverse event, thus creating “evidence” that vaccines cause autism to be used in legal actions against vaccine manufacturers and in Vaccine Court. None of this is new. The FDA and CDC knew that stimulated reporting could be a problem.
Moreover, it is likely not because of the choice of algorithm to data-mine VAERS that Israel recognized the safety signal for myocarditis associated with COVID-19 vaccination. As Dr. Iannelli points out, there was a big difference in how Israel and the US approached their COVID-19 vaccination efforts. First, myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination is an adverse event seen more often in the young, particularly young men. Second, it’s most often seen after the second dose of the vaccine. Dr. Iannelli notes that in the early months of the rollout, in the US it was high-risk people (e.g., the elderly and those with chronic diseases, as well as those in high-risk jobs, like healthcare) who were prioritized to be vaccinated, while in Israel vaccinated all of its citizens, with no restriction on age. He further notes that it wasn’t until March and April 2021 that older teens and young adults were receiving the vaccines, concluding:
And since myocarditis was mainly found after they got their second dose, it shouldn’t be a surprise that we didn’t see a safety signal until May.
A safety signal that was detected.
A safety signal that we were all told about.
Indeed.
Putting it all in context in a way The BMJ did not
I don’t mean to say that Willman’s report is entirely misguided. Clearly, he has documented problems at the FDA and the CDC in terms of vaccine safety monitoring. It’s just that, from my reading and consideration of Dr. Morris’ points, the main problem with the algorithm used to screen VAERS for adverse events related to COVID-19 vaccines was almost certainly not the problem that Willman emphasized: the choice of an empirical Bayesian algorithm versus calculating PRR. It was the control group initially chosen while doing the Bayesian analysis, and that is a valid point. Unfortunately, Willman flubs it completely by framing the problem almost entirely as a battle between PRR and empiric Bayesian methods, with the ‘correct” method being obvious (in retrospect), rather than as an issue with choice of control group during a massive vaccine rollout and a publicity campaign designed to promote stimulated reporting. Yes, Willman does mention the stimulated reporting, but mainly in passing and in a quoted email to Peter Marks from Richard Forshee.
Another frustrating thing about this article is that it does not really acknowledge the function of VAERS, falling seemingly inadvertently into line with the antivax view of VAERS as the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring, when in fact VAERS is an early warning system whose signals cannot be taken at face value and must be investigated using more rigorous methodology. Just as frustrating is its failure even to acknowledge that any algorithm chosen to analyze VAERS reports would involve deciding upon how much of a trade-off between sensitivity and specificity would be ideal, a decision about which reasonable scientists can have reasonable scientific and public health policy disagreements, as there are pros and cons to every approach.
Finally, Willman is not wrong to report that the CDC and FDA were in a bit of the “circle the wagons” mode in response to misuse of their data by the antivaccine movement (some examples of which we here on SBM wrote about at the time). Many of us engaged in science communication at the time were frustrated by the communications from the CDC and the FDA, although I can understand and sympathize with Marks’ apparent fear that Szarfman’s report would be weaponized by the antivaccine movement, a concern that Willman doesn’t seem to take seriously. The sad thing is, Willman’s reporting could have been valuable if it hadn’t been spun as a battle of a single brave whistleblower and dogmatic—even negligent—FDA officials, rather than as a difficult choice of methodology by the FDA and CDC to screen for adverse events.
The article concludes:
But while reflecting on the events, DuMouchel said that he could not explain the government officials’ resistance. “It’s really hard to know what they really had in their mind,” he said. “Or whether to believe or to accept their excuses for not wanting to switch to a new method . . . I think that they were wrong.”
Approached by The BMJ, Szarfman insisted that she had not sought to undermine public support for the covid vaccines. She recalled her efforts with what seemed to be resigned frustration. “Very few people understand the statistics,” she said. “That’s the problem.”
Over lunch near his residence in Miami, Florida, DuMouchel voiced regret that FDA officials had rebuffed Szarfman’s attempts to overhaul the deficient approach with VAERS. “If they had paid attention to Ana, they would have done better.”
Maybe. Maybe not. An equally plausible case could be made that if they had “listened to Ana,” there would have been so many false positive signals that the CDC and FDA could not have dealt with them and that it would have undermined confidence in vaccines, Szarfman’s and DuMouchel’s insistence that such was not their goal notwithstanding. Unfortunately, as valuable as it might have been to learn about this controversy at the FDA and CDC during the early months of the rollout of the vaccines, right now, given the way Willman is reporting it and with the knowledge that this article is most likely just a lightly edited version of a chapter in his book with Peter Doshi, I have to wonder what the larger aim is. Given The BMJ’s recent history with articles by Peter Doshi and Paul Thacker, I wonder if its editors even care anymore that they are willingly lending the prestige of their journal to antivax narratives, like the one claiming that the CDC and FDA “covered up” vaccine safety signals in order to keep the vaccines flowing.
    • 

The Anti-Vaccine Movement Supports Big Pharma
It’s common knowledge that anti-vaxxers are dedicated to filling the coffers of Big Coffin. Simple math leads to another obvious conclusion: they also work extremely hard to enrich hospitals and Big Pharma. 
Jonathan Howard on October 28, 2021
Link

A recent analysis estimated that 342,000 unvaccinated people were hospitalized with COVID-19 in the USA over a 3-month period this summer, and each hospitalization costs about $20,000. Though the analysis “made assumptions that result in a conservative estimate of costs attributable to preventable, unvaccinated hospitalizations”, it concluded that “total preventable costs for those three months now stand at an estimated $5.7 billion”. While this analysis did not specify how much money was spent on pharmaceutical agents, clearly these costs make up a substantial part of any hospital bill. As any doctor knows, patients hospitalized with COVID-19 are treated with a cocktail of pain medications, steroids, antibiotics, sedatives, and anti-viral agents. While some of these medications are cheap, others can be quite expensive. Remdesivir, for example, costs over $3,100 per treatment course. Given how hospitals seek to maximize profit, even a single Tylenol pill can cost $15.
In contrast, the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine costs $19.50 per dose, while the Moderna vaccine costs $15 per dose. Medicare also pays about $40 for administering the vaccine. As such, vaccinating these 342,000 individuals with two mRNA doses would have cost around $41 million, though only about $13.5 million of this would have gone to pharmaceutical companies. Even if every unvaccinated patient hospitalized with COVID-19 was treated with just nine $15 Tylenol pills, the vaccines would save money. Overall, the cost of a COVID-19 hospitalization is 150 times more expensive than vaccination.
Notably, the vaccines are very effective at keeping people alive and out of the hospital, and we should all be grateful to everyone involved in their development. According to CDC data and data from individual states, over 90% of people who are hospitalized with COVID-19 are unvaccinated. Basically, if all of the 342,000 hospitalized patients had been vaccinated, one would expect that 287,000 of them would have avoided this fate. About 45 million people could have been fully vaccinated with the $5.7 billion used to treat the 287,000 unvaccinated, hospitalized Americans this summer. The vaccine works for adolescents as well. A recent CDC study found that of 179 hospitalized patients age 12-18 years, 97% were unvaccinated. The study further found that “All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients”. Vaccines could have prevented all of this.
Additionally, COVID-19 patients can incur significant healthcare costs even if they are not hospitalized. Many outpatients are eligible to receive expensive monoclonal antibodies. Regeneron charges $1,250 per infusion, while other monoclonal antibodies costs about $2,100 per infusion. These costs do not include fees charged by treatment centers. Overall, an analysis of COVID-19 outpatients from a private insurance company found treatment costs were $500-$1,000 per patient. This adds up to a lot of money considering millions of Americans were infected this summer.
Moreover, unethical doctors have raked in money selling fraudulent COVID-19 “treatments” such as ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine to unvaccinated patients with COVID-19. The anti-vaccine group America’s Frontline Doctors wrote $8.5 million worth of these prescriptions, enriching themselves of course, but also enriching pharmaceutical companies. Ironically, the toxic side effects of these medications have themselves led to a number of hospitalizations, further enriching hospitals and the pharmaceutical industry.
        ◦ It’s common knowledge that anti-vaxxers are dedicated to filling the coffers of Big Coffin. Simple math leads to another obvious conclusion: they also work extremely hard to enrich hospitals and Big Pharma. Make sure they know that.

Goodbye to the Novavax Vaccine? Our Flailing Medical Establishment Rejects Medical Freedom and Refuses to Fund Gold-Standard Science.
Our current Medical Establishment doesn’t seem to grasp that they are no longer just Fox News and Twitter celebrities who can comment from the sidelines as if they were passive observers.
Jonathan Howard on April 29, 2025
Link
Novavax may be the best COVID-10 Vaccine to date
Once upon a time, Dr. Marty Makary was a big fan of the Novavax vaccine. “It uses a tried & true mechanism of action,” he said. It just needed a “better PR firm,” he added, linking to an article titled The mRNA Vaccines Are Extraordinary, but Novavax Is Even Better.
Under this administration, we are prioritizing the Gold-Standard of Science
Things are very different today. Dr. Makary no longer cares about tried-and-true mechanisms of action when it comes to vaccines. With the assistance of Dr. Tracy Beth Hoeg, a COVID-fabulist, sports medicine doctor, and political appointee, Dr. Makary recently put the brakes on full approval for the Novavax vaccine. As the article FDA Asks Vaccine Maker to Complete New Clinical Trial for Delayed Covid-19 Shot reported, they are demanding a new randomized-controlled trial (RCT).
On social media, Dr. Makary, who authors We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April 4 years ago, depicted himself as a champion of science and evidence-based medicine. Although previous RCTs showed the Novavax vaccine was 90% effective against preventing COVID, including 80% in adolescents, Dr. Makary now claims that every tweak to it requires a fresh RCT.  He also depicted himself as heroically standing up against Big Pharma. They were too greedy to run a new trial.
They did not honestly study the issue
However, there is no reason why the NIH should not fund such vaccine RCTs. Dr. Jay Bhattacharya agrees that RCTs are the only valid method for learning about vaccines. Although he massively overhyped them in April 2021, promising they blocked transmission and eliminated severe disease, in his article The Covid Vaccine Trials: Failures in Design and Interpretation he blasted previous public health officials for saying what he said. He wrote about “a mismatch between the clinical trial endpoints and the public health needs” as well as a “failure in the interpretation of the trials, with a mismatch between what public health officials claimed and recommended and what the trials actually showed.”
Moreover, Dr. Bhattacharya clearly feels that running such trials is the responsibility of the agency he now leads. In the video below, he excoriated his predecessors for not running such studies of drugs like ivermectin. They controlled “billions of dollars of funding,” Dr. Bhattacharya pointed out. “They did not honestly study the issue in 2020,” he said. Dr. Bhattacharya feels Dr. Fauci and the NIH should have “definitively” studied these medications and done “high-quality trials.” He implied they refused to study them to hide that they worked, and he also defended people’s right to take them. “Why would you not permit people to take it,” he asked? In reality, Dr. Fauci and the NIH tried to study hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin in 2020 but couldn’t get anyone to enroll.
There isn’t enough time between identification of strains included & release of vaccine
Unlike myself, Drs. Makary, Hoeg, and Bhattacharya did nothing to advance a COVID-RCT before they were sworn into office. They merely called for others to do RCTs and treated this as a genuine accomplishment. They made such trials sound really easy and blasted their predecessors for their supposed failures, the same way they are blasting Novavax today. There’s always a villain and it can no longer be the Medical Establishment. Now, these doctors are the Medical Establishment, with enormous power and resources at their disposal. Despite this, they still feel it’s someone else’s job to run RCTs. They still feel their role is to give TV interviews and send Tweets calling for other people to do the Gold-Standard of Science. RCTs were for Francis Collins and Toni Fauci only apparently.
However, by refusing to fund and perform vaccine-RCTs, they are advocating for Big Pharma to do the research that determines whether or not vaccines are safe and effective. Our Medical Establishment doesn’t want independent agencies to generate Gold-Standard of Science for the American public. They bash Big Pharma as greedy, but they expect people to trust the results of their studies.
Of course, we don’t have to play dumb about what’s actually happening here. Drs. Hoeg and Makary are not demanding a new RCT to advance medical knowledge or protect the America public, but rather to please their boss by sabotaging the Novavax vaccine. As they surely know, a new trial might be “prohibitively expensive“, and there is virtually no chance it could have actionable results before the next variant emerged. As Dr. Tara Smith said:
Dr. Michael Osterholm, who recently launched the Vaccine Integrity Project to safeguard vaccines the U.S. similarly said:
Since the season is only X number of weeks long, by the time they could get vaccine approved with early season studies, it would be too late… to get vaccine out. It makes no sense at all. Unfortunately, we’ve got a combination of government scientists and public relations people who don’t understand what they don’t understand. And this is potentially a very dangerous concern.
Doctors Who Performatively Fetishized RCTs Aren’t Out to Advance Medical Research, But Rather to Sow Doubt & Mistrust
He’s, right, though this sort of methadolatry is an old anti-vaxx trick, which we’ve written discussed often here at SBM. While it would be great if RCTs could be whipped up in an instant, there’s a reason I titled one of my previous articles Doctors Who Performatively Fetishized RCTs Aren’t Out to Advance Medical Research, But Rather to Sow Doubt & Mistrust. Now, these merchants of doubt have power, and they are using the same tricks, wielding RCTs as a weapon.
This is all part of a broader assault on vaccines. Dr. Makary is currently downplaying measles, refusing to advise parents to get the MMR, and cheering for the pediatric COVID vaccine to be taken away. Meanwhile, the headlines read US Halts Funding for New COVID-19 Vaccines and, Dr. Bhattacharya wants to pull existing mRNA vaccines from the market. There is no reason to think that the mRNA boosters will be treated different than the Novavax vaccine.
None of this surprises those of us who paid attention. Drs. Makary, Hoeg, and Bhattacharya spread copious anti-vaccine misinformation over the past several years. Today, they are threatening to take away all COVID vaccines under the guise of protecting the American public from itself. They feel that they, the Medical Establishment, knows what’s best for your health, and they want to use government power to limit your choices.
A study of the Novavax vaccine, specifically funded by Novavax the company, won’t convince anyone to get it. Moreover, absolutely no one who was going to get the Novavax vaccine asked for a new RCT of it. They were satisfied with the existing data. Recent data from the company showed it has fewer side effects than the mRNA vaccines, and its many fans are rightfully angry that our Medical Establishment is threatening their medical freedom. Apparently, the question “Why would you not permit people to take it?” applies only to quack treatments, not to vaccines with a proven track record.
This Is Not How We Do Science, Ever
Our current Medical Establishment doesn’t seem to grasp that they are no longer just Fox News and Twitter celebrities who can comment from the sidelines as if they were passive observers. They are in charge, and it’s their job generate high-quality data, exactly like they demanded from their predecessors. Similarly, the rest of us have the right to call for them to do RCTs and hold them accountable for their failures. They signed up for this. Since Drs. Makary, Hoeg, and Bhattacharya claim we need new RCTs of COVID vaccines, we should all call for them to do these trials themselves.
Yet, instead of providing the American public with the Gold-Standard of Science we deserve, our Medical Establishment is continuing the pattern they established during COVID. For vaccines, they required the Gold-Standard of Science. They felt it was necessary to protect the public from potential risks of the vaccine. We must be very careful!
However, such none of this was necessary when it came to the virus. Listen to what they said in summer 2021, when the virus was 1-year old, right before the Delta and Omicron waves arrived. These confident pronouncements were not made based on the the Gold-Standard of Science. There was no RCT that showed we had herd immunity in May 2021 or that natural immunity to COVID was likely lifelong. For the virus, vibes were just fine. There was no need for the Gold-Standard of Science, and there was no need to be careful. Nothing’s changed, except who has power and who is the Medical Establishment.
Today, these doctors are going to use our tax money to dredge private medical records to “discover” the cause of autism and attack transgender people, with the “results” known in advance. As Katherine Wu recently reported about this inversion of the scientific method:
NIH officials found the memo’s directives appalling. “This is not how we do science, ever,” one of them, who requested anonymity out of concern for professional retribution, told me. “This is politicized research, exactly what we were always told we would never do.”
For the past 5 years, the attitude of our Medical Establishment has been: RCTs for thee, fishing expeditions for me. This is the quality of “science” they are going to give us today. We all know the “conclusions” in advance and because it’s not the Gold-Standard of Science, we should reject the predetermined results.

TURBO CANCER

Here we go again: Another study is being misrepresented as evidence that COVID vaccines cause cancer
An eminent oncologist, cancer researcher, and cancer center director is promoting a study that seems to show—but, when critically examined, doesn’t—that COVID vaccines are associated with increased cancer risk.
David Gorski on September 29, 2025
Link
When I was thinking about what to write for today, I had a number of ideas, and, unfortunately, they all had to do with the utter nightmare that federal medical, public health, and biomedical research programs are becoming under the current administration, overseen by Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who, in return for being given free rein to “go crazy on health” (i.e. eliminate vaccines) has signed on to the dismantling of public health. Then, life intervened, and, uncharacteristically, I didn’t have time to write anything until last night, which led me to think that maybe I should do a reverse Commando (it’s the opening joke from last week’s post—look it up if you don’t remember) and do a simpler post about something else. True, it’s about vaccines, but it’s also about looking at a study that is being circulated widely and misrepresented as being good evidence that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer. Yes, we’re back at “turbo cancer.”
Here’s what brought this study to my attention:
Censorship shows up on @LinkedIn once again for peer-reviewed literature. This time the Korean study with data on 8.4 million people is labeled as misinformation. Sad to see. @RetsefL @RWMaloneMD @RobertKennedyJr @KUPERWASSERLAB https://t.co/LEw1cs2OPF pic.twitter.com/AJXr4uxDkh
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) September 28, 2025
Sadly, it’s Prof. Wafik El-Deiry again, someone who featured prominently in last week’s post, and he’s at it again, whining about “censorship” again because LinkedIn moderated his post and snitch-tagging RFK Jr. and antivaxxers turned members of the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), Robert “Inventor of mRNA Vaccines (not)” Malone and Levi Retsef. Last week, you’ll remember, as a member of the ACIP COVID-19 working group Prof. El-Deiry gave an error- and misinformation-filled presentation to ACIP that fear mongered about the dreaded “DNA contamination” of vaccines and contained false claims that there was good evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are associated with an increased risk of cancer.
As I described last week, we have met Prof. El-Deiry before in the context of his having demonstrated too little skepticism of work claiming that contaminating DNA from mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines could integrate into genomic DNA and cause “turbo cancers,” to overinterpreting and overextrapolating results that his lab published linking binding of the spike protein to p53 (the granddaddy of tumor suppressor genes) to possible cancer development, to being willing to let his good name as a respected cancer researcher and director of a major cancer center be weaponized against vaccines by being interviewed by an antivax “journalist.” I’ve expressed my disappointment in Dr. El-Deiry on a number of occasions, as well as my admiration for his pre-COVID vaccine work, especially his groundbreaking work from the 1990s on another tumor suppressor, p21, which I cited often in my graduate work. Then, as now, Prof. El-Deiry was quite…defensive…when criticized:
A typical response to Prof. El-Deiry when called out.
Also, he retreats to what I like to call appeal to impact factor:
I understand the journal IF is 11 and they publish after peer review. Not only is science politicized but it is also censored.
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) September 28, 2025
An impact factor of 11 is quite respectable, but that doesn’t mean the journal can’t publish crap. Let me remind you that The Lancet once published a fraudulent case series by a certain British gastroenterologist that falsely linked the MMR vaccine to autism, and The Lancet has a much higher impact factor. Moreover, Dr. Young above made some very valid criticisms, as you’ll see. No, I’m not saying that this study is fraudulent. Rather, I’m saying it’s not very good and very likely suffers from significant biases that render its findings of associations between COVID-19 vaccines and cancer suspect.
So let’s take a look at the paper, published online last Friday: 1-year risks of cancers associated with COVID-19 vaccination: a large population-based cohort study in South Korea, by Hong Jin Kim, Min-Ho Kim, Myeong Geun Choi & Eun Mi Chun. Two of the authors are faculty at Department of Internal Medicine, Ewha Womans University Mokdong Hospital, one from Ewha Womans University Seoul Hospital, and the last from based at Kyung-in Regional Military Manpower Administration.
Let’s start with the title, which should be a red flag for problems with this paper: One year risks. As I’ve emphasized time after time after time after time, cancer takes a long time to develop, usually years, sometimes decades. I routinely cite a study done examining survivors of the nuclear bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, which found that the increased risk of cancer attributable to the ionizing radiation dosages victims survived, well, let me just quote a summary of the findings again:
What do these data show? First, the risk of developing a radiation-induced cancer is dose-related—the higher the dose, the greater the probability a cancer in an A-bomb survivor was caused by radiation exposure. Second, the A-bomb data allow us to determine the briefest interval from radiation exposure to cancer diagnosis. For leukemias, this is about 2 years, and for solid cancers, about 10 years. These increased risks, especially those for solid cancers, were most easily detected after 30 years and remain over a person’s lifetime.
Remember, ionizing radiation is a very powerful carcinogen. It’s incredibly unlikely that, even if COVID-19 vaccines contributed to cancer development (a hypothesis for which there is no good evidence), the effect would not be as dramatic as for ionizing radiation. Remember, the intervals described above (two years for hematologic malignancies and ten years for solid cancers) are the briefest interval observed between radiation exposure to cancer diagnosis. Put that into context by considering that December will mark the five year anniversary of the first doses of the Pfizer mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine rolling out to the public, starting with healthcare workers, who were prioritized. That’s how I got my first dose in December 2020.
In fairness, more recent studies show shorter minimum latency periods. For example, the CDC World Trade Center Health Program defines minimum latency periods for these cancers as:
The Administrator of the WTC Health Program has determined minimum latencies for the following five types or categories of cancer eligible for coverage in the WTC Health Program:
(1) Mesothelioma — 11 years, based on direct observation after exposure to mixed forms of asbestos in case series;
(2) All solid cancers (other than mesothelioma, lymphoproliferative, thyroid, and childhood cancers) — 4 years, based on low estimates used for lifetime risk modeling of low-level ionizing radiation studies;
(3) Lymphoproliferative and hematopoietic cancers (including all types of leukemia and lymphoma) — 0.4 years (equivalent to 146 days), based on low estimates used for lifetime risk modeling of low-level ionizing radiation studies;
(4) Thyroid cancer — 2.5 years, based on low estimates used for lifetime risk modeling of low- level ionizing radiation studies; and
(5) Childhood cancers (other than lymphoproliferative and hematopoietic cancers) — 1 year, based on the National Academy of Sciences findings.
Again, remember that these are minimum latencies, and they are generously low estimates, as a fair reading of the whole document, which cites longer estimates in its discussion, will indicate.
In brief, I, as several others on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, as well as other social media observed, an increased one-year risk almost certainly represents detection bias of some sort, in which those in the vaccinated group are more likely than those in the unvaccinated group to have their cancers detected. Again, more on that later.
Now consider the findings:
The oncogenic potential of SARS-CoV-2 has been hypothetically proposed, but real-world data on COVID-19 infection and vaccination are insufficient. Therefore, this large-scale population-based retrospective study in Seoul, South Korea, aimed to estimate the cumulative incidences and subsequent risks of overall cancers 1 year after COVID-19 vaccination. Data from 8,407,849 individuals between 2021 and 2023 were obtained from the Korean National Health Insurance database. The participants were categorized into two groups based on their COVID-19 vaccination status. The risks for overall cancer were assessed using multivariable Cox proportional hazards models, and data were expressed as hazard ratios (HRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). The HRs of thyroid (HR, 1.351; 95% CI, 1.206–1.514), gastric (HR, 1.335; 95% CI, 1.130–1.576), colorectal (HR, 1.283; 95% CI, 1.122–1.468), lung (HR, 1.533; 95% CI, 1.254–1.874), breast (HR, 1.197; 95% CI, 1.069–1.340), and prostate (HR, 1.687; 95% CI, 1.348–2.111) cancers significantly increased at 1 year post-vaccination. In terms of vaccine type, cDNA vaccines were associated with the increased risks of thyroid, gastric, colorectal, lung, and prostate cancers; mRNA vaccines were linked to the increased risks of thyroid, colorectal, lung, and breast cancers; and heterologous vaccination was related to the increased risks of thyroid and breast cancers. Given the observed associations between COVID-19 vaccination and cancer incidence by age, sex, and vaccine type, further research is needed to determine whether specific vaccination strategies may be optimal for populations in need of COVID-19 vaccination.
Here is the graph:
Looking at this result and study, I had a number of questions, but one thing stood out, something I noticed immediately, even leaving aside for the moment, specific questions about the methodology used to do the multivariate analysis. (For example, I see no mention of specific very important confounders. More on that later.) Look at the specific cancers that have an increased one-year risk in the vaccinated:
    • Thyroid cancer
    • Gastric Cancer
    • Colorectal cancer
    • Lung cancer
    • Breast cancer
    • Prostate cancer
What do these cancers have in common? It helps if you remember that this is a South Korean study. Why? Most readers know that in the US we routinely screen for breast, prostate, and colorectal cancer in the US, with high risk populations (e.g., smokers) also screened for lung cancer (although uptake of that screening is low). So what about gastric and thyroid cancer. First, gastric cancer is more common in Asian populations, which is why Japan and Korea both have active screening programs for gastric cancer. In the past barium studies were used, but now it’s endoscopy. So, unlike the case in the US, in South Korea gastric cancer is a screen-detected cancer.
Thyroid cancer is another interesting cancer to have been detected in this study. We don’t routinely screen for thyroid cancer in the US, but in South Korea—you guessed it!—they do. Moreover, South Korea has the highest incidence of thyroid cancer in the world, which has been called an “epidemic.” There is now good evidence that the large increase in the incidence of thyroid cancer in South Korea is almost certainly the result of overdiagnosis from the ultrasound screening program. Overdiagnosis, if you’ll recall, is the detection of real disease by screening that is very early and/or indolent and would likely, if untreated, never cause the patient harm. If you want to review in detail the concepts of overdiagnosis and lead time bias, both of which can increase the apparent incidence of cancers screened for as well as the apparent five-year survivals, I refer you to previous posts (linked in this paragraph) of mine on the topic.
I’ve discussed overdiagnosis a number of times on this blog for a number of cancers, including breast cancer and, yes, thyroid cancer. You might remember that, after the March 2011 meltdowns at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant in Japan as a result of damage sustained from a tsunami that hit Japan, there was concern about an “epidemic” of thyroid cancer in Japan. After the disaster, Japan started an ultrasound screening program for thyroid cancer, resulting in an “epidemic” of thyroid cancer diagnoses that were later shown to be almost certainly nearly all due to overdiagnosis.
So what does this all have to do with the study linking the six cancers above to COVID-19 vaccines? I think you probably can figure out where I’m going with this. First of all, there is no good detailed description of how standard confounders were treated, such as age, smoking history, sex, family history, obesity, alcohol use, etc. Don’t get me wrong. There was some stratification for age and sex, but:
Meanwhile, vaccinated males were more vulnerable to gastric and lung cancers, whereas vaccinated females were more susceptible to thyroid and colorectal cancers. In terms of age stratification, the relatively younger population (individuals under 65 years) was more vulnerable to thyroid and breast cancers; by comparison, the older population (75 years and older) was more susceptible to prostate cancer (Additional File 3). Booster doses substantially affected the risk of three cancer types in the vaccinated population: gastric and pancreatic cancers (Table 1). Our findings highlighted various cancer risks associated with different COVID-19 vaccine types.
Prostate cancer is a disease of old men. Autopsy series, for instance, show that more than half of men over 80 have foci of cancer in their prostates, and the median age at diagnosis is late 60s. As for that finding that boosters are associated with increased risk of gastric and pancreatic cancers at one year, I looked at that result and, again, strongly suspected some form of detection bias. After all, pancreatic cancer takes years to develop. It’s rare for this cancer to go from nothing to cancer within a year. Indeed, the WTC Health Program cites studies showing that it takes 18 years from the time of the first cancer-causing mutations in the pancreas to clinically evident pancreatic cancer.
What this study screams to me is healthy vaccinee bias, specifically a side effect of healthy vaccinee bias known as healthy user bias. You might recall that healthy vaccinee bias is a type of confounding in observational studies (like this one, a retrospective observational study) where healthier, more health-conscious individuals are more likely to get vaccinated. This bias can lead to the overestimate of vaccine efficacy, which is obviously not an issue in this study, which didn’t even try to estimate vaccine efficacy. That wasn’t its purpose. Healthy user bias, which is related, is the likelihood that people engaging in one health behavior (e.g., getting vaccinated against COVID-19) will be more likely also to engage in other health interventions, such as cancer screening. What I think we’re very likely seeing in this study is nothing more than a failure to correct for screening intensity, along with other potential confounders, so that the likelihood that people who were vaccinated and boosted were more likely to undergo screening, leading to an apparent increased incidence of the six screen-detected cancers described within a year, or to seek medical care for lesser symptoms, leading to, for instance, an earlier diagnosis of pancreatic cancer, a cancer that is not routinely screened for. Add to that lots of evidence that has failed to find a post-vaccination surge in cancer cases, either in the US or worldwide, and this paper looks fatally flawed, at least to me.
Moreover, at the end of the study:
The data that support the findings of this study are available from National Health Insurance Service in South Korea but restrictions apply to the availability of these data, which were used under license for the current study, and so are not publicly available. Data are however available from the authors upon reasonable request and with permission of National Health Insurance Service, South Korea.
One hopes that there will be independent researchers who will request and receive the data.
All of this brings me back to Prof. El-Deiry. He’s an eminent cancer researcher and has been for 30 years. He was rumored to be a contender to head the National Cancer Institute (likely because of his receptiveness to nonsense about “turbo cancer” due to COVID-19 vaccines). Fortunately (and highly unusual for this administration), it appears that someone actually qualified to run NCI will be appointed. He really should know better. He really should have been able to see the glaring problems with this study that make its conclusions linking COVID-19 vaccines both highly implausible from a biological and clinical standpoint based on what we know about carcinogenesis and cancer latency and very suspicious for specific obvious biases. Seriously, the finding that only cancers routinely screened for came up in the analysis other than the secondary analysis for “boosters” should have been a huge red flag for detection bias in the context of what we know about how long cancer latency is.
Sadly, if there’s one thing I’ve learned during the pandemic, it’s that no one is entirely immune to misinformation. Indeed, people whom you wouldn’t expect fall prey to misinformation in topics in which they have expertise. Apparently, that includes eminent oncologists and cancer researchers.


Antivaxxers misrepresent a study to falsely claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer
The latest antivaccine propaganda claims that a 2018 research paper published by researchers at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center shows that the RNA in the Moderna and Pfizer COVID-19 vaccines can cause cancer. As usual, it’s a complete misapplication of a cherry picked study grounded in a lack of understanding of molecular biology. Same as it ever was.
David Gorski on March 8, 2021
Link

The topic of this post might be a bit niche, but, given my background in molecular biology research, particularly earlier in my career, every so often I like to take on a topic that’s a bit “niche,” particularly if it is relevant to medical misinformation being promoted online, and even more so if it’s relevant to medical misinformation about COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines being promoted online. Many have been the times that I’ve mentioned how, with respect to the new COVID-19 vaccines, everything old is new again. At the risk of being repetitive (but also providing the benefit of your not having to click on a link to see what I’m talking about; that is, unless you want to), antivaxxers have falsely spread misinformation and conspiracy theories claiming that COVID-19 vaccines kill; make women infertile; cause autoimmune disease; “reprogram your DNA“; aren’t needed because COVID-19 is not only not a serious disease but is a “casedemic” based on overly sensitive tests; can cause Alzheimer’s disease; can cause prion disease; and/or are loaded with “toxins” (in this case, the lipid nanoparticles that contain the mRNA used in the vaccines). To these old antivax tropes was added the claim that the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are not really vaccines at all but rather “experimental gene therapy”. (No, they’re vaccines.) Just about the only claim that antivaxxers haven’t made yet about COVID-19 vaccines is that they cause autism, and that’s only because there are as yet no COVID-19 vaccines approved for use in children and babies and no mass vaccination program of children. Just wait until there are, and you’ll see that claim too.
And here it comes, the claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer
I did forget one common antivaccine claim, though. It’s one that I hadn’t yet seen about the COVID-19 vaccine, even though it’s a claim that dates back decades about early versions of the polio vaccine used in the late 1950s and early 1960s, namely that vaccines cause cancer. (It’s a claim that’s morphed and metastasized to invoke “chronic inflammation”—which can contribute to cancer—from vaccines in general as a cause of cancer.) You remember that hoary old claim, don’t you, that because early versions of the polio vaccine were contaminated with a virus (SV40), those polio vaccines given to children over 60 years ago are responsible for a wave of cancer over the last two decades. I discussed in my inimitable detail how that claim was investigated and found to have no scientific basis way back in 2013. Now that claim has been repurposed for the COVID-19 vaccine. No, antivaxxers are not claiming that the COVID-19 vaccines by Moderna, Pfizer/BioNTech, or Johnson & Johnson are contaminated with SV40. Rather, they are focusing their false claim that COVID-19 vaccines will cause a wave of cancer in decades to come on the mRNA-based design of these vaccines and a cherry picked study from Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center from 2018 (to give their misinformation the patina of scientific respectability). I haven’t seen this claim widely disseminated (yet), but as a trained molecular biologist I thought I’d try to nip it in the bud before it grows too much.
Let’s start with this Tweet:
1.) What is the mortality rate of the COVID -19 vaccine?2.) Has it been tested for pathogenic priming?3.) Does this vaccine cause cancer in the long run since " New research suggests that mRNA itself may carry cancer-causing changes"? (source https://t.co/polCaNV7jo)
— Mo (@Mo_Forestt) March 6, 2021
To answer the first question, so far, based on observations after tens of millions of vaccines administered in the US alone, we do not yet have a single case of death that can be definitely attributed to the vaccine and the number of deaths soon after vaccination with the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines is actually less than would be expected by random chance alone if the vaccines have nothing to do with the deaths. To answer the second question, “pathogenic priming” is scare term invented by an antivaxxer named James Lyons-Weiler to describe antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE), which has been a problem in the development of vaccines against Dengue Virus, Ebola Virus, HIV, RSV, and the family of coronaviruses. In brief, ADE is a condition when insufficient antibody titers due to the vaccine trigger enhancement of disease with subsequent infection. Vaccine-induced non-neutralizing or weakly neutralizing antibodies bind to newly infecting virus to promote enhanced virus uptake into host cells. ADE was indeed a concern early on during the development of COVID-19 vaccines but fortunately appears not to be an issue. If it were, we would have seen it after the nearly 90 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines (and counting) that have been administered so far in the US (as of Sunday).
Which brings us to the third question based on this study touted by MSKCC by press release two and a half years ago. The source of this “interpretation” of the MSKCC study to weaponize it as evidence that the mRNA in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines will cause cancer appears to come from one of our favorite conspiracy quack sites, Natural News.
Quoth antivaxxers, “Oh, no, RNA causes cancer!”
The article that appears to have been the origin of the claim that somehow the RNA in COVID-19 vaccines causes cancer, based on a mechanism first described by scientists at MSKCC more than two years before the first cases of COVID-19 puzzled Chinese health authorities in Wuhan, was published last week on NaturalNews.com under the title “MEDICAL SHOCKER: Scientists at Sloan Kettering discover mRNA inactivates tumor-suppressing proteins, meaning it can promote cancer“. The article is by S.D. Wells, one of Mike Adams’ minions at Natural News, a veritable workhorse who spreads conspiracy theories and misinformation under Mike Adams’ banner.
The first paragraph is…something:
There’s a secret layer of information in your cells called messenger RNA, that’s located between DNA and proteins, that serves as a critical link. Now, in a medical shocker to the whole world of vaccine philosophy, scientists at Sloan Kettering found that mRNA itself carries cancer CAUSING changes – changes that genetic tests don’t even analyze, flying completely under the radar of oncologists across the globe.
So now, it’s time for independent laboratories that are not vaccine manufacturers (or hired by them) to run diagnostic testing on the Covid vaccine series and find out if these are cancer-driving inoculations that, once the series is complete, will cause cancer tumors in the vaccinated masses who have all rushed out to get the jab out of fear and propaganda influence. Welcome to the world of experimental and dirty vaccines known as mRNA “technology.”
That “secret layer” of information is only “secret” if you don’t know simple molecular biology, but I’ll let that pass for the moment. Instead, observe how this observation is framed as a conspiracy theory. There’s a “secret” aspect to mRNA vaccines that “they” don’t want you to know about, an aspect that will harm you because…well, you’ll learn that soon enough. I can’t help but note that the PR department at MSKCC must be aware of the conspiracy theories being spun based on this science, because someone added this disclaimer to the press release being used as justification for Wells’ claim:
Researchers at the Sloan Kettering Institute have found that changes in an information-carrying molecule called messenger RNA can inactivate tumor-suppressing proteins and thereby promote cancer. The findings pinpoint previously unknown drivers of the disease. It’s important to note that mRNAs are a normal component of all cells and the specific ones discussed here are not involved in mRNA-based vaccines, like the one developed against SARS-CoV-2.
Because, of course they’re not. Wells is interested in making it seem to those who don’t know enough molecular biology to assess the claim (the vast majority of the population) that any old “RNA” or “mRNA” can shut off tumor suppressor genes and thereby cause cancer. Still, being a molecular biologist, I was interested in the specifics. Before I do that, let’s delve deeper into the claims:
The information carrying molecule, messenger RNA, can instruct human cells ultimately in the same way as cancer drivers, playing a major role in causing cancer to thrive while inactivating natural tumor-suppressing proteins the human body creates to save you from cancer. This is the complete opposite of what the CDC and the vaccine manufactures are telling everyone right now about the Covid vaccines, and this is based on clinical research by molecular biologists at the Sloan Kettering Institute.
Even sequencing the DNA in cancer cells doesn’t reveal these changes, that’s how sneaky the vaccines are. It’s like a Trojan horse that tells your cells to allow these changes to be made, as if they were safe, but they’re not. All assumptions being made about mRNA being ‘safe’ right now have been completely turned 180 degrees with this research. Consider this very carefully if you have not yet been vaccinated with mRNA technology, and you may want to ‘lawyer-up’ if you already got the jabs.
Notice the conspiracy theory again. Not only did “they” not tell you about this, but “they” hid this ability of mRNA from you in a manner making it unlikely to be found, even by oncologists! (Damn, those scientists at Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech are clever and evil, aren’t they?) I mean, seriously, Wells even brings Bill Gates into the mix, because of course Bill Gates is part of the conspiracy. He’s part of every vaccine conspiracy:
Bill Gates and the Vaccine Industrial Complex are very sinister, as we all know, but to create vaccines that truncate (disable by cutting short) cancer tumor suppressors, and destroy the human body’s ability to protect against cancer, well, that’s just complete insanity. Truncated tumor-suppressor proteins are similar to the DNA mutations that cause cancer cells to mutate and multiply uncontrollably. Will America see cancer cases skyrocket over the next few years due to Covid vaccines? Only time will tell, but right now, science is revealing that it’s likely. Pay close attention.
Therefore, anyone who is scared to death of the Covid vaccines is pro-science rather than anti-science, because the science shows the mRNA technology is very dangerous, especially concerning proteins that fuel cancer tumors. Let’s say that again: Science shows mRNA technology can fuel cancer tumor growth.
No, not exactly. Let’s look at the actual paper to see why.
Lying with science
So let’s take a look at the press release and the scientific paper the press release was promoting. The press release is entitled “In a Twist, Scientists Find Cancer Drivers Hiding in RNA, Not DNA“, and the paper was published in Nature by Christine Mayr, a molecular and cellular biologist at MSKCC who studies mRNA. The study is entitled “Widespread intronic polyadenylation inactivates tumour suppressor genes in leukaemia“, which is, of course, not the sort of title that most people would understand. Don’t worry. I’ll explain.
But first, I need to explain some background. When discussing the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines and how they don’t “reprogram your DNA” and are not “gene therapy“, I discussed how DNA encodes RNA that ultimately encodes protein. Before I discuss what the paper actually shows and why Wells is misapplying its findings, I think it helpful to review the basics of this aspect of molecular biology again. Here is a very basic diagram of the process:

Basically, DNA replicates from a DNA template and results in a double-stranded molecule that is very stable, as it has complementary sequences that tightly bind to each other in a sequence-specific fashion. This DNA template is unwound by enzymes that use the template to make RNA strands, which are single-stranded, which is then used by a ribosome to make protein out of amino acids. Again, to put it simply, each nucleotide equals one letter of the code; each three-nucleotide sequence (codon) equals one “word” that translates to an amino acid. Given that there are four nucleotides, there are 64 possible codons. Since there are only 20 amino acids, that means that most amino acids are encoded by more than one combination of nucleotides or more than one codon; i.e., the genetic code is redundant. Of course, it’s more complicated than that, as this diagram shows:
After the genetic code was cracked 60 years ago, it soon became apparent that the RNAs encoding for proteins are often not fully formed right after they’re transcribed. Often RNA starts out as a longer precursor RNA (a pre-mRNA) that is spliced to the final mRNA sequence before being transported out of the nucleus into the cytoplasm to be used to drive the production of protein in the cytoplasm. In brief, the precursor RNA that is initially transcribed contains sequences known as “exons” and “introns”. In genes, exons contain the nucleotide sequences that encode actual protein, while introns contain nucleotide sequences that do not code for anything but can have important sequences that regulate gene production and activity. Here’s an illustration of the splicing process from Wikipedia:
This diagram is actually fairly simple, with two exons and one intron. Some genes have many exons and introns, requiring multiple splices, as in this diagram:
Did I forget to mention that mRNAs are also processed to have a “cap” at one end and a stretch of As (a poly-A tail) at the other end? The poly-A tail is very important in regulating mRNA stability and therefore its half-life in the cytoplasm. In any event, as with any biological process, things can go wrong with these splicing events. Splice site mutations, for instance, can result in mis-spliced mRNAs and proteins lacking exons:
I could go on and on and on. There are normal genes can produce more than one protein through alternative splicing:
Sometimes when splicing goes awry, it can result in a truncated protein lacking one end. For instance, if an intron is left attached to two exons, chances are that the ribosome (the enzyme complex that translates mRNA into protein) will hit a “stop” codon (three nucleotide code that tells transcription to stop) long before it reaches the other end of the intron, at which point transcription will just stop. All of this is not even counting the other molecular modifications that the RNA can undergo on its journey from transcription to pre-mRNA through splicing to the final “mature” mRNA.
Unsurprisingly, if these sorts of errors occur in genes important to processes regulating cell growth and invasion, cancer can result, either from a mis-splicing removing a regulatory region in the protein that keeps it in check or by producing a protein that doesn’t function as it should. Examples of cancers that are caused or accelerated by a splice site mutation are accumulating. It is this latter possibility, a truncated protein that doesn’t function, that the paper being misapplied by Wells examines. The proteins compromised by the truncation are tumor suppressor proteins, whose function is to shut down growth or other processes that can result in cancer when they are overly active.
So what did the paper show? What was interesting about the paper is that it showed the existence of splicing errors in tumor suppressor genes in a specific cancer, chronic lymphocytic leukemia, without mutations in splice sites to explain how these proteins became truncated due to splicing errors, or, as the authors put it in the manuscript:
We discovered widespread upregulation of truncated mRNAs and proteins in primary CLL cells that were not generated by genetic alterations but instead occurred by intronic polyadenylation
And:
The truncated proteins generated by intronic polyadenylation often lack the tumour-suppressive functions of the corresponding full-length proteins (such as DICER and FOXN3), and several even acted in an oncogenic manner (such as CARD11, MGA and CHST11). In CLL, the inactivation of tumour-suppressor genes by aberrant mRNA processing is substantially more prevalent than the functional loss of such genes through genetic events.
So what does this all mean? First, to reiterate and simplify, the authors detected truncated mRNAs and proteins for a number of tumor suppressor genes in CLL that could not be explained by DNA mutations in the genes themselves, such as splice site mutations. They did a lot of other controls, such as making sure that the explanation for the truncated proteins was not cleavage by proteases, enzymes that cut proteins at specific amino acid sequences. After ruling out other possibilities, the authors demonstrated that these mRNAs and proteins were truncated because of a process called intronic polyadenylation. But what is that?
Polyadenylation is the process of adding a bunch of adenosines (As) to the 3′ end of an RNA molecule. It’s how the poly-A tail is added to the end of an mRNA, but it turns out that it’s a common process for polyadenylation to occur in introns. This process is very widespread and was appreciated well over a decade ago. It’s involved in diversifying the products of immune cell mRNAs, the process explained thusly:
In the splicing literature, isoforms generated through recognition of an IpA signal are often described as ‘alternative last exon’ events. Genes that generate IpA isoforms are thought to harbor competing splicing and polyadenylation signals, producing a full-length messenger RNA (mRNA) when splicing outcompetes polyadenylation and otherwise producing a truncated mRNA. As the defining event is the recognition of an IpA signal, we call these transcripts IpA isoforms. It is now possible to recognize the widespread expression of IpA isoforms through the analysis of 3ʹ-end sequencing data.
Or, to put it more simply, whether there is a truncated protein or a full-length protein depends on the balance of splicing to poly-adenylation at the site in the intron. If there’s more splicing activity, you get much more of the whole protein. If there’s more polyadenylation, you get much more of the truncated protein. What Mayr’s lab found was that too much polyadenylation can result in truncated tumor suppressor proteins in CLL, contributing to the development of the cancer, which is why, according to the MSKCC press release which explains the findings pretty well:
These findings help explain a long-standing conundrum, which is that CLL cells have relatively few known DNA mutations. Some CLL cells lack even known mutations. In effect, the mRNA changes that Dr. Mayr’s team discovered could account for the missing DNA mutations.
Because CLL is such a slow-growing cancer and people with CLL often live for many years, it’s too early to say whether these mRNA changes are associated with a poorer prognosis.
There are some important differences between the mRNA changes and a bona fide DNA mutation. Most important, the inactivation of tumor suppressors through mRNA is usually only partial; only about half of the relevant protein molecules in the tumor cells are truncated. But in many cases this is enough to completely override the function of the normal versions that are present. And because this truncation could apply to 100 different genes at once, the changes can add up.
So why does none of this have anything to do with mRNA-based vaccines causing cancer? I’m glad you asked and hope you don’t mind that I took this opportunity to geek out a bit, in a molecular biology sense. The biology being abused by Wells is actually quite complex and fascinating, and I don’t get to discuss pure molecular biology very often any more. I hope I didn’t lose too many readers with the explanation, but I also bet more than a few of you have already figured out why what Wells is peddling is utter nonsense. If not, here we go.
The payoff of all that beautiful science: Mayr’s paper has nothing to say about whether COVID-19 vaccines can cause cancer
So why do I say that Wells is totally misapplying Mayr’s paper? Simple. There are three reasons that anyone with a knowledge of molecular biology could identify. First, both mRNA vaccines, Moderna and Pfizer, use mRNAs encoding the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. (The Moderna version, for instance, uses a pre-fusion stabilized spike protein. This detail isn’t really important to understand why Wells is misrepresenting the science, but the molecular biology geek in me wanted to mention this.) Unlike oncogenes and tumor suppressor proteins, which are mutated versions of proteins with normal functions in normal cells, the coronavirus spike protein is not made by normal human cells and has have no normal function in human biology. Its only function is for the virus. SARS-CoV-2 binds to the ACE2 receptor on human cells and thereby allows the coronavirus to enter cells to set up shop and start the COVID-19 infection process and churn out more virus. Even if a truncated spike protein were made through the mechanism that Wells apparently doesn’t understand or is lying about, there’s no known biological mechanism for these mRNAs to cause cancer.
Second, the mRNA in the Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines does not undergo any splicing, both of which occur in the nucleus. The mRNA sequences in these vaccines is a complete mRNA sequence for the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and needs no splicing before transcription. Indeed, it really wouldn’t make any sense at all to include in a vaccine an mRNA that requires splicing, as that’s an extra step where things could go wrong and that doesn’t provide any countervailing advantage to make it worthwhile to do. Basically, when you are trying to get eukaryotic cells (as in human cells) to produce a protein from an RNA, keeping the design of the mRNA as simple as possible is best. Use the RNA sequence encoding the protein you want to produce, tack on whatever regulatory sequences to the coding sequence in order to drive expression of the protein, and get as much of the RNA into the cytoplasm to encounter as many ribosomes and churn out as much protein as possible before the RNA, unstable molecule that it is, inevitably degrades. In other words, no splicing or truncated proteins, even if the proteins being produced were even relevant to cancer, which the coronavirus spike protein is not.
Finally, for cancer to develop there needs to be continuing production of the oncogene or continuing elimination of tumor suppressor function in the cell over the long term. The mRNA vaccines used against COVID-19 were intentionally designed to be short-lived. Even if they did produce some sort of truncated protein that could potentially cause cancer, the mRNA and the protein would be gone long before they could trigger cancer, as carcinogenesis is a process that takes months to years, not days to weeks. As I discussed before, the mRNA from these vaccines hangs around for days at most and the protein for a couple of weeks at most. The vaccine’s effects with respect to making spike protein are transient by design.
I will give S.D. Wells credit in a warped sort of way. He understands that the vast majority of people do not have a sufficient background in molecular biology to understand why the Mayr lab paper says nothing about whether COVID-19 vaccines could potentially cause cancer, why even applying it to cancer causation through splicing errors that are not caused by mutations in DNA is a risible misapplication of the paper. He knows that people will see the MSKCC press release about the Mayr lab’s finding that truncated mRNAs can contribute to the development of CLL in the context of his false claims that mRNA-based COVID-19 cause cancer and just make the connection, as scientifically baseless as it is, that the Mayr lab paper found a mechanism by which the mRNA from COVID-19 vaccines can cause cancer too. Again, to misapply a study that deceptively and effectively, I suspect that Wells must have some background in molecular biology, particularly if he was the one who found that paper to cherry pick. Either that, or he’s the luckiest antivaccine propagandist I’ve encountered in a long time.
In the meantime, I’ll finish this post the way I like to finish posts about COVID-19 vaccines and say that, in the age of COVID-19 everything old is new again when it comes to antivax disinformation. There is no good evidence that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer or even have a plausible mechanism by which they could cause cancer. Mike Adams’ minion S.D. Wells is, quite simply, spreading disinformation. I’m still waiting for antivaxxers to claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause autism, and I know it’s coming sooner or later.

There is no evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are causing cancers associated with “accelerated aging”
A recent presentation at AACR found a link between markers of accelerated aging and an increased risk of cancer. Then antivaxxers got a hold of it to blame COVID-19 vaccines not just for cancer, but for “accelerated aging” causing it.
David GorskionApril 15, 2024
Link

Those who follow me on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, know that I just spent the last few days in Orlando (unfortunately) to attend the annual meeting of the American Society of Breast Surgeons. You might also know that I stirred the pot a bit on social media by posting my objection to the keynote speaker citing what I like to call a zombie statistic, namely that long-debunked claim that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US, accounting for over 250,000 deaths annually. Unfortunately, the stirring didn’t take, but if you want to know why this zombie statistic is bogus but nonetheless won’t die and, worse, seemingly has become part of accepted wisdom, a statistic thrown out at the beginning of so many medical talks as though it were accurate, read this. Moreover, the real number is likely 5- to 20-fold lower. I even thought about writing an update looking at the latest evidence regarding the death toll from medical errors, but decided that that was a project that would require more time than I had last weekend, between travel, meetings, and the like. File it away for later, in favor of something that I can handle fairly quickly but still caught my interest.
I’ve now written more times than I can remember why the antivax claim that COVID-19 vaccines are causing a wave of “turbo cancers” is utter nonsense. Briefly, the idea is that somehow the evil humors in the vaccine are more powerful than the most powerful known carcinogen (ionizing radiation) and have caused a wave of highly aggressive cancers in only three years since the vaccines were even widely administered. Never mind that most cancers take more like 10 years to show up after exposure to a carcinogen and that the ones being reported (mostly solid tumors like breast, colon, etc.) do not match the few cancers types that can appear less than three years after exposure to a carcinogen, like leukemias. I thought I had seen every twist on the “turbo cancer” myth; that is, until this weekend.
You see, another meeting was going on last week, overlapping the breast surgery meeting. It’s a meeting that I used to go to every year but, since the pandemic, have not attended. I’m referring to the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR). This year, I had to choose, and unfortunately it made more sense to choose a clinical meeting. In any event, there was a talk presented at the meeting that found that the incidence of “accelerated aging”—I’ll explain how that was defined in a moment, when I get into the weeds of the study that I could find, even though it hasn’t been published in a peer-reviewed journal yet—has increased in younger cohorts of adults. If confirmed, it would be a very interesting finding, something worthy or further research to determine why this might be happening. It might also potentially be an explanation for why the incidence of cancer has been increasing in younger people over the last 25 years.
Quote antivaxxers: It’s got to be the vaccines that done it!
Of course, that’s not how antivaxxers saw it, and the news reports in even conventional media didn’t help. Before I get to the abstract itself, let’s look at the AACR press release, entitled, blandly enough, Accelerated Aging May Increase the Risk of Early-onset Cancers in Younger Generations. Basically, the finding was that accelerated aging was more common in recent birth cohorts and was associated with increased incidence of early-onset solid tumors. SciTech Daily’s headline tacked onto the press release was a little more provocative but not particularly alarming, Unraveling the Rapid Aging Mystery Behind Early-Onset Cancers. ASCO Post reported, Accelerated Aging May Be a Risk Factor for Early-Onset Cancers in Younger Generations, while CNN added, Accelerated aging linked to cancer risk in younger adults, research shows. You can probably see where I’m going with this and how antivaxxers decided to spin the study, which, again, hasn’t even been formally published yet.
First, there was the NY Post headline, Cancer rates rising in young people due to ‘accelerated aging,’ according to ‘highly troubling’ new study. Note the “highly troubling” part added. Also note that this article was actually by Melissa Rudy of Fox News. It also, for no apparent reason other than to fear monger, quotes Dr. Brett Osborn, portrayed as an “expert in longevity.” Never having heard of Dr. Osborn before, naturally I just had to Google him. Unsurprisingly, this is what I found near the top of the search results:
Yeah, Dr. Osborn is a body builder and ripped. My question: Natty or not? (I vote for not.)
Why don’t I have a professional photographer shoot me looking all studly like this?
And:
To Brett Osborn, DO, FAANS, CSCS, most ailments of modern-day society can be prevented. The West Palm Beach neurosurgeon, author, and founder of Senolytix views good health as a privilege to be earned.
“Patients should not expect their doctors to keep them in good health,” he says. “Most patients could solve their problems by taking simple steps, like losing weight, exercising more, and eating better.”
Dr. Osborn founded Senolytix to help put patients on a path to extend the number of years of optimal body and mental health. From comprehensive assessments of a patient’s condition, he develops a plan built around better nutrition, proper exercise, and medications that may include hormone replacement therapy, supplements, and improved sleep.
On his website, he makes it even more explicit:
The following are the most important:- Health is a privilege, NOT a right.- There are no “diets,” or secret exercise regimens which will grant one health or a particular body type. Proper manipulation of one’s biochemistry through the above modalities (i.e., turning on the right genes through strength training) will grant one health and longevity.- Health is a lifelong endeavor. There are no races. It is a lifestyle. We must constantly strive to better ourselves (through daily physical and mental challenges) in order to delay the aging process.- Keep bodily inflammation at a minimum (through strength training, nutrition and supplementation, proper sleep and stress reduction techniques). This maintains nearly all disease processes in check.
Good health is a “privilege to be earned”? Seriously? This is the sort of attitude that is everything that is wrong with “alternative health.” What about people who are not sufficiently privileged to be able to adhere to a program like the ones that Dr. Osborn promotes? What about people with genetic predisposition to disease that they inherited through no fault of their own? No one is saying that lifestyle changes, such as a healthier diet and getting more exercise and better sleep, can’t be very beneficial to health, but these people seem to engage in a combination of magical thinking that people have complete control over their health and whether they get sick or not. (“This maintains nearly all disease processes in check”? At least he said “almost.”) Unsurprisingly, like most medical “entrepreneurs,” Dr. Osborn has a YouTube channel, a Twitter feed, and other social media where he hawks his company Senolytix, which offers all sorts of tests and “longevity” medicine interventions. Oh, and his father, whom he cites as an inspiration, was a chiropractor.
My point is simply that he is clearly not a real expert on the science that was reported at AACR. Being boarded by the American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine is not a qualification of which I’d be proud. If you don’t believe me, just search for this organization on this blog.
I don’t want to dwell too much on Dr. Osborn’s take, though. Rather, I mention it mainly to show how a mainstream news organization quoting an anti-aging entrepreneurial neurosurgeon with an agenda, someone who dogmatically states:
NO ONE is too old for strength training. NO ONE is exempt from exercise. Numerous studies have demonstrated that one’s ability to combat disease is resident within our muscles. Muscles are the protein depots from which our immune system indirectly generates antibodies. Stronger individuals live longer, period. This HAS been proven.
Actually, there is indeed such research, but that same research shows that there are other factors associated with longevity. As we say, it’s complicated.
In any case, it’s a spin on the findings like that of Dr. Osborn that really is just a short hop, skip, and a jump to someone like Mike Adams in a story like Government comes up with another new excuse for the genocide they’ve unleashed upon the planet: ‘accelerated aging’ among the young is causing all of these ‘turbo cancers’, complete with an image like:
Subtle, Mike isn’t.
Let’s see how he spins these findings. After that, I’ll go through the study to tell you what the investigators really found, so that you can see how quacks cherry pick unpublished studies from meeting proceedings and spin them into, well, something like this.
Hilariously, this isn’t even original Mike Adams. He’s republishing an article by someone named Stefan Stanford republished at AllNewsPipeline.com, with an added tagline, “Eugenicists Covering Up Genocide To Avoid Being Executed For Crimes Upon Humanity.” Nice.
Behold:
The latest mind-boggling story over at the NY Post on Tuesday proving just how full of ‘s’ our ‘globalist overlords’ and the mainstream media are in 2024 is titled “Cancer rates rising in young people due to ‘accelerated aging,’ according to ‘highly troubling’ new study.”
Reporting that new research presented this week at the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) Annual Meeting in San Diego, California has found that ‘the young’ are now aging much more rapidly than they have in the past and thus, they are being struck much more frequently with problems that had normally been mainly associated with ‘the elderly,’ take note that once again, these globalist scum are trying to come up with an excuse for the genocide they’re carrying out that should, in any kind of ‘just’ society, leave them all executed and buried 6′ under for their crimes upon humanity.
Reporting that ‘accelerated aging,’ when someone’s biological age is greater than their chronological age, is increasing the risk of deadly cancer tumors in ‘the young,’ we warned just days ago in this story on ANP that so-called ‘turbo cancers’ were exploding among younger generations, with Dr. William Makis MD warning us he had never seen anything like this before.
And while the globalists continue to come up with one excuse after another for this ‘explosion‘, such as ‘global warming‘ or ‘bacteria in the gut linked to processed foods,’ Dr. Makis ties the huge spike in these cases of rapidly spreading cancers in the young directly to the ‘COVID vax.‘
One more time, Dr. Makis is an antivax quack, and “turbo cancer” is not a thing. Moreover, let’s just say that the above take is a…highly exaggerated…version of what the study found, as you will see. Elsewhere, there are articles on quack antivax websites with headlines like, WEF-Linked Study Blames ‘Accelerated Aging’ for Spike in Turbo Cancers Among Young People. I note that the study said nothing about “turbo cancers.”
Meanwhile, on social media:
ACCELERATED AGING!!!What could it be??? Harmful mRNA???💀💉 https://t.co/C0cQd9Vsyi
— Cyberpunk Sense 👑 (@napoleon21st) April 9, 2024
Just wait until they start giving this to all the c19 v@xxed people with the screwed up metabolism and accelerated aging. Oh, what fun.
— Joanie J. 🇺🇸 (@joaniej0243) April 13, 2024
Government comes up with another new excuse for the genocide they’ve unleashed: ‘accelerated aging’ among the young is causing all of these ‘turbo cancers’ – NOT THE KILLER CLOT SHOT.https://t.co/RR5lwOz7s0
— Bob March (@BobMarch273045) April 13, 2024
💥WEF trying to claim "accelerated aging" responsible for turbo cancers in young people. Some are dying within one week of diagnosis. Doctors point to clear evidence that cancers are appearing only in young people having received mRNA vaccines. https://t.co/PQ6G7u2IXZ
— Linda Britton-Fairchild (@FairchildL3853) April 14, 2024
In fairness, there is another contingent blaming the “accelerated aging” on COVID-19, which is more plausible, but still overblown, given that such trends do not happen over a time period as short as the four years since COVID-19 hit.
But what did the study actually show?
“Accelerated aging”?
I almost hesitated to write this post because (1) I didn’t attend AACR and therefore didn’t attend the talk. Thus, all I have are the abstract, press releases, and news reports of interviews with the first author, Ruiyi Tian, MPH, a graduate student at Washington University in St. Louis, and her PhD thesis advisor in whose lab she did the work, Dr. Yin Cao, an associate professor of surgery and senior author of the new research; and (2) I don’t have the figures or detailed methods. I thought about it, though, and then figured that I do have enough to discuss that it should quickly become obvious that antivaxxers are just making stuff up about this research. Also, I’m sure it’s likely disconcerting to Ms. Tian and Dr. Cao; so if either of you see this post and want to chime in or ask for advice on what to do with antivaxxers swarming, let’s just say my email is [email protected].
So here’s the abstract:
The first thing to note is that this study took advantage of the UK Biobank. As I was unfamiliar with this particular database, I took a look at the UK Biobank website, to see that it is an impressive piece of work:
UK Biobank participants have generously provided a very wide range of information about their health and well-being since recruitment began in 2006. This has been added to in the following ways:
    • Imaging: Brain, heart and full body MR imaging, plus full body DEXA scan of the bones and joints and an ultrasound of the carotid arteries. The goal is to image 100,000 participants, and to invite participants back for a repeat scan some years later. 
    • Genetics: Whole genome sequencing for all 500,000 participants, whole exome sequencing for 470,000 participants, genotyping (800,000 genome-wide variants and imputation to 90 million variants).
    • Health linkages: Linkage to a wide range of electronic health-related records, including death, cancer, hospital admissions and primary care records. 
    • Biomarkers: Data on more than 30 key biochemistry markers from all participants, taken from samples collected at recruitment and the first repeat assessment. 
    • Activity monitor: Physical activity data over a 7-day period collected via a wrist-worn activity monitor for 100,000 participants plus a seasonal follow-up on a subset.
    • Online questionnaires: Data on a range of exposures and health outcomes that are difficult to assess via routine health records, including diet, food preferences, work history, pain, cognitive function, digestive health and mental health. 
    • Repeat baseline assessments: A full baseline assessment is undertaken during the imaging assessment of 100,000 participants.
    • Samples: Blood & urine was collected from all participants, and saliva for 100,000.
That’s a heck of a lot of data to mine. I can see why this database was attractive to Tian and Cao. One shortcoming of the study, though, is immediately apparent (and mentioned in a number of places). This is a UK-only study. Whether its results are generalizable to other populations is an open question. I also did some searches and found that there was a study by a different group using the UK Biobank published a year ago that showed correlation between a different set of biomarkers related to aging and the risk of developing cancer. What this study does that’s different is to try to quantify the risk of early onset cancers in people with elevated biological age as assessed by the nine biomarkers included in the PhenoAge calculator.
Next up, how was “accelerated aging” defined? Here’s how:
Biological age was assessed using the PhenoAge algorithm based on nine blood chemistry markers collected at baseline, including albumin, alkaline phosphatase, creatinine, C-reactive protein, glucose, mean corpuscular volume, red cell distribution width, white blood cell count, and lymphocyte proportion. AA was quantified by standardizing the residuals of biological age after regression against chronological age. Multivariable Cox proportional hazards models were used to estimate hazard ratios (HRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). In secondary analyses, we compared the associations with late-onset cancers (diagnosed after age 55).
To put it more simply, nine biomarkers were examined, and an algorithm used to calculate each person’s “biological age” as indicated by these markers and compare it with their chronological age. CNN Health actually gives a good explanation of the relevance of each of these markers:
They homed in on nine blood-based markers that have been shown to correlate with biological age:
    • albumin: a protein made by the liver that declines with age
    • creatinine: a waste product in blood produced by protein digestion and the breakdown of muscle tissue; a measure of kidney function. Lower levels correlate with better longevity.
    • glucose: With age, blood sugar stays higher for longer after meals.
    • c-reactive protein: made by the liver in response to inflammation; relatively higher levels correspond to faster aging
    • lymphocyte percent: The concentration of these white blood cells related to immune function tends to decrease with age.
    • mean cell volume: a measure of the average size of red blood cells, which increases with age
    • red cell distribution width: the difference between the size of a person’s smallest and largest red blood cells, which tends to increase with age
    • alkaline phosphatase: an enzyme produced mainly by the liver and bones that tends to increase with age
    • white blood cell counts: Numbers of white cells in the high end of the normal range in the blood may correspond with greater aging.
I do, however, feel obligated to point out one thing. PhenoAge is just one algorithm. It purports to measure “biologic age,” but does it? Does it really? That, too, is a weakness of the study. There is, of course, evidence that PhenoAge is better predictive of age-related health outcomes, such as all-cause mortality, cancers, healthspan, physical functioning, and Alzheimer’s disease, than other measures. It would have been nice to look at other potential measures of biologic age besides a single algorithm. One also can’t help but note that it would be a lot less sexy to say that a panel of biomarkers predicts your risk of early onset cancer than it was to say that “accelerated aging” does.
Moving on, CNN actually summarized the findings of the study pretty well:
They then checked cancer registries to see how many in the group had been diagnosed with early cancers, which the researchers defined as cancers appearing before age 55. There were nearly such 3,200 cancers diagnosed.
The researchers found that people born in 1965 or later were 17% more likely to show accelerated aging than those born from 1950 through 1954.
Basically, people who are currently younger than 59 have a 17% higher chance of showing signs in this panel of accelerated aging than those aged 70-74. This has consequences. Overall, for all cancers, people with accelerated aging have an of developing cancer with a hazard ratio (HR) of 1.08, but this was driven primarily by a few cancers, such as lung cancer (HR 1.42), gastrointestinal (HR 1.22), and uterine cancer (HR 1.36). Moreover, those with the highest degree of accelerated aging had the highest risk of early onset cancer, as high as two-fold (lung cancer).
So what does this all mean? One thing that it doesn’t mean is that COVID-19 vaccines are causing an epidemic of “accelerated aging” that is in turn causing an epidemic of early onset “turbo cancers.” These sorts of changes in biomarkers don’t happen overnight in a population, and a little over three years since the start of the mass vaccination campaign against COVID-19 is basically overnight. Also, again, it must be emphasized that cancers in response to carcinogens don’t pop up overnight, as the whole “turbo cancer” narrative claims. They take several years, usually a decade or more. Only some of the hematological malignancies take a timeframe under three years, and even then, even if COVID-19 vaccines were as cancer-causing as someone like Dr. Makis claims, we would only just now be starting to see an uptick in a small number of specific hematologic malignancies.
What is interesting about this study, if its results are replicated and bear out, is that they suggest a potential set of blood tests that could identify people at a higher risk for lung, GI, and uterine cancers, as well as a less dramatically elevated risk of other cancers. In other words, testing for accelerated aging could be a way of identifying people who are at higher risk, so that targeted interventions can be developed and implemented to decrease their risk.
What might explain these results and why these specific cancers seemed to be the most influenced by accelerated aging? One possible explanation:
The study wasn’t designed to answer questions about why these cancer types seemed to have the strongest ties to accelerated aging, but Ruiyi Tian, the graduate student who led the research, has some theories.
Tian said it’s possible that lungs are more vulnerable to aging than other types of tissues because the lung has a limited ability to regenerate. Stomach and intestinal cancers, she says, have been linked to inflammation, which increases with aging.
Not vaccines.
As an oncologist says:
Dr. Anne Blaes, who studies the impact of biological aging in cancer survivors at the University of Minnesota, said the study results are exciting because they could point to a better way to find people who are at higher risk of getting cancer when they’re young. Right now, young adults who don’t have a family history or other risk factor aren’t regularly screened for most kind of cancer.
“We’re seeing more and more cancers, especially GI cancers and breast cancers, in younger individuals. And if we had a way of identifying who’s at higher risk for those, then really, you can imagine we’d be recommending screening at a different time,” said Blaes, a professor and director of the Division of Hematology and Oncology at UM medical school. She was not involved in the new research.
Blaes said that if you can find people who are at higher risk because their cells are aging faster, you can target lifestyle interventions too: things like nutrition, exercise and sleep.
“There are medications that also look like they can slow down accelerated aging,” said Blaes, who is testing two of them in cancer survivors. Cancer survivors often show greater biological aging, perhaps because of the after effects of therapies like chemotherapy and radiation.
The medications belong to a class called senolytics, drugs thought to target and get rid of damaged and aging cells.
Of course, this reminds me of Dr. Osborn, whose company is called Senolytix, but let’s just say that, just perusing his website, I am less impressed with his dedication to rigorous science, although his website is quite slick and he does conveniently have three different levels of patient access, Express (meet the nurse practitioner, not Dr. Osborn), Essential, and Elite VIP (“our most extensive, full-service, VIP Concierge membership,” complete with full access to Dr. Osborn, “dependent on Dr. Osborn’s capacity & Neurosurgery call schedule,” of course). I note that the Elite VIP membership offers what many dubious anti-aging clinics that I’ve seen over the years have offered
That and his fear mongering in the NYP article didn’t impress me with his dedication to science:
“Our nation’s health – let alone Britain’s – is imperiled, and unless radical measures are taken, this trend will likely worsen before it gets better,” he warned.
“The younger population will be stricken with lethal diseases at an earlier age.”
Maybe, but what does he mean by “radical measures”? Never mind. I don’t care, for purposes of this discussion. He fits in mainly because of how Fox News used him as a dubious “expert” who promotes infrared saunas as longevity tools in order put an alarming spin on the story. From there, disinformation merchants picked up on it. Of course, antivaxxers and others promoting quackery have long been skilled at distorting and misappropriating legitimate research in order to promote a narrative supporting antivaccine views and quackery. This was just a particularly egregious one. It doesn’t matter that there’s zero evidence, either in this study or anywhere else, to support the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines are responsible for the phenomenon observed in the study so badly distorted by Mike Adams and his ilk.

Do COVID-19 vaccines cause “turbo cancer”?
Over the last several months, antivaxxers have been claiming that COVID-19 vaccines cause “turbo cancer”, cancers (or cancer recurrences) of a particularly aggressive and fast-growing variety diagnosed in younger and younger patients. “Turbo cancer” is not a thing, and the evidence cited is as weak as any antivax “evidence”, including anecdotes and misinterpretation of epidemiology.
David Gorski on December 19, 2022
Link

One of the oldest antivax tropes, one I recall encountering beginning soon after I started paying attention to the antivaccine movement, is that vaccines somehow cause cancer. As I wrote ten years ago, the original version of this claim derived from the observation that an early batche of the polio vaccine from the 1950s, particularly Albert Sabin’s oral vaccine, were contaminated with SV40, which led to a “cancer epidemic” over the coming decades. (SV40 is a monkey virus known as SV40, which stands for “Simian Vacuolating Virus 40” and was found to have contaminated some of the cells that the virus was grown in, specifically kidney cells derived from Asian rhesus monkeys.) The gory details aren’t important for purposes of what I’m about to discuss—and I’ve already written in depth about what happened and why this claim, although plausible because SV40 was one of the first oncogenic viruses ever discovered, turned out not to have any good evidence to support it. (Oncogenes are genes that cause cancer in experimental animals and, in some cases, humans.)
Unsurprisingly, it didn’t take long for antivaxxers to try to link COVID-19 vaccines to cancer as well, with attempts beginning even before the FDA granted an emergency use authorization (EUA) for the Pfizer vaccine two years ago. First, they falsely claimed that the mRNA vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” even though basic molecular biology should have told them that mRNA in the vaccine can’t integrate into your genome, and that the mRNA vaccines were “gene therapy, not vaccines” complete with a conspiracy theory about the CDC having supposedly changed the definition of a vaccine to include them. Next came misrepresenting old studies to claim that mRNA causes cancer. More recently, long-time antivax lawyer Thomas Renz got access to the Defense Medical Epidemiology Database (DMED), a database tracking the health of military personnel, and used it to make claims that are, at best erroneous and at worst intentionally misleading, specifically that COVID-19 vaccines have resulted in an epidemic of cancer in military personnel, including a nearly 900% increase in esophageal cancer and a nearly 500% increase in breast and thyroid cancers since before the military imposed its vaccine mandate. As I explained at the time, the claims were incredible on their face just from a scientific plausibility standpoint given that we know from the nuclear bombings at Hiroshima and Nagasaki that the cancers due to the most powerful carcinogen of all, large doses of ionizing radiation, take at least two years to begin showing up (leukemias) while most solid cancers don’t show up for around 10 years. Given that the vaccines were only introduced to the general population two years ago, even if the vaccines were as powerful a carcinogen as an ionizing radiation dose from being exposed when a nuclear bomb goes off, it would be only now that we might be beginning to see a glimmer of a cancer signal for leukemias, and even then most people didn’t receive the vaccine until months or even a year later, making too soon.
“Turbo cancer”: The new wrinkle on the vaccine-cancer lie
I suspect that even antivaxxers promoting the “COVID-19 vaccine-cancer link” probably realized—or have come to realize—deep down in what remains of their hearts the utter implausibility of their claim that COVID-19 vaccines are responsible for a wave of cancer. (At least those with any actual knowledge of cancer biology and molecular biology probably do.) That’s why, as antivaxxers often due in response to science and evidence, they have been moving the goalposts over the last few months hence the claim now that COVID-19 vaccines cause what they have dubbed “turbo cancer”. For instance:
Dr Charles Hoffe ~ “As a family doctor a small percentage of cancer patients would be diagnosed with stage 4, now 2/3rds of my cancer patients are diagnosed with stage 4The tumours are bigger than ever they grow aggressively,spread very aggressively & are resistant to treatment” pic.twitter.com/tWw3rwf74f
— Janey (@_Janey_Jay) November 14, 2022
I haven’t been able to ascertain when and by whom the term “turbo cancer” was coined with respect to COVID-19 vaccines. According to Google, use of the term dates back to at least the fall 2020, where I found it in the comments of a post about the impending EUA for the Pfizer vaccine, after which a commenter sarcastically wrote on November 30, 2020, “I can’t wait for the turbo cancer”. Unsurprisingly, besides Dr. Charles Hoffe (cited in the Tweet above), the Idaho pathologist Dr. Ryan Cole (who is also known for pushing the false COVID-19 vaccine-cancer link) uses the term, as does a Swedish pathologist named Dr. Ute Kruege. Truth be told, even though the term “turbo cancer” appears to have been bubbling around the darker depths of COVID-19 antivax conspiracy social media since sometime in 2020 at least, I didn’t start seeing it used much until early this year, and it didn’t really take off to the point of entering the mainstream zeitgeist until the summer and fall. I must admit that, as propaganda, it’s a frighteningly effective phrase, which is why I feel a bit embarrassed that I haven’t addressed the claim before.
The forms of evidence used generally consist of anecdotes and a claim that there has been a huge increase in excess mortality from cancer since the vaccines rolled out. First, let’s look at typical anecdotes, which started with pathologists like Cole and Kruege claiming that they were observing a huge increase in the number of cancers they’ve been seeing, an increase that neither has apparently seen fit to publish in the scientific literature and that other pathologists do not appear to be reporting, other than on Rumble or on antivax conspiracy sites. For instance, Kreuge claims:
Doctors for Covid Ethics posted an interview with her where she shared her concerns about unusual features that have been showing up in samples from the past year.
    • Age – The average ages of the samples she received dropped, with a rise in the number of samples from people in their 30’s-50’s.
    • Size – It used to be unusual for Dr. Kruger to find a tumor 3 cm in size. In this new environment, she’s regularly seeing tumors of 4 cm, 8 cm, 10 cm, and the occasional 12 cm. In a shocking anecdote, 2 weeks ago she found a 16 cm tumor that took up an entire breast.
    • Multiple Tumors – Dr. Kruger has begun to see more cases of multiple tumors growing in the same patient, sometimes even in both breasts. She had 3 cases within 3 weeks of patients who had tumors growing in multiple organs. One had tumors in his/her breast, pancreas and lungs within months of getting vaccinated.
    • Recurrence – There has been an uptick in patients who have been in remission from their cancer for many years, suddenly getting an aggressive recurrence of their cancer shortly after vaccination.
Of course, without actual controls, this is nothing more than the anecdotal claimed experience of two pathologists, who claim to have found a huge increase in cancer in their practices and decided that correlation (which was not shown) must equal causation because to antivaxxers it has to be the vaccines that explain any increase in a disease. It’s not good evidence of even an association between the vaccines and subsequent development or progression of cancer. In any event, let’s dig into the “turbo cancer” claim.
COVID-19 vaccines and “turbo cancer”: Hematologic malignancies
What is the difference between the more mundane antivax claims that somehow the mRNA vaccines are causing cancer and the claim that they are causing “turbo cancer”? Part of the idea is that the vaccines are somehow resulting in an epidemic of unusually aggressive fast-growing cancers (hence the term “turbo”) in young people or that they are reactivating cancers that were either in remission or previously under good control in a—you guessed it—”turbo” form that rapidly grows and spreads. For instance, check out this two minute video excerpt from one of Dr. Hoffe’s talks:
The video describes the case of a patient with an angioimmunoblastic T cell lymphoma whose cancer was reported to have started growing rapidly after he received the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine, published in November 2021 by a group of investigators in Brussels. This case report is interesting for a couple of reasons. First, it’s a great example of confusing correlation with causation. Let’s quote the case report:
A 66-year-old man with no significant medical history except for hypertension, hypercholesterolemia and type 2 diabetes presented on September 1, 2021 with cervical lymphadenopathies that became recently apparent during a flu-like syndrome. The two doses of BNT162b2 mRNA vaccine had been administered, respectively, 5 and 6 months earlier in the left deltoid. Besides moderate asthenia, he did not report any constitutional symptom. Blood examination indicated a mild inflammatory syndrome, without anemia or white blood cell changes; Lymphocytes immunophenotyping was unremarkable. Protein electrophoresis and immunoglobulin levels were normal and Coombs test was negative.
A 18F-FDG PET/CT revealed multiple voluminous hypermetabolic lymphadenopathies above and below the diaphragm as well as several extra-nodal hypermetabolic lesions (Figure 1, left panel). Considering a presumptive diagnosis of stage IV lymphoma, a left cervical lymph node biopsy was performed. Pathological examination revealed residual atrophic germinal centers, surrounded by an expanded paracortical area composed of an atypical T-cell infiltrate with clear cell morphology, expressing TFH cell markers (CD3, CD4, PD1, ICOS, BCL6, CXCL13) and a loss of CD7. The paracortical area contained an increased number of high-endothelial venules, supported by an increased number of follicular dendritic cell networks, with some foci of EBV+ B-cell immunoblastic proliferation in the background (Figure 2). These features highly suggested a diagnosis of AngioImmunoblastic T cell Lymphoma (AITL), pattern 2.
So this man was diagnosed with an angioimmunoblastic T cell lymphoma six months after having received the Moderna vaccine. This particular form of lymphoma is described as a “rare, often but not always, aggressive (fast-growing) form of peripheral T-cell lymphoma (PTCL).” It’s also a disease that is almost always advanced when it is first diagnosed, either stage III or IV. Its prognosis is generally poor, with “disease relapse and infections” being “common with this cancer,” and a five year overall survival (OS) of 63% and progression-free survival (PFS) of 41% for low risk disease, which fall to an OS of 21% and 13% for high risk disease. So right off the bat, this patient had a poor prognosis at the time of diagnosis.
Here’s what happened next:
Fourteen days after the PET/CT, a booster dose of the BNT162b2 mRNA vaccine was administered in the right deltoid in preparation of the first cycle of chemotherapy. Within a few days following the vaccine booster, the patient reported noticeable swelling of right cervical lymph nodes. In order to get a baseline close to the initiation of the therapy, a second 18F-FDG PET/CT was performed 8 days after the vaccine booster administration, i.e. 22 days after the first one.
Here’s the image:

For those who haven’t seen PET scans before, the black areas are areas that take up the tracer and are therefore more metabolically active. Given that cancer cells are generally more metabolically active than normal cells, this indicates an increase in the extent of the cancer (other than the brain, which is highly metabolically active normally). Of course, just as likely, if not more so, is the possibility that the tumor was rapidly growing at the time of diagnosis and the vaccine had nothing to do with its rapid progression over 22 days. Indeed, it strains credulity that anything could cause such rapid progression in a mere eight days.
The authors speculated that the mRNA from the vaccine had gotten to the lymph nodes under the arm (axillary lymph nodes) and somehow fired up the cancer. By way of background, it is known that injection of COVID-19 vaccines in the shoulder can, because of the lymphatic drainage patterns of the arm, lead to lymphadeopathy (enlargement of the lymph nodes) under the arm, due to inflammation and immune reaction to the vaccine, a phenomenon that was soon found to interfere with the interpretation of routine screening mammograms. The authors noted that, on biopsy, the “pathological picture showed reactive benign changes with prominent germinal centers.” The authors speculated that somehow the vaccine stimulated T follicular helper (TFH) cells and somehow promoted cancer growth:
In fact, the supposed enhancing action of the vaccine on AITL neoplastic cells is fully consistent with previous observations identifying TFH cells within germinal centers as key targets of nucleoside-modified mRNA vaccines both in animals and in man (1, 2). Malignant TFH cells, the hallmark of AITH, might be especially sensitive to mRNA vaccines when they harbor the RHOA G17V mutation which was present in our case. Indeed, this mutation facilitates proliferation and activation of several signaling pathways in TFH cells (16). Furthermore, mice genetically engineered to reproduce the RHOA G17V and TET2 mutations—both were present in our case—develop lymphoma upon immunization with sheep red blood cells (16). This experimental observation is relevant to RNA vaccines as RNA of sheep red blood cells was shown to be responsible for their ability to stimulate TFH and induce germinal center reaction (17).
Antivaxxers generally do not mention that the authors also wrote that “extrapolation of the findings of this case to other patients with AITL or other peripheral T cell lymphoma involving TFH cells is premature” because “AITL patients are rare and their mutation profile is heterogeneous” and “their immune reactions might be affected by their treatment,” while concluding that, whatever the result of further studies of the effect of mRNA vaccines on AITL, “it should not affect the overall favorable benefit-risk ratio of these much-needed vaccines.” In any event, this case report did involve a lot of handwaving and speculation, which led me to ask: Have followup studies (unmentioned, of course, by antivaxxers) supported this idea?
The answer is: Not much. There’s a case report of recurrence of a primary cutaneous CD30-positive lymphoproliferative disorder following COVID-19 vaccination that doesn’t show evidence of causation. There’s also a case report of two hematologic malignancies diagnosed in the context of the mRNA vaccination campaign published in June, a case of a diffuse large B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphoma diagnosed one week after her second dose dose of the Pfizer vaccine and a case of T/NK lymphoma manifested on the third day after the initial dose of the Pfizer vaccine. The rapid sequence implies, more than anything else, that these diagnoses were likely coincidence, with the authors themselves pointing out, “The link between the two events reported is only temporal,” adding that “any clinical event, especially when associated with novel vaccines or treatments, should be reported, as this is the starting point for additional investigations of particular mechanisms of action, thus consolidating knowledge about the safety profile, to the benefit of the patients.” Overall, there is no evidence suggesting causation of hematologic malignancies by COVID-19 vaccines, and the changes in lymph nodes observed are generally benign.
There’s another anecdote, published by Roxanne Khamsi in The Atlantic (which, unfortunately, has “balanced” great pandemic reporting by Ed Yong and others with outright conspiratorial nonsense) titled “Did a famous doctor’s COVID shot make his cancer worse?” The article featured one of the patients from the case report of the angiolymphatic T-cell lymphoma report, who turned out to be Michel Goldman, described as a “Belgian immunologist and one of Europe’s best-known champions of medical research.” One thing I learned reading the article is that Goldman is rather naïve:
“I would say that 95 percent of the reactions were extremely friendly,” Michel told me later. But as he’d feared, anti-vaccine activists picked up on the story. “The lymph nodes of those who have taken these shots are exploding, burgeoning, and bulging with this toxic bioweapon,” a right-wing influencer named Jane Ruby wrote on Telegram beneath a screenshot of Michel’s CT scans, which had appeared in his published paper (and are reproduced in this article). “LYMPHOMA – That’s right… Cancer of the lymphatic system … STOP THIS FROM GETTING INTO BABIES AND CHILDREN!!!!!” Ruby’s claims were amplified on Natural News, among other anti-vaccination sites where, again, the very images that Michel’s brother had used to diagnose his illness were presented as shocking evidence of vaccination’s dangers. “PHOTOS: LYMPHOMA CANCER EXPLODING IN THE BOOSTED,” one website said.
When I told Michel about these online posts, he shook his head in disappointment. “They’re looking for anything to support their crazy vision,” he said. “It makes me sad about the world in which we are living.” That’s not to say he was surprised. Michel knew, for instance, that medical experts have dispelled false rumors about vaccines infecting people with COVID-19. He told me that he’d obsessed over getting the tone of the manuscript exactly right, so as not to fuel vaccine skepticism. He was careful, for example, to describe the vaccine as possibly “inducing” the “progression” of his cancer—rather than “causing” it to surface. “I spent hours and hours,” he said. “I’ve never spent so much time on details in a paper.”
I could have told Goldman that it wouldn’t have mattered how he and his brother phrased the case report, that it would have been used the way it was used regardless. I’ll also say that, having read the case report, I can’t honestly say that the article wasn’t written clearly enough to make it sound as though Goldman and his brother were speculating that the vaccine might have “induced” the “progression” of his tumor. Moreover, whether or not they realized it, Goldman and his brother actually handed antivaxxers another talking point to replace the antivax claim that the COVID-19 vaccines were causing cancer with a more credible-seeming claim that they were fueling “progression” of “turbo cancer” in people who already had it, particularly those whose cancers were either in remission or had been growing slowly or not at all under treatment. None of this is to say that his case report shouldn’t have been published, just that Goldman shouldn’t have been the least bit surprised by how his case report was weaponized by the antivaccine movement, particularly given this speculation that was in the paper but that I quote from the Atlantic article because it’s more layperson-friendly:
He also came across another, very important clue. In 2018, a team of researchers based at Columbia University’s Institute for Cancer Genetics had published an intriguing study using mice with a pair of gene mutations that, when they co-occur, predispose T cells to go rogue. (Michel’s tumor, which had been sequenced by this point, showed the same two mutations.) When these mice were injected with sheep red-blood cells—as an experimental stand-in for invading microbes—the animals developed the subtype of lymphoma that was diagnosed in Michel.
Now Michel had a theory to explain the bleak coincidence that had befallen him. Serge agreed that it made sense. The brothers had co-written research papers in the past, including ones on the use of stem cells for heart repair and dendritic-cell vaccines for cancer. It was time for them to write another.
Again, speculation of a link and what mechanism might account for it is not inappropriate in the scientific literature, but no one should be surprised when that link and the mechanism become antivax talking points. Goldman can go on Belgian TV all he likes and say that vaccination is safer than not being vaccinated, but he should realize that his contributing to an article like this one in The Atlantic actually undermines his message, given the bothsidesism in the reporting. While the report did correctly point out how difficult it is to report on potentially rare side effects of a vaccine, in my assessment it gave a bit too much attention to Goldman’s speculative claim, although I was very happy to see that Goldman was doing well when the article was written.
Other “theories” of causation
I will note that Goldman’s idea is not the only speculative “theory” that antivaxxers tout. For example, Ryan Cole—the Idaho pathologist whom we’ve met before spreading the claim that he’s seeing lots and lots more cancer, which he attributes to COVID-19 vaccines, of course:
According to Cole, human cells have so-called toll-like receptors (TLRs) that classify whether a foreign object in the body is harmful or not. “When the [COVID-19] shots go into the body, they turn some of these [TLRs] off. Normally, they have to be on,” he said.
The pathologist added that when the vaccines turn off some of these TLRs, the immune system’s alert mechanism is compromised as a result. TLR7 and TLR8 are in charge of detecting viruses, while TLR3 and TLR4 are responsible for keeping cancer in check.
I’ve discussed before that this is a misrepresentation of the science in that the modified RNA used in the mRNA vaccines do not change the ability of the immune system to recognize anything other than the modified mRNA:
The UK Column article claimed that the study used RNA modifications to “turn off [T]oll-like receptors”. But no such thing is described in the study by Karikó et al. The modifications and their effects are associated with the modified RNA only, and don’t change the ability of TLRs to detect other microbial components.
To use an analogy, modifying RNA is like putting on camouflage to evade detection by sentries guarding a border. But those sentries remain capable of detecting other intruders that don’t have the camouflage.
Furthermore, as Karikó et al. noted, the modifications used in the study are also observed in nature, and mammalian RNA is naturally replete with such modifications. If the article’s claim that such modifications weaken the immune system were true to begin with, then such pre-existing modifications alone would be enough to weaken the immune system even without the COVID-19 vaccines.
In short, the article misrepresented the study’s findings and is inconsistent with real-world observations.
Cole, I note, basically parrots the claim in the article cited in the excerpt above, and adds to it this claim:
Furthermore, he pointed out that the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein binds to the P53 gene – the so-called “guardian of the genome” – which suppresses tumors. The spike protein’s S1 subunit also binds to the TMPRSS-2 gene linked to prostate cancer in men and the BRCA genes linked to breast cancer in women.
“We’re giving a shot that makes a spike protein. That’s a toxin that triggers cancer genes in bad ways and turns off other pattern receptors,” Cole told the New American contributor. “We don’t know how long the immune system is suppressed after these shots and how long these receptors are shut off – because those studies aren’t done.”
p53 is indeed arguably the most important tumor suppressor gene. Genetic syndromes in which p53 function is decreased or eliminated do, in fact, lead to a vastly increased risk of a number of cancers. Where did Cole get this claim from? There is evidence that SARS-CoV-2 infection can lead to downregulation (decreased production/activity) of p53, suggesting that persistent COVID-19 infection could be a risk factor for developing cancer because of lower P53 levels detected in patients with severe COVID-19 and long COVID. There is also an in silico (computer modeling) study from 2020 suggesting that the spike protein can interact with p53.
A recent review article notes:
A direct interplay between p53 and SARS-CoV-2 has been suggested for the first time following an in silico study reporting on the ability of the S2 subunit of the virus to physically and strongly interact with p53 (Singh and Bharara Singh, 2020). In the same line, another mechanism of interaction has been highlighted in a large animal model study showing that p53 can regulate ACE2 receptor in a tissue- and sex-specific fashion (Zhang et al., 2021). It is of interest that the reported higher expression of ACE2 in females can be related to estrogens activity, and perhaps contributing to the lower disease susceptibility of females compared to males (Bonaccorsi et al., 2020). Thus, this first level of interactions between p53 and SARS-CoV-2 occurs via the modulation of ACE2 expression in a sex-related manner and via a direct interaction between the S2 subunit of the viral spike protein and p53, although the significance of this interaction has not been addressed so far. Of note, a direct regulatory activity of p53 on SARS-CoV-2 replication is a shared feature characterizing other previous coronaviruses (Ma-Lauer et al., 2016).
Note that, first, all of this, even if it pans out, says nothing about the vaccine; rather, it is about persistent SARS-CoV-2 infection, not vaccination. The vaccine only transiently produces the spike protein, which is rapidly externalized. If it weren’t externalized, then it wouldn’t be able to provoke an immune response. p53 is not just an intracellular protein, but, unlike the spike protein, is primarily an protein of the nucleus. Vaccination is transient by nature, and, even if this proposed interaction were relevant, would require prolonged interaction between spike and p53. Basically, this is antivaxxers doing what antivaxxers like to do, pulling a claim out of their nether regions and then looking for scientific studies that can be twisted to support that claim, no matter how tenuous the support, leading to headlines like this one from Mike Adams, “THE VACCINE-CANCER ATROCITY: Like clockwork, most vaccinated Americans will lose immune function by Christmas and start growing accelerated CANCER tumors that will kill them over the next ten years“.
Let’s just say that I’ll take my chances.
Excess mortality
Another claim going around to support the conspiracy theory that the vaccines are causing “turbo cancer” comes from—among other sources—the horribly self-named The Ethical Skeptic (TES). The claims coming from TES arise from his incompetent analysis of CDC provisional death statistics. I might have to go into the claims in more detail in a subsequent post, but for now let me just thank Prof. Jeffrey Morris for deconstructing these claims almost four months ago so that I don’t have to do so now, given how long this post has become.
Prof. Morris notes first:
An anonymous, apparently very experienced and prolific analytical systems modeler who is heavily followed on twitter, @EthicalSkeptic, has been modeling the publicly CDC provisional deaths by cause data for the past 6 months, and concludes from his models that a specific factor (which must not be named) in early Spring 2021 introduced an inherent change point into the data leading to increasingly high numbers of excess deaths in the USA…These posts have been very influential, with many touting them as evidence of serious harm, and others dismissing them outright. The lack of detailed documentation of the analytical steps make it difficult for others to evaluate his model and conclusions.
Unfortunately, although TES blocked me on Twitter making it hard for me to verify, this does appear to be true. In any event, Prof. Morris carefully looks at TES’s claims and finds them…lacking. First, it’s very instructive to look at one of Prof. Morris’s many graphs:

Prof. Morris observes:
We see how the the mid-2020 and early 2021 major deficits resulted in ~4k deficit cancer deaths relative to baseline since the beginning of the pandemic by spring 2021, which recovers all the way to baseline by late 2021 and reaches a maximum of ~2k excess cancer deaths by early 2022, after which it starts to decline again.
Based on these data and the proposed seasonal/annual linear baseline, there were major deficits of cumulative cancer deaths during the pandemic relative to baseline through Spring 2021, which then recovered and moved into excess territory in early 2022, with about 2k excess (which is <2 days of cancer deaths at the baseline 11.5k weekly rate).
In other words, a lot of this could be reporting artifacts, specifically delays in reporting and changes in screening due to the pandemic could explain a lot of this:
Many oncologists have stated that the delaying of cancer screenings/preventative care during the pandemic could lead to an eventual increase in cancer deaths, with cancers diagnosed later, but at a later and less treatable stage. Indeed this may occur and may be starting to occur, but is not fully apparent yet in these data.
Of course, those claiming high excess cancer deaths including @EthicalSkeptic are not considering that factor, but are claiming it is due to another “must not be named factor” starting in Spring 2021. Based on my understanding of carcinogenesis from >25 years of experience in cancer research, even after a major carcinogenic insult, I would not expect it to lead to a high number of excess cancer deaths for many years given the time it typically takes to for cancer to initiate, develop, become advanced, and lead to death even in cases of extreme established carcinogens.
In order to advance such a claim for this unnamed factor, one would need to at least have a plausible hypothesis and some evidence for how this factor could produce advanced cancers and deaths so quickly, beyond near-baseless speculation.
Prof. Morris is echoing a point that I’ve made many times. Even in the highly unlikely event that COVID-19 vaccines (or even, as I discussed above, COVID-19 itself) can somehow predispose people to cancer, this increase in cancer incidence would not be expected to manifest itself for several years. Even if the “analysis” (if you can call it that) by TES is epidemiologically appropriate (which is doubtful), it is far more likely that something else accounts for the increase in excess mortality besides COVID-19 vaccines, as much as antivaxxers do what they want to do and find a way to blame vaccines for something bad, particularly in the middle of a pandemic that has already caused so many bad things to happen and is continuing to do so.
There is no such thing as “turbo cancer”
Unsurprisingly, “turbo cancer” isn’t a thing. Oncologists don’t recognize it as a phenomenon, nor do cancer biologists, and if you search for it on PubMed, you won’t find a reference to it. Basically, it’s a clever term coined by antivaxxers to scare you into thinking that COVID-19 vaccines will give you cancer, or at least greatly increase your risk of developing cancer. The “evidence” marshaled to support the concept consists of the usual misinformation techniques used by antivaxxers: citing anecdotes, wild speculation about biological mechanisms without a firm basis in biology, and conflating correlation with causation, no matter how much one must squint to see it.
Unfortunately, “turbo cancer” is also too frightening and pithy of a term to go away any time soon. I expect antivaxxers to be using it for years to come, perhaps for the rest of my life.

Dr. William Makis and “turbo cancer”: Falsely blaming COVID-19 vaccines for cancer
A prominent oncologist and cancer biologist, Wafik El-Deiry, recently amplified claims that COVID-19 vaccines cause “turbo cancer,” wanting a “civil discourse about science and actual answers that are missing.” Unfortunately, calls for “civil discourse” by an eminent oncologist about unfounded claims only lends undeserved credibility to them. So, once more into the fray…
David Gorski on October 2, 2023
Link
There’s a line from a movie that I like to quote sometimes when I feel obligated to blog once more about a previously covered topic that I’ve become tired of. It comes from The Godfather, Part III and features aging mafia don Michael Corleone (played by Al Pacino) expressing frustration over being pulled back into the family “business” that he thought he had finished, all with an immortal line, “Just when I thought I was out…they pull me back in.” As I sit and type this, I’m feeling that same energy about claims that COVID-19 vaccines cause “turbo cancer.” Heck, I had even had an idea for a post today that had nothing to do with COVID-19 or vaccines, but, again, I’m feeling the energy of this video right now, and I go once more into the fray, particularly given that the person who pulled me back in is someone whom I never would have predicted even a few months ago, an eminent oncologist and cancer biologist whose research greatly influenced me (and whose work I used to cite a lot) when I was in graduate school in the 1990s, Prof. Wafik El-Deiry.
Before I get into the latest “turbo cancer” claims, I will note that the last time I published a post on this blog about the claim that COVID-19 vaccines somehow cause fast-growing “turbo” cancers and/or stimulate the “turbo-charged” growth of cancers in remission was late last year; so, in fairness, I guess that it is not unreasonable to write an update, even if I did do a couple of other posts over at my not-so-secret other blog in the interim. The claim has, as all dubious antivax claims do, mutated and metastasized. (What can I say? I’m a cancer surgeon and cancer biologist. I sometimes can’t resist borrowing terms from cancer to describe dubious claims, misinformation, and disinformation.) When last I discussed the concept of “turbo cancer” nine months ago, I could not ascertain when the term had been invented and who had invented it, but I did know who was promoting it, doctors like a family doctor named James Hoffe:
Dr Charles Hoffe ~ “As a family doctor a small percentage of cancer patients would be diagnosed with stage 4, now 2/3rds of my cancer patients are diagnosed with stage 4The tumours are bigger than ever they grow aggressively,spread very aggressively & are resistant to treatment” pic.twitter.com/tWw3rwf74f
— Janey (@_Janey_Jay) November 14, 2022
A physician who more recently started promoting the idea of “turbo cancer” is Dr. William Makis, a nuclear medicine radiologist who frequently misrepresents himself as an “oncologist.” I noted on his X (Twitter) feed that he appears to have taken up the “turbo cancer” banner sometime around February or March, for example:
NEWS: Canadian doctor Dr.Anil Kapoor has died suddenly on Feb.28, 2023 after a "short and courageous battle with an acute illness"
He battled with an aggressive (turbo) cancer for a month before passing away#turbocancer#diedsuddenly#cdnpoli #ableghttps://t.co/7ekxIGmAso pic.twitter.com/7qWdvuwMot
— William Makis MD (@MakisMD) March 3, 2023
Since then he’s been relentless in promoting the idea of “turbo cancer” supposedly caused by COVID-19 vaccines, for example, a few weeks ago he was claiming that “turbo cancers” were “decimating” teachers who had been forced to be vaccinated.
My uncle had the vaccine and he got run over by a turbo truck 😔
— Joel Ramirez (@JoelRam97490484) September 6, 2023
Indeed, here is a post from Dr. Makis published while I was still writing this SBM post:
It is promoting a recent article on his Substack (because of course he has a monetized Substack) entitled TURBO CANCER – Hepatobiliary System (Part 3) – Stage 4 COLON Cancer – Why are COVID-19 mRNA Vaccinated getting these types of Turbo Cancers? – 30 recent tragic cases. Unfortunately, it’s paywalled, meaning that I can’t go through it in detail. However, fortunately I have other sources to see what Makis is claiming. Unfortunately, the source that “pulled me back in,” so to speak was one that I really wish hadn’t, namely the aforementioned Dr. El-Deiry, who Tweeted/posted this over the weekend:
I watched this interview that speaks of persecution of scientists and physicians who are reporting cancers or looking into mechanisms in the setting of COVID vaccines. The concerns are about repeated boosters that ultimately dampen the very immune system they are boosting.…
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) September 30, 2023
Because Dr. El-Deiry has a blue check and the whole post won’t embed, I will cite it in its entirety, for the benefit of those of you who don’t have (or no longer have) an X/Twitter account:
I watched this interview that speaks of persecution of scientists and physicians who are reporting cancers or looking into mechanisms in the setting of COVID vaccines. The concerns are about repeated boosters that ultimately dampen the very immune system they are boosting. Description of turbo cancers sound a lot like hyperprogression and sounds awfully similar to p53 with the range of tumors among young people.
Should this be ignored or should it be investigated as part of the risk:benefit ratio for different age groups who are getting 5th and 6th booster shots 3 years into the COVID pandemic.
IS THE COVID VACCINE CAUSING TURBO CANCERS?
William @MakisMD MD a Canadian oncologist gives a 30 minute interview describing that clinical oncologists are seeing more cancers among younger people in certain professions with mandated vaccines. Breast, colon, brain, lung cancers, lymphoma and leukemia cancers. Also rare cancers such as angioimmunoblastic lymphoma, or infiltrating basiloid carcinoma. Canadian doctors, teachers, etc. He mentions a surge in go fund me pages with younger people with cancer “that we haven’t seen before.” He talks about other side effects such as sudden death or heart attacks or people too sick to work. He mentions turbo-cancers in pregnant women and young kids as young as 12. He says turbo cancers including among young people will be a long-term effect of COVID vaccination and that they are rising. He says the cancers are treatment resistant and that more research into their mechanisms would be helpful. A rise in all cause mortality among 18-24 worldwide is mentioned. It is mentioned that only 5-6% of Canadians have taken boosters in the last 6 months.
He describes in detail several possible mechanisms that could lead to cancer in susceptible individuals.1- He says the liposomal nanoparticles or LNP go systemic in the body.2- Pseudouridine modification of the mRNA vaccine which stabilizes the RNA suppresses innate immune surveillance by dampening activity of toll-like receptors.3- DNA fragments might integrate thereby disrupting tumor suppressor genes.4- Plasmid DNA may be taken up by the microbiome which can amplify it. 5- Repeated shots cause shift to IgG4 which is associated with tolerance and seems associated with more flu or repeated COVID infection.“The more doses the more damage to the immune system”The interview includes mention of@P_J_Buckhaults @Kevin_McKernan Angus Dalgleish among others.Doctors being persecuted for causing vaccine hesitancy.
It’s a sad day for science if scientists can’t ask scientific questions and are not supported to investigate them. This is not about anti-vaxx. It’s about risks among certain groups that may be more susceptible to adverse events plus general information. Are they fear-mongering or providing discussion and insight into molecular mechanisms in the tradition of science and medicine? I believe more research is needed on those whose cancers are growing faster or on material from those who die in temporal association to vaccine boosters. These may be rare events but they need to be talked about, understood and known better as potential risks. This should be done in a safe environment as part of science and medicine with no politics.
I was gobsmacked when I read this.
When an eminent scientist is a bit too trusting…
I must admit that it is very disturbing to me to see someone as eminent as Dr. El-Deiry lending his reputation built up over more than three decades actually posting a video by antivax conspiracy theorist Del Bigtree. And make no mistake, Del Bigtree has been a major antivax conspiracy theorist and misinformation spreader since at least 2016 when he produced the antivax conspiracy film VAXXED, with the godfather of the modern antivaccine movement Andrew Wakefield, who made his directorial debut with the film. His video podcast The Highwire has since served as an outlet for a relentless promotion of antivax misinformation of the worst sort. Let’s put it this way. If you appear on The Highwire with Del Bigtree, at least one of two things are true about you. You are almost certainly antivax or, as sometimes happens, you’ve made a huge mistake.
Let me also make three brief observations before I discuss Dr. Makis’s claims in more depth. First, it is, as Dr. El-Deiry observes, good to be open minded. It is not, however, good to be so open-minded that your brains fall out. His belief that scientific “truth” will always drive out the lies is painfully naive, and I would have thought that a cancer biologist who has been studying tumor suppressor genes for over three decades would recognize the dodginess of the claims being made. Apparently I was wrong. Second, the reaction to physicians and scientists who have started to spread misinform has nothing to do with “persecution.” Rather, as I like to say, it’s about quality control, not censorship. and Dr. El-Deiry’s apparent affinity for the universal narrative of conspiracy theorists, that they are being “persecuted” by nefarious forces who want to cover up some great evil, is disturbing. Finally, the video itself mentions a veritable host of doctors spreading misinformation about COVID-19 who have been on The Highwire before—whom, hilariously, Bigtree describes as “some of the greatest scientists and doctors in the world”—such as Dr. Peter McCullough, Dr. Paul Marik, and Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, all of whom are antivax conspiracy theorists. Dr. McCullough, for example, has been promoting the “died suddenly” conspiracy theory about vaccines and sells unproven supplements to treat “COVID-19 vaccine injury.” Dr. Marik is one of the founders of the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC), a group of now antivax doctors who have been selling dubious cures for COVID-19 since 2020, and Dr. Malone has become one of the most prolific spreaders of misinformation and conspiracy theories about COVID-19 vaccines since the mRNA vaccines were first announced, even before they were ever approved.
Unsurprisingly, Bigtree introduces Dr. Makis as an oncologist, a claim that Dr. El-Deiry took at face value. He’s not. He’s a nuclear medicine physician, a radiologist. His ResearchGate profile even still says that, as does this legal decision. There’s nothing wrong with that, of course. The problem is that he misrepresents himself as an oncologist. Moreover, he lost his medical license. I also note that Bigtree seems to claim that Dr. Makis invented the term “turbo cancer.” He clearly did not. As I pointed out before, it was a term being used in 2022, but Dr. Makis doesn’t seem to have glommed onto it until February or March of 2023, at least if his X/Twitter feed is any indication. I also can’t help but note that one of the studies apparently cited (there are no direct citations) showing an increase in cancer incidence among younger people ran from 1990-2019; in other words, the rise in cancer incidence predates the pandemic, but antivaxxers are misrepresenting the study as support for “turbo cancer”:
Even more hilarious, antivaxxers don't even bother to read the study, which only covers the years 1990 to 2019.😂 https://t.co/cuejD08RXl
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) September 6, 2023
Dr. Makis and “turbo cancer”
Right at the beginning of the interview, Dr. Makis relates an anecdote about a 12-year-old boy who, according to him, developed stage IV brain cancer four weeks after a single dose of the Moderna vaccine. Of course, 12-year-olds have, alas, developed horrible brain cancers since, basically, forever. Indeed, I discussed more cases of children with brain cancer than I care to remember in debunking the treatments offered by cancer quack Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski. This anecdote tells us nothing other than that Dr. Makis is prone to the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. Dr. Makis claims that he had never seen anything like this before, despite having diagnosed 20,000 cancers in his career, which makes me wonder: He’s diagnosed so many tumors but never a brain cancer in a child? Perhaps he wasn’t a pediatric doc. Various forms of brain cancer are, unfortunately, sometimes pediatric tumors. It is also true that the incidence of childhood and adolescent brain tumors has been increasing, but the increase dates to long before the pandemic and has been relatively slow and there is no evidence of a large spike since COVID-19 vaccines were recommended for children.
In any event, Dr. Makis starts out claiming that there has been an epidemic of what he calls “turbo cancer” since the COVID-19 vaccines came out, adding that oncologists “don’t know how to treat” these cancers and that after such tumors are surgically excised doctors discover that the tumor has already spread. My reaction to claims like this is that there’s a phenomenon common among antivaxxers and COVID-19 conspiracy theorists since the pandemic hit, specifically their tendency to discover a phenomenon that they hadn’t known about before and then claiming that it’s something never seen (or only very rarely seen) before the vaccines rolled out. One good example is sudden cardiac death in young people, a sad phenomenon that was identified as a syndrome 50 years ago and has long been so known that we have identified gene mutations and anatomic abnormalities that predispose to sudden cardiac death. It’s the very reason why schools require sports physicals before children and adolescents can participate in strenuous and contact sports. As I like to say: Just because it’s new to you doesn’t mean it’s new, and I repeat that to Dr. Makis, who opines about advanced breast cancers in women in their 20s and 30s, which I saw before the pandemic, most likely because I’m in a tertiary care cancer center. (Years ago, one of my colleagues, now retired, saw breast cancer in a 14 year old, which is rare.)
In addition, there is no evidence that an unusual number of people are dying of cancer since the vaccines rolled out, as a friend of the blog pointed out:
Makis is an ghoul who torments and harasses families who have lost loved ones to falsely blame their deaths on vaccines.
He is the personification of pure evil.
And you promote him on your Twitter page? Shameful.
Turbo cancer is a made up term by people like Makis to grift… pic.twitter.com/kFiBbeCBap
— The Real Truther (@thereal_truther) September 30, 2023
Next up, instead of looking at the actual medical literature, Dr. Makis looked at GoFundMe pages for young people raising funds with cancer. Shockingly, Bigtree actually noted something semi-reasonable, namely that there is no way to know how many of these people were vaccinated against COVID-19, saying that we just “assume” that. Too bad he didn’t also point out that the number of GoFundMe pages for young people raising money for treatment of advanced cancers could also correlate with a lot of other things other than actual cancer incidence (such as lack of insurance that becomes more prevalent during economic downturns, belief in alternative medicine cures (lots of Burzynski patients use GoFundMe to try to pay for his quackery), and the like. Instead, Bigtree asked rhetorical questions like, “When do we remember this many young people getting cancer at the same time?” and “When do we remember this many athletes collapsing with heart attacks?” It’s an interesting question, but more like one of selective memory. After all, there is a veritable industry of misinformation promoting these stories; so of course we “remember” them more! Dr. Makis, for his part, blames this nonexistent epidemic of “turbo cancer” on vaccines, claiming to have observed it in doctors and other professions for whom vaccines were mandated. Again, he presents no evidence other than anecdotal evidence.
This brings us to Bigtree asking about potential “mechanisms” by which mRNA vaccines could supposedly cause cancer. First up, as listed in Dr. El-Deiry’s post above as #2, Dr. Makis blames the pseudouridine base used in the vaccines. Of course, pseudouridine is used because native, unmodified mRNA has a very short half-life—minutes to hours, generally, and I know, having studied mRNA half-life for a gene that I first identified in the 1990s—which is too short to produce sufficient spike protein to result in a useful immune response. Of course, antivaxxers will exaggerate the other way and claim that the modified mRNA never goes away and keeps pumping out spike protein almost indefinitely, but that is nowhere near true. In any event, Dr. Makis cites work that pseudouridine-containing RNA can decrease the activity of proteins known as Toll-like receptors, which is in part how these modified mRNAs escape degradation by the immune system. Dr. Makis, of course, claims without evidence that the mRNA vaccines damage cancer surveillance. It’s all hand-waving, of course, based on papers that did find this but have shown no link to cancer. In brief, there is no evidence that modified mRNA “dampens the immune response” to cancer, including the 2005 paper by Kariko et al that found that the modified mRNA did dampen the immune response to…RNA!
Next up, Dr. Makis leans into the claim that the mRNA from the vaccine can be “reverse-transcribed” into the genome or that the “DNA contamination” of plasmid fragments can somehow integrate into the genome and cause insertional mutagenesis and cancer. I’ve dealt with both of these claims in detail before; so I won’t reinvent the wheel (much). For the latter claim, Bigtree plays a brief snippet of a video that I recently debunked elsewhere in which Dr. Philip Buckhaults promotes an unpublished study that hasn’t been peer-reviewed to fear monger about “contamination” of the vaccines with residual plasmid DNA from the manufacturing process. Unfortunately, last month Prof. El-Deiry found that testimony convincing as well:
For the record, Wafik is not anti-vaccine and never has been. Vaccines save lives and the COVID vaccines given to millions of people around the world have saved countless lives. As a physician, I happily received my first COVID vaccine by December of 2020. There are questions 3…
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) September 23, 2023
As for the claim that the mRNA can be “reverse-transcribed” into DNA—the dreaded cDNA coding for the evil spike protein, no less!—that “integrates” into the genome, that is a claim made a long time ago that was based on a very bad scientific study that has never been replicated. It was a very artificial system used in vitro, anyway, and it’s not as though DNA in the bloodstream hasn’t been extensively studied for a long time.
Another claim made by Dr. Makis is that this contaminating DNA can be picked up by our “gut bacteria” and alter the microbiome of those bacteria, to unknown effect. What Dr. Makis, even as he cites Philip Buckhaults and Kevin McKernan’s fear mongering about DNA “contamination,” fails to mention is that even Buckhaults’s and McKernan’s work, if you take it at face value (which, obviously, I do not), shows that the fragments of DNA in the vaccine are nearly all very small, averaging in the 100 bp range. They don’t code for anything, they can’t induce bacteria or other cells to code for anything. There is no good biological mechanism described by which they could get into the nucleus and insert themselves into the genome, and even if they could mutational mutagenesis events from such a process that could give rise to cancer would be very rare, as they would have to specifically inactivate a tumor suppressor gene or activate an oncogene. Indeed, given the multiple-hit hypothesis of cancer, it’s unlikely that just affecting one tumor suppressor or one oncogene would be enough. Multiple cancer-promoting integrations would have to happen in the same cell.
Predictably, next Dr. Makis fear mongers about the lipid nanoparticles that are used to hold the mRNA molecules and that fuse to cells in order to introduce the mRNA into them, so that their transcriptional machinery can start using the mRNA as a template to make spike protein. His concern is that the lipid nanoparticles are “unmodified” (whatever that means) and that they “go systemic.” I’ve discussed the biodistribution studies for the lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) before. You might recall that very soon after the vaccines were introduced antivaxxers began fear mongering about “sterility” and female fertility on the basis of a Japanese biodistribution study of the LNPs used in the Pfizer vaccine that found that the lipid nanoparticles did lodge in the ovaries. As I pointed out at the time, the study used a huge dose of LNPs injected intravenously, not intramuscularly (the way vaccines are injected) and then measured where in the body they ended up. Peak accumulation in the ovaries was 0.095% (or less than 1:1,000 of the total dose of lipid nanoparticle. Unsurprisingly, Dr. Makis is unable to produce any evidence even tenuously linking these LNPs to an increased risk of cancer—or even to mechanistic studies in vitro or in mice that would suggest they could cause cancer. (And, no, this study wouldn’t have counted even if Dr. Makis had mentioned it.)
Finally, Dr. Makis handwaves about “antibody shift” in which the immune system shifts to a different kind of antibody (IgG4) after repeated exposures to an antigen promoting immune tolerance for that antigen. His claim is that this “antibody shift” happens after repeated COVID-19 boosters and then predisposes to cancer, as well as to infection with a number of other pathogens. As I like to say, I am not an immunologist, but I do know that this is pure nonsense, thanks to a number of social media scientists and doctors who do know what they are talking about and have taken the time to address this claim:
Makis' trolling on IgG4 is immunologically illiterate + been addressed to death.
Evidence of harmful immunosuppression is not therehttps://t.co/63fHR5khbzhttps://t.co/FgTwS15HXrhttps://t.co/CcwZPC5NrKhttps://t.co/6bCPEp74Y6https://t.co/BQTe7NBX1xhttps://t.co/kaDGj0wu6o pic.twitter.com/i4qDmOapPQ
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) September 30, 2023
Let’s just say that the question of antibody switching and COVID-19 vaccines is far more nuanced than what Dr. Makis suggests and that there is no good evidence to support his fear mongering. Nor is there good evidence that the vaccines can cause autoimmunity:
It's just Makis + Hart disinforming again.
It's telling watching the non-expert contrarians abusing terminology like "IgG4" that they were willfully ignorant on before the pandemic.https://t.co/kcFmevlkpVhttps://t.co/CcwZPC5NrKhttps://t.co/oXd8CaGQ3ehttps://t.co/Im6E7qH4Ep pic.twitter.com/0irIlKYNY9
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) June 5, 2023
Finally, Dr. Makis dons the mantle of the persecuted brave maverick scientist—and not just about COVID-19. He claims to have treated many patients with radioisotopes as a nuclear medicine doctor. In fairness, it is true that some cancers are treated by nuclear medicine doctors with radioisotopes, Thyroid cancer, for instance, is treated with radioactive iodine, which preferentially goes to the thyroid gland. However, it’s a huge stretch to make the claim that Dr. Makis is an oncologist. Again, he is a radiologist who specializes in nuclear medicine imaging, and there’s nothing wrong with that. It’s an important specialty in oncology. What is wrong with Dr. Makis is the claim that he makes that he was “curing” 80-85% of his stage IV neuroendocrine cancer patients, but that the Canadian government shut him down for some reason because they “didn’t like the program.” He further claims that the government, after shutting him down and taking away his license, is rebuilding his program, but under government control. Somehow, given Dr. Makis’ history, I’d be more prone to believe that the government had a very good reason for shutting down his operation and stripping him of his license.
You should probably look into people before you platform them https://t.co/zpCzMWgkgi pic.twitter.com/WB4diSVHEd
— Jonathan Laxton MD, FRCPC 🐈🐱🐈‍⬛ (@dr_jon_l) April 12, 2023
Bigtree, of course, calls this “socialism,” in which the government “stole” Dr. Makis’ technology. But have no fear! His loss of license has freed him to “speak out” against “turbo cancer” and all manner of horrific “vaccine injuries”! He even claims to have found leukemias that can kill in a manner of days or even hours.
Bigtree also cites a paper co-authored by Peter McCullough (whom, as we showed before, is pure antivax conspiracy theorist) and Stephanie Seneff, who prepandemic had claimed that by 2025 GMOs and vaccines would result in all children being autistic, which, if you know the background of these claims, should be all you need to see to know that Brandolini’s law is in full effect.
For Prof. El-Deiry, this is Brandolini's law. My corrollary to Brandolini's law is that Brandolini was an optimist. It takes at least two to three orders of magnitude more energy to refute bullshit than it does to produce it. pic.twitter.com/75lzggvPwr
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) October 1, 2023
It is not about “free speech” or “persecution”
I am not saying that every scientifically reasonable concern about vaccines that have been distributed to billions of people now should not be the subject of scientific investigation. What I differ about is what constitutes a scientifically reasonable concern. To know what concerns are and are not scientifically reasonable, you have to know a few things. First, you need to know the science and potential mechanisms. Dr. Makis, unsurprisingly, claims that we are not studying these “mechanisms,” when his own discussion indicates that we have. . Second, you need to know the specific misrepresentations of science used by antivaxxers to promote fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines. Finally, contrary to Dr. El-Deiry’s claims, who is making these claims matters. I know he’s been on NIH study sections before. When grant applications are discussed, the criteria used to rank it include the qualifications and track record of the investigators, as well as the overall environment in which they work. He wouldn’t question that that should be considered for NIH applications. So why does he react so strongly to criticizing quacks and cranks like Dr. Makis based on their long track record of spreading misinformation about COVID-29 and vaccines?
Nor is it about “free speech,” as Prof. El-Deiry claims:
Are you an advocate for suppression of free speech? It’s been stated repeatedly this is not anti-vaccine and so I’ll point this out as you list pro-vax in your profile. If you are able to debate about facts, mechanisms and concerns then that would be positive. The reason the post…
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) September 30, 2023
Full quote:
Are you an advocate for suppression of free speech? It’s been stated repeatedly this is not anti-vaccine and so I’ll point this out as you list pro-vax in your profile. If you are able to debate about facts, mechanisms and concerns then that would be positive. The reason the post was made was exactly about the intimidation and persecution you’re promulgating and claims of misinformation. Personal attacks on scientists or anyone else is not constructive at all. A scientific conversation is not possible with someone with your attitude.
Nor is it about “censorship” or “repression,” as Dr. El-Deiry claims:
Is that your tactic when you disagree with someone? Just try to discredit and censor conversation?
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) September 30, 2023
Again, Dr. El-Deiry’s attitude is either willfully or just painfully naive. He is either utterly unaware of the well-funded networks that exist to spread misinformation and/or he is sympathetic to the misinformation being spread. I am having a hard time envisioning another possibility. I like to cite the famous adage from Spider-Man, “With great power comes great responsibility.” In science, I like to rephrase that somewhat to say something like, “With great scientific reputation comes great responsibility.” The bottom line is that Dr. El-Deiry has a 30-year career studying cancer, tumor suppressor genes, and, more recently, tumor immunology. He is the director of a new cancer center. I’ll just reiterate that his work in the 1990s was work that I cited often as a graduate student and researcher. When he platforms cranks—and, Dr. El-Deiry’s call for “civility” and disdain for “attacking” such “scientists” as Dr. Makis and others notwithstanding, these are cranks whose views he is platforming and presenting not as the fear mongering they are but as scientifically credible concerns that demand urgent investigation—it matters. A lot. Moreover, criticizing the views and behaviors of the likes of Dr. Makis, removing their licenses to practice, and other sanctions are not “persecution,” defamation, or “censorship” of scientific debate. They are desperately needed quality control.
I hope that Dr. El-Deiry will eventually understand that.

COVID-19 vaccine-caused “turbo cancer” nonsense just keeps getting more turbocharged
No matter how implausible it is or how weak the evidence for it is, the myth that COVID vaccines cause “turbo cancer” just won’t die. Quite the contrary, alas. Antivaxxers are—dare I say?—turbocharging it with bad science.
David Gorski on April 22, 2024
Link

As I like to bore my readers by endlessly repeating it, there’s nothing new under the sun when it comes to antivaccine misinformation. Every single antivax trope about COVID-19 vaccines that so surprised many of my colleagues when it first showed up has been directly traceable to old antivax tropes going back decades. That includes claims that vaccines somehow “permanently alter your DNA”—”homologous recombinaltion tiniker” and “molecular mimicry,” anyone?—and thereby cause a host of problems, such as autoimmune diseases and even cancer. Last week, I discussed how antivaxxers twisted a study to falsely blame COVID-19 vaccines for “accelerated aging” leading to—you guessed it!—cancer. This week, I’m going to look at some more of the “evidence” being promoted by antivaxxers as “proof” that the evil COVID-19 vaccines are killing younger people left and right by causing cancer, a 14,000% increase in “turbo cancer,” even.
Before I dig in, though, let me just remind everyone that just because in the realm of antivax disinformation “everything old is new again” with COVID-19 doesn’t mean that the COVID-19 vaccine-related versions of old antivax tropes haven’t gained new twists. In the case of the antivax claim that vaccines cause cancer, the new COVID vaccine-related twist is that the new mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines don’t just cause something as mundane as your run-of-the-mill cancers of the sort that, taken together, are the second leading cause of death after cardiovascular disease. Oh, no. They’re too awful to cause just run-of-the-mill average cancers. They’re such super-powerful magical carcinogens that they cause “turbo cancers” described by antivaxxers as cancers that develop and grow so rapidly as to be essentially untreatable or cancers, previously in remission, that spring back to life, thanks to the mRNA itself or minute quantities of contaminant plasmid DNA fragments from the plasmid used to generate the mRNA left over from the manufacturing process. Never mind that we know from the atomic bombings at Hiroshima and Nagasaki that the shortest period for the development of cancer after exposure to one of the most potent carcinogens known (ionizing radiation) is around two years for leukemias and ten years for solid cancers. In comparison, COVID-19 vaccines have only been around a little more than three years and the claims of “turbo cancers” started less than two years after they were first granted emergency use authorization (EUA). Tellingly, for the most part, it is not “turbo leukemias” being blamed on the vaccines, but “turbo” solid cancers of the type that take over 10 years to develop.
Of course, this latest “evidence dump” billed as “TURBO CANCER Literature is growing rapidly – 6 new COVID-19 Vaccine Turbo Cancer papers published in April 2024 – 26 total – the dam is breaking and it will take Pfizer & Moderna with it“) comes from disgraced and delicensed nuclear medicine doc Dr. William Makis, one of the originators and now one of the foremost promoters of the “turbo cancer” lie. I’m not going to cover all of the articles, although I note that I’ve already discussed some of them and why they are not good evidence for a link between COVID-19 vaccines and cancer, “turbo cancer” or otherwise. Part of the reason Makis’ post got my attention is because one of the studies is a preprint published by someone whom I’ve discussed before, a director of a cancer center who has demonstrated himself to be far too receptive to fancifully implausible claims of a “biological mechanism” to explain how COVID-19 vaccines can supposedly integrate into genomic DNA and thereby cause cancer, even though he should really, really know better. (Worse, he doubled down in response to even polite, respectful criticism.) I’m referring to Dr. Wafik El-Deiry, someone whom I actually quite admired back in the 1990s as a graduate student and later postdoc, indeed, from then until relatively recently, when I noticed him granting an interview to an antivax propagandist. Let’s just say that I’ll agree that the “turbo cancer” literature is growing, rather like maggots on a rotting wound of bad science.
Et tu, Dr. El-Deiry?
That Dr. William Makis is an antivax quack is a point that I’ve made multiple times here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, bringing the receipts, of course, that led me to that unfortunate conclusion. As for Prof. Wafik El-Deiry, I’ve noted before how he is an unexpected source to have been so credulous about claims of someone like Phillip Buckhauts, who has been furiously promoting claims that fragments of the SV40 promoter in the fragments of plasmid DNA left over from the vaccine manufacturing process are “integrating” with genomic DNA and causing cancer. That’s because Dr. El-Deiry is an oncologist and cancer biologist whose work influenced me as a graduate student 20 years ago and who is now the director of the Legorreta Cancer Center at Brown University. He’s been a big name in p53 research for 30 years. I hadn’t heard much from him for several months, but now apparently he’s trying to publish an article describing experiments that, well, look at the title of his preprint: SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 subunit inhibits p53 activation of p21(WAF1), TRAIL Death Receptor DR5 and MDM2 proteins in cancer cells, posted a week ago to the bioRxiv preprint server.
In fairness, one could argue that this study isn’t about the vaccine at all, but rather SARS-CoV-2 infection, and that this is just another example of an antivaxxer like Dr. Makis willfully misinterpreting a study to link it to the “turbo cancer” narrative, an example of which I just discussed last week. Maybe, although antivaxxers seem to interpret the paper otherwise, given the answers to his Tweet about the preprint:
pic.twitter.com/8Ss6GLah1l
— Nick Petosky (@pizzapicklespur) April 16, 2024
Again, this could just be antivaxxers willfully misinterpreting, but…
There’s enough evidence prove correlation- even in such short time frame. Causation has always been very difficult near impossible- one must entertain intuition, antidotal reporting. It’s trail/error but coupled with risk benefit weight. Science isn’t Algorithm friendly
— Beth McCarthy (@Cart44072Mc) April 17, 2024
Nor is science friendly to willfully confusing correlation—that actually doesn’t exist—with causation.
Before I get into the experiments, let’s just unpack some of the abstract:
Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) and COVID-19 infection has led to worsened outcomes for patients with cancer.
This is, of course, true enough, but, I suspect, not for the reasons that Dr. El-Deiry is going to argue. Rather, any severe infectious disease is going to lead to poorer outcomes for patients with cancer, if only because of the disruption of treatment and by making them sick from a cause other than the cancer. Still, do go on, Dr. El-Deiry:
SARS-CoV-2 spike protein mediates host cell infection and cell-cell fusion that causes stabilization of tumor suppressor p53 protein
Given that p53 is a tumor suppressor, the “guardian of the genome,” even, one might think that this would actually make one less susceptible to cancer; that is, if it really happens. That’s why I had to go to the actual text to see what Dr. El-Deiry meant:
An in-silico analysis using HADDOCK 2.2 software previously suggested that p53 and BRCA1/2 may interact with the heptic repeat-2 region of the S2 subunit through C-terminal domain [6]. DNA damage or therapy-induced tumor suppressor p53 protein transcriptionally activates genes leading to multiple effects preserving genome integrity, altering metabolism, immune response, cell cycle, DNA repair, cell growth and cell apoptosis to prevent or eliminate transformed cells [7]. Loss of p53 function increases the incidence of carcinogen-induced tumorigenesis and drives chemo-resistance [8]. SARS-CoV-2 infection has been found to alter p53 stabilization. The previous studies have shown that SARS-CoV-2 spike in particular plays a role to stabilize and activate p53 by mediating cell-cell fusion or induction of ROS in host cells during SARS-CoV-2 virus infection [9, 10]. In response to cellular stress, activated p53 regulates specific gene expression, including MDM2 (E3 ligase). MDM2, in turn, binds to p53 and triggers p53 ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation [11], while interruption of MDM2-p53 interaction leads to p53 stabilization. Thus, a putative interaction between SARS-CoV-2 spike, p53 and p53 related signaling pathways following SARS-CoV-2 infection could impact cellular homeostasis, tumorigenic pathways, and/or response to cancer therapeutics.
I note that the study dates back to 2020 and that I’ve previously noted that the findings of this study, even if the study pans out, said nothing about the vaccine; rather, it was about persistent SARS-CoV-2 infection, not vaccination. The vaccine only transiently produces the spike protein, which is rapidly externalized. If it weren’t externalized, then it wouldn’t be able to provoke an immune response. p53 is not just an intracellular protein, but, unlike the spike protein, is primarily a protein of the nucleus. Vaccination is transient by nature, and, even if this proposed interaction were relevant, would require prolonged interaction between spike and p53. In fairness, at this point, Dr. El-Deiry hasn’t mentioned the vaccine…yet. He’s only mentioned SARS-CoV-2 infection. Moreover, what he seems to be saying is that the spike protein activates p53, not deactivates it, the latter of which being necessary for cancer formation. In fact, almost nowhere does Dr. El-Deiry even mention the vaccine. However, where he does mention it, I think he gives the game away, as you will see.
I will also note that this preprint is a bit thin in that it only has four figures. That doesn’t mean that it’s wrong or even not good science, just that not a lot of information is there. Personally, I actually wish more journals would publish shorter, punchier papers with only one or two key findings, rather than insisting on ten-figure, many thousand word epics. Be that as it may, let’s summarize the key findings. First, however, note that we can’t describe the findings without examining the methods first, starting with the cell lines used: human lung cancer cells H460, breast cancer cells MCF7, colorectal cancer cells HCT116 (p53 wild-type or p53-null), and sarcoma cells U2OS with p53-knockout (U2OS-P53KO). One can see why he would choose some of these cell lines, particularly the ones lacking p53, if one wants to test whether SARS-CoV-2 spike protein interacts with p53. In any event, these cells were transfected with a plasmid designed to produce the S2 unit of the spike protein:
The plasmids pcDNA3.1-SARS2-spike (#145032) and p-CMV-Neo-Bam-p53wt (#16434) were obtained from Addgene.
Before I even look at the results of the experiments in which this plasmid is used, I had questions. Maybe some of my more advanced molecular biology colleagues more familiar with SARS-CoV-2 than I can help out. Even a surgeon-molecular biologist like myself knows that the SARs-CoV-2 spike protein is made of two subunits, S1 and S2. The S1 subunit contains a receptor-binding domain that recognizes and binds to the host receptor angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), while the S2 subunit mediates viral cell membrane fusion. Moreover, the inactive S protein exists as a single peptide, but is activated by cleavage into S1 and S2 by cellular proteases during infection.
If you look at the construct on the company’s website, it states that it encodes the full length spike protein, which makes me wonder: When the protein is made in cancer cells, is it processed and cleaved into its subunits S1 and S2 at its furin cleavage site the way that a normal spike protein is? The reason I ask this is because at some points in the manuscript the product made by the plasmid is described as S2, while in other parts it’s described as spike. We know that the spike protein is 1,273 amino acids in length. A virologist whom I asked about this mentioned that throughout the paper there are references to “S2 expression,” wondering whether this was just sloppy terminology or whether another reagent was used. He also wondered whether cancer cells—remember, all the cell lines used are cancer cells—can proteolytically process the S protein into S1 and S2? I don’t know the answer to that question, but if I were reviewing the paper I would require that the authors answer the question, either with the literature or with additional control experiments.
Let’s just describe what the study shows as described by its authors. The authors did an immunoprecipitation experiment, which involves using antibodies to precipitate a protein, but used a somewhat more complex version that can determine if other proteins are attached to the precipitated protein. For simple IP, in brief, an antibody (monoclonal or polyclonal) against a specific target protein is used to form an immune complex with that target in a sample, such as a cell lysate. The immune complex is then captured, or precipitated, on a beaded support to which an antibody-binding protein is immobilized (such as Protein A or G). Any proteins not precipitated on the beads are then washed away. Finally, the protein is separated from the antibody and run through a polyacrylamide gel for Western blot detection.
In brief, First, here’s a diagram describing the basic concept of immunoprecipitation (IP):
Summary of a simple IP procedure.
But what about co-precipitation? The main difference is that what is precipitated and analyzed are complexes of the two different proteins:
Protein complex immunoprecipitation (Co-IP) method. [1] Addition of antibody to protein extract. [2] Target proteins are immunoprecipitated with the antibody. [3] Coupling of antibody to beads. [4] Isolation of protein complexes. The proteins from 4 are then separated from the antibody and analyzed by Western blot.
You don’t need to know the fine details, but rather to understand the co-IP is a test to see if two proteins bind to each other and, if so, by how much. As I learned myself during graduate school and later during my fellowship research, IP can be a tricky technique, co-IP even more so. It can be influenced by a lot of things and the co-precipitation of two proteins doesn’t necessarily in and of itself demonstrate that two proteins physically interact with each other. For example, they could just be in the same subcellular fraction.
The immunoprecipitation experiments reported appear to show that there was reduced interaction between p53 and a protein called MDM2 following SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 overexpression in these cell lines. More specifically, the IP assay showed that MDM2 protein bound to p53 in the cells, while cells with “SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 subunit” overexpression displayed reduced amounts of MDM2 bound to p53 when compared to what was observed with the empty vector transfection control. In some experiments, cancer cells were exposed to cis-platinum compounds, which induce double-stranded DNA breaks and activate the DNA repair system in cells, as evidenced by increased activated p53. Since MDMs and p53 are known to interact with each other, the question of whether MDM2 actually binds to p53 itself is not so much an issue. However, what is interesting is that the paper itself shows that p53 and the S2 protein localize in different parts of the cell, and p53 does not co-preciptate with SARS-CoV-2 spike S2:
Our observations from lack of co-immunoprecipitation between p53 and the SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 protein subunit are consistent with different cellular locations of SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 and p53 in the cancer cells treated with cisplatin (Figure 1C). The immunofluorescence imaging showed that the majority of p53 was localized in the nuclei, while the majority of SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 subunit was localized in the cytoplasm in H460 cells treated with cisplatin (Figure 1C). These results do not demonstrate SARS-CoV-2-spike S2 subunit protein binding to wild-type p53 in cancer cells either in the absence or presence of cisplatin treatment. As this is a protein subunit, and some small amount of nuclear staining is observed, we cannot exclude that spike S2 can gain access to the nucleus or that intact spike could do so as well.
In additional experiments, it was shown that transfection of cells that do not express any p53 with the plasmid expressing p53 ± pcDNA3.1-SARS2-spike (the plasmid making spike) resulted in decreased transcriptional activity by p53, specifically as measured by co-transfection with a PG13-luciferase reporter gene. This particular plasmid contains 13 copies of the p53 binding site attached to the gene for luciferase. Basically, the more active p53 in a cell, the more bioluminescence will be measured. Now, I know from personal experience that these experiments are also tricky to do, but I will admit that this figure is fairly convincing that, however it does it, the presence of S2/spike does appear to decrease the activity of p53 in the cell:
#1 is the situation of wild type p53 doing what wt p53 does. #2 adds pcDNA-SARS2-spike. #3 and #4 are negative controls, S2 without p53 (#3) and no spike or p53 (#4). The reason to use a cell line that doesn’t make active p53 is so that the exogenous p53 can be controlled completely.
But what does this have to do with cancer? Well, Dr. El-Deiry takes it back to p21, one of the genes turned on by p53 whose function is to induce cell cycle arrest, and finds that p21 doesn’t increase nearly as much in response to cis-platinum chemotherapy in cells transfected with pcDNA3.1-SARS2-spike as it does in cells transfected with control empty vector even though p53 levels increase by the same amount. Similar results were shown with TRAIL Death Receptor DR5 (which contributes to apoptosis or programmed cell death), and MDM2.
So what does it all mean? Hell if I know. First of all, these studies were all done in cancer cells, not normal cells. The authors note that their results differ from other reports:
Our findings differ from previous reports that have shown that SARS-CoV-2 spike stabilized p53 and activated p53 [9, 10]. In the previous studies, the p53 activation and stabilization was caused by the spike-ACE2 mediated cell-cell fusion and an increase in ROS in cancer or normal cells [9, 10].
One of the studies cited was done in retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cells, which are not cancer cells, which could make a difference, while the other study included human tissue from postmortem examinations, but did include cancer cell lines and non-cancer cell lines. In any event, there are also a number of weaknesses in this study as well, which, in fairness, the authors acknowledge. One is a biggie:
We have not conducted in vivo experiments and some of our experiments lack additional controls such as in flow analysis or by looking at kinetics of cell cycle checkpoint regulation. We have not evaluated normal cells such as airway, muscle, immune, brain or intestinal cells. Cycling vs quiescent cells are also important to investigate for potential differential effects of spike or other SARS-CoV-2 proteins. We have not investigated immune cell interactions such as NK or T-cells in our experiments where spike S2 protein was overexpressed in culture. These would all be reasonable early future directions.
“Some of our experiments lack additional controls”? Perhaps those controls should have been done for this manuscript. Perhaps the authors should have looked at cycling versus quiescent (non growing) cells. Maybe the authors should have looked at some normal cells, such as airway, muscle, immune, brain, or intestinal cells. Perhaps in vivo mouse experiments should have been done. Maybe some of these experiments are being done for the submitted version and, for some reason, Dr. El-Deiry was anxious for as many people as possible to see this.
So far, a case can be made that this is just another paper being intentionally misinterpreted by antivaxxers as evidence for “turbo cancer.” In reality all this paper shows is that, in cell culture, it’s possible that SARS-CoV-2 infection might interfere with p53 activity. Of course, in cancers in which p53 is already inactivated or mutated, these findings would likely have little applicability. After all, p53 is already mutated and nonfunctional in these cancers. Would these findings tell us anything about how SARS-CoV-2 might affect cancer response to chemotherapy? Maybe to cis-platinum in certain cell types, but that’s about it so far. Basically, overall it’s a study in cancer cells in dishes using an artificial system in which plasmids coding the relevant proteins using a liposome-based system to introduce the DNA into the cells, after which the cells were broken open and the extracts subjected to immunoprecipitation.
Taking the most charitable view of the study, I find it mildly interesting, but far too preliminary to make much of a conclusion about and missing relevant controls, which is probably one reason why it’s a preprint rather than submitted to the high quality journals in which Dr. El-Deiry has usually published over the last 30 years. I’m not sure that it adds much to what we already know about spike protein and SARS-CoV-2 infection.
However:
Our results have implications for the biological effects of spike S2 subunit in human cells whether spike is present due to primary COVID-19 infection or due to mRNA vaccines where its expression is used to promote anti-viral immunity. A perturbed p53 pathway is concerning but also complicated in sorting out since cellular transformation and cancer are a multi-step process that evolves over time. Further detailed studies can more fully characterize the effects of spike, as well as structural determinants within the protein for interaction between the DNA damage sensing and response pathways as well as the p53 tumor suppressing pathway. With respect to the p53 pathway, further studies are needed to unravel how less MDM2 is bound to p53 in the presence of spike and the mechanisms underlying reduced p21(WAF10), TRAIL Death Receptor DR5 as well as MDM2 under conditions where there is less degradation of p53 due to reduced interaction with MDM2.
“Whether spike is present due to primary COVID-19 infection or due to mRNA vaccines where its expression is used to promote anti-viral immunity”? Antivaxxers have noticed:
yikes. Hello cancer! Bye bye p53!“As loss of p53 function is a known driver of cancer development and confers chemo-resistance, our study provides insight into cellular mechanisms by which SARS-CoV-2 spike S2 may be involved in reducing barriers to tumorigenesis during and… https://t.co/GctoFTp6km
— aussie17 (@_aussie17) April 16, 2024
“Our results have implications for the biological effects of spike S2 subunit in human cells whether spike is present due to primary COVID-19 infection or due to mRNA vaccines where its expression is used to promote anti-viral immunity…”
— aussie17 (@_aussie17) April 16, 2024
Meanwhile:
Complete loss or mutation of p53 doesn’t cause cancer immediately either in mice or humans. Similarly HPV E6 takes years to cause cervical or head and neck cancer (and there’s an effective vaccine for HPV). These things are well known. But clearly loss of p53 is associated with…
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) April 16, 2024
The rest of the Tweet:
But clearly loss of p53 is associated with cancer over time. It is a difficult area when one discusses “causes.” It’s like cause of death. There’s an immediate cause but there can be many contributing factors.We need more science and research to have a solid knowledge base and concrete plans to address risks. Research takes time, costs money, and needs to be better supported in the US to continue to have increasing impact on health, quality of life and even costs of healthcare.
So did Dr. El-Deiry mean his mention of the vaccine, which was almost a throwaway, as a dog whistle to the antivax movement blaming the COVID-19 for “turbo cancer”? Who knows? Only he can answer that for sure. I do know that, given his past history of credulity to the idea that minute amounts of contaminating DNA from the COVID-19 vaccine, SV40 in particular, cause cancer, antivaxxers were guaranteed to latch onto this paper as more evidence for “turbo cancer,” whether Dr. El-Deiry meant it that way or not.
But what about the other “evidence”?
I spent longer than I had anticipated discussing Dr. El-Deiry’s paper, mainly because it’s actual basic bench science and I don’t get to discuss basic bench science as much as I like. One other paper that I definitely haven’t discussed before was cited by Dr. Makis that I might well have to discuss, although the discussion might be done at my not-so-super secret other blog. As for the other “evidence,” it largely consists of case reports, such as this preprint (leukemia in a young woman after the second dose of the Moderna vaccine, as though young people never got leukemia before the vaccine) this paper (hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis with intravascular large B-cell lymphoma after her second dose in the presence of immunosuppression due to lupus), and this case report (Primary Cutaneous Adenoid Cystic Carcinoma in a Rare Location With an Immune Response to a BNT162b2 Vaccine), none of which actually show that the vaccine caused the cancer.
Again, I am not saying that every scientifically reasonable concern about vaccines that have been distributed to billions of people now should not be the subject of scientific investigation. What I differ about is what constitutes a scientifically reasonable concern. Dr. Makis’ “concerns” are anything but reasonable, while I’ve found Dr. El-Deiry to be either willfully or just painfully naive. Either way, he still seems utterly unaware of the well-funded networks that exist to spread misinformation and/or he is sympathetic to the misinformation being spread. Worse, his latest study doesn’t really provide any new information of value with respect to the question of whether SARS-CoV-2 infection has any effect on cancer risk or development.

Forget “turbo cancers” caused by COVID-19 vaccines. Does COVID itself cause cancer?
The Washington Post recently published an article asking if COVID-19 infection can cause cancer. Probably not, but cancer caused by a virus is more more plausible than “turbo cancer” caused by the vaccine.
David Gorski on June 10, 2024
Link

It’s long been a trope among the antivaccine movement that vaccines cause cancer, dating back to long before the pandemic. During the COVID-19 pandemic, however, this old trope mutated into a new, more aggressive form with claims arising in 2022 (as best as I can tell) that COVID-19 vaccines can cause what antivaxxers dubbed “turbo cancers,” cancers seen mainly in younger people that are unusually aggressive and more often fatal compared to “run-of-the-mill” cancers. Since then, the “turbo cancer” claim has, as cancers do, mutated and evolved to the point where there are some antivaxxers out there who, whenever they hear of a case of cancer in a celebrity, will blame the vaccine, regardless of the cancer type, how old the celebrity is, or whether the celebrity has even been vaccinated or not. In this, “turbo cancer” resembles “died suddenly,” in which it is always the COVID-19 vaccine to blame for the cancer or the sudden death, respectively, regardless of age or circumstances. COVID-19 vaccines seem to be magical that way, at least among conspiracy theorists. If you die and were ever vaccinated against COVID-19, it was the vaccines, regardless of how old you were or how bad your health might have been before death. If you develop cancer and were ever vaccinated against COVID-19, it was the vaccine.
But what about the disease itself?
COVID and cancer: Start with anecdotes
A more interesting question came up in an article in The Washington Post by Ariana Eunjung Cha entitled ‘Unusual’ cancers emerged after the pandemic. Doctors ask if covid is to blame. Of course, the idea that SARS-CoV-2 can cause cancer is somewhat more plausible than the claims that COVID-19 vaccines, in particular the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, can cause “turbo cancer”; so I was interested right away in what sort of evidence is marshaled to support the idea. I was, however, tempted to adapt Betteridge’s Law of Headlines to this article, given the implied question—without an actual question mark!—and conclude that the answer is no, but I thought I’d go through the article, do some PubMed searches, and see what I thought about the state of the evidence regarding this question. Unfortunately (although not unexpectedly) the article starts out with some oncologists sharing anecdotes, because of course it does:
Kashyap Patel looked forward to his team’s Friday lunches. All the doctors from his oncology practice would gather in the open-air courtyard under the shadow of a tall magnolia tree and catch up. The atmosphere tended to the lighthearted and optimistic. But that week, he was distressed.
It was 2021, a year into the coronavirus pandemic, and as he slid into a chair, Patel shared that he’d just seen a patient in his 40s with cholangiocarcinoma, a rare and lethal cancer of the bile ducts that typically strikes people in their 70s and 80s. Initially, there was silence, and then one colleague after another said they’d recently treated patients who had similar diagnoses. Within a year of that meeting, the office had recorded seven such cases.
“I’ve been in practice 23 years and have never seen anything like this,” Patel, CEO of Carolina Blood and Cancer Care Associates, later recalled. Asutosh Gor, another oncologist, agreed: “We were all shaken.”
There was other weirdness, too: multiple patients contending with multiple types of cancer arising almost simultaneously, and more than a dozen new cases of other rare cancers.
Increasingly, Patel was left with an unsettling thought: Could the coronavirus be inflaming the embers of cancer?
I’ve discussed so many times over the years why “personal clinical experience” of physicians and other clinicians can be profoundly misleading. My favorite go-to examples have been pediatricians like Dr. Jay Gordon, who famously cited his “personal clinical experience” as the reason why he had long before come to the conclusion that vaccines cause autism. Worse, in Dr. Gordon’s case, he was absolutely convinced that his 30 years of “personal clinical experience” trumped all the scientific and epidemiological evidence that had consistently found (and consistently continues to find) no link between vaccines and autism. There are, of course, a lot of other examples, such as oncologists who come to believe that something or other causes cancer, such as wifi or cell phones, even though the evidence does not support that. I’m not saying that Drs. Patel and Gor fall into this category; I don’t know that yet. What I am saying is that we physicians frequently forget that we are human beings who are very prone to confirmation bias, recency bias, and selective memory, which is why careful epidemiological studies and randomized controlled clinical trials came into existence to determine causes of disease and identify treatments that work.
In fairness, however, one must also emphasize that the very first step in identifying associations is often “personal clinical experience” or personal observations of a potential link. Such observations in and of themselves are almost never sufficient to conclude that there is a link between an environmental factor (such as a virus and viral infection) and a disease, but they can be hypothesis generating observations that lead to more rigorous observations that can either confirm or fail to confirm the observed association scientifically. Because associations between environmental exposures and diseases are rarely as strong and clear-cut as, for example, tobacco smoking and lung cancer, it usually takes multiple large epidemiological investigations to confirm or refute the hypothesized link between an exposure and a disease and to quantify any dose-response effect. I will also note that, in the case of the pandemic, finding or refuting a link could be very difficult given potential confounding factors given the disruptions in screening and treatment that occurred in 2020 and well into 2021, combined with trends that predated the pandemic of more younger people being diagnosed with, for example, colorectal cancer, and the expected increase in cancer diagnoses that will occur over the next 20 years just because of the aging of the population.
One thing that I always do whenever I encounter articles like this is to Google the names of the experts used as sources, as in the past I have occasionally found some glaring failures to recognize that the source interviewed was a crank. I found no evidence of this for Drs. Patel or Gor, both of whom appear to be well-respected oncologists. That being said, I was curious about the example of cholangiocarcinoma. It is indeed an uncommon cancer, although there are other risk factors besides age for this cancer, including the most potent risk factor of all primary sclerosing cholangitis (which is associated with a 10-15% lifetime risk of cholangiocarcinoma), inflammatory bowel disease, cirrhosis or chronic liver disease due to viral hepatitis or chronic alcohol use, and a few others, none of which were mentioned. Moreover, one case of a cancer in a 40-something year old that is normally diagnosed in people over 70 does not a link make, and nothing is mentioned about whether the other cases were in younger people or in people in the age range more commonly associated with cholangiocarcinoma.
COVID and cancer: Cautionary notes
The WaPo article notes, as anyone discussing this topic must note, that the hypothesis that viral infection can cause cancer is not new. Many are the examples of cancers whose risk factors include viral infection, in particular cervical cancer, which is caused by certain strains of the human papilloma virus (HPV). Similarly, viral hepatitis, particularly due to hepatitis B and C, is a major cause of liver cancer worldwide, and infection with Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV) is associated with various forms of cancer, including Burkitt lymphoma, immunoblastic lymphoma, nasopharyngeal cancer, and stomach (gastric) cancer. Indeed, the WaPo article notes that 15-20% of all cancers worldwide likely originate from infections like these and other infections.
That being said, however, WaPo notes:
But there is no real world data linking SARS-CoV-2 to cancer, and some scientists remain skeptical.
John T. Schiller, a National Institutes of Health researcher and pioneer in the study of cancer-causing viruses, said pathogens known to cause cancer persist in the body long-term. But the class of respiratory viruses that includes influenza and RSV — a family that counts the coronavirus as a member — infects a patient and then typically goes away instead of lingering and is not believed to cause cancer.
“You can never say never, but that sort of … virus does not suggest being implicated in cancers,” Schiller said.
Count me in with the skeptics…for now. That doesn’t mean that I can’t be persuaded, but it does mean that the evidence that I’m seeing so far does not convince me. Let’s take a look, and maybe you’ll see why, even though in fairness there could be other mechanisms beyond just a direct transformation of cells into cancer:
David Tuveson, director of the Cancer Center at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory and former president of the American Association for Cancer Research, said there’s no evidence the coronavirus directly transforms cells to make them cancerous. But that may not be the full story.
Tuveson said a number of small and early studies — many of which have been published within the past nine months — suggests that coronavirus infection can induce an inflammatory cascade and other responses that, in theory, could exacerbate the growth of cancer cells.
He has wondered whether it could be more akin to an environmental stressor — like tobacco, alcohol, asbestos or microplastics.
“Covid wrecks the body, and that’s where cancers can start,” Tuveson said, explaining how autopsy studies of people who died of covid-19 showed prematurely aged tissue.
It drives me crazy how, in 2024, reporters often still don’t include links to the relevant studies cited either as part of the article or by scientists interviewed for the article in the online version of news articles. Drives. Me. Crazy. There is no excuse. I wasted a fair amount of time on PubMed trying to find out which studies Dr. Tuveson was referring to, and the best I could come up with were studies showing that the virus could induce cellular senescence in the lung; e.g., this one, this one, and a few others. Senescence is the property that most normal cells have that limit the total number of cell divisions that they can undergo, after which they cease to divide and become senescent. Whether this is what Dr. Tuveson was talking about or not, I don’t know and can’t tell; so I’ll move on. (End of rant, also given that there are links to most studies in this article; I guess I was just annoyed about this one because this is a fairly general claim presented without links to studies.)
I will, however, note that chronic inflammation is usually not the sort of stimulus that causes cancer rapidly. Most cancers associated with chronic inflammation are diagnosed many years, sometimes decades, after the chronic inflammation starts; e.g., Marjolin’s ulcers, which are chronic ulcers after burn injuries that can degenerate into skin cancer, for which the mean latency after injury is 20-30 years, although one must concede that cases have been observed as soon as a few years after injury. Basically, in considering this hypothesis for COVID-19, we run into the same problem that those suggesting that COVID-19 vaccines. cause cancer run into, the fact that the pandemic is only four years old and that even the strongest carcinogens, such as ionizing radiation, generally do not cause solid tumors until a decade or more after exposure, although some hematologic malignancies can arise as little as two years after exposure. That’s why, if there’s one thing that’s true in this reporting, it’s that it will take many years to confirm or refute a link between COVID-19 infection and various cancers.
COVID and cancer: Evidence and hypotheses
First, let’s look at the current mainstream hypothesis, namely that the increase in late stage cancers has been observed since the pandemic started is likely an artifact of delayed care and delayed screening, which the WaPo article acknowledges as a possibility:
Even as the first wave of the coronavirus pummeled the United States, public health officials predicted a surge of cancer cases. A Lancet Oncology paper analyzed a national registry showing increases of Stage 4 disease — the most severe — across many cancer types in late 2020. Baptist Health Miami Cancer Institute, UC San Diego Health and other large institutions have released data showing continued increases in late-stage cancers.
Xuesong Han, scientific director of health services research at the American Cancer Society and lead author of the Lancet Oncology study, attributed the jump to people delaying or skipping care because of fears related to the virus or because of economic reasons and also to cultural factors, language barriers and discrimination. But Han acknowledged that biological mechanisms of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes covid-19, could be at play.
“I don’t have the data to support this opinion,” Han said. “But it’s an important question to follow up on.”
This is much better in that the article includes links to the actual studies. In any case, these studies (plus one in JAMA Oncology published in February that examined a nationwide cancer database) suggest that the increases observed were due to underdiagnosis of cancers, particularly early stage disease, during the time period when clinics and hospitals were closed to nonurgent cases. I’m sure that this is at least part of the story, but it it the whole story? The evidence in the article is largely mechanistic and circumstantial, as WaPo described some of the research presented at a recent symposium about COVID-19 and cancer.
For example:
The group’s loosely affiliated members are launching research studies that are trying to piece together the puzzle of coronavirus infection, long covid and cancer.
Wallace — the University of Pennsylvania scientist considered a father of the field of human mitochondrial genetics, which explores the power plants that fuel human cells — is researching how covid affects energy production in cells and how that might influence cancer vulnerability.
Separately, biodata experts are sequencing the gene profiles of organs from people who succumbed to covid and underwent autopsies.
And a University of Colorado team is studying whether covid reawakens dormant cancer cells in mice. Their provocative findings, according to a preprint report released in April, showed that when mice that were cancer survivors were infected with SARS-CoV-2, dormant cancer cells proliferated in the lungs. They saw similar results with the flu virus.
The preprint is interesting, but largely a mouse model, and I’ve learned over the years to be fairly skeptical of mouse models, at least initially. Sometimes they translate to humans; often they don’t. In fairness, the WaPo article does mention this, before moving on to other articles. Again, it’s all circumstantial:
Other studies offer telltale clues about the link between viruses and cancer.
Pathologists from the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences reported in 2021 in the journal Communications Biology that SARS-CoV-2 proteins fueled the replication of a herpesvirus considered one of the major viruses leading to cancer. Other studies have implicated the coronavirus in helping to stimulate dormant breast cancer cells.
A paper published in 2023 in the journal Biochimie explored mechanisms the coronavirus could exploit to aggravate several forms of cancer, including lung, colorectal, pancreatic and oral. Researchers suggested the most likely pathway was through disrupting the body’s ability to suppress tumors, but researchers acknowledged a lack of direct evidence to support the theory.
First off, I’m not particularly impressed with the Biochimie review article, as it really represents a lot of speculation. Particularly weak, in my opinion, was the speculation of a link with breast cancer based on, well:
The hyperglycosylated S protein of the SARS-CoV-2 gamma variant can downregulate E-cadherin expression and upregulate the levels of N-cadherin and of the Zinc finger protein SNAI1 (SNAIL), resulting in increased EMT in breast epithelia cells. This, as with NF-κB pathway activation, can cause metastasis of breast cancers [174]. In another study the correlation between inhibiting the SARS-CoV-2 receptor, ACE2, and breast cancer has been illustrated [175]. COVID-19 treatment strategies which target ACE2 contributes to a dysregulated immune system which favors cancer progression. This pro-tumorigenic state is dominated by immunosuppressive T regulatory (Treg) cells and anti-inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-10. This immunosuppressive state in group 1 or luminal A breast cancer may enable tumor cells to proliferate and metastasize to distant organs [175].
The other article on breast cancer cited comes from 2020 and is interesting, but again quite speculative, as is the article on SARS-CoV-2 reactivating replication of herpes virus, which is even more speculative. None of this means that there might not be a link between SARS-CoV-2 infection and cancer, but it’s not particularly persuasive, at least not yet, to me. Other speculation in the Biochimie review is more suggestive, such as the ability of the virus to cause pulmonary fibrosis, which is a risk factor for lung cancer.
Given all the speculation about mechanism in this paper, I was surprised to see that nothing by Dr. Wafik El-Deiry was mentioned. He’s featured in this blog before because he has been a bit too ready to believe the “turbo cancer” narrative and has blurred the line, probably unintentionally (although I’m still not sure) between his research suggesting that spike protein from the virus can interfere with the activity of p53, a tumor suppressor gene so important that it has been called the “guardian of the genome” and claims that the vaccine causes cancer. Indeed, I’m kind of surprised that he wasn’t interviewed for this article. But I digress.
I’ll also note that during my PubMed searches I found one interesting analysis published less than two months ago examining the question of whether there is an association between the three types of COVID-19 exposures (critically ill COVID-19, hospitalized COVID-19, and respiratory syndrome infection) and 33 different types of cancers in the European population using a Mendelian randomization (MR) model and found:
The results of the inverse-variance-weighted model indicated that genetic liabilities to critically ill COVID-19 had suggestive causal associations with the increased risk for HER2-positive breast cancer (odds ratio [OR] = 1.0924; p-value = 0.0116), esophageal cancer (OR = 1.0004; p-value = 0.0226), colorectal cancer (OR = 1.0010; p-value = 0.0242), stomach cancer (OR = 1.2394; p-value = 0.0331), and colon cancer (OR = 1.0006; p-value = 0.0453). The genetic liabilities to hospitalized COVID-19 had suggestive causal associations with the increased risk for HER2-positive breast cancer (OR = 1.1096; p-value = 0.0458), esophageal cancer (OR = 1.0005; p-value = 0.0440) as well as stomach cancer (OR = 1.3043; p-value = 0.0476). The genetic liabilities to SARS-CoV-2 infection had suggestive causal associations with the increased risk for stomach cancer (OR = 2.8563; p-value = 0.0019) but with the decreasing risk for head and neck cancer (OR = 0.9986, p-value = 0.0426). The causal associations of the above combinations were robust through the test of heterogeneity and pleiotropy. Together, our study indicated that COVID-19 had causal effects on cancer risk.
Let’s just say that I’m not entirely convinced that this model did indicate causal effects on cancer risk for these tumors, although I was intrigued that only the HER2-positive subtype of breast cancer showed an association. I also note that the associations were generally quite small; for example, a 9.2% increased risk of HER2-positive breast cancer (for stomach cancer, 23.9% increased risk and for esophageal and colon cancer, much less than 1% increased risk) associated with severe infection. It also doesn’t make a lot of sense that less severe COVID-19 might associate with esophageal cancer. Moreover, “statistically significant” does not equal “clinically significant. For example, I’m not even sure why they reported barely statistically significant increased risks for certain cancers of around 0.05%-0.10%. Such tiny increases could easily be due to random noise and, even if valid, would not be clinically significant. Even so, though, the numbers for other cancers, such as the 23.9% increased risk of stomach cancer, are somewhat intriguing.
The WaPo article moves on to describe the sorts of research being done to clarify whether there is a link between COVID-19 infection and cancer:
From his practice in this Southern town, Patel is conducting his own research into what he has taken to calling “an unusual pattern” of cancers. He is driven by watching patients — especially younger ones — die so quickly.
He’s looking at potential correlations between long-covid markers and unusual cancers. He has collected data from nearly 300 patients and wants to create a national registry to analyze trends. So far, his office has logged more than 15 patients with multiple cancers, more than 35 patients with rare cancers and more than 15 couples with new cancers since the pandemic began in 2020.
Patel theorizes the effects of coronavirus infections could be cumulative in people infected multiple times. Pandemic-related stress may compound the threat, he said, by exacerbating inflammation.
If a link is established between the virus and cancer, he said, doctors might identify patients at greater risk and implement screenings earlier and even put some patients on anti-inflammatory drugs.
This is all well and good, but data from a small practice like this is unlikely to be particularly informative given the small numbers of patients enrolled. Determining associations and teasing out causation versus correlation require large databases; so a national registry would be better. However, we don’t need to reinvent the wheel, given that there are already huge cancer databases, such as the SEER Database and the American College of Surgeons National Cancer Database (NCDB), which already track a number of cancer risk factors—although, as I’ve learned over the years, a frustratingly small number in some cases—could be adapted to track infections in future patients entered into the database. I also note from some minor experience that producing and maintaining such databases requires a huge amount of resources and work.
The bottom line
One bottom line that I must emphasize before discussing the science regarding cancer and COVID-19 is that there is not a shred of even mildly compelling evidence that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer, “turbo cancer” or otherwise, nor is there a plausible mechanism by which the vaccine could do this, not that these observations have stopped antivaxxers from citing this news article:
‘Unusual’ cancers emerged after the pandemic. Doctors ask if covid is to blame.—or the vaccine? https://t.co/8SFIMr7vbf
— DENNIS PATTILLO (@LUPO12345) June 8, 2024
Hmmmm….what other variable, besides Covid , aren't they looking at?I recall every single article in 2020 and 2022 specifying who was vaccinated and who wasn't.Now, in 2024, there's vaccine amnesia.#VaccineAmnesia https://t.co/EHmh0s8seV
— Nancy Vera (@TheCubanNancy) June 7, 2024
This is in both the NYPost and WaPo today.The Post mentions possible implication of vaccines, WaPo denies this.Neither is denying an increase in cancer.https://t.co/V0TRchDZIl https://t.co/jcPGigVXYB
— Pilgrim😎 (@villagerssn) June 7, 2024
Leave it to the NY Post to add to its secondary reporting of a WaPo article a couple of paragraphs falsely trying to blame the vaccines, even though the WaPo article quoted a scientist explicitly saying that there’s no scientific reason to say it was the vaccines, while featuring a photo of a nurse taking care of a critically ill patient in an ICU. Antivaxxers gonna antivax, I guess.
But back to the question of COVID-19 infection itself and vaccines.
My perspective after having read the WaPo article and done a perusal of the recent scientific literature is that it is certainly possible that COVID-19 infection could predispose to certain kinds of cancers. It might even reawaken dormant cancer cells in cancer survivors. However, the evidence thus far is only mildly suggestive, to me at least, and, truth be told, to most virologists and cancer biologists. It could well be a case of a confounder such as delays in cancer screening and treatment. Indeed a number of oncologists and cancer researchers predicted that delays in screening and treatment due to the early pandemic might result in an increase in cancer cases over the next few years, as the system caught up with the delays. Again, it will take years of research to tease out what is or is not happening with respect to cancer prevalence and whether it is linked to COVID-19 infection, and it will be difficult to separate effects of COVID-19 from confounders, such as the pre-pandemic increasing incidence of cancers (e.g., colorectal) cancer in younger people and the expected increase in cancer prevalence just because the median age of the population in developed countries is continuing to increase.
Unfortunately, WaPo couldn’t resist a very annoying journalistic trope. Remember how the article started with a group of oncologists sharing anecdotes and speculating over whether COVID-19 was causing an increase in incidence of rare cancers and multiple cancers? Well, the article is bookended with an anecdote:
Then there’s Bob and Bonnie Krall, a couple who in a 14-month stretch endured three types of cancer between them, despite neither having a family history or genetic predisposition.
You know where this is going next:
Cancers typically start in one part of the body and spread. It’s rare for discrete cancers to begin in different parts of the body during a short window of time. Patel said the Kralls and the 78-year-old had coronavirus antibodies “through the roof” in their blood although he’s not sure how that relates to cancer, if at all.
Patel met the Kralls in 2022 when Bob was diagnosed with chronic lymphocytic leukemia, a cancer of the blood and bone marrow. During one of her husband’s treatments, Bonnie mentioned she was dealing with her own health issues related to long covid, including stomach pain. Medications weren’t helping. Patel ran tests and discovered Bonnie had cancer, too. By the time she was scheduled for surgery a few weeks after diagnosis, the malignancy in her abdomen had grown three more centimeters and weighed 8.5 pounds. This year, Bob’s doctors found cancer in his lungs.
I hate to hear of cases like these, and I wish the Kralls nothing but good fortune (and, of course, response to therapy) in their battle with their cancers. Unfortunately, though, Cha used their case to make the speculation about COVID-19 and cancer feel much more believable to a lay public, more so than current scientific evidence would suggest:
Bob’s blood cancer, CLL, is considered rare with only four or five cases in every 100,000 people, but he has been surprised to find four of his neighbors and friends have it, too.
“It’s like a cold. It seems like everyone has it,” said Bob, 73, a flight instructor.
Even before Patel mentioned his research, Bonnie, 74, who used to work part-time as a front desk assistant and lives with her husband in Fort Mill, S.C., had wondered whether their cancers were related to the coronavirus. She was infected shortly before her cancer diagnosis.
“Maybe if we didn’t get covid …” she started before trailing off. Bob shrugged and finished for her. “Maybe we would have been better? Maybe we would have been worse.”
Notice the implication that “everybody’s getting” this particular rare cancer and it therefore is likely to be due to COVID-19. Maybe. Maybe not. We don’t even know that “everyone has it”—or even that way more people “have it” than before 2020. This is all purely anecdotal and a very annoying journalistic trope that I’ve seen over and over and over that, in the name of providing “human interest” to a story, actually undermines the reporting by presenting human beings who are suffering as examples suggesting a phenomenon that might very well not be real. The same thing was routinely done in stories about vaccines and autism. Of course, this is not a case of a hypothesis that’s been long falsified, like the claim that vaccines cause autism, but it does give undue credence to one side of the controversy.
Over the next few years, I fully expect the evidence base to grow and the science to be done that will clarify if there really is an association between cancer risk and COVID-19 infection, repeat COVID-19 infections, or long COVID. Right now, I am agnostic regarding such a link. It is not implausible that such a link might exist between COVID-19 and elevated risk of certain cancers. I’m just hoping that in a couple of years I can revisit this topic and have a more definitive answer one way or the other.

Quoth Myrna Mantaring: “US government data” confirms a “143,233% increase in cancer cases due to COVID vaccination”? I answer with a plea for math-based reality checks.
Myrna Mattaring, a retired scientist who worked in diagnostic labs, claims that COVID-19 vaccines caused a 1432% increase in cancer cases, a clearly impossible claim. Here I make a plea for examining such claims, including a much more famous and accepted one, with basic math.
David Gorski on September 3, 2024
Link

If there’s a lesson that I’ve learned about the claims of cranks, quacks, and pseudoscientists, it’s that too much is never enough in terms of their hyperbolic claims. For example, with respect to COVID-19 vaccines and cancer, it wasn’t enough just to falsely claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer. Oh, no. They had to cause “turbo cancers,” cancers so much nastier, fatal, and prone to appearing in younger people than regular boring, run-of-the-mill cancers. Nor is it enough to say that the vaccines have caused the incidence of cancer merely to have doubled or tripled—or even quadrupled—any of which, if true and provable with statistics and epidemiology linking vaccination to cancers, would be alarming enough. That’s not enough for cranks. Oh, no. Behold the latest claim from Myrna Mantaring, MT, MCI, MS, MBA, CLSp MB (ASCP), who “has more than 50 years of experience in the fields of Diagnostic and Research Laboratory Technology, Microbiology, Immunology, and Molecular Biology” (but apparently none in epidemiology), who has appeared with antivaxxer Polly Tommey (buddy of Andrew Wakefield) on CHD.TV to claim that there has been a “143,233% increase in cancers due to COVID vaccination” in the US:
"The increase in cancer, according to the latest report, the US government data confirms [a] 143,233% increase in cancer cases due to COVID vaccination. That's unreal. But it's true."Myrna Mantaring, MT, MCI, MS, MBA, CLSp MB (ASCP), who has more than 50 years of experience in… pic.twitter.com/kzDcuHDb9c
— Sense Receptor (@SenseReceptor) August 18, 2024
“US government data”? Which “US government data”?
Amusingly, even some antivaxxers are responding with “WTF?”:
I don't think the increase is that high.
— My Dog Is Fat (Fat Dog Acceptance Movement) (@CypressXMX) August 18, 2024
“I don’t think the increase is that high” is a hilarious understatement.
Interestingly enough, the video of Polly Tommey interviewing Myrna Mantaring was first posted on CHD.TV on August 14 under The People’s Study but it didn’t appear to start gaining much traction until last week, when The Lioness of Judah posted a link to the video on their popular conspiracy Substack, Exposing the Darkness, having shown up on—where else?—Rumble.
The money quote that all the sources amplifying this video cite is this:
The increase in cancer, according to the latest report, the US government data confirms [a] 143,233% increase in cancer cases due to COVID vaccination. That’s unreal. But it’s true.
Big, if true.
Actually, Mantaring was right the first time, when she categorized it as “unreal.” But who, pray tell, is Myrna Mantaring? Her history, as described as follows. From 2005 to 2015 she served as a military hospital’s health science administrator and research-technology laboratory manager. (Note that the hospital is not named.) From 2015 until her retirement in 2021, she also worked as a clinical-diagnostic laboratory manager for the same hospital’s department of nephrology. Again, these are not really qualifications that I would associate with the ability to be able to parse and analyze “US government data” regarding COVID-19 vaccination and cancer, much less to conclude that COVID vaccines had caused a 1,423.33-fold increase in cancer cases when even a quack like William “turbo cancer” Makis doesn’t make such a claim.
So why write about a fringe claim that is clearly absolute bollocks (as my British friends would put it)? I would argue that it’s worth my attention for the same reason that writing about Dr. Marty Makary’s bogus “estimate” that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US, namely to examine such factoids under the lens of critical thinking and basic mathematical literacy. The main difference between the two is that Makary’s estimate became so widely believed that I keep seeing it pop up, mentioned as an accepted factoid, even in ostensibly evidence- and science-based sources, like John Oliver’s This Week Tonight. It doesn’t even matter that, like Mantaring’s estimate, it doesn’t even pass the “smell test” in terms of being plausible from a strictly mathematical standpoint, although, admittedly, it is more plausible than Mantaring by a lot.
Here’s what I mean.
Makary’s estimate in 2016 was that that over 251,000 people a year were dying in hospitals as a result of medical errors. According to the CDC, in 2010 only 715,000 of US deaths occurred in hospitals, implying that, if Makary’s estimate were accurate, then 35% of inpatient deaths are due to medical errors. It was worse than that, though, because Makary’s upper estimate was 400,000 inpatient deaths due to medical error. That was 56%—yes, 56%—of all inpatient deaths! As I said at the time It wasn’t anywhere near plausible that somewhere between one-third to over one-half of all inpatient deaths in the US were due to medical error. It just wasn’t, unless you’re a conspiracy theorist of the type who believes that hospitals were intentionally killing COVID-19 patients through their protocols. Of course, Makary’s estimate, based as it was on unjustified extrapolation from small studies that used an overly broad definition of death by medical error, was just low enough to seem plausible if you didn’t look too closely at the numbers and didn’t compare them to known statistics.
Now, let’s do the same thing with Myrna Mantaring’s estimates. To do that, I head over to the CDC’s website and look at the incidence of new cancer cases by year:
There are a couple of things right here that we can look at. First, note that the trend in new cancer cases per 100,000 population is actually slowly declining. Now, let’s look at the numbers for the year 2020, given that COVID-19 vaccines didn’t receive emergency use authorization (EUA) until December of that year and mass vaccination didn’t really take off until early 2021. According to the accompanying data table, the models rate in 2021 (which I use because the actual rate was lower due to disruptions in screening and patient care due to the pandemic in 2020) was 447.5 per 100,000. Now, if Mantaring were correct and the incidence of new cancer cases increased 143,233% due to COVID-19 vaccines, it’s a simple matter to see what that would look like by multiplying 447.5 by the 1,432.33-fold increase claimed by Mantaring. If you do that, you’ll quickly come up with an estimate for incidence of new cancer diagnoses per year of 640, 968 per 100,000, or more than 6.4 times what is possible. That Mantaring didn’t do that sort of basic plausibility check on her number tells me all I need to know about her.
Moreover, even if you accept the idea of “turbo cancer,” in which COVID-19 vaccines are supposedly so carcinogenic that they can cause cancer faster than ionizing radiation (two to ten years, depending on the specific malignancy), you would expect to have started seeing the trend in the numbers by 2022 at least, and the trend couldn’t be the least bit subtle if we were going to achieve the mass death from cancer estimated by Mantaring by this year. Basically, like Makary’s estimate, Mantaring’s estimate doesn’t pass the basic smell test, but even more obviously. Truly, mathematical literacy is not a characteristic of cranks, although at least Makary didn’t produce a number higher than was physically even possible.
Watching the video, I looked for an explanation for how Mantaring came up with her estimate. I was amused by her introduction. Tommey wanted to talk about Mantaring’s sister, but Mantaring wanted to list her credentials, none of which were particularly relevant to her overarching claim regarding cancer. She also pointedly mentioned that when the pandemic hit in March 2020 she was considered an “essential employee” and came to work every day, which is also fairly irrelevant given that it would be expected that laboratory personnel responsible for doing lab tests in a hospital can’t do their jobs remotely. But she did start “following all news, seminars, symposia, and investigations related to the pandemic, the early treatment, the development and approval of the gene-based vaccine, as well as the CDC reporting system.” Impressive, if true, given that the sheer volume of “news, seminars, symposia, and investigations” described would have been beyond the ability of one person to follow them all while doing her job, which more and more sounds like more of a laboratory technician than an investigative scientist.
Of course, because Mantaring performed PCR diagnostics of viral diseases, she claims that she was immediately able to “recognize the government’s continuing fraud and deception in their COVID-19 testing and vaccine policies,” which she characterized as “crimes against humanity” and part of the “World Economic Forum’s diabolical new world agenda.” She also mentions how “fetal cell lines” were used in the manufacture of the vaccines, a longstanding antivax trope that seeks to weaponize religious objections about abortion to sow disgust about vaccines, while going on about the “limited safety data” and supposedly rushed testing—and this all in the first three minutes of the video!
I wasn’t really interested in going over the same old, same old antivax tropes about COVID-19 vaccines, nearly all of which Mantaring hit at one time or another, along with “early treatment protocols” about hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin, which she urged her family and friends not to take the vaccine but to use these repurposed drugs, which do not work. Unsurprisingly, she states that the reason she retired in 2021 was to avoid mandatory COVID-19 vaccination at her job. That is why I basically listened to the video in the background, waiting for something—anything—describing how she had come up with her ridiculously implausible estimate for such a massive increase in cancer incidence being linked to the COVID-19 vaccines.
I did learn, however, that Mantaring’s sister in Toronto was diagnosed with sarcomatoid urothelial carcinoma, a rare and aggressive cancer of the bladder, “after being fully vaccinated and boostered as mandated by the vaccine passport per the Trudeau government.” Sadly, she couldn’t tolerate the preoperative chemotherapy and was scheduled for surgery in April 2022, at which point it had invaded the uterus and surrounding bowel, requiring more extensive surgery. Eventually it spread to the liver, and her sister died from her disease, seven months from diagnosis. While this is a tragic story, it is not unusual for a cancer like this one, which is aggressive. After this, Mantaring claims that her sister’s story confirmed for her what she had been hearing from people in her circle about cancer in vaccinated people, leading her to go on and on about how spike protein supposedly causes cancer, facilitated by its also causing “vaccine-acquired immune deficiency,” a nonexistent syndrome that antivaxxers like to call VAIDS.
So I listened to the video, wondering if there was any more than the quotes about cancer from COVID vaccines that had been highlighted by The Lioness of Judah and various antivaxxers on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, and other social media, other than this in response to a question about Tommey why the public “fell in line with” and “obeyed” government vaccine mandates “without thinking” (of course—sheeple!):
Because they trusted the government. They would not think that the government will lie to them. And it’s also a belief that a sophisticated form of medicine from big pharma, no less, big names—Pfizer, AstraZeneca, J&J—you would think, they would have no second thoughts. But what triggered my suspicion was, coming from an immunology background and working in an immunization clinic, we don’t do this. We don’t push out a vaccine with less than a year of trials.
Actually, in a pandemic, we do, and the testing was adequate. Elsewhere, she asks:
How can a government people trust lie to them?
Good question, but few are the people who trust the government never to lie, particularly in our current political climate.
At this point, I was getting tired; so I’m just going to come around to the punchline. Myrna Mantaring doesn’t present any evidence to support her claim that as a result of COVID-19 vaccination cancer cases have increased by 143,233%, other than referring to unnamed and undescribed US government data. Her entire argument on this point boils down to basically, “Trust me, bro.” No, seriously. She doesn’t even show graphs or charts. Even cranks as cranky as William Makis show graphs and charts. They might be poorly conceived, designed, and analyzed graphs and charts, but they are at least an attempt to show evidence. From Mantaring, we get nothing.
It’s worse than that. With a little help from a reader, I was made aware of the origin of the “143,233% increase” in cancer claim, and it’s about what you might have predicted. First, it’s not a new figure. In fact, it’s older than even I had suspected. It comes from a conspiracy website called The Exposé, started in 2020 by a British welder named Jonathan Allen-Walker, and an article published there in August 2022 entitled U.S. Government data confirms a 143,233% increase in Cancer cases due to COVID Vaccination. The analysis involved the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS), because of course it did. Basically, the anonymous author of the article examined cancer-related reports to VAERS related to flu vaccines administered from 2008 to 2020 and COVID-19 vaccines administered between December 2020 and August 2022, and came up with this graph:
I’ve explained more times than I can remember why VAERS is not reliable when it comes to estimating population prevalence of a given condition or for linking that condition to vaccines, given the base rate fallacy and thus don’t know the base rate of the given condition to compare the VAERS data to. Moreover, after the release of COVID-19 vaccines, for the first time ever, the CDC publicized VAERS and encouraged reporting adverse events to it, which, to the surprise of no one familiar with VAERS, led to a huge spike in reports of adverse events related to COVID-19 vaccines. Again, this number fails a basic plausibility test, and only the mathematically illiterate would take such an estimate seriously.
As I reach the end, again one might wonder: Why did I bother? Myrna Mantaring is so obviously off the deep end that it seems pointless to discuss a clearly and obviously fantastical estimate for how much COVID-19 vaccines supposedly increase the number of cancer diagnoses. I bothered because, for one thing, to most people it’s not obvious that her estimate is so obviously off the deep end and mathematically impossible. To know that takes background knowledge. For example, just look at some of the responses in The Lioness of Judah’s comments after one commenter suggests that there’s no way the increase is this high, even though that commenter seems clearly to believe that COVID-19 vaccines contribute to cancer:
You get the idea.
In the end, I wrote about this as a basic plea to do a reality check whenever you see a figure that seems implausible or inflated. With Mantaring’s estimate, it’s really easy, which is why I chose it, much the same way that I like to use homeopathy as an example of extreme implausibility. All you have to do is to look up cancer incidence statistics and then see if what she is claiming is even possible. (It isn’t.) For a claim like Marty Makary’s “third leading cause of death” claim about medical errors, it’s trickier. First, you have to parse his claim a bit and realize that it’s only about in-hospital deaths, not all deaths. Then you have to look up the statistics for how many people die in hospitals in the US every year, so that you have something to compare to. Doing that, you will see that, while Makary’s estimate of 250K to 400K deaths due to medical errors in hospitals is possible, it is incredibly implausible that such a high percentage of deaths in hospitals are due to medical errors. If you want to go further, you can then compare Makary’s number to total deaths in the US every year. If you do so, you’ll find that it’s also pretty darned implausible there too, given that at the time there were estimated to be 2.6 million deaths per year in the US; Makary’s estimate would imply that medical errors cause between 10% and 15% of all deaths every year. Even that comparison tells you how implausible Makary’s numbers were; yet almost no one pointed this out, andhis “third leading cause of death” factoid became so ubiquitous that even other ostensibly reason-based sources routinely cite it.
Skepticism and critical thinking are your friends, and I hope that this little exercise, even carried out on an estimate from an obvious crank whose argument boils down to “trust me, bro” inspires you to apply such methods to any numbers-based claim that doesn’t sound plausible or correct. Now, if only the press and many of my medical colleagues who still parrot Makary’s figure would do the same thing.

The opposite of “turbo cancer”: COVID-19 vaccines sensitize cancer to immunotherapy
A new preliminary study published in Nature suggests that COVID-19 vaccines might actually boost the immune system to make immunotherapy more effective. If confirmed in followup studies, this result suggests that the vaccines do the opposite of causing “turbo cancer.”
David Gorski on October 27, 2025
Link

I’m so very, very tired of writing about the devastation that our Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is wreaking on our federal public health apparatus, including the National Institutes of Health, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the Food and Drug Administration. On the other hand, it seems well nigh impossible these days to write about some cool science without acknowledging this backdrop, which is one reason why I found a study published last week in Nature fascinating and the reaction to the study by antivaxxers rather typical.
The study is entitled SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccines sensitize tumours to immune checkpoint blockade, and its first author is Adam J. Grippin, with its corresponding author being Steven Lin. The key takeaway point from the study is that patients treated with immunotherapy, specifically immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs), who had been vaccinated against COVID-19 with one of the mRNA vaccines within 100 days of initiating therapy with ICIs survived longer than those who had not. Looking at this finding in retrospective data, the authors tested the hypothesis that COVID-19 mRNA vaccines sensitize tumors to ICI therapy and found the same effect in mice, allowing them to do additional preclinical studies that suggest a potential mechanism for the effect. If this effect holds up in subsequent studies, it suggests that, far from causing “turbo cancers,” COVID-19 vaccines might actually prime the immune system against “immunologically cold” cancers, an effect that potentiates the action of ICIs.
Before I dig into the study itself, let’s look at ICIs and how they have revolutionized cancer therapy. I’ll use an example from my specialty, breast cancer, to look at how ICIs are now used to treat a specific subtype of breast cancer known as triple-negative.
Immune checkpoint inhibitors
One of the most important discoveries in cancer therapy in the last couple of decades has been the targeting of immune checkpoints with a class of humanized monoclonal antibodies that, as a class, are now referred to as immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs). The existence of immune checkpoints was discovered in the 1990s by Tasuko Honjo, and Jim Allison, Ph.D. Allison observed that T-cells are controlled by a safety mechanism or “brake,” specifically a negative immune checkpoint protein called cytotoxic T-lymphocyte–associated protein 4 (CTLA-4). T-cells are usually “turned on” by a cell called an antigen-presenting cell, which has a targeted antigen bound to one of a class of proteins from the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) via the T-cell receptor (TCR). This binding results in the activation of the T-cell to attack cells that have the antigen that had been presented to it, such as a cancer cell. Such an activated T-cell is known as an antigen-specific T-cell.
When CTLA-4, which is found on the surface of T-cells is activated by binding to a protein known as B7, this interaction works to turn T-cell off, preventing it from becoming an antigen-specific T-cell and attacking its targeted cells, including cancer cells, keeping the T-cell in an inactive (non-killing) state. Physiologically, this is useful mechanism to prevent overactivation of the immune system that could cause excessive damage to surrounding normal tissue. Of course, cancers are very good at evolving strategies to subvert natural physiological mechanisms (like angiogenesis—stimulating the ingrowth of new blood vessels to supply their need for oxygen and nutrients—for example) to their own advantage, and, not unexpectedly in retrospect, some cancers have evolved ways of activating these immune checkpoints, thus tamping down the immune response that might otherwise have targeted the invading cancer cells. After his discovery, Allison was able to block CTLA-4, which freed the T-cells stopped from working at the immune checkpoint to resume working normally and eliminate cancer in laboratory mice.
Here’s a useful illustration from the National Cancer Institute:
During the same decade, Honjo was studying what is now the most commonly targeted immune checkpoint inhibitor protein duo, the programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1)/Programmed Cell Death Ligand 1 (PD-L1) system. In this system, PD-1 is the ICI that is expressed not he surface of T-cells, and PD-L1 binds to PD-1 to inhibit T-cell activation. Again, from the NCI, here’s a diagram showing how this system works and how it can be inhibited:
Again, unsurprisingly, some cancer cells express PD-L1, which allows them to activate immune checkpoint inhibition and dial down the T-cell response against them, while blocking the binding of PD-1 and PD-L1, with monoclonal antibodies to either has proven to be an effective strategy to reverse the negative immunomodulation that tumor cells can use to evade the body’s immune responses to them. So important have the discovery of immune checkpoints and how immune checkpoint inhibition can be used to effectively treat a growing number of cancers been to cancer research that in 2018 the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine was awarded jointly to James Allison and Tasuku Honjo “for their discovery of cancer therapy by inhibition of negative immune regulation.”
Of course, my description of how immune checkpoints work and how immune checkpoint inhibitors can be used to treat cancer is, by necessity, very basic. It’s way complicated than the above, but for purposes of my discussion, what I’ve described will have to suffice. After all, thousands of papers and many book chapters have been written about the mechanisms of immune checkpoints and their inhibition, as well as strategies to treat cancer using immune checkpoint inhibition. Since the initial discovery of immune checkpoint inhibitors, immune checkpoint inhibition has been found to be effective in a number of kinds of cancer, including but not limited to:
    • Bladder cancer
    • Breast Cancer
    • Head and neck cancers
    • Hodgkin lymphoma
    • Kidney cancer
    • Melanoma
    • Non-small cell lung cancer
In my field of specialty, breast cancer, the immune checkpoint inhibitor pembrolizumab (trade name Keytruda) has revolutionized the treatment of the deadly subtype of breast cancer known as “triple-negative” breast cancer (TNBC) as a result of the KEYNOTE-522 trial. In this trial, pembrolizumab was combined with chemotherapy treatment before surgery, the combination resulting in a much higher rate of pathological complete response (pCR, no viable tumor seen in the surgical resection specimen) than standard chemotherapy alone. Indeed, the pCR rate was 65% in the experimental group, which was higher than ever observed for TNBC before. This result translated to a significant improvement in overall survival. After the reporting of the results of KEYNOTE-522 in 2020, almost overnight the standard of care for TNBC changed to immune checkpoint inhibitors plus chemotherapy. This is but one example of the power of ICIs.
COVID-19 vaccination and ICIs
Last week, Adam Grippin and colleagues presented their results at the European Society for Medical Oncology Congress in Berlin, and soon after their results were published in Nature. Although this was a retrospective study and not a prospective randomized controlled trial, the results were striking and very promising. In a commentary in The Scientist Grippin and colleagues explain their rationale in lay language:
The COVID-19 mRNA-based vaccines that saved 2.5 million lives globally during the pandemic could help spark the immune system to fight cancer.1 This is the surprising takeaway of a new study that we and our colleagues published in the journal Nature.2
While developing mRNA vaccines for patients with brain tumors in 2016, our team, led by pediatric oncologist Elias Sayour, discovered that mRNA can train immune systems to kill tumors – even if the mRNA is not related to cancer.3
Based on this finding, we hypothesized that mRNA vaccines designed to target the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes COVID-19 might also have antitumor effects.
So we looked at clinical outcomes for more than 1,000 late-stage melanoma and lung cancer patients treated with a type of immunotherapy called immune checkpoint inhibitors.4 This treatment is a common approach doctors use to train the immune system to kill cancer. It does this by blocking a protein that tumor cells make to turn off immune cells, enabling the immune system to continue killing cancer.
In brief, Grippin et al carried out a non-interventional, retrospective review of patient data using the MDACC electronic health record system, which contains a record of the patients who are treated at the primary campus of the University of Texas-MD Anderson Cancer Canter, examining patients with melanoma and lung cancer thusly:
The chart review for this study involved three groups of patients: (1) patients with tumour biopsies confirming stage III or stage IV NSCLC [non-small cell lung cancer] between January 2017 and September 2022; (2) patients with melanoma of any stage who received single- or multi-agent immune checkpoint blockade between January 2019 and December 2022; and (3) a tissue-agnostic cohort, which included all patients with pathology results for PD-L1 from January 2020 to October 2023 at our institution across a wide range of histologies.
And:
Patients were separated into two groups: (1) patients who received a COVID-19 mRNA vaccination within 100 days of ICI start; and (2) patients who did not receive a COVID-19 vaccination. Survival analysis was performed using these groups, with subanalysis involving staging of the tumour, brand of mRNA vaccine, number of doses of the COVID-19 vaccine, location of metastases and cycle of immunotherapy.
The authors did their best to control for as many confounders as they could. Indeed, from an interview for Science:
Grippin says he and his colleagues “utilized as many statistical approaches as we could” to account for potential confounding factors, but the association between improved survival rates and COVID-19 vaccines persisted. Patients who received non-mRNA vaccines for influenza and pneumonia, for example, didn’t do better than the average immunotherapy patient.
But how much was the increase in overall survival observed in the patients who had received at least one COVID-19 vaccination within 100 days of starting immune checkpoint inhibitor therapy for their cancer? As I like to say, a picture is worth the proverbial thousand words:
CAPTION: a–e, Survival for patients with NSCLC (a–c) or metastatic melanoma (d,e) treated with ICI who received a COVID-19 mRNA vaccine within 100 days of initiating ICI or did not receive a COVID-19 mRNA vaccine. Survival is shown for all patients with NSCLC (a), patients with unresectable stage III NSCLC (b), patients with stage IV NSCLC (c) and patients with metastatic melanoma (d and e). P values and HRadj were calculated using two-sided Cox proportional hazards regression (Supplementary Tables 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11), including all variables that were significantly associated with survival on univariable analysis (Supplementary Tables 2, 4, 6, 8 and 10). The number of patients at risk at each timepoint is indicated below each graph.
Or, to put it in verbiage:
After controlling for 39 covariables with Cox proportional hazards regression, including clinical stage, histology, steroid use, performance status, mutation status, comorbidities and treatment year, we found that receipt of a COVID-19 mRNA vaccine within 100 days of initiation of ICI was associated with significantly improved median OS (20.6 months versus 37.3 months) and 3 year OS (30.8% versus 55.7%, adjusted hazard ratio (HRadj = 0.51, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.37–0.71, P < 0.0001) (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Tables 2 and 3). This survival advantage was similar for patients with stage III unresectable NSCLC (HRadj = 0.37, 95% CI = 0.16–0.89, P = 0.0268) (Fig. 1b and Supplementary Tables 4 and 5) and stage IV NSCLC (HRadj = 0.52, 95% CI = 0.37–0.74, P = 0.0002) (Fig. 1c and Supplementary Tables 6 and 7); patients who received mRNA vaccines from either vaccine manufacturer (Extended Data Fig. 1a); and patients who had or had not received a previous COVID-19 mRNA vaccine (Extended Data Fig. 1b). Patients who received two vaccines in the 100 days surrounding initiation of ICI experienced similar OS compared with those who received only one vaccine (Extended Data Fig. 1c). These results were also consistent when considering only those patients whose closest mRNA vaccine was within 100 days before their first ICI (Extended Data Fig. 1d), when narrowing the vaccination window to 50 instead of 100 days (Extended Data Fig. 1e), when restricting to only those patients treated during the pandemic (Extended Data Fig. 1f), after correcting for immortal time bias (Extended Data Fig. 1g) and with propensity score matching (PSM; Extended Data Fig. 1h,i). Patients who received a COVID-19 vaccine within 100 days of chemotherapy (a group that did not include targeted therapies owing to significant heterogeneity and limited patient numbers within different drug cohorts) but did not receive ICI had no detectable survival benefit (Extended Data Fig. 2a). Likewise, patients who received a pneumonia or influenza vaccine within 100 days of initiating ICI (Extended Data Fig. 2b–e) and those with resectable stage III tumours (Extended Data Fig. 2f,g) experienced no improvement in survival.
For advanced stage cancers of this sort, this is a big deal, a very large survival benefit. Basically, the median survival of those who had received a COVID-19 vaccination within 100 days of starting immunotherapy was nearly twice as long as it was for those who had not. It would be easy to dismiss the results as coming from a retrospective study and not an RCT if (1) they weren’t so dramatic; (2) the authors hadn’t controlled for so many confounders; and (3) the authors hadn’t seen similar results from non-mRNA-based vaccines.
Even more interesting is how this result built on previous work in a mouse model by the same group. In their study, published in July in Nature Biomedical Engineering, the authors showed that early interferon responses (interferons are a class of critical immune modulatory proteins) could be enhanced via systemic administration of lipid particles loaded with mRNA coding for antigens not specific to the tumor and that the enhancement could bolster the efficacy of ICIs. (There are other papers suggesting that mRNA vaccines not necessarily expressing a specific tumor antigen can be used to augment cancer immunotherapy.) It was this result that led the authors to ask the question of whether COVID-19 vaccines could have a non-COVID-specific effect that could enhance tumor response to ICI therapy.
Based on the observation in their human retrospective study that administration of COVID-19 vaccines before ICI therapy was associated with a major improvement in survival in advanced NSCLC and melanoma, the authors went back to their mouse models, recreating commercial preparations of COVID mRNA vaccines for administration to tumour-bearing animals in conjunction with ICIs. The authors chose mouse B16F0 melanoma and Lewis lung carcinoma (LLC) as models to test immunogenicity and efficacy of spike RNA-lipid nanoparticle vaccines due to the effects of the vaccine in these clinical settings and because both tumor models are poorly responsive to ICIs. (As a side note, I did a lot of work with Lewis lung carcinoma in mice in the 1990s, for example this paper, and am quite familiar with the tumor model.) Without going into all the experiments they did, I can say that (1) they basically replicated in mice what they had observed in the retrospective study and (2) using a different antigen (in this case, the cytomegalovirus antigen pp65, which is expressed in in human glioma but not in B16F0 tumors) they showed similar results, with the addition of mRNA vaccine to ICI therapy resulting in more potent anti-tumor effects.
As the authors summarized in another article:
We used mouse models to show that mRNA vaccines stimulate inflammation, which drives innate immune cells in the tumour to train other immune cells, called T cells, to infiltrate and kill tumours. Although the tumours counter this by displaying a molecule called PD-L1 that shuts down the immune attack, combining the mRNA vaccine with antibodies to block PD-L1 overcomes this defence mechanism and enables tumour killing. We found similar effects of vaccination in people, including broad immune activation in healthy volunteers and PD-L1 expression on tumour cells in individuals with cancer.
Together, these data indicate that widely available mRNA vaccines might sensitize tumours to immune-checkpoint blockade. The findings challenge the prevailing assumption that mRNA cancer vaccines function mainly by training immune cells to target pre-selected tumour antigens, and introduce another mechanism by which mRNA vaccines can trigger antitumour immune responses. Our data indicate that off-the-shelf mRNA vaccines could be useful in the first-line or pre-surgical therapy setting, and lay the groundwork for the development of universal immune stimulants to sensitize tumours to immune-checkpoint blockade.
Ain’t science cool?
Equally compelling is the potential for turning immunologically “cold” tumors “hot.” A “cold” tumor is a tumor that is unlikely to provoke much of an immune response because they tend to be surrounded by cells that are able to suppress the immune response and keep T cells from attacking the tumor cells and killing them. As the authors write:
Our findings suggest that mRNA vaccines may provide just the spark the immune system needs to turn these “cold” tumors “hot.” If validated in our upcoming clinical trial, our hope is that this widely available, low-cost intervention could extend the benefits of immunotherapy to millions of patients who otherwise would not benefit from this therapy.
Another potential advantage of this approach is this:
We and many others are currently working hard to make personalized mRNA vaccines for patients with cancer. This involves taking a small sample of a patient’s tumor and using machine learning algorithms to predict which proteins in the tumor would be the best targets for a vaccine.5 However, this approach can be costly and difficult to manufacture.6
In contrast, COVID-19 mRNA vaccines do not need to be personalized, are already widely available at low or no cost around the globe, and could be administered at any time during a patient’s treatment. Our findings that COVID-19 mRNA vaccines have substantial antitumor effects bring hope that they could help extend the anti-cancer benefits of mRNA vaccines to all.2
Again, this is the opposite of the nonsensical claim from antivaxxers that COVID-19 vaccines have been responsible for an epidemic of “turbo cancer,” a term never heard or used before COVID-19 vaccines that appears to have been made up of whole cloth by antivaxxers to describe very aggressive cancers that, according to them, were caused by COVID-19 vaccines. Never mind that, even aside from the extreme biological implausibility of any vaccine or exposure causing a rash of cancer diagnoses within a year (which was when the first claims of “turbo cancer” started circulating in the darkest recesses of antivax social media, there is zero evidence to support the claim that the COVID-19 vaccines cause cancer, much less highly aggressive “turbo cancers.”
Here I’ll interject by saying what a lot of scientists have been saying about this study. It’s preliminary. However, it’s also very exciting and compelling, because Grippin et al have combined their retrospective clinical observation with experiments in mice that suggest a plausible mechanism for the effect observed and a rationale to design a randomized controlled clinical trial to test the hypothesis that mRNA vaccines administered to patients with cancers that can be treated with ICIs within 100 days of commencement of therapy will enhance the antitumor effect of the ICIs. Even better, these findings suggest that a strategy in which an mRNA anti-tumor vaccine is developed using an antigen specific to the tumor being treated will be highly effective, because not only would the vaccine provoke an immune response to the tumor antigen but would also have the sorts of nonspecific responses observed by Grippin et al using nRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines.
Unfortunately, despite the promise of mRNA vaccines:
The finding is one more example of the potential of mRNA-based technologies for treating rare cancers and genetic diseases in addition to protecting against infection. Yet political attacks on them, based on unproven safety concerns, are mounting—with some states considering legislation to outlaw mRNA products. In August, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, announced the agency was terminating nearly $500 million in grants for research into mRNA vaccines. Treating some applications of mRNA technology as “politically taboo” threatens to create a “chilling effect” for the field, Coller says.
It is because of this “stigma,” Lin explains, that his team hasn’t attempted to seek federal funding for its planned clinical trial. But he remains optimistic that the new findings will attract interest and support from other backers. “There’s so much yet to learn,” he says. “This is just the beginning.”
Steven Lin is the corresponding author and principal investigator who oversaw this research.
In the beforetime (before Trump and HHS Secretary RFK Jr.), NIH funding for such a clinical trial would have bene virtually assured, given the rigor of the science and the promise of the findings reported last week. Now, with mRNA vaccines being demonized and the mRNA platform being falsely portrayed as dangerous by the “make America healthy again” (MAHA) activists now running all non-military federal health programs, Dr. Lin is forced to beg for scraps to fund what is likely to be a highly impactful clinical trial that could revolutionize cancer therapy as much as the discovery of immune checkpoint inhibitors did over the last 20 years and angiogenesis inhibitors did the decade before that.
Fortunately, for the world, the US isn’t the only country in the world, and the work is being pursued in a number of countries, as described in this Washington Post article:
“It is not unexpected. You can expect that more data will come out,” said Katalin Kariko, the University of Pennsylvania researcher who shared the 2023 Nobel Prize in medicine with Drew Weissman for work that led to the development of the coronavirus vaccines.
Kariko, who was not involved in the new study, said that in May she was in Europe speaking with other scientists “and they mentioned that the covid vaccine has an effect on cancer growth.” There are about 150 clinical trials of mRNA vaccines ongoing around the world, Kariko said, almost half for treatment of infectious diseases and many of the others for cancers.
The damage that President Trump and his lackey HHS Secretary RFK Jr. have done to public health, medicine, and biomedical research in the US has already been monumental. The damage is so severe that the CDC is in free fall and irreparably damaged, thanks to massive layoffs and budget cuts, and the NIH and FDA are barely functional. Meanwhile, NIH and other government funding for one of the most promising medical technologies yet devised for vaccines and to treat cancer, mRNA delivered by lipid nanoparticles, has been eliminated, all because of the delusional beliefs of antivaxxers that somehow mRNA technology is evil and harmful.
When the supremacy of the US in biomedical research is surpassed by China and the European Union, something that is likely to happen in the next few years at the most and the brain drain of young scientists who see the writing on the wall and decide to depart for greener pastures leaves us a distant third (if even that) in biomedical research, it will have been an entirely self-inflicted wound, one we as a nation will probably never recover from. Foregoing studying the promise of mRNA vaccines as cancer treatments are just one example; there are, sadly, many, many more.


And so 2026 begins…with a resurrection of the myth that COVID vaccines cause “turbo cancers”
I had hoped to let this cup pass, but, after a week and a half, I found that I couldn’t. Eminent oncologist and cancer researcher Dr. Wafik El-Deiry is back and doubling down on the unproven claim that COVID vaccines cause “turbo cancers,” this time with an added dash of conspiracy theory. What happened to him?
David Gorski on January 12, 2026
Link

And so it begins…
And so 2026 begins…
As I sat down last week to write the first post of 2026, I had been thinking that I would write about this week’s topic, but after thinking about it I decided to address a more general question of whether it is ever a good idea to debate science deniers. Then, as I sat down to write this week, there were the news stories about how the longtime antivax activist who is now Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., had unilaterally decided to remake the CDC-recommended vaccine schedule in the image of Denmark because Denmark vaccinates against the fewest diseases of any European Union country. However, that was over a week ago, and Steve had already discussed it. (That’s not to say that I might not address, either here or at my not-so-super-secret other blog, it as part of RFK Jr.’s broader war on the vaccine schedule, but I felt less impetus to do it now.) Then, over the weekend, I saw a post on X, the disinformation hellsite formerly known as Twitter, by eminent oncologist and cancer researcher Dr. Wafik El-Deiry (whom we’ve met before here) touting his review article (not really a “study”) in which he wildly speculated about links between COVID-19 vaccines and cancer. True, he didn’t call them “turbo cancers,” but he did parrot the headline calling the vaccines “jabs”:
Shocking study linking covid jabs and cancer 'censored' by mysterious cyberattackhttps://t.co/3lYZhLrULS
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) January 10, 2026
A couple of observations. First, the review article in question, COVID vaccination and post-infection cancer signals: Evaluating patterns and potential biological mechanisms, co-authored by Charlotte Kuperwasser and Wafik S. El-Deiry, was officially published on January 3, and it was on or about that date when Dr. El-Deiry started flogging a narrative in which a cyberattack on the journal website, OncoTarget, had kept the article from being viewed. The “Daily Fail” is bad enough as a source, but then Dr. El-Deiry posted:
Shocking New Covid Study Linking Jabs to Cancer Goes Offline after Cyberattackhttps://t.co/VaHXnvmtIo
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) January 11, 2026
Yes, you read that right. He posted an Infowars link about his review article. However, that wasn’t the worst, at least not in my not-so-humble opinion:
‘Tip of a Very Damaging Iceberg’: COVID Vaccines Linked to Several Cancer Types in New Review

A systematic review of 69 studies identified safety signals for leukemia, lymphoma, breast and lung cancer. The paper identified mechanisms — including the spike protein and DNA…
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) January 8, 2026
Children’s Health Defense? Seriously? If CHD were ever to praise and publicize a study or review article that I’d authored or co-authored, I would not be proud of it. Quite the opposite. I’d be deeply ashamed, to the point where I’d STFU and reexamine my entire professional life, scientific activities, and belief systems before daring to reemerge, most likely humbled and apologetic, especially if I had made the enormous reputation-damaging mistake that Dr. El-Deiry did. I quote from the CHD article:
Wafik El-Deiry, M.D., Ph.D., one of the co-authors, told The Defender that the paper “is the first most comprehensive presentation summarizing the world‘s literature on the subject matter of COVID vaccines, COVID infection and cancer.”
He said some of the review’s findings “look like a smoking gun” linking COVID-19 shots to cancer.
Karl Jablonowski, Ph.D., senior research scientist for Children’s Health Defense, said the review’s findings may represent “the tip of a very damaging iceberg.”
“It is not remotely surprising that a gene-therapy rebranded as a vaccine, never tested for oncogenic safety, with severe immune dysregulating effects, injected into a billion people would correlate with an increased risk of cancers worldwide,” Jablonowski said.
El-Deiry said the review may provide insights into rising cancer rates in recent years, including an increase in so-called “turbo cancers.”
“I believe there is a risk of cancer associated with COVID vaccination,” El-Deiry said. “The magnitude of the risk remains to be more precisely defined, including the risk of hyperprogression.” Hyperprogression refers to cases where “a pre-existing tumor grows more aggressively.”
Seriously, Dr. El-Deiry. Giving an interview to CHD’s publication, The Defender, is not a good look for any legitimate scientist, but it’s even worse than that. Since last weekend (at least), Dr. El-Deiry has been flogging a claim that he’s being “censored” because of a cyberattack on OncoTarget, the journal that published his review article, a claim for which he has presented no evidence and that he blames on PubPeer, a website that exists to do postpublication review of scientific articles. Much of the discussion there is about the methodology, design, and quality of various scientific papers. However, what PubPeer is best known for—one might even say notorious for—is the exposure of image manipulation in the scientific papers. These criticisms and demonstrations of image manipulation can lead to corrections and sometimes even to retractions of scientific papers. One particularly controversial aspect (at least among scientists) of PubPeer is that it allows anonymous commentary and goes to great lengths to protect the anonymity of its commenters when they are threaten with libel suits.
Before I move on, I will admit that I have mixed feelings about the anonymity of PubPeer commentary. On the one hand, anonymity allows junior researchers to be safer in criticizing the work of more senior and entrenched researchers who could destroy their careers. On the other hand, anonymity can be a mask behind which malicious actors can cause mischief. That being said, as long as I’ve been following PubPeer commentary and stories on Retraction Watch, I have seen little or no evidence that anonymous commentary finding evidence of image manipulation has been malicious. Indeed, most of the examples that I’ve seen of image manipulation uncovered on PubPeer seem to be due to carelessness and lax oversight of trainees as they prepare scientific manuscripts than due to intentional fraud. Moreover, some of the most famous contributors to PubPeer are not anonymous. (Elizabeth Bik comes to mind.)
Why did I discuss PubPeer? It will become apparent shortly. First, let’s look at what OncoTarget says about the alleged cyberattack, without presenting any evidence whatsoever for these charges:
In December 2025 and January 2026, our server encountered malicious cyberattacks that led to disruptions of online publications and website access.
The Dark side of PubPeer: there are suspicions that certain individuals associated with PubPeer may have been involved in cybercriminal activities, including hacking servers, causing journal websites to go offline, and using illegitimate practices to influence Google search results for journals and scientists.
It turns out that PubPeer has nearly 100 threads about papers authored or co-authored by Dr. El-Deiry. I am not going to comment on the validity of these threads here—that would take enough effort for at least one more post, and I want to stick to my originally intended topic—other than to note that Dr. El-Deiry, like a number of researchers whose papers are unflatteringly dissected by PubPeer commenters, very much resents being called out on PubPeer. Indeed, as Leonid Schneider at For Better Science noted on Friday:
El-Deiry has been battling his PubPeer critics for some time now, mostly on X where he also directly or via proxies runs the account Science Guardians. Their favourite hate targets are Elisabeth Bik, Kevin Patrick and yours truly.
ScienceGuardians, I note, claims to do basically the same thing as PubPeer, only anonymity is not permitted, and those running the site claim to use “stringent verification” that contributors are legitimate academics, which sounds a bit elitist, even to me. Also, hilariously, if you look at the ScienceGuardians entry for a recent excellent study showing that, contrary to the narrative being pushed by antivax “turbo cancer” cranks that there isn’t a huge amount of DNA contamination, you’ll see that the commenters included antivax cranks like Jessica Rose and Kevin McKernan, with zero actual reputable legitimate academic scientists.
In any event, the post that made me finally decide to address Dr. El-Deiry’s paper was this one:
This is the type of ongoing public defamation I am being subjected to for pursuing scientific truth. 

I am referred to as a “scientifically illiterate” “pathetic whiny wuss” who is “dumb as two bricks” with racial undertones of being a “white male” and as a “dude who was caught… pic.twitter.com/qmkufLJG1h
— Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP (@weldeiry) January 10, 2026
I mean, seriously. In context, Schneider was so obviously engaging in sarcasm and mockery that Dr. El-Deiry should be embarrassed to have thought it to be a real admission of guilt, particularly given the part in which Schneider claims to have been behind the vaccine-induced cancers. Also, it was pointed out on X that there probably was no cyberattack:
Clearly parody, Wafik. 🙄 the level of dumb here: your site is hosted on cloudflare CDN so this is not DDOS. Cloudflare shows you server is misconfigured and down. You broke your site. 

Trying making a copy up your site when it’s working and restore. easy fix..
— Víðópnir (@rnbrd) January 9, 2026
Helpful information. Will Dr. El-Deiry take this advice? Let me just
point out that this is an easy-to-make mistake. My not-so-super-
secret other blog once went down for a while because of the same
error. I managed to fix it without crying, “DDoS!”
With that background, I will now examine the decline of a once-great scientist through the lens of this latest incident, which demonstrates how even the best of us can fall prey to ideology-based pseudoscience. True, this is not a story on par with that of, for instance, Linus Pauling‘s descent into “vitamin C cures everything, including cancer” quackery and Luc Montagnier’s fall into alternative medicine and antivax quackery. Both were Nobel Laureates for whom I once coined the term “Nobel Disease” to describe Nobel Laureates who embraced nonsense in their later years. It is, nonetheless, very disappointing to me, as Dr. El-Deiry has made real and important contributions to oncology and the science of cancer, in particular regarding the tumor suppressor genes p21 (CDKN1A) and p53, that led me to admire his work and him quite a bit. Indeed, his work was frequently cited in my papers in the 1990s and early 2000s, and I even met him in person once many years ago. There was a period of time after I had first become aware of his tendency to jump on the antivax train to link his work with p53 to “turbo cancers” when he appeared to have quieted down and gone back to what he’s best at, tumor suppressor research, but, starting with his promotion of the misinterpreted South Korean study claiming to link COVID-19 vaccines to cancer (deconstructed by yours truly when it came out a few months ago), he seems to have re-emerged and, if anything, doubled down.
A sadly dubious review article begins
Let’s take a look at the review article on OncoTarget, COVID vaccination and post-infection cancer signals: Evaluating patterns and potential biological mechanisms, co-authored by Charlotte Kuperwasser and Wafik S. El-Deiry. The first thing I noticed was the rapid turnaround time, with the manuscript submitted November 26, accepted December 26, and published on January 3. Another thing that really struck me is the open peer review (which I’ll discuss after the article). It makes me wonder who the peer reviewers were, given that these were some of the most milquetoast “critiques” I’ve seen and many of them missed the point of the big flaws in this “study.” I wonder even more based on this footnote to the paper:
The Editor-in-Chief, Dr. Wafik S. El-Deiry, was not involved in the peer-review process or the decision-making for this paper. Dr. El-Deiry shared the submitted manuscript with National Cancer Institute (NCI) Director Anthony Letai by email electronically on December 12, 2025.
So, even if Dr. El-Deiry “was not involved in the peer-review process or the decision-making for this paper,” he is the editor-in-chief of the journal. While I applaud him somewhat for trying to take the decision-making out of his own hands, I still have to wonder whether others involved with the journal would be willing to tell him that this paper didn’t meet peer-review standards. Basically, even though Dr. Letai apparently shepherded the manuscript through the peer-review process, it is nonetheless a major conflict of interest for an editor-in-chief to submit a manuscript like this, particularly one that can be easily predicted to be controversial, to his own journal. It was bad enough when John Ioannidis was publishing dubious papers in a journal for which he had recently served as editor-in-chief, but this is worse.
Before I get into the nitty-gritty, let’s cite the abstract of this review, so that everyone knows the broad outline of what the review claims to have done and to have found:
A growing number of peer-reviewed publications have reported diverse cancer types appearing in temporal association with COVID-19 vaccination or infection. To characterize the nature and scope of these reports, a systematic literature search from January 2020 to October 2025 was conducted based on specified eligibility criteria. A total of 69 publications met inclusion criteria: 66 article-level reports describing 333 patients across 27 countries, 2 retrospective population-level investigations (Italy: ~300,000 cohort, and Korea: ~8.4 million cohort) quantified cancer incidence and mortality trends among vaccinated populations, and one longitudinal analysis of ~1.3 million US military service members spanning the pre-pandemic through post-pandemic periods. Most of the studies documented hematologic malignancies (non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas, cutaneous lymphomas, leukemias), solid tumors (breast, lung, melanoma, sarcoma, pancreatic cancer, and glioblastoma), and virus-associated cancers (Kaposi and Merkel cell carcinoma). Across reports, several recurrent themes emerged: (1) unusually rapid progression, recurrence, or reactivation of preexisting indolent or controlled disease, (2) atypical or localized histopathologic findings, including involvement of vaccine injection sites or regional lymph nodes, and (3) proposed immunologic links between acute infection or vaccination and tumor dormancy, immune escape, or microenvironmental shifts. The predominance of case-level observations and early population-level data demonstrates an early phase of potential safety-signal detection. These findings underscore the need for rigorous epidemiologic, longitudinal, clinical, histopathological, forensic, and mechanistic studies to assess whether and under what conditions COVID-19 vaccination or infection may be linked with cancer.
My first reaction was that the term “growing number of peer-reviewed publications” supposedly supporting a link between COVID-19 vaccines and cancer is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. Second, I noted that these 69 reports only encompassed 333 patients with cancer, which, when weighed against the literally billions of doses of COVID-19 vaccines administered to billions of people, is a truly infinitesimally tiny number of cancer reports. Remember what I said as the vaccines started rolling out? Whenever you administer so many doses of a product to so many billions of people, there will be cases in which adverse events occur within close temporal proximity to vaccination by random chance alone, even highly implausible adverse events. I always like to bring up the example of, for instance, a person who receives a vaccine and then the next day dies due to a piece of granite falling off of a building, hitting them in a rare freak accident and coincidence. How do investigators determine that these rare cancers aren’t just a different example like the one I just mentioned? There are, of course, statistical methods to do that.
In any case, here’s a table that describes the literature surveyed:
Notice how the vast majority of the papers analyzed are case reports. I’ve discussed a number of these case reports myself, and I’ve found none particularly convincing for a mechanistic link between COVID vaccines and cancer, much less “turbo cancers.” Anyone wanna bet whether I see some of those papers here? Before I get into the case reports and studies included and the highly questionable interpretations of rare events, there’s an even bigger issue that jumped right out at me when I read the Materials and Methods section, where they described their search strategy for their scoping review:
A comprehensive search of the world’s literature was conducted using PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and React19 between January 2020 and April 2025. Eligible publications included case reports, case series, cohort or population-level analyses, systematic reviews, and mechanistic or preclinical studies that described either (i) new-onset, recurrent, or rapidly progressive malignancy temporally associated with COVID-19 vaccination or SARS-CoV-2 infection, or (ii) experimental evidence implicating vaccine or infection-induced immune perturbations in oncogenic, proliferative, or metastatic processes.
Initial searches in PubMed using conventional keyword combinations such as “COVID-19 vaccine and cancer,” “vaccination and cancer,” “COVID-19 vaccine and tumor,” or cancer-specific terms paired with “COVID-19 vaccine” yielded little to no indexed results. Even when known case reports were used as anchors for “similar articles,” PubMed returned no related entries. This highlighted a structural limitation in standard indexing pathways and necessitated a broader, more strategic search approach.
Wait, what?
React19.org is a valid data source? I don’t think so
I basically facepalmed when I read that Kuperwasser and El-Deiry were including React19.org in their search strategy, along with more traditional databases like PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar? Notice how they justify including React19 because they didn’t find enough references searching PubMed using conventional keyword combinations related to vaccines and cancer. Let me just note that React19 is a highly dubious source, maintained by an organization that proclaims its purpose thusly:
React19 is a science-based non-profit offering financial, physical, and emotional support for those suffering from longterm Covid-19 vaccine adverse events globally.
Our mission is to bring healing to the moms, dads, friends, and loved ones who are facing life-altering side effects from their Covid-19 vaccine. We build bridges between patients and research institutions in order to develop a better understanding of our vaccine complications. React19 works with both patients and providers, as well as research teams. Our programs all fall within our 3 categories of assistance (financial, physical, and emotional). Programs include funding, promoting, and sharing relevant scientific research; bringing the right medical teams together with patients; direct financial assistance; educational outreach; and supporting communities where impacted people can begin to heal physically and emotionally.
I examined React19.org’s X feed and soon found that it sure looks like an antivax org, full of anecdotes of alleged horrific injuries due to COVID-19 vaccines, even to the point of platforming longtime antivax activists like Dr. Sherri Tenpenny:
The interview is now live and this is a conversation everyone needs to hear.

Dr. Joel Wallskog joins Dr. Tenpenny to discuss his journey from respected orthopedic surgeon to vaccine-injured patient, and how systemic denial from the CDC, FDA, and NIH led him to co-found React19.… pic.twitter.com/pP6O6wQWTk
— React19 – Official (@React19org) November 22, 2025
Seriously, if you platform Dr. Tenpenny to discuss how “They” are
suppressing the evidence regarding vaccine injuries, you’re antivax.
Right from the start, Dr. El-Deiry’s approach appears to be: If he can’t find articles damning COVID-19 vaccines from standard databases of biomedical research articles, he’ll look elsewhere, even if he has to turn to a source that is clearly antivax. If I were reviewing his manuscript, his inclusion of React19.org would have been enough, in and of itself, for me to strongly recommend rejecting the manuscript with extreme prejudice.
Epidemiological evidence for a COVID vaccine-cancer link? Not so much…
Kuperwasser and El-Deiry clearly want the reader to think that there is a cancer safety signal in epidemiological data. The problem is that the studies that they cite don’t really show that, at least not anywhere near convincingly. They all have serious confounders that can explain their results. One study in particular cited by Kuperwasser and El-Deiry stood out to me very strongly, mainly because I have discussed it before—and fairly recently. I’m referring to the Korean study that was being widely touted a few months ago as slam-dunk evidence that COVID vaccines are associated with an increased risk of cancer, which Kuperwasser and El-Deiry describe thusly:
Kim et al. [8] analyzed approximately 8.4 million individuals between 2021 and 2023 to assess 1-year cumulative cancer incidence following COVID-19 vaccination using the South Korean National Health Insurance Service database. The authors reported statistically significant associations between vaccination and six specific cancers, including thyroid (HR 1.35), gastric (HR 1.34), colorectal (HR 1.28), lung (HR 1.53), breast (HR 1.20), and prostate cancer (HR 1.69) using propensity score matching and multivariable Cox proportional hazards models. Associations varied by vaccine platform, with mRNA vaccines linked to thyroid, colorectal, lung, and breast cancers, and cDNA/adenoviral vaccines associated with thyroid, gastric, colorectal, lung, and prostate cancers; heterologous vaccination was associated with thyroid and breast cancer. Stratified analyses suggested effect modification by sex and age, and booster-dose analyses identified increased risks for gastric and pancreatic cancer. The authors emphasized that despite adjustment for measured confounders, residual confounding, detection bias, and limited follow-up preclude causal inference, and that the findings should be interpreted as epidemiologic associations warranting further study rather than evidence of vaccine-induced cancer risk.
I deconstructed the study in depth not long after it was published; so I won’t go into great detail here. Suffice to say that this study, carried out in South Korea, screamed healthy vaccinee bias at me, given that it only looked at cancers diagnosed at one year. You might recall that healthy vaccinee bias is a type of confounding in observational studies (like this one, a retrospective observational study) where healthier, more health-conscious individuals are more likely to get vaccinated. This bias can lead to the overestimate of vaccine efficacy, which is obviously not an issue in this study, which didn’t even try to estimate vaccine efficacy. That wasn’t its purpose. Healthy user bias, which is related, is the likelihood that people engaging in one health behavior (e.g., getting vaccinated against COVID-19) will be more likely also to engage in other health interventions, such as cancer screening. What the results of the S. Korean study finding increased cancer diagnoses in vaccinated people seemed to be far more compatible with was a failure to correct for screening intensity, along with other potential confounders, so that the likelihood that people who were vaccinated and boosted were more likely to undergo screening, leading to an apparent increased incidence of the six screen-detected cancers described within a year, or to seek medical care for lesser symptoms, leading to, for instance, an earlier diagnosis of pancreatic cancer, a cancer that is not routinely screened for.
Kuperwasser and El-Deiry also cite an Italian study that was represented as finding increased rates of hospitalization for cancer in patients who had been vaccinated but suffers from much the same problems. Indeed, the authors themselves note:
Compared with the unvaccinated, those receiving ≥1 dose showed a significantly lower likelihood of all-cause death, and a slightly higher likelihood of hospitalization for cancer (HR: 1.23; 95% CI: 1.11-1.37). The latter association was significant only among the subjects with no previous SARS-CoV-2 infection, and was reversed when the minimum time between vaccination and cancer hospitalization was set to 12 months. The subjects who received SARS-CoV-2 vaccination showed a substantial reduction in all-cause mortality, and a risk of cancer hospitalization that varied by infection status, cancer site, and the minimum lag-time after vaccination. Given that it was not possible to quantify the potential impact of the healthy vaccinee bias and unmeas-ured confounders, these findings are inevitably preliminary.
This was not at all convincing for a link between COVID vaccination and cancer, and even Kuperwasser and El-Deiry seem to realize this, noting:
Both studies provide early, population-level associations rather than causal estimates and underscore the importance of long-term follow-up and molecular correlation to distinguish true biological effects from health-system or behavioral confounders.
The problem is that neither study actually shows a convincing population-level association after proper control for very obvious confounders, nor does the Department of Defense study cited, which showed an increase in incidence among military personnel of mature T/NK-cell lymphomas that began in 2020 (before vaccines) and continued through 2021-2023 (after military personnel were almost universally vaccinated against COVID-19). Even Kuperwasser and El-Deiry were forced to concede, however, that the “authors did not attribute the observed changes in NHL [non-Hodgkins lymphoma] incidence to vaccination or infection,” and that “the analysis was not designed to establish causality at the individual level,” noting that changes “in diagnostic practices, healthcare access and utilization, and pandemic-related disruptions to routine medical care cannot be excluded from this time-trend analysis as with others conducted during the pandemic period.” Of course, none of this prevents them from speculating wildly that “population-level analyses combined with the case-based literature indicate that a cancer signal warrants further prospective evaluation to determine whether COVID-19 vaccination confers any measurable cancer risk or merely reflects surveillance and reporting biases.”
Oddly enough, what is written above is a lot more tame and tentative than what Dr. El-Deiry said to CHD when he said that the thought these signals were a “smoking gun.” It’s as though Dr. El-Deiry cloaks the conclusions of his scientific articles in all the caveats expected but lets his real beliefs out when talking to antivax outlets like CHD. It’s almost as if Dr. El-Deiry knows that he’s generating material for antivaxxers to weaponize against vaccines. This is a recurring theme when comparing the actual review article and what Dr. El-Deiry says about it on social media and in interviews. (Seriously, Dr. El-Deiry, please stop promoting your results to loons like those working at CHD, thus giving them fodder for their antivax propaganda and lending your name to it as well. I honestly care less that you seem to think this really weak evidence is some sort of super-concerning “cancer signal” that requires further investigation than that you seem to be enthusiastically participating with antivaxxers who want to weaponize your findings to cast doubt on vaccines.)
DNA contamination a-go-go!
Moving on, Kuperwasser and El-Deiry really lose the plot when they discuss the issue of “DNA contamination” of COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. Recall that one of the tenets of the belief system behind “turbo cancer” is that there is a large amount of residual DNA contamination in the vaccines left over from the plasmids used to make the vaccine that the SV40 promoter sequence. I’ve discussed time and time again just how implausible this is and how bad the studies claiming to find high levels of DNA contamination in the vaccines are. Does any of this stop Kuperwasser and El-Deiry from citing the same crap studies, by the likes of Kevin McKernan and Didier Raoult? Of course not. It didn’t even stop him from citing a publication from Science, Public Health Policy, and the Law, the antivax fake journal founded by James Lyons-Weiler and published by his antivax org the Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge (IPAK), which, in addition to publishing poor quality antivax studies, also launders retracted studies by antivaxxers by finding a new home for them that appears to be a legitimate journal. Tellingly, Kuperwasser and El-Deiry don’t even cite a recent high quality paper that basically concluded that prior claims of excess DNA contamination of the vaccines was due to misinterpretation of improperly conducted analyses—ouch, that’s got to hurt—and that, in reality, DNA contamination of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines is well below accepted safety limits when the specimens are subjected “rigorous application of well-controlled methods that minimise mutual interference of vaccine components.” (Ouch. That’s going to hurt more.)
I could go on and point out how, even if the DNA contamination were as horrendous as McKernan (and, apparently, Kuperwasser and El-Deiry) want you to believe, it would still be incredibly unlikely even for a piece of DNA containing an intact SV40 promoter to cause cancer. First, it would have to get into the nucleus, which naked DNA has a hard time doing. Second, it would have to integrate into the genome in just the right spot that either (1) turns on a powerful oncogene or (2) disrupts a powerful tumor suppressor gene. Even if you accept the estimate provided in the paper based on in vitro (cell culture) studies as valid in vivo (in the human body) that 1-10% of cells demonstrate genomic integration of DNA with lipid-based systems, the only location where the concentration of such DNA contamination, even if you accept the highest estimates, might accomplish that is the muscle injection site, and that would mean the only sort of cancer that might even theoretically be caused by such a mechanism would be a soft tissue sarcoma arising from the muscle or connective tissue. None of this stops Kuperwasser and El-Deiry from writing, “No studies have been conducted demonstrating that the level of DNA impurities present in the vaccines are insufficient to transfect cells, nor have studies ruled out the possibility of integration.”
Prove to me a negative! (Dr. El-Deiry should know that science can’t absolutely prove a negative.)
The review does include a case report of an injection site sarcoma—one case report. You’d think that if DNA contamination were such an issue and if COVID-19 vaccines were responsible for “turbo cancer”—excuse me, “hyperprogression,” as the authors prefer to call it—there would have been a lot more such cases in the literature after billions upon billions of doses of vaccine. I can’t totally discount the possibility that an mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine was responsible for this woman’s sarcoma near her injection site but, even if it was, the lack of more cases suggests that such an event is so incredibly rare as to be almost undetectable epidemiologically. Such a conclusion conflicts with the “turbo cancer” narrative, in which antivaxxers are claiming that vaccines are responsible for a wave of highly aggressive cancers, even though there is no evidence of such a wave and the evidence for an increase in cancer among younger people shows that the increase started over three decades before the pandemic.
But, biology, man!
There is a whole section of the paper that tries to argue for biological plausibility based mainly on in vitro studies, for a couple of hypotheses. One is that the spike protein itself can cause cancer through a variety of biological activities. Perusing the list of articles cited to support this contention, I was struck by how most of them were looking at SARS-CoV-2 infection rather than vaccination. (Remember my discussion of speculation in 2024 that SARS-CoV-2 infection might predispose to cancer?) You might remember that Dr. El-Deiry himself published articles suggesting that the spike protein might bind to the p53 (TP53) tumor suppressor gene and thereby predispose to cancer, writing:
The transformation of a normal cell into a cancer cell involves disruption of multiple safeguards controlling cell growth, survival, and DNA repair. Laboratory studies have reported that the spike protein, whether it is produced by infection or by vaccination, has biological activities [110, 145, 152–158] with oncogenic potential [159–161]. For example, in addition to interacting with ACE2 receptors, spike protein fragments have been shown to interact with NRP-1, integrins, and TLRs leading to VEGF/NRP-1 signaling [155, 162, 163]. Spike protein has also been reported to induce DNA damage [160, 164, 165] and modify p53 pathway under oxidative stress [164, 166]. Therefore, in theory, such interactions of spike protein with these pathways could contribute to cellular transformation, both from the vaccine but also from infection, especially if the spike protein remains present long after vaccination or from multiple COVID infections.
The problem is that this is highly speculative. Indeed, the phrase “in theory” is doing some seriously heavy lifting here. As I read this, I asked myself one question: Has anyone demonstrated that the spike protein can transform cells, even in vitro? Nope. Not that I’m aware of. Until I see that, I will give this speculation all the due that it deserves; i.e., brief consideration before demanding some actual direct data.
Another hypothesis in the review is that the vaccine somehow causes immune dysregulation that leads to the growth of the latent cancer cells that we all have in our bodies that are generally kept in check by our immune systems. Let’s start with that one:
The rapid appearance of cancer, the anatomical proximity of the tumors to vaccine sites, and the histologic signatures of inflammation the support immune mechanisms that promote the progression of latent clones rather than de novo carcinogenesis. We hypothesize two interrelated processes: localized inflammation and modulation of the tumor microenvironment with transient functional immunosuppression that relaxes immune surveillance. Might account for hyperprogression of latent or occult cancer cells (Figure 5).
Accompanying this is a diagram that illustrates a “conceptual model” for the proposed mechanism:
Figure 5: Proposed mechanism of tumor hyperprogression following COVID-19 vaccination. (A) Conceptual model illustrating how inoculation with mRNA vaccine leads to immune reactions depending on its biodistribution. Strong immunostimulation can override immunosurveillance of latent cancer cells and trigger tumor hyperprogression. (B) Schematic representation of the major immune cell types influencing tumor growth and immune regulation following mRNA vaccine exposure. LNP–encapsulated modified mRNA (modRNA/mRNA) interacts with innate immune sensors altering cytokine signaling (TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-6) and immune-cell polarization leading to immunosuppression and reduced cytotoxic CD8+ T-cell activity. Expansion of myeloid suppressor populations, along with pro-tumor cytokine feedback loops, fosters accelerated tumor cell proliferation and immune evasion. The imbalance between anti-tumor (M1, CD8+, NK) and pro-tumor (M2, Treg, MDSC) networks favors tumor hyperprogression.
I’m not an immunologist, but you don’t have to be an immunologist to recognize this as handwaving of the first order. Let me just briefly show you what I mean. The overall argument being made is that there’s a transient cytokine surge after vaccination against COVID-19 that can cause secretion of proteins known as cytokines that lead to a “synergistic pro-inflammatory circuit capable of stimulating proliferation and angiogenesis” that is “known to rapidly promote the development of cancer if transformed or pre-malignant cells already exist.” Here’s one thing. Some articles cited implicate mainly chronic inflammation as a trigger for activating dormant tumor cells, while others implicate more acute inflammation, and one cited article is about respiratory infections activating breast cancer metastases in lungs, concluding that “SARS-CoV-2 infection substantially increases the risk of cancer-related mortality and lung metastasis compared with uninfected cancer survivors.” (Vaccinating would be a good way to prevent that.)
Here’s the other thing. All vaccines cause a transient cytokine surge. That’s how they work! They provide an antigen (± adjuvant) that results in stimulation of the immune system and, ultimately, immune memory of the antigen, so that the immune system is ready to be more rapidly activated if it ever encounters the same antigen(s). Why, then, would Kuperwasser and El-Deiry focus solely on COVID-19 vaccines as potentially causing a brief inflammatory cytokine storm that can cause dormant tumor cells to activate and start growing rapidly? Inquiring minds want to know, and certainly no explanation is given in the paper as to why COVID-19 vaccines would be more likely to cause this phenomenon than, basically, any other vaccine in existence.
Then there was one final thing about the immune system. Remember that study I discussed a couple of months back in which it was shown that mRNA vaccination with COVID-19 vaccines is associated with higher rates of survival in patients with advanced cancers undergoing immunotherapy with immune checkpoint inhibitors such as pembrolizumab? It’s dismissed by the authors by saying that, “mRNA vaccination was associated with increased Type I interferon signaling and elevated tumor PD-L1 expression” but that “PD-L1 upregulation in the absence of checkpoint inhibitor therapy is generally associated with enhanced tumor immune evasion and resistance to T-cell–mediated cytotoxicity, raising questions about the biological interpretation of these findings.” How? They don’t really say, but they go on to say that “the study did not provide comparative analyses between interferon treatment and the combination of mRNA vaccination with checkpoint blockade,” which would have been nice but doesn’t really detract from the study’s findings. They also write:
Furthermore, the study did not address key limitations, alternative mechanistic explanations, or the broader clinical context necessary to fully interpret the reported effects.
Personally, I thought that the authors of the immune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) study did these things just fine. For instance, the authors looked at patients who had received non-mRNA-based vaccines, like the influenza vaccine, within 100 days of their immunotherapy and found no survival benefit, and they did discuss potential other mechanisms and also basically replicated in mice what they had observed in the retrospective study and (2) using a different antigen (in this case, the cytomegalovirus antigen pp65, which is expressed in in human glioma but not in B16F0 tumors) they showed similar results, with the addition of mRNA vaccine to ICI therapy resulting in more potent anti-tumor effects.
Near the end of the article, there’s a section called “Gaps in Knowledge.” I hate to say it, but this is basically an appeal to ignorance combined with a Gish gallop to give the impression that we know so little about how spike protein from SARS-CoV-2 or the vaccine causes cancer, without any actual evidence that the spike protein from SARS-CoV-2…oh, you know…actually causes cellular transformation or cancer, which is why I cringed when I read:
The distinction between vaccination associated tumor initiation and promotion also remains unresolved. There is no empirical validation that vaccination only accelerates pre-existing disease rather than also initiating new malignancies.
This is as perfect an example of putting the cart before the horse. There is no good evidence that COVID-19 vaccination causes new malignancies or accelerates pre-existing disease; certainly nothing but speculation based on carefully selected articles was presented in this review article, and even then the case presented was not very persuasive.
Then there are errors. So. Many. Errors. The entry on the review article on PubPeer—oh, dear, I hope I don’t anger Dr. El-Deiry too much—goes into them in great detail; so I’m not going to enumerate them all. I will point out one, however:
“Notably, a study of cardiac tumors in the post-COVID period revealed both a 1.5% increase in tumor incidence and the expression of spike protein with the tumors, particularly in those associated with vaccination [86].” However the authors of the referenced paper by Mitrofanova et al. (2023) state: “There was no correlation with vaccination, and no significant differences were found between patients from 2016–2019 and 2021–2023 in terms of gender, age, and cardiac rhythm disorders”. Either this article was misinterpreted by the authors, or was cited incorrectly.
I tend to think it was misinterpreted.
But what about React19.org again?
I mentioned early in this post that Kuperwasser and El-Deiry had included React19.org, an antivax organization, in its data sources. However, if you look through the article, it’s hard to figure out where React19.org even comes in. For that, I had to look to the peer review. Oddly enough, Reviewer #1 didn’t even mention the very obvious problem that including data from an antivaccine group that isn’t even curated or subject to peer review as if it were co-equal with publications from sources such as PubMed and Google Scholar, while the best Reviewer #2 could come up with was:
The authors indicate that most of the oncologic effects were associated with vaccination. Could this be due to the inclusion of REACT19 in their database search?
Not the greatest question. I would have asked what the heck the authors were thinking when they included a database maintained by an antivax organization, but at least someone asked about React19.org. In any event, I assume that what was included was this listing of 3,500 publications supposedly related to COVID-19 adverse events, of which 199 fall under the category of “oncology.” Perusing the list, I noticed that a lot of the articles involved lymphadenopathy in nearby nodes to the injection site and how they can confound the mammographic diagnosis of breast cancer, something known since soon after the vaccines rolled out. In any event, the authors responded:
Yes, the REACT19 database was one of several resources used in our search strategy, and when filtered for “Oncology” it contains approximately 199 references. Many of the reverences overlap with the peer-reviewed literature identified through PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar but could not be found using conventional searching on those platforms.
Thus, the rationale for including REACT19 was not to preferentially capture vaccine- associated outcomes, but rather to address a well-recognized limitation in the discoverability of peer-reviewed publications on SARS-CoV-2 infection, COVID-19 vaccination, and cancer. As noted in the Methods and Limitations sections, much of the relevant literature is not consistently indexed with standard Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) or cross-referenced using conventional oncology or vaccinology search terms. Consequently, reliance on traditional database queries alone fails to retrieve a substantial portion of the existing peer-reviewed case literature.
We explicitly acknowledge in the manuscript that this reliance on publicly available but incompletely indexed literature imposes inherent limitations, including potential reporting bias, incomplete capture, and challenges in verification. We emphasize that this affects both infection- and vaccination-associated reports and reflects structural limitations of current indexing systems rather than an a priori focus on vaccination. Accordingly, the predominance of vaccination-associated reports in the assembled literature should be interpreted as descriptive of the published record to date, not as evidence of differential risk.
I would be interested in discovering which studies could not be found using conventional searches of PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar, but were found only in the much smaller React19.org database. Inquiring minds want to know, and I must admit that I’m not willing to take the time to try to duplicate all the searches that the authors list in their methods. Looking at the list of 199 references at React19.org, I doubt now that including the database made much of a difference, but the fact that the authors don’t recognize that they were using a database maintained by an antivax source disturbs me.
Mixed messages drive me crazy
Overall, this review article is basically a nothingburger. It’s far more speculation than anything else, as I mentioned before, a case of putting the cart before the horse. The authors carefully select three studies that they think they can point to as strong suggestive evidence in population studies that COVID-19 vaccination is associated with an increased risk of cancer. When these studies are examined in more detail, they all suffer from potential confounders that could easily explain their results, none more than the S. Korean study, which is about as obvious an example of healthy user/healthy vaccinee bias as I’ve ever seen. The authors also present a tiny number of case reports—at least the number is incredibly tiny relative to the billions upon billions of doses of vaccine that have been administered over the last four years—as though they suggested anything but the entirely predictable phenomenon that, if you administer a medication to a large enough number of people, you will find a number of bad things that happen to a number of people soon after receiving that medication by random chance alone. No convincing argument or evidence is presented to suggest causation.
Next, they list various mechanisms by which COVID-19 vaccines in general—and the spike protein in particular—might cause cancer. They then speculate wildly about these potential biological mechanisms and “gaps in knowledge” about COVID-19 vaccines and cancer. Most of these biological mechanisms strike me as a stretch, at best, particularly the invocation of “inflammation” as somehow activating dormant cancer cells that we all have in our bodies, again, because all vaccines cause transient inflammation, but the authors don’t address what is different about the inflammation caused by COVID-19 vaccines that it would lead to cancer.
There’s just one problem. If COVID-19 vaccines were truly responsible for a wave of “turbo cancers” or, as the authors would prefer to say, hyperprogression, then the epidemiological data would be there now, and it would be impossible to deny. By now, there would have been a worldwide wave of cancer correlating temporally and physically with the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines across the globe. We see no such thing. Related to this problem is the paucity of evidence that COVID-19 vaccines or the spike protein generated by them can cause neoplastic transformation (conversion of a normal cell to cancer) in cell culture or animal models, much less in humans. Again, this whole review article strikes me, more than anything else, as an exercise in—you guessed it!—putting the cart before the horse. Seriously, provide us with some compelling evidence, and we will change our minds, but Kuperwasser and El-Deiry don’t because they can’t. That evidence doesn’t exist, and it isn’t for lack of people trying to find it, either.
The mixed messages this review gives are best summed up by comparing the Limitations section to the conclusion of the paper. The authors list limitations such as:
The findings of this review should be interpreted within several important limitations inherent to the available literature and study design. First, although there are larger studies published, most reports are single-patient case descriptions or small case series. Many reports lack documentation of pre-existing conditions, prior oncologic history, concurrent infections, or medications that could confound interpretation. Therefore, while these observations are valuable for early signal detection, they are highly susceptible to publication bias and selective reporting. It is plausible that cases perceived as unusual or temporally linked to vaccination are preferentially submitted for publication, while the absence of comparable control observations limits inference regarding incidence or relative risk.
Let’s also not forget to emphasize yet again that, compared to the billions of humans who have collectively received billions of doses of vaccine, the number of these cases is mind-bogglingly infinitesimal, leading to the more likely possibility that many, if not all, of these case reports represent coincidence, a possibility not even really considered seriously by the authors.
Then:
The mechanistic hypotheses proposed here remain speculative in the absence of direct in vivo validation. No current studies have demonstrated oncogenic transformation or tumor initiation causally attributable to the COVID mRNA vaccine or its components. Nor have animal studies demonstrated vaccine-induced tumor promotion either. These mechanisms should therefore be regarded as biologically plausible models that warrant targeted experimental study.
This argument is basically: Ignore the lack of evidence supporting any of our speculations. We still think these biological mechanisms are plausible, and you should too, so much so that you should take our conclusions seriously:
The collective worldwide evidence from 2020–2025 underscores a biologically plausible connection between COVID-19 vaccination and cancer. The recurring clinical findings documented across many reports of de novo cancer onset, rapid tumor progression, viral reactivation, and reawakening of dormant disease, highlight critical gaps in knowledge and understanding of how large-scale immune changes produced by the vaccine interact with cancer biology.
Except that the whole review article is basically forced to admit that the collective worldwide evidence from 2020-2025 does not actually “underscore a biologically plausible connection between COVID-19 vaccination and cancer.” If it did, there would be at least some direct and compelling evidence implicating COVID-19 vaccines and cancer. There isn’t. Even Kuperwasser and El-Diery are forced to admit it.
So what happened to Dr. El-Deiry? He’s been in science longer than I have. By any objective measure, he’s accomplished way more in his scientific career than I have, with close to ten times the number of publications that I have, and even though his first publication was seven years before mine, that doesn’t explain such a huge difference. Dr. El-Deiry also did pioneering work on both p53 and on p21 and is now the director of a major cancer center. In contrast, as I enter the home stretch of my career, I know that I will never be a cancer center director or even a chair of a department of surgery. Yet, for some reason, late in his career, Dr. El-Deiry has embraced contrarianism. Worse, he’s embraced conspiracism to the point of trying to get the attention, well:
Let’s just say that snitch-tagging antivaxxers like RFK Jr., Dr. Peter McCullough, and the anonymous Jikkyleaks is not a good look for any scientist, no matter how much under attack he feels himself to be.
I keep scratching my head and trying to give Dr. El-Deiry the benefit of the doubt. His incredible past scientific accomplishments, coupled with my previous admiration for his work, compel me. But I’m having a harder and harder time managing to continue doing it, particularly now that he’s published an article that uses classic techniques that I’ve long watched antivaxxers use for two decades, specifically citing all sorts of scientific studies and engaging in imaginative speculation about “mechanisms” of vaccine injury, all without actually showing any compelling scientific evidence that the vaccine injury postulated is actually occurring. In such reviews, the tentative nature of scientific discourse is maintained, but the articles serve primarily to cast doubt on the safety and efficacy of a vaccine (or vaccines). It’s difficult for me not to see this article the same way, particularly given that Dr. El-Deiry is now portraying himself as the victim of persecution and conspiracy based on the criticism, sometimes harsh, of his claims about COVID-19 vaccines.


COVID-19 vaccination and screening mammography
Reports of enlarged lymph nodes under the arm after COVID-19 vaccination have led doctors to tweak mammography guidelines. Antivaxxers, unsurprisingly, have tried to weaponize this observation to spread fear and confusion about these vaccines.
David Gorski on March 22, 2021
Link

[Editor’s note: Dr. Gorski has a grant deadline this week (tomorrow, actually). As a result, he’s reposting something from his not-so-super-secret other blog. Actually, he thinks it’s a sufficiently important topic that he regrets not posting it to SBM first. So, even though Dr. Gorski hates it when he has to skip a week posting new material on SBM, he is more than happy to remedy his previous error and post this on SBM. He’s also updated the post and added a bit of material to it. In any case, if you don’t read his not-so-super-secret other blog, it’s new to you, and even if you do this version is beefed up a bit.]
I’ve said many times before that there’s nothing new under the sun when it comes to the antivaccine movement. Basically, every antivax trope, lie, distortion, talking point, and bit of disinformation has been resurrected, dusted off, and repurposed to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about the COVID-19 vaccines. As they’ve done since I first started, antivaxxers have blamed COVID-19 vaccines for death, infertility, and Alzheimer’s disease, while characterizing them as a sort of toxin-laden “gene therapy” that can “reprogram your DNA“. True, there is one antivax lie that hasn’t (yet) been resurrected for COVID-19, namely the claim that the vaccines cause autism, but that’s only because no COVID-19 vaccine has been approved or mandated for children. (You can bet that the vaccine-autism myth will reappear as soon as we start vaccinating children against COVID-19.) Even so, I now realize that I’m not entirely correct in saying that there is “nothing new under the sun” from antivaxxers about COVID-19 vaccines. Earlier this month, I came across one that I’d never heard before. Have you heard the one about the COVID-19 vaccine, lymph nodes, and mammography? I should have heard of it before, given that my surgical specialty is treating breast cancer, but, oddly enough, I hadn’t.
Before we see how antivaxxers are weaponizing this new observation, let’s start with the sane, sober, reality-based discussion of what I’m talking about, in this case from a CNN news report:
When she found a lump in her left breast during a routine self-check, Boston primary care physician Dr. Devon Quasha knew exactly what to do. She immediately scheduled a diagnostic mammogram and ultrasound at Massachusetts General Hospital for early January.
Then the Moderna vaccine became available to health care professionals in the city. She received her first Covid-19 shot about a week before her scheduled mammogram. Quasha didn’t notice much of a reaction to the vaccine at first, but a couple of days before her appointment her left arm began to hurt.
Tender, swollen lumps developed under her left armpit, along with a large swelling above her collarbone — all areas where there are lymph nodes, the body’s filters for germs. “You have lymph nodes above and below your collarbone,” Quasha said. “You don’t want to feel those. It was scary when I felt it.”Lymph nodes contain immune cells that help fight invaders. That’s why it made sense to Quasha that the nodes were reacting to the vaccine, building antibodies as they were designed to do. But she couldn’t be sure.
You can see how this might be alarming to women, particularly to a woman who had recently noticed a lump in her breast. To physicians and scientists, it’s no surprise at all that an injection that can cause local inflammation could also cause inflammation of the local lymph nodes, namely the axillary lymph nodes (the lymph nodes under your arm) or the supraclavicular lymph nodes (lymph nodes in your lower neck right above your collarbone). These two lymph node basins are where breast cancer often spreads first, particularly the axillary lymph nodes, which is why they are used in staging breast cancer, with positive lymph nodes imparting a higher cancer stage. Here’s an illustration:
And here’s a more “anatomic” illustration:
Radiologists and breast cancer doctors have already encountered this phenomenon:
After the ultrasound, Quasha’s radiologist was concerned. She told Quasha she considered the lump she had felt in her breast to be of little significance, but the lymph nodes that showed up as white blobs on her mammogram were another matter.
In non-pandemic times, that finding would set off alarm bells, requiring the need for further investigation, even an immediate biopsy. Yet Quasha had just had the vaccine. After talking it over with her, Quasha said her doctor decided not to do a biopsy at that time. Instead she told Quasha to come back for a follow-up ultrasound in six weeks.
And this was the correct thing to do from a clinical standpoint. Other things that can cause lymphadenopathy (swollen lymph nodes) are injuries or infections in the arm, which can lead to an inflammatory reaction in the lymph nodes under that arm. That’s just the lymph nodes doing their job. For example, if bacteria get into the lymph vessels, the lymph nodes are a point at which the immune system can stop the bacteria from spreading further. In addition, any sort of significant (or sometimes even not-so-significant) inflammatory reaction can lead to lymphadenopathy in the lymph node basin draining the area where the inflammation is occurring.
It turns out, though, that axillary and supraclavicular lymphadenopathy on the side of the shoulder in which a woman received a COVID-19 vaccine is turning out to be more common than anticipated:
Similar scenarios had been happening in mammogram centers around the country. As radiologists compared notes with colleagues, word began to spread.
“We all started talking about it, and it was like a wildfire,” said Dr. Connie Lehman, chief of breast imaging in Massachusetts General’s department of radiology.
“I cannot tell you how many women are showing nodes on mammograms and people thought it was going to be not that common,” said Lehman, who is also a professor of radiology at Harvard Medical School.
Tales of unnecessary biopsies spurred the patient care committee of the Society of Breast Imaging (SBI) to put out an advisory in January: Ask your patients about their Covid-19 status, and record the date and which arm received the vaccine. Consider that before automatically scheduling a biopsy.
“We wanted to advocate that women don’t always need to have a biopsy,” said Dr. Lars Grimm, associate professor of radiology at Duke University School of Medicine and one of the authors of the SBI advisory. “Because oftentimes the default if you see swollen lymph nodes in a patient would actually be to recommend doing a biopsy.”
In a story in the Washington Post on Friday:
After vaccination, a swollen lymph node may appear as a lump in the armpit. These glands are hotbeds of immune activity, filtering pathogens and storing germ-fighting cells. If you’ve had a sore throat or a cold, there’s a chance you’ve felt a swollen node in your neck. The post-vaccine node may be palpable, too.
This side effect appears to be more common after the Moderna and Pfizer shots than after the Johnson & Johnson vaccine. In Moderna’s trials, about 1 in 6 recipients reported swelling or tenderness in armpit lymph nodes, often on the same side as the shot, after a second dose.
In the context of breast imaging, abnormally enlarged lymph nodes observed on mammography or axillary ultrasound are frequently of concern. Most commonly, they do not represent breast cancer, but they can. Depending on how suspicious the enlarged lymph nodes are, a core needle biopsy, guided by ultrasound, might be ordered. One can see how this sort of side effect of COVID-19 vaccines could wreak havoc with mammographic screening.
It’s also not as though vaccination by an intramuscular injection in the shoulder didn’t sometimes result in enlarged axillary lymph nodes before COVID-19. Anything that causes an inflammatory reaction in an upper extremity can lead to enlargement of the lymph nodes on that side of the body, and vaccination is no different. The difference with the COVID-19 vaccine is that there is a mass vaccination program going on, with tens of millions of women who are older (and thus undergoing routine screening mammography) receiving the shots. The law of large numbers thus dictates that, in that setting, radiologists are going to see a lot of women whose mammograms and/or breast and axillary ultrasounds detect enlarged lymph nodes after a COVID-19 vaccine. Before the COVID-19 mass vaccination program, the numbers of women who received a vaccine of any kind soon before undergoing mammography was much smaller than it is now. After all, the main vaccines adults over 50 receive include the shingles vaccine, a yearly influenza vaccine that many adults don’t bother with, maybe a Tdap if they haven’t received a tetanus vaccine in over ten years, and a vaccine against pneumococcal pneumonia recommended for those 65 and older.
Indeed, since I first started seeing this warning late last month, we’ve had several cases of women with enlarged axillary lymph nodes seen on mammography after COVID-19 vaccination right at my cancer center’s own breast center. We’ve even seen at least one in the context of a newly diagnosed cancer on the same side, a situation in which seeing enlarged lymph nodes is particularly concerning because, absent vaccination, such a finding can mean that the cancer is not stage I (no positive lymph nodes), but rather stage II or above, depending on the number of suspicious lymph nodes detected. This left the difficult question of whether to wait 4-6 weeks and repeat the ultrasound or to biopsy the lymph node(s) now.
So the SBI advisory to do mammograms either before receiving the COVID-19 vaccine or 4-6 weeks after the second dose of the vaccine is both a reasonable and practical response to this observation. So is the suggestion that axillary lymphadenopathy observed on mammography and/or ultrasound may not necessarily be immediately biopsied but instead followed up with repeat imaging in 4-12 weeks to make sure that the lymphadenopathy has resolved. Doctors involved in screening mammography and the evaluation of women for breast cancer (such as yours truly) make these sorts of clinical judgments all the time. COVID-19 vaccinations complicate these sorts of judgments, but, when you come right down to it, not by very much.
Indeed, some radiologists and breast cancer doctors have gone a step further, saying:
At Mass General, Lehman and her team have gone a step further. They are screening all women regardless of vaccine status, but telling those with no history of cancer that any swelling in the lymph nodes that might be connected to a Covid-19 vaccine is benign — meaning not cancerous.
“This follows the American College of Radiology recommendations that if you have a known inflammatory cause you can say it’s benign,” said Lehman, who recently published a paper on the hospital’s procedures.”
If their concern is a swelling or tenderness after the vaccine in their armpit, we suggest that they wait four to six weeks, talk to their doctor, and if it persists, then we have them come in to do an evaluation of it,” she said.
But how common is supraclavicular or axillary lymphadenopathy after COVID-19 vaccination? Going back to the SBI advisory:
For patients receiving the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine, axillary swelling or tenderness (i.e., lymphadenopathy) was a solicited adverse event reported in 11.6% of patients (vs 5.0% for placebo) following dose 1 and 16.0% of patients (vs 4.3% for placebo) following dose 2.(9) Furthermore, lymphadenopathy was also reported as an unsolicited adverse event in 1.1% of persons in the vaccine group (vs 0.6% in the placebo group). Lymphadenopathy occurred in the arm and neck 2-4 days following vaccination with a median duration of 1-2 days.
For patients receiving the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine, lymphadenopathy was only reported as an unsolicited adverse event with 58 more cases in the vaccine group than the placebo group (64 vs 6 respectively).(10) Lymphadenopathy occurred in the arm and neck within 2-4 days of vaccination and lasted for a mean of 10 days. As lymphadenopathy was only reported as an unsolicited adverse event, the true incidence rate is likely higher. Reported rates and duration of adenopathy in both trials were based on clinical assessment (i.e., physical examination), and therefore rates and duration of subclinical adenopathy appreciable on mammography are likely greater. Anecdotally, mammographically detectable axillary adenopathy following COVID-19 vaccinations has been unilateral.
So basically the Moderna vaccine produced a significant incidence of axillary lymphadenopathy on the same side as vaccination in its phase 3 clinical trial, while the same adverse reaction was reported much less frequently after the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine in its phase 3 clinical trial. No doubt the recommendations will change as we learn more.
So what are antivaxxers doing with this? (I did, after all, point out at the beginning of the post that antivaxxers were going wild with this.) Well, let’s head on over to that factory of unhinged conspiracy theories, antivaccine quackery, and quackery in general, Natural News:
Yes and no. As I explained above, yes, axillary lymphadenopathy can be a symptom of breast cancer. It can also be a symptom of lymphoma, lung cancer, and other cancers, or it can be a symptom of infection or inflammation. Of course, Mike Adams’ minion Lance D. Johnson can’t resist going on about “inflammation”. (I sometimes wonder if these other “authors” for Adams’ site are just pen names for the man orchestrating the nonsense, but on the other hand not even Mike Adams could churn out the sheer quantity of conspiracy mongering and quackery on his site all by himself.) Here’s what I mean:
The vaccines are not only causing an inflammatory response in the arm of recipients, as seen with most vaccines, but the shots are also causing systemic inflammation throughout women’s breast tissue. The doctors are concerned because the inflammation goes up with each vaccine dose. After the first dose of the Moderna vaccine, women, on average, have 11 percent swollen lymph nodes in their breast tissue. After the second dose, the inflammation increases to 16% of their lymph nodes in breast tissue. The Moderna vaccine is built on the experimental mRNA platform that metaphorically terraforms human cells so they can support foreign virus replication. The mRNA platform alters cellular processes, causing unpredictable inflammation as the immune cells respond to these newly developed virus properties.
Um, no. Axillary lymph nodes are not in breast tissue. In fact, there’s even a membrane/fascia separating the breast tissue from the axillary fat and lymph nodes. Indeed, when I’m operating, I know I’m in the axilla when I divide that membrane and the different-appearing axillary fat starts to pouch out. Yes, there are a few lymph nodes in the breast itself. We encounter them during surgery sometimes and sometimes they are noted on pathology reports after breast surgery, but that’s not what radiologists have been reporting. Also, the COVID-19 vaccine is “terraforming human cells”? That’s a new antivax metaphor. I’ve heard the bogus claims that these mRNA-based vaccines are “gene therapy, not vaccines” (they are vaccines), and that they “reprogram your DNA” (they don’t), but “terraforming human cells”? That’s one seriously overblown metaphor there, truly next-level antivax nonsense! Also, mRNA vaccines do not alter cells to “support foreign virus replication”. They do one thing. They provide the template for the cells into which the mRNA enters to make a single protein (the spike protein) from SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. That’s it. The immune system does the rest.
Of course, to Adams, it’s all a conspiracy, because, well, everything is:
In order to conceal the evidence of this widespread vaccine injury, the doctors are changing mammogram guidelines and refusing to screen the breast tissue of women who were recently vaccinated for covid-19. The doctors now advise all women patients to reschedule their yearly mammograms, either before the first dose or four weeks after the second dose. “We don’t want these patients to get a false positive to have this sort of alarm,” Parkinson said.
And:
The doctors pride themselves in “saving lives” through early detection of breast cancer, but when it comes to vaccine injury, the doctors turn a blind eye and delay the screening process. Obviously, women and the rest of society are being deceived about the origins of cancer and chronic disease. Women are being misled about the underlying causes of inflammation that create the conditions for breast cancer to develop. Vaccination initiates an inflammatory process. The experimental mRNA vaccines are designed to reprogram cellular functions, to create spike proteins that will create even more inflammation throughout the body. The fact that the doctors are willing to forgo breast cancer detection after a woman is vaccinated, shows just how far the medical establishment will go to cover up vaccine injury and the true origins of cancer.
No, it just goes to show that anything that confounds the results of a screening test is not a good thing. Moreover, delaying screening mammography a few weeks is unlikely to be harmful in the vast majority of women, while unnecessary biopsies of lymph nodes can be harmful. Of course, leave it to antivaxxers to come up with a way to link the observation that COVID-19 vaccination can cause enlarged lymph nodes under the arm to the common antivax trope that vaccines cause systemic inflammation that leads to autoimmune diseases, cancer, and neuroinflammatory diseases.
I was surprised to see someone push back against this nonsense in the comments, a commenter by the name Dr. Stan:
Dr Stan here, Ive been an Emergency Physician for 28 years. Spent 18 years in the US Navy as a Corpsman and Medical Corps Officer. Joshua, you are a moron. Concerning the vaccines causing breast inflammation, this is pure bullshit. Concerning immunizations in general, they have saved millions of lives world-wide. The number of childhood deaths are way down thanks to the HIB and meningitis vaccines alone. The Covid virus is concerning because it seems to kill healthy people for no good reason. The new vaccines may help, probably won’t hurt. All the reports of weird untoward reactions are mostly journalistic hype, anything to get people to read your articles. So Mike, I think you should stop scaring your viewers with your bullshit comments about the vaccines.
I would quibble with Dr. Stan when he says that the new COVID-19 vaccines only “may help.” No, they will definitely help. He is, however, correct about vaccines in general and that the claim that the COVID-19 vaccine causes “breast inflammation” is BS; it causes local inflammation that can result in enlargement of the local lymph node basis, where lymph nodes do what lymph nodes, being part of the immune system, do when they encounter lymph drainage from an area of inflammation. They enlarge and get ready to combat potential threats. In any event, the rest of the comments (e.g., “oncologists are merchants of death”) are what you would expect in the comment section of Natural News.
The bottom line is that, practically speaking, the observation that a vaccine injected into the shoulder can cause inflammation of local lymph nodes, such as lymph nodes under the arm or above the clavicle, is a big nothing burger. Doctors have noted the phenomenon and changed breast imaging guidelines in a cautious and reasonable manner to compensate. It is indeed very important to reassure women by explaining this phenomenon clearly, but that’s not what antivaxxers are out to do. They want to frighten women into thinking that this observed adverse event means that the vaccine is causing some sort of inflammation that is causing breast cancer. Unfortunately, I fully expect that, sooner or later, antivaxxers will start finding anecdotes of women who developed enlarged lymph nodes after COVID-19 vaccination and were found to have breast cancer.
It’s coming, just as the claim that COVID-19 vaccines cause autism will be coming, just as soon as a COVID-19—any COVID-19 vaccine—is approved for children and babies. That’s how antivaxxers roll, and always have rolled.

Are vaccines driving the emergence of “escape mutant” variants of COVID-19?
Geert Vanden Bossche is back, and this time he’s blaming COVID-19 vaccines for driving the evolution of more dangerous “escape variants” of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes the disease, that are capable of evading vaccine-induced immunity. As antivaxxers making this argument always do, unfortunately, he ignores the much larger problem in which free circulation of the virus is a far more powerful driver of evolution than the relatively small proportion of the world population that has as yet been vaccinated.
David Gorski on August 16, 2021
Link

I was perusing the in box of my account for this blog last week, when I came across a bit of what I like to call “fan mail”. No, this wasn’t hate mail (which is what a lot of my “fan mail” consists of), but rather an email of the “Won’t you reconsider what you wrote about a crank?” variety. The crank is Geert Vanden Bossche, whom I first wrote about in March in the context of an open letter by him that had gone viral warning of global catastrophe if the mass vaccination campaign against COVID-19 were not stopped. The reason for his warning was a prediction that mass vaccination would select for more dangerous variants of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. This led a reader (whose name I will not reveal) to ask me whether, in light of the much more transmissible (and possibly more virulent) Delta variant that’s been spreading across the US like proverbial wildfire over the last few of months, I might want to “reconsider” my previous criticism of Vanden Bossche:
I just saw an MSN article about how doctors are terrified of what is coming…I wonder if perhaps you would reconsider your critique of Geert Vanden Bossche. He seems to have been prescient, even if the causes are not exactly as he had predicted. The media loves to call this a “pandemic of the unvaccinated,” but other countries have noted a high percentage of “cases” among the vaccinated, while the CDC found that in the Cape Cod incident, 75% of the infected were vaccinated, and, that they were just as likely to transmit the virus as the not vaccinated. If the idea that the vaccinated have very mild illness is true, they are much more probable to spread the illness. For example, they may not recognize their mild symptoms as COVID, and not consider that they, being vaccinated, are able to contract and spread it.
It is also a bit facile that you characterize Vanden Bossche as “anti vaxx.” This epithet seems to be tossed around at anyone who doesn’t suddenly rush out and take the mRNA vaccines. As well, the terms “conspiracy theorist” and “disinformation” get thrown around quite a bit, as if any debate or dissension from the media narrative is either gravely deluded, or perhaps even malicious.
This particular reader cited an article published on the conspiracy website ZeroHedge titled ‘Vaccine Expert Vanden Bossche Calls For “Immediate Halt” To Vaccinations, Says They Encourage “Escape Mutant” Variants‘. Included in that article are two interviews with Vanden Bossche, one by Dr. Chris Martenson for the Peak Prosperity vlog, titled “Vaccines: Awesome Ingenuity or A Huge Mistake?”:
And, of course, Bret Weinstein’s Dark Horse Podcast:
I note that evolutionary biologist turned COVID-19 contrarian and conspiracy theorist Bret Weinstein has been featured on SBM before, mainly for his promotion of the unproven anti-worm drug ivermectin as a miracle cure for COVID-19 based on very bad science and a massive misunderstanding of meta-analyses. I’m not going to go into the weeds of these podcasts so much, given that the viral ZeroHedge article that has been spreading around social media like a proverbial Delta variant of COVID-19 misinformation is much newer than either of those podcasts and links to a blog post by Vanden Bossche (ominously titled “C-19 Pandemia: Quo vadis, homo sapiens?”) that contains his latest arguments.
Before I get into the question of whether “Vanden Bossche was right” or not, first let me point out that I don’t use the terms “antivaxxer” and “conspiracy theorist” lightly. I only use them when the person being described is definitely spreading antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories, and I believe I documented quite thoroughly that Vanden Bossche was doing exactly that in his letter. Let’s just put it this way. When your prediction of “global catastrophe” to COVID-19 mass vaccination invokes almost exactly the same argument that the godfather of the modern antivaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield, used a mere three months before the reports of an outbreak of a novel coronavirus disease in Wuhan, China regarding measles and the MMR vaccine, you are antivaccine. Sure, Vanden Bossche adapted Wakefield’s arguments to the specifics of COVID-19 vaccination, but at its heart his was basically the same argument that Wakefield had made, that mass vaccination would drive the evolution of new variants of the virus being vaccinated against so that it would become more deadly and better able to evade a vaccine-acquired immune response. Indeed, as I described not long after he had published his article in the house journal of the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), Wakefield took his prediction to a ridiculous extreme, predicting a mass extinction of—you guessed it—humans due to ever more deadly measles variants selected for by mass MMR vaccination. Vanden Bossche predicted basically the same thing due to COVID-19 vaccination, even citing some of the same examples as Wakefield. Let’s just put it this way. When your message is approvingly embraced by antivaccine propagandists like Del Bigtree, either you yourself are antivaccine or you should really take it to heart that antivaxxers love you and rethink your arguments.
In fairness, one does have to acknowledge the difference in situations. The measles vaccine has been around since the early 1960s and the current MMR since the 1970s. In the US, 90%+ of children are vaccinated against measles, and we’ve been vaccinating against measles since the 1960s, with nary a hint of the emergence of deadly variants. So of course, Andrew Wakefield’s fear mongering was, on its face, easily identifiable as ridiculous. In the case of COVID-19, which hit Wuhan seemingly out of nowhere in late 2019 and was declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization (WHO) a mere three months later, in March 2020, the question of whether vaccination can cause the sort of scenario that Wakefield and Vanden Bossche are warning about seems much less ridiculous. The operative word, of course, is “seems”, and I can certainly see how the emergence of variants like the Delta variant in a mere few months since Vanden Bossche’s viral letter might seem to support a conclusion that his prediction was correct. Of course, one also must point out that the best “incubator” for evolutionary selection pressure to produce more transmissible variants that can evade the immune response is to have a virus circulating freely among billions of people and that there is nothing special about “natural” immunity compared to vaccine-acquired immunity to SARS-CoV-2 that would make it any less of an evolutionary selection pressure to select for more transmissible variants, the claims of advocates of “natural herd immunity” as a way out of the pandemic notwithstanding.
One also has to acknowledge that Vanden Bossche has altered Wakefield’s argument somewhat in that his core claim was that it is mass vaccination during a pandemic that is dangerous:
Having been featured on Dr. Chris Martenson’s Peak Prosperity and Bret Weinstein’s Dark Horse podcast, Vanden Bossche has been outspoken – yet measured and reasoned – in his critiquing of mass vaccinations during the midst of the Covid pandemic. One of his main gripes with vaccination efforts is that vaccinating during the middle of a pandemic could potentially lead to a long runway of variants, some of which may evolve to be far more difficult to deal with than the original Covid virus.
One can’t help but counter that the beginning of mass measles vaccination occurred when measles was endemic, with millions of cases a year each and every year and around 5,000-6,000 deaths a year due to the disease. Measles vaccination nearly eliminated the disease, bringing it to the point where, before Andrew Wakefield, the disease had been reduced to very low frequency, with deaths rare.
The return of the revenge of predictions of global disaster by Geert Vanden Bossche
What is Geert Vanden Bossche up to these days? What is he claiming now? What’s led to all the social media chatter about his latest claims, examples of which include:
https://t.co/PAQo2TThti
— Tom (@aneurincupboard) August 15, 2021
Another strong voice telling it like it is…https://t.co/x3t1ZSysBQ
— Back on Double Secret Probation (@thecraigrpowers) August 14, 2021
Of course if you bring it up, all the lemmings will shout anti-vax! So disappointing. https://t.co/hJojPpbvnw
— Victor Liew 🕐☯️📈 (@victorliew) August 14, 2021
I can’t help but note right here why Bret Weinstein, promoter of the unproven (and almost certainly ineffective) anti-helminthic drug ivermectin that he is, loves Geert Vanden Bossche’s message. Right in the very first summary paragraph of his blog post, Vanden Bossche advocates for, in addition to “calling an immediate halt to the mass vaccination program” for COVID-19, “replacing it [the mass vaccination program] by widespread use of antiviral chemoprophylactics while dedicating massive public health resources to scaling early multidrug treaments of Covid-19 disease.”You can also see why antivaxxers love the message, which is yet another variant (if you’ll excuse the term) of the favorite antivaccine trope that it is the vaccinated who spread disease, not the unvaccinated.
Vanden Bossche’s claim is the latest attempt to “flip the script” and, in response to the observation that it is the unvaccinated who can be a danger to the vaccinated by spreading disease given that no vaccine is 100% effective, has traditionally involved the claim that “shedding” of virus from the vaccine after vaccination can result in the infection of unvaccinated children who come into contact with the recently vaccinated. This claim dates back long before the pandemic and has long been used to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about attenuated live virus vaccines like the MMR and varicella (chickenpox) vaccines, leading to false claims before the pandemic that MMR strain measles was the “real” cause of measles outbreaks. Although shedding is not uncommon, cases of shedding leading to infection are vanishingly rare, making this basically a myth. Vaccinated children were not spreading measles and chickenpox. Antivaxxers have gone to ridiculous extremes trying to do the same thing with the mRNA- and adenovirus-based COVID-19 vaccines by claiming that the vaccinated “shed” the spike protein and that is causing people around them to become sick. Examples include, most famously, claims that women living with people who were vaccinated have suffered menstrual irregularities and even miscarriages as well as claims of general vague illnesses from “shed” spike protein. There is no good evidence to support these claims. As you will see, the invocation of the Delta variant, which can, it seems, be spread by vaccinated people, is just the latest “variant” of this attempt to “flip the script.”
So basically, Vanden Bossche is doubling down and pointing to the Delta variant as a harbinger of things to come. Of course, infectious disease epidemiologists had long been warning of something like the Delta variant and, like Vanden Bossche, warn that it could be a harbinger of worse variants to come. However, unlike Vanden Bossche, public health scientists see this variant as a warning that emphasizes the urgency to get as many people vaccinated as quickly as possible in order to forestall the emergence of still more variants. Unsurprisingly, Vanden Bossche doesn’t see the Delta variant the way that infectious disease epidemiologists do:
As of the early days of the mass vaccination campaigns, at least a few experts have been warning against the catastrophic impact such a program could have on global and individual health. Mass vaccination in the middle of a pandemic is prone to promoting selection and adaptation of immune escape variants that are featured by increasing infectiousness and resistance to spike protein (S)-directed antibodies (Abs), thereby diminishing protection in vaccinees and threatening the unvaccinated. This already explains why the WHO’s mass vaccination program is not only unable to generate herd immunity (HI) but even leads to substantial erosion of the population’s immune protective capacity. As the ongoing universal mass vaccination program will soon promote dominant propagation of highly infectious, neutralization escape mutants (i.e., so-called ‘S Ab-resistant variants’), naturally acquired, or vaccinal neutralizing Abs, will, indeed, no longer offer any protection to immunized individuals whereas high infectious pressure will continue to suppress the innate immune defense system of the nonvaccinated. This is to say that every further increase in vaccine coverage rates will further contribute to forcing the virus into resistance to neutralizing, S-specific Abs. Increased viral infectivity, combined with evasion from antiviral immunity, will inevitably result in an additional toll taken on human health and human lives. Immediate action needs, therefore, to be taken in order to dramatically reduce viral infectivity rates and to prevent selected immune escape variants from rapidly spreading through the entire population, whether vaccinated or not.
I can’t help but cite Andrew Wakefield again regarding measles, just to remind you how similar this argument is to Wakefield’s:
Antibiotic use has selected out multiply resistant, more dangerous, and more pathogenic strains of bacteria. This growing threat has led what many senior public health officials in the UK and the U.S. to describe as the “post-antibiotic apocalypse” and the “end of modern medicine.” It is estimated that 50,000 annual deaths occur in Europe and the U.S. from infections that “antibiotics have lost the power to treat.” So in fewer than 80 years, we have reached the point at which, for example, with prosthetic surgery, wards are being closed down, patients are being sent home, and operations are no longer possible, because once the prosthesis becomes infected with such bacteria, it is virtually impossible to get rid of them.
Are vaccines destined for a similar fate? It’s a very interesting question. One answer is, why not? For vaccines, resistance equates to strains of the microbe, the virus, or the bacteria that can elude the imperfect immunity created by the vaccine.
Let’s look at Vanden Bossche’s argument a bit further. On the surface, it appears to make sense. The problem with it, though, is simple. Each and every variant of concern (variants that either do or might lead to increased transmissibility of the virus or more severe disease) arose in populations with low vaccine uptake. For instance, the Delta variant was first identified in December 2020 in India. I can’t help but note that the first COVID-19 vaccines by Moderna and Pfizer were only just starting to be distributed then, and India was, aside from vaccine clinical trial participants, 100% unvaccinated, given that the variant had likely circulated at least a few weeks before being identified.
But, wait, you’re thinking: Didn’t the Delta variant spread in the US after the mass vaccination program was well under way? Oddly enough, Vanden Bossche doesn’t even refer to this rather obvious correlation that doesn’t mean causation, other than obliquely, noting that Delta is “now spreading very fast and as reserves of susceptible individuals become depleted as more and more youngsters become vaccinated.” This is, of course, not that surprising, given that this variant is so much more transmissible than the original SARS-CoV-2 and would be expected, all other aspects being equal, to outcompete less transmissible viruses. Moreover, the more transmissible the virus, the higher the percentage of the population that needs to be immune, either through vaccination or previous infection, to reach herd immunity. There’s a reason why measles, one of the most transmissible respiratory viruses there is, needs very high vaccine uptake for herd immunity.
So Vanden Bossche issues a dire warning:
In parallel with universal vaccination, more infectious strains have rapidly expanded in prevalence. According to molecular epidemiologists, Sars-CoV-2 is now also rapidly evolving towards resistance to S-specific Sars-CoV-2 Abs (9, 10). They have ascribed this to S-directed immune pressure that is now rapidly building up in the population. There can be no doubt that resistance to vaccinal Abs will be the endpoint of any mass vaccination program that uses modern vaccines during a pandemic of an acute self-limiting viral disease caused by a highly mutable virus.
Notice the cleverness of the wording. Vanden Bossche doesn’t say that these variants emerged after mass vaccination started, only that they have expanded in prevalence. Of course, in the absence of vaccination, one would naturally expect any strain that is more infectious to become more common in a population, particularly a variant (like Delta) that is several times more transmissible than the original Wuhan SARS-CoV-2. Given that few populations anywhere are anywhere near a level of vaccine uptake that one would expect to produce herd immunity, this claim is basically a meaningless observation, a correlation that doesn’t necessarily equal causation.
As noted by Alexis Madrigal, founder of the COVID Tracking Project:
One way to think about it, as the epidemiologist Ellie Murray has laid out, is that if Delta is as transmissible as the CDC thinks, we need a much higher percentage of our population vaccinated for immunizations and natural infection alone to cause the virus to peter out. Even when the huge majority of people in a given place have gotten the coronavirus or a shot, there might still be outbreaks, as the Brown University public-health expert Ashish Jha fears will happen in South Dakota after the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally.
These realities have already smashed the more optimistic projections of late spring, including my own. Having stared at these numbers for months and months with the COVID Tracking Project at The Atlantic, I never thought that we’d see hospitalization numbers higher than they were during the winter peak in any state. But here we are.
Madrigal also notes that there is a lot of randomness to where the worst outbreaks occur during pandemics, and this one is no different:
Back in the spring, when the variant we were most worried about was called Alpha, Michigan and almost Michigan alone got absolutely torched, matching its peak for hospitalizations from the winter. This didn’t happen anywhere else, though some epidemiologists expected it to, based on the experience of European countries. Alpha just kind of went away, and it seemed like the U.S. might be in the clear.
Enter Delta. In this surge, a piece of Missouri began to take off before the rest of the country. Would it be like Michigan? As we all now know, the answer was no. The southeastern United States is now experiencing huge outbreaks as many states come close to matching or surpassing their pandemic peaks in cases and hospitalizations.
The health-care system in north Florida is under pressure that few places have seen at any time during the entire pandemic. Why there? Why not somewhere else with similar vaccination rates and political opposition to viral countermeasures? No one knows with total certainty, and we’re unlikely to ever find out.
Vanden Bossche seems to sense that this is a weakness in his argument, which appears to be why (to me, at least) he pivots to the Lambda variant:
That viral resistance to S-specific neutralizing Abs may occur is anything but a myth. To my knowledge, the most compelling example of a variant capable of escaping neutralizing anti-S Abs is the lambda variant of Sars-CoV-2. This variant has incorporated an important change in the N-terminal domain (NTD) of its spike protein. This antigenic shift causes the virus to become resistant to neutralizing Abs. The change is caused by a deletion mutation and prevents neutralizing Abs from binding to the receptor-binding domain (RBD) of S (11). Thanks to this mutation, the lambda variant may gain a substantial competitive advantage if the virus is suddenly put under substantial and widespread S-directed immune pressure. A prominent surge in cases (as has been observed, for example, in several South American countries) may lead to a dramatic increase in S-directed immune pressure, especially in healthy people who become rapidly re-exposed to the virus as a result of a steep increase in infectious pressure. This explains how all of a sudden an immune escape mutant that is capable of resisting S-specific antibodies can rapidly become predominant in populations that experience a substantial surge in cases. But also populations that are subject to mass vaccination can exert strong immune pressure on viral infectiousness (i.e., on S protein). This suggests that high vaccine coverage rates eventually turn populations in excellent breeding grounds for such vaccine-resistant variants.
Again, most sources I find state that the Lambda variant was first identified in Peru in December 2020, but William Haseltine notes that the Lambda variant, which differs by 23 nucleotide changes and 18 amino acid changes from the original Wuhan strain, was identified in August 2020, again, before there were any vaccines, much less selective pressure to evade S-protein-based immunity due to a mass vaccination program. He also notes that 16 nucleotide mutations and 11 amino acid mutations lie outside the S gene that encodes the spike protein, adding that the effect “of any of these changes may be mitigated by changes in the ability of Lambda to enhance replication and improve down-regulation of the innate and adaptive immune response early in infection.” He has also noted that the variant is less susceptible to antibodies generated by the major vaccine used in South America.
In the US:
Genomic sequencing has identified 1,060 cases of Covid-19 caused by the Lambda variant in the United States so far, according to the independent data-sharing initiative GISAID. While that number is a far cry from the surge in cases caused by the Delta variant — representing about 83% of new cases in the US — infectious disease experts have said that Lambda is a variant they are watching closely.
So Lambda is currently driving a tiny fraction of the COVID-19 infections in the US. I’m a bit confused, too. Existing research (albeit still on a preprint server and not yet fully peer reviewed) found that after vaccination titers for Beta, Delta, Delta plus and, Lambda variants were decreased between 2.5- to 4-fold, which might sound like a lot, but is, as the authors described, only a modest decrease in neutralization, as they note in their conclusion:
In sera collected ~3 months post-second immunization, BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 mRNA vaccine elicited antibodies neutralized the variants with a modest 3-fold average decrease in titer resulting in an average IC50 of about 1:600, a titer that is greater than that of convalescent sera and likely, in combination with post-vaccination T- and B-cell memory responses, to provide durable protection.
In other words, Lambda is basically no more resistant to vaccine-induced antibody-mediate immunity than Delta or Beta, with a modest decrease in the titer needed to neutralize the spike protein. What this will mean in the real world remains to be determined by measuring the effectiveness of the various COVID-19 vaccines against these variants, but there is plenty of reason to conclude that the vaccines offer considerable protection against at least severe disease from these variants. The authors even say so!
But the innate immune system!
Antibodies alone are not the be-all and end-all of the immune system. That’s why Vanden Bossche also tries to do a bit of a shuffle in his arguments by invoking the innate immune system (as opposed to the adaptive immune response, which is the immune response provoked by a vaccine or infection, a specific response to the antigen challenge seen by the immune system). Early in the post, VandenBossche writes:
Innate immunity critically contributes to protecting a population from Covid-19. This is why children and healthy people (i.e., not immune suppressed and without underlying disease) are enjoying a significant degree of protection from Covid-19 disease. Natural, innate antibodies (Abs) and Natural Killer (NK) cells can target non-mutable common structures in otherwise highly mutating viruses and hence, deal with all Sars-CoV-2 variants (1)
This is, of course, largely speculation. The reference cited is a review article about animal models looking at innate antibodies (again, antibodies present in the body that weren’t induced by infection or antigen challenge and that were there before any such challenge) that doesn’t even look at SARS-CoV-2 or even other coronaviruses. He also cites other articles, but one only discusses what “innate antibodies” are, while the other discusses how such antibodies might be the “bridge” between innate and adaptive immunity. Basically, it’s all speculation without good experimental or clinical evidence. There has been lots of speculation why children suffer severe disease and complications so much less frequently than adults, particularly older adults, but if there is a well-accepted explanation for the differential virulence of COVID-19 that is based on age I am as yet unaware of it.
This recent review notes several possible reasons:
Factors proposed to explain the difference in severity of COVID-19 in children and adults include those that put adults at higher risk and those that protect children. The former include: (1) age-related increase in endothelial damage and changes in clotting function; (2) higher density, increased affinity and different distribution of angiotensin converting enzyme 2 receptors and transmembrane serine protease 2; (3) pre-existing coronavirus antibodies (including antibody-dependent enhancement) and T cells; (4) immunosenescence and inflammaging, including the effects of chronic cytomegalovirus infection; (5) a higher prevalence of comorbidities associated with severe COVID-19 and (6) lower levels of vitamin D. Factors that might protect children include: (1) differences in innate and adaptive immunity; (2) more frequent recurrent and concurrent infections; (3) pre-existing immunity to coronaviruses; (4) differences in microbiota; (5) higher levels of melatonin; (6) protective off-target effects of live vaccines and (7) lower intensity of exposure to SARS-CoV-2.
Notice how Vanden Bossche zeroed in like a laser on innate immunity, when there are several other plausible contributors to this difference in severity of COVID-19 in children compared to adults. (I’m also guessing that he doesn’t like that bit about potential nonspecific effects of live vaccines.)
That doesn’t stop Vanden Bossche, though. As you read this quote, remember that he, just like Wakefield, is trying to develop a competing COVID-19 vaccine based on “innate immunity,” specifically natural killer cells (more on what they are in a moment):
Innate immunity critically contributes to protecting a population from Covid-19. This is why children and healthy people (i.e., not immune suppressed and without underlying disease) are enjoying a significant degree of protection from Covid-19 disease. Natural, innate antibodies (Abs) and Natural Killer (NK) cells can target non-mutable common structures in otherwise highly mutating viruses and hence, deal with all Sars-CoV-2 variants (1). However, as they merely serve a first line of immune defense and have relatively low affinity, they’re not armed well enough to deal with high concentrations of pathogens (1, 2, 3). Although our innate immune defense system can be considered a very potent natural bioweapon against Sars-CoV-2, it is populated by Abs that can readily be outcompeted by spike protein (S)-specific Abs. This is because the binding affinity of antigen (Ag)-specific Abs for a specific antigen is much higher than the affinity of innate, polyreactive Abs for the same antigen (the latter primarily bind to multiple surface-expressed binding sites(*1) through multivalent interactions (*2); 3, 6, 7). This biophysical phenomenon already explains why morbidity and mortality rates tend to increase with increased infectious viral pressure (e.g., due to enhanced intrinsic infectiousness of the circulating virus or due to overcrowding, mass gatherings, close contacts etc., especially if combined with poor hygiene and housing conditions).
Again, this is all speculation and ignores a lot of other science. But of course to Vanden Bossche, it has to be the innate immune system, preexisting antibodies, and natural killer cells, which are “early responders” in the immune system that are unique in that they can recognize and kill stressed cells in the absence of antibodies and MHC, allowing for a much faster immune reaction and were named “natural killers” because it was observed that they do not require activation to kill cells that are missing “self” markers.
Flipping the script
Vanden Bossche also channels a favorite antivaccine talking point regarding COVID-19 vaccines:
As abundantly reported in the literature and social media, vaccinated subjects do not only spread Sars-CoV-2 variants (*4) but are now also increasingly developing symptomatic infections (*5).
This has been widely discussed in the media, as well as in the scientific literature, for instance, by Madrigal:
But it’s also become clear that vaccinated people who do get infected can spread the virus. The most recent piece of evidence came when American scientists were able to culture virus from samples taken from vaccinated people who’d gotten infected. Those same people showed similar viral loads to unvaccinated people. And yes, even those with asymptomatic infections.
Although that’s bad news, there is some good news too: Breakthrough infections appear to be significantly shorter than infections in the unvaccinated. That would reduce the amount of time that people with breakthrough infections could spread the virus.
There will undoubtedly be many more studies along these lines, and the papers cited above are preprints, meaning that they have not yet been peer-reviewed. But the data, including unpublished studies cited by public-health officials, are pointing in the same direction: Breakthrough infections are happening. And when they do, those people can spread the virus.
I always like to reemphasize here that, of course, some vaccinated people become infected. That was always expected, because no vaccine is 100% effective. Contrary to antivaxxers’ claims that these breakthrough infections mean that the vaccines are useless, less than 100% effectiveness is still effective, just not perfect. So, yes, vaccinated people can be infected with SARS-CoV-2, particularly the Delta variant. However, they are much less likely to become seriously ill because of it. Once infected with Delta, vaccinated people can transmit the virus to others. Also, as you might recall from the frenzied reporting when the CDC announced its findings and started recommending indoor masking again, vaccinated people infected with Delta can develop levels of virus in their respiratory system equal to what is observed in infected unvaccinated people, but, again, it appears that virus levels fall more quickly than in unvaccinated people and remain infectious for a shorter period of time.
This goes back to the concept of sterilizing immunity, in which the immunity of a vaccine is so effective that the virus cannot replicate in the vaccinated individual sufficiently to gain a foothold and cause infection, much less be transmissible by that person. In reality, sterilizing immunity exists for vaccines on a spectrum, as described in January in Scientific American:
Although many vaccines widely used today (against measles, for example) produce very effective sterilizing immunity, others, such as the hepatitis B vaccine, do not. With these vaccines, an individual’s immune system is trained to prevent illness, yet the pathogen can persist in that person’s body, potentially allowing them to infect others. A lack of sterilizing immunity means that the pathogen can continue to circulate in a population, where it may cause illness in unvaccinated and vulnerable people or evolve to evade our immune responses, Bowdish explains.
And an example:
The case of rotavirus—which causes severe vomiting and watery diarrhea and is especially dangerous to infants and young children—is fairly straightforward. Vaccination limits, but does not stop, the pathogen from replicating. As such, it does not protect against mild disease. By reducing an infected person’s viral load, however, it decreases transmission, providing substantial indirect protection. According to the Centers for Disease Control, four to 10 years after the 2006 introduction of a rotavirus vaccine in the U.S., the number of positive tests for the disease fell by as much as 74 to 90 percent.
Another favorite example cited by antivaxxers is pertussis, because the vaccine doesn’t produce sterilizing immunity:
For example, vaccines against Bordetella pertussis, the primary bacterium that causes whooping cough, or pertussis, do a great job of preventing illness but do not entirely clear the pathogen. Rather, as B. pertussis replicates in the upper respiratory tract, vaccine-induced antibodies apply pressure via natural selection to weed out bacteria whose disease-causing genes are turned on. Because these same genes are responsible for the parts of the microorganisms that are targeted by antibodies, bacteria that keep them turned off evade the immune response and hang out undetected in the upper respiratory tract, Bowdish explains. This becomes a problem when someone with a naive immune system, such as an infant, contracts the pathogen. In the absence of antibodies, B. pertussis‘s disease-causing genes become activated again, causing illness. Nevertheless, the introduction of pertussis vaccines in the 1940s cut annual U.S. cases from more than 100,000 to fewer than 10,000 by 1965. In the 1980s cases began slowly climbing again as parents increasingly refused to vaccinate their children. Today there is renewed focus on reducing the chance of exposure and getting antibodies to infants by immunizing pregnant women and new mothers.
Again, in medicine, as in life, nothing is 100% certain except that each and every one of us will one day die, and efficacy for any intervention exists on a spectrum, and even a nonsterilizing vaccine can be very, very useful:
In a paper in the October 2020 issue of the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, researchers modeled what a COVID-19 vaccine with varying types of protection could mean. They found that if a vaccine protects 80 percent of those immunized and 75 percent of the population is vaccinated, it could largely end an epidemic without other measures such as social distancing. “Otherwise, you won’t be able to rely on the vaccine to return us to ‘normal,'” says Bruce Y. Lee, a co-author of the paper and a professor at the CUNY Graduate School of Public Health and Health Policy. That is, if the vaccine only prevents disease or reduces viral shedding rather than eliminating it, additional public health measures may still be necessary. Even so, Lee stressed that a widespread nonsterilizing vaccine could still reduce burden on the health care system and save lives.
You might note that antivaccine “thinking” tends to be black and white. Either the vaccine is 100% effective, or it’s crap; the vaccine is either 100% safe, or it’s deadly. Like Vanden Bossche, they are very clever at sounding complex and nuanced in the service of demonizing vaccines. Vanden Bossche tries to impress with jargon and his handwaving invocation of variants coupled with invocations of natural killer cells and the innate immune system, and it does sound very impressive indeed. However, at its heart, it’s all speculation without any firm evidence, as well as a “reimagining” (if you will) of the old-fashioned antivaccine tropes that vaccines are (1) ineffective (Vanden Bossche’s claim that they don’t work against variants); (2) dangerous; and (3) make the vaccinated dangerous to the unvaccinated (Vanden Bossche’s claim that vaccines drive the evolution of more transmissible and dangerous variants).
Is it possible that SARS-CoV-2 could evolve variants that evade immunity from vaccines? Of course. Vaccination is a selective pressure, but it’s just one of many, and the current crop of variants all evolved before there even was a mass vaccination program. The bottom line is that the best way to forestall the development of further variants, one or more of which might be able to evade the immune response, whether due to prior infection or due to vaccination, is by vaccinating as many people as possible as fast as possible and following public health interventions:
We do not know yet whether this variant is more concerning than the Delta variant,” pharmacist and epidemiologists Dr. Ravina Kullar, who is an expert with the Infectious Diseases Society of America, wrote in an email on Friday.
“There needs to be extensive genomic surveillance studies that are done to assess how the vaccines’ efficacy is affected by the Lambda variant,” Kullar wrote. Until Covid-19 cases overall decrease, “the best way to prevent the emergence of more variants is getting fully vaccinated, not traveling internationally, and following strict infection prevention measures including wearing a face mask, physically distancing from others, and not attending large social gatherings.”
The CDC concurs. The bottom line is that the best conditions for the emergence of more dangerous and transmissible variants are when SARS-CoV-2 is spreading unchecked all over the world through billions of people. The best way to decrease the chances of variants like this emerging is to do whatever is feasible to decrease transmission and thereby dramatically decrease the number of people being infected. The vaccines work, but probably not as well for the Delta variant. Moreover, vaccination doesn’t have to completely block transmission to be effective in helping to end the pandemic. Finally, Vanden Bossche hasn’t said anything new compared to his previous claims. He’s just pointed to the emergence of more transmissible variants, which happened before the mass vaccination program, and blamed the vaccine for them.

Why antivax arguments for COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” remind me of homeopathy
An antivaxxer by the ‘nym “A Midwestern Doctor” makes an argument that COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” is not impossible despite the basic science that concludes it is. Sound familiar?
David Gorski on January 15, 2024
Tweet

It’s been a long time since I’ve written about the antivaccine myth of “shedding,” particularly in the context of COVID-19 vaccines. As you might recall, shedding is a real phenomenon, but only for vaccines made from live attenuated virus (LAV); i.e. vaccines that use a weakened version of the pathogenic virus in order to cause a harmless infection that can stimulate an immune response that protects against the fully pathogenic version of the virus causing the disease targeted. Examples of currently used LAV vaccines include vaccines against measles, mumps, rubella, rotavirus, varicella, and influenza (the intranasally administered vaccine). Because LAV vaccines contain live virus, people vaccinated with them can in some cases “shed” vaccine-strain virus for a period of time afterward. However, the “attenuated” in LAV means that this virus is attenuated, which means that infection caused by it is asymptomatic or very weakly symptomatic. In the age of the pandemic, I must admit that I was surprised when this particularly antivax myth reared its ugly head mere weeks after the mRNA-based vaccines were released, mainly because with these viruses there is no molecular or biological mechanism for “shedding” of mRNA, the spike protein it produces, or anything else to affect others. Yet the myth persists, What inspired me to write about it again after all this time was a post by an antivax quack who goes by the ‘nym A Midwestern Doctor (AMD) entitled What Is The Current Evidence for mRNA Vaccine Shedding? Even as AMD asks, “And how can you protect yourself from it?” I started to realize just how much his arguments remind me of those of homeopaths.
I also note that COVID-19 antivax quack Pierre Kory has also written a whole long nine-part series on shedding that turns out to be in essence a much longer version of the same sorts of tactics AMD used. I might well address parts of Dr. Kory’s posts that are not included in AMD’s post in a future SBM post, but for purposes of this one I will (mostly) refer to AMD’s “musings.”
First, though, let’s delve into a bit of background, and then I will discuss AMD’s claims about COVID-19 vaccine shedding, concluding with why such rationales remind me very much of the “scientific” rationales proposed by homeopaths and defenders of other incredibly implausible alternative medicine treatments—I’m also talking about you, reiki and other forms of “energy medicine”—to try to deceive people that something that is so implausible from a basic science standpoint as to be, for all intents and purposes, impossible is actually plausible.
How big a deal is shedding in real life?
As I wrote above, LAV vaccines generally don’t replicate as well as and are much less virulent than the original strains causing disease. They thus produce immunity to wild-type pathogenic organisms—wild type (WT) denotes the unmodified virus “out in the wild” that causes disease—without the patient’s having to endure the risks of going through the disease caused by the virus. Still, because an actual viral infection is involved, no matter how mild or even asymptomatic, when LAV vaccines produce immunity, generally this type of vaccine is not recommended for patients who have an impaired immune system due to concern about even the weakened virus strains used in LAV vaccines being able to cause significant infection.
Prepandemic, one precaution frequently recommended at pediatric cancer centers regarding LAV vaccines was to keep children whose immune systems had been impaired by chemotherapy away from their siblings who had received LAV vaccines, such as MMR, for a period of time. Guidelines published a decade ago by the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) include different recommendations for different LAV vaccines. For example, the IDSA states that healthy people who live with an immunocompromised person can receive the following live vaccines without endangering that person:
    • MMR (measles, mumps and rubella)
    • Varicella & Zoster (chickenpox and shingles)
    • Rotavirus
    • Yellow Fever
    • Typhoid
However, the guidelines also stated that persons living with anyone who is immunocompromised should not receive the OPV, because of the risk of transmitting vaccine strain polio to others and the possibility of that strain reverting to wild-type polio. The IDSA also recommended that highly immunocompromised patients—e.g., those receiving cancer therapy or a bone marrow transplant—should not handle the diapers of infants who received rotavirus vaccine for 4 weeks after the vaccination and should avoid contact with people who develop skin lesions after receiving varicella or zoster vaccines until the lesions resolve. Last year, the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices incorporated the 2013 IDSA guidelines and updated them to state:
Household contacts and other close contacts of persons with altered immunocompetence should receive all age- and exposure-appropriate vaccines, with the exception of smallpox vaccine (12,13). Receipt of vaccines will prevent the vaccine-preventable disease, so there can be no potential transmission to the contact with altered immunocompetence. The live MMR, varicella, and rotavirus vaccines should be administered to susceptible household contacts and other close contacts of immunocompromised patients when indicated. No specific precautions are needed unless the varicella vaccine recipient has a rash after vaccination, in which case direct contact with susceptible household contacts with altered immunocompetence should be avoided until the rash resolves (14,15). All members of the household should wash their hands after changing the diaper of an infant who received rotavirus vaccine. This minimizes rotavirus transmission, as shedding may occur up to one month after the last dose (16,17). Household and other close contacts of persons with altered immunocompetence should receive annual influenza vaccination. Introduction of low levels of vaccine viruses into the environment likely is unavoidable when administering LAIV. LAIV vaccine viruses are cold-adapted, so they can replicate in the nose and generate an immune response without entering the lungs (i.e., they are temperature sensitive and replicate poorly at core body temperatures). No instances have been reported of illness caused by attenuated vaccine virus infections among health-care providers or immunocompromised patients. LAIV may be administered to healthy household and other close contacts of persons with altered immunocompetence unless the person with altered immunocompetence is in a protective environment, typically defined as a specialized patient-care area with a positive airflow relative to the corridor, high-efficiency particulate air filtration, and frequent air changes (3). No preference exists for inactivated influenza vaccine use by health-care workers or other persons who have close contact with persons with lesser degrees of immunosuppression (e.g., persons with diabetes, persons with asthma taking high-dose corticosteroids, or persons infected with HIV), and no preference exists for inactivated influenza vaccine use by health-care workers or other healthy persons aged 5-49 years in close contact with all other groups at high risk.
There you have it, reasonable precautions based on copious evidence. As for vaccinating patients with significant immunocompromised, all indicated non-live vaccines continue to be recommended, although they might not generate as much of an immune response, and there is even emerging evidence that some LAV vaccines can be safely administered to immunosuppressed people. Despite that, before the pandemic, antivaxxers would routinely engage in fear mongering about LAV vaccines that was unwarranted and not based in science or evidence. Let’s just say that antivax fear mongering about COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” is even less based in science than prepandemic fear mongering about vaccine shedding before the pandemic. That was a real thing, but nowhere near as dangerous as portrayed by antivaxxers.
In contrast, COVID-19 vaccine shedding is not a real thing because it can’t be, much as homeopathy doesn’t work because the laws of physics and chemistry say that it can’t.
A Midwestern Doctor addresses “shedding” due to COVID-19 vaccines. Hilarity ensues.
With that science- and evidence-based background regarding the real issues involved with LAV vaccines and the shedding of vaccine strain viruses, let’s take a look at what AMD writes. As is frequently my won’t, I will start at the beginning of his Substack (of course) post:
When doctors in this movement speak at events about the vaccines, by far the most common question they receive is “is vaccine shedding real?”
This is understandable as this vaccine shedding (becoming ill from vaccinated individuals) represents the one way the unvaccinated are also at risk from the vaccines and hence still need to be directly concerned about them.
Simultaneously, this is a difficult question to answer for a few key reasons.
No, it’s actually not a difficult question to answer for a few key reasons. First, as I will explain in a moment, from a basic science standpoint, the claim that COVID-19 vaccines shed anything—mRNA, spike protein, lipid nanoparticles, evil humors, anything—is so incredibly implausible as to be, for all intents and purposes, impossible. I will grant you that the contention is not (quite) homeopathy-level impossible, mainly because there is actual mRNA, spike protein, and lipid nanoparticles involved, but the amounts and concentrations are minuscule.
But let’s see what AMD’s “few key reasons” are, starting with his last reason first, well, just because:
Finally, in theory, shedding with the mRNA vaccines should be “impossible.” Because of this, stating it’s real puts anyone who does so in a very awkward position.
If by “awkward position,” AMD means the position of arguing for something that is, for all intents and practical purposes, scientifically impossible, I’ll concede his point. That certainly would be an “awkward position”; that is if you have a sense of shame. Most antivaxxers do not; so arguing for something so unsupported by science is really not an “awkward position” for most of them to be in.
But before discussing that point further, let’s see what AMD lists as the other “key reasons” that make arguing for COVID-19 vaccine shedding a “difficult question” to him:
First and foremost, we believe it is critical to not publicly espouse divisive ideas (e.g., “PureBloods” vs. those who were vaccinated) that prevent the public from coming together and helping everyone. The vaccines were marketed on the basis of division (e.g., by encouraging immense discrimination against the unvaccinated), and many unvaccinated individuals thus understandably hold a lot of resentment for how the vaccinated treated them. We do not want to perpetuate anything similar (e.g., discrimination in the other direction).
Likewise, we don’t want to create any more unnecessary fear—which is an inevitable consequence of opening up a conversation about shedding.
I get it. AMD is one of those antivaxxers who wants to be seen as rational and scientific; so of course he doesn’t like the idea of “purebloods” adopted by the antivaccine movement.
One point I’ve long made about so-called “alternative” medicine is to emphasize just how many of its precepts are more religious than rational or scientific in nature. In particular, a huge part of alternative medicine relies on the concept that “contamination” (these days more frequently referred to as “toxins”) cause most, if not all, disease. Several years ago, I started pointing out how the various “detoxification” regimens that make up so much of alternative medicine (and, not coincidentally, the basis of many treatments for many conditions—like autism—that antivaxxers used to attribute to vaccines) had more in common with religious ritual purification than they did with science or medicine. This concept of “purity” versus “contamination” (the latter implied to be with evil) also has a lot to do with the idea that “natural immunity” to a disease (which in reality should be called post-infection immunity given that vaccine-induced immunity is natural) and has infected the discourse over COVID-19 vaccines, so much so that one of my go-to video clips when discussing this topic is of Brigadier General Jack D. Ripper from one of my favorite movies of all time, Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb explaining how fluoridation is a Communist plot to “sap and impurify” the “precious bodily fluids” of real Americans. Why? Because anti-fluoridation, antivaccine, and anti-GMO pseudoscience all tap into the alternative medicine fear of “contamination” as a cause of ill health and “purity of essence” (again, from Dr. Strangelove) as key to good health. Not coincidentally, concepts of “contamination” versus “purity” (or even “pureblood” or “purebloods”) are also behind the fear stoked by antivaxxers that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines “permanently alter” your DNA, thus contaminating and corrupting it with evil (the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein).
The term “purebloods” comes, of course, from the Harry Potter novels and movies, in which a “pureblood” denoted a wizard without any muggle ancestry, “muggles” being the term for non-magical humans. In the Harry Potter universe, the main villain Lord Voldemort, as well as his followers, preached an ideology in which “purebloods” were considered superior (and thus born to rule the wizard world) compared to “half-bloods” (wizards with some muggle ancestry) and muggles, who were viewed as lesser beings, as denoted by the slur used by “purebloods” to describe them, “mudblood.” The term “pureblood” thus not-so-subtly echoes Nazi ideology. After all, it’s not as though it wasn’t incredibly clear in the Harry Potter novels and movies that the magical “pureblood”/”mudblood” dichotomy was a very obvious metaphor for Nazi beliefs about racial “purity” and the superiority of the “Aryan” race. Indeed, muggles were viewed (with disgust) by Voldemort and his followers as inferiors (much like the way Nazis viewed Jews and other “inferior races”) and were thought to be “contaminating” the pure wizard race. Voldemort even expressed horror at the thought of wizards mating with Muggles and having children that was every bit as strong as the disgust that Nazis expressed at the thought of Jews mixing with “pure Aryans.”
No wonder AMD doesn’t want to be associated with this idea! Who would, other than actual fascists? Besides being fascist and racist in origin, the idea of the COVID vaccine “pureblood” has led to all sorts of embarrassing antics by antivaxxers, including dating services for the unvaccinated, “unvaccinated” blood banks (using the term “SafeBlood“), and an antivaxxer like Del Bigtree actually refusing transfusion for a life-threatening hemorrhage until he could fly to a quack clinic in Mexico to receive “unvaccinated blood.”
Nonetheless, AMD states:
That being said, from having looked into this extensively, I am relatively sure of the following:
     1.  Shedding is very real.
     2.  People’s sensitivity to it greatly varies.
     3.  Most of the people who are highly sensitive to shedding have already figured it out, so if you do not already believe it is an issue for you, you probably don’t need to worry about it.
     4.  There is still no agreed upon mechanism to explain why it happens.
For all of these reasons, we would greatly appreciated if you could share your shedding experiences. Those stories are being collected here.
Anecdotes. Of course, AMD wants anecdotes. Let’s see what “evidence” he can muster to support his contentions that shedding is “very real” and that people’s “sensitivity to it greatly varies.”
The mechanistic “trap”?
AMD, like many homeopaths, is at least smart enough to know that basic science doesn’t support what he’s laying down. Remember that homeopathy is based on two main principles, which homeopaths call “laws”: the Law of Similars and the Law of Infinitesimals. The Law of Similars is often paraphrased as “like cures like” and states that to cure a disease or relieve a symptom, you treat the patient with something that causes that symptom. There is, of course, no scientific basis for a general rule or “Law” that using something that causes a symptom will relieve a symptom. Homeopathy’s founder Samuel Hahneman made that up based on late 18th century beliefs about medicine and how the human body worked. (I note that theories that diseases were caused by “miasmas” or imbalances in the four humors still predominated then.)
The Law of Infinitesimals is even less plausible or supported by evidence.I also find it the easiest to explain to the uninitiated why this “law” is utter bunk. In brief, the Law of Infinitesimals states that homeopathic remedies become stronger with dilution. Indeed, the process of making a homeopathic remedy involves serial dilution, usually 1:100. The mother tincture (or original compound or medicine) is diluted 1:100 and then shaken vigorously (succussed), the succussion step being claimed by homeopaths to be absolutely essential to “potentize” the remedy. After that, the remedy is diluted again in the same way. Each 1:100 dilution is designated by “C”, such that a 6C dilution equals six 1:100 dilutions. The problem comes with the higher dilutions. For instance, a 12C solution is on the order of a 10-24 dilution ((10-2)12 = 10-24). Many homeopathic remedies are on the order of 30C, which is a 10-60 dilution, or more than 1036-fold greater than Avogadro’s number. Some homeopathic remedies go up to 100C or more, or 10-200. Here’s a hint: The number of atoms in the known universe is estimated to be around 1078 to 1082. The math just doesn’t work, and remedies over around 12C are basically water. “Lesser” dilutions contain so little remedy that it’s highly unlikely that they have a pharmacological effect. How do homeopaths explain this? They then concede that there isn’t any actual remedy left in the “stronger” homeopathic dilutions, but that water retains the “memory” of the substance that it had been in contact with.
As is often my wont, too, I will include this video of Richard Dawkins explaining why homeopathy is pure pseudoscience, as it is, despite some of Dawkins’ hot takes on social issues, the best two minute encapsulation of why homeopathy is nonsense:
And, because of the humor potential, I also can’t resist including this Mitchell & Webb sketch. It makes fun of more than just homeopathy, but the parts of the sketch about homeopathy—homeopathic lager, anyone?—are particularly cutting:
Why did I just explain for the umpteenth time on this blog why homeopathy is physically impossible or, as I like to say, how for homeopathy to work large swaths of well-established physics and chemistry would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong? Simple. Homeopaths make an argument very much like what AMD uses, namely that focusing on “mechanism” doesn’t mean that homeopathy doesn’t work, much less that it can’t work. Check out what I mean in this quote by AMD:
In the previous article (which provides important context for the ideas laid forth in this one) I discussed the habitual tendency of science to reject observations which have no mechanism that could explain how they are happening. In turn, I argued this was problematic as it results in many critically important observations being dismissed since their “mechanism” lies outside the existing scientific paradigm.
One of the most common ways this happens is for logical arguments to be put together which assert the observation cannot be real. In some cases, the argument is quite compelling, while in others (provided you understand the subject) it’s actually ridiculous.
See what I mean? There is, of course, a germ of truth in this deceptive argument in that sometimes science is too quick to reject a claim based on known science and known biological or physical mechanisms. (Indeed, I was shocked that AMD didn’t cite Ignaz Semmelweis, handwashing, and puerperal fever; Barry Marshall, Robin Warren, and the discovery of H. pylori as a major cause of peptic ulcer disease; or citrus fruits as a preventative for scurvy in the 18th century, those being three of the favorite go-to examples that quacks love to cite of real medical phenomena initially dismissed because there was no known biological mechanism for them at the time they were proposed.) Homeopaths love to claim that a lack of a known mechanism doesn’t mean that their quackery works, too, even though the physics and chemistry demonstrating that homeopathy is physically impossible are even stronger than the chemistry and biology showing that COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” doesn’t and can’t happen. Like antivaxxers, COVID-19 quacks often make up fantastical implausible and unproven physical “mechanisms” like “water memory” being due to “chains of nano-pearls.”
Indeed, we at SBM frequently point out a couple of things in response to these sorts of arguments. First, it is not necessary to know the exact mechanism of some putative effect in order to deem that effect plausible. This seems so obvious that it ought not be necessary to repeat it over and over again, and yet the topic can’t be broached without some nebbishy South Park do-gooder chanting a litany of “just because you don’t know how it works doesn’t mean it can’t work,” as if that were a compelling or even relevant rebuttal. Let’s get this straight once and for all: IT ISN’T. Let’s put it this way (as I like to phrase it), “plausibility ≠ knowing the biological mechanism.” Revisiting homeopathy, the point is not that we don’t know a particular mechanism for homeopathy, for example; the point is that any proposed mechanism would necessarily violate scientific principles that rest on far more solid ground than any number of equivocal, bias-and-error-prone clinical trials could ever hope to overturn. The same is true for “energy medicine” and for claims based on non-existent anatomical structures (iridology, reflexology, auricular acupuncture, meridians, chiropractic “subluxations”), non-existent physiologic functions (“craniosacral rhythms“), or non-existent anatomic-physiologic relations (“neurocranial restructuring,” “detoxification” with coffee enemas, dissolving tumors with orally administered pancreatic enzymes). The spectrum of implausible health claims euphemistically dubbed “CAM” or “integrative medicine” is full of such nonsense, and so is the spectrum of implausible claims by people like AMD related to COVID-19 vaccines, including “shedding.”
In light of that discussion, here’s the example that AMD uses to justify his dismissal of biological plausibility as a reason that COVID-19 vaccine shedding doesn’t occur, much less sicken those who come into contact with those vaccinated against COVID-19:
For example, since the mRNA vaccines were an experimental gene therapy, one of the immediate fears people had about them (myself included) was that they would permanently alter your DNA.
To address this, countless articles were written which ridiculed that notion. This was done by repeating a few logical arguments which sounded nice and were deemed to be “true” because the “experts” had espoused them (e.g. consider these frequently cited pronouncements by Paul Offit and Anthony Fauci). Those arguments were as follows:
     1.  The vaccines cannot enter the nucleus of the cell
     2.  mRNA from the vaccines breaks down rapidly in the cell, so it does not have time to enter the nucleus and change your DNA.
     3.  mRNA is not DNA, and hence believing mRNA can change DNA represents a fundamental lack of knowledge of biology.
On the surface, that train of logic effectively “refutes” the DNA alteration hypothesis. However, in reality, each of the above premises was false or highly misleading (e.g., the mRNA was designed to resist being broken down so it could remain active for a prolonged period).
AMD then goes on to cite the usual dubious studies and “evidence” supposedly showing that the mRNA in the vaccine (or the plasmid DNA left over in the vaccine) can get into the nucleus and “permanently alter your DNA,” even causing “turbo cancers.” Given that I’ve written about just about all of these studies before over the last three and a half years, I see no need to refute this in depth other than to cite the posts (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here, among other places) and point out that this is a common quack technique, to propose a “mechanism” for quackery based on poor quality studies or the willful misinterpretation of decent studies. Again, this is a lot like homeopaths, reiki practitioners, acupuncturists, and other advocates of implausible/impossible treatments.
Basically, there is no known plausible biological mechanism by which mRNA vaccines can “permanently alter” your DNA in the ways claimed by antivaxxers like AMD. This statement is based on a body of scientific evidence so large that all you really need to do is to read an introductory-level book on molecular biology to understand why the claim is so incredibly implausible. To overturn biology as established as the “central dogma,” you need very compelling counterevidence, and nothing presented by AMD or other antivaxxers qualifies. As I also like to say, it is theoretically possible to demonstrate that homeopathy works, but that would require evidence so clear-cut and irrefutable that it leads us to question very well-established physics and chemistry. Similarly, it is theoretically possible that somehow mRNA vaccines “permanently alter your DNA” in a way to cause harm (such as “turbo cancer”), but demonstrating such a phenomenon would require clear-cut and irrefutable evidence that leads virologists and molecular biologists to question very well-established biology and genetics. That’s incredibly unlikely. I will concede that it’s not as unlikely as a discovery by homeopaths leading physicists and chemists to question well established laws of physics and chemistry, but it’s pretty damned unlikely, so much so as to be, for all practical purposes, impossible.
Look for COVID-19 quacks to misrepresent what I just wrote; that is, if they respond at all.
mRNA vaccines and COVID-19
mRNA vaccines rely on something I’ve discussed before, namely the “central dogma” of molecular biology. I must admit, I’ve always hated the use of the word “dogma” associated with science, but no less a luminary than Francis Crick first stated it in 1958, and it has been restated over the years in various ways. Perhaps my favorite version of the central dogma was succinctly stated by Marshall Nirenberg in 1958 and has since been commonly paraphrased to say, “DNA makes RNA makes protein”, which about summed up all of molecular biology in five words. (Why I used the past tense in a moment.) In any event, for purposes of understanding RNA viruses, this is the main sequence that you need to understand:
Basically, DNA replicates from a DNA template and results in a double-stranded molecule that is very stable, as it has complementary sequences that tightly bind to each other in a sequence-specific fashion. This DNA template is unwound by enzymes that use the template to make RNA strands, which are single-stranded, which is then used by a ribosome to make protein out of amino acids. Again, to put it simply, each nucleotide equals one letter of the code; each three-nucleotide sequence (codon) equals one “word” that translates to an amino acid. Given that there are four nucleotides, there are 64 possible codons. Since there are only 20 amino acids, that means that most amino acids are encoded by more than one combination of nucleotides or more than one codon; i.e., the genetic code is redundant. Of course, it’s more complicated than that, as this diagram shows:
For instance, messenger RNA (mRNA) doesn’t always start out fully formed. Often it’s made as a longer precursor molecule that is spliced to the final mRNA sequence before being transported out of the nucleus into the cytoplasm to be used to make protein. In fact, it’s even more complicated than that. Remember how I used the past tense when I said that the central dogma summed up all of molecular biology? It did, but then we started finding exceptions to the central dogma, such as retroviruses and microRNAs that can regulate gene expression, for instance. You don’t really need to know the gory details of many of these, although I will mention a couple of relevant ones and refer you to a post that does go into the gory details, for anyone who’s really interested.
Exceptions aside, RNA vaccines consist mainly of, well, RNA. One problem with RNA vaccines is that RNA is an inherently unstable molecule. It is, after all, a messenger. It doesn’t need to persist any longer than the message needs to be made. In aqueous solution, RNA molecules rapidly degrade. Indeed, the instability of RNA is why public health experts have been concerned about distributing RNA vaccines. Both companies adopted a similar strategy in designing their mRNA to encode the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein with stabilizing mutations added to lock this surface protein into a form easily recognizable to the immune system and therefore make it a better antigen. Pfizer and Moderna also used modified nucleosides (the RNA equivalent to DNA nucleotides) that are more stable to make their RNAs, and placed their RNA within a lipid nanoparticle (LNP) delivery system in which LNPs fuse with the cell membrane to deliver the RNA to the cytoplasm. Together, this system leads the mRNA for the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein being delivered to the cytoplasm of the muscle cells, where the ribosomes use it as a template to make the spike protein, which then serves as the antigen that stimulates the immune system to produce antibodies against it.
Now here’s the thing. Unlike LAV vaccines, mRNA vaccines cannot replicate. They do not contain a viable virus. Moreover, each dose of vaccine only contains either 30 μg (Pfizer) or 100 μg (Moderna) of mRNA. That’s micrograms—not a lot. In addition, the amount of spike protein made as a result of vaccination with mRNA vaccines is tiny, as I discussed before; the amount detectable in the bloodstream after vaccination is on the 30-40 pg/mL (1 pg = 10-12 g) for a few days. This makes the frequent fear mongering by antivaxxers about “shedding” of spike protein from the vaccinated somehow causing illness in people who come into contact with them approach almost homeopathy-level implausibility, particularly when you remember that the experiments showing toxicity due to spike protein in cell culture frequently cited by antivaxxers as a reason that “shedding” of the spike protein might sicken others used a 100,000x higher concentration of spike protein than can be detected in the bloodstream after vaccination. That’s not homeopathy-level, but it’s getting there.
That doesn’t even ask the question: Can spike protein even be shed? There is no good evidence that it can, much less that it can sicken others. Similarly, even though there is some evidence that mRNA fragments from the vaccine can find their way into breast milk, again, it’s important to remember that mRNA consisted of fragments, the concentration was tiny, and none was detected later than 48 hours after vaccination. Some “shedding”!
Anecdotes and conspiracy theories: The commonalities between “shedding,” homeopathy, and other impossibly implausible treatments
Amusingly, AMD even basically concedes all what I just discussed in the previous section, in essence admitting that “shedding” should be impossible:
In the case of shedding, a few major points argued against it being possible.
    • The design of the mRNA vaccines was that lipid nanoparticles containing mRNA were injected in the body, after which they made their way into cells and causes cells to begin producing vaccine spike protein for an unspecified amount of time.
    • Because of this, there were relatively few options of what could be shed. For instance, while it is unlikely the lipid nanoparticles or the mRNA it contained could be transmitted from the vaccinated individuals to their environment, if it could be, there was very little to transmit, so it was simply not possible a single injection could contain enough vaccine material to perpetually sicken those around the vaccinated individual.
    • The only other option was the spike protein being produced by the vaccine was the agent that “shed” (e.g., because the mRNA didn’t break down and hence produced spike indefinitely or because the mRNA had integrated into the cell genome and hence the body was producing spike indefinitely).
    • Spike “shedding” didn’t make sense either because the concentration of spike protein (which is rapidly broken down in the environment) would have to be orders of magnitude higher within the vaccinated individual than in the area around them. In turn, this argues against the shedding being able to affect others if an infinitely higher concentration did not affect the vaccinated individual.
I forgot to mention that last bit, which is actually true, although “infinitely” is a bit of an exaggeration. In any event, there is no evidence that the vaccine produces spike protein indefinitely. Even the longest estimates for how long it can produce spike are only on the order of a few weeks, tops, and, again, the amount produced is truly minuscule.
AMD was doing so well here, at least until this part:
Since I was nonetheless seeing numerous clear cut cases of shedding occurring, this suggested to me that I was missing a huge piece of the puzzle which once known invalidated much of the above logic.
Whenever I see this, I ask: How do you know that what you are “seeing” is “shedding”? No, seriously. How? To prove “shedding” you need to show a number of things:
    • mRNA, spike protein, LNPs or something else attributable to the vaccine is somehow “excreted” or “shed” into the environment in measurable quantities. This has never been demonstrated to my knowledge, other than the finding that tiny amounts of mRNA fragments from the vaccines can be excreted in breast milk for up to 48 hours after vaccination.
    • Whatever is “shed” or “excreted” that is attributable to the vaccine can be transmitted to other people. This, too, has never been demonstrated to occur, much less a mechanism shown.
    • Whatever is “shed” or “excreted” that is attributable to the vaccine is, when transmitted to other humans, present in a sufficient quantity to be toxic and to cause all the symptoms and ailments attributed by antivaxxers to “shedding.” None of this has ever been shown either.
All AMD has boils down to anecdotes and conspiracy mongering. For instance, he points out that the Pfizer clinical trial protocol excluded pregnant and lactating women. Of course, anyone who has ever been involved in a clinical trial knows that this is a pretty standard exclusion ever since the thalidomide disaster over 60 years ago; AMD even mentions this! He then concludes that “suggested either that Pfizer knew shedding was a real problem, or that they were following the existing standards—the FDA stipulates that gene therapies need to be evaluated for shedding before being given to humans (and furthermore be subsequently tested in humans)” and then adds that “both the FDA and the EMA classify the mRNA vaccines as a gene therapy.” I note that that FDA link is exclusively about virus- and bacterial-based gene therapy (which the vaccines are not) and how shedding data are required for gene therapies using such vectors. Ditto the EMA link, which also discusses viral vectors, DNA vectors, and bacterial vectors, although it does mention that the testing “of of RNA and DNA vectors, plasmids or artificial chromosome DNA should include tests for genetic identity and integrity including confirmation of the therapeutic sequence and regulatory/controlling sequences, freedom from extraneous agents, sterility and endotoxin levels,” which was done for the mRNA vaccines.
In other words, AMD is either ignorant or being deceptive (i.e., lying). Take your pick.
As for the rest, all the evidence that AMD can muster consists of anecdotes, in which he cites “the strongest proof for shedding” as coming “from the observations by Pierre Kory and Scott Marsland at their clinical practice which is dedicated to treating vaccine injuries (which places them in a unique position to observe and evaluate this phenomenon).” This is some seriously thin gruel, even as described by AMD:
They have:
    • Seen more than twenty patients develop similar symptoms after a shedding exposure, particularly after a “strong” shedding exposure.
    • Found that those symptoms resemble what is seen in other spike protein pathologies (e.g., long COVID or a mRNA vaccine injury).
    • Found those symptoms often respond to the same treatments used for treating other spike protein pathologies (e.g., ivermectin which binds the spike protein).
    • Found many patients will repeatedly have shedding symptoms emerge after the same exposure (e.g., always feeling ill when a vaccinated husband returns from a long trip away).
    • Been able to determine that those they suspect are a shedder (e.g., the husband) test positive (through an antibody test) for a high spike protein levels.
    • Found that eliminating the shedder from the patient’s life or treating the (asymptomatic) shedder with a vaccine injury protocol significantly helps their patient get well.
Twenty patients? Out of how many patients seeking out these quacks? Color me unimpressed. None of this demonstrates “shedding.” It might be worth investigating Dr. Kory’s “case reports” further in a follow-up post, either here or at my not-so-secret other blog, but this post is already getting too long to do it here. In particular, many of the bullet points above are consistent with the power of suggestion in which the persons, because they believe in shedding, feel ill when the vaccinated person is around. Seriously, contrary to what AMD claims, mechanism does matter. If you can’t demonstrate a biological, it’s hard to take such dubious anecdotes seriously as evidence for shedding. If you’re going to claim that shedding occurs in the face of the overwhelming body of evidence from basic science demonstrating that it can’t occur you damned well need to provide much more compelling clinical evidence than the vague anecdotes like this if you expect to persuade scientists to start to doubt the scientific consensus (and the evidence supporting it) that COVID-19 “shedding” occurs and can cause others to become sick is a real phenomenon:
The sensitive patients tend to be the most susceptible to shedding, and I’ve seen numerous reports of individuals (e.g., consider this report from one of Pierre Kory’s patients) who can immediately tell if they are around individuals who have been vaccinated (e.g., because they immediately feel a “toxic” presence or feel a shedder injure them).
Psychic mediums claim to be able to “feel” the presence of ghosts, too, and homeopaths claim that magic shaking of each dilution “potentizes” it to make it more powerful. They also say that mechanism doesn’t matter, and neither does all the science demonstrating that homeopathy can’t work, because they know it does and just need to figure out the mechanism.
Which reminds me of antivaxxers like AMD and Dr. Kory, who claims such harms from vaccine “shedding.”

Antivax quacks are continuing to make up fantastical biological mechanisms for COVID-19 vaccine “shedding”
A couple of weeks ago, I discussed why antivax quacks’ claimed biological mechanisms for COVID-19 vaccine “shedding” reminded me of homeopaths. Confabulation about fantastical scientific mechanisms continues, courtesy of “A Midwestern Doctor.”
David Gorski on January 29, 2024
Link

A couple of weeks ago, I discussed how the arguments made by antivax quacks like “A Midwestern Doctor” (AMD) for the existence of “shedding,” be it of mRNA, spike protein, or evil humors, from people vaccinated with the mRNA-based vaccines against COVID-19 reminded me of the same sorts of fantastical biological “mechanisms” claimed by homeopaths to support their magical mystical remedies. (Memory of water, anyone?) At the time, I left open the possibility for the need for a part two of this discussion because in his—hers? its?—original post, AMD promised a summary of what he thought to be the best evidence for COVID-19 vaccine shedding. Of course, I predicted that whatever fantastical biological “mechanisms” AMD might suggest would almost certainly be just as much bollocks as the dubious mechanisms that he had already suggested, but that doesn’t mean it’s not worth deconstructing. Why? Because antivax quacks across social media are pointing to AMD’s new magnum opus on “shedding,” Unraveling the Mysteries of mRNA Vaccine Shedding, as though it were some definitive new answer to all the criticisms that those who claim that shedding from COVID-19 vaccines is making the unvaccinated sick don’t know basic biology and biochemistry.
I mean, even antivax quack Dr. Pierre Kory is trumpeting the post:
Something about the COVID vaccines is causing them to sicken people in direct proximity to recently vaccinated individuals.This article has the science on how that could be possible and covers what people are doing to protect themselves (ie. in dating).https://t.co/hthFRgyE1H
— Pierre Kory, MD MPA (@PierreKory) January 27, 2024
When Pierre Kory thinks you make sense, you are likely a quack.
Unfortunately, when I was writing last week’s post, I didn’t notice that AMD had posted this new epic on the very same day that I was writing the post, but I don’t mind waiting a week for something like this. So let’s dig in.
Shedding: It’s more magic!
When examining the claims of quacks like AMD and Dr. Kory about something like shedding, I sometimes like to refer to it as Hogwarts science. Of course, that’s an insult to the magic taught at Hogwarts, because within the fictional world of Harry Potter magic actually works in a reproducible manner following established principles that could be investigated scientifically and falsified. Not so nonsense like what AMD wrote.
Let’s start with AMD’s main claims, his “executive summary,” if you will. I’ll start with the second claim first:
Since shedding of mRNA vaccines in theory should not be possible, whenever those individuals (who are often suffering immensely) share their stories, they are immediately ridiculed and dismissed.
AMD should have stopped there and changed the wording to say that shedding “is not possible.” This assertion is based on decades of science regarding mRNA, mRNA delivery in liposomes, how mRNA is translated into protein, what happens to that protein, and how minuscule the amount of protein is that results from mRNA vaccines. This conclusion is based on science more solid, replicated, and understood, to the point where it would take some truly compelling evidence to make molecular biologists, scientists, and physicians start to doubt the impossibility of shedding that can actually sicken others. As I will describe, nothing presented in AMD’s post counts. It’s just anecdotes and handwaving about biology that AMD clearly understands, at best, superficially or, at worst, not at all.
Over the last two years, we have collected a significant amount of data that suggests a sizable number of unvaccinated people will become ill around individuals who were vaccinated in a fairly consistent and repeatable manner.
No, not by a long shot. All that I’ve ever been able to find from AMD and Dr. Kory are anecdotes that aren’t even particularly compelling and, surprisingly given how many patients Dr. Kory claims to have treated, not all that many of them. This article is no exception. After seeing this first claim, I read the rest of the article, specifically looking for the evidence behind this assertion. All I found was a repetition of much of the “clinical evidence” claimed and unsupported assertions made in the post that I discussed the first time around, including that:
    • Individuals “appear to be affected by being in proximity to a vaccinated person (particularly if they are quite close to them), by touching something a vaccinated person contacted (particularly bed sheets), and for particularly sensitive individuals, being in an area which had previously been densely occupied by shedders (conversely being outdoors, presumably due to airflow, reduces how much a shedder affects someone nearby).” There is zero evidence other than dubious anecdotes to support these assertions.
    • The effects of shedding will resolve once the person claiming to be affected by the shedding “simply stops being in contact” with the “shedder.” Again, no evidence other than assertions based on anecdotes is made for this claim. AMD also claims that “most people” are not affected by shedding. I would alter that to nobody is effected by shedding from individuals vaccinated with COVID-19 vaccines because there is no biochemical or biological mechanism for shedding even to occur, AMD’s and Dr. Kory’s handwaving notwithstanding.
    • Susceptibility to shedding varies among individuals and that shedding is strongest soon after vaccination or boosting, with some people supposedly shedding a lot more than others. I realize that I’m getting repetitive, but the only evidence for this is Dr. Kory’s claims about patients upon whom he’s plied his quackery.
    • Magically, effects of “shedding” are “typically either immediate (e.g., nosebleeds, headaches and dizziness), onset in 6-24 hours (e.g., menstrual issues) or gradually show up over time.” Again, no good evidence other than Dr. Kory’s descriptions of the various cases he claims to have treated is presented.
    • Vaccinated individuals have a specific “smell” to which the unvaccinated affected by shedding are sensitive. AMD even cites a large number of anecdotes (e.g., 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32). AMD claims, “The labels I’ve seen used to describe the smell are as follows: ‘mild sickly sweet,’ ‘rotting [or dying] flesh,’ ‘magnetic onion,’ ‘unpleasant,’ ‘distinctive,’ ‘the smell of death,’ ‘medicines plus latrines’ ‘musty plus rancid‘ ‘dead animal,’ a ‘decomposing body,’ ‘road kill,’ ‘like ammonia but not as strong,’ ‘sweet,’ ‘sour stomach’ ‘elderly person as their flesh breaks down with age,’ ‘a chemical flu smell’ ‘of seaweed,’ ‘putrid,’ ‘sweet meat’ ‘strange and metallic‘ ‘sharp, pungent and toxic’ ‘horrible’ ‘unique odor’ ‘chemical,’ ‘vinegar,’ ‘subtle like a pheromone.'” AMD further notes that the bolded descriptions were reported by more than one person. Personally, my first impression was that, contrary to what AMD claims, these statements aren’t consistent. They’re all over the place. Moreover, my first move would not to be to take these claims at face value, but to challenge AMD and Dr. Kory to do a double-blinded test of the people making these claims to try to figure out if they really can “smell” the vaccinated, thanks to shedding. My guess is that an actual rigorously administered test would fail to find any such ability, which is why Dr. Kory and AMD show no interest in doing such an investigation.
    • “Injury” from “shedding” is due to “circulatory impairments (e.g., microclotting). Again, no evidence is presented other than known evidence that COVID-19 infection can cause disorders in clotting. Again, vaccination produces far too little spike protein to do this. Hilariously, AMD comes very close to homeopathy when asserting that the clotting is due “their adverse effects on the physiologic zeta potential (which once treated appears to fix spike protein injuries) and to a lesser extent activating the cell danger response).” If you go to those links (particularly this one), you will find that AMD believes in some serious water woo to increase the “liquid crystalline water in the body.” He even cites Masaru Emoto, a true blast from the past. Emoto, you might remember, claimed that you could impress your “intent” upon water through sound imparting its “vibrational frequencies” to the water. Yes, basically, Emoto would talk or sing to the water and claim that the water now had magical healing properties, because, you know, we are all water. His basic idea was that human consciousness could affect the actual molecular structure of water. (I first wrote about him 18 years ago.)
Let’s just put it this way. If you’re citing Masaru Emoto for anything, you are truly heading into homeopathy-level bullshit. Seriously:
The extraordinary life work of Dr. Emoto is documented in the New York Times Bestseller, The Hidden Messages in Water. In his book, Dr. Emoto demonstrates how water exposed to loving, benevolent, and compassionate human intention results in aesthetically pleasing physical molecular formations in the water while water exposed to fearful and discordant human intentions results in disconnected, disfigured, and “unpleasant” physical molecular formations. He did this through Magnetic Resonance Analysis technology and high-speed photographs.
You get the idea. Come to think of it, though, the very idea of “shedding” of COVID-19 vaccines to sicken some of unvaccinated who come into contact with a vaccinated individual does rather remind me of the principles of Emoto’s water woo in that it relies on the same sorts of pseudoscience to justify it. Maybe it isn’t a big surprise that AMD would be drawn both to antivax conspiracy theories about shedding and to Dr. Emoto’s water woo.
Here’s the bullet point that caught my attention and led me to want to write this part two, though:
We have identified a few plausible mechanisms (and the evidence to support them) to explain why this transmission occurs. These include exosome mediated shedding (most likely), asymptomatic COVID-19 shedding and transfected bacterial shedding.
“You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.” Scientifically, at least.
Before I look at the specific claimed mechanisms, such as exosome mediated shedding—spoiler alert: this is not a thing for mRNA and spike protein—let’s look at some other claims:
In this article, we will explore some of the greatest concerns surrounding shedding, such as what’s currently known about sexual shedding, the odor some notice shedders emit, receiving vaccinated blood transfusions, cancer and shedding, and the existing methods which can be used to mitigate the harmful effects of shedding.
I like how AMD says “explore some of the greatest concerns surrounding shedding.” That’s because, yes, thanks to antivax quacks like AMD, there are many concerns about “shedding.” None of them are based in science, as I started to discuss two weeks ago. Again, AMD seems to think that unsupported anecdotes trump science:
To help unravel this mystery, we recently put out a call for individuals to share their own shedding injuries and see if those accounts matched what we had observed. These is understandably a lot of interest in this subject (e.g., a Tweet about it received 555k views) and we’ve now collected hundreds of stories (which can be viewed here).
I’ll give you an idea of the sorts of stories that this request garnered by citing just one, from a “holistic” practitioner who had urged her husband not to be vaccinated. He did anyway, and this is what was reported (I quote liberally, to give you the full quality of what I’m talking about):
He “put off” his second shot until February. (Later on, I checked his batch number and it was a “hot” batch that caused more deaths and severe adverse reactions than other batch numbers.) Unfortunately: the body takes about 72 days to produce sperm. 72 days to the date, I was ovulating and we didn’t use protection. Minutes after completion, I felt an aching, throbbing, stabbing sensation on one side of my lower abdomen. It slowly spread to the other side. About 15 minutes later, my back (kidney-region) on both sides had started throbbing. I’ve never experienced anything like that before (I’m now 42); my cycles have always been normal and on time. Two weeks later, my menses started and my menstrual cup was filled with large half-dollar+ sized clots for the duration of the cycle. Again, new to me. I immediately scheduled with my OBGYN, who did a scan and told me that since my normal annual checkup 3 months prior, I’d developed several large uterine polyps, one directly blocking the cervix/uterine entrance. (I believe that my body was trying to protect me from that point of entry). “Surgery is the only option if you want kids.” Well, not for me.
Daily visualization coupled with Chinese meds to treat BLOOD STASIS in the lower house took care of it. A couple of weeks later, the scans were normal and surgery was avoided. I have continued, with some reservation, to sleep with my partner, given he is not boosted. My clots seem to fade/lessen with addition of proteolytic enzymes, fiber, ivermectin, and avoidance of people recently vaccinated. They worsen each time there’s a widespread vaccination event (like this fall/winter 2023-24). We did become pregnant over the summer ’23, but the spotting was more than it should have been and we miscarried around 5 weeks. I suspect autoimmune/crosswiring with the spike protein molecular mimicry, preventing continuation of the pregnancy.
During the pandemic, there were studies demonstrating that among men who had recovered from severe covid, several had spike protein in sperm samples. How it migrates there, I don’t know. Based on my symptoms and the science I’m aware of, it seems obvious that the spike protein migrates to the testes and semen, and is transferable during sex. It seems less obvious but still concerning that perhaps this IS a bioweapon, and one of its tactics is to destroy fertility, male and female alike.
I’ll just point out that there is no evidence that COVID-19 vaccines impair fertility. You get the idea, though.
“Speculative hypotheses” about shedding
The most honest thing that AMD writes in this post is arguably this:
Since mRNA “shedding” is such an inexplicable phenomenon, attempts to explain or predict it inevitably result in a large number of highly speculative hypotheses being raised.
Of course, what AMD does after this is—you guessed it—to suggest a number of highly speculative hypotheses. It’s worse than that, though. Not only does he speculate wildly, but he does so while demonstrating that he doesn’t understand some very basic molecular biology and biochemistry. I mean, seriously, look at how he tries to “explain” the “variable sensitivity” of people to contact with the vaccinated who are “shedding”:
From all the previously received case reports, it has been established that the sensitivity to either the spike protein (or a yet unknown vaccine component) varies by orders of magnitude (discussed further in the first half of this series). While this does not explain how the vaccine is able to “shed” it explains why some people can be relatively unaffected by high concentrations of it (e.g., the asymptomatic shedders) whereas others get very ill from the tiny amount of the shedding agent which exits the body and can be absorbed from the environment.
This in turn is consistent with the hypotheses that the spike protein’s toxicity is partly a result of it being an allergen (some people are extraordinarily sensitive to an allergen) and it being an agent which collapses the physiologic zeta potential (as everyone has a differing critical threshold below which impaired zeta potential will trigger microclotting throughout the body).
There’s that zeta potential again! It is true that zeta potential is a real thing, but it is not so much true that it works this way in the human body. Material scientists define zeta potential thusly:
Zeta potential is a measure of the magnitude of the electrostatic or charge repulsion/attraction between particles and is one of the fundamental parameters known to affect stability. Its measurement brings detailed insight into the causes of dispersion, aggregation or flocculation, and can be applied to improve the formulation of dispersions, emulsions and suspensions.
Let’s just put it this way. Zeta potential is a variable used in optimizing waste water treatment processes in which size, density, and charge of particles to be removed are considered. Zeta potential is also used in optimizing drug delivery systems and in enhancing hemagglutination, but, contrary to AMD’s handwaving, there is no evidence that it has anything to do with “shed” spike protein from vaccines causing hypercoagulability of the blood. Again, AMD is doing some highly speculative handwaving here.
Next up is exosome shedding. I can’t help but remember that one common appeal to exosomes that I first encountered during the pandemic came from germ theory deniers who claimed that SARS-CoV-2 didn’t exist and that it was, in fact, exosomes. What are exosomes? In brief, they are small extracellular vesicles (like bubbles) that bud off from cells and can bump into and fuse with other cells. They were first discovered nearly 40 years ago. According to a 2020 review article:
Exosomes are EVs with a size range of ~40 to 160 nm (average ~100 nm) in diameter with an endosomal origin. Sequential invagination of the plasma membrane ultimately results in the formation of multivesicular bodies, which can intersect with other intracellular vesicles and organelles, contributing to diversity in the constituents of exosomes. Depending on the cell of origin, EVs, including exosomes, can contain many constituents of a cell, including DNA, RNA, lipids, metabolites, and cytosolic and cell-surface proteins. The physiological purpose of generating exosomes remains largely unknown and needs investigation. One speculated role is that exosomes likely remove excess and/or unnecessary constituents from cells to maintain cellular homeostasis. Recent studies reviewed here also indicate a functional, targeted, mechanism-driven accumulation of specific cellular components in exosomes, suggesting that they have a role in regulating intercellular communication.
So let’s see how AMD invokes exosomes:
During COVID, we noticed that the virus appeared to poison the exosome system and in turn that injecting healthy exosomes into the blood stream often produced remarkable results for those patients (as well as for long COVID and to a lesser extent vaccine injuries). In the case of the vaccine, this makes a lot of sense, as the vaccine works by causing cells to mass produce spike proteins (which get pushed to the cell surface at which point they can bud off into toxic exosomes that traverse the body). In turn, it has been shown this does indeed occur after vaccination (and I suspect, due to the vaccine design, much more frequently than is seen in COVID—which may account for why “vaccine” shedding differs from COVID-19 shedding).
The study cited above did indeed find that there were exosomes with spike protein in them released from cells after vaccination with the Pfizer vaccine. It studied both mice and humans. One thing that maddened me is that, while it reported the concentration of anti-spike antibodies, the study reported spike protein concentration in relative densities (i.e., increase in spike), which was far less helpful. However, we know from previous studies that the concentration of spike protein that gets into the circulation is very tiny, meaning that (1) it’s incredibly unlikely that any of it is “shed” anywhere and (2) even if it were it would be at such a tiny amount that one would have to postulate it to be the most powerful toxin in the world to cause any effect whatsoever. Again, I say, “Plausibility. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.” Basically, AMD is pointing to a phenomenon observed in one study that is irrelevant to the question of whether “shedding” from COVID-19 vaccines even occurs, much less that minuscule quantities of spike protein are transmitted from the vaccinated to the unvaccinated in a quantity that has a biological activity. When I made my reference to homeopathy last week about this phenomenon, I wasn’t kidding. It’s basically the magical Law of Contagion all over again, just like with homeopathy.
So what evidence does AMD cite besides the aforementioned study? This:
A 2023 peer-reviewed study found that unvaccinated children who were around COVID-19 vaccinated parents developed an immune response to the spike protein that was not seen in children with unvaccinated parents. Additionally, they were also able to find spike protein antibodies in surgical masks worn by the physicians. This led the authors to hypothesize that antibodies being directly transferred through the parent’s breath to their children.
This study is also totally irrelevant to shedding, as it demonstrates that antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 might possibly be transferred from mother to baby, not spike protein. Truly, AMD is either ignorant or lying about some very basic biology here. Take your pick. I know which one I pick, based on what AMD says next:
I however would argue the results suggest spike coated exosomes (which produce spike antibodies once they arrive in the childen) are being transferred. This is because, to the best of my knowledge, it has not otherwise been shown antibodies can be directly transferred to someone else through breath (this would change a lot of the fundamental principles of how herd immunity works in the population) and if the transference were to occur, the concentration in the child would be dramatically lower than the parent (which as best as I can tell was not what the study found).
Let me cite the actual paper:
The simplest interpretation of our results is that 1) aerosol transmission of Ab can occur and that 2) the propensity for this transfer is, unsurprisingly, directly related to the amount of nasal/oral Ab found within those in the population possessing immunity. We have yet to encounter an equally parsimonious interpretation, although admittedly this does not mean one does not exist.
Correct. For AMD’s speculation to be true, there would have to be a lot of spike protein in the respiratory tracts of the vaccinated. There is no evidence that there is, at least not any presented by AMD and not any that I’m aware of. Again, consider plausibility. Given the incredibly tiny amount of spike protein generated by vaccination, it is incredibly implausible that there would be enough in the respiratory passages of the vaccinated to transfer enough to another person to provoke an immune reaction.
None of this stops AMD from paddling further and further into wild speculation:
Significant amounts of (RNA containing) exosomes can be found in your breath, and those exosomes (which derive from the lungs) vary depending upon on the disease state someone has (“sicker” people have “worse” exosomes). To illustrate, see this 2013 paper, this 2020 paper and this 2021 paper
The first paper (from 2013) detected micro-RNAs in exosomes. Although they are RNA molecules, micro-RNAs are not the same thing as mRNAs; rather, they are short lengths of specialized RNA that regulate gene expression, and this study looked at them in the breath of patients with asthma, not with infectious disease, compared to normal controls. Seriously, it’s almost as though AMD knows that his readers won’t read or understand the actual study, which in this case is a brief study presented as a letter. The second study (from 2020) did indeed detect extracellular vesicles and proposed that they might be useful biomarkers for disease. The third study (from 2021) again examined exosomes in the breath of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases (like asthma) and again proposed them as potential biomarkers in chronic pulmonary disease. Let’s just say that none of these studies are particularly relevant to the claims being made by AMD that somehow exosomes with spike protein are being “shed.” Again, given the tiny quantity of spike protein even made after vaccination, AMD is paddling further and further down the river of scientific implausibility towards homeopathy-level implausibility.
Finally, AMD proposes—surprise! surprise!—plasmid DNA contamination as a “plausible” mechanism by which vaccine shedding could occur. Of course, as I’ve written a number of times before, this plasmid DNA contamination is minor and not harmful, nor does it integrate into the genome to cause “turbo cancer.” I think, though, that I’ll let you read a decent chunk of AMD’s justification for his invocation of “plasmidgate,” just to give you a good laugh:
In turn, I believe it is quite possible those plasmids are in turn integrating into the recipient’s genome or their microbiome. Assuming they are in fact integrating into the microbiome, the transfected bacteria will reproduce the spike protein plasmid and can hence transfect other bacteria in the microbiome (which in turn can produce the spike protein). In turn, since we are always spreading our microbiome (including through the air) to those around us, spike transfected bacteria provide a way that the vaccine could allow a replication competent organism to be transmitted to those around us—something which on the surface appears impossible with the mRNA technology (and is hence frequently used to argue against the possibility of shedding).
Presently, the following data points exist to support this hypothesis:1. It is now known that the most dangerous vaccine lots also had higher amounts of the plasmid contaminants.2. One system of medicine (based on terrain theory) believes the microbiome transforming into a pathologic state is the root cause of many illnesses. In turn, this system “treats” a variety of diseases by providing plasmids extracted from healthy states of the common organisms found within the body under the theory that unhealthy ones will take up those plasmids, transform into the healthy ones that live with the body and then produce more of the “healthy” plasmids. In essence, this approach seeks to restore health is exactly the opposite of what the (spike protein plasmid containing) COVID vaccines are doing.While I do not follow the fairly complex protocols adherents of this school of medicine ask patients to follow, I have found that some of their remedies are extremely helpful for specific diseases that are otherwise quite difficult to treat. With spike protein injuries, we’ve found one remedy this system believes “treats” the microorganism which causes blood clotting is quite helpful for both vaccine injuries and long-haul COVID. This in turn suggests to us that something about the spike protein pathologically alters the microbiome until it is reversed with a healthy plasmid.
First off, no, it is not “known” that the “most dangerous vaccine lots also had higher amounts of the plasmid contaminants.” Those were bogus, crappy studies done by antivax ideologues using poor methodology.
Second, that “one system of medicine” is something called Sanum Therapy. Oddly enough, I don’t recall having heard of it before, but its main proponents call it a “unique naturopathic form of therapy” described thusly:
SANUM therapy is a unique therapeutic concept that uses medicinal products from various microorganisms to support or restore the microbial balance and thus the regulatory capacity of the body. The medicines are made from specific bacteria (Bacto preparations) and lower fungi (Myco preparations) according to a traditional and proprietary process. Depending on the disease, these can be used as single remedies or in combination with other SANUM preparations from plant and organ extracts, physiological carboxylic acids as well as from mineral and trace elements in the therapy. SANUKEHL® preparations, which are also produced from bacteria or fungi in a specific process, represent a special group of medicines and expand the range of applications of the entire range of medicines for especially chronic diseases.
Again, this is all based on the terrain theory of medicine by Antoine Béchamp. In the late 19th century terrain theory was in competition with Louis Pasteur’s germ theory and ultimately lost out. Basically Béchamp argued that microorganisms were not the cause of disease but rather the consequence of disease, that injured or diseased tissues produced them, and that it was the health of the organism that mattered, not the microorganisms. In other words, the “terrain” was all. Claude Bernard, another scientist supporting terrain theory at the time, described the milieu intérieur, the interstitial fluids regarded as an internal environment in which the cells of the body are nourished and maintained in a state of equilibrium, which he and others also called terrain.
Béchamp’s idea, known as the pleomorphic theory of disease, stated that bacteria change form (i.e., demonstrate pleomorphism) in response to disease. In other words, they arise from tissues during disease states. Béchamp further postulated that bacteria arose from structures that he called microzymas, which to him referred to a class of enzymes, that microzymas are normally present in tissues, and that their effects depended upon the cellular terrain. Ultimately, Pasteur’s theory won out over the theories of Bernard and Béchamp, based on evidence and experiments, but Béchamp was influential in the 19th century, and, given the science and technology of the time, his hypothesis was not entirely unreasonable. It was, however, superseded by Pasteur’s germ theory of disease and Koch’s later work that resulted in Koch’s postulates.
As I’ve written many times before, though, antivaxxers love to invoke terrain theory, for a very simple reason: If microorganisms aren’t the primary cause of disease then vaccines are unnecessary. These days, as AMD does in his post, antivaxxers love to invoke terrain theory in the form of changes to the microbiome, which is the ecosystem of normal bacteria and other microorganisms that live on and in us, benefiting both the microorganisms and us. While the microbiome does indeed impact health, as one can see by, for instance, antibiotic-induced diarrheas that can result from wiping out the normal flora of the gut, antivaxxers and quacks attribute near-magical powers to the microbiome. Indeed, in this case, AMD cites a single study in a dodgy journal that reported that SARS-CoV-2 could infect gut bacteria and then suggests this as one piece of evidence that shedding from the vaccine is possible. Even if the study is valid and reproducible, it’s utterly irrelevant to the claims of “shedding” from COVID-19 vaccines. AMD also cites two abstracts from a known antivaxxer (just look at her X/Twitter feed if you don’t believe me) claiming that COVID-19 vaccination decreases the amount of a beneficial species of bacteria in the gut flora. Again, even if this were true, it would be irrelevant to the question of whether “shedding” occurs.
AMD also mentions in passing the possibility of pheromones or even allergic reactions to “lipid nanoparticle breakdown products” being behind the “shedding” phenomenon. The less said about these unsupported speculations, the better.
A purity cult
AMD concludes with this hilarious characterization of the post that I just powered through, trying not to laugh too hard:
Given how controversial the idea an injection being given to billions of people could actually be actively harming unvaccinated people is, we’ve put a lot of thought into if we wanted to broach this topic. For this reason, we’ve spent a long time researching the topic and tried to stick to claims we could provide the evidence to substantiate.
At this point, I feel we have been able to answer many of the questions numerous people have asked us to explore. Nonetheless, there are a few topics that have not yet been covered I know many of you still want some guidance on. The dilemma we face is that most of those answers rely more speculative evidence and our fear is that if they are associate with these points, they will be focused on and hence used to dismiss the rest of the critically important points raised throughout this article.
I have little doubt that AMD and Dr. Kory “spent a long time researching the topic,” but clearly “claims we could provide evidence to substantiate” mean something very different to them than the term means to me or actual scientists with actual knowledge of the basic science relevant to their claims. All that AMD managed to present were anecdotes with no controls as evidence, wild speculation based on either misunderstood (or intentionally misrepresented) science, and fear mongering.
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again. Antivax is, at its core, a purity cult. Moreover, you will find few better examples illustrating that it is a purity cult than the idea of vaccine shedding, which, unlike the case of live attenuated virus vaccines (which can shed), is near homeopathy-level implausible in the case of COVID-19 vaccines. Think of it this way. To the antivaxxer, being vaccinated is such a “contamination” of one’s “purity,” that your associating with someone who has been vaccinated risks contaminating you too. That’s because the purity involved is not a scientific concept, but rather a moral and mystical one, in which vaccines somehow corrupt your “purity of essence” (phraseology intentional) so badly that you must be cast out, lest you contaminate those who remain “pure.”

COVID-19 Vaccination Significantly Reduces Risk of Severe Inflammatory Syndrome in Kids
A new analysis of 2023 MIS-C cases reveals that the COVID-19 vaccine significantly reduces the risk of this dreaded complication.
Clay Jones on March 29, 2024
Link

Remember MIS-C, the “multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children” that was all the rage during the early months of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic? I certainly do. Children with MIS-C, in addition to fever, present with non-specific complaints such as abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhea, rash, and conjunctivitis (pink eye) a few weeks after COVID-19, which could have been a mild or even undetected case. These patients then go on to develop an intense inflammatory response throughout the body that can injure multiple organs, in particular the heart, leading to shock and the need for intensive care.
I have seen just a couple cases of MIS-C so far, both in the first year of the pandemic and both involving an extremely ill child who needed transfer to a facility with a pediatric intensive care unit. The possibility of a patient developing this dreaded complications of COVID-19 had many of worried every time an ill child came into the hospital with unexplained fever. This was a completely new and quite serious clinical entity and not much was known about the typical course in those early months. Nobody wanted to delay diagnosis and appropriate medical care.
This meant that work-ups for kids with fever became more aggressive than usual for a while. Though uncommon even at its peak, fear of MIS-C and some (necessarily) hastily thrown together diagnostic algorithms meant that a lot of children underwent expanded laboratory evaluations who wouldn’t have in the past. And this meant that a lot of children were admitted for close observation for 24 hours when some of these labs were abnormal. It was, I admit, a bit of a mess for a while. We did our best.
Most of that anxiety has cooled, not that MIS-C has gone away. We have become more comfortable with the clinical assessment but cases have also plummeted. Throughout the pandemic, spikes in the incidence of MIS-C have followed spikes in cases of COVID-19, and about 1 out of every 3,000 to 4,000 children with COVID-19 developed MIS-C during the worst months of 2020 and 2021. Thankfully the risk has decreased dramatically since the early days, likely because of genetic changes in subsequent dominant variants as well as the positive impact of vaccines and protective antibodies acquired from previous infection.
Earlier this month, a report from the CDC highlighted the importance of COVID-19 vaccination in preventing MIS-C. Researchers looked at every case of MIS-C reported to the CDC surveillance system through the end of February that had occurred in 2023, which amounted to 117 total cases. The total number of cases in reality was likely a bit higher, however, because not all jurisdictions have reported their 2023 numbers yet. There was also a change in the case definition of MIS-C for surveillance purposes last year which may have caused some confusion and an undercount of true cases.
Even with this potential limitation, there were some interesting findings. The overall incidence was much lower (0.11 cases/million person-months) compared to 2022 (0.56 cases/million person-months), and far below the peak of 6.79 cases/million person-months during October 2020 through April 2021. The median age of patients diagnosed with MIS-C in 2023 also shifted younger, decreasing from 9 years during the early days down to 7 years. This is still older than the typical age when Kawasaki disease, an inflammatory vasculitis that has significant clinical overlap with MIS-C, is diagnosed.
Half of the patients required intensive care, with about a third developing shock and a quarter developing cardiac dysfunction. This is only a little better compared with severity seen in the early days of the pandemic, meaning that while MIS-C incidence is much lower it remains every bit as serious a condition. The mortality rate in the 2023 cases was 3%.
When it comes to the relationship between MIS-C and vaccine status, the results are impressive. 112 (96%) of patients with MIS-C were eligible for the vaccine but only 20 had received even one dose. And for 12 of those 20 it had been more than a year since their last dose. That means 93% were either unvaccinated or far out from their last vaccination, lending support for yearly boosters that are recommended by the CDC.
Being current with the COVID-19 vaccine dramatically reduces the risk of developing MIS-C. It may not be a common problem, but it is a bad one and kids deserve to be protected. Add this to the fact that these vaccines are incredibly safe and also reduce the risk of severe acute COVID-19 and it sure seems pretty clear that it is the right thing to do.

Is the Pediatric COVID Vaccine in Competition with Routine Vaccinations?
Of course not. The sad state of Florida shows us why.
Jonathan Howard on January 17, 2023
Link

In previous articles (here and here), I discussed the asinine notion that doctors who promoted pediatric COVID-19 vaccination did so at the expense of routine vaccination. This myth was promulgated by contrarian doctors who had never previously expressed the slightest interest in vaccines or the anti-vaccine movement. However, during the pandemic, these non-pediatricians absurdly anointed themselves Chief Defenders of the Routine Vaccination Schedule. In this self-assigned role, they did nothing to promote confidence in routine vaccines. Instead, they were very worried that providing parents with accurate information about COVID-19 and the vaccine against it would negatively impact other vaccines.
Contrarian doctors’ arguments against the pediatric COVID-19 vaccine took two forms. The first was that pediatricians could only do one thing at a time. In an essay that favored letting unvaccinated, healthy children contract COVID-19, Dr. Vinay Prasad wrote:
Doctors’ time is limited. Routine childhood vaccine rates are slipping. Contrary to COVID-19 shots, the measles vaccine is sterilizing and high rates are needed to halt spread. Doctors must realize that pro-vax does not mean zealotry, but evidence first…To the proposition: Should doctors encourage healthy kids (11 and under) to be vaccinated against COVID-19? I say, “No, Save your breath for routine vaccination”.
Of course, pediatricians who vaccinate their patients against COVID-19 are not “zealots,” and they are putting evidence first. Doctors are obligated to inform their patients about all vaccines that will keep them safe and out of the hospital, and obviously this includes the COVID-19 vaccine. Moreover, pediatricians have been vaccinating children against multiple pathogens their entire careers, and Dr. Prasad presented no evidence that administration of the COVID-19 vaccine would be such a time burden that they would be unable to simultaneously vaccinate children against measles. He just had a hunch.
Notably, Dr. Prasad, who said it was “healthy and natural” for children to get sick with COVID-19, also spoke of the benefits of other vaccine-preventable diseases, undermining his performative concern about routine vaccination. In his pro-virus essay “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?” he advocated using sick children as human shields not just for COVID-19, but also for chickenpox. He wrote:
Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
In reality, there’s no evidence that the US chickenpox vaccination program increased the rate of shingles in adults. Moreover, the CDC estimates that in its first 25 years, the chickenpox vaccine prevented 91 million cases, 238,000 hospitalizations, and 2,000 deaths, and children vaccinated against chickenpox have substantially less risk of shingles. That’s a big deal. Children have the right to be protected against diseases that can harm them. Of course, an effective vaccine is also available for shingles. Grandparents don’t need their sick grandkids to theoretically lower their shingles risk, generation after generation, forevermore.
Similarly, in another pro-virus article titled “I Am Going to Mask Because I Want to Get Fewer Colds & Other Flawed Ideas“, Dr. Prasad spoke of the potential benefits of the flu, which normally kills hundreds of children each year, most of them unvaccinated. He wrote:
There is the arrogance that avoiding colds and flu is good for us. Of course it is the case that getting sick is unpleasant, but our knowledge of immunology and the body is so primitive we should not conclude that avoiding it is ‘good for us.’ We have no idea if that is true in the long run. It is natural to be infected repeatedly with respiratory viruses— if we got fewer infections what would that mean for auto-immunity for cancer?
Of course, anti-vaxxers say the exact same thing. To pick one example amongst many, an article titled “The Unreported Health Benefits of Measles” claimed, “The truth is that measles and other childhood infections may actually protect against life-threatening conditions like cancer and heart disease”. How would Dr. Prasad argue against this, assuming he would argue against it? He’s spoken of the health benefits of three vaccine-preventable diseases: COVID-19, chickenpox, and the flu. What’s so different about measles, pertussis, and HPV?
Contrarian doctors’ second argument against the pediatric COVID-19 vaccine was that if parents were encouraged to use it, they would magically lose trust in other vaccines. In an article full of misinformation titled “The CDC Is Breaking Trust in Childhood Vaccination“, Drs. Leslie Bienen and Tracy Høeg wrote that:
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases…The general trust deficit is more troubling than skepticism toward this particular vaccine, because it could conceivably drive down uptake of other childhood vaccines that we know are more important to children’s health, such as those against measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
According to Drs. Bienen and Høeg the measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib) vaccines are in a competition with the COVID-19 vaccine, and there can be only one winner. Dr. Bienen and Høeg presented no evidence that vaccinating children against COVID-19 would harm vaccine uptake for “more significant diseases”, especially considering COVID-19 killed more American children nearly every month of the pandemic than measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib) have killed my entire life (thanks to vaccines, of course). Over 650 infants and toddlers have died of COVID-19, though Drs. Bienen and Høeg refused to share that sad fact.
Fortunately, the real world has given us a perfect opportunity to judge the validity of these doctor’s claims. If they were right, Florida should be a shining star in routine vaccination. Under the guidance of sheltered anti-vaccine doctors such as Dr. Hoeg, Florida is officially anti-vaccine for children when it comes to COVID-19. Misinformation superspreader, Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo, said “From what I have seen, there is just insufficient data to inform benefits and risk in children. I think that’s very unequivocal.” Similarly, Gov. Ron DeSantis said “I would say we are affirmatively against the COVID vaccine for young kids. These are the people who have zero risk of getting anything.” Florida would eventually be the only state not to order vaccines for children younger than 5 years.
So what about Florida’s routine vaccination rates?
It turns out the Chief Defenders of the Routine Vaccination Schedule were wrong. An article titled “Florida School Immunization Rates Lowest in Over 10 Years” was published last month, and it should shock and anger anyone who actually cares about the routine vaccination schedule. It said:
Last year marked a more than 10-year low for Florida’s kindergarten and seventh-grade students completed all doses of required immunizations, according to a recent report form the state Department of Health.
The sad truth is that routine vaccination rates are dropping everywhere. Nationally, around 93% of children entering kindergarten received routine vaccines in the 2021-22 school year, above Florida’s rate of 91.7%, but several points below pre-pandemic levels.
As anyone with basic knowledge of the anti-vaccine movement could have predicted, spreading unwarranted fear and doubt about COVID-19 vaccines isn’t the best way to instill confidence in routine vaccines. Lydia Greene, a formerly anti-vaccine mother turned vaccine-advocate explained why:
Covid centrists like Zdogg, Høeg , and Prasad like to blame pro-vaccine pediatricians for vaccine hesitancy. As a highly hesitant parent who was once very fearful of vaccination, I was constantly on the lookout for these centrist points of view, like Dr. Bob Sears and Dr. Paul Thomas. If these medical professionals can find something to be cautious about, then surely my reasons for not vaccinating are in plain sight and being ignored by the people I should trust the most.
I have also noticed that the reasons the covid centrists caution against vaccinating children for covid, can be extrapolated to any vaccine on the schedule. I know those tropes well, and they are being recycled. If you do get a chance to look at the discussions taking place in their comment sections, you will see many vaccine myths being shared and not a single correction by the centrist doctor.
These aren’t just covid vaccine myths, they are myths about the entire childhood schedule. They offer zero correction because they know who butters their bread. Vaccine centrists breed hesitancy and validate parental fears on vaccination. As a formerly vaccine-hesitant parent who now does consultation for healthcare workers to decrease hesitancy, that is my professional opinion.
She’s right, and for once I find myself in agreement with leading anti-vaxxer Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who correctly grasped that anyone who purposefully undermines confidence in the COVID-19 vaccine, undermines confidence in all vaccines.

The Alternative to Vaccinating Children Isn’t Just “Not Vaccinating” Them
It’s putting them on an inevitable collision course with the virus—without any protection from the vaccine.
Jonathan Howard on August 17, 2022
Link

[Editor’s note: Steve Novella is on vacation this week. (He actually takes vacations sometimes! Who knew?) In his absence, Jonathan Howard has stepped in. Also, to answer questions about SBM yesterday, Harriet Hall couldn’t provide her usual post due to a last-minute personal issue. She will return as usual next week.]
I previously discussed doctors who disparage the utility of pediatric vaccination since many children already have “natural immunity“. Among the many flaws in their reasoning, they forget that 10,000 babies are born every day in the US. These babies arrive without immunity and have the highest risk of dying of all children. As vaccines have been successively approved for younger children, these doctors have used their considerable influence to spread fear and doubt at every step of this process, ensuring unvaccinated children contract the virus. However, in their copious comments on pediatric COVID, these doctors have collectively avoided a very important and very obvious question.
At what age do they feel people should get vaccinated?
Since they trash the vaccine for babies and toddlers, perhaps they think vaccination should start at age 5. I’ve not heard them say this, and they’ve written misleading articles about vaccinating children this age. Moreover, starting vaccination at age 5 makes no sense, as these children have the lowest risk of severe outcomes of any children.
Perhaps then they think that vaccination should start in adolescence. I’ve not heard them say this, and they’ve written misleading articles about vaccinating children this age as well. Moreover, starting vaccination in adolescence makes no sense, as these children are most vulnerable to vaccine-myocarditis, which they’ve treated as a fate worse than death from COVID. Since the vaccine-myocarditis risk drops after 25, maybe this is the age when contrarian doctors feel vaccination should finally start.
No one knows what these doctors think, and I doubt they do either. They’ve seemingly given no consideration to how old they feel a child should be before they deserve protection against COVID.
In contrast, pediatricians who actually care for sick children were thrilled when they could finally vaccinate their youngest patients. These doctors realize the question of what age to vaccinate children is intimately linked with another very important and very obvious question. How long can the average newborn expect to avoid COVID? I don’t know for sure, but my gut tells me “not that long“. I expect only the most isolated children will enter kindergarten never having encountered the virus. None will remain uninfected once they’ve been in school awhile, and most likely, they’ll be exposed to the virus throughout their lives.
Doctors have an obligation to be very clear when writing about children, COVID, and vaccines. The alternative to vaccinating children isn’t just “not vaccinating” them. It’s putting them on an inevitable collision course with the virus. The vaccine isn’t perfect, but it has consistently been shown to lower the risk of severe outcomes, even the Omicron variant. In essence, doctors who oppose vaccinating children actively support millions of them getting COVID every year without any protection from the vaccine.
And thus we come to the final very important and very obvious question. What will be the consequences of this? Fortunately, severe outcomes remain exceedingly rare in children. However rare events multiplied millions of times add up. Over 500 children younger than 5-years have died in the USA and thousands more have been hospitalized. Some of these children are very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU.
Those will be the consequences of failing to protect millions of babies and toddlers from the virus, and contrarian doctors, sheltered from the consequences of their words, don’t seem to have given this a moment’s thought.

Study laundering: IPAK, antivax “scientists,” and the return of living dead antivax studies
Antivaxxers don’t like it when one of their crappy studies that they somehow managed to sneak into a decent peer-reviewed journal is deservedly retracted, as happened to Mark Skidmore’s paper that estimated that 278K people might have died from COVID-19 vaccines. Fortunately for Skidmore and others, there exist fake journals that will launder their study by republishing it so that antivaxxers can continue to claim the work has been published in a “peer-reviewed journal.”
David Gorski on October 30, 2023
Link

When I sat down to write this week’s post for SBM, I hadn’t intended on revisiting last week’s topic, but then I saw a post on Popular Rationalism, which is James Lyons-Weiler‘s Substack, entitled Gorski Gaslights His Blog Readership on Skidmore et al.’s Peer-Reviewed Study. My first reaction upon reading the titled was “Who are the ‘et al’?” After all, one of the points I made about Michigan State University economics professor Mark Skidmore‘s awful paper was that he was sole author in the original paper and remains sole author of the “revised” paper, as I wondered why he didn’t recruit any real statisticians, epidemiologists, or even social scientists skilled in the construction of meaningful survey questions. My second reaction was amusement, mainly because most of the “defenses” of Prof. Skidmore’s paper were predictable and unconvincing. My third reaction was a bit of déjà vu combined with the satisfaction of seeing that James Lyons-Weiler had basically confirmed everything that I said about his journal without meaning to do so. In doing so, he reminded me that this is not the first time that we’ve seen a retracted paper resurrected in a dodgy journal; the only difference is that this time the dodgy journal was more obviously dodgy than the usual journal used to launder a retracted antivax study and even more obviously ideological. Given that Lyons-Weiler’s response allows me a chance to discuss his “Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge” (IPAK) grift, of which the “journal” in which Prof. Skidmore’s paper was republished is but a small part.

James Lyons-Weiler declares his glorious purpose
What struck me first about Lyons-Weiler’s post defending Mark Skidmore’s paper is that he basically admits to laundering the study in the service of fighting back against what he perceives as “censorship.” First, however, he takes great umbrage at criticism based on his journal:
As Editor-in-Chief of Science, Public Health Policy & the Law, I have established rigorous review practices and policies. To date we have published papers by invitation only. The peer-review process is as unbiased as possible: the authors of a paper do not know who the reviewers are, and we do not allow conflicts of interest between authors and reviewers.
Unlike other journals, we consider submissions that may have been wrongfully retracted. The reviewers are made aware that the paper has been sent to the journal following retraction, and why the journal is reviewing the study or paper anew.
The decision to publish or not publish the paper is entirely dependent on the feedback we receive from the peer reviewers.
So far, this sounds fair enough; that is, unless you look at Science, Public Health Policy & the Law. Lyons-Weiler’s assertions only seem reasonable until you see exactly what sort of “journal” he is running. Also note his glorious purpose: He openly states that he’s rescuing “wrongfully retracted” papers. Does anyone want to bet that Lyons-Weiler invited Prof. Skidmore to submit his retracted manuscript to Science, Public Health Policy & the Law. Lyons-Weiler doesn’t say that he did this, but reading between the lines I strongly suspect that he did.
An antivax “editorial board” for a fake journal
Peer review is meaningless if the editors and peer reviewers have a known bias and/or are conspiracy mongering cranks. It’s already a huge knock against the journal that James Lyons-Weiler created the journal and also serves as its Editor-in-Chief. Any journal worth its salt will try to recruit a prestigious and qualified editorial board. So let’s take a look at the editorial board of Science, Public Health Policy & the Law, starting with Lyons-Weiler himself. I will include links to SBM articles or tags about individual editorial board members and then briefly discuss them. Let’s just say that many of these names will be…familiar. Also, no doubt Lyons-Weiler, should he see this, will cry “ad hominem”! However, I would counter that the background and qualifications of an editorial board matter, and that his board is both highly biased with antivaxxers and unqualified. See if you agree:
    • Editor-in-Chief: James Lyons-Weiler, The Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge. James Lyons-Weiler, as I have discussed before, started out as a legitimate scientist but somehow went down the antivax rabbit hole years before COVID-19. He first made a name for himself just as COVID-19 was threatening to become a pandemic in early 2020 by being one of the first cranks to claim that SARS-CoV-2 (as it came to be named), the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, had been the result of a lab leak from a lab working on coronavirus vaccines since the SARS epidemic 20 years ago. He based that claim on his having supposedly found found nucleotide sequences from a commonly used plasmid in the then newly published sequence of SARS-CoV-2. (Hint: He didn’t.) He’s also been claiming that deaths from COVID-19 were misclassified and actually due to deaths from bacterial pneumonia, an old trick that antivaxxers used to use to claim that influenza deaths from superimposed secondary bacterial pneumonia were not actually flu deaths. Before the pandemic, he railed (badly) against studies that found that autism is primarily genetic in nature. More amusingly, in 2018 he got into a pissing match with another antivaxxer, stung by her criticism that he wasn’t sufficiently antivax. Long before the pandemic, he was a frequent presence at antivax conferences and on antivax panels; he even helped another editorial board member (Paul Thomas, below) run a highly dubious “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study.
    • Russell L. Blaylock, MD, Theoretical Neuroscience Research, LLC, Ridgeland, MS, USA. Russell Blaylock? Now that’s a blast from the past! Dr. Blaylock is a retired academic neurosurgeon who was a clinical assistant professor of neurosurgery at the University of Mississippi, who later turned quack and antivaxxer (but I repeat myself) and has since long been a fixture in the “alternative health” movement. Before the pandemic, he was claiming falsely that vaccines cause the fatal neurodegenerative disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS, commonly known as Lou Gehrig’s disease), Parkinson’s disease, and autism, as well as that vaccines such as the H1N1 vaccine are dangerous or ineffective; that dental amalgams and fluoridated water are harmful to our health; and that aluminum cookware, aspartame, and MSG are toxic substances that cause brain damage. Unsurprisingly, with the arrival of COVID-19, Dr. Blaylock embraced all the usual conspiracy theories and pseudoscience about it, including that the COVID-19 vaccine is a “dangerous, essentially untested experimental vaccine.” (This “editorial” by him in a similarly dubious journal is a greatest hits of COVID-19 misinformation, conspiracy theories, and pseudoscience, including a rant about ivermectin.)
    • Dolores J. Cahill, Professor, School of Medicine, Conway Institute, University College Dublin. I must confess to having been unfamiliar with Prof. Cahill, although I had heard the name before. It didn’t take me much Googling to discover that she has been abusing her position as a tenured professor of immunology to make all sorts of false claims about COVID-19, including that COVID-19 can be prevented by taking vitamin C, vitamin D and zinc; the most efficient treatment is hydroxychloroquine; children wearing a mask will be starved of oxygen and see their IQ lowered; and RNA-based vaccines do far more harm than good. She has even been quoted as saying, “If you paid me ten million, I wouldn’t take it. I would go to prison first. If someone vaccinated me [with an RNA vaccine], I would charge them with attempted murder.” A sure sign of just what a crank she is comes from the bravery of students at her university who wrote a 33-page scientific rebuttal of her claims, a document that was signed by 133 students from the university’s School of Medicine and sent to its administrators.
    • Gayle Delong, PhD, Baruch College, City University of New York. First off, as I mentioned in last week’s article, Gayle DeLong unfortunately died of breast cancer nearly two years ago, Even so, before her untimely passing, we had met Gayle DeLong before. She was an associate professor of economics at the Zicklin School of Business, where her areas of expertise were listed as international finance, financial institutions, and regulated industries, who had published an utterly execrable paper that falsely linked HPV vaccines to female infertility, a paper that was ultimately retracted, ironically right as CoVID-19 was making itself known in Wuhan. Before that, she had been publishing awful studies mining the VAERS database, the first of which I wrote about in 2011. Indeed, she “pioneered” (if you will) a number of bad study designs that have proliferated in the antivax “scientific literature” during the pandemic and been used by COVID-19 antivaxxers to blame COVID-19 vaccines for death, infertility, and general destruction.
    • Xavier A. Figueroa, PhD, Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge, Public Health Policy Initiative. Just being associated with IPAK is big enough red flag for pseudoscience and quackery for me, but maybe others need convincing. So I Googled, which led me to his Substack, where, among other nonsense, he rails against “scientism” as a “psyop”; promotes the quackery of spike protein “detoxification”; and misleadingly cites VAERS reports as evidence that COVID-19 vaccines are deadly. That told me all that I needed to know about him, as well as that he is a good fit for James Lyons-Weiler’s quack institute.
    • Ted Fogarty, MD, Past Chairman, University of North Dakota Department of Radiology; Assistant Professor, Heart of America Medical Center. Although I appear never to have written about Dr. Fogarty, I did vaguely recall the name. He is a radiologist (like, for instance, Dr. William Makis, another COVID-19 quack), which always makes me wonder why he thinks he has expertise in infectious disease and vaccines. It didn’t take long to discover that he has long been known in “alternative health” circles for his advocacy of hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) for, well, just about everything (even Alzheimer’s) through his “integrative medicine” medical practice (MoPlatte Hyperbarics) , including—unsurprisingly—as a treatment for advanced COVID-19. Equally unsurprisingly, he is antimask, and has parroted a number of antivax talking points before the North Dakota legislature, including the usual distortions about the Vaccine Court and a truly risible claim that mRNA vaccines are “manipulating genomics at a ribosomal level,” which, if you know anything about molecular biology, you will recognize as a meaningless phrase. So, yes, predictably he’s antivax, too.
    • Brian Hooker, PhD, Professor of Biology Simpson University. Antivax “luminary” Brian Hooker has been featured here many, many times, as well as at my not-so-super-secret other blog. Suffice to say that he, with Andrew Wakefield, was responsible for the creation of the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory in 2014 and was also a major character in Del Bigtree and Andrew Wakefield’s antivax pseudodocumentary “epic” VAXXED. These days, he’s been palling around with tech bro turned rabid antivaxxer, Steve Kirsch. ‘Nuff said.
    • Mary Holland, President, Children’s Health Defense. Mary Holland is president of Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivax organization, Children’s Health Defense. If that doesn’t demonstrate that she’s antivax to the core, I don’t know what will, but maybe her misusing her status as a lawyer to promote the “Nuremberg 2.0” narrative of retribution against public health officials and provaccine doctors and scientists or her abuse of research ethics in 2011 in the service of bad science and law claiming that vaccines cause autism will do the trick.
    • Rick Jaffe, Esq. Rick Jaffe was cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski‘s lawyer for decades; that is, until Burzynski stiffed him for ~$250,000 in legal bills. Before that, he was the one who had hatched Burzynski’s plan to use dubious clinical trials as cover for administering his unproven antineoplaston therapy to cancer patients. These days, Mr. Jaffe is a typical lawyer representing quacks, in particular stem cell quacks, while claiming that COVID-19 vaccines are “gene therapy” and lamenting has been lamenting how the organization that certifies most continuing medical education (CME) is trying to make its standards more rigorous, thus endangering courses in “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM).
    • Anthony R. Mawson, MA, DrPH, Jackson State University. Dr. Mawson is very appropriate to this medical board, too, as he was an earlier example of how retracted antivax studies don’t die, but come back, zombie-like, in dubious journals, the better to be laundered. More on this later in the post. These days, he too is palling around with Steve Kirsch.
    • James O’Dell, Bioregulatory Medicine Institute, Louisville, KY. I was unfamiliar with James O’Dell, but a quick Google search found his practice’s website, Inner Light Consultants, LLC. There, I learned that he is a “a highly sought-after traditional Chinese practitioner and one of Louisville’s most established naturopathic doctors”; in other words, a total quack offering cupping, acupuncture, naturopathic treatments, and more. His Bioregulatory Medicine Institute appears to have been founded in order to promote quackery like acupuncture meridian therapy, anthroposophic medicine, homeopathy, naturopathy, energy medicine, reflexology, and more—basically almost every form of quackery known to humans.
    • Jacob Puliyel, MD, MRCP, M Phil, Head of Pediatrics,, St. Stephens Hospital, Delhi, India. Similarly, I was not familiar with Dr. Puliyel, but it did not take me long to find that his name appears a lot in articles about “coercive vaccination” and was the plaintiff in a case, Jacob Puliyel v. Union of India, which held that “bodily integrity is protected under Article 21 of the Constitution of India and no individual can be forced to be vaccinated.” One could argue that he’s not “antivaccine” but “anti-mandate.” However, that argument would be undermined by his writing about COVID-19 and vaccines as the “abandonment of the scientific process” while fear mongering about spike protein from the vaccine, as he approvingly cited conspiracy theorists. Also, he defended Andrew Wakefield’s 1998 Lancet case series against Brian Deer’s investigative journalism that demonstrated scientific fraud in that series. (Addendum: Readers have informed me that Dr. Puliyel is a longtime antivax activist who has written for the antivax blog Age of Autism back in the day, his favorite topics being to fear monger about the oral polio vaccine, to claim incorrectly that HPV vaccines have “zero effect,” and to argue against universal Hib vaccination in India by casting doubt on a large clinical trial supporting its efficacy. Amusingly, he also took great umbrage in 2010 over being called part of the “antivaccine lobby” in The BMJ. Thank you, readers, for educating me about another longtime antivax quack.)
    • Christopher A. Shaw, PhD, University of British Columbia, Dept of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences Programs in Neuroscience and Experimental Medicine. Before the pandemic, Christopher Shaw featured here a number of times as an example of a scientist doing bad studies in order to “prove” that vaccines cause autism and Gardasil causes premature ovarian insufficiency in young women, all while supporting false claims that HPV vaccines have caused the sudden deaths of young women and using the results of an abusive FOIA request to intimidate a legitimate scientist who, having learned how she had been tricked into accepting an invitation to appear at an antivax “roundtable,” wisely withdrew. His work has also been funded by a wealthy antivaxxers.
    • Paul Thomas, MD, Integrative Pedatrics. What more can I say about Dr. Paul Thomas that I haven’t said already, particularly in my most recent post about him after the state of Oregon had suspended his license to practice medicine? He was a rising star in the antivax movement around 5 years ago and, with James Lyons-Weiler, ran a highly dubious “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study that was published in a (sort of, given that it was an MDPI journal) legitimate journal and then ultimately retracted. Since his medical license was suspended, Dr. Thomas has started a “health coaching” business. where he “will not be diagnosing or treating” but rather “providing information as a wellness coach” at $420 a pop for a 45 minute “coaching” session over Zoom. Truly, the grift is strong in this one.
Again, I know that Lyons-Weiler, should he see this, will whine to high heaven that this is an “ad hominem” attack. Again, I will emphasize that in order to judge a journal you really do need to know the expertise of its editorial board, and his editorial board consists entirely of antivaxxers, quacks, and cranks, one of whom has been deceased nearly two years. (Seriously, man, update your editorial board page.) After all, he already has claimed that I have nothing but ad hominem:
The study by Mark Skidmore et al. that was published earlier this month survived peer review. The reviewers gave substantiative feedback, and the authors addressed their critiques. Fair enough. Now the paper is part of the living, published knowledge base, not lying in ashes like so many Nazi-burned books.
After publication of our substack announcing Dr. Skidmore’s exoneration by the MSU IRB, naturally, and predictably, a person named David Gorski had to try to spin the events into a narrative he always spins: that vaccine are always safe, that the IRB got it wrong, that Science, Public Health Policy & the Law is an “antivax” “fake” journal, all the usual vacuous and empirically impoverished ad hominem he could muster.
If your journal was founded by an antivaxxer (you) and its editorial board consists of antivax conspiracy theorists (which I demonstrated rather conclusively that it does), then it is not at all unreasonable to call it an antivax journal. As for the “fake” bit, well, look at what Lyons-Weiler said about the “peer review” that it underwent. He as much as admitted that he invited Prof. Skidmore to resubmit to his journal, the results of which were always going to be predictable given the makeup of his editorial board. I note that Lyons-Weiler’s “journal” lists him as the “reviewing editor” for Prof. Skidmore’s paper. Given that, you can damned well predict that not only would Lyons-Weiler be sympathetic to the findings of this “study” but that he’d assign it to “peer reviewers” who, as antivaxxers, would also be sympathetic to the “study” and likely to overlook its massive methodological flaws.
Finally, just peruse the table of contents of the most recent issue of Science, Public Health Policy & the Law. There, you will find not one but two articles by Mark Skidmore, the first being this one, the second being an equally awful epidemiological study claiming to have found a correlation between access to hydroxychloroquine and lower mortality from COVID-19 and makes the claim that making hydroxychloroquine more widely available could have saved over a half a million lives. What about other, non-Skidmore, issues? There’s an article promoting an antivax narrative about MMR, associating Gardasil with teen suicide, promoting Dr. David Brownstein‘s quack treatment protocol for COVID-19,
Answering critiques
At this point, let me briefly scratch my head at this response to my critique by Lyons-Weiler:
The critique erroneously tries to emphasize that the study extrapolates from 39 vaccine-related fatalities to make nationwide estimates. This is a misleading representation. The actual sample size of the study is 2,840 participants, not 39. Thirty-nine is a result, it’s an estimate, not a sample size.
I went back and reread my post, and conclude that he’s trying to obfuscate by making a distinction without a real difference. Basically, he’s admitting that there were only 39 deaths reported among the social circles of the entire sample of 2,840 respondents, which is how I described the results, and I never called it a sample size; indeed I cited this passage from the study:
A total of 2840 participants completed the survey between December 18 and 23, 2021. 51% (1383 of 2840) of the participants were female and the mean age was 47 (95% CI 46.36–47.64) years. Those who knew someone who experienced a health problem from COVID-19 were more likely to be vaccinated (OR: 1.309, 95% CI 1.094–1.566), while those who knew someone who experienced a health problem following vaccination were less likely to be vaccinated (OR: 0.567, 95% CI 0.461–0.698). 34% (959 of 2840) reported that they knew at least one person who had experienced a significant health problem due to the COVID-19 illness. Similarly, 22% (612 of 2840) of respondents indicated that they knew at least one person who had experienced a severe health problem following COVID-19 vaccination.
Later, I cited this passage from one of the Supplemental Data sections:
As shown in Figure 1 in the body of the article, expected fatalities exceed reported fatalities for the 65-74 and 74-85 age groups, but the other categories generate positive vaccine deaths after subtracting expected fatalities. Setting COVID-19 vaccine fatalities to zero for the 65-74 and over 74 age groups, and tallying net fatalities for the other age groups generates 39 vaccine-related fatalities.
Let’s just put it this way. Extrapolating the results of a survey of 2,840 individuals to a population of ~330 million is problematic enough, but extrapolating from 39 reported deaths among the social circle of this sample of 2,840 is even more problematic. I will once again emphasize that, even if this was all totally valid and accurate, the most that can be said is that there is a perception that the vaccines can kill people that, if extrapolated from this survey, suggests that people’s beliefs suggest that around 278,000 people died after vaccination, which is why I laughed at Lyons-Weiler’s further defense:
Gorski, critique accuses the study of making broad claims based on a small number of fatalities without providing the necessary context. The study employs statistical methods to analyze data from 2,840 participants, and the 39 fatalities are contextualized within this framework. The critique’s failure to provide this context undermines its own argument, casting doubt on its intent and validity.
This sounds like a repeat of the gaslight, but it’s actually a general feature of bona fide critical thinking to consider context, too. Double-bad on Gorski
Nope. These statistical analyses are the science equivalent of putting the proverbial lipstick on a pig.

Unfortunately, Lyons-Weiler can’t resist digging himself in deeper:
The critique broadly labels the study’s methodology as flawed without engaging with the specifics of how the study conducted its analyses. The study employs logit regression analyses among other statistical methods, which the critique fails to address. This omission is a significant weakness, as it dismisses the study’s findings without adequately challenging the methods that led to those findings.
Seriously, the first thing I learned in biostatistics is that if the assumptions behind your analysis are hopelessly flawed, as they are in Prof. Skidmore’s study, no amount of statistical prestidigitation, no matter how advanced the methods, will make the study produce valid results. Moreover, again, the issue is how Prof. Skidmore took results from a survey that might have been interesting in and of themselves, for example how ideology and vaccine hesitancy will it more likely that one will attribute the death of someone in one’s social circle to vaccines and less likely that one will attribute the death to COVID-19, and misused that result to extrapolate a meaningless “estimate” of the number of deaths caused by COVID-19 vaccines. As for his claim that I said that Prof. Skidmore ignored other causes of death, well, not exactly. I actually said very little about that in the most recent version of the critique (mainly because the post was getting too long), but in an older version, I discussed this, and I also mentioned in the new version how you can’t correct for deaths from other causes that “would have happened anyway” using the methods described, particularly criticizing his apparent assumption that people with chronic diseases who died relatively quickly would probably have “died anyway.”
Also let me scratch my head at this part:
While the study does incorporate data from the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), it does so for comparative purposes and does not solely rely on this database for its conclusions. The critique’s overemphasis on the use of VAERS data misrepresents the study’s multifaceted approach to data analysis.
I hardly mentioned the study’s use of VAERS, although I did point out that it can’t be used to provide a reliable estimate of the prevalence of any adverse event because of the nature of the database, only pointing out that in Prof. Skidmore’s “comparison” of his results to VAERS he “appeared to accept nearly every respondent’s report of a death from the vaccine as having been caused by the vaccine.” Which he clearly did.
Before I move on to how this study was laundered, let me just laugh a bit at this part of Lyons-Weiler’s post:
The study underwent rigorous ethical oversight, receiving approval from the Institutional Review Board (IRB). Furthermore, it survived a peer-review process that included substantive feedback, to which the authors responded adequately. This adds an additional layer of validation to the study’s methodology.
Saying that cow pie must smell great because dogs love its smell does not mean that it does, in fact, smell great. (I’m sure you can guess what is the cow pie and what are the reviewers in this homespun analogy. I just hasten to caution that I love dogs and somewhat regret comparing them to the peer reviewers of this paper, although I also note that my two dogs love to roll in deer poop and I have to watch them very closely when they’re at my parents’ house, where deer frequently use their yard as a way station.)
Finally:
The methodology employed in the study by Mark Skidmore et al. adheres to scientific rigor and is well-suited to address the research questions posed. While no study is beyond critique, it is crucial that such critiques are grounded in a thorough understanding of the study’s methods, rather than misrepresentations or oversimplifications. The methodological choices made in this study are both defensible and appropriate, contributing to its value in the ongoing discourse on COVID-19 vaccination experiences and decisions.
In light of these points, Gorki’s critique’s approach appears to rely on the readership’s inability to discern its misleading tactics from bona fide critique.
Such tactics compromise the critique’s integrity and do a disservice to scientific discourse. It is imperative for critiques to adhere to the principles of reason, science, and logic to contribute constructively to academic and public discussions.
The only “disservice” done to science is articles like Prof. Skidmore’s and defenses of such dreck by science denialist cranks like James Lyons-Weiler.
Study laundering
I mentioned that Prof. Skidmore’s republication of his retracted study in a journal such as Lyon-Weiler’s is an example of “study laundering,” whereby a study that’s been retracted is published elsewhere in a dodgy journal that superficially appears to be a legitimate scientific journal but, upon closer inspection, is not. This brings me back to another member of the editorial board, namely Anthony Mawson.
Back in the day, long before the pandemic, Mawson was known as one of the first antivax “scientists” to have set up a “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study, the goal of which was to demonstrate that vaccinated children had much more autism and were generally more unhealthy than unvaccinated children. He also “pioneered” crowdfunding bad antivax studies all the way back in 2012. Ultimately, his study, which—surprise!—showed that vaccinated children were less healthy in that they had a higher risk of autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders. Like Prof. Skidmore, Mawson used a survey to come to his results. Hilariously, when his study was initially published in Frontiers of Public Health, a not great but not illegitimate journal, it received heated criticism, leading the publisher to describe the study thusly:
This article was provisionally accepted but not published. In response to concerns raised, we have reopened its review. @70Hertz
— Frontiers (@FrontiersIn) November 28, 2016
Basically, in essence the study ended up being nixed, although I don’t recall the word “retraction” ever having been used. After that, Mawson appears to have divided the study up two minimal publishable units and had them published as two papers in a bottom-feeding predatory open access journal even lower on the food chain that the first, after having promoted its second coming among the antivaccine crowd. Ultimately, the paper landed in the Journal of Translational Science, where it was apparently retracted but then reappeared again. As I joked at the time, “the check must have finally cleared.” Of course, the Journal of Translational Science is a dubious, bottom-feeding journal in my opinion. Even so, one might argue that this journal is marginally better than Lyons-Weiler’s journal in that, unlike Lyons-Weiler’s journal, it doesn’t appear to be pure antivax. Rather, it appears to be about the pay-to-publish model. On second thought, maybe that isn’t better. Either way, the study is still there, published on the journal’s website, thus laundered from its former retraction and appearing to have been a legitimate, peer-reviewed study. It rather makes me wonder if Mawson was one of the peer reviewers for Prof. Skidmore’s manuscript.
I also note that Brian Hooker has also had at least one bad study retracted, his “reanalysis” of a 2004 study showing no correlation between MMR vaccination and autism, which he published in that most ideological of right-wing antivax pseudojournals, the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons, the house journal for the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons. You remember AAPS, right? As I described before nearly 18 years ago, AAPS doctors are so far “outside the herd” that the organization promotes dangerous medical quackery, such as antivaccine pseudoscience blaming vaccines for autism, including a view that is extreme even among antivaccine activists, namely that the “shaken baby syndrome” is a “misdiagnosis” for vaccine injury; its HIV/AIDS denialism; its blaming immigrants for crime and disease; its promotion of the pseudoscience claiming that abortion causes breast cancer using some of the most execrable “science” ever; its rejection of evidence-based guidelines as an unacceptable affront on the godlike autonomy of physicians; or the way the AAPS rejects even the concept of a scientific consensus about anything. Let’s just put it this way. The AAPS has featured publications by antivaccine mercury militia “scientists” Mark and David Geier and, as of two years ago (the last time I checked) still promoting antivaccine pseudoscience.
Of course, these are not the only members of the editorial board who have had their bad studies retracted by journals. Two other editorial board members have done that as well, specifically, James Lyons-Weiler himself and Paul Thomas. Their crappy paper was a report of Dr. Thomas’ “vaxxed/unvaxxed” study that was retracted by MDPI’s International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health in 2021 due to problems in methodology. To my surprise, Lyons-Weiler never republished this study in his own journal. Maybe even he knows his journal is fake, try as he might to deny it. Or maybe he knows that he doesn’t need to launder his retracted papers, given how retracted papers seem to be highly cited and shared on social media far beyond their retracted status would lead you to believe they should be. In this area, Andrew Wakefield was unfortunately the pioneer before social media even existed.
But what about IPAK?
I will concluded by taking a brief look at James Lyons-Weiler’s IPAK, because his dubious “journal” is but a part of his activities spreading misinformation about science. If you look at the IPAK website, you will see that it seems to exist to offer online courses on a variety of topics. Its course listings appear, on first glance anyway, to be benign enough; that is, until you look at some of the instructors and subject matter.
The first thing that irritated me about the course list is that you can’t easily get a good description of all the courses. Clicking on most of the titles takes you not to an information page with a detailed course description but rather to a PayPal page to pay for the course, and you have to scroll all the way down the page to find links to the descriptions of some of the courses. I was amused, however, at the offering of a course called How Not To Be Fooled. Purporting to be a course in critical thinking, which is laughable enough coming from IPAK, it is taught by Mark McDonald, who promoted the discredited idea promoted with Dr. Robert Malone that the pandemic caused an epidemic of “delusion” that qualified as a “psychosis.” Just a brief perusal of McDonald’s Substack should be enough to show you that he is anything but a critical thinker. (He’s also a raging transphobe, too.) Seriously, though, click through yourself if you don’t believe me. Even on the registration page, which has some more, many of the course descriptions are so bare-bones and the instructors generally so laughable that it amazes me that anyone would pay up to $180 for these courses, although I do note that at least they admit that the Wholistic Approaches to Human Health course is taught by antivax quack David Brownstein. Overall, it looks to me as though there is a mixture of unobjectionable science with pure pseudoscience and quackery.
Combine Lyons-Weiler’s republication of bad retracted science (the Skidmore paper) with his “institute,” which appears to exist mainly to sell online courses mixing science with pseudoscience and bad science, and you see the model: Promote antivaccine pseudoscience, cultivate relationships with antivax quacks and fellow travelers like Mark Skidmore, and then portray oneself as hopelessly “persecuted” and “silenced,” using retractions like that of Skidmore’s paper as examples. Of course, as I like to say, retraction is not “censorship” but rather quality control, to which I also like to add that far too few, not too many, papers are retracted. Then, building on that narrative, profit. It’s not as though this hasn’t been a strategy used by quacks since time immemorial. The only difference now is that Substack, social media, and video make the profit margin so much more potentially lucrative.
ADDENDUM: James Lyons-Weiler is…not pleased…with me. Looking over his rambling, oh-so-self-righteous and “civil” defense of his journal, I do wonder about his reading comprehension. For example, he claims that I called his journal a “pay-to-publish” journal. I did not. I called the journal in which Anthony Mawson republished his retracted study “pay-to-publish.” Don’t believe me? Reread this post! He also claims that I called his journal a “bottom-feeding predatory open access journal.” Don’t believe me? Again, reread this post! Look, Lyons-Weiler’s journal is a crappy, biased fake journal, in my opinion, but I never called it “pay-to-publish” or “predatory open access.” I do consider it to be very much bottom-feeding in addition to be biased. (Just look at the table of contents of the handful of issues published), however, even though I never explicitly described it as such.

How antivaxxers laid the groundwork to blame COVID-19 vaccines for Damar Hamlin’s cardiac arrest
Right after Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin collapsed from a cardiac arrest after a tackle and was resuscitated on the field, antivaxxers immediately pounced, blaming COVID-19 vaccines even as CPR was still continuing. That’s because antivaxxers had “primed the pump” over more than a year with stories of young athletes who had supposedly “died suddenly.” (Warning: This one’s long, even by Gorski standards.)
David Gorski on January 9, 2023
Link

One week ago, I was in a wistful mood as I idly flipped channels looking for some background television as I contemplated the end of the holidays and my impending return to work the next day and entry into the gloomiest part of the year, when I came across a shocking and disturbing scene. Actually, at first the scene was not so much shocking as puzzling. It was an NFL football game, and the action was stopped due to what appeared to be a player injury, something that is not uncommon at all. What was uncommon and caught my eye was the number of players milling around on the field, seemingly every member of both teams, which signaled to me that this injury was not your run-of-the-mill sprain. Rather, it suggested that the injury was very, very serious. And so it was, as quickly became apparent. CPR was being administered to a player on the field, as the announcers, shocked into uncharacteristic reticence, intermittently commented on what was happening on the field using hushed and horrified voices. I soon learned that the player was Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin, who had gotten up after a tackle but then collapsed. As the CPR on Hamlin continued for what seemed like an interminable amount of time, I had two thoughts. The first was shock: Was Hamlin dead? Had he died on the field? No one knew at the time whether Hamlin had died or suffered irreversible brain damage from lack of blood flow, and over the next several days it was not clear whether he would recover, as he spent several days on the ventilator.
Fortunately, Damar Hamlin was not dead and did ultimately survive apparently neurologically intact, with recent reports indicating that he has been weaned from the ventilator and is now talking to family and teammates.
Damar Hamlin FaceTimed into our team meeting today to talk to players and coaches.
What he said to the team: “Love you boys.” ❤️ pic.twitter.com/8dorrWNaxt
— Buffalo Bills (@BuffaloBills) January 6, 2023
I bet you can guess what my second thought was. I was half-tempted to leave a lot of space after this paragraph to give readers a chance to guess, but instead I’ll just tell you my second thought: Have antivaxxers started blaming Hamlin’s cardiac arrest on vaccines yet?
Ghoulishly and disgustingly, it turns out that they had. Damar Hamlin collapsed at about 8:55 PM ET. He underwent CPR for nine minutes, as well as defibrillation with an automated external defibrillator (AED), and was down for 19 minutes before being taken off the field to an ambulance, which left for University of Cincinnati Hospitals at 9:25 PM.
So let’s take a look at Twitter from that evening:
Is Damar Hamlin going to be yet another case of #diedsuddenly? Horrific.
— JoeKanYou (@joekanyou) January 3, 2023
Note the timestamp: 9:12 PM.
It turns out that Dr. Drew Pinsky (a.k.a. “Dr. Drew”) was even faster off the mark, at 9:08 PM:
So disturbing. Another athlete who dropped suddenly. 🙏🙏🙏 https://t.co/zk6akqwTBO
— Dr. Drew (@drdrew) January 3, 2023
I’ll give Dr. Drew credit. He was clever. He didn’t directly blame vaccines for Damar Hamlin’s collapse. However, the above Tweet was definitely an antivax dog whistle, as Dr. Drew is clearly very much aware of the “died suddenly” antivax narrative that seeks to falsely blame any sudden cardiac arrest and/or death in a young person as being due to COVID-19 vaccines. Also notice how “dropped suddenly” resembled “died suddenly”. I would guess that this was no accident, and a number of doctors noticed that right away and took Dr. Drew to task:
You know exactly what you're doing here, and it's despicable.
— Tyler Black, MD (@tylerblack32) January 3, 2023
For real? Did you not see the blunt trauma immediately preceding the fall?
— Rachel Alter, MD MPH (@RachelAlter007) January 3, 2023
Within an hour, bigger names in the disinformation social media world were weighing in similarly, for example Charlie Kirk at 9:52 PM:
This is a tragic and all too familiar sight right now: Athletes dropping suddenly.
— Charlie Kirk (@charliekirk11) January 3, 2023
At the time, I noted two things. First, I hate how dealing with the tsunami of antivaccine messaging over the last two years has led me to the point where, when I see news of young person collapsing and possibly dying unexpectedly, one of my first thoughts is to wonder whether antivaxxers have started to blame vaccines yet. (Invariably, they have.) Second, to antivaxxers, it’s always about the vaccines. It’s always been about the vaccines. It always will be about the vaccines.
As the week rolled on, it also became apparent to me that antivaxxers had been waiting for something like Damar Hamlin’s collapse. While it’s true that they had been claiming that COVID-19 vaccines have been responsible for a wave of thousands, if not millions, of people who “died suddenly” due to clots, to the point where they had even produced an antivaccine conspiracy movie disguised as a documentary, Died Suddenly, it turns out that there are specific “flavors”—variants, if you will—of the “died suddenly narrative.” One of these has been built up over the last 14 months, if not longer, so that when Damar Hamlin collapsed a week ago, a rare event, they were ready to pounce.
Even though I’ve written about this case twice on my not-so-super-secret other blog, I thought that it would be worthwhile to describe how this narrative came about and who produced it. Some of what I write will be familiar to those who also follow my other blog, but what I seek to do here is to put the antivax disinformation that arose from Damar Hamlin’s cardiac arrest into some perspective and emphasize two things. First, the narrative of young people “dying suddenly” (because of vaccines) is nothing new, and these sorts of narratives date back to long before the pandemic. Second, this particular “variant” of the “died suddenly” narrative was created in 2021 and had been nurtured carefully by an anonymous astroturf website associated with a now well-known publisher known for spreading antivaccine disinformation. My goal is to explain how the old “died suddenly” narrative gave birth to the new COVID-19 version, how the specific variant about young athletes “dying suddenly” because of vaccines was created and built up throughout 2022, and how the antivax narrative about Damar Hamlin—shall we say?—evolved in ways specific to COVID-19 antivax claims in order to sound more plausible as doctors pushed back by pointing out that the most likely explanation for Hamlin’s cardiac arrest was a phenomenon called commotio cordis.
So let’s start with commotio cordis.
Commotio cordis: Cardiac arrest due to a blow to the chest
The first thought that came to mind among emergency room doctors, and trauma surgeons on social media was that the most likely cause of Hamlin’s collapse was commotio cordis. This is a phenomenon when a blow to the chest can result in disruption of the heart rhythm, ventricular fibrillation, and cardiac arrest. It’s not common, but it is a described phenomenon. As is the case with any cardiac arrest, survival is inversely proportional to how quickly effective CPR and electrical cardioversion are administered, and because commotio cordis happens outside of the hospital, like other cardiac arrests in the community, it has a high mortality rate. A 2012 review article noted:
Approximately 10 to 20 cases are added to the Commotio Cordis Registry yearly.3,4 Until the late 1990s, commotio cordis was only rarely reported. It is thought that this increase in the number of cases is not due to an increase in incidence but rather to a greater awareness based on the 1995 New England Journal of Medicine report on commotio cordis.2 Many more cases of commotio cordis are now recognized as such. Indeed, what was thought to be a uniquely North American phenomenon is increasingly being reported in countries outside the United States.5
Commotio cordis primarily affects young individuals, generally in adolescence. In the Registry, the mean age is 15 years4; there have been very few commotio cordis victims over the age of 20 years. It traditionally has been thought that the stiffening of the chest wall contributes to this decrease in incidence in older individuals; however, this decreased incidence in those over 20 years of age is likely also influenced by the reduced ball-related sports participation by older individuals. Victims are overwhelmingly male. A partial explanation for the overwhelming predominance of males is that they populate the majority of sports in which commotio occurs, but it appears unlikely that the 95% predilection for males reflects a 95% incidence of chest wall impact in sports and activities of daily living. I suspect that there may also be some gender-related biological susceptibility to chest wall impact induced sudden cardiac death. Indeed, other arrhythmic conditions demonstrate a gender predilection for arrhythmia, including females with long-QT syndrome6,7 and males with Brugada syndrome.8 Genetic differences in ion channels between the sexes or biological modification of these channels by sex hormones may be involved in the male susceptibility to commotio cordis.
One common misconception about commotio cordis is that it requires a blow hard enough to damage the heart muscle and cause a cardiac contusion, something that I used to see not infrequently in victims of vehicular trauma back in the 1990s when I still did trauma surgery. Timing is likely more important, as commotio cordis is much more likely to happen if the blow lands at a specific point in the cardiac electrical cycle, as shown in this helpful graphic from Wikipedia:

Although there are other possible diagnoses, such as hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy (HOCM), these are much less likely given the history of a blow to the chest. Also, as some noted:
As I have discussed here and elsewhere in the context of antivaxxers claiming that we are seeing a wave of sudden arrhythmic death syndrome (SADS), we routinely require sports physicals on children and adolescents before letting them participate in school sports in order to screen them for conditions known to be associated with SADS. Just imagine how much more in-depth the medical evaluation is of NFL football players and elite athletes before they are signed. That aside, the main point here is that Damar Hamlin’s tragic collapse, given what was witnessed and what we know, was so incredibly unlikely to be due to COVID-19 vaccines as to make the probability near homeopathic, but antivaxxers immediately put vaccine injury at the very top of their delusional “differential diagnosis,” to the point where to them it’s nearly the only possibility, other than to consider far more likely possibilities just long enough to dismiss them and point the finger at vaccines again. We can say with a very high degree of confidence just based on what we know now that vaccines did not cause Damar Hamlin to try to “die suddenly,” but in the bizarro world of antivaxxers it is taken as an article of faith that it was vaccines that caused Hamlin’s cardiac arrest.
How the antivax narrative about Damar Hamlin evolved
As more and more reporting soon suggested that it was probably the blow to the chest that had had resulted in Hamlin’s cardiac arrest, the antivax narrative…changed. Basically, antivaxxers started claiming that commotio cordis is incredibly rare and never been reported in the NFL before; so it couldn’t possibly have been the cause of Damar Hamlin’s collapse. Unsurprisingly, within two hours after Hamlin’s arrest, the pandemic’s wrongest man Alex Berenson was at the forefront of pushing this narrative based on a cherry picked article:
I don’t even want to talk about any of this tonight. @HamlinIsland should be the only focus. But to see people ALREADY trying to spin this, and to announce what questions are and are not to okay to ask, is sickening. ENOUGH.
— Alex Berenson (@AlexBerenson) January 3, 2023
The “spin is already starting”? “But to see people ALREADY trying to spin this”? Truly, projection is all these people can do, and Berenson was trying to “spin this” to be about vaccines beginning almost immediately after Hamnlin’s collapse. I also note that Berenson quoted the same passage from the 2012 review article that I did above, but spun it very differently.
It didn’t take me long as I did more reading to discover that commotio cordis is actually, if anything, very much underdiagnosed:
Although commotio cordis usually involves impact from a baseball, it has also been reported during hockey, softball, lacrosse, karate, and other sports activities in which a relatively hard and compact projectile or bodily contact caused impact to the person’s precordium. While only 216 instances have been reported to the US Commotio Cordis Registry (as of 2012), [4, 5] this is probably a considerable underestimation of its true incidence since this entity still goes unrecognized in many instances and continues to be underreported.
And, in case you didn’t get it the first time:
Approximately 15-25 commotio cordis deaths are added to the US Commotio Cordis Registry every year. [14] The actual incidence is, in all likelihood, considerably greater because of lack of recognition and underreporting.
Another antivax talking point that started to appear was that Damar Hamlin, at age 24, is too old to have been a victim of commotio cordis, which most commonly affects teenaged boys. Nope. Just because Damar Hamlin is 24 years old does not mean that he couldn’t have been the victim of commotio cordis:
Although reported in a wide range of ages (6 wk to 50 y), commotio cordis occurs most frequently in male children aged 10-18 years, with a mean age of 15 ± 9 years. Data from the US Commotio Cordis Registry show that 26% are younger than 10 years and 75% are younger than 18 years. [5]
So basically Hamlin’s age is at the upper range of the mean age plus (I presume) standard error, suggesting that it wouldn’t be rare compared to the total incidence of commotio cordis for it to happen to a 24-year-old.
Then the antivax narrative…evolved again, this time thanks to Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone and Dr. Peter “COVID-19 vaccines are depopulation” McCullough, amplified by Steve Kirsch. Let’s start with Malone:
What we do know – is that it's not normal for an elite specimen that is only 24-years old to have a heart attack on the field. And he's not the only elite athlete dropping. This is status quo and seemingly accelerating.
— Sowell Train (@415GoldIsValue) January 3, 2023
Actually, no, you cannot “safely assume that those known preconditions were not present,” as the article I just cited above describes:
Autopsy of those with fatal commotio cordis typically shows normal cardiac morphology. Small oval or circular abrasions or bruises are often noted over the precordium, primarily over the left ventricle. In general, there’s no evidence of rib fractures, hemothorax, hemopericardium, external myocardial contusion; no congenital or acquired structural entities known to predispose young people and athletes to sudden death; no evidence for aortic rupture or traumatic injury; and no evidence of either damage or thrombosis of the coronary arteries.
So, no. NFL physicians very well might not have found anything that would predispose Damar Hamlin to commotio cordis because there probably wasn’t anything to find. Unsurprisingly, throughout yesterday and last night, the antivax narrative continued to…evolve…further.
Enter Dr. Peter McCullough, whom Steve Kirsch quoted in an update to a Substack that published at 7:54 PM PT, which if you do the math works out to be a little less than two hours after Damar Hamlin’s collapse on national TV, indicating that truly the antivax blogopshere (or Substackosphere, if you will) was all over this tragedy immediately:
I watched the play live both as a fan and a cardiologist and I saw blunt neck and chest trauma, a brief recovery after the tackle and then a classic cardiac arrest. I have communicated to one of the most experienced trainers in the world and we agree that it was a cardiac arrest in the setting of a big surge of adrenalin. If Damar Hamlin indeed took one of the COVID-19 vaccines, then subclinical vaccine-induced myocarditis must be considered in the differential diagnosis.
Also, according to Kirsch:
Note that McCullough originally speculated that the injury that Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin was due to commotio cordis (a phenomenon in which a sudden blunt impact to the chest causes sudden death in the absence of cardiac damage). The time delay from the hit until he collapsed is expected in commotio cordis.
Basically, McCullough started out by suggesting the most likely diagnosis from an actual science-based perspective, namely commotio cordis, but then apparently realized that it would be much better from an antivax perspective to start finding a way to blame vaccines:
Peter believes that the ventricular tachycardia and ventricular fibrillation could have been set up by the vaccine if he took it.
“If he took it”. It should be emphasized here that the NFL never actually imposed a vaccine mandate on its players, although for the 2021 season it did impose policies that dictated that any game canceled due to a COVID-19 outbreak would, if it couldn’t be rescheduled during the regular season, be forfeited by the team that had the outbreak and, even more “incentive” not to have preventable outbreaks, no one on the team would be paid for the forfeited game, as well as be “responsible for all additional expenses incurred by the opposing team and will also be required to pay any shortfall between actual and expected payment to the VTS poo”. The league later reported that 95% of its players and personnel have been vaccinated.
NFL policies aside, Dr. McCullough’s narrative combined the fear mongering about the small risk of myocarditis in young men due to COVID-19 vaccines with the whole false “died suddenly” conspiracy narrative, but cleverly made it a “just asking questions” sort of wild speculation, rather than outright saying that this is what happened. He didn’t have to say it outright. He knew that his JAQing off would, when it hit antivax social media, be transformed into assertions rather than speculation, particularly after the appearance in antivax Substacks of links to a case series of two (!) rugby players who died after a blow to the chest, one of whom had a distant history of viral myocarditis and the other of whom had evidence on autopsy of fibrosis of the heart consistent with a previous bout myocarditis, leading the authors to conclude:
Myocarditis may increase the risk of life-threatening ventricular arrhythmias caused by blunt impact to the chest, particularly in contact sports. Screening and prevention measures should be considered to reduce this risk.
In the world of antivaccine misinformation, “might” quickly became “does”, and the fact that the only reference cited involved what could only just barely be called a case series given that there were only two cases in it, much less that a case series doesn’t demonstrate causation, was not mentioned. There’s just one problem, and I will cite a recent article on commotio cordis to explain:
Histologic findings are almost always normal. There’s typically no evidence of acute or chronic myocardial infarction, infection, or inflammation, nor evidence of active or healed myocarditis or arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. Hemorrhage has been reported in the anterior left ventricular wall and in the A-V node and specialized conduction system, but the significance of these findings is uncertain.
In other words, nearly all commotio cordis happens without any evidence of heart inflammation, acute or chronic, which is, of course, entirely consistent with the currently postulated mechanism of a blow to the chest at the “wrong” time in the cardiac electrical cycle disrupting the rhythm of the heart and leading to ventricular fibrillation. It’s therefore not surprising that on autopsy histologic findings in the hearts of the young athletes who die of commotio cordis are almost always stone cold normal. Basically, antivaxxers cherry picked a two patient case series that speculates that a history of myocarditis might predispose athletes to commotio cordis and use it to speculate that it must have been vaccine-induced myocarditis that predisposed Damar Hamlin to suffering the same. Even more cleverly and conveniently, you can still accept medical findings that myocarditis associated with COVID-19 vaccines is uncommon and nearly always mild and self-limited and find McCullough’s narrative that “vaccine-induced” myocarditis predisposes to commotio cordis persuasive.
Amusingly, antivaxxers couldn’t even get their narratives straight. For example, another antivax cardiologist named Dr. Sanjay Verma claimed that it was nearly impossible to cause commotio cordis with a shoulder pad hit to the chest, which appeared to be the precipitating event, because shoulder pads are designed to absorb precisely such a shock:
We don’t have to be equivocal and say it probably wasn’t Commotio Cordis. I can say with 100% scientific and clinical confidence that such a scenario (right shoulder pad hitting left precordium as I saw on multiple replays) is virtually impossible and cannot be deduced conclusively the night of the incident. This has never before occurred in 103 years of NFL.
So is Dr. Verma saying that Dr. McCullough doesn’t know what he’s talking about when he claims that the vaccine could have predisposed Damar Hamlin to commotio cordis? Crank fight! Also notice the extreme confidence Dr. Verma exhibits, saying not just that commotio cordis is unlikely but saying with “100% scientific and clinical confidence” that it’s “virtually impossible”. Such extreme confidence in one’s own pronouncements is a sign of quackery and pseudoscience; true experts almost never talk that way. Even if commotio cordis is every bit as rare as Berenson, Verma, and hordes of other antivaxxers are trying to portray it, that wouldn’t mean that Damar Hamlin didn’t suffer from it. Given the thousands of hits to which NFL players are subject each and every year (and have been subject to for many decades), eventually one would expect that even a rare tragic event like this would become close to inevitable. The law of large numbers applies, in which, when the numbers are large enough, eventually even rare events occur.
It also didn’t take long, when it was still uncertain whether Damar Hamlin would live or, if he did live, would suffer permanent brain damage due to low blood flow after his cardiac arrest, to start weaving conspiracy theories, with a commenter on Steve Kirsch’s Substack ranting:
On the negative front: There is ZERO chance the NFL lets the family have an autopsy performed for possible link to vaccine. If it showed a link and that information became public, the league would probably shut down the rest of the year at least since every player would be considered a ticking time bomb. Players Association will go nuts. I’d say they pay off his family to prevent posthumous analysis if that’s where this ends up.
It got even worse than even this, with Dr. Paul Alexander posting on his Substack on January 4 an article with a headline reading MURDER charge Pfizer & Moderna & Fauci (FDA, CDC, NIH) makers of mRNA/DNA gene injection (vaccine), indict them, killing a black man on live television DAMAR HAMLIN, while lying about commotio cordis and claiming, “What you need for murder charge to stick is below in my substacks; he ‘died’ on the field, they are lying about commotio cordis, they killed him with this deadly gene vaccine they made Chauvin 2.0.” You can read the whole thing if you’re interested and even peruse his Substack for a lot more of the same, but you get the idea. Antivaxxers were combining false (or at the very least wildly speculative and unverifiable) claims that the vaccine had given Damar Hamlin myocarditis, which had predisposed him to commotio cordis, and that now “They” were “covering up” a racist “murder” akin to the death of George Floyd at the hands of police officer Derek Chavin. Nor was Dr. Alexander the only one making this vile comparison. So was Toby Rogers, who wrote:
What Pfizer did to Damar Hamlin is the same thing that Derek Chauvin did to George Floyd — 9 minutes without breath.
But there will be no statement from the NAACP, Black Lives Matter, Southern Poverty Law Center, the Democratic Party, nor the NFL Player’s Association about the shots that stopped Damar Hamlin’s heart. Such a possibility does not even cross their minds. It’s unthinkable.
The internal mental colonization is so great that most Americans will reach for any excuse, no matter how preposterous, to exonerate the shots.
Pfizer literally killed a Black man (stopped his heart for 9 minutes) on live TV and then told all Americans to shut up if they know what’s good for them.
But how did we get here?
How we got here: Before the pandemic
A lot of people were surprised by how fast and ghoulish antivaxxers were after Damar Hamlin collapsed, even as they hypocritically accused vaccine advocates of politicizing his near-death. As I related above, antivaxxers were openly (and quite prominently) speculating about and blaming COVID-19 vaccines as the cause of his cardiac arrest while CPR was still being administered on the field. Within a day or two, antivaxxers were all over the media, both social and traditional, spreading their narrative and blaming vaccines as the cause of other athletes having cardiac arrests and dying.
Those of us who have been countering antivaccine misinformation and disinformation since long before the pandemic were not at all surprised, and, going forward, when something like this happens again—which it will—neither should you be surprised. Let me relate some history to show that the “died suddenly” antivax narrative is most definitely not new. Then I will describe how the rise of specific version of this myth that arose shortly after COVID-19 vaccines received emergency use approval (EUA), after which I will show how the “variant” of this version of this myth involving the “sudden deaths” of athletes was not random. Rather, it was a carefully planted story that had been nurtured since at least November 2021, with antivaccine doctors like Dr. Peter McCullough lending an air of seeming academic credibility. As you will see, Damar Hamlin’s collapse happened at a particularly unfortunate time, as the narrative about athletes supposedly having “died suddenly” due to vaccines had received a fresh shot in the arm right before Christmas.
False claims that vaccines kill have been a staple of antivax conspiracy narratives going back as long as I can remember. The most recent prepandemic version of this narrative was a claim that arose nearly immediately after HPV vaccines such as Gardasil and Cervarix were approved in 2006 for girls aged 9-26 to protect against cervical, vulvar and vaginal cancers caused by Human Papillomavirus (HPV) types 16 and 18 and genital warts caused by HPV types 6 and 11. Later versions of these vaccines covered more HPV types, with Gardasil 9 now covering—you guessed it—nine HPV types, and indications were broadened to include females 9 through 45 years of age for the prevention of cervical, vulvar, vaginal, anal, oropharyngeal and other head and neck cancers caused by human papillomavirus (HPV) and males 9 through 45 years of age for the prevention of anal, oropharyngeal and other head and neck cancers caused by HPV.
The first time I wrote about the specific claim that Gardasil is killing girls and young women was eight years ago, when The Toronto Star published a particularly execrable news report that suggested that the death of a 14-year-old girl named Annabelle Morin might have been due to Gardasil, even noting:
…many of the girls say the vaccine was pushed on them by school officials, nurses or doctors who understated the risks, sometimes claiming zero significant side effects despite the existence of a list of rare but serious vaccine-related reactions published by the drug’s maker.
The Star has found the girls’ concerns are not isolated, that in Canada important safety information about the vaccine has not been communicated to many young patients and their parents.
I discussed in great detail why Morin’s tragic story was not evidence of causation (and didn’t even really strongly suggest possible causation). I also mentioned how antivaxxers had been blaming Morin’s sudden death in 2008 on Gardasil for at least three years when The Star article was published, her mother having encountered fear mongering about Gardasil on Joseph Mercola’s website, leading her to sue Merck over her death. Nor was Morin the only sudden death exploited by antivaxxers. For example, the death of 18-year-old Jasmine Renata, who was found dead in her bed six months after her last dose of the three-shot series of Gardasil in 2009, was exploited by antivaxxers, who convinced her mother that Gardasil, not any genetic conduction defect predisposing to SADS (sound familiar?), had killed her. Three years later, antivax scientist Christopher Shaw, who was known for also claiming that Gardasil causes premature ovarian insufficiency, testified at a New Zealand inquest that Gardasil had killed her, claiming to have found aluminum in her brain tissue that had been taken at autopsy, while another antivax pathologist, Dr. Sing Han Lee—think of him as a precursor to COVID-19 era antivax pathologist Dr. Ryan Cole—testified that there was foreign DNA from the HPV strain used in the vaccine in Rentata’s blood—bound to aluminum of course—and that that must have caused her death.
Again, does any of this sound familiar?
In 2018, the antivax group—more specifically the anti-Gardasil group—SANEVAX had made a series of YouTube videos entitled Sacrificial Virgins, which blamed Gardasil for the death of 19-year-old Jasmin Soriat, a German woman who in 2017 died in her sleep three weeks after receiving her second dose of Gardasil.
I could go on and on, but the point is simple. The narrative that vaccines are killing young people long predates the pandemic. Indeed, the “sacrificial virgins” narrative was preceded by another narrative blaming vaccines for death, specifically the false claim that vaccines cause sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), a Vaccine Court ruling notwithstanding. (This particular Vaccine Court ruling was ultimately struck down.)
That doesn’t even count other antivaccine tactics that we see in the Damar Hamlin case, such as blaming vaccines for deaths that were clearly due to something else. The Alan Yurko case from two decades ago comes to mind, in which antivaxxers blamed vaccines for shaken baby syndrome. Let’s just say that the “Free Yurko” movement was a particularly disgusting and despicable example of this phenomenon, every bit as bad as Paul Alexander ranting that pharma and the government “murdered” a Black man on live television. Of course, before the pandemic, antivaxxers loved to compare vaccine mandates to the Holocaust and Nazi war crimes (with themselves as persecuted Jews)—planned, of course, as in “plandemic“!—and claim that vaccines are a plan to depopulate the earth; so their willingness to “go there” should be no surprise. These sorts of conspiracy theories are no different, other than intensity and specific elements related to COVID-19, from the same basic antivax conspiracies from years past.
How we got here since the pandemic
I’ve already discussed how antivaxxers have developed a narrative claiming that an epidemic of young, presumably healthy people having “died suddenly” arose beginning soon after governments all over the world undertook mass vaccination campaigns against COVID-19. Indeed, as I predicted, they weaponized reports of death after COVID-19 vaccination made to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database, starting almost immediately. By summer 2021, the narrative had evolved to become an updated version of the hoary old antivax chestnut portraying vaccines as a “depopulation agenda“. Not coincidentally, one of the antivaxxers promoting the claim that vaccines are causing “depopulation” during the summer of 2021 was disgraced cardiologist Dr. Peter McCullough, whom I quoted earlier. This was the first thread woven into the narrative prepared ahead of time that was ready and waiting for Damar Hamlin (or someone like him) to suffer.
The second thread arose at around the same time, based on the detection of two safety signals for COVID-19 vaccines. The first safety signal was the association of the AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson vaccines with a rare kind of blood clot in the brain, which was likely the origin of the antivax buzzword “clot shot”. The risk was small, and getting vaccinated was still far safer than getting COVID-19, but the antivax narrative was predictably full of fear mongering. Part of this thread were antivax doctors and embalmers claiming that they were finding clots of unprecedented numbers and sizes in the recently deceased, which led to the antivax conspiracy movie Died Suddenly, which famously confused obvious postmortem clots with clots that had formed during life. (Seriously people, pathologists have long known how to distinguish the two.)
The second safety signal was the detection of an elevated risk of myocarditis after mRNA vaccines in young people, particularly teenaged males and young men, a risk that, according to the most recent evidence (discussed by Steve Novella in November), is real but very small. As we’ve written before, the risk was low and nearly all cases were mild and self-limited, but thus was born the narrative that vaccines could lead to heart attacks and sudden cardiac death, an unproven (and almost certainly false claim) promoted by Dr. Peter McCullough and, more recently, Dr. Aseem Malhotra, who famously now blames the vaccines for his 70-year-old father’s sudden death of a heart attack.
Together these threads were woven into the “died suddenly” narrative, in which COVID-19 vaccines are supposedly causing a tsunami of sudden cardiac deaths in young people due to myocarditis and clots. That might have been enough by itself to lay the groundwork for antivaxxers to be ready to pounce and blame Damar Hamlin’s commotio cordis on vaccines, but it turns out that there are…variants…of the “died suddenly” narrative. One of these is the conspiracy theory that 80 Canadian doctors died mysteriously and suddenly, deaths that antivaxxers blamed on the vaccine. (There is no evidence for this.) The second variant is specific to athletes, namely the conspiracy theories that an unprecedented number of athletes have “dropped suddenly” of cardiac arrests with many of them dying. Not coincidentally, Dr. McCullough has been flogging this conspiracy theory for months, which is perhaps why he was so quick to speak to Steve Kirsch the night of Damar Hamlin’s cardiac arrest.
When I first Tweeted about this, it didn’t take long for antivaxxers to start responding with links like this one, which claims to be of a “database” of athletes who suffered cardiac arrest and/or sudden deaths, and Tweets like this:
Its this Gemma pic.twitter.com/MCvWzT9POn
— all about the truth (@motherhubbardx) January 6, 2023
It’s a claim that was amplified to his massive audience by Tucker Carlson:
Before the mRNA vaccine, 29 cardiac arrests per year in sports, after the vax 1,500 in ONE year. Two thirds of those cases resulted in death. Awake yet? #StoptheShots #VaccineDeath #Myocarditis #Tucker pic.twitter.com/xLDQQAOnpj
— Now The End Begins (@NowTheEndBegins) January 5, 2023
I soon noticed that many of the Tweets and social media posts featured this graph:

As you can see, this graph comes from a website called Real Science (GoodSciencing.com), whose tagline is “Science needs open discussion anything else is totalitarian”. (I normally say that grammar flames are weak, but I’ll make an exception here to point out the run-on sentence, mainly because it pains me to read it.) A quick perusal of the site shows that, contrary to its name, the website and blog is full of COVID-19 misinformation about vaccines, ivermectin, and masks, as well as science denial about climate change. The specific post featuring the graph above was “1652 Athlete Cardiac Arrests, Serious Issues, 1114 of Them Dead, Since COVID Injection“. (Note that the anonymous bloggers behind this website have already added more than 50 new “cases” to their number, which had been 1,598 at the time of Hamlin’s collapse and had grown to 1,616 by the time I read it a couple of days later.)
First, I should mention that it’s blog post from anonymous authors, who describe themselves thusly:
We are a small team of investigators, news editors, journalists, and truth seekers, now backed up by others, who are discovering pieces of information that we can investigate. It doesn’t really matter who we are. What really matters is that we care carrying on an investigation and we’re presenting the evidence we’ve found, almost all of it documented in mainstream media publications.
We’re doing this anonymously because we’ve seen people viciously attacked and threatened for doing things like this, so we’re not going to open ourselves or any of our contacts to that. Also, please note, we’re not being paid and we’re not making any money from this – it is costing us time, effort, and money. We’re doing it because there is a concerted effort to block all of this information, but as some smart people used to say, “sunlight is the best disinfectant.”
Sunlight would indeed be the best disinfectant if that sunlight were shone on the identities of the “investigators” behind this blog and website. Ultimately it was, as I will discuss in a moment, but first let me note that I immediately suspected that there’s a good reason why they are hiding their identities. More likely than being afraid of professional consequences is the possibility that they are part of an astroturf organization and have no relevant credentials, training, or experience to carry out the analysis they claim to be carrying out. (That much is obvious just from their “analysis”.) More likely, they are political operatives and propaganda specialists, rather than physicians, scientists, public health people, or any relevant specialty.
Archive.org led me to the very earliest version of this post on the Wayback Machine, dated November 9, 2021. It was listed as an “update,” implying that there was at least one earlier version of the post that was never archived or existed under a different URL. However much earlier than November 9, 2021 this article was posted, at that time there were only 77 athletes listed, with the title of the post being “77 Athletes Suffer Cardiac Arrest, 28 Die, After COVID Shot”.
Here’s one interesting thing. This website was cited by Dr. Pierre Kory last summer to claim that athletes were dying en masse from COVID-19 vaccines, as deconstructed by Dr. Susan Oliver:
Dr. Oliver also cited a study showing that, according to the FIFA Sudden Death Registry, 617 players with sudden cardiac events were reported from 67 countries from 2014-2018, with 142 of them surviving their arrests. This was only for soccer players (or football to the rest of the world), not all athletes.
Here’s another interesting thing. In her January 6th 2023 tweet cited above, Gemma O’Doherty mentions a “peer-reviewed study”. You won’t be too surprised to learn that “peer-reviewed” is doing a lot of heavy lifting here, as is “study”, but what’s interesting is that it is a letter to the editor of the Scandinavian Journal of Immunology by Panagis Polykretis and Peter McCullough titled “Rational harm-benefit assessments by age group are required for continued COVID-19 vaccination“. OK, so that in and of itself is not that interesting. What is interesting is that McCullough cited the blog post on Goodsciencing.com as his source for claiming 1,598 deaths among young athletes in 2021 and 2022. In their letter, Polykretis and McCullough compare these “1,598 deaths” to a 2006 study that found 1,101 reports of sudden cardiac death in athletes over a 38-year period, which is where the oft-cited (by antivaxxers) average of 29 cardiac arrests per year comes from.
This was a classic example of antivaxxers comparing apples to oranges. First, the 2006 study used very stringent inclusion criteria to identify cases of cardiac events and cardiac death among athletes younger than 35 years. Then, as Dr. Eric Burnett noted:
Now, bc this is a systematic analysis, they have strict definitions of what an athlete is and what constitutes SCD. Of note they only looked at young athletes < 35 y/o pic.twitter.com/MAhYcQZUMh
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) January 5, 2023
Now if @P_McCulloughMD is going to make a direct comparison to this study population he is going to have to stick to the strict definitions as outlined above. So which peer reviewed source or official SCD registry did he use for his comparison? pic.twitter.com/VFgdxOhlag
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) January 5, 2023
If you look at this list many people are older than 35, many aren’t athletes, and some didn’t even die. And not all that died had died from SCD. Here are some examples.
— Eric Burnett, MD (@Doctor_Eric_B) January 5, 2023
As I perused the blog post for the first time, like Dr. Burnett I immediately noticed a lot of questionable entries. Many of these athletes were indeed older than 35 years (some a lot older). For example, just a brief scroll down the list showed that the antivax blog had included:
    • Mike Leach, a 61-year-old football coach who suffered a heart attack in his home (as if 61 year olds never suffered heart attacks in their homes before the vaccine).
    • Antonis Mandalos, a 60-year-old Olympiakos Volos Football (soccer, for my US readers) player for 18 years and then coach, who collapsed due to a cardiac arrest.
    • Tommy Kloza, the 65-year-old “popular owner of a long-standing gym in Rhode Island”, who “died “suddenly” and “unexpectedly” in the gym car park. (I note that the use of the term “car park” strongly suggests that the anonymous antivaxxers who wrote the article are British or Australian, as in the US we would say “parking lot”.)
I could go on and on and on, but given that others have trod the same ground I’ll restrain myself except for three examples. One was a 19-year-old who had gone on a swim on his own in Thousand Island Lake in California, trying to reach one of the islands. He didn’t make it. Again, it’s as if before the vaccines no one had ever overestimated his swimming ability before and died trying to swim too far in a very cold lake. Another was a bodybuilder who “died after ‘sudden recent decline,’ possibly dialysis related”. (If you’re on dialysis, you are not “healthy”.) The third was a 27-year-old sprinter who died of suicide, a self-inflicted gunshot to the head. In fact, this list contains are athletes and former athletes who died of suicide, car crashes, drownings, cancer, and even falling off of a cliff! Many were older than 25, some a lot older and quite a few having no longer been athletes for decades and many not even dying on the field of play.
And they’re still adding to the list!
An unfortunate coincidence leads to a tsunami of astroturfed disinformation
Thus far, I’ve demonstrated that antivaxxers had been “priming the pump”, so to speak, with a pre-existing false narrative about a supposedly unprecedented wave of cardiac arrests and deaths among young, healthy athletes, blaming this wave of death and destruction on COVID-19 vaccines, even though in the vast majority of cases the vaccination status of the deceased wasn’t even known. Moreover, in an unfortunate bit of timing Dr. McCullough had published his letter to the editor recently, leading to an uptick in antivax fear mongering about athletes supposedly suffering cardiac arrests and “dying suddenly”. All antivaxxers needed was a high profile case to seize on, and when Damar Hamlin collapsed they wasted no time doing just that, even though it was pretty obvious that it was almost certainly commotio cordis that had caused his collapse.
But who started this narrative? We can’t be sure that Goodsciencing.com was the origin of this narrative, but it is arguably by far the most prominent source and has been slowly adding to its list at least since November 2021. Fortunately, the people behind what is almost certainly an astroturf anonymous website appear now to have been identified. Maarten Schenk at Lead Stories cleverly used Gravatar hashtags to identify very likely conclusively those behind the Goodsciencing.com website. You can read the investigation for the details of how this was done if you like but the CliffsNotes version follows. Basically two of the Gravatar MD5 hashtags were resolved to email addresses, which were then found in the contact information published on websites associated with NewsBlaze – a right-wing “alternative news site” owned by Alan Gray.
Schenk’s evidence that Gray is behind Goodsciencing.com includes these observations:
    • Alan Gray is the CEO and editor-in-chief of NewsBlaze.
    • The “admin” user on goodsciencing.com uses an email address from a NewsBlaze-owned domain name.
    • The same email address is used on accounts for several other websites connected to Alan Gray and to NewsBlaze.
    • “Alan Gray” on Telegram and NewsBlaze Australia on Twitter were among the earliest to promote the site.
    • NewsBlaze was communicating with a known anti-vaccine activist on Twitter only weeks before goodsciencing.com went live.
I would also point out that the blog’s use of “car park” instead of “parking lot” strongly suggests that those behind it are British or Australian, which is consistent with Alan Gray being behind Goodsciencing.com. Of note, Media Bias/Fact Check rates NewsBlaze as a “questionable source” based on its “extreme right bias, promotion of propaganda and conspiracy theories as well as the use of poor sources”. If you want a taste of the sorts of things Alan Gray publishes about COVID-19, I came across this article claiming that no vaccine for COVID-19 is needed because there is a “simple cure” (an asthma medication). Anyone who’s paid attention to COVID-19 and antivaccine misinformation and disinformation knows that NewsBlaze is a major Australian source.
Unfortunately, Damar Hamlin’s cardiac arrest was the inciting event for a perfect storm of antivax disinformation, timed perfectly. It happened on national TV during a Monday night NFL football game on the last night of a long holiday season, when a lot of people were off work and watching. It also happened not long after Dr. McCullough had become merely the most recent antivaxxer to have resurrected the conspiracy theory claiming that there had been a huge increase in the number of young athletes dying suddenly since early 2021 when, not at all coincidentally, the mass vaccination against COVID-19 really got underway, his letter to the editor having conveniently (for antivaxxers) been accepted on December 17, 2022, a week before the holiday season. The bottom line is that Damar Hamlin collapsed on January 2, but antivaxxers had been priming the “athletes dying suddenly” conspiracy pump for at least a year before he ever set foot on the field that fateful evening. They were ready, and they took full advantage, starting even before doctors and medics had finished resuscitating him.
If you want to know why one of my first thoughts when Damar Hamlin collapsed was whether antivaxxers had started blaming vaccines yet, now you know. This is what we have to deal with, and I still hate it that this is now how I think when I see a potential tragedy—or actual tragedy—unfold.

The “Disinformation Dozen” spreading anti-vaccine messaging on social media
Just twelve individuals are generating two-thirds of all of the anti-vaccine messaging on Twitter and Facebook.
Scott Gavura on April 1, 2021
Link 

Back in January I wrote about the COVID Anti-Vaxxer Playbook, the three key messages that antivaccine groups have coalesced around to destroy confidence in the COVID-19 vaccine. Anti-vaccine messaging on social media had exploded since the pandemic began, creating business opportunities not just for anti-vaxxers, but also for the major social media companies (YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter) who profit from the activity, traffic, and sharing.
In February, Steven Novella predicted the situation that is now emerging around the world – a race between getting vaccines into arms, and the rapid spread of new variants of SARS-CoV-2 that are more infectious and potentially more deadly. While the vaccine rollout in USA has accelerated, we are nowhere near herd immunity, and yet the USA is rapidly reaching the point where it will soon have the vaccine available to anyone that wants it. Whether those who are currently vaccine hesitant decide to take the vaccine may be an important factor in reaching herd immunity, which may need to be as high as 85-90% (vaccinated, or infected and survived). While vaccine hesitancy appears to be dropping, as of this week approximately 1 in 4 Americans will not take the vaccine if offered it.
A new report identified that just twelve anti-vaxxers are responsible for almost two-thirds of all anti-vaccine content on Facebook and Twitter. And the platforms continue to do as little as possible to remove this content. Removing this content and its creators from these platforms may help reduce (or at least stop the growth) of the anti-vaccine sentiment that exists.
Fostering vaccine hesitancy – A deliberate strategy
The Gallup poll reporting on vaccine hesitancy asked those reluctant for their reasons:
Asked for the main reason behind their reluctance to be immunized, those who are unwilling to receive a COVID-19 vaccine are most likely to say they say they want to wait and confirm it is safe (23%) or do not think the health effects from the disease would be serious if they contracted it (20%). Additionally, 16% are concerned about the speed with which the vaccine was developed, 15% do not trust vaccines in general, 10% say they already have COVID-19 antibodies due to having the disease, 9% are concerned about having an allergic reaction to the shot and 7% prefer to wait and see how effective it is in preventing the disease.
This seems consistent with the unified anti-vaccine messaging that major anti-vaccine groups and voices have been pushing, which I described back in January:
     1.  COVID-19 is not dangerous: There are few deaths, and death reports are exaggerated. “It’s just the flu.” “It will just go away on its own.”
     2.  COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous: “The vaccines were rushed.” “The vaccines are killing people.” “Natural” immunity is better. “Vaccines are toxic.”
     3.  Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted: “It’s politics over health.” “It’s Big Pharma profits over health.”
With approximately 25% of Americans unwilling to accept the vaccine, and the variants surging, a massive vaccine education effort is underway. And while it’s good to see that confidence in the vaccine program itself is growing, more steps need to be taken to counter the misinformation campaign that is in full swing. That’s where this new campaign to hold social media accountable comes from.
The “Disinformation Dozen”
The Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH), which published the Anti-Vax Playbook, recently published a new report that analyzes anti-vaccine messaging on social media. It identified 12 individuals it calls the “Disinformation Dozen” who they have calculated are responsible for up to 65% of the anti-vaccine content on Facebook and Twitter:
     1.  Joseph Mercola
     2.  Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
     3.  Ty and Charlene Bollinger
     4.  Sherri Tenpenny
     5.  Rizza Islam
     6.  Rashid Buttar
     7.  Erin Elizabeth
     8.  Sayer Ji
     9.  Kelly Brogan
     10.  Christiane Northrup
     11.  Ben Tapper
     12.  Kevin Jenkins
The twelve were identified by looking at anti-vaccine content and its sources. All individuals had large numbers of followers, produced lots of anti-vaccine content, or whose growth (in terms of followers) was growing quickly. Over 812,000 posts were extracted from Facebook and Twitter in February and early March, and 65% of the content was attributable to these twelve individuals. Importantly and frustratingly, Facebook doesn’t address the source of the content and stop it there. If 12,000 people share a Mercola anti-vaccine article, then this is considered 12,000 individual shares of anti-vaccine messaging attributed each of those 12,000 people, not 12,000 shares of a single post attributed to Mercola.
Are the platforms acting?
CCDH notes that the current algorithms that serve up suggested posts are spreading vaccine misinformation. In particular, Instagram has been audited and it observed that followers of leading anit-vaxxers would be automatically served more anti-vaccine content, focusing on COVID-19 misinformation and conspiracy theories, in addition to antisemitic content and posts on QAnon. Following “wellness influencers” with links to the anti-vaccine movement will also lead to suggested posts with increasing amounts of antivaccine and COVID-19 misinformation. Even following a mix of trusted health authorities and anti-vaccine pages means that users will eventually be recommended anti-vaccine content:

CCDH made the following recommendations, which have yet to be acted on by Facebook/Instagram:
    • do not let those that spread anti-vaccine messages to gain “verified” status
    • exclude posts about COVID-19 or vaccines from recommendations
    • blacklist accounts that spread misinformation
    • limit the number of suggested posts that a user is exposed to
The impact of algorithms featured in this week’s grilling of tech CEOs by Congressional House Energy and Commerce subcommittees, where questions about COVID-19 misinformation were raised. Congressman Mike Doyle challenged the CEOs to deplatform the CCDH’s dozen, in a pointed exchange:
BREAKING: Facebook, Twitter and Google challenged to deplatform the Disinformation Dozen – 12 anti-vaxxers responsible for up to 65% of vaccine disinformation.@USRepMikeDoyle has set them a deadline: "look at it today and get back to us tomorrow." pic.twitter.com/KFyPbt9KO2
— Center for Countering Digital Hate (@CCDHate) March 25, 2021
The CBC television show Marketplace recently partnered with CCDH in an investigation of the social media giants. In February they reported more than 800 posts on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and Twitter. These posts had a combined 1.5 million likes and 120,000 comments. Not coincidentally, the posts centred on the three key anti-vaccine messages. Despite the reporting of this content, only 12% of the posts were removed, but that number jumped to 53% after Marketplace journalists identified themselves directly to the platforms. Twitter and YouTube took the least action on posts with anti-vaccine content.
On a more positive note, the social media platforms have just recently removed some of the social media accounts of the Disinformation Dozen. Notably, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Instagram account (almost a million followers) has been deleted, but he still maintains a Facebook page for himself and his organization, “Children’s Health Defense”. Rashid Buttar (#6 on the list) has also seen his public Facebook page and Instagram page deleted. But no-one has lost all their platforms, and all continue to have access to at least one major social media platform to spread disinformation.
Deplatforming and removing misinformation
It takes only a short exposure to anti-vaccine messaging to create hesitancy. Social media platforms have failed in this pandemic to remove misinformation and anti-vaccine messaging that can create this hesitancy. CCDH’s work has demonstrated that a large amount of this content can be attributed to a small number of individuals. Until these platforms take stronger and more effective measures, starting perhaps with removing the “Disinformation Dozen” and improving the algorithms to reduce the spread of this content, then social media will continue to be a problem in countering anti-vaccine sentiment and COVID-19 vaccine uptake.

Deliberately Spoiled Vaccines: Conspiracy thinking and health professionals
A Wisconsin pharmacist is facing charges after deliberately tampering with a batch of COVID-19 vaccines, demonstrating that a health professional’s education is no vaccine against conspiracy beliefs.
Scott Gavura on January 7, 2021
Link

In what feels like eons ago, but was actually just last week, reports emerged that hundreds of doses of the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine had been accidentally spoiled, as they had been left out of the refrigerator overnight. What initially sounded like a colossal blunder was subsequently identified to be a deliberate act, and Wisconsin pharmacist Steven Brandenburg was arrested. Subsequent reports and investigations into his past have revealed a frightening but unsurprising pattern – one where an “admitted conspiracy theorist” takes actions that harm others. Moreover, in leveraging his privileged position as a health professional with access to the vaccines, Brandenburg’s actions appear deliberately intended to compromise public health and our overall confidence in COVID-19 vaccination.
I’ve pieced together as many details as I could from the various news reports. Apparently Brandenburg, a licensed pharmacist at Aurora Medical Center in Grafton, Wisconsin, removed 57 vials of the Moderna vaccine from a refrigerator and left them out all night, knowing this would render them ineffective. He also knew that these ineffective vaccines would be administered, giving recipients the belief that they were vaccinated. However, the actions were identified by another pharmacy staff member and reported. After an internal investigation where Brandenburg eventually confessed to this act, he was fired, and is now facing criminal charges. He has been released on bail.
The reports suggest a Brandenburg has history of worrying actions. He had apparently taken a gun to work, twice. In the midst of a divorce, he had recently stated the government was planning cyber-attacks and intended on shutting down the power grid. In December, he purchased a water purifier and was stockpiling food and weapons. And with respect to the COVID-19 vaccines, he had apparently embraced online conspiracy theories, and believed that they were unsafe. Based on a statement from the police:
Brandenburg, an admitted conspiracy theorist, told investigators that he believed that Covid-19 vaccine was not safe for people and could harm them and change their DNA.
The antivaccine claim that the COVID-19 vaccine can harm your DNA is something that David Gorski discussed at this blog back in November. David pointed out that this claim goes back to Spring 2020, when we learned that Moderna’s vaccine candidate was an RNA vaccine. Admittedly, to someone with little-to-no knowledge of basic science, the idea of a vaccine containing RNA or DNA that is injected into you might sound frightening. But the actual science is both very exciting and should also reassure anyone who takes a few minutes to learn how RNA vaccines actually work. In short, mRNA from vaccines don’t enter your nucleus and therefore can’t integrate with your DNA, nor can they “change” your DNA in any way. Any health professional, like a pharmacist, should have sufficient education and cognitive ability to understand the basic science of vaccine technology well enough to know this type of claim is absurd. Moreover, a health professional who wants to know more can easily access credible medical resources that are widely used and trusted. Brandenburg, a hospital pharmacist licensed for over 20 years, would presumably have used these sources and medical references throughout his career – yet he chose to believe conspiracy theories instead of actually studying the science.
Sadly, other health professional have amplified and promoted the claim that RNA-based vaccines can affect your DNA. Dr. Carrie Madej is a Georgia-based internal medicine doctor who has actively promoted this baseless and science-absent idea. She is an anti-mask, anti-vaccine physician who believes that vaccines are “transhumanism” (a made up term). Madej was actually scheduled to speak at the “MAGA Health Freedom” rally yesterday in Washington, DC. (It sounds like she was indeed there.) Despite her medical training, she, like Branderburg, is clearly enamored with promoting baseless and absurd conspiracy theories.
Probably the most frightening aspect of these reports is that health professionals, who ought to know better, have been caught up in and are amplifying unfounded fears about vaccines. They are fomenting and promoting conspiracy-based ideas to non-health professionals with the credibility of medical credentials and a white lab coat. How much harm are these individuals causing? It’s understandable to ask if this is just the first time Branderburg has been caught acting on his conspiracy beliefs – or if there is a history of behaviors that’s gone undetected. Clearly, a health professional’s education is no guarantee or vaccine against conspiracy thinking.

Justin Bieber, Ramsay Hunt syndrome, SADS, and how to antivaxxers everything is always about vaccines
I never thought I’d be writing about Justin Bieber, but such are the strange times we live in, given how after Bieber announced that he had developed facial paralysis as a result of Ramsay Hunt syndrome antivaxxers swooped in to blame it on COVID-19 vaccines. Elsewhere, they blame every unexplained death of a young person on vaccines to the point of claiming that “they” are covering up the deaths, because to them it’s always about the vaccines.
David Gorski on June 13, 2022
Link

I must admit that I never thought that I’d be writing about Justin Bieber on SBM for any reason, but such are the strange times that we live in today that I find myself doing just that. Sure, I could imagine Bieber being featured on this blog for being yet another celebrity spreading antivax misinformation, for example, but to my knowledge I’ve never heard of him doing that. Also, being the old fart that I am, I must confess that I’m not a Belieber and never have been. Such is life. However, over the weekend Bieber’s name started bubbling up on my social media feeds, with fans sharing a video that posted to Bieber’s Instagram feed, which I’ll repost here:




View this post on Instagram










A post shared by Justin Bieber (@justinbieber)
From a story in Rolling Stone:
Bieber explained that the entire right side of his face was unable to move, and he could only smile and blink on the left side.
“As you can see, this eye is not blinking. I can’t smile on this side of my face. This nostril will not move. So there’s full paralysis on the side of my face,” he said in a video posted on Instagram.
The singer said he hoped fans now understood why he had to cancel a set of tour dates. “So for those who are frustrated by my cancellations of the next shows, I’m just physically, obviously not capable of doing them. This is pretty serious. As you can see.”
And:
“Obviously, my body’s telling me I gotta slow down,” he said, before adding that he’d take the time to “rest and relax” before heading back on the road.
Along with getting plenty of rest, Bieber said he was also doing facial exercises to “get my face back to where it’s supposed to be.”
“It will go back to normal. Just time and we don’t know how much time that’s gonna be, but it’s gonna be okay,” he said. “And I have hope, and I trust God, and I trust that this is all for a reason. I’m not sure what that is right now. But in the meantime, I’m gonna rest.”
The health update comes a few days after he was forced to postpone a number of tour dates, citing health concerns and saying his sickness was “getting worse” without providing additional details.
Whatever my opinion of Justin Bieber as a performer (he’s obviously talented but just not my cup of tea), I couldn’t help but feel empathy for him as he apologized to his fans for canceling a number of upcoming shows because he physically can’t do them, and demonstrated how one side of his face is paralyzed. We’ll discuss potential causes in a moment (hint: it wasn’t a vaccine, COVID-19 or otherwise), but first let’s take a look at the sadly predictable reaction. On Friday, Steve Kirsch stated explicitly Why I’m 99% certain that Justin Bieber’s facial paralysis was caused by the COVID vaccine, subtitling it, “Was it vaccine related? That’s what the math says. Here’s my calculation.” As usual, his “math” rests on a misinterpretation of the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database, the assumption that everything reported to the database is caused by the vaccine, and the confusing of correlation with causation, all using his usual chicanery, in which he makes up a figure to inflate an estimate that he doesn’t like. Meanwhile, a fake news site (Vancouver Times, rated as a questionable source) posted an article claiming that Bieber blames the COVID-19 vaccine for his Ramsay Hunt syndrome and saying that the “vaccine ruined my life.“. The article consists mainly of Tweets and a reference to a Daily Mail article that, while sensationalistic, does not, as the fake news site claims, report that Bieber blamed the vaccine for his condition and plans on suing Pfizer.
Then, of course, there’s always Twitter:
Within three months, Justin Bieber (who was on tour) and his wife suffered facial paralysis and a brain clot respectively. But don’t dare ask any questions. Because that would make you a far-right conspiracy theorist worthy of cancellation on social media. pic.twitter.com/TZK5rnA1ua
— Viva Frei (@thevivafrei) June 11, 2022
Hailey bieber gets a blood clot and stuffers mini stroke and weeks later justin biebers face is paralyzed and they both promoted and got all doses of vaccine… coincidence?
— Tiana (@TianaMitch98) June 10, 2022
Justin Bieber’s face is paralyzed two months after his wife develops a blood clot in her brain. Media won’t acknowledge both are covid vaccine injuries. The “mystery” illnesses plaguing vaccinated people of all ages is now epidemic. https://t.co/4qom2VSGNq
— Patrick Brauckmann 🕉️ (@vonbrauckmann) June 10, 2022
We’ll discuss Justin Bieber’s wife Hailey Bieber and her stroke in a moment (something I had not known about prior to the stories about Bieber’s facial paralysis bubbling up over the weekend and that Steve Kirsch also claims), but first one antivaxxer, ironically, came close to the answer without actually realizing it.
https://t.co/pYzwB1Hl90
— Amaru ⛤ 𓋹🖤🏴‍☠️ (@thirdeyemafia) June 10, 2022
No, Bieber’s facial paralysis is not due to the COVID-19 vaccine, but far more likely a consequence of what usually causes Ramsay Hunt syndrome, a sequelae of varicella zoster virus (VZV) infection not unlike shingles. Let’s go through this story step-by-step, starting with Justin Bieber’s Ramsay Hunt syndrome, continuing to the questions about Hailey Bieber’s stroke, and then continuing in a more general fashion to discuss how antivaxxers (1) immediately blame any health problem suffered by a celebrity on vaccines and (2) blame any unexplained death they can on the vaccines. Is it possible that vaccination might reactivate dormant VZV? Yes, but it’s certainly not proven, and it’s not even clear if Bieber received a COVID-19 vaccine.
Ramsay Hunt syndrome is not vaccine injury
The simplest way to think of Ramsay Hunt syndrome is as a subset of shingles. Specifically, it’s shingles that affects the facial nerve near where it emerges near the ear, which is why it’s also known as herpes zoster oticus, to signify its relationship to the ear. There, it can cause the usual (and well-known) painful rash with vesicles (blisters) of shingles on the face, facial paralysis, and hearing loss. I must admit that I did not recall ever having heard of Ramsay Hunt syndrome before, although likely it was covered in medical school. I had certainly heard of and even encountered shingles that involves the facial nerve; indeed, when the skin lesions associated with shingles involve the temporal or zygomatic branches of the facial nerve, it can even endanger the eye.

A review in BMJ Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry about Ramsay Hall syndrome notes:
The strict definition of the Ramsay Hunt syndrome is peripheral facial nerve palsy accompanied by an erythematous vesicular rash on the ear (zoster oticus) or in the mouth. J Ramsay Hunt, who described various clinical presentations of facial paralysis and rash, also recognised other frequent symptoms and signs such as tinnitus, hearing loss, nausea, vomiting, vertigo, and nystagmus. He explained these eighth nerve features by the close proximity of the geniculate ganglion to the vestibulocochlear nerve within the bony facial canal. Hunt’s analysis of clinical variations of the syndrome now bearing his name led to his recognition of the general somatic sensory function of the facial nerve and his defining of the geniculate zone of the ear. It is now known that varicella zoster virus (VZV) causes Ramsay Hunt syndrome.
Compared with Bell’s palsy (facial paralysis without rash), patients with Ramsay Hunt syndrome often have more severe paralysis at onset and are less likely to recover completely. Studies suggest that treatment with prednisone and acyclovir may improve outcome, although a prospective randomised treatment trial remains to be undertaken. In the only prospective study of patients with Ramsay Hunt syndrome, 14% developed vesicles after the onset of facial weakness. Thus, Ramsay Hunt syndrome may initially be indistinguishable from Bell’s palsy. Further, Bell’s palsy is significantly associated with herpes simplex virus (HSV) infection. In the light of the known safety and effectiveness of antiviral drugs against VZV or HSV, consideration should be given to early treatment of all patients with Ramsay Hunt syndrome or Bell’s palsy with a 7–10 day course of famciclovir (500 mg, three times daily) or acyclovir (800 mg, five times daily), as well as oral prednisone (60 mg daily for 3–5 days).
From the video, I couldn’t see whether Bieber had the classic vesicular rash on his ear or in the mouth. As for epidemiology, another review notes:
Ramsay Hunt syndrome affects both immunocompetent and immunocompromised patients and has an incidence of about 5 per 100,000 people per year; in contrast, the incidence of Bell palsy is much higher, at about 15-30 per 100,000 people per year. Ramsay Hunt syndrome accounts for roughly 7% of acute facial paralysis cases, with zoster sine herpete comprising approximately 10% of those.
And:
Ramsay Hunt syndrome can present in anyone, and there are cases reported in patients ranging from 3 months of age to 82 years, although patients in their 7th and 8th decades are most susceptible. Factors that increase the risk of herpes zoster will increase the incidence of Ramsay Hunt syndrome, including stress, chemotherapy, immunocompromise, infection, malnutrition, and others.
So basically Ramsay Hunt syndrome is a facial paralysis syndrome that is considerably less common than Bell’s palsy that is caused by VZV, which is the virus that causes chickenpox. As with shingles, VZV can, after chickenpox infection, remain dormant in ganglia and nerves, to be reactivated later. My review reading also reveals that the prognosis for Ramsay Hunt syndrome is not as good as it is for Bell’s palsy. Only 70% of those suffering from Ramsay Hunt syndrome recover normal or near-normal facial function, while over 90% of Bell’s palsy patients do, which might follow from the observation that more than twice as many Ramsay Hunt patients present with complete paralysis of half the face compared to Bell’s palsy.

Since VZV infections are usually self-limited, the treatment of Ramsay Hunt syndrome is generally geared towards decreasing the incidence of late complications, which can include spastic facial paralysis and postherpetic neuralgia, as well as synkinesis, which is due to aberrant nerve regeneration that leads to nerves connecting to the incorrect muscles and can manifest itself as, for example, a twitching of the mouth during eye closure or winking during a smile. (I’m sure that Steve Novella can go on and on about synkinesis.) In general, the treatment is a combination of oral antiviral medications plus steroids. Recovery, when it occurs, can take months, and the worse the initial paralysis, the less likely a full recovery is, although there is nearly always some recovery.
The point to remember here is that Ramsay Hunt syndrome is actually fairly well characterized. Its cause is known, the reactivation of dormant varicella zoster virus in the ganglion leading to the facial nerve, just as shingles is due to the reactivation of dormant varicella virus in another nerve distribution. Why the virus reactivates might not be well understood but it is well understood that it is the virus that causes the syndrome. It is not a vaccine or vaccines.
In fact, one great thing about the chickenpox vaccine is that it can also prevent shingles and Ramsay Hunt syndrome, as was noted over the weekend by some on Twitter:
Bieber was 5 before a vaccine for chickenpox was available in Canada in '99. My own kids had chickenpox in 97, my son had shingles at 16. There's no available vaccine for shingles until age 50. There a lot of people who didn't have the option for a chickenpox vaccine as children.
— Debbie 🇨🇦🍁🙏✝️⛪🍁🇨🇦 (@dsmeso) June 12, 2022
I'm not sure why FDA approval took longer but it wasn't started at the same time across the country. Vaccination started across provinces from 2000-2007, my province in 2004. Our CP vaccines now our Merck & GlaxoSmithKline
— Debbie 🇨🇦🍁🙏✝️⛪🍁🇨🇦 (@dsmeso) June 12, 2022
Likely Bieber never got the chickenpox vaccine because he had chickenpox as a child and the vaccine wasn’t offered until he was older. As for the COVID-19 vaccine, I can find no information about when or even if Bieber was ever vaccinated against COVID-19, meaning that this supposed correlation between vaccination and Ramsay Hunt syndrome is purely speculative. Even if there were evidence that COVID-19 vaccines could somehow trigger the syndrome, there’s no evidence that Bieber ever had the vaccine within a plausible timeframe for it to be related to his current condition. Indeed, there are case reports of COVID-19 infection resulting in Ramsay Hunt syndrome. It’s antivaxxers doing their damnedest to blame his condition on vaccines, in the absence of not just evidence but even a plausible correlation.
But what about Bieber’s wife, Hailey Bieber?
Hailey Bieber’s “small stroke”
In March, stories started appearing in the media about Hailey Bieber suffering a “small stroke”, for instance, as this article in People Magazine describes:
Bieber shared a screenshot of the Notes app on her Instagram Stories on Saturday, March 12. In the message, she revealed details about her hospitalization on Thursday, March 10 while she was having a meal with her husband, Justin Bieber.
“On Thursday morning, I was sitting at breakfast with my husband when I started having stroke like symptoms and was taken to the hospital,” the 25-year-old wrote. “They found I had suffered a very small blood clot to my brain, which caused a small lack of oxygen, but my body had passed it on its own and I recovered completely within a few hours.”
Unsurprisingly, given the diagnosis of a small stroke, then as now, antivaxxers were quick to blame COVID-19 vaccines, a claim that, as you can see from some of the Tweets that I included in this post, they’re returning to since her husband’s announcement that he has been diagnosed with Ramsay Hunt syndrome; I will not rehash that with additional examples. What I will mention is that her stroke was actually not a full-blown stroke, but rather what is colloquially called a “mini-stroke”, a common lay term for a transient ischemic attack (TIA). TIAs occur when there is blockage of a blood vessel to the brain that resolves on its own, often from a small clot being dislodged and traveling to the brain.
From a news story a month ago:
The 25-year-old model explained how her fingertips went numb and she lost her ability to speak.
“The right side of my face started drooping,” she said.
Dr. Ryan Fillmore, neuro-intensivist and medical director of the stroke program at Novant Health Presbyterian Medical Center, said Bieber’s symptoms were classic signs of a stroke, which is a blockage of blood flow to the brain.
In her case, however, the quicker passing of symptoms made Bieber’s a transient ischemic attack (TIA), which many people call a ministroke.
Fillmore said a TIA is generally more short-lived than a full-blown stroke.
“When symptoms last more than 24 hours, at that point, you would be considered to have had a stroke,” Fillmore said. “The other key difference is, on findings on brain imaging, in a stroke, you would have permanent brain damage.”
It also turns out that Bieber’s risk factors for having a TIA were actually came out fairly quickly in her medical workup. About a month and a half ago, Hailey Bieber posted this video to YouTube, which mentions some of them:
You don’t have to watch the video, as I can summarize from this article:
In her video, Bieber describes how doctors found several factors that likely led to her condition, including a hole in her heart, a recent COVID-19 infection, long airplane travel during which she did not move much, and birth control.
“I had just recently started birth control pills, which I should have never been on because I am somebody who suffers from migraines,” Bieber said, noting that she never discussed that point with a doctor before going on the medication.
Fillmore said, in some cases, migraines can point to a clotting condition, and birth control and immobility on a flight can both increase the risk of clots on their own, particularly those in the legs.
“If you have a hole in your heart, then you have an abnormal connection between the veins and arteries of your body,” Fillmore said. “So, if there is a clot in your leg in the veins, that can travel up to the heart and go through that abnormal hole in the heart, and subsequently travel to the brain and cause your strokes and ministrokes.”
It turns out that that “hole in the heart” was a patent foramen ovale:
More tests revealed that Hailey had a patent foramen ovale (PFO), a small opening between the upper heart chambers, the right and the left atrium.
Hailey’s PFO was grade 5, the highest grade, and it was between 12 (.47 inch) and 13 (.51 inch) millimeters, she said.
The blood clot inside Hailey allegedly escaped through the opening and traveled to her brain, which is what caused her TIA.
Hailey underwent a PFO closure operation to plug the gap inside her heart and she was able “to move on from this really scary situation.”
Normally, this hole between the two atria closes shortly before birth, and it’s a fairly common condition, particularly given that people with a PFO and no other heart abnormalities are generally asymptomatic. Apparently this was the case for Hailey Bieber; that is, until she had her TIA, after which the PFO was diagnosed (as it’s in the differential diagnosis for stroke in a young person) and fixed.

The bottom line is that, not only was Hailey Barber’s TIA not caused by the COVID-19 vaccine, very likely her having had COVID-19 contributed to the clotting that led to her TIA. However, first, foremost, and always, any health issue suffered by a celebrity must have been due to vaccines, because that’s how antivaxxers roll. It doesn’t matter if there’s a plausible link or not. It doesn’t matter that explanations for what happened exist all over the mainstream media. What matters is the narrative.
Which brings us to SADS.
COVID-19 shots make antivaxxer so SADS
Regular readers will be familiar with the longstanding tactic of weaponizing reports to the VAERS database, a tactic that dates back 20 years at least but since the pandemic has been weaponized in a manner never before seen. You might also be familiar with the way that antivaxxers leap onto the sudden unexplained (and sometimes even explained) deaths of celebrities to blame the COVID-19 vaccine. One of the earliest examples occurred in January 2021, a little more than a month after the Pfizer vaccine had first started rolling out, when baseball legend Hank Aaron died two and a half weeks after receiving his first dose of the vaccine. It apparently never occurred to antivaxxers that Aaron was 86 years old and in poor health and that octogenarians can die suddenly due to old age and other age-associated conditions, but they were quick to blame the vaccine, even though there was no evidence linking the vaccine to Aaron’s death. Last month, antivaxxers tried to link a COVID-19 booster to Goodfellas actor Ray Liotta unexpectedly dying in his sleep at the age of 67, as well as former Dallas Cowboys running back Marion Barber who was found dead at age 38. The list goes on: comedians Bob Saget, Louie Anderson, Gilbert Gottfried, and Foo Fighters drummer Taylor Hawkins.
You know where this is going. For example:
TOTALLY normal, nothing to see here, not at ALL related to the COVID Vaccine, along with Ray Liotta and Andrew Fletcher. Marion Barber, former Dallas Cowboys running back, dead at 38 #COVID19 #COVIDVACCINE #VaccineSideEffects #rayliotta #andrewfletcher https://t.co/dw4mDxA912
— Vigilant Knight (@RedPillMage) June 2, 2022
I’ll spare you more examples. Let’s just say that it’s not true. The lack of evidence of a connection hasn’t stopped one antivaxxer named Mark Crispin from starting a veritable list of all unexplained deaths of non-elderly adults and attributing them to COVID-19 vaccines, which he refers to as being “in memory of those who ‘died suddenly.'” Just peruse his Substack if you don’t believe me. It’s full of these articles.
Meanwhile, Mike Adams over at Natural News recently ranted in an article titled “Sudden vaccines deaths are now so common they’ve assigned a SYNDROME name for it: Sudden Adult Death Syndrome (SADS)”:
The murderous medical regime knows that covid vaccines are killing healthy young people at an alarming rate, so they’ve suddenly assigned a medical label for the phenomenon in order to distract people from the truth. Now, healthy young people who suddenly die without any medical explanation are said to have died from Sudden Adult Death Syndrome (SADS) rather than from vaccines..
Just yesterday, he added to the conspiracy theory with an article titled “Healthy young people now dying en masse across Australia, and the corporate media still won’t dare mention vaccines“. Of course, no evidence is presented that “healthy young people are dying en masse” in Australia, much less that vaccines had anything to do with it.
Unsurprisingly, SADS is not a new term. (I’ve encountered papers about it going back at least 15 years, and a nearly 20 year old paper defined it as sudden death without a structural cause or toxicological finding detected at autopsy, and “Sudden Adult Death Syndrome” is also a misnomer for the real term for which SADS is the acronym, “Sudden Arrhythmic Death Syndrome,” meaning sudden death due to heart rhythm disturbances.) Adams concedes that SADS is not a new term (although he sticks with the misnomer), and then rapidly pivots to the conspiracy theory that “they” are now trying to hide all the supposed carnage due to COVID-19 vaccines by relabeling sudden deaths in young adults as being due to SADS, much as antivaxxers a decade and longer ago claimed that SIDS deaths were “really” vaccine-caused deaths. Adams claims:
While SADS has existed in medical terminology long before covid, doctors and the media are now using this syndrome label in a new way: To try to explain away vaccine deaths. From what we can tell so far, there are no such “sudden deaths” in unvaccinated young adults. So far, this seems to be happening solely among those who have been vaccinated.
The UK Daily Mail has published an article detailing this new so-called “syndrome” which is of course just a convenient label to mask the true underlying cause of these sudden deaths. The title of their article is, “Healthy young people are dying suddenly and unexpectedly from a mysterious syndrome – as doctors seek answers through a new national register,” and it says that everyone under the age of 40, “…may potentially be at risk of having Sudden Adult Death Syndrome (SADS).”
Again, this term is at least 20 years old, which tells you that it’s been happening for many, many years, and, in fact, the sudden death of young adults with no apparent cause is a long-described phenomenon (more on that later). The paper I cited above estimated that in the UK no cause is found for roughly 4.1% of all sudden unexpected deaths under 65 years, while the Daily Mail article notes: “SADS is an ‘umbrella term to describe unexpected deaths in young people’, said The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners, most commonly occurring in people under 40 years of age”.
It’s not clear to me why SADS was trending last week or why there have been several articles in the mainstream press about SADS in recent days (e.g., in the UK, Canada, and Australia), but it has, and Mike Adams, being the savvy propagandist that he’s always been, has picked up on it and woven it into a conspiracy theory:
Never before in the history of medicine have doctors and the media urged young people to “get their hearts checked.” This is only happening after the global push for covid vaccines which hijack the body’s cells and force them to create spike protein particles that cause blood clots.
And, later in the article:
In summary, the murderous medical regime first injects billions of people with a biological weapon that might kill them, then they pretend to be shocked and surprised when so many healthy young adults start dying for no apparent medical reason. Do these medical monsters have no humanity (or scientific credibility) remaining at all?
Although this syndrome is called SADS, what’s really sad is that it was all done on purpose in order to achieve global depopulation. If anything, these deaths should be labeled, “Vaccine Depopulation Syndrome” deaths. But of course the media and the medial tyrants are working triple time to cover all this up, and they know that dead vaccine victims don’t talk, so they can’t tell the living humans to save themselves by avoiding these deadly jabs.
As an aside, I’ll mention that it’s never been clear to me why “they” would want to kill so many young people with “clot shots” or “depopulate” the planet with vaccines, but that’s just me. At this point, I also find it hard not to point out that not even Mike Adams claims that incidence of SADS has been increasing since December 2020, which is when the COVID-19 vaccines first rolled out. Wouldn’t you think that such an observation, at the very minimum, would be the prerequisite for even speculating that COVID-19 vaccines might be causing SADS? (I’m surprised that he didn’t just lie and say that the incidence has been increasing.)
I’m married to a pediatric APRN, which is why I like to note that pediatricians and APRNs who routinely do sports physicals and screenings know that SADS, while fairly rare, is not so rare that they don’t need to worry about it and try to screen for it. For example, this review article noted:
In this issue of Heart, Behr et al7 estimate mortality due to SADS from mortality statistics and a prospective survey of coroners’ evaluations from 117 jurisdictions in England. The coroners’ evaluation was extensive and included assessment of expert cardiac pathologists and home interviews of next of kin. The authors derive an estimated annual mortality of 0.16/100 000 people per year. This is substantially greater than that expected from the official ICD 798.1 category of sudden death (cause unknown—instantaneous death) of 0.10/100 000 people per year. Furthermore, they calculate that the number of potential SADS cases, on the basis of all ICD codes to which SADS could be assigned, is 1.34/100 000, a rate that is >8 times greater than the survey’s estimate.
Moreover, we know a number of conditions that are associated with SADS including long QT syndrome, Brugada syndrome, progressive cardiac conduction defect, arrhythmogenic right ventricular dysplasia/cardiomyopathy (ARVD/C), catecholaminergic polymorphic ventricular tachycardia (CPVT), short QT syndrome, Wolff-Parkinson-White (WPW) syndrome, and Timothy syndrome.

Frequently, SADS isn’t diagnosed until after a family member dies and a workup is undertaken for a genetic predisposition to sudden cardiac death:
Over the past two decades, a large number of inherited arrhythmogenic syndromes that cause sudden death have been characterised. Some are associated with structural heart disease, such as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. Others do not produce structural heart disease. Most are due to inherited abnormalities of cardiac ion channels, such as the long QT syndrome, short QT syndrome, familial catecholaminergic polymorphic ventricular tachycardia and Brugada syndrome. Many of these syndromes can be identified or suspected from a resting ECG or exercise test, but individually they are rare, and not commonly sought in routine health examinations The only symptoms that affected individuals’ experience are due to arrhythmias, such that the first manifestation of the disease is often cardiac arrest from polymorphic ventricular tachycardia degenerating to ventricular fibrillation and sudden death. Some affected individuals are more fortunate, experiencing non‐sustained arrhythmias, presenting as palpitations or syncope, leading to recognition of the disease and treatment. Other affected but asymptomatic or undiagnosed individuals are identified when a family member dies suddenly, and the possibility of a genetic abnormality is considered, leading to screening of the victim’s relatives. Unfortunately, a postmortem examination of the victim does not suggest the specific cause, and, all too frequently, the possibility of an inherited sudden death syndrome is not considered, or family members are not informed of the possibility when the autopsy is unrevealing.
SADS is, as you can see, an uncommon and mysterious event, with multiple possible causes and, worst of all, often no warning signs or only very vague warning signs, such as fainting, which can have a number of causes. That makes it perfect for antivaxxers to latch onto as being caused by vaccines.
In fact, this isn’t even the first time that antivaxxers have tried to associate SADS with vaccines, although they’ve never done it quite explicitly. Regular readers might remember back in the day how often antivaxxers tried to blame the sudden deaths of young women and adolescent girls on HPV vaccines like Gardasil, to the point of even making a documentary called Sacrificial Virgins to describe the alleged phenomenon. As sad as these deaths were, there was no evidence to demonstrate that HPV vaccines either caused or contributed to them, and, in retrospect, they were almost certainly due to SADS even though SADS is much more common in males.
To antivaxxers, it’s always the vaccines. Always.
At SBM we frequently write about how correlation does not necessarily equal causation in medicine. Sometimes it does, obviously, but very often—far more often than lay people understand—it does not. Unfortunately, the human brain is not wired that way; quite the opposite, in fact. It’s wired to look for associations and then to attribute causation to any associations found, even when those associations are tenuous at best.
Because antivaxxers believe vaccines are causing horrific harm, whenever a celebrity suffers an unexplained, rare, or sudden decline in health, they start looking for a cause, and that cause nearly always is vaccines, or at least includes vaccines. Before the pandemic, they used to do it routinely for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and any unexplained death of an adolescent girl after HPV vaccination. Since the pandemic, they’ve turned the technique up to 11. They did it with Justin and Hailey Bieber; they’ve done it with every celebrity who’s died suddenly and unexpectedly since the vaccines started rolling out; and now they’ve developed an explicit conspiracy theory that “they” are supposedly “covering up” deaths due to COVID-19 vaccines by misattributing them to deaths due to SADS. One, Mark Crispin Miller, has even taken this tactic to an extreme that even I have never seen before, in essence insinuating that all sudden deaths are due to the vaccine.
Unfortunately, the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy is a powerful one when used as disinformation, because it appeals to the way most people think. It’s not enough simply to say that correlation does not equal causation, particularly because sometimes it does. We have to explain why this particular message in this particular case does not show causation from correlation and often doesn’t even show correlation. Such is the case with COVID-19 vaccines and Ramsay Hunt syndrome, Hailey Bieber’s TIA, and all the celebrity deaths that antivaxxers are trying desperately to attribute to them.

If the BMJ Wants to Revisit Venerable Institutions Who Misled the Public in 2021, They Should Look Inward at the BMJ
Until the BMJ demonstrate the integrity to revisit their own dismal failures regarding life and death matters, there’s no reason to care about their opinions regarding less consequential issues, is there?
Jonathan Howard on October 1, 2026
Link

“We may still pay a price for the pursuit of emergency use authorizations for covid-19 vaccines in children”
I got my start at SBM in May 2021 writing a response to a short opinion piece in the BMJ titled Covid vaccines for children should not get emergency use authorization. It was by Drs. Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral and concluded that the vaccine should be unavailable to most children until it cleared arbitrary, time-consuming regulatory hurdles.
It claimed the vaccine’s benefit for children would be “relatively minor” and that “unlike adults, covid-19 vaccination is not addressing an emergency.” “We may still pay a price for the pursuit of emergency use authorizations for covid-19 vaccines in children,” it warned ominously.
The only facts in it were that the swine-flu vaccine caused Guillain-Barré syndrome in 1976 and that COVID was milder for children. However, the article omitted what mattered most and what I discussed at length in my article—the basic facts of how COVID had already hurt children the first year of the pandemic.
Nonetheless, despite being entirely fact-free, this article met the standards of the BMJ.
“Circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable”
However, this was not the only or even the worst piece of fact-free, anti-vaccine drivel the BMJ published that month. Another opinion piece that also met the BMJ’s standard was titled Vaccinating children against SARS-CoV-2 by Drs. Jennie S Lavine, Ottar Bjornstad, and Rustom Antia. It also aged poorly.
I’ve not discussed these authors previously; however, I’ve discussed doctors like them many times before. None of them treated COVID patients, and their inexperience allowed them to speak about pediatric COVID with a sheltered casualness available only to the laptop class. Pediatricians who treated sick children never blew off what they saw as “typically mild.”
I’ve also discussed their ideas and techniques many times before. That’s what We Want Them Infected was all about, and the BMJ paper certainly wanted them infected.
It spoke as if the pandemic was ending in May 2021, and it too warned that vaccinating children could have dire consequences.
Unfortunately, as virus circulation decreases, the age of primary infection increases, and since age is directly associated with pathogenicity, vaccinating children would likely lead to lower infection rates but higher case fatality rates. Additionally, depending on the relative durations of immunity induced by vaccines and infection, and the rate of viral antigenic change, vaccinating children might increase the frequency of large seasonal epidemics, leading to overall increases in virus induced morbidity and mortality.
In their telling, vaccinating little Johnny might kill Granny, you know, based on the rate of viral antigenic change. The safer path for them both was to let Johnny get COVID, repeatedly.
They spoke about a “balanced decision” and came down firmly on the side of the virus:
Should childhood infection (and re-exposures in adults) continue to be typically mild, childhood vaccination will not be necessary to halt the pandemic. The marginal benefits should therefore be considered in the context of local healthcare resources, equitable distribution of vaccines globally, and a more nuanced understanding of the differences between vaccine and infection induced immunity.
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood as transmission blocking immunity wanes but disease blocking immunity remains high. This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
We knew by May 2021, when these BMJ papers were published, that infections in younger people invariably spilled into older people. There was also preliminary evidence via an RCT (published later that month in the NEJM) that the COVID vaccine was safe and effective for adolescents. Neither of the BMJ papers mentioned these important results.
Instead of informing its readers, the BMJ paper did PR on behalf of the virus. It said that circulation of SARS-CoV-2 “may in fact be desirable,” followed by “booster re-exposures throughout adulthood to keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.” Here we are, once again.
Source: xkcd comic
“COVID-19 vaccine strongly effective for children and adolescents amid delta and omicron”
The BMJ paper also made predictions. It spoke of “decreasing virus circulation” and speculated that “childhood vaccination will not be necessary to halt the pandemic.” It further presumed that “childhood infection (and re-exposures in adults) would continue to be typically mild.”
All of this turned out to be wrong, and this wasn’t some mere academic debate. The stakes were high.
The Delta and Omicron variants arrived immediately after these two BMJ papers were published, each variant spiking pediatric infections, hospitalizations, and deaths. Parents of deceased children predictably felt regret for skipping the vaccine, which unsurprisingly turned out to be very effective in preventing rare, but grave outcomes in children. Meanwhile, COVID infections failed to keep COVID infections mild. Today the headlines read: Repeat COVID infections tied to higher odds of new health conditions.
Oops.
Last week, Dr. David Gorski wrote an article titled Once again, The BMJ, Wittingly or Unwittingly, Reinforces an Antivax Narrative that discussed an “investigation” by the BMJ regarding a short delay in reporting a rare vaccine side effect. This side effect was nearly always temporary and mild, and it did not fundamentally change the risk-benefit equation for the vaccine. Nonetheless, the BMJ treated this perceived failure as a big scandal.
However, if the BMJ wants to once again revisit venerable institutions that misled the public in 2021, they should look inwards at the BMJ. Until they demonstrate the integrity to revisit their own dismal failures regarding literal life-and-death matters, there’s no reason to care about their opinions regarding issues less consequential than that, is there?

MYOCARDITIS

Myocarditis and how to think about it… like a cardiologist
In response to the dumpster-diving VAERS study published earlier this month, pediatric cardiologist and guest blogger Dr. Frank Han adds context by explaining how cardiologists think about and diagnose myocarditis.
Frank Han on September 18, 2021
Link

You may have seen multiple articles out there that describe myocarditis after COVID vaccination and how you should be concerned about it. There are many layers to the diagnosis of myocarditis, and I as a board-certified pediatric cardiologist, wish to share with you some of those layers of nuance.
This article will focus on myocarditis as a disease from the perspective of the mainstream pediatric cardiologist – for excellent articles on the research methodology related to postvaccine myocarditis and statistics, I refer you to the excellent previously-written work on Science Based Medicine by Dr. David Gorski, Dr. Dan Freedman, and Dr. Jonathan Howard.
The heart, myocarditis, and complex etiology
Many news sources at this point have tried to make the case that COVID vaccine myocarditis is worse than COVID disease myocarditis. To understand where this assertion comes from, one needs to begin with some definitions. The heart muscle is composed of many different types of tissue, including connective tissue (scaffolding), muscle tissue (the workhorse), nerve tissue (the communications network), electrical tissue (for communication inside the heart), and vascular tissue (to keep everything fed). Myocarditis at its core is inflammation of the heart. There are many, many causes of myocarditis, and because myocarditis appears to happen after vaccination in mostly kids and young adults, I will focus my discussion on this group. The risk-benefit ratio in older adults is much, much more clear.
Kids can get myocarditis from many different sources, but most kids generally get myocarditis because they were exposed to a virus of some variety. Here are only a few of those causes (citation: European Society of Cardiology):
Myocarditis is typically diagnosed in the Cardiology office or hospital setting with the following case definition by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (with small regional variations):
Just looking at the cases of reported myocarditis can be quite disheartening to the non-medical reader. The next question is naturally, why didn’t the mRNA platform vaccination get paused immediately after all these cases of myocarditis were found? Weren’t the adenoviral vector platform vaccines paused right after the discovery of vaccine-induced thrombotic thrombocytopenia? Well, if you don’t remember anything else – I would emphasize that not all myocarditis is of the same severity. Why didn’t myocarditis feature prominently in the core clinical trials? It wasn’t because the researchers weren’t looking, it’s because of a concept known as study power. If a fluorescent needle can only be found in 1 in 100 000 haystacks, many haystacks must be searched to locate the needle. If the needle lives in 1/50 haystacks, the search is much easier.
The historical incidence of myocarditis of all causes is estimated at around 1-2/100 000 (citation: Moss and Adams Heart Disease in Infants). Myocarditis historically has been diagnosed slightly more in men than in women. The classic blood test used to look for myocarditis is troponin, which is a normal component of the heart muscle. The problem with just labeling every patient who has troponin in the blood as a “myocarditis” is that not all that bleeds troponin, is myocarditis (citation: American College of Cardiology):
It is a cardiologist’s role to help sort out which patients have genuine myocarditis, and which patients have a higher troponin level in the blood due to some other cause (which could be something as simple as a football match). The diagnosis of myocarditis can also sometimes be difficult! There is a saying in medicine – patients don’t always read the textbook. This means that patients rely on us to figure out why their body has done something unusual, and they don’t always directly fit the traditional list of characteristics that we were taught to search for in medical school. When the diagnosis becomes difficult, cardiologists or radiologists specializing in cardiac MRI can come to the rescue – and image the heart. (Image citations UCDavis and Auntminnie.com). There are specialized MRI criteria that cardiologists use to help confirm the diagnosis.


Cardiologists can use the combination of how the patient is behaving, the EKG, echocardiogram, lab tests, and cardiac MRI (if available) to triage the severity of the illness. Not all hospitals may offer cardiac MRI, and sometimes you may observe a cardiologist making use of the other tests that are available in that particular hospital’s toolkit. Every discussion of COVID vaccine myocarditis versus COVID disease myocarditis must include a description of their comparative severity otherwise that discussion can very easily be misleading.
What is known about COVID vaccine versus disease myocarditis?
The real incidence of viral myocarditis from all seasonal viruses in young men is a little difficult to calculate but is probably higher than the numbers quoted above. Why? Because every patient with a sniffle doesn’t see a cardiologist to figure out if there is myocarditis, and rightfully so. It’s reasonable to match your depth of testing with the severity of the disease. The severity of viral myocarditis ranges from being symptom-free, all the way up to requiring life support. The same can be said about SARS-CoV-2 viral myocarditis.
In teenage boys and girls, who are most at risk of post-vaccine myocarditis, what is the rate of COVID-19 viral myocarditis versus COVID-19 vaccine-induced myocarditis? From this pre-print out of Cleveland, using the TriNetX Research network, 876 per million boys developed myocarditis overall, and split into 12-15 versus 16-19, those rates were 601 and 561 per million respectively. For the girls, the rates were 213 per million overall, and 235 per million and 708 per million in the 12-15 versus 16-19 age groups respectively. According to the same study, myocarditis after infection is 6 times more likely than after vaccination. According to this 2nd article, which surveyed side effects after COVID infection versus COVID vaccination (albeit in an older age group), the incidence of all the side effects that mattered were worse in the patients who were infected with the genuine virus than vaccination. It was also acknowledged that the vaccination poses an increased risk above baseline of myocarditis. Again – COVID illness myocarditis is a bigger bad actor than COVID vaccine myocarditis.
The now-infamous study authored by Høeg et al is deeply misleading; their core premise is that vaccination myocarditis occurs at a higher rate than in those who get COVID disease. If you purely look at VAERS reports without doing any other analysis, this is the unusual conclusion you will arrive at. VAERS in fact, specifically instructs the reader to not use their database in this way; it is meant as a tool to generate hypotheses, not to search for causality. Databases such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink are much better databases to research this problem. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention use very specific myocarditis criteria (which aligns with what most cardiologists use) to be as certain as possible, that cases are being estimated as accurately as possible.
All myocarditis is serious, including vaccine-induced
At no point do I wish to downplay myocarditis – if I were to meet a patient with COVID vaccine myocarditis who was deathly ill, I would announce it to the world, and warn everyone of the risks. I thankfully have yet to meet such a patient, and the patients that are in my clinic have all recovered. In my entire clinic, comprising all my cardiologist partners, I have counted approximately 5 total COVID vaccine myocarditis cases. I have similarly asked many colleagues about their experiences, and the consensus is that they are uniformly symptomatically recovering. Although this study had not collected many MRIs by the publication deadline, the study group is going to do a follow-up work that contains MRI studies. The patients in my clinic who are recovering from post-COVID vaccine myocarditis have cardiac MRIs that look very, very reassuring. Some unpublished data exist of patients who have had very concerning cardiac MRIs after COVID vaccination in the absence of documented COVID infection – each of those patients has cardiologists who are watching these patients very carefully. The CDC has convened a specific study group to monitor these patients. This is not the work of an organization that wishes to downplay myocarditis.
Conclusion: Worry about the virus, not the vaccine
        ◦ I support all efforts to mitigate the risk of mRNA vaccination myocarditis, but given the accelerating Pediatric Intensive Care Admissions, I would be against any effort that attempts to do this at the cost of vaccination efficacy or at the cost of even more PICU admissions. PICU admissions, even if they don’t result in serious long term complications, represent a significant hit to a teenager’s quality of life. I appreciate the efforts of Professor Shane Crotty’s group in elucidating the relative effectiveness of natural immunity versus immunity post-immunization, and eagerly await the Immunology community’s discussion on this hot topic. I won’t claim to be able to expertly interpret their studies and will refer you to them for their perspective. In the end, the risk of COVID vaccine myocarditis is larger than vaccination with many classical vaccines, but the absolute risk is still very, very small – and far smaller than the disease itself. You are trading in a significant risk for a much smaller, calculated risk and pediatric cardiologists are ready to give the necessary care to each patient who may have this complication.

Myocarditis and COVID-19: A Tale of Two Articles
Whether myocarditis is serious or not depends on the symptoms it produces and the damages it does, not on its underlying cause. Those who write about COVID-19 and vaccines should try to be consistent and thorough.
Jonathan Howard on July 11, 2021
Link

“Even in the Sickest of the Sick, Covid-19’s Effect on the Heart Appears to be Modest”
On May 14th 2021 Drs. John Mandrola, Andrew Foy, and Vinay Prasad wrote an article titled “Setting the Record Straight: There is No ‘Covid Heart’.” The article acknowledged “that SARS-CoV-2 can sometimes, though rarely, cause heart inflammation — just as many other viruses do”, but there was no indication that “SARS-CoV-2 had some special proclivity to harm the heart”. Fearful that needless tests may uncover incidental “injury”, causing unnecessary fear, they wrote “people who have recovered from Covid-19 have no special reason to worry about their hearts.” Even “in the sickest of the sick”, they wrote,
Covid-19’s effect on the heart appears to be modest. A London-based team reported on a series of 148 patients who had recovered from severe Covid-19. Cardiac magnetic resonance scans done during convalescence showed that nearly half of the individuals had no major heart abnormalities, and 9 out of 10 had normal heart function.
This referenced a study that found a “myocarditis-like scar in 26% (39/148), infarction and/or ischaemia in 22% (32/148) and dual pathology in 6% (9/148)”. Of course, a study that found that “nearly half of the individuals had no major heart abnormalities” also found that over half of the individuals did have major heart abnormalities. Nevertheless, it’s unclear what the clinical implications of this are, if there are any at all. After all, this was an imaging study and it’s not clear what to make of a “myocarditis-like scar.”
Generally, I liked this article. It acknowledged that COVID-19 can cause some heart inflammation, while pushing back on sensationalized narratives that captured the public’s attention. It reasonably concluded that “The issue of Covid-19 induced cardiac problems was massively overblown” and felt that the initial worries about “COVID heart” represented an opportunity to learn “lessons for how science is communicated to the public”. Though I feel it would have been strengthened had it mentioned myocarditis as a complication of multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) in children, I agree that COVID-19 is scary enough without the need to exaggerate its dangers. The overall prognosis seems good too. Over a year into the pandemic, we are not seeing large numbers of post-COVID-19 patients with unexpected cardiac complications as far as I know.
The article noted that “incentives in the modern media” favor fearful headlines and that reassuring but more accurate information “won’t spread nearly as quickly”. Drs. Mandrola, Foy, and Prasad concluded their article by writing, “The broader lesson is that science communication in times of crisis must keep a level head. The public, and decision-makers, need properly controlled studies instead of early sensational reports”. I agree.
“Humans have only one heart; inflaming it at a young age is not a small thing”
With this in mind, it’s worthwhile to examine how one of these authors has since discussed vaccine-induced myocarditis. On July 1st 2021, cardiologist Dr. Mandrola wrote an article titled “Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect, Not Absolutism”. I won’t go over them all, but the article checked off many “red flags” I wrote about in my previous article on this subject. I urge you to read both our pieces. On balance, I feel that Dr. Mandrola’s article omitted key facts and rebutted invented arguments, overestimating the harms of the vaccine relative to the virus in the process.
Dr. Mandrola’s aim was “to argue that when it comes to vaccinating young people at low risk from the virus, parents and younger people should be allowed to weigh the vaccine decision with their clinicians without anyone being tarred as an antivaxxer.” I know of no one who would call parents and younger people antivaxxers for this reason.
In his article, Dr. Mandrola pushed back on those who called vaccine-induced myocarditis “mild” by writing,
I disagree; calling myocarditis mild reminds me of the saying about minor surgery. Minor surgery is surgery on someone else; mild myocarditis is something that happens to other folks’ kids. Humans have only one heart; inflaming it at a young age is not a small thing.
He rightly noted that affected young people were “discharged from the hospital” and said that, “As an electrophysiologist, I see the complications of myocarditis: heart failure and ventricular arrhythmia due to scar. Availability bias notwithstanding, heart rhythm doctors feel the asymmetry of myocarditis risk. Although it is true that most myocarditis resolves without issue, it is also true that sometimes it does not.” He favorably quoted University of Michigan cardiologist Dr. Venk Murthy, who said in a Twitter thread that influenced my thinking on this topic that, “people with myocarditis are usually counseled to limit activity, placed on 1 or more meds and are at lifetime increased risk of cardiac complications. This can have profound consequences.”
Dr. Mandrola worried that “minimization of harm from myocarditis, might reduce trust in messaging” about the vaccines, even in “at-risk adults who refuse the vaccine”. Was he at all concerned by those who minimize the myocarditis caused by the virus? No, he was not. He was only concerned that some minimized vaccine-induced myocarditis. I share Dr. Mandrola’s worry that the “minimization of harm from myocarditis” might be responsible for low vaccination rates in large swaths of the country. Many people are under the illusion that COVID-19 is completely harmless in children.
While he did acknowledge that COVID-19 has killed hundreds of children, something other articles on this subject neglected to do, Dr. Mandrola, a cardiologist writing about children, COVID-19, and the heart, did not even mention MIS-C-associated myocarditis in either of his articles, even though it is much more severe than vaccine-induced myocarditis and likely occurs at a slightly higher rate. In an article in which he says, “medical decisions should be made” with “judgment and benefit-harm balances and considerations of special circumstances”, he doesn’t even acknowledge the most severe form of cardiac damage to affect children and young adults during the pandemic. I will discuss it.
In addition to this, Dr. Mandrola belittled the successful vaccine trial in adolescents as follows:
After a “positive” trial in which just over 1100 kids aged 12 to 15 years received an mRNA vaccine, a movement arose to vaccinate young and old alike. I put “positive” in quotes for two reasons: The first is that this trial measured noninferiority of the immune response, not clinical outcomes. That was necessary because so few kids get sick with COVID-19. The other reason is that the authors claimed a favorable safety profile, but 1100 kids is not enough to inform the safety of a vaccine that will be given to many millions.
To be generous, this is only partially correct. The trial was titled “Safety, Immunogenicity, and Efficacy of the BNT162b2 Covid-19 Vaccine in Adolescents”. As the title clearly states, the trial evaluated “efficacy against confirmed coronavirus disease 2019”. Sixteen COVID-19 cases occurred among placebo recipients, while none occurred in those who received the vaccine:

The trial authors wrote that “the vaccine efficacy in this trial provides a high level of certainty about the efficacy results”. I would call this clinical outcome positive – without the quotation marks.
I confess to being confused by Dr. Mandrola’s description of this study. I think he means that severe clinical outcomes, being rare in children, couldn’t be evaluated in this study. This is true, as I will explain below. However, even if severe outcomes are not common, kids definitely get sick with COVID-19. In fact, sixteen children who received a placebo injection got COVID-19 in this trial. Dr. Mandrola does not believe it is a “clinical outcome” when an adolescent gets COVID-19 in a trial of a vaccine designed to prevent them from getting COVID-19. I bet most of his readers would disagree with him, however they wouldn’t know the vaccine prevented COVID-19 in adolescents unless they read the trial themselves. His article omits this fact.
Dr. Mandrola is right that this trial was not large enough to fully “inform the safety of a vaccine that will be given to many millions”. It was too small to detect rare events, such as myocarditis from the vaccine or serious complications from the virus. However, only the largest trials can detect rare events, and the rarer the event, the larger the trial must be to detect it. The adult vaccine trials, which were about twenty-times larger than the adolescent trials, also did not detect rare events, such as blood clotting with the Johnson & Johnson vaccine. The inability to detect rare events is a fundamental limitation of clinical trials, not a flaw of this particular trial.
Rare events can usually be detected once a vaccine or medication is taken by large numbers of people. This is why post-marketing surveillance, called a phase IV trial, is so crucial. It’s a fact that no serious safety signal emerged during the trial. The authors were not only justified to report this finding, the data from their study required it. They didn’t claim that rare side effects would not emerge once millions of children received the vaccine.
All of this makes me wonder. Other than a trial that enrolled hundreds of thousands of adolescents, which would be required to meaningfully detect a rare event such as myocarditis, is there anything a trial could do so Dr. Mandrola wouldn’t feel he had to put “positive” in quotes? Did he make his objections known when the plans for the adolescent vaccine trial were announced or only after it was completed? Has he been similarly critical of other randomized-controlled trials, or is this the only trial he has singled out this way? As he does not feel someone getting COVID-19 is a “clinical outcome”, what would he call it? Why didn’t he inform his readers that the vaccine prevented COVID-19 in adolescents? Would he have been similarly silent had the vaccine been significantly less effective at preventing COVID-19? We can only guess.
Dr. Mandrola also raised some challenging and important questions of his own. These questions are the core of the article and by far the best part, in my opinion. For example, he asked whether it was ethical for a hospital to mandate a vaccine in an “18-year-old who works in engineering, has no patient contact, and who recovered from COVID-19 a few months ago”. I hadn’t thought of such a nuanced question. He also asked, “would one shot (especially in younger males) offer a better benefit-harm calculus?” This is a very reasonable question as the myocarditis risk is highest in young males after the second vaccine dose. However, this would have to be weighed against seeming lower efficacy of one shot (Planas et al. and Bernal et al.) against the Delta variant compared to two shots. Given the rare outcomes it would have to detect, only a massive trial, which would likely take years just to enroll subjects, could definitively determine if one shot offered a better benefit-harm calculus than two shots. The Delta variant is now the dominant strain in the US, and given how fast it is spreading, there will not be time to fully study this proposal.
But it is an interesting and valid question, as are most of the questions Dr. Mandrola ponders. There are no clear-cut answers to many of them. As viral-induced immunity seems robust and long-lasting, I do not think the 18-year-old engineer should be required to receive a vaccine as long as he can document he was previously infected and no new information emerges about COVID-19 reinfection rates. You may disagree, but Dr. Mandrola is right- he is not an antivaxxer for asking these questions, nor am I for my response.
How common is vaccine-induced myocarditis?
Though we don’t know the true incidence, vaccine-induced myocarditis seems uncommon. According to the CDC, “The highest reporting rates were among males aged 12−17 years and those aged 18−24 years (62.8 and 50.5 reported myocarditis cases per million second doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine administered, respectively)”. This translates to about 1 in 16,000 for the highest risk group, males ages 12-17 years. Israel, however, reported a higher rate of myocarditis, from 1 in 3,000 to 1 in 6,000 males ages 16-24 years. We will better learn the true incidence over time, however likely the worst is over. Vaccination rates have been dropping steadily in the US, including for young people most at risk for myocarditis.
Is vaccine-induced myocarditis mild?
As a neurologist and psychiatrist, I view the heart as a pump to deliver blood to the brain, so I am a bit out of my territory when discussing whether or not myocarditis can be “mild”. However, most medical professionals with relevant expertise seem to think “mild” is an appropriate word to describe vaccine-induced myocarditis. The CDC noted that, of the 323 persons meeting their definition of vaccine-induced myocarditis, “309 (96%) were hospitalized. Acute clinical courses were generally mild; among 304 hospitalized patients with known clinical outcomes, 95% had been discharged at time of review, and none had died.” Multiple medical organizations, including the American Heart Association and American Academy of Pediatrics agreed and released a statement expressing their view. It said,
The facts are clear: this is an extremely rare side effect, and only an exceedingly small number of people will experience it after vaccination. Importantly, for the young people who do, most cases are mild, and individuals recover often on their own or with minimal treatment. In addition, we know that myocarditis and pericarditis are much more common if you get COVID-19, and the risks to the heart from COVID-19 infection can be more severe.
Israel, which first sounded the alarm about the vaccine, also noted that “95% are considered to be mild cases…In most cases myocarditis took the form of mild illness that passed within a few days”. A co-author on his original article about “COVID heart”, Dr. Vinay Prasad, also wrote an article about vaccine-induced myocarditis with Drs. Venk Murthy and Brahmajee K. Nallamothu. It properly noted that rare side effects “could not have been detected in their clinical trials” and said about vaccine-induced myocarditis that, “Although most cases reported to date are mild and resolve without consequence, myocarditis can be a serious condition”.
Dr. Mandrola disagrees with this characterization, and I can see why. All but a few young people with vaccine-induced myocarditis have been admitted to the hospital for monitoring and have had elevated troponin levels, a marker of cardiac injury. Dr. Mandrola is right that I would not call this “mild” if it happened to my vaccinated son. Even if he was admitted “just for monitoring”, this would be frightening; I wouldn’t feel comfortable until he was back home and without symptoms for some time.
Fortunately, the vast majority of young people with vaccine-induced myocarditis do go home without symptoms. Most are hospitalized for only a short time, often just a couple days, and require only over-the-counter pain medications. Nearly 80% of cases have recovered without symptoms thus far, and the rest are presumably headed in that direction:

Most importantly, according to Dr. Katherine Poehling, a pediatrician on the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), no deaths or severe outcomes have been reported so far. (I’ve heard rumors on social media that the deaths of two teens are being investigated. Neither was diagnosed with myocarditis as far as I know, and history shows us why it is important not to jump to conclusions about these sad cases.)
Commenting on its favorable prognosis, Dr. Grace Lee, a pediatrician at Stanford, said “This is not like any myocarditis I’m used to seeing”. Dr. Sallie Permar, the chair of pediatrics at Weill Cornell Medicine and New York–Presbyterian Komansky Children’s Hospital, said children are being hospitalized “because we wanted to monitor them, out of an abundance of caution…Even the kids are asking, ‘Why am I going to the hospital?'” Other doctors who have treated and authored case series on these patients agree on the favorable outcome so far. Dr. James de Lemos, a professor of medicine, said, “They’ve all done well” and all recovered clinically after spending “just a couple of days” in the hospital. Dr. Pei-Ni Jone, a pediatric cardiologist, said, “The good news is, all these children recovered”.
Dr. Jone is right – this is good news, though these favorable outcomes are sometimes inexplicably omitted from articles on this subject. Dr. Mandrola’s article, for example, noted that no one has died from the vaccine and that “most of the affected kids recovered and were discharged from the hospital,” but otherwise provided no information on either the clinical course or frequency of vaccine-induced myocarditis.
So is vaccine-induced myocarditis “mild”? This is clearly a subjective question. I don’t think I’ve ever described it that way, though I’ve certainly quoted many others who have. In fact, as I wrote previously, to me it’s serious any time a young person gets admitted to the hospital, even if they leave after a few days of feeling well, as most seem to do. Cardiac injury, even if temporary, is obviously not trivial. Affected people are often advised to limit vigorous activity for 3-6 months, which must stink, especially during the summer.
Though vaccine-induced myocarditis is rare, rare harms multiplied by tens of millions of people add up. Over 1,000 cases of myocarditis have been reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), and there are certainly cases that have gone unreported. While reports to VAERS do not prove causality, it’s clear that a large number of people, most of them young, have suffered from this problem. I fully agree with Dr. Mandrola that vaccine-induced myocarditis shouldn’t be minimized.
Happily though, the overall outcome of these cases is quite encouraging so far. Almost all seem to resolve in a short time without symptoms and with normal cardiac tests, such as ECGs and echocardiograms. These cases will have to be monitored over time, but hopefully this pattern will continue. Overall, I think the CDC has done an admirable job of informing the public about vaccine-induced myocarditis in a transparent way. The CDC says that it will continue to “closely monitor reports of myocarditis after receipt of the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and will bring any additional data to ACIP for consideration”. For now, if it is ever appropriate to call myocarditis mild, vaccine-induced myocarditis seems to fit the bill.
How common is COVID-induced myocarditis?
MIS-C occurs in about 1 in 3,200 children infected with COVID-19, and thus far it has affected at least 4,196 American children, perhaps many more as cases may be undercounted. According to the CDC, “The median age of patients with MIS-C was 9 years. Half of children with MIS-C were between the ages of 5 and 13 years.”
In one study of 191 children with MIS-C “53% had evidence of myocarditis, 80% were admitted to an intensive care unit and 2 died”. A systematic review of 15 case series/reports found that 75% of children with MIS-C have myocarditis. Of course, MIS-C is not the only way that COVID-19 can cause cardiac damage, especially in adults, but this damage is harder to define and quantify.
Is COVID-induced myocarditis mild?
In contrast to vaccine-induced myocarditis, COVID-19 can cause severe cardiac complications. There have been cases of fulminant myocarditis in COVID-19, though it seems to be rare. Additionally, myocarditis and coronary artery aneurysms frequently occur in children with MIS-C. Other studies have reported acute heart failure in children with MIS-C. Other common cardiac complications of myocarditis due to MIS-C include “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Cardiac arrhythmias have led “to hemodynamic collapse and need for ECMO support” in some children. This heart damage doesn’t seem “modest” to me.
Children with MIS-C are extremely sick and are treated with much more than over-the-counter pain medications. Dr. Cleavon Gilman has a heart wrenching Twitter thread of some of their stories, though it’s not as devastating as his thread on children who have died of COVID-19. Dr. Gautam Singh, chief of pediatric cardiology at Children’s Hospital of Michigan, who authored a study on cardiac dysfunction in children with MIS-C, said, “Almost invariably, half of them required going on mechanical ventilation or a breathing machine, heart-supporting medications”. 37 children have died of MIS-C. None of this has happened with vaccine-induced myocarditis, thankfully.
In contrast to vaccine-induced myocarditis, the effects are longer-lasting, though happily most children seem to recover well. Dr. Singh said about children in his study, “Fortunately, they all did very well, and they went home, which is great gratification. When we studied these children and followed them about five to six months (later), we found about 19% to 20% have some involvement of their heart function that was not clinically obvious, but by echocardiographic measurements.” One review found that 6%-14% of children had persistent ventricular dysfunction when they left the hospital. As with vaccine-induced myocarditis, the long-term consequences of this, if any, will only become apparent over time.
Dr. Mandrola wrote in his article that, “A neutral observer might wonder: well, if folks were that excited about myocarditis in young people after the infection, why are they not equally worried about this early signal of harm from the vaccine?” I understand this neutral observer’s confusion, especially if she has thus far only read articles that neglect to mention myocarditis due to MIS-C or elaborate on the favorable prognosis of vaccine-induced myocarditis. I imagine that once the neutral observer learns this information, she will better understand the asymmetries in the concern.
To summarize how COVID-19 has harmed children and young adults thus far, it has killed 488 children younger than 17 years and 2,682 young adults ages 18-29 years. It has hospitalized tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of children, even accounting for the fact that many tallies include incidental COVID-19 cases in children hospitalized for other reasons. Several studies (Kim et al. and Havers et al.) found that one-third of hospitalized children go to the ICU and about 5% need mechanical ventilation. There are more questions than answers about long-COVID in children, but I feel comfortable saying that a lot of children felt sick for a long time, even though fortunately the overwhelming majority are perfectly fine.
After reviewing all the data, the CDC concluded that “the benefits of vaccinating all recommended age groups with mRNA COVID-19 vaccine clearly outweigh the risks of vaccination, including the risk of myocarditis after vaccination.” They calculated that,
Per million second doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine administered to males aged 12–29 years, 11,000 COVID-19 cases, 560 hospitalizations, 138 ICU admissions, and six deaths due to COVID-19 could be prevented, compared with 39–47 expected myocarditis cases after COVID-19 vaccination.
Notably, this “analysis did not include the potential benefit of preventing post-COVID-19 conditions, such as prolonged symptoms and MIS-C”.
Though Dr. Mandrola claimed it was “dubious to force young people to expose themselves to a risk for an unknown benefit to society”, this is another rebuttal to a non-existent argument. Everyone is very clear: the primary reason to vaccinate young people is to protect them from COVID-19. It’s just a nice bonus that they are also less likely to spread a deadly virus to a vulnerable family member, teacher, or coach. After all, one study found that 43,000 children lost a parent to COVID-19 and assuredly some children have infected their family this pandemic. Losing a parent hurts children too.
Whether myocarditis is serious or not should not depend on its cause
In my opinion, whether myocarditis is serious or not depends on the symptoms it produces and the damages it does, not on its underlying cause. Dr. Mandrola does not seem to agree.
When discussing viral-induced cardiac damage he wrote that “the issue of Covid-19 induced cardiac problems was massively overblown” and “even in the sickest of the sick, Covid-19’s effect on the heart appears to be modest”. Remember, this statement was written in reference to an imaging study that found 28% of patients with severe COVID-19 had infarcted myocardium, which is dead heart tissue, or ischemia, a lack of blood flow that causes injury and infarction. These statements were also written well after it was known that COVID-19 had caused severe myocarditis in several thousand children with MIS-C, though Dr. Mandrola doesn’t acknowledge this in his articles. In contrast, when discussing less severe vaccine-induced myocarditis, he wrote, “Humans have only one heart; inflaming it at a young age is not a small thing”. So, which is it?
On March 10th 2021, he said on Twitter that the pandemic was “essentially done” and that “human life has to be more than avoiding one pathogen”. He compared a contagious virus to bike injuries. He implored former CDC director Dr. Tom Frieden to stop discouraging behaviors, namely congregating indoors, that spread the virus. By this point hundreds of American children had already died of COVID-19 as had thousands of young people between the ages of 18 to 30. Tens of thousands (or more) of children and young adults had been hospitalized due to COVID-19, many ending up in the ICU due to MIS-C and myocarditis. Despite this, Dr. Mandrola said that the “young have almost no risk” from the virus. In contrast, when discussing less severe vaccine-induced myocarditis, he emphasized that affected young people were “discharged from the hospital”. He further wrote that “calling myocarditis mild reminds me of the saying about minor surgery. Minor surgery is surgery on someone else; mild myocarditis is something that happens to other folks’ kids.” So, which is it?
His concern about the long-term prognosis seems similarly dictated by the cause of the myocarditis. In his article on the virus, he wrote that “people who have recovered from Covid-19 have no special reason to worry about their hearts”. Again, this statement was written after it was known that some children with myocarditis due to MIS-C have persistent cardiac dysfunction at hospital discharge. In contrast, when discussing less severe vaccine-induced myocarditis, he warned of “complications of myocarditis: heart failure and ventricular arrhythmia due to scar”. So, which is it?
Either of his two positions alone seems reasonable to me. It is reasonable if a doctor believes the effects of COVID-19 on the heart are generally “modest” even in the sickest patients, and long-term consequences are nothing special to worry about. It is reasonable if a doctor believes that myocarditis is never “mild” and long-term consequences are definitely something to worry about. However, I find it problematic when a doctor, who doesn’t want to be tarred as an antivaxxer, takes both of these positions, within weeks of each other, dependent entirely on whether the cause of the heart injury was the virus or the vaccine and in inverse proportion to both the severity of the damage and the number of affected children.
It is reasonable to expect a doctor with a large platform writing for the public about children and a deadly virus to be accurate, consistent, and thorough, especially considering the questions he poses are important and don’t have clear answers.

COVID-19 and balancing the risks: The vaccine or the virus
Given recent reports of myocarditis after vaccination with mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines in young people, we think it’s a good time to reexamine the risk/benefit ratio of these vaccines in this population.
Jonathan Howard on June 30, 2021
Link
Myocarditis 101
With recent reports of myocarditis after vaccination in young people after the mRNA vaccines, it is worthwhile to reexamine the risk/benefit ratio of these vaccines in this population. First let’s start with what is known about myocarditis in this population.
Myocarditis is inflammation of the heart muscle, and pericarditis is inflammation of the pericardium (outer lining of the heart). It can be caused by a wide variety of infectious agents, toxins, or as part of an autoimmune condition. It typically presents with chest pain and shortness of breath. Patients typically have ECG abnormalities and elevated serum troponin levels, a marker of cardiac injury. Myocarditis is more common in young men and can be quite serious depending on the underlying cause.
How has the COVID-19 vaccine affected children and young adults?
The CDC conducted a risk-benefit analysis and reported data from two vaccine-safety monitoring systems: The Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) and the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD). Each of these two databases has their own strengths and weaknesses. According to the CDC, “VAERS accepts all reports from everyone regardless of the plausibility of the vaccine causing the event or the clinical seriousness of the event”. This makes VAERS useful to rapidly detect potential vaccine side-effects that may be rare. But anyone can file a report, and even in the case of well-intentioned reports, it is not possible to establish cause and effect. Antivaxxers abuse this database frequently, as David Gorski has described many times. Of course, many side effects go unreported as well. My children felt tired for a day after their vaccines and had sore arms. I didn’t report this to VAERS. However, most clinicians would know to report a serious outcome like myocarditis, and I find it unlikely that there is a very large number of young people with the condition going undetected by the CDC.
In contrast to VAERS, the VSD surveys nine participating integrated healthcare organizations covering 12 million people. It is a public health surveillance activity that “Monitors a limited set of prespecified vaccine safety outcomes”. It is “Designed to detect statistically significant associations and statistical signals (values above specified statistical thresholds), which do not necessarily indicate a safety problem”. This database is not public as it contains confidential patient information.
Each of these databases has collected information on myocarditis after the mRNA vaccine. Based on data from VAERS, after approximately 300 million doses of the mRNA vaccine, the following numbers were reported:
    • 1,226 total myocarditis cases.
    • 267 myocarditis cases were reported after the first dose. The median age was 30 years and 66% were male. The median time to symptom onset 4 days.
    • 827 cases after the second dose. The median age was 24 years and 79% were male. The median time to symptom onset was 3 days.
    • 132 cases after occurred after an unknown dose.
The risk of myocarditis increased with decreasing age and was more common in males. According to VAERS reports:
    • For males age 12-17 years, the risk after the second dose is 66.7 per one million, or 1 in 14,992.
    • For males age 18-24 years, the risk after the second dose is 56.3 per one million, or 1 in 17,761.
    • For males age 25-29 years, the risk after the second dose is 20.4 per one million, or about 1 in 49,019.
From the VSD, the rate of myocarditis was reported as a group for people age 12-39 years only and only goes through June 5th, perhaps before many adolescents received their second vaccine dose. According to VSD reports:
    • For people age 12-39 years, the risk after the second dose is 12.6 per one million, or 1 in 79,365.
    • For males age 12-39 years, the risk after the second dose is 32.0 per one million, or 1 in 31,250.
    • For females age 12-39 years, the risk after the second dose is 4.7 per one million, or 1 in 212,765.
Most importantly, the outcomes for these cases has been favorable thus far. Most cases of myocarditis can be successfully treated with pain and anti-inflammatory medications. Some have required no treatment at all. The CDC reviewed 484 preliminary reports from people 29 year or younger detected via VAERS. Of these 323 met the definition of myocarditis and/or pericarditis and 148 are under review. Of these 323 cases:
    • 309 (95.6%) were hospitalized.
    • 295 (95.4%) have been discharged.
    • 218 (79%) recovered without symptoms.
    • 5 (1.5%) were lost to follow-up.
    • 9 (2.9%) remain hospitalized, two in the ICU.
In their report of 29 confirmed cases from VSD:
    • 22 (75%) were admitted to the hospital for a median of 1 day (range 0-13).
    • 2 (5.7%) were admitted to the ICU.
    • All were discharged home.
    • Nearly all follow-up visit notes indicated resolution of symptoms at the time of follow-up.
    • Of those that had follow-up, the ECG, echo, lab testing, most had returned to normal or baseline.
Other studies also report a good prognosis. A study of 7 teenagers ages 14-19 years noted that all “resolved their symptoms rapidly”. During a “clinician call” with the Infectious Disease Society of America and the CDC, it was noted that these patients were admitted for cardiac monitoring and all were hemodynamically stable, something that seems true for almost all cases so far. Two studies (Larson et al and Rosner et al) of 15 adult men with vaccine-induce myocarditis reported favorable outcomes. Another case series reported on 23 men age 20-51 years in the military with myocarditis, after more than 2.8 million doses of the vaccine. All patients had significantly elevated troponin levels, which is evidence of cardiac injury. Fortunately, “All patients received brief supportive care and were recovered or recovering at the time of this report”. 16 had recovered fully, while 7 had “chest discomfort” at the time of the report.
Doctors who have treated and authored case series on these patients agree on the favorable outcome so far. Dr. Pei-Ni Jone, a pediatric cardiologist said, “The good news is, all these children recovered”. Dr. James de Lemos, a professor of medicine, said, “They’ve all done well” and all recovered clinically after spending “just a couple of days” in the hospital. Most were not very sick or required ICU care. Affected people may be advised to limit vigorous activity for 3-6 months and long-term monitoring will continue. A warning about myocarditis is now part of the FDA Fact Sheet about the vaccine, which is of course necessary.
In summary, the highest risk is for vaccine-induced myocarditis is in males ages 12-17 after the second vaccine dose, though it is not a common event. According to a statement by the American Heart Association, “The facts are clear: this is an extremely rare side effect, and only an exceedingly small number of people will experience it after vaccination”. The vast majority of affected individuals are admitted to the hospital, though for a brief time. Though some people were monitored in the ICU, almost all cases have recovered without symptoms or seem on the road to recovery. Vaccine-induced myocarditis is rare and serious, permanent consequences seem rarer still.
This is all very good news, but care should be taken to not minimize these cases by focusing on the low rate and good outcomes, as is often done with the effects of the virus on young people. A rare outcome multiplied by millions of people can add up to a non-trivial number. Myocarditis is potentially a very serious, even fatal, condition. It’s serious anytime a young person gets admitted to the hospital, even if they leave after a few days feeling well, as most seem to do. Affected individuals may have felt quite sick, and it must have been a very scary experience for them and their families. It is also not a small thing to for a young person to have to avoid vigorous activity for 3-6 months. Though there is every expectation that these people will continue to remain well, this is not guaranteed, and they will have to be monitored over time. Additionally, more cases will come to light as awareness of the condition grows, some with potentially less favorable outcomes.
How has COVID-19 affected children and young adults?
Now lets’ look at how COVID-19 has affected young adults and children. According to data from the CDC, the number of confirmed cases is:
    • 0-4 years: 576,162
    • 5-17 years: 2,805,814
    • 18-29 years: 6,088,943
As this represents confirmed cases and is likely a substantial underestimate of the true number of infections, the CDC has made the following estimates for COVID-19 cases:
    • 0-4 years: 4,466,773
    • 5-17 years: 22,203414
    • 18-49 years: 55,616,991
    • Assuming that people ages 18-30 years account for an equal share of the cases, this translates to about 21.5 million infections for this age group.
The CDC reports the following deaths:
    • 0-4 years: 155 (1 in 29,000 cases)
    • 5-17 years: 316 (1 in 68,000 cases)
    • 18-29: 2636 (1 in 8,150 cases)
    • 316 of these deaths occurred after 4/1/21
Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) is a serious condition affecting the GI tract, skin, and heart caused by COVID-19 (discussed by Clay Jones over a year ago). Importantly, MIS-C can cause myocarditis. As of June 2, 2021:
    • 4,018 MIS-C cases had been reported to the CDC, though this may be a substantial undercount as many cases have gone unreported.
    • 36% of cases were in persons aged 12–20 years.
    • The estimated incidence of MISC-C is 1 in every 3,164 SARS-CoV-2 infections.
    • 60%–70% of patients with MIS-C are admitted to intensive care, 1%–2% die
As I discussed in a previous article, an accurate count of the hospitalizations for young people is difficult to obtain. There are many ways in which hospitalizations can be undercounted, as not all hospitalizations are reported to government agencies. According to some studies, hospitalizations have also been overcounted by up to 45%, as incidental infections have been included in many tallies. One study, which excluded incidental COVID-19 infections, found the hospitalization rate for COVID-19 in teens was triple that of the flu. Regardless of the exact number, at a minimum, tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized due to COVID-19. Quite plausibly, this number is well over 100,000 people, especially if young adults under 30 years are counted. Children with underlying risk factors such as obesity are at the highest risk of hospitalization. A consistent finding in several studies of hospitalized children is that some can be quite sick. In two studies (Kim et al and Havers et al) one-third need ICU level care and 5-6% need to be intubated. This is an important distinction that must be considered when comparing hospitalizations from COVID-19 with those from vaccine-induced myocarditis.
Of course, COVID-19 can affect children who are not ill enough to be hospitalized. Even among the vast majority of children who do fully recover, some were nonetheless quite really sick for a long time. Estimates from the UK are “that 12.9% of UK children aged 2 to 11, and 14.5% of children aged 12 to 16, still have symptoms five weeks after their first infection”. Another study found that 4.4% children had illness duration ≥28 days, while 1.8% of children experienced symptoms for ≥56 days. While these rates are relatively low, when multiplied by the millions of children who have had COVID-19, this results in a large number of really sick children. Extrapolating these numbers to the US, it means that 500,000 children have had symptoms for two months or more. Other studies fortunately, found lower rates of persistent symptoms.
There are currently more questions than answers as to how COVID-19 might affect children over the long-term, but we should be humble and consider the virus may have complications that we cannot appreciate now. Though the clinical implications are not clear, a study from the UK recently found evidence of brain injury on imaging. Importantly, this study compared scans from people before and after their infections.
What does COVID-19 have in store for children and young adults?
Pandemics are moving targets and the past is at best a rough guide for the future. Predicting the future has made fools of many thus far, especially those who declared herd immunity had arrived months ago in the US. There are factors that make the future for young people more optimistic and factors that make it more pessimistic. In trying to tease these out, I will do some “back of the envelope” calculations and estimates.
On the optimistic side of the ledger, 46.1% of Americans have been fully vaccinated. The CDC estimates that there have been 114.6 total million infections, or that 34% of Americans have been infected. This immunity (both from the mRNA vaccines and virus) seems to be long-lasting, though only time will tell for sure. As there is likely considerable overlap between these two groups, perhaps 70% of Americans have immunity to COVID-19 at this point, though no one knows the exact number. This will form a significant barrier that will prevent COVID-19 from overwhelming cities and hospitals again, especially as the most vulnerable people are the most protected. COVID-19 cases have fallen to a low-point since the start of the pandemic, as have deaths and cases of MIS-C. This is great news. The vaccines work wonderfully, and COVID-19 hospitalizations and deaths occur essentially only in unvaccinated people today, which is not great news.
On the negative side of the ledger, the US is still averaging over 10,000 cases and nearly 300 deaths per day, numbers that seem low only because they are compared with much higher numbers from six months ago. 53.9% of Americans have not been fully vaccinated, and 18 states have vaccinated 40% or fewer of their residents. Among the 18,000 COVID-19 deaths in May, only 150 were in fully vaccinated people. Again, the vaccines really work. The number of vaccine doses delivered daily in the US has steadily decreased since its peak in mid-April. Currently, the USA is averaging only about 900,000 doses per day, and despite great outreach efforts and incentives, the number is likely to continue to decline. Likely the vaccine curve has already peaked for young people most at risk for myocarditis as well. Many people simply do not want to be vaccinated. Many of these people will be hard to convince and they are often not taking steps to prevent themselves from getting infected. According to news reports from rural Missouri,
Nobody’s wearing masks or practicing social distancing. They believe right-wing media’s lies that COVID is “just like the flu” or “vaccines are experimental” or “it’s all a Democrat hoax.” They’re following Trump’s notion that masks make men look “weak.”
Some governors have worked to undermine vaccine efforts, forbidding state agencies or private business from requiring vaccines as a condition of entry. This includes large states, namely Florida and Texas. Sadly, low vaccine rates will prevent many states from reaching the herd-immunity threshold, which will likely be higher than previously thought due to the Delta variant. COVID-19 is spreading in states with low vaccination rates:
Of course, herd immunity is not a state-level phenomenon, and the degree of immunity can vary greatly from neighborhood to neighborhood even within a city. Moreover, young people tend to travel and congregate together.
Most concerning is the emergence of the Delta variant (discussed by Steven Novella last week), which seems up to 60% more contagious than even other COVID-19 variants, which were themselves more contagious than the original virus. According to news reports from Australia, infections have occurred after “encounters of roughly five to 10 seconds between people walking past each other in an indoor shopping area in Sydney in at least two instances”. Queensland’s chief health officer, Dr. Jeannette Young said “with the Delta variant, we’re seeing very fleeting contact leading to transmission. At the start of this pandemic, I spoke about 15 minutes of close contact being a concern. Now it looks like it’s five to 10 seconds that’s a concern. The risk is so much higher now than it was only a year ago”. Obviously this is not scientific proof. Hopefully we’ll know more definitive information about this soon, but several cities in Australia recently announced a lockdowns as a result of this variant. Similar lockdowns are being imposed in several Asian and African countries where this variant is surging. Some American cities that seemed to be through the worst are again encouraging masks.
Outbreaks of the Delta variant have affected children in highly vaccinated countries such as Israel and the UK. It accounts for about 20% of new infections in the US, more than twice what it was two weeks ago. According to some reports, “It is responsible for half of new cases across a swath that includes Missouri, Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska, Colorado, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Utah and Wyoming”. This variant seems to cause worse outcomes as well. According to data from Scotland, the hospitalization rate is nearly twice as high due to the Delta variant and it was most commonly found in younger people. Fortunately, the vaccines still offer solid protection, especially against severe disease requiring hospitalization.
Some who opposed the Emergency Use Authorization for the mRNA vaccine for children counted on high vaccine update in adults obviating the need for the vaccine in young people. Unfortunately, this was always more of a hope than a plan. Though COVID-19 cases are at a low-point today, a similar dip was observed last summer before the nightmare that engulfed the US in the late fall and winter. The current decrease in hospitalizations is due to immunity in older people, not younger people. Indeed, according to the CDC, “COVID-19 associated hospitalization rates have remained stable in adolescents and young adults”.
Given the low vaccine-uptake in large swaths of the country and the emergence of the Delta variant, it seems inevitable that the virus will continue to spread, particularly among the unvaccinated for the foreseeable future. If the Delta variant becomes dominant in the US, as it seems poised to do, only the most isolated young people or those surrounded almost entirely by vaccinated people will remain unexposed. Less contagious viral strains infected 33% of Americans in a year. It seems implausible a large percentage of unvaccinated young people will be able to avoid the virus for years to come. As such, I suspect that most everyone will gain immunity to COVID-19 eventually. It’s just a question of whether it’s through the vaccine or virus.
And many young people remain vulnerable. There are about 125 million Americans under the age of 30 years. Subtracting out the 10 million who have been vaccinated and the nearly 50 million who have virus-induced immunity, this means that about 70-80 million Americans under the age of 30 years remain vulnerable. Of course, the Delta variant is unlikely to be the last variant, and it’s not implausible a variant may arise that is significantly more dangerous to young people.
“The vaccines are safe and effective, and they prevent COVID-19 illness”
The CDC calculated:
Among adolescent boys ages 12 to 17 the researchers estimated that, for every one million second dose vaccinations, 5700 covid-19 cases, 215 hospital admissions, 71 intensive care unit admissions, and two deaths would be prevented. Against this there might be an estimated 56 to 69 cases of myocarditis.
Obviously these numbers will change over time as the pandemic evolves. In my opinion, the evidence clearly shows that based on current knowledge, vaccinating people over the age of 12-years is still significantly safer than leaving them vulnerable to the virus.
After the CDC’s presentation on vaccine-induced myocarditis, multiple medical organizations have come out in favor of vaccinating adolescents and young adults. A statement signed by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP), American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), American College of Physicians (ACP), American Heart Association, American Hospital Association (AHA), American Medical Association (AMA), American Nurses Association (ANA), American Public Health Association (APHA), Association of Public Health Laboratories, Association of State and Territorial Health Officials (ASTHO), Big Cities Health Coalition, Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists, Infectious Diseases Society of America, and National Association of County and City Health Officials (NACCHO) said:
The vaccines are safe and effective, and they prevent COVID-19 illness. They will help protect you and your family and keep your community safe. We strongly encourage everyone age 12 and older who are eligible to receive the vaccine under Emergency Use Authorization to get vaccinated, as the benefits of vaccination far outweigh any harm. Especially with the troubling Delta variant increasingly circulating, and more readily impacting younger people, the risks of being unvaccinated are far greater than any rare side effects from the vaccines. If you get COVID-19, you could get severely ill and be hospitalized or even die. Even if your infection is mild, you or your child could face long-term symptoms following COVID-19 infection such as neurological problems or diminished lung function.
The World Health Organization and multiple other countries have similarly decided to vaccinate teens including Belgium, Canada, Spain, Italy, France, Germany, Singapore, The Philippines, Hungary, and Dubai, to name a few. Israel, which first identified the cases of myocarditis and also reported a higher rate than the US (1 in 3,000 to 1 in 6,000 males ages 16 to 24), has also decided to vaccinate people over the age of 12 years. Israel too noted that “95% are considered to be mild cases”. After new outbreaks with the Delta variant, health authorities there recommended that all 12-15-year-olds be vaccinated, after previously saying it was a matter of the parent’s preference. Dr. Galia Barkai, director of the Pediatric Infectious Diseases Unit at Sheba Medical Center, said about this decision,
We were gathering information regarding myocarditis, we were waiting for more children to get vaccinated in other countries such as in the United States. There were days with no COVID-19 cases in Israel. I tend to think that being more conservative was the right decision, and now things have changed.
Some Israelis are now wondering if their government was too slow to vaccinate children ages 12-15 years.
The core of medicine is the balancing of benefit and risk
The core of medicine is balancing risk and benefit. It’s a debatable question at exactly what age the benefits of vaccination exceed the risks, and the answer to this question will evolve as the pandemic evolves. Reasonable people can disagree about the exact age where the vaccine is likely to cause more problems than it prevents. No one is proposing vaccinating newborns and every reasonable person favors vaccinating older adults.
Some have reasonably proposed that the risk/benefit ratio for young people could be improved by giving just one mRNA injection or spacing out the interval between injections. In one study, one dose of the Pfizer mRNA vaccine was 83% effective at reducing hospitalizations with the alpha variant and 94% against the Delta variant, though the confidence intervals were very large (62-93% for the alpha variant and 46-99% for the delta variant) indicating great uncertainty about the true number. Of course, as previously noted, young people can suffer from COVID-19 without being sick enough to be hospitalized. It’s not clear whether these strategies will improve the safety of the vaccine while still reducing the risk of the virus to young people. Unfortunately, the Delta variant will likely move faster than science’s ability to adequately evaluate these approaches, but they deserve serious consideration. Additionally, the CDC’s position that the very small number of people who had myocarditis after the first vaccine dose should still consider getting the second vaccine dose seems very questionable at best.
For some, however, this near unanimity of opinion in medical organizations and governments favoring vaccination in young people is an invitation to distinguish themselves by reflexively opposing this consensus. Those who opposed vaccines in adolescents even before myocarditis cases became apparent are now using this side effect to justify their opposition. Some red flags to look out for are articles that:
    • Only describe the risk of COVID-19 to young people as “low” or “rare” without specifying the exact of number of deaths or the number of cases of MIS-C. Astonishingly, I’ve read multiple articles on COVID-19 and children by respected doctors that do not even mention these rare, but catastrophic outcomes.
    • Mention that pediatric hospitalizations may have been overcounted, without mentioning that they might have been undercounted.
    • Do not mention that at a minimum COVID-19 has hospitalized tens of thousands of children/young adults and that quite plausibly this number is well over 100,000 people.
    • Equate hospitalizations due to vaccine-induced myocarditis with hospitalizations due to COVID-19. As stated previously, hospitalizations due to COVID-19 are typically much more severe, with many needing ICU-level care and some needing mechanical ventilation.
    • Confidently assert the vaccine-induced myocarditis rate is much higher or more dangerous than we currently know without providing compelling evidence as to why.
    • Speculate on the potential long-term effects of vaccine-induced myocarditis while simultaneously minimizing or not acknowledging the potential long-term effects of the virus itself, including viral-induced myocarditis associated with MIS-C.
    • Fail to acknowledge that the vast majority of cases of vaccine-induced myocarditis have fully recovered or seem likely to do so.
    • Mention that several countries, such as the UK, are not vaccinating adolescents currently, without mentioning that these countries plan to do so in the near future and are outliers in countries with abundant vaccines.
    • Confidently assert that relatively untested alternatives, such as a single injection or spacing out injections, have been definitively shown to be safer and as effective as the current two-dose vaccine schedule.
    • Confidently speak as if the pandemic is “essentially done” for young people or that they can be protected simply by increasing vaccination in adults, as if this is a trivial task given the previously described vaccine hesitancy.
    • Ignore the implications of the highly contagious Delta variant, which unvaccinated people may have to avoid for years to avoid getting infected.
    • Don’t acknowledge that vaccine hesitancy/refusal is a significant, likely intractable problem in much of the country, leaving tens of millions of unvaccinated children potentially exposed to the virus.
    • Mention limitations with VAERS without noting that other vaccine-safety monitoring databases exist, namely VSD, and that the myocarditis rates are similar between the two.
Portray vaccination of young people primarily as a means to benefit adults by creating herd immunity. Everyone is clear: young people should be vaccinated to protect themselves. Perhaps one day COVID-19 vaccination will be like polio vaccination, designed to prevent a resurgence of a disease that currently poses no risk to American children. But for now, it’s just a bonus that children might not lose their mom or dad because they’ve been vaccinated.

Peer review of a VAERS dumpster dive
A new preprint study on COVID vaccine myocarditis dives into the VAERS dumpster with predictable and embarrassing results.
Daniel Freedman on September 12, 2021
Link

Editor’s note: Dr. Dan Freedman is providing an extra bonus post today about a poor quality study that went viral late last week. Dr. Gorski’s post will publish on Monday as scheduled, just a little bit later than usual. Think of Dr. Freedman’s post as a warm-up, as Dr. Gorski plans on discussing the same study in his usual inimitable fashion. (It deserves two posts.)
There is a new preprint study of COVID-vaccine-associated myocarditis (C-VAM) by Hoeg et al. being shared on social media and several news sites that has not passed peer review. The claim from the study authors is that they replicate the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practice’s (ACIP) analysis of C-VAM event reports from the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) and found a much higher incidence than previously reported. The study falls short of this claim in many ways but perhaps most significantly, it appears the authors wandered into the VAERS quagmire with no understanding of how the system works.
Dumpster diving in VAERS has been well covered by Science Based Medicine for 13 years. This is a classic antivaccine trope where reports from VAERS are dredged up to scare people. This is despite multiple disclaimers that you have to click through to access this data, which explicitly warn against using the data as Hoeg et al. do. This is just part of the disclaimer:
VAERS accepts reports of adverse events and reactions that occur following vaccination. Healthcare providers, vaccine manufacturers, and the public can submit reports to the system. While very important in monitoring vaccine safety, VAERS reports alone cannot be used to determine if a vaccine caused or contributed to an adverse event or illness. The reports may contain information that is incomplete, inaccurate, coincidental, or unverifiable. In large part, reports to VAERS are voluntary, which means they are subject to biases. This creates specific limitations on how the data can be used scientifically. Data from VAERS reports should always be interpreted with these limitations in mind.
The ACIP has an additional advantage that these investigators lack – the raw data from these reports has been adjudicated by VAERS staff at the Centers for Disease Control (CDC). These significant limitations of the Hoeg et al analysis should be kept in mind as we review some of the individual cases. The authors claim to use the same methodology as the ACIP review but a brief review raises some suspicions. VAERS ID 1345283 describes a teen with chest pain and right axis deviation on EKG. The report states “no clear diagnosis but a suggestion that it sounded clinically like a viral pericarditis”. Right axis deviation is not one of the criteria used by the ACIP to determine cases of myocarditis or pericarditis (see Table 1). This is the problem with just plugging in search terms (“troponin”, “myocarditis”, etc) to VAERS and not thoroughly reviewing cases. As Ryan Marino said, “this is like thinking that a search for ‘gunshots’ on NextDoor is a way to track gun violence”.
The most glaring examples of cases that were not reviewed in detail by Hoeg et al are the cases with a comorbid infection. This represents a significant confounding variable which makes it impossible to discern with such limited data if the myocarditis was due to the vaccine or the intercurrent illness. VAERS ID 1334617 describes a positive SARS-CoV-2 PCR and VAERS ID 1361923 describes a rhinovirus/enterovirus positive PCR. The authors also include a report of a patient with EBV-positive PCR, serologies pending. These cases were likely excluded by ACIP due to these confounders.
There are other notable cases like VAERS ID 1382338 where the patient is described as encephalopathic to the point of needing intubation for airway protection. Is this a case of C-VAM or a viral infection causing both encephalitis and myocardial injury? VAERS ID 1386269 describes a patient with difficulty walking due to neurological weakness. No mention of any cardiac diagnosis. These cases were likely excluded by ACIP due to incomplete information.
The authors also included a 14-year-old patient who appears to have received their Pfizer vaccine before the Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for 12-15 year olds; VAERS ID 1292713 received a 2nd dose on 4/28/21 and the EUA did not occur until 5/10/21. There is no explanation for this in the manuscript. Perhaps these dates were recorded incorrectly but without the ability to investigate this inconsistency in the data, the authors could not possibly know anything more than speculation.
There are also a number of patients with mild elevations in troponin (0.12-0.23) and mild symptoms (one patient had 1 hour of chest pain and saw their pediatrician a week later). While I lack the expertise to weigh in on what is and what is not pediatric myocarditis, there are fortunately others (twitter thread here and here) with this expertise. These pediatric cardiologists have seen patients with V-CAM and the outcomes appear to be significantly better than myocarditis or multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) from the virus itself. The preprint briefly touches on this but only discusses three references for outcomes of V-CAM when there are at least four additional references (here, here, here), including the most comprehensive review to date of 63 pediatric V-CAM cases in Pediatrics, that are curiously absent from Hoeg et al.
These are just seven cases out of 257 that I and others found on brief review. It is likely that there are more, which is one of the reasons why experienced experts in the field warn that VAERS isn’t suitable for this kind of analysis. As a passive reporting system, VAERS can serve as an early signal detector that can then be evaluated in larger, active safety monitoring systems like the Vaccine Safety Database (VSD).
Despite my frustration with the authors for getting in over their heads, I am grateful that they ported the VAERS data into their own interactive database (though this should have still contained a disclaimer about the potential for misuse of this data). One of the cases (ID 1231560) was written by a mom describing the scary experience of her child being in the cardiac unit and waiting for test results. This serves as a good reminder that myocarditis is a frightening disease. We need to inform parents of this risk to the best of our abilities. However, this is not an excuse to come up with half-baked analyses including inappropriate data that will certainly be co-opted by the antivaccine movement. And when the paper fails to be published in a journal because of the above methodological flaws, the antivaccine movement will cite this as evidence of a conspiracy.
Peer review is an important academic process where many of the mistakes noted above could have been recognized and addressed. Even if the study was flawless, this type of analysis would still be problematic given the very nature of VAERS. If the authors wanted to calculate the incidence of V-CAM, they could have requested data from VSD.
The study provides a lot of important lessons on what not to do. Don’t do research in an area that is outside of your expertise without help from someone more experienced. Don’t ignore important disclaimers on the CDC’s dataset. Don’t post your methodologically-flawed study on a preprint server when you fail to find a journal. Consider that the problem is with your analysis, not the journals. Don’t dumpster dive in VAERS. Many people, including Hoeg et al., will not understand the complexity and flaws of a useful warning system like VAERS. If you do not have access to all of the data, don’t let assumptions take the place of limitations.
        ◦ VAERS is like when your uncle is in the hospital but your aunt won’t let you talk directly to the healthcare professionals so that all you get is filtered, incomplete and sometimes wildly inaccurate information. VAERS is only as good as the reporter filling out the event – and frequently the data is imperfect. That’s why the data comes with a lengthy disclaimer. Please pay attention to it.

Dumpster diving in the VAERS database to find more COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis in children
“Dumpster diving” is a term used to describe studies using data from the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System database by authors, almost always antivaxxers, who don’t understand its limitations. Last week, non-antivax doctors who should know better fell into this trap when they promoted their study suggesting that COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are more dangerous to children than the disease.
David Gorski on September 13, 2021
Link

I’ve been writing about how antivaxxers misuse the Vaccine Adverse Events Recording System (VAERS) database dating back to very early in my history as a blogger. VAERS, for those unfamiliar with it, is a database to which anyone can report any adverse event (AE) noted after vaccination. It serves as an early warning system that can generate hypotheses regarding correlations between specific AEs and vaccines, but by its very design cannot test these hypotheses. (I’ll explain in detail later in this post when I discuss the shortcomings of VAERS.) Indeed, out of curiosity, I did some searching of all of my blogs and discovered that the first time that I mentioned VAERS and its shortcomings was in 2005 in the context of a discussion of chelation therapy for autism. The first time that I ever discussed VAERS here on Science-Based Medicine (SBM) was in 2008 in the context of a discussion of harms attributed by antivaxxers to the human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccine. Because of its very nature, VAERS is prone to misunderstanding and misuse, and, unsurprisingly, VAERS has become a favorite tool of antivaxxers to claim that vaccines cause whatever AE on which they want to blame vaccines. That’s why, over the years, we’ve mentioned VAERS on this blog many times, and I’ve mentioned it elsewhere many times going back to 2005.
Last week, VAERS was in the news, and for once it wasn’t because of antivaxxers abusing it. Unfortunately, that makes the misuse of the database all the more potentially damaging. You see, there was a study published as a preprint last week, and it’s being held up as “evidence” that vaccinating 12-17 year olds against COVID-19 is more dangerous than COVID-19 because of post-vaccination myocarditis. It goes along with a common refrain that a lot of physicians who really should know better have been repeating without context and, sadly, even though they are not antivaccine need to be fact-checked as though they were, namely the false narrative that masks and vaccines to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 are at best useless in children or even worse than the disease.
In adding to this refrain, this study contributes material to the antimask and antivaccine movement and falls prey to the same sorts of gross errors observed in studies done by antivaxxers using VAERS data. You’ll note that guest blogger Dr. Dan Freedman has already commented on some of the glaring problems with this study. I view my commentary as complementary in that I will provide a lot of background that I’ve learned the hard way over nearly 20 years and emphasize different problems than the ones Dr. Freedman did. Moreover, I’ll cite problems pointed out by others on social media with more expertise than I in the nitty-gritty of these sorts of analyses, to complement my knowledge of VAERS. I will begin by describing how this study is being spun, continue to discuss the history and structure of VAERS, which is absolutely essential to understand why this study is so bad, and then finish by delving into the study itself, using the analysis to make some observations.
Prelude: Doctors who should know better stumbling through VAERS
As many times as I’ve seen antivaxxers misuse VAERS to try to blame vaccines for autism, sudden infant death syndrome, infertility, and more, I must admit that I was unprepared and profoundly disappointed late last week to see the database abused in a similar fashion by investigators who are not antivaccine (although definitely biased) and then to see their bad science amplified in stories like this one in The Guardian by its science editor Ian Sample (who really should know better), titled “Boys more at risk from Pfizer jab side-effect than Covid, suggests study“:
Healthy boys may be more likely to be admitted to hospital with a rare side-effect of the Pfizer/BioNTech Covid vaccine that causes inflammation of the heart than with Covid itself, US researchers claim.
Their analysis of medical data suggests that boys aged 12 to 15, with no underlying medical conditions, are four to six times more likely to be diagnosed with vaccine-related myocarditis than ending up in hospital with Covid over a four-month period.
Most children who experienced the rare side-effect had symptoms within days of the second shot of Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine, though a similar side-effect is seen with the Moderna jab. About 86% of the boys affected required some hospital care, the authors said.
This study actually suggested nothing of the sort, for reasons that I will explain. In fairness, though, let’s see what the study’s first lead author had to say last week when the study first hit the preprint server medRxiv:
"For boys 12-17 without medical comorbidities, the likelihood of post vax dose 2 CAE is 162.2 & 94.0/million respectively. This… exceeds their expected 120-day COVID-19 hospitalization rate at both moderate (August 21, 2021 rates) & high COVID-19 hospitalization incidence" pic.twitter.com/nnqxYAoTM0
— Tracy Høeg, MD, PhD (@TracyBethHoeg) September 9, 2021
And, of course, the obligatory “I’m not antivaccine; I’m pro-vaccine”:
I have to add: I am a pro-vaccine and pro recognizing natural immunity. I think transparency about this rare side effect from the CDC will only increase vaccine uptake among adults. I hope we can learn more about this condition & optimize pediatric vax recs to minimize harm.
— Tracy Høeg, MD, PhD (@TracyBethHoeg) September 9, 2021
No, I don’t think that Dr. Tracy Høeg (or any of the other authors) is antivaccine. However, it is very clear that she and her co-authors are completely out of their depth here and do not understand how VAERS works, even though Dr. Høeg, a sports and spine medicine specialist, does also have a PhD in Epidemiology and Public Health from University of Copenhagen. She really should know better, but this study demonstrates that she does not, as I will show. As for the rest of the authors, Allison Krug is also an epidemiologist who, again, really should know better, while Dr. John Mandrola is an adult cardiologist with a definite axe to grind who bills himself as a “medical conservative”. As for Josh Stevenson, I had never heard of him before this, but he is listed as being with a corporation called Truth in Data, LLC. I couldn’t find out much more about him other than that and what’s on his Twitter feed.
[ADDENDUM: Since this post went live earlier this morning, several people have reached out to inform me that Stevenson is a member of the team behind Rational Ground. I have therefore added this addendum, plus some additional Tweets below about this. A brief perusal of Rational Ground website reveals a group dedicated to minimizing the severity of COVID-19 and resisting mask mandates and lockdowns, and his Twitter feed is consistent with that. Interestingly, his Twitter bio does not list his affiliation with Rational Ground, almost as though he didn’t want anyone to know it. Indeed, a Google search of his name plus “COVID” doesn’t bring it up in the first three long pages of results. (Maybe he’s embarrassed, or maybe he doesn’t want people citing his work to be aware of his bias.) Interestingly, no one on the Rational Ground team appears to have anything resembling the necessary expertise to analyze COVID-19 data, including Stevenson, who describes himself as a “data visualization expert who focuses on creating easy to understand charts and dashboards with data” whose “background is in computer systems engineering & consulting, and his Bachelor’s degree is in Audio Engineering.” Quelle surprise.]
Unfortunately, even though it’s a preprint that has not yet been peer-reviewed, it’s been picked up by the usual suspects and amplified on social media. For example, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya was ebullient:
This paper, by @TracyBethHoeg, @KrugAlli, @drjohnm, @ifihadastick is a model of how to analyze VAERS data.
Key takeaway:Risks & benefits of covid vax for children depend on previous immunity, comorbidities, etc. Personalized decision making better than universal vax. https://t.co/g0FiPRoYLa
— Jay Bhattacharya (@DrJBhattacharya) September 9, 2021
Bhattacharya clearly understands VAERS as well as the authors of this paper (i.e., not at all); otherwise, he would not have said anything quite so cringe-inducingly wrong. On the other hand, he is one of the main signatories of the Great Barrington Declaration, which advocated basically doing nothing about the pandemic other than “focused protection” of the “vulnerable,” apparently blissfully unaware that it’s impossible to protect the vulnerable if COVID-19 is spreading unchecked through the entire population.
Dr. Vinay Prasad was even more enthusiastic:
Rate of cardiac adverse event after vax dose 2 in boys aged 12-15 is……
A Bombshell finding from dream team of authors@drjohnm @TracyBethHoeg @KrugAlli Josh Stevenson
……….1 in 6200
Exceeding risk of hospitalization in that age grouphttps://t.co/bZBecW0nXi pic.twitter.com/WookiLYjNU
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) September 9, 2021
I would hardly call these authors a “dream team” (especially Josh Stevenson, who has no requisite expertise to help carry out such an analysis). I will, however, admit that, unlike Dr. Prasad’s previous characterization of combatting health misinformation as LeBron James “dunking on a 7′ hoop,” deconstructing this paper is a little harder, maybe like dunking on an 8′ hoop, simply because it requires a detailed explanation of how VAERS works and why it can’t be used to do what the authors used it for. I also can’t help but note that Dr. Prasad is well-known for demanding more rigorous data for various medical interventions, such as masking to slow the spread of COVID-19. Yet on this topic, he seems quite happy with a low-quality study that misuses the VAERS database, which is why this unrelated assertion made me laugh:
Over the years, I have done or led umbrella evidence reviews of NCCN guidelines, bone marrow transplant, medical reversals, medical devices, drugs, procedures, surgeries, cancer screening tests….……that is why when I say the evidence for a claim is weak, I mean it https://t.co/WUDLX4hB6E
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) September 12, 2021
I can’t really comment on these indications for bone marrow transplantation, but Dr. Prasad is oddly oblivious to the weakness of the study by Høeg et al.
Moreover, as was pointed out over the weekend, the rapidity with which this preprint study made it into major news outlets of a certain ideological bent reeks of astroturfing:
3/ Turners article was published less than 2 hours after the report was put out, interesting to see besides GBD/Collateral Global characters, who else was quick to take the study seriously pic.twitter.com/PZSDcCj3bk
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
5/ Stevenson one of the other authors is also in Rational Ground, skeptic groups with more of a anti vax vibehttps://t.co/mbfebsbS70
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
7/ Pandata and HART are very close, even have weekly joint meeting.They spend a lot of time rummaging through VAERs and considering how to represent the data pic.twitter.com/AUXBbLKtDD
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
Indeed.#HARTleaks pic.twitter.com/Ogusiq6kdS
— James Neill  ≠ 𝕏 (@jneill) September 12, 2021
Worst of all, though, politicians opposed to vaccine mandates and masking are using the study to justify their message:
This is absolutely not true and was shown to be false. Gross antiscience disinformation from an elected member of the US Congress. Antiscience aggression is contributing to the death of 1,500 Americans each day. Enabled by social media. 100,000 needless American deaths since May https://t.co/Euc0ZNz45V
— Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD (@PeterHotez) September 12, 2021
Never mind that it is not yet even peer-reviewed. Bad science has real consequences:
That dreadful VAERS preprint is, I fear, having a huge ripple effect
Very hard to put the genie back in the bottle; Congress’s Anti-Vaxxer in Chief is championing it, she has a massive conservative anti-vaxx fan base, & the press are all over it
I worry about the consequences https://t.co/7x9emvYkrt
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) September 13, 2021
Let’s dig in and explain what’s wrong with the study. Before I dig into the weeds of the study, its methodology, and its conclusions, though, a brief history of VAERS is necessary to provide context. If you’re already very familiar with VAERS, its proper uses, its weaknesses, and how it’s been misused by antivaxxers, you can probably skip the next section, although you might still at least want to skim it.
A brief history of VAERS and why it is not a reliable data source
VAERS is a bit of an odd beast when it comes to vaccine safety reporting systems. It was established jointly by the FDA and CDC in 1990 as an outgrowth of the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986 and was intended as an “early warning system” or, as I like to call it, a “canary in the coalmine”. To accomplish that function, the CDC and FDA designed VAERS as an open system that allows anyone to enter any suspected AE after vaccination. It’s also an open system in that the data are freely available on the VAERS website to search for reports of AEs after vaccination. Anyone can do it. (I have.) Unfortunately, seemingly everyone has, whether they understand VAERS or not.
According to the CDC, the objectives of VAERS are to:
    • Detect new, unusual, or rare vaccine adverse events;
    • Monitor increases in known adverse events;
    • Identify potential patient risk factors for particular types of adverse events;
    • Assess the safety of newly licensed vaccines;
    • Determine and address possible reporting clusters (e.g., suspected localized [temporally or geographically] or product-/batch-/lot-specific adverse event reporting);
    • Recognize persistent safe-use problems and administration errors;
    • Provide a national safety monitoring system that extends to the entire general population for response to public health emergencies, such as a large-scale pandemic influenza vaccination program.
However, there are a lot of caveats, as you can see from the CDC’s own description of VAERS:
Established in 1990, the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) is a national early warning system to detect possible safety problems in U.S.-licensed vaccines. VAERS is co-managed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). VAERS accepts and analyzes reports of adverse events (possible side effects) after a person has received a vaccination. Anyone can report an adverse event to VAERS. Healthcare professionals are required to report certain adverse events and vaccine manufacturers are required to report all adverse events that come to their attention.
VAERS is a passive reporting system, meaning it relies on individuals to send in reports of their experiences to CDC and FDA. VAERS is not designed to determine if a vaccine caused a health problem, but is especially useful for detecting unusual or unexpected patterns of adverse event reporting that might indicate a possible safety problem with a vaccine. This way, VAERS can provide CDC and FDA with valuable information that additional work and evaluation is necessary to further assess a possible safety concern.
Then there’s this disclaimer:
VAERS accepts reports of adverse events and reactions that occur following vaccination. Healthcare providers, vaccine manufacturers, and the public can submit reports to the system. While very important in monitoring vaccine safety, VAERS reports alone cannot be used to determine if a vaccine caused or contributed to an adverse event or illness. The reports may contain information that is incomplete, inaccurate, coincidental, or unverifiable. In large part, reports to VAERS are voluntary, which means they are subject to biases. This creates specific limitations on how the data can be used scientifically. Data from VAERS reports should always be interpreted with these limitations in mind.
The strengths of VAERS are that it is national in scope and can quickly provide an early warning of a safety problem with a vaccine. As part of CDC and FDA’s multi-system approach to post-licensure vaccine safety monitoring, VAERS is designed to rapidly detect unusual or unexpected patterns of adverse events, also known as “safety signals.” If a safety signal is found in VAERS, further studies can be done in safety systems such as the CDC’s Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) or the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment (CISA) project. These systems do not have the same scientific limitations as VAERS, and can better assess health risks and possible connections between adverse events and a vaccine.
In brief, the key strength of the VAERS database is its open nature, which allows instantaneous reports from anyone, health provider or lay person, which in turn provides the data for rapid hypothesis generation. However, the key weakness of the VAERS database is also its open nature, which can lead to bias and the inclusion of incomplete, inaccurate, coincidental, and unverified information. Indeed, let’s go back to my first mention of VAERS in 2005, which I wrote after learning about a now-famous anecdote from James Laidler:
The chief problem with the VAERS data is that reports can be entered by anyone and are not routinely verified. To demonstrate this, a few years ago I entered a report that an influenza vaccine had turned me into The Hulk. The report was accepted and entered into the database.
Because the reported adverse event was so… unusual, a representative of VAERS contacted me. After a discussion of the VAERS database and its limitations, they asked for my permission to delete the record, which I granted. If I had not agreed, the record would be there still, showing that any claim can become part of the database, no matter how outrageous or improbable.
Since at least 1998 (and possibly earlier), a number of autism advocacy groups have, with all the best intentions, encouraged people to report their autistic children—or autistic children of relatives and friends—to VAERS as injuries from thimerosal-containing vaccines. This has irrevocably tainted the VAERS database with duplicate and spurious reports.
Laidler’s example is not the only one. In 2006, in response to a lot of commenters crying “BS!” after having read about Laidler’s anecdote, another autism advocate also known for combatting antivaccine misinformation then decided to see if he could replicate Laidler’s experience. He could:
VAERS has two ways of submitting a report. Firstly, you could download a PDF, fill it in and post it off. Or, you could do what I elected to do and fill in and submit a report online.
VAERS has a helpful popup which tells you exactly what it needs to know – which are the most important pieces of data it needs. However, the fact that I live in the UK was not deemed of importance. Neither was the fact that I told VAERS that my daughter had been turned into Wonder Woman. The only piece of contact data I submitted was my email address and I wasn’t even asked for that. I submitted it voluntarily.
As Jim Laidler himself once put it:
You see, the VAERS database is not a good source of material for any epidemiological study, a fact acknowledged by the very people who maintain it. The purpose of the VAERS database is to act as a repository for any complications following a vaccination. These complications may be due to the vaccines or may be coincidental, but the VAERS team wants to hear about them all. After all, their purpose is to watch for any unexpected consequences of vaccinations.
This is a statement that, I hope, answers the question that I’m sure many of you have: Why on earth would the CDC and FDA maintain such a flawed database in the first place? I also like to note that, whatever the merits or lack thereof in maintaining a database like VAERS, contrary to the way it is portrayed by antivaxxers, VAERS is by no means the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring. Antivaxxers love VAERS because its flaws make it easy to use to produce seeming correlations between vaccines and autism (and all the other things they blame vaccines for), but there are other systems that are active surveillance systems, such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) and the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment (CISA) project. These are two of the systems used to test the hypotheses generated by VAERS.
That same year, I discussed how attorneys suing vaccine manufacturers for “vaccine-induced” autism (never mind that vaccines do not cause autism) had gamed the VAERS database for litigation purposes by encouraging their clients to submit reports of autism as an AE after vaccination, thus hugely distorting the database. At the time, I noted how this feature of VAERS makes it inherently unreliable for as a tool for longitudinal studies of the rates of vaccine-related AEs. Regular readers will remember how I keep harping on “baseline rates” of AEs (the rate that would occur in the absence of vaccination). The problems with all studies of VAERS are that there is no “control group” and there is no way of knowing whether the sample in VAERS is a representative one. (In fact, it certainly is not.)
That’s why those of us who’ve written about VAERS like to refer to studies like this as “dumpster-diving” or “garbage in, garbage out”. True, I didn’t invent the term “dumpster diving” to describe these VAERS studies, but I have used it to describe various misuses of VAERS, starting with the father-son duo of Mark and David Geier’s dumpster dive for autism in 2006, followed by other examples like:
    • A blogger trying to claim that vaccines cause sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) in 2006.
    • Stephanie Seneff trying to show that aluminum adjuvants in vaccines cause causes autism in 2012.
    • Gary Goldman trying to prove that the H1N1 vaccine causes miscarriages in 2012.
    • Neil Miller and Gary Goldman trying to prove that combining childhood vaccines in one visit increases the risk of autism in 2016.
    • Gail Delong trying to prove that HPV vaccines decrease female fertility.
There are more examples, of course. Unfortunately, in the age of the COVID-19 pandemic, those of us familiar with this history of VAERS warned that antivaxxers would weaponize the database to blame all sorts of complications on COVID-19 vaccines. Nobody listened. Unfortunately, it has come to pass, as I’ve discussed multiple times on this blog, when antivaxxers have pointed to VAERS to try to blame the vaccine for a “holocaust” or even “depopulation” based on VAERS reports, something I documented as early as February, less than two months after the EUA for the Pfizer vaccine. Indeed, blaming the COVID-19 vaccines for thousands of deaths and a number of other complications based solely on their own analysis of VAERS data is a prominent feature of antivaccine arguments, to the point that Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. maintains a weekly update of fear-mongering VAERS reports.
Into this history boldly stride Høeg et al. It does not go well.
Dumpster-diving for myocarditis
So let’s circle back to the study (“SARS-CoV-2 mRNA Vaccination-Associated Myocarditis in Children Ages 12-17: A Stratified National Database Analysis“) by Høeg et al., who fall prey to the same sorts of missteps in analyzing VAERS as the Geiers, Seneff, Goldman, Miller, and a depressing array of antivaxxers during the 17 years I’ve been blogging and, I’m guessing, before. Things go very wrong right from the first sentence of the abstract that describes the objectives of the study as:
Establishing the rate of post-vaccination cardiac myocarditis in the 12-15 and 16-17-year-old population in the context of their COVID-19 hospitalization risk is critical for developing a vaccination recommendation framework that balances harms with benefits for this patient demographic.
And, near the end of the introduction:
Our primary aim was to stratify post-mRNA vaccination myocarditis by age and vaccination dose within the 12–17-year-old population. Our secondary aim was to provide an updated estimate to complement the CDC’s [2,3,6] and FDA’s [4] findings. Our final aim was to perform a harm-benefit analysis of mRNA COVID-19 vaccination myocarditis with that of COVID-19 hospitalization for children with and without one or more comorbidity at low, moderate, and high 120-day COVID-19 hospitalization rates.
I was half-tempted just to stop right here, throw my hands up, do a dramatic facepalm, and rant that you can’t do this with just VAERS data, much less compare your VAERs-estimated risk of myocarditis between age groups and then compare that risk to the risk of hospitalization from COVID-19 and leave it at that. (I know. You can do it, but you’ll end up with unreliable results, because by its very nature VAERS does not allow for an accurate estimate of the frequency or incidence of any given AE after vaccination using its public-facing data.) All VAERS can do is to detect potential safety signals that require other monitoring systems to determine if these signals are spurious or represent real correlation and causation by the vaccine. (After all, what have I just spent something like 2,500 words discussing in the context of the history and design of VAERS?) However, I suspect that the authors would become very offended and indignant and then argue that they can indeed do such a thing, pointing to their methods. That leaves me little choice but to go into the weeds of their methods, as noxious as those weeds are. Also, they will point out that the CDC itself has used VAERS data to estimate this frequency, which is true but incomplete and misleading.
That brings me to another point, just as important. Why on earth did these investigators basically repeat the analysis that the CDC and FDA did for a recent meeting of the Advisory Council on Immunization Practices (ACIP), only without all the extra data that ACIP has? As our guest blogger from earlier today put it:
Good thread. I'm not sure why the authors felt the need to repeat ACIPs analysis without access to the adjudicated data the CDC has. I wish they had known more about VAERS & it's flaws before making this unforced error.
Hopefully they'll see reasonable critiques this one.
— Dan Freedman, DO (@dfreedman7) September 12, 2021
Exactly. Unlike Høeg et al., ACIP had access to data adjudicated by investigators at VAERS and the CDC to determine if the AE actually happened and to assess the likelihood that it might have been due to the vaccine. ACIP also had access to up-to-date data from VSD, a far more reliable source. So I echo Dr. Freedman’s sentiment: What on earth did the authors hope to accomplish by, in essence, repeating that analysis, but with unadjudicated and much less complete data? Choosing to do this suggests an ideological bias, that the authors didn’t believe the CDC, FDA, and ACIP. I don’t expect everyone just to take the word of ACIP that its analysis is the be-all and end-all on this question, but a measure of humility is called for. As Dirty Harry once said, “A man’s got to know his limitations”, and the Høeg et al. clearly did not know their limitations or the limitations of the dataset they chose to use. That it was open, convenient, and easily accessible does not excuse them, particularly given that they could have requested the adjudicated dataset:
Key point about VAERS. The disclaimer has two parts. The first part warns against using the incomplete data to draw conclusions. The second part highlights other tools used to investigate signals found in VAERS. If a team wants better data than VAERS, they just need to ask for it pic.twitter.com/vLlkNjQPKv
— Dan Freedman, DO (@dfreedman7) September 12, 2021
They could also have gotten access to VSD data. All that’s required is a written protocol approved by an institutional review board (IRB). They did not, which leads to these questions:
I have to wonder if they had prior motivation to share a certain result?
— Ryan Marino, MD (@RyanMarino) September 12, 2021
Yeah I feel for Alli. We had some exchanges & I know she's trying to act in her child's best interest. Unfortunately the data is only as good as the docs who reviewed it. Even if this analysis was done flawlessly, it still would be problematic bc of the very nature of VAERS
— Dan Freedman, DO (@dfreedman7) September 12, 2021
And:
Tracy Hoeg is very open that she does not want her two preteen boys vaxxed (or masked, for that matter). I wouldn’t be surprised if talk of mandates pushed her to go on the offensive with this exercise in confirmation bias.
— BadgerChick (@billbadgerchick) September 11, 2021
Did the authors’ biases lead to this analysis? Who knows? I just know that the result is definitely not good, and the involvement of Josh Stevenson in particular makes this whole study very suspect indeed.
In any discussion of using VAERS data for anything, the search strategy is all, because in any epidemiological study case ascertainment is all. Høeg et al. make a big deal about aligning their inclusion criteria “with the CDC working case definition for probable myocarditis” and “same objective findings of cardiac injury used by the CDC to identify probable cases”, but their search strategy is rather broad:
We searched the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) data for females and males ages 12-17 in reports processed from 1/1/2021 through 6/18/2021 with diagnoses of “myocarditis,” “pericarditis,” “myopericarditis” or “chest pain” in the symptom notes and required the term “troponin” in the laboratory data. We defined a CAE using the CDC working case definition for a probable case.[2] Specifically, the symptom of “chest pain” required at least one of the following: diagnosis of myocarditis, peri- or myopericarditis, acute myocardial infarction; elevated troponin; abnormal electrocardiogram (EKG), abnormal echocardiogram (ECHO), or cardiac MRI (cMRI) findings consistent with myocarditis (as defined in Supplement 1). Cases and hospitalizations with an unknown dose number were assigned to dose 1 or dose 2 in the same proportion as the known doses: 15% occurred following dose 1 and 85% occurred following dose 2.
I was also unclear about this:
To compute crude rates per million for doses 1 and 2, our denominators included all children with at least 1 dose of any vaccination and all fully vaccinated children, respectively, as of 6/11/2021[6] to accommodate both reporting lag and a pre-defined 7-day risk window, consistent with the CDC’s analysis.
How can you use all children with at least one dose of any vaccination, given that the only vaccine that a child 12-17 years old can get is the Pfizer vaccine, given that the Moderna vaccine has not been granted an emergency use authorization (EUA) for persons under 18? Also, the Pfizer vaccine wasn’t granted an EUA for the 12-15 year age group until May 10, meaning that any data before that could only apply to 16-17 year olds, who were included in the original Pfizer EUA in December. Thus, for the 12-15 year group, this study only analyzed about five weeks’ worth of data. Surely the analysis could have been carried out to a more recent date, given that VAERS is updated weekly. Moreover, these data all apply largely to before the delta variant took off in the US to become the dominant variant driving infections. Remember, Delta is much more infectious than the original SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, and that changes the equation markedly. In other words, even if these data turn out to be valid (doubtful), they’re already hopelessly out of date.
This method of case ascertainment immediately led to major criticism from pediatricians, and one pediatric cardiologist in particular by the name of Dr. Frank Han:
What is the premise of that article? directly scanning VAERS data will result in capturing more cases of myocarditis, and therefore the "conclusion" that COVID vaccine generates a higher risk of myocarditis than COVID disease. But – cardiologists have diagnostic criteria. #heart
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
Myocarditis is defined by @MayoClinicCV as: "an inflammation of the heart muscle (myocardium). The inflammation can reduce your heart's ability to pump and cause rapid or abnormal heart rhythms (arrhythmias)." Many things can cause myocarditis, and most of these are viruses.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
The most definitive test is always a pathological specimen, but this technique is plagued with false negatives, and the need to involve an interventional cardiologist. It is difficult to justify taking a snippet of a teenager's heart when s/he's recovering nicely.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
This is where Advanced Cardiac Imaging faculty can be useful – we can detect myocarditis by cardiac magnetic resonance imaging, and my wonderful colleagues at @scmrchd are doing just that. This snaps pictures of the heart and shows the inflammation/ injury (with no Xrays).
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
A cardiologist's job is to put all the data together to make a holistic assessment, then give the diagnosis of myocarditis / no myocarditis. We also follow MRIs over time, and the result of that long term followup has resulted in patients recovering https://t.co/X2LA7TGP3j
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
Those who are eligible for vaccination deserve a chance to improve their odds of staying out of the hospital. Yes, kids don't die as much as adults with COVID, but outcomes aren't binary. PICU admit = negative impact on quality of life.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
Remember VAERS is designed as a research hypothesis generating tool, not a diagnostic tool, and most **definitely** not a tool to seek causation. Physician review of VAERS reports really matters. Cardiologists assessing patients for myocarditis using formal criteria matters.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
In the end – vaccination with COVID in those who are eligible trades in a significant risk with a much smaller risk. That's what counts in the end.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
Dr. Han’s account might be anecdotal, but evidence backs it up. Also, in fairness, Dr. Han is describing a specialist’s method of diagnosing myocarditis. In a search strategy, one doesn’t have that luxury. Still, insisting on elevated troponin does strike me as practically guaranteed to overcall cases of myocarditis. For more information, I refer you to this Twitter thread by another pediatric cardiologist, Dr. Jennifer Huang, who acknowledges that the possibility of myocarditis after vaccination is a scary one for parents. (No one, least of all I, claim otherwise. Certainly Dr. Jonathan Howard, who’s written about this extensively on SBM, does not.) She then notes:
While we still don’t know the long term outcomes of post-vaccine myocarditis, we do know that other myocarditis caused by viruses (#1 cause) like Covid can sometimes lead to death or need for heart transplant…
And we haven’t seen that from post-vaccine myocarditis in the US. pic.twitter.com/ok9UHIUyVa
— Jennifer Huang, MD 黃 心 平 🏳️‍🌈 (@drjhuang) September 10, 2021
Those questions aside, Høeg et al. reported this about cardiac adverse events (CAEs) after COVID-19 vaccination from their analysis:
A total of 257 CAEs were identified. Rates per million following dose 2 among males were 162.2 (ages 12-15) and 94.0 (ages 16-17); among females, rates were 13.0 and 13.4 per million, respectively. For boys 12-15 without medical comorbidities receiving their second mRNA vaccination dose, the rate of CAE is 3.7 to 6.1 times higher than their 120-day COVID-19 hospitalization risk as of August 21, 2021 (7-day hospitalizations 1.5/100k population) and 2.6-4.3-fold higher at times of high weekly hospitalization risk (7-day hospitalizations 2.1/100k), such as during January 2021. For boys 16-17 without medical comorbidities, the rate of CAE is currently 2.1 to 3.5 times higher than their 120-day COVID-19 hospitalization risk, and 1.5 to 2.5 times higher at times of high weekly COVID-19 hospitalization.
In the discussion, Høeg et al. add:
Our post-second-dose-vaccination rates of CAE among adolescent boys aged 12-15 was 162.2/million which exceeded the rates reported by the CDC[2,6] by 143-280% (2.4-3.8 times). Among boys age 16-17, our estimate was 94.0/million, 31.5-41% higher than the CDC estimate. For girls 12-15 years old, our rate was 13.0/million, which was 43-100% higher that the CDC’s estimate.[2,6] Among girls 16-17, our estimate was 13.4/million, which was 47-65% higher than the CDC’s estimate.
I wonder why that might be…
In search of an answer, it didn’t take long for people to notice that there are some rather…questionable…cases included in the analysis by Høeg et al., as Dr. Freedman notes about COVID vaccine associated myocarditis (C-VAM):
The authors claim to use the same methodology as the ACIP review but a brief review raises some suspicions. VAERS ID 1345283 describes a teen with chest pain and right axis deviation on EKG. The report states “no clear diagnosis but a suggestion that it sounded clinically like a viral pericarditis”. Right axis deviation is not one of the criteria used by the ACIP to determine cases of myocarditis or pericarditis (see Table 1). This is the problem with just plugging in search terms (“troponin”, “myocarditis”, etc) to VAERS and not thoroughly reviewing cases. As Ryan Marino said, “this is like thinking that a search for ‘gunshots’ on NextDoor is a way to track gun violence”.
The most glaring examples of cases that were not reviewed in detail by Hoeg et al are the cases with a comorbid infection. This represents a significant confounding variable which makes it impossible to discern with such limited data if the myocarditis was due to the vaccine or the intercurrent illness. VAERS ID 1334617 describes a positive SARS-CoV-2 PCR and VAERS ID 1361923 describes a rhinovirus/enterovirus positive PCR. The authors also include a report of a patient with EBV-positive PCR, serologies pending. These cases were likely excluded by ACIP due to these confounders.
There are other notable cases like VAERS ID 1382338 where the patient is described as encephalopathic to the point of needing intubation for airway protection. Is this a case of C-VAM or a viral infection causing both encephalitis and myocardial injury? VAERS ID 1386269 describes a patient with difficulty walking due to neurological weakness. No mention of any cardiac diagnosis. These cases were likely excluded by ACIP due to incomplete information.
On Twitter last night, Max Kennerly looked at even more:
I will grant the authors of the paper ( https://t.co/VS1gCI3Kft ) one thing, they set up a link to make it easy to comb through the VAERS reports included in their analysis: https://t.co/tiy5CDUD7f
So let's take a look at some of them./3
— Max Kennerly (@MaxKennerly) September 13, 2021
VAERS ID 1328253-1. Notice what little information it provides. I've highlighted how, despite two days in the hospital, they never got any information about the vaccination, all of which would've been on the vaccine record card. (Check your own, you'll see.) That's odd./5 pic.twitter.com/DfrHphitOi
— Max Kennerly (@MaxKennerly) September 13, 2021
VAERS ID 1347549-1. Missing vaccination info. Conflicting info on whether hospitalized, or just seen in emergency room. No diagnosis of myocarditis, pericarditis, or myopericarditis. No MRI./7 pic.twitter.com/sFcK6fqhIT
— Max Kennerly (@MaxKennerly) September 13, 2021
The study had 202 hospitalized boys age 12-17 total. Those four I discussed above are 2% of that entire dataset.
They're hardly alone. VAERS 1360831-1 says "myocarditis," but not much else. Doesn't even say which dose of the vaccine it was. No MRI./9 pic.twitter.com/NkUf3LUtbq
— Max Kennerly (@MaxKennerly) September 13, 2021
I didn't review all of the reports, these are from a brief skim of the first three dozen they listed. Point is, VAERS is useful, but it can't do what the authors claim, there's just not enough reliable data to derive incidence rates, much less do a harm-benefit analysis.
/end pic.twitter.com/iPUiV0ENEM
— Max Kennerly (@MaxKennerly) September 13, 2021
In the comments after the preprint, Dr. David Goldberg notes:
Although the scientific question that is being address is an important one, I have concerns about the methodology used to adjudicate the outcome. In similar circumstances (e.g., the FDAs Mini-Sentinel Initiative), complex clinical outcomes like this (e.g., acute liver failure) were adjudicated independently by two experts, with a third person serving to break any ties. That seems not to have been done in this study, as there was only one cardiologist involved. Secondly, the clinical data to adjudicate the outcome of myocarditis seems to be insufficient in many cases. Although one could argue “this is the best data we have” sometimes that is not good enough. When the question is so important and politically charged, incomplete/invalid data is sometimes worse than no data. Unless the authors can have two-party adjudication with record review, and classification using standard techniques (e.g., definite vaccine-induced myocarditis, highly likely, probable, possible, not) then there are major methodological concerns with the outcome, and the overall validity of the study.
In fairness, this sort of analysis is difficult—maybe even impossible—to accomplish using VAERS data. Indeed, it is impossible to accomplish using unadjudicated data from VAERS, as Høeg et al. did. However, I like Dr. Goldberg’s point about how incomplete and invalid data can be worse than no data. Moreover, it is not difficult to see how analyzing adjudicated data, as imperfect as such data also are, would come much closer to this ideal than the analysis by Høeg et al.
The most pertinent question of all, however, comes from Roger Sehault:
Why did you choose to compare vaccine related CAE with COVID hospitalizations? Why not compare Vaccine related CAE with COVID CAE? Are we comparing apples to apples?
Why indeed? I’d also ask another question: Why did the authors not choose to compare vaccine-related hospitalizations (which could be gleaned from VAERS and the vast majority of which in children are for CAEs due to suspected myocarditis) with COVID-related hospitalizations?
Again, as many have pointed out, the clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis is benign, although frequently it does involve an overnight stay (or up to a few days’ stay) in the hospital for cardiac monitoring. Besides comparing apples to oranges, this sort of analysis makes vaccine-associated myocarditis sound more dangerous than the complications of COVID-19 in children. It leaves out important context that, even if its estimate of risk of myocarditis is valid (and, again, remember that VAERS by its very nature cannot provide a good estimate of any given vaccine AE), children are far more likely to die or suffer serious (and possibly life-long) complications from COVID-19. The authors acknowledge this (sort of) in the text of their study, but it’s buried in the discussion, almost as an afterthought. It’s context that is not in the abstract and therefore goes missing from all the news reports and social media posts touting this study as “scientific evidence” that children should not be vaccinated against COVID-19 because the vaccine is supposedly more dangerous than the disease. I will refer you to Jonathan Howard’s recent post in which he lists much of the recent evidence about COVID-19 vaccination in children. Spoiler alert: Although no one should take this potential AE lightly, thus far the short-term data has been consistently favorable for vaccinating individuals in the 12-17 year old age group.
VAERS: Graveyard of epidemiology (with rare exceptions)
The study by Høeg et al. is a striking example of what can happen when doctors wander into an area where they clearly lack basic critical knowledge, even doctors who are not antivaccine. After over 15 years of experience, I now expect antivaxxers to be tripped up dumpster diving in VAERS, but I do not expect it from investigators who are not antivaccine. Mea culpa. I was wrong this time. However this happened, hubris, bias, ideology, or whatever reason, Høeg et al. inadvertently did exactly the same thing antivaxxers have been doing for years: Dumpster diving in VAERS. They used better statistics than the usual antivaxxer, but the end result was the same. They should be embarrassed.
One very critical rule about research utilizing a database is that the investigators should have a strong understanding of its structure, purpose, and weaknesses. It is clear from this paper that Høeg et al. lacked an understanding of the purpose of VAERS, which is not as a database that can accurately estimate the incidence or prevalence of a given AE after vaccination. By its very design it can’t be used to do that, hence all the post-reporting adjudication and curating that go on behind the scenes at the CDC when analyzing VAERS data. The purposes of VAERS are safety signal detection and hypothesis generation. When reports of a certain AE after vaccination reach a certain threshold, there’s a safety signal, which leads the CDC to investigate first the hypothesis that the AE is actually associated with vaccination (this is where the vaccine-autism hypothesis consistently fails) and then, if there is a correlation, whether that correlation could be an indication of causation. Other databases, active surveillance system databases like the VSD and CISA, are required to test these hypotheses, because again – VAERS data are by the design of the database unsuitable for this purpose.
Surprisingly, given that I often disagree with him, one particular cardiologist gets it (mostly) right. After saying what I just said, that VAERS is only good for signal detection, not epidemiology, he notes:
3) Nearly all of the increased risk follows the second dose.
To this extent, this parallels the initial reports from Israel. It also highlights the errors in previous reports in which sex breakdown was not done (eg NEJM).
— Angry Cardiologist (@AngryCardio) September 12, 2021
This is basically where the data appear to be going. There’s a signal. It’s not yet clear how large the risk of myocarditis is in this age group. He also notes:
3) Moreover, I’m not a fan of binning kids as “with comorbidities” and “without comorbidities”. I get the logic—overweight & otherwise sick kids are at higher COVID risk. However, this plays into the idea that some kids’ illness is not as important. A coldly American idea.
— Angry Cardiologist (@AngryCardio) September 12, 2021
In fact, the dead giveaway, the aspect of this study that is the “tell” behind the authors’ purpose is that “apples and oranges” comparison between COVID-19 CAEs and hospitalization rates for COVID-19 itself. I didn’t really go into the analysis in this study of risk based on comorbidities given how the core structure of the study was so badly designed, but he’s also mostly correct about that. I would add, though, that comorbidities are important and do need investigation.
        ◦ I’m sure I will anger some people with my conclusion. I don’t care. It needs to be said. The bottom line is this. This study is a dumpster dive whose only difference from what antivaxxers have been doing with VAERS since before I first started paying attention 17 years ago is that the statistics are better, but that isn’t saying much. However “provaccine” you might be (and I’ll take the investigators’ word that they are, in fact provaccine), when you find yourself doing the sort of poor quality analysis of VAERS data that antivaxxers have been doing at least since 2006, you really need to rethink your approach. Similarly, if you think that a low quality study like this that uses a database for a purpose for which it was never designed is a “bombshell” from a “dream team”, all while demanding ever more rigorous randomized trials for interventions like masking (I’m talking to you, Dr. Prasad), you might want to think about the biases that led you to such inconsistency in your standards of evidence.

The dumpster diving VAERS preprint debacle: How did we get here?
Last week, SBM devoted a lot of digital ink to a poorly done study analyzing the VAERS database for myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination that was widely publicized to imply that the vaccine is more dangerous than the disease. Three out of the four authors should have known better, leading me to ask: How did we get here?
David Gorski on September 20, 2021
Link
Last week, I wrote about a study published as a preprint that I referred to as a “dumpster dive” into the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database. Adding to the criticism were two guest bloggers, Dr. Dan Freedman and pediatric cardiologist Dr. Frank Han, as well as the newest regular blogger, Dr. Jonathan Howard. Given the copious coverage we’ve provided to this one bad preprint, you might wonder, what’s left to say? Quite a bit unfortunately, albeit not so much about the science anymore, given that, between Twitter and SBM bloggers and guest bloggers, the study has been thoroughly deconstructed, with lengthy explanations of why the study’s design was so poor and its conclusions not justified by its data and analysis. Rather, I’ll be discussing what’s been revealed since this preprint was published and the reaction of those supporting its authors, not to mention that one of the authors, Josh Stevenson, had an undisclosed conflict of interest in that he is associated with a COVID-19 minimizing group opposing masks, lockdowns, and vaccine mandates.
There’s a regular segment on The Amber Ruffin Show called “How Did We Get Here?” Now seems as good a time as any for a postmortem on this incident thus far that asks, “How did we get here?” So how did we get here, where normally-respectable physicians teamed up with a COVID-minimizing crank to dumpster dive in the VAERS database and produce a study that seemed almost intended to spread fear of COVID-19 vaccines and discourage mandates for adolescents, particularly adolescent boys?
How we got here, a recap
Before I look into the fallout that helped reveal how we got here, a brief recap is likely required for most readers, who can click on the links above and in this section if they desire more detailed information. Let me just say now that what surprised me more than anything else about the preprint VAERS study is that doctors with training in epidemiology could misunderstand VAERS so badly that they unwittingly carried out the same sort of awful, incompetent VAERS analysis that antivaxxers have been doing for a couple of decades, all in order to produce evidence that suggests that the risk of myocarditis in adolescents due to COVID-19 vaccines makes the risk/benefit equation of the vaccine unfavorable in this age group. VAERS, of course, is a 30-year-old database to which anyone can literally report anything that might be an adverse event after vaccination.
As I like to say, the greatest strength of VAERS is that anyone can report anything to it, but simultaneously the greatest weakness of VAERS is that anyone can report anything to it. This open nature makes VAERS useful as an early reporting system, a “canary in the coal mine”, if you will, that can find safety signals if there are a large number of reports of a particular adverse event after a given vaccine, but to determine if such a safety signal indicates actual correlation that might indicate causation requires other, more rigorously maintained, active surveillance systems such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD). That’s why, at best, VAERS can be hypothesis generating, not hypothesis testing, and it is not suitable for estimating the incidence of an adverse event after vaccination. Indeed, as I said last time, were I a peer reviewer of that study, I’d have been tempted to say that unadjudicated VAERS reports (CDC officials try to verify the reports to determine if they are real and to find more medical information before using them in any analysis) cannot, by the very nature of the VAERS database, be used to do the sort of analysis that its authors (Tracy Beth Høeg, John Mandrola, Allison Krug, and Josh Stevenson) were trying to do, much less to compare the incidence of myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination to hospitalizations due to COVID-19 itself, and that any attempt to use it that way is folly and incompetent science of the worst sort.
Indeed, the open nature of VAERS is why antivaxxers love VAERS so much. Not only can trial lawyers and antivaxxers seeking to sue vaccine manufacturers or to bring claims before the Vaccine Court game VAERS by encouraging reports of “vaccine-induced autism”, but, as a passive reporting system, VAERS has certain biases, including, paradoxically, both underreporting and overreporting of cases depending on the specific adverse event. Longtime regular readers of SBM and my not-so-secret other blog know that what I like to call “dumpster diving” into VAERS is a common technique used by antivaxxers to try to find spurious associations between autism, sudden infant death syndrome, autoimmune diseases, premature ovarian failure and infertility, and basically any other adverse outcome that antivaxxers want to attribute to vaccines. Indeed, the first time I ever encountered this technique was in 2005, and, as I—and others familiar with how antivaxxers have misused VAERS before had been warning before any COVID-19 emergency use authorization (EUA)—had been warning, antivaxxers continue to use VAERS to given the impression that COVID-19 vaccines are causing a “holocaust” of death and depopulation and numerous other harms. Again, the fact that Høeg et al either didn’t know or didn’t care about the limitations of VAERS and how unsuitable it is for the sort of analysis that they carried out, coupled with their inclusion of a COVID-19 minimizing crank, is very troubling.
How we got here, part two: Josh Stevenson
Regular readers might recall that I had no idea who Josh Stevenson was when I wrote my deconstruction of the dumpster diving preprint. Later in the day, after my post had gone live, I added an addendum including a bit of what I had learned about Josh Stevenson, namely that he had listed only Truth in Data, LLC as his affiliation for the preprint and that there was a huge omission, namely that he was a major contributor to Rational Ground, a COVID-19 minimizing website opposed to most public health interventions to mitigate COVID-19, where he is described as:
Josh is a data visualization expert who focuses on creating easy to understand charts and dashboards with data. He is based out of Nashville, where he provides analysis to support local advocacy groups for in-person learning and other rational, data-driven covid policies. His background is in computer systems engineering & consulting, and his Bachelor’s degree is in Audio Engineering.
Yes, this is exactly the sort of expertise one would want to include in a team analyzing unadjudicated VAERS reports, right?
Meanwhile a coauthor of mine, Duke University Professor of Global Health & Public Policy Gavin Yamey pointed out to me:
I was very alarmed to see that Josh Stevenson was an author. He is a member of Rational Ground, one of the most extreme Covid denialist groups in the United States. They harass scientists. He has a smiley face on his Twitter bio. Prof Balloux, I'm so upset to see he was an author
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) September 17, 2021
Many of us here have blocked him (I unblocked him to see if he still is a smiley) & also Rational Ground's leader, Justin Hart. They go after a whole lot of scientists. So unpleasant. If you give them $2,750/mth, you can access their content. Pay up & let me know what you find 😉 pic.twitter.com/qoWZRLvaRi
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) September 17, 2021
Groups like Rational Ground (RG) & their partners (e.g. @ianmSC) have often orchestrated vicious pile-ons against me. Here's one pile-on: I'm called mentally unstable & delusional.
They deny Covid is a problem, deny the science on NPIs, etc. Why was an RG author on that study?? pic.twitter.com/U5NKDQxIrG
— Prof Gavin Yamey @gavinyamey.bsky.social (@GYamey) September 17, 2021
How did we get here? Why was Josh Stevenson an author on this preprint? What is Rational Ground, anyway? And how is Rational Ground’s grift so expensive?
It didn’t take much of a perusal of Rational Ground to find a lot of articles railing about “lockdowns” and opposing mask mandates. Of course, there are rational risk-benefit analyses and economic considerations about the use of “lockdowns” to slow the spread of COVID-19, but Rational Ground is clearly not about that. Rather, it’s about fear mongering. Indeed, sampling of the articles opposing “lockdowns” (which, at least in western democracies are far from complete “lockdowns”) blames them for a veritable panoply of evils, more tuberculosis, deaths from cancer, heart disease, suicides, starvation, childhood deaths, more cases of HIV, child abuse, domestic/sexual abuse, opioid deaths, and much, much more. It’s not just “lockdowns,” either. Basically, Rational Ground paints an entirely dire picture of any sort of public health intervention to slow the spread of COVID-19, particularly mask mandates, for which they have an entire page full of articles opposing masks, falsely claiming that masks don’t have any effect on the spread of COVID-19, and a whole lot of other misinformation about COVID-19, ranging from semi-responsible to pure denialist.
Unsurprisingly, Rational Ground enthusiastically endorsed the Great Barrington Declaration not long after it was published. The Great Barrington Declaration, as you might recall, was a document published nearly a year ago (two months before there was even a vaccine as the Pfizer vaccine wasn’t issued an emergency use approval until two months later!) by a trio of scientists, Dr. Sunetra Gupta of the University of Oxford, Dr. Martin Kulldorff of Harvard and Dr. Jay Bhattacharya of Stanford, that called for the United States and the United Kingdom to end their lockdowns and promotes allowing the virus to spread among young people in order to build herd immunity. At the time, I described it as eugenics, given that its authors advocated “focused protection” of those “vulnerable” to severe disease and death due to COVID-19 (the elderly, those with chronic health conditions that predispose to severe disease, etc.), ignoring that it is impossible to “focus” protection of these people from an infectious disease if that disease is spreading unchecked through the very population with whom they live and who take care of them. In addition, the Great Barrington Declaration was instigated by a right wing libertarian think tank, the American Institute of Economic Research (AIER), which widely promoted it, while its signatories were able to appear on conservative media to promote their message gain access to the highest levels of government in the UK and US, with one of them prominently defending Florida Governor Rick DeSantis and his opposition to mask and vaccine mandates:
This is not the first time billionaires aligned with industry have funded proponents of “herd immunity.” Gupta, along with Harvard University’s Martin Kulldorff and Stanford University’s Jay Bhattacharya, wrote the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), which, in essence, argues that covid-19 should be allowed to spread unchecked through the young and healthy, while keeping those at high risk safe through “focused protection,” which is never clearly defined. This declaration was sponsored by the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER), a libertarian, climate-denialist, free market think tank that receives “a large bulk of its funding from its own investment activities, not least in fossil fuels, energy utilities, tobacco, technology and consumer goods.” The AIER’s American Investment Services Inc. runs a private fund that is valued at $284,492,000, with holdings in a wide range of fossil fuel companies (e.g. Chevron, ExxonMobil) and in the tobacco giant Philip Morris International. The AIER is also part of “a network of organizations funded by Charles Koch—a right-wing billionaire known for promoting climate change denial and opposing regulations on business” and who opposes public health measures to curb the spread of covid-19.
And:
In October 2020, Gupta, Kulldorff, and Bhattacharya met with two of US President Donald Trump’s senior health officials, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar and Scott Atlas. Atlas was at the time on leave from his fellowship at the Hoover Institution, a conservative think tank affiliated with Stanford University. The meeting reportedly led the administration to eagerly embrace the GBD. Nor did the GBD authors limit their efforts to national governments. For example, in March 2021 Florida Governor Ron DeSantis hosted a video roundtable with Atlas, Gupta, Kulldorff, and Bhattacharya, where they expressed opposition to masks, testing and tracing, physical distancing, and mass vaccination. YouTube removed the video “because it included content that contradicts the consensus of local and global health authorities regarding the efficacy of masks to prevent the spread of Covid-19.” GBD authors, predictably, cried, “Censorship!” Bhattacharya continues to advise Governor DeSantis on Florida’s covid-19 policies, including providing legal testimony in support of DeSantis’s ban on mask mandates in public schools.
True, Rational Ground is a relatively small fish in a big pond of groups promoting COVID-19 misinformation, but it’s a nasty one. In particular, Justin Hart is a particularly vile conspiracy theorist spreading the silliest antimask disinformation:
Masks are a petri dish of filth. They are not just a small inconvenience. They are harmful, physically and psychologically. @Rational_Ground @justin_hart @jhaskinscabrera https://t.co/3VLaxgCcdn
— Abir Ballan (@abirballan) June 18, 2021
As well as the “casedemic” conspiracy theory and election fraud conspiracy theories:
Listen to Justin Hart, Patriots!He was right about erection fraud, and he is right about this! pic.twitter.com/FvlNrm45Bj
— TheBaldening (@TheBaldening) June 7, 2021
Here's this supposed data guy writing off 56 positive tests in Ontario, Canada as almost certainly false positives… if he'd click through to the article he would learn that 26 of them were in one school. pic.twitter.com/5hKQasFG6j
— Zach Hensel (@alchemytoday) September 15, 2021
Naturally, when it was pointed out that Josh Stevenson was a coauthor of the preprint and those of us who had been unfamiliar with his activism, a lot of us wondered: How did we get here?
So, @TracyBethHoeg, how could you possibly have been unaware that one of the co-authors of your #VAERS preprint was associated with this group? And how can you continue to associate with such a person? You see why your association with him makes me doubt you and your co-authors? https://t.co/7B5oc1xZBS
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) September 17, 2021
So people asked the lead author, Dr. Høeg, who showed up in the comments of Dr. Freedman’s guest post to deny any knowledge of his association:
Just a bit about Rational Ground, a brief perusal of whose website shows that it's an antimask, anti-"lockdown," anti-vaccine mandate (possibly even antivax) group made up of people with zero expertise in infectious disease, medicine, or epidemiology. https://t.co/DY91gX9UIe
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) September 13, 2021
Even more interestingly, before the publication of the preprint, Mr. Stevenson appeared to have gone through an intentional effort to hide his association with Rational Ground, at least on his social media profiles (he was still listed on the website):
I have this screenshot of his bio from June 16th on my phone. He appears to have removed the RG link recently, because I know I saw it still there within the last couple weeks. He has been an active member of the Hoeg/Krug crew since May. They know. pic.twitter.com/KiplBO5ANq
— Joe Friday (@justthefacts85) September 13, 2021
rationalground accidentally admits what they're doing 🤣 pic.twitter.com/mLAJyT50vO
— Hypoautonomic (@hypoautonomic) September 14, 2021
All of this left me wondering: Were the other three coauthors at least sympathetic to the aims of Rational Ground, or were they “useful idiots” for the antimask crowd? I must admit that it strained credulity (at least mine) that Dr. Høeg did not know Josh Stevenson’s background. Apparently, they go back at least to February, but did Dr. Høeg truly not know about Stevenson’s activism minimizing COVID-19 and opposing masks and public health mandates? Take a look:
Hoeg and Josh Stevenson go back to February 2021.
The thread linked below is where this connection appears to have started.
Krug jumps into the mix with Stevenson around May and gives him a special shout out in June.
2/ https://t.co/OIkaY4CEsb pic.twitter.com/YdEo3lvijG
— Joe Friday (@justthefacts85) September 13, 2021
Josh Stevenson’s one Medium post is really something else.
The authors have knowingly teamed up with a fringe anti-masker here. Hoeg is claiming not to know anything about his connections, while Stevenson himself is quietly cleaning things up.https://t.co/CSJwADMFgQ
4/ pic.twitter.com/y3jUbeDUPv
— Joe Friday (@justthefacts85) September 14, 2021
Out of curiosity, I looked up Allison Krug’s LLC too.
Artemis Biomedical was voluntarily dissolved on September 1, 2021.
Wait, what??
She even reinstated it in January 2021 after it had lapsed.
Seems like a strange thing to do just days after the preprint was released.
6/ pic.twitter.com/gFU2tQRbmq
— Joe Friday (@justthefacts85) September 14, 2021
You be the judge! Maybe Stevenson really did hide his activism. Maybe Dr. Høeg and her coauthors were willfully blind. I don’t know. I just know that it looks…bad, particularly given how there seemed to be a network of media and social media outlets poised to publicize it as evidence that we should not vaccinate, for example:
https://t.co/AeLaL5bKah
— Jenny Warren 💙 (@sopranobunny) September 11, 2021
2/ First off, the prominence of the report in the UK media compared to other studies does smell suspicious.
Not suprised Camilla Turner in Telegraph was one of the first to push it, she's been in touch with UsForThem for over a year pic.twitter.com/aTxdTvmjGQ
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
4/ Onto the authors of it, Hoeg isn't known in UK, contact in US describes her as a small potatoe who has radiply gained a larger platform.
There are questions if her credentials and that of the preprint are being oversoldhttps://t.co/TAi4j7u4x2
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
6/ Funny enough Rational Ground also has Todd Kenyon as a member, who is also on Pandata. pic.twitter.com/j9lDJdDAks
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
8/ Considering how much is clearly wrong with the report, those who came put promoting it hard from the start should have their objectivity questionedhttps://t.co/ALdh8oXhhI
— Karam Bales (@karamballes) September 11, 2021
Meanwhile, COVID-19 minimizer and antivaxxer Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Tweeted out:
When boys and young men are at a higher risk of being hospitalized from side effects of taking the covid vaccine than actually being hospitalized from covid itself, there is every reason to stop the covid vaccine mandates.
Stop the insanity.https://t.co/9HD62jF8cR
— Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸 (@mtgreenee) September 12, 2021
As did “inventer of mRNA vaccines” Robert Malone:
SARS-CoV-2 mRNA Vaccination-Associated Myocarditis in Children Ages 12-17: A Stratified National Database Analysishttps://t.co/mvY9lzyUZi
— Robert W Malone, MD (@RWMaloneMD) September 12, 2021
Interesting indeed.
How we got here, part three: The Medscape report
About a week after the preprint was published, Medscape published a news report about it that was most…revealing. It was by Alicia Ault and titled “COVID Vaccine Preprint Study Prompts Twitter Outrage“. I will admit that I very much hated the headline, as it simply made the incident sound as though it was just another Twitter kerfuffle, but fortunately the article was better and revealed some interesting things. First of all, Drs. Mandrola and Høeg appeared to be backtracking a bit:
Two of the authors, John Mandrola, MD, a cardiac electrophysiologist who is also a columnist for Medscape, and Tracy Beth Hoeg, MD, PhD, an epidemiologist and sports medicine specialist, told Medscape Medical Newsthat their estimates are not definitive, owing to the nature of the VAERS database.
“I want to emphasize that our signal is hypothesis-generating,” said Mandrola. “There’s obviously more research that needs to be done,” he said.
“I don’t think it should be used to establish a for-certain rate,” said Hoeg, about the study. “It’s not a perfect way of establishing what the rate of cardiac adverse events was, but it gives you an estimate, and generally with VAERS, it’s a significant underestimate.”
That last part, of course, is utter nonsense and simply reinforces my impression that none of the authors truly understand VAERS. Yes, it is true that VAERS is a passive reporting system, meaning that it relies on doctors, healthcare workers, and relatives to submit reports, which can lead to underreporting. Certainly, for minor adverse events, the underreporting is likely to be significant. After all, who’s likely to bother reporting, for example, a sore arm, brief fever and chills, or a headache to VAERS? Not very many. In contrast, though, severe adverse events, such as death (or myocarditis, particularly myocarditis requiring hospitalization) are far more likely to be reported—or even overreported, which is why the VAERS team at the CDC doesn’t use unadjudicated VAERS data to estimate the incidence of adverse events after vaccination. They try to adjudicate the data by contacting the person filing the report to verify whether the incident actually happened and trying to obtain clinical data. Then they look at other databases more suitable to the task of determining correlation, frequency, and potentially inferring causation, like the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD). Worse, as we documented on SBM and others did on Twitter, there were a fair number of reports used in the preprint analysis that were…sketchy…at best.
Now here’s what really got my skeptical antennae twitching:
Both Hoeg and Mandrola said their analysis showed enough of a signal that it warranted a rush to publish. “We felt that it was super time-sensitive,” Mandrola said.
“Super time-sensitive”? Why? Why was it “super time-sensitive” that Høeg et al publish their results, some of which we were discussing nearly three months ago in balancing the risks of vaccination against the risk of the virus? Particularly curious is that a common defense of this preprint from its authors and others is that the frequency of myocarditis after vaccination of adolescents was within the range of published results, which is true (albeit at the high end of the range). So, again, what was the rush?
According to Medscape:
Hoeg told Medscape Medical News that the paper went through peer-review at three journals, but was rejected by all three, for reasons that were not made clear.
She and the other authors incorporated the reviewers’ feedback at each turn and included all of their suggestions in the paper that was ultimately uploaded to medRxiv, said Hoeg.
They decided to put it out as a preprint after the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued its data and then a warning on June 25 about myocarditis with use of the Pfizer vaccine in children 12 to 15 years of age.
That was over two months before the preprint was submitted. The authors’ story is just not lining up. Again, what was the rush? The Medscape story wonders, too:
Harlan Krumholz, MD, SM, the Harold H. Hines, Jr. professor of medicine and public health at Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, which oversees medRxiv, tweeted, “Do you get that the discussion about the preprint is exactly the purpose of #preprints. So that way when someone claims something, you can look at the source and experts can comment.”
But Ziaeian tweeted back, “Preprints like this one can be weaponized to stir anti-vaccine lies and damage public health.”
That was Boback Ziaeian, MD, PhD, assistant professor of medicine at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, Los Angeles. Krumholz replied:
Yes, unfortunately these days, almost anything can be weaponized, distorted, misunderstood. #preprint says: further research is warranted. There is no question that this preprint is worthy of deep vetting and discussion. But there is a #preprint artifact to examine.
— Harlan Krumholz (@hmkyale) September 14, 2021
It is true that anything can be (and is being) weaponized, but that doesn’t mean that outlets like medRxiv should make it so easy. From my perspective, Krumholz was being either disingenuous or utterly oblivious, take your pick.
The Medscape article then finished with:
Both Mandrola and Hoeg said they welcomed critiques, but that they felt blindsided by the vehemence of some of the Twitter debate.
“Some of the vitriol was surprising,” Mandrola said. “I kind of have this naïve notion that people would assume that we’re not bad people,” he added.
However, Mandrola is known on Twitter for sometimes being highly critical of other researchers’ work, referring to some studies as “howlers,” and has in the past called out others for citing those papers.
Hoeg said she found critiques about weaknesses in the methods to be helpful. But she said many tweets were “attacking us as people, or not really attacking anything about our study, but just attacking the finding,” which does not help anyone “figure out what we should do about the safety signal or how we can research it further.”
The Tweet:
I wear a mask; I’m not dying on the mask hill. But citing howler studies like the one below does science and science KOLs no favors. Not only is it embarrassing for AG, it’s embarrassing for JAMA. (BTW — you all should be following @mikejohansenmd) https://t.co/xREcQGq50R
— John Mandrola, MD (@drjohnm) October 18, 2020
My goodness, Dr. Mandrola sounded almost like…me, given that I characterize his preprint as a “howler” of a study.
This brings us to the lamentations of certain doctors in the same ideological tent with respect to COVID-19 of how very, very mean critics have supposedly been. Indeed, I found it very interesting how I was so thoroughly criticized for supposedly relying on ad hominems in my post last week, when in fact the original version of the post barely mentioned the authors, other than to lament that they should know better than to have done such a crappy analysis. In fact, I bent over backwards not to engage in ad hominem attacks. Then I learned that Josh Stevenson was a coauthor of the paper, was informed who he was, and then had to add more about him and start asking the other coauthors why they would team up with someone like him.
Enter Dr. Vinay Prasad.
How we got here, part four: Dr. Vinay Prasad and “medical tribalism”
As I noted a week ago, one of the fans of this preprint was Dr. Vinay Prasad. You remember Dr. Prasad, don’t you? First, he was a big fan of the preprint, calling it a “bombshell” by a “dream team” of authors, which made me wonder if he knew who the heck Josh Stevenson was, leading to Dr. Høeg thanking him profusely:
And unfortunately it is likely more frequent than 1/6200 because 1. VAERS typically gives an underestimate and 2. The rate in the FDA report for 16-17 yo boys was 2x higher than ours.
Btw, our entire team has been inspired by your thoughts and analyses, Vinay. Thank you.
— Tracy Høeg, MD, PhD (@TracyBethHoeg) September 9, 2021
You might also recall that Dr. Prasad, someone whom I like to refer to as a rising star in oncology, was someone whose work, prepandemic, met with some approval here at SBM. Then, unfortunately, for whatever reason, Dr Prasad decided that the sort of work we do here at SBM and other doctors and scientists do to combat scientific and medical misinformation was the equivalent of Michael Jordan or LeBron James “dunking on a 7′ hoop”, leading to retorts by Steve Novella and myself, who expressed nothing but disdain for our efforts, seemingly thinking it beneath him to address alternative medicine, antivaccine pseudoscience, and the like. Ironically, if there’s anything that the COVID-19 pandemic has shown us, it’s just how dangerous the sort of medical misinformation that we at SBM have long combatted actually is.
In any event, Dr. Prasad used his outlet at Medscape to weigh in on the preprint and the reaction to it in an article titled “Vaccine Tribalism Is Poisoning Progress on COVID Science“. Oh, dear. It turns out that Dr. Prasad, in an utterly unsurprising twist, views critics of the preprint as the problem, not those who wrote the preprint, and reveled in the publicity. He begins with an astounding contortion of “bothsidesism”:
As I look across social media, I am concerned. Clearly there is a small, but vocal minority of people who are critical — often irrationally so — of vaccination. They are wrong. But, what I see more and more, among the ranks of physicians and other professionals, is a growing minority on the other end of the spectrum. These are people who are quick to label legitimate scientific dialog as “anti-vax” or “dangerous misinformation.” In many cases, the speakers have little knowledge of the issues themselves. They couple this condemnation with a strong sense that they are “morally” correct, working to purge the world of dangerous anti-vax thinking. Ironically, they are further polarizing an already polarized debate, and worse, they are simply wrong. These are real and live issues. Intelligent scientists have to discuss these policy implications openly. The stakes could not be higher.
As we continue to investigate unanswered questions during this unprecedented pandemic, the tribalism and polarization must end. Simply raising questions about the vaccines isn’t anti-vax, so let’s not label it as such. Instead, we need to welcome new questions and invite ongoing, open discussions from medical professionals. If not, we risk poisoning progress.
How “reasonable.” How “measured.” How utterly ignorant of the history of the antivaccine movement. Even more unsurprisingly, after citing some studies, Dr. Prasad pivots to point to the reaction to the preprint as an example of exactly what he’s talking about:
But on social media, the calls against the authors came vociferously, passionately, and very nearly constantly. Many were skeptical of the study being based on VAERS data, which is self-reported. And, I agree that generally VAERS data is unsuited to draw conclusions about the frequency of adverse events. But there are several unique features here: the authors reviewed all cases by hand, using the expertise of a cardiologist; many cases had features that were challenging for alternative explanations; and finally, the authors acknowledged many limitations in the paper and provided the primary source data for others to code differently in a convenient app. All that said, I am sure there are persistent errors in the paper, both of inclusion and exclusion, and others may wish to make different external comparisons. The paper is not perfect, but it offers something, even if it’s not the end of the story.
It is indeed highly amusing to me to observe how quickly the eminent Dr. Prasad went so quickly from praising a “bombshell” paper by a “dream team” of investigators to describing it as “not perfect” and likely still containing “persistent errors” that lead others to want to make “different external comparisons”. (One wonders how rapidly that Tweet of his will go down the memory hole.) Of course, critics of the preprint pointed out how none of the “unique features” cited by Dr. Prasad redeems the analysis in the least.
None of that stopped the so-much-more-rational-than-us Dr. Prasad from characterizing this as “medical tribalism” that poisons everything:
The “tribe” of med-Twitter that had existed before was fractured. Many felt that dogged an unyielding devotion to vaccines (i.e., two mRNA doses has to be good for everyone, everyone must get a booster ASAP) was synonymous with being pro-vaccine, and anti-pandemic. One driving factor has been a new entrant into previously academic debates: the public. As medical and research discussions have increasingly become part of the mainstream during COVID-19, many doctors have been labeled as anti-vaxxers or COVID-deniers because the public will take their questioning of the science and treat it as fact. While I understand the desire to prevent this, we can’t neglect the fact that an ongoing and careful reconsideration of harms and benefits is often warranted in this complex and constantly changing pandemic. What works for an 80-year-old might not be right for a 16-year-old boy. Log fold risk by age is not intuitive, not fully processed, nor understood. A tribe that developed a policy platform over years was unable to handle a scientific moment that twisted and fractured the usual rules, especially as the public entered the debates.
The funny thing is, it’s not the pro-vax “tribe” that lacks nuance. Sure, there are occasional members who do. Vaccine advocates are human, and there will always be a range of behaviors, from civil to overly vociferous. Overall, though, it is the vaccine advocate side that has been discussing how to promote vaccination and problems with various vaccines with far more “nuance” than Dr. Prasad or the authors of this study.
In fact, I’d go so far as to say that it’s not the “nuance” brought by Dr. Prasad, the authors of this preprint, and others that vaccine advocates criticize. It’s the antivaccine talking points that these physicians and scientists parrot, I’ll assume unknowingly. Indeed, Dr. Prasad’s entire article is basically a retread of an antivaccine talking point frequently inadvertently parroted by people who view themselves as so very “reasonable” and “nuanced” that I’ve dealt with more times than I can remember, portraying vaccine advocates as unreasonable, frenzied, self-righteous zealots who engage in “vaccine exceptionalism” and “bully” parents to vaccinate and turn well baby visits into “battlefields“. Meanwhile, if these “nuance-lovers” mention it at all, they only mention in passing how “tribal” those whose talking points they sometimes parrot go. Indeed, antivaxers are quite enamored of Holocaust analogies, either with vaccines causing a Holocaust or laws requiring children to be vaccinated before they can attend school being likened to Nazi-ism.
It is also very much amazing to me how utterly clueless and oblivious Dr. Prasad is to how the work of these scientists whom he praises is used. In fairness, it is definitely true that it is impossible to control how one’s work is used once it’s published, but let’s step back a minute and look at the whole picture. The preprint study’s authors admitted that their manuscript was rejected by three different journals. In the Medscape story, Dr. Høeg claims it was for “unclear reasons,” but I have a hard time believing that, unless the editors of all three journals “triaged” their manuscript, declining to send it out for peer review because they deemed unsuitable. If any or all of the journals sent the manuscript out for peer review, the authors would have received detailed critiques from at least two peer reviewers from each journal. The authors know that. Dr. Prasad knows that. In fact, the authors even admitted it in the Medscape report. Høeg outright stated that she and her coauthors had incorporated critiques from peer reviewers into the version of the manuscript that they published as a preprint! (I can’t help but observe that, if this version has been “improved” by addressing reviewer comments, I’d hate to see the first version of the manuscript.) In light of that history, publishing the manuscript as a preprint reeks of bypassing peer review to put the study’s conclusions before the general public, having failed to produce an article that could pass peer review.
But none of that stops Dr. Prasad from parroting another favorite antivaccine talking point, again I’ll assume unknowingly:
Many of these commenters need to be honest and appraise their own skill set. Are you capable and do you have experience quantifying rare harms? Are you certain that the federal agencies tasked with this appraisal — the same agencies that have made colossal errors — are not making errors here? For most people on Twitter, the best way to be a science communicator is to sit this one out. When used correctly, science is the greatest lighthouse for human endeavors, but if misused, science has led to some of the greatest errors in our history.
Demonizing people interested in better characterizing vaccine safety signals is not pro-vax; it is pro-ignorance and anti-science. Vaccine tribalism is poison.
I’d ask Dr. Prasad the same questions. What he’s engaging in is pure credentialism. Of course, on paper I appear not to have the “credentials” to criticize Høeg et al. However, that leaves out the 16 years of practical experience I have deconstructing dumpster diving VAERS studies carried out by those with an antivaccine agenda, experience that armed me with the knowledge to know immediately that Høeg et al were doing the same thing and falling into the same trap of using VAERS data inappropriately to estimate the frequency of an adverse event. Dr. Prasad, for all his “credentials,” was utterly unaware of that history, what VAERS is, and how it has been misused. How else could he have so risibly characterized the study a “bombshell” by a “dream team of authors”?
How we got here, conclusion
The publication of this preprint, the reaction to it, and the defense of its authors by a certain contingent of medical social media combine to create a depressing affair. How did we get here? Allow me to speculate. First, we got here because of an unholy alliance between antivaxxers, the resistance to public health interventions, conspiracy theorists like QAnon believers, and political actors backed by industry to promote COVID-19 misinformation in order to stoke resistance to masks, “lockdowns,” and now even vaccine mandates. Am I saying that Dr. Prasad and Høeg et al. are conspiracy theorists? Of course not. What I am saying is that there is a contingent in medicine (most of medicine) that has been utterly unaware and unconcerned about medical misinformation, some (like Dr. Prasad) even going so far as to express contempt for efforts to address this misinformation as beneath them.
This is not a new problem, and one “good” effect of the pandemic is that it’s forced a number of my colleagues who had been oblivious to the power of quackery, antivaccine conspiracy theories, and health misinformation to have their noses rubbed in it to the extent that they have to admit that I had a point all those year. Unfortunately, there remains a contingent of doctors who view themselves as so much more “reasonable” than those awful vaccine advocates, as so much more capable of “nuance,” to whom part of the message of conspiracy theorists resonates because they themselves are resistant to, for instance, government health mandates and view themselves as apostles of evidence and science. Dr. Prasad, for instance, was well known before the pandemic for (correctly) railing against weak science, and yet that didn’t stop him from initially characterizing Høeg et al. as a “bombshell” by a “dream team”. I know I keep repeating that, but it can’t be repeated too often, given Dr. Prasad’s long-expressed contempt for “debunking” antivaccine pseudoscience.
This can lead to really bizarre incidents, such as a formerly reasonable thoracic surgeon not minding Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. representing his writing as part of Children’s Health Defense or Monica Gandhi liking Tweets by rabid antivaxxers like Rob Schneider because antivaxxers share their disdain of big pharma:
ID doc likes anti-vaxxer QT of politician claiming pharma = fraud: Twitter. pic.twitter.com/vgyHZPftfD
— 🩸Matthew J Brunner🩸 (@mattjbrunner) September 19, 2021
We saw the same phenomenon with Peter Gøtzsche before the pandemic, a phenomenon that has become depressingly common during the pandemic, with embarrassing results.
Meanwhile, I can’t help but point out that at least two of us at SBM are not as zealous as Dr. Prasad seems to think. Indeed, back in January, when there were a few insinuating that he was antivaccine, Jonathan Howard and I both pushed back and defended him, in spite of our strong disagreements with him on vaccines and other topics:
Agreed. Even at my most critical of him, I never thought Dr. Prasad was even slightly antivaccine.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 28, 2021
        ◦ I rather suspect that these doctors’ self-image as being so much more “reasonable” and “nuanced” than everyone else, combined with the ego massage that they get from expressing “contrarian” views about COVID-19, is what leads them astray. Tribalism can certainly be a problem, particularly when one “tribe” doesn’t recognize that it is just as liable to fall prey to “tribalism” as any other human being and believes its “tribe” to be so much more “reasonable” and “nuanced” than any other. The result is often anything but reasonable or nuanced, and that appears to be what has happened in the sad debacle of the VAERS preprint, in which contrarians team up with a COVID-19-minimizing activist to produce an poorly done dumpster dive into VAERS that was immediately seized on by antivaxxers and antimaskers as evidence that vaccinating adolescents against COVID-19 is more dangerous than the disease.

More Thoughts on the VAERS Pre-Print
A recent pre-print inappropriately used VAERS to calculated the rate of myocarditis after the COVID-19 vaccine. However, even if the rate was correct, the article glosses over the dangers of the virus and the efficacy of the vaccine.
Jonathan Howard on September 16, 2021
Link

As I wrote previously, there are three important questions when discussing COVID-19 Vaccine-Associated Myocarditis (C-VAM):
    • How frequently does it occur?
    • What are the clinical outcomes?
    • How does this risk compare to that of the virus?
A recent pre-print by Dr. Tracy Hoeg et al. sought to answer some of these questions. Drs. Daniel Freedman and David Gorski recently discussed the problems with using Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) to determine the rate of C-VAM. Please read their articles if you have not done so already. I was pleased to see in the comments section of these articles and on social media that Dr. Hoeg and her co-authors are taking these criticisms seriously. In this spirit, I would like to offer several additional critiques.
COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis: The frequency
In addition to the criticisms of Drs. Freedman and Gorski, I would add that Dr. Hoeg’s paper does not mention any of the studies using the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD). The VSD is an active monitoring system that is directly linked to patients’ medical records. As such, it is not subject to the same limitations as VAERS, a passive monitoring system that contains unverified and possibly duplicate cases. As such, I feel their paper would be strengthened if it mentioned two studies that made use of this database.
    • The CDC’s VSD report found the rate of myocarditis/pericarditis was 1 in 27,000 for children ages 12-17 years. If we assume that all cases occurred in boys, this yields a rate of 1 in 13,500.
    • A study of 6.2 million individuals using safety surveillance data from VSD found a rate of 6.3 additional myocarditis cases per million doses during the first week after vaccination in people age 12-39 years old. Since almost all cases were in males, this translates to a rate of 1 in 79,000 for males in this age group.
COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocarditis: Clinical outcomes
While the precise frequency of C-VAM in adolescents remains unclear, there is universal agreement from multiple sources that the clinical course is very favorable in the short-term. Dr. Hoeg’s paper states “the clinical course was reported to be relatively benign” and several case series are used to support this claim. I’m glad Dr. Hoeg included this information. I would add that the CDC has provided updated information from VAERS to the data presented in Dr. Hoeg’s paper, and this data continues to be generally reassuring. Unlike Dr. Hoeg’s team, the CDC reviewed the medical record of cases submitted to VAERS. In their most recent report, 701 out of 742 cases were admitted to the hospital. At the time of their report, all but 18 had been discharged home and 5 of these were in the ICU. Typically affected individuals are placed in the ICU for monitoring, and no affected adolescents have needed life support as far as I know. 77% had no symptoms at the time of the report.
Beyond this, multiple other sources, provided below, support the claim that C-VAM has a favorable short-term prognosis. I suggest that Dr. Hoeg include these in the references.
    • The CDC’s VSD report gave information on 56 individuals, and all had been discharged home from the hospital, most after 1-2 days. 24 individuals were followed at least 7 days after discharge, and of these 6 still had at least one symptom.
    • In the study of 6.2 million individuals using safety surveillance data from VSD, “82% were hospitalized (median length of stay, 1 day), and nearly all were recovered at record review”.
    • “Patients resolved their symptoms rapidly”. (Marshall et al.)
    • “Hospital course is mild with quick clinical recovery and excellent short-term outcomes”. (Jain et al.)
    • The clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis-like illness appears favorable, with resolution of symptoms in all patients”. (Rosner et al.)
    • “The clinical course was mild in all six patients”. (Mouch et al.)
    • “All patients in our series remained clinically stable during a relatively short inpatient hospital stay”. (Patel et al.)
    • “All patients had resolution of their chest pain, were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, and were alive with preserved left ventricular ejection fraction at last contact”. (Larson et al.)
    • According to reports from Israel, “Most cases have been in the hospital for up to 4 days, and 95% are considered to be mild cases”.
    • According to reports from Ontario, “Most cases appear to be mild and respond well to conservative treatment (e.g. non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs) and rest”.
Pediatricians who have treated these patients voice similar sentiments. Dr. Grace Lee, a pediatrician at Stanford, said, “This is not like any myocarditis I’m used to seeing”. Dr. Sallie Permar, the chair of pediatrics at Weill Cornell Medicine and New York–Presbyterian Komansky Children’s Hospital, said children are being hospitalized “because we wanted to monitor them, out of an abundance of caution…Even the kids are asking, ‘Why am I going to the hospital?'” Dr. James de Lemos, a professor of medicine, said, “They’ve all done well” and all recovered clinically after spending “just a couple of days” in the hospital. Dr. Pei-Ni Jone, a pediatric cardiologist, said, “The good news is, all these children recovered”.
Despite these positive reports, affected individuals felt unwell, with chest pain and often shortness of breath. To varying degrees, they have all had markers of cardiac injury. They will have to be monitored over the long-term for myocardial scarring, as this may pose a risk for future cardiac dysfunction. Additionally, they are advised to avoid physical activity for several months. As such, the condition should not be minimized.
The virus: Clinical outcomes, hospitalization rates
I found Dr. Hoeg’s discussion of the COVID-19’s harms particularly lacking. I suspect no one will be surprised to learn that I feel the paper understated both the harm of the virus and the efficacy of the vaccine. Several of authors have a history of applying different standards to the virus and the vaccine, in my opinion. One of the authors said that the “young have almost no risk” from the virus, and then later said myocarditis from the vaccine should never be called “mild“. Another suggested that RSV was being misdiagnosed as COVID-19 in hospitalized children, meaning COVID-19 wasn’t really that bad. I’ve written about this several times before. Another of the authors, Josh Stevenson, “is part of Rational Ground, a group that supports the Great Barrington Declaration and is against lockdowns and mask mandates”. The pre-print did not make this fact known. So let me make my bias clear: I expected this paper to understate both the harm of the virus and the efficacy of the vaccine. I feel my expectations were met. Read my criticisms with this in mind.
Dr. Hoeg’s paper compares those hospitalized from the vaccine with those hospitalized from the virus. Following a model used by the CDC, Dr. Hoeg compares hospitalization rates over a 120-day period. But there is nothing magical about 120-days, and zooming out over a longer time frame a bit brings more clarity. As of August 14th, 2021, 1 in 2,000 children in the US had been hospitalized according to the CDC. This means tens of thousands of American children have been hospitalized. Even if 40% of these were due to incidental COVID-19 cases (a complicated topic I discussed here), this rate still exceeds the highest rate of C-VAM in Dr. Hoeg’s study, which was about 1 in 6,200 boys age 12-15 years after the second vaccine dose. At present, an average of 344 children are hospitalized every day with COVID-19 in the US. While the number is decreasing slightly for the first time in a month, this is still well above the previous peak during January 2021.
Moreover, as one critic noted, “the study does not take into account differences in treatment practices when comparing hospitalisation rates between covid-19 infections and myocarditis and pericarditis presenting post-vaccination”. In other words, pediatricians may have different standards when deciding whether to admit a child with COVID-19 compared to a child with C-VAM. It’s conceivable that as pediatricians grow more familiar with C-VAM, they’ll decide that not all children need to be hospitalized.
Importantly, the benefits of the vaccine accrue over time, while its risks are contained within the first week. For this reason, the CDC also calculated the vaccine’s benefit at one-year, not just after 120 days. Unless the vaccine stops being effective at 120-days, a longer time frame provides a more realistic sense of the vaccine’s benefits. I believe Dr. Hoeg’s paper should discuss this further rather than simply note this as a limitation of its methods.
The virus: Clinical outcomes, hospitalization severity
Perhaps most glaringly, Dr. Hoeg’s paper provides no information on the clinical course of children and adolescents hospitalized with COVID-19. As with C-VAM, many children go home after a couple of days, seemingly on the way to full recovery. However, a significant minority are very sick. A CDC report found that:
Among 3,116 hospitalized children and adolescents with COVID-19 during March 1, 2020–June 19, 2021, for whom complete clinical data were available, 827 (26.5%) were admitted to an ICU, 190 (6.1%) required invasive mechanical ventilation, and 21 (0.7%) died. Among 164 hospitalized children and adolescents with COVID-19 during June 20–July 31, 2021, for whom complete clinical data were available, 38 (23.2%) were admitted to an ICU, 16 (9.8%) required invasive mechanical ventilation, and three (1.8%) died.
This just does not happen with the vaccine, though readers of Dr. Hoeg’s paper will remain largely ignorant of this fact. As one pediatric cardiologist said on Twitter,
I have yet to witness (and have asked my colleagues too) one post-vaccine myocarditis child go on life support. Have I heard of post-#COVID19 disease children get on life support, and MISC kids go on life support? Absolutely.
— Frank Han MD 🇺🇦Pediatric/ACHD/GUCH Cardiologist (@han_francis) September 10, 2021
The vaccine can keep children out of the hospital. In the clinical trials of adolescents (here and here) twenty subjects contracted COVID-19, all of them in the placebo group. Dr. Hoeg’s paper should report this. The vaccine is working in the real world. A study by the CDC found that unvaccinated adolescents are hospitalized 10 times more often than vaccinated ones. Dr. Hoeg’s paper should report this finding, which was published after the pre-print was written.
The virus: Clinical outcomes, MIS-C, and myocarditis
Dr. Hoeg’s paper states that in “the US, there have been 4404 multisystem-inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) cases in a population of 74 million”. The current number is 4,661 cases, and this may be a substantial undercount. As Dr. Hoeg showed when calculating the rate of C-VAM, using a denominator other than the entire pediatric population of the US, gives a clearer view of the condition. One study calculated that MIS-C occurs in about 1 in 3,200 children infected with the virus. Again, this is a higher rate than the rate of C-VAM found in Dr. Hoeg’s paper.
Dr. Hoeg’s paper did not mention myocarditis as a complication of MIS-C. However, as I discussed previously, the cardiac complications of MIS-C are frequent and can be severe, including “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Dr. Gautam Singh, chief of pediatric cardiology at Children’s Hospital of Michigan, who authored a study on cardiac dysfunction in children with MIS-C, said, “Almost invariably, half of them required going on mechanical ventilation or a breathing machine, heart-supporting medications.” He added that “When we studied these children and followed them about five to six months (later), we found about 19% to 20% have some involvement of their heart function that was not clinically obvious, but by echocardiographic measurements”. One review found that 6%-14% of children had persistent ventricular dysfunction when they left the hospital. Though more recent studies show that children with MIS-C do well in the long-run, 41 children have died of MIS-C in the US.
The virus can cause myocarditis in children independent of MIS-C. A study by CDC found that 1 in 754 children younger than 16 years with COVID-19 developed myocarditis, while the rate for their uninfected peers was 1 in 28,000. The risk of myocarditis for children under 16 years was therefore 37 times higher for children infected with COVID-19. Dr. Hoeg’s paper does not reference this study. However, it seems reasonable to me that long-term concerns about myocarditis due to the vaccine should also apply to myocarditis due to the virus.
The virus: Clinical outcomes, long-COVID
Dr. Hoeg discusses long-COVID in children by referencing a study that find “1.8% of children with symptomatic COVID-19 experiencing at least one symptom two months after infection compared with 0.9% of negatively”. Other, studies have found a higher rate of prolonged symptoms. One recent study from England found a much higher rate. It also found that infected children were twice as likely as uninfected children to report multiple symptoms such as headache and “unusual tiredness” 15 weeks later. While the exact rate of long-COVID is unknown, given that millions of children have contracted the virus in the US, I can safely say a large number of children felt really sick for several weeks. This is a new virus, and we have to be humble about its potential long-term sequelae.
The virus: Clinical outcomes, deaths
Dr. Hoeg’s paper reports a pediatric mortality rate from England of six per million infections, though no explanation is given as to why this one country is considered an appropriate standard for reference. After all, in less-resource rich countries, children have died in much greater numbers (e.g. Indonesia and Brazil). In the US, where all of the paper’s authors are based, roughly 1 in 50,000 children who contracted COVID-19 have died from it, though the exact fatality rate is unknown. Children clearly die at a very low rate, but given the large number of children who contracted the virus, this translates to a significant number of dead children in my opinion. Around 500 American children have died thus far, and the American Academy of Pediatrics added 102 deaths to their tally since July 29th 2021. I suggest that Dr. Hoeg report these numbers, not just the fatality rate from another country.
About 25% of young people who die have no underlying medical condition (and common conditions such as obesity and asthma are the most common underlying conditions in those who die of COVID-19). As such, most deceased children, even those with an underlying condition, were robbed of many decades of life. Sadly, adolescents who were eligible for the vaccine have died since the vaccine became available to them. (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here).
In contrast, the CDC investigated the deaths of several adolescents and concluded that none were related to the vaccine, though six are still under investigation. Thus far, 8.9 million adolescents have been vaccinated. People should know this.
Conclusion: Assess the risks of the vaccine and the virus
It’s not easy to write about children, COVID-19, and the vaccine. There’s a lot we don’t know, the pandemic is a dynamic, unpredictable target, and new information emerges all the time. Several of the papers I referenced previously came out after Dr. Hoeg’s pre-print. There’s plenty of room for nuance and good-faith disagreement. A healthy teen in Norway does not have the same risk as an obese teen in Florida. A child who recovered from the virus does not have the same risk as one who has never been exposed. Several countries are vaccinating adolescents with just one vaccine dose. This will reduce their risk C-VAM, but will leave them more vulnerable to the virus. This strikes me as an entirely reasonable balance in places where most adults have been vaccinated and the virus isn’t spreading out of control. Soon we will be having a similar discussion for children younger than 12-years.
Determining the best course of action necessitates a thorough and comprehensive review of all available data. The risks of the vaccine shouldn’t be minimized or maximized. The risks of the virus shouldn’t be minimized or maximized. We need to be as clear as possible about the risks we are facing. Though the vast majority of children do well, the virus can be really bad for a small percentage of children. I believe that anyone who writes about COVID-19 and children has an obligation to make this very clear.
        ◦ Dr. Hoeg’s paper does not do this. Even if it nailed the rate of V-CAM, its omissions of key facts means that overall, it obscures more than it clarifies. Dr. Hoeg and her colleagues have repeatedly stated they are pro-vaccine and welcome feedback on their pre-print. As such, I hope that when the final version of their paper is published in a peer-reviewed medical journal, pertinent information will not be omitted. Sadly, even if these omissions are rectified in the final version of their paper (which has already been rejected from three journals), it won’t get nearly the same attention as the pre-print. That cat is out of the bag.

The Vaccine Versus the Virus: An Update
The virus is more dangerous than the vaccine for adolescents and young adults. Pro-vaccine doctors must share this fact.
Jonathan Howard on September 6, 2021
Tweet

Editor’s note:
I decided to take the holiday off. Fortunately, Dr. Howard was eager and itching to go with a post to fill in for me. In fact, Dr. Howard has been such a good and reliable contributor that we decided to make him a regular. He’ll be writing every other Friday, plus other days to fill in when there are gaps and/or he has something to say. We think Dr. Howard has been and will be an excellent addition to our stable of regular bloggers. Please join me in welcoming him aboard!– David Gorski
I previously wrote about vaccine-myocarditis, and as the CDC recently gave new information on both the virus and the vaccine, an update is in order. As a reminder, myocarditis is inflammation of the heart muscle, and pericarditis is inflammation of the pericardium (the outer lining of the heart). It can be caused by a wide variety of infectious agents, toxins, and autoimmune conditions. It typically presents with chest pain and shortness of breath. Patients often have ECG abnormalities and elevated serum troponin levels, which are both markers of cardiac injury. Myocarditis is more common in young men and can be quite serious, even fatal, depending on the underlying cause.
The CDC’s data comes from two vaccine-safety monitoring systems: The Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) and the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD). Each of these two databases has their own strengths and weaknesses. According to the CDC, “VAERS accepts all reports from everyone regardless of the plausibility of the vaccine causing the event or the clinical seriousness of the event”. This makes VAERS useful to rapidly detect potential vaccine side effects that may be rare. But anyone can file a report, and even in the case of well-intentioned reports, it is not possible to establish cause and effect.
VSD surveys nine participating integrated healthcare organizations covering 12 million people. It is a public health surveillance activity that “Monitors a limited set of prespecified vaccine safety outcomes”. It is “Designed to detect statistically significant associations and statistical signals (values above specified statistical thresholds), which do not necessarily indicate a safety problem”. This database is not public as it contains confidential patient information.
There are three important questions. What is the rate of vaccine-induced myocarditis, what are the clinical outcomes, and how does this risk compare to that of the virus?
Vaccine-myocarditis rates
    • The CDC’s VAERS report tallied 1,903 cases of myocarditis and 671 cases of pericarditis in all age groups by August 18th, 2021. The highest myocarditis rate was 1 in 14,000 in males age 16-17 after their second dose of the Pfizer vaccine. The rate was 1 in 23,000 for males age 12-15 and 1 in 27,000 for males age 18-24 years after their second dose of the Pfizer vaccine Interestingly, the myocarditis rate was 1 in 32,000 in males age 16-17 after their second dose of the Moderna vaccine. The myocarditis rate was less than 1 in 100,000 for females at any age.
    • From CDC’s VSD report, the rate of myocarditis or pericarditis was 37 per 1 million children ages 12-17 years. If we assume that all cases occurred in boys, this yields a rate of 1 in 13,500.
    • Another recent study of 6.2 million individuals using safety surveillance data from VSD study identified 34 myocarditis cases in patients 12-39 years old. Among patients 12 to 39 years old, there was a risk of 6.3 additional myocarditis cases per million doses during the first week after vaccination. Since almost all cases were in males, this translates to a rate of 1 in 79,000 for males in this age group. They myocarditis risk was higher with the Moderna vaccine.
    • Data from Ontario showed a rate of 1 in 11,000 for males age 12-17 after their second dose and a rate of 1 in 6,100 for males age 18-24 after their second dose
    • Data from Israel of people older than 16 years showed a rate of 1 in 37,000 people, and the average age was 25-years-old. However, this data was not stratified by age, and so we cannot deduce the rate for young males highest at risk. Israel previously reported a rate of 1 in 3,000-6,000 males ages 16 to 24.
Vaccine-myocarditis outcomes
While there is still uncertainly regarding the frequency of vaccine-myocarditis, outcome data continues to be consistently favorable in the short-term.
    • In the CDC’s VAERS report, 701 out of 742 cases were admitted to the hospital. At the time of the report all but 18 had been discharged home and 5 of these were in the ICU. Typically this is done for monitoring, and no affected adolescents have needed life support as far as I know. 77% had no symptoms at the time of the report.
    • The CDC’s VSD report reported on 56 individuals, and all had been discharged from the hospital usually after 2-3 days. 24 individuals were followed at least 7 days after discharge, and of these 6 still had at least one symptom.
    • In the study of 6.2 million individuals using safety surveillance data from VSD, “82% were hospitalized (median length of stay, 1 day), and nearly all were recovered at record review…These results from our safety surveillance are reassuring,” said lead author Dr. Nicola Klein.
    • According to reports from Israel, “Most cases have been in the hospital for up to 4 days, and 95% are considered to be mild cases.”
    • According to reports from Ontario, “Most cases appear to be mild and respond well to conservative treatment (e.g. non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs) and rest”.
Other cases series report the following:
    • “All patients in this series had a benign course; none required intensive care unit admission”. (Dionne et al)
    • “Patients resolved their symptoms rapidly”. (Marshall et al)
    • “Hospital course is mild with quick clinical recovery and excellent short-term outcomes”. (Jain et al)
    • “All patients received brief supportive care and were recovered or recovering at the time of this report”. (Montgomery et al)
    • The clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis-like illness appears favorable, with resolution of symptoms in all patients”. (Rosner et al)
    • “The clinical course was mild in all six patients”. (Mouch et al)
    • “All patients had resolution of their chest pain, were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, and were alive with preserved left ventricular ejection fraction at last contact”. (Larson et al)
Thus far 8.9 million adolescents have been vaccinated. The CDC investigated the deaths of several adolescents and concluded that they were unrelated to the vaccine, though six are still under investigation. Around the world, news from New Zealand reports the death of one woman due to vaccine-myocarditis and there is a report of a 42-year-old man who developed myocarditis two weeks after vaccination and died.
Almost all myocarditis cases occurred several days after vaccination, and there is no doubt the relationship is causal. Though the short-term outcomes for adolescents seems reassuring so far, individuals with vaccine-myocarditis had chest pain and many had shortness of breath. Though most recovered, about 25% had persistent symptoms at last follow-up. They had markers of cardiac injury and are almost always admitted to the hospital. As myocarditis can cause scarring, the potential for arrhythmias exists later in life and affected individuals will have to be monitored over the long-term. Additionally, affected individuals are advised to avoid strenuous physical activity for several months. As such, vaccine-myocarditis should not be trivialized.
Update on the virus
The virus causes myocarditis at a higher rate than the vaccine for children and young adults. According to a study from the CDC, 1 in 754 children younger than 16-years with COVID-19 were diagnosed with myocarditis, while the rate was 1 in 1,024 for people age 16-24 years. The study found that “The myocarditis risk is 37 times higher for infected children under 16 years and seven times higher for infected people ages 16-39 compared to their uninfected peers”.
Moreover, a total of 4,661 cases of Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C) cases have been reported thus far, and this may be substantial undercount. In one study of 191 children with MIS-C “53% had evidence of myocarditis, 80% were admitted to an intensive care unit and 2 died”. A systematic review of 15 case series/reports found that 75% of children with MIS-C have myocarditis. Complications such as coronary artery aneurysms frequently occur in children with MIS-C. Other studies have reported acute heart failure in children with MIS-C. Other common cardiac complications of myocarditis due to MIS-C include “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Cardiac arrhythmias have led “to hemodynamic collapse and need for ECMO support” in some children. Though 41 children have died in the US from MIS-C, happily, most children seem to do well in the long-term.
Fortunately, the Delta variant does not seem to cause worse outcomes in children. The overwhelming majority of children who get COVID-19 will be fine, thankfully. The CDC found no increase in length of hospital stay or the percentage of hospitalized children admitted to the ICU with the Delta variant. They found that among 3,116 hospitalized children and adolescents with COVID-19 during March 1, 2020–June 19, 2021, 827 (26.5%) were admitted to an ICU, 190 (6.1%) required mechanical ventilation, and 21 (0.7%) died. Among 164 hospitalized children and adolescents with COVID-19 during June 20–July 31, 2021, 38 (23.2%) were admitted to an ICU, 16 (9.8%) required mechanical ventilation, and three (1.8%) died. According the CDC, “The differences in these indicators of severe disease between the two periods were not statistically significant.”
However, because the Delta variant is much more contagious, more children are getting sick now than ever before. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, 203,962 child COVID-19 cases were reported from August 19th to August 26th, 2021. As a result, schools are being forced to close across many parts of the country due to COVID-19 outbreaks (e.g. Kentucky, Florida, Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, Mississippi, Alabama, South Carolina, Tennessee, Missouri, West Virginia).
The CDC found that “Weekly COVID-19–associated hospitalization rates among children and adolescents rose nearly five-fold during late June–mid-August 2021”. Currently, an average of 365 children are being hospitalized every day, more than ever before. In Florida alone, an average of 68 children are going to the hospital every day. The American Academy of Pediatrics added 47 new deaths between August 12th and August 26th, 2021. Sadly, multiple adolescents, including some with no underlying health issues, have died of COVID-19 after the vaccine was available to them (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here).
Almost all countries with abundant supply are vaccinating children older than 12-years. Multiple medical organizations, including the American Heart Association and American Academy of Pediatrics agreed and released a statement supporting the vaccine in adolescents. Their statement said:
The facts are clear: this is an extremely rare side effect, and only an exceedingly small number of people will experience it after vaccination. Importantly, for the young people who do, most cases are mild, and individuals recover often on their own or with minimal treatment. In addition, we know that myocarditis and pericarditis are much more common if you get COVID-19, and the risks to the heart from COVID-19 infection can be more severe.
Since then, evidence has emerged that the vaccine works very well for adolescents. According to the CDC, “Hospitalization rates were approximately 10 times higher in unvaccinated compared with fully vaccinated adolescents, indicating that vaccines were highly effective at preventing serious COVID-19 illness in this age group during a period when the Delta variant predominated”. The CDC estimated that the benefits of vaccination for teenagers and young adults are substantial in preventing infection, hospitalizations, and deaths. Assuredly, schools with more vaccinated students will have an easier time staying open.
The bottom line
This infographic shows quite clearly the impact, and benefits, of COVID-19 vaccines in younger people:
In light of this information, Dr. Tom Shimabukuro, the deputy director of CDC’s Immunization Safety Office said, “COVID-19 vaccines continue to undergo the most intensive safety monitoring in U.S. history. Getting vaccinated remains the best way to protect yourself and your loved ones against a virus that has taken millions of lives.” He’s right.
        ◦ The virus is much more dangerous than the vaccine for adolescents and young adults. Pro-vaccine doctors will share the facts. Anti-vaccine doctors won’t.

COVID Vaccines and Cardiac Effects – Reality vs Lies
COVID mRNA vaccines only result in rare, mild, and transitory myocarditis, but this doesn’t stop misinformation from spreading.
Steven Novella on January 5, 2022
Link

After airing a viral video showing a young athlete unconscious on the field following a cardiac arrest, anti-vaccine crank Del Bigtree asked his viewers, “All of these sports are mandating this vaccine on everybody in order to play, and I can only ask the very simple question, do you ever remember hearing a story of an athlete having a heart attack on the field?” The obvious implication is that this is a new phenomenon, and he is encouraging his audience to make a connection to the COVID vaccines. He also states there is no evidence for a connection, and he can also hide behind the notion that he is “just asking questions”, but the implication is undeniable, and that’s all it takes.
Social media also facilitates compiling and spreading video and audio clips to create what are in essence mini-documentaries, with a specific message apparently supported by the video evidence being presented. These videos, however, may be complete fabrications, all lies and misinformation. That athlete lying on the field, for example, had a cardiac arrest due to a primary cardiac condition having nothing to do with COVID vaccines. We can be highly confident that the vaccine was not involved – because the video is from 2013.
This is now the reality we are living in. Pictures can be used out-of-context to falsely support a narrative. Eventually, they tend to get debunked as “the internet” will generally find the source material and expose the fraud, but by the time this happens the damage is already done. This phenomenon is also not limited to social media – even major news outlets (like Fox News and Newsmax) have been caught red-handed using misleading photos out-of-context. This is combined with opinions presented as facts, or hiding behind posing leading questions without making explicit claims.
This misinformation not only affects people’s behavior, but can affect policy. Anti-vaccine crank Sheri Tenpenny, for example, was invited to give testimony to the Ohio Health Committee in support of a bill essentially banning vaccine mandates. Among the claims she made to the committee was that COVID vaccines “magnetize” people, and offered as evidence misleading videos from the internet.
The science about COVID vaccines and cardiac effects
Meanwhile the reality, slowly documented through careful scientific study, is that the current COVID vaccines are both safe and effective, and the reported cardiac effects are rare, mild, and transient. No one would reasonably argue that vaccines are entirely without side effects. No medical intervention is. They are designed to provoke a specific immune response, which creates the possibility of inflammatory side effects. One such side effect is myocarditis or pericarditis – inflammation of the heart or the lining around the heart, respectively.
According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, myocarditis/pericarditis rates are ≈12.6 cases per million doses of second-dose mRNA vaccine among individuals 12 to 39 years of age. In reported cases, patients with myocarditis invariably presented with chest pain, usually 2 to 3 days after a second dose of mRNA vaccination, and had elevated cardiac troponin levels. ECG was abnormal with ST elevations in most, and cardiac MRI was suggestive of myocarditis in all tested patients.
In almost every case the symptoms were mild and resolved completely, with or without treatment. This is a rare, mild, and transitory side effect, and therefore not a significant phenomenon, and not a reason to avoid the vaccine. Further, when considering any medical intervention we cannot only consider risk, we have to consider risk vs benefit. We know the vaccines are highly effective at preventing severe COVID, and based on that alone the benefits outweigh this tiny risk. However, the benefits are even more direct. COVID-19 itself is much more likely to cause myocarditis that the mRNA vaccines:
After adjusting for patient and hospital characteristics, patients with COVID-19 during March 2020–January 2021 had, on average, 15.7 times the risk for myocarditis compared with those without COVID-19.
This is not uncommon with inflammatory vaccine side effects, they often mimic (but are less severe and less common) complications of the very infection that they prevent. If a vaccine increases the risk of Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS – inflammation of the peripheral nerves) slightly, then it’s a good bet that the illness the vaccine prevents is far more likely to cause GBS itself.
In fact these types of illnesses (including GBS and myocarditis) are often either infectious or post-infectious syndromes. That means they are caused by the inflammation brought about by an active infection, or they are an auto-immune inflammatory response that follows an infection. The post-infectious auto-immune response is often caused by molecular mimicry, which means that an antigen on the infecting organism (virus or bacteria) looks very similar to a self-antigen (on the coating around nerves for GBS or in the heart muscle for myocarditis, for example). The immune system then starts to target the self-antigen, because it looks too much like the viral or bacterial antigen.
This is likely the case with myocarditis following mRNA vaccinations as well. Rare individuals, due to genetic variation, have cardiac self-antigens that are similar to the spike protein targeted by the COVID vaccines. This causes the inflammation provoked by the vaccine to target the heart muscle, causing the myocarditis. But in this case the heart antigen must only be a little similar to the spike protein, because the inflammatory response is mild and transient.
        ◦ The science regarding the mRNA vaccines and myocarditis is reassuring – this is a rare and mild side effect. Meanwhile, COVID is a potentially deadly disease, and is far more likely to produce myocarditis as a side effect that the vaccines that prevent COVID. But of course it takes a lot less mental energy to watch a video online and react with fear, than to wade through the scientific evidence and make an informed risk vs benefit assessment.

Why Can’t We Discuss This Taboo Subject Everyone is Talking About?
Unlike doctors who work with COVID-19 patients, I am not afraid to discuss taboo topics. To find out more, become a member and receive exclusive content.
Jonathan Howard on January 30, 2022
Link

Why is this such a taboo subject?
No one is talking about the risks of over vaccinating young people. This is a taboo subject. To bolster this claim, I present you with an article titled “Should Teen Boys Get Boosted” from The Atlantic, a widely-read international magazine. This article quoted world famous vaccine expert Dr. Paul Offit saying that he did not feel young people benefitted from boosters and that he advised his own son against getting a booster.
You can also learn Dr. Offit’s opinion on this taboo subject in articles titled “Too Much Focus on Boosters, Says FDA Vaccine Advisor“, “Top Doctors Refuse to Give Their Own Kids a Third Shot“, and “A Skeptic’s Case Against Boosting Everyone“. You can read an editorial he wrote in The Washington Post titled “We Don’t Need Universal Booster shots. We Need to Reach the Unvaccinated“. He shared his thoughts on this taboo subject on ZDoggMd’s large podcast, twice (here and here). Dr. Offit’s thoughts about this taboo subject, as well as his strong support for the first two vaccine doses, were even discussed right here on Science Based Medicine.
Some smart people agree with Dr. Offit about this taboo subject and have expressed their views publicly. World Health Organization Chief Scientist, Dr. Soumya Swaminathan, recently broached this taboo subject, saying “there’s no evidence right now” that suggests healthy children and adolescents need booster shots. Dr. Amesh Adalja, of Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health said “I don’t think there’s any strong evidence that we’ve seen waning immunity in teenagers, especially against what matters – serious disease”. Dr. Walid Gellad, a drug policy researcher at the University of Pittsburgh, also said “We need to be very certain about benefits because the risks remain uncertain. I am not sure that we know enough about the benefits or the risks to clearly say the benefits outweigh the risks”.
These people all take issue with the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, which voted 13-to-1 to approve the third shot. You can watch their 4-hour meeting where the risks and benefits of this taboo topic were extensively discussed in public. If you just want to review their slides on this taboo subject, you can do so here. Since this subject is taboo, myocarditis was only mentioned 62 times.
Even though the risk of over-vaccinating young people is a taboo subject, the stakes could not be higher. According to data from the VAERS, in just under 1 million people age 16-24 years who received a booster, there were 4 confirmed myocarditis cases, all recovered, with 9 cases still under review. Moreover, researchers on vaccine-related myocarditis say that while long-term monitoring is needed, “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly”.
Meanwhile, consider that 764 children are being hospitalized with COVID-19 every day. This is not a taboo subject. Newspapers were bursting with headlines of a record number of children being hospitalized this winter, most of them unvaccinated. In New York’s recent omicron wave, of the children recently-admitted to hospitals “91% of 5 – 11-year-olds were unvaccinated and only 4% were fully vaccinated. Among 12-17-year-olds, 65% were unvaccinated while 26% were fully vaccinated”. You never read any articles about hospitals being deluged with vaccine-injured children did you? That’s because this is a taboo subject.
COVID-19 vaccines & kids: Why are officials not discussing the myocarditis risk?
To learn more about boosters in children, you can also listen to this podcast with Drs. Marty Makary, Zubin Damania, and Monica Gandhi. They’ve been reliable, trustworthy guides this pandemic, repeatedly telling us that it’s over, for real this time. They are careful to avoid the tribalism and groupthink that plague other doctors. For example, even though not a single child in the entire world is known to have died from the vaccine, and healthy children have definitely died from the virus, Dr. Makary said on this podcast, “maybe the rate of death from the vaccine parallels the rate of death from COVID in a healthy child”. You won’t get that sort of nuance from vaccine-absolutists, and their slavish devotion to “facts“.
In a segment called “COVID-19 Vaccines & Kids: Why Are Officials Not Discussing the Myocarditis Risk“, podcast listeners also heard that:
It’s impossible to have the discussion, if you are coming at it from the advocacy point of view, that there might be a risk associated with the vaccine…In a moment we are going to talk about myocarditis with Moderna, nobody wants to talk about that.
That’s right! The entire topic of vaccine myocarditis is taboo. Who has talked about it besides me and my guests? No one. Unlike doctors who work with hospitalized COVID-19 patients, I am not afraid to discuss taboo topics. Whether it’s accurate or not, I’ll share the information “they” don’t want you to know about.
        ◦ To find out more, become a member and receive exclusive content.

That latest article on the post vaccine myocarditis autopsy analysis
The autopsy report for two teens who allegedly died of vaccine myocarditis was released this week. What are the implications for vaccinating children and adolescents?
Frank Han on February 19, 2022
Link

An important article just came out on Valentine’s Day describing the autopsy results of two people who apparently died of post-vaccine myocarditis. First off, I most certainly think that these two deaths were tragic, and second, I call for calm in light of the publication of this article. I would like to take some time to explain the nature of the analysis presented in this article – which is generally intended for healthcare workers to figure out why COVID vaccine associated myocarditis is happening.
The authors form a collaboration between the Connecticut State Medical Examiner’s office and several universities, and they analyzed two hearts of two teenagers who were found deceased 3 and 4 days after COVID vaccination. The cardiology community would have loved to have these analyses earlier in the rollout of COVID vaccination, but due to the limitations of federal law (HIPAA), the desires of families, the lack of resources, and the actual absence of real pathologists in some medical examiner offices, only very few autopsy reports are available for public viewing. The shortage of board certified pathologists is a very serious issue that deserves its own article, but let us focus on myocarditis here.
What can cause myocarditis?
The causes of myocarditis are quite numerous, and here is a partial list:
    • Viruses
    • Parasites
    • Bacteria
    • Fungi
    • Protozoa
    • Toxins
    • Pharmaceutical and illegal drugs
    • Immunological issues
What did the authors do?
What the research group in question did was to examine the hearts by eye, by some basic testing, and by microscopy slides. One boy was normal weight and the other was obese, and the heart of the first boy was of normal size and overall appearance. The heart of the second boy was quite large and dilated, which is a red flag to the cardiologist that something happened long before the present time. Why long before? As discussed in the definitive text on heart disease in infants, children, and adolescents, myocarditis is not capable of either causing substantial hypertrophy or dilation in a few days or weeks.
The team reported that the boys had no obvious symptoms and then were found deceased. While there are mechanisms by which this may happen, professional cardiologists know that this statement by itself is not sufficient evidence to guarantee that the myocarditis indeed was the cause of their demise. More information is needed, such as an overnight EKG documenting an arrhythmia. An example of a situation where there is enough proof to definitively state the cause of cardiac arrest, is commotio cordis, where a baseball player is hit by a baseball on his or her chest specifically near the heart, and ventricular fibrillation is documented.

The next part of the analysis was microscopic, and neither child had evidence of prior COVID infection by PCR. With the first child, there were findings of perivascular inflammation, scarring, and neutrophils with histiocytes. He also received molecular testing revealing two genetic mutations of unknown significance. The second child had similar cellular findings, which did support the cellular diagnosis of myocarditis in both cases. The authors then concluded that a “stress cardiomyopathy” was likely present in these children based upon the specific pattern of injury. They also mentioned that the cellular findings of myocarditis in these cases were unusual if compared to classical biopsy findings of myocarditis.
At this point things get more controversial. The rest of this analysis (up to the action plan) will mostly be my editorializing based upon what I know about cardiology. An optimal use of this report is to perhaps give ideas to future investigators to eventually get us to a molecular mechanism and more definitive answer. The slides presented in the report do not by themselves conclusively identify COVID vaccine myocarditis as the cause of the myocarditis. The bottom line of the next few paragraphs is that I would love for there to be a complete analysis but time and resources sometimes do not permit it.
Takotsubo cardiomyopathy
Stress cardiomyopathy is something readers may have heard of referred to as Takotsubo cardiomyopathy; this word is a reference to the Japanese octopus trap that resembles the shape of the heart in this disorder.

What you see is that the pointy part of the heart’s left ventricle balloons out and contracts poorly; this is classically seen after major life stressors. Takotsubo cardiomyopathy normally occurs in much older adults, and women more than men. While it is possible this is catecholamine-induced, what the general public might not know is that we give catecholamines such as epinephrine to heart surgery patients nearly all the time to support heart function, sometimes for several days, and the recipients do not all go on to develop stress cardiomyopathy. This explanation by itself should not account for the findings shown.
Next, dilated ventricles and extensive fibrosis do not develop in a few days. These problems are usually the result of weeks or months of the heart trying to heal after being damaged by some previous abnormal process. Fibrosis just means tissue replacement (in this case heart muscle) with scar tissue that cannot contract and therefore cannot help pump blood. That process could be a genetic cardiomyopathy, myocarditis, or some other process entirely such as an inborn error of metabolism. There’s also many viruses that could have been bad actors here. Any of these processes could have caused a fatal heart rhythm problem that ultimately killed these children. None of these processes require vaccinations to take place.
They mention genetic tests of unknown significance. Gene tests are done to see if a mutation in DNA was responsible for a problematic heart; the classic example that most people know about is hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. This means that a gene mutation has caused the heart to become abnormally thick. A gene mutation was picked up on the first teen (whose heart appeared normal) but not the second (whose heart was large and dilated). The gene mutations described in the first teen were present but not well-studied enough to know what they mean, otherwise known as variants of unknown significance. This happens all the time in pediatric cardiology when we are asked to sort out why a child has a large and poorly functioning heart. We do sometimes get normal gene tests in clearly malfunctioning hearts (where more in-depth whole exome sequencing may be needed). Indeed, one of the very common ways that children come to us as pediatric cardiologists for diagnosis is via minding their own business and discovering some potentially heart-related symptoms. The diagnosis may be subtle, and these two decedents have no prior medical records for us to review publicly. It is very common for dilated cardiomyopathy and myocarditis to have minimal symptoms or no symptoms at all in children until the heart starts having trouble meeting daily needs. Genetic testing to figure out why a bad heart is a bad heart is…complicated.
The authors specifically do not mention an analysis of the conduction system; this could have provided valuable insight as to the cause of any potential end-stage heart rhythm disorder.
An immunofluorescence assay paired with some blood analyses of frozen samples could have advanced our understanding of this disorder quite substantially, but they are not reported here. Immunofluorescence is the science of detecting specific cell types and proteins using certain molecules that glow in the dark. Unfortunately, they are rather expensive and only certain hospitals have the capability to run these.
For all these reasons, reporting to the public that these children definitely died of postvaccine myocarditis is not entirely supported by the data. More analysis is necessary. Cardiomyopathies of other types could still have accounted for the pathological findings above. It is not yet possible to make sweeping conclusions based upon this paper alone, rather, this should serve as a stepping stone for other investigators to perform more in-depth analyses.
What should we do next?
Based on the knowledge added by these two deaths, what are our options and recommendations for COVID-19 vaccinations and treatment? Based on medium-to-high certainty evidence, my opinions are:
    • It is unwise to withhold vaccination just because one is afraid of the side effects, especially for those who have never been diagnosed with COVID-19; getting entirely unvaccinated people to their first vaccination should be a global priority. In locations that have high SARS-CoV-2 transmission, boosting should also be emphasized. Vaccination gives you a better chance of getting only mild COVID disease. Dying is not the only nasty outcome of COVID (even in kids). People with comorbidities do indeed fare poorly, but even people with minimal comorbidities can get ill, as is being more frequently demonstrated with long COVID.
    • Virus-derived immunity in the absence of vaccination is irregular and sometimes not helpful at all. The COVID omicron variant has quite substantial immune escape. At bare minimum, those who are unvaccinated and recovered from COVID should consider the benefits of hybrid immunity (getting vaccinated at least once after SARS-CoV-2 infection).
    • Nonpharmaceutical interventions remain important (ventilation, masks, handwashing, etc.).
    • Paxlovid is just now starting to be available, but distribution and scarcity remain and issue.
    • The highest risk groups for postvaccine myocarditis are older teen boys and young men, especially in the 1st week after each dose. However, it is not necessary to be frightened of myocarditis (and especially no reason to be frightened of pericarditis). Three potential methods for decreasing risk exist:
        ◦ spacing out the first two doses by at least 8 weeks
        ◦ using Pfizer instead of Moderna for the people younger than 40 (those younger than 5 years and older than 40 have a substantially lower risk of myocarditis)
        ◦ use a protein subunit vaccination if your country makes these available (Novavax, Soberana, but the most effective vaccine is the one you can access most easily)
    • The symptoms of myocarditis are a mixture or subset of chest pain, dizziness, palpitations, abdominal pain, fatigue, exercise intolerance, fever, and shortness of breath within the first week after vaccination. If a family member has these symptoms they should immediately seek out medical care.
At the point the real cause of postvaccine myocarditis remains unknown, but the immunology community has a few working ideas. While the cause is unknown, the majority of these patients who sustain post-vaccine myocarditis do well, and the treatment regimens for myocarditis have an extremely long track record of safety. Greater collaboration between immunologists, cardiologists, and pathologists could help us get some definitive answers on why this happens and how to decrease the risk in future mRNA vaccination technologies (of which many clinical trials are currently being conducted for other diseases).

COVID-19 vaccination and myocarditis: another preprint
A preprint from Thailand gives us more information about vaccine-associated myocarditis in younger people, but should not be weaponized by antivaccine activists as a reason to avoid vaccination against COVID-19.
Frank Han on August 13, 2022
Link

The Department of Clinical Tropical Medicine, Faculty of Tropical Medicine, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand, published a preprint on COVID vaccination-associated myocarditis recently, whose core strength is its prospective cohort design, one of the only potential analyses of asymptomatic (subclinical) COVID vaccination myocarditis, and close follow-up with vaccination dose #2. While it is a strong effort from a team who had very little time to compile the project, there are multiple actors distorting the cardiac evaluation that was done, which demands immediate discussion from a board-certified pediatric cardiologist – like me.
Methods
COVID vaccination myocarditis, while not being completely solved from a mechanistic standpoint, is a well-known disease process now, mostly associated with the mRNA subtype of COVID vaccinations. The age groups most at risk are older boys and young adult men. The time period of highest risk is after the 2nd dose, hence the effort by many national health agencies like the Canadian NACI, US CDC and British NHS to find ways to raise awareness and decrease the risk of vaccine-associated myocarditis. Hypothesized mechanisms generally fall within the realm of transient autoimmune reactions, such as molecular mimicry, a reaction against the lipid nanoparticle, vesicle trafficking resulting in an immune reaction against distant targets, and potential dendritic cell activity. The goal of the present study was to characterize the incidence of symptomatic and asymptomatic myocarditis in a group of students after they received the 2nd dose of COVID vaccination (this dose was chosen because it is previously known to be the period of highest risk).
The authors of the preprint were able to analyze 301 students ranging from 13-18 years of age, of which two-thirds were boys. They tried to record baseline characteristics of these children including ECG, past medical history, echocardiogram, and physical examination. The team then tried to repeat that assessment at least two points although not all the data at each of these points was displayed in the preprint version of paper.
Results
Of the data displayed to the reader, they indicate that some of the kids met criteria for myocarditis, evidenced by EKG changes, troponin detectable in the blood, and some had cardiac MRI findings consistent with myocarditis. They also report a rate of subclinical myocarditis and a rate of abnormal EKG findings amongst their 301 students. While the MRI findings are rigorous and clearly support the diagnosis of myocarditis in those patients in which it was done, the remainder of the patients EKG findings deserve detailed discussion because characters who wish to maximize fear surrounding myocarditis are hyping the EKG findings with a lack of medical knowledge in regards to their clinical significance. The crowd who believes COVID vaccinations in kids is not necessary is saying that abnormal EKGs by themselves are sufficient to diagnose subclinical myocarditis, which is incorrect. At the most basic level of research analysis, the least one can do is compare EKG findings before and after. While the preprint claims they did this, the EKG findings pre vaccination are not available to the reader. It is difficult to compare the cited rates given in this article with the rates used in the prior population studies due to their different statistical methods, but I wish to strongly emphasize, that articles portraying a high rate of myocarditis are not deserving of hype on that reason alone. I can only hypothesize why the timing of the troponin elevation is only after several days, but this may be due to the amount of time required to generate the immune response. The timings of troponin elevation discussed also mirror what has been discovered in prior projects on vaccination myocarditis. Troponins are a useful test to help confirm myocarditis, but I emphasize that troponin in the bloodstream is not diagnostic of myocarditis by itself – it is a cardiologist’s role is to sort out all the other causes of troponin in the bloodstream such as physical exercise.
The EKG findings discussed in the paper are listed below:Bad actors may say that 18% of the EKGs were abnormal, but this number is derived from simple subtraction without acknowledging which of these EKG findings are normal variants. They are trying to use these findings to convince people that all the EKG findings demonstrated are abnormal, which, as any medical student or trainee physician should know, is patently false. Some people will use the argument at this point that “no science is settled”, but this knowledge is one of the foundations of general pediatric cardiology. These fundamental EKGs have extremely precise definitions that have no room for debate. I will refrain from using technical terminology as much as possible in the next paragraph, where I will define these different EKG results and what they mean.
     1.  Normal sinus rhythm: EKGs are a two-dimensional representation of a 3-dimensional phenomenon – the electrical wave washing over the heart, stimulating muscular contraction. If you could visualize this wave, it would look something like waves on a beach that repeat on a regular basis. This is what the expression “normal sinus rhythm” means in pediatrics; the electricity is washing over the heart from top right to bottom left in an orderly fashion. The lines on the EKG represent the height of the waves, like if you were placing a meter stick in the water.
     2.  Sinus arrhythmia: I admit that we cardiologists could have named this better, but this means that the EKG rhythm is varying with the patient’s respiratory rate. This is most visible in toddlers, and its effects gradually disappear with age. Bad actors are trying to claim this is abnormal, but in pediatrics sinus arrhythmia is an absolutely normal finding. Even medical students learn this. Antivaxxers claiming that this is abnormal is akin to saying freckles are a medical disease (they are not).
     3.  Sinus tachycardia: While this is a sensitive indicator of myocarditis (meaning even low level myocarditis can cause sinus tachycardia), the EKG result just means that the heart rate is faster than average for the child’s age. This EKG finding can be legitimately claimed as abnormal only if a comparison of pre-vaccination EKGs can be made.
     4.  Sinus bradycardia: This just means that the heart rate is somewhat slower than average for the child’s age. In the vast majority of circumstances, this EKG finding is also a normal variant in pediatrics. This EKG finding can only be legitimately claimed as abnormal if a pre-vaccination comparison can be made.
     5.  Premature atrial or ventricular contractions: These represent extra beats from the top two or bottom two chambers of the heart. Many children are found to have these incidentally; while they can be generated by myocarditis, the presence of a tiny amount of these beats is not worrisome. We start to worry when their quantity is increasing, they disturb heart function, they are triggered by exercise, or they are present in a sustained manner. While it is easier to make the argument that this EKG finding is abnormal, it again must be compared with a pre-vaccination EKG (and preferably a 24 hour EKG monitor).
     6.  Junctional escape rhythm: This rhythm means that the top chambers are perceived, by the rest of the heart, to be slower than what is necessary for a normal heartbeat. As a consequence, the bottom chambers make their own beats to catch up. This is very, very frequent in kids who are physically fit, and especially so at rest. In the absence of blood pressure and heart function derangement, this EKG finding is normal.
     7.  Ectopic atrial rhythm: This means that rather than starting in the top right of the right atrium, the heartbeat starts in a slightly different place. As a sole finding in a child, this is an absolutely normal EKG.
     8.  Diffuse ST elevation: This is the only EKG in the collection of EKG findings that is abnormal at all times; it may suggest irritation of the membrane covering the heart (pericarditis).
I repeat – the discovery of one of the EKG findings above is not sufficient to diagnose myocarditis. At minimum, the reader should be allowed to compare the EKG findings pre-vaccination versus post-vaccination. I include this table again to remind the reader that myocarditis has many causes:An elevated troponin has its own causes as well, not all of which are myocarditis:

On subclinical myocarditis
The definition of subclinical myocarditis is a patient with lab, imaging, or EKG findings consistent with myocarditis, but minimal or no symptoms (minimal chest pain, shortness of breath, or palpitations for example). The crowd that is most anti-COVID vaccination is very supportive of the finding of subclinical myocarditis in this article without considering its limitations. Cardiologists have formalized the criteria for myocarditis to avoid diagnosing every person with troponin in the blood with myocarditis. This would be misdiagnosis and, unnecessarily frighten the patient. I particularly emphasize – even if it is coming from me – a speaker who analyzes articles critically when they do not fit the speakers preconceived notions, and fails to analyze critically when the articles do match their preconceived notions, is presenting you with a biased and possibly deceptive assessment of the world. Many kinds of disinformation would not have an audience, if the public knew when a science communicator was presenting only one side of an issue. People opposing COVID-19 vaccinations especially do not consider the behavior of subclinical myocarditis – which has been researched:
    • In this study from Turkey, people who had rheumatic fever-associated myocarditis did not land in the hospital due to that diagnosis (although they needed monitoring).
    • In this study, some athletes were found to have subclinical myocarditis after contracting COVID.
This point is especially important – people who wish to instill fear about vaccination myocarditis rarely stays consistent, and usually do not compare discussion of vaccine myocarditis with the rates of subclinical myocarditis due to viral infections. The outcomes of mild and subclinical myocarditis are generally very good. Regarding the preprint – we need, at the very least, to understand the significance of the authors’ diagnoses of subclinical myocarditis, and a full disclosure of the children’s cardiac testing prior to vaccination (and preferably at all stated data collection time points). This is a modification to their project that can be done during the peer review process.
Conclusions
This research team made a strong effort to try and design a prospective clinical case series/ small clinical trial to see what happens to kids who get the mRNA COVID-19 vaccine. It does have its limitations but it was what they could come up with on short notice. A study on COVID vaccination myocarditis is not worthy of hype only because it reports the highest rate of myocarditis yet observed. We have strict myocarditis criteria to make sure healthcare workers who diagnose myocarditis systematically go through all the causes of elevated troponins that are not due to myocarditis.
The takeaway points are:
    • In the end, to the trained observer, there are no shocking findings in this study. Overall, it supports the current body of knowledge regarding COVID vaccination myocarditis.
    • The prevalence of subclinical myocarditis after COVID vaccination is not discernable based upon the project as currently presented; while preprints are a great way to get studies out quickly, they should not be used to inform policy before being peer reviewed by other healthcare professionals trained in the subject matter. It will be good to see what an updated rate of subclinical myocarditis is after peer review and editing, preferably with refinement of diagnostic criteria to match the international Brighton collaboration criteria and and myocarditis formal case definition criteria
    • Based upon data available so far, people who have recovered from vaccination myocarditis have minimal to no symptoms, although they should have long term follow-up.
    • While some patients with myocarditis carry some subclinical ongoing findings by MRI, one disease process does not automatically apply to a different disease process (for example certain diseases of the heart that carry gadolinium enhancement can heal to the point that some of the enhancement resolves).
    • If you are concerned about subclinical myocarditis, all you need to do is discuss doing the testing with your physician.
Also, pediatric cardiologists are currently collaborating with national health agencies to continue study of pediatric postvaccine myocarditis and determine what the clinical outcomes are.
Ways you can decrease your risk of vaccine-associated myocarditis include:
    • Space out your doses at 8 weeks or longer.
    • If you are a teen boy or young adult male, pick Pfizer over Moderna.
    • It is plausible that Novavax may produce less myocarditis but the real-life behavior of this vaccination in post-EUA surveillance has yet to be adequately studied, since it was only recently granted United States FDA Emergency Use Authorization.
if you don’t want to have anything to do with mRNA vaccinations, nobody can twist your arm (really, pediatricians aren’t looking to twist anyone’s arms). All you have to do is not vaccinate, hopefully while understanding the risks of COVID-19 in unvaccinated populations.

Medical Conservatives: A High Rate of COVID-Myocarditis is “Good News”, A Low Rate of Vaccine-Myocarditis is “Deeply Concerning”
Doctors who repeatedly and blatantly contradict themselves, convincing parents that rare vaccine side effects are a fate worse than death, don’t deserve our trust.
Jonathan Howard on January 30, 2023
Link

[Editor’s note: Because of a family health emergency over the weekend, Dr. Gorski did not have a post ready for his usual Monday morning slot. This is also the reason that the virtual Q&A for the movie Virulent: The Vaccine War, originally scheduled for yesterday evening, was postponed and is in the process of being rescheduled. Fortunately, Dr. Jonathan Howard filled in. Dr. Gorski anticipates being back next week. In addition, since our recent loss of Dr. Harriet Hall, we now have a gap in our schedule on Tuesday. Until we are able to find someone to take that spot regularly—no one can ever truly replace Dr. Hall—Tuesdays will be empty.]
A question
Should the gravity of a medical condition be judged based on its underlying cause or the frequency/severity of the injury that results? Though I believe the gravity of a medical condition should judged based on the frequency/severity of the injury that results, my opinion is surprisingly controversial amongst doctors. I also do not believe that vaccine side effects can be equated to COVID deaths in young people simply because both are rare. One is much worse than the other. This too is surprisingly controversial amongst doctors.
COVID myocarditis
In an article titled “Setting the Record Straight: There is no ‘Covid Heart’” three medical “conservatives“, Drs. John Mandrola, Andrew Foy and Vinay Prasad, argued that “The issue of Covid-19 induced cardiac problems was massively overblown.”
They thought the frequency of COVID-related heart disease was not too concerning, referencing a study of athletes where “just 21 of the 3,000 had definite, probable, or possible cardiac involvement based on lab testing and cardiac imaging.” They said this rate, 1 out of 143 people, was “reassuring”. It was “less than 1%”, they correctly noted. They similarly discussed another study where “researchers studied 145 student athletes who had Covid-19 and found myocarditis in only 1.4% of them.”
“Just 21 of the 3,000″ and “only 1.4%” is how they described the rate of COVID-myocarditis.
Drs. Mandrola, Foy and Prasad were similarly reassured about the severity of COVID-related heart disease. “People who have recovered from Covid-19 have no special reason to worry about their hearts”, they wrote. “Even in the sickest of the sick, Covid-19’s effect on the heart appears to be modest,” they said about one study. “Cardiac magnetic resonance scans done during convalescence showed that nearly half of the individuals had no major heart abnormalities,” they wrote, though this means that just over half of the individuals had major heart abnormalities. Though Drs. Mandrola, Foy and Prasad did not report it, this study also found:
Myocardial infarction was found in 19% (28/148) and inducible ischaemia in 26% (20/76) of those undergoing stress perfusion (including 7 with both infarction and ischaemia). Of patients with ischaemic injury pattern, 66% (27/41) had no past history of coronary disease.
Drs. Mandrola, Foy and Prasad told their readers this damage was “modest” and not a “special reason to worry”.
The felt the real lesson was about science communication. They expressed their “concern about overdiagnosis” in a letter and warned about “hyperbolic messaging.” They wrote:
The broader lesson is that science communication in times of crisis must keep a level head. The public, and decision-makers, need properly controlled studies instead of early sensational reports. In a world where success is measured by clicks, the idea that even mild cases of Covid-19 could pose a new and unprecedented threat to the heart took off. That fear has largely been unsubstantiated, though news of it won’t spread nearly as quickly.
Dr. Mandrola spread this message on social media, warning about “fear-mongering howler-science” studies on COVID-myocarditis. He reacted to the study that showed 1.4% of athletes with COVID had myocarditis by saying this was “good news”.
To summarize, according to medical “conservatives”, myocarditis is “modest” even in “the sickest of the sick”, so long as COVID is the cause. Those who have recovered have “no special reason to worry about their hearts” and anyone who claims otherwise is “fear mongering”. A study showing cardiac involvement in “just” 21 of 3,000 athletes was “reassuring”, and another showing myocarditis in “only” 1.4% of athletes was “good news”. “The evidence for the assertion that a Covid-19 infection is a big heart risk for young people is unconvincing”, Drs. Mandrola and Prasad wrote recently, linking to their article Setting the Record Straight: There is no ‘Covid Heart’ as proof.
Medical “conservatives” implored us to engage in sober, rational analysis regarding COVID. In times of crisis, we must keep a level head.
1.4% of athletes with myocarditis is “good news” and studies on COVID-myocarditis are “fear-mongering howler-science.”
Vaccine-myocarditis
But then something happened that changed everything for so-called medical “conservatives”.
The COVID vaccine was found to cause myocarditis in about 1 in 10,000 adolescent males after their second Pfizer dose. (I discuss vaccine-myocarditis rates here.) It is vanishingly rare in younger children, if it happens at all. If we generously estimate that 10 million adolescent males have been vaccinated, this means that 1,000 boys younger than 18-years have been affected by vaccine-myocarditis, which is slightly higher than the number of children (914) who were hospitalized with COVID in one day during the peak of the Omicron wave. In one (pre-Omicron) study, 38% of hospitalized children were sick enough to be intubated in the ICU.
Though medical “conservatives” protest that the “media” minimizes the clinical course of vaccine-myocarditis, doctors who’ve actually treated these patients and published their findings (like Dr. Frank Han) are in complete agreement about its short-term prognosis. The initial report from Israel said “95% are considered to be mild cases,” and 27 studies from around the world have confirmed this pattern.
The largest systematic review of adolescents and young adults summarized 23 studies involving 854 patients. It found a “low incidence rate and largely favorable early outcomes of COVID-19 mRNA vaccine–associated myopericarditis in adolescents and young adults.” Even in those with abnormal cardiac imaging, a systematic review of 468 cases found that “all reported cases with abnormal cardiac MRI findings showed a favorable clinical course at the acute phase.” Another review of 276 cases reported that, “Fortunately, most myocarditis cases associated with mRNA vaccines are mild in nature and do not have serious complications and require only a few days of hospital admission.” Another systematic review of 22 studies stated “the prognosis of this self-limiting condition is generally good.”
Every study I could find on the clinical course of vaccine myocarditis
Gargano et al. (Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report)	Acute clinical courses were generally mild.
Israel Ministry of Health	95% are considered to be mild cases.
Yasuhara et al. (JAMA Pediatrics)	This systematic review and meta-analysis found low incidence rate and largely favorable early outcomes of COVID-19 mRNA vaccine–associated myopericarditis in adolescents and young adults from a wide range of populations. These findings are reassuring but continued follow-up is warranted.
Samimisedeh et al. (Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging)	All reported cases with abnormal cardiac MRI findings showed a favorable clinical course at the acute phase.
Khan et al. (Cureus)	Fortunately, most myocarditis cases associated with mRNA vaccines are mild in nature and do not have serious complications and require only a few days of hospital admission
Ling et al. (The Lancet Respiratory Medicine)	The prognosis of this self-limiting condition is generally good, long-term outcomes for affected patients after 3 months and 6 months are currently awaited.
Dionne et al. (JAMA Cardiology)	All patients in this series had a benign course; none required intensive care unit admission.
Marshall et al. (Pediatrics)	All 7 patients resolved their symptoms rapidly.
Woo et al. (Journal of Medical Virology)	In agreement with previous reports on these patients’ relatively favorable clinical courses, symptoms of all 74 patients in this review resolved, and nearly a third (31.0%) of them recovered with conservative treatment.
Diaz et al. (JAMA)	All were discharged after a median of 2 days. There were no readmissions or deaths.
Jain et al. (Pediatrics)	Hospital course is mild with quick clinical recovery and excellent short-term outcomes. Myocardial injury and edema are noted on CMR. Close follow-up and further studies are needed to understand the long-term implications and mechanism of these myocardial tissue changes.
Montgomery et al. (JAMA Cardiology)	All patients received brief supportive care and were recovered or recovering at the time of this report.
Rosner et al. (Circulation)	The clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis-like illness appears favorable, with resolution of symptoms in all patients.
Mevorach et al. (The New England Journal of Medicine)	All the cases were clinically mild, involving a mean duration of hospitalization of 3.1 days
Nygaard et al. (The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal)	The mild phenotype of myopericarditis cases in our study were comparable with cases described in other studies, except 1 patient with myocarditis and MIS-C, who needed treatment at intensive care unit.
Witberg et al. (The New England Journal of Medicine)	Most cases of myocarditis were mild or moderate in severity.
Mouch et al. (Vaccine)	The clinical course was mild in all six patients.
Larson et al. (Circulation)	All patients had resolution of their chest pain, were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, and were alive with preserved left ventricular ejection fraction at last contact.
Truong et al. (Circulation)	Most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine myocarditis occurring in persons <21 years have a mild clinical course with rapid resolution of symptoms. Abnormal findings on cardiac MRI were frequent. Future studies should evaluate risk factors, mechanisms, and long-term outcomes.
Patone et al. (Nature Medicine)	Most vaccine-associated myocarditis events have been mild and self-limiting.
Lai et al. (Journal of the American College of Cardiology)	This study found a significantly lower rate of mortality among individuals with myocarditis after mRNA vaccination compared with those with viral infection–related myocarditis. Prognosis of this iatrogenic condition may be less severe than naturally acquired viral infection–related myocarditis.
Varma et al. (The Medical Journal of Australia)	COVID-19 mRNA vaccine-associated myocarditis has a mild, self-resolving clinical course, in contrast to reported complications and long term sequelae associated with COVID-19, such as multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children, and other forms of myocarditis. The long term consequences of myocardial injury with vaccine-associated myocarditis nevertheless warrant further investigation.
Witberg et al. (The New England Journal of Medicine)	Our study indicates that BNT162b2 vaccine–induced myocarditis in adolescents appears to be a rare adverse event that occurs predominantly in males after the second vaccine dose. The clinical course appears to be mild and benign over a follow-up period of 6 months, and cardiac imaging findings suggest a favorable long-term prognosis.
Mansanguan et al. (Tropical Medicine and Infectious Disease)	The clinical presentation of myopericarditis after vaccination was usually mild and temporary, with all cases fully recovering within 14 days.
Naveed et al. (Canadian Medical Association Journal)	Although observed rates of myocarditis were higher than expected, the benefits of vaccination against SARS-CoV-2 in reducing the severity of COVID-19, hospital admission and deaths far outweigh the risk of developing myocarditis
Mevorach et al. (Circulation)	The clinical presentation was mild, with resolution of postbooster myocarditis in all cases, as judged by clinical symptoms, inflammatory markers, and troponin levels, ECG, echocardiogram normalization if abnormal (<55% ejection fraction), and a relatively short hospital stay.
Goyal et al. (QJM: An International Journal of Medicine)	Myocarditis following COVID-19 vaccination is often mild, seen more commonly in young healthy males and is followed by rapid recovery with conservative treatment.
Gao et al. (American Journal of Preventative Medicine)	Although an increased risk of myocarditis and pericarditis was found among individuals who received COVID-19 vaccine, it is worth noticing that myocarditis or pericarditis was predominantly mild in the vaccinated individuals.
COVID myocarditis versus vaccine myocarditis: Severity
Several studies have compared clinical outcomes between vaccine-myocarditis, classic viral myocarditis, and myocarditis caused by multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), a potentially devastating COVID complication that has affected over 9,300 American children, 9 times more than the number of children who’ve developed vaccine-myocarditis.
Though Drs. Mandrola, Foy and Prasad, neglected to mention MIS-C in their article on “COVID heart”, myocarditis and coronary artery aneurysms frequently occur in children with MIS-C. Other studies have reported acute heart failure in children with MIS-C. Other cardiac complications of myocarditis due to MIS-C include “shock, cardiac arrhythmias, pericardial effusion, and coronary artery dilatation”. Cardiac arrhythmias have led “to hemodynamic collapse and need for ECMO support” in some children. Though most children recover well, 76 children have died of MIS-C.
One review that compared vaccine-myocarditis, classic viral myocarditis, and myocarditis caused by MIS-C, found that vaccine-myocarditis was the mildest of the three. It said:
Compared with classic myocarditis, those with MIS-C myocarditis had better clinical outcomes, including rapid recovery of cardiac function. Patients with vaccine-related myocarditis had prompt resolution of symptoms and improvement of cardiac function.
Patients with vaccine-myocarditis recover faster than children with MIS-C-myocarditis
Another study “reviewed the data of 42 COVID‐19‐related myocarditis patients from two systematic reviews and compared the outcomes with 74 patients” with vaccine-myocarditis. It found:
The number of patients who experienced complications or required intensive care was significantly lower among the mRNA vaccine‐related myocarditis patients. Furthermore, there was no mortality reported among the mRNA vaccine‐related myocarditis patients, and more patients recovered without myocarditis‐specific medical treatments.
Patients with vaccine-myocarditis far better than those with COVID-myocarditis
Additionally, there is emerging evidence that COVID can damage the heart beyond acute myocarditis. Though medical conservatives reflexively deride studies whose results they don’t like as “fear mongering howler science”, one study found “that heart attack death rates took a sharp turn and increased for all age groups during the pandemic.” According to one article:
The spikes in heart attack deaths have tracked with surges of COVID-19 infection—even during the presumed less-severe Omicron phase of the pandemic. Furthermore, the data showed the increase was most significant among individuals ages 25-44, who are not usually considered at high risk for heart attack.
“The dramatic rise in heart attacks during the pandemic has reversed what was a prior decade long steady improvement in cardiac deaths,” said Yee Hui Yeo, MD, first author of the study and a Cedars-Sinai physician-scientist. “We are still learning the many ways by which COVID-19 affects the body, regardless of age, gender, ethnicity or race.”
Dr. Yeo is right to take a medically conservative approach towards a brand new virus. We’ll be learning about the effects of repeat COVID infections on our brain, lungs, and heart for the rest of our lives. Only a medical radical would suggest repeatedly exposing unvaccinated children to a novel virus and hoping for the best.
COVID myocarditis versus vaccine myocarditis: Frequency
COVID myocarditis is more frequent than vaccine-myocarditis, even for young males. One study found that:
Among males aged 12 to 17 years, the incidence of myocarditis or pericarditis after infection with SARS-CoV-2 was about twice as high as after vaccination with 2 doses of an mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine. When MIS, a post–COVID-19 syndrome that often includes cardiac complications, was included in the comparison, the risk of cardiac problems was about 2 to 6 times higher after infection than after 2 doses of vaccine. Men aged 18 to 29 years had a 7 to 9 times greater risk of cardiac complications after infection than after 2 doses of vaccine.
Though he claims otherwise on social media and his writing for the general public, in his review on the topic, even Dr. Prasad was forced to concede that:
The incidence of myocarditis found for young men after SARS-CoV-2 infection is larger than what we found for myocarditis following COVID-19 vaccination.
I’ve not seen him acknowledge his own finding elsewhere.
A blatant double standard
Looking at all of this, it’s hard to conclude that the vaccine poses a bigger risk to the heart than the virus, though of course, COVID’s harms are not limited to myocarditis. This is why pediatric hospitals were deluged with sick children during the Delta and Omicron waves, while no hospital in the world had to open a vaccine-injury unit. Over 2,000 children have died from COVID in the US, double the number of children who’ve been affected by vaccine-myocarditis. As far as I know, no children have died from the vaccine, which has proven effective in limiting COVID’s gravest harms in children, including MIS-C and death. Many more children would have suffered had no efforts been made to protect them from COVID as some medical “conservatives” advocated.
Nonetheless, because I value consistency in my writing, I’ve said many times that it’s serious whenever a young person is hospitalized with vaccine-myocarditis, even if nearly all of them leave after a couple of days feeling fine. Though it is very rare, some patients can be quite sick and not all recover immediately. A small number of adults around the world have died from this disorder. These are tragedies. Most individuals are advised to abstain from vigorous activity for several months, and they will have to be monitored over the long-term for possible cardiac scarring and arrhythmias. So, while vaccine-myocarditis shouldn’t be minimized, a doctor who says its prognosis is “usually mild and temporary” would only be honestly reporting what literally every study on the topic has reported thus far.
Medical “conservatives” felt otherwise. Dr. Mandrola told his Twitter audience it would be inappropriate for doctors to accurately report these results. He felt that to maintain “trust”, doctors had to both minimize the risk of COVID and exaggerate the harms of the vaccine. This is because medical “conservatives” have an absurd and blatant double-standard for how they evaluate harms of the virus versus harms of the vaccine.
    • Though Drs. Prasad and Mandrola felt that “Even in the sickest of the sick, Covid-19’s effect on the heart appears to be modest,” they felt “even the slightest bit of inflammation in the heart should be treated seriously” when the vaccine was to blame.
    • They wrote that wrote that people who have recovered from COVID “have no special reason to worry about their hearts”. However, they warned the vaccine could “scar tissue created in response to heart inflammation can be the source of the rhythm disturbance”.
    • With COVID-myocarditis, they discouraged unnecessary tests and even signed a “letter of concern about overdiagnosis”. With the vaccine, Dr. Prasad warned that “subclinical myocarditis is often far greater than reported myocarditis”.
    • While they felt “The issue of Covid-19 induced cardiac problems was massively overblown,” Dr. Mandrola wrote that “vaccine-induced myocarditis concerns demand respect”.
    • Though they wrote with COVID-myocarditis, we “need properly controlled studies instead of early sensational reports,” they were eager to amplify early sensational reports about vaccine-myocarditis. “I don’t think people realize the damage continuing to push 2 doses in young men will do,” Dr. Prasad tweeted, one month after warning us to avoid “hyperbolic messaging” about COVID-myocarditis.
    • Dr. Mandrola dismissed the idea that “even mild cases of Covid-19 could pose a new and unprecedented threat to the heart”. However, when discussing the vaccine he said, “Humans have only one heart; inflaming it at a young age is not a small thing”.
    • Dr. Prasad said 21 of 3,000 patients with COVID-myocarditis was “reassuring”. When discussing the much lower rate of vaccine-myocarditis, he said “That 1/3-5k ballpark is deeply concerning”. “We ought to make a concerted effort to lower harms in this group”, he said about the vaccine, of course.
    • Dr. Mandrola felt concerns about COVID-myocarditis were “fear mongering”, and that it was “good news” that 1.4% of athletes developed COVID-myocarditis on cardiac MRI. Good news! In contrast, with the vaccine and a myocarditis rate of 0.01%, he said we need more “caution” and that accurately quoting studies that describe vaccine-myocarditis as “mild” was a “trust shredder”.
    • “The point is that the risk of COVID in this age group is super low, as is the risk of vaccine-induced myocarditis”, Dr. Mandrola said, implying an equivalency between vaccine side-effects and death.
    • Though Dr. Mandrola had previously argued for “robust critical appraisal of medical evidence” when discussing COVID-myocarditis, he responded to someone who provided accurate information about COVID’s harm to children by saying:
“I think we can avoid being too quantitative”.
Yes, one can avoid being too quantitative, but this is not a goal to strive for.
Dr. Mandrola warns us to not to be “too quantitative” when discussing COVID.
And that’s how it always has been with these doctors. Vaccine side-effects were treated as a life-altering catastrophe for masses of adolescents, while anything the virus did to young people was brushed off as “fear mongering” – and yes, this includes children and young adults dying from COVID. I previously discussed Dr. Prasad’s horrifying admonition that we should casually accept unvaccinated children dying of COVID as a “matter of course”.
He was not alone. In December 2020, after thousands of young adults had already died, none were vaccinated, and the majority had yet to be infected, Drs. Mandrola and Foy wrote an article titled “No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus“. The core of their argument was that “the infection fatality rate for young adults is quite low”. In other words, not that many young people will die of COVID. They said a “fear of death” was not a valid reason for young adults to avoid the virus. Sure, “an excess of 12,000 deaths sounds bad” they wrote, but it’s just a “tiny absolute increase in risk”. They felt our focus should be on all the people who didn’t die. They wrote:
Thus, the individual risk for a person this age is found by dividing 4,560 (the number dead from COVID19 in this study) by 88 million. This equates to a 0.0052% risk of dying from COVID19.
Of course, anything that kills young people could be minimized this way. Currently, over 43,000 Americans ages 19-44 years have died of COVID, and the vast majority would be alive had they been vaccinated and boosted. Even though this is 6 times the number of soldiers who’ve died fighting in wars since 9/11, Drs. Mandrola and Foy told them not to fear this outcome. Moreover, death is not the only bad outcome from COVID, though Drs. Mandrola and Foy and didn’t even mention COVID’s non-fatal harms.
I too am confused
It does not make much sense to me that doctors who feel this way about thousands of dead young people, instead feel the need to warn them about something that has killed a small number of young adults around the world. However having told young people not to fear death or anything else COVID might do to them, medical “conservatives” instead felt they should be very afraid of vaccine-myocarditis. No longer were we told to calculate “the individual risk for a person this age”, and anyone who did so would be accused of minimizing this side effect. Even though virtually no teenagers are getting vaccinated today, and it’s plausible there are no children in the hospital with vaccine-myocarditis, medical “conservatives” retain their laser-like focus on this side effect.
Dr. Prasad has some thoughts on vaccine-myocarditis
In contrast, even though medical “conservatives” declared the pandemic over multiple times, children are still getting sick with and very rarely dying of COVID. However, could you ever imagine Dr. Prasad or any medical “conservative” making a video about a child who died of COVID or spent 160 days on a ventilator? Of course not. Medical “conservatives” overtly and consciously do not acknowledge such children, even though there are many more of them. Dr. Prasad even suggested there was something fundamentally wrong with anyone who shared basic facts on pediatric COVID. He always said they were breathless. This was an artistic critique. He did not like their tone.
In fact, Dr. Prasad complained that children seriously injured by COVID received too much media attention. He said providing accurate information to parents only “sabotaged school reopenings”. In April 2021 he said that the “media’s breathless coverage of MIS-C and variants has been a disservice”. The Delta and Omicron variants would rip through the pediatric population the next year, causing unprecedented illness, especially for unvaccinated children. Many misinformed parents were under the illusion it was “just the flu” and some of their children really suffered. “I just had a false sense of security that it was just like the flu and it wasn’t that serious. Obviously it is that serious and it was that serious. Now, I can see,” said one mother whose unvaccinated child wound up on a ventilator. Yet, Dr. Prasad felt that parents like her had been overly-informed about COVID’s risk to children. Imagine that.
In contrast, he excoriated The Atlantic for not covering “the human story of a 22 year boy with myocarditis.” “There is little to no coverage of a serious, proven AE (adverse event) in young healthy people,” he said. “It won’t be pretty,” he added, breathlessly.
Reality check: COVID has killed about 1,850 more children than the flu since the start of the pandemic.
Trust in medicine
I believe the gravity of a medical condition be judged primarily based on the frequency/severity of the injury that results, rather than its underlying cause. I also don’t think vaccine-myocarditis is a fate worse than death. Medical “conservatives” disagree. Nonetheless, I always like to find points of agreement with the doctors I discuss, and Dr. Mandrola was right about the importance of trust in medicine.
Doctors who repeatedly and blatantly contradict themselves are motivated by ideology, not evidence. They don’t deserve our trust.
The top quote is about the virus. The bottom is about the vaccine. The authors are the same.

“Among patients aged 12-39 years with no predisposing comorbidities, the relative risk of heart failure or death was markedly higher for myocarditis associated with covid-19 disease than for myocarditis associated with vaccination.”
Doctors used *that result* to claim the vaccine is more dangerous than the virus.
Jonathan Howard on February 10, 2023
Link

A Flashback
The first few times I read anti-vaccine articles, I found them superficially plausible. I lacked the background knowledge to spot their flaws and was blissfully ignorant of the mendaciousness that characterizes the anti-vaccine movement. It was only when I dug further that I realized their grave flaws. For example, in a collection of articles titled “200 Evidence Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate,” Sayer Ji, the founder of the anti-vaccine site GreenMedInfo listed an article titled “A Measles Outbreak Was Reported in a Highly Vaccinated Population, San Diego, 2008.” 
Sounds bad, right?
However, the actual title of the article, which was published in the journal Pediatrics in 2010, was “Measles Outbreak in a Highly Vaccinated Population, San Diego, 2008: Role of the Intentionally Undervaccinated.” The article concluded that “measles outbreaks can occur among clusters of intentionally undervaccinated children, at major cost to public health agencies, medical systems, and families.” In attempting to convince people vaccines don’t work, Mr. Ji distorted the findings of articles that showed vaccines work quite well. 
Previously, this sort of blatant deception was practiced only by the most egregious anti-vaccine grifters.
A Review
With this in mind, let’s again discuss vaccine-myocarditis. Broadly speaking, there are two types of studies on this rare side effect, those on its frequency and those on its clinical course. Generally speaking, studies on the frequency of vaccine-myocarditis tell us nothing about its severity, and studies on its severity tell us little about its frequency. We only know that vaccine-myocarditis is relatively rare, since most studies on its severity contain dozens, not thousands of patients.
Studies on its frequency require researchers to comb through databases to find needles in haystacks, and unsurprisingly, there is a large variation in what they’ve found. In contrast, studies on its clinical course start with those needles and report on patient outcomes. Fortunately, there is complete agreement amongst over 25 studies that “most myocarditis cases associated with mRNA vaccines are mild in nature and do not have serious complications and require only a few days of hospital admission.” Several studies (here, here, and here) have compared the severity of vaccine-myocarditis to COVID-myocarditis and classic viral-myocarditis. These studies all found that vaccine-myocarditis was by far the mildest, which is not a surprise given its generally favorable prognosis.
Patients with vaccine-myocarditis fare better than those with COVID-myocarditis.
A New Study
Another recent study, Clinical Outcomes of Myocarditis After SARS-Cov-2 Mrna Vaccination In Four Nordic Countries: Population Based Cohort Study, again confirmed the unsurprising news that vaccine-myocarditis is milder than viral-myocarditis. The study used a Nordic myocarditis cohort and examined 7,292 patients 12-years or older who had a diagnosis of myocarditis as a main or secondary diagnosis from 2018-2022. Anyone admitted to hospital for myocarditis within 28 days of vaccination with a mRNA vaccine was categorised as having vaccine-myocarditis, while patients admitted to hospital for myocarditis within 28 days of a positive SARS-CoV-2 PCR were categorised as having COVID-myocarditis. The study found:
Among patients aged 12-39 years with no predisposing comorbidities, the relative risk of heart failure or death was markedly higher for myocarditis associated with covid-19 disease than for myocarditis associated with vaccination.
This all seems pretty straightforward. While vaccine-myocarditis can make young people sick, COVID-myocarditis can make them much sicker. Though myocarditis is rare from both the vaccine and the virus, when tragedies occur, the virus is always to blame.
Contrarian Doctors Misinform
However, one aspect of the Nordic study allowed contrarian doctors to claim its authors did not understand their own results. In this study, 530 (7.3%) patients had vaccine-myocarditis, 109 (1.5%) had COVID myocarditis, and 6,653 (91.2%) had conventional myocarditis. Since 530 is larger than 109, contrarian doctors concluded the vaccine was more dangerous than the virus.
Dr. Tracy Hoeg, who boasted on Twitter about her child getting both COVID and chickenpox, composed a long Twitter thread that concluded, “the overall risk of developing myocarditis post vax appears higher post vax than post covid.” Dr. Marty Makary, who said herd immunity arrived in spring 2021, spread Dr. Hoeg’s misinformation and added:
The myth that myocarditis was more common after covid than after the vax was propagated by the medical establishment with poor studies of vax-associated myocarditis that had low capture methodology. Hundreds of thousands of young ppl got myocarditis for no good reason.
In reality, no hospital in the world had to open a vaccine-injury unit, though many were deluged with sick children at multiple points during this pandemic.
Dr. Anish Koka, a cardiologist who thought concerns about the Delta variant’s impact on children were 😂, said:
COVID myocarditis = mostly older ppl with bad hearts that spill troponins. Their prognosis is bad. Comparing their prognosis to the teenager that has vaxx myocarditis makes not a whole lot of sense.
Dr. Koka is right that it makes no sense to compare cardiac outcomes in older patients with COVID to younger men with vaccine-myocarditis. That’s why the authors did this:
Doctors Inform
Unsurprisingly, there were some serious problems with the musings of Drs. Hoeg, Makary, and Koka. Most importantly, the Nordic study was a study on the severity vaccine-myocarditis versus COVID-myocarditis. It was not designed to determine the respective rates of these conditions. It did not present the denominators, namely how many people were vaccinated versus how many tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 via PCR. These numbers were not the same. As Dr. Bob Morris pointed out:
What Dr. Hoeg is dutifully missing here is that this study was not designed to compare vaccine induced myocarditis rates to COVID induced rates. It was designed to compare severity. She is completely misrepresenting the study results…
During the study period, the Scandinavian countries had an average of 1200 cases of COVID per 100,000 people and delivered 8200 vaccine doses/100k people every 4 weeks. In other words, every 4 weeks 8.2% of people got a shot. 1.2% were diagnosed with COVID. SO, IF MYOCARDITIS WERE COMPLETELY UNRELATED TO COVID OR THE VACCINE, WE WOULD STILL EXPECT 8.2% OF CASES TO HAVE BEEN VACCINATED AND 1.2% TO HAVE BEEN DIAGNOSED WITH COVID IN THE PRECEDING 4 WEEKS.
Dr. Jeffrey Morris similarly noted:
There are no denominators, but at end of 2022 for vaccines would be ~63 million doses, and for infections be ~9 million PCR+ infections, so they are not equivalent.
Moreover, the Nordic paper only included subjects with a diagnosis of myocarditis as a main or secondary diagnosis. In other words, someone hospitalized with COVID and myocarditis that was not severe enough to rank as a main or secondary diagnosis would not be captured by this study. Sick COVID patients can have a dozen things wrong with them, I am certain that this study missed many cases of COVID-myocarditis.
The distortions spread by contrarian doctors were so egregious that Dr. Anders Hviid, the paper’s senior author, was forced to respond. After reading Dr. Koka’s obviously false assertion that he compared COVID-myocarditis in older patients to vaccine-myocarditis in younger patients, Dr. Hviid said:
But that is not what we have done?! Our primary reference grp is conv. myo. Comparing vaxmyo vs c19myo directly, we restrict to “individuals aged 12-39 years, with no predisposing comorbidities”.
Dr. Hviid later felt obligated to make an announcement that said:
PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT. Our recent study on myocarditis is a prognostic study of myocarditis patients. It is NOT a study designed to compare excess risks of myocarditis following vax vs inf. Please interpret responsibly.
“The point of our study is that vax myo does not carry the same risk of HF (heart failure) and death as other types of myo”, he added.
Beyond this, even if Dr. Hviid’s study somehow showed that vaccine-myocarditis was more common than COVID-myocarditis, that is not the proper comparison. The proper comparison is which can do more harm overall, the vaccine or the virus. Dr. Hviid’s paper showed once again that COVID-myocarditis is much more severe than vaccine-myocarditis, though this understates the risk of SARS-CoV-2 whose harms are not limited to myocarditis. Tyler Gilreath, a healthy 20-year-old, died of a brain abscess after getting COVID, not myocarditis. He didn’t get vaccinated because he was worried about myocarditis though.
Though Drs. Hoeg, Makary, and Koka will never inform their audience of this, some children have needed amputations or lung transplants after their bout with COVID. Others have had strokes. The virus has killed hundreds of teenagers, and teenage athletes have died of COVID after the vaccine was available to them. No children are known to have died from the vaccine, which has proven effective at limiting COVID’s greatest harms, including death. Say what you will about vaccine-myocarditis, it shouldn’t be controversial to state that it is less severe than death. Yet, this is a very controversial opinion amongst doctors.
Let’s review one of the study’s core conclusions:
Among patients aged 12-39 years with no predisposing comorbidities, the relative risk of heart failure or death was markedly higher for myocarditis associated with covid-19 disease than for myocarditis associated with vaccination.
It’s a sad commentary on our pandemic discourse that doctors -who will never care for a sick child themselves- twisted this result to scare parents away from vaccination. Dr. Hviid had to spend his time correcting obvious misinformation spread not by random internet quacks, but by doctors with large social media followings and access to powerful politicians (Florida/Virginia). I’m sorry he had to see his research misrepresented this way.
Those of us who were aware of unsavory characters like Sayer Ji before the pandemic knew to double check his every claim. It is now necessary to do this with many doctors as well.
Dr. Sabina Vohra-Miller summarizes this essay

Dr. Vinay Prasad: “The Incidence of Myocarditis Found for Young Men after SARS-CoV-2 Infection is Larger Than What We Found for Myocarditis Following COVID-19 Vaccination.”
That plus 12 other thoughts about Dr. Vinay Prasad’s recent memo.
Jonathan Howard on December 2, 2025
Link

In pat 5 of his series Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is Definitely Coming for Your Vaccines, Dr. David Gorski discussed a “leaked” memo by Drs. Vinay Prasad, which claimed that he and Dr. Tracy Hoeg had identified at least 10 children who died from the COVID vaccine. Though there will be some overlap, I’d like to add my own thoughts to Dr. Gorski’s devastating takedown.
1. The FDA identified, publicized, and acted on problems with COVID vaccines in 2021
In April 2021, the FDA paused the J&J vaccine after 6 cases of clotting were reported after 6.8 million doses. They published 12 cases in JAMA that month. The next month, the CDC published an MMWR of 17 cases. Deaths from the J&J vaccine were confirmed by the CDC and publicized in the media. Use of the vaccine plummeted, and eventually the FDA revoked it authorization. None of this was hidden, and the AstraZeneca vaccine was never approved in the US for this reason. Similarly, the FDA added a warning label about vaccine-myocarditis in June 2021. Vaccine-advocates trusted this and because we value science and evidence, we supported it 100%. There was 0 controversy about this, a pandemic rarity.
However, our current FDA leadership would have us believe that the same FDA and CDC employees who identified, publicized, and acted on these safety signals, missed or covered up children who were killed by the mRNA vaccines. They are making very serious allegations against their predecessors and they are not shy about that.
However, that’s unlikely. As Dr. Amy Cho said about the FDA memo:
It doesn’t even pass the smell test. I know (because I actually practice medicine) that pediatric deaths that are unexpected are *always* medical examiner cases. I also have made multiple submissions to VAERS and the CDC contacted me as part of their investigation so I know they follow-up. One was for a Bell’s palsy that occurred a few weeks after a vaccination. So it seems inconceivable they wouldn’t investigate a child’s death.
Indeed.
2. Actual FDA experts do not trust Drs. Prasad and Hoeg
Dr. Prasad is an oncologist while Dr. Hoeg is a sports medicine doctor who has offered unproven treatments previously. Neither has expertise in cardiology or vaccines, which has been evident for years. Multiple articles report that genuine experts at the FDA do not trust their integrity regarding the COVID vaccine. According to an article titled How two FDA Officials, Prasad and Hoeg, Seized Vaccine Oversight:
She (Dr. Tracy Hoeg) pointed to a recent label change that required vaccine makers to warn of the risk of myocarditis for young men. And she displayed about two dozen reports of young people who had died after getting the vaccine, found in the agency’s adverse event database. While such reports do not prove causality, Høeg seemed convinced. “Timing fits,” read a slide in her presentation, viewed by STAT. “Diagnosis fits. No better explanation found. Sufficient information provided.”
Cautiously, despite fears that they might face retribution, some of the scientists began to push back at Hoeg’s suggestion to effectively take the vaccine away from millions based on thin evidence. One participant described the mood in the room as “quiet horror.” “It was so far off base,” said the agency official, who was not authorized to speak publicly.
When it became clear that no career regulator would stand by the decision, and when vaccine center director Vinay Prasad said the move wasn’t necessary because he had already limited access to the shots, Høeg backed down.
Another article titled FDA to Present Data it Claims Ties Covid Shots to Child Deaths at CDC Meeting reported that:
One former FDA official, who requested anonymity to speak freely, pushed back on the findings.
“I can tell you on a stack of Bibles that we looked through all of the autopsy reports and that we didn’t find anything,” the official said in a text message. “Unless someone was hiding them from us I don’t know what they’re referring to.”
Another article titled FDA Claims Covid Vaccine Caused Kids’ Deaths. Experts are Skeptical said:
Several CBER staff members who work with vaccines, and who were granted anonymity for fear of repercussions, told STAT they were upset over what they called a “misleading” and “politically charged” email. One worried a team member would ask to be moved to another center.
“Jumping from these case reports to their preexisting vaccine policy preferences is awfully convenient,” said another employee.
Exactly.
I trust that these journalists have vetted their anonymous sources, and I trust them more than our current FDA leadership.
3. Our FDA leadership previously made false claims that the COVID vaccine killed people
In February 2022, Dr. Hoeg posted the following:
I believe this is the 1st confirmed post-vax myocarditis death in the US:
"Because he wanted to take his classes in person, George Jr. needed to be fully vaccinated" 

"An autopsy report … shows George Jr. died from “COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis”https://t.co/iWlGn46AMB
— Tracy Beth Høeg, MD, PhD (@TracyBethHoeg) February 9, 2022
This was false, as I pointed out to Dr. Hoeg at the time. This young man died around six weeks after his 2nd vaccine dose. He had no cardiac symptoms, only sinus symptoms, and the coroner who blamed the vaccine couldn’t even pronounce “myocarditis.”
However, Dr. Hoeg did not care at all that she was spreading obvious anti-vaccine misinformation. She responded to me by posting a “more clear cut” case of a vaccine-fatality, and her dishonest post about George Jr. remains up and uncorrected to this day. As I recognized nearly 4 years ago:
Her goal is to undermine vaccine confidence. She’s succeeded.
Similarly, in 2023 Dr. Marty Makary amplified the disinformation of his eventual boss, claiming that Kennedy shared “true stories of children who died immediately after the vaccine”. That’s false. In reality, Kennedy stole pictures of unvaccinated children who died of other causes to deceive parents about the COVID vaccine.
For his part, Dr. Prasad has already announced that he starts with his conclusions and works backwards to provide the “evidence”, which I discussed in my essay Dr. Vinay Prasad Embraces Policy-Based Evidence Making. These are the FDA officials who are asking us to blindly trust them today.
Of course, the anti movement, especially Kennedy, has long exploited deaths of children to advance their agenda. Dr. Gorski has discussed these tragedies for years, and I remember the article Medical examiner: Girl’s Death Not Caused by HPV Vaccination from 2014. That’s why I wrote in my first SBM article:
Unfortunately, those of us who are familiar with the anti-vaccine movement know what is about to happen. Millions of children ages 12-15 years will soon be vaccinated against COVID-19. Horrible, improbable things will happen to a few of them. The media will write emotionally powerful stories about some these children. Parents of these children will implore others “not to make the same mistake I did”. The anti-vaccine movement will amplify and distort these tragedies to implicate the vaccine, though of course we must always keep an open-mind and consider that the vaccine is responsible. Anti-vaccine activists will claim the COVID-19 vaccines were “rushed” and “not properly studied”. Parents will be frightened. Of course, this has been the pattern with nearly every vaccine for years before COVID-19 emerged.
That article, from May 2021, refuted Dr. Prasad’s early anti-vaccine writing.
4. Where are the case reports?
Although Dr. Prasad implied that VAERS is the only way doctors communicate information about vaccine side effects, this is not true. We also publish in medical journals. Multiple case series of vaccine-myocarditis had already been published by June 2021, and as pediatric cardiologist Dr. Frank Han wrote:
If I were to meet a patient with COVID vaccine myocarditis who was deathly ill, I would announce it to the world, and warn everyone of the risks.
I’ll revise this article if readers share examples, but I am unaware of any reports published in the medical literature of American children who died from the vaccine. Is it possible that dozens of doctors saw children die of vaccine-myocarditis and filled out VAERS reports but did not publish their cases? Sure. Is it likely? No.
5. Kennedy purges doctors who don’t confirm his anti-vaccine views
Kennedy is the boss here. He is the one calling the shots. As virologist Dr. Angela Rasmussen wrote:
Prasad can heap suffering on CBER staff all he likes, but it always must be in the service of Kennedy’s MAHA agenda. What Kennedy asks, Prasad will deliver. He will overrule career agency scientists to delay vaccine licensure. He will force FDA scientists to withhold or hide data from public view or scrutiny, even when it was generated and analyzed by government employees with taxpayer funds. He will put his thumb on the scale of vaccine evaluations and call it Gold Standard.
I am sure the FDA leadership is aware of articles titled NIH Whistleblower Fired Amid Turmoil Over Vaccine Policy and Fired CDC Chief Says She Was Ousted for Refusing to Blindly Back Vaccine Guidance. They know their continued employment depends on them providing Kennedy with anti-vaccine talking points and policies. It also forbids them from contradicting Kennedy’s disinformation or promoting vaccines in any way.
6. Drs. Prasad and Hoeg are fine with anti-vaccine data fraud
After Florida surgeon general Dr. Joseph Ladapo was caught altering data to defend his mystical anti-vaccine beliefs, Dr. Prasad rose to his defense. “This is a stupid news story,” he said. “Ladapo is close to correct that his critics.”
This is a stupid news story. It's not COVID vs. vaccine bc post vax, all people get Covid eventually. It also matters what the age, sex and prior covid status is. It matters what dose we are talking about and Moderna or Pfizer. Ladapo is closer to correct than his critics. https://t.co/NPr6ocsvRI
— Vinay Prasad MD MPH (@VPrasadMDMPH) April 7, 2023
Dr. Hoeg similarly showered Dr. Ladapo with praise, describing him as a “friend and colleague.” That neither doctor cares about data fraud, as long as it was for the sake of infecting unvaccinated children with COVID, reveals their total disregard for basic research ethics.
7. Diagnosis myocarditis can be challenging
To neurologists, the heart is a pump to deliver blood to the brain, and Dr. Han wrote a nice explainer for folks like me titled Myocarditis and How to Think About it… Like a Cardiologist. Apparently, making the right diagnosis can be challenging. One NEJM study reported that:
A total of 61 patients underwent endomyocardial biopsy. Myocarditis was confirmed by biopsy in 40 of 61 patients.
Incredibly, 33% of patients with suspected myocarditis who were sick enough to need a biopsy, did not end up having myocarditis.
Ruling out other causes of myocarditis to isolate the vaccine as the sole cause adds another layer of complexity. Several of the “vaccine fatalities” in VAERS also tested positive for COVID, for example. It’s often not cut and dry.
8. Our FDA leaders were always against vaccinating children and they were never trustworthy
We are not starting from scratch with our FDA leaders. We don’t have to play dumb and pretend they are neutral scientists objectively evaluating the data to generate reliable evidence for the American public. We are all very familiar with their abysmal COVID track record, and it’s vital that we interpret their current statements with this in mind.
Dr. Prasad, for example, was against the pediatric COVID vaccine months before there was a pediatric COVID vaccine, and he never wavered, no matter what happened on the ground. As the pandemic progressed, Dr. Prasad offered entirely contradictory reasons to oppose the vaccine:
    • 2021: Kids are less likely to acquire SARS-CoV-2.
    • 2022: Most kids already had COVID-19
Dr. Prasad causally blew off anything the virus did to children, including killing 19 of them in a single month. 19 is more than 10 last I checked.
In February 2022, as the pediatric death toll surged past 1,000, Dr. Prasad authored blatantly pro-infection articles. “Getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life,” he wrote in his article Should We Let Children Catch Omicron? “It is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger,” he said. This was at the end of the Omicron wave, the worst part of the pandemic for children, when 5-6 children died daily and nearly 1,000 children were hospitalized daily. None of this moved Dr. Prasad at all. He said people who even acknowledge it were “idiots“.
Our FDA leaders literally spread volumes of fake statistics and disinformation (volume 1 and volume 2), and there’s no reason to think they instantly morphed into ethical truth-tellers the moment they entered the government. Our baseline assumption should be that they remain indifferent to children hurt by viruses and utterly untrustworthy today. That’s entirely their fault, and it’s their job to fix it. It’s the responsibly of government doctors to earn our trust, not our obligation to gift it to them.
Dr. Hoeg laughing at a “murdered by Pfizer” sign. Credit to Pandemic Accountability Index.
9. There is no risk-benefit analysis
Everything in medicine is about balancing risk versus benefit, which previous public health officials recognized. As one article reported:
An analysis presented at a CDC meeting in June 2021 focused on people aged 12 to 29 — those at highest risk for myocarditis. In that population, Covid had killed 2,767 since the beginning of the pandemic.
Although COVID’s harms are not limited to myocarditis, every study I know of found the virus causes both a higher rate and more severe myocarditis than the vaccine. This includes the work of Dr. Prasad who found in a systemic review:
The incidence of myocarditis found for young men after SARS-CoV-2 infection is larger than what we found for myocarditis following COVID-19 vaccination.
Fortunately, both the risk of severe outcomes from the virus and the vaccine have dropped since the pandemic’s first years, except for babies who have neither immunity nor any risk from the vaccine. However, Dr. Prasad’s memo attempted no such analysis. As law professor Dorit Reiss wrote:
Dr. Prasad sent an email to CBER suggesting changes to the approval for respiratory vaccines based, apparently, on the conclusion of an unpublished investigation into VAERS report by unknown people. A few thoughts beyond what was already reported, based on the full email.
Dr. Prasad is expressly saying he is not going to do a risk/benefit analysis, even for COVID-19 vaccines, let alone for any other vaccines. Based on this internal investigation of VAERS report, he decided there’s a problem. There is no more thorough review of the data.
Dr. Prasad does not want transparency on this. He is threatening against leaks in the email, he is not suggesting to publish any of these as case studies or give the methodology, and he is upset over previous leaks. We do not know who investigated, either. Much of the email is devoted to justifying public claims made by Prasad, his colleagues, before and to try and counter criticism of previous VAERS claims by Dr. Hoeg. This is an act of justification.
Dr. Prasad is not suggesting a deliberative process to assess next steps, as was FDA’s usual practice. He has decided, apparently without consulting with anyone. That is not good governance. It is more problematic given that Dr. Prasad’s expertise is not in vaccines, but it would be problematic even if he were a vaccine expert.
10. Dr. Prasad’s unprofessional memo was a distraction
Our medical establishment is failing. While they fear monger about vaccines, measles and pertussis are spreading and killing children. Elsewhere babies are being hospitalized with botulism as the headlines read FDA Delays Left Recalled Baby Formula on Store Shelves, Food Safety Expert Says. Meanwhile, the leadership of the FDA, CDC, and NIH are universally distrusted by respectable doctors, their own employees, and large swaths of the American public. It’s been nothing but media drama from our medical establishment, daily for months- even after my article was posted.
However, Drs. Prasad’s overtly political and inflammatory, unprofessional memo- Healthy young children who faced tremendously low risk of death were coerced, at the behest of the Biden administration, via school and work mandates, to receive a vaccine that could result in death– successfully took off the spotlight, at least for now.
Moving forward, we need to hold our medical establishment accountable for what’s happening today not relitigate supposed ultrarare vaccine harms from years ago. Don’t let the performative drama distract from the incompetence and malevolence of our medical establishment.
11. Quacks and sycophants feel it is wrong for citizens to question to their government.
Quacks like Sayer Ji and sycophants like Dr. Anish Koka were gleeful at the possibility the vaccine killed children. They rushed to defend our medical establishment and implied that it was inappropriate for citizens to question government doctors of Dr. Prasad’s stature. They demanded we accept that the COVID vaccine killed children because Dr. Prasad was honest and reliable, while his critics were fools, in a cult. They demanded faith in Dr. Prasad. Dr. Koka wrote:
Prasad is a prolific clinical researcher , a clinical practicing oncologist and an epidemiologist who quickly climbed the ladder of academia publishing papers about pharmaceutical industry gamesmanship and spoke about regulatory capture frequently. This made him very popular among academic lefties who enjoyed his broadsides against big pharma. This is why he ended up as a professor at the elite University of California San Francisco .
The problems for Vinay started when he refused to blindly go along with his tribe on lockdowns and school closures because they appeared to violate basic common sense as well as principles that demand strong hard evidence before administering therapeutics with very real / expensive downsides!! Then when he took the same skepticism he always had towards overly broad therapies from the pharmaceutical industry to the push for the Covid vaccine for everyone regardless of their risk from the vaccine .. he really became an outcast.
The truth is Prasad is very smart, very accomplished and way more logically consistent than his former tribe who can best be described as cultists. They hate him because he was the best of them and can’t be dismissed as some random eccentric crank on YouTube. America is very lucky to have him leading an agency that has lost its way.
Of course, neither Dr. Prasad’s credentials nor Dr. Koka’s juvenile accusations substitutes for evidence, and in reality Dr. Prasad produced an enormous amount of content about this vaccine-side effect on multiple platforms- blogs, social media, podcasts, and yes YouTube. Here are some of his videos there:
    • Our New Myocarditis Paper – Shows the Risk Highest in Young Men
    • Myocarditis From Moderna 2nd Dose Higher in Men Under 40 Than Covid19
    • Myocarditis & Teens: Vaccine Benefit & Risk
    • New MMWR CDC Study Compares Covid Myocarditis to Vax Myocarditis | Is It Good Science?
    • The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly of the Covid Vaccine
    • Thailand Myocarditis After Vaccine Study
    • New Study Documents Covid19 Vaccine Harms – Low Platelets, GBS, Myocarditis – I Unpack
    • “UPDATED DATA: UK Myocarditis Authors Stratify by Sex for Men under 40- Vax vs Virus”
    • How Are Kids and Young Adults Doing 90 Days After Vaccine Myocarditis? Kaiser Northwest Estimate of Myocarditis/Pericarditis Compared to CDC’s Estimate
    • How CDC’s Vaccine Safety Missed Cases of Myocarditis | ID doc Dr. Katie Sharff Discusses New Study
    • Myocarditis | Kids Vax | Kids Mask
    • Myocarditis Data from Ontario Province: Specific Vaccine & Interval Between Doses
    • CDC Director Is Wrong Re Myocarditis Numbers 5-11 & CDC Cannot Count Vaccine Doses – Huge Blunders!
    • Myocarditis Update – Israeli Data – Sweden – Denmark – So Much More
    • Closing Thoughts on Myocarditis and Vaccines
    • Myocarditis In The UK: Moderna Vs. The Virus! New Nature Medicine Paper
While Dr. Prasad wasn’t “random”, he was absolutely an “eccentric crank” on YouTube and given his obsession with this side effect and inability to admit error, we have every right to be suspicious of his objectivity today. There was absolutely zero chance that he was going to conclude “You know what, the vaccine was safe after all. I’ve been wrong the whole time.”
12. All vaccines are in danger
As Dr. Gorski discussed in detail, Dr. Prasad’s memo is a bad sign for all vaccines. It threatens multiple existing vaccines as well as future vaccine-development. The article A Bad Omen for Vaccine Development at the FDA added:
The cumulative effect of these changes, if realized, would be a far more difficult path for developers to get any new vaccine approved by the FDA. Even annual updates, such as for flu shots, would be subject to strict scrutiny. Companies would need to spend much more time and money to get their vaccines to market, and the uncertainty surrounding their approval would be significantly higher.
Prasad’s plan would change the vaccine landscape in two big ways — both of which would harm the large majority of Americans who appreciate vaccination. Most immediately, it would mean vaccines take months or years longer to become approved as developers labor to meet the FDA’s new requirements. The large clinical trials that Prasad is demanding take a lot of time and resources to complete. While the FDA double-checks whether a vaccine is perfectly safe, Americans will enjoy all the safety of no vaccine…
When Americans can’t access a vaccine to protect them from the next awful disease, Vinay Prasad will say he is keeping them safe. The physicians and patients who must deal with the consequences may disagree.
As a result of Dr. Prasad’s memo, many parents will be tricked into believing that tried and true vaccines haven’t really been properly tested and we can’t really be sure they are safe and effective. The damage will last for decades, and the price will be paid in sick and suffering children, as it was with COVID.
This time last year he wrote an article titled Sabotaging RFK Jr’s Confirmation Will Increase Vaccine Hesitancy. Today the headlines read New ACIP Chair Compares Covid Requirements to Holocaust, Says Shots Caused Cancer, Miscarriages. It’s no surprise that Andrew Wakefield is feeling vindicated today and is making a comeback. Dr. Prasad helped unleashed this on all of us.
13. Show us the evidence
We also need to be both aware of our biases and open about them. I hope the COVID vaccine didn’t kill any children, however, it’s entirely possible. I previously discussed a study from Korea where 2 out of 2,076,259 adolescents had fulminant myocarditis, though neither died. Given that tens of millions of American children were vaccinated, I would not be surprised if some died, and I won’t blow off their deaths by saying 10 is a small number. Every life matters, especially children.
However, the burden of proof is entirely on the FDA to provide the evidence. Wiping away all drama and deliberate distractions, that’s all that matters, and thus far we have none. As the article FDA and Prasad’s Covid Vaccine Death Claims Lack Ley Details reported:
“You need clear evidence to make a statement like that” about deaths, Paul Offit, director of the vaccine education center at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, told Endpoints. By clear evidence, Offit pointed to an autopsy showing “a damaged myocardium was the reason that that child died,” as well as proof that the child wasn’t also infected with Covid and/or another virus that could cause myocarditis.
Otherwise, “all you’re doing is scaring people. It’s completely unprofessional, dangerous and irresponsible to do this.”
He’s entirely right, and over and over again, evidence is all experts asked for:
    • Jesse Goodman: When you send a letter to a thousand people or more, this is a really extraordinary claim that would normally merit a very detailed scientific analysis and presentation at an appropriate forum.
    • Daniel Jernigan: It is not clear what process was used for attributing deaths to the vaccine. Some greater transparency is needed.
    • Kathyrn Edwards: We don’t know where it’s coming from. We don’t know which vaccines. We don’t know what the time frame was. We don’t know how many of these cases have an autopsy that shows actual cardiac involvement.
    • Peter Hotez: With almost one billion COVID immunizations administered to Americans during the pandemic, and perhaps close to 100 million for children and adolescents, it is conceivable that such a one in 10 million or 100 million event occurred. Given the public health implications, this is not something one casually blurts out in an email.
    • Jason Schwartz: In any prior administration would have been very clearly presented, typically at public meetings. Instead, we are left to parse the subtleties of an internal email.
I predict that when and if the FDA reveals their cases, they will be like that of Ernesto Ramirez, Jr., suggestive, but hardly definitive. As with Dr. Prasad’s initial memo, they will be a Rorschach test that will cause more anger, division, and doubt. Dr. Prasad’s defenders will say his evidence is unassailable, no matter how thin it is. That’s baked in. However, Dr. Prasad’s premature “leak” has already poisoned the inevitable debate about his actual evidence.
But my mind is open. Maybe the FDA leaders will surprise me and do something they’ve not done the entire pandemic. If they produce high quality evidence, which is authored by reliable, apolitical FDA professionals and widely accepted by trusted experts, then I will accept it, exactly as I accepted the J&J vaccine killed some people. I will be critical of the FDA officials who missed this important signal. My loyalty is to a process, not an outcome.
In contrast, our FDA leaders will never accept the overwhelming evidence that the COVID vaccine prevented rare but grave harms in some children. That’s the difference between them and those of us who value data and evidence above politics and ideology.


Dr. Marty Makary: Using Dead Children to Create a Spectacle of Accusations
Via podcasts, Fox News interviews, and “leaked” memos, our FDA leaders are teasing “profound revelations” about dead children and hidden data, complete with dastardly villains and brave heroes, namely themselves. Stay tuned for more!
Jonathan Howard on December 12, 2025
Link
I Call That Herd Immunity
Like last week’s essay on Dr. Marty Makary and his belief in mad scientists, biowarfare, Nazi war criminal doctors, and half rat-deer carcasses, this essay will require you to watch several of his videos. It’s painful, but it’s important to be aware of his past credibility and disinformation techniques both to judge his current credibility and to recognize his current disinformation techniques.
Though there are countless examples, the three videos below demonstrate Dr. Makary’s modus operandi. First, he makes things up, conflating his desires with reality. He then accuses public health officials who share accurate information, of making things up. His core message was that everyone else is lying to you, and he repeated it over and over again for years on end.
In May 2021, Dr. Rochelle Walensky wisely warned about variants, calling then a “wild card”. However, immediately after being shown this clip, Dr. Makary falsely claimed leaders like her were pushing for “total absolute risk elimination”. He further claimed that public health leaders were trying to “manipulate the public” by hiding the good news “that most of the country is at herd immunity”. They were “dishonest,” he said.
In this video from July 2021, just before the Delta variant arrived, he said that one of the “biggest failures of our medical leadership has been ignoring natural immunity,” which he said provided “decades of protection against severe illness” and was “probably lifelong”.
In this video from 2023, Dr. Makary claimed that Kennedy was censored because he posted “true stories” of children killed by the COVID vaccine. “Asking questions is not allowed,” Dr. Makary said.
Dr. Makary was wrong about all this, of course. In reality, we did not have herd immunity in May 2021, immunity is not lifelong, and Kennedy stole pictures of unvaccinated, deceased children for his anti-vaccine propaganda against the wishes of their grieving parents.
Although Dr. Makary lacks the integrity to revisit his preposterous predictions, his pattern is clear. He speaks with complete confidence as he makes serious, yet false, allegations about public health officials. His goal is not to communicate science and evidence in a neutral way, but rather to inflame his audience by appealing to their emotions and grievances. It’s all one big performance.
They Suppressed the Data
Though his manipulative techniques were dishonest, they were effective. Dr. Makary’s genuine skill at spreading doubt on TV catapulted him to head the FDA, where he is still performing, still creating a spectacle of accusations to enrage and exploit his audience. Just like he did in 2023, Dr. Makary is again claiming the COVID vaccine killed some children. However, instead of simply presenting the evidence and letting it speak for itself, our FDA leaders are doing what they do best, being dramatic to spread anger and mistrust.
In the video below, Dr. Makary accuses his predecessors of hiding evidence that the COVID vaccine killed children. “These were deaths, the data for which, accrued in the prior administration. It was not released to the public. We chose to release it”, he said. That’s a very serious accusation, and it’s not a one-time occurrence for Dr. Makary. He is making the rounds with these allegations.
“They suppressed the data. It was never made public… we have a moral obligation to make that information public“, he said in another overtly political video, in which he blasted the Biden administration and vaccine mandates.
In this video, Dr. Makary said that the previous FDA leaders who disagreed with him about his conclusions regarding the COVID vaccine were “paid by big pharma.”
Dr. Makary also claimed that doctors who even suggested the COVID vaccine might have fatal side effects were victims of a “censorship machine.” “This is like Chinese Communist Party kind of stuff… if you disagree, you could just disappear,” he said. As a reminder, Dr. Makary was a media celebrity who now runs the FDA.
They called Prasad’s analysis “a huge exaggeration.” Some of the deaths were rated as “‘possibly related,’ which is very far” from a causal relationship, the person said.
Previously, when there was evidence of COVID vaccine harms, apolitical, trustworthy FDA scientists simply presented it in a peer-reviewed journal. There was no drama, just data, and therefore no controversy. Everyone trusted it.
In contrast, our current FDA leaders are once again producing theater to trigger emotions. It’s what they do best. Via podcasts, Fox News interviews, and “leaked” memos, they are teasing “profound revelations” about dead children and hidden data, complete with dastardly villains and brave heroes, namely themselves. They’ve given us a preview of coming attractions. The grand reveal is coming soon. Stay tuned for more!
We need to be clear about the function of this theater. First, it is a form of COVID revisionism, allowing doctors who were wrong about herd immunity, natural immunity, the vaccines being a perfect panacea, and pretty much everything else to absurdly claim their pandemic vision has been vindicated. We were right about the horrors of vaccine mandates all along!
Second, these tragedies of dead children will provide our medical establishment with a much-needed distraction from their gross incompetence, at least until the next wave of purges and righteous resignations. Every moment spent relitigating vaccine battles from 2021 is a moment not spent discussing their failure to contain measles, pertussis, and botulism in baby formula today.
Finally, these salacious allegations will provide a pretext to spread doubt and mistrust about all vaccines. If they lied about the COVID vaccine, what else are they hiding? Anti-vaxxers have long fantasized about “secret hidden data” (remember the “CDC whistleblower” pseudoscandal), and the leaders of the FDA will soon deliver it to them. The hepatitis B vaccine was just the first causality in their war, and the FDA leaders are all in on Kennedy’s anti-vaccine agenda.
We also need to get ahead of their game, or at least catch up to their running start. When the FDA leaders eventually release their evidence, likely with great fanfare and pageantry, people will parse over every detail like religious scholars. However, the FDA leaders have already poisoned any possibility of a fair discussion with their dramatic roll-out. This was their intention, of course.
No matter the quality of their evidence, quacks and sycophants will eagerly amplify their claims of a cover-up. They’ve already declared the FDA leaders have proved their case beyond a doubt. They don’t need to see the evidence. Their blind support for government doctors is baked in.
In contrast, those us who actually care about evidence will try to keep an open mind, but we will justifiably question anything our FDA leaders produce. We know their abysmal track record. We know they’ve obsessed over this side effect for years and have previously made false claims of COVID-vaccine fatalities. We know they have to please their boss, Kennedy. We know how they minimize children killed and injured by viruses- “breathless coverage of rare anecdotes of MIS-C and death in kids.” We know they start with their policy opinions and work backwards to retrofit the “evidence.” We don’t have to play dumb and pretend these are neutral, unbiased, reliable actors. We are also aware that FDA insiders, the anonymous people who deserve our trust, vigorously disagree with how their leadership has spun these 10 cases thus far, calling it a “huge exaggeration.”
We have many reasons to be skeptical of our medical establishment. Unfortunately, anyone who expresses the slightest doubt of them, even by simply asking to see evidence, is invariably dismissed as part of the cover-up, on the payroll of Big Pharma, and a censor who wants to make brave doctors disappear.
Dr. Makary’s theatrics made sure of that.


The PULS test and COVID-19 vaccinations
No, nobody has proven that the COVID vaccine series increases your risk of heart attack. Here’s why.
Frank Han on December 7, 2021
Link

You may have heard about a recent abstract submitted to the American Heart Association sowing doubt in regards to the safety of the COVID vaccinations based on the results of a blood test. I as a pediatric and adult congenital cardiologist, am here to advise you that this abstract doesn’t mean what you think it means. To understand the context behind this abstract, several puzzle pieces of knowledge are required.
Levels of evidence
While the American Heart Association is one of my professional organizations, whose members are mainly cardiologists and cardiac surgeons, not everything they produce is the highest level of evidence, and this has always been this way. For anyone who has not attended an AHA scientific session, you will hear cardiologists debate the most controversial topics in the field and get very passionate about their sides of the argument. If you have never experienced cardiology before, you would rightly wonder whether these cardiologists know anything at all about their work. What you will not hear though, is a cardiologist able to overturn cardiac physiology or fundamental principles in the field. For example, we will always have newer ways to treat coronary artery disease, however it is an absolute impossibility for anyone to overturn the fact that aortic valve stenosis will eventually need to be treated if it is severe enough. The fact that a big atrial septal defect in a teenager needs to be fixed, will never be overturned. The best kinds of new insights about cardiology will take into account existing knowledge while expanding our knowledge about areas of the heart that aren’t as well studied. The things discussed at scientific conferences are uniquely the topics that are at the fuzzy edge of the known and unknown.
How do we sort out what evidence is best? The levels of evidence that we rely upon in cardiology are similar to the levels of evidence in other clinical fields:

An abstract falls in the “Case Series and Case Reports”/”Expert Opinion” category. An abstract can be created by anyone who wants to introduce their research project, and it has the lowest peer review requirement. I, as a lowly first year cardiologist, can also produce an abstract about anything that I want to write about. It takes considerably more teamwork, with peer review, to write something like a clinical practice guideline or a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
Plaques and heart attacks: Some basic considerations
It is known in cardiology that having high cholesterol strongly influences your risk of heart attack, however, there is not a 1:1 relationship. There are people out there who control their cholesterol very well, and still suffer from heart attacks. Conversely, I have personally seen children with severely elevated cholesterol who do not have heart attacks. There is an inherent difference in plaques (the actual lesions that cause heart attacks when broken); some are more prone to fall apart and create a heart attack (a “vulnerable plaque”), and some are more stable, leaving the people with these plaques mostly unaware of their presence. Considerable effort has been devoted to figuring out why some plaques are more dangerous, and others less so. The current state of the science of the vulnerable plaque focuses on using different types of imaging to identify them in the arteries of the heart, using artificial intelligence and fluid dynamics. This debate is still an area of much research to this day, and the latest research has in fact discovered that most vulnerable plaques when ruptured, do not create heart attacks. Further, plaques that rupture and heal may actually contribute to coronary narrowing rather than themselves generating heart attacks. For all these reasons, the science of detecting which plaque will create the heart attack is still advancing.
What is the PULS test?
The world of laboratory science has put forth many blood tests to try to identify the more dangerous plaques, and one of these is the PULS (in some journals referred to as CADPA). It is a relatively new lab test by GD BiosciencesTM designed to test several proteins naturally present in the body with a goal of improving risk-based stratification of patients with coronary artery disease (the classic heart attack).
The biomarkers measured by the PULS test include:

A score is then compiled that estimates the risk of heart attack in the patient. While the score is the subject of some promising research, and draws its validation from seminal studies in Cardiology (ADVANCE, Orentreich, PMRP-Marshfield, and MESA), it is not standard of care in every cardiology office because more validation is required before it can be elevated to the level of a clinical practice guideline. A clinical guideline is the highest level of guidance for cardiologists that informs items such as the sequences of medications used to treat a brand new heart attack or how to place a heart stent.
What is the nature of this study?
The author of the AHA abstract is a cardiac surgeon turned holistic health practitioner, and based upon review of his website and this abstract he appears to frequently do PULS blood tests. He tested samples of some patients’ blood using PULS before and after vaccination, and compared the results. The actual data analysis, based even upon review of the abstract, is unclear. The PULS data from two patients are presented in the abstract, and the author concludes that the cardiac risk of the patients is therefore elevated. He also recommends that people take aspirin and quercetin to mitigate their post-vaccination risk of cardiac issues.
What are the methodological flaws of the study?
In this type of study, at the bare minimum, a statistical analysis of the subjects and comparison to controls is expected, to see if the intervention (in this case the vaccine) created an effect that can be demonstrated to be different from people who did not receive the experimental intervention. This was not explicitly demonstrated anywhere in the abstract. An abstract is the most basic level of science that can be submitted to the American Heart Association, so this appears to have flown under the radar of peer review (abstracts are subjected to a relatively low level of peer review). If the author intends for readers to understand the risks of COVID-19 versus vaccination, the more complete thing to do is to compare the much bigger, and much more deranged, immune response of COVID disease to the immune response to COVID vaccination. There were also no efforts to compare the immune response in COVID vaccination to the response shown in classical adult booster vaccines such as influenza or pneumonia. Most importantly, if you run a test designed to search for inflammation after a procedure designed to generate temporary inflammation, you will find inflammation. Macrophages, T cells, eosinophils, and collagen remodeling are expected responses after any infection. He also stated that aspirin and quercetin might benefit the user if taken after vaccination. There is no evidence provided in the study to show they decrease your inflammatory markers after vaccination. Furthermore, the PULS test was never validated with vaccinations.
Members of the antivax ecosystem will never tell you this – the only way they can promote their views is to take studies out of context and overstate the risks. There is no evidence that will change their minds. Rather, they look for any shred of evidence that validates their pre-existing biases and ignore nuance, context, or contradictory evidence. By contrast, a responsible clinician or scientist is prepared to change their mind once sufficient evidence arises to challenge existing beliefs.
What is a better way to interpret this article?
Because this is so important, it bears repeating – if you run a test designed to search for inflammation, after a procedure designed to generate temporary inflammation, you will find inflammation. This is similar to saying if you drive 100 kilometers, you will expect to find the petrol tank to be lower at the end. The decreased petrol level is not an indictment on the safety of the petrol tank.
I do not wish to discount the experiences of those who have experienced genuine heart attacks after COVID vaccination because I know these people exist. However, it is crucially important to realize that the preconditions of the heart attacks were already there. One of the most common ways to discover a heart attack is through “minding your own business”, not knowing you almost had a deadly problem. One of my previous professors, who thankfully survived, discovered his coronary artery disease in this way, while shoveling snow. Coronary artery lesions are a complex interplay of atherosclerosis, inflammation, high cholesterol, stress, and genes. The vaccination did not place the coronary artery lesions in the patient. If the heart attack had happened 2 days before the COVID vaccination, it would have been deemed unrelated. Because some heart attacks have happened after COVID vaccination, it is easy to deem them related when this is not necessarily the case. Should patients find out their coronary artery status prior to COVID vaccination? This is too costly to be applied to the entire world. However, if you are interested in determining if you have coronary lesions prior to vaccination, you are welcome to do so. Know that doing this will find a lot of people with no heart artery issues.
        ◦ The abstract is at best, in my opinion, potentially useful in guiding the ongoing investigations into postvaccine myocarditis, but only in the hands of trained immunologists and cardiologists. This abstract is too widely misinterpreted, and those who profit from disinformation are only too happy to use this work to advance their cause. A basic rule of research is to not overstate your conclusions when your project doesn’t have the data to support those conclusions. This abstract as submitted, essentially wants to show vaccines have more risk than was previously reported. This has been repeatedly demonstrated to be false by many centers. The abstract also fails to take into account that patients with coronary artery disease are amongst those who suffer the worst outcomes if they experience COVID. On this basis alone – people with heart failure and coronary artery disease in fact, need COVID vaccination the most (this is a known comorbidity increasing severity of COVID disease). Only hearing about the risks is an unbalanced assessment. Discussions of vaccine safety must always place the risks into the context of the very significant benefit they provide to adults, even (or especially) those with pre-existing coronary artery disease.

Letter to a Medical Student: You Erred. You Are Owed an Apology.
While you are an adult who is responsible for your own words, the editors of Sensible Medicine did you a grave disservice by letting you publish your article.
Jonathan HowardonNovember 6, 2022
Link

Dear Mr. Allely,
I recently read your article on Sensible Medicine titled “Failing Our Kids: Myocarditis in Young Boys“. You wrote about yourself, a healthy 25-year-old male, and said “I faced a far higher risk of being hospitalized with the vaccines I was mandated to take than if I had simply been infected with Covid…These data covered today suggest that we may have inflicted a greater number of hospitalizations on young boys by vaccinating them”.
To be blunt, I expected more from a medical student. Let’s go over how you came to your conclusions, why they were flawed, and why I think the doctors in charge of Sensible Medicine owe you an apology.
First, let’s discuss the risks of the vaccine. You cited a recent paper from Israel and said, “the risk of myocarditis from Pfizer vaccination in males from 16-29 years as 10.7 in 100,000. So roughly 1 in 10,000.” Though the rates of vaccine-myocarditis vary widely from one study to the next, that rate seems reasonable to me, especially when discussing adolescents, nearly all of whom received the Pfizer vaccine. This was the only sensible part of your essay.
With regards to the clinical course of vaccine-myocarditis, you castigated Dr. Eric Topol who described the condition as “mild”. You said:
Whether a median of three days of hospitalization can ever be considered mild is another question. I would argue that if you take a healthy young middle school boy and put him in the hospital for a few days you’d damn well better be sure the upside from your intervention is far greater.
However, you failed to let your readers know it’s not just Dr. Topol who describes vaccine-myocarditis this way. The Israeli paper you cited said:
The clinical course appears to be mild and benign over a follow-up period of 6 months, and cardiac imaging findings suggest a favorable long-term prognosis.
Literally every study on this topic reports the same thing, and though grave outcomes have occurred, including the deaths of a few young men, they are vanishingly rare. Here’s a collection a papers on the subject, none of which you quoted:
    • “All patients in this series had a benign course; none required intensive care unit admission” (Dionne)..
    • “All 7 patients resolved their symptoms rapidly” (Marshall)..
    • “All were discharged after a median of 2 days. There were no readmissions or deaths” (Diaz).
    • “Hospital course is mild with quick clinical recovery and excellent short-term outcomes” (Jain).
    • “All patients received brief supportive care and were recovered or recovering at the time of this report” (Montgomery).
    • The clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis-like illness appears favorable, with resolution of symptoms in all patients” (Rosner).
    • ” All the cases were clinically mild” (Mevorich).
    • “Acute clinical courses were generally mild” (Gargano).
    • “The mild phenotype of myopericarditis cases in our study were comparable with cases described in other studies, except 1 patient with myocarditis and MIS-C, who needed treatment at intensive care unit” (Nygaard).
    • “Most cases of myocarditis were mild or moderate in severity” (Witberg).
    • “The clinical course was mild in all six patients” (Mouch).
    • “All patients had resolution of their chest pain, were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, and were alive with preserved left ventricular ejection fraction at last contact” (Larson).
    • “Most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine myocarditis occurring in persons <21 years have a mild clinical course with rapid resolution of symptoms” (Truong).
    • “95% are considered to be mild cases” (Israel Ministry of Health).
    • “Most vaccine-associated myocarditis events have been mild and self-limiting” (Patone).
    • “Most cases were mild, and the symptoms resolved without extensive intervention” (Lee).
I won’t criticize you for saying vaccine-myocarditis shouldn’t be called “mild”. We both agree that it’s a big deal whenever a child is hospitalized, and around 20% individuals have persistent symptoms. However, your quarrel about calling vaccine-myocarditis “mild” isn’t just with Dr. Topol – it’s with dozens of doctors from around the world who, unlike us, actually cared for these patients and wrote the papers we read and cite. Your misinformed readers won’t know what they said. They’ll just think it was just Dr. Topol who minimized vaccine-myocarditis.
Your discussion of COVID’s risk was blatant misinformation. I really don’t know how else to describe it. To minimize the virus, you cited a CDC MMWR from June 2021 titled “Hospitalization of Adolescents Aged 12–17 Years with Laboratory-Confirmed COVID-19 — COVID-NET, 14 States, March 1, 2020–April 24, 2021“. It found:
COVID-19 adolescent hospitalization rates from COVID-NET peaked at 2.1 per 100,000 in early January 2021, declined to 0.6 in mid-March, and rose to 1.3 in April. Among hospitalized adolescents, nearly one third required intensive care unit admission, and 5% required invasive mechanical ventilation; no associated deaths occurred.
You claimed that since no adolescents were vaccinated at this time, “these data is the worst case scenario”. You said:
At the peak of hospitalization from Covid in this age group, 2.1 per 100,000 adolescents were hospitalized with Covid. None died. Pfizer’s vaccine data from the NEJM study suggests that just under 9 per 100,000 adolescent boys were hospitalized with myocarditis. None died. So risk of hospitalization from Pfizer’s vaccine series may have been over four times as likely to land a young boy in the hospital than Covid over this time period.
Everything about this is wrong. Let’s go over the problems one at a time. First, you stated no adolescents died, which was true for the 204 hospitalized adolescents in the CDC report from COVID-NET data. However, that data doesn’t tell the whole story. COVID-NET is a surveillance network that covers about 10% of the US population. That other 90% matters. The American Academy of Pediatrics, which collected data from 43 states, reported that 296 children had died by the end of April 2021. So yes, some adolescents died of COVID during this time period. Your misinformed readers won’t know this.
Moreover, your comparison is absurd. You wrote, “So risk of hospitalization from Pfizer’s vaccine series may have been over four times as likely to land a young boy in the hospital than Covid over this time period”. However, the risk of an adolescent being hospitalized was 2.1 per 100,000 the week ending January 9th, 2021. This was not their risk of being hospitalized during the entire first 13 months of the pandemic. Your statement would have been accurate had you said, “So risk of hospitalization from Pfizer’s vaccine series may have been over four times as likely to land a young boy in the hospital than Covid on January 9th, 2021.” Of course, every vaccine would fail if its risks and benefits were judged this way.
Common sense should have told you the adolescent hospitalization rate was higher than 2.1 per 100,000. If the hospitalization rate were this low, this would mean that only 450 adolescents ages 12-17 would be hospitalized if every single one of them was infected in the US. In fact, many thousands of adolescents have been hospitalized.
Additionally, you provided no rationale for why you chose to evaluate to risk of the virus only from March 1, 2020–April 24, 2021. Did COVID vanish after this? No. In fact, the second year of the pandemic was much worse for children than the first. Mitigations measures vanished, and the Delta and Omicron variants arrived causing unprecedented illness in children. The time period from March 1, 2020–April 24, 2021 was far from the “worst case scenario” as you said. In reality, 20% of pediatric deaths occurred during the Omicron wave. About 180 children died from COVID in January 2022 alone. Your misinformed readers won’t know this.
Hospitalization Rates Ages 12-17
Of course, the Delta and Omicron variants would have taken a much greater toll on adolescents had none been vaccinated, and to your credit you acknowledged “that vaccines decrease the risk of severe disease”. This is all vaccine-advocates have ever said. However, it’s a really important point, and you short changed your readers by glossing over it.
To pick one study you ignored, a CDC MMWR titled “Characteristics and Clinical Outcomes of Children and Adolescents Aged <18 Years Hospitalized with COVID-19 — Six Hospitals, United States, July–August 2021” found that “Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one (0.4%) was fully vaccinated”. That seems like a pretty big deal to me. Why didn’t you tell your readers about this?
Moreover, this CDC report found that children hospitalized with COVID were very sick, and a few died:
Approximately one half (54.0%) of patients hospitalized for COVID-19 received oxygen support, 29.5% were admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU), and 1.5% died; of those requiring respiratory support, 14.5% required invasive mechanical ventilation (IMV).
Neurological complications are not rare in children hospitalized with COVID. Despite this, you wrote, “Covid hospitalization in young men is rare and mild, if we want to use Dr. Topol’s standards”.
Really?
Can you not see the difference between a child hospitalized for a few days with vaccine-myocarditis and a child intubated for nearly 1.5-weeks with COVID? After being intubated for 11 days, 15-year-old Paulina Velasquez said:
My message, technically is: If you’re eligible to get the vaccine, please do. I plan on getting vaccinated as soon as my doctor lets us know when I can.
She spent over a month in the hospital and had to relearn basic motors skills. Such outcomes are not common with COVID, thankfully, but they are not exceedingly rare either. Other children have needed amputations or had strokes. Over 1,800 children have died of COVID, including healthy teenage boys who were eligible to be vaccinated. Over 9,000 children have suffered from MIS-C, and most of these children go to the ICU. 74 children have died of MIS-C. It’s not minimizing vaccine-myocarditis to say these grave outcomes are exceedingly rare from the vaccine. No children are known to have died from it.
Your readers won’t know any of this. You didn’t discuss this CDC report or any of the other 19 studies (I compiled them here) showing that the vaccine has already protected many children from the worst harms of the virus, including MIS-C. Even though they say things like “All 7 deaths occurred in patients who were unvaccinated” you decided not to inform your readers about them. Even during the Omicron wave, studies reported that only unvaccinated children died of COVID.
I am not a mind-reader, so I don’t know if the glaring omissions and inappropriate comparisons in your article were because you didn’t know basic information or because you purposefully neglected to mention anything that would undermine your argument. Assuming your article merely reflected your ignorance of this topic, the good news is that there is a simple way to prevent this problem in the future. If you write about a subject outside your expertise, ask someone who is an expert to read your article first. They will likely bring a perspective you lack.
I am sure there are pediatricians at your medical school who can tell you what it is like to care for a child sick with COVID. I suggest talking to them would be more useful than a conversation with the doctors at Sensible Medicine, none of whom care for sick children. Maybe you could ask them whether their hospitals were filled with children suffering from vaccine side-effects or from COVID. I think I’ll know what they’ll say.
I am sure other experts will help you too. Dr. Frank Han, for example, is a pediatric cardiologist who has treated children throughout the pandemic and published on vaccine-myocarditis. I imagine he’d be willing to read your articles. Like you, I am not an expert in pediatric cardiology, so I’ve asked for his help before.
I do worry, though, that there may be a larger problem. I fear that you weren’t careless. I worry that you started with a conclusion and selectively presented only the information that would advance your narrative. I worry that you purposefully avoided sharing facts that cast the vaccine in a good light or the virus in a bad light.
This is characteristic of writers on Sensible Medicine. I previously wrote about these doctors and said, “If ten data points are needed to understand the risks and benefits of the vaccine, they cherry pick the three that support their position”. Some doctors at Sensible Medicine unabashedly want unvaccinated children to get COVID, saying that that it is “natural and healthy” when children get sick and that pediatric COVID vaccine-advocates are “off their rocker“. This is why they receive favorable coverage from leading anti-vaxxers such as RFK Jr.
I can’t help doctors who simply don’t care whether their work is accurate and thorough. However, I can warn you. I advise you to read a previous article of mine (and this by Dr. David Gorski) about the dangers of doctors who have to say increasing outrageous things to pander to their audience. That article concluded that having the wrong audience is worse than having no audience.
I imagine my article will upset you. You’ll feel victimized and attacked. That’s how everyone feels when criticized. However, I urge you to resist the natural temptation to immediately dismiss what I’ve said simply because it was blunt and critical. We all make mistakes, and I’ve had to issue a couple corrections to my writing here. I’ve thanked the people who pointed out my errors. Only people who disagree with us can point out our flaws and make us better. Surrounding yourself in an echo-chamber, like many writers at Sensible Medicine, is a guaranteed way to make sure you won’t improve.
You are an adult who is responsible for your own words, especially when you use your credentials as a medical student. However, the editors of Sensible Medicine did you a grave disservice by letting you publish your article. They owe you an apology, and I mean that very seriously. It was their job to help you know your limitations and ensure your writing met basic standards of academic quality. They failed you. Their careers are safe. Yours is just starting.
So let me try to help you in ways they won’t.
Those who oppose child COVID vaccines are contradicting nearly every pediatrician and medical association with the relevant expertise. These are the people who cared for sick children throughout the pandemic and created the medical literature we rely on. They may be wrong. They are not infallible or immune to challenge, even from a medical student. However, you have to backup your arguments with thorough, rigorous data, not just the cherry-picked, manipulated data points that fit your narrative. To paraphrase you, if you take a 14-year-old football player and expose him to a virus that could kill him, you’d damn well better be sure you had a good reason not to vaccinate him.
While it’s fun to pretend that you are smarter than doctors with the real-world experience and responsibility you currently lack, I suggest that you keep in mind this quote by David Brin.

“Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect”
Dr. John Mandrola, a cardiologist and founder of the monetized misinformation blog Sensible Medicine, recently promoted an article titled “They Suffered Myocarditis After Covid-19 Vaccination Years Later Some Still Haven’t Recovered“. The article shared several sad stories of people affected by vaccine-myocarditis. As described by its author:
    • One military member recalled being pressured by commanders and his mother to get a vaccine. He still feels chest pain to this day.
    • A professional biker who experienced heart inflammation after COVID-19 vaccination must monitor his heart rate levels to make sure he doesn’t tax his heart too much.
    • An American doctor received a vaccine in January 2021, shortly after they were cleared. He still experiences pain.
    • A young boy who suffered myocarditis at 14 has resumed exercise, but his mother still worries.
    • Another boy, who was 9 when he suffered the inflammation, “still has periods when his heart hurts,” his mother told us.
The article was not published in a peer-reviewed medical journal, but rather The Epoch Times. According to its Wikipedia page:
The Epoch Times is a far-right international multi-language newspaper and media company affiliated with the Falun Gong new religious movement.
A section titled “COVID-19 Coverage and Misinformation” begins:
The Epoch Times has spread misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic in print and via social media including Facebook and YouTube. In 2022, Raquel Miguel of the European watchdog EU DisinfoLab said, “The Epoch Times has played a noticeable role in transmitting and amplifying many anti-vaccine narratives”. 
While anecdotes shared by anti-vaccine misinformation websites should always be approached with great skepticism and never amplified by responsible doctors, in this case they are entirely plausible. While most people with vaccine-myocarditis recover, some have persistent symptoms. The vaccine harmed them, and they deserve sympathy. There have even been a small number of deaths outside of the US. I am unaware of the mRNA vaccines causing any definite deaths in the US, but I suspect the number isn’t zero.
For these reasons, Dr. Mandrola has consistently worried that people are minimizing this side-effect. He’s authored an article titled Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect, Not Absolutism. “Humans have only one heart; inflaming it at a young age is not a small thing”, he wrote, about the vaccine. Dr. Mandrola expressed similar concern on social media many times. Although the doctors who’ve treated these patients and published their findings universally find “the vast majority of cases to be clinically mild”, Dr. Mandrola feels they are wrong about their own patients. Though he is seemingly unperturbed by anything the virus can do to the heart – “even in the sickest of the sick, Covid-19’s effect on the heart appears to be modest” – when the vaccine is to blame, he rejects the entire concept of “mild myocarditis”.
Fair enough. I wouldn’t call it “mild” had my son been hospitalized after the vaccine, and I’d still be worried, even if he recovered “quickly” as nearly all teens do.
With the vaccine, there’s no such thing as mild myocarditis
“No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus”
With that in mind, let’s revisit a study titled “All-Cause Excess Mortality and COVID-19–Related Mortality Among US Adults Aged 25-44 Years, March-July 2020“, which was published on December 6th, 2020. It found that 4,535 COVID deaths were recorded among young adults during the pandemic’s first 5-months.
Some people felt 4,535 was a concerning number of young people to have died from COVID in such a short time, especially considering there had been just 4.49 million confirmed cases of COVID by the end of July 2020. One article from January 10, 2021 titled “COVID-19 Has Killed Thousands of Young Americans. This is Not Just a Tragedy For the Elderly” reported on two families whose 21-year-old sons died of COVID. The families described “how quickly and severely the young men got sick”. “He wrapped his arms around me and he died in my arms,” the mother of one victim said. “He was a perfectly healthy, 21-year-old college athlete who did all the things he should to stay healthy and it took him down,” said the father of the other victim.
“No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus”
Others were less concerned by thousands of deceased young people. Indeed, Dr. Mandrola had reassuring thoughts on these 4,535 young adults, killed by COVID in the prime of their life. Along with a fellow “medical conservative” Dr. Andrew Foy, he authored an essay on December 29th, 2020 titled “No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus“. It encouraged its readers to focus on the tens of millions of young adults who hadn’t died of COVID, while ignoring the fact that tens of millions of young adults had yet to contract COVID. The authors were very concerned that young people might overestimate their risk of COVID and try too hard to avoid it. They wrote:
We offer four reasons why this study and OpEd do not support the claim that young adults should live in fear from the virus…
An excess of 12,000 deaths sounds bad, but Professor Don Boudreaux, from George Mason University, has noted that there are nearly 88 million people in this age group. Thus, the individual risk for a person this age is found by dividing 4,560 (the number dead from COVID19 in this study) by 88 million. This equates to a 0.0052% risk of dying from COVID19.
Their article concluded that:
The young have many reasons- ethical and moral–to adhere to social distancing during the pandemic. Fear of death is not one of them.
Drs. Mandrola and Foy did not discuss adverse COVID outcomes other than death. 16-year-old Kitty McFarland described her experience with Long Covid by saying, “You go through so many phases of up and down, it’s like being on a rollercoaster forever.” Al Brown, a young, healthy father, needed a heart transplant after his bout with COVID. Candice Davis, an unvaccinated 30-year-old, lost three of her limbs and half of her foot. That someone could survive COVID, but be seriously injured by it, did not factor into their advice that young people should face the virus without fear.
However, despite knowing that COVID killed 4,535 young adults in just 5 months and that only a relatively small percentage had been infected, Drs. Mandrola and Foy told them their “fear of death” was misplaced. Moreover, they chose to convey this incautious message at perhaps the most pivotal point in the pandemic. There was good news. Vaccination campaigns had begun just 2-weeks prior. There was bad news. 2,438 Americans died on the day it was published, and the peak of the deadliest wave came less than 3-weeks later, when over 3,000 Americans would die daily. When it finally subsided in the spring of 2021, Dr. Mandrola again reminded his audience, “Young have almost no risk“. He was speaking about the virus, of course, not the vaccine.
The Delta and Omicron variants arrived within a year, and approximately 40,000 young adults age 25-44 have now died of COVID. Countless others survived, but were gravely injured. There would have been many fewer such tragedies had young adults lived with a bit more fear of the virus and a bit less fear of the vaccine.
“Nobody Should Go Through This. He Was Only 36 and I’m 35 and We Have Three Kids.”
So let’s be clear what’s happening here. The same doctor who told young people not to fear literal death after COVID killed 4,535 young adults in 5-months with drastic mitigation measures in place, is now sharing a handful of (plausible) stories from an anti-vaccine misinformation page to again scare people about the COVID vaccine. It’s “don’t minimize myocarditis from the vaccine” by the author of “don’t fear literal death from COVID“.
While the professional biker who must monitor his heart rate levels to make sure he doesn’t tax his heart too much deserves sympathy, is he really worse off than Faith Voss-Paulson, a 40-year-old mother of four who died of COVID after refusing her daughter’s pleas to get vaccinated? I don’t think so. To paraphrase Dr. Mandrola:
Humans have only one life; losing it at a young age is not a small thing. Mild death only occurs in other folks’ kids.
To add to the absurdity, while nearly 40,000 young adults died of COVID, not nearly that many developed vaccine-myocarditis. 1 in 2,200 young adults has died of COVID, which is higher than the rate of vaccine-myocarditis, a condition that usually resolves.
Respect the thing that won’t kill you. Don’t fear the thing that might.
The Epoch Times shared anecdotes, knowing that emotional stories are often more powerful than data. I also often remind my readers about the real-world consequences of misinformation. A news story titled “Though Young and Healthy, Unvaccinated Father Dies of COVID” explains why I believe death is worse than vaccine-myocarditis. It said:
Healthy and in their 30s, Christina and Josh Tidmore figured they were low-risk for COVID-19. With conflicting viewpoints about whether to get vaccinated against the virus filling their social media feeds and social circles, they decided to wait.
On July 20, Josh came home from work with a slight cough initially thought to be sinus trouble. On Aug. 11, he died of COVID-19 at a north Alabama hospital as Christina Tidmore witnessed a doctor and her team frantically try to resuscitate her husband.
“She would say, ‘I need a pulse. ‘I would hear, ‘no pulse,’ “Christina Tidmore said through tears. “They were trying so hard.”
According to his widow, “Josh was completely healthy, active, not a smoker.” She added, “Nobody should go through this. He was only 36 and I’m 35 and we have three kids.”
Josh would almost certainly be alive today had he been vaccinated. Unfortunately, many prominent doctors used their platform and credentials to falsely pacify him about the virus that killed him, instead of providing him accurate information about the vaccine that could have saved him. Neither Dr. Mandrola nor The Epoch Times ever had anything to say about Josh or any of the other thousands of dead young adults who chose not to live in fear of COVID and died as a result.
Maybe Dr. Mandrola is right, and at least when the vaccine is the cause, there is no such thing as mild myocarditis. However, there’s certainly no such thing as mild death. And the many doctors who repeatedly told young people not to fear literal death from COVID, should be ignominiously ignored when they sanctimoniously scold us for supposed minimizing something that is milder and less frequent than say, literal death. This includes vaccine-myocarditis, and anything else that is less impactful than 40,000 young lives lost to COVID and countless more seriously injured by it.
Part 2 is coming up.

Part 2: Is an Abnormal Lab Value After Vaccination More Concerning Than Death From COVID?
Jonathan Howard on November 3, 2023
Link

“There is No COVID Heart”
On May 14, 2021, three “medical conservatives,” Drs. John Mandrola, Andrew Foy and Vinay Prasad, published an article titled “Setting the Record Straight: There is No ‘Covid Heart’”. In it, they argued that “The issue of Covid-19 induced cardiac problems was massively overblown.” Though the virus had existed for barely over year, they were very confident it would cause few long-term cardiac sequelae. “Even in the sickest of the sick, Covid-19’s effect on the heart appears to be modest,” they wrote. They were reassured by a study of patients who had recovered from severe COVID. Even though the study reported that “myocardial infarction was found in 19% and inducible ischaemia in 26%,” Drs. Mandrola, Foy and Prasad described it thusly:
Cardiac magnetic resonance scans done during convalescence showed that nearly half of the individuals had no major heart abnormalities, and 9 out of 10 had normal heart function.
Although this means that over half of the patients had a major heart abnormalities, they concluded, “People who have recovered from Covid-19 have no special reason to worry about their hearts.”
While in reality, many people who have recovered from COVID do have reasons to worry about their heart, Drs. Mandrola, Foy and Prasad made one point I agree with. They wrote:
Screening low-risk patients with MRI and other fancy tests is neither necessary nor wise.
This is exactly right. All medical tests should either guide care or provide patients with information they need to plan their lives. Performing a battery of tests on asymptomatic people will invariably turn up a slew of “abnormalities” of dubious significance, which are certain to cause anxiety, but unlikely to improve outcomes. 
“Subclinical Myocarditis”
However, something happened that completely changed their opinion on screening low-risk patients for cardiac damage. A study from Thailand found the COVID vaccine caused an elevated troponin (a marker of cardiac injury) in 4 of 301 (1.3%) of children who had no cardiac symptoms. In contrast to COVID patients with actual myocardial infarction, Dr. Prasad felt these children had a special reason to worry about their hearts. He fretted extensively about “subclinical myocarditis” on social media, as well as his monetized YouTube and Substack channels.
“Screening low-risk patients with MRI and other fancy tests is neither necessary nor wise.”
Not all doctors were so concerned about this abnormal lab value. Dr. Frank Han, a pediatric cardiologist who has actually treated patients with vaccine-myocarditis and published on it, discussed “subclinical myocarditis” here at SBM. He wrote:
The definition of subclinical myocarditis is a patient with lab, imaging, or EKG findings consistent with myocarditis, but minimal or no symptoms (minimal chest pain, shortness of breath, or palpitations for example).
In other words, someone with “subclinical myocarditis” feels fine, and abnormal lab values are not synonymous with myocarditis. As Dr. Han explained:
Troponins are a useful test to help confirm myocarditis, but I emphasize that troponin in the bloodstream is not diagnostic of myocarditis by itself – it is a cardiologist’s role is to sort out all the other causes of troponin in the bloodstream such as physical exercise… Cardiologists have formalized the criteria for myocarditis to avoid diagnosing every person with troponin in the blood with myocarditis. This would be misdiagnosis and, unnecessarily frighten the patient
Indeed, a vigorous game of soccer can elevated troponin levels in children. So can COVID. One study found 7% of children with COVID had “subclinical myocarditis,” though the authors wisely concluded:
Routine troponin screening does not yield much information in previously healthy paediatric COVID-19 patients without any sign of myocardial dysfunction. Elevated troponin levels may be observed but it is mostly a sign of myocardial injury without detectable myocardial dysfunction in this group of patients.
While this makes sense to me, it’s certainly possible that “subclinical myocarditis” will lead to a scar and cause a problematic arrhythmia in the future. However, to the extent that this is to be feared, the virus poses a greater threat than the vaccine. Most importantly, the danger is entirely theoretical.
This is not true of COVID itself, of course. It has killed around 2,000 children and hospitalized 200,000 more. Some of these children are very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU. Rarely, children have had strokes, seizures, or needed amputations. Around 9,500 children have developed MIS-C, and most of these children go to the ICU. At least 79 children have died from it. Not all children feel back to normal after their infection and we have to be humble about the possibility of long-term consequences of repeated infection.
This all seems worse than an elevated troponin level in a child who feels fine, does it not?
Theoretical Versus Real Harms
Fortunately, multiple studies have shown the vaccine can drastically lower these rare, but grave harms in children. This is why the authors of the paper from Thailand on “subclinical myocarditis” concluded:
Overall, COVID-19 mRNA vaccination has an extremely favorable outcome and should be recommended for adolescents.
Many doctors felt otherwise, and Dr. Han also noticed the tendency of those who worry about “subclinical myocarditis” to be much less concerned about known harms of the virus. He wrote:
The crowd that is most anti-COVID vaccination is very supportive of the finding of subclinical myocarditis in this article without considering its limitations…people who wish to instill fear about vaccination myocarditis rarely stays consistent.
That’s an understatement. Look how Dr. Prasad discussed the theoretical harms of the vaccine versus the real harms of the virus, including literal death.
(Misinformation alert: COVID killed many more children than the flu )
I suppose I’m just a breathless fear mongerer, but I feel death is worse than an abnormal lab value. Before the pandemic, my view wouldn’t have been controversial amongst doctors.

As Diseases Spread and Trust in the FDA Crumbles, Its Leaders Are Obsessed with an MRI Abnormality in 1 in 61,500 Males Ages 12-24
Our medical establishment told people to “Stop Trusting the Public Health Establishment”. Now, almost no one trusts our medical establishment.
Jonathan Howard on July 18, 2025
Link
Most concerning, over a median follow-up of 159 days, 60% of individuals (98/161) with initial late gadolinium enhancement
Things are not going well at the FDA. Recent headlines declare: Inside the Staff Exodus and Tanking Morale That Threaten Makary’s FDA and Inside the Collapse of the F.D.A. Meanwhile, dangerous diseases are spreading. Recent headlines declare: Measles Cases in the U.S. Hit the Highest Total Recorded in More Than 30 Years, ‘Fighting to Breathe’: Whooping Cough Surges as Vaccination Rates Drop, Pediatric Flu Deaths Hit Record High For Non-Pandemic Season, and CDC Says COVID-19 Cases Rising in 25 States.
Yet, at this moment, with all that’s going on, the FDA’s leaders, Drs. Marty Makary and Vinay Prasad, have devoted most of their time and energy to protecting Americans from the grave “dangers” of COVID vaccines. Using their government power to repeatedly override vaccine-experts and reject our medical freedom has been their top priority. As Dr. Georgios Pappas put it:
The policy proposed by Prasad and Makary violates the right of individual persons to protect themselves from an infection with considerable mid- and long-term sequelae.
Drs. Makary and Prasad initially made their case in a widely panned NEJM editorial, An Evidence-Based Approach to Covid-19 Vaccination. This was followed this up by an official FDA warning and a JAMA editorial titled US FDA Safety Labeling Change for mRNA COVID-19 Vaccines.
Their own data shows the absurdity of their concern. Drs. Makary and Prasad revealed the COVID vaccine was totally safe for nearly everyone. They had to dig deep to find a problem with it, and so they turned to their favorite topic, vaccine-myocarditis. Drs. Makary and Prasad have been obsessed with this side effect for 4 years, producing a deluge of spooky content to encourage COVID infections in unvaccinated young people.
In their JAMA article, Drs. Makary and Prasad said vaccine-myocarditis occurred in males aged 12-24 years at a rate of 1 in 37,000. They revealed that nearly all patients fully recover, something that’s been known for years, and that a lingering MRI abnormality in 60% of them was the “most concerning” part about it all. They wrote:
Most concerning, over a median follow-up of 159 days, 60% of individuals (98/161) with initial late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) had persistence and a minority (5% [5/98]) had worsening LGE and symptoms. A total of 4% of patients (11/272) continued to have arrhythmias at a median follow-up of 31 days and 2% required antiarrhythmic medications. These findings raise questions about the benefit-risk assessment for COVID-19 vaccination in healthy male adolescents and young adults.
This translates to 1 in 61,500 overall young men overall, or about 450 abnormal MRIs if every American male age 12-24 were to get the vaccine. Those are the stakes. That’s what all the fuss is about. By way of comparison, at the peak of the Omicron wave in January 2022, nearly 1,000 children were being hospitalized with COVID every day.
Dr. Prasad also devoted an entire speech to this MRI finding. Listen to how serious and sober he is as he discusses late gadolinium enhancement after the vaccine. It is “not benign,” he said.
Breathless coverage of rare anecdotes of MIS-C & death in kids
Dr. Prasad didn’t always feet this way. In his article Setting the Record Straight: There is No ‘Covid Heart’, he argued that late gadolinium enhancement after myocarditis was “no special reason to worry”. Is myocarditis dangerous or not? According to our medical establishment, myocarditis is dangerous only when it is caused by the vaccine.
In reality, COVID myocarditis killed some young people, while the vaccine has not, and COVID’s harms are not restricted to myocarditis. However, our medical establishment has a long history of treating vaccine side effects more seriously than anything COVID could do. In their view, it was a “truly unacceptable” to accurately report that vaccine-myocarditis was almost always “mild“, however it was “breathless” to even mention literal death from COVID. That was just “rare anecdotes,” just 19 dead kids in a single month. He spoke in a vulgar, unprofessional manner about anyone who disagreed.
While our medical establishment treated entirely hypothetical risks from the vaccine with the utmost seriousness, nothing the virus did mattered them. Just listen to how Dr. Prasad spoke about children going to the hospital with COVID during the Delta wave versus how he spoke about “subclinical myocarditis“- which is nothing more than an abnormal value in a kid who feels fine. He never worried that repeat COVID infections might not be good for kids.
And this is all still going on today. Compare how Dr. Makary speaks about “vaccine injuries” versus his casual dismissal of children dying of measles. “We have to be honest with people,” he said as he embraced “soft eugenics” and falsely claimed only children with underlying medical conditions were vulnerable to measles.
The observed vaccine efficacy was 100%
While our medical establishment claims to value data and evidence, SBM readers know this performative nonsense. Though both the virus and vaccine were new, they greatly overhyped the vaccine in early 2021, promising it offered perfect protection against severe disease, blocked transmission, and would end the pandemic. When reality proved otherwise, they turned against the vaccine with a vengeance rather than admit error.
Our medical establishment always opposed vaccinating children, and Dr. Prasad started his anti-vaccine campaign in January 2021 months before there was any data about the pediatric COVID vaccine when he thought the pandemic was “abating“. In the video below, from February 2021, Dr. Prasad spread obviously fake statistics- COVID only kills 1 in a million children– and fear mongered about mundane vaccine side effects such as headaches and fevers. There was no data about the pediatric COVID vaccine at the time, but Dr. Prasad’s mind was already made up.
The data from the randomized-controlled trial (RCT) in adolescents was released in March 2021 via a company press release. It was published in the NEJM in May 2021, and all 16 COVID cases occurred in the placebo group. The Delta and Omicron variants arrived later that year causing unprecedented sickness in children. The AAP says COVID hospitalized 234,000 children over all the first four years of the pandemic. Unsurprisingly, dozens of observational studies have since shown its value in limiting these rare, but grave COVID harms in children. None of this mattered to Dr. Prasad. You can read his entire body of work and not learn any of this. He didn’t feel his readers deserved to learn these basic facts from him.
While Dr. Prasad never devoted a single thought to any child harmed by COVID, he made an overwhelming amount of scary content like this.
Similarly, as Omicron loomed in December 2021, our medical establishment laughed at and mocked anyone who wanted the first booster dose. Even though the results were only available as a press release at the time, an RCT of 10,000 people showed that it was safe and 95% effective at preventing COVID. It was published in the NEJM several months later, and it doesn’t take a genius to imagine a vaccine dose that lowered infection rates would also lessen severe disease.
The results from a large observational study were also available when this podcast aired. It found:
Vaccine effectiveness evaluated at least 7 days after receipt of the third dose, compared with receiving only two doses at least 5 months ago, was estimated to be 93% (231 events for two doses vs 29 events for three doses; 95% CI 88–97) for admission to hospital, 92% (157 vs 17 events; 82–97) for severe disease, and 81% (44 vs seven events; 59–97) for COVID-19-related death
None of this mattered to our medical establishment. No RCT, no observational trial, no COVID variant, no packed pediatric hospital or dead child altered their anti-vaccine ideology one bit. They never looked back. They didn’t care at all.
It’s data from families that say their kids have been acting with bad behavior … and they eliminate the petroleum-based food dyes and the behavior improves. That is data.
In their JAMA article, Drs. Makary and Prasad predictably demanded new “randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in these populations prior to issuing further marketing approvals.” In contrast, when it comes to things they want to be true, anything goes. They are fine limiting vaccines without RCTs, and commenting on another trivial risk, petroleum-based food dyes, Dr. Makary recently said:
We have a lot of data and it may not necessarily be the traditional 50 year randomized control trial follow up. It’s data from families that say their kids have been acting with bad behavior … and they eliminate the petroleum-based food dyes and the behavior improves. That is data.
For our medical establishment, the drone-like phrase: gold-standard science and common sense, gold-standard science and common sense, gold-standard science and common sense, common sense and good science means: We will demand incredible evidence for things we don’t want to be true and use vibes to justify things we want to be true. As Dr. Ben Mazer put it:
In the current health administration, we’re witnessing the birth of a new medical philosophy: EBMOFCV Evidence-Based Medicine only for Covid Vaccines
This risk-taking approach may, in part, be responsible for widespread loss of trust in public health and medicine
Despite their inglorious track record of failed predictions and pro-virus disinformation, Drs. Prasad and Makary had the audacity to end their JAMA article by speaking about trust. They wrote:
During the COVID-19 pandemic, broad, one-size-fits-all mandates were aggressively pursued, requiring vaccines in populations with potentially net-negative benefit-risk profiles. This risk-taking approach may, in part, be responsible for widespread loss of trust in public health and medicine and growing hesitancy against all vaccination. Public trust takes decades to build, but can be forfeited in a single action. The FDA’s class SLC action on mRNA products represents one step toward rebuilding that trust.
I know whom I blame for the “widespread loss of trust in public health and medicine and growing hesitancy against all vaccination” and it has nothing to do with a rare, temporary vaccine side effect that was widely-publicized and discussed.
Though it was recently scrubbed from the FDA’s website to make it seem as if it had been covered it up, the FDA warned about vaccine-myocarditis as early as June 2021. So did the CDC. It was hardly some state secret. I’ve written extensively on this side effect, starting in June 2021. So have many others. No one is just now discovering it thanks to the courage of Drs. Makary and Prasad, and they are the only ones who talk about it constantly today. Americans are not breathing a collective sigh of relief because finally, they put an end to our national nightmare of vaccine-myocarditis. No one thinks Drs. Makary and Prasad are heroes because they saved a narrow demographic group the minuscule risk of an abnormal MRI after a voluntary vaccine.
The medical freedom community is calling for the resignation of podcaster surgeon Marty Makary, the new FDA Commissioner.
Fortunately, it’s not my job to restore trust in the FDA. That is up to its leaders, and it’s not going well for them. Prior to assuming office, Dr. Prasad gave interviews called Stop Trusting the Public Health Establishment, and many people absorbed his message. Now, the knives are out for them from all directions. Cranks are “calling for the resignation of podcaster surgeon Marty Makary” because they haven’t banned all COVID vaccines, and a recent editorial in the Washington Times titled Trump Agenda For Biotech Being Sabotaged From Within was all about Dr. Prasad. It said:
An affinity for central planning is the hallmark of progressive thinking. Dr. Prasad’s FDA is moving away from the America First principle of trusting parents and doctors to make medical decisions back toward the failed Obama-Biden approach, which lets unelected, unaccountable bureaucrats decide who gets a chance at life. He wants the government to define what counts as “effective” or “appropriate” and force families to beg for permission from unelected elites in Washington.
Dr. Prasad’s rise is an example of what Mr. Trump means when he refers to “the deep state.” He is a careerist insider, left-wing ideologue working from within to hollow out the president’s biotech revolution by ceding administrative and regulatory power back to the bureaucrats and the woke elite. Mr. Trump should remove him from his posts before he pushes his personal, anti-MAGA agenda any further, causing irreparable harm to the American biotech industry.
Meanwhile, medical organizations with relevant expertise are suing them, and vaccine experts are rightfully mocking them. They are utterly silent as their boss does all he can to contribute to “growing hesitancy against all vaccination.” They don’t really care about that at all.
Trust in our medical establishment is justifiably tanking, and 100 more articles and podcasts about an MRI abnormality won’t fix that. Incredibly, ensconced in a bubble of their own creation, Drs. Makary and Prasad seem to actually have fallen for their absurd notion that a rare, “mild” vaccine side effect was the root cause of mistrust for millions of furious Americans. Once the FDA finally comes clean about vaccine-myocarditis, everything will be just fine. I could have told them they were high on their own supply and wrong about all that.
Drs. Makary and Prasad are the medical establishment now. It’s our right to hold them accountable, and it’s their job to earn our trust. They are failing badly. They signed up for this, and they only have 3.5 more years to go, though sadly the rest of us are along for the ride.
    • 

Yet Another Silly Reason Doctors Give For Leaving Babies Vulnerable to COVID: 🍒-Picking
By cherry-picking only the studies that advance their agenda, contrarian doctors who don’t care for sick children can misinform parents and further their goal of having unvaccinated children contract COVID.
Jonathan Howard on July 17, 2022
Link

In a previous article, I described how silly it was for doctors to demand a million-child randomized-controlled trial of children under the age of 5 years in the middle of a raging pandemic. I also mocked the idea that the best way to maintain trust in routine pediatric vaccinations was to misinform people about the COVID vaccine for children. I’d like to explore two more silly reasons doctors have given for leaving unvaccinated babies vulnerable to COVID.
For part 1, I will remind you of a previous article where I described how contrarian doctors selectively report and omit information to minimize pediatric COVID and frighten parents about vaccines. There has been a deluge of research throughout the pandemic, and it’s not hard to find one or two studies that support any preconceived viewpoint, even if these studies are outliers from the general trend. It’s also really easy just to not mention unwanted facts, namely that COVID can be really bad for a very small percentage of children, that rare tragedies add up to non-trivial numbers when tens of millions of children get COVID, and that the vaccine isn’t perfect, but it has consistently been shown to limit COVID’s harms for children.
Honest brokers do their best to report the totality of the evidence. However, by cherry-picking only the studies that advance their agenda and refusing to share unwanted facts, doctors who don’t care for sick children can misinform parents to increase the numbers of unvaccinated children who contract COVID. Two recent articles by familiar names demonstrate this misleading technique.
Vaccine myocarditis: Rate
With this in mind, let’s review the latest information on vaccine-myocarditis. Vaccine-myocarditis most commonly occurs in adolescent and young-adults males several days after their second vaccine dose. Most, but not all, studies found a higher rate with Moderna compared to the Pfizer. Until last month, only the Pfizer vaccine was authorized for children in the US. Below are the rates of vaccine-myocarditis for young males after their second dose of the Pfizer vaccine, except where noted otherwise. (If I learn of other studies, I will add them).
    • USA: 1 in 2,650, 12-17 years
    • Hong Kong: 1 in 2,700, 12-17 years
    • USA (Vaccine Safety Datalink): 1 in 6,800 12-17 years, no statistical signals for children 5-11 years
    • Meta-analysis: 1 in 7,200-20,000, 12-17 years with “low certainty” after an mRNA vaccine
    • Israel: 1 in 9,350, 16-29 years
    • Denmark: 1 in 10,000 12-17 years, either vaccine dose
    • Israel: 1 in 12,000 12-15 years
    • Ontario: 1 in 12,300, 12-17 years
    • USA (VAERS): 1 in 13,000 16-17 years, 1 in 21,500 12-15 years, 1 in 400,000 5-11 years
    • USA: 1 in 16,600, 12-17 years
    • Nordic registry data: 1 in 17,500, 16-24 years
    • Nordic Countries: 1 in 18,200, 16-24 years
    • Singapore: 1 in 20,700, 12-19 years (includes myocarditis/pericarditis and Pfizer/Moderna)
    • French national health system (Epi-phare): 1 in 38,500, 12-29 years
    • France: 1 in 52,300, 12–17 years
    • UK: 1 in 71,000 under 18 years (males and females, first or unknown dose), 1 in 100,000 (males and females, second dose)
    • Denmark: No increased risk for males
In case you missed it, I’ll highlight that one American vaccine-safety monitoring found a rate of 1 in 400,000 for males 5-11 years, while the other found no “statistical signals” for this age. According to one CDC report, after 8.7 million Pfizer doses given to children ages 5-11, there were only 11 cases of myocarditis. Seven of the children had recovered and 4 were “recovering”. Additionally, it’s now well-known that the rate can be greatly reduced by spacing out the vaccine doses. A study from Ontario found a rate of 1 in 100,000 for adolescent boys with an extended interval between doses.
As virtually no children older than 5 (slide 20) are receiving their second vaccine now, many more cases have already happened than will happen in the future. I’m confident the number of times I’ve discussed this topic exceeds the number of children currently hospitalized with it, which plausibly is zero. Several other doctors can say this as well.
Vaccine myocarditis: Clinical course
While there is clearly great variability regarding the rate of vaccine-myocarditis, the clinical course entirely consistent across all studies. Affected children feel chest pain, shortness of breath, palpitations, and fatigue. Nearly all are hospitalized, and there are markers of cardiac inflammation on routine tests. While it’s never a trivial matter when a child is hospitalized, most leave feeling fine after a couple days. All studies report the condition is nearly always mild, with a good outcome:
    • “All patients in this series had a benign course; none required intensive care unit admission” (Dionne)
    • “All 7 patients resolved their symptoms rapidly” (Marshall)
    • “All were discharged after a median of 2 days. There were no readmissions or deaths” (Diaz)
    • “Hospital course is mild with quick clinical recovery and excellent short-term outcomes” (Jain)
    • “All patients received brief supportive care and were recovered or recovering at the time of this report” (Montgomery)
    • The clinical course of vaccine-associated myocarditis-like illness appears favorable, with resolution of symptoms in all patients” (Rosner)
    • ” All the cases were clinically mild” (Mevorich)
    • “Acute clinical courses were generally mild” (Gargano)
    • “The mild phenotype of myopericarditis cases in our study were comparable with cases described in other studies, except 1 patient with myocarditis and MIS-C, who needed treatment at intensive care unit” (Nygaard)
    • “Most cases of myocarditis were mild or moderate in severity” (Witberg)
    • “The clinical course was mild in all six patients” (Mouch)
    • “All patients had resolution of their chest pain, were discharged from the hospital in stable condition, and were alive with preserved left ventricular ejection fraction at last contact” (Larson)
    • “Most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine myocarditis occurring in persons <21 years have a mild clinical course with rapid resolution of symptoms” (Truong)
    • “95% are considered to be mild cases” (Israel Ministry of Health)
    • “Most vaccine-associated myocarditis events have been mild and self-limiting” (Patone)
While this is good news, a very small number of children have needed treatment in the ICU or have not fully recovered. Though they seem headed in that direction, they will likely face restrictions with vigorous activity until they do. While the condition should not be minimized for these reasons, the long-term clinical picture looks mostly encouraging as well. According a recent CDC report/a>,
At least 90 days after myocarditis diagnosis, most patients who were reached reported no impact on their quality of life, and most did not report missing school or work.
Radiographic abnormalities (late gadolinium enhancement) have been found on follow-up cardiac MRI several months later in several studies. While these parameters were improved from baseline, their clinical significance is unknown. As such, affected individuals will have to have their cardiac status monitored over time. Though there have been some fatalities associated with mRNA vaccines, most occurred in adults older than 50. 23.3 million American children have received two vaccine doses, and there are no clear fatalities as far as I know.
Risk versus benefits
Obviously, the risk of the vaccine has to be viewed in the context of its benefits. Because they consider both the risks and benefits, nearly all pediatricians, including cardiologists, continue to strongly advocate for pediatric vaccination. As they work with sick children, they know that their hospitals have been deluged with COVID patients at times, but none have opened a vaccine-injury ward. That’s why they are “alarmed” at low pediatric vaccination rates. This is in contrast to the doctors I criticize who believe “natural immunity” will protect children, though enough children remain vulnerable that over 300 are being hospitalized with COVID daily.
Fortunately, the vaccine continues to limit these severe outcomes, even with Omicron. This includes the vaccine’s ability to prevent MIS-C, which can cause much a more severe myocarditis in 75% of affected children. (Happily MIS-C seems to have vanished for now). Several studies (here and here) have found the vaccine’s benefits outweigh the risks for all age and sex subgroups, though this could change if new variants escape our current vaccines.
Cherry-picking
What relevance does any of this have to vaccinating children younger than 5 years? Most pediatricians would answer “none at all”, given the extremely reassuring data from children ages 5-11 years and that younger children will receive a lower vaccine dose. If the vaccine is routinely given to young children, they might need fewer shots when they are older and most vulnerable to vaccine-myocarditis.
Unfortunately, not all doctors felt the need to communicate this information in an informative, nuanced way when discussing the vaccine for young children.
Dr. Marty Makary, who said we had reached herd immunity over a year ago, warned:
The small size of the studies in children under 5 makes it nearly impossible to observe rates of rare complications such as myocarditis, which occurs in 1 in 2,650 12-17 year-old boys after the 2nd dose. This complication has been associated with EKG changes in children and even concerning MRI findings months after recovering from myocarditis. The New England Journal of Medicine reported one case of vaccine-associated myocarditis death in a 22-year-old in an Israeli population study. Keep in mind that babies can’t tell you when they have myocarditis.
Dr. Tracy Hoeg, who suggested last year that pediatricians were confusing COVID and RSV, similarly wrote:
The trials, in other words, enrolled only a fraction of the number of participants that would have been required to determine efficacy against end points like severe disease, hospitalization, and rare adverse events such as myocarditis, which has been linked to COVID vaccination in males in the 12- to 17-year-old age group at a rate of up to 1 in 2,700.
The cherry has been picked.
Did Drs. Makary and Hoeg reference these particular studies because they had the strongest methodology? Of course not. They shared them as established fact for one reason only – they had the highest rate of vaccine-myocarditis. The many larger studies showing lower rates, especially for children ages 5-11, were unmentionable. Similarly, because the vaccine-myocarditis almost always has a favorable prognosis, neither doctor reported this, though the death of a 22-year-old in Israel was used to scare parents. The fact that babies have the highest risk of dying from COVID and that over 500 children younger than age 5-years have died so far was also unmentionable. All harms of the virus are unmentionable, as is all evidence that the vaccine can limit these harms.
While at least Drs. Makary and Hoeg shared an accurate number, which was by no means certain given their previous work, here’s why this cherry-picking matters. Very few people who read their essays will know they were only told a very small fraction of the relevant information. The governors they advise (Florida, Virginia) are likely similarly ignorant. And so, many people are now wildly misinformed, and some politicians are recommending against vaccinating children.
In early 2021, Drs. Makary and Hoeg both felt herd immunity was just around the corner and so there was no need to vaccinate children. Rather than say “I was wrong”, their goal now is to frighten parents by casting the vaccine in the worst possible light and to pacify them by casting the virus in the best possible light. Judging by the abysmal vaccination rate for young children, they’ve succeeded. As pediatric hospitalizations creep upwards once again, nearly matching the Delta peak of last summer, they should visit a children’s hospital and take a well-deserved victory lap.

Viral Videos of Alleged Vaccine Side Effects
These viral videos do not represent vaccine side effects.
Steven Novella on January 25, 2023
Link

Recently Elon Musk, owner of Twitter, has boosted videos of people alleging neurological side effects shortly after receiving one of the COVID vaccines. These videos started appearing after the vaccines were first rolled out, but often news stories have a second or third life on social media. It’s a good opportunity to look back at the data we have so far regarding the side effect profiles of the various COVID vaccines, and also give some much-needed perspective on these viral videos.
According to the CDC: “More than 667 million doses of COVID-19 vaccine have been given in the United States from December 14, 2020, through January 18, 2023.” That is a huge set of data, and side effects have been carefully tracked through various monitoring mechanisms. In order to establish that a symptom or disease is actually a side effect of a vaccine we need more than the simply fact that they occurred sometime after a vaccine dose. With so many doses given, people will continue to get all the ailments of life at the usual rate, and by coincidence along many people will get sick after getting the vaccine.
Monitoring systems generally report anything adverse that happens after receiving a vaccine as a side effect. They then leave it to epidemiologists to do statistical analysis, to see if the risk of any particular negative outcome is more likely after receiving a dose of a particular vaccine than the background rate. They can also compare negative outcomes among the various vaccines. So far there have been only four serious adverse event types where it seems likely the risk is higher after receiving a COVID-19 vaccine. These are: 
    • Anaphylaxis (a potentially life-threatening allergic reaction)
    • Thrombosis with thrombocytopenia syndrome (TTS)
    • Myocarditis/pericarditis
    • Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS)
All of these adverse events are extremely rare, but they do seem to have occurred at higher rates than the background rate (matched for demographic features). Of note, however, GBS only occurred after the J&J/Janssen vaccine, not after either mRNA vaccine (Pfizer or Moderna). Also TTS was only caused by the adenovirus vaccines (J&J and AstraZeneca), not the mRNA vaccines.
All of these adverse events have something in common – they are caused by immune activation. This is the kind of side effect one would expect after a vaccine, which triggers immune activity. TTS can cause blood clots in the brain, and GBS attacks the nerves, so they are included as neurological complications. Otherwise there have been no major neurological complications of the COVID-19 vaccines established epidemiologically. Specifically, there is no link to seizures or any movement disorder.
One potential neurological side effect remains controversial – Bell’s palsy, a form of facial paralysis. There may be a small increased risk with viral vaccines (but no more than other vaccines), but probably not with the mRNA vaccines. If there is an increased risk, it must be tiny as the data cannot clearly establish a link. Further, there is a strong signal that COVID itself can cause Bell’s palsy, so getting vaccinated is likely protective overall.
With that update on the data for side effects, what do we make of the viral videos showing alleged neurological side effects? Before I comment I want to point out that I generally do not agree with making remote medical assessments of public figures. Sometimes I will comment on the commenting, but otherwise I think such information should come from medical professionals who have done a proper assessment and have the permission of their patient to make certain details public. I also think it’s reasonable to legally require people seeking certain public offices, such as the Presidency, to disclose basic health information through an objective source. Otherwise, people publicly speculating (without objective information or even a medical background) about medical diagnoses is inappropriate, of little value, and should not be magnified.
I make two exceptions to this rule. The first is when people post their own medical information online in order to promote a point of view, either to promote a treatment, warn about a risk, or impact the conversation on a public health issue. In such cases they chose to put their own medical information into the public square and a response is fair game. Still, I aim to be respectful and not overstep what is necessary to counter dangerous misinformation. Second, I tend to limit my comments to those cases where there is enough public information to have an opinion (otherwise I just point out the lack of such information). I also tend to stick with neurological issues, since I am a neurologist. In particular, videos of claimed movement disorders are amendable to analysis because the diagnosis is mostly in just looking at how subjects move. Yes, a direct exam provides more information, but sometimes the movement itself is the key, and a video is adequate.
With all that in mind, let’s take a look at three videos of alleged COVID vaccine neurological side effects. None of them provide objective medical information. They are simply anecdotes, of limited clinical utility and unable, by themselves, to establish cause and effect. There is also good reason to conclude, just from watching the videos themselves, that they are not vaccine side effects.
The first is of Angelia Desselle (one of the videos promoted by Musk). The video certainly looks dramatic, but to a neurologist’s eye this does not conform to any known movement disorder. There are only so many ways in which the parts of the brain that control movement can be damaged or function abnormally. The most likely diagnosis in this case is what is known as a functional movement disorder (a specific type of functional neurological disorder). These are real neurological disorders, but they are not caused by pathology or anything biological with the nervous system. They are complex disorders thought to be mainly a manifestation of psychological stress. The patients are generally not “faking it”. That tends to be the most common public comment by non-experts, and it is almost certainly incorrect. Again, these patients have a real and serious disorder that requires complex treatment, but it is not the kind of thing that can be directly caused by a vaccine.
The second video of Shawn Skelton is also typical for a functional movement disorder. These are definitely not seizures. They are not typical for any other known movement disorder. The third video is also of Shawn Skelton. This is less-specific shaking. From this video alone it would not be possible to completely rule out (or in) seizures, but in the context of the other video it is more likely functional. The third video is titled: “Does the moderna cause seizures???? Yes it does!!!”
By all available evidence, no, it doesn’t. Seizures have not been established as a side effect for any COVID-19 vaccine, including Moderna. Even if she were having seizures, that would not establish that they were caused by the vaccine. And the provided video evidence does not establish she is having seizures, but rather is more likely to be a functional neurological disorder.
According to reports:
However, since the video was released, Skelton has been treated and released from Deaconess Orthopedic Neuroscience hospital, according to the Evansville Courier & Press newspaper. Skelton says MRIs, CT scans and blood cultures came back no results, and doctors told her her problem is probably stress-related.
Translation: Functional neurological disorder.
I think the best response to such videos is for experts to set the record straight, and then for the public to subsequently ignore them. Of course, that’s not the culture of social media, but that’s my advice. There is nothing to be gained from confrontation. Such people deserve our sympathy, and their privacy should be respected as much as possible – even though they forfeited their own privacy by posting videos of themselves online. The goal is to mitigate the spread of misinformation as much as possible, while minimizing personal backlash.
Either way – these videos are not reliable medical evidence. They are anecdotes and very likely do not represent true vaccine side effects. It is unfortunate that some have chosen to exploit them to promote dangerous antivaccine misinformation. Meanwhile, after billions of doses given, the COVID-19 vaccines have proven extremely safe and effective.

COVID-19 Vaccination and Factors Contributing to Vaccine Refusal
An examination of COVID-19 vaccine refusal in Hong Kong suggests that fostering trust in health authorities, boosting confidence in vaccines, and combating misinformation are all necessary as we prepare for the next pandemic.
Scott Gavura on October 26, 2023
Link


As we’re now three years out from the beginning of the pandemic, there’s a lot of information emerging about our behaviors from one or two years ago. Given the demonstrable benefits of COVID-19 vaccination, it’s important to understand the reasons for declining the vaccine. Two weeks ago I looked at a study examining the use of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, and the relationship with endorsement of misinformation, or of lack in trust in scientists and physicians. Today I want to look at reasons for vaccine refusal in an non-American population – in this case, Hong Kong.
Background
Pre-vaccine, Hong Kong was regarded as having a strict but effective pandemic response. Its containment strategy failed as the more contagious Omicron variant took hold in 2022, and swept through a population that was poorly vaccinated. At that point, 82.4% of adults aged 80 and older were either unvaccinated or had received only one dose. By, comparison, these rates were 2.9% in New Zealand, 9.0% in Singapore, and 6.7% in England. Hong Kong subsequently experienced the highest daily COVID-19 mortality in the world, with 39.3 deaths per million people. While Hong Kong’s overall COVID-19 death rate per capita is lower than that of the UK and US, it has surpassed many other countries in the Asian-Pacific.
One hypothesis for the low vaccination rate was the fact that there were few or zero COVID-19 cases for extended periods, which could have led to complacency. However, low or zero COVID was achieved in other countries (e.g., Singapore, Australia, New Zealand) which subsequently had high vaccination rates. A more unique factor could have been the social and political changes that had occurred in Hong Kong related to a proposed extradition bill which divided Hong Kong residents and led to mistrust of officials (for some). In short, the extradition bill would allow Hong Kong to extradite criminal suspects to China (or any other country), even countries for which it didn’t have an extradition treaty. The bill was met with massive protests in Hong Kong. Groups like Amnesty International, Hong Kong Human Rights Monitor, and Human Rights Watch all voiced opposition to the bill.
This study, from Phylllis Lun and colleagues, which was published in JAMA Open on October 19, 2023, leveraged data from 20 waves of data from a prospective cohort study. It also drew upon a population-wide registry of all COVID-19 vaccination appointments. The researchers sought to measure the progression of willingness to get vaccinated into actual vaccine uptake. They also investigated the factors influencing the rejection of COVID-19 vaccines, and the overall effect on the population.
Patients were drawn from an ongoing population-based cohort study which had recruited over 18,000 adults and adolescents (>15 yrs). This study sampled just over 1000 from that group several times between 2020 through 2022. Response rates were good, at about 75%. The researchers also compared Hong Kong findings with a sample drawn from Singapore. Willingness to vaccinate against COVID-19 was assessed as receiving at least 1 dose of vaccine, making a vaccination appointment, or expressing an intention to vaccinate. COVID-19 vaccine refusal was defined as having no intention to receive COVID-19 vaccines. Political views were assessed as whether participants were “for, against or neutral” towards the extradition bill, which were classified as “proestablishment, nonestablishment, and neutral”, respectively. Trust in vaccine information sources was assessed by asking about the level of trust in the World Health Organization (WHO), government health authorities, physicians, academics, and traditional and social media platforms as information sources for COVID-19 vaccines. Vaccine confidence was assessed using 3 statements on the perceived effectiveness, safety, and importance of COVID-19 vaccines:
    • COVID-19 vaccines are effective
    • COVID-19 vaccines are safe
    • COVID-19 vaccines are important for children to have
Findings
Overall, an amazing 28,000 interviews were conducted.
Vaccination willingness – from before rollout to mass vaccination
In 2020 (pre-vaccine), around two-thirds (65%) of adults in Hong Kong expressed a willingness to get vaccinated once a vaccine became available. This willingness increased to 73% in response to positive COVID-19 vaccine trial outcomes, and a local outbreak. However, when the Hong Kong government announced the procurement of vaccines from Germany, mainland China, and the United Kingdom, with individuals not having the option to choose their preferred vaccine (though this decision was later reversed after 12 days), the willingness to vaccinate dropped to 55%. The launch of the vaccination program and a surge in media reports regarding adverse events following COVID-19 immunization were accompanied by a decline in vaccination willingness, reaching its lowest level at 44%:

The authors looked at the daily numbers of vaccine appointments over time. They noted that in adults aged 18-59, workplace vaccine mandates were associated with an increase in daily COVID-19 vaccination appointments by 74% and the vaccine pass in Hong Kong was associated with an increase of 131%. Vaccination appointments increased by 44% during the Omicron surge. However, lottery-based incentives were not associated with changes in vaccination appointments. In older adults (age ≥60 years), the vaccine pass was associated with a 94% increase in vaccination appointments, and subsequent reopening of premises under the vaccine pass was associated with an 112% increase. Similarly, the Omicron surge was associated with an increase in vaccination appointments (107%). Lottery-based incentives and workplace mandates were not associated with changes in vaccination appointments among older adults:

Factors Associated With COVID-19 Vaccine Refusal
Individuals holding “nonestablishment” political beliefs were more likely to refuse the COVID-19 vaccine when compared to those with “proestablishment” views among adults aged 18 and older (adjusted incidence rate ratio, 3.26 [with a 95% confidence interval of 1.63-6.51]). This was also observed in adults aged 60 and older,but to a lesser extent (adjusted incidence rate ratio, 2.10 [95% CI, 1.15-3.83]). Levels of trust in sources of vaccine information, confidence in vaccines, and misconceptions about vaccines differed based on an individual’s political views:

The study also found that political involvement during the 2014 “Occupy Central protests” was associated with a higher likelihood of COVID-19 vaccine refusal.
Vaccine Misconceptions and Trust in Vaccine Information Sources
Over half of the adult population (59%) in Hong Kong reported a major misconception about COVID-19 vaccines. In contrast, this number was 17% in in Singapore (Figure A below). Somewhat incredibly, at one point 57% of participants in Hong Kong opposed vaccination in adults aged 80 years and older, the age group that accounted for most COVID-19 deaths (see eFigure 9).
Figure B below shows the relative trust in different sources of information, which may be compared with a parallel assessment Singapore, where much higher trust overall was observed.

While opposition to vaccination went down over time (eFigure 9), these misconceptions may have had an influence on vaccine uptake in older adults, which was abysmal (eTable 1), leading to the horrendous death rate when the Omicron wave hit.
Vaccine refusal in adults aged 18–59 years was attributed to low vaccine confidence with regards to safety, effectiveness, and their and importance, and was also influenced by political views, distrust in the WHO, government health authorities and academics. In adults aged 18–59 years, building vaccine confidence with regard to the safety, effectiveness, andimportance of COVID-19 vaccines was analyzed to potentially change vaccine refusal rates by about 9%. Addressing mistrust in the WHO, health authorities and academics could move the needle a further 5%. Shifting political views could reduce refusal by 7% (adults aged 18-59) and 5% (ages >60 yrs).
Lessons and Interpretation
Examining international studies of vaccine acceptance and uptake allow us to look at data from our own countries with a different lens. This study of Hong Kong residents examined the shift in vaccination willingness from before vaccine distribution, to widespread vaccination. It identified the significant influence of political ideologies on both short-term and long-term COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Importantly, the researchers found that a substantial portion (about 73%) of the relationship between political views and vaccine refusal could be influenced by factors that may be changeable, such as mistrust in health authorities, low confidence in vaccines, and misconceptions about vaccines. This gives important lessons for public health organization and health professionals everywhere. If you’re a health care professional, your relationship with your patients may make an important difference in your patient’s vaccination willingness. Health care professional attitudes may have had an effect in Hong Kong. The authors noted that many physicians were unvaccinated and were also significant sources of vaccine misinformation. Clearly, attitudes can outweigh expected science literacy. If health care professionals aren’t convinced, their patients likely won’t be, either.
About 59% of adults in Hong Kong held at least one misconception about COVID-19 vaccines, substantially more that Singapore. As has been discussed elsewhere, even brief exposure to misinformation may impact vaccine perceptions. In this case, one in four adults in Hong Kong believed that COVID-19 vaccines posed a greater risk than the infection itself, a belief that persisted for a year, despite Hong Kong experiencing the world’s highest daily COVID-19 mortality rates at one point. How we can “vaccinate” against vaccine misconceptions is an open question, perhaps for another post. The authors suggest that building trust is key. Fostering trust in health authorities, government health agencies, and academic institutions could support “resistance” against misinformation and misconceptions with also supporting vaccine update and confidence. While I am a layperson and non-expert when it comes to Hong Kong, it appears the fractious relationship between residents and the government over the past several year may have led to a significant effect on confidence and trust, which led to deep skepticism of the COVID-19 vaccination campaign. Less than half of adults (47%) expressed trust in their government health authorities regarding COVID-19 vaccines, compared with 91.0% of adults in Singapore.
Where vaccine refusal is widespread, the authors argue that the primary explanations are more likely to be related to systemic, overarching factors rather than individual characteristics. They identified four key factors that they believe accounted for 75% of vaccine refusal among adults. While political views were found to be a contributing factor, they were not the primary cause. While mandates drove uptake in younger adults, they did not drive residential care resident and elderly vaccinations (and it did not appear there was a specific campaign to vaccinate this population).
Conclusion
This study offers a comprehensive examination of COVID-19 vaccine refusal in Hong Kong. It identifies potential factors contributing to Hong Kong’s low vaccination rates and identifies the challenges that face public health organizations in Hong Kong, with lessons for health care professionals and public health worldwide.
Trust is key. Trust in health authorities, health professionals and public health agencies, with trusted messengers to build confidence are lessons that extend beyond Hong Kong. Thinking about the bruising that public health agencies took during the pandemic (and the criticism they continue to face), highlights the challenge we face as we continue to deal with this pandemic while starting to prepare for the next one.

The Trolley Problem and Vaccinating Young People Against COVID-19
The harms we cause often lead to more grief than the harms we fail to prevent. Is this why some doctors are willing to leave young people vulnerable to a deadly virus?
Jonathan Howard on October 8, 2021
Link

Introduction: The harms we cause, the harms we fail to prevent
Death from COVID-19 is worse than myocarditis from the vaccine. Though this seems like an uncontroversial statement, intelligent doctors from prestigious universities have penned articles opining that it is preferable to leave young people vulnerable to the virus. While some doctors are clearly motivated by reflexive contrarianism and the media appearances that brings, I suspect that this viewpoint is partially explained by a quirk in how we perceive risk, specifically our tendency to view risks of omission differently from risks of commission. Put another way, we regret harms we actively cause more than those we passively fail to prevent.
The trolley problem
The choice to vaccinate young people against COVID-19 can be likened to the trolley problem. In this famous thought experiment, a trolley is about to kill five people. By pulling a lever, the trolley will be diverted, and just one person will die. Would you pull the lever?
Recognizing that a simple tug on a lever can save four lives, most people say they would pull it. However, a subtle twist can change people’s response. Consider the following:
As before, a trolley is hurtling down a track towards five people. You are on a bridge under which it will pass, and you can stop it by putting something very heavy in front of it. As it happens, there is a very heavy man next to you – your only way to stop the trolley is to push him over the bridge and onto the track, killing him to save five. Should you proceed?
In contrast to the original scenario, many people will reject pushing the heavy man. Yet other than feeling more responsible for the heavy man’s death, nothing has really changed. Multiple variations of the trolley problem exist, and they demonstrate that people feel differently about a bad outcome depending on whether they believe they caused the calamity or whether they merely failed to prevent it.
Moreover, people’s behavior depends on what they perceive the status quo to be, as this determines whether or not they perceive themselves to be taking an action. For example, people are more likely to save for retirement or be an organ donor when they have to opt out of doing so, rather than opting in. With regards to the trolley problem, while some people would be unwilling to push the heavy man on to the train tracks, they might also be unwilling to rescue him if he were in the process falling onto the tracks, as rescuing him would condemn five other people to death.
Medicine and the trolley problem
The practice of medicine is analogous to the trolley problem in that clinicians often must choose between harms they might directly cause versus harms they might fail to prevent. When a treatment harms a patient, clinicians naturally feel responsible, even if the treatment was appropriate. The desire to avoid harming patients at all costs is captured in the dictum “First, do no harm”. Taken to its extreme this would preclude any medication, surgery, or diagnostic test. Conversely, when a disease harms a patient, clinicians feel sympathy, but they are unlikely to feel personally responsible. This serves as a powerful motivation to avoid harming patients through action, even if inaction is more likely to result in substantial harm. Studies have provided evidence of the Omission Bias in doctors. In one study, pulmonary and critical care doctors were given scenarios involving the evaluation of pulmonary embolism and treatment of septic shock, two potentially fatal conditions. When an omission option was available, a majority of respondents chose a suboptimal treatment strategy.
Of course, a patient who is harmed by their illness may suffer more than a patient who is injured by a treatment. Though suffering from an illness is not necessarily reduced because it is “natural”, it is often perceived this way. In one study, many people refused a vaccine or medication against influenza due to potential side effects, even when it lowered the overall risk of a poor outcome. In contrast, many people were willing to accept a treatment as long as it was called a “natural herb”, even when the risks and benefits were identical to a treatment synthesized in a laboratory. The Omission and Naturalness Biases are driving factors behind anti-vaccine sentiments.
Currently, vaccinating young people feels like doing something and not vaccinating them feels like doing nothing. Moreover, the harms of vaccination, while uncommon, are highly visible, while the benefits to any individual are often invisible. For these reasons, the risks of vaccinating are often perceived as greater or unwarranted compared to the risks of not vaccinating. When a young person develops myocarditis after a vaccine, clinicians may feel responsible. In contrast, when a young person is harmed by the virus, individual clinicians will not feel culpable, even if the person dies from the virus. The harms of vaccination feel intentional, like someone stealing $20 from you. The harms of the virus feel accidental, like having $20 fall out of your wallet. Similarly, vaccine mandates for COVID-19 are perceived as a deviation from the status quo. Therefore, they have generated opposition from some doctors who previously voiced no concern over vaccine mandates other diseases like polio and measles. These mandates have existed for decades and are a routine part of life, and they were previously opposed by only the most dedicated anti-vaccine advocates.
According the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, 650 children and 3,643 adults age 18-29 have died of COVID-19 in the USA. The American Academy of Pediatrics has added 185 deaths to its tally since July 1st, including many teenagers who were old enough to receive the vaccine. After hundreds of millions, perhaps billions of doses, I am aware of eight possible deaths from the mRNA vaccines (here, here, here, and here) in the entire world and even these were mostly, if not exclusively, in adults. Though I’ve consistently argued that vaccine-myocarditis should not be trivialized, the virus is clearly more dangerous than the vaccine. Seat belts too can severely harm people, though these injuries are rightly considered mild compared to the injuries they prevent. As with seat belts, there is no rational reason to treat harms caused by the vaccine as categorically worse than harms caused by the virus.
Letting a child ride in a car without a seatbelt is doing something. Even though it might not feel that way, not vaccinating young people is also doing something; it is leaving them vulnerable to a dangerous virus. These harms are not just theoretical. Tragically, young people have died or needed mechanical ventilation in the ICU after declining the vaccine for fears of side effects. A recent study by the CDC found that unvaccinated children are hospitalized 10 times more often than vaccinated ones. As such, vaccines fit perfectly with the dictum “First do no harm”. Framing it this way takes the spotlight off the clinician and puts it where it belongs, on the patient. Clinicians must take care not to let their desire to appear blameless take precedence over what is actually best for patients. For this reason, I would pull the lever, steering young people away from the virus and towards vaccination, even though some will develop myocarditis. To others, however, the situation is more analogous to pushing a large man onto the train tracks. Lives would be saved, but at an unacceptable cost; they would feel responsible for those who were hurt by the vaccine.
Another thought experiment
With this in mind, I propose a thought experiment of my own.
Imagine that all children are born with perfect immunity to COVID-19, though this gift comes with a cost. About 1 in 8,000 boys will develop myocarditis when they hit puberty. This hospitalizes them for 2-3 days, however essentially all affected boys recover fully with simple treatments. They are advised to abstain from vigorous activity for several months and will have to be monitored over the long-term.
An enterprising doctor develops a medication that prevents this myocarditis, but negates children’s immunity to COVID-19. While the vast majority of children who take this medication will be fine, overall, young people who contract COVID-19 will be hospitalized at a higher rate than they were previously. Some will be very sick, needing ICU-level care and mechanical ventilation. Others will get long-COVID and feel sick for weeks or months. Those who take this medication are now at risk for viral myocarditis from the virus, and this will be life-threatening for some of them. If this medication is given to many millions of American children, thousands will get MIS-C, which is associated with more severe cardiac outcomes. Hundreds of children will die of COVID-19.
        ◦ Not vaccinating young people leads to the same grave harms as using this hypothetical medication. If you wouldn’t give young people this medication on the principle of “First do no harm”, then you should be in favor of vaccinating them against COVID-19.

Overhyping Vaccines Wasn’t Pro-Vaccine. It Was Pro-Stop-Worrying-About-COVID.
Overselling the vaccine in 2021 was not being pro-vaccine. It was pro-stop-worrying-about-the pandemic, from the doctors who assured us herd immunity was imminent. 
Jonathan Howard on October 1, 2023
Link

What it means to be pro-vaccine
In a previous article I discussed what I discussed what it means to be pro-vaccine. I wrote:
Being pro-vaccine means taking into account all of the relevant data to make a fair, accurate risk-benefit calculation about a vaccine…Though most vaccines are overwhelmingly safe and effective, their imperfections cannot be ignored or wished away.
No vaccine is 100% effective or safe, and being pro-vaccine means acknowledging their blemishes and areas of uncertainty, at least with new vaccines.
When the original COVID mRNA vaccine data was announced (here and here), they were 95% effective against COVID infection and even better against severe disease, though not 100% effective as several doctors claimed. There was a lot to be positive about, and it was vital to convey this information to the public. I encouraged vaccination with every patient I saw, and I still do. Countless people are alive today because doctors properly extolled the benefits of the COVID vaccines.
While optimism was entirely appropriate in early 2021, so was caution and humility. The virus was just a just year old, and January 2021 was the deadliest part of the pandemic. Over 3,000 Americans died on some days that month. The virus had given us many reasons to respect it in that first year, and we didn’t know what variants might be on the horizon.
The vaccines, of course, were brand new. Only 36,930 people had been vaccinated in the two mRNA trials, and they lasted just several months. The median age was 52-years, and trial participants are often unrepresentative of the public at large. There were just 347 cases of COVID, 40 severe cases, and only 1 COVID death in these trials.
It wasn’t possible to conclude from the original vaccine trials that the vaccines would be 100% effective against death. These trials taught us a lot, but they were the starting point of us learning about these vaccines, not the end. Over the next few months, hundreds of millions of people around the world would be vaccinated. We still had a lot to learn about their real-world effectiveness, especially over the long-term. We had literally everything to learn about their impact on viral transmission.
Because I am pro-vaccine, I hope I never portrayed them as a perfect panacea that would end the pandemic, and I did my best to acknowledge their unknowns. For example, in April 2021 I said:
Im very very optimistic vaccines will cut transmission of disease. I’m not certain of it. This is why I wear a mask still in public and when treating covid patients.
In May 2021, I warned of the “potential for development of escape variants” and discussed the significance of low vaccine-uptake in adults. I wrote:
I hope this ages poorly, but given the large numbers of unvaccinated adults, COVID-19 is likely to remain a threat to American children for the foreseeable future, especially in regions of low-vaccine uptake. Many scientists doubt that the US will achieve the vaccination numbers needed for herd immunity.
Sadly, immune-evading variants arrived and that did not age poorly. My track record here is not spotless, but I tried to take a medically conservative approach to the both the virus and vaccines. A doctor who exaggerated the vaccines’ benefits set the public up for disappointment and opened the door for anti-vaxxers spread doubt and mistrust.
Indeed, other doctors took a very different approach at the time. They relentlessly minimized the threat of variants- variants schmariants– and promoted vaccines as “essentially bulletproof”, both in terms of preventing severe COVID and halting viral transmission, with absolute certainty, just months after the first doses were given in December 2020. Some doctors mocked and ridiculed anyone who urged any caution at all after vaccination.
Assuming you agree with my definition of “pro-vaccine”, judge for yourself whether or not the following comments met that standard.
“For somebody who’s already been fully vaccinated…There’s an infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone.”
Dr. Monica Gandhi, January 9, 2021:
No time in history do we have this extraordinary detection of asymptomatic infection since latter can transmit to others. So, please be assured that YOU ARE SAFE after vaccine from what matters – disease and spreading. Two vaccinated people can be as close as 2 spoons in drawer!
Dr. Monica Gandhi, January 11, 2021:
So, why can two vaccinated people be as close as two spoons in a drawer? Because both are so highly protected from what matters- disease. Even though vaccines reduce asymptomatic infection (I bet much higher reduction after that 2nd dose, this is just before 2nd dose in Moderna)
Dr. Vinay Prasad, February 16, 2021:
A vaccinated grandparent can hug a young grandkid… we know the vaccine is 100% effective against protecting against bad outcomes for grandparent. (Author note: this was false at the time).
Dr. Vinay Prasad, February 18, 2021
Drs. Monica Gandhi and Zubin Damania February 22, 2021:
Dr. Damania: So Monica, I gonna tell something publicly that I have not said. This table is new, right? The last time you were here, I had a six-foot round table. We were six feet apart. This table is now about three feet. And the reason I’m doing that is, I believe with a 95% efficacy that two vaccinated people can hang out.
Dr. Gandhi: They could totally hang out. And remember, it’s not 95% efficacy against severe disease. It’s 100% against severe disease. (Author note: this was false at the time). And then yeah, maybe one person who got the vaccine will not feel well for a few days, because it was mild disease. So that’s the amazing thing. Keep on focusing on preventing what got us into trouble to begin with.
Dr. Damania: And even with variants, you know, if they’re gonna be setting against… ’cause the variance of the new bugaboo, right? Like, oh, we always knew there was mutations. That’s what coronaviruses do, all viruses do that. But the thing is if the vaccines are effective against severe disease, which they are, even against the Brazilian variant.
Dr. Gandhi: Yes. I really need to say something. I need to say variants shmariants.
Dr. John Mandrola March 10, 2021:
Ky (Kentucky) has vaccinated about 1 in 3 older people. CT (Connecticut) has done even better. The vaccine squelches severe cases. Millions have natural immunity. Young have almost no risk The pandemic (of bad disease) is nearly over. And this is a really worthy cause of celebration!!!!!!
Dr. Marty Makary, March 10, 2021:
An unpublished study conducted by the Israeli Health Ministry and Pfizer showed that vaccination reduced transmission by 89% to 94% and almost totally prevented hospitalization and death, according to press reports. Immunity kicks in fully about four weeks after the first vaccine dose, and then you are essentially bulletproof.
Dr. Marty Makary, March 18, 2021:
If anyone hears of a person hospitalized or dead from Covid-19 after full vaccination, please let me know. The data show that vaccines confer near perfect protection against death and hospitalization from Covid. Can’t we be honest about that?
Dr. Monica Gandhi, April 2, 2021:
Don’t worry, even the most pessimistic, variant-discussing, doom-steeped people are no match for the vaccines!
Drs. Zubin Damania and Jay Bhattacharya, April 14, 2021:
Dr. Bhattacharya: I mean, I think that the central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID…
Dr. Damania: Now, you and I are both vaccinated. We shook hands. We don’t wear masks. We’re about three feet apart from each other. And in the early days of the pandemic that would’ve gotten us both hung. But now I can say with confidence because I’ve looked at the data, like our chances of giving each other COVID are-
Dr. Bhattacharya: Are zero.
Dr. Damania: Pretty much zero…
Dr. Bhattacharya: The vaccine is incredibly effective… And in many ways has defanged the epidemic, it’s taken away the the specter of death and hospitalization that comes with the disease for the older population to the extent that the older population is vaccinated.
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, April 16, 2021:
Dr. Fauci is probably the number one anti-vaxxer in the country in some sense, because he has modeled behavior that has made people think the vaccine won’t give you back your life, but it will. It’s an incredibly effective vaccine. You know, he was wearing a mask. He has been vaccinated, I don’t really understand what he’s trying to do here.
Dr. Monica Gandhi, May 5, 2021:
Vaccinated people can be as close as two spoons in a drawer- I have said it before and I will finally just say it again now that we have all this data out there on the vaccines (tons of data on real-world effectiveness & transmission – will add to this Saturday – more studies!)
Dr. Vinay Prasad, May 13, 2021:
For somebody who’s already been fully vaccinated, they can wear the mask out of solidarity or in a symbolic sense, but their wearing a mask indoors is not benefiting anyone else. There’s an infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone.
Dr. Monica Gandhi, May 17, 2021:
Good to see this January 9 tweet has so much evidence behind it now in real world that vaccines block transmission since biological plausibility was ample.
Drs. Tracy Beth Høeg, Lucy McBride, Allison Krug, Monica Gandhi May 26, 2021:
As we saw in Israel and Britain, vaccinating adults indirectly protects children. The same trend is evident here in the United States: Adult vaccination has lowered covid-19 incidence among children by 50 percent in the past four weeks.
Dr. John Mandrola July 29, 2021:
If you were vaccinated and had mild to moderate URI symptoms, why on earth would you get a COVID test? Have the vaccines not transformed SARSCOV2 into just another regular respiratory virus?
These statements were not pro-vaccine. They were pro-stop-worrying-about-COVID.
I fully recognize that this is all written with the benefit of hindsight, but the vaccines did not turn out to be the miracle-cure-all we hoped they would be. According to one article from KFF in November 2022:
The share of COVID-19 deaths among those who are vaccinated has risen. In fall 2021, about 3 in 10 adults dying of COVID-19 were vaccinated or boosted. But by January 2022, as we showed in an analysis posted on the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, about 4 in 10 deaths were vaccinated or boosted. By April 2022, the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) data show that about 6 in 10 adults dying of COVID-19 were vaccinated or boosted, and that’s remained true through at least August 2022. (Author note: keep in mind the base rate fallacy. )
Someone who received only the first 2 mRNA vaccine doses in early 2021 might as well be unvaccinated today, and the Johnson and Johnson vaccine, is officially a historical relic, unavailable in the US. Meanwhile, the vaccine’s impact on transmission has fluctuated throughout the pandemic, but it has often been middling at best. Until better vaccines arrive, I will always mask at work.
Assurances the vaccines were “100% effective against protecting against bad outcomes for grandparent” and that they lowered the risk of transmission to “zero” were not pro-vaccine. These were pro-stop-worrying-about-COVID. At the start of 2021, these same doctors also claimed the end of the pandemic was imminent.
    • The same doctor who said “Don’t worry, even the most pessimistic, variant-discussing, doom-steeped people are no match for the vaccines!”, had previously given an interview titled Pandemic Exit Interviews: Stop Panicking About the COVID-19 Variants, Says UCSF’s Monica Gandhi
    • The same doctor who said had vaccinated people had “pretty much zero” risk of transmitting to virus, had previously recorded a podcast titled The End of The Pandemic With Dr. Monica Gandhi.
    • The same doctor who said vaccines rendered people “essentially bulletproof!”, had previously authored an article titled We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April.
    • The same doctor who said “vaccinating adults indirectly protects children“, had previously authored an article titled I’ve Been Yearning For An End To The Pandemic. Now That It’s Here, I’m A Little Afraid.
    • The same doctor who said vaccinated people had an “infinitesimally low probability of even having an infection that can be detected on a PCR test, let alone being able to spread it to someone” had previously recorded a podcast titled The Motivation We Need to Reach the End of the COVID-19 Pandemic with Dr. Monica Gandhi.
The pattern isn’t that hard to spot. These doctors wanted us to stop “living in fear” and were willing to overhype brand new vaccines to pacify their audience. Unfortunately, the Delta and Omicron variants arrived and more Americans died of COVID after these podcasts and articles then before them. Yet today, many of these same doctors actively discourage COVID vaccines for the same reason- they want us to stop “living in fear”. Like I said, the pattern isn’t that hard to spot.
Despite their flaws, COVID vaccines are the greatest medical achievement of my lifetime, and in an update to this article, Drs. Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman deservedly won the Nobel Prize for their research. They have already have saved many millions of people from death and serious suffering. Because I still support them unambiguously and publicly, I often receive hostile feedback from distrustful people who feel they were oversold initially. I get where they are coming from.
While their anger may be mistargeted, it is totally understandable.

Do Covid-19 Vaccines Affect Fertility?
Fears of future infertility are keeping some parents from vaccinating their children for COVID-19. These fears are not supported by any evidence.
Harriet Hall on May 31, 2022
Link

A friend told me he had encountered a man who was fully vaccinated. This man says his whole family is vaccinated except his young 7-year-old daughter. He says he’s worried about the effect on her fertility or future reproductive abilities. My friend asked me to point to the best evidence that this shouldn’t be a concern.
I had not encountered this concern before, so I did some Googling. I couldn’t find any “best evidence” or indeed, any evidence at all. It appears that this is a social media myth based on an assumption that the vaccine could cause the body to attack syncytin-1, a protein in the placenta that shares a small piece of genetic code with the spike protein of the coronavirus. One expert dismisses this concern, saying “the overall construction of the protein is so completely different, your immune system is way too smart to be confused by that.”
Another expert, in China, is concerned because the angiotensin 2 converting enzyme (ACE2) is present in the ovaries and testes. He thinks SARS-CoV-2 infection might disrupt ovarian function and hence oocyte quality. And it might impair spermatogenesis.
Another paper from China by the same authors says “Whereas COVID-19 has not yet been reported to damage female fertility, its potential detrimental effects cannot be ignored”.
The British Medical Journal reports that a protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis has been developed to study these concerns, and research is ongoing. This was also based on the concerns of Chinese scientists. This worries me, since a 2016 study found that 80% of China’s clinical trial data are fraudulent.
I must admit that the man’s fears are not entirely unwarranted. Science-based concerns have been raised. This is an area that calls for more study. At present, there simply is no evidence one way or the other.
On the other hand, there IS clear evidence that the disease can kill children, and dead children are unable to reproduce. So I would emphasize the solid evidence for that risk in contrast to the purely speculative and hypothetical risks of possible reproductive consequences that have not yet been evaluated and for which there is no evidence. Of course, he wants to be cautious and protect his child, but in the worst-case scenario, wouldn’t it be better to have an infertile daughter than a dead one? And of course, if she remains unvaccinated and is infected by SARS-CoV-2, she would be a source of risk to other people, especially the very young and the very old.
That man’s fears are based on speculation and hypotheses, not evidence, but they may well prove stronger than rational arguments and evidence. Anyway, the effort to change his mind is worth a try, if only in the interests of public health. Don’t we have a duty to protect vulnerable individuals?

Antivaxxers rejoice at the “silver lining” from the pandemic, spillover of distrust of COVID-19 vaccines to all vaccines
Distrust of COVID-19 vaccines has lead to spillover of distrust to all childhood vaccines, and antivaxxers are rejoicing.
David Gorski on August 15, 2022
Link

Antivaxxers have long opposed vaccine mandates of any kind, but in particularly they’ve always despised school vaccine mandates. During the pandemic, this opposition predictably resulted in spillover to opposition to vaccine mandates for health care workers or by any private company, whether mandated by government or decided upon by a private entity. What a lot of people who only started paying attention to the antivaccine movement since it became impossible to ignore during the pandemic often appear unaware of is that this opposition to vaccine mandates is nothing new. Indeed, it’s been a feature of the antivaccine movement since long before I ever started paying attention. The endgame of the antivaccine movement has always been the elimination of all vaccine mandates, including school vaccine mandates Indeed, going back to before the pandemic, I’ve warned for a long time that the endgame of the antivaccine movement is the elimination of all vaccine mandates of any kind, be the mandate for school or daycare, healthcare workers, or workers of any kind. They want all such mandates gone, so that their “freedom” is not impacted, and they don’t even have to go to the minor difficulty (in most states) of obtaining a personal belief exemption.
I was reminded of this history over the weekend, when, while doing what I’ve done for nearly two decades and perusing the dark underbelly of antivaccine social media in order to keep an eye on what the opposition is doing, I naturally perused Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense website. Given RFK Jr.’s prominence in the antivaccine movement since 2005, CHD is, of course, a mandatory stop on any tour of antivax websites. On Friday, CHD published an article under the byline of The Defender Staff (the news part of CHD is referred to as The Defender) titled “A COVID Silver Lining? More Parents Than Ever Questioning ‘Routine’ Childhood Vaccines“, with a blurb that read:
Children and teen vaccination rates began plummeting with the onset of the pandemic, and as concerns surfaced around the safety of COVID-19 vaccines, some parents also began questioning the need for the long list of other vaccines recommended by public health officials.
As you might imagine, RFK Jr. and his band of antivaxxers think it’s a good thing that the suspicion of COVID-19 vaccines is metastasizing to long-used childhood vaccines, such as MMR, the polio vaccine, and all the other vaccines on the childhood vaccination schedule recommended by the CDC. I’ll discuss this more in a moment, but first, let’s look at the facts.
Declining childhood vaccination rates endanger children
Declining childhood vaccination rates since the pandemic first hit are indeed a problem. Early on, this decline was due to closure of pediatrics and family practice clinics for routine medical care other than emergencies. As noted in Science last month:
In what UNICEF Executive Director Catherine Russell called a “red alert,” childhood vaccination rates in many countries worldwide have dropped to the lowest level since 2008, in part because of the COVID-19 pandemic. UNICEF and the World Health Organization together track inoculations against diphtheria, pertussis, and tetanus—which are administered as one vaccine—as a marker for vaccination coverage overall. In 2021, only 81% of children worldwide received the recommended three doses of the combined vaccine, down from 86% in 2019. As a result, some 25 million children remain insufficiently protected against the three dangerous diseases.
The majority of children who missed vaccines were in underdeveloped countries, but the US was not immune, its childhood vaccination rate having fallen as well, as the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) warned earlier this month in an article titled “How distrust of childhood vaccines could lead to more breakouts of preventable diseases“:
The latest data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) show that most of those children have since gotten their shots. However, the national childhood vaccination rate among kindergarteners declined by 1%, from 95% in 2019 to 94% in 2021.
“One percent may sound like nothing, but it’s not nothing … when you put it in terms of number of doses or kids,” says Kelly Whitener, JD, an associate professor at the Georgetown University McCourt School of Public Policy’s Center for Children and Families.
According to CDC data, approximately 211,000 kindergarteners did not have all required vaccines in 2021, compared with about 201,000 in 2019, even with 2021 enrollment down by 10%.
Before the pandemic, antivaxxers loved to point to numbers like a 94% childhood vaccination rate overall and ask why doctors were so concerned over a “minor” decline. I’d point out that community/herd immunity requires a high vaccination rate for very transmissible diseases (e.g., measles). More importantly, averaging out the vaccination rate for large areas (such as the whole country or individual states) can mask much larger declines clustered in communities where parents with a high degree of vaccine hesitancy tend to cluster. Those communities with much lower vaccination rates than the surrounding area can then serve as foci of outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases.
We saw this very dynamic at play the year before the pandemic, when measles outbreaks were reported in a number of places in the US. The most famous of these outbreaks, however, occurred in the Orthodox Jewish communities in New York, specifically in Brooklyn and Rockland County. The Brooklyn Orthodox Jewish community, it turns out, has been a hotbed of vaccine hesitancy for a long time, having suffered a rather large outbreak in 2013, when an unvaccinated adolescent returned from London and brought measles with them. In 2019, the Orthodox communities in Rockland County and Brooklyn suffered more outbreaks of measles as a result of low vaccine uptake promoted by antivaccine misinformation targeted at them from outsiders like Del Bigtree and an antivaccine rabbi named Hillel Handler. In 2019, much of the misinformation was being spread in a very “old school” manner, in the form of a 40-page handbook called “The Vaccine Safety Handbook” published by a group called Parents Educating and Advocating for Children’s Health, or PEACH. These days, the misinformation is spreading on Telegram and in WhatsApp groups.
Here’s a blast from that past, just to give you an idea:
It’s worth noting that most of the speakers are secular antivax activists. Del Bigtree and Andrew Wakefield himself are also on the docket.
— Jaclyn Jeffrey-Wilensky (@jeffwilen) May 14, 2019
This was advertised through robo calls and what’s app groups starting Sunday night. Big names on anti-vaccination circuit Including Andrew Wakefield – the author of 1998 debunked study on supposed link between vaccines Ana autism.
— Gwynne Hogan (@GwynneFitz) May 14, 2019
As I wrote last November, the very same communities were being targeted with misinformation about COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines. I also hasten to add that the antivaccine activism in these particular Orthodox communities is not typical; in my state, for instance, Orthodox religious authorities have a history of working with public health officials to encourage vaccination in their communities.
My point is not so much to focus on this particular group—I could easily focus on a number of other communities targeted by antivaccine misinformation)—other than as a convenient example to illustrate that history matters, and when childhood vaccination rates fall slightly in the US overall there is a risk that they’ll fall a lot in areas like Rockland County and Brooklyn. For example, remember that case of polio in the US that made the news last month? Guess where it occurred? You guessed it: Rockland County, where an unvaccinated 20-year-old man was hospitalized in June for paralytic polio.
The story is complicated by the finding that the man had developed polio from the vaccine-derived strain used in the oral polio vaccine (OPV), which has not been used in the US in over 20 years because in rare cases the attenuated (weakened) polio virus used for the vaccine can recombine to become a disease-causing form. However, the risk is low (As Scott Gavura noted recently, in 10 years during which 10 billion doses of OPV were administered, fewer than 800 cases of vaccine-derived paralytic polio were reported, and the injected version of the polio vaccine protects against vaccine-derived polio.) and in impoverished areas the OPV has many advantages, including being much cheaper and easier to administer. Again, without getting lost in the weeds, the point is that if vaccine uptake declines as a result of increased distrust of childhood vaccines due to fear of COVID-19 vaccines, we’re likely to see the first outbreaks in communities that have historically had a low degree of confidence in childhood vaccines and health authorities.
That is, of course, a feature, not a bug, of antivaccine messaging; indeed, as I pointed out a couple of months ago, “new school” anti-COVID-19 vaccine antivaxxers are sounding more and more like “old school” antivaxxers when it comes to childhood vaccines, and that is not a good thing.
Spillover of vaccine distrust: “A silver lining”?
Unsurprisingly, where you and I (and anyone who supports science-based medicine) see an alarming trend, RFK Jr. and his antivax minions see a “silver lining”. In the article, The Defender Staff starts out by recounting how childhood vaccine uptake fell dramatically in 2020 all over the world and how, contrary to what was expected, it has not yet rebounded to prepandemic levels. Naturally, since I’m a native Michigander and have lived in Michigan since 2008 after having returned to my home state after a 20-year sojourn away for residency, PhD studies, fellowship, and my first academic job, this passage caught my attention more than any other in RFK Jr.’s recounting of “spillover” vaccine hesitancy from COVID-19 vaccines and is also part of the reason why, when I saw this article, I immediately decided that this would be my topic for this week’s SBM post:
When Michigan compared its 2020 vaccination data against the 2016-2019 period, it found vaccination coverage had declined in “all milestone age cohorts, except for birth-dose hepatitis B coverage.”
At this juncture, state officials are openly speculating that COVID-19 shots — thus far rejected by the parents of 97% of under-5-year-olds — are the reason parents are increasingly ambivalent about childhood vaccination more generally.
Referring to this “spillover doubt,” a Michigander public health spokesperson said parents who once accepted childhood vaccination without question are now saying, “Wait a minute. Do I really need these vaccines?” and asking, “How are these vaccines made?”
According to another Michigan official, “vaccination” — the “V-word” — has become a “trigger word” for irate parents who believe government not only overstepped its authority during COVID-19 but is fraudulently pushing unsafe vaccines on their little ones.
To expand on the issue of antivaccine misinformation celebrated by RFK Jr in Michigan, let’s look at one of its citations, a Bridge Michigan article from four weeks ago:
At the LMAS health department in the Upper Peninsula, a social media post about an “immunization” clinic prompted one resident to accuse the health department of sneaking COVID vaccines in among other routine childhood shots, said Kerry Ott, department spokesperson.
Vaccination opponents have “gained new members because of COVID,” she said.
Ott said “vaccination” is now considered a “trigger word” among those who feel the government overstepped its authority during COVID or who have doubts about vaccines developed to combat the virus.
“I wasn’t expecting to be accused of trying to vaccinate people with the COVID vaccine and telling them that it’s polio,” Ott said. “There is a solid wall of people that are not going to budge from believing these conspiracy theories, and I have not found a way to even open a conversation with folks on that side (and) behind that line.”
Again, antivaccine misinformation is always rooted in conspiracy theories, just like all science denial.
It’s not just Michigan, either. In April, POLITICO published a story describing how COVID-19 vaccine distrust is spilling over to childhood vaccines, with public health officials in ten states reporting that they are concerned about an increasing number of families. Also, consistent with what I’ve been writing here and elsewhere, the manner in which antivaxxers over the last decade have increasingly made their messages to the general public (as opposed to their social media messaging to hardcore antivaxxers) about “freedom” and “parental rights” more than specific claims of vaccine harms has paid off spectacularly since COVID-19 hit:
Parents who were hesitant to vaccinate their children before the pandemic have now been joined by people who think the government mishandled the crisis, see Covid-19 vaccine mandates as federal overreach, or are exposed to misinformation about childhood vaccinations, said Rupali Limaye, professor of International Health at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
“You get a decline in trust towards your government, and people looking for other sources to inform their decision-making process,” she said. “So they go to social media, [where] misinformation is outpacing evidence-based information.”
Immunization advocates say it was easier to bat down spurious claims that drove pre-pandemic hesitancy, such as that vaccines cause autism. But it’s harder to push back against an argument about personal freedom from government mandates.
“I would have told you in April 2020 that that was going to actually be our moment to turn the anti-vaccine tide,” said Melissa Wervey Arnold, CEO of the Ohio Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics. “Unfortunately, instead, the freedom movement took over.”
I noted early in the pandemic how rapidly antivaxxers so quickly joined the more general reaction against public health interventions designed to slow the spread of COVID-19 and right wing conspiracy theorists (including QAnon). I even predicted that this confluence would spread to distrust of all childhood vaccines, having noted that a decade ago antivax ideology was shifting to become more and more tightly associated with far right wing politics, even as popular culture still mistakenly viewed antivax beliefs as more associated with the hippy-dippy crunchy left and the “progressive” RFK Jr. was openly cavorting with far right wing movements and outright fascist groups were more and more aligning themselves with antivaxxers. Basically, what was once an ideology that spanned right and left (and tended to be more associated with the left) long ago started becoming much more associated with right-wing antigovernment, anti-regulation ideologies. Obviously, I consider this a very dangerous development, while antivaxxers like RFK Jr. are rejoicing.
RFK Jr. and minions recount a number of antivax conspiracy theories as factual and, instead of being misinformation, as very much justifiable reasons for parents to be suspicious of vaccines. I won’t cite them all, other than to point out that they include the misuse of the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS), a frequent topic on this blog recently and dating to back before the pandemic; the false claim that vaccines cause sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), which they don’t; a related claim that there was a large drop in SIDS early in the pandemic because infants were missing routine vaccines (also not true); false claims that unvaccinated children are much healthier than vaccinated children (also definitely not true); and more.
Again, the point is not so much to refute each bit of misinformation being firehosed in this article, most of which has been discussed at one time or another on this very blog, but rather to point out that, as predicted, the antivaccine misinformation, disinformation, and conspiracy theories about COVID-19 vaccines are inevitably spilling over to all vaccines. Naturally, RFK Jr. is ecstatic, quoting an antivaccine doctor whose attention whoring apparently worked to get the attention of CHD’s staff:
Want to know what I'm experiencing on the frontlines of medicine? Parents are DONE with giving their kids any and all 💉. Not only that but they're disgusted with what they had already allowed to be injected into their kids. They wish they could turn back ⏰.
— Heather Gessling, MD (@HGessling) August 6, 2022
@HighWireTalk #thehighwire
— Heather Gessling, MD (@HGessling) August 7, 2022
Which is where the “silver lining” comes in, in which RFK Jr.’s crew pivots to “natural health”:
Sadly, whatever temporary or longer-lasting silver lining may have emerged from the COVID-19-induced lull in childhood vaccination, children and their parents still face many challenges.
According to a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention study, the weight status of children and adolescents who were already overweight or obese worsened significantly during 2020, and children’s food insecurity is rising both domestically and internationally.
In addition, the massive social and behavioral changes commanded through government restrictions have prompted dire headlines about young people’s mental health — although experts caution these could counterproductively lead to overdiagnosis and overmedication with black-box-warning drugs known to cause violence and suicide.
Rather than more vaccines or drugs that have never delivered on their hype or promises, what children and youth need to thrive are the slower-but-surer public health fundamentals — such as solid nutrition, safe housing and economic security — and the loving attention of their parents.
Does anyone want to guess what that last part about “health fundamentals” is about before clicking on the link? (No cheating if you’ve already clicked on the link!) The link goes to an article on CHD citing a low quality ecological analysis in India that concludes that sanitation and nutrition do more to prevent vaccine-preventable diseases than vaccines do. (Remember what I’ve written about how easily the ecological fallacy can mislead in epidemiology going back something like 14 years?) The study claims to find that a “one percentage point increase in households with toilets corresponds with 0.33 fewer measle cases per 1000” for children under five. Given that measles is a highly transmissible respiratory disease, it doesn’t even make sense that more toilets and better sanitation would have much of an effect on measles transmission, certainly not more than the MMR vaccine. Going along with that is something not mentioned by CHD, namely that no such association was observed for diphtheria, pertussis, or tetanus, given that diphtheria and pertussis are, like measles, both also diseases transmitted through respiration.
COVID-19 distrust metastasizes
Unfortunately, CHD is not incorrect about one thing, namely that distrust of COVID-19 vaccines is indeed spilling over to infect public attitudes about routine childhood vaccination. The AAMC notes, as I did above, that the first effects will likely be seen in areas with traditionally low uptake of vaccines, but, thanks to the fusion of right-wing messaging equating vaccine mandates with assaults on “freedom”, I fear that it likely won’t just be there for long.
According to AAMC:
In addition to pockets of vaccine hesitancy among likeminded communities, the U.S. has also seen an uptick in vaccine distrust in certain regions of the country. In Texas, for example, conscientious exemptions have increased from 0.45% of K-12 students in the 2010-2011 school year to 2.7% in the 2021-2022 school year, according to data from the Texas Department of State Health Services. For private schools, the vaccine exemption rate for the last school year was 4.23%, but some schools report even higher rates. One private school in Travis County, Texas, had 43% of its student population exempt from at least one vaccine, while nearly 50 schools recorded more than 10% of their student populations with exemptions.
Of course, Texas has a long history of resistance to vaccine mandates due to vaccine resistance being conflated with “freedom”. Indeed, in 2016 I observed that when the next big outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases happen, they’ll probably happen in Texas, a point I reiterated in 2019. (Also remember that a decade ago the Texas Republican Party included planks in its party platform opposing vaccine mandates and supporting the teaching of creationism in schools; again, the affinity between the far right and antivaccine beliefs is, contrary to what so many of the intelligentsia seem to think, not new.) If anything, events have made me think that I was correct, although I would also add Florida, Idaho, and a number of other states with high levels of COVID-19 conspiracism in the public discourse to that list.
I also fear that these predictions by Drs. Paul Offit and Rupali Lamaye are correct:
In many ways, he worries that there is little that scientists can do to reverse the trend of vaccine distrust.
“Academic institutions can answer scientific questions … [but] the majority aren’t [refusing vaccines] because there’s a specific scientific concern,” Offit says. “The data are there; the issue is this cultural issue” of distrusting the government and federal mandates.
Rupali Lamaye, PhD, MPH, deputy director of the International Vaccine Access Center at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, also believes that there will be repercussions down the road to continued resistance to vaccines.
“I think this is going to be our future for a bit. We’re going to continue to see outbreaks,” she says. “We’ve lost too much trust over the pandemic.”
There was a time years ago when I naïvely believed that a major outbreak of a vaccine-preventable disease would bring the vaccine-hesitant and antivaxxers back to seeing the value of vaccination and the misinformation that claimed that they caused so much harm and didn’t work. I had learned long before the pandemic how naïve I had been, as I witnessed outbreak after outbreak leading antivaxxers to double down. Then came COVID-19, killing over a million people in the US alone and likely tens of millions worldwide, which not only didn’t dampen antivaccine misinformation but rather turbocharged it beyond anything I had ever seen before in my nearly quarter of a century paying attention to the antivaccine movement.
If there’s one thing that the pandemic has shown about antivaccine beliefs and science denial, it’s that the information deficit model of distrust of science, which posits that science denial can be reversed by providing accurate information (i.e., that good information is enough to chase away bad information) is very much lacking. When a belief becomes embedded in an ideology that is core to a person’s self-identity, as distrust of vaccines has for so many, it is incredibly difficult to combat. Indeed, I’ve likened it to changing a person’s politics or religion, because, when you come right down to it, it’s a lot like that. That’s not to say that debunking can’t work. It can and does. It’s just that providing “good information” to counter “bad information” is in most cases not enough. Think of it this way: Does just providing accurate information about evolution affect the beliefs of creationists, whose beliefs are nearly always based on their religious beliefs? Usually not. Promoting good science is important, but it is not enough.
Unfortunately, there is a reason why antivaxxers are rejoicing.

What the heck happened to The BMJ?
Last week, The BMJ published an “exposé” by Paul Thacker alleging patient unblinding, data falsification, and other wrongdoing by a company running three sites for the massive clinical trial of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. It was a highly biased story embraced by antivaxxers, with a deceptively framed narrative and claims not placed into proper context, leading me to look into the broader question: What the heck happened to The BMJ?
David Gorski on November 8, 2021
Link
The British Medical Journal (now The BMJ) is one of the oldest and most respected medical journals in the world that also has a history of publishing some excellent investigative journalism. For instance, over a decade ago, it was The BMJ that published investigative journalist Brian Deer’s articles recounting the strong evidence indicating that Wakefield’s case series published in The Lancet that linked the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to autism was based on fraud. That study launched the modern iteration of the antivaccine movement and is, as I like to say, the study that launched a thousand quackeries directed at autistic children to “cure” them of their “vaccine-induced autism.” The headline of Deer’s accompanying commentary after his account of how the “case against the MMR was fixed” even referred to Wakefield’s study as “Piltdown medicine“, after the infamous Piltdown Man fraud.
Unfortunately, more recently the investigative journalism coming from The BMJ has left a lot to be desired, and I say this even though The BMJ recently published a commentary co-authored by Gavin Yamey and me about the Great Barrington Declaration and the new “merchants of doubt“. Indeed, I almost felt a reluctance to write this post, as it felt a bit like biting the hand that feeds, but after seeing an article published by The BMJ last week I felt that I had no choice. The article was by investigative journalist turned anti-GMO muckraking crank Paul Thacker and was titled “Covid-19: Researcher blows the whistle on data integrity issues in Pfizer’s vaccine trial“. It’s an article that, since its publication last Tuesday, has been widely cited and shared by a wide variety of antivaxxers in order to portray the clinical trial of the Pfizer vaccine that led to its emergency use authorization (EUA) in the US as hopelessly corrupt. Here are a few examples from Twitter:
Wait till everybody finds out about the vaxxes Pfizer are alleged to have given to a placebo group in the tests, to make it look like the adverse events were normal when they were suffered by both groups in the #RiggedTrials.https://t.co/Z2sVflFINY
— Michael O'Bernicia (@TheBernician) November 2, 2021
Whistleblower report on Pfizer’s pivotal phase III trial:
– data falsified– unblinding of patients – untrained vaccinators– slow to follow up on adverse events– quality control staff overwhelmed by problems– whistleblower fired after warning the FDAhttps://t.co/95y4nHYXpu
— Klaus K (@KlausKblog) November 6, 2021
COVID-19 vaccines are effective at reducing the risk of severe illness, hospitalization & death. There are also concerns about uncommon but underreported adverse events, some data quality, & suppression of politically unpopular perspectives. https://t.co/Noq6I2n2ZC
— Joseph A. Ladapo, MD, PhD (@FLSurgeonGen) November 4, 2021
That last Tweet comes from Dr. Joseph Ladapo, Gov. Ron DeSantis’ selection to head up the Florida Department of Health, whom Jann Bellamy discussed in September. He’s a member of “America’s Frontline Doctors” who, in addition to supporting a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, has openly opposed mask and vaccine mandates, while echoing antivax talking points.
If you don’t believe me about how much antivaxxers have embraced Thacker’s work, take a look at Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivax Children’s Health Defense website, which republished Thacker’s report verbatim under the terms of the under the terms of the Creative Commons BY NC license used by The BMJ. Interestingly, Children’s Health Defense even features an “author page” for Thacker that, if you don’t look closely enough, could give the false impression that he had written the article for Children’s Health Defense. From this author’s page, one can see that Thacker wrote two other articles for The BMJ that were republished, both demonstrating that he clearly buys into the conspiracy theories surrounding the “lab leak” hypothesis for the origins of COVID-19. Perusing The BMJ‘s site itself, one can see that Thacker is a regular contributor and there are more articles about the “lab leak” hypothesis that Children’s Health Defense didn’t republish.
For this post, I’m going to focus primarily on the article about the Pfizer clinical trial because it is the one that most resembles actual journalism, albeit just barely given that its sourcing is a bit sketchy and its framing is relentlessly one-sided and clearly designed to leave the reader with exactly the sort of message that antivaxxers are taking from it, namely that Pfizer is corrupt and was careless about oversight of the massive clinical trial of its COVID-19 vaccine in 2020. Thacker’s articles about the “lab leak” hypothesis published in The BMJ in general don’t even try to resemble investigative journalism (not that I won’t briefly cover them). Basically, it’s hard not to wonder what the heck has happened to The BMJ, in much the same way I recently wondered what the heck happened to John Ioannidis, a scientist whom I used to admire greatly until his turn into COVID-19 contrarianism and minimization.
I will also preface the remainder of the post by emphasizing that, if Thacker’s report is accurate, there did appear to be some significant problems with the three sites in Texas managed by Ventavia, the company that ran the clinical trials. However, the overall impression given by the article is that the entire enterprise should now be questioned, Thacker’s Competing Interests statement that he “has been doubly vaccinated with Pfizer’s vaccine” notwithstanding. In other words, narrative matters. Context matters. Framing matters. Everything about Thacker’s article frames the clinical trial and Pfizer in the worst possible light. It’s almost as though the report is custom-made to provide grist for antivax conspiracy theories, and it definitely succeeds at doing just that. Whatever good some of the report might do, that The BMJ commissioned this report and failed in its “fact checking” to realize that every good propagandist knows how to spin verified facts into deceptive narrative does not speak well of what has happened to the journal, particularly in light of other articles it has published.
Thacker’s whistleblower report on Ventavia and Pfizer
I will begin by discussing what Thacker reports in his article, starting with this framing right at the beginning of the report, and I will quote liberally citing the same Creative Commons license that Children’s Health Defense cited when it republished the article in its entirety:
In autumn 2020 Pfizer’s chairman and chief executive, Albert Bourla, released an open letter to the billions of people around the world who were investing their hopes in a safe and effective covid-19 vaccine to end the pandemic. “As I’ve said before, we are operating at the speed of science,” Bourla wrote, explaining to the public when they could expect a Pfizer vaccine to be authorised in the United States.
But, for researchers who were testing Pfizer’s vaccine at several sites in Texas during that autumn, speed may have come at the cost of data integrity and patient safety. A regional director who was employed at the research organisation Ventavia Research Group has told The BMJ that the company falsified data, unblinded patients, employed inadequately trained vaccinators, and was slow to follow up on adverse events reported in Pfizer’s pivotal phase III trial. Staff who conducted quality control checks were overwhelmed by the volume of problems they were finding. After repeatedly notifying Ventavia of these problems, the regional director, Brook Jackson, emailed a complaint to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Ventavia fired her later the same day. Jackson has provided The BMJ with dozens of internal company documents, photos, audio recordings, and emails.
Notice the framing. Contrary to Bourla’s statement, the narrative goes, “several” (three, actually, as it turns out) sites in Texas run by Ventavia were supposedly flouting clinical trial safety and unblinding patients, but an intrepid whistleblower reported them. Whistleblower narratives can be valuable, but they can also be potentially misleading, particularly when used as grist for a report by someone like Thacker. After all, whistleblowers often have their own axes to grind. That characteristic in and of itself is not a reason to dismiss (or not to protect) whistleblowers, but it is a reason to be cautious about basing conclusions on their claims alone, particularly a whistleblower who was employed by the company for just two weeks, as was the case with Jackson.
Similarly, when evaluating reports of problems with the conduct of a clinical trial, it is important to consider the actual details and context of the reported violations. In this case, Thacker mixes reports from Jackson that might have impacted trial data and safety with reports that could not possibly have. More than that, Thacker gleefully mixes the two, starting thusly in the more detailed discussion of his findings:
Exasperated that Ventavia was not dealing with the problems, Jackson documented several matters late one night, taking photos on her mobile phone. One photo, provided to The BMJ, showed needles discarded in a plastic biohazard bag instead of a sharps container box.
So apparently Ventavia was careless about disposing of sharps. That’s definitely sloppy lab practice, if it happened, although I feel obligated to point out that we don’t know if this was one screwup or a common problem. Either way, Ventavia’s handling of sharps couldn’t possibly have affected the results of the clinical trial and is more a concern of OSHA violation than any concern that the FDA should look into that could have resulted in data compromise or compromise of the safety of patients. It’s interesting to me that Thacker chose to lead with this tidbit in the section after his introduction, when he started to go into more detail about his more general charges listed in the introduction, given that it has nothing to do with data integrity. I understand that he’s trying to frame the story as one of poor laboratory management, but, really, this accusation seems to have been inserted at the beginning in order to provide what I like to call a “Yuck!” factor, to get the reader to feel disgust on a visceral level towards the company, before going into the more mundane and difficult-to-explain issues of clinical trial management. It’s a very transparently manipulative framing tactic akin to how Thacker likes to paint genetically modified organisms (GMOs) as “unnatural” and “Frankenfood”.
The “yuck” factor having been established, Thacker then continues:
Early and inadvertent unblinding may have occurred on a far wider scale. According to the trial’s design, unblinded staff were responsible for preparing and administering the study drug (Pfizer’s vaccine or a placebo). This was to be done to preserve the blinding of trial participants and all other site staff, including the principal investigator. However, at Ventavia, Jackson told The BMJ that drug assignment confirmation printouts were being left in participants’ charts, accessible to blinded personnel. As a corrective action taken in September, two months into trial recruitment and with around 1000 participants already enrolled, quality assurance checklists were updated with instructions for staff to remove drug assignments from charts.
Notice the contrast between what Thacker writes in the introduction, in which he claims that Ventavia unblinded patients, not that “inadvertent unblinding may have occurred”. There’s a huge difference between the two. Think about it. Leaving the printouts in patient’s charts might have compromised blinding in some cases and was definitely a sloppy practice (and was corrected), but Thacker quite noticeably presents zero evidence that unblinding ever actually occurred, despite stating unequivocally right at the beginning of the article that patients were “unblinded”. Which message do you think that readers will come away with, the one saying that Ventavia definitely unblinded patients or the one saying that unblinding “may have” happened?
I find it even more telling that the scope of problem is not mentioned until more than halfway into the report, where it’s revealed that Ventavia ran three sites in Texas out of the 153 total clinical sites participating in the Pfizer trial and signed up a small fraction (~1,000 by the time the whistleblower was fired) of the trial’s over ~44,000 subjects. Note again the framing, “Early and inadvertent blinding may have occurred on a far larger scale”. This is clearly meant to imply more than just the Ventavia sites, given the context. Of course, Thacker reports almost as an afterthought that appropriate corrective measures were eventually instituted at this one site. One could certainly argue that Ventavia took longer to institute these corrective policies than it should have, but, even so, when I looked at the details of the actual claims made they do not support the insinuation that wide-scale inadvertent unblinding had occurred in the Pfizer trial.
Thacker does something even more deceptive as well. According to an anonymous source:
After Jackson left the company problems persisted at Ventavia, this employee said. In several cases Ventavia lacked enough employees to swab all trial participants who reported covid-like symptoms, to test for infection. Laboratory confirmed symptomatic covid-19 was the trial’s primary endpoint, the employee noted. (An FDA review memorandum released in August this year states that across the full trial swabs were not taken from 477 people with suspected cases of symptomatic covid-19.)
“I don’t think it was good clean data,” the employee said of the data Ventavia generated for the Pfizer trial. “It’s a crazy mess.”
Again, note the juxtaposition. These 477 patients who reported COVID-19 symptoms but never received nasal swabs were across the entire trial of well over 40,000 subjects, but the way it’s phrased, not put into context of the size of the entire trial, makes this sound like a huge number. As has been pointed out, though, this is deceptive framing that leaves out some very important information:
What @thackerpd didn't mention: The share of non-tested trial participants was very similar in the treatment and the placebo groups (9.2% vs 10.1%), and a sensitivity check was done on this issue. https://t.co/7g4B3AUqyG pic.twitter.com/q3DDySb2KG
— Andreas B (@AndreasShrugged) November 3, 2021
In other words, the FDA and Pfizer did the appropriate analysis and demonstrated that the missing PCR test results for SARS-CoV-2 were similar in both the control and experimental groups and that excluding them had minimal effect on the estimated vaccine efficiency found by the trial. One would think that this would be an incredibly important thing to mention in order to put the figure of 477 people with COVID-19 symptoms within seven days of a dose who were not tested into proper context. Thacker’s implication that these 477 cases had an impact on the results of the trial is a big nothingburger that Thacker tries to turn into a gourmet double-decker burger of doubt.
Let’s look at some of the other charges from the whistleblower, listed in Thacker’s report in addition to the two main charges of “unblinding” (which might have happened, but Thacker never establishes to have actually happened and, if it ever did, what the frequency was) and failure to swab every subject who reported COVID-19 symptoms:
    • Participants placed in a hallway after injection and not being monitored by clinical staff
    • Lack of timely follow-up of patients who experienced adverse events
    • Protocol deviations not being reported
    • Vaccines not being stored at proper temperatures
    • Mislabelled laboratory specimens, and
    • Targeting of Ventavia staff for reporting these types of problems.
I’ll deal with the mislabeling of specimens first because it’s the easiest. This is the only place where Thacker makes this claim. A common theme you’ll be hearing from me is that details matter, and Thacker’s piece is notably lacking in details. How many specimens? What was the specific mislabeling? Without knowing these details, there is no way to determine how serious the problem was or if it could possibly have affected the clinical trial data significantly. Think of it this way. There’s a huge difference between one or two (or a handful of) specimens being mislabeled and the error caught and corrected and large numbers of specimens mislabeled so that they became useless because there was insufficient information to allow the investigators to correct the mislabeling. Which happened? We don’t know. Thacker doesn’t tell us. He just tells us it was awful.
Now, let’s move on to the first claim on the list (participants in the hallway). That is obviously less than ideal, even if it happened only once, but, again, details matter. Thacker never reports how often this happened or how many subjects were treated this way. He seems to imply that subjects were left standing in the hallway (or maybe I’m reading too much into this). Were there chairs? Again, this would have been less than ideal, particularly if monitoring was lax, but Thacker gives no details to let me as someone who’s dealt with clinical trials over his career come to a judgment. Moreover, even if this did happen, it would have been incredibly unlikely that it affected the results of the trial from these sites.
The next example is also curious. Thacker states that his whistleblower reported that Ventavia staff were “slow to follow up on adverse events”, but these are the only two examples that he could apparently find:
Ventavia was not keeping up with data entry queries, shows an email sent by ICON, the contract research organisation with which Pfizer partnered on the trial. ICON reminded Ventavia in a September 2020 email: “The expectation for this study is that all queries are addressed within 24hrs.” ICON then highlighted over 100 outstanding queries older than three days in yellow. Examples included two individuals for which “Subject has reported with Severe symptoms/reactions … Per protocol, subjects experiencing Grade 3 local reactions should be contacted. Please confirm if an UNPLANNED CONTACT was made and update the corresponding form as appropriate.” According to the trial protocol a telephone contact should have occurred “to ascertain further details and determine whether a site visit is clinically indicated.”
Again, coming back to my theme, details matter, and I bet that Thacker knows that a Grade 3 local reaction sounds horrible to the average reader, who won’t know what it is. In fact, a grade 3 local reaction is just that, local. Vaccine reaction grades, both local and systemic, are defined in this document, with a Grade 3 local reaction to the injection being a one that meets certain criteria; e.g., requiring the use of narcotics for pain, being greater than 10 cm in diameter, causing significant discomfort at rest that interferes with daily activities, association with a high fever or heart rate, and the like. These are not potentially life-threatening reactions and do not require hospitalization. (If they did require hospitalization or were life-threatening, that would automatically upgrade them to Grade 4.) While it’s obviously less than ideal that it took more than 24 hours to contact these patients, failure to do so for two patients is not such an incredible lapse that it invalidates the trial or is consistent with patients being endangered by the trial.
Regarding Thacker’s report of protocol deviations not being reported, I’m a bit confused, given this passage:
Documents show that problems had been going on for weeks. In a list of “action items” circulated among Ventavia leaders in early August 2020, shortly after the trial began and before Jackson’s hiring, a Ventavia executive identified three site staff members with whom to “Go over e-diary issue/falsifying data, etc.” One of them was “verbally counseled for changing data and not noting late entry,” a note indicates.
At several points during the late September meeting Jackson and the Ventavia executives discussed the possibility of the FDA showing up for an inspection (box 1). “We’re going to get some kind of letter of information at least, when the FDA gets here . . . know it,” an executive stated.
It sounds as though protocol violations were reported to the company, which took corrective action. You can argue if it acted fast enough or was tough enough on the staff involved, but I’m getting mixed messages here.
I also note that, although Thacker claims that Ventavia “falsified data” in the very introduction of his report, this is the only mention of “falsifying data” that occurs anywhere else. There is no description of any specific incidents of “falsifying data” listed, only a memo mentioning three staff members, one of whom was apparently counseled about “changing data and not noting late entry.” One also notes that this memo comes from early August 2020, shortly after the trial began, which means that Ventavia intervened before that many patients could have been signed up. This is truly thin gruel to make sensationalistic claims about “falsifying data” in the introduction in such a way as to make it sound as though the practice was widespread. Basically, we don’t know if falsification occurred, if it occurred how often it occurred, or what the specific “falsifications” were. Indeed, the phrasing of the memo could have indicated that the changing of data, which could have been the correction of errors for all we know, and not noting a late entry could have been discussed in the context of how even minor violations like that could be interpreted as falsifying data. Again, we just don’t know, and Thacker doesn’t tell because he doesn’t have evidence. (If he did, you know he would have cited more than just a cherry picked quote from a memo, which is very thin gruel indeed to base a charge of “data falsification” on.)
As for vaccines not being stored at the appropriate temperature, the Pfizer vaccine needed to be stored at -70°C (and was known at the time to be good for at least six months at that temperature), thus requiring either a -80°C freezer or dry ice. Once it’s thawed, the vaccine was reportedly at the time good for five days in a refrigerator. Knowing these parameters, details (of which Thacker provides none) matter. How far off were the temperatures? For how long? How many doses of vaccine were involved? If, for example, a single vial of vaccine were left out on the bench at room temperature for several hours, that would be a rather trivial violation compared to the situation where a whole shipment was stored in, for instance, a standard -20°C freezer rather than a -80°C freezer. We have no way of knowing how serious or prevalent this problem was. More importantly, Thacker doesn’t report whether the vaccines stored at an incorrect temperature were ever administered to clinical trial subjects or whether they were discarded, which matters a whole heck of a lot when it comes to vaccine trial safety and efficacy, particularly given that administering such vaccines would actually result in a lower vaccine efficacy because presumably they would lose potency the longer they were stored at too warm a temperature. Leave it to Thacker, though, to make it seem as though huge numbers of vaccine doses were messed up by being improperly stored.
The last item in Thacker’s list, if true, is the most damning charge, that Ventavia targeted employees for speaking out. It’s hard to tell if this were truly the case with Brook Jackson, but I will concede that the optics aren’t great. On the other hand, Thacker reports that Ventavia fired her the same day that she sent a complaint to the FDA detailing her concerns. It’s unlikely that the FDA contacted the company the same day of a complaint. (The FDA generally doesn’t move that fast.) Yet, Thacker goes out of his way to imply that the reason she was fired is that she ratted out Ventavia to the FDA. Similarly, it’s a bit disturbing that none of the Ventavia sites were among the sites audited by the FDA. On the other hand, there are always minor errors in trials of this size, particularly when they’re undertaken in haste, as the vaccine trials were in the middle of a pandemic. It’s impossible to know if the problems at Ventavia sites reported by Thacker rise to the level that they could have impacted the results from that site to a significant degree.
In the end, we’re left with a lot of smoke, but no clear fire. There clearly were some problems with Ventavia, which ran three clinical trial sites and signed up a small fraction of the total clinical trial subjects for the entire trial. Again, that’s not good. We have Brook Jackson and an anonymous source claiming that the environment at Ventavia was beyond the pale compared to previous places where they’d worked, coupled vaguely described incidents and allegations without even good examples or estimates of how prevalent the problem was. It’s also reported that Pfizer did audit the company and was apparently sufficiently satisfied to use it again. Of course, to Thacker, Pfizer (or any other large pharmaceutical company) is pure evil; so you can’t trust that. I would counter that, if one site’s data were so unreliable due to problems of the sort that Thacker reported, then pure profit motive would provide a strong reason for a pharmaceutical company to cut that company loose, rather than risk the FDA ever finding out.
None of this is to say that nothing should be done. Assuming that Thacker’s allegations are not a huge exaggeration, at the very least an FDA audit would be a good idea. At the very worst, even though it’s standard practice to do sensitivity analyses to look for variation in results, protocol deviations, failure to do follow-up testing, etc., between sites in a large clinical trial like this, in the worst case scenario, the data from the subjects enrolled at Ventavia sites could be excluded and the rest of the subjects reanalyzed. My guess is that, even if this most extreme step were to be undertaken, it would make minimal difference in the results of the trial.
Basically, Thacker takes fairly uncontroversial observations (e.g., that the FDA is underfunded and doesn’t audit sites as often as it should, something I’ve noted multiple times in my posts for SBM about cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski and his bogus clinical trials, for instance) and combines them with vague reports of what are probably mostly minor violations played up as huge, impactful violations:
addressed within 24 hours? That’s a good one. I’m not going to mention what my average used to be 😂
The one good point it raises is that FDA is severely underresourced. There’s no doubt there. 2/
— Jason Gallagher (@JGPharmD) November 2, 2021
Again, the most disturbing thing about the report is the question of whether Ventavia did, in fact, retaliate against Jackson for her having agitated about problems at the site, even if the timeline suggests that it’s probably impossible for her having reported her concerns to the FDA to have been the reason she was fired. If that’s the case, then there should be an investigation and harsh penalties applied to Ventavia. The rest of the report is just Thacker being Thacker, trying to turn a molehill into the proverbial mountain, as long as it fulfills his purpose of demonizing big pharma.
What the heck happened to The BMJ?
If Thacker’s muckraking (and not in a good way) report on Ventavia were the only example of The BMJ going wrong, it wouldn’t be such a big deal. Every publication makes missteps from time to time, and no editor’s judgment is perfect. Sometimes otherwise solid publications screw up. It happens. Unfortunately, this is part of a pattern.
I first noted inklings of unease with The BMJ in 2017, when it published a couple of rather credulous “state of the art” reviews on “integrative medicine,” specifically, about using such “integration” of quackery with real medicine to treat chronic pain and headache. Again, these could have been missteps. It’s not as though The BMJ is the only respected medical journal to have published nonsense about “integrative medicine”. It is, sadly, a thing these days. Unfortunately, though, there is the case of Peter Doshi.
The first time I can recall ever having mentioned Peter Doshi was in 2009, when he spoke at an antivaccine conference hosted by Barbara Loe Fisher’s National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) and, when contacted about it, responded with a transparent, “my speaking there does not imply endorsement”. (Remember that 2009 was the year when the H1N1 influenza pandemic was bearing down on us and that at the time Doshi had been fear mongering about the flu vaccine and questioning its efficacy.) Since then, he’s been nothing if not consistent. While all the while claiming he’s “not antivaccine”, he’s parroted more than a few antivaccine talking points himself while trying to portray himself as an authority on influenza and the flu vaccine. Through it all, he’s played the “victim” card that people who are borderline antivaccine or antivaccine love to play, claiming that they are “just asking questions” and that anyone who “questions” vaccines is labeled, in a knee-jerk fashion, “antivaccine”. In fact, Doshi’s borderline antivaccine stylings go back further than 2009, when senior pseudonymous epidemiologist whose blog I used to read religiously back then chastised him for an “unhelpful” commentary in which Doshi had claimed that estimates for yearly influenza deaths were “grossly inflated.” That was 2006.
Since then, Peter Doshi somehow managed to become an associate editor of The BMJ. How this happened, I have no idea, but periodically he publishes posts for The BMJ that are—to put it kindly—far below the standards that a medical journal with the history of The BMJ should ever associate itself with. Early this year, for instance, he published one more such blog post entitled, Pfizer and Moderna’s “95% effective” vaccines—we need more details and the raw data. It was a post custom designed to try to claim that Pfizer and Moderna had exaggerated the efficacy of their vaccines through some statistical prestidigitation. He also called for the “raw data,” echoing a Thacker technique of cloaking dubious claims in issues that almost everyone can agree on, such as transparency in clinical trials. (John Skylar and Skeptical Raptor also discussed the deception behind his articles.) Doshi once also bought into a truly risible conspiracy theory about the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) that I hadn’t even seen from antivaxxers. There was much mockery. More recently, Doshi published more misinformation in The BMJ about COVID-19 vaccines, claiming that there was “no biodistribution data” (even though there was and biodistribution data aren’t required for vaccines anyway) and insinuating that the trials had been unblinded earlier this year not out of ethical concerns about leaving the subjects in the placebo group susceptible to a potentially deadly pandemic disease, but rather to hide differences in adverse events between the groups and to facilitate the ability of businesses and local governments to mandate COVID-19 vaccines not yet approved by the FDA but only available under an EUA. (I wrote about the issue of unblinding the Pfizer and Moderna clinical trials in April. Suffice to say that it’s a complex issue of clinical trial ethics and science, far more so than what Doshi implies.)
Indeed, Doshi has history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines. At this point, I can’t help but note that Doshi also once signed a petition “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS. When called out on it by Steve Salzberg, he responded disingenuously:
On the question of signing the HIV/AIDS petition, Doshi responded that “Seeing how my name was published and people have misconstrued this as some kind of endorsement, I have written the list owner and asked for my name to be removed.” He declined to state directly that he agrees that the HIV virus causes AIDS—though I gave him ample opportunity.
Here’s what Peter Doshi signed and then only asked for his signature to be removed from the document after being publicly called out. It’s a petition “questioning” the hypothesis that HIV causes AIDS, and the Wayback Machine shows his name in the list of signatories.
No surprise, Peter Doshi has his own author page over at RFK Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense of articles republished from The BMJ under a Creative Commons license, his most recent “contribution” being an op-ed in which he laments calls for state medical boards and medical specialty boards to take action against the medical licenses and board certifications, respectively, of physicians spreading COVID-19 misinformation. Let’s just say that we at SBM disagree strongly and, if anything, think that state medical boards have not gone nearly far enough to protect the public.
It goes beyond that, though. Peter Doshi actively has actively allied himself with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. For instance, he served as one of the expert witnesses last year for the plaintiffs in Children’s Health Defense’s lawsuit against the University of California opposing its flu vaccine mandate:
Currently hand in glove with Children’s Health Defense…Acting as a sort of “expert witness” for their injunction.https://t.co/tz8PbiY6OV pic.twitter.com/jIZTpNv8wL
— Rosewind (@Rosewind2007) January 20, 2021
More recently, there’s been this:
Here is is as well:
For those of you not familiar with him, Ivor Cummins, a.k.a. “The Fat Emperor,” is one of the more famous COVID-19 contrarians, and his approval should be a red flag right there. That’s right. Peter Doshi testified before Senator Ron Johnson’s panel on COVID-19 a week ago, ostensibly about “COVID-19 vaccine injuries and mandates“. We’ve met Sen. Johnson before in the context of his promotion of dangerous “right-to-try” legislation. Since the pandemic, he has, predictably and like so much of the rest of the Republican Party, pivoted to become a COVID-19 pandemic minimizer and an opponent of COVID-19 vaccine mandates to the point of parroting antivaccine talking points. In his testimony, Doshi denies that this is a “pandemic of the unvaccinated,” citing a report from July from the UK that most hospitalizations are among the fully vaccinated. It turns out that this report was in error, substituting “vaccinated” for “unvaccinated” and the majority of hospitalizations were among the unvaccinated, even though they made up only 31% of the population at the time. He even cites cherry-picked tables to claim that the vaccine doesn’t save lives in what is basically an updated rehash of the nonsense he peddled in May (also deconstructed by Dr. Hilda Bastian). In a truly risible moment, he even cites the Merriam-Webster definition of “antivaxxer” as opposed to those supposedly opposed to mandates to argue that he and his fellow COVID-19 contrarians are “not antivaccine” and that large numbers of people would qualify as “antivaccine”. He even parrots the antivaccine talking point that mRNA vaccines are not really vaccines and therefore shouldn’t be mandated like vaccines. I kid you not.
I was flabbergasted. I knew Doshi was bad. I’ve known it since 2009. However, until I saw this video clip even I never realized he was this bad. I used to say that Doshi was not antivaccine. I’m no longer so sure and am leaning towards believing that he is antivaccine, based on his long history on the H1N1 vaccine, other vaccines, and finally the COVID-19 vaccines. Indeed, at the very least I have to agree with Dr. Zoë McLaren:
The BMJ has been regularly publishing fodder for anti-vaxxers. Appears that Peter Doshi is the reason why. @amymaxmen @jeremyfaust @GYamey @eliowa https://t.co/eFr60KiDIW
— Zoë McLaren, Ph.D. (@ZoeMcLaren) November 5, 2021
In the meantime, Paul Thacker has published some doozies of conspiracy mongering articles about the “lab leak” hypothesis of SARS-CoV-2 origins.(He even bought into a narrative beloved of cranks that discussion of the origins of the pandemic has been “suppressed” by labeling any discussion of lab leak hypotheses as a “conspiracy theory”, referring to it as a “conspiracy to label critics as conspiracy theorists.” (Meanwhile, on his own Substack, he explicitly buys into the “Fauci lied” narrative spread by US Sen. Rand Paul and right wing media.) I don’t want to go into detail about these conspiracy theories, given that I’ve discussed them before, other than to say that, recent news reports of “gain of function” notwithstanding, it is still incredibly unlikely—arguably impossible, even—that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered in a laboratory, be it in Wuhan, China, where the pandemic appears to have originated or anywhere else. It is only slightly more likely than that that COVID-19 could have arisen due to the escape of a natural coronavirus being studied in a laboratory, but a natural origin due to a “spillover event” from an animal reservoir (most likely bats) remains far, far more likely than the incredibly unlikely possibility of a lab leak of a “gain-of-function” engineered coronavirus or a natural bat coronavirus being studied causing the pandemic.
Finally, before I conclude it is necessary to recount a bit of Paul Thacker’s history. Besides being known for promulgating anti-GMO conspiracy theories, this is a “journalist” who is known for using abusive Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests in order to harass scientists, in particular Kevin Folta. More recently, Steve Novella discussed how Thacker attacked him (and me) as “vaccine cheerleaders” based on our supposed denial and downplaying of potential complications due to the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccines. Thacker was, as usual, peddling nonsense, of course, because neither Steve nor I (nor other science bloggers targeted by him) had actually denied or tried to “sweep under the rug” the clotting complications being reported for that vaccine last spring. Rather, we had adopted a “wait and see” approach given the relative rarity of the complication reported. It didn’t take us long to acknowledge that the specific clotting problem attributed to the vaccine was very likely in rare cases caused by the vaccine. Thacker, as usual, misrepresented caution for “vaccine cheerleading” and denial that vaccines could ever cause harm. It’s what he does and why I expect that I will soon be subjected to yet another article by Thacker smearing me. It’s coming. I’m willing to endure it, though, if this post forces Thacker to publish more of the evidence behind his article and provide at least some of the details enumerated above that were missing, so that I can at least have a shot at judging the actual severity of the allegations made by his whistleblower. Right now, I just can’t, and certainly I know not to take Thacker’s word for anything.
Too bad that The BMJ doesn’t know that.
Sadly, I can now see a bit more why The BMJ has fallen so far, at least in its reporting, if not the science it publishes. Its editor-in-chief, Fiona Godlee, recently echoed Thacker’s conspiracy mongering in an official editorial for The BMJ, calling for a “full and open independent investigation” into the origins of SARs-CoV-2:
But, as Paul Thacker explains (doi:10.1136/bmj.n1656), suppression of the lab leak theory was not based on any clear evaluation of the science. Indeed, it happened despite no good counter-evidence for the alternative: natural spillover from animals to humans. Instead the lab leak theory sank under the weight of a concerted campaign by heavily conflicted scientists, leading to a “year of biased, failed reporting” by science journalists and journals. Now, thanks to the seismic shift in US politics and some dogged and fearless journalism, the theory is emerging from the shadows into mainstream public debate. We don’t know which theory is right, but a lab leak is plausible and worthy of serious inquiry.
This paragraph could have been published verbatim by Fox News or on any number of websites run by COVID-19 contrarians, and the part about there being “no good counter-evidence” for natural spillover as an origin is just plain wrong, given everything that we know about previous pandemics and the nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2. Indeed, it is irresponsible in the extreme to have written “we don’t know which theory is right” without providing the context of which one is more likely to be correct. (Also, it’s a hypothesis, not a “theory”. In science, the word “theory” implies a much higher level of confidence than is justifiable in this context.) I outright cringed as I read Godlee’s article, having discovered it when I wondered what else The BMJ had published by Thacker besides his most recent “exposé”. It was incredibly disappointing to me to see the editor of The BMJ write something like this op-ed.
Unfortunately, Thacker’s most recent “bombshell” is yet another example of how The BMJ has gone astray, at least in terms of its news reporting and commentary, over the last several years. Peter Doshi, for instance, has now been with the journal for several years, despite many of us asking why the heck he’s still an editor, and Thacker is just the most recent symptom of the rot. I note that Doshi, for instance, has defended Thacker’s story as having been “rigorously fact-checked“. Unfortunately, it’s not the individual “facts” that he uses to weave a deceptive narrative; rather, it’s how he weaves those “facts” together to tell a story while leaving out important context, something all skilled propagandists know. Reluctantly, as I’ve observed the descent of The BMJ‘s news reporting and commentary to the level of conspiracy theory and supporting antivaccine narratives, I must conclude that the rot must start at the top. It’s not as though the problems with The BMJ‘s reporting and having an editor like Peter Doshi haven’t been pointed out for a long time now.
        ◦ Think about it this way. If one of your editors and one of the freelance reporters that you’ve been publishing have their own pages at an antivaccine website, which republishes their work enthusiastically to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines and COVID-19 public health interventions, you really are doing things very, very wrong and contributing to pandemic misinformation in a huge way, given The BMJ‘s status

Peer review fail: Vaccine publishes antivax propaganda disguised as “reanalyses” of Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccine clinical trial data
In order portray COVID-19 vaccines as dangerous, Peter Doshi has now managed to get poorly designed and performed “reanalyses” of the clinical trial data used by the FDA to grant emergency use approval of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines published in two reputable journals, The BMJ and Vaccine? What happened?
David Gorski on September 5, 2022
Link

While contemplating the lessons thus far from the COVID-19 pandemic, I cannot help but emphasize how starkly the pandemic has revealed the shortcomings in scientific publishing. Before the pandemic, I expected to see poorly designed studies designed to stoke fear about vaccines by exaggerating adverse reactions (or even making them up) only in bottom-feeding and predatory journals and generally viewed it as a rare to nonexistent occurrence to see such papers published in reputable journals. Obviously, the publication of Andrew Wakefield’s fraudulent case series linking the MMR vaccines to “autistic enterocolitis” published in The Lancet in 1998 was one huge exception, but in general reputable journals did not traffic in what I like to refer to antivaccine disinformation disguised as legitimate scientific studies. Since the pandemic, there has been one exception, The BMJ, which has published enough dodgy vaccine articles that I once asked, “What the heck happened to The BMJ?” My post was in response to a deceptive “exposé” by Paul Thacker published in The BMJ about Ventavia Research Group, a Texas contract research organization (CRO) subcontracted by Pfizer to run three out of its 153 clinical trial sites for its COVID-19 vaccine trial in 2020. Thacker’s report was based on a single “whistleblower” briefly employed at Ventavia but with little to no actual evidence of alleged data falsification, patient unblinding, and worse, with Thacker attempting to generalize these problems (again, without evidence) to the entire Pfizer clinical trial. In my post, I also listed a number of other examples of The BMJ‘s failures with respect to reports and studies on vaccines, a pattern that, unfortunately, did predate the pandemic and has been traceable to one of its editors, Peter Doshi, who has a long history of antivaccine-adjacent and outright antivaccine stylings going back at least to the H1N1 pandemic in 2009. Indeed, one of his “reanalyses” resulted in what I like to call the “slasher lie” about the Pfizer vaccine that it is only 12-19% effective against COVID-19.
Last week, Peter Doshi managed to expand his penchant for deceptive “reanalyses” to Vaccine, one of the foremost journals about vaccine science, in a study titled “Serious adverse events of special interest following mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in randomized trials in adults“. The article had previously made a huge splash in antivaccine social media in June as a preprint, where its PlumX Metrics showed (as of yesterday) over 584,000 abstract views, over 109,000 downloads, and over 29,000 Tweets about it, with its download rank being 7th for the SSRN preprint site. Now that the paper, whose flaws and misleading nature were discussed in great detail by many scientists (which I will discuss in a moment), as well as by our very own Dr. Jonathan Howard and Dr. Harriet Hall, has somehow inexplicably gone from preprint to peer-reviewed publication in Vaccine, the onslaught started again. Here are some examples:
New study published in #Vaccine shows concerning rate of serious adverse events after mRNA vaccination, but estimates are limited b/c @pfizer & @moderna_tx won't release patient-level trial data.
Why are doctors blindly following Big Pharma?https://t.co/M2QAoUsf5J
— Joseph A. Ladapo, MD, PhD (@FLSurgeonGen) September 2, 2022
Does this one look familiar? It’s Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the Florida Surgeon General who was previously a member of the COVID-19 minimizing, “natural immunity” touting, hydroxychloroquine– and ivermectin-pushing, antivax quacks known as America’s Frontline Doctors before being tapped by Governor Ron DeSantis to be his Surgeon General.
Here are some more. Here’s the study’s first author:
Our study examining mRNA vaccine serious adverse events study is now peer-reviewed in the Journal Vaccine
Serious adverse events of special interest following mRNA COVID-19 vaccination in randomized trials in adultshttps://t.co/PlUZZZePKB
— Joseph Fraiman (@JosephFraiman) August 31, 2022
Who in response to criticism said:
It is peer-reviewed so based on the rules of those who "Follow the Science" it can officially be called "The Science"
— Joseph Fraiman (@JosephFraiman) September 1, 2022
Seriously, peer review isn’t some magical talisman that makes a bad paper “science”. I like to paraphrase Winston Churchill about democracy by saying about peer review that it has been said that peer review is the worst method of deciding what should be published in the scientific literature except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.
In particular, they cited this “finding” from the paper, which reinforces an antivax narrative that the vaccine is more dangerous than the disease:
"Combined, there was a 16 % higher risk of Serious Adverse Events in mRNA vaccine recipients than placebo recipients."https://t.co/nqhqOudPQE
— Joe Quinn (@SeosQuinn) August 31, 2022
”Pfizer and Moderna mRNA COVID-19 vaccines were associated with an excess risk of serious adverse events of special interest” https://t.co/QoKxl31CUQ
— Susanna Strandvik (@StrandvikS) September 4, 2022
The study was also misrepresented as being an “independent” randomized controlled clinical trial when in fact it was merely a “reanalysis” of the trial using different definitions of adverse events:
Moderna – the excess risk of serious AESIs (15.1 per 10,000) vs placebo group (6.4 per 10,000)Pfizer – the excess risk of serious AESIs (10.1 per 10,000) vs placebo group (2.3 per 10,000) https://t.co/42izMkdbJL #Covid19 #cdnpoli pic.twitter.com/HrD55K8Ynq
— Murray 🇨🇦 (@RMurray1977) September 1, 2022
Then, of course, there were the conspiracy theories about a “coverup”:
„Full transparency of the COVID-19 vaccine clinical trial data is needed to properly evaluate these questions. Unfortunately, as we approach 2 years after release of COVID-19 vaccines, participant level data remain inaccessible.“ Peter Doshi https://t.co/4LwJzLERoo
— Andreas Falk (@andifalk) September 4, 2022
I rather regret not writing about this study before here at SBM, back when it was a preprint (although Jonathan and Harriet did). Its having managed to go from preprint to actual publication in a usually-reputable peer-reviewed vaccine journal provides me the opportunity to rectify that oversight, examine how the manuscript changed from preprint to publication, and discuss from my perspective exactly why this paper is a huge flaming dumpster fire. Finally, I’ll ask how a highly eminent statistician (Sander Greenland), one whose work on Bayesian statistics both retired SBM contributor Kimball Atwood and I have cited before in talks and blog posts, sullied his name by associating itself with this exercise in revisionist science. It turns out that there’s history there dating back 14 years that I had totally forgotten about. Worse, I strongly suspect that there’s no way Vaccine would have published this dreck had Prof. Greenland not put his name on it.
Strap in, this is a long one even for me (although not my longest ever by far).
The Vaccine article: from preprint to peer-reviewed article
Let’s follow the path from preprint to peer-reviewed article in Vaccine. The first thing I wondered when I read the preprint for the first time is more of a meta issue, specifically: Why was this study even done in the first place? In the introduction to the preprint, Fraiman et al. wrote:
We sought to investigate the association between FDA-authorized mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and serious adverse events identified by the Brighton Collaboration, using data from the phase III randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trials on which authorization was based. We then use the results to illustrate the need for formal harm-benefit analyses of the vaccines that are stratified according to risk of serious COVID-19 outcomes, as well as contextualize the findings against post-authorization observational data.
What is the Brighton Collaborative? (I’m actually surprised that I hadn’t heard of it before.) It’s a group dedicated to vaccine safety and improving the scientific rigor of vaccine science. Learning that, to be honest, made me a bit annoyed at some criticisms of the study that the serious adverse events (SAEs) had been pulled out of someone’s nether regions. That the Brighton Collaborative is involved doesn’t absolve Doshi for his chicanery in this paper, but we should be careful regarding criticisms we make.
Back to my meta question, though: Why does this study exist? I’ll preface my answer by pointing out a simple observation. It’s been 21 months since the randomized clinical trial (RCT) results for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines were first reported. Both of them involved only ~43K and ~30K participants, respectively. Next, I will point out that even large randomized clinical trials used to approve drugs and vaccines miss less common adverse events (AEs), including serious AEs (SAEs). That’s why we do postmarketing surveillance studies, particularly for vaccines. Less common AEs sometimes don’t show up until after a vaccine is rolled out and distribution goes from a population of tens of thousands to administration to millions, tens of millions, hundreds of millions, and even billions, as has happened with the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 mRNA vaccines over the last 21 months. In other words, if you are truly interested in the actual real-world safety and efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines right here, right now, in September 2022, then the original RCT data are not the best data to use to estimate rates of adverse events. After all, well over 12 billion doses have been administered since then, and numerous countries have safety and efficacy data. Say what you will about Peter Doshi’s “reanalysis” of the clinical trial data in January 2021 that falsely concluded that the Pfizer vaccine had only demonstrated 19% efficacy, in January 2021 the randomized clinical trial data for the vaccine was all that there was. It made sense to look at those data then. Today? Not nearly as much.
So, given that background, why reanalyze the original RCT results from Pfizer and Moderna at all now? There’s one reason, and one reason only, that scientists might want to reanalyze data from a completed and long ago published clinical trial, and that’s if they suspect some sort of serious flaw in the RCT design or how the RCT was carried out. They might even suspect outright fraud. Doshi and his colleagues don’t explicitly say this, but if you know Doshi’s history you’ll understand that the real reason he undertook this analysis was almost certainly because he thought that the RCTs for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccine didn’t show what they claimed to show and were analyzed in such a way to exaggerate efficacy and hide adverse events. It’s not as though he’s made a secret of this belief, given that he’s a senior editor at The BMJ who’s been allowed to use the journal as his own soapbox to argue just that going back to January 2021.
Interestingly, this paragraph underwent some…changes…in the final version published in Vaccine:
We sought to investigate the association between FDA-authorized mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and serious adverse events identified by the Brighton Collaboration, using data from the phase III randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trials on which authorization was based. We consider these trial data against findings from post-authorization observational safety data. Our study was not designed to evaluate the overall harm-benefit of vaccination programs so far. To put our safety results in context, we conducted a simple comparison of harms with benefits to illustrate the need for formal harm-benefit analyses of the vaccines that are stratified according to risk of serious COVID-19 outcomes. Our analysis is restricted to the randomized trial data, and does not consider data on post-authorization vaccination program impact. It does however show the need for public release of participant level trial datasets.
I note that in the first paragraph, a sentence was added touting the Brighton Collaborative as a “a global authority on the topic of vaccine safety”. In any event, it’s tempting for me to claim that because a paragraph was revised from preprint to paper in order to tone it down, that means I can dismiss everything in the preprint. After all, “lab leak” conspiracy theorists did exactly the same thing recently based on the removal of a single word from a preprint to finished paper. I will, however, refrain and note again that most likely peer reviewers demanded that Fraiman et al. tone it down.
There’s another “tell” in the Methods section regarding what this study is really about:
Pfizer and Moderna each submitted the results of one phase III randomized trial in support of the FDA’s emergency use authorization of their vaccines in adults. Two reviewers (PD and RK) searched journal publications and trial data on the FDA’s and Health Canada’s websites to locate serious adverse event results tables for these trials. The Pfizer and Moderna trials are expected to follow participants for two years. Within weeks of the emergency authorization, however, the sponsors began a process of unblinding all participants who elected to be unblinded. In addition, those who received placebo were offered the vaccine. These self-selection processes may have introduced nonrandom differences between vaccinated and unvaccinated participants, thus rendering the post-authorization data less reliable. Therefore, to preserve randomization, we used the interim datasets that were the basis for emergency authorization in December 2020, approximately 4 months after trials commenced.
The definition of a serious adverse event (SAE) was provided in each trial’s study protocol and included in the supplemental material of the trial’s publication. [2], [3], [4] Pfizer and Moderna used nearly identical definitions, consistent with regulatory expectations. An SAE was defined as an adverse event that results in any of the following conditions: death; life-threatening at the time of the event; inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization; persistent or significant disability/incapacity; a congenital anomaly/birth defect; medically important event, based on medical judgment.
Here Doshi is echoing a common antivax talking point, in which it is claimed that the unblinding was carried out to hide AEs and much lower efficacy than reported based on the data used to obtain EUAs for the vaccines. Of course, the question of whether or not to unblind a clinical trial is a complex issue and depends on the intersection of bioethics and science. In the case of COVID-19 vaccines, after efficacy and safety were demonstrated in the first analyses, it became unethical to leave the control groups of those studies unprotected against COVID-19, which was surging around the world and causing mass illness, disability, and death. I won’t go into more detail, as I discussed the issue of unblinding the trials in detail over a year ago. Moreover, multiple assessments of the trials have concluded that both were rigorously conducted.
To accomplish the task of making the vaccines look bad, instead of looking at all AEs, as the papers and reports analyzing the data from the clinical trials did, Doshi and his colleagues decided to focus on “serious adverse events of special interest” (AESIs). The first version of this list was published early in the pandemic based on five reports from China and has undergone a total of four updates, the most recent of which was published last September. These SAEs were determined in the following manner described by Fraiman et al.:
We used an AESI list derived from the work of Brighton Collaboration’s Safety Platform for Emergency vACcines (SPEAC) Project. This project created an AESI list which categorizes AESIs into three categories: those included because they are seen with COVID-19, those with a proven or theoretical association with vaccines in general, and those with proven or theoretical associations with specific vaccine platforms. The first version was produced in March 2020 based on experience from China. Following the second update (May 2020), the WHO Global Advisory Committee on Vaccine Safety (GACVS) adopted the list, and Brighton commenced a systematic review process “to ensure an ongoing understanding of the full spectrum of COVID-19 disease and modification of the AESI list accordingly.” [7] This resulted in three additional AESIs being added to the list in December 2020. The subsequent (and most recent fourth) update did not result in any additional AESIs being added to the list. [1].
We matched SAEs recorded in the trial against an expanded list of AESIs created by combining Brighton’s SPEAC COVID-19 AESI list with a list of 29 clinical diagnoses Brighton identified as “known to have been reported but not in sufficient numbers to merit inclusion on the AESI list.” [7] Sensitivity analysis was used to determine whether use of the original versus expanded list altered our results.
So right away when I first read the preprint, I wondered how these diagnoses were being combined, mixed, and matched. The new version of the paper doesn’t alleviate my questions. If you look at the Brighton Collaborative document, you’ll see a lot of unremarkable standard AEs and SAEs, but you’ll also find ones that require interpretation. Here is the table defining its AESIs in Brighton’s Safety Platform for Emergency Vaccines (SPEAC):
The AESIs included because they have a theoretical or proven association with specific vaccine platforms are interesting, mainly because none of them are associated with the mRNA platform, but rather platforms that existed before the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines were released. Also note how the AESIs are (mostly) listed as broad categories, rather than specific diagnoses. Exceptions include, of course, myocarditis, which is associated with COVID-19 and has been associated in safety data with COVID-19 vaccines, but mapping the AEs in the clinical trials to these categories requires some subjectivity. There are more than just what’s listed above, delineated in a number of charts under each organ system. For example, colitis is listed in Annex 6, which encompasses the gastrointestinal system.
Indeed, here’s a passage that suggested the subjectivity to me:
We matched SAEs recorded in the trial against an expanded list of AESIs created by combining Brighton’s SPEAC COVID-19 AESI list with a list of 29 clinical diagnoses Brighton identified as “known to have been reported but not in sufficient numbers to merit inclusion on the AESI list.” [7] Sensitivity analysis was used to determine whether use of the original versus expanded list altered our results.
I note that in the original preprint, this passage read rather differently in that it used an example that really stood out as subjective:
We matched SAEs recorded in the trial against an expanded list of AESIs created by combining Brighton’s SPEAC COVID-19 AESI list with a list of 29 clinical diagnoses Brighton identified as “known to have been reported but not in sufficient numbers to merit inclusion on the AESI list.” Sensitivity analysis was used to determine whether the original versus expanded list had an effect on identifying a safety concern. For SAEs that described symptoms, not diagnoses, the clinician reviewers independently judged whether each SAE type was likely to have been caused by an AESI. For example, the SAE “abdominal pain” is a symptom based diagnosis, which was judged as fitting within the SPEAC clinical diagnosis of “colitis/enteritis.” Disagreements were resolved through consensus; in two cases, consensus could not be reached and were resolved by the judgment of a third clinician reviewer (PW) to create a majority opinion. For each included SAE, we recorded the corresponding Brighton Collaboration AESI category and organ.
Here’s a hint: Not all abdominal pain is due to colitis (inflammation of the colon) or enteritis (inflammation of the intestines). True, these are common causes, but there are so very many others. Similarly, what mapped to myocarditis and pericarditis? There are lots of causes of chest pain other than myocarditis and pericarditis. Also, in the supplemental data (which are in a Word document that can download and look at for yourself using a link at the end of the paper given that the lists are rather long to reproduce here), there are two lists, a list of “Included SAE types (matching AESI list)” and a list of “Excluded SAE types (not matching AESI list).”
Admittedly, many of the SAEs in the excluded list do make sense given that they include fractures, gunshot wounds, head injuries, and the like, but a number do not, such as viral pharyngitis, volvulus, vomiting, and others. When the preprint was published, Dr. Susan Oliver has posted a video discussing the problems with it, which I include here:
Dr. Oliver didn’t really discuss the meta problems with it and Doshi’s history, but she did note many of the same things that I did, in particular the odd choices of what was and wasn’t included as SAEs. For example, Doshi included diarrhea, but not vomiting (or, as the surgeon in me can’t help but note, intestinal perforation or volvulus, the latter a known complication of a certain vaccine); hyperglycemia (high blood sugar) but not hypoglycemia (low blood sugar); gastrointestinal hemorrhage but not duodenal ulcer hemorrhage (which is a form of gastrointestinal hemorrhage); and coronary artery disease but not atherosclerosis (which causes coronary artery disease). It’s all very curious. Perhaps the most important issue is that “events related to COVID-19” were excluded, which on the surface makes sense, but, given that COVID-19 cases were much more common in the placebo controlled group, automatically biases the results for the remaining SAEs to the vaccine-group.
That’s not all, though. Instead of comparing the number of people who had SAEs, they did this:
In their review of SAEs supporting the authorization of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, the FDA concluded that SAEs were, for Pfizer, “balanced between treatment groups,” [15] and for Moderna, were “without meaningful imbalances between study arms.” [16] In contrast to the FDA analysis, we found an excess risk of SAEs in the Pfizer trial. Our analysis of Moderna was compatible with FDA’s analysis, finding no meaningful SAE imbalance between groups.
The difference in findings for the Pfizer trial, between our SAE analysis and the FDA’s, may in part be explained by the fact that the FDA analyzed the total number of participants experiencing any SAE, whereas our analysis was based on the total number of SAE events. Given that approximately twice as many individuals in the vaccine group than in the placebo group experienced multiple SAEs (there were 24 more events than participants in the vaccine group, compared to 13 in the placebo group), FDA’s analysis of only the incidence of participants experiencing any SAE would not reflect the observed excess of multiple SAEs in the vaccine group.
To put it briefly, they compared number of SAEs, not the number of patients who suffered an SAE. This sort of analysis is guaranteed to double count SAES—at least!—because some of the SAEs or groups of SAES will be linked. For example, as Dr. Oliver originally pointed out, abdominal pain often goes along with diarrhea, to which I would add that colitis or enterocolitis can lead to gastrointestinal hemorrhage. Moreover, formal reporting systems for clinical trial AEs require that all AEs be entered, even when they are related, which is why analyses are usually done at the patient-level, as in “number of patients who suffered this AE”, rather than in total AEs reported in each group independent of the number of patients. I’d be willing to bet that if the same statistical analysis were done using per-patient-level data rather than SAE-level data the statistical significance would likely disappear.
Let’s look at the new version of the “money table,” which summarized the results and was being shared from the preprint on social media. I’ll cite David Grimes’ Tweet about it:
They *claimed* to find harms using a logistic regression on combined data, but I've serious concerns about how they implemented that model and details aren't there. A simple 2×2 chi^2 test on their rate data yields this; aka nothing, even after torture pic.twitter.com/knzTxN6RK9
— Dr David Robert Grimes (@drg1985) September 2, 2022
At this point, I can’t resist mentioning that defenders of the preprint claimed that this paper wasn’t “p-hacking” because no p-values were used. Personally, I’ll give that one to them and call the paper an exercise in data-dredging instead. (Of course, p-hacking is just a subset of the broader category of data dredging.) Or one can call it inflation bias if you like. It’s all the same thing in concept, namely when researchers try out several statistical analyses and/or data eligibility specifications and then selectively report those that produce significant results—or in this case seemingly significant results. In any event, whether you call it p-hacking, data dredging, or whatever else you might want to call it, it has been a widespread problem even under normal circumstances in the scientific literature, but a less known aspect of it is that it can be weaponized in the service of portraying vaccines, in this case the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, as more dangerous than they are and the RCTs used to garner their EUAs in December 2020 as flawed and not showing the “true extent” of serious AEs attributable to them.
Fraiman et al. also included this doozy of a comparison in both the preprint and the final paper. Here’s the version from the final paper:
In the Moderna trial, the excess risk of serious AESIs (15.1 per 10,000 participants) was higher than the risk reduction for COVID-19 hospitalization relative to the placebo group (6.4 per 10,000 participants). [3] In the Pfizer trial, the excess risk of serious AESIs (10.1 per 10,000) was higher than the risk reduction for COVID-19 hospitalization relative to the placebo group (2.3 per 10,000 participants).
I notice that the wording was changed from “surpassed” to “was higher than,” but it’s basically the same paragraph in the preprint and the final paper. So what’s the problem? Think of it this way. You can only hospitalize patients, not SAEs (or AEs). An individual patient in the vaccine group could suffer more than one AE, but a patient in the placebo control group could only be hospitalized once (in the context of the limited timeframe of the clinical trial) for COVID-19. Here Doshi is comparing apples and oranges in order to make it look as though the vaccines were more dangerous than actually getting COVID-19, which is a ridiculous contention given what we know. Moreover, in clinical trials in general a lot of the “serious adverse events” are not serious enough to warrant hospitalization. In fact, according to the standard terminology used to rate SAEs in clinical trials grade 3 events and above (on a five-point scale) are rated severe. If you look at the list of specific AEs, you’ll see that some grade 3 AEs require hospitalization; some don’t. Grade 3 is defined as an AE that:
    • Is severe or medically significant but not immediately life-threatening; OR
    • Requires hospitalization or prolongation of hospitalization indicated; OR
    • Limits self care/activities of daily living (ADL)
For completeness, I’ll mention that grade 4 AEs are by definition life-threatening events that require urgent intervention and that grade 5 events are by definition AEs that result in death. Any rigorous evaluation would compare hospitalizations due to AEs in control versus hospitalizations due to AEs in the vaccine group, not AEs (regardless of whether they are AESIs or just AEs). Again, the comparison was deeply intellectually dishonest then in the preprint and remains so now.
There’s another issue here as well. The rate of hospitalizations in the placebo control group would be expected to be highly dependent on the level of COVID-19 that was circulating in the populations tested during the time period in which the clinical trial was carried out, as these trials were not challenge trials, in which subjects are intentionally exposed to the virus. As a result, most people in the placebo and vaccine groups were not exposed to COVID-19, because these trials were carried out in the summer and early fall of 2020, before the really big winter surge hit.
Here’s a graph of COVID-19 cases in the US in 2020-21:

Enrollment for the Moderna trial ended on October 23, 2020; for the Pfizer trial, November 14, 2020. Note that this was before the winter surge took off. Had the trial started a few months later and ended in, for example, February 2021 or later, you can bet that the rates of hospitalization for COVID-19 would have been much higher in the placebo control group.
The bottom line is that this study is deeply misleading based on what sure looks like data dredging combined with misleading comparisons, further combined with a low enough risk of COVID-19 in the two populations to allow for a low rate of hospitalization when normalized to the entire population in the control group.
This paper is nothing less than antivax misinformation disguised as a “reanalysis” of the original Pfizer and Moderna trials. Worse, it doesn’t even show what it claims to have shown, that the trials were somehow designed and written in such a way as to hide lots of adverse events. As such, it’s no different at its core than Peter Doshi’s back-of-the-envelope “reanalysis” of the Pfizer trial in which he claimed that the vaccine was not more than 90% effective but rather only 19% effective. It just has fancier statistics and a much longer discussion of limitations, including this section, a beefed-up version of what is undoubtedly pure Peter Doshi, given how it echoes what he’s been demanding since January 2021, when he falsely claimed that the vaccines were only 19% effective:
We emphasize that our investigation is preliminary, to point to the need for more involved analysis. The risks of serious AESIs in the trials represent only group averages. SAEs are unlikely to be distributed equally across the demographic subgroups enrolled in the trial, and the risks may be substantially less in some groups compared to others. Thus, knowing the actual demographics of those who experienced an increase in serious AESI in the vaccine group is necessary for a proper harm-benefit analysis. In addition, clinical studies are needed to see if particular SAEs can be linked to particular vaccine ingredients as opposed to unavoidable consequences of exposure to spike protein, as future vaccines could then be modified accordingly or sensitivities can be tested for in advance. In parallel, a systematic review and meta-analysis using individual participant data should be undertaken to address questions of harm-benefit in various demographic subgroups, particularly in those at low risk of serious complications from COVID-19. Finally, there is a pressing need for comparison of SAEs and harm-benefit for different vaccine types; some initial work has already begun in this direction. [47].
Full transparency of the COVID-19 vaccine clinical trial data is needed to properly evaluate these questions. Unfortunately, as we approach 2 years after release of COVID-19 vaccines, participant level data remain inaccessible. [45], [46].
Again, given the billions of doses of these vaccines administered thus far, the only reason to sift through subject-level data in nearly three year old clinical trials of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, each of which only included only tens of thousands of participants, is if you’re looking for dirt and fraud, not to do an objective evaluation of whether the vaccines are safe and effective. After all, conditions have changed; the rise of the Delta and Omicron variants led to the vaccines becoming significantly less effective against infection and transmission, even as they remain potent at preventing hospitalization and death. If you really want to know how safe and effective the vaccines are now (and have been over time), the original clinical trials are far from the best dataset to use, and this “reanalysis” failed to find even a signal that there might have been a severe design defect or fraud in the original clinical trials. I’m all for data transparency and have no objections to releasing patient level data, but Doshi knows that this is not a trivial thing to do, as all the data have to be carefully de-identified and curated.
The authors
Whenever reviewing a paper of this sort, I always find it useful to look at the authors, even at the risk of being accused of ad hominem. Of course, it’s not an ad hominem if you discuss the persons making an argument briefly and then deconstruct the argument they make based on science, data, and reasoning. After all, track record matters. Interestingly, this group is, to say the least, a mixed bunch, ranging from authors associated with antivaxxers to highly respected academics: Joseph Fraiman, Juan Erviti, Mark Jones, Sander Greenland, Patrick Whelan, Robert M. Kaplan, and Peter Doshi.
I’ll start with the corresponding author, Peter Doshi, because regular readers will know that we’ve written about his antivaccine messaging before. In brief, Doshi is a senior editor at The BMJ, which inexplicably hired him several years ago despite his long history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement since at least 2009, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines, as well as having signed a petition in 2006 “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS. It continues to employ him even after he fell for a conspiracy theory that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database was being made inaccessible to suppress reporting of serious adverse events. That’s not all, though, he’s also served as an expert witness for the plaintiffs in antivaccine leader Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s lawsuit against the University of California’s influenza vaccine mandates.
Since the pandemic, Doshi has only gotten worse. For example, he has used his title as a BMJ editor when taking part in a “roundtable” organized by Sen. Ron Johnson to go dumpster diving in VAERS to find “vaccine injuries” due to COVID-19 vaccines, whether the injuries were caused by them or not. In his testimony, Doshi denied that COVID-19 at the time (November 2021) was a “pandemic of the unvaccinated”. He even cited cherry-picked tables to claim that the vaccine wasn’t saving lives in what was basically an updated rehash of the nonsense he had peddled a few months earlier in which he claimed that there was “no biodistribution data” for COVID-19 vaccines and made a number of other negative false claims about the vaccines (also deconstructed by Dr. Hilda Bastian). In a truly risible moment, he even cited the Merriam-Webster definition of “antivaxxer” as opposed to those supposedly opposed to vaccine mandates to argue that he and his fellow COVID-19 contrarians were “not antivaccine” and that large numbers of people would qualify as “antivaccine”. He even parroted the antivaccine talking point that mRNA vaccines are not really vaccines and therefore shouldn’t be mandated like vaccines.
But what about the rest? Two other names that immediately leapt out at me are Joseph Fraiman and Patrick Whelan. Dr. Fraiman is an emergency medicine doctor in New Orleans who has appeared at the Urgency of Normal summit held by Gov. DeSantis and Dr. Ladapo and been associated with COVID-19 minimization since the beginning of the pandemic. In particular, recently he has been arguing that children should not be vaccinated against COVID-19 using arguments identical to those used by antivaxxers to argue against childhood vaccines since…time immemorial: “The question is, if you have a child who is at risk or has co-risk factors for COVID-19, that’s a discussion with your pediatrician, but if you have a healthy child, the chances of that child dying are incredibly low, essentially close to zero if not actually zero”. He’s also made statements claiming that “unvaccinated are more educated on the vaccine than most people who have gotten it”, and that experts cannot disprove concerns made by anti-vaccine advocates. (He’s also recently embraced the Great Barrington Declaration despite its increasing irrelevance.) You get the idea.
As for Patrick Whelan, he’s a pediatric rheumatologist at UCLA who made a splash in December 2020 by testifying to the FDA about his fears that the Pfizer mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine could cause microvascular injury to the brain, heart, liver and kidneys in ways not assessed in safety trials and has been featured on antivaccine websites. He’s also warned against vaccinating those who have had COVID-19 because “sky high” antibodies after vaccination in people who were previously infected may contribute to adverse events. He, too, appeared at Sen. Ron Johnson’s antivaccine panel to fearmonger about spike protein from COVID-19 vaccines. Of late, Dr. Whelan appears to have been more quiet, with more recent searches turning up his name mainly in association with his December 2020 testimony and things he said in 2021. This paper apparently represents a return to vaccine “skepticism”.
I’ll be honest, I wasn’t able to find much about Mark Jones and Juan Erviti. Jones is an associate professor of health sciences and medicine at the Institute for Evidence-Based Healthcare, as well as a biostatistician at Bond University in Australia. Searches for his name related to COVID-19 turned up little except references to the preprint and Vaccine study, an article on cancer overdiagnosis, with little on COVID-19 other than articles studying healthcare workers’ responses to the pandemic and a letter asking why more studies of COVID-19 vaccine efficacy haven’t been carried out in Australia. As for Erviti, he’s published with Doshi before in The BMJ expressing skepticism over monitoring of COVID-19 vaccine safety and efficacy, as well as a BMJ Rapid Response to an article demanding patient-level data from the Pfizer and Moderna vaccine trials.
Then there are Sander Greenland and Robert M. Kaplan, who will feature in the next section.
The real reason why Vaccine published this paper?
The two authors of this paper who seem beyond reproach are Sander Greenland and Robert M. Kaplan. Greenland, as I mentioned above, is a retired emeritus professor and a veritable god of statistics, someone whom I have regularly cited before. Kaplan is a Distinguished Emeritus Professor of Health Services and Medicine at UCLA, where he led the UCLA/RAND US Agency for Health Care Research and Quality (AHRQ) health services training program and the UCLA/RAND CDC Prevention Research Center. Currently, he is an adjunct professor of medicine and primary care and population health at Stanford University. He’s had a long and storied career, having published over 560 articles and chapters and served as Chief Science Officer at the AHRQ and Associate Director of the National Institutes of Health, where he led the behavioral and social sciences programs. He was also Professor and Chair of the Department of Family and Preventive Medicine at the University of California, San Diego and is past president of several professional societies, including the American Psychological Association Division of Health Psychology, Section J of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (Pacific), the International Society for Quality of Life Research, the Society for Behavioral Medicine, and the Academy of Behavioral Medicine Research. He was also elected to the National Academy of Medicine in 2005.
Seeing these two makes me wonder: Why on earth did they sign on to this awfulness? For Sander Greenland, there could well be an answer. I can’t believe I either didn’t know or remember this, but this isn’t Greenland’s first antivax rodeo. Does anyone remember the Autism Omnibus hearings? Back in the mid-2000s, the Vaccine Court decided to take an approach to the flood of claims attributing autism to “vaccine injury” in which complainants would choose a few cases that they considered to be the very best, the most convincing, as evidence of a link between vaccines and autism, dividing them into two groups: causation due to mercury in the thimerosal preservative that had been used in many childhood vaccines before 2002 and other causation (e.g., MMR as a cause of autism). These cases then served as “test cases” to determine whether the ~5,000 other cases could go forward. Let’s just say that the complainants’ cases were all based on bad science and featured many of the usual suspects as expert witnesses arguing for vaccine causation. However, it turns out that one of those expert witnesses was not one of the usual suspects. As Steve Salzberg described at the time of a ruling on the test cases for a thimerosal-autism link, it was Sander Greenland:
It’s interesting that Vowell found that even if the “exquisitely small” amounts of mercury in vaccines had an effect, they wouldn’t cause autism. It was also somewhat sad to see how a well-known statistician, UCLA professor Sander Greenland, appearing in support of the thimerosal-autism link, embarrassed himself by presenting testimony that “largely represented an opinion based on a set of assumptions,” according to the ruling. Greenland’s arguments relied entirely on the existence of “clearly regressive autism,” but the Special Master pointed out that Greenland “was not qualified to opine on its existence.” Ouch.
Apparently, if the comments after Salzberg’s post are to be believed, Greenland later tried to claim that he had not testified in favor of a link between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, but he most definitely did. I have the receipts in terms of the transcript of his testimony.
As for Kaplan, I still remain puzzled why he put his name on this paper. It’s a blot on his reputation. On the other hand, in July 2021, Kaplan was arguing that vaccines were getting more credit than they deserved for the decline of COVID-19 cases being observed at the time, touting—you guessed it!—”natural immunity”:
As coronavirus infections decline in the U.S., it seems appropriate to celebrate the triumph of vaccines over viruses. But how much of the credit do vaccines deserve? Less than you might expect.
And later:
But one trend appears to be clear. As in previous pandemics, the rapid fall in new cases preceded the widespread distribution of vaccines. Although vaccines deserve much credit for declining rates of Covid-19, the protection provided by natural infection has been underappreciated. Emerging evidence shows that previously infected people have effective and durable immunity that rivals or exceeds the benefits of vaccines.
Sound familiar? I also note that this was before the rise of the Omicron variants, which have shown that “natural immunity” after infection is anything but “durable”. Still, you get the idea. Kaplan also wrote an op-ed for The Wall Street Journal, a hotbed of COVID-19 minimization, in which he stated that the “idea that recent, deliberate misinformation campaigns created hesitancy to the Covid-19 vaccine appears itself to be misinformation”. So apparently Kaplan was predisposed to Doshi’s narrative about the Pfizer and Moderna clinical trials because he thinks that “natural immunity” to COVID=19 is being ignored by public health officials. I could be wrong, but at least that’s the way it appears to me.
Defenders of Fraiman et al. will, of course, vigorously deny that they are antivaccine (as do all the authors themselves) and frequently issue a rejoinder along the lines of accusing anyone who questions anything about the safety and efficacy of any vaccine “antivaccine”. My rejoinder to such a rejoinder would be to suggest that maybe—just maybe—when you coauthor a study that leads to headlines on antivax sites like “Landmark first peer-reviewed study on Pfizer and Moderna covid vaccines confirms ‘excess risk’ of adverse side effects“, “New Study of Pfizer and Moderna Data Suggests Vaccine Harm Outweighs Benefit” (on The Epoch Times, yet!), or “Vaccinated at Higher Risk of Serious Adverse Events: Reanalysis of Original Trial Data” (also The Epoch Times), it should give you serious pause about what has been published. Again, maybe—just maybe—when your study inspires a hard core antivaxxer like Dr. Paul Alexander to publicize on his Substack with a rabid-sounding title like “BOOM! Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joe Ladapo SCHLONGING big pharma Pfizer & Moderna, all of them; new Doshi study in VACCINE journal shows catastrophic adverse events after mRNA injections” (and using the study as the basis for a whole lot of other invective against vaccines), you should reconsider where your career has brought you. (As an aside, I must admit that I’ve never seen “schlong” used as a verb, much less in all caps, in this manner. Clearly, I am more sheltered than I had thought.) Maybe—just maybe—when your study has inspired over 16,000 Twitter interactions across over 2,400 Tweets and 14,000 re-Tweets in just five days, the vast majority of which are using your study to amplify antivaccine conspiracy theories, you might ask yourself if your study is actually antivax propaganda more than a study.
A few more examples, because I can’t resist:
It’s not antibodies that are the issue. Its what else the vaccines do. Eg see: https://t.co/mdCqqwFx6lFoetuses are notoriously susceptible (think thalidomide or even alcohol). Other red flags include preferential accumulation of lipid nanoparticles in ovaries & menstrual issues
— Alan Johnson (@AlanJohnson1959) September 5, 2022
Bringing awareness to the massive amounts of deaths caused by these injections! It's a good thing that your dullard opinion means absolutely nothing!https://t.co/EBCWrclQtE
— Donnie V (@DonnieV23) September 5, 2022
no evidence for all-cause mortality benefit was ever demonstrated from the initial vaccine. In fact, both pfizer and moderna's trials were trending in the wrong direction before they sabotaged their control groups. https://t.co/QaDR9wX9De
— Eric Meller (@EricMeller) September 4, 2022
I'm not telling you what to do. But I feel this info is not being discussed widely and openly enough yet so would like to share it. These pharmaceutical companies have a long history of malfeasance and profit seeking at any cost.https://t.co/e5R01RgBgn
— Communist Varmint (@ooXei1sh) September 4, 2022
As I perused mentions of this study on Twitter, I also noted that quite a few of the Tweets were just links to the study Tweeted in response to pro-vaccine Tweets.
Don’t get me wrong, though. Contrary to how antivaxxers will characterize what I just wrote, I’m not saying that vaccines are sacrosanct in any way. It is certainly true that, if a scientist participates in a scientifically sound study that comes to a conclusion that antivaxxers happen like because it calls the safety or efficacy of a vaccine into question, absolutely the scientist should stand by the results. Unfortunately, that is not what we have here—far from it! In fact, what we appear to have here is not a group of scientists innocently wondering if there were more adverse events (of special interest!) in the vaccinated group in the Pfizer and Moderna studies, but rather a group of scientists that included several who almost certainly started with the conclusion that the vaccines must be more harmful than the disease and looked for a manner to “reanalyze” the clinical trial data to come to that conclusion, even if they had to compare apples and oranges (AEs and hospitalizations) and redefine AES as AESIs in order to achieve the desired result. Even then they failed, as David Grimes points out.
I’ll conclude this post with a little speculation—and I openly admit that it is speculation, as I have no “inside knowledge”—about why this paper, as horrible as it is, as heavily (and correctly) criticized as the preprint was in June, ended up in Vaccine with only relatively minor changes in the context of its findings. I strongly suspect that it’s the same reason that John Ioannidis was able to get a much worse paper published rather easily in which he used a satirical index of scientific influence in order to portray critics of the Great Barrington Declaration as far more influential on social media than they are for actual science. It’s the name. When someone like Ioannidis submits a manuscript as the most published living scientist at the moment, someone whose reputation is downright intimidating, rare is the peer reviewer or editor who will just say: Reject! Although Sander Greenland and Robert Kaplan are not quite at the level of John Ioannidis, they are very eminent in their fields, with Greenland being a legend. Again, I cannot demonstrate it, but it’s not unreasonable to suspect that those names dazzled the reviewers and editors, who changed what should have been a rejection to a conditional acceptance in which the authors had to change a few things and add a lot more caveats but left their basic analysis more or less intact. Thus was born antivax propaganda disguised as a “reanalysis” of clinical trial data.
I end with a plea to the most eminent physicians and scientists among us: Learn to understand how exercises like this one are weaponized as disinformation and refuse to lend your eminent names to them. When you sign on to a manuscript like this, you become part of the problem and provide antivaxxers with the powerful ammunition of your reputation, no matter how much you might try to tell yourself that you’re just doing a scientific study and are not antivaccine.

Scientific review articles as antivaccine disinformation
Antivaxxers have always written dubious scientific review articles to try to make their wild speculations about vaccine science seem credible. Usually such articles wind up in bottom-feeding journals. Unfortunately a recent pseudo-review article was published by an Elsevier journal, making it seem more credible when it isn’t.
David Gorski on April 25, 2022
Link

I’ve long lamented a certain blind spot among my fellow physicians and scientists, a problem that the COVID-19 pandemic has made even more painfully apparent to me. What I’m referring to is our inability as a group to recognize when science is being distorted and thereby weaponized in order to become disinformation. This is not a new technique, but it’s been turbocharged and used more frequently and intensely than ever before. I was reminded of this by a recent Twitter thread, the first part of which I will cite here:
McCullough just published a paper in “Food and Chemical Toxicology” that posits biological mechanisms underlying purported innate immune suppression and harm from SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccination, using VAERs to support their hypotheses of vaccine relatedness of noted pathologies.
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) April 21, 2022
This long review article presents many details about various biological pathways, but their links to mRNA vaccines are almost wholly speculative. In some cases, they link to other vaccines, old mRNA technology, or COVID-19 infection, but are not directly linked to mRNA vaccines.
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) April 21, 2022
Naturally, antivaxxers have been spreading this study far and wide as yet more “evidence” that mRNA vaccines against COVID-19 are dangerous:
Please tell me how to sue and how to get a lawyer before I die. I was 100% documented healthy and now I have an issue in almost every system in my body. My eyes can no longer focus, my brain is vibrating 24hrs a day, and I can no longer work or exercise.
— WeTheUSPeople (@WeTheUSPeople) April 23, 2022
mRNA vaccines promote sustained synthesis of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein.
The spike protein is neurotoxic, and it impairs DNA repair mechanisms.
Suppression of type I interferon responses results in impaired innate immunity.https://t.co/236jClq43r
— Dr. Lynn Fynn (Fan Account)🐭 (@fynn_fan) April 17, 2022
Dear Helen u weren’t the premier who relentlessly pushed this dangerous injecticide down our throats. A lot of citizens are suffering ma’am. Time to pull the plug I think.
Innate immune suppression by SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccinations: The role of… https://t.co/c9kP1r38aM
— Sagezza (@sagezza2) April 21, 2022
I could list many more such Tweets, as well as the study being shared this way on Facebook with similar messaging that it’s strong evidence that mRNA vaccines are dangerous and suppress the innate immune system, the spike protein is toxic, and large numbers of people are being harmed by them—exactly as intended by the antivaxxers who wrote it. But is it evidence of any of this? I think that you know the answer. Rather, it is a prime example of what I now refer to as misinformation (or disinformation) by scientific review article (or, more accurately, a pseudo-review article). It appears to have all the trappings of science, but its speculation goes far beyond what the science will support, all in the service of promoting a certain narrative and providing what seems to be scientific support for a pseudoscientific conspiracy theory. Unsurprisingly, it worked, as its social media engagement demonstrates.
It is also true that Prof. Morris nailed it perfectly in the fourth Tweet in his series. This “review” article is almost entirely speculative. However, not having such a long history of examining antivaccine pseudoscience, he missed observing that the article is speculative in a deceptive manner that I’ve seen many times before dating back to the Hannah Poling story in 2008, in which antivaxxers tried to rebrand autism as a mitochondrial disorder in which vaccines interacted with a metabolic disease to trigger autism, a narrative that “functional medicine” guru Dr. Mark Hyman echoed and that was still being promoted up to right before the pandemic. As a preview, I’ll mention that other examples include Yehuda Shoenfeld’s “ASIA” diagnosis, the idea of “molecular mimicry” by HPV vaccines, and “homologous recombinaltion tiniker” (misspelling preserved from the original). Think of this long “review” as a Gish gallop disguised as a review article. There are lots of claims, all speculative, many for which the cited evidence is at best tenuous and often requires quite the leap to go from what the evidence finds about a process and how that process might be related to COVID-19 vaccination.
Combined with the speculative claims about biological mechanism is also an exercise in dumpster diving into the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database in a manner very much like how Tracy Beth Høeg and other COVID-19 contrarians did for myocarditis last summer in an echo of how Mark and David Geier did it 16 years ago trying to “prove” that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that was used in some childhood vaccines until around 2001-2 caused autism, other antivaxxers tried to link the H1N1 vaccine to miscarriages (sound familiar?), and how Stephanie Seneff used the same deceptive technique to try to demonstrate in 2012 that aluminum adjuvants in vaccines and exposure to acetaminophen caused autism. Since COVID-19 vaccines hit the scene in December 2020, weaponization of VAERS reports has been a constant among antivaxxers.
Who wrote this paper?
The last name I mentioned is important. Why? Because Stephanie Seneff is the lead author of the paper that’s been going around. She was an antivaxxer before the pandemic who blamed vaccines and GMOs for autism; it’s not surprising that she pivoted to being anti-COVID-19 vaccines, although early in the pandemic she tried to blame glyphosate and e-cigarettes for COVID-19. (I kid you not.) Like many antivaxxers before and during the pandemic, she has no primary expertise in vaccines, infectious disease, public health, epidemiology, or any other relevant biomedical academic disciplines. Rather, she’s a computer scientist at MIT, and her sole qualification (if you can call it that) is an undergraduate biophysics degree from the late 1960s. In addition to her history promoting antivaccine misinformation, she has also made some truly off-base proclamations over the last several years, including her prediction in 2014 that by 2025 half of all children born that year will be autistic. (It’s 2022 now. How’d that prediction work out?) She even once claimed that GMOs can cause concussions.
We’ve also met Peter McCullough before. He’s a cardiologist who has been promoting a narrative that COVID-19 vaccines are causing a “holocaust” for over a year now. Unsurprisingly, he’s also promoted ivermectin as a near “miracle cure” for COVID-19. Basically, Dr. McCullough has become a major force in promoting COVID-19 pseudoscience, quackery, and misinformation and is frequently on the speaker’s list for COVID-19 denial rallies and events.
I was interested in the other two authors, Greg Nigh and Anthony Kyriakopoulous, as I didn’t recall having heard of them before. Greg Nigh is listed as being affiliated with Immersion Health in Portland, OR. Surprise! Surprise! Immersion Health is a naturopathic oncology clinic:
Immersion Health opened its doors in 2014. Dr. Greg Nigh and Maria Zilka, the clinic’s founders, have collaborated on cancer treatment for 10 years. Immersion Health brings them together to offer intensive, comprehensive and individualized programs for the treatment of all types and stages of cancer. In addition to cancer care, Dr. Nigh offers the full range of primary care medicine, including functional lab testing and genetic polymorphism analysis.
Immersion Health was started as an intensive naturopathic oncology clinic. Dr. Nigh develops comprehensive and intensive treatment programs for all types and stages of cancer.
The cancer treatment approach at Immersion Health is unique, recognizing cancer as a metabolic disease. At Immersion Health we are delivering therapies that address all aspects of health and vitality, because long-term success against cancer depends on a strong immune system, low inflammation, ongoing detoxification, lifelong nutritional strategies, stress management, physical activity and much more. Immersion Health brings this all together into individualized treatment plans that optimize every individual’s potential for recovery and ongoing wellness.
Naturopathy is quackery, and naturopathic oncology doubly so. Just peruse this blog for many, many examples. Unsurprisingly, naturopaths have pivoted to COVID-19 quackery. Of the group, Anthony Kyriakopoulous has the closest to what one might consider actual qualifications, working at the Nasco AD Biotechnology Laboratory, a lab in Greece described as a “private research laboratory focusing on the discovery, development and thereafter clinical application of patented medicinal formulations to provide innovative technology against infections inflammation autoimmunity and cancer”. He also appears to have some expertise in RNAs and inflammation, but, as I always say, if you’re an expert in something but associate your name with cranks, quacks, and pseudoscientists like Stephanie Seneff, Peter McCullough, and Greg Nigh, that should be a major red flag that perhaps the expert has gone crank.
Of course, defenders of authors like these would call what I just wrote an “ad hominem” attack. It’s not, really. It could be an ad hominem attack if the only reason I gave for their paper being wrong were because it was authored by them, but you know me better than that. My response to such a charge is always the same: Qualifications matter. Author history matters. All but one of the authors are utterly unqualified to write a review article like this, and the one who arguably does have some qualifications is not the first author or the corresponding author. That tells me a lot before I read beyond the abstract.
Finally, this is a long article. That’s why, unlike Prof. Morris, I’m going to approach it more from the angle of disinformation and its similarities to previous papers like it before the pandemic than get into the weeds of each and every claim, especially given that he has provided a good blog post that does get into the weeds, some of which I will borrow from given that it’s impossible not to address some claims. Again, Prof. Morris was quite correct that the paper is largely speculative and doesn’t cite a lot of primary evidence, but that very speculativeness is a hallmark of many prior antivax narratives that try to postulate a biological “mechanism” by which vaccines caused autism and all manner of other health issues dating way, way back. Similarly, the paper does a VAERS dumpster dive to try to lend credibility to its speculation.
A scientific review as disinformation
One of the more interesting things, from a disinformation standpoint, is a figure right at the beginning of the review, described as a “graphical abstract.” When I first read the paper, I hadn’t recalled seeing such a figure described thusly, but I did recall a number of figures from the past in which vaccines were inserted into metabolic and immune pathways to make a science-y looking diagram arguing how vaccines caused this problem or other. Let’s take a look:

Let’s look at the actual written abstract and compare:
The mRNA SARS-CoV-2 vaccines were brought to market in response to the public health crises of Covid-19. The utilization of mRNA vaccines in the context of infectious disease has no precedent. The many alterations in the vaccine mRNA hide the mRNA from cellular defenses and promote a longer biological half-life and high production of spike protein. However, the immune response to the vaccine is very different from that to a SARS-CoV-2 infection. In this paper, we present evidence that vaccination induces a profound impairment in type I interferon signaling, which has diverse adverse consequences to human health. Immune cells that have taken up the vaccine nanoparticles release into circulation large numbers of exosomes containing spike protein along with critical microRNAs that induce a signaling response in recipient cells at distant sites. We also identify potential profound disturbances in regulatory control of protein synthesis and cancer surveillance. These disturbances potentially have a causal link to neurodegenerative disease, myocarditis, immune thrombocytopenia, Bell’s palsy, liver disease, impaired adaptive immunity, impaired DNA damage response and tumorigenesis. We show evidence from the VAERS database supporting our hypothesis. We believe a comprehensive risk/benefit assessment of the mRNA vaccines questions them as positive contributors to public health.
I will concede that the immune response to the vaccine is likely different than the immune response to a SARS-CoV-2 infection, but not in the way described in this paper that implies that it’s just as bad or worse than the immune reaction to infection. The authors claim that the “mRNA vaccine initiates a set of biological events that are not only different from that induced by infection but are in several ways demonstrably counterproductive to both short- and long-term immune competence and normal cellular function” but, as Prof, Morris notes, they self-cite to do it:
A preprint has revealed a remarkable difference between the characteristics of the immune response to an infection with SARS-CoV-2 as compared with the immune response to an mRNA vaccine against COVID-19 (Ivanova et al., 2021).
Where does that link go? Straight back to this review article! (If you don’t believe me and think that I altered the link, just go to the article itself and click on the link.) The actual paper is a preprint from August that appears to be still a preprint, and the interesting thing about it is that the paper demonstrates a good thing about COVID-19 mRNA vaccines, namely:
In COVID-19 patients, immune responses were characterized by a highly augmented interferon response which was largely absent in vaccine recipients. Increased interferon signaling likely contributed to the dramatic upregulation of cytotoxic genes in the peripheral T cells and innate- like lymphocytes observed in COVID-19 patients. Analysis of B and T cell repertoires revealed that while the majority of clonal lymphocytes in COVID-19 patients were effector cells, in vaccine recipients clonal expansion was primarily restricted to circulating memory cells. Taken together, our analysis of immune responses to the mRNA vaccine reveals that despite the lack of dramatic inflammation observed during infection, the vaccine elicits a robust adaptive immune response.
Then Seneff et al. also claim:
All of these observations are consistent with the idea that the anti-COVID-19 vaccines actively suppress type I IFN signaling, as we will discuss below.
More likely, it’s consistent with the vaccines not stimulating type I IFN signaling and all the inflammation that comes with it, which is a good thing. After all, that’s what you want from a vaccine: a robust immune response that doesn’t come with all the inflammation caused by the infection but still ends up producing memory cells that can be reactivated by contact with the provoking antigen! After all, the main issue is that actual infection is, well, infection. It stimulates the immune response as the virus is replicating freely and damaging cells, thus leading to inflammation, both specific to the infection and nonspecific. Also, the mRNA vaccines induce muscle cells to make the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, which is the protein that binds to the ACE2 receptor on human cells and allows the virus to enter them. That’s the target of the immune response. Infection would be expected to result in an immune response to more viral proteins than just the spike protein.
Just the introduction is full of additional misrepresentations, for example:
Since long-term pre-clinical and Phase I safety trials were combined with Phase II trials, then phase II and III trials were combined (Kwok, 2021); and since even those were terminated early and placebo arms given the injections, we look to the pharmacosurveillance system and published reports for safety signals. In doing so, we find that that evidence is not encouraging. The biological response to mRNA vaccination as it is currently employed is demonstrably not similar to natural infection. In this paper we will illustrate those differences, and we will describe the immunological and pathological processes we expect are being initiated by mRNA vaccination. We will connect these underlying physiological effects with both realized and yet-to-be-observed morbidities. We anticipate that implementation of booster vaccinations on a wide scale will amplify all of these problems.
This is a deceptive misrepresentation of what actually happened, something I wrote about over a year ago. Basically, once the vaccines were released under an emergency use authorization (EUA), there was no way to guarantee that subjects in the placebo arm of the large clinical trials carried out by Pfizer and Moderna for their vaccines would not simply get vaccinated. After all, the EUA had been issued, and doctors and the government were doing everything they could to encourage people to be vaccinated against COVID-19. The unblinding and crossover of the clinical trials was actually the ethical thing to do, even if it complicated the long term safety surveillance. Once a vaccine demonstrated to be effective and safe has been released to the public, regardless of the regulatory mechanism under which it was approved, it was, quite simply, unethical to continue to withhold the vaccine from the subjects in the placebo group. This is an issue that antivaxxers and those who enable them have long distorted; so it’s not at all surprising that Seneff et al. are doing it too.
They also parrot a number of common anti-COVID-19 vaccine talking points that I’ve discussed both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog:
The mRNA vaccines manufactured by Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna have been viewed as an essential aspect of our efforts to control the spread of COVID-19. Countries around the globe have been aggressively promoting massive vaccination programs with the hope that such efforts might finally curtail the ongoing pandemic and restore normalcy. Governments are reticent to consider the possibility that these injections might cause harm in unexpected ways, and especially that such harm might even surpass the benefits achieved in protection from severe disease. It is now clear that the antibodies induced by the vaccines fade in as little as 3–10 weeks after the second dose (Shrotri et al., 2021), such that people are being advised to seek booster shots at regular intervals (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2021b). It has also become apparent that rapidly emerging variants such as the Delta and now the Omicron strain are showing resistance to the antibodies induced by the vaccines, through mutations in the spike protein (Yahi et al., 2021). Furthermore, it has become clear that the vaccines do not prevent transmission of the disease, but can only be claimed to reduce symptom severity (Kampf, 2021a). A study comparing vaccination rates with COVID-19 infection rates across 68 countries and 2947 counties in the United States in early September 2021, found no correlation between the two, suggesting that these vaccines do not protect from spread of the disease (Subramanian and Kumar, 2947). Regarding symptom severity, even this aspect is beginning to be in doubt, as demonstrated by an outbreak in an Israeli hospital that led to the death of five fully vaccinated hospital patients (Shitrit et al., 2021). Similarly, Brosh-Nissimov et al. (2021) reported that 34/152 (22%) of fully vaccinated patients among 17 Israeli hospitals died of COVID-19.
Note the appeal to “natural immunity” (more properly called postinfection immunity or infection-induced immunity) above all, even though evidence is increasingly showing that “natural immunity” wanes as well and likely doesn’t last much longer than vaccine-induced immunity. Moreover, the rise of the very variants that can evade prior immunity (Delta and Omicron) demonstrates that “natural immunity” can be bypassed by the virus almost as easily as vaccine-induced immunity. In addition, as any immunologist knows, antibody levels don’t stay high forever after an infection or a vaccine. If that were the case, our blood would soon become a viscous glop of nothing but high levels of antibodies to previously-encountered antigens to which the immune system had responded. It’s the development of memory cells, which can quickly be reactivated to produce antibodies when the immune system encounters an antigen again, that matter more. As for disease transmission, once again we see the “Nirvana fallacy”, in which anything less than 100% safety and efficacy implies that a treatment or vaccine is worthless, in this case that the “vaccine doesn’t prevent transmission”. Actually, it does; it’s just not 100% effective and the effect, like that of the vaccine, does wane. The way to look at it is that the vaccines are “less good” at preventing infection and transmission than they are at preventing serious disease and death, not that they don’t prevent transmission or infection at all. Let’s just say that it doesn’t look good when the evidence cited for the claim that the “vaccines don’t prevent transmission” is a study as risibly awful as Subramanian and Kumar.
The rest of the paper before the VAERS dumpster diving reminds me of something I used to do with a friend of mine back when we were in junior high. It probably won’t surprise readers to learn that, even at that tender age, I was a science geek (also just what was considered in the mid-1970s to be just a geek). There were times when my friend and I would wildly speculate about science that we only slightly understood, wondering if there were a link between this idea and other ideas, whether genetic engineering were possible (remember, this was the 1970s), and a whole bunch of “what ifs”. It was fun at the time, even though our knowledge of science was junior high science geek level, and such flights of speculative fancy no doubt increased our enthusiasm for science, to the point where both of us became doctors, me a surgeon-scientist and my friend a pathologist.
Let’s just say a lot of this paper reminds me of those days, stringing ideas together without much in the way of good evidence, and saying “What if?” Of course, junior high science geeks ultimately grew up to study serious science, but this paper strikes me as being similar to what we did, the exception being that we were engaging in our speculative arguments innocently. This paper is not so innocent, even if it seems to have applied a gloss of scientific findings to the same sort of speculative flights of fancy. For instance, the authors try to claim that this “suppression” of IFN responses predisposes people to cancer:
Both IFN-α and IRF9 are also apparently necessary for the cancer-preventative properties of a fully functional BRCA2 gene. In a study presented as an abstract at the First AACR International Conference on Frontiers in Basic Cancer Research, Mittal and Chaudhuri (2009) describe a set of experiments which show for the first time that BRCA2 expression leads to increased IFN-α production and augments the signal transduction pathway resulting in the complexing of IRF9, STAT1 and STAT2 described previously. Two years prior, Buckley et al. (2007) had established that BRCA1 in combination with IFN-γ promotes type I IFNs and subsequent production of IRF7, STAT1, and STAT2. Thus, the exceedingly important cancer regulatory genes BRCA1 and BRCA2 rely on IRF7 and IRF9, respectively, to carry out their protective effects. Rasmussen et al. (2021) reviewed compelling evidence that deficiencies of either IRF7 or IRF9 lead to significantly greater risk of severe COVID-19 illness. Importantly, they also note that evidence suggests type I IFNs play a singularly important role in protective immunity against COVID-19 illness, a role that is shared by multiple cytokines in most other viral illnesses including influenza.
Being a breast cancer surgeon, I know a fair amount about BRCA2 and BRCA1, as well as their functions preventing cancer. Also note how Seneff et al. cite a 13-year-old abstract about BRCA2 and IFN-α production. If I were reviewing the paper, I would have asked: Where’s the published paper? I would have noted that, given that this is a 13-year-old finding, it should have found its way into the scientific literature by now. A quick search of PubMed for anything published together by the two authors who published the abstract about BRCA2 showed me that apparently these results never made it into a full paper. Even if they had, the abstract itself simply showed that the BRCA2 tumor suppressor was needed for breast cells to make IFN-α. In other words, the finding is basically irrelevant to COVID-19 vaccines or any other vaccines. If the result held up, it would really only show that the need for BRCA2 to produce IFN-α in breast cells might be relevant to the cancer suppressing function of the gene. In fairness, more recent data suggest a link between BRCA2 deficiency and immune signaling, but that leaves the question: Why did Seneff et al. so selectively cite a 13-year-old abstract?
Then there’s this:
A recent early-release study has found that the mRNA in the COVID-19 vaccines is present in germinal centers in secondary lymphoid tissue long after the vaccine is administered, and that it continues to synthesize spike glycoprotein up to at least sixty days post-vaccination (Röltgen et al., 2022). This suggests that immune cells taking up the mRNA in the arm muscle migrate into the lymph system to the lymph nodes, presumably in order to expose B-cells and T-cells to the toxic antigen. The persistence of the mRNA in the lymph nodes and its sustained synthesis of SARS-CoV-2 spike glycoprotein reflect the clever engineering involved in the mRNA technology, as described above.
Imagine that! The antigen sticks around in the lymph nodes to stimulate an immune response! How horrible!
This paper is rife with such odd citations about biological processes, many unrelated to vaccination or infection, all marshaled in the service of trying to convince you that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines cause harm. Indeed, the authors even invoke codon usage, fear mongering about “coinfection” with other viruses, and supposed molecular mimicry (although they don’t use the term) of the spike protein because of its supposed similarity to various important human proteins. There are mentions of microRNAs (something in which I have some expertise as well) and exosomes, as well as metabolism. Rather than go through them all (or even a lot of them), I’m going to quote Prof. Morris:
This very long review article presents many details about various biological pathways, most related to cancer, but their links to mRNA vaccines are almost wholly speculative. In some cases, they link to other vaccines, old mRNA technology, or COVID-19 infection, but are not directly linked to mRNA vaccines.
In fact, so much of their evidence is from papers on severe COVID-19 infections, not vaccination, much of the evidence in this article might be better suited to a paper pointing out potential downstream dangers of severe COVID-19 infections than on trying to raise alarm about mRNA vaccination.
A number of places in the article seem to make stronger statements linking mRNA vaccines to some of these processes, but they self-cite a previous review article by senior author McCullough and do not reference any primary biological research making these connections.
They suggest connections of these mechanisms to various anecdotal case reports for herpes zoster reactivation, liver damage, optic neuropathy, T cell lymphoma progression, Hepatitis C reactivation, events not yet confirmed to be related to mRNA vaccination.
The paper amounts to laying out a series of hypotheses about mechanisms of harm that may come from mRNA vaccines. Hypothesis generation is a valuable exercise, including in this context of understanding downstream biological effects of vaccination that might induce harm.
However, not all hypotheses are equally supported. Some are well-girded in direct evidence from relevant studies, while others are more speculative and extrapolate principles from other settings, e.g. SARS-CoV-2 infections or other injected vaccines, as done here.
Again, Prof. Morris is entirely too kind. I would put it a different way. This “review” is the scientific equivalent of a form of what the kids like to call shitposting – a bunch of low-quality provocative assertions on social media designed to provoke a visceral reaction. In this case, the visceral reaction intended is disgust and fear of mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines. Prof. Morris is, of course, quite correct when he identifies the purpose of this torrent of speculation as shifting the burden of proof, with the authors claiming that their wild speculation must be taken seriously by scientists and their proposed harms be investigated right now, rather than presenting anything resembling actual compelling evidence why their ill-formed hypotheses should be taken seriously in the context of what is already well-established about human biology and immunology:
Challenging public health institutions to disprove the assertions made by this article, rather than taking responsibility to validate them or urge other scientists to do so, is a bold move. This type of statement in which one makes a claim and presumes it should assumed true unless other scientists can disprove it, is the classic “shifting the burden of truth” trick. A scientist proposing a hypothesis has the burden of validating it; it is not the responsibility of the scientific community to disprove it, and the hypothesized claim certainly does not have the benefit of presumption of truth unless disproven. This is a common tactic used by many during the pandemic.
In addition, this whole “review” article is one big Gish gallop, in which a torrent of questionable claims is made in an attempt to overwhelm the reader with the quantity of claims, with no regard for their quality. I’ve been told that it’s impossible to Gish gallop in a paper, because one has the time to read and address every claim, but one could easily spend 20,000 words or more to address each and every claim in this “review”. That’s the point. That’s why I’m trying to point out how this review is similar previous efforts and to put it into context with disinformation in general
The purpose of a paper like this is to put a seemingly scientific gloss on speculative scientific bafflegab in which the various concepts are at least “six degrees of separation” away from any biological “framework” having anything to do with vaccines. Scientists with the requisite expertise recognize this handwaving as the crap that it is, but those without the requisite expertise don’t. Even some doctors and scientist without the proper specialized expertise won’t recognize it for what it is, disinformation.
After all the scientific shitposting (if you’ll excuse the term), Seneff et al. then try to make all their speculation and JAQing off sound plausible by appealing to—you guessed it!—VAERS.
Into the VAERS dumpster!
Let’s take a look at the VAERS reports examined by Seneff et al. The easiest thing for me to do is to quote the Tweets. For example, here’s Table I, which Seneff attribute to inflammation:
One nerve inflammation symptom is anosmia. They claim this “clearly demonstrates” the spike injected into arm reached the olfactory nerve, ignoring that anosmia is common with COVID-19 but not linked to vaccine, and could be caused by previous COVID-19 infection, not vaccine. pic.twitter.com/M7WBiENxI3
— Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334) April 21, 2022
Indeed. There is no known mechanism by which the tiny amounts of spike protein that make it into the bloodstream after vaccination could injure the olfactory bulb and cause anosmia (loss of the sense of smell), which also happens to be a well-known symptom of COVID-19 infection itself. There’s also quite a bit of evidence that it is direct infection of the cells in the olfactory bulb with SARS-CoV-2 that is responsible for anosmia. If there’s a symptom of the virus that we’d expect the vaccine not to cause, it would be anosmia.
Let’s just say that this passage from the review should tell you all you want to know about it. I laughed out loud when I read it:
There were nearly 100,000 cases of nausea or vomiting, which are common symptoms of vagus nerve stimulation or damage (Babic and Browning, 2014). 14,701 cases of syncope linked to COVID-19 vaccines represented 96.3% of all cases of syncope, a well-established feature of vagus nerve dysfunction (Fenton et al., 2000).
People passed out after vaccination, and that must mean the vaccine was somehow hurting the vagus nerve? Seriously, I can only laugh. Lots of people faint after blood draws or shots; it’s a common reaction, particularly in certain populations. It’s the same sort of claim that, you might remember, antivaxxers made about the HPV vaccine because so many teenage girls faint after receiving it, except that they at least had a more plausible mechanism than that the vaccine somehow messed up the vagus nerve. Don’t get me wrong. Stimulation of the vagus nerve can cause fainting. That’s why they call it a “vasovagal” reaction. However, in general it’s pain or fear that results in that stimulation.
Since I’m a cancer doctor, I’ll mention this one too:
The authors even admit:
Cancer is a disease generally understood to take months or, more commonly, years to progress from an initial malignant transformation in a cell to development of a clinically recognized condition. Since VAERS reports of adverse events are happening primarily within the first month or even the first few days after vaccination (Rose, 2021), it seems likely that the acceleration of cancer progression following vaccines would be a difficult signal to recognize. Furthermore, most people do not expect cancer to be an adverse event that could be caused by a vaccine, and hence they fail to enter a report when cancer develops shortly after vaccination.
They should have stopped right there, but they couldn’t resist continuing:
However, as we have outlined in our paper, if the mRNA vaccinations are leading to widespread dysregulation of oncogene controls, cell cycle regulation, and apoptosis, then VAERS reports should reflect an increase in reports of cancer, relative to the other vaccines, even if the numbers are small. The experiment demonstrating impairment of DNA repair mechanisms by SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in an in vitro study provides compelling evidence that the vaccines could accelerate the rate of DNA mutations, increasing cancer risk (Jiang and Mei, 2021).
Again, Seneff et al. were right at first before they went wrong. Cancer is the culmination of a process that, in general, takes years, from the initial insult that resulted in cellular transformation to the development of a cancerous tumor detectable by symptoms, physical exam, or screening tests. As I discussed before when antivaxxers did a similar thing with another database to try to blame cancer on COVID-19 vaccines, even after radiation exposure from an atomic bomb, the increased risk of cancer from such a carcinogenic exposure is too long for this to make sense. For leukemias, it’s about two years before the earliest signals can be seen. (The vaccines have only been widely available for less than a year and a half). For solid cancers, the lag time is about 10 years. The increased risks from radiation from the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, especially those for solid cancers, were most easily detected after 30 years and remain over a person’s lifetime. Basically, the authors concede (sort of) that it’s too early to detect an increased risk of cancer from COVID-19 vaccines but then pivot to a hand wave that says, “But look at our mechanisms!” Never mind that the mechanisms were highly speculative to begin with and unproven.
I could go on about the VAERS section, but Prof. Morris did a fine job with it already, and I only wanted to harp on the cancer part because I’m a cancer surgeon and biologist myself. Remember, VAERS is a database to which anyone can contribute anything as a report of an “adverse event” after vaccination, and antivaxxers have been gaming VAERS since the 1990s. It’s a problem that has only gotten so much worse since the pandemic hit. VAERS is useful as an early warning system, but only if you know how to use it, a skill that involves knowing the base rate of the adverse events reported in the population.
Disinformation now and disinformation then
I started this post by pointing out how bogus scientific “review” articles are a long-time favorite technique of spreading antivaccine misinformation. In fact, they are a favorite tool of spreading science denial of all kinds, particularly of evolution and climate science, but I know antivaccine science denial better than I know those other forms, which is why I’ll stick to a couple of examples from the past. One dates back to 2011, when a Helen Ratajczak published an article in the Journal of Immunotoxicology titled “Theoretical aspects of autism: Causes–A review“. This review article was picked up by Sharyl Attkisson, an antivax reporter who has now become an all-around conspiracy theorist and COVID-19 denialist, to promote the claim that vaccines cause autism. As an aside, Attkisson’s report produced the still hilarious misspelling that those of us who have been following the antivaccine movement a long time still bring up to this day, “homologous recombinaltion tiniker.” She meant to write homologous recombination, the process by which DNA with a highly homologous (similar) sequence to a sequence in the genome can integrate itself in that spot, but the misspelling lives on.
Basically, Ratajczak’s claim was that DNA from the “fetal cells” used to manufacture some vaccines could get into the brain, undergo homologous recombination with the DNA of neurons, and produce “foreign” proteins (fusions of “self” proteins plus the fetal protein) that would result in autoimmunity and cause autism. That’s it. That’s the idea, which is incredibly implausible. To do what Dr. Ratajczak claims, the minute amount of human fetal DNA in a vaccine would have to:
    • Find its way to the brain in significant quantities.
    • Make it into the neurons in the brain in significant quantities.
    • Make it into the nucleus of the neurons in significant quantities.
    • Undergo homologous recombination at a detectable level, resulting in either the alteration of a cell surface protein or the expression of a foreign cell surface protein that the immune system can recognize.
    • Undergo homologous recombination in many neurons in such a way that results in the neurons having cell surface protein(s) altered sufficiently to be recognized as foreign.
That’s leaving aside the issue of whether autoimmunity in the brain or chronic brain inflammation is even a cause of autism, which is by no means settled by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, quite the opposite. It’s not at all clear whether the markers of inflammation sometimes reported in the brains of autistic children are a cause, a consequence, or merely an epiphenomenon of autism. In other words, Dr. Ratajczak’s hypothesis is incredibly implausible on the basis of what we know about molecular biology and human biology. It’s not quite homeopathy-level implausible, but nonetheless quite implausible.
Her review was useful in that it also listed another favorite “hypothesis” of antivaxxers from a decade ago, namely deficiencies in metal metabolism that predisposed children to autism when they were exposed to mercury (from vaccines, of course):
Defective metallothionein might be responsible for the greater amount of blood mercury found in autistic children compared to neurotypical controls (Desoto and Hitlan, 2007; Geier et al., 2010). Metallothionein plays an important role in the development and continued function of the immune response, in neuronal development, and in the detoxification of heavy metals. Many classic symptoms of autism may be explained by a metallothionein defect, including gastrointestinal (GI) tract problems, heightened sensitivity to toxic metals, and abnormal behaviors. Porphyrinuria in children with autism is considered a marker of heavy metal toxicity (Geier and Geier, 2006a; Nataf et al., 2006, 2008; Rossignal, 2007; Geier et al., 2009). Individuals with severe autism had increased mercury-intoxication-associated urinary porphyrins (Geier et al., 2009).
Again, there was (and still is) no good scientific evidence to support the plausibility of these hypotheses. I could list a whole slew of papers trying to link various metabolic processes to autism via vaccine “injury” but will spare you. I’ll also note that the Hannah Poling case was a huge driver of papers claiming to link mitochondrial disorders to autism via vaccine injury. The idea was that mitochondrial disorders make a child susceptible to neurologic damage due to fevers due to vaccines. But you know what causes fevers more effectively? Actual infections! That’s why it is highly recommended that children with mitochondrial diseases receive the full slate of childhood vaccines. And don’t even get me started on another highly speculative “mechanism” how vaccines could supposedly cause autism known as “microcompetition“.
One thing that distinguishes Ratajczak’s review from that of Seneff et al. is that Ratajczak discussed a number of non-crank hypotheses with actual science behind them (e.g., the association of certain gene mutations, increased paternal age, and more) along with her vaccine-autism causation pseudoscience, the better to disguise the antivaccine pseudoscience. Seneff et al. could have learned from that, but apparently they didn’t. The idea was the same, though, to get a “review article” into the scientific literature to provide scientific-sounding highly speculative talking points that antivaxxers could use to blame autism on vaccines, exactly the same thing that Seneff et al. accomplished.
Finally, Seneff et al. was published in Food and Chemical Toxicology, a journal by a large scientific publishing house, Elsevier. I note that it’s the same journal that published Gilles-Eric Séralini’s awful GMO study that was ultimately retracted. More importantly, it is a journal that had no business publishing a review article like this, given that it’s not a journal dedicated to vaccines, infectious disease, epidemiology, or other relevant specialties. It is a toxicology journal, but it’s a stretch for it to cover alleged adverse reactions from COVID-19 vaccines and a whole lot of Gish galloping about potential biological mechanisms for those complications. One has to wonder why Jose Luis Domingo, who is listed as the editor who handled this review, let it pass and why the peer reviewers didn’t reject it.
I think I know why. The most charitable explanation is likely twofold. First, COVID-19 articles, particularly ones claiming adverse reactions from vaccines, bring clicks, and editors want to publish them. More importantly, though, an explanation that doesn’t require any sort of conflict of interest or nefarious motivation on the part of the journal editor is that neither journal editors nor peer reviewers recognize misinformation and disinformation. They therefore reviewed Seneff et al. as though it were a serious attempt at a scientific review, not recognizing the Gish galloping. Even giving them that benefit of the doubt, though, I have a hard time not faulting them for failing to recognize the highly speculative nature of the claims, the obvious misuse of VAERS, and the even more highly selective citation (and self-citation) of papers that don’t really support the hypotheses proposed, at least not without a lot of contortions of logic and biology. These were not subtle flaws.
As professions, we scientists and physicians could in the past be blissfully oblivious to misinformation and disinformation. No longer. If we don’t get our acts together to recognize them, the result will be many more “reviews” like this weaponized to attack public health. Actually, it’s already too late, but maybe the deluge can be at least reversed and the cranks forced to publish this nonsense where they used to: In bottom-feeding journals and on their own websites, rather than in Elsevier journals..

Nobel for Medicine Goes To mRNA Vaccine Science
The work of Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman made possible the mRNA vaccines, with implications that go beyond this one application.
Steven Novella on October 4, 2023
Linl

The 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine goes to Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman for their mRNA work which lead to the rapid development of vaccines against the COVID-19 pandemic. There is no mistaking the intent of the Nobel committee in this award to specifically recognize the contribution of mRNA vaccines. They open their press release with a discussion of vaccines and the pandemic.
The Science
Messenger RNA (mRNA) was discovered in 1961 at the Institut Pasteur in Paris. It was known that DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) contains the genetic information of inheritance, which consists of genes that code for specific proteins. The DNA resides inside the nucleus of each cell, and yet protein is manufactured outside the nucleus. mRNA was discovered as the messenger – an mRNA molecule is made as a copy of a DNA gene (transcription), travels to outside the nucleus and then directs the assembly of a specific sequence of amino acids into a protein (translation). This process is known as the central dogma of molecular biology.
In the 1980s it was discovered how to manufacture mRNA outside of living cells – in vitro. This created the potential for using mRNA as a therapeutic tool. However, in vitro mRNA was not very stable and caused inflammatory reactions when injected into mammals. For this reason many researchers thought its therapeutic potential would be limited, even a dead end.
This is where Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman come in. They began a collaboration into figuring out what was different between natural (in vivo) mRNA and in vitro mRNA. They discovered that in vivo mRNA has chemically modified bases compared to the in vitro version. Apparently a step was missing in the creation of in vitro mRNA.
RNA has four bases like DNA, but slightly different. DNA has the famous ATGC bases – adenine, thymine, guanine, and cytosine. They form the four-letter genetic code of DNA. RNA, rather has an AUGC code – with uracil replacing thymine. These bases are molecules that can be chemically modified.
The breakthrough for Karikó and Weissman came from research they did with various modifications of the RNA bases. They focused on the inflammatory reaction that in vitro RNA was provoking, which seemed to occur through stimulation of dendritic cells in the immune system. They found that a particular modification of the mRNA bases essentially shut down the inflammatory response of the dendritic cells. Their results were published in 2005.
They further found that the modified mRNA was more stable and significantly increased the translation into proteins. The modified bases, they found, also shut down a regulatory enzyme that decreased protein translation. These later findings were published in 2008 and 2010.
Their work revived interest in mRNA as a potential therapeutic tool. Moderna, one of the companies who eventually manufactured an mRNA vaccine, was founded in 2010, to capitalize on the work of Karikó and Weissman.
mRNA Vaccines
The science of in vitro mRNA is certainly important and impactful work, opening up a powerful new therapeutic tool for modern medicine. But it seems clear that Karikó and Weissman also partly owe their Nobels to the fact that the technology their research created met the moment with the COVID-19 pandemic.
The timing was perfect. Their research lead to the development of mRNA vaccine technology, initially working on Zika and MERS-CoV. But when the pandemic hit, the mRNA vaccine technology was ready, and was able to show its true potential.
mRNA vaccine work by injecting the code for a spike protein from the COVID virus (SARS-CoV-2) into the subject. The mRNA is taken up by the muscle cells where it is translated into the spike protein and released into the blood. This provokes an immune response against the protein, priming the body for later exposure to the full live virus.
One big advantage of this approach is that nothing has to be cultured. Vaccines made from modified or inactivated viruses require culturing of the virus in cells, which is a slow process. Meanwhile, we have the ability to mass produce in vitro mRNA once we know the genetic sequence, which is something we can now also do very quickly.
In vitro mRNA for these reasons is a fantastic vaccine platform. We encountered a novel virus, rapidly sequenced its genetic code, manufactured mRNA for its proteins, which were then modified and packaged in a delivery system. The pandemic hit in early 2020, and by December we had approval for two mRNA-based vaccines, which were rapidly mass-produced and distributed. Vaccines based on other platforms were also developed, but the mRNA vaccines were quicker and appear to be more effective. This is the kind of rapid-response technology we need for future pandemics.
The technology is also not done. Researchers are working on self-replicating mRNA, which I wrote about recently. This allows for the injection of a much smaller amount of mRNA which then replicates itself, providing a longer stimulation of the immune system and potentially greater immunity or reduced need for booster shots. This technology is still in development but showing promise.
There are also potential applications for mRNA technology beyond vaccines including immunotherapies, protein replacement therapies, and genome engineering.
The work of Karikó and Weissman was a critical fulcrum between the development of in vitro mRNA and therapeutic applications.

Methodolatry and COVID
Doctors who call for an RCT for everything generally haven’t run a single RCT on anything. Why is this?
Jonathan Howard on May 12, 2022
Link

An interesting comment
An interesting comment was left in a previous article about a video made by a contrarian doctor. According to reader named Squirrelelite, this doctor,
Mentioned a tweet from Matthew Yglesias suggesting that lots of people would have died if we had waited to do an RCT to approve boosters as Gruber and Krause wanted. He then goes on to claim that 2 or 3 hundred thousand people would have quickly signed up for the trial to get access to a booster shot, ignoring the huge cost and time delay to enroll 5-8 times as many people as were in the original vaccine trials. And he states that it would “only” take 11 months to run that trial. He claims we don’t have effectiveness results on 12-15 year olds without such a trial and also ignores these results from back in February or this result from January… (He) claims Gruber and Krause were “vindicated” but he doesn’t talk about any numbers to support that.
I confess, I lacked the fortitude to watch the video Squirrelelite provided, so I can’t promise they are reporting it fairly. Regardless, it’s certainly true that many doctors have lamented that boosters – and multiple other pandemic interventions – have not been studied in large, randomized controlled trials (RCT). Squirrelelite’s comment referenced Drs. Marion Gruber and Philip Krause, two scientists who resigned from the FDA last summer in protest of the decision to offer a booster to all adults. They felt there was not enough evidence to support this. They shouldn’t be called anti-vaccine for their skepticism of boosters at the time, but they haven’t exactly been vindicated, as I will explain.
Having an idea for an RCT is infinitely easier than actually doing an RCT
I love RCTs. All doctors do. In a fantasy world with unlimited time and money, but without ethics, an RCT would yield the optimal answer for many medical questions. They are the gold-standard for their ability to randomize patients and minimize bias. They are truly a remarkable achievement with a fascinating history. I firmly believe that every intervention that can be studied via an RCT should be.
However, in the real world, significant ethical and practical limitations prevent us from doing this. Having an idea for an RCT is infinitely easier than actually doing an RCT.
    • The safety of the subjects in RCTs is paramount, as it should be, especially given the history of Nazi atrocities and the Tuskegee Study. Basic ethics and Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) strictly limit what can be studied via an RCT. RCTs can only be used to study interventions that have a reasonable chance of benefiting patients or when there is true uncertainty about which treatment is better, which is termed clinical equipoise. There’s never been or will be an RCT showing that smoking harms or that parachutes help. Having said this, there are many fewer “parachutes” in medicine than we often believe. Medicine is full of treatments that everyone “knew” worked, until they were found to be useless in an RCT. To repeat, I firmly believe that every intervention that can be studied via an RCT should be.
    • Only the largest RCTs can reliably detect rare treatment harms or benefits. The rarer the event, the larger a study must be to detect it, something termed a study’s power. Generally, rare events can only be detected once the studied treatment has been given to large numbers of people outside an RCT. Real-world studies have taught us much more about rare vaccine harms and benefits than the RCTs.
    • RCTs are hard to do for rare diseases as it is challenging to enroll enough patients.
    • RCTs are of relatively short duration. Any treatment harm or benefit that occurs many years later is unlikely to be detected via an RCT.
    • RCTs are slow. A doctor who has an idea for an RCT can’t just start one the next day. It takes time to design the trial, to get funding, to have it evaluated and approved by an IRB, to set up the infrastructure, to enroll patients, to run the study, and to synthesize the data. Most RCTs take many years to from the time they are conceived to when the final data changes clinical care, which is obviously problematic in a pandemic that arrived like a tornado. As I will discuss, the COVID vaccine trials had several unique features, including the rapid spread of COVID, that allowed them to proceed faster than most RCTs.
    • RCTs are expensive, and funding can be hard to come by, especially for studies where no one can profit based on the outcome. The COVID vaccine trials were unique in that full funding was immediately available.
    • An RCT can sound perfect right until the moment you actually have to enroll patients into it. Those of us who have done this know that recruitment can be very difficult. Some patients are eager to do so, but many don’t want to be a “guinea pig”. A normally hard process is much harder in a pandemic. One researcher, who has actual experience running an RCT this pandemic, said:
I think of what my clinical research team went through to enroll people in that trial, and I thought my nurses were going to die. One of them got covid and got sick. Imagine trying to do that on a daily basis, multiple patients, some of them facing intubation, none of them have their families
Patients or their families have to be able to give informed consent, which can be impossible for delirious, intubated COVID patients and their distraught families. As another researcher said:
There was one day our system had 84 deaths. And then you’re going to ask me to potentially put them on a placebo? It’s just really heart wrenching, talking with families, if your patients are able to communicate — and you’re dealing with all these deaths.
Given all of this, it’s no surprise that clinical trials can fail to recruit enough patients. A proposed RCT of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin run by the NIH closed after enrolling just 20 patients, or 1% of their goal. I’m sure that study looked great on paper. Graveyards are full of dead RCTs and there’s research into why trials fail. The vaccine trials were unique in that boatloads of volunteers, like me, beat down the door to enter them. I am skeptical that hordes of twice-vaccinated people would be similarly eager to enter into a booster trial. Anyone who acts as if recruiting a large number of subjects into an RCT is a trivial matter while a pandemic rages is either clueless or dishonest.
    • RCTs require an enormous infrastructure and multiple experts with different skills. Pfizer has this. You don’t. Most RCTs occur at multiple locations, and teams have to be in place at every site. One of the mRNA vaccine trials occurred at 152 sites worldwide. The vaccines weren’t just a scientific triumph, the RCTs were also logistical marvel. To get a sense of how complicated RCTs are, one article listed the following costs: regulatory affairs, site identification and selection, site contracting and payments, site initiation and activation, site management, onsite monitoring, drug safety management, drug logistics, biological sample logistics, clinical supplies logistics, medical writing, site close-out, project management, study files/document management, data management, statistics, quality control, communication with central CRO/sponsor, and pass-through costs, which includes, trial insurance policies for each country, shipping: physical files to sites, site contracts, and tumor/blood samples, blood tubes and shipping packages, office supplies: files, paper, and printing, payments to sites per enrolled patient (to cover clinical procedures and laboratory tests), publication fees, ethics committee evaluation fees, site contract fees, regulatory authority evaluation fees, travel costs for selection, initiation, routine monitoring, and close-out visits, central pathology and radiology reviews, translational/biomarker studies, coordinating investigators, drug manufacturing and testing, drug distribution services, EDC license and service fees, web tools (imaging platforms, eTMF), document translations, and data and Safety Monitoring Board (DSMB).
    • Given their complexity, RCTs don’t always smoothly. Serious problems can sometimes arise and small hiccups are more common than not. Vaccine trials in particular have to be close to flawless. Those who enjoy spreading fear about vaccines will magnify the slightest imperfection to cast doubt on the whole project. This happened with the original COVID vaccine RCTs, much to the delight of anti-vaxxers. A rushed or sloppy RCT would do much more harm than good
    • RCTs, including the vaccine RCTs, commonly exclude key segments of the population, such as pregnant women or immunocompromised patients. As such, other study designs are used to evaluate the vaccine in these populations. The exclusion of pregnant women from most RCTs is a source of controversy.
    • RCT participants, who have to be savvy enough to learn about the trial in the first place, may not be representative of the general population. They are generally healthy and motivated enough to travel back and forth to the study site on a regular basis. The most vulnerable people, those who benefit from the booster the most, would likely be underrepresented in an RCT, thus skewing the results. Racial and ethnic minorities have also been underrepresented in clinical trials.
    • An RCT done in one area may not generalize to another. For example, an RCT of masks in Bangladesh relied on “role-modeling by community leaders”. Its results would not be applicable to areas where community leaders oppose masks.
    • Unlike any other condition in medicine, the disease being studied changes rapidly in a pandemic. The vaccine RCTs were done with a variant that is long gone. Does anyone believe these RCTs, where the vaccine was 95% effective at stopping COVID, have any relevance to our individual and policy choices today? Of course not. These RCTs rapidly became historical relics, and we’ve learned much more about the vaccines through real-world studies. An RCT of other interventions that was initiated at the pandemic’s onset, would likely be obsolete due to the more contagious variants that are circulating today.
Given this, researchers use different types of observational studies to investigate topics that are difficult or impossible to study via an RCT. Though they aren’t as rigorous as RCTs, they can provide invaluable information about vaccines/medicines once they’ve been released in the real-world.
Because they don’t select patients randomly, however, they have a greater potential for spurious associations due to random chance and confounding variables. For example, it’s possible that sicker people were more likely to get vaccinated than healthy people, who were misled into believing they had zero risk from the virus. Without controlling for this discrepancy, simply evaluating outcomes in vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals would make the make vaccine appear less effective than it actually is.
Researchers try to control for bias and most acknowledge their limitations in their papers. While these limitations can be magnified out of proportion by those who wish to cast doubt on the validity of studies whose outcomes they don’t like, there are a lot of really bad observational studies out there, and discussing their flaws is a major topic here at Science Based Medicine.
Methodolatry: RCT worship
Those who claim RCTs and only RCTs can provide reliable information are guilty of methodolatry, a favorite technique of anti-vaxxers. Disingenuous anti-vaxxers may pretend they would embrace vaccines if only there were an RCT showing (fill in the blank.) However, they reject the validity of existing RCTs, and it’s clear that if their proposed RCT were done, they would seamlessly shift to demand yet another.
For example, anti-vaxxers may point out there is no RCT showing that the HPV vaccine prevents cancer. This is true. The RCTs of the HPV vaccine used a surrogate endpoint, cervical intraepithelial neoplasia, which can be a cancer precursor. As HPV-related cancers take many years to develop, this outcome would not be possible to study in the time-frame of an RCT, nor would it be ethical to let people remain in the placebo group once evidence emerged of the vaccine’s safety and efficacy.
Unfortunately, methodolatry isn’t just a problem for anti-vaxxers. Just two short years ago, serious people wrote an article titled “Will HPV Vaccination Prevent Cervical Cancer?” which reviewed the RCTs of the HPV vaccine. They said that “None of the trials were designed to determine efficacy or effectiveness against cervical cancer. There were no reported cases of cervical cancer in any trials”. As such, they authors felt that,
It is still uncertain whether HPV vaccination prevents cervical cancer as trials were not designed to detect this outcome, which takes decades to develop… There are too few data to clearly conclude that HPV vaccine prevents cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 3.
The rebuttal to this piece was titled “Evidence of HPV Vaccination Efficacy Comes From More Than Clinical Trials”. It discussed “the huge amount of non-trial research evidence that enables most scientists to conclude that HPV vaccination will prevent most cervical cancers”. These scientists were right.
Of course, it wasn’t a great leap to surmise that if a vaccine that prevented a cancer precursor, it would also eventually prevent cancer. Indeed, there is now clear evidence from massive observational studies showing the HPV vaccine is very effective at preventing cervical cancer. Those who reject this evidence because it was not obtained from an RCT are guilty of methodolatry.
I am wary of the phrase, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Too often it is invoked by quacks when asked to provide evidence for their latest miracle cure. There argument boils down to, “There may be no evidence that magic beans cure cancer, but there’s also no evidence that magic beans don’t cure cancer. Therefore, I am right to sell magic beans to cancer patients.” They are fond of pretending that at some point in the future, science will properly study magic beans and their cancer-healing properties will be revealed.
Nevertheless, it is of course true that the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. If aliens destroyed all guns and someone said one minute later “There’s no data that gun violence had decreased”, that person wouldn’t be wrong, but they’d be thinking like an anti-vaxxer and there’s nothing wise or useful about their comment. Massive RCTs are the best, but we are allowed to believe reasonable things with lesser evidence.
I’m confident a large RCT lasting 20 years could have shown the HPV vaccine prevents cancer, but there would have been a real cost of waiting. Countless millions of people are protected against HPV-related cancers because doctors used the vaccine based on very solid, but less-than-perfect data.
None of this was controversial amongst doctors previously. Only cranks, who wrote articles like “The Truth is Out: Gardasil Vaccine Coverup Exposed” and “Can Pharma Improve on Nature? HPV Vaccine vs Natural Infection“, opposed the HPV vaccine. And any doctor who said we should not use the HPV vaccine until there was an RCT showing it reduced all-cause mortality would be immediately recognized as a crank.
Things are very different with COVID.
Methodolatry: Impossible studies
Most often, anti-vaxxers protest there has never been an RCT of the entire vaccine schedule, and therefore studies showing the safety of individual vaccines are useless. “We both agree that RCTs are the gold-standard in medicine. How could anyone be against an RCT of the full vaccine schedule to settle this once and for all?”, they ask.
They’re fully aware that no parent would sign their infant up for such an RCT, nor would it be approved by an IRB. Even absent these obstacles, such a study would take decades and would be impossible to actually carry out. That’s the point.
Anti-vaxxers don’t like that studies overwhelmingly show that vaccines benefit children. So they purposefully call for impossible studies to diminish the credibility of these studies. Predictably, anti-vaxxers disparage parents who volunteer their children for RCTs of vaccines. That’s how ridiculous they are.
Anti-vaxxers are always able to move the goalposts, identifying gaps that they feel only an enormous RCT could fill. The RCTs that have been done are deemed fatally flawed. Frequently, they are felt to be too small in size or too short in duration. Though there are many studies showing vaccines are safe and effective, the only study that matters to anti-vaxxers is just one more, forever undone RCT.
However, demanding impossible RCTs while rejecting the perfectly good studies that have already been done is the entire point for those who wish to spread fear about vaccines and fetishize “natural” immunity. In contrast, when an observational study claims to reveal vaccine imperfections, anti-vaxxers suddenly have no issue with non-RCTs, even when the methods are extremely dubious. In fact, these studies are lauded as bombshells.
Image source: https://virologydownunder.com/
RCTs in a pandemic
Fortunately, there were multiple well-done RCTs this pandemic, not all of them run by pharmaceutical companies. The RECOVERY trial showed a dirt-cheap steroid saved lives in severely ill patients. They also evaluated 9 other treatments via RCTs. The researchers who demonstrated that surgical masks slowed COVID also proved that it’s possible to investigate these sort of interventions via an RCT, at least in Bangladesh where the were able to use a “grassroots network of volunteers” to gather data.
These RCTs were medical science at its best, and there absolutely should have been more of them. Hopefully before the next pandemic, the CDC will have established an “RCT Strike Force” that is capable of rapidly testing interventions. Citizens also need to know that signing up for RCTs is a heroic and vital effort where their safety is a priority. Without these brave volunteers, medical progress would stop.
Everyone who worked on or volunteered for an RCT this pandemic deserves our gratitude. It was really hard work.
Though I wish more interventions had been studied via enormous RCTs, I recognize that we can’t study every intervention this way. Sadly, we don’t have an RCT Strike Force today, so our public health leaders had to make choices. You may disagree with their choices, but they couldn’t have studied everything via an RCT despite what some contrarian doctors claim. Moreover, there is an opportunity cost. Every dollar and hour spent running an RCT for boosters would be a money and time not spent convincing people to get the first two doses.
It’s not easy to say exactly which interventions can and should be studied via an RCT in a raging pandemic. They are necessary to properly evaluate new vaccines. I’m glad that this was our top priority. They are necessary to properly evaluate medications. I didn’t give my COVID patients hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin based on a few lousy, even fraudulent, observational studies. Without a well-done RCT showing otherwise, except for patients facing certain death, I assumed these drugs would result in more harm than benefit.
But other interventions have an entirely different risk/benefit profile and favor their use even absent large RCTs. We often have to do our best with solid but imperfect data obtained via observational studies or small RCTs. Early in the pandemic, decisions had to be made with no data at all. Such is life. Time is not an unlimited luxury in a pandemic and we can’t let perfect be the enemy of good when forklifts are needed to move dead bodies to overflowing morgues. As Dr. Trisha Greenhalgh wisely wrote:
Regulators were right to have suggested a booster without the benefit of an RCT
Circling back to boosters, the evidence we have about their value isn’t perfect, but it’s very good. An RCT of 10,000 people showed that a booster was safe and 95% effective at stopping COVID. Predictably contrarian doctors minimized this trial saying there was “no data” the vaccine prevented hospitalizations and deaths. This is true, but like those who claim there’s no evidence that the HPV vaccine stops cancer, it’s not wise or helpful. In fact, it’s potentially dangerous. There are a lot of people who don’t know how much the third shot could help them.
Of course, it wasn’t a great leap to surmise that if vaccine stopped COVID infections, it would also lower COVID hospitalizations and deaths. Indeed, there is now clear evidence from large observational studies in different countries showing that boosters are effective at limiting severe disease. Additionally, vaccines still help stop the spread of the virus. Again, we are allowed to believe reasonable things.
Furthermore, the risks were not that high. Had boosters been of no benefit, the worst case scenario would have been an unnecessary vaccine dose for millions of people. This is problematic given the serious issue of vaccine inequity, but hardly a tragedy for those who received the vaccine. Fortunately, the vaccine-myocarditis rate is much lower with the booster and patients almost always do well in a short time.
I’m sure that if regulators could have snapped their fingers and willed a massive booster RCT into existence, they would have. Since they don’t operate in Fantasyland, they had to make a decision based on the best evidence they had at the time.
Had they demanded an RCT large enough to show the booster prevented hospitalizations and deaths, we might just now be getting the results, assuming enough people volunteered to let it be run at all. Remember, an NIH trial at the start of the pandemic closed after enrolling just 20 people, though it “planned to rapidly enroll approximately 2,000 adults”.
Moreover, a booster RCT that started last summer, would have begun before the arrival of variants that are more contagious and seem better at evading the immune system. It’s not clear that its results would any more relevant today that the RCTs of the first two doses.
Regulators were clearly right to have suggested boosters without the benefit a massive RCT. Many millions of people would have been left vulnerable while a booster RCT was run. Doctors who actually treat COVID patients know that this delay would have been very costly and the information gained would have been barely of use.
Currently, the main issue with boosters is that most people are convinced they don’t need one. This is not a surprise. Even after an RCT showed the booster was extremely effective in preventing COVID, contrarian doctors thought it was really funny to sit together in a podcast studio and proudly declare they were “unmasked, unboosted, and unrepentant”. One joked that being an “unboosted male” was his preferred pronoun. They were not discussing the results of a massive RCT showing the booster failed, of course. They require massive RCTs to advocate for vaccines, but they don’t require any evidence at all to trash them. They presumed that because there wasn’t a massive RCT showing the booster prevented severe COVID, that meant the booster didn’t prevent severe COVID. For these doctors, absence of evidence is evidence of absence.
Doctors unconcerned with pandering to their podcast audience – those who actually treat COVID patients – know the best way to save lives and prevent suffering is to encourage every eligible person to get a booster, not to spread unwarranted doubt about the solid evidence we have that they are beneficial. While some contrarian doctors have belatedly done this for the most vulnerable adults, boosters have been shown to be of benefit for every age group studied thus far, even teens.
Perhaps more people would have taken this crucial dose if influential doctors hadn’t made a public mockery of it all, punching down at vulnerable people for giggles.
A blatant double standard
Contrarian doctors are very familiar with the strengths and weaknesses of various study designs, and they could have used their large platforms to educate the public on this topic. They could have informed people that while all doctors agree RCTs are the gold-standard, having an idea for an RCT is infinitely easier than actually doing an RCT.
Instead, they’ve mislead their audience into believing that only enormous RCTs can determine the value of pandemic interventions, that enormous RCTs are trivial endeavors, and that more enormous RCTs weren’t done because the folks in charge were stupid and apathetic. In so doing, they successfully undermined confidence in all measures (vaccines, masks, testing, lockdowns) to control the virus and public health in general.
One doctor even proposed that no public health restriction last longer than three months unless it can be proven beneficial in an RCT. I guess restaurants will have to get rid of their bathroom signs saying Employees must wash their hands before returning to work, unless an RCT can prove this is beneficial by August. The guy making your pizza can determine his “own personal risk level” the next time he uses the bathroom at work. After all, there’s “no data” he’s doing anything wrong, is there?
The gimmick becomes entirely clear when one realizes the blatant double standard they have for when data is deemed reliable. Those doctors who call for an RCT for every proposed measure to limit the virus are perfectly content to use weak observational data, or no data at all, when it bolsters their argument that children should be left vulnerable to the virus. Though information on vaccine side-effects comes mainly from observational studies, contrarian doctors discuss this topic all the time. They’ve not questioned the validity of this data because it did not arise from RCTs. It’s only with purported vaccine benefits that the rigor of an RCT is demanded.
As with the booster trial, even then RCTs are often deemed insufficient. The pediatric RCTs (here and here) showed the vaccine was extremely effective in preventing COVID. However, in their missives opposing pediatric vaccination, contrarian doctors either pretended these studies didn’t exist or they blatantly misrepresented them, falsely claiming they didn’t measure “clinical outcomes”. They disparaged their usefulness, saying they were too small to “inform the safety of a vaccine that will be given to many millions”. Another doctor said, “There are no RCTs that show the vaccine prevents deaths or provides any other tangible benefit to children, while there could be harms”. For doctors sheltered from the consequences of their words, positive facts about the vaccine, even when from an RCT, are unmentionable facts.
Of course, it wasn’t a great leap to surmise that if a vaccine stopped COVID infections, it would also lower COVID hospitalizations and deaths. Indeed, there is now clear evidence from many observational studies showing that the vaccine is very effective in preventing these rare but devastating outcomes in children. But because these weren’t RCTs and they show the vaccine is beneficial, contrarian doctors do their best to pretend they don’t even exist. They actively resist believing reasonable things.
An impossible study
Despite the copious evidence, from both RCTs and real-world studies, that the vaccine benefits children, predictably, contrarian doctors feel yet another RCT is needed. Just last week, a contrarian doctor said,
If Pfizer and Moderna want these vaccines to be given to children, they should first conduct a randomized controlled trial that shows that they reduce hospitalization and all-cause mortality. They failed to do so for adults. They should not get away with that for our children.
I am going to do something that will likely come as a huge surprise to this doctor. I am going to pretend he was serious. I encourage you to do the same the next time a doctor suggests an RCT. Consider whether the proposed study would really change anything and whether or not that study could really be done. At first glance, his demand seems reasonable. It would be nice to have an RCT showing that the vaccine saves children’s lives.
So, would it actually be possible to run this RCT?
Fortunately, children rarely die from COVID or anything else. A child dying in a vaccine RCT would be an exceedingly rare event. As such, it would take one of the largest and longest RCTs in the history of medicine to evaluate the vaccine’s effect on all-cause mortality. As such, this trial requires an immense number unvaccinated children whose parents would be willing to enter them into an RCT with a 50% chance they would get vaccinated.
LOL, as they say.
There are many more obstacles. Would an IRB approve a study where children are purposefully left unvaccinated? Of course not. Would ethical doctors work for this study or enroll their patients in it? Of course not. Would anyone fund it? Of course not. Even if these obstacles didn’t exist, would the results be available in a useful timeframe? Of course not.
As with anti-vaxxers calling for an RCT of the entire vaccine schedule, there’s no way this study could actually be run. It’s just another impossible study. Again, that’s the point. Calling for a bevy of RCTs, with no regard as to whether they could actually be done, is what contrarian doctors do when they don’t like the results of the many studies showing the vaccine is beneficial for children.
This willful blindness makes some sense when one realizes the individual demanding this impossible RCT was one of several influential doctors who wanted unvaccinated children to contract COVID. His efforts were very successful. He should take a public victory lap.
Instead, after 1,500 dead children died and tens of thousands more hospitalized, he’s beclowning himself to avoid acknowledging the overwhelming evidence the vaccine can lessen these severe outcomes. He can’t point to any actual evidence the vaccine is riskier that the virus. All he can do is wish away unwanted studies, demand an absurd RCT, and loudly proclaim that until this undoable study is done, there’s literally no evidence in the world that could convince him children should be protected from a potentially deadly virus. All he’s got is methodolatry, and he’s happy to leave children vulnerable to COVID rather than say “I was wrong”.
Though this impossible RCT is an unserious demand from an unserious person, it has a very serious effect – it fools parents into believing the pediatric vaccine hasn’t really been tested, when nothing could be further from the truth. Thanks in part to this and many other falsehoods spread by contrarian doctors, pediatric vaccine rates are abysmally low.
It’s not just Pfizer and Moderna who want these vaccines to be given to children, as this doctor suggested. Essentially all doctors who actually care for sick children want them vaccinated too. They have to deal with the real-world consequences of myths spread by contrarian doctors. The pandemic has been about much more than making YouTube videos on their laptop for many pediatricians.
Doctors who call for an RCT for everything, generally haven’t run a single RCT on anything
And suddenly I have déjà vu. This sort of sophistry is very familiar to those of us who thought it was worthwhile to think about these issues prior to the pandemic. It’s all just pathetic variations of “Will HPV Vaccination Prevent Cervical Cancer?” blended with a dose of “Can Pharma Improve on Nature? HPV Vaccine vs Natural Infection”.
Contrarian doctors are always able to move the goalposts, identifying gaps that they feel only an enormous RCT could fill. The RCTs that have been done are deemed fatally flawed. Frequently, they are felt to be too small in size or too short in duration. Though there are many studies showing vaccines are safe and effective, the only study that matters to contrarian doctors is just one more, forever undone RCT.
However, demanding impossible RCTs while rejecting the perfectly good studies that have already been done is the entire point for those who spread fear about vaccines and fetishize “natural” immunity. In contrast, when an observational study claims to reveal vaccine imperfections, contrarian doctors suddenly have no issue with non-RCTs, even when the methods are extremely dubious. In fact, these studies are lauded as bombshells.
When pandemic interventions aren’t studied via an RCT, it’s not because doctors are ignorant and lazy, it’s because these studies are expensive, slow, and really hard. It’s no surprise that contrarian doctors always call for someone else to do an RCT rather than doing these studies themselves. It’s extremely easy to point a camera at yourself and bemoan that other doctors failed to run dozens of RCTs. It’s extremely difficult to actually run an RCT.
That’s why doctors who call for an RCT for everything generally haven’t run a single RCT on anything.

Take a Pledge to Enroll in a Randomized-Controlled Trial
As COVID cases and hospitalizations increase yet again, I’d like my contribution to medical research to be more than convincing people to skip vaccine doses. So should you.
Jonathan Howard on September 8, 2023
Link

Not long ago, a contrarian doctor sought to induce conformity and groupthink in his readers by asking them to take a public, written pledge to refuse further COVID vaccines unless they demonstrated benefit via a randomized-controlled trial (RCT). While I agree that RCTs are the gold-standard for evidence, they are not the only study design by which we can learn about the world, especially during a rapidly advancing and changing pandemic. There have been no RCTs of SARS‑CoV‑2, after all, and encouraging people to contract it repeatedly it is a choice made without evidence of safety.
However, this doctor’s pledge was not meant to advance research. Rather, endless calls for other doctors to do RCTs are made to create fear, uncertainly, and doubt about medical knowledge. I am confident that such mistrust will make people less willing to enroll in actual RCTs.
My recognition that not everything can be studied via a pristine RCT does not mean that I am against RCTs in principle, of course. If I could snap my fingers and will RCTs into existence, I certainly would. In fact, I am such a strong believer in RCTs that I volunteered to be in a COVID-vaccine RCT myself, and I’ve tried to recruit patients into RCTs as well. It’s depressing that many of them close prematurely because they are unable to enroll enough subjects. According to one article titled “Uninformative Research” is the Global Health Crisis You’ve Never Heard Of:
A 2021 study of thousands of COVID-19 drug trials, only 5% of the “study arms” included enough people to generate a statistically valid result.
Any doctor who actually cares about RCTs should find this very disturbing.
I don’t know if I have any sway over my readers. However, to the extent that I can motivate you, I would ask you to take one of these two pledges.
For Medical Professionals
Actually doing an RCT is infinitely more meaningful than merely writing “do an RCT.” As such, I pledge not to sit on the sidelines, only dreaming of RCTs for others to do. Instead, I pledge to work on RCTs and to encourage my patients to enroll in them.
For The General Public
Medical research requires willing volunteers, without whom medicine would never advance. If the opportunity arises, I pledge to volunteer to be in an RCT to further medical knowledge and benefit others.
As COVID cases and hospitalizations increase yet again, I’d like my contribution to medical research to be more than convincing people to skip vaccine doses. So should you.

The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 1/10)
This book — written by “Anonymous”, edited by Children’s Health Defense lawyer Mary Holland and Children’s Health Defense Publisher Liaison and Thinking Moms’ Revolution co-founder Zoey O’Toole, and published by “The Turtles Team” — purports to use only mainstream references to prove its points. But the book employs all the standard tropes in a master class of science denial and antivax tactics and techniques.
Frank Han on July 13, 2023
Link

If you haven’t heard about this book yet, it’s written by “Anonymous”, edited by Children’s Health Defense lawyer Mary Holland, Children’s Health Defense Publisher Liaison and Thinking Moms’ Revolution co-founder Zoey O’Toole, and published by “The Turtles Team”. It purports to use only mainstream references to prove its points, but the gist of the book is that they are hostile to all vaccines and will not stop until nobody gets vaccines anymore and all the mandates are removed.
Because this is a fairly long book that employs all of the antivaxxer tactics, I will spread my posts out into 10 more reasonably digestible pieces to show you how, as with all antivaxxer speeches, it is a paper tiger. This book has big promises but, to someone who actually knows the vaccine science, the book doesn’t really deliver much beyond money in the “Anonymous” author’s bank account. A more charitable interpretation of this book is a live masterclass of science denial/antivax techniques as explained here along with this illustration of the major tactics:
The general way these articles will be constructed is quotes with their associated debunks, and answers to the questions at the end of each chapter, that on first glance, appear to be gotcha questions, but actually are easy to answer with just a little extra medical knowledge. Statements that are repetitive will be addressed only once or twice (which is why not all of the debunks answer every single set of end-of-chapter questions).
If you only remember one thing from this series, remember that there is nothing one can say to a Children’s Health Defense board member, or a dedicated antivaxxer, that would convince them that vaccines are safe and effective. Science doesn’t work that way – even Mary Holland says, in this book, science must be willing to challenge old paradigms. That has been done several times over by dedicated scientists (for example, the removal of an old rotavirus vaccine for intussusception). It is actually CHD who is never willing to change their mind, because it would affect their income if they actually operated honestly.
1. “This paternalistic tendency is evident in long-standing attempts by scientific and medical entities to portray the public conversation on vaccines as a lopsided dispute.”
Actually, the reality is more complicated. Medicine does have a history of being paternalistic towards patients, which is something that even mainstream physicians cannot dispute. I will easily own up to our profession having this as a stain on its reputation in the past. This is why the entire profession has been coaching its medical students, nurses, nurse practitioners, pharmacists, and physician assistants, for an extremely long time, about how to make medicine more of a shared decision making process.
There still are times where it is medically necessary to be strict in giving out medical interventions – a classic example of this is a heart attack. A person actively having a heart attack is actively putting their life in danger if they were to reach for their Arizona homeopath instead of an actual interventional cardiologist trained and ready to help fix the heart artery blockage. Extreme paternalism is required to save a life in this case. At other times, it is medically necessary to give the patient a full explanation of what is going on, plus the risks and benefits of each type of treatment. After the explanation, a shared decision can be made.
How does this apply to vaccine science/research? A research reputation is not built by walking into a research meeting and saying “Hey listen to me, I know how the entire medical establishment got it wrong.” A reputation is built by consistently crafting research questions, creating the project that answers them, and interacting professionally with your colleagues to discover the correct answers (and hopefully eventually delivering that research breakthrough to patients).
Even physicians don’t get respect straight out of the box – those who go into vaccine research start out as nobodies, and have to prove their worth. Our professions are, from a certain perspective, kind of paternalistic to us as students/ junior physicians. Physician respect towards junior physicians is earned, bit by bit, from senior physicians. Mainstream physicians may seem paternalistic from the CHD’s perspective, but the requirement for vaccine debate is the same for everybody – the consistent application of the scientific method.
Let’s bring it back to the main point: once multiple research centers, national health departments, and medical professionals have researched a certain topic thoroughly, the burden is solely on the antivaxxer to prove their case using better scientific reasoning than what was previously provided. In every major vaccine, there is a very large body of literature demonstrating both their safety and utility/efficacy. It is not paternalistic to say to Children’s Health Defense that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and that being taken seriously at the professional vaccine discussion table requires a certain fee. The entry fee to the discussion table is democratic – scientific debate and a dedication to scientific reasoning is expected of all. Engaging in a vaccine debate first requires a semblance of shared reality, and next requires adherence to all the usual rules of science. Stating that vaccines are magnetic does not engender much enthusiasm from a mainstream physician in participating in debate.
2. “Clinical trials of vaccines are rigged to hide their true (and high) rate of side effects.”
The truth of the matter is that clinical trials – even for a well off “Big Pharma company” – require lots of laboratory, clinical, and financial resources to run. For the foreseeable future, probably all licensed vaccines will have side effects revealed that did not occur during the initial clinical trials submitted for FDA approval. This is absolutely not because any physician is “secretly smiling in a back room wishing for side effects”. Rather, there will always be side effects too rare to detect in the initial clinical trials. To detect a very rare event, a large number of people must be enrolled – and this is not always practically achievable by the chief investigator conducting a clinical trial for initial vaccine approval.
I am well aware of Big Pharma misconduct, and join all members of the public in celebrating each time a pharmaceutical company is penalized for such misconduct. However, based on resource limitations alone (and this is only just one of several reasons), it is not possible to design a million-person clinical trial for every vaccine in the future, or to seek out every possible side effect within one clinical trial (this is an explicit demand set forth in the book although not in these exact words).
How do we search for those rare side effects? This is why the various vaccine safety monitoring systems were set up, including the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), the Clinical Immunization Safety Assessment Project (CISA), the Post-licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring System (PRISM), and most recently V-safe. Ultimately, other research projects are done to detail how they think the side effect happened and how to potentially avoid it in the future. If a phase III clinical trial does not catch the side effect, the side effect monitoring system generally will. If mainstream physicians truly didn’t care about vaccine side effects, these monitoring systems wouldn’t exist.
3. “Adding a vaccine to the American schedule recommended by the CDC instantly guarantees sales of millions of units per year in the US alone, thus assuring its manufacturer a handsome return on its initial investment.”
At this point I would like to remind the audience that successfully bringing a new vaccine to the market requires an extremely large amount of clinical, laboratory, and financial resources. While COVID vaccines are uniquely profitable amongst vaccines, the vaccines against childhood vaccine-preventable diseases are actually one of the least profitable products for the companies that develop them. Vaccine proposals also fail all the time, meaning companies have invested considerable money and received no return.
While I understand the hostility to pharma-funded studies, what other solutions are available to achieve the funding required to complete such a project? It is the antivax community that claims to have the highest standard of safety required to approve a vaccine, and that requires money. Would Robert F. Kennedy Jr. agree to put up his own money to fund such projects? I have never heard of such a clinical trial funded by him. I have never heard what an antivaxxer would consider an acceptable funding source. Perhaps that would mean he would have to agree to a reassuring result, pointing to the safety of vaccines, which would go against his narrative.
If the antivax ecosystem genuinely cared about safety, they would not trawl social media posts insinuating that everyone who died in the news experienced a vaccine side effect (and in this case their fact-checking is so poor that someone they claimed died, didn’t actually die), assault actual pediatrician lawmakers, and create 24/7 media platforms distributing distorted information about vaccines. If they really cared, they would produce actual actionable peer-reviewed research on how to prevent a vaccine side effect, for example.
There is also no self reflection whatsoever, into the income of Del Bigtree’s Highwire, his customized bricks used to line the walkway of his ranch, or the income statements of Children’s Health Defense. I would encourage supporters of Bigtree to think about this for a second – he has requested payment to make bricks on his ranch engraved with the names of donors, so the names of the donors can be stepped upon. Let’s see if a dedicated antivaxxer can come up with a funding source agreeable to their community and produce successfully peer-reviewed research leading to a better solution than what we have currently.
4. Insistence of saline placebo for all vaccines
Dr. Gorski covered this claim in detail here. In the book it’s sort of implied that there have been no true randomized controlled trials for several classical vaccines, which is not true. If you don’t believe me, reference the package inserts for the influenza, pneumonia, HPV, rotavirus, and dengue vaccines. Each new vaccine requires a clinical trial to win approval under the regulations of each of our international health agencies (CDC, EMA, etc., etc.). The book’s authors also insist only the three-arm trial, or comparison to saline placebo, is the right way of doing clinical trials for vaccines. Both assertions are incorrect.
The regulatory burden of a new prospective vaccine candidate, if brand new, is to be better than a placebo “designed to resemble the test drug as far as possible except for the active ingredient”. But for a better vaccine, the comparison should be that it must perform better than its predecessor. A basic premise of the randomized controlled trial, the standard to aim for, in testing new medicines, is that there are two groups, one getting the real medicine, and one getting the “fake” medicine, to see how much better the real medicine is. One reason to use an old vaccine as a placebo is that if you just inject water, it will be easy for the study subjects to tell they had no vaccine. There is also this thing called the “double blind” trial, which means that the patients and the physicians both don’t know who is getting what. Then, the structure of the truly “double blind placebo controlled randomized controlled trial” is created. For a detailed discussion of the ethics of vaccine placebo, see this reference.
Remember – the Children’s Health Defense crew builds their brand on saying vaccines are always wrong and there is no way to test a vaccine that would satisfy them. This is not the position of a rational physician or basic scientist; in most things, we must be prepared to overturn paradigm. I fully realize these words are not explicitly spelled out on their website, but it is in fact spelled out through their actions. As adults in a free country, we are all entitled to our opinions, but the admittance fee to an actual scientific debate is dedication to scientific reasoning and the scientific method.
Mary Holland cares little for that. She will say anything to make people think vaccines are unsafe, regardless of whether or not this is grounded in reality. In this part of the book, they complain that there were no vaccines tested against placebo – this is a failure of very basic fact checking. Just one example can be found in the 9-valent Gardasil immunization that was tested versus a saline placebo. According to the World Health Organization, “Placebo use in vaccine trials is clearly acceptable when (a) no efficacious and safe vaccine exists and (b) the vaccine under consideration is intended to benefit the population in which the vaccine is to be tested.”
They then go on to insist on a “three arm” vaccine randomized controlled trial, while failing to realize that the modern HPV vaccine insert does in fact have data on such a trial where the amount of adverse events in the saline was no different from the plain adjuvant group. This is inconvenient to their narrative so it is naturally excluded.
Ethically, according to the WHO standard above, there are times when a vaccine placebo must be another vaccine – so certain vaccine trials are in fact done this way (specifically, when an older vaccine is available that can provide a bit of protection, it is ethically mandatory to do this rather than giving the patient water and leaving them vulnerable to a dangerous disease). Other vaccine trials are formulated to make the placebo equal in every way to the real vaccine being tested except for the thing intended to generate an immune response – one of the pneumonia vaccine RCTs is done this way.
The primary mission of a vaccine inventor in the eyes of a regulator is to prove a new vaccine improves upon an old vaccine in some way – this is the most direct reason why a placebo is often an old vaccine. The mission is not to prove the vaccine is more effective than plain water. Practically, it would constitute additional unnecessary steps to compare to saline placebo when the vaccine is supposed to be compared against its older predecessor.
5. There is little scientific merit in comparing results from different clinical trials.
The allegation stated in this part of the book is that two clinical trial covering the same topic must not be compared with each other (or with the general population) because there may be confounding variables that are not accounted for. Making such a statement means the authors either never tried to thoughtfully read the limitations section of a clinical trial, or have made a very poor attempt and are completely misunderstanding the point of having that section on a research paper.
Even our most well-respected clinical trials have issues that the authors describe at the end of their research paper. The authors always try to put their paper into context, and describe how their paper is supposed to contribute to the existing knowledge base. Authors also usually reference how they used the knowledge gained from other similar research projects to better answer the research question at hand. Sometimes the paper will provide a new perspective, or bring up an issue that wasn’t thought about before – all this will be explained in the discussions and results section.
Lastly, the authors will explicitly spell out how to compare their paper to similar papers using all the correct guardrails and design specifications of a scientific publication – meaning they will say what would be a good comparison versus an overgeneralization. The authors of the book completely missed all this.
We acknowledge differences in populations, and then compare when it is scientifically reasonable to do so, and always state in our article discussion sections the potential limits of such comparisons. This is a very large hole in the author’s comprehension of how collaboration between scientific institutions is conducted.
6. RCT control groups cannot be replaced with data from another trial, or any other externally calculated background rate.
The claim here appears to be that control groups are being removed after randomization and replaced with externally selected control groups. This is a misrepresentation of what is being done. In every phase 3 clinical trial, the subjects are randomized to test group and control, or some more complex variation of it – the COVID vaccine clinical trial for the original Pfizer vaccine is illustrative here, where their control group selection was described in great detail. Clinical trials are always going to be compared to external populations after the study is done, because that is the point of doing clinical trials in the first place. Why? The researcher wants to be able to generalize to the population. There are many different methods of post-approval surveillance, as mentioned earlier in this article.
Researchers regularly think about the benefits and pitfalls of comparing their studies to an external population; in fact this is regularly taught in public health training programs. That Mary Holland has failed to appreciate this is her fault alone. In addition, there is also the possibility of external investigators verifying or refuting the claims of the original clinical trial investigators. For example – we have pediatric cardiologists who discovered myocarditis as a consequence of the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines when the original investigators failed to do so. This is one of many examples of peer review/scientific debate in action.
7. “As we shall shortly see, this method (design a trial in which the reported rate of adverse events in the control group would likely be very similar to that of the trial group) is exactly the one vaccine manufacturers employ to deliberately obscure the real incidence of vaccine adverse events.”
When you have insufficient medical or research knowledge to put your reading of clinical trials into the wider overall context, you can come to a conclusion in line with any conspiracy theory you wish. There are several pieces of medical knowledge necessary to understand where this claim falls apart.
First, medical problems will occur before, during, and well after vaccine clinical trials, and for the future existence of all humanity. The “side effect free vaccine” is only a dream; in fact there are side effects to most every aspect of medical care/intervention (even choosing to do nothing, which may cause disease progression). To design a vaccine capable of never experiencing adverse medical events would require a vaccine against all disease, which would be amazing, but clearly an impossible demand of the medical ecosystem.
Next, it requires medical knowledge to distinguish a related from an unrelated adverse event – such knowledge can be acquired through careful study in medical school and careful medical investigation. A more straightforward example is coronary artery disease (the most common kind of adult heart disease) – it is not biochemically plausible or logical to claim that a diagnosis of coronary artery disease was the result of a pneumonia vaccine.
Next, the premise is that the usage of placebo substances that aren’t salt water (saline) allows the deliberate obfuscation of vaccine side effects. This premise is quite conspiratorial. The most obvious reason why is that vaccines have a long period, even after formal FDA and ACIP approval, where they are monitored for side effects, and if needed, valid side effects are added to the formal immunization label. The mRNA COVID-19 vaccines had myocarditis added to their immunization labels this way, and the adenoviral vector COVID vaccines had vaccine-induced thrombotic thrombocytopenia added to their labels in this manner.
Next, someone who claims there is an international conspiracy to hide side effects has never had to personally run a randomized controlled trial. In 2023, with modern computing and worldwide communications, whistleblowing and exposing misconduct is quite easy to do during a randomized controlled trial (even though this particular example did not really affect the final data analysis).
The author doesn’t quite come out and explicitly say it in this case, but they are talking this way because they are hostile to the aluminum adjuvant. They also forget that there are multiple ways to test adjuvant safety, that do not involve formal phase III randomized clinical trials. Next, there is no mention of the human safety of all the potential adjuvants that aren’t aluminum. Why no mention of all that testing? It would degrade their narrative.
Lastly in this section, they spend a lot of time talking about the testing of one of the rotavirus vaccines and again, lamenting that salt water was not used as the placebo in that particular clinical trial. By the way, this counts as an internal inconsistency – the book is OK with using sugar, salt, and water, as placebos, but they forget the placebo in this trial had as its major ingredients, sugar and water. They aren’t even willing to follow their own rules. When you have so many statements that are only lightly based in reality, it is difficult to keep track of them all.
8. The Nürnberg Code
This is an old favorite of antivaxxers, along with the revenge fantasy (where they hope to cause harm to physicians who advocate for vaccines). They believe most vaccine trials to be violations of the Code. The actual 1947 Code delineates what is considered to be acceptable medical experimentation on human beings. In clinical trials, nobody is being required to participate in pediatric vaccine trials. If a family did not want to, all they had to do is walk the other way. There is a very, very extensive informed consent process that occurs before enrolling a family in a pediatric vaccine clinical trial. It goes over the monitoring, tests to be drawn, doses to be given, randomization, how they plan on searching for side effects, known and theoretical side effects, and much, much more. Furthermore, the antivax ecosystem frequently forgets that this code is superseded by the Helsinki declaration.
9. Questions at the end of chapter 1 – these are framed as gotchas when they are actually quite easy for pediatricians to answer.
The questions are:Was the vaccine that you are recommending tested in a pre-licensure clinical trial with a (real) placebo control group? If not, how do you (or anyone else, for that matter) calculate its true rate of adverse events?The rate of adverse events is calculated by the clinical trials in addition to each nation’s pharmacovigilance system continually monitoring vaccine recipients for a long time after the formal national vaccine approval. The multiple logical errors in insisting on a “true placebo” are explained earlier in this article. Not difficult for a pediatrician to look this information up and share with the family.
While there is plenty for a physician to memorize, a physician should not be graded solely by the volume of memorized information; rather a great pediatrician is a great diagnostician and knows how to put each piece of medical information into context. Physicians are certainly ready and willing to help any families interested in learning about vaccine science, but we insist that the science be learned systematically, just like any other scientific discipline.
The true rate of adverse events is going to be first calculated by the initial clinical trial investigators, which is a number provided in the published study. As was illustrated by the distribution of the COVID-19 vaccines, myocarditis was an adverse event not well captured by the initial clinical trials. The most accurate age-stratified rates of myocarditis were calculated by independent investigators studying the issue at the population level and are now all available to discuss with your physician if desired.
Is it morally acceptable to conduct a clinical trial in infants for a new vaccine, where the “control group” receives an untested compound, i.e., the vaccine-sans-antigen, which is likely to cause irreversible side effects and has no potential benefit?Is it morally acceptable to fully expose children to the risks of vaccine preventable disease? I would hope it is not political to say no to that. The placebo contents are examined by researchers and regulators using multiple tools, not just the randomized control trial, to specifically assess the risk of side effects.
I will gladly acknowledge the existence of vaccine-associated adverse events, having diagnosed vaccine myocarditis myself in my clinical practice. One that is more germane to infants is Dravet Syndrome in which some infants are just predisposed to have fevers accompanied with seizures. This is nobody’s fault – they just have a genetic problem with a certain aspect of their brain electricity. This can look absolutely terrifying to the parent seeing this for the very first time, but this can also mean that the infant would have a seizure if they had a fever with the real disease. Pediatric neurologists are quite capable of keeping kids as safe as possible from seizures. Do I like to see kids get this? Of course not, but a holistic interpretation of all the potential benefits of not having vaccine preventable disease is also necessary. This chapter does none of those things.
Vaccine myth and no science
This first chapter tried to explain how vaccine clinical trials are “turtles all the way down” – a phrase that implies claims of vaccine safety are based on a very shaky foundation. But the authors did an incredibly poor job of making their case, from not even being able to follow their own rules, to creating clearly impossible demands, to forgetting the rules of even very simple fact checking, to at times making interpretations that are entirely contrary to acceptable scientific practices.
All of us in pediatric medicine are aware of the shortcomings of the currently available vaccine science, which is why the quest to make the better vaccine is a never-ending quest. The authors of the book make little to no effort to sincerely understand why current vaccine clinical trials are done in the manner that they are, and even attempt to complain that things were not done that were actually done. The authors of the book make little sincere effort to make a substantive contribution to advance vaccine science in a way that would suit their demands. This sets the scene for the debunking of the remainder of the book – and a promise to the reader that more biting commentary is to come in the other 9 parts of this debunk.

The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 2/10)
The second installment in debunking the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down”: Chapter 2, supposedly concerned with “The Science of Adverse Events”.
Frank Han on July 16, 2023
Link

In the first installment of this series debunking the book “Turtles All the Way Down” (written by “Anonymous”, and edited by Children’s Health Defense lawyer Mary Holland and Children’s Health Defense Publisher Liaison Zoey O’Toole), I examined and debunked the first chapter of the book. As I said then, because this is a fairly long book, I’ll be spreading my posts out over 10 more reasonably digestible pieces. This is the next installment in the series – debunking Chapter 2 – which is supposedly concerned with “The Science of Adverse Events”. As in the previous installment, I will present quotes or paraphrases of statements from the chapter with their associated debunks, and answers to the questions at the end of each chapter. Statements that are repetitive will be addressed only once or twice even though they might appear several times within the chapter.
1. At present, officially sanctioned medical science knows very little about the harmful effects of vaccines. It cannot, and does not, anticipate which children will be injured by vaccination.
This is partially true in that there is no Star Trek style “medical tricorder” yet invented that can be waved over everyone’s immune system ahead of time to determine which minority of people can be anticipated to have a vaccine associated adverse event. I’m sure Children’s Health Defense would love to have such a tool, but then still be hostile towards vaccines – it’s their brand. Due to financial reasons, they can’t say anything else.
The collective knowledge, though, of vaccine side effects, is quite large – a search of vaccine side effects on Pubmed alone (this is just one database) reveals more than 54 000 entries. Again, vaccine safety surveillance, or pharmacovigilance, is always active after the release of a new vaccine. The claims linking ingredients such as thiomersal in immunizations with autism and sudden infant death syndrome have been thoroughly, thoroughly debunked, and yet the authors still bring this up.
They next go on to criticize the 2011 Institute of Medicine report, whose role was to investigate several vaccine side effects, but they are very upset that the report in general spoke to the safety of vaccines. If an immunization creates more benefit than risk, then according to even the author’s own exhortations, this is one part of following the science and then accepting that immunization into the mainstream.
It escapes the author’s thinking that we can be simultaneously supportive of effective and safe vaccines, while also being supportive of the rare patient who developed vaccine-derived polio, or the teenager who developed myocarditis (who will need the care of a cardiologist). The risk of paralysis (severe polio disease), although small, multiplied across the entire world population who received the polio vaccine, means that a massive number of people are free of the devastating disease of paralytic polio.
If the authors actually cared about helping those with a vaccine associated adverse event or figuring out the mechanism of a rare adverse event – they would fund studies to this effect. For example, here’s an article about a well done vaccine adverse event study on COVID-19 vaccine associated postural orthostatic tachycardia. The study was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health; Doris Duke Charitable Foundation; American Heart Association; the American Society of Nuclear Cardiology; the Smidt Heart Institute (A.C.K.); and the Burns & Allen Chair in Cardiology Research (P.-S.C.), Cedars-Sinai Medical Center.
What they do instead, is fund narrative articles full of biologically nonsensical information that is relatively free of scientific reasoning. Which antivax strategy was used here? Flood the zone with information, with complete disregard as to whether or not it is correct. Robert F Kennedy Jr or Steve Kirsch are most definitely not coming to your aid if you get a vaccine associated adverse event – your physician will do that. Someone like me is going to treat vaccine associated myocarditis, not Del Bigtree. The moral high ground would be to come up with the better research project (perhaps even figure out more genetic predictors of vaccine side effects), but there is clearly no effort on the part of this group to do so.
2. Scientific research into the mechanisms underlying side effects of vaccines should investigate, among other things, (1) the effects that vaccine ingredients (like aluminum adjuvants) have on the body; (2) the biochemical interactions between vaccine components; (3) the biochemical interactions among multiple vaccines administered at the same time; (4) genetic characteristics that may increase vulnerability to vaccine injury; and (5) permanent or transient health conditions that may increase susceptibility to injury.
There have been attempts to do all these things. The antivax strategy used here, is to be disappointed that these research problems are not thoroughly researched to perfection (No True Scotsman Fallacy).
(1) The effects that vaccine ingredients (like aluminum adjuvants) have on the body:
Many adjuvants have come and gone, and those that were retired left the scene due to too many unfavorable symptoms. The modern research into adjuvants actually stretches back many decades at least, something that is ignored in the book.
Adjuvants have been around for a very long time and probably date back to at least the 1800s, when a scientist discovered that certain killed bacteria, when given to patients, can cure certain limited types of cancer. It was after this that the usefulness of adjuvants in enhancing immunity with vaccination was discovered, which is where aluminum compounds come into the picture.
Aluminum is never present in a vaccine as the base metal – no aluminum filings are being injected. It is aluminum chemically reacted with something else like hydroxide. This is actually the oldest and most well studied adjuvant, and in many ways, is the standard against which prospective new adjuvants are judged.
However, the lack of a precise set of mechanisms showing how the aluminum actually exerts its action is a legitimate knowledge gap. Some ideas have been proposed, such as the sensing of aluminum salts by special receptors inside the cells. One very fascinating discovery is that surgical removal of the area of skin containing the adjuvant after vaccination actually does not impede the subsequent immune response, meaning the actual aluminum isn’t behaving like a slow release mixture of the bacteria/virus being vaccinated against (like what is done with some of our oral medications).
Before someone misinterprets what I say as “take out all the aluminum because it’s not needed”, I remind the audience that certain types of vaccines do not produce a meaningful response unless an adjuvant is added (we wouldn’t want to waste an injection). Side effects of this oldest adjuvant do exist, but the book glosses over the fact that more than 3 billion vaccine doses have been given, with side effects attributable to this adjuvant being a tiny fraction of that total (approximately 130 cases).
(2) The biochemical interactions between vaccine components:
It was not originally apparent that it was feasible to mix diphtheria, pertussis, and tetanus into one vaccination. Chemists and vaccine researchers had to do separate projects to figure this out. At the most basic level, vaccine active ingredients must be put in a container with other items (like sugar, salt, water, and acidity modifying agents) such that it has a usable shelf life. It would not be acceptable for eggs to come to you, the grocery shopper, already cooked – that means the proteins have changed their shape and have become solid egg protein. The same goes with vaccines – you need the active ingredients to stay chemically stable in their containers until they reach the user.
There is quite a bit of research studying vaccine interactions that is completely ignored by the authors. In just this one study, the investigators learned not to conjugate (meaning chemically stuck together) pneumococcal vaccine to tetanus because it could cause weakened immunity to pneumococcal vaccine when given with another vaccine also conjugated to tetanus toxoid. This is one of the big reasons why the modern iteration of the PCV13 (pneumoccal vaccine) is conjugated to a diphtheria protein, rather than the tetanus toxoid.
Biochemical interactions between multiple vaccines have to be studied in order to make multi-vaccine doses (D-T-aP refers to three vaccines for example). You can’t have one vaccine degrade the other, otherwise they couldn’t be mixed together. Chemists literally had to figure out all the interactions before they could decide which vaccines could be mixed and which vaccines needed to sit in separate containers before giving to a person. There are many studies directly addressing this, for example: one group tried mixing the strep pneumoniae vaccine with a group C meningitis vaccine; the group realized that this mixture produced weaker immunity than just doing a meningitis vaccine by itself. This mixture never got FDA approval thanks to studies like these.
In other vaccines, you will see addition of salts and buffers. The addition of certain salts is to make sure the vaccine is about the same saltiness as the human body (everyone’s probably seen what happens to your fingers when submerged in the ocean for too long). The buffer is to make sure the vaccine is the same acidity as your body – you wouldn’t want to mix something that is a lot more acidic or basic than your body, into your arm. The interactions between salts and buffers is extremely well established chemistry lab science. Failure to read this science on the part of the authors is not sufficient evidence to say the science did not happen.
(3) The biochemical interactions among multiple vaccines administered at the same time:
This is a thinly veiled reiteration of the old antivax talking point of demanding a randomized placebo controlled trial of the entire vaccine schedule. Would the antivax community suddenly be satisfied if such a trial actually happened? Absolutely not, because they will find something else to be upset about.
In addition, the biochemical interactions between multiple vaccines administered at the same time has been studied for a very long time both in RCTs and post-marketing surveillance and pharmacovigilance of children receiving their country’s standard vaccine schedule.
There are also multiple issues with demanding such a trial. First, based upon the clinical trials that are already available, the number of adverse events will be very small, necessitating a very, very large trial. Next, making randomized controlled trials that big necessarily involves preventing large numbers of children from receiving vaccinations against real, health endangering, and sometimes deadly, vaccine preventable diseases, which is clearly unethical (this book generally glosses over all vaccine benefits).
Again, failure to read any of this science on the part of the authors is not sufficient evidence to say the science did not happen.
(4) Genetic characteristics that may increase vulnerability to vaccine injury:
Genetic characteristics that may increase the potential for vaccine related adverse events have been studied but could use additional study, for sure. For example – Dravet syndrome is a problem with your body’s ion channels, that may cause you to have a seizure with a fever (after a vaccination). An ion channel is responsible for maintaining the electricity that allows your body to function. When the ion channel functions too slowly or too quickly, disorders like Dravet syndrome can occur. This is however, nobody’s fault. It is not something you can catch by going to Starbucks. It is also easily treatable by a trained pediatric neurologist.
Compare that to the conditions that vaccine preventable diseases sometimes cause that absolutely, definitely have no cure such as subacute sclerosing panencephalitis after measles or deafness after congenital cytomegalovirus. Even if Dravet syndrome is diagnosed – that would mean the patient is still subject to febrile seizures with the actual disease. So, I hope a discussion is completed in regards to whether or not the family actually wants a child diagnosed with Dravet syndrome to gamble with the actual disease and all its complications.
The vast majority of people with inherited congenital problems still deserve vaccination, such as people with Turner syndrome, prematurity, or congenital diaphragmatic hernia. In fact, these patients at times need classical vaccinations more urgently than the general population because they may be more liable to become seriously ill.
(5) Permanent or transient health conditions that may increase susceptibility to injury:
What are some of those conditions? I invite the reader to view the published vaccine inserts that list conditions that count as generally accepted medical precautions or contraindications to receipt of certain vaccines. For example, certain immunodeficiencies mean the patient may not receive live vaccines (e.g. certain types of cancer patients). Encephalopathy after pertussis vaccine is a reason to not receive further doses of that vaccine. Again the author pretends that this part of vaccine science didn’t get researched, but in reality, they just failed to read about it.
Note the lack of quantifiable contributions of the authors to actually advance the research, despite their strong exhortations that it be done. The statement that “there is no scientific foundation” in this particular subject is then, objectively wrong, as I’ve shown several times above. A productive way of spending their time would be to fund publishable research into vaccine side effects that is successful in peer review amongst the scientific community. The authors don’t do that.
3. The lack of solid science illuminating the mechanics of vaccination side effects has another important downside: It allows researchers conducting clinical trials to arbitrarily decide whether a particular adverse event observed in the trial is related to the vaccine or not.
This is an intentional distortion of what actually happens. While it is true that determining whether an adverse event is due to a vaccine is sometimes subjective, it is the knowledge of medicine of the person making the determination that helps create the determination. There are no people who make adverse event determinations based upon a whim or the side of the bed their cat woke up on. Some events are clearly unrelated, such as car accidents and gunshots.
The United States Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System and the UK Yellow Card scheme are designed to allow as many reports as possible, but due to the subjective nature of the system, further analysis via a more robust database is needed, such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink. I will go through how pediatric cardiologists determine the presence of a now very famous vaccine adverse event – COVID19 mRNA vaccine associated vaccine myocarditis.
The cardiologist first determines the time course of events/symptoms. Next, they do an EKG, troponin, echocardiogram, and blood testing to determine if any other infections have recently occurred (because viral infections always place people at risk of myocarditis). Then, the definitive test for diagnosing myocarditis is cardiac MRI. Once all the tests have resulted, and no infection is found, the diagnosis of vaccine related myocarditis is established. Note that it took until 2023 for us to have some research delineating exactly why this happens. Some side effects are definitely more subjective than others, but the overall determination is definitely not made on a whim.
Remember, Children’s Health Defense wants the side effect count as high as possible so they can continue to malign vaccines. There is no situation in which they would accept a vaccine as safe, which would degrade their messaging. They actually care little about the actual healthcare of children. If the reader follows the posts on this website for a few years, it becomes evident that this is not only my opinion – CHD always finds something new to complain about in regards to immunizations.
4. There is never any mention of the fact that no attempt was made to establish whether or not a causal link exists.
The allegation here is that initial reports of possible vaccine related adverse events use the terminology “condition X was reported following use of the vaccine” and emphasize that “a causal association could not be established”, therefore the vaccine researchers don’t actually care to research vaccine side effects. This is an intentional distortion of what we do.
When initial reports of adverse events come in, investigators do not have enough information, based upon the reports alone, to determine if the adverse event was caused by the vaccine. One of the reasons is that many of the adverse events also occur in the absence of a vaccine. After reports are made, in the United States, the CDC needs to follow up, call physicians, and sometimes get additional medical testing to figure out what really happened.
The reports must be collated, verified (no reports of turning into The Incredible Hulk can be used), and other investigators must start working on potential vaccine adverse event mechanisms before a valid side effect or adverse event can be established. The rates of a particular adverse event are also compared to the rates of those events in the general population – the “background rate” – to see if they’re occurring at a higher rate among those who are vaccinated. This can take a long time. To make statement #4 with a straight face requires ignoring all of this willingly.
5. If our child experienced a health problem following vaccination, what medical tests are at your disposal to decide whether the condition was actually caused by the vaccine?
In every vaccine out there, the overall risk to all age groups for which it is targeted is far outstripped by the benefits, otherwise no national health agency would approve the vaccine. They have certainly been instances when rare side effects only became apparent after approval and further pharmacovigilance review, such as myocarditis after the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and intussusception after the RotaShield® vaccine.
The selection of tests may not necessarily be good enough to formally diagnose every observed side effect that has ever been recorded, but myocarditis is efficiently diagnosed by cardiac MRI and intussusception is efficiently diagnosed by ultrasound. There are actually many more tests for different types of possible adverse events than this book is giving the medical community credit for – and authors ignore that on purpose.
However, many side effects and adverse events that occur following vaccination also occur in the absence of a vaccine – both myocarditis and intussusception, for example, have other causes. Part of determining whether a particular health issue following vaccination was caused by the vaccine involves ruling out other possible causes. However, there are specific adverse events that have been determined to be related to specific vaccines and if they occur within a certain time following the vaccine it can be assumed that they are caused by the vaccine.
6. We fear that our child could be adversely affected by a particular vaccine. What medical tests can you perform in order to determine whether or not she is at high risk of being injured by that vaccine?
The author is sort of correct in the second part of this question in that there is no Star-Trek style medical tricorder that can scan a baby ahead of time, to predict every possible vaccine side effect. However, this discussion should always be accompanied by the risks of the disease that the vaccine is trying to prevent. While the ability to predict vaccine side effects ahead of time, for an individual patient, is limited, the risks versus the benefits are very, very well known.
Willful misrepresentation
Overall, the authors in this chapter attempted to make a case that the toolbox for diagnosing vaccine related adverse events is an empty toolbox, and full of missing links. If the speakers wanted to go to Home Depot and take a picture of an empty toolbox, and claim this is the toolbox used by a professional car mechanic, this would be clear evidence of misrepresentation. This is exactly how this chapter reads to someone who is actually trained on pediatric vaccines. It shouldn’t require a medical degree for the reader to appreciate that the Home Depot scam I invented is not reflective of reality. One can give the impression that vaccine science is full of missing links very easily – if one fails to read all the links that were provided even in the sources that the authors cited. This whole chapter, is therefore, a great example of the authors simply putting their heads in the sand.

The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 3/10)
The third installment in debunking the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down”: Chapter 3, “Deficient by Design: The Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS)”.
Frank Han on July 25, 2023
Link

This is the third installment of debunking the book “Turtles All the Way Down” (written by “Anonymous”, and edited by Children’s Health Defense lawyer Mary Holland and Children’s Health Defense Publisher Liaison Zoey O’Toole). Because this is a fairly long book, I’ll be spreading my posts out over 10 more reasonably digestible pieces. This is the next installment in the series – debunking Chapter 3 “Deficient by Design: The Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS)”.
As in the previous two installments, I will present quotes or paraphrases of statements from the chapter with their associated debunks, and answers to the questions at the end of each chapter. Statements that are repetitive will be addressed only once or twice even though they might appear several times within the chapter.
1. VAERS suffers from underreporting bias:
This is partially true in that nobody will deliver a VAERS link to your doorstep and solicit reports, however there are multiple means at the public’s disposal to report what they believe to be adverse events. VAERS is a passive surveillance system, meaning it relies on voluntary reporting.
It is certainly now widely known that during the COVID pandemic, systems were at times slow to react to potential vaccine associated side effects. For example, it took a certain period of time for vaccine associated myocarditis to be recognized by all major national health systems. Even mainstream physicians can get behind the call to ask for VAERS reports to be acted upon more quickly.
However, this thought process – which pervades this chapter – has a big logical hole in it: VAERS is not designed nor was it intended to be acted upon alone. It is intended to be used in conjunction with the national and international vaccine reporting databases such as the Vaccine Safety Datalink, university researchers, the British Yellow Card system, the European EMA, and similar systems in other countries.
One of the few times the Vaccine Safety Datalink is mentioned, the authors claim that its data being “concealed forever”. If this were genuinely true, like how classified data is concealed forever, nobody would be able to produce any research projects from it. The VSD is open to any competent researchers with the CV adequate to analyze the data. Contrary to the beliefs of the authors, there is no effort to constrain researchers from using the VSD – a wide variety of researchers have written studies based upon this active surveillance database. Anyone with the academic credentials to design a well thought out research project from the VSD may use it. Contrary to the belief that vaccine safety researchers are willfully blind to rare adverse events, the people who are actually employed to research these side effects are actively thinking about the ways they could be missing blind spots and side effects not easy to spot.
An example of VAERS working as it was intended to work
Let’s look at a specific serious but rare vaccine side effect – vaccine-induced thrombotic thrombocytopenia – and the viral vector adenovirus COVID-19 vaccine from Johnson & Johnson. On April 13, 2021, the CDC issued a Health Alert regarding Cases of Cerebral Venous Sinus Thrombosis with Thrombocytopenia after Receipt of the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 Vaccine:
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) are reviewing data involving six U.S. cases of a rare type of blood clot in individuals after receiving the J&J COVID-19 vaccine that were reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). … All six cases occurred among women aged 18–48 years. The interval from vaccine receipt to symptom onset ranged from 6–13 days. One patient died. …
CDC will convene an emergency meeting of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) on Wednesday, April 14, 2021, to further review these cases and assess potential implications on vaccine policy. FDA will review that analysis as it also investigates these cases. Until that process is complete, CDC and FDA are recommending a pause in the use of the J&J COVID-19 vaccine out of an abundance of caution. …
Further extensive review followed, including comparing cases with VSD:
Subsequently, the pause was lifted on April 23. 2021, and information about the rare side effect was added to the Fact Sheets for healthcare providers and patients. The CDC continued to investigate and monitor cases and by December 2021 calculated an incidence rate of 1/100,000. Subsequently:
In December 2021, after reviewing updated vaccine effectiveness and safety data, the ACIP [Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) – CDC] made a preferential recommendation for the use of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines over the Janssen COVID-19 Vaccine in all persons 18 years of age and older in the United States. The ACIP recommended and CDC endorsed that the Janssen COVID-19 Vaccine may be considered in some situations: when a person has a contraindication to receipt of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, when a person would otherwise remain unvaccinated for COVID-19 due to limited access to mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, and when a person wants to receive the Janssen COVID-19 Vaccine despite the safety concerns identified.
Based on continued monitoring and research, on May 5, 2022, the J&J vaccine EUA was modified to restrict candidates for this vaccine to “individuals 18 years of age and older for whom other authorized or approved COVID-19 vaccines are not accessible or clinically appropriate, and to individuals 18 years of age and older who elect to receive the Janssen COVID-19 Vaccine because they would otherwise not receive a COVID-19 vaccine.” As of May 10, 2023, this vaccine is no longer available in the US. All this work started with reports to VAERS.
When all the vaccine pharmacovigilance databases are used together, they work as intended. It’s easy to complain that a BMW sports car cannot tow a tractor, but that is only if you have unrealistic expectations.
2. VAERS cannot detect small adverse events:
It is possible to have empathy with those who encountered genuine vaccine related adverse events while also insisting on systematic, rules-guided research on this issue. This statement is mathematically illogical – VAERS, on its own, does not provide a denominator (total number of vaccine recipients). Other systems such as vaccine logs, are necessary to provide that number. People who had a great experience after vaccination generally are not on VAERS describing how uneventful their experience was.
This statement is wrong on several other levels as well: Studies that originated from VAERS data revealed small signals of intussusception with an older rotavirus vaccine, suspicion of corneal graft rejection after COVID immunization, VITT after COVID immunization, and an Australian study of fainting after HPV vaccination. This is obviously a non-exhaustive list.
3. Anyone can report to VAERS/ VAERS is passive reporting:
This is a double-edged sword. It is possible for dishonest actors to encourage false reporting to VAERS at any time, although Dr Shimabukuro, the CDC deputy director, advises us that there is no current evidence of widespread systematic gaming of the system. It is also accurate that this is a “passive surveillance” system, in that anyone is invited to report. However, the system does not actively solicit the recording of adverse events, in the same way V-Safe, a system implemented during the rollout of the COVID vaccines, solicits reports.
Prospective researchers who want to use VAERS should acknowledge that its “open door policy” does allow as many reports as the public is willing to write up, but that appropriate work is necessary to filter out reports that do not make biological sense, are clearly not vaccine related, or are clearly fraudulent — for example the report of a vaccine turning a man into the Hulk.
People who run databases that mirror VAERS (like OpenVAERS) know this – you have to acknowledge that you’ve read the warning on the official VAERS website before you can access the data. But again, I remind the reader that the main goal of the antivax ecosystem is to stir up as much fear as possible about vaccines, without any thought as to whether that fear may have any validity.
Liz Willner, the author of OpenVAERS, theoretically knows to not regard VAERS reports as stand-alone proof of causality, but she and other like-minded people prefer to de-emphasize this. The number of safe vaccines for a dedicated antivaxxer is, has, and always will be zero. These people face absolutely no consequences when someone listens to their advice and contracts a vaccine-preventable disease.
4. The promise of vaccine adverse event reporting systems has not been realized because these systems are intentionally designed to be unable to fulfill their stated mission of monitoring vaccine safety:
See points #1 and #2 above. It is easy to criticize a BMW X5 for being unable to tow a tractor, but that is if you have unrealistic expectations.
5. Questions to ask your doctor:
Are you familiar with the VAERS system? Have you ever filed a case with VAERS?
As a cardiologist I am happy to report suspected cases of vaccination myocarditis to VAERS and respond to their requests for clinical discussion. I encourage other pediatricians to use it as well. Any physician who administers vaccines has to be aware of VAERS. Whether they’ve ever filed a report will depend on whether they’ve observed a reportable event (see below).
If your patient experiences an adverse health event following vaccination, do you check VAERS for reports of similar symptoms before deciding how to proceed with the case? Do you report it to VAERS?
All healthcare providers are required to report certain adverse events to VAERS (see below). If a patient experiences an event following vaccination that doesn’t meet those requirements, it is reasonable to check VAERS personally, before deciding how to proceed with a possible vaccine adverse event case, but this should be done in conjunction with other research as well.
Do you think healthcare professionals should be required by law to report adverse health events following vaccination, similar to their obligation to report cases of notifiable infectious diseases
This aspect of VAERS as represented in the book is a clear misrepresentation. Healthcare workers are already required by law to report certain adverse events:
Under the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA), healthcare providers are required by law to report to VAERS:
    • Any adverse event listed in the VAERS Table of Reportable Events Following Vaccination [PDF – 5 Pages] that occurs within the specified time period after vaccinations
    • An adverse event listed by the vaccine manufacturer as a contraindication to further doses of the vaccine
Healthcare providers are strongly encouraged to report to VAERS:
    • Any adverse event that occurs after the administration of a vaccine licensed in the United States, whether it is or is not clear that a vaccine caused the adverse event
    • Vaccine administration errors
Healthcare providers who administer COVID-19 vaccines are required to report additional adverse events:
    • Serious AEs regardless of causality [emphasis added]. Serious AEs per FDA are defined as:
         (a)  Death
         (b)  A life-threatening AE
         (c)  Inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization
         (d)  A persistent or significant incapacity or substantial disruption of the ability to conduct normal life functions
         (e)  A congenital anomaly/birth defect
         (f)  An important medical event that based on appropriate medical judgement may jeopardize the individual and may require medical or surgical intervention to prevent one of the outcomes listed above
    • Cases of myocarditis after a Pfizer-BioNTech, Moderna, Novavax, or Janssen COVID-19 vaccine
    • Cases of pericarditis after a Pfizer-BioNTech, Moderna, Novavax, or Janssen COVID-19 vaccine
    • Cases of Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in children and adults
    • Cases of COVID-19 that result in hospitalization or death
Healthcare providers are encouraged to report to VAERS any additional clinically significant AEs following vaccination, even if unsure whether the vaccine caused the event.
Certain side effects are common to most vaccines – sore arm, fatigue, fever, chills, headache, muscle and joint aches. They are usually short lived, lasting a day or two. They are also listed in the vaccine insert and described in the handout that the patient receives. However, it is not necessary for healthcare workers to report every possible sore arm and fever under the sun for the VAERS system to be able to generate information on such side effects, although it is reasonable to debate this particular point.
The fault, dear authors, …
Overall, this chapter is an attempt to explain how VAERS is inadequate to detect vaccine side effects without ever acknowledging that VAERS was designed to work in concert with additional active vaccine adverse event reporting systems. This information has been publicly available for decades. As demonstrated above, this synergy does work to detect vaccine side effects. That they do not produce the result the authors want to hear is not the fault of VAERS, it is the fault of the authors.

he Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 4/10)
The debunking resumes with the fourth installment in debunking the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down”: Chapter 4, “Epidemiology 101,” in which the antivax authors put a biased spin on basic concepts in epidemiology as a lead-in to their obviously intended purpose of claiming that all the studies finding vaccines to be safe and effective should be discounted.
Frank Han on August 10, 2023
Link 

This is the fourth installment of debunking the book “Turtles All the Way Down” (written by “Anonymous”, and edited by Children’s Health Defense lawyer Mary Holland and Children’s Health Defense Publisher Liaison Zoey O’Toole). Because this is a fairly long book, I’ll be spreading my posts out over 10 more reasonably digestible pieces. This is the next installment in the series – debunking Chapter 4 “Epidemiology 101”.
As in the previous three installments, I will present quotes or paraphrases of statements from the chapter with their associated debunks, and answers to the questions at the end of each chapter. Statements that are repetitive will be addressed only once or twice even though they might appear several times within the chapter.
This chapter serves as a descriptor of the various major epidemiological techniques and research strategies, as well as basic descriptions of what constitutes a randomized controlled trial. It also illustrates the difference between finding an epidemiological correlation, versus a physiological mechanism of how something happens biologically. In general, these introductory descriptions are reasonable. However, they are subtly wrong enough that the unitiated may take the authors word and then accept the distortions that are going to be set up in chapter 5 and beyond. Here, I show you exactly what those distortions are.
     1.  The answer is that the term causal link has a different meaning in medicine than in exact sciences like chemistry and physics… In medicine, however, the situation is radically different. Such certainty doesn’t exist.The reality of the matter is that the authors are demonstrating a substantial lack of knowledge of human biology. We are able to watch individual cells move about and do their daily business. We are able to read a large fraction of the human genetic code. We are able to able to create animations of how power generating molecular machines in our bodies work. We are able to replace enzymes in many genetic diseases, such as Pompe disease. We are able to diagnose rare genetic conditions. We are able to perform heart surgery on babies weighing less than 1 kg, to remove extra blood vessel connections that shouldn’t exist. We are able to deliver babies with a level of safety that the Ancient Romans would only have dreamed of. We are able to perform heart surgeries on babies before they are born. It’s clear we don’t know every last molecular interaction in the human body, but we know a very large number of ways the body works. I could make this entire debunk about this one point, but this statement is simultaneously an attempt to set up antivax tropes in the next chapter and a profoundly lazy attempt to gloss over excellent medical research that has directly addressed this point.
     2.  To date, science has no definitive answers as to why one gets cancer while the other does not. This is an entire subspecialty of genetics, the research into tumor suppressor genes. One of the roles of tumor suppressor protein p53 is exactly to help people not get cancer. One of an entire class of anticancer drugs is known as immune checkpoint inhibitors, whose invention was based upon knowing the roles of the immune checkpoints in cancer. This is a recurring theme in this entire book – the lack of reading on the part of the authors is not sufficient evidence by itself, to claim that something doesn’t exist.
     3.  Similarly, if a vaccine increased the risk of a certain side effect, the vaccine would be considered a cause of the side effect, even if it did not occur in every vaccinee.This is a distortion of what actually happens. The most contemporary example of this is the rollout of the COVID vaccines. A fair number of people on the web point to the OpenVAERS system (described in previous Turtles debunks) as evidence of mass, coordinated attempts to ignore vaccine side effects and causation. The authors almost see their own internal logical error – they explicitly say that epidemiological studies cannot prove causation on their own; they must be paired with biological studies to show a mechanism. They fail to see the error when they say, in previous chapters, to use VAERS for what it is not designed to do, which is to demonstrate causation. The sentence quote above is a veiled attempt to ask the reader to believe whatever VAERS reports say, indicate that a vaccine is causative of a side effect. VAERS has a disclaimer on its front page to remind the reader to explicitly not do this (and how to use VAERS properly is described in previous posts linked at the bottom of this page). Again, another recurring theme throughout this book is, that the readers are so disorganized that they can’t even stick to their own rulebooks.
     4.  A typical example is the “Back to Sleep” campaign, begun in 1994, which recommended laying infants on their backs, as opposed to their stomachs or sides, in order to reduce the risk of “crib death” (SIDS). This recommendation is made despite the fact that medical science still does not know exactly why back sleeping appears to be safer for babies.The authors neglect that current pediatric science knows a great deal about SIDS. Our brains have several automatic functions, and one of those functions is the control of breathing. In a typical adult, if we are sleeping and our airways are obstructed by something, provided the rest of the body is healthy, we’ll awake and readjust our position to sleep more effectively. How we know our brains control our breathing comes from decades of neurological research into how certain areas of the brain work; in large part this is thanks to the research of neurologists dealing with patients who survived a stroke. When certain areas of the brain were injured due to lack of oxygen, the researcher would have been able to figure out the function that is no long working, which would be a big clue into the proper function of the particular segment of brain that was injured. In infants, one of the suspected mechanisms of SIDS is the disordered control of breathing – meaning, when the infant has an airway blockage, the infant is not able to reposition quickly enough before they suffocate. Another suspected mechanism is related to the normal transmission of information from the segment of the brain controlling breathing via neurotransmitters (one of the fundamental units of information in the brain). While all the mechanisms of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome are not yet worked out, there is a campaign from the American Academy of Pediatrics to encourage as many infants as possible to be put to sleep on their backs in a spartan, toy free crib. Why? There is actual incontrovertible evidence that fewer babies died over time when the babies were put to sleep on their backs. Despite the fact that the likely multiple mechanisms of SIDS have not been worked out in their entirety, placing a baby on the back carries minimal harm to the baby. There was an opportunity to decrease infant death – and so that opportunity was taken. Research into the actual mechanisms of SIDS can occur at the same time, without having to delay giving the general public an opportunity to get an easy and cheap tool to decrease sudden infant death. The Back To Sleep campaign directly addresses one of the hypothesized mechanisms of SIDS – if the baby’s airway is blocked due to a suboptimal sleeping position (like rolled against a toy), position the baby in an unblocked position to begin with so that they don’t have to worry about a blocked airway during sleep. Inevitably, this discussion is accompanied by a discussion of why “mainstream scientists won’t admit vaccines cause SIDS” – that’s because they don’t cause SIDS. A specific statistical relationship would have been observed in the epidemiology of SIDS, and that relationship is not there.
It is important to understand – and this point will come up again later in the book – that epidemiological studies, no matter how well done, cannot rule out a causal link between two phenomena (such as a vaccine and a new autoimmune condition) for an individual.There are quite a few relevant real life examples where this is wrong by being absolutist, and those include the rotavirus vaccine, polio vaccine, and thimerosal. An old iteration of the rotavirus vaccine was found to cause intussusception in a subset of infants who received it. The rotavirus vaccine trials used for licensure didn’t pick it up, but intussusception is not a minor affair, meaning it can cause a baby severe intestinal injury, bleeding, or death. Before that association became well known, it was feasible to both conduct epidemiological studies, and conduct research into the reason why it happens. Ultimately, the CDC discovered this valid association, and the rotavirus vaccines have been updated accordingly to decrease that risk. Actual rotavirus disease is one of the leading causes of infant mortality around the world (and one of the causes of severe life-threatening vomiting/ diarrhea in US children) – and so maintaining access to protection against this disease is critical. While rotavirus vaccine intussusception was occuring only in a small fraction of children, the vaccine community made it their duty to make the vaccines better. This was established by epidemiological and mechanistic studies working together.The story of thiomersal goes back to the search for a safe and effective preservative for some of the early iterations of the vaccine (it reaches back to the 1930s). It is logical that vaccine manufacturers and end-users alike don’t want mold or bacteria to grow in their vaccines before they reach the arm of a patient, and so in the search for a safe and effective preservative, thiomersal was studied and used in early childhood vaccines. As time passed there were concerns for the toxicity of mercury and its relationship with autism, but the people generally expressing these concerns have a poor command of the biochemistry behind thiomersal. There is mercury metal, ethylmercury, and methylmercury, which are the three versions of mercury relevant to this discussion. When the thiomersal molecule reaches the body, it is broken down into two molecules, one of which is ethylmercury, which through the normal metabolic processes of the body, is eliminated. Methylmercury is generally a product of bacterial interactions with the metallic mercury atom, and this is stored in the body for much longer, and is part of the reason why there are intake limitation recommendations on tuna for example. Mercury metal looks nice in thermometers, but hopefully is not something that everyday people are exposed to, as this has well established toxicities. The key point here is that thiomersal, in the concentrations present in vaccines, did not have consistent evidence demonstrating that it was a genuine threat to health and safety. The preservative was removed anyway as a precaution. The corollary argument given by dedicated antivaxxers is that thiomersal is related to autism. If that were actually true (which it is not), removal of thiomersal should have caused a decrease in total yearly autism diagnoses. The actual number of diagnoses has risen, due to multiple reasons. The toxicity of something must always be analyzed in the context of the amount the human body is being exposed to, as well as its chemical format. This was established by epidemiological and mechanistic studies working together.The story of the polio vaccine actually begins with the efforts to make an inactivated and attenuated version of the poliovirus (the Salk and Sabin vaccines). Ultimately, several companies rose to the challenge of mass producing the immunization, and initial studies indicated that this was a very safe and very effective vaccine. Crowds were coming out and lining up to receive the product, since just in the US alone, nearly every family knew someone who was paralyzed by polio. The problem came when a specific company did not inactivate their inactivated virus vaccine well enough, and mistakenly delivered live virus to some children. This caused paralysis in a subset of those children and became a significant incident known as the “Cutter incident”. Just like in all the other cases, epidemiologic studies and mechanistic studies worked together to solve the problem and in the United States, only the inactivated vaccine is currently used. The downsides of the oral polio vaccine are discussed in a later debunk dedicated to a chapter describing the “mysteries” of the polio vaccination.One of the likely mechanisms of COVID vaccine myocarditis were not worked out in actual heart tissue until 2023, but its epidemiology and highest risk groups (teen boys and young men) was worked out by separate epidemiologists well before 2023. I have discussed the topic elsewhere, in detail, on Science Based Medicine. The reason Vioxx caused heart attacks, and was ultimately pulled off the market, was not well known initially, but the epidemiological research went on in parallel with the research into the biological mechanism.Overall, the chapter attempts to mix in the No True Scotsman fallacy, use fake experts, and attempt to engage in distortions of the truth. It was reasonable of them to include some basic lessons in epidemiology in the beginning of the chapter, but the descriptions of our major epidemiological concepts were just wrong enough that it took a discerning eye to help see where the distortions were (their attempts to set up distortions in the next chapter). Just because epidemiological studies cannot show a biological mechanism, doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be taken seriously and be used to guide studies into the biological mechanism. In the previous debunk, I illustrated how the VAERS system and accompanying vaccine safety monitoring systems detected vaccine induced thrombotic thrombocytopenia, just like they should have. Epidemiologic studies do not deserve criticism for not being able to do something that they were not designed to do, and VAERS is not the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring.

The Grand Debunk of the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down” (part 5/10)
The fifth installment in the grand debunk the antivaxxer book “Turtles All the Way Down”: Chapter 5.
Frank Han on September 7, 2023
Link

The Grand Debunk continues with chapter 5, starting with this claim and moving methodically through each subsequent false and/or deceptive claim. Let’s dig in:
1. FDA calculated, for the first time, the amount of mercury infants were receiving in routine vaccinations and discovered that the cumulative amount far exceeded the threshold considered safe by various government health agencies.
To make this statement, one has to willfully ignore all the research into the safety of this preservative used in vaccine doses. One also has to ignore the difference between ethyl and methylmercury (the former is easily removed in the body) and that the form of mercury in thiomersal is not the same as metallic mercury in a thermometer, not to mention the fact that thimerosal was removed from childhood vaccines over two decades ago, despite no consistent evidence of its harm in vaccine doses. In addition, one of the primary proponents of the idea that mercury in vaccines causes autism, Mark Geier, had his medical license suspended partially due to giving out incorrect diagnoses and conducting chemical castration without informed consent. One would think that the moral high ground would be clear, but giving out wrong diagnoses is clearly medical malpractice. One of these same citations loves to indicate high-profile cases of ethylmercury poisoning, while conveniently ignoring that the doses were far in excess to all the ethylmercury present in all the vaccines even when it was a commonplace preservative before 2001. The authors are quite hostile to the conflicts of interest of the US authors into the safety of thimerosal; however they neglect to consider that physicians from other countries also have the ability to conduct their own scientific studies and reviews to independently discuss the safety of thimerosal. Remember, national health agencies, just like any other employer, are going to employ people who have the best CV for the job – even if that means they work for the US CDC. Ultimately, the antivaxxer strategy used here is lying by omission. Moreover, we have been able request non-thimerosal containing immunizations anyway for many years.
2. If common features between the injured children emerged, they could further investigate them to identify exactly what was causing the damage – a vaccine, a particular vaccine ingredient, a combination of a vaccine and specific medical conditions, or even something unrelated to the vaccine itself. However, this line of investigation has never appealed to the medical establishment.
The problem is this is also completely untrue. The epidemiological studies for COVID vaccine myocarditis came out very quickly after the reports of myocarditis from Israel initially came out. I can actually, join in the call with other cardiologists, to request that such research be done more quickly next time. However, “never appealed” is a very specific statement, and this research alone demonstrates it is wrong. The mechanism of COVID vaccine myocarditis has now been worked out to likely at least come from a mistake in the body’s release of cytokines (one of the molecules responsible for inflammation). Common characteristics of patients getting intussusception after an older rotavirus vaccine were worked out. Neuropathy (nerve pain) after COVID vaccine has a body of research behind it. It may be lost upon the authors, but the vaccine researchers generally don’t want bad side effects for themselves or the children in their lives either. What is a legitimate point of discussion is how to get this research done more quickly and thereby, more quickly produce actionable information for the public.
3. A “safer” research approach, then, would be to fund research that would look for, and find, non-vaccine factors responsible for the adverse reactions blamed on vaccines
This is an exceptionally conspiratorial line of thinking. It is true that pharmaceutical companies prefer for their products to receive positive press and positive research. The companies after all, are indeed after sustained profits – and this description of them is correct in the book. They are obligated to produce profit for themselves and shareholders. However, the book fails to consider that it is well within the abilities for organizations not controlled by pharmaceutical companies, to conduct research. Mainstream physicians join everyone else in celebrating the removal of medications that are ultimately found to have more harm than benefit. Many of them also agree that regulators need to be more separate from the pharmaceutical companies that they regulate. This is not a difficult viewpoint to take – but, the antivax ecosystem always then leads the reader to lower quality research to mislead the audience. Again, the moral high ground should be clear – when you don’t like the research already provided, find a way to design better research or have superior scientific reasoning. After following and writing about the antivax ecosystem for a long time, Science Based Medicine has yet to observe members of the antivax ecosystem doing this. Their central dispute is that nobody wants to conduct research critical of vaccines when the factor(s) being researched are intrinsic to vaccines. Yet, there are examples of vaccines that were investigated due to safety concerns. One is the Hemophilus influenza vaccine, which was temporarily recalled in 2007 due to a suspicion for bacterial contamination, although further review found no bacterial contamination. Moderna recalled a batch of COVID vaccines from one particular manufacturer after contamination was suspected. A particular H1N1 vaccine batch set was recalled due to suspicion that it was not as potent as originally advertised. It should not be hard to figure out why even vaccine researchers themselves don’t want to give themselves RSV vaccine associated enhanced respiratory disease, or COVID vaccine myocarditis. This is why work is always ongoing to search for vaccine side effects and when possible, make things better.
4. Genes alone, as it turns out, can explain only a tiny fraction, if any, of the huge rise in the autism rate
There are whole professions dedicated to the genetic and environmental factors contributing to autism. Between these two studies alone, 245 new genes were discovered that are linked to autism. There is also spontaneous mutation – when genes change due to mistakes in the copying of those genes (or degradation over time). Some genes are clearly documented to do this. There are yet other professionals who have looked into the environmental factors associated with autism. When the narrator of this book clearly has an agenda, they will omit any research they like to fulfill that agenda. Personally, I prefer to consult professionals actually trained in the field, to tell me the ultimate causes of autism. The hardliners in the antivax ecosystem also always gloss over the simple observation that people with autism are not looking to be “fixed” or “eliminated”; they can lead full and complete lives just like those humans who don’t have autism. Moreover, the earliest changes in the brain consistent with autism have actually been detected before childbirth – while I don’t expect the general public to know this particular fact, it is hopefully obvious that vaccines cannot travel back in time to cause something before they existed.
5. Retrospective observational studies are relatively inexpensive and easier to perform. In addition, they have one more distinct feature that is crucial to the discussion that follows: Their results can be rather easily “adjusted”
It is in fact relatively simpler to perform retrospective studies, but they have clear limitations that are taught to students of medicine and epidemiology. One form of the adjustments that the authors claim to protest is p-hacking, but people who share the authors beliefs routinely engage in this type of study “adjustment”. In addition, studies done by mainstream epidemiologists are always criticized for their conflicts of interest, when studies funded by Childrens Health Defense for example, never receive that kind of negative attention from the authors (despite there being clear logical fallacies that wouldn’t even pass the authors own tests). The major techniques of research falsification are actually well documented, and I encourage the reader, if interested, to specifically read into this topic to learn how to spot falsification. It is exceptionally conspiratorial to say that the entire ecosystem of vaccine researchers is conspiring together to put out only research that is supportive of vaccines. I challenge the reader to try and get a group of physicians together to agree on what to order for lunch! The book authors clearly have not attempted to create and lead an international research collaboration – this process is described mildly as herding cats. I was part of a research study on vaccine myocarditis, and it was months of work just to get the official permission to get the study started, and we weren’t even giving people any medicines in a randomized clinical trial (this was just a retrospective observational study). Physicians and basic science researchers in this process are generally not very nice to each other when finding each others mistakes – they get caught all the time and errors are fixed. They almost get it right by the end of this chapter, saying “no conspiracy is necessary”, but then go on to imply that there are ongoing worldwide conspiracies in vaccine research.
I can easily join with the public in criticizing vaccine research failures such as the Cutter incident (which specifically was a failure in a particular batch processing but not an indictment on the overall effectiveness of the vaccine), but I encourage the reader to also be aware of much more serious kinds of vaccine falsification, like actually making fake vaccines, actually destroying vaccines, and antivax healthcare workers fraudulently injecting patients hoping for vaccination with saline. The authors of this book and organizations who think like them have a complete lack of awareness that their actions inspire people to do things like this. The most important take-home point for the reader, to address this point of the book, is that the retrospective observational study is not the only format of study available to a vaccine researcher. A vaccination can be tested multiple ways before finding out it is safe or might need to be retired. One should also be wary of an antivaxxer’s choice of the “moving goalposts” tactic – which means that as soon as one of their conditions is satisfied, they claim that another condition needs to be satisfied before they will agree that a vaccine is generally safe and effective. For a dedicated antivaxxer, the number of safe vaccines is, will be, and always has been, zero.
6. Even when researchers formally declare that they have randomly allocated subjects – for example, in selecting members of the control group in a “case-control” study – we have only their word for it.
One side of the coin is – people who commit randomization fraud before the FDA, in a clinical trial, do actually receive prison sentences and get permanently debarred from ever producing a clinical trial for them again, like what happened in the 1995 Biocryst attempt to produce a psoriasis drug. It is easy to join in public criticism of researchers who commit this degree of fraudulent research. While the true incidence remains unknown, there is still no evidence however, that this type of conduct is widespread. The other side of the coin is that statisticians and data monitoring organizations actually have several levels of protections against this. First, humans are very poor random number generators. Even a simple look through of fraudulent patient randomization assignments, may reveal lots of patients with the same birthday. Different sites being monitored by Institutional Review Boards can be flagged for protocol violations. Certain universities may develop risk scores to specifically determine if fabricated vital signs were present. Date tests can reveal a high number of data entries just on the weekends. Statistical tests can reveal number preferences, which may indicate a human was trying to enter numbers into a database rather than experimentally determine values. So, the research analysis and statistics community have many tests at their disposal to police randomized clinical trials. We do not only have to rely on the researcher’s word. If the reader is interested in formally studying this topic, s/he is encouraged to do it systematically by obtaining a research degree.
7. As such, the institutional (or business) entities in charge of allocating research budgets set their own criteria and priorities, which, of course, align with their agendas and interests. Thus, as one might expect, research money is directed toward studies that are consistent with, or at least do not oppose or contradict, the policies of the funding body.
Yes, generally research funding organizations have missions, constraints, budgetary constraints, and rules they wish for researchers to follow if they want to request funding. However, the implication that negative research cannot be published has a truth that is more complicated. Even mainstream researchers are calling for more negative research to be published (meaning research that says that something does not work). One of the most famous modern day examples of this is Merck – they could technically sell lots of hydroxychloroquine for COVID, but even the manufacturer, who should be “protecting their interests” according to the authors, explicitly warns against using hydroxychloroquine for COVID. This is despite the incessant pleas of ultra right wing physician organizations like America’s Frontline Doctor’s to the contrary. If you attempt to submit a research project to a funding organization that is trying to encourage a different type of research, your project proposal is guaranteed to be denied. That’s not censorship, despite what certain media pundits will try to tell you – the rules were transparent, and you, the researcher, refused to follow them. The consequence is that you get ignored. Those rules are applied equally to everyone. Drug companies don’t publish all their negative research, but we have research that shows a huge percentage of drug candidates fail their clinical trials. In this source alone, ten different clinical trials failed – and it clearly wasn’t censored.
8. A spokesperson for the health establishment will patiently explain that the vaccine topic is extremely complex, and the average parent simply cannot make sense of it at all.
As usual the truth is more complicated. There is general consensus now, that being patronizing to your patient is something that should be relegated to the history books. However, it remains correct that thoroughly understanding vaccine research requires a high degree of proficiency in many specialties, not limited to organic chemistry, biochemistry, epidemiology, statistics, public health, virology, microbiology, immunology and infectious disease. It is not humanly possible to just suddenly be proficient at these subjects by looking at Youtube, Paul Thomas, Jen Margulis, Bob Sears, or Rumble videos. There is a gold standard of what sincerely learning a foreign subject to a level of proficiency high enough to debate actual professionals looks like – and that is the World Science Festival. I invite the reader to focus attention on Brian Greene, the host, whose specialty is physics and mathematics. He actually prepares well enough for debates to be able to debate people who actually professionally trained in science fields other than physics and mathematics, and has an excellent command of the techniques of standardized scientific debate. Just in the same way as I would never dare to stroll into an architecture studio and suddenly proclaim I can design the new bridge, or stroll into a particle accelerator and say I know how to do the experiments better than the physicists, if I were new to vaccines, I would never dare to stroll into a infectious disease physician’s office and say I know better than they do. This isn’t a demand for the cessation of debate – this is a request to approach vaccine science the same way one would approach any new subject, with an appropriate mix of curiosity and humility. Physicians actually welcome reasoned debate according to the rules of standardized scientific debate – however the authors of this book don’t actually want that. It should not be controversial to state that parents with no training in medicine do not suddenly know better than the experts in vaccine science through reading this book. However, this is not meant as an insult – this is a request to approach vaccine science with the same humility and curiosity as any other new topic. If a parent wants to understand the science as well as a professional, there is nothing stopping the curious mind. I encourage anyone interested in learning vaccine science to go for it, but do it properly. The pathway to do it well is very clear and the same for all interested – and it contains no shortcuts. Sincere discussion with your pediatrician is welcome at all times.
9. Madsen 2002: MMR Vaccine and Autism/ CDC conflict of interest and “What stands out in the Madsen 2002 study, quite astoundingly, is that the raw data plainly contradict the study’s conclusion. The Danish data, presented in Table 2 of the paper, actually show a 45% higher risk of autism in MMR vaccinated children, compared to the non-MMR-vaccinated. Suspiciously, after the researchers manipulated the data, the trend was reversed to indicate an 8% lower risk of autism in the MMR-vaccinated children. To repeat, while the raw data imply a higher risk of autism among MMR-vaccinated children, the study’s final results indicate the opposite.”
There’s a lot to unpack here. First off, epidemiologists from different countries are going to collaborate and sometimes have employment in more than one organization. That’s been a thing since the earliest days of epidemiology, and occurs in multiple disciplines outside even outside of science. People who work in the same field are naturally going to want to collaborate professionally when there are shared interests. The authors think they have a “gotcha” here, but they most certainly do not. Next, the authors used an old antivax trope, that if only they could see the raw data all the time, they would be able to produce studies that support the antivaxxer narrative. The current mainstream medical position is that the association between MMR vaccination and autism is either zero or so small as to be practically speaking, indistinguishable from zero. Here’s why – I actually read the study. First off, there are several more modern studies (of which this is one) that refute any relationship between MMR vaccines and autism. Antivaxxers keep on trying to recycle this claim because they think some people can be duped. Next, the calculations shown in the study are only suspicious if you have no idea what you are looking at. They criticize that there is an 8 percent lower risk of autism in the MMR vaccinated children. They then fail to read the fact that the authors specifically mentioned, that they have tight confidence intervals (high confidence in the statistical result) demonstrating the two groups being compared are not statistically any different. If the editors want to be seen as having any credibility at all analyzing studies, they shouldn’t be making such a simple mistake. Let’s next look at the study and the table they are referencing:
The only pair of numbers up top that differ by 45% are the 53 and 77, which are numbers that delineate the number of children diagnosed with autism, versus the number of children with other autism spectrum disorders. Both were in the unvaccinated group. Let’s be real here – the authors can’t even distinguish the vaccinated from the unvaccinated groups correctly when reading a study. These two points alone should trash their claims.
10. And, of course, there wasn’t a single word about the awkward fact that the study didn’t actually investigate the question the media claimed it had definitively answered: Could “too many vaccines” be causing autism?
News media incorrectly describing scientific research papers is a genuine problem and a valid criticism. However, the reader should also be aware that the antivax ecosystem has been complaining about the number of vaccines for several decades without any evidence that it is “too many”. This particular claim is discussed in detail here, author credits to Skeptical Raptor. One can also logically think through the study here, without complaining about the conflicts of interest and directly thinking through the core claims.
11. The antigen is just one of numerous substances inside a vaccine vial. Vaccines typically contain a host of other ingredients that serve various functions, such as preservatives, stabilizers, adjuvants, and more. Some of these ingredients are known to be highly toxic (aluminum, mercury) or carcinogenic (formaldehyde). The adverse biological effects this conglomeration of biological and chemical ingredients could potentially have on an infant’s body have never been studied in depth, not individually and not in combination.
Except, they have been studied in depth and in combination. The antivax ecosystem here is trying to scare people by scaring them about chemicals. In reality, a chemist (such as myself, a BSc in Chemistry/ Biochemistry) could tell you that we are all made of chemicals. If chemicals didn’t exist we wouldn’t exist. Also, the dose makes the poison – even air and water can damage the body in large quantities. Formaldehyde is naturally produced by the body as well as by certain plants that we eat (pears for example) (citation Lehninger’s Biochemistry). The pear contains more formaldehyde than exists in all the vaccines added together. It doesn’t matter which pear brand. One can get toxic effects from formaldehyde, from repeated workplace exposure – but clearly the vast majority of the population does not work with containers of the stuff. Pure mercury is never placed in vaccines – thiomersal does exist these days, but only in the multi-dose flu vaccine which a parent can ask to be replaced with a single dose flu vaccine. Mercury and thiomersal are not the same thing. Aluminium adjuvants have been studied quite exhaustively. Two sources on this exist here and here.
12. In order to assess the strength of the immune response elicited by vaccines, whatever that actually means, one must include the adjuvant in the calculation in one way or another. Similarly, it is not unreasonable to assume that other vaccine ingredients may also affect the level of antigenic stimulation induced by the vaccine. Yet, despite the key role adjuvants play in the strength of immune response to vaccines, they are not even mentioned in the paper.
There is a simple principle of vaccine regulation here – despite the exhortations of the authors and their colleagues, every vaccine component does not need to be tested every single time a new vaccine is made with that adjuvant or excipient. An introduction to vaccine adjuvant science is here. The next principle to think of, at least in relation to aluminium adjuvant, is that it has been in vaccines for around 50 years. The phase 3 clinical trials do exactly what the authors claim isn’t being done – test complete vaccines including their adjuvants. It took vaccine science to figure out that some vaccines just don’t work without adjuvants.
13. The trick, it seems, was to assign controls who were at least as sick as their matching cases, just with different diseases. If that’s the case, considering that the Gardasil vaccination rate was slightly higher in the control group, it seems that the study’s raw data indicate that Gardasil probably is a risk factor for autoimmune disease. But the authors, delivering on their employer’s promise to make customers’ products look good, masterfully buried this result under heaping piles of deceptive statistics.
The core premise here does have a little bit of basis in reality – in that autoimmunity after exposure to HPV proteins has been demonstrated theoretically in animal models and through some basic science projects. This cannot be eliminated entirely, as proteins have a limited number of basic building blocks which repeat some of the time (to build the basic structures of proteins). So, the prospect of entirely eliminating molecular mimicry is probably biologically impossible. However, unlike the viewpoint espoused by Yehuda Shoenfeld, such links must then be tested in the real world with some version of clinical studies. Lets pretend for a minute that the Grimaldi study is too tainted by conflicts of interest to be believable. The other question to ask yourself – if you were able to get a straightforward blood test in the future that predicted your autoimmune risk after HPV vaccination, would you then consent to HPV infection and all its consequences, if your test came up that you had that gene? Full informed consent would actually discuss this perspective as well. We do have a study from Denmark in 2022 describing autoimmune markers found in patients with suspected neurological symptoms but not in those without neurological symptoms (after HPV vaccine). However, much larger, earlier population studies, done with better statistical methods, support there being no overall link. This likely means one of two things – there are so many recipients of HPV immunization that the overall rate of people experiencing these sorts of complications may be a nonzero number, but it is very very tiny. It is also plausible that the genetic predisposition to autoimmunity was already there but some people happened to have it show up after this immunization. The benefit to the individual man or woman in the reduction of anal, oral, and cervical cancer, though, is extremely clear. Also, remember that carrying autoimmune markers by itself does not imply a clinical diagnosis of autoimmune disease, as some autoimmune markers against nerves are actually markers of nerve repair. Read the next paragraph if you want the more detailed molecular explanation, and click here if you want a very detailed deep dive courtesy of Ed Nirenberg –
L1 protein is the main surface protein of the HPV virus, and it is slightly different between the many different types of HPV virus. The modern HPV vaccine typically carries 9 different L1 proteins, to help women be immune against most types of HPV that actually cause human disease (although the lack of some variants is a recognized deficiency of this vaccination). There are also several interior proteins that form the inside structure of the virus. The claim that keeps getting recycled is an incorrect interpretation of the known biochemistry of this virus – the authors repeatedly reference Shoenfeld’s claim that there is molecular mimicry, between body proteins, and the L1 protein of HPV, on the basis of comparison of protein structure (specifically the amino acids themselves). The bits of protein being compared between HPV L1 and the human body are short – the pure act of protein comparison is legitimate, and a commonly used technique in my world (the chemistry/ biochemistry lab). However, the Shoenfeld group fails to realize that their technique should also yield molecular mimicry between the HPV proteins not included in the vaccine versus the body. It should be straightforward to see here, that if a protein is not included in the vaccine, it cannot place the human recipient at risk of molecular mimicry. Also, the claim that HPV vaccine causes brain or nervous system injury in mice, literally does not directly carry over to humans (mice experiments are a reasonable starting point but their findings do not necessarily extend directly to humans).
14. The McKeever 2004 study demonstrates how researchers whose work could potentially provide valuable clues to advance understanding of serious and unexplained medical conditions – the soaring allergy rate, in this case – are quick to dismiss obvious conclusions if they are harmful to vaccines’ reputation.
One can reach this conclusion if the authors just read one study and fail to read any others. The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia has looked into the relationship, by reviewing all the major studies looking at allergy and its relationship to vaccines, and there is none. There are also professional allergists and pulmonologists looking into the immune mechanisms of allergy and asthma. I don’t know about you, but if I want to hear about a completely new topic, I prefer hearing about it from people who study it professionally as a starting point.
15. No matter how contorted or fallacious a study may be, it will receive full support from the medical establishment as long as it supports the vaccine safety dogma.
In the antivaxxer ecosystem, there has yet to be one prominent figure, who thoughtfully analyzes the results of a study that goes contrary to antivaxxer dogma. Again, one would think that the moral high ground would be obvious, but it is not. One only has to do a quick search on Pubmed and Google to see all the vaccine candidates that failed or otherwise had their approval withdrawn.
16. At the BMJ,” he writes, “we did several studies where we inserted major errors into papers that we then sent to many reviewers. Nobody ever spotted all of the errors. Some reviewers did not spot any, and most reviewers spotted only about a quarter.
The peer review process actually deserves reform for many reasons! Most mainstream researchers know at least one thing they want to change about peer review and this is one of those things. This is one of the small number of statements that is accurate in this book. We can agree on criticizing legitimate shortcomings of peer review.
17. Do you know who funds most vaccine safety research? Are you familiar with the process used to allocate medical research grants?
Being a physician is not a competition to see who can memorize the most things. If you want to seek out someone with this talent, seeking out a lawyer is more appropriate. A physician is generally not going to have the funder of every journal article they ever read, memorized. However, we are quite capable of making decisions on conflicts of interest and discussing journal articles in a group. If this is a concern the reader has, they are welcome to discuss it with their physician. Most physicians have a general idea on research grant allocation but only those who actually had to create research grants in medical school, will have the most detailed information. A lack of memorization alone is not sufficient to make a physician suboptimal.
18. Would you expect pharmaceutical companies and government agencies to fund vaccine safety studies that could potentially find serious faults in the vaccines they manufacture, license, and recommend to the public?
This is not the gotcha Mary Holland thinks it is. It only takes a brief Google or Pubmed search to find all the funded studies that resulted in vaccine withdrawal or stopping a vaccine candidate.
19. Are you aware that studies published in leading medical journals which ostensibly confirm the safety of vaccines suffer from serious methodological flaws and are fraught with authors’ conflicts of interest?
The definition of conflict of interest here, is very important. Based upon the author’s statements above, they believe anyone who works with the CDC, even peripherally, has a conflict of interest. The authors have no better solution for the massive amount of funds required to research a vaccine well and bring it to market following all US FDA regulations. The circle of people who are qualified enough to be a vaccine researcher for the CDC is small – this is why the same names come up again and again. The author can’t even read a data table correctly on the MMR study above, but thinks this counts as a methodological error. With the lack of ability to even have a rational definition of conflict of interest, the author’s viewpoint is clear – no study speaking to vaccine safety is acceptable. It would be against their financial interest to say anything good about vaccines. This is not a rational position for a scientist to take. Even the editor, Mary Holland, exhorts the reader to always be ready to overturn a paradigm.Overall, this chapter attempted to show that epidemiological studies are purposefully biased. Due to all the points addressed above, the authors actually succeeded in a separate goal – burying their heads in the sand. If the authors combine an exceptionally conspiratorial view of the world with either a poor understanding of the actual vaccine papers or a total lack of effort in actually reading those papers, they can come to any conclusions they like. We have standardized rules of scientific investigation and debate for a reason – one of the biggest reasons is to eliminate a place where malicious actors may make false claims or falsify research. Just one point that stands out – the authors sincerely believe that vaccine trials will always get “rubber stamped” if they support the safety dogma. A big problem with that line of thinking – vaccine and new drug trials fail all the time. The authors didn’t even try to look at these studies. All are welcome at the table of vaccine debate, and in fact, despite the exhortations of the authors, the debate occurs amongst professionals in the field, all the time. The admissions price to the debate is the same for everyone though – one needs to have a good working understanding of the basic scientific principles governing the field (or at least give an honest attempt to achieve that good working understanding). The methods and techniques in vaccine science research are standardized for patient safety, and the authors are not permitted to invent their own rules on a whim. The point about the Madsen article is worth revisiting here – the mistake the Turtles authors made in their discussion is so fundamental that it is generally corrected in college level science courses (and maybe even high school). That they make no attempt to honestly engage with the merits of the article is very telling as to their true intentions. They just gave an entire lesson on epidemiology in Chapter 4 – one would think they would be competent enough to at least try to read vaccine research articles with logical reasoning by the next chapter. They appear to have fallen asleep at their own lesson.
Thus endeth the debunk of Chapter 5.

PREVENTION

As imperfect as they are, public health interventions save lives
On Friday, JAMA Health Forum published a study that is just more evidence that public health interventions against COVID-19 saved lives.
David Gorski on July 29, 2024
Link

One of the developments during the COVID-19 pandemic that, I must admit, I did not foresee was the rapid development of widespread resistance to mask mandates leading to their rapid politicization, with most of the resistance coming from the right. I should not have been blindsided; that I was surprised was a result of my not having been sufficiently aware of history, given that during the influenza pandemic of 1918 there arose similar resistance to masking and mask mandates, but, of course, in 1918 there was no mass media beyond newspapers and other publications, nor was there the Internet or social media. Of course, it wasn’t just resistance to masking that became an issue during the most recent pandemic; it was resistance to public health interventions in general, including mask mandates, restrictions on public gatherings, and, of course, vaccines. Of these, I realized that the antivaccine movement would quickly transfer its old misinformation, disinformation, tropes, pseudoscience, and conspiracy theories to the new COVID-19 vaccines, and so it did. However, it was broader than that. It was about public health, with resistance to vaccines being part of the entire package of resistance to other public health interventions, such as mask mandates, school closures, business closures, and restrictions on public gatherings.
Of course, COVID-19 was a novel organism when it spread from its initial outbreak in Wuhan, China to the rest of the world to become a pandemic. There were no vaccines, nor were there any effective treatments other than supportive care. For the most severely ill patients, treatment consisted of basically supporting the patient and treating the compilations, hoping to keep the patient alive as long as possible to allow the lungs and body to recover. However, the novelty of the virus did not mean that it was so completely novel and different from existing respiratory viruses that nothing we knew before about public health was applicable anymore. It was a respiratory disease, spread by respiratory droplets and aerosols. It was a coronavirus, and we knew a lot about coronaviruses, particularly given the close call we had with SARS in 2002-2003. There was a long and extensive public health literature and considerable experience in dealing with infectious respiratory viral diseases. In brief, it was not necessary to reinvent the wheel.
That’s why, while perusing my usual sources for knowledge, monitoring quacks and antivaxxers, and blog fodder, a study published on Friday in JAMA Health Forum, entitled US State Restrictions and Excess COVID-19 Pandemic Deaths. Some of the descriptions of the study were a bit…hyperbolic, for instance:
"These study findings do not support the views of those opposing COVID-19 restrictions who erroneously believe the restrictions did not work. To the contrary, the package of policies implemented by some states probably saved many lives."https://t.co/IBYHKZzcbh
— Barry Hunt – #DavosSafe #WHOknew (@BarryHunt008) July 27, 2024
Others were more straightforward:
If all 50 states + DC had adopted the most restrictive COVID-19 measures, excess mortality would have been 10-21% lower New modeling work by @christopherruhm in @JAMAHealthForumLINK: https://t.co/UbYkdmfQ5q pic.twitter.com/code835s5A
— Kevin Griffith (@AssumeNormality) July 26, 2024
One thing that caught my eye about the study was that it is a single author study. This is a pretty rare thing these days. The other thing that caught my eye was that it was by an economist, Christopher J. Ruhm, although he is a health policy economist and the study did follow Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) reporting guideline for cross-sectional studies.
In the introduction, Ruhm basically says what I said above, just with references:
US states swiftly responded to the emergence of COVID-19 by implementing a variety of policies including initial emergency declarations, diverse forms of shutdowns and, later, mask and vaccine mandates. The initial actions were almost universal,1 but opposition to these measures quickly developed.2,3 This dissent spilled into the political arena where Republican governors and legislatures in multiple states limited the authority of public health officials and banned mask and vaccine mandates.4,5
Numerous studies have evaluated the impact of policies designed to mitigate the COVID-19 pandemic.6–8 Early analyses suggested that strong social distancing measures curtailed the initial spread of COVID-19,9,10 with evidence of interactive effects between public and private mitigation efforts.11 However, the specific modeling assumptions and design criteria of some of these studies have been questioned,3,12,13 and these analyses generally covered only the initial stages of the pandemic.
I can’t help but note that limiting the authority of public health officials has long been a goal of the antivaccine movement, dating back years before the pandemic. Indeed, several years ago, as measles outbreaks were popping up again as the result of low MMR vaccine uptake, Republicans in my own state tried to pass a bill that would have sharply limited the power of local public health officials to act during an outbreak, including their power to keep unvaccinated children out of school, an incident that I once sarcastically referred to as “make measles great again,” given that it happened early in the first Trump administration. In any event, during COVID-19, there was a stark difference between “red” and “blue” states in terms of mask mandates, “shutdowns,” and vaccine mandates.
This study specifically looked at seven state activity limitations passed early in the pandemic, including stay-at-home orders; restaurant, bar, leisure activity, primary school, and higher education closures; and restrictions on public gatherings, data obtained from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME). In addition, three behaviors were examined, including the percentage of the population completing a primary COVID-19 vaccination series and the the percentage of days individuals stated that they always wore a mask outside their home. In addition:
The percentage of the analysis period during which all states required individuals to wear masks when outside of the home was calculated using information from Ballotpedia35; for the District of Columbia, data were from the IHME.34 Kaiser Family Foundation data36 were used to construct variables indicating whether state government or school employees were required to be vaccinated as of February 2022, whether there were school mask requirements, and whether there were prohibitions on government vaccine or school mask mandates.
Actual behaviors were also examined:
Three behaviors were examined. CDC vaccination data37 were used to calculate the percentage of the population completing a primary COVID-19 vaccination series. The percentage of days individuals stated that they always wore a mask outside their home (mask use) was obtained from IHME.34 Reductions in time outside the home compared with the prepandemic period (mobility reductions) came from Opportunity Insights.38
The time period chosen for correlating public health policies with excess death rates was chosen to be July 2020 to June 2022, because before July 2020 state restrictions and public health policies were very similar across all states; it was the summer of 2020 when policies started to diverge between “red” and “blue” states, as explained in the introduction:
An additional challenge is that initial COVID-19 exposure was concentrated in a small number of locations: primarily New York state, its surrounding states, and Massachusetts. These initial infection rates were probably largely idiosyncratic, reflecting factors such as having high population densities, being travel destinations, and making extensive use of public transportation.16–18 During this early period, policy variation across states was limited1 and the lethality of COVID-19 was especially high19 because medical professionals had little experience with and few tools available to treat severe COVID-19 infections. Consequently, studies containing data for the early pandemic period, such as those examining the overall performance of states20 or groups of policy responses,21 faced particular challenges. Reverse causation also may have been problematic given that states with the worst initial conditions were likely to have implemented the most restrictive policies.22 Moreover, restrictions were often introduced as packages, which made it difficult to disentangle specific policy effects.
And as documented in the discussion:
Considerable policy variation emerged in the second half of 2020, with states reducing or eliminating activity limitations and, somewhat later, mask requirements. Mobility reductions also declined rapidly during this period, as did mask use after the start of 2021. Vaccinations first became available in December 2020 and quickly became widespread, but with considerable geographic heterogeneity. Activity limitations had been essentially phased out by June 2021 and mask requirements by March 2022, at which point 23 and 11 states had instituted vaccination mandates for state and school employees, respectively, and 15 states had mandated masks in schools. Conversely, 13 states had prohibited vaccination mandates and 7 had outlawed school mask requirements (eTable 3 in Supplement 1).
I think it’s worth looking at eTable 3, just to see the variability between states in policies after July 2020:
That’s a wide array of public health interventions and a wide variability in what was permitted in various states. So how did this correlate to excess deaths? In brief, Ruhm began the analysis approximately 4 months after the first COVID-19 deaths in the US to mitigate what he describes as the “largely idiosyncratic variation at the start of the pandemic.” He then looked at excess deaths, age-standardized excess death rates per 100 000, and excess death ratios, using using state-level mortality and population data from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention for 2017 to 2019 as baseline to compare the excess death rates from 2020 to 2022. Moreover, his primary analysis focused less on individual policies, but on packages of “weak” versus “strong” public health interventions, defined thusly:
Therefore, particular emphasis was placed on results for packages of weak and strong restrictions, where the former (latter) were calculated using population-weighted averages for the 10 states with the lowest (highest) overall restriction scores. Specifically, weak restrictions referred to activity limitation scores and mask requirements of 0.80 and 1.41 SDs less than the national average; no vaccine or mask mandates; and vaccine and school mask prohibition values of 0.79 and 0.75, respectively. Strong restrictions referred to activity limitation scores and mask requirements of 1.07 and 1.26 SDs, respectively, greater than the national average; universal school and state vaccination mandates and school mask requirements; and no vaccine or mask mandate prohibitions (eTable 1 in Supplement 1).
This brings us to the “money figure,” Figure 3:
The overall figure shows the estimated age-standardized excess death rates and ratios from July 2020 to June 2022 for states with weak and strong COVID-19 restrictions, and differences between them. Weak restrictions refer to population-weighted average values of standardized activity limitations scores, standardized mask requirements, mask and vaccination mandates, and state prohibitions on vaccination mandates and mask mandates in schools for the 10 states with the lowest overall restriction scores. Strong restrictions refer to corresponding population-weighted averages for the 10 states with the highest overall restriction scores. These are estimated from population-weighted regressions of the outcomes on these variables and excess death rates or ratios from March 2020 to June 2020 (N = 51). Behavior shows the estimated age-standardized excess death rates and ratios from July 2020 to June 2022 due to behaviors responses associated with weak and strong COVID-19 restrictions. The behaviors include mask use, mobility reductions, and vaccination rates. These are estimated from population-weighted regressions of behaviors on restrictions and of excess death rates and ratios on the corresponding behaviors with additional controls for excess death rates or ratios from March 2020 to June 2020. For calculating marginal effects, estimated values of behaviors from the first set of regressions are used in the second stage. Error bars show 95% CIs based on standard errors.
Continuing the analysis, Ruhm tries to estimate how many more people would have died if all 50 states had adopted the “weak” restrictions and how many lives might have been saved if all 50 states had instituted “strong” restrictions, leading to the second “money chart,” this table:
These analyses led the Ruhm to observe:
Using the primary specifications, the estimates suggested that if all states had weak restrictions, there would have been 1.3 million to 1.4 million excess deaths from July 2020 to June 2022, that is, 271 000 to 447 000 more than estimated with universal strong restrictions, a 25% to 48% difference (Table). Compared to the 1.18 million actual excess deaths over the study period, weak restrictions in all states would have resulted in an estimated 13% to 17% increase, and strong restrictions in a 10% to 21% decrease. Behavioral changes were associated with 49% to 79% of the overall restriction premia (Table and Figure 4; eTable 9 in Supplement 1).
Interestingly, not all polices were as strongly associated with higher or lower excess death rates, as Ruhm notes in the discussion, even as he correctly and emphatically points out that his study does not support the resistance view that COVID-19 public health interventions do not work:
These study findings do not support the views of those opposing COVID-19 restrictions who erroneously believe the restrictions did not work. To the contrary, the package of policies implemented by some states probably saved many lives. However, all restrictions were not equally successful. Evidence of protective effects was weakest for activity limitations. This may have partially concealed benefits at the start of the pandemic, before the analysis period, or reflected reverse causation given that most activity limitations were implemented before political considerations dominated, when states were likely to be especially responsive to local variations in infection rates.
I also note that Ruhm did not downplay or deny the potential costs of the public health interventions described, contrary to the caricature of public health advocates promulgated by those opposed to public health interventions as people who don’t give a rodential posterior about the harm caused by business and school closures, limitation of nonurgent care at hospitals, and the like. He even notes that “reductions were not necessarily sufficient to justify imposing restrictions because they also imposed a variety of costs,” pointing to harms to educational attainment caused by school closures, as well as harms in terms of financial loss and social isolation, particularly in nursing home patients, caused by “lockdowns,” even as he notes that harms from “loss of liberty” that can’t really be precisely valued. Being an economist, Ruhm couldn’t help but put things in more financial terms than I as a physician like, noting that “using value of statistical life estimates ranging from $4.7 million to $11.6 million,42,43 the estimated lives saved from strong (vs weak) restrictions over the 2-year period were worth $1.3 trillion to $5.2 trillion—6% to 22% of 2021 gross domestic product—providing a possible benchmark against which to evaluate this loss.”
Overall, to me this study is pretty strong evidence that longstanding public health science did not have to be reinvented at the beginning of the pandemic and that standard interventions for infectious viral diseases worked for COVID-19, no matter how much advocates of “natural herd immunity” and antivaxxers—but I repeat myself—try to argue otherwise. The study is not without weaknesses, obviously. No study is. For instance, this is a cross-sectional study and therefore can’t directly demonstrate causation, and the study design was at the state level, which meant that the study could not identify effects due to the polices of local governments. Also, since policies were often introduced as “packages,” it was difficult to assign importance to individual policies. Timing of policy implementation wasn’t always clear, either. Even so, I have to agree with Ruhm that his study is persuasive evidence that “strong COVID-19 restrictions saved lives and that the death toll was probably considerably higher than it would otherwise have been in states that resisted imposing these restrictions, banned their use, or implemented them for only relatively short periods of time.”
As I wrote this on Sunday, I was rather surprised at how little discussion I found regarding this study from the usual sources that I would have expected to be attacking it. I didn’t even find much on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, where I would have expected to find a lot of the usual suspects piling on, trying to find any flaw that they could. The vast majority of the posts on X were either positive or just neutral postings of a link to the study and a story about it. It’s been two days since the study was published; that’s usually plenty of time for Brownstone Institute flacks, “Sensible Medicine” brave mavericks, and antivaxxers to have come up with long rants about how bad the study has. I don’t know whether the lack of such attacks means that they haven’t found a good attack yet or that, for some reason, they haven’t really noticed the study even though it was published in a JAMA journal. What I do know is that thesis yet more evidence that public health interventions work and that failure to adhere to them is associated with unnecessary death and morbidity.

The Great Barrington Declaration Wasn’t a Plan For Public Health Officials. It Was a List of Absurd Demands of Them.
The authors of the GBD advised and influenced many politicians at the highest level. They claim to have delineated many practical policies to protect the vulnerable, and they said it would’ve been possible, certainly. So an obvious question emerges. Why didn’t they protect the vulnerable?
Jonathan Howard on February 23, 2024
Link

“During high transmission times, older people should be offered home delivery of groceries and other essentials.”
The protocol for one of the COVID vaccine trials was 414 pages of dense policies and procedures. This is the kind of serious document that serious scientists produce when actually they intend for their plan to be acted on in the real-world.
With this in mind, let’s consider the plan to to “protect the vulnerable”, which was the pillar of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). How might we have accomplished this laudable goal? Though many people thought the best way to protect the vulnerable was to limit spread of COVID and vaccinate as many people as possible, the GBD claimed that by spreading the virus among hundreds of millions of unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans, herd immunity would arrive in 3-6 months, and the pandemic would be “naturally over.” While “not vulnerable” people lived in a world of pure COVID, “vulnerable” people would be locked down in a world of zero COVID. The only tasks were identifying “vulnerable” and “not vulnerable” people and creating an impenetrable wall between them.
A section of the GBD titled Protecting the Old and Other High-Risk Groups laid out their “plan”, which they called “focused protection”. You should take 5 minutes and read it. It’s just 880-words long. Their answer to the question “How do we protect older people living at home?” was only four sentences long. It turns out, the GBD wasn’t a serious plan for public health officials, it was just a laundry list of demands of them.
Many of the GBD’s demands were banal and obvious. As Gideon Meyerowitz- Katz wrote:
Of the 19 policies proposed on the GBD website itself, 13 were commonplace, boring recommendations that virtually every developed country in the world implemented in March/April 2020. These are the sort of bland and obvious stuff that public health departments tried to promote at the very start, like “test people who are at high risk” or “meet outside to lower your risk of infection”. That they form the vast majority of suggestions that made up Focused Protection gives us some insight into how useless the policy was and still is.
However, many of their other demands sounded great, but left out a few details- kind of like a coach whose game plan is to “score more points than the other guys.” It’s certainly not the wrong plan, but it’s not a good plan, and his team will lose. To pick just one example, the GBD wrote that “During high transmission times, older people should be offered home delivery of groceries and other essentials.”
That sounds nice, but it’s worth thinking seriously about this part of their “plan” for a moment, something the authors of the GBD clearly did not do. Creating a program overnight to deliver fresh food and other essentials to tens of millions of seniors for months on end while the virus spread uncontrolled would not be an easy task. There are many opportunities for things to go wrong. Who would identify the homebound vulnerable? How would they create their shopping lists? What if seniors weren’t internet savvy? How would the funding structure be arranged? What if the people who were supposed to be delivering food were themselves sick with COVID or caring for a sick relative? What if they turned out to be scammers who left seniors hungry? What if seniors refused the service and went to crowded grocery stores anyway while the virus was raging? What about younger people with underlying medical conditions? Who would determine who qualified for this program?
In an interview from October 2021, a year after the publication of the GBD, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya sought to answer these questions by saying:
We could have offered free DoorDash to older people. I mean, yeah, it would depend on the community and the living circumstances. It would be a local thing, right?
This was obviously something Dr. Bhattacharya just thought of off the top of his head. The idea of millions of homebound seniors surviving off DoorDash for months on end is something a high school student might come up with, and it shows how little thought the authors of the GBD put into their declaration, especially considering delivering groceries and other essentials to homebound seniors was just one of many tasks public health officials were supposed to accomplish as the virus raged.
None of this stopped the authors of the GBD from making very bolds claim about their list of demands, however. Without any evidence, the GBD flatly stated that it was “possible to shift infection risk from high-risk older adults to low-risk younger adults”. It claimed public health professionals could do easily this if they tried. It said:
A comprehensive and detailed list of measures, including approaches to multi-generational households, can be implemented, and is well within the scope and capability of public health professionals.
Of course, the authors of the GBD didn’t have to actually do anything themselves, not even lobby governments for home delivery of groceries and other essentials. Once they wrote the words “During high transmission times, older people should be offered home delivery of groceries and other essentials“, they had just one job, to make endless media appearances congratulating themselves for their “plan” and to convince the public it was all well within the scope and capability of public health professionals.
Meanwhile, it was up to public health officials to convert the GBD’s demands into reality. It was their job to actually get groceries and other essentials into the hands of older people. Though the authors of the GBD boasted, “we have delineated many practical policies” to protect the vulnerable, this wasn’t close to true. Anyone who actually wanted to implement their “plan” wouldn’t have a clue what their first step might actually be. Indeed, two years after the publication of the GBD, Dr. Bhattacharya backtracked and admitted the hollowness at the its core by saying:
I think that was probably the most legitimate criticism of the, of the Great Barrington Declaration is how do you do focused protection? Now, the Great Barrington Declaration was a one page document. It wasn’t aimed at producing a comprehensive strategy for—a detailed tactical strategy for how to do focused protection in every single setting. What it was, was, was a change in principles, how we are managing the pandemic and an invitation to discussion and thinking and creative thinking by local public health. Right? So we gave some suggestions for how this might be accomplished in some settings, right? So for instance, in dense urban settings with lots of multigenerational homes, it might have involved making hotel rooms available for older people who live in multigenerational homes.
So they’ve, if someone is exposed in the house, they can call local public health. Local public health, then offers them hotel room for a few days until they get cleared. Or organizing home deliveries. It would’ve been difficult no matter what, especially in very, very crowded places, very, very poor places, without the vaccine. But it would, I think it would’ve been possible, certainly.
It wasn’t possible actually, which is why the GBD can’t point to anywhere in the world where “focused protection” was a success. Sweden couldn’t avoid the restrictions they opposed, and the Delta variant pummeled Florida immediately after Dr. Bhattacharya falsely told its citizens “we have protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population.” Obviously, nowhere achieved herd immunity in 3-6 months through the mass infection of unvaccinated youth as the GBD promised.
“Why didn’t they just protect the vulnerable and get on with life?”
However, the fundamental futility of the GBD was a feature, not a bug. First, it provided a fig leaf to shield against accusations that the GBD was a “let it rip” strategy. After all, they wrote the words, “older people should be offered home delivery of groceries and other essentials“.
Second, it provided a scapegoat. Indeed, when overwhelmed, underfunded, and besieged public health officials invariably failed to meet the GBD’s many demands, the authors of the GBD blamed them. It was as if our coach, the one whose plan was to “score more points than the other guys,” berated his players after their inevitable loss by saying “I told you exactly what to do.”
Dr. Bhattacharya, for example, said their failure to implement his demands “was a failure of imagination on the part of public health“. He scolded them further, saying the reaction of the “public health community was to just to throw up their hands and say, ‘We can’t do it.'” On social media, he asked “why didn’t they just protect the vulnerable and get on with life?“, as if there was no difference between writing the words “older people should be offered home delivery of groceries and other essentials” and actually delivering groceries and other essentials.
This is how the slogan “protect the vulnerable” morphed from a half-baked “plan” into a battering ram to repeatedly attack public health officials and convince the public they were incompetent and indifferent to the suffering of the vulnerable. As measles cases ramp up around the world, the purposeful undermining of public health as a valid concept will be the lasting legacy of the GBD.
Of course, the authors of the GBD advised and influenced many politicians at the highest level. They met with President Trump and his Health and Human Services Secretary, Alex M. Azar. Dr. Scott Atlas brought their ideas to the White House, and Dr. Bhattacharya said it was “an absolute honor” to work with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. They claim to have delineated many practical policies to protect the vulnerable, and they said it would’ve been possible, certainly. So an obvious question emerges.
Why didn’t they just protect the vulnerable?
Side note: I invite you all to listen to my podcast with science writer Wendy Orent discussing these topics.

Old antivax tropes never die: “COVID theater,” “Urgency of Normal,” and the Great Barrington Declaration
Last week, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis held a roundtable calling to “end COVID-19 theater” that brought together the Great Barrington Declaration and “Urgency of Normal,” a movement to end mask mandates and other COVID-19 mitigations in schools. The arguments used long predate the pandemic and echo a dark side of the history of American medicine.
David Gorski on March 14, 2022
Link

As I tried to figure out what to write about today, I had a number of ideas. However, reading Dr. Jonathan Howard’s post yesterday about the consequences of a medical myth reminded me of a topic that I had been meaning to write about, parts of which I’ve alluded to on a number of occasions, but that I’ve never quite come out and explicitly written about in a way that I’ve meant to. I’m referring yet again about how “everything old is new again” in antivaccine messaging, this time around the idea that children don’t need to be vaccinated against a potentially deadly disease because the disease “only” kills a relatively small number of them. As I will show, this is not a new antivax talking point. The exact same argument has been used by antivaxxers to oppose vaccinating against, for example, measles going back years and years. Indeed, I now like to ask those who argue against vaccinating children against COVID-19 if they also oppose vaccinating against measles and chickenpox. (I’ll explain more explicitly why in the second half of this post.) It is also, at its heart, a deeply eugenicist viewpoint, as I will also argue near the end.
In the meantime, let’s start out with some context, conveniently provided in a widely publicized event that also prodded me to address this topic. Recall that Dr. Howard’s post was about the myth that “healthy children” simply do not die of COVID-19. Echoing that myth was an event that took place a week ago today, namely Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’ “roundtable” that he called The Curtain Close on COVID Theater. During that staged event, Florida’s Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo shocked public health officials by announcing that the State of Florida does not recommend vaccinating children 5-11 against COVID-19. In doing so, he used almost exactly the talking point I’m describing, namely that the risk of children dying from COVID-19 is so low that vaccinating them is not justified:
But it was not until the very end of this 90-minute event that Ladapo abruptly shared his news, telling the viewing audience: “The Florida Department of Health is going to be the first state to officially recommend against the Covid-19 vaccines for healthy children.” He did not elaborate on it or explain how this decision had been reached, when it would be official or what led to this decision. Later Monday, DeSantis clarified that Florida parents would have the choice, but he added: “We are not just going to follow the CDC in the state of Florida. … We’re going to do our own stuff.”
Whatever misfires in messaging that the CDC might have demonstrated during the pandemic, its recommendation that children ages 5-11 be vaccinated against COVID-19 was not one of them. Let’s just say that Dr. Ladapo is not a particularly reliable person to be making such a decision, particularly given his history and his membership in the COVID-19 grifting group America’s Frontline Doctors. Recall that America’s Frontline Doctors first came to prominence in July 2020 when they held a press conference to tout hydroxychloroquine as a highly effective treatment for COVID-19 and that Dr. Ladapo appeared in the infamous video from that press conference with Dr. Stella Immanuel, a quack who believes that a wide variety of gynecological complaints derive from “demonic seed” inserted in sleeping women when they dream about sex with demons, hence her designation as the “demon sperm” doctor. Although it is not clear whether Dr. Ladapo is still a member of America’s Frontline Doctors, since then the group has sued over supposed deaths from COVID-19 vaccines and been busted running a telehealth prescription mill for ivermectin, which is, as I like to say, the new hydroxychloroquine in that it is a repurposed drug that doesn’t work against COVID-19.
With that background, here’s the video of Gov. DeSantis’ “roundtable”:
It’s also on Facebook:
Note the tagline: “Governor DeSantis hosts a roundtable with physicians nationwide on ending COVID theater once and for all.”” Also note the talking point: COVID-19 mitigations are now “COVID-19 theater.” Before I go on, I can’t help but mention how about a week before his roundtable Gov. DeSantis berated high school students at an event for continuing to wear masks, contemptuously referring to wearing masks as “ridiculous” and condescendingly and sarcastically saying, “Honestly, it’s not doing anything, and we gotta stop with this COVID theater. So if you want to wear it, fine, but this is ridiculous.” It’s a talking point, but of course I can’t help but think: Project much? After all, this roundtable was primo “COVID theater.”
The players and the message
Before moving on to the messaging and how the idea that we should not vaccinate children because “not that many of them die” of a disease is a longstanding antivax trope, it’s useful to point out briefly which physicians were invited and agreed to participate in this “roundtable” discussion. First, all three authors of the Great Barrington Declaration were there by Zoom: Oxford University theoretical epidemiologist Sunetra Gupta; Stanford University health policy professor Jay Bhattacharya; and Harvard University biostatistician Martin Kulldorff. I’ve written about the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) a number of times before. In brief, the GBD is a statement that was published a couple of months before COVID-19 vaccines started being distributed under an emergency use authorization (EUA) that advocated a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic. The GBD was written at the behest of the libertarian free market think tank American Institute for Economic Research (AIER). In brief, Martin Kulldorff,, after having been invited to meet with AIER editorial director Jeffrey Tucker, lawyer Stacey Rudin, and AIER officials at a weekend conference, soon enthusiastically spearheaded an effort to promote an “anti-lockdown” message advocating a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic. The result was another weekend conference at AIER headquarters, to which Kulldorff invited Gupta and Bhattacharya and AIER invited sympathetic journalists and scientists. The result was the GBD, which was birthed at a second weekend conference held at AIER headquarters in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, hence the name. (Tucker even bragged about contributing to its drafting.)
Also featured at the roundtable was Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg. We last met Dr. Høeg when she coauthored a really bad manuscript that was published as a preprint and represented a dumpster dive into the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) database and was widely criticized, including right here on SBM, thus doing the same thing that antivaxxers have done with VAERS going back at least two decades, misunderstanding and misusing it to claim or exaggerate horrible harms from vaccines, this time myocarditis. More recently, Dr. Høeg has been most associated with an effort that has big GBD vibes, namely the “Urgency of Normal.” Basically, “Urgency of Normal” is an effort that is an offshoot of the antimask “open up the schools”—and damn the consequences!—movement. Dr. Høeg, along with a number of other of the “usual suspects” of COVID-19 minimizing doctors, argues that schools should, in essence, stop all COVID-19 mitigations, particularly mask mandates, social distancing, and virtual schooling because—sound familiar?—children are at such low risk of dying from COVID-19 that we should just let the virus rip and, of course, because masks and the mitigations supposedly do so much more harm than the virus to children:
Meanwhile, children’s already-low risk from COVID has become even lower. Vaccines are available to children aged five and up, the Omicron variant is causing milder disease, and vaccines continue to be extremely protective against severe disease in the Omicron era.
Based on a careful review of all of this evidence, we believe it is time to allow children the same return to normalcy that adults have enjoyed. Children’s schools, athletics, and activities should be restored to their 2019 norms. Masks should become optional in US schools (we suggest, by February 15), and we can also return to pre-pandemic norms for quarantines: if you are sick, stay home.
When the initiative was announced, I immediately found it rather interesting that, although “Urgency of Normal” mentions the vaccines as making “already-low risk” children even “lower” risk (whatever that means), “Urgency of Normal” pointedly does not recommend that children be vaccinated; instead it only notes only that vaccines are “available to children aged five and up.” This tracks with Høeg’s dumpster dive into VAERS regarding myocarditis that sought to portray COVID-19 vaccines to be at least as dangerous to children as SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, itself. I also find it…interesting…how many reports I hear of parents citing “Urgency of Normal” to say that quarantines are no longer necessary for children with COVID-19.
“Urgency of Normal” provided a toolkit to parents to use to argue to school boards to drop mask mandates and other COVID-19 mitigation measures. I have relatives who have pointed out to me just how successful this effort has been, with lots of parents whom you wouldn’t otherwise think to be susceptible to such an effort enthusiastically embracing the slogan. Almost immediately, though, it was pointed out how “Urgency of Normal” misused and misrepresented scientific studies. I’ll cite just a couple of examples of contemporaneous Twitter threads ripping apart its misuse of suicide statistics:
New version: Now that suicides not useful, just remove it!
It just disappears. That's awful & unscientific.
It should keep the topic, but more accurately: "Fortunately, there were no significant increases in child suicides in 2020."
Hiding it is unscientific & biased.
/2 pic.twitter.com/5HoA59htNK
— Tyler Black, MD (@tylerblack32) February 2, 2022
Weird! They *didn't* just edit their slides to remove the inaccurate data. They moved a non-summary entry to the summary entry.
/4 pic.twitter.com/uZc6wedwH4
— Tyler Black, MD (@tylerblack32) February 2, 2022
I sent the authors a JAMA article (1.5 million Ontario youth, suicide attempts + overdose presentations in the first 15 months of pandemic were LOWER; Ray et al), and other articles.
Honest scientists would include them in their slides.https://t.co/DwEXg6jCbI
/6
— Tyler Black, MD (@tylerblack32) February 2, 2022
I wish they would STOP WEAPONIZING CHILD SUICIDE.
They don't care about suicide statistics. They use child suicide to scare parents, and it reinforces the moral panic.
It pushes their agenda to open schools no matter what the science says.
/8 pic.twitter.com/LtjeVqCGeX
— Tyler Black, MD (@tylerblack32) February 2, 2022
Also:
I adapted the table from the German study Hoeg gets her figures from. If you see this, please consider reporting. Hoeg is off by orders of magnitude. This is just terrible.https://t.co/KdgntQpDZX
— Loretta Torrago (@Loretta_Torrago) January 30, 2022
Others have also piled on, given how obvious the propaganda of “Urgency of Normal” is. When you boil it all down, both the GBD and “Urgency of Normal” argue that COVID-19 isn’t dangerous to most people, and therefore we should just stop trying to stop its spread and use “focused protection” to keep massive numbers of the vulnerable from dying. In the case of GBD, the argument goes that “lockdowns” cause far more harm than COVID-19 (which, according to the GBD, is not dangerous to most people) and that we should therefore let the virus rip to achieve “natural herd immunity” faster, while using “focus” protection for the elderly and those with chronic health conditions that make them more vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19. In the case of “Urgency of Normal,” the argument goes that school mitigations such as mask mandates and virtual school have caused a wave of depression and child suicides far worse than any harm from the virus and that we should therefore drop all those mitigations and let the virus rip through schools, which will eventually result in—you guessed it!—”natural herd immunity.” And guess what? Last week, Martin Kulldorff himself published a new article in his new gig as scientific director of the Brownstone Institute (a.k.a. the “spiritual child of the GBD that now spreads antivaccine misinformation in addition to promoting the GBD) entitled Should I Vaccinate My Child Against Covid? In the article, Kulldorff argues exactly the same thing, that children are at such low risk from COVID-19 that risk-benefit ratio of vaccinating is unfavorable.
As I like to say, “Urgency of Normal” is the GBD, just for children and schools. Both base their arguments on essentially the same claim, that COVID-19 is not dangerous to “most people.” Both oppose any COVID-19 mitigation mandates. Both oppose masking, falsely claiming it to be ineffective. Both oppose vaccine mandates of any kind and, indeed, seem to go out of their ways to discourage vaccination against COVID-19 by downplaying its effectiveness and exaggerating its risks. Indeed, underscoring that last point, neither the GBD authors nor Dr. Høeg seemed the least bit disturbed that they had been placed on the same roundtable with Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, a physician and scientist who 30 years ago did some work getting RNA into cells using lipid nanoparticles and now claims that he “invented mRNA vaccines” even as he is now a bona fide antivaccine crank and conspiracy theorist who claims that the vaccines are causing mass death and claimed on Joe Rogan’s podcast that we are all victims of a “mass psychosis.” If any of the GBD authors or Dr. Høeg were not at least antivaccine-adjacent, they would have refused to be associated in any way with someone like Dr. Malone.\
Back in time…the measles
The core argument against vaccinating children used by people like Drs. Ladapo, Gupta, Kulldorff, Bhattacharya, and Høeg is that COVID-19 is not dangerous to children or, at least, that it kills so few children that the risk-benefit profile of vaccinating is not favorable. To their credit, they don’t make ridiculous claims of the sort documented by Dr. Howard yesterday, in which he described how Dr. Marty Makary repeatedly claimed this:
In reviewing the medical literature and news reports, and in talking to pediatricians across the country, I am not aware of a single healthy child in the U.S. who has died of COVID-19 to date.
As Dr. Howard noted:
As evidence for this extraordinary claim, Dr. Makary referenced his own paper and claimed it was a study of “pediatric COVID-19 deaths”. It turns out that in this study, a three children died, and Dr. Makary used these three children to extrapolate to the hundreds of children who had died by that time. Dr. Makary would later speculate that “maybe the rate of death from the vaccine parallels the rate of death from COVID in a healthy child”. It’s no surprise Dr. Makary has been favorably profiled on RFK Jr.’s anti-vaccine website.
Sound familiar? The GBD makes similar claims for “healthy adults” under the age of 65 as being so incredibly unlikely to die that we should just open up society, stop enforcing mask mandates, and let the “healthy” be exposed to COVID-19, just as “Urgency of Normal” tries to argue that children are so incredibly unlikely to die of COVID-19 that we should just stop all virtual schooling and open up the schools, stop enforcing mask mandates in schools that are open, and let “healthy children” be exposed to COVID-19. In contrast, as Dr. Howard pointed out, thus far according to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, over ~1,638 children have died of COVID-19, one third of these during the recent Omicron surge, with thousands having been hospitalized. Yet, during Gov. DeSantis’ roundtable, one of the other doctors, Dr. Joseph Fraiman, claimed, “The question is, if you have a child who is at risk or has co-risk factors for COVID-19, that’s a discussion with your pediatrician, but if you have a healthy child, the chances of that child dying are incredibly low, essentially close to zero if not actually zero.”
Florida Gov's announcement on kids vaccines contains a falsehood.
It implies healthy kids may have a 0% chance of dying from COVID. In fact the data suggest 20%+ of kids who died had no underlying conditions.
It was not hard to Google this fact. #Vaccinate 💉 pic.twitter.com/iWVF9DaEWA
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) March 10, 2022
One Twitter denizen made a particularly callous analogy and got called out:
Your “rounding error” is higher mortality than most vaccine-preventable diseases was in children pre-vaccine, even adjusted for population growth. In 2021 Covid was the leading cause of death from disease in children, and in 2022 we’re set to outpace that at 156 deaths already.
— Ed Fudman (@EFudman) March 1, 2022
Which brings me to the measles.
Whenever I hear the sorts of arguments that I just listed, I like to respond thusly. The doctors who make the sorts of arguments commonly used to say that children shouldn’t be vaccinated against COVID-19 (e.g., that “only” ~1,600 children under 18 have died of COVID-19 during the pandemic and therefore COVID-19 is not “that dangerous” to children) don’t realize that antivaxxers have been making the exactly the same argument about measles and varicella vaccines (among others) for decades. Again, everything old is new again in antivaxland, and these doctors apparently don’t realize that they are parroting a longstanding antivaccine trope, which is why I’m happy to educate them. Indeed, whenever I hear this argument, I like to counter it by observing that the measles used to kill around 500 children per year right before the measles vaccine was introduced (and a lot more a few decades before that, 6,000 per year in 1912) while varicella used to kill around 100 children per year. Of course, neither of these figures counts the many more cases of permanent neurological injury from both diseases. As I like to ask all these physicians arguing that COVID-19 “isn’t very dangerous” to children, if you make that argument for COVID-19, then why don’t you also oppose school vaccine mandates for MMR and varicella? If you make the same argument about COVID-19 vaccines, like it or not, believe it or not, you are parroting very old and more general antivax talking points.
In case you don’t believe me, let’s go back to 2015, when I wrote about a certain talking point that antivaxxers were using very frequently back then. I used to like to call it the Brady Bunch gambit. The gambit is named after an episode of the classic sitcom The Brady Bunch that first aired in 1969 and featured the hijinks that ensued when all of the Brady children caught the measles, a situation that was mostly played for laughs. A variation of the Brady Bunch gambit included examples of old sitcom storylines that played getting the measles for laughs or didn’t treat it as that big a deal, with the measles being represented as a childhood disease that everyone got and recovered from. For example, here’s a video example that I cited last time, the videos of the original Brady Bunch episode having all been taken down over the last seven years:
I also note that that 52 year old Brady Bunch episode also features “natural immunity.” When Mike Brady (the father) catches the measles near the end of the episode, it is revealed that he never had measles as a kid but that his wife Carol had and was therefore immune to it as an adult.
At the time, I wondered why the writers had all the kids unvaccinated against measles, given that the measles vaccine had been licensed six years before the episode aired and that the incidence of measles had dramatically plunged in just that time and speculated that, while it might not have been so implausible that the older kids remained unvaccinated, it strained credulity that they younger ones were. I also couldn’t help but note that The Brady Bunch wasn’t exactly a font of scientific knowledge, citing an infamous three-part “very special episode” of the show in which the family vacationed in Hawaii and Bobby found a tiki statue claimed to cause bad luck. Once the tiki statue was in Bobby’s possession, all sorts of bad things started happening to the family, including a surfing accident and Peter nearly being bitten by a tarantula. In the story, there was a curse that couldn’t be lifted until the tiki was returned to an ancient burial ground. Perhaps that particular story from The Brady Bunch serves as an argument that there actually do exist tiki statues in Hawaii that confer extreme bad luck on the ones who possess them.
The reality was, of course, different from the fuzzy-headed nostalgic thinking of comedy writers in the 1960s, all of whom likely suffered from survivorship bias; i.e., that they had the measles and it wasn’t so bad led them to believe that it wasn’t bad for anyone. In fact—as I like to point out—according to the CDC, before the vaccine, 48,000 people a year were hospitalized for the measles; 4,000 developed measles-associated encephalitis; and 400 to 500 people died. By any stretch of the imagination that was a significant public health problem, and the introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963, followed by the MMR in 1971, made it much less so. As Dr. John Snyder reminded us nearly 13 years ago in his response to Dr. Sears making the same arguments in his vaccine book that touted an “alternative vaccination schedule,” measles is not a benign disease, regardless of what popular culture thought of it 50 or 60 years ago. (More recent data show that a severe complication of measles,subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), is more common than we used to think.) Meanwhile, over 13 years ago, Dr. Sears was claiming that “the risk of fatality from measles is “as close to zero as you can get without actually being zero,” or one in many thousands,” in other words, practically a rounding error (as our Twitter troll quoted above put it).
Sound familiar, “Urgency of Normal” and GBD?
I also can’t help but note another similarity in this line of argument about COVID-19 vaccines, which echoes the same line of argument about measles vaccines. Right before the COVID-19 pandemic, the biggest story about antivaxxers spreading disinformation was the story of a massive and deadly measles outbreak in Samoa. One of the major talking points of antivaxxers was that measles is a “mild disease” in “developed countries” and is only deadly in those countries (like Samoa) that are less developed. It is of course true that measles is much more lethal in less developed countries, where poverty, overcrowded conditions, and malnutrition are much more prevalent. (Indeed, it was widely reported last month how concerned public health officials are about a measles outbreak in Afghanistan that had already killed over 150 people.) However, none of that means that measles is a “mild disease” here in the safety of our rich nations. Again, even here in the US, disturbingly large percentages of children suffering from measles require hospitalization, and measles can still kill roughly 1-2 in a thousand due to neurologic or pulmonary complications. As I just mentioned, even for survivors, subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) is a horrible and fatal late complication of measles that typically manifests itself 7-10 years after infection. Antivaxxers want you to think that it’s only “those” people (i.e., mostly brown and impoverished) who die from measles, while for our well-off “healthy” (white) children measles is only a minor disease. They’re wrong. Poverty and malnutrition do make measles a lot worse, but it’s still not a minor disease, the contortions of logic and science antivaxxers go through to blame measles deaths in Samoa (and, at the time, Congo) on anything but measles notwithstanding.
Again, does any of this sound familiar, “Urgency of Normal”? Aside from death from COVID-19, what about long COVID? Or multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MISC), severe complications of COVID-19 seen in adults and children? I ask again: If you oppose COVID-19 vaccine mandates for children, why do you support such mandates for MMR and varicella vaccines? The arguments that you deploy against COVID-19 vaccines are exactly the same as the arguments long deployed by antivaxxers against these vaccines. Or maybe you didn’t realize that.
Children shouldn’t die
Perhaps a more “nuanced,” if you will, description of the argument against vaccinating children for COVID-19 goes more like, “Children account for ‘only’ less than 0.2% of COVID-19 deaths.” Is that really such a strong argument? No, it is not, as has been pointed out:
Kids account for <0.2% of cancer deaths in USKids account for <0.2% of heart disease deaths in USKids account for <0.3% of all deaths in the US pic.twitter.com/Z0n61SuPLC
— Shematologist, MD (@acweyand) January 18, 2022
Also from our very own Dr. Howard:
All arguments against vaccinating healthy kids boil down to one thing:
Not that many healthy kids will die, so why bother? pic.twitter.com/6HNpktK5jO
— Jonathan Howard MD (@19joho) March 8, 2022
Exactly. While it was true that before vaccines and modern healthcare, children died in huge numbers due to vaccine-preventable diseases, including measles, to the point that many children never made it to adulthood and old cemeteries are full of headstones showing deaths at a very young age, today children die at such a small frequency that even small numbers of children dying are considered horrific. Imagine, if you will, someone making the argument in the 1950s that because only a few thousand children per year die of cancer that it wouldn’t be worth it to invest all that money in research that ultimately led to childhood cancer being 85% survivable (all comers) today.
Eugenicist thinking about the pandemic: It’s not just for activists
There’s a final point that needs to be mentioned. Supporters of the GBD and Urgency of Normal howl with wounded self-righteous outrage when I bring this up, but it needs to be said. The arguments being made in favor of these very similar initiatives reek of eugenics. Remember that the key idea behind both is to “let the virus rip” through the “healthy population,” be they younger adults without comorbidities that make them vulnerable to severe disease from COVID-19 (the GBD) or the vast majority of children without comorbidities (“Urgency of Normal”). In fairness, the GBD was making this argument before there was a vaccine while “Urgency of Normal” made this argument over a year after there was a vaccine and months after it had been approved for children. Even so, the idea is the same: Unless you are “vulnerable,” you don’t need to worry about dying from the virus, making all mandates for mitigations unnecessary and even more harmful than doing nothing. Even so, I like to quote this article from when the GBD was first published:
“We’ll get herd immunity, but let’s do that with a vaccine, not by sacrificing people,” said Halkitis. “It’s not 1918, for God’s sake.” In the meantime, both Halkitis and Gonsalves agreed that it would be dangerously unwise to follow the Great Barrington Declaration’s advice. “The idea that you can keep outbreaks among the young away from the elderly is ridiculous,” says Gonsalves. “They can spin it however they like, but they don’t really have a plan—it’s grotesque, and it borders on eugenics.”
As I said at the time, it didn’t “border” on eugenics. It still doesn’t “border” on eugenics. It is eugenicist thinking.
What still never ceases to amaze me is how, now that there are safe and effective vaccines against COVID-19, GBD advocates and “Urgency of Normal” don’t actively advocate that everyone get vaccinated. After all, what better means of “focused protection” of the “vulnerable” is there than vaccination? Even if the vaccines are unfortunately imperfect in preventing infection and forward transmission (although that does not mean, as antivaxxers like to say, that they don’t prevent infection and transmission at all), they nonetheless remain very effective at preventing serious disease. Instead, both groups seem to emphasize “natural immunity” over all else, including vaccine-induced immunity, even though the ability of new variants to evade immunity due to prior infection in addition to immunity from prior vaccination, rather demonstrates that postinfection immunity does not appear to be long-lasting or superior to vaccine-induced immunity. That means that any true “focused protection” effort against COVID-19 requires vaccines.
Unfortunately, it’s not just Urgency of Normal or the GBD espousing eugenicist thinking. As Laura Appleman has argued, the COVID-19 pandemic has exposed just how prevalent eugenicist thinking is in our society and in medicine:
Far from being a shameful moment of our past, eugenic philosophy is alive and well in the twenty-first century. Nowhere has this been more apparent than in our response to the current public health crisis. The COVID-19 pandemic has exposed the viral nature of eugenic philosophy, which has continued to guide U.S. treatment of the captive and vulnerable for over 100 years. The long tail of eugenics informs our choices over those we institutionalize, detain, and sequester in long-term care and group homes.
And:
The hidden history of eugenics continues to affect the world today. Our nationwide response to COVID-19 illustrates how public health policies and medical practice are still guided by a belief system disadvantaging the captive and vulnerable. Premised on a subconscious blueprint of eugenic thinking, our COVID-19 response has highlighted an underclass of the “unfit” and “undervalued,” whose lives are literally treated as less valuable.
And:
Accordingly, it should be no surprise that our response to COVID-19 uses the familiar blueprint of eugenics, with predictable consequences for the captive and vulnerable, who are pushed to the side, ignored, or sacrificed for the “greater good.”
I quote Appleman because she discusses a number of examples of eugenicist thinking with respect to the pandemic, which shows how, unfortunately, the GBD and “Urgency of Normal” are far from aberrations. Unfortunately, they are all too much consistent with a lot of the response to the pandemic. Moreover, the GBD at least was never a legitimate strategy for “focused protection” of the vulnerable. As Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz points out, GBD’s “focused protection” never really made sense, as it advocated very little different from what was already being done and included proposals that were wildly impractical, such as relocating large portions of the population to individual housing and providing older workers with a 3-6 month sabbatical, noting that these ideas “ignored the reality that the pandemic was never going to be over in such a short time, and has proven to be a worthless argument given that we’re nearly 2 years on from the GBD publication and these older people are still at risk.” He refers to the GBD as a “branding exercise,” and I would say that the same description applies to “Urgency of Normal.” Meyerowitz-Katz is, of course, too polite to refer to “focused protection” for what it was, a sham based on eugenics, but I will.
If you don’t believe how impractical “focused protection” always was, listen to a Councillor in Local Government in the UK named Adrian Cooke, who noted just how utterly impractical the GBD was:
Accordingly, “Focused protection” (which, reading through, consisted of 17 initiatives that were already routine, one that could be useful (free N95 masks), and one that was barking mad (split “vulnerable” people away from families and house them in hotel rooms for however-many-months-or-years)) would need to somehow isolate around 50% of the country (the JCVI Categories 1-9 (available here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/priority-groups-for-coronavir… as priorities for vaccination) would make this very clear to everyone, published in early January 2021). Of the 50% left, more than half would be children.
We would need to run the country (of 67 million people) with about 15 million adults. Including the health system, which would still certainly collapse with the number of people (of the “less vulnerable”) who would need treatment, unless spread out (somehow, without NPIs) over 2 years or more.
Notwithstanding that protection was voluntary, and even a small fraction of the more vulnerable would further swamp the system.
Moreover, despite the shift in the politics of the antivaccine, antimask, and “anti-lockdown” movement to the far right, the ideas behind the GBD and “Urgency of Normal” are all too appealing both ends of the political spectrum and everywhere in between, as evidenced by how fast the “Urgency of Normal” toolkit found its way into political discussions in even the most “progressive” and “liberal” of school districts to argue for ending mask mandates. Indeed, back when the antivaccine movement was viewed as more a phenomenon of the hippy-dippy crunchy left, the same sorts of arguments against measles vaccination were made, that “only” those who weren’t healthy were at risk and “healthy children” didn’t die of the measles, at least not in developed countries.
Again, no one is arguing that early in the pandemic the choices weren’t very difficult and that the probability of a given person surviving COVID-19 wasn’t part of the equation. Nonetheless, from my perspective, GBD and Urgency of Normal both devalue the lives of those who are less than perfect, less than healthy, by in essence telling everyone who is healthy that they don’t have to worry and shouldn’t be expected to sacrifice anything to protect who are less than healthy and at high risk. It even devalues the lives of healthy children, viewing the few of them who do die of the coronavirus have been described as a “rounding error.” (Do I need to emphasize yet again that children should not die if it can be relatively easily prevented?) The sooner we recognize how deeply this sort of thinking is still embedded in medicine and society, the sooner we can work to expunge it.
In the meantime, I will keep asking these doctors who so indignantly claim that they “aren’t antivax” as they use exactly the same argument that antivaxxers have long deployed against the MMR vaccine alongside the debunked claim that MMR causes autism, namely that measles is not dangerous to “healthy” children and therefore MMR is unnecessary: Why do you oppose vaccinating children for COVID-19 but not measles, given that COVID-19 is clearly more deadly to children than measles? I fear that I will wait long for a coherent answer.

Pro-Infection Doctors Didn’t Honestly Question Whether Mitigation Measures Slowed COVID. They Sought To Undermine Them Precisely Because They Slowed COVID.
Pro-infection doctors wanted them infected, and in this upside-down mirror world, the only policies that “helped” or “worked” were those that spread COVID.
Jonathan Howardon March 8, 2024
Link
“We should have studied whether social distancing works.”
In a previous article I discussed how doctors performatively fetishized randomized-controlled trials (RCTs) not to advance medical research, but rather to spread doubt and mistrust about unwanted mitigation measures. In that article, I wrote the following:
Pro-infection doctors didn’t honestly question whether mitigation measures slowed the spread of the virus, they sought to undermine them precisely because they slowed the spread of the virus.
It’s worth expanding on this because it shows how utterly disingenuous much of our COVID discourse really was. For example, consider the article How to Save Science From Covid Politics by Dr. Vinay Prasad. He wrote:
Let’s say we want to find out if a particular policy—say, mask mandates—actually helps. A randomized trial is a tool that allows us to separate the biases of the world—some states are blue, some people take more precautions, some places have higher vaccine rates—and lets us figure out the actual value of an intervention. By randomly assigning groups to either have the intervention or not, you balance out the variables and isolate the effect of the mandate.
Many experts have called for more randomized trials during the pandemic. But they were ignored. We should have studied whether social distancing works, and how much distance is ideal. We should know a lot more about who to test, why we’re testing, and how often to test. Even school closure and reopening could have been studied. Randomized trials could have turned political fights into scientific questions. Not running them was a huge failure.
This seems straightforward, but it raises a very basic question. What exactly does Dr. Prasad mean by the words “helps” and “works”? He seems to be saying, “We should have done RCTs to investigate whether or not mitigations measures slowed the spread of COVID.” He seems to further imply that if only we had solid evidence from RCTs that mitigation measures “helped” and “worked”, then we would be perfectly justified in using them and nobody would object to them, as if we all shared the same goal.
But we didn’t all share the same goal.
“It is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger… Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk… For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life… Exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future… Immunity is built through illness.”
Indeed, slowing the virus was not Dr. Prasad’s goal for most of the pandemic, especially for children. Quite the opposite actually. His article Should We Let Children Get Omicron?, written during the deadliest part of the pandemic for children and just two weeks before the article discussed above, was crystal clear about his intentions. He wrote:
These measures are premised on the idea that America’s children must be shielded from exposure to Covid-19. What kids really need, however, is a return to normal. When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…
Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger.
He proposed using sick, unvaccinated children as human shields to theoretically protect more vulnerable adults. He said:
Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
He favorably quoted Professor Francois Balloux who said:
I’m not sure how to convey this message in a half-acceptable way. But, if the objective were to send SARCoV2 into endemicity, then healthy kids have to be exposed to the virus, ideally earlier than later. This is not ‘eugenism’; it is bog-standard infection disease epidemiology.
He similarly quoted an editorial in the BMJ that said:
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood… This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
Dr. Prasad urged his readers to accept pediatric fatalities “as a matter of course”, writing:
While the death of any child is a tragedy, Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course.
“Schools are not sterile, nor should they be. Immunity is built through illness,” he concluded.
“Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.”
So let’s image a fantasy world where it was possible to have run every RCT Dr. Prasad dreamt of. Let’s further pretend that these pristine RCTs unambiguously showed that mitigation measures meaningfully slowed the spread of COVID. Would Dr. Prasad then say these measures “helped” or “worked”? Would he have come out guns blazing advocating for these mitigations?
Of course not. His mind was already made up. He didn’t need any RCTs to say it was “reckless” to even try to prevent COVID in children. When Dr. Prasad asked the question should we let children get Omicron?, he answered not by calling for any RCTs, but by saying “restrictions in schools must never return”. He added this:
It is important to emphasise that a more laissez-faire approach to kids and Covid makes public health sense, too. Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.
And there it is. Pro-infection doctors didn’t honestly question whether mitigation measures slowed the spread of the virus, they sought to undermine them precisely because they slowed the spread of the virus. Almost no one, not even Dr. Prasad, sincerely doubted that mitigation measures limited the spread of the virus. However, some doctors feigned ignorance about their impact because they felt that “shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk.” In this upside-down mirror world, by definition, the only policies that “helped” or “worked” were those that “allowed” unvaccinated children to be repeatedly exposed to SARS-CoV-2.
It only makes sense when you remember this- they wanted them infected.

Advice and Encouragement for the “Urgency of Normal” Team
Reasonable people won’t believe things are normal until you stop talking about COVID.
Jonathan Howard on August 14, 2022
Link

Measles, 2019
In 2019, undervaccination caused a measles outbreak in New York. While no one died thankfully, some children got very sick. According to a report on the outbreak,
Serious complications included pneumonia (in 37 patients [5.7%]) and hospitalization (in 49 patients [7.6%]); among the patients who were hospitalized, 20 (40.8%) were admitted to an intensive care unit.
While it got a lot of attention at the time, the outbreak ended. Though we continue to encourage the MMR vaccine, virtually no one mentions this outbreak anymore. Our collective silence demonstrates that with regards to measles, we actually believe things are back to normal.
Urgency of Normal, 2022
With this in mind, let’s meet the organization Urgency of Normal, whose leadership team includes pro-virus doctors who believe that “For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.” Their stated mission sounds very reasonable.
We are a group of scientists and pediatric, infectious disease, emergency, mental health, and ICU doctors concerned that COVID-19 mitigation measures for children are doing more harm than good. Health must be viewed holistically— yet school policymakers have narrowly defined “safety” as the mere absence of COVID, putting children into a loop of mitigation measures that are uncoupled from actual risk. After two years of living with one disruption after another, the toll on children’s mental and physical health is increasingly evident and alarming. To protect them, an urgent return to fully normal life and schooling is needed.
These doctors are upset that children’s lives have been disrupted, as are we all. To this end, they’ve ceaselessly said the words “schools should be open“, while simultaneously dunking on every measure to actually help schools open. When the virus ripped through schools last winter, forcing them to close and the National Guard to “teach” students, their predictable reaction was to pretend this wasn’t happening. For Urgency of Normal doctors, unwanted news is unmentionable news, and whether schools are actually open or not matters much less than cementing their reputations as people who say “schools should be open”.
Any mention of how the virus has harmed children is, of course, strictly forbidden. Despite their prolific pandemic pontifications, Urgency of Normal doctors never simply state the number of children who’ve died or been hospitalized this pandemic, and they shame those who even acknowledge that on rare occasions, children are gravely affected by the virus. For example, concierge internist Dr. Lucy McBride said another doctor was engaging in “fear-based messaging” after this doctor merely shared a news story about a baby who died of COVID. Dr. McBride, who coined the term “fear of normal” in March 2021 to describe people who didn’t feel the pandemic was over, said that sharing this information was a sign of communication “gone awry”. Like I said, unwanted news is unmentionable news.
The advice and encouragement
However, since the Urgency of Normal group first formed, one thing has become very clear- they don’t believe their core message. I’m sure they are sincere in their belief that it’s dandy when unvaccinated children get COVID. However, these doctors clearly don’t think the pandemic is over. This is why they talk about COVID constantly. Their YouTube videos, Substack articles, TV appearances, and social media feeds are almost exclusively devoted to COVID, COVID, and more COVID. This doesn’t reinforce a sense of normalcy, does it?
So here’s my advice and encouragement for these doctors.
Now that the CDC has adopted your position and “restrictions” for nearly all children vanished long ago, you should model the behavior you expect from others. Since you think things are normal, you should mention COVID as often as you do the 2019 measles outbreak. Reasonable people won’t believe things are normal until you stop talking about COVID. I’m confident you can do this. I believe in you.

The Smoke Alarm Fallacy
The fact that we did a decent job of protecting children at the start of the pandemic was used to claim that children didn’t need protection at all. That’s farcical.
Jonathan Howard on March 10, 2023
Link

In a recent article for Peste Magazine, I described the origin of a zombie myth spread by contrarian doctors, namely that COVID only kills one a in million children. In reality, this reflected the odds of an elementary school child dying only during the pandemic’s first 7 months. As new variants arrived and protections vanished, more children inevitably died. According to the Coronavirus in Kids (COVKID) Tracking and Education Project, the actual pediatric death rate as of September 2022 ranged from a low of 7.2 per million for 4-year olds to a peak of 91.8 per million for infants. Of course, often the numerator matters more than the denominator. Over 700 children under age 4 years have died of COVID in the US. That’s horrible. Many thousands more were injured by the virus, though grave outcomes in children are very rare outcome fortunately.
However, beyond the fact that this “one a in million” number is both blatantly and tragically false, doctors predictably used it in an inappropriate way to minimize COVID’s impact on children. The fact that we did a decent job of protecting children at the start of the pandemic was used as evidence that children didn’t need protection at all, not even a vaccine. Doctors who claimed that children didn’t need to be vaccinated against COVID because more children died of some other cause, failed to grasp that our reactively successful efforts to project children in the spring of 2020 was the only reason they could make these ludicrous comparisons.
I’m calling this absurd line of thinking the smoke alarm fallacy after a classic line from The Simpsons, and I’ve been seeing it everywhere lately. Even though forklifts were needed to move corpses into massive trucks when the virus was uncontrolled, the fact that we didn’t let this happen everywhere in the spring of 2020 now allows people who experienced this carnage exclusively from their laptop to claim that “we massively overreacted to COVID“.
Maybe we did.
However, those who make this claim never grapple with what really would have happened had we allowed the virus to spread freely amongst 70 million unvaccinated children in spring 2020. I am confident that had we done nothing to protect them, many more children would have suffered and died from COVID. They also would have helped spread the virus to millions of others, including their teachers and loved ones, none of whom were vaccinated at the time. Anyone who fantasizes things would have been just peachy should be taken as seriously as Homer Simpson.
It is not even debatable.

Do Masks Work?
Let’s review the evidence for the effectiveness of wearing face masks during a pandemic (reprinted from NeuroLogica).
Steven Novella on May 13, 2020
Link

The question of whether or not wearing a facemask “works” is incredibly complicated. It may not seem so at first, but let me list some of the specific questions contained in that broad question. We need to consider different kinds of masks – cloth, surgical, N95. We need to consider who is wearing the mask – someone known to be infected, someone who is well, and in what setting – out in public or in the presence of those known to be sick. We also need to operationally define “work”. We can measure reduction in the spread of the virus, in droplets, in aerosolized particles, and also in different conditions (breathing, coughing) and at different distances. We can measure deposition of virus on surfaces. We can also measure transmission of actual disease, both the chance of spreading and of catching specific illnesses. And of course, all of these questions need to be addressed with each specific infection, and so prior research may not apply perfectly to COVID-19. And further, we need to compare the efficacy of wearing a mask to the real-work effectiveness of intending to use a mask.
It should not be surprising, therefore, that we do not have all the answers to these questions specifically for COVID-19. What we have are slices of research with different results and therefore you can look at the preliminary evidence we do have and come to different conclusions. The CDC and the WHO, in fact, have done this. Here is the CDC recommendation:
CDC recommends wearing cloth face coverings in public settings where other social distancing measures are difficult to maintain (e.g., grocery stores and pharmacies), especially in areas of significant community-based transmission.
CDC also advises the use of simple cloth face coverings to slow the spread of the virus and help people who may have the virus and do not know it from transmitting it to others. Cloth face coverings fashioned from household items or made at home from common materials at low cost can be used as an additional, voluntary public health measure.
Cloth face coverings should not be placed on young children under age 2, anyone who has trouble breathing, or is unconscious, incapacitated or otherwise unable to remove the mask without assistance.
The cloth face coverings recommended are not surgical masks or N-95 respirators. Those are critical supplies that must continue to be reserved for healthcare workers and other medical first responders, as recommended by current CDC guidance.”
And here is the WHO:
If you are healthy, you only need to wear a mask if you are taking care of a person with COVID-19.
The WHO recommends masks for those who are symptomatic or known to have COVID-19, and those exposed to people who are sick, but not for the healthy out in public. The guidelines are actually not that far off from each other, but there is that one difference.
What does the scientific evidence actually say? I will start with some recent studies dealing specifically with COVID-19. There is a recent study which is getting a lot of press but I think has limited implications. The study involved four subjects with COVID-19 coughing with several mask types, and without any mask, onto petri dishes. The masks themselves were also swabbed after coughing. They found the masks did not prevent spread of the virus through coughing (for every mask type, some virus still made it onto the petri dishes). They also found virus on the outside of the masks but not the inside, which is a bit counterintuitive. They speculate that airflow around the mask may be depositing the virus on the outside. Some outlets have reported this finding as suggesting that masks “don’t work” but that cannot be concluded from this one study.
First, they did not test the efficacy of the masks without coughing. They did not test the efficacy of the mask for others exposed to the coughing. And they did not test the factor of distance – perhaps masks reduce the safe distance to avoid transmission. They also did not test to see if masks reduce the amount of virus in the environment of the sick. The study really only tested the filtering ability of the masks for coughing and at short distance.
Another recent study, however, found that surgical masks (which are much less effective than the N95 masks) are somewhat effective:
Surgical face masks significantly reduced detection of influenza virus RNA in respiratory droplets and coronavirus RNA in aerosols, with a trend toward reduced detection of coronavirus RNA in respiratory droplets. Our results indicate that surgical face masks could prevent transmission of human coronaviruses and influenza viruses from symptomatic individuals.
More importantly, there is a recent systematic review of 19 trials, which concludes:
The study suggests that community mask use by well people could be beneficial, particularly for COVID-19, where transmission may be pre-symptomatic. The studies of masks as source control also suggest a benefit, and may be important during the COVID-19 pandemic in universal community face mask use as well as in health care settings. Trials in healthcare workers support the use of respirators continuously during a shift. This may prevent health worker infections and deaths from COVID-19, as aerosolisation in the hospital setting has been documented.
My summary of all this is that, first, we don’t have definitive evidence to know exactly what the effect of mask wearing is in every setting. But we can make some reasonable extrapolations from the data we have. First, for hospital workers, they really should be using the N95 masks, and surgical masks if the former are not available. For the public the cloth masks may be of some benefit, both in spreading and receiving the virus. However, the benefit is likely to be modest. It should not be considered full protection, but just a way to reduce the chance of spread a little bit.
But I think perhaps the biggest factor in terms of the general public use of face masks is the intention to treat consideration – how are people actually using their face masks. The data shows that the modest decrease in risk of spread is only there if people use their masks consistently and properly. When they don’t, what little protection there is vanishes.
Now I am going to introduce some personal anecdotal information, through my observations over the last two months. I am still seeing patients, with maximal precautions, which includes everyone who comes into the clinic wearing a face mask. I have also been deliberately observant when I am out in the public (for essential services). What I have observed is most people not using their masks properly. Many people have the mask below their nose, which is essentially useless. Or the mask is on loosely. But far and away the greatest violation of protocol is that people touch their mask or temporarily remove their mask, and frequently adjust their mask. This is understandable. Non health-care providers are not used to wearing masks. They were not trained how to use them. The masks can be uncomfortable, and whenever you cannot touch your face, it itches. So people are constantly fidgeting with their masks.
This may be worse than useless. We now have data of virus deposition on the outside of face masks, so touching your mask is a good way to spread the virus. Also, there is the “false sense of security” issue. People may feel they don’t have to be a rigorous with social distancing because they are wearing a mask.
So here, then, is my bottom line. Sure, wear face masks whenever you are out in public or have to be exposed to other people – but wear the mask properly, don’t touch or adjust it, don’t take it off or lower it even briefly. Further, understand this is only modest protection. It may statistically help reduce the spread of the pandemic, but it is not total protection. So you still have to adhere to strict recommendations to avoid spread – physical distancing and hand washing being the most important. Also, if you are sick, you can apparently cough the virus through your mask, so still cough into your elbow and not at other people or onto the environment. But most importantly, if you think you may be sick, self-isolate. A mask is not adequate protection for others.
So wear the mask properly, but act as if the mask does not work.

Do face masks decrease the risk of COVID-19 transmission?
As wearing masks to prevent the spread of COVID-19 becomes a culture war issue, the evidence for whether they prevent transmission of COVID-19 remains contested. A new systematic review and meta-analysis provides the best evidence yet that social distancing and masks are highly effective at decreasing the risk of contracting coronavirus, while eye protection might also help, but it’s not a slam dunk.
David Gorski on June 8, 2020
Link

I’ve bemoaned the increasing politicization of school vaccine mandates, in which support for such mandates is starting to fracture, with the right increasingly allying itself with antivaxxers, having been attracted by antivaxxers’ clever use of rhetoric associated with “freedom” and “parental rights” to oppose strengthening vaccine mandates and support weakening them with very permissive “personal belief exemptions.” Although antivaxxers have been co-opting right wing rhetoric for a long time, I was particularly alarmed in 2015 when several candidates for the GOP nomination actively pandered to antivaccine views in the second Republican presidential debate. Little did I know that this year a pandemic would reveal that it’s not just school vaccine mandates that have become politicized, but public health measures in general. We see this in many forms, from the protests against lockdowns to the way that wearing or not wearing masks, of all things, has become a symbol of political identity, with antipathy towards them largely associated with the political right. (I suppose that, had I known more history about previous pandemics, especially the 1918-19 influenza pandemic and the rise of the “Anti-Mask League of San Francisco,” I would have been less surprised at the resistance to masks.) It also didn’t help that the initial messaging and science on masks was confusing and sometimes contradictory. Fortunately, there’s a new meta-analysis of what we know about masks and COVID-19 transmission published in The Lancet last week that helps clarify things and gives me an excuse to update Steve Novella’s excellent post “Do Masks Work?”
Disinformation, information, and confusion over masks
Before I get to the study, though, I want to relate a brief story regarding news articles published a week and a half ago that show a bit of the disinformation about masks that is flying around social media. In brief, The New York Post published a story entitled “Healthy people should wear masks only if caring for coronavirus patients, WHO says“. It was a republication of a Fox News story entitled “WHO guidance: Healthy people should wear masks only when ‘taking care of’ coronavirus patients“. Here’s an excerpt from the NY Post story:
The World Health Organization is recommending healthy people, including those who don’t exhibit COVID-19 symptoms, only wear masks when taking care of someone infected with the contagion, a sharp contrast from the advice given by American public health officials who recommend everyone wear a mask in public.
“If you do not have any [respiratory] symptoms such as fever, cough or runny nose, you do not need to wear a mask,” Dr. April Baller, a public health specialist for the WHO, says in a video on the world health body’s website. “Masks should only be used by health care workers, caretakers or by people who are sick with symptoms of fever and cough.”
The recommendation differs from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), which urges individuals to wear a mask or face covering in public settings, regardless of infection, to limit the spread of the virus.
Now here’s the Fox News version:
The World Health Organization is recommending healthy people, including those who don’t exhibit COVID-19 symptoms, only wear masks when taking care of someone infected with the contagion, a sharp contrast from the advice given by American public health officials who recommend everyone wear a mask in public.
“If you do not have any respiratory symptoms such as fever, cough or runny nose, you do not need to wear a mask,” Dr. April Baller, a public health specialist for the WHO, says in a video on the world health body’s website posted in March. “Masks should only be used by health care workers, caretakers or by people who are sick with symptoms of fever and cough.”
The recommendation has not changed and differs from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), which urges individuals to wear a mask or face-covering in public settings, regardless of infection or not, to limit the spread of the virus.
Notice any differences? First, both articles are framed as though this is a new recommendation, particularly the NY Post article, given its deceptive editing. Notice how the NY Post article removes the part about the videos being posted in March and the mention of how the WHO’s recommendations have not changed. Basically both are presenting this information to cast doubt on the CDC recommendation to wear masks, although the Fox News story is marginally less deceptive in that it admits that these are old recommendations that have not been updated, while the NY Post edited out the phrases pointing that out. At the time, I suspected that this bit of disinformation was the reaction to a story that the WHO was about to do an about-face on its mask recommendations:
Why the sudden bit of disinformation? I think I know. Here's a story out of New Zealand reporting that @WHO is about to do an about-face and reverse its previous recommendation that masks only be worn if you're sick or taking care of a #COVID19 patient. 4/ https://t.co/9JacrBs16D
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) May 29, 2020
Also, unlike what the two articles claim, the WHO was not telling people not to wear masks, as Stephan Neidenbach pointed out:
This is cherry picking what the WHO is actually saying. The WHO’s advice has not changed since the beginning of April. There is a global concern over a major shortage of medical masks. This is what the WHO is asking healthy people not to wear, unless they are in close proximity with those who are sick. They need to be saved for the medical community and sick patients.
WHO stresses that it is critical that medical masks and respirators be prioritized for health care workers.
The WHO is not making any global statement on non-medical masks at all. For that they are leaving it up to individual governments based on their own needs and considerations.
As you can see, there is no inherent contradiction in the WHO’s and CDC’s recommendations, just cherry picking of a passage by sources not known for their honesty or accuracy. That being said, though, it is true that the messaging on masks has been confusing and that the science has been less clear than we would like, as Steve himself pointed out. (My favorite line? “Wear the mask, but act as if the mask doesn’t work.”) So let’s see what this new study brings to the table. Will it help bring more clarity? My guess is: Yes, but not very much more. The reason is simple: GIGO (garbage in, garbage out). The quality of the studies that the meta-analysis relies on isn’t ideal.
Masks versus coronavirus: The evidence
This meta-analysis was funded by the WHO and carried out by the COVID-19 Systematic Urgent Review Group Effort (SURGE). The meta-analysis covered 172 observational studies and 44 comparative studies on SARS-CoV-2 (the coronavirus that causes COVID-19) and the related coronaviruses MERS-CoV (which causes Middle East Respiratory Syndrome) and SARS-CoV (the virus that causes the original SARS, first identified in 2002), doing a systematic review of the observational studies and a meta-analysis of the comparative studies. One could argue that not limiting the study to COVID-19 is a weakness, and perhaps it is, but these coronaviruses are highly related and COVID-19 is so new that there aren’t a lot of studies to look at.
In the introduction, the authors note:
SARS-CoV-2 spreads person-to-person through close contact and causes COVID-19. It has not been solved if SARS-CoV-2 might spread through aerosols from respiratory droplets; so far, air sampling has found virus RNA in some studies2, 3, 4 but not in others.5, 6, 7, 8 However, finding RNA virus is not necessarily indicative of replication-competent and infection-competent (viable) virus that could be transmissible. The distance from a patient that the virus is infective, and the optimum person-to-person physical distance, is uncertain. For the currently foreseeable future (ie, until a safe and effective vaccine or treatment becomes available), COVID-19 prevention will continue to rely on non-pharmaceutical interventions, including pandemic mitigation in community settings.9 Thus, quantitative assessment of physical distancing is relevant to inform safe interaction and care of patients with SARS-CoV-2 in both health-care and non-health-care settings. The definition of close contact or potentially exposed helps to risk stratify, contact trace, and develop guidance documents, but these definitions differ around the globe.
To contain widespread infection and to reduce morbidity and mortality among health-care workers and others in contact with potentially infected people, jurisdictions have issued conflicting advice about physical or social distancing. Use of face masks with or without eye protection to achieve additional protection is debated in the mainstream media and by public health authorities, in particular the use of face masks for the general population;10 moreover, optimum use of face masks in health-care settings, which have been used for decades for infection prevention, is facing challenges amid personal protective equipment (PPE) shortages.11
You might have noted lots of studies being publicized that are presented in alarmist terms because viral RNA is detected in the air or on surfaces. That’s why it’s really important to note, as the authors do, that detection of viral RNA alone does not mean that there’s infectious virus there. It’s worrisome, to be sure, but you have to remember that the virus could be inactivated and thus not infectious in those locations. That being said, the authors also note that, oddly enough, before their article, there were no comprehensive reviews of information on SARS-CoV-2 or related betacoronaviruses that have caused epidemics; so they decided to systematically review the effect of physical distance, face masks, and eye protection on transmission of SARS-CoV-2, SARS-CoV, and MERS-CoV.
In their review, the outcomes of interest were: risk of transmission (WHO-defined confirmed or probable) to people in health care or non-health-care settings by those infected; hospitalization; intensive care unit admission; death; time to recover; adverse effects of interventions; and “contextual factors such as acceptability, feasibility, effect on equity, and resource considerations related to the interventions of interest.” Confirmed cases were defined as requiring laboratory confirmation (with or without symptoms), while probable cases had clinical evidence of infection but in whom laboratory testing hadn’t been done to confirm infection or was inconclusive.
The article is open-access; so you can look at the data too. There were some studies that covered COVID-19, 64 studies, of which only seven were comparative in design. Studies included came from all around the world, as well, although, unsurprisingly given that SARS and COVID-19 both originated in Asia, China and other Asian countries were heavily represented. Risk of bias was generally low, and the authors didn’t find any strong evidence of publication bias.
Here’s the flowchart showing how studies were chosen:
In terms of physical distancing, the authors found that a physical distance of more than 1 meter is associated with an 82% decrease in the risk of transmission (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 0·18, 95% CI 0·09–0·38). Specifically, a subanalysis of 29 unadjusted and 9 adjusted studies found that the absolute risk of infection from an exposed individual was 12.8% at 1 m and 2.6% at 2 m. Reassuringly, this risk remained the same even when the six COVID-19 studies in the subanalysis were isolated. A little surprisingly (to me, anyway), the risk was also the same in health care or non–health-care settings. Finally, each meter of increased distance resulted in a doubling in the change in relative risk.
When it came to masks, an analysis of 29 unadjusted and 10 adjusted studies demonstrated that the use of masks was also associated with a large decrease in transmission, both for N95 masks and for disposable surgical masks or similar reusable 12- to 16-layer cotton masks. (N95 masks are called that because they filter out 95% of particles. They are thicker, more difficult to use correctly, and have to fit correctly to be effective.) Overall, the authors reported that masks and respirators reduce the risk of infection by 85% (aOR 0·15, 95% CI 0·07–0·34), with greater effectiveness in health care settings than in the community, a difference that the authors attribute to the greatly increased use of N95 masks in healthcare settings compared to in the community. Indeed, in a subanalysis they found that respirators were 96% effective (aOR 0·04, 95% CI 0·004–0·30), while other types of masks were which were 67% effective (aOR 0·33, 95% CI 0·17–0·61; pinteraction=0·090). Finally, the authors note that eye protection (e.g., visors, goggles, face shields) is similarly associated with a decreased risk of transmission. Specifically protection also was associated with less infection (n=3713; aOR 0·22, 95% CI 0·12 to 0·39, RD −10·6%, 95% CI −12·5 to −7·7; low certainty).
In the discussion, the authors note:
We found evidence of moderate certainty that current policies of at least 1 m physical distancing are probably associated with a large reduction in infection, and that distances of 2 m might be more effective, as implemented in some countries. We also provide estimates for 3 m. The main benefit of physical distancing measures is to prevent onward transmission and, thereby, reduce the adverse outcomes of SARS-CoV-2 infection. Hence, the results of our current review support the implementation of a policy of physical distancing of at least 1 m and, if feasible, 2 m or more. Our findings also provide robust estimates to inform models and contact tracing used to plan and strategise for pandemic response efforts at multiple levels.
The use of face masks was protective for both health-care workers and people in the community exposed to infection, with both the frequentist and Bayesian analyses lending support to face mask use irrespective of setting. Our unadjusted analyses might, at first impression, suggest use of face masks in the community setting to be less effective than in the health-care setting, but after accounting for differential N95 respirator use between health-care and non-health-care settings, we did not detect any striking differences in effectiveness of face mask use between settings.
The study does have some limitations, the most significant of which is that all the studies included in the systematic review and meta-analysis were not randomized and most were observational, which means that they weren’t always adjusted, and might suffer from recall and measurement bias (e.g., direct contact in some studies might not be measuring near distance). This is the “GIGO” problem that I mentioned at the beginning; the quality of a number of the studies was not very high, and eight of the included haven’t been peer-reviewed yet, currently existing only on preprint servers. It also didn’t assess the effect of duration of contact with persons infected with coronavirus because, as the authors point out, whether or not this variable was judged a risk factor considerably varied across studies, from any duration to a minimum of 1 h. Still, this is probably the best evidence existing thus far supporting social distancing, facemasks, and possibly eye protection to slow the spread of COVID-19.
The authors conclude:
Our comprehensive systematic review provides the best available information on three simple and common interventions to combat the immediate threat of COVID-19, while new evidence on pharmacological treatments, vaccines, and other personal protective strategies is being generated. Physical distancing of at least 1 m is strongly associated with protection, but distances of up to 2 m might be more effective. Although direct evidence is limited, the optimum use of face masks, in particular N95 or similar respirators in health-care settings and 12–16-layer cotton or surgical masks in the community, could depend on contextual factors; action is needed at all levels to address the paucity of better evidence. Eye protection might provide additional benefits. Globally collaborative and well conducted studies, including randomised trials, of different personal protective strategies are needed regardless of the challenges, but this systematic appraisal of currently best available evidence could be considered to inform interim guidance.
I’d agree that this is the best evidence we currently have, but I’d also caution that there is still a lot of uncertainty. Also, as Steve pointed out in his previous post, people stink at using masks properly. He suggested that that’s because they aren’t medical personnel and aren’t used to wearing masks, but even medical personnel tend to adjust their masks take them off, or even fail to cover their noses with them. Even I struggle with this sometimes, and I’m a surgeon; I’ve been wearing surgical masks, sometimes for many hours at a time, since I was a young man.
This study led C Raina MacIntyre and Quanyi Wang to conclude in an accompanying editorial:
For health-care workers on COVID-19 wards, a respirator should be the minimum standard of care. This study by Chu and colleagues should prompt a review of all guidelines that recommend a medical mask for health workers caring for COVID-19 patients. Although medical masks do protect, the occupational health and safety of health workers should be the highest priority and the precautionary principle should be applied. Preventable infections in health workers can result not only in deaths but also in large numbers of health workers being quarantined and nosocomial outbreaks. In the National Health Service trusts in the UK, up to one in five health workers have been infected with COVID-19,10 which is an unacceptable risk for front-line workers. To address global shortages of PPE, countries should take responsibility for scaling up production rather than expecting health workers to work in suboptimum PPE.11
Chu and colleagues also report that respirators and multilayer masks are more protective than are single layer masks. This finding is vital to inform the proliferation of home-made cloth mask designs, many of which are single-layered. A well designed cloth mask should have water-resistant fabric, multiple layers, and good facial fit.12 This study supports universal face mask use, because masks were equally effective in both health-care and community settings when adjusted for type of mask use. Growing evidence for presymptomatic and asymptomatic transmission of SARS-CoV-213 further supports universal face mask use and distancing. In regions with a high incidence of COVID-19, universal face mask use combined with physical distancing could reduce the rate of infection (flatten the curve), even with modestly effective masks.14 Universal face mask use might enable safe lifting of restrictions in communities seeking to resume normal activities and could protect people in crowded public settings and within households. Masks worn within households in Beijing, China, prevented secondary transmission of SARS-CoV-2 if worn before symptom onset of the index case.15 Finally, Chu and colleagues reiterate that no one intervention is completely protective and that combinations of physical distancing, face mask use, and other interventions are needed to mitigate the COVID-19 pandemic until we have an effective vaccine. Until randomised controlled trial data are available, this study provides the best specific evidence for COVID-19 prevention.
As Steve mentioned before, the issue is indeed complex, but I agree that on COVID-19 wards N95 respirators should be the minimum level of protection for healthcare workers. Indeed, in our hospital, they’re now required in the operating room as well, even though we test all of our patients for COVID-19 before surgery. The authors cite two randomized trials currently being carried out. One is a randomized controlled trial of N95 masks versus standard medical masks among nurses taking care of COVID-19 patients; the other is a Danish study in which participants are first screened for COVID-19 antibodies and then randomized to wear masks or not outside the hospital. At the end of the trial, if they haven’t developed symptoms necessitating swab testing for COVID-19 they will be retested for COVID-19 antibodies. Personally, in light of this systematic review and meta-analysis, I have to question whether these studies can be completed because, for the nurses taking care of COVID-19 patients at least, I don’t see how there can be clinical equipoise (genuine uncertainty about which group will do better). I know that, if I were taking care of COVID-19 patients all the time, I wouldn’t be too thrilled to be randomized to the regular medical facemask group.
In terms of cloth masks, the evidence is more mixed than it is for medical masks and N95 respirators. For instance, a recent review of the literature by Clase et al published two weeks ago notes that, even though there was no direct evidence (before the SURGE review) that cloth masks block transmission, it is still reasonable to recommend them based on their ability to decrease contamination of public spaces and reduce aerosol droplets:
When we apply the principles of evidence-based medicine to public policy, there is high-quality, consistent evidence that many (but not all) cloth masks reduce droplet and aerosol transmission and may be effective in reducing contamination of the environment by any virus, including SARS-CoV-2. No direct evidence indicates that public mask wearing protects either the wearer or others. Given the severity of this pandemic and the difficulty of control, we suggest that the possible benefit of a modest reduction in transmission likely outweighs the possibility of harm. Reduced outward transmission and reduced contamination of the environment are the major proposed mechanisms, and we suggest appealing to altruism and the need to protect others. We recognize the potential for unintended consequences, such as use of formal personal protective equipment by the general public, incorrect use of cloth masks, or reduced hand hygiene because of a false sense of security; these can be mitigated by controlling the distribution of personal protective equipment, clear messaging, public education, and social pressure.
It’s a complicated question, and I tend to agree, although personally when I’m out and about in a store I tend to wear one of my medical masks. Certainly, as the review/opinion piece says, there’s no good evidence that cloth masks increase the risk of transmission and prior plausibility combined with evidence that they decrease the emission of respiratory droplets suggest that they are worthwhile to wear. There is also newer evidence from Asia that East Asian countries’ early adoption of masks has played a role in their ability to control the transmission of COVID-19 and that Japan’s culture of wearing masks when ill could explain why it has escaped relatively unscathed compared to many nations.
A review published in Science a week and a half ago makes a similar argument.
Airborne spread from undiagnosed infections will continuously undermine the effectiveness of even the most vigorous testing, tracing, and social distancing programs. After evidence revealed that airborne transmission by asymptomatic individuals might be a key driver in the global spread of COVID-19, the CDC recommended the use of cloth face coverings. Masks provide a critical barrier, reducing the number of infectious viruses in exhaled breath, especially of asymptomatic people and those with mild symptoms (12) (see the figure). Surgical mask material reduces the likelihood and severity of COVID-19 by substantially reducing airborne viral concentrations (13). Masks can also protect uninfected individuals from SARS-CoV-2 aerosols and droplets (13, 14). Thus, it is particularly important to wear masks in locations with conditions that can accumulate high concentrations of viruses, such as health care settings, airplanes, restaurants, and other crowded places with reduced ventilation. The aerosol filtering efficiency of different materials, thicknesses, and layers used in properly fitted homemade masks was recently found to be similar to that of the medical masks that were tested (14). Thus, the option of universal masking is no longer held back by shortages.
From epidemiological data, places that have been most effective in reducing the spread of COVID-19 have implemented universal masking, including Taiwan, Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, and South Korea. In the battle against COVID-19, Taiwan (population 24 million, first COVID-19 case 21 January 2020) did not implement a lockdown during the pandemic, yet maintained a low incidence of 441 cases and 7 deaths (as of 21 May 2020). By contrast, the state of New York (population ~20 million, first COVID case 1 March 2020), had a higher number of cases (353,000) and deaths (24,000). By quickly activating its epidemic response plan that was established after the SARS outbreak, the Taiwanese government enacted a set of proactive measures that successfully prevented the spread of SARS-CoV-2, including setting up a central epidemic command center in January, using technologies to detect and track infected patients and their close contacts, and perhaps most importantly, requesting people to wear masks in public places. The government also ensured the availability of medical masks by banning mask manufacturers from exporting them, implementing a system to ensure that every citizen could acquire masks at reasonable prices, and increasing the production of masks. In other countries, there have been widespread shortages of masks, resulting in most residents not having access to any form of medical mask (15). This striking difference in the availability and widespread adoption of wearing masks likely influenced the low number of COVID-19 cases.
As does Greenhalgh et al in The BMJ:
Substantial indirect evidence exists to support the argument for the public wearing masks in the covid-19 pandemic. The virus has been shown to remain viable in the air for several hours when released in an aerosol under experimental conditions,18 and such aerosols seem to be blocked by surgical masks in laboratory experiments.19 Individuals have been shown to be infectious up to 2.5 days before symptom onset,20 and as many as 50% of infections seem to occur from presymptomatic individuals.21 Community prevalence of covid-19 in many countries is likely to be high.22 Modelling studies suggest that even a small reduction in community transmission could make a major difference to demand elsewhere in the system (eg, for hospital bed space and ventilators).23
Again, the evidence is not as clear as we would like, but, on balance, it is plausible that masks prevent transmission, and there is good evidence that they decrease levels of aerosols, which is particularly important given that we know that asymptomatic people can transmit the virus. Now, with this new systematic review and meta-analysis, there is moderate quality evidence that they do prevent COVID-19 transmission, both in healthcare settings and in community settings.
So what now?
As you might have gathered, even this “best evidence” so far is only good enough to lead the authors to say that they are “moderately” certain that social distancing and the wearing of masks are likely to produce a large decrease in COVID-19 transmission. On the other hand, in a pandemic involving a virus that was only identified and sequenced less than five months ago, what that means is that a lot of the science is still uncertain and will change. Worse, because everyone is working so fast and papers are being rushed through, peer review sometimes suffers. Retraction Watch maintains a list of COVID-19 papers that have been retracted thus far that continues to grow, and two very high profile COVID-19 papers were retracted by The Lancet and The New England Journal of Medicine last week because no one bothered to look into whether a tiny company could produce the sort of database whose data were analyzed in the paper and that company refused to let an independent third party audit of its data. On the mask front, a study purporting to show that masks don’t stop COVID-19 spread was retracted because it was pointed out that the authors didn’t recognize the concept of limit of detection (LOD) of its in-house test for COVID-19 and didn’t express their findings below the LOD as “dozens of news stories, nearly 10,000 Twitter users, and the World Health Organization. These sorts of retractions add to the feeling of mistrust of science among too many members of the public.
The bottom line remains, though, that we have to learn to go with what we know, even in the face of uncertainty, even in the face of crappy retracted science papers, and even in this age of political division, and, right here, right now, there is more than enough evidence to suggest that mask wearing significantly decreases the risk of COVID-19 transmission. As Steve wrote last week, this is a marathon, not a sprint, and it is science that will eventually win the day. As I’ve said many times before, science as process can be messy, and in a pandemic every misstep, each of which would probably have made little stir if it were in a different area of science under different circumstances, will be magnified and politicized. We need to keep that in mind and view with caution each new discovery breathtakingly announced to the public.
And, yes, we need to wear our masks but, as Steve put it, continue to behave as though they don’t work very well. Eventually science will settle the issue, but until it does the balance of evidence supports routine wearing of masks. It’s also important to remember that masks are not the be-all and end-all. Social distancing, masks, and face protection all work together to reduce the risk of coronavirus transmission as low as feasible.

Misinformation and disinformation about facemasks and COVID-19
As evidence accumulates that facemasks work to decrease the risk of spreading COVID-19, new myths have arisen claiming that, not only do facemasks not work, but that they are actively harmful. These myths have no basis in physiology or chemistry, but that hasn’t stopped anti-mask activists from using them to claim protection under the Americans With Disabilities Act.
David Gorski on June 29, 2020
Link

One of the more depressing aspects of the COVID-19 pandemic has been the way that it has revealed just how politicized public health has become, including fights over relatively benign requirements such as wearing a mask in public buildings. The politicization of public health mandates is not new (nothing involving public policy can escape some degree of politics), but what is unprecedented is the level of politicization we are seeing now. Indeed, I first noted this a few years back when it became apparent that school vaccine mandates were becoming increasingly politicized as a result of antivaxxers’ successful messaging to the right wing by portraying school vaccine mandates as government overreach and an assault on “parental rights” and “health freedom”. Indeed, by 2015 and the second Republican Presidential Debate, several GOP candidates were blatantly pandering to the antivaccine movement by expressing support for “parental rights” and support for widely applied “personal belief exemptions” to school vaccine mandates. It wasn’t long before several powerful right wing antivaccine groups, such as Texans for Vaccine Choice and Michigan for Vaccine Choice were wielding considerable influence in Republican Primaries at the local level in some states, which saw a significant number of antivaccine legislators elected and working to block any attempt to eliminate nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates.I suppose that I shouldn’t be surprised, then (although I am a little bit) that the same politicization has infected the response to COVID-19, in particular, the discussion over whether mandates requiring mask wearing as a strategy to slow the spread of coronavirus. I will also admit that my knowledge of history was a little lacking, as I did not know that during the 1918 influenza pandemic there was resistance to mask wearing and that there was even an Anti-Mask League (also dubbed the “Sanitary Spartacans“) formed in 1919 in San Francisco. History repeats, only more intensely than 100 years ago.
Sadly, facemasks have become yet one more flashpoint, one more symbol, in the culture wars, and it doesn’t help that President Trump himself recently explicitly said that some Americans wear facemasks not as a means of preventing the spread of COVID-19 but rather “to signal disapproval” of him and that so many are portraying wearing masks as somehow unmanly, leading one columnist to lament that it’s “worrisome that, in order for us to survive as a species, spouses and daughters or sons must scour Etsy for Venom-themed masks so that their 52-year-old packaging-engineer husbands and fathers can feel gender-secure when they pop out to Safeway for some milk.” Indeed, over on his own blog, our fearless leader discussed the facemask war that has erupted around the country. Seemingly every day, I come across videos of people ranting and spewing misinformation against masks while they refuse to wear one:
This is a Trader Joe’s today. In Los Angeles. Cases are through the roof in California. Is there any way to reach these people?
https://t.co/q1hIQr6aCL
— Read Let This Radicalize You (@JoshuaPHilll) June 27, 2020
Angry Florida woman arguing against mask mandate brings up the devil, 5G, Bill Gates, Hillary Clinton, "the pedophiles" and the deep state pic.twitter.com/gviSA2wrKa
— Gifdsports (@gifdsports) June 24, 2020
pic.twitter.com/OpvKracUOp
— Larry Cook (@stopvaccinating) May 21, 2020
You’ll find ugly (and sometimes racist) memes implying that mask wearing is cowardly:
Here's a particularly ugly meme going around that implies it's cowardly to wear a mask in public to slow the spread of #COVID19. That's the messaging of #coronavirus deniers, that it's no big deal and taking precautions makes you a coward. pic.twitter.com/DqOd5XIEos
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) April 30, 2020
Or that mask wearing is a sign of emasculation or submission:
First, let’s quickly visit some other opposition to masks coming from anti-vax/conspiracy circles: 1) Emasculation – aka: real men don’t wear masks, aka: does PPE make you gay?2) Slavery – aka: face covering is a sign of submission, aka: didn’t slaves cover their faces? 2/ pic.twitter.com/BggAkZkeNu
— Michelle Cohen, MD (@DocMCohen) May 11, 2020
Or that mask wearing is about control, not public health:
Mandates to wear masks to slow the spread of COVID-19 have even been likened to the masks that slaves were sometimes forced to wear:
This is a new #COVID19 antivax meme going around, although the comparison is nothing new. White, privileged, entitled antivaxxers do so love comparing their "plight" to slavery, as though being asked to wear a mask were anywhere near the equivalent of being enslaved and tortured. https://t.co/EDzKP6TfkK
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) May 19, 2020
Given that I’ve recently discussed the evidence in favor of wearing facemasks in order to slow the spread of coronavirus and that Steve updated that evidence last week, I’m more interested in looking at the myths that those opposing masks have cited in order to claim that, not only do masks not stop transmission of COVID-19, but that they cause harm. The evidence is now pretty strong and getting stronger that the use of facemasks decreases the risk of transmitting COVID-19, including a recent study suggesting that countries that mandated facemask use early have done better in the pandemic. There will never be a randomized controlled clinical trial of this (indeed, given what we know, it’s likely that such a trial would now be ethical, given the lack of clinical equipoise), but observational evidence has become more convincing. And, yes, it is true that public health officials shot themselves in the foot, messaging-wise, with mixed messages, starting out discouraging facemask use, only to do an about-face and support the use of masks. Indeed, as I discussed last time, anti-mask advocates recently weaponized the World Health Organization’s initial recommendation not to wear a mask unless you’re sick or around sick people. I’ll discuss some of these problems at the end, as well as a rather unexpected advocate of masks who’s made his presence known.
Myth #1: The Americans with Disabilities Act says you don’t have to wear a mask
You might have noticed that the woman ranting in Trader Joes in the first Tweet above claims that she has a “medical condition” that makes it impossible for her to wear a facemask. This is a common claim, so common that you might have seen this card that mask refusers have been spreading around social media and that some of them have been using to try to trick shop and restaurant owners into believing that they have a legitimate medical condition that precludes mask use. (Of course, I couldn’t help but note that the Trader Joe’s woman didn’t have any noticeable respiratory issues, given how loud and long she could yell.)
Here is the card:
Superficially it appears official, but in reality it’s the sort of thing anyone with a color printer and a laminating machine could produce. Moreover, the “Freedom to Breath Agency” is most definitely not a government agency. As this news story notes:
The card looks semi-legitimate, especially if the person showing the card has a laminating machine – but it’s absolutely unofficial an unenforceable in any legal capacity. As noted by the Department of Justice, the card may include a message suggesting that exemption from face mask rules is allowed because of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) – but it’s all a sham.
It turns out that the person who originated this card is someone named Lenka Koloma, who publishes claims like this about COVID-19:
Virus is created in each and every living organism at any given time. Virus is a way how [sic] your cells cleanse themselves of toxic material that has been absorbed from an external environment. This a wonderful, natural process of your body’s intelligence for self-preserving functions.
Virus is produced when your body is exposed to any unfavorable conditions that create stress on your system. Such stressors are:
1/ Environmental toxins – smoking, alcohol, processed food, industrial chemicals (BPA, PCB, fluoride, parabens, aluminum, lead, mercury and the remaining 80,000+ chemicals in our world)2/ Medications3/ Emotional Stress (such as fear of disease and/or death)4/ Physical Injury5/ Ionized Radiation6/ Electromagnetic Radiation ( such as 5G)
Longtime readers will likely find the claim that the body produces viruses in response to various stressors to be a familiar one. It’s the sort of thing that Robert O. Young, a cancer quack and germ theory denialist, used to claim all the time. You might recall that he was finally arrested and convicted after many years of selling snake oil to desperate cancer patients and that he lost a $105 million lawsuit by a woman whose breast cancer progressed under his treatment. Indeed, Young used to like to claim that viruses were “molecular acids“:
The point being that viruses are molecular liquids or gases (venom) that can be created by chemical imbalances in humans, plants and animals (by malnutrition or toxic acidic food and/or drink consumption), also created in humans, plants and animal glands, sometimes used in defense (snake venom) or emergency (overactive adrenals), also can be crystallized in laboratories, rarely, if ever crystallized in vivo, and foolish to call viruses contagious when viruses are nothing more than acidic liquids or gases from biological transformation or rotting matter.
It’s funny how germ theory denialism of this sort permeates so much of alternative medicine. That’s why it’s not surprising that germ theory denial is coupled with denial of the efficacy of masks. In any event, the US Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of North Carolina issued a denial:
COVID-19 ALERT: Fraudulent Facemask Flyers, “Exempt” Cards not Authorized by U.S. Department of Justice https://t.co/pTa64ILFZK pic.twitter.com/4A1wKvDpCK
— US Attorney MDNC (@USAO_MDNC) June 26, 2020
The Department of Justice also warned people:
The Department of Justice has been made aware of postings or flyers on the internet regarding the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the use of face masks due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many of which include the Department of Justice’s seal.
These postings were not issued by the Department and are not endorsed by the Department.
The Department urges the public not to rely on the information contained in these postings and to visit ADA.gov for ADA information issued by the Department.
Nor was the above card the only example of such fraudulent “medical exemption” cards:
This is an example of a card being distributed in Maine, claiming that the bearer is exempt from face mask requirements under the Americans with Disabilities Act. These documents are not issued or endorsed by @TheJusticeDept. Actual ADA info: https://t.co/5syNOfJaGq pic.twitter.com/YFxeUgkL9j
— U.S. Attorney Maine (@USAO_ME) June 26, 2020
This incident goes to show how far anti-mask activists will go to try to misuse and abuse a law for their own purpose. Before I move on to other myths, let me just point out that the ADA does not mean that business owners must allow maskless people into their buildings:
If a person with a disability is not able to wear a face mask, state and local government agencies and private businesses must consider reasonable modifications to a face mask policy so that the person with the disability can participate in, or benefit from, the programs offered or goods and services that are provided. A reasonable modification means changing policies, practices, and procedures, if needed, to provide goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations to an individual with a disability. The requirement to modify a policy, practice, or procedure does not include individuals without disabilities, as they are not protected under the ADA.
Examples of reasonable modifications to a face mask policy
    • Allow a person to wear a scarf, loose face covering, or full face shield instead of a face mask;
    • Allow customers to order online with curbside pick-up or no contact delivery in a timely manner;
    • Allow customers to order by phone with curb-side pick-up or no contact delivery in a timely manner;
    • Allow a person to wait in a car for an appointment and enter the building when called or texted; or
    • Offer appointments by telephone or video calls.
The same source also notes that there are three conditions when an agency or business does not have to provide a reasonable modification to the facemask policy:
    • Fundamental Alteration: The modification would change the nature of the service, program, activity, goods, services, or facilities. A fundamental alteration is a change to such a degree that the original program, service, or activity is no longer the same.
    • Undue Burden: A state and local government agency or private business is not required to take any action that it can demonstrate would result in an undue financial or administrative burden. An undue burden is a significant difficulty or expense.
    • Direct Threat: The individual with a disability poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others. A direct threat is a significant risk to the health or safety of others that cannot be eliminated by a modification of policies, practices, or procedures, or by the provision of auxiliary aids or services.
During a pandemic, it’s not too hard to see how that last one could apply to those refusing to wear a mask. As for legitimate medical reasons not to wear a mask, contrary to what the anti-mask brigade will claim, the list is quite short:
    • People with severe (not mild) respiratory ailments, such as asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), or cystic fibrosis.
    • People with post-traumatic stress disorder, severe anxiety, or claustrophobia, for whom masks can cause severe anxiety or even fear.
    • Some people with autism, who are sensitive to touch and texture and for whom covering the nose and mouth with fabric can cause sensory overload, feelings of panic, and extreme anxiety.
    • Persons who have extreme difficulty putting on and removing a mask without assistance.
That’s really about it, and even many of these people can learn to function with a mask. This brings us to Myth #2.
Myth #2: Masks impair gas exchange, leading to low oxygen levels and/or CO2 retention
I must admit that it came as quite a surprise to me as a surgeon, as someone who’s been wearing medical masks many hours a day since he was in his early 20s, that there were people out there claiming that masks can make one hypoxic (low oxygen levels in the blood) or hypercapnic (high CO2 levels in the blood). If that were the case, I’ve apparently been hypoxic and/or hypercapnic several hours a day for at least a couple of days a week nearly my entire adult life! More recently, surgeons at my institution have been wearing N95 masks in the operating room. These are masks that will stop 95% of bacteria or virus particles; unsurprisingly, their pore sizes are much smaller than standard paper medical masks or cloth masks. I haven’t been hypoxic, and, when this silly myth started making the rounds, I put a pulse oximeter on myself and checked, out of curiosity and for the sake of science. I will admit that I don’t really like wearing an N95 mask to operate with because it doesn’t take long to get hot, it tends to leave red marks on the bridge of my nose and under my chin, and only one pair of my glasses “plays well” with an N95 mask while the my others tend not to fit. Those are, however, a small price to pay for safety.
In any event, if you hang out on social media, it won’t take you long to find memes like this:
“Continual” mask wearing is, of course, not defined in any of these dysinfo memes.
Are we talking about a 20 min trip to Costco? Or a 9 hr surgical procedure where surgeon, anesthetist and nurses all wear masks throughout?
Guess what? Neither case leads to hypercapnia. 7/ pic.twitter.com/nerQ9zFD3C
— Michelle Cohen, MD (@DocMCohen) May 11, 2020
This part is so important.
The hypercapnia dysinfo depends on the idea that CO2 can’t leave your mask and therefore you breathe it in repeatedly. CO2 is roughly 4% of exhaled air, a roughly 100X higher concentration than in room air. 16/ pic.twitter.com/aKXtAz7S2o
— Michelle Cohen, MD (@DocMCohen) May 11, 2020
There are even videos out there of people using a pulse oximeter (the finger clip that measures the oxygen saturation in your blood using an LED) to measure their oxygen saturation with and without a mask, purportedly showing that their saturation levels drop when they’re wearing a mask. Of course, one can cause one’s saturation level to fall a bit by not breathing as deeply, for instance; so any test where someone knows his oxygen saturation is being monitored is suspect, particularly when it’s clearly been done for propaganda purposes.
Let’s just say that I like this video better, in which a nurse not only measures his oxygen saturation with a pulse oximeter but monitors his end-tidal CO2 level as well while putting on more and more masks. (Spoiler alert: Three masks don’t affect either value.) End-tidal CO2 measures the CO2 content in the breath at the end of exhalation, when the concentration of CO2 is at its highest, and serves as a measure of ventilation (gas exchange), while O2 saturation serves as a measure of adequacy of oxygenation (how much oxygen is dissolved in the blood).
Check it out:
We have so many people who lack even the most basic, elementary school-level science literacy in this country, who cite "decreased oxygen intake" or "carbon dioxide retention" as a reason it to not wear a mask in public. #wearyourmask#DoBetter#PublicHealth#TrustANurse pic.twitter.com/Sw1FZ17HVb
— Kilometers Morales, RN (@MurseWordsworth) June 27, 2020
And here’s a doctor demonstrating the same principle, this time with a surgical mask and an N95 mask:
The bottom line: Masks do not lead to CO2 retention or decrease oxygenation of the blood.
Of course, the hilarious thing is that Myth #2 and Myth #3 are often both accepted, even though they are mutually exclusive.
Myth #3: Masks don’t stop viruses because the pore sizes are too small
The silliness of this myth is obvious when you realize that people who claim that masks are impairing gas exchange and oxygenation also claim that masks can’t stop virus particles because they’re so small. I think that the pseudonymous physician Doc Bastard put it best:
The idiots arguing against masks because their pores are so large that they allow a virus through are the same idiots who think the pores are also small enough to prevent molecules of oxygen and carbon dioxide from passing through.Your education system has officially failed you.
— Doc Bastard (@DocBastard) June 28, 2020
Although I like this explanation too:
Shrodinger's task mask pic.twitter.com/WTr8PqbDkn
— Ray Canton (@ryacker) June 28, 2020
Or, as Dr. Cohen put it:
Here’s the critical point:
If surgical masks aren’t tight enough to block airborne viruses, they are DEFINITELY not tight enough to block CO2.
A molecule of CO2 is WAY SMALLER than a virus. 15/ pic.twitter.com/3Zho82bsd7
— Michelle Cohen, MD (@DocMCohen) May 11, 2020
So SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, is a fairly large virus, measuring approximately 120 nm (0.12 micron) in diameter. N95 masks filter out at least 95% of very small (0.3 micron) particles, while surgical facemasks and cloth facemasks obviously filter out only much larger particles. Here’s the thing, though. A mask doesn’t have to filter individual virus particles to be effective because SARS-CoV-2 doesn’t float around free in the air as individual virus particles. It floats in the air in respiratory droplets, and aerosols, whose particles are much larger than individual virus particles. I’ve discussed aerosols and respiratory droplets in great detail before in the context of whether Ebola could be spread by respiratory droplets. The bottom line is that aerosol and droplet particles range from a few microns in diameter to as large as 100 microns, many, many times larger than even the large SARS-CoV-2 virus. Most of these droplets are too heavy to remain suspended in the air and settle, landing on nearby floors and surfaces. These can be stopped by simple facemasks.
Again, evidence is accumulating that wearing facemasks is an effective means of preventing COVID-19 transmission, so none of this should be surprising. Is it perfect? Of course not. No medical intervention is, but being even just 50% effective could save a lot of lives.
Myth #4: Masks concentrate the virus (if you have it) and make you sicker
This is a myth that appears to have been popularized (if not originated) by neurosurgeon turned quack Dr. Russell Blaylock and was prevalent on social media about a month ago. (Sadly, it still hasn’t gone away.) Here’s an example:
And here’s the money quote that’s been showing up all over Twitter and Facebook:
And still is, as of yesterday:
By wearing a mask, the exhaled viruses will not be able to escape and will concentrate in the nasal passages, enter the olfactory nerves, and travel into the brain.
Russell Blaylock, MD
— 💕Dee🤍🤍 (@deemarwar) June 28, 2020
From the article:
There is another danger to wearing these masks on a daily basis, especially if worn for several hours. When a person is infected with a respiratory virus, they will expel some of the virus with each breath. If they are wearing a mask, especially an N95 mask or other tightly fitting mask, they will be constantly rebreathing the viruses, raising the concentration of the virus in the lungs and the nasal passages. We know that people who have the worst reactions to the coronavirus have the highest concentrations of the virus early on. And this leads to the deadly cytokine storm in a selected number.
It gets even more frightening. Newer evidence suggests that in some cases the virus can enter the brain.11,12 In most instances it enters the brain by way of the olfactory nerves (smell nerves), which connect directly with the area of the brain dealing with recent memory and memory consolidation. By wearing a mask, the exhaled viruses will not be able to escape and will concentrate in the nasal passages, enter the olfactory nerves and travel into the brain.13
This is, to put it mildly, nonsense, utter poppycock. There is no evidence that wearing a facemask increases the risk of SARS-CoV-2 entering the brain or that it makes it more likely that you will suffer severe COVID-19 disease if you are infected. For one thing, you’re not going to be rebreathing the virus particles. They’re in respiratory droplets that will lodge in the mask.
As Sarah Stanley, associate professor of infectious diseases and vaccinology at the University of California, Berkeley School of Public Health, notes:
Stanley also noted that when infected with COVID-19, the tissues in the nose already harbor the virus. “Breathing out the virus is not going to appreciably change the amount that is there,” she said in an email. “Therefore, there should be no reason why wearing a mask would increase your chance of infection in the brain.”
Also, it’s Russell Blaylock. He’s antivaccine and there is literally no form of quackery that I haven’t seen associated with him at one time or another. As the Encyclopedia of American Loons puts it:
Russell Blaylock is one of the big legends in the most radical quackery and denialist movements, and one of the most influential peddlers of, shall we say, nonconformistic medical advice in the US (indeed, you can hardly enter any quack-related or denialist discussion, regardless of the particular topic, without encountering a reference to Blaylock – he is absolutely everywhere). Blaylock is a trained neurosurgeon, though he has retired as such in order to, instead, take up his roles as a perceived expert on nutrition and toxins in food, teeth, and vaccines. He claims that vaccines (in particular the H1N1 vaccine) are dangerous, that dental amalgams and fluoridated water are harmful to our health; and that aluminum cookware, aspartame (also here) and MSG are toxic substances causing brain damage. It is probably unnecessary to point out that science, research, and reality fail to agree with him on these points.
Basically, Dr. Blaylock was putting the “q” in “quack” long before I took an interest in refuting medical misinformation.
Quackfight
Those are the main myths about how facemasks supposedly cause harm; others exist but are mostly variations on one of the three main themes in Myths #2-4 ± claims that masks don’t work to slow the spread of COVID-19. I wish to conclude, however, with a rather surprising observation I made last week. It actually made my jaw drop. This isn’t a myth, but rather something I would never have expected to come from one of the biggest quacks out there in the form of a headline I saw on Friday, FACT CHECK: Natural News remains the most outspoken pro-mask independent news publisher, even as InfoWars and others have become strongly anti-mask:
With all the misinformation and lies from mainstream media circulating around, it’s worth pointing out that Natural News remains nearly the only pro-mask independent news publisher in existence, where most of the other indy media publishers (at least those who are right-leaning) have become “anti-mask” in their editorial coverage.
The dishonest mainstream media, of course, lies about all this and claims that both myself and Natural News are telling people that masks don’t work. Quite the opposite is true. No independent media publisher has been more strongly pro-mask than Natural News, even when that position has gone against most of the indy media.
And:
InfoWars is not only 100% anti-mask, they have been claiming since March — when I parted ways with them — that the coronavirus is a “hoax” and that all the deaths were being faked. The Gateway Pundit and other conservative indy media outlets have long claimed the coronavirus was “no worse than the flu,” and they tend to run stories that claim masks are bad or that masks don’t work.
I think that both InfoWars and The Gateway Pundit are wrong in their conclusions about masks. While I disagree with their assessment on masks and the severity of the virus, I strongly defend their right to speak, by the way. I’m not contributing to InfoWars any longer, and Alex and I strongly disagree on this topic of masks, but his voice is still very important, especially given the extreme assaults against humanity and human freedom that are now under way by the left-wing media, rioters and communist sympathizers.
This podcast is rather revealing:
Here’s part of Adams’ rationale:
So the rest of the world is now looking at American and saying: What’s wrong with these Americans? They won’t wear masks! And they think that it’s a statement of freedom, of rebellion or something, to not wear a mask. Well, I’m here to try to help correct everyone on that. The way to defeat globalists who released this thing is to wear a mask and defeat it. By stopping the spread, stopping the epidemic, you are defeating the globalists, and the way to stop the spread is to wear a mask. In fact, wearing a mask is a sign of resistance to globalism! That’s what people need to understand. Not wearing a mask means you are an obedient sheeple slave to the globalists, because you will likely get infected and then you will be part of the coronavirus death count or hospitalization crowd or you’re going to be microchipped and have your antibodies tested and all that. If you don’t wear a mask, then you’re going to be treated like a slave.
Wearing a mask helps preserve your freedom because it stops the spread—or it helps stop the spread…it doesn’t stop it entirely. But along with other things that I’ve also promoted here, such as zinc and vitamin D3 and, you know, testing asymptomatic carriers and things like that, we can stop the spread of this. We can stop it long before there’s a vaccine available. That’s the other point. Not wearing a mask means that you support vaccines, because if you don’t wear a mask vaccines are the only way we’re going to get it stopped, and that’s only if the vaccine even works, which is highly unlikely. But if you don’t wear a mask you are continuing the spread of this and making the case of the vaccine industry that says a vaccine is the only thing that’s going to stop this. So the way to beat the vaccine industry is to stop this pandemic before a vaccine is available, so that on the day they finally have a vaccine available nobody needs it because we’ve already beat it.
That’s why wearing a mask is the true act of resistance or rebellion or freedom or liberty or patriotism, whatever you want to call it. Wearing a mask is how you preserve your freedom and stop this pandemic. So for those people out there saying, “Well I’m not wearing a mask, I’m a free American,” OK, be free—in your grave! Because you’re going to be dead. How free are you when you’re dead? Not that free! You’re locked in a little coffin box. That’s pretty small. If you thought locking down yourself in your apartment or house was bad, wait till you’re locked down in a coffin, dead, because you refused to wear a mask. It just makes no sense. Everybody should wear a mask.
You know, if Adams wants to beat the globalists by getting people to wear masks, this one time I say to him: “Knock yourself out!” (At least as long as people are wearing masks.) And how bad do InfoWars and Gateway Pundit have to be to have an arch-quack like Mike Adams lecture them thusly:
InfoWars has gone so deep into the anti-mask slant on all this that they now run scary-sounding anti-mask headlines like this: “SadoMASKism – The love of fear and pain.” You have to chuckle at the word play.
The conclusion among InfoWars hosts like David Knight and Alex Jones is that masks kill people and deprive the body of oxygen. Such claims have no basis in medical reality, but they make for very entertaining coverage.
Says the man who’s been producing cartoons, videos, and songs promoting quackery and antivaccine views for at least 15 years. Don’t worry, though. Although Adams has flipped the usual conspiracy theories about COVID-19 to justify wearing a mask as a sign of rebellion against the “globalists” who (in his mind) started the pandemic, he’s still the same old Mike Adams:
Finally, we wonder why the mask-pushing hysteria of the corporate-run media completely ignores the role of nutrition (zinc, vitamin D, vitamin C, elderberry, etc.) Because the bigger truth in all this is that the mainstream media is anti-nutrition. And that’s far more dangerous than being anti-mask.
So if you’re looking for news publishers to blame in all this, blame the lying left-wing media for blacklisting any mention of nutrition, for attacking hydroxychloroquine and for pushing weaponized lockdowns and vaccine mandates that will probably end up killing more people than the pandemic itself.
Of course, when it comes to Mike Adams, it’s also always about the grift. I notice that he sells something called the “Bioscarf” on his website for $44.99 apiece, which, according to the blurb, has “been lab-verified at one of the FDA’s premier testing facilities to filter out an average of 99.75% of all airborne particulates size 0.1 microns and larger.” He also sells something called the ReadiMask, a disposable mask with eye shield costing $11.99 apiece(!):
I note that you can get exactly the same mask from the manufacturer for $8.99, because of course you can.
Myths never die
        ◦ Sadly, as I’ve described before, the COVID-19 pandemic has been a magnet for medical conspiracy theories, and, part and parcel with those conspiracy theories, are myths about coronavirus and any recommended public health interventions. Unfortunately, the misinformation and disinformation tend to flow faster than medical authorities can keep up with it. I’m guessing that the myths about masks will continue and will mutate, taking forms that even I can’t predict, but I also predict that the myths I discussed above will never go away. Why should they? Antivaccine myths always keep popping back up, no matter how often they’re refuted, and COVID-19 myths won’t be any different.

The Mask Ask: Understanding and Addressing Mask Resistance
The wearing of masks has become contentious on scientific and ideological grounds. Why is that, and how can we communicate with people who don’t follow the scientific guidelines?
Grant Ritchey on October 16, 2020
Link

It is so easy to be wrong – and to persist in being wrong – when the costs of being wrong are paid by others.— Thomas Sowell
We are in unprecedented times. This may come as a shock for those who haven’t interacted with civilization since March, but the pandemic will be around for a while; effective vaccines and treatments are still likely months away. Even in our modern scientific era, our current prevention and mitigation strategies for keeping the SARS-CoV-2 virus at bay are not much better than we employed over a century ago during the 1918 H1N1 pandemic. Self-isolation, social distancing, hand washing (and other personal hygiene measures), and mask wearing are the best weapons we have to slow down the spread of this virus at the moment. The world is watching in suspense as the scientific method is utilized in real-time to safely and expeditiously create the desperately-needed vaccines and therapeutics.
Much has been written about the pandemic and how communities and individuals are navigating the confusing and ever-changing information and recommendations put forth by experts and non-experts alike. In this article, we would like to zero in on some of the factors that affect people in their everyday lives; namely, why masks are important and effective, the psychology behind mask non-compliance, and how to communicate the importance of mask wearing with the public, our friends, and our families.
The science of masks as a covid-19 mitigation effort
There are three ways to manage the spread of infectious diseases from a public health perspective:
     1.  Prevention, largely through wide-spread vaccination to achieve herd immunity, clean water, sanitation measures, etc.
     2.  Effective therapeutics to minimize mortality, shorten disease duration and sustained adverse effects.
     3.  In the absence of a vaccine or effective treatments, the tactic of last resort is behavior modification.
Unfortunately, with the emergence of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that caused the COVID-19 pandemic, the world has been forced to employ option # 3 – behavior modification – until the science catches up and provides us with a vaccine and/or an effective treatment.
At the onset of the pandemic, behavior modification focused on hand hygiene, cough etiquette, and disinfection of surfaces to reduce transmission through fomites (an object or material that can become contaminated and transmit infection). When these proved ineffective in making a substantial impact on viral spread, social isolation and social distancing was deemed necessary, and voluntary compliance was encouraged. The science behind these efforts was largely based upon our knowledge of mitigating transmission of the influenza and other viruses, due to lack of evidence and experience about the novel coronavirus itself.
At that time, masks were not recommended for the general public, in part, to conserve scarce PPE needed for front-line healthcare workers. Moreover, the rationale was that, like influenza, the disease was largely spread through droplets (5-100um) generated through coughing and sneezing. Such large droplets quickly succumb to the effect of gravity, and fall to the ground or other surfaces. Over time, however, it became apparent that the role of aerosols, which are smaller than droplets (<5um), generated through breathing and speaking was greater than initially anticipated. Moreover, we learned that the viral aerosols can spread from pre- or asymptomatic patients. These aerosols can be sustained in the air for several hours, especially in environments that lack robust ventilation. This means that in addition to continued social isolation, something that had been wearing thin on the psyche of the nation, another tactic was necessary. The solution: widespread use of masks.
The effectiveness of masks can be seen in other countries that quickly implemented mask usage. The most rigorous example is Taiwan, where the spread of COVID-19 remained low (411 cases and 7 deaths as of May 21, 2020, with a population of 24 million) in spite of lack of social isolation because universal mask usage was implemented early and comprehensively. This early success has persisted; as of 15 October 2020, the total cases for the country remain low at 531, with still only 7 deaths – quite an impressive public health feat.
This new knowledge led to the CDC and the WHO recommending widespread mask usage, including homemade cloth masks, as masks can reduce the number of viral particles spread throughout the surroundings with each breath, reduce the likelihood and severity of COVID-19 illness, and protect uninfected individuals from aerosols and droplets. It is particularly important to wear a mask in indoor areas that can accumulate high concentrations of aerosols, including healthcare settings. Figure 1 presents talking points that can be used when addressing the need to wear masks.
FIGURE 1: Why masks are needed to control the covid-19 pandemic
Factors that influence compliance with mask utilization
An individual’s decision to wear – or not wear – a mask during the current pandemic no doubt is also influenced by many complex factors. Among some of the influencing factors are the role of social identity (a social factor), heuristics (a neurological factor), and cognitive dissonance (a psychological factor). Following is a description of these factors and how they may be influencing compliance with mask usage.
Social Identity
As humans evolved, being part of a social group had a great influence on survival and progress. The benefits of being part of a social group were significant, including protection, division of labor, shared resources, bonding, and a sense of belonging. Being alone and isolated was a death sentence, so we have an innate drive to join groups and oppose other groups in times of conflict.
In essence, being part of a group becomes part of one’s identity. In contemporary times, the context of social identity is less about physical proximity and physical protection, but rather is more of a social network and a way of thinking. This can create a bias toward accepting and believing things that are consistent with one’s perceived social group rather than accepting facts supported by evidence. The sense of belonging remains so important – and the costs of isolation so great – that belonging becomes more important than being correct.
The negative consequence of social identity thinking is that it creates an “us” vs “them” mentality, with a natural preference toward “us” rather than “them”, and the costs of becoming excluded or ostracized are great in a social context. Furthermore, in times of conflict, the sense of “us” vs “them” is amplified.
So what does this have to do with mask wearing?
As the COVID-19 pandemic emerged in the US, Shana Gadarian, a political scientist from Syracuse University, conducted a series of surveys using a nationally representative sample to understand levels of compliance with mitigation efforts such as hand washing, staying home, social distancing, and wearing masks. The studies also sought to identify demographic factors that were associated with these behaviors. The most consistent determinant of mask wearing was political partisanship – even trumping (see what we did there?) other factors such as age, zip code, gender, and education. Democrats were more likely to wear masks (73%) than republicans (53%) (the analyses were conducted within the same states so that differences in state mask mandates did not influence the results).
While behaviors such as hand washing and staying home are not as noticeable, mask wearing is. Based on the science as described above, the benefits of these practices are clear. However, when mask usage becomes politicized, the social costs with mask usage (or non-usage) become greater. These costs impact one’s social identity, resulting in a perceived or real social loss when wearing a mask in public. The mask (or lack thereof) becomes a de facto “Scarlet M” branded upon one’s face.
At the onset of the pandemic, the uncertainty level was extremely high largely because this was a novel virus and the public health and medical communities were still learning about the virus and making recommendations based on incomplete information. Now, more than 9 months later, there have been significant strides in knowledge about the virus, but we are still largely in a position of uncertainty. Not having a uniform message from those leading the nation’s pandemic efforts creates a situation where individuals are forced to make a choice on whose viewpoint to value or trust, and the tendency is to place greater value on the messaging from political leaders than the scientific experts (recall the perspective that it is evolutionarily more beneficial to be part of a social group than to be correct). Furthermore, having groups that are polarized to not trust the other side has amplified the politicization of mask wearing. Over time, the mask has become a banner to signal to others which in-group an individual belongs to.
Heuristics
In order to reduce the constant burden of decision making, our brains use heuristics to help us navigate the complicated landscape of everyday life. A heuristic is a “mental shortcut that allows an individual to make a decision, pass judgment, or solve a problem quickly and with minimal mental effort”. Heuristics are necessary tools to prevent “paralysis by analysis”, but there are corresponding liabilities to taking such short cuts, which can result in incorrect judgments, decisions, and actions.
There are several types of heuristics which could come into play when someone makes the choice to wear a mask or not. One is called the “anchoring heuristic“, in which a person places more significance on the first piece of information they receive. This typically occurs with numerical figures, but can also apply to non-numerical data. For example, if a person initially reads a believable article or watches a compelling video about the harms of mask wearing, this will be the “anchor” on which subsequent information is evaluated. If the first quantity of information is accepted as true (even if it isn’t), any new information that contradicts the original data is summarily accepted as false (even if it isn’t), leading to a vicious cycle of confirmation bias (more about that below). The fact that early on in the pandemic public health leaders did not recommend masks contributes to this anchoring heuristic.
Another is called the “representative heuristic”, where information is categorized by what the person generalizes about other, similar information. For example, a person may say “masks aren’t required for everyone during flu season, therefore they aren’t necessary now.”
Motivated reasoning (or motivated cognition) refers to an individual’s propensity to evaluate and accept a claim which favors or confirms a previously held position. This “confirmation bias” can involve the cherry picking of data and information; the individual amplifies information which agrees with his or her belief while minimizing or ignoring data which refutes said beliefs. This explains why a patient may believe a random person on YouTube rather than a consensus of experts on a given topic. For example, because a patient identifies with a “tribal” group that refuses to wear masks, he/she might deny any statistics or data which goes against his/her belief or is conveyed to him/her by a member of a different “tribe”.
Another effect is that of “immediacy”. When someone refuses to wear a mask, the effects of that choice cannot be readily demonstrated. If the individual, for example, is shopping in a public place without a mask, he/she will likely never know if he/she infected anyone. There is no immediate feedback, so any consequence is not registered in that person’s mind. If that same person happened to infect a susceptible individual who subsequently became ill or even died, he/she would never know the devastation caused. With mask wearing (or fluoride or vaccines), the consequences of following or not the scientific guidelines aren’t usually immediately apparent.
Cognitive dissonance
In their book Mistakes Were Made (But Not By Me), Tavris and Aronson discuss the phenomenon of cognitive dissonance, a term coined by social psychologist Leon Festinger in 1957. Called “the engine of self-justification”, cognitive dissonance can be defined as the psychological tension that arises when one acts in a way that is inconsistent with one’s beliefs or knowledge. This tension must be resolved somehow, and our brain will contort itself into all sorts of self-deceptions and rationalizations in order to be at peace with itself. The most common example is smoking: almost all smokers know that what they are doing is unhealthy, yet they continue. How can they rationalize their desire to be healthy (or their image of themselves as a healthy person) while smoking? In this case, the individual might say to herself “Smoking helps me lose weight, which is healthy” or “My aunt smoked a pack a day for 60 years and she’s still fit as a fiddle”. The human brain is capable of impressive feats of cognitive gymnastics.
For those opposed to mask wearing, the tension may take on an internal debate like this: “I am a kind and considerate person. I do not want to endanger anyone, and I may spread disease if I do not wear a mask. How can I justify not wearing one?” Such conversations occur beneath the level of consciousness, but the conflict is real and continuous for many issues within all of us. The resolution for a mask opponent may take the form of “I know I’m not sick, so I’m not going to infect anyone” (conveniently ignoring that asymptomatic spread is common), or “It’s a violation of my rights to force me to wear a mask. If someone doesn’t want to get infected, then they should just stay home”. This self-justification removes individual responsibility and shifts it onto others.
Discussing mask compliance
This article’s irony is that we discuss how information alone isn’t useful in changing behavior while hoping that the reader will change their behavior based on the information we are providing. So can we change behavior? Initiating change requires communication strategies that will be well received. Providing correct information is essential; however, messaging can be more effective when considering the psychological factors addressed above: social identity, heuristics, and cognitive dissonance.
Communication strategies are based on two broad categories:
     1.  Communicating with recipients of COVID-19 scientific misinformation (of which there is no shortage), and
     2.  Engaging with those who refuse to wear a mask based on a belief that such expectations infringe upon their rights.
Regardless of the reason or the circumstance, and despite the apparent wide differences in motives, there are commonalities in the approach one can take.
Perhaps it is best to begin with what not to do. When someone holds an opposing perspective – be it about masks, a favorite sports team, or politics – the first temptation is to consider the other person’s viewpoint is wrong. Calling people out in this manner might feel good and give us a brief feeling of righteous superiority, but it is counterproductive in the long run. As soon as a person feels attacked or disrespected, they become defensive and less receptive to change.
Another approach often employed is listing all the “objective” evidence in support of a position while refuting the others. After all, if everyone just had the facts (we tell ourselves), our correct position would be obvious, right? In fact, quite the opposite is true. Decision-making for most people is influenced by new information using emotion rather than logic. In some cases, presenting good scientific evidence can actually backfire, causing the person to anchor to an erroneous belief even more firmly.
A resource for lessons on effective communication strategies is found in research on vaccine hesitancy. There, investigators found that sharing facts with hesitant parents may not be useful and can be harmful in motivating such an individual to be more steadfast in their beliefs. What researchers did find persuasive was messaging from peers, even more so than from experts. Consequently, showing graphs, charts, and statistics around vaccines – or masks – may make us feel knowledgeable and confident, but it is usually not convincing for doubters.
In order to be persuasive, one must employ the tools of empathy and narrative. Just as a picture is worth a thousand words, a story is worth a thousand graphs. Our recommendation is to start by trying to find common concerns and values to grow the conversation.
For example, in talking to a non-mask wearer, one may start the conversation with “I notice that you aren’t wearing a mask. I realize that is your personal choice, and I know they can be uncomfortable and a hassle” (empathy). “But I’m concerned about my elderly parents and friends that might become infected if we aren’t careful. I read a story about an otherwise healthy 72-year-old who was accidentally infected by her asymptomatic grandchild and spent two weeks on a ventilator “. This provides a narrative with an emotional appeal – something that is more likely to change behavior than scientific evidence.
Conclusion
It would be nice if human beings based their worldviews, attitudes, and behaviors on logic and reason – running complex cognitive algorithms to determine the best course of action in any given situation – but our species is not hard wired that way. There are social, neurological, and psychological reasons that influence many behaviors. Often, emotion supersedes logic and we place a higher value on short-term pleasure or comfort over long-term benefit. Our brains can justify and rationalize just about anything we do or think if it makes us feel better about ourselves, relieves internal psychological tension, or allows us to achieve a goal. Moreover, our brains take cognitive “shortcuts” which allow us to complete tasks and solve problems quickly by rote and repetition. And we are influenced by our peers, and seek to be in compliance with others who are like us. All of these cranial “hacks” are useful – even necessary – in the right situations, but they can make us vulnerable to cognitive errors and mental mistakes.
Even if we could reduce our world to a series of calculations and analyses, the time and energy costs necessary to do so would literally prevent us from living our lives. There is simply too much sensory and informational input bombarding us to continuously perform so many cranial calculations. That is why we humans often make decisions that defy valid scientific information and cause us to behave in ways that are against the best interests of ourselves and society. Some of us smoke against our better judgement. Some of us eat unhealthy foods and don’t exercise as we should. And some of us refuse to wear masks.
Using communication strategies geared toward mask usage that appeal to emotions, rather than facts, and perhaps providing examples promoting use of masks from an opponent’s social community are likely to be more effective in changing behavior. To be effective, find shared values, and use narratives that create emotional responses to motivate positive change in mask-wearing behavior.

This article was originally published in the Journal of the Michigan Dental Association and has been modified for the Science Based Medicine readership and reposted with permission. The lead author of the paper is Dr. Julie Frantsve-Hawley.
Dr. Frantsve-Hawley is the director of analytics and evaluation at the DentaQuest Partnership for Oral Health Advancement. She has extensive experience in evidence-based health care, medical and dental research, analytics, implementation science, scientific publishing, and advocacy. She has served as the Executive Director of the American Association of Public Health Dentistry. She received her PhD from Harvard University’s Biological and Biomedical Sciences program.

“Masks make you sicker”: The COVID-19 myth that just won’t die.
Masks work to slow the spread of COVID-19, but the “masks make you sicker” narrative, like antivax nonsense, has proven to be unkillable and to be a killer.
David Gorski on October 19, 2020
Link

[Editor’s Note: Grant application deadline struck again; so this post might look familiar to some of you. I promise new material next week.]
Of all of the disinformation about COVID-19 that’s been spreading, for all the conspiracy theories, the confluence of COVID-19 deniers, antivaxxers, and even QAnon conspiracy theorists, for all the unproven and disproven treatments (like hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, and the like), for all the quackery that’s been promoted, even by the President, the most depressing nonsense about the COVID-19 pandemic that’s persisted and proven incredibly resistant to disconfirming science is the myth that, not only do masks not work to slow the spread of COVID-19, but they actually make people sicker. This particular myth has been very destructive to efforts by public health officials to slow the spread of the disease, leading to the misuse and abuse of the Americans With Disabilities Act, which has been incorrectly used (and, quite frankly, grossly misused) as an excuse not to wear a mask by those who oppose mask mandates. Even worse, masks (or, more precisely, refusals to wear a mask) have become a badge, a signifier, of loyalty to a particular tribe, largely thanks to President Trump’s refusal to wear a mask, dismissal of masks as unimportant, and even mocking of people who wear masks as “weak” and “afraid”, even after he himself got sick with COVID-19, largely because of his lackadaisical approach to COVID-19 at the White House.
Masks work to slow the spread of COVID-19, primarily to prevent the wearer from spreading the virus, but also, to a lesser extent, to protect the wearers themselves from coronavirus. That’s why my attention was drawn to an article by Olga Khazan in The Atlantic on the origin of the idea that masks make you sicker. It turns out that this idea is nearly as old as the pandemic and even more resistant to evidence than you might think. Khazan begins by describing the first time she became aware of the claim, overhearing it while swimming in her local pool:
About a month ago, I was in my local pool when I overheard a middle-aged woman in the next lane whisper it to her friend, in the way you vaguely assert something that you’re pretty sure is true but don’t fully understand. “Masks don’t even do anything,” she said. “In fact, they can make you sicker. Because you’re breathing in all the … stuff … you breathe out.”
“OK Boomer,” I thought. I dismissed her as a random neighborhood conspiracist and swam my laps.
I had a hard time not being a bit surprised that a journalist who has written quite a bit about COVID-19 hadn’t heard the antimask claim that masks make you sick until a month ago. I recall seeing permutations of this particular claim as far back as April, although Khazan’s article shows that the claim goes back at least a couple of months before that.
She then continues on about how she started seeing the claim more and more on social media:
But then I started to see this false notion appear more frequently on Facebook. It wasn’t the typical argument anti-maskers use, that mask mandates infringe on people’s freedoms. It was that the masks themselves are causing illness. The horror of the idea was apparent even to me: the feds, in their hall-monitor stupidity, forcing you to do something that’s actually bad for you.
Most recently, this surfaced in the form of “copypasta”—a post copied and pasted by many people onto social media, rather than shared as a link—from a purported “OSHA Inspector.” “I have worked in a clean room for 23 years and 10 years on submarines before that,” it reads. The inspector, supposedly from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, goes on to debunk each type of mask. N95s won’t “filter your air on the way out,” so they don’t reduce the risk of catching COVID-19 from someone who has it. Surgical masks, the post claims, are rendered useless by the moisture from your breath and the “amount of particles” on them. Cloth masks, meanwhile, trap carbon dioxide, risking the health of the wearer. “I know, facts suck,” it concludes. “They throw a wrench into the perfectly (seeming) packaged pill you are willingly swallowing.”
All of these claims are, of course, false. We now know that all forms of masks can interrupt transmission of COVID-19, with the most effective being N95 masks (which I always wear while operating or seeing patients in clinic), surgical masks being next, and cloth masks being the least effective, but still more than effective enough to be worth wearing. The evidence is both epidemiological and anecdotal, for instance, when two stylists worked at a hair salon in Missouri while infected with the coronavirus, but none of the 139 clients they saw while they had it got sick, because everyone wore a mask.
My purpose with this post is not to relitigate the evidence that masks work. They do, and the evidence only gets stronger as time goes on. Rather, it’s to look at this particular piece of misinformation or frequently, when used by ideological actors, active disinformation. Khazan describes the phenomenon:
Though the latest public posts mentioning the supposed OSHA inspector date from September, the idea that masks make you sicker has been spreading online for months now, even after various fact-checking sites debunked the claim. I emailed Facebook to ask for more information about this type of post, but the company did not respond. One instance of the OSHA post was taken down after my email. But others live on, circulating among mask-haters and affirming what they perceive to be their righteousness. The post is an especially bizarre example of the “infodemic” scientists have been battling alongside the coronavirus pandemic, in which the internet is a giant telephone game reverberating with the weirdest stuff imaginable.
Welcome to the club! If there’s one thing the COVID-19 pandemic might actually be good for, it’s that it’s opened the eyes of a lot of people oblivious to medical misinformation to just how pervasive it is and how resistant to countering with evidence and science it is. Those of us who have been combatting antivaccine misinformation and disinformation for many years could have told them, could have warned them, but I’m not sure many of them would have listened, other than the reporters who had already long been covering the antivaccine movement, a distinct minority.
Perhaps the key point of Khazan’s article that resonated with me is how the myth that masks make you sick evolved organically from the claim that masks don’t work, which had been fueled by antimaskers who latched on to statements by public health officials early in the pandemic:
These videos and articles all came months after government officials had begun encouraging—and then mandating—that people wear masks in public. But crucial to understanding the spread of this particular piece of misinformation is that, for many weeks early in the pandemic, everyday people were told not to wear masks. Back then, prominent experts claimed masks were needed for health-care workers and were borderline ineffective for the general public. Versions of this advice also suggested that masks could raise the risk of illness. On March 12, Jenny Harries, England’s deputy chief medical officer, claimed that masks could “actually trap the virus.” Therefore, she said, “for the average member of the public walking down a street, it is not a good idea.” (Harries did not respond to a request for comment.)
In particular, this Tweet by the US Surgeon General has aged…poorly:
It’s true, though, that, unfortunately, early in the pandemic, public health officials did discourage the wearing of masks by the general public, but the motivations were mixed. In retrospect, the primary motivation appears to have been fear that the public, most of whom at the time were at relatively low risk, would buy up all the masks, creating even worse shortages for medical personnel than what was already the case, with the further rationalization that there wasn’t a lot of hard evidence yet that masks worked to slow the spread of this particular novel coronavirus. And, in retrospect, I get it (sort of). After all, in March and April, in my neck of the woods, it was damned near impossible to find toilet paper, and regular surgical masks were exorbitantly priced, even on Amazon, and took a month to ship. Even though I can understand the motivation, in retrospect it’s obvious how much harm this initial reticence caused.
By the time the Surgeon General issued updated advice on masks in April, it was too late:
Sharing the updated guidance we issued in April and have been articulating far & wide since then. We continue to learn new things about covid19 and strive to update all accordingly. https://t.co/59ce48GhZD
— Dr. Vivek Murthy, U.S. Surgeon General (@Surgeon_General) July 20, 2020
The original confusion had been a midwife to the birth of the antimask movement. Indeed, it was obvious by mid-March that this message had backfired spectacularly, as Dr. Zeynep Tufekci noted when she wrote about how to “help manage the shortage, the authorities sent a message that made them untrustworthy”:
First, many health experts, including the surgeon general of the United States, told the public simultaneously that masks weren’t necessary for protecting the general public and that health care workers needed the dwindling supply. This contradiction confuses an ordinary listener. How do these masks magically protect the wearers only and only if they work in a particular field?
Second, there were attempts to bolster the first message, that ordinary people didn’t need masks, by telling people that masks, especially medical-grade respirator masks (such as the N95 masks), needed proper fitting and that ordinary people without such fitting wouldn’t benefit. This message was also deeply counterproductive. Many people also wash their hands wrong, but we don’t respond to that by telling them not to bother. Instead, we provide instructions; we post signs in bathrooms; we help people sing songs that time their hand-washing. Telling people they can’t possibly figure out how to wear a mask properly isn’t a winning message. Besides, when you tell people that something works only if done right, they think they will be the person who does it right, even if everyone else doesn’t.
It also certainly didn’t help that the World Health Organization didn’t change its recommendations downplaying the importance of wearing masks until June. (In fact, I’ve long been frustrated at how slow the WHO has been in general to change its recommendations in response to new science.) This was particularly infuriating, given that, as Dr. Tufekci noted, mask use had always been advised as part of the standard response to being around infected people, especially for people who may be vulnerable, WHO officials were wearing masks during their news briefings, and since the SARS experience in 2003 that health officials in many high-risk Asian countries had advised wearing masks. She also pointed out that the messaging at the time also recommended that people who were sick should wear masks to protect others, further noting that, given the increasing evidence of asymptomatic transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, such advice would imply that everyone should wear masks when around others.
Indeed, just this Thursday, President Trump himself repeated misinformation about masks and COVID-19 during his televised town hall, mangling and misinterpreting a CDC study. Host Savannah Guthrie called him out for his misinterpretation of the study, leading Trump, in essence, to shrug his shoulders and respond, “That’s what I heard and that’s what I saw”. A week earlier, stories had been published describing how President Trump had blocked the CDC from requiring masks on public transportation.
Messaging screwups early in the pandemic aside, though, what about the “masks make you sicker” claim? Khazan states:
Versions of this advice also suggested that masks could raise the risk of illness. On March 12, Jenny Harries, England’s deputy chief medical officer, claimed that masks could “actually trap the virus.” Therefore, she said, “for the average member of the public walking down a street, it is not a good idea.” (Harries did not respond to a request for comment.)In fact, the earliest instance of a “masks make you sicker” claim I could find was in a February 27 news article published on a Utah radio station’s website. (Its author did not return a request for comment.) Though the article has since been updated, the original contains the subhead “Wearing a face mask incorrectly might put you at greater risk of getting sick.” The article then quotes a doctor named David Eisenman as saying, “I think people see a mask and they see an illusion of protection.” Though Eisenman’s quote does not quite support the subheading on the article, I reached out to him to see whether he still stands by his interview.
In short, he does not. “These things come back and haunt you,” Eisenman, a professor-in-residence at UCLA, told me. “Science recommendations have evolved. Now I would say that the evidence is very much in favor of masks as an important protector in the spread of COVID-19.”
This is very much like what happens with alternative medicine cancer cure testimonials. Once the testimonial of a cancer patient who chose alternative treatment instead of conventional science-based treatment is published, later information that the patient’s cancer progressed and the patient ultimately died often never find their way into the consciousness of people spreading the testimonial. As Grant Ritchey notes, this is partially due to the anchoring heuristic, in which a person places more significance on the first piece of information they receive than on subsequent pieces of information. In this case, the first piece of information was that mask wearing doesn’t protect the general public. (Never mind that the same message is that mask wearing did protect health care workers.) Add to that some motivated reasoning to cherry pick information, data, and studies that support one’s preexisting point of view and the message from President Trump and others turning the refusal to wear a mask into an ideological signifier, and the recipe for our current disaster of “mask wars” was written.
All of this has led to yet another example of how, once started, pseudoscientific misinformation is almost impossible (if not altogether impossible) to kill. As Khazan puts it:
The “masks make you sicker” idea underscores how online misinformation is like an ocean liner: Once it’s headed in one direction, it’s difficult to turn around. The advice on masks changed seven months ago, but some people have stuck with what experts were saying in the confusing early days. One doctor’s criticisms of masks—which he now recants—live on in Twitter threads. And as people find new ways to share incorrect information, through posts, photos, and videos, social-media platforms are struggling to catch and remove all the hokum. Before long, the conspiracy theories break free of Facebook and infect reality.
My only quibble is that conspiracy theories don’t “break free of Facebook.” They’ve always been free of Facebook. Facebook might be the single most powerful tool in existence to spread baseless conspiracy theories and pseudoscience, but conspiracy theories and pseudoscience spread in parallel in other ways, independent of Facebook. Those other ways don’t just include other social media platforms, such as Twitter, Instagram, Tik Tok, and others, but in society in general. People spread these conspiracy theories among themselves in their social circle, and it also spreads from there. In other words, Facebook reflects and amplifies preexisting conspiracy theories; it generally doesn’t create them. After all, 9/11 conspiracy theories appeared almost immediately after the World Trade Center attacks, even though current social media platforms didn’t exist back then, and the then-embryonic social media consisted of blogs (which were themselves new), Usenet, email lists, and some web-based discussion forums.
Unfortunately, the “masks make you sicker” narrative will likely prove as impervious to reason and evidence as 9/11 Truth, antivaccine, and climate change conspiracy theories that undergird so much science denial.

One More Time – Masks Work
The evidence supports the conclusion that mask-wearing policies are effective and justified.
Steven Novella on January 13, 2021
Link

Ten months into this pandemic there is still discussion about whether or not wearing a facemask helps prevent the spread of COVID-19. There is also some “mask-denial” which may just be poorly informed skepticism or ideologically driven. Masks have become, unfortunately, a political symbol. The evidence is also pretty clear that wearing facemasks helps protect against the spread of COVID-19. But the evidence is complex enough to feed (unjustified) denial, and warrants periodic review.
We need to first recognize that the question – do masks work? – is comprised of many subquestions. There are different kinds of masks, including cloth masks (and in fact there are different kinds of cloth masks), surgical masks, and masks designed specifically to filter out viruses, such as N95 masks. Compliance is an important variable – how consistent are people in wearing the mask, how well does it fit, and do they keep it dry? There are also different situations in which masks can be worn – in a hospital or other high-risk setting, in the presence of people known to be infected with COVID-19, or in the general community (which can be further divided by the rate of infection in the community). Does mask wearing protect the wearer or other people? Does it prevent infection and/or reduce the severity of infection? No one study is going to address all these questions.
There are also different kinds of evidence we can use to get at these questions. We can look to see how well masks prevent droplet spread, or even specifically viral spread. We can look at the risk of individuals for contracting the disease. We can look at epidemiological evidence to see if mask-wearing policies affect the spread of COVID-19. We can also look at the effect on spread of other viruses. Again, no single study is going to be definitive. We need to look at the pattern of evidence to see if it supports a beneficial role for wearing masks, what kinds of masks, in what settings, and with what benefits. Mask wearing as a measure also needs to be disentangled from other prevention methods, such as distancing, hand washing, and contact tracing.
With all that in mind, what is the current state of the evidence for wearing masks as a public health measure to fight the pandemic? The short answer is – the evidence is very strong that masks are beneficial, but let’s dive into the details.
A recent review found that all masks filter out droplets and viruses, but vary significantly based on mask type. Cloth masks were not as effective as hospital masks which were not as effective as N95 masks. One thing to point out here is that there is a clear “dose response” effect – the better masks were in fact better at filtering virus. This dose-response also holds up when comparing the spread of virus to people.
At this point the evidence is very clear that hospital masks and N95 masks are effective, but the evidence is equivocal for cloth masks. This is likely because of variables in cloth mask design. The two most significant variables seem to be the fit over the face, and the number of layers. Having a well-fitting mask with three layers of cloth works well (but still not as well as a hospital mask).
Epidemiological studies provide perhaps the best evidence for the efficacy of masks, or more specifically, mask policies. One study comparing mask-wearing policies in different states in the US found that after states initiated mask-wearing policies, the spread of the virus decreased. Another study found that the risk of a spreading event was far greater in “mask-off” social settings than “mask-on” settings. Comparing countries with different mask-wearing policies also finds a good correlation with reduced spread.
So masks reduce the spread of droplets and to some extent virus itself, they show a dose-response curve with mask quality, and epidemiological studies show a strong correlation between mask-wearing and reduced spread of COVID. This is more than sufficient evidence to justify mask-wearing policies, and to educate the public about what kinds of masks work and how to properly use them.
What is lacking is randomized controlled trials, mostly because of the practical and ethical hurdles of randomizing people to not wearing a mask, especially given the current state of the evidence and the fact that a deadly pandemic is still raging. There was one RTC of mask wearing, however – the DANMASK trial. The strength of this study is that it was randomized, people were instructed with good pandemic hygiene with one group advised to wear and mask and the other not. This was an intention to treat model. The results were statistically negative.
But there are significant limitations to this trial that caution against broad interpretation. The study was only powered to see a 50% reduction in infection. The rate in the community was already very low. Compliance with mask wearing in that group was <50%. Infections were self-reported. The dropout rate was high – 16%.
At most what this study shows is that simply recommending mask wearing in the community where the rate of infection is low will not produce a dramatic difference in infection rates – but even that conclusion is affected by the limitations of the study. This is certainly not strong enough evidence to counter the epidemiological evidence, which is more extensive and more compelling.
As a side note, there is also the incidental evidence that all the measures taken during the pandemic (not just mask wearing, but distancing as well) has caused all other respiratory virus infection rates to plummet. The CDC has been tracking the flu, cold viruses, and other viruses, and the spread of these illnesses over the last year has flatlined. Whatever we are doing, it is working to prevent infections by all droplet-spread viruses. They also warn these viruses are likely to rebound with a vengeance once pandemic measures are relaxed.
We always have to make medical decisions with imperfect evidence. The evidence for mask-wearing is imperfect and complex, but there is a strong signal in this data that wearing a quality mask properly and consistently protects the wearer and especially protects others. This is more than enough to justify universal mask-wearing in public until vaccination and herd immunity bring an end to this pandemic.
In fact, this evidence and the experience of this pandemic may change public health practices in the future. Hopefully people who may have the flu, or were just exposed, will feel more comfortable distancing and wearing a mask to reduce spread to others. These tools work to prevent the spread of respiratory viruses and we should use them.

How antimaskers weaponize techniques of scientific analysis to attack mask mandates
There’s a new paper out analyzing how antimask activists weaponize the tools of data visualization and scientific argumentation to produce convincing antimask propaganda. Antimaskers are claiming that it shows that they are more “scientific” than those supporting the consensus viewpoint with respect to COVID-19 and masks. What it really shows is that they are good at weaponizing the tools of data visualization and scientific arguments to come to the conclusions that they want to come to.
David Gorski on May 17, 2021
Link

After more than two decades dealing with antivaxxers, quacks, pseudoscience advocates, contrarians, and conspiracy theorists, I’ve noticed some things about how such people operate and view themselves. For example, virtually all of them believe themselves to be “brave mavericks” of some sort, unlike the run-of-the-mill “sheeple” who accept the narrative of mainstream science and, in their mind, cower before the authority of physicians and scientists on such matters. One other thing that I’ve noticed about them is that they truly believe that they are the scientific ones, the ones “following the science,” the “true” science, at least in their minds. Obviously, my observations are just that, personal observations. I don’t claim that they are scientific. That’s why I’m always interested to find studies that try to look at the characteristics of the arguments of antivaxxers, quacks, pseudoscience advocates, contrarians, and conspiracy theorists and one reason why I’m starting by listing these characteristics that I’ve noticed having observed the rhetoric of such people online going back to the days of Usenet. (Yes, I’m dating myself.) That’s why a new narrative going bubbling up among antimaskers, COVID-19 deniers, contrarians, and conspiracy theorists caught my attention over the weekend.
Here’s a representative series of Tweets:
This paper is a riot…must read for anyone that thinks that scientists are actually objective and looking at data using the scientific method. HINT: they aren't. 🙂@tickerguy https://t.co/h3j1fTR7tA
— Doc J (@ewtnewbie) May 11, 2021
MIT researchers 'infiltrated' a Covid skeptics community a few months ago and found that skeptics place a high premium on data analysis and empiricism.
"Most fundamentally, the groups we studied believe that science is a process, and not an institution."https://t.co/8hfX7TkC66
— Marco M (@pastamagistrat) May 12, 2021
"Indeed, anti-maskers often reveal themselves to be more sophisticated in their understanding of how scientific knowledge is socially constructed than their ideological adversaries, who espouse naïve realism about the “objective” truth of public health data."
— thersites (@commieleejones) May 10, 2021
"Its members value individual initiative and ingenuity, trusting scientific analysis only insofar as they can replicate it themselves by accessing and manipulating the data firsthand."
— thersites (@commieleejones) May 10, 2021
"Many of the users believe that the most important metrics are missing from government-released data."
"One user wrote: 'Coding data is a big deal—and those definitions should be offered transparently by every state. Without a national guideline—we are left with this mess'."
— thersites (@commieleejones) May 10, 2021
"In fact, there are multiple threads every week where users debate how representative the data are of the population given the increased rate of testing across many states."
— thersites (@commieleejones) May 10, 2021
"For these anti-mask users, their approach to the pandemic is grounded in more scientific rigor, not less."
— thersites (@commieleejones) May 10, 2021
That last Tweetstorm goes on a while longer, but those of you familiar with science denial were likely cringing at several of the quotes from the paper referenced. (More on that in a moment.) The reason, of course, is that they seems to be saying that antimaskers are more “scientific” than those supporting the primary scientific position.
Elsewhere, Michael Levitt, a professor of biophysics at Stanford and 2013 Nobel Laureate in Chemistry who’s decided that he’s an epidemiology and virology expert, leading him to become a COVID contrarian after the pandemic started, loves the article:
This is not a surprise.
Good scientists know just how wrong preconceptions are.
Science is driven by bravely questioning everything. All is assumed wrong until data shows otherwise.
A few so-called ‘scientists’ are scared nay-sayers. Deniers betraying the scientific method. https://t.co/NJaAO3PyGM
— Michael Levitt (@MLevitt_NP2013) May 13, 2021
Then, on Friday Mike Adams’ drone Ethan Huff over at Natural News wrote about this study under the title, “Vaccine propagandists infiltrated vaccine skeptics group, found that the skeptics are MORE scientific and rigorous in their thinking compared to obedient, dumbed-down mask wearers“. That’s why I was cringing as I read those quotes; it’s almost as though they were custom-made for antimaskers and COVID-19 contrarians to take the study and use it to promote exactly the message that Huff was promoting on Adams’ site.
The quotes I’ve included (because antivaxxers and antimaskers love them so much and are widely quoting them) are, admittedly, consistent with the self-view of antivaxxers and COVID-19 cranks that I’ve seen over the years. That’s why I decided that this week’s topic for me had to be this paper, a paper from the conference proceedings of CHI 2021 under Human-Computer Interaction (cs.HC); Computers and Society (cs.CY). It is currently available on the preprint server arXiv. The article is from MIT, credited to Crystal Lee, Tanya Yang, Gabrielle Inchoco, Graham M. Jones, Arvind Satyanarayan, and titled “Viral Visualizations: How Coronavirus Skeptics Use Orthodox Data Practices to Promote Unorthodox Science Online“, which was well-received:
Just to add to @aspenkhopkins. First, yes, most CS folks publish their research in conferences. Second, Crystal’s paper was published at CHI, the top venue is her field. The paper received Honorable Mention, which means it’s the top 5% of the submissions. https://t.co/vDlQ0M9m81
— Herman Saksono (he/him) (@hermansaksono) May 16, 2021
I found this helpful to learn, given that most conference proceedings in medicine are actually not as rigorously peer-reviewed as journal articles.
I had to see if this paper really concludes what antivaxxers and COVID-19 contrarians are claiming that it concludes. As you might imagine, the answer is: Not really. Unfortunately, the paper is written in a manner that makes it very easy for antimaskers and antivaxxers to portray it as concluding that they are more “scientific,” understand better that science is a process, and are thus more “dedicated to science” than those trying to combat COVID-19 disinformation. It’s another example of how I wish that researchers would consider how their words might be weaponized by cranks when they write papers like this, especially computer scientists without a lot of experience in techniques of disinformation. Had the authors simply asked a couple of skeptics in the trenches to read over their manuscript, they could likely have ameliorated this issue (but that’s probably just me with an overinflated view of my own importance). On the other hand, this take on the study is true:
Have witnessed this. The distrust seems to lie in expert interpretations of data, and consensus among experts.
It's very much1) Raw Data2) ???3) Conclusion,
where for (2) they swap expert consensus for their own read.
In fairness after Iraq, etc etc… 🤷
— Joi Ito's Jibo sez 🇺🇦 (@JMEightDigits) May 11, 2021
I’m probably being unfair. It was probably impossible to write such a paper in such a manner that parts of it couldn’t be selectively quoted. On the other hand, the authors didn’t have to make it just so easy.
Still, let’s dig in. Before I do, note that this paper is about what the authors describe as “antimaskers.” Appropriately (to me, at least), they use “animasker” as a “synecdoche for a broad spectrum of beliefs: that the pandemic is exaggerated, schools should be reopening, etc.,” further noting:
While groups who hold these beliefs are certainly heterogeneous, the mask is a common flashpoint throughout the ethnographic data, and they use the term “maskers” to describe people who are driven by fear. They are “anti-mask” by juxtaposition. This study therefore takes an emic (i.e. “insider”) approach to analyzing how members of these groups think, talk, and interact with one another, which starts by using terms that these community members would use to describe themselves.
As an aside, even though the study doesn’t really address the question, in my experience the Venn diagram between antimaskers and antivaxxers has at least 80% overlap, which is another reason this study interested me. It likely could apply to antivaxxers as well.
Using the same data to come to different conclusions
It will come as no surprise to scientists how scientists can examine the same data and come to different conclusions. The differences can come from emphasizing one dataset over another, doing a different kind of analysis, and a variety of other factors. It is thus not always obvious when a different interpretation of data drifts into contrarianism or even outright science denial, although frequently it is quite obvious (for example, the claim that vaccines cause autism). The abstract of this paper (sort of) acknowledges this point:
Controversial understandings of the coronavirus pandemic have turned data visualizations into a battleground. Defying public health officials, coronavirus skeptics on US social media spent much of 2020 creating data visualizations showing that the government’s pandemic response was excessive and that the crisis was over. This paper investigates how pandemic visualizations circulated on social media, and shows that people who mistrust the scientific establishment often deploy the same rhetorics of data-driven decision-making used by experts, but to advocate for radical policy changes. Using a quantitative analysis of how visualizations spread on Twitter and an ethnographic approach to analyzing conversations about COVID data on Facebook, we document an epistemological gap that leads pro- and anti-mask groups to draw drastically different inferences from similar data. Ultimately, we argue that the deployment of COVID data visualizations reflect a deeper sociopolitical rift regarding the place of science in public life.
That last sentence is a bit of a “Well, duh!” conclusion in my book, but that doesn’t mean it’s not worthwhile to explore it. In the introduction, the authors note:
Almost every US state now hosts a data dashboard on their health department website to show how the pandemic is unfolding. However, despite a preponderance of evidence that masks are crucial to reducing viral transmission [25, 29, 105], protestors across the United States have argued for local governments to overturn their mask mandates and begin reopening schools and businesses. A pandemic that affects a few, they reason, should not impinge on the liberties of a majority to go about life as usual. To support their arguments, these protestors and activists have created thousands of their own visualizations, often using the same datasets as health officials.
This paper investigates how these activist networks use rhetorics of scientific rigor to oppose these public health measures. Far from ignoring scientific evidence to argue for individual freedom, antimaskers often engage deeply with public datasets and make what we call “counter-visualizations”—visualizations using orthodox methods to make unorthodox arguments—to challenge mainstream narratives that the pandemic is urgent and ongoing. By asking community members to “follow the data,” these groups mobilize data visualizations to support significant local changes.
So far, so good. What the authors discuss in the introduction is undeniably true. Antimaskers and those who minimize the severity of the pandemic have become very skilled at making slick-looking figures to support their claims, often using the same datasets used by public health officials. Seeing how they do this on social media is, therefore, of interest. So how did the authors examine this question?
First, they examined the circulation of COVID-related data visualizations through quantitative and qualitative methods. They started with a quantitative analysis of nearly half a million Tweets that used data visualization to talk about the pandemic, while using network analysis to identify user communities who retweet the same content or engage with each other (such as antimaskers and those supporting mask mandates). They used a computer vision model to extract feature embeddings and identify clusters in visualization designs, noting that they found that “anti-mask groups on Twitter often create polished counter-visualizations that would not be out of place in scientific papers, health department reports, and publications like the Financial Times.”
In addition, the authors undertook a six month long observational study of antimask groups on Facebook over the period from March to September 2020, a time frame during which these groups formed and consolidated, justifying it thusly:
Quantitative analysis gives us an overview of what online discourse about data and its visual representation looks like on Twitter both within and outside anti-mask communities. Qualitative analysis of anti-mask groups gives us an interactional view of how these groups leverage the language of scientific rigor—being critical about data sources, explicitly stating analytical limitations of specific models, and more—in order to support ending public health restrictions despite the consensus of the scientific establishment.
I don’t know enough about the computer algorithms and methodology to comment extensively on the nitty-gritty of the visualization analysis performed, but I can comment a bit on the observational study, whose methods the authors describe thusly:
While qualitative research can involve clinical protocols like interviews or surveys, Clifford Geertz [45] argues that the most substantial ethnographic insights into the cultural life of a community come from “deep hanging out,” i.e., long-term, participant observation alongside its members. Using “lurking,” a mode of participating by observing specific to digital platforms, we propose “deep lurking” as a way of systematically documenting the cultural practices of online communities. Our methods here rely on robust methodological literature in digital ethnography [30, 69], and we employ a case study approach [92] to analyze these Facebook groups. To that end, we followed five Facebook groups (each with a wide range of followers, 10K-300K) over the first six months of the coronavirus pandemic, and we collected posts throughout the platform that included terms for “coronavirus” and “visualization” with Facebook’s CrowdTangle tool [33]. In our deep lurking, we archived web pages and took field notes on the following: posts (regardless of whether or not they included “coronavirus” and “data”), subsequent comments, Facebook Live streams, and photos of in-person events. We collected and analyzed posts from these groups from their earliest date to September 2020.
One aspect of this paper bothers me. Nowhere do the authors identify which antimask groups in which they “deep lurked,” other than to note that, since September, Facebook has “banned some of the groups we have studied, who have since moved to more unregulated platforms (Parler and MeWe).” I don’t recall having read a study of this type that didn’t explicitly list the Facebook pages examined.
As a preview of the findings, the authors write:
While previous literature in visualization and science communication has emphasized the need for data and media literacy as a way to combat misinformation [43, 47, 89], this study finds that anti-mask groups practice a form of data literacy in spades. Within this constituency, unorthodox viewpoints do not result from a deficiency of data literacy; sophisticated practices of data literacy are a means of consolidating and promulgating views that fly in the face of scientific orthodoxy. Not only are these groups prolific in their creation of counter-visualizations, but they leverage data and their visual representations to advocate for and enact policy changes on the city, county, and state levels.
This preview rings true to those of us who have studied antivaxxers and other groups that oppose the scientific consensus. If anything, science denialists tend to delve very deeply into the data. The problem, of course, is that their preconceptions are so strong that, to echo the old saying about drunks looking for their keys and a lamppost, they use data for support rather than illumination. While it is true that many, if not most, scientists approach data trying to test a hypothesis hoping to find support for it, meaning that they have some degree of bias, science denialists take natural human bias to an extreme in which they will parse the data into finer and finer bits until they find a way to support what they want to believe. Alternatively, as this paper suggests, they create data visualizations that support their point of view.
The authors visualized the Twitter networks using the Louvain method of community detection, a commonly used method of identifying communities in large networks, and found six main networks sharing COVID-related visualizations:
     1.  American politics and media.
     2.  American politics and right-wing media (red).
     3.  British news media.
     4.  Anti-mask network.
     5.  New York Times-centric network.
     6.  World Health Organization and health-related news organizations.
Of interest, the antimask network was found to be anchored by former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson, the man who has been called the “pandemic’s wrongest man,” as well as “blogger @EthicalSkeptic, and @justin_hart.” The authors also note that a key target of this network was The Atlantic‘s @Covid19Tracking project (which collates COVID-19 testing rates and patient outcomes across the United States). The antimask network also had the highest fraction of retweets of in-network Tweets.
Here is Figure 2, which includes a sampling of some antimask COVID-19 minimizing/denying countervisualizations:
The authors comment thusly on this figure:
While there are certainly visualizations that tend to use a meme-based approach to make their point (e.g., “Hey Fauci…childproof chart!” with the heads of governors used to show the rate of COVID fatalities), many of the visualizations shared by anti-mask Twitter users employ visual forms that are relatively similar to charts that one might encounter at a scientific conference. Many of these tweets use area and line charts to show the discrepancy between the number of projected deaths in previous epidemiological and the numbers of actual fatalities. Others use unit visualizations, tables, and bar charts to compare the severity of coronavirus to the flu. In total, this figure shows the breadth of visualization types that anti-mask users employ to illustrate that the pandemic is exaggerated.
And it is true. Antivaxxers, conspiracy theorists, and antimaskers have become very adept at producing memes and, as this study shows, data visualizations with deceptive messages. Overall, the authors identified eight major clusters of types of visualizations used by antimaskers: line charts (8,908 visualizations, 21% of the corpus), area charts (2,212, 5%), bar charts (3,939, 9%), pie charts (1,120, 3%), tables (4,496, 11%), maps (5,182, 13%), dashboards (2,472, 6%), and images (7,128, 17%), also noting that The remaining 6,248 media (15% of the corpus) “did not cluster in thematically coherent ways.”
Antimask discourse
Overall, the MIT investigators found seven main themes in antimask discourse:
     1.  Emphasis on original content.
     2.  Critically assessing data sources.
     3.  Critically assessing data representations.
     4.  Identifying bias and politics in data.
     5.  Appeals to scientific authority.
     6.  Developing expertise and processes of critical engagement.
     7.  Applying data to real-world situations.
To be honest, I was more interested in the qualitative analysis of the content of antimask Facebook groups than the quantitative analysis of the types of data visualizations they promote on Twitter, for the simple reason that it produced potentially more actionable information. I will do this in part by examining some of the quotes cherry picked by antimaskers and then putting them into context to show (1) how cherry picked they are and (2) that they do not mean what antimaskers think they mean. However, I will also discuss key points above. I’ll start with one favorite quote by antimaskers, namely that the paper supposedly concludes that they are more sophisticated in their understanding of science. Here’s the quote in context near the beginning of the article, the cited quote in bold:
As science and technology studies (STS) scholars have shown, data is not a neutral substrate that can be used for good or for ill [14, 46, 84]. Indeed, anti-maskers often reveal themselves to be more sophisticated in their understanding of how scientific knowledge is socially constructed than their ideological adversaries, who espouse naive realism about the “objective” truth of public health data. Quantitative data is culturally and historically situated; the manner in which it is collected, analyzed, and interpreted reflects a deeper narrative that is bolstered by the collective effervescence found within social media communities. Put differently, there is no such thing as dispassionate or objective data analysis. Instead, there are stories: stories shaped by cultural logics, animated by personal experience, and entrenched by collective action. This story is about how a public health crisis—refracted through seemingly objective numbers and data visualizations—is part of a broader battleground about scientific epistemology and democracy in modern American life.
Basically, this is the final paragraph of the introduction, in which the authors set up their story, which is how antimaskers use the fact that there is no such thing as a totally objective analysis of data. Of course, scientists do their best to eliminate as much bias as they reasonably can from their analysis. Antimaskers do not and dismiss criticism that their analyses are biased with observations that there is a socially constructed aspect to all scientific knowledge. It’s the same technique that antivaxxers use. Let’s just say that, in context, this quote does not support the contention that antimaskers are more sophisticated about science. Not really. I will, however, say that this sentence quoted by antimaskers is perhaps the most grating sentence in the paper, as it really doesn’t qualify the assertion made in the way that it needs to be qualified. For one thing, it utterly ignores the role of disinformation merchants in stoking antimask narratives, seemingly assuming honest motives in the case of all antimaskers.
Then there’s the quote about how antimaskers value “unmediated access” to information and privilege. Let’s see the statement in its context, which is that this desire for “unmediated access to information” is so that antimaskers can use that information to promote their message, which is what leads to an “emphasis on original content”:
Many anti-mask users express mistrust for academic and journalistic accounts of the pandemic, proposing to rectify alleged bias by “following the data” and creating their own data visualizations. Indeed, one Facebook group within this study has very strict moderation guidelines that prohibit the sharing of non-original content so that discussions can be “guided solely by the data.” Some group administrators even impose news consumption bans on themselves so that “mainstream” models do not “cloud their analysis.” In other words, anti-maskers value unmediated access to information and privilege personal research and direct reading over “expert” interpretations. While outside content is generally prohibited, Facebook group moderators encourage followers to make their own graphs, which are often shared by prominent members of the group to larger audiences (e.g., on their personal timelines or on other public facing Pages). Particularly in cases where a group or page is led by a few prominent users, follower-generated graphs tend to be highly popular because they often encourage other followers to begin their own data analysis projects, and comments on these posts often deal directly with how to reverse-engineer (or otherwise adjust) the visualization for another locality.
Of course, data transparency is a good thing. Scientists themselves argue about data transparency, and there is a growing movement to make raw data used in analyses available to other scientists for analysis. This has led to the creation of, for instance, databanks for genomic data. The problem with the data visualizations produced by antimaskers is that the vast majority of them do not know what they are doing and don’t even try to control for their own biases.
Consistent with their bias, the discussion of data sources and reliability by antimaskers tends to focus on exaggerated concerns about how data can be “manipulated” for nefarious purposes
Many of the users believe that the most important metrics are missing from government-released data. They express their concerns in four major ways. First, there is an ongoing animated debate within these groups about which metrics matter. Some users contend that deaths, not cases, should be the ultimate arbiter in policy decisions, since case rates are easily “manipulated” (e.g., with increased testing) and do not necessarily signal severe health problems (people can be asymptomatic). The shift in focus is important, as these groups believe that the emphasis on cases and testing often means that rates of COVID deaths by county or township are not reported to the same extent or seriously used for policy making.
But, later in the article, the authors point out how this is a “sleight of hand” (their very words):
For instance, they argue that there is an outsized emphasis on deaths versus cases: if the current datasets are fundamentally subjective and prone to manipulation (e.g., increased levels of faulty testing, asymptomatic vs. symptomatic cases), then deaths are the only reliable markers of the pandemic’s severity. Even then, these groups believe that deaths are an additionally problematic category because doctors are using a COVID diagnosis as the main cause of death (i.e., people who die because of COVID) when in reality there are other factors at play (i.e., dying with but not because of COVID). Since these categories are fundamentally subject to human interpretation, especially by those who have a vested interest in reporting as many COVID deaths as possible, these numbers are vastly over-reported, unreliable, and no more significant than the flu.
Although the authors didn’t state it this way, I will. Antimaskers, because of their exaggerated concern over “manipulation” of the data, either go to great lengths to find ways to manipulate the data themselves to show what they want it to show or to place a naive faith in the “raw data,” which brings us to #3 and their criticism of data representations. The idea is conspiratorial at its core, namely that somehow the “raw data” are more pure and “can’t be spun”:
An ongoing topic of discussion is whether to visualize absolute death counts as opposed to deaths per capita, and it is illustrative of a broader mistrust of mediation. For some, “raw data” (e.g., counts) provides more accurate information than any data transformation (e.g., death rate per capita, or even visualizations themselves). For others, screenshots of tables are the most faithful way to represent the data, so that people can see and interpret it for themselves. “No official graphs,” said one user. “Raw data only. Why give them an opportunity to spin?” (June 14, 2020). These users want to understand and analyze the information for themselves, free from biased, external intervention.
This feeds into #4 and the identification of bias and politics. The authors cite various posts in which those creating data visualizations admit their bias but argue that, by sticking as close as possible to the “raw data,” they can “keep the effect of bias to a minimum.” But where does this bias that they fear so much come from? A lot of them point to “specific profit motives that come from releasing (or suppressing) specific kinds of information.” In addition, consistent with my aforementioned guesstimate of the high overlap between antimaskers and antivaxxers, the authors note that many are suspicious of the benefits of a coronavirus vaccine, predictably pointing out “how the tobacco industry has historically manipulated science to mislead consumers.” (Yes, as I’ve frequently pointed out, antivaxxers love to point to tobacco companies and how they manipulated and denied science, all while remaining conveniently ignorant that they are using exactly the same sorts of techniques to do the same thing.) Unsurprisingly, the authors found evidence that antimaskers believe that pharmaceutical companies have “similarly villainous profit motives, which leads the industry to inflate data about the pandemic in order to stoke demand for a vaccine.”
One of the more ironic, but not entirely unexpected findings of this paper is how antimaskers crave scientific respectability and, to try to gain it, have used appeals to scientific authority, which brings me to the quote about how this paper supposedly found that antimaskers are more, not less scientifically rigorous. I think you’ll see how blatantly that line (in bold) was cherry picked to convey a different meaning than what the authors intended:
Paradoxically, these groups also seek ways to validate their findings through the scientific establishment. Many users prominently display their scientific credentials (e.g., referring to their doctoral degrees or prominent publications in venues like Nature) which uniquely qualify them as insiders who are most well-equipped to criticize the scientific community. Members who perform this kind of expertise often point to 2013 Nobel Laureate Michael Levitt’s assertion that lockdowns do nothing to save lives [67] as another indicator of scientific legitimacy. Both Levitt and these anti-mask groups identify the dangerous convergence of science and politics as one of the main barriers to a more reasonable and successful pandemic response, and they construct their own data visualizations as a way to combat what they see as health misinformation. “To be clear. I am not downplaying the COVID epidemic,” said one user. “I have never denied it was real. Instead, I’ve been modeling it since it began in Wuhan, then in Europe, etc. […] What I have done is follow the data. I’ve learned that governments, that work for us, are too often deliberately less than transparent when it comes to reporting about the epidemic” (July 17, 2020). For these anti-mask users, their approach to the pandemic is grounded in a more scientific rigor, not less.
Notice how in no way are the authors claiming that antimaskers’ approach to the pandemic is more scientifically rigorous. They’re simply making a statement about how antimaskers themselves believe that their approach to the pandemic is more scientific. Also note how the authors mention Michael Levitt, whose copious pronouncements on COVID-19 have been referred to as “lethal nonsense” (based on his having declared the pandemic “over” in August). More recently, Levitt has been downplaying the number of deaths from COVID-19 in Brazil. Unfortunately, his status as a Nobel Laureate has given his pronouncements on COVID-19 far more heft in the media than they observe.
Of course, it is no surprise to any skeptic who’s followed, for example, the antivaccine movement or other science denialist movements that the cranks in those movements, even as they castigate science as “corrupt,” crave the legitimacy that science brings, which is why antivaxxers latch on to the pronouncements of physicians and scientists with no special expertise in the relevant disciplines to back up their claims. Examples of such scientists abound, and include people like James Lyons-Weiler, a bioinformaticist who’s recast himself as a vaccine expert and now—surprise! surprise!—a COVID-19 expert; Paul Thomas, a pediatrician with no expertise in clinical trials or vaccines who claims to be doing a clinical study of vaccines; Christopher Exley, a chemist who fancies himself a vaccine expert; Christopher Shaw, a neuroscientist who also fancies himself a vaccine expert; and the father-son duo of Mark and David Geier, neither of whom has any specific expertise in autism or fields relevant to vaccines. The same thing is happening with COVID-19, as the case of Levitt demonstrates. He’s a structural biologist whose Nobel Prize was in chemistry. Before the pandemic, he has no special expertise in epidemiology, infectious disease, pandemic modeling, or anything else relevant to COVID-19. Sadly, since the pandemic, he hasn’t developed any such expertise.
The list of such scientists with no special expertise who have become the darlings of antimaskers is a long and dishonorable one. Worse, occasionally, there are even scientists who really should know better, some of whom actually have relevant expertise, who have fallen down the rabbit hole of COVID-19 minimization. Great Barrington Declaration, anyone?
Then there’s the part about “individual initiative”:
Anti-maskers have deftly used social media to constitute a cultural and discursive arena devoted to addressing the pandemic and its fallout through practices of data literacy. Data literacy is a quintessential criterion for membership within the community they have created. The prestige of both individual anti-maskers and the larger Facebook groups to which they belong is tied to displays of skill in accessing, interpreting, critiquing, and visualizing data, as well as the pro-social willingness to share those skills with other interested parties. This is a community of practice [63, 102] focused on acquiring and transmitting expertise, and on translating that expertise into concrete political action. Moreover, this is a subculture shaped by mistrust of established authorities and orthodox scientific viewpoints. Its members value individual initiative and ingenuity, trusting scientific analysis only insofar as they can replicate it themselves by accessing and manipulating the data firsthand. They are highly reflexive about the inherently biased nature of any analysis, and resent what they view as the arrogant self-righteousness of scientific elites.
As a subculture, anti-masking amplifies anti-establishment currents pervasive in U.S. political culture. Data literacy, for antimaskers, exemplifies distinctly American ideals of intellectual selfreliance, which historically takes the form of rejecting experts and other elites [53]. The counter-visualizations that they produce and circulate not only challenge scientific consensus, but they also assert the value of independence in a society that they believe promotes an overall de-skilling and dumbing-down of the population for the sake of more effective social control [39, 52, 98]. As they see it, to counter-visualize is to engage in an act of resistance against the stifling influence of central government, big business, and liberal academia. Moreover, their simultaneous appropriation of scientific rhetoric and rejection of scientific authority also reflects longstanding strategies of Christian fundamentalists seeking to challenge the secularist threat of evolutionary biology [11].
This is, of course, an apt comparison, one that the antimaskers quoting this paper so approvingly seem to have…missed…in their praise of the study. I wonder why. Of course, creationism (a.k.a. evolution denial) in all its forms, particularly “intelligent design” creationism (which does not dispute that evolution takes place but co-opts scientific arguments to argue that there must be a “designer” (a.k.a. God) guiding evolution) does indeed use similar techniques. Indeed, whole organizations have been set up for this purpose. One could even say that the most prominent of these anti-evolution groups, the Discovery Institute, is mimicking science by having been set up as an “institute” to imitate legitimate scientific societies and “institutes.” It’s tempting to note how heavily evangelical Christians are represented in antimask activism and wonder how much overlap there is in a Venn diagram of creationists or evolution deniers and antimaskers. (Oh, wait. I just did.)
Two things that antimaskers get right and wrong simultaneously
Interestingly, antimaskers don’t get everything wrong. They are, however, an example of how they can get something right in the wrong way, such that it leads them astray. For instance, let’s look in context at another quote that antimaskers have been cherry picking (bolded):
Most fundamentally, the groups we studied believe that science is a process, and not an institution. As we have outlined in the case study, these groups mistrust the scientific establishment (“Science”) because they believe that the institution has been corrupted by profit motives and politics. The knowledge that the CDC and academics have created cannot be trusted because they need to be subject to increased doubt, and not accepted as consensus. In the same way that climate change skeptics have appealed to Karl Popper’s theory of falsification to show why climate science needs to be subjected to continuous scrutiny in order to be valid [42], we have found that anti-mask groups point to Thomas Kuhn’s The Structure of Scientific Revolutions to show how their anomalous evidence—once dismissed by the scientific establishment—will pave the way to a new paradigm (“As I’ve recently described, I’m no stranger to presenting data that are inconsistent with the narrative. It can get ugly. People do not give up their paradigms easily. […] Thomas Kuhn wrote about this phenomenon, which occurs repeatedly throughout history. Now is the time to hunker down. Stand with the data,” August 5, 2020). For anti-maskers, valid science must be a process they can critically engage for themselves in an unmediated way. Increased doubt, not consensus, is the marker of scientific certitude.
Doubt is the product of antimaskers, just as it was the product of tobacco companies and is the product of, for example, antivaxxers and climate science denialists. This paper highlights how this is true, pointing out how very skilled antimaskers have become at sifting through data and finding areas of uncertainty to highlight as a means of casting doubt on specific scientific consensuses.
As I’ve discussed before, climate science deniers love to quote Michael Crichton’s infamous statements, such as, “Let’s be clear: the work of science has nothing whatever to do with consensus” and “There is no such thing as consensus science. If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it’s science, it isn’t consensus. Period.” I’ve responded to this nonsense before in detail, which is a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of science. (After all, as I asked, what is a scientific theory like the theory of evolution or Einstein’s theory of relativity but a statement of the current scientific consensus regarding a major scientific topic?) Also, explanatory power is all; if your model has no explanatory or predictive power, it’s useless. So, basically, antimaskers (from my perspective) have the correct understanding that science is a process not an institution and not just a body of knowledge, but they use it to draw the wrong conclusions about scientific consensus and how to approach data.
The authors also have a point about data transparency, as I mentioned above, and consistency of coding:
This plays into a third problem that users identify with the existing data: that datasets are constructed in fundamentally subjective ways. They are coded, cleaned, and aggregated either by government data analysts with nefarious intentions or by organizations who may not have the resources to provide extensive documentation. “Researchers can define their data set anyhow [sic] they like in absence of generally accepted (preferably specified) definitions,” one user wrote on June 23, 2020. “Coding data is a big deal—and those definitions should be offered transparently by every state. Without a national guideline—we are left with this mess.” The lack of transparency within these data collection systems—which many of these users infer as a lack of honesty—erodes these users’ trust within both government institutions and the datasets they release.
These statements about data collection and standardization weren’t wrong, particularly early in the pandemic. The problem is that they use this as an excuse to “analyze” the data they can access any way they want.
Implications
There are a number of implications of this study, if its findings hold up. Perhaps the implication that’s most counterintuitive to skeptics and science communicators is that increasing data literacy in the public will not, in and of itself, mitigate the effects of misinformation and disinformation. As I quoted the authors above, they have a form of data literacy “in spades.” Similarly, the authors note:
Powerful research and media organizations paid for by the tobacco or fossil fuel industries [79, 86] have historically capitalized on the skeptical impulse that the “science simply isn’t settled,” prompting people to simply “think for themselves” to horrifying ends.
Horrifying ends indeed. Also:
As David Buckingham [17] has noted, calls for increased literacy have often become a form of wrong-headed solutionism that posits education as the fix to all media-related problems. danah boyd [16] has documented, too, that calling for increased media literacy can often backfire: the instruction to “question more” can lead to a weaponization of critical thinking and increased distrust of media and government institutions. She argues that calls for media literacy can often frame problems like fake news as ones of personal responsibility rather than a crisis of collective action.
And:
While previous literature in visualization and science communication has emphasized the need for data and media literacy as a way to combat misinformation [43, 47, 89], this study finds that anti-mask groups practice a form of data literacy in spades. Within this constituency, unorthodox viewpoints do not result from a deficiency of data literacy; sophisticated practices of data literacy are a means of consolidating and promulgating views that fly in the face of scientific orthodoxy. Not only are these groups prolific in their creation of counter-visualizations, but they leverage data and their visual representations to advocate for and enact policy changes on the city, county, and state levels.
The problem isn’t a deficit in information, data, or data literacy. It’s how all that is weaponized. As the authors note, the problem isn’t that antimaskers need more scientific literacy, which characterizes their approach as uninformed. Quite the opposite. They are not uninformed, or, as the authors write, “This study shows the opposite: users in these communities are deeply invested in forms of critique and knowledge production that they recognize as markers of scientific expertise.” Nor will creating “better” data visualizations ameliorate this problem. The problem is that it’s a form of critique and knowledge production that is by design in opposition of “consensus” in a way that has a hard time even considering that the consensus might have a point, scientifically speaking. All this critique is primarily done as an act of “resistance,” rather than for purposes of scientific illumination. This makes it prone to its own set of extreme biases, biases that antimaskers don’t really admit, if they even recognize them. Meanwhile, hordes of “citizen scientists” now think themselves better than epidemiologists at analyzing data.
One huge disappointment I had about this paper is that, disappointingly, it hardly touched on the role of ideologically motivated astroturf groups in encouraging antimaskers, providing them with ideas and support, and helping them publicize their message. “Astroturf” refers to campaigns that are orchestrated by ideological groups but designed to appear to be “grassroots,” hence the term “astroturf,” or fake grass roots. Remember the Great Barrington Declaration, the document signed by three scientists that advocated, in essence, letting COVID-19 rip through the healthy population in order to achieve herd immunity, all while using “focused protection” to keep safe the elderly and those with comorbidities that put them at high risk from the disease. It was, as I put it, eugenics-adjacent, if not straight up eugenics. It was also the product of a right wing think tank that conceived and promoted the declaration, using it to lobby governments to lift “lockdowns” and “open up” again. It’s a group that likens itself and fellow antimaskers to “abolitionists“.
The authors seem to assume that the bulk of antimask activity on social media producing data “countervisualizations” is organic in nature, but we know that it’s not. Tobacco companies were real and tried to counter and deny the science showing the harmful health effects of smoking. Fossil fuel companies are real and, through their influence and cash, assisted by right wing think tanks, promote denial of climate science. The same phenomenon has occurred with COVID-19. Disinformation campaigns about COVID-19 mitigation measures promoting antimask and anti-“lockdown” demonstrations have been shown to be astroturf fueled by right wing donors, such as the Koch brothers, with support and behind-the-scenes coordination from The Convention of States project, which has been funded by Republican megadonor Robert Mercer’s family foundation, and two members of Trump’s White House, Ken Cuccinelli, Acting Director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, and Ben Carson, Secretary of Housing And Urban Development. Indeed, a number of these campaigns have been generated by well-funded organizations. One example was the promotion of hydroxychloroquine as a cure for COVID-19. (If you have a cheap cure for COVID-19, you don’t need lockdowns.) So how much of this activity described by Lee et al is truly organic, and how much is a result of astroturf? That is the question, isn’t it? What disappointing to me is that the authors hardly even touched on this question, even as an area for future research.
My one disappointment aside, I do think this article is a major contribution in that it shows that the problem is most definitely not an information deficit problem, nor is it a science literacy problem. As the authors conclude:
In other words, our paper introduces new ways of thinking about “democratizing” data analysis and visualization. Instead of treating increased adoption of data-driven storytelling as an unqualified good, we show that data visualizations are not simply tools that people use to understand the epidemiological events around them. They are a battleground that highlight the contested role of expertise in modern American life.
Science has always been a battleground. COVID-19 is just the latest front, and it’s being waged by people like this:
They can even sometimes give the appearance of being justified in their boasts, but in reality:
I couldn’t have said it better myself.

School mask mandate wars: Politics (Florida) v. Science (North Carolina)
Florida’s governor, Ron DeSantis, dictated a state-wide ban on school mask mandates based on misinformation and pure politics, while North Carolina officials took a bipartisan approach to masking based on science.
Jann Bellamy on August 26, 2021
Link

As schools reopen across the country, mask mandates are a hot button issue. Today we look at how two conservative southern states handled mandates with vastly different approaches. In one, North Carolina, decisions are based on bipartisan compromise and science, while in the other, Florida, a dictate from the governor relies on misinformation and raw politics. I happen to live in one (Florida), but (fortunately) spend a lot of my summer in the other (North Carolina), giving me something of a front-row seat from which to view the controversy.
North Carolina
As happened in many states, North Carolina’s students, teachers, and parents were subjected to a shifting and sometimes confusing variety of studies, orders, and directives related to K-12 school closures during the 2020-21 academic year. But this past spring, after a protracted battle between the Republican-controlled legislature and Gov. Roy Cooper, a Democrat, the legislature unanimously passed, and the governor signed, a compromise bill, The Reopen Our Schools Act of 2021, paving the way for in-person instruction for the remainder of the school year.
Under the Act, local school boards could choose “Plan A” or “Plan B”, which required different safety measures for reinstituting in-person instruction, with Plan A offering expanded opportunities for reopening classrooms.
However, school boards choosing Plan A were also required to
partner with the ABC Science Collaborative of the School of Medicine at Duke University (ABC Collaborative) to allow the ABC Collaborative to collect and analyze data from . . . students in Plan A in grades six through 12. A local board shall both engage in robust contact tracing and report on requested information in the form specified by the ABC Collaborative.
By way of background, the ABC Science Collaborative describes itself as
an initiative that extends across 13 states, connecting scientists and physicians with school and community leaders to help understand the most current and relevant information about COVID-19. The program helps school leaders and state policymakers arrive at informed decisions about returning to school using data from their own communities. . . The ABC Science Collaborative is coordinated by the Duke Clinical Research Institute at the Duke University School of Medicine and is funded through grants from the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences, the National Institutes of Health, and the Food and Drug Administration.
The ABC Collaborative was to report interim results and a final analysis to the state, the latter by June 30, 2021.
Let me pause here to remark on how extraordinary I find this provision of the Act, requiring a science-based collection and analysis of data by a reputable institution in order to inform public health policy, and in a unanimously-passed bipartisan bill to boot! With the caveat that I have not looked at legislation in any systematic way for similar provisions, in my decade-plus of posting here on SBM I cannot recall writing about a piece of legislation mandating the legitimate collection and analysis of data on which to base public health policy. In fact, although I admittedly focus on such subjects, what I regularly encounter is the wholesale incorporation of pseudoscience into state and federal laws and policies affecting the public’s health. There outta be a law, and it should look like this one.
From March to June, 2021, the ABC Collaborative, apparently expanding the reach of its original mandate, collected data from all North Carolina elementary, middle, and high schools operating under Plan A, which included in-person instruction, masking, and minimal physical distancing (3 feet or under). The data represent 100 local school districts and 14 charter schools, comprising more than 1,280,000 students and 160,000 staff. As the lead authors of the report explained in a New York Times Guest Essay, because there was a universal school mask mandate at the time of their data collection, they could not compare masked to unmasked schools. They did, however, look to data from other jurisdictions examining these situations.
The Collaborative’s final report concluded that:
North Carolina schools were highly successful in preventing the transmission of COVID-19 within school buildings and offers science-based learnings for the nation’s schools to limit COVID-19 spread.
In particular, the data showed that:
    • Proper masking is the most effective mitigation strategy to prevent COVID-19 transmission in schools when vaccination is unavailable or there are insufficient levels of vaccination among students and staff;
    • With masking in place, Plan A – full, in-person instruction – is appropriate for all grades and all schools;
    • Full-capacity bus transportation can and should resume, with the seating of up to three masked students per bus seat;
    • Some within-school guidelines can be relaxed, e.g., quarantine can be modified for people who were exposed to COVID-19 but are either vaccinated or were appropriately masked when exposed; and
    • Schools should examine safety protocols surrounding athletics. With proper safety protocols in place, particularly vaccination, schools could resume fall athletics while limiting the spread of COVID-19.
In addition to this report, the Collaborative has authored The Year in Review and a Path Forward, described as offering “a road map for school leaders and policymakers to use the latest science as they plan the path forward for K-12 in-person instruction”. (As you shall see, I know someone who could really use a copy.)
For the current (2021-22) academic year, Gov. Cooper declined to issue a state-wide mandate, opting instead to have each school district choose whether to implement a mask requirement. The Raleigh News & Observer reports that, as of August 24th, 27 of the 115 total districts have made masks optional. All of those districts are in rural or “red” areas and many have low COVID vaccination rates. Eighty-eight districts, accounting for 78% of the state’s 1.5 million public school students, have decided to require masking in school buildings and on busses; some will even require masks outdoors. At least 35 districts reversed their original decision to make masks optional, some after Gov. Cooper sent them a letter requesting the change. It is unknown how many of the state’s charter and laboratory schools, accounting for 9% of the total student population, will require masks.
According to the News & Observer, even where masks are required, a parent can request an opt-out “if a medical or learning issue” prevents masking, but the final decision on exemptions resides with each school.
Not everyone is happy with this plan, nor is everyone satisfied with the districts’ individual decisions. A doctors’ group has a petition on change.org urging Gov. Cooper to institute a statewide mask mandate for schools via executive order. In Union County, where the school board voted to make masks optional, local physicians urging the board to institute a mask requirement asked a newspaper to keep their identities confidential due to fears of retaliation. A school board member who voted to make masks optional reported personal attacks on her character and the board to the same newspaper.
Nevertheless, in sum, in North Carolina, a bipartisan law created a plan to collect and analyze data on which the state government and local school boards could base their decisions. Some districts have apparently embraced the science, while others have not. The net results is that, for now, over three-quarters of North Carolina’s public school students are under a mask mandate which, while not without some controversy, has maintained local control by decision makers acting in what they believe is their constituents’ best interests, whether or not we might agree with the results.
Florida
With this in mind, let’s turn to my home state, Florida
On July 30, 2021, Gov. Ron DeSantis issued an Executive Order that essentially banned mask mandates in Florida public schools. (Technically, it directed the state’s health and education agencies to develop rules “to ensure safety protocols for controlling the spread of COVID-19 in schools”, but the results are preordained by the Order.) He had previously ordered that all public schools be open for in-person instruction five days a week.
Gov. DeSantis’s Order was chock full of cherry-picked evidence, unsupported assertions, COVID myths, and downright falsehoods, all wrapped in a protective coating of “parental rights” talking points designed to please his base. He rested his authority to issue the Order on a new state law he signed in June of this year, the “Parents Bill of Rights”, which prevents the state and other units of government
from infringing on the fundamental rights of a parent to direct the upbringing, education, health care, or mental health of a minor child without demonstrating that such action is reasonable and necessary to achieve a compelling state interest and that such action is narrowly tailored and is not otherwise served by less restrictive means . . .
How this new law will affect cases, like this one, where parents choose “alternative” remedies over science-based treatments remains to be seen. In the case of local mask mandates, my view is that they could meet even this tough standard, but only if science is correctly applied to the matter, which, as you will see, is not part of the governor’s plan.
In the Order, the governor refutes the CDC’s mask wearing guidance as lacking “a well-grounded scientific justification”, citing a Brown University study done by an economist using now-outdated data, which Kaiser Health News concluded was “cherry-picked” by the governor and offered “little basis for his position and includes a variety of elements that are not accurate.” A pediatrics professor at the University of Florida called DeSantis’s claim “patently false”.
The Order also says that there is “no statistically-significant evidence to suggest that counties with mask requirements have fared any better than those without mask requirements during the 2020-2021 school year”. Of course, “fared any better” is vague. By what metric? Number of cases? Hospitalizations? Deaths? We don’t know because the Order cites no evidence in support of this assertion. And the general public (which is apparently who he is referring to) is not the same population as school students. However, we do know that modeling and epidemiological studies (like that of the ABC Science Collaborative) support masking in general and masking for school students in particular.
Again citing no evidence, the Order asserts that “masking children may lead to negative health and societal ramifications” and that “studies have shown that children are at a low risk of contracting a serious illness due to COVID-19 and do not play a significant role in the spread of the virus”. In fact, the most you could say is that the evidence is uncertain regarding spread and, in any event, it partly depends on the community rate, which is quite high in Florida right now. And, if it was ever true that children are at low risk of contracting COVID or experiencing serious symptoms, as SBM’s own Dr. Jonathan Howard has explained, that is no longer the case.
Finally, the Order, ensuring that even more COVID mask myths are blessed with the official imprimatur of state government, and once again without citing any evidence, claims that masks “could inhibit breathing, lead to the collection of dangerous impurities including bacteria, parasites, fungi, and other contaminants, and adversely affect communications in the classroom and student performance.” No, masks do not interfere with breathing and no, they do not collect “dangerous impurities” if you wear a clean mask (duh!). On the latter point, it is interesting that the governor, who totally trusts parents to make momentous decisions regarding their children’s health, suddenly finds they can’t be trusted with basic hygiene measures, like keeping their children’s stuff clean.
We simply do not have enough data to conclude one way or another on the effect masks have on learning but, in the words of one research psychologist who studies the cognitive and social development of children:
Ultimately, how children feel about wearing masks at school, and how much they psychologically benefit from wearing them, is going to depend on how the parents, teachers and caregivers around them present the issue.
Certainly, we can well imagine that a child, too young to fully evaluate the issue on his own, taken to a mask protest by his parents and told to hold up a sign an anti-mask sign, might become anxious and confused when his school district imposes a mask mandate.
The governor’s Order threatened local school districts with financial penalties for failure to comply, giving the Florida Commissioner of Education the authority to pursue “all legal means available to ensure school districts” obey the his dictates, including withholding state funds from noncompliant school boards.
In addition, in an incredibly irresponsible and undoubtedly politically-motivated move, the Florida Department of Health’s “How do I prevent and prepare for COVID?” webpage does not include mask-wearing, although it does include a link to the CDC at the bottom of the page. The CDC does, of course, advise to “wear a mask”, science-based advice the governor rejected.
This, I am pleased to report, has resulted in a coup against DeSantis by some school districts, who have enacted varying forms mask mandates for students and faculty in open defiance of his Executive Order. As of Wednesday morning, ten districts, including some of the largest, like Miami-Dade and Hillsborough (Tampa), representing over half of Florida’s public school students, have these mandates in place.
In response, state officials have doubled down with the threats, promising to dock the salaries of, and possibly remove, school board members who vote to enact mandates. Officials are seeking compensation records of board members voting for mandates in two districts, Alachua (Gainesville, home of the University of Florida) and Broward (Ft. Lauderdale). (Three Broward teachers recently died of COVID.) The state is expected to move against other board members this week.
The governor’s office has also doubled down on the misinformation. Just yesterday, a Washington Post news report quoted the governor’s press secretary saying, again falsely,
There is no empirical evidence to support the assertion that the benefits of forced masking of schoolchildren outweigh the potential harms. Masking kids under 12 is not recommended in many EU countries, because their health authorities have found that the risks are not well understood — and the data shows that forced masking of young children has a negligible impact on covid prevalence and spread.
The Post dutifully reported that “public health experts dispute this”, quoting a pediatric infectious disease physician from the Mayo Clinic who said that “studies have unequivocally shown that there are no negative health effects on children from wearing a mask.” As for what Europe is doing, the hypocrisy is, once again, interesting. I’m pretty certain that Gov. DeSantis would reject European public health authorities’ opinions on, say, gun control or universal health care coverage. In any event, I did not check the mask policies in each of the 28 EU countries, but reports from European health authorities like the Association of Schools of Public Health in the European Region, the European Academy of Paedatrics, and the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control show that they have (unlike the governor) fully evaluated the evidence and recommend masking in school settings, depending on local conditions and with exceptions for certain students (like those too young or the disabled).
The federal government has now joined forces with the renegade school boards, with Pres. Biden and his Secretary of Education offering financial support and threatening litigation. Parents have filed their own lawsuits against the state, one of which is being tried in Leon County (Tallahassee) right now, with none other than Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, of Great Barrington Declaration fame, testifying on behalf of the state.
Florida’s “chaotic” school openings are playing out against Florida’s alarming COVID stats, including its pediatric cases. (I am heartbroken that these include the deaths of two children in my own community this month.) Just-opened schools are having to shut down because of COVID, almost 30,000 students, teachers and staff are in quarantine, and health departments are backlogged on contact tracing. Seventeen school employees, including teachers, have died of COVID just since August 1st. At the same time, public opinion polls show support for both mask and COVID vaccine mandates for students and teachers.
To be fair, pediatric cases in North Carolina are on the rise as well, as they are nationally, but I could not find that any schools had shut down, nor could I find any statistics on the number of students and school staff in quarantine, if any. School personnel have died from COVID in the state, although none recently that I could find.
Compare and contrast
So, in states with comparable political climates, one, North Carolina, in a bipartisan effort, looked to the data and science to inform decision-making on mask mandates and left the issue to local control, resulting in over three-quarters of public school students being under a mask mandate. In the other, Florida, the governor dictated to local school boards what they must do based on repeated misrepresentations of the evidence and is now threatening to impose financial and other penalties on school board members who have been elected to office by the citizens of their own communities, all in a state with some of the worst COVID stats in the country and in defiance of public opinion.
And here’s the really disturbing part: Gov. DeSantis’s Executive Order could have, like North Carolina’s report, set forth the actual evidence and declared parents should decide. In other words, the same result, just without the misinformation. It wouldn’t be the result the scientific and educational community might prefer, but at least the state wouldn’t be complicit in spreading falsehoods. But he didn’t. He chose to manipulate parents, the ones he claims he trusts to make the best choices for their children, with cherry-picked and fabricated “facts” (and easily debunked at that) in order to achieve the results he wanted.
Which approach do you think is best?
UPDATE: Judge throws out Gov. Ron DeSantis’ ban on mandatory masks in Florida schools. Tallahassee Democrat, August 27, 2021.

Legislatures and litigation: anti-vaxxers continue attacks on COVID mitigation
Anti-vaxxers are attacking COVID-19 mandates in state legislatures and in court even as COVID-19 cases numbers and hospitalizations remain high among the unvaccinated.
Jann Bellamy on June 3, 2021
Link

A so-called “health freedom” group is touting recently passed state laws crippling government and private sector measures to mitigate the COVID pandemic. Meanwhile, on another front, anti-vaxxers are attacking these measures in court.
If their intent is to ensure that COVID-19 case numbers and hospitalizations remain high among the unvaccinated, they are doing a good job. According to a recent analysis by The Washington Post, while national case numbers and hospitalizations are declining,
adjustments for vaccinations show the rate among susceptible, unvaccinated people is 73 percent higher than the standard figures being publicized. With that adjustment, the national death rate is roughly the same as it was two months ago and is barely inching down. The adjusted hospitalization rate is as high as it was three months ago.
For example,
When current hospitalizations are spread across only the unvaccinated population, D.C. and Michigan have rates about twice as high as the adjusted national rate. Pennsylvania, Maryland, Florida and Rhode Island have rates about 50 percent higher than the adjusted national hospitalization rate.
And in Washington state,
unvaccinated seniors are 11 times as likely to get hospitalized than seniors who got the shot. For unvaccinated people age 45 to 64, the chance of covid-19 hospitalization is 18 times higher.
Well done, anti-vaxxers.
“Right to Refuse”
National Health Freedom Action and its sister organization, National Health Freedom Coalition, support your “right” to be bamboozled by charlatans with their promotion of so-called “health freedom” laws or, as I prefer to call them, Quack Protection Acts. These laws, passed in eleven states, prohibit the prosecution of quacks for the unlicensed practice of medicine, leaving them free to diagnose and treat the vulnerable and desperately ill with their dangerous nostrums, confident in the knowledge that the state’s authority to hold them responsible has been effectively neutered.
Apparently buoyed by the opportunity presented by the pandemic promote their cause, NHFA has launched a “Right to Refuse” campaign aimed at aiding those who want to increase their chances of coming down with COVID-19 by refusing vaccination. To ensure that their pro-pseudoscience propaganda is spread among people attracted to their anti-public health campaign, “Right to Refuse” includes tracts on how to successfully pass Quack Protection Acts. It also refers readers to the notoriously anti-vaccine National Vaccine Information [actually, misinformation] Center, funded by alternative medicine tycoon Joseph Mercola, for more know-how on anti-vaccination legislation in general.
In sum, a group that promotes dangerous and ineffective Gerson protocol quackery for deadly cancers is also discouraging safe and effective immunization against a deadly virus.
NHFC recently sent out an email blast congratulating NHFA and its “Right to Refuse” campaign on its success in getting state laws passed designed to hog-tie public and private efforts to combat both the current and future pandemics. (I wrote about a number of pending bills in a March post, some of which, unfortunately, have now been signed into law.) They’ve even named these new laws after themselves, calling them “Right to Refuse laws”. I’m not sure how much of this “success” can actually be attributed to NHFA given the anti-science proclivities among certain politicians eager to please their freedom-loving base, but NHFC did include a handy summary of these freshly-passed state laws in their email, from which I freely borrow.
Several the “Right to Refuse laws” concern so-called “vaccine passports”, that is, written proof of vaccination.
In a new law that, on its face, applies to all immunizations, not just COVID-19, Alabama prohibits state and local governments from issuing vaccine passports and from requiring immunization as a condition of receiving government benefits or services. Likewise, businesses cannot refuse goods or services based on immunization status. Fortunately, there are exceptions for health care providers and hospitals. Alabama colleges and universities must provide exemptions from vaccination requirements to any student or employee with a “bona fide medical condition or religious belief that is contrary to vaccination”, and no student or employee can be required to take a vaccine available only under an FDA emergency use authorization, again with exceptions for those involved in health care.
In Arkansas, state and local government entities can no longer require proof of vaccination against COVID-19 “for any purpose”. In a separate section of the law that does not specify who is governed by its prohibitions, proof of vaccination “shall not be a condition for entry, travel, education, or services.”
Similarly, Florida (my state) will not allow businesses to require that patrons or customers show proof of vaccination or recovery from COVID, nor will it allow educational institutions to require the same from students or residents. State and local governments cannot make “access to, entry upon, or service from” their operations contingent on proof of vaccination. To the chagrin of “Right to Refuse”, health care facilities are exempt and the prohibitions do not apply to employers vis a vis their employees, meaning that, in the kind of histrionic language beloved by anti-vaxxers, “it appears employers may be able to choose to require their employees to be injected”.
Although not mentioned in the NHFC email, the new Florida law also greatly restricts local governments’ authority to require mitigation measures during a public health emergency, including arbitrary times limits that are wholly unrelated to the level of threat presented. The law bestows on the governor the authority to override local orders he personally finds unnecessarily restrictive of “individual rights or liberties”. In turn, in rock-paper-scissors fashion, the state legislature will be able to override a state of emergency declared by the governor.
Per Indiana’s new legislation, state and local governments can neither issue nor require vaccine passports and proof of COVID immunization for driver’s licenses and other state-issued IDs is prohibited. An Iowa law prohibits state and local governments from requiring proof of immunization as well. Like Florida, Iowa bans businesses from requiring proof of immunization for patrons or others entering their premises, but this does not apply to their employees. Public and private health care facilities are exempt. Another Iowa law restricts the ability of school boards and local governments to require face masks. Utah also exempts those engaged in health care activities from its recently enacted prohibition against state and local governments requiring any COVID-19 vaccine, a prohibition that lasts only as long as the vaccine lacks full FDA approval. Like Alabama, Utah also enacted a law aimed at student vaccinations required by institutions of higher learning, adding a personal belief exemption. Unvaccinated students cannot be required to choose remote learning over in-person classes.
Montana, in one of the more sweeping new laws, couches its prohibitions in terms of “discrimination” and applies them to all immunizations except those required by schools and day care centers. There is also a blanket prohibition against requiring anyone to receive “any vaccine whose use is allowed under an emergency use authorization or any vaccine undergoing safety trials”.
Thus, it is an “unlawful discriminatory practice” for any person or governmental entity to refuse or deny anyone
any local or state services, goods, facilities, advantages, privileges, licensing, educational opportunities, health care access, or employment opportunities based on the person’s vaccination status or whether the person has an immunity passport.
Similar provisions apply to public accommodations.
Employers cannot require employees to be vaccinated or “discriminate” against them regarding terms and conditions of employment based on vaccination status. It is unclear whether the employer would be prohibited from inquiring whether the employee is vaccinated or from requiring masks and other mitigation measures of unvaccinated employees. That uncertainty alone could cause some employers to forego any such requirements. Health care facilities are permitted ask whether employees are vaccinated, but only to the extent it is necessary to implement “reasonable accommodation measures” for other employees, patients, and visitors to protect them from communicable diseases. Nursing homes are also exempt to the extent they are required to comply with federal government guidelines.
Ohio also enacted sweeping new legislation, but with a different tack, making virtually all emergency actions subject to legislative review, rescission, or invalidation. Gov. DeWine vetoed the bill but the legislature overrode his veto.
The new law time-limits any state of emergency declared by the governor to 90 days, with extensions granted by the legislature, although the legislature can end any state of emergency earlier if it wants. The legislature can rescind or invalidate any rule issued by an administrative agency (the state health department, for example) in response to a declared state of emergency.
The law also requires the governor and the state health department to report to the legislature every action they or their representatives take in response to the state of emergency and any such action is immediately subject to legislative review, rescission, or invalidation, in whole or in part. As well, it significantly restricts, but does not eliminate, the authority of local health departments regarding quarantine orders, school closures, and gathering bans.
In a resolution, Louisiana’s legislature declared that day care centers and schools (including colleges and universities) must inform students that the COVID-19 vaccine is authorized for emergency use only, has not been fully approved by the FDA, and that they have a right to refuse the vaccine. Students must also be told, falsely that the vaccine is “experimental”. (A resolution such as this can, at best, direct a state agency to take certain actions, but does not have the force of law, so I’m not sure how effective this will be.)
In an even more legally meaningless (but undoubtedly base-pleasing) action, falsely stating that “measures are being considered to mandate experimental vaccination”, the North Dakota legislature passed a resolution urging Congress not to issue vaccine passports or enact any law that would “restrain an individual’s right to travel or participate in commerce, religious freedom, and education based on whether the individual has received a COVID-19 vaccine”.
Alaska’s legislature gave everyone a right to refuse the COVID-19 vaccination “based on religious, medical, or other grounds”, with no exception that I can find for employers requiring employee vaccinations or medical facilities. Similarly, a new law in Kentucky provides religious and “conscientiously held beliefs” exemptions to any immunization required by the state during an epidemic.
Litigation threatened
In addition to the state legislatures, anti-vaxxers are turning to the courts to attack COVID-19 vaccines. As reported in the Washington Post (in an article well worth reading in its entirety), anti-vaccine careerists Del Bigtree and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. are chumming up cases to challenge employer and school vaccine mandates, aided by a New York law firm, Siri & Glimstead. Bigtree’s outfit, the Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN), which paid the firm nearly $1.3 million in 2019, “has advertised Siri & Glimstad’s services and sought plaintiffs for challenges to mandates”. Kennedy’s anti-vaxx group, the Children’s Health Defense, is helping spread the word by running an ad:
If you or anyone you know is being required by an employer or school to receive a covid-19 vaccine, ICAN is offering to support legal action on your behalf to challenge the requirement.
Of course, employers like a county-owned skilled nursing facility in Wisconsin and the Durham County (N.C.) Sheriff’s Department, both the subject of litigation threats over their vaccination requirements for employees, can ill afford budget-draining litigation, which may, as the article points out, lead to their backing off. This, in turn, could have a chilling effect on other employers who want their employees vaccinated against COVID.
Fortunately, Rutgers and Princeton are not so cowed. According to the Post, both have received letters from Siri & Glimstead but are holding firm. Said a Princeton rep,
We conducted a careful review and are confident in our legal position.
The Post also reports that “ICAN’s legal team remains active on other vaccine-related fronts”. Siri & Glimstead have filed a complaint on ICAN’s behalf “asking a federal court to order Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra to remove the finding that ‘vaccines do not cause autism’ from all communications with the public”.
That one deserves its own SBM post. Stay tuned.

Masks Revisited
A recent Cochrane review, limited in scope and problematic in methodology, does not show that masks do not work, despite common misreporting.
Steven Novella on February 15, 2023
Link

This is an issue that will not go away – do masks and mask mandates work to reduce the spread of COVID? It’s actually a good thing that the question continues to be researched. This is actually a difficult question to pin down definitively, so more research is always better. What is unfortunate is the degree the question has been politicized. One’s answer to this question is less likely to be determined by the science than your political affiliation.
A recent review of studies has rekindled the debate, and is making the rounds within the political right media. Anti-maskers are treating the study as if it is the final word in the debate – but it isn’t. The study is a Cochrane review, which does give it some gravitas, but it has important limitations – specifically in the kinds of evidence that is reviewed.
There are different ways to address the question – do masks work to reduce the spread of respiratory viruses in general and COVID-19 specifically? I reviewed these types of evidence here, but will summarize quickly. We can test whether or not different kinds of masks reduce the spread of respiratory droplets, which are the known primary mechanism by which COVID is spread. The answer is yes, for surgical masks and N95 masks, and equivocal for cloth masks. So face masks do what they are supposed to do, and better masks do it better.
Do they work out in the community when people wear them? This question has a lot of potential confounding variables, and this is why there are so many different results from research. One factor is – how much is the infection being studied spreading in the community. Studies looking at mask wearing during low risk situations do not find any statistical benefit (likely because the baseline risk is too low), but during high risk situations they are more likely to find a benefit and the magnitude and statistical significance of that benefit will be greater.
Also, how are we measuring infections? Do we simply allow people to self-report, do we check public health records, or do we only count laboratory-confirmed infections? Studies can also focus on individual or on communities. They can be controlled or observational. They can also follow an intention-to-treat model, looking not specifically at whether masks work but whether mask mandates or other public interventions work. These are actually different questions. Masks may work when worn properly, but mask interventions fail due to low compliance (people wearing the wrong masks, or wearing them incorrectly, or not wearing them when they are supposed to). Further, if the people in the population being studied are already taking preventive precautions, this will dilute out the effect of the intervention. You can’t force people to not wear a mask or to expose themselves to infection. You can only encourage them to do so or make it easier vs doing nothing.
It’s worth pointing out that all of these potential confounding factors decrease the observed effect of masks and mask interventions, with one exception. As one systematic review concludes, controlled studies can only create a false negative for the efficacy of mask-wearing, not a false positive, and they find that such studies actually underestimate the effect of mask wearing. However, observational studies may overestimate the efficacy of mask wearing in one way – mask wearers may engage in other protective activities, such as avoiding indoor crowds. However, again this depends on your question. If the question is, “does wearing a specific type of mask in a specific way reduce the risk of infection?” observational studies may overestimate that effect. But if your question is, “do mask mandates work?” then it doesn’t matter. If mandating mask wearing makes people engage in other good hygiene and protective behavior, and it total they reduce spread, that’s a good thing. And in fact the evidence is strongest for this effect.
With this background it is also important to note that there is no one perfect study that addresses this question. There are only studies with different strengths and weaknesses and different trade-offs.
For example, one of the bigger trials was the DANMASK trial, which was a randomized controlled trial with statistically negative results (although a trend of benefit). But this study has multiple limitations – the study was only powered to see a 50% reduction in infection. The rate in the community was already very low. Compliance with mask wearing in that group was <50%. Infections were self-reported. The dropout rate was high – 16%. But anti-maskers, or uninformed journalists, can point to this study and say it shows masks don’t work.
If we look at all the evidence we do see conflicting results, but on the whole there is a good signal that proper mask wearing is effective at reducing the risk of infections in relatively high risk environments. As I wrote previously:
Epidemiological studies provide perhaps the best evidence for the efficacy of masks, or more specifically, mask policies. One study comparing mask-wearing policies in different states in the US found that after states initiated mask-wearing policies, the spread of the virus decreased. Another study found that the risk of a spreading event was far greater in “mask-off” social settings than “mask-on” settings. Comparing countries with different mask-wearing policies also finds a good correlation with reduced spread.
Further, during social distancing and mask wearing policies, the rate of all respiratory infections plummeted. We basically had no flu season for the last two years, and now that policies have eased, the flu is coming back. Of course, this effect is not specific to masks and includes all precautions. But this data unequivocally shows that together these precautions work.
Let’s take a look at the recent Cochrane review. This is a review only of controlled studies – the kind of study that is most likely to underestimate the effect of mask-wearing. They did not included other kinds of studies. Not all of the studies reviewed were of COVID – they included studies of other respiratory viruses (which therefore may be different) and they included studies that were not taking place in the middle of a pandemic. This is a huge red flag, as it is pretty clear from existing data that masks only work in high-risk situations.
The one study they included of health professionals in a high risk setting only compared surgical masks with N95 masks, which showed no statistical difference, but did not compare either to no mask. Also, health care professionals are the most likely to engage in the full range of protective behavior (distancing, hand washing, protective face shields, gloves and gowns). Given this, it is not surprise that the difference between a surgical mask and an N95 mask was not statistically significant.
There are other criticisms of this review as well. The studies that took place in a hospital setting included part-time mask wearing, only when with patients. But the data shows that mask wearing only works when you where them continuously when in the hospital, not just in the patient room. They combined data from different settings and with different interventions. They also did not consider the effect of the infected person wearing a mask, only the effect on the wearer. But we know that masks are most effective when everyone wears them – both the giver and the receiver.
But the biggest error I see in reporting this study is the conclusion that it shows that “mask mandates don’t work”, when that was not even studied. Studies looking specifically at mask mandates show that they do work. The most recent and largest study looking at this concludes:
Our estimates imply that the mean observed level of mask wearing corresponds to a 19% decrease in the reproduction number R. We also assess the robustness of our results in 60 tests spanning 20 sensitivity analyses. In light of these results, policy makers can effectively reduce transmission by intervening to increase mask wearing.
This recent Cochrane review is very limited in scope and is highly problematic in its methods. The most we can conclude from it is that we need better and more relevant controlled trials of mask wearing to more precisely determine its effect on the spread of COVID. But it does not show that mask wearing does not work or that mask policies don’t work. Further, if we look at the totality of the evidence (not just these trials) the best current conclusions are:
Properly wearing face masks when in public during high risk of spread reduces the risk of spread of respiratory viruses in general and COVID specifically.
During a pandemic of a respiratory virus, mask mandates are an effective public health measure.
N95 masks likely offer the best protection, but need to be worn over the mouth and nose to be effective, and need to be worn continuously when in public (not just in targeted situations).

The Cochrane mask fiasco: How the evidence-based medicine paradigm can produce misleading results
Last week, the Cochrane Collaborative was forced to walk back the conclusions of a review by Tom Jefferson et al that had been spun in the media as proving that “masks don’t work.” Tom Jefferson himself has been problematic about vaccines for a long time, but the rot goes deeper. What is it about the evidence-based medicine paradigm that results in misleading conclusions?
David Gorski on March 13, 2023
Link

On Friday, the New York Times published on Opinion piece by Zeynep Tufekci entitled Here’s Why the Science Is Clear That Masks Work. Written in response to a recent Cochrane review, Physical interventions to interrupt or reduce the spread of respiratory viruses, that had over the last month been widely promoted by antimask and antivaccine sources, the article discusses the problems with the review and its lead author Tom Jefferson, as well as why it is not nearly as straightforward as one might assume to measure mask efficacy in the middle of a pandemic due to a novel respiratory virus. Over the month since the review’s publication, its many problems and deficiencies (as well as how it has been unrelentingly misinterpreted) have been discussed widely by a number of writers, academics, and bloggers, including our very own Steve Novella, as swell as Katelyn Jetelina and Kristen Panthagani, Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz Jason Abaluck, among others.
My purpose in writing about this kerfuffle is not to rehash (much) why the Cochrane review was so problematic. Rather, it’s more to look at what this whole kerfuffle tells us about the Cochrane Collaborative and the evidence-based medicine (EBM) paradigm it champions. AFter all, the authors cited above do an excellent job of that, although they do miss a lot of important context about the Cochrane Collaborative, Tom Jefferson, and the EBM paradigm under which Cochrane operates and that it has successfully promoted as the “gold standard” of scientific and medical evidence. I want to ask: What is it about Cochrane and EBM fundamentalists who promote the EBM paradigm as the be-all and end-all of medical evidence, even for questions for which it is ill-suited, that can produce misleading results? This is a topic that we at SBM used to write about on a regular basis when it came to the EBM paradigm’s application alternative medicine interventions, where EBM has never truly been able to definitively conclude that magical interventions—e.g., homeopathy, reiki, “energy healing” like therapeutic touch, and intercessory prayer—don’t work because the RCTs were “equivocal.” We used to call EBM’s failure to consider the low to nonexistent prior probability as assessed by basic science that magic like homeopathy could work its “blind spot.” Jefferson’s review, coupled with the behavior of EBM gurus like John Ioannidis during the pandemic, made me wonder if there’s another blind spot of EBM that we at SBM have neglected, one that leads to Cochrane reviews like Jefferson’s and leads EBM gurus like Ioannidis to make their heel turns so soon after the pandemic hit, which, truth be told, did catch me by surprise.
First, let’s look at how the review was used and misused. Much of how it was received was predictable, although, before Tufekci’s article, I had seen little discussion of Tom Jefferson himself. Let’s just say that it did not surprise me that he was the first author of the Cochrane mask review, for reasons that will soon become apparent.
The usual suspects do their usual thing with the Cochrane review
Before I “go meta”—not that Meta!—it’s necessary to emphasize that not even this not-so-great review ever actually concluded that “masks don’t work.” Rather, it only concluded that the evidence is uncertain. Naturally, not being about nuance, antimaskers referenced the Cochrane systematic review as definitive scientific evidence that “masks don’t work,” even to the point of being cited in a Congressional committee hearing to put CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky on the defensive over mask mandates. Elsewhere, many of the usual suspects were Tweeting and posting proclamations like this:
For the nattering nabob self-appointed "experts" who do not understand what a Cochrane review finding means. https://t.co/m4Fwg52sCX
— Robert W Malone, MD (@RWMaloneMD) February 5, 2023
Most respected medical report shows that they lied and masks never worked. Not at all. What will the #BringBackMasks people say about this? 🙉🙈 report here👇 https://t.co/q1uQNehHGU pic.twitter.com/U9kMIFnctk
— MACHISMO🇨🇦 (@Arnoldcarling) March 4, 2023
“Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety*, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”
—Benjamin Franklin*Masks, no evidence they work. RCTs did not show a clear reduction in respiratory viral infection with use of masks https://t.co/vMR54b1k1T pic.twitter.com/irbjsYP8RN
— Shaun Waugh (@culturewaugh) March 11, 2023
I could go on and on, as there are thousands of Tweets like this, as well as likely thousands of posts on various other social media with variations of the very same message, specifically that the “gold standard” of evidence, a Cochrane systematic review, “proved” that “masks don’t work.” Indeed, perusing the triumphant gloating on social media from ideological sources opposed to COVID-19 interventions, including masks and vaccines, I was struck by how often they used the exact phrase “gold standard” to portray Cochrane as an indisputable source, all to bolster their misrepresentation. As Tufekci reports, this misrepresentation must have finally rattled Cochrane’s leadership, as they finally issued a statement:
Now the organization, Cochrane, says that the way it summarized the review was unclear and imprecise, and that the way some people interpreted it was wrong.
“Many commentators have claimed that a recently updated Cochrane review shows that ‘masks don’t work,’ which is an inaccurate and misleading interpretation,” Karla Soares-Weiser, the editor in chief of the Cochrane Library, said in a statement.
“The review examined whether interventions to promote mask wearing help to slow the spread of respiratory viruses,” Soares-Weiser said, adding, “Given the limitations in the primary evidence, the review is not able to address the question of whether mask wearing itself reduces people’s risk of contracting or spreading respiratory viruses.”
She said that “this wording was open to misinterpretation, for which we apologize,” and that Cochrane would revise the summary.
Soares-Weiser also said, though, that one of the lead authors of the review even more seriously misinterpreted its finding on masks by saying in an interview that it proved “there is just no evidence that they make any difference.” In fact, Soares-Weiser said, “that statement is not an accurate representation of what the review found.”
There is now a statement on the Cochrane website, as Tufekci notes:
Full Cochrane statement.
Also, last prepandemic update of this review, same lead author, DID consider evidence besides randomized trials & concluded: "Surgical masks or N95 respirators were the most consistent and comprehensive supportive measures."
Changed only after pandemic. pic.twitter.com/nvOjVKJxbK
— zeynep tufekci (@zeynep) March 10, 2023
There are also a number of other interesting things about this review, but first let’s look at why I was not in the least bit surprised to learn who the first author was. It also led me to wonder now, as I did in 2009 and 2013, why the Cochrane Collaborative still employs him.
Methodolatry at Cochrane, or: Meet the new Tom Jefferson, same as the old Tom Jefferson
We have met that lead author before. His name is Tom Jefferson, and we at SBM have been writing about him intermittently since 2009, as I will discuss later. What really stood out in the NYT article—and, given his history that I will relate— is that soon after his Cochrane systematic review was published Jefferson gave an interview to Maryanne Demasi, a journalist who has been over the years devolved into an antivaccine propagandist, as one can easily see merely by perusing her Substack, which is where she first published her interview with Jefferson, and how many times she is positively cited by antivax sources. Her interview with Jefferson was widely picked up by the usual suspects in the antivax social media ecosystem, such as the Brownstone Institute and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense. Unsurprisingly, Demasi is also a contributor to the Brownstone Institute website, as is Tom Jefferson himself, something that has only been rarely mentioned in the reporting about this review.
In the interview, Jefferson made very confident proclamations, like:
There is just no evidence that they [masks] make any difference. Full stop. My job, our job as a review team, was to look at the evidence, we have done that. Not just for masks. We looked at hand washing, sterilisation, goggles etcetera…
And:
There’s no evidence that they [masks] do work, that’s right. It’s possible they could work in some settings….we’d know if we’d done trials. All you needed was for Tedros [from WHO] to declare it’s a pandemic and they could have randomised half of the United Kingdom, or half of Italy, to masks and the other half to no masks. But they didn’t. Instead, they ran around like headless chickens.
First of all, as Steve Novella, Katelyn Jetelina and Kristen Panthagani, Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, Jason Abaluck, and others have pointed out, the study doesn’t say that there is “no evidence” that facemasks “do work.”
I facepalmed when I read Jefferson’s simplistic (to the point of being simple-minded) pronouncement about randomized clinical trials (RCTs), wanting to respond: Tell me you don’t understand the ethics of RCTs without telling me you don’t understand the ethics of RCTs. Also, tell me you don’t understand the logistics of doing a randomized clinical trial this massive without telling me you don’t understand the logistics fo doing an RCT this massive. I will discuss these issues more near the end of this post, but first I need to set up the discussion.
There is a pattern that we at SBM had been observing about Jefferson for a very long time, in which he is much more circumspect with his conclusions in the systematic reviews he writes for Cochrane but then gives interviews to sympathetic journalists in which he makes pronouncements like the ones he made in his interview Demasi; for instance, during the last pandemic, H1N1 influenza in 2009, he all but came out and stated, “The flu vaccine doesn’t work.” It’s his schtick, apparently. Jefferson is much less definitive in his Cochrane conclusions and includes the necessary shortcomings and caveats, likely because peer reviewers insist on it in academic articles, but then says what he really thinks in interviews, where there is no peer review. Sometimes, he’s even appeared with utter quacks like Gary Null to falsely claim that flu vaccines aren’t safe in pregnancy and that statins don’t work.
I once referred to his schtick this way:
…he insinuates that the flu vaccine doesn’t work while never actually saying that you shouldn’t get it. He maintains plausible deniability, while trashing the vaccine left and right. What he says in public also differs from what he says in his Cochrane reviews, as I’ve pointed out before. For his reviews, he has to stick to the evidence, and peer reviewers have to be satisfied. When he’s talking to journalists, he can let his freak flag fly higher and, as I put it, go full mental negative on the flu vaccine.
Which brings us back to my purpose in writing this.
I had been meaning to write about the Cochrane systematic review on masks almost since it was first published, but somehow other things kept getting in the way, including a personal family health emergency that I mentioned six weeks ago that has stabilized but is ongoing. I simply didn’t have the time to delve deeply, and then when I finally did Steve had already written about the systematic review.
However, in the back of my mind, another angle that no one had covered (much) kept percolating. I’ve noticed over the last three years, this weekend having encompassed the third anniversary of the World Health Organization’s declaration of COVID-19 as a pandemic, a tendency for scientists who were known primarily before the pandemic as strong advocates of evidence-based medicine, devolving into promoters of COVID-19 denial, antimask, anti-public health, and even antivaccine pseudoscience. Think Dr. John Ioannidis, whom we at SBM lionized before 2020. Think Dr. Vinay Prasad, of whose work on medical reversals and calls for more rigorous randomized clinical trials of chemotherapy and targeted therapy agents before FDA approval we generally wrote approvingly.
Basically, what Jefferson exhibited in his almost off-the-cuff claim that massive RCTs of masks should have been done while a deadly respiratory virus was flooding UK hospitals was something we like to call “methodolatry,” or the obscene worship of the RCT as the only method of clinical investigation. I’ve long pointed out how methodolatry leads the EBM paradigm to be too open to alternative medicine, but it turns out that it might also lead to COVID contrarianism. So let’s take a trip down memory lane, back to the early days of this blog, before moving on to discussing methodolatry in the context of Jefferson’s studies and how many EBM
EBM and “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM)
Longtime regular readers who have been with us since the beginning might remember that one common theme of this blog has been the difference between evidence-based medicine (EBM) and what we introduced as science-based medicine (SBM). Indeed, in Steve Novella’s very first post introducing the blog 15 years ago, he described the difference between EBM and SBM this way:
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. Most relevant to this blog is the focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that lie outside the scientific paradigm, or for which the scientific plausibility ranges from very little to nonexistent.
We spent much of the first year of this blog’s existence, and, rather than reinvent the wheel yet again, I will quote liberally from some of these old posts. Indeed, a few weeks later, Dr. Kimball Atwood expanded on the concept of what we mean by “science-based medicine” as opposed to EBM:
Some might be surprised to find that EBM is not synonymous with “science-based medicine.” Although based on previous, evolving standards of clinical trial designs, statistics, epidemiological methods and other pertinent tools, EBM is a semi-formal movement within modern medicine that has existed for fewer than 20 years; it comprises sets of guidelines for assessing evidence, which will be discussed further below.
And:
To many in this era of EBM it seems self-evident that all unproven methods, including homeopathy, should be subjected to such scrutiny. After all, the anecdotal impressions that are typically the bases for such claims are laden with the very biases that blinded RCTs were devised to overcome. This opinion, however, is naive. Some claims are so implausible that clinical trials tend to confuse, rather than clarify the issue. Human trials are messy. It is impossible to make them rigorous in ways that are comparable to laboratory experiments. Compared to laboratory investigations, clinical trials are necessarily less powered and more prone to numerous other sources of error: biases, whether conscious or not, causing or resulting from non-comparable experimental and control groups, cuing of subjects, post-hoc analyses, multiple testing artifacts, unrecognized confounding of data due to subjects’ own motivations, non-publication of results, inappropriate statistical analyses, conclusions that don’t follow from the data, inappropriate pooling of non-significant data from several, small studies to produce an aggregate that appears statistically significant, fraud, and more.
A few years later, Dr. Atwood wrote a multipart article asking Does EBM Undervalue Basic Science and Overvalue RCTs? (Hint: the answer is yes.) He also wondered whether it is a good idea to test highly implausible health claims. (Hint: the answer is usually no, at least not using RCT efficacy trials of the sort placed near the very top of the EBM pyramid of evidence, just under systemic reviews, evidence syntheses, and meta-analyses of RCTs.)
As I like to ask: Which of the following is more likely, that a 30C homeopathic solution of…something…that has been diluted on the order of 1037-fold more than Avogadro’s number and thus is incredibly unlikely to contain even a single molecule of that something has a therapeutic effect or that the RCTs concluding that it does reveal the problems and biases in clinical trials? As I also like to say, given the usual p-value of 0.05 designated for “statistically significant” findings, under ideal circumstances, with perfectly designed and executed RCTs, by random chance alone 5% of these RCTs will be “positive.” Of course, in the real world, RCTs are not perfect, either in design or execution, and the number of “false positives” is therefore likely considerably higher than 5%. Yet, basic science alone tells us that a 30C homeopathic remedy is indistinguishable from the water used to dilute it, which means a placebo-controlled RCT is testing placebo versus placebo and “positive” results show us nothing more than the noise inherent in doing RCTs.
I also like to caution: EBM is correct that “first principles” in basic science cannot tell you whether a treatment works or not. RCTs are indeed necessary. History is littered with treatments that appeared effective in preclinical in vitro and animal models but failed to pan out in clinical trials. However, in contrast, if basic science tells you that a treatment modality is impossible, that (like homeopathy) it would require that multiple well-established laws and theories of chemistry and physics be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong, in order for it to “work,” then that should be enough. RCTs should not be necessary. Indeed, they would arguably be unethical, because another ethical requirement for clinical trials is that the treatment being tested be grounded in good science based on what is known at the time of the trial.
But what about COVID-19? Guess what? What has happened since the pandemic hit suggests to me that EBM also undervalues epidemiology compared to RCTs.
EBM during the pandemic: A different flavor of methodolatry?
Let’s revisit what Jefferson said in his interview with Demasi, because it’s important to my discussion of methodolatry. Basically Jefferson’s statement saying that the WHO should have just done RCTs of masks in the UK and Italy was perhaps the most blatant manifestation of “methodolatry,” a term used to describe the EBM tendency to view RCTs as the only valid method of clinical investigation and to devalue to an inappropriate degree any evidence that does not come from an RCT, that I can recall having seen in a long time. Indeed, Jefferson’s blithe suggestion of “Why didn’t they just do RCTs of masks” as a pandemic crashed into two major countries demonstrates just how methodolatry ignores practicality. (So easy!) It ignores expense, as Jefferson did when he suggested that RCT. It ignores ethics, as Jefferson did when he actually suggested an RCT of masks for a respiratory virus at the beginning of a pandemic that was flooding hospitals in Italy and the UK with very ill and dying patients, overwhelming the healthcare resources of the two countries.
Tufekci notes this problem in her article:
Why aren’t there more randomized studies on masks? We could have started some in early 2020, distributing masks in some towns when they weren’t widely available. It’s a shame we didn’t. But it would have been hard and unethical to deny masks to some people once they were available to all.
Actually, given the prior probability based on basic science that masks can block the respiratory droplets that transmit viruses like SARS-CoV-2, it is arguable that even what Tufekci proposed would have been unethical, as there would have been no clinical equipoise, an absolute requirement for an RCT to be ethical. Basically, as I’ve discussed before, clinical equipoise is genuine uncertainty whether an intervention is likely to help the experimental group compared to a control group not receiving it. As Tufekci notes:
Scientists routinely use other kinds of data besides randomized reviews, including lab studies, natural experiments, real-life data and observational studies. All these should be taken into account to evaluate masks.
Lab studies, many of which were done during the pandemic, show that masks, particularly N95 respirators, can block viral particles. Linsey Marr, an aerosol scientist who has long studied airborne viral transmission, told me even cloth masks that fit well and use appropriate materials can help.
Also, once again, carrying out RCTs of masks on a general population is incredibly difficult, which usually leaves epidemiological evidence as the best available evidence, which EBM claims to be all about:
Perhaps the best evidence comes from natural experiments, which study how things change after an event or intervention.
Researchers at Mass General Brigham, one of Harvard’s teaching hospital groups, found that in early 2020, before mask mandates were introduced, the infection rate among health care workers doubled every 3.6 days and rose to 21.3 percent. After universal masking was required, the rate stopped increasing, and then quickly declined to 11.4 percent.
In Germany, 401 regions introduced mask mandates at various times over three months in the spring of 2020. By carefully comparing otherwise similar places before and after mask mandates, researchers concluded that “face masks reduce the daily growth rate of reported infections by around 47 percent,” with the effect more pronounced in large cities and among older people.
Also note Jefferson’s dismissive tone, how he characterizes doctors and public health officials as “running around like headless chickens” because evidence was uncertain. Now, don’t get me wrong. Mistakes were made, as they say, in the heat of the initial confrontation with the novel coronavirus. Hydroxychloroquine was embraced by many hospitals in the US (including one where I worked and another major one in my city) as a standard of care in March 2020 based on very sketchy evidence and little more than the word of the Chinese government that it appeared to work, only to be found not to work as the pandemic’s first summer was drawing to a close.
Still, I’d be willing to bet that Jefferson belongs to what SBM contributor Dr. Jonathan Howard likes to call the “laptop class,” a term borrowed from Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) co-author Dr. Jay Bhattacharya when he railed against pandemic restrictions that in reality describes Dr. Bhattacharya himself, as well as his co-authors and nearly all of the GBD promoters. Let’s just say that I doubt that Dr. Jefferson went anywhere near COVID-19 wards to treat patients, as Dr. Howard did in New York City early in the pandemic. His “laptop class” status leads me to wonder what Dr. Jefferson would have recommended in March 2020, had he had actual “skin in the game” rather than just an intellectual interest in what EBM shows regarding pandemic restrictions?
Actually, we have an idea, given that in April 2020, Jefferson co-authored an article arguing tha there was no point in nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) and mitigations to slow the spread of COVID-19 and railed against “lockdowns”:
Because there are no licensed treatments for COVID-19 non-pharmaceutical interventions, management of complications and early recognition of those deteriorating and most likely to benefit from hospitalisation, should be the mainstay of management.
Changing the emphasis from hospitals to the community could avert a disaster for the wider population. Care in the home setting restricts movements of the infected. All those with a fever and a cough should stay at home; they could be prescribed pulse oximeters, and oxygen could be delivered to severely affected cases; rescue antibiotics prescribed along with daily video-monitoring could be used to detect deterioration. In the older population, the mildly ill and the recovering, food supplies should be delivered at home.
Older Patients admitted to hospital are at greater risk of delirium, pressure sores, adverse effects of new medications, malnutrition and hospital-acquired infections. [6] An older person admitted to hospital runs the risk of never seeing the light of day again. This is probably the clearest message coming from Italy.
Lockdown is going to bankrupt all of us and our descendants and is unlikely at this point to slow or halt viral circulation as the genie is out of the bottle. What the current situation boils down to is this: is economic meltdown a price worth paying to halt or delay what is already amongst us?
Masks, I note, are not “licensed,” nor do they require a license. Also note Jefferson’s complete disconnect from the actual dire situation “on the ground” in April 2020. He suggests these policies as though they could easily be implemented immediately and would not require considerable planning of weeks to months. In addition, one can already detect a significant bias against masks and other NPIs in favor of a “let ‘er rip” fatalism that six months later became the basis of the GBD. That same month, he questioned whether COVID-19 pandemic was actually a pandemic at all, rather than just a long respiratory illness season, arguing that because during a pandemic the proportion of deaths among the young should increase COVID-19 couldn’t be a true pandemic. I kid you not. He concluded:
The data support the theory that the current epidemic is a late seasonal effect in the Northern Hemisphere on the back of a mild ILI season. The age structure of those most affected does not fit the evidence from previous pandemics.
The outbreak does, however, fit with the WHO’s definition of a Pandemic. This definition does not help explain the age structure of those most affected, and how this differs from that of seasonal outbreaks. The definition of a pandemic remains elusive.
What would Sherlock have made of all this?
I daresay that Sherlock Holmes would have sharply and sarcastically criticized Jefferson’s “reasoning,” such as it is, the way he often did with his friend Watson’s attempts to figure out a case. Seriously, if you were arguing in April 2020 that COVID-19 was just a bad “seasonal” flu-like illness, you lost the plot three years ago.
Methodolatry beyond Cochrane and Jefferson: When is epidemiology sufficient?
Jefferson is not alone among EBM gurus who took a major heel turn during COVID-19 to turn into contrarians who claim that NPIs like masks don’t work and that the COVID-19 vaccine should not have been authorized for children under an emergency use authorization because, supposedly, COVID is “not a danger” to children, even though around 1,800 children—a very large number for pediatrics!—have died of COVID since the pandemic hit, making it a leading cause of pediatric death. It is a number that is, on a population basis, roughly the same as the 400-500 deaths from measles that occurred every year before the first measles vaccine was licensed in the early 1960s. Back then, nearly every physician correctly believed that several hundred pediatric deaths a year were such a bad thing that the toll justified developing a vaccine and instituting the mass vaccination campaign in the 1960s that ultimately reduced the number of measles deaths a year to zero or single digits. Since COVID-19, a number of EBM fundamentalists think that a similar death toll among children is acceptable until and unless there are massive RCTs testing vaccination and then boosters in children.
Indeed, these EBM doctors calling for RCTs über alles don’t seem to realize that they are recycling exactly the same arguments that antivaxxers used to make against the measles vaccine, or vaccines against chickenpox or whooping cough, before the pandemic, all in the name of calling for ever larger, more impractical, and expensive RCTs of every conceivable combination of vaccination and boosters. Does any of this sound familiar? Those of us who remember countering the antivaccine movement before the pandemic remember antivaxxers routinely calling for huge, expensive, and impractical RCTs of variants of the entire vaccine schedule in order to determine whether vaccines cause autism or all the other things that they blame vaccines for. I’m not saying that EBM fundamentalists like Jefferson and Prasad are antivaxxers (although they certainly echo longstanding antivax tropes). What I am saying is that there seems to be something about EBM that leads its most visible and vocal promoters down a path towards sounding like antivaxxers. I realize that my saying this is likely to piss some people off, likely people I even respect, but it is an observation that has been increasingly difficult for me to discount.
Again, let’s go back to the evidence pyramid of EBM:
We used to routinely note that basic science considerations are relegated to the very bottom of the pyramid, as “level 5 evidence” consisting of “expert opinion without explicit critical appraisal, or based on physiology, bench research or ‘first principles.'”” It is true that epidemiology is higher on the pyramid—just below RCTs!—but for some reason, among EBM fundamentalists, that doesn’t seem to translate to any more respect than EBM gives basic science when it considers RCTs of homeopathy or energy medicine. Indeed, Jonathan Howard has documented how the response of self-proclaimed EBM adherents to proposed policies to vaccinate or boost children is always to say that there are “no RCTs” and to call for huge, impractical RCTs before recommending such interventions.
Indeed, look at Vinay Prasad writing at the Brownstone Institute and his Substack, you’ll see a similar attitude, although does give a slight amount of leeway:
     1.  In an emergency situation, if governments mandate or advise individual level behavioral interventions (e.g. masking), those entities should have generated robust data in 3 months (cluster RCTs) to demonstrate efficacy, or the intervention is automatically revoked. Some may argue 3 months is too short, but if it is truly a crisis warranting emergency proclamations, then you should see a signal in 3 months, and governments can expand sample size to ensure prompt results.
     2.  If a trial is positive that does not mean the policy continues forever, but must be debated (net benefit/ net harms/ tradeoffs) by the body politic.
Three months to generate robust RCT evidence? You can tell that Dr. Prasad has probably never actually gotten a clinical trial protocol funded and approved by an institutional review board (IRB) as principal investigator. Even under emergency situations, you might, if you’re lucky, be managing to randomize in 2-3 months. You won’t have robust evidence of anything yet. This is methodolatry at its most ridiculous.
Does EBM attract or contribute to contrarianism?
Don’t get me wrong here. The EBM paradigm is not wrong. Rather, it is seriously limited by, yes, methodolatry. Its entire framework assumes that RCTs are at the very strongest form of clinical evidence, thus putting aggregations of RCTs (e.g., meta-analyses, Cochrane systematic reviews, and other forms of systematic reviews) at the very top of the EBM pyramid. There is no doubt that EBM is correct that, in general, the best way to determine the efficacy of a drug or vaccine is a well-designed RCT. Far be it from me to imply otherwise! Moreover, I have echoed calls for more scientific rigor in drug approval, in particular the RCTs used to support the drug approval.
There are caveats, of course. the entire EBM model assumes that there is scientific plausibility. (Remember, that was one of the problems with EBM that we used to point out all the time with respect to clinical trials of homeopathy that could lead to misleading results.) In addition, it assumes that such a trial would be ethical. If one wanted to contest my criticism here, one could argue that EBM fundamentalists like Jefferson ignore the absolute requirement that a clinical trial be ethical and the relative requirement that it be feasible in favor of their worship of the RCT as the only valid method of clinical investigation that can produce definitive results.
Moreover, Cochrane meta-analyses are notoriously tricky to do. First of all, you have to decide what the question is. Then you have to decide what studies out there address the question. Then, for the case of something like masks, you have to realize that you will, by the time you go through the literature and apply EBM standards to them, looking the highest quality RCTs, you will be looking at only a small, highly select part of the literature. While this is fine for new drugs and asking if they are efficacious, for a multifactorial question like whether masks slow the spread of COVID-19 at the population level, a large amount of compelling and high quality scientific evidence could well be excluded because the EBM paradigm demands it.
Yet, as I like to point out, no EBM adherent seriously doubts that smoking and tobacco can cause lung cancer, heart disease, and a host of other maladies, even though there is not and never will be an RCT testing whether smoking causes these conditions because such a study would be profoundly unethical. Epidemiology is sufficient to lead to a conclusive conclusion that smoking causes lung cancer, for instance. Similarly, although there are RCTs that are cited as evidence that vaccines don’t cause autism, in reality it is nearly all epidemiology that leads to the conclusion that vaccines do not increase the risk of autism. No RCTs are required to reach these conclusions in a scientifically rigorous fashion, as is the case for a large number of other medical questions.
Even Cochrane seems to accept a lesser level of evidence in the midst of a deadly pandemic:
Brown, who led the Cochrane review’s approval process, told me that mask mandates may not be tenable now, but he has a starkly different feeling about their effects in the first year of a pandemic.
“Mask mandates, social distancing, the other shutdowns we had in terms of even restaurants and things like that — if places like New York City didn’t do that, the number of deaths would have been much higher,” he told me. “I’m very confident of that statement.”
Based on what, I wonder? There were no RCTs of mask use against COVID-19. So how could he know? I’m not saying he was wrong, but it would appear that even Cochrane editors abandon the strict EBM paradigm in the breach.
It occurred to me as I was wrapping up that one potential shortcoming of my argument is that so many of these methodolatrists tend to be very selective what conclusions to them require RCTs and what conclusions can be accepted without them. I cite again Vinay Prasad, who is very dismissive of epidemiological evidence for assessing the effectiveness of, for example, masks to prevent the spread of COVID-19 or of vaccination and/or boosters for COVID-19 in children, but will accept crappy dumpster dives into the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) database and various other epidemiological studies to conclude that myocarditis from the vaccines in adolescents and young men is an unacceptable risk.
And yet…I don’t think that ideological misuse of the EBM paradigm is the explanation. It is undoubtely true that some of these EBM fundamentalists do indeed do exactly that, calling for impossibly rigorous RCTs for interventions that they do not support while accepting much lower quality evidence to fear monger about low probability complications of those interventions. However, I can’t help but wonder if there is something about the EBM paradigm that either attracts contrarians or facilitates those predisposed to contrarianism to descend further into it. EBM certainly emphasizes uncertainty in evidence and conclusions, which is a good thing for skeptics to do when the question is a new drug. However, this skepticism can become unhealthy and misleading when coupled with the attitude, “If it’s not an RCT, it’s crap” or “Anything other than RCT evidence is crap.” EBM adherents will vigorously deny that they think that, but the conclusions coming out of Cochrane and touted by its most zealous adherents suggest otherwise.
Fifteen years ago, when Steve Novella co-founded SBM with Kimball Atwood, Wally Sampson, Harriet Hall, and me, I had to be convinced that the EBM model valued RCT evidence over everything and therefore discounted basic science. Once I realized that this was correct, i saw examples everywhere, mainly in the world of CAM. What I never suspected until now is that that same blind spot seems to contribute to an attitude that we can’t know anything with sufficient certainty to act, even in the middle of a pandemic.
I also note that 13 years ago, we noted that Cochrane might be finally starting to “get it” with respect to SBM as opposed to EBM when some EBM bigwigs actually started to concede that further studies might not be necessary for interventions like homeopathy. Unfortunately, I’ve seen little evidence that this “getting it” has stuck. Now I think that the evidence pyramid has had another malign effect during the pandemic, the devaluation of what is often the form of evidence most suited to address relevant questions given resources, medical ethics, and practicality, questions such as whether masks and other NPIs decrease the spread of COVID. Basically, more and more EBM seems to have one tool, and you know what they say about having only one tool and that tool is a hammer. The result was the Cochrane mask fiasco.
Fifteen years ago, we introduced the concept of SBM, primarily as a “fix” to EBM that would restore the consideration of basic science and the prior probability it estimates for highly implausible treatments. Based on what I’ve seen from EBM thought leaders during the pandemic, I’m wondering if another fix is in order from SBM. I will admit that I do not yet know what that fix will be yet, but I will be contemplating the question.

ZShield: Unproven Protection from SARS-CoV-2 Infection, Especially for Kids
If it seems to good to be true, it probably is. And ZShield face shields being marketed to the general public certainly fits that description, especially when it comes to their use by children.
Clay JonesonSeptember 18, 2020
Link 
While enjoying my early morning bowl of sugar-laden breakfast cereal, some CNN, and a few minutes of peace and quiet earlier this week, I watched a commercial for a new brand of face shields. ZShield, a trademarked line of face shields manufactured by ZVerse, comes with claims of providing protection from the spread of COVID-19 by way of an innovative design that is more comfortable and user friendly. Their website further claims that the benefit of a ZShield goes beyond lowering the wearer’s risk:
By wearing one of our ZShields, you are helping to shield yourself and those around you, your neighbors, customers, nurses and doctors, grocery store clerks, teachers, hair stylists, restaurant servers and so many others. We invite you to join us and Be the Shield.
With one exception, the face shield specifically marketed for medical professionals (ZShield Health), the design of the various ZShield products involves a unique attachment at the neck and a shield that goes up rather than down. In addition to this feature, these shields can easily be pulled down when protection from respiratory viruses is less desirable, such as when drinking coffee at your favorite cafe. The commercial and website heavily feature a face shield designed for children attending school, and it is implied that a face mask is rendered unnecessary by wearing the ZShield Youth or one of the other shields.
It all sounds so amazing. It’s comfortable, easy to use, even dishwasher safe. And according to ZShield, not everyone can wear a mask all day, so this must be a great alternative. Plus the learning environment for our children is more positive because facial expression is an important aspect of communication. It almost sounds too good to be true.
ZShield: It’s too good to be true
There are a lot of problems with these products, and a lot of red flags on the website promoting them. Because I’m the pediatrician on the team, however, I’ll try to mostly stay in my lane and focus on their use by children as personal protective equipment. But honestly, the issues I’ll raise with using ZShield to prevent COVID-19 in kids are pretty generalizable.
So are these face shields effective? The website FAQ provides one of the worst examples of marketing malarkey that I’ve seen in quite a while:
Are your face shields effective in preventing the spread of COVID-19?
Our ZShield Flex and ZShield Wrap face shields provide a barrier for respiratory droplets. Our face shields are designed based on customer feedback and demand for a comfortable, reusable, easy to clean face covering that provides a threshold of hygiene while allowing for easy communication and a full view of the wearer’s face.
Customer satisfaction is probably not the best primary metric when designing a medical device aimed at the prevention of an infectious disease. I mean, it is true that an effective product that nobody will use is worthless. But so is something that everyone will wear but doesn’t provide much protection. Where will ZShield fall on this spectrum? Hmmm…I wonder.
Oh, and what the heck is a “threshold of hygiene”? Rubbing your hands with dry bar soap provides a threshold of hygiene. So does 1-ply commercial toilet paper for that matter, but I would not consider either of these interventions to be effective. I need a bit more detail when I’m facing a viral pathogen that might put me or my family on a ventilator.
This answer above also doesn’t mention the ZShield Youth or the ZShield Health, probably because a lawyer(s) told them not to include those for, let’s just say legal reasons. I do, however, have a few more problems with this answer other than just the strategic bait and switch. First off, the claim that these products “provide a barrier for respiratory droplets” is true but problematic. Just how protective a barrier is against the novel coronavirus depends on the design of the barrier.
The best “barrier”, of course, is distance from the virus, ideally enhanced by vaccine induced herd immunity. Face masks also provide an excellent barrier that is the next best thing to widespread immunity. Classic face shields that start at the forehead, go down far enough to cover the face, and wrap around the side of the head provide a helpful barrier, but not to the same degree as masks. And there is solid evidence that a combination of a mask and face/eye shielding increases protection.
But what about the innovative design of the ZShield products? Does it work as a mask substitute? Does it work as well as classic face shields? I mean, it has to at least be better than nothing?
ZShield: Probably worse than nothing?
The unique design of up-going ZShield face shields is bad. It’s comically bad. It’s like I’ve been fooled by a very effective, Poe’s-Law-defining, satirical performance art piece. But I haven’t been, because it isn’t satire. It’s real.
There are four fundamental forces in physics that govern how all objects and particles interact. The sexiest is gravity, coming in just ahead of the strong interaction. Respiratory droplets that are > 5 micrometers in diameter, once expelled from their source (probably Larry in accounting), are quickly pulled towards the center of the Earth by the gravitational force. See where I’m going with this yet?
If a person is wearing a face shield that is open at the top, as all ZShield products except for the one marketed to healthcare professionals are, they are within roughly 3 feet of the source, and their head is situated below said source, their face shield will inconveniently collect falling infected respiratory droplets and direct them towards the eyes, mouth, and nose. Children, in general, live for many years below most adults.
Yet the ZShield website FAQ provides the following reassuring information:
According to an article published in JAMA, face shields appear to significantly reduce the amount of inhalation exposure to influenza virus, another droplet-spread respiratory virus. In a simulation study, face shields were shown to reduce immediate viral exposure by 96% when worn by a simulated health care worker within 18 inches of a cough.
The article they cite, which does concludes that face shields should play a role in reducing the transmission of the novel coronavirus, cites a study that involved the use of coughing patient and breathing worker simulators. In addition to the fact that it involved a different virus, the most glaring problem with using the study as support for ZShield products is that the authors tested classic face shields that attach at the forehead, with no gap between the shield and the skin, and that extended down to the chin, just like the CDC recommends. There have been a grand total of zero studies looking at face shields that attach at the neck and open to the sky, and there probably never should be.
Also left out of the above answer is the fact that the study looked at short term exposures to simulated coughs at 1 and 30 minutes. This is not generalizable to many situations, especially adults at work, or kids in school, both in indoor environments for hours at a time. The 96% reduction of inhaled particles was seen in the immediate period after a cough involving large droplets but there was only a 68% reduction of immediate inhalation of smaller airborne particles.
At 30 minutes, there was only a 23% reduction of inhaled smaller airborne droplet nuclei. This is important because there is growing evidence that SARS-CoV-2 is also spread via airborne particles smaller than 5 microns that can float further and for a much longer period of time. And, again, this study did not include face shields with the unique ZShield design. It did confirm that distance from the source of droplet or airborne particles is an extremely important factor in lowering your risk of infection. For all but the very tall, keeping at a distance from people is probably more effective at avoiding illness from the novel coronavirus than wearing a ZShield with the neck attachment and getting within 6 feet of an infected individual.
Theoretically, if a child or shorter adult were to cough directly up into someone’s face at an extremely close range, one of these unique ZShield face shields might actually provide better protection than a classic face shield. It would depend on how much force was generated though because any droplets that were forced above the head of the ZShield wearer would quickly settle right into their various face holes.
But at least the FDA approval process for these is on the level…right?
ZShield: Yeah…it’s probably not on the level
With so many obvious problems with the design of the ZShield face shields being marketed to the general public, it’s hard to imagine that they would be approved by the FDA for use. Well, though they probably don’t deserve to be, they might barely make the grade, but only after a relaxation of the approval process during the pandemic.
In April, the FDA issued an emergency use authorization that included face shields because of widespread PPE shortages in healthcare settings, making the process extremely simple. Face shields were declared to be exempt from premarket approval and, when marketed for use only in healthcare settings, needed only follow a few general guidelines. They had to be labelled properly (single use, reusable, etc.), not have an attached mask component, not burst into flames spontaneously, and cover the front and sides of the face.
There is no specific mention of which direction they should point in the FDA emergency use authorization, however it does state that they must be used in accordance with CDC recommendations. These recommendations do specify that a face shield should cover the forehead. Only the ZShield Health, the first face shield they produced and one that is only marketed to healthcare entities, follows this guideline because it is designed like a classic face shield.
In May, the FDA issued updated guidance that superseded the April emergency use authorization. This time, they included distribution of face shields intended for medical use to the general public and softened the approval criteria by taking out the clear need to adhere to CDC recommendations for face shield design. They also altered the wording regarding undue risk just a bit. Here is the original:
The product is not intended for any use that would create an undue risk in light of the public health emergency; for example, the labeling does not state that use of the authorized face shield alone will prevent infection from microbes or viruses…
Not surprisingly, ZVerse began marketing the new ZShield products to the general public that same month. In the press releases, they straight up claim that their unique face shields can serve as an alternative to face masks, which is demonstrably untrue. In the FDA update, the language about proper labeling and lack of flammability was the same. But they took out the part about proscribing labeling that claims that face shield use alone is effective as a prevention of infections and replaced it thusly:
The product is not intended for any use that would create an undue risk in light of the public health emergency, for example, the labeling does not include uses for antimicrobial or antiviral protection or related uses or uses for infection prevention or reduction or related uses…
When you look at the product labels for the ZShield products, sure enough they don’t make any claim about preventing infections. Yet as I’ve already described above, that kind of language is all over the marketing, which is pretty shady in my humble opinion, particularly given how bad their design is. If this isn’t undue risk in light of the public health emergency we are experiencing during this pandemic, I don’t know what is. It’s unfortunate that there is nothing in the language of the FDA approval guidance that would require additional protections when such a significant change is made to the form of an existing medical device.
Conclusion: ZShield is not the answer
The manufacturers of ZShield appear to be choosing comfort and ease of use/customer preference over effectiveness in the design of products that they are selling to the general public. It’s dangerous to promote what is essentially an untested medical device with such low likelihood of preventing the spread of COVID-19. And the degree to which they’ve contorted the available scientific studies and expert recommendations to give the appearance of legitimate protection is wrong.

Science-Based Satire: Kinesiology Masks Revolutionize Coronavirus Prevention
Can colorful elastic tape applied to your face by certified practitioners reduce your risk of catching the novel coronavirus? No. And that’s a hard no. This is satire.
Clay Jones on March 13, 2020
Link

Albuquerque, NM – ElastiCorp, makers of elastic athletic tape popular among elite athletes as well as weekend joggers, has developed a more effective medical mask that may be a game changer in the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic.
Properly applied, our Kinesio Mask technology is a revolutionary advance in reducing your risk of becoming infected with the coronavirus,” ElastiCorp CEO Greg Vern Der Derp explained. “Plus it’s 100% safe and made from non-GMO cotton, spandex, and adhesive resins. It’s like a warm hug for your immune system!
What makes ElastiCorp’s new medical mask so effective? According to Vern Der Derp, it is designed to facilitate the wearer’s innate healing powers while at the same time supporting and stabilizing the nasal and oral musculature. It is safe for people of all ages and won’t interfere with your ability to talk or swallow.
According to medical experts, like ElastiCorp Chief of Research and Marketing Mort Fishman MD, the secret to Kinesio Mask technology is its ability to restore cellular homeostasis and to promote lymphatic drainage by gently lifting the skin. “Lymphatic drainage plays a key role in the immune system. And if you target the regions where viruses like coronavirus are known to enter the body, you can reduce inflammation and decrease the risk of infection by a percentage. And the masks come in seven different colors!”
There is a potential downside to the Kinesio Mask, however, and that’s the potential for a false sense of security. It isn’t magic, it’s science. You can’t simply place an order on Amazon Prime, or pick one up at the nearest CVS, and expect to see the benefits being touted by ElastiCorp. Each mask needs to be specifically applied based on your individual facial structure, which can only be determined during an evaluation by a certified Kinesio Masking Method (KMM) provider. These highly trained experts have all mastered The Method during an intensive course, known as The Weekend, that was designed by ElastiCorp and is very reasonably priced.
Vern Der Derp, who has used a Kinesio Mask since the initial prototype was developed in January, has never tested positive for the novel coronavirus. Not even once. “I can’t stress enough how important it is to be evaluated by a professional, a certified professional. There are people out there claiming to know the Method who haven’t gone through The Weekend, so be careful. Ultimately, you may not know if your mask was properly applied for weeks or even months. If you get sick, it wasn’t.”
If you register online for The Weekend using the code “Gorski”, you will receive a 5% discount.
Behind the mask
The novel coronavirus pandemic is scary, so naturally there are all kinds of bogus claims being made to take advantage of our collective fear. Fear, and the panic that is might induce, will only add to the overall harm that comes from this virus. You will be better off by far listening to experts from reputable organizations such as the WHO and the CDC.
Kinesiology tape is nonsense. Colorful and artistic in its application, but nonsense nonetheless. It works no better than traditional athletic tape, it just costs more. For one example of just how silly it gets out there in researchlandia, in 2018 I discussed a non-satirical study looking into the influence of kinesiology tape color on athletic performance. Seriously.
I couldn’t help but giggle at the thought of someone having elastic tape placed over their mouth and nose in a foolhardy attempt to prevent viral infections. I can imagine that the placement of holes for breathing would be based on a complex algorithm or perhaps even quantum mechanics. The language I used is exactly what proponents of these products use. I just took it one (maybe two) steps further. I do feel, a bit, like perhaps I’m violating Poe’s Law. It wouldn’t be the first time.

Handwashing to Prevent Pandemic
A new study finds that handwashing at airports is probably the single most effective method for preventing pandemics.
Steven Novella on February 12, 2020
Link

The new Wuhan Coronavirus outbreak (which has officially been named Covid-19) has renewed interest in pandemics, the risk of having one, and how to prevent them. As is often the case, people tend to focus their attention suboptimally, based largely on fear or availability, not on hard numbers. There is talk of closing borders, and no story about the Coronavirus is complete without a picture of many people wearing surgical masks. What we should be showing is a picture of someone washing their hands.
A new study looks at the epidemiology of pandemics – worldwide spread of a contagious disease – and the impact of improving handwashing at airports, especially key travel hubs. The results reinforce the importance of hand-hygiene in preventing disease spread.
Only about 70% of people, for example, wash their hands after using a public restroom. Of those, only about half wash with soap and water for the requisite 15 seconds minimum. The study authors estimate that at any given time only about 20% of people moving through an airport have clean hands. The rest are at risk for carrying pathogens, as they operate kiosks, use handrails, touch the arms of chairs, and elsewhere. The risk for spread of disease is therefore immense.
They further identified the 120 airports around the world that are most influential in spreading disease. These include the most trafficked, but that was not the only criterion. Having a position between different regions, and therefore serving as a gateway, is also important. Connecting to large international hubs is also a factor. They conducted simulations of disease spread involving these airports. To drill down a bit further, they identified the 10 most important airports to a hypothetical outbreak location. They then examined the impact of even modest increases in handwashing at those 10 airports.
First, by increasing “traveler engagement” with hand hygiene at all airports, the risk of an outbreak turning into a pandemic can be reduced by 24-69%. By focusing just on the 10 most important airports for a particular outbreak, the risk of spreading to a pandemic can be reduced by up to 37% – that’s with just increasing hand-hygiene messaging for passengers at 10 airports.
The results suggest that handwashing is likely the single most effective method for reducing the spread of flu-like viral illness. This should not only focus on airports, although they are the most important for global spread. Any public location is a potential risk for the spread of viruses, and being careful what you touch, plus practicing good hand-hygiene while in public, is an important safety measure.
What about those masks? The bottom line (for basic surgical masks) is that they block large particles and droplets, but not small particles. This does reduce the spread of respiratory pathogens from a sick wearer. So if you are sick and you are going into public (which you probably should not do), wearing the mask will partially protect others. If you are not sick and want to protect yourself from getting a pathogen, the mask modestly reduces your risk – if they are worn properly and consistently. But this benefit is only measurable if you are in the middle of a disease outbreak.
So, for example, if you are in China there may be some benefit to wearing a mask (tightly and consistently) if you are going out into public. Outside of China, in the US, for example, there is no reason to wear a mask and it will likely be of no benefit. In other words, there is no evidence for routine preventive use, only for use during an outbreak.
What about travel restrictions? These make intuitive sense – a contagion is spread internationally largely through air-travel, so restrictions should help. However, the evidence does no support travel restrictions as a policy solution. A 2014 systematic review of travel restriction for influenza outbreak found that it only delayed, but did not prevent, international spread. A 2020 review for non-influenza viruses, which would include Coronaviruses like SARS, MERS, and the current Wuhan strain, found minimal evidence for effectiveness. This is not the same as concluding it doesn’t work, and the authors called for more research.
The evidence is mixed, however. A 2006 study found a substantial role for airline travel in the spread of influenza virus. Another study from 2006 found benefit to reduce the spread of a moderately contagious disease by restricting regional travel >50 km. I think the bottom line is that travel restrictions are not as effective as we thought, but we need more research to understand its impact better.
Meanwhile, there is also evidence for major downsides to travel restrictions. They reduce information sharing, and the availability of resources in hard-hit areas. This may paradoxically increase a local outbreak, feeding into an epidemic and even pandemic, while only delaying the inevitable.
Combined with this evidence, the current study suggests that our efforts might be best focused on increasing hand hygiene at airports, especially those that are vital hubs to the outbreak region, rather than restricting travel. Masks in targeted areas, with proper instruction on use, may also have a benefit, but probably not as much as handwashing.
The latest numbers (which will be out of date by the time you read this) as of 2/11/2020 is that >40,000 cases have been confirmed in China, with >1,000 deaths. The numbers are still increasing geometrically, and we don’t appear to be close to the end of this epidemic, which has a high risk of turning into an official pandemic. These numbers are still dwarfed by an average flu season, to put things into perspective. There have been 13 million flu cases so far this season, with >6,000 deaths. The death rate from the novel Covid-19 Coronavirus is greater, but so far the total cases are lower by orders of magnitude. Only time will tell how big this epidemic will get.

Part of a Complete Breakfast
Infection control. When one adheres to compliance it is effective. Like masks and COVID 45.
Mark Crislip on March 21, 2023
Link

For much of my career in Infectious Diseases I was head of infection control for two hospital systems and one long-term care facility, a total of 6 institutions with differing levels of care and acuity. So I tend to see everything through the lens of infection and infection control. Makes me fun at parties.
The goal of infection control is to, well, control infection. Kind of a duh. But it can be divided into preventing hospital acquired infections (surgical wound infection, ventilator acquired pneumonia, central line infections, etc.) and preventing the spread of contagion to staff and patients (influenza, COVID 45, chickenpox, etc.).
When I started in the biz, I thought the occasional hospital acquired infection was the price paid for high-tech invasive medicine. You can’t do what we do to people and not get the occasional infection.
Wrong.

My first hint was hand hygiene. It has been known for 200 years that hands are an excellent source to spread infections around the hospital and that handwashing stops the spread of germs. Despite that ancient knowledge, handwashing compliance with adherence -or is it adherence with compliance?- was abysmal.
There was one surgeon who refused to wash his hands or wear gloves for dressing change, and a medical specialist said it was too much of a bother as the sink was on the other side of the room. And the anesthesiologists? Jesus. Getting them to wash hands much less do full barriers for central line infections or alcohol wiping a medicine bottle was impossible, much less washing hands.
One of the good things about hospitals assuming physician practices is it standardizes good behavior, or you are gone. This was decades ago, and all of the above doctors are long gone. But it taught me early that a remarkable number of doctors are recalcitrant morons who willingly ignore best practice and the medical literature. As you read this, remember, that sometimes highly educated and trained doctors are unable to do the right thing.
Then came alcohol foam. At first, I thought it was like Easy Cheese, a convenient way to deliver alcohol and it was to be used orally. To my disappointment, I quickly discovered that it was better used on the hands. With only 20% adherence with compliance, infection rates fell by half. That was amazing. As compliance with adherence to using alcohol foam increased over time to 100%, the hospital infection rates fell in lock step.
The dose-response curve was interesting and unexpected, at least by me. And we really did get to 100%. The rule was you had to foam when entering and exiting a room. Period. And if noticed in real time, you would be (nicely) asked to foam, and the only response was ‘thank you.’ No whining, complaining, bitching or yelling allowed. I literally went to every nurse and doctor in the system to tell them the expectations and that if anyone complained about being asked to foam, they would be referred to me. I never got a referral.
Hand hygiene, combined with various targeted interventions for ventilator-associated pneumonia, line-related infections, catheter-related urinary tract infections, etc., drove our infection rates down to almost zero. In the early days of my practice, I made a living taking care of hospital-acquired infections; at the end? Almost nothing. It was nice to put myself out of work.
Around a decade ago, I realized that infections were not the price of doing business and that infection rates should be close to zero. Close, but not quite.
The problem was threefold. To keep infections at zero you have to do multiple interventions all the time, no fails ever aka perfection. Not humanly possible. Another is there would occasionally be some perfect storm of rare events that would combine to circumvent all our hard work. Microorganisms are wily creatures and will take advantage of even the slightest opportunity to start an infection.
And we do not always have control over patients’ behaviors after discharge and, to paraphrase Art Linkletter (anyone know what I am referring to here?), patients do the darnedest things and get infected.
The medical literature is filled with case reports and outbreaks of infections caused by the damnedest events and was one of the aspects of care that makes ID entertaining.
Preventing infections isn’t easy or simple. Multiple interventions, always done perfectly. But I am proud to say my hospitals were as close to perfection as is possible.
And it also depends on whether the organism can be part of the human condition or is only a pathogen. For example, besides hand hygiene, I am skeptical that outside of an outbreak, much of what we do to prevent the spread of MRSA or ESBL E. coli or other organisms that can be a normal part of our microbiome, does much to prevent spread. But for organisms that are only pathogenic? Much more important.
Which gets us to COVID 45, part of your complete infection control program and prevention in the real world.
All the cleaning and disinfection we do are mostly medical theater. COVID 45 is spread predominantly by aerosols/droplets. I do not doubt some poor slob has stuck his finger on some COVID laden snot and then placed that finger in his eye. Shit happens. You want to be grossed/entertained? Just watch people’s hands in a public space, say an OR break room. Fingers wander. But most successful interventions to prevent COVID spread are directed are the primary mode of transmission: the air.
So do masks work, and by work I mean prevent infection. Sure as hell do in the hospital. Well, mostly. I was initially surprised when I saw there were studies evaluating the efficacy of masks worn in the OR did not prevent infection.
From the limited results, it is unclear whether the wearing of surgical face masks by members of the surgical team has any impact on surgical wound infection rates for patients undergoing clean surgery.
But I considered. The organisms that cause surgical wound infections, Streptococci and Staphylococci, are not usually found in the upper respiratory tract. They can be. But not usually. It is rare for oral Streptococci to lead to infections from procedures. But Streptococci can jump from the HCW to patients, which is why masks are a good idea. Because, as noted, shit can happen. So I would prefer to have anyone doing a procedure to wear mask. Hopefully a new mask with each procedure. As a fellow I had a panic call from the OR. The surgeon had her mask around the neck during lunch and in the middle of an open heart a broccoli floweret fell from the mask and into the mediastinum. Largest cardiac vegetation of my career. The patient did fine; there should be nothing on a piece of cooked broccoli that can cause an infection.
But hospitals are controlled, aseptic environments where you have people like me pointing out your infection control failings in real time. The infected patient is in a fixed position, in bed most of the time, in a room with little for a pathogen to prosper and rapid air turnover. A hospital room has 6-12 air changes an hour, depending on the room. Air is pumped out of the rooms into the outdoors and with it pathogens, never reused. Makes the heating bill a bitch.
With knowledge of the predominant method of transmission (contact, fecal oral, droplet, aerosol, etc.), it is simple enough to throw together the necessary personal protective equipment to protect yourself from whatever pathogen the patient has. Each intervention does not lead to a binary result, it just decreases the odds of infection.
For what it is worth (little), 36 years of taking care of acute infections and I never caught one from a patient. I was up to by eyebrows in COVID and I have avoided that pathogen. So far. I did convert my PPD as a fellow, but I suspect it was a non-occupational TB exposure, from an unknown tubercular. Some data suggests that many healthcare workers PPD conversions are not work related. As one example
In the setting of an effective tuberculosis infection-control program, TST conversion rates were low, and the risk of conversion among HCWs was associated most strongly with nonoccupational factors.
Los Angeles and the county hospitals I frequented may not be the as TB free as one would like.
I can remember two respiratory outbreaks in my long and storied career. One was influenza, likely from a nurse who became symptomatic in the middle of their shift and spread flu to a few patients. And there was a chickenpox outbreak in one of our ICUs, the source never identified.
But otherwise no infections or outbreaks I can recall. I do not doubt there was the occasional transmission of flu or adenovirus or COVID or RSV from patient to staff, but it would be hard to know if these were acquired as part of work or part of life.
To my mind (lots of opinion to follow), trying to apply the concepts of hospital infection control to COVID was bound to be suboptimal or even ludicrous. I still think the 6-foot rule was stupid. It is fine for a hospital room, but in the real world people are constantly moving in and out of each other’s haze and air currents will take droplets and aerosols far from their origin.
Masks? I wrote the first draft in the Fiji airport waiting for a flight home from New Zealand, and the few who are wearing masks are wearing them poorly or the wrong ones.
It is, I think, clear, that masks, as well as other social distancing (like avoiding people inside as much as possible), stops respiratory infection transmission. Most respiratory viruses disappeared during COVID. China, following the lead of Florida, has seen the results of changing from maximal to minimal COVID prevention.
The recent Cochrane meta-analysis is, to my mind, worthless. I am not a big fan of meta-analysis as a means of coming to a truth of a matter. To my mind, the theory behind a meta-analysis is you collect multiple piles of cow manure into one large pile, and you get spun gold. Mmm. No.
A meta-analysis can offer a nice overview of a topic, but I have never found an expert in a field who thought a meta-analysis in their field of expertise was the last word on a topic. The more expertise in a field, the more you read the primary literature and try to apply it to patients, the less enthusiastic you are about meta’s. I use them like the proverbial drunk and a lamppost.
Masks to prevent respiratory infections in the community? There are a lot of questions around mask use as there are with vaccinations. Like all of medicine, it is complex.
“If you wear a mask while there’s a pandemic, are you less likely to get sick?”“If you wear a mask while you have a respiratory illness, are you less likely to infect other people?”“If you make people less likely to get sick during a pandemic, does that have lasting benefits to them, or does it just delay an infection without significantly changing their long-term health outcomes? Does it reduce transmission enough to change the overall dynamics of the pandemic?”“If you tell people to wear masks, will they actually wear masks correctly and reliably?”
Nope.
“If you mandate that people wear masks, will they actually wear masks correctly and reliably?”“What are the costs, to the median person and to a person who is unusually affected by wearing masks, of wearing masks?”
My take, no surprise, is the better the mask and the more you wear it, the less the odds of getting a respiratory illness, including COVID 45. Add other protective interventions, the odds go down further. There are other opinions:
“There is just no evidence that they” — masks — “make any difference. Full stop.” Tucker Carlson.
Whoops. Wrong attribution, same credibility for me. It was Tom Jefferson, who said in the same interview.
The idea that the COVID virus is transmitted via aerosols has been repeated over and over as if it’s “truth” but the evidence is as thin as air.
Which begs the question: why does the Cochrane hire these authors? If you judge a person by the company they keep, it cannot be good for their reputation. Of course, it could be they like the opinions of a maverick. I saw Maverick recently. Awful. Predictable, cliché ridden, full of unbelievable plot holes, brain-dead. It looked good until you actually thought about it. Made Plan 9 From Outer Space look good in comparison.
Is that what the meta analysis showed? I plowed through the whole thing. Nope.
As noted above, it was extremely difficult to get highly educated and trained medical professionals to use protection correctly. Insert pregnancy joke of your own choosing here.
The key paragraphs in the article?
Adherence with interventions, especially educational programmes, was a problem for many studies despite the importance of many such low-cost interventions. Adherence with mask wearing varied; it was generally around 60% to 80%, but was reported to be as low as 40% (see Table 1). Overall, the logistics of carrying out trials that involve sustained behaviour change are demanding, particularly in challenging settings such as immigrant neighbourhoods or students’ halls of residence.
The identified trials provided sparse and unsystematic data on adverse effects of the intervention, and few of the RCTs measured or reported adherence with the intervention, which is especially important for the use of medical/surgical masks or N95 respirators. No studies investigated how the level of adherence may have influenced the effect size.
and
The observed lack of effect of mask wearing in interrupting the spread of influenza-like illness (ILI) or influenza/COVID-19 in our review has many potential reasons, including: poor study design; insufficiently powered studies arising from low viral circulation in some studies; lower adherence with mask wearing, especially amongst children; quality of the masks used; self-contamination of the mask by hands; lack of protection from eye exposure from respiratory droplets (allowing a route of entry of respiratory viruses into the nose via the lacrimal duct); saturation of masks with saliva from extended use (promoting virus survival in proteinaceous material); and possible risk compensation behaviour leading to an exaggerated sense of security
Given the adherence to mask use and other issues, this study is no different than comparing homeopathy to water.
You could reasonably conclude that mask mandates have issues or that infection control techniques used outside the hospital have adherence issues, rendering judgment on their efficacy problematic. That would be a reasonable response. A messy literature should lead to a messy conclusion. To conclude that masks don’t work? I wonder how it feels to have the blood on innocents on your hands?
But then, not even the Cochrane agrees with the Cochrane:
one of the lead authors of the review even more seriously misinterpreted its finding on masks by saying in an interview that it proved “there is just no evidence that they make any difference.” In fact, Soares-Weiser said, “that statement is not an accurate representation of what the review found.”
I remember as an intern discussing whether a study that looked at upper GI endoscopy was helpful for upper GI bleeds. The study said no, but my GI attending pointed out no intervention to stop the bleeding was done. They just looked, said yep, there’s bleeding, and removed the scope. There has to be an intervention before you can declare it is of use or not. And a chin mask doesn’t cut it.
If you have highly infectious diseases, as most respiratory viri are, and you are not OCD punctilious with your infection control, no prevention is going to work. It was really difficult to get proper prevention methods in HCWs. In the real world? Forgetaboutit.
I was going to use seatbelts as my go to example, figuring that everyone uses seatbelts, 100% adherence, and how combined with multiple other engineered safety features cars have become remarkably safe compared to the 1950s. A nice metaphor for infection prevention, I assumed there would be nice before and after data as everyone would use seatbelts to avoid the annoying chime.
Nope.
People don’t wear their damn seatbelts.
15%.
And use of seatbelt reminder systems only increases seatbelt use a few percentage points.
The Cochrane reviews have never done a meta-analysis on seatbelt use. I assume if they did, they would use the same methodology and ignore whether seatbelts were actually used correctly, just if seatbelts were in the car. And I assume they would conclude
“There is just no evidence that they” — seatbelts — “make any difference. Full stop.”
It’s all about the odds. Depending on the infection, various interventions, if done correctly, will decrease the odds of spreading infection. The more interventions you apply and the more adherent with compliance you are, the better the results. And it is a royal pain in the neck to do correctly and consistently. In the real world, compared to the hospital, interventions will likely be less than impressive because adherence with compliance will stink on ice. Infection control will be done haphazardly, at best.
Still, I wore an N95 on the plane and in the waiting areas. I avoid people if I can. The best thing about COVID was I had a great excuse to avoid people, which I prefer to do anyway. And I don’t inhale. Learned that from Clinton.
COVID 45 was and is horrific. It has killed 7 million people and is still killing around 1000 people a day. Around a 0.1% death rate. But that’s nothing. Influenza killed maybe 5% of the world in 1918-1919. In three months. In a slow moving, relatively empty, world. Flu will return, and avian influenza is waiting its turn to become infectious as well as fatal.
When, not if, we get a respiratory infection that is both highly contagious and has a 5, 20, 50% mortality rate, we will need every intervention to slow the infection down, please. And people will look at nonsense like erroneous takes on the Cochrane reviews and those interventions will not be used. And a lot people will die unnecessarily.
Full stop.

Letter to a Medical Student: There Is No Elite RCT Strike Force
None of us have to fantasize what we would have done during a pandemic. What you actually did the past three years is exactly what you would have done.
Jonathan Howard on May 5, 2023
Link

Dear Mr. Knudsen,
I recently read your article on Sensible Medicine titled Death and Isolation During a Pandemic. You wrote movingly of your grandfather’s death and reflected on the tragedy of people dying alone at the start of the pandemic. As someone who lived through it all, I couldn’t agree more. Anyone who worked in the hospital at that time remembers patients suffering without their loved ones and aching goodbyes via IPads. I’m sure you’ve read about it. It happened to an overwhelming number of families who will be forever scarred. I’ll never forget one father who screamed at us over the phone that we didn’t try hard enough to save his 35-year-old son. Had he been there, he would have at least had the comfort of knowing we did everything possible. His son had clots throughout his body, and there was nothing to do. How horrible that he believes his son might still be alive had we only tried a bit harder.
However, your article contained this problematic section. You wrote:
Now, the empirical question, does limiting visitors reduce the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and thus lower the incidence of COVID-19? The answer to this question is important and can provide a framework for thinking about the risk-benefit calculus of allowing visitors. Unfortunately, we don’t have an answer or any high quality data supporting this question, as shown in this systematic analysis. As discussed previously, there are a host of possible upsides to this policy; however, it is unclear if they are true.
Even with reasonable predictions, we live in a world that is messy and random, and thus require rigorously designed studies to uncover one form of the truth. I imagine that a cluster randomized controlled trial could have provided an answer. This would consist of randomizing hospitals into two groups: ones that allows visitors and others that restrict them. Then, over time, outcomes would be tracked in each group to measure the impact of the policy. I specifically left outcomes vague because the pertinent outcomes are debatable, but I would argue that a good starting point is COVID-19 hospital admissions. Another relevant outcome may be the number of positive COVID-19 cases in the surrounding community – although this would be more difficult to directly link to the policy. The broader point being that there are ways to uncover answers. There are smart people in positions of power with resources that can design and conduct such studies. Ultimately, they failed us, and we are left without answers and policies that caused significant harm.
Really, what would have been the point of your study?
It might not seem so, but there’s a lot to unpack here.
We both agree that randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the “gold standard” in medicine, so how could I object to your call for a rigorous RCT to answer an important question? To answer that, I am going to do something that the doctors behind Sensible Medicine obviously didn’t do- I am going to respect you and take you seriously.
First of all, who exactly are “they“? Whom exactly did you have in mind when you wrote, “There are smart people in positions of power with resources that can design and conduct such studies“? You seem certain that someone had the time, resources, and authority to run your imagined RCT, but just chose not to for some stupid reason. Incredibly, you also think “they” should have had the foresight to run your imagined RCT. As morgues overflowed with victims of a new virus that lacked treatments and a vaccine, you think “they” should have been marshaling their resources to conduct an RCT of hospital visitation policies, as if there were no bigger fish to fry. Of course, your imagined RCT would have sounded utterly absurd at the start of the pandemic, which is why nobody actually suggested anything like it at the time.
You see, unless you know something I don’t, there isn’t a well-funded, elite RCT Strike Force that’s been training for a pandemic- though when a real virus arrived, they sat on the sidelines doing nothing for no particular reason. You seem to think that a large group of people with relevant medical expertise were really lazy. Who exactly do you think spent the pandemic twiddling their thumbs?
Maybe there should be an RCT Strike Force, but the cold truth is that no government or institution anywhere could have instantly whipped up dozens and dozens of rigorous RCTs to answer every pandemic conundrum and quandary, as you seem to imagine. In the real-world, politicians meddled with scientific agencies, and the CDC couldn’t even get basic tests right. Much of the federal response was in shambles from the pandemic’s earliest days. You should read about it. According to one recent article:
Early on, the government went off the rails.
In February 2020, the focus was on containment, with measures such as the travel ban on China and repatriation of Americans, including those stranded on cruise ships. Emergency mobilization efforts “languished,” the report noted. There was “confusion and friction about who was in charge of what problems.” The government’s “crisis action plan” amounted to little more than jargon. “There was little in it about what people would actually do.”
On Feb. 24, 2020, President Donald Trump tweeted from India, “The Coronavirus is very much under control in the USA … Stock market starting to look very good to me!” But according to the report, that same day, the White House task force concluded “containment was failing.” It was time to shift to mitigation. The next day, a high-ranking Centers for Disease Control and Prevention official, Nancy Messonnier, announced that community spread in the United States was inevitable. The stock market dived.
“President Trump was furious,” the report recalls. He kept downplaying the danger. “It’s going to disappear,” he said on Feb. 27. “Everything is really under control,” he said Feb. 29.
It was not. The authors of the report show, in detail, how federal crisis management “splintered by the third week of March.” HHS Secretary Alex Azar had placed the assistant secretary for preparedness and response, Robert Kadlec, in charge of the HHS effort — but at the same time, Vice President Mike Pence’s staff kicked him off the White House task force. The head of the Food and Drug Administration was not even on the task force for the first month. The CDC was “fractured into too many missions.” While some officials recognized the urgency of a crash program of testing and masks, “Kadlec had no money, no real emergency fund.”
“By late April, as a frightened and bewildered country became more and more confused about continuing business and school closures, and after some brow-raising comments at a White House briefing in which he discussed treating the virus with light, heat, or disinfectant, Trump essentially detached himself from his own government,” the report says. “He moved toward questioning and challenging what other government officials were doing.”
“The administration abdicated its wartime responsibility to lead,” they add. “It left the battlefield, and the war strategy” to the states and localities. By April, the White House chief of staff concluded the task force was “useless and broken.”
This is whom you imagine had the power, resources, and competency to have carried out your imagined RCT. They are “they.” 
Even if “they” had an elite RCT Strike Force at their disposal and bizarrely prioritized your imagined RCT at the start of the pandemic, it still faced many obstacles. I agree that COVID hospital admissions would be a reasonable outcome to track. But a woman who visits her sister at Hospital X, isn’t necessarily going to be admitted to Hospital X if she contracts COVID herself. At Bellevue, where I worked, nearly all of our patients were transferred from other overwhelmed hospitals. You should read about it. As such, your study would require that hospital visitors be followed and their hospital admissions tracked.
I am not an expert in this area, but it sure seems to me your imagined RCT would require informed consent for every hospital visitor. How would a grieving family feel if they lost another loved one and only later learned she was infected in a hospital that was part of a medical experiment to which she did not consent? Doesn’t she have the right to know the risks of your RCT, which include death, before she participates in it? At least one Twitter commentator had this to say about your proposed study:
Do you disagree? They ended their Twitter thread by saying, “The author of that blurb should have all their past contributions to field research reviewed for breaches of consent.”
Consenting every visitor at multiple hospitals while COVID raged would have been a Herculean task. Obtaining informed consent is a lengthy, formal process, not something done as people walk by you in the hallway. It’s not like asking people to sign a petition. Could you imagine actually trying to obtain informed consent from grieving families? What woman, on the verge of losing her husband of 50-years, would listen patiently as you explained the nature of your experiment? Much of this would have to be done via translator phones. Did you consider this? Many our patients did not speak English.
Tracking every visitor at multiple hospitals while COVID raged would also have been a Herculean task. How exactly do you think this should have been done? People would likely travel great distances to say goodbye to a loved one. Would grieving families be willing to share details of their fate to researchers over the telephone? It’s easy to imagine people would just want to be left alone if they got very sick with COVID as part of your experiment.Again, who exactly had the resources to do all this? Such expertise can’t be created out of thin air in a matter of weeks in the middle of a raging pandemic. There’s not an endless supply of clinical research coordinators. Why should these skilled professionals have dropped everything to run your imagined RCT? Thankfully, “they” chose to prioritize vaccine RCTs.
Many more questions and challenges remain:
    • Would administrators have let their hospitals participate in your imagined RCT? I doubt it. An RCT of hospital visiting policies wouldn’t have been on their radar at the pandemic’s start. They were too busy trying to get PPE, staffing, and places to store the dead bodies.
    • Would multiple hospital IRBs have approved a study that allowed large numbers of unvaccinated family members into unventilated rooms full of contagious patients? As morgues overflowed and forklifts were needed to move corpses into refrigerated trucks, would an IRB have actually accepted that there was true clinical equipoise and that your study needed to be run at that moment? I’m skeptical.
    • I work at two hospitals, NYU and Bellevue, that are blocks apart in terms of their distance, but worlds apart in terms of the patients they treat and communities they serve. To control for these discrepancies, you’d have to enroll a large number of hospitals. How many would have to participate to get meaningful results? What would happen to your study if some dropped out?
    • What if hospital staff objected to your study? We are packed like sardines on the elevators on a normal day. Your imagined RCT would have greatly increased our exposure to the virus at a time when no one was vaccinated. I wouldn’t have been thrilled to have been randomized to the “visitor’s allowed” hospital. We had enough sick healthcare workers as it was, and several of my co-workers died. You should read about them. Why didn’t you factor us into your imagined study?
    • What if other family members objected to your study? It’s easy to imagine family members strongly disagreeing about whether to visit a dying relative. Imagine an elderly couple living with their two adult children. If dad gets hospitalized, his immunocompromised daughter may strongly feel the risk of anyone visiting is too high. Does she get a say in your RCT? What if her brother visits their dad against her wishes and brings the virus home. What effect might this have on the family? He too might regret his decision, especially if anyone suffers as a result. What if your RCT created great conflict in people and families? Did you think about this at all?
    • What if the general public objected? Allowing hospital visitors would have meant more people on subways and buses, and therefore more risk for the essential workers who used them. You should read about their experience. Would these unvaccinated workers have had any input into your study?
    • Many hospitals were deluged with COVID patients in the spring of 2020. You should read about it. It’s not unreasonable to imagine that large groups of mourners in a hospital room would have greatly increased the spread of COVID in the spring of 2020. What contingency measures would be in place if that happened? Did you even consider that possibility?
    • Might patients and their families preferentially chose a hospital that was randomized to allow visitation? How would this affect the results?
    • Would a trial conducted in the spring of 2020 have any relevance today? I don’t think so. Both the population and the virus itself have changed too much. The original vaccine RCTs became obsolete in less than a year. Why would your RCT age better?
    • How long would your study have taken? In New York, one of the states with the strictest policies, hospital were mandated to allow visitors in June 2021. Do you really think your study would have been yielded actionable results before this? I doubt it.
    • Would you, or anyone else, support visitation restrictions today if your study found that hospital visitors increased the spread of COVID? Even RCTs that yield an unambiguous scientific result rarely allow us all to agree what policy should flow from them. They almost never provide a crystal clear answer to complicated social and ethical questions, a point you recognize. But have you given any thought into how your imagined RCT might actually inform policy? Let’s pretend your study found that allowing visitors increased community COVID infections by 14.3% (or any other number). Should hospitals allow visitors or not? Would everyone agree with your answer? Are you certain that your imagined RCT wouldn’t interject uncertainty and polarization into the rare issue where there seems to be near uniform agreement today? I’m not sure exactly when the policy of restricting visitors should have ended, but like everyone else, I’m glad it’s gone. So, even if your study were perfectly and rapidly executed at the pandemic’s start, for how long would it have held relevance? Everybody made up their mind about this issue long ago, and everyone agrees on it today. So really, what would have been the point of your study?
Challenge 1
Your imagined RCT didn’t occur to anybody at the start of the pandemic and there’s no one who actually could have run it had the idea oddly popped into their head. To be blunt, I think it’s just another sad example of An Impossible, Unethical Study of Dubious Value That’s Not Meant to be Taken Seriously. Since you disagree, I have two challenges for you- one for now and one for later.
My immediate challenge is to write the protocol for your imagined RCT. I challenge you write up the exact methods, outcome measures, and power analysis for an RCT that actually would have gotten IRB approval as well as buy-in from the relevant stakeholders and that actually would have been feasible at the pandemic’s start and actionable in a useful time frame.
For reference, the protocol for just one of the pediatric vaccine RCTs was 460 pages of dense policies and procedures. You should read it. I don’t expect you to produce such a document, but it shows the enormous thought and effort that serious people put into designing an RCT, even a completely straightforward one, when they actually intend for it to be done in the real world. Moreover, RCTs are very expensive and our public health agencies haven’t been drowning in money. Quite the opposite, actually. You should read about it. Your trial sounds expensive. So in your proposal, please include an estimate of how much your study will cost, where funding should come from, and how this might have impacted funding for RCTs for vaccines and COVID treatments.
Of course, writing a protocol and securing funding is the easy part. Once those are done, the real work begins. Research staff has to be hired and trained, hospitals have to agree to sign-up, multiple IRB boards have to give their approval, subjects have to be enrolled, outcomes have to be measured, and the data has to be analyzed and published. Running a large RCT is a logistical marvel with many moving parts and opportunities for things to go wrong. I suggest you listen to people who actually tried this pandemic. You could learn a lot. One researcher said:
I think of what my clinical research team went through to enroll people in that trial, and I thought my nurses were going to die. One of them got covid and got sick. Imagine trying to do that on a daily basis, multiple patients, some of them facing intubation, none of them have their families.
Another said:
There was one day our system had 84 deaths. And then you’re going to ask me to potentially put them on a placebo? It’s just really heart wrenching, talking with families, if your patients are able to communicate — and you’re dealing with all these deaths.
It turns out that actually running an RCT is a lot harder that just imagining one, especially during a pandemic. How would your study have overcome these obstacles?
Not surprisingly, graveyards are full of dead RCTs and there’s research into why trials fail. You should read about it. This continued during the pandemic. An article from the Gates Foundation titled “Uninformative Research” is the Global Health Crisis You’ve Never Heard Of said:
According to a 2021 study of thousands of COVID-19 drug trials, only 5% of the “study arms” included enough people to generate a statistically valid result. Chaos is to be expected during a crisis like a pandemic, but the norm during “peacetime” is nearly as worrisome. A recent study of U.S. clinical trials related to heart disease, diabetes, and lung cancer found that only 26% ended informatively. To put it bluntly: Three out of four were a waste of time and money.
Even trials “they” ran failed miserably during the pandemic. Although it was much less complicated that your imagined RCT, a proposed RCT of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin run by the NIH closed in a month after enrolling just 20 patients, or just 1% of their goal. I’m sure that study looked great on paper. Why would your study succeed when “they” couldn’t enroll more than 20 patients in the most basic RCT imaginable?
Let’s see what you can come with.
Challenge 2
My second challenge for you is more long term. I challenge you to avoid a lamentable career of merely writing blogs, imaging one impossible RCT after another and then whining that “they” didn’t do the trials you imagined. Unfortunately, throughout the pandemic, a small number of doctors, who’ve yet to make any contribution to an actual RCT, have falsely claimed that RCTs and only RCTs can answer even the most basic questions and that dozens of complicated RCTs could have easily been done if only “they” weren’t so stupid and incompetent. These doctors never promoted an actual RCT or encouraged their audience to enroll in one. Like you, they pretended the RCT Strike Force was real, and rather than do the hard work of advancing an actual RCT, they merely fantasized aloud what they would have done if they were in charge of it. It’s sad that these doctors are more famous and influential than the largely anonymous researchers who actually ran RCTs, don’t you think? (You should read this too).
Such idle fantasizing about impossible RCTs is a waste of time for a highly-trained medical doctor. It’s just not a valuable contribution. Do you really want your memoir to be titled “RCTs I Imagined and Things I Would Have Done“? I hope not.
Instead, I challenge you not to sit on the sidelines, but rather to become “they” and actually do the RCTs you imagine. You wrote that “there are ways to uncover answers”, and you made it all sound so easy. Soon, you should be the one uncovering those answers with RCTs.
In the meantime, I suggest you use your voice to educate the public that RCTs aren’t the only means by which doctors can learn about the world. There haven’t been any RCTs of the virus after all, and your statement that visitor restrictions caused “significant harm” wasn’t based on an RCT, was it? You just knew.
We can also make important decisions without an RCT to guide us. No RCT proved it would be safe to allow visitors at hospitals. We just used common sense and collectively agreed that the harm of COVID patients dying alone exceeded the unknown risk of allowing visitors. This didn’t seem to bother you. Yet, if we had clinical equipoise at the start of the pandemic don’t we still have it today? After all, your imagined RCT wasn’t actually done. So, would you support doing your RCT today, even though it would mean some families would be barred from visiting their dying loved one? I doubt it. People rarely demand rigorous RCTs to justify policies they support.
I also suggest you also use your voice to educate the public on the value of RCTs. Being part of an experiment is scary for a lot of people, yet medicine couldn’t advance without willing volunteers. Being a “guinea pig” is a derisive term, when it should be a compliment. Though it’s not been the main focus of my career, I’ve tried to enroll patients in many different studies over the years. It’s not always easy. As you’ll find out, many patients don’t trust “they“. Unfortunately, articles like yours give the public every reason to distrust “they“- the actual people who actually try to enroll patients in RCTs. How do you think “they” feel when a medical student degrades them as you did? Do you think it makes their job easier? Do articles like yours actually advance the cause of RCTs?
I don’t think so.
And this upsets me, because I believe strongly in RCTs. Those of us who recognize we can’t study every aspect of the pandemic via an RCT are not against them in principle, as some doctors imply. It would be wonderful if running an RCT was as easy as imagining one. Because I want RCTs to actually succeed in the real-world I’ve encouraged people to enroll in them. Here’s what I said in the very first article I wrote this pandemic:
I’ve always believed that people who participate in medical research are doing a noble thing. If no one volunteered for such research, medicine would never advance.
I doubt that alone convinced anyone to enter an RCT, but I suspect if more doctors spread positive messages about RCTs, instead of berating “they“, this would have had a positive impact in the real-world. My dedication is such that I volunteered to be in a vaccine-RCT. My contribution was a small one,- the study took place at my hospital and I got snacks- but at least it was a real one. I want my actions to match my words, and I don’t feel like a complete backseat driver when I say that more RCTs should have been done this pandemic. The UK’s RECOVERY program was a model for what should have been, and I actually think a well-funded, elite RCT Strike Force would be amazing.
Until that exists, however, your statement that there are “smart people in positions of power with resources that can design and conduct such studies” was gross misinformation. Endless calls for someone else to run impossible RTCs of everything are just a way for the commentariat class to do what they’ve done the entire pandemic; spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about common sense measures to control a rapidly-spreading virus in a world with finite time and resources. Doctors imagine impossible studies not because they actually want them to get done, but rather to sow doubt in the public’s mind. They want people to think that we shouldn’t do anything until we know everything. None of this is new. Casting doubt on vaccines by calling for an impossible RCT of the entire vaccine schedule over the entire human lifespan looking at every outcome imaginable is one of the oldest anti-vaxxer tricks in the book. You should read about it.
Fantasies of impossible studies always end with some version of what you said: “they failed us, and we are left without answers and policies that caused significant harm.” In the real-world, during a raging pandemic with a brand new virus, “they” had to make many difficult decisions without the benefit of a rigorous RCT to guide them at every turn. Yet, doctors who merely imagine RCTs absurdly claim “they” have only themselves to blame for their predicament.
Unfortunately, this was all part of a larger trend where doctors with no real-world responsibility for anything made impossible things sound very easy in Tweets, editorials, and YouTube videos. They acted as if there were no difference between writing “protect the vulnerable” and actually protecting the vulnerable. As I wrote previously:
In the imaginary world, all it took to protect nursing homes and open schools was to say “protect nursing homes” and “open schools”. In the real world, this was impossible when the virus was allowed to spread freely.
When impossible things could not be done effortlessly in the real-world, “they” were always to blame. Is it any surprise that in the real-world, public health officials were routinely threatened and even attacked by angry, paranoid citizens? You should read about it.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with fantasizing how you would have handled the pandemic had you been given unlimited time, money, and power, as well as total public cooperation with all of your imagined plans- basically God-like powers. However, you should recognize that this is just play-acting, not a serious contribution. You see, none of us have to fantasize what we would have done during a pandemic. What you actually did the past three years is exactly what you would have done.
And something tells me that if you’re brave enough to devote your career to actually running RCTs, you’ll no longer be impressed by doctors who merely imagine RCTs they would have done, while moaning “they failed us” because in the real world, actually running an RCT is a lot harder than just imagining one.
Note: I also turned this into a video essay.

What’s So “Wonderful!” About an Article That Provoked Hateful Revenge Fantasies Against Frontline Doctors and Public Health Officials?
“May he be forever riddled with guilt. May he suffer the loss of a loved one in the same manner. May he die alone.”
Jonathan Howard on May 31, 2024
Link

Letter to a Medical Student: There Is No Elite RCT Strike Force
Let’s revisit two of my prior essays.
In one of them, Letter to a Medical Student: There Is No Elite RCT Strike Force, I discussed an article on Sensible Medicine, a monetized blog that spreads blatant anti-vaccine misinformation, titled Death and Isolation During a Pandemic by Ben Knudsen. Mr. Knudsen felt public health officials tried too hard to stop the spread of a deadly virus at the start of the pandemic. He wrote:
It seems as if our hyper-focus on the virus blinded us to the negative implications of certain policies – a calamitous error that will leave a stain on public health’s reputation for decades.
Mr. Knudsen castigated “they” because “they” did not do a randomized controlled-trial (RCT) of hospitalization visitation policies at the start of the pandemic. He felt “they” could and should have done any RCT he merely imagined years later. He wrote:
I imagine that a cluster randomized controlled trial could have provided an answer. This would consist of randomizing hospitals into two groups: ones that allows visitors and others that restrict them. Then, over time, outcomes would be tracked in each group to measure the impact of the policy… There are smart people in positions of power with resources that can design and conduct such studies. Ultimately, they failed us, and we are left without answers and policies that caused significant harm...
I think many of the pandemic policies can be summed up with a simple phrase: “We missed the forest for the trees”. Public health had a myopic focus on stopping the spread of the virus through policies such as limiting visitors in hospitals, masking children, school closures, vaccine mandates, isolating older individuals and by doing so, were unable to see or predict the detrimental harms. Obviously, this doesn’t apply to all policies, but many of them failed to consider what it means to be human.
In my essay, I made it clear there was no distance between myself and Mr. Knudsen about the suffering caused by people dying without their family in 2020. I saw it with my own eyes, and I described it in my essay. However, hospitals were full of people who were kind and compassionate to their dying relative. Those who lost a loved one to COVID should know this. Of course, too many of these kind and compassionate people died of COVID too. Maybe it’s because he didn’t witness this himself, but Mr. Knudsen neglected to inform his readers about any of this.
However, I also argued that anyone who seriously thought about Mr. Knudsen’s imagined RCT for even a nanosecond, something he did not expect his readers to do, would recognize that it would have been both impossible and a waste of resources. There’s no way this RCT actually could have been done, especially considering the most basic RCTs imaginable failed miserably at the time. Mr. Knudsen completely misinformed his readers when he said, “There are smart people in positions of power with resources that can design and conduct such studies.” If the doctors behind Sensible Medicine were in charge of our entire pandemic response, there’s no way they would have pulled off this study. It didn’t even occur to them at the time, and to my knowledge, they did nothing to advance an actual RCT during the pandemic.
It so happens that casually imagining RCTs is the easiest thing in the world. As those who tried will tell you, actually doing them was extremely hard, especially when the virus was spreading unchecked. Those who lost a loved one to COVID should know this too.
Open Letter to a Medical Student Part 2: “It Was Criminal in My Mind”
In my follow-up essay, Open Letter to a Medical Student Part 2: “It Was Criminal in My Mind”, I argued that people who’ve done nothing to advance actual RCTs imagine impossible RCTs years after the fact not to promote medical research, but rather to create doubt and fury about “they”.
My follow-up essay featured many comments from Sensible Medicine readers to illustrate this point. None of them expressed a willingness to enroll in an actual RCT. None of them pushed for more funding for medical research. None of them expressed sympathy for overwhelmed public health officials who had to make difficult decisions on the fly as a new virus rapidly swamped their cities, overflowing hospitals and morgues.
Indeed, we should not forget what happened when the virus was allowed to spread uncontrollably. It wasn’t pretty. Instead of reminding his readers of this tragic history, Mr. Knudsen told them that “public health had a myopic focus on stopping the spread of the virus“, as if that were an absurd goal when hospitals needed forklifts to move corpses in giant trucks.
Read this article
Certainly, no Sensible Medicine reader who lost a loved one early in the pandemic was comforted by Mr. Knudsen’s disdain towards those who had real-world responsibility at that time. Right or wrong, the difficult decision to ban hospital visitors was made to limit mass illness and death, not out of wanton indifference, as Mr. Knudsen implied. Amazingly, it didn’t occur to Mr. Knudsen that the best way to have to prevented people from dying without their families in 2020, was to have prevented them from dying in the first place. Perhaps those in mourning today might have received a sliver of solace had they been reminded of why tough, painful decisions were made.
However, this is not the goal of Sensible Medicine.
May he be forever riddled with guilt. May he suffer the loss of a loved one in the same manner. May he die alone.
Predictably, instead of gaining insight, Sensible Medicine readers were full of “rage and sorrow”, as one typical commentator put it. This rage was often directed at entire medical profession. One person said:
The medical community is no longer run by humans. Stay away and live longer. There is never any excuse for unethical and down-right rotten behavior in the field of medicine.
Others hinted at retribution:
The powers that be messed up big time during the Covid pandemic. I hope we never forget how death was dehumanized. It was criminal in my mind.
I urge you to read all the comments yourself, particularly from those who lost a loved one to COVID. Sensible Medicine made these damaged people feel much worse, all just to take cheap shots at already beleaguered public health officials– many of them failed to consider what it means to be human, a calamitous error that will leave a stain on public health’s reputation for decades, they failed us, and we are left without answers and policies that caused significant harm. Even though hundreds of public health officials were forced to leave their jobs due to threats and abuse, Sensible Medicine writers are eager to keep pouring fuel on that fire.
However, amidst the anger and mistrust, I can’t stop thinking about one comment in particular. Immediately after the comment calling “the powers that be” criminals, Dr. Adam Cifu, a founder of Sensible Medicine who can be very sensitive to even the slightest hint of indecorous tone when “medical conservatives” have their factual errors corrected, said to Mr. Knudsen:
Wonderful! Thank you so much Ben.
Remember, Mr. Knudsen’s article merely imagined an absurd, obviously impossible RCT. Its whole purpose was to dunk on public health officials and to manipulate, exploit, and provoke people, including vulnerable, grieving people, into making comments like this:
I will never forgive the staff that had become so brainwashed with their own needs to mask up, Mask my Mom up over her O2, which she really didn’t need, yet got sent “home” with. Now I realize the incentives to keep C19 monies moving into these hospitals. To the MD that wouldn’t let her go “home” on her birthday, may he be forever riddled with guilt. May he suffer the loss of a loved one in the same manner. May he die alone.
        ◦ What’s so wonderful! about all of this?

Lions Led by Donkeys, 1917
Those who sent unprotected children into classrooms filled with COVID-19 must be remembered for more than their unparalleled capacity for self-pity, inglorious oppression fantasies, and juvenile trolling of public officials.
Jonathan Howard on September 24, 2021
Link

The last movie I saw in the theatres was the World War I epic 1917. It masterfully showed what it would be like to “go over the top”, rushing out of the trenches and into a field of bullets and bombs. “Lions led by donkeys” was a phrase that described the bravery of the common solider compared to the ineptitude and indifference of the generals who sent them to their deaths. While I marveled at the bravery of these young men, I was grateful that I would never live through something like that.
Ron Desantis and friends
But in some ways, we are living through something like that. As pediatric cases, hospitalizations, and deaths reach their peak, politicians with an eye on higher office are not just sending children into dangerous environments, they are actively inhibiting every attempt to keep them safe. Governors like Ron Desantis seem determined to have as many children as possible contract the virus. He not only opposes school closures, but also mask and vaccine mandates. He has threatened to withhold funding to schools that implement mask mandates, even after this was ruled unlawful by a judge. He recently stood by and said nothing as a local government employee claimed that “the vaccine changes your RNA”. His actions make some sense given his beliefs: he doesn’t think the virus is dangerous to children, saying that “COVID, I view, is a very minor risk”.
Governor DeSantis is not operating in a vacuum. Doctors and epidemiologists at prestigious universities have influenced his decision to let children remain vulnerable to the virus. His problematic new Surgeon General was discussed here yesterday by Jann Bellamy. These doctors have repeatedly said that masks, lockdowns, and school closures are useless at best and counterproductive at worst. Other doctors gave him the false idea that pediatric hospitalizations for COVID-19 are misdiagnosed cases of RSV, an explanation offered in an attempt to minimize the impact of COVID-19 on children. Several of his advisors signed the infamous Great Barrington Declaration (discussed here by Dr. David Gorski), which advocated letting young, healthy people catch the virus to create herd immunity. As they put it:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk. We call this Focused Protection…Schools and universities should be open for in-person teaching. Extracurricular activities, such as sports, should be resumed. Young low-risk adults should work normally, rather than from home.
This all sounds nice, but its sophistication reminds me of my childhood plan to stop crime by “locking up all the bad guys”. I also wonder, did the signers of the Great Barrington Declaration and their young family members actually live out their suggested plan by trying to catch the virus to contribute to herd immunity? Did their financial sponsors?
The doctors who influenced Governor DeSantis don’t take care of patients with COVID-19. They have no plan to protect children and young adults as they reject the notion that the virus is a danger to them. Though they are active in the media, often appearing on TV, YouTube videos, and newspapers, they are completely sheltered from the consequences of their words. They’ll never work a night shift, intubate a dyspneic patient, deliver bad news to a grieving family, or transport a body to the morgue. Utterly lacking in practical experience, they pontificate on the virus as if were a game, a brand-building opportunity.
Instead of enumerating how the virus has harmed children, they hide behind irrelevant comparisons and false information in their ceaseless effort to undermine every attempt to protect them. An anti-mask article noted that “COVID-19 is less of a threat to children than accidents or the common flu”. It is true that accidents kill more children than COVID-19, however this is entirely irrelevant as to whether or not masks can protect them from a dangerous virus. Further, the claim that the flu is a greater threat than COVID-19 is simply wrong. In a year when COVID-19 killed hundreds of children, the flu claimed a single pediatric victim. The supposition that “the long-term harm to kids from masking is potentially enormous” is provided without evidence. Similarly, an article opposing vaccines for young people noted that “While anyone can get infected, the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young”. This claim was repeated in an article opposing testing children to limit outbreaks. Again, it is true that COVID-19 is worse for old people. However this doesn’t mean it is harmless for young people, and it is entirely irrelevant as to whether or not the vaccine can protect adolescents from a dangerous virus.
Though the vast majority of children do well with COVID-19, not all do. Tens of thousands of children have been hospitalized, and between 25%–33% of them need ICU level care. Even though the Delta variant doesn’t seem to cause worse outcomes for children, its increased infectivity means children are suffering more now than ever before. A recent CDC report found that “Weekly COVID-19–associated hospitalization rates among children and adolescents rose nearly five-fold during late June–mid-August 2021”. There have been over 4,661 cases of Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C), and children with this condition are often extremely sick, needing ICU-level care. Over 500 children have died from the virus, including some teens without underlying conditions who died after the vaccine was available to them. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, 102 children have died of COVID-19 since August 12th, 2021.
Fortunately, the vaccine is working. The CDC found that “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents”. Of course, you’ll never hear any bad news about the virus or good news about the vaccine for adolescents from these doctors. They don’t want these facts to be true, so they don’t acknowledge these facts.
“We have protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population”
Whether it’s just politics or a pure pride, someone like Governor DeSantis is incapable of self-reflection and admitting error. On August 1, 2021, Governor DeSantis created a “mission accomplished” moment when he quoted one of his medical advisors who said, “We have protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population”. Sadly, the vulnerable were not protected. Several weeks later after that Tweet was sent, mobile morgues would be needed to store the dead bodies. From July 4th to early September, over 7,000 people died in Florida, and over 17,000 people were hospitalized there at the end of August. According to the American Association of Retired People, “Florida led the nation in nursing home resident and staff deaths in the four weeks ending Aug. 22.” Nearly 70 children per day were being hospitalized during the recent peak, and some were sick enough to need life support. Some died (here, here, here, here). In total, 17 children under age 16-years of age have died of COVID-19 in Florida, and the death toll has more than doubled since August. Dr. Mobeen Rathore, a Florida pediatrician who actually treats sick children said:
Kids do get sick. Kids do get hospitalized. Kids do get sick and go to the ICU get intubated, be on a ventilator and even be on ECMO which is a heart lung machine, sort of a last ditch effort to support these children. Unfortunately children do die. In fact many of you probably heard the news, there’s a 17-year-old who died in St. Johns County just in the last few days so I think we have to be very sure and understand that kids can get serious illness. And I can tell you that in the almost 18 months ending in June we had three deaths in our area in children. That’s one death every six months. And just in July and August we had four deaths in children so that’s two deaths a month.
Things are also not going well for young adults, those considered at “minimal risk of death”. According to one nurse at a Florida hospital, ‘”It’s horrible. I’ve never bagged so many thirtysomething-year-olds, leaving behind young kids, pregnant wives.” Teachers are dying too. In Miami, 15 educators died over a 10-day period. No matter what happens in his state, Governor DeSantis will never admit error and reverse course.
Similarly, the doctors who are who advised Governor DeSantis seem incapable of self-reflection or admitting error. They have no plan to protect children other than to hide behind meaningless bromides that the virus is more dangerous for old people than children and false claims that the flu is more dangerous. Even as the Delta variant causes unprecedented harms in children, these doctors continue to minimize the virus. On a day when 1,544 Americans died of COVID-19 one said, “The emergency phase of the disease is over”. They continue to disparage vaccines in children, masks, testing, school closings, and basically any effort to keep children safe. As graduate student Mallory Harris pointed out, these doctors are reluctant to criticize these safety measures at their own schools. As she said,
Instead, they have used cable news, podcast appearances and social media to tell people outside the University that such public health measures are ill-advised. And they have gone to government officials elsewhere, most notably in Florida, to push them to strike down policies that align with Stanford’s. Especially from within the confines of a wealthy, elite university, there is a disconnect between staying silent about public health measures — and protecting yourself — while simultaneously critiquing those same measures — from which others stand to benefit.
“Distortions, misinformation, ad hominem attacks and outright slander”
As COVID-19 kills and hospitalizes more children and young adults than ever before, the signers of the Great Barrington Declaration have a clear message: they are the real victims here. Their grievances are twofold: people have said mean things about them and they don’t have a large enough platform. On a day when 534 Americans died of the virus, they complained “We did not expect a multi-pronged propaganda campaign that gravely distorted our arguments and smeared us”. In their view, there was “an aggressive media campaign against the Great Barrington Declaration. The propaganda campaign included multiple distortions, misinformation, ad hominem attacks and outright slander”. They frequently complain on social media about being the victims of “slander” and “censorship” (here, here, here, here, here, here). On a day when 994 American died, they wrote a widely-viewed editorial about how Facebook was “silencing” debate. To them, the removal of their Facebook page was “deeply sinister“. On a day when 615 Americans died of the virus, they wrote an editorial about “five prominent scientists who have faced the modern-day inquisition”, though none of these scientists were tortured. In this editorial, they defend people such as Dr. John Ioanaddis and his mathematically-impossible claim that the fatality rate of COVID-19 was “an order of magnitude lower than the conventional narrative implies”.
On a day when 533 Americans died of the virus, these doctors felt compelled to speak out against what they felt was a real tragedy – YouTube removed a video of their “roundtable” discussion with Governor DeSantis. One complained, “There’s nothing more dangerous than being able to censor what is said in a country, because then you are simply not ever going to even hear the truth. And you are entering into a phase of countries that we used to criticize severely like the USSR, like communist China…I mean, this is almost the end of our civilization if we have this sort of censorship, I’m afraid”. Seldom have “censored” individuals been both so omnipresent in the media and empowered with the ability to directly influence politicians at the highest level.
Though these doctors can’t take it, they can dish it out. They have made their opposition to masks very well-known with offensive tweets, calling masks “retarded” and analogous to the Taliban’s treatment of women. Another said masks were a form of “child abuse” based on a “fantastic” study by an anti-vaccine activist that has now been retracted.
Others lob juvenile insults at people like Dr. Fauci who suggested that vaccinated people should still take basic precautions not to contract the virus. Similarly, the government of New Zealand is criticized for enforcing its lockdown, even though that country has suffered as many COVID-19 deaths the entire pandemic as the state of Florida suffers in a few hours, and citizens there have overall enjoyed many fewer interruptions to their daily living.
Healthcare workers have been victims
To be clear, healthcare workers have been victims this pandemic. I remember the fear early in the pandemic of caring for COVID-19 patients. Early on, there was not enough PPE and healthcare workers had to convert trash bags into protective gowns. Thousands of healthcare workers have died of the virus, including friends and teachers of mine (here and here). Countless others have been sickened by the virus, though they survived.
Healthcare workers have suffered greatly in less direct ways. Dr. Michelle Fiscus, the top vaccine official in the Tennessee, was fired for promoting vaccines. Dr. Rick Bright, the director of the Department of Health and Human Services’ Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority, was fired from for doubting the effectiveness of hydroxychloroquine. Other public health officials have faced “angry and armed protesters at their personal residences, vandalism, and harassing telephone calls and social media posts, some threatening bodily harm and necessitating private security details”. More recently, anti-vaxxers have taken to protesting outside hospitals. Pediatricians and educators have been threatened for trying to keep children safe. One man in Tennessee told healthcare workers at a school board meeting, “You can leave freely, but we will find you, and we know who you are”. The threats of violence are real and growing.
I hope none of the doctors who influenced Governor DeSantis experienced any of this. I’m glad they haven’t been fired. I hope they never feared contracting the virus at work and bringing it home to their family. It’s nice that one of these doctors is “looking forward to teaching in person this fall and said he will happily meet with students, as Stanford is requiring vaccinations for everyone on campus.” I’m glad the vaccine mandates he opposes allow him to feel safe at work. I don’t want any of these doctors to die like the teachers in Miami. Other, less-protected teachers, have quit because they don’t feel safe. I don’t blame them. I further hope these doctors don’t quit because of the stress they experienced at work during this pandemic. Even before this latest, preventable wave, many doctors and healthcare workers who actually treat COVID-19 patients left their profession. The burnout has only worsened with time. I really hope no one has threatened these doctors or protested outside their offices or homes. Sadly, target of their ire Dr. Fauci has needed security for himself and his family. Given the enormous suffering it caused them, I sincerely hope the removal of their YouTube video or Facebook page remains the worst thing these doctors experience this pandemic.
Lions led by donkeys, 2021
        ◦ While children with COVID-19 obviously have a much higher chance of a good outcome than a young man on a World War I battlefield, lions are again being led by donkeys. I’m a bit embarrassed to admit that I don’t know the names of any World War I generals, though I am sure I’m not alone. We’ve mostly forgotten the names of those donkeys. We should make sure that the politicians and academics who send unprotected children into classrooms filled with COVID-19 are remembered for more than their unparalleled capacity for self-pity, inglorious oppression fantasies, and juvenile trolling of public officials who need bodyguards for the sin of trying to protect young people from a dangerous virus.

Pro-Infection Doctors Didn’t Just Want Kids in School. They Wanted Them There Unvaccinated, Untested, and Unmasked. They Wanted Them Infected.
The virus massively disrupted schools around the world, and those of us who did nothing more than acknowledge this obvious reality were absurdly blamed for it.
Jonathan Howard on May 17, 2024
Link

We should end mask mandates and social distancing in most settings not because they don’t slow the spread—the usual argument against such measures—but because they probably do.
In a prior essay, I discussed how the We Want Them Infected movement is trying to rebrand itself as the All We Really Wanted Was Poor Kids in School movement. With their assurances that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months in tatters, pro-infection doctors are now furiously trying to rewrite history, portraying themselves as nothing more than selfless warriors for children and their education.
The facts tell a different story.
As child labor laws loosen across the country, many pro-infection doctors were eager to join forces with an unapologetic pro-tobacco, child-labor advocate who encourages children to dropout of school. It was a surreal experience to be sanctimoniously lectured about the importance of education by doctors who partnered with this man, especially considering they devoted great effort not to ensuring that schools could safely reopen, but by ensuring that when children returned to school, they faced the virus without any protections at all. They saturated the media with articles such as The Case Against Covid Tests for the Young and Healthy, The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young, and The Downsides of Masking Young Students Are Real, and Kids Don’t Need Covid-19 Vaccines to Return to School.
If all these doctors cared about was children learning in classrooms, as they now claim, shouldn’t they have wanted healthy students learning from healthy teachers? Shouldn’t they have wanted cautious parents to feel their children were safe at school too? Why did they devote their entire pandemic effort to removing the most trivial mitigation measures, even after schools were open?
As I previously discussed, pro-infection doctors didn’t object to these measures because they doubted whether they slowed the virus, but precisely because they knew that’s exactly what they did. Remember, they felt it was “fantastic” when cases spiked in unvaccinated young people, and in articles such as Herd Immunity is Still Key in the Fight Against Covid-19, they expressed great gratitude- “thank you, thank you, thank you“- to those who “generate herd immunity by living normal lives“. They produced pro-virus content, such as the article Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?, which said:
Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger… Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk… For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life… Exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future… Immunity is built through illness.
This article also advocated removing mitigation all measures because this would allow children to get sick. It said:
Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.
These doctors lamented that mitigation measures just “postponed the inevitable”, and as early as March 2020 said:
School closures may also diminish the chances of developing herd immunity in an age group that is spared serious disease.
In an article titled Slow the Spread? Speeding It May Be Safer from January 2022, the deadliest month of the pandemic for children, Dr. Apoorva Ramaswamy gave the game away entirely writing:
We should end mask mandates and social distancing in most settings not because they don’t slow the spread—the usual argument against such measures—but because they probably do.
I didn’t want to go to school. I just wanted to stay at home.
Of course, letting the virus rip in schools didn’t help children’s education. Sick children couldn’t learn, and sick teachers couldn’t teach. During the Omicron wave, 30% of New York City students were absent. According to one article:
New York City students are missing school in record numbers — staying home in droves because they’re sick, quarantined, fearful of getting COVID-19 in class or don’t see the point of going because so many others are absent, families and educators told the Daily News.
Elsewhere, the National Guard was called to act as substitute teachers during the peak of Omicron wave, and desperate principals begged parents to act as substitute teachers. Unsurprisingly, at many points in the pandemic, overwhelming COVID outbreaks shuttered schools, not just in blue states, but also in Florida, Arkansas, Idaho, Texas, Oklahoma, Kentucky , Alabama, Georgia, Wyoming, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina, North Dakota, Tennessee, Kansas, West Virginia, Missouri, Louisiana, and Mississippi. I urge you to read one of these articles to learn about the challenges educators faced because the virus sickened their students and staff. A typical article titled 2 Tennessee School Districts Temporarily Close Due to COVID from September 2021 said:
Of the 2,444 cases reported from Aug. 17 to 30 in Sumner County, 868 were among school-age children between 5 and 18 years old, according to the Tennessee Department of Health.
It also said:
Pediatric COVID-19 admissions have also surged and school mask mandates have become the center of debates, especially as children under the age of 12 are still not eligible for the vaccine. On average, nearly 340 children are now seeking hospital care for COVID-19 each day, according to the latest government data.
Despite this, some doctors with no real-world responsibility for opening schools falsely portrayed all viral-induced school closures as a “decision“. They said it was a “mistake” to have closed schools, implying that if only they were in charge, everything would have been just fine. Somehow, they would have overcome teacher shortages and sick children in ways no one else figured out, even while hospitals up the street were using forklifts to move these children’s older relatives into overflowing morgues.
In reality, of course, the virus forced people with actual responsibility to make hard, often unpopular choices. Indeed, another article titled Four Kansas School Districts Temporarily Close As COVID-19 Outbreaks Hit 31 Schools reported:
“With the rise in Covid numbers in our staff and student population, as well as in our county, the board was forced to make adjustments,” the district said in a Facebook post Tuesday. “One of those adjustments includes the requirement to wear masks while case numbers are high.”
These local officials faced didn’t want to “make adjustments”, the virus forced them, and they faced furious backlash and outright threats because of this.
Much like “protect the vulnerable” and “do an RCT“, writing the words “open schools” was much easier than actually opening schools, especially when the virus was allowed to spread freely. Yet, some doctors are genuinely proud of the many times they merely “called for” schools to open.
Beyond this, children who lost a parent to COVID, an estimated 245,000 of them in the US, struggled too. In New York City, 8,600 children, or 1 in 200 children, lost a parent or caregiver in the pandemic’s first two years. After her father died of COVID, 15-year-old Elizabeth George said, “I didn’t want to go to school. I just wanted to stay at home.”
Most tragically, dead children will never learn again, and dead teachers will never teach again. One article from September 2021 was titled Child Covid Deaths More Than Doubled In Florida As Kids Returned To The Classroom. In New York City alone, 74 educators, including 30 teachers, died in the pandemic’s first couple of months. Even after vaccines were available, headlines read 15 Miami-Dade Educators Die From COVID-19 in 10 Days. There would have been many more such tragedies had the virus been allowed to infect 73 million children at the start of the pandemic as some doctors proposed.
The bigger problem is that lockdowners like Howard (an NYU doctor, I think), think that living your life is an irresponsible act. Sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act.
It turns out that not all disruptions to education were because liberal politicians, beholden to teacher’s unions, made cowardly choices. The virus massively disrupted schools around the world, including Sweden. However, the simple statement “it’s bad that the virus closed schools” was also a controversial statement. Those of us who did nothing more than acknowledge this obvious reality were subject to juvenile taunts- “fringe scientists“- and absurdly accused of actively advocating for school closures. Pro-infection doctors inhabited a world of magical thinking where anyone who recognized the virus’s impact on schools was held responsible for it. For example, one pro-infection doctor, who did not read my book, wrote a fake review of it in which he said:
The bigger problem is that lockdowners like Howard (an NYU doctor, I think), think that living your life is an irresponsible act. Sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act.
Of course, I never said “sending your kids to school is an irresponsible act“, but intellectual honesty was besides the point for pro-infection doctors. I sinned by suggesting that the mass infection of children might also disrupt their education.
The purpose of blaming the messenger was of course, to silence and discredit the messenger. Pro-infection doctors had a vested interest in obscuring what the virus did to education, and they felt virtuous for their open refusal to acknowledge its impact. Indeed, nothing the virus did to schools, or children or teachers, seemed to matter to them. They certainly never advocated for better control of the virus so that schools that were forced to close by it could safely reopen. They greeted COVID’s harms to education with either complete indifference or absurd misinformation, falsely claiming that the flu killed more children than COVID, and that:
Teachers were actually at lower risk of COVID than the population of other workers at large. Being around kids actually protected them, in some sense, because the kids are not super-spreaders.
I wonder how teachers feel knowing their pandemic experience was discussed in such a blasé manner by laptop class doctors who wisely avoided the virus until after they were vaccinated.
It’s all enough to make one think that children learning in classrooms wasn’t the main priority for pro-infection doctors. Rather, their chief objective was to infect as many children as quickly as possible to hasten the arrival of herd immunity, and schools were just a tool to accomplish this goal- a goal they shared with their wealthy libertarian friend who told kids to dropout of public schools so they can smoke after their shift at Walmart and Chic-Fil-A.

Yes, Schools Were Closed in Sweden
“I had kids in grades 4, 7, and 8 when the pandemic broke out. The latter two were remote for a year and then hybrid for another 6 months or so.”
Jonathan Howard on April 7, 2023
Link

Sweden, which initially aimed to “protect the vulnerable” via herd immunity through mass infection of unvaccinated youth, had a much higher death rate than its Nordic neighbors, especially before vaccines became available. According to a report in Science:
The virus took a shocking toll on the most vulnerable. It had free rein in nursing homes, where nearly 1000 people died in a matter of weeks. Stockholm’s nursing homes ended up losing 7% of their 14,000 residents to the virus. The vast majority were not taken to hospitals.
A report by the government-appointed, independent Swedish Corona Commission later reported the unsurprising news that uncontrolled spread of the virus in the community was the “single most important factor behind the major outbreaks and the high number of deaths in residential care.” According to one damning investigation, “The Swedish people were kept in ignorance of basic facts such as the airborne SARS-CoV-2 transmission, that asymptomatic individuals can be contagious and that face masks protect both the carrier and others. ” Horrifyingly, it also found that:
Many elderly people were administered morphine instead of oxygen despite available supplies, effectively ending their lives.
Children weren’t necessarily spared. Dr. Jonas Ludvigsson, a Swedish pediatrician and epidemiologist who was an original signer of the Great Barrington Declaration, claimed that there were “no major school outbreaks in Sweden,” even though such outbreaks had been reported in Swedish media. He also published a letter in The New England Journal of Medicine that claimed there had been no excess mortality in Swedish children in 2020 compared to 2019. However, in emails to Swedish chief epidemiologist Anders Tegnell from July 2020, Dr. Ludvigsson wrote “unfortunately we see a clear indication of excess mortality among children ages 7-16 old, the ages where ‘kids went to school.’”
Looking back on Sweden’s response, King Carl XVI Gustaf said, “I think we have failed. We have a large number who have died and that is terrible.” Prime Minister Stefan Lofven agreed, saying “Of course the fact that so many have died can’t be considered as anything other than a failure.”
Despite this, Sweden has many admirers around the world. In their fevered imagination, Sweden was a pandemic paradise, which never imposed restrictions on its citizens or closed schools. This is all false. In reality, as with nearly every other country, Sweden took drastic measures to control the virus at times, though it was too late for many of its most vulnerable citizens.
David Steadson, a public health researcher who co-authored the investigation referenced above, noted that Sweden’s restrictions on elderly and vulnerable people led to what he called “the longest continuous lockdown in the world.” Mr. Steadson told me:
There were also many other restrictions put in place that people ignore, including alcohol sales restrictions, all large events and large localities shutdown, including sports events, zoos, theatres, theme parks. Sports activities all shut down or went outdoors. Even “recommendations” (ie technically binding but unenforced) on restricting travel outside your home region.
Schools were affected as well. Mr. Steadson also told me:
Contrary to popular myth, Sweden did close schools. In early March 2020, the Government amended the school regulations to allow all schools from preschool and up, to move to remote or hybrid learning in the event of outbreaks of staff issues. On March 27, 2020, on the recommendation of the Swedish Public Health Agency, all high schools (Grade 10 and up) and Universities and adult education moved to remote learning, with 3 months summer holidays beginning a few weeks later. 
Following the 2020 summer break, many schools, predominantly middle school and up (from grade 7) – elected to continue with hybrid and remote classes, however, no statistics on school closures were kept.
Indeed, while Sweden never officially closed schools for younger children, overwhelming COVID outbreaks caused many school closures at the local level, as was true in the US (Kentucky, Florida, Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, Mississippi, Alabama, South Carolina, Tennessee, Missouri, West Virginia). Mr. Steadson, who lives in Sweden himself, told me about his experience with his own children. He said:
I had kids in grades 4, 7, and 8 when the pandemic broke out. The latter two were remote for a year and then hybrid for another 6 months or so.
In a long Twitter thread, a user named Annika compiled dozens of articles showing the many schools closures in Sweden while noting, “These examples don’t even include anything from early 2022, when omicron shut down even more schools.”
Sweden’s response will be debated for decades. However, anyone who engages in the absurd fantasy they took no measures to control the virus or that they paid no price for their early inaction should be completely ignored. Here’s the reality.

A Modest Proposal: Schools Must Open With Untested, Unmasked, Unvaccinated Children
Kids don’t need Covid-19 vaccines to return to school and the downsides of masking young students are real.
Jonathan Howard on January 14, 2022
Link

“Schools must be open”
School closures have been one of the great tragedies this pandemic. Children have lost years of educational opportunities during their most formative years. This will impact them the rest of their lives. While we can’t change the past, we can hopefully agree now that schools must be open. To that end, I formulated a detailed, comprehensive plan: I vowed to say the words “schools must be open” at every opportunity.
My plan succeeded. I said “schools must be open” in newspapers, podcasts, on TV, and on social media. I even testified in court that “schools must be open.” Now, everyone knows that I say “schools must be open” all the time.
3 is larger than 1,090 and the best way to avoid getting sick with the virus is to get sick with the virus
Children have very low-risk from COVID-19, fortunately. I reasoned that as long as older people are more endangered by the virus, there’s no reason to protect children from it. That’s why I strenuously opposed vaccinating children, having them wear masks, testing them, and vaccine requirements for schools. I told parents that COVID vaccines for children should not get emergency use authorization, that kids don’t need COVID-19 vaccines to return to school and that the downsides of masking young students are real. I even said that omicron infection may be nature’s vaccine. I wanted to make the virus seem as attractive as possible – as if I were writing a commercial for a pharma company. Ask your doctor if Omicron™ is right for you. It’s Nature’s Vaccine!
I lived and breathed vaccine side-effects. The number of times I said the words “vaccine myocarditis” easily exceeds the number of children who are currently hospitalized with the condition. I made sure not to let parents know that almost all cases of vaccine myocarditis are “mild and resolve quickly“. I even mentioned fevers as a reason not to vaccinate children. Studies showing the vaccine can keep adolescents alive and out of the hospital (study 1, study 2, study 3, study 4, study 5, study 6, study 7, study 8) remain, of course, completely unmentionable.
Beyond this, I said the pandemic was over multiple times. Who can forget when I said “delta variant, delta shmariant” just before that variant hospitalized and killed a large number of children. My writing contained blatant factual errors – always understating the harms of the virus and overstating the risks of the vaccine. For example, in the past two years, the flu killed 3 children while COVID-19 has killed 1,090 children. So naturally, I told parents that more children died from the flu last year than COVID-19 and that COVID-19’s mortality risk for children is less than the already low risk from the annual influenza. If any “lockdowner” disagrees with this, I’ll write in an editorial in the Wall Street Journal or go on Fox News lamenting how I’ve been silenced.
I can take credit for the fact that just 17% of children ages 5-11 and 54% of children ages 12-17 are fully vaccinated against COVID-19. When I see that pediatric cases and hospitalizations are now more than double their previous peak, I know my efforts have paid off. After all, mass infection of children is exactly what I was hoping for when I said,
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection.
This all makes perfect sense in a world where 3 is larger than 1,090 and the best way to avoid getting sick with the virus is to get sick with the virus.
Don’t blame me
Repeatedly saying “schools must be open”, while simultaneously opposing vaccines, masks, testing, and vaccine requirements is a legacy I can be very proud of. Just read any newspaper to know how things are working out for children and schools right now. Though if you read about schools closing due to an overwhelming number of COVID-19 cases, don’t blame me. I did my part.
No one said “schools must be open” more often than me.

Looking Back 5 Year Later – Were Lockdowns Worth It?
Steven Novella on March 5, 2025
Link 
An excellent article on the BBC gives a good overview of the continuing controversy over universal lockdowns as a pandemic mitigation strategy during COVID. We now have significant data about how various countries around the world fared compared to their mitigation strategy. Interestingly, this data is unlikely to resolve the controversy.
But it can inform our decisions for the next pandemic – and there will be a next pandemic. Already the bird flu, H5N1, is extremely concerning. It is spreading in mammals, and there are occasional human cases. A single mutation may be enough to allow for human-to-human transmission. But even just as an avian pandemic, it can be economically devastating, as indicated by egg prices.
So did we learn any lessons from the COVID pandemic about the risks vs benefits of universal lockdowns and other measures? We potentially did, if we choose to listen, but there is still an extreme emotional response to the shutdowns that clouds the discourse.
From a scientific and medical perspective, we do need to look at the question from the perspective of risks vs benefits. It is a trade-off, which means there is no one correct answer. What risks are we willing to pay for the potential benefits? The best we can do is document those risks and benefits so that we can make the best informed decision.
There are various approaches to addressing the question of if there were benefits to various types of lockdown. We can model the spread of the virus, we can look longitudinally at the effects of lockdowns and lifting them in one region, or we can compare different countries with different policies. No method is perfect or yields the same results, which is why this will not end debate.
A lot of attention has been paid to Sweden, which is one of four countries that did not institute lockdowns. It is useful to compare Sweden to Norway, Finland, and Denmark because these countries are otherwise very similar. A 2024 study compared the death rate in these countries throughout the pandemic. They found that Sweden had excess deaths in 2020 compared to their neighbors, but fewer deaths in 2022. What do we make of this frustratingly ambiguous result?
From this and other data it does seem that lockdowns early on in the pandemic did work. Of course, we also have to define what we mean by “work”. Most studies use excess deaths, but we can also look at COVID cases and COVID-specific deaths. But there is another very important, and often forgotten, outcome – flattening the curve (remember that?). Part of the goal was to slow the spread of COVID so that healthcare systems would not become overwhelmed. Is this what we are seeing in the Scandinavian data? Perhaps.
It’s easy to forget, although I know healthcare workers will not, that in 2020 hospitals were overwhelmed with COVID. Patients were literally sharing ventilators. Neurologists were called into cover medical floors. Hospitals were beyond capacity. Other treatments, including cancer treatments, were delayed. Many healthcare workers were traumatized and burned out – let alone affected by COVID itself.
Therefore, there was some value in delaying some cases of COVID, even if in the end the numbers averaged out over time, as appears to be the case on Scandinavia. Of course, there are lots of moving parts here. Omicron and other variants that came later caused their own surges. Policies were fluctuating over time. And the vaccine eventually became available, and how aggressively that was rolled out is a huge factor. The data is complex.
Also, for those countries that did not institute universal mandatory lockdowns, most had measures of their own. Taiwan, which is an island, instituted exhaustive contact tracing, testing, and targeted quarantine. They also had the luxury of limiting travel to the island. It’s important to remember, we are not just comparing lockdowns to doing nothing, but to all the alternatives. Japan had voluntary isolation, but data shows that this was just as effective as mandatory isolation in other countries. But again, Japan has its own culture and voluntary isolation may not work as well everywhere. Sweden limited public gatherings and some gathering places. There is also mask-wearing.
It is possible, therefore, to cobble together something very similar to universal lockdowns with a host of lesser measures that together have a similar result. Which measures are feasible and will work appear to be specific to each country.
What about the risks? It does seem that collectively we underestimated the risks of lockdowns, which is not surprising given that there was no prior experience with anything like COVID in modern times. School shutdowns, which perhaps remain the most controversial, had a negative impact on the learning of a generation. According to recent US data:
“In 2022, only 26% of eighth graders were at or above pro­fi­cient in math, much worse than before the pan­dem­ic (33% in 2019).
Less than a third of fourth graders (32%) were at or above pro­fi­cient in read­ing, two per­cent­age points low­er than right before the pan­dem­ic (34% in 2019).”
These numbers are not catastrophic, but they are significant. Schools were less prepared for online learning that was hoped. They did not have the equipment, the experience, or the curriculum. Families were also similarly unprepared, exacerbated by the existing digital divide.
Social isolation was also not good for mental health, and caused an increase in domestic violence.
But of course, we will never know the counter-factual. What would have happened if we did not close down schools? By how much would that have worsened the pandemic? Many schools had to shutdown anyway due to teacher exposure or illness, for example. Again we are left with data but no clear ultimate answer.
What does all this mean for how we respond to the next pandemic? We were not prepared for COVID – are we prepared for the next pandemic, and what should we do to be prepared? There are some clear strategies that many experts have already pointed out.
First, we need a plan. During COVID the experts admitted we were “building this plane as we are flying it.” This was partly unavoidable, because SARS-CoV-2 was a unique virus and it took time to research and understand it. But there is a lot we can plan for, even for a novel infectious agent.
There are some win-wins we should not neglect, measures with little to no downside. Employers and employees should have a work-from-home plan. If someone is sick, exposed, or just in a high risk area, they should have the capacity and infrastructure to work from home as necessary. This is not possible for all jobs, but for most it is.
Schools likely need a massive investment in their training, preparedness, and infrastructure so that they can shift to online learning, for individuals or entire classes, when necessary while minimizing any downside. This can actually be a net positive, as sick days do not necessarily mean missing class or work. There is data that online learning can be effective in reducing learning loss during shutdowns.
Essentially schools and teachers need a plan for what to do when they cannot have in person class. Just holding a class online does not work. They need a curriculum designed to function online. They may not be learning the same things or the same way, but online learning time can be maximized and can be effective.
For communicable respiratory illnesses, people should have and know how to use masks. They work. Which other methods are likely to be effective, such as hand-washing, should also be communicated to the public when known.
When vaccines are available, everyone should be up-to-date on all recommended vaccines.
There also needs to be a playbook for available options to limit the spread of an infectious illness, including contact tracing, testing, targeted isolation, limiting public interactions, and various degrees of voluntary and mandatory shutdowns. These need to be tailored to the community and to the infectious agent. Perhaps these can even be color-coded levels of response to aid public communication.
Also – this can communicate to the public that the more effectively we institute lower levels of response, the more likely we are to avoid the more draconian measures. Further, if the public is made aware of the possible measures ahead of time, and feel like there is a thoughtful plan in place, they are more likely to accept them when instituted.
We are definitely more prepared now than we were pre-COVID, but not nearly enough. We can’t just forget our COVID experience as a bad dream and move on. That is no longer the world we live in. We need to be perpetually prepared for outbreaks, epidemics, and pandemics, with early detection, a host of response options, and high degrees of public buy-in. We are not there.

Was Closing Schools an Obvious and Colossal Mistake?
Maybe it was a mistake to close schools. However, those who make this claim should honestly grapple with what would have happened had nothing been done rather than indulge an absurd fantasy that everything would have been fine and dandy.
Jonathan Howard on November 4, 2022
Tweet

Lately, I’ve seen a narrative emerge that closing schools and shifting to remote learning at the pandemic’s start was an obvious and colossal mistake. Maybe it was. I certainly didn’t like it for my own children, and I won’t pretend to be an expert in education. However, I’m not sure that remote learning was an obvious and colossal mistake.
We know what happened in the real-world. What would have happened had schools remained open without any mitigation measures?
One obvious answer, is that nearly all children would have gotten COVID, as would everyone they live with, and most school employees. Despite early hopes that schools were magically immune to the spread of COVID, subsequent research revealed the unsurprising news that the virus spreads quite well in schools, especially those without any mitigation measures.
How then would the unmitigated spread of COVID affected children, none of whom were vaccinated?
The vast majority would have been just fine, thankfully. However, in the real world, the CDC COVID Data Tracker reports that over 1,850 children have died of COVID. This number would have been higher had 60-70 million unvaccinated children contracted the virus over several months time in 2020. It’s reasonable to assume that several thousand children would have died had no mitigation measures been taken.
Death is not the only bad outcome from COVID. In the real world, around 150,000 children have been hospitalized with COVID. Some were very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU. Neurological complications are not uncommon in hospitalized children. Rarely, they have needed amputations or had strokes. Over 9,000 children had MIS-C and most of these children go to the ICU. 74 children have died of MIS-C. The vaccine has drastically lowered the risk of these rare, but grave outcomes. Many thousands more children would have been hospitalized or developed MIS-C had no mitigation measures been taken at the pandemic’s start.
In the real world, many pediatric hospitals were deluged during the Delta and Omicron waves. It’s doubtful they would have had the resources to treat sick children had tens of millions of them contracted COVID in a short time span, especially considering many healthcare workers were sick with COVID at the start of the pandemic. Of course, more healthcare workers would have contracted COVID, either from their jobs or their own children, had no mitigation measures been taken in schools.
In the real word, over 200,000 American children lost a parent or caregiver to the virus by the spring of 2022. In New York City, 8,600 children, or 1 in 200 children, lost a parent or caregiver in the pandemic’s first two years. This was bad for children. After the death of her father, 15-year-old Elizabeth George said, “I didn’t want to go to school. I just wanted to stay at home”. Many more children would have brought the virus home to their unvaccinated families had no mitigation measures been taken at the pandemic’s start. There would be many more COVID orphans.
Beyond this, some children just feel really rotten from COVID, and not all bounce back immediately. In the real world, many children felt too sick to attend school. During surges, many parents, perhaps vulnerable themselves, did not feel safe sending their children to school without mitigation measures. During the Omicron wave, 30% of New York City students were absent. If schools had remained open without mitigation measures, many children would have missed school anyway for these reasons.
Teachers would have been at risk as well. According to one news article from May 11th, 2020:
The New York City Department of Education said it has now lost 74 employees to COVID-19. On Monday, official announced the two new deaths. All but four of the 74 DOE employees who died were based in schools across the city. The other 70 school-based employees include:
    • 28 are paraprofessionals
    • 30 are teachers
    • 2 are food service staffers
    • 2 are administrators
    • 2 are facilities staff
    • 2 are school aides
Even after vaccines were available, headlines read “15 Miami-Dade Educators Die From COVID-19 in 10 Days”. More educators, none of whom were vaccinated at the pandemic’s start, would have died had no mitigation measures been taken. Would teachers have been willing to work in schools with no mitigation measures?
In the real world, sick teachers couldn’t teach. New Mexico called in the National Guard to act as substitute teachers during the winter Omicron wave. Elsewhere, principals begged parents to act as substitute teachers. The virus still closed schools. One typical headline from Texas from September 2021 read, “At least 45 districts shut down in-person classes due to COVID-19 cases, affecting more than 40,000 students”. Similar headlines appeared throughout the country whenever cases soared. One school in New York City sent a notice that though it was “open”, the kids were just going to hang out in the auditorium much of the day. There weren’t enough teachers, and so the school was nothing more than a daycare center. More educators would have been out sick had no mitigation measures been taken. Who would have taught the students?
So maybe closing schools was an obvious and colossal mistake. However, those who make this claim should honestly grapple with what would have happened had nothing been done rather than indulge an absurd, revisionist fantasy that everything would have been fine and dandy.

Why Did the “Urgency of Normal” Stop Caring About the Mental, Social, Emotional, and Behavioral Health of our Children?
Genuine concern is consistent concern, and the silence from the Urgency of Normal about literally everything happening today is clarifying.
Jonathan Howard on September 3, 2026
Link

“I’m not talking about they made a mistake, I’m talking about misciting. Academic misconduct.”
The Urgency of Normal (UON) was founded in January 2022 by doctors who will be familiar to SBM readers, including Drs. Tracy Beth Høeg, Monica Gandhi, Lucy McBride, and Vinay Prasad, as well as Allison Krug. The UON felt mitigation measures for children did more harm than good and described itself by saying:
We are a group of scientists and pediatric, infectious disease, emergency, mental health, and ICU doctors concerned that COVID-19 mitigation measures for children are doing more harm than good. Health must be viewed holistically— yet school policymakers have narrowly defined “safety” as the mere absence of COVID, putting children into a loop of mitigation measures that are uncoupled from actual risk. After two years of living with one disruption after another, the toll on children’s mental and physical health is increasingly evident and alarming. To protect them, an urgent return to fully normal life and schooling is needed.
None of this was new for them. They all said the exact same thing the previous year in videos such as The Motivation We Need to Reach the End of the COVID-19 Pandemic, How To Stop Living In Fear of COVID, and How A Coming End To The Pandemic Is Causing Anxiety. The UON was stale material by doctors who never changed their tune, no matter what the virus did.
Predictably, their material contained many basic errors, all of which understated the harms of COVID and overstated the risks of mitigations. For example, even though a single child died of the flu in the 2020-2021 season and COVID killed around 600 children, the UON nonetheless said that “COVID is a flu-like risk for unvaccinated children“. This is the “nuance” and integrity they brought to their work, and according to an article titled Why Is This Group of Doctors So Intent on Unmasking Kids?:
Tyler Black, a child and adolescent psychiatrist and suicidologist at BC Children’s Hospital in Vancouver, hadn’t heard anything about the Urgency of Normal group or its “tool kit” until it came out. But when he saw it go up on Twitter, he was appalled. “Their document was so poor, with so many mistakes, that it required immediate public correction,” he said…
“It was really, really gross to see what they did with the mental health science. It’s a true perversion of what science communication is supposed to be,” Black said. “They had mis-cited the CDC—I’m not talking about they made a mistake, I’m talking about mis-citing. Academic misconduct.” The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention study found that there was no significant increase in child suicide, yet the group used that study to claim the opposite—an increase in suicide. After pushback, the authors edited the tool kit to remove that mention of suicide, he said, without noting what had been revised…
The bottom line about kids’ mental health in the pandemic, Black said, is that “when we ask kids, just as many say that they’re doing better as say that they’re doing worse, and most kids say that their mental health has not changed during the pandemic.” Black is concerned that the authors of the Urgency of Normal tool kit may be miscommunicating the evidence on other topics as well. “They’re picking the science that makes their point, and that by the very definition is extremely biased, unreliable science.”
Indeed, an article from 2023, Teen Suicide Plummeted During Covid-19 School Closures, New Study Finds, reported that:
Rates of suicide and suicide attempts among teenagers were at their lowest when schools were closed for the Covid-19 pandemic.
“I sorry, Mommy. Mommy hugs, I scared. I don’t like it. Mommy!”
It’s important to remember what was happening in January 2022 when the UON launched their crusade against mitigations. That month was the peak of the Omicron wave, the most devastating for children, when around 900 were being hospitalized daily with COVID. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics
The largest peak was in winter 2022 during the omicron surge, with 6,527 child hospitalizations the week of Jan. 15.
The youngest children, those too young to be vaccinated, were the hardest hit. According to an article titled Not So Mild? Hospitalizations Exploding Among Utah Infants, Children with COVID-19′s Omicron Strain:
“I sorry, Mommy. Mommy hugs, I scared. I don’t like it. Mommy!”
Those were the last words 3-year-old Justin Lee Francis spoke to his mother, Yvonne, before he was sedated and put on a ventilator at Primary Children’s Hospital last week, when he was diagnosed with COVID-19, asthma, pneumonia and other illnesses.
“Those words are burned in my memory,” Yvonne Francis said Thursday from the hospital, where Justin Lee still is on a ventilator, still sedated, and slowly recovering after nearly a week in the intensive care unit. “He was really scared.”
This was also the deadliest part of the pandemic for children, as Melody Shreiber discussed in her article A Fifth of All US Child COVID Deaths Occurred During Omicron Surge. 179 children died in the first 10 weeks of 2022, and this all would have been much worse had we all listened to the UON at the time.
“U.S. Schools Close in Droves as Omicron Drives Staff Shortages”
Schools were affected too. As happened whenever the virus spread uncontrolled, they were forced to close. An article titled U.S. Schools Close in Droves as Omicron Drives Staff Shortages reported:
School closings are accelerating across the U.S. as omicron infections ensnare teachers and drive staffing shortages.
The speed of this Covid-19 surge led large districts like Atlanta, Detroit, and Prince George’s County in Maryland to adopt remote instruction just days into the new year, often leaving parents little time to readjust schedules.
Nationally, the number of in-person closings has tripled since Dec. 19 as the percentage of positive tests surged. At least 3,229 schools were closed in the first week of January.
Even when schools were open, this did not mean necessarily mean students were learning in them. An article from January 2022 titled COVID Hammers NYC School Attendance Among Students and Teachers reported:
The omicron surge is taking a toll on attendance in public schools all over New York City. Student attendance was 76% on Monday, the Department of Education told FOX 5 NY.
“The mental, social, emotional & behavioral health of our children.”
Many people read about overwhelmed pediatric hospitals and closed schools at the time and worried about the mental, social, emotional, and behavioral health of our children. Not the UON doctors, however. None of this bothered them at all. Though they claimed to view children’s health “holistically”, they had their own agenda and were happy to use children to advance it.
It turns out that the UON was only worried about the mental, social, emotional, and behavioral health of our children in relation to COVID mitigations. They wanted them gone and thus claimed that removing them was the one and only key to improving the mental, social, emotional, and behavioral health of our children. No other problems needed addressing. This was all that was needed.
A typical X post of theirs from March 2022 said:
The impact on the mental, social, emotional & behavioral health of our children can’t be measured by a PCR [test],” said @etholland71. “We are so laser-focused on the burden of disease, but the burden of the mitigation measures is high.”
They linked to an article titled Student Masking Now Up to Parents featuring Dr. Eliza Holland that said:
Holland is one of a national group of physicians and scientists who have formed an all-volunteer organization called the Urgency of Normal, which launched in January and advocates for maintaining in-person learning, de-escalating the fear around getting Covid, and appropriately balancing the risks to children’s health. “Right now, we are seeing a mental health crisis in our children, which was already bad and has only gotten worse during the pandemic,” said Holland. “I have admitted far more children with severe eating disorders, suicidal ideation, and drug overdose than I have with severe Covid.”
The Urgency of Normal’s summary of the evidence to date on student masking efficacy says that “[w]ell-controlled, real-world studies have not demonstrated any clear benefit of masking students.” While a widely circulated CDC study found a higher Covid incidence among students in Georgia schools that did not require masks, the difference was found to be not statistically significant. Other studies did not control for important confounding variables such as vaccination rates among students. “When an intervention’s real-world benefits are too small to measure, we should feel comfortable ending its use,” concludes the summary.
On the other side of the ledger, Holland notes that masking creates real impediments. “Masking makes it hard to understand each other and one’s teacher, and difficult for children with speech issues to be understood,” she said. “It’s harder for children for whom English is a second language to communicate, and children with special needs who can’t comply with mask mandates are being left out of the school environment.”
Holland said she has observed that children have been taught to feel unsafe without a mask, and that those anxieties may take a longer-term toll. “The health messaging has been lacking in nuance, and the risk stratification has not been well portrayed,” she said. “Unvaccinated children are still at much lower risk of severe disease and hospitalization than vaccinated adults.” As well, transmission rates among children are much lower than among adults, according to CDC data.
“Children are treated as if they are horrible spreaders, and they are the ones who must continue to mask as if they are a threat to everyone around them,” even as adults are allowed to unmask, said Holland. “As some of my colleagues have said, the impact on the mental, social, emotional, and behavioral health of our children can’t be measured by a PCR [test],” said Holland. “We are so laser-focused on the burden of disease, but the burden of the mitigation measures is high.”
Though Dr. Holland complained that “children are treated as if they are horrible spreaders,” a headline from the next year read More Than 70% of US Household COVID Spread Started with a Child, Study Suggests. Meanwhile, while Dr. Holland dunked on mitigations, other UON leaders acted as publicity agents for the virus and extolled its virtues. Dr. Prasad and Krug wrote an article on February 2, 2022, titled Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?, in which they said COVID infections were “natural and healthy” for children. They wrote:
These measures are premised on the idea that America’s children must be shielded from exposure to Covid-19. What kids really need, however, is a return to normal. And when it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.
It is important to emphasise that a more laissez-faire approach to kids and Covid makes public health sense, too. Dropping masks, quarantines, distancing, and all other mitigations will allow children to develop the kind of broad immunity gained by living a normal life.
Dr. Prasad and Krug also endorsed using infected children as human shields for older adults. They wrote:
Shielding kids from exposure only increases their future risk. This is partly why the UK does not vaccinate against chickenpox. Serious complications from the disease are rare among children, and the circulating virus allows adults to be naturally boosted against reactivation-driven shingles. By rebuilding population immunity among the least at-risk, moreover, we help buffer risk for those most vulnerable.
The UK has since started vaccinating for chickenpox; however, no one at the UON had any concern that a severe case of COVID or losing a parent or teacher to the virus might impact the mental, social, emotional & behavioral health of our children. None at all.
“I think 2-3 years to remove Red Dye #3 is bullshit.”
A lot’s happened since January 2022. COVID is still shuttering schools and children still have mental health problems. However, you wouldn’t know about any of this from the UON. Their final social media post was on January 16, 2025, when they shared a typically juvenile diatribe by Dr. Prasad. He wrote about threats to children as he saw them and how he hoped the US would respond. He boasted of the randomized trials he “would” do and the videos he planned on making. He said:
I think the US should be extremely conservative when it comes to exposing us to uncertain chemicals that are banned in other parts of the world in our food, cosmetics, and furniture. (Red dye #3 was banned from lipstick for 35 years, but not gummy bears)
I think 2-3 years to remove Red Dye #3 is bullshit. It should happen ASAP. Lots of other chemicals can go. I would adopt a US philosophy of: if it is toxic anywhere, it is toxic here.
To substantively improve American’s health, I think you have to be honest and say being fat is bad for your health. It’s terrible for your health. Healthy at all body sizes is the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard. US med schools are deranged.
The built environment needs to be changed so people walk more, move more.
Subsidies to corn and other garbage agricultural products that pump people full of highly refined carbohydrates and low value calories needed to be completely cut.
If subsidies are introduced in the market, and these can be debated, they should be introduced for fruits and vegetables, and studied
Effort should be made to explore be the implications of teaching people about cooking and food culture more broadly. I would conduct randomized experiments.
The NIH budget is being spent on shit. Probably 2/3 of NIH funding is spent on the dumbest research possible. Not the most important human health priorities. It can all be cut and repurposed. NIH funded a study to increase CT screening in homeless people with substance abuse issues– NIH has been run incompetently.
School lunch programs and school nutrition need to be completely revamped. We feed kids dog food. IT is disgraceful. A sign of a failed country is to close kids schools and feed them dog food. US doesn’t value children enough.
Also we should not need to be giving 12 year olds Ozempic. That is crazy.
Many things need to be done. But the US should be the nation that says: if it’s toxic anywhere. It’s toxic here too. I have a few videos I making on this topic that I’ll be posting soon.
While Dr. Prasad portrayed red dye #3 as a grave threat to children, he did not even mention their mental, social, emotional & behavioral health.
Four days after this, on January 20, 2025, Trump took the oath of office, and the moment that happened, the UON vanished. Poof. Their previously prolific X feed became a silent ghost town.
Today, they are reading the same headlines as you and I. However, from ICE raids to the weakening of child labor laws, nothing has stirred them to express the slightest bit of concern about the mental, social, emotional, and behavioral health of our children. With MAHA/MAGA in power and COVID mitigations gone, so is their concern.
Obviously, genuine concern is consistent concern, and the silence from the UON about literally everything happening today is clarifying. It reveals just how sincere they were about the mental, social, emotional, and behavioral health of our children back in January 2022, when COVID raged and mitigations against it were the only problems children supposedly faced.


Can Air Purifiers Stop Spread of COVID-19 Virus?
Air purifiers can remove droplets and viruses from the air, but they cannot prevent the spread of COVID-19 in a mass gathering.
Steven Novella on June 24, 2020
Link

As parts of the US and other nations start to open up from the COVID-19 lockdown, there is a question of how best to safely do that. The goal, obviously, is to maximize economic activity while minimizing the spread of the virus. Meanwhile the virus is still surging in some parts of the world, including some US states, and the current surges seem to be related to poor policy choices – opening up too quickly or without proper safeguards.
The US state that seems to be surging the most right now is Arizona, yet a mass Trump rally was just held yesterday in Phoenix at the Dream City Church. The mass gathering in the hottest red zone of COVID-19 in the US was defended because the church recently installed an air purification system:
“We’ve installed these units and it kills 99.9% of COVID within 10 minutes,” Zastro says. “When you come into our auditorium, 99% of COVID is gone, killed, if it was even there in the first place,” Barnett says. “Thank God for good technology.”
Do air purifiers actually work to filter out the SARS-CoV-2 virus? Yes and no, but mostly no from a practical point of view depending on how you use it. Let’s take the most basic question first, can a good HEPA filter in an air purification system filter out viral particles and remove them from the air? The answer is clearly yes.
Coronaviruses are about 0.125 microns in size. HEPA filters are rated to 0.3 microns, so it might seem at first that they would not filter out the smaller viruses. But a NASA study showed that the HEPA filters are very efficient at filtering out particles down to 0.01 microns. Further, with COVID-19 viral particles are often suspended in very small droplets, and those droplets are much bigger than 0.3 microns and can be efficiently filtered as well.
The makers of the air filtration system in this case also claims that it cleans viruses out of the air with ionization. The idea here is to create ionized air particles that are then attracted to and bind to viruses and other small particulates in the air, making them easier to filter, causing them to drop to the ground, or in the case of germs, deactivating them.
Ionizers may be helpful in some setting, such as minimizing contamination in a sterile environment, but are not generally recommended for home use. They don’t really add much to a good HEPA filter (which is the industry standard) and they generate ozone, which can trigger asthma attacks in some people.
There has not yet been time to test many air filtration systems specifically for COVID-19, but even if we assume that the core claim is true, that a HEPA filtration system will clear out 99.9% of the virus, the more important claim is still – will it prevent the spread of COVID-19? The answer to this question depends on context, but for most situations the answer is a resounding no. The reason for this has to do with volume and how the virus spreads.
When thinking about and describing technology it is often the case that consumers focus on one number or feature and miss perhaps more important features. Cameras are rated by their megapixels, and computers by their processor speed. In this case everyone is focusing on the filtration efficiency, with the rally organizers emphasizing over and over the “99.9%” efficiency of the air filtration system they installed. But that number tells us nothing without another, arguably more important, number – the CFM, or cubic feet per minute.
The CFM rates how much air the purifier will process in a minute. This number is then multiplied by the efficiency to get the CADR, or clean air delivery rate, roughly analogous to replacing the air in a room with fresh air. So a CADR of 400 will bring 400 cubic feet of clean air into a room every minute. That may sound like a lot, and it is, for a regular room in a house. A large auditorium, however, will be in the hundreds of thousands of cubic feet at least. This means that even a robust system with a CADR in the thousands would take hours to replace all the air in the auditorium once (not 10 minutes as claimed). Of note, the “10 minute” claim was based on a study in a small sealed room – which cannot be generalized to a massive open auditorium.
The limiting factor on how big an air purification system can be is mainly noise. Bigger systems are noisy, causing a background of masking noise like being in a wind tunnel. This obviously would not work for an event where you need to hear people speak. It is safe to say that, unless there was a loud background roar of massive air purifiers, whatever system they had installed in the large auditorium likely had a negligible effect on the circulating virus and small droplet particles in the air.
Further still, spread of the virus in a mass gathering likely is not significantly from circulating air that would have a chance to go through a filter. Rather, it is from direct person-to-person spread. If you are talking without a mask to someone relatively close you are spraying them with small droplets, and if you are infected those droplets may be teeming with virus. Droplets can also spread the virus through intermediaries, like door handles, walls, or whatever people may touch. The bottom line is that in a mass gathering an air purification system is likely worthless in terms of reducing the spread of COVID-19.
However, claiming that an air purification system can protect people in a mass gathering can arguably be counterproductive. It may give some people a false sense of security, so perhaps they will be less careful about social distancing, wearing a mask, or touching things. In fact, it seems to have created the justification for the mass gathering in the first place.
I should note that this specific context does not necessarily mean that air purifiers are useless in every setting. If a sick person is isolating in a small room, whether at home or even in a hospital, a good and powerful enough air purification system can reduce circulating droplets and virus and reduce the chance of spreading the infection to others in the same building. We don’t have the evidence to know how effective this is for COVID-19 but that limited claim is plausible. The recommendation is that the system should have as high a CADR as possible without creating so much noise that it disturbs sleep.
        ◦ Perhaps the best air purification system, however, is to just be outdoors. For now that may be the only way to safely have mass gatherings in places where the virus is still spreading – outside, with masks, and with enough space to allow for adequate social distancing. There is no way, however, to make an indoor mass gather safe where the virus is spreading.

Hospital Measures Prevented COVID Transmission
A new study finds that hospital measures to limit the spread of COVID-19 worked, and we probably should keep them.
Steven Novella on January 17, 2024
Link

I attended medical school during the early days of the HIV pandemic. HIV transformed the subspecialty of infectious disease and hospital care, introducing the concept of “universal precautions”. Essentially we assume everyone is a potential vector and behave accordingly.
Over the years other infectious organisms became prominent in hospitals, such as antibiotic resistance bacterial strains and C. dif. Respiratory viral epidemics became more common as well. Each time new protocols were put in place to reduce the spread of infection around the hospital, and each time those new measures were here to stay. Now, when I am covering the consult service and have to roam around the hospital seeing patients, you have to look above the door to see what restrictions are in place. About half the time I have to gown and glove to enter the patient’s room.
During the recent COVID pandemic other precautions were put in place – universal masking with extra precautions for those known to have COVID, such as N-95 masks, gown, glove, and face shield. I knew these new measures would never go away, even once the pandemic of officially over. But did these measures actually work to prevent the spread of COVID in health care settings?
Spoiler alert – yes, absolutely. Anecdotally the effect was profound. On average I tend to get 2-3 respiratory infections per year (a bit more when I had kids in school living at home). Such infections are an occupational hazard but also just a life hazard, unless you live and work in a remote area. But during the COVID pandemic, with universal masking and other precautions, I went two and a half years without a sniffle. Within a week of universal mandatory masking being lifted from the hospital where I work being lifted, I got my first cold since the start of the pandemic.
As impressive as this is, this is SBM and we don’t rely on anecdotes alone. There is plenty of objective data to show that masking and social distancing work to prevent respiratory viruses. One of the most impressive is the flu data. When the COVID shutdown began, that abruptly ended the 2019-2020 flu season. During the height of the pandemic, flu cases in the US dropped from an annual average of about 35 million cases to only 9 million cases in 2021-2022. There are no estimates for 2020-2021 because there were so few cases. In 2022-2023 the flu was back up to 31 million cases. This result is unambiguous.
What about for COVID itself? This is a new virus with a single pandemic, so we don’t have the kind of data that we have for recurrent flu seasons. We need to make more sophisticated epidemiological comparisons to see how specific measures worked. Just such an analysis was recently published in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases. Here is what they did:
We performed retrospective cross-sectional analyses of viral genomics from all available SARS-CoV-2 viral samples collected at UC San Diego Health and social network analysis using the electronic medical record to derive temporospatial overlap of infections among related viromes and supplemented with contact tracing data.
This is a uniquely powerful analysis because of the combination of techniques they used. They relied mostly on genomic analysis – studying the specific genetic variants of the specific strain of the virus that individuals were infected with as a way of reverse engineering the spread of the virus. However, during the first Omicron wave the virus strains that were spreading were too similar to rely entirely on this method. So they supplemented with contact tracing.
What they found was that the COVID virus spread very little within patient care settings even during the height of the pandemic. When the virus did spread it did so outside of patient care settings – so in the cafeteria, not in the patient room.
This strongly suggests that the measures put into place to prevent the spread of SARS-CoV-2 during patient care were very effective. This strengthens the case for what I assumed would happen anyway – keeping these measures even outside the context of a pandemic.
In the past year many health care systems (such as my own hospital) relaxed the mandatory masking requirements in the patient care setting, but are now reinstituting some of them. For example, where I work healthcare workers are required to mask during all patient encounters, while patients are encouraged to mask if they do not have symptoms and required to mask if they do have symptoms.
When masking requirements were relaxed, we started to see the return of COVID transmissions. And now that flu season is upon us, we are again seeing the “tripledemic” of COVID, the flu, and RSV. There are also the usual regular cold viruses going around.
This is simply the world we now live in. Population sizes, concentration in cities, global travel, and increasing encroaching on wild spaces has created a perfect storm of infectious diseases. We simply need to recognize this new reality and up our game.
This may be a positive side effect of the COVID pandemic – at least we now have a “masking infrastructure” in place. People know how to access and use masks when appropriate. There is also more social pressure not to go out into the public when one is sick, coughing and sneezing. Hand hygiene is also important. And for hospitals, infectious precautions have ratcheted up another couple of notches, and perhaps we should not ever relax them.
The political nonsense around masking also needs to end. Masks are not a political statement. They are an effective and essential measure of limiting the spread of respiratory viruses in a world increasingly plagued by them. And it’s only going to get worse.

Nasal Sprays To Prevent COVID
The evidence for nasal sprays to prevent COVID-19 is too preliminary to recommend their use.
Steven Novella on August 9, 2023
Link

While the pandemic still lingers, vaccination programs and the natural course of pandemics is reducing the risk of getting COVID-19 and the severity of illness if you do get infected. The WHO has now ended the public health emergency of concern for COVID-19. Many people have stopped wearing masks routinely. Risk of transmission is fairly low this summer.
COVID is still out there, however, and the long term health risks from a COVID infection are potentially serious. People are often left in a gray zone, wondering if masks are still a good idea and how much they should do to protect themselves. (Short answer – wear a mask if you have symptoms or are around people with symptoms.) One increasingly popular option being heavily marketed is various nasal sprays. They are offered as an option to masking, providing hours of protection from getting infected with COVID. But do they work?
No nasal spray currently on the market has proven efficacy in preventing or treating infection from COVID-19, and there are no FDA approved products in the US. But the idea is plausible and there is some preliminary research. The problem for now is that research is scant, while the marketing is getting heavy and way ahead of the science.
A nasal spray approach to preventing or treating COVID makes sense from the point of view that the nasal cavity is often the first line of defense against COVID, and a common point of entry of the virus. Nasal sprays are easy to use, and can be administered at home. They could potentially provide an extra layer of protection, and even if the duration of effect is relatively short, it could cover an outing in public or a plane trip. There are also several nasal spray vaccines under development, and these could provide a useful alternative to injectable vaccines.
The state of the science for the non-vaccine and non-antibody nasal sprays, however, is distressingly preliminary. I could find very few studies on PubMed, and they are mostly either pre-clinical or case series. First, of course, we need to consider what substance was being studied. There are several that are most promising and marketed – nitric oxide (NO), xylitol, and Iota-Carrageenan (I-C), which is a sulfate polysaccharide.
NO has demonstrated anti-viral effects, including against SARS-CoV-2. A 2021 pilot study found that NO nasal spray decreased viral shedding of SARS-CoV-2 but it did not track clinical outcomes. There is a large clinical trial underway, with initial results anticipated in 2024.
Xylitol is a sugar alcohol that may have antiviral activity. Preliminary studies find that xylitol may have activity against SARS-CoV-2. Another pilot study found the time to negativization of viral titers was shorter using xylitol NS. However, there are currently no clinical trials of xylitol nasal spray and COVID.
The use of NS with Iota-Carrageenan was tested in one clinical trial, using it four times a day in a setting where health care workers were treating COVD positive patients. They found:
A total of 394 individuals were randomly assigned to receive I-C or placebo. Both treatment groups had similar baseline characteristics. The incidence of COVID-19 differs significantly between subjects receiving the nasal spray with I-C (2 of 196 [1.0%]) and those receiving placebo (10 of 198 [5.0%]). Relative risk reduction: 79.8% (95% CI 5.3 to 95.4; p=0.03). Absolute risk reduction: 4% (95% CI 0.6 to 7.4).
These preliminary results are just that – preliminary. They are enough to justify a hypothesis of potential clinical efficacy and to execute full phase 3 type clinical trials, but not enough to justify clinical claims. The FTC agrees. In 2021 they sued Xlear, inc, for marketing a product with xylitol with claims that it could prevent or treat COVID. (Case status is still listed as pending.)
It is well-established that outcomes from pre-clinical and preliminary research are poor predictors of ultimate clinical efficacy demonstrated in rigorous clinical trials. The existing research on the above three types of nasal sprays for COVID, while plausible, are extremely thin. They are insufficient as a basis for making any health claims. But what about a risk-vs-benefit analysis – even if the probability of benefit is low, the nasal sprays to appear to be relatively benign?
The big problem here is that these products are partly being marketed as an alternative to proven preventive methods, such as wearing an effective mask and social distancing. The concern is that use of a nasal spray, if they turn out to be ineffective (completely or in the dose and method of use), will essentially give people permission not to use a more effective preventive method, or to take excessive infection risks. An ineffective nasal spray can provide a false sense of security, and increase the overall risk and spread of COVID.
Ideally clinical research will test each specific nasal spray formula not just to see if it has preventive efficacy, but also in comparison to other established preventive methods. One or more of these products may prove ultimately effective. The problem is that we currently just don’t know, the research is far too scant.

Can “optimizing your metabolism” through diet prevent or cure COVID-19?
A favorite claim by those favoring “holistic” therapies is that using diet to “optimize metabolism” can prevent or treat COVID-19. These claims are of a piece with similar claims for many other diseases and are just as exaggerated.
David Gorski on August 31, 2020
Link

Since COVID-19 was officially declared a pandemic on March 11, unsurprisingly much of the material written for this blog has focused on the science and pseudoscience of COVID-19. In particular, we have covered medical misinformation, urban legends, astroturf disinformation campaigns, and conspiracy theories being spread in what is sometimes called a COVID-19 “infodemic”, as well as the regulatory and public health issues regarding proposed COVID-19 therapeutics and vaccines. However, there is one disturbing false (or at least highly distorted) narrative that we haven’t really addressed, at least not directly. I’m referring to a narrative that started very early on in the pandemic that nutrition and lifestyle can protect you against the coronavirus, or at least make it much less likely that you will develop life-threatening illness if you do “catch this cold“, as Del Bigtree so disturbingly and deceptively put it as he vastly understated the dangers posed by the virus and basically proposed leaving those at high risk for serious disease on their own during this pandemic. (I will be quoting him again later, near the end of this post.)
Of course, those inclined to distrust “Western medicine” and believe in so-called “alternative medicine”, or, as it’s increasingly called as it’s been infiltrating conventional medicine, “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine”, have long overemphasized the potential benefits of nutrition and lifestyle in preventing infectious diseases (or at least drastically ameliorating their symptoms to the point where they go from being potentially life-threatening to minor inconveniences that serve only to “strengthen the immune system”). Just as a reminder, I’ll cite an example over a decade ago during the H1N1 influenza pandemic. Then, HBO’s “politically incorrect” pundit Bill Maher, whom I had noticed spreading antivaccine talking points years before (and who’s still doing it), touted the benefits of nutrition and lifestyle and bragged that, because of it, he’d never catch the flu, even on an airplane. Indeed, Maher said, “I would never get the flu on an airplane”, presumably because his immune system is so healthy and, thanks to his lifestyle, there is no “swamp” there for the virus to breed in, leading his guest Bob Costas to retort in an exasperated voice, “Oh, come on, Superman!” (This was the best retort ever to Maher’s antivaccine nonsense, with the possible exception of Bill Frist basically calling him the “crazy person” when it comes to vaccine pseudoscience.)
Maher is just one of the more amusing examples of antivaxxers and quacks implying (or outright claiming) that nutrition can do a better job of preventing infectious disease than vaccines. I could quote many others, given that I’ve been following the antivaccine movement since the early 2000s. One particular favorite is a common antivaccine claim that, because children in Third World countries are much more likely to die when they contract measles than children in First World countries, nutrition and sanitation are far more important in preventing measles than vaccines, the idea being that better nutrition makes for a “stronger immune system”. Basically, it’s a good example of how antivaxxers take a pebble of truth (certainly poor nutrition does impact the immune system) and try to turn it into a boulder of an unsupported claim or outright lie (e.g., that nutrition can do as well or better, in “strengthening the immune system” to prevent infectious diseases, than vaccines).
It’s not just infectious diseases, either. This fetishization of nutrition and food above all permeates not just the antivaccine movement but all of alternative medicine. Indeed, when alternative practitioner Toni Bark developed a deadly cancer, the cognitive dissonance was such that her son had to admit that she developed her cancer even though she had lived what he considered to be an incredibly healthy lifestyle and consumed a vegan diet. (Yes, there is considerable victim blaming among the “nutrition cures everything” crowd.) A corollary of the “food as medicine” mindset is a persecution complex, in which advocates like to claim that any suggestion that food can cure or prevent disease is dismissed by nasty scientists and skeptics as “quackery”. (It’s not; only overblown claims for the medical benefits of foods, nutrients, diet, and lifestyle are so dismissed.)
So it should be no surprise that similar claims are being made regarding COVID-19 and have been since very early in the pandemic, including claims that vitamin C (of course!) or an “alkaline diet” (double of course!) can treat or cure COVID-19.
Which brings me to an article reviewing a book by Dr. Asseem Malhotra, The 21 Day Immunity Plan:
Winter is coming and the current spate of Coronavirus-related news is not encouraging: the pandemic is ravaging Europe, efficient cures are still just over the horizon, and many are prophesizing that the second wave will hit us even harder than the first one. But amidst this doom and gloom, Dr. Aseem Malhotra’s book, The 21 Day Immunity Plan (1), is a much needed breath of fresh air.
Malhotra is a familiar name for European Scientist readers – in one of our most read articles of the year, Covid-19 and the elephant in the room, Dr. Malhotra excoriated the mainstream media for their failure to notice the role nutrition has in the outcome of Covid-19 cases. Obesity, diabetes, and other metabolic diseases led to increased hospitalization rates, overwhelming the NHS:
The government public health message enhanced by the media to stay at home, protect the NHS and save lives has been powerful and effective. Given the speed at which health markers for metabolic disease improve from dietary interventions, an equally strong if not more significant population health message should now be to “eat real food, protect the NHS and save lives.”
Driving that point home, Malhotra has now followed up on this story with a solid 21-day program on how to optimise the immune fonction [sic].
To see where this is going, let’s first look at what we know about the factors that predispose to death or serious illness from COVID-19.
COVID-19 risk factors
Since the earliest major outbreak of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China, doctors have recognized certain risk factors that portended a higher likelihood of life-threatening illness and death from SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Many of these risk factors have been confirmed over and over again in multiple studies in multiple countries.
Unmodifiable risk factors for death from COVID-19
The first—and by far the strongest—risk factor for serious disease and death due to coronavirus is unchangeable. Specifically, it is age. It has been known since very early on in the pandemic that, the older you are, the more likely you are to die if you contract COVID-19—and not by a little. The CDC has published a handy-dandy guide that tells you how much higher or lower your risk of death due to the virus is compared to the reference group (18-29 year olds). There is a dramatic increase in the risk of hospitalization and death with rising age, going from a 2x higher risk of hospitalization and 4x higher risk of death for 30-39 year olds to a 13x higher risk of hospitalization and 630x higher risk of death in those 85 years of age or older:

In terms of absolute numbers, the reported case fatality rates (CFRs, or the risk of dying if you develop symptomatic COVID-19) range from 13%-20% for those over 80.
A recent study from PNAS shows this age effect most starkly:
In terms of infection fatality rate (IFR), which includes all infections, including the asymptomatic, we know this
For every 1,000 people infected with the coronavirus who are under the age of 50, almost none will die. For people in their fifties and early sixties, about five will die — more men than women. The risk then climbs steeply as the years accrue. For every 1,000 people in their mid-seventies or older who are infected, around 116 will die. These are the stark statistics obtained by some of the first detailed studies into the mortality risk for COVID-19.
And:
“COVID-19 is not just hazardous for elderly people, it is extremely dangerous for people in their mid-fifties, sixties and seventies,” says Andrew Levin, an economist at Dartmouth College in Hanover, New Hampshire, who has estimated that getting COVID-19 is more than 50 times more likely to be fatal for a 60-year-old than is driving a car.
This preprint quantifies the risk. (Note that preprints are not yet peer reviewed.)
Another major risk factor for death is also unchangeable in that sex also matters. Men have a significantly higher risk of dying from COVID-19 than do women, as also shown in the preprint:
A recent correspondence in The Lancet suggests, though, that the relationship is not straightforward:
The overall male to female mortality sex ratio per 100,000 population was 1·4 (crude ratio 1·3). This ratio was not equal at all ages. For example, for people aged 0–9 years the ratio was 0·81. The ratio was 1·9 in the 40–49 years age group, 2·3 in the 50–59 year age group, 2·6 in the 60–69 years age group, and 1·65 in people older than 80 years (appendix p 1).
There was some variation across countries, although broadly the pattern was similar, and the numbers became too small for clear-cut interpretation (appendix p 3).
These data alter our understanding of male–female differences; the relationship is not straightforward, and efforts should now be made to understand risk based on the interaction of sex and age, along with other factors.
Unsurprisingly, ethnicity also plays a role. Of course, it can be difficult to separate socioeconomic factors from ethnicity, but we do know that there is a considerable racial and ethnic gap in terms of COVID-19 mortality, with Black people suffering death rates twice as high as white people, and Hispanic/Latino people somewhere in between. There is also evidence that Native American and Alaska Native people are at higher risk of death and severe disease as well.
Of course, we’re still early in our experience with COVID-19, and it will take considerably more research to tease out the reasons for elevated risk of severe disease and death in various populations. My point here is that there are at least two major risk factors that are not modifiable (sex and age) and at least one that might not be modifiable (race, if the increased risk is truly due to race and not more due to comorbidities and social forces that disproportionately affect Black populations and other minorities). No matter whether risk of death from COVID-19 can be decreased by “metabolic optimization” or not, if you’re 80 years old you’ll still be many, many times more likely to die of COVID-19 than if you’re 20 years old.
Modifiable risk factors for COVID-19
Another observation that was made early in the pandemic is that a number of chronic comorbid conditions correlate strongly with the risk of severe disease and death from COVID-19. Currently, these conditions include:
    • Cancer
    • Chronic kidney disease
    • COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease)
    • Immunocompromised state (weakened immune system) from solid organ transplant
    • Obesity (body mass index [BMI] of 30 or higher)
    • Serious heart conditions, such as heart failure, coronary artery disease, or cardiomyopathies
    • Sickle cell disease
    • Type 2 diabetes mellitus
It’s also suspected that these conditions also predispose to severe disease from COVID-19:
    • Asthma (moderate-to-severe)
    • Cerebrovascular disease (affects blood vessels and blood supply to the brain)
    • Cystic fibrosis
    • Hypertension or high blood pressure
    • Immunocompromised state (weakened immune system) from blood or bone marrow transplant, immune deficiencies, HIV, use of corticosteroids, or use of other immune weakening medicines
    • Neurologic conditions, such as dementia
    • Liver disease
    • Pregnancy
    • Pulmonary fibrosis (having damaged or scarred lung tissues)
    • Smoking
    • Thalassemia (a type of blood disorder)
    • Type 1 diabetes mellitus
As you can see, these are a mixture of unmodifiable and potentially modifiable diseases and conditions. For instance, if you have cancer, chronic kidney disease, sickle cell disease, thalassemia, type 1 diabetes, or dementia, medical control can be optimized, but these can’t be reversed. The interesting question arises for conditions and diseases that can be impacted by lifestyle and nutrition, such as hypertension, obesity, and type 2 diabetes, the focus of the claims made by Dr. Malhotra.
Who is Dr. Aseem Malhotra?
Upon looking into his claims, I realized that I didn’t recall having ever heard of Dr. Malhotra before. It turns out that he appears (to me, at least) to be the UK equivalent to Dr. Mehmet Oz, a celebrity doctor known for promoting all sorts of dubious medicine, particularly diet advice. A quick search of this blog revealed that I had mentioned him before, as I had quoted him trying to explain away negative data on hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19. At the time, I had no idea of his reputation; so mea culpa.
In any event, Dr. Malhotra is a British consultant cardiologist best known for promoting a low-carb, high-fat fad diet known as the Pioppi diet, a diet that earned the “honor” of being named one of “Top 5 worst celeb diets to avoid in 2018” by the British Dietetic Association, along with the ketogenic diet, nutritional supplements, and a number of other fad diets, which characterized it as, in essence, a tarted up version of the Mediterranean diet that “recommends a higher fat diet than the traditional Mediterranean one” and notes that “adherents are encouraged to eat lots of vegetables, nuts, legumes, and fish and discouraged from eating red meat, starchy carbs, and sweetened treats.” It also encourages 24-hour fasting. Dr. Malhotra is also very much in the anti-processed sugar camp, having characterized sugar as “enemy number one in the Western diet.” To give you an idea of how anti-sugar he is, he recently made headlines by attacking Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust for accepting a gift of 1,500 Krispy Kreme doughnuts sent to the staff as a gift for their work in dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK in March and April:
Absolutely disgraceful. Feeding junk food to already overweight and obese #NHS staff? I will forward this to CEO of @NHSEngland Simon Stevens personally and I can assure you he won’t be impressed especially as THESE foods a root cause of increased death rates from #COVID19 https://t.co/zAkIsyMJL4
— Dr Aseem Malhotra (@DrAseemMalhotra) April 22, 2020
And I’m going to tell your mother! Amusingly, Dr. Malhotra was dragged hard for his remark (and deservedly so!), as you will see if you click on the Tweet above and look at the responses, although there were also people who bought into this demonization of doughnuts.
Dr. Malhotra also seems to argue that modern medicine does more harm than good treating chronic conditions with medications, channeling Peter Gøtzsche in claiming that “too much medicine can kill you.” Of course, it is not in itself unreasonable to criticize too much medical intervention, but to me a brief perusal of Dr. Malhotra’s oeuvre gave off a seriously disturbing vibe that medicine doesn’t do any good for chronic illness. Unsurprisingly, he is a statin denialist, even having gone so far as to suggest that stopping statins might save more lives and that statins might not benefit anyone.
You get the idea.
So what is Dr. Malhotra arguing? I haven’t read his book, although the review makes plain that it’s basically a repackaging of his promotion of the Pioppi diet. Of course, any book called The 21 Day Immunity Plan that implies that you can basically “fix” your immune system with diet in 21 days is going to draw a lot of skepticism, and rightly so. For instance, how does he justify 21 days? Why not 30 days? Why not 14 days? Why not 60 days? According to the credulous review:
Of course, one will question the arbitrary choice of 21 days. Why would three weeks be enough? Well, as it happens, the number 21 is explained at length by the author, who refers to numerous studies (4) as well as his first-hand experience with the program. In the context of the book, this is justified by good pragmatic reasons such as:
    • For most people it takes three weeks to break any habit, or for many what is a form of addiction to sugar and ultra-processed food. »
    • Most people with adverse metabolic health will start to see marked improvements to their health and/or shape albeit to different degrees within three weeks, without having to count calories. »
    • It is the need to change the narrative around the impact of lifestyle changes and show that their effect on health can be rapid and substantial. We should use this to motivate ourselves to continue to reap the benefits of improved health for life.
What’s Reference 4? Jean-Paul Oury, the reviewer, cites two studies without links or references to them:
A previous diet and exercise study carried out by researchers at the University of California involving 31 participants also revealed reversal of metabolic syndrome in 50 per cent of those that followed a low-fat, high-fibre diet combined with 45–60 mins of moderate intensity exercise per day. Markers of insulin resistance improved but again there was no correlation with weight loss suggesting an independent benefit on metabolic health. Similar rapid improvements in markers of metabolic health with reversal of metabolic syndrome in all participants were observed in a trial involving 7 obese children from a diet and exercise program within 21 days.
31 participants? Seven obese children? These are not particularly large studies. As for Dr. Malhotra’s “first hand experience with the program”, you know what they say about anecdotes…
Still, one has to consider the possibility that, history of overblown claims for the dangers of processed sugar and pharmaceutical medicine and the benefits of a specific fad diet aside, it’s possible Dr. Malhotra could have a point. In fact, he probably does have a germ of a good point. It’s clearly just massively exaggerated.
Can “metabolic optimization” prevent or treat coronavirus?
The first thing to realize here is that, if you’re obese (particularly if you’re morbidly obese), losing weight is a good thing for your health. Even if it doesn’t do a thing to decrease your risk of life-threatening COVID-19, reaching a healthier weight can decrease your risk of any of a number of complicating conditions, including hypertension, heart disease, type 2 diabetes, certain cancers, stroke, fatty liver disease, and more. There is no doubt that losing weight to come closer to a healthy weight range is associated with improvements in many of these conditions, especially type 2 diabetes and hypertension, which can sometimes be reversed by weight loss to the point where medication is no longer necessary.
At the risk of “going anecdotal”, I know that this can be true. Over about a two to three year period, I changed my diet and started exercising regularly, ultimately losing 50 lbs. As a result, the dose of blood pressure medicine that I need to keep my blood pressure under control has declined markedly, and I might even be able to get off of blood pressure medicines altogether. (We’ll see. Given that I’m now at my target weight, with a BMI in the “normal”—whatever that means—range, I might well have maximized my benefit on that score, and my family history doesn’t bode well for my ever getting completely off of blood pressure medication.) Similarly, I might well be able to get off of statins, as my total, LDL, and HDL cholesterol levels are quite acceptable now. (As an aside, I look at studies suggesting that ACE inhibitors might decrease the risk of life-threatening COVID-19, and I wonder if I want to be off my ACE inhibitor altogether or not while the pandemic is still raging.)
The bottom line is that we have no strong evidence yet that “metabolic optimization” will decrease the risk of severe COVID-19, although it is certainly scientifically plausible that weight loss to bring oneself out of the obese range could well help. It’s also undeniable that weight loss and exercise are good things for one’s general health if one is obese, and that a healthier diet can impact type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and other chronic “lifestyle diseases”. On the other hand, it is possible that it might be that treating the “root causes” of metabolic syndrome might not lead to a decreased risk of severe COVID-19, a scenario that could happen if the “root cause” of metabolic syndrome leads to metabolic syndrome through a different mechanism from the one by which it increases the risk of severe COVID-19. Basically, we just don’t know yet. Moreover, where Dr. Malhotra goes wrong is in touting a fad diet as The One True Diet to fix one’s immunity in three weeks, a claim for which there is no good evidence. For example, how do we know his diet is a more effective, healthier way to “metabolic optimization” compared to all the other “healthy diets” out there? We don’t.
It’s particularly irritating to see these sorts of statements:
Dr. Aseem Malhotra : The best vaccine against Coronavirus is optimising metabolic health https://t.co/mWbew8aaER
— Dr. Jason Fung (@drjasonfung) August 28, 2020
In particular, there’s a distinct possibility of this:
More importantly, “optimizing metabolic health” takes time. It’s highly unlikely that 21 days would make a significant difference in decreasing your risk of severe COVID-19, and it’s unhealthy to lose weight too quickly. (We don’t know, but it’s not at all implausible that rapid weight loss could potentially actually be another factor for severe COVID-19.) It’s generally advised that you shouldn’t lose more than a pound or two per week. If you’re 25 lbs. overweight, that’s 12-25 weeks to get down to your target weight. Obviously, if you’re more overweight than that, it will be longer. Losing weight and changing your diet is also very, very hard. Many people can’t do it, or at least they have a lot of difficulty doing it. The reason I could do it is that I had several advantages, including:
    • I have money.
    • I don’t live in a food desert, where calorie-rich fast food is a main food source and it’s difficult to find vegetables, fruits, and other healthier choices for food.
    • I can arrange my schedule so that I have time for exercise.
    • I have a supportive wife.
    • And many others.
Not everyone has these advantages.
There’s another pernicious aspect to this narrative. Even if nutrition could prevent coronavirus, Dr. Malhotra’s is a very privileged position that basically excludes those unable to “optimize metabolic health”. These “nutrition cures and prevents #COVID19” people labor under a delusion of privilege in that they have the time, resources, and luxury to “optimize their metabolism”. There’s also a subtext of victim blaming where it’s your fault if you get sick because you didn’t “optimize your nutrition”. And, make no mistake, victim blaming is rampant among these “nutrition prevents/cures COVID-19” propagandists. Indeed, Del Bigtree did just that when he urged his presumably “healthy” listeners to “catch this cold“. That’s why I’m going to quote him again extensively:
What is the group that is really at risk? Let’s be honest about this and say something that might get me some trouble here, but let’s be honest. That group is very well known. It’s people over the age of 65—not just because you’re over the age of 65, but you’re sick with other diseases. You have heart disease. You have COPD. You have diabetes. You have issues, many of those issues coming from the fact that you didn’t treat your body very well while you were on this planet. And I want to talk about this for one minute as we close this down. That 0.26% are the most sick among us, and I have nothing against you. Go ahead and bubble wrap your house. Lock yourself in your basement. Go and do what’s necessary.
But here’s the problem. When you were my age, you were most likely eating food and fast food and Doritos and drinking Coca-Cola, which you’ll never find in my home. You were eating that all the time. You probably were drinking a lot of alcoholic beverages and really liked to party and enjoyed your cigarettes and said to yourself, “You know what? It’s more about the quality of my life right now. I don’t care if I live to be 100 years old. I want to enjoy my life right now. I like the finer things in life. I like good rich food. I like smoking a cigarette once in a while. I like to drink my drinks.” And you know what? Good on you! That’s the United States of America. No problem, that, some of my best friends think like that. It’s great, and they’re fun to hang out with. That’s perfectly OK.
But here’s what’s not OK. When you reach that point in your life where now your arteries are starting to clog up, your body is shutting down, and the alcohol is eating up your liver, and you have diabetes, or you have COPD, you have asthma, you can’t breathe, all the cigarette smoking has finally caught up with you, you have heart disease because of the way you decided to live your life in the moment, here’s what you are now. You are pharmaceutical-dependent. You did that to yourself, not me. You decided that the moment mattered, and now you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent, which is really what that 0.26% is, and that’s OK too. Thank God there’s drugs out there! There’s drugs that allow you to eat the Philly cheesesteak even though your body knows it hates it, but, go ahead, take the Prilosec. What difference does it make? Drug yourself! Drug yourself! Get through the day! Don’t exercise! Maybe just attach an electrode and see if a little electricity to the stomach will give you the abs you want.
Come on! Grow up! You made choices! And now that you’re pharmaceutically dependent, here’s what you don’t get to do. You don’t get to say I have to take a drug to protect you. That’s what this is. You don’t get to say I have to wear a mask and suck in my own CO2 to protect you. You don’t get to say I have to lock myself in a basement and destroy my career and take away my own ability to feed children because you are pharmaceutical dependent. You lived your life. You made your choice. And thank God we live in the United States of America so you don’t have to worry about grocery police standing outside a grocery store saying, “Really? You really need four liters of Coca-Cola? You really need four bags of Doritos or Chitos or Fritos or whatever the heck it is, little cupcakes with synthetic icing on them? You really need all that?” Because we could go there. We could go there. If we’re really going to get into each other’s schiznit, that’s what we could do.
Or could we live and let live? Eat all the Twinkies you want! Drink all the bourbon you want, and smoke as many cigarettes as you want, and when you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent I will go ahead and say thank God the drug companies are there for you, but you do not get to make me pharmaceutical-dependent. You do not get to put me in the way of Heidi Larson, who wants to eradicate natural health and natural immunity and make us all pharmaceutical dependent.
Again, make no mistake. Dr. Malhotra’s message is simply a more genteel, less obviously judgmental version of the message that Del Bigtree is promoting. As I mentioned when I first dealt with Bigtree’s message, I once coined a term, the central dogma of alternative medicine, to describe the belief that we have near-total control over our health through lifestyle, such as diet, activity, exercise, and a Secret-like belief that wishing makes it so. It never seems to occur to them that age is a major risk factor for death from COVID-19 and that people can’t do anything about how old they were when the pandemic hit, nor can older men like myself do anything about the fact that we were older men when the pandemic hit.
Certainly, a healthy weight, exercising, eating a healthy diet are all good things for your health. Who knows? They might even lower your risk of severe COVID-19. However, don’t be fooled by overblown claims for what they’ll do for your risk of COVID-19, and don’t forget the judgmental implications behind advice like that promoted by Dr. Malhotra. He’ll deny it to high heaven, of course, and maybe he personally doesn’t intend to be judgmental, but judgment is there nonetheless.

Vitamin D for the prevention of COVID-19: A randomized controlled trial
A large clinical trial shows vitamin D supplementation had no effect on COVID-19.
Scott Gavura on March 31, 2022
Link

Depending on where you live, and the persistence of public health rules like masking and vaccination entry requirements, it feels like the beginning of the end of COVID-19, or maybe the end of the end. While some have made the decision to “move on” after more than two years, there’s still a lot of COVID-19 being spread around, along with the continued problem of getting populations vaccinated. Recognizing that disease control will continued to be challenged by new variants, waning immunity, possible vaccine escape, and continued vaccine hesitancy (where vaccines are widely available), we continue to need good measures for preventing or controlling disease.
A year into the pandemic I blogged about one of the earliest randomized controlled trials that studied vitamin D for the prevention of COVID-19. Vitamin D has long been thought to play a role in supporting immune function, in addition to effects on muscle and bone. Given many people live where there is inadequate sunlight to support vitamin D synthesis for parts of the year, deficiency, particularly in older adults, is common. There has been widespread interest in the possible role of vitamin D supplements to help raise vitamin D levels, and possibly prevent infection or minimize the severity of disease. This was the case prior to the arrival of COVID-19, and interest grew in the early period of the pandemic, particularly before the arrival of effective vaccines.
Trials studying the effectiveness of vitamin D for the prevention of upper respiratory infections have been either negative or weakly positive. No clear, consistent benefit has been established. A challenge with much of the observational data is that vitamin D blood levels may be a indicator of poor overall health status, but deficiency may not independently be causing more illness. This highlights the importance of prospective trials with randomization, where actual causality can be inferred. The study I blogged about a year ago was an interesting design of a single dose of 200,000 IU (which would be the equivalent of taking 200 tablets of the standard 1000 IU tablet strength). Compared to placebo, the massive dose did raise vitamin D levels in the blood but had no effect on any of the outcomes measured.
The trial
This new trial, which has been published as a preprint (meaning it has not undergone peer review), was recently discussed on Twitter by epidemiologist Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz. It is from David A. Jolliffe and colleagues from a number of centres across the United Kingdom. It’s titled “Vitamin D Supplements for Prevention of Covid-19 or other Acute Respiratory Infections: a Phase 3 Randomized Controlled Trial (CORONAVIT)”. CORONAVIT was a prospective trial conducted “within” the COVIDENCE cohort study, which was a trial established in May 2020 with the goal of identifying risk factors related to COVID-19 infections.
This was a three-arm, parallel, open label study. To be included, you had to be 16 years of age and participating in the COVIDENCE trial. You were excluded if you were already taking vitamin D, or had a small number of medical conditions. 6,200 patients were assessed as eligible, and randomized (1:1:2) as follows:
     1.  High Dose Group – Offered supply of 3,200 IU vitamin D per day if their blood 25(OH)D levels were less than 75 nmol/L
     2.  Low Dose Group – Offered supply of 800 IU vitamin D per day if their blood 25(OH)D levels were less than 75 nmol/L
     3.  No Dose Group – Not offered testing or any supply of vitamin D
Participants were asked to complete monthly follow-up survey which included questions about respiratory infections, exacerbations of asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, COVID-19 symptoms, and adverse effects. The final survey was sent in June 2021 which was the six-month follow-up. Vitamin D testing was offered to a subset of participants (800 in each treatment group and 400 who were randomized but received no treatment.)
The primary endpoint was the proportion of participants that developed at least one (swab- or physician-confirmed) acute respiratory illness of any kinds. Secondary endpoints included:
    • the proportion of participants developing (PCR-confirmed) COVID-19
    • the proportion of participants hospitalized for COVID-19
        ◦ the proportion of hospitalized patients requiring respiratory support (i.e., mechanical ventilation)
    • the proportion of all participants dying of COVID-19
    • the proportion of participants developing confirmed COVID-19 who reported symptoms lasting more than four weeks
        ◦ the proportion reporting ongoing symptoms at the end of the study
Harms that were measured included the incidence of death, serious adverse effects (and the % leading to discontinuation from the study), high calcium and high levels of vitamin D.
The results
Here is a snapshot from Table 1 showing baseline characteristics. The median age of participants was 60 with a fairly wide age range (16-88+), predominantly female, and overwhelmingly White (94%+).
Only a small percentage (2.5%) of participants had been vaccinated (1 or more doses) at the time of recruitment.
In those where baseline vitamin D was tested, the mean 25(OH)D was 39.7nmol/L. Per the UK National Health Service, adequate levels are defined as ≥75 nmol/L, and 97.4% were below this threshold. Almost all (95.4%) of participants randomized to the treatment groups consented to a 25(OH)D test (by mail).
Follow-up was for six months (December 2020 to June 2021). During this period almost 90% received one or more doses of a COVID-19 vaccine. 90.9% of participants randomized to treatment reported they took their vitamin D supplement at least 6 days per week. In the intention-to treat analysis, there were significant increases in vitamin D levels noted in those on the supplements:
    • High dose treatment 102.9 nmol/L
    • Lower dose treatment 79.4 nmol/L
    • No treatment 66.6 nmol/L
In a sensitivity analysis where non-adherent participants were excluded as well as those in the no-treatment group that actually took vitamin D supplements, the differences were greater:
    • High dose treatment 103.4 nmol/L
    • Lower dose treatment 79.5 nmol/L
    • No treatment 53.7 nmol/L
Primary and secondary endpoints
So did vitamin D prevent respiratory infections, including COVID-19? No. There were no statistically significant differences between the group in terms of the proportion who experienced at least one confirmed acute respiratory infection. With some of the measures like symptom persistence, the vitamin D groups look (non-significantly) worse. There were also no differences in the incidence or severity of COVID-19 infections, the duration of related symptoms, or in any other measure (I have trimmed out the P values here for readability, they’re on page 20 if you want to see them).
A subgroup analysis showed no evidence that vaccination modified the effects of the allocation. Moreover, the sensitivity analysis (described above) did not reveal any differences compared to the primary, intention-to-treat, analysis. That is, excluding patients in the control group who took vitamin D supplements didn’t change the results. Also, excluding patients in the treatment groups who were non-compliant with therapy didn’t change the results.
There were few adverse events. A few patients in the high-dose group developed hypercalcemia and symptoms resolved with the discontinuation of vitamin D.
Conclusion: Vitamin D strikes out again
There were multiple strengths to this study, including the baseline low levels of vitamin D, and the demonstrable effectiveness of the supplements. Compared to the study I blogged about a year ago, this was a more typical (daily) dose versus a single massive dose. There were few dropouts and a modest number of COVID-19 cases. The limited number of cases, particularly of hospitalizations, means we need to be cautious in making definitive conclusions. However, there was no suggestion of benefit.
In this randomized controlled trial, vitamin D had no effects on the incidence or consequences of COVID-19 or other acute respiratory infections. This was despite active treatment with vitamin D that did meaningfully raise serum vitamin D levels.
This is another prospective trial with vitamin D in COVID-19 to show no meaningful effect in the prevention of acute illness. Having said that, it’s clear that (at least in this population) vitamin D deficiency is widespread, and supplementation may be appropriate for individuals anyway. But there continues to be no persuasive evidence to suggest that vitamin D supplementation will help protect you from COVID-19 infections.

Chiropractors falsely claim they can protect patients from coronavirus
Chiropractors are falsely claiming that their spinal “adjustments” can protect people from coronavirus infection, as well as giving other dubious health advice on COVID-19. As they have with other bogus remedies, the media and government authorities should take action.
Jann Bellamy on March 12, 2020
Link

Some chiropractors are falsely claiming that spinal “adjustments” will do everything from “boosting the immune system” (which you can’t do), helping ward off the novel coronavirus, to actually preventing patients from contracting the virus. They also advise other dubious measures for keeping the virus at bay.
These bogus assertions are based on their misrepresentation of the human nervous system as susceptible to interruptions of “nerve flow” or “nerve energy” between the brain and the rest of the body. According to chiropractors, these putative interruptions are caused by “subluxations”, or “misalignments”, of the spinal vertebrae, creating deleterious effects such as a compromised immune system. Chiropractors can “correct” these “subluxations” with spinal “adjustments”, thereby restoring “nerve flow”. As one chiropractic website “explains”:
Spinal adjustments have been shown to boost immune function because they serve to correct the spinal misalignments that cause neural dysfunction. Neural dysfunction stresses a body out, which may lead to a weakened immune system and lowered response to a foreign body, such as the cold virus.
Organs that have a strong relationship with the immune system, such as the lymph nodes and the spleen, communicate with your brain and nerves, and if your nervous system isn’t functioning at an optimal level, a communication breakdown can occur. You can imagine what may happen next. Getting a chiropractic adjustment is a great place to start so you can get any spinal misalignment you may have corrected. Even one adjustment can bring about an immediate immune boost.
No, it won’t. Actually, what the “adjustment” (in the form of spinal manipulation) may do is cause anything from mild to moderate adverse events, such as pain, to vertebral artery dissection and consequent stroke following cervical manipulation. At the least, the patient will have wasted money on a worthless treatment.
Unfortunately, neither the uselessness of, nor risks associated with, their treatments are keeping chiropractors from exploiting the coronavirus epidemic. There’s even a new poster and patient handout offered by one company warning that skipping your chiropractic “adjustments” will put you at greater risk for contracting the coronavirus.
As is often the case in the service of pseudoscience, a good, old-fashioned anecdote is employed as evidence of the “adjustment’s” effectiveness. In a post titled “Coronavirus”, this chiropractic practice claims that
a patient [was seen] last week suffering from cold and flu symptoms for two weeks with no change after 2 rounds of prescribed medications and a variety of over the counter medications all to no avail. One adjustment and 2 days later the patient was 80% better. That is the power of an adjustment. Safe and effective. No side effects. That’s protection. Have you had an adjustment lately?
[Emphasis in original.]
A Texas chiropractor is, more creatively, window dressing his false claims with science-based advice, while at the same time adding adjunct pseudoscience and a touch of historical negationism which casts chiropractors as the saviors of Spanish flu victims. Under the title “7 Ways to Protect Yourself from Coronavirus” we find:
Standard recommendations to prevent infection spread include regular hand washing, covering mouth and nose when coughing and sneezing . . .
This comes with a warning against two perennial CAM bugaboos, sugar and dairy, because
too much sugar weakens our immune system, and voilà! Sickness isn’t an if, it becomes a when.
But that’s nothing compared to what milk will do to you: milk increases antibiotic resistance, making us more susceptible to “superbugs” like coronavirus; contains high levels of estrogen and progesterone, which leads to abnormal early puberty and increases the risk of uterine, breast and prostate cancers; contains casein, which facilitates the growth of cancer cells; increases the risk of Type I diabetes and multiple sclerosis; disrupts the body’s Vitamin D production and negatively affects bone growth; and, because of sulfurous amino acids, leaches the calcium out of our bones, thereby “leading to a vastly higher risk of osteoporosis at an earlier age”.
While there may be reasons one would not want to consume milk, this is a vast overstatement of the risks.
In any event, chiropractic “adjustments” are essential:
Of course I have to include this. Everyone who comes into my office for their first visit has a misalignment of their C1 vertebra, also known as a vertebral subluxation. This is significant because just about every nerve in the entire body passes through the C1 as the spinal cord. When there is a subluxation of the C1, this adds stress, tension, and/or pressure to some aspect of some nerve that travels to somewhere in the body. When this happens, people experience symptoms either immediately or eventually. Removing the subluxation and restoring proper positioning of the C1 allows the nervous system to properly communicate with the body and vice versa. Since the nervous system is the master system, it happens to control all other systems, including the immune system.
Everyone?
To “boost” his case, the website cites this unpublished 4-page paper from 1978, full of uncredited statistics and anecdotes, for the claim that:
[P]eople infected with influenza [during the 1917-18 epidemic] who received chiropractic care as their primary means of treatment died at such a lower rate than those treated by medicine that it was staggering.
While some chiropractors may depend on the patient’s making the connection between an immune system “boost” and protection against the coronavirus, others are not so subtle. From a Charlotte, NC, chiropractor’s website:
[W]hat I want to talk to you about is how to strengthen your immune system, how to make yourself coronavirus proof, so that you don’t have to worry about it, your family doesn’t have to worry about it. . . .
So, in order to make you coronavirus free and may make you independent and not have to worry, make your body strong enough to know, that regardless, if somebody walks in and sneezes on you or shakes your hand or kisses you, you’re not going to wind up getting sick because you got to make sure your immune system is kicking on all cylinders. Which means, your nervous system has to be kicking on all cylinders. . . .
Now, the best way to do that is to find an upper cervical chiropractor. To check this area, we have objective tools [one of these, perhaps] that we can actually scan your neck and see if there’s any interference anywhere between your brain and your body. If there is, then we can figure out what’s causing that interference. We can remove that interference. Make sure the brain’s talking at 100%, and that way it keeps your immune system kicking at 100%, so then you can fight off anything, anything that comes in and tries to hurt you.
[Emphasis added.]
This is not only patently false, it is dangerous. Anyone who believes he is immune from the coronavirus is unlikely to take precautions for himself or others, increasing the risk of contracting COVID-19.
If an “adjustment” isn’t enough to nip your coronavirus in the bud, you can, according to this California chiropractor, pop some dietary supplements, which he conveniently sells to his patients. After incorrectly saying that the coronavirus is “the latest version” of the flu, he says:
In my office we have some amazing supplements in the area of immunity. One of these is Echinacea Premium from Mediherb. It is fabulously potent. . . Echinacea is an immune booster and balancer. . . We use the Standard Process supplement Immuplex to rebuild the immune system. [Caution: non sequitur ahead.] Dig that people used to live much shorter lives than we live today. So all these supplements rebuild a tired, depleted system. . .
Acute infections can be addressed with Congaplex and sometimes Andrographis Complex which contains echinacea premium. Garlic can be helpful for many people too. We sell garlic capsules. The trick to acute infections is to jump all over them with supplements within a few hours of the moment you get an inkling you might be coming down with something. Why? There is a good chance if you address the infection quickly enough it never takes hold.
“Immuplex” is basically a multi-vitamin/mineral supplement to which a “proprietary blend” of bovine liver, spleen, and thymus extracts, veal bone extract, and other ingredients have been added. Even the maker of “Congaplex” (which also contains animal organ extracts) admits it doesn’t know if it works in humans. There is no evidence that either echinacea or garlic will prevent, or reduce the severity of, COVID-19. In fact, federal law prohibits the sale of dietary supplements to treat infectious diseases.
Fortunately, the promotion of bogus preventatives and remedies for coronavirus infection is getting media, blogosphere, and government attention. On Monday, the Washington Post reported that the FDA and FTC sent warning letters to seven companies touting various products, including teas, essential oils, and colloidal silver. The Post also ran a column by a registered dietician several days ago noting that claims one could “boost” one’s immune system were proliferating and explaining why this is nonsense, although it did not mention chiropractors. Televangelist Jim Bakker’s shilling for “Silver Solution” was widely reported. Even the CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health is warning against alternative remedies being promoted for coronavirus infections.
Unfortunately, no one has alerted the public to the dangers of chiropractors promoting their “immune boosting” powers. In fact, the standard recommendation to “check with your health care provider” could lead some patients to rely on their chiropractors for advice about the coronavirus. After all, they promote themselves as “primary care providers”. Newspapers and other media should do a better job of warning the public away from unreliable health care advice given by those who are, regrettably, licensed by the states to practice pseudoscience.

THERAPY

Two New Antivirals Targeting COVID-19
There are two new drugs on the horizon that actually work against COVID-19.
Steven Novella on November 10, 2021
Link

Recent weeks has seen the announcement of two new drugs that could potentially treat acute COVID-19 infections. The UK approved molnupiravir by Merck, which will now be tested in clinical trials and likely licensed early next year. Meanwhile, Pfizer a day later announced Paxlovid, which it says is 89% effective in preventing hospitalizations and death, and now seeks FDA approval. If one or both of these antiviral drugs works out, what could this mean for the pandemic?
Right now there are several tools we have for tackling the COVID pandemic. One is public health measures to reduce spread of the disease – masking, social distancing, avoiding crowds, especially in indoor spaces, isolating if exposed or sick, testing, and contact tracing. Together these methods have been critical to minimizing the spread of COVID, but they are not enough on their own to stop the pandemic or prevent spikes in infection. There are also, of course, vaccines, which reduce the chance of contracting the illness if exposed, reduces the severity of illness if you do get it, and reduces the chance of passing on the virus to others. Vaccines are rightly considered our best hope for ending the pandemic, or at least having life return mostly to normal.
We also need to treat people who become sick with COVID despite preventive measures. Here also there are two types of interventions: supportive, and anti-viral. Supportive measures reduce the symptoms and complications of infection, and keep people alive until their immune system can fight off the infection. Using steroids like prednisone has turned out to be one of the most effective measures, because the most severe outcomes from COVID are likely due to the body’s immune reaction to infection, the worst being so-called cytokine storm. It may also be necessary to intubate patients with severe illness so that a ventilator can breathe for them until their lungs recover, although it was discovered that delaying intubation as long as possible may improve outcomes. A March 2021 systematic review, however, found no difference in all-cause mortality between early and late intubation, so at least there is no advantage to early intubation and no risk from delay.
The high-tech treatment for COVID has been some type of immunoglobulin treatment. This can be intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG), which is simply pooled antibody proteins from many donors. It can also be hyperimmune gamma globulin, which is taken from donors who have had COVID-19 (convalescent plasma), and is considered more effective than regular IVIG. There are also monoclonal antibodies, which are one type of antibody against SARS-Cov-2 (usually the spike protein) which have to be produced in a bioreactor (not taken from people). Research into all of these antibody treatments is ongoing, but overall they have some efficacy in reducing the severity of illness. However, they are expensive and of limited availability, and so by themselves are not going to have a large impact on the pandemic.
Finally, we have therapeutic treatments, specifically direct anti-viral drugs. This treatment option for COVID has so-far eluded medical experts. There have been many proposed treatments, the most famous (or infamous) have been hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin. We have discussed these two drugs extensively here so I won’t go over them again, except to say that neither drug has been shown to be an effective treatment for COVID-19 in clinical trials, and neither is recommended for use. They have, however, become very politically controversial. As an aside it does demonstrate how easy it is for those with political or anti-science agenda to flip the script as needed. In this case some of them reject a safe and effective preventive measure (vaccines), in favor of an unproven pharmaceutical treatment for the disease once it occurs.
Despite all the controversy over the past almost two years, we may now finally have two antiviral drugs that actually work. The data for Pfizer’s Paxlovid is particularly impressive, if it holds up to review. They report the result of a phase 2/3 double-blind placebo-controlled trial in patients with COVID who were not hospitalized:
The scheduled interim analysis showed an 89% reduction in risk of COVID-19-related hospitalization or death from any cause compared to placebo in patients treated within three days of symptom onset (primary endpoint); 0.8% of patients who received PAXLOVID™ were hospitalized through Day 28 following randomization (3/389 hospitalized with no deaths), compared to 7.0% of patients who received placebo and were hospitalized or died (27/385 hospitalized with 7 subsequent deaths).
This is a good absolute and relative risk reduction, essentially making COVID a much less deadly illness. If used widely this treatment would significantly reduce the COVID burden on the hospital system. While the data was presented as 89% relative risk reduction in hospitalization or death, it should be noted there were zero deaths in the treatment group (compared to 7 in the placebo group). The FDA must now review this data and determine if they will give the drug an emergency use authorization (EUA) and start the process for full approval. They may also ask for more data, which would certainly come in any case as researchers track the results of treatment.
Merck’s drug, meanwhile, was shown to have a 50% reduction in hospitalization – from 14% to 7%, with deaths decreased from 8 to zero. This is a similar outcome, but it’s hard to do a direct comparison because of different populations and methods. But it’s safe to say that both drugs are highly effective.
Hopefully by early next year one or both of these drugs will be available to treat patients newly diagnosed with COVID-19 (whether under an EUA or as part of ongoing clinical trials). What does this mean for the pandemic? This is, potentially, huge news, and could be a game-changer. In the best-case scenario where both drugs are confirmed to be safe and highly effective, this would mean that the lethality of COVID-19 is dramatically mitigated, reducing hospitalizations and deaths. This would be a very welcome respite for overburdened hospital systems and workers, which will have a significant downstream benefit to health care overall. We may also finally start to see the mortality rate for COVID start to dramatically come down.
        ◦ The vaccines have clearly been the most important medical development for tackling this pandemic, and this will remain true. Vaccines are necessary to reduce spread and avoid spikes in illness, and to allow life to return to normal. But it also increasingly looks like, despite the availability of vaccines, we are going to have to live with COVID-19 for the foreseeable future. It will likely become endemic like the flu. Having effective anti-viral treatments will therefore be essential to reducing the health burden of this virus.

Alternative Medicine Exploits Coronavirus Fears
Alternative medicine has been quick to capitalize on the public’s fear of coronavirus. They offer an array of bogus treatments.
Harriet Hall on February 4, 2020
Link

The news is full of alarming reports about the new coronavirus that originated in China and is spreading throughout the world. There is no treatment other than supportive measures, and there is no vaccine to prevent it. Scientists don’t yet know much about it, although they are already working on a vaccine. It is only natural that the public is worried about it, even though it would make far more sense to worry about influenza, which is causing far more infections and deaths and for which we have treatments and a vaccine. Fears increased when it was announced that it can be transmitted from person to person. We see pictures of empty streets in China and hear of stranded travelers. The death toll keeps rising and is announced on the news on a daily basis.
I was just thinking it wouldn’t be long before CAM (complementary and alternative medicine) stepped in to allay fears by offering bogus remedies, and sure enough, I started seeing them everywhere.
Homeopathy Safe Medicine announced:
    • So if you are a homeopathy user you don’t need to wear a face mask (or even goggles), and certainly not a white space suit in fear. Just take your usual influenza remedy, and have them at hand.
    • If you are not a homeopathy user yet it is exactly the right time to join us, and begin living life normally again.
A practitioner of siddha medicine in Tamil Nadu claimed to have formulated an herbal medicine to cure coronavirus in 24-40 hours. He even offered to travel to Wuhan to offer his cure to the Chinese.
Promoters of the pro-Trump QAnon conspiracy theory urged their fans to ward off the illness with bleach (Miracle Mineral Solution or MMS). Jordan Sather said he would have to get home and “MMS the whole state…MMS the shit out of everything.”
China’s National Health Commission recommends traditional Chinese medicine, with individualized remedies based on whether the patient is categorized as damp, hot, toxic, or bruised.
Simply Health lists 14 natural methods to treat coronavirus, including foods, acetaminophen, honey, heating pads or cold packs, steamy showers, hydration with hot liquids, gargling, bundling up, and resting. They offer the encouraging but false information that coronavirus is just like a cold: it causes the same symptoms and will disappear from the body in the same amount of time. They must not be reading the headlines.
The Herbal Prepper Academy lists herbs and essential oils to fight coronaviruses. The 37 herbs include cayenne, ginger, cinnamon, garlic, horseradish, kudzu, Dyers Woad, gingko biloba, and many more. Six essential oils that “assist the respiratory system” are listed: thyme, oregano, eucalyptus, rosemary, lavender, and sage. They comment that some are better for children and others are better for adults “who can handle a more intense essential oil.” They warn not to ingest, but to take through inhalation only.
An article in The Washington Post reported that Facebook, Google, and Twitter are scrambling to stop misinformation about coronavirus.
Carahealth advised that constituents in herbs exhibit a diverse array of anti-viral, virostatic, immune enhancing, and anti-influenza activities and may present a solution. They recommend echinacea, barberry, astragalus, elderberry, and turmeric. They also recommend Vitamin D as an alternative flu prophylactic.
An article on ScienceAlert reported that India’s government was recommending homeopathy for coronavirus prevention (specifically, Arsenicum album 30 daily for 3 days) and asked “What’s the harm?” They commented that India’s tips might be the second least effective advice offered, after the Dalai Lama’s advice to chant a mantra as protection.
I’m sure there are many more examples out there, but I was too discouraged at this point to keep googling. I suppose I shouldn’t object to people taking bogus remedies if it makes them worry less, since science doesn’t yet have anything effective to offer, and reassurance can make people feel better. But I certainly can’t condone the suggestions for things known to be harmful like MMS. And there is always the danger that people who accept this kind of CAM advice today may go on to use other bogus remedies tomorrow and may die unnecessarily from a life-threatening illness that could have been effectively treated with mainstream science-based methods.
Bottom line: question random advice; ask for evidence.

More Pseudoscience for COVID-19
The science and pseudoscience of COVID-19 are being tested in the real world.
Steven Novella on April 8, 2020
Link

Fear is a protective response but it can also breed irrationality and therefore become counterproductive. Fear is also a blunt evolutionary tool that does not work well in complex situations that require nuance and calculation. We are seeing this play out in many forms throughout the world in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The pandemic has brought into focus the very thing we discuss the most at SBM – the relationship between scientific evidence and delivering the best medical possible care. The cooler, more professional heads have been saying from the beginning – there is good reason for concern, but not panic. Let’s take steps that are evidence-based and prudent based on our best predictions about what is likely to happen, but there is no need to lose our heads. The actual response around the world has been variable. We are seeing pretty much every possible response and outcome. As is often the case with any time of instability and fear, pseudoscience oozes out of the gutter to exploit the situation, or perhaps out of sincere but misplaced hope.
The biggest pseudoscience is the denial of epidemiology itself, and by extension of experts and the very notion of expertise. One form this took (and still does) was a denial of the pandemic or its seriousness. One common tactic of denial was to falsely compare COVID-19 to the flu. This is not the flu. The mortality rate, while still unknown, is at least two orders of magnitude greater than the flu and perhaps more. The 2018-2019 season flu caused 35.5 million cases and 34,000 deaths in the US, with a mortality rate of around 0.01%. Currently COVID-19 in the US has caused 374,329 cases and 12,064 deaths. The mortality rate of COVID-19 is hard to say, because those are not all completed cases.
If you look at all completed cases worldwide the mortality rate is currently 21%. But this is unlikely to be accurate, partly because there are many cases unreported and many people who are asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic who are not being counted. At the same time, early reporting in NYC shows an increase in deaths at home (not tested and therefore not counted) which would mean the number of deaths from COVID-19 may be underestimated by as much as 40%. So the mortality rate is somewhere between 2 and 3 orders of magnitude greater than the flu, and this is a very contagious disease. By now everyone should know the goal of physical distancing is to flatten the curve, to limit the pulse of cases that threaten to overwhelm our hospitals and ICUs (which is already happening in places like NYC).
At the other end of the spectrum are those offering false or premature treatments for COVID-19. We have already discussed TCM, chiropractic, and false naturopathic claims. These are pure pseudosciences exploiting the crisis. But also there are semi-legitimate potential treatments that are simply untested or not adequately tested, most famously hydroxychloroquine which David has discussed twice now. This is an already-approved drug with potential serious side effects and very preliminary and contradictory early testing.
This is also a great case to illustrate exactly why we recommend a science-based approach. The probability that hydroxychloroquine will turn out to be an effective treatment for COVID-19 is not zero as there is some encouraging pre-clinical data. But the probability, based just on pre-clinical data, is extremely low. Most treatments that look encouraging don’t pan out, for a variety of reasons. It is perhaps more likely that this drug will cause more deaths and harm from side effects and other unintended consequences (like depriving people who actually need the drug) than it will help with the pandemic. At this point all we can say is that rigorous clinical trials are needed. But this requires patience, and that is in short supply during a crisis.
There are also some other pure pseudosciences rearing their heads. I was waiting for homeopathy to make an appearance, and it has, in Cuba. The Cuban government is dispensing a homeopathic potion for primary prevention of COVID-19. The product is PrevengHo-Vir, which seems to have come into existence just recently, and is produced by a Cuban pharmaceutical company. Homeopathy is nothing but magic water, with effectively zero probability of working. Offering this as a preventive treatment for COVID-19 is malfeasance.
What this will accomplish is giving official backing to witchcraft, and also has the potential to create a false sense of security among those treated. Perhaps they will loosen their physical distancing because they believe they are protected. This is a well-documented backfire effect. The Cuban government, in turn, justifies their position by citing the inclusion by the World Health Organization of homeopathy in its list of recognized traditional treatments. This is exactly what we warned about at the time – giving false legitimacy to pseudoscience.
Meanwhile the FDA and FTC are trying to do their job by issuing strongly worded warning letters (yeah, I know) to 7 companies selling pseudoscience for COVID-19:
The FDA and FTC jointly issued warning letters to Vital Silver, Quinessence Aromatherapy Ltd., Xephyr, LLC doing business as N-Ergetics, GuruNanda, LLC, Vivify Holistic Clinic, Herbal Amy LLC, and The Jim Bakker Show. The products cited in these warning letters are teas, essential oils, tinctures and colloidal silver.
Colloidal silver is old-school snake oil we have debunked years ago. Do not use it. Essential oils have also been addressed here several times in the past.
At the very least, I hope the pandemic serves to focus attention on the need for science and expertise and the risks of relying on snake-oil, hype, and magic. This is an opportunity to see all this play out in real time around the world, and we have the ability to gather the numbers and see the results. Also, the effects of the pandemic are fairly rapid – rapid enough that even non-experts can draw the line of causation. Rely on pseudoscience at your own peril.

An incomplete list of COVID-19 quackery
Possibly the only thing spreading faster than COVID-19 is the pseudoscience about COVID-19.
Scott Gavura on May 28, 2020
Link

The COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic is the most significant public health event of a generation. Its worldwide spread has totally disrupted our old (early 2020) way of life. At time of writing there are 5.5 million confirmed cases and 350,000 deaths, across 217 countries. A vaccine, if an effective one is ever developed, is many months (more likely years) away. This is the most frightening event many people may ever have experienced. While we now understand a lot about the structure of virus itself, there are many aspects of COVID infections that remain unclear, including transmission and treatment. Uncertainty is frightening, but that is what we are dealing with. Different countries are taking different approaches. It is not surprising that in the absence of robust science and consistent public health advice, COVID pseudoscience has exploded. 
Quackery, or health fraud, is a health practice that is ignorant or fraudulent. It can include a diagnosis, a test, or a treatment. A quack is someone that promotes these types of therapies. However, just because something is unproven does not make it quackery. An absence of evidence does not mean evidence of absence. Plausibility matters. The contributors to this blog are Bayesians which in short means that our assessment of “new” data, evidence, or claims is informed by the existing evidence; this includes, in the case of medicine, our understanding of basic science. In evaluating a medical claim, we ask, “Is this plausible, based on what we already know?” It is no different in a pandemic with a novel virus. In the case of COVID, while much is unknown about the infection, there is also a tremendous amount that is known – including human biochemistry, physiology, coronaviruses (in general), and how virus-based infections are transmitted or can be prevented.
Plausible therapies that are unproven may not be quackery. They could be considered experimental until better evidence emerges. However, many therapies that are currently being promoted for COVID-19 are clearly quackery. Unbound by evidence and driven by a combination of ignorance, hyperbole and usually grift, the number of products and interventions touted as useful to prevent or treat COVID infections continues to grow. Here is a list of what I’ve encountered so far, and a bit about each one where there is some information to share. If I missed anything, please leave it in the comments, and I’ll do a follow-up or add to this list over time.
Hydroxychloroquine
If you asked me in March, I wouldn’t have put this on the list. Hydroxychloroquine started out as perhaps weakly plausible based on poor, but promising, evidence. But as more and more evidence has emerged, it is now difficult to accept that there is any “there” there. Not only is there no evidence of benefit, there is now increasingly convincing evidence of harm. If this therapy was simply abandoned given it is ineffective, it wouldn’t be quackery. While some clinical trials are being shut down, it continues to be prescribed and promoted despite the lack of any convincing evidence it can prevent or treat COVID infections. That’s why it’s becoming quackery. Outside of an ongoing clinical trial, there is little rationale for its use. David Gorski has more in posts here and here.
Bear bile and other forms of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM)
Despite the Chinese government’s endorsement and promotion of bear bile injections and other forms of TCM, there is no credible evidence that it is effective. Bear bile extraction is exceptionally cruel, as Jann Bellamy documents, and there is no proven role for TCM in COVID. The tactics on display by the Chinese government are part of an ambitious strategy by the Chinese government to build the reputation of TCM as equal to “Western” medicine. Yes there are papers in the scientific literature that tout TCM. Regrettably, one of the biggest enablers and promoters of TCM outside China is the World Health Organization.
Bleach (when ingested)
I’ll set aside the more obvious warning about injecting disinfectant to mention a more pernicious quackery that has been around for some time. Chlorine dioxide is an industrial bleach product that has been promoted for years as a medical product. Branded as “Miracle Mineral Solution” or “MMS“, this blog has covered this quackery extensively. It is now being promoted as a COVID treatment by conspiracy theorists and grifters. The FDA has issued warning letters to vendors.
Colloidal silver
Colloidal silver has been covered previously at Science-Based Medicine. Silver is used medicinally in some drug products and devices, but when consumed will not have any beneficial antiviral properties. It can, however, turn you blue.
Chaga mushroom blends
I had a delicious tea today. It contained chaga mushrooms. I bought it for an alternative to all the coffee I’ve been drinking, and didn’t realize it’s also touted as some sort of anti-viral. Even for a fungi, chaga doesn’t look that attractive, and I gather it has a long history of unwarranted fame as some sort of health panacea (spoiler alert: probably not). While some manufacturers claim chaga will help with your immunity, there is no credible evidence to substantiate these claims.
Oil of oregano
Oil of oregano has been a perennial quack remedy for more than a decade. It is perhaps not surprising that it’s being positioned as an antiviral. Which I supposed it could be, if you dripped the oil directly on a virus. I get emails regularly touting how oil of oregano is effective, based on in vitro (petri dish) studies. But by that argument, drinking margaritas should be an effective COVID strategy, because alcohol-based hand sanitizers are indeed antiviral, when used properly. Doses matter. The delivery method matters. By consuming it, we dilute it, and it’s not going to have any meaningful effects. Save your oregano for your pizza.
Homeopathy
Homeopathy is the air guitar of medicine – it looks like a drug, but it’s usually just pure water (sometimes sprayed on little balls of sugar). Not surprisingly, it hasn’t been shown to be effective for any medical condition, except perhaps thirst. Despite its German origins, homeopathy is big in Cuba. Edzard Ernst noted that homeopathy is being given in Cuban eldercare facilities, apparently to protect against COVID infection.
Aquarium water (drinking it)
Despite a CBC story that cautions against it, I couldn’t find any other endorsements of this admittedly bizarre strategy. It may be referring to the consumption of the drug chloroquine which is sold for the treatment of various fish infections. Consumption can be fatal. Chloroquine is not the same as hydroxychloroquine, but both seem ineffective at treating COVID infections. See also the tonic water, below.
Zinc
Zinc has been touted as a cold remedy for decades, but the evidence supporting these claims is mixed. If it does work, the effectiveness is modest and side effects are common. A chiropractor made a video touting tonic water (see the next item) and zinc which apparently garnered 21 million views. There is no credible evidence to support the claim that zinc has any role in preventing or treating COVID infections.
Tonic water
This may be based on confusion between chloroquine (no evidence for COVID) and quinine, a completely distinct drug. Both have roots as anti-malarial medications but your more common exposure to quinine is the tiny amount added to tonic water. Interestingly, tonic water used to be medicinal, but there is no reason to expect that today’s tonic water will have any health benefits, unless you derive medicinal benefits from its combination with gin.
Chiropractic adjustments
Jann Bellamy covered this in a prior post. In some jurisdictions, regulators have taken action against chiropractors who are making claims about the effectiveness of chiropractic adjustments for preventing COVID infections. You can’t “boost” your immune system with chiropractic, or any other physical intervention, for that matter.
Elderberry
Harriet Hall blogged about this at the end of December 2019 (how long ago that feels now) and she felt the evidence for elderberry product was promising, but that more research was required. Like a lot of natural-based products, the active ingredient (if there is one) hasn’t been identified, and the products may not be free of side-effects. While some cold viruses are coronaviruses, there is no research that examines elderberry and COVID.
Juice fasting
Juice can be delicious but existing solely on juice sounds like some form of punishment. Depriving your body of a balanced diet isn’t a good idea even when there isn’t a pandemic. Why put your body at risk through dietary deficiencies?
Methanol
Drinking methanol is a bad idea for any reason. Methanol is not ethanol. This quackery has killed over 700 Iranians so far. If it doesn’t kill you, it may leave you blind.
What’s missing?
        ◦ The COVID-19 pandemic is evolving quickly, and I have no doubt that I am only scratching the surface of the implausible therapies being promoted to treat or prevent infections. Did I miss anything? Let me know in the comments. I’ll give a special SBM prize for the most bizarre, implausible COVID quackery someone can find.

ProtocolKills.com: Repackaging an old narrative about conventional medicine versus alternative medicine for COVID-19
Quacks claim that medicine, not the disease, kills, with their nostrums as the cure. ProtocolKills.com shows that victims and their families are often their best spokespeople because they are so sympathetic and questioning their testimonials is easily portrayed as attacking very sympathetic victims. Cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski used to do this, weaponizing his patients against any critics and using them as foot soldiers against legislators seeking to rein him in. Is the same thing happening with COVID-19?
David Gorski on April 24, 2023
Link

Back in February, I was wandering around the downtown of a nearby town where I had just gotten my hair cut, when I saw this in a shop near the barbershop:

I snapped the photo above, thinking that website advertised—ProtocolKills.com—looked like potential blog fodder for an SBM post, and then went about the rest of my day, filing the website in an overstuffed folder on my computer full of potential blog topics. As happens all too often, there it stayed—until today, when a reader sent me a link to the website and asked me about it. As I perused the website, my first thought was: “Too many videos. I’ll never have time to get through them and write about this.” Then I poked around more and saw that there were a number of anecdotes describing the supposed horrific treatments inflicted upon people with COVID-19, the consistent theme being that the COVID-19 victims whose stories were told on the website would have all been just fine if it hadn’t been for nefarious doctors pushing remdesivir, steroids, vaccines, ventilators, and other treatments. In other words, the consistent narrative of the website is that it was medicine, not COVID-19, that killed all the people whose stories are recounted on this website.
Unsurprisingly, I also immediately saw that the website promotes a lot of quackery for COVID-19, such as Miracle Mineral Solution (MMS), ivermectin, Hulda Clark’s parasite cleanse (now there’s a blast from the past!), and even colloidal silver! At the top of the page promoting COVID-19 quackery, there was what Dr. Peter Lipson once dubbed a quack Miranda warning:
After learning I had been poisoned with Remedesivir and Baracitinib, I knew I had to rid my body of these drugs and repair it myself. So, I researched and found many things that helped me recover drastically and I still use many of these daily or as needed. I don’t endorse any specific supplement brand but I do try to find the most reputable one. I am not a doctor and don’t recommend anything to anyone, these are things that helped me. Please contact a trusted health care professional or do your own research to decide what is best for selfcare.
Also at the bottom of every anecdote:
Any use of protocolkills.com- including implementation of any suggestions or stories on the site and/or use of any resources available on protocolkills.com does not create a professional relationship between that entity and protocolkills.com or any of it’s professionals.​All content on this site and corresponding blog is for informational purposes only. All stories and imagery published were granted permission by the author. All other unaffiliated sites must get explicit permission from the authors themselves to republish.
Where have we seen this before? Many times?
I knew then that I had to write about ProtocolKills.com this week, because it shows very well how much COVID-19 misinformation has adopted a very old narrative used by quacks of all varieties, in particular the cancer quacks that I have long written about (and used to write about a lot more often before the pandemic). Although the origin of such narratives can be difficult to trace, what is not difficult to figure out are who profits from such narratives and who are the victims. Unfortunately, as I used to discuss routinely with the case of cancer quack Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski and Robert O. Young, often the victims become the most vocal and sympathetic evangelists and pitchmen for this quackery. This is why I realize that it is very likely that I will be attacked as callous and heartless for pointing out that what is being promoted on ProtocolKills.com is quackery and suggesting that the patients described died of COVID-19 rather than the protocol used to treat them. My preemptive response now is, as it has always been, that I empathize with patients and families who are suffering, especially those who die prematurely of a disease like COVID-19 (or cancer or anything else). However, that empathy and sympathy do not stop me from trying to point out how their stories do not necessarily support their conclusions and thereby hopefully inoculate others who might be susceptible to the alternative medicine that they promote in their narratives with a healthy prebunking.
“It’s the treatment, not the disease, that kills!”
If there’s one thing that the COVID-19 pandemic has taught me is that certain narratives in the denial of science-based medicine and the ineffective treatments that flow from that denial are eternal. It’s not just the conspiracy theories, either, although they are very important. I still argue that all antivaccine messaging is in some way yoked to what I like to call the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, indeed that all science denial is a form of conspiracy theory. However, the narratives that link to those conspiracy theories are also very old and, although protean in their manifestations, still remain recognizable. Some of you have probably gotten tired of me saying things like “In the age of the pandemic, everything old is new again” and “There’s nothing new in antivaxland” over and over during the last three years or so, but it’s really true, and my repetition tends to be for educational and skeptical purposes. After all, once you become familiar with the common narratives behind quackery and antivaccine pseudoscience, you will start to see them everywhere among the “new schoolers” spreading misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines and COVID-19 itself, as well as the quacks who prey on them. Examples include the ideas that vaccines: somehow change your DNA (which predates COVID-19) to make you somehow different from human (e.g., “transhumanism”); are deadlier than the disease; are part of a “depopulation agenda”; contain “fetal tissue” or DNA; are full of toxins; produce immunity that is much inferior to “natural” immunity after infection; and sterilize our girls and women. (Let’s also not forget the idea that the virus was created in a lab or that it isn’t deadly.)
It isn’t just antivaccine messaging, either. One narrative common to both antivaccine messaging and to many forms of pseudomedicine is the idea that medicine is more deadly than the disease. Basically, this is the idea that the disease isn’t what kills, but rather the medical interventions to treat the disease. While it is undeniably true that there have been (and still exist) medical treatments whose benefits are marginal and/or whose risks arguably outweigh the benefits, that is not what I’m talking about. What I’m talking about is, for example, this sort of narrative, starting with one of the first such cartoons I ever came across:
Then, of course, there’s Mike Adams pushing the same narrative:

Notice any similarities? The narrative is that conventional medicine is not interested in curing the patient but instead promotes toxic—and profitable!—treatments, while rejecting “nontoxic” natural treatments that work miraculously. As I will keep emphasizing, this is a very old narrative, too:

Indeed, the narrative consists of three key parts:
     1.  The disease is not deadly and/or it is the treatment, not the disease, that kills patients. One might remember that Robert O. Young went beyond claiming that treatment is more deadly than the disease by claiming that the cancerous tumor itself is the body’s effort to remove the true cause of the cancer. It’s also the same idea behind German New Medicine and its bastard offspring Biologie Totale. (Young also claimed that sepsis doesn’t exist.)
     2.  There exist nontoxic (often “natural”) alternatives to conventional medicine. Examples for cancer include Hulda Clark’s parasite cleanses, MMS, Stanislaw Burzynski’s antineoplastons. For COVID-19, examples include hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, zinc, and the various “early treatment” protocols promoted by quack groups like Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance. (FLCCC)
     3.  “They” are trying to cover it all up: how toxic and ineffective “conventional medicine” is and the existence of nontoxic and highly effective “natural alternatives.” Often woven in the anecdotes will be stories about how the patient recovered on the unproven treatment, only to relapse when he couldn’t get it anymore.
You don’t even have to look past the photo above to see the elements of the story in just the shopkeeper’s narrative, with cold, uncaring physicians and nurses rejecting her efforts to save her husband—who was improving on ivermectin!—and forced him to be treated with steroids.
Anecdotes with a familiar message
My first inclination was to try to find the story in the poster. Searching for the names of the doctors on the website using Google Advanced Search didn’t return anything; so I tried searching for the hospital, Beaumont (now, unfortunately, rechristened since a merger as “CoreWell Health,” perhaps the most boringly corporate name for a hospital that I’ve ever seen) and only came up with one entry, for which the name did not match the name of the shop owner, nor did the husband’s name match her husband’s name. The two men were roughly the same age (one was 39, the other 41); both had a similar appearance (bearded, although the shopkeeper’s husband was cleanshaven in a couple of the photos). Their stories also appeared to be from around the same time late 2021/early 2022), during the Omicron surge, which, not-so-coincidentally, was around the same time that the promotion of ivermectin as a COVID-19 cure was hitting its peak. I did ultimately find a GoFundMe for the shopkeeper, but decided to stick with stories on the ProtocolKills.com website, starting with Kyle and Sarah because it was the story that the search for Beaumont returned.
Here’s part of the narrative after Kyle had fallen ill with COVID-19 pneumonia:
Kyle fell ill on 11/7/21 and was admitted to the hospital on 11/15/21 for “COVID” pneumonia. He was mistreated and refused potentially life-saving medications when he was in their death camp. He was prescribed Ivermectin and azithromycin by a telehealth doctor that we contacted because we were afraid of the horror stories we heard about what was going on inside the hospitals. We had a difficult time finding a pharmacy that would fill the Ivermectin prescription. Kyle started complaining that he was having a little bit of difficulty taking a full breath. I ordered a pulse ox machine online and made an appointment for urgent care in hopes to get some steroids. At home, his oxygen was 84-94%. When my husband arrived at the appointment the next day, his blood oxygen level was 91%. The urgent care staff told him they couldn’t treat him, that he needed to go to the emergency room, he was hypoxic.
Right from the start, you see the narrative. Sarah describes the hospital as a “death camp.” She and her husband found a telehealth doctor to prescribe him ivermectin (which doesn’t work) and azithromycin (of note, part of the hydroxychloroquine-azithromycin protocol promoted by Didier Raoult in early 2020 that resulted in a number of “miracle dure” testimonials). I couldn’t help but wonder if it had been one of America’s Frontline Doctors (another COVID quack group) that had been busted for running a telehealth ivermectin prescription mill, but they had been busted a couple of months before Kyle fell ill.
The story continues with Kyle being admitted to the hospital because he was hypoxic and his chest X-ray showed signs of an atypical pneumonia consistent with COVID-19 pneumonia. He was apparently not tested for COVID-19 at that time, with Sarah doubting that he actually had COVID-19 because of the lack of testing. However, I point out that the chest X-ray appearance of COVID-19 pneumonia can be so characteristic as to be diagnostic. Sarah and Kyle wanted him to get monoclonal antibodies, which, I suspect, were refused because most existing monoclonal antibodies then had lost their ability to neutralize SARS-CoV-2 because of the rise of the Omicron variant.
In any event, Kyle became more hypoxic, and, according to the account, doctors urged him to take remdesivir, an antiviral authorized for use against COVID-19 that is a prodrug converted by the body into a drug that interferes with the action of viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and evades proofreading by viral exoribonuclease, while correctly (in my opinion) refusing to give him ivermectin, which, as I’ve discussed many times here, does not work against COVID-19:
They refused to give monoclonal antibodies because now they were telling him he was too sick to get them. We asked about him taking his prescription for Ivermectin and they refused to let him take it and somehow talked him out of it (I wasn’t allowed in so I’m not sure exactly how that went down, but he was very afraid to take it after talking to the doctors.) They just continued to try and convince him to take the Remdesivir. The night of the 17th, after talking to many staff members and every single one of them convincing him that he would get worse, he was coerced and feared into accepting the Remdesivir. The doctors also refused to give Kyle inhaled steroids stating that they don’t give breathing treatments to COVID patients because it “spews COVID particles everywhere.” They were adamant, it was their way or the highway.
A recent Cochrane review suggests that inhaled steroids might be useful in mild COVID-19 but evidence was lacking for severe COVID-19, with an NIH consensus statement concluding that for hospitalized adults with COVID-19 there “is insufficient evidence for the Panel to recommend either for or against the use of inhaled corticosteroids for the treatment of COVID-19 in these patients.” Given the lack of evidence that inhaled steroids work in hospitalized COVID-19 patients, it was not at all unreasonable not to use them for the reasons stated above. Also, he was already apparently already on intravenous steroids. (Steroids are mentioned later as a cause of his white blood cell count going up.)
The story continues:
At this point, I was getting very sick and tired of the nonsense going on and I brought to the attention of the attending that they never tested Kyle for COVID and insisted that they tested him in hopes that it would come back negative and I can visit and help advocate for my husband. On 11/23/21, unfortunately, his test was still positive for COVID. BUT they already had him “enrolled” in their deathly COVID treatment plan and actually completed the whole course of Remdesivir before they even tested him! WOW! Kyle’s oxygen requirements started to increase as the days went on and his white blood cell count was rising, daily, consistently. I asked about a potential infection and they told me the white blood cell count was going up due to the steroids. On 11/26/21 Kyle told me and the staff that he was having chest and back pain and they gave him Tylenol. I could tell he was working harder to breathe or perhaps harder to breathe against the high flow oxygen he was on?!
Whatever treatments Kyle was or was not receiving, this story is an all-too-familiar one to ICU doctors who treated scores of COVID-19 patients during the various surges since the pandemic hit. His clinical course as related sounds entirely consistent with deterioration due to COVID-19 pneumonia, including what later happened when he suffered the complication of a pneumothorax and required a chest tube. This suggested to me that he required high positive end-expiratory pressure, PEEP, to maintain oxygenation, which can definitely result in a pneumothorax. It’s a delicate balancing act that ICU physicians have to do with such patients: not enough PEEP and they can’t maintain oxygenation, but too much PEEP can result in a pneumothorax. Often there is no choice but to use as much PEEP as needed and accept the risk of pneumothorax. It’s not that doctors want to see patients get pneumothoraces or that they don’t care. They’re just trying their damnedest to balance risk and benefit.
The rest of Kyle’s hospital course, even filtered through the anecdote as told by his widow, is also sadly familiar to critical care doctors and infectious disease specialists. Kyle developed a bacterial pneumonia requiring antibiotics, as well as other complications, such as renal failure, the latter of which his wife blamed exclusively on remdesivir, even though COVID-19 and/or sepsis would be more likely culprits. He required increasing amounts of respiratory support, leading his wife to complain about his being in the prone position and how she kept urging them to wean his ventilator settings. Per her telling, they would do so successfully while she was around and then put the ventilator settings right back up overnight, when she wasn’t. Instead of medical need, she attributes this behavior to malign intent:
Every day was trying to wean sedation, paralytic, etc (not one thing at a time), & whenever he wouldn’t tolerate those changes or wasn’t ready for them, his oxygen would drop and they would crank everything back to the max. It was a seemingly never-ending cycle of never making progress, and never getting off the ventilator. They were setting him up for failure, every single day.
And:
When I would leave at night, they did whatever they wanted (most times) and everything would always go wrong when I wasn’t there. When the doctors listened to me about trying to wean one thing at a time (specifically the FIO2 on the vent) he was able to get his oxygen requirements down to 70%. By morning it was back up to 100%, full vent support.
This, too, will sound very familiar to critical care doctors trying to wean severely ill COVID-19 patients from very high settings on the ventilator and failing. Moreover, I actually sympathize with Sarah’s feeling of a loss of control that comes when forced to leave a loved one for the night when they are ill and in the hospital. I’ve had that experience, and it might even be worse for a physician because as physicians we know a lot more. That being said, Kyle’s story comes across to me as more consistent with his having contracted very severe COVID-19 and then suffering an all-too-familiar cascade of complications as a result, with steroids and remdesivir failing to reverse his deterioration. The same appears true of the man in the poster in the shop window, judging from the GoFundMe account, with the husband reportedly deteriorating sometime after the administration of remdesivir, his wife noting that after “he was given a medication we demanded he NOT receive, his health quickly went downhill,” leading him to be “on a ventilator working most of the time at 100%” and on dialysis three times a week.
While it is true that remdesivir can cause renal impairment, causing grade 3/4 decreased kidney function in 2%-19% of patients and it is even possible that in this case it did just that, the far more likely explanation is that COVID-19, the sepsis that occurred after the COVID-associated bacterial pneumonia, and his cardiovascular and pulmonary collapse were the primary causes of his renal failure. To put it more simply, it is possible that remdesivir contributed to his renal failure, but that is not to say that remdesivir killed him. Again, it’s far more likely that remdesivir—along with everything else that modern medicine can offer—failed to save him, as it unfortunately did for more than a million other Americans over the last three years.
One of the earliest stories featured was that of the founder of this website, Greta Crawford, from October 2021, where she noted:
Everyone in my family got Covid. but I was the only one to go to the ER. Their Protocol nearly killed me, not Covid.
That is about as succinct a statement of the narrative about conventional medicine, that it is the treatment, not the disease, that kills (or nearly kills). Unfortunately, Crawford’s experience is what it is to be one of the minority who suffer severe disease from COVID-19 or the even smaller minority who die. It seems unfair and random to those who become deathly ill when most do not, and it is! Unfortunately, that is how diseases work. Just because the rest of your family did fine after catching COVID-19 is no guarantee that you will if you catch it.
I’ll make one more analogy. Those who, for example, believe in Stanislaw Burzynski’s antineoplastons often claim that it was chemotherapy, not the cancer, that killed their loved ones when they couldn’t get antineoplaston therapy. In this analogy, though, chemotherapy is far more toxic than remdesivir and does, on occasion, actually lead to the deaths of cancer patients before their cancer can, either through immunosuppression and opportunistic infection or other complications. (Some chemotherapy agents can injure the heart, for instance.) Nothing in medicine is perfect, and every effective treatment involves a risk-benefit calculation. When used appropriately, chemotherapy will cure some cancers and increase the chance of surviving others after surgery and other treatments, but there are risks. Similarly, as was the case for ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine testimonials, the timeline between use of the unproven drug and clinical improvement was often too fast to be believable or consistent with coincidence.
I thought about discussing other anecdotes, but they all take similar forms to the one I discussed, although the end result is not always death but rather injury and a patient out for “justice.” Instead, I’ll finish with the conspiracy theory at the heart of this website.
The most powerful promoters of alternative medicine
There is a section on the website called Hospital Protocols that attributes all the harm to malice. I saw elements of this conspiracy theory in Crawford’s account, where she spends considerable time complaining that it is “all about the vaccines,” at one point saying, “My Pulmonologist came in daily to harass me, and scare me into taking the vax.” At the end of her account, she writes:
The evil don’t need Covid concentration death camps we have them in the form of hospitals now. Instead of dragging people and forcing them into camps, the people willing go under the guise they will be healed from a man-made virus. A virus created/funded by the same man that has financial interests in the drug Remdesivir. Drugs like HCQ and Ivermectin have been banned and hospital protocols only allow unproven novelty drugs and ventilators that kill. Corruption is everywhere, having faith in God allows us to stand up against corruption and relinquish fears. Faith over fear. Do not comply.
Shades of “Cut! Burn! Poison!” indeed!
Under Hospital Protocols, she argues that genocide is the reason “why hospitals kill”:
Unvaxxed and those receiving a form of government monthly payment are targets. Freethinkers and those that can lessen the financial failures of the government need to be removed. The elderly, the disabled, those on Medicare, the uneducated, those with previous conditions, the poor, and the unvaxxed are targets for this mass genocide.
Why? From what I can tell, she thinks the reason is profit, mostly:
The first wave of Covid was presented in mainstream media as the worst pandemic in history with unprecedented death rates. We later found out from hospitals and nurses that this was not true and in fact, hospitals were nearly empty with nurses and doctors filling their time with tic tok dance videos. So when the second round, or the “Delta Variant”, came about, something had to change.​The Delta Variant just happened to coincide with the vaccine distribution. Although kept quiet, it is known that many vaxxed patients end up in the hospital with reactions to the shot. One thing that had to be done to keep this pandemic in play was to increase the actual death count of patients. Aside from going to citizens’ homes and outright murdering them, the easiest way was to have them walk into the hospitals where trusted doctors could administer poison to each victim.
Even though the vax has caused deaths and injuries that are suppressed or not reported, many people are now aware and not willing to get the shot. The government is able to scare the public into believing that Covid is deadly by paying hospitals to kill off patients. Then doctors and hospitals proclaim that the unvaxxed are the ones dying and everyone needs to receive the shot to survive. The truth is the unvaxxed are targeted for death by the hospitals and the hospitals don’t report that just as many vaxxed are hospitalized and dying as well.
There are simple ways to combat Covid at home with drugs like Ivermectin, HCQ, Budesonide, even CBD. These known, effective treatments are being suppressed so that patients will be forced to go to hospitals and ultimately murdered.​Through Remdesivir, paralytic drugs, and ventilators, the hospitals knowingly put patients to death so they can earn money and increase the fear of Covid.
Dr. Jonathan Howard has discussed extensively the myth and conspiracy theory that COVID-19 wasn’t that deadly and that hospitals were “empty.” The reason was that elective surgeries and treatments had been canceled, and he also noted that emergency rooms, ICUs, and COVID-19 wards were far from empty. As for the rest, that is some Mike Adams-level conspiracy mongering there, with the government supposedly wanting more people to die and using the vaccine to accomplish this, all for purposes of…control? This, supposedly after considering whether to go into the homes of citizens to murder them.
To this end, the site warns of various tactics, including PCR tests to diagnose you with a supposedly benign “disease,” refusal to retest because they “want to get paid for Covid deaths,” pushing vaccines, financial incentives for “the protocol” from the government, promoting premature use of “deadly” ventilators, and the usual litany of COVID-19 conspiracy theories. Elsewhere on the site, recommended “leaders” listed include antivax icons like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and COVID-19 quacks like Dr. Zev Zelenko (now deceased) and Dr. Mary Talley Bowden.
Long ago when discussing cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski, I noted that the families of his patients—even family of the ones who died (particularly of the ones who died)—were his most powerful weapon. The reason is that they believed whole-heartedly either that their loved ones would have been saved if only they could have accessed Burzynski’s antineoplastons or that the reason their loved ones died was because they only got antineoplastons too late because their oncologists had put up every roadblock and refused to work with Burzynski. Because they had suffered the tragedy of the death of a loved one or dealing with a child with a deadly cancer, they were, in essence, untouchable as far as criticism goes. Indeed, when I discussed testimonials related to patients of Stanislaw Burzynski and other cancer quacks and how those testimonials did not support the cancer quack’s claims of incredible efficacy for their nostrums, I frequently came under attack as being callous and uncaring. I even once had a Burzynski patient report me to my state medical board for having discussed her case on my blog based on her public postings on Facebook and other social media.
With that background it was with some trepidation that I ultimately decided to discuss ProtocolKills.com and the sorts of anecdotes and testimonials there. I will conclude by emphasizing just how similar the overall vibe of this website is to the vibe that I used to encounter routinely on websites devoted to extolling Stanislaw Burzynski, Robert O. Young, and other cancer quacks, which finally led me to decide to chance writing about it, if only to demonstrate the constants in narratives about alternative medicine and antivaccine claims. Indeed, it’s not just cancer quacks. In fact, the vibe of ProtocolKills.com is perhaps more similar to the vibe that I used to find on antivaccine blogs and websites extolling miraculous claims for “autism biomed” quackery, where parents who mistakenly believe that the “medical-industrial complex” and vaccine manufacturers had intentionally given their children autism in order to profit from vaccines. In all of these narratives, nefarious forces are at best indifferent to the “collateral damage” falsely attributed to science-based conventional treatments and at worst actively murderous, even to the point of genocide or “depopulation.” Also common to all narratives is the belief that “they” are actively suppressing highly effective and “alternative” treatments.
The problem for those of us trying to defend science-based medicine from such narratives is that those who mistakenly view themselves or family members as “victims” of vaccines, chemotherapy, COVID-19 treatments, ventilators, or other conventional medical treatments are, in fact, victims, just not in the way that they think. In reality, they are victims of the quacks and grifters who promote false narratives that cancer and COVID-19, for example, are curable with nontoxic natural treatments and that conventional treatments like chemotherapy for cancer and remdesivir and supportive care like ventilators for COVID-19 are what really resulted in the deaths of their loved ones, not the diseases themselves, while “They” (doctors, the government, big pharma, vaccine manufacturers, public health officials, etc.) are trying to “hide” The Truth (with a capital T) of the deadliness of their interventions, based on nefarious motives. The conspiracy theories are about as obvious as obvious can be, but they believe them.
They are also incredibly effective ambassadors for the alternativ medicine interventions they promote and the conspiracy theories behind them for obvious reasons. Because they or their relatives are also victims of a deadly disease like cancer or COVID-19 or parents who have a very difficult time dealing with a child with a neurodevelopmental disorder, survivors or surviving family members of the deceased are very sympathetic, and their ironclad belief in alternative medicine is that much more persuasive. This is no less true of those who lost loved ones—like a husband—to COVID-19 than it was (and still is) for those who lost children to cancer. Those of us who labor to explain why their anecdotes and testimonials do not support the narrative of deadly conventional medicine compared to nontoxic miracle “cures” like ivermectin for COVID-19 or antineoplastons for cancer are thus very easily cast as the villains attacking very sympathetic people, no matter how respectful and empathetic we try to be about it. Quacks know that, which is why they realize that these survivors and surviving family members are their most persuasive and untouchable allies.
Same as it ever was, unfortunately. The diseases might change, but the tactics, narratives, and conspiracy theories of quacks do not.

ProtocolKills.com: Misinformed refusal on steroids
Back in the day, I used to refer to something I dubbed “misinformed refusal,” a term that refers to how antivaxxers had weaponized “informed consent” by inverting it to frighten parents against vaccinated. In the age of the pandemic, ProtocolKills.com generalizes misinformed refusal to all COVID-19 treatments with the help of “hospital hostage negotiator” Laura Bartlett, who views COVID-19 treatments in hospitals as “holding patients hostage” and provides an “informed consent template” that refuses remdesivir, intubation, and other COVID-19 interventions.
David Gorski on May 8, 2023
Link

A couple of weeks ago, I wrote about ProtocolKills.com, a website and effort started by a woman named Greta Crawford in order to “inform”—misinform, actually—the public about the supposed dangers of hospital protocols to treat COVID-19 and how hospitals, not COVID-19, had killed so many people and almost killed her, a conclusion that she came to seemingly because everyone in her family caught COVID-19 but she was the only one who was hospitalized with serious illness from it. Basically, a large part of the website includes anecdotes from COVID-19 patients who became severely ill and were hospitalized (or their surviving family members if they didn’t make it), all complaining about how doctors and hospitals wouldn’t treat them or their loved ones with ivermectin or any other unproven/disproven treatment or quackery and how intubation, remdesivir, intubation, and everything else about conventional medicine, not COVID-19, had harmed them or killed their loved ones. Indeed, I had become aware of the website when I saw this poster in a shop window near the barber shop where I had just gotten a haircut:

I try to be as empathetic as I can when seeing stories like these. After all, I’ve lost family members over the course of my life, and I know how painful it is. I also understand that it is a very human trait to want to blame something. If you’re antivaccine and didn’t protect yourself or your loved one against an infectious disease like COVID-19, then there’s likely an element of guilt as well, whether acknowledged or unacknowledged. It’s therefore only natural to look for another cause to blame, and, given how horrible it is to be an ICU patient on a ventilator, particularly a COVID-19 patient who requires chemical paralyzation, sedation, and prone positioning, as well as many invasive procedures, such as chest tubes, central lines, and more. Add to that the isolation procedures in the early part of the pandemic, in which patients all too often died alone, family members unable to visit and lend some comfort. I’ll even admit that during the first year of the pandemic, the possibility that I could end up paralyzed on a ventilator and possibly meet my end that way terrified me, as did the possibility of a loved one ending up this way. So I get it. To some extent, I get it. I also understand that those whose stories are featured on ProtocolKills.com website will likely react very negatively to my characterization of the site. Unfortunately, treatments such as Hulda Clark’s zapper, colloidal silver, and MMS are pure quackery, and if you promote quackery I am going to call it that.
Again, the consistent theme on this website that the COVID-19 victims whose stories were told on the website would have all recovered completely if it hadn’t been for nefarious doctors pushing remdesivir, steroids, vaccines, ventilators, and other treatments. In other words, the consistent narrative of the website is that it was medicine, not COVID-19, that killed all the people whose stories are recounted on this website. As I described, it is a consistent theme of quackery, particularly cancer quackery, which often claims that it is chemotherapy, not cancer, that kills. Unsurprisingly, ProtocolKills.com is also antivaccine as hell, with many of the anecdotes complaining about doctors “pushing vaccines.” Unsurprisingly, the website promotes a lot of quackery for COVID-19, such as Miracle Mineral Solution (MMS), ivermectin, Hulda Clark’s parasite cleanse, and even colloidal silver.
I only alluded to it briefly in my previous post, but there’s more to ProtocolKills.com than just the stories blaming conventional medicine for COVID-19 deaths and harm. I had meant to come back to this website, and yesterday morning I saw the perfect excuse. Quack tycoon Joe Mercola featured the founders of ProtcolKills.com and its accompanying websites HospitalHostageHelp.com and OurPatientRights.com in an interview, along with an article promoting their efforts. Given that Mercola’s grift now involves leaving his articles live for only 48 hours before moving them to his Substack so that they can only be accessed by paying subscribers, I thought today would be the best day to write about ProtocolKills.com again. Mercola portrays them as heroes in his title How to Save Your Life and Those You Love When Hospitalized, and, Mercola being Mercola, generalizes it beyond COVID-19 by listing as one of his bullet points:
Laura Bartlett and Greta Crawford have founded an organization to address the forced treatments patients receive when they’re hospitalized for COVID-19, but the same strategy can be used to protect yourself against other medical hazards as well
Because of course he did.
Misinformed refusal, not “informed consent”
Before I discuss the purpose of all these testimonials on ProtocolKills.com, let me briefly recap a key concept, that of informed consent. Informed consent, of course, is one of those medical principles that is akin to Mom, apple pie, and the American flag in terms of being viewed as a Good Thing. Here’s a brief description of what informed consent is:
Informed consent is the process in which a health care provider educates a patient about the risks, benefits, and alternatives of a given procedure or intervention. The patient must be competent to make a voluntary decision about whether to undergo the procedure or intervention. Informed consent is both an ethical and legal obligation of medical practitioners in the US and originates from the patient’s right to direct what happens to their body. Implicit in providing informed consent is an assessment of the patient’s understanding, rendering an actual recommendation, and documentation of the process. The Joint Commission requires documentation of all the elements of informed consent “in a form, progress notes or elsewhere in the record.” The following are the required elements for documentation of the informed consent discussion: (1) the nature of the procedure, (2) the risks and benefits and the procedure, (3) reasonable alternatives, (4) risks and benefits of alternatives, and (5) assessment of the patient’s understanding of elements 1 through 4.
It is the obligation of the provider to make it clear that the patient is participating in the decision-making process and avoid making the patient feel forced to agree to with the provider. The provider must make a recommendation and provide their reasoning for said recommendation.
In addition, there are exceptions to the paradigm above that mainly occur in situations in which a patient is incapacitated or otherwise unable to participate in the process and make an informed decision:
Several exceptions to the requirement for informed consent include (1) the patient is incapacitated, (2) life-threatening emergencies with inadequate time to obtain consent, and (3) voluntary waived consent. If the patient’s ability to make decisions is questioned or unclear, an evaluation by a psychiatrist to determine competency may be requested. A situation may arise in which a patient cannot make decisions independently but has not designated a decision-maker. In this instance, the hierarchy of decision-makers, which is determined by each state’s laws, must be sought to determine the next legal surrogate decision-maker. If this is unsuccessful, a legal guardian may need to be appointed by the court.
Informed consent is a bedrock principle of patient autonomy, based on the idea that a competent adult can accept or refuse any medical intervention after being informed of the rationale, risks, and benefits.
All physicians are familiar with informed consent, but especially surgeons (like me) and other proceduralists, who have to obtain informed consent from the patient before every procedure performed. In general, we have to explain the rationale, the expected benefits, potential complications or harms, and alternatives to the proposed procedure. In the case of breast surgery, this discussion can take quite a while, and I document it in the note documenting the initial patient consultation in addition to having the patient sign the hospital’s informed consent form.
Or:
Obtaining informed consent in medicine is process that should include: (1) describing the proposed intervention, (2) emphasizing the patient’s role in decision-making, (3) discussing alternatives to the proposed intervention, (4) discussing the risks of the proposed intervention and (5) eliciting the patient’s preference (usually by signature). Discussion of all risks is paramount to informed consent in this context. Most consent includes general risks, risks specific to the procedure, risks of no treatment and alternatives to treatment. Additionally, many consent forms express that there are no guarantees that the proposed procedure will provide a cure to the problem being addressed.
Since long before the pandemic hit, antivaxxers have actively worked to turn the principle of informed consent on its head by emphasizing it as a reason to refuse vaccines. In brief, they massively exaggerate the potential harms (and make a number of such harms up out of whole cloth) while simultaneously downplaying or denying the efficacy of vaccines in preventing the diseases against which they are targeted. The idea is to present a false picture of the true risk-benefit ratio of the vaccines to the point that any competent reasonable adult who believes the false risk-benefit ratio presented by the antivaccine narrative would be foolish to agree to receive the vaccine or let their child receive it. That’s why when I first wrote about antivaxxers and informed consent in 2010, I referred to what antivaxxers do with informed consent as “misinformed consent,” but then I realized that a more accurate term for it as “misinformed refusal.” That is the term I have used ever since.
Antivaxxers used to be the group that most prominently and aggressively used misinformed refusal as a tactic and argument to discourage people from accepting vaccination, but it was a narrative that cancer quacks also used. As you will see, ProtocolKills.com and HospitalHostageHelp.com expand the concept of misinformed refusal to all science-based COVID-19 interventions, and Joe Mercola just amplified it to his millions of readers.
Misinformed refusal on steroids for COVID-19
Let’s see what Joe Mercola has to say about Laura Bartlett and Greta Crawford. Crawford, as you recall, is the founder of ProtocolKills.com; while Bartlett appears to have started what she calls the Hospital Hostage Hotline after having met Crawford. Because Mercola sunsets his articles to his paid Substack 48 hours after they are published (which means that by sometime tomorrow morning his article will be gone), I will quote generously. I have also saved a copy of the article as a PDF. The interview is nearly an hour and a half long, but fortunately there’s a printed transcript, as I don’t have time to watch. Right at the beginning of the interview, Mercola states that the informed consent misinformed refusal templates being promoted by Crawford and Bartlett were based on the Jehovah’s Witness templates for refusing blood and blood products.
First, here’s Mercola with his usual false equivalence:
Welcome everyone. Dr. Mercola, helping you take control of your health. And today we’re going to dive deep into how to protect yourself from one of the highest contributors to the likelihood of you dying prematurely, which is going into the hospital for conventional medical care. We’ve already been well-established. In fact, I was the person who promoted this meme in July of 2000. Not 2020, 2000 – 23 years ago, literally, that doctors are the third leading cause of death. And one of the ways they’re able to do this is to – well, there’s so many ways, but one of the ways is the hospital. And I mean, thank God we have hospitals. They are enormous healing centers and they have saved, no doubt in my mind, millions and millions of people’s lives as a result of that. But they’ve also killed at least that many, I would think.
So, the key here is to understand what the dangers are and take proactive measures to guard yourself and your family, because the issue is, it’s going to be your family members most likely, not even you, that is going to need to know this information. And when you’re in the hospital, you’re not going to be able to do squat because you’re potentially in a coma. And you have to have someone understand this so they can navigate through the system and successfully rescue you from a premature terminal event. So exciting, powerful information. You definitely want to bookmark this and keep it around because you will invariably need it at some time in the future.
The false equivalence is, of course, the claim that hospitals have “killed at least as many” patients as they have saved. Indeed, Mercola’s claim that “one of the highest contributors to the likelihood of you dying prematurely” is “going into the hospital for conventional medical care” is classic quack narrative, in which hospitals and medicine are portrayed as incredibly dangerous, a narrative that goes back to the 1970s and Dr. Robert Mendelsohn’s book Confessions of a Medical Heretic and likely much earlier. It’s a narrative that portrays medicine as a religion and hospitals as temples where patients are sacrificed to that religion. In this, ProtocolKills.com and HospitalHostageHelp.com are doing nothing more than updating an old quack narrative for COVID-19. Consistent with how medical misinformation has been amped up to 11 since the pandemic hit, in this narrative hospitals are now not just killing centers but killing centers that hold you hostage and force you to accept dangerous and ineffective COVID-19 treatments that kill, after taking advantage of people so critically ill with COVID-19 that they have to be on ventilators (which are killing machines, too), sedated and paralyzed, while the families are kept out.
Like all good conspiracy theories, there is a germ of truth that is twisted to serve the conspiracy. In this case, it’s the way that the pandemic forced hospitals to keep most loved ones out in order to protect staff and patients from outside infection. This imperative led to untold numbers of patients dying truly horrible deaths, able only to see their families on iPads or phones. While it is possible, in retrospect, to wonder if hospitals needed to be so strict, one must also remember the shortage of personal protective equipment (PPE)—including N95 masks, gowns, gloves—and how overwhelmed the staff were in so many hospitals due to the waves of critically ill patients for whom they were caring. Reasonable discussion and analysis of what we did right and what we did wrong is not what Mercola and his interviewees are about, however. Using the chaotic hospital conditions, particularly during the first year of the pandemic when vaccines were not available, to portray COVID-19 patients as hostages being forced to undergo dangerous and ineffective treatments—while, of course, being denied the nontoxic effective treatments like ivermectin that “They” don’t want you to know about—is what they are about.
Greta Crawford starts the narrative:
Well, my name is Greta Crawford and I started a website and created a website called ProtocolKills.com. This came after I was in the hospital with COVID. My family got COVID, but unfortunately, I was the one that went to the hospital. In the process of going to the hospital, I was denied informed consent and was completely unaware of some of the things they were doing to me. I was given five rounds of remdesivir, which nearly took my life and did not even know that I was being poisoned at the time.
Mercola asks her if she has long term kidney damage as a result, to which Crawford replies:
I actually do not. I’ve done a lot of detox. Every day, I do detox and a lot of prayer. And I don’t feel that I’ve had any type of damage. I feel okay right now. But as far as getting things checked out by a medical doctor, I have not done that yet. But right now, I’m leaning more on my faith.
So, but during the time in the hospital, I went from thinking I was going to go home after I got oxygen to actually feeling like that I was going to die. I was almost certain I was going to die after being given just the first dose of remdesivir. Again, once I got out of the hospital, I realized what had happened to me and the constant push for the vaccine in the hospital, the harassment for not getting vaxxed, and the fact that I was given medication without my knowledge at all, which led me to start the website to not only inform people about what was going on, but a platform to allow other victims who were not as fortunate as me. Many of them, the majority of them, did not make it out alive.
And so, it’s a platform for them to share their story. We have over 250 stories on there about what they faced in the hospital, and we really wanted to get this information out there to the public, but we also wanted to give a solution, not just to scare people. And that’s where I ended up meeting Laura. And Laura, you can take it from there.
Actually, the majority did make it out alive; that is, if you count all hospitalized COVID-19 patients. It is, however, true that the mortality of patients who required mechanical ventilation was greater than 50%, but only a minority of patients were ill enough to require mechanical ventilation. Basically, just like critical pulmonary illness before COVID-19, if your lungs are injured enough that you can’t breathe on your own without a ventilator, it’s a marker for severe disease and a much higher likelihood of dying.
The interesting thing is that Bartlett started out as an advocate of inhaled steroids to treat COVID-19:
And so, before I met Greta at the beginning of COVID, early 2020, I started helping my brother, Dr. Richard Bartlett, who had a protocol utilizing budesonide, inhaled budesonide steroid, as part of his protocol to treat COVID early. And we also found it very effective once people were in the hospital to help reverse the COVID, and also the scarring of the lungs and the inflammation of the lungs. And even people on ventilators were able to – not all, but there are instances where it even helped people who were on ventilators long as 30 days come off the ventilator and go home. So, I was helping him get that message out early 2020. I’m not a doctor. I’m not a nurse. I’m just somebody who could help get that known around the world. My background is in media PR.
And so, he asked me if I could help him and I did. And within 24 hours of him asking, we had a local story, a local affiliate in West Texas cover it. And then it just – he went viral on YouTube with one interview in Dallas. And I was just tasked with helping him get the message out. And in the process, people who knew my brother, knew me, started reaching out to both of us with stories that they were in the hospital and they were having a hard time getting the doctor to respect their right to informed consent. It was an overwhelming number of instances where people just felt like they were being bullied or coerced, that their right to try budesonide, for instance, was just dismissed.
Of course, steroids, both intravenous and inhaled, were widely used early in the pandemic. As I liked to point out at the time, the question of whether using steroids in acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), of which COVID-19 viral pneumonia is an example, has been a longstanding question in critical care medicine, one that intensivists used to debate back when I was a surgical resident in the 1990s. These days, a recent meta-analysis suggests that that steroids results in a modest benefit in the treatment of non-COVID ARDS, although “questions still remain regarding the dosage, optimal corticosteroid agent, and treatment duration in patients with ARDS.” As for COVID-19, a viral pneumonia, it was less clear whether steroids would be beneficial given their immunosuppressive effect, which could theoretically worsen the infection. No benefit was seen in COVID-19 ARDS. The authors note this while contrasting their result with current recommendations:
The effect of corticosteroid treatment is different between non-COVID-19 and COVID-19 patients. In non-COVID-19 ARDS patients, corticosteroids can reduce mortality in the experimental group, while no improvements in mortality were observed in patients with COVID-19. Similar results were obtained by Baek et al. [45,46]. However, this finding conflicts with the current recommendation of steroid treatment for ARDS caused by COVID-19 [47]. The heterogeneous results may be caused by the disease severity and the different types of glucocorticoids used in patients with COVID-19.
I don’t want to dwell on this too much, other than to say that, although more evidence is needed, steroids probably don’t help most severely ill COVID-19 patients and that Bartlett was (and is) clearly an evangelist because her brother treated COVID=19 patients early in the pandemic with budesonide and saw what he thought were encouraging results. It wasn’t a randomized, controlled, double-blinded trial, though; so the potential for confirmation bias was very strong, particularly given how early in the pandemic it had not yet become clear what the likelihood of recovery was on one’s own, but none of that stopped him from finding his way into press reports about budesonide portraying it as a “silver bullet.” In any event, Bartlett set up her hotline:
And it was almost as if informed consent didn’t exist. But in fact, it never went away. Even during the COVID shielding for hospitals, informed consent between the doctor and the patient never went away. You always had the right to informed consent. And so that’s where my work back in 2020 started. And in the process, I realized that, since there were so many calls that I was receiving with people reaching out for help, I thought, “Well, why doesn’t somebody come up with a way for people to quickly access some information of what their rights are and their patient rights?” And so, I started a hotline, a nationwide hotline, called the Hospital Hostage Hotline. And it’s still in effect. I still get calls from all over the country. And I’ve been able to help people who went in for even non-COVID reasons like a urinary tract infection that quickly was diagnosed as COVID and they were being pushed towards a protocol and told they couldn’t leave, for instance, the hospital. And they needed to know they could, that they always had the right to leave AMA, against medical advice, if that’s what they chose.
They also had the right to either consent or not consent to things and it should be respected. And I realized that one of the biggest tools for getting that informed consent notice to the doctor was not to just verbally say it, but to have it in writing. And these aren’t my original ideas. I actually had a hospital insider reach out seeing what I was doing, somebody who had been in the system and knew how to navigate the system at a high level in administration, give me some tips and tools on how to navigate the hospital system to make sure that informed consent was not only documented and then served in a way that, it was delivered effectively to get into the electronic medical record, but also, what their basic patient rights were and how to advocate for them.
And, later:
These are things I heard throughout the last couple of years. “I feel like I’m a prisoner. They won’t let me leave.” But in fact, they always had the right, their patient right, to leave a hospital whenever they chose to. It’s not up to the doctor when they can leave. They have to make that medical choice for themself, whether or not they feel like they can leave. And I always told them, “If you want to leave, you feel like you can leave, leave. If you change your mind, you can go back to a hospital. Say something changes in your health condition that warrants going back to a hospital, you can do that. Either that hospital or another hospital. You can always get transferred to another hospital. If you don’t like what’s happening in this hospital, the care that you’re receiving, you can transfer to a different hospital or a different level of care.” But there are options. And people were coerced, lied to and manipulated during this, and they still are.
It’s actually a myth that leaving the hospital against medical advice (AMA) will result in your insurance company not paying for your hospital stay. Indeed, one study in 2012 found no correlation between leaving AMA and the disallowance of payment by the insurance company, while also finding that many residents and physicians believe that leaving AMA will lead to the insurance company refusing to pay. Of course, Bartlett includes anecdotes about doctors telling patients that if they leave AMA insurance might not pay for their stay. Of course, to Bartlett, this is evidence of the conspiracy, that it’s all about profit, not science-based medicine, and that the “threats” are encouraged, rather than being the result of a widely held misunderstanding, again weaponizing a real problem by misattributing the reason for the problem as being not an urban myth that too many doctors believe (and that I once believed), but an intentional policy:
The bottom line is, it seems like, in my opinion, money has been a big factor. Profit has been a big factor in a lot of suffering. Patients were afraid to leave because they were told, like in the instance of a gentleman that I was helping in New Jersey who went in for a urinary tract infection. That was his reason for going to the hospital. He was an elderly man, didn’t know why he was feeling the way he was feeling. This was early 2020 and he was treated for that. And they quickly tested him for COVID and started him on that road towards fast tracking him, in my opinion, towards a ventilator. And they told him flat out, “If you leave, none of this will be covered by insurance.” Just like you said, Dr. Mercola. So, that was a big factor.
Let’s move on to what’s in the template for this informed consent misinformed refusal:
As mentioned, you can customize your Caregivers and Consent document any way you like. But to give people a starting point, the template, available on OurPatientRights.com, includes things like:
    • “I do not consent to the use of medications without my being informed of each medication’s risks, benefits and alternatives before they are ordered. Only after that information is communicated shall I choose to either grant consent or to not grant consent for each and every medication that is ordered.”
    • “I do not consent to receiving any vaccine or booster for COVID-19 or COVID-19 variant.”
    • “I do not consent to receiving the seasonal flu vaccine.”
    • “I request and consent to the use of 1 mg of budesonide via nebulizer every 4 to 6 hours for COVID-19 or COVID-19 variant diagnosis with respiratory issues.”
If you want to, you could change the verbiage to state that you do not consent to ANY vaccine. If you have allergies, add that to the list. Personally, I would recommend adding the following dietary notice:
    • “I do not consent to receiving ANY processed food, such as high-fructose corn syrup or seed oils. The only acceptable oil for me is butter, ghee, beef tallow or coconut oil. Acceptable forms of protein would be eggs, lamb, bison, beef or non-farmed seafood; but they must not be prepared with seed oils. If the hospital is unable to provide this food for me, my family or friends will bring it for me.
    • Additionally, I do not consent to not being able to take my normal supplements while in the hospital.”
I would strongly recommend that you integrate this additional clause because it’s a stealth form of abuse. These kinds of foods can only impair your effort to get well, no matter what your problem is. You may also want to add a notice saying you do not consent to receive blood donations from COVID-19 vaccinated donors, and that all blood donations must be from donors confirmed to have not received any COVID-19 vaccines.
Regarding nebulized budesonide, I can only note that physicians are not generally obligated to provide a treatment that they do not themselves consider effective and safe. Patients can ask all they want for budesonide, but doctors are not obligated to provide it unless it is considered a standard of care. Of course, true informed consent means that doctors will indeed go through all the standard-of-care options for treatment, their pros and cons, their risks and benefits, and then a collaborative decision will be made by the patient with the help of the doctor. Basically, there is no need for such a statement about a treatment that is widely considered a standard of care.
Similarly, patients can ask for all the quackery that they want, like ivermectin for COVID-19, but doctors are not obligated to provide it. Even Mercola acknowledges this. It is true that there have been a number of lawsuits trying to force hospitals to allow patients to use unproven or disproven treatments for COVID-19, but they are generally losing propositions. Of course, from my perspective, the real point of these efforts is to frighten medical staff, fear monger about medicine, and sell quackery like MMS and colloidal silver, not true “informed consent.”
Crawford claims:
What we’ve experienced using these documents is a complete change in the attending physician, from being aggressive and maybe trying to push you, to being very helpful and efficient. Once they receive these documents, they just do a 180. As a matter of fact, one patient’s brother told me he’s getting treated better than he’s ever been treated at a hospital before.
As a physician myself, I simply note that, yes, learning that you are dealing with a highly litigious patient will indeed tend to make doctors very, very cautious and deferential. Not wanting to get sued, they will be very careful. What Mercola fails to mention is that they will also make sure to dot all their “i’s” and cross all their “t’s” in the medical record, detailed and rigorous documentation of every discussion, intervention, and rationale for interventions being generally the best defense.
Mercola even brags about the above threat:
Again, having this document in your medical record virtually guarantees that they cannot harm you by doing something you don’t agree with. Of course, some psychopath might ignore your directives, but they’ll have to pay a hefty price, as they’re guaranteed to lose a malpractice suit and be stripped of their medical license. The legal consequences are so severe that the person doing it would have to be beyond irrational.
I would also point out that having such a document in your medical record virtually guarantees that your physicians will hesitate and might even consult the hospital attorney and ethics board before doing anything. That is, of course, a feature, not a bug of this entire enterprise, as everyone agrees:
Dr. Joseph Mercola:You have a large number of people who signed this document, examples that you said. And I’m wondering if anyone has used this when the physician has violated their consent and they’ve been prosecuted. It went up to the medical board or had their license removed.
Laura Bartlett:Not yet. No, this is novel. This is new. But I’m telling you that this definitely puts them on notice.
Dr. Joseph Mercola:Exactly.
The idea is to instill fear in doctors more than anything else, all while supporting the typical quack narrative that medicine is deadly, at the behest of government hospitals are intentionally trying to kill COVID-19 patients for profit, and that there are cheap, nontoxic “cures” that “They” don’t want you to know about:
The Delta Variant just happened to coincide with the vaccine distribution. Although kept quiet, it is known that many vaxxed patients end up in the hospital with reactions to the shot. One thing that had to be done to keep this pandemic in play was to increase the actual death count of patients. Aside from going to citizens’ homes and outright murdering them, the easiest way was to have them walk into the hospitals where trusted doctors could administer poison to each victim.​Even though the vax has caused deaths and injuries that are suppressed or not reported, many people are now aware and not willing to get the shot. The government is able to scare the public into believing that Covid is deadly by paying hospitals to kill off patients. Then doctors and hospitals proclaim that the unvaxxed are the ones dying and everyone needs to receive the shot to survive. The truth is the unvaxxed are targeted for death by the hospitals and the hospitals don’t report that just as many vaxxed are hospitalized and dying as well.
There are simple ways to combat Covid at home with drugs like Ivermectin, HCQ, Budesonide, even CBD. These known, effective treatments are being suppressed so that patients will be forced to go to hospitals and ultimately murdered.​Through Remdesivir, paralytic drugs, and ventilators, the hospitals knowingly put patients to death so they can earn money and increase the fear of Covid.
That’s some weapons-grade conspiracy mongering right there.
ProtocolKills.com: Misinformed refusal on steroids and generalized to all medicine
No physician will deny that patients have autonomy and that a competent adult—or designated spokespeople for children or adults who can no longer advocate for themselves—should have the right to refuse any medical treatment after being informed of its risks and benefits, as well as the alternatives available and their risks and benefits. That isn’t what misinformed refusal is about, nor has it ever been. In the case of vaccines, I noted over a decade ago that misinformed refusal was all about painting a false picture of the risk-benefit ratio of vaccines in order to portray them in the worse light possible and thereby discourage vaccine-hesitant parents from vaccinating their children. For parents who go beyond being vaccine-hesitant, a secondary purpose was to sell quackery, such as “vaccine detoxes,” and “autism biomed” to treat children whose autism was falsely attributed to vaccines.
ProtocolKills.com is nothing more than a vastly expanded update of the same tactic. It’s doing the same thing, not just for vaccines, but for all conventional science-based COVID-19 treatments—and not just for COVID-19 treatments, but for all science-based medical treatments, period. It is the weaponization of informed consent, which is twisted into misinformed refusal turned into a set of legal documents intended to instill in physicians fear for their medical licenses and in hospitals and physicians fear of expensive lawsuits. Truly, in the age of the pandemic everything old is new again in terms of antivaccine tactics and tropes, but more than that. Everything old is new again and then cranked up to 11.

Misinformation, Trust, and Non-Evidence-Based COVID-19 Treatments
Misinformation drove 1 in 20 Americans to use useless therapies like ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 infections.
Scott Gavura on October 12, 2023
Link

Early in the pandemic, and in the absence of any convincing evidence, hydroxychloroquine and later ivermectin were promoted as potential cures for COVID-19 infections. Despite multiple statements from FDA and other organizations, there was a significant increase in the demand for these products and also their prescription rates. A drug which is clinically ineffective, but has side effects, is arguably harmful, and both ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine met these conditions. Their use consequently contributed to worse outcomes and unnecessary expense for users.
Given the negative consequences of non-evidence-based treatments during a pandemic, Roy Perlis and associates sought to quantify both the prevalence of the use of these treatments, and the relationship with endorsement of misinformation, or of lack in trust in scientists and physicians. If health professionals and public health organizations want to improve their messaging and help connect people with good health information, we need to understand what drives people to use treatments that are ineffective. The paper was published on September 29, 2023 in JAMA Health Forum, and reveals some interesting relationships about the characteristics of those that used these treatments.
The Study
This analysis pulled data from December 2022 through January 2023 from the COVID States Project, a consortium that has conducted a 50-state internet survey every 4-8 weeks since spring 2020. Survey respondents were 18 years or older and resided in the USA. The survey sought to meet representative representation for race, ethnicity, age and gender.
Participants were asked if they had been diagnosed with COVID-19, or believed they had previously been infected. The primary analysis included all of those that answered “yes”. Participants were then asked if they had taken hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, or an FDA-approved antiviral medication. Political affiliation was determined by asking “Generally speaking, do you think of yourself as a…” with Republican, Democrat, Independent, or other as choices. Finally, COVID-19 vaccine–related misinformation was assessed by by presenting respondents with statements about the vaccine; and whether they agreed, disagreed, or were not sure about the statement:
Below are some statements about the COVID-19 vaccines that are currently being distributed. To the best of your knowledge, are those statements accurate or inaccurate?
The COVID-19 vaccines [accurate/inaccurate/not sure]:
    • will alter people’s DNA.
    • contain microchips that could track people.
    • contain the lung tissue of aborted fetuses.
    • can cause infertility, making it more difficult to get pregnant.
    • contain a bioluminescent marker used to trace people.
Trust in institutions was evaluated by asking how much respondents trusted a given group to do the right thing:
How much do you trust the following people and organizations to do what is right? [a lot/some/not too much/not at all]:
    • Donald Trump
    • Hospitals and doctors
    • Pharmaceutical companies
    • Scientists and researchers
    • The news media
    • Social media companies
The researchers measured conspiracy-mindedness via the 4-item American Conspiracy Thinking Scale:
How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? [strongly agree/somewhat agree/neither agree or disagree/somewhat disagree/strongly disagree]
    • Even though we live in a democracy, a few people will always run things anyway.
    • The people who really ‘run’ the country are not known to the voters.
    • Big events like wars, the current recession, and the outcomes of elections are controlled by small groups of people who are working in secret against the rest of us.
    • Much of our lives are being controlled by plots hatched in secret places.
Finally, the researchers examined sources of news by asking whether individuals had received any news about COVID-19 in the prior 24 hours from a list of sources including Facebook, CNN, Fox News, MSNBC, and Newsmax.
The Results
Here are the characteristics of those that did or did not use non-evidence-based-treatments. Overall, 799 (5.9%) reported the use of at least one non-evidence-based treatment, compared to 7.3% that reported uses of an FDA-approved treatment. Interestingly but perhaps not surprisingly given the “horse paste” comments and photos that circulated at the time, as many as 30% of individuals using ivermectin and 14% of individuals using hydroxychloroquine reported that they did not receive these interventions from a medical professional.
The table shows that those that used these treatments were more likely to be male and more likely to have a higher income. More education seems to bias towards treatment. Both Democrats and Republicans were more likely to use these treatments vs. independents. Users also tended to be heavier consumers all the media sources reported, compared to non-users.With respect to the connection between endorsing misinformation related to vaccines and the use of non-evidence-based medications, 2,461 out of 10,718 individuals (23.0%) expressed their support for at least one aspect of vaccine-related misinformation. In survey-weighted regression models, this endorsement was linked to a notably higher likelihood of having used non-evidence-based treatments. In adjusted models, but not in unadjusted ones, misinformation was modestly but significantly linked to the receipt of prescription antiviral treatments.
Users reported substantially more trust in social media and Donald Trump, but also in the pharmaceutical industry, with less trust in scientists. Trust in hospitals and physicians was linked to a reduced likelihood of using non-evidence-based treatments, but an increased likelihood of receiving antiviral treatment. A similar trend was observed with trust in scientists, where greater trust was associated with a reduced likelihood of using non-evidence-based treatments and an increased likelihood of receiving antiviral treatment. Interestingly, the presence of trust was connected to a higher likelihood of using either non-evidence-based or antiviral treatments, although the magnitude of these effects varied considerably.
Not just political persuasion driving use
The findings from this research align with other research that examined prescription data for ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, showing an increase in use during the early stages of the pandemic. Notably, this paper identified a significant proportion of these treatments were obtained without a prescription from a medical professional, emphasizing the limitations of relying solely on prescription data to estimate use.
Other studies using county-level data have linked higher support for Donald Trump with a greater prevalence of non-evidence-based COVID-19 prescriptions. Similarly, research has also suggested that more politically conservative physicians were more inclined to prescribe them. Importantly, this study shows that use was not simply a matter of political affiliation. Drivers of use included the endorsement of vaccine-related misinformation, a lack of trust in healthcare institutions and scientists, and a tendency towards conspiratorial thinking related to politics.
Disappointingly, almost one quarter of the American population believes inaccurate information related to COVID-19, with specific subgroups being more inclined to do so. Embracing COVID-19-related misinformation may reduce the willingness to be vaccinated, an intervention which has been shown to reduce the likelihood of harms from COVID-19 infections. False information is predominantly disseminated online and regrettably during the pandemic, by political figures and media outlets. Interestingly, watching cable news (regardless of that channel’s perspective) were associated with increased odds for treatment: both evidence-based and non-evidence based.
The authors conclude that misinformation may not only reduce the likelihood of vaccination but may drive the use of ineffective and possibly harmful treatments like hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin. How we get to a better place, from a public health perspective, is less clear. Refuting misinformation feels more challenging than ever before, and we need better strategies – to manage the ongoing harms of this pandemic, and to prepare for the next one.

Black Market Anti-virals
New antivirals for COVID have rapidly led to a black market in dubious knock-offs.
Steven Novella on June 1, 2022
Link

COVID-19 presented a novel infectious illness that has caused significant worldwide morbidity and mortality with significant economic and cultural effects. At the same time researchers worked quickly to study the virus that causes COVID and develop effective treatments. Within a year multiple vaccines were approved and in production, giving us a powerful tool to reduce the pandemic. It took longer to develop effective anti-viral treatments for active infection (after some false starts with drugs like hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin that turned out to be ineffective).
However, recently two anti-viral drugs have been approved that have been shown to be highly effective in treating early COVID illness. Molnupiravir (by Merck) is an oral drug that has been shown to reduce the chance of hospitalization and death by 50%, if taken early for mild COVID. Benefits are less if taken later in the course of the illness, and more research is needed to see if it is effective in moderate to severe COVID. The most recent analysis of this data, however, show only a 30% in risk of hospitalization. An independent study is also underway, and regulators are waiting to see if even this 30% reduction holds up.
Nirmatrelvir (by Pfizer), meanwhile, was found to reduce the chance of progressing from mild COVID to severe COVID by 89% compared to placebo. This drug is given in combination with ritonavir as a “pharmacokinetic enhancer” to block metabolism and prolong the effectiveness of nirmatrelvir.
The addition of these drugs (especially nirmatrelvir) to existing treatment, and vaccines for prevention, will help turn COVID into a more manageable disease and also help the transition to living with endemic COVID, much like we live with endemic flu. One of the greatest burdens of COVID is the dramatically increased hospital admissions, especially during spikes, that overwhelm staff and resources and push aside more routine care, resulting in negative health outcomes. Reducing hospitalizations among those who get COVID is therefore highly useful.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has added molnupiravir to their list of recommended COVID treatments, and state:
molnupiravir should be provided only to non-severe COVID-19 patients with the highest risk of hospitalization. These are typically people who have not received a COVID-19 vaccination, older people, people with immunodeficiencies and people living with chronic diseases.
There are two reasons for limiting the use of these antivirals. The first is that, while they appear to be safe with few side effects in the clinical trials so far, they are new drugs. When we start giving them to millions of patients it is possible, even probable, that new side effects will emerge. On a risk-vs-benefit basis, therefore, they should be limited to the people who most need them.
The second reason is that the availability of these antivirals is limited. Production can only be ramped up so quickly. At first supplies were limited even in the countries where production was located, but there is now enough availability that they are available for any who need them. That is – in developed Western nations. Supplies are still critically limited in poorer countries.
Unfortunately, as has now been documented in a recent BMJ article, this has lead to the creation of a black marker in generic versions of these drugs. Their reporters contacted an online market, Indiamart, and report:
Within hours, three sellers got in touch to make offers, even though the Mexican authorities have not permitted generic versions of the drug to be imported into the country. One seller gave advice on how avoid customs.
Black markets for generic versions of these drugs sprang up almost instantly when the initial studies created hype about their effectiveness. As the BMJ article points out, this is problematic on many levels. First, online black markets do not require a prescription (of course) or the involvement of a physician. Like all drugs, these antivirals may not be safe for some populations (such as women who may be pregnant), and can have drug-drug interactions. They should only be taken under physician supervision, or as part of a clinical trial.
There is also a huge concern about indiscriminate use of these antivirals, which can cause antiviral resistance (just like indiscriminate use of antibiotics can cause antibiotic resistance). Those who do not truly need the drug will incur costs and risks without probable benefit, and can eventually reduce the effectiveness of these drugs for those who do.
Further, there is no quality control for black market drugs, and every reason to think that the sellers involved are less than scrupulous. This opens the door to many risks, such as taking worthless substances, unknown substances which can cause allergy or negative interactions, and risking contamination and adulteration.
The BMJ authors correctly point out that this is a high risk whenever there is dramatically unequal distribution of healthcare resources. However, the risk goes beyond that. Even the perception of scarcity will drive the black market, and that perception can be entirely manufactured for the purpose. A drug can be “scarce” because it is not approved, because it is not safe and effective. The lack of approval can then be blamed on a conspiracy, with the black market as a remedy.
The BMJ study also highlights the fact that the availability of online marketplaces can quickly establish a black market infrastructure for new products. Also, online markets can exist in locations with lax regulations but supply anywhere in the world. Local regulations may therefore be of little benefit, especially if those same black marketers are adept at avoiding customs.
One solution to the exploitation of black market drugs (which tends to target the most vulnerable) is tighter regulations, and more international regulations. However, this addresses only supply. We need to also address demand. In cases of drugs and products that are inherently fraudulent or useless, education is the best tool. But when it comes to generic knock-offs of effective drugs, improving the supply, especially to poor nations, can also be effective. Merck has announced, for example, that they will offer voluntary licenses to generic manufacturers in poor countries, and moves like this can be a big help.

“Base Spike Detox” and Signature Spike Support Formulas: Nattokinase quackery to treat COVID-19 and COVID-19 “vaccine injury”
Dr. Peter McCullough and a number of “anti-COVID-19 vaccine” antivaxxers out there has pivoted to quackery to “detox” from the supposedly malign effects of COVID-19 vaccines. Everything old is new again, this time with nattokinase.
David Gorski on July 24, 2023
Link

If there’s one reliable characteristic of physicians who go all-in on antivaccine beliefs, it’s that, after they have come to identify vaccines as The One True Source of All Chronic Disease (or just a bunch of toxic sludge causing “vaccine injury”), it is almost inevitable that they come up with quackery to treat what they view as vaccine-induced chronic disease or injury. Back in the “old days,” I used to write about what was called “autism biomed,” because the primary antivaccine claim 15 years ago was that childhood vaccines cause autism. Basically, “autism biomed” was—and remains—a blanket term used by believers in the vaccine-autism conspiracy theory to describe a rather large collection of quackery that included chelation therapy, various “detox” regimens, “metabolic” treatments, and more, none of which had one iota of evidence to support them as treatments for autism spectrum disorders. Use of the term “biomed” was meant to imply that these were legitimate “biomedical” treatments for “vaccine-induced autism,” when in reality they consisted mainly of a motley collection of “detox” quackery, often bolstered by “functional medicine” and various alternative medicine treatments like naturopathy and homeopathy. This brings me to Dr. Peter McCullough and his “Base Spike Detox,” which uses enzymes like nattokinase and bromelain to “detox” the spike protein from both COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines. As it turns out, Dr. McCullough’s protocol is just a variant of an earlier protocol that I first learned about earlier this year, Signature Series Spike Support Formula sold by The Wellness Company and promoted by Dr. McCullough, a video of whom is featured on the product page, but had never gotten around to writing about on this blog.
Here are the ingredients of the supplement, which is advertised to let you “get back to that pre-COVID feeling”:

As for the claims:
Spike Support Formula contains all natural, non-GMO, scientifically-supported ingredients:
Nattokinase has been researched to dissolve spike proteins and blood clots.
Dandelion root may prevent spike protein from binding to your cells.
Selenium to help reduce stress, aiding in helping the body repair itself and recover.
Black sativa extract may facilitate cellular repair.
Green tea extract provides added defenses at the cellular level through scavenging for free radicals.
Irish sea moss is mineral-rich and could help rebuild damaged tissue and muscle.
Leaving aside the nattokinase for a moment, you can see that most of the claims for the herbs and extracts are all fairly generic; i.e., “rebuild damaged tissue”; “facilitate cellular repair”; or “help reduce stress.” We’ll look at the other claims in a moment, such as that nattokinase dissolves spike protein and dandelion root “may prevent spike protein from binding to your cells.”
Obviously, Dr. McCullough is far from the first example of COVID-19 antivax docs making a pivot towards unproven treatments. One prominent example that comes to mind is America’s Frontline Doctors, a group that first made a name for itself resisting “lockdowns,” masking, and public health interventions for COVID-19 but then later pivoted to a highly profitable grift running a telehealth prescription mill for ivermectin. Ivermectin, of course, was billed the inexpensive highly effective treatment for COVID=19 that “They” don’t want you to know about. In addition, although I have been unable to figure out who first came up with the idea of using nattokinase to “dissolve spike protein,” I do know that this particular detox formulation appears to have been the “brainchild” (and I do use the word “brain” very loosely here) of Jen VanDeWater, who’s a pharmacist selling something called “Dr. Jen VanDeWater’s Spike Recovery Formula,” which is billed as the “gold standard” in combatting “shedding” and fending off the “deadly spike protein”:
These are the basics for the claims about nattokinase as a treatment for COVID-19, long COVID, and COVID-19 “vaccine injury.”
Dr. McCullough, however, is a bit different in that he’s promoting his nostrums not just to treat COVID-19 and long COVID, but to “detox” people from the dreaded spike protein used as the antigen in COVID-19 vaccines. The key ingredient in the Spike Support Formula is nattokinase, which is a proteolytic enzyme (an enzyme that cleaves proteins at specific sites), and now apparently Dr. McCullough has added another proteolytic enzyme, bromelain, to the mix:
I have found in my clinical practice that most multiply infected and or COVID-19 vaccine injected patients with post-COVID-19 symptoms respond slowly after three months or more of “Base Spike Detox” which contains:
     1.  Nattokinase 2000 FU (100 mg) twice a day
     2.  Bromelain 500 mg daily
     3.  nano Curcumin 500 mg twice a day
So what are nattokinase and bromelain, and why does Dr. McCullough promote them as treatments to “detox” you from spike protein, whether it comes from COVID-19 or the dreaded and much more evil (apparently) spike protein that the mRNA vaccines induce your cells to make in minute quantities? Let’s find out.
Nattokinase
I was unfamiliar with nattokinase before, but several months ago I had bookmarked a post by Dr. Paul Alexander that basically laid out the entire “rationale”—again, if you can call it that—for using nattokinase to “detox” from the dreaded spike protein. First, he says that you need to “detox” the spike protein, particularly if you’ve had the vaccine:
Spike protein (due to the COVID vaccine or virus) is becoming increasingly concerning and people are begging for solutions. They are scared and in many instances distraught as to the spike circulating within them. As a result, a spike detoxifier is needed. This detoxifier can potentially help manage the amount of spike protein in your body (especially spike induced by the Pfizer and Moderna gene platform).
Seeing a claim like this leads me to point out some things. First, the amount of spike protein that gets into the bloodstream as a result of the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines made by Pfizer and Moderna is infinitesimally small, definitely smaller than the amount of spike protein one gets from an—oh, you know—actually infection with SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Second—and I know I’m repeating myself from above, but bear with me—antivaxxers have been recommending “detoxification” to treat “vaccine injury” or “vaccine toxicity” since long before I ever first took notice of the antivaccine movement which was well over two decades ago. Nattokinase, as you will see, is just the latest wrinkle in this old narrative.
Unsurprisingly, instead of blaming the virus for long COVID, Alexander blames—you guessed it!—the vaccine:
This is a particularly important consideration given the massive reporting of symptoms post recovery from virus infection or taking the COVID mRNA-DNA gene injection (Pfizer and Moderna). I am referring to what is called ‘LONG-COVID’ and you may have heard this term or similar. The advancing ‘maturing’ science is focusing on clarifying this condition yet it is clear just by looking around us in our own personal daily lives (ourselves, our family members, our friends, or our work colleagues as well as just strangers who shared their struggles), that this COVID gene injection or the virus leaves many with symptoms and often debilitating crippling one. This is no laughing matter and some (many) people are very damaged by the gene injection vaccine (as well as the virus).
At least Dr. Alexander sort of acknowledges that the virus might actually cause long COVID. Of course, he frames it by saying “some (many) people” were damaged by the “gene injection” vaccine “as well as the virus.” His readers know what he really means, namely that he’s claiming that the vaccine is the primary cause of what is being labeled “long COVID.” Lest you fail to get that message, he rapidly pivots to claim:
The reality is that the COVID gene injections (so called vaccines) induces the very toxic dangerous part of the COVID virus that causes severe and often fatal disease sequelae, this being the spike protein, as part of the immune response. The spike protein and especially the S1 sub-unit of the spike protein is highly pathological and is more than likely involved in the often crippling post-vaccination syndrome e.g. LONG COVID. The spike protein is devastatingly toxic (references here, here, here).
I can’t help but note that the first article uses a mouse model to study acute lung injury from COVID-19 involving artificially high doses of spike protein. The second article is by Stephanie Seneff, a naturopath, and Peter McCullough. (‘Nuff said.) The third article is about the incidence of acute allergic reactions to COVID-19 vaccines, and I note that pretty much all vaccines can cause rare allergic reactions, making COVID vaccines nothing unique on that score. None of these articles, other than the mouse model, demonstrates that the spike protein is a “toxin” that causes long COVID, and even the mouse model is of limited utility in that the dose used (400 µg/kg) is huge compared to anything a vaccine could cause and arguably even more than infection can cause. Also, the recombinant spike protein was administered not intramuscularly or intravenously, but intratracheal, meaning that the investigators squirted saline containing it into the tracheas of the mice. Anyway, cherry picking and misrepresenting studies is how dishonest antivaxxers roll.
So what does nattokinase supposedly do? Actually, maybe it’s more appropriate to ask: How does nattokinase supposedly “dissolve” the dreaded spike protein, which to antivaxxers is so much more horrible if it comes from the toxin-laden vaccines rather than naturally from the disease?
According to Alexander:
Recent literature has shown nattokinase to be effective in degrading the spike protein associated with COVID-19 [3]. It has long been known to reduce the risk of clot formation and improve circulation [3].
Before I started looking into what nattokinase is even supposed to do, let me just briefly note that the first thing I always wonder about when I see an enzyme being touted as a treatment for anything is how a protein—an enzyme—can work when taken orally. In general, proteins are rapidly broken down in the stomach and proximal small intestine by a number of other very efficient enzymes that chew up the peptide chain. It is true that there are a few exceptions, but they tend to be digestive enzymes, which can survive in the harsh chemical environment of the stomach and enzymatic environment of the small intestine. Examples include pancreatic enzymes, whose function can indeed be replaced by oral supplementation because these enzymes are among the enzymes that work in digestion. Nattokinase does not appear to be one of these enzymes. So what is it?
It turns out that nattokinase is an enzyme used to ferment soy bean products that have long been a dietary staple in Japan. It also turns out that it’s been a popular supplement dating back to long before the pandemic. If you do a Google search for just “nattokinase” a lot of the results will be supplement sellers promoting it for its various claimed health benefits. In brief, nattokinase is extracelluar enzyme secreted by the bacterium Bacillus subtilis, used to ferment boiled or steamed soybeans resulting in a preparation called nattō. The Memorial Sloan-Kettering website notes:
Nattokinase is also available as a supplement and is most known for its effects on prevention and treatment of clots and to improve blood circulation.
And:
Nattokinase has been promoted as an alternative anticancer treatment based on the notion that it can help dissolve the fibrin coating around a tumor, and increase oxygen supply in the blood to inhibit cancer cell growth. However, these mechanisms have not been proven in humans.
Nattokinase is also purported to treat Alzheimer’s disease and hypertension and a number of other disorders, because of course it is.
So right away you can see why nattokinase would be attractive to COVID antivax quacks, given that one of the main false claims about these vaccines is that they are causing people to “die suddenly” of clotting disorders leading to strokes and myocardial infarctions (heart attacks). (They aren’t.) To quacks, nattokinase could be a two-for, both supposedly “dissolving” that nasty, toxic, evil spike protein (from the vaccine) and also dissolving clots. It’s also not as though nattokinase doesn’t have activities in vitro (test tube and cell culture) that do have relevance to clotting:
In vitro studies show that nattokinase decreases clot formation by cleaving and inactivating the plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI) via proteolysis at P1-P1’ peptide bond. PAI is a key inhibitor of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) that converts plasminogen to plasmin. PAI inactivation allows for greater tPA activity and increased lysis of clots (10) (11). In the absence of PAI, nattokinase affects direct proteolysis of fibrin; however, this effect is less than the protelysis achieved by the PAI-mediated pathway (2). The fibrinolytic activity of nattokinase is estimated to be four-fold that of plasmin (12).
The question, of course, is whether the in vitro activities of nattokinase translate into anything therapeutic in vivo in humans. The answer is: We don’t know. However, it strikes me as highly unlikely that nattokinase does these things in the human bloodstream when taken orally. One WebMD perusal of the evidence is full of “maybes” and other qualifiers like “possibly,” in which it’s claimed that nattokinase “might” increase your risk of bleeding, decrease your blood pressure, etc., but notes that there’s basically little to no clinical evidence to support these uses.
So what evidence do doctors like Dr. McCullough cite when recommending nattokinase? They always have some evidence to cite, but is it in any way convincing? In an earlier Substack post from February, Dr. McCullough was touting the Dissolution of Spike Protein by Nattokinase, which he called the “Holy Grail of COVID-19 vaccine detoxification,” handwaving an “explanation” of why the vaccine-induced spike protein is so much more nasty than the much huger amounts of spike protein produced by an actual infection:
Far and away the most common question I get from those who took one of the COVID-19 vaccines is: “how do I get this out of my body.” The mRNA and adenoviral DNA products were rolled out with no idea on how or when the body would ever breakdown the genetic code. The synthetic mRNA carried on lipid nanoparticles appears to be resistant to breakdown by human ribonucleases by design so the product would be long-lasting and produce the protein product of interest for a considerable time period. This would be an advantage for a normal human protein being replaced in a rare genetic deficiency state (e.g. alpha galactosidase in Fabry’s disease). However, it is a big problem when the protein is the pathogenic SARS-CoV-2 Spike. The adenoviral DNA (Janssen) should broken down by deoxyribonuclease, however this has not be exhaustively studied.
This leaves dissolution of Spike protein as a therapeutic goal for the vaccine injured. With the respiratory infection, Spike is processed and activated by cellular proteases including transmembrane serine protein 2 (TMPRSS2), cathepsin, and furin. With vaccination, these systems may be avoided by systemic administration and production of Spike protein within cells. As a result, the pathogenesis of vaccine injury syndromes is believed to be driven by accumulation of Spike protein in cells, tissues, and organs.
It is, of course, utter nonsense to claim that the vaccines were rolled out with “no idea on how or when the body would ever breakdown the genetic code.” Extensive preclinical work on the vaccines, plus the two decades of work before that developing the mRNA vaccines in general, provided a lot of knowledge on how mRNA, even the modified mRNA used in the vaccines, is broken down in cells and the body. Just because we don’t know everything does not mean that we know nothing, although that is a frequent false dichotomy promoted by antivaxxers.
It is, of course, true that the mRNA vaccines were designed using modified ribonucleotides that are more resistant to being broken down by human ribonucleases, but that’s mainly because most mRNAs are quite short-lived and rapidly broken down this way. To have a chance of making sufficient spike protein to elicit an immune response, a much longer half-life was required. Instead of half lives of minutes to hours which is typical for most mRNAs (the median half-life of all human mRNAs as a group is around 10 hours), a half-life on the order of days was required. (As an aside, the half-life of the mRNA for a gene that I once studied as a graduate student was around 4 hours, but would decrease to less than an hour in response to cell stimulation with serum.) In contrast, the half-life of the mRNA for spike protein used in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines is on the order of a few days, with the spike protein being detectable for at most a few weeks. While it is true that one study oft-cited by antivaxxers found vaccine mRNA fragments in the blood as long as 28 days after vaccination, I note that this was mostly fragments, meaning that the mRNA would not be expected to generate further spike protein and that the authors speculated that this finding might have been due to slow leakage of the lipid nanoparticles out of the injection site. In any event, contrary to what antivaxxers claim, neither the modified mRNA nor the spike protein coded for by that mRNA persist longterm in the human body. They do not need to be “detoxed.” The body can do a perfectly find job of that.
In the same post, Dr. McCullough cites three studies. One is, unsurprisingly, an in vitro study in which cells infected with SARS-CoV-2 and lysates from cells were exposed to different doses of nattokinase, after which the authors reported:
When cell lysates transfected with S protein were incubated with nattokinase, the S protein was degraded in a dose- and time-dependent manner. Immunofluorescence analysis showed that S protein on the cell surface was degraded when nattokinase was added to the culture medium. Thus, our findings suggest that nattokinase exhibits potential for the inhibition of SARS-CoV-2 infection via S protein degradation.
They also appear to have done some of the appropriate controls, such as heating nattokinase to inactivate it or treating it with a protease inhibitor to inhibit its ability to cleave protein strands and then observing that such treatments eliminated the ability of nattokinase to degrade spike protein. A similar study, also cited by Dr. McCullough, reported that nattokinase can inhibit SARS-CoV-2 infection in cell culture. Of note, both studies examined whether nattokinase had an effect on spike protein produced by the virus (SARS-CoV-2) not whether the enzyme could degrade spike protein produced by cells transfected with the vaccine. Overall, the two findings aresomewhat interesting. They might or might not lead to the use of nattokinase to treat or alleviate COVID-19 infection. My prediction is that they probably won’t, simply because the vast majority of cell culture results don’t translate to a treatment, but I’ll concede that the findings are somewhat interesting nonetheless.
Of course, Dr. Peter McCullough is a lot less…measured…in his reaction to the study:
Based on these findings, nattokinase and similar products such as serrapeptase should undergo well-funded, accelerated preclinical and clinical development programs. The issue at hand is the urgency of time, similar to that with SARS-CoV-2 infection and empiric early therapy. It will take up to 20 years to have a fully developed pharmaceutical profile to characterize the safety and efficacy of nattokinase in the treatment of vaccine injury and post-COVID syndromes. Large number of people are sick now and many believe empiric treatment is justified given sufficiently low risk of side effects and potentially high reward. My recommendation is to discuss this with your doctor or seek a specialist in holistic or naturopathic medicine who is experienced with the safety profile of nattokinase in a range of applications.
Notice how McCullough assumes that this will be used for “vaccine injury,” even though the intent of the researchers who published these papers was to explore whether nattokinase can inhibit the infection of human cells by SARS-CoV-2. Also notice how much he exaggerates the timeline for figuring out whether nattokinase has a clinical effect on SARs-CoV-2 infection. It doesn’t take 20 years to test a compound that already exists and already has some preclinical evidence, even if you count doing the necessary preclinical animal model studies. Far from it! Dr. McCullough is simply exaggerating how long it would take to provide strong clinical evidence for nattokinase in order to justify using it now without any such evidence.
But what about the claimed effects of nattokinase with respect to clotting? There, the evidence is rather mixed. There is, for example, some in vitro evidence for activities in vitro (test tube and cell culture) that do have relevance to clotting:
In vitro studies show that nattokinase decreases clot formation by cleaving and inactivating the plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI) via proteolysis at P1-P1’ peptide bond. PAI is a key inhibitor of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) that converts plasminogen to plasmin. PAI inactivation allows for greater tPA activity and increased lysis of clots (10) (11). In the absence of PAI, nattokinase affects direct proteolysis of fibrin; however, this effect is less than the protelysis achieved by the PAI-mediated pathway (2). The fibrinolytic activity of nattokinase is estimated to be four-fold that of plasmin (12).
The question, of course, is whether the in vitro activities of nattokinase translate into anything therapeutic in humans. The answer is: We don’t know, but it strikes me as highly improbable. Let’s look.
Again, nattokinase is an enzyme. It should be expected to be digested when taken orally; it would not be expected to get into the bloodstream where it might actually be able to exhibit its ability to break down clots that it exhibits in a test tube. Its proponents, however, frequently cite this review article that claims otherwise. However, the way this review was written immediately got my skeptical antennae twitching with claims such as:
Nattokinase is considered to be a safe, powerful, low cost, and all-natural supplement for the treatment of heart and cardiovascular disease [5,6,7]. Animal [3,4,8] and human trials [9,10,11] have demonstrated that NK provides support to the circulatory system by thinning the blood and dissolving blood clots.
That first sentence is…something. But what about the cited articles? There are animal studies, but I zeroed in on the human studies. What impressed me about them was that none of them ever actually showed that nattokinase actually got into the bloodstream by measuring its concentration in the blood. For example, this randomized, double-blind study randomized healthy volunteers to receive a single dose of nattokinase supplement or placebo after a baseline blood draw. After the dose, blood was collected at 2, 4, 6, and 8 hours and various clotting parameters measured. The results? Basically nothing, although the authors sure tried to make it seem otherwise:
As a result, D-dimer concentrations at 6, and 8 hours, and blood fibrin/fibrinogen degradation products at 4 hours after NK administration elevated significantly (p < 0.05, respectively). Factor VIII activity declined at 4 and 6 hours (p < 0.05, respectively), blood antithrombin concentration was higher at 2 and 4 hours (p < 0.05, respectively), and the activated partial thromboplastin time prolonged significantly at 2 and 4 hours following NK administration (p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, respectively). All the changes, however, were within the normal range. In conclusion, thus, a single-dose of NK administration appears enhancing fibrinolysis and anti-coagulation via several different pathways simultaneously.
The key passage: “All the changes, however, were within the normal range.” In other words, no clear effect was demonstrated, and the authors did not actually even measure nattokinase in the blood of study subjects, which is odd, given that they went to the trouble to draw all those timed blood samples.
In fairness, there is a pharmacokinetic study in humans—a ten year old study!—suggesting that nattokinase can get into the bloodstream, but interestingly the study did not say that it detected bioactive nattokinase. Given that it used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to detect nattokinase in the blood, it is entirely possible that the antibody in the assay detected consisted of large fragments of degraded nattokinase or nattokinase that had been denatured (the protein unfolded) and was therefore inactive, leading the authors to note that “looking for intact enzyme and bioactive nattokinase peptides should be a consideration for future studies investigating the pharmacokinetic profile of nattokinase.” No kidding, as I noticed that a lot of the human studies of nattokinase (for example, this one) didn’t measure it in the blood even by ELISA. This all left me wondering whether it was actually nattokinase or something else in the concoction that might be affecting what was observed.
As you might expect, I couldn’t resist doing my own PubMed search on nattokinase to see what sorts of studies had been done more recently on nattokinase. I couldn’t help but immediately find this 2021 double-blind randomized controlled clinical trial that found zero effect of nattokinase versus placebo on the progression of atherosclerotic disease, which is one of the indications claimed for this enzyme. My entire take on nattokinase with respect to clotting and atherosclerosis is that it’s possible that maybe some intact enzyme survives digestion in the gut to be absorbed into the bloodstream to do something therapeutic, but that the evidence that it actually does anything clinically relevant in cardiovascular disease when administered orally is quite weak.
However weak the evidence is for oral nattokinase as a clot buster and drug to prevent atherosclerosis, the evidence base to support a conclusion that it does anything therapeutic whatsoever for COVID-19, long COVID, or COVID-19 “vaccine injury” is far, far weaker, as in close to nonexistent. None of this stops Dr. McCullough or others from promoting this quackery.
But what about bromelain? I think you know the answer.
Bromelain
Bromelain is an enzyme extract derived from the stems of pineapples, although it exists elsewhere in the pineapple as well. Wikipedia tells me that bromelain is commonly used in cosmetics, as a topical medication, and as a meat tenderizer, the last of which is something I always look for in a therapeutic enzyme. (That’s sarcasm. I realize that nearly all of you realize that, but I can never count on everyone realizing it.) In any event, bromelain contains proteases, which break down proteins by using water to break the bonds between the amino acids, usually at specific sites based on short peptide sequences recognized by the enzyme. It turns out that bromelain has a fairly broad specificity.
So what does Dr. McCullough claim about bromelain for “detoxing” spike protein? He starts out by referencing a review article by Varila et al, noting:
Bromelain is available in topical Nexobrid to cleanse third degree wound eschars. One vial contains 2 g of concentrate of proteolytic enzymes enriched in bromelain, corresponding to 0.09 g/g concentrate of proteolytic enzymes enriched in bromelain after mixing (or 2 g/22 g gel). The proteolytic enzymes are a mixture of enzymes from the stem of Ananas comosus (pineapple plant).
Oral bromelain has been safety tested up to 12 grams per day which is considerably higher than the typical 500 mg once a day used for Base Spike Detox. Bromelain partially degrades the Wuhan Spike protein and is a mild blood thinner. The review by Varilla points out that the PT and PTT blood tests can be prolonged with Bromelain. I have found patients taking Bromelain and Nattokinase together in Base Spike Detox need to be informed of the risks of bleeding and for them not to undergo d-dimer, PT, or PTT testing since the results will be abnormal as a result of therapy.
Again, just like activity as a meat tenderizing, I always look for something that, when used topically, breaks down burn wound eschars, which is the black burned skin overlying third degree burns and deep second degree burns that needs to be debrided (removed) before skin grafts can be applied. Oddly enough, Dr. McCullough even includes the prescribing information for Nexobrid:

This is all very interesting to me as a surgeon, but it is irrelevant to whether or not Nexobrid (and bromelain) are useful at all for treating COVID-19 or “detoxing” spike. It’s just information that looks impressive to nonphysicians.
Still, bromelain is one of the proteins that can be absorbed orally and retain its activity in the bloodstream, the evidence being more robust than the evidence for nattokinase:
Bromelain is absorbed efficiently in the human body and thus has a high bioavailability in an in vitro study [35]. This occurs as a result of its ability to bind to the two principal antiproteinases in the blood, alpha 2-macroglobulin and alpha1-antichymotrypsin. Without any significant side effects, it has been recorded that almost 12 g/day of bromelain can be taken in an in vivo study [36]. In addition, bromelain is absorbed in its active form throughout the gastrointestinal tract, with approximately 40 percent of the total bromelain absorbed in its high molecular weight form from the intestine [37]. In terms of pharmacokinetics, the maximal level of bromelain in the blood was obtained an hour after oral dosing [35]. Furthermore, [36] found that bromelain retains its plasma proteolytic function. Based on this, a more recent in vitro test showed that after 4 h, approximately 30% of bromelain remained stable in artificial stomach juice and that after the same time, roughly 20% of bromelain also remained stable in artificial blood [35].
Of course, just because bromelain can get into the bloodstream as an active enzyme does not mean that it does anything for COVID-19. This bothers Dr. McCullough not in the least, as he doesn’t even try to claim that bromelain does anything other than get into the bloodstream in active form and possibly break down clots:
We await additional post-COVID-19 and vaccine injury studies with Bromelain. It is reassuring it has bona fide proteolytic effects in the form of an approved topical therapy and its oral formulation is well absorbed and at doses of 500 mg patients are well below a threshold of concern. Since the Spike protein is known to be thrombogenic and many of the post-COVID-19 and vaccine injury syndromes are potentially related to micro- and macro-thromboses, Bromelain is well positioned as a component of Base Spike Detox.
Let me get this straight. Even Dr. McCullough admits that bromelain is unproven in COVID-19 and that there are no studies. (He can’t even cite an in vitro study showing that bromelain can actually digest spike protein in cell culture!) Out of curiosity, I did a quick PubMed search for studies examining bromelain and the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. I found three. One study suggested that antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 can cross react with bromelain (among a number of other antigens from food). I looked at the chart, and it only shows 30% crossreactivity. Make of that what you will. I don’t make very much of it. Another study found that a lectin constituent of bromelain could bind spike protein with a “low micromolar KD,” which is not particularly tight binding for a drug. (Let’s just say that I’ve worked with repurposed drugs whose concentration to achieve 50% effect is in the low micro molar range and rapidly learned the hard way that such compounds are generally not considered particularly good drug candidates because generally a lot of drug is needed and that means toxicity. The third study presents evidence that bromelain can decrease the expression (amount made) of the ACE2 receptor, which is what SARS-CoV-2 binds to via its spike protein to get into the cell. However, the concentrations of bromelain required are huge, as high as 75 µg/ml, which reminds me of ivermectin, where the amount of drug required to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 in cell culture is a couple of orders of magnitude higher than what can be achieved safely in the bloodstream.
No wonder quacks love it. In fairness, there are other papers on bromelain and COVID-19 that have been published that only come up if I search just “bromelain” and “COVID-19.” One study showed that bromelain can inactivate SARS-CoV-2, but required, again, very high concentrations of bromelain (at least 50 µg/ml). Another study is quite speculative, combining curcurmin and bromelain and suggesting that they might modulate the immune system to treat COVID-19. (Unsurprisingly, Dr. McCullough loves this study.) Then there’s an in silico modeling study suggesting that bromelain can bind to the spike protein. (Dr. Paul Alexander loves this one.) I could go on, but you get the idea. This is all very thin gruel indeed even to try to use as preliminary evidence to justify a randomized clinical trial, much less to treat anyone with in the absence of clinical trials.
Treatments targeting spike protein
In the end, everything old is new again. If you are an antivax physician, you believe that vaccines are toxic sludge pits that poison your body with “toxins” that need “detoxing.” In the age of COVID-19, the only difference is that the “toxins” being targeted by “detox” regimens are different. They’re the spike protein, primarily, even if the antivax quacks have to find a way to portray that evil “unnatural” spike protein made by the vaccines as so much worse than the “natural” spike protein from the infection that to them causes no harm other than producing “natural immunity.”
I like to say that the antivax movement is, when you boil it all down, a purity cult, and the quacks who use unproven treatments like nattokinase and bromelain to treat a disease like COVID-19 through “detoxification” are just catering to that belief.

It rises again! Bleach as an “early treatment” alternative to vaccines and a cure for COVID-19
Bleach…it had to be…bleach. Again. This time around, it’s being used to treat COVID-19, because of course it is. MMS is a slasher quackery. No matter how often it appears to have died, it always returns for another installment in its quackery franchise.
David Gorski on March 7, 2022
Link

I’ve been writing about quackery and the antivaccine movement for over two decades, having blogged about these topics for well over 14 years here on SBM and 17 years at my not-so-secret other blog. During that unbelievably—to me—long time, I’ve learned a few things, not the least of which is, as readers no doubt get tired of me repeating since COVID-19 hit, that there is nothing new under the sun with respect to antivax quackery. To put it another way, everything old is new again. I have, of course, written about this in general and in specifics going back to even before the pandemic was officially declared a pandemic, but also in the context of individual antivax claims that have been resurrected, recycled, and given a fresh coat of COVID-19 paint in order to appear shiny and new. Examples include misuse of the VAERS database by antivaxxers to portray COVID-19 vaccines as deadly, as well as claims that vaccines sterilize our womenfolk (or even our girls before they go through puberty). So I suppose I shouldn’t have been surprised to see the resurrection of a form of antivaccine quackery commonly used to treat “vaccine-induced” autism back in the day. A decade or so ago, it was all the rage in antivax circles and was featured prominently across multiple years during the yearly antivaccine quackfest known as AutismOne, which was usually held at a hotel near O’Hare International Airport in Chicago. True, there are some seemingly new wrinkles based on the fact that the technology used in the first approved vaccines hadn’t been approved for use in vaccines before, but even the claim that the mRNA-based vaccines can “permanently alter your DNA” was not new (and seemingly won’t die).
In light of this history, I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised that antivaxxers are now touting bleach—excuse me, Miracle Mineral Solution (MMS) or chlorine dioxide—as a cure for COVID-19, and I’m not. I am, however, still amazed at how advocates of unscientific medicine can persuade people that a chemical bleach used in water disinfection and purification can cure so many things. MMS is what some refer to as a “zombie treatment” in that it always rises from the dead even when killed. I tend to prefer the term “slasher quackery”, though, because MMS is more like Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers, two iconic slashers featured in innumerable horror movies since the 1980s. No matter how many times the slasher appears to have been killed at the end of one installment in the movie franchise, he always returns to kill more hapless college students.
Enter Mark Sircus and an article published a few weeks ago, Chlorine Dioxide Cure For COVID? Of course, quacks began touting MMS as a cure for COVID-19 very early in the pandemic, but, even so and even at this late date in the pandemic, I thought it worth discussing the claims made by Mr. Sircus, who is an acupuncturist and practitioner of traditional Chinese medicine who insists on calling himself “doctor” even though he most definitely is not a physician. After all, if grifters can sell magic dirt from a special peat bog in Canada as a cure-all for COVID-19, why not bleach?
Start with a conspiracy…
Sircus, as is typical in these sorts of pitches, starts out with a conspiracy theory about how “they” don’t want you to know about “cures” for COVID-19 (links to Bitchute pages removed):
When discussing any cure for COVID, the first thing to note is that neither health officials nor politicians are interested in a cure. Therefore, to expect any kind of medical sanity or truth from the FDA about what is and is not safe and effective to treat or cure COVID is a bad idea. Trusting the FDA about anything is like trusting a thief or pathological liar.
There is a massive, yawning gulf between what pharmaceutical companies want us to believe about health and medical treatments and reality. Decades of pharmaceutical propaganda have distorted people’s perception of reality so severely that at least half the population has slept [sic] walked into taking experimental vaccines so dangerous that if you die from them, life insurance companies will rule suicide.
They did it. No guns or concentration camps were needed. We have seen two years of them making the world their concentration camp. Pretty impressive. Lockdowns included. Hospitals were one of their primary weapons. There is no doubt that pharmaceutical terrorism is fully operational. However, people are starting to wake up and get smart. A video shot this past weekend in Paris, France, shows thousands of protesters surrounding the headquarters of Pfizer in the nation’s capital and chanting “assassins!”
As we approach the second anniversary of the World Health Organization officially declaring COVID-19 a pandemic, I must admit that before I encountered this post I had not encountered the conspiracy theory that if someone dies from a COVID-19 vaccine insurance companies won’t pay off a life insurance policy because they will rule the death a suicide. I might have to investigate that one further on my not-so-super-secret other blog, but right now doing so would be too much of a diversion. So I’ll just say one word: Wow. Also, sometimes even I can be surprised.
And, of course, Sircus thinks that the vaccines don’t work:
Just about everyone alive today is starting to understand that COVID genetic vaccines are not a cure; they do not stop infection, though perhaps they do provide, at best, temporary protection from the most severe forms of COVID, hospitalization, and death. However, I seriously doubt even that. The most obvious evidence of them not working is the need for boosters and the worldwide sky-high infection rates experienced by the vaccinated. Moreover, with millions of reported adverse reactions and uncountable vaccine deaths, even thinking of COVID vaccines as a cure is a disgusting medical perversion.
Of course, no one claimed that COVID-19 vaccines are a “cure,” although I will admit that they have often been oversold as the be-all and end-all to stop the pandemic, probably because, comparatively speaking and as difficult as even a mass vaccination program is, maintaining policies and mitigations to slow the spread of disease is so much more difficult, particularly given the flood of disinformation about masks and “lockdowns”—seriously, is there anywhere in the US or Europe where there’s anything even resembling a “lockdown” any more?—and the pandemic weariness of the public, vaccination is “easy.” Similarly, the emergence of variants like Delta and Omicron doesn’t mean that the vaccines don’t work. They were a not-unexpected and feared result of letting the virus circulate so widely, where the selective pressure on the virus has always been to develop the capability to spread more easily and quickly, vaccines or not. Similarly, what Sircus neglects to point out is that these variants, particularly Omicron, have shown as remarkable an ability to evade “natural” (more properly, infection-induced) immunity as they have to evade vaccine-induced immunity. Moreover, the need for vaccine boosters is not an indication that the vaccines don’t work, just that immunity from them can wane, just as “natural immunity” (again, more properly called infection-induced immunity or postinfection immunity) wanes as well. And don’t get me started on Sircus’ parroting of the antivaccine misuse of the VAERS database to misattribute reports there as definitely having been caused by the vaccine and thereby portray a “vaccine Holocaust“.
Similarly, it is just not true that “early treatment” has been ignored by big pharma and the medical profession (presumably in favor of the evil vaccine). Early in the pandemic, it was determined, for instance, that the steroid dexamethasone could decrease mortality from COVID-19, and physicians were so desperate that they repurposed the antimalarial drug hydroxychloroquine as a treatment, even in the absence of good evidence that it actually worked. Moreover, the development of drugs like Paxlovid and molnupiravir, both of which were intended to be early treatments for COVID-19 that could prevent its progression to severe disease, shows that finding effective antiviral treatments for COVID-19 has been a strategy to combat the pandemic since the beginning, a strategy that is only recently starting to bear fruit because drug development takes time. Of course, antivaccine conspiracy theorists like to refer to Paxlovid, for instance, as “Pfizermectin” based the mechanism of Paxlovid being protease inhibition, a mechanism supposedly shared by ivermectin, antivaxxer’s favorite repurposed drug that doesn’t work against COVID-19,.
But what about MMS?
Miracle Mineral Solution (a.k.a. chlorine dioxide bleach): The wonder drug?
Given the setup about how “early treatment” and “cures” for COVID-19 are supposedly being “suppressed”, all, apparently, to allow for tyrannical governments to impose “lockdowns” and mask mandates, while killing their citizens with a vaccine that doesn’t work—because “depopulation”?—Sircus gets into the meat of his claims for MMS, starting first with the observation that…well, let’s just look:
So what is chlorine dioxide, and why should everyone have some ready at home? Dr. Stephanie Seneff, writing for the Weston Price organization, says, “Chlorine dioxide (CD) is a strong oxidizing agent that has found many applications in wastewater treat­ment and food disinfection. It is popular among campers as a way to disinfect water taken from a lake or stream prior to using it as drinking water. In recent years, it has become a popular treatment choice among alternative medicine specialists for various diseases and conditions, despite the fact that the mainstream medical establishment has come down very hard against it. To say that it is controversial would be an understatement.”
Of course, it’s not really “controversial”; that is, unless you’re a believer. Physicians know that drinking a bleaching chemical most commonly used as a surface disinfectant and water purification chemical is incredibly unlikely to produce a therapeutic effect on a viral disease, just based on mechanism alone. It is interesting, however, to look at what the reference cited by Sircus also says about MMS:
Kerri Rivera is the mother of an autistic child. Like many other parents of autistic chil­dren, she was desperate to find a way to improve her child’s autistic symptoms. She spent over a million dollars trying to find a treatment that would work to heal her son. She was sufficiently impressed with the improvements she witnessed following CD treatment that she decided to become actively involved in promoting the idea that it might be useful for autism.
Kerri has developed a protocol to treat autism that includes various nutritional supplements (such as chondroitin sulfate and vitamin D) and a modified ketogenic diet that eliminates gluten and casein. Although the protocol can also include a number of other components— anti-parasitic medications, humic and fulvic acid, black seed oil, digestive enzymes, binders, thyroid supplements, ionic foot baths and hy­perbaric oxygen—she believes that an essential aspect is the idea of frequent tiny doses of CD throughout the day.
Before I briefly revisit Kerri Rivera’s claims, I’ll just remind readers that MMS is 28% sodium chlorite in distilled water. Proponents recommend diluting MMS in either water or a food acid, such as lemon juice, a process that results in the formation of chlorine dioxide. In essence, MMS is equivalent to an industrial-strength bleach and disinfectant. I’ll briefly revisit its history, as well, for those not familiar with it. MMS was originally sold by a man named Jim Humble, who has long claimed that MMS can be used to successfully treat AIDS, hepatitis A, B, and C, malaria, herpes, TB, most cancer and many more of mankind’s worse diseases. He even goes so far as to claim that 5,000,000 people have used MMS and that “hundreds of thousands” of lives have been saved. Unfortunately, it appears that for this function Jim Humble uses more concentrated MMS—a lot more concentrated. More horrifically, Humble bestows his “blessings” on poor people in less developed countries like Haiti.
Of course, Rivera has been featured on this blog before, beginning a decade ago when I wrote about how she was “bleaching away what ails you“, specifically in her case, autism. Perhaps the most horrific part of Rivera’s MMS protocol for autism was the method of use of MMS. She not only recommended feeding autistic children bleach until they started showing signs of becoming ill from it, but also advocated bleach enemas. What horrified me the most about this quackery is how MMS advocates misinterpreted the “strings” and “rope-like” things they fish out of their children’s stools as “parasites” dying from the MMS when in fact any surgeon or gastroenterologist would recognize them as sloughed pieces of the lining of the colon. At least Sircus doesn’t appear to recommend MMS enemas, but it’s likely because adults, unlike autistic children, would not be likely to stand for the discomfort that bleach enemas would cause.
Let’s return to Sircus’ claims. His “logic” (such as it is) is very much like the “logic” used by believers in colloidal silver, namely that if a substance is an effective antibacterial and antiviral agent for surfaces and water, then it will be a cure for bacterial and viral infections when taken internally:
Once dissolved in water, this gas releases free oxygen – much in the same way as hydrogen peroxide will. The magic happens when oxygen & chlorine are bound in one molecule; there are VERY few pathogens found in water that can survive coming into contact with this compound! This is why this compound has become the chemical of choice for water sanitation the world over!
Dr. Puya Yazdi states firmly, “Chlorine dioxide is an antiviral. It destroys the proteins on the outside of viruses and degrades the virus.”
Chlorine dioxide gas is effective against:
    • Human influenza (IFV)
    • Measles
    • Human herpes (HHV)
    • Human adenovirus (HAdVs)
    • Influenza A (in mice)
Chlorine dioxide solution also inactivated human and monkey rotaviruses (that cause diarrhea) and hepatitis A.
Again, it is important to emphasize that a chemical that can kill bacteria and inactivate viruses on surfaces and in water will rarely be effective doing the same thing in the body, usually because of the required concentrations involved. Colloidal silver, for instance, is used as a topical antibacterial agent to treat wounds, particularly burn wounds. It works because it is possible to get a high enough concentration of silver on the surface of a wound for it to work without too much of it being absorbed into the bloodstream at toxic levels. (Unsurprisingly, colloidal silver has been touted as a cure for COVID-19 as well.) Even at nontoxic doses, prolonged use of colloidal silver can produce argyria and turn you blue. As infectious disease specialist and former SBM blogger Mark Crislip once noted as well, it’s not even clear that colloidal silver is that great a medicine for burn wounds.
None of this stops Mr. Sircus from referring to MMS as the “Tiger tank of modern medicine“:
It is hard to dispute; once you get to know chlorine dioxide like millions already do, that it is the Tiger Tank of medicine, the point of the spear, an essential treatment that the FDA will never accept. It really is too good to be true, but it is true, as campers and water treatment systems have known for decades.
Being the World War II buff that I am—since junior high!—I can’t help but interject here the Tiger was a German heavy tank that was feared for its destructiveness and heavy armor that made it difficult to destroy or disable. I also can’t resist pointing out that the Tiger was also very expensive (costing twice as much per tank as a Panzer), difficult to manufacture, and very fuel inefficient, even for a tank. I thus suggest that Mr. Sircus’ analogy might not quite be the one he was looking for.
Sircus continues:
Chlorine dioxide empowers the immune system giving it a massive assist in its battle against pathogens and diseases. Though it is not the only oxygen therapy that can and should be employed, it is best if near-instant results are required, which is crucial if you come down with a COVID and suffer from a severe drop in oxygen.
Elsewhere, Mr. Sircus claims:
There are other ways to ram oxygen down our mitochondria’s throats. However, one of the best and least expensive ways is chlorine dioxide. Chlorine dioxide” is a substance that provides oxygen to tissues and all body fluids, activating the mitochondria of cells, which in turn generate more energy that allows the body to recover.
Dr. Andreas Klacher says, “Many debilitating secondary infections with their toxins will be neutralized, thus relieving the liver and kidneys. In addition, there is much more oxygen and thus much more energy in the body. Chlorine dioxide thus provides more quality of life and lifetime in the short term.”
While it is true that immune cells generate oxygen free radicals to attack and destroy pathogens, it does not follow from this physiological function of the immune system that ingesting an oxidizing agent will help the immune system generate this oxygen. For one thing, these cells generate high concentrations of these free radical in a hyperlocal fashion, releasing them when they are in close contact with the pathogen being attacked. For another thing, the low oxygen levels in the blood are different problem in that they are due to poor gas exchange in the lungs as a result of the inflammation caused by the virus and the immune response to it. Conceivably, adding more free radical to the mixture (if that were even possible using MMS) could just as likely make the clinical situation worse by increasing the inflammation in the lungs due to the immune system attacking the virus as make it better—probably more likely. Indeed, even if MMS did “ram oxygen down our mitochondrias’ throats” that would not necessarily be a good thing if it generated too many free radicals, which can damage DNA and proteins, potentially even killing cells (which could increase inflammation) and even be carcinogenic.
That reminds me. Mr. Sircus repeats the false antivax claim that COVID-19 vaccines can cause cancer, touting MMS as—you guessed it!—the cure for vaccine-induced cancer. Whom does he cite to support this claim? Andreas Kalcher, who, shockingly, appears to have been featured on this blog only one time before, in the context of a discussion of how Jim Humble and his Genesis II Church have been one of the primary promoters of MMS quackery around the world. Kalcker, it turns out, is quite the quack. He’s a true believer in MMS and has used it to treat autism, even using intravenous MMS to treat COVID-19. You heard that right, intravenous bleach! In addition to recommending the ingestion of bleach, bleach enemas, and bathing in bleach, there are quacks using intravenous bleach to treat COVID-19.
Also, why is Mr. Sircus referencing campers and water treatment systems? It is true that chlorine dioxide is used as a water treatment, both in water treatment systems and as water purification tablets for campers. It works mainly through oxidation to kill bacteria and inactivate viruses. It has some advantages over traditional chlorine, but is more expensive and is often used with chlorine to disinfect pools and water. Also:
Acute exposure of the skin to chlorine that originates from the decomposition of chlorine dioxide causes irritations and burns. Eye exposure eyes to chlorine dioxide causes irritations, watering eyes and a blurry sight. Chlorine dioxide gas can be absorbed by the skin, where it damages tissue and blood cells. Inhalation of chlorine dioxide gas causes coughing, a sore throat, severe headaches, lung oedema and bronchio spasma. The symptoms can begin to show long after the exposure has taken place and can remain for a long time. Chronical exposure to chlorine dioxide causes bronchitis. The health standard for chlorine dioxide is 0,1 ppm.
I would also note that the concentration used to disinfect water is generally on the order of 1-5 ppm, which is a very high concentration to try to achieve in the body. Of course, I’ve done the math before regarding the claimed use of MMS to treat children and found that the amount recommended in, for example, Kerri Rivera’s protocol is easily much more than 120 times the amount of chlorine dioxide a child would get from just drinking tap water.
Mr. Sircus even goes beyond this and claims that MMS is so miraculous that it can dissolve blood clots caused by COVID-19 spike protein. It is, of course, true that clotting is a major complication of COVID-19 resulting in cardiac and pulmonary complications that can (and often do) lead to death. Referencing Kalcker again, Sircus exults:
Chlorine dioxide works on the central damaging aspect of COVID vaccines, which is coagulation in the blood. “Normally doctors prescribe an anticoagulant, such as warfarin, which is a substance equal to rat poison, which in the long term, will cause strokes, etc. So it’s not a solution at all. However, chlorine dioxide is a solution because we have seen that it directly dissolves mini clots before they get bigger,” says Dr. Andreas Kalcker.
“Oxygen deprivation is the cause of death for most covid-19 victims. Chlorine dioxide floods the blood with oxygen, immediately enriching the hemoglobin molecules on red blood cells and allowing patients to breathe again,” continues Kalcker.
Notably, many sick and dying have red blood cells clumping together and are not moving freely. Severely clumped red blood cells (Rouleau) affect proper oxygenation because the red blood cells do not circulate well enough to deliver oxygen where it is needed. Early in the pandemic, New York physicians noted that it seemed COVID patients had been transported to 30,000 feet in altitude and were starving for oxygen. This video shows that after taking chlorine dioxide, the red blood cells regain proper size and shape and move freely through the blood.
Note first how Sircus blames COVID-19 vaccines for blood clots. While it’s true that certain COVID-19 vaccines have been associated with (rare) clotting issues, he doesn’t mention that COVID-19 itself is so much more likely to cause blood clots that are one of the consequences of the infection that endanger life than even the highest risk from the vaccine ginned up by the most hysterical antivaxxers that it is far, far safer to be vaccinated than it is to get COVID-19. That is not the narrative that quacks like Sircus like to promote, however.
I must admit that that video is…something else. Whoever made it claims to have had a person drink 280 ml of a 114 ppm solution of chlorine dioxide, touted as “3x the therapeutic dose” and having had a blood draw before and after. The claim is that the red blood cells go from clumped to freely moving, indicating that they can now deliver oxygen appropriately. Of course any hematopathologist or hematologist will tell you that the appearance of red blood cells under the microscope is highly dependent on a number of factors, in particular how long the sample has been sitting after being drawn and how it was prepared (anticoagulant included or not?). This exercise in microscopy is nothing more than glorified live blood analysis that tells us nothing informative. Moreover, even if you take this video at face value, it’s one person. Unless one can show effects in a large number of people and correlate them to actual functional changes that improve the ability of the red blood cells to transport oxygen—instead of just alleged changes in appearance—you’ve shown nothing.
I like to think of it as a Rorschach test, only using red blood cells instead of inkblots. Interestingly, even if you take this test at face value—which you definitely should not—it shows the “effect” of chlorine dioxide wearing off at two hours, which would imply that you’d better keep drinking bleach to maintain a steady state level. Of note, that’s not how even MMS advocates recommend using it.
Bleach will not treat or cure COVID-19
When COVID-19 first hit, those of us who had been deconstructing various forms of quackery and antivaccine misinformation fully expected that pretty much every quackery under the sun would be recommended for the new coronavirus disease. Even now, more than a decade after I first learned that “autism biomed” quacks were using bleach (MMS) to treat autism, which they (of course) believed to be caused by vaccines, I still shake my head that anyone could think that ingesting (or injecting) a strong oxidizing agent can treat a viral disease based on its properties disinfecting surfaces and water. Yet they do, and here we are. I suppose that I shouldn’t be so surprised, given that homeopaths think that they can also treat COVID-19.
Unfortunately, the latest installment in the MMS horror franchise is COVID-19.


The misuse and abuse of meta-analyses
The meta-analysis has been misused and weaponized to promote dubious COVID-19 treatments.
Scott Gavura on November 25, 2021
Link


Today’s post is a short one. The idea emerged as I read through the tireless blogging from David Gorski and others and the work of epidemiologists like Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz who have painstakingly gone through the ivermectin literature, trial-by-trial, even scrutinizing patient-level data, to uncover some truly poor science (some of which appears fraudulent). Through their work, they’ve exposed how research studies are being misrepresented, even weaponized, to promote the use of ivermectin.
This post is not about ivermectin. It is about the tools we use to bring some sense to the medical literature – and ways in which casual readers, and even seasoned professionals, can be misled. I want to summarize some of the methods used to compile and summarize evidence, and the approaches that can be used reduce biases and improve the quality of our conclusions and decisions about our health. 
Finding good evidence
To guide decision-making in medicine, we need effective methods to identify, compile, and analyze volumes of information. The amount of evidence that’s generated on a daily basis is near-impossible for anyone to keep up with, even if the specific topic you’re interested in is niche or narrow. New evidence can be unclear and even contradictory, and the “best evidence” can change quickly. Just look at how the pandemic guidance has changed since early 2020, from the utility of masks, the relevance of handwashing, and how to manage (what is now recognized as) an airborne infection.
Let’s say you’re interested in therapies to treat COVID-19 infections. The World Health Organization has cataloged over 334,000 publications in its COVID-19 database. If I restrict my search just to clinical trials for COVID-19 treatments, I’m still left with over 1,000 papers, with more emerging daily. How do we identify the high quality, most relevant evidence from weaker evidence – and how should we try to wrap our head around the totality of all of this data?
A single clinical trial is usually insufficient (though not impossible) to change clinical practice. That’s often because there are so many considerations when asking a specific clinical question and designing a trial. What dose? What patient population? What is the treatment protocol? What is the endpoint that’s being measured? How large was the trial? And was the trial conducted in a way to be a truly “fair test” of a treatment – meaning blinding and appropriate controls? Several trials, may be conducted by different investigators, with a mix of findings. What’s needed is a method to identify the best of the best, and to try to synthesize what may appear to be contradictory findings.
In a lot of cases, we rely on the work of others to give us that perspective. Narrative reviews (like a blog post!) are the quickest and easiest, but the most prone to bias, because the author can cherry-pick the evidence to comment on:

A narrative review tends to be a discussion of a topic, where the author decides what evidence is relevant and worth discussing. They may be written by experts who have a deep understanding of the topic, and will summarize pertinent data and make general conclusions. This is not to say that narrative reviews are necessarily inaccurate – only that they can be prone to biases that may not be easy to spot. A narrative review leaves the reader totally in the hands of the author. For that reason, reading one or more narrative reviews can be reasonable starting points to understanding a topic, but cannot be considered comprehensive or definitive summaries of the evidence base of a topic or clinical question.
Systematic reviews and meta-analyses
Sometimes we want to know what the best evidence says. The opposite of the narrative review is the systematic review. That’s where the evidence is formally and systematically searched and analyzed.
A systematic review is a summary of the evidence that addresses a specific question and uses explicit, rigorous, and transparent methods to identify, select, appraise, and combine research studies. The included trials must be identified from a systematic search, with pre-defined quality criteria, that should be published in advance of the search itself. Researchers will identify the search strategy, the selection criteria (which trials will be included) and the analytic methods that will be applied. Doing all this in advance reduces the risk of bias when the data is actually analyzed. PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) defines the minimum data requirements that should be reported in a systematic review, improving the quality, consistency, and transparency of reviews.
A meta-analysis can be part of a systematic review, but can also be done on its own. (A systematic review appraises data before it is combined and analyzed in a meta-analysis.) It is a statistical compilation of multiple studies that examine the same topic, and it can be a useful tool as part of a systematic review. Done carefully, then can give a “point estimate” (aka “best guess”) of an effect that may be more precise than any of the individual trials that were included. But just as individual clinical trials can be biased, so can meta-analyses. Meta-analyses cannot correct for fundamentally poor source data. That is, they cannot glean accurate information from flawed research. The “garbage in, garbage out” adage applies here. Moreover, if different trials measured different endpoints, then they cannot be combined in a meta-analysis. Or you’ll see something kind of like this:

This is statistical heterogeneity, as discussed in a post by Dr. William Paolo back in August:
When analyzing the results of a meta-analysis it is imperative to focus on the degree of statistical heterogeneity to determine if the resultant point estimate of the compiled studies are, in fact, similar enough to be combined into a singular parsimonious estimate of effect. Theoretically, multiple smaller studies can be pooled and analyzed as a singular body of evidence if the component studies are of analogous design and methodology (allocation concealment, randomization, intention to treat analysis etc.) or rejected if this is not the case. It is required that the included studies be the same in terms of design, inclusion and exclusion criteria, demographics, equivalent doses of an intervention, outcomes, and a myriad of other factors to comfortably combine said studies into a unitary body of evidence. Concordant with this is the expectation that if the included studies of a meta-analysis are of equal kind that experimentally derived results, taken under similar conditions, should roughly approximate one another. In other words, all things being equal, the same exact experiment done in multiple places by different people should roughly find the same results if the studies are in fact similar enough to be analyzed as one.
Ivermectin trial alchemy
With the above in mind, let’s take a closer look at how the meta-analysis has been misused in the pandemic. Ivmmeta.com is a site that is frequently cited by advocates of ivermectin which, as David Gorski first discussed way back in June, seemed to brought to us by the people that created hcqmeta.com (Remember hydroxychloroquine? How vintage.) It’s impressive, in an information-overload kind of way, claiming to be a “real-time meta-analysis of 67 studies”. Rather than go through the criticisms of the website in detail, I will point you to the writing and blogging of Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz who has scrutinized the data presented – and the website’s response to his initial criticisms.
In something of a hilarious development, the ivmmeta authors have added a section titled "with GMK exclusions" to their website
Unfortunately, this still includes endless awful studies. Let's take a look at some of the papers that remain on this website https://t.co/moT5tNnD1n
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) October 26, 2021
In short, ivmmeta.com (or sister sites, like c19ivermectin.com) does not adequately take into account the quality and diversity of the data it is combining. As David Gorski highlighted, there are warnings in the actual literature about this:
Different websites (such as https://ivmmeta.com/, https://c19ivermectin.com/, https://tratamientotemprano.org/estudios-ivermectina/, among others) have conducted meta-analyses with ivermectin studies, showing unpublished colourful forest plots which rapidly gained public acknowledgement and were disseminated via social media, without following any methodological or report guidelines. These websites do not include protocol registration with methods, search strategies, inclusion criteria, quality assessment of the included studies nor the certainty of the evidence of the pooled estimates. Prospective registration of systematic reviews with or without meta-analysis protocols is a key feature for providing transparency in the review process and ensuring protection against reporting biases, by revealing differences between the methods or outcomes reported in the published review and those planned in the registered protocol. These websites show pooled estimates suggesting significant benefits with ivermectin, which has resulted in confusion for clinicians, patients and even decision-makers. This is usually a problem when performing meta-analyses which are not based in rigorous systematic reviews, often leading to spread spurious or fallacious findings.36
You might be asking at this point – has anyone actually done a robust systematic review of ivermectin? The answer is yes, and the results will not surprise (spoiler: ivermectin doesn’t seem to work).
A tool, not a quality indicator
        ◦ All types of data can be combined into a meta-analysis. When used to study high-quality trials of similar populations that used similar methods, they can be powerful tools. But a meta-analysis is just a tool, and cannot make gold out of lead. Combining poor quality studies that are not sufficiently similar in a meta-analysis does not give us any useful information. Moreover, in the absence of rigorous, transparent, and pre-specified rules, meta-analyses are prone to bias, just like the source clinical trials themselves. Meta-analyses prepared outside the framework of a rigorous systematic review should be viewed with caution.

Jumping the Gun: Antibody Drugs for Covid-19
Why did the US government promise to buy a product that had failed testing?
Harriet Hall on November 10, 2020
Link

The Eli Lilly company has announced a deal with the U.S. government. The government will pay Eli Lilly $375 million to deliver 300,000 doses of its experimental Covid-19 antibody drug over two months, with an option to purchase another 600,000 doses by June 30. They anticipate manufacturing up to a million doses by the end of 2020. Patients will have no out-of-pocket costs. The deal is contingent on Eli Lilly being granted an emergency use authorization (EUA). The drug failed to show a benefit in hospitalized patients but the company “is confident the drug is helpful to those earlier in the course of the disease”. I question whether a failed study and the company’s “confidence” are enough to justify an EUA.
Several companies have been testing monoclonal antibody drugs, singly or as cocktails of two or more antibodies, as a potential treatment for Covid-19. Some of the early results were promising. President Trump was given Regeneron’s experimental antibody cocktail along with several other treatments when he was hospitalized at Walter Reed. He recovered but couldn’t possibly know what was responsible for his improvement. Nevertheless, he hyped Regeneron’s drug, calling it miraculous, announcing that it had cured him.
Regeneron had recently released data showing that its drug, a cocktail of two lab-generated antibodies, appeared to help the body clear the virus when it was given early in the disease. The trials were not complete and had not been published. Giving it to the President was authorized under “compassionate use” guidelines for experimental drugs.
A spokesperson for the company said:
We feel like the early indications of antiviral activity and potential impact on the clinical course of disease is very promising
But several authorities questioned the wisdom of giving it to the President. “It is bad science, bad medicine and bad ethics to give unproven things to powerful people”, wrote Dr. Vinay Prasad in a Twitter post. Another doctor commented, “V.I.P. medicine doesn’t mean better medicine when there is no data”. And of course, our own David Gorski weighed in.
On October 30, 2020, Regeneron announced additional results from an ongoing phase 2/3 placebo-controlled trial in outpatients. They confirmed earlier reports that treatment with REGN-COV2 reduced viral load and time to alleviate symptoms, and additionally reduced medical visits by up to 72% in patients with one or more risk factors. They have submitted results to the FDA requesting an EUA. Other studies are ongoing, including an open-label study of inpatients and a trial for prevention of the disease in household contacts of infected individuals.
Regeneron has announced a federal supply deal that lacks some of the customary protections. It is a $450 million contract to supply up to 300 million doses to the government for national distribution. It was negotiated through a third party and details are not available.
Vaccines
Currently there are 149 Covid-19 vaccines in preclinical development and 38 in clinical trials. Even if one of them is a clear winner, it will still take a long time to scale up production and there are already discussions about the ethics and practical challenges of vaccine allocation while supply is limited.
The government has made deals for experimental vaccines, too. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has announced a $1.5 billion deal with Moderna for the first 100 million doses with an option to buy up to 400 million more doses. The 53-page contract is full of redactions and details are sketchy.
Emergency use authorizations
The FDA can issue emergency use authorizations (EUA) for experimental drugs. The recent experience with hydroxychloroquine is a cautionary tale. The FDA issued an EUA for hydroxychloroquine in March 2020 but quickly had to revoke it 3 months later, in June, because every single good study had found it ineffective for Covid-19 and it was known to cause serious side effects.
Conclusion: Questionable use of taxpayer dollars
I’m puzzled. Eli Lilly did a clinical trial, and its product failed to do what it was supposed to do, but the US government agreed to buy the product anyway, for over $300 million, and give it to patients. What is going on here? The pandemic is a health emergency, and I understand the need to get treatments approved as quickly as possible, and it might make sense to expedite delivery by starting to manufacture a drug before the studies are complete, assuming the studies are well done and are showing strong promise. But when one company has positive evidence from clinical trials, is there any justification for making a deal with another company that has only negative evidence and “confidence”? I just don’t get it. Maybe someone can explain it to me.

Zinc and COVID
Should you take a zinc supplement to prevent a COVID-19 infection?
Scott Gavura on November 26, 2020
Link

It’s been a few months since I blogged about hydroxychloroquine and COVID-19, and I’m still getting emails defending its use, even as more and more evidence has emerged to show that it is not effective to prevent or treat the disease, regardless of setting. It seems, according to some disgruntled readers, that I didn’t properly account for the magical healing powers of zinc in my analysis. I regularly receive apparent statements of fact like “The hydroxychloroquine helps zinc to enter cells and stop the virus,” backed not by references, but by ALL CAPS telling me just how ignorant I am to even write about the topic. So today’s post is a closer look at zinc.
Zinc as an antiviral is nothing new. It’s one of the first “alternative” medicines I remember researching way back in the 1990s, when claims circulated that zinc lozenges could shorten the duration of a cold. And the studies into zinc lozenges go way back into the 1980s. Working often in community pharmacy settings, there were regular requests for zinc lozenges during cold and flu seasons, usually followed by complaints from consumers about their (lack of) palatability. It’s been a topic of this blog over the years, most notably when a “homeopathic” zinc spray was identified that (1) actually contained zinc and (2) caused a loss of the ability to smell.
Do we need zinc at all?
In short, yes. Zinc is a trace mineral with functions throughout the body. Zinc deficiency is a significant issue worldwide where access to a healthy diet and adequate calories is a problem. In diets where foods that contain zinc (e.g., meat, shellfish, chicken, nuts, lentils) are consumed regularly, zinc deficiency is less common, but still possible. Depending on where you live, some foods may be fortified with zinc, such as breakfast cereals. Severe deficiencies when food access is not a problem are more common where there are chronic diseases that cause reduced absorption (e.g., inflammatory bowel diseases) or as a consequence of gastrointestinal tract surgery. Some medications can increase the body’s loss of zinc as well (e.g., diuretics).
A severe zinc deficiency is most commonly associated with impaired growth, but the effects include immune system dysfunction. So being deficient in zinc could conceivably affect your susceptibility or response to a COVID-19 infection, but there is no evidence to suggest that supplementing with zinc has any meaningful effects. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, and the signals of benefit that have appeared in research studying zinc supplementation and the common cold (which can be caused by coronaviruses, among other viruses) has led to questions about whether or not zinc is a reasonable preventative option to try, considering overall risks and benefits.
The evidence for zinc to prevent or treat the common cold
There is no evidence to suggest that zinc-containing nasal sprays are safe or effective and they should be avoided. The same can be said for anything labelled as “homeopathic”. The preparations that have been the most studied are lozenges and tablets. One systematic review, published in 2011, identified 13 placebo-controlled trials with wide variation in doses. Low doses (<75mg/day) were found to be ineffective and trials with higher doses were founds to reduce the duration of colds (by 42%), but not their incidence. Another systematic review included 17 trials that compared zinc to placebo or no treatment. This analysis found that zinc reduced the duration of cold symptoms (by an average of 1.65 days) but the results varied widely across the trials. This review noted that adverse events (taste, nausea) were more common in the zinc group. Finally a Cochrane review from 2013 was withdrawn in 2015, citing concerns with the data analysis. It remains withdrawn as of the last update in 2016.
So should you take zinc to prevent or treat COVID-19?
Malnutrition in general is associated with reduced immunity, so situations where zinc deficiency is known, or highly likely, should be addressed, just as they should be for other vitamin deficiencies. There is some evidence that lower zinc levels may be associated with poorer outcomes from COVID-19 infections. Whether it’s the zinc, or zinc is just a surrogate for another factor, is not established.
Supplementing with zinc, in the absence of a known deficiency, is trickier. One approach for those interested in minimizing any risk, even theoretical, could include looking at your diet and then evaluating whether it is providing you with adequate zinc. For most of you without major medical conditions or restrictive diets, it probably is. Regular supplementation in the absence of a deficiency has some risks, however, as long-term high doses can interfere with copper absorption. Moreover, zinc is not easy to take as a supplement, especially in lozenge form, and can cause nausea and stomach upset. If you are feeling sick and decide to start supplementing with zinc lozenges, there is no persuasive evidence to suggest that it will be harmful, but neither is there good evidence to suggest it will offer you much benefit. And if in spite of the lack of evidence, you want to take a zinc supplement routinely, it will likely be safe as long as you keep the daily dose low (stay under 40mg/day, if you’re an adult). Just keep distancing, masking, and avoiding crowded indoor spaces.

Vitamin D shows no efficacy against moderate to severe COVID-19 infections
A new trial failed to find evidence that a massive dose of vitamin D improves outcomes in patients with moderate to severe COVID-19 infections.
Scott Gavura on March 4, 2021
Link


Vitamin D has long been thought to play a role in supporting immune function, in addition to effects on muscle and bone. Given many people live where there is inadequate sunlight to support vitamin D synthesis for parts of the year, there has been widespread interest in the possible role of vitamin D supplements to help raise vitamin D levels, and possibly prevent infection or minimize the severity of disease. Last September, Dr. Anthony Fauci noted that he was among the millions of Americans that take vitamin D supplements, elevating interest in this supplement. Now a new randomized controlled trial investigates the effects of a single massive dose of vitamin D in hospitalized COVID-19 patients.
What did we already know about COVID-19 and vitamin D?
Dozens of observational studies published since the pandemic began have examined the relationship between vitamin D and COVID-19 infections. Other publications have tried to make sense of all of these studies. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) published guidelines on vitamin D and COVID-19 in December 2020 which incorporated a comprehensive evidence review. It found little evidence for vitamin D to prevent COVID-19 infections:
The panel discussed the evidence for the association of vitamin D status with COVID‑19. They agreed that low vitamin D status was associated with more severe outcomes from COVID‑19. However, it is not possible to confirm causality because many of the risk factors for severe COVID‑19 outcomes are the same as the risk factors for low vitamin D status. Vitamin D is a negative acute phase reactant, meaning its serum concentration falls during a systemic inflammatory response, which may occur during severe COVID-19 illness. Therefore, it is difficult to know if low vitamin D status causes poorer outcomes or vice versa.
The panel discussed the significant limitations in the retrospective association studies. These included historic and inaccurate vitamin D status measurements, lack of generalisability to UK practice, the likelihood of confounding and general low quality of the evidence.
The panel reviewed only one controlled trial that used vitamin D to treat COVID-19, which used oral calcifediol (the circulating metabolite of vitamin D). While the stated outcome of the trial was positive (reduced need for ICU treatment), the panel noted several concerns with the design and approach, leading to the conclusion there remained insufficient evidence to support routine use. Notwithstanding the evidence for prevention and treatment, the panel noted that vitamin D deficiency is widespread in the United Kingdom, so it recommended the everyone should consider a supplement in the winter months, and some should continue supplementing year-round. It did not recommend vitamin D solely to prevent or treat COVID-19, except as part of a clinical trial.
Another comprehensive summary was published in January 2021 by Alberta Health Services which summarizes 12 studies, selected based on quality criteria. This review noted that most of these studies found a statistically significant difference with greater deficiency in those with COVID-19 or more severe disease. However, vitamin D deficiency may be an indicator of general nutritional deficiency, or overall health status. That is, it is possible that this is an association only, and not a causal relationship:
There is an overlap between groups at high risk of vitamin D deficiency and groups at high risk of severe COVID-19. Examples include people with chronic disease, older age, and people of Black and minority ethnic heritage, which makes assessment of observed associations between low vitamin D and COVID-19 infection challenging. Vitamin D levels may be indicative of co-morbidities that may themselves impact COVID-19 outcomes, so whether low vitamin D levels are a cause of disease or consequence of health disparity has remained a point of debate.
The report also identified three prospective randomized controlled trials assessing vitamin D in hospitalized patients with COVID-19, noting the largest trial showed no benefit.This report also noted that it is important to have adequate vitamin D levels, regardless of any potential effects on COVID-19. It recommended that health care providers and patients follow supplementation guidelines established by Health Canada.
So based on these two reviews from the United Kingdom and Alberta, there is sufficient evidence to support routine supplementation of vitamin D, but insufficient evidence to suggest that vitamin D supplementation can help prevent or treat COVID-19.
What did this new study find?
Recognizing that many people are vitamin D deficient and noting the correlation between low vitamin D status and outcomes of COVID-19, this study measured the effect of vitamin D (as vitamin D3, the version usually sold in stores) on hospital length of stay in patients hospitalized with moderate to severe COVID-19. The study is from Igor H. Murai and colleagues from the University of Sao Paulo in Brazil, and was published February 17, 2021 in The Journal of the American Medical Association.
This was a double-blind, multi-site, randomized, placebo-controlled trial that enrolled 240 patients from June through August, 2020. In order to be included participants had to be at least 18 years old, had a confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19, and clinical signs that suggested moderate to severe COVID-19. People were excluded if they were already taking vitamin D3 supplementation or had a number of other factors.
Participants were randomized to a single oral dose of 200,000 IU of vitamin D (that is 200 tablets if you take 1,000 IU tablets, a dose sold in many stores) or placebo. Rather than tablets, the study used vitamin D dissolved in peanut oil. The 200,000 IU dose was chosen as it is in the recommended range for treating individuals with vitamin D deficiency. The primary outcome measured was length of stay, but they also measured in-hospital mortality, the number of patients admitted to the intensive care unit, the number of patients requiring mechanical ventilation, and serum levels of vitamin D. After randomization the groups were fairly evenly matched, with an average age of 56 years and about 55% males.
Effects of Vitamin D supplementation
Before we look at the efficacy, let’s take a look at the effects of this massive supplement on serum vitamin D levels. In Figure 3 (below) vitamin D levels are shown on the day of randomization and also on the day of discharge. In all patients, as well as those who were admitted with a vitamin D deficiency, the vitamin D supplement significantly raised vitamin D levels:
Effects on hospitalization
There were no significant differences between the two groups with respect to the primary endpoint. This was consistent for all patients as well as those who had been admitted with a vitamin D deficiency:
There were no significant differences between the groups for any of the secondary outcomes. No significant adverse events were reported with the exception of one patient who vomited the vitamin D dose.
A companion editorial raises concerns about several limitations in the trial, which are worth noting:
First, the study was underpowered. The authors state that the number of participants was chosen on the basis of feasibility, and that with 208 participants they would have 80% power to detect a 50% difference in hospital length of stay, which is a highly improbable result. Second, the authors excluded patients who required invasive mechanical ventilation and those admitted to the intensive care unit, and less than 15% of patients required noninvasive ventilation. Accordingly, most of the patient population would be considered moderately ill and the results cannot be generalized to critically ill patients, who were excluded. This is important because the benefit of other anti-inflammatory therapies among patients with COVID-19 (e.g., dexamethasone, tocilizumab) is highly dependent on severity of illness, with moderately ill patients receiving little or no benefit and severely ill patients receiving a substantial benefit.13–15 Third, only 115 study participants (48.3%) had vitamin D deficiency (25[OH]D <20 ng/mL), and only about one-fourth of the patients had severe vitamin D deficiency (25[OH]D <12 ng/mL) (based on Figure 3 in the article12). Fourth, although the authors demonstrated that circulating levels of 25(OH)D increased in the patients who received vitamin D3, they did not measure circulating levels of 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, the active form of vitamin D. Accordingly, it is unclear whether patients were able to efficiently convert 25(OH)D to 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, because this conversion is inhibited by the osteocyte-derived hormone fibroblast growth factor 23, which is elevated in acutely ill patients.
Vitamin D doesn’t seem to help COVID-19, but supplements may still be advisable
In this randomized controlled trial, a single large dose of vitamin D had no effect on outcomes in hospitalized COVID-19 patients. This was despite the measurable effectiveness of the supplement at significantly raising serum vitamin D levels. Prospective trials with vitamin D in COVID have been relatively rare, and have suffered from poor quality and mixed results. The findings from this large trial gives more strength to the hypothesis that low vitamin D levels may correlate with poor COVID-19 outcomes, but may not be worsening them. Having said that, there is good evidence that many people have vitamin D deficiency, and supplementation may in fact be appropriate. But there is no strong evidence to suggest that supplementation will help protect you from severe COVID-19 infections.

The effectiveness of zinc and vitamin C on the duration of COVID-19 infections
Vitamin C and zinc have been heralded as treatments for colds for decades, but how well do they work against COVID-19? A new clinical trial provides the answer.
Scott Gavura on February 18, 2021
Link
In 1747, James Lind proved that scurvy could be prevented by a diet that included citrus fruit. It wasn’t until 1912 that the active ingredient, ascorbic acid (later called vitamin C), was discovered. Scurvy has been relatively rare since that time in populations with access to a varied diet. We likely wouldn’t have pharmacy shelves lined with bottles of vitamin C today if it were not for Linus Pauling, who spent the later parts of an otherwise brilliant scientific career touting megavitamin therapy, with, among other supplements, vitamin C. Since the 1970s, massive doses of vitamin C in those without deficiency have shown no meaningful medicinal effects, but the vitamin retains a health halo among alternative medicine proponents that is utterly resistant to research that shows it to be, on balance, useless.
COVID-19 emerged just over a year ago and has resulted in a pandemic the likes of which has not been seen in generations. While many patients only experience mild symptoms, some patients progress to severe illness, hospitalization, and death. Because most cases are mild and because the likelihood of progressing to severe disease isn’t perfectly predictable, it is perhaps not surprising that (1) many people, understandably fearing severe disease, will try any number of folk remedies, and (2) because most people recover, that their recovery may be attributed to whatever treatment approach they followed, no matter how unorthodox or implausible.
Vitamin C and zinc have been touted as effective treatments for the common cold for decades. While the evidence is poor for vitamin C and weak (but better) for zinc, the virus that causes COVID-19, SARS-CoV-2, is a coronavirus, and coronaviruses can also cause the common cold. Yes it’s a stretch, but anything that could potentially help reduce the morbidity and mortality of COVID-19 would be welcomed, and given the public’s embrace of zinc and vitamin C for colds, it was perhaps warranted to test these two products for their effectiveness against COVID-19 disease. The results will not surprise you.
The evidence to date
I blogged about zinc and COVID-19 last November. At that time there were no clinical trials that studied zinc for preventing or treating SARS-CoV-2 infections. The evidence for colds (which can be caused by coronaviruses) is promising, but weak overall, only possibly modestly reducing the duration of colds. In terms of COVID-19 trials with Vitamin C, I found 45 clinical trials in the COVID-19 / WHO clinical trials database. Searching PubMed for published clinical trials, I could only find this protocol studying intravenous high-dose vitamin C, and the results have not been published. Another open-label trial found no benefit from high-dose intravenous vitamin C. An open-label pilot trial in China also showed no benefit in terms of “invasive mechanical ventilation-free days”. Even outside of COVID-19 infections and looking at the critically ill more generally, there is no strong evidence for its use. So that brings us to the current trial.
COVID A to Z
This trial was published on February 12, 2021, and is from Thomas et al. from the Cleveland Clinic. The “COVID A to Z Clinical Trial” was a randomized controlled trial intended to study adults diagnosed with a SARS-CoV-2 infection who were expected to recover at home. The trial enrolled only adults and participants were randomized to one of four groups:
     1.  8,000 mg of ascorbic acid (to be divided over 2-3 times per day with meals) for 10 days,
     2.  50 mg of zinc gluconate at bedtime for 10 days,
     3.  both therapies for 10 days, or
     4.  usual care (no treatment)
Participants were asked to track their symptoms daily, and to complete a survey until day 28 to assess hospitalization and adverse effects. The primary end point was the number of days from the time of peak symptom score to a 50% resolution in those symptoms. They also measured the number of days to reach a symptom score of zero, as well as the incidence of hospitalizations, death, other medications, and adverse events.
The trial was intended to recruit 520 participants but an interim analysis was completed after 214 patients were enrolled. Based on pre-specified stopping rules, the trial was then terminated for futility, as there were no meaningful differences between the three treatment groups and the control group that received no treatment.
The average age of participants was 45 years old, 62% women and 38% were current or former smokers. At least one-quarter had used vitamins and minerals previously.
There was no significant difference in the time required to reach a 50% reduction in symptoms. In the usual care group, this was 6.7 days, while it was 5.5 days in the ascorbic acid group, 5.9 days in the zinc gluconate group, and 5.5 days in the group that received both products:

In terms of secondary endpoints, there were no significant differences in any parameter. Few reported any adverse effects, with slightly more in the vitamin C group.
Not promising but also not harmful
This was a prospective trial of two supplements intended to simulate what someone might do if told they had a COVID-19 infection – take large doses for the duration of the illness with the hope that it will support recovery and reduce the risk of severe disease. This trial showed that these products, in these doses, had no measurable effects on the severity of COVID-19 infections. This is perhaps not surprising given the evidence for vitamin C and zinc against colds is not impressive, so there was weak plausibility for a strong treatment effect. However, both of these supplements were generally well tolerated, and there were also no serious negative consequences from their use. So while there is no evidence, based on this trial, to support their use, those that choose to take these supplements in line with this trial can also be reassured that they are unlikely to cause themselves any harm.

Does convalescent plasma work against COVID-19? Who knows?
Last night, the FDA issued an emergency use authorization (EUA) for convalescent plasma to treat COVID-19, even though there are no randomized clinical trials demonstrating efficacy and safety. Does this plasma work? Who knows? But that didn’t stop the FDA from issuing the EUA, almost certainly as a result of intense political pressure from the Trump Administration.
David Gorski on August 24, 2020
Link

Normally, I try to write my weekly post for this blog by Saturday. Unfortunately, for whatever reason, this weekend Sunday afternoon arrived, and I hadn’t yet written my post. Sure, I had started a post, but I wasn’t really happy with the topic or how it was coming out, which is probably why I hadn’t finished it by my usual time. Then, on Sunday afternoon, I started seeing stories like this one in The Washington Post:
On the eve of the Republican National Convention where President Trump hopes to revive his flagging political fortunes, he will announce the emergency authorization of convalescent plasma for covid-19, a treatment that already has been given to more than 70,000 patients, according to officials familiar with the decision.
In a tweet late Saturday night, White House press secretary Kayleigh McEnany said the announcement at 5:30 p.m. Sunday involved “a major therapeutic breakthrough on the China virus.” Officials confirmed on Sunday the treatment is convalescent plasma; they spoke on the condition of anonymity because they weren’t authorized to discuss the issue. The White House declined to comment.
I must admit that when I heard about McEnany’s Tweet about an announcement of a “major therapeutic breakthrough” for COVID-19, I had a sneaking suspicion that it might be something like Oleandrin, the extract from the oleander plant whose utter lack of evidence of efficacy against COVID-19 (other than an in vitro study in cell culture) was discussed last week by our very own Steve Novella. It was just a sneaking suspicion, because, as has been discussed, oleander is toxic and there’s no evidence that it works against COVID in humans. That’s thin gruel even for Donald Trump to hold a press conference to make an announcement of a “therapeutic breakthrough”, even if the CEO and founder of MyPillow.com Mike Lindell had also endorsed Oleandrin. After all, if Anderson Cooper could slice, dice, and humiliate Lindell on live TV, I suspect that even Trump would be reluctant to come back for seconds.
So it makes sense that the announcement would be about a treatment with some biological plausibility, and this announcement gave me the chance to take a look at the current evidence for the use of convalescent plasma to treat COVID-19.
What is convalescent plasma?
The use of convalescent plasma to treat infectious disease is a very old concept, dating back over 100 years. In brief, the use of convalescent plasma is a form of passive immunization in which plasma from patients who have survived an infectious disease is collected and used to treat patients with active disease. The idea behind the use of this plasma is quite simple, namely that the antibodies against the disease present in the convalescent plasma will bind to the microorganism causing the disease and thereby help a patient with the disease mount an effective immune response against the organism.
Because I’m a history buff, I couldn’t resist reading a bit about the history of convalescent plasma as a treatment for infectious disease. Generally, it was thought that the first application of convalescent plasma for this indication was during the 1918 influenza pandemic, and, as noted in this article, there were several studies carried out during that pandemic suggesting that the plasma could be effective in decreasing mortality. A meta-analysis of eight reports from that time involving 1,703 patients was even published in 2006, confirming the benefit. True, the studies from the time were not randomized, double blind, or placebo-controlled, but the risk reduction for death was impressive, as this excerpt of the abstract shows:
Eight relevant studies involving 1703 patients were found. Treated patients, who were often selected because of more severe illness, were compared with untreated controls with influenza pneumonia in the same hospital or ward. The overall crude case-fatality rate was 16% (54 of 336) among treated patients and 37% (452 of 1219) among controls. The range of absolute risk differences in mortality between the treatment and control groups was 8% to 26% (pooled risk difference, 21% [95% CI, 15% to 27%]). The overall crude case-fatality rate was 19% (28 of 148) among patients who received early treatment (after <4 days of pneumonia complications) and 59% (49 of 83) among patients who received late treatment (after ≥4 days of pneumonia complications). The range of absolute risk differences in mortality between the early treatment group and the late treatment group was 26% to 50% (pooled risk difference, 41% [CI, 29% to 54%]). Adverse effects included chill reactions and possible exacerbations of symptoms in a few patients.
In actuality, though, this sort of therapy had been tried against polio in New York in 1916. The first documented use of convalescent plasma therapy was in Italy in 1906, when Francesco Cenci, a public health doctor working in a small town of Central Italy near Perugia, used serum from a 20 year old man who had just recovered from the measles to prevent measles infection in four children. Later in 1906, Cenci used convalescent serum to treat a child seriously ill with the measles complicated by pneumonia. Cenci also reported that a similar treatment had been made on two children in 1900, in the Pediatric Clinic of Rome directed by Luigi Concetti, that was thought to be the first to use serotherapy against diphtheria in Italy, after the seminal studies by Emil Behring and Shibasaburo Kitasato. By way of additional history, the first reference to antibodies came from Emil von Behring and Shibasabura Kitasato in 1890, when they showed that the transfer of serum from animals immunized against diphtheria to animals suffering from it could cure the infected animals, although investigators had been experimenting with such methods going back to 1880 or so. In any event, Behring was later awarded the Nobel Prize for this work in 1901.
Since then, convalescent plasma has been tried and used for a variety of infectious diseases, with possible therapeutic efficacy claimed for the management of measles, Argentine haemorrhagic fever, influenza, chickenpox, infections by cytomegalovirus, parvovirus B19 and, more recently, Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV), H1N1 and H5N1 avian flu, and severe acute respiratory infections (SARI) viruses. Convalescent plasma has also been used in Ebola virus disease, with some reports of success dating back to the 1970s, when the disease was first described. Unfortunately, most of the studies of convalescent plasma for various infectious diseases have been of low quality, and many weren’t randomized. Unsurprisingly, with the rise of antibiotics and other antimicrobial therapies in the mid 20th century, interest in convalescent plasma to treat infectious disease waned, only to reappear periodically whenever there is a new epidemic or pandemic for which there is no effective treatment; i.e., Ebola virus, H1N1 influenza, severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in 2003, and MERS in 2012. Indeed, successes using convalescent plasma for these latter two diseases established the precedent for using the same treatment for COVID-19.

Of course, the use of antibodies to treat a viral disease makes sense, although their use has had a mixed history. The concept is, as I mentioned above, simple, and well described in this article (from which the figure above was taken and is under Creative Commons license):
The convalescent plasma therapeutic approach is based on the principle of passive antibody therapy, a short-term strategy whereby antibodies from the blood of someone who recovered from an infection can be administered to protect or treat another person [6, 21]. Effectively, the end goal is the same as vaccines, making antibodies against a specific infectious agent readily available. For instance, a vaccine relies on the host immune cells (B lymphocytes specifically) to produce antibodies after antigen recognition and signal amplification by the immune system, a process that may take weeks [24]; on the other hand, in the case of passive antibody therapy, the process is expedited by providing a patient with immediate immunity when the premade antibodies are given. Therefore, for COVID-19 patients, the expedited approach could prove lifesaving. Nevertheless, this advantage does not come without caveats, as immunization with passive antibody therapy is typically of shorter-term protection, in part because of the half-life of antibodies in circulation [25] and lack of new production by B lymphocytes. Today, passive antibody therapy relies primarily on pooled immunoglobulin preparations that contain high concentrations of antibodies. In contrast, plasma has been used emergently in epidemics in which there is insufficient time or resources to generate immunoglobulin preparations [21].
The practicality of using pooled immunoglobulin preparations or convalescent plasma to treat COVID-19 during a pandemic is also questionable, given that immunoglobulins are a blood product that has to be collected from donors who have recovered from COVID-19, and it is questionable whether, even if it is effective, there would be enough supply to meet the needs of patients suffering from severe COVID-19 disease. Also, because convalescent plasma is a blood product, there is a non-zero risk of transmitting blood-borne disease from it. True, the risk is quite low, given how we now test blood products for viruses like hepatitis B and HIV, but it is not zero. Finally, antibody therapy generally is most effective when administered prophylactically or implemented early after the onset of symptoms.
Convalescent plasma to treat COVID-19: Does it work? Who knows?
There were already rumblings last week that something like this might happen, that Trump might push the FDA to issue an emergency use authorization (EUA), the same way he pressured the FDA to issue an ill-advised EUA for hydroxychloroquine, a drug that, according to the latest randomized controlled trials, does not work in severe or mild COVID-19 or work to prevent COVID-19 when used as prophylaxis after a known exposure to a person with the disease. Unfortunately, none of the increasingly negative evidence has stopped the propaganda or astroturfing promoting hydroxychloroquine as a “game changer” or way out of the pandemic, even after the FDA had revoked the EUA for the drug in June. For example, there was this Tweet on Saturday morning:
The deep state, or whoever, over at the FDA is making it very difficult for drug companies to get people in order to test the vaccines and therapeutics. Obviously, they are hoping to delay the answer until after November 3rd. Must focus on speed, and saving lives! @SteveFDA
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 22, 2020
Regular readers know that I consider this sort of statement from the President to be very dangerous, as it is basically accusing the FDA of plotting against a COVID-19 treatment or vaccine that is safe and effective. Anyone who knows how the FDA works knows how ridiculous that accusation is. In addition, it’s a perfect sort of statement for COVID-19 deniers to point to, to bolster their claims of a conspiracy to bypass regulations in order to approve drugs and treatments that are unproven and possibly even toxic, mainly because Trump is arguably doing just that.
That was only the latest indication, though. Three weeks ago, for instance, President Trump was praising convalescent plasma, his administration having funneled $48 million into a program with the Mayo Clinic, allowing more than 53,000 Covid-19 patients to get plasma infusions. At the time, the same story reported that the FDA was preparing to issue an emergency use authorization for the plasma and that there was a lot of concern about there not being sufficient evidence to justify such a move:
The move would mean the F.D.A. is “yielding to political pressure,” said Dr. Luciana Borio, who oversaw public health preparedness for the National Security Council under Mr. Trump and who was acting chief scientist at the F.D.A. under President Barack Obama.
“I’m not as concerned about the political leaders having a misguided approach to science,” she said. “What I’m really concerned about is scientists having a misguided approach to science.”
On Monday, four former F.D.A. commissioners — including Dr. Scott Gottlieb, who served under Mr. Trump — called for more rigorous clinical trials to evaluate whether plasma is an effective treatment for the coronavirus. “If this is going to work, we need to do it right,” they wrote.
They also wrote:
This effort should be coupled with serious studies to figure out whether and when plasma works. Thousands of covid-19 patients have been treated with plasma, but we are not much closer to definitively answering those questions. Its use makes common sense, and preliminary studies are promising, but we won’t know how to best use convalescent plasma products until we complete randomized clinical trials in which some people are treated and others receive usual care.
Consider the confusion surrounding the use of hydroxychloroquine as a treatment for covid-19. Early studies without randomization gave contradictory results. We couldn’t tell if hydroxychloroquine had an effect or if differences in the mortality rates were due to something else.
Subsequent randomized trials showed no meaningful benefit and, in some trials, significant side effects and worse outcomes, enabling us to conclude hydroxychloroquine isn’t providing an advantage and allowing us to focus attention on more promising treatments.
Randomization might sound arbitrary, but we have only a limited supply of plasma, and we don’t yet know if it’s the plasma or something else that might make a patient better or worse. Maintaining clear and consistent standards for proving the safety and effectiveness of treatments will be critical in building trust in both treatments and an eventual vaccine.
The date this article was published was August 3.
So what do we know about the use of convalescent plasma versus COVID-19? Sadly, the answer is: Not much. We have some small case series, such as this one of five critically ill patients, all of whom recovered, but they’re not that useful other than as preliminary studies. We have a small randomized clinical trial of 103 patients in Wuhan, China with severe or life-threatening COVID-19, which was a negative trial. That’s not surprising, though, given that plasma therapy is usually less effective or actually ineffective in advanced, severe disease. The trial was also terminated early because the outbreak was contained and did not meet its accrual target of 200 subjects. There’s also a multicenter trial from Iran of 189 subjects, all COVID-19 positive patients, including 115 patients in the plasma therapy group and 74 patients in the control group that reported a decreased need for intubation in patients treated with plasma. However, it was not randomized, nor was it blinded.
It turns out that accrual has been a problem for the currently ongoing clinical trials as well, as described in this article in MedPage Today:
Recruitment into clinical trials, particularly in areas well past peak like New York, had slowed, and therapeutic hopes turned to treatments substantiated by data from randomized controlled trials (RCTs), i.e., remdesivir and dexamethasone.
But more than 50,000 COVID-19 patients in the U.S. have been treated with the convalescent plasma via the FDA’s expanded access program — and researchers are so determined to get an evidence-based answer to whether this century-old treatment strategy works that they’re starting to pool their data.
In addition:
But the unexpected demand for plasma has inadvertently undercut the research that could prove that it works. The only way to get convincing evidence is with a clinical trial that compares outcomes for patients who are randomly assigned to get the treatment with those who are given a placebo. Many patients and their doctors — knowing they could get the treatment under the government program — have been unwilling to join clinical trials that might provide them with a placebo instead of the plasma.
The trials have also been stymied by the waning of the virus outbreak in many cities, complicating researchers’ ability to recruit sick people. One of those clinical trials, at Columbia University, sputtered to a halt after the outbreak subsided in New York. One of its leaders, Dr. W. Ian Lipkin, looked for hospitals in other hot spots in the United States to continue the work. But he found few takers.
And:
As of last week, just 67 people had enrolled in the Columbia study — too few to form sound statistical conclusions. In a last-ditch effort, Dr. Lipkin’s team shipped the plasma to Brazil, where the epidemic is still raging.
Now, at the height of a public health crisis, the government’s push to distribute an unproven treatment to desperately ill patients as quickly as possible could come at the cost of completing clinical trials that would potentially benefit millions around the world by determining whether those treatments actually work.
Last week, as the FDA was on the verge of issuing an EUA, a group of top federal health officials, including Dr. Francis Collins and Dr. Anthony Fauci pushed back, arguing that the data for the use of convalescent plasma are currently too weak to justify an EUA. The result was that the EUA was put on hold, even though close to 100,000 patients had been treated with convalescent plasma, resulting in this outcome:
As of Monday, August 17, a nationwide program to treat Covid-19 patients with a fluid made from the blood of people who’d recovered from the disease—so-called convalescent plasma—had reached 97,319 patients.
That’s a huge number of people, considering that nobody really knows whether convalescent plasma actually works against Covid-19.
A spontaneously generated, self-assembling group of clinicians and cross-disciplinary researchers that built the nationwide program to ensure “expanded access” to convalescent plasma also created protocols for randomized, controlled trials, the gold standard for evidence in science. They hoped to test plasma’s ability to prevent disease after exposure, its capacity to treat Covid-19—and what Michael Joyner, an exercise physiologist at the Mayo Clinic who was instrumental in setting up the expanded-access network, called a “Hail Mary” protocol to try to help people who are severely ill, on ventilators.
The distribution system got approved and built; the trial protocols did not. They never began.
Unfortunately, this experience has not really helped. It hasn’t given us an answer. Let’s look at the preprint published two weeks ago by the Mayo Clinic group running the COVID-19 Expanded Access Program for convalescent plasma. Because it is a preprint, it has not been peer reviewed, nor is it randomized. It is retrospective, not prospective. It is open-label, not blinded. It did involve 2,807 acute care facilities in the US and its territories. Basically, this is the sort of thing that acupuncturists do; they base their belief in a treatment on inferior trial designs rather than randomized controlled clinical trials.
The trial itself examined 35,322 patients transfused with convalescent plasma. It included a high proportion of critically-ill patients, with 52.3% in the intensive care unit (ICU) and 27.5% receiving mechanical ventilation at the time of plasma transfusion. Seven-day mortality was 8.7% [95% CI 8.3%-9.2%] in the patients transfused within 3 days of their COVID-19 diagnosis but 11.9% [11.4%-12.2%] in the patients transfused 4 or more days after diagnosis (p<0.001). Similar findings were observed in 30-day mortality (21.6% vs. 26.7%, p<0.0001). So these were sick patients, and, to be honest, on an absolute basis these results are not that impressive. On the other hand, to be fair, we do use adjuvant chemotherapy that produces similarly small absolute increases in survival.
An aliquot of each plasma sample used to treat patients was saved, because at the time the study was begun there was no reliable way to measure the amount of anti-COVID antibodies. Binding antibody levels from the sera used were tested using the Ortho-Clinical Diagnostics VITROS Anti-SARS-CoV-2 IgG chemiluminescent immunoassay (CLIA) in accordance with manufacturer instructions. The Ortho-Clinical IgG CLIA is a qualitative assay based on a recombinant form of the SARS-CoV-2 spike subunit 1 protein. Plasma samples were divided into low, medium, and high levels of antibody. The finding was:
Importantly, a gradient of mortality was seen in relation to IgG antibody levels in the transfused plasma. For patients who received high IgG plasma (>18.45 S/Co), seven-day mortality was 8.9% (6.8%, 11.7%); for recipients of medium IgG plasma (4.62 to 18.45 S/Co) mortality was 11.6% (10.3%, 13.1%); and for recipients of low IgG plasma (<4.62 S/Co) mortality was 13.7% (11.1%, 16.8%) (p=0.048). This unadjusted dose-response relationship with IgG was also observed in thirty-day mortality (p=0.021). The pooled relative risk of mortality among patients transfused with high antibody level plasma units was 0.65 [0.47-0.92] for 7 days and 0.77 [0.63-0.94] for 30 days compared to low antibody level plasma units.
The authors used various methods to control for confounding and got similar results.
Having read the paper, I have to say, I’m getting a very “hydroxychloroquine” vibe from it. It’s a retrospective study for which the analyses were not pre-planned. There are a number of confounders that couldn’t be controlled for, in particular the reasons why a clinician might decide to treat a patient with convalescent plasma versus other therapies. Also, the analysis appears not to have been adjusted for study period, when outcomes might have been improving as doctors became better at managing COVID-19 patients, especially severely ill COVID-19 patients, or for periods after the publication of studies showing efficacy of remdesivir and the steroid dexamethasone. There are also a number of other major shortcomings that are catalogued in this post. Here’s the key point:
The part I don’t understand even from the Mayo paper is how they could say it is consistent with efficacy when it could also be consistent with the low titer units being unsafe. The Mayo study measured donor antibody levels in sera using the Ortho-Clinical Diagnostics VITROS Anti-SARS-CoV-2 IgG chemiluminescent immunoassay. This is qualitative assay based on a recombinant form of the SARS-CoV-2 spike subunit 1 protein. Results of this assay are based on the sample signal-to-cut-off (S/Co) ratio, with values <1.0 and ≥1.00 corresponding to negative and positive results . However, they created a “semi-quantitative” interpretation of this assay and established relative, low, medium and high binding antibody levels by setting thresholds for low and high based on the ~20th and ~80th percentiles of the distribution for the S/Co ratios, respectively. To us, a key issue to consider in this approach is that if their ‘low’ category included sub-therapeutic doses with non-neutralizing concentrations, rather than being removed from the pool of available plasma (as in our trial), these can theoretically trigger antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE) which can facilitate virus uptake and subsequent worsening of symptoms. For this reason, doesn’t it seem the group receiving ‘low’ titer plasma could have actually been made WORSE, causing the ‘high’ group to look relatively efficacious and fostering an erroneous interpretation of the results???
Without a real control group, you can’t rule out this possibility with observational evidence. The same post also notes that many of the names of FDA officials were redacted from the EUA announcement. I’ve never seen anything like this before, and the redaction of the names of people involved in evaluating the science is very suspicious to me.
Basically, this isn’t very impressive evidence. Sure, it works as preliminary data to justify an RCT, but it doesn’t show that convalescent plasma works. I also totally agree with this sentiment:
The authors provided a list of reasons why it was not possible to randomize patients to CP from the start. These reasons are singularly unconvincing.
Indeed they are.
Politics versus science in COVID-19
The story of convalescent plasma as a treatment for COVID-19 is a story of how, as was the case for hydroxychloroquine, politics interfered in the ability of doctors and scientists to determine if a treatment actually works. The bottom line right now is well described by a Cochrane “living systematic review” that, as of yesterday, was concluding:
We are very uncertain whether convalescent plasma is beneficial for people admitted to hospital with COVID-19. For safety outcomes we also included non-controlled NRSIs. There was limited information regarding adverse events. Of the controlled studies, none reported on this outcome in the control group. There is only very low-certainty evidence for safety of convalescent plasma for COVID-19. While major efforts to conduct research on COVID-19 are being made, problems with recruiting the anticipated number of participants into these studies are conceivable. The early termination of the first RCT investigating convalescent plasma, and the multitude of studies registered in the past months illustrate this. It is therefore necessary to critically assess the design of these registered studies, and well-designed studies should be prioritised.
This was last updated in June, and I’m afraid that the Mayo Clinic experience doesn’t change that conclusion, and I agree with this sentiment:
Here’s another perspective, using the more up-to-date number: “In my mind, treating 98,000 people with plasma and not having conclusive data if it worked is problematic, and we should have a more robust data set before we give 98,000 people a product,” says John Beigel, associate director for clinical research at the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases’ Division of Microbiology and Infectious Diseases.
Yet that’s exactly what we’ve done, and that’s what we’re going to be doing a lot more of now that the President has announced the FDA’s EUA for convalescent plasma. Yes, it’s true that EUAs include language saying that the EUA is “not intended to replace randomized clinical trials and facilitating the enrollment of patients into any of the ongoing randomized clinical trials is critically important for the definitive demonstration of safety and efficacy” and that the FDA “continues to recommend that the designs of ongoing randomized clinical trials of COVID-19 convalescent plasma and other therapeutic agents remain unaltered, as COVID-19 convalescent plasma does not yet represent a new standard of care based on the current available evidence”. It included the same sort of language in the EUA for hydroxychloroquine. It didn’t matter. People (and too many doctors) still view an EUA as close enough to the same thing as FDA approval for the two to be a distinction without a functional difference
Particularly irritating to me was this nauseatingly sycophantic statement by Alex Azar, Health and Human Services Secretary, included in the actual EUA announcement by the FDA – something I’ve never seen before in an EUA by the FDA:
“The FDA’s emergency authorization for convalescent plasma is a milestone achievement in President Trump’s efforts to save lives from COVID-19,” said Secretary Azar. “The Trump Administration recognized the potential of convalescent plasma early on. Months ago, the FDA, BARDA, and private partners began work on making this product available across the country while continuing to evaluate data through clinical trials. Our work on convalescent plasma has delivered broader access to the product than is available in any other country and reached more than 70,000 American patients so far. We are deeply grateful to Americans who have already donated and encourage individuals who have recovered from COVID-19 to consider donating convalescent plasma.”
Seeing what’s happened during the pandemic, I’m reminded what I wrote about the Trump administration very early in its time. Even just 80 days in, I saw signs of weakening the FDA’s ability to make sure that drugs are only approved based on the strongest scientific evidence, while more recently I saw even more alarming signs of the same problem. When the cruel sham of “right-to-try” was passed into law in 2018, that pretty much sealed my fear that the FDA is becoming totally politicized, and I wasn’t surprised that the law is failing. The pandemic just provided the pretext for the final assault on the FDA as a reliable arbiter of which drugs should be approved based on actual scientific evidence, rather than fairy dust, wishful thinking, and the political imperative of a President known for promoting snake oil.

HYDROXYCHLOROQUINE

Are hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin an effective treatment for COVID-19?
Saturday morning, President Trump Tweeted a claim that the combination of azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine “have a real chance to be one of the biggest game changers in the history of medicine” and hoped that they be “put in use IMMEDIATELY” to treat COVID-19. His claims were based on a single clinical trial out of France. Unfortunately, although it is not implausible that these drugs could inhibit viral replication in humans, the trial touted last week had some very glaring methodological flaws. That’s why the answer to the question is: We still don’t know. [NOTE ADDENDUM ADDED 3/27/2020.]
David Gorski on March 23, 2020
Link
Given how fast events related to the COVID-19 pandemic are moving, I debated whether I should even write about this, even though it blew up on social media on Saturday. Upon reflection, though, it seemed to me a perfect example of the sorts of stories we’re going to be dealing with for the duration of this crisis, and it’s an excellent example of how responsible leadership should not behave with respect to news of potential new treatments for coronavirus disease. Although it didn’t begin with these two Tweets from President Trump on Saturday morning, it did blow up as a result:
HYDROXYCHLOROQUINE & AZITHROMYCIN, taken together, have a real chance to be one of the biggest game changers in the history of medicine. The FDA has moved mountains – Thank You! Hopefully they will BOTH (H works better with A, International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents)…..
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 21, 2020
….be put in use IMMEDIATELY. PEOPLE ARE DYING, MOVE FAST, and GOD BLESS EVERYONE! @US_FDA @SteveFDA @CDCgov @DHSgov
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 21, 2020
It’s likely you’ve heard this, because whenever the President says or Tweets something, it’s news, no matter how irresponsible. Because I was working on a grant application most of the day on Saturday, I was sitting in front of my computer and, as I took the occasional social media break, saw this news explode on Twitter and Facebook over the course of hours. That led me to look into it and to discover just how thin a gruel the evidence supporting this “game changer” was and how irresponsible it was to tout these drugs as “game changers” based on a single preliminary and, to be honest, not very good study.
With the COVID-19 pandemic in the US entering the steep part of the sigmoidal curve and caseloads (and deaths) increasing exponentially, of course the public is desperately seeking some sign that there will be an effective treatment soon. Sadly (spoiler alert!), this is almost certainly not such a sign. Let’s look into why, but, first, let’s look at the two drugs and why it was suspected that they might be active against the virus causing COVID-19, SARS-CoV-2.
Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin
Hydroxychloroquine (trade name Plaquenil) is a derivative of chloroquine (trade name Aralen), a common antimalarial drug. Indeed, some of you reading this might well have taken chloroquine as prophylaxis to prevent malaria while traveling to tropical regions where the disease is endemic. It is also used to treat amoebic liver abscesses when other drugs used for such infections are not working. These drugs also mildly suppress the immune system, which is why they are used as part of the treatment of some autoimmune disorders, such as lupus erythematosis or rheumatoid arthritis. One thing that should be understood is that these are not entirely benign drugs. They have a number of side effects and adverse reactions. In addition to more mild side effects, such as nausea, headache, loss of appetite, and diarrhea, there are two more severe potential side effects. One is that long term use of these drugs can damage the retina and lead to macular degeneration, which is why patients taking these drugs long term need regular ophthalmological examinations. They can also affect the heart by prolonging the QT interval and also lead to drug-induced torsade de pointes, a potentially lethal ventricular tachycardia.
The other drug in the combination, azithromycin (trade names Zithromax, Azithrocin, and others), is a common antibiotic, used to treat a number of infections, ranging from ear infections, to strep throat, pneumonia, and a number of sexually transmitted infections, including chlamydia and gonorrhea. It’s commonly prescribed as a “Z-Pak,” to be taken for five days, and it’s widely prescribed. It can also be used to treat malaria. It has few adverse side effects, but it shares one with hydroxychloroquine: QT-segment prolongation. Indeed, the FDA issued a warning in 2013 that azithromycine “can cause abnormal changes in the electrical activity of the heart that may lead to a potentially fatal irregular heart rhythm.” The warning further cautioned that people with certain pre-existing conditions are at particular risk, such as those with QT interval prolongation, low potassium or magnesium levels, a slower than normal heart rate, or those who use certain drugs to treat abnormal heart rhythms.
A number of doctors on Twitter were alarmed at the suggestion that two drugs that can affect heart rhythm be taken together without much stronger evidence that they were effective (more on the study in a moment):
Hi, ER Doc here. This is a DANGEROUS combination of drugs with tons of side effects. Together they can make your heart go into abnormal rhythms and even KILL you. Please do NOT take them unless they have been prescribed by your doctor.
— Sam Ghali, M.D. (@EM_RESUS) March 21, 2020
Moreover, President Trump’s claim resulted on a run on the drugs and shortages at pharmacies, with some doctors writing scripts for their family and friends:
There are reports in Boston that pharmacies are seeing a spike of hydroxychloroquine prescriptions by physicians for themselves or their families 😬
Just a reminder that this is not only deeply unethical and but also quite harmful if it doesn't work https://t.co/XaNSYkOPwX
— Michael L. Barnett (@ml_barnett) March 21, 2020
And even dentists are getting in on the action:
Well it finally happened to me.
A dentist just tried to call in scripts for hydroxychloroquine + azithromycin for himself, his wife, & another couple (friends).
NOPE.
I have patients with lupus that have been on HCQ for YEARS and now can’t get it because it’s on backorder.
— Katherine Rowland (@DRxKatherine) March 22, 2020
Elsewhere on Twitter:
that is not the actual paper.this is the pre-print.it is very far from definitive and has serious and well acknowledged issues that preclude drawing conclusions…https://t.co/fHf05AYJBy
— Ralph Marcucio (@mcfunny) March 21, 2020
Another concern was that it is easy to overdose on hydroxychloroqine, its therapeutic window (the difference between the lowest effective dose and doses that will cause toxicity, in this case cardiac toxicity) being narrow.
But why was it thought that these drugs might be active against SARS-CoV-2? First, it’s been known for a long time that chloroquine has antiviral activity against certain viruses (summarized in this commentary). The evidence, however, has been fairly conflicting, as described here:
The in vitro antiviral activity of chloroquine has been identified since the late 1960’s (Inglot, 1969; Miller and Lenard, 1981; Shimizu et al., 1972) and the growth of many different viruses can be inhibited in cell culture by both chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine, including the SARS coronavirus (Keyaerts et al., 2004). Some evidence for activity in mice has been found for a variety of viruses, including human coronavirus OC43 (Keyaerts et al., 2009), enterovirus EV-A71 (Tan et al., 2018), Zika virus (Li et al., 2017) and influenza A H5N1 (Yan et al., 2013). However, chloroquine did not prevent influenza infection in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial (Paton et al., 2011), and had no effect on dengue-infecteds [sic] patient in a randomized controlled trial in Vietnam (Tricou et al., 2010). Chloroquine was also active ex vivo but not in vivo in the case of ebolavirus in mice (Dowall et al., 2015; Falzarano et al., 2015), Nipah (Pallister et al., 2009) and influenza virus (Vigerust and McCullers, 2007) in ferrets.
More recently:
Recently, Wang and colleagues (Wang et al., 2020) evaluated in vitro five FDA-approved drugs and two broad spectrum antivirals against a clinical isolate of SARS-CoV-2. One of their conclusions was that “chloroquine (is) highly effective in the control of 2019-nCoV infection in vitro” and that its “safety track record suggests that it should be assessed in human patients suffering from the novel coronavirus disease”. At least 16 different trials for SARS-CoV-2 already registered in the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (ChiCTR2000029939, ChiCTR2000029935, ChiCTR2000029899, ChiCTR2000029898, ChiCTR2000029868, ChiCTR2000029837, ChiCTR2000029826, ChiCTR2000029803, ChiCTR2000029762, ChiCTR2000029761, ChiCTR2000029760, ChiCTR2000029741, ChiCTR2000029740, ChiCTR2000029609, ChiCTR2000029559, ChiCTR2000029542) propose to use chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine in the treatment of COVID-19 (“Chinese Clinical Trial Register” (ChiCTR)). In a recent publication (Gao et al., 2020), Gao and colleagues indicate that, “according to the news briefing”, “results from more than 100 patients have demonstrated that chloroquine phosphate is superior to the control treatment in inhibiting the exacerbation of pneumonia, improving lung imaging findings, promoting a virus negative conversion, and shortening the disease course”.
I must say that the paper by Gao et al is really thin gruel. Its methods were not well described, and it simply asserted a positive result. I also note that the half-maximal effective concentration (EC50) for blocking viral replication in vitro was 1.13 μM and the half-cytotoxic concentration (CC50) was greater than 100 μM. These are high concentrations for a drug, especially the CC50. The same paper also found that remdesivir (a new antiviral drug) also had antiviral activity against SARS-CoV-2.
As for azithromycin, well, hang on for its rationale.
The study: Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin as a treatment of COVID-19
So here is the study by Gautret et al., “Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin as a treatment of COVID-19: results of an open- label non-randomized clinical trial“. It was carried out at locations in France and Viet Nam and is a preprint that hasn’t yet gone through peer review (at least not as of yesterday). Interestingly, it was posted on March 17, which means it had been four days before Trump took notice of the study. It is also not a randomized study, and the primary endpoint was detectable presence of the virus, with reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR, as SARS-CoV-2 is an RNA virus) used to determine if a specimen was positive or negative for SARS-CoV-2. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were simple. Patients could be included if they were >12 years old and had PCR-documented SARS-CoV-2 in a nasopharyngeal sample at admission, “whatever their clinical status.” Patients were excluded if they had an allergy to hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine or had “another known contraindication to treatment with the study drug, including retinopathy, G6PD deficiency and QT prolongation. Breastfeeding and pregnant patients were excluded based on their declaration and pregnancy test results when required.” The primary endpoint was viral load of SARS-CoV-2, as documented by qRT-PCR.
After that, there were three groups studied:
    • Patients from the main medical center, who received hydroxychloroquine (n=20).
    • “Control” patients from another center who received standard treatment (n=16).
    • Patients from the main center who received hyroxychloroquine and azithromycin (A) (n=6, but not really, as I will explain).
Before I discuss the problems with the study, I’ll cut to the chase and post a copy of the graph that’s been showing up all over social media, a graph showing the percentage of patients who were positive for the virus over time:
On the surface, it looks very promising, doesn’t it? The percentage of patients PCR-positive for SARS-CoV-2 is lower in the hydroxychloroquine-treated group and drops to zero by day 5. Of course, there are no error bars. Why might that be? Let’s go to the source:
We enrolled 36 out of 42 patients meeting the inclusion criteria in this study that had at least six days of follow-up at the time of the present analysis. A total of 26 patients received hydroxychloroquine and 16 were control patients. Six hydroxychloroquine-treated patients were lost in follow-up during the survey because of early cessation of treatment. Reasons are as follows: three patients were transferred to intensive care unit, including one transferred on day2 post-inclusion who was PCR-positive on day1, one transferred on day3 post-inclusion who was PCR-positive on days1-2 and one transferred on day4 post-inclusion who was PCR- positive on day1 and day3; one patient died on day3 post inclusion and was PCR-negative on day2; one patient decided to leave the hospital on day3 post-inclusion and was PCR-negative on days1-2; finally, one patient stopped the treatment on day3 post-inclusion because of nausea and was PCR-positive on days1-2-3. The results presented here are therefore those of 36 patients (20 hydroxychloroquine-treated patients and 16 control patients). None of the control patients was lost in follow-up.
So basically, an intent-to-treat analysis was not done, and patients who dropped out in the treatment group because they got sicker were excluded from the analysis. This is not how things are done. These patients were obviously sicker and could easily have had higher viral loads. Leaving them out of the final analysis was not justifiable. What is an intent-to-treat analysis and why is it important? Basically, it is a design in which the results of a trial are analyzed based on the initial treatment to which the patient was assigned, not the final actual treatment administered, requiring that subjects be included even if they do not adhere to the protocol. Intent-to-treat is designed to avoid misleading artifacts in the data that can come about from problems such as unequal dropout between groups (which this study definitely had) or crossover. Of course, intent-to-treat makes the analysis more difficult, because it’s not infrequent that there are missing data points, but there are statistical methods to deal with missing data.
Aside from not adhering to an intent-to-treat design, here’s where the study is truly revealed to be crap. This huge lapse was pointed out on Twitter by Gaetan Burgio, an Australian geneticist, who waded into the supplementary data and found this table:
Looking at supplementary Table 1, most of the controls had viral load qualitatively detected or the PCR was not done !!!! . Only 4 out of 16 controls had a proper measure of the viral load !!!! This is insane ! pic.twitter.com/hDhKewVcTu
— Gaetan Burgio (@GaetanBurgio) March 21, 2020
And Rachael Dunlop, who did the same, and posted this to Facebook:
Read the Tweet and the Facebook post, but to make a long story short, researchers didn’t do PCR on a lot of the samples from the controls. They used incomplete data from even their own patients and didn’t do an intent-to-treat analysis and also had very small numbers. It’s also unclear to me what criteria were used to determine who got azithromycin. All the paper says is that it was given to six patients to suppress upper respiratory infections, noting simply that “depending on their clinical presentation, azithromycin was added to the treatment” and that it was added to “prevent bacterial super-infection.”
As for the PCR, I am unclear on how this assay was carried out. Because PCR amplifies nucleotide sequences exponentially, small differences in technique, temperature cycling settings, etc. can make a huge difference. I’ve done a lot of PCR. The primer sequences used are not included, and the only reference to PCR methods is a citation of a paper that hasn’t been published yet. This is basically all the method:
For all patients, 500 μL of the liquid collected from the nasopharyngeal swab were passed through 0.22-μm pore sized centrifugal filter (Merck millipore, Darmstadt, Germany), then were inoculated in wells of 96-well culture microplates, of which 4 wells contained Vero E6 cells (ATCC CRL-1586) in Minimum Essential Medium culture medium with 4% fetal calf serum and 1% glutamine. After centrifigation at 4,000 g, microplates were incubated at 37°C. Plates were observed daily for evidence of cytopathogenic effect. Presumptive detection of virus in supernatant was done using SU5000 SEM (Hitachi) then confirmed by specific RT- PCR.
This is a two-step assay. First, the swab contents were sterilized by filtration and inoculated on Vero E6 cells, which were examined daily for evidence of viral replication (cytopathic effect, meaning that cells were dying because the virus was replicating in them). Then the media was examined under scanning electron microscope for virus particles, only after which was PCR done. So wait a minute. This, of course, leads me to wonder why only PCR results were reported and whether the virus was seen in the media by electron microscope. Was PCR not done on some of the samples because no viral particles were seen by scanning electron microscope? Inquiring minds want to know! In any event, a procedure as tricky as trying to culture virus in cells, isolating RNA from the viral particles in the supernatant, and then doing RT-PCR has a lot of places where things can go wrong and/or where results can vary a lot depending on small differences in technique. Standardization is key, as is blinding of laboratory technicians doing the assays to the group that the patients came from. (Perhaps virologists can elaborate on the assay used to detect SARS-CoV-2 here.)
Worst of all, there is no evidence from this paper that these two drugs made any difference in the clinical outcomes of these patients. I understand that this was a pilot study and that it will require a much larger trial to determine if hydroxychloroquine has any effect on clinical outcomes, but the hype over this study is unconscionable. This is at best an uncertain result from a very preliminary study with very serious methodological shortcomings that looked only at viral positivity in nasopharyngeal aspirates. The authors justify their publication thusly:
For ethical reasons and because our first results are so significant and evident we decide to share our findings with the medical community, given the urgent need for an effective drug against SARS-CoV-2 in the current pandemic context.
We show here that hydroxychloroquine is efficient in clearing viral nasopharyngeal carriage of SARS-CoV-2 in COVID-19 patients in only three to six days, in most patients. A significant difference was observed between hydroxychloroquine-treated patients and controls starting even on day3 post-inclusion.
No, the ethical thing to do would have been to analyze the data properly and go through peer review. A number of journals are accelerating peer review of COVID-19-related papers, so that they can be published rapidly. This paper almost certainly would have failed peer review, given that it is not randomized, doesn’t do a proper intention-to-treat analysis, and has a whole lot of missing datapoints among the control subjects. As Dr. Burgio put it:
In short, all this hype on the clinical trial is based on a open label, non randomized and underpowered clinical trial on HCQ treatment against #COVID19 with viral load as an outcome that was not properly measured in 2/3 of the control cohort !!!
— Gaetan Burgio (@GaetanBurgio) March 21, 2020
Exactly. Now one of the physicians involved, Didier Raoult, MD, PhD is advertising an “open label” trial for the prevention of COVID-19:
We’re an independent group of scientists and physicians working on an open-data clinical trial for prevention of COVID-19, through the use of hydroxychloroquine in combination with other therapeutic agents, for prevention of SARS-COV2 infection in high risk health care workers.
Unlike a typical commercial drug trial, our objective is to share trial data with the public* and health-care professionals as close to real-time as possible (with a reasonable level of data quality assurance).
Given the rapidly spreading coronavirus pandemic, we’re looking for every possible means to fast-track the effort.
It’s led by Gregory J. Rigano, Esq. Yes, you have that right, a lawyer. Dr. Raoult is listed only as one of two consulting physicians and scientists. The other? Dr. Chandra Duggirala, who is described as a “physician, clinical investigator, inventor and serial entrepreneur.” He’s also into antiaging research and has “founded a software company at the intersection of nutritional biology and A.I.” What could go wrong?
What’s depressing is that Dr. Raoult has a very good publication record and is viewed as one of France’s top scientists. He knows how it should be done. Why is he choosing to do it this way? A pandemic is not a good excuse to throw rigorous methodology out the window, particularly when a randomized trial using viral load as the endpoint could be completed very quickly. At least the French government is trying to replicate Dr. Raoult’s trial independent of him; so hopefully we will have some clarity soon. There are also at least three trials of hydroxychloroquine to treat or prevent COVID-19 on ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT04308668, NCT04304053, and NCT04315896).
Real world consequences and the future
Now that it has dawned on everyone that we have a real pandemic that could kill many millions of people worldwide, it’s understandable that people are desperate for effective treatment. We feel helpless, and understandably so, given a case fatality rate almost certainly considerably higher than that of influenza. Also, there is no vaccine (with no likelihood of one for at least a year) and no specific treatment other than supportive care. Even though most people will have mild disease, 20% or so will require hospitalization and 5-6% will wind up on a ventilator, some for extended periods of time, before recovering or dying. We are in a situation where hospitals could soon be overwhelmed with COVID-19 patients, as has already happened in Italy and Spain. The President’s words were deeply irresponsible, and he essentially single-handedly caused shortages of hydroxychloroquine, which is used to treat lupus and other autoimmune diseases. Worse, the dose used in the clinical trial reported was high (600 mg daily, with typical doses for lupus being 200-400 mg daily). If the drug is given to huge numbers of people without proper monitoring, there will be people who get sick or even die from it.
I got a lot of pushback on Twitter for complaining about this study over the weekend, with people asking “what’s the harm?” (death could be the harm in some cases) and asking why China and some other countries have added hydroxychloroquine to their recommended treatments. I couldn’t find the actual clinical trials published, only this announcement stating that the drug is “recommended for inclusion in the next version of the Guidelines for the Prevention, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Pneumonia Caused by COVID-19 issued by the National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China” and a transcript in Chinese of a press conference held in February announcing the findings. Basically, other than this study and some in vitro studies, I can’t evaluate the evidence at this time. (If someone knows where to find the data, please let me know.)
The abstract of the Chinese expert consensus, translated into English, reads:
Here we found that treating the patients diagnosed as novel coronavirus pneumonia with chloroquine might improve the success rate of treatment, shorten hospital stay and improve patient outcome. In order to guide and regulate the use of chloroquine in patients with novel coronavirus pneumonia, the multicenter collaboration group of Department of Science and Technology of Guangdong Province and Health Commission of Guangdong Province for chloroquine in the treatment of novel coronavirus pneumonia developed this expert consensus after extensive discussion. It recommended chloroquine phosphate tablet, 500mg twice per day for 10 days for patients diagnosed as mild, moderate and severe cases of novel coronavirus pneumonia and without contraindications to chloroquine.
Again, without the evidence base used to come to this recommendation, I have a hard time judging whether the recommendation is scientifically justified. “Might improve the success rate of treatment” doesn’t sound like very definitive results.
Searching Pubmed, I found various articles reviewing the question of whether chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine are effective against COVID-19. This one, published two weeks ago, examined six articles (one narrative letter, one in-vitro study, one editorial, expert consensus paper, two national guideline documents) and 23 ongoing clinical trials in China and concluded that chloroquine “seems to be effective in limiting the replication of SARS-CoV-2 (virus causing COVID-19) in vitro,” going on to conclude in addition:
There is rationale, pre-clinical evidence of effectiveness and evidence of safety from long-time clinical use for other indications to justify clinical research on chloroquine in patients with COVID-19. However, clinical use should either adhere to the Monitored Emergency Use of Unregistered Interventions (MEURI) framework or be ethically approved as a trial as stated by the World Health Organization. Safety data and data from high-quality clinical trials are urgently needed.
Another recent review, by Dr. Raoult, notes that there have been mixed results using chloroquine to treat viral illnesses, despite its broad antiviral activity in cell culture and states, “Preliminary trials of chloroquine repurposing in the treatment of COVID-19 in China have been encouraging, leading to several new trials,” adding:
According to preliminary reports [50,51] from the Chinese authorities suggesting that approximately 100 infected patients treated with chloroquine experienced a more rapid decline in fever and improvement of lung computed tomography (CT) images and required a shorter time to recover compared with control groups, with no obvious serious adverse effects, the Chinese medical advisory board has suggested chloroquine inclusion in the SARS-CoV-2 treatment guidelines.
So, could hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine be effective drugs to treat and/or prevent COVID-19? Sure, it’s possible. There’s a plausible mechanism by which the drugs could inhibit viral replication (several, actually), plus in vitro evidence of antiviral activity. On the other hand, caution is definitely indicated, as Dr. Raoult notes:
The antiviral properties of chloroquine described in vitro have sometimes been confirmed during treatment of virus-infected patients but have not always been reproduced in clinical trials depending on the disease, the concentration of chloroquine used, the duration of treatment and the clinical team in charge of the trial.
The bottom line is that more data are desperately needed. Sadly, the French study doesn’t provide us with the data needed and has muddied the waters more than clarified whether using hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 is an effective intervention. Fortunately, there are multiple trials testing hydroxychloroquine and other drugs with antiviral activity against COVID-19, including a “global megatrial” by The WHO.
Sadly, as the pandemic progresses, we’re going to see a lot more of this, preliminary studies hyped as “game changers.” As editor of SBM, I’m already getting emails from PR flacks touting this “expert” or that’s new treatment for COVID-19. Until there is an effective vaccine or treatment, this will be the new normal, with incremental advances being touted as “game changers” and desperate people wondering why there isn’t a treatment yet. Whenever you see a study like the French study touted, wait a while to see what the experts say about it, and don’t share it before you get a feel for whether it’s a good study or not. Don’t be like President Trump.
ADDENDUM 3/27/2020: I was made aware of this excellent post discussing the trial. It turns out that Didier Raoult’s group played even faster and looser with the data in this study than my post indicates. Worse, Raoult’s group has a documented history of data fabrication, likely due to his tyrannical manner of running the institute and his demand for results, where he publicly humiliates students, postdocs, and researchers who do not produce the results he wants. Indeed, the American Society for Microbiology even banned him from publishing in its journals for a year after data fabrication was detected in one of his group’s papers. Raoult also has a history of accusations of sexual misconduct with underlings, and he is feared in the French scientific community due to his propensity to use his power and influence to silence critics. After I posted this, a small randomized trial from China testing chloroquine to treat COVID-19 was published. It showed no benefit. That doesn’t mean that there might not be a benefit observed in a larger trial, but it sure does suggest that this is no “miracle drug,” because if its effects were so dramatic they should be seen in a small trial.
In terms of other science, Raoult is a climate science denier, having been quoted as saying, “La planète ne se réchauffe plus depuis 1998. Jusqu’à cette date, le réchauffement brutal était lié à un phénomène météorologique : El Niño.” (“The planet has not warmed since 1998. Until that date, the sudden warming was linked to a meteorological phenomenon: El Niño”). He also published a book, La vérité sur les vaccins (The Truth About Vaccines) that has a distinctly antivaccine vibe to it, given the title, the blurb, and what I’ve been able to find out about it. He’s also been quoted as saying:
I have never done randomized trials…The effect of randomized stuff, maybe it works on people who had a myocardial infarction, but putting that in infectious diseases, it doesn’t make sense.
That explains a lot about why his trial design was so incompetent.
Overall, Raoult strikes me as a “brave maverick” who might have been a great scientist in his prime but who has now become arrogant and dictatorial and has now come down with a serious case of the Dunning-Kruger effect. He has no expertise in clinical trials and in fact disputes the usefulness of randomized clinical trials in infectious disease. Anything he publishes on COVID-19 should be taken with a huge grain of salt.

Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin versus COVID-19: Grift, conspiracy theories, and another bad study by Didier Raoult
On Friday, Prof. Didier Raoult posted another study of azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine used against COVID-19. It is a single arm observational study of patients with mostly mild (or even asymptomatic) disease that is painfully uninformative with respect to the question of this treatment’s effectiveness. That didn’t stop America’s Quack Dr. Oz and other grifters from touting Raoult’s study, as well as a handful of “miracle cure” testimonials, to promote the treatment as a cure and attack the FDA.
David Gorski on March 30, 2020
Link

Last week, I wrote about an experimental treatment for COVID-19 that repurposes old drugs. One version of the treatment uses chloroquine (which is sold under the trade name Aralen and others), an anti-malaria drug that’s also used to treat autoimmune diseases. Another version, the one that at the time was getting the most press, claimed that the combination of hydroxychloroquine (trade name Plaquenil, and it’s a drug which is very similar to chloroquine) and the antibiotic azithromycin (often prescribed in the famous “Z-Pak”) could completely render SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, undetectable in patients. As I described, it was a horrible, horrible study about which I later found out things that make me suspect that its awfulness could have been due to more than mere incompetence and instead might have been scientific fraud. Meanwhile, the only existing randomized trial of chloroquine in COVID-19 was negative. As I said at the time, that doesn’t mean that the drug doesn’t work, but it does strongly suggest that its effects are probably not dramatic, although it is also possible that the dose used was too low.
Professor Didier Raoult releases another COVID-19 study
With that background in mind, as I was thinking about what to write this week, I wasn’t planning on writing about this particular issue again, but then I observed two developments. First, Professor Didier Raoult, who published the hydroxychloroquine/azithromycin study, published another trial that’s being flogged as evidence that his combination works. Second, in the conspiracy fever swamps on social media and even on traditional media an emerging narrative was being promoted late last week. It came in the form of articles like this one by a local Pacific Legal Foundation member named Kathy Hoekstra, “Michigan’s doctors fight coronavirus, and governor’s office“. First, let’s discuss the new study of azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine, because I know that’s what will likely most interest people. Again, it’s from Raoult’s group and is entitled “Clinical and microbiological effect of a combination of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin in 80 COVID-19 patients with at least a six-day follow up: an observational study“.
Unsurprisingly, the first thing I noticed about the study is that it is a single arm, unrandomized trial with no control group. Right there that tells you it’s not going to produce good evidence for the efficacy of azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine against COVID-19. Before I dive into the weeds, let’s just say that I like this description of the trial:
@schneiderleonid @MicrobiomDigest https://t.co/l62Wm7WIYH
Have fun. This paper is so empty that it looks like a cohort description… Without any control group.
— Mathieu M.J.E. Rebeaud, ½PhD #StayTheFuckHome (@Damkyan_Omega) March 27, 2020
In the introduction to the paper, Raoult touts his previous study:
In a preliminary clinical trial on a small cohort of COVID-19 patients, we demonstrated that those treated with hydroxychloroquine (600 mg per day, N=20 patients) had a significant reduction in viral carriage at D6-post inclusion, with 70% of patients testing negative for the virus through nasopharyngeal PCR, compared to untreated controls (N=16) with only 12.5% patients testing negative using PCR at D6-post inclusion (16). In addition, of the twenty patients who were treated with hydroxychloroquine, six received azithromycin for five days (for the purposes of preventing bacterial super-infection) and all (100%) were virologically cured at D6-post inclusion, compared to 57.1% of the remaining 14 patients (16). By contrast, a Chinese study conducted in 30 COVID-19 patients showed no significant differences between patients treated with 400 mg per day during five days (N=15) and controls (N=15) regarding pharyngeal carriage of viral RNA at day7, however, patients received multiple additional treatments including antivirals (17).
As I discussed before (as did others), this study showed nothing of the sort, given the missing PCR data, the inconsistent methodology for reporting PCR data, the lack of an “intention to treat” analysis, the exclusion of six patients in the experimental group who got sicker, and more. It was a terrible, terrible study, but Didier Raoult touted it as evidence that his drug combination could potentially “cure” severe COVID-19 infection.
So what about this new paper? The experimental design is…odd. Basically, Raoult studied 80 patients with PCR-documented SARS-CoV-2 RNA from a nasopharyngeal swab who were admitted to the infectious diseases ward at the University Hospital Institute Méditerranée Infection in Marseille, France. Here, the patient cohort is described:
Upon admission, patients were grouped into two categories: i) those with an upper respiratory tract infection (URTI) presenting with rhinitis and/or pharyngitis, and/or isolated low-grade fever and myalgia, and ii) those with lower respiratory tract infections (LRTI) presenting with symptoms of pneumonia or bronchitis. The time between the onset of symptoms and admission, and the time between the onset of symptoms and treatment was documented.
Risk factors for severe COVID-19, including older age, cancer, cardiovascular disease, hypertension, and diabetes (4), as well as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, obesity and any immunosuppressive treatments were documented. The national early warning score (NEWS) for COVID-19 patients, was collected upon ward admission and during follow up. The NEWS score was calculated based on the following parameters: age, respiratory rate, oxygen saturation, temperature, systolic blood pressure, pulse rate and level of consciousness (19). We defined three risk categories for clinical deterioration: low score (NEWS 0-4), medium score (NEWS 5-6), and high score (NEWS≥7) for COVID patients.
The need for oxygen therapy, transfer to the intensive care unit (ICU), death, and length of stay in the ID ward were documented.
Again, it was maddening to read the methods section describing how the virus was assayed. Like the case in the previous paper, the methods were not well described. For instance, at one point the authors state that cultures “were attempted in a random selection of patients” without describing how “random” patients were chosen for an attempt to culture the virus from their nasopharyngeal swab. Be that as it may, here are the patient characteristics:
A total of 80 patients with confirmed COVID-19 were hospitalised at the Méditerranée Infection University Hospital Institute (N=77) and at a temporary COVID-19 unit (N=3) with dates of entry from 3–21 March 2020. All patients who received treatment with hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin (16) for at least three days and who were followed-up for at least six days were included in this analysis. The median age of patients was 52 years (ranging from 18 to 88 years) with a M/F sex ratio of 1.1. 57.5% of these patients had at least one chronic condition known to be a risk factor for the severe form of COVID-19 with hypertension, diabetes and chronic respiratory disease being the most frequent. The time between the onset of symptoms and hospitalisation was on average five days, with the longest time being 17 days. 53.8% of patients presented with LRTI symptoms and 41.2% with URTI symptoms. Only 15% of patients were febrile. Four patients were asymptomatic carriers. The majority of patients had a low NEWS score (92%) and 53.8% of patients had LDCT compatible with pneumonia. The mean PCR Ct value was 23.4.
I was scratching my head as I read this. By this description, these patients mostly had mild disease. Only 15% had fever? Fever is a prominent feature of symptomatic adults with COVID-19. Only 53% had lower respiratory tract infection symptoms? Four of the patients (5%) were asymptomatic? 92% had low COVID-19 severity scores as measured by the National Early Warning Score (NEWS)? Why were they even admitted in the first place, rather than instructed to isolate themselves in their homes? That’s what’s generally done; asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2-positive patients and patients with mild COVID-19 symptoms are generally just told to stay home for at least two weeks and call if their symptoms worsen. Later in the paper, we learn that only 15% of these patients required oxygen, while only three required ICU admission, with one death.
This is a curious way to present the data. First, there is a totally pointless use of a polynomial regression analysis, given that if you use enough variables you can fit almost any curve to an equation. Let’s just put it this way; those R2 values are pretty much meaningless, as are the equations to which these curves were fitted. Why is the equation a quadratic equation for Figure 1 and an exponential equation for Figure 2? Who knows? It sure does produce some nice R2 values, though.
Basically, this is a nothingburger of a paper. It studied patients with low severity or even asymptomatic COVID-19 disease, the vast majority of whom would likely have cleared the virus just as fast without the medications. Again, this is such a useless paper, even as an observational paper, that it tells us, in essence, nothing new.
Meanwhile, Raoult was on Twitter yesterday bragging about “curing” COVID-19:
1003 patients traités à l'@ihu_marseille avec le protocole hydroxychloroquine-azithromycine. Notre priorité est de guérir les patients diagnostiqués positifs au COVID-19. Merci aux équipes de diagnostic et de soin qui se mobilisent jour et nuit.#SFMPhttps://t.co/V6HiXiuHUM pic.twitter.com/ohKeHctkYr
— Didier Raoult (@raoult_didier) March 29, 2020
Translation: “1003 patients treated with @ihu_marseille with the hydroxychloroquine-azithromycin protocol. Our priority is to cure patients diagnosed with COVID-19. Thank you to the diagnostic and care teams who are mobilized day and night.”
I did like this response:
Donc d'apres les statistiques : 80% de formes bénignes donc 800 traitements pour rien + 20 % de patients traités avec un médicament sans aucune preuve soit 200 environs que vous avez exposés a un risque. Donc 100% d'inutilité et de piétinement de la médecine. Bravo ! #Covid_19
— L'interne des temps modernes (@InterneDTM) March 29, 2020
Translation: “So according to the statistics: 80% benign forms, therefore 800 treatments for nothing + 20% of patients treated with a drug without any evidence, or around 200 that you exposed to a risk. So 100% uselessness and trampling medicine. Well done! #Covid_19”
A new narrative about chloroquine, hydroxychloroquine, and azithromycin
Let’s circle back now in light of yet another uninformative trial on COVID-19 from Prof. Raoult. To understand Hoekstra’s attack against the State of Michigan, you first have to know that late last week Michigan’s Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs issued a warning letter about physicians prescribing hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine to family members with the intent to stockpile, thus creating shortages. The letter, signed by Deb Gagliardi, Director of the Bureau of Professional Licensing, and Forrest Pasanski, Director of the Enforcement Division, warned:
Prescribing hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine without further proof of efficacy for treating COVID-19 or with the intent to stockpile the drug may create a shortage for patients with lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, or other ailments for which chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine are proven treatments. Reports of this conduct will be evaluated and may be further investigated for administrative action. Prescribing any kind of prescription must also be associated with medical documentation showing proof of the medical necessity and medical condition for which the patient is being treated. Again, these are drugs that have not been proven scientifically or medically to treat COVID-19.
The letter further reminded pharmacists that they should not fill prescriptions if the pharmacist “believes the prescription will be used for other than legitimate medical purposes or if the prescription could cause harm to a patient” and reminded health care workers that they are “required to report inappropriate prescribing practices.” It was, of course, a reasonable thing to do in order to try to stop some very unethical prescribing that was causing shortages and making it difficult or impossible for lupus patients, for example, to obtain their chloroquine. A followup letter on Friday cited a joint statement by the Michigan State Medical Society and the Michigan Pharmacists Association and a second joint statement by American Medical Association, American Pharmacists Association, and American Society of Health-System Pharmacists.
Unsurprisingly, to Hoekstra, who cited the azithromycin/hydroxychloroquine study that I discussed last week as evidence that these drugs provide great hope, this action was an unconscionable affront to physician autonomy in prescribing off-label medications and saying that ” if you live in Michigan, and you or a loved one is infected with this potentially lethal disease, you’re out of luck.” She also noted that Henry Ford Hospital and the University of Michigan have protocols that include these drugs, further noting:
With his state now the nation’s pandemic epicenter, and with the blessing and help of the president and FDA, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo brought in 70,000 doses of hydroxychloroquine, 10,000 doses of Zithromax and 750,000 doses of chloroquine.
The implications of Whitmer and her administration’s knee-jerk scare tactics should terrify all Michigan residents. Not only is our state’s top leader threatening the selfless health care workers who are on the frontline trying to save lives, but she’s denying possible life-saving medications to actual COVID-19 victims.
It was a profoundly dishonest article, given that there really is no good evidence that these drugs impact the course of COVID-19 and, worse, they are not benign drugs. the chloroquine drugs can cause dangerous cardiac arrhythmias. It’s an uncommon side effect, but common enough that most protocols using these drugs against COVID-19 require the patient to be on a cardiac monitor. Moreover, the therapeutic window (the difference between the lowest therapeutic dose and a toxic dose) of the chloroquine derivatives is narrow. In any event, you get the idea. It’s a conspiracy theory fueled by those promoting the drugs as miracle cures for COVID-19 that states that there is a cure for COVID-19 that “they” don’t want you to know about. In that, it’s now different than a lot of cancer cure conspiracy theories.
Anecdotes and miracle cures
So what’s driving the narrative about the chloroquine drugs? It certainly isn’t sound clinical trial evidence and science, at least not yet. No one would be happier than I to see some combination of hydroxychloroquine, chloroquine, and/or azithromycin to be validated as effective against COVID-19 in a clinical trial or, even better, validated as prophylaxis against the disease. We’re just not there yet, unfortunately, although there are multiple clinical trials looking at the question now. Until those trials are completed, what’s really driving the narrative are “miracle cure claims,” like this one Tweeted out by President Trump a week ago:
A great early result from a drug that will start tomorrow in New York and other places! #COVIDー19 https://t.co/4F4Qk4WFtK
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 23, 2020
The story is about a man named Rio Giardinieri, a 52-year-old who developed severe COVID-19 disease. He’s been showing up all over the media telling this story of how a single dose of chloroquine saved his life:
After more than a week, doctors told him there was nothing more they could do and, on Friday evening, Giardinieri said goodbye to his wife and three children.
“I was at the point where I was barely able to speak and breathing was very challenging,” Giardinieri said. “I really thought my end was there.”
Then a friend sent him a recent article about hydroxychloroquine, a prescription drug that’s been used to treat malaria for decades and auto-immune diseases like lupus.
If you’ve read testimonials for alternative medicines for cancer or even testimonials for Stanislaw Burzynski, you know what’s coming next. Giardinieri’s testimonial is essentially the same thing:
Giardinieri said he contacted an infectious disease doctor about the drug.
“He gave me all the reasons why I would probably not want to try it because there are no trials, there’s no testing, it was not something that was approved,” said Giardinieri.
“And I said, ‘Look, I don’t know if I’m going to make it until the morning,’ because at that point I really thought I was coming to the end because I couldn’t breathe anymore,” Giardinieri continued.
“He agreed and authorized the use of it and 30 minutes later the nurse gave it to me.”
After about an hour after taking the pills, Giardinieri said, it felt like his heart was beating out of his chest and, about two hours later, he had another episode where he couldn’t breathe.
He says he was given Benadryl and some other drugs and that when he woke up around 4:45 a.m., it was “like nothing ever happened.”
He’s since had no fever or pain and can breathe again. Giardinieri said doctors believe the episodes he experienced were not a reaction to the medicine but his body fighting off the virus.
Sounds pretty dramatic, doesn’t it? In actuality, reading this testimonial made me think more than ever that it wasn’t the chloroquine that was responsible for Giardinieri’s remarkable recovery. He had only gotten one dose. Antivirals don’t usually work that fast. This is almost certainly a case of confusing correlation with causation. One also wonders if that “pounding heart” was a cardiac arrhythmia brought on by the drug. There’s no way of knowing for sure, though. In any event, no one’s listening to the caveats and the reasons to doubt these anecdotal stories. They’re only hearing this:
“To me, there was no doubt in mind that I wouldn’t make it until morning,” said Giardinieri. “So to me, the drug saved my life.”
This is the message people are getting. Meanwhile, here in Michigan, in response to the letter warning against hoarding and inappropriate subscribing of chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine, a man named Jim Santilli wrote a Facebook post complaining and describing his own “miracle cure” with hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin:
Of note is this passage. Note how similar to Giardinieri’s story Santilli’s story is:
On March 18th, I had a sudden onset of severe respiratory and cardiac issues. I immediately went to the hospital and they did a COVID-19 test. While waiting for the test results in the hospital, my breathing continued to worsen as treatment was received. On the morning of March 21st, I was not doing well and it was a major struggle to breathe. Feeling like I was slowly drowning, I honestly believed I would not live to see midnight. The x-ray that morning also showed my condition was worsening, including some collapsing in the lungs. Luckily, the infectious disease physicians decided to try a non-approved, experimental combination (Hydroxychloroquine and Azithromycin). After my first dose, I had a major improvement. My gasping for air stopped, and I was in tears of happiness due to having hope restored. I finally felt I would beat COVID-19 and it was no longer beating me. On March 22nd, I remained about the same. However, March 23rd brought a significant improvement. I continued to recover and was miraculously able to go home on March 24th to continue the treatment.
These are the narratives being promoted in the press and on social media. Indeed, Santilli’s story is showing up on the local Fox News broadcast, with a slanted report that makes it sound that the drug combination is definitely what saved him. Were hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin responsible for these handful of “miracle recoveries”? We really have no way of knowing without a randomized clinical trial. One thing is for certain. As is the case for alternative cancer cure testimonials, nothing will convince these patients that the “miracle drug” probably wasn’t what resulted in their improvement, and their stories sound convincing to the medically untrained. Worse, I predict that, even if the clinical trials are clearly negative, these sorts of stories will drive conspiracy theories that “they” (e.g., big pharma) covered up the evidence that these drugs work. Maybe the worst possibility of all is that we will never know for sure if these drugs work because the premature hype precludes completing a decent randomized clinical trial of sufficient power to answer the question definitively because no one will agree to be randomized to placebo. That is a distinct possibility, especially now that the FDA has caved to pressure and approved the use of these drugs against COVID-19 despite the extreme paucity of clinical effectiveness.
Enter the grifters and snake oil salesmen
Unsurprisingly, America’s Quack, Dr. Mehmet Oz, has jumped on the chloroquine bandwagon (because of course he has—it’s the sort of thing he does). Here is Mr. Giardinieri being interviewed by Dr. Oz on a segment on The Sean Hannity Show:
Dr. Oz on benefits, risks of using hydroxychloroquine to treat Coronavirus
Cardiac surgeon Dr. Mehmet Oz discusses benefits and risks of using hydroxychloroquine 'off-label' to treat coronavirus
Posted by Sean Hannity on Wednesday, March 25, 2020
Note that Dr. Oz’s take on Raoult’s study is completely credulous, and he says that he interviewed Raoult, because of course he has. He also reported that Raoult now asserts that it’s unethical to withhold hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin from COVID-19 patients, which just goes to show that he has no clue about the concept of clinical equipoise. Even worse, he’s parroting anecdotes while referring to them as “studies.” (None of them, other than Raoult’s studies and the negative Chinese study of chloroquine are published yet.) In fact, it’s profoundly unethical of Dr. Oz to promote this as yet unproven treatment. Looking over Dr. Oz’s website, it exploded yet another of my irony meters to see that his Thursday show this week will be “The COVID-19 Pandemic: Beware of Scammers Trying to Take Advantage of Your Fear of the Virus.”
Just look at Dr. Oz’s interview with Prof. Didier Raoult if you don’t believe me. Unsurprisingly, when Dr. Oz asks Prof. Raoult if there were any differences in clinical outcomes in the patients treated with his combination, he dodged the question.
Meanwhile, we have doctors like Dr. Vladimir Zelenko in New York is promoting an unproven drug cocktail involving hydroxychloroquine and posting videos like this that prove nothing:
🚨WATCH: The latest video from a leading physician in Kiryas Yoel, NY, Dr. Zelenko, regarding the his findings after treating a select high risk group of 699 patients in the past week w the chloroquine combination drug approved to treat COVID19 patients #COVID19 #Corona #hope pic.twitter.com/bLnWC82YSB
— Michalli 🦋 מיכל (@86thatplease) March 27, 2020
Meanwhile, he’s making incredibly irresponsible claims:
Zelenko is one of a handful contending it should be in widespread distribution to people at higher risk of having a serious case of Covid-19 with mid-level symptoms, most often without even confirming their illness is in fact connected to coronavirus.
He wrote in the emails sent on Friday that his clinic had so far given 669 outpatients the drug cocktail, and that none had died. He attached a spreadsheet in which he listed 54 high-risk cases, including three who required hospitalization.
In an interview Friday, Zelenko encouraged doctors to resist calls from infectious disease experts to prescribe the drug only as part of clinical trials and to critical patients.
“This is a World War III situation — it’s the virus versus humanity,” he said. “If we were to adopt their approach, there would be an extra million dead people.”
There is zero evidence that withholding hydroxychloroquine from mild cases will result in an extra million deaths. Dr. Zelenko’s actions and words are irresponsible and unethical.
It’s even worse, though. It’s not just hucksters like Dr. Oz and irresponsible doctors like Dr. Zelenko. Now, a shadowy conservative business group founded by a big time political donor to the Republican Party is entering the fray:
A conservative business group founded by a prolific Republican political donor is pressuring the White House to greenlight an unproven COVID-19 treatment, saying in an online petition that the country has plants in the U.S. ready to produce a drug but can’t because of “red tape, regulation, and a dysfunctional healthcare supply chain.”
In recent days, Home Depot co-founder Bernard Marcus’ Job Creators Network has placed Facebook ads and texted supporters to sign a petition urging President Donald Trump to “CUT RED TAPE” and make an anti-malarial drug called hydroxychloroquine available for treating those sickened with the virus, one such message obtained by ProPublica reads.
Mark my words, the same people who foisted the deceptive “right-to-try” law on us in order to weaken the FDA will take full advantage of the COVID-19 pandemic to further weaken the FDA in the name of “speeding up cures” and “cutting red tape.”
Finally, are stem cell quacks getting in on the action? I think you know the answer to that question:
Today we were joined by a very prominent guest in the medical field!
He sits down with us to discuss a very promising development, stem cell therapy to bolster immunity and ultimately defeat the disease.
Head to https://t.co/J0eGAZktZ8! pic.twitter.com/1F4FJjlOg6
— Rudy W. Giuliani (@RudyGiuliani) March 28, 2020
Yes, Rudy Giuliani is promoting not just hydroxychloroquine, but he’s also promoting stem cell quackery and cells from placentas:
Our special guest today on Common Sense describes the process of extracting placenta ”Killer Cells” and their effectiveness in attacking cancer and virally infected cells.
Trials need to be EXPEDITED.
Head to https://t.co/J0eGAZktZ8
— Rudy W. Giuliani (@RudyGiuliani) March 28, 2020
I fear that, when all is said and done, the COVID-19 pandemic will be the single greatest opportunity for grifters and snake oil salesmen I’ve seen in my lifetime. Until a vaccine and/or effective treatment is developed, the grift will continue.
In the meantime, we wait the results of clinical trials and for science to do what it always does, as I find myself living in one of the hottest COVID-19 hotspots in the US.

“Miracle cure” testimonials aside, azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine probably do not work against COVID-19
Here we go again. Didier Raoult has published another uninformative study looking at the use of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin to treat COVID-19. Unfortunately, recent data examining these drugs have been trending in the direction of the conclusion that these drugs probably don’t work against COVID-19 but do cause harm. Sadly, the lack of evidence hasn’t stopped the hucksters from promoting hydroxychloroquine as a cure for COVID-19.
David Gorski on April 13, 2020
Link

The COVID-19 pandemic has been a golden opportunity for quackery and antivaccine conspiracy theories. This is not unexpected, given the size and the current lack of specific therapies for the disease other than supportive care and the current death toll. However, there is another assault on evidence- and science-based medicine that doesn’t come from quacks (although quacks have definitely joined in on the attack). Rather, it comes from desperate and/or opportunistic doctors who, either through a terrified imperative to “do something, anything” in the face of dying patients whom they can’t save or from self-aggrandizing doctors like Dr. Mehmet Oz, Didier Raoult, and others, who, drunk with the arrogance of ignorance and loving the attention, promote unproven treatments with no evidence an irresponsible attitude of, “What harm could it do?” (Answer: A lot. The specific drugs, chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine, have toxicities that have been well-known since the 1960s.) Add to that politicians like Donald Trump, full of magical thinking and possessed of a long history of selling snake oil himself, glommed onto these drugs as the solution to the pandemic before clinical trials showed any benefit.
I’ve written about how incredibly weak the evidence base supporting the use of chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine (including the combination of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin) is twice already. Given that there have been developments in the two weeks since last I wrote about this topic, I thought that an update would be in order, as there are new studies. I’ll start with the “miracle cure” testimonials that have been used to argue that hydroxychloroquine ± azithromycine “saved” patients. (I know I’ve discussed a couple of these before.) Then I’ll move on to Didier Raoult’s latest study. Finally, I’ll discuss other evidence, including evidence of drug toxicity without evidence of benefit.
Familiar-sounding “miracle cure” testimonials
I’ve alluded to the sorts of anecdotes that have spread on social media and promoted by President Trump and his allies and how much they resemble alternative cancer cure testimonials from the patients of quacks like Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski. I’m referring, of course, to the stories of people like Rio Giardinieri and Jim Santilli, both of whom report their symptoms having remarkably improved after one dose of hydroxychloroquine.
The testimonial by a local Michigan State Representative Karen Whitsett takes the sort of testimonials that have been circulating one step further:
A Democratic state representative from Detroit is crediting hydroxychloroquine — and Republican President Donald Trump who touted the drug — for saving her in her battle with the coronavirus.
State Rep. Karen Whitsett, who learned Monday she has tested positive for COVID-19, said she started taking hydroxychloroquine on March 31, prescribed by her doctor, after both she and her husband sought treatment for a range of symptoms on March 18.
“It was less than two hours” before she started to feel relief, said Whitsett, who had experienced shortness of breath, swollen lymph nodes, and what felt like a sinus infection. She is still experiencing headaches, she said.
Unsurprisingly, the next day, Trump was touting her story:
Although he didn’t specifically name her, President Donald Trump praised a Detroit Democratic state representative during his daily briefing Tuesday for singling him out as she fought a coronavirus infection.
State Rep. Karen Whitsett, D-Detroit, who tested positive for coronavirus, said Monday that the drug hydroxychloroquine, and Trump’s continued trumpeting of the drug, helped save her life.
“She thought she was dead,” Trump said Tuesday. “I think she’ll be voting for me now.”
Whitsett, who learned Monday she had tested positive for COVID-19, said she started taking hydroxychloroquine on March 31, prescribed by her doctor, after both she and her husband sought treatment for a range of symptoms on March 18, twelve days. After taking the drug, she started feeling better within a couple of hours.
A relative of mine who forwarded the link to me noted that there were…inconsistencies…with Rep. Whitsett’s story. Supposedly, from what I can tell, she first started experiencing symptoms on March 18 and started taking hydroxychloroquine on March 31, with immediate relief. Then there’s this:
Whitsett said she was familiar with “the wonders” of hydroxychloroquine from an earlier bout with Lyme disease, but does not believe she would have thought to ask for it, or her doctor would have prescribed it, had Trump not been touting it as a possible treatment for COVID-19.
I note first that it shouldn’t be too surprising that Rep. Whitsett got better in roughly twelve days, given that that’s well within the parameters of the typical time course of symptomatic COVID-19 illness for people who recover. I also note that chronic Lyme disease is, of course, a fake diagnosis beloved of quacks, which to me throws up a big red flag regarding her story. Be that as it may, as I pointed out before, these sorts of stories actually make me think that hydroxychloroquine probably isn’t responsible for the recovery of the patients. If you know how these drugs work, you know that it’s very unlikely that a single dose of the drug would work so dramatically within 2-8 hours, and these stories all have a rather odd similarity to them. Unfortunately, the media gobble these stories up, because they’re compelling human interest stories and are hopeful at a time when most of the other news about the pandemic is profoundly depressing and alarming. Worse, these stories feed the narrative that I discussed before: that those doctors citing the lack of evidence for these drugs, and urging caution, are leading to the unnecessary deaths of COVID-19 patients.
Unsurprisingly, Rep. Whitsett is, unfortunately, feeding that narrative by starting with a valid criticism of our response to the pandemic thus far (the relative lack of testing for COVID-19 compared to what we need in order to be able to control the pandemic while loosening the restrictions of the current general lockdown that’s been imposed on huge swaths of the US and how this response demonstrates major disparities in care related to race) to point out that the only reason she was likely tested for COVID-19 is because she’s a state representative and to accuse state health authorities of, in essence, letting her family members die:
Now, Whitsett says her cousin, Cheryl Fowler, is asking for hydroxychloroquine but has been unable to get it at Henry Ford Hospital.
“They will not give it to her,” she said. In order to change that, “I need to talk to the president of the United States.”
Gambrell said he believes doctors plan to give his mother hydroxychloroquine on Thursday, but they did not want to give it to her Wednesday because of other medication she is taking for pneumonia.
Fowler needs the drug immediately, Whitsett said. “They want to wait until the person needs a ventilator,” she said. “By the time they’re ventilated, it’s too late.”
The most recent narrative regarding hydroxychloroquine is that it has to be started early in the course of COVID-19 infection or it will be ineffective. Unfortunately, there currently is no good evidence to support this latest narrative. Of course, nothing will convince patients relating these anecdotes that hydroxychloroquine very likely didn’t save them:
“Whether hydroxychloroquine works or not is a question that still needs an answer. At this point anyone who says the drug helped them is simply relating an anecdote. I have also seen patients on hydroxychloroquine who have died. I totally understand the need for hope but this is not a miracle drug,” Local 4′s Doctor Frank McGeorge said.
Whitsett believes it worked for her.
Just like cancer patients believe that Stanislaw Burzynski’s quackery or various other cancer quackery “worked for them.” Humans, being pattern-seeking animals, are very prone to latching on to correlations and imputing causation to them. Meanwhile, right wing Fox News pundits are Tweeting things like this:
An old pal in Los Angeles (no Trump fan) just texted me that seven friends of hers (here and in Sweden) ALL took hydroxychloroquine, all recovered quickly, zero side effects. Called it a “godsend.”
— Laura Ingraham (@IngrahamAngle) April 10, 2020
Her anecdote, even if verified, doesn’t mean that hydroxychloroquine was why they got better. The vast majority of patients with COVID-19 recover uneventfully. Only a minority develop severe disease, and only a minority of patients taking hydroxychloroquine suffer significant side effects, the minority suffering life-threatening side effects being even smaller. Without a control group and a large number of patients you simply can’t tell if an intervention for COVID-19 “worked” or, more specifically, if hydroxychloroquine is safe in this setting.
As I’ve said before, the COVID-19 pandemic has indeed revealed major disparities in care and outcomes among minority populations, but attempting to restrict the off-label use of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine in order to prevent hoarding and preserve the supply for patients who need it is not one of them. It’s also supremely irresponsible of journalists to publish these stories, even if they interview a medical expert to caution that, barring good evidence from randomized trials, there’s no way of knowing if the treatment was responsible for the patient’s recovery. The reason is that the cautionary statements from health experts about hydroxychloroquine ± azithromycin are always lost in the hopeful message of a patient who recovered after taking the drug.
Indeed, even when the patient gets worse after taking hydroxychloroquine, the narrative is that the drug saved him, as long as he ultimately gets better. Take the case of Billy Saracino. One week after developing COVID-19 symptoms:
The fateful day came on March 20, when Saracino woke up in the middle of the night uncontrollably coughing. His wife immediately called Bock.
At his doctor’s urging, Saracino swallowed three pills of Hydroxychloroquine (at 200 mg each), and another three the following morning before he was admitted to Hackensack University Medical Center.
“I had a feeling [Billy’s case] was turning bad,” said Bock, “so we started him before he went into the hospital.”
On March 21, with a fast heart rate and difficulty breathing, Saracino went to the emergency room:
Saracino was immediately taken for a chest X-ray, which showed bilateral viral pneumonia. Then, he was admitted to the ER — which, unlike the triage area — was completely full, he said.
“My heart rate wasn’t good and my oxygen was low,” Saracino said. “My doctor was on the phone with the doctors and went through all my symptoms. He said ‘You cannot let him out.'”
And then:
Saracino spent three nights in the hospital: Saturday, March 21 through Monday, March 23. He had chills, body aches and a terrible migraine. He would spent two hours sleeping, and then another two awake.
But then, exactly 48 hours after taking the initial dose of Hydroxychloroquine, Saracino says he started to feel better.
“I was sweating, I had to change clothes,” Saracino said. “Then I started walking around a little bit.”
“It’s no question,” Bock said. “I think Hydroxychloroquine really helped him through this.”
Every patient that Bock put Hydroxychloroquine on recovered except for one, whose condition worsened rapidly over the course of several hours, before the medication had time to work, the doctor said.
So let me get this straight. Saracino got worse for two days while taking the drug, and then he got better? Truly, no matter what the clinical course (other than death), whenever a patient receives hydroxychloroquine or the hydroxychloroquine/azithromycin combination, it must have been the drugs that were responsible for his recovery, even if he kept getting worse for two days after starting the drug before turning the corner. Seriously, you could just as plausibly blame hydroxychloroquine for Saracino’s clinical deterioration on March 20! Don’t believe me? Read the case of Carl Shuck, who was treated with hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, and zinc but was still on a ventilator for two weeks before recovering. Read the case of Sophie Avouris, a 102 year old woman who was treated with hydroxychloroquine and the azithromycin for a week and recovered.
You get the idea. Basically, if you receive these drugs and recover, no matter how much time it takes, obviously the drugs cured you. Such is the narrative the media is feeding the public, “miracle recoveries” that might or might not have had anything to do with hydroxychloroquine with or without azithromycin.
Didier Raoult publishes another study
Unchastened by the fierce criticism for his first two studies, last week Didier Raoult published another study. The first of his trio of scientific crap was an unrandomized study that claimed that the combination of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin eliminated the virus completely compared to controls or hydroxychloroquine alone. Its flaws were so numerous and manifest as to make the study painfully uninformative. Indeed, based on the shenanigans Raoult engaged in with the data, plus his history of fabricating data, I now suspect, but obviously cannot prove, scientific fraud. Even the International Society of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy (ISAC), which publishes the journal that published this study, backed away, even going so far as to state that the article “does not meet the Society’s expected standard, especially relating to the lack of better explanations of the inclusion criteria and the triage of patients to ensure patient safety.” Muddying the waters is a second statement issued a week later, apparently at the behest of Elsevier, that seems to soften the criticism and points out that the journal’s peer review process had been followed, even as it suggests a possible joint investigation with Elsevier.
The second study in the trio was a single arm case series that consisted of a huge percentage of COVID-19 patients treated with azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine who were not very ill at all. Only 15% of them even had fever, even though data from around the world show that 90% of symptomatic COVID-19 patients have fever during the course of their illness. Basically, the vast majority of these patients were patients who would have been sent home and told to self-quarantine, with instructions to call or go to the emergency room if they get significantly worse and especially if they start experiencing shortness of breath. Raoult claimed that the combination of azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine was very effective in clearing the SARS-CoV-2 virus, but there’s no way of knowing if these patients wouldn’t have cleared the virus anyway. It, too, was a singularly uninformative study.
So what about the third study? As of Sunday, Raoult has published only an abstract and a data table for 1,061 patients treated with his azithromycin/hydroxychloroquine combination, with no full manuscript yet. Of course, this dataset suffers from even more issues than his previous papers, as there are no methods to look at, and we can’t look at his study design in depth or his inclusion/exclusion criteria. Taking the results at face value, between March 3 and April 9, Raoult’s group tested 59,665 specimens from 38,167 patients for COVID-19 by PCR. There were 3,165 patients who tested positive, of which 1,061 met Raoult’s unstated inclusion criteria and were treated with his azithromycin/hydroxychloroquine combination. The mean age of the patients was 43.6 years old, and 492 (46.4%) were male. The results further state that a “good clinical outcome and virological cure” were observed in 973 patients within 10 days (91.7%), with prolonged viral carriage in 47 patients (4.4%), with viral clearance in all but one by day 15. They further observed:
A poor outcome was observed for 46 patients (4.3%); 10 were transferred to intensive care units, 5 patients died (0.47%) (74-95 years old) and 31 required 10 days of hospitalization or more. Among this group, 25 patients are now cured and 16 are still hospitalized (98% of patients cured so far). Poor clinical outcome was significantly associated to older age (OR 1.11), initial higher severity (OR 10.05) and low hydroxychloroquine serum concentration. In addition, both poor clinical and virological outcomes were associated to the use of selective beta-blocking agents and angiotensin II receptor blockers (P<0.05). Mortality was significantly lower in patients who had received > 3 days of HCQ-AZ than in patients treated with other regimens both at IHU and in all Marseille public hospitals (p
This study suffers from the same issues that Raoult’s much smaller study. The overwhelming majority of patients (1,008, or 95%) had a low national early warning score (NEWS), with 97.4% of the patients with a “good clinical outcome” (not defined). The table shows patients taking beta blockers and angiotensin II receptor blockers having “poor virological outcome,” while patients taking metformin (used to treat type II diabetes), beta blockers (used for hypertension and angina, as well as certain cardiac rhythm disturbances), dihydropyridine derivatives (a class of calcium channel blockers, often used for hypertension, cardiac rhythm disturbances, and angina), angiotensin II receptor blockers, HMG CoA reductase inhibitors (statins), and diuretics (used to treat hypertension and heart failure) were more likely to have “poor clinical outcomes.” Of course, it is most likely the diagnoses for which these drugs are used, rather than the drugs themselves, that are responsible for the poor outcomes in COVID-19 patients, and there’s no indication that Raoult’s group tried to do any sort of analysis to tease out whether these associations were with the drugs themselves or with the conditions being treated with the drugs.
The bottom line is that this study is also uninformative. For one thing, a 0.5% fatality rate is at the low end of current estimates and might even be the “true” case fatality rate when all cases of mild and asymptomatic infections are included in the denominator. This study certainly doesn’t show that Raoult’s treatment was responsible for the low mortality rate. When the overwhelming percentage of the patients you treat have mild or asymptomatic disease, then of course should expect to observe that the fatality rate among these patients will be low, no matter what you do. The reason Didier Raoult refuses to do a truly randomized trial is because he’s now a true believer in his combination, which has led him to conclude that it’s unethical to randomize COVID-19 patients to a placebo control group. Worse, French President Emannuel Macron has started emulating our President Donald Trump and become a booster for Raoult’s bad science. Whether it’s out of a misplaced nationalistic pride or other reason Macron has been talking up Raoult’s results, even though Raoult has produced no data sufficiently compelling to know if his combination is safe and effective or not.
Worse, there appear to be some…discrepancies…in the reporting of Raoult’s data on his website. There’s an excellent Twitter thread by Lu Chen, a scientist at the NIH’s National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences functional genomics library:
(1/n) Raoult’s team reported the result of hydroxychloroquine + azithromycin trial to treat COVID19 for > 1k patients.https://t.co/DVnnv15sIFhttps://t.co/rNlvr60zR3
Once again, data is broken, and I smelled their anxiety several days ago. https://t.co/sKQe0tB5DY
Threads🔻
— Lu Chen #noCoffee (@houndcl) April 9, 2020
She reported possible discrepancies between what Raoult published, and what he had previous posted on the IHU COVID-19 website:
(2/n) I closely monitor IHU’s COVID-19 website since the birth on 3/26. https://t.co/1ea5nQKR37
This website reports the number of COVID positives & death in APHM/IHU, and num of positives & death with >3d treatment. Some major discrepancies have been found.
website data: pic.twitter.com/NODsEQVZRX
— Lu Chen #noCoffee (@houndcl) April 9, 2020
Indeed, she notes some suspicious numbers:
(3/n)
Suspicious numbers:
3/30: number of patients with “H+A” treatment -8
4/4: no update
4/5: total death + 1, BUT “H+A” death +2. (NOBEL PRIZE PLEASE!)
4/5-4/6: >10k increase in total tests, >2k increase in total positive.
4/8: Total tests -10k, total positives -1.7k
— Lu Chen #noCoffee (@houndcl) April 9, 2020
And a “massive data loss” after April 6, with data only through March 31 being reported”
(4/n)
I had a gut feeling on 4/6 that they will take “some” action since the death in H+A start to increase dramatically.
What a coincidence! -No data on 4/7-Massive data loss on 4/8-Rush a preprint out on 4/9 which reports the data till 3/31
— Lu Chen #noCoffee (@houndcl) April 9, 2020
Now, as a response in the Twitter thread mentions, there could be an innocent explanation, but I agree 100% with Lu Chen that the data management is a disaster and Raoult’s group has no idea what it’s doing analyzing clinical trial data. Basically, I don’t trust any data coming out of that group:
(9/n) Conclusion
The data management is a disaster. No matter combo work or not, Raoult's team doesn't have a good system to handle the clinical data from thousands of patients properly.
Cannot wait to see the data from the other 1k patients who already received 3d treatment.
— Lu Chen #noCoffee (@houndcl) April 9, 2020
Also, it’s important to emphasize that the patients in this trial were drawn from the general population volunteering to be tested for COVID-19, which likely explains why 95% had mild or asymptomatic disease. This trial says basically nothing about whether Raoult’s combination works.
Raoul Didier: Brave maverick doctor
I sometimes like to refer to doctors who think they have The Answer to a particular clinical problem, even when the evidence that their proposed treatment is an “answer” to anything is incredibly weak or even nonexistent, as “brave maverick doctors.” They like to see themselves as bucking the system. Because, prior to his promotion of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin being echoed by President Trump, celebrity doctors like Dr. Oz and Dr. Drew, and a wide variety of right wing pundits, he was unknown outside of France, other than in some international scientific circles. That’s why this post was of great interest to me, as it described his history. And what a dubious history it is, at least with respect to COVID-19. On January 23, 2020, Raoult was saying things like:
You know, this is a crazy world. The fact is that some people have died from the coronavirus in China, you know, I don’t feel so concerned. It’s true to say that the world has gone completely crazy, that is to say that if something is happening where there are three Chinese people who are dying and that becomes a worldwide alert, the WHO gets involved, it’s on the radio and on television. […] In other words, there is no longer any sense of lucidity.
Whenever there is a disease in the world we wonder whether we are going to have the same thing in France. It has become utterly insane. [ …] I don’t know, people don’t seem to have anything to worry about, so they try and find something to be afraid of in China, just because they are unable to face what they might be afraid of if staying in France. That’s it, this is not serious.
Eventually, he discovered hydroxychloroquine. One thing that bothers me is how few people know the origin of the idea that hydroxychloroquine might be effective against COVID-19. The hypothesis that antimalarial drugs might be effective treatments for COVID-19 originated in Wuhan, China during the early phase of the pandemic in January. There, Chinese researchers reported that none of their 80 patients with lupus erythematosus who were taking hydroxychloroquine went on to become infected with SARS-CoV-2. As a result of that and old evidence of antiviral activity for the drugs, they became interested in using these antimalarial drugs to treat COVID-19. (Never mind that immunosuppressed patients are exactly the patients most likely to assiduously follow the recommendations of public health authorities during a pandemic.) A number of clinical trials were registered, and, based on anecdotal reports and small clinical trials (nearly all of which are as yet unpublished), in February the Chinese government published an expert consensus recommending CQ or HCQ for patients with COVID-19. Soon after, a number of nations followed suit. Apparently Raoult found out about this, and suddenly, at the end of February, he posted a video entitled Coronavirus: End of the game, later renamed “Coronavirus: A way out of the crisis?”
In the video, Raoult said:
    • “From all respiratory infections, it is probably the easiest to treat.””
    • “There’s no need to get excited.”
    • “Be careful, there will soon be no more chloroquine in drugstores.”
The article lists numerous other examples of Raoult downplaying the severity of COVID-19, comparing it to seasonal influenza, and denouncing government actions to stop its spread as an overreaction. There’s also a recounting of his history of abusive behavior towards his underlings, charges of sexual harassment leveled at him, his history of being a climate science denier, and mismanagement at his institute. Meanwhile, evolutionary biologist P.Z. Myers has dissected in detail Raoult’s painful misunderstanding of evolutionary biology, while others have described a history of data fabrication by his group. Oh, and did I mention that he might be an antivaxxer? In 2018, he published a book entitled La vérité sur les vaccins. The title and the blurb for the book sure sound at least borderline antivaccine to me. The very best thing that can be said on this score is that Raoult strikes me as someone who exaggerates the risks of vaccines and buys into too much false balance with claims made by antivaxxers.
In other words, Didier Raoult is a dubious source.
Conflicting, but mostly negative, evidence
So, the evidence base supporting hydroxychloroquine comes mostly from Didier Raoult, but not entirely. The most recent Chinese randomized trial was published online as a preprint (meaning that it hasn’t undergone peer review yet). It’s a larger (but still small) randomized trial of hydroxychloroquine given for five days at a dose of 400 mg/d. They reported that time to clinical recovery, body temperature recovery time, and cough remission time were significantly shortened in the treated group and that the proportion of patients with improved pneumonia was higher in the hydroxychloroquine group (80.6%) compared to controls (54.2%). They also noted that all four patients who progressed to severe illness were in the control group, while two patients in the hydroxychloroquine group experienced minor side effects (one had a rash, the other headache). There are some problems, however. First, this is not placebo-controlled. The authors claim that neither “the research performers nor the patients were aware of the treatment assignments,” but how could that be? The patients could know if they were receiving hydroxychloroquine or not, as could the nurses and the physicians treating them. That could subtly have affected their assessments of the patients, and it could have affected how patients reported their symptoms. (The study relied on patient reports of how severe their coughs were, for instance.) True, body temperature is an objective endpoint, but most other endpoints examined has at least some degree of subjectivity. Worse, the statistics were dodgy on the paper. For instance, I see what looks like Student’s t-test being used on a case of multiple comparisons, and one of the p-values (Table 2) is 0.0476. Let’s just say that whenever a p-value is that close to 0.05 buy still “significant,” my skeptical antennae start twitching wondering if the data underwent some “massaging” to make sure the p-value was significant.
These Tweets also point out some other flaws:
Details do not match the original plan, to recruit 300 cases in three groups. Intended outcomes: RNA clearance and T cell recovery time.https://t.co/mkfJy3Po8A
Earlier press release is different again:https://t.co/sEEXIIeSrR
— Smut Clyde, X-Ray Haruspex (@SmutClyde) March 30, 2020
They obviously had recruiting problems, given they only found 62 patients with an initial target of 300.
Original plan: (a) control group, (b) 100mg 2x/day, (c) 200mg 2x/day.
100mg 2x/day is underdosed given the IC50. So dropping that group to increase N/group makes sense.
— ice9 (@__ice9) April 1, 2020
They write "significantly improved" but the significant is just a clinical assessment. There is not a single significance test in the paper. I think they had to stop the study when they ran out of new patients and simply published results so far. Underpowered results.
— JH – the masked pokemon! (@jhan2qt) March 31, 2020
Basically, the best you can say about this study is that it is mildly promising, but so badly flawed that no firm conclusion can be drawn. Rigorous double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trials are desperately needed.
It’s also not as though there weren’t evidence of harm, either. For example:
France reported 43 cases of heart incidents linked to treating coronavirus patients with hydroxychloroquine, the malaria drug President Donald Trump has repeatedly touted as a potential “game changer.”
As the U.S. stockpiles as many as 29 million doses of the drug, which is also used to treat lupus and rheumatoid arthritis, the data on adverse reactions from France’s drug safety agency highlights the risk of using unproven treatments to stem a pandemic that’s killed more than 100,000 people worldwide.
Meanwhile, Sweden is reporting a similar experience, with several hospitals no longer routinely using these antimalarial drugs, due to adverse events.
In addition, there are studies that are concerning about the potential risks of widely prescribing these drugs. Most are not peer reviewed and thus published on a preprint server, such as this one from NYU that observed QT-segment prolongation in adult patients treated with hydroxychloroquine. Last week, another preprint was published from a multinational team out of Brazil. This was a parallel, double-blinded, randomized, phase IIb clinical trial that studied 81 COVID-19 patients. There were two groups, patients receiving high dose (600 mg twice a day over ten days) versus low dose (450 mg twice a day on the first day, once a day thereafter for the next four) chloroquine plus ceftriaxone, a cephalosporin antibiotic. There was no placebo control because Brazil had mandated chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19 patients. The study reports that the high dose patients showed more severe QT prolongation and that there was a trend towards higher mortality compared to the low dose. In summary:
The high dose CQ arm presented more QTc>500ms (25%), and a trend toward higher lethality (17%) than the lower dosage. Fatality rate was 13.5% (95%CI=6.9–23.0%), overlapping with the CI of historical data from similar patients not using CQ (95%CI=14.5-19.2%). In 14 patients with paired samples, respiratory secretion at day 4 was negative in only one patient.
To be honest, this “trend” had a p-value of 0.35; so I find it hard to call it even a trend. However, it is very clear that, at best there is no difference between the groups, and at worst higher doses of the drug are associated with a higher risk of death. Even so, the results were alarming enough that the Brazilian researchers stopped using high dose chloroquine, moved the patients in the high dose arm to the low dose arm, and are now studying only the low dose protocol, a reasonable precaution given that their preliminary data on viral clearance in respiratory secretions in confirmed cases suggest little or no effect of the drug, even at high dosage. However, in the absence of placebo controls, I really have a hard time figuring out how useful this study will end up being in determining if chloroquine is effective.
Bringing it on home
Finally, experience in hospitals in my neck of the woods suggest that hydroxychloroquine might actually be harmful. One is a study from my own institution that is currently undergoing peer review that suggests that reported worse outcomes in patients treated with hydroxychloroquine. It has somehow leaked prematurely on social media. I know about it because an associate dean sent it to a number of faculty. I didn’t share it, although I did mention publicly that I knew about it and had read it. All this leaves me, as it left others who knew about the study, torn on how to discuss it, given that it’s not yet peer reviewed or published, and that it hasn’t shown up on a preprint server yet. What I think I will do is simply to mention that it is a quasi-randomized study reporting on 63 hospitalized patients in affiliated institutions with COVID-19 that found, at the very least, no difference in outcomes, but with some parameters suggesting a worse outcome compared to supportive care alone. When the manuscript is published, either after peer review or on a preprint server, I’ll add the relevant links and then decide whether to beef up the discussion in this post or to do a new post about the study, either here or on my not-so-secret other blog.
That aside, my medical alma mater, the University of Michigan, recently published a blog post about its experience with COVID-19, including with the use of hydroxychloroquine to treat it. Basically, doctors at U. of M. have decided to stop routinely using hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19, because they have seen no evidence of efficacy but have seen toxicity:
Michigan Medicine just changed its guidelines on prescribing these drugs. There’s a lot of excitement about whether these already existing options for malaria could be useful in COVID-19, but so far that excitement hasn’t materialized in patient care data.
“Our infectious disease division and our antimicrobial pharmacists have reviewed all the available data and we found no convincing evidence that these drugs were effective in treating people with COVID-19,” Kaul says.
That’s consistent with what’s been observed firsthand in Michigan Medicine’s hospitals.
“We haven’t seen any clear evidence of benefit so we aren’t going to use hydroxychloroquine routinely anymore,” Chopra says. “We were initially recommending it to both inpatients and outpatients, but we’re no longer doing that routinely. That’s based upon the fact that we’ve been prescribing hydroxychloroquine for a few weeks, did not see therapeutic benefit, but did see adverse effects.”
Those side effects Chopra has seen in his patients include liver function toxicity, nausea and vomiting.
I’ll conclude by simply saying this. Taken together, the evidence that hydroxychloroquine, chloroquine, or the hydroxychloroquine/azithromycin combination is an effective treatment for COVID-19 is getting weaker with every publication, to the point where I am 95% sure now that they either don’t work or that any benefit they might have will be outweighed by side effects. Could I still be wrong? Sure, and I’d be happy to be wrong given the desperate need for effective treatments against COVID-19. But I don’t think I am. In the end, the hype over these drugs and particularly the rush by doctors on the flimsiest of evidence to make hydroxychloroquine, in essence, a standard of care, have shown just how weak most doctors’ allegiance to evidence-based medicine is and represent one of the most massive failures of EBM that I can recall.

Dexamethasone and Hydroxychloroquine: Why Randomized Controlled Trials Matter
What does the best evidence tell us about hydroxychloroquine and dexamethasone?
Scott Gavura on August 20, 2020
Link

With COVID-19 cases continuing to rise, and no vaccine available anytime soon, investigations into repurposing existing drugs, to treat or prevent infections, continue to be a priority. Thankfully, the evidence base has improved dramatically since the early months of 2020 where there was almost nothing to guide treatment. Initial observations, starting in China and then Europe, led to case series reports and eventually, medical professionals started to form hypotheses about potentially effective therapies. Some of these approaches sounded plausible, and weak but promising observational studies started to emerge, showing correlations between specific treatments and better outcomes for patients. At the same time, randomized controlled trials (RCTs) were launched, based on the expectation that (1) these therapies might offer some benefit and (2) better evidence was needed. RCTs are experiments that are intended to reduce sources of bias, which can confound or distort the findings that come from observational studies. RCTs of COVID-19 treatments are now appearing regularly, as there has been adequate time to plan them, recruit patients, administer the therapy, collect data, and then evaluate and publish the results. And the conclusions of these trials show that some previously promising therapies did not actually seem to work. This 180° pivot in treatment advice after only a few months may seem bewildering – after all, if the medical advice isn’t consistent, why should you believe the newest evidence? But the findings of RCTs are exactly what we should have expected when we started treating COVID-19 based on anecdotes and research methods that were almost certain to have hidden biases. As more robust evidence emerges, the evidence-based approach to treating COVID-19 is changing. And it will continue to change. That is a good thing. One way to illustrate this evidence evolution is to examine two therapies that were both initially thought to be promising: Hydroxychloroquine and dexamethasone.
The importance of randomized controlled trials
Correlation does not equal causation. This is embedded in the minds of most health professionals during their training. But medical professionals are human, and humans are prone to biases. Carefully designed research can cut through biases and give us a better perspective on the value of different treatments. RCTs are sometimes called the “gold standard” of evidence. While RCTs cannot answer every question, they are a rigorous method of examining if there is a cause and effect relationship between a treatment and an outcome. One of the key feature is randomization: it distributes a population randomly into two (or more) groups, where we expect the only meaningful difference between the two groups is the treatment itself. A second important but not essential feature is blinding: where both the investigators and the participants are not aware of where the patient is randomized, to avoid any hidden biases in evaluating the effects. RCTs can be flawed (in terms of design, conduct and analysis), and they are time consuming and expensive to mount. However, a well-designed RCT provides a better view of a treatment’s “true” effect than a comparable observational study.
RCTs can and have shown that widely accepted treatments and practices are in fact useless. The example that I still think about today is a paper that was published while I was in pharmacy school, and its 30-year-old lessons are still relevant. The Cardiac Arrhythmia Suppression Trial (CAST) was a randomized controlled trial that was designed to test the effectiveness of drugs to treat a specific type of arrhythmia: heart rhythm dysfunction that had no symptoms, but could be detected with cardiac monitoring equipment. The occurrence of these premature beats was known to be a risk factor for subsequent sudden death, and medication existed that had been shown to reduce their frequency. Drug treatment of these arrhythmias was common, and many millions were spent every year on drug therapy. However, no evidence actually existed to prove that treating these arrhythmias actually reduced the risk of death. A randomized controlled trial, CAST, was established to presumably demonstrate the merits of this approach. 1,500 people were randomized to one of encainide, flecainide, or placebo. Both of these drugs were already in use to treat arrhythmia, so it was expected that they would show a mortality benefit. However, the trial was stopped early. While the drugs did reduce ventricular premature beats, they were also causing a significantly increased rate of deaths due to arrhythmia or cardiac arrest, as well as increasing the risk of death due to a second heart attack. The drugs were killing patients (8.3% mortality on the drugs vs. 3.5% on placebo), not helping them. Not only did CAST reinforce the importance of studying endpoints that matter to patients (like death) instead of surrogate indicators (like the presence of premature beats) but it reinforced the critical importance of rigorously testing therapies, prospectively, with RCTs.
How we know hydroxychloroquine doesn’t have any beneficial effect on COVID-19
David Gorski and other contributors have written numerous posts over the past several months regarding hydroxychloroquine from its anecdotal beginnings based on Chinese hypotheses to observational trials that were published in France. I refer you to those excellent posts if you’re interested in the politics, posturing, and bad arguments in favour of its use. I want to show you why there is now convincing evidence that hydroxychloroquine is ineffective, by looking past the (methodologically) weaker trial designs, and summarizing the six largest, most rigorously conducted trials. Five of these trials have been published, and one is available in pre-print only. (Thank you to Dr. Perry Wilson for the helpful list on Twitter.) Here are the findings and links so you can peruse the research yourself:
     1.  In patients admitted to a hospital with mild-to-moderate COVID-19 and randomized to hydroxychloroquine or a placebo for 2-3 weeks, there was no difference in terms of improvement (measured by checking if the body had eliminated the virus) at the 28 day point. [Ref: BMJ 2020; 369:m1849]
     2.  After exposure to someone with COVID-19, patients were randomized to hydroxychloroquine or placebo for five days. There was no difference in terms of the subsequent rate of infections. The hydroxychloroquine group experienced more side effects. [Ref: N Engl J Med 2020; 383:517-525]
     3.  Non-hospitalized patients with confirmed COVID-19 and less than five days of symptoms were randomized to hydroxychloroquine or placebo for one week. There was no difference in terms of the reduction of viral load, the risk of hospitalization, or the time to resolution of symptoms. [Ref: Clinical Infectious Diseases 2020; ciaa1009]
     4.  In non-hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID-19 or probable COVID-19, patients were randomized to hydroxychloroquine or placebo for five days. There was no difference in overall symptom severity over 14 days. The hydroxychloroquine group experienced more side effects. [Ref: Ann Int Med 2020; doi.org/10.7326/M20-4207]
     5.  In hospitalized patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 who were receiving supplemental oxygen, patient were randomized to usual care, usual care plus hydroxychloroquine, or usual care plus hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin. There was no difference between the groups in terms of clinical status at day 15. [Ref: N Engl J Med 2020; DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa2019014]
     6.  In a preprint article (not yet peer-reviewed), hospitalized patients with COVID-19 were randomized to hydroxychloroquine for 10 days or until discharge, versus usual care. There was no difference with respect to 28 day mortality, but the hydroxychloroquine group had an increased duration of hospital stay and an increased risk of progressing to ventilation or death. [Ref: medRxiv 2020; doi 10.1101/2020.07.15.20151852]
Dr. F. Perry Wilson (@methodsmanmd) has done the world a great service by putting all the RCTs into the following table, where you can contrast with Didier Raoult’s paper (row 1, previously discussed by David Gorski), which was not an RCT:

The table is not every RCT, and more RCTs will undoubtedly emerge. But prospectively conducted rigorous trials give a consistent picture: hydroxychloroquine does not have any meaningful effects on the prevention or treatment of COVID-19 infections.
One good trial can change practice
In contrast with hydroxychloroquine, another cheap generic drug that has been around for years has also been studied for COVID-19, and the results don’t seem nearly as controversial. Dexamethasone is from the class of drugs known as corticosteroids – a type of drug that reduces inflammation. Corticosteroids mimic the chemical cortisol, a hormone produced by the body (corticosteroids are not similar to steroids like testosterone, which have different functions). Corticosteroids have a huge array of effects and that’s why you see them in non-prescription anti-itch creams (e.g., hydrocortisone) or used in the treatment of inflammatory diseases (e.g., prednisone). Along with a huge array of potentially beneficial and even life-saving effects (through reducing unwanted inflammation) there is also a huge list of side effects, which increase in severity with dose, type of corticosteroid, and duration of use.
Corticosteroids are regularly used in patients that are critically ill and in intensive care units. Their use has not been without controversy and it has not always been clear that the more immediate, beneficial effects correlate with longer-term outcomes, like survival. One of the earliest observations in patients with COVID-19 infections was the lung damage observed on X-ray. Given corticosteroids have the potential to reduce inflammatory damage, there was interest in testing them to see if they actually improved survival. These drugs were also used in the past to treat other illnesses related to COVID-19, like SARS and MERS, but the overall evidence from this use was unclear owing in part to different doses and treatment protocols. Dexamethasone is inexpensive and available in virtually every hospital and pharmacy.
The RECOVERY group (Randomised Evaluation of COVID-19 Therapy) designed an evaluation of dexamethasone in critically ill patients. (The same research group is responsible for the hydroxychloroquine paper that is still in preprint (#6) above.) It prospectively randomized hospitalized patients to receive dexamethasone or usual care. Patients received oral or intravenous dexamethasone (6mg daily) for ten days. Over 2,000 patients were recruited starting in mid-March, 2020. The primary outcome was 28-day mortality. Overall, 22.9% of patients that received dexamethasone died, compared to 25.7% of patients who received usual care. This result was statistically (and clinically) significant, and was even more pronounced in patients that received mechanical ventilation: 23.3% in the dexamethasone group versus 41.4% in the usual care group. Those who received oxygen without ventilation also benefited (23.3% vs. 26.2%). In the group that was receiving no ventilation support at randomization, there was no effect.
This large, rapidly conducted trial gave a clear answer to an important question. Dexamethasone will reduce the risk of death in some hospitalized patients by up to one-third. It clarifies early uncertainty about the risks and benefits of corticosteroids and has changed how COVID-19 will be treated.
Good evidence matters
In a time of pandemic, there is pressure to act. When COVID-19 arrived, medical professionals had to base treatment decisions on low-quality evidence, even anecdotes. There is tremendous pressure on researchers and medical professionals for clear, consistent answers, which is near-impossible when you start with almost nothing. Initial uncertainty is now being replaced by higher-quality, less biased evidence. Well-designed, rigorous research is giving us answers and changing medical practice – telling us that some therapies are ineffective, while some will save lives. RCTs are not perfect, and cannot answer every question we have about COVID-19. However, they contain safeguards in their design and when done well, can dispel accumulated dogma. We need more evidence on how to prevent and treat COVID-19 infections, and we need to be humble enough to accept that what we think may be true today, isn’t.

Hydroxychloroquine and the price of abandoning of science- and evidence-based medicine
Based on anecdotal evidence early in the pandemic and then-unreported clinical trials, followed by hype and bad studies by French “brave maverick doctor” Didier Raoult, antimalarial drugs hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine became the de facto standard of care for COVID-19, despite no rigorous evidence that they worked. A steady drip-drip-drip of negative studies has led doctors and health authorities to rethink and backtrack, while proponents counterattack. The story of these drugs demonstrates the peril of bypassing EBM even during a pandemic.
David Gorski on April 27, 2020
Link

I have been discussing the premature—and, from my perspective, bizarre—fixation with using the antimalarial drugs chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 and the abandonment of critical thinking and science-based medicine ever since a French “brave maverick doctor” named Didier Raoult first published a truly execrable and possibly fraudulent study last month claiming that the combination of hydroxychloroquine plus azithromycin could eliminate SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Since then, Raoult published a second study, an uncontrolled case series made up primarily of patients with very mild or even asymptomatic COVID-19 and an update on the case series that suffered from all the same flaws that made the first case series singularly uninformative. Meanwhile, as I discussed a couple of weeks ago, studies from any source other than Raoult’s group were piling up and strongly suggesting that neither hydroxychloroquine nor the hydroxychloroquine + azithromycin combination demonstrate detectable activity against COVID-19 but do cause toxicity. As I’ve pointed out before, the entire saga shows that, when push comes to shove and a crisis hits, physicians’ dedication to science- and evidence-based medicine is disturbingly weak. (If you don’t believe me, look at the comments after this video, which consist mostly of doctors questioning why the doctor in the video was not enthusiastic about using the drug and touting their anecdotal experience to argue that the drug works.) So it came as no surprise (to me, at least) when the FDA issued a warning on Friday about chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine:
The Food and Drug Administration warned consumers Friday against taking malaria drugs chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine to treat Covid-19 outside a hospital or formal clinical trial setting after deaths and poisonings were reported.
The agency said patients taking the drugs for approved reasons, including malaria or to treat autoimmune conditions like lupus, should continue taking their medicine as prescribed.
The agency also said it became aware of reports of “serious heart rhythm problems” in patients with the virus who were treated with the malaria drugs, often in combination with antibiotic azithromycin, commonly known as a Z-Pak. It also warned physicians against prescribing the drugs to treat the coronavirus outside of a hospital.
The full text of the FDA warning can be found here. Given this warning, I thought that an update on the hydroxychloroquine story was in order, as a lot of things have happened just in the last two weeks that demonstrate that, even in a pandemic, it’s almost never a good idea to bypass science- and evidence-based medicine. Certainly, in the case of hydroxychloroquine, it wasn’t.
First, though, it’s been said that the FDA’s issuance of an emergency use authorization (EUA) for these drugs to treat COVID-19 was one of the most irresponsible things the FDA has ever done, far more based on politics than science, and the FDA’s having to issue this warning demonstrates one reason why. The public and, sadly, many doctors don’t know the difference between an EUA and FDA approval, tending to view them as basically equivalent. The restrictions on the use of these drugs in the EUA, such as the statement that they “should be used for COVID-19 only when patients can be appropriately monitored in the hospital as required by the EUA or are enrolled in a clinical trial with appropriate screening and monitoring” tended to get lost in the hype for these drugs. This hype was epic and pervasive, too, coming from President Trump and his supporters at Fox News (such as Laura Ingraham and Sean Hannity), Didier Raoult and the cult of personality that’s sprung up around him since he published his first study, America’s quack Dr. Mehmet Oz, and a wide variety of fame-seeking “brave maverick doctors” touting uncontrolled, incompetently done, and unethical “case series” of COVID-19 patients whom they’ve treated with hydroxychloroquine and various other drugs.
Meanwhile, the drumbeat of negative studies has continued since last I wrote about this
The negative evidence continues to accumulate
The FDA warning capped off weeks during which a drip-drip-drip-drip of negative studies had been appearing on preprint servers and, to a lesser degree, in the peer-reviewed medical literature. For example, last Friday JAMA Network Open Access published a randomized controlled trial from Brazil that had previously been available on a preprint server. It appears to be the same study I discussed two weeks ago. This was a parallel, double-blinded, randomized, phase IIb clinical trial that studied 81 COVID-19 patients. There were two groups, patients receiving high dose (600 mg twice a day over ten days) versus low dose (450 mg twice a day on the first day, once a day thereafter for the next four) chloroquine plus ceftriaxone, a cephalosporin antibiotic. There was no placebo control because Brazil had mandated chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19 patients. The study reports that the high dose patients showed more severe QT prolongation and that there was a trend towards higher mortality compared to the low dose. Specifically, by day 13, 6 of the 40 patients in the low-dose group had died, while 16 of the 41 patients in the high-dose group had died. When adjusted for age, the result was not statistically significant, but nonetheless concerned the doctors enough during an interim analysis that the study was halted. One weakness of this study is that it was not able to independently assess the toxicity of chloroquine because all patients also received azithromycin, according to the hospital protocol.
This study joined another study published on a preprint server earlier in the week. This was a retrospective cohort study of 368 hospitalized veterans at US Veterans Health Administration medical centers until April 11, 2020, some of whom were treated with hydroxychloroquine (hydroxychloroquine, n=97; hydroxychloroquine + azithromycin, n=113; no hydroxychloroquine, n=158). The findings:
Rates of death in the HC, HC+AZ, and no HC groups were 27.8%, 22.1%, 11.4%, respectively. Rates of ventilation in the HC, HC+AZ, and no HC groups were 13.3%, 6.9%, 14.1%, respectively. Compared to the no HC group, the risk of death from any cause was higher in the HC group (adjusted hazard ratio, 2.61; 95% CI, 1.10 to 6.17; P=0.03) but not in the HC+AZ group (adjusted hazard ratio, 1.14; 95% CI, 0.56 to 2.32; P=0.72). The risk of ventilation was similar in the HC group (adjusted hazard ratio, 1.43; 95% CI, 0.53 to 3.79; P=0.48) and in the HC+AZ group (adjusted hazard ratio, 0.43; 95% CI, 0.16 to 1.12; P=0.09), compared to the no HC group.
The authors concluded:
Specifically, hydroxychloroquine use with or without co-administration of azithromycin did not improve mortality or reduce the need for mechanical ventilation in hospitalized patients. On the contrary, hydroxychloroquine use alone was associated with an increased risk of mortality compared to standard care alone.
Baseline demographic and comorbidity characteristics were comparable across the three treatment groups. However, hydroxychloroquine, with or without azithromycin, was more likely to be prescribed to patients with more severe disease, as assessed by baseline ventilatory status and metabolic and hematologic parameters. Thus, as expected, increased mortality was observed in patients treated with hydroxychloroquine, both with and without azithromycin. Nevertheless, the increased risk of overall mortality in the hydroxychloroquine-only group persisted after adjusting for the propensity of being treated with the drug. That there was no increased risk of ventilation in the hydroxychloroquine-only group suggests that mortality in this group might be attributable to drug effects on or dysfunction in non-respiratory vital organ systems.
The obvious weakness of this study is that it was retrospective. One can always question whether the authors adequately controlled for confounders and whether there was some form of undetected selection bias going on. On the plus side, I note that in this study the authors did attempt to control for a wide variety of potential confounders, including comorbidities, medications, and clinical and laboratory abnormalities. One can also ask how applicable these results are to the general population, given that the cohorts studied consisted only of men whose median age was 65 years and the majority of whom were African-American. Even so, this study at the very least failed to discover even a hint of activity of hydroxychloroquine against COVID-19. If hydroxychloroquine were the “game changer” described by President Trump and Didier Raoult, one would expect to find some indication of that in a study like this.
A few days after my last post on the subject of hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19, another negative study, this time from investigators in France, was posted on a preprint server. This was a study of 181 patients with pneumonia due to SARS-CoV-2 requiring supplemental oxygen support treated in four French hospitals. The authors collected data from the routine care of all adults in these hospitals with documented COVID-19 requiring oxygen to emulate a target trial aimed at assessing the effectiveness of hydroxychloroquine administered at a dose of 600 mg/day. The composite primary endpoint was transfer to an intensive care unit within seven days after inclusion and/or death from any cause. Analyses were adjusted for confounding factors by inverse probability of treatment weighting. Exclusion criteria included:
    • the presence of a contraindication to hydroxychloroquine at 600 mg daily (including patients under dialysis)
    • the start of hydroxychloroquine before admission to the hospital
    • treatment with another experimental drug for COVID-19 (tocilizumab, lopinavir-ritonavir, or remdesivir) within 48 hours after admission
    • organ failure requiring immediate admission to the ICU or continuous care unit (CCU)
    • ARDS at admission (defined by the need for non-invasive ventilation with provision of positive airway pressure or invasive mechanical ventilation)
    • discharge from the ICU to standard care
    • decision to limit and stop active therapeutics made at admission
    • opposition to data collection by the patient or her/his legal representative.
The results:
This study included 181 patients with SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia; 84 received HCQ within 48 hours of admission (HCQ group) and 97 did not (no-HCQ group). Initial severity was well balanced between the groups. In the weighted analysis, 20.2% patients in the HCQ group were transferred to the ICU or died within 7 days vs 22.1% in the no-HCQ group (16 vs 21 events, relative risk [RR] 0.91, 95% CI 0.47–1.80). In the HCQ group, 2.8% of the patients died within 7 days vs 4.6% in the no-HCQ group (3 vs 4 events, RR 0.61, 95% CI 0.13–2.89), and 27.4% and 24.1%, respectively, developed acute respiratory distress syndrome within 7 days (24 vs 23 events, RR 1.14, 95% CI 0.65–2.00). Eight patients receiving HCQ (9.5%) experienced electrocardiogram modifications requiring HCQ discontinuation.
This study, too, has significant limitations, given that it was not randomized but rather an attempt to emulate a randomized trial by collecting prospective data. Also, it used a short-term outcome as the primary outcome studied. Even so, this negative trial at the very least suggests that, if hydroxychloroquine has any activity at all against COVID-19, it is certainly not dramatic.
Also published on Friday was a case series of 85 patients with COVID-19 in Nature Medicine reporting that the combination of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin was associated with QT interval prolongation from a baseline average of 435 ± 24 ms (mean ± s.d.) to a maximal average value of 463 ± 32 ms after three days. In a subset of nine patients who developed severe QT prolongation (greater than 500 ms, a known marker of high risk of malignant arrhythmia and sudden cardiac death), five had a normal QT interval on screening electrocardiogram, suggesting that a normal baseline ECG alone does not mean a patient’s risk from these drugs is low.
Finally, an actual attempt at a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies of hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 by Iranian investigators was published on a preprint server a week ago. I approached it with caution, given that I found it hard to wrap my brain around doing a meta-analysis of studies of such disparate designs, the majority of which have not yet even passed peer review yet and exist only on preprint servers, but I was game to take a look.
The findings:
Seven studies including four clinical trials and three observational studies have entered into the study. The results of meta-analysis of clinical trials showed that there were no significant differences between patients who received the standard treatment with HCQ regimen and the patients that received the standard treatment without HCQ (RR: 1.44, 95% CI, 0.80-2.59). CT-Scan findings improved in 59% (95% CI 0.15-0.92) and nasopharyngeal culture following RT-PCR resulted negative in 76% (95% CI 0.56-0.89) of patients received hydroxychloroquine. Meta-analysis of observational studies showed 75% (95% CI, 0.54-0.88) of patients were discharged from the hospital, 34% (95% CI, 0.07-0.14) admitted to intensive care unit and 1.5% (95% CI, 0.03-0.83) have expired.
And the conclusion:
This study indicated no clinical effectiveness regarding role of HCQ for treatment of COVID-19 patients. However, further large clinical trials should be taken into account in order to achieve more reliable findings.
I concur. While existing studies don’t conclusively demonstrate that hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work or causes more harm than good, to me they are sufficient to demonstrate that, if hydroxychloroquine does have clinically relevant activity against COVID-19 it is definitely not powerful or a “game changer.” If hydroxychloroquine were a “miracle drug” for COVID-19, existing studies would have shown evidence of that. They don’t. Quite the contrary, actually, the data we are seeing now are most consistent with the conclusion that hydroxychloroquine is most likely ineffective at best against coronavirus and, at worst, harmful to COVID-19 patients.
Didier Raoult counterattacks
Unsurprisingly, the drip-drip-drip-drip of evidence suggesting that at the very least hydroxychloroquine is no wonder drug for COVID-19 and in fact might not work at all has resulted in a backlash. For example, Didier Raoult attacked Elisabeth Bik on Twitter after she tweeted about the results of the VA study:
Wow. Preprint on patient group of 368 hospitalized veterans with COVID-19. Hydroxychloroquine treatment: *higher* death rates than treatment without HC.
"Rates of death in the HC, HC+AZ, and no HC groups were 27.8%, 22.1%, 11.4%, respectively."https://t.co/vkCzPph3vp pic.twitter.com/EkANISjvjx
— Elisabeth Bik (@MicrobiomDigest) April 21, 2020
Raoult, in an obvious attempt to intimidate her by siccing his sycophants and fanboys on her, subtweeted her with this comment:
The witchhunter @MicrobiomDigest is not attentive to details when she judges that a study is useful to her paranoiac fights! Control group was treated with azithromycin.Nearly dying patients with lymphopenia were treated with hydroxychloroquine.Fraudulent study. Fake news. https://t.co/zI8MgsfHlx
— Didier Raoult (@raoult_didier) April 22, 2020
Yes, it’s true. Some of the no hydroxychloroquine group did receive azithromycin, which was not hidden. One also can’t help but marvel at the irony of a man who claimed that randomized controlled studies shouldn’t be done in infectious disease, that he was so convinced that his treatment works that he considers doing a randomized trial “unethical,” and as a result hasn’t even attempted to use a control group since his first awful paper criticizing the control group design of any study. Heck, given how awful all of his studies on hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin to treat COVID-19 have been, Raoult criticizing any study leads to intense pain due to my eyes rolling so far that they see into my eye sockets and stretch my optic nerves too far. This is very much of a piece with how Raoult reacted to criticism from a French intensivist named Dr. Damien Barraud in an interview on French television. I’ll include the video for those of you who speak French and translate a couple of key passages:
Basically, Barraud lambasted Didier for “medical populism”:
I haven’t seen a better description of what happened. Take everyone hostage and want to pass as the savior with the miracle drug that will save the world, by ignoring all the methodological and ethical rules yes, this is medical populism.
Barraud has also said that he’s “monstrously angry” with Raoult and accused him of having generated “unnecessary psychological fatigue” among caregivers, noting:
“Very early on, from the start of the patient’s arrival and the communication from the IHU, some conventional doctors were asked to prescribe this. We had to (put a policy in place), hold meetings and waste time on some something that should not have happened because at this time there is for the time being no tangible proof of any effectiveness to have a beneficial effect in the patients in general “, he assured.
We in the US have been unaware of just what a crank Dr. Raoult is, so that when he appears on The Dr. Oz Show or on Fox News he appears authoritative, but his colleagues in France have been trying to educate us.
Let’s just say that Raoult did not react well to Dr. Barraud’s criticism, posting this notice to his institute’s Twitter feed:
Communiqué. pic.twitter.com/Um5JlXySFX
— IHU Méditerranée Infection (@IHU_Marseille) April 14, 2020
Here’s the original French text:
Dr. Damien Barraud médecin réanimateur au CHR de Metz-Thionville, profite en ce moment d’un quart d’heure de gloire worholien en enchainant les interviews sur RMC, BFM TV et La Marseillaise.
Les propos qu’il tien dans ces interviews sont étrangement similaires à ceux tenus par le compte Twitter anonyme @fluidloading qui revendique être un médecin de la même région que le Dr. Damien Barraud.
Si ce compte Twitter est bien celui du Dr. Damien Barraud, nous somes heureux que dans les interviews données en son nom, ce médecin n’ait pas repris les injures publiques et les attaques diffamatoires que le propriétaire du compte @fluidloading se permet quotidiennement.
Nous espérons que, si le Dr. Damien Barraud n’est pas l’auteur des attaques portées par le compte @fluidloading, il s’en désolidarisera rapidement. Elles pourraient en effet justifier une plainte pénale et le lancement d’une procédure auprès de l’order des médecins. Poursuites que nous ne souhaitons pas lancer, car nous sommes aujourd’hui concentrés sur le soin des malades hospitalisés et suivis à l’IHU. Au-delà des polémiques nous espérons que le Dr. Damien Barraud trouvera le temps de se reconcentrer sur sa belle mission de médecin.
And here’s the translation (from a combination of Google Translate and me, although, surprisingly, I understood all but a few words of this):
Dr. Damien Barraud, critical care specialist at CHR Metz-Thionville, is currently enjoying a quarter of an hour of Warholian glory by doing serial interviews on RMC, BFM TV and La Marseillaise.
The comments he made in these interviews are strangely similar to those made by the anonymous Twitter account @fluidloading who claims to be a doctor from the same region as Dr. Damien Barraud.
If this Twitter account is indeed that of Dr. Damien Barraud, we are happy that in the interviews given in his name, this medicine did not take up public insults and defamatory attacks that the owner of the account @fluidloading allows himself daily.
We hope that, if Dr. Damien Barraud is not the author of the attacks carried by the @fluidloading account, he will quickly dissociate himself from it. They could in fact justify a criminal complaint and the initiation of a procedure with l’Ordre des Médicins. Pursuits that we do not wish to launch, because we are today concentrating on the care of hospitalized patients and followed at the IHU. Beyond the controversies we hope that Dr. Damien Barraud will find time to refocus on his beautiful medical mission.
Lovely. Dr. Raoult just doxxed Dr. Barraud in a passive-aggressive manner. “If Dr. Damien Barraud is not the author of the attacks” by @fluidloading, we hope that he will “quickly dissociate himself from it.” Particularly amusing is his “we’re too busy taking care of patients” shtick, a diversion beloved of “brave maverick doctors” the world over to excuse their lack of evidence for their treatments. He’s also destroyed another one of my irony meters, given that le Dr. Raoult seems to have plenty of time to do media interviews and appear on The Dr, Oz Show hawking his risibly bad science.
Raoult clearly meant to sic his Twitter followers on Dr. Barraud in retribution. Unfortunately, his threat to complain to l’Ordre des Médicins is not an idle one. As discussed in February, in a time that seems fanciful in its normality from the lens of mid-April and the COVID-19 pandemic, l’Ordre des Médecins values “collegiality” and civility above all. It took the side of homeopaths against French physicians who signed a statement lambasting homeopathy as quackery and urging the French government to stop funding it, even going so far as to temporarily suspend the license of one of doctors who signed the statement. So it’s not at all clear that Dr. Barraud would be in the clear if the bully Dr. Raoult decided to follow through with his threats.
That’s not all, though. Raoult is truly melting down. He promoted a truly awful Brazilian telehealth study (the PREVENT Senior Trial) purporting to show benefit in COVID-19 patients showing early symptoms:
Un manuscrit dont la publication devrait faire parler : expérimentation de la bithérapie HCQ+AZ au Brésil. Des résultats qui vont dans le sens d'une prescription dès les premiers symptômes. https://t.co/j6XIANLKHz pic.twitter.com/K0hFEHserc
— Didier Raoult (@raoult_didier) April 18, 2020
It turns out that, besides being a bad study, it was suspended because of ethical violations. It turns out that the trial had started before proper ethical approvals were obtained.
Meanwhile, the best that he can do, evidence-wise, is to post a review article to the IHU website about the pharmacology and safety of his hydroxychloroquine/azithromycin combination. He doesn’t even bother to post his papers even to preprint websites, which, although they don’t peer review papers posted to them, do subject them to a brief quality checklist before posting. Moreover, it turns out that—surprise! surprise!—Raoult is now in trouble with regulatory authorities in France for not having obtained proper consent:
Translation:
Between the pre-print and the published article, the IHU completely revised the part on the ethics committee in the first observational.
With confirmation this time that no consent was requested.
Color me not surprised that Raoult apparently plays fast and loose with clinical trial ethics and regulatory compliance:
The National Agency for the Safety of Medicines and Health Products (ANSM), which did not authorize the second study on hydroxychloroquine (Plaquenil *, Sanofi) conducted at the institute hospital-university (IHU) in Marseille by Pr Didier Raoult, awaits that the investigators bring objective elements to demonstrate its observational nature, indicated Dominique Martin in an interview with APMnews.
And:
The question is whether this study is observational or interventional, he said.
Observational studies are only subject to the opinion of a committee for the protection of individuals (CPP) while intervention research must have the green light from ANSM and a CPP.
Basically, Raoult appears to be dancing around the definitions of observational studies from the standpoint of regulatory compliance in France.
Meanwhile, back in the US, an NIH Expert Panel, convened by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (directed by US epidemics expert Anthony Fauci), amended its recommendations for treating COVID-19 on April 21 to recommend against using Raoult’s hydroxychloroquine/azithromycin combination, citing potential cardiac toxicities due to the combination. The panel also concluded that, as of that date, there was as yet insufficient evidence to recommend any kind of treatment either to prevent infection with the coronavirus or to prevent the progression of symptoms in those who are already infectious.
The malignant effect of bypassing science-based medicine
Doctors as a group tend not to deal with feelings of helplessness very well, in my experience. When a patient is dying despite our best efforts, our natural reaction is to do something—anything!—even when we do not have a specific treatment that we know to be effective. Even though supportive care is medical care, it often doesn’t feel that way, particularly when a patient is not only not getting better but is getting worse. We want to feel as though we’ve helped our patients, and just keeping them alive as long as we can in the hopes that their bodies can fight off coronavirus just isn’t as satisfying as giving them a drug that helps to eliminate the virus and save their lives. It’s thus understandable that some doctors jumped on the hydroxychloroquine bandwagon. It’s understandable even that some are still holding out hope that it will be shown to be effective.
For example, after the VA study was published:
The recent "negative" data is no more meaningful that the earlier"positive" data. We actually still have no data regarding efficacy.
— Less-Is-More Cardiologist (@DavidLBrownMD) April 23, 2020
And:
Anybody can conclude anything from confounded observational studies. There is no data that reliably tells us anything and there won't be until the results from RCTs are available.
— Less-Is-More Cardiologist (@DavidLBrownMD) April 23, 2020
This is what I like to refer to as “methodolatry,” defined as the obscene worship of the double-blind placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial as the only valid means of clinical investigation. It’s endemic in the strongest proponents of evidence-based (as opposed to science-based) medicine. It’s usually most evident when EBM proponents insist that only such trials can demonstrate whether highly improbable therapies (like homeopathy or reiki) work or not is through such trials, even when basic science alone can demonstrate that they are so improbable as to be, for all intents and purposes, indistinguishable from impossible. However, methodolatry also comes into play when EBM proponents dismiss existing observational studies about hydroxychloroquine as telling us “nothing” about whether the drug works or not against COVID-19 when in fact existing evidence is enough to tell us, at the very minimum, that if the drug does have activity, its effects are not dramatic. If they were, the existing observational studies and randomized clinical trials would have picked up at least a hint of it. They didn’t, which means that if hydroxychloroquine has any effect at all against COVID-19 it is modest enough to require large randomized clinical trials to detect. From that, I conclude that the drug should not be administered to COVID-19 patients outside of the auspices of such clinical trials.
Methodolatry among physicians aside, though, the premature promotion of hydroxychloroquine has had a number of deleterious effects on our nation. I’ve already discussed how Trump’s boosterism resulted in panic prescribing and hoarding, leading to shortages of the drug for patients with autoimmune diseases who need it. I’ve also speculated how the EUA and promotion of the drug will make it harder for scientists to complete the randomized clinical trials that our above cardiologist and I are waiting for. After all, if you are led to believe a drug works, why would you consent to be on a clinical trial where you might be randomized to receive a placebo? You wouldn’t, of course, and that’s what happened in France, with four out of five patients offered enrollment in Discovery, a randomized trial to study the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine and other treatments, refusing to be enrolled and refusing any treatment other than hydroxychloroquine.
It’s worse than that, though. Not only has the hydroxychloroquine craze made it harder to do the clinical trials necessary to determine if the drug benefits COVID-19 patients, but it’s derailing research into other drugs:
People with COVID-19 who arrive at the Salvador Zubirán National Institute of Medical Sciences and Nutrition in Mexico City to search for treatment can choose from a menu of clinical trials, carefully presented by a worker trained to offer an unbiased portrait of the potential risks and benefits.
But neurologist Sergio Iván Valdés-Ferrer already knows which trial most will choose — and it’s not his. Instead, many people opt for one involving hydroxychloroquine, a malaria drug that has been touted by US President Donald Trump and other influential figures as an effective coronavirus treatment. High demand for the drug in Mexico has quickly depleted the country’s supply. Its use is now limited to hospitals, and patients are eager to ensure that they receive it.
“There’s a tremendous bias,” says Valdés-Ferrer, who is studying the effects of a dementia drug on COVID-19. “Studies of any other drug that are enrolling all ages and degrees of severity are in big trouble.”
And:
Psychiatrist Eric Lenze of Washington University in St. Louis, Missouri, recently launched a trial of an antidepressant that he hopes could lessen the immune response linked to some severe COVID-19 cases. The trial has so far enrolled ten participants; three others declined to take part because they were already planning to take hydroxychloroquine. And Sauer says that she and her colleagues have encountered similar resistance while enrolling participants into a trial of the antiviral drug remdesivir.
So many people are taking hydroxychloroquine or insisting on being prescribed it that some doctors are compromising rigorous study design and allowing patients to take hydroxychloroquine anyway. Either way, the hype is making the interpretation of clinical trials for other drugs difficult:
Data from clinical trials can also be skewed by excluding participants who refuse to give up chloroquine treatment. Chloroquine can cause heart arrhythmias, for example, and so may not be given to some people who have pre-existing heart problems. That means that a trial that excludes chloroquine-takers could end up enrolling a disproportionately large number of participants with heart conditions, says Malhotra.
But allowing participants to take chloroquine could muddle efforts to interpret data. Chloroquine’s effects, especially its effect on the immune system, could take days to fade, says Malhotra. This could make it difficult for trial investigators to distinguish the effect of the treatment they are testing from the effect of the chloroquine.
Exactly, and there are now over 100 clinical trials of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine. Many are duplicative and the sheer number of clinical trials is not justified by the existing data concerning these drugs. One of the scientists in the article notes that the question of whether hydroxychloroquine is effective against COVID-19 could have been answered already if there had been a concerted effort to develop a handful of rigorous clinical trials, instead of the current situation. In the meantime, how many people have been harmed by what might well be an ineffective drug?
As the situation stands, CQ and HCQ, unproven drugs without clear evidence of benefit for COVID-19 but with evidence suggesting harm, became de facto standard of care before rigorous science supporting their use had been completed and remained so for nearly three months. Only now are doctors and government health authorities rethinking the situation and abandoning the drugs outside the auspices of clinical trials, thus coming into line with what I and others have been saying all along, that there was insufficient evidence that these drugs are effective against COVID-19 to justify using them indiscriminately. It turns out that, even during a pandemic, no good comes from abandoning science- and evidence-based medicine.

Hydroxychloroquine, retinal toxicity, and COVID-19
Hydroxychloroquine is being promoted as a treatment or prevention for COVID-19 based on questionable evidence. The long-term impact of hydroxychloroquine on the retina introduces another reason to be cautious about its use outside of clinical trials.
David Weinberg on May 1, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: The COVID-19 crisis brings us a double-dose of Dr. Weinberg this week, with a timely post about hydroxychloroquine.]
In recent weeks an obscure drug has become the subject of much attention and debate in the public arena. The drug is called hydroxychloroquine. Hydroxychloroquine and a closely relative drug, chloroquine, are members of a class of chemicals known as quinolines. These drugs were long-ago recognized as anti-malarials. Chloroquine, in particular, was used extensively during WWI for the treatment and prophylaxis of malaria.


Later, these drugs were recognized to be effective against certain autoimmune diseases, particularly rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus. Patients with these chronic diseases are often on these medications for many years, much longer than typically required for malaria. With prolonged exposure a new adverse effect was recognized: a potentially blinding retinal toxicity. The first cases of retinal damage attributed to chloroquine was reported in 1957. Due to a superior safety profile, hydroxychloroquine has largely replaced chloroquine for treatment of autoimmune disease, but can produce retinal injury identical to chloroquine.
Retinal injury from hydroxychloroquine
Early detection is desirable because continued treatment can result in significant disability. The damage is often progressive long after the medication is stopped, probably because chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine have a strong affinity for pigmented tissues and remain sequestered for years after the medication is discontinued. The classic pattern of retinal toxicity is often referred to as bull’s-eye retinopathy (or bull’s-eye maculopathy) because the retina displays a concentric zone of decreased pigment surrounding the center of the retina (the macula, see image below). With conscientious monitoring, toxicity from hydroxychloroquine is usually recognizable before the patient becomes symptomatic.

An expert panel from the American Academy of Ophthalmology has issued recommendations for the hydroxychloroquine treatment and monitoring. The upper limit of the recommended dose was recently decreased to 5 mg/kg/day. If dosing guidelines are followed, the risk of toxicity is estimated to be <1% in the first 5 years, <2% up to 10 years. After 10 years the risk rises more steeply, up to 20% after 20 years. Higher doses confer a higher risk of toxicity. Baseline eye examination is recommended within 1 year of initiating therapy and annual screening exams beginning after 5 years of treatment. There are a couple of case reports of what appears to be hydroxychloroquine toxicity after only a couple of months of exposure, but these are very rare events.
Hydroxychloroquine and COVID-19
Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, “hydroxychloroquine” has become a household word. Based on some intriguing laboratory data and very preliminary clinical reports, hydroxychloroquine has emerged as a potential treatment for the novel coronavirus, prompting some high level government officials and other high profile personalities to advocate for widespread use. David Gorski has written several detailed analyses of the state of evidence (or lack thereof) for the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19, and I have nothing to add to his excellent review of the evidence. I agree that based on very thin data there is irrational exuberance among some prominent opinion-makers.
At this moment, there is no shortage of clinical trials looking at hydroxychloroquine in the context of COVID-19. A search on clinicaltrials.gov had 117 hits (as of 4/21/2020). The studies are from all around the world and have variable designs. Investigators are exploring intervention with hydroxychloroquine at various stages of infection, and some are looking at prophylaxis for known exposures and high-risk individuals. Many doses and schedules of treatment are being explored. I did not do a detailed review of all 117 studies, but I reviewed a sample. Most of the studies are looking at doses in excess of the American Academy of Ophthalmology recommended upper limit of 5 mg/kg/day sometimes by several multiples. Duration of treatment ranges from a few days to a few weeks.
Even at these high doses I suspect the risk of retinal toxicity with short-term exposure is low. There are, however, caveats to this conclusion. Patients with COVID may be critically ill and are likely to be on multiple medications. The potential retinal toxicity of hydroxychloroquine in critically ill, metabolically compromised, multiply-medicated patients is unknown. Considering the devastation seen due to COVID-19, the risk seems justified in the context of clinical trials. We can be hopeful that data from clinical trials will be responsibly collected, collated, and reported. I look forward to these data to inform us about the safety and efficacy of hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19.
Outside clinical trials, hydroxychloroquine is also being used, largely based on encouragement of a few high profile opinion-makers. I fear that some people, desperate to protect themselves, may take the medication at doses and durations sufficient to put them at risk for retinal damage (or even worse, die after drinking the wrong substance based on a misunderstanding). Meanwhile, patients with disabling diseases like rheumatoid arthritis and lupus are sometimes having difficulty filling their prescriptions.
Conclusion: Low short-term risk, but completely uncertain efficacy
The world desperately needs effective treatments for COVID-19. We can only hope that effective strategies will be discovered. This can only happen by using a science-based, systematic approach. Unless good data supporting the safety and efficacy of hydroxychloroquine emerge, there are many reasons to be cautious adopting it for widespread use. Fortunately, current knowledge suggests that the risk retinal toxicity from short-term exposure to hydroxychloroquine is low.

Hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19: Evidence can’t seem to kill it
Despite the accumulating negative evidence showing that hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work against COVID-19, activists continue to promote it as a way out of the pandemic. This week, the AAPS and a Yale epidemiologist joined the fray with embarrassingly bad arguments.
David Gorski on July 27, 2020
Link

I find it odd at this juncture in late July that I’ve been writing about a certain drug that was touted as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19 as far back as March. I am referring, of course, to hydroxychloroquine, an anti-malarial drug that also has immunomodulatory effects that make it also useful to treat various autoimmune diseases, such as systemic lupus erythematosus. It’s a drug that, despite the lack of evidence for its efficacy and the continued publication of negative studies testing its efficacy against the disease, just won’t die. Truly, hydroxychloroquine is the Jason Voorhees of drugs, at least with respect to COVID-19. After each new study showing it to be ineffective, it always seems to rise, just as Jason always comes back for another round of killing after seemingly having died at the end of the previous movie.
The hypothesis that antimalarial drugs might be effective treatments for COVID-19 originated in Wuhan, China during the early phase of the pandemic in January. There, Chinese researchers reported that none of their 80 patients with lupus erythematosus who were taking hydroxychloroquine went on to become infected with SARS-CoV-2. As a result of that and old evidence of antiviral activity for the drugs, they became interested in using these antimalarial drugs to treat COVID-19. (Never mind that immunosuppressed patients are exactly the patients most likely to assiduously follow the recommendations of public health authorities during a pandemic.) A number of clinical trials were registered, and, based on anecdotal reports and small clinical trials (nearly all of which are as yet unpublished), in February the Chinese government published an expert consensus recommending CQ or HCQ for patients with COVID-19. Soon after, a number of nations followed suit. From there, a French “brave maverick scientist” named Didier Raoult latched onto the drug as the “answer” to the COVID-19 pandemic, publishing risibly bad studies claiming to show its efficacy. Tech bros such as Elon Musk discovered the claims about hydroxychloroquine and Raoult’s bad science, leading to Donald Trump Tweeting favorably about his study and, ultimately, to the FDA issuing an emergency use authorization for the drug to treat COVID-19.
Since then, there has been a drip-drip-drip of negative studies of hydroxychloroquine, some studies observational, but, increasingly, many being randomized clinical trials, such as the publication of a randomized controlled clinical trial of the drug as post-exposure prophylaxis that was entirely negative. This was followed by two more, first, a Spanish post-exposure prophylaxis trial that was also negative. Then there was the Recovery Trial from the UK, which failed to find a benefit from hydroxychloroquine in hospitalized patients treated with the drug, leading to the revocation of the FDA’s original ill-advised EUA.
Despite the weight of the negative evidence that’s been accumulating, for some reason, last week the advocates of hydroxychloroquine as a treatment for COVID-19 have been doubling down. You might think that they’d slink off and pretend that the negative evidence hasn’t been accumulating. To quote John Belushi, “But nooooo!” No, they have to double down. I’m going to look at two examples. The first one is particularly disappointing, as it involves an apparently respected epidemiologist. The second is less so, given that it involves the crank medical “society” known as the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), a group featured on this very blog more than once before.
Harvey Risch: Defending hydroxychloroquine with bad science
I’m generally a big fan of epidemiology and epidemiologists. After all, epidemiology is how we know that tobacco smoking causes cancer and that vaccines do not cause autism, sudden infant death syndrome, autoimmune diseases, diabetes, or the other conditions and diseases attributed to vaccines by antivaxxers. Epidemiology is also how we will ultimately figure out who is at most risk for serious disease, complications, and death from COVID-19 and then use that information to fine-tune the public health response to the pandemic and to develop additional interventions. So I scratched my head mightily yesterday when I saw an op-ed in Newsweek by Harvey Risch, MD, PhD, a professor of epidemiology at the Yale School of Public Health entitled “The Key to Defeating COVID-19 Already Exists. We Need to Start Using It“. What is this “key” that Risch is talking about? Hydroxychloroquine. No, seriously, I kid you not. He’s talking about what I’ve started calling the “acupuncture of the COVID-19 pandemic”:
As professor of epidemiology at Yale School of Public Health, I have authored over 300 peer-reviewed publications and currently hold senior positions on the editorial boards of several leading journals. I am usually accustomed to advocating for positions within the mainstream of medicine, so have been flummoxed to find that, in the midst of a crisis, I am fighting for a treatment that the data fully support but which, for reasons having nothing to do with a correct understanding of the science, has been pushed to the sidelines. As a result, tens of thousands of patients with COVID-19 are dying unnecessarily. Fortunately, the situation can be reversed easily and quickly.
I am referring, of course, to the medication hydroxychloroquine. When this inexpensive oral medication is given very early in the course of illness, before the virus has had time to multiply beyond control, it has shown to be highly effective, especially when given in combination with the antibiotics azithromycin or doxycycline and the nutritional supplement zinc.
This far into the pandemic, with double-blind, randomized, controlled clinical trials starting to be published and showing, each and every one of them so far, that hydroxychloroquine shows no benefit versus COVID-19 (I’ll discuss them shortly), let’s just say that I am flummoxed to find, in the midst of a crisis, that a seemingly respected epidemiologist is fighting for a drug that almost certainly doesn’t work based on low quality and anecdotal evidence when far higher quality evidence is becoming available and even the bulk of the observational evidence has been negative, with one notable outlier. I am even more flummoxed to find that Newsweek provided this epidemiologist a platform to promote this argument, particularly given how he based it primarily on a commentary and review that he wrote in May, which is basically ancient history as far as the evidence base for hydroxychloroquine goes.
Next up, Risch uses an appeal to authority—his, and that of an epidemiology journal:
On May 27, I published an article in the American Journal of Epidemiology (AJE) entitled, “Early Outpatient Treatment of Symptomatic, High-Risk COVID-19 Patients that Should be Ramped-Up Immediately as Key to the Pandemic Crisis.” That article, published in the world’s leading epidemiology journal, analyzed five studies, demonstrating clear-cut and significant benefits to treated patients, plus other very large studies that showed the medication safety.
This sort of appeal to the respectability of a scientific journal just makes me laugh these days. Journals far more prestigious than AJE have published utter rubbish before, for example The Lancet‘s publication of Andrew Wakefield‘s case series and that awful Surgisphere study on hydroxychloroquine in May. I could go on and name many other bad or even fraudulent papers in many other journals, but instead I’ll just refer to Retraction Watch for a sampling. The point is simple. Being published in a respected journal is not a guarantee of quality or that the study is even right. Indeed, I often point out that the highest profile journals, the ones that publish the most bleeding edge research, probably have a higher rate of studies that turn out to be wrong, because that’s what happens on the bleeding edge of science. Surely the eminent Prof. Risch knows this, but he makes the appeal anyway.
Since Prof. Risch referenced his own opinion article in AJE, I figured that I had to go and take a look at it. At this point, Newsweek annoyed the crap out of me because there was no direct link to the article, forcing me to go to the extra step of Googling its title and finding the article. Come on, Newsweek! It’s 2020! There’s no excuse for not including a direct link to the source and hasn’t been for at least a decade! Here, by the way, is the direct link. At this point, I would also like to point out that Prof. Risch is on the editorial board of AJE, a fact conveniently not mentioned in his Newsweek op-ed that is highly relevant, given that editorial board members can exercise a lot of influence on what gets published in a journal.
Reading the article, I was struck at how weak the arguments were. Prof. Risch basically tries to compare hydroxychloroquine to remdesivir, which I discussed nearly three months ago, when the results of the first randomized clinical trial (RCT) was announced, in essence, by press release. And, guess what? I’m not that impressed with the evidence for remdesivir’s efficacy against COVID-19, either!
Funny, though, until recently, hydroxychloroquine cultists were claiming that the drug would be effective against COVID-19 in seriously-ill hospitalized patients and then, as evidence accumulated that it isn’t, pivoted to the argument that it has to be given as early as possible in order to work. Clearly, there is a double standard at work here that Prof. Risch is not acknowledging. (We wouldn’t want to suggest that goalposts are being moved, would we?) Moreover, his argument is bullshit, plain and simple. If a drug strongly inhibits coronavirus replication, there’s no reason that it couldn’t be effective both in advanced disease and in early disease—or even as a prophylactic treatment to prevent infection. It’s true that it might not work as well (or at all) in all those situations, and it’s even true that one treatment is unlikely to work as well (or at all) in all those clinical situations, but there’s no a priori scientific reason to make the blanket declaration that one treatment can’t possibly be useful in both situations.
Think of it this way. The life-threatening inpatient acute respiratory distress syndrome caused by SARS-CoV-2 is on a continuum of disease, not a completely different disease, from symptomatic outpatient infection. In any event, I also agree that, because remdesivir hasn’t been studied in outpatient use, its use in outpatients is currently not that well supported, but, then, it is an intravenous medication only at present, making this argument rather a straw man and a red herring.
The rest of Prof. Risch’s AJE article is a veritable Gish gallop of cherry-picked studies. Hilariously, he relies heavily on uncontrolled “studies” and case series from two grifters, Didier Raoult and Vladimir Zelenko. I’ve written about Didier Raoult, a “brave maverick” true believer in his combination of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin and a bully, on several occasions, starting with his truly execrable study claiming that his combination of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin cleared coronavirus in all patients. None of these studies were controlled or randomized. Unbelievably, Prof. Risch cites Raoult’s case series of 1,061 COVID-19 patients as though it were anything but singularly uninformative and useless for evaluating whether his drug combination is effective against COVID-19. The results published as a preprint aren’t any more useful or convincing, either.
That’s not the most embarrassing thing in Prof. Risch’s article, though. This is:
The first study of HCQ+AZ (24) was controlled but not randomized or blinded, and involved 42 patients in Marseilles, France. This study showed a 50-fold benefit of HCQ+AZ vs standard-of-care, with P-value=.0007. In the study, six patients progressed, stopped medication use and left the trial before the day-6 planned outcome measure of swab-sampled nasopharyngeal viral clearance. Reanalysis of the raw study data elsewhere (25) and by myself shows that including these six patients does not much change the 50-fold benefit. What does change the magnitude of benefit is presentation with asymptomatic or upper respiratory-tract infection, vs lower respiratory-tract infection, the latter cutting the efficacy in half, 25-fold vs standard-of-care. This shows that the sooner these medications are used, the better their effectiveness, as would be expected for viral early respiratory disease. The average start date of medication use in this study was day-4 of symptoms. This study has been criticized on various grounds that are not germane to the science, but the most salient criticism is the lack of randomization into the control and treatment groups. This is a valid general scientific criticism, but does not represent epidemiologic experience in this instance. If the study had shown a 2-fold or perhaps 3-fold benefit, that magnitude of result could be postulated to have occurred because of subject-group differences from lack of randomization. However, the 25-fold or 50-fold benefit found in this study is not amenable to lack of randomization as the sole reason for such a huge magnitude of benefit. Further, the study showed a significant, 7-fold benefit of taking HCQ+AZ over HCQ alone, P-value=.035, which cannot be explained by differential characteristics of the controls, since it compares one treatment group to the other, and the treated subjects who received AZ had more progressed pneumonia than the treated subjects receiving HCQ alone, which should otherwise have led to worse outcomes. The study has also been described as “small,” but that criticism only applies to studies not finding statistical significance. Once a result has exceeded plausible chance finding, greater statistical significance does not contribute to evidence for causation (26).
I had a hard time believing that an actual professor of epidemiology at a school as reputable as Yale could write such drivel. The study he is referring to is Gautret et al., a study so awful, so full of flaws (and maybe even fraudulent), that it was quite properly dragged on science and medical Twitter for days and weeks afterward. That Prof. Risch would cite such an abomination of science tells you all you need to know about him.
Next, Prof. Risch cites Vladimir Zelenko. No, seriously, an epidemiologist is citing an unethical case series that hadn’t even been published yet in May. The link he provides in the citation is a link to a Google Documents page that no longer exists and was last accessed in April. I suspect that this was probably the same spreadsheet of patients that Zelenko had posted in early April that looked like this. I’m now leaning towards Prof. Risch’s commentary having not been peer-reviewed, because if an AJE peer reviewer let an author cite a link to a Google Document and call it a “two-page report,” its peer review sucks, and its editor should be ashamed of himself for publishing this. Zelenko’s evidence is so crappy that anyone citing it seriously should be thoroughly mocked.
The fourth study cited by Prof. Risch is the Prevent Senior study carried out in Brazil. It, too, was an awful study, as outlined by Elisabeth Bik. There was no randomization and no good documentation if the patients actually had COVID-19 or not. The two groups compared were not equally sick, and the reasons for hospitalizations and deaths were not listed. Moreover, the study was performed by an insurance company in Brazil which was promoting its telemedicine app for COVID-19:
2/ The study is performed from an insurance company in Brazil which has promoted its telemedicine application for #COVID19 ! So they have an interest to show efficacy of telemedicine against COVID19. the fact they have declared no COI is a joke https://t.co/Hz2DTjgeim pic.twitter.com/z1Md7ZJShK
— Dr Gaetan Burgio @[email protected] (@GaetanBurgio) April 18, 2020
But back to the Newsweek op-ed:
Since publication of my May 27 article, seven more studies have demonstrated similar benefit. In a lengthy follow-up letter, also published by AJE, I discuss these seven studies and renew my call for the immediate early use of hydroxychloroquine in high-risk patients. These seven studies include: an additional 400 high-risk patients treated by Dr. Vladimir Zelenko, with zero deaths; four studies totaling almost 500 high-risk patients treated in nursing homes and clinics across the U.S., with no deaths; a controlled trial of more than 700 high-risk patients in Brazil, with significantly reduced risk of hospitalization and two deaths among 334 patients treated with hydroxychloroquine; and another study of 398 matched patients in France, also with significantly reduced hospitalization risk. Since my letter was published, even more doctors have reported to me their completely successful use.
This is painful to read. Seriously, this is an epidemiologist? Apparently so, but he’s an epidemiologist who confuses correlation with causation:
Beyond these studies of individual patients, we have seen what happens in large populations when these drugs are used. These have been “natural experiments.” In the northern Brazil state of Pará, COVID-19 deaths were increasing exponentially. On April 6, the public hospital network purchased 75,000 doses of azithromycin and 90,000 doses of hydroxychloroquine. Over the next few weeks, authorities began distributing these medications to infected individuals. Even though new cases continued to occur, on May 22 the death rate started to plummet and is now about one-eighth what it was at the peak.
A reverse natural experiment happened in Switzerland. On May 27, the Swiss national government banned outpatient use of hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19. Around June 10, COVID-19 deaths increased four-fold and remained elevated. On June 11, the Swiss government revoked the ban, and on June 23 the death rate reverted to what it had been beforehand. People who die from COVID-19 live about three to five weeks from the start of symptoms, which makes the evidence of a causal relation in these experiments strong. Both episodes suggest that a combination of hydroxychloroquine and its companion medications reduces mortality and should be immediately adopted as the new standard of care in high-risk patients.
An Epidemiology 101 student should be able to dismantle the argument above. This is the sort of argument antivaxxers make, such as that the expansion of the vaccine schedule in the early 1990s was followed by a rise in the prevalence of autism, or claims that nations with more vaccines in their recommended schedule have higher infant mortality rates. The question to ask is: What else happened around the times that the magic drug hydroxychloroquine was disbursed to Pará or taken away from Switzerland? But, no. Whatever changes in COVID-19 mortality we’re observed must be due to the magic drug. Also, which is it? I thought that the addition of azithromycin, zinc, or doxycycline to the hydroxychloroquine was important!
It amuses me that on the very same day that Prof. Risch published his Newsweek op-ed, the New England Journal of Medicine published a clinical trial of 667 patients with mild-to-moderate COVID-19 randomized to receive placebo or hydroxychloroquine (with and without azithromycin, yet!), with the primary outcome being clinical status at 15 days. Can you guess what the result was? (Sure, I knew you could.) It was completely negative. But, wait! I can see Prof. Risch countering with the observation that this was a trial of hospitalized patients. We have that covered too! One week ago yet another randomized controlled trial of hydroxychloroquine was published in Clinical Infectious Diseases. It was a Spanish trial of 293 non-hospitalized patients with mild COVID-19, exactly the sort of study that Prof. Risch wanted. Guess what? It was negative. No benefit was observed with HCQ beyond the usual care. It is true that both of these studies did have one significant weakness, namely that they were both open label, but open-label randomized trials are still way better in terms of determining the efficacy of a drug than any of the crappy observational studies cited by Prof. Risch to argue that everyone should be getting hydroxychloroquine now. One could even argue that the trials were underpowered to detect smaller effects, but Prof. Risch is not claiming small effects on mortality. He’s claiming that hydroxychloroquine is a game changer that could save hundreds of thousands of lives!
The AAPS enters the fray
Regular readers are probably familiar with an organization known as the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS) and its journal, the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons (JPANDS). Basically, AAPS is a far right-wing/libertarian advocacy organization disguised as a medical professional society. When I first discovered this group, I noted that it was pretty much a fusion of a John Birch Society-like right wing group with a medical society and that it trafficked in the most vile antivaccine misinformation (e.g., that shaken baby syndrome is a “misdiagnosis” for vaccine injury and Andrew Wakefield’s recent claim that the measles vaccine will result in a mass extinction of humans), anti-immigrant fear-mongering, climate science denial, blaming breast cancer on abortion using execrable “science,” and more, such as the claim that radiation from the Fukushima reactor breach is good for you. The AAPS views doctors as some sort of mythical brave mavericks outside the herd whose godlike total autonomy must never be infringed by the government or anything else and rejects even the concept of a scientific consensus about anything. (Donald Trump’s first Secretary of Health and Human Services, Tom Price, is a member of AAPS.) Earlier this year, it even sued to protect its “right” to promote antivaccine misinformation.
Unsurprisingly, AAPS is all on board with hydroxychloroquine as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19, to the point that it’s even filed a lawsuit against the FDA! (Here are the original and follow-up filings.) Now here’s the hilarious part:
AAPS files with the court a chart showing how countries that encourage HCQ use, such as South Korea, India, Turkey, Russia, and Israel, have been far more successful in combatting COVID-19 than countries that have banned or discouraged early HCQ use, as the FDA has. Last week the FDA even misled the public by falsely stating that HCQ should not be used to treat COVID-19, when multiple studies show its benefits, and thousands of patients have been successfully treated worldwide.
“The interference with public access to hydroxychloroquine is disrupting our political processes,” notes AAPS General Counsel Andrew Schlafly. “Perhaps that is what some want, in order to deter Americans from attending political conventions and even voting, but it is unconstitutional for the FDA to infringe on these constitutional rights by blocking access to this safe medication.”
Here’s the chart:
No, seriously, that’s the chart. I have so many questions and observations, too:
    • This is a relatively small group of countries. There is no evidence that they were randomly selected. On what basis were they selected for this chart? I sense cherry picking.
    • Given that hydroxychloroquine was (and still is) unproven, any mass adoption of the drug likely followed increases in fatalities and cases, and almost certainly was a step that was taken after other steps such as lockdowns, greatly increased testing, social distancing, etc. Isn’t it likely that the hydroxychloroquine adoption increased after these countries’ deaths/cases peaked and after they had taken other known steps that reduced measures of mortality rates (such as increased and broader testing)?
    • More importantly, there are probably dozens of other factors that correlate with “country starts administering hydroxychloroquine to COVID-19 patients in large numbers”. In other words, what are the confounders?
This whole “analysis” (if you can call it that) reminds me very much of the time when antivaxxers published a truly awful study that “correlated” the number of recommended vaccines in a country’s vaccine schedule with the country’s infant mortality rate.
One also can’t help but note that AAPS has also falsely claimed that masks and social distancing are not effective in slowing the spread of COVID-19. So, of course, it can’t possibly be different policies with respect to lockdowns, testing, and contact tracing that explain the differences in mortality rates between countries. Of course, AAPS has to find another “reason” to explain differences between nations. Naturally, AAPS being AAPS, it cherry picked a relatively small sample of countries to make a correlation and incorrectly infer causation.
The bottom line
Hydroxychloroquine is the acupuncture of the COVID-19 pandemic. What do I mean by that? Like acupuncture, hydroxychloroquine is an intervention with a very low prior plausibility (although, in fairness, the prior plausibility of acupuncture is much lower than even that of hydroxychloroquine) whose cultists behave just like acupuncture cultists when it comes to evidence. They believe their magic treatment works; so, like acupuncturists, they tend to downplay accumulating evidence from double-blind, placebo-controlled trials and point to much poorer quality observational studies, while making excuses like these, described for a similar situation, the use of vitamin C to treat cancer:
Because I’m dedicated to evidence and science when it comes to medical decision making, I always concede that it is still possible that hydroxychloroquine might still be found to have some anti-COVID-19 activity, although it’s becoming increasingly clear that, if there is any activity it will likely be very modest and require large clinical trials to detect, to the point where it’ll probably be clinically insignificant. That being said, it’s amazing how much believers in acupuncture, vitamin C to treat cancer, and hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 have in common. It’s also distressing how much like the villain in a slasher flick the drug is. No matter how many times it appears to have died, it always comes back.

Ivermetin

Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine
Ivermectin has been touted as a potential antiviral to treat COVID-19 infections. There is no good evidence it is effective.
Scott Gavura on April 15, 2021
Link

With the arrival of safe and effective vaccines to prevent COVID-19, bringing what looks like a pathway to a post-pandemic world, I wasn’t sure if it was still worth looking at unproven COVID-19 treatments. After all, it’s been over a year and we have much more knowledge about what actually works to prevent and treat SARS-CoV-2 infections. But amazingly there are still very passionate supporters of treatments that lack any strong evidence of benefit. Ivermectin falls into that category.
Ivermectin has been touted as a miracle treatment for almost as long as the global pandemic has been around, and that enthusiasm remains strong (in some) despite accumulating research that says otherwise. Importantly, there has been significant progress since a year ago in treating COVID-19, including the repurposing of other drugs that have actually been demonstrated to work (e.g., dexamethasone, tocilizumab). In that same amount of time, we’ve also seen drugs demonstrated to be ineffective, like hydroxychloroquine. It may be that the hydroxychloroquine crowd has finally moved on to something else. 
Weak evidence for use of ivermectin
Ivermectin (Stromectol) is an anti-parasitic drug. It is used to treat intestinal strongyloidiasis (threadworm, caused by infection from Strongyloides stercoralis) and also onchocerciasis (river blindness, caused by the parasitic worm Onchocerca volvulus, and spread by the Simulium blackfly). There has been interest in ivermectin since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, because it was observed that at high concentrations it had antiviral properties against the SARS-CoV-2 virus.
However, there was an important red flag in that finding. A few weeks after the initial finding was published, a short paper appeared in the British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology that described the considerations for using ivermectin as an antiviral. While it acknowledged the antiviral properties of high concentrations of the drug in laboratory (in vitro) experiments, it noted that it would likely not be possible to achieve the same concentrations of the drug in the plasma of the blood, because the drug itself is tightly bound to blood proteins. Even giving 8.5 x the FDA-approved dose (1700mcg/kg) resulted in blood concentrations far below the dose identified that offered antiviral effects:
If a drug can’t reach sufficient levels in the blood or plasma, it will not have any meaningful effects.
The earliest trials were tiny and underpowered to detect anything. One of the more widely cited papers is this one, published in October 2020, which was a chart review (not a randomized, controlled trial) that looked at hospitalized patients treated with or without ivermectin. The authors observed that ivermectin was associated with lower mortality, especially in patients with severe pulmonary involvement. However, patients who received ivermectin were also more likely to receive steroid drugs (which have been proven to reduce mortality from COVID-19), meaning that the use of steroids could have distorted the observed outcomes. The authors correctly called for a randomized controlled trial to validate these findings.
One randomized, prospective trial that appeared subsequently was this one which was published in December 2020. This small trial looked at hospitalized patients in Bangladesh and randomized 72 patients to ivermectin (12mg daily for five days), ivermectin (single dose of 12mg) with doxycycline (an antibiotic) for five days, or placebo. The authors found that viral clearance was earlier in the five-day ivermectin arm, compared to placebo. The trial did not look at any other endpoints other than safety (it was well tolerated), and the authors noted that larger trials would be required.
In March 2021 another randomized controlled trial was published that looked at the use of ivermectin in patients with mild (i.e., non-hospitalized) COVID-19. This was a much larger trial of 476 patients that gave five days of ivermectin 300 μg/kg per day for 5 days, or placebo. (Before you read on, look up 300 μg/kg in the image above.) The researchers found that ivermectin had no effect on the time to resolution of symptoms.
Lest you think I’m cherry picking, I’ll point to a health technology review dated February 8, 2021 that attempted to comprehensively and systematically compile and evaluate all the relevant published evidence for ivermectin, up to January 5, 2021. It found a total of six publications and made the following conclusion:
The primary studies identified in this report including those within the [systematic review] were found to have high risk of bias, thus producing a very low quality of evidence that preclude the ability to draw any strong conclusions as whether ivermectin could reduce all-cause mortality, improve clinical symptoms and hospitalization, and enhance viral clearance in patients with COVID-19. The decision for the use of ivermectin to treat COVID-19 is currently discouraged by the included guidelines due to lack of strong evidence. It is possible that the inconsistency in the observed efficacy of ivermectin in recent human studies was in part due to insufficient concentration of the drug reached in the plasma of patients when the approved dose for parasitic infections was used to treat COVID-19. Well-conducted, dose-response trials are needed to provide reliable conclusions regarding the benefit and harms of ivermectin for the treatment and prevention of COVID-19. Until then, interpretations of existing evidence in this report should be taken with caution.
Even Pharma says don’t do it
Ivermectin is well tolerated, with no fatalities (to date) reported from overdose. In cases of significant exposure to veterinary formulations of ivermectin, with much larger doses, side effects have ranged from rash and headache to more severe effects, like seizures. The FDA recently warned against using ivermectin, noting that some people have been hospitalized after use. The NIH commented on the lack of evidence in February 2021, in its COVID-19 Treatment Guidelines:
There are insufficient data for the COVID-19 Treatment Guidelines Panel (the Panel) to recommend either for or against the use of ivermectin for the treatment of COVID-19. Results from adequately powered, well-designed, and well-conducted clinical trials are needed to provide more specific, evidence-based guidance on the role of ivermectin in the treatment of COVID-19.
Given the reasonable side effect profile at regular doses, and worldwide interest in the drug, you would expect the manufacturer to be enthusiastic, or at least, non-committal about the potential for use. In February, Merck, the manufacturer of ivermectin, made the following statement about its drug.
Company scientists continue to carefully examine the findings of all available and emerging studies of ivermectin for the treatment of COVID-19 for evidence of efficacy and safety. It is important to note that, to-date, our analysis has identified:
    • No scientific basis for a potential therapeutic effect against COVID-19 from pre-clinical studies;
    • No meaningful evidence for clinical activity or clinical efficacy in patients with COVID-19 disease, and;
    • A concerning lack of safety data in the majority of studies.
We do not believe that the data available support the safety and efficacy of ivermectin beyond the doses and populations indicated in the regulatory agency-approved prescribing information.
Consider that carefully. The pharmaceutical company that has the most to gain from the sale of ivermectin is actively discouraging its use to treat COVID-19.
Conclusion: There is no evidence ivermectin can treat COVID-19
The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic led to widespread interest in repurposing existing drugs to reduce the risk or severity of infections. While some drugs have been successfully repurposed and are now in routine use to treat COVID-19, far more have been tested and found to be ineffective. Anecdotal evidence and hypotheses are great starting points to research. But as evidence emerges, we need to focus on the most rigorous evaluations to inform our decision making. Similar to hydroxychloroquine, there is no convincing evidence that demonstrates ivermectin has any meaningful clinical effects in the treatment of COVID-19.

Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 2
A few months ago, Scott Gavura wrote about how the veterinary deworming drug ivermectin has become the new hydroxychloroquine in that it is being promoted as a highly effective treatment against COVID-19—and by many of the same people who previously promoted HCQ—despite evidence that is, at best very weak and at worst completely negative. Unfortunately, with the publication of two new and biased reviews, the “HCQ vibe” about ivermectin is stronger than ever.
David Gorski on June 21, 2021
Link

I must admit that I approached this week’s topic initially with a distinct lack of enthusiasm. The reason is quite simple: Been there, done that. The topic is ivermectin, the new-old wonder drug to treat COVID-19 that evidence can’t seem to kill, and I’m definitely getting flashbacks to a year ago when the first “miracle drug” for COVID-19 was being widely touted, used, and studied. That drug was hydroxychloroquine, and ivermectin is basically the new hydroxychloroquine, as Scott Gavura pointed out a couple of months ago.
So why write about ivermectin again now? For one thing, it’s still being touted, despite an evidence base that can be described most charitably as weak. Second, two new new review articles were published last week and are being touted by ivermectin fans as significant evidence that we should take the drug seriously as a treatment for COVID-19. Hint: They’re not.
To see why I’m getting a strong “hydroxychloroquine” vibe from ivermectin, let’s briefly review what happened with hydroxychloroquine early in the pandemic. After that, I’ll discuss the narrative about the drug being promoted by quacks like Joe Mercola. Finally, I’ll address the evidence for ivermectin in COVID-19, including the two papers cited above.
Hydroxychloroquine: A brief history
When the COVID-19 pandemic first hit early in 2020, it was a truly frightening time, particularly in hospitals in the hardest-hit areas, which were deluged with incredibly sick patients and no treatments other than supportive ones. Faced with dying patients for whom they couldn’t do a lot, doctors felt desperate and started trying something—anything—to save their patients’ live. They thus often threw “everything but the kitchen sink” at the disease, which, again, was understandable early on, when there was no evidence, but is less so now.
In that time of desperation, one drug was more popular than any other. It was an antimalarial drug, hydroxychloroquine (HCQ), which had been repurposed to treat COVID-19 based on in vitro observations of antiviral activity, its known mild immunosuppressive effect that had led it to become a mainstay of the treatment of autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosis, and observations in Wuhan, China during the first epidemic that ultimately led to the pandemic.
How did hydroxychloroquine become the first “miracle drug” for COVID-19? In brief, Chinese researchers reported that none of their 80 patients with lupus erythematosus who were taking hydroxychloroquine went on to become infected with SARS-CoV-2. As a result of that and old evidence of antiviral activity for the drugs, they became interested in using these antimalarial drugs to treat COVID-19. (Never mind that immunosuppressed patients are exactly the patients most likely to assiduously follow the recommendations of public health authorities during a pandemic.) A number of clinical trials were registered, and, based on anecdotal reports and small clinical trials (nearly all of which are as yet unpublished), in February 2020 the Chinese government published an expert consensus recommending CQ or HCQ for patients with COVID-19. Soon after, a number of nations followed suit. From there, a French “brave maverick scientist” named Didier Raoult latched onto the drug as the “answer” to the COVID-19 pandemic, publishing risibly bad studies claiming to show its efficacy. Tech bros such as Elon Musk discovered the claims about hydroxychloroquine and Raoult’s bad science, leading to Donald Trump Tweeting favorably about his study and, ultimately, to the FDA issuing an emergency use authorization for the drug to treat COVID-19.
Unfortunately, it was not long before a drip-drip-drip of negative studies started to cast doubt on whether hydroxychloroquine had any activity against COVID-19, and by summer’s end last year it was pretty obvious that there was no “there” there with hydroxychloroquine, that it didn’t work. Even so, the drug continued to be promoted with enthusiasm ranging from just suggesting that it could prevent COVID-19 after exposure to the virus to full-blown “miracle drug” claims. I once referred to hydroxychloroquine as the “Black Knight” of COVID-19 treatments, a reference to the scene in Monty Python and the Holy Grail in which the Black Knight refuses to admit defeat even as Arthur lopped off limb after limb because evidence just couldn’t seem to kill it. The saga of hydroxychloroquine demonstrated the importance of randomized clinical trials, even in a pandemic, and the price of abandoning science- and evidence-based medicine in the face of hucksters and astroturf groups promoting the drug with bad science and “miracle cure” testimonials the drug and physicians making an honest effort to try something—anything—to save their patients.
As it became clear from more and more evidence that hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work against COVID-19, the narrative started to—shall we say?—evolve? For instance, Dr. Vladimir Zelenko claimed that you had to use zinc with hydroxychloroquine. Others started coming up with cocktails of drugs, vitamins and supplements willy-nilly, with no evidence for efficacy of any of the individual components except the steroids sometimes included in the mix, with grand claims that the cocktail was the miracle cure. Truly, 2020 was a year of physicians behaving badly.
In the midst of this massive shifting of goalposts came ivermectin, which many, including Scott and myself, have dubbed “the new hydroxychloroquine.”
Enter ivermectin, the new hydroxychloroquine
Just as hydroxychloroquine was repurposed based on in vitro (cell culture and biochemical) studies showing antiviral activity that didn’t translate to in vivo (in experimental animals or humans) activity, it was proposed to repurpose ivermectin based on in vitro observations of antiviral activity. Just as hydroxychloroquine was widely used despite a marked lack of evidence, so, too, in many parts of the world ivermectin is being used to treat COVID-19 patients despite a marked lack of evidence. Just as an astroturf effort to promote hydroxychloroquine as an effective treatment for COVID-19 popped up, so, too, an astroturf campaign, complete with conspiracy theories about ivermectin—like hydroxychloroquine!—being an inexpensive drug that “they” don’t want you to know about because its wide use would harm big pharma profits and the sales of COVID-19 vaccines, has emerged.
As we’ve seen, hydroxychloroquine is an antimalaria drug that also has modest immunosuppressive effects sufficient to be useful for some autoimmune diseases, but what is ivermectin? Basically, as Scott Gavura described, ivermectin (Stromectol) is an antiparasitic drug used to treat intestinal strongyloidiasis (threadworm, caused by infection from Strongyloides stercoralis), onchocerciasis (river blindness, caused by the parasitic worm Onchocerca volvulus, and spread by the Simulium blackfly), and roundworm infestations. In veterinary medicine, ivermectin is commonly used to prevent heartworm in dogs and cats and is also used off-label to treat a number of other parasitic infections in animals, including mites in dogs (demodectic mange, scabies, and ear mites) and intestinal parasites (hookworms, roundworms), and Capillaria. In farming, the drug is also used as a deworming medicine in cattle, swine, sheep, goats, and horses.
The interest in ivermectin appears to have originated in an Australian study published early in the pandemic that showed that high concentrations of ivermectin in vitro demonstrated antiviral activities. I’m not going to rehash that study in detail, as Scott has already discussed it, other than to repeat and emphasize that the concentrations used in the experiments published were not concentrations that were achievable in the plasma using standard dosages and to cite a short article from June 2020 that pointed out that pharmacokinetic considerations made ivermectin a poor candidate as an antiviral drug, regardless of how much antiviral activity it might have exhibited at high concentrations in vitro. Basically, the article pointed out that it is likely not possible to achieve the same concentrations of the drug in the plasma, because the drug itself is tightly bound to blood proteins and that even 8.5X the FDA-approved dose (1,700 μg/kg) resulted in blood concentrations far below the dose identified for antiviral effects. I’ll also point out that Scott nicely summarized earlier studies that failed to find a significant impact on the clinical course of COVID-19.
Unfortunately, as was the case with hydroxychloroquine before, conspiracy theories have arisen around the supposed “suppression” of ivermectin. I hasten to point out that hydroxychloroquine hasn’t gone away. Indeed, it is still being touted in Brazil now, fed by the misinformation promoted by Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, even as Brazil’s death toll has hit 500,000 and looks likely to surpass that of the US, whose death toll recently hit 600,000 but is slowing down markedly as more and more people are vaccinated. Even so, ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine in much of the rest of the world, particularly in the antivaccine, COVID-19-minimizing conspiracy world. One example is how, a month ago, ivermectin was being offered to every citizen of India as the pandemic was killing thousands of people a day in that country.
Let’s look at the narrative.
COVID, ivermectin and the “crime of the century”
Last week, über-quack Joe Mercola published an article entitled “COVID, Ivermectin and the Crime of the Century“, naming it after an episode of Bret Weinstein’s podcast. It features an interview with Dr. Pierre Kory, one of the most prominent proponents of ivermectin for COVID-19 by evolutionary biologist Bret Weinstein, who has become prominent as a COVID-19 contrarian and spreader of disinformation, particularly about the “lab leak theory” of SARS-CoV-2 origins and now likes to Tweet about “persecution” by Twitter:
Why are @PierreKory and @Covid19Critical’s accounts suspended?
If they were laypeople making a heterodox case they would be deserving of a fully-throated defense. But they’re top clinicians publishing an impressive body of evidence
Why can’t we talk about #Ivermectin, @jack?
— Bret Weinstein (@BretWeinstein) May 29, 2021
It also turns out that Dr. Pierre Kory is president of the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) and has testified before Congress. During that testimony, Dr. Kory claimed that ivermectin, used with other medicines such as vitamin C, zinc and melatonin, could “save hundreds of thousands of people,” and cited more than 20 studies.
The narrative of Mercola’s article is eerily similar to the narratives we heard about hydroxychloroquine a year ago, namely that ivermectin is a cheap, safe, and effective drug that “they” don’t want you to know about that could have saved hundreds of thousands of lives if not for doctors’ fetish for randomized clinical trials.
For example:
Yet, despite stellar credentials and being on the frontlines treating hundreds of COVID-19 patients, they have been dismissed as “kooks on the fringe, making wild-eyed claims,” Weinstein says. How can that be? Initially, the FLCCC insisted, based on the evidence, that COVID-19 was a corticosteroid-dependent disease and that corticosteroids were a crucial part of effective treatment.
And:
Since those early days, the FLCCC has been vindicated and corticosteroids, as well as blood thinners, are now part of the standard of care for COVID-19 in many places. The same cannot be said for the remainder of the protocols, however, including the use of ivermectin, which continues to be suppressed, despite robust clinical evidence supporting its use in all phases of COVID-19.
I do like how the FLCCC claims the “brave maverick doctor” and “brave maverick scientist” role and assumes that, because Dr. Kory was on the right side of a couple of areas then he must be right about everything. I also can’t help but note that Dr. Kory, contrary to his “brave maverick” claims, was nowhere near the only one proposing the use of anticoagulants and steroids as part of the supportive treatment of severe COVID-19. These were being debated at my hospital in March 2020 (admittedly, along with hydroxychloroquine).
And, of course, Dr. Kory pulls the favorite gambit of doctors promoting dubious treatments, the “we can’t do randomized clinical trials because it’s unethical” gambit:
With regard to calls for randomized controlled trials, Kory points out that once you can see from clinical evidence that something really is working, then conducting controlled trials becomes more or less unethical, as you know you’re condemning the control group to poor outcomes or death.
And, of course, ivermectin is being “suppressed”:
As noted by Weinstein, ivermectin appears to be intentionally suppressed. It’s simply not allowed to be a go-to remedy. The obvious question is why? Don’t they want to save lives? Isn’t that why we shut down the world?
“I would have these data arguments,” Kory says. “But it’s not about the data. There’s something else. There’s [something] out there that is just squashing, distorting, suppressing the efficacy of ivermectin, and its egregious.”
Indeed, as noted by Weinstein, it’s not even difficult to prove that ivermectin is being suppressed and censored. Censorship of certain COVID-related information, such as ivermectin, is written into the community guidelines. You’re not allowed to talk about it. If you do, your post will be censored, shadow-banned or taken down. If you persist, your entire account will be taken down.
Meanwhile, journalist Matt Taibbi, someone who really should know better but apparently does not, is promoting the conspiracy theory with an article on Substack entitled ‘Why Has “Ivermectin” Become a Dirty Word?’ Its subtitle? “At the worst moment, Internet censorship has driven scientific debate itself underground.”
Ask yourself if this sounds familiar:
A consequence is that issues like the ivermectin question have ended up in the same public bucket as debates over foreign misinformation, hate speech, and even incitement. The same Republican Senator YouTube suspended for making statements in support of ivermectin, Ron Johnson, has also been denounced in the press for failing to call the January 6th riots an insurrection, resulting in headlines that blend the two putative offenses.
“You have these ideas about the need to censor hate speech, calls for violence, and falsity,” Kory says, “and they’ve put science on the same shelf.”
Congratulations, Mr. Taibbi! You’ve used an argument identical to one that I’ve seen used by antivaxxers and quacks on many an occasion dating back 16 years, complete with a false characterization of quality control as “censorship.” Indeed, fans of cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski loved to use similar arguments, claiming that their hero’s work was being “suppressed.”
Taibbi even uncritically quotes ivermectin fans saying just that:
Ivermectin may never be proven effective as a Covid-19 treatment, but its story has already appeared as a powerful metaphor of the Internet’s transformation. Once envisioned as a vast democratizing tool, which would massively raise global knowledge levels by allowing instant cross-global communication between all people, it’s morphed instead into a giant unaccountable bureaucracy for suppressing dialogue, run by people with an authoritarian vision for information flow. Many ivermectin advocates believe discussion of the the [sic] drug is being suppressed because of its status as a threat to a billion-dollar vaccine business, but it’s just as likely that its reputation worldwide as a “populist” treatment, a medicine taken by people not waiting for official validation, has made it a target of censors and pundits alike.
“I think what happened is that at the outset of the pandemic, it was decided that all information must go in one direction, from the Gods of Science down,” says Kory. “But that’s not the way it works. Science happens on the ground. That’s where the little discoveries are made. They don’t happen at the top of the mountain.”
As I said, Dr. Kory is pushing a classic conspiracy theory very much like the classic conspiracy theory about hydroxychloroquine last year, that ivermectin is a cure for COVID-19 that “they” don’t want you to know about. (And it’ll render vaccines unnecessary.) I see echoes of Kevin Trudeau.
Shorter Taibbi, substituting "#COVID19" for "natural": pic.twitter.com/nTKFnnTUgX
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) June 20, 2021
But what about the evidence?
Mercola cites in the interview the various lines of evidence listed by Dr. Kory. It turns out that Scott already dealt with a number of those studies. I’m going to focus mainly on the two that I cited initially. Both are being touted on Twitter.
Here’s the first:
***MORE PUBLISHED IVM EVIDENCE: “Although several drugs received Emergency Use Authorization for COVID-19 w/unsatisfactory supportive data, #Ivermectin, on the other hand, has been sidelined irrespective of sufficient convincing data supporting its use.” https://t.co/VeAH54967e
— FLCCC Alliance (@Honest_Medicine) June 19, 2021
And here’s the second:
Let’s dig in, starting with the “clinical review article.”
Mechanisms of ivermectin against SARS-CoV-2?
The first article is labeled a “clinical review article”. That immediately puzzled me, because it’s far more a basic science review article than it is a clinical review. The vast majority of the article is a rehash of in vitro studies showing antiviral activity of the drug at high concentrations, as listed in Table 2. It is not really a systematic review, and it’s published in a relatively minor journal by two people who are part of a pro-ivermectin advocacy group, and people on Twitter also immediately saw a lot of issues with the studies cited, for example:
I haven't had a chance to look through this paean to IVM in detail but this part is ridiculous. The virus replicates in the cytoplasm. Inhibition of importins cannot plausibly have an antiviral effect on SARS-CoV-2. pic.twitter.com/WhHzASrW3a
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) June 17, 2021
4/n Now, this might be something of a red flag for publication in a scientific journal, but this affiliation isn't mentioned in the paper or the conflicts of interest which is a bit odd pic.twitter.com/TDmG9qf3Lg
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) June 17, 2021
Basically, the authors cite a paper that found that ivermectin inhibits the activity of a protein, importin, that, according to them, “blocking the nuclear transport of viral proteins.” Given that the viruses replicate in the cytoplasm (the rest of the cell other than the nucleus), you can see why Ed was unimpressed.
Also:
On the contrary, SARS-CoV-2 itself has several viral proteins that prevent import of host factors needed to turn on genes critical for antiviral defense. This description of IVM's MoA in fact outlines a clear mechanism for toxicity to the host.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) June 17, 2021
Wow, okay this is really a mess. The paper they cite for the ionophore properties of IVM is completely speculative and presents no data to support an actual ionophore function of the IVM, let alone how that produces an antiviral effect.
— Edward Nirenberg 🇺🇦 (@ENirenberg) June 17, 2021
Perusing the totality of the paper, I noted that the authors cite a lot of biochemical papers that purport to show that ivermectin interferes with various cellular processes relevant to the replication of SARS-CoV-2 in a sort of “shotgun” approach, all with a heaping dose of speculation. For instance, they cite computer modeling (in silico) work thusly:
Another in-silico study by Swargiary et al. demonstrated the best binding interaction of −9.7 kcal/mol between Ivermectin and RdRp suggesting inhibition of viral replication [33]. The RdRP residing in nsp12 is the centerpiece of the coronavirus replication and transcription complex and has been suggested as a promising drug target as it is a crucial enzyme in the virus life cycle both for replication of the viral genome but also for transcription of subgenomic mRNAs (sgRNAs) [34]. Ivermectin binds to the viral rdrp and disrupts it. The highly efficient binding of ivermectin to nsp14 confirms its role in inhibiting viral replication and assembly. It is well known that nsp14 is essential in transcription and replication. It acts as a proofreading exoribonuclease and plays a role in viral RNA capping by its methyltransferase activity [35]. Moreover, highly efficient binding of ivermectin to the viral N phosphoprotein and M protein is suggestive of its role in inhibiting viral replication and assembly [23].
This is a lot of handwaving and speculation. It might have value as evidence to support trying ivermectin in animal models of viral illnesses, but in and of itself, none of it is good evidence that ivermectin actually works in humans.
Then there was this red flag:
That’s a world-record time for acceptance of a review article for publication! The only other instances that I can recall of such rapid acceptance have been by “pay-to-publish” predatory journals.
Be that as it may, oddly enough, the only human evidence cited by the authors comes primarily from a pro-ivermectin website, Ivermectin for COVID-19: real-time meta analysis of 60 studies, whose abuse and misunderstanding of the use of p-values is epic:
The probability that an ineffective treatment generated results as positive as the 60 studies to date is estimated to be 1 in 2 trillion (p = 0.00000000000045).
I like how this was immediately mocked:
7/n Indeed, the authors have copied the information in this paragraph directly from this shoddy website, leading to this wonderful sentence making its way into a published scientific paper pic.twitter.com/U4NIgERNOw
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) June 17, 2021
I also can’t help but note that this ivmmeta.com website uses exactly the same dubious techniques as were used by another website, hcqmeta.com, to tout hydroxychloroquine. Indeed, it very much appears that the same people are behind the two websites, and it is rather clear to me that these websites represent an astroturf effort to promote unproven treatments for COVID-19.
There’s a saying I invoke all the time for meta-analyses: GIGO, or “garbage in, garbage out”. Neither ivmmeta.com nor hcqmeta.com is a true meta-analysis, as neither properly takes into account the quality of the studies being pooled, as is pointed out here:
10/n In fact, one of my favourite parts is where a WHO investigation that concluded that ivermectin should not be given outside of a clinical trial as the evidence is so woeful is misrepresented as showing that ivermectin is massively beneficial! pic.twitter.com/MARkZRcsR5
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) June 17, 2021
12/n Anyway, this website is what I would call solidly pseudoscientific – mimicking science closely enough to trap the unwary, but so filled with errors that the evidence is largely worthless
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) June 17, 2021
To quote the WHO analysis:
Compared with previous drugs evaluated as part of the WHO Living Guidelines for Therapeutics in COVID-19 (see below), currently there are far fewer RCT data available for ivermectin. The existing data on ivermectin also have a substantially higher degree of uncertainty, with included trials having enrolled substantially fewer patients with far fewer events.
And:
For most key outcomes, including mortality, mechanical ventilation, hospital admission, duration of hospitalization and viral clearance, the panel considered the evidence of very low certainty. Evidence was rated as very low certainty primarily because of very serious imprecision for most outcomes: the aggregate data had wide confidence intervals and/or very few events. There were also serious concerns related to risk of bias for some outcomes, specifically lack of blinding, lack of trial pre-registration, and lack of outcome reporting for one trial that did not report mechanical ventilation despite pre-specifying it in their protocol (publication bias).
I also can’t help but note that there are other astroturf-like websites promoting ivermectin too, such as c19ivermectin.com, which has identical formatting and methodologies to a previous website for hydroxychloroquine, c19hcq.com.
We have been warned about them for a long time:
Different websites (such as https://ivmmeta.com/, https://c19ivermectin.com/, https://tratamientotemprano.org/estudios-ivermectina/, among others) have conducted meta-analyses with ivermectin studies, showing unpublished colourful forest plots which rapidly gained public acknowledgement and were disseminated via social media, without following any methodological or report guidelines. These websites do not include protocol registration with methods, search strategies, inclusion criteria, quality assessment of the included studies nor the certainty of the evidence of the pooled estimates. Prospective registration of systematic reviews with or without meta-analysis protocols is a key feature for providing transparency in the review process and ensuring protection against reporting biases, by revealing differences between the methods or outcomes reported in the published review and those planned in the registered protocol. These websites show pooled estimates suggesting significant benefits with ivermectin, which has resulted in confusion for clinicians, patients and even decision-makers. This is usually a problem when performing meta-analyses which are not based in rigorous systematic reviews, often leading to spread spurious or fallacious findings.
This is as good a point as any to move on to the meta-analysis being touted by Dr. Kory. It comes from the UK, specifically from authors associated with the BIRD Group, a pro-ivermectin advocacy group that appears to me to be very similar to the FLCCC.
The BIRD Group “meta-analysis”: Bad science and undisclosed conflicts of interest
As last week closed, I noticed this on Twitter:
Unsurprisingly, it’s being spread all over social media as “slam dunk” evidence that ivermectin works against COVID-19:
This meta-analysis of Ivermectin effectiveness is just now peer reviewed and published. The evidence of prophylactic effectiveness is particularly important. https://t.co/FKT3zETmtw
— Bret Weinstein (@BretWeinstein) June 20, 2021
1/ Three recent fundamental papers on Ivermectin: There are no more excuses not to apply RIGHT NOW IVM for COVID treatment. 1- June 17, 2021.Systematic Review and Meta-analysis by Dr. Lawrie PUBLISHED in the American Journal of Therapeutics.https://t.co/HOv2kDKIPl pic.twitter.com/XrR9XRE2b4
— JML (@JML21071664) June 19, 2021
"Meta-analysis of 15 trials found that ivermectin reduced risk of death compared with no ivermectin (average risk ratio 0.38, 95% confidence interval 0.19–0.73; n = 2438; I2 = 49%; moderate-certainty evidence)." https://t.co/RTnfU0RpUr
— Association of American Physicians & Surgeons (@AAPSonline) June 19, 2021
Nobody can say no to #ivermectin anymore. 62% death risk reduction. 86% infection risk reduction. Peer reviewed, published in the American Journal of Therapeutics. @BIRDGroupUK https://t.co/bYCYIq6OVE https://t.co/N4IR3VKEPj
— Barend Petrus Uys (@bpuys6) June 19, 2021
A systematic review, meta analysis is the highest form of evidence since it evaluates the signal across multiple RCT's. https://t.co/9vnUUMPqWO
— Jeff Barczewski (@jeffbski) June 19, 2021
No, this is not what meta-analyses necessarily do.
The article, published in the American Journal of Therapeutics by investigators affiliated with the BIRD Group led by Andrew Bryant, purports to be a “Systematic Review, Meta-analysis, and Trial Sequential Analysis to Inform Clinical Guidelines“. In fairness, what I can say from this meta-analysis is that, just like the case with hydroxychloroquine a year ago, it is possible that ivermectin has some clinically meaningful effect on COVID-19 disease progression and survival. It’s not particularly likely or plausible in light of the pharmacokinetics problem mentioned above, in which huge doses of ivermectin would be required to reach the same concentrations in the plasma that caused antiviral effects in the in vitro studies that I discussed above, but it’s not impossible.
I would add, however, that if there really is a clinical effect due to ivermectin on SARS-CoV-2 infection, this disconnect between pharmacokinetics and the concentration of the drug needed in vitro to see antiviral effects would strongly suggest an entirely different mechanism of action in vivo. Again, prior plausibility matters, as we have discussed so often in the context of, for example, homeopathy or reiki. No, I’m not saying that the level of plausibility of ivermectin as a treatment for COVID-19 is anywhere as low as that of homeopathy or reiki. Ivermectin is, after all, a real drug with real effects on biochemistry, not a claim that water has memory or that you can project healing energy into patients. However, overcoming this plausibility problem based on pharmacokinetics is not trivial, either. It would require high quality clinical evidence from large, well-designed, rigorous double-blind randomized clinical trials. Unfortunately, as I read, it became very clear to me that the meta-analysis does not include any large, well-designed, rigorous double-blind randomized clinical trials, which is why it suffers from the same problem that I discussed before, GIGO.
The selection strategy was described thusly:
We searched the reference list of included studies, and of two other 2021 literature reviews on ivermectin,9 as well as the recent WHO report, which included analyses of ivermectin.12 We contacted experts in the field (Drs. Andrew Hill, Pierre Kory, and Paul Marik) for information on new and emerging trial data. In addition, all trials registered on clinical trial registries were checked, and trialists of 39 ongoing trials or unclassified studies were contacted to request information on trial status and data where available. Many preprint publications and unpublished articles were identified from the preprint servers MedRxiv and Research Square, and the International Clinical Trials Registry Platform. This is a rapidly expanding evidence base, so the number of trials are increasing quickly. Reasons for exclusion were recorded for all studies excluded after full-text review.
Interesting. The authors contacted Dr. Kory and his fellow ivermectin advocates at FLCCC. I also note that the American Journal of Therapeutics published a systemic review of ivermectin for COVID-19 about a month and a half ago that basically reminds me of the “clinical review” that I discussed first. Hilariously, at one point, the FLCCC systematic review tries to compare COVID-19 case counts and death rates with areas with and without ivermectin distribution programs in order to argue that fewer people dying in areas where ivermectin was used suggests that ivermectin works. This is a fallacious ecological “analysis” very similar to the argument used a nearly a year ago by an astroturf group for hydroxychloroquine.
But back to the BIRD Group meta-analysis, the first thing I noticed was that all of the studies were small, one as small as 24 patients, many of them not double-blind, a significant number, in fact, open-label, in which everyone knows which patients are in which treatment group. The second thing that I noted is that, contrary to the way this meta-analysis is being represented, pooling data from a large number of small, low-quality clinical trials does not magically create one large, high quality clinical trials.
Another way of putting it:
Ivermectin meta-analyses:
1) Most of the studies are poorly designed and don’t provide datasets. No way to demonstrate replicability.
2) Grouping observational studies and RCTs with different populations, control groups, dosing, and outcomes: unreliable due to heterogeneity. https://t.co/PQEyyqTtrv
— MJ (@mjaeckel) June 19, 2021
Garbage in garbage out
— PaedsHaemDoc 🗿 (@dr_barrett) June 19, 2021
In fairness, the authors don’t actually say that meta-analyses of crappy studies do make good evidence, at least not in the paper. However, ivermectin advocates touting the study fans are certainly making that claim, and Dr. Kory sure did seem to me to imply the same in his interview with Bret Weinstein. In any event, one large, well-designed rigorous double-blind clinical trial for prevention, along with one large, well-designed rigorous clinical trial for treatment, could trump this entire meta-analysis.
Indeed, Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz did a reanalysis of the studies analyzed by the BIRD Group that shows that if you leave out the two studies that are as yet only preprints, are very small, and actually appear to have been miscategorized as higher quality than they are, the results are very different:
This basically shows that without those two studies, the analysis demonstrates no benefit for ivermectin at all compared to placebo, with a confidence interval that includes everything from a big benefit to a large harm from the drug. Interestingly, the between-study heterogeneity also reduces when you do this from about 50% to 6.6%, which is lower than the value the authors give in their sensitivity analysis in the paper.
What this means is that, if you exclude some of the low-quality research on ivermectin, the paper goes from showing a massive benefit to no benefit at all. On top of this, there’s an interesting point — even if you don’t agree with these assessments, taking the only three studies that the authors of the meta-analysis considered to be at a “low risk of bias” (i.e. high-quality), you find that these high-quality studies have failed to find any benefit for ivermectin.
This is, of course, what those of us who’ve questioned whether ivermectin works for COVID-19 have been saying all along. The few existing higher quality clinical trials testing ivermectin against the disease uniformly have failed to find a positive result. It’s only the smaller, lower-quality trials that have been positive. This is a good indication that the drug probably doesn’t work.
Details matter, and, particularly the classification of risk of bias in the individual studies used. There’s another problem. Look at the funnel plot, which is a simple scatter plot of the intervention effect estimates from individual studies against some measure of each study’s size or precision used to look for publication bias. Publication bias is the tendency to publish positive studies and not publish negative studies. Figure 7 shows a funnel plot that Bryant et al characterize as not seeming “to suggest any evidence of publication bias.” However, if you look at the plot, the opposite is true, as, instead of seeing studies clustered on either side of 1.0, which is what you would expect in a funnel plot showing no evidence of publication bias, there is a clear preponderance of studies on the side of the plot less than 1.0 (meaning that the risk of death is lower in the ivermectin group), most of which are smaller, lower quality studies, with the larger studies more closely clustered around 1.0 (no effect).
That’s why I’m going to go back to a warning:
Nevertheless, assessments of ivermectin as prophylaxis or treatment for mild to severe COVID-19 continue being published in preprints26 27 and protocol repositories,28 29 which do not follow the recommended process to ensure quality standards in publications; whereas peer-reviewed reports (both observational and experimental studies) are slowly emerging, yet methodologically limited by heterogeneity in population receiving ivermectin, dosis [sic] applied and uncontrolled cointerventions.28–30 Similarly, other studies that can be rapidly retrieved in ClinicalTrials.gov, medRxiv and MEDLINE make up a quite heterogeneous body of evidence31–33 (including ivermectin as intervention, but with different underlying clinical questions), among other issues that do not contribute to the certainty of evidence—according to the systematic reviews that we comment on below.
What anyone considering any meta-analysis, be it this one or any other, needs to be aware of is the existence of a number of pitfalls in meta-analyses, for example:
Meta-analysis is a powerful tool to cumulate and summarize the knowledge in a research field through statistical instruments, and to identify the overall measure of a treatment’s effect by combining several individual results [4]. However, it is a controversial tool, because several conditions are critical and even small violations of these can lead to misleading conclusions. In fact, several decisions made when designing and performing a meta-analysis require personal judgment and expertise, thus creating personal biases or expectations that may influence the result [5, 6].
As statistical means of reviewing primary studies, meta-analyses have inherent advantages as well as limitations [7]. Pooling data through meta-analysis can create problems, such as nonlinear correlations, multifactorial rather than unifactorial effects, limited coverage, or inhomogeneous data that fails to connect with the hypothesis. Despite these problems, the meta-analysis method is very useful: it establishes whether scientific findings are consistent and if they can be generalized across populations, it identifies patterns among studies, sources of disagreement among results, and other interesting relationships that may emerge in the context of multiple studies.
One can’t help but wonder whether the known bias of an organization dedicated to promoting COVID-19 treatments like ivermectin crept into this meta-analysis. The first author Andrew Bryant, Tess Lawrie, and the most of the authors are affiliated with the Bird Group, a UK group whose website looks like this:

The BIRD Group touts ivermectin thusly:
Partnering with worldwide clinical experts, BIRD recognises the growing body of research that shows that ivermectin is a safe, effective medicine we could use to combat Covid 19.
Although ivermectin is licensed in the UK, it cannot be prescribed for Covid 19 until it receives Government approval.
Ivermectin is readily accessible and very low cost and can effectively reach worldwide populations very quickly. Our aim is to get ivermectin approved soon in the UK and around the world. Time is critical and we know that the quicker we deploy, the more lives we can save.
Indeed, the second author, Tess Lawrie, is a founder of the group and appears tightly allied with Dr. Kory:
The seed was planted late in December, when Dr. Tess Lawrie watched Dr. Pierre Kory of the Front-Line Covid-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) testify before the US Senate on the potential of ivermectin for prevention and treatment of covid-19. She looked into the data and decided to conduct a rapid systematic review and meta-analysis to assess the data for herself. She was struck by the seeming efficacy of the drug in reducing mortality and morbidity, and, as a doctor, considered it her duty to inform the UK health authorities about this potential breakthrough treatment.
The FLCCC Alliance is listed as an affiliated organization, along with a number of others, including the Alliance for Natural Health International and the antivaccine group Physicians for Informed Consent, both of which we have encountered before.
Elsewhere, the BIRD Group claims that ivermectin can prevent “long COVID,” the syndrome of systemic illness that has been noted in some patients to last for months after recovering from the disease, and that it is “already saving lives around the world,” a claim for which there is no good evidence and identical to frequent claims by the FLCCC and other ivermectin advocates. Basically, it’s the idea that we could be saving so many lives in the US, UK, and other nations where ivermectin is not approved to treat COVID-19 if only we would change course.
Bias. It’s something one has to be very, very careful of when designing a meta-analysis, and bringing up the possibility is not an indictment of the motives of anyone involved in the study. What is an indictment of the study is that nowhere in the paper could I find a mention of the affiliation of Dr. Bryant and the other authors with the BIRD Group, although they did note that the revised meta-analysis was funded by a GoFundMe, “Help us get life-saving drug approved for covid-19“. It’s a simple recognition of human nature, and it’s particularly pernicious when it is an undisclosed conflict of interest.
Which is why:
Concluding, research related to ivermectin in COVID-19 has serious methodological limitations resulting in very low certainty of the evidence, and continues to grow.37–39 The use of ivermectin, among others repurposed drugs for prophylaxis or treatment for COVID-19, should be done based on trustable evidence, without conflicts of interest, with proven safety and efficacy in patient-consented, ethically approved, randomised clinical trials.
Italics mine. After all, what’s good for the goose, and all that. Ivermectin fans frequently automatically reject criticism of studies of the drug due to bias and even spread the conspiracy theory that the reason ivermectin hasn’t been widely adopted is because it’s a cheap drug off patent that big pharma can’t make much money from. It’s a fair criticism of the BIRD Group and FLCCC, and it’s an especially fair criticism given the undisclosed conflict of interest involved. I’m sure that Bryant et al. didn’t disclose it because they don’t consider a non-financial conflict of interest to be a true conflict of interest, but being associated with an advocacy group most definitely is.
Indeed, Dr. Kory himself was on Twitter the other day ranting about how his meta-analysis is a “game-changer” but “they” are “censoring” and “suppressing” it. He even completed the crank requirement of including a conspiracy theory positing that “big pharma” is “suppressing” ivermectin so that “they” can develop a new ivermectin-like drug for COVID-19 that can be patented, paving the way for lots and lots of profit:
Where the &#%!? is the major media? A historic, landmark paper identifies the real “game changer” drug in Covid.. and… they dutifully keep censoring. Memo to media: the agencies are CAPTURED. They JUST #%$! gave Pharma over 4B to… invent a new ivermectin. WTF. DO YOUR JOB. https://t.co/AnbtEer2Gi
— Pierre Kory, MD MPA (@PierreKory) June 20, 2021
Leading to these sorts of responses, which remind me, more than anything else, of the rhetoric of antivaxxers, first about Drs. Kory and Weinstein:
The real life "Jude Law" from Contagion. A miracle drug that's being suppressed by big phama while also being studied all over the world in multiple large scale clinical trials.
— Sam (@SamueldLtoronto) June 20, 2021
Ouch. Harsh, but fair, though.
Then there was this:
It’s also been noted:
What is this Tweet referring to? Simple. A few months ago, Frontiers in Pharmacology provisionally accepted a systematic review by Dr. Kory and FLCCC doctors that used many of the same studies as the current one and then decided to reject it:
Regardless of the publication stage or subject of a manuscript, if the integrity of an article is called into question, our policy is to investigate. Upon further scrutiny by our Research Integrity team about the objectivity of this paper during the provisional acceptance phase, it was revealed that the article made a series of strong, unsupported claims based on studies with insufficient statistical significance, and at times, without the use of control groups. Further, the authors promoted their own specific ivermectin-based treatment which is inappropriate for a review article and against our editorial policies.
In our view, this paper does not offer an objective nor balanced scientific contribution to the evaluation of ivermectin as a potential treatment for COVID-19. Frontiers’ has published more than 2,000 rigorously peer-reviewed articles on COVID-19 since the pandemic erupted via our Coronavirus Knowledge Hub, and we are acutely aware of just how critical high-quality, objective research in this area is at this time. Frontiers takes no position on the efficacy of ivermectin as a treatment of patients with COVID-19, however, we do take a very firm stance against unbalanced or unsupported scientific conclusions.
Which, predictably, led to cries of “Censorship!”:
"This is clear censorship. It's indefensible in science to reject a peer-reviewed paper." —Dr. @PierreKory
We will have more to say on this highly concerning development soon. Relief from this pandemic is here and it has a name: #Ivermectin. https://t.co/kXHZuDdm73
— FLCCC Alliance (@Honest_Medicine) March 1, 2021
I’m sorry, but Dr. Kory should not be surprised that someone would point out his own very blatant conflicts of interest when discussing his review. Live by accusations of conflicts of interest, die by accusations of conflicts of interest, scientifically at least, especially when the meta-analysis is as bad as this one and doesn’t disclose that it comes from members of an advocacy group dedicated to promoting the drug being studied:
So, am I rejecting this meta-analysis out of hand? Not at all, even in spite of its many flaws and the undisclosed conflict of interest! I’m simply pointing out that, contrary to the language being used by Dr. Kory and his admirers to promote it, this meta-analysis is, at best, mildly suggestive that ivermectin might have activity against SARS-CoV-2. At worst, it’s a biased piece of scientific hackery. Certainly, given the extreme lack of biological plausibility based on the drug’s pharmacokinetics, this meta-analysis is by no means the “slam dunk” rejoinder to skeptics of the drug that ivermectin advocates think it is.
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine
Ivermectin advocates hate it when we say this, but it’s true. Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine. It’s been promoted the same way and by the same people. The same conspiracy theories have sprung up around it as the scientific evidence supporting its use is weak at best, negative at worst. That’s why I’m going to go back to what I once wrote about hydroxychloroquine:
Because I’m dedicated to evidence and science when it comes to medical decision making, I always concede that it is still possible that hydroxychloroquine might still be found to have some anti-COVID-19 activity, although it’s becoming increasingly clear that, if there is any activity it will likely be very modest and require large clinical trials to detect, to the point where it’ll probably be clinically insignificant. That being said, it’s amazing how much believers in acupuncture, vitamin C to treat cancer, and hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 have in common. It’s also distressing how much like the villain in a slasher flick the drug is. No matter how many times it appears to have died, it always comes back.
Substitute the word “ivermectin” for every instance of “hydroxychloroquine,” and the paragraph above is still accurate.
Again, I concede that it is possible that ivermectin has clinically relevant in vivo antiviral activity against SARS-CoV-2. Based on current evidence, however, it seems unlikely that it does, when pharmacokinetics considerations are taken into account. As I routinely used to say when discussing hydroxychloroquine, I’d be happy to change my mind if compelling scientific evidence for ivermectin were published. It’s just that neither of these reviews qualify, nor do any of the clinical trials I’ve seen thus far. That’s why I agree that ivermectin shouldn’t be used to treat COVID-19 outside of the context of a well-designed clinical trial with a strong scientific rationale.
Certainly, the conspiracy mongering by Bret Weinstein, Pierre Kory, and their fans are not leading me to reconsider that opinion.

Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 3: Conspiracy theories vs. science
Last month, I discussed why ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine:, basically a “miracle cure” that isn’t. Since then, conspiracy theories about its being “suppressed” have continued to bump heads with the science showing that, at the very best, evidence for its efficacy is very weak and, at the worst, the drug is useless.
David Gorski on July 5, 2021
Link

A couple of months ago Scott Gavura explained why the veterinary deworming drug ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, a repurposed drug touted as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19 despite evidence that is, at best, very weak and, at worst, supportive of the conclusion that ivermectin is ineffective against COVID-19. Then, two weeks ago, I posted a typically lengthy, detailed, and snarky article about how ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine. What I meant was that, just as 12-15 months ago the antimalarial drug hydroxychloroquine was the repurposed drug touted as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19 that fizzled when tested with rigorous clinical trials, over the first half of 2021 ivermectin has become the repurposed drug touted as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19. Like hydroxychloroquine, which by the end of last summer I was describing as the Black Knight of COVID-19 treatments, an homage to (of course) the Black Knight in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, belief in ivermectin as a highly effective treatment for COVID-19—that will eliminate the need for vaccines, too!—seems similarly immune to having its limbs hacked off by science, the way that they were for hydroxychloroquine. This post won’t be as long—although it might be as snarky—and will deal more with the conspiracy theories that have cropped up around ivermectin. Unsurprisingly, they’re very similar to the conspiracy theories that cropped up around hydroxychloroquine. Many of these conspiracy theories are being promoted by a group of doctors who bill themselves as the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC).
I mentioned the FLCCC in my last post about ivermectin. The reason was because of its role in producing the latest “meta-analysis” of ivermectin clinical trials. Basically, Pierre Kory, one of the founders of the FLCCC, collaborated with Tess Lawrie, the founder of the British equivalent of the FLCCC, the BIRD Group. Both are groups that promote ivermectin, although the FLCCC promotes more than just ivermectin. For instance, FLCCC promotes protocols such as the I-MASS protocol, touted as an “in-home” treatment protocol for COVID-19 that involves vitamin D3, melatonin, aspirin, a multivitamin, a thermometer, and an antiseptic mouthwash. Another FLCCC protocol is I-MASK, which is promoted as an outpatient treatment protocol and involves ivermectin, zinc, melatonin, various vitamins, and fluvoxamine. The FLCCC’s most “advanced” protocol is MATH+, a hospital treatment protocol that involves—of course!—ivermectin, plus zinc, fluvoxamine, and a bunch of other vitamins and supplements, along with steroids and anticoagulants. None of these protocols has anything resembling solid evidence from randomized clinical trials to support it.
“The biggest crime committed during the [COVID-19] heist”?
The introduction above brings me to an article that was posted last week on the website of über-quack Joe Mercola, titled “The Biggest Crime Committed During Vaccine Heist“. You can see from the very title the implied conspiracy, namely that evidence for the efficacy of ivermectin is being “suppressed” so that vaccines can be foisted on the world, to the enormous profit of big pharma. Of course, Mercola, as he was before, is very impressed with Tess Lawrie and the “evidence” of her recent meta-analysis, featuring an interview with her on the Speaking Naturally podcast. Since I already deconstructed that meta-analysis in detail the other day and there now exists another, even better, explanation by epidemiologist Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz explaining why that meta-analysis is a bad one that, with a very minor change in classification of studies included, results in a completely negative finding, I won’t be repeating that analysis, although I will point to another meta-analysis that has been published since Tess Lawrie’s meta-analysis, published last week in Clinical Infectious Diseases, the official journal of the Infectious Diseases Society of America, by investigators from Brazil, Peru, and the US.
In brief, the investigators searched for published and preprint randomized controlled trials (RCTs) assessing ivermectin effects on COVID-19 adult patients were searched through March 22, 2021 using five search engines. The primary outcomes examined were all-cause mortality, length of stay (LOS), and adverse events (AE). Secondary outcomes examined included viral clearance and severe AEs. Risk of bias (RoB) was evaluated using Cochrane RoB 2·0 tool. Inverse variance random effect meta-analyses were performed, with quality of evidence (QoE) evaluated using GRADE methodology.
The results:
Ten RCTs (n=1173) were included. Controls were standard of care [SOC] in five RCTs and placebo in five RCTs. COVID-19 disease severity was mild in 8 RCTs, moderate in one RCT, and mild and moderate in one RCT. IVM did not reduce all-cause mortality vs. controls (RR 0.37, 95%CI 0.12 to 1.13, very low QoE) or LOS vs. controls (MD 0.72 days, 95%CI −0.86 to 2.29, very low QoE). AEs, severe AE and viral clearance were similar between IVM and controls (all outcomes: low QoE). Subgroups by severity of COVID-19 or RoB were mostly consistent with main analyses; all-cause mortality in three RCTs at high RoB was reduced with IVM.
Notice that last sentence. The RCTs with high risk of bias demonstrated significant reductions in all-cause mortality in patients suffering from COVID-19. In any case, contrary to the findings of Lawrie’s meta-analysis, there weren’t really any good high quality trials. I also note that these authors didn’t include one of the studies (Elgazzar 2020) that Meyerowitz-Katz described as having “no information whatsoever on allocation concealment at all, and the two sentences on randomization procedures actually contradict each other, yet it is still rated as ‘low risk of bias’ for both of these fields”. It’s also one of the studies that, when removed from Lawrie’s meta-analysis, resulted in a positive meta-analysis becoming negative. As far as the other, Niaee 2020: this newer meta-analysis rates this study as having a high risk of bias—appropriately so, in my opinion.
This meta-analysis concludes:
In conclusion, in comparison to SOC or placebo, IVM did not reduce all-cause mortality, length of stay, respiratory viral clearance, adverse events and serious adverse events in RCTs of patients with mild to moderate COVID-19. We did not find data about IVM effects on clinical improvement and need for mechanical ventilation. Additional ongoing RCTs should be completed in order to update our analyses. In the meanwhile, IVM is not a viable option to treat COVID-19 patients, and only should be used within clinical trials context.
Let’s just say that, based on its methodology and more appropriate assessment of risk of bias, I think that this meta-analysis is more likely to be correct than Lawrie’s.
Then, on Friday, yet another study showed up in the literature. The study describes IVERCOR-COVID19, a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. It’s a decent-sized randomized controlled study, 501 patients, in which ivermectin was tested for its ability to prevent hospitalization in patients diagnosed with COVID-19. Patients were randomized to either ivermectin (N = 250) or placebo (N = 251) arms in a staggered dose, according to the patient’s weight, for 2 days. The trial was carried out from August 19, 2020 and February 22, 2021 in the province of Corrientes, Argentina by the Ministry of Public Health of the Province of Corrientes in coordination with the Corrientes Institute of Cardiology “Juana F. Cabral”. Patients over 18 years of age residing in the province at the time of diagnosis of COVID-19 by PCR for SARS-CoV-2 within the last 48 hours before enrollment were eligible. Exclusion criteria included current home oxygen use or hospitalization at the time of diagnosis; history of COVID-19 hospitalization; breastfeeding women; known allergy to ivermectin; presence of mal-absorptive syndrome; presence of any other concomitant acute infectious disease; known history of liver disease; need for dialysis; concomitant use of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine; or use of ivermectin up to seven days before randomization.
And the results? Nada. Zilch. Bupkis:
In the IVERCORCOVID19 trial, in patients with a positive COVID-19 nasal swab by RT-PCR technique in the last 48 h, ivermectin in a staggered dose according to the patient’s weight for 2 days had no significant effect on preventing hospitalization of patients with COVID-19. No significant differences were observed in secondary outcomes such as the time elapsed from study enrollment to hospitalization in those who required it. Additionally, no significant differences were observed in the use of invasive mechanical ventilatory support, the requirement for dialysis, negative nasal swabs at 3 and 12 days after study enrollment, or in all-cause mortality. Patients who received ivermectin required invasive mechanical ventilatory support earlier. The use of ivermectin was not associated with increased adverse events.
There was no significant difference in mortality, although the trial was not powered to find a difference in this endpoint, and the increased need for mechanical ventilatory support in the ivermectin group could easily have been due to random chance because the total number of patients who required it in the study was small.
Is this study the be-all and end-all? Of course not. It had a lower rate of hospitalizations and was—shall we say?—overly optimistic in its power calculations, assuming a high rate of efficacy for ivermectin, with an odds ratio of 0.3 to 0.5, which translates into an estimated 50-70% reduction in hospitalization, which means that this trial doesn’t rule out a lower level of efficacy for ivermectin. This study is, however, yet another in the drip-drip-drip of negative studies of ivermectin that is becoming very reminiscent of the drip-drip-drip of negative studies for hydroxychloroquine a year ago.
None of this stops Tess Lawrie from going into conspiracy theories about the “suppression” of ivermectin.
Tess Lawrie the conspiracy theorist
The first observation I feel the need to make about Tess Lawrie’s interview is a simple one. She promotes herself as a “respectable” researcher whose work on ivermectin is being scorned due to the nefarious machinations of big pharma and the ideological blindness of other physicians, which leads me to a word of advice. The last thing a “respectable researcher” wants to do is to be featured by Joe Mercola or to be interviewed on a podcast like Speaking Naturally. Why? It’s the official podcast of the Alliance for Natural Health, a pro-quackery group that’s rabidly antivaccine. Let’s just say that ANH-USA is not just antivaccine, but promotes cancer quackery (such as Stanislaw Burzynski’s antineoplastons), among other pseudoscience. Particularly amusing to me has been the ANH-USA’s ranting against state medical boards that actually try to rein in quacks. Less amusing is ANH-USA’s activity promoting laws to make it easier for quacks to practice and advertise their quackery, as well as so-called “right-to-try” laws. Again, this is not the sort of group you want to appear with if you want any serious scientist or academic physician to take you and your work seriously. The ANH-USA is really just one step above Mike Adams or Alex Jones—maybe.
Here’s the podcast:
(I love the takeoff on the e.r. opening credits to try to make it seem as though there is medical authority to this podcast. Nice touch, if you’re a quack.)
Let’s look at Mercola’s bullet points:
    • While the list of crimes committed by authorities during the COVID-19 pandemic is a long one, perhaps the biggest crime of all is the purposeful suppression of safe and effective treatments, including ivermectin. This appears to have been done to protect the COVID “vaccine” program
    • The COVID shots were brought to market under emergency use authorization (EUA), which can only be obtained if there are no other safe and effective alternatives available
    • Several systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies looked at ivermectin for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 infection. A rapid review performed on behalf of the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) in the U.S., January 3, 2021, found the drug “probably reduces deaths by an average 83% compared to no ivermectin treatment”
    • According to a more recent review and meta-analysis, ivermectin, when used preventatively, reduced COVID-19 infection by an average 86%
    • Another recent scientific review concluded ivermectin produces large statistically significant reductions in mortality, time to clinical recovery, and time to viral clearance
See what I mean? The idea is the same idea that I heard incessantly over a year ago about hydroxychloroquine, namely that the evidence for the overwhelming efficacy of HCQ against COVID-19 is being “suppressed” in order to protect the profits of big pharma, which at the time was developing new antivirals and, of course, the COVID-19 vaccines, the latter of which have been enormously effective and successful since the release of the first two vaccines under an emergency use approval (EUA) in December 2020.
To set the stage, Mercola goes on and on about how a “gold standard review” of the evidence for ivermectin supports its use, reporting a 62% reduction in mortality due to the coronavirus associated with use of the drug. Again, that meta-analysis shows nothing of the sort, because of the principle of “garbage in, garbage out.” In fact, the highest quality clinical trials thus far all show no detectable effect from ivermectin on COVID-19 hospitalizations or mortality. He then pivots to how the World Health Organization is supposedly “suppressing” ivermectin.
Which brings us to the conspiracy theory:
But why? Why don’t they want people to feel confident that there’s treatment out there and that COVID-19 is not the death sentence they’ve been led to believe it is? The short answer is because ivermectin threatens the vaccine program. As explained by Andrew Bannister in a May 12, 2021, Biz News article:15
What if there was a cheap drug, so old its patent had expired, so safe that it’s on the WHO’s lists of Essential and Children’s Medicines, and used in mass drug administration rollouts?
What if it can be taken at home with the first signs COVID symptoms, given to those in close contact, and significantly reduce COVID disease progression and cases, and far fewer few people would need hospitalization?
The international vaccine rollout under Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) would legally have to be halted. For an EUA to be legal, ‘there must be no adequate, approved and available alternative to the candidate product for diagnosing, preventing or treating the disease or condition.
The vaccines would only become legal once they passed level 4 trials and that certainly won’t happen in 2021 … The vaccine rollout, outside of trials, would become illegal.
The vaccine manufactures, having spent hundreds of million dollars developing and testing vaccines during a pandemic, would not see the $100bn they were expecting in 2021 … Allowing any existing drug, at this time, well into stage 3 trials, to challenge the legality of the EUA of vaccines, is not going to happen easily.
Why, then, would the WHO “suppress” this suppose miracle cure for COVID-19? I bet you can guess where this is going. Enter Bill Gates!
Because, of course Bill Gates is involved:
The WHO’s rejection of ivermectin only makes sense if a) you take into account the EUA requirements; and b) remember that the WHO receives a significant portion of its funding from private vaccine interests.
The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is the second largest funder of the WHO after the United States, and The GAVI Alliance, also owned by Gates, is the fourth largest donor. The GAVI Alliance exists solely to promote and profit from vaccines, and for several years, the WHO director-general, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, served on the GAVI board of directors.16
And, of course, according to Joe Mercola Merck is in on it, because its patent on ivermectin expired 25 years ago and it no longer makes much money off of the drug, although it did receive a $356 million contract from the US government to develop an antiviral treatment for COVID-19.
Besides quoting the bad meta-analysis by the BIRD Group, Mercola cites the FLCCC and its bad science. If you’ve been reading this blog more than a year and a half, ask yourself if this passage sounds familiar to you:
The FLCCC also points out that ivermectin distribution campaigns have resulted in “rapid population-wide decreases in morbidity and mortality,” which indicate that ivermectin is “effective in all phases of COVID-19.” For example, in Brazil, three regions distributed ivermectin to its residents, while at least six others did not. The difference in average weekly deaths is stark.
In Santa Catarina, average weekly deaths declined by 36% after two weeks of ivermectin distribution, whereas two neighboring regions in the South saw declines of just 3% and 5%. Amapa in the North saw a 75% decline, while the Amazonas had a 42% decline and Para saw an increase of 13%.
You might recall that this is exactly the same sort of argument that was made for the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine a year ago. Comparing the rates of COVID-19 deaths in various countries based on their use of hydroxychloroquine was risibly bad science then, and comparing the rates of COVID-19 deaths in various regions in Brazil based on their use of ivermectin now is equally risibly bad science now. Funny how the FLCCC doesn’t mention India. In May, ivermectin was being offered to every citizen of India as the pandemic was killing thousands of people a day in that country. This somehow lead to bizarre claims that ivermectin was “crushing” COVID-19 in India, claims based on highly dubious “analyses” supposedly correlating ivermectin use with decreased numbers of deaths in various regions of India. Ultimately, the Indian health ministry ditched ivermectin as a recommended treatment earlier this month because—surprise, surprise!—it could find no evidence that ivermectin was working. No wonder the FLCCC didn’t mention India.
Tess Lawrie echoes FLCCC conspiracy theories
At this point, it is important to point out that the FLCCC doesn’t just claim that ivermectin prevents and treats COVID-19. That’s not enough for them! No, the FLCCC goes beyond that, claiming that ivermectin also prevents the condition that’s becoming known as COVID long haul syndrome or “long COVID”. This is a syndrome that’s been reported in people who have recovered from COVID-19 but continue to have persistent symptoms for weeks or even months later that include fatigue, “brain fog”, persistent loss of taste or smell, persistent cough, shortness of breath, and other chronic problems. It’s estimated that somewhere between 10% and 33% of those who recover from COVID-19, even mild cases, can develop long haul symptoms.
Back to the FLCCC:
The FLCCC believes ivermectin may also be an important treatment adjunct for long-haul COVID syndrome. In their June 16, 2021, video update, the team reviewed the newly released I-RECOVER protocol.
Keep in mind that ivermectin is not to be used in isolation. Corticosteroids, for example, are often a crucial treatment component when organizing pneumonia-related lung damage is present. Vitamin C is also important to combat inflammation. Be sure to work with your doctor to identify the right combination of drugs and supplements for you.
Last but not least, as noted by Kory in this video, it’s really important to realize that long-haul syndrome is entirely preventable. The key is early treatment when you develop symptoms of COVID-19.
Of course, steroids, at least, are known to be effective in preventing the most severe lung damage from COVID-19. They’re no panacea, of course, but they work. The amusing thing is that dexamethasone, the steroid most widely used to treat severe COVID-19, is dirt cheap, having been off patent for a very long time. Although the FLCCC does include dexamethasone (or other corticosteroids) in its protocol, one wonders why the conspiracy theorists don’t spin conspiracy theories about dexamethasone being “suppressed” because it’s so cheap and pharma can’t make enough money selling it. Oh, that’s right! It’s because steroids aren’t being “suppressed”! That’s because, unlike the case for ivermectin, HCQ, and all the other vitamins and treatments other than steroids in the FLCCC’s various COVID-19 protocols, steroids have actually been shown scientifically to work. Funny that!
Now let’s revisit the video above of Tess Lawrie appearing on the podcast of the quackery-promoting group ANH-USA. I must admit that I nearly spit up my coffee laughing when she started out describing how she had formed a nonprofit company called Evidence-Based Medicine Consultancy, Ltd. to “accommodate this new work we’re doing around ivermectin and other COVID-related research,” but, more risibly, how her company is “completely independent and has “no conflicts of interest.” Seriously? As I mentioned last time, she founded an organization, the BIRD Group, whose purpose is to promote the use of ivermectin! That’s a pretty hefty conflict of interest in my books! That’s why I was totally unsurprised to see her immediately pivot to the same conspiracy theory that the FLCCC and Joe Mercola are promoting, namely that there’s no incentive for big pharma to research ivermectin because it’s so cheap, which is true but misleading in that it is the grain of truth in the conspiracy theory that undergirds the other claims, namely that the WHO, Bill Gates, Merck, big pharma, and the rest are “suppressing” ivermectin in order to protect the vaccine program and the massive profits that it can bring.
Lawrie even uses the same bad science that I described above when she touts how Peru used ivermectin last year and “greatly benefited from it” but that a new president took over and stopped its use leading to—you guessed it!—a resurgence of COVID-19:
Of course, some of the investigators from the meta-analysis I discussed earlier are based in Peru.
Be that as it may, it seemingly never occurs to Lawrie that there might be a number of other causes for such an apparent occurrence. In any event, if you’re using anecdotal evidence that confuses correlation with causation that’s as bad as what was used by astroturf groups that promoted HCQ a year ago (and are using the same bad arguments to promote ivermectin as well now), I really have to wonder how you managed to get a PhD.
Basically, Tess Lawrie is all-in on conspiracy theories. She even goes on and on about how the “mainstream media are colluding” to suppress ivermectin, because of course she does. And look at some of the imagery in the podcast:

I once argued that all science denial is a form of conspiracy theory. The FLCCC, BIRD Group, and Tess Lawrie illustrate a corollary of that principle, which is this: If you sense that conspiracy theories are being used to support a seemingly scientific argument, you should look deeper. Use of conspiracy theories to support an argument, are almost always a very good indication that what is being promoted is ideologically motivated bad science and/or pseudoscience. I see nothing in the FLCCC or BIRD Group that disabuses me of that rule of thumb. That goes double when the FLCCC claims that ivermectin works based on bad science, while claiming that doing a proper placebo-controlled randomized controlled clinical trial would be “unethical” because they already “know” that ivermectin works against COVID-19, spurning such trials because “people are dying.”
Unfortunately, conspiracy theories, once born, are almost impossible to kill.
The disinformation war to promote ivermectin has only just begun
I’m getting a definite feeling of, as Yogi Bera would put it, “déjà vu all over again.” What do I mean? Just as the evidence started strongly trending against hydroxychloroquine as a COVID-19 treatment a year ago, the evidence appears to be strongly trending against ivermectin as a COVID-19 treatment. Indeed, ivermectin seems less likely to be effective based on a simple observation, namely that the concentration required to achieve antiviral effects in cell culture are several times higher than what can be achieved in the bloodstream of human beings. Of course, it’s possible that there’s another mechanism not captured in cell culture by which ivermectin could exhibit antiviral effects, but there’s a general rule in drug development that relies on Bayesian analysis. Basically, if a drug can’t achieve an effective concentration in the bloodstream that matches the concentration needed in cell culture, that means it has a low prior probability of working in animals or humans. Combine a low prior probability from basic science with equivocal clinical trials, and you have a drug that almost certainly doesn’t work.
That hasn’t stopped the campaign to promote ivermectin, though. Just the other day, Anna Merlan published an article in Vice titled “The Ivermectin Advocates’ War Has Just Begun“. It’s a depressing read mainly for its contrast with hydroxychloroquine because, after clinical trials turned resoundingly negative for hydroxychloroquine, the more mainstream promoters of the drug backed off, leaving just the hard core conspiracy theorists still pushing it. (Indeed, not even the FLCCC promotes hydroxychloroquine.) Yet the promotion of ivermectin continues apace, using a narrative in which proponents of the drug are being “silenced,” much as antivaxxers now claim they are being “silenced.” (Unsurprisingly, many—but, in fairness, not all—ivermectin advocates are also antivaccine.)
Merlan starts with the story of Ivory Hecker, a former local TV reporter who was fired and accused her ex-employers of “muzzling her for not letting her cover Bitcoin and hydroxychloroquine”. Now, she’s all-in for ivermectin:
The coverage extended also to ivermectin, Hecker claimed, the anti-parasitic drug that several fringe doctors and less-fringe media personalities are claiming is a miracle preventative and cure for COVID-19. That claim has now led Hecker, post-firing, into the company of a new set of friends: the Front-Line Critical Care COVID-19 Alliance (FLCCC), a group of ivermectin-promoting doctors and their allies. On a weekly conference call, which was free and open to the public, Drs. Pierre Kory and Joseph Varon, two of the FLCCC’s founders, lightly interviewed Hecker and heavily implied that all three of them are under the same oppressive thumb of censorship, being silenced by the forces of media, Big Pharma, and their unnamed co-conspirators.
“I’ve left two jobs” in medicine, Kory said, shortly after Hecker declared her gratitude that she’s not in jail for her beliefs. “I was attacked and harassed by two different employers and I left.” What was happening to all of them, he said, was a signal of how oppressive the public sphere has become for people who speak out: “In a certain sense, I’d like to believe it’s gotten so absurd that we now have to pay attention and do something and fix it. This can’t go on.”
The conspiracy mongering includes claims that, because of government, medical, media, and (of course!) big tech’s “suppression” of discussions of how great ivermectin is for COVID-19, lots and lots of people have died unnecessarily. How many? Well…:
Ivermectin advocates believe themselves to be fighting against the forces of censorship to promote a suppressed cure for COVID-19. (Asked during a question and answer session how many people had been killed by social media censorship against ivermectin, Kory and Varon offered estimates in the six figures.) Despite the fact that the drug’s effectiveness at treating any kind of viral infection is far from clear, their holy war has taken on new vigor over the past several weeks, as prominent members of the so-called “Intellectual Dark Web” have begun advocating for the drug—and have found themselves running afoul of policies meant to prevent platforms being used for the advocacy of unproven medical claims.
Even worse, the conspiracy theories and claims of “suppression” are money-makers:
Their claims of suppression are also making ivermectin’s biggest promoters ever more famous. Kory announced this week that he’ll be following up on his appearance on Joe Rogan’s podcast, where he preached the gospel of ivermectin to millions, with an appearance on Dr. Drew. But on their weekly Zoom call, Varon and Kory agreed with Hecker, the fired reporter they were interviewing, that something truly sinister was taking place. Kory hinted at a new theory that may begin to take shape in the ivermectin sphere, asserting that something called the “Trusted News Initiative” may be to blame for ivermectin’s lukewarm reputation in the mainstream media.
“A large part of the major mass media have made a decision that they’ll only allow discussion on what’s determined to be correct and efficacious by the WHO and the NIH,” he said. That decision seemed be linked, he implied, to the Trusted News Initiative, an project begun in 2019 involving a group of news organizations trying to agree on new standards and technologies to combat disinformation, most recently around elections and vaccines, and to provide continuing education resources to help journalists learn how to identify things like manipulated images.
In other words, predictably, the conspiracy theory is…evolving. It’s becoming wider, in order to become a broader conspiracy theory that portrays efforts by journalists and the mass media to combat disinformation and help journalists identify manipulated images and real “fake news” (news that is fake, compared to real news that politicians call “fake news” because it’s a threat) as a threat to whatever the conspiracy theorists believe in.
Ivermectin as a “cure” (or at least a highly effective treatment) for COVID-19 is basically science denial. It is still possible that science will show ivermectin to be effective against COVID-19, but from my perspective that outcome is looking less and less likely. Thus, not surprisingly, the promotion of ivermectin requires denying the inconvenient science, with all the techniques of denial used by denialists ranging from creationists, to antivaxxers, to cancer quacks, to climate science deniers being marshaled against disconfirming science. Because all science denial includes a conspiracy theory, we should therefore not be surprised that ivermectin advocates have not only embraced conspiracy theories about the “suppression” of their favored COVID-19 cure, but have gone beyond that to go even bigger on the conspiracy mongering to portray any effort to combat disinformation as a grand conspiracy to suppress The Truth about…everything.

Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 4: Bret Weinstein misrepresents meta-analyses
Evolutionary biologist turned podcaster Bret Weinstein has promoted the anthelmintic drug ivermectin as a highly effective treatment for COVID-19 based on a massive misunderstanding of a meta-analysis. Here, we correct this misunderstanding and explain why ivermectin is unlikely to be effective against COVID-19.
William Paolo on August 2, 2021
Link

[Editor’s note: Dr. Gorski is on vacation this week (for the first time since the pandemic started, he’s actually heading to the lake for a few days). Fortunately, we have a guest post by William F. Paolo, MD, associate professor of emergency medicine and public health and preventative medicine at SUNY Upstate, which continues our Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine series. This time, Dr. Paolo directly addresses the misinformation about ivermectin promoted by evolutionary biologist and podcaster Bret Weinstein, in particular, his misrepresentation and misunderstanding of meta-analyses.]
The ongoing COVID-19 epidemic has resulted in a large group of non-medical or public-health related experts with the surprising confidence to publicly express definitive opinions on topics clearly outside of their expertise. The most striking example of this has come from the evolutionary biologist Dr. Bret Weinstein, who has turned his elevation in the public eye from issues pertaining to culture to one regarding the assessment of science. This has, most toxically, manifest in sweeping and non-empirical claims regarding the role of ivermectin in the treatment and prophylaxis of the SARS-Cov-2 related disease COVID-19.
What Bret Weinstein claims
The claims of Dr. Weinstein in terms of the efficacy of ivermectin for SARS-Cov-2, if true, would render it one of the most astonishingly effective xenobiotics in the history of modern medicine. The claims are variable and, mostly, cunningly phrased as exploratory questioning, but the following have been either stated by Dr. Weinstein or endorsed by guests on his podcast. Ivermectin “shows itself to be about 86 percent effective at preventing contraction of Covid“. Ivermectin could be a “safe and effective medicine that prevented 85% of COVID cases and did not appear to select for different strains“.
As these assertions and “questions” have made their way into multiple different podcasts and have been picked up in the mainstream press, the alleged “suppression” of this information has also become a popular theory – one which seemingly demonstrates a volitional and diffuse campaign to suppress this knowledge. Finally, as ever, one cannot help but note the simultaneous appearance of numerous unfounded mRNA vaccine assertions based on anecdote or discredited theories coinciding with the assertions about the wonders of ivermectin. The evidence for the efficacy and safety of the mRNA vaccines is astounding whereas the evidence that ivermectin may benefit is small and teeming with methodological and study design flaws. One can’t help but wonder how an individual, with any history of training in scientific reasoning, can look so credulously at the small and poorly designed ivermectin studies and find a miracle drug while simultaneously dismissing the well-designed large trials and ongoing safety monitoring that has given us the success of the mRNA COVID vaccines.
To assess the reliability of these claims it is imperative to critically appraise the same literature Dr. Weinstein is citing. Multiple small studies comprise our knowledge and all are compiled into two recent meta-analyses, Bryant et al. and Hill et al., all of which are of low quality and one, Hill et al., has been recognized by some experts as being of “critically low quality“. It is hard not to note that this is similar to what was advocates did arguing for the efficacy of hydroxychloroquine over a year ago, only taken to a much greater extreme. As you will see, on this score too, ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine.
Misunderstanding meta-analyses
One of the more bizarre claims made by Dr. Weinstein is that “…large RCTs amplify systematic error in addition to signal, whereas meta-analysis amplifies signal, and corrects for error“. To be as generous as possible – my presumption is that this is a pithy way of attempting to make the following assertion:
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs), whether they are large or small, are singular experiments and, though they are understood to be the experimental gold standard to determine causation, are only as good as their methodology. If a large RCT has errors in its design all the results are fruits of the poisonous tree and are a methodological house of cards that can make erroneous results seem more or less likely. On the other hand, meta-analyses, as they are the combination of multiple studies into a singular result to find the larger point estimated effect of smaller RCTs, will mitigate for the errors of singular RCTs by merging the world’s available literature into one pooled result. In this way the combination of multiple studies overcomes the biasing effects of smaller or poorly done studies and the true “signal” (that which is the actual real-world result) becomes more apparent in the summated result.
Though this sounds intuitively true, it is entirely without an understanding of the assessment and critical appraisal of meta-analysis, and philosophical underpinnings of role of its role within the hierarchy of evidence.
Limitations and role of meta-analyses
A meta-analysis is a subcomponent of a systematic review in which it is held that multiple studies addressing a single topic can be combined into a composite point estimate (and confidence bounds) to determine the pooled results of multiple smaller studies. Methodologically the review treats individual experimental studies as its participants, defining inclusion and exclusion criteria based upon the question under investigation and the ability of the discovered studies to bring the question to a parsimonious resolution. After review, the studies are analyzed for bias and methodological soundness, weighted, and analyzed separately and/or together to develop a result that represents the newly derived estimate of effect based upon the combined included studies.
The soundness of a systemic review is determined by its internal methodology and the assessment of the included studies and is not intrinsic to the included studies themselves. However, the summated results of the review are in fact predicated on the validity and reliability of each included study and cannot be analyzed independent of the cogency of the studies underpinning its new result. In other words, it is decidedly not true that one can mitigate for studies with poor methodology by combining them with more poor studies despite the assertion of Dr. Weinstein above. As with the results of a computer program algorithm, a maxim long understood and repeated by computer programmers, “Garbage In, Garbage Out” (often abbreviated GIGO) applies. Or, as SBM editor Dr. Gorski likes to put it on Twitter:
This us almost exactly wrong. Meta-analyses are like computer programs: Garbage in, garbage out. You can't turn a bunch of turds into gold through meta-analysis, which is what #ivermectin advocates have tried to do. https://t.co/lbsVy76MrR
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) July 16, 2021
Which he elaborated on here:
Sure. They seem to think that smoothing out randomness in studies that don't have a high degree of bias is the same thing as eliminating bias. Again, garbage in, garbage out. Meta-analysis can't magically turn a bunch of turds into a gold ingot.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) July 29, 2021
Systematic reviews can be well or poorly done, like any other scientific endeavor, and are not, by virtue of merely being of a kind, automatically understood to be high-level evidence. They are, however, recognized in the hierarchy of evidence as the apex of the EBM pyramid because science relies on experimental reproducibility and a study with similar results done multiple times is much more powerful than a single RCT done once. However, this does not mean that a systematic review and/or a meta-analysis in and of itself, independent of the component studies or the assessment of experts, is automatically high-level evidence.
That data can be combined to find a single result is obvious, that it is scientifically sound or reliable to do so is the question posed when critically apprising a performed review. That said, it is simply not true that the plural of garbage is evidence, to put it less sarcastically than Dr. Gorski. Each individual meta-analysis is only as good as the studies that underpin it, without being able to supersede its components. The combination of multiple bad studies does not amplify signal and if it indeed does, there is no reason to trust the reliability of that signal, given the unreliability of the studies that comprise the finding. Garbage in still equals garbage out.
Limitations of included studies
The multiple studies that comprise the ivermectin literature are not of high enough quality evidence to make definitive recommendations. There are numerous methodological flaws in each component study that do not cancel themselves out simply by aggregating with one another. Not analyzed are the in-vitro studies that demonstrate the biological plausibility of ivermectin’s role in mitigating SARS-Cov-2 infection. Though mechanistic and in-vitro studies are helpful they are far from definitive in terms of relevant patient-oriented-outcomes (reductions in infections, morbidity, and mortality) and many plausible therapeutics fail to demonstrate efficacy when trialed in human subjects.
In terms of prophylaxis there are numerous low quality studies that comprise the world’s literature with the net result suggesting a potential non-definitive benefit of ivermectin. However, the trials all suffer from numerous methodological flaws such as an observational study based upon potential administration of ivermectin without controlling for dose, testing, other therapeutic agents, demographics, or epidemiological data, a case controlled trial that did not control for dosage, usage, or other concomitant prophylactic agents, or the largest contributor to the positive body of evidence that was retracted for plagiarism and ethical violations. It is simply false to assert that the combination of these poor studies is greater and independent from its component parts. Though it may be true that ivermectin is a safe and effective prophylaxis the accumulation of low-quality studies does not change that assertion to being more likely true than its negation. To utilize these studies as the foundation for making the assertion that it is true, or even likely, that ivermectin offers an 86% rate in reducing the contraction of SARS-Cov-2, is spurious and is not in keeping with a rationally critical assessment of the body of evidence.
The studies that pertain to the ability for ivermectin to prevent mortality in SARS-Cov-2 suffer from similar limitations. They include a study that utilizes a non-blinded convenience sample without reliable randomization, a study in which ivermectin patients also received higher doses of steroids which reduced its ability study to control for the effects of ivermectin in isolation, a prospective trial of 24 patients with no patient-oriented-outcomes, and, importantly, a well designed randomized controlled trial that did not find ivermectin to be efficacious. Unsurprisingly, as with prophylaxis, the evidence does not support a definitive positive pronouncement on the effects of ivermectin and certainly does not approach the level of evidence to be able to state confidentially what effects (if any) it has – let alone the assertion of 99% efficacy. Finally, other than the theoretical assertion that ivermectin does not induce resistance, at this time there is no evidence with the medical literature to suggest this is true.
A sound scientific mind would assess the evidence, critically appraise the studies involved, and conclude that there is an interesting hypothesis to be explored, but it is impossible to make definitive statements as to the efficacy of ivermectin as a prophylaxis or treatment until larger, better studies are done. Oddly, this is exactly what has been done without the need to posit a non-parsimonious distributed suppression theory.
Statistical heterogeneity
This is a forest plot, a type of graphical display of estimated results from the studies in a meta-analysis, along with the overall results, taken from a recent meta-analysis by Bryant et al. This particular meta-analysis was widely touted by ivermectin advocates, including Bret Weinstein, despite its rather glaring flaws (discussed previously on SBM, along with the conspiracy theories promoted by some of its authors, in particular Tess Lawrie):
Another component not discussed by Dr. Weinstein when giving full uncritical scientific credence to the ivermectin literature, and one that undermines his point that meta-analysis the de facto gold standard information, is statistical heterogeneity. It is also a component not discussed in previous SBM posts on this meta-analysis, which makes this a good time to bring it up. When analyzing the results of a meta-analysis it is imperative to focus on the degree of statistical heterogeneity to determine if the resultant point estimate of the compiled studies are, in fact, similar enough to be combined into a singular parsimonious estimate of effect. Theoretically, multiple smaller studies can be pooled and analyzed as a singular body of evidence if the component studies are of analogous design and methodology (allocation concealment, randomization, intention to treat analysis etc.) or rejected if this is not the case. It is required that the included studies be the same in terms of design, inclusion and exclusion criteria, demographics, equivalent doses of an intervention, outcomes, and a myriad of other factors to comfortably combine said studies into a unitary body of evidence. Concordant with this is the expectation that if the included studies of a meta-analysis are of equal kind that experimentally derived results, taken under similar conditions, should roughly approximate one another. In other words, all things being equal, the same exact experiment done in multiple places by different people should roughly find the same results if the studies are in fact similar enough to be analyzed as one.
The test to determine the heterogeneity, or the difference of the experimental results, is denoted in the arrow from the Forest plot presented above. There are several different ways to measure the heterogeneity of data but the most accessible, and understandable, measurement, is the I2 statistic that assesses the percentage of variance that is owing to heterogeneity. In general, I2is measuring the degree of variance attributable to heterogeneity with higher numbers representing more heterogeneity and lower numbers repressing a more homogenous data set. Opinions vary on the optimal percentages to categorize the impact of statistical heterogeneity but, in general, the following rules of thumb apply when determining impact of heterogeneity on the meta-analysis in question:
    • 0% to 40%: might not be important
    • 30% to 60%: may represent moderate heterogeneity
    • 50% to 90%: may represent substantial heterogeneity
    • 75% to 100%: considerable heterogeneity
The I2 calculated for this dataset is 62%, indicating a substantial risk that the summated result provided in the “total” row derives from multiple studies that did not find the same thing and therefore is not easily reducible to a singular reliable summated estimated effect. This is an unsurprising result given the variable methodologies and definitions of the included and analyzed studies. It is possible to combine these studies and produce a single result however the combination of multiple studies does not therefore, invariably, result in reliable data.
By way of example, it would be possible to combine multiple studies looking at aspirin for the prevention of death in myocardial infarctions into a single result and claim new knowledge under the guise of empiricism and the patina of science. However, if said studies had variable definitions of myocardial infarction, different means of follow-up, differing measures of outcomes of interest, and variable dosing regimens of aspirin, the singular discovered data point is no more a real-world reflection of the actual efficacy of aspirin than were the individual studies on their own. The combination of studies that are not the same does not get us closer to the question we are asking as the amalgamation of said studies does not, in and of itself, mitigate for the need for investigational data to be consistent with one another owing to similar experimental parameters. Such is the case with both ivermectin meta-analyses, even in their initial form with the subsequently retracted study intact, owing to the variability of the small studies included in the analysis.
Conclusions
There is simply not enough evidence, at this point, to support the efficacy of ivermectin as a novel therapeutic for SARS-Cov-2 infection and certainly zero evidence for the striking claims made by Dr. Weinstein. The low-quality studies that comprise the scientific literature demonstrate that the hypothesis that ivermectin is associated with a reduction in mortality and/or transmission may be true, but the negation of this hypothesis, on a Bayesian analysis of in vitro data and the current total body of evidence, is even more likely. A mundane reading of the evidence implies, like many therapeutics before, that there is not enough evidence in either direction suggesting the need for well-done randomized controlled trials. Many other promising therapeutics have gone through similar iterations in terms of early promise in small studies followed by confirmation or rejection in larger well-designed trials. The distinction, in the case of ivermectin, is its attachment to an individual and a movement amplified via conspiratorial reasoning and anti-vaccine sentiment.
A scientific mind, at its best, modifies hypotheses considering empirical evidence derived from experimentation or observation and attempts to fit hypotheses to the data derived. Unscientific reasoning begins with an assumed conclusion and manipulates existing and future data to fit the foregone conclusion. This sort of thinking is known as backwards reasoning and, in its most extreme, produces a cognitive bias known as anchoring in which an individual will use a particular “anchored” conclusion to fit all subsequent data. There seems to be little in the critical appraisal of the evidence or in the subsequent retraction of the largest positive study to alter Dr. Weinstein’s foundational assumption that ivermectin is an effective therapeutic for SARS-CoV-2 infection, demonstrating his unscientific approach to the assessment of evidence.
The striking thing to note, in the case of Dr. Weinstein, is how his reasoning shifts depending on whether ivermectin is being discussed or the mRNA COVID vaccines. Large, well-conducted mRNA trials are dismissed out of hand whereas anecdotes or wild speculation and false claims are elevated to the level of meaningful data. The role of systematic reviews and meta-analysis are overstated and misunderstood whereas false claims by misleading “experts” are passed off as evidence contradicting his earlier assertions regarding evidentiary hierarchies. In a holistic view it appears, in terms of his understanding of ivermectin, Dr. Weinstein either doesn’t know, doesn’t care, or doesn’t understand what the evidence shows – I’m not certain which is the preferred option.
Ivermectin advocates (many of whom, albeit not all, advocated hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 this time last year) have apparently learned from the experience of seeing one “miracle drug” for COVID-19 fail as more randomized clinical trials showed no evidence of efficacy. Although it is possible (albeit unlikely) that well-designed randomized clinical trials will show that ivermectin has efficacy against COVID-19, the very same thing appears happening now, over a year later, for ivermectin. Meanwhile, ivermectin advocates like Bret Weinstein are still trying to portray it as a wonder drug based on a badly flawed understanding of what meta-analysis can and cannot do.

Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 5: The Nobel Prize gambit
Ivermectin continues to be the new hydroxychloroquine, an unproven repurposed drug promoted to treat COVID-19. Now the advocates are pointing to the history of the drug’s developers being awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine, as though that has anything to do with its effectiveness against COVID-19.
David Gorski on August 9, 2021
Link

As regular readers know, I was on vacation last week. In my absence, guest blogger Dr. William Paolo provided an excellent fourth installment for our “Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine” series, in which he discusses the epic misunderstanding of the role and conduct of meta-analyses in the medical literature, a misunderstanding that (among other misunderstandings) has led Bret Weinstein to proclaim ivermectin as, in essence, a miracle cure for COVID-19. A few weeks earlier, I had noted Weinstein’s conspiracy mongering over ivermectin, as well as that of others. Little did I suspect as my vacation wound down and I contemplated what I would write for my first post after returning that I’d be adding “take 5” to our “Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine” series. It came in the form of a Tweet by Peter Kory, who has been featured in previous installments:
Powerfully compelling review… published by a group of absolute Giants in Medicine (not ⁦@Covid19Critical⁩ 😀). Crickets from every science desk of every major news outlet across the US… again. https://t.co/58AN67fcf6
— Pierre Kory, MD MPA (@PierreKory) August 7, 2021
Of course, there are few better topics to ease me back into the groove of blogging after over a week away, so I figured: What the heck?
Dr. Pierre Kory, as you might recall, has featured prominently in past installments of this series as one of the most prominent advocates promoting ivermectin as a miracle cure for COVID-19. Indeed, he is president of the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) and has testified before Congress. During that testimony, Dr. Kory claimed that ivermectin, used with other medicines such as vitamin C, zinc, and melatonin, could “save hundreds of thousands of people”, and cited more than 20 studies.
As I’ve discussed before, ivermectin is an anti-helminthic drug used as a dewormer in veterinary medicine and to treat parasitic diseases in humans, including internal nematode infections such as Onchocerciasis, Strongyloidiasis, Ascariasis, cutaneous larva migrans, filariases, Gnathostomiasis and Trichuriasis, as well as for oral treatment of ectoparasitic infections, such as Pediculosis (lice infestation) and scabies (mite infestation). However, as I’ve also discussed before (and will again in this post), there is no good evidence that ivermectin is effective against COVID-19, although there are low quality studies and, yes, meta-analyses. Worse still for ivermectin as a COVID-19 treatment, the prior plausibility on the basis of basic science is low, because the in vitro cell culture studies that showed activity against SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, required a much higher concentration of ivermectin than is achievable in the blood with standard (or even high) doses of the drug. So, as I have said repeatedly, it’s possible that ivermectin might have activity against COVID-19 in humans, but not very likely and, even if it does, it’s even less likely that it will be as efficacious as is being claimed.
My first reaction was: So somebody published a review. My second reaction was to see the sorts of things being posted on social media about it. As you might imagine, there was a lot of conspiracy mongering:
Why the silence from the majority of the medical community, & media? Is it because there’s no wealth to be gained from the repurposing of this low cost treatment? https://t.co/6JyymsEU01
— JBales (@JBales20) August 7, 2021
There is not much worse than the “health experts” that somehow lead this country completely ignoring the science behind therapeutics https://t.co/gYPgk3i0iU
— Stephen Smith (@smsmith18) August 7, 2021
The best scientists among the best scientists writing about ivermectin.https://t.co/hSrcPwdoOl
— Filipe Rafaeli (@filipe_rafaeli) August 5, 2021
Of course, I’m partial to this one:
Siri, show me the single worst Scientific Manuscript Title ever 😳😬🙄😵🤯🥇
👇
“Ivermectin: a multifaceted drug of Nobel prize-honored distinction with indicated efficacy against a new global scourge, COVID-19” https://t.co/PJF4HkHsQO
— Per Damkier (@Per_Damkier) August 7, 2021
Yes, I must admit that I’m hard pressed to remember ever having seen a title of an ostensibly scientific article so obviously click-baity. Then there are the authors. Whenever considering an article, it is always useful to consider the source, and the authors of this review are…quite something.
The authors
The review is as bad as you might imagine, given certain members of its author list. What do I mean? Let’s just say that at least one of the authors should be familiar to regular readers of this blog: Peter McCullough.
I first encountered Dr. Peter McCullough in May, when he was promoting an imminent “Holocaust” due to COVID-19 vaccines. At the time, he was being billed by the likes of Joe Mercola and Mike Adams as “doctor with the most citations in the National Library of Medicine on these topics” (i.e., COVID-19). He’s also a consultant cardiologist and Vice Chief of Medicine at Baylor University Medical Center and Principal Faculty in internal medicine for the Texas A & M University Health Sciences Center who’s been making the rounds on the COVID-19 conspiracy circuit. By June, I encountered him promoting the idea that COVID-19 vaccines are designed for “global depopulation“. By July, I noted “holistic cardiologist” Dr. Joel Kahn citing Dr. McCullough for the purposes of fear mongering about COVID-19 vaccines.
Thomas Borody is a real scientist from Australia, known for having developed antibiotic triple therapy for Helicobacter pylori infections that cause duodenal ulcers, after Robin Warren and Barry Marshall had described and then cultured spiral bacteria from the stomachs of patients with gastritis and gastric and duodenal ulcers. Unfortunately, like a fair number of formerly reputable scientists, he appears to have fallen down the ivermectin rabbit hole. as a search for his name quickly reveals, complete with a number of interviews in which he touts a triple therapy including ivermectin as a near-cure for COVID-19, some dating back to last summer. He is the closest thing to an absolute “Giant in Medicine” in the list.
David Scheim, I had never heard of before. However, a quick search of his name revealed that he has authored books claiming that the mafia killed John F. Kennedy, Jr. He does, however, list his affiliation as being a Commissioned Officer, US Public Health Service, Inactive Reserve, Blacksburg, VA. He has also been promoting ivermectin to treat COVID-19 since at least June of last year. I couldn’t find what “Inactive Reserve” means (maybe someone in the USPHS can explain), but there is a “Ready Reserve“, consisting of three main components: Selected Ready Reserve (SELRES), Individual ReadyReserve (IRR), and Retired Reserve. Then I found this article:
After 15 years as chief of NEI’s Management Information Systems Branch, Dr. David Scheim has retired. He will remain on “inactive duty” as a commissioned officer.
Scheim joined NEI in 1981 as chief of the computer support branch. NEI has been a wonderful place to work and a “privileged life of technology,” he says, because NEI management allowed him the opportunity to explore and work with state-of-the-art computer hardware and software. “Most of what I’ve done at NEI is database development,” he says.
Scheim was one of the pioneers of client-server database technology at NIH. He designed and implemented several such extramural computing systems, and demonstrated client-server concepts and methodologies at various intercampus forums. He also was a member of the NIH Architectural Management Group.
So Mr. Scheim is a retired computer database developer and hasn’t been an active member of the NIH or the US Public Health Service for 25 years.
Dr. Alessandro Santin, it turns out, is a gynecological oncologist and researcher at Yale. He, too, has apparently fallen into the ivermectin rabbit hole and has been touted by Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care (FLCCC):
Dr. Alessandro Santin, a practicing oncologist and scientist who runs a large laboratory at Yale, believes firmly that ivermectin could vastly cut suffering from COVID-19. @TrialsiteN #ivermectin https://t.co/09B8cCgzdC
— FLCCC Alliance (@Honest_Medicine) March 23, 2021
Most of his prominence in the ivermectin promotion circuit has come from Italy, however, for example, this article, having been quoted as saying, “Ivermectin can really be the game-changer against Covid 19. It works. Now the literature is going in one direction only.” (I can’t help but note that Dr. Santin is correct that the literature is going in one direction with respect to ivermectin. Unfortunately for him, it’s not the direction that in which he claims it’s going.)
Finally, Morimasa Yagisawa is a visiting professor at Kitasato University, Omura Satoshi Memorial Institute in Tokyo, and, yes, he believes that ivermectin is a very effective treatment for COVID-19, having given a statement to the World Health Organization declared that “ivermectin is almighty for prophylaxis, for treatment of early and late stage, and also for long COVID-19 (or) post-acute sequelae (of SARS-CoV-2).” Well, even given potential issues with English aside, that’s a rather…bold…statement.
So it’s clear that the authors of this review are very much fans of ivermectin. Of course, that doesn’t necessarily mean that they don’t make some good points (although I’d be more inclined to be less skeptical of them if they hadn’t included Dr. McCullough as a co-author, given just how utterly bonkers his ramblings about COVID-19 are). Still, after reading this post, it became clear to me that this was more propaganda than science, as you will see.
In praise of an unproven drug: The Nobel gambit
What amused me as I read the article is the whole framing of ivermectin. It’s clear that all the criticism of ivermectin proponents and the poor quality of evidence that they marshal to make their cases has gotten to them, particularly sarcastic cracks about using a horse or sheep dewormer to treat or prevent COVID-19. So the authors bend over backwards to discuss just how awesome a drug ivermectin is—for worms and parasites, that is:
The 2015 Nobel prize for the discovery of ivermectin (IVM) and an antimalarial treatment was the Nobel committee’s first award for treatment agents for infectious diseases since that of 1952 for streptomycin [1]. A macrocyclic lactone of multifaceted potency [2, 3], IVM as deployed worldwide since 1987 has made major inroads against two devastating tropical diseases, onchocerciasis and lymphatic filariasis [4]. During the year since IVM treatment of another global scourge, COVID-19, was first applied [5], results from more than 20 randomized clinical trials (RCTs) of IVM treatment of COVID-19 have been reported [2, 6, 7], with inpatient and outpatient treatments of COVID-19 conducted in 25 countries [2]. A likely biological mechanism has been indicated to be competitive binding with SARS-CoV-2 spike protein sites, as reviewed [8, 9].
I remember this well. The antimalarial treatment included in the 2015 Nobel Prize was artemisinin, which is a derivative of a compound used in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). As I noted at the time, just because artemisinin came from TCM did not mean that TCM’s precepts were scientifically valid, leading me to point out that artemisinin was a triumph of natural products pharmacology and the scientific method, not TCM. Scott Gavura, for his part, echoed this criticism, pointing out that the 2015 Nobel Prize in Medicine did not validate herbalism or naturopathy, while Steve Novella pointed out that artemisinin had low bioavailability and a short half-life, meaning that it had to be chemically modified (that pesky natural products pharmacology again!) before it could be an effective antimalarial drug.
Why do I mention this? Simple. TCM proponents are still pointing to artemisinin as “evidence” that TCM has a scientific basis, and the arguments in the ivermectin review article reminds me of the same tactic. Basically, the authors are pointing out how awesome ivermectin is as a drug to treat various parasites and worms—so awesome that its developers shared a Nobel Prize—and using that glow to argue that the drug is also highly effective against SARS-CoV-2 infections, even though antiviral activity is a much different thing than activity against parasites. In fairness, ivermectin is a pretty awesome drug for worms and parasites, as this pre-pandemic review from 2011 points out:
There are few drugs that can seriously lay claim to the title of ‘Wonder drug’, penicillin and aspirin being two that have perhaps had greatest beneficial impact on the health and wellbeing of Mankind. But ivermectin can also be considered alongside those worthy contenders, based on its versatility, safety and the beneficial impact that it has had, and continues to have, worldwide—especially on hundreds of millions of the world’s poorest people. Several extensive reports, including reviews authored by us, have been published detailing the events behind the discovery, development and commercialization of the avermectins and ivermectin (22,23-dihydroavermectin B), as well as the donation of ivermectin and its use in combating Onchocerciasis and lymphatic filariasis.1–6) However, none have concentrated in detail on the interacting sequence of events involved in the passage of the drug into human use.
And the effects of ivermectin on human health have been spectacular:
Ivermectin proved to be even more of a ‘Wonder drug’ in human health, improving the nutrition, general health and wellbeing of billions of people worldwide ever since it was first used to treat Onchocerciasis in humans in 1988. It proved ideal in many ways, being highly effective and broad-spectrum, safe, well tolerated and could be easily administered (a single, annual oral dose). It is used to treat a variety of internal nematode infections, including Onchocerciasis, Strongyloidiasis, Ascariasis, cutaneous larva migrans, filariases, Gnathostomiasis and Trichuriasis, as well as for oral treatment of ectoparasitic infections, such as Pediculosis (lice infestation) and scabies (mite infestation).14) Ivermectin is the essential mainstay of two global disease elimination campaigns that should soon rid the world of two of its most disfiguring and devastating diseases, Onchocerciasis and Lymphatic filariasis, which blight the lives of billions of the poor and disadvantaged throughout the tropics. It is likely that, throughout the next decade, well over 200 million people will be taking the drug annually or semi-annually, via innovative globally-coordinated Mass Drug Administration (MDA) programmes. Indeed, the discovery, development and deployment of ivermectin, produced by an unprecedented partnership between the Private Sector pharmaceutical multinational Merck & Co. Inc., and the Public Sector Kitasato Institute in Tokyo, aided by an extraordinary coalition of multidisciplinary international partners and disease-affected communities, has been recognized by many experts and observers as one of the greatest medical accomplishments of the 20th century.15) In referring to the international efforts to tackle Onchocerciasis in which ivermectin is now the sole control tool, the UNESCO World Science Report concluded, “the progress that has been made in combating the disease represents one of the most triumphant public health campaigns ever waged in the developing world”.16)
None of this, of course, means that ivermectin is effective against COVID-19, only that it has been spectacularly effective against certain scourges of the developing world, such as onchocerciasis, the second leading cause of blindness caused by an infectious disease, and lymphatic filariasis, also known as Elephantiasis for its ability to cause severe lymphedema and “elephant” limbs.
So, yes, ivermectin is a fantastic drug, both for animals and humans, when used for purposes supported by medical science.
But what about the evidence?
I knew there was something fishy about this review when I saw this in the abstract:
The RCT using the highest IVM dose achieved a 92% reduction in mortality vs. controls (400 total subjects, p<0.001).
That part about 400 subjects plus the 92% reduction in mortality is a narrative I had heard before. Hmmm, I wondered, Which study is that? It sure sounds familiar. It didn’t take me long to realize that this was a study out of Egypt (Elgazzar 2020) that (1) had never been peer reviewed and only been available on a preprint server; (2) as the largest randomized trial of ivermectin for COVID-19 drove seemingly “positive” results in meta-analyses even though the rest of the studies without it wound up producing a negative result; and (3) was very likely was fraudulent, complete with plagiarism and data that appeared to have been made up, leading to its retraction from a preprint server—surely the first time I had ever seen that before!
Let’s just put it this way, if the results from Elgazzar 2020 reflected ivermectin’s true activity, then, as Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz (whom I have quoted before) noted in his discussion of the potential fraud, ivermectin would be “most incredibly effective treatment ever to be discovered in modern medicine”. As a physician (opposed to an epidemiologist), I did quibble a bit with Meyerowitz-Katz (we do have treatments that are greater than 90% effective at eliminating the diseases or conditions that they treat, especially a number of vaccines), I couldn’t deny that he was certainly correct if one were to restrict this observation to antiviral drugs. If Elgazzar 2020 were accurate and generalizable, ivermectin would indeed be the most incredibly effective antiviral treatment ever to be discovered. I further noted that that result alone should have raised a number of red flags. Of course, it did among authors doing meta-analyses who were not ivermectin advocates from the BIRD Group or the FLCCC, which is why they excluded it from their analyses. Apparently it did not for the authors of this review, who accept its results as basically fact, stating again in the text:
The RCT that used the largest dose of IVM, 400 µg/kg on each of days 1-4 [22], had 2 vs. 24 deaths in the treatment vs. control groups (n=200 each), a 92% reduction in COVID-19 mortality (p<0.001).
In fairness, this review was just published, and the retractions and allegations of fraud occurred less than a month ago. Perhaps the paper was already too far along in the pipeline towards publication to note this. On the other hand, this is currently an online pre-proof of a journal article in press. There is, of course, time to correct it by removing any reference to Elgazzar 2020 and also pointing out that the meta-analyses from the BIRD Group and the FLCCC cited so prominently in this article become negative without it.
The authors make another point that seems reasonable but is definitely arguable:
Another objection that has been raised to the RCT evidence supporting IVM efficacy was that study populations were too small [31]. Yet it is well known in clinical trial design that highly effective drugs will establish statistically significant results with smaller sample sizes, with larger study populations required for minimally effective drugs [32]. For example, as noted above, the highest dose IVM treatment study for COVID-19 that tracked mortality had 2 vs. 24 deaths in treatment vs. control arms of 200 subjects each [22], with a z test p-value of 0.0006 [33]. But for a drug with a more modest RR of 75%, for example, the treatment and control arms would need more than 3,800 subjects each to yield the same statistical significance [33].
Yes and no. (Also, there they go citing Elgazzar 2020 again as if it weren’t at the least bogus and at the worst fraudulent!) In theory, yes, if an effect due to a drug on a given disease is really dramatic it should be detectable in smaller randomized clinical trials. However, smaller trials are also more subject to spurious results, particularly if they are not well-conducted. Why? Because they will have a small number of events, such that even a spurious event by random chance alone could affect their results far more than such an event could affect a larger trial. And, make no mistake, none of these trials were particularly well conducted, with many of them biased. There is one exception, though. Unsurprisingly, this trial produced a negative result for ivermectin, at least when used in adults with mild to moderate disease. In any event, I have a saying about meta-analyses:
Sure. They seem to think that smoothing out randomness in studies that don't have a high degree of bias is the same thing as eliminating bias. Again, garbage in, garbage out. Meta-analysis can't magically turn a bunch of turds into a gold ingot.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) July 29, 2021
That saying applies to every meta-analysis thus far of ivermectin, simply because the evidence base is so bad. I also have another saying, namely that equivocal clinical trials of a drug with low prior plausibility = “the drug almost certainly doesn’t work”. Again, the low prior plausibility is based on the in vitro studies in which ivermectin required a high concentration, far higher than is achievable in human blood, to exhibit antiviral activity against SARS-CoV-2. Having worked with an anticancer drug for which the effective concentration in mice was barely achievable—and then only with a potentially toxic dose—this observation alone made me very skeptical of ivermectin as a COVID-19 treatment. I always leave open the possibility that I could be wrong and the drug might be effective, but based on what I know now I think the probability that the drug will be shown to work against COVID-19 in larger randomized trials is quite low. Under normal circumstances, I’d estimate those chances as being so low that the trials aren’t worth doing, but in the current political climate, particularly with so many ideologues and grifters promoting ivermectin as a cure for COVID-19, I have to hold out hope that a negative large clinical trial might help slow the grifting or that the best result that could likely be expected, a modest effect, would at least put ivermectin into perspective. No, I’m not naïve. I know that a resoundingly negative clinical trial of ivermectin probably won’t achieve that, but I can hope, can’t I?
What about the rest of the studies cited in this review? There were two animal studies, one of which is a study in golden hamsters that’s been on a preprint server since November, not a good sign it will ever passing peer review. Interestingly, the study showed no effect of ivermectin on viral load, although it claimed to show a major effect on SARS-Cov-2-associated pathology, including loss of sense of smell. The study was not blinded, something that researchers doing animal research often forget to do, even though failure to blind can cause the same problems in animal research as in human clinical trials. The second study wasn’t even of SARS-CoV-2, but of mouse hepatitis virus (MHV), a type 2 family RNA coronavirus similar to SARS-CoV-2. This study was not blinded, either, except for the pathologist examining the liver sections for signs of viral infection. Given that it didn’t even test ivermectin against SARS-CoV-2 and didn’t really show that MHV is so similar to SARS-CoV-2 that the results would be generalizable, color me less than impressed by these animal studies.
Lastly, the authors cite data from Peru:
The clinical experience of IVM treatments of COVID-19 in 25 countries extends far beyond the RCT results summarized, yet incomplete tracking and lack of control data exclude most of this for evaluation. The record of nationally authorized such treatments in Peru provides a notable exception [42]. In ten states of Peru, mass IVM treatments of COVID-19 were conducted through a broadside, army-led effort, Mega-Operación Tayta (MOT), that began on different dates in each state. In these MOT states, excess deaths dropped sharply over 30 days from peak deaths by a mean of 74%, in close time conjunction with MOT start date (Figure 1B). In 14 states of Peru having locally administered IVM distributions, the mean reduction in excess deaths over 30 days from peak deaths was 53%, while in Lima, which had minimal IVM distributions during the first wave of the pandemic due to restrictive government policies there, the corresponding 30-day decrease in excess deaths was 25%.
Reductions in excess deaths by state (absolute values) correlated with extent of IVM distribution (maximal-MOT states, moderate-local distributions, and minimal-Lima) with Kendall τb = 0.524, p<0.002, as shown in Figure 1C. Nationwide, excess deaths decreased 14-fold over four months through December 1, 2020. After a restrictive IVM treatment policy was enacted under a new Peruvian president who took office on November 17, however, deaths increased 13-fold over the two months following December 1, through February 1, 2021 (Figure 1A).
Does this sound familiar? It’s the same sort of ecological “analysis” that an astroturf group was doing for hydroxychloroquine last year that I discussed. The methods of this study are equally awful, which is probably why this article, too, is only on a preprint server thus far, and guess what? It’s a study whose first author is David Scheim, a man with no discernable expertise in the sort of complex epidemiology that would be required to make sense of the Peruvian data, while the other author is Juan Chamie of—you guessed it!—the FLCCC. I’ll say about this study the same thing that I said about the HCQ astroturf site: This is all utter rubbish, methods, conclusion, and all, as you will see. It’s so bad that it reminds me of a study by two antivaxxers without any qualifications in epidemiology, Neil Z. Miller and Gary S. Goldman, that tried—and failed—to correlate the number of vaccines in the recommended vaccine schedules of various countries with those countries’ infant mortality rates.
Seriously, this is some really bad stuff. Let’s just put it this way. Ecological studies of the use of a drug are pretty much worthless because it’s impossible to control adequately for other potentially confounding factors or, in the case of a pandemic, the unexpected resurgence of a virus due to new variants, such as what we are seeing in the US due to the delta variant. But COVID-19 cranks do love their “real world evidence,” don’t they?
I can’t resist finishing this section with these Tweets:
lol at their moronic graph. legality of IVM in Peru highlighted at the expense of what might actually drive excess death… like cases of coronavirus. pic.twitter.com/jxLmLVthGc
— Hypoautonomic (@hypoautonomic) August 7, 2021
I've read the paper and what caught my attention was their metric – they consider something like reduction % in X days from the deaths peak day – which is debatable, to say the least. When the daily deaths curve looks like a plateau, it's hard to define when the peak happened.
— Frankito, o Curioso® (@WeiseFranklin) August 8, 2021
This tells you a lot about the quality of this review.
A notable omission
I’ll conclude by pointing out a very notable omission of a study in this review. The authors cite meta-analyses that use what they refer to as “Cochrane methodology”, which is all well and good, except that they forget to mention that a real, honest-to-goodness Cochrane systematic review and meta-analysis of ivermectin for COVID-19 has actually been published. Its conclusions were—shall we say?—not particularly good for ivermectin:
We found no evidence to support the use of ivermectin for treating or preventing COVID-19 infection, but the evidence base is limited.
Evaluation of ivermectin is continuing in 31 ongoing studies, and we will update this review with their results when they become available.
And:
Based on the current very low- to low-certainty evidence, we are uncertain about the efficacy and safety of ivermectin used to treat or prevent COVID-19. The completed studies are small and few are considered high quality. Several studies are underway that may produce clearer answers in review updates. Overall, the reliable evidence available does not support the use ivermectin for treatment or prevention of COVID-19 outside of well-designed randomized trials.
Coming back to small studies and small numbers of events, Cochrane noted:
Our confidence in the evidence is very low because we could only include 14 studies with few participants and few events, such as deaths or need for ventilation. The methods differed between studies, and they did not report everything we were interested in, such as quality of life.
The Cochrane Collaborative, being the Cochrane Collaborative, didn’t really include prior plausibility/prior probability in its analysis, but even without it the best that it could say about ivermectin to treat COVID-19 is that there isn’t good evidence to support it and that maybe ongoing trials will clarify the question. That’s far less…optimistic…a picture than this particular review paints.
In fairness, this Cochrane review wasn’t published until late July, and the publication date of the “Nobel”-touting review was early August. So in this case it really is possible that the authors didn’t know about the Cochrane review. I’m sure they’ll get to correcting their preprint online-only article right away to remove any mention of Elgazzar 2020 and add a citation and discussion of the Cochrane review.
The bottom line
There is a vast disinformation campaign about COVID-19, public health interventions to slow its spread, and especially vaccines. Back when the pandemic was new, hydroxychloroquine was promoted as a treatment in part because if there were a highly effective treatment for COVID-19 advocates could argue that masks, social distancing, and “lockdowns”—and even vaccines—were unnecessary. As the evidence finally convincingly showed that hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work, the same antimaskers and antivaxxers pivoted to ivermectin. Again, I suspect that there’s a reason why the FLCCC and BIRD Groups always included Elgazzar 2020 in their meta-analyses, just as I suspect that this latest clickbait “review” prominently features this same study, despite flaws and bias that were obvious even before the analysis that led it to be retracted. Basically, this review article is part of this disinformation campaign.
I originally entitled this series, “Ivemectin is the new hydroxychloroquine” because of the obvious parallels between the quality of evidence for hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin (low) and the concerted astroturf campaign designed to promote both drugs as a rationale to argue that public health interventions and vaccines to slow the spread of COVID-19 are unnecessary when a “highly effective” treatment supposedly exists. I note, though, that hydroxychloroquine advocates never went as far as ivermectin advocates have gone. Perhaps future posts in this series should be entitled, “Once, ivermectin was but the learner. Now it is the master.” The subtitle could be, “Only a master of astroturfing and grift.”
Yes, I’m still a Star Wars fan, and I had to work that quote in, even if the result was a bit awkward.

Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, take 6: Incompetence and fraud everywhere!
Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, a drug repurposed for COVID-19 that almost certainly doesn’t work but is still being touted as a “miracle cure” by quacks, grifters, and political ideologues. Are the data supporting it all fraud?
David Gorski on October 11, 2021
Link

I’ve long been saying that ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine, so much so that I have to say now that ivermectin is no longer new, even as I speculate what new “miracle cure” for COVID-19 will become the “new ivermectin”. Readers might remember that, very early in the pandemic, hydroxychloroquine, a widely used antimalarial drug with mild immunosuppressive properties that make it also useful to treat some autoimmune diseases, was seized upon as the (then) only effective treatment for COVID-19 based on reported observations in Wuhan, China during the first major outbreak. There, a group of Chinese researchers reported that none of a group of their 80 patients with lupus erythematosus who were taking hydroxychloroquine went on to become infected with SARS-CoV-2. Based on that very thin gruel, hydroxychloroquine for a time became part of the de facto standard of care around the world, including in one of the hospitals that I practice at. The devotion to hydroxychloroquine spread, thanks to promotion by Dr. Oz, then-President Donald Trump, and a veritable rogues’ gallery of quacks, and it took a long time for the evidence to catch up and kill it. There was a reason why I called hydroxychloroquine the Black Knight of COVID-19 treatments, because no amount of evidence appeared able to kill it, until it did. Even so, a year later there remains a contingent of quacks who still promote it not just as a treatment but as a preventative.
At the time, at least early last year, I could understand why so many doctors latched onto hydroxychloroquine. After all, patients were getting deathly ill and dying in droves, and they didn’t know what to do beyond supportive care that tried to keep them from dying long enough to clear the infection. Under circumstances like those, it’s human nature to try something like hydroxychloroquine, nor was it unethical then, at least initially, to try it, at least until there was more evidence. These days, not so much. We know hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work, and there are vaccines and potential treatments.
Enter ivermectin, an anthelmintic drug commonly used around the world to treat diseases caused by parasitic roundworms in both animals and humans. Based on a recent BBC news report, “Ivermectin: How false science created a Covid ‘miracle’ drug“, it’s looking more and more as though the clinical trial base for the drug as a treatment for COVID-19 is almost all either fraudulent or so badly done that it might as well be fraudulent. Given the publication of that news report, now seems to be as good a time as any to revisit ivermectin and look at the massive fraud that’s fueled massive grift and many conspiracy theories.
Ivermectin: Bad science helps feed a craze
As Scott Gavura and I have written a number of times, these days ivermectin has supplanted hydroxychloroquine as the “drug of choice” of antivaxxers, quacks, grifters, and ideologues, and the propaganda and astroturf campaigns to promote it as a “miracle cure” or preventative as good or better than the vaccines. There have also been a number of clinical trials testing ivermectin, some with seemingly—if you’ll excuse the term—miraculous results, so much so that there have been meta-analyses.
Ivermectin suffers from two problems in terms of evidence. First, it was first touted based on studies from over a year ago that showed it to have activity against SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, in cell culture. Unfortunately, what made ivermectin’s prior plausibility low is the fact that the concentration required to achieve this antiviral activity in vitro is many times higher than what can be achieved in the bloodstream with normal dosing. Anyone who does drug development research—as I’ve done, and with a repurposed drug, yet!—knows that this is a huge problem for any drug that an investigator proposes to take to the clinic. Basically, for a drug to look promising to have a high probability that it works in animals (and then in humans) as well as it works in cell culture, its effective concentration can’t be so high that it can’t be achieved in the bloodstream with even high doses. There are occasional exceptions to this rule, such as when a drug’s mechanism in vivo turns out to be different than the mechanism observed in cell culture, but ivermectin isn’t one of those.
The most widely touted evidence for the efficacy of ivermectin against COVID-19 are meta-analyses by advocacy groups touting ivermectin as a way out of the pandemic, such as the BIRD Group in the UK and the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCCA) in the US, that supposedly show, based on an aggregation of existing clinical trials of COVID-19, that ivermectin is highly effective as a preventative after exposure and as a treatment that prevents progression of mild disease to severe disease. Unfortunately, these meta-analyses are highly dependent on a small number of highly “positive” trials, which, if removed, turn positive meta-analyses into negative meta-analyses. Seemingly not coincidentally, these very highly “positive” clinical trials are also the most dodgy, either very badly done at best or outright fraudulent at worst.
My piece links to the amazing investigative work of @stephaniemlee and the Buzzfeed team on this extremely dodgy study, you can read their full investigation here https://t.co/SJ4x4fuG7u
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) September 2, 2021
The first mainstream news report about this came to us, courtesy of BuzzFeed News, about a month ago in the form of a story by Stephanie Lee and Ken Bensinger titled “A Prominent Study Said Ivermectin Prevents COVID, But The Data Is Suspect“, which built on the analyses of Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, an epidemiology postdoc at the University of Wollongong in Australia whom we’ve met before on the topic of dodgy ivermectin studies, and Kyle Sheldrick, who has also been analyzing questionable COVID-19 studies. Oddly enough, I haven’t discussed this news report here on SBM, but it’s worth looking at because it sets the stage for the BBC report.
The BuzzFeed report focuses on a study done in Argentina and led by Dr. Hector Carvallo, which led to a lot of hype of this sort:
I know this is difficult to accept. The implications of it are both beautiful and horrifying:
Ivermectin is a near-perfect COVID prophylactic.
I'm sorry and you're welcome. I mean both, and I don't think they can be disentangled in this case. https://t.co/yNz0B9cfcA
— Bret Weinstein (@BretWeinstein) June 11, 2021
And, from BuzzFeed:
The fervor has grown ever since. “A near-perfect COVID prophylactic,” tweeted Bret Weinstein, a biologist who is best known for resigning from Evergreen State College in 2017 after he criticized an anti-racism education event. He has declared that the medication renders vaccines irrelevant. “If ivermectin, a drug out of patent, is safe and effective for treating and, more importantly, preventing COVID,” he told Fox News’ Tucker Carlson this summer, “then there shouldn’t be vaccines that we’re administering.”
Carvallo’s findings have been a powerful data point in this argument. The Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCCA), a group of physicians that formed in March 2020, cites Carvallo’s study, along with others, in recommending that ivermectin be “systematically and globally adopted” as both a cure and preventative against COVID-19.
The head of the organization, pulmonologist Pierre Kory, talked up the study to Joe Rogan — the podcast star who said this week that he is now taking ivermectin, among other drugs, after testing positive for COVID. Kory also invoked it during a Senate committee hearing in December, when he asserted that ivermectin “basically obliterates transmission of this virus.”
And:
For anti-vaccine activists, the clinical trial results couldn’t have been better. The drug ivermectin, scientists in Argentina announced last year, prevented 100% of COVID-19 infections.
That glowing finding helped spark a craze for the decades-old medication, which is normally used to delouse people and deworm livestock, and drive the perception that it is a silver bullet against the pandemic.
Let me just stop briefly right here. Any study that concludes that a drug is 100% effective is very suspect right off the bat. Why? Nothing in medicine is 100% effective, and a claim of 100% efficacy would be far higher than the known efficacy of treatments that have been demonstrated to be extremely efficacious for a large number of diseases. As I also like to say, in medicine the only thing that is 100% certain is death. Each and every one of us will die someday of something.
The BuzzFeed article and an article by Meyerowitz-Katz detail the numerous problems with this study, just beginning with:
The study in question is a perfect case in point — it is reportedly a prospective observational trial where medical staff working in one of several hospitals either took ivermectin and a nasal spray made from seaweed and used normal PPE or a control group with just normal PPE. Of those who took the nasal spray and ivermectin, none got Covid-19, while up to 90% of the medical staff who didn’t take these prophylactics contracted the dread disease.
Now, even at face value this study is incredibly shoddy. As I pointed out on twitter, the study was “peer reviewed” in less than a week, the tables have incorrect numbers, the results contradict results the authors posted elsewhere online, the graphs were made, badly, in Excel using default settings, there are no descriptions of most pertinent details about the trial, and the journal the study is published in is about as predatory as journals get.
Also:
Once the paper started circulating, staffers at the Hospital Cuenca Alta, about an hour outside of Buenos Aires, grew alarmed. In December, its board of directors sent word to Argentina’s health ministry that it had no idea why it was listed as having participated.
“Although the aforementioned article contains data referring to patients from this [hospital] as participants in the respective clinical trial, they are false since this hospital did not participate in the investigation carried out,” a letter shared with BuzzFeed News read. The hospital’s ethics committee also did not receive any request to conduct the study.
Carvallo’s explanation is that the hospital wasn’t asked to participate as an institution. “It was not through ethics committees,” he said. Essentially, he claimed, staffers at local hospitals had heard about the pilot study’s promising results through word of mouth and individually wanted to participate at a time when no COVID vaccines were available.
I could go on and on (e.g., about one of the authors withdrawing her name from the paper when Carvallo couldn’t answer questions about it to her satisfaction), but I want to get on to the more recent findings of the BBC. Read the BuzzFeed report and Meyerowitz-Katz’s articles for the gory details of what looks to me like probable fraud. To me, the BBC report is even more damning because it strongly suggests a wider pattern of shoddy research mixed with outright fraud than previous reports, to the point where I’ve started to wonder if there is any legitimate, non-shoddy, non-fraudulent ivermectin trial that showed a positive result. (I’ve pointed out before how the better quality ivermectin studies showed no activity against COVID-19.)
Ivermectin: A false “miracle drug” for COVID-19
In their reporting on ivermectin for the BBC, reporters Rachel Schraer and Jack Goodman were aided by the aforementioned Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz and Dr. Kyle Sheldrick, along with two additional fraud hunters, Dr. James Heathers and Dr. Nick Brown. The findings are incredible. After repeating the unfortunate history of the drug as a COVID-19 treatment and mentioning how antivaxxers and antimaskers have wholeheartedly embraced it, we learn:
The BBC can reveal that more than a third of 26 major trials of the drug for use on Covid have serious errors or signs of potential fraud. None of the rest show convincing evidence of ivermectin’s effectiveness.
Dr Kyle Sheldrick, one of the group investigating the studies, said they had not found “a single clinical trial” claiming to show that ivermectin prevented Covid deaths that did not contain “either obvious signs of fabrication or errors so critical they invalidate the study”.
Major problems included:
    • The same patient data being used multiple times for supposedly different people
    • Evidence that selection of patients for test groups was not random
    • Numbers unlikely to occur naturally
    • Percentages calculated incorrectly
    • Local health bodies unaware of the studies
The scientists in the group – Dr Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, Dr James Heathers, Dr Nick Brown and Dr Sheldrick – each have a track record of exposing dodgy science. They’ve been working together remotely on an informal and voluntary basis during the pandemic.
And observational trials don’t get a pass either, given how they’ve been used as propaganda tools to promote ivermectin:
The team also looked at six particularly influential observational trials. This type of trial looks at what happens to people who are taking the drug anyway, so can be biased by the types of people who choose to take the treatment.
Out of a total of 26 studies examined, there was evidence in five that the data may have been faked – for example they contained virtually impossible numbers or rows of identical patients copied and pasted.
In a further five there were major red flags – for example, numbers didn’t add up, percentages were calculated incorrectly or local health bodies weren’t aware they had taken place.
On top of these flawed trials, there were 14 authors of studies who failed to send data back. The independent scientists have flagged this as a possible indicator of fraud.
The BBC, of course, has to be circumspect, as do the intrepid team of ivermectin study investigators who uncovered these problems, but I don’t. This reeks to high heaven of fraud, particularly given that it was primarily the studies that found large positive effects against ivermectin due to the drug were the ones with the biggest problems. As the BBC reports, the worst problems were found “all in the studies making big claims for ivermectin—in fact, the bigger the claim in terms of lives saved or infections prevented, the greater the concerns suggesting it might be faked or invalid, the researchers discovered.” Sheldrick, for instance, concedes that it’s very difficult to rule out human error, but to me these errors are so bad that they are virtually indistinguishable from fraud. Moreover, if these were in fact human errors, then the investigators behind these trials have no business being anywhere near anything resembling clinical trials or human subjects research—or any medical research of any kind. I wouldn’t even want them in a position to experiment on mice.
It’s worth it to go to the horse’s mouth, so to speak, to see what’s wrong with many of these studies:
A recent study in Lebanon was found to have blocks of details of 11 patients that had been copied and pasted repeatedly – suggesting many of the trial’s apparent patients didn’t really exist.
The study’s authors told the BBC that the “original set of data was rigged, sabotaged or mistakenly entered in the final file” and that they have submitted a retraction to the scientific journal which published it.
I like to use this particular brief clip whenever I hear a claim as ludicrous-sounding as this:
What I fear is that the authors might well try to resubmit the paper, only with more cleverly designed fraudulent patients. Yes, I said it. This is not the sort of clinical trial error that happens innocently.
Then, from Iran:
Another study from Iran seemed to show that ivermectin prevented people dying from Covid.
But the scientists who investigated it found issues. The records of how much iron was in patients’ blood contained numbers in a sequence that was unlikely to come up naturally.
And the patients given the placebo turned out to have had much lower levels of oxygen in their blood before the trial started than those given ivermectin. So they were already sicker and statistically more likely to die.
But this pattern was repeated across a wide range of different measurements. The people with “bad” measurements ended up in the placebo group, the ones with “good” measurements in the ivermectin group.
The likelihood of this happening randomly across all these different measurements was vanishingly small, Dr Sheldrick said.
It almost certainly didn’t happen randomly. Sure, it’s possible that it did, but the odds against it are so long that, for all intents and purposes, it is reasonable to assume that this was not random. Either that, or one must assume that the investigators were so incompetent at propensity score matching that, again, they should have no business being anywhere near clinical trials or human subjects research or, yes again, any scientific research. Again, take your pick.
As usual, Meyerowitz-Katz has summarized the problems on Medium:
Is ivermectin for Covid-19 based on fraudulent research?
Part 5. This one has an ENORMOUS impact on the literaturehttps://t.co/suNR4FC203
— Health Nerd (@GidMK) October 8, 2021
Re: "But they must have recognized it after looking at the raw data, yet they repeatedly refused to give the raw data when people repeatedly asked."
And for all the ivermectin fans who've displayed baseless paranoia about the BBC:https://t.co/wbFX4257Fi pic.twitter.com/tYkmOFdRAg
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) October 8, 2021
I don’t think this was an honest mistake either, and, as the headline states, this study (Niaee et al) is the sole remaining randomized trial that shows a benefit from COVID-19 in treating COVID-19. Kyle Sheldrick has also written about it:
Dr Niaee and colleagues claim to have randomised 180 patients into six different treatment groups. I do not believe this claim is true.
The six groups have 30 patients each. Two groups did not receive ivermectin (one received a placebo and one did not). Four groups received ivermectin at different doses and frequencies.
Traditionally in table one of an RCT authors describe certain characteristics of patients in each group. Something immediately caught my eye. The number of participants in each arm who had not actually tested positive for the virus was wildly different:
Control Group: 40%Placebo Group: 53%Ivermectin Group 1: 23%Ivermectin Group 2: 23%Ivermectin Group 3: 3%Ivermectin Group 4: 30%
The authors claim this had a p value of 0.421 from a Chi Square test. Just eyeballing this it seemed wildly off to me, and when calculating this I got a p value of about 8*10^-4. (The authors now accept that the actual p value should be <0.001 and state this was “a typographical error.”)
I contacted the corresponding author on the address given in the journal article and requested raw data but received no response. I then attempted through an email address I found online on an earlier preprint and also received no response. I then attempted through his institutional contact details at his university and also received no response. At that point I gave up and posted a comment to pubpeer pointing out the very unexpected imbalance in baseline data and suggested the trial should not be included in meta-analyses unless IPD could be provided and reviewed.
And:
A few of the first things to jump out at me where:
– All patients with missing baseline data (6 patients) occurred in a single arm. This is extremely unlikely with less than a 1 in 10,000 chance of occurring if only random chance is at play.
– While the averages from the summary data were similar between groups, the range of values between arms were wildly different.
– Far fewer patients with low oxygen levels (<90) occurred in the ivermectin arms.
– Hypotensive patients appear far more frequently in some arms than others.
So I ran some statistical tests on how unlikely some of these mismatches were. The numbers below are slightly less extreme than those I presented in my first round of criticism to Dr Niaee. Dr Niaee objected to grouping arms into single-dose and multi-dose groups, and demanded I rerun the analysis with 6 independent groups of 30. I agreed.
We already knew that the chi square for whether patients had actually tested positive to corona virus was 21 with a p value of 0.0008, this means the chance of a mismatch this extreme happening in genuinely randomised groups is less than 1 in 1,000.
There’s more, of course. Again, read Meyerowitz-Katz’s article (if you can) and Sheldrick’s article for the gory details. Suffice to say that Meyerowitz-Katz has concluded:
This is the fifth part in this ongoing saga, and honestly I’m unsure that there will be many more. At a certain point, you have to accept that the evidence-base is so corrupted that the message that has been pushed for months by eager promoters of the drug is very unlikely to be true. If ivermectin does have a benefit in the treatment of Covid-19, it is probably going to be small, and certainly not as impressive as people have been arguing for the last year.
Moreover, there are serious concerns with the studies on prophylaxis too. While it is plausible that ivermectin has some use against Covid-19, the staggering scale of the fraud has made it almost impossible to say anything for certain, except that people rarely fake trials for effective drugs.
Ultimately, we have to wait for larger randomized trials to really know whether ivermectin has a benefit from Covid-19. Unfortunately, it appears that the benefits spruiked for months are most likely based on seriously flawed, and in some cases potentially fraudulent, research.
This is one place where I now strongly disagree with Meyerowitz-Katz,even as I deeply admire his work exposing the incompetence and fraud behind existing ivermectin studies. Now, my position has evolved. We don’t need to wait for larger randomized trials to know if ivermectin works to treat or prevent COVID-19. The existing evidence base is quite clear. It almost certainly doesn’t; that is, if you take a Bayesian approach that looks at the prior probability based on preclinical basic science studies that show that the drug can’t reach a concentration in the bloodstream sufficient to show antiviral activity. As I like to say, very low to nonexistent prior probability based on basic science plus equivocal clinical trial evidence equals, “the drug almost certainly doesn’t work” (especially if you add the huge element of fraud). If you prefer, my conclusion can be phrased a bit more carefully and precisely as, “The odds that ivermectin has a meaningful clinical effect in preventing or treating COVID-19 are so low as to be, for all practical intents and purposes, indistinguishable from not working”.
In fact, I’m now ready to go one step further. It is now arguably no longer ethical to design and carry out new clinical trials of ivermectin against COVID-19. There is no good preliminary evidence that it works in humans to justify such trials, meaning that the only potential effect left is possible harm to clinical trial subjects. If you prefer, I can phrase this proposition more carefully and precisely and say that the chances that clinical trial subjects participating in a randomized trial of ivermectin against COVID-19 will be harmed are so much greater than the chances that any will be helped that it is unethical to do such a trial. I’d love to hear the counterargument, but I’m having a hard time not becoming less and less tentative in this conclusion the more I learn.
The pushback
I’ve often wondered why there has been such a flood of bad papers touting ivermectin as a “miracle cure” or “miracle preventative” for COVID-19 given that we didn’t see that for hydroxychloroquine last year. Don’t get me wrong. The evidence for hydroxychloroquine was not strong. Quite the opposite, it was incredibly weak. However, there didn’t appear to be any major fraud. There were plenty of small studies, bad studies, and the like, but no evidence of fraud except for, ironically enough, one study that linked hydroxychloroquine to dangerous and fatal cardiac arrhythmias, which briefly came close to fooling even me. (I expressed skepticism about the study but in retrospect not nearly enough and thereby learned a valuable lesson.)
Both drugs achieved a cult-like snake oil miracle cure status among antivaxxers, antimaskers, and ideologues, and for much the same reason: If there exists a miracle cure or preventative for COVID-19, then all the public health interventions that these activists hate (lockdowns, mask mandates, vaccine mandates) all become unnecessary. Business can go back to making money, and life can revert to near normal, all without pesky government interventions on behalf of public health or any collective action of any kind. The ideological motivation for promoting hydroxychloroquine (at least after the first wave of the pandemic had crested, while doctors still believed the Chinese experience and recommendations for the drug) has been the same for ivermectin. So it’s not surprising that ivermectin cranks are pushing back hard against the growing reports of fraud and incompetence behind the most commonly cited studies claiming that ivermectin is a potent treatment for COVID-19.
For instance, after the BuzzFeed report, one famous conspiracy site known for COVID-19 minimization, antimask and antivaccine propaganda, and conspiracy theories about the pandemic, defended Hector Carvallo and portrayed the BuzzFeed article and the work of Meyerowitz-Katz and Sheldrick as —you guessed it!—a conspiracy on the part of the “mainstream medical establishment” to “silence” the brave maverick doctors trying to cure COVID-19. Amusingly, Carvallo even quotes Arthur Schopenhauer:
He is confident that eventually, ivermectin will be widely used against COVID-19. “All truth passes through three phases,” he told BuzzFeed. “First it is ridiculed, then it is violently opposed, then it is accepted as self-evident. We are in phase two now.”
Yes, he’s quoting Arthur Schopenhauer. This is a quote that I laugh at, because those who quote it erroneously think that they have an unpopular “truth” that will go through these stages, forgetting that untruth or fraud will never make it past the second stage. In fact, here’s a variation of my retort:
All “fake medicine” truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed by the rationally inclined because it is ridiculous and based upon feelings, conspiracy theories, bad science, and pseudoscience instead of reality. Second, it is opposed by the rationally inclined. Third, the more complete the science and information that falsify it, the more vehemently it is embraced as “self-evident” by its non-rationally inclined believers.
I think we’re in the third stage now, given some of the other responses coming from ivermectin believers:
– Their suggestion that metanalyses consider patient-level data is silly, because it would mean we would have to throw away every meta-analysis ever written, because they would have "high risk of bias." (He is confused what that means)
[2/]
— bad_stats 🕜💵🖨️🕣 (@thebadstats) October 9, 2021
And, of course, there is a fake “meta-analysis” that ivermectin frauds still cite:
BECAUSE of the work done by these researchers.
No mention of the fact they haven't removed the other trials found to be fraudulent.
And of course, no addressing the list of reasons why https://t.co/sR53wYvC1R is an abomination…
[7/]
— bad_stats 🕜💵🖨️🕣 (@thebadstats) October 9, 2021
I really should do a post on that website, but it so much resembles websites maintained for hydroxychloroquine back in the day (and, indeed, seems to be maintained by the same astroturf groups) that I’ve had a hard time motivating myself.
And this isn’t all:
I’m going to strongly disagree with Dr. Sheldrick here too, just as I did with Meyerowitz-Katz, even if I risk being too repetitive and say again that I admire the whole crew’s work digging out the inconsistencies and omissions that strongly suggest fraud in these studies. One last time, from a Bayesian perspective we can now reasonably conclude that the chances that ivermectin produces a clinically relevant benefit against COVID-19 in humans are so infinitesimally small that it really isn’t necessary—or even desirable—to do any more large clinical trials reach a reasonable scientific conclusion that, for all practical purposes, ivermectin doesn’t work. (That is a different statement.) It’s also arguably unethical to design new clinical trials, for the reasons I’ve discussed above, as well as a waste of resources, in particular, the most precious research resource of all, human subjects.
I also understand another argument that I sometimes hear in other quarters, namely that we need a couple of slam-dunk large randomized clinical trials for ivermectin as a treatment or preventative for COVID-19 to convince doctors that it really doesn’t work. (This has been the same argument for decades for the need to do yet another large epidemiological trial looking at whether vaccines are associated with an increased risk of autism.) Then I ask myself: Really? If they’re not convinced now, what makes anyone think that another one, two (or three or four or ten) large RCTs would convince them?
        ◦ Sadly, the ideology behind the antimask, antivaccine, and COVID-19 minimizing movement is a powerful drug that will, as antivaccine beliefs have, stand up against any evidence that science can produce, and, even if that weren’t the case, there’s just way too much grifting potential there.

Ivermectin: The acupuncture of COVID-19 treatments
As high-quality evidence increasingly and resoundingly shows that ivermectin does not work against COVID-19, advocates are doing what acupuncture advocates do: Turning to lower quality “positive” studies to claim incorrectly that their favorite ineffective treatment actually does “work”.
David Gorski on March 21, 2022
Link

I’m getting tired of writing about ivermectin as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19, just as in 2020 I got tired of writing about hydroxychloroquine as a miracle cure for COVID-19. Oddly enough, as high-quality evidence accumulated that hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work, it faded in importance such that by early 2021 it was no longer the preferred wonder drug among COVID-19 conspiracy theorists. Ivermectin rose to replace it, or, as Scott and I like to say, ivermectin became the new hydroxychloroquine.
As high-quality evidence accumulates that ivermectin doesn’t work, I keep wondering what will be the new ivermectin, but, for some reason, ivermectin seems to have “legs”. So far, it’s withstanding a far greater assault in terms of evidence and even demonstration of probable fraud in the largest randomized controlled clinical trials cited to support its use to treat COVID-19. Moreover, as has long been the case with quackery like acupuncture, as the evidence from RCTs show it not to be any better than placebo, similarly as negative RCTs accumulate and serious deficiencies and probable outright fraud invalidating the positive RCTs, advocates are increasingly citing lower quality observational studies as “proof” that ivermectin “works” against COVID-19. It’s reminding me very much of a much older topic that we’ve been writing about since the founding of this blog, acupuncture, so much so that I’m beginning to think that ivermectin is the acupuncture of COVID-19 treatments.
Because of this, I find myself saying, “Once more unto the breach.” The reason is that ivermectin advocates are back and they’re flogging two more studies as evidence that ivermectin is the cheap, highly effective, nontoxic treatment for COVID-19 that “they” don’t want you to know about, for example:
Here’s another PEER REVIEWED and published study showing 70% reduction in mortality compared to taking Remdesivir. https://t.co/2ppjE4Q5zb
— Kim Iversen 🇺🇸 (@KimIversenShow) March 8, 2022
I’ll get to those studies in a moment. In the meantime, legislative efforts to bypass science and professional recommendations continue apace, as touted here on TrialSiteNews, one of the largest antivaccine and medical conspiracy theory websites out there right now:
The New Hampshire’s state House approved a bill making ivermectin available by a medical prescribers’ “standing order,” meaning pharmacists will be able to dispense the medication without individual prescriptions.
Narrowly approved
The Republican dominated House in Concord voted 183-159 to approve the bill.
Republicans had argued that the drug is already over the counter in several countries and had been used specifically for COVID-19.
According to the legislation, a pharmacist would be able to fill a request for the drug under a “standing order“.
Meanwhile, Jeffery Tucker, who founded the libertarian “free market” think tank, the Brownstone Institute as the “spiritual child of the Great Barrington Declaration” (which advocated in essence a do-nothing let ‘er rip” strategy for the COVID-19 plus a poorly defined strategy of “focused protection” for those vulnerable to severe disease or death) gloats that New Hampshire voted for “pharmaceutical freedom“:
The New Hampshire House of Representatives has voted to make Ivermectin available at any pharmacy that wants to distribute this drug even without a prescription. It will likely pass the Senate and become law.
It’s a hugely positive breakthrough for medical and pharmaceutical freedom. It’s only tragic that this was not the situation two years ago. The doctors the world over who have rallied behind this treatment believe that many lives might have been saved. If one state in the Northeast had at least made the option available, outcomes might have been very different.
The Epoch Times reports that “Similar bills are pending legislative approval in Oklahoma, Missouri, Indiana, Arizona, and Alaska.”
Magnificent! What’s key here is the concept of human choice.
The irony is very bitter: the vaccine mandates have been universal and people have lost careers for refusing or been rejected for participation in public life. People were forced to get shots of doubtful efficacy in most cases that many people did not want or because they did not see the need and feared their side effects.
Meanwhile, a drug they would have chosen to take was denied to them, again by force, and physicians who believed they were saving lives had their licenses taken away for using their professional discretion.
For a good part of last year, many people in the world could freely buy Ivermectin, a generic drug that at least 8 quality studies have shown to be an effective treatment for Covid-19. It has long been part of the alternative treatment protocol for Covid since it was first tried in early 2020, but never recommended by the FDA, CDC, or NIH. At some point, the CDC was tweeting denunciations of it, somehow with the implication that this treatment was distracting from the main push of vaccine fanaticism.
I quote Mr. Tucker because it’s important to remind you before I discuss the studies of how the promotion of ivermectin has so easily become part of the COVID-19 disinformation machine plus a much older phenomenon. That older phenomenon is one of which long-time readers are very aware, specifically how quacks and antivaxxers have long argued that people should be allowed to “choose” their quackery (or “choose” not to vaccinate their children), portraying such “choice” as “health freedom” while portraying those trying to hold medicine to a scientific standard of being, in essence, fascists and authoritarians trying to keep the “people” from the “cures”. There’s also a conspiracy theory at the heart of such appeals, namely that “they” are “covering up the evidence” and “they” don’t want you to know the “truth”. Such appeals have been very effective over the last decade, as I’ve pointed out that the main reason that the politics of vaccine resistance have shifted very much rightward is because of a longstanding campaign by antivaxxers to rebrand their antivaccine views as “health freedom” and “parental choice”, even co-opting the women’s health slogan “my body, my choice” in a highly cynical way.
That’s why it’s important to look at the whole conspiratorial package behind “COVID-19 resistance”, and not just the individual parts, such as antivaccine pseudoscience or resistance to masks and other nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to mitigate the spread of COVID=19. Indeed, Tucker explicitly makes this case for me. First, he mocks a CDC cartoon about how to identify health misinformation:
You are welcome to peruse the entire document, the main message of which is that the government is always correct, always knows the most science at the time, while front-line doctors with experience are very likely quacks, crazies, or ruthless profiteers.
Sometimes it seems like the people who produce such propaganda are forever attempting to live in the world of the movie Contagion, where every alternative treatment is a scam promoted by a corrupt “blogger” and where the CDC knows all. This cartoon is a smear in every way.
I perused the document. It’s actually quite reasonable and mild, perhaps even too much so. It warns people to look out for professional-looking websites that feature quote-mined quotes, cherry-picked statistics, deceptively edited videos, old images being recirculated as though they were recent, and misleading diagrams. It identifies several types of misinformation creators and spreaders, such as the disinformer, the casual sharer, the believer, the mischief maker, and others. It suggests the CDC as one of several sources to fact check claims against, urging people, “If you’re not sure, don’t share!” All of this is very reasonable; so I wonder why Tucker reacts so violently against this message and uses a straw man huge enough that, if set afire, it could be seen from space to mischaracterize the message. Actually, no I don’t.
Unsurprisingly, though, Tucker pivots to cry “Freedumb!”:
This battle is much larger than the legal status of Ivermectin. That’s just one symbol. What’s really at stake here is the idea of medical freedom itself. And freedom is a precondition for scientific inquiry and the search for the truth. It is also essential for public health. This is one of many lessons of the disastrously botched pandemic.
The decisions of the New Hampshire legislature to enshrine that freedom into law in this one instance represent a mighty tribute to the principle and a repudiation of the use of force in disease management.
That’s exactly what I’ve been saying, except that, unlike Tucker, I realize that ivermectin doesn’t work and vaccines do, while also understanding that denialists like him might portray what they are doing as a “medical freedom” and a “search for the truth,” but what they are really doing is spreading misinformation that doesn’t really much care for what is “true” or not, as long as it decreases the power of government.
On to ivermectin. Again.
Observational studies a-go-go
If there’s one principle that should help you to identify when a medical claim is probably nonsense, it’s that you should look at the quality of evidence cited by the proponents of that medical claim. That’s why I mentioned acupuncture. Here at SBM, we’ve long pointed out how, as higher quality evidence from randomized controlled clinical trials of acupuncture that use proper blinding and better controls (i.e., sham acupuncture needles, acupuncture at the “wrong” sites that aren’t acupuncture points, actual double blinding to experimental group), it’s become increasingly obvious that acupuncture is nothing more than a theatrical placebo with no therapeutic effects, acupuncture advocates have shifted to preferring “pragmatic” trials. As Steve Novella pointed out so long ago, such studies are nothing more than the “rebranding” of unblinded trials. Early in the process of investigating a new treatment, unblinded studies can be justified as hypothesis-generating studies, but they are generally not considered the final word. Similarly, nonrandomized observational studies can be justified for a similar reason, in order to test whether larger randomized studies are justifiable.
It’s true that so-called “pragmatic” studies are also unblinded, but their purpose is different. They are not so much hypothesis generating as “real world” testing. As I’ve pointed out, such studies are “putting the cart before the horse“. The reason is that pragmatic trials do have a specific use in medicine. They are designed to test the “real world efficacy” of an intervention outside the highly controlled auspices of controlled randomized clinical trials (RCTs). The assumption is thus that the medical treatment being tested has already been demonstrated to be efficacious in RCTs and that the pragmatic trial is going to see how much less efficacious the treatment is when, as always happens when a new treatment is released “into the wild”, so to speak, it’s applied to a larger, less defined population with less rigor in methodology and follow-up.
The situation with ivermectin is similar in that ivermectin advocates prefer lower-quality clinical evidence than RCTs, because, as has been discussed here a number of times, all the high quality RCTs for ivermectin to treat COVID-19 have been resoundingly negative thus far, and the positive RCTs cited have all been found to contain, at best, serious flaws that invalidate their results, or to have been likely outright fraudulent. It turns out that all the dubious meta-analyses promoted by ivermectin advocates also become negative if these studies are left out (as they should have been, given their poor quality). In brief, all the higher-quality RCTs that tested whether ivermectin works are, as is the case of the higher quality RCTs of acupuncture for pretty much any indication, negative. There’s a definite rule of thumb at work here for the two. The higher quality the study, the more likely it is to be negative. Just as acupuncture advocates cite low quality unblinded studies that might have been acceptable early in the process of investigation, ivermectin advocates now cite lower quality studies that aren’t RCTs, and that’s exactly what Kim Iversen cites above.
Two observational studies that show…nothing
So let’s take a look at the two studies that Ms. Iversen touted in the Tweet that I quoted above. I’ll remind you of them by citing the Tweets again:
Here’s another PEER REVIEWED and published study showing 70% reduction in mortality compared to taking Remdesivir. https://t.co/2ppjE4Q5zb
— Kim Iversen 🇺🇸 (@KimIversenShow) March 8, 2022
The first cited study comes from Cureus and is titled “Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for COVID-19: A Citywide, Prospective, Observational Study of 223,128 Subjects Using Propensity Score Matching“. Most of the investigators are from Brazil, but one name stands out: Pierre Kory, MD of Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC). I’m not sure why it’s making the rounds now, given that it was first published two months ago, but such is life on social media. Either that, or it’s been making the rounds since then, but I just never noticed. I suspect that part of the reason is that it started out as a preprint that made the rounds even earlier. Indeed, in January, the FLCCC was flogging it thusly:
Results of the world’s largest study of ivermectin in COVID have just been posted. Meticulously collected data from hundreds of thousands of patients find massive reductions in hospitalization & death. “Controversy” over. Join us tomorrow for discussion with study investigators https://t.co/BQt9fia44I
— Pierre Kory, MD MPA (@PierreKory) January 5, 2022
You might well recall that the FLCCC is a group of doctors who are not at all “frontline” doctors treating COVID-10 but, as I’ve suggested, are prolific spreaders of COVID-19 misinformation, including antivaccine misinformation and the promotion of ivermectin as a cure-all for COVID-19. Last fall, they were even caught running a telehealth prescription mill selling ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine prescriptions to anyone who had the cash.
But what about the study itself? You can see how it might impress someone like Ms. Iversen, given that it involved looking at 223,128 subjects. However, quantity doesn’t always trump quality, and one notes right away that this study is not a randomized controlled clinical trial, but rather an observational study:
We analyzed data from a prospective, observational study of the citywide COVID-19 prevention with ivermectin program, which was conducted between July 2020 and December 2020 in Itajaí, Brazil. Study design, institutional review board approval, and analysis of registry data occurred after completion of the program. The program consisted of inviting the entire population of Itajaí to a medical visit to enroll in the program and to compile baseline, personal, demographic, and medical information. In the absence of contraindications, ivermectin was offered as an optional treatment to be taken for two consecutive days every 15 days at a dose of 0.2 mg/kg/day. In cases where a participating citizen of Itajaí became ill with COVID-19, they were recommended not to use ivermectin or any other medication in early outpatient treatment. Clinical outcomes of infection, hospitalization, and death were automatically reported and entered into the registry in real time. Study analysis consisted of comparing ivermectin users with non-users using cohorts of infected patients propensity score-matched by age, sex, and comorbidities. COVID-19 infection and mortality rates were analyzed with and without the use of propensity score matching (PSM).
Reading the paper, I honestly was a bit confused. Reading the abstract and the methods, it came across to me that ivermectin was offered as prophylaxis to everyone but if anyone became sick with COVID-19 it was not recommended, and, yes, that appears to be what was done:
Patients who presented signs or the diagnosis of COVID-19 before July 7, 2020, were excluded from the sample. Other exclusion criteria were contraindications to ivermectin and subjects below 18 years of age. The dose and frequency of ivermectin treatment was 0.2 mg/kg/day; i.e., giving one 6 mg tablet for every 30 kg for two consecutive days every 15 days.
During the study, subjects who were diagnosed with COVID-19 underwent a specific medical visit to assess COVID-19 clinical manifestations and severity. All subjects were recommended not to use ivermectin, nitazoxanide, hydroxychloroquine, spironolactone, or any other drug claimed to be effective against COVID-19. The city did not provide or support any specific pharmacological outpatient treatment for subjects infected with COVID-19.
This is, to say the least, a rather strange design. First, of all, when this study first started, people were asking the same question as I was: Why on earth would you recommend that patients take two doses, separated by a day, every two weeks?
Odd protocol or not, let’s see what the authors claim to have found:
Summarized thusly:
Of the 223,128 citizens of Itajaí considered for the study, a total of 159,561 subjects were included in the analysis: 113,845 (71.3%) regular ivermectin users and 45,716 (23.3%) non-users. Of these, 4,311 ivermectin users were infected, among which 4,197 were from the city of Itajaí (3.7% infection rate), and 3,034 non-users (from Itajaí) were infected (6.6% infection rate), with a 44% reduction in COVID-19 infection rate (risk ratio [RR], 0.56; 95% confidence interval (95% CI), 0.53-0.58; p
Leading to the conclusion:
In this large PSM study, regular use of ivermectin as a prophylactic agent was associated with significantly reduced COVID-19 infection, hospitalization, and mortality rates.
If you believe this study, then, everyone should be taking ivermectin, two doses separated by a day, every two weeks. But should we believe it? There are a number of reasons not to, not the least of which is Kyle Sheldrick’s analysis:
And:
Oh look, the appendix was taken down after its impossibilities were noted.
Why am I not surprised? 🙄https://t.co/2bAIFmPWYzhttps://t.co/s6nO1O2Pd4https://t.co/R1DH46v616 pic.twitter.com/D6xDcELBmC
— Atomsk's Sanakan (@AtomsksSanakan) January 10, 2022
And:
In other words, data being presented…changed. Also, as pointed out by Sheldrick, the analysis claimed is pretty much impossible and hidden behind “data available upon request”:
They've taken those "data available from the corresponding author on reasonable request" statements to the next level.
When are we going to see "title available on reasonable request"?
— longfacehorse (@longfacehorse) January 10, 2022
In other words, not only is this study not a randomized clinical trial, which is how you really determine if a drug treatment works, either to treat or prevent a disease, but it has a lot of…issues. These are issues similar to some of the randomized trials. It’s not clear to me whether this is sloppiness or potentially outright fraud; it could be either. However, this is not a good study. It does appear very impressive, though, to people like Ms. Iversen. I also rather doubt that it was truly a prospective study. Rather, it appears to be a retrospective study masquerading as a prospective study:
This was a prospective, observational study. Although study design, institutional review board (IRB) approval, and data analysis occurred after completion of the voluntary prophylaxis program, all data were collected prospectively in real time with mandated reporting to the registry of all events as they occurred during the citywide governmental COVID-19 prevention with ivermectin program, from July 2020 to December 2020, developed in the city of Itajaí, in the state of Santa Catarina, Brazil. Demographic and clinical data were reported from medical records of patients followed in a large outpatient setting (a provisional outpatient clinic set in the Convention Center of Itajaí) and several secondary outpatient settings, as part of the universal health system (Sistema Único de Saúde [SUS]).
Why is this important? In retrospective studies, one looks at an existing dataset; i.e., patients in the past. In a prospective study, one sets up and looks at patients as they present and collects the data as it happens. Given that, retrospective studies tend to be more bias-prone. What we appear to have here is a prospective data collection for residents of Itajaí onto which was later grafted a retrospective study. Here’s a hint: Just because the data were collected prospectively, you can’t call your study prospective if you designed it after data collection had been completed.
Similarly, the claim that there was a dose-response, I love how Sheldrick described how a massive apparent decrease in mortality could be observed even if ivermectin did nothing. I quote him here because he describes it better and more succinctly than I ever could:
On to the next study.
This study is titled “ Treatment with Ivermectin Is Associated with Decreased Mortality in COVID-19 Patients: Analysis of a National Federated Database“. Not giving me confidence in their abilities, the investigators are plastic surgeons and urologists at the University of Miami. Nothing against University of Miami, but rather plastic surgeons and urologists are generally not the ones who have the correct skills to do a study like this. In any event, this study is also being promoted by FLCCC. Amusingly, one of the authors, a medical student, pushed back:
Hi Dr. Peterson, first author of the paper, I think the information and data is being crudely misrepresented and misinterpreted. This is an abstract (NOT PEER REVIEWED) from a conference I presented at. We did not submit the manuscript for a reason, weak evidence.
— Iakov Efimenko (@AesBrah) March 8, 2022
And he’s right! I didn’t notice that at first, namely that it’s published in a supplement of the International Journal of Infectious Diseases dedicated to publishing Abstracts from the Eighth International Meeting on Emerging Diseases and Surveillance, IMED 2021, November 4-6, 2021. That’s why there’s just an abstract with no full article. I’ll give the student, Iakov Efimenko, credit for being honest. What I won’t do is to spare his mentors. Students can be forgiven for this bad a study, particularly when they learn from the mistake, mentors less so.
Basically, this is an example of confounding by indication. In a retrospective database review, the authors compared patients who received remdesivir for COVID-19 to those who received ivermectin. Can anyone see the problem? It should be obvious, and the name of the confounding should tell you: Patients who receive remdesivir receive it intravenously and are pretty much all hospitalized, while those who receive ivermectin take it as outpatients. As a result, it would be expected that the remdesivir patients would do worse; they’re all hospitalized, and the study didn’t correct for that!
Or:
World's worst study. Remdesivir has to be used as inpatient therapy so patients are already hospitalized vs an oral drug that you can take at any stage of the disease. Worthless data from the bright minds of the department of Plastic Surgery.
— B&B (@Bladeandbarrel) March 3, 2022
Personally, after perusing this thread, I’m less harsh, at least on the students:
New embarrassingly bad study of ivermectin is a textbook example of “confounding by indication”
In short a retroactive database review found that people w/ COVID did worse if given remdesivir (only given to sick inpatients) than ivermectin (only given to well outpatients)🤔 1/ pic.twitter.com/f76tBBmuVl
— Nick Mark MD (@nickmmark) March 3, 2022
The methods are weird.
They found 1.7 million people w/ COVID. Out of this group they identified 1,072 who received ivermectin (not exactly widely used) & 40k who received remdesivir
The groups were very dissimilar: IVM was 10 yrs younger. They don’t report any comorbidities3/ pic.twitter.com/RI2n1orRcI
— Nick Mark MD (@nickmmark) March 3, 2022
The authors are interesting…
The first two are medical students, the 3rd is a plastic surgery resident.(Nothing wrong with this, though it is weird for the MS not to be affiliated w/ SOM)
The fifth & sixth authors are plastic surgeons. Neither has expertise in ID or COVID5/ pic.twitter.com/wIu7SL1hrI
— Nick Mark MD (@nickmmark) March 3, 2022
All of this makes me wonder – did the authors all even read/approve this abstract?
Did the peer reviewers think it was odd that plastic surgeons were doing research on ivermectin for COVID?7/
— Nick Mark MD (@nickmmark) March 3, 2022
As Dr. Mark must know, peer review of abstracts for meetings is pretty perfunctory. Usually most of them are approved for at least a poster presentation. Also, these days, it seems that all specialties seem to view themselves as qualified to do COVID-19 research. I have, after all, seen orthopedic surgeons, ophthalmologists, and all manner of specialties without special expertise in infectious diseases doing COVID-19 research.
In any event, this, too, is not a good study, even as a preliminary hypothesis-generating paper, given the obvious confounders based on indication, hospitalization, and age. It is, however, an excellent case study in the creation of COVID-19 misinformation in real time:
Notice the part where the author woke up to find that his conference abstract had been shared thousands and thousands of times on social media. Notice also how YouTube’s accursed algorithm “suggests” a couple of the very videos by ivermectin-pushing influencers that were mentioned in this video as falsely portraying this abstract as slam-dunk evidence that ivermectin works against COVID-19. It had even been included in the “meta-analysis” at IVMmeta, an anonymous pro-ivermectin site that claims to be doing a “real time meta-analysis” of ivermectin studies.
Ivermectin: The acupuncture of COVID-19
Coming out last week were stories about yet another negative RCT for ivermectin versus COVID-19, for example, this one in The Wall Street Journal, “Ivermectin Didn’t Reduce Covid-19 Hospitalizations in Largest Trial to Date“:
The latest trial, of nearly 1,400 Covid-19 patients at risk of severe disease, is the largest to show that those who received ivermectin as a treatment didn’t fare better than those who received a placebo.
“There was no indication that ivermectin is clinically useful,” said Edward Mills, one of the study’s lead researchers and a professor of health sciences at Canada’s McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. Dr. Mills on Friday plans to present the findings, which have been accepted for publication in a major peer-reviewed medical journal, at a public forum sponsored by the National Institutes of Health.
And:
The researchers prescribed half of the patients a course of ivermectin pills for three days. The other half received a placebo. They tracked whether the patients were hospitalized within 28 days. The researchers also looked at whether patients on ivermectin cleared the virus from their bodies faster than those who received a placebo, whether their symptoms resolved sooner, whether they were in the hospital or on ventilators for less time and whether there was any difference in the death rates for the two groups.
But, but, but…, I can hear some of you saying. This study hasn’t been published yet! You’re just citing a newspaper article! True enough. That’s exactly why I only mention this study—and only very briefly, at that—because it is yet another RCT that has failed to find a therapeutic effect for ivermectin versus COVID-19. (If it were the only RCT, I would have waited for it to be published in the peer-reviewed literature before discussing it.) There are a number of other such RCTs, and, again, all the high quality RCTs are negative, including another recent RCT, which was also negative.
Add to that the extreme biological implausibility behind the hypothesis that ivermectin can treat COVID-19. While it is true that ivermectin demonstrates antiviral activity against SARS-CoV-2 in cell culture, the concentrations required are much higher than what can be achieved in the human body. These observations alone meant that it was always highly unlikely that this repurposed anthelminthic drug (used to treat roundworm infestation-based diseases) would ever show activity against COVID-19 in humans at nontoxic (or even toxic) doses. As I described the last time I wrote about ivermectin a few months ago, the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics always meant that the drug probably wouldn’t work in humans, and ivermectin is not “Pfizermectin,” as is claimed in a common conspiracy theory based on the fact that Pfizer’s new COVID-19 drug Paxlovid is a protease inhibitor and ivermectin also demonstrates protease inhibitor activity in cell culture.
The bottom line is that there is now an increasing body of high quality evidence demonstrating that there is no detectable therapeutic effect due to ivermectin against COVID-19. So what are activists doing? Like acupuncture advocates, they’ve stopped looking at high quality RCTs, which are pretty much all negative, and turned their attention to poorer quality studies. Just as acupuncture advocates turned their attention to touting unblinded studies and pragmatic studies, so too are ivermectin advocates now touting retrospective analyses, which can be hypothesis-generating in the absence of an RCT but are, from my perspective, close to pointless in the context of a situation in which several negative RCTs exist. They’re even doing the same thing as acupuncture advocates; i.e., lobbying state legislators for laws that permit their treatment even in the absence of high quality evidence for it, all in the name of “health freedom”.
Truly, ivermectin has become the acupuncture of COVID-19.

Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine Six Years On
Steven Novella on September 2, 2026
Link

We deal with a seemingly endless conveyor belt of fad quack remedies (the proverbial game of whack-a-mole). We always have some new nonsense to deal with. For this reason I occasionally will look back at the pseudosciences of yesterday to get an update on any relevant research.
It often takes years, even decades, for definitive clinical research to get done, long after the public’s attention span has waned and the charlatans have moved on to the next con. This means the snake oil peddlers get to make unjustified overhyped statements about their latest miracle remedy, and our response is often mostly that the plausibility is low and there currently is insufficient clinical evidence to recommend the treatment. Then, years later, when the clinical evidence is there, everyone has moved on. It’s an endless cycle.
So let’s take some time to look back and a couple of dubious treatments for COVID, see what people said at the time, and where the latest clinical evidence is – ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine (HCQ). You can just search our posts to see what we here at SBM had to say. For example, Scott Gavura started a series of posts – Ivermectin is the new hydroxychloroquine – in which he concluded (in 2021), “Similar to hydroxychloroquine, there is no convincing evidence that demonstrates ivermectin has any meaningful clinical effects in the treatment of COVID-19.” No one here recommended the use of either drug, which were just distractions from effective treatments.
What were the less credible sources saying at the time? RFK Jr. in an interview with Children’s Health Defense in December 2020 said, “if hydroxychloroquine works, which it does. And if Ivermectin works, which it definitely does, he legally can not get emergency use authorization for any vaccines, because if there’s an approved drug that works against you, you cannot get emergency use authorization. So he had to kill hydroxychloroquine. He had to kill Ivermectin.”
As an aside, I suggest you read the whole transcript (even though the formatting is terrible). It’s always informative to listen to someone like RFK speak when they think they are speaking to compatriots. The nonsense flows unobstructed. The interview is an endless stream of lies, distortions, and rank conspiracy mongering.
Also in 2021, Dr. Pierre Kory, a critical care specialist and co-founder of Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance, said, “Mountains of data have emerged from many centers and countries around the world showing the miraculous effectiveness of ivermectin, it basically obliterates transmission of this virus. If you take it, you will not get sick.”
In 2020 Dr. Vladimir “Zev” Zelenko said, “Any obstruction to life saving medication (HCQ) should be viewed has crimes against humanity.”
There are many more examples, but you get the idea. Promotion of both of these drugs were definitive, unqualified, and incredibly hyped. There were all all entirely wrong. Let’s take a look at the updated evidence, starting with ivermectin. The latest systematic review is from this year, 2026, which looks at a total of 40 RCTs involving 23,243. The found: “For prevention, there was no statistically significant difference between the ivermectin group and control group in SARS-CoV-2 infection rate [risk ratio (RR) 0.37; 95% Confidence Interval (CI) 0.12 to 1.20]. For treatment, all-cause mortality for both hospitalized patients (RR 0.94; 95%CI 0.74 to 1.20) and outpatients (RR 0.88; 95%CI 0.55 to 1.42) showed no statistically significant difference.” They then concluded that, “This meta-analysis provides evidence that ivermectin does not statistically significantly reduce the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection or improve clinical outcomes in patients with COVID-19.”
This was the latest but not necessarily the best systematic review. Another review from 2025 was a bit more rigorous, because it assessed risk of bias, and stuck to randomize controlled clinical trials. They also found that ivermectin was not associated with any benefit for either treatment or prophylaxis.
Another 2025 review found, “ivermectin did not significantly influence critical clinical outcomes in COVID-19 patients.”
These outcomes are consistent with older reviews, which shows that additional, larger, more rigorous studies confirmed what the older studies showed – that ivermectin is simply not an effective treatment for COVID-19. It takes a lot of studies, however, to reach such conclusions. Treatments can be tested in different populations, in-patient vs out-patient, as treatment vs prophylaxis, and following different outcomes such as length of hospital stay, mortality, severity, and transmissibility. But no matter how you look at it – ivermectin simply does not work.
So why did RFK Jr. and so many others say that “it definitely does”? It’s just more evidence that RFK is not a scientist, not a doctor, not a critical thinker, and frankly does not know what he is talking about. He is a conspiracy theorist and his logic is biased and muddled. He has a consistently poor grasp on fine details, always in the direction that serves his narrative. Again – read the interview, it’s amazing.
What about hydroxychloroquine? The latest relevant review is from 2025, which looks as many treatments, and conclude in part, “Several interventions do not seem to result in a benefit for any patient important outcomes, including ACEi/ARB, aspirin, colchicine, fluvoxamine, hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, and lopinavir-ritonavir.”
The most recent review of HCG specifically is from 2024, and found not benefit from HCG for any treatment outcome in COVID, and perhaps a small prophylactic benefit although with low confidence that should be “interpreted with caution”. So essentially, no clear benefit for prevention or treatment.
This is all in line with this Cochrane review from 2020, in which the data was already so definitively negative that Cochrane uncharacteristically concluded: “We do not think new studies of hydroxychloroquine should be started for treatment of COVID-19.”
So 5-6 years later updated systematic reviews of the additional clinical trials even more confidently conclude that both ivermectin and HCG are of no benefit for the prevention or treatment of COVID-19. I feel compelled to point out – this is not an isolated or cherry picked example. This is what we see over and over again. Those following a science-based medicine approach have a much greater success at predicting later research than those hyping miracle cures.
There is a reason for this. The whole idea behind SBM is to develop and constantly tweak the best methods for predicting the probability that any intervention will be safe and effective, based upon a detailed inference from all available scientific evidence. What this simply means is that science works, but you have to look at the scientific evidence in a rigorous and unbiased way. There’s the rub.

Pfizer’s new COVID-19 protease inhibitor drug is not just “repackaged ivermectin”
Pfizer recently announced that its new protease inhibitor-based drug was 89% effective in preventing hospitalization due to COVID-19 and it is seeking an emergency use authorization for it from the FDA. Antivaxxers claim that ivermectin targets the same protease and is being “suppressed” to protect Pfizer’s profits from the new drug. What’s the real story? Hint: Antivaxxers took a grain of truth and—shall we say?—exaggerated. A lot.
David Gorski on November 15, 2021
Link
Last week, Steve Novella discussed announcements of drugs that, unlike the “miracle cures” (primarily hydroxychloroquine in 2020 and ivermectin this year) that have been promoted so heavily on social media, actually have evidence for their efficacy against COVID-19. Specifically, he mentioned Pfizer’s new drug Paxlovid, which in its clinical trials was 89% effective in preventing hospitalization due to COVID-19 if taken soon after symptoms develop. The other drug was Merck’s molnupiravir (trade name to be Lagevrio), which is now available through a clinical trial in the UK. Both drugs are very promising, and the Pfizer drug (a combination of PF-07321332 and ritonavir—more on why it’s a combination later—before it received a trade name), for example, decreased the hospitalization rate from 7% to 0.8% over 28 days in a Phase 2/3 study, which Steve correctly described as a “good absolute and relative risk reduction”, with no deaths in the drug treatment arm. (It was so good that Pfizer stopped the study, because it would be unethical to continue with such a result in an interim analysis.) As a result, Pfizer has applied for an emergency use authorization for its drug. In an interim analysis of a phase 3 study, the Merck drug demonstrated a 50% reduction in hospitalization, again with no deaths in the treatment arm.
Unsurprisingly, COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and antivaxxers are not pleased. This is why they seem to have come up with one of the sillier claims that I’ve seen thus far, although I must admit that it’s not obvious how silly they are if you don’t have a background in drug development and some specific knowledge about ivermectin and the Pfizer drug. (That’s rather the point.) Here are a couple of representative Tweets. I could post a whole bunch of them, but will restrain myself:
Protease inhibitors are established tools for preventing viral infections. The latest one from Pfizer inhibits an important protease used by the virus. One of the unmentionable compounds Ixx does that & more. Many other OTC compounds also do this. Why is this suppressed?
— pmcd (@pmcdunnough) November 12, 2021
And, of course:
John Campbell PhD explaining the similarities & differences between Ivermectin & Paxlovid.
Study of Uttar Pradesh (and how the media avoid India now that they're no longer a C19-disaster zone!) tells it all..
Meanwhile 100% of IC patients in GZA-hospitals in Antwerp are vaxxed. pic.twitter.com/WS0alaynDO
— miles. (@miles22402745) November 10, 2021
The basic idea behind this conspiracy theory is simple. Both ivermectin and the Pfizer drug are protease inhibitors, but ivermectin is being “suppressed” because Pfizer wants to make huge profits from its drug Paxlovid and ivermectin is a cheap competitor. (Merck’s drug is not a protease inhibitor, but instead works by being incorporated into the new RNA strand being copied to be packaged into the new virus particles being produced, where it, as one scientist put it, causes the coronavirus to “mutate itself to death.”)
As is the case with many COVID-19 conspiracy theories, there is a tiny grain of truth in the comparison of the drugs, but only a very tiny grain that conspiracy theorists seem to view as a whole field of wheat. In this post, I’ll discuss how one has to ignore some very basic pharmacological principles that differentiate the drugs in order to make the leap to the claim that ivermectin is just like Paxlovid, but being “suppressed” because it’s cheap and generic, as opposed to Paxlovid, which will be on patent and, of course, not cheap. In fact, ignoring one principle will do, the same pharmacological principle whose willful misunderstanding led to people claiming that ivermectin is a miracle cure for COVID-19, namely that concentration matters.
Spoiler alert: Ivermectin does inhibit the same protease that PF-07321332 does, but, as is the case for viral replication, it requires a concentration that is not achievable by oral dosing.
How does Paxlovid work?
As the conspiracy theorists point out correctly, Paxlovid belongs to a general class of drugs known as protease inhibitors. Enzymes belonging to the class of proteases break down proteins by specifically cleaving them into smaller peptides, often by recognizing a specific short amino acid sequence. (Indeed, back in my lab days, we used to use a trypsin to digest the proteins that held cells in cell culture to the substrate, so that we could replate them. Trypsin digests only at a very specific amino acid sequence.) There are a wide variety of proteases in nature, including serine proteases, cysteine proteases, metalloproteases, and more, with some working better in acid pH conditions, others in neutral or basic pH. These proteases are ubiquitous, as well, occurring in basically all organisms ranging from procaryotes to humans and are involved in a wide variety of physiological processes. The aforementioned trypsin, for instance, is a digestive enzyme normally found in the proximal small intestine.
It is therefore unsurprising that many viruses use proteases in their life cycles. The most famous of these among the general public is likely the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), which causes acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). It is the HIV protease that is the key target of the protease inhibitor cocktails that revolutionized the treatment of AIDS in the 1990s, changing it from a virtual death sentence to a chronic, manageable disease:
The main purpose of HIV is to copy itself as many times as it can. However, HIV lacks the machinery it needs to reproduce itself. Instead, it injects its genetic material into immune cells in the body called CD4 cells. It then uses these cells as a kind of HIV virus factory.
Protease is an enzyme in the body that’s important for HIV replication. Protease inhibitor drugs block the action of protease enzymes. This prevents protease enzymes from doing their part in allowing HIV to multiply, interrupting the HIV life cycle as a result. This can stop the virus from multiplying.
There are, of course, now a number of protease inhibitors approved for the use in treating HIV/AIDS, such as atazanavir, fosamprenavir, ritonavir, and others. In any event, protease inhibitors are the mainstays for the HIV/AIDS treatment known as HAART (highly active antiretroviral therapy), which usually consists of three or more medications to treat HIV, mixing protease inhibitors with other antiretroviral drugs. (Yes, some COVID-19 conspiracy theorists are noting that protease inhibitors are used to treat AIDS as well, and then circling back to an older—several months!—conspiracy theory that COVID-19 vaccines make you more susceptible to AIDS. (They don’t.)
Which brings us to PF-07321332.
PF-07321332 is a class of protease inhibitor that targets the 3C-like protease, which is the main protease found in coronaviruses. (Other names for this protease include coronavirus 3C-like protease, Mpro, SARS 3C-like protease, SARS coronavirus 3CL protease, SARS coronavirus main peptidase, SARS coronavirus main protease, SARS-CoV 3CLpro enzyme, SARS-CoV main protease, SARS-CoV Mpro and severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus main protease.) This particular protease has long been recognized as a potential drug target for the treatment of coronavirus-induced diseases because it plays a key role in processing the polyproteins translated from the viral RNA into functional viral proteins.
An article from Science explains in lay terms:
Monoclonal antibodies blocking surface proteins of the coronavirus can slow the infection of new cells with SARS-CoV-2, but their application has been hamstrung by cost, availability, and the need to infuse or inject them. In contrast, Pfizer’s ingestible candidate operates inside an infected cell; it blocks enzymes, called proteases, that normally act early in a virus’ life cycle to help it replicate (see graphic, below). Many protease inhibitors are approved for HIV treatment, and Pfizer’s compound has a nearly 20-year history. Pfizer scientists designed a version of the compound back in 2003 to block a protease in the coronavirus that causes severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), a cousin of SARS-CoV-2.
And:
As SARS-CoV-2 infects cells, reproduces itself, and spreads, the coronavirus relies on dozens of viral and host proteins to complete its life cycle. Pfizer’s new oral pill inhibits the main viral protease used to create other proteins for the virus. And Merck’s drug inserts a defective RNA building block when the virus uses an enzyme known as a polymerase to copy its genome.
And here’s a visual representation:
Steps in SARS-CoV-2 replication
Where Paxlovid/PF-07321332 and molnupiravir target the SARS-CoV-2 life cycle.
And another figure demonstrating how a long SARS-CoV-2 protein is cleaved into smaller structural proteins:
As Steve discussed last week, the rapid development of these two drugs adds more hope that the pandemic can finally be brought under control and become manageable, given that we have safe and effective vaccines and now drugs that can be used to treat the unvaccinated who become ill or the unfortunate vaccinated people who suffer breakthrough infections and, if real world data resemble clinical trial data, prevent the vast majority of them from dying or even requiring hospitalization.
It also turns out that PF-07321332 has been a long time coming. In the paper reporting the drug as a promising candidate to treat COVID-19:
In effort to identify inhibitors of the SARS-CoV-1 Mpro in response to the 2002 SARS outbreak led to the identification of PF-00835231 (1, Fig. 1) as a potent inhibitor of recombinant SARS-CoV-1 Mpro in a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based substrate cleavage assay (17). PF-00835231 also demonstrated potent inhibition (inhibition constant (Ki) = 0.271 nM) of recombinant SARS-CoV-2 Mpro, which is expected given that the SARS-CoV-1 and -CoV-2 Mpro share 100% sequence homology across their respective substrate binding sites (18).
Unfortunately, potent in vitro activity against a drug’s target does not necessarily translate to a good drug, and PF-00835231 had poor bioavailability. Specifically, it was poorly absorbed when given orally to experimental animals. So, as pharmacologists do when they have a potent drug candidate that isn’t well absorbed, Pfizer scientists started chemically modifying it to improve its oral bioavailability and testing those analogues in vitro for activity against the 3CL, and:
PF-07321332 demonstrated potent inhibition in FRET Mpro assays representing Mpro from all coronavirus types known to infect humans (6, 7, 30), including beta-coronaviruses (SARS-CoV-2, SARS-CoV-1, HKU1, OC43, MERS) as well as alpha-coronaviruses (229E, NL63) (Fig. 3B and table S2). No inhibitory effects were noted against several mammalian cysteine (caspase 2, cathepsin B, cathepsin L), serine (chymotrypsin, elastase, thrombin) and aspartyl (cathepsin D) proteases at the highest concentration tested (100 μM) of PF-07321332 (table S3). This was also the case for HIV-1 protease, a viral aspartyl protease (table S3).
That last part is important, because specificity is important. PF-07321332 would not have been very useful if, in addition to the SARS-CoV-2 protease, it also inhibited human proteases important in a number of processes, such as protein digestion. Such inhibition could have caused a number of undesirable and potentially harmful gastrointestinal side effects. PF-07321332 did not and was therefore deemed a good candidate with good oral bioavailability. It also exhibited potent antiviral activity against SARS-CoV-2 in vitro.
There was still a problem, though. There’s a reason that Paxlovid is a combination drug, containing PF-07321332 with ritonavir, an anti-HIV drug:
Paxlovid is a combination of two different drugs – the HIV drug ritonavir (a capsule) and an experimental drug PF-07321332 (a pill).
Ritonavir protects the body from metabolising PF-07321332. It acts by being broken down by the body first (known as a sacrificial chemical) to ensure enough PF-07321332 reaches the virus intact.
It’s a clever strategy to maximize the efficacy of PF-07321332. CYP3A4 is a P450 enzyme and often considered the most important drug-metabolizing enzyme, among the most abundant of its type in the liver. As noted by Pfizer:
These in vitro studies, which established a predominant role for CYP3A4 in the metabolism of PF-07321332, also presented an opportunity to boost therapeutic concentrations of PF-07321332 in the clinic via co-dosing with the potent CYP3A4 inactivator ritonavir (RTV), which is used as a pharmacokinetic enhancer of several marketed protease inhibitors (e.g., darunavir, lopinavir) that are subject to metabolic clearance via CYP3A4 (35, 36).
Before I move on, I will note that drug companies like Pfizer often have huge libraries of compounds predicted to target certain enzymes based on computer modeling, and we can expect more compounds like this in the future to be tested.
Speaking of computer libraries, let’s contrast Pfizer’s Paxlovid with ivermectin.
“Ivermectin works just like the Pfizer drug!” Not so much.
So where does the claim that Paxlovid is just “repackaged ivermectin” designed to increase pharma profits come from? Again, it reminds me a lot of how ivermectin came to be thought of as a “miracle cure” for COVID-19 based mainly on in vitro studies of its ability to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 replication cell culture. To that end, let’s look at the paper from which I took one of the figures above. Basically, it was a computer modeling study that was used to identify existing compounds that could target 3CLPro, hence the segue I used. The authors used computer modeling to identify potential promising candidates to inhibit 3CLPro and then tested the top “hits” in cell culture. One of the compounds identified by this strategy was ivermectin.
Before I get to this, let me just point out that it was thought that ivermectin inhibited SARS-CoV-2 replication through the inhibition of a different protein, α/β1 importin, something reported a decade ago. This particular protein is involved in the transport of proteins into the nucleus from the cytoplasm. In the case of SARs-CoV-2 infection, the transport of certain proteins into the nucleus is important for completion of its lifecycle. (I won’t go into the details other than that.)
Now here’s the thing. Inhibition of this protein complex by ivermectin and preventing the replication of HIV and the Dengue virus requires fairly high concentrations (at least in terms of drug concentrations). The original Australian paper that examined the ability of ivermectin to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 replication showed similar results. Now the problem. As stated in this review:
As noted, the activity of ivermectin in cell culture has not reproduced in mouse infection models against many of the viruses and has not been clinically proven either, in spite of ivermectin being available globally. This is likely related to the pharmacokinetics and therapeutic safety window for ivermectin. The blood levels of ivermectin at safe therapeutic doses are in the 20–80 ng/ml range [44], while the activity against SARS-CoV2 in cell culture is in the microgram range. Ivermectin is administered orally or topically. If safe formulations or analogs can be derived that can be administered to achieve therapeutic concentrations, ivermectin could be useful as a broad-spectrum antiviral agent.
Even this paper proposing ivermectin as a treatment for COVID-19 notes:
A dose of 12 mg twice daily alone or in combination with other therapy for 5–7 days has been proposed as a safe therapeutic option for mild, moderate or severe cases of Covid-19 infection.10 The time to reach maximum plasma concentration of 20–50 ng/ml, after a dose of 6 or 12 mg, respectively is approximately 4 h.
This was almost certainly the reason that ivermectin doesn’t work against COVID-19 in spite of its activity in vitro against SARS-CoV-2. It requires a concentration 10- to 20-fold higher than is safely achievable in the blood. That’s why the review concluded that maybe an ivermectin analogue that is either more active or can achieve a higher concentration safely in the bloodstream is worth investigating. Ivermectin itself is a crap drug based on that mechanism.
But what about its protease inhibition? It’s the same damned principle. Yes, ivermectin can inhibit 3CLPro in vitro, but it’s the same old story, as has been pointed out:
There is a tiny iota of truth: There *is* evidence that both drugs bind/inhibit the viral main protease (Mpro).
But there is a critical difference between them:
For PF-07321332 this is at a concentration actually achievable in vivo (3nM), ivermectin isn’t even close (21μM)!2/ pic.twitter.com/m21jkKZDv1
— Nick Mark MD (@nickmmark) November 8, 2021
The papers to which Nick is referring are the Pfizer paper, recently published and no longer a preprint, and the computer modeling paper.
I further note that these efforts to target 3CLPro date back to 2003 during the original SARS epidemic:
I am told (in general) that they have large libraries of enzymes / protease inhibitors they scan through (in silicon). They then try to find a pre-existing one with properties similar to what they want, then start modifications and testing from there to get a better match.
— Punctuated Equilibrium 🦠x0 🇮🇱🇺🇸🇨🇼🇪🇬🎗️ (@GainOfDystopia) November 6, 2021
To put things in full context, here’s a reminder. Nanomolar (nM, 10-9 mol/L) concentrations are 1,000-fold lower than micromolar (μM, 10-6 mol/L). The idea is the same for 3CLPro as it was for α/β1 importin. The concentrations of ivermectin needed to inhibit 3CLPro are much, much higher than can be safely achieved in the blood and extracellular fluids of human beings with oral dosing, and it that’s what needs to happen for the drug to work in a living, breathing human being. Many are the drugs that show good activity in cell culture but founder when the attempt is made to test them in mice and other laboratory animals. It turns out that this is just one (among many) reasons why drug development is very, very hard and that promising compounds that appear to work well in cell culture fail when tested in animals.
Indeed, let’s just say that a Ki (the concentration producing 50% of maximal inhibition of a target) of 3.1 nM for a target like 3CLPro is the sort of incredibly low Ki that pharmacologists and medicinal chemists dream about when trying to develop a new drug to target a specific enzyme. I myself have fallen victim to the very same problem in my research career so I am very, very aware of this problem. Let’s just say that my drug’s Ki was a lot closer to that of ivermectin than that of PF-07321332. Let’s also say that my drug, like ivermectin, shows a lot of other fairly nonspecific activities that require high concentrations as well and leave it at that. Again, drug development is hard, and promising compounds that work in cell culture often fail for reasons of achievable plasma concentrations and pharmacokinetics, something that anyone who’s done drug development is painfully aware of.
Unfortunately, apparently ivermectin cultists are not aware of this very basic principle, which is why the drug was promoted based on an Australian cell culture study that in and of itself strongly suggested that the drug was actually not a particular promising COVID-19 treatment based on pharmacokinetic considerations alone with respect to its ability to inhibit viral replication and α/β1 importin. Now they’re doing it again based on a study that shows that ivermectin is not a particularly promising COVID-19 treatment based on pharmacokinetic considerations alone, just this time with a different target, 3CLPro.
        ◦ Contrary to the conspiracy theory being pushed by cranks, Paxlovid is not just “repackaged” ivermectin, and ivermectin isn’t being “suppressed” to protect the profits of Pfizer. No one, least of all I, denies that large pharmaceutical companies have done some pretty shady things, but “suppressing” ivermectin in favor of the Pfizer and Merck drugs does not appear to be one of them. Ivermectin, although a fantastic drug to treat diseases caused by roundworm infestations, just doesn’t work against COVID-19, and there was never any really compelling reason to suspect that it would. Now here’s hoping that the clinical trial results for PF-07321332 (Paxlovid) and molnupiravir (Lagevrio) hold up in the real world. That would truly be as much of a game-changer as the development of effective and safe vaccines a year ago.

Science-based medicine isn’t just for CAM. The case of ivermectin shows that it never was.
Another large randomized controlled trial for ivermectin showed no efficacy for the early treatment of COVID-19. This is not a surprise to science-based medicine advocates. Here’s why the story of ivermectin shows that SBM isn’t just for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) —and never was.
David Gorski on April 4, 2022
Link

A couple of weeks ago, I likened ivermectin to acupuncture. The reason why the comparison came to me is because the reaction of those promoting ivermectin as a highly effective treatment—miracle cure, even—for COVID-19 is the same approach to evidence demonstrated by advocates of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM)—or, as it’s now called, “integrative medicine” or “integrative health”—and especially by acupuncture advocates. Specifically, as more and more high-quality evidence from randomized clinical trials has failed to find a therapeutic effect from using ivermectin to treat COVID-19, increasingly its advocates point to positive studies that are less rigorous, such as observational and uncontrolled clinical studies. This is, more or less, exactly what acupuncture advocates have been doing as more and more high-quality studies with appropriate sham acupuncture placebo groups fail to find a detectable benefit for acupuncture for treating anything. They’ve been citing lower quality “pragmatic” studies, which might not be blinded (much less double-blinded), placebo-controlled, or, in some cases, even randomized. As I explain time and time again, though, citing pragmatic studies is putting the cart before the horse. Pragmatic studies are intended to see how well a treatment that’s been shown to work in high quality randomized controlled clinical trials works “out in the wild” outside of clinical trials and all the rigid protocols and selection criteria, a situation where the indications for the treatment inevitably expand as well. Ivermectin advocates even use the same sorts of excuses, too, when randomized controlled trials (RCTs) fail to show a benefit when ivermectin is used to treat COVID-19, such as claiming that medicine is biased and there is a double standard. (There is a double standard, but it doesn’t favor what acupuncture and ivermectin advocates think it does.)
In my post two weeks ago, I briefly mentioned an RCT of ivermectin for COVID-19 that was very much negative, but I didn’t discuss it extensively because it had not yet been published and had only been publicized in a news report from The Wall Street Journal. It turns out that last Thursday the study was finally published, in The New England Journal of Medicine, and, as described, it was a resoundingly negative trial, without even a hint of a whiff of efficacy. Was it a perfect trial? Of course not. No trial is. It was, however, large and well-designed and showed zero detectable effect from the early treatment of COVID-19 with ivermectin on hospitalizations and emergency room monitoring. As such, it was just one more drop in the drip-drip-drip of negative RCTs for ivermectin. Along with the drip-drip-drip of evidence that the most famous and largest RCTs of ivermectin for COVID-19 were either incompetently carried out or even fraudulent, and, as I mentioned, ivermectin for COVID-19 is looking increasingly like acupuncture for, well, anything.
So why bring this up again so soon after writing about it? I started thinking (always a dangerous thing) about science-based medicine (SBM) and the very purpose of this blog, and it occurred to me that the case of ivermectin is a very good real-world example of the utility of SBM and why evidence-based medicine (EBM) can fail for so long in a case like that of this particular drug.
Let’s go way, way back to the beginning, to explain the differences between EBM and SBM. Then I’ll explain how these differences apply. The primary difference is that SBM takes into account prior probability of a treatment working in evaluating clinical evidence.
SBM versus EBM
In the very first post ever on this blog all those years ago, SBM founder Dr. Steven Novella wrote:
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are not reliably safe and effective.
This is why the authors of this blog strongly advocate for science-based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products.
What did Steve mean by “prior scientific plausibility”? In brief, it’s an estimate of how likely a proposed treatment, when tested in an RCT or other clinical study, is likely to produce a positive result; i.e., a result consistent with the treatment “working” for the indication against which it is being tested. More specifically, it is an estimate of the prior probability of a given hypothesis before a study is conducted (in the case of an RCT that the null hypothesis will be rejected and there will be a statistically significant difference between the treatment group and the placebo group, indicating that the treatment works). I realize that this is boiling it down a bit, but I am writing for a lay audience.
It turns out that clinical trials are imperfect and can have a lot of “noise” even when designed and carried out perfectly. It also turns out that, from a Bayesian perspective, the prior plausibility that a treatment works matters a lot in interpreting clinical trial results; i.e., “posterior probability” the probability that a “positive result” is a “true positive” depends on the prior plausibility. (I’ll explain more in the next section what I mean by that.) Of course, in 2008, the original intent of SBM was to look at the evidence for treatments advocated as part of “alternative medicine”, CAM, or, as CAM is now more frequently called, “integrative medicine” or “integrative health”, both modalities in which “alternative medicine” (i.e., quackery) is “integrated” into conventional EBM. As I’ve argued, the newer names for CAM involving “integration” are nothing more than a rebranding of quackery.
Over the years, we’ve discussed many examples of alternative medicine with very low prior plausibility. Our favorite, as you might imagine, is homeopathy. The reason is simple. Based on homeopathy’s Law of Infinitesimals, which states states that the more you dilute a homeopathic remedy, the stronger it gets, we know that most homeopathic remedies are diluted to the point that it is unlikely that a single molecule of the original remedy is left. Homeopathy is thus arguably the purest example of a treatment with zero prior plausibility, given that most homeopathic remedies are is either water or another diluent. After all, as I like to say, for homeopathy to “work” for any disease or medical condition, several well-established laws of physics and chemistry would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. It is, of course, true that there are other alternative medicine treatments that have a similar level of implausibility—impossibility, really—based on basic science considerations. (“Energy healing” comes to mind first.) However, homeopathy is so common and ubiquitous that it makes an excellent teaching example, which is why I use it so often. Also, I’ve noticed that a lot of people don’t even know what homeopathy is, including medical students and physicians. Many seem to think that homeopathy is just another form of herbal medicine. In any event, because many homeopathy remedies are just water used to make sugar pills, homeopathy is an excellent way to test the “noise” in clinical trials because it’s basically testing placebo vs. placebo.
So how does one consider prior plausibility in RCTs?
SBM vs. EBM: Prior probability/plausibility
We’ve long discussed the differences between EBM, which uses frequentist statistics, and SBM, which uses Bayesian reasoning that incorporates an estimate of prior plausibility
I’ve long complained about “methodolatry” in EBM, defined as the obscene worship of the RCT as the only valid method of investigation in medicine. It’s a term that I first learned in the context of countering misinformation about the H1N1 influenza vaccine back in 2009, taught to me by a senior epidemiologist. There’s a lot of methodolatry in EBM, and it’s part of the reason why treatments like acupuncture (whose prior plausibility, based on its pre-scientific concepts and mechanism of action is very, very low, albeit probably not zero) keep showing up as potentially working—or at least “needing more study”—to EBM practitioners. I would also like to take this opportunity right here to quote SBM co-founder and former regular Dr. Kimball Atwood, who discussed why EBM and SBM ought to be synonymous (but currently are not) and, more importantly why EBM is incomplete, and SBM is intended to complete it, or at least to fill in its “blind spot”. As Dr. Atwood put it, EBM “should not be without consideration of prior probability, laws of physics, or plain common sense” and “SBM and EBM should not only be mutually inclusive, they should be synonymous”.
Elsewhere, he argued:
That discussion made the point that EBM favors equivocal clinical trial data over basic science, even if the latter is both firmly established and refutes the clinical claim. It suggested that this failure in calculus is not an indictment of EBM’s originators, but rather was an understandable lapse on their part: it never occurred to them, even as recently as 1990, that EBM would soon be asked to judge contests pitting low powered, bias-prone clinical investigations and reviews against facts of nature elucidated by voluminous and rigorous experimentation. Thus although EBM correctly recognizes that basic science is an insufficient basis for determining the safety and effectiveness of a new medical treatment, it overlooks its necessary place in that exercise.
You can see where I’m going with this, I hope. In the post from which I drew that quote above, Dr. Atwood explained in more detail what I’m talking about in terms of Bayesian theory. It also discusses how an estimate of prior probability affects the posterior probability that a given p-value in a clinical trial indicates a “true” result, or, as Steven Goodman and Sander Greenland put it in 2007 put it, the “prior probability” of a hypothesis is its probability before the study, and the “posterior probability” is its probability after the study.
In fact, I think I’ll insert here a table that we at SBM like to cite to illustrate:

This is Table 2 from the 2007 article by Goodman and Greenland that illustrates how prior probability affects posterior probability for given p-values. Notice one thing. The lower the prior probability, the much lower the posterior probability for a given p-value, such that if a prior probability is estimated to be 1%, then the posterior probability of a result for a standard p-value less than or equal to 0.05 is only 14%, meaning that it’s only ~14% likely that the result is not a false positive under the conditions specified, which are commonly used conditions in designing RCTs. Even results with fairly low p-values bear serious questioning in the case of a treatment with a very low prior probability/plausibility. (For those of you who are more knowledgeable, the mathematical formulas and reasoning used to derive these numbers are in the reference.)
For something like homeopathy, in which the prior probability based on its scientific impossibility under currently understood science is zero, the situation is, of course, far worse than in the table above. I will also quote Steve Novella and myself from a 2014 paper that we coauthored, in order to address a common criticism of our argument that RCTs of highly improbable/implausible treatments (like homeopathy) are akin to testing whether magic works as medicine:
It should also be noted that ‘biologically plausible’ does not mean ‘knowing the exact mechanism’. What it does mean is that the mechanism should not be so scientifically implausible as to be reasonably considered impossible. In other words, the mechanism should not violate laws and theories in science that rest on far sturdier and longer established foundations than imperfect, bias-prone clinical trials. For example, homeopathy violates multiple laws of physics with its claims that dilution can make a homeopathic remedy stronger and that water can retain the ‘memory’ of substances with which it has been in contact before [9]. Thus, treatments like homeopathy should be dismissed as ineffective on basic scientific grounds alone. That is why we propose the term science-based medicine (SBM) as opposed to evidence-based medicine (EBM). SBM restores basic science considerations to EBM and is what EBM should be.
I’m assuming that most SBM readers accept that, for example, homeopathy or energy healing is so incredibly implausible/improbable from basic science considerations alone that basic science is all that is needed to reject it as a treatment. I’m also assuming that most SBM readers will accept that, for example, acupuncture, although not as improbable/implausible as homeopathy, is still incredibly implausible, with a prior probability reasonably estimated as very much less than 1%. (I’d say very much less than 0.0001%, even.) I’ll also emphasize right here that, while basic science alone can in the cases under discussion here be enough to reject a proposed therapy as so implausible as to be impossible and not worth testing in RCTs, basic science is never enough to demonstrate that a treatment works, no matter how plausible the mechanism and compelling the preclinical data in cell culture and animals. Many are the treatments that appeared highly promising before being tested in humans, only to fail.
But what about ivermectin for COVID-19? That doesn’t fall into the same categories as homeopathy or acupuncture, does it? It’s an actual drug that is highly effective against diseases caused by roundworm infestations. Its discoverers even won the Nobel Prize for that indication! Is it so implausible that ivermectin might also work against a viral illness like COVID-19? There was even a proposed mechanism for its antiviral activity against SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. That mechanism was even based on in vitro cell culture studies!
All of these are reasonable considerations. So join me as I discuss them in the last two sections of this post, in which I hope to convince you that the prior probability for ivermectin was always very, very low—not homeopathy-level low, admittedly, but quite low.
Ivermectin vs. SBM: Back to the future
So how did the idea come about that ivermectin might be an effective treatment for COVID-19 anyway? You might remember how the idea that repurposing hydroxychloroquine, an anti-malarial drug with immune modulating properties that make it useful as a mild immunosuppressive drug to use to treat autoimmune diseases, took hold early in the pandemic. In brief, Chinese physicians in Wuhan reported in early 2020 that none of a group of 80 patients with lupus erythematosus who were taking hydroxychloroquine went on to catch COVID-19. (Never mind that immunosuppressed patients were exactly the patients most likely to assiduously follow the recommendations of public health authorities during an epidemic.) A number of clinical trials were registered, and, based on anecdotal reports and small clinical trials (nearly all of which are as yet unpublished), in February the Chinese government published an expert consensus recommending CQ or HCQ for patients with COVID-19. Soon after, a number of nations followed suit. In addition, French scientist Didier Raoult started flogging hydroxychloroquine as a cure for COVID-19 and was soon joined by President Donald Trump and of course!—Dr. Mehmet Oz. The rest, unfortunately, is history. Even though by late summer 2020, it was becoming quite clear that hydroxychloroquine was ineffective against COVID-19, a conspiracy theory of a “suppressed cure” had been born.
The idea that ivermectin could be repurposed to treat COVID-19 is similar, but based on even less evidence. I discussed this evidence several months ago, when a conspiracy theory was being spread that Pfizer’s new antiviral drug Paxlovid was “Pfizermectin” because both ivermectin and Paxlovid have protease inhibition activity. I’ll just recap briefly.
It’s been known for years that ivermectin can inhibit coronavirus replication through the inhibition of a protein called α/β1 importin, something reported a decade ago. This particular protein is involved in the transport of proteins into the nucleus from the cytoplasm. In the case of SARS-CoV-2 infection, the transport of certain proteins into the nucleus is important for completion of its lifecycle. Now here’s the thing. Inhibition of this protein complex by ivermectin and preventing the replication of HIV and the Dengue virus requires fairly high concentrations (at least in terms of drug concentrations). The original Australian paper published in May 2020 that examined the ability of ivermectin to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 replication showed similar results, specifically the need for a very high concentration of drug to inhibit the importin that was needed for SARS-CoV-2 replication.
So what’s the problem? It’s basic pharmacology, as summarized in this review:
As noted, the activity of ivermectin in cell culture has not reproduced in mouse infection models against many of the viruses and has not been clinically proven either, in spite of ivermectin being available globally. This is likely related to the pharmacokinetics and therapeutic safety window for ivermectin. The blood levels of ivermectin at safe therapeutic doses are in the 20–80 ng/ml range [44], while the activity against SARS-CoV2 in cell culture is in the microgram range. Ivermectin is administered orally or topically. If safe formulations or analogs can be derived that can be administered to achieve therapeutic concentrations, ivermectin could be useful as a broad-spectrum antiviral agent.
Specifically, the IC50 (the concentration that produces 50% of maximal inhibition of a process) was in the 6 μM. Given that the molecular weight of ivermectin is 875 g/mol, 6 μM translates into ~5.25 mg/L or ~5.25 μg/ml, a concentration that is roughly 66-fold higher than the upper end of the range of blood levels of ivermectin safely achievable in a human’s bloodstream. Even this paper proposing ivermectin as a treatment for COVID-19 notes this serious problem:
A dose of 12 mg twice daily alone or in combination with other therapy for 5–7 days has been proposed as a safe therapeutic option for mild, moderate or severe cases of Covid-19 infection.10 The time to reach maximum plasma concentration of 20–50 ng/ml, after a dose of 6 or 12 mg, respectively is approximately 4 h.
This is almost certainly the reason that ivermectin doesn’t work against COVID-19 in spite of its activity in vitro against SARS-CoV-2. It requires a concentration roughly 66- to 197-fold higher than is safely achievable in the blood. That’s why the review concluded that maybe an ivermectin analogue that is either more active or can achieve a higher concentration safely in the bloodstream is worth investigating. Based on the proposed mechanism in the Australian paper, ivermectin was never a good candidate as a treatment for SARS-CoV-2. As I discussed for the claim that ivermectin should be considered a promising drug for COVID-19 based on its protease inhibitor activity, the situation is just as bad. Again, based on in vitro results, ivermectin was never a promising candidate as an antiviral drug to treat COVID-19.
But how do we translate this into prior probability? In the discussion of the NEJM trial to which I linked above, someone suggested what is probably an accurate assessment:
Yup. As liked to say, it wasn't homeopathy-level implausibility, but it was highly implausible.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) March 31, 2022
I think that a pretest probability of much less then 1% is accurate given in vitro results like the experiments that I described. I also noted on Thursday after seeing the NEJM study:
To accept that such a mechanism might be operative, the clinical trial results have to be highly compelling and pristine. None of the clinical trials for #ivermectin even came close to that standard.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) March 31, 2022
In other words, if ivermectin were to be actually useful against COVID-19, it would almost certainly have to work by a different molecular mechanism than the one described in the in vitro study cited because it’s known to be impossible to safely achieve ivermectin concentrations in human blood that are sufficient even to inhibit viral replication by 50%—or even anywhere near such concentrations. Of course, it’s always possible that such a previously unknown mechanism was operative, but highly unlikely. Moreover, to consider that such a mechanism might be operative, the clinical trial results would have to be pristine in terms of very compelling results from very well-designed and executed clinical trials, or, as Steve Novella once put it, “When the basic science dictates that a proposed treatment is highly implausible, the bar for clinical evidence should be raised proportionately”.
This never applied to any clinical trial of ivermectin for COVID-19, not even the seemingly strongly “positive” ones, and that’s even leaving aside the discovered incompetence and likely fraud in the largest “positive” trials, which led to falsely “positive” meta-analyses.
As I said, these negative results never surprised those of us with SBM tendencies. Given the very low prior probability that ivermectin is effective against COVID-19 based on in vitro data, even the best “positive” clinical trials likely had a low posterior probability. Moreover, they weren’t the only trials. Most trials were equivocal or negative, and, as is the case with acupuncture, the larger and better designed the study, the more likely it was to be negative, which leads me to an adage that I frequently use on Twitter (because it’s pithy) but have not yet (as far as I can recall) repeated here on SBM:
Very low prior plausibility
+
Equivocal clinical studies
=
Drug doesn’t work for the proposed indication
Or at least, any effect observed will be too small and inconsistent to be clinically useful.
SBM: It’s not just for CAM anymore. (It never was.)
It’s been a long time since we’ve discussed the difference between EBM and SBM in quite this much detail, discussions like this having been common here around 2008-2010, but I felt that a discussion like this was overdue. The reason, of course, has been the pandemic and how EBM has treated highly implausible COVID-19 therapies in the same way that it’s long treated highly implausible CAM therapies, through the lens of methodolatry, in which only RCTs matter for determining if a treatment does or doesn’t work and in which even flawed RCTs trump basic science—except that they don’t, at least when Bayesian considerations are used.
What makes the discussion of ivermectin interesting to me in this context is that it is an example of why SBM matters in all areas of medicine, not just the consideration of “integrative” quackery. SBM mavens all immediately realized that, even if you accepted the rationale proposed at face value, ivermectin was incredibly implausible as an effective therapy for COVID-19 just based on the in vitro data alone. It’s basic pharmacology. A drug that only inhibits the target protein at a concentration that is at least nearly 70-fold higher than the highest blood concentration of drug that can be safely achieved using standard dosing is incredibly unlikely to be an effective treatment. It’s also a general principle that most highly effective drugs inhibit their target at nanomolar or ng/ml concentrations, not micromolar or μg/ml concentrations. Candidate drugs that only inhibit their target at such high concentrations, in general, tend to be incredibly unlikely to be useful drugs.
Indeed, any pharmaceutical company that developed a drug just like ivermectin for COVID-19 would have abandoned it after in vitro testing showing that it required such a high concentration to inhibit the intended target. A drug company would have deemed such a candidate compound as not worth pursuing further, except maybe as a base molecule to chemically modify so that it either inhibits the desired target at a much lower concentration or becomes able to achieve much higher blood levels safely. Yet a number of scientists whom I respect were, until very recently, saying that ivermectin “probably doesn’t work” or even saying that there was a strong developing evidence base; that is, until it all fell apart with the determinations that a couple of the largest, most “positive” studies couldn’t possibly have been carried out as reported. Basic pharmacology matters.
I also realize that ivermectin believers won’t accept an SBM-based argument against ivermectin any more than believers in acupuncture or homeopathy accept SBM-based Bayesian arguments against their favorite woo. Indeed, in reaction to the NEJM study, there were a lot of reactions like this:
Effect of Early Treatment with Ivermectin among Patients with Covid-19 | NEJM, FAKE NEWS https://t.co/fMxY0LYuQN
— skp (@pt34tide) April 1, 2022
And this:
All of them fell under the sorts of “rationales” as in this meme, which I most definitely am stealing:
I'm stealing that meme. pic.twitter.com/dthJgAAKR8
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) March 31, 2022
However, remember that EBM arguments don’t sway believers in homeopathy or acupuncture, either; so one should not expect that EBM or SBM arguments would sway ivermectin believers. My hope is that SBM thinking will be more likely to sway EBM adherents who don’t really take into account prior plausibility in evaluating RCT evidence and therefore take much longer to reach a conclusion that is obvious to SBM about a treatment, in the case of ivermectin that it doesn’t work against COVID-19. Indeed, at this stage I would argue that it is unethical to begin another RCT of ivermectin to treat COVID-19. Given how resoundingly negative the evidence is now, such a trial would be all risk with no realistic potential for any patient to benefit. I’m not even sure whether it’s ethical to continue to recruit patients to RCTs of ivermectin still enrolling.
In future talks about the differences between SBM and EBM and how EBM should be (but still is not) synonymous with SBM, I plan on adding the example of ivermectin for COVID-19 to my long-used examples of homeopathy and acupuncture when I discuss Bayesian thinking and prior probability/plausibility because SBM isn’t just for CAM any more. It never was, and never should have been. If I’ve been guilty of not applying it to conventional medicine as much as I do to CAM, the case of ivermectin has shown me the error of my ways.

Ivermectin booster Dr. Tess Lawrie goes all-in for homeopathy for COVID and long COVID
Tess Lawrie has been promoting ivermectin for COVID-19 for two and a half years. Of late, she has becoming more of a general multipurpose quack, promoting ivermectin to treat cancer. Now she’s promoting homeopathy for COVID and long COVID while a Research Fellow at St. Mary’s University Twickenham. What does this tell us about medicine?
David Gorski on March 6, 2023
Link
I know that, since the COVID-19 pandemic hit, I keep repeating the mantra, “Everything old is new again.” I even know that I probably repeat it so much that it sometimes gets annoying. So be it. It’s a message that is important to me due to my simple hope that, if the newbies who have joined “our side” understand that none of this is new, they will learn the recurring themes, narratives, and forms of quackery, misinformation, and disinformation, the better to be prepared for the future. That brings us to homeopathy.
Remember ivermectin? Who can forget it, the repurposed drug used to treat helminthic (round-worm) diseases in animals and humans that COVID-19 quacks quickly repurposed to claim as a miracle cure for COVID-19 as evidence mounted that the last repurposed “miracle cure,” the antimalaria drug hydroxychloroquine (which is also used to treat rheumatoid arthritis), didn’t work against COVID-19, leading me to refer to it as the “Black Knight of COVID-19 treatments.” Basically, ivermectin was the new hydroxychloroquine, but its being the new hydroxychloroquine didn’t stop both drugs from remaining in the armamentarium of COVID quacks everywhere, immune to evidence, complete with conspiracy theories and dubious meta-analyses—even an appeal to the Nobel Prize!—to explain its lack of acceptance by “mainstream medicine.” Personally, I came to the conclusion that ivermectin was the acupuncture of COVID=19 treatments (a highly implausible treatment from a basic science standpoint supported by the flaws in the evidence-based medicine paradigm) and a perfect example to explain how science-based medicine isn’t just for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” or whatever advocates of combining quackery with evidence-based medicine are calling it these days.
Which brings us back to Dr. Tess Lawrie.
Lawrie, you might remember, first made her name as one of the founders of the British Ivermectin Recommendation Development (BIRD) Group, a group that teamed up with the US group the COVID Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) to vigorously promote ivermectin as a highly effective treatment for COVID-19, despite all evidence to the contrary, including basic pharmacokinetics. When last I discussed Lawrie, she had done what most quacks who believe in a particular treatment eventually do and embraced ivermectin as not just a highly effective treatment for COVID-19 but as a potential cancer cure.
Given that background (and the title of this post, which gives it away), I suspect that you know what’s coming next. That’s right. Lawrie has now embraced The One Quackery To Rule Them All for COVID-19, long COVID, and a number of other things. That’s right, it’s homeopathy time, baby!
Homeopathy: The air guitar of medicine
Advocates of science-based medicine like to refer to homeopathy as the “air guitar of medicine,” because, like an air guitar, it’s performative and can appear impressive, but, just as pretending to play guitar doesn’t produce any actual music, homeopathy doesn’t produce any therapeutic effects because almost by definition it can’t. I realize that our regular readers know what homeopathy is and why it’s quackery, but whenever discussing homeopathy I always feel obligated to provide a brief explanation for those who’ve never encountered this blog before, rather than just links. I hope our regulars will bear with me.
To reiterate, homeopathic remedies are the purest quackery, and I frequently refer to homeopathy as “The One Quackery To Rule Them All.” I also generally think it’s always worth a brief explanation of why. Basically, homeopathy was invented by a German physician Samuel Hahnemann in 1796 and is based on two “laws” that have no basis in science. (I suppose calling them “laws” made them sound more important, like Newton’s Laws of Motion.) The first is the Law of Similars, which states that you treat a given symptom using something that causes that symptom. No matter how much homeopaths try to claim otherwise and cite cherry picked examples, there is no physiologic, biochemical, or medical basis for such a broad general principle, and in fact what the first law of homeopathy resembles more than anything else is the principles of sympathetic magic, specifically Sir James George Frazer’s Law of Similarity as described in The Golden Bough (1922) as one of the implicit principles of sympathetic magic.
The second “law” of homeopathy, the Law of Infinitesimals, is even more ridiculous and pseudoscientific (or even mystical). I also find it the easiest to explain to the uninitiated why this “law” is utter bunk. In brief, the Law of Infinitesimals states that homeopathic remedies become stronger with dilution. Indeed, the process of making a homeopathic remedy involves serial dilution, usually 1:100. The mother tincture (or original compound or medicine) is diluted 1:100 and then shaken vigorously (succussed), the succussion step being claimed by homeopaths to be absolutely essential to “potentize” the remedy. After that, the remedy is diluted again in the same way. Each 1:100 dilution is designated by “C”, such that a 6C dilution equals six 1:100 dilutions. The problem comes with the higher dilutions. For instance, a 12C solution is on the order of a 10-24 dilution ((10-2)12 = 10-24). Many homeopathic remedies are on the order of 30C, which is a 10-60 dilution, or more than 1036-fold greater than Avogadro’s number. Some homeopathic remedies go up to 100C or more, or 10-200. Here’s a hint: The number of atoms in the known universe is estimated to be around 1078 to 1082. The math just doesn’t work, and remedies over around 12C are basically water. “Lesser” dilutions contain so little remedy that it’s highly unlikely that they have a pharmacological effect.
Even though these days Richard Dawkins gets on my nerves for a number of reasons that I will not go into here, I do have to give him props for perhaps the best two-and-a-half minute explanation why homeopathy is quackery ever committed to video:
With that explanation taken care of, let’s move on.
Tess Lawrie embraces homeopathy for COVID-19
Yesterday, as I was looking for topics to blog about, I came across an article on Tess Lawrie’s Substack entitled Homeopathy for long Covid. It is, unfortunately for my purposes, one of her articles only for paid subscribers, but, as is her wont, Lawrie had posted a promotional Substack newsletter three days before entitled There’s a reason why the Queen had a homeopath. I was half-tempted to retort that there’s a reason why King Charles III is heavily into homeopathy—something we used to criticize him harshly for when he was Prince Charles—but it’s not because homeopathy works. Instead, I noted how Lawrie had bought into the usual homeopathy narrative about its being “suppressed,” with a tagline reading: “On the pernicious rewriting of homeopathy’s history, and how well-crafted research is revealing what many have known all along: homeopathy works.”
Where have we heard that one before? Also, as our very own Dr. Mark Crislip has described, there is no good evidence that homeopathy is effective against COVID-19. As you will see, that is not unexpected given that homeopathy is basically quackery, mostly water or ethanol diluent with no medicinal value.
Lawrie, as is the case with most quacks, is not happy with Wikipedia. Indeed, she starts out by looking at Wikipedia:
Let’s start with the lies and misinformation about homeopathy. Here’s how the internet’s propaganda factory Wikipedia currently defines it:
Homeopathy or homoeopathy is a pseudoscientific[1][2][3][4] system of alternative medicine. It was conceived in 1796 by the German physician Samuel Hahnemann. Its practitioners, called homeopaths, believe that a substance that causes symptoms of a disease in healthy people can cure similar symptoms in sick people; this doctrine is called similia similibus curentur, or “like cures like”.[5]
The entry then describes homeopathy as ‘quackery and fraud’ and goes on to state:
During the 1970s, homeopathy made a significant comeback, with sales of some homeopathic products increasing tenfold. The trend corresponded with the rise of the New Age movement, and may be in part due to chemophobia, an irrational preference for “natural” products, and the longer consultation times homeopathic practitioners provided.
Reader, are you suffering from ‘chemophobia’? I think I may be, though I would argue that a preference for natural products is entirely rational. Out of curiosity, I thought I’d look at what the Wikipedia entry for homeopathy used to say. Here’s what it said on 31 October 2003:
Homoeopathy is a method of treating diseases and medical conditions invented, or at least popularized, by the German Samuel Hahnemann in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. It is based on the theory that each naturally occurring element, plant, and mineral compound will, when ingested or applied, result in certain symptoms. Hahnemann believed that, by diluting these substances in a standardized manner, one could reach the true essence of that substance. Hahnemann described this process of dilution as “potentizing” (German: “potenziert”) the substance. These dilute amounts could then be used to treat the very symptoms they were known to produce.
Hahnemann and his students approached their treatments in a holistic way, meaning that the whole of the body and spirit is dealt with, not just the localised disease. Hahnemann himself spent extended periods of time with his patients, asking them questions that dealt not only with their particular symptoms or illness, but also with the details of their daily lives.
Well, that’s quite a shift in perspective isn’t it?
Gee, Lawrie says that as though it were a bad thing to have quackery properly described as quackery and pseudoscience on Wikipedia!
It is a shift in perspective, but the shift doesn’t show what Lawrie thinks that it shows. Rather, it shows just how much alternative medicine practitioners dominated Wikipedia entries. Indeed, back in 2004-5, when I first started blogging, one of my biggest complaints about Wikipedia was that cranks and quacks had a lot more time and believers to edit entries like the one on Wikipedia, far outnumbering skeptics, leading to credulous Wikipedia entries just like the one that Lawrie posted. At this point, a shout out to Susan Gerbic and her Guerilla Skepticism on Wikipedia project is obligatory, to express gratitude for working to change that.
Complete with the narrative that homeopathy is being unduly “suppressed,” Lawrie continues, likening this “suppression” and “redefinition” to various narratives about COVID-19:
It continues to amaze me how successfully nefarious influences can redefine how we see the world. We have seen this in technicolour over the past three years, with respected dictionaries redefining words such as ‘vaccine’ to comply with a big pharma narrative, and people described as ‘variant factories’ in a clear attempt to demonise a specific group.
The claim that the word “vaccine” has been somehow “redefined” in order to encompass mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines is, of course, a favorite conspiracy theory of antivaxxers. Let’s just say that the word “vaccine” was not “redefined,” although the definition was clarified to try to prevent misunderstandings, basically changing a very specific definition of “vaccine” to a more general accepted phrasing of the definition. There was no nefarious intent, but Lawrie, being the conspiracy theorist that she is, imputes nefarious intent.
She then likens that “redefinition” to what she perceives as having happened to homeopathy:
I was reminded of this recently, when I spoke to Dr Philippa Fibert, my next Tess Talks guest. Philippa is a practising homeopath, and also Research Fellow at St Mary’s University, Twickenham here in the UK.
She pointed out to me that the intense scepticism about homeopathy is actually a recent phenomenon. It wasn’t that long ago that homeopathy was fairly mainstream, and is still available on the UK’s National Health Service, albeit in only two locations: the NHS Centre for Integrated Care in Glasgow, and the Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine.
The latter used to be called Royal London Homeopathic Hospital; this was where Philippa’s great aunt, Dr Lena Banks, and her great aunt’s partner, Dr Marjorie Blackie, worked. Dr Blackie was the Queen’s Homeopath.
Only someone utterly devoid of knowledge of history can claim that skepticism about homeopathy is a recent phenomenon. Whenever I see that claim, I like to refer to a classic essay entitled Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions. The author? Oliver Wendell Holmes. The year? This essay was based on two lectures that he presented to the Boston Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge—in 1842! It is an essay worth reading in its entirety. Other than the lack of knowledge in the 1840s of Avogadro’s number, whose first accurate measurement was at the time of Holmes’ lectures decades in the future and whose magnitude lets us know that in 30C dilutions it is unlikely that even a single molecule of starting substance remains, its devastating critique of homeopathy as pseudoscience is relevant today.
That must be why Lawrie invokes the fantasy of future vindication, which is a favorite of quacks and supporters of quackery everywhere—and writes:
Like many safe, natural alternatives to pharmaceuticals, homeopathy has been under a sustained and calculated attack for some time. But I do believe that is about to change – and Philippa is playing a key role in its rehabilitation as an accepted and respected form of medicine.
So what is Fibert claiming. I think you can predict. Again, as I pointed out, there is no evidence that homeopathy can effectively treat COVID-19—not that homeopaths would ever admit that—and it’s equally improbable to think that homeopathy could be used to treat long COVID. None of this stops Fibert or Lawrie:
Those suffering from Long Covid have been turning to homeopathy – and so Philippa has led a service evaluation project to document the outcomes. The results have shown that people are experiencing improvements with homeopathic treatment so now, Philippa is spearheading a well-designed randomised controlled trial to evidence the outcome of the homeopathic treatment of the symptoms associated with long Covid.
It is not my purpose to discuss all the ins and outs of why homeopathy is quackery and will not be useful for COVID or long COVID. It’s homeopathy, and we at SBM have spilled so much digital ink explaining why homeopathy is quackery that I don’t want to reinvent the wheel here yet again. Rather, what interested me is the inevitable progression we have seen in Tess Lawrie. First, she started out promoting ivermectin for COVID-19, helping an army of quacks cement the narrative that ivermectin is a cheap, safe, and “suppressed” cure for COVID-19 in the public’s mind. Then she decided that COVID-19 wasn’t enough; ivermectin should also be used to treat cancer, because of course she did. Now she has gone beyond ivermectin for COVID or cancer and embraced The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy.
I will revisit this observation. First, however, who is Philippa Fibert, besides being a homeopath?
How medical academia can promote COVID quackery
At this point, I’m going to shift gears a bit and refer to an article by Matthew Hongoltz-Hetling that appeared in this month’s issue of The New Republic entitled, A Doctor’s War Against the Right-Wing Medical-Freedom Movement, which carries the tagline, “As alternative medicine infiltrates mainstream health care, one physician is fighting back with everything he has.” I’ll come clean right here. The doctor in the article is me, and the article is basically about how alternative medicine quackery has infiltrated medicine over the last couple of decades, laying the groundwork for a lot of what we are seeing now. As the “main character” in the article, I will say that I’m (mostly) happy with the narrative and how I come off. (My quibbles might be a topic for a future post sometime. For example, I get the impression that I come across like the aging gunslinger played by John Wayne in The Shootist, whom all the young guns are looking to knock off and who is on the declining side of his career, which, come to think of it, might not be that inaccurate. I do prefer, however, to look at myself more like G’Kar in Babylon 5 episode The Long Twilight Struggle, if only because G’Kar does ultimately triumph even if he does later die a tragically foretold death. But I digress, as I often do.) What Hongoltz-Hetling gets right is how alternative medicine has infiltrated academic medicine:
Between 1999 and 2017, NCCIH had spent a total of about $2.2 billion “for clinical trials [that] produced no sound, consistent evidence for the efficacy of any alternative therapies,” Dr. Donald Marcus of the Baylor College of Medicine pointed out in a 2020 article in The Journal of Clinical Investigation. The National Library of Medicine lists 49 different NCCIH-funded studies that reference homeopathy; some of the study authors lack medical degrees, and yet have associations with top-tier medical institutions—for instance, Ted Kaptchuk, an acupuncturist who went on to direct an alternative-medicine program at Harvard Medical School; or Gary Schwartz, whose research at the University of Arizona is focused primarily on mediums and energy healing.
The alternative-health industry also influences academia through overt lobbying. And even as it enjoys the financial benefits that come with being embraced by the political right (Americans spent $34 billion on products and services in 2007), it has aggressively wooed the academic circles that are usually dominated by the political left. For example, in 2017, after receiving a $200 million gift from the Henry and Susan Samueli Foundation, the University of California Irvine earmarked funds for up to 15 faculty chairs supporting a curricular focus on integrative health in its College of Health Sciences. Deep-pocketed alternative-medicine groups have also funded partnerships with University of California San Francisco, Harvard Medical School, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Sidney Kimmel Medical College of Thomas Jefferson University, and Vanderbilt University School of Medicine. As of 2017, 15 research medical schools had begun offering alternative medicine to the public, according to Marcus. Johns Hopkins offers Reiki “to transmit Universal Life Energy to the client”; Duke University offers acupuncture for stroke victims.
Why do I mention this—other than wanting to slip in a link to an article in a mainstream magazine about myself, something that has never happened before?—and point out how medical academia has been corrupted by quackery? Simple. Let’s take a look at Philippa Fibert. She is indeed a Research Fellow at St. Mary’s University Twickenham in the Department of Psychology and Pedagogic Science. Interestingly, this department is listed as a department of the Faculty of Sport, Allied Health and Performance Science, which lists itself as offering programs in these areas:
    • Applied Physics
    • Health and Exercise
    • Nutrition
    • Physiotherapy
    • Psychology
    • Sport Rehabilitation
    • Sport Science
    • Sports Coaching
    • Strength and Conditioning
Worse, Fibert describes her history thusly:
I am a Research Fellow with a particular interest in improving long-term outcomes for children, and assessing the effectiveness of non-pharmacological treatments.
I started out working with children with special needs as a teacher, then as a parent educator. I then came across a treatment that seemed to be really helpful for them, however few think it can work apart from those who have experienced it first hand.So, to start untangling the evidence, I embarked on research into this area. I completed a psychology research MSc at Goldsmiths University where I conducted a comparative case series examining the effectiveness of this treatment for children with ADHD. This was partly funded by Turner’s Court Youth trust, an ex borstal supporting crime prevention measures (1:4 prison inmates have had a diagnosis of ADHD).
The treatment is called Homeopathy. The Case Series findings were significant, and in several cases, life changing. Patient stories are available in articles in Green Parent and Autism Now Magazines, case reports in the European Journal of Integrative Medicine, and the full case series in the journal ‘Homeopathy’.
Quelle surprise. She plied her quackery on autistic children and children with ADHD, and Goldsmith University supported this research as part of her degree program. But let’s get to the quackademic medicine that allowed her to test water on children with significant medical conditions:
A pilot randomised controlled pragmatic trial was then conducted at the University of Sheffield to provide more substantial information about the long-term effectiveness of non-pharmacological approaches. It assessed the effectiveness of homeopathy and nutritional therapy. Results suggest that both treatments may be helpful: in particular nutritional therapy for restlessness/inattention, and homeopathy for emotional dysregulation (https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00431-019-03374-z).
I now work at St Mary’s University, Twickenham: within the department of Psychology and Pedagogic Science where we’re running a trial exploring the effects of Kefir on ADHD, sleep and the microbiome; and I teach on the MSc in Chronic Disease Management.
Meanwhile I continue to pursue my research interests in improving health outcomes. A recent study explored the effectiveness of the homeopathic remedy bacillinum for ringworm in rural Africa, and found it better and cheaper than conventional care over the long term. A service evaluation of homeopathic treatment for long COVID suggests that patients feel 47% better after 2 consultations (12 weeks).
Let’s look at her study cited above. Basically, it claims to be a randomized trial of homeopathy and nutritional therapy in ADHD, but it was not blinded, much less double-blinded. Those assessing the subjects after interventions knew which child was in which group. So basically, it was a useless trial, even as a “pilot” trial.
As for bacillinum? I hadn’t heard of this particular homeopathic remedy before, but a quick Google search revealed that it is purported to be made from the sputum of a patient with tuberculosis. I kid you not. It is claimed to be useful for:
Addison’s disease. Alopecia. Consumptiveness Growth, defective. Hydrocephalus. Idiocy. Insanity. Joints, affections of. Phthiriasis. Pityriasis Ringworm. Scrofulous glands. Teeth, defective; pitted. Tuberculosis.
If you ever want more of an indication that homeopathy is quackery, just look at the list of the diseases supposedly treated by a homeopathic remedy claimed to have been made by diluting the sputum of a patient with tuberculosis! Then be thankful that the sputum was diluted to nonexistence and bacillum is basically water, just as I was thankful to learn that Lyssinum, a homeopathic remedy purported to have been made from the sputum of a rabid dog, is also generally diluted to 200C, far beyond nonexistence. Ditto a homeopathic remedy to treat Ebola made from the sputum of Ebola patients. Again, you can’t make stuff like this up. (At least, I can’t.) It makes me wonder why the homeopaths didn’t use diluted SARS-CoV-2 to treat COVID.
Quackademic medicine, COVID, and homeopathy
We at SBM have been writing about quackademic medicine ever since the very beginning of this blog. Although I wish I could claim to have coined the term “quackademic medicine,” unfortunately I can’t. (Dr. R. W. Donnell has that honor.) The point, however, is how before the pandemic quackery had so thoroughly infiltrated itself into medical academia that even “hard core” academic medical centers, like Duke, Stanford, the Cleveland Clinic and even my alma mater, the University of Michigan, have embraced quackery, to the point where U. of M., for instance, has a naturopath in a high-ranking faculty position in its Department of Family Medicine who promotes homeopathy there.
Across the pond, Philippa Fibert is fundraising £40,000 to do a “pilot RCT” of homeopathy for long COVID. with this preliminary data:
Dr. Fibert told HINT: “This trial provides an excellent opportunity to develop much-needed evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy at a time when other healthcare providers are struggling to develop effective protocols for the treatment of Long-COVID.
“In a prelude to the pilot RCT, we have already been collecting the MYMOPs (Measure Your Own Medical Outcome Profile) of Long-COVID patients and found a 36% improvement after just one consultation. After their second consultation the improvement climbed to 48%.”
We hope this project will put homeopathy front and centre as the medicine of choice for the symptoms associated with Long-COVID. You can be part of this ground breaking project by helping us raise the funding needed.
We have the enthusiasm, now all we need is £40,000 and with your help we know we can do it!
There’s nothing like subjective outcome measures in a survey as “evidence” that magic water helps a poorly understood condition that often has vague symptoms and whose diagnostic criteria aren’t fully solidified yet to guarantee that placebo effects will provide a seemingly positive outcome to justify raising money for a pointless RCT. Let me remind you what the remedies used in the “preliminary trial” were:

Basically, it’s just a grab bag of common homeopathic remedies, including the quite rightly mocked Oscillococcinum®, which includes extract of duck liver and heart. Basically, it’s a “throw everything but the kitchen sink” approach to COVID-19, if that everything is the water in the kitchen sink without the actual, you know, kitchen sink.
I argued in Matt Hongoltz-Hetling’s piece that quackademic medicine is both a cause and symptom of what led so many doctors to embrace COVID quackery, antimask stances, and antivax beliefs. Certainly, homeopaths in universities and medical schools doesn’t help. It should thus be no surprise that people like Philippa Fibert exist and are now promoting homeopathy for long COVID, after having promoted it for so many other conditions.
Unfortunately, this example of Tess Lawrie expanding her quackery suggests two things that seem new but are not. First, once a doc starts down the dark path of quackery, forever will it dominate her destiny. Consume her it will (with only rare exceptions). This has clearly happened to Lawrie, who started out embracing the then “sort of” quackery of ivermectin, which is now COVID quackery because the evidence clearly shows that it does not work, and then progressed to embracing ivermectin quackery for more diseases (like cancer), and then ran headlong into the arms of The One Quackery To Rule Them All. It is incredibly likely that there is any coming back from this for her. The question is: Is there any coming back from this, period?

Courts should not order hospitals and physicians to administer ivermectin against their will
Courts in several states have ordered hospitals to administer ivermectin to COVID patients against the medical judgment of treating physicians. Patients have no legal right to a particular treatment and health care providers should not be forced to administer this drug.
Jann Bellamy on September 9, 2021
Link

Nine lawsuits have been filed recently seeking judicial orders forcing hospitals to administer the controversial drug ivermectin to COVID patients against the medical judgment of their treating physicians. In at least one case, in addition to the hospital, the physicians themselves were named as defendants. Seven have been successful, although one order was superseded by another judge, who ruled in favor of the defendant hospital. Hospitals are appealing other orders. In two lawsuits, the hospital prevailed and the judge refused to order administration of ivermectin.
The rulings are an unsettling development because, as we shall see, patients have no legal right to such a remedy. Indeed, in no case where I was able to review the pleadings and orders (they were not available in all cases) did the plaintiff cite any legal authority for the judge to act nor did their orders cite any authority for doing so.
Today, after a brief review of ivermectin, we’ll take a closer look at the facts of these cases. Then we’ll discuss the their ethical and legal implications.
Ivermectin, the alleged wonder drug
Ivermectin has been extensively covered here on SBM in posts by our own Scott Gavura, DPharm, and Dr. David Gorski (also here and here), as well as in a guest post by Dr. William Paolo. By way of background, here is some basic information from those posts and other sources:
    • Ivermectin is approved by the FDA to treat parasites in people and, in a different formulation, is used to prevent heartworm disease and treat parasites in animals. The FDA has not approved ivermectin to prevent or treat COVID, although off-label use for that purpose is not illegal.
    • At this time, there is insufficient evidence of ivermectin’s effectiveness as a COVID prophylactic or treatment and a growing body of evidence points to the conclusion that it is not effective for these uses. It can also have side effects. Some people have ingested the animal formulation and become seriously ill.
    • The FDA, WHO, the AMA, the American Pharmacists Association, and the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists all oppose the use of ivermectin to prevent or treat COVID outside of a clinical trial. According to the NIH COVID-19 Treatment Guidelines Panel, there is insufficient evidence to recommend its use. The CDC has issued a Health Advisory warning on ivermectin. Even Merck, the drug’s maker, recommends against using it for COVID.
    • Despite all of this, and the availability of vaccines and effective treatments for COVID, some physicians, politicians, right-wing media personalities, as well as all-out quacks, continue to promote ivermectin. A group calling itself the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) aggressively promotes ivermectin with cherry-picked evidence and has created unproven treatment protocols that include it.
The facts
The nine lawsuits have similar facts so I won’t discuss each individually (for one reason, it would make this post entirely too long). However, before we begin, here’s a list of each patient for whom judicial intervention was sought, with links to more information about their cases, including media reports and documents filed with the courts. (I’ll link to some of these again in referring to particular cases.)
    • Randy Clouse (also here), Illinois
    • Richard Cyganovich (also here), New York
    • Glenna Dickinson (also here), New York
    • Nurije Fype (also here), Illinois
    • Michael Gangemi (also here), New York
    • Pete Lopez (also here), Texas
    • Judith Smentkiewicz, New York
    • Jeffrey Smith (also here and here), Ohio
    • John Swanson, New York
In a typical case, a patient contracts COVID and is hospitalized. In most cases the patient is in the ICU and some are on ventilators. A family member has read about ivermectin online, seen it discussed on Fox News or in other media, and/or discovered the dubious advice of the FLCCC.
Because most of the COVID patients in these cases are incompetent to make their own decisions due to their illness, a spouse or other family member wants one of the patient’s physicians to administer ivermectin. The physician and/or the hospital refuse. Some family members then get prescriptions for ivermectin from physicians who do not have privileges at the hospital, but the hospital still declines either to administer the ivermectin with its own staff or allow the physician without privileges to do so. In the Texas case, the patient had been prescribed ivermectin at a VA Medical Center but was admitted to the hospital before he was able to take it.
The family member then files suit on behalf of the patient seeking to force the hospital to allow administration of ivermectin. In all but one case, the plaintiffs are represented by New York law firm of attorney Ralph C. Lorigo. The plaintiffs seek emergency relief, asking that the court enter an order requiring the hospital to administer ivermectin immediately. The courts have issued such orders before the hospital has had an opportunity to be heard and, in at least one case, before the hospital was served with notice that the action had commenced.
Favorable orders are usually based on documentary evidence filed by the plaintiffs. Plaintiffs have submitted copies of the unproven FLCCC protocols, supporting affidavits from physicians who prescribe or promote ivermectin, studies purporting to show the effectiveness of ivermectin, and news articles about similar cases in which courts have ordered hospitals to administer the drug. In one case, Dr. Pierre Kory, president of the FLCCC and ivermectin promoter extraordinaire, himself supplied an affidavit. In another, there is an affidavit from Dr. Fred Wagchul, one of the FLCCC’s founders. Needless to say, this evidence generally presents a glowing picture of ivermectin’s effectiveness as a COVID treatment.
In the cases won by the plaintiffs, the courts either ordered the hospital to administer ivermectin to the patient (with, in some cases, the family delivering ivermectin to the hospital from an outside pharmacy, which is against hospital protocol) or ordered the hospital to allow a physician who did not have privileges at the hospital to administer the drug. The hospitals have appealed at least two of these cases.
In several cases, according to media reports, patients have improved after being treated with ivermectin, which their families, their attorney, and some doctors interpret as evidence of the drug’s effectiveness.
One doctor said that Nurije Fype had been weaned off a ventilator and discharged from the hospital after receiving small amounts of ivermectin for 20 days. Judith Smentikeiwicz’s family thinks ivermectin saved her life, her son claiming that, in less than 48 hours, his mother was taken off the ventilator, transferred out of the ICU, and was sitting up on her own and communicating. Mr. Lorgio, the attorney who obtained the order, said that Ms. Smentikeiwicz “was on a ventilator, literally on her deathbed, before she was given this drug. As far as we’re concerned, the judge’s order saved this woman’s life.” Mr. Lorgio also claimed, in the case of John Swanson, that after one dose of ivermectin, Swanson was breathing on his own and taken off the ventilator “and was making great progress”.
Fortunately, for balance, some news reports about these seemingly miraculous recoveries also quoted experts cautioning that correlation does not mean causation and pointing out that there is still not enough evidence to support ivermectin’s effectiveness for COVID.
In the case of Pete Lopez, who unfortunately passed away, the family is angry because, they say, the hospital refused to administer ivermectin after being ordered to do so by a court. The hospital has appealed the order and Mr. Lorgio, the family’s attorney, is seeking to hold the hospital in contempt. In the Fype case, Mr. Lorgio tried to get the judge to order the hospital to pay the plaintiffs’ legal expenses and issue a $25,000 fine, but the judge refused, saying the hospital had complied with the court’s order.
Hospitals have had some success in fighting these actions.
In Ohio, a judge, having given the hospital an opportunity to present evidence, ruled that it “bears no duty to honor a prescription” for ivermectin written for COVID patient Jeffrey Smith (also represented by the Lorgio firm), superseding a previous order by a different judge requiring the hospital to do so. Twenty-one days of ivermectin had been prescribed by Dr. Fred Wagshul, who (as was revealed at the hearing) had never reviewed Mr. Smith’s clinical information or discussed treatment with his physicians, is not board-certified in any specialty, and has not worked in a hospital for 10 years. (At the time of the hearing, Mr. Smith had received 13 doses.) Dr. Wagshul said that the pharmaceutical industry and U.S. government have “smeared” ivermectin and “‘censored’ its allegedly undeniable beneficial value”. (An odd claim in light of the fact that the drug’s own manufacturer advises against its use.) He nevertheless testified that “I honestly don’t know” if ivermectin had benefited Mr. Smith.
In an interview, Dr. Wagshul claimed that the science behind ivermectin is “irrefutable”, that the CDC and FDA were in a “conspiracy” against the drug to protect the FDA’s Emergency Use Authorizations for COVID-19 vaccines, that the mainstream media and social media companies had been engaged in “censorship” regarding ivermectin’s benefits, and that the government’s refusal to acknowledge its benefits amounted to “genocide”. In the same article, another physician called the FLCCA doctors “snake oil salesmen” and reviewed the “serious problems” with organization’s research.
A physician testifying for the hospital said that “there is no conclusive evidence to show enough benefit exists to outweigh [the drug’s] risks”. Mr. Smith’s treating physician “disputed any notion that ivermectin demonstrably helped his patient” and said there isn’t enough evidence to support its use. The hospital’s chief of staff testified that a physician who is not board certified would never be admitted to practice there and was concerned that Dr. Wagchul had never seen the patient or reviewed his information.
The court, in ruling in the hospital’s favor, said that:
While this court is sympathetic to the Plaintiff [Mr. Smith’s wife and his medical proxy] and understands the idea of wanting to do anything to help her loved one, public policy should not and does not support allowing a physician to try ‘any’ type of treatment on human beings . . .
The court found that ivermectin
has not been shown to be effective at this juncture. The studies that tend to give support to ivermectin have had inconsistent results, limitations to the studies, were open label studies, were of low quality or low certainty, included small sample sizes, various dosing regiments, or have been so riddled with issues that the study was withdrawn.
In a New York case, last week a judge issued an order (via letter) refusing to force the hospital to treat the patient with ivermectin, although he deferred a final ruling on the petition. The patient’s prescription, written by Dr. Ross Nochimson, who specializes in “Interventional Pain and Regenerative Medicine” and was not one of the patient’s treating physicians, read
Take 5.5 pills by mouth once daily up to 5 days Depending [sic] on clinical symptoms and improvement.
As with the Smith case, there was nothing in the record to indicate that Dr. Nochimson had ever “clinically observed” the patient or “reviewed his medical record” or “what the pills are for; what are clinical symptoms and what would constitute improvement”. On the other hand, “extensive affidavits” from the patient’s treating physicians specified the “possible deleterious impact Ivermectin may have” on the patient.
The record also included an affidavit from Dr. Pierre Kory extolling the virtues of ivermectin, an affidavit to which the judge was apparently referring when he noted that only doctors without personal knowledge of the patient’s medical situation were advocating giving him the drug.
In a third case ruling in favor of a hospital, the prescribing physician, Dr. Alan Bain, was also criticized by the hospital’s attorney for failing to perform an adequate review of Randy Clouse’s medical history prior to prescribing ivermectin and ignoring “widespread medical advice” on its use, charging that Dr. Bain wanted to make Mr. Clouse (also represented by the Lorgio firm) “a guinea pig”. The hospital, in rebuttal to the plaintiff’s description of Mr. Clouse’s condition, filed documents showing that the patient was already improving and that he no longer had an active COVID case. In any event, according to the hospital, the patient’s physicians “believe administration of ivermectin will likely result in kidney and lung damage, which can lead to organ failure and death.”
In a testament to how widespread misinformation about ivermectin has become, the patient’s wife, understandably upset, claimed that a ruling in her husband’s favor “could have helped save the lives of ‘thousands of other people'”, although she said she would not appeal.
Ethical and legal views
Noted bioethicist Arthur Caplan blasted the decisions forcing hospitals and physicians to administer ivermectin in an Ars Technica interview. “There is no standard of care saying you have to use [ivermectin]”, he said, and orders forcing its administration were asking doctors to do something “unethical and illegal”. Calling the original order (now overturned) in the Jeffrey Smith case “absurd”, Dr. Caplan said that if he were these doctors, he “simply wouldn’t do it”.
Unfortunately, from a legal standpoint, as has happened in some of these cases, refusing to follow a court’s order may result in the other side filing a motion to hold you in contempt.
As I said earlier, none of the cases in which I reviewed the pleadings and orders cited any legal right to force a physician or hospital to administer a drug against a physician’s medical judgment. This absence would be notable to any lawyer because it is a basic rule of pleading one’s case, not to mention winning it, that the plaintiff be able to point to some law – whether it be a statute, administrative rule, a constitutional provision, or common law – giving him a right to relief based on the facts of his case. So basic is this principle that I began to wonder if there had been some drastic change in the law since I was in active practice.
Fortunately, this has not happened. James M. Beck, an experienced litigator at the international law firm Reed Smith LLP, and a drug and device law expert, has done the heavy lifting in researching and analyzing the issue and recently wrote about it in a blog post titled “More COVID Kookiness – Ivermectin Lawsuits“, which gives you some idea of his thoughts on the subject.
We are unaware of any legal basis for a court to order the off-label use of any medication over the objections of treating physicians and hospitals, whether or not some interloping non-staff physician might have prescribed it.
So there!
According to Mr. Beck, “precedent rejecting some sort of constitutional right to ‘medical’ use of unproven treatments goes back a long time”, as do cases rejecting statutory and common law grounds. This includes Prohibition, when a court refused to allow physicians to prescribe large amounts of alcoholic “medicine”, as well as cases rejecting a right to use medical marijuana and the quack cancer drug Laetrile. He also cites the Abigail Alliance case, which, in dispensing with the notion that a patient has a right to access experimental drugs, helped fuel a movement that ended in the “Right to Try” laws. These do not provide a right to access off-label drugs from unwilling physicians either, in part because these laws are “expressly voluntary”. Nor does the FDA’s compassionate use program provide any legal basis for doing so.
Mr. Beck concludes:
If a patient wants to self-medicate against COVID-19, whether by taking ivermectin, injecting bleach, or anything else, we’re not trying to stop them. Just leave a forwarding address for any Darwin Award. Nor would we object to a patient seeking off-label use of ivermectin as a COVID-19 treatment being transferred to a facility willing to provide it. But beyond that, patients have no legal basis to go to court to force unwilling health care providers either to participate in an off-label use they do not believe is therapeutic, or to force hospitals tolerate such a use in their facilities.
Hospitals and physicians would do well to cut and paste his blog post if faced with a lawsuit seeking to force them to administer ivermectin.
I imagine the judges who ordered the administration of ivermectin were greatly influenced by the dire straits of the patients who sought it and the cherry-picked information filed in support of their petitions. Where hospitals and physicians have been allowed to present their own evidence prior to the court’s decision, defendants have generally fared better. And I imagine some of these orders will be overturned on appeal.
        ◦ However, in the face of overwhelming legal precedent holding that no patient has a right to a particular treatment, and especially in the face of stringent opposition by those who would be forced to provide it, these decisions are indeed troubling.

The Brownstein protocol is not a proven treatment for COVID-19
Dr. David Brownstein is a “holistic” physician who practices in Dr. Gorski’s neck of the woods. Unfortunately, he just wrote a book promoting an unproven protocol involving vitamins, nebulized hydrogen peroxide and iodine, and intravenous ozone to treat COVID-19. There is no evidence that his protocol works, other than a very poor quality case series.
David Gorski on March 15, 2021
Link

As we’ve discussed many times before, the COVID-19 pandemic has been a golden opportunity for quacks and grifters and has resulted in a year (and counting) in which even “respectable” doctors have been behaving very badly indeed by spreading COVID-19 disinformation, unproven “miracle cures”, and backing anti-public health activists such as anti-maskers and anti-“lockdown” protesters, so much so that I’ve discussed quite a few of them since COVID-19 was officially declared a pandemic a little over a year ago. Unfortunately, a few of these “brave maverick doctors” are in my area, and one of them has managed to gain some national (and even international) notoriety. His name is Dr. David Brownstein, and he’s promoting yet another unproven treatment for COVID-19, nebulized hydrogen peroxide. I first noticed him promoting this several months ago, but he showed up a week ago on the website of that über-quack of über-quacks, Joe Mercola (the man who, with a net worth upwards of $100 million, is proof positive that quackery pays) in an article entitled “Nebulized Peroxide — A Simple Treatment for COVID-19“, complete with a video clocking in at nearly an hour and a half.
Mercola promotes Brownstein thusly:
Dr. David Brownstein, who has a clinic just outside of Detroit, Michigan, has successfully treated over 200 patients with what has become my favorite intervention for COVID-19 and other upper respiratory infections, namely nebulized hydrogen peroxide.
A peer-reviewed consecutive case series of 107 COVID-19 patients treated with nebulized peroxide and other remedies, including oral vitamins A, C and D, iodine, intravenous hydrogen peroxide and iodine as well as intravenous (IV) vitamin C, along with intramuscular ozone, was published in the July 2020 issue of Science, Public Health Policy, and the Law.1 All patients survived.
I’ll discuss that publication in a minute, but note the journal. It’s not a journal that would normally publish case series or randomized clinical trials. It’s a medical policy and law journal. Why, one might ask, would someone like Dr. Brownstein choose such a journal? And what of his claim now that he’s up to 220+ patients treated by his protocol without a single death? (Well, almost, as you will see…)
Before we get to that, let’s introduce you to Dr. Brownstein.
Dr. David Brownstein: Promoting alternative medicine in the suburbs of Detroit
I first encountered Dr. Brownstein in 2016, when former SBM blogger, but, more importantly, local internist and primary care doctor, Dr. Peter Lipson, took him to task for complaining about the announcement of age-appropriate vaccine requirements by a Jewish sleepover summer camp in Michigan stating, “No child, camper, staff, artist in residence, volunteer, doctor, nurse, and their families will be allowed to come to camp without documentation of complete immunization according to the policy.” That requirement set Dr. Brownstein off, and he laid down a heapin’ helpin’ of antivaccine misinformation, including the “toxins gambit” in response, leading to Dr. Lipson to call him out on it (and on several other things as well, right here on SBM).
I next encountered Dr. Brownstein throwing a temper tantrum at how difficult it was to recertify for his family practice boards. Basically, he was very unhappy about how it was all about “drugs, drugs, and more drugs” (and vaccines), and bitterly bemoaned how none of the questions were about “nutritional therapies”, “natural treatments”, or the rest of the sort of quackery that he believes in, such as acupuncture, emotional freedom technique, intravenous vitamin and minerals, elimination diets, and more. After that, it was off to the races, with Dr. Brownstein spewing all sorts of antivaccine misinformation about the shingles vaccine, keynoting antivaccine conferences around Michigan, and attacking the New York Times for a pro-vaccine editorial, the last of which was a year before the pandemic hit. So, basically, Dr. Brownstein is the Michigan equivalent of antivaccine physicians like Drs. Lawrence Palevsky, Sherri Tenpenny, Andrew Wakefield, and Dr. Mark Geier. He’s basically the Big Kahuna of antivaxxers in southeast Michigan, maybe of the whole state.
Unsurprisingly, like so many antivaxxers, of late Dr. Brownstein has pivoted to COVID-19 pseudoscience. Indeed, back in May he was warned by the FTC (here’s the warning letter) to stop advertising his “treatment protocols of Vitamins A, C & D, as well as nutritional IV’s, iodine, ozone and nebulization to support the immune system with respect to Coronavirus Diseases 2019 (COVID-19)”. As a result, he’s been discussing his “Plan B“, which was removed from his website, and now is moving on to “Plan C“. Basically, it’s some sort of “study” that was clearly put together in order to get past the part of the letter that warned:
It is unlawful under the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 41 et seq., to advertise that a product or service can prevent, treat, or cure human disease unless you possess competent and reliable scientific evidence, including, when appropriate, well-controlled human clinical studies, substantiating that the claims are true at the time they are made. For COVID-19, no such study is currently known to exist for the products or services identified above. Thus, any Coronavirus-related prevention or treatment claims regarding such products or services are not supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence. You must immediately cease making all such claims.
Which brings us to the “study” by Dr. Brownstein that Mercola touted:
A study on COVID_19 Therapies by Dr. David Browstein and colleagues has just been published on COVID-19 therapies. This…
Posted by VIAL on Thursday, July 9, 2020
Unsurprisingly, when I first looked at the study last summer, I found its abstract to be singularly unimpressive and, in fact, determined that Dr. Brownstein’s “study” wasn’t even really a study at all, but rather an editorial citing an article by antivaccine “scientist” James Lyons-Weiler. The “study” was retrospective, not randomized, not blinded (much less double blinded), and involved all manner of quackery, including oral vitamins A, C, D, and iodine given to 107 subjects (99%), with intravenous solutions of hydrogen peroxide and Vitamin C given to 32 (30%) and 37 (35%) subjects, 37 patients (35%) of the cohort receiving intramuscular ozone, and a nebulized hydrogen peroxide/saline mixture, with Lugol’s iodine used by 91 (85%). In the article, Dr. Brownstein claimed that 100% of the 107 patients treated recovered, with a high degree of rapid symptomatic improvement. It was the very definition of an utterly uninformative study, even less informative than Didier Raoult’s awful studies. Will Dr. Brownstein be able to deliver anything better this time? Let’s find out, but I suspect you know the answer.
Let’s just say that this time around he’s claiming that early treatment with his protocol can eliminate COVID-19 “long haul syndrome”, basically a poorly defined, not yet well characterized constellation of symptoms that persist after a patient recovers from a bout of COVID-19. Indeed, a study published last month in JAMA Network Open reported that at 6 months after COVID-19 infection, over 30% of adults were still having “long haul” symptoms, including fatigue, persistent loss of smell or taste, “brain fog”, and other symptoms. Interestingly, there are preliminary reports of patients with “long haul” COVID-19 symptoms improving after receiving a COVID-19 vaccine. I’m not yet convinced that this is more than a placebo effect, but it’s intriguing, as this Twitter thread by Prof. Akiko Iwasaki at Yale University suggests:
Back when I first learned about #longcovid in June 2020, I proposed 3 possible mechanisms. 1) Persisten viral reservoir 2) Viral fragments/remnants (RNA, protein) 'viral ghost’ driving inflammation3) Autoimmune response induced by the infection (2/)https://t.co/KilBUcnA2e
— Prof. Akiko Iwasaki (@VirusesImmunity) February 28, 2021
Funny how Dr. Brownstein is apparently not interested in this hypothesis. Long haul COVID-19 is a fascinating phenomenon, a worthy topic for its own post. I fear that “COVID long haulers” will be ripe targets for the sort of quackery that doctors like Drs. Mercola and Brownstein offer. In the meantime, let’s look at what Dr. Brownstein is saying now.
Dr. Brownstein curing COVID-19? Not so fast there…
So now that Dr. Brownstein’s “case series” (such as it is) has reached 230 patients according to him, you’d think he’d be ready to publish in a reputable journal, or at least to attempt to do so. You’d be wrong. Instead, he’s publishing a book (of course!), so that he doesn’t have to deal with all that pesky peer review. The title? A Holistic Approach to Viruses, and it comes with a strong recommendation by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., as fantastic an indication that there can be that it’s utter antivaccine nonsense, particularly how he says, “Dr Brownstein gives us the recipe for bolstering the most powerful and successful vaccine ever devised- the human immune system.” The book’s promotional blurb is similar:
COVID-19 should be a wakeup call for all Americans. The carnage it has caused did not have to occur. Moving forward let us make sure nothing like this happens again. You can rest assured that other viruses will be around in the future. The way to combat these pathogens resides within us- a strong, well-supported immune system.
Of course, no one in “conventional medicine” is saying that general health isn’t important when it comes to determining your resistance to pathogenic viruses and bacteria. However, I get a very strong germ theory denial vibe like so many other examples that I’ve seen before from this whole passage. Dr. Brownstein’s idea is apparently that you can “boost” your immune system with vitamins, iodine, and hydrogen peroxide in order to fight off SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, as well as viruses that cause the flu and other illnesses. Basically, the idea is that you don’t need vaccines if you only just live the right lifestyle, eat the right foods, and take the right vitamins and supplements.
So what does his treatment consist of? According to his “case series”, this is the protocol:
    • Vitamin A: 100,000 IU/day*** in the form of emulsified Vitamin A palmitate
    • Vitamin C: 1,000 mg/hour while awake in the form of ascorbic acid until bowel tolerance (loose stools) was reached
    • Vitamin D3: 50,000 IU/day in an emulsified form
    • Iodine: 25 mg/day in the form of Lugol’s solution or tableted Lugol’s solution
And:
Most patients were instructed to nebulize a dilute solution of 0.04% hydrogen peroxide in normal saline. The solution was mixed for the patient in the office. A sterile 250 cc bag of normal saline was injected with 3 cc of 3% food grade hydrogen per- oxide and 1 cc of magnesium sulfate. The patient was instructed to draw off 3 cc of the dilute solution and nebulize it hourly until symptoms improve. Additionally, the patient was instructed to add in one drop of 5% Lugol’s solution to the dilute hydrogen peroxide mixture. As the symptoms improved, the frequency of nebulizing could be reduced by the patient. If symptoms worsened or there was a concern that the patient was suffering from a more severe case, the patient was advised to come to the office and receive intravenous injections of Vitamin C and hydrogen peroxide along with intramuscular injections of ozone.
If the vitamin C and ozone were necessary, this is how Dr. Brownstein would administer them:
    • Vitamin C: 2.5 grams of sodium ascorbate (5 cc of a 500 mg/cc ascorbic acid solution) mixed with an equal amount of sterile water given as an intravenous push over 2-3 minutes.
    • Hydrogen peroxide: 30 cc of a 0.03% solution of dilute hydrogen peroxide given as an intravenous push over 2-3 minutes.
    • Ozone: 20 cc of 18 mcg/cc ozone (as an oxygen/ozone gas mixture) given in each buttock as an intramuscular injection.
Intramuscular ozone injections in the buttocks? Ouch! As for the hydrogen peroxide solution, a 0.03-0.04% solution is only a 3-4:10,000 solution, so very dilute that it’s doubtful that it could have any therapeutic effect. Certainly, it’s not going to kill much virus, given that the virus that’s causing the problem is mostly already in the cells lining the lungs, happily replicating and then bursting out to infect more cells. Although they don’t talk about the rationale much, I refer back to Dr. Mercola touting nebulized hydrogen peroxide way back in April:
Your immune cells actually produce hydrogen peroxide. This is in part how your immune system kills cells that have been infected with a virus. By killing the infected cell, viral reproduction is stopped. So, hydrogen peroxide therapy is in essence only aiding your immune cells to perform their natural function more effectively.
It is indeed true that some immune cells use hydrogen peroxide to kill cells infected with virus. But guess what? There’s a huge difference between immune cells generating small amounts of peroxide that can result in very high concentrations locally that are sufficient to kill infected cells and either injecting or inhaling nebulized hydrogen peroxide. In his article from nearly a year ago, Mercola listed a bunch of studies that demonstrate that nebulized hydrogen peroxide can kill viruses on surfaces and thereby disinfect them. That’s no big surprise, it’s a strong oxidizing agent. Its ability to kill viruses on inanimate surfaces does not mean that it’s a good treatment to kill virus in your lungs.
These days, the protocol seems to have evolved. Dr. Brownstein was very big on adding Lugol’s iodine solution to the nebulized hydrogen peroxide:
And then maybe a few years after that, hydrogen peroxide came in my window. That one, I was a little leery about, using an IV (intravenous) or nebulize, just because, I couldn’t wrap my head around, “How am I going to use this oxidative therapy? Isn’t that going to make people worse?” But the more I learned about hydrogen peroxide and it’s produced every cell in the body, it’s produced in huge amounts throughout the body, every second, every minute, every day, I started using IV and nebulized peroxide and I mixed the nebulized peroxide with a nebulized iodine in one solution. And that really was a cool addition, for people who were developing lung problems or pneumonia or lung cancer or COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease), coughing, and they can’t breathe and they’re wheezing and things like that, adding a nebulized dilute solution of hydrogen peroxide at 0.04% and one drop of 5% Lugol’s solution, which supplies 6.25 milligrams of iodine really helped a lot of people out.
There really is no good basis in basic or clinical science to use these interventions to treat COVID-19 patients. Certainly, Dr. Brownstein, for all his reading, can’t produce any, nor can Dr. Mercola. As for “really helping people out,” how does he know? How does he know that nebulized normal saline wouldn’t have produced exactly the same effect? He doesn’t, because there are no trials. Certainly, his “retrospective” trial shows nothing. Indeed, he uses that as an excuse, at one point in the interview saying:
But there are a lot of people who have died because the governments and the powers that be, and the AMA (American Medical Association) and everybody else out there has said, “There’s nothing you can offer and don’t offer anything because it hasn’t been randomized, double blind, placebo-controlled, therefore, you can’t do it. And if doctors do it, we’re going to censor them and hold them accountable.” And that’s been the biggest disaster of this whole thing.
That might have been a (somewhat) reasonable thing to say in March 2020. I say “somewhat” because people were dying and we knew little about the novel coronavirus that was ravaging the world, including whether the treatments tried without randomized clinical trials would help or hurt. When people are dying, doctors will try things before there are randomized clinical trials testing them, just out of sheer desperation. Here’s the problem, and I’ll bring you back to the example of HCQ again. It looked as though it might have promise very early on, but it didn’t take long before science showed that it doesn’t work against COVID-19. A year later, Dr. Brownstein’s statement is no longer even semi-reasonable, as there have been a large number of randomized trials on various COVID-19 treatments. We now have an idea of a few things that (probably) work and a lot of things that definitely don’t. In light of that history, Dr. Brownstein’s statement comes across to me as just another excuse to keep using unproven treatments on COVID-19 patients. Unsurprisingly, Mercola is totally in agreement with this excuse and even responds by parroting two myths about COVID-19: first, that the case number is vastly inflated (which is one he’s promoted before) and that most people die of their comorbidities with COVID-19, not of COVID-19. It’s a form of COVID-19 disinformation that I like to call the “6% gambit” because it claims that only 6% of deaths attributed to COVID-19 were actually due to SARS-CoV-2 and that the rest were due to comorbidities.
And on what basis does Dr. Brownstein base his assessment that his treatment is effective against COVID-19? Anecdotes, straight from his book:
“[Among] our [COVID-19] patients, we’ve had no deaths,” he says. “We’ve had a couple of hospitalizations, but much smaller than should be for the reported statistics. And we’re still using the same protocol we’ve been using for 25 plus years for flu and flu-like illnesses.
A patient I called over the weekend told me ‘There are two things out of what you gave me that I could tell really made me feel better.’ I gave him the whole protocol of oral vitamin A, C, D and iodine and nebulized peroxide and iodine.
He said, ‘I forgot to use the iodine the first day or two. When you asked me about it, I re-added it back in orally. That made the difference. My mucus thinned out, my breathing was better. I forgot to put the iodine in the nebulizer [too], and [when] I did both at the same time — the oral iodine and the nebulized hydrogen peroxide with iodine — everything cleared up …’
His breathing was 80%, 90% better shortly after the first or second dose of iodine. He’s another success story that we’ve had, which is supporting people’s immune systems during these viral illness times … I would implore my colleagues to add iodine into whatever regimen you’re using to treating patients who are ill with flu-like illnesses such as COVID-19.”
Now here’s the thing. Dr. Brownstein’s practice, his Center for Holistic Medicine, is located in West Bloomfield, a wealthy suburb northwest of Detroit. (Its median household income is nearly $102,000, compared to the US as a whole at $57,700.) Dr. Brownstein caters to well-off suburbanites with a love of woo. As a result, it is not surprising that he could have had 107 COVID-19 patients without a single death for a virus with a relatively low case fatality rate. It’s not even surprising that he might reach 230 patients without a single death (that he knows about). For one thing, he’s almost certainly seeing mainly mild cases of COVID-19, patients who do not require hospitalization.
Similarly, he’s very selective about whom he includes on his “trial”. They have to be patients in his practice. Remember how I said “almost” about Dr. Brownstein’s claim that he had no deaths? Or maybe I should have said “not quite”:
Dr. Joseph Mercola:And I wonder what your experience has been, because my guess is that most of the patients you’re seeing are very early on. You’re not seeing people who have just been lingering out there and not knowing what to do.
Dr. David Brownstein:That’s true. We’ve had a few patients referred to us, who weren’t our patients, and they were sick for a long period of time before they came to us. And out of our patients, the numbers hold true.
We had one patient die who was referred to us after he was sick for almost two weeks. And he was in his late 80s, got a bunch of comorbidities. And my partner treated him for two days and he died on the second day of his treatment. That was the only blemish in our protocol, but out of our patients who started early, we have very few hospitalizations, no deaths. And I would agree with Dr. Zelenko. Long-haulers are rarely minimal. When I looked at the first 107 patients, the long-haulers were 2%, now the reported numbers of them are somewhere averaging between 25% and 40% are developing long-haul symptoms. And that less than 5% number hasn’t changed with the next 150 or so patients that we’ve treated with it.
Yep. As I predicted. Dr. Brownstein and his practice are seeing the mild patients, and the patients he sees who don’t have mild cases he’s leaving out of his “case series” because they “weren’t our patients” initially. This makes me wonder how truly “consecutive” his “consecutive” case series is, now that it’s supposedly up to 230 or so patients. I also wonder why it took him so long to accumulate 230 patients. He has a large practice and accumulated 107 patients between February and May (four months), but it took him another eight months to gather another 123 patients? That is…odd. Moreover, his first 107 patients were reportedly diagnosed either via PCR or antibody testing but also included “those not tested diagnosed via symptomatology,” and I have to wonder about February given that the first two cases of COVID-19 in Michigan were not confirmed until March 10, 2020. The more I look at this “study”, the more odd things I find about it.
As for Dr. Zelenko, you might remember him. He’s still around and still promoting hydroxychloroquine (HCQ), even though there are now multiple randomized clinical trials showing that it doesn’t work against COVID-19. I once referred to HCQ as the “Black Knight of COVID-19 treatments“. Nothing has happened since then to change my mind about that or my opinion that Dr. Zelenko is a self-aggrandizing quack.
There is no evidence that inhaled hydrogen peroxide either treats or cures COVID-19, and nebulized mists of it are corrosive and can irritate and damage the mucus membranes and the airways, something that’s definitely not a good idea to subject the lungs to if you have COVID-19. Nor is there any good evidence that anything else that Dr. Brownstein does in his COVID-19 protocol is beneficial, with the possible exception of vitamin D therapy (although recent clinical evidence has not been encouraging even for vitamin D).
One year in, too much and not enough have changed
Last week marked the one-year anniversary since the World Health Organization officially declared COVID-19 a pandemic. Much has changed since then. What has changed greatly is that we now have at least three safe and effective vaccines available in the US, with more likely to come and an administration that actually supports science-based public health measures. Unfortunately, another change is the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 variants that are more transmissible (and possibly more virulent) against which current vaccines might be less effective, leaving us in a race to vaccinate as many people as possible before variants emerge that can evade the immunity produced by vaccines. What hasn’t changed is the paucity of effective treatments. Unfortunately, what also hasn’t changed are the intransigence of the antivaccine movement, which has pivoted to demonize COVID-19 vaccines even as it’s embraced QAnon conspiracy theories, and the proliferation of unproven and downright quacky treatments for the disease, along with the conspiracy theories that “they” are keeping the “cure” for COVID-19 from you. Dr. Brownstein and Dr. Mercola epitomize that.

Oleandra – The New COVID Snake Oil
Oleandrin is being promoted as the new COVID-19 snake oil – but it is a deadly toxin.
Steven Novella on August 19, 2020
Link

This compound, oleandrin, which is being pushed as a possible cure for COVID-19, is a microcosm of the many things that are wrong with the supplement and alternative medicine industries. This particular snake oil has some urgency because it is being promoted to president Trump. As Axios reports:
The experimental botanical extract, oleandrin, was promoted to Trump during an Oval Office meeting in July. It’s embraced by Housing and Urban Development Secretary Ben Carson and MyPillow founder and CEO Mike Lindell, a big Trump backer, who recently took a financial stake in the company that develops the product.
Lindell told Axios that in the meeting, Trump “basically said: …’The FDA should be approving it.'”
This is a new twist on an old scam. The pattern, as we have reported previously, is now well-established. A CAM entrepreneur secures a supply of an obscure natural product that has little to no current market value. Once they have essentially cornered the market they then promote the useless product as an exotic natural cure for whatever. They do this through the usual channels, but the holy grail is to get exposure through a CAM celebrity, like Dr. Oz. Once Dr. Oz features your product on his show, you rake in the snake oil lucre.
That appears to be what is happening with oleandrin, except the celebrity snake oil peddler is the president. He has a lot of influence on his followers, and perhaps even some influence with the FDA to boot. Look what happened with hydroxychloroquine.
Oleandrin displays another feature of the CAM industry, or currently dysfunctional regulations. Specifically, this deals with the giant hole blown in the FDA’s ability to protect the public from snake oil known as DSHEA (The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994). This was a gift to the supplement industry, creating a new category of health product that could make quasi-medical claims without any evidence of safety or effectiveness. It essentially allows supplements to be regulated more like food while making or implying medical claims.
Lindell is now trying to drive oleandrin through this hole:
The first path is as a COVID-19 drug, which would involve a rigorous process that includes clinical trials.But to hedge his bets, Whitney said he is also pushing the FDA to allow oleandrin to be sold off the shelf as a dietary supplement — a move that could be made immediately, Whitney has told administration officials. [Andrew Whitney is from Phoenix Biotechnology, the company making oleandrin – SN]
This strategy reveals the absurdity of the regulation, and how easily it is abused. Oleandrin is clearly a drug, but Whitney will try to get it categorized as a dietary supplement to essentially bypass FDA requirements for scientific evidence of safety and efficacy. As long as you don’t name a disease in the promotion, this powerful drug is magically a “supplement”. This shows how the category exists only to bypass the FDA. It is not a real science-based category at all – it’s a regulatory fiction. (True supplements are vitamins and minerals, not herbal drugs or any other “natural” drug.)
This episode also reveals the dangers of mixing politics and science. Politicians should not be meddling in the details of scientific organizations, like the FDA. The FDA should be completely independent, using scientific evidence to fulfill its mandate. When political priorities intrude on questions that should be purely based on scientific evidence, bad science and bad regulations result.
Let’s take a look at oleandrin specifically to see where we are with the science. Oleandrin is a chemical derived from the plant, oleandra (Nerium oleander). As an aside, many people may know this plant from the game Red Dead Redemption II, where it is plant that can be harvested and used to make poison. It is a beautiful Mediterranean plant used around the world for landscaping. Every part of the plant is poisonous, containing the powerful cardiac toxin, oleandrin. This can lead to cardiac arrhythmias and can be fatal.
The science made public so far is a single pre-clinical study, showing that oleandrin has anti-viral activity against SARS-CoV-2 in a test tube (the study is pre-print and has not been peer-reviewed). That’s it. This is another common feature of the snake oil industry – tout products based upon preclinical data only. This kind of data may seem promising, and allows snake oil peddlers to claim their products are backed by scientific studies. But this kind of in-vitro study tells us very little about the activity of potential drugs in living organisms. Very, very few compounds that have “promising” activity in vitro go on to become useful medicinals.
Among the many potential problems include what we call pharmacodynamics and pharmacokinetics. How is the substance absorbed, where does it go in the body, how is it metabolized and eliminated, and how long does it last? Any one of these factors can be a deal-breaker.
But even more important – what are the dose-specific desirable effects, side effects, and toxicities? In order for a drug to be useful there needs to be a sufficient dose range in which beneficial medical effects can be achieved without significant side effects or toxic damage to any organ. Again, many promising drugs fail because they cause kidney or liver damage – or fatal cardiac arrhythmias. In fact, it’s easy to find substances which kill viruses or bacteria in the petri dish. Many poisons (or bullets) will do this. The trick is to find substances that will inhibit or kill the virus at doses lower that those that cause toxicity to human cells.
Showing potentially useful activity in vitro is just the first step to finding a useful drug. It is not a very impressive step, as most such substances will eventually fail later research. We need more than one in vitro study to understand the potential harms and benefits of the drug. If it is still looking promising (unlikely but possible) then we need to do animal testing for both safety and possible effectiveness. If it survives animal testing (also unlikely) then we can proceed to preliminary human testing, just making sure it is safe and learning about how humans process the drug and how the drug affects humans. If the drug is looking safe in humans (phase 1 studies) then we can do preliminary efficacy trials, with further safety testing (phase 2). Then and only then can we do definitive double blind placebo controlled efficacy trials (phase 3).
Putative drugs fail every step along the way in this scientific gauntlet. Most drugs fail because of toxicity, and many more because they simply don’t work in a safe dose range. Often during the preliminary development stage, pharmaceutical companies have to tweak the chemical structure of naturally-occurring chemicals in order to give them any chance of being a useful drug.
To take a raw plant-based powerful poison, and promote based upon a single pre-print in-vitro study is scientifically absurd and morally horrible. To do so in the middle of a pandemic is nothing short of malfeasance.

Chiropractors continue to make claims about chiropractic and COVID-19
Chirorpractors continue to make unsubstantiated claims about COVID-19.
Scott Gavura on April 2, 2020
Link

Never let a good crisis go to waste
– attributed to Rahm Emanuel but also Winston Churchill
Perhaps not surprisingly, as the COVID-19 pandemic has upended and disrupted society, there are those that are leveraging legitimate fears to sell dubious products and services. Jann Bellamy blogged last week about naturopathy, chiropractic, and COVID-19. Two days ago, CBC News profiled action being taken in Ontario:
There’s no scientific evidence that chiropractic care can boost your immune system, but that hasn’t stopped some chiropractors from touting the practice as a tool to prevent infection from the novel coronavirus that has caused the COVID-19 pandemic.
The problem is so widespread that one Ontario man has filed at least 34 complaints against chiropractic clinics in the province alone in the past few weeks.
“As soon as there is public fear to exploit, these practitioners are really quick to get on message and promote this type of misinformation for their own profit,” said Ryan Armstrong, who runs an independent non-profit called Bad Science Watch.
Multiple organization have made statements regarding inappropriate marketing, the CBC reports:
Across the country, provincial governing bodies have issued warnings to their members not to spread misinformation about chiropractic care and COVID-19.
The College of Chiropractors of B.C., the Alberta College and Association of Chiropractors, the Manitoba Chiropractors Association and L’Ordre des chiropraticiens du Quebec have all put out statements in the last week or so.
Nationally, the Canadian Chiropractic Association has also warned members about making unsubstantiated claims.
Provincial governments are curtailing access to chiropractic. The Alberta government has ordered chiropractors to not provide services unless it is felt to be emergency or critical. Alberta’s chiropractic regulator has stated the following:
The Alberta government ordered chiropractors to cease normal operations and limit care to urgent, critical and emergency cases only. Chiropractors are not permitted to provide any service that does not constitute urgent, critical or emergency care.
The ACAC was asked by some members to clarify what urgent, critical and emergency chiropractic care means.
This is defined for all chiropractors as follows:
Urgent neurological chiropractic care:
    • This is defined as a pathology that could reasonably lead to a neurological deficit. The patient must be a demonstratable candidate for response to manual treatment, as delivered by a chiropractor; and if left untreated would result in the patient seeking urgent or emergency care at a medical facility. This must be established with a complete neuro/ortho/biomechanical assessment. No other form of assessment may be used to establish the need for care. Subluxation, wellness or functional care does not meet the criteria for urgent neurological chiropractic care in the context of what has been communicated by Alberta Health.
Urgent musculoskeletal chiropractic care:
    • This is defined as a pathology that could reasonably be a musculoskeletal condition for the patient that does, or would incapacitate the patient’s ability to function in performing daily activities without immediate intervention; and if left untreated would result in the patient seeking urgent or emergency care at a medical facility. This must be established with a complete neuro/ortho/biomechanical assessment. No other form of assessment may be used to establish the need for care. Subluxation, wellness or functional care does not meet the criteria for urgent musculoskeletal chiropractic care in the context of what has been communicated by Alberta Health.
Relying on patient preference to receive chiropractic care is not currently acceptable in establishing the need for urgent, critical or emergency care. Any consideration for in-person care should begin with the assumption that in-person care is not necessary.
While many will argue that all chiropractic is unnecessary, given this is coming from the chiropractic regulator, it leave only a very small number of patients eligible for treatment, if this order is followed. If chiropractors are following orders to offer noting but the most urgent/critical cases, then touting unproven benefits related to coronavirus should, hopefully, cease. We will keep monitoring.

TCM for COVID-19
Despite the many claims, there is no real evidence that traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is effective for prevention or treatment of COVID-19
Harriet Hall on April 7, 2020
Link

There have been many claims for the efficacy (and even the superiority) of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) compared to so-called “Western” medicine. The COVID-19 outbreak that started in Wuhan, China, could have been a unique opportunity for them to demonstrate to the world just how effective TCM could be. They might have cured COVID-19 with TCM, and they might have done controlled studies to show that herbal remedies were better than pharmaceutical remedies. But they didn’t. Here’s what happened instead.
They used “Western” pharmaceuticals
Based on evidence from a seriously flawed study, Chinese health organizations have officially recommended that COVID-19 patients take chloroquine. Chloroquine phosphate tablets (500 mg, 2 times per day) for a total of 10 days is the official recommendation of the Department of Science and Technology of Guangdong Province and Health Commission of Guangdong Province.
But a small controlled study subsequently showed no benefit.
Favipiravir (Avigan), a drug developed to treat new strains of influenza, was given to 340 COVID-19 patients in Wuhan, China. Chinese authorities reported that it was safe and “clearly effective.” Patients who got the drug tested negative for the virus in four days, compared to 11 days for patients who did not get the drug. X-rays showed improvements in 91% of those who got the drug, compared to 62% of those who didn’t. The article describing that study appears to have been withdrawn.
They added TCM to other treatments
In one published study, four pneumonia patients were treated with both Western pharmaceutical and Chinese herbal antivirals (lopinavir/ritonavir (Kaletra®), arbidol, and Shufeng Jiedu Capsule). Three patients improved symptomatically and two were discharged with negative tests. But one of those had tested negative before treatment, so presumably the diagnosis of COVID-19 was wrong. There was no control group, so no way to know whether their clinical course might have been the same with pharmaceuticals alone – or with no treatment at all.
A Chinese healthcare institute claims that acupuncturists trained in herbal medicine have treated COVID-19 patients with “important results”. They reported a 90% success rate with Qing Fei Pai Du Tang, a remedy dating back to the Han dynasty. Qing Fei Pai Du Tang is a mixture of 21 herbs, two of which (Ma Huang and Xi Xin) have been banned or restricted in other countries due to toxic effects.
They did poorly designed studies and reported anecdotal data
An integrative medicine website lists published research papers related to the treatment of COVID-19 using traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). It claims that:
the core pathogenesis of COVID-19 is a dampness pestilence caused by external cold-dampness distressing lung and spleen, transforming to heat due to dysfunctional qi activity and endogenous stagnated heat.
That is not the language of science.
They recommend various herbal regimens for different stages of the disease. They report that the use of herbal medicine to treat COVID-19 was widespread in China, that 85% of confirmed COVID-19 cases were treated with herbal remedies. They provide a long list of recommended herbal decoctions, powders, pills, granules, capsules, and injections. They report several allegedly successful studies – retrospective cohorts, case series, and case studies – using different herbal formulations, sometimes “semi-individualized,” and different endpoints. Nothing resembling a well-designed clinical trial with an appropriate control group. They describe ongoing research on various proposed treatments including chloroquine, convalescent plasma, favipiravir, and stem cell therapy. None of these are TCM, but they recommend TCM. They recommend using TCM as an adjunctive therapeutic option but admit that “The clinical evidence of CM [Chinese medicine] on COVID-19 is far from conclusive.”
An article on MedicineNet reported that supplements suggested by the Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine to treat or prevent coronavirus include:
    • Radix astragali (Huangqi),
    • Radix glycyrrhizae (Gancao),
    • Radix saposhnikoviae (Fangfeng),
    • Rhizoma Atractylodis Macrocephalae (Baizhu),
    • Lonicerae Japonicae Flos (Jinyinhua), and
    • Fructus forsythia (Lianqiao)
They also reported claims that Qingfei Paidu soup, made with ephedra and licorice root, had been effective in treating the symptoms of hundreds of COVID-19 patients; but they pointed out that those claims had not been verified by researchers or news reporters outside of China.
They repeat the NIH warning that not only are the claims inconclusive, but “some TCM herbal and supplement products may be adulterated with pesticides, industrial chemicals, prescription pharmaceuticals, or mislabeled herbs and other substances”. The NIH points out that even when studies show improvements, they are only of marginal benefit. The NIH has concluded that:
no evidence exists that any combination of herbs will cure COVID-19, or even lessen symptoms.
TCM hype and hope outweigh scientific evidence
TCM is gaining popularity in Africa because “TCM has so far played a substantial role in China’s fight against the novel coronavirus”.
YouTube videos claim that TCM has been proven effective, and Chinese doctors offer to share their expertise with overseas counterparts.
I don’t know what all these sources mean by “proven effective”, but the evidence is far below the standard that I would accept as “proof”.
Chinese government sources and news sources that follow the government-controlled narrative must be considered unreliable. TCM is important to the Chinese national agenda, and a propaganda campaign has “pumped up pseudoscience”.
Other bogus claims for COVID-19 treatments abound
I wrote an article for the Skeptical Inquirer website about how COVID-19 has provided a field day for scams and misinformation. Every kind of alternative medicine has jumped on the coronavirus bandwagon. Here are a few examples:
    • A doctor in India has been claiming Prince Charles is his patient and was cured through homeopathy and Ayurveda. A task force plans to study the treatment that was used. A spokesperson for Prince Charles said, “This information is incorrect. The Prince of Wales followed the medical advice of the National Health Service (NHS) in the UK and nothing more”.
    • Acupuncturists have claimed that COVID-19 can be treated by stimulating an acupressure point for the lungs to help strengthen Qi and blood flow.
    • Jann Bellamy has written about chiropractors claiming to protect patients from coronavirus with spinal adjustments.
    • Indian authorities are irresponsibly pushing homeopathic remedies like Arsenicum album 30C and two drops of sesame oil in each nostril each morning for prevention.
    • Naturopaths are pushing intravenous vitamin C.
    • Functional medicine practitioners are promoting detox, supplements, eliminating sugar, and “boosting the immune system” with diet.
The bogus claims make the Internet sound like a duck farm at feeding time. The Center for Inquiry has developed a new resource to inoculate against coronavirus misinformation.
The bottom line: TCM is probably not effective for prevention or cure of COVID-19
The NIH commented on alternative treatments including herbal therapies and teas. They said “There is no scientific evidence that any of these alternative remedies can prevent or cure the illness caused by COVID-19″. Instead of believing TCM claims, we should listen to the scientific experts and wait for real evidence.

Chinese government recommends bear bile for COVID-19
The Chinese Government is relentlessly promoting TCM for COVID-19, including a remedy containing bear bile, which is cruelly extracted from the gall bladders of living wild or “farmed” bears.
Jann Bellamy on May 7, 2020
Link

The National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China recommends injections containing bear bile in official guidelines for the treatment of COVID-19 with Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). The Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA), a global environmental non-profit, discovered Tan Re Qing, a Chinese patent medicine, among the government’s COVID-19 treatment recommendations. (You can find it on the official list here.) One of the ingredients in Tan Re Qing is bear bile, which is harvested from the gallbladders of bears, either in the wild or from bears held in captivity and “milked” for their bile. (In response to a claim that this was “fake news”, EIA posted a rebuttal, with further evidence.)
EIA noted the irony in China’s promoting bear bile as a COVID-19 remedy “despite a scientific consensus pointing to China’s wildlife trade as the most likely cause of the coronavirus pandemic”. The organization, which monitors illegal trafficking in wild animals, says traffickers were touting their illegal products based on the Chinese government’s recommendations. Bear bile farming is legal in China, but harvesting from wild bears is not. Bear bile is also imported into China from Laos, Vietnam, and North Korea, even though Asiatic black bears, a species commonly farmed for their bile, are protected from international commercial trade in animals and animal products under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora.
Bear bile extraction is nauseatingly cruel. As a recent National Geographic article explains:
At bear bile farms in China and across Southeast Asia, the animals may be kept for decades in small cages. Bile is routinely extracted by inserting a catheter, syringe, or pipe into the gallbladder. All methods for extracting bile are invasive and “cause severe suffering, pain, and infection,” according to Animals Asia, a nonprofit dedicated to ending bear bile farming. Neglect and disease are common on these farms, and consumers risk ingesting bile from sick bears, which may be contaminated with blood, feces, pus, urine, and bacteria, according to Animals Asia.
From a 2011 SBM post on TCM:
The Humane Society of the United States reports that the process of milking is so painful for the bears that they moan and often chew their paws during the procedure. In order to make access to the animals easier, the farmers often break the bears’ teeth and pull out their claws, sometimes brutally removing whole digits. If the bears stop producing bile, they are left to die, or are killed for their gallbladder and paws (considered a delicacy in China).
National Geographic also reports a concern about another TCM product recommended by the Chinese government for COVID-19: Angong Niuhuang Wan, a pill traditionally containing rhino horn. Although rhino horn is banned from global trade and, under Chinese law, the pill must instead contain buffalo horn, some traffickers continue to market pills containing rhino horn.
Indian officials were so alarmed that the recommended remedies might encourage poaching they sent out an alert to wildlife officers. One senior forest official told an Indian newspaper:
They (poachers) do poaching whenever there is an opportunity. Poaching is basically demand-driven. If the demand is high then people will take the risks.
Promotion of TCM for COVID-19
The Chinese government is busy promoting TCM for COVID-19, including exporting TCM products and practitioners to “help” other countries. At a press conference, a Chinese official claimed, without evidence (because there is none), that TCM has “alleviated symptoms, reduced the severity of the virus, improved recovery rates and reduced mortality rates”.
One China expert sees this boosterism as a means of deflecting criticism of China’s response to the pandemic by “causing distraction from questions that could be embarrassing for the Chinese government”. It also jibes with the government’s use of TCM as a tool of nationalism and a lucrative export product.
As David Gorski explained in a prescient 2016 SBM post, Chinese authorities are aggressively promoting TCM by putting TCM and “Western” medicine on “equal footing”, with specific policies “giving equal attention to TCM and Western medicine”. All of this is, as he pointed out, in accord with Mao’s original fabrication of so-called “traditional Chinese medicine” as a means of unifying China and, to boot, a cost-saving measure replacing effective medicine with cheap pseudoscience. This plan includes:
    • Enacting the “Law on Traditional Chinese Medicine”, effective in 2017, requiring local governments to set up TCM institutions in publicly-funded health care facilities, envisioning TCM as “key to reform of medical and health sectors and the drive toward a Healthy China”.
    • State support of TCM research, and development and protection of TCM intellectual property and TCM formulae as state secrets.
    • Of special relevance to COVID-19, expansion of TCM in dealing with disease prevention and control and “dealing with public health incidents”.
    • “Protecting and breeding” rare or endangered wildlife, implying that “the government will promote the preservation and utilization of these animals for their various body parts that are, barbarically, used in TCM concoctions”.
Hence, bear bile as a COVID-19 remedy.
As one Chinese official commented at the time,
The new law on traditional Chinese medicine will improve global TCM influence, and give a boost to China’s soft power.
Here in the U.S., acupuncturists and TCM practitioners are happy to help spread the government’s propaganda and concomitant “boost to China’s soft power” by credulously regurgitating questionable Chinese research, aided by state legislators who have given these practitioners broad scopes of practice and incorporated their pseudoscience into state law. So, ironically, while the Trump administration rails against the Chinese government for (among other things) its role in fomenting a global pandemic, state-licensed health care practitioners are actively promoting what is, in part, a bid for global influence by that same Chinese government.
Thus, the Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (CCAOM), doing its own part to give “equal attention to TCM and Western medicine”, links several documents on treating COVID-19 with TCM among its “Member Resources“. The CCAOM was created “to advance the standing of acupuncture and Oriental medicine (AOM) in the U.S.”, accomplished in part by its establishment of the Accreditation Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, the U.S Department of Education-approved accrediting agency for acupuncture and TCM schools. Accreditation makes acupuncture/TCM students eligible for federal student loans. (I wonder what Betsy DeVos would think if she knew the agency she heads plays an important part in advancing China’s interests in the U.S.)
One resource, the “Hubei Province Integrated Chinese/Western Medicine Hospital Critical Viral Respiratory Disease Formulas“, helpfully explains that “the new coronavirus pneumonia roughly approximates Chinese medicine’s ‘warm disease’ or ‘epidemic disease’ category'”, with presenting symptoms including “feeling heaviness in the body” and “greasy tongue coating”.
The fundamental pathogenic factors are dampness and heat. Clinically we need to consider the upper and middle burner for our primary treatment strategy, paying attention to latent heat, and damage to qi and yen.
Some 10 pages of TCM remedies are provided, ending with the recommendation that health care providers “secure and guard your upright, healthy qi”.
Another recommended resource, “How COVID-19 (2019-nCoV) is Currently Treated in China with TCM“, translates Chinese treatment protocols into English, advising that “Chinese medicine should take a primary role in effective treatment and must not be absent in action” and asking readers to “please share this article and the herbal prescriptions with everyone”.
Here, we learn authorities in Wuhan issued an edict that “all medical institutions in Wuhan will ensure that all infected patients take Chinese medicine before midnight on February 3, 2020.” (So much for informed consent!) Treatments include herbal formulas “administered to patients according to the individual’s TCM pattern diagnosis” (a nonsensical, pre-scientific system), including tongue and pulse diagnosis. Patients also received acupuncture at specified points “to strengthen the immune system”, “alleviate early symptoms, and to shorten the duration of the virus”, as well as moxibustion.
Specific treatment protocols are set out, based on TCM diagnoses such as “wind-cold invading the exterior”, for which the “treatment strategy” is “expel wind, release the exterior, clear heat, detoxify”. Another diagnosis: “damp heat afflicting the lung”, with the advised “treatment strategy” of “transform dampness, detoxify, disperse the lungs and expel pathogens”. And so on.
Based solely on the uncontrolled, unrandomized, unblinded observation of patients, results attributed to these TCM treatments are described as reduction of fever, increase in energy, and “obvious improvement in symptoms and an overall improved mental state”. The document claims that the Hubei Provincial Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine
diligently used TCM . . . revealing that Chinese herbs played a definitive role in positive treatment outcomes. Chinese herbal formulas harbor the unique potential to reduce fever and cough symptoms, limit disease progression, and improve overall immunity, and thus a person’s ability to mount an essential response to the virus.
Yet another CCAOM resource is from the Healthcare Medicine Institute, a provider of state-approved acupuncture/TCM continuing education courses in the U.S., titled “Acupuncture and Herbs COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Findings“. The entire document credulously repeats literally unbelievable results claimed by Chinese health authorities for a remedy called Qing Fei Pai Du Tang, a concoction of some 20 different herbs:
    • For patients with pneumonia, symptoms “markedly improved” for 60%, and 30% “stabilized”, for a 90% positive response rate.
    • Of 701 COVID-19 patients treated, “130 patients were cured, symptoms including fever and coughing completely resolved in an additional 51 patients, symptom improvements occurred in an additional 268 patients, and stabilization occurred in 212 patients.”
    • 112 patients had a body temperature in excess of 37.3 degrees C. “After taking Qing Fei Pai Du Tang for one day, 51.8% of patients’ body temperatures returned to normal. After 6 days, 94.6% returned to normal temperature.”
    • Of 351 patients, 214 had coughs. “After one day of drinking Qing Fei Pai Du Tang, 46.7% of patients’ coughs completely resolved. After 6 days, 80.6% had significant reductions in coughing.”
The “Findings” also recommend acupuncture points for COVID-19 treatment, including several “to eliminate pathogens from the body”.
Given the Chinese government’s relentless promotion, one can fairly view TCM as an ambassador for China’s international influence. After all, no one can legitimately make the case that it offers safe and effective treatment of disease. Yet, TCM (often in the form of acupuncture, a theatrical placebo) has infiltrated every facet of the U.S. healthcare system: prestigious medical centers, government institutions, public and private insurance, and healthcare provider licensing. All of this was done with the full support of the U.S. and state governments, albeit unwittingly, in the form of licensing laws, research funds, mandated insurance coverage, and legitimization of TCM education (including student loans). Without much effort on its part, the Chinese government has, in the guise of a healthcare practice, been wildly successful in spreading its ideology throughout America, an ideology grounded in a rejection of science, indifference to human suffering, and cruelty to animals.

Fake Homeopathy COVID Scam
A naturopath was arrested for selling fake homeopathic COVID treatments, which reveals the “alternative” rot in the medical system.
Steven Novella on July 21, 2021
Link

The Department of Justice announced that it has arrested Juli A. Mazi, 41, of Napa for, “one count of wire fraud and one count of false statements related to health care matters”. While the arrest is encouraging, it also highlights the incongruous double standard that currently exists in medicine.
Although this is not stated in the DoJ announcement, Mazi is a naturopath who practices as a primary care physician in California. Her practice includes “classic homeopathy”, which is something we have discussed at length on SBM. In short, homeopathic potions are made from fanciful ingredients but often diluted to such an extent that no original ingredients remain. They are therefore mostly just magic water, claimed to contain the “energy” of its previous contents. If that weren’t enough, extensive clinical trials have demonstrated that homeopathic magic water doesn’t work for any indication that has been tested.
What caught the attention of the DoJ was a tip that Mazi was selling homeopathic pellets as a substitute for COVID vaccination. As the announcement states:
This defendant allegedly defrauded and endangered the public by preying on fears and spreading misinformation about FDA-authorized vaccinations, while also peddling fake treatments that put people’s lives at risk. Even worse, the defendant allegedly created counterfeit COVID-19 vaccination cards and instructed her customers to falsely mark that they had received a vaccine, allowing them to circumvent efforts to contain the spread of the disease,
First, she was spreading misinformation about the FDA-authorized COVID vaccines. Obviously, in the middle of a pandemic, especially when we are bumping up against vaccine misinformation in terms of the vaccination program, such actions are horrific. But of course, Mazi is not the only one spreading such misinformation. As we pointed out previously, it was found that 65% of misinformation on Facebook and Twitter is coming from just 12 individuals – the “Disinformation Dozen”. That, however, is apparently insufficient to garner the attention of the DoJ. I understand that the DoJ has no authority to do anything in these cases, because they have technically not broken any laws (and that, of course, is the problem).
The DoJ statement also cited Mazi for “peddling fake treatments that put people’s lives at risk”. So – just like almost the entire alternative medicine industry and a huge part of the supplement industry. How is Mazi unlike any other naturopath? Anyone selling homeopathy, acupuncture, untested herbal remedies, energy medicine, or most things labeled “alternative” are “peddling fake treatments”.
What really makes Mazi different is the next bit – giving counterfeit COVID-19 vaccinations cards to her customers. Tellingly, the DoJ considers this to be “even worse” that peddling fake treatments that risk people’s lives. But is it really? I would consider selling fake treatments to be at the top of my list. From the DoJ perspective, the counterfeit cards is what makes this a legal case at all. If Mazi had just skipped that part, she could have continued selling fake homeopathic pellets to her customers, risking their lives, without any legal entanglements. We know this is true because there are countless alternative practitioners doing that right now, just as there are others spreading misinformation about vaccines.
There is also some concern about what is actually in those homeopathic pellets. Mazi claims they have a tiny part of the COVID-19. Hopefully, that’s a lie. If they were prepared from infected source material, that would be a legitimate concern (but this did not crack the DoJ’s top three). Homeopathic potions are not always harmless, sometimes they actually contain stuff. Let’s hope this is not one of those times.
Mazi instructs her customers that they should take 2-4 pellets, but the amount doesn’t really matter. You can give the same dose to infants. It’s all magic energy anyway, so silly things like dosing are inconsequential. She claims without evidence that this will produce lifelong immunity to COVID, because of the magic energy that will teach your immune system to fight the virus.
In the announcement the DoJ touts their “Health Care Fraud Strike Force”, which they indicate has charged individuals who have “billed the Medicare program for nearly $19 billion”. Again, they give away the real focus of this task force, Medicare fraud. So if you just charge your customers cash, you can fly under the DoJ radar.
My real point in discussing this case is to point out the hypocrisy of the whole situation. The government often makes a big show of cracking down on health fraud, but not for selling fake treatments with unproven claims. Cases typically involve some other kind of fraud. Meanwhile we allow, even celebrate, the increasing existence in our healthcare system and marketplace of unproven products and practitioners who are overtly not science-based. We allow practitioners to sell unproven, often blatantly unscientific, treatments and products with unproven health claims. Homeopathy is legal and has an FDA stamp of approval. Naturopaths are licensed by many states.
Now, during the worst pandemic in the last century, we are seeing what this brings us. Anti-vaccine disinformation is rife within the alternative medicine community. Practitioners will sell fake treatments for COVID – that is what they are often licensed to do. Homeopathy is literally 100% health fraud, and yet we sanction its existence. It is sold alongside real medicine in pharmacies. Our tolerance of what previous generations considered health fraud, our acceptance of rebranding fraud as “alternative”, “complementary”, or “integrative” is biting us hard.
You can’t water down the science-based standard of care in medicine, carve out exceptions, weaken regulations, and allow unscientific practitioners to spread dangerous misinformation, attack science-based institutions and undermine experts, and then complain when they do exactly that, just because we are in a pandemic.
This should be a wake-up call. People often ask “what’s the harm” of allowing what are essentially placebo treatments to thrive. This is the harm. Our science-based infrastructure has been devastated, and now we are literally dying from medical misinformation.

Homeopathy and COVID 45: The Toothless Old Man Laughs
As Billy Preston noted, “Nothin’ from nothin’ leaves nothin'”. And so it is with Homeopathy and COVID 45. Catholicon.
Mark Crislipon August 25, 2022
Tweet

O Homeo, Homeo, wherefore art thou Homeo?Deny thy fantasy and refuse thy name.Or if thou wilt not, be but sworn my loveAnd I’ll no longer be a Realist.‘Tis but thy fantasy that is my enemy:Thou art thyself, though not a Hanneman.What’s Hanneman? It is nor hand nor footNor arm nor face nor any other partBelonging to reality. O be some other name.What’s in a name? That which we call a dilutionBy any other name would smell not at all;So Homeo would, were he not Homeo call’d,Retain that dear delusion which he owesWithout that title. Homeo, doff thy fantasy,And for that name, which is no part of thee,Join reality.
Regular readers know I like to refer to our “Distinguished” Competition (we so need standard irony punctuation) using the rubric SCAM: Supplements, Complementary, and Alternative Medicine. It’s perhaps too cute by half (and not my invention) but I have never been happy with the nouns used to describe SCAMs. What is the opposite of science-based medicine? Fantasy-based? Fiction-based? BS- based? The nonsensical ravings of a lunatic mind-based? How would you even pronounce NRLM? See? We got issues here. But NRLM is perhaps the most fitting.
Of all the NRLM-based cults, homeopathy may be the most unhinged from reality. Well, there is Tong ren. Perhaps it is a fool’s errand to try to rank NRLMs that are based on less reality than Superman, Green Lantern, and Triplicate Girl. Although the last are/is the patron saints/saint of all bureaucracies in the multiverse.
COVID has been a boon to all NRLM-based therapies, allowing them to churn out what Harriet Hall has dubbed Tooth Fairy Science:
…refers to doing research on a phenomenon before establishing that the phenomenon exists. Tooth Fairy science is part of a larger domain that might be called Fairy Tale science: research that aims to confirm a far-fetched story believed by millions of scientifically innocent minds. Fairy Tale science uses research data to explain things that haven’t been proven to have actually happened. Fairy Tale scientists mistakenly think that if they have collected data that is consistent with their hypothesis, then they have collected data that confirms their hypothesis.
These studies get published in the Journal of Tooth Fairy Science or some equivalent and listed on the Pubmeds, sometimes resulting in remarkably credulous responses by legitimate medical organizations.
Pubmed has 80 hits for COVID and Homeopathy, compared to 28 for naturopathy, 51 for chiropractic, and a whopping 213 for acupuncture. The last not a surprise since COVID 45 started in China and there are far too many papers to review in one blog entry without an ondansetron prescription.
It is worth a high-level view of this peculiar medical literature to see what the homeopaths are up to. Many of these articles are from India, where homeopathy is popular and India may have surpassed the US in COVID 45 deaths. Association is not causation. But. Remembering that homeopathy is literally nothing, I am not so certain that applying homeopathy to COVID in India warrants the warning from one abstract, not in large friendly letters, that suggested, “there is no need to be panic”.
There are three broad uses of homeopathy for COVID 45. Actually, zero. Humor me here. But amongst homeopathic weaponry are for such diverse elements as prevention, vaccination, treatment, and long COVID.
One way to approach homeopathy is using Bayes Theorem, which makes my head hurt. As I have mentioned before, I took, and dropped, statistics 4 times in college. Once a year for 4 years. So I am not the best for explaining Bayes, but in medical practice, the basic application is that the less likely the disease, the more likely a positive test result is a false positive. Similarly, the less plausible the intervention, the more likely positive results are spurious.
Since the prior plausibility that homeopathic therapies will do anything is exactly zero, we understand that any positive homeopathic study is a false positive. Why waste time on the studies? Because it can be fun to point at homeopathy and laugh. And no matter how implausible an NRLM study, someone in reality-based medicine, as we will see, will be snookered into touting it. Same as it ever was.
Let’s look at some of the 80 hits (and I seriously considered a Rickroll for the last link) and see what the homeopaths are up to and, perhaps, have a chuckle along the away. So no drinking milk.
COVID-19 Pneumonia: A Potential Role of Homeopathy. Well, no potential role if you are a fan of reality, but the author feels that homeopathic remedies
may potentially improve the pneumonia in COVID-19 non-responder patients, especially in the early stages of the disease.
and suggests, as do many NRLM papers, that someone waste time and money to do a real clinical trial to demonstrate efficacy. I will note that most patients with COVID do fine and that in the early stages of disease, you do not know if they are going to be a non-responder. So how would one judge when to give said nostrum? The author suggests three nostrums, Arsenicum album, Stannum, and Ribes nigrum because he has found them helpful. When would one use Arsenicum? When
“Air passages constricted. Asthma worse at night. Burning in chest. Suffocative catarrh. Cough worse after midnight; worse if lying on the back. Expectoration. Wheezing respiration.”
I am always amazed are the specificity of homeopathic symptoms. What if the cough is worse at 11:59 p.m.? And if you are standing at a time zone line and jump across at the strike of midnight. Would that change the treatment?
That symptom complex is not like any COVID 45 I have taken care of. So often NLRM providers complain the real doctors only treat symptoms, not the underlying cause of dis-ease. But homeopathy is all about the symptoms, ignoring the underlying pathophysiology completely. COVID is too new for any homeopathic provings specific to that illness. So they can ignore COVID and just go after symptoms.
I suspect that it is the alleged immune effects that will be credited for the effects of most NLRM interventions and as a target for the those interventions. Support the immune system like it needs a sling.
Homeopathic Remedies in COVID-19: Prognostic Factor Research. It was open label, multi-centric, outpatient, observational study aka designed to be completely useless for any conclusions. Twenty-seven different homeopathic nostrums were given and, in a disease where most people get better, most people got better. They credited the homeopathy:
homeopathic medicines were associated with improvement in symptoms of COVID-19 cases.
and suggested further studies.Such garbage.
Homeopathy combat against coronavirus disease (Covid-19) got retracted. Why?
… the lack of empirical data and the lack of testing of the proposed model as a severe limitation that invalidates the conclusions drawn in the article. The conclusion that epidemiological studies are needed to evaluate homeopathic treatment are not justified based on the model developed by the authors. The simplified approach provided by the authors is not appropriate to model the complex biological associations and not based on evidence-based health research principles.
Doesn’t that apply to every homeopathy paper ever published? And almost every NRLM studies? I think so.
I did not realize that there was homeopathic psychiatry. Insert your own joke here. Well, there is in India where it is proposed that to cope with COVID isolation a
… web-portal will capture all the patients’ symptoms. Then homeopathy E-Prescriptions would be generated by the psychiatrists. This transmission of E-Prescription would be done using the proposed secret session key using Advanced Encryption Standards. Ignatia, Natrum Sulphuricum, Aconite, Arsenicum Album, Belladonna, etc are the important homeopathy medicines as prescribed by the homeopathy psychiatrists in COVID-19. Mathematical calculations were done on this proposed technique with positive efficacy. Hence, homeopathy telemedicine is the pivotal way to cure psychiatric patients remotely in this Post-COVID-19 “New Normal” context.
If mathematical calculations show positive efficacy, who am I to argue? Why bother with e-prescriptions when the homeopathic effect can be sent over the phone? Let’s get digital here people.
Homeopathy is popular in India where millions have received homeopathy as a COVID preventative. I will not suggest there is any association between homeopathy and the tremendous numbers of infection and deaths from COVID in India. Nope. Not me.
AYUSH for COVID-19: Science or Superstition? AYUSH is an acronym for Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, Sowa Riga and Homeopathy. I think with our Bayesean knowledge alone we can safely assign the answer the question in the title to the latter rather than the former option.
The big problem for reality-based thinkers is that every study uses several dozen interventions. Some ‘personalize’ for the individual, others ‘personalize for the epidemic:
Successful homeopathic prescriptions are based on careful individualization of symptoms, either for an individual patient or collectively in the case of epidemic outbreaks.
It is nice to be able to have it both ways. It is the odd thing about many NLRM based therapies when viewed from reality. It is the system that is the catholicon, not the specific intervention within the system. It is homeopathy that is effective, not the specific remedy.
They are also trying nosodes for COVID. We have vaccines that are safe and effective and instead they are testing the homeopathic, well, not equivalent. I always wonder how NLRM studies make it through ethics committees and I would love to read the informed consent. But then I have always been a fan of science fiction and comics.
And there is homeopathic immunotherapy for COVID: dilute the convalescent serum from COVID patients and inject it in the ill. Really. Convalescent serum was tried early in the COVID epidemic and was not effective. Diluting the serum is unlikely to improve its efficacy.
Of course, there are no quality studies to show benefits from homeopathy. And, despite the plea that (bold added)
For homeopathy, shunned during its 200 years of existence by conventional medicine, this outbreak is a key opportunity to show potentially the contribution it can make in treating COVID-19 patients. This should be done through performance of impeccably controlled, prospective, randomized clinical trials, with publication of their findings in well-ranked conventional medicine journals. If the homeopathy community fails to take advantage of this rare opportunity, it might wait another century for the next major pandemic.
I doubt they will have to wait another century for a pandemic to prove their catholicon is worthless. New word. I learned a new word. I will use it freely moving forward. Catholicon. Sweet. I don’t expect any homeopathy studies that will meet those criteria. And even homeopaths recognize they are doing a bad job with clinical studies.
Confirmation bias leading to lowering of symptom threshold, keynote prescribing, and deficiency in checking of all symptoms in each case were identified as the most important sources of bias.
Remember when I mentioned someone would be bamboozled by a homeopathy study? I give you PulmonaryAdvisor.com, who
…offers healthcare professionals a comprehensive knowledge base of practical information and resources focused on pulmonary and critical care medicine to assist in making the right decisions for their patients.
Just no critical thinking applied to NRLM. Pulmonary Advisor asks the question, “Can Homeopathic Treatment Speed Recovery in Patients With COVID-19?” Yes! And demonstrates yet again that mainstream medicine can’t appropriately evaluate NLRM studies due to a lack of understanding of NLRM medicine.
It was a study out of India where patients were randomized to receive standard therapy plus placebo vs. standard therapy plus individualized homeopathy (bold added):
Forty homeopathic medicines were prescribed for the patients. Of these, Arsenicum album was prescribed to 9.93% patients (n = 15), Bryonia alba and Phosphorus were to 7.94% (n = 12) patients each; Rhus toxicodendron to 6.62% (n = 10); Natrum muriaticum (n = 9, 5.96%); Hepar sulphuricum & Pulsatilla nigricans (n = 7, 4.63% each); Lycopodium clavatum & Nux vomica (n = 6, 3.97% each); Belladonna, Carbo vegetabilis, Chininum arsenicum, Gelsemium (n = 5, 3.31% each). At first prescription 44.37% (n = 67) of patients received 30C potency, 47.68% (n = 72) received 200C potency and the remaining 7.94% (n = 12) received higher potency. Of all, 63% (n = 96) patients received one homeopathic medicine only, while 36.42% (n = 55) patients required two or more homeopathic medicines during the study period.
Remember at 30 C
this would require giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient.
So any reality-based human would realize that this study compared two placebos and found one placebo was better at improving mostly subjective symptoms. And it was a single-blind study, the treating naturopath knew who was getting what. As we have learned, and relearned, when NRLM practitioners are not blinded to treatment groups, the results are unreliable. Actually, the results are reliable in that there will be a false-positive salubrious effect credited to the NRLM.
Two major flaws in the study: the underlying treatment is unhinged from reality. The other was inadequate blinding.
Pulmonary Advisor recognizes neither if these flaws, gullibly quoting the paper:
A major limitation of the current study is the fact that because of the large number of COVID-19 patients at the hospital, follow-up laboratory tests could not always be performed because of a resource crunch. Further, restricted access to patients because of the high transmissibility of COVID-19 limits the number of homeopathic prescriptions, since various patient attributes and disease characteristics need to be known when selecting these medications.
Yet another medical reviewer falling off the turnip truck. No critical thinking whatsoever. Hey, Harriet. Can you write a book similar to There’s No Such Thing as the Tooth Fairy! for healthcare providers? Sorely needed.
The treatment of COVID with homeopathy did result in the funniest line in the medical literature, also the saddest. From Adjunctive homeopathic treatment of hospitalized COVID-19 patients (COVIHOM): A retrospective case series I give you
At the start of treatment, each patient received Influenzinum, either in CH200 potency or in case of very bad condition, in CH10,000 potency on day one.
Remember, at 13 C
If pure water were used as the diluent, no molecules of the original solution remain in the water.
At 30 C
this would require giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient.
200C?
the total mass of pills that would have to be consumed to encounter a single molecule of the original substance would be billions of times greater than the mass of the Earth.
The multiverse isn’t likely not big enough to find one molecule on 10,000C. As many have said, it should be homeopathic delusions, not dilutions.
Still, there are some reality-based assessments. In Role of Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Prevention and Treatment of COVID-19: An Overhyped Hope, they sum it up as well as I could.
However, no clinical evidence of these alternative medicines to treat COVID-19, lack of high-quality data, little or no data to support their claims, lack of statistically significant number of participants, long-term efficacy, proper follow-up,no comparative control groups and no adherence to strict quality norms while conducting clinical trials are some of the concerns expressed by experts.Therefore, unless research is not conducted as per standard protocols, CAM will be seen with a lot of skepticism in medical science.
Except at Pulmonary Advisor.
That’s it, a brief tour of some the NLRM homeopathic studies.
After that I need a drink. Thank the gods bartenders do not subscribe to homeopathic principles.
Catholicon.

Department of Self Aggrandizement
See my talk at SkepticCamp 2022. Alt Med in the Age of COVID: What is the Evidence.

Naturopaths exploit COVID-19 with unproven treatments and self-promotion
The American Association of Naturopathic Physicians endorses unproven IV Vitamin C as a COVID-19 therapy and pushes for inclusion of naturopaths in fighting SARS-CoV-2. Actually, naturopaths should sit this one out and let the doctors and nurses on the front lines have the PPE they are currently wasting administering bogus treatments.
Jann Bellamy on April 9, 2020
Link

Naturopaths, chiropractors, TCM practitioners, and charlatans selling various nostrums are serving up a seemingly limitless supply of blog fodder in their efforts to exploit the COVID-19 pandemic. Today we take yet another look at this phenomenon, focusing (again) on naturopathy.
Naturopathic “doctors” and “physicians” display an allegiance to pseudoscience and quackery combined with an inflated sense of their competency that does not bode well for their role in combating the coronavirus pandemic, a role they insist on playing to the detriment of their patients and to the real health care providers on the frontlines of treating victims of COVID-19.
The pandemic puts naturopaths and their organizations in an awkward position. To the authorities, they must at least appear to toe the scientific line by urging compliance with advice given by the CDC and other reputable sources, including the fact that there are no proven preventatives or treatments for COVID-19. Otherwise, they could risk the consequences. On the other hand, they’re not about to give up their livelihood – indeed, their raison d’être — which depends on bogus diagnoses, worthless treatments, and a rejection of evidence-based medicine, including their traditional opposition to immunization.
This tension has resulted some hypocritical advice from the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP), which is asking its members to
Please communicate only evidence-based, accurate information. . . Refrain from posting medically inaccurate or unsubstantiated claims regarding any potential therapies with relation to COVID-19.
The AANP correctly states that
there are no known preventive measures, treatment protocols, or cures specifically for COVID-19 [and] claims that you or naturopathic medicine can prevent, treat, or cure COVID-19 are considered false and misleading. Such claims could impede public health efforts, harm the profession by drawing negative attention, and could put your license in jeopardy.
Given the naturopathic view that evidence-based medicine is optional, one could rationally conclude that “harm the profession by drawing negative attention” is the driving force behind this effort.
Yet, even as they try their hardest to project an air of scientific authority, the AANP cannot resist promoting unproven therapies.
A recent AANP press release urges physicians and hospitals to utilize IV Vitamin C as “an effective and affordable intervention” for “high risk and hospitalized patients”, pretentiously offering themselves as “a resource to physicians and organizations looking for clinical guidance in the proper use of this intervention”. Why? Because Paul Anderson, ND, described as an expert on IV Vitamin C and a member of the AANP’s COVID-19 Task Force, has “been using IVC safely and effectively . . . for over 20 years” and his review of the evidence “shows that the use of IVC in hospitalized COVID-19 patients has a high probability of reducing hospital stay, duration and improving outcomes.”
Should the medical profession count on the AANP’s and Anderson’s assessment of the evidence? Well, the FDA and its experts were decidedly unimpressed by Anderson’s supposed expertise when he served as the AANP’s point man in trying to get approval for the use of unproven substances in compounded drugs. Anderson
testified before the PCAC [Pharmacy Compounding Advisory Committee, a panel of experts advising the FDA] in support of sodium dichloroacetate, stating that his group had administered over 10,000 doses orally and IV as an adjunct treatment for cancer. Anderson testified at the same committee meeting in favor of cesium chloride. Both substances were voted down unanimously by the PCAC and cesium chloride was ultimately banned by the FDA.
Later, the agency also concluded that sodium dichloroacetate is not appropriate for use in compounded drugs.
Before its ban, cesium chloride, which can have deadly side effects, was used by naturopaths and other fringe practitioners in the treatment of cancer based on a crackpot “theory” that it neutralizes the toxic material produced by tumor cells and prevents them from dividing.
In fact, the FDA has rejected, due to lack of evidence of safety and efficacy, at least a dozen of the AANP’s nominations for substances naturopaths, in their devotion to “evidence-based, accurate information”, have heretofore freely employed in treating their patients.
The California Naturopathic Doctors Association and the state’s Naturopathic Medicine Committee (NMC) are all-in on promoting IV Vitamin C as well:
NMC is also aware of the new research that is available regarding IV Vitamin C and shortened duration of hospital stays for COVID-19 patients, and are prepared to help get NDs into hospitals to assist with administering this therapy to patients should it be recognized as a treatment option.
Not that the medical profession, even without this background information, would ever consider a press release from the AANP as guidance in the treatment of COVID-19, it is worth noting that the Australian Government Department of Health recently issued a safety alert, stating it
is aware of a report that intravenous high-dose vitamin C may be beneficial in the management of a COVID-19 infection. We have investigated this report and found there is no robust scientific evidence to support the usage of this vitamin in the management of COVID-19.
Other experts agree that the evidence for IV Vitamin C in the treatment of COVID-19 is lacking and recommend against it.
In another display of mixed messaging, the AANP advises naturopaths not to claim
This product will boost your immunity to COVID-19 and is a must-have during this pandemic! Purchase now through our site.
Yet, the AANP also says
The global impact of the pandemic and extremely high demand for some products is definitely interrupting the supply of certain ingredients, especially for immune support products. In the face of supply challenges across the entire supplement industry, AANP’s corporate partner Fullscript encourages providers to use their similar products tool to find brands or products that you may not have tried before in case your trusted product may be unavailable.
So, don’t claim a product will “boost” a patient’s immune system but we’ll help you find products that allegedly provide immune “support” to stock your online pharmacy. I’m sure there’s a difference in there somewhere. (Unlike medical ethics, which regards in-office dietary supplement sales as a financial conflict of interest, this is not considered an inherent conflict in naturopathic practice.) By the way, instead of the hard sell, the AANP suggests a subtler approach to promoting dietary supplements in this recommended script for naturopaths advising their patients on COVID-19:
The CDC has recommended that patients secure a three month supply of medications. Our practice has products in stock if you are running low & need refills.
Note the conflation of “medications” with “products in stock”.
To further one’s suspicion that the AANP’s supposed dedication to evidence-based treatment of COVID-19 is less than robust, the AANP is urging participation in a global collection of treatment anecdotes, one purpose of which is to “report contributions by naturopaths to COVID-19 management and risk reduction”. Called the “Naturopathy and Complementary Medicine COVID-19 Support Registry”, it collects case reports not only from naturopaths, but also chiropractors, acupuncturists, herbalists, and practitioners of reiki, healing touch, Ayurvedic, and TCM, as well as MDs, DOs, and nurses, and their patients. The Registry asks practitioners and patients to check off, from a long list of unproven treatments, any therapy they’ve employed, including turmeric/curcumin, colostrum, hydrotherapy, mushrooms, homeopathy, echinacea, olive leaf, garlic, yarrow, and (of course) IV Vitamin C, and state their therapeutic goal (prevention, treatment, recovery, etc.). Practitioners and patients are then asked to provide the “case outcome”, all the way from “did not become infected with COVID” and “full recovery-remained outpatient” to “hospitalization-ICU” and “death”.
In other words, having admonished naturopaths not to use unproven treatments, the AANP is urging naturopaths to report the results of those unproven treatments which, of course, they cannot do without using them.
Color me suspicious that this survey will actually produce any information truly useful in treating COVID-19. Rather, I wager it will be a repository of unconfirmed, cherry-picked cases to be deployed as PR and “evidence” of the success of naturopathic and other CAM treatments. We’ll see what happens.
Paging Drs. Fauci and Birx!
In another bit of pretentious self-promotion, the AANP issued a press release encouraging “all government officials coordinating the national response” to COVID-19 to use naturopathic doctors “in changing the trajectory of this public health crisis”. (In a similar bid to exploit the crisis, the California Naturopathic Doctors Association is lobbying for an emergency scope of practice expansion.) In language that blows one’s irony meter wide open, considering naturopathic opposition to vaccination and its association with lowered vaccination rates and higher rates of vaccine-preventable diseases, the AANP claims that
Many current public health practices . . . are foundational principles of naturopathic medicine and inform our approach to support public health efforts through this current pandemic. We stand in solidarity with our colleagues at the . . . CDC, . . . WHO and State and Local governments in promoting essential public health measures to reduce the burden on U.S. and global healthcare systems.
Right, just not the “public health practice” of immunization to reduce epidemic diseases, which their “colleagues” at the CDC named one of the 10 greatest public health achievements of the 20th century.
In its pitch, the AANP also makes the demonstrably false claim that “NDs are trained comparably to conventional doctors to diagnose and triage according to presenting symptoms . . .” The American Academy of Family Physicians begs to differ, noting, among other deficiencies, the low standards for admission to naturopathic “medical” school and their lack of a residency requirement (and therefore meaningful clinical experience), and some 15,000 hours’ difference between the education and training of naturopaths and family practice doctors. Ex-naturopath Britt Hermes has done an excellent exposé (also here) of naturopathic education and training as well, including its emphasis on quackery like homeopathy and bogus diagnoses like “adrenal fatigue”.
The press release ends with a plug encouraging
those individuals who test positive to the SARS-C0V-2 virus but are instructed by healthcare authorities to self-quarantine at home to receive personalized care from naturopathic doctors via telemedicine.
That’s a bad idea. The California NMC has, unsurprisingly, “already received numerous complaints” about naturopaths claiming their nostrums will prevent or treat COVID-19.
In some states, naturopaths are authorized to evaluate and test patients, including children, for COVID-19, a troubling development in light of their lack of education in infectious diseases and their ability to go straight into practice without adequate clinical training. They are also continuing to see patients in the office for no good reason: these naturopathic practices, for example, still offer bogus IV treatments. Another practice offers in-office acupuncture. In each of these and countless other visits to naturopathic offices, patients are increasing their exposure to the virus and naturopaths and their staff members are needlessly consuming scarce personal protection equipment. PPE is a zero-sum game, and for every mask, gown, or pair of gloves used by a naturopath administering some useless nostrum, there is a physician, nurse, or other healthcare provider out there on the front lines without proper PPE risking his or her life.
Some states have created this debacle by foolishly licensing naturopaths as health care providers and others by tolerating their practices under so-called “Health Freedom” laws. During the pandemic, states should not deem naturopaths “essential workers” (which allows them to continue working) and order them to donate their PPE to health care practitioners who actually need it.

Pandemic drives huge surge in herbal remedy sales
The COVID-19 pandemic has fueled a boom in herbal supplement sales.
Scott Gavura on November 11, 2021
Link

You may or may not have noticed that I stepped away from blogging a few months back, though it feels like longer to me. I want to express my appreciation to the David Gorski and Steven Novella for their understanding, and to Dr. Jonathan Howard for stepping in while I was away. I’ve learned a lot from Dr. Howard’s posts, and I hope you’ve appreciated his writing, too. They’ve been saying blogging is dead or dying for over a decade, but I’m thrilled to be back making my modest contribution to SBM’s Sisyphean mission and keeping science and medicine blogging alive.
– Scott
For more than a year, I felt like it was inappropriate or irrelevant to write about anything other than the pandemic, given how quickly the science was emerging and how it totally dominated all aspects of our lives. I wasn’t thinking of much else. But I’m increasingly optimistic that we are on our way out. Notwithstanding new variants, breakthrough infections, and the inevitable antivaxxer tears, it’s the effectiveness of the vaccines and now the emergence of effective antivirals that makes it look like the worst of the pandemic may be behind us.
With that cautious optimism in mind, maybe it’s time to look at some of our recurring topics, such as the popularity of complementary and alternative medicine. Pre-pandemic, I probably would have guessed a global pandemic that kills millions might turn people away from unsubstantiated, unproven supplements that have limited roles in actually promoting health. I would have been terribly wrong. The pandemic created the conditions for a huge surge in demand for herbal remedies, as detailed in the 2020 American Herbal Council annual report. They recently reported that supplements made up of herbal and/or fungal ingredients had sales that exceeded $10 billion in 2020, a 17.3% increase over 2019, crushing the previous record increase of 9.4% in 2018. Let’s take a closer look at some of the highlights.
Elderberries sales surge amidst pandemic
Elderberries make me think of Monty Python, not supplements. But elder berry (or elderberry, if you prefer) was the top selling “mainstream” (food/grocery/pharmacy) supplement in 2020, with a sales surge of a whopping 150% over 2019. This ingredient has been growing in popularity for past few years, moving from 25th top selling herbal ingredient in 2015, to first place in 2020. The fruit of the European or Black elder tree, it has a long history of use in food, beverages and for medicinal purposes, where berries are used as a laxative, diuretic, and to treat respiratory infections. It is an active ingredient in supplements like Sambucol and is manufactured into a variety of lozenges and other products. The Natural Medicines Database rates elder berry as “possibly effective” for influenza but notes that a small clinical trial with adults and children showed it did not reduce the duration of symptoms. Harriet Hall blogged about it in 2019 and was perhaps a bit more optimistic than I am now. In 2020, the largest double-blind, randomized, placebo controlled study of elder berry on influenza (87 patients) was published and found no meaningful effects. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health says, “There’s not enough information to show whether elderberry is helpful for any other health purposes”. Perhaps not surprisingly, there is also no published evidence to suggest it is effective to prevent or treat COVD-19 infections. The Herbal Gram report notes:
Google searches for “elderberry” peaked in late March 2020, shortly after the World Health Organization declared the COVID-19 outbreak a pandemic,6 and the fifth most-common search with “elderberry” in 2020 was “elderberry coronavirus.”7 According to the US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), there were no published human clinical trials related to elder berry and COVID-19 as of July 2021,8 and the FDA sent warning letters to at least five companies in 2020 for marketing products with unsubstantiated claims involving elder berry and COVID-19.9
It is understandable that “immune health” would be a frequent reason for seeking dietary supplements in 2020, perhaps demonstrating the triumph of marketing over evidence. There are no dietary supplements that can actually boost immunity or improve resistance to, or the consequences of, COVID-19 infections. The report notes that other products that were popular in 2020 for “immune health” included echinacea, garlic, and turmeric, with all of these products experiencing sales increases.
Ashwagandha
Ashwagandha sales had a large increase (185%) in mainstream channels with $31 million in sales, putting it as the 12th best selling herb in 2020. Popularity has grown quickly over the past few years as more consumers in North America have become familiar with this product. Ashwagandha is used in the Ayurveda medical system and is touted to be an “adaptogen”, a product said to help one resist or adapt to stress. The name of the plant is Withania somnifera, which is a small shrubbery from which the roots are dried and used for medicinal purposes. Oral consumption of ashwagandha seems to be safe, and there is evidence that it does have medicinal effects. The Natural Medicines Database rates it as “possibly effective” to reduce stress and stress-related weight gain. Harriet Hall discussed ashwagandha in March 2021, and noted The Medical Letter‘s warning about the risk serious adverse events:
There is no convincing evidence that ashwagandha supplements are effective or safe for any indication; patients should be advised not to take them. FDA-approved drugs are available for treatment of all the conditions for which these herbal supplements are being promoted.
The paper quotes a survey conduced by the “Council for Responsible Nutrition” which represents dietary supplement manufacturers, with some insight into how and why consumers changed their supplement habits:
According to CRN’s 2020 COVID-19 Consumer Survey, 43% of supplement users changed their supplement routines since the beginning of the pandemic, and of those, 91% increased their supplement intake. When asked why these consumers increased their supplement intake, nearly a quarter cited mental health reasons, including stress and anxiety.
There’s no question that the pandemic has affected mental health. It’s not surprising that people sought out therapies and tried to self-medicate with supplements, particularly when health professionals may have been harder to access.
Apple cider vinegar
This supplement has admittedly always puzzled me. It’s vinegar, not magic! Yet the pandemic was the backdrop to a 100% surge in mainstream market sales over 2019, leading to an amazing $80 million in sales. ACV has been recommended as a cure-all for decades, for everything from weight loss to digestive issues (especially the ubiquitous “detox”) to the belief that it can affect blood sugars and insulin sensitivity. New to me, you can apparently get ACV in tablets, capsules and even “gummies” now. Personally, I use ACV occasionally in a salad dressing. For that purpose, it seems to be highly effective. For any medicinal or health-oriented use, research and evidence is lacking.
On the decline
Harriet Hall discussed garcinia back in 2013 when it was featured on The Dr. Oz Show. Sales through mainstream channels skyrocketed through 2015, hitting $54 million, based on his promotion of the fruit as a “magic weight loss cure”. Following multiple lawsuits, Senate hearings, and an FTC settlement with a garcinia manufacturer, sales have been steadily declining.
Another product which probably deserves its own blog post is ivy leaf supplement, which is manufactured into cold and influenza remedies. Sales of these products dropped significantly in 2020, possibly owning to the dramatic decrease in colds and influenza due the public health measures enacted to control the spread of the novel coronavirus.
Finally, another product with significant decline in sales is CBD oil, down from a peak in 2019. While it was the top selling product in the “natural” sales channel (meaning specialty supplement retailers, like GNC), sales dropped 36% over 2019, to $57 million. The report speculates on possible factors for the decline, ranging from isolation at home, the prioritization of immune health, and the quality issues with CBD in the United States market place, where many products advertised as containing CBD actually have no CBD in them. (If you’re looking for regulated, quality-controlled CBD then I invite you to come to Canada when cannabis products are not only legal, the number of retail shops seemingly has no upper limit. Just don’t try crossing the border with it.)
The pandemic affected everything, even supplement buying behavior
        ◦ The pandemic disrupted industries and forced businesses to adapt – and the herbal supplement industry is no exception. What surprised me was how much the pandemic has turned out to be a net positive for this industry. Clearly, the decades of marketing herbal remedies and dietary supplements as safe and effective has paid off, driving sales increases and demand for products with little to no evidence of efficacy. But given what we’ve seen in the pandemic in terms of demand for products like hydroxychloroquine and later ivermectin, a lack of effectiveness is no barrier to sales success.

BOO: Or how “magic dirt” became a MLM miracle cure scam for COVID-19
“BOO” stands for Black Oxygen Organics, a “cure” for COVID-19 that got the attention of regulators last week. Basically, it’s dirt billed by its believers as “magic dirt” that sells for $110 a bag (plus shipping) through a multilevel marketing sales model. What can this latest COVID cure tell us about the relationship between alternative medicine and COVID-19 denial?
David Gorski on December 6, 2021
Link

Last Thursday, NBC News published a story by Brandy Zadrozny titled “‘Magic dirt’: How the internet fueled, and defeated, the pandemic’s weirdest MLM“. The story was about something called “BOO”, which stands for Black Oxygen Organics, a company and product that over the last several months had become a hit among believers in alternative medicine as a miracle treatment for COVID-19. I debated about writing about BOO because the story seemed almost too unbelievable for even me, but then I considered the simple fact that antivaxxers had been using a form of bleach solution, known as Miracle Mineral Supplement (MMS, also sometimes called Miracle Mineral Solution) to treat autism and lots of other conditions for years and years (or, as I put it, bleaching away what ails you) and I had been writing about it. (Unsurprisingly, MMS is also now billed as a treatment for COVID-19, as I’ll touch on later.)
But what is BOO? In brief, it’s mud, dirt, peat bog, or whatever you want to call it, as Zadrozny explains:
The social media posts started in May: photos and videos of smiling people, mostly women, drinking Mason jars of black liquid, slathering black paste on their faces and feet, or dipping babies and dogs in tubs of the black water. They tagged the posts #BOO and linked to a website that sold a product called Black Oxygen Organics.
Black Oxygen Organics, or “BOO” for short, is difficult to classify. It was marketed as fulvic acid, a compound derived from decayed plants, that was dug up from an Ontario peat bog. The website of the Canadian company that sold it billed it as “the end product and smallest particle of the decomposition of ancient, organic matter.”
Put more simply, the product is dirt — four-and-a-half ounces of it, sealed in a sleek black plastic baggie and sold for $110 plus shipping. Visitors to the Black Oxygen Organics website, recently taken offline, were greeted with a pair of white hands cradling cups of dirt like an offering. “A gift from the Ground,” it reads. “Drink it. Wear it. Bathe in it.”
BOO, which “can be taken by anyone at any age, as well as animals,” according to the company, claims many benefits and uses, including improved brain function and heart health, and ridding the body of so-called toxins that include heavy metals, pesticides and parasites.
Unsurprisingly, Black Oxygen Organics has a magical mystical origin story for its products:
CEO and Formulator, Marc Saint-Onge, made an exhaustive search in Canada analyzing 63 peat bogs across Ontario and Quebec. Years of testing and evaluating led to the discovery of a living source with one of the highest levels of fulvic acid in the world.
Black Oxygen Organics owns the sole extraction rights to one of the richest living sources of fulvic minerals in the world, an uncontaminated, fulvic acid-rich peat bog in the Ottawa Valley in Ontario, Canada.
Black Oxygen Organics developed and owns the proprietary harvesting methods and controls every aspect of manufacturing from start to finish. No outside influences and no middle formulator means we can provide a better product at a better price and be more generous with our rewards plan.
Today, Black Oxygen Organics sustainably harvests from one of the richest peat bogs on the planet, not far from Marc’s home in Ottawa.
I do love a good peaty single malt scotch, but this is ridiculous. As for Marc Saint-Onge, he describes himself as a “orthotherapist, naturopath, kinesitherapist, reiki master, holistic practitioner, herbalist and aromatherapist,” in other words, a practitioner of several forms of total quackery. Beyond the quackiness of Saint-Onge himself, there’s also a Quack Miranda Warning on the website—”BlackOxygen products are to be used as supplementary products and are neither designed nor should be marketed as having the ability to prevent, cure, treat or cure human disease, including COVID-19″—which should tell you all you need to know about the claims for BOO. However, I’ll cut to the chase (unusual for me, I know!) before going into the history. In September, Health Canada announced a recall of Black Oxygen Organics tablets and powders, citing potential health risks and promotion of the products in ways that had not been evaluated or authorized. On Friday last week, the FDA followed suit around the same time that the company announced that it was closing up shop as it was faced with a class action lawsuit by Georgia residents over, hilariously…well, I’ll just let NBC News story tell the tale:
Growing concern among BOO sellers about the product — precipitated by an anti-MLM activist who noticed on Google Earth that the bog that sourced BOO’s peat appeared to share a border with a landfill — pushed several to take matters into their own hands, sending bags of BOO to labs for testing.
The results of three of these tests, viewed by NBC News and confirmed as seemingly reliable by two soil scientists at U.S. universities, again showed elevated levels of lead and arsenic.
Those results are the backbone of a federal lawsuit seeking class action status filed in November in Georgia’s Northern District court. The complaint, filed on behalf of four Georgia residents who purchased BOO, claims that the company negligently sold a product with “dangerously high levels of toxic heavy metals,” which led to physical and economic harm.
And:
Assuming the company-provided analysis was correct, two of the scientists confirmed that just two servings of BOO exceeded Health Canada’s daily limits for lead, and three servings — a dose recommended on the package — approached daily arsenic limits. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has no comparable daily guidelines.
Holy traditional Chinese medicine herbal remedies, Batman! It does puzzle me how those so committed to “natural” remedies can be so fond of treatments that have at times poisoned people because they contain unsafe levels of arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury. There’s something that’s actually rather poetic, though, about a “miracle dirt” that’s billed as a cure for everything that ails you, including COVID-19, actually coming from a peat bog (Moose Creek Bog in Ontario) that abuts a landfill. I view this observation as a metaphor for so much of alternative medicine.
But let’s go back to how BOO got to this point, first by examining the claims for BOO made by the company.
The “science” of BOO
So what is fulvic acid anyway, and what does it do? This is its chemical structure, for those of you with a chemistry background.
As those among you with organic chemistry backgrounds can see, it’s a polyphenolic acid. There are, of course, more than one kind of fulvic acid, as it can polymerize, but there’s no need to go into a lot of detail. I can’t help but mention this aspect of fulvic acid and similar compounds described in a recent study published by the Royal Society of Chemistry by a group of scientists in China:
Humic substances (HS) are redox-active organic compounds that constitute a major fraction of natural organic matter in soils. The electron transfer capacity (ETC) of soil HS is mainly dependent on the type and abundance of redox-active functional groups in their structure. It is unclear whether or not agricultural land-use types can affect the ETC of HS in soils. In the present study, we evaluate the responses of ETCs of soil humic acids (HA) and fulvic acids (FA) to different agricultural land-use types. Our results show that both HA and FA of paddy soil showed the highest ETCs, followed by tomato soil, celery cabbage soil, grapevine soil, and myrica rubra soil, respectively. Agricultural land-use types could affect the transformation and decomposition of HS in soils, and thus further change the intrinsic chemical structures associated with ETC
So fulvic acids are interesting compounds that can be important in agriculture, but what about humans? An article written before the pandemic points out that fulvic acids have been touted to treat:
    • Hay fever.
    • Eczema (atopic dermatitis).
    • Alzheimer disease.
    • Cancer.
    • Fatigue.
    • Lead toxicity.
    • Infection of the airways.
I also searched this site to see how many times we have mentioned fulvic acid over the years. I came up with only twice, once by the now-retired (from SBM) Mark Crislip in 2017 and once by me more recently, both times mostly in passing.
Perusing Facebook, I found other claims:
And:
And of course fulvic acid can “detox” glyphosate:
There are also a number of private groups proclaiming fulvic acid to be a cure-all.
In any event, as the article from WebMD noted, there is no good evidence that fulvic acid does anything for any of the listed conditions. Not that that stopped BOO from selling its bog woo. Perusing the archived website of Black Oxygen Organics, specifically the Science section, I was struck by how much the rationale for BOO resembles homeopathy:
Fulvic acid is the end product and smallest particle of the decomposition of ancient, organic matter. Organic matter is just a fancy way of saying peat bog.
When extracted, purified and delivered in a liquid supplement form, it carries all the nutritional information, anti-oxidant capacity and genetic coding of everything in that decomposed matter. We know the fundamental building blocks of our bodies are the same as other organisms so it only makes sense to nourish your body with what it is made of, optimizing regeneration and repair.
See the homeopathy vibe? It’s as though the fulvic acid from the decomposing matter in the peat bog retains a memory of all the “nutritional information, anti-oxidant capacity and genetic coding” of everything that produced it. That’s not unlike the idea behind homeopathy that the water used to dilute the original compounds used for homeopathic remedies retains a “memory” of the remedy. Still, this is not homeopathy, and I’m not claiming that it is. I’m just pointing out how similar themes keep resonating through all of alternative medicine. One of these is the Law of Contagion, which suggests that once two things have come in contact they retain “memories” or “influences” from each other.
Other influences include “detoxification” in the form chelation of heavy metals, as a naturopath named Frank Stubenvoll, billed as also a “specialist and certified teacher in the field of mitochondria therapy and Kirlian diagnosis”. His paper making this claim is truly a masterpiece of pseudoscience, as Kirlian diagnosis was used. If you don’t remember or don’t know what that is, Kirlian diagnosis involves doing something called Kirlian photography, which is basically a photographic technique that supposedly shows a person’s “energy” or “aura.” As described on Quackwatch, during this procedure, the object (e.g., a person’s hand) is placed on a photographic emulsion within an apparatus that generates a high-voltage (15,000 to 100,000 volts), low-amperage (so that it’s not dangerous), high-frequency electric current. The resulting photo shows a fuzzy glow surrounding the outline of the object. As Stephen Barrett noted:
Proponents correlate these patterns with acupuncture meridians and claim that “auric” qualities reveal changes in health and emotional state. Kirlian photography has also been claimed useful for demonstrating changes before and after chiropractic spinal manipulation. However, scientific investigators have shown that Kirlian effects depend on physical factors that are well understood.
And:
Kirlian photography is alleged to detect all types of disease (even before physical signs appear) and emotional states. Many “energy healers,” “clairvoyants,” and other occult practitioners still rely on it today. “Supernaturally gifted” people are claimed to generate unusually dramatic photos. However, scientific investigation has found that the outcome depends on the type of film, the voltage, the skin resistance (which can be affected by perspiration and the amount of pressure of the finger on the film), how well the subject is electrically grounded, the humidity of the room, the exposure time, the photographic development time, and even the order of the photograph in a series [3,4].
Now there’s a rousing endorsement of fulvic acid and BOO as “chelation” therapy of the heavy metals that you’ll absorb from the BOO mud itself.
Then, of course, BOO claims that its peat bog-derived products have “antioxidant” properties, using with a heaping helping of bizarre chemistry to justify the claims:
Due to its nanite size, fulvic acid moves easily into cells, including crossing the blood brain barrier. It bonds to nutrients, carrying up to sixty times its molecular weight in nutrition into the cell.
The biochemist in me from my time as a chemistry major, graduate student, and medical student keep asking, how on earth does this work? What does this even mean?
This too:
Free radicals are toxic by-products that cause significant cellular damage. Each cell in your body can be hit by up to 10,000 free radicals per day and they need to be neutralized in order to not ravage living cells and tissue. To be neutralized each free radical needs a donor electron.
One molecule of fulvic acid can donate fourteen tera-trillion electrons. That’s twenty-one zeros! It has the unique ability to react with both negatively and positively charged unpaired electrons, rendering free radicals harmless. It then alters the mineral to new useable compounds or eliminates them as waste.
It is, of course, true that free radicals can do this, but what are free radicals? In brief, a free radical is an atom, molecule, or ion that has at least one unpaired valence electron. In the vast majority of cases of free radicals, these unpaired electrons make the radical highly chemically reactive, which is why they can oxidize surrounding molecules by “grabbing” elections from them. Often those molecules contain oxygen, which is why free radicals can produce something called “reactive oxygen species,” commonly abbreviated ROS. (I realize that’s simple, but hopefully not simplistic.) Here’s a diagram.
Basically, there is a balance between free radicals, which are used by the body in a number of processes, such as the immune system destroying bacteria and pathogens, and antioxidant systems. When that balance is disrupted in favor of oxidants like free radicals, that’s called oxidative stress, and ROS can lead to damage to surrounding proteins, lipids, DNA molecules, etc.
Once again, the biochemist in me wondered a couple of things. First, nobody in science uses a term like “tera-trillion”, which, I assume, came from combining the SI prefix “tera” (1012) with trillion (109) to come up with 1021; so why did BOO use it? The obvious answer, of course, is this: It sounds way more impressive than zetta, which is the correct SI prefix to use to denote 1021. Second, and more importantly, I wondered: How could a single molecule of fulvic acid could donate 14 x 1021 electrons? This was coming across to me as chemical babble, a term I like to use based on a famous term from Star Trek known as “technobabble”, which is a term that what writers and fans use to denote very impressive scientific-sounding verbiage used in the show that actually doesn’t mean anything. After all, a mole of anything is 6.023 X 1023, which means, apparently, that a single molecule of fulvic acid can donate 1/100 of a mole of electrons. Perhaps my chemistry is rusty, but the entire idea seems ludicrous. Even if you assume that a single molecule of fulvic acid could continually donate these electrons over time, then why can’t it do so indefinitely?
Pseudoscience aside, until last Friday, Black Oxygen Organics marketed several products, including BlackOxygen Tabs, claimed to contain 1.80 g of pure BlackOxygen Fulvic, and BlackOxygen Powder, claimed to be “pure fulvic” with a recommended dose of 2.5 g orally, 25 g in a bath, and 2.5 g (with baking soda) for a mask. The company even marketed BlackOxygen Coffee, because there’s nothing I like more than making a “cup of mud” into a literal description of my coffee.
But what about COVID19?
BOO and COVID-19
So we know that fulvic acid has been promoted by alternative medicine practitioners for a long time as the “natural cure” (for almost everything) coming from peat bogs that “they” don’t want you to know about. So how did we get to COVID-19? If there’s one overriding principle of alternative medicine quackery, it’s that remedies that “work” for some things will almost always be trotted out to treat any new disease that comes along, and, boy, did COVID-19 come along in a big way, which brings us back to Zadrozny:
By the end of the summer, online ads for BOO had made their way to millions of people within the internet subcultures that embrace fringe supplements, including the mixed martial arts community, anti-vaccine and Covid-denier groups, and finally more general alternative health and fake cure spaces.
And people seemed to be buying; parts of TikTok and Instagram were flooded with #BOO posts. The businessman behind Black Oxygen Organics has been selling mud in various forms for 25 years now, but BOO sold in amounts that surprised even its own executives, according to videos of company meetings viewed by NBC News.
The stars appeared aligned for it. A pandemic marked by unprecedented and politicized misinformation has spurred a revival in wonder cures. Well-connected Facebook groups of alternative health seekers and vaccine skeptics provided an audience and eager customer base for a new kind of medicine show. And the too-good-to-be-true testimonials posted to social media attracted a wave of direct sellers, many of them women dipping their toes into the often unprofitable world of multilevel marketing for the first time.
But what kind of science was being used to justify this claim? Here’s one example:
The claim is that humic acids, including fulvic acid, are antiviral. It’s based on cherry picked and misinterpreted science, including in vitro studies supposedly showing humic acids to be “be effective in vitro against a wide range of viruses, including influenza, HSV, HIV, and others”. None of the studies cited are more recent than 1992 (one is from the early 1970s), and none are human studies, although there is one study cited that looked at HSV-1 in rabbits in which humic acids were used the conjunctival sac of the eye along with or immediately after the infectious agent. That last one is obviously a highly artificial study, particularly if topical humic acid is used right after a virus is applied. The link cited goes to a “clinical education” website for “nutritional information” aimed at chiropractors, acupuncturists, etc.
Meanwhile, Black Oxygen Organics was posting testimonials of “miracle cures” attributed to its products on its Instagram page, two of which are archived at truthinadvertising.org here and here.
The NBC News report lists other testimonials used to sell the product:
“Who would have thought drinking dirt would make me feel so so good?” one person in a 27,000-member private Facebook group posted, her face nuzzling a jar of black liquid.
Another user posted a photo of a baby sitting in a bathtub of water colored a deep caramel. In the caption, she shared that the baby had contracted hand, foot and mouth disease — a virus that mainly affects children and causes painful sores. “Tiny is enjoying his Boo bath!” she wrote. “We’re happy to say our bottom feels happier and we’re in a better mood!”
Many such posts are dedicated to tactics for getting kids and loved ones to take BOO.
“Boo brownies for the picky family,” one poster offered.
Testimonials like these make up the majority of posts in dozens of Facebook groups, set up and overseen by BOO sellers, with hundreds of thousands of collective members, where BOO is heralded as a miracle drug. Teams of sellers in these private Facebook groups claim that, beyond cosmetic applications, BOO can cure everything from autism to cancer to Alzheimer’s disease. Conveniently in these times, BOO proponents say it also protects against and treats Covid-19, and can be used to “detox” the newly vaccinated, according to posts viewed by NBC News.
Unsurprisingly, BOO turned out to be a huge MLM scam:
More than 99 percent of MLM sellers lose money, according to the Consumer Awareness Institute, an industry watchdog group. But according to social media posts, BOO’s business was booming. In selfies and videos posted to Facebook, Instagram and TikTok, women lather BOO on their faces and soak their feet in sludge-filled pasta pots while, they claim, the money rolls in.
Black Oxygen Organics’ compensation plan, like most MLMs, is convoluted. According to their company handbook, sellers, called “brand partners,” can earn income in two distinct ways: through retail commissions on bags of BOO they sell, and through recruiting other sellers, from which they earn additional commission and bonuses. The more recruits a seller brings in, the more quickly the seller rises in the ranks — there are 10 titles in the company, from brand partner to director to CEO, with compensation packages growing along the way.
Because, first and foremost, it’s also at least always about the grift; so of course there’s an MLM involved! Indeed, the people running Black Oxygen Organics even knew that they had created a monster and that their sellers had gone too far:
In September, Montaruli, BOO’s vice president, led a corporate call to address the Facebook groups and what he called “the compliance situation.”
“Right now, it’s scary,” Montaruli said in a Zoom call posted publicly, referring to the outlandish claims made by some of BOO’s sellers. “In 21 years, I have never seen anything like this. Never.”
“These outrageous claims, and I’m not even sure if outrageous is bad enough, are obviously attracting the haters, giving them more fuel for the fire, and potential government officials.”
Montaruli called for “a reset,” telling BOO sellers to delete the pages and groups and start over again.
One slide suggested alternatives for 14 popular BOO uses, including switching terms like ADHD to “trouble concentrating,” and “prevents heart attack” to “maintain a healthy cardiovascular system.”
And so in September, the Facebook groups evolved — many went private, most changed their names from BOO to “fulvic acid,” and the pinned testimonials from customers claiming miracle cures were wiped clean, tweaked or edited to add a disclaimer absolving the company from any liability.
Because grifters gonna grift. Always. Also note the way BOO hawkers (like most supplement hawkers) were urged to use the FDA’s limitations under the DSHEA of 1994 to hide behind so-called “structure-function” claims (e.g., “boosts the immune system” or “supports heart health”) to avoid the FDA coming after them for making specific disease claims.
When there is no science, all quackery is possible, including for COVID-19
BOO and fulvic acid quackery for COVID-19 and, before that, pretty much every disease and condition, is yet another reminder that belief often fuses with grift when it comes to medicine that is unscientific, pseudoscientific, or rooted in superstition and prescientific beliefs in medicine tarted up with woo babble (another nod to Star Trek technobabble) to sound scientific. As I say time and time again, there might well be belief that a product does all these miraculous things, but there’s very frequently grift involved as well. Looking again at the example of MMS, which has been touted for cancer, autism, and all manner of diseases and conditions, I can’t help but note that it only took quacks a few weeks after the pandemic hit (if that) to start touting this form of bleach as a treatment for COVID-19. Indeed, Kerri Rivera, who had made such a splash in “autism biomed” circles by advocating giving bleach orally and by enema to autistic children to treat their “vaccine injury,” jumped on the COVID-19 quackery bandwagon. As I myself noted as early as March 2020, COVID-19 has been a golden opportunity for quacks, with Scott Gavura producing an incomplete list as early as May 2020 that included MMS, colloidal silver, traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, chiropractic, juicing, and several others.
        ◦ We can now add magic dirt in the form of mud taken from a peat bog next to a landfill to that list. That it’s peat from a bog that distillers of single malt scotch whiskey would reject as not being good enough for their products makes no difference. It’s “natural”, and the pandemic affords all manner of grifting opportunities. That is enough.

Bovine Pancreatic Insufficiency
Repurposed drugs that have multiple mechanisms of action in treating infections usually end up doing nothing. For example, fluvoxamine and COVID 45.
Mark Crislip on February 23, 2023
Link

My editor over at Medscape said I tended to have obscure titles for my blog entries. I will not argue, since I sometimes I wonder what the hell I was getting at when I reread the entries for my Gobbet o Pus. The meaning of the title will come clear later in the blog when I beat a metaphor to death. I sometimes wonder if my propensity for obscure word play is due to some residual DNA from my grandmother. She was a high-functioning undifferentiated schizophrenic who had a variety of odd quirks about specific word usages, such as the word ‘job’ leading to her recurring correction in her thick Boston accent: a job is what a dog does on the carpet. Wisdom from the depths of insanity.
There are four approaches to the treatment of infectious diseases. The first is antimicrobials, which almost always targets a specific enzyme in a critical biochemical pathway of the pathogen. There can be other mechanisms of action but the antimicrobial target is usually very specific. When you have to resort to treating an infection with a detergent, you are really hurting for an intervention.
The sooner you give antimicrobials, the better the response. For viri, it is best if the treatment is given less than 72 hours after the onset of symptoms. This is part of why the response of COVID to remdesivir appears so anemic: most of my patients did not get to the ER until day 8 or so of illness.
Another form of treatment is supplementing the immune system, most often in the form of antibodies. That is expensive and inconvenient, but, depending on the infection, can be quite effective. Probably a better therapeutic option for toxic shock syndrome and tetanus than COVID.
Then there is interfering with the host’s response to the infection. Much of the damage from infections can be due to a vigorous response of the immune system to the infection and the collateral damage to the host cells as the immune system attacks the pathogen, a very much ‘It became necessary to destroy the town to save it‘ situation. So the thought is if you can blunt the immune system, you can decrease the damage from infection.
Steroids have been the most popular approach, and the efficacy has been variable. Patients often get better faster from a variety of infections with the addition of steroids, but at the cost of adverse drug reactions: increase in blood sugars, infection and delirium. For many, but not all, infections, the risk-benefit is a wash.
Then there are those drugs that move in mysterious ways. Drugs that mechanistically do not appear to directly, specifically, or predominantly target either pathogens or the immune system.
A semi-classic example is statins. There were many hints that statins decreased mortality in sepsis. By what mechanism? Many alleged, likely what I call the cold fusion effect. The effect isn’t really there, but clever people who talk loudly in restaurants somehow find mechanisms of action:
HMG CoA inhibitors (statins) decrease the production of isoprenoid lipid and inhibit the activation of GTPase protein via their effects on prenylation. Statins have been shown to act on several crucial steps in sepsis: the generation of proinflammatory cytokines (IL-6, IL-8, and TNFα), modulation of leukocyte and monocyte functions, and reduction of oxidative stress as well as improvement in endothelial function and platelet activity. In one trial, simvastatin reduced the systemic response to endotoxin administration and decreased expression of Toll-like receptors that hold a key early role in sepsis. In addition, an antimicrobial effect of statins on methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus and methicillin-resistant S. aureus has been reported.
The clinical result: Who knows? As one typical meta-analysis concluded
Fifteen studies had mortality data of which 10 showed lower mortality among statin users, 4 showed no difference in mortality, and 1 showed increased mortality among statin users. Nine studies examined the risk of developing sepsis and/or infection of which 5 studies showed decreased risk among statin users, whereas 4 studies showed no difference. The overall conclusion of these reviews was that statins may have a beneficial effect in the treatment and prevention of various infections, but due to heterogeneity and observational design of the included studies, further randomized studies are needed to address this effect.
My take on the entirely of the literature? Much ado about nothing. So often the benefit is found in subgroup analysis, not primary end points. So likely garbage.
This brings us to fluvoxamine and the treatment of COVID-45. I first learned about the topic over at HIV and ID Observations, a great infectious disease blog. I always refer colleagues to his classic “How to Figure Out the Length of Antibiotic Therapy“. It had an entry titled Could This Be Our First Effective, Inexpensive, Widely Available Outpatient Treatment for COVID-19? Fluvoxamine is an old antidepressant. Why would it work for COVID-45?
… it has a legitimate mechanism of action — actually, multiple mechanisms, as it has anti-inflammatory, anti-platelet, and potentially antiviral activity independent of its psychoactive properties. If you want to get into the weeds, read this nice summary. But of course many drugs have in vitro mechanisms of action that don’t pan out.
No. That’s the cold fusion explanation. Coming up for a reason a medication (or cold fusion) could work when, in fact, it doesn’t. Sort of a real medicines corollary to Harriet’s Tooth Fairy Science. When a drug has multiple mechanisms for treating infections that are independent of going after the pathogen, it likely has no mechanism of action.
As Dr. Sax noted:
Most of the secondary endpoints also favored fluvoxamine, though the differences were not always statistically significant
Which to my mind is always suggests the findings are nothing.
Dr. Sax is always skeptical, which is why his blog has been a delight to read.
Look, we’ve all been burned by promising studies of these repurposed drugs, and it’s quite reasonable to reserve final judgment until we see the complete data, and even other studies.
And such a study is now out: “Effect of Fluvoxamine vs. Placebo on Time to Sustained Recovery in Outpatients With Mild to Moderate COVID-19“.
Fluvoxamine didn’t do squat. Or in a more professional assessment:
The median time to recovery was 12 days in the fluvoxamine group compared with 13 days in the placebo group, and there was no significant benefit for the primary outcome of time to sustained recovery. For the secondary composite outcome of hospitalization, urgent care visit, emergency department visit, or death through day 28, the fluvoxamine group had an event rate of 3.9% compared with the event rate of 3.8% in the placebo group.
When the use of fluvoxamine came up in our group meeting a while back, I suggested it was the usual BS we have seen time and again. No real, single, mechanism of action. No specific antimicrobial effects. Small flawed studies. It was ivermectin, hydroxychloroquine, statins, etc., yet again.
And now the metaphor you have all been waiting for.
So you may not be aware that male cows have pancreatic insufficiency. One of the effects of pancreatic insufficiency is fat malabsorption. Fat floats to the top in water. Like cream, only less appealing. So the stool of steers with pancreatic insufficiency floats in water, in addition to being particularly foul smelling. In clinical research, small, retrospective uncontrolled studies of medications with no good mechanism of action yield findings that are the result of bovine pancreatic insufficiency. Then researchers with anosmia examine the buoyant result and think they found something.
Nope.
And you may find yourself looking at retrospective studiesAnd you may find yourself with no placebo controlAnd you may find yourself with a large number of mechanisms of actionAnd you may find yourself in a beautiful hospital, with a beautiful studyAnd you may ask yourselfWell…How did I get here?
Letting the days go byLet the studies hold me downLetting the days go byStudies flowing undergroundInto the blue againAfter the money’s goneOnce in a lifetimeWater flowing underground
And you may ask yourselfHow do I work this?And you may ask yourselfWhere is that large placebo controlled trial?And you may tell yourselfThis is not my beautiful clinical trialAnd you may tell yourselfThis is not my beautiful clinical result
Letting the days go byLet the water hold me downLetting the days go byWater flowing undergroundInto the blue againAfter the money’s goneOnce in a lifetimeWater flowing underground
You may ask yourself, “What is that beautiful study?”You may ask yourself, “Where does that treatment go to?”And you may ask yourself, “Am I right, am I wrong?”And you may say to yourself, “My God, what have I done?”
Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…Same as it ever was…


Doctors Who Performatively Fetishized RCTs Aren’t Out to Advance Medical Research, But Rather to Sow Doubt & Mistrust
Actually running an RCT is a lot harder than merely calling for one. Those who recognized this obvious fact are not against RCTs.
Jonathan HowardonMarch 3, 2024
Link

“The study, conducted at ACTG sites across the United States, planned to rapidly enroll approximately 2,000 adults who had laboratory-confirmed infection with SARS-CoV-2…Since its launch in May, however, the study had enrolled only 20 participants, despite efforts by the study sites to enhance recruitment.”
It’s worth listening to people who actually worked on randomized-controlled trials (RCTs) during the pandemic. One researcher said:
I think of what my clinical research team went through to enroll people in that trial, and I thought my nurses were going to die. One of them got covid and got sick. Imagine trying to do that on a daily basis, multiple patients, some of them facing intubation, none of them have their families.
Another said:
There was one day our system had 84 deaths. And then you’re going to ask me to potentially put them on a placebo? It’s just really heart wrenching, talking with families, if your patients are able to communicate — and you’re dealing with all these deaths.
Not surprisingly, graveyards are full of dead RCTs. At the start of the pandemic, a proposed RCT run by the National Institutes of Health of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin – the most basic RCT imaginable, run by the vaunted NIH- closed in a month after enrolling just 20 patients, or just 1% of their goal. No doubt that study looked great on paper.
To make matters worse, even successful RCTs had a very short shelf-life. Both the virus and the population changed dramatically and constantly. As such, the original vaccine RCTs became historical relics in less than a year.
“In Defense of the Randomized Trial”
It turns out that actually running an RCT, especially one that has lasting value, is a lot harder than merely calling for an RCT, especially during a pandemic.
Not everyone felt this way. In podcasts, Tweets, and editorials, some doctors made RCTs sound pretty easy- “You could have run many cluster RCTs of different masking strategies“. These doctors lamented that other doctors did not do more RCTs and argued that knowledge obtained outside of RCTs was invalid, at least for the benefits, though not the purported harms, of any measure to limit COVID, including vaccines.
Despite their professed love for RCTs, these doctors did nothing to advance actual RCTs. They never worked on an RCT themselves, and although RCTs require a large number of motivated, trusting volunteers, like me, they never even encouraged their audience to enroll in one. Instead of promoting RCTs and trying to instill confidence in researchers who actually recruit people into them, methodolatrists undermined them by spreading fear, uncertainly, and doubt.
Stealing from a pre-pandemic anti-vaccine technique where vaccines were said to be unsafe because the entire vaccine schedule had not been studied via an RCT, pandemic methodolatrists similarly claimed that mitigation measures that had not justified themselves via an RCT were worthless by default. The formula was mind-numbingly simple:
    • I don’t like mitigation measure X.
    • Mitigation measure X was not studied via an RCT, though if it was studied via an RCT (e.g. pediatric vaccines), that RCT was too small or is now out of date.
    • Therefore we should not do mitigation measure X.
This again reveals how the virus was treated fundamentally different from measures to control it. I’ve discussed many times how the risks of each were held to absurdly different standards. Doctors treated rare, usually mild vaccine side-effects, even abnormal lab values after vaccination, as a fate worse than death from COVID, for example, and as morgues overflowed with COVID victims, claimed that measures to contain the virus “can be far worse than anything coronavirus can do.”
At a more fundamental level, doctors had different standards for how knowledge could be obtained in the first place and even what constitutes an action. Any proposed measure to limit COVID was deemed an action whose benefit needed to be proven via an RCT. “It is scientifically and morally wrong to push policies year after year with no credible data they help,” wrote one doctor in an essay titled In Defense of the Randomized Trial that berated other doctors for not doing more RCTs. This doctor boasted that he was “one of the few who called for RCTs“, as if merely calling for RCTs was a genuine achievement.
However, these doctors’ demands for RCTs were applied very selectively, only to the benefits of mitigation measures they opposed. They did not need RCTs to make bold, confident claims that mitigation measures caused harm. While literally all observational studies that supported vaccines and mitigation measures were summarily discarded- “observational data has been used to support vaccines, but is plagued by confounding”- any small observational study that showed a whiff of harm was treated with the utmost gravity. With these studies, even a VAERS dumpster dive was lauded as a “bombshell“.
Similarly, removing mitigation measures wasn’t viewed as taking an action, and so these doctors didn’t demand RCTs to prove it was safe to take them away. They didn’t need RCTs to push policies that spread the virus. Pro-infection doctors didn’t demand RCTs before advocating for unvaccinated children and young adults to contract COVID.
Indeed methodolatrists never demanded RCTs to support their favored pandemic policies. The baseline was conveniently set so they were always right by default, and never had to prove anything. The burden of proof always lay with those who wished to limit the spread of the virus, never with those who wanted to infect young people with it.
Thus it becomes clear, methodolatrists performatively fetishized RCTs not to advance medical research, but rather to sow anger and mistrust about unwanted mitigation measures and the entire concept of public health. Methodolatry converts a study design into an epistemological weapon, as Dr. David Gorski recently explained.
“When you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you’re prolonging the problem because you’re preventing population immunity.”
Of course, it wasn’t a secret that some doctors had a vested interest in attacking mitigation measures. They said it was “fantastic news that we have a lot of cases” and that it was “reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger.” Pro-infection doctors didn’t honestly question whether mitigation measures slowed the spread of the virus, they sought to undermine them precisely because they slowed the spread of the virus. As one doctor lamented early in the pandemic:
When you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you’re prolonging the problem because you’re preventing population immunity.
Pro-infection doctors knew mitigation measures interfered with their plan to achieve herd immunity in 3-6 months through the mass infection of unvaccinated youth. Not all doctors who “called for” RCTs were pure-of-heart, neutral observers simply pleading for better science and data. Many had an agenda. They wanted them infected.
“I think of what my clinical research team went through to enroll people in that trial, and I thought my nurses were going to die.”
We can all agree RCTs are the gold-standard and more should have been done during the pandemic. However, please reread the quotes from actual researchers that opened this essay. It was not possible to have conducted an RCT for every mitigation measure for every variant and every demographic subgroup. Decisions have to be made in real-time with incomplete evidence, and encouraging people to repeatedly contract a new, mutating virus absolutely is a decision.
Those who recognized these obvious facts are not against RCTs as has been claimed, and doctors who sat on the sidelines doing nothing but saying “RCTs for thee, but not for me“, aren’t really for RCTs, are they?

Do You Have Coronaphobiaphobia? Ask Your Doctor if Notmybizumab is Right for You.
Jonathan Howard on February 24, 2023
Link

Are you a doctor who has written multiple articles saying “now is the time to stop living in fear?” Did you say cautious people were not “truly not actually living right now“, months before anyone had been vaccinated? Are you engulfed with white hot rage by the handful of people who still wear masks in crowds? Have you relentlessly mocked them on your podcasts and Twitter feed? Have you called them “idiots“, “STUPID“, a “bunch of fools” “total morons“ “delusional” and “off their rocker”? Did you mercilessly shame anyone who wanted a booster just weeks before the Omicron variant ripped through the population? Do you actively encourage strangers, whose lives you know nothing about, to repeatedly expose themselves to a new, mutating virus with unknown long-term consequences? Do people who are still trying to avoid SARS-CoV-2 remind you the pandemic didn’t end in 2021 as you said it would? Have you coined new terms to stigmatize anyone who doesn’t want to repeatedly get sick with COVID for the rest of their lives?
If so, you may have coronaphobiaphobia, an inexplicable fear of and inappropriate obsession with total strangers who want to avoid COVID. Signs of coronaphobiaphobia include:
    • The number of YouTube videos you’ve made greatly exceeds the number of COVID patients you’ve treated
    • You’ve claimed that young people felled by COVID don’t matter, since more die of other causes and grandma has more risk
    • You’ve treated a rare, vaccine side-effect with “excellent short-term outcomes” as a fate worse than death
    • You’ve repeatedly spread bogus statistics minimizing COVID’s harms
    • You’ve said Long COVID is “massively exaggerated“
    • You’ve declared the pandemic over multiple times in the past two years
Coronaphobiaphobia affects 56% of podcasting doctors
Fortunately, there is hope. Notmybizumab™ has been clinically proven to help sheltered doctors develop basic empathy for people who’ve been affected by COVID and those who wish to avoid it. Unlike you, many people have seen firsthand what the virus can do. Such people may wish to avoid constant infections themselves. They may not feel comfortable eating in crowded restaurants. They may still wear a mask on a train. Others may not fear COVID themselves, but instead wish to avoid spreading it to a vulnerable family member, co-worker, or even an elderly stranger on the bus.
It may not seem that way now, but cautious people don’t hurt you at all.
Notmybizumab™ can help you adjust to a painful, challenging world where people you’ll never meet don’t want to get COVID over and over again. Doctors who take notmybizumab™ are 75% less likely to meltdown after seeing a stranger with a mask, and they are 87% less likely to berate them on social media. Even though society has adopted 100% of your preferred COVID policies, hearing about someone who is still trying to avoid the virus may make you feel as if all your podcasts and YouTube videos were for naught. Notmybizumab™ will allow you to finally relax! You’re free to get COVID as many times as you want, and unvaccinated children are still getting really sick with COVID exactly as you intended.
If you are suffering from coronaphobiaphobia, ask your doctor if notmybizumab™ is right for you.
Warning: Notmybizumab™ may cause substantial loss of Substack/YouTube revenue. Doctors on notmybizumab™ report a loss of funding from shadowy right-wing think tanks. Tell your doctor about all of your income streams before starting notmybizumab™.

Treating the Unvaccinated
Should vaccination status be used to triage care for critically ill patients during a crisis?
Steven Novella on December 8, 2021
Link

There is a debate going on regarding how to allocate limited resources during a pandemic surge. During the COVID pandemic hospitals have been overwhelmed in terms of their availability of ventilators and intensive care unit (ICU) beds. When this happened early on in the pandemic there was no ethical dilemma – resources were allocated based on need. Now, however, the situation is different. In the US every adult who wants to be vaccinated can be vaccinated (unless they have a medial reason they cannot). We therefore have a population of citizens who are voluntarily unvaccinated, and in recent surges they make up the vast majority of those requiring hospitalization and ICU care. How should this affect decisions regarding triaging of care?
This is not a new issue for the medical profession. Organ transplants, for example, are a limited resource. People will die on the waiting list for an available organ, and so how do we decide who to prioritize? The core ethical principles involved are utility, justice, and respect for persons as individuals.
Utility is the easiest to understand – who is most likely to benefit medically from the limited resource, and who is most likely to suffer from the absence of that resource? For example, with organ transplantation, the person most close to death whose life is most likely to be saved by a transplant gets the highest priority. A less obvious factor is location. Being located closer to the donor organ and the hospital system able to do the transplant gives a higher probability of success.
The principle of justice means that the overall system operates fairly, so that there is no systematic bias in allocation that would put some individual at an unfair disadvantage in receiving care. This principle may at times conflict with the principle of utility, so basically they have to be balanced. At present the recommendation is to give each principle equal weight in making decisions about priority.
Respect for persons as individuals means that the life and welfare of each person is an end unto itself, not just a means to an end. Further, this requires respect for individual autonomy, including transparency, informed consent, and the right to refuse care.
Under the umbrella of justice, however, there are two other ethical principles that may come into play when triaging patients based upon their vaccination status – reciprocity and proportionality. In a recent editorial, William Parker, MD focuses on these principles, arguing that there should be a very limited role for considering vaccination status in treatment decisions. The principle of reciprocity as a general ethical rule simply means that in any social contract we get back what we give. We all play by the same rules, giving each other what we expect to receive from others.
Applied in a medical context, this could mean that medical care itself is part of a social contract, with society providing resources and privileges to the medical profession in exchange for their services, professionalism, and ethical behavior. What does or should reciprocity mean at the individual healthcare level, however? That depends on context.
In the normal healthcare context, everyone is treated as equally deserving, without any consideration for any personal details. We do not withhold care because someone is a prisoner or because they are responsible for their own medical problems. If you get into an accident because you were speeding while drunk, you still get full health care to treat your injuries. There is no judgement, no politics, and no blame. That is part of the professionalism of medicine; we do not judge our patients, we treat them.
But as I said, this is in the context of normal medical care. There is also the context of crisis medical care, in which resources are limited. Now the decision is not whether to treat patient A, but rather whether to treat patient A or B if you can only treat one. This is a very real dilemma during this pandemic, and during local surges hospital systems are being overwhelmed. This means, for example deferring elective surgeries in favor of life-saving care for acutely ill COVID patients. By “elective surgeries” I am not just referring to cosmetic surgery or quality of life surgery. Patients needing mastectomy for breast cancer, or bypass surgery for coronary artery disease are also considered elective in that they can be temporarily delayed while a patient with COVID pneumonia may die without immediate life-saving care.
If we apply only the principle of utility, then it is clear that the people requiring immediate lifesaving care should have priority. The risk of death from cancer or heart attack will increase for those who delay surgery, but by a much smaller degree than the risk of death if those with severe COVID are not treated. If mastectomy is delayed by 4 weeks, for example, the relative increase in mortality is 8% (or an absolute increase of about one in 100 patients). That is real and significant, but still much lower than if we do not treat the acutely ill.
This triage can happen subtly, by large hospital centers turning away transfers of COVID patients because they do not have any available beds, but some of those beds are occupied by patients who have had surgery that could have been deferred.
Since most of those COVID patients now are the voluntarily unvaccinated, the question is – does the principle of reciprocity mean we can prioritize vaccinated patients with breast cancer over unvaccinated patients with COVID, essentially using reciprocity to trump utility? Some experts are flirting with this question. Dr. Parker answers this question by referring to the principle of proportionality – allowing someone to die because they chose not to be vaccinated is out of proportion (the punishment does not fit the crime). There are several reasons for this.
First, from a utility point of view, if you look at the numbers the decision to not get vaccinated likely does not place a burden on the overall society and healthcare system worth one full life. Parker estimates it is worth 0.001 of a life. He writes:
Proportional reciprocity (“payback”) for vaccination would be about 0.001 lives worth of medical care, orders of magnitude lower than what would be required to justify denying life-saving treatment to the unvaccinated so the vaccinated can get elective procedures.
Second, the decision whether or not to get vaccinated is not the sum total of a person’s worth nor their contract with society. An otherwise-upstanding citizen might have decided for various reasons to not get vaccinated, while a career criminal, spouse abuser, and drug user did get vaccinated. Should that latter really be the sole determinant of triaging care?
Further, the decision not to get vaccinated may be complicated. A member of a racial minority may not trust the vaccine because of historical medical injustice. Would we not be compounding that injustice to deny care based on their reaction to prior injustice? People may also have been influenced by their religious group, their family, or their social circle.
At SBM we are careful to distinguish the pseudoscience from the person. We are highly critical of false medical claims, poor regulations, and willing con-artists. But ordinary people who believe, use, and even spread false medical beliefs are victims. They do not deserve our condemnation, but our sympathy. I believe most people who decide to not get vaccinated are victims of misinformation, a society that does not sufficiently prioritize scientific literacy and critical thinking skills, and dysfunctional media and political systems. As frustrating as their choice to refuse a safe and effective vaccine at the expense of their own health and the health of others is, we still need to remember that this does not make them bad people. It makes them victims of pseudoscience (even if it results in them propagating that victimhood to others).
        ◦ It’s also important for the medical profession to stay above the political fray. It’s easy to get sucked into blaming the unvaccinated for the pandemic’s continuing harm. The solution, however, is not to use triage of medical care as a solution or a punishment. That is not the role of the medical profession, which is primarily to care for all patients without judgement. Rather, the pandemic is all the more reason that we need to find other solutions to the problem of vaccine hesitancy. Education is the preferred method, but if that is not enough then applying a variety of carrots and sticks may be justified. But we can’t withhold medical care.

More drug shortages due to COVID-19
COVID-19 is worsening a long-standing problem: Drug shortages
Scott Gavura on April 16, 2020
Link

As the blog’s resident pharmacist I’ve taken on the topic of drug shortages a few times over the past several years, an issue that may sometimes be invisible to patients but something that most pharmacists grapple with every day of their working lives. Prescription drugs routinely go into shortage situations, and all evidence suggests that the problem has been worsening, not improving, over the past several years. Even before the COVID-19 pandemic emerged, the FDA listed hundreds of drugs currently in shortage, a situation also observed in countries like Canada and also the United Kingdom. Many countries maintain standing lists of drugs that are in short supply. In general, most of these shortages have traditionally been generic drugs, not brand-name products. All health systems rely heavily on lower-priced generics to help offset the cost of new, patented, high-cost drugs. There are substantial barriers for manufacturers to enter the generic drug manufacturing market, and there is significant competition that drives prices down low. The result has been the gradual outsourcing and consolidation of manufacturing, with supply chains that may stretch across continents. There are far fewer shortages of brand name drugs but they can occur when manufacturers experience problems with manufacturing or changes in demand.
I first blogged about drug shortages back in 2011 and the post could have been written yesterday, with perhaps even more urgency, as the problems seems to be getting worse, not better, despite efforts to reduce them. In 2018, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb established the Agency Drug Shortages Task Force to determine the root causes of drug shortages, and propose recommendations to address them. And that was pre-COVID. While access to personal protective equipment, intensive care units and ventilators have grabbed headlines, there is increasing concern about access to prescription drugs – not just to treat COVID patients, but longer-term effects on access to many prescription drugs.
Initial worries
The first concerns about COVID-related drug shortages emerged shortly after Wuhan, China was locked down in early January. As China is a major supplier of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) to the rest of the world, there were concerns that the lockdown would threaten shipments of APIs out of Wuhan to the rest of the world, disrupting the manufacture of drugs worldwide. The table below (from the FDA’s Task Force on shortages) shows the distribution of manufacturing of APIs and finished products (e.g., tablets/capsules/vials) in 2019: largely done outside North America. Just 12% of APIs used in American drugs were manufactured in the USA, and only 37% of finished products were actually manufactured domestically:As you can see, 14% of APIs come to the US from China and, the first COVID-related drug shortage was reported by the FDA on February 27. The drug and manufacturer were not named. At that time, the FDA noted:
Also, as part of our efforts, the FDA has identified about 20 other drugs, which solely source their active pharmaceutical ingredients or finished drug products from China. We have been in contact with those firms to assess whether they face any drug shortage risks due to the outbreak. None of these firms have reported any shortage to date. Also, these drugs are considered non-critical drugs.
The second wave of shortages
This attention to APIs coming out of China was the focus of regulators and the broader health care market for several weeks. In mid-February, the scrutiny remained on China. Even as late as mid-March, European regulators seemingly were focusing on supply chains and travel restrictions. It was only after the COVID started to spread outside China, and case numbers exploded in Europe did broader recognition start of what I’ll call the second wave of drug shortages – the treatments essential to keep patients intubated, ventilated, and alive in intensive care units. By late March and early April, it was apparent that existing supplies of these medications were insufficient to treat the thousands of new patients that required hospitalization. On April 6, the European Union noted:
Some EU Member States have indicated that they are starting to see shortages of certain medicines used for patients with COVID-19 or are expecting such shortages to occur very soon. These include medicines used in intensive care units such as certain anaesthetics, antibiotics and muscle relaxants as well as medicines used off-label for COVID-19. EU authorities are therefore putting in place additional measures to mitigate the impact of the pandemic on the supply chain of medicines in a coordinated manner.
It’s worth reiterating that drug “shortage” is just an imbalance between supply and demand. These can be local, regional, national, and international. While primary concerns were about supplies of drugs, from China, treating COVID patients was causing shortages through surges of demand. And as the pandemic has taken hold in United States, the same surges in demand occurred. By late March, demand was surging and outstripping supply:
Demand for drugs given to patients on ventilators is outstripping supply, according to Vizient Inc., a pharmaceutical-purchasing group that works with more than half of U.S. hospitals and health systems. Hospital orders for sedatives, analgesics and neuromuscular blockers increased 58% overall in March compared with January, Vizient said. Those medicines are used to prevent movement, manage pain and soothe patients who can’t breathe without the assistance of a machine.
On April 2, The New York Times reported:
Across the country, as hospitals confront a harrowing surge in coronavirus cases, they are also beginning to report shortages of critical medications — especially those desperately needed to ease the disease’s assault on patients’ respiratory systems.The most commonly reported shortages include drugs that are used to keep patients’ airways open, antibiotics, antivirals and sedatives. They are all part of a standard cocktail of medications that help patients on mechanical ventilators, control secondary lung infections, reduce fevers, manage pain and resuscitate those who go into cardiac arrest.Demand for these drugs significantly increased in March as the pandemic took hold in the United States. Orders for antibiotics like azithromycin and antiviral medicines like ribavirin nearly tripled. Medicines used for sedation and pain management, including fentanyl, midazolam and propofol, increased by 100 percent, 70 percent and 60 percent respectively.Demand for albuterol, a common asthma inhaler medication, has also risen significantly, given its importance in easing the breathing of patients with severe infection.
While not all of these drugs are currently in a shortage situation, their rising use are raising concerns that shortages are far more likely. This is being observed across North America. From a Canadian hospital:
Even though ICUs have yet to be overrun with a feared surge of coronavirus cases, the drugs are being administered at a far higher rate than usual, say doctors and pharmacists. “Some hospitals have reported they’re essentially using a 30-day supply of certain medications in just one day,” said Dr. Michael Warner, ICU head at Toronto’s Michael Garron Hospital. “Overall, our consumption of these drugs could increase by an order of magnitude.”
Importantly, none of these drugs can be easily manufactured. Most of them are sterile injectable drugs, which are more difficult and complex to manufacture, compared to oral products like liquids, tablets, and capsules. In the case of brand-name drugs, there may be only a small number of manufacturing sites worldwide. It’s not known if supplies and reserves exist for these drugs, or how quickly manufacturers can ramp up manufacturing to cope with worldwide surges in demand. Wholesalers in the U.S. reported difficulties meeting orders, particularly in New York, at the end of March:
Using its comprehensive data on purchasing patterns and current fill rates, Premier found that these products experienced the greatest spikes in demand during the month of March but were also unable to be supplied in the requested quantities – two early warning signals for shortages. Drugs include antimalarials and antivirals that may be an effective COVID-19 treatment, as well as antibiotics used to cure infections. Other products at risk of shortages include bronchodilators for keeping airways open, as well as sedatives and neuromuscular blockers used to intubate patients. Demand for these products was even higher in COVID-19 hotspots like New York, suggesting that products could move from regional shortages into national shortages as the disease spreads to additional communities.
Drugs have now moved into true shortage situations.
In the past few days (April 13), the FDA has continued to report new shortages of drugs for patients that require ventilation and intensive care:
Increasing demand for sedatives used to help put COVID-19 patients onto ventilators means the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) added two more – this time the injectables propofol and dexmedetomidine – to its list of drug shortages.
The propofol shortage was also previously listed by the American Society for Health-System Pharmacists (ASHP) earlier this month, with manufacturers noting increased demand. Michael Ganio, senior director of pharmacy practice and quality at ASHP, previously told Focus via email: “We have multiple reports of increases in purchases and utilization of sedatives like midazolam, fentanyl, and propofol to treat COVID-19 patients who require mechanical ventilation.”
And:
A Pfizer spokesperson told Focus via email: “As of today, Pfizer’s manufacturing and distribution network continues to operate at high performance with no operational disruptions due to COVID-19. Historically, Pfizer has had a market share of approximately 15% for Propofol. We recently have observed an unprecedented surge in demand for Propofol beyond Pfizer’s historical demand which is limiting our ability to fully satisfy customer orders in the short-term. We are making every effort to advance the ordering of additional materials, increase our production, reduce lead times and expedite orders to customers, especially those in high-impact areas.”
As we see the pandemic spread across countries and around the world, time will tell if we have “flattened the curve” enough for manufacturing and supplies to match the needs of hospitalized patients who needs these drugs to stay alive.
Treating COVID: The third wave of shortages
I don’t want to spend time in this post talking about possible COVID treatments, as the data are evolving quickly. Earlier this week David Gorski discussed the weak evidence to support the use of hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin to treat COVID-19. While current treatment guidelines (as of April 14) do not recommend the use of either product outside of a clinical trial, the hype around these products has caused surges in demand that have led to concerns of shortages for non-COVID patients that rely on these medications to treat their illness. From April 10, in The Journal of the American Medical Association:
Hydroxychloroquine is recommended for all patients with lupus, especially those with no contraindication such as pregnancy. It relieves constitutional, musculoskeletal, and mucocutaneous manifestations and decreases thrombotic events, organ damage, and mortality. Hydroxychloroquine helps maintain disease remission and prevent flares. Among patients with lupus that is not organ threatening, 80% achieve remission with hydroxychloroquine and may sustain it with this therapy for long periods.2Although there is no rigorous scientific evidence supporting the use of hydroxychloroquine in COVID-19 as of early April 2020, consumers are stockpiling the drug not only for treatment but also prophylaxis prompted by media reports of possible efficacy. A rationale for hydroxychloroquine use in COVID-19 is based on in vitro studies showing that chloroquine inhibits virus replication.3 Because hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine may have in vivo antiviral and anti-inflammatory effects, they offer a potential means to mitigate COVID-19.A recent small (n = 36), open-label nonrandomized trial in France suggested that therapy with hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin decreased viral load and replication,4 garnering significant media attention. However, randomized clinical trials are required to assess the efficacy and safety of hydroxychloroquine as prophylaxis or treatment for COVID-19. The FDA has authorized its use for treatment of patients hospitalized with COVID-19 but not for prophylaxis. President Trump has touted hydroxychloroquine therapy, despite very limited evidence of efficacy.5,6Since being prominently featured in the press and on social media as a potential COVID-19 therapy, demand for hydroxychloroquine has exploded and a shortage has ensued. Some physicians are prescribing it for prophylaxis as well as outpatient treatment of COVID-19, often along with azithromycin. Some health care workers are taking it as prophylaxis without any evidence to support this use.
Azithromycin is a common treatment used for adult and pediatric infections, including pneumonia. A shortage of azithromycin may mean selecting inferior products or challenges in treating these infections. Given these are both oral drugs, it’s hoped that shortages will be short-lived without causing harm to patients that need them.
Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin are the most well-known products that are being used to treat COVID-19. There are a number of products being utilized and/or investigated in clinical trials, with new drugs likely to be added over the coming weeks and months. From the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control is a list of “unproven” products as of April 12:
    • lopinavir/ritonavir (Kaletra®)
    • remdesivir
    • oseltamivir
    • ribavirin and interferon
    • colchicine
    • tocilizumab/sarilumab
    • corticosteroids
    • antibiotics
As “old” drugs are repurposed and investigated, it is possible that we will see unpredictable surges in demand for products, raising the risk of additional shortages, with effects beyond COVID. Like patients with lupus are already experiencing, a drug can move from stable into shortage in a matter of a few weeks, and manufacturing supply chains may struggle to adapt. What we have now in the USA and other countries is a growing list of drug shortages – the number of drugs that are short in the USA due to COVID now numbers 23 at my last count.
A fourth wave of shortages?
I’ve described these shortages as waves and I’m not sure if that’s the right analogy, as the different drivers of shortages are going to have overlapping effects for some time. The fourth category or wave of shortage that I want to discuss is the manifestation and exacerbation of what we have been experiencing for years, in a new world where supply chains may be more tentative. As I have noted in past posts, problems in manufacturing and distribution of prescription drugs can emerge throughout the supply chain. In some cases, it is regulatory agencies like the FDA that identify quality or safety issues, interrupting production. In other cases it may be difficult to obtain or process raw materials that meet FDA quality standards. When these problems emerge, manufacturers may decide that supporting production for low-profit or low-volume products doesn’t make economic sense, leading to discontinuation, and yes, more shortages. While this is outside my area of expertise, I am skeptical that shifting manufacturing of APIs from China or India is something that can occur quickly, or can be done without additional supply chain interruptions. My sense is that manufacturing hundreds of different drug products to high standards may be more difficult that manufacturing PPE. It is unlikely that manufacturers who may derive little profit from these products will be willing (or able) to do this. Consequently, massive changes cannot (or will not) occur without significant intervention and direction from governments and regulators. Price hikes for low cost generics may be inevitable, as more countries insist on domestic manufacturing. Whether or not this shift in manufacturing can (or should) occur is something that we will observe over the coming months and years as we find out what the new normal looks like.
The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated and made apparent the long-standing challenges with pharmaceutical drug manufacturing and supply. It’s possible this could lead to the changes that are essential to address long-standing problems that have become worse over the past decade. The supply chain has been brittle and vastly too opaque for years. Some countries, like New Zealand, mandate a level of manufacturing transparency that is unavailable in other countries. Group purchasing organizations, wholesalers, manufacturers, regulators, health systems, and insurers need to find new ways to collaborate and share information in order to fix these fragile supply chains and to reduce the impact of shortages on patients. More transparency will help. Leadership is essential. I’ve noted before that no single organization “owns” drug shortages. Health systems need to act now, decisively, to fix these problems.

POLITICS, LAW, AND REGULATIONS

Dr. Joseph Ladapo’s assault on public health in Florida: Will it be coming to the federal government next year?
The Florida Department of Health, run by Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo, just released guidance on COVID-19 vaccines based on antivax tropes. Is the federal government next?
David Gorski on September 16, 2024
Link
The number of developments worrisome for the future of public health in this country have been coming so fast and furious that I can’t keep up with them on a weekly posting schedule here at SBM. I had hoped to write about something other than COVID-19 and vaccines, but unfortunately, there’s been another development in the past few days. That’s after last week, when I noted that former President and Republican nominee for President Donald Trump had cozied up to Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who’s been a rabid antivax loon for nearly two decades now (at least), leading them both to come up with a riff on Trump’s “make America great again” (MAGA) slogan, namely “make America healthy again” (MAHA). Let’s just say that it wasn’t the greatest slogan—MAHA?—and RFK Jr.’s plan was a mixture of the not-bad (e.g., concern about regulatory capture) with the absolute bonkers (e.g., giving half of the NIH budget to research into “holistic” therapies) and, tellingly and conveniently enough, mentioned absolutely nothing about vaccines. It’s as if RFK Jr. and Trump both thought that we would totally forget about RFK Jr.’s two decades of antivax fear mongering and conspiracy theories. Now, hot on the heals of that disturbing news, it’s difficult for me not to take notice of the recently issued Updated Guidance for COVID-19 Boosters for the Fall and Winter 2024–2025 Season from the Florida Department of Health, currently run by COVID-19 contrarian and now arguably antivax physician Dr. Joseph Ladapo, discouraging the use of mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines for older people (and that’s not all) based on misrepresented science and antivax tropes.This guidance was sent by email last Thursday to all licensed healthcare providers in the state of Florida.
Before I discuss just how off-base this “guidance” is and what it says about the danger to public health in this country, I can’t help but note that Dr. Jonathan Howard just posted a good summary of what I’m talking about when I point to the fact that RFK Jr. has been appointed honorary co-chair of Trump’s transition team, should Trump win in November. What, exactly, “honorary co-chair” means or entails is unclear, but what is clear is that RFK Jr. has managed to achieve considerable influence in the Trump campaign and will likely himself score a major cabinet position, the most likely position being Secretary of Health and Human Services, a truly horrifying prospect given that he would then have control over the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the FDA, the CDC, and the NIH are parts of HHS. Of course, for this to happen, Republicans would also have to retake control of the Senate, given that the chances that a Senate controlled by Democrats would ever confirm someone like RFK Jr. for HHS, speculation has thus already begun as to who, if Trump wins, might score leadership positions in these government agencies critical to medicine and public health. Jonathan and I have speculated that contrarian physicians like Drs. Vinay Prasad, Scott Atlas, Jay Bhattacharya, and, yes, Joseph Ladapo might be up to head the FDA, CDC, and the like. (I think it less likely that someone bonkers will be appointed to the NIH, but that could just be wishful thinking if Trump retakes power and RFK Jr. becomes HHS secretary.)
This brings us back to Dr. Ladapo. If you want to see the direction that the federal government will likely take if Trump becomes President again and RFK Jr. oversees the appointment of federal officials overseeing public health agencies, such as the FDA Commissioner and CDC Director, look no further than Florida, where COVID-19 contrarianism, hostility to public health, and outright antivax misinformation have taken over the Department of Health of a large state.
“Updated guidance”? More like the same old misinformation
So let’s look at what the updated guidance regarding COVID-19 boosters for the winter season says. I note that, almost certainly (for reasons that I will discuss shortly) Dr. Ladapo had a great deal of influence in these guidelines. They begin with a dog whistle to antivaxxers:
The Florida Department of Health (Department) is reminding health care providers of the importance of remaining up to date with current literature related to COVID-19 vaccines and boosters, and the importance of providing patients with informed consent.
Remember, whenever you see someone hostile to vaccines invoke “informed consent,” what they virtually always really mean is something that, over the years I’ve referred to as “misinformed consent” or, more recently, “misinformed refusal.” What do I mean by those terms? I mean that, under the seemingly unobjectionable cloak of a bedrock principle of medical ethics, informed consent, what is really being fed to you is at best a biased—and at worst utterly incorrect or made-up—summary of the evidence designed to portray vaccines in the worst possible light and falsely imply that the risks outweigh the benefits. Trying to produce misinformed refusal in an audience is, of course, a tactic not limited to antivaxxers. Quacks use it too, to frighten you away from conventional medicine.
Now comes the spin designed to provoke misinformed refusal, first the semi-reasonable but painted in the worst possible light:
On August 22, 2024, the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved and authorized updated versions of mRNA vaccines from Pfizer-BioNtech and Moderna. The FDA approved the vaccine for people 12 and older and provided emergency use authorization for children 6 months to 11 years old. The stated target of these boosters is the Omicron variant which is not causing a significant number of infections.
The most recent booster approval was granted in the absence of booster-specific clinical trial data performed in humans. Furthermore, this booster does not protect against the currently dominant strain, accounting for approximately 37% of infections in the United States. There are currently limited data to inform whether these boosters offer any substantial protection against the virus and subsequent circulating variants. Although randomized clinical trials are normally used to approve therapeutics, the federal government has not required COVID-19 vaccine manufacturers to demonstrate their boosters prevent hospitalizations or death from COVID-19 illness.
Notice the methodolatry, defined as the profane worship of the double-blind randomized clinical trial (RCT) above all other forms of evidence and devoid of context regarding whether an RCT would be feasible or practical. Basically, when you see someone invoking RCTs regarding updated vaccines to target variants, you are very likely looking at methodolatry that weaponizes EBM against public health and vaccines to sow doubt and mistrust. The implication is that large RCTs need to be done when updating a vaccine to target the predominant strains of a virus in circulation, when in fact the practice adopted for COVID-19 vaccines is similar to what we have long done with influenza vaccines.
It is, of course, true that if the experts picking the strains to include in the yearly update to the seasonal influenza vaccine pick wrong, which has occasionally happened in the past, the efficacy of the vaccine will be disappointingly low, compared to years when they prognosticate accurately regarding the strains expected to circulate that season. One can argue how accurately scientists have chosen the strain of SARS-CoV-2 to include in this year’s update to the vaccine, but Dr. Ladapo’s argument goes beyond that to imply that the strains chosen have resulted in an ineffective vaccine. Moreover, one might even question whether everyone needs a yearly COVID-19 booster, as Dr. Paul Offit did last year, but that’s not what Dr. Ladapo is doing here either. Worse, as you will see, in contrast to what Dr. Offit was arguing, namely that boosters should be targeted to those at highest risk for severe disease and death from COVID-19, what Dr. Ladapo appears to be doing is discouraging the use of mRNA vaccines in that very population, in addition to young people who, as antivaxxers have long deceptively argued, are at such low risk that vaccines are unnecessary.
That’s why I contrast the spin that Dr. Ladapo’s department places on the situation, which is to imply that a mismatch means that the vaccine won’t work, to a more sober assessment from a less “contrarian” scientist, Andy Pekosz, PhD, a professor in Molecular Microbiology and Immunology, who contributed to an article published by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, What to Know About the Updated COVID Vaccine for Fall, Winter 2024–25:
As in previous years, there are mRNA vaccines—one from Moderna, one from Pfizer—and a protein-based vaccine, from Novavax. One nuance this year is that the mRNA and protein-based vaccines target different—though closely related—variants.
The updated mRNA COVID vaccines from Moderna and Pfizer are based on the KP.2 strain, one of the FLiRT variants that have been spreading since early spring. These variants and their sub-variants have caused the majority of infections during this summer’s COVID wave. The protein-based Novavax vaccine is based on the JN.1 variant, which accounted for the majority of COVID infections in the first few months of 2024 and is the parent strain from which KP.2 and other currently circulating variants branch from.
At the end of the day, laboratory experiments show that all of the updated vaccines available this season can recognize circulating COVID variants and therefore should be similarly effective in reducing your chance of becoming severely ill from COVID infection or needing to be hospitalized.
As you can see, Dr. Ladapo is trying to persuade you that the new vaccines are likely to be ineffective because they supposedly target the “wrong” strains of SARS-CoV-2 compared to the strains that are currently circulating, when in fact the strains are very similar, meaning that vaccinating against one will likely provide adequate protection against the other related strains. Indeed, that is exactly the rationale cited by FDA’s Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC) in making its recommendations to manufacturers:
The committee unanimously voted to recommend a monovalent JN.1-lineage vaccine composition. Following the vote, the committee discussed considerations for the selection of a specific JN.1 lineage SARS-CoV-2 strain (e.g., JN.1 or KP.2) and expressed a strong preference for JN.1.
During this meeting, the advisory committee was informed of the manufacturing timelines, and they reviewed the available data. These data included information on the circulation of SARS-CoV-2 virus variants, current vaccine effectiveness, human immunogenicity data of current vaccines against recently circulating virus variants, the antigenic characterization of circulating virus variants, animal immunogenicity data on new candidate vaccines expressing or containing updated spike components, and preliminary human immunogenicity data on JN.1 candidate vaccines.
Based on the totality of the evidence, on June 6, 2024, FDA initially advised the manufacturers of the licensed and authorized COVID-19 vaccines that the COVID-19 vaccines (2024-2025 Formula) for use in the United States beginning in fall 2024 should be monovalent JN.1 vaccines.
FDA has continued to monitor the circulating strains of SARS-CoV-2. Based on the most current available data, along with the recent rise in cases of COVID-19 in areas of the country, the agency has further determined that the preferred JN.1-lineage for the COVID-19 vaccines (2024-2025 Formula) is the KP.2 strain, if feasible. This change is intended to ensure that the COVID-19 vaccines (2024-2025 Formula) more closely match circulating SARS-CoV-2 strains. FDA has communicated this change to the manufacturers of the licensed and authorized COVID-19 vaccines. The agency does not anticipate that a change to KP.2 will delay the availability of the vaccines for the United States.
I can see here from this why Moderna and Pfizer based their vaccines on the KP.2 strain and Novavax stuck with the JN.1. It’s simple logistics. Because the vaccines by Moderna and Pfizer are mRNA-based, it’s way easier for them to change the sequence of the template used to make the mRNA to be included in the vaccine and quickly ramp up manufacturing than it is for Novavax, whose vaccine uses recombinant protein as the antigen, which takes longer to make because there are the additional steps of making and purifying the protein product to be packaged in the vaccine.
Let’s look at the final “guidance” here, and then in the next section I’ll point out the antivax tropes used to come up with the “guidance”:
Based on the high rate of global immunity and currently available data, the State Surgeon General advises against the use of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. Any provider concerned about the health risks associated with COVID-19 for patients over the age of 65 or with underlying health conditions should prioritize patient access to non-mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and treatment.
You read that right. Dr. Ladapo is advising against the use of any mRNA vaccines, period. I kid you not. He’s advising against them for everybody and only grudgingly saying that they might be used in older people and those with underlying chronic health conditions, you know, those who have been known since the beginning of the pandemic to be among the populations at the highest risk for severe disease and death from COVID-19, but only after prioritizing “patient access to non-mRNA COVID-19 vaccines and treatment.” WTF? Seriously, all treatments for COVID-19 are “non-mRNA,” because only the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines are mRNA-based, not any treatments for COVID-19 that I’m aware of. One wonders if he’s implying that doctors should encourage the use of ineffective treatments like ivermectin, but I could be reading too much into it. Maybe.
Now let’s look at the rationale cited. You will recognize several common antivax tropes. Indeed, Dr. Ladapo made it very clear that he’s conspiracy mongering in his post on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, in which he accuses public health authorities of “gaslighting” the public regarding vaccines and dons the mantle of being all about The Real Science:
@CDCgov & @US_FDA are gaslighting Americans with their new, unproven COVID-19 boosters, and recommend them for 6 month-old babies!We say bring data, acknowledge serious safety concerns & acknowledge the many people who believe they’ve been injured by these vaccines.See my…
— Joseph A. Ladapo, MD, PhD (@FLSurgeonGen) September 13, 2024
“Acknowledge serious safety concerns”? You mean the minor or nonexistent safety concerns that antivaxxers have been flogging for nearly four years? and the “many people who believe they’ve been injured by these vaccines”? You mean like the ones who have been fooled into thinking that their cancers—excuse me, “turbo cancers”—were caused by the vaccine?
Seriously, even though this “guidance” seems semi-reasonable if that’s all you read, Dr. Ladapo can’t help but give the game away when he’s on social media. Also note how he says at the end, “See my latest guidance.” Not “see the Florida Department of Health’s latest guidance,” but “see my latest guidance.” You can see why I refer to this document as being all Dr. Ladapo and refer to it as his. I’m just taking my lead from the crank himself.
How not to justify “updated guidance”
Right before the “guidance” in bold, Dr. Ladapo suggests that “they” are either hiding evidence or at least not providing sufficient evidence to assuage the fears of the public (fears that, I note, have been stoked by antivaxxers) over “serious safety concerns”:
Additionally, the federal government has failed to provide sufficient data to support the safety and efficacy of COVID-19 boosters, or acknowledge previously demonstrated safety concerns associated with COVID-19 vaccines and boosters, including:
    • prolonged circulation of mRNA and spike protein in some vaccine recipients,
    • increased risk of lower respiratory tract infections, and
    • increased risk of autoimmune disease after vaccination.
Later in the “guidance,” Dr. Ladapo claims as a risk:
Elevated levels of mRNA and spike protein from the mRNA COVID-19 vaccine persist among some individuals for an indefinite period, which may carry health risks.
I’ve discussed concern number one above, the “prolonged circulation of mRNA and spike proteins” in “some” vaccine recipients. I note that the word “some” is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. For example, the half-life of the mRNA for spike protein used in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines is on the order of a few days, with the spike protein being detectable for at most eight weeks in “some” patients. While it is true that one study oft-cited by antivaxxers found vaccine mRNA fragments in the blood as long as 28 days after vaccination, I note that this was mostly mRNA fragments, meaning that the mRNA would not be expected to generate further spike protein. Indeed, the authors speculated that this finding might have been due to slow leakage of the lipid nanoparticles out of the injection site. In any event, contrary to what antivaxxers claim, neither the modified mRNA nor the spike protein coded for by that mRNA persist long term in the human body, and there’s no evidence that their observed persistence is unsafe.
As for the last two? Regarding the claimed increased risk of lower respiratory tract infections associated with COVID-19 vaccination, I note that no studies were cited, unlike the other concerns later in the document. I do remember studies showing an increase in other infectious diseases associated with the lifting of COVID-19 restrictions after the vaccines became available, such as this one from Israel. However, you know what increases your risk of subsequent lower respiratory infections? That’s right, COVID-19 does, and the risk increases with each reinfection. As for the last one, there is no robust evidence linking COVID-19 vaccination to any autoimmune diseases, later in the “guidance” Dr. Ladapo claims:
The mRNA COVID-19 vaccine may be associated with an increased risk of autoimmune diseases including systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), rheumatoid arthritis, and psoriasis.
But what did that study actually conclude? Not exactly what Dr. Ladapo tried so much to imply above:
We report that the risk of developing most AI-CTDs did not increase following mRNA vaccination, except for systemic lupus erythematosus with a 1.16-fold risk in vaccinated individuals relative to controls. Comparable results were reported in the stratified analyses for age, sex, mRNA vaccine type, and prior history of non-mRNA vaccination. However, a booster vaccination was associated with an increased risk of some AI-CTDs including alopecia areata, psoriasis, and rheumatoid arthritis. Overall, we conclude that mRNA-based vaccinations are not associated with an increased risk of most AI-CTDs, although further research is needed regarding its potential association with certain conditions.
See what I mean?
Many among the rest of the “risks” come straight out of the fever swamp of COVID-19 antivax nonsense. I’ll start with some of the most egregious before moving to the just exaggerated, starting with—you guessed it!—”turbo cancer” and the claims that the mRNA vaccines “permanently alter your DNA”:
Potential DNA integration from the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines poses unique and elevated risk to human health and to the integrity of the human genome, including the risk that DNA integrated into sperm or egg gametes could be passed onto offspring of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine recipients. 
Oh, no! The vaccines are going to corrupt our DNA! Actually, no they are not, and the study cited by Dr. Ladapo above was an infamous one by Kevin McKernan, who has done his best to torture science to demonstrate that somehow, against all of what we know about molecular biology and what it takes for DNA to integrate into the genome, that nasty and supposedly “massive” DNA contamination from the vaccine is affecting your DNA. It’s not, and I discussed that very study in gory detail a long time ago. It’s utter nonsense. That Dr. Ladapo would cite such ideologically motivated horribly bad “science” to support his “guidance” should tell you all you might want to know.
But let’s look at some more claims:
    • “The mRNA COVID-19 vaccines present a risk of subclinical and clinical myocarditis and other cardiovascular conditions among otherwise healthy individuals.”
    • “The mRNA COVID-19 vaccine may be associated with an increased risk of postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS).”
Here’s the interesting thing. As anyone who’s paid attention to the real issue of an elevated risk of myocarditis after vaccination with the mRNA vaccines knows, that risk occurs primarily in young people, in particularly young men, who nearly all make a full recovery, not the over-65 population who are most at risk of severe disease and bad outcomes if they catch COVID-19. As Dr. Paul Offit put it regarding Dr. Ladapo’s attempt to frighten everyone, including older people, away from the mRNA-based vaccines:
“It’s just such a dangerous game he plays,” said Offit, who has served on the FDA’s independent vaccine advisory committee. “You only have a roughly 1,000 times greater likelihood of dying [from Covid] if you’re over 65 than if you’re under 18.”
“The mRNA vaccines are remarkably safe,” he added.
As for POTS, yes, there is a small increased risk of POTS after vaccination, but the risk of POTS is much higher after COVID-19; specifically a recent study in Nature Cardiovascular Research concluded that COVID-19 infection is associated with a five-fold greater risk of POTS than COVID-19 vaccination. I can’t help but notice how Dr. Ladapo cited this exact study but failed to mention this or that the odds ratio for post-vaccination POTS was 1.10, quite low. Funny that. Actually, no, it’s not funny. It’s predictable given that Dr. Ladapo is an antivax crank.
I also can’t resist letting Dr. Peter Hotez also chime in:
5/n Covid vaccination protects heart health https://t.co/xbxGpap4hw
— Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD (@PeterHotez) September 13, 2024
In other words, Dr. Ladapo is either lying by admission or just plain lying, although one does have to allow for the possibility that he’s a true believer and his ideology has blinded him to what the totality of evidence shows.
Finally, there’s this:
Throughout the pandemic, studies across geographic regions found that the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines are associated with negative effectiveness after four to six months. As efficacy waned, studies showed that COVID-19 vaccinated individuals developed an increased risk for infection.
I can’t help but note that the first study cited concluded:
Effectiveness against COVID-19 hospitalization and death was 70–80% after the second dose and >90% after the booster dose. mRNA-1273 vaccine protection showed similar patterns. mRNA vaccines provide comparable, moderate, and short-lived protection against symptomatic BA.1 and BA.2 Omicron infections, but strong and durable protection against COVID-19 hospitalization and death.
Moreover, the findings of “negative vaccine efficacy” are likely an artifact of biases related to measuring the true versus observed levels of infection in some observational studies in which exposure and testing of individuals vary based on vaccination status, as this commentary describes:
Different sources of bias produce negative VE by influencing either (1) the true levels of infection or symptomatic infection by vaccination status (e.g., by differences in exposure) or (2) the observed levels of infection or symptomatic infection by vaccination status (e.g., by differences in testing) (Figure 1). Although the biases related to (1) cause true underlying (symptomatic) infection differences that exist even given perfect sampling, biases related to (2) cause a perception of differences that do not reflect the real (symptomatic) infection levels present in the population. Although both categories of bias are important to discuss in the broader context of VE studies, their relevance for a specific study will depend on the type of VE being measured. The biases related to (1) and (2) can both influence VE measurements of infection and symptomatic infection; the biases related to (2) are less likely to play a role when measuring VE against severe outcomes (e.g., intensive care unit admission, intubation, and death) because testing for these outcomes is unlikely to differ across vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals [14].
I recommend reading the whole commentary, as it points out how these biases can give a false appearance of “negative efficacy,” and this figure is worth looking at too, as it summarizes the issues:
One notices that antivaxxers always cherry pick these studies and ignore the overall totality of the evidence, which shows that COVID-19 vaccines are safe and effective and reduce your chance of severe disease that can result in death. It’s no surprise that Dr. Ladapo does the same thing. Nor is it any surprise that he implies that the following will help as much or more than the vaccines:
Improving habits and overall health help manage and reduce the risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and obesity, risk factors for serious illness from COVID-19.
The State Surgeon General and the Department continue to encourage Floridians to prioritize their overall health by:
    • Staying physically active,
    • Minimizing processed foods,
    • Prioritizing vegetables and healthy fats, and
    • Spending time outdoors to support necessary vitamin D levels.
This is the same sort of false dilemma that antivaxxers have long used. Sure, you’ll be healthier if you stay physically active and prioritize healthy eating, although staying outside is a two-edged sword if you don’t also avoid excessive sun exposure that can increase your risk of skin cancer. As for all of this supposedly reducing your risk of COVID-19, this is a trope that COVID-19 contrarians were spewing before there was even a vaccine, when, for instance, Dr. Aseem Malhotra attacked Krispy Kreme for providing free doughnuts to frontline healthcare workers in the UK and claimed that “metabolic optimization” could cure COVID-19. Everything old is new again. Too bad most people, including many of my colleagues, don’t recognize that.
Florida public health pseudoscience: Coming soon to the federal government?
When Florida Governor Ron DeSantis first appointed Dr. Ladapo as Florida’s Surgeon-General and therefore the person in charge of the Florida Department of Health and the state’s entire public health apparatus, many of us were justifiably alarmed, an alarm that has been totally validated by his performance since his appointment. After all, Dr. Ladapo was a founding member of America’s Frontline Doctors, which made a name for itself in that horrible first summer of the pandemic by touting hydroxychloroquine as a miracle cure for COVID-19 and later turned to telehealth grift selling prescriptions for ivermectin to cure COVID-19, and a signatory of the Great Barrington Declaration, the document published by contrarian scientists brought together by a right-wing think tank to advocate a social Darwinist “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic with poorly defined “focused protection” for those most at risk for severe disease and death from the pandemic.
Moreover, this “updated guidance” is far from the first time that Dr. Ladapo has tried to mislead using the usual denialist techniques of cherry picking evidence and even outright misrepresenting it. Last year, he was busted for altering a Florida Department of Health study for lying with statistics to make it look as though the vaccine was more dangerous than COVID-19 for men under 40. Earlier this year, consistent with its inclusion in this “guidance,” Dr. Ladapo was parroting McKernan’s bad science that massively exaggerated the problem of DNA contamination of the vaccine.
Given the recent developments in which Donald Trump has cozied up to RFK Jr. and (apparently) promised him a cabinet-level position in his administration, should he win in November, it’s very easy to foresee what will happen to medicine, public health, and science in general if Trump becomes President again. You need look no further than Florida, except that it could even be worse than Florida. After all, Dr. Ladapo isn’t the only doctor hostile to vaccines and public health science who would likely find a leadership position in a second Trump administration. There is ample reason to be afraid, very afraid.

Hopkins Business School to Platform COVID-19 Contrarians at Health Policy Symposium
Drs. Jay Bhattacharya, Scott Atlas, and Marty Makary are also set to speak at Stanford next month
Allison Neitzel on September 8, 2024
Link

Next month, Stanford University’s Department of Health Policy is set to host a conference on pandemic policy featuring a number of prominent COVID-19 minimizers. Of particular concern to public health and medical experts is the participation of the university’s new president, Jonathan Levin, who previously served as its business school dean. The event itself was organized by Stanford health economist and author of the pro-economy, anti-lockdown Great Barrington Declaration, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya.
But before that, Bhattacharya and two of the other physician panelists from the Stanford conference, Dr. Scott Atlas and Dr. Marty Makary, are set to appear at a similar event this week in Washington D.C. hosted by the Johns Hopkins University Carey Business School. This forum, which is notably not being conducted in coordination with the prestigious Johns Hopkins medical or public health schools, reveals a concerning trend: Right-wing business interests are working to infiltrate academia in order to legitimize pro-business, anti-public health policy.
The Atlas Dogma
Atlas, Bhattacharya’s colleague from Stanford’s conservative think tank, the Hoover Institution, will be speaking at Hopkins on a panel titled “Health policy 2025 & beyond.” In June 2022, the Democratic-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis (HSSCC) published a report, “The Atlas Dogma: The Trump Administration’s Embrace of a Dangerous and Discredited Herd Immunity via Mass Infection Strategy,” specifically exposing the work of Atlas and Bhattacharya within the Trump White House in 2020.
Atlas and Bhattacharya are founding fellows of the Academy for Science and Freedom at the right-wing and politically active Hillsdale College – a sponsor of the Heritage Foundation’s infamous Project 2025 plan, which serves as the extremist policy strategy for a second Trump presidency and is markedly anti-public health.
Back in June, Atlas and Bhattacharya spoke at an event at the New College of Florida titled “Reversing the Ideological Capture of Universities and Institutions.” New College is a public liberal arts school overhauled by the far-right state government to be the “Hillsdale of the South.”
The Heritage Foundation
This past March, Atlas co-authored a report titled “COVID Lessons Learned: A Retrospective After Four Years” published by the Committee to Unleash Prosperity, a group whose leadership includes Steve Forbes, Chairman and Editor-in-Chief of Forbes Media; Arthur Laffer, a former member of President Reagan’s Economic Advisory Board; and Steve Moore, a Wall Street Journal contributor and visiting fellow for The Heritage Foundation’s “Project for Economic Growth.”
The Heritage tie is notable given their authorship of Project 2025. Heritage also authored a “Road Map for COVID-19 Congressional Oversight” which appears to be the playbook being followed by the current GOP-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic (HSSCP) (the HSSCP replaced the HSSCC following the 2022 midterms).
Misleading claims
Atlas’s co-authors on “Lessons Learned” include Philip Kerpen, president of the Committee to Unleash Prosperity; Casey Mulligan, Professor in Economics at the University of Chicago and former chief economist for the Council of Economic Advisers in the Trump Administration; and Steve Hanke, Professor of Applied Economics at Johns Hopkins.
Their report contains multiple misleading claims including “lockdowns do not work to substantially reduce deaths or stop viral circulation” (they did) and “masks were of little or no value” (false). It echoes messaging promoted by the GOP-led HSSCP, including overstating damage caused to children from school closures and decrying the harm of supposed governmental suppression of scientific dissent.
This week, Atlas and Bhattacharya will be joined for the “Physician autonomy and leadership” panel by Makary, who is, tellingly, the sole medical representation from Hopkins. Makary infamously over-promised that the U.S. would “have herd immunity by April” in a 2021 Wall Street Journal opinion piece, despite having no background in infectious diseases or epidemiology.
The Norfolk Group
Bhattacharya and Makary are both members of the Norfolk Group apparently created to send GOP-friendly experts to the HSSCP. Shortly before the opening HSSCP hearing in February 2023 featuring Bhattacharya and Makary, the Norfolk Group published a blueprint of “questions for a COVID-19 commission,” which bears a striking resemblance to the Heritage Foundation’s “Road Map.”
Of note, Norfolk Group member Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg – part of the 2022 so-called Urgency of Normal, which felt very much like a school-focused rebrand of the Great Barrington Declaration and downplayed the risk posed to children by COVID-19 – is currently a visiting scholar at MIT’s business school, the Sloan School of Management (she is not participating in the Stanford or Hopkins events but testified to the HSSCP last year).
Rounding out the “Physician autonomy and leadership” panel are two Hopkins professors: Phil Phan (Professor of Strategy and Entrepreneurship) and Dan Polsy (Professor of Health Economics and Policy). Shortly following the signing of the Great Barrington Declaration, Polsy hosted Bhattacharya at a webinar on the “herd immunity vs. lockdown” debate through the business school.
Dark money and rewriting history
As my colleague Walker Bragman reported, the lineup at this Hopkins event also features speakers affiliated with right-wing dark money groups with ties to billionaire Charles Koch, a major donor to Hopkins ($1.3 million from 2021-2022) and Stanford ($3.3 million from 2020-2022). The Great Barrington Declaration, which codified the herd immunity strategy pushed in the Trump White House, was itself on the edges of the Koch Network.
These Hopkins and Stanford events as well as the GOP-led HSSCP serve the purpose of rewriting pandemic history to push an anti-public health agenda favored by right-wing business interests – just ahead of the presidential election. If these contrarians continue to be platformed this way, there must be a concerted effort to draw attention to the damage their ideologically-motivated strategies caused in Trump’s mismanagement of the COVID-19 outbreak.
Preview of what may come
The doctors who aided in his destructive pandemic response are very likely contenders for positions in a second Trump administration. These “conferences” serve the dual purpose of auditions and campaign-adjacent events, and their dangerous anti-science narratives are not something academia should be validating by platforming. This is not about academic freedom or censorship; this is an issue of academic integrity and information safety.
If you have not already, now would be an excellent time to read Science-Based Medicine’s Dr. Jonathan Howard’s 2023 book “We Want Them Infected,” which expands on the HSSCC’s “Atlas Dogma” report. And perhaps donate a copy to Stanford’s President Levin and the Carey Business School.

Stanford University will host a conference on pandemic planning featuring the usual (COVID-19) suspects
This week, Stanford University announced a conference on pandemic policy that features several of the usual suspects who spread misinformation during the COVID-19 pandemic. Truly, Stanford has become the “respectable” academic face of efforts to undermine public health.
David Gorski on August 26, 2024
Link
If there was one thing that I would not have predicted—but, arguably, should have been able to predict—regarding the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s the degree to which my fellow academics, particularly physicians and scientists, would contribute to public fear, misunderstanding, and doubt about public health interventions utilized to mitigate the worst of the pandemic. If I had been able to predict the level of complicity of my fellow academics in advocating for just letting the disease rip in a futile bid to achieve “natural herd immunity,” opposing tried-and-true interventions to slow the spread of respiratory diseases (e.g., masking) using a narrow fundamentalist interpretation of evidence-based medicine (EBM), promoting unproven “repurposed drugs” as near miracle cures, and even fear mongering about vaccines, I might have been able to predict that Stanford University would end up being the epicenter of such activities, if only because of its tight affiliation with the right wing think tank, The Hoover Institution. If that weren’t enough, then the fact that one of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration, the document advocating a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic promising “natural herd immunity” in six months, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, is Stanford faculty should have helped. So should the fact that Dr. John Ioannidis, formerly the greatest EBM guru (whom I once admired) who very early in the pandemic took a heel turn in favor of minimizing how dangerous COVID-19 was and advocating—you guessed it—”natural herd immunity” approaches to the pandemic.
That background is why, while I was disappointed, I wasn’t entirely surprised to start seeing posts like this on social media:
Sweet Jesus. Vinay Prasad and Monica Ghandi the two people who have literally not once been correct? The very people who have disabled and killed ppl with their misinformation?
— CleanTheAir #CleanTheAirInSchools (@ProHealth4MyKid) August 25, 2024
Vinay Prasad and Monica Ghandi are only two of the participants in this conference and, arguably, not even the worst ones.
And:
It's not so much that these individuals should be censored or the conference cancelled, But balance is needed. Their (shoddy) track records and (highly compromising) conflicts and incentives should be examined and laid bare.@SalvMattera @michaelzlin
— If I may… (@Mr_Inquisitr) August 25, 2024
Actually, given the way the conference is organized, I suspect that any “balance” would turn out to be false balance, in which the opinions of the academics who have turned into cranks are represented as being equal to the opinions of public health scientists.
Of course, four years later, I’ve become all too familiar with the dismal track record of certain prominent Stanford University faculty with respect to promoting bad science, pseudoscience, and misinformation about the pandemic. For example, look what happened to Renée DiResta, who was the technical research manager at Stanford Internet Observatory, a cross-disciplinary program of research, teaching and policy engagement for the study of adversarial abuse in current information technologies. Unfortunately, the example of DiResta is just another example of why Stanford has gotten even more problematic. The mission of the Stanford Internet Observatory has been “refocused,” with Stanford having having ended the Election Integrity Partnership’s rapid-response election observation work designed to analyze and counter election misinformation. As a result of Republican pressure, the Stanford Internet Observatory is in essence being dismantled right before the election, and Stanford didn’t renew DiResta’s contract or the contracts of several other employees.
Naturally, I was intrigued. So let’s take a look at this one-day conference, who is participating, and how these participants have “distinguished themselves” as—alas!—highly influential (mostly) academic pandemic minimizers and COVID-19 misinformation spreaders.
Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past?
The title of the conference is Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past, which should tell you a lot? For example, knowing who the speakers and panelists are, I know that “assessing the past” will likely consist of highly revisionist history of the COVID-19 pandemic presented through the lens of claiming that public health interventions didn’t work and then justifying a “plan” for the future in which all those pesky public health measures that interfered with “freedom” be minimized or not used at all. Let’s take a look at how the conference is being advertised:
Bringing together esteemed academics, public health practitioners, journalists, and government officials from all sides of the COVID-19 policy debate in conversation with one another with an eye toward reforms in science and public health to better serve the public.
With millions of lives lost, the COVID-19 pandemic wrought havoc on the world. Despite decades of planning for the “next” pandemic, public health systems faced tremendous stress and often buckled and failed. Universities served as centers for valuable scientific work but failed to support their academic freedom mission by sponsoring vigorous discussion and debate on matters of pandemic policy. To do better in the next pandemic, we need to learn the lessons of the COVID-19 era.
“Esteemed academics, public health practitioners, journalists, and government officials from all sides of the COVID-19 policy debate”? My first reaction was to laugh derisively. No, far from “all sides” are represented. The best that could be said is that the truly radical “infect the all to reach ‘natural herd immunity’ faster” contingent—e.g., Scott Atlas (yes, that Scot Atlas!)— is “balanced” by those who think that it was acceptable to do some public health interventions and try to save some lives, as long as the interventions weren’t too “onerous” (by their definition) and didn’t disrupt business or school too much (again, by their definition). It’s like the line from 1980 movie The Blues Brothers in which the owner of a bar where the Blues Brothers were been booked to play answers their question about what kind of music the bar features: “We got both kinds. We got country and western!”
“We got both kinds of COVID contrarianism. We got “‘natural herd immunity’ infect them all”-based COVID minimization and COVID antivax!”
Here’s another thing that I noticed about this conference that I bet most did not, even those rightfully criticizing Stanford for hosting a conference of this type: its date, October 4, 2024. Does that date ring any bells? It did immediately for me. Why? Because it’s the fourth anniversary of the signing of the Great Barrington Declaration, which was signed on October 4, 2020 and then released to the world the following day. I have a hard time believing that the selection of this particular date for this particular Stanford conference was not entirely intentional, given the involvement a signatory of the Great Barrington Declaration (Sunetra Gupta) and GBD-adjacent faculty as a panelists. I could be wrong—and maybe I am wrong—but it’s hard not to see the choice of date as very intentional. Another oddity is that October 4 is during Rosh Hashanah, one of the most important Jewish holidays, with the site even noting this thusly, “We are aware that the conference date coincides with Rosh Hashanah. We deeply appreciate the significance of this holiday and regret the overlap.” I guess lining the conference up with the fourth anniversary of the signing of the GBD was too important to schedule the conference on a day when Jewish faculty could attend.
OK, I’ll stop, as I know I’m risking starting to sound as conspiratorial as some of the faculty recruited as panelists for this conference!
Still, it’s worth a brief reminder. The Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was a “scientific” declaration facilitated by the right wing “free market” think tank, the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER). Named for the location of AIER’s headquarters in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, the GBD called for what was, in essence, a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic to achieve “natural herd immunity” in six months by letting the young and healthy just get COVID and using “focused protection” to keep those at high risk of death and complications from COVID safe. It’s a tactic that never would have worked—and didn’t work—and was profoundly social Darwinist at its heart. Of particular note, how “focused protection” would work was never really spelled out in sufficient detail to determine just how the GBD signatories would keep those most at risk for death and severe disease due to COVID-19 safe.
Also, adding to the imprimatur of Stanford University being placed on this conference, Stanford President Jonathan Levin will be providing the opening remarks to introduce the day’s proceedings. Of note, he became President of Stanford on August 1, 2024; so he’s new in the job. I also note that the Wayback Machine shows that the conference’s webpage first went live on or around August 2, a placeholder that described the conference, but left all the speakers and panelists to be “announced later,” which they were last week. Most likely, this conference was being organized before Levin officially became Stanford University president, but it is disturbing that he would basically agree to participate, even in the ceremonial manner that most university presidents giving opening remarks at a university-hosted conference do.
Levin, of course, is not a public health scientist or physician. Rather, he is an economist who was elevated to university president after having served before that as the Dean of the Stanford Graduate School of Business. He’s also a collaborator who has published with Dr. Jay Bhattacharya before in economics journals. Even thought Bhattacharya is not a speaker or panelist, it makes sense that Levin would be amenable to participating by introducing the conference.
Let’s look at the various sessions of this conference.
“Evidence-Based Decision Making During a Pandemic”?
Session 1 is entitled Evidence-Based Decision Making During a Pandemic. The blurb describing it seems benign enough; that is, if you are unfamiliar with the participants:
The interventions undertaken to control the COVID-19 pandemic – lockdowns, extended school closures, social distancing, mask mandates, vaccine mandates – were unprecedented in their scope and global impact. How well did these policies work to protect the public from COVID-19 and what were their collateral harms? How can scientists better inform pandemic policy in real time during the next pandemic?
Of course, the key aspect of the GBD and pandemic minimizers is that they always underplay the harm of the virus and overplay the “collateral damage” from public health policy designed to address the pandemic. One of the key giveaways here is the choice of “language,” particularly “lockdowns.” Basically, “lockdowns” has turned into one of those right wing dog whistles that the “freedom über alles” contingent always uses—usually with a sneer—to describe business and school closures and shelter in place orders. It is true that there were business and school closures, there was never anything in terms of policy that approached the sorts of real “lockdowns” that one saw in some authoritarian regimes, in particular China. Moreover, again, the GBD was never about protecting the public from COVID-19. It was about opening up the country for business as fast as possible without regard for harms that the “young and healthy” might suffer from the virus, and only a passing nod to protecting those who were actually the most vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19. Again, as I like to point out, “natural herd immunity” was always a pipe dream for SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, given that natural herd immunity requires lifelong—or at least very long-lasting—postinfection immunity. It was known in 2020 that postinfection immunity from coronaviruses tended to be relatively brief and that coronaviruses were good at evolving variants that could bypass preexisting immunity as a result of infection with prior variants. One had to ignore everything that was known about coronaviruses before 2020 to think that “natural herd immunity” was even a possibility, much less than the truly fantastical belief that it could be achieved in six months.
But let’s look at the participants in this session:
    • Eran Bendavid, Professor of Health Policy, Stanford
    • Monica Gandhi, Professor of Medicine, UCSF
    • Marty Makary, Chief of Islet Transplant Surgery, Johns Hopkins
    • Anders Tegnell, Former Swedish State Epidemiologist
Drs. Marty Makary and Monica Gandhi have been discussed many times on this blog, mostly by Dr. Jonathan Howard, but also by me. Makary, you might remember, was one of the originators of the false claim that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US, a claim based on ridiculous extrapolation from relatively small studies that doesn’t pass even a basic “smell test.” What I mean by that is that, 250K-400K deaths from medical errors would translate to up to 15% of all deaths and over half of the deaths of hospitalized patients in the US that occur every single year. The real number, although still too high, is likely 10- to 20-fold lower. As embarrassed as I was then that Dr. Makary shares my specialty (surgical oncology), I was even more embarrassed at how he quickly became a COVID-19 minimizer starting very early in the pandemic, repeatedly proclaiming an “end to the pandemic” because we’ll have herd immunity” by this date or other and repeatedly being wrong about the pandemic being over.
Monica Gandhi probably represents one of the “both kinds” of COVID-19 minimization in that throughout the pandemic she presented herself as the “reasonable” middle ground between “let ‘er rip” ideologues like Makary and Atlas and conventional public health science recommending standard public health interventions to mitigate the pandemic, viewing the latter as too strict, all the while polluting the COVID-19 information landscape with obvious misinformation and falsely pacified people the worst was over, when in fact the worst was yet to come. Basically, she tried to have it both ways, as Dr. Howard described:
Though she initially said, “It’s simple math. We don’t need to vaccinate those under 11 to get to herd immunity”, she eventually wrote an passionate defense of pediatric COVID vaccination, for example. It’s also likely she will discuss uncontroversial blunders, such as the CDC’s botched tests at the start and the tragedy of those who died due to anti-vaccine misinformation. Who could argue with her call to encourage outdoor activities?
However, these potential areas of agreement aside, Dr. Gandhi unleashed a firehose of poor predictions and bogus statistics throughout the pandemic, always minimizing the virus, of course. If you are unfamiliar with her overwhelming litany of pollyannaish prognostications, repeated declarations of herd immunity, and mocking those who disagreed- “I genuinely with all my heart apologize for anyone who continues to try to scare you about variants“- I suggest you familiarize yourself here: Pandemic Accountability Index, Mehdi Hasan, me, and me again.
Those last few links are excellent summaries of why Dr. Gandhi has been so problematic.
But what about the other two? I’m less familiar with Eran Bendavid other than that he, too, is Stanford faculty, but he has featured on this blog before. For example, he was coauthor with Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and John Ioanndis of an early infamous study that vastly overestimated the seroprevalence of COVID-19 in Santa Clara county and was widely used to argue that the infection fatality rate (IFR) was so low that we didn’t really need to do anything—hint: “lockdowns,” masking, and social distancing—to address COVID-19. He also co-authored a March 2020 op-ed with Bhattacharya in the conservative Wall Street Journal asking, Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? (You can guess their answer.) As we here at SBM like to remind our readers, pretty much everything Jay Bhattacharya has said about the pandemic has turned out to be spectacularly wrong, particularly his predictions. As for Bendavid, as he decried the “Faustian bargain” that made pandemic scientists media figures in 2021, he also revealed a bit too much of an open mind, to the point of being open enough to allow one’s brains to fall out:
The ideal scientist comes into her trade with a sense of wonder, curiosity, openness, and marvel at what nature has to show us. The corruption of scientific norms is a collective manifestation of the erosion of many scientists’ spirits. Many—I would venture most—scientists hold that spirit as a personal ideal. Its erosion happens when science gets blended with social, economic, and psychological forces that exploit the human being inside the scientist, and none more strongly than the media with its fondness for conflict, strife, and black-or-white-ism.
This all sounds lovely, if you don’t know the actual context and the veritable cottage industry of contrarian scientists who stoked fear, uncertainty, and doubt about public health—and continue to do so—and that Bendavid collaborated willingly with scientists who are experts at the very dark arts he self-righteously decries.
As for Anders Tegnell, those who sought to minimize the severity of COVID-19 and advocate a “let ‘er rip” approach loved Sweden because, supposedly, its policies were not so restrictive, while falsely representing Sweden’s COVID-19 results as being as good or better than its neighbors. (And, yes, Sweden did close schools.) Tegnell was a central figure in this and has represented himself as some sort of truth teller who stood up to conventional wisdom (and was right). Let’s just say that GBD author Martin Kulldorff thanked Tegnell in March 2020 for his “wise epidemiological sane Covid-19 work.” What did he mean by that? Pursuing a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, of course! He also declared in March 2020, “Herd immunity before vaccine is inevitable, basically no matter what we do to prevent it.” By April 2020, he was voicing the delusion that there “may be herd immunity in Stockholm by May.” (How did that work out?) Again, the Pandemic Accountability Index has a roundup of Tegnell’s actions and quotes that demonstrate clearly that he was solidly in the “natural herd immunity” camp, as well as a deconstruction of the “Swedish myth” that Sweden did well because of that approach and evidence of how much of a fanboy Tegnell was of one of the most notorious social media influencers pushing COVID-19 misinformation, Ivor Cummins, a.k.a. The Fat Emperor.
Truly, a “fair and balance” panel. I’m sure they’ll express a moderate, evidence-baed take on the successes and failures of public health interventions for COVID-19. (Yes, that’s sarcasm, in case it wasn’t obvious.)
Onward to Session #2.
Pandemic Policy from a Global Perspective?
The second session is entitled Pandemic Policy from a Global Perspective. It is represented thusly:
Because the world economy is global in scope, pandemic policy decisions made by Western governments had profound impacts on the health and economic prospects of people worldwide, including the collapse of global markets, severe supply chain disruptions, large-scale government borrowing to finance pandemic policies, and global inflation. How can the interests of the world’s poor be better represented in the decisions of Western government during the next pandemic?
Yes, you can guess what this will be about. It will likely misrepresent real concerns and debates about disparities in pandemic response, access to vaccines, and health care capacity in poor nations compared to rich nations being exacerbated by the responses of wealthy Western governments as reasons that we should have just pursued a “natural herd immunity” approach. Yes, I’ve seen this movie before. The basic argument is that, because the populations of less developed, poorer nations tend to be on average younger than the populations of more developed nations, letting the virus rip in such countries can achieve “natural herd immunity” faster and with less potential suffering and death than in developed countries (although this fact never stopped that GBD-adjacent from arguing that we should pursue “natural herd immunity” in developed countries too). Never mind that the crowding, the poorer health and nutrition, and the much less robust healthcare infrastructure in such countries would likely obviate any “advantage” in terms of lower morbidity and mortality when a younger population undergoes mass infection.
Let’s look at the participants:
    • Kevin Bardosh, Applied Medical Anthropologist, University of Washington
    • Sunetra Gupta, Professor of Theoretical Epidemiology, Oxford University
    • Anup Malani, Professor of Law, University of Chicago
    • Vinay Prasad, Professor of Medicine, UCSF
I won’t say much more about Sunetra Gupta, given that she was one of the authors of the GBD and remains an advocate of “natural herd immunity.” Nor do I find it necessary to say a lot about Dr. Vinay Prasad, given that he’s been one of the most prolific social media influencers promoting COVID-19 minimization, antimask misinformation, and even fear mongering about the COVID-19 vaccines that has expanded to echoing old antivax tropes about the childhood vaccine schedule. Suffice to say that Dr. Prasad opposed the COVID-19 vaccine for children even before it was approved for children; has portrayed cancern about the virus as “irrational” fear; embraced the antivax message of “do not comply”; frequently misrepresented studies as demonstrating the the COVID-19 vaccine is dangerous; approved of reporting parents who want to vaccinated their children against COVID-19 to child protective services; has repeatedly denied that virus mitigation measures work; and echoed antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s misleading claim that most of the childhood vaccination schedule has never been tested against saline placebo controls in RCTs.
I’m not as familiar with Kevin Bardosh and Anup Malani as perhaps I should be. Bardosh is Director and Head of Research at Collateral Global, a research institute and educational charity based in the UK. He is also affiliated with the School of Public Health, University of Washington and Edinburgh Medical School, and a perusal of his X (Twitter) feed shows that he is very much on the side of emphasizing the harms of the world’s COVID-19 response compared to any benefits. Collateral Global is anything but a pro-public health organization, too. Basically, it’s a GBD-adjacent, anti-“lockdown” org formed by GBD author Gupta and others:
Collateral Global is founded and directed by Sunetra Gupta and her partner Alexander Caccia, a UK Ministry of Defence contractor with ties to Canadian government fossil fuel investments, who had secretly drafted the GBD document. He had also secured PR support for Gupta’s claims about herd immunity from an agency linked to the Cabinet Office ‘Nudge Unit’. OpenDemocracy has now revealed that Gupta personally received funding for her discredited research on herd immunity from a Tory billionaire.
Indeed, it appears to have been formed by all three GBD authors, as discussed in this email:
From the depth of our hearts, a belated thank you for signing the Great Barrington Declaration. With over 850,000 signatures, together we opened up the pandemic debate. While many governments continued with their failed lockdown and other restrictive policies, things have moved in the right direction. For example, most schools have re-opened, most countries prioritized older people for vaccination and Florida rejected restrictions in favor of focused protection without the negative consequencesthat lockdowners predicted.
While occasionally censored, we have not been silenced. Since authoring the Declaration in October 2020, the three of us have actively advocated for focused protection through social media, op-eds and interviews on, for example, vaccine passports and natural immunity.
We have also launched Collateral Global, a charity staffed with academics from across the world to document and disseminate information about the collateral damage of the restrictive measures so that we don’t repeat the mistakes of this pandemic and are able to inform future policy with evidence and analysis. Collateral Global is crowdfunding so that this work can be done to the highest possible standards. You are welcome to join us and help us in those efforts at www.collateralglobal.org, as well as follow us on Twitter, etc. We are also planning an initiative on scientific freedom soon.
With enormous gratitude,
Jay Bhattacharya Sunetra Gupta Martin Kulldorff
Well, alrighty then. Of course, if you don’t believe me, feel free to peruse its website, where Kevin Bardosh bemoaned the WHO calling misinformation spreaders “conspiracy theorists” (which the vast majority of them are). He also published (with several of the usual suspects, including Makary, Prasad, and others) an infamous article arguing that college booster mandates were unethical, based on inappropriate comparisons.
As for Anup Malani, he’s an Indian economist and lawyer, faculty at the University of Chicago, not a public health scientist or physician. He seems to think that because economists are good at statistics they are also good at analyzing COVID-19:
On this I disagree. 1/ Empirical economists are good at…stats. And stats are useful for analyzing Covid data. See eg recent AER-I paper on selection bias in COVID surveillance.2/ Fields (including economics!) often get trapped in particular ways of thinking about things.… https://t.co/FWBmjcAOza
— Anup Malani (@anup_malani) December 22, 2023
While I don’t disagree that sometimes an “outsider” can bring a new perspective to investigations, I also note that often “outsiders” lack deep subject knowledge that is possessed by actual subject experts. Perusing Malani’s publication record, I find less to object to from him, other than his being interviewed by the COVID-19 minimizers at Collateral Global. Perhaps he’s one of the “both” country and western, as well. (If anyone is more familiar with his work than I could become Googling him, perusing his publications, and looking at his social media feeds, please weigh in down in the comments.) It will also be interesting to see how he responds to the virus minimization blather of the other panelists and the borderline antivax bleatings of Dr. Prasad. If he is one of the reasonable panelists, he will likely turn out to be the token skeptic on the panel.
Onward to Session #3.
Misinformation, Censorship, and Academic Freedom?
Session #3, Misinformation, Censorship, and Academic Freedom, is the one that produced the biggest “WTF?” reaction from me, for obvious reasons, namely the panel participants. Its description is full of false dichotomies:
The pandemic saw the conflict of two clashing approaches to informing the public and protecting it against rumors and harmful falsehoods. On the one hand, governments censored information contrary to public health pronouncements in social media settings and heavily influenced traditional media sources to convey those pronouncements. On the other hand, dissident scientists and university professors sought means to reach the public with their message despite censorship and suppression. Does the suspension of free speech rights during a pandemic help keep the population better informed or does it permit the perpetuation of false ideas by governments?
“Dissident scientists”? More like “brave maverick doctors,” COVID-19 minimizers, and outright cranks, many of whom started out as one or the other of the first two and, as the pandemic progressed, evolved into the third. (Martin Kulldorff and Vinay Prasad immediately come to mind.) Also, although I wasn’t (initially) familiar with the moderator (George Tidmarsh), get a load of the panelists:
    • Scott Atlas, Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution
    • Jenin Younes, Litigation Council, New Civil Liberties Alliance
Yikes! Hosting a panel on misinformation, censorship, and academic freedom with Scott Atlas and Jenin Younes as the sole panels is a lot like having a discussion panel on childhood vaccines and autism consisting of Andrew Wakefield (godfather of the 21st century antivax movement) and Aaron Siri (a lawyer who frequently works with antivaxxers like RFK Jr. and Del Bigtree)! Also, why just two on the panel? It’s not as though the conference lineup isn’t packed with COVID-19 cranks bemoaning how they’ve supposedly been “canceled” and “censored.” Surely one or two of them could have done double-duty and appeared on two panels.
Dr. Scott Atlas, you might remember, is a neuroradiologist and, so it seems, a formerly well-respected one, having served as the chief of the neuroradiology section at Stanford University. Unfortunately, Dr. Atlas became a right wing hack at The Hoover Institution at Stanford, a conservative think tank that’s been a font of bad takes on COVID-19. In 2020, he improbably (and briefly) served as a key advisor to President Donald Trump about the government pandemic response, despite his utter lack of expertise in any relevant medical or scientific discipline to do so. Atlas, of course, has been a fairly frequent topic on this blog given all the misinformation he has spewed (and continues to spew), particularly thanks to Dr. Howard, who’s kept a careful log of his statements, most recently last month. Unsurprisingly, Dr. Atlas was entirely on board with the GBD, and, as a result, in October 2020 the Trump administration was seriously considering a herd immunity-based strategy before there was even a vaccine.
By November 2020, Stanford was distancing itself from Dr. Atlas because he had urged resistance to public health policies and mandates:
Stanford University on Monday evening distanced itself from White House coronavirus task force member Dr. Scott Atlas, a senior fellow at the school’s Hoover Institution, after he urged Michigan residents to “rise up” against new public health measures.
“Stanford’s position on managing the pandemic in our community is clear. We support using masks, social distancing, and conducting surveillance and diagnostic testing. We also believe in the importance of strictly following the guidance of local and state health authorities,” the university said in a tweet.
“Dr. Atlas has expressed views that are inconsistent with the university’s approach in response to the pandemic. Dr. Atlas’s statements reflect his personal views, not those of the Hoover Institution or the university.”
In particular, this now deleted Tweet caused an uproar, and this is personal to me because Atlas’ Tweet was in response to pandemic restrictions in Michigan:
Atlas later tried to take it back, but no one believed him:
I remember that in April 2020, armed militia menaced legislators in Michigan because they disapproved of the “lockdowns” and public health mandates that Gov. Gretchen Whitmer had ordered. I highly doubt that Dr. Atlas was unaware of that history when he urged people to “rise up.” His reaction to the criticism of his Tweet was very disingenuous.
I could go on and on about Dr. Atlas, but just use the search box on this blog or my not-so-super-secret other blog, and peruse Dr. Howard’s recent post about him.
As for Jenin Younes, yikes again! First, note that she is a lawyer who has been closely associated with AIER, under whose auspices Bhattacharya, Kuldorff, and Gupta wrote the GBD and whose Twitter handle used to be @leftylockdowns1. A brief perusal of her articles and social media feeds demonstrates that she’s all about opposing any mandatory public health response to COVID-19, including “lockdowns” and mask and vaccine mandates. Her New Civil Liberties Alliance also sued to enjoin California’s law penalizing doctors for disseminating so-called misinformation about Covid-19 to patients. So, she’s pro-quack, too.
I’m sensing a theme here for this conference. On to Session #4!
COVID-19 Origins and the Regulation of Virology?
The last session is entitled COVID-19 Origins and the Regulation of Virology. Given what’s come before, I’m sure you can guess what the focus will be here, but let’s see what the organizers say:
The stakes in the debate about the origin of the pandemic could not be higher. If the pandemic started from an inadequately regulated wildlife trade or zoonoses, reforms to reduce the likelihood of human contact with wild species is vital. On the other hand, if the pandemic started due to dangerous laboratory experiments and inadequate protocols to prevent leaks, then more stringent regulation of such experimentation is warranted. What is the evidence on these topics, and what is the path forward?
This sounds reasonable enough, particularly the first part. Note, however, the false equivalency between a zoonotic origin for the pandemic and “lab leak.” Also note the only person on this panel, which makes me wonder if they plan on adding someone else or if this will just be a talk. And who is this sole panelist? It’s Laura Kahn, Co-Founder, One Health Initiative.
I must confess that I wasn’t very familiar with Kahn, who is a physician and biosafety researcher with a book coming out in early October (surely another coincidence?) entitled One Health and the Politics of COVID-19. Some of the reviews suggest to me where she is coming from:
This book challenges One Health’s most pernicious dogma—that nature is necessarily deadlier than the consequences of human hubris. The book is especially courageous as it criticizes leading contemporary scientific powerholders who support unnecessarily risky virological work. Trust in science requires ethics and transparency.
Some of her social media posts suggest that, although she does emphasize zoonosis and how to prevent zoonotic spillover whenever possible, she is also rather open to lab lake conspiracy theories. I mean, Tweeting:
BREAKING NEWS: Rand Paul Confronts FBI's Wray About Declassifying COVID-… https://t.co/wNrVtpCVx6 via @YouTube
— Laura Kahn (@LauraKahn1) October 31, 2023
Let’s just say that treating anything Rand Paul says about COVID-19 as serious is not a good look for someone who purports to be evidence-based. Nor is credulously publicizing something like this from an anti-GMO group known for promoting lab leak conspiracy theories:
This is that anti-gmo group, right? I knew I had seen these authors before.
— Gigi Gronvall (@ggronvall) April 24, 2022
In addition, Googling found an article that she wrote for the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists in March 2022, The origins of SARS-CoV-2: still to be determined, in which she makes “lab leak”-adjacent arguments if not outright arguments for lab leak, denigrating two of the key papers published in 2022 that supported a zoonotic origin from the Wuhan animal markets, which both Steven Novella and I wrote about at the time.
Her take:
Two recent papers, Worobey et al. and Pekar et al., present geospacial analysis of animal stalls in the Huanan market and viral phylogenetic analysis but do not provide convincing evidence of natural spillover. The data and analyses discussed by Worobey are equally consistent with both hypotheses: (1) that SARS-CoV-2 first entered humans at the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, and (2) that SARS-CoV-2 first entered humans at another location and was subsequently brought to the market and then amplified in the market by humans. The authors’ assertion that the data and analyses support only the natural spillover hypothesis is false.
Perhaps, but not really. The evidence in those papers is far more consistent with a SARS-CoV-2 spillover event at the Huanan Seafood Market, as Steve and I discussed. I also note that she wrote about the preprints, given that her article was published in March 2022 and the final versions of the papers were published in July 2022, honing in on one phrase that lab leak proponents really hated, to the point that they gloated over its removal in the final version of, first raging that the “hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a laboratory-related spillover—for example, from a laboratory-acquired infection—remains a viable possibility” before proclaiming:
Science is the objective pursuit of truth. Preventing future COVID-19 pandemics requires finding the truth. Premature, false declarations of “dispositive evidence” or “proof” does not generate public trust in science and does not protect public health.
That sure sounds like a lab leak proponent argument. As I pointed out, the use of that word in the preprint really ticked off lab leakers, to the point where they responded to its removal by gloating:
Those preprints from a while ago, arguing for wet market spillover (against e.g. lab leak followed by market super-spreading), are now published.Idk when I'll get to them but at least they don't say "dispositive" anymore.https://t.co/nXAvtTN5PThttps://t.co/zyXaHuGIaP
— David Bahry (@DavidBahry) July 26, 2022
The real part of the article that raised my eyebrow, though, was in the Acknowledgements:
Kahn would like to thank Elisa Harris, Milton Leitenberg, and Richard Ebright for their invaluable comments, edits, and suggestions.
Richard Ebright? Yikes! He’s a Rutgers University chemistry professor who has been one of the most obnoxious and hostile lab leak proponents, he and his fellow lab leak believer microbiologist Bryce Nickels to scientists who publish in support of a zoonotic origin “fraudsters,” “liars,” “perjurers,” “felons,” “grifters,” “stooges,” “imbeciles,” and “murderers.” Milton Leitenberg has published with Ebright, in particular this lab leak-promoting An appeal for an objective, open, and transparent scientific debate about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and published on his own Did the SARS-CoV-2 virus arise from a bat coronavirus research program in a Chinese laboratory? Very possibly., in which he denied that lab leak was a conspiracy theory. As for Elisa Harris, she was a cosignatory of an open letter to Nature Medicine, along with lab leak conspiracy theorists Alina Chan, Richard Ebright, and others demanding an expression of concern followed by retraction.
And…uh-oh:
Important Op Ed. Opinion | The Pandemic Probably Started in a Lab. These 5 Key Points Explain Why. – The New York Times https://t.co/K4J5UVzz1T
— Laura Kahn (@LauraKahn1) June 3, 2024
This horrible NYT op-ed by Alina Chan (called “important” by Kahn) was full-on lab leak conspiracy theory, and I discussed why soon after it was published. It’s not for nothing that I’ve referred to Chan as the queen of lab leak conspiracy theories.
I’ve changed my mind. Kahn appears to be at least lab leak-adjacent. I’ve long argued that the current version of lab leak is primarily a conspiracy theory far more than it is a useful or valid scientific hypothesis (most recently three weeks ago), but on what can be gleaned from some Googling I don’t think Kahn is a hard core lab leak proponent. She does, however, seem, at minimum, a little too receptive to the idea given how little the actual scientific evidence supports it.
Stanford should be ashamed, but won’t be
Wrapping it all up is another Stanford Professor, Dr. John Ioannidis, because of course he is. Before the pandemic, Ioannidis was someone whom I admired. Unfortunately, since the pandemic, my opinion—and that of a lot of Ioannidis’ former admirers—soured. Why? Early in the pandemic Ioannidis was quick to embrace “natural herd immunity” approaches to COVID-19 that later became the basis of the Great Barrington Declaration. Again, the GBD was a strategy that never would have worked—and didn’t work—and was profoundly social Darwinist. Although Ioannidis was not an author—indeed, in fairness he refused to sign it, although not based on disagreeing with the GBD’s premise but because of his opposition to “signing petitions” as a means of settling “questions of scientific fact”—his call early in the pandemic for what sure sounded like a variation on the idea of “focused protection” was all over the GBD. He was also a co-author, along with GBD co-author Jay Bhattacharya of the infamous Santa Clara seroprevalence study that misleadingly claimed that over 80 times more people had been exposed to COVID-19 than previously thought (and therefore the infection fatality rate, or IFR, was way lower than was being claimed, meaning COVID was not nearly as dangerous as claimed and therefore all those public health interventions were unnecessary). Ioannidis also made a vile evidence-free accusation that ICU doctors were inadvertently killing COVID patients by intubating them willy-nilly when the patients really didn’t need mechanical ventilation. And don’t even get me started on Ioannidis’ infamous “Kardashian index” paper, in which he smeared scientific critics and opponents of the GBD as “science Kardashians” using risibly bad methodology based on what was originally published as a satirical index to comment on scientists with more social media influence than influence in the scientific literature. Through it all, Ioannidis continues to treat theoretical death from a vaccine as being of more concern than actual death from COVID-19 and to falsely accuse expert panels whose conclusions he doesn’t like of “panel stacking.”
Sadly, it sounds like a very appropriate wrap-up for a conference so loaded with COVID-19 misinformers.
So what happened to Stanford? At the risk of comparing apples to oranges (although I don’t think I am), I liken it to the case of the Cleveland Clinic, an institution that is generally science- and evidence-based, but through ideology allowed in whole centers and institutes that support “integrating” quackery like “functional medicine,” acupuncture, reiki, and others into conventional medicine. How that ideology got entrenched, I don’t know, but it remains so. As for Stanford, my best guess is that it is the right-wing libertarian/conservative influence of The Hoover Institution that attracts COVID-19 contrarians opposed to anything that can be cast as a “lockdown” or any other public health mandate.
The sad thing is, whatever good public health faculty there are at Stanford, their voices do not dominate. Rather, it is the voices of the worst of the worst contrarians, like Jay Bhattacharya, Eran Bendavid, John Ioannidis, and Scott Atlas who dominate the public discourse regarding public health science coming out of Stanford. This is a propaganda-fest masquerading as a legitimate conference on public health responses during a pandemic, and Stanford University ought to be ashamed for putting its imprimatur on the whole affair.

An Open Letter to the President of Stanford, Jonathan Levin: Don’t Censor Drs. Scott Atlas, John Ioannidis, Sunetra Gupta, Marty Marky, Monica Gandhi, Jay Bhattacharya, and Vinay Prasad. Amplify Their Voices.
I trust you’ll have the intellectual integrity to play videos of these speakers. Anything less, would be misinformation and censorship.
Jonathan Howard on August 31, 2024
Link

Dear President Levin,
Your university will soon be hosting a conference titled Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past. The conference claims to value “vigorous discussion and debate on matters of pandemic policy”, and says that it is “bringing together esteemed academics, public health practitioners, journalists, and government officials from all sides of the COVID-19 policy debate.”
Right off the bat, this is obvious misinformation. There will be no vigorous discussion and debate on matters of pandemic policy. The conference organizer, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, carefully curated the speakers to create an echo chamber and foster groupthink. Unsurprisingly, they agree with him. I’ve extensively quoted many of them in my writing, and I know they basically marched in lockstep. They were mostly united in their belief that young people should be infected with SARS-CoV-2 instead of vaccinated against it, and that the pandemic ended years ago. Each of these articles/podcasts is by or about one of the speakers:
    • Dr. Eran Bendavid and Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, March 2020: Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say?
    • Dr. John Ioannidis, April 2020: The Bearer of Good Coronavirus News
    • Dr. Anders Tegnell, April 2020: Sweden Resisted a Lockdown, And Its Capital Stockholm is Expected to Reach ‘Herd Immunity’ In Weeks
    • Dr. Scott Atlas, April 2020: The Data Is In — Stop The Panic And End The Total Isolation
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta, July 2020: We May Already Have Herd Immunity
    • Dr. Monica Gandhi, February 2021: The End of the Pandemic
    • Dr. Marty Makary, February 2021: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by Apri
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad, April 2021: The Motivation We Need to Reach the End of the COVID-19 Pandemic with Dr. Monica Gandhi
A more accurate name for the conference would be “Doctors Who Declared The Pandemic Over Years Ago Meet In the Middle of a COVID Surge to Claim They were Right“.
What could they possibly debate? Perhaps doctors who said we had herd immunity in 2020 will get into it with those who said we didn’t have herd immunity until early 2021. Several doctors who said COVID wasn’t anything to worry about in the first place will also chime in. This is what is being promoted as “all sides of the COVID-19 policy debate.”
If that wasn’t enough doublespeak, one of the sessions, Misinformation, Censorship, and Academic Freedom, features Dr. Scott Atlas, a celebrity radiologist who advised a President and predicted COVID would kill 10,000 Americans. However, despite this professed loathing of misinformation and censorship, I fully expect that this conference will censor its speakers’ misinformation. I hope you’ll read recent articles on the conference (Dr. David Gorski, Pandemic Accountability Index, Allison Neitzel and Walker Bragman), as well as my articles on these speakers. I predict the quotes we’ve collected will be purposefully censored. I am confident the conference will be a giant exercise in deliberate collective amnesia and pandemic revisionism. I expect the plan to infect 250 million unvaccinated Americans to reach herd immunity in 3-6 months will be silenced and suppressed, even though several speakers were leaders of the We Want Them Infected movement. I predict the speakers will fantasize that they would have opened schools, but will say nothing about how they actually worked to deliberately infect the unvaccinated students and teachers within them.
That’s unfortunate.
Doctors who died of COVID were silenced. In contrast, the conference speakers were loud and famous. They advised world leaders and were ubiquitous in the media. They were everywhere, except hospitals. In this video, the former President of the United States specifically credits Dr. Atlas and other Stanford doctors for influencing his thinking on “herd mentality.” Not bad access for “censored” doctors.
Though only a few of the speakers treated COVID patients, they greatly influenced our pandemic response, and for this reason, I’ve worked diligently to preserve their words. I don’t want them to be censored or have their voices erased. Quite the opposite. They deserve to have their pandemic pronouncements amplified and remembered for the rest of their careers. Those of us who worked with COVID patients will never forget the consequences.
You are giving the introduction to the conference, meaning you are setting the tone and giving your personal stamp of approval to it. I am sure we both agree it’s important to have an accurate account of the pandemic and to reject cancel culture. In that spirit, I believe you are obligated to boost these doctors voices. The attendees and the general public deserve to know what they said and the policies they pushed. The speakers claim to have been “silenced”, and you have a unique opportunity to remedy that injustice.
I can help.
While other doctors were treating sick patients, these doctors were in front of cameras. I have collected some clips below and many more are available here. I trust you’ll have the intellectual integrity to play many of them. Anything less, would be misinformation and censorship, betraying the purported mission of this conference and your university.
Sincerely,
Jonathan Howard
Dr. Scott Atlas
Dr. Scott Atlas denies he advocated for herd immunity through mass infection combined with videos of him doing exactly that
Dr. Scott Atlas says it’s wrong to use kids as shields for adults with the vaccine, which no one proposed anyway, followed by him advocating using kids as shields for adults with the virus in June 2020.
Dr. John Ioannidis
Dr. John Ioannidis says most COVID cases are asymptomatic only 1 in 1,000 will die, if COVID is to blame at all, April 2020
Dr John Ioannidis says COVID isn’t dangerous for healthy people under age 65, April 2020
Dr. John Ioannidis calls COVID “common and mild” outside of nursing homes and hospitals, May 2020
Dr. John Ioaniddis, who treated 0 COVID patients, falsely blames doctors who treated COVID patients for their deaths
Dr. Sunetra Gupta
Dr. Sunetra Gupta says the pandemic is “on its way out” and the death rate is close to 1 in 10,000, May 2020
Sunetra Gupta says COVID isn’t something to worry about for those under 55, maybe even 65, September 2020
Dr. Sunetra Gupta proposes the mass infection of unvaccinated youth to reach herd immunity September 2020
Dr. Sunetra Gupta says variants don’t matter, neither do COVID cases, May 2021
Dr. Sunetra Gupta, who wanted to infect kids as human shields for adults, opposes vaccinating them, October 2021
Dr. Marty Makary
Dr. Marty Makary says “most of the country is at herd”, May 2021
Dr. Marty Makary says “natural immunity” is better than vaccine-immunity, December 2021
Dr. Marty Makary calls the Omicron “nature’s vaccine” and “omi-cold”, January 2022
Dr. Monica Gandhi
Dr. Monica Gandhi discusses how to stop living in fear of COVID, October 2020
Dr. Monica Gandhi watches herself mock variants, “variants schmariants” in February 2021, before Delta and Omicron arrived
Dr. Monica Gandhi watches her poor predictions read back to her
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya claims children won’t spread COVID, April 2020
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya falsely says kids have zero risk and opposes vaccinating them before Delta and Omicron arrive, May 2021
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya says COVID is seasonal and we basically have herd immunity right before the Delta variant arrived, May 2021
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya says COVID prevents against reinfection and severe disease right before Omicron arrived, September 2021
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya says COVID is “much less deadly” for people under 70 before anyone was vaccinated, October 2020
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya says 1 flu death is larger than 133 COVID deaths for kids, November 2020
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya promises herd immunity in 2020, then creates his own definition of herd immunity in 2022 to avoid admitting error
Dr. Vinay Prasad
Dr. Vinay Prasad spreads fake statistics and worries more about vaccine-side effects than death from COVID, in February 2021, before there was a COVID vaccine
Dr. Vinay Prasad treats actual harms from COVID Delta variant with less seriousness than abnormal lab values in kids who feel fine after the vaccine

Open Letter II: President Levin, There Are Now 160 Million Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Have Censored We Want Them Infected Doctors
$160 million is a lot of money, especially when you consider its not just money. It’s lost dreams, careers, and discoveries.
Jonathan Howard on February 14, 2025
Link
Dear President Levin,
On October 4th 2024, the month before the most consequential election of our lifetime, you opened a conference titled Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past. Prior to this, I shared my thoughts with you in an article titled Don’t Censor Drs. Scott Atlas, John Ioannidis, Sunetra Gupta, Marty Makary, Monica Gandhi, Jay Bhattacharya, and Vinay Prasad. Amplify Their Voices. I wrote:
You are giving the introduction to the conference, meaning you are setting the tone and giving your personal stamp of approval to it. I am sure we both agree it’s important to have an accurate account of the pandemic and to reject cancel culture. In that spirit, I believe you are obligated to boost these doctors voices. The attendees and the general public deserve to know what they said and the policies they pushed.
I also provided you with multiple clips of these doctors saying absurd, obviously false things, though you didn’t care about any of that. None of their repeated errors of basic fact bothered you in the slightest.
In a follow-up article, I noted that instead of accurately reporting the speakers’ records, you covered up their misinformation and sanctimoniously scolded scientists who tried to warn you in books such as The Deadly Rise of Anti-Science. It’s worth sharing your speech again, especially in light of what’s happened since and that several of the speakers are cheering it on. You said:
Good morning and welcome to everyone. I appreciate the opportunity to be here.
Now, you might wonder: Why is Jon Levin opening this conference on pandemic policy? You might say, Jon is no public health expert. And I might say: Well, I did run a business school during the COVID pandemic, so I have some experience making pandemic policy decisions. They also say you learn most by making mistakes. So I think there are probably a thousand Stanford MBAs who are willing to argue that I’m basically a world expert.
However, that’s not why I’m here.
When I was invited to participate in this event a few months ago, it was with the understanding that the goal was to bring together people with different perspectives, engage in a day of discussion, and in that way, try to repair some of the rifts that opened during COVID.
That struck me as a valuable goal, and the sort of goal we should aim for at Stanford. So I agreed to give a few brief remarks to that effect.
What followed was disappointing. When I was invited, I asked around and indeed the organizers were talking to some well-known people with quite different views who were likely to speak. However, it was not so straightforward. Some invitees weren’t able to make it, or withdrew, or didn’t want to participate in an event with other speakers whose views and behavior they found attacking or abhorrent.
When an initial and partial agenda was posted, it was immediately perceived as one-sided, and as I’m sure you all noticed became the subject of op-eds and social media posts.
Ironically, instead of repairing rifts as intended and perhaps spurring fresh thinking, the process seemed to reopen old and existing divisions.
As an observer and as the leader of this university, I found the episode dispiriting, in a way that goes beyond the specifics of this particular event.
We have many issues today at Stanford, and on other campuses, where views are divided, and in some cases, like this one, where feelings are raw.
Yet I believe we need to make every effort to get people who disagree, even sharply, in dialogue with one another. I believe it’s essential for us to do that as members of the faculty and university leaders – not just because it’s a way to advance knowledge, but because we need to model that behavior if we want to expect it from our students. And in today’s world, we absolutely need to ask and expect our students to be able to engage with, listen to, and debate with people with whom they disagree. My view is that we need to err on the side of talking to one another.
So I hope today’s conference will come off in a way that involves just that – thoughtful and robust discussion across different perspectives. I hope it yields some important insights about future pandemic policy – we certainly need that. Perhaps it does even bridge a few divides among those in the room.
And I hope even more that all of you will join in the larger project of trying to make Stanford and other campuses forums for the type of robust and thoughtful discussion that is at the heart of universities when we’re at our best.
A lot has happened since then, and none of it will bridge divides, repair rifts, or advance knowledge. Donald Trump won, RFK Jr. will lead the HHS, and two of the conference speakers, Drs. Marty Makary and Jay Bhattacharya, are poised to lead the FDA and NIH. Shortly after Dr. Bhattacharya’s nomination, you said the following:
Jay Bhattacharya has been nominated to be the director of the National Institutes of Health, which is the most important funder of biomedical research in the country, in fact in the world. I think he’ll do an exceptional job in that role.
I know Dr. Bhattacharya’s track record very well, and nothing in it suggests he’ll do “exceptional job” or that he disapproves of anything that’s currently happening. But hopefully you are right, and Dr. Bhattacharya will ride to the rescue. Maybe 4 years from now we’ll marvel at the excellent state of science in the US. He’s our best hope, which says a lot about the situation we are in.
As you know, the headlines read Stanford to Lose $160 Million in NIH Funding Change and the courts seem powerless to stop it. Meanwhile, decent people are being purged from the NIH. This is what myself and many others were afraid of. I am not going to pretend I anticipated the specific threats to institutions like Stanford. That wasn’t my job. But the doctors I warned about and you applauded didn’t exactly hide their grievances, conspiracies, or intentions.
Fact check: No one suggested a devastating take down of scientists, just their “premises.”
While you obviously didn’t have the power to stop this on your own, you had a platform to sound the alarm. Instead, you chose to ignore and obscure the risk. You had the opportunity to hold important people accountable by doing nothing more than playing videos of them talking. You had the chance to present evidence that these speakers said false and dangerous things, and you passed it up. Incredible.
These videos are the reason I was never invited to speak at such a conference by the way. These doctors’ desire for “debate and discussion” didn’t include someone like me, who would have been willing to remind them of what they said.
I can’t help but wonder if authority figures had simply been honest about the existence of misinformation and its dangers if that could have moved the needle in a meaningful way. Sadly, we’ll never know. Like you, nearly all of them prioritized phony “thoughtful and robust discussion” over blunt, uncomfortable truths. They greeted misinformation with a shrug and yawn, and now we all face “many potential issues,” as you gently put it.
We both want funding to be restored to Stanford and everywhere else. Until then, I hope you’ll take a moment to read how I ended my second article:
When someone spreads dangerous, blatant misinformation, honest brokers call it out, even if the person spreading the misinformation has fancy credentials and can speak in scientific jargon… It doesn’t bode well for the future that leaders of major American institutions say naked emperors are wearing beautiful clothes.
I think my stark warning aged much better than your banal cliches about “different perspectives’. It turns out there’s a steep price to pay when “leaders” refuse to acknowledge that naked emperors are naked. $160 million is a lot of money, especially when you consider its not just money. It’s lost dreams, careers, and discoveries.
Worst of all, we are just getting started and these guys are in charge.


The President of Stanford Is Unsure Which Number is Larger, 9 or 133
It doesn’t bode well for the future that leaders of major American institutions say naked emperors are wearing beautiful clothes.
Jonathan Howard on October 11, 2024
Link
We need to make every effort to get people who disagree, even sharply, in dialogue with one another.
In a previous article, I wrote an open letter to the Stanford President, Jonathan Levin, regarding a conference at his university, Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past. As SBM readers know, this conference featured doctors who mostly didn’t treat COVID patients, but instead spread misinformation about it and tried to purposefully infect people with it. My letter predicted that the conference would be a giant exercise in deliberate amnesia. As such, I encouraged President Levin to reject censorship and simply play videos of the speakers from the first two years of the pandemic.
Sadly, President Levin embraced censorship. Instead of honestly informing the conference attendees about the speakers, he whitewashed their pandemic record with the following speech:
Good morning and welcome to everyone. I appreciate the opportunity to be here.
Now, you might wonder: Why is Jon Levin opening this conference on pandemic policy? You might say, Jon is no public health expert. And I might say: Well, I did run a business school during the COVID pandemic, so I have some experience making pandemic policy decisions. They also say you learn most by making mistakes. So I think there are probably a thousand Stanford MBAs who are willing to argue that I’m basically a world expert.
However, that’s not why I’m here.
When I was invited to participate in this event a few months ago, it was with the understanding that the goal was to bring together people with different perspectives, engage in a day of discussion, and in that way, try to repair some of the rifts that opened during COVID.
That struck me as a valuable goal, and the sort of goal we should aim for at Stanford. So I agreed to give a few brief remarks to that effect.
What followed was disappointing. When I was invited, I asked around and indeed the organizers were talking to some well-known people with quite different views who were likely to speak. However, it was not so straightforward. Some invitees weren’t able to make it, or withdrew, or didn’t want to participate in an event with other speakers whose views and behavior they found attacking or abhorrent.
When an initial and partial agenda was posted, it was immediately perceived as one-sided, and as I’m sure you all noticed became the subject of op-eds and social media posts.
Ironically, instead of repairing rifts as intended and perhaps spurring fresh thinking, the process seemed to reopen old and existing divisions.
As an observer and as the leader of this university, I found the episode dispiriting, in a way that goes beyond the specifics of this particular event.
We have many issues today at Stanford, and on other campuses, where views are divided, and in some cases, like this one, where feelings are raw.
Yet I believe we need to make every effort to get people who disagree, even sharply, in dialogue with one another. I believe it’s essential for us to do that as members of the faculty and university leaders – not just because it’s a way to advance knowledge, but because we need to model that behavior if we want to expect it from our students. And in today’s world, we absolutely need to ask and expect our students to be able to engage with, listen to, and debate with people with whom they disagree. My view is that we need to err on the side of talking to one another.
So I hope today’s conference will come off in a way that involves just that – thoughtful and robust discussion across different perspectives. I hope it yields some important insights about future pandemic policy – we certainly need that. Perhaps it does even bridge a few divides among those in the room.
And I hope even more that all of you will join in the larger project of trying to make Stanford and other campuses forums for the type of robust and thoughtful discussion that is at the heart of universities when we’re at our best.
I wouldn’t have been have afraid to mentioned that many of these doctors predicted COVID would kill less than 50,000 Americans and that the mass infection of unvaccinated youth would lead to herd immunity in 3-6 months.
We’ve had more flu deaths among children this year than COVID deaths.
With President Levin’s admonition to “listen to” people in mind, let’s revisit just one of the videos I presented to him. In this video, from November 2020 Dr. Jay Bhattacharya said “we’ve had more flu deaths among children this year than COVID deaths”.
The first reported COVID death in the US was on 2/28/2020. By the time Dr. Bhattacharya recorded that video, COVID had killed at least 133 children according to the American Academy of Pediatrics. During that same time frame, the flu killed 9 children. The next year, just 1 child died of the flu while COVID killed several hundred children. Currently, the CDC reports 1,935 COVID deaths and 438 flu deaths amongst children since the start of the pandemic, though obviously children should be vaccinated against both viruses.
Yet, according to President Levin, its fine for people to have “different views” on this topic. He feels “we need to make every effort to get people who disagree, even sharply, in dialogue with one another.” Sounding more like a college freshman than a university President, President Levin feels everything is a matter of opinion and what really matters is that no one get their feelings hurts. In President Levin’s telling, it’s not wrong for Dr. Bhattacharya to say that 9 is larger than 133, however it is wrong for people like me to say this isn’t a “different view” and it shouldn’t be a topic of “dialogue”.
I supposed I’ll be accused of silencing debate and discussion, but 133 is larger than 9. This wouldn’t have been controversial in 2019. When someone spreads dangerous, blatant misinformation, honest brokers call it out, even if the person spreading the misinformation has fancy credentials and can speak in scientific jargon. It’s not that hard. President Levin, however, expects us all to be open to the possibility that 9 is larger 133, and it doesn’t bode well for the future that leaders of major American institutions say naked emperors are wearing beautiful clothes.
Correction notice: An earlier version of this article misstated the number of flu deaths as 338, not 438. Thanks to the reader who spotted the error.

Canadian authorities warn chiropractors and naturopaths against making false COVID-19 claims
Regulators in British Columbia are investigating bogus COVID-19 preventatives and issuing public alerts warning chiropractors and naturopaths against advertising information that is not evidence-based. Other Canadian and U.S. authorities should follow suit to protect the public against pseudoscience.
Jann Bellamy on March 26, 2020
Link

From my last SBM post:
Chiropractors are falsely claiming that their spinal “adjustments” can protect people from coronavirus infection, as well as giving other dubious health advice on COVID-19. As they have with other bogus remedies, the media and government authorities should take note.
Thankfully, some have, at least in Canada.
Regulatory authorities in British Columbia are warning both chiropractors and naturopaths not to make false claims about the effectiveness of their therapies in the prevention and treatment of COVID-19. According to Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) news reports, the British Columbia College of Chiropractors and College of Naturopathic Physicians, which regulate these practitioners, are investigating several alleged violations of their policies against health claims that are not evidence-based.
This is in stark contrast to the U.S., where pseudoscience is legalized via state chiropractic and naturopathic practice acts. And, unlike the Canadian media, which has fairly regularly published exposés of charlatans (also here and here), the U.S. media has done nothing (that I can find) to warn the public about practitioners (as opposed to products) touting bogus treatments for COVID-19.
According to the CBC, several B.C. chiropractors are making just the sort of false claims American chiropractors are using in marketing their practices as a COVID-19 preventative. In a website post titled “boost your immune system with chiropractic care”, a B.C. chiropractic clinic suggested that spinal “adjustments”
have shown to improve immune function by correcting spinal misalignment or subluxations that cause neural dysfunction.
Other B.C. chiropractors posted on Facebook that, in the face of COVID-19, regular chiropractic “adjustments” should be part “standard hygiene practice”. Yet another B.C. chiropractor e-mailed patients promising “essential nutrition to protect yourself against coronavirus” with a supplement called “Immunoplex”, at $29.99 for 90 capsules.
However, quite unlike the U.S., the CBC reports that these clinics are facing investigation by College of Chiropractors of B.C. (CCBC). In a public notice, the CCBC said it
has become aware that some registrants are promoting treatment or supplements as a means to boost the immune system and may imply that this will prevent infection from the novel coronavirus (COVID-19). Any such claims made by registrants are inappropriate. When such claims are brought to the attention of the CCBC they will be forwarded immediately to the Inquiry Committee for investigation.
As stated in part 9.5 of the Professional Conduct Handbook, “The prevention and treatment of infectious disease is not within the scope of chiropractic practice.”
Patients with questions about infectious disease, such as COVID-19, should be advised to contact their medical doctor, nurse practitioner or local public health officials.
The warning is based on recent CCBC policy changes confronting “misleading and unsubstantiated claims” that “are contrary to acceptable evidence”. In 2017, the CCBC’s Professional Conduct Handbook was amended to prohibit chiropractors from advertising “health benefits of their services when there is not acceptable evidence that these benefits can be achieved”. In 2018, the CCBC approved an “Efficacy Claims” policy that, “due to the absence of acceptable evidence”, prohibited chiropractors from telling patients that chiropractic can be used to treat diseases or conditions like Alzheimer’s, cancer, diabetes, infections, infertility, or Tourette’s syndrome, or has any beneficial effect on childhood diseases or conditions like ADHD, autism, cerebral palsy, or other developmental or speech disorders. The CBCC made it clear that this list is not exhaustive and that “absent acceptable evidence” chiropractors are “not free to make claims about the effectiveness of chiropractic”.
The CCBC also warned chiropractors that
the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases is not within the scope of chiropractic practice [and] chiropractors must not provide any professional advice or counseling to patients in relation to vaccination issues. Patients with vaccination questions should be advised to contact their local public health officials.
At the time, all chiropractors were directed to review social media and other online materials and to remove offending information. If you don’t, the CCBC said in effect, we’ll do it for you.
Fortunately for American chiropractors, these rules don’t apply. Otherwise, as we’ve documented many times here on SBM, some of them would be out of business, or nearly so.
A naturopath in the regulatory crosshairs
According to the CBC, Allison Patton, a registered naturopath and Surrey, B.C. city councillor, is the subject of an investigation by the B.C. College of Naturopathic Physicians (a misleading name, considering naturopathic education and training), for advertising treatments, together costing more than $600,
including items like an “Immune Supportive Vitamin Boost” for $99 and a $325 “HiDose Ozone/UVBI IV” treatment, in which blood is drawn, injected with ozone and exposed to UV light before being transfused back into the body. Patton wrote that these treatments “could help strengthen our systems so we may stay as healthy as possible.”
Patton attempted to defend herself by telling the CBC that the Facebook post (since deleted) touting this pseudoscience was put up “in response to encouragement from her patients”, inadvertently affirming the disturbing conclusion that patients falsely believe naturopaths are capable of providing competent medical advice on infectious diseases.
The College previously suspended Patton from practice for three days and fined her $500 after she campaigned for public office representing herself as a “community physician” and referring to her “medical practice” without making it clear that she is a naturopath.
Despite its disciplinary action against Patton and its notice to the public (see below), it is worth noting that the College still tolerates plenty of pseudoscience. Quackery like applied kinesiology and iridology, for example, are specifically permitted. And when issuing a ban on further use of IV turmeric/curcumin, in response to a patient’s death after an IV injection of turmeric/curcumin performed by a California-licensed naturopath, current patients already receiving a course IV turmeric/curcumin treatments were excluded, in spite of the fact that there is no reliable evidence that these injections are safe and effective for any condition.
And lest you think Patton is an outlier, claims that patients can “boost their immune systems” (which you can’t do) with all sorts of nonsense (also here) like vitamin injections are common in naturopathy.
Patton’s “ozone therapy” is absolute quackery. Per FDA regulations, ozone is toxic, potentially dangerous, and has no known useful medical application. Yet, “ozone therapy” like that advertised by Patton is used by naturopaths for all sorts of maladies. According to ex-naturopath Britt Hermes,
Licensed naturopaths market ozone gas for just about anything. I have seen ozone advertised by naturopaths for chronic diseases, cancer treatment, Lyme disease, viral infections, chronic fatigue syndrome, autoimmune diseases, “detoxification,” and to “boost the immune system.”
Despite ozone’s uselessness as a treatment and potential dangers
licensed naturopaths in California were able to earn continuing education credits in a course that taught how to “confidently use ozone therapies in clinical practice with an understanding of the safety concerns.” The class was just two and a half hours and taught by a licensed naturopathic doctor who graduated from Bastyr University. The course is “approved by the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians and Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine.”
In addition to its investigation of Patton, the College issued a notice to the public saying that “any statements by naturopathic doctors about the prevention and/or treatment of COVID-19, beyond the information made available by the public health authorities, are inappropriate, potentially harmful, and likely to violate” its policies on false and misleading advertising. The notice added that any such statements “will be forwarded to the inquiry committee for investigation.”
Other Canadian provinces and the U.S. should follow British Columbia’s lead. For over 100 years, chiropractors and naturopaths have taken advantage of patients with their quack remedies, too often with the government’s blessing. Even a life-threatening global pandemic won’t quell their mendacity.

NewsGuard identifies social media “super-spreaders” of COVID-19 misinformation
NewsGuard has identified “super-spreaders” of COVID-19 misinformation on Facebook and Twitter, including Dr. Joseph Mercola, the NVIC, Rush Limbaugh, and Ty Bollinger.
Jann Bellamy on May 21, 2020
Link

NewsGuard, a company that evaluates and rates news and information websites, recently analyzed Facebook Pages and Twitter accounts to identify what it calls “super-spreaders” of COVID-19 misinformation, Rush Limbaugh, Dr. Joseph Mercola, and the National Vaccine Information Center among them. (There are separate lists of Facebook and Twitter super-spreaders in Europe.)
To qualify as a super-spreader, a Facebook Page or Twitter account must have published or shared “clearly and egregiously false content about the virus”, have more than 100,000 page “likes” or followers, respectively, and have been active on the date NewsGuard published its data — that is, neither Facebook nor Twitter had acted as of that date to take down the misinformation.
NewGuard describes this as an ongoing project, one among several designed to out COVID-19 misinformation, and notes that the listed Pages and accounts may not be the most frequent offenders or have the largest audiences – they simply met the criteria for this particular data set. NewsGuard’s larger message, it seems, is that, despite promises by Facebook and Twitter to effectively police their products for COVID-19 misinformation, whatever they are doing isn’t working, a point we’ll return to in a moment.
But first, the lists.
Among the 31 Facebook super-spreaders, whose combined accounts reach over 21 million followers, the top spot goes to Global Informers (which I’d never heard of) with almost 5 million “likes”. Described as an “English-language page for a business with an address in Turkey and managed from Pakistan”, created in 2017, Global Informers posted a link to PressTV, an Iranian propaganda outlet, with the false claim that the novel coronavirus was created in a lab as a bioweapon, and to RT, the Russian propaganda outlet, claiming, without substantiation, that the U.S. military started the pandemic.
(In this post, I will not provide a link to the misinformation itself, although you can find it on the NewsGuard website.)
Coming in at #2 is Rush Limbaugh (over 2.3 million Facebook Page “likes”), upon whom Donald Trump recently bestowed the Presidential Medal of Freedom, cited for his false claims that the novel coronavirus was created in a lab as a bioweapon and that it is similar to the common cold. Also speaking from the far right of the political spectrum, The Gateway Pundit (631,000 likes, but scoring 0 out of 100 on NewGuard’s rating scale) posted false claims that the drug hydroxychloroquine “has a 100% success rate in treating COVID-19”.
Not surprisingly, super-spreaders include websites shilling for unproven COVID-19 cure-alls we’ve covered here on SBM, like colloidal silver, Vitamin C, and the aforementioned hydroxychloroquine, as well promoting debunked claims that the virus is linked to 5-G technology and Bill Gates.
Two Facebook Pages affiliated with Ty Bollinger (whose promotion of cancer quackery has been called out in SBM posts), The Truth About Cancer (sadly, with almost 1.2 million “likes”) and Cancer Truth, are cited for their false claims that the virus was created in a lab as a bioweapon and that it is connected to 5G technology. NewsGuard’s evaluation of Bollinger’s The Truth About Cancer website correctly describes it as one that “has repeatedly promoted unproven and potentially dangerous cancer treatments.”
Another perennial SBM “favorite”, the National Vaccine Information Center (or, as we prefer, the National Vaccine Misinformation Center), accurately described as a publisher of “articles with false and unsubstantiated claims about vaccination”, is cited for its Facebook Page touting Vitamin C as prophylactic against COVID-19.
Twitter trust issues
NewsGuard identified 10 Twitter super-spreaders, who reach a combined following of over 3 million. The list again begins with someone I’ve never heard of: Femi Fani-Kayode, who takes the number 1 spot with almost a million Twitter followers. He’s identified as a former Nigerian politician (the Nigerian Prince, perhaps?) “who has repeatedly shared misinformation about vaccines and 5G technology”, including claims linking the latter to the pandemic.
Another unknown to me, David Icke, with over 310,000 followers, is a former British football player, “who has repeatedly promoted conspiracy theories, including the idea that the world is under the control of shape-shifting aliens”. He tweeted both that the coronavirus does not exist and, in what would seem to be a mutually-exclusive proposition, that 5G technology is connected to its spread.
Into this illustrious group who should fall but Dr. Joseph Mercola, “an osteopathic physician and alternative medicine advocate . . . who has published false claims about standard medical practices such as vaccinations”. (Not only that, he actually funds the anti-vaccination movement.) Mercola has made frequent appearances on SBM, going back at least to 2009, with the eponymous post 9 Reasons to Completely Ignore Joseph Mercola, all the way up to a few days ago, with a mention in a David Gorski post on COVID-19 and conspiracy theories.
Mercola, who has had frequent run-ins with regulatory authorities, made the Twitter super-spreaders list by “suggesting that high heat, including from a sauna or steam bath, can treat the coronavirus” and “promoting unproven herbal remedies for COVID-19” to his almost 300,000 followers.
NewsGuard uses these super-spreader lists as a cudgel to beat Facebook and Twitter over the head for not doing enough to remove this sort of misinformation from social media, a legitimate criticism, along with a bit of self-promotion.
Despite Facebook’s announced efforts to stop the spread of this type of misinformation, these pages continue to be allowed to use Facebook to publish blatant misinformation about COVID-19 — seemingly in violation of the platform’s content policies. In some cases . . . we found evidence of what appears to be “coordinated inauthentic behavior“, which violates Facebook’s policies. We also found that in a majority of the false posts we reviewed, Facebook did not provide any warning, fact-checking language, or links to more credible sources — despite the platform’s recent promises to do so. Of the posts we have identified so far publishing COVID-19 misinformation, 63% did not have any warning or fact-check link attached to the post . . .Whether or not a fact check was shown appeared to be random. Even for the posts that did have fact-checker warnings, those warnings would only have appeared after the hoax had been published. That lapse is exacerbated by Facebook’s policy of not providing information to its users that Facebook Pages like these have been known to publish misinformation or hoaxes in the past. This prior bad conduct is especially true of purveyors of COVID-19 hoaxes . . .
[Quotation reformatted for easier reading.]
NewsGuard aims similar criticisms at Twitter.
On the other hand,
NewsGuard has found that 80% of the 174 COVID-19 misinformation sites we have now identified had already been rated Red by NewsGuard for publishing misinformation in the past.
In other words, don’t trust Facebook or Twitter; check it out on NewsGuard.
“Rated Red” is a reference to NewsGuard’s rating system, which “employs a team of trained journalists and experienced editors to review and rate news and information websites based on nine journalistic criteria” assessing credibility and transparency and assigning each a red or green rating indicating its credibility. When NewsGuard is downloaded, these red and green (also, yellow for satire and grey for not rated) icons appear next to news links on search engines and social media feeds. Hovering over the icon will give you some information on the rating, while clicking on the rating will take you to a “Nutrition Label” for a more complete assessment of the site.
Altogether, NewsGuard has issued detailed ratings of more than 4,000 websites which it claims account for 95% of online engagement with the news. Specific to the pandemic, the company, in addition to its super-spreader lists, debunks the most popular COVID-19 myths, such as
Bill Gates plans to use COVID-19 to implement a mandatory vaccine program with microchips to surveil people.
It also created a Coronavirus Misinformation Tracking Center, including a list of websites known to be posting false coronavirus information. The list includes 56 domains of the NaturalNews.com Network, another SBM frequent flyer, as well as WestonAPrice.org, whose “appalling legacy” Harriet Hall discussed, and “natural health expert” Sayer Ji’s GreenMedInfo.com. Links are provided to “Nutrition Labels” for these sites. (I’ve provided them here as well.)
I downloaded NewsGuard (normally $2.95/month, but available free until July 1 “with no strings attached”), mainly because I wanted to support its efforts to combat misinformation on the internet, especially medical misinformation. According to a 2019 STAT News article written by a former health news reporter and now NewsGuard analyst,
Americans consume an unhealthy diet of health misinformation. Of the sites analyzed by NewsGuard, 11% provide misinformation about health; in other words, more than 1 in 10 news websites accessed by Americans includes bad information about health.
Of all the sites with red ratings, 37% publish false or unfounded health claims.
These sites accounted for more than 49 million engagements (shares, likes, comments, etc.) on social media in the past 90 days — more than major news websites such as NPR, Business Insider, or Forbes. In a recent search on Facebook for “vaccines and CDC,” several of the top-page results were from NewsGuard red-rated websites.
NewsGuard has come in handy when replying to emails from certain friends of the family who are spreading COVID-19 nonsense or just dubious political “news” in general. Even if you don’t subscribe, nosing around the website is interesting and, if you wish, you can suggest a site for review. I’m certainly going to.

Trump administration announces some COVID-19 tests can skip FDA review, providing new opportunities for dubious lab tests
The Trump administration unexpectedly announced that the FDA will no longer regulate some lab tests, including those for COVID-19. In addition to potentially allowing unreliable COVID tests on the market, the decision creates an opening for more bogus CAM tests.
Jann Bellamy on August 27, 2020
Link

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced last week that the FDA can no longer require some lab tests, including tests for COVID-19, to undergo FDA review prior to going on the market, a move that surprised many. The announcement covers only laboratory-developed tests (LDTs), that is, tests assembled and used within a single lab. This can include tests developed by academic and medical center labs as well as testing behemoths like Quest, Genova, and LabCorp. HHS did not exempt tests made by one company and sold to other labs or commercial firms.
HHS also rescinded all previously-issued FDA guidance documents and informal statements of policy concerning LDTs, taking the position that any FDA regulation can be legally accomplished only through the process of notice and rulemaking or new legislation passed by Congress, both of which can take years.
It is important to note that HHS’s decision covers all LDTs, not just those for COVID-19. As we’ll see later in this post, this not only has disturbing implications for testing during the pandemic, it is also a boon to quacks and fringe medical practitioners who were already exploiting the lax regulation of LDTs to fabricate dubious diagnoses and sell bogus treatments to patients.
Before HHS rescinded the FDA’s authority altogether, the agency’s regulation of LDTs came in fits and starts. By way of background, the FDA regulates in vitro diagnostic devices (IVDs), which analyze human samples (such as blood, saliva, tissue, and urine) as medical devices. However, in the past, it did not use this authority to regulate a particular type of IVD, the laboratory-developed test.
Instead, it focused on commercial test kits, which are broadly marketed to laboratories or directly to the public. These tests have to undergo the same pre-market approval process as other medical devices regulated by the FDA. In some cases, this means clinical studies demonstrating that the device is safe and effective for its intended use. An LDT could avoid this review, even when it’s used for the same purpose as an FDA-approved test. For example, there are both LDTs and FDA-approved tests for vitamin D. This has led to complaints of a double standard from labs facing the much stricter standard.
There is some oversight of labs that offer LDTs. A federal law, The Clinical Laboratories Improvement Act (CLIA), requires assessment of whether a lab is able to test according to instructions and detect what is intended to be detected, that is, the test’s analytical validity. However, a key element is missing in that evaluation: clinical validity. Does the test accurately diagnose or predict the risk of a particular clinical outcome?
For example, Great Plains Laboratory sells the “IgG Food MAP with XMAP® Technology”, an LDT, to health care practitioners. Because Great Plains is CLIA certified, this test, presumably, accurately “detects all food antibodies” as advertised and is therefore analytically valid. But do the test’s results give a clinician information to accurately diagnose or to predict risk? Not if the clinician is practicing science-based medicine.
Historically, LDTs were developed by hospitals, researchers, and academic medical centers for their own use. That is no longer true. In the past 15 years or so, there has been an explosion in the use of LDTs by commercial labs and biotechnology companies. A few years ago, the FDA estimated that there were about 11,000 LDTs offered by 2,000 laboratories, giving impetus to stricter oversight of the burgeoning LDT market.
In 2014, the FDA announced it would henceforth use its medical device regulatory authority to oversee LDTs. Then, in late 2016, the agency reversed course and announced it would not finalize its draft guidance on LDTs, although it maintained the agency retained the authority to regulate them (and took action against LDTs based on that authority just last year). There were efforts in Congress to come up with a regulatory solution via a new law, but those efforts have yet to bear fruit.
Prior to HHS’s pulling the FDA’s jurisdiction, labs wanting to market COVID-19 LDTs were required to get emergency use authorizations (EUAs) from the FDA. Under this procedure, labs could begin using self-validated LDTs as long as they submitted an EUA to the FDA within 15 days.
An FDA spokeswoman said in May that there were problems with some COVID-19 tests whose developers had applied for an EUA, indicating that the requirement was effective in weeding out bad tests. According to a New York Times report
“Some of the laboratories didn’t do their validation properly, making it impossible to tell if they had a good test or not” [the agency spokeswoman] said. “Others included data that suggested the test did not perform well, likely missing far more positive cases than authorized tests.”
Other laboratories, she added, had manufacturing problems such as contamination. And several made unsupported claims in their labels for home testing.
At the time HHS took action, over 170 labs had notified the FDA that they had validated their own LDTs and were awaiting FDA authorization. HHS’s decision mooted that necessity.
(Labs can still voluntarily seek an EUA, which will allow them to avail themselves of the liability protection afforded by the PREP Act. Labs bypassing FDA pre-market approval will forego this protection.)
Pros and cons
According to the Washington Post, the move
came as a surprise to many at the FDA and was a point of intense disagreement between HHS Secretary Alex Azar and FDA Commissioner Stephen Hahn . . . [who] vociferously opposed the change, arguing that the agency has the authority to regulate [LDTs] during a public health emergency like the current pandemic.
Public health experts told the Post that
the shift could result in unreliable coronavirus tests on the market, potentially worsening the testing crisis that has dogged the United States if more people get erroneous results. They argued the change is unlikely to solve current testing problems, which at this point are largely due to shortages of supplies such as swabs and chemical reagents.
Former FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, who served in the Trump Administration, was critical as well, telling Axios:
We’ll see a plethora of DTC [direct-to-consumer] Covid tests enter the market, where tests ship directly to consumers and are processed in a central lab operating outside FDA oversight.
Dr. Michael Carome, director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group told the New York Times:
Suppose you get a Covid test and you actually have the infection and it comes back negative, . . . You may believe you’re OK and that may leave you in your home, exposing family and friends to the virus when you should quarantine.
Critics include former FDA officials Peter Lurie and Alberto Gutierrez, the latter calling HHS’s action “Letting the Wild West be the Wild West”.
Others, however, supported the move as helping “new and more innovative tests to market more quickly”, charging that the FDA’s review “sharply slowed testing” at the beginning of the pandemic, according to the Washington Post.
“This is what we needed and asked for five months ago,” said Melissa Miller, director of the University of North Carolina Medical Center’s Clinical Molecular Microbiology Laboratory.
And:
The emergency use authorization “requirement meant well. But in my opinion was a disaster,” Michael Mina, an epidemiologist at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, wrote on Twitter.
FDA regulatory practitioners who had represented clients trying to obtain COVID-19 test EUAs were critical of the FDA as well, charging that
the lack of adequate testing at the outset of the pandemic can be directly linked to FDA’s controversial laboratory-developed test (LDT) policy . . .
Signaling the implications of the administration’s decision beyond the pandemic, Jeff Allen, president and chief executive of Friends of Cancer Research, told the Times
“I think it’s quite alarming” . . . He noted that a growing number of tests are in development to help determine whether cancer patients are responsive to certain drugs. “It’s really important for the performance of those tests to be assured.”
Mr. Allen and other critics also note that the new plan appears to leave the F.D.A. with no knowledge of what lab-developed tests are being devised, much less how they are performing.
It is unclear whether the FDA will now have the authority to remove an LDT lacking clinical validity from the market. According to the Washington Post,
Administration officials who defended the change said that the tests still will be subject to CMS regulation [that is, CLIA] and that the FDA will have the authority to take a bad test off the market.
But it is not clear to me whether they are referring only to the agency’s authority to take action under CLIA, which applies only to analytical validity. Or, are they saying the agency can still remove a test from the market for lack of clinical validity or other failings not covered by CLIA? Since HHS’s position is that the FDA lacks authority to regulate LDTs at all, and it quashed all existing FDA policy on the subject in the process, I don’t see how the FDA would have jurisdiction to take action. In this opinion, I am joined by patient safety activist Madres Tomes, CEO of Device Events and a former FDA manager, who said HHS’s action
removes the post-market oversight that is required for devices cleared or approved by the FDA. That oversight is critical in these times to ensure that providers are using the best tests available.
Dr. Gottlieb also noted that the FDA might not be able to “take needed enforcement actions against bad tests” because of HHS’s decision.
A boon for quacks?
However COVID testing might be affected, I worry that HHS’s taking the FDA out of the picture will embolden labs inventing dubious tests and marketing them to fringe practitioners and scientifically naïve consumers, a subject we have addressed regularly here on SBM. As a journal article criticizing dubious lab tests (covered in this SBM post) noted, there are now whole laboratories devoted to CAM testing. CAM practitioners, such as naturopaths, “promote and sell a wide range of tests, many of which are of dubious clinical significance”. Some “have little or no clinical utility and are widely discredited”. Results “are often accompanied by extensive clinical interpretations which may recommend, or be used to justify, unnecessary or harmful treatments”.
(As a warning to consumers, both Quackwatch and Naturopathic Diaries offer lists of these dubious tests. It is important to note that while all non-standard tests are LDTs, some are legitimate FDA-approved tests used for illegitimate purposes.)
Among these are direct-to-consumer “personalized” dietary recommendations based on DNA testing, which David Gorski aptly characterized as “modern astrology”. As well, autism charlatan Amy Yasko uses a “DNA Nutrigenomic Test” to make dietary supplement recommendations (conveniently available for purchase from her husband’s online store) to parents of autistic children. Although it had, regrettably, not taken action against either of these tests, the FDA has now lost all authority to do so. Labs know this and, I predict, will exploit this regulatory void.
In a 2015 post, pediatrician John Snyder wrote poignantly about how dubious tests exploit patients and complicate his medical practice:
What I find to be a common theme with these patients is that they and their parents are summarily taken advantage of by their alternative care providers when they are given a fictitious diagnosis and treated with a variety of useless potions, elixirs, and false hopes. Often, parents bring their children to these providers because they are frustrated by their child’s chronic complaints of fatigue, pain, or other somatic issues that have eluded a satisfactory diagnosis or treatment. Invariably, the diagnosis that has remained so elusive to me is quickly found and treated by these much more “holistic” and open-minded providers. In fact, I have never seen a consultation note from one of these providers indicating any uncertainty as to diagnosis or treatment regimen. Typically a large battery of expensive, inappropriate, and sometimes outright fraudulent lab tests is ordered, often from equally questionable laboratories. Again, there are invariably interesting findings prompting tailored and bizarre treatments. In typical red-flag sCAM fashion, some of these providers have their own supplement store, available online only to their patients, prominently displayed on their website. These providers are perceived as being more holistically informed about health and wellness then “conventional” doctors like myself, as if there are two distinct ways of treating illness and maintaining health…as if there is truly such a thing as alternative medicine.
It can be very difficult to manage patients who are being simultaneously “treated” by such providers. . .
[Emphasis added; links in original.]
As a possible solution, one lab trade group has called for a single regulatory standard covering all diagnostic testing, LDTs and otherwise. That sounds like a sensible solution, as long as it doesn’t include a get-out-of-jail-free card for quack tests. It may take this pandemic to finally spur Congressional action.

Is the FDA is Hiding “Evidence” the COVID Vaccine Killed Children?
It’s everything anti-vaxxers have been crowing about for decades.
Jonathan Howard on February 20, 2026
Link

Previously, I published 13 thoughts on Dr. Vinay Prasad’s “leaked” memo, which alleged the COVID vaccine killed at least 10 children. Dr. Prasad hasn’t produced a shred of evidence to support this claim, which if taken at face value, means the FDA is currently hiding the evidence while allowing a deadly product to remain on the market. It’s everything anti-vaxxers have been crowing about for decades. As such, I would like to share 6 more thoughts on this topic.
1. A Timeline Review.
    • July 2023: Although he was just a Fox News commentator at the time, Dr. Marty Makary said that “One thing RFK Jr. did is he would post true stories of children who died immediately after the vaccine. These were otherwise healthy children.” This was false. In reality, RFK stole pictures of unvaccinated children who died from other causes to sell his anti-vaccine propaganda publications.
    • September 2025: Dr. Marty Makary, now the FDA commissioner, claimed that the COVID vaccine killed children in an interview on CNN and promised a report would be released “in a few weeks.” No report is released.
    • September 2025: News organizations report that “Food and Drug Administration officials plan to present data they claim links the Covid vaccine to 25 deaths in children at what’s expected to be a closely watched vaccine advisory committee next week, a source confirmed to NBC News.” This presentation on 25 dead children does not occur.
    • November 2025: Stat News published an article titled How Two FDA Officials, Prasad and Høeg, Seized Vaccine Oversight that said:
She (Dr. Tracy Høeg ) pointed to a recent label change that required vaccine makers to warn of the risk of myocarditis for young men. And she displayed about two dozen reports of young people who had died after getting the vaccine, found in the agency’s adverse event database. While such reports do not prove causality, Høeg seemed convinced.
“Timing fits,” read a slide in her presentation, viewed by STAT. “Diagnosis fits. No better explanation found. Sufficient information provided.”
Cautiously, despite fears that they might face retribution, some of the scientists began to push back at Hoeg’s suggestion to effectively take the vaccine away from millions based on thin evidence. One participant described the mood in the room as “quiet horror.” “It was so far off base,” said the agency official, who was not authorized to speak publicly.
When it became clear that no career regulator would stand by the decision, and when vaccine center director Vinay Prasad said the move wasn’t necessary because he had already limited access to the shots, Høeg backed down.
    • November 2025: Dr. Vinay Prasad sent a “leaked” memo that said:
The team has performed an initial analysis of 96 deaths between 2021 and 2024, and concludes that no fewer than 10 are related. If anything, this represents conservative coding, where vaccines are exculpated rather than indicted in cases of ambiguity. The real number is higher.
This is a profound revelation. For the first time, the US FDA will acknowledge that COVID-19 vaccines have killed American children. Healthy young children who faced tremendously low risk of death were coerced, at the behest of the Biden administration, via school and work mandates, to receive a vaccine that could result in death. In many cases, such mandates were harmful. It is difficult to read cases where kids aged 7 to 16 may be dead as a result of covid vaccines.
    • December 2025: Dr. Makary made the media rounds to support Dr. Prasad’s claim and accuse his predecessors of a cover-up. “You’ve got to be honest,” he said, promising the evidence would soon be released.
    • December 2025: Dr. Jeremy Faust wrote an article titled FDA Vax Chief Jumped the Gun on Claims of Kid Deaths From COVID Shots that said:
According to a Dec. 5 post-marketing safety memo prepared by FDA scientists assigned to study the issue, agency scientists concluded that the actual number of deaths linked to COVID-19 vaccines in the U.S. is somewhere between zero and seven…
The final Dec. 5 memo, according to FDA employees with knowledge of the situation, states that under an established World Health Organization (WHO) framework, zero deaths were deemed “certain” to have been caused by COVID-19 vaccines, two were judged to be “probable/likely,” while five were “possible.”
Probable/likely cases are those determined to have been “unlikely” due to another cause. But for the “possible” category, an alternative explanation was determined to have been equally likely, meaning that the chance that vaccines were responsible for those deaths was 50-50 at most.
From this, it appears that the real number of deaths that FDA officials have linked to pediatric COVID-19 vaccines might be as low as zero — but probably rests in the range of two to five. This means that Prasad’s memo opened with a number of deaths that is 200% to 500% of the number that the scientists he assigned to study the problem reported.
    • January 2026: Endpoints news published an article titled FDA Report Claiming Covid Vaccine Link To Children’s Deaths Misses Deadline that said:
An end-of-the-year deadline the FDA set to share the results of an investigation into children’s deaths allegedly caused by the Covid-19 vaccine has come and gone.
The agency didn’t respond to a question about whether the release date has been delayed and if the report will be made public in the future. The FDA’s plan to release the report is entirely self-imposed, and it wasn’t clear why it hasn’t been made public yet.
The FDA has yet to release evidence a single child was killed by the COVID vaccine.
2. The FDA Has Taken Action Against Potentially Unsafe Treatments.
The current version of the FDA has shown it will not hesitate to take drastic actions based on potential safety signals. According to a recent article Regenxbio Gene Therapy Trials Suspended By Fda Over Safety Worries:
Regenxbio lost almost a fifth of its value Wednesday after the Food and Drug Administration placed a clinical hold on two of the company’s experimental gene therapies. Regulators acted after researchers found a case of brain cancer in a 5-year-old child who had received one of the treatments, RGX-111, four years earlier. The agency decided to extend the hold to the second therapy, RGX-121, because of similarities between the two and “shared risk between the clinical studies,” Regenxbio said Wednesday.
The FDA has not taken any similar actions against the COVID vaccine and in fact, in December 2025, Dr. Makary announced they rejected plans to place black box warning on them. He said:
When it comes to the black box warning, we have no plans to put that on the COVID vaccine. The safety and epidemiology center within the FDA did recommend that. It was a recommendation formally put out. But some of our scientists and leadership, like Dr. Vinay Prasad, have said it may be different today than it was in the first year of COVID when the shot came out. Because when you have those two doses three months apart, that’s when you see the side effects go way up like myocarditis in young people.
So according to Dr. Makary, Dr. Prasad has evidence that the COVID vaccine killed children, which would vindicate his years-long obsession with this topic, but when given power, he personally overruled apolitical scientists who wanted to put a warning label on it. That’s as plausible as his claim that We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April.
3. Prasad’s Sycophants Won’t Care.
Trust in the FDA has justifiably collapsed, and no one can make the affirmative case it’s thriving under its current leadership. There are perhaps 10 doctors, consumed by tribalism and groupthink, who will defend Dr. Prasad no matter what he does. After he “leaked” his memo they said:
    • Dr. John Mandrola: Surely the evidence will be forthcoming…I look forward to the details of the investigation. You should too.
    • Dr. Venk Murthy: To be clear, I believe there should a proper scientific report backing these conclusions related to vax myocarditis. I have faith that it will come in due course.
    • Dr. Anish Koka: Prasad is a prolific clinical researcher , a clinical practicing oncologist and an epidemiologist who quickly climbed the ladder of academia publishing papers about pharmaceutical industry gamesmanship and spoke about regulatory capture frequently. This made him very popular among academic lefties who enjoyed his broadsides against big pharma. This is why he ended up as a professor at the elite University of California San Francisco. The problems for Vinay started when he refused to blindly go along with his tribe on lockdowns and school closures because they appeared to violate basic common sense as well as principles that demand strong hard evidence before administering therapeutics with very real / expensive downsides!! Then when he took the same skepticism he always had towards overly broad therapies from the pharmaceutical industry to the push for the Covid vaccine for everyone regardless of their risk from the vaccine .. he really became an outcast. The truth is Prasad is very smart, very accomplished and way more logically consistent than his former tribe who can best be described as cultists. They hate him because he was the best of them and can’t be dismissed as some random eccentric crank on YouTube. America is very lucky to have him leading an agency that has lost its way.
Though these doctors had “faith” in Dr. Prasad, they’ve since moved on. Today, they aren’t the least bit bothered by his refusal to produce evidence of COVID vaccines fatalities, and without missing a beat, they are vigorously defending both his edict to unilaterally axe the Moderna flu vaccine and his subsequent reversal.  In their view, Dr. Prasad is right even when he contradicts Dr. Prasad.
An analogy can be made to Trump’s most devoted followers. Although it was his signature campaign promise in 2016, they were unbothered by his failure to get Mexico to pay for the wall. They correctly knew he was signaling his loyalty to them and his loathing of non-White immigrants. Similarly, Dr. Prasad’s sycophants knew not to take him literally. They recognized that he too was signaling support for their anti-vaxx views and that’s all that matters to them.
4. Prasad and Makary Have Also Moved On.
Drs. Prasad and Makary have also moved on. Neither of them speaks about children killed by the COVID vaccine today. They learned, correctly but unfortunately, that there’s no price to be paid for their absurd predictions and disinformation. In fact, that’s exactly how they obtained fame and power in the first place.
5. Some Quacks are Happy, Others Are Mad.
Quacks like Dr. Simone Gold, the founder of America’s Frontline Doctors who pled guilty attacking the Capitol on January 6th, have used Dr. Prasad’s claim to spread rank anti-vaccine disinformation. This shows the damage of his reckless “leadership.”
Other cranks, however, are furious that the FDA has yet to provide evidence of COVID vaccine fatalities. An article titled about Dr. Robert Malone, a member of the ACIP, titled Federal Vaccine Advisers Take Aim at Covid Shots said:
In an interview with The New York Times, Dr. Robert Malone, one of the panelists, claimed that the Food and Drug Administration was “hiding” data on the risks of Covid vaccination and had refused to share it despite multiple requests. “I am trying to force F.D.A. to come clean on that,” he said.
It pains me to say it, but based on the FDA’s public statements, Dr. Malone is entirely correct. It’s terrifying that Drs. Prasad and Makary are our best defense against his desire to take away COVID vaccines.
6. My Mind Was Open. It’s Not Anymore.
In my prior article on this topic, I bent over backwards to give Drs. Prasad and Makary the benefit of the doubt. Despite their deluge of bogus statistics and disinformation, I wrote:
But my mind is open. Maybe the FDA leaders will surprise me and do something they’ve not done the entire pandemic. If they produce high quality evidence, which is authored by reliable, apolitical FDA professionals and widely accepted by trusted experts, then I will accept it, exactly as I accepted the J&J vaccine killed some people. I will be critical of the FDA officials who missed this important signal. My loyalty is to a process, not an outcome.
Because my loyalty is still to a process, my mind is no longer open. I have seen how this FDA functions, and I don’t trust its leaders at all. In a recent interview about why he left that sinking ship, FDA legend Dr. Richard Pazdur said:
All of a sudden, I was given a press release with a quotation by myself written in it, and asked to just agree to it.
Perhaps the moment this article is published, the FDA will finally release its “evidence” the COVID vaccine killed 10 children. However, I will view it and everything the FDA leaders say with Dr. Pazdur’s warning in mind. So should you.

“Fauci Files” and Florida’s Grand Jury Investigations Fail to Deliver
Although multiple antivaccine investigations have failed to deliver any substantive evidence of alleged crimes, the latest antivax flops won’t flip anyone.
Mallory Harris on June 13, 2024
Link

In the past few months, multiple anti-vaccine investigations have unsurprisingly failed to produce any substantive evidence of alleged crimes warranting massive tribunals. In response, one might expect conspiracy theorists to come to the realization that maybe Covid-19 vaccines weren’t actually a mass depopulation plot and stop calling for public hangings. Unfortunately, I don’t see that happening anytime soon. To understand why, I unfortunately think we need to return to Hillary Clinton’s emails.
A bit of history
In the weeks leading up to the 2016 Presidential election, WikiLeaks began publishing emails from the hacked email account of John Podesta, Hillary Clinton’s campaign chair. To be sure, those emails shed light on some shady aspects of Clinton’s charitable foundation, her ties to big money, and her candidate’s operations. Yet for those who believe that she is a cold-blooded reptilian who orders executions of her political enemies and drinks children’s blood to maintain her youthful vibrancy, the emails at first appeared underwhelming.
A lot of the emails centered around boring logistics: Podesta making plans to pick up his wife’s prescriptions, giving cooking advice to his co-workers, meeting up with his brother for dinner, and getting invited to fundraisers. The latter two emails happened to involve pizza, including mention of the now-infamous restaurant “Comet Ping Pong Pizza.” And so the Pizzagate conspiracy theory was born. In brief, adherents believed that every mention of cheese pizza in the emails was code for child pornography and Comet Ping Pong Pizza was actually hosting Satantic ritual abuse of children in its basement. This all, of course, culminated in an armed man showing up at the pizzeria to liberate the kids from the basement. But there was no abuse, no pornography, and no imprisoned kids; in fact, there wasn’t even a basement.
All this is to say that conspiracy communities do not necessarily need evidence for their claims. In fact, the very lack of evidence can often be the most galvanizing. They thrive on the idea of secret knowledge and investigations, but are not necessarily interested in what the resulting documents actually look like. And lately, leaders of anti-vaccine and Covid conspiracy theory movements have really been failing to deliver results, yet their followers don’t seem to care that their bold promises of future revelations keep falling flat.
The “Fauci Files”
One of my favorite examples in this genre was the release of the “Fauci Files,” a subplot of the larger “Twitter Files” manufactured news cycle. For those unaware, the Twitter Files consisted of Elon Musk giving a group of people access to internal documents on Twitter prior to his purchase of the company, which they then proceeded to misread and misrepresent in long threads. In December of 2022, Musk began to promote the forthcoming release of an installment focused on former NIAID Director Anthony Fauci.
The project ran into a few hiccups, with Musk stating a month later that it had to be delayed because a “key researcher can only travel to Twitter in early Feb.” But surely it would be worth the wait. After all, Musk at the time implied that legal action should be pursued against Dr. Fauci. A case (Murthy v. Missouri) was also working itself up to the Supreme Court alleging that the government, including Dr. Fauci specifically, was running a massive censorship regime to oppress oppositional voices on Twitter. So, to reiterate, the stakes were extremely high to give us something good.
Here’s what “key researcher” Paul Thacker finally came up with in April, four months and two trips to Twitter later:
The Epoch Times took this as evidence that Dr. Fauci lied under oath, quoting Great Barrington Declaration co-author and Murthy v. Missouri plaintiff Martin Kulldorff who called this finding “explosive.” As someone who has helped run social media accounts for several organizations and individuals, I found this quite amusing. Please don’t tell them about all of the times that Nancy Pelosi has texted me to ask for a donation while she was simultaneously on the floor of the House giving a speech. Or the time that Herman Cain posted a tweet downplaying the dangers of COVID-19 12 days after he died of it. And, even if Dr. Fauci did help draft a couple of tweets, pointing that out does nothing to establish his alleged involvement in a mass social media censorship campaign (again, a key claim in a case that was recently heard by the United States Supreme Court).
It is unclear to me why Thacker needed to travel to Twitter to find this publicly available information, although maybe he needed multiple visits to uncover this one email from a former Twitter employee where she says something positive about Dr. Fauci.
Incidentally, Musk stated a full week prior to the Fauci Files’ release that it was time to “move on” from the Twitter Files as “there’s not a lot…that’s left,” so users like @pepedownunder and @TruthWarrior_77 may be excused for missing the Fauci Files’ publication and inquiring about them a full nine months after their release.
Florida Man
And it’s not just Musk’s coterie overhyping an imminent epic reveal of public health malfeasance and then (much more quietly) coming back months or years later with nothing to show for it. Around the same time that Musk was teasing the Fauci Files, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis announced that he was calling for a grand jury to “investigate crimes and wrongdoing committed against Floridians related to the COVID-19 vaccine.”
Fourteen months later, the Grand Jury released its first report, a 33-page document that includes “vaccine” and related words exactly 29 times:
    • 21 times in the introduction, to explain the charge of the grand jury and how it examined whether there was “criminal activity or wrongdoing” with respect to COVID-19 vaccines
    • 2 times to explain assumptions underlying mathematical SIR models of disease transmission and note that COVID-19 vaccines may be assumed to both reduce susceptibility and risk of severe disease
    • 2 times to highlight how some nonpharmaceutical interventions disrupted administration of international vaccination programs against diseases like measles
    • 3 times to discuss the CDC’s changing guidelines about masking (in response to new data about infection and transmission amongst vaccinated people as the delta variant began to spread)
    • 1 time in the conclusion, to note that “[t]here is a case to be made that…lockdowns enabled others in high-risk groups to ‘bridge the gap’ until 2021 when they had access to vaccines.” Notably, this claim (which the report suggests the Grand Jury may follow up on at a later date) would mean that both lockdowns and vaccines helped to save lives in Florida.
Everything else in this report is pointedly not about vaccines: It rehashes old grievances about shelter-in-place orders, masks, and other nonpharmaceutical interventions. Even those who agree with the gist of this report (that COVID-19 wasn’t as deadly as they said and that the measures implemented to prevent its spread were not worth their costs) should agree that it doesn’t remotely address the particular concerns that Governor DeSantis seemed to think it would. To be fair, the grand jury is expected to make multiple reports and has requested an extension through the end of this year to complete their investigation, so they may just be waiting on those to get to the alleged mass criminal conspiracy.
But it does seem worth comparing this pretty weak showing to Florida grand jury reports on, for example, the Parkland shooting (which called for the removal of four members of Broward County school board members) or federal immigration policies (which concluded that crimes were being “enabled by government agencies”). Even the 2006 grand jury investigation into Jeffrey Epstein, which culminated in a plea deal that has been panned as “completely unprecedented” in its leniency, led to a prostitution charge.
Much ado about nothing
In this case, we’re talking about the (purported) crime of the century, ranging from fraud that killed millions to the most egregious case of governmental censorship in US history. One of the richest men in the world gave internal company documents to his idea of a top investigative journalist and the Governor of one of the most populous states deployed state resources — all to get to the bottom of this. And there is still nothing.
As someone who always believed these theories were a load of hogwash, I may be biased, but I find the anti-climactic outcomes of these investigations to be pretty compelling evidence that there is no there there. Still, the absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence. I think there are two other explanations that adherents to anti-vaccine conspiracy theories are likely to gravitate toward.
The first is that the grand jury and Fauci Files flopped because the folks involved didn’t do a good enough job. In fact, David Gorski of Science-Based Medicine has pointed out that Musk’s hand-picked journalist has a history of errors. At least one Covid conspiracy theorist, Trump HHS science advisor Paul Alexander, was thinking along these lines when he republished a Substack post calling the Florida grand jury “a grift, a clown show, which was set to fundraise off ‘health freedom’ sentiment for [Desantis’] political run.” (Alexander added his own commentary involving something about “moma [sic] breast milk teat suckers”). So here is one thing that Alexander and I agree on: The influencers in the Covid conspiracy movement do not deserve your money and do not have your best interests at heart. But I also think that won’t be the takeaway for their biggest fans.
The other option is one that can keep the conspiracy alive and keep powering its influencers: Maybe the people behind these crimes are just too good at covering everything up. After all, the grand jury report notes that the CDC, FDA, and US Army all declined to participate in the proceedings. So we need to keep digging, and we need you to keep doing your part at home. Members of the anti-vaccine community can stay engaged and connected with one another as they trade theories to fill in the (numerous) evidentiary gaps.
Keeping it real
Like the doomsday cult members who double down when the clock hits 12:01 and the flood is nowhere to be seen, true believers will only become more convinced when combing over Thacker’s thread or skimming the findings out of Florida, if they even saw those. Even so, it’s important that we follow up as anti-vaccine investigations continue to fall apart — especially when they were publicized prior to any findings being released by mainstream news outlets, with little to no coverage of their laughably null and irrelevant conclusions. It’s also important to remain clear-eyed that the latest flops from the anti-vaccine movement likely will not change many minds. In fact, they may just strengthen existing convictions that were never based on evidence in the first place.

Government watchdog to investigate politicization of CDC and FDA during COVID-19 pandemic
Based on numerous reports of White House interference, a government watchdog will investigate politicization of the CDC’s and FDA’s actions during the coronavirus pandemic.
Jann Bellamy on October 22, 2020
Link

The Government Accountability Office (GAO) announced last week that it would review whether the CDC’s and FDA’s scientific integrity and communications policies have been violated, as well as whether those policies are being properly implemented to assure scientific integrity throughout the agencies. The review is being conducted at the request of several U.S. Senators “in light of public reports that the Trump Administration has improperly exerted political influence on the CDC and FDA” since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.
As Senators Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), Gary Peters (D-Mich), and Patty Murray (D-WA), told the GAO in their request:
The CDC’s and FDA’s independence as scientific agencies is crucial to safeguarding the public health and saving lives. These agencies must be able to develop, review, and disseminate public health data, guidelines, and other information that are based on science, facts, and medical principles – not the political imperatives and moods of a president and his advisors.
Yet, they charge that
the Trump Administration has reportedly pressured the CDC and FDA throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, repeatedly applying political pressure and imposing orders on career scientists that undermine the agencies’ credibility and independence.
Citing reports from major media organizations, agency announcements, and Mr. Trump’s Twitter account, the Senators’ letter catalogued numerous instances of putative political interference in CDC and FDA decision-making, interference they say “seeds confusion, erodes public confidence, and diminishes the agencies’ credibility”. (SBM’s David Gorski lamented this erosion of trust in a recent post, “In the age of COVID-19 pandemic, can we trust the CDC and FDA anymore?“, citing a number of the same public reports relied upon by the Senators in their request to the GAO.)
Offenses against scientific integrity on the Senators’ list include:
    • The White House’s allegedly overruling CDC officials who wanted to recommend, in March, that elderly and physically fragile people not fly on commercial airlines due to the coronavirus.
    • Reported interference, in April, by Vice President Pence, and again by the White House this month, in an extension of the CDC’s “No Sail” order prohibiting cruise ship voyages, despite evidence that cruise ships have been a major source of outbreaks.
    • The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS, of which the CDC and FDA are a part) political appointees’ reported “significant efforts to edit, water down, and caveat CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Reports”.
    • In May, the White House’s blocking the publication of the CDC’s “Opening Up America Again Framework”, eventually published only after the White House required substantive changes.
    • HHS officials accusing the CDC of “undermining the President” when it released information on pregnant women and COVID-19.
    • HHS political appointees excoriating a CDC official for remarks she made about the U.S. needing to take its virus response seriously, accusing her of being “duplicitous” and undermining the President.
    • In July, the White House ordering the CDC to stop collecting certain COVID-19 data, “instead filtering the data through a third-party contractor at HHS” resulting in “significant issues with the quality, completeness, and transparency of data”. [Although it was not cited in the list, NPR has reported on apparent irregularities in HHS’s awarding the contract and the contractor’s financial connections to Mr. Trump.]
    • Mr. Trump and Mr. Pence exerting “considerable public pressure on the CDC to revise its guidelines for schools”. This resulted in new guidance, which the White House reviewed and substantially edited.
    • The appearance of “highly-criticized” testing recommendations for asymptomatic patients (since reversed) on the CDC website, not written by CDC scientists but dropped there by HHS, “flouting the agency’s strict scientific review process” and containing “elementary errors”.
    • The FDA’s Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for hydroxychloroquine (since revoked), a drug highly touted by Mr. Trump for COVID-19 but widely criticized for lack of quality evidence.
    • In August, Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Dr. Anthony Fauci, and National Institutes of Health head Dr. Francis Collins reportedly voiced concerns that data did not support the FDA’s EUA for convalescent plasma and the authorization was put on hold. Mr. Trump called Dr. Collins and told him to “get it done by Friday” and suggested to reporters that the FDA wanted to limit its use until after the election. On August 23, the FDA issued an EUA for convalescent plasma.
    • HHS Secretary Alex Azar allegedly overruling the FDA when he revoked the agency’s ability to regulate lab-developed diagnostic tests, including COVID-19 tests.
    • In August, Mr. Trump made a “clearly spurious” claim that the “deep state” at the FDA is delaying potential COVID-19 treatments and vaccines until after the election.
    • After remarks by the lead career official in charge of FDA vaccine review suggested that the FDA’s forthcoming guidance will set a higher bar for a vaccine EUA, Mr. Trump said it “sounds like a political move” and that the White House “may or may not” approve the guidance. After a news report that the White House had actually blocked the guidance, the Administration reversed course.
The review is grounded in the GAO’s jurisdiction to investigate and evaluate, at the request of Congress, federal programs and activities, and provide “information, analyses, options, recommendations, and other assistance to help the Congress make effective policy, funding, and oversight decisions”. The GAO has already issued three reports on the federal government’s response to the pandemic, the most recent of which criticizes the CDC on an issue raised by the Senators’ letter — guidance on reopening schools:
Portions of CDC’s guidance on reopening K-12 schools are inconsistent, and some federal guidance appears misaligned with CDC’s risk-based approach on school operating status. CDC should ensure that its federal guidance on reassessing schools’ operating status is cogent, clear, and internally consistent.
In this case, authority for the GAO review is grounded in the CDC’s and FDA’s policies on scientific integrity and the premise that those policies are being violated by the Trump Administration. According to the request, the CDC’s “Guidance on Scientific Integrity” requires that CDC employees “affirm a commitment to ensure that research and services are based on sound science, meet real public needs, and help achieve public health goals” and states that the “CDC has a responsibility to conduct the best science and is committed to disseminating scientific findings and results without being influenced by policy or political issues”. Likewise, according to the FDA’s policy on scientific integrity, the agency promotes an environment where “scientific decisions are protected from political influence”. The FDA policy requires “shielding the agency’s science and its scientific staff from political influence” and “maintaining a firm commitment to science-based, data-driven decision-making” and is “committed to a culture of openness with the media and public that values the free exchange of ideas, data and information”.
The GAO is asked to audit the implementation of these policies and “understand the extent of any undue political influence at the CDC and FDA”, an issue which raises “a larger concern about independence of CDC, FDA, and other public health agencies”. It is also asked to identify “current structures . . . in place at these agencies to allow them to independently carry out their missions” and recommend “additional structures or steps . . . to enhance the agencies’ abilities to independently carry out their missions, free from political influence”.
The review will not happen quickly. According to the GAO, “the required skills will be available to initiate an engagement in about three months”.
Interestingly, in a poll just out, 36% of respondents said they trusted health officials’ COVID-19 information at agencies such as the CDC and FDA, with 26% saying the same about their state or local governments. Sixteen percent trusted information from Mr. Trump “a great deal or quite a bit”.
Meanwhile, the revelations continue. A day before the GAO’s letter agreeing to the review, Pro Publica published an extensive exposé of the CDC’s failures during the coronavirus pandemic headlined “Inside the Fall of the CDC“. It reports the White House’s rejection of the CDC’s guidance on reopening houses of worship, including elimination of a warning about the dangers of singing. Part of the Administration’s meddling included a call from the Vice President to a CDC infectious disease expert, telling him that the White House’s edits to the guidance were not optional and the CDC’s failure to use them was “insubordinate”.
On October 14, Science ran its own in-depth news report on plummeting confidence in the CDC, titled “The inside story of how Trump’s COVID-19 coordinator [Dr. Deborah Birx] undermined the world’s top health agency”, including the charge from CDC insiders that Dr. Birx “flouted science and undermined the agency to placate the president”. As well, CDC head Dr. Robert Redfield “has quietly complied with many of the administration’s demands”.
According to Science, many CDC execs and professionals plan to leave the agency if Trump is re-elected as public confidence in the agency has eroded.
In 2015, CDC was viewed favorably by 70% of the public, the highest for any agency measured. But in March, the percentage of the public that held a “great deal” of trust in CDC dropped to 46%. In September, it was only 19%.
Also last week, The Wall Street Journal [paywall] and Axios [free] reported that an open letter from current and former CDC Epidemic Intelligence Officers, first published in May, topped 1,000 signatures. The letter begins:
We hereby express our concern about the ominous politicization and silencing of the nation’s health protection agency during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. In previous public health crises, CDC provided the best available information and straightforward recommendations directly to the public. It was widely respected for effectively synthesizing and applying scientific evidence from epidemiologists and biomedical researchers at CDC and worldwide. Its historic credibility was based on incomparable expertise and 70+ years of institutional memory. That focus and organization is hardly recognizable today.
Saying the “absence of national leadership on COVID-19 is unprecedented and dangerous”, the signatories “urgently call upon the American people to demand and our nation’s leaders to allow CDC to resume its indispensable role”.
All of this was before Mr. Trump, this week, called Dr. Fauci a “disaster”, claiming that people were “tired” of hearing about the virus from Fauci and “these idiots, all these idiots who got it wrong” and complaining that Fauci “loves being on television” and has made “a lot of bad calls”.
A GAO investigation into improper political influence at two of the nation’s top scientific agencies may be the least of Mr. Trump’s worries, but hopefully it will result in new safeguards against politicians meddling in science, part of a larger effort to mend the guardrails of democracy this Administration has all too easily blown through.

Note to Readers: If you are eager to learn more about the government’s COVID-19 mismanagement you can follow along on American Oversight’s COVID-19 Oversight Hub.

FDA and FTC issue more warning letters citing products and services making illegal COVID claims
The FDA and FTC have issued hundreds of warnings to companies selling products and services claiming, without adequate evidence, that they can prevent or treat COVID-19, but the possibility of government action doesn’t seem to be a deterrence.
Jann Bellamy on November 19, 2020
Link

Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, the FDA and FTC have sent several hundred warning letters to companies and individuals allegedly selling products and services making misleading, deceptive, or scientifically unsupported claims about their ability to prevent, mitigate, or treat COVID-19, a topic we’ve covered before here on SBM. Apparently undeterred by the possibility of government action, advertising and selling of COVID-19 nostrums continues apace, aided and abetted in some cases by laws that invite such nefarious activities via lax regulation. Today we take a look at the government’s latest efforts to pursue COVID scofflaws.
(The FDA has jurisdiction over false and misleading labels and labeling of consumer products such as drugs, dietary supplements, and cosmetics. The FTC has jurisdiction over unfair and deceptive advertising in all its forms. The regulatory authority overlaps, hence warning letters are sometimes issued jointly. You can report a product to the FDA here and a product or service to the FTC here.)
Herbs, supplements, and other “natural” products
Dietary supplements, including herbal remedies, are only lightly regulated by the FDA, creating a fertile field for unsupported claims. As easy at this is to pull off, some marketers apparently have not learned the trick of sticking to claims that their products “boost the immune system“, thereby only implying that they are effective against COVID-19, while avoiding direct statements that they can prevent or treat it. Claiming the latter invites a warning letter from the FDA by making the product, in the eyes of the law, an unapproved new drug.
Per the FTC, a company cannot advertise that a product can prevent, treat, or cure a disease unless it has competent and reliable scientific evidence, including, when appropriate, well-controlled human clinical studies, substantiating that the claims are true at the time they are made.
Only a handful of drugs have been shown to be effective in treating COVID-19 and, for now, there is no approved preventative on the market. This means that sending warning letters to marketers touting preventatives and cures is somewhat like shooting the proverbial fish in a barrel.
For example, Prairie Dawn Herbs, a Colorado firm, stepped over the line by recommending its herbal formulas “to help protect the immune system and combat symptoms of . . . covid . . .”, including Echinacea tincture, Echinacea glycerite, thieves oil, eucalyptus oil, mentholated salve, skin heal salve, and chest tea. And, while the Chinese government is busy promoting TCM for COVID-19, the U.S. government is not impressed. Thus, references to the fact that Chinese hospitals are using herbs to treat COVID is, fortunately, not dispositive of their effectiveness in the eyes of the FDA or FTC. This claim, among others, earned Griffo Botanicals a warning letter:
Did you know that hospitals in HuBei and WuHan published Chinese herbal guidelines for treatment of COVID-19 in its various stages and presentations? Griffo Botanicals has produced 4 new COVID formulas based on these guidelines. The intention of these formulas is to ease symptoms, while bringing the body back into balance. They promote recovery, improving both mild and moderate symptoms while reducing the inflammatory load on the lungs and other organs that occur during Covid-19 infection. . . .
Perhaps due to the gravity of COVID-19, the feds are targeting even small operators. The Tonic Therapeutic Herb Shop & Elixir Bar, of Shepherdstown, West Virginia, got a warning letter referencing an article that could be a tutorial on how to make illegal claims:
SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19): HERBAL PROTOCOLS FOR THE TREATMENT OF INFECTION AND POST-CORONAVIRUS SYNDROME
The article recommends a plethora of unproven remedies to “help prevent infection and reduce the severity of symptoms”, including Japanese honeysuckle, Chinese skullcap, elderberry, licorice, Cordyceps (“also known as caterpillar fungus”), Astragalus, hyssop, thyme, elder flower, peppermint, red clover, Calendula, violet, nettle, mullein, chickweed, and medicinal mushrooms.
Aside from the violations of federal law, it seems clear that this collective of herbalists is treating disease, which, to my understanding, is limited to licensed health care professionals like physicians and nurse practitioners under West Virginia law. I could not find out whether West Virginia licenses the practice of herbalism or that the state has a so-called “health freedom” law.
A warning letter to Beephothocary, another small company, demanded they stop claiming its propolis, a substance produced by bees to build their hives, is an effective antiviral against COVID.
As you might imagine, the cure-all du jour, CBD, is also being monetized as a COVID treatment. A Las Vegas outfit called Senior Living, LLC, and its website, blueribbonhemp.com, got a warning letter for claims that CBD and NAC (n-acetyl cysteine) “Fight Viral Infections like Coronavirus”. Likewise, an Arizona company named (with the apparent intent of exploiting America’s affinity for the military) For Out Vets LLC, doing business as Patriot Supreme, was warned against promoting CBD as a treatment for lung inflammation caused by COVID.
Another au courant medical marvel, salt therapy, was the subject of a warning letter to a California firm, Oxford Medical Instruments, for claiming its salt inhaler, which “involves the process of breathing salty air through high-quality salt pipes that aids someone to reduce respiratory disorders especially during this era of coronavirus” can “ensure your respiratory tract is in the best condition to effectively fight the coronavirus pandemic and keep you healthy from other respiratory complications like pneumonia”.
Previous government warnings about claiming silver-containing products can effectively treat COVID notwithstanding, companies continue to promote these nostrums. Michigan company Spartan Enterprises (doing business as Watershed Wellness Center) received a warning letter for saying:
Today, Planes are arriving from China carrying one of the most deadly viruses every known, the Coronavirus. The best way to protect yourself against this is with liquid angstrom silver.
And, even more expansively:
Will silver, this kind of silver, kill that virus [i.e., the coronavirus]? Well yes! Silver will kill that virus. It will kill any virus, any bacteria, yeast, mold, and fungus, nothing can survive it. So, this means when you take this, the virus will be killed, well it might kill some of it.
A company called Silveryguy, which advertises on Amazon, was warned against hawking atomized colloidal silver, which “can be inhaled deep into the lungs, the action of silver colloids getting on the lining of your lungs may prove to inhibit the virus from replicating too quickly” and “may reduce your body’s overreaction to the virus”. A Georgia-based outfit, Peterson Research Laboratories, received a warning letter for making the following claim, which nicely displays the sort of sciency-sounding nonsense beloved by supplement pushers, plus a pitch to fringe practitioners who want to profit off selling COVID nostrums to their patients:
Simple Silver (Colloidal Silver) with ionic solubility technology is a dietary supplement that has ionic solubility that may supports the Immune system ability to fight off and kill nasty pathogens that can cause illnesses inside and outside the body such as: CORONAVIRUS (COVID-19) . . . Ideal for dedicated health care professionals working with Covid-19 patients . . .
Failure to adequately address similar unlawful claims following warnings has resulted in the FDA seeking injunctive and other relief in court. Most recently, at the request of the FDA, the U.S. Department of Justice filed a civil complaint for permanent injunction in a New Jersey district court against Natural Solutions and individual defendants for selling a “nano silver product” that defendants claim can treat or cure COVID-19.
Finally, the aptly-named Predator Nutrition, a British firm, was told to stop making COVID-related claims for its products, including salidroside, a bioactive component of the plant Rhodiola rosea, the “potential” of which was couched in life-saving terms:
. . . in ameliorating sepsis induced lung injury [footnote omitted], and protection against pulmonary fibrosis. [footnotes omitted] Attacking the lungs and causing pulmonary fibrosis is one of the most common symptoms seen in those for whom Covid-19 turns severe or fatal.
Pharmaceuticals
“Natural” products aren’t the only ones in trouble for false COVID marketing. The FDA recently went after companies selling pharmaceuticals as unproven COVID remedies.
According to the FDA, sales reps for Nephron Pharmaceuticals Corporation sent emails promoting Budesonide, an FDA-approved drug for the treatment of asthma in children, as a treatment for symptoms associated with COVID. In one email quoted by the FDA, a sales rep said that:
Over the last few weeks, doctors and researchers have touted the benefits of using Budesonide as a treatment for symptoms associated with COVID-19. One physician, who went viral this month, called Budesonide a “silver bullet”.
Two internet pharmacies, Medication-house.com (China) and Extrapharma.com (Russia), received warning letters in September regarding their sale of Arbidol, an antiviral used in some countries for influenza treatment but not FDA-approved in the U.S. because no application for approval has ever been filed. Both websites claim that Arbidol is effective in preventing COVID.
Health clinics
“Wellness” practitioners received FTC warning letters as well. The FTC cited New York City’s Tribeca Wellness Collective for promoting:
Thymosin Alpha 1 peptide therapy, Endolaser IV therapy, high dose vitamin C IV therapy, ozone IV therapy, vitamin B12 injections, and supplements. [references added]
I was intrigued by the “Endolaser IV therapy”. An endolaser is a medical device used in eye surgery, so I couldn’t imagine what an IV Endolser was. Here’s an “explanation” from Tribeca Wellness:
So the reason that we use the IV Endolaser is because specifically the red light helps to support your body’s natural immune system. So it supports natural killer cells, T helper cells, and T suppressor cells, which are all cells that your immune system uses to keep you healthy, recognize foreign invaders, as well as kill them, and alert your body that you’re being invaded, and the appropriate response to that.
I must confess I still have no idea how this works. In any event, according to the FTC, there is no reliable scientific evidence it works for COVID.
Park Avenue Skin Solutions, whose address is one floor above Tribeca Wellness (and is therefore, in fact, not on Park Ave.) was cited in an FTC warning letter for similar claims.
But for sheer volume of unsubstantiated COVID claims catalogued in an FTC warning letter, I have not found anything to beat MD Beauty Labs in West Palm Beach, Florida. MD Beauty Labs advises that
It only makes sense that we should boost our immune system so that we can improve our chances to fight off disease.
How?
In addition to Thymosin Alpha-1 there are several other IV Therapies and Supplements that are beneficial. [They are] IV Vitamin C Therapy – Helps the immune system and possibly inhibit viral replication; IV Glutathione Therapy – Powerful Antioxidant; IV Colloidal Silver Therapy – Antimicrobial and Immune Boost; AHCC- Japanese Medicinal Mushroom Extract – Supports Immune Function; Vitamin D3 – Helpful to enhance immune function; Path DS – Provides a powerful combination of herbs to naturally support a healthy immune system. Liposomal Vitamin C; Liposomal Glutathione; Liposomal Curcumin; Melatonin – Has been found to have anti-viral properties; Wellness Tonic- A blend of medicinal herbs that help boost the immune system; PRP spray – Purified Immunoglobulins from cow’s colostrum; Zinc – Supports immune system. We also have an Immune Support kit, containing mineralized D3, Liposomal Vitamin C, Zinc and Immuno PRP Spray. [Reformatted from original.]
The FDA and FTC have responded to the gravity of the pandemic by more aggressively pursuing unlawful claims that products and services can treat or cure COVID-19. It is unfortunate that they do not have the resources to mount this type of campaign against more pedestrian bogus remedies, which remain on the market to bilk the public.

COVID-19 vaccine rollout creates new scamming opportunities for crooks
As new COVID-19 vaccines become available to the public, swindlers are adjusting their cons to fit the moment, even going door-to-door to peddle their scams.
Jann Bellamy on December 17, 2020
Link
With the initial administration of Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine earlier this week in the U.S., and the prospect of Moderna’s vaccine receiving an FDA Emergency Use Authorization at any moment, scammers are concocting fresh schemes to exploit the public’s understandable eagerness to end the pandemic. Having already hawked various nostrums, including fake preventatives and impotent therapeutics, vultures are circling the internet, knocking on doors, and dialing for dollars, ready to pluck the bones of financially and emotionally distressed consumers.
In my view, the U.S.’s patchwork, inadequate coronavirus response, combined with our disjointed healthcare system and dauntingly complex health insurance plans (when available at all), practically invite fraudsters to participate. Add, on top of this, a vaccine distribution system that is still in the making and the lack of public information on how it will work, one would be surprised if scammers passed on the opportunity.
FDA authorization of the vaccines themselves is only the beginning in a complex distribution system that ends with a jab in the arm. As a Kaiser Family Foundation issue brief on vaccine distribution points out:
While initial planning documents have been released, numerous outstanding questions and challenges remain. These range from questions regarding the respective roles of the federal, state, and local governments, to financing and coverage of a vaccine, addressing racial and ethnic disparities and communication and public trust.
For example, once cleared by the FDA, the federal government and 64 different state, local, and territorial jurisdictional immunization programs will manage delivery of several hundred million vaccine doses, most of which have yet to be manufactured, to administration sites across the country. These jurisdictions, many of which are already financially strained, will implement various prioritization schedules, some still in development, to allocate the initially limited vaccine doses to specific population groups. Health care workers, those with certain underlying health conditions, and people over age 65, are expected to take precedence. Other groups, like healthy adults and children, may have to wait until spring or summer of next year to be vaccinated.
Administration of the vaccine will likely take place in a wide variety of locations, including public and private hospitals and clinics, medical practices, pharmacies, and potentially government-run mass vaccination locations. And, while the intent is that no American will have to pay for the vaccine or its administration, “despite these measures, limitations and gaps related to a COVID-19 vaccine remain, and some individuals, particularly adults, may still face cost and access barriers”.
Thus, as the Kaiser brief points out:
Given that demand will be high and supply low during the initial phase of distribution, vaccine doses will be seen as highly valuable and therefore vulnerable to theft, fraud or corruption.
As with the rest of the pandemic, swindlers have risen to the challenge.
One media outlet in New York has already reported on recorded calls offering people a chance to avoid long lines and receive an early dose of the Pfizer vaccine for $79.99. The Better Business Bureau announced it is investigating vaccine distribution swindles offering consumers an earlier dose of the vaccine as well. Sometimes these calls come from a familiar caller ID name because “most consumers don’t realize that caller ID can be changed by a simple computer program”. (I added that last bit because, until I read it, I was one of those consumers.)
Check Point, a cybersecurity firm, found a number of vaccine “vendors” on dark web marketplaces exploiting the news of vaccine approval. For example, one vendor advertised the authorized Pfizer vaccine for $250 in Bitcoin, shipping from the U.S., the U.K., or Spain. Engaging in a dialogue with some vendors, researchers found another offering an unbranded COVID-19 vaccine for 0.01 Bitcoin (about $300), claiming that 14 doses were required.
This jibes with a recently issued Interpol global alert to law enforcement across its 194 member countries “warning them to prepare for organized crime networks targeting COVID-19 vaccines, both physically and online”. Interpol anticipates both the sale of fake vaccines and theft of the real thing, “with the pandemic having already triggered unprecedented opportunistic and predatory criminal behaviour”.
Check Point also found, as reported by ComputerWeekly.com,
multiple examples of emails incorporating vaccine lures into their subject lines spreading malicious .exe files that installed malware, and others spreading the Agent Tesla keylogger remote access trojan (Rat), in both instances seeking to exfiltrate their victim’s data and credentials, and take over accounts.
In addition, Check Point researchers reported a “sharp rise” in potentially malicious domains related to vaccines in November, with over 1,000 registered last month, “exceeding the number of vaccine-related domain name registrations in the previous three months put together”.
Another cyber security firm, KnowBe4, found phishing examples exploiting recent media reports that the Pfizer vaccine may not be available in the U.S. in large volumes until the spring of next year. Links in emails directed users not to media reports but instead to a credential phishing website.
A KnowBe4 researcher quoted in ComputerWeekly.com explains that such schemes exploit some of the basic questions and concerns we all have about the new vaccines: how soon they will be available, safety issues, how and when can one get vaccinated, and how much it will cost. “Put very simply”, he said, “this is pretty much what we expected”.
According to a report in the Detroit Free Press, consumer watchdogs are reporting that imposters are claiming to be with the Social Security Administration in order to get sensitive information. For example, the scammer will say he is calling to sign the person up to receive their vaccine, requesting Medicare number, address, and financial information.
The Federal Trade Commission, working with the National Association of Attorneys General, put out consumer education tips last week on avoiding vaccine scams:
    • You likely will not need to pay anything out of pocket to get the vaccine during this public health emergency.
    • You can’t pay to put your name on a list to get the vaccine.
    • You can’t pay to get early access to the vaccine.
    • No one from a vaccine distribution site or health care payer, like a private insurance company, will call you asking for your Social Security number or your credit card or bank account information to sign you up to get the vaccine.
    • Beware of providers offering other products, treatments, or medicines to prevent the virus. Check with your health care provider before paying for or receiving any COVID-19-related treatment.
On that last one, I feel compelled to note that taking advice from a licensed health care provider doesn’t guarantee that it will be science-based, thanks to our state legislatures. Choose your provider wisely.
In addition to using texts, emails, social media platforms, and calls, according to the FTC, some fraudsters are employing an old-fashioned touch and actually going door to door with their pitch. The agency advises anyone contacted by someone making suspicious offers to avoid giving them money or personal information and instead report them to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or file a complaint with your state or territory attorney general through consumerresources.org.
The Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (OIG) put out its own alert recently, reiterating these warnings and adding that the public should be wary of anyone claiming to be a contact tracer who asks for personal or financial information or offering HHS grants related to the COVID-19 pandemic. As well, do not respond to, or open hyperlinks in, messages about COVID-19 from people and companies you don’t know. You can submit complaints of suspected fraud to the OIG here.
While the average SBM reader is likely savvier than most about COVID-19 fraud, it wouldn’t hurt to share these resources with others who might not be as sophisticated about the wiles of scammers. Given the unknowns about the availability, timing, and logistics of getting a vaccine, I am especially worried about swindlers who claim they are scheduling “vaccination appointments”, gaining personal information and possibly pre-payment in the process. And I’m not too confident about the ability of some Americans to separate fact from fiction right now, or to recognize a con when they see one.

“Health Freedom” group promotes legislation negating masks, other public health measures
National Health Freedom Action is promoting state legislation that would block enforcement of public health measures (e.g., mask wearing and social distancing) during epidemics and other emergencies. The organization and its allies embrace junk science and have successfully passed laws protecting quacks.
Jann Bellamy on September 24, 2020
Link

An organization calling itself “National Health Freedom Action” (NHFA) is promoting state legislation that would block public health measures designed to prevent the spread of communicable diseases like COVID-19. If enacted, the legislation would prevent both government and private businesses from instituting public health measures, like mask requirements and social distancing, by making compliance with those measures voluntary.
Before we get to the specifics, let’s take a look at NHFA and its operations.
Under the rubric of “health freedom”, a legally meaningless term, NHFA supports several alternative medicine hobbyhorses. Their chief legislative success has been passage of “safe-harbor” laws protecting quacks from being disciplined under state health care practitioner licensing acts, thereby making it virtually impossible for a state to combat the victimization of consumers by charlatans and their nostrums. They and their allies have been instrumental in getting these “Quack Protection Acts” passed in 11 states. One version is now pending in Massachusetts; a Wisconsin bill came close to passing but, fortunately, failed.
In Maine, for example, an unlicensed practitioner providing “alternative or complementary health care services” can diagnose and treat any disease or condition (with very few exceptions), without informed consent and without any obligation to refer the consumer to a physician. There is no requirement that a CAM practitioner keep patient records (of, say, symptoms and treatment) nor are there confidentiality protections for patient information. Unlike licensed health care practitioners, such as physicians and nurses, there are no education and training requirements; no criminal background checks; no prohibitions against false advertising, conflicts of interest, or financial or sexual exploitation of patients (at least those prohibitions established by the state’s licensing laws); and no required reporting (e.g., of infectious diseases or child abuse). They essentially practice medicine with no standard of care and completely free of state regulation.
Concomitant with protecting quacks, NHFA opposes licensing of health care practitioners like dietitians and massage therapists. They also oppose vaccination mandates and support “personal and philosophical” exemptions, including the virtually unchecked authority of health care providers to underwrite vaccine exemptions. NHFA supports GMO labeling, “protection of access to” dangerous raw, unpasteurized dairy products, and parental “rights” to choose “alternative” health care for their children. (We’ve discussed the tragic consequences for the child when parents exercise their “rights” a number of times here on SBM, including here, here, and here.)
NHFA, with its sister organization, the National Health Freedom Coalition (NHFC), promotes false information about COVID-19, including posts by GreenMedInfo and the Weston A. Price Foundation, both on NewsGuard’s list of websites known for spreading COVID-19 misinformation. For example, a post by Weston A. Price Foundation founder (and English major) Sally Fallon Morell opines, among other idiotic notions, that the rollout of 5G is somehow responsible for the COVID-19 outbreak and that vaccines make people susceptible to it, both thoroughly debunked by David Gorski. (Morell has a book out promoting this and other nonsense, such as “the disease called Covid-19 is not contagious and scientists have not properly isolated and purified a virus associated with the disease”.) Another post recommends the use of homeopathy, falsely claiming that it “is very effective in epidemics”.
NHFC, in turn, hosts the United States Health Freedom Congress, which is sponsored by COVID-19 misinformation “super-spreaders” mercola.com and the National Vaccine Information Center (or, as we prefer here at SBM, the National Vaccine Misinformation Center), as well as companies selling various nostrums, like EMF “protection” and homeopathic remedies.
The “Right to Refuse” model act
In sum, NHFA operates within an ecosystem of COVID-19 misinformation, profit-making quackery promotion, anti-consumer legislation, anti-vaccination hysteria, and all-around junk science. It is therefore unsurprising that NHFA is spearheading an effort to pass legislation blocking public health measures during the current pandemic. Billed as the “Right to Refuse” law, NHFA drafted a model act for state legislatures, fresh off the presses, ready and waiting for introduction in your state’s next legislative session.
The “Right to Refuse” model act gives all individuals the “right” to refuse health-related “countermeasures” including, “but not limited to”, refusing
     1.  medical treatments or procedures;
     2.  testing;
     3.  physical or mental examination;
     4.  vaccination;
     5.  experimental procedures and protocols;
     6.  collection of specimens;
     7.  participation in tracking or tracing programs;
     8.  the wearing of masks;
     9.  the maintaining of measured distance from other humans and animals that is not otherwise unlawful;
     10.  the involuntary sharing of personal data or medical information; and
     11.  other recommended or mandated countermeasures.
All existing laws, regulations, and orders addressing outbreaks or potential outbreaks of contagious, infectious, or communicable diseases, to the extent they impose the disease countermeasures listed above, are overridden. More broadly, if a law, regulation, or order was created in response to an emergency, whether it relates to disease spread or not, including national security emergencies and “any peacetime emergency”, provisions conflicting with the “Right to Refuse” are also overridden.
Given the fact that unspecified “other recommended or mandated countermeasures” are forbidden, and the right to refuse is “not limited to” the listed countermeasures, it is hard to imagine what might be left in the government’s toolbox to combat a public health or national security emergency, other than some confusing and contradictory measures we’ll get to in a moment. Ebola epidemic? Too bad. Biochemical warfare? Too bad. Nuclear attack? Too bad, because
An individual who has been directed or ordered by a government . . . or public or private business entity, to subject to a directive or order [described in the list above] may choose to decline to comply, respond to, or participate with said directive or order.
Note that this would include hospitals, nursing homes, and other health care facilities, which, during the current pandemic, would be prevented from barring individuals who refuse to wear masks, socially distance, or have their temperature checked.
To emphasize the startling breadth of its prohibitions, under the heading “Coercion”, the model act provides:
The government or its designees, or other employers, businesses, non-profits, institutions, churches, travel carriers, or other public or private entities, may not infringe upon, put conditions on, restrict, or take away a person’s ability to fully participate in necessary and important services and lifestyle choices and preferences including but not limited to education, daycare, employment, travel, religion, hobbies, entertainment, sports, and lifestyle preferences, based on a person choosing to decline countermeasures as described [in the list above].
To ensure that we are all fully informed about our right to uninhibited lifestyle choices and preferences, not to mention hobbies and entertainment, the model acts requires anyone (government official and businessperson alike) daring to direct, or even request, our compliance with the listed countermeasures to read us our “rights” by reciting both the above-quoted paragraph and the 11 countermeasures we can refuse, along with assorted other verbiage, to the tune of almost 350 words. In addition, the person refusing the countermeasure (we’ll call him the “refusenik”) must be given a copy of the section of the model act requiring this recitation of his rights. Then, the reader of the recitation of rights has to “obtain a signature of acknowledgement of receipt of notification” of the right to refuse by the refusenik.
By my calculation, this recitation of the right to refuse takes about 3 minutes. (I have a Southern accent, your results may differ.) Then there’s the additional time necessary to give out the written notification of the requirement that one’s right of refusal be recited and get a signature. Given the anti-mask sentiment in certain quarters, high-traffic government offices and businesses would likely have to hire someone whose sole duty it is to read refuseniks their “rights”, give them the written handout, and get it signed. (Given their anti-regulation sentiment, query how many refuseniks are going to stand there patiently while all of this takes place.)
But wait . . . there’s more, although it’s so poorly drafted it’s hard to make heads or tails of it.
According to the model act, if our refusenik is actually infected, or reasonably believed to be infected, or has been exposed to infection, he “may” (not “must”, but “may”) participate in isolation or quarantine. However, if this isolation or quarantine is truly optional, other provisions don’t make any sense. For example, if our refusenik is “non-infected”, this apparently optional quarantine must be based on “sufficient evidence of contact or close proximity with an infected person”. But why would this evidence be necessary if the person is voluntarily choosing quarantine? Likewise, isolation and quarantine must “include reasonable notice and due process”. Again, if the isolation or quarantine is self-imposed, how would due process (that is, notice and an opportunity to be heard) come into play?
If the restrictions are not voluntary, what means would the government have of knowing a person is infected in the first place, given the right to refuse requests for medical information and testing? In any event, even if the drafters meant quarantine or isolation can be mandated, I’ll guarantee you the refusenik’s attorney is going to argue that the “Right to Refuse” law says otherwise; that “may” means it’s voluntary. (The thought occurs to me that this obfuscation could be intentional.)
Isolation or quarantine, whether mandated or self-imposed, “must be of the least restrictive means possible” and includes the right to live in one’s home with family or friends as well as a prohibition against removing minor children from the home. Testing, treatment, tracking, or prevention cannot be imposed as a requirement of ending quarantine or isolation. And the drafters of this model act, being who they are, included this:
A person in isolation or quarantine has the right to utilize the health care treatments of their choice. . .
One would like to think that a law undermining public health during a pandemic has little chance of passing, but the facts suggest otherwise. First, there is the anti-mitigation, anti-science, pro-quackery “leadership” coming from the top echelons of our government. Second, a “right to refuse” law, similar but weaker in its terms, already passed in Minnesota. Third, as mentioned, NHFA has been successful in passing laws giving quacks carte blanche to prey on consumers by eliminating state oversight. Fourth, state legislatures have shown themselves more than willing to throw obstacles in the way of public health measures like vaccination. Finally, state legislatures have also proven themselves incapable of understanding science many times, having passed numerous laws licensing quackery. In other words, don’t count them out.

Experts Abused for Talking to the Public
Nature survey finds that most media experts talking about COVID are facing threats and attacks.
Steven Novella on October 20, 2021
Link

One of the manifestations of the new political and social world we are living in is the so-called “death of expertise“. This refers not to the loss of actual expertise, but rather the loss of a baseline of public respect for the concept of expertise and for experts themselves. A recent Nature survey highlights a disturbing marker of this trend – experts (in this case mostly doctors) facing threats of physical harm for expressing their opinions about COVID-19 in public. This is completely predictable, for anyone paying attention, but it’s worth reviewing how we got here.
It’s easy, even fashionable, to blame all such trends on social media. While social media certainly greatly facilitated our “post truth” world, the trends all started long before the internet. In the US in particular, there has long been a cultural undercurrent of anti-intellectualism, rooted in a distrust of authority and an attraction towards conspiracy theories. But this occurred alongside a general respect for excellence and ability. Scientists, especially medical scientists, rank among the most respected professions, at levels in the 80s, and stable over decades of surveys.
These apparently contradictory attitudes can exist at the same time because people generally can compartmentalize their beliefs, but something else is going on as well. In the abstract many people still respect experts and scientists, but now they can choose which experts and scientists to believe. This is the new reality – it’s not the absence of facts, but the existence of “alternative facts”. The problem is not as much ignorance as the false illusion of knowledge.
This is where social media comes in. Ready access to information on demand creates a powerful illusion of knowledge, and even the sense that we all can “do our own research” and come to a reliable conclusion, even about complex technical topics we do not really understand. You don’t have to look beyond the comments section of SBM to witness non-experts arguing over technical details in the scientific literature in areas where they lack any formal background. Even for those not trying to substitute their own opinions for those of experts, they can easily fall prey to believing the “wrong experts”. Who are the “wrong experts” and how does that happen?
People generally grossly underestimate a few things: First they underestimate how much information is out there, and specifically that you can find facts and opinions to support pretty much any belief you want. They further underestimate (or are simply unaware of) the power of confirmation bias. It is a well-established psychological phenomenon that we tend to seek out, notice, accept and remember information that supports what we believe or want to believe, while simultaneously ignoring, forgetting, or explaining away information that contradicts our beliefs. When you combine these two factors, it can create the powerful illusion that the facts support our beliefs, whether they do or not.
Further still, social media often uses algorithms that automate the process of confirmation bias. Therefore, confirmation bias is no longer just a passive process, but an active one – we are being fed information that supports what we already believe. Social media platforms do this to maximize clicks, and don’t seem to care about the beliefs themselves. This process also causes the existence of networks of people with similar beliefs in so-called “echochambers” that further reinforce the beliefs and add an element of community identity to them.
But many people and organizations using social media do care what those beliefs are. This creates another factor, perhaps the most insidious – other people are curating information for you designed to manufacture specific illusions of knowledge. Both these factors (a media just wanting to maximize engagement for profits and ideologues selling specific beliefs) play off each other, as the media is all-too-happy to give oxygen to radical beliefs because it’s good for their bottom line.
Finally, the information we are being fed is not in isolated facts, but is woven together into a compelling narrative. Those narratives then take on a life of their own, as they organize our knowledge and beliefs and serve as filters for the further acquisition of curated “facts”. Our place in society is now largely determined by which narratives we identity with, and these narratives are largely isolated from each other, without any common ground to resolve differences.
This is where “alternative experts” comes in. Social media also makes it easy to select and elevate those voices in the noise that support our narrative. It also makes it easy to create the illusion of an established institution, of journalism, experts, or even scientists. People who previously would have faded to the fringe because their ideas were fatally flawed or unconvincing, can now be brought back to the center of the conversation because they support a particular narrative.
With this view of our current situation, it is not at all surprising that attacks on public experts have been increasing. Nature surveyed more than 300 scientists who made media appearances to talk about some aspect of COVID-19. Of those surveyed 70% reported that as a result they had experienced some kind of threats or attacks – 59% attacks on their credibility, 30% reputational damage, 22% threats of sexual assault, and 15% received death threats.
It should now be easy to understand how this can happen. An expert appearing in the mainstream media simply to talk about the results of a research study, or synthesize the evidence for or against some treatment, is (whether they know it or not) either supporting or refuting some narrative. If they are refuting a narrative that you have been led to believe through the above processes, you might think the experts are therefore lying, and part of some vast conspiracy. You are not just disagreeing with their facts, you are defending civilization. This is what radicalization looks like.
        ◦ Scientists are largely not prepared for this new reality. Just as climate scientists, previously working in anonymity without much media attention, were suddenly thrust into the middle of a political cage match, health experts are experiencing the same thing with respect to COVID.

The “Natural Immunity is Real Act”: Real or an act?
Republican legislators have proposed a law requiring federal agencies to acknowledge, accept, truthfully present and incorporate “consideration of natural immunity” in their COVID regulations. It’s just political theatrics based on a flawed understanding of infection-induced “natural” immunity.
Jann Bellamy on November 18, 2021
Link

A recent House Bill (H.R. 5590) and its Senate companion (S. 2846), both titled the “Natural Immunity is Real Act”, would require all federal agencies issuing rules or regulations relating to COVID-19 to
acknowledge, accept, agree to truthfully present, and incorporate, the consideration of natural immunity as it pertains to COVID–19 with respect to the individuals subject to the applicable regulations.
As the bill helpfully explains, natural immunity means “immunity that is naturally existing”. Natural immunity, of course, sounds so much more pleasant and less scary than the CDC’s term: “infection-induced immunity”.
The sponsor of H.R. 5590, Rep. Diana Harshbarger (R-TN), appears to believe the evidence on natural immunity is settled and one’s level of immunity can be both accurately determined and used as an indication of sufficient protection from the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Per her press release:
I introduced this bill today because the Biden Administration must ‘follow the science’ and be open, honest and transparent about the millions of Americans who have natural immunity against the COVID-19 virus . . . . There’s ample scientific evidence from numerous peer-reviewed studies that natural immunity from previous COVID-19 infection is effective, durable and long-lasting.
According to a Tennessee TV station, Rep. Harshbarger thinks that unvaccinated individuals could submit blood samples for antibody testing and, if antibodies are found, they should not be subject to any vaccine mandate.
Some of the House bill’s co-sponsors, all fellow Republicans, seem to share her confidence that natural immunity can be measured accurately and that its effectiveness against the virus is settled. Rep. Daniel Webster (R-FL) charges that:
Too many medical leaders [whom he accuses of “denying science”] are refusing to publicly recognize what overwhelming data has already shown – protection afforded to individuals with natural immunity is real, robust and durable.
Rep. Chris Stewart’s (R-UT) comments suggest a belief that infection-induced and vaccine-induced immunity are equivalent:
The vaccine offers effective protection against COVID-19; natural immunity offers effective protection against COVID-19.
And, from Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL):
No American should be forced to choose between getting the COVID vaccine or keeping their job, particularly when the Biden policy fails to recognize that millions of Americans have immunity because they’ve already had and recovered from COVID.
On the other hand, at least one co-sponsor, Rep. Jeff Van Drew (R-NJ), acknowledges the science is not as settled as his colleagues make it out to be:
We know vaccines work, but natural immunity could be equally or similarly as effective in certain individuals. If the CDC would devote time into its research, we would have robust, evidence-based research that could help America finally move on from this virus.
In fact, the CDC has done just that, as you’ll see in a moment.
Indeed, the “numerous peer-reviewed studies” linked in Rep. Harshbarger’s comment, which is actually a letter from Republican MDs and other health care professionals in Congress to CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky, takes a more nuanced approach. Although the letter cherry-picks the studies it cites supporting natural immunity’s effectiveness against the virus, it also admits that the evidence is not all in:
. . . we urge the CDC to harness available data and technology to . . . truly determine an individual’s level of protection against COVID-19. It may be the case that it is not medically necessary for an individual to receive a vaccination. It may also be the case that a sufficient level of protection may be produced from one dose.
Rep. Harshbarger is not anti-vaccination but is emphatically anti-vaccine mandate. She is a Pharm.D who admirably, considering the enormous resistance to COVID-19 vaccination in her party, made a “get vaccinated” Public Service Announcement, although in it she firmly states that the decision is up to the individual. She’s also introduced bills prohibiting vaccine mandates and “passports“.
That is not to say the anti-vaccination forces aren’t delighted with the opportunity presented by the Natural Immunity is Real Act to further their cause. The execrable National Vaccine Information Center “news” outlet, The Vaccination Reaction (such a cute name!), which earlier this year ran a reprint of an American Institute for Economic Research (AIER) article questioning why mainstream medicine was “downplaying or erasing natural immunity”, touted the bill. The AIER, a libertarian think tank, has promoted “in essence, letting COVID-19 rip through the ‘healthy’ population in order to achieve ‘natural herd immunity'”. As SBM’s Dr. David Gorski explained in his post on the subject, “natural immunity” is a long-time anti-vaccine trope resurrected for COVID-19.
Other co-sponsors of the bill have not been shy about their anti-vaccination sympathies. Rep. Mo Brooks (R-AL) pushed anti-vaccine talking points in a letter to President Biden. Rep. Madison Cawthorn (R-NC) saw a prelude to confiscation of guns and Bibles in a proposed door-to-door immunization drive. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) also pushed misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines, saying falsely that the vaccines were “failing” and were ineffective in reducing the spread of the virus. Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) called researchers studying low vaccination rates “Needle Nazis” and spread vaccine misinformation, including continuing to refer to approved vaccines as “experimental”. And, prior to the pandemic, Rep. Mark Green (R- TN), an MD, and Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL) gave credence to the widely discredited (mainly because it never existed in the first place) vaccine-autism connection.
Meanwhile, back at the CDC . . .
Health experts have pushed back against the proposed law. Kenneth Goodman, director of the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine Institute for Bioethics and Health Policy and the Florida Bioethics Network, told the Orlando Sentinel that it is
bad science, dangerous policy and saddest of all, ideology tricked out as ethics . . .
And in response to Rep. Daniel Webster’s claim to another Orlando news outlet that the bill is “just saying there are other options than just a vaccine”, pediatric pulmonologist Dr. Akinyemi Ajayi pointed out that, while there is some natural immunity protection acquired from an infection, it is not clear how long it lasts and that a verifiable way to determine natural immunity does not currently exist.
An associate professor of medicine in the Division of Infectious Diseases at University of Utah Health made similar points in a Deseret News article about the proposed law:
While there is some evidence natural infection provides strong immunity, there is variability from person to person and less predictability than vaccine immunity . . . . Clinical antibody tests available also are not great correlates of immunity to COVID-19 and have wide variability from test to test.
Meanwhile, it appears that the CDC has been doing pretty much what the proposed law dictates all along, only not with the result its backers would likely prefer. On Oct. 29, 2021, the CDC published a Science Brief titled “SARS-CoV-2 Infection-induced and Vaccine-induced Immunity”, an overview of the current scientific evidence regarding infection-induced and vaccine-induced immunity, including both peer-reviewed and preprint publications, as well as unpublished CDC data. In a signal that the CDC will continue to “consider” natural immunity, the report says that “new data continue to emerge, and recommendations will be updated periodically”.
Key findings include:
    • Fully vaccinated and previously infected individuals both have a low risk of subsequent infection for at least 6 months.
    • We don’t have sufficient data to determine an antibody titer threshold indicating when an individual is protected from infection and no FDA-authorized test can reliably determine whether a person is protected.
    • There is a wide range of antibody titers from infection but vaccines (especially mRNA vaccines) typically lead to a more consistent and higher-titer initial antibody response.
    • More quality evidence exists regarding vaccine-acquired than infection-induced immunity and, in fact, there is not enough evidence to apply what we know about the latter to children and those with a mild or asymptomatic infections.
    • Vaccination after infection significantly enhances protection and further reduces risk of reinfection.
Thus, the CDC continues to recommend COVID-19 vaccination for all eligible persons, including those who have been previously infected.
On the same day, the CDC issued a Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Early Release, a study showing that COVID-19 was over five times more common among hospitalized people who were unvaccinated and had a previous infection, compared with those who were fully vaccinated and hadn’t had COVID-19 before. The study concluded that
All eligible persons should be vaccinated against COVID-19 as soon as possible, including unvaccinated persons previously infected with SARS-CoV-2.
Although, technically, the bill (should it become law) would not apply to the CDC’s report or study (because neither is a rule or regulation), it sure looks to me like the CDC has acknowledged, accepted, and truthfully presented natural immunity and incorporated it into its recommendations.
Funny that the Representatives and Senators supporting the Act didn’t take the time to ring the federal agency most responsible for COVID research and policy and ask them whether they were “considering” natural immunity before blasting the Biden Administration for failing to “follow the science” and introducing legislation on October 18, 2021, a mere 11 days before the CDC’s report and study came out. We can safely assume that neither was done in less than two weeks, so obviously both were ongoing projects when Rep. Harshbarger’s press release was issued and the bills introduced.
I can’t find that any of the bills’ sponsors have responded to the report or study. Then again, I wonder if it matters to them. I suspect the House and Senate bills were just a bit of political theater, designed to play to political bases. If they really cared about “following the science”, one would think they would have hailed the CDC’s recent publications as within the spirit of their proposed legislation and urged constituents to follow the CDC’s recommendations. But, of course, they didn’t, because it doesn’t fit their anti-mandate or anti-vaccination narrative. The Act was an act all along.
UPDATE: In a special session called by Gov. Ron DeSantis, the Florida Legislature just passed, and DeSantis signed, a new law:
businesses are required to exempt employees from a [that is, the federal] mandatory vaccination policy if they have Covid immunity from prior infection, are tested periodically for the virus or choose to wear personal protective equipment provided by the company.
‘We recognize people who have natural immunity,’ DeSantis said. “Whatever a private employer wants to do, you’re automatically exempt because of natural immunity.’
Here’s the actual language of the new law regarding “natural immunity”:
To claim an exemption based on COVID-19 immunity, the employee must present to the employer an exemption statement demonstrating competent medical evidence that the employee has immunity to COVID-19, documented by the results of a valid laboratory test performed on the employee. The Department of Health shall adopt a standard for demonstrating competent medical evidence of such immunity.
This should be interesting, considering that Florida’s new Surgeon General and head of the state health department drafting the standard is Dr. Joseph Ladapo, a member of the kook anti-vaccine America’s Frontline Doctors (or maybe former member, to my knowledge he hasn’t said one way or another). Stay tuned. e

FTC warns naturopaths, acupuncturists, physicians, and chiropractors about false and misleading COVID-19 claims 
Since March, the FTC has issued almost 250 warning letters to companies and individuals making unsubstantiated claims for COVID-19 treatments. Included among these are naturopaths, acupuncturists, physicians, and chiropractors.
Jann Bellamy on June 18, 2020
Link

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has issued almost 250 warning letters to individuals and companies since March demanding that they cease making (or assisting others in making) bogus claims that their nostrums can prevent or treat COVID-19. While it is not unusual for the FTC to go after health care product marketers, such as dietary supplement retailers, the agency’s warnings to licensed health care practitioners, especially regarding clinical treatments, are less common. It suggests both that the agency is taking COVID-19 very seriously and that it is actively searching the internet for COVID-19 claims, as opposed to acting solely on consumer complaints.
It is unlawful under the FTC Act to advertise that a service or product can prevent, treat, or cure human disease unless there is competent and reliable scientific evidence, including, when appropriate, well-controlled human clinical studies, substantiating that the claims are true. Because no alleged preventative or treatment currently meets this standard for COVID-19, it is fairly easy for the FTC to conclude that advertisements making such health claims run afoul of the law, with a warning letter to follow.
The FDA, which has primary responsibility for claims on product labeling, joined the FTC in some of the warning letters.
Not surprisingly, naturopathic, acupuncture, and chiropractic practices are among those warned, as well as MDs and DOs who skate along on the fringes of medicine. It is unsurprising as well that COVID-19 preventatives and treatments aren’t the only dubious therapies being offered by these practitioners, as demonstrated repeatedly on the websites cited in warning letters. While the FTC’s focus on COVID-19 is understandable, it is lamentable that so many other false and misleading claims go unaddressed, leaving those suffering from, for example, cancer, serious neurological conditions (like Alzheimer’s), and chronic health conditions (like diabetes), to the wiles of pseudoscience.
That said, it is indeed satisfying to imagine the panicky feeling practitioners must experience when, upon receiving a warning letter, they realize that the FTC, which tangles with behemoths like Apple and Microsoft with its substantial resources (including crack litigators from the Department of Justice), has honed in on their little clinic. They may have no shame, but they do have assets, and violations of the FTC Act can result in thousands of dollars in fines, injunctions against further sale of their products and services, and mandated refunds to consumers, not to mention the attorneys’ fees and costs of mounting a defense.
SBM has already covered the COVID-19 shenanigans of some CAM practitioners: chiropractors touting “adjustments” to “boost” the immune system, naturopaths (including the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians [AANP] and the California Association of Naturopathic Doctors) pushing IV Vitamin C, and acupuncturists (backed by the Chinese Government) shilling for “Traditional Chinese Medicine”.
Let’s see what the FTC’s investigators found.*
Despite an enthusiastic endorsement from the AANP, the FTC has repeatedly issued warning letters to clinics offering intravenous Vitamin C to prevent or treat COVID-19. Some of these are infusion clinics where it is unclear whether a licensed medical practitioner with prescription privileges is in charge. Since Vitamin C and other compounded infusions are prescription drugs under federal law, it is also unclear how they are operating from a legal standpoint.
One such clinic is Onus IV, in Colorado, which claims “Vitamin C is already being used to prevent and treat COVID-19 in China and Korea. And it is working.” The clinic falsely says that even small amounts of Vitamin C “dramatically decrease severity of symptoms and increase survival rates” and “large doses work better. Intravenous large doses work better still. . . .”
Detox VIP, a mobile IV service in South Florida, (with an MD medical director) also touts high dose Vitamin C infusions “as a way to increase your natural defenses against COVID-19” based on a “Chinese medical team report”.
In fact, the alleged success of Vitamin C use in China is mentioned by many clinics, an odd selling point considering the vilification of China’s response to the pandemic. According to Holistique Medical Center, a Washington naturopathic clinic offering typical naturopathic quackery like homeopathy, “Shanghai doctors [are treating COVID-19] with intravenous vitamin C, safely and effectively without any deaths reported.” A naturopathic doctor and “chiropractic internist”, who runs the Epigenetics Healing Center in Kansas, advises
Iv vitamin c in high doses are knocking covid 19 out in wuhan China. Come get yours at the Epigenetics Healing Center asap.
He goes so far as to claim that
Coronavirus? It is something that should NOT be worried about! Typically, it is only serious for the elderly and immunocompromised. Vitamin c infusions seem to mitigate any issue with it.
Medical doctors are offering IV Vitamin C as well. The LaCava Center, run by an Illinois “integrative” physician board-certified in OB/GYN, offers “VITAMIN C IV AT 50% OFF!” and says that “research shows that high dose Vitamin C is effective against COVID-19.”
The Kansas-based Riordan Clinic, staffed by an MD, a DO, and an ND, where “Vitamin C has been at the center of the mission . . . for almost 45 years” aims to “protect . . . patients from an otherwise potentially devastating exposure to COVID-19” with its signature treatment. The clinic was founded by the late Hugh Riordan, a psychiatrist who believed that nutrition and vitamins are an effective treatment for diseases such as cancer and the father of stem cell entrepreneur Neil Riordan, who has himself made a few appearances here on SBM.
To give you an idea of the geographic and provider diversity, other clinics nabbed by the FTC for promoting IV Vitamin C for COVID-19 include the Envista Medical Neck & Back Center (California MDs and DCs), Whole Health Chicago (an “integrative” practice which includes an MD, a “chiropractic physician specializing in functional medicine”, a TCM practitioner, and a homeopath), Revive and Rally Health Lounge (Kansas, run by an MD and an RN), Aspire Regenerative Health (California ND), iCRYO (a multi-state cryotherapy-infusion franchise operation with an MD Chief Medical Officer), LotusRain Naturopathic Clinic (California), Naturopathic European Medical Centre (which, despite the name and spelling, is in Wisconsin), Holgistic Personalized Healthcare/Natural Care Institute (Michigan MD and ND partnership), Traditional Chinese Medicine Clinic (Colorado Doctors of Oriental Medicine and Acupuncturists), East Valley Naturopathic (Arizona), Gonino Center for Healing (Texas DO), Hawaii Naturopathic Retreat, Health Associates Medical Group (California MD, DO, DC and LAc combo), Restore Med Clinic (California MDs), Revival Hydration (a “100% mobile” California infusion company using unspecified “medical professionals”), Sage Integrative Medicine Clinic (Washington NDs), and Vero Clinics (Illinois MD).
Acupuncture, TCM, and naturopathy for COVID-19
Acupuncture and TCM practices are well-represented among the COVID-19 advertising scofflaws. Among the FTC’s collars and their offending claims:
    • A Center for Natural Healing (California): “Treatment with Chinese Medicine has already proven in China to strongly support recovery from COVID” and “to help with the prevention and treatment of COVID-19”.
    • Inner Works Acupuncture (Oregon): “Chinese herbal medicine for COVID-19 is a great option for prevention, suspected exposure, early-stage and mild symptoms . . . [and] may help keep your respiratory illness from progressing . . .”
    • Integrative Acupuncture (Vermont): TCM “should take a primary role in effective treatment” of COVID-19.
    • Holistic Health Acupuncture (Oregon): “Herbal support for acute illness and prevention and treatment of COVID-19”.
    • Acupuncture Healing Center (Illinois): Can “facilitate the body’s response to expel the pathogen (coronavirus) . . .”
    • AcuIntegra (Tennessee): “TCM proved effective in 89% of the 1,245 confirmed COVID-19 patients” in a Chinese province.
    • Art of Wellness Acupuncture (California): “[A]cupuncture brings down fever significantly, and herbs have been shown to help resolve the severe cough”.
    • Beatty Acupuncture (Oklahoma): “Coronavirus treatment options for both Coronavirus prevention and COVID-19 positive treatment” including gummies and sprays.
    • Mind & Body Acupuncture (California): Promotes “a powerful herb – Tiger Cane” which “experts in China” found “has strongest effect for Anti coronavirus”.
And so on.
In addition to IV Vitamin C, naturopathic practices tout a variety of unsubstantiated preventatives and remedies for COVID-19, thereby catching the eye of the FTC. Typical of naturopathy, with its potpourri-of-quackery approach to practice, their recommendations varied.
We’ll start with two naturopaths who’ve made appearances here on SBM before, Paul Herscu and Amy Rothenberg (also here). Their Connecticut Naturopathic Health Care Clinic got a warning letter for claiming that products it sells, including homeopathic remedies and remedies containing zinc, elderberry, and Echinacea, can treat or prevent COVID-19.
Others naturopathic practices blessed with a warning letter include:
    • Portland Clinic of Holistic Health (Oregon): PCCH nasal spray used “once daily for prevention and several times daily for treatment” of COVID-19.
    • Ashland Natural Medicine (Oregon ND who is also a DC and homeopath): “Chinese medicine, homeopathy and western herbs appear to be helping many people with the infection[,] so our intention is to use them to treat ill people.”
    • Dr. Alan Christianson (Arizona): Touts Echinacea, Astragalus, and other “natural solutions” to the coronavirus.
    • Dr. Dale’s Wellness Center (California Traditional Naturopath and Homeopath): Sells “BioFilm Detox” claiming you can “take BioFilm Detox 20-30 minutes before you use ALLFLU or anything that you’re using to get rid of the COVID-19, but ALLFLU is the best thing to use, it’s the most effective, you feel a difference after using it once”.
    • Hansen Clinic of Natural Medicine (Arizona): Claims its PhytoBiotic product contains an ingredient that works “by blocking the release and spread of the virus within the body”.
    • LotusRain Naturopathic Clinic: In addition to Vitamin C IVs, mentioned above, the clinic offers “Hydrogen Peroxide IVs” and “AVACEN – Advanced Vascular Circulation Enhancement” as in-clinic options for preventing COVID-19.
    • Arizona Natural Medicine Physicians: On a webpage titled “Coronavirus: Supplements, Herbs & Homeopathic Remedies” this naturopathic-acupuncture practice offers “homeopathic injections such as Engystol which helps support immune function and prevent infection”.
    • Dramov Naturopathic Medical Center (Oregon): From a hyperlink labeled “COVID-19/CORONAVIRUS”, this practice takes consumers to a retail website promoting “Viral Immune Support” supplements.
    • Evergreen Naturopathic (Washington): On its “Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) FAQ” page, the practice offers patients “personalized herb tinctures to directly confront the viral infections that are most prevalent throughout the year while strengthening and supporting both the immune system and the sensitive tissues that are most susceptible to these infections.”
    • Hawaii Naturopathic Retreat: In addition to Vitamin C IVs, the clinic offers “immune boosting packages to help you protect yourself against the coronavirus” including “antiviral supplements” and a variety of other IV treatments and injections, as well as an infrared sauna and “colonics with probiotics”.
    • Post Falls Naturopathic Clinic (Idaho): Claims it used “energetic signatures of the Coronavirus and influenza” to create the COVID-19 & Flu Immune Booster, “a new homeopathic remedy to boost your immune system”.
Other MDs and DOs, alone and in cahoots with naturopaths and chiropractors, were caught in the FTC’s dragnet as well. Again, the variety of remedies is notable. The Center for Occupational & Environmental Medicine (South Carolina MD) claims that “very sick patients” using “TML drops” would be “without fever and pretty much asymptomatic in 10-24 hours.” New Leaf Wellness (Iowa & Oklahoma DO) says patients can “Beat Covid 19 with Hormones and Glutathione”. The Holtorf Medical Group (California MD, DO, and ND) promotes colloidal silver, as does the Envista Medical Neck & Back Center (California MDs and DCs). Envista also says, in a Facebook post,
Scared of the Corona Virus. We got stem cells!!!
Dr. Adrian Hohenwarter (Pennsylvania MD) recommends “d-Lenolate Olive Leaf 60 caps”; Dr. Brownstein’s Holistic Medicine (Michigan MD), iodine, hydrogen peroxide, and vitamins; Dr. Ronald Hoffman (New York MD), melatonin, nitric oxide, and Beta glucans; Dr. Jill Carnahan (Colorado MD and another SBM post alum), antioxidants; McDonagh Medical Center (Missouri DOs), ozone and UV light therapies; and Cypress Natural Medicine (California, NDs and a DO), herbal tinctures.
Gordon Medical (California MD-ND combo) touts nebulized hydrogen peroxide, while another MD-ND practice, Renaissance Health Centre (Arizona), recommends IV hydrogen peroxide and ozone therapies.
Finally, although in smaller numbers, chiropractic practices also received FTC warning letters. Among them is Fuller Life Chiropractic (Georgia), which promoted its services to people concerned about COVID-19 by claiming
Anything that interferes with proper nerve system function will have a negative impact on your immune system. Chiropractic has been shown to be the most effective form of healthcare for restoring proper nerve system function.
Likewise, Dr. Eric Nepute, a Missouri chiropractor, in a Facebook discussion of coronavirus, suggested his patients would not come down with COVID-19
Because they’ve been getting adjusted regularly, because adjustments help improve the nervous system, which helps improve the immune system. Period.
This is straight-up traditional chiropractic vitalism and similar claims have already been called out as inappropriate, including by chiropractors themselves. The difference here is that we have none other than the FTC finding that there is no competent and reliable scientific evidence to support it. The same can be said for the ubiquitous IV Vitamin C.
Pseudoscience does not exist in a vacuum. Along with Vitamin C, homeopathy, acupuncture, and hydrogen peroxide for COVID-19, these practitioners offer dubious nostrums like hyperbaric oxygen, dietary supplements, other IV “cocktails”, bioidentical hormone replacement therapy, chelation, infrared saunas, iridology, energy “medicine”, and craniosacral therapy, among others, for many other diseases and conditions. Again, as welcome as these warning letters are, it is unfortunate that the FTC does not regularly cast a wider net and target practitioners whose claims are not backed by “competent and reliable scientific evidence”. Or, as in the case of homeopathy and some other quack remedies, any science at all.

        ◦ *Links to all FTC COVID-19 warning letters can be found here. The letters provide links to the offending websites and other internet sources of misinformation. I have not added links to the individual warning letters or the offending materials in this post, as there are so many and they are easily available from the FTC’s list. I did not check to see if these claims have been removed or whether the individuals or companies have otherwise responded to the FTC.

FTC targets physicians’ COVID claims with cease-and-desist letters
The FTC recently announced it had issued 20 more cease-and-desist demands to physicians and others claiming their products and services prevent or treat COVID-19 without sufficient scientific backing. Unfortunately, this has not stopped many of the targets from making other bogus health claims.
Jann Bellamy on February 24, 2022
Link

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) recently announced it had issued cease-and-desist demands to 20 marketers ordering them to immediately stop making baseless claims, on their websites and via social media, that their products and services can prevent or treat COVID-19.* They were told to notify the FTC within 48 hours of specific actions they have taken to address the agency’s concerns. According to its press release, the FTC previously issued over 400 similar demands to marketers offering COVID nostrums.
While the FTC is understandably concerned about bogus COVID remedies, many of the products and services under scrutiny are the same ones we’ve covered numerous times here at SBM when sold for other diseases and conditions, yet they remain on the market: vitamins and other dietary supplements, herbs, homeopathy, IV infusions, and quack gizmos. As with other quack nostrums, COVID products and services are offered by hucksters who range from those who have no apparent education and training in medical science, or any science for that matter, to well-educated and well-trained physicians.
The FTC also advises recipients of its cease-and-desist letters
to review all other claims [in addition to COVID] for your products and immediately cease and desist from making claims that are not supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence. You must immediately cease and desist making all such claims.
Unfortunately, that warning appears to have had little effect on the plethora of dubious remedies offered even when the targeted COVID claims may have been taken down.
The FTC Act makes it illegal
to advertise that a product can prevent, treat, or cure human disease unless you possess competent and reliable scientific evidence, including substantiating that the claims are true at the time they are made.
For the products and services marketed for COVID cited in the FTC’s letters, no such evidence “is currently known to exist”.
Today we’ll take a look at some of these recent cease-and-desist letters and see how the same old quackery has been rejiggered to meet the demands of a modern pandemic. We’ll also look at how, regrettably, similar claims for other diseases and conditions are still marketed to the public by the very same people. We’ll focus on letters sent to physicians, who should know better, as well as a few charlatans who seem to be practicing medicine without a license.
But first, before we get to these folks, I would be remiss if I didn’t tell you about . . .
“Quantum” homeopathy
A Canadian outfit, AshNu Technologies, offers “memberships” to access something called “Infoceuticals” (or “ICs”) and the equipment purportedly required to “imprint ICs onto water or apply the ICs directly to the body”. These were advertised to prevent or treat COVID-19, and are still advertised to “support”, “help”, “maintain”, “treat” and otherwise benefit mitochondrial and energy production, the cardiovascular, reproductive, respiratory, digestive, endocrine, and nervous systems, and, of course, to “cleanse” and “restore the body”.
What are ICs? To begin with, you’ll not be surprised to learn that, like many quack remedies, they “work by stimulating the body’s own healing abilities”. Specifically (I guess),
ICs are electromagnetic signals that are generated using algorithms or recorded from substances that have healing, therapeutic, or other biological effects.
A video “explains” ICs “from the point of view of the “Quantum Electrodynamic (QED) Theory”:
Here you will learn how water is able to mimic the electromagnetic spectrum of diluted substances as well as how one can record and store these electromagnetic signals – thus, creating ICs from active substances.
You can deliver these ICs to your body by either transferring them to a glass of water via a gizmo (conveniently available for purchase) and drinking it, or by applying the gizmo directly to your body. Here we demonstrate using the “Glowing IC Pad”, currently marked down from $275 to $192.50. (Other gizmos for sale do the same thing but in a different way.)
Apparently in the spirit of the homeopathic mantra “like cures like”, AshNu offered an IC that
was made with the help of a highly diluted solution of an mRNA-based vaccine. It may be used to help ease side effects and adverse reactions from the vaccine.
This nonsense caught the FTC’s eye and they were told to cease such claims, which the company apparently did.
But AshNu, having simply removed its reference to COVID-19, still offers this IC for many other conditions:
Chlorine dioxide solution, also known as miracle mineral solution (MMS), [which] has been used as an alternative means to manage various conditions such as arthritis, cold/flu, malaria, hepatitis, measles, herpes, cancer, HIV, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Additionally, it has been used to improve oral and dental health.
And so on, with dozens of dietary supplements and other substances being transformed into ICs via this, um, technology, for numerous conditions, apparently without penalty.
With that bit of particularly idiotic “quantum” quackery out of the way, we’ll turn to the more serious problem of . . .
Even more physicians behaving badly
As our own Dr. David Gorski lamented in a post titled “2020 and the Pandemic: A Year of (Some) Physicians Behaving Badly”
the character of too many physicians has been found wanting, as they spent 2020 denying the pandemic, peddling quack cures, or spreading misinformation in the service of defying public health interventions.
A few more physicians recently found themselves recipients of FTC warnings in the latest tranche of letters. This is not the first time a crop of doctors has run afoul of the FTC Act for promoting COVID treatments lacking “competent and reliable scientific evidence”.
Brandon Mack M.D., an anesthesiologist, owns IVita Drip Therapy, with clinics in Wyoming and Kansas offering IV infusions concocted from various vitamins, minerals, pharmaceutical drugs and such, with names like the “Classic Cowboy” (a rebranded Myers Cocktail, a naturopathic staple) and “Forever Young” for “only $129” a pop. Since the FTC’s letter, his website no longer advertises his “Covid Blend”, promoted as
a powerhouse of immunity boosting Vitamin C, along with other essential elements working together to strengthen immune responses to serious viral illness….
But his other infusions, equally unsupported by adequate scientific evidence, remain on offer.
Similarly, although with a more glam website, a medical practice called Pretty Healthy NYC advertised, according to the FTC:
To help in the fight against coronavirus, my practice offers IV Vitamin C and Glutathione, along with a wide range of preventative and treatment-based infusion protocols, individually customized for each patient’s needs. These IV treatments are offered in our office or in the patient’s home.
One of Pretty Healthy NYC’s physicians, Roxanna Namavar, D.O., a psychiatrist, answered the call when “wellness” kook Christina Cuomo, wife of now-cancelled CNN anchor Chris Cuomo, rang up. Using what is quoted in the FTC’s cease-and-desist demand as the “Cuomo Protocol”, in a display of privilege that was deservedly criticized in the press, Dr. Namavar administered an at-home (in the Hamptons, no less) infusion containing
magnesium, NAC (a precursor to glutathione, said to be very helpful against COVID-19), vitamin C with lysine, proline, and B complex, folic acid, zinc, selenium, glutathione and caffeine (to combat the headache).
In a further obnoxious display of privilege, Dr. Namavar showed up in full hazmat gear at the same time as doctors and nurses working on the frontline in NYC hospitals were scrambling for PPE.
Again, these things don’t happen in a vacuum and plenty of nonsense remains on the website. Dr. Namavar practices “energy healing” and is “NADA certified in auricular acupuncture”. One of her partners, an M.D., practices so-called “Natural and Integrative Medicine”. They still advertise, among other services lacking adequate scientific backing, “Antiviral Infusions” as well as “Customized Cocktails”
to help rebalance your body, bring it back into homeostasis, and enhance cellular signaling.
They also practice so-called “functional medicine” which, they advertise,
Based on the results of your lab work, genetics, and symptoms, we suggest different options that elevate distinct aspects of your mood, lifestyle, and health.
The FTC cited Idaho D.O.s Christopher Peine and Peter Abraham for their promotion of “Low Dose Immunotherapy (LDI)” for treatment COVID. Their novel “discovery” was
that the body was actually responding to the COVID-19 proteins (viruses are not living organisms and are not dangerous to humans by themselves) and if we could tell the immune system to “tolerate” this protein, then we could stop the inflammatory response. . . . I decided to try this technique [previously used to “promote ‘immune tolerance’ to proteins that trigger allergies, autoimmune conditions, and inflammation”] for COVID-19 in the spring of 2020 with a mixture of coronavirus proteins from old strains of the virus.
And the results?
[S]o far, knock on wood, every patient I’ve tried it on has gotten better. Pretty much, either full resolution or near resolution, within literally hours to days.
But, as the FTC points out, they don’t have “competent and reliable scientific evidence” to support their claims and “must immediately cease”. Despite the FTC’s warning to review all of their claims, not just COVID, their clinic continues to offer LDI for chronic fatigue, endometriosis, “chronic Lyme” disease, and herpes, among other conditions. They, too, practice “functional medicine”.
Another D.O and FTC letter recipient, Texan Matthew Barker, apparently took a page from the chiropractic playbook by touting osteopathic manipulative treatment to “boost your immune system” and thereby help ward off COVID. Even more alarmingly, he claimed that an
all-natural herbal tea from Wei Labs may help prevent the Coronavirus from infecting individuals through immediate germ removal and immune support. The ingredients work together to remove germs from the throat, respiratory tract, and heart. At the same [sic], enhancing and supporting the immune system….”
Wei Labs got its own letter from the FTC about its teas and other concoctions, advertised as COVID preventatives and treatments. As the company’s website “explains”, from the Traditional Chinese Medicine viewpoint “the SARS-CoV2 virus and its infection-induced immune reaction is viewed as Cold Evil Qi” (sounds like a character in a James Bond movie). Wei Labs’ website cited ridiculous stats purportedly from an outfit called the National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine, such as the claim that one of its herbal formulas “has more than a 90% effective rate” in the treatment of patients diagnosed with coronavirus pneumonia.
Angelica Kokalis, an Indiana practitioner of acupuncture and TCM, who has a financial relationship with Wei Labs, was also the recipient of an FTC letter demanding she cease advertising Wei Labs products for the prevention and cure of COVID-19. She, like others, was warned to review all claims for all products she sells or is paid to promote and “immediately cease and desist making claims that are not supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence”, a review that should wipe out most of her website. Like others, she advertises many scientifically unfounded services and products, including TCM for tremors, COPD, cancer, allergies, facial paralysis, and in-vitro fertilization, among others.
Tracy Gapin, M.D., is a urologist and head of the “Gapin Institute for Elite Health and Performance”, which runs a “Precision Health Optimization & Performance Center” for men in Sarasota, Florida. Dr. Gapin, who seems fond of superlatives, was warned against advertising the “power of peptides” for “radically upgrading your health” by “boosting your immune system“, these peptides having “probably saved my life” when he personally contracted COVID, which he was “battling” but ultimately won “with Precision Health”.
In addition to physicians caught in the FTC’s net, a Texas nurse anesthetist, Glenn Cochrane, head of Krystal Anesthesia and Pain Specialists and an outfit called Infinity Functional Performance, which specializes in “lifestyle optimization”, got a letter warning him against advising that his protocol of vitamins, minerals, peptides, teas, and the drug famotidine “all available through my practice” will protect one against COVID-19. Mr. Cochrane continues to offer “functional medicine” and IV infusions such as Myers Cocktails and “Immune Boost” via his anesthesia practice. He sells dodgy diagnostics, like the “Saliva and Blood Hormone Home Test Kit”, and therapies like “testosterone replacement therapy monthly membership”. (It is not clear to me how these are within a nurse anesthetist’s scope of practice in Texas.)
In addition to actual physicians, “Dr. Monica Sava“, whose Ph.D. is in Measurement, Statistics and Evaluation, received an FTC letter for, among other things, selling
a very powerful tincture set [$500 for four tinctures!] that has now worked [for COVID] on a ton of people. And I do have a supplement protocol to boost your immune system. Aside from the fact that people taking my basic antiviral and medicinal Mushrooms have been healthy all year.
Although Connecticut does not have a Quack Protection Act, Sava certainly seems to me to be practicing medicine without a license. She offers “Holistic Immune and Lyme Healing”, which involves taking a health history and what she calls “addressing” various health issues such as “adrenal and thyroid issues”, “food allergies” and “overall inflammation” with “therapeutic grade” supplements sold through her website, all of which looks an awful lot like diagnosing and treating disease.
Like Sava, Tim Pendry of Sunshine Health Food and Wellness Center in Titusville, Florida, does not hold any health care practitioner license or, as best I can tell, have any education or training in medicine. He nevertheless felt free to dispense medical advice on the prevention and treatment of COVID, including the use of colloidal silver and dietary supplements, along with his unfavorable analysis of vaccines and pharmaceutical drugs. (Florida doesn’t have a Quack Protection Act either.) Although the FTC told him to cut that out, he still dispenses advice on topics like “when is the appropriate time to take a Statin based on blood work results” and offer diagnostics like cholesterol testing and something called “bloodwork analysis” and “blood typing”.
While we should be glad that the FTC is vigorously attacking the problem, quackery was not invented during the pandemic. Yet there seems to have been a far more aggressive effort to combat COVID quackery than, say, cancer quackery, neuroscience quackery, naturopathic quackery, or stem cell quackery. Regulators need take a more holistic approach (if I may use that term) to the problem by disciplining physicians and other professionals who promote all sorts of nonsense as well as enforcing laws against practicing medicine without a license. Congress and the state legislatures should get rid of laws that countenance quackery, like naturopathic practice acts, quack protection acts, DSHEA, and laws dumbing down the standard of care. Finally, the VA, medical schools, and other organizations (looking at you, Cleveland Clinic) should stop promoting “complementary, alternative and integrative medicine”, which encourages belief in unscientific gibberish like “energy healing”. Had the government and other institutions not so-enamored the public with “CAM” and “integrative medicine”, COVID scofflaws wouldn’t have had such a fertile field on which to sow their dangerous mischief.

*Links to all FTC COVID-19 warning letters can be found in the press release. The letters provide links to the offending websites and other internet sources of misinformation. I have not added links to the individual warning letters or the offending materials in this post, as there are so many and they are easily available from the FTC’s list, but do link to non-COVID claims. I checked to see whether some, but not all, of the offending claims have been removed. I did not check to see whether the individuals or companies have otherwise responded to the FTC.

Are the FDA’s VRBPAC and the CDC’s ACIP hopelessly compromised by conflicts of interest over COVID-19 vaccines?
The FDA’s VRBPAC and the CDC’s ACIP are the two main committees that approve vaccines to be sold in the US and issue recommendations regarding who should receive them and when. In the wake of the recent recommendation that children 5-11 receive the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is now portraying committee members as thralls of big pharma. But are they? Let’s just say that RFK Jr…distorts, exaggerates, and poisons the well.
David Gorski on November 29, 2021
Link

Here in the US, as Sunday of a long Thanksgiving holiday weekend rolled around, I was debating what to write about or even if to update and recycle a post from my not-so-super-secret other blog. (Clearly, with the tryptophan hangover persisting, I wasn’t up to do any in-depth analyses of some of the newer statistical nonsense out there about how COVID-19 vaccines are supposedly killing more people than they save, but fear not. I do intend to get to that at some point because it’s more misuse of VAERS, only on mega-doses of steroids.) Then I saw a rather long post over on one of Children’s Health Defense (CHD), the website of one of the oldest and most influential antivaxxers out there, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., and I knew I had my topic. The article was published the day before Thanksgiving and is titled “14 ACIP Members Who Voted to Jab Your Young Children — and Their Big Ties to Big Pharma“. Unlike most articles on CHD, it’s not credited to any single author, but rather to the Children’s Health Defense Team. Whenever I see that credit, I can’t help but speculate that maybe no one wanted to take personal credit for this article because it’s so misleading and bad, but then I remember: This is RFK Jr.’s website. Misleading is his business model.
Then I saw that there was a second article with the same theme credited to the same team, “17 Pharma Henchmen Who Voted to Experiment on Your Kids — and How to Shun Them“. This article is referring to the members of the US Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA’s) Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC), the committee that had previous decided to issue an emergency use authorization (EUA) for the Pfizer vaccine for children aged 5-11. I was sensing a theme.
But back to the first article that had caught my attention. It was referring to the decision announced by the Center for Disease Control’s (CDC’s) Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) earlier this month to recommend the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine for children 5-11 years of age after VRBPAC had decided to recommend the EUA for that age group. ACIP reviewed the evidence regarding the balance of benefits versus risks in vaccinating children 5-11 years old and concluded that the benefits outweigh the risks. Naturally, as has been the case all along with any decision by the FDA’s VRBPAC and CDC’s ACIP to expand the EUA for COVID-19 vaccines, this announcement didn’t sit well with antivaxxers like RFK Jr., leading to articles like the one on the CHD website, with an “editor’s note” saying:
EDITOR’S NOTE: Following the Oct. 26 meeting of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC), Children’s Health Defense argued it is time to shun the individuals — and institutions — that are selling out America’s children without even a prick of conscience. At the close of this article about the members of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC’s) Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), we reiterate our list of suggestions for shunning.
I can’t resist a bit of snark here by expressing my amusement how the editor of CHD linked the word “conscience” to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary definition of the word. That’s some world-class argumentation there! I’m torn between wondering if CHD did this just to appear more authoritative or if its editor thinks its readers are too ignorant to know the definition of the word “conscience”. Take your pick.
Still, the reason I was drawn to these articles is because they collectively demonstrate a lot about the antivaccine mentality. First of all, as I have argued many times before, if all science denial is based in conspiracy theory (and it is), then the denial of the safety and efficacy of vaccines is science denial on steroids, at least when it comes to the conspiracy theory aspect. The central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement is simple, when boiled down to its essence, but can rapidly become very complicated as the various layers of conspiracy theory are piled on. In brief, the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement posits that vaccines are harmful and ineffective, but that “they” don’t want you to know about it, the “they” behind the coverup apparently being big pharma, doctors, the FDA, the CDC, various state medical boards, basically every legitimate medical professional society (as opposed to faux medical professional societies functioning as ideological advocacy groups disguised as medical societies—like the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, or AAPS). The motivations behind the efforts of “them” to promote vaccination—and, of course, suppress the “truth about vaccines” showing how horrible and ineffective they are—include, as always, money and the “pharma shill gambit“, but also a desire for power, tyranny, and “control”.
None of this is to argue that conflicts of interest (COIs) aren’t important, particularly undisclosed conflicts of interest. Indeed, I have argued for a broader definition of such COIs, which is one reason why when I co-authored a BMJ article about the American Institute for Economic Research‘s (AIER’s) role in drafting the eugenics-adjacent Great Barrington Declaration as part of the new merchants of doubt, I insisted on including in the disclosures section my role as editor of this blog and a mention that I had previously written posts critical of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD). It’s also why I keep harping on AIER, despite its insistence that it never paid the GBD signatories, to publicly reveal whether it paid for their travel and lodging. However, such a broader definition of COI is not what antivaxxers are about, as you will see. CHD’s message is that 14 members of ACIP have “deep ties” to pharma. But do they?
Before ACIP and its “pharma ties,” some antivaccine nonsense
You can tell where CHD is coming from right from the opening volley in its ACIP article, which is full of sound and fury, signifying nothing (at least not any reasonable scientific objections):
On Nov. 2, the members of ACIP voted 14–0 to recommend Pfizer’s Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) COVID shot for children 5 –11 years old.
Committee members readily voted “yes” despite many unknowns about long-term safety, including a complete lack of data on the risk of heart problems like the ones experienced by some adolescents who received COVID vaccines.
Neither the disgracefully unscientific vote nor CDC Director Rochelle Walensky’s prompt endorsement came as a surprise. Though billed as “independent,” the 14 ACIP members — like the 17 members of FDA’s VRBPAC who voted the same way the previous week — have deep ties to pharma, with careers that hinge on promoting and rubber-stamping the United States’ destructive one-size-fits-all vaccination agenda.
Describing the VRBPAC and ACIP meetings as “a total sham,” Children’s Health Defense President Mary Holland said, “Sadly, approval from these committees means nothing in terms of safety.”
Political scientist Toby Rogers agreed, stating the ACIP meeting “was not a scientific review. It was banal bureaucrats announcing plans for a Blitzkrieg and the bought white coats were cheering them on.”
With their vote to give young children the dangerous injections, ACIP members signaled that they, too, deserve to be shunned, along with the powerful institutions with which they are affiliated. The latter include the nation’s top universities and leading pediatric hospitals.
I couldn’t help but note the addition of the word “Blitzkrieg” in the introduction. It’s actually a rather subtle Godwin for antivaxxers (no mention of Nuremberg…yet) and adds just the right touch of comparing vaccine advocates to Nazis, and no antivaccine screed would be complete without that. The visual imagery lurking in the background, though, is unmistakably Adolf Hitler giving a speech to cheering crowds about invading Poland.
Given the gravity of the charge, namely that all these ACIP members are so utterly compromised by filthy pharma lucre and/or “deep ties” to pharma, I was expecting something more. I had to wait, because next CHD went on to rant:
Without exception, all the universities at which ACIP members have appointments — Brown, Drexel, Harvard, Michigan State, Ohio State, Stanford, University of Maryland, University of Washington, Vanderbilt and Wake Forest — have mandated COVID vaccines.
Oh, dear. So has my university! Whatever will I do? I must be hopelessly compromised! No, wait! I had zero to do with my university’s decision. Of course, I fully approve of the vaccine mandate at my university. Indeed, if anything, I don’t think it goes quite far enough, because it allows for religious exemptions in addition to medical exemptions, but I realize that’s a fight vaccine advocates in few areas are likely to win in the current political environment. In any event, this charge is rather silly even by CHD standards. Where’s the evidence that any of these ACIP members had anything to do with drafting the COVID-19 vaccine requirements at these universities, and even if any of them did, so what? Apparently to CHD, you can only be “free of COI” in this respect if you actively opposed the COVID-19 vaccine mandate at your university. I also can’t help but mention, even if it might cause me some trouble if certain people read this, that I was very disappointed in both of the major hospitals where I work for being very slow to require COVID-19 vaccination of their doctors, nurses, and staff. (One of them only just requested that I upload my vaccination card before December 1.) Would that make me more acceptable as an ACIP member to RFK Jr.? Somehow, I doubt it. Funny how COIs like this only work in one direction, though.
It’s also funny how before getting to “naming names,” the CHD Team Gish gallops through a veritable antivaccine “greatest hits” about COVID-19 vaccines, including citing Paul Thacker’s awful and highly deceptive BMJ “investigation” claiming sloppy research practices at a clinical research organization (CRO) subcontracted by Pfizer last year to run three sites (out of 153) doing the initial phase 3 clinical trial of its vaccine, claims about the use of “fetal cell lines” in developing COVID-19 vaccines, and, of course, the “toxins” gambit, this time with a hilarious bit that, I must admit, I had never heard before:
Equally disturbingly, Strickler McAtee told other journalists that Pfizer’s vaccine exhibits an unusual fluorescent blue glow, stating she had “never once [previously] seen anything do that, not even close” during her 10-year career inspecting “hundreds of thousands of units” of vaccines. She also reports that her co-workers at the plant are being unprecedentedly kept in the dark about what the vaccine’s ingredients are.
Unsurprisingly, both articles come from conspiracy sites like LifeSite News. It was also McAtee, whoever she is, is claiming that there’s luciferase in the Pfizer vaccine. Here’s the thing. Luciferase is an enzyme that takes a substrate and then converts it into a luminescent—not fluorescent—compound. In fact, there are multiple different kinds of luciferase, the most commonly used type being the enzyme that fireflies use to produce that pretty glow at night, although another common type comes from the sea pansy. They are, in fact, very “natural” in that they are enzymes that were found in nature. Scientists recognized their usefulness as markers of gene expression for experiments; so they isolated and cloned the genes for these enzymes and plopped them into various plasmid expression vectors. Here’s the thing. None of these enzymes produce bioluminescence—again, not fluorescence—unless the substrate for the enzyme is present and the temperature is correct. Basically, none of the COVID-19 vaccines contain luciferase, and even if they did they wouldn’t glow because they don’t contain the substrate, and even if they did contain substrate, they’d have to be at room temperature (or, better yet 37°C) to produce their characteristic luminescence. (The Pfizer COVID vaccine needs to be stored at -70°C or at least on dry ice.)
And, no, the fact that those making this claim about a “blue glow” cite a paper from last year describing the discovery of a previously undescribed type luciferase produced by the larvae of cave worms that produced blue bioluminescence does not make this nonsense any more plausible. That the sources cite such a paper tells me that either they are ignorant of the science or know that their readers are ignorant and don’t know that there are a number of kinds of luciferase. (Take your pick.) In any event, this kind of luciferase is not used in biological research as a marker. So even if the Pfizer vaccine contained luciferase (which it does not) it would not contain this specific luciferase enzyme, which is why I laughed heartily when I read this:
Strickler told LifeSite that she emailed the company and asked if luciferase was in the Covid vaccine and was told that it was “only used in the testing of the vaccine,” but would not be included in the final product. “But the way I see this is the whole thing is experimental,” Strickler said.
Again, the sorts of luciferase enzymes used in many molecular biology generally produce a greenish-yellow or red light, you know, just like the firefly species from which it originated! It is true that Renilla luciferase, which is sometimes used as a marker, produces more of a green to greenish-blue glow, which is why it is often used with in dual luciferase assays with firefly luciferase when two different colors are needed to distinguish two different reactions, but in general firefly luciferase is the workhorse, so much so that when scientists say “luciferase” it’s generally assumed that they mean firefly luciferase. If they don’t, they will specify the type of luciferase. I discussed the use of luciferase in the testing of the Pfizer vaccine a lot more here. The only reason I spent a couple of paragraphs on this nonsense is to demonstrate that CHD is going to spew unrelated antivax misinformation, even when it’s trying to tar ACIP members as pharma shills. RFK Jr. and his minions just can’t help themselves.
Then there’s this:
Pediatric hospitals, meanwhile, are playing a frontline role as COVID vaccination sites. Promoting the injection for 5-year-olds, First Lady Jill Biden visited Texas Children’s Hospital straight away, applauding the hospital for the 39,000 pediatric vaccine appointments it had already scheduled.
Also worthy of shunning are the 20,000 individual vaccine providers who were pre-positioned to “hit the ground running” and “get shots in little arms.”
Within two days of ACIP’s and Walensky’s verdicts, these providers had administered the jab to thousands of 5- to 11-year-olds, and within the first week, according to the White House, 900,000 children had been injected.
It’s also funny—but not surprising—that CHD views advocating for vaccines and being ready to vaccinate children against a serious infectious disease as bad things, something so horrible that either of them should disqualify you from serving on ACIP and make you worthy of “shunning.” With that background, let’s move on to see what CHD views as so horrible that shunning is demanded.
“Conflicts of interest”
So CHD has two articles, one on ACIP members and one on the members of the FDA’s Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC, the committee that decides to issue EUAs or full approval for vaccines and other biological products) alleging horrific COIs. Because between the two committees there are 31 members and both articles are long, I decided to look for the absolute worst, most damning “COIs” that RFK Jr. and his minions could come up with, although I will start with the chairs of both committees. First, here’s CHD about ACIP’s chair Dr. Grace Lee:
Dr. Grace Lee ([email protected]) chaired the November ACIP deliberations. Lee has been associate chief medical officer for practice innovation at Stanford Children’s Health and a pediatrics professor at Stanford School of Medicine since 2017, after having spent two decades at Harvard and Boston-area hospitals.
In addition to policy work focusing on financial rewards and penalties to reshape hospital performance, Lee has built her reputation by shoring up the pretense that the nation has a functioning vaccine safety surveillance system.
Lee served as past principal investigator for the CDC’s Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), a large database that includes comprehensive longitudinal medical and vaccination records for two million children and seven million adults. Although VSD analyses have the potential to permit enlightening vaccinated-unvaccinated comparisons of health outcomes, the CDC has sole access to the data.
Where I see someone with fantastic qualifications to chair ACIP, having actually run one of the largest vaccine safety surveillance systems in the US, antivaxxers of course see a hopelessly conflicted person. First, it’s a lie that the CDC has “sole access” to VSD data. It does not. In fact, the CDC does not control who gets access to VSD data. The National Center for Health Statistics Research Data Center (NCHS RDC) does, as I will discuss. To lead to this, I like to point to an example from 2003, when antivax father-and-son grifters Mark and David Geier got access to VSD data and were busted trying to merge different VSD datasets in a way that could have potentially linked personally identifiable fields to adverse events reports, an analysis that was not included in the institutional review board (IRB)-approved protocol. (They also tried to abscond with renamed files.) At the time, the Geiers were looking for evidence in the VSD that thimerosal-containing vaccines were linked with an increased risk of autism. Funny how CHD doesn’t mention that part when complaining about the VSD.
In any event, any investigator who wants to can access publicly available VSD datasets. For more analyses not possible with those datasets, investigators can submit a research proposal to NCHS RDC and the IRBs of the relevant participating VSD sites using a process described in more detail here. Note again that the CDC doesn’t actually even control access to the data. Basically, if CHD wants access to VSD data, all they have to do is to develop a scientifically and ethically sound research protocol and submit it to the RDC and the relevant IRBs. One wonders why they haven’t. (Actually, I at least do not.)
Now let’s look at VRBPAC’s chair:
Dr. Arnold Monto ([email protected]) is professor of public health and epidemiology at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. Monto has been acting chair for VRBPAC’s COVID-19 vaccine deliberations since October 2020. Previously, he was a four-year VRBPAC member (through January 2020).
Monto was a key player in pandemic planning and response for many decades, including during past headline-grabbing pandemics (real or invented) such as the 1968 Hong Kong influenza, bird flu, severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) and Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS).
Monto is a key proponent of the unproven theory that schoolchildren must be vaccinated to achieve “herd immunity.”
He was a full member of VRBPAC and has been a key player in pandemic planning and response for decades? He, too, certainly sounds eminently qualified to me to be chairing his committee. But not to CHD, obiously.
So tell us more, cranks:
Notably, the University of Michigan houses the nation’s #5-ranked School of Public Health and one of the country’s largest university health systems. In 2020, the university received $144 million in revenue via the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act — most of which (94%) was associated with the Provider Relief Fund administered by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The CARES monies represent an amount nearly equal to what the university received in private gifts ($149 million) from foundations and others.
The University of Michigan has been embroiled in a massive sex abuse scandal, with allegations that it covered up decades of abuse by the university’s late athletic physician Robert Anderson — reportedly “the largest scale of sexual abuse by a single person in U.S. history.”
Let’s see. Just because U. of M., one of the top medical schools in the country and arguably the top public medical school in the country—and I’m not just saying that because I graduated from there—received lots of coronavirus aid money and receives lots of federal grant funding, Dr. Monto is…conflicted? Seriously, this is the same sort of “law of contagion”-like COI to which I’ve been subjected. You might remember that because my university received a large grant from Sanofi-Aventis antivaxxers tried to portray me as hopelessly in the pocket of big pharma, even though I never got even a tiny taste of that sweet sweet pharma lucre and had nothing to do with the research projects funded.
Here’s the worst RFK Jr. could apparently come up with about Dr. Monto:
    • Monto founded and co-directs the University of Michigan-based Michigan Influenza Center, one of five centers across the country that collects data for CDC.
    • Monto has served as principal investigator on studies funded by CDC, the National NIH and Sanofi Pasteur.
    • According to POGO and Open Payments, between 2014–2020, Monto received 117 payments totaling more than $176,000 (65% for consulting and speaking fees) from Pfizer as well as Seqirus, Hoffmann-La Roche, Sanofi, Genentech, Novartis and Shionogi.
    • Monto has consulted for the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA).
    • In earlier clinical trials (2006–2008 and 2011–2013), Monto laid the groundwork for the “nonpharmaceutical interventions” that have been brought to the fore during COVID (e.g., masking, “sequestration” and social distancing).
So I’ll accept that receiving consulting fees is a legitimate COI, but it’s not an undisclosed COI as far as I can tell. Similarly, having served as PI of a Sanofi Pasteur study is a legitimate COI. Even so, is this so “conflicted” that Dr. Monto would steer the committee towards whatever pharma wants? Hardly. I also find it odd that the mention of his having received consulting fees from pharmaceutical companies is buried in a list of bullet points, rather than front and center, given that this is arguably a COI, while the other “COIs” that CHD rants about are not. It just goes to show how warped RFK Jr.’s perspective is.
Let’s see some of the other “worst” COIs, starting with this VRBPAC member:
Dr. Hayley Gans ([email protected]) is a professor of pediatrics at Stanford University Medical Center and has served on VRBPAC since mid-2019. Gans has been at Stanford since her medical internship and residency in the early 1990s.
In 2015, Stanford received $50 million from the Gates Foundation to “accelerate” efforts in vaccine development. Unsurprisingly, Gans is a staunch vaccine proponent, stating, “History and science support vaccines as one of the safest and most effective infectious disease prevention strategies, second to clean water.”
The bulk of Gans’ research and publications focus on infant immunity and the “challenges of tailoring vaccines and effective immunizations for young children,” notably measles vaccines made by Merck.
Gans advocates vaccinating severely immunocompromised children and adults, including those about to receive organ transplants.
At the December 2020 meeting at which VRBPAC recommended Pfizer’s first EUA, Gans initially expressed reservations about including 16- and 17-year-olds but then voted with the majority anyway in favor of the vaccine for those 16 and up.
Note again the homeopathy-like “law of contagion”-style COI: Just because Stanford University received money from the “evil” Gates Foundation, Dr. Gans must be hopelessly conflicted. (You know that if CHD could show that she had received any of that money herself they’d have been all over it; in fact, at the time Dr. Mark Davis was running the center that got the money to develop new vaccines.)
Dr. Gans did get $4,700 from GlaxoSmithKline, which seems to be a pretty small price to agree to be a pharma shill, and apparently consulted with Merck, but here’s the thing. Few are the heavy hitter scientists who’ve never, ever in their entire career accepted money from pharmaceutical companies to fund research. Also horrible to CHD is the fact that Dr. Gans has received funding/grant support from the National Institute of Health’s National Vaccine Program Office and has consulted for Department of Health and Human Services. Again, one thing that antivaxxers frequently get wrong is their belief that if you’ve ever received grant funding from the NIH you must be hopelessly in the pocket of the powers-that-be. They don’t understand that, for instance, NIH grant applications go through multiple rigorous levels of review, starting with a study section review, and that reviewers really do concentrate almost exclusively on the science, not your belief system.
I rapidly got tired of all the innuendo that had nothing to do with any payments from pharmaceutical companies; so I went through and looked for just that. The following ACIP members were reported to have received payments from pharmaceutical companies: Oliver Brooks, Wilbur Chen, Camille Kotton, Katherine Poehling, Pablo Sanchez, and Helen Keipp Talbot. In addition, the following VRBPAC members received funding from pharmaceutical companies: Arthur Monto, Hayley Gans, Ofer Levy, Michael Nelson, Steven Pergam, and Jay Portnoy. Of course, both VRBPAC and ACIP have very stringent reporting requirements governed by the Federal Advisory Committee Act, in which all advisory committee members are required to report all paid or unpaid positions and all income or gifts greater than $1,000.
Indeed, the COI regulations are so stringent that even CHD had to admit that pharma’s representative on VRBPAC, Paula Annunziato of Merck, is a non-voting member. That’s right, pharma is represented on VRBPAC, but only as non-voting members.
Meanwhile for other members, CHD goes all “law of contagion” again:
Dr. H.. Cody Meissner ([email protected]) is professor of pediatrics and chief of pediatric infectious disease at Boston’s Tufts University School of Medicine, an institution to which he appears quite loyal.
After going to medical school at Tufts in the early 1970s, Meissner remained in Boston for postgraduate training at Boston Floating Hospital, Dana Farber and Harvard, devoting a brief two years to NIH before accepting a faculty position at Tufts in 1979.
Since 2014, Tufts Medical Center has received more than $14 million in “general payments” from companies that include Boston Scientific, Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals, Jansswen, Biogen, Amgen, Pfizer, Gyrus Acmi, Sanofi, Otsuka and Genentech.
More significantly, Tufts has received more than $38.5 million in research payments — with Pfizer as the top funder (12% of total). Other biopharma companies providing research monies include Merck, Gilead, Shire, Takeda, Abiomed, Otsuka, Novartis and AbbVie.
And:
    • Meissner has served on ACIP since 2008 as well as on various committees of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), a medical trade group notorious for its own conflicts of interest.
    • Since 2010, Meissner has sat on the Massachusetts Vaccine Purchasing Advisory Council and, since 2017, on HHS’s National Vaccine Advisory Committee.
These are bad things exactly…why?
Then there’s this:
Patrick Moore, M.D., MPH ([email protected]) has been a professor of microbiology and medical genetics at the University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute (UPCI) since 2002. Pittsburgh is home to influential foundations such as the Richard King Mellon Foundation — which just announced a $150 million grant for the city’s development of science, technology, robotics and manufacturing — and the Pittsburgh Foundation. Moore holds the Pittsburgh Foundation Endowed Chair in Innovative Cancer Research.
Moore had a varied career prior to settling at Pittsburgh, including (like CDC’s Amanda Cohn) a two-year stint as a CDC EIS officer (in the “special pathogens” branch), some time at CDC’s Fort Collins lab, two years as Deputy Commissioner for the New York City Department of Health and eight years in Columbia University’s epidemiology division.
See the game here? If you are faculty at a medical school that has ever received pharmaceutical funding, particularly from Pfizer, you’re hopelessly conflicted. Again, this is no different than what antivaxxers tried to do to me 11 years ago. It’s worse than that, though. If your university has ever received grants from any foundation that RFK Jr. doesn’t like, again you’re hopelessly conflicted. RFK Jr. also either doesn’t understand or knows that his readers don’t understand (take your pick) the nature of endowed chairs, in which the endowment-granting agency has no say over who is chosen for the chair or how the funding for the chair is used.
Then there’s this:
Melinda Wharton, M.D., MPH ([email protected]), the second CDC member of VRBPAC, is director of the Immunization Services Division in the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases. Wharton’s training spans Harvard, Johns Hopkins, the University of Michigan and Duke University.
Wharton’s entrée into CDC was as an EIS officer in the mid-1980s, followed by “positions of increasing responsibility” in CDC’s immunization program through the present day.
The Defender reported in January that concomitant with the plummeting vaccination rates triggered by COVID lockdowns was “an overall drop in reports of infant vaccine adverse events,” including “a precipitous drop in Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) reports” — the lowest yearly number recorded in the history of the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS).
This good news did not stop Wharton from fretting over “lagging” childhood vaccination rates.
The claim that lagging vaccination rates had decreased the rate of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) comes from the deceptive use of statistics by two antivaxxers, Amy Becker and Mark Blaxill. The claim that vaccines cause SIDS is a longstanding one in the antivaccine movement that’s led grieving mothers to become antivaccine activists. The bottom line is that vaccines, if anything, likely protect against SIDS; at the very worst we know that the are not linked with it. Of course, to RFK Jr., Dr. Wharton’s real sin is to be long serving high ranking career official at the CDC, given that the CDC is one of the triumvirate of key villains of the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement. (The other two are the FDA and the American Academy of Pediatrics.)
CHD seems especially peeved at members of these two committees who don’t have identifiable financial COIs but are interested in health disparities and equity in access to health care. In one case, ACIP’s Beth Bell, they go to rather ridiculous extremes:
At UW, Bell is on faculty at the UW Alliance for Pandemic Preparedness (formerly called, until fall 2020, the MetaCenter for Pandemic Preparedness and Global Health Security), which “harness[es] big data and forward-thinking strategies to devise more unified approaches to current and future health security risks.”
“Health security” and biosecurity are the linchpin buzzwords that global technocrats are using to push for complete control over people’s “ability to work, to socialize, to travel, conduct business, access public services and to purchase essential goods and services.”
Like many of the individuals who make their way onto FDA and CDC committees, Bell started her CDC career as an officer in the Epidemic Intelligence Service (EIS), a branch that journalist Jon Rappoport has dubbed the “medical CIA.”
As Rappoport notes, EIS graduates’ occupancy of “key positions in the overall medical cartel” furnishes an “unparalleled opportunity” to control information — and disseminate disinformation.
You see where this is going, right? Of course, as I’ve described before, Jon Rappoport is a major antivaccine conspiracy theorist. Examples of his misinformation include claims that COVID-19 vaccines are part of a “global depopulation agenda“. Before the pandemic, Rappoport was known for having promoted conspiracy theories about Ebola and claims that the tetanus vaccine was an example of “racist population control” in Kenya based on the false antivax claim that the vaccine was sterilizing young women.
It gets “better”:
Bell’s comments about wanting to make sure “socially vulnerable” communities and people of color have access to COVID shots echo troubling racially oriented remarks made by Melinda Gates early on in the pandemic. Located in Gates’ backyard, UW not only benefits from close ties with and extensive funding from the Gates Foundation — an organization tainted by allegations of medical experimentation and an underlying eugenicist ideology — but also enjoys extensive support from Microsoft.
The theme emerges again. Not only is Bell somehow tainted because UW receives funding from the Gates Foundation, but she is linked to a “eugenicist agenda.” Where did that come from? It came from a reasonable speculation by Bill Gates about hard trade-offs about funding medical care, particularly in the last three months of life:
You’re raising tuitions at the University of California as rapidly as they can and so the access that used to be available to the middle class or whatever is just rapidly going away. That’s a trade-off society’s making because of very, very high medical costs and a lack of willingness to say, you know, “Is spending a million dollars on that last three months of life for that patient—would it be better not to lay off those 10 teachers and to make that trade off in medical cost?” But that’s called the “death panel” and you’re not supposed to have that discussion.
Asking this question is, of course, not “eugenicist,” but a simple question of financial trade-offs versus ethics. No one is saying not to provide any end-of-life care, but it is questionable whether very expensive heroic care benefits either the dying or society. This is a discussion that bioethicists deal with all the time, but because Bill Gates brought it up it’s “eugenicist.” Of course, the irony is that it is the antivaxxers who advocate, rather than vaccinating as much of the population as possible, just letting the virus rip through the population in order to achieve “natural herd immunity,” never mind that such a strategy will result in millions more deaths around the world. Truly, it is antivaxxers who are the eugenicists.
What is to be done?
Far be it from me to deny that financial COIs are important and should be disclosed, even if they are small. I cringe whenever I hear colleagues claim that their judgment is not at all affected by tangible rewards, be they financial or just meals or pharma tchotchkes like pens, mugs, or folders. Such denial is usually based in hubris, the belief that one is immune to normal human tendencies that research has demonstrated again and again. Issues of regulatory capture and “revolving doors” between academia, government, and pharma are real concerns.
That being said, it is not real-world practical solutions to these problems that RFK Jr. is looking for when he castigates ACIP and VRBPAC members as mindless pharma shills who’ve sold out our children. Among the issues of research and consulting payments from pharma that some of the members of these two committees have received (which make up a shockingly small proportion of the two articles), he basically tries to poison the well against everybody by throwing anything he can find against the wall and seeing if it will stick, including trying to tar anyone whose university has ever accepted research funding from a pharmaceutical company (related to vaccines or not), the Gates Foundation, or any other foundation that RFK Jr. deems to be evil, whether the member received any of that funding or not. Again, I’ve been at the receiving end of this tactic in my own way, even though I never received even a tiny portion of the largess that my university received. I refer to the “law of contagion” from homeopathy to describe this, because that’s what it reminds me of. Apparently if a university has ever been in contact with pharmaceutical company money, it is hopelessly compromised, and therefore every one of its faculty is hopelessly compromised. That is patently ridiculous, but antivaxxers eat it up.
Finally, given the current capitalist society that we have, no major scientific breakthrough can be turned into a widely available medical product or device that can benefit the populace without the involvement of pharmaceutical and device companies. As a result, the heaviest hitters in medicine and medical science will often have consulted for or received research funding from pharmaceutical or device companies, sometimes substantial amounts, just because they want to see their discoveries turned into medicines, vaccines, or devices that benefit humanity. There are a number of possible responses to this issue, such as more public funding of research, with government and universities getting a share of the returns from any products developed, as well as more rigorous reporting of potential financial conflicts of interest. Again, practical, workable, real-world solutions to real issues are not what RFK Jr. is about. What he is about is demonizing VRBPAC and ACIP members as greedy pharma drones who decided to issue an EUA for the Pfizer vaccine for children aged 5-11 not because they believed that the data show that the benefits outweigh the risks, but rather because of greed.
        ◦ That’s because part of the central conspiracy of the antivaccine movement is that no one can ever be pro-vaccine because of a rational evaluation of the risk-benefit ratio of vaccinating. It must be because they are blinded by ideology or in the pockets of big pharma, and these CHD articles reflect that. In fact, I would say that it is RFK Jr. and his antivaccine propagandists who should be shunned, not any of the members of VRBPAC or ACIP.

Why are physicians threatened by efforts to report doctors to their state medical board for COVID-19 misinformation?
It’s not “cancel culture” to delicense physicians promoting dangerous misinformation about COVID-19. It’s quality control. Why do so many physicians think it is?
David Gorski on January 17, 2022
Link

We at SBM have long lamented how physicians can practice quackery and promote pseudoscience while spreading medical conspiracy theories and only rarely do state medical boards do anything concrete to stop them. Indeed, so uncommon is it for a state medical board to suspend or revoke the license of even the worst quacks that, when a quack does suffer sanctions from his state medical board, we tend to write about it here. Examples include when Florida revoked the license of a “Lyme literate” doctor and New York sanctioned other promoters of the fake diagnosis that is “chronic Lyme disease“. (Of note, one of those New York doctors sued Jann Bellamy and the editors of SBM, also naming some of us who had long ago left or retired from this blog, for having written about him.) Surprisingly to me, even pediatricians and other doctors who are leaders of the antivaccine movement have largely escaped discipline from their state medical boards, to the point that it is noteworthy when they are actually disciplined, with the example of Dr. Bob Sears and Dr. Paul Thomas coming to mind.
Counterexamples also come to mind, such as Dr. Rashid Buttar, who treated autistic children and cancer patients with chelation therapy and referred to the North Carolina Medical Board as a “rabid dog“. Two years later, he was free to practice again (mostly) unencumbered, having signed a consent decree with the Board that reprimanded him and ordered him (1) to provide informed consent to his patients as dictated by the Board; (2) to obey all laws, as well as rules and regulations governing the practice of medicine in North Carolina; (3) to notify the Board if he changes his address; and (4) to meet with the board periodically. And don’t even get me started on cancer quack Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, who has been treating patients with his ineffective “antineoplastons” for 45 years now, with at least three attempts by the Texas Medical Board failing to stop the harm, the most recent attempt ending with a consent decree in 2017 after four years. Meanwhile, doctors peddling COVID-19 misinformation, such as Dr. Lee Merritt, COVID-19 quack Dr. Simone Gold, and long-time antivax “leader” Dr. Sherri Tenpenny, are easily renewing their medical licenses. (Tenpenny has long referred to vaccines as a method of “mass destruction” and “depopulation” and more recently actually claimed that COVID-19 vaccines make you magnetic, if you remember that gem from last year.) Worse, COVID-19 denying and quackery-friendly legislators are trying to hamstring state medical boards.
In the months after the pandemic first hit in 2020, many of my colleagues were shocked to see the number of physicians promoting outright misinformation and even antivaccine quackery about COVID-19. They shouldn’t have been. This was completely foreseeable if only they had been paying attention. So was the shock expressed by colleagues that, for example, America’s Frontline Doctors (the ones pushing hydroxychloroquine in 2020 and ivermectin last year whose number included the infamous “demon sperm” doctor) didn’t suffer any consequences. Quite the opposite, in fact. One of them, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, was nominated to take charge of the public health bureaucracy in Florida, where he is now implementing all manner of unscientific and dangerous COVID-19 policies. That’s why I was heartened to see colleagues wake up to the threat of misinformation and the promotion of quackery, as manifested by the formation of No License for Disinformation, founded by Dr. Nick Sawyer and colleagues, whose goal is to change the current situation, in which doctors promoting COVID-19-related disinformation have faced virtually no consequences so far. Of course, I have argued that NLFD doesn’t go far enough and that this effort shouldn’t be primarily restricted to just COVID-19 misinformation and quackery, but do welcome the baby steps towards a more general effort to hold quacks accountable.
You’d think that the vast majority of doctors would approve of a renewed effort to purge our profession of dangerous doctors practicing COVID-19 quackery and promoting harmful misinformation. I like to hope that you’d be right, but lately I’ve been seeing a number of doctors who are very disturbed by NLFD and have been expressing their unease in op-eds and on social media. I’ve been seeing more and more of this after a Maine physician named Dr. Meryl Nass had her license suspended for promoting COVID-19 disinformation, although certainly there are doctors who agree with me:
Regulatory action for physicians who spread #COVID #misinformation:
Maine is right! This needs to become standard. We witness the routine ruining of lives & families that occurs when people are victims of misinformation and scientific untruths.
Boundaries must protect. #Safety https://t.co/NRVlXfMQb4
— WesElyMD (@WesElyMD) January 13, 2022
There were others who were—shall we say?—much less enthusiastic about this development. Why is this? Why are some doctors so uncomfortable over the idea of state medical boards sanctioning doctors who promote COVID-19 disinformation? Doctors, after all, hold a special high status in society. Because of our medical expertise, physicians’ medical credentials lend credence to their pronouncements and, when physicians promote pseudoscience and quackery, their assumed expertise is trusted by much of the public.
“Cancel culture” vs. quality control
So what do I mean by doctors who come across as threatened by an effort to hold COVID-19 disinformation-promoting doctors accountable? Of course, there were predictable responses like this from non-physicians, which were easy to dismiss:
Maine’s medical licensing board. How much were they paid to do this? They are a disgrace. Free speech is dead America. Wake up
— delete (@coffeejones123) January 13, 2022
You seem blissfully unaware that pretty much everything written off as a conspiracy theory has been subsequently proven to be correct.
Maybe a little less righteous indignation and more critical thinking would be a good thing for you.
— Bob Johnston (@Lunatic__Fringe) January 13, 2022
I do so love how conspiracy theorists love to claim that every conspiracy was a “conspiracy theory” that was later shown to be correct. One key difference between conspiracies and conspiracy theories is that conspiracies have strong evidence to support that there was an actual conspiracy.
There were, however, reactions like this from doctors:
Should doctors lose their license for misinformation? Sure, if you can distinguish between science and morality https://t.co/1XG6AyRbFA
— Saurabh Jha (@RogueRad) January 12, 2022
To be honest, I wasn’t sure what Dr. Jha’s point about this was. Moral arguments can be just as misleading if they use pseudoscience, conspiracy theories, and quackery to support them. In any event, Dr. Jonathan Howard and I responded:
Dr. Daly calls it “cancel culture”; I call it quality control.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 13, 2022
Doctors who promote misinformation have long hidden behind the First Amendment and “free speech” dating back to long before the pandemic. One prominent example includes the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), which is, in essence, a medical John Birch Society camouflaged as a legitimate medical professional society. I’ve written about the AAPS a number of times, relating how it’s promoted antivaccine pseudoscience blaming vaccines for autism, including a view that is extreme even among antivaccine activists, namely that the “shaken baby syndrome” is a “misdiagnosis” for vaccine injury. It’s worse than that, though. AAPS has promoted HIV/AIDS denialism, blamed immigrants for crime and disease, promoted the pseudoscience claiming that abortion causes breast cancer using some of the most execrable “science” ever, and not only rejected evidence-based guidelines as an unacceptable affront on the godlike autonomy of physicians; the very concept of a scientific consensus about anything. Indeed, in August an AAPS member likened the recent statement by the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) endorsing disciplining doctors for spreading COVID-19 misinformation to the Soviet NKVD, which led me to quip that at least he didn’t invoke Nazis.
I mention the AAPS for two reasons, first to contrast it with the doctors expressing extreme reserve about NLFD and second to disabuse readers of the concept that there aren’t a lot of crank MDs and DOs. It’s easy to make fun of the AAPS, because it is truly a home for little but medical conspiracy theorist “brave maverick doctors” who “don’t follow the herd” even when the herd is actually correct, hence the antivax and HIV/AIDS denial that has flowed from it. However, the doctors expressing reservations most assuredly are not cranks. (Although I didn’t recall ever having interacted with Dr. Daly before, I actually rather like Dr. Jha.)
What is interesting is why doctors who practice science-based medicine would react negatively, to the point of unironically echoing the whole “cancel culture” talking point, leading to a continuation of the conversation:
And they should be perhaps the echo chamber of Twitter is affecting me. Battling quackery and censorship is a challenging dual mandate.
— Ryan P. Daly, MD (@DrRyanPDaly) January 13, 2022
Actually, “Mr. Bond” makes an excellent point that echoes what we at SBM have been saying for a long time.
Then there was this:
Who decides on what is mis-information?
— Terry Maratos-Flier (@Maratosflier) January 13, 2022
A flippant response would be to ask: If state medical boards can’t be tasked at determining what is quackery and misinformation, then who can? The response, though, isn’t so flippant if you think about it, particularly in the context of my periodic laments over the last two decades over how state medical boards so rarely ever actually discipline outright quacks like Dr. Buttar or Burzynski. And if state medical boards can’t enforce even a minimal standard of professional behavior, both in terms of treating patients and public health messaging by licensed doctors, then what good are they? Sure, getting rid of doctors who are impaired due to substance abuse disorders, who assault patients, or who defraud third party payers and patients is good and necessary, but it’s not sufficient, nor is it “cancel culture” for state medical boards to sanction misinformation-spewing physicians.
Let’s take a look at the common concerns expressed by non-quack physicians about NFLD.
Start with an “easy” example
In considering the whole issue of “cancel culture” and physicians’ reactions to Dr. Nass’ suspension by Maine, let’s start with the article that Dr. Jha cited, “Physicians React: Should Docs Lose Their Licenses for Spreading False COVID Information?” The article breaks down physician responses on social media into two categories, Yes, Those Doctors Are Doing Wrong and No, Those Physicians Have a Right to Speak Their Beliefs. Since I am arguing the first point, I’ll be focusing more on the arguments for the second, most of which boil down to a fear that “science and controversial thought” were being “muzzled.” Interestingly, these sorts of arguments came from perspectives that could be considered both right and left wing. For example, here’s one who based opposition on distrust of big pharma:
Another clinician claimed the “truth is very difficult to discern from less-than-truth in a country running on a profit-oriented economic ideology.”
While, from the other side:
“Who can determine exactly what is truth?” asked another clinician. “For sure, the ‘Federal Government,’ who ‘is here to help you,’ is not qualified to make such determinations, and who are you to make such a suggestion as to remove someone’s license because they disagree with you. Give me a break!”
“What is truth?” How, very, very deep! (Really, most doctors are pretty crappy at philosophy.)
While it is true that big pharma doesn’t have the greatest track record in terms of its messaging, it does not follow from that history that it is impossible to discern good science from bad or quackery from science-based medical care, nor do past errors by the federal government imply the same thing. Similarly, it is the state governments who set up state medical boards, which are made up of physicians and stakeholders from the public, and no one—no one—is saying that the federal government (or a state government) should take away a physician license.
This is where my “easy example” comes in, specifically naming physicians who deny germ theory and use that denial to spread antivax misinformation, something I did last week on Twitter:
And, lest you claim that no doctor would ever deny germ theory, just let me say that I can provide a number of undeniable examples to you of just such doctors (e.g., Kelly Brogan), along with the receipts. (I've been writing about this sort of thing for nearly two decades.)
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 13, 2022
This, of course, is an “easy example” if you don’t overthink it. I’m not talking about, for instance, the relative contribution of host susceptibility versus the microbe to the development and severity of disease. I’m talking about the very basic concept of whether “germs” cause disease at all, the denial of which is a longstanding belief in large swaths of alternative medicine and the antivaccine pseudoscience spawned by it. I’m talking about people like Dr. Kelly Brogan:
And there are many more like her out there. State medical boards rarely do anything about them.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 13, 2022
We at SBM have written about Dr. Brogan before. Recall that she was denying germ theory years before the pandemic. Unsurprisingly, she continues to deny germ theory when it comes to COVID-19. As I’ve said many times before, if there’s one thing that those of us who have been struggling to counter medical misinformation, quackery, and antivaccine pseudoscience frequently encounter, it’s medical professionals and scientists who have a hard time believing us when we describe just how unscientific, pseudoscientific, and just plain conspiracy-addled various beliefs underlying alternative medicine and antivaccine pseudoscience are. Surely, they seem to think, there’s no way anyone could actually believe that in 2022! How wrong they are, and among the alternative medicine beliefs that provoke the most disbelief among my colleagues (and among educated lay people) is germ theory denial. Few doctors believe me when I say there are people (and doctors) who deny basic germ theory. I have to show them the evidence.
Generally, most physicians expressing discomfort over medical board sanctions for spreading health misinformation will agree that a physician like Kelly Brogan, who denies basic germ theory, should face sanctions from her state medical board. Certainly Dr. Daly did. Therein lies the trap. By conceding that promoting one very obvious sort of medical misinformation should be sanctionable by a state medical board, the naysayers concede my main point, that state medical boards should have the power to sanction physicians who promote misinformation. The rest is just “haggling over the price” (to echo a famous joke); i.e., determining what specific sorts of misinformation should be sanctionable.
That’s when these doctors usually retreat into complaining that “dogma will prevail” if sanctioning doctors on the basis of their spreading misinformation becomes widespread. Then, even as they concede that misinformation coming from doctors can be dangerous, they won’t take a stand on where to draw the line, leading to exchanges like this:
So what misinformation would you say is worth pulling a license for?
Vaccines are full of graphene and hydra that will blow up your head when 5g comes online?
— Ryan Bedell (@ryanbeed) January 14, 2022
Notably, Dr. Ryan never answered Mr. Bedell’s very reasonable question about real world examples. Presumably he does not support sanctioning speech promoting conspiracy theories like that, but maybe I’m wrong. He never answered the question. Those of us who are trying to fight disinformation do not have the privilege and liberty of not taking stands on these questions. No one is saying that these questions are easy in general, but sometimes they are. Kelly Brogan and physicians who deny germ theory are not difficult cases, at least conceptually. I concede that implementing standards for misinformation that rises to the level of being dangerous is not easy.
“Settled science,” Or “What about scientific debate?”
Another common complaint by physicians over the move to sanction doctors promoting misinformation is that no science is “settled” and that such sanctioning will somehow inhibit “scientific debate”. For instance, here’s an example from the Medscape article:
However, many physicians worried that science and controversial thought were being muzzled.
“Absolutely no,” a doctor stated. “Who judges what is misinformation in this age where debate is canceled? Science advances with challenge and it’s not about an authority dictating the allowable opinion.”
Again, I also quote Dr. Daly, who asks the questions:
Clearly. That’s a black and white example as can be. Not the slippery slope. What theories are challengeable? Or is all science settled ?
— Ryan P. Daly, MD (@DrRyanPDaly) January 13, 2022
And appeals to the “art” of medicine:
That’s not the gotcha you think it is. I’ve literally been writing about this very topic for nearly two decades. I’m manager of a blog devoted to these sorts of discussions.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) January 13, 2022
This is, of course, a very common straw man fallacy frequently invoked whenever professional and scientific sanctions against physicians spreading misinformation are advocated. Here are a couple of more examples from the Medscape article:
One specialist warned that if disinformation doctors are held responsible, then “that means a lot of doctors” will be “gone” because “almost anything that is written or said about COVID can be contested.”
Another physician warned his colleagues about suppressing new ideas: “To condemn what we didn’t try, or purposefully ignore a different approach because [it] doesn’t agree with our opinion is suppression of information.”
Here we go again with “What is truth?”
My response is simple. No one is suggesting, much less arguing, that “all science is settled” or that state medical boards should strip doctors of their medical licenses for taking medical or scientific positions that are reasonably debatable from a scientific standpoint. Certainly, I’ve never made that claim, nor have I argued anything like this. I do, however, argue that there are certain scientific conclusions in medicine that are as close to being “settled” as one can imagine, to the point that not accepting them is unscientific quackery. Basic germ theory is one. That homeopathy is physically impossible is another. As I like to say about homeopathy, for homeopathy even to have a chance of working would require not just that huge swaths of very well-established theory in physics and chemistry be wrong, but that they be spectacularly wrong. Another way of putting it is that to provide sufficient evidence to make homeopathy physically plausible would require a level of evidence that can topple major theories undergirding our current understanding of chemistry and physics. I generally conclude by saying that all theories are “challengeable”, but that simply denying them based on no evidence (or on highly dubious “evidence” and conspiracy theories) is not a “challenge” that professional societies and medical boards are obligated to take seriously as “scientific debate”.
Similarly, just because the science of COVID1-19 is rapidly evolving, having started out with us knowing little about the coronavirus, its mechanism of activity, its transmissibility, and the like, contrary to the claim that “almost anything that is written or said about COVID can be contested”, it’s not as though we know nothing about it. Even in the early days of the pandemic we knew a lot about coronaviruses, of which SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, was a novel example. For example, as early as January 2020, I could say with a great deal of confidence that SARS-CoV-2 was not a result of a vaccination campaign in China against the flu vaccine.
To sum it up, rapidly evolving science and a lack of knowledge do not mean no knowledge or that we cannot with a high degree of certainty know what is not true or recognized science denial and conspiracy theories when we see them. It doesn’t mean we can’t know quackery when we see it. Moreover, it’s now nearly two years since the pandemic hit the US. The “fog of war” argument about the lack of scientific knowledge regarding COVID-19 and SARS-CoV-2 is much less compelling now than it might have been in March 2020.
Aside from that, doctors also often express fears that such sanctions will shut down “nuance”:
There is tremendous multi-faceted COIs in medicine, hype, and misinterpretations of what trials actually inform us – just see poop-show of nutritional science. Let none of my comments be thought of as anti-vax, I’m pro-nuance. And Pro-vax.
— Ryan P. Daly, MD (@DrRyanPDaly) January 13, 2022
Here’s the problem. We are not dealing with “nuance,” and the fallacy that we are talking about here is not anything resembling “scientific debate”. It’s denialism. On a conceptual level, it’s no different than the denial of, for example, climate science, evolution, or that HIV causes AIDS. Indeed, germ theory denial is a form of denialism, as is antivaccinationism. Physicians who express concern that holding physicians who are promoting denialism to account will somehow shut down scientific debate are doing exactly what brothers Mark and Chris Hoofnagle warned about years ago, mistaking denialism for debate. It’s exactly the trap that disinformation peddlers want you to fall into. Denialism generally involves at least more than one of five things: conspiracy theories, fake experts, cherry picked evidence, impossible expectations (and moving goalposts), and, of course, logical fallacies.
Speaking of logical fallacies…
“It’s a slippery slope”
Another oft-expressed concern is that if state medical boards start sanctioning doctors promoting COVID-19 misinformation, it’ll be a slippery slope to their sanctioning all sorts of other things. In other words, they express fear that “gray areas” will end up being sanctioned. Examples include (and I don’t mean to keep picking on Dr. Daly, who seems sincere and dedicated to evidence-based medicine, but he sums up the common arguments rather succinctly). Here’s another invocation of the “slippery slope”:
Yes clearly. Not my larger point. There’s a role for sanctions and quality control. For each egregious example there’s is a grey zone one. Or uncommonly something we’re just frankly wrong about as a profession. Blackswans.
— Ryan P. Daly, MD (@DrRyanPDaly) January 13, 2022
And:
Not sure we are arguing the same argument here. And likely agree on many points. Arguing dualMandate of balancing quackery and censorship is a hard one with a slippery slope. Not an all or none arguement
— Ryan P. Daly, MD (@DrRyanPDaly) January 13, 2022
Again, no one claims that this is an all-or-none argument. I’ll also point out that, contrary to what some argue, a slippery slope argument is not always a logical fallacy, conceding that there can be occasional valid uses of it. The are, however rare, and I agree that is it almost always a logical fallacy that avoids the specific question at hand and instead distracts with extreme hypotheticals, all without any evidence that the action proposed will lead to the chain reaction suggested, ultimately resulting in the undesirable consequences proposed, which become increasingly improbable the farther along the chain reaction of consequences one drifts. It’s an appeal to fear, not reason.
At its essence, the slippery slope argument, whether the person deploying it realizes it or not, is always an argument to do nothing, based on invoking the fear of some inevitable awful consequence somewhere down the line if a first step is taken.
This wasn’t a doctor who said this, but it is a more extreme example of what I’m talking about:
What's next? The gulag for her? This is all disturbingly similar to Stalin's Soviet Union.
— Swamp_Yankee (@BenFranklin1171) January 13, 2022
And:
It's not the vaccine , a flu shot never gave us a yearly card, we saw health cards in nazo Germany, lest we forget.history can repeat itself. They could easily have bred and trained covid sniffing dogs to eradicate covid they chose not to
— nashville kittens12 (@Happycats678) January 13, 2022
None of the doctors that I encountered went as far as putting Nazi Germany or the Gulags at the end of their slippery slope, but at their core their arguments were not far removed from this.
Whataboutism
The final sort of argument that I’ve seen involves something known as “whataboutism” or “whataboutery”. In brief, whataboutism is a logical fallacy and rhetorical technique of distraction in which a person responds to a criticism with a counter-accusation in order to divert attention to a different topic. The origin of the term goes back to the Cold War, where it was coined to describe the oft-used technique by the Soviet Union to counter various charges made against it. The following is a classic example:
One clinician suggested enforcement against health food, drug company commercials, and talk shows: “What about all the [misinformation] at the health food stores and the like. Doctors of natural-whatever? Those info-commercials on tv. How many faxes do I get to ‘approve’ because ‘patients request’ braces and pain-treating expensive compounds advertised on TV? We tolerate those…. What about Dr Oz and the docs on talk shows claiming BS?”
This bit of whataboutism is not nearly the “gotcha” that physicians (and others) making this argument think it is, at least not to me. I’ve been arguing to do something about all of these things for a very long time, as has everyone here at SBM. Need I remind you how often we have written about the licensure of quacks, Dr. Oz, and quackery in pharmacies? And that’s just a small sample.
State medical boards vs. COVID-19 (and other) misinformation
State medical boards are in a difficult situation that has only become more so with the rise of quacks promoting COVID-19 misinformation. I’ve long lamented how reluctant they are to discipline doctors practicing quackery and promoting antivaccine conspiracy theories and other dangerous misinformation, even before the pandemic. It was a problem that few seemed to appreciate or have much desire to do anything about. Worse, whenever state medical boards actually did something about it, it became obvious that quacks had considerable political pull in some states. The example that I like to cite the most often is that of Dr. Rashid Buttar, whom I mentioned earlier. Buttar led a successful effort by the North Carolina Integrative Medical Society to get legislators to change state law to make it friendlier to practitioners of alternative medicine.
Then the pandemic hit, and finally the severity of the problem of doctors using their professional status to spread misinformation is being appreciated, perhaps for the first time. Unfortunately, we as a profession have a lot of members who either can’t or don’t want to see it as a problem. I suspect that the reason now is similar to the reasons then, involving our dislike of “being told what to do” and an attitude that any of us could fall victim to a bogus complaint to a state medical board. (Ironically, I myself have experienced exactly that, when several years ago a patient of Stanislaw Burzynski reported me to my state medical board for my blog posts about her case.) I get it. I also get that a lot of my colleagues and I have to make medical decisions based on less than ideal evidence bases all the time (the “art” of medicine). Unfortunately, too many of us extrapolate that to justify what quacks do.
        ◦ That needs to change, and we need to work to clean up our own profession. Before the pandemic, I wouldn’t have cared so much where we started, with quacks like Stanislaw Burzynski or with antivaxxers like Paul Thomas. Given that we are still in the middle of a pandemic that’s killed northward of 800K in just the US alone, starting with doctors promoting COVID-19 misinformation makes a lot of sense. As imperfect as it is and even if it doesn’t go far enough for my tastes, NLFD is as good a strategy to start with as any. Again, this is professional quality control, not “cancel culture”, and, even if it were, not all “cancel culture” is a bad thing.

The Oregon Medical Board suspends the medical license of antivax pediatrician Dr. Paul Thomas
Late last week, the Oregon Medical Board suspended the licenses of two physicians, one for bragging about not wearing a mask around his patients, the second being Dr. Paul Thomas, an antivaccine pediatrician, whose continued practice was deemed a threat to his patients. It’s time for more state medical boards to step up, as Oregon’s has.
David Gorski on December 7, 2020
Link

If there’s one thing that the COVID-19 pandemic has made all too painfully undeniable, it’s that there are a lot of healthcare professionals out who are very awful people, with very awful, unscientific beliefs about the pandemic, pushing awful unproven treatments, unscientific treatments, or even just plain quackery (often based on conspiracy theories) to prevent or treat COVID-19, while denying the efficacy of public health interventions such as masking and social distancing, using bad science to deny the severity of the pandemic, and even participating in the ongoing disinformation war against COVID-19 vaccines being waged by antivaxxers. Sadly, more than a few of these disinformation spreaders are physicians, with some of the usual antivax physician suspects jumping on the COVID-19 denial grift train so effortlessly. Sadly, physicians behaving badly is nothing new, as there are antivaccine pediatricians(!) like Dr. Bob Sears and Larry Palevsky, and many have been the times that I’ve bemoaned the seeming inability of state medical boards to act to take away the licenses of quacks like Stanislaw Burzynski (who’s managed to keep practicing in Texas since the late 1970s despite peddling nonsense) and antivaxxers who endanger their patients—or even of just run of the mill utterly incompetent surgeons.
That’s why I was so elated over the weekend to see a medical board doing what medical boards should do. I’m referring, of course, to the Oregon Medical Board, which recently decided to act against the licenses of two doctors spreading disinformation about medicine and thereby endangering their patients and the public, Dr. Steven LaTulippe and Dr. Paul Thomas, the latter of whom will be the main topic of this post, for reasons that will become apparent as you continue to read. I will, however, mention first why the Oregon Medical Board suspended Dr. LaTulippe’s license first:
From a local news story:
The Oregon Medical Board suspended the license of an Oregon doctor who said he refuses to wear a mask in his clinic while also encouraging others to not wear masks.
Dr. Steven LaTulippe told a pro-Trump rally in November that neither he nor his staff wears a mask while working in their Dallas, Ore. clinic. That violates a state order requiring health care workers to wear a face-covering in health care settings.
Members of the medical board voted Thursday evening to suspend LaTulippe’s license immediately. According to a statement on the Oregon Medical Board website, the suspension was issued “due to the board’s concern for the safety and welfare of licensee’s current and future patients.”
The indefinite suspension prevents LaTulippe from practicing medicine anywhere in the state. LaTuilippe ran a family practice clinic called South View Medical Arts in Dallas, Ore.
I found it particularly amusing that it was the Oregon Republican Party that posted the video that led to the spotlight being shone on Dr. LaTulippe’s crank beliefs and ultimately to his license being suspended:
Nice job, Oregon Republicans! More videos like this, please, so that we can identify other COVID-19 denying quacks for the Oregon Medical Board to examine! There’s so much disinformation in just Dr. LaTulippe’s brief remarks, including his claims that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19 is rapidly mutating and has already mutated into something else (not true), meaning that COVID-19 is “over” (whatever that means). Someone like him should not be let anywhere near COVID-19 patients, and not just because he believes so much nonsense but because his failure to adhere to infection control protocols (like facemasks) will facilitate the spread of the virus, possibly to his other patients.
The Oregon Medical Board suspends the medical license of antivaccine pediatrician Dr. Paul Thomas
I’m more interested in the story of Dr. Paul Thomas, than that of Dr. LaTulippe. The reason is that Dr. Thomas is an antivaccine pediatrician whom I’ve been covering for nearly three years at my not-so-secret other blog but who, for whatever reason, has only been briefly mentioned in passing here on SBM. He is, like Dr. Bob Sears, a pediatrician. Like Dr. Sears, he has also made a name for himself promoting antivaccine pseudoscience, propaganda, and disinformation, even writing a book, like the one written by Dr. Sears, that promotes an “alternative” vaccine schedule not based in science. Unlike Dr. Sears, he has claimed to do “science” to support his assertions that unvaccinated children are healthier than vaccinated children. (More on that later.) From my perspective, it appears that Dr. Thomas is much more into “integrative pediatrics” woo than Dr. Sears, which puts him on a similar level with another antivaccine pediatrician, Dr. Lawrence Palevsky, who showed up in the news a year and a half ago during all the measles outbreaks in Brooklyn and Rockland County, NY spreading antivaccine pseudoscience to Orthodox Jews.
The suspension of Dr. Thomas’ license last week by the Oregon Medical Board provides me with the perfect pretext to discuss him, as he’s been a rising star in the antivaccine movement since around 2017 or 2018 and recently made waves with a really awful “vaxxed/unvaxxed” study that claimed to find that unvaccinated children are healthier. More importantly, it provides me with the opportunity to discuss my belief that antivaccine physicians should lose their medical licenses because, by definition, they are practicing so far below the standard of care that they endanger their patients.
Here’s a PDF of the Oregon Medical Board’s order, issued on December 3. Let’s take a look at some key passages. First, however, note how the order points out that Oregon law allows its medical board to temporarily suspend the license of a physician without a hearing when the “Board has evidence that indicates that Licensee’s continued practice constitutes an immediate danger to the public” or finds that “that Licensee’s continued practice of medicine by a physician presents a serious danger to the public health or safety”. This is important in that I don’t recall any previous cases in which a quack or antivaxxer had their license suspended because their state medical board viewed them as such a threat to patients or public health.
Let’s get to the meat of the findings, shall we?
The Board finds that Licensee’s conduct has breached the standard of care and has placed the health and safety of many of his patients at serious risk of harm. It is therefore necessary to emergently suspend Licensee’s license to practice medicine. The acts and conduct that support this Order for Emergency Suspension follow:
3.1Licensee has published an alternative vaccination schedule that decreases the frequency of many recommended vaccines and omits others, including rotavirus. Licensee promotes his unique, “Dr. Paul approved” schedule as providing superior results to any other option, namely improved health on many measures, and fraudulently asserts that following his vaccine schedule will prevent or decrease the incidence of autism and other developmental disorders. Licensee uses this claim to solicit parental “refusal” of full vaccination for their children, thereby exposing them to multiple potentially debilitating and life-threatening illnesses, including tetanus, hepatitis, pertussis (whooping cough), rotavirus, measles, mumps, and rubella.
Licensee’s promotion of this alternative vaccination schedule exposes patients to the risk of harm in violation of ORS 677.190(1)(a), as defined by ORS 677.188(4)(a).
This, of course, is nothing new. Dr. Thomas published his book (co-authoring it with another rising star in the antivaccine movement, Jennifer Margulis), The Vaccine-Friendly Plan: Dr. Paul’s Safe and Effective Approach to Immunity and Health- from Pregnancy Through Your Child’s Teen Years, nearly five years ago. That, of course, brings up the question of why the Oregon Medical Board considered it necessary to suspend Dr. Thomas’s license on an emergent basis, before a full hearing. The most serious (to me) of Dr. Thomas’ “unprofessional or dishonorable conduct which exposed his patients to the risk of harm, as well as gross or repeated acts of negligence in violation of ORS 677.190(13)” listed by the Board in its order of emergency suspension was this one:
3.3.3Patient D, a now 9-year-old male, was completely non-immunized. Patient D sustained a large, deep scalp laceration at home in a farm setting on August 8, 2017, and was treated with colloidal silver and with his parents suturing the wound independently. Patient D subsequently developed acute tetanus requiring intubation, tracheotomy, feeding tube placement and an almost two- month ICU stay at Doernbecher Children’s Hospital. Patient D was then transferred to Legacy Rehabilitation. Licensee saw Patient D for follow-up in clinic on November 17, 2017. Licensee’s notes documented a referral to a homeopath, recommendation of fish oil supplements, and “phosphatidyl seine.” He did not document an informed consent discussion about the risk/benefit of immunization for a child who had just sustained and still had sequelae of, and remained vulnerable despite prior infection, to tetanus, a life-threatening and disabling disease that is preventable by proper vaccination. Licensee’s care placed Patient D at serious risk of harm and constitutes gross negligence.
The standard of care, of course, after a laceration resulting in what must have been a grossly contaminated wound in a child (or adult) who has either not had a tetanus vaccination or whose tetanus vaccination status is unclear or in doubt is to recommend a tetanus booster plus tetanus immune globulin (TIG). Colloidal silver won’t cut it, being quackery. Homeopathy certainly won’t cut it, being The One Quackery To Rule Them All. (I note that Dr. Thomas’ practice is an “integrative pediatrics” practice, which of course goes along with his general antivaccine bent.) Basically, if the facts of this case are as stated by the suspension order, this is gross malpractice of the most negligent kind, in my not-so-humble opinion. It’s even worse than that, because he did it twice! Not only did he not recommend tetanus vaccination (and, apparently, TIG) once when the child first presented with his laceration, but he did it a second time, not recommending it during a followup visit after the child’s hospital discharge! Tetanus infection doesn’t make you immune to a second infection, because it’s a toxin produced by Clostridium tetani, the bacteria tetanus that causes tetanus, that is dangerous. The child was still susceptible to tetanus when Dr. Thomas saw him after discharge.
That’s not all when it comes to preventable disease due to Dr. Thomas’ medical negligence, though. For instance, there were children who were hospitalized with rotavirus infections, including a ten year old girl and twins born at 35 weeks gestation, who developed rotavirus gastroenteritis at ten months of age and required hospitalization for five days. For these latter patients, the Board does note this:
Licensee’s clinic chart contains documentation of parental refusal of vaccines, but they are inconsistent regarding specific vaccines and their timing. In addition, Patient G and Patient H’s mother stated during hospitalization that she thought her children had received rotavirus vaccine. Failure to adequately document specific parental refusal and lack of providing parental clarity constitute acts of negligence.
Correct. These cases demonstrate extreme medical negligence, and there is no excuse. Similarly, so is placing the fake diagnosis of chronic Lyme disease on a girl and then not following the standard of care to work up her symptoms:
3.3.5Patient F is a 7-year-old female who Licensee followed in clinic for constipation, food allergies, mold allergies and possible “chronic Lyme disease. Review of her chart from Licensee’s clinic reveals that she was nonimmunized. Licensee ordered repeated IgE allergy panels and recommended elimination diets, vitamin supplements and provided antibiotics for acute infections. Licensee failed to provide an appropriate referral to a pediatric gastroenterologist to exclude a diagnosis of malabsorption or celiac disease, a referral to pediatric allergy/immunology or to pediatric nutrition. Licensee’s neglect to seek consultative support and oversight, and his failure to address Patient F’s lack of immunizations, placed the health of this patient at serious risk and was grossly negligent.
Not doing a proper, science-based medical workup to rule out potential medical and physiological causes of a patient’s symptoms and instead treating them for fake diagnoses constitute malpractice in my book.
There are also cases described in which Dr. Thomas measured antibody titers for measles, mumps, and rubella, using those levels to decide not to give the additional doses of the vaccine recommended. Never mind that, as the Board put it, except for “rare cases of suspected immune deficiency, there is no clinical indication for assessment of antibody titers” and regardless “of antibody titers, the standard of care requires a second dose of the recommended MMR vaccination”.
Then, as one might expect for an antivaccine pediatrician, there were cases in which the child developed a vaccine-preventable disease, such as an 11-year-old boy who was on Dr. Thomas’ delayed schedule and developed pertussis. One case like this involved not just failure to vaccinate, but gross patient mismanagement:
3.3.2Patient C is a now 7-year-old male. He was admitted to Randall Children’s Hospital in August 2013 at approximately 10 weeks of life with fever and a diagnosis of Kawasaki’s disease. Licensee saw Patient C in clinic for three days in clinic with fever. Though Dr. Thomas reevaluated Patient C daily and sent repeated labs, he made a clinical decision to treat a febrile child a less than 3 months old with intramuscular ceftriaxone on the basis of a “bagged” and not catharized urine sample and in the absence of blood cultures. Any child of this age is at higher risk for serious bacterial infection (late onset group B strep, pneumococcal bacteremia, urinary tract infection, pneumonia, meningitis) as well as inflammatory illnesses such as Kawasaki’s disease. Licensee breached the standard of care by failing to refer Patient C to the Emergency Room or hospital for definitive lab testing (guided bladder tap, blood cultures done with bedside ultrasound, possible lumbar puncture) and observation. Licensee’s management of Patient C’s illness in clinic breached the standard of care. Patient C remained non immunized for pertussis and subsequently contracted pertussis when his older brother, Patient C, became ill with pertussis on September 24, 2018.
Even I know that you have to take a persistent fever in an infant under three months old a lot more seriously than Dr. Thomas did, and I’m not even a pediatrician or internist.
Here’s a particularly interesting finding by the Board. I’ll preface this finding by noting that “integrative doctors” like Dr. Thomas almost always tout their supposedly superior ability to “listen to patient concerns” and to “work with patients”. They tout their “respect” for their patients’ wishes, negatively contrasting it with, apparently, the cold, unfeeling, dismissive behavior of science-based physicians. It turns out though, that if the following allegations recounted in the Board’s order are true, Dr. Thomas is not so respectful of parents who are pro-vaccine and want the standard vaccine schedule:
3.2Licensee is insistent and direct in his communication with parents and guardians that they should accept his alternative vaccine schedule.
What does the Board mean by that? It provides two examples:
3.2.1A patient’s mother sought subsequent treatment by Provider X after having been “reduced to tears” by Licensee’s “bullying” her into his personal vaccine schedule against her express wishes for full vaccination for her child.
3.2.2Patient A’s mother requested polio and rotavirus vaccinations for Patient A according to CDC Recommendations, but Licensee did not have those vaccines in the clinic, and Patient A would therefore not be able to get them. Patient A’s mother reported that the Licensee questioned why she wanted Patient A to get the polio vaccine and asked whether they were traveling to Africa. During the appointment, Licensee continually connected vaccines (not specific) with autism. Licensee asked her how awful she would feel if Patient A got autism and she could have prevented it.
So Dr. Thomas reduced one mother to tears because she wanted to follow the standard, science-based CDC-recommended vaccine schedule for her child, as he tried to bully her into accepting his unproven “alternative vaccine schedule.” (Funny, but doesn’t this sound like a common description by antivax mothers of pediatricians and nurses trying to persuade them to accept the CDC vaccine schedule, that of bullies.) He also tried to guilt another mother into not giving her child recommended vaccines using a false claim that vaccines cause autism, an antivaccine claim that has been tested time and time and time again through numerous studies, none of which has produced any scientifically convincing evidence that vaccines cause or even are associated with an increased risk of autism. I guess that Dr. Thomas is understanding, empathetic, and willing to work with parents, as long as the parents do what he wants them to do, rather like the caricature of science-based physicians recommending the standard CDC-recommended vaccine schedule. The word “projection” comes to mind here.
And I do love what the Board wrote here:
3.1Licensee has published an alternative vaccination schedule that decreases the frequency of many recommended vaccines and omits others, including rotavirus. Licensee promotes his unique, “Dr. Paul approved” schedule as providing superior results to any other option, namely improved health on many measures, and fraudulently asserts that following his vaccine schedule will prevent or decrease the incidence of autism and other developmental disorders. Licensee uses this claim to solicit parental “refusal” of full vaccination for their children, thereby exposing them to multiple potentially debilitating and life-threatening illnesses, including tetanus, hepatitis, pertussis (whooping cough), rotavirus, measles, mumps, and rubella.
And here:
Licensee’s false claims regarding the safety of the CDC Recommendations, his failure in following these Recommendations absent unsolicited parental refusal of vaccines, his failure to document any such refusal, and his failure to adequately vaccinate children is grossly negligent in violation of ORS 677.190(13) and exposed his patients to the risk of harm in violation of ORS 677.190(1)(a), as defined in ORS 677.188(4)(a).
Because making demonstrably false claims about vaccines in order to dissuade patients from vaccinating or parents from vaccinating their children is fraud and malpractice, as far as I’m concerned, and should be grounds to suspend or even permanently revoke a physician’s license. Dr. Thomas’s antivaccine grift has real health consequences for children, and his popularity in the Portland area has real public health risks. Indeed, he was peddling his message during a measles outbreak nearly two years ago.
Dr. Thomas: A rising star in the antivaccine movement
As I said near the beginning of this post, Dr. Thomas has been a rising star in the antivaccine movement ever since he first published his book touting his “alternative vaccine schedule”. Unsurprisingly, in his promotion of his book, one can easily find all sorts of red flags for antivaccine pseudoscience, including favorite quack tropes about “blindly following your doctor’s recommendations” or “counting on some government agency to have your best interests first,” coupled with a sales pitch for his book, his videos, and, above all, his nutritional supplements. Supplements, did I say? Oh, yes. Dr. Thomas sells lots and lots of supplements, in particular “Dr. Paul Approved Nutraceuticals” (vitamins, minerals, herbs and more) that are “selected to maintain optimal cellular function and to restore optimal cellular function for those individuals with unique dietary requirements and sensitivities”.
Because of course he does.
Unsurprisingly, Dr. Thomas has, like Dr. Palevsky, jumped on the COVID-19 denial grift train with his new book, COVID-19: Life-Saving Strategies The News Media Will Never Tell You. Here’s a rule of thumb. Whenever you see a book title about how “They” don’t want you to know something, like Kevin Trudeau, run. It’s almost certainly a scam or, at best, misinformation. I can tell just from the blurb:
Are you worried that you or a loved one might die from COVID-19? It is your healthy immune system that protects you and keeps you alive. In COVID-19: Life-Saving Strategies the News Media Will Never Tell You, Paul Thomas, M.D. provides possible solutions backed by sound science and his experience in his own clinical practice. In this book, you will discover:
    • The best type of immune-boosting diet.
    • Why a ventilator should only be used as a last resort.
    • 6 essential dietary supplements that support immunity and lung health (Hint: It’s not just about vitamin C).
    • 1 possible way to get a conventional doctor to administer vitamin C while you’re in the hospital.
    • Many other easy-to-implement key action steps to strengthen your immune system.
This book provides a way to take your destiny into your own hands and dramatically increase your chances of staying healthy. The many scientific references included in the book also make it an ideal resource for health care providers.
Hard pass.
But how did Dr. Thomas get to where he is now? Certainly, he has followed the same sort of path that Dr. Sears did, publishing a book with an “alternative vaccination schedule” that delays and omits certain vaccines based on fear-mongering antivax pseudoscience claiming that vaccines cause autism, autoimmune disease, and all sorts of other problems, but that’s not all. He’s also been good about getting favorable press coverage from local and national media figures who are prone to “false balance” when it comes to vaccine stories, as he did with Genevieve Reaume, a reporter for KATU, the Portland, OR ABC affiliate, a year and a half ago. Her story went beyond false balance and, in the midst of an MMR outbreak in Portland and Washington, basically lionized Thomas as a “brave maverick doctor” being “persecuted” by The Man for his views. The basis of the story was Dr. Thomas’ claim that he is doing “studies” of the 15,000 patients in his practice and that then those studies “showed” that unvaccinated children are rarely diagnosed with autism. Unsurprisingly, it used poor study design and incorrect statistical analyses.
As I pointed out at the time, there are issues where there are not two sides to the story. Whether the MMR vaccine causes autism is one. Worse, when it comes to conspiracy theory-based movements like the antivax movement, facts don’t matter, and presenting antivaccine pseudoscience side-by-side with science does falsely elevate the pseudoscience, no matter how much refutation to antivax pseudoscience is included. Dr. Thomas was engaging in information warfare, and it’s asymmetric warfare. He continues to do so. What do I mean?
First, Dr. Thomas has teamed up with James Lyons-Weiler, whom you might recall attacking a study that found that autism is primarily genetic and using risibly incompetent science to try to demonstrate early in the pandemic that SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19 (which at the time was still called 2019-nCoV) was not natural and had been engineered. A while back, Dr. Thomas teamed up with Lyons-Weiler to do antivaccine “science”. One of the early fruits of that collaboration (if you can call such a rancid piece of rotten science a “fruit”) was an incompetent study, published as the COVID-19 pandemic was getting started in China, that demonized aluminum adjuvants using some really incompetent pharmacokinetic modeling. It was a wonder to behold in its awfulness. The other “collaboration” between these antivaccine cranks involved a “vaxxed/unvaxxed” study.
What is a “vaxxed/unvaxxed” or “vaccinated/unvaccinated” study? I’ll remind those who might be unfamiliar with the concept or don’t remember it. It’s any study that compares health outcomes between a vaccinated cohort of children and those of an unvaccinated cohort. In its purist form, it is a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study comparing “vaxxed” to “unvaxxed.” Of course, such a study would be highly unethical because, by its very design, it would require that a group of children be intentionally placed in a control group that would be left vulnerable to vaccine-preventable diseases because the control group would only receive placebo vaccines. Antivaxxers don’t like it when that simple fact is pointed out to them, of course, because they really and truly believe that vaccines do more harm than good. Of course, it never occurs to them that their belief would make such a randomized, controlled clinical trial unethical as well, because they would be intentionally placing children into a group who would be—to them—being exposed to something they view as a grave threat to their health, vaccines. (After all, they believe that vaccines are toxins-laden interventions that cause autism, autoimmune diseases, obesity, alter DNA, render females infertile, and have created the “sickest generation” of children—and in some cases even kill.) True, their belief is erroneous, but intent matters. It all comes down to clinical equipoise, which is the genuine uncertainty over whether an intervention is on balance beneficial, harmful, or without detectable effect. A randomized controlled trial (RCT) of “vaxxed/unvaxxed” children violates clinical equipoise.
As a result, some of the savvier antivaxxers, who know that a “vaxxed/unvaxxed” RCT would be highly unethical (or who are at least willing to concede that the overwhelming view of physicians and scientists who do clinical trials is that a “vaxxed/unvaxxed” RCT would be highly unethical) have retreated back to suggesting observational “vaxxed/unvaxxed” studies, such as retrospective and epidemiological studies. The whole idea is that vaccines cause autism, the obesity epidemic, and in general the “sickest generation” of children, even though there is no evidence that they do. Of course, doing such a study is a hell of a lot more difficult than antivaxxers think, given how difficult it is to account for confounders and how many subjects are needed to provide sufficient power to detect differences in a condition whose prevalence is in the low single digit percentage range. Still, none of this has stopped antivaccine “scientists” and physicians from trying to do such studies. Unsurprisingly, the results are always dismal in that the studies are inevitably positive (i.e., claim to find that unvaccinated children are healthier than vaccinated children) but so poorly designed and executed that they are singularly uninformative and their conclusions are not supported by their data and design. Examples abound, unfortunately, such as risibly incompetent “vaxxed/unvaxxed” studies by Brian Hooker and Neil Z. Miller, studies by Anthony Mawson that were retracted and republished and retracted, Internet surveys by quacks about vaccinations, and a number of others that I could reference.
The even more rancid “fruit” of that collaboration, Thomas and Lyons-Weiler’s “vaxxed/unvaxxed” study, was published right before Thanksgiving. I’m not going to go into detail over why it was so bad, which you can just read here for the gory details. I will give you the Cliffs Notes version, which is that the study, apparently unable to find a statistically significant difference in health outcomes between vaccinated and unvaccinated children in Thomas’ practice using standard methods, Thomas and Lyons-Weiler invented a metric, the Relative Incidence of Office Visit (RIOV) and then did what sure looks to me like a lot of p-hacking to find statistically significant differences in the numbers of office visits for various diagnoses between the two groups as determined by billing records over 20 years. RIOV appears to have been designed to crank up sensitivity over specificity, thereby finding “differences” that might or might not mean anything (or even be real).
Worse, Thomas and Lyons-Weiler promise a “follow-up” study soon. I do wonder, though, how feasible that study will be given that Dr. Thomas can no longer treat patients, at least until there is a hearing before the Oregon Medical Board and possibly forever. (Obviously, I’m rooting for the latter possibility.) There will probably no effect, given that this has been a retrospective study. In any event, you can see how Thomas has teamed up with other antivaccine grifters to produce “science” to demonize vaccines.
Cry persecution!
Unsurprisingly, the reaction of antivaxxers to this news was to cry, “Persecution!” and “Freedom!” with a touch of “Fight forced vaccination!” conspiracy mongering. Indeed, on his website, Dr. Thomas posted this:
Dr. Paul now faces attacks on three fronts:
     1.  Providence Health Plans, the largest local insurance company terminated all contracts.
     2.  The State of Oregon terminated all contracts.
     3.  BREAKING NEWS, the same week his data is published and CHD Defender posts about it comes:
“By order of the Oregon Medical Board, the license of Paul Norman Thomas, MD to practice medicine is hereby suspended, effective December 3, 2020, at 5:15 p.m. Pacific Time. As of this date and time, Licensee must stop practicing medicine until further order of the Board.”
Integrative Pediatrics and our providers are fighting to preserve your right to direct your child’s medical care with Providence Health Plan (PHP) and with those covered by OHP (Oregon Health Plan). PHP and the Oregon Health Authority (OHP) intend to terminate our provider contracts in an effort to restrict your provider choices and force you and your children into compliance with CDC vaccine “recommendations.”
In an unprecedented move the Oregon Medical board suspended my license without a hearing potentially endangering countless patients.
Dr. Paul and Integrative Pediatrics have secured a team for legal action, civil lawsuits, and a class-action lawsuit against patients’ wrongful abandonment by PHP and OHA / OHP and the Oregon Medical Board.
Of course, the part about patients being “abandoned” or “endangered” is nonsense. After all, as this news story notes, Dr. Thomas has eight doctors and nurse practitioners who work for him. Surely his partner or the docs who work for him can see his patients while his license is suspended. Unsurprisingly, although his practice does very well and he is anything but poor, Dr. Thomas has started a legal defense fund, the better to milk his antivaccine fans for cold hard cash. Meanwhile, antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. was also rallying the antivaccine troops before this order was published:
In recent years, the Oregon Health Authority has targeted Dr. Thomas by removing his access to the CDC’s Vaccines For Children program, which pays for vaccines for low income families. Providence Health Plan and the Oregon Health Authority’s Oregon Health Plans, which are major health plans, have threatened to drop Dr. Thomas’ insurance coverage, claiming that the practice’s low vaccination rate signifies inferior care. These maneuvers could trigger a domino effect, closing down Dr. Thomas’ practice and leaving thousands of families with no pediatric care.
My response to this is that the closing of Dr. Thomas’ pediatrics practice would not be a bad thing. Quite the contrary. As for the Oregon Health Authority having removed his access to CDC’s Vaccines for Children program, I can’t help but wonder why Dr. Thomas cares, given how little enthusiasm he has for vaccinating according to the CDC schedule.
Meanwhile, Dr. Thomas’ “collaborator” took to video on Facebook:
Unsurprisingly, he starts his rant with COVID-19 disinformation, such as the “casedemic” before pivoting to ranting about the Oregon Medical Board’s action, bragging about their awful aluminum study and RIOV study. Even less surprisingly, he portrays the Board’s action as “a clear retaliation for daring to do science in the United States”. I must admit, I laughed out loud when he said that, given how utterly awful Dr. Thomas’ and his “science” was, but, hey, conspiracy mongerers gonna conspiracy monger. The Medical Board didn’t even mention the studies in its order, and state medical boards generally don’t take action regarding physician licenses based on their publications to peer-reviewed literature, no matter how awful or unethical the study. That’s not their charge, unless something in how the study was done could be proven to be a danger to patients or the public. Lyons-Weiler also pulls the “other patient” gambit because Dr. Thomas also practices—believe it or not!—addiction medicine, a truly frightening thought to me, given that he is an “integrative pediatrics” quack who is antivaccine.
Lyons-Weiler also portrays the suspension of Dr. Thomas’ license as a threat to their trial, to which I was tempted to say, “Good! It’s a scientifically crappy trial designed to generate propaganda and disinformation for the antivaccine movement”. What I’ll say instead is: How? It’s a retrospective study. The data are already there and just need to be analyzed in the manner the investigators stated that they would do. Given that there are 20 years’ worth of data, stopping now is unlikely to make any difference in the number of subjects in the study. Of course, likely Lyons-Weiler knows that, but realizes that his audience does not. He needs a threat, and he needs a hook to ask for money.
You get the idea.
State medical boards: More please!
What the Oregon Medical Board has done with Dr. Thomas (and Dr. LaTulippe) is a very rare occurrence. All too often, after being obtained for the first time medical licenses end up in practice being more like a right rather than a privilege, and it often takes incredible effort on the part of state medical boards to suspend or revoke a physician’s medical license, even quacks like Stanislaw Burzynski, who still has a Texas medical license after 40 years of Texas Medical Board efforts to stop his quackery. Look at Dr. Bob Sears, who did have his license restricted with the condition that he practice under the supervision of the Medical Board of California for three years. The list goes on.
Basically, it’s very difficult in most states (some more than others) for the state medical board to suspend or revoke a physician’s license, which is why many medical boards, by and large, tend to go after mainly the easiest, most obvious cases. That’s why the physician behaviors most likely to result in strong action against a medical license include running a prescription mill, sexual improprieties with patients, or practicing while impaired due to addiction to alcohol or illicit substances. It’s a matter of resource allocation and prioritization. State medical boards tend to react primarily to what they perceive to be the most immediately and obviously dangerous behaviors; most importantly, though, behaviors that can be definitively proven. It’s worse than that, though. In some states, Quacks like Dr. Rashid Buttar still practice and even have enough political influence among legislators to get state laws rewritten to be more favorable to quacks.
That’s why, seeing what the Oregon Medical Board did last week, suspending the licenses of two dangerous doctors in rapid succession, I can only say: More, please.

iate Professor of Surgery and member of the faculty of the Graduate Program in Cancer Biolog

State legislators dispense with standard of care for COVID treatment and encourage medical misinformation
State legislatures are considering bills that protect doctors and other health care providers from being held accountable for using unproven COVID-19 treatments and spreading medical misinformation.
Jann Bellamy on February 10, 2022
Link

Legislators in several states have introduced bills, some of which have passed, protecting physicians who prescribe unproven COVID-19 prophylaxes and treatments (like hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin) from discipline by state medical boards. Other bills hamstring efforts to prevent the spread of medical misinformation.
Such proposals, typically sponsored by Republicans and supported in Republican-led statehouses, substitute the judgment of legislators, who often have no science background, for that of medical peers, and relieve physicians of the burden of adhering to a standard of care. As noted bioethicist Arthur Caplan told a reporter, this type of legislation is “purely ideology masquerading as medicine”.
Today we’ll take a look (in no particular order) at some of these efforts to sacrifice good patient care on the altar of political expediency as well as welcome pushback from the medical profession.
One bill has already become law in Tennessee where, as I explained in a previous post,
the legislature bull[ied] the state medical board into rescinding its COVID anti-misinformation policy and [threw] huge bureaucratic obstacles in the board’s way before it can discipline physicians who use unproven COVID treatments, including downright quackery.
By way of background, as noted in that post:
In July [2021], the FSMB [Federation of State Medical Boards] issued a statement reminding physicians who spread COVID misinformation that they risk disciplinary action. Since then, according to the FSMB, at least 15 boards published statements about false or misleading information and at least 12 boards have taken disciplinary action against a licensee. The FSMB is currently developing guidelines for medical boards to help address the spread of disinformation.
Although the statement did not address the use of unproven therapies, this crackdown sent physicians, under threat from being held to the standard of care, running to their friends in state government for protection from medical boards doing their job.
Like Tennessee, North Dakota has already taken action. A new law protects from discipline physicians, nurse practitioners, and pharmacists who prescribe, dispense, or administer ivermectin, although a regulatory board can still take action on another basis, such as inappropriate documentation, substandard care, or “any basis that would in the board’s determination harm the patient”.
This is somewhat of an improvement over the original bill, which would have shielded the prescription of any drug off-label for the treatment of COVID-19, as well as
distributing documented medical information, providing information regarding the licensee’s professional experience or observations, or speaking against a public official.
Which would be a cover for, say, distributing information “documented” in sketchy source material or relying on “professional experience” that flies in the face of evidence-based medicine.
The legislation was opposed by hospital, medical, and pharmacy groups, to no avail.
In a sign of just how far down the rabbit hole some legislators have gone, one of the bill’s sponsors, Rep. Bill Tveit,
responded to data showing that unvaccinated people die at a higher rate with his own data: screenshots of a self-reported article from doctor Stella Immanuel, who in October 2021 claimed she and her team treated more than 7,000 patients, of which “only eight precious souls,” who she wrote had advanced stages of COVID, died. Immanuel, who was briefly boosted by Donald Trump when he was president, has also contended that the US government is at least partially run by reptiles.
Fortunately, despite rowdy constituents who appeared at a committee hearing to support the bill, Virginia rejected a similar effort. The state legislature recently voted down a proposal that would have protected doctors and pharmacists who prescribed or dispensed ivermectin and other off-label COVID-19 treatments.
In a particularly ham-fisted attempt, a Colorado bill was introduced last year that would shield physicians, nurse practitioners, and pharmacists who prescribe or dispense any FDA-approved drug off-label for the treatment of COVID-19, specifically including hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin, as long as the patient gives “informed consent”. Not only could providers not be disciplined for prescribing, no matter their degree of negligence or the harm caused, regulators were forbidden from even initiating an investigation of such conduct. Happily, the bill failed.
A bill introduced in Pennsylvania, and now before the House Health Committee, would prohibit regulatory boards from taking disciplinary action against physicians (as well as other providers) for prescribing, with the patient’s “informed consent”, or dispensing, any therapeutic drug
for off-label use to the patient for prophylaxis or for at-home, early-stage outpatient or hospital inpatient treatment of coronavirus infections [not just COVID-19] causing respiratory syndrome-related illnesses . . . absent a showing of recklessness or gross negligence.
As originally filed, there were no circumstances under which a physician could be held responsible for inappropriate prescribing. It was only in the amended bill that recklessness or gross negligence was added to allow disciplinary action. Legally, this replaces the usual negligence standard (that is, falling below the standard of care, or what a reasonable physician would do in similar circumstances) with a very high bar. Although state law can vary, recklessness generally requires a showing that the physician was “so careless that it is considered an extreme departure from the care that a reasonable [physician] would exercise in similar circumstances”. Gross negligence “demonstrates reckless disregard for the safety or lives of others, which is so great it appears to be a conscious violation of other people’s rights to safety”.
In Wisconsin, a group of legislators recently unveiled a set of so-called “medical freedom” bills that prohibit hospitals and other health care entities and credentialing agencies (such as the state medical board) from taking action against a health care provider
for ordering an innovative or novel therapy based on his or her assessment of the patient and any available clinical data supporting the innovative or novel therapy.
The bills are startling in their breadth. They would apply to the entire range of licensed health care providers in Wisconsin including, in addition to physicians and nurses, chiropractors and massage therapists. “Innovative or novel therapy” is undefined and is not limited to drugs. Protection from disciplinary or other adverse action is not confined to treatment of COVID-19 and presumably applies to any disease or condition.
Of course, “any available clinical data” would allow the provider to cherry-pick the data to support his choice of therapies. This is evidenced by the legislators’ citation to a dodgy website, the anonymous “c19early.com”, for treatments they claim are “demonstrating clear signals of efficacy and robust safety profiles”. This includes the decidedly inefficacious ivermectin, the drug of choice among the conspiracy-minded, such as the legislators themselves, who say that
[m]any continue to speculate as to the exact reasons why the efforts of these health care professionals have been actively suppressed by those who have assumed the responsibility of dictating the response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
In another demonstration of utter cluelessness, the bills’ proponents depict the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance [FLCCC] as
health care professionals with first-hand experience treating COVID-19 patients through each phase of the disease [who] worked tirelessly to identify and utilize early treatment options . . .
FLCCC has made several appearances here on SBM, and not in a good way. As Dr. David Gorski details, the “brave maverick doctors” of FLCCC have concocted COVID-19 protocols using ivermectin, vitamins, melatonin, zinc, mouthwash and other nostrums, but
[n]one of these protocols has anything resembling solid evidence from randomized clinical trials to support it.
A third “medical freedom” bill would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense a prescribed drug unless there is an “absolute contradiction” to the patient’s taking the drug. This amends current law, which allows a pharmacist to refuse a prescription if there is simply a “contradiction”. “Absolute contradiction” means that the drug is
not safe to be used as prescribed under any circumstance because of the severe or potentially life-threatening risks involved.
This is necessary, according to the bill’s sponsors, because, citing hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin as examples,
big government, corporate media, and big pharma have waged a war of intimidation on pharmacists who distribute medicines in the treatment or prevention of COVID-19.
Fortunately, the medical profession and hospitals are pushing back. According to the Wisconsin Hospital Association:
This legislation removes the most fundamental tool hospitals use to ensure safe patient care through medical staff governance and privileging. This legislation circumvents an existing evidence-based process medical staff within a hospital use to maximize the health and safety of the patients and communities they serve.
And, from the Wisconsin Medical Society:
[W]e believe these bills are not necessary. Further, the bills appear to undermine some basic safeguards now in place that help prevent care that might fall below minimal accepted standards.
A bill has been introduced in Indiana that permits physicians and nurse practitioners to create “standing orders” allowing pharmacists to dispense ivermectin without a prescription. Per the bill, ivermectin thus dispensed is, ipso facto,
considered to be issued for a legitimate medical purpose in the usual course of professional practice.
The standing order must “specify a mechanism to document the screening performed with the patient” and the dose dispensed in the patient’s medical record, as well as a “plan for evaluating and treating adverse events”.
The pharmacist must give the person receiving ivermectin under a standing order “a standardized information sheet” that has to include “the importance of follow-up care and health care referral information” but cannot discourage the recipient from using ivermectin for the treatment of COVID-19. Physicians and nurse practitioners cannot be disciplined if the pharmacist fails to follow a standing order and pharmacists cannot be disciplined if there is a defect in the standing order.
Frankly, I am not sure how all this would work. How would the pharmacist verify that the standing order is legitimate? (I’m assuming here that the patient keeps the standing order until he wants to use it?) Does giving the patient accurate information about ivermectin, such as the overwhelming consensus that it is ineffective and its risks, constitute “discouraging” the patient from using it? Can pharmacists refuse to participate? (I assume, for one thing, that screening and other procedures will take time the busy pharmacist may not have to spend on this sort of thing.) Who is to execute this “plan” for adverse events?
In any event, this bill is identical in language to one introduced in New Hampshire, which may mean there is some as-yet-unidentified group pushing it. Fortunately, according to a local news report, multiple medical experts testified against this bill in a recent committee hearing. Also encouraging is the news that a “fact-based” coalition made up of “more than 50 business leaders, healthcare institutions and advocacy groups” has been formed in New Hampshire to educate legislators and the public about COVID-related issues.
Finally, my state of Florida, is not about to be left behind in this race to the bottom. Companion House and Senate bills would allow the medical and other health care practitioner regulatory boards to discipline health care providers for misinformation (called “free speech” in the bill) posted on social media only if the board can prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” (the evidentiary standard required for conviction in criminal cases) that the “free speech” “led to the direct physical harm” of an actual patient of the practitioner.
This is, in effect, an impossible standard to meet. Nevertheless, boards could be fined up to $1.5 million (a figure apparently pulled from nowhere) each time they try to discipline a practitioner for “free speech” but fail to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt.
        ◦ I’m sure it was merely a coincidence, but the House bill was filed just as we were learning that a Florida physician had lodged a complaint with the medical board against our infamous Surgeon General, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, for spreading false information. To no one’s surprise, the complaint that was promptly dismissed, no threat of a $1.5 million penalty required.

State legislatures consider bills prohibiting COVID-19 vaccination mandates and other public health measures
Bills seek to prevent the states and private employers from mandating COVID-19 vaccines and other pandemic mitigation measures. Some proposed legislation would severely handicap public health officials in combating future health emergencies.
Jann Bellamy on March 11, 2021
Link

Although, to my knowledge, no government entity or employer has actually mandated COVID-19 vaccination, legislation is pending in several states to head off any such attempts. Some of these bills attack mitigation measures like mask wearing as well, or provide religious and other exemptions to COVID-19 immunization. Other, more sweeping, bills tie the hands of public health officials with overly-broad measures going well beyond the current pandemic and exhibiting little regard to what the future may bring.
The vast majority of bills, almost to the point of exclusivity, are sponsored by Republican legislators. As is true of bills weakening or eliminating school immunization requirements, anti-vaccination organizations like the Alliance for Natural Health, which assiduously protects your right to be bamboozled by fringe medical practitioners and their nostrums, are busy lobbying state legislatures to make sure vaccination mandates and the like never see the light of day, or at least permit generous exemptions.
While I don’t believe broad COVID-19 mandates are warranted in our current circumstances, too many of these bills attack sensible public health measures like mask wearing or ban mandates in situations where they may be appropriate, like long-term care facilities. Bills broadly handicapping public health officials without thinking through the consequences are downright dangerous.
Before we get to the pending legislation, let’s look briefly at how current federal law addresses state and private employer mandates. The FDA allows administration of the three COVID-19 vaccines currently available in the U.S. under an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) issued for each. Per the federal law allowing the FDA to issue EUAs, the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services must specify whether individuals may refuse the vaccine and the consequences for that refusal. Here, the FDA has made clear that anyone may refuse a COVID-19 vaccination and requires that this information be disclosed to the public. According to a recent JAMA Viewpoint article by public health and health law experts, “mandating COVID-19 vaccines under an EUA is legally and ethically problematic”.
However, at the end of last year, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission issued pandemic-related Q&As that “favor a voluntary vaccination approach, but do not expressly prohibit a mandatory policy with appropriate ‘outs’ for disability and religious accommodations.” As best I can tell, the advice was not limited to vaccines with full FDA approval.
Where employees are unionized, a collective bargaining agreement could require bargaining over the implementation of a mandate, or even consent-based vaccination, to avoid violating federal labor laws.
In sum, federal law does not require vaccination of anyone but apparently does not prohibit private-sector employers from mandating employee vaccinations. (Please note: this is an SBM post, not legal advice. Consult a lawyer if you have questions.)
With that, let’s turn to the pending state bills. As noted in my previous post on school vaccination legislation, different states have different abbreviations for legislation. To simply things (for me), I’m going to use whatever combination of letters and numbers the particular state uses with a link to the legislature’s website, where you can find all the details.
Hog-tying public health
Legislators in several states have introduced bills curtailing the authority of health officials to implement mitigation measures in a public health emergency. These take various forms, some disallowing vaccination mandates altogether, others adding that anyone refusing voluntary vaccination in an emergency cannot be quarantined or isolated, while others still create exemptions to vaccination mandates. Some bills are directed only at COVID-19; others cover all immunization mandates. The titles of, and language used in, several bills give us a hint as to their sponsors’ ideological leanings.
Maryland HB 17, the “Consent of the Governed Act”, is an especially ham-fisted and poorly drafted reaction to the state’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic. Current Maryland law allows the Governor to declare a state of emergency and to issue orders to mitigate that emergency, such as Gov. Larry Hogan’s orders restricting restaurant capacity, mandating mask-wearing, and similar measures.
No matter the emergency or its circumstances, HB 17 limits the duration of any state of emergency to 14 days, with a 14-day extension if approved by a two-thirds majority of the General Assembly, which must convene within 3 days of the order. Oddly, an emergency order cannot apply at all to state legislators or judges and the Governor cannot “threaten or arrest” legislators or judges for violation of an emergency order.
The Governor cannot require
any member of the public to remain indoors, wear a face covering, not congregate or assemble, close or limit capacity of a business, church, or school, or interfere with the right to obtain and try any medical treatment desired for any illness . . . or receive a vaccine or be forced under penalty of law to make any other health decision.
Private citizens would have the right to sue to enforce this proposed law and could get an injunction and treble damages (and attorneys’ fees and costs) if they can prove the emergency order is “unreasonable as applied” to them.
A similar effort to gut public health measures during emergencies is underway in Missouri. HB 1144 tracks the language of a “Right to Refuse” Model Act promoted by the “National Health Freedom Action” organization. As I described in a post last September, this group and its associates spread vaccine and COVID-19 misinformation and support laws shielding quacks, allowing the sale of unpasteurized milk, and otherwise protecting pseudoscience and those who benefit from its commodification.
HB 1144’s sweeping provisions handicap both the state government and individual business owners who try to institute protective measures such as mask wearing and building capacity limitations, giving everyone the right to refuse such measures and imposing absurd conditions on their implementation. For example, a shop owner who wants customers to wear a mask must read aloud portions of the law granting the right to refuse this and other mitigation attempts to each potential customer, give them a written copy of the law, and get a written acknowledgement of its receipt.
In South Carolina, HB 3217 allows anyone to refuse a vaccination offered as “part of any mass immunization project to protect against infectious disease, or to prevent the spread of a pandemic or a contagious or possibly contagious disease”. HB 3511 goes even further, providing that anyone who refuses a vaccination in such circumstances “may not be denied any right or privilege of citizenship”, which is defined to include “shopping”.
In another sweeping measure, South Carolina HB 3526 transfers the authority to declare a state of emergency from the Governor to the state legislature and removes “public health emergency” altogether (and well as other events) from the list of circumstances permitting an emergency declaration. Declared public health emergencies would still be allowed in some circumstances but the power to mitigate them is reduced. For example, an infectious agent, chemical agent, or the like, posing “a substantial risk” of “widespread illness” would no longer be a sufficient reason for a public health emergency, which would be limited to risks of “a significant number of human fatalities” or “a serious economic impact to the agricultural sector, including food supply”. The authority to temporarily isolate or quarantine anyone is completely removed and a court order required.
In North Dakota, HB 1320, which was, fortunately, soundly defeated, would have banned any state vaccination mandate, in any circumstances, and prohibited “making receipt of a vaccine a condition for entry, education, employment, or services”, presumably pre-empting school vaccination mandates along with the rest. It was strongly opposed by school officials and the science-based health community and supported by a North Dakota “health freedom” organization and two chiropractors, among others.
In Oklahoma, a similar bill (SB 223), provides that any state entity, including school districts, cannot “through direct or indirect means, compel or coerce any person . . . to receive any immunization”, seemingly eliminating all school vaccination requirements as well. Likewise, Oklahoma SB 352 prevents any state entity or from compelling or coercing anyone “to undergo any unwanted medical procedure”, including immunizations and face mask wearing, with persons violating the proposed law subject to misdemeanor conviction. (Private employers are specifically excepted.)
In what appears to be an attempt to cover any and all situations that could possibly arrive, Idaho HB 63, prohibits any state or local law or order that mandates “vaccination, immunization, genetic modulation, or inoculation” (or, as the bill refers to it, “forced or coerced vaccination”) in “any state of disaster or emergency or any proclaimed state of extreme emergency, insurrection, or martial law” and prohibits quarantining or isolation of those who refuse vaccination. (I had to look up “genetic modulation“. The science is beyond me but I am curious as to how it would come into play in an insurrection and such.)
With the preamble that a new law is required to “maintain the individual liberty, parental rights, and free market principles of the citizens and businesses of Nebraska”, LB 643 allows anyone to refuse vaccination during a state of emergency declared by the Governor “or anytime thereafter” without punishment, penalty, or “implication”.
A Florida bill (HB 6003) removes the authority of the state Public Health Officer, in a public health emergency, to require quarantine of anyone refusing vaccination and to require vaccination of an individual who poses a threat to the public health when quarantine is unavailable. Kentucky law currently allows the state’s health agency to require vaccination in any area where a pandemic is declared. HB 36 (the “Ensuring Bodily Autonomy and Informed Consent Act”) and SB 37 would repeal that authority.
In Tennessee, under current law, any person’s right to claim a religious exemption from immunizations and medical procedures (presumably including testing) is suspended when an epidemic threatens and an employee’s religious exemption right is suspended when necessary to protect the health of others. HB 10 (which failed in a subcommittee of the Health Committee) and SB 07 would eliminate those suspensions as well as institute blanket religious and conscience exemptions for all immunizations and medical procedures. The bills would also eliminate misdemeanor charges for physicians who fraudulently provide medical exemptions or certificates of vaccination. Specific to COVID-19, Tennessee SB 187 and HB 13 provide that government entities “shall not force, require, or coerce a person to receive an immunization or vaccination for COVID-19 against the person’s will”, although, without a state COVID-19 vaccination mandate, they would not have any authority to do so in the first place.
Washington HB 1006 creates “religious, philosophical, or personal” objections to all state-mandated immunizations, including any that might be required for state and day care center employees, and adds these exemptions to the school-mandated MMR immunization, which is currently limited to medical exemptions.
Virginia HB 2242 prohibits the state from requiring COVID-19 vaccinations and prohibits discrimination based on vaccination status in a number of situations, including health insurance coverage and state employment, where vaccine refusal is accorded the same status as other traditionally protected classes in employment discrimination law, like race, religion, and gender.
Although Wisconsin law permits health officials to mandate immunization in a public health emergency, SB 4 and AB 23 would exclude COVID-19 vaccination from this law. New York A 4269 prohibits mandatory COVID-19 vaccinations as well. In Connecticut, proposed bills prohibit the state from mandating any vaccine that has been given only an EUA (SB 405) and the COVID-19 vaccine in particular (HB 5401). Similarly, Virginia HB 2336 prohibits both public and private entities from requiring any vaccine that is not FDA-approved, presumably including those with only EUA.
Should any state entity mandate COVID-19 vaccination for any purpose, such as employment or school attendance, Washington SB 5144 allows “religious, philosophical, or personal” exemptions. In Virginia, HB 2268 adds a religious exemption to immunizations required by public health authorities during an epidemic as well as removes the suspension of the religious belief exemption for school vaccinations during an emergency or epidemic. Michigan HB 4008 adds medical and religious belief exemptions to immunizations administered during a pandemic, although parents are allowed to refuse consent for immunization of a child on any ground.
Not all bills curtail the ability to act in an emergency. New York A 416 allows the governor, in consultation with state health authorities, to determine “by clear and convincing evidence” that “the health of others is or may be endangered” by an actual or suspected “case, contact or carrier” of a contagious disease which “may pose a significant threat to the public health resulting in severe morbidity or high mortality”. Upon this determination, the “case, contact or carrier” can be detained for at least 3 days, and for up to 60 days with additional due process protections but, in any case, for no longer than they are contagious. The order can be directed at an individual or a group, who can be detained “in a medical facility or other appropriate facility . . . designated by the governor”. In addition to detention, the governor can require quarantine and order testing, vaccination, and treatment, although no medication can be required without a court order.
New York A 2081 adds COVID-19 vaccination to the list of required immunizations for residents and employees of long-term care facilities, with medical and religious exemptions as well as the right to refuse “after being fully informed of the health risks” of refusal.
Employers restricted
A number of states have legislation proposed or pending that bar employers from mandating either vaccinations in general, or COVID-19 vaccinations in particular, whether in certain circumstances or by banning them altogether.
Connecticut’s proposed HB 5402 prohibits any employer from requiring proof of COVID-19 vaccination from employees, vendors and customers, presumably including hospitals, long-term care facilities, and the like. It also bans public officials from requiring proof of vaccination as a condition of using some public facilities, like parks.
Mississippi HB 719 (which died in committee) and Wisconsin bills SB 5 and AB 25 would prohibit any employer from requiring that employees be vaccinated against COVID-19, while Kentucky SB 37 and Oklahoma HB 1057 would prohibit employers from requiring vaccination against any disease. All of these bills appear to include hospitals, nursing homes, retirement communities, and similar businesses.
In Minnesota, HF 261 requires that COVID-19 vaccines be made available to teachers and other school employees but says they (and students) can’t be required to take them. Similarly, Missouri HB 838 prohibits public employers from requiring COVID-19 vaccination for public employees, no matter where they work. North Dakota HB 1301, which was defeated, prohibited employers from requiring vaccination of employees, with hospitals, long-term care facilities, and the like excluded, although medical and religious exemptions were allowed. Interestingly, even though the bill also contained protection against liability for the transmission of communicable diseases, it was opposed by the business community, which wanted to retain the right to require employee immunization. Conversely, Oregon SB 451 prohibits immunization requirements for registered nurses and other medical staff as a condition of employment.
Pennsylvania HB 262 bars both private and state government employers from requiring any immunization or “invasive medical test”, defined to include providing tissue or bodily fluid samples (in other words, including COVID-19 testing). Employees can sue for treble damages if they are retaliated against or otherwise penalized for their refusals. Indiana SB 74 grants employees medical, religious and “conscience” exemptions from vaccinations required by an employer and prohibits, upon pain of actual and punitive damages, any discrimination against an employee claiming an exemption. Indiana HB 1488 prohibits employer-required vaccinations if the vaccine has only emergency use approval and bans the employer from inquiring into the employee’s reason for refusing the vaccine.
Given the inevitability of future pandemics and other health emergencies, I worry about how states will manage without the public health tools eliminated by this year’s proposed legislation. Fortunately, some ill-conceived bills have already been defeated. You can help ensure others suffer the same fate by contacting your state representatives.

Dr. Joseph Ladapo of “America’s Frontline Doctors” is now in charge of public health in Florida
Dr. Joseph Ladapo, a member of the fringe medical group “American’s Frontline Doctors” and signer of the widely criticized Great Barrington Declaration, is Florida’s new Surgeon General, appointed because he agrees with the dubious COVID-19 policies of Gov. DeSantis and, like the Governor, allows ideology to trump science.
Jann Bellamy on September 23, 2021
Link

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has found his ideal ideologue in Dr. Joseph Ladapo, whom he appointed this week as Florida’s Surgeon General and head of the state’s Department of Health. (While technically he must be confirmed by the Florida Senate, this is a mere formality in the Republican-controlled legislature.) Dr. Ladapo will thus be in charge of public health for Florida’s 21-million-plus citizens (including me), running an agency of some 17,000 employees tasked with, among other jobs, the state’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic. He has also been hired by the University of Florida’s med school, which DeSantis claims is totally coincidental.
He will replace Dr. Scott Rivkees, the current state Surgeon General, who has resigned. Dr. Rivkees, a pediatric endocrinologist, has been sidelined by the DeSantis administration, presumably because he refuses to go along with DeSantis’s policies. The Deputy Secretary of Health has also resigned.
Dr. Ladapo does not have a background in public health and has never been in charge of so much as a department at the UCLA Geffen School of Medicine where, prior to his appointment, he was an associate professor and health policy researcher “whose primary research interests include assessing the cost-effectiveness of diagnostic technologies and regarding the population burden of cardiovascular disease”, according to his UCLA bio (which was just taken down). He has an MD and PhD in Health Policy from Harvard and is board-certified in Internal Medicine.
While obviously qualified in his particular area, it is equally obvious that he is not the most qualified person to head the public health agency of the country’s third largest state. In my view, the only reason he got the job is because DeSantis needed window dressing for his anti-science views on managing the state’s COVID response. In this regard, Dr. Ladapo is eminently qualified. Dr. Ladapo is both a member of the fringe medical group “America’s Frontline Doctors” and a signatory to the Great Barrington Declaration, which we’ll return to in a moment.
Dr. Ladapo proved his loyalty to DeSantis on his very first full day in office by issuing an “emergency” rule giving parents sole discretion over whether their children wear masks at school. The rule also says that if a student has been exposed to COVID-19, parents can choose to keep their children in school “without restrictions or disparate treatment, so long as the student remains asymptomatic”.
A research scientist at the University of Florida’s department of biology and the Emerging Pathogens Institute told the Miami Herald that
asymptomatic people are a ‘major source’ of COVID-19 transmission. He said transmission can occur with people before they develop symptoms or with people who never develop symptoms.
The CDC recommends that students who are not fully vaccinated and are exposed to someone with COVID-19 get tested and be quarantined at home for 14 days after exposure, regardless of their test results.
Issuing the “emergency” rule was a clever political ploy that killed two birds with one stone. By replacing DeSantis’s previous ban on mask mandates, it automatically mooted at least some of the court and administrative challenges filed by school districts and parents against that ban. They will now have to file completely new lawsuits challenging the new rule. And by issuing an “emergency” rule, the Department of Health circumvented all the usual requirements of notice to the public and possibly a hearing before the rule could be implemented.
Dr. Ladapo continues the DeSantis tradition of listening only to “experts” who happen to agree with him, like Drs. Scott Atlas and Jay Bhattacharya, whom DeSantis chose as his expert witness in the recent case he lost over mask mandates.
At the press event announcing his appointment, Dr. Ladapo said he would “reject fear” as a public health strategy, saying fear has been “something that’s been unfortunately a centerpiece of health policy in the United States ever since the beginning of the pandemic, and it’s over here”.
He accused unspecified “scientists” of “taking the science and basically misrepresenting it to fit their agendas”. This is from a person who, as you will see, has repeatedly been involved in misrepresentations of science, has raised unwarranted fears about the COVID-19 vaccines, and most definitely has an agenda.
When asked whether Florida should be promoting vaccination, Dr. Ladapo said that too much emphasis had been placed on that approach, that it’s “been treated almost like a religion and that’s just senseless”, and that the state should be supporting several measures for good health: “vaccination, losing weight, exercising more (and) eating more fruits and vegetables”, which made it sound like he was promoting eating vegetables as the equivalent of vaccination. He acknowledged that the COVID-19 vaccine “prevents the risk of serious illness” but said
People get to make the choice about what they want to do with that information.
Yep, and the rest of us just have to live with the consequences.
DeSantis chimed in that “telling the truth is important” and that
You’ve got to tell people the truth and you’ve got to let them make their decisions.
This is interesting sentiment from a governor who has repeatedly lied about the effectiveness of masks, falsely stating that they don’t work, that they cause disease and developmental issues in children, and that they interfere with breathing. He also relentlessly promoted hydroxychloroquine, despite the lack of evidence, going so far as to cop a million doses of the stuff, most of which sat unused. His promotion created a run on the drug, which infuriated rheumatologists, whose patients need hydroxychloroquine as a legitimate treatment for lupus and rheumatoid arthritis. Oh, and he recently stood by silently while a speaker he’d invited to weigh in against vaccine mandates falsely claimed that the COVID vaccine “changes your RNA”.
Given extraordinary powers over public health by the legislature, DeSantis has banned mask mandates, vaccine mandates, “vaccine passports” and, except for very early in the pandemic, has rejected shutdowns as a means of virus control. He has, of late, de-emphasized vaccination and continued his policy of fully opening up the state, his strategy being to set up monoclonal antibody clinics and treat the disease instead of preventing it. He has positioned himself as the anti-Fauci and fundraised via the sale of sophomoric merchandise like “Don’t Fauci my Florida” tee shirts and anti-mask beer koozies.
None of this has worked out well for the citizens of Florida.
Florida saw a terrific surge in cases, hospitalizations, and deaths over the summer, with nearly 20% of tests coming back positive. As of September 22nd, Florida has the second highest COVID-19 death rate in the nation. About a month ago, we also had the nation’s highest hospitalization rate. Our percentage of people fully vaccinated is just under 57%, 21st in the nation.
With that, let’s turn our attention to some interesting background information on my new Surgeon General.
America’s Frontline Doctors
The COVID pandemic has brought the kooks out of the woodwork and, in a crowded field, none kookier than Dr. Stella Immanuel, one of the founders of the fringe medical group, America’s Frontline Doctors, which is affiliated with the right-wing organization Tea Party Patriots Action. She has famously claimed that “tormenting spirits” are responsible for “serious gynecological problems” and impotence, and that “many women suffer from astral sex regularly”, “astral sex” being “the ability to project one’s spirit man into the victim’s body and have sex with it” which is “very common among Satanists”.
Dr. Immanuel was a speaker at an America’s Frontline Doctors-sponsored “White Coat Conference” held last year on the steps of the U.S. Supreme Court, although the Court had nothing to do with the event. She falsely claimed that hydroxychloroquine, zinc, and Zithromax were “cures” for COVID-19. (This and other misinformation caused a video of the event to be pulled from social media.) Also speaking was Dr. Simone Gold, who later distinguished herself by participating in the January 6th insurrection, going so far as to enter the Capitol Building, which had conveniently been opened up for her by thugs smashing through the windows and doors and overcoming the Capitol police. This got her both arrested and fired from her job. Among other crackpot statements, Dr. Gold has claimed that the COVID-19 vaccine is actually an “experimental, biological agent deceptively named a vaccine”.
And guess who else put in an appearance at the “Conference”? Florida’s new Surgeon General, Dr. Ladapo, himself a member of America’s Frontline Doctors.
In addition to his work with America’s Frontline Doctors, Dr. Ladapo has written a series of opinion pieces for The Wall St. Journal that, to borrow a phrase, have taken the science and basically misrepresented it to fit his agenda. Each one could probably merit its own post, so I’ll limit our review to a few highlights.
A June 22, 2021 WSJ Commentary by Dr. Ladapo and a co-author carried the clickbait headline “Are Covid Vaccines Riskier Than Advertised?”, with the subhead “There are concerning trends on blood clots and low platelets, not that the authorities will tell you”. A better title would have been “Anti-Vaccination Talking Points”, perhaps with the subhead “Things THEY don’t want you to know”.
Basically the authors claim that there is a government cover-up of adverse events from the COVID-19 vaccine, even though the data they looked at to support this assertion was government-published adverse event reporting, the VAERS database. Speaking of “agendas”, they say that “the silence around these potential signals of harm reflects the politics surrounding Covid-19 vaccines”, even while admitting that this government-published data cannot demonstrate a causal link between a vaccine and a claimed harm. They then say that “stigmatizing such concerns is bad for scientific integrity and could harm patients”, a “stigmatization” they apparently fabricated. If the government isn’t saying anything, as they charge, how can it be “stigmatizing” anyone’s “concerns”?
They then dress up a Norwegian Medicines Agency report on death following vaccination in the frail elderly as a “sign of life for scientific honesty” just so they can throw in some scary statistics, which, as Dr. Gorski explained in a post on anti-vaccination fear-mongering, aren’t so scary after all.
In any event, their claim of “silence” around the four potential adverse events they highlight (thrombocytopenia, myocarditis, deep-vein thrombosis, and death) is nonsense. The CDC has posted information on all of these; for example, here, here, here, and here.
In his WSJ columns, Dr. Ladapo has continually flogged ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, writing as recently as September 16th that the evidence regarding these drugs is “unsettled”, citing (and linking to the website of) the self-declared Early COVID Care Experts group, because they “have reported low rates of hospitalization and death when using these therapies”. In other words, anecdotal evidence trumps clinical trials. The Early COVID Care Experts include (in addition to Dr. Ladapo himself), conspiracy theorist Dr. Peter McCollough, who falsely claimed that COVID vaccines have killed up to 50,000 people, that vaccines don’t protect against the delta variant, and there’s no clinical reason to go get vaccinated. He was recently sued by a Baylor University health system affiliate to stop him from claiming he is associated with that institution because of “irreparable reputational and business harm” to the institution.
Another member is Dr. Victor Zelenko, whose claim that his cocktail of drugs, including hydroxychloroquine, was “100% effective” was apparently a factor in former President Donald Trump’s embrace of this “miracle” cure.
Other of his commentaries have attacked mask and vaccine mandates. The latter, he says, “can’t end the spread of the virus as effectiveness declines and new variants emerge” and “are not 100 percent effective at preventing a vaccinated person from spreading the disease”. While it is true that mandates may not “end” the pandemic, they certainly do help prevent the spread of the virus and keep people out of the hospital (as he admits). Why make the perfect the enemy of the good? No intervention is 100% effective, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t at least consider using it.
In attacking mask mandates (which is really an attack on mask wearing itself) he claims that “most [trials] have shown that wearing a mask has little or no effect on respiratory virus transmission”. This is simply untrue.
If there is one consistent theme running through his WSJ columns, it is that things he doesn’t agree with (e.g. masks) are not supported by sufficient evidence, no matter how strong the evidence is in their favor. At the same time, the things he does agree with (e.g., ivermectin), he contends, are being rejected just because they are not “certain”, even when they, in fact, have sufficient competent evidence to reject their use. It’s almost as if the more evidence there is, the greater his objection, while the less evidence there is, the more enthusiastic he becomes.
Finally, there’s Dr. Ladapo’s signature on the greatly problematic Great Barrington Declaration, the central thesis of which is that we should lock down only the most vulnerable and let everyone else go about their business until herd immunity is reached. (He has since backpedaled somewhat, saying there were “a couple of things” he didn’t agree with, although we don’t know which ones.) The Declaration, which was backed by a libertarian think tank, and which anyone could sign, was roundly criticized by epidemiologists and other experts. There were a number of reasons for this, which Dr. Gorski covered extensively in his post on the subject, but the main reason was, according to epidemiologists, it was unlikely to work. It was also highly dubious ethically.
Back in 2016, Dr. Ladapo wrote an opinion piece for The Washington Post about the valuable lessons he learned from his wife’s unfortunate experience with what he describes as a chronic, debilitating illness. Lesson No. 2 is “Don’t be afraid to ask for a specialist”.
This experience [finding effective pain relief for his wife] reiterated how important it is to bring in specialists. As an internist, most of my training in pain management happened on the job while caring for patients with cancer. Though I picked up strategies from more experienced nurse practitioners and physicians, I don’t have nearly the expertise of specialists, who receive formal training in a range of interventions and therapies. They also spend more time with patients suffering from chronic, painful conditions and learn through these interactions how to better aid their suffering.
It is sad that Dr. Ladapo fails to recognize the need for humility and respect for those with greater expertise now. He has no expertise in public health, epidemiology, virology, or infectious diseases, yet he has, over and over, scorned the advice of those who do.
        ◦ Perhaps as the weight of his new job as protector of the public health settles in, his willingness to pontificate about matters outside the scope of his education and training will abate and he will again have the wisdom to listen to those with the formal training and experience necessary to effectively combat the pandemic. Of course, if that happens, he will likely be out of a job, just like Dr. Rivkees. Only time and Florida’s COVID stats will tell.

Florida Surgeon General declares single positive COVID test proves immunity forever
Florida’s Surgeon General, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, continues to defy scientific consensus with new rules declaring a single positive COVID test proves one has “natural immunity” forever. This is but one example of recently enacted laws and similar efforts gutting public health protections in Florida, thanks to Ladapo and his boss, Gov. Ron DeSantis.
Jann Bellamy on December 30, 2021
Link

Once again defying the science, Florida’s new Surgeon General, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, recently issued an “emergency” rule basically declaring that a single positive COVID test, no matter when it was taken, proves that one has immunity from COVID in perpetuity.
Per legislation recently passed by the Florida Legislature and signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis, this “natural immunity” will exempt employees from private employer vaccine mandates. This is only one of several loopholes to private employer mandates created via the new law, which also guts other public health measures designed to protect Floridians from COVID infection.
The new legislation was passed in a whirlwind three-day special legislative session convened by DeSantis in November, a mere two months from the start of the regular session in January, 2022. In my view (shared by others), this was yet another act in DeSantis’s base-pleasing COVID theater, there being no valid reason any of this couldn’t wait a couple of months, or was necessary in the first place.
In addition to providing exemptions to private employer vaccine mandates, which we’ll return to in a moment, legislation passed during the special session:
    • Prohibits school districts from imposing mask or vaccine mandates for students and allows parents to take legal action against districts that don’t comply, as well as recover costs and attorneys’ fees. (This codifies into law DeSantis’s previously-issued executive order, and yet another Department of Health “emergency” rule, banning mandates.)
    • Prohibits school districts from quarantining asymptomatic students or school employees (even if exposed to COVID) unless they have a positive SARS-CoV-2 test.
    • Bans public employee vaccine mandates altogether (including K-12 schools, state-run healthcare facilities, and the state university system) and authorizes fines for failure to comply.
    • Removes the state health officer’s authority to require vaccination during a public health emergency.
    • Allocates $5 million to the state Attorney General to investigate complaints of violation of the new law and to fight federal vaccine mandates, with which this new legislation conflicts.
    • Begins a process intended to transfer responsibility for worker safety from the federal OSHA to a state agency.
The Legislature gave the Florida Department of Health, headed by Great Barrington Declaration supporter and (former?) member of the fringe grifter group, Americas Frontline Doctors, Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the job of fleshing out some of the new law’s provisions via the enactment of rules, hence the Surgeon General’s decision that positive COVID tests “prove” immunity.
Before we move on, let me update you on Dr. Ladapo’s tenure as Florida’s Surgeon General, as he’s been in the news near-continuously since he was introduced to SBM readers in September, where his casting doubt on vaccines, cheerleading for hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin, spreading misinformation about masks, and dumpster-diving in VAERS was reported. Since then, Dr. Ladapo has packed quite a bit of controversy into less than four months in office. Dr. Ladapo
    • got his Florida medical license in record time (two days) and then had a complaint filed against him with the medical board speedily dismissed;
    • was awarded an annual salary of $437,000 (the highest ever paid), including tens of thousands of dollars from the University of Florida’s medical school, where he was also hired, and given tenure, in record time (for teaching and research) on the suggestion of a wealthy DeSantis donor, although the press reports that Dr. Ladapo has yet to show up for work there;
    • continued to spread misinformation;
    • been kicked out of a state Senator’s office for refusing her request to wear a mask due to what she described to him as a “serious condition”, later identified as breast cancer, for which she was undergoing treatment. He has yet to apologize, instead making up a lame excuse about not be able to “communicate” while wearing a mask; and
    • starred in a PSA that barely mentioned vaccines, left out testing and mask wearing altogether, yet promoted treatments of questionable effectiveness (again).
With that, let’s turn to the exemptions to private employer vaccine mandates created by the legislature and Dr. Ladapo’s new rules implementing those exemptions.
Private Employer Vaccine Mandate Exemptions
Although DeSantis bloviated about banning all vaccine mandates, the new law, as applied to private employers, instead creates exemptions so easily met, and penalties so severe for violations, that it might as well be a ban. In fact, anyone wanting to evade a private employer vaccination mandate but unable to figure out how is probably unqualified for the workforce in the first place. Thus, DeSantis and the Legislature can claim that they are respecting a private employer’s right to make decisions about how to run his or her business while effectively gutting it.
Per the new law, if a private employer requires vaccination, an employee can opt out with:
     1.  Medical reasons, including “pregnancy or anticipated pregnancy”, based on a physician’s, P.A.’s, or nurse practitioner’s “professional opinion”, made after examining the employee, that vaccination “is not in the best medical interest of the employee”.
     2.  Sincerely held religious beliefs.
     3.  “Competent medical evidence” that the employee has immunity, “documented by the results of a valid laboratory test”.
     4.  Regular testing, at no cost to the employee.
     5.  Unspecified “employer-provided protective equipment”.
The Department of Health was directed to enact “emergency rules” to implement these exemptions within 15 days and to create forms for claiming them. Per current Florida law, emergency rules can be adopted by an agency only when
an agency finds that an immediate danger to the public health, safety, or welfare requires emergency action, [in which case] the agency may adopt any rule necessitated by the immediate danger . . .
The law also requires that the agency state
the specific facts and reasons for finding an immediate danger to the public health, safety, or welfare and its reasons for concluding that the procedure used is fair under the circumstances . . .
In this case, the Legislature obviated these prerequisites, without ever saying exactly what the emergency was or telling us what threat to the public it was supposedly alleviating, by simply declaring that “all conditions [for enacting an emergency rule] are deemed met”. It also tossed the usual requirement that emergency rules be in effect for only 90 days, allowing these very special emergency rules to remain in effect until the Department of Health could go through the regular rule-making process, which involves notice to the public, possibly a hearing, and can take months, even years, to complete (and probably won’t be completed anyway before this portion of the new law expires on its own terms on July 1, 2023).
With the usual protections for the public from government overreach conveniently short-circuited, Surgeon General Ladapo promptly issued the required emergency rules and forms.
For one, the Department of Health (presumably with a lot of “guidance” from DeSantis and Ladapo), relying on its well-known expertise in theology, decided that “based on religious reasons” included “sincerely held moral or ethical belief(s)”, an expansion that is questionable, in my view, based on the Legislature’s specifically using the term “religious reasons” in the new law. The rule also prohibits employers from inquiring “into the veracity of the employee’s religious beliefs”. In any event, the practical result of this exemption is that any employee can claim it, no questions asked.
Now, from theology we move on to the science component of the rules, or the lack thereof.
Per the Legislature’s direction to elucidate just what it meant by the term “anticipated pregnancy”, the Department decided that if the employee intends to become pregnant and is of child-bearing age, that’s an “anticipated pregnancy” and the employee’s representation must be accepted. The rule does not eliminate the requirement that a healthcare professional “document” this “medical reason” for a vaccination exemption (nor presumably could it be eliminated, based on the explicit wording of the law), leaving the employee in the curious position of having to get her doctor to sign off on her declaration that she intends to get pregnant, although the doctor, unlike the employer, is not prohibited from inquiring into the patient/employee’s statement of her intent.
More disturbingly, the Legislature, by including pregnancy and “anticipated pregnancy” as a “medical reason” for a vaccination exemption, is ignoring the advice of the CDC, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, and the Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine, among others, that COVID vaccination is safe for women who are pregnant or intend to become pregnant. Indeed, according to the CDC,
people who are pregnant or recently pregnant are more likely to get severely ill with COVID-19 compared with people who are not pregnant.
And in requiring a healthcare professional to “document an exemption based on . . . pregnancy or anticipated pregnancy”, the Legislature and the Department appear to be co-opting the medical community into endorsing its scheme. Per the exemption form devised by the Department, a physician, P.A., or nurse practitioner must declare that
It is my professional opinion . . . that COVID-19 vaccination is not in the best medical interest of the employee.
To claim an exemption based on “immunity”, the Legislature requires that
the employee must present to the employer an exemption statement demonstrating competent medical evidence that the employee has immunity to COVID-19, documented by the results of a laboratory test performed on the employee. The Department of Health shall adopt a standard for demonstrating competent medical evidence of such immunity.
Of course, the only problem is that there is no such thing as “competent medical evidence” demonstrating immunity via a lab test. Therefore, the Department adopted an “emergency rule” incorporating incompetent medical evidence to demonstrate immunity, that being an FDA-authorized or approved positive diagnostic test or a positive antibody test, even though, according to the CDC,
At this time, there is no FDA-authorized or approved test that providers or the public can use to reliably determine whether a person is protected from infection.
Diagnostic tests are designed to tell you if you have a current infection. Antibody tests look for antibodies in your immune system produced in response to the COVID-19 virus. Having a current infection does not mean you are immune from future infection. Having antibodies doesn’t mean they are sufficient to protect against an infection nor is there any agreed-upon level of antibodies that might confer protection or consensus about how long protection might last. And relying on a prior infection or the presence of antibodies to protect you sans vaccination subjects you to a much greater risk of getting reinfected than if you were vaccinated following a case of COVID. That is why the CDC (and pretty much everyone else) advises those who’ve had COVID to get vaccinated. Yet here we are.
The Department also devised an exemption form, which simply requires the employee to attach the lab test results, check a box indicating whether it is a PCR, antigen, or antibody test, and provide the test date.
Notably, there is no limitation on how old the test can be. So, if an employee had a positive diagnostic lab test in, say, January, 2020, the first time tests were made public in the U.S. (that is, almost two years ago), he can still use that result as “competent medical evidence” he has immunity.
Nor is there any limitation on how recent the test can be. Under the literal terms of the new law and the Department’s rule, an employee could submit a positive diagnostic test performed the same day, which means he should be quarantining, and meet the criteria for immunity.
In sum, in defiance of the expert consensus, the Legislature and the Dr. Ladapo have decided that (1) prior infection provides “natural immunity” from future infection in perpetuity, and (2) lab tests not designed to demonstrate “natural immunity” are a reliable way to determine this “natural immunity”.
I sense that even the Department itself is somewhat befuddled by its new rules.
When asked whether the department’s rule is making the case that natural immunity lasts forever, a department spokesperson referred a reporter back to the rule.
To ensure that private employers know the Legislature and Gov. DeSantis mean business, heavy fines can be imposed for terminating an employee for refusing vaccination: up to $10,000 for employers with fewer than 100 employees and up to $50,000 for those with greater than 100 employees. Employees can file complaints, which the law protects from public view, against their employers, triggering a requirement that the Attorney General investigate and, if she finds it appropriate, impose fines, giving the whole thing a star chamber quality.
All of this has left Florida employers in a “tough spot” according to one employment law expert, who notes that employers must now try to figure out how to comply with Florida’s new law, while at the same time comply with conflicting federal vaccine mandates per OSHA, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (covering healthcare employees), and federal contractor rules.
        ◦ Meanwhile, Florida’s COVID infection rate continues to climb, again landing our state case rate in the U.S.’s top 10.

The ABIM vs. medical misinformation: Better late than never?
Last week, the New England Journal of Medicine published an editorial by the President of ABIM discussing how the board certification can be taken away from diplomates who spread medical misinformation. Is this too little, too late?
David Gorski on May 23, 2022
Link

Over its 14 years of existence, one of the core messages of Science-Based Medicine has been very consistent. We have bemoaned how easily doctors who are quacks, antivaxxers, and grifters not only manage to avoid professional penalties and keep their medical licenses and board certifications, but often to keep practicing more or less unimpeded by either state medical boards or the private boards that certify them in their chosen medical specialties. Flowing from this dismay, we have also advocated for change to empower state medical boards and specialty boards to hold doctors accountable for professional misdeeds, up to and including being able to revoke their medical licenses and board certifications. After all, without a medical license, a physician cannot practice, and without a board certification it is very difficult to practice, as Medicare and Medicaid, as well as most insurance companies, require it to reimburse a physician, and most hospitals require it to grant privileges. One has only to consider the example of Texas cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski, who “discovered” antineoplastons in the early 1970s and has been charging large consultation fees to administer them since the late 1970s to treat cancer patients despite no good evidence that they are effective. Over the more than 40 years of having plied his quackery on cancer patients, Dr. Burzynski had managed to avoid significant sanctions from the Texas Medical Board (most recently in 2017) and the FDA for his “clinical trials” that were designed primarily as marketing tools to let him keep using antineoplastons rather than actual clinical trials to determine if antineoplastons work. So it was with great interest that I encountered an op-ed in The New England Journal of Medicine by the President and CEO of the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) Richard J. Baron, MD, and the chair of its board of directors, Yul D. Ejnes, MD, titled “Physicians Spreading Misinformation on Social Media — Do Right and Wrong Answers Still Exist in Medicine?” Obviously, I think you know how I (and SBM members) will answer, but first let me start with a little context.
COVID-19: Old quacks revitalized and joined by new quacks spreading disinformation
Burzynski arguably pioneered the technique that we see so much in evidence today; he recruited his patients to use for PR and politics to spread misinformation about cancer and “health freedom.” Basically, the techniques that Burzynski used in the 1990s to pressure the FDA and Texas Medical Board were the same techniques later used to pressure state legislatures and then the US Congress to pass “right-to-try” laws in the name of “medical freedom”. The very same technique is being used to pressure legislatures to promote laws banning COVID-19 vaccine mandates, making repurposed and ineffective treatments like ivermectin available over-the-counter, and immunizing physicians against penalties for using quackery to treat COVID-19.
When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, what we’ve been warning about since 2008 about physicians promoting quackery and misinformation very quickly became a global threat to public health. The usual physician suspects from the past, whom we had long been writing about since back in the day (e.g., Rashid Buttar, Russell Blaylock, Andrew Wakefield, Paul Thomas, Bob Sears, Sherri Tenpenny, Kelly Brogan, various members of old crank medical organizations like the AAPS, etc.), many of whom had been so forgotten that they were largely unknown outside of the deepest, darkest circles of the antivax and quack Internet, soon found themselves becoming relevant—even famous—again, along with the new generation of quacks and cranks who arose to spread COVID-19 misinformation (e.g., Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, Peter McCullough, Simone Gold, Vinay Prasad, Marty Makary, Pierre Kory, Joseph Ladapo, Paul Marik, Vladimir Zelenko, Aaron Kheriaty, and many others). There is now a veritable army of quacks, some of whom are into serious grift (e.g., America’s Frontline Doctors running a prescription mill for ivermectin), but all of whom are spreading dangerous misinformation about COVID-19, vaccines, and unproven treatments for COVID-19 like ivermectin (which to me is now disproven), hydroxychloroquine, and many others, all while doing their damnedest to promote “health freedom,” or, as I like to put it, freedom from professional responsibility, government regulation, or any consequences whatsoever for endangering patients.
Again, this was a problem that SBM had long written about going back to the very beginning of this blog, namely how toothless state medical boards are, how easily bad and even dangerous doctors can keep practicing, and how oblivious our fellow physicians had been to the threat of medical misinformation before the pandemic, a threat to which they have only fitfully been waking up. For example, I noted at the end of 2020 how it had been a year of physicians behaving badly. Before I discuss the NEJM op-ed, I think it’s worth quoting myself from nearly a year and a half ago:
If anything, the COVID-19 pandemic has reinforced my opinion, first stated 12 years ago, that medical practice itself is a sadly weak check on BS, particularly when the medical system is stressed. Just look at the list of examples that I’ve discussed in this post and realize that there are many more that I could have discussed if I didn’t mind having this post balloon up to 10,000 words or more. The point, of course, is that all too often we physicians view ourselves as relatively immune to being led astray by “BS”, certainly far more so than others. It is that arrogance that leads to doctors like Dr. Scott Atlas pontificating on areas of medicine that he doesn’t understand and then portraying himself as Galileo when criticized for it. Don’t believe me?
After listing a number of examples of physicians spreading dangerous COVID-19 misinformation, as well as historical examples, such as Stanislaw Burzynski, Christopher Duntsch, and others, I concluded:
The bottom line is that practicing medicine is a privilege, one of the highest privileges society can grant to any human being. It is not a right. Unfortunately, all too often the law treats it more like a right, with state medical boards being loathe to strip quacks and other doctors practicing inarguably substandard medicine of their privilege to practice. That needs to change, and that change needs to include stopping physicians from abusing the privilege of their profession to spread disinformation that kills, as too many physicians did in 2020 and, sadly, are likely to continue to do in 2021.
2021 has come and gone, and we’re not far from the halfway point in 2022. What’s happened? The good news is that, as a result of the tsunami of misinformation and disinformation being promoted by physicians, a disturbing number of whom are vaccine-hesitant or outright antivax, nearly a year ago the Federation of State Medical Boards asserted that spreading dangerous medical misinformation could be grounds for a physician’s license to be suspended or revoked, although, unfortunately, the FSMB has no statutory power and all state medical boards are governed by their individual state laws, which have been under assault by “health freedom” antimaskers and antivaxxers not to discipline doctors for spreading COVID-19 misinformation. As I’ve noted before, quacks and antivaxxers targeting state medical boards is nothing new. It’s long been a tactic of theirs to target state medical boards legislatively, just as advocates for pseudomedical “disciplines” like naturopathy, acupuncture, and the like have long targeted legislators to achieve licensure in more and more states. In the past, it was mostly quack-friendly legislators prodded by powerful pseudomedicine interests. For example, in 2010, the aforementioned Buttar led a successful effort by the North Carolina Integrative Medical Society to persuade legislators to change state law to make it friendlier to practitioners of alternative medicine. Now, North Carolina law prevents its medical board from disciplining a physician for using “non-traditional” or “experimental” treatments unless it can prove they are ineffective or more harmful that prevailing treatments. The same thing is happening today, just on a scale I’ve never seen before.
Other good news is that a new medical advocacy group, No License for Disinformation (NLFD) has been formed and advocates to state medical boards and specialty medical boards to take misinformation seriously and even sanction doctors who promote it. NFLD has been quite successful since it was formed in garnering press and access to state medical board officials and specialty boards. Unfortunately, much of the rest of medicine has been very resistant to such efforts, apparently viewing them as an unacceptable assault on “freedom.” Indeed, just over the weekend, I saw statements like this about a proposed California law that would empower its medical board to discipline doctors who spread misinformation.
If your dr is treating you for Covid or goes beyond the guidelines to save you, Appreciate him or her because these are the most trying times for drs. Not only do we have to stress about every lives we take on but now we have to fight boards . This is coming I’m sure👇 pic.twitter.com/JC2m85dXmH
— sabine hazan md (@SabinehazanMD) May 19, 2022
You might remember Physicians for Informed Consent, a virulently antivax physicians’ group.
With that background, let’s look at the NEJM editorial.
The ABIM weighs in…belatedly
It’s hard to argue with the opening of the NEJM op-ed on medical misinformation:
Medicine has a truth problem. In the era of social media and heavily politicized science, “truth” is increasingly crowdsourced: if enough people like, share, or choose to believe something, others will accept it as true. This way of determining “truth” doesn’t involve scientific methods; it relies instead on “the wisdom of crowds,” which has particular power in a democratic society in which leaders and policies are chosen by the will of the group. Such choices anchor concepts like freedom and liberty. But they may not be helpful in determining whether a building will collapse, whether your brakes will stop your car — or whether a medication or vaccine works.
Growing allegiance to crowd-endorsed “facts” poses a serious challenge for the institutions and structures that the medical enterprise has developed to protect the public and ensure that people can tell who can or cannot be trusted as medical professionals or relied on for scientific knowledge. These structures include comprehensive medical education, licensure, and board certification, and leaders in all these areas are struggling to figure out how to respond to assertions by doctors on social media that are not supported by evidence and may harm patients. The Surgeon General has identified medical misinformation as a major public health threat, and many professional societies, including the American Medical Association, have called for action to combat it.
As much as I hate to say “I told you so”, I told you so, at least we’ve been telling the medical profession, state medical boards, etc., so for over 14 years. None of this is anything new, and SBM has been warning about it since 2008, with some of its member having been warning about it years before. Indeed, one of our bloggers, Val Jones, even coined a term for the attitude of physicians about alternative medicine quackery, medical misinformation, antivaccine pseudoscience, and the like, describing most physicians who didn’t take it seriously as “shruggies”—and she did it in 2008, defining a “shruggie” thusly:
Shruggie (noun): a person who doesn’t care about the science versus pseudoscience debate. When presented with descriptions of exaggerated or fraudulent health claims or practices, their response is to shrug. Shruggies are fairly inert, they will not argue the merits (or lack thereof) of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) or pseudoscience in general. They simply aren’t all that interested in the discussion, and are somewhat puzzled by those who are.
Sound familiar? As hard as it is to believe, even more than two years into the pandemic and the tsunami of dangerous misinformation and conspiracy theories, there are still a lot of shruggies in the medical profession.
It hasn’t been just social media, either, which largely didn’t exist (at least not at the massive scale it does now) when Steve Novella founded SBM in 2008. The problem had been brewing years before on websites, blogs, Internet discussion forums, Usenet, and old-fashioned email lists. It had also been brewing in our very profession of medicine, with the rise of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), later “rebranded” as “integrative medicine,” which was based on the “integration” of outright quackery into evidence-based medicine. Let’s just put it this way. When there are academic departments in medical schools that promote quackery such as reiki, naturopathy, homeopathy, and even anthroposophic medicine, it’s little wonder that medical academia has been reluctant to confront those in its ranks who promote COVID-19 contrarianism, misinformation, and even outright antivax views.
Baron and Ejnes then note:
The issue of what physicians can and cannot say on social media has been hotly debated by legal scholars and in medical journals. Coleman has observed that “professional speech” is a legally contested domain between speech that can be regulated or prohibited by licensing boards and speech protected by the First Amendment. It is also unclear when physicians’ speech on social media constitutes “medical practice.”1 Mello has questioned why First Amendment protections should extend to harmful speech that leads to death from preventable disease, when some other forms of speech — such as fraudulent commercial speech, which may be less harmful — are prohibited.2
It’s true, too. No one, not even those of us at SBM who have advocated for disciplinary actions that apply to physicians who use their status as trusted professionals to give a patina of science and the authority of medicine to fraud and conspiracy theories, have claimed that there is a bright line between misinformation/disinformation and legitimate differences in scientific and medical opinion. That being said, the ABIM does ask the right question, namely, “Do Right and Wrong Answers Still Exist in Medicine?” I’ll add a spoiler alert by pointing out that the op-ed concludes, “There aren’t always right answers, but some answers are clearly wrong.”
Exactly!
Certainly, at the very least I would agree with Baron and Ejnes that there are indeed answers that are clearly wrong in medicine. They do exist. Cranks and quacks like to wrap themselves in the observation that “medicine changes” as new evidence comes in, all in order to argue that they are doing nothing more than engaging in “debate” and to claim that their views might be vindicated or that they are at least plausible enough not to be immediately dismissed, but such arguments are subterfuge, camouflage to fool the unwary. I also like the example used by Baron and Ejnes, specifically how ABIM certifying exams are constructed specifically the use of “distrators,” answers that are wrong but plausible enough to trap those whose knowledge of the topic is insufficiently deep, although I will argue that it is actually rather simplistic and naive as a comparison to COVID-19 misinformation (and, indeed, medical misinformation and quackery in general):
Creating these exams involves bringing together academic and practicing expert clinicians from a particular field to write and critique multiple-choice questions that have a single best answer — a process that may provide a useful perspective on somewhat analogous efforts to assess the information that doctors and others disseminate through informal public channels such as social media. The challenge in writing multiple-choice exam questions is not constructing a question with a right answer; rather it’s creating the “distractors,” the wrong but plausible answers. As anyone who has taken a multiple-choice exam knows, even someone with no knowledge of the relevant field can pass a test when the wrong answers are obviously implausible. An exam question measures something important only if someone acquainted with the field might believe the wrong answers are correct. The expert clinicians spend most of their time debating the distractors: Is that answer really wrong? If anyone around the table can find a valid article that might support the choice of option C as correct, then option C can’t be used as a distractor. In these discussions, the experts are guided by peer-reviewed medical literature, not by “prevailing opinion” or what a committee member believes; they don’t take polls. They accept the methods underlying scientific studies as a safer guide to practice than the received wisdom, intuition, or even “democratic process.” Informed by that literature, they conclude that some answers are definitively wrong.
There’s also quality control in such examinations. If, for example, certain wrong answers are chosen at too high a frequency, the question or answers might be modified or dropped from future versions of the examination. The point, though, is that there are answers that are plausible scientifically, but nonetheless wrong.
There is a huge difference, though, between the example of exam questions and distractors discussed above and the real world misinformation being promoted about COVID-19, a disturbing amount of it by physicians. Specifically, physicians tend to be really good at cherry picking (or even producing) seemingly scientific papers published in the peer-reviewed medical literature to support their misinformation. The problem of misinformation and disinformation is far more complex than there just being no papers to support a particular answer. In addition, physicians can be really good at misrepresenting or distorting the findings of legitimate scientific publications in the service of their disinformation, be it demonizing COVID-19 vaccines, claiming that masks don’t work to slow the spread of COVID-19, or arguing that COVID-19 is not dangerous. In this, I have always thought that Brandolini’s law (also known as the bullshit asymmetry principle), which states that the “amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it” is far too optimistic. I tend to think that it takes at least two—if not three—orders of magnitude more time and effort to refute bullshit as it does to produce it, and disinformation spreading doctors are very good indeed at producing and repackaging bullshit. Basically, the example used by Baron and Unje is very simplistic and doesn’t recognize the full magnitude of the misinformation problem. It is, however, a start, and I think they are starting to “get it”:
As the ABIM confronts the danger of medical misinformation, we recognize that there are many clinical issues on which physicians legitimately hold a spectrum of opinions, all supported by evidence; such justifiable positions would not make it as “distractors” on our exam, nor would they meet our definition of “false information,” as determined by experts consulting the literature. A whole range of statements with which many — or even most — physicians might disagree would therefore not trigger our disciplinary process. On the other hand, when someone certified by the ABIM says something like “the origin of all coronary heart disease is a clearly reversible arterial scurvy” or “children can’t spread Covid” or “vaccines don’t prevent Covid deaths or hospitalizations,” we are not dealing with valid professional disagreement; we are dealing with wrong answers.
I like that Baron and Unje didn’t just mention false claims about COVID-19 and included one about heart disease. It suggests that maybe—just maybe—they now recognize that the problem of medical misinformation being spread as “health freedom” and the “democratization” of medical knowledge is much broader than COVID-19 and predates the pandemic by decades.
Also, conspiracy theories (e.g., that COVID-19 is a “plandemic” or “casedemic” or that COVID-19 vaccines contain microchips or other tracking devices) should easily fall into this category, as not even being plausible enough to be a distractor in a multiple choice question. I am, however, a bit concerned. Again, there is no bright line between a wrong answer that’s plausible enough to be a “distractor” and bullshit, given the talent a lot of physicians have for cherry picking the scientific literature, and I have to wonder if the experts in the ABIM are up to the task of identifying certain claims as implausible. I say this because I saw no mention of the ABIM consulting experts in conspiracy theories and disinformation to adjudicate cases. We’ve documented many times throughout our 14 years of existence how physicians not acquainted with medical misinformation and quackery are often flummoxed when they encounter many of these claims. They just don’t have the background to adjudicate anything in the “gray areas” and sometimes struggle even with cases that to those of us who study quackery and misinformation are obvious.
Difficulties aside, I applaud ABIM for starting to grapple with the issue of its diplomates spreading medical misinformation and disinformation, even if they’re late and appear to have a bit of a naïve view of what medical misinformation and disinformation are. Basically, I hope that they will learn and suspect that they might have an easier time actually doing something meaningful than many state medical boards will, given the politics in a distressing number of states.
Finally, although it’s the largest, the ABIM is but one of many boards certifying various medical specialties. I, for instance, am certified by the American Board of Surgery, which has not yet stepped up to the plate, and no other board besides ABIM has yet gone as far. Certainly, I hope that a year from now I will no longer be able to say that.

“Censorship” and “thoughtcrime”? Antivaxxers and COVID-19 contrarians attack California AB 2098
One of the oldest tropes favored by quacks of all stripes, including antivaxxers, is to portray any attempt at regulating their quackery as an assault on freedom of speech. It’s therefore not surprising that after its passage by the California legislature prominent spreaders of COVID-19 misinformation are labeling AB2098, which seeks clarify and codify the power of the Medical Board of California to discipline physicians for spreading COVID-19 misinformation, as creating “thoughtcrimes”, in a desperate bid to persuade Governor Gavin Newsome not to sign the bill into law.
David Gorski on September 26, 2022
Tweet

I don’t often take a two-week vacation, and, on those rare occasions that I do (e.g., 25th and, this year, 30th wedding anniversaries), when I return and have to sit down to figure out what my first post after vacation will be about I sometimes struggle. This time, though, much of the time that I was away my Internet access was so spotty and slow that I was actually cut off from the world way more than normal and started to lose track of what was going on, which was not a bad thing. It didn’t take long, though, when I sat down to see a common theme bubbling up among antivaxxers and COVID-19 contrarians who deny that they are antivax but parrot antivax misinformation that increasingly sounds like pre-pandemic old school antivax propaganda. This theme has been increasing attacks on AB 2098, a recently passed bill in California that is awaiting Governor Gavin Newsom’s signature.
According to MedPageToday:
A bill that would allow regulators to discipline doctors for spreading misinformation related to COVID-19 has been approved by California’s Legislature.
If signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom (D), the first-of-its-kind law would make California the first state to try to legislate an issue that has contributed to thousands of unnecessary hospitalizations and deaths during the pandemic, according to the American Medical Association, The New York Times reported.
The new law would designate the dissemination of false or misleading information to patients as “unprofessional conduct,” the Times noted, and thus subject to punishment by the Medical Board of California and the Osteopathic Medical Board of California.
The bill, known as Assembly Bill 2098 (AB 2098), states that the spread of misinformation about COVID vaccines has “weakened public confidence and placed lives at serious risk,” and that healthcare professionals are “some of the most dangerous propagators of inaccurate information” when it comes to COVID vaccines.
Personally, the one thing that surprised me is that, as of yesterday (four weeks after the bill was passed by the California legislature), Gov. Newsom has not yet signed it into law. Unsurprisingly, the usual suspects are not happy that this bill passed. For example, just two days ago, the Brownstone Institute published an article by Laura Powell titled “The Dystopian Vision of the Health-Information Police” about—you guessed it!—AB 2098. Just for yucks, I searched the Brownstone Institute website for other articles on AB 2098 and found lots of opprobrium:
    • “Where Is the Bio-Fascist State Headed?” by Aaron Kheriaty, which only briefly mentions AB 2098 in the context of all sorts of other “fascist” laws on COVID-19 mandates and other public health laws
    • “The Dangers of Compelled Belief” by Donald Boudreaux
    • “The Case Against the Physician Gag Order” by Aaron Khariaty
You get the idea.
Elsewhere, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, a Stanford academic, Senior Scholar at the Brownstone Institute, and one of the three writers of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD), the “don’t worry, be happy” eugenicist call to let COVID-19 rip through the healthy non-elderly population in order to achieve “natural herd immunity” while using a mostly undefined strategy of “focused protection” to protect the elderly and others with chronic health conditions that put them at high risk for severe disease and death from COVID-19, likened AB 2098 to draconian lockdowns in Shanghai by the authoritarian Chinese government, while portraying himself a “victim” of “persecution” due to his stance on “lockdowns” and having helped draft the Great Barrington Declaration.
Meanwhile, on Twitter, there were the predictable cries of “censorship”:
There should continue to be an ongoing attack on CA’s AB2098 and the idea that promoting censoring thoughts it somehow a good and/or noble thing to do.
These ideas of censoring thoughts and legislation that limits thoughts should not be tolerated. https://t.co/DTHpTGxuKC
— Agnostic Libertarian (@AgnosticLiberty) September 25, 2022
Appeals to “protect physician freedom of speech”:
Tell Gov. @GavinNewsom to VETO AB 2098. Protect Physician Freedom of Speech in California. https://t.co/tD6Jy0ijpV
— Carol Moreau (@CarolMoreau9) September 23, 2022
And, of course, an “authoritarian liberty grab”:
Be more melodramatic. Biggest babies on the planet. Read the bill, it affirms the medical board’s ability to do its job and keep patients safe. Facts don’t care about your feelings.
— Dr. Jon (@TheDrJon) September 25, 2022
Along with a likely astroturf campaign to persuade Gov. Newsom to veto AB 2098:
Time To Tell Governor NewsomVETO AB 2098We need a massive amount of calls, tweets and emails to make an impact. Please take the following action steps today!1. Call Governor Newsom's office (916)445-28412. ONE MINUTE ACTION EMAIL 3. Tag @GavinNewsom Veto AB2098
— Ghazaal Sa (@GhazaalSa) September 23, 2022
There’s also been a bit of the old false “Nuremberg Code gambit” playing out as well:
So it was easy for me to decide to write about AB 2098. Specifically, I want to contrast the hysteria being fomented by antivaxxers and COVID-19 cranks about the bill with what the bill actually says and would do if signed into law, while providing a bit of context about how portraying attempts by government to protect consumers against false claims in medicine as “censorship” of physicians is nothing new.
AB 2098
AB 2098 was drafted in response to a very real problem, specifically the spread of dangerous misinformation by licensed physicians during the COVID-19 pandemic. Introduced in February by Evan Low and cosponsored by Assemblymembers Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Akilah Weber, and Buffy Wicks, as well as by Senators Richard Pan and Scott D. Weiner, the law’s purpose as stated by Assemblymember Low in a press release was:
This bill declares that disinformation and promotion of COVID-19 misinformation and disinformation to the public as unprofessional conduct for licensed physicians and surgeons. Under this law, California Medical Boards will be given the tools necessary to bring discipline actions against a licensee. Due to their specialized knowledge and training, licensed physicians possess a high degree of public trust and therefore must be held to account. The spreading of misinformation, of inaccurate COVID-19 information, contradicts that responsibility and threatens to further erode the public trust in the medical profession and puts all patients at risk
The text of the bill as passed by the legislature on August 30 can be found here. First, the bill proclaims:
SECTION 1. The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:(a) The global spread of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus, or COVID-19, has claimed the lives of over 6,000,000 people worldwide, including nearly 90,000 Californians.(b) Data from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) shows that unvaccinated individuals are at a risk of dying from COVID-19 that is 11 times greater than those who are fully vaccinated.(c) The safety and efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines have been confirmed through evaluation by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the vaccines continue to undergo intensive safety monitoring by the CDC.(d) The spread of misinformation and disinformation about COVID-19 vaccines has weakened public confidence and placed lives at serious risk.(e) Major news outlets have reported that some of the most dangerous propagators of inaccurate information regarding the COVID-19 vaccines are licensed health care professionals.(f) The Federation of State Medical Boards has released a statement warning that physicians who engage in the dissemination of COVID-19 vaccine misinformation or disinformation risk losing their medical license, and that physicians have a duty to provide their patients with accurate, science-based information.(g) In House Resolution No. 74 of the 2021–22 Regular Session, the California State Assembly declared health misinformation to be a public health crisis, and urged the State of California to commit to appropriately combating health misinformation and curbing the spread of falsehoods that threaten the health and safety of Californians.
There is nothing in the above list of statements that I can argue with. These are examples of statements about COVID-19 that are demonstrably accurate that COVID-19 contrarian doctors frequently contradict, as described in (e). Indeed, as I have argued many times before, physicians who spread COVID-19 misinformation are automatically considered more credible than the average pundit by virtue of their professional status. Our MD and DO degrees, combined with our professional licensure by the state, automatically make us experts in the eyes of the public, whether we have relevant domain-specific expertise in COVID-19 and vaccines or not. Worse, a number of my colleagues have parlayed their professional credentials into a brand that, in the name of “freedom” and “questioning”, involves spreading flagrant misinformation about COVID-19 (and, increasingly, other medical topics).
Let’s take a look at relevant passage stating what this bill does. First, the legislative counsel’s digest states:
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of physicians and surgeons by the Medical Board of California and the Osteopathic Medical Board of California. Existing law requires the applicable board to take action against any licensed physician and surgeon who is charged with unprofessional conduct, as provided.
This bill would designate the dissemination of misinformation or disinformation related to the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus, or “COVID-19,” as unprofessional conduct. The bill would also make findings and declarations in this regard.
Which is why, in Section 2, the AB 2098 explicitly states that spreading COVID-19 misinformation is unprofessional conduct:
It shall constitute unprofessional conduct for a physician and surgeon to disseminate misinformation or disinformation related to COVID-19, including false or misleading information regarding the nature and risks of the virus, its prevention and treatment; and the development, safety, and effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines.
Of course, where the rubber hits the road is in how “misinformation” and “disinformation” are defined. First, misinformation:
“Misinformation” means false information that is contradicted by contemporary scientific consensus contrary to the standard of care.
Next, disinformation:
“Disinformation” means misinformation that the licensee deliberately disseminated with malicious intent or an intent to mislead.
These are, of course, fairly standard definitions of “misinformation” and “disinformation”. I do note, however, that the definition of “misinformation” is different than in a prior version of the bill, which defined misinformation thusly:
“Misinformation” means false information that is contradicted by contemporary scientific consensus to an extent where its dissemination constitutes gross negligence by the licensee.
To be honest, I like the previous definition better, as it makes it more clear that AB 2098 is not targeting potentially legitimate scientific disagreements over the practice of medicine, but claims that are both flagrantly and demonstrably false and dangerous to the public, such as antivax claims about COVID-19 and claims supporting COVID-19 quackery. Whichever definition you pick, however, let me just reiterate that it is a favorite trope of quacks and antivaxxers to claim that doctors “can’t” say anything that doesn’t adhere to medical “dogma”, lest they be excommunicated—or worse!—from the Church of Medicine. Such a trope intentionally ignores anything resembling nuance, in particular the part about how “contemporary scientific consensus” and “standard of care” actually encompass rather broad swaths of evidence and practices and how a physician has to be very far from that consensus and standard in order to enter the category of misinformation. Even then, because doctors tend to stick together and react in a very threatened manner whenever faced with any sort of regulations on their professional speech, even when the regulations are narrow and there’s little or no chance they’d run afoul of them.
Indeed, I’ve actually argued in the past that the bill doesn’t go far enough in that it limits itself to COVID-19 misinformation and quackery. I’ve long argued that state medical boards need to be empowered to discipline doctors for promoting quackery of all kinds. One has only to look at the examples of Stanislaw Burzynski in Texas and Rashid Buttar in North Carolina to see that even doctors who do far more than simply advocate quackery and antivaccine misinformation all too often manage to avoid sanctions by their state medical boards and keep their medical licenses. Be that as it may, state medical boards have long had the power to regulate professional conduct and define and sanction physicians for “unprofessional conduct”. There is thus value in explicitly defining spreading COVID-19 misinformation as being unprofessional conduct subject to state medical board regulation and discipline.
Of course, quacks have long wrapped themselves in the First Amendment when they misrepresented attempts to crack down on their conduct as assaults their “freedom of speech”. Unfortunately, a number of seemingly more reasonable and unquacky physicians have taken up the same call. What they fail to recognize is that it is relatively rare for a physician only to spread misinformation. Usually, they practice what they preach, so to speak. Pre-pandemic, Dr. Buttar, for instance, didn’t just claim that mercury in vaccines caused autism; he treated autistic children with his own “transdermal chelation therapy” quackery (which skeptics’ disparagingly dubbed “Buttar’s butter“) to “detoxify” them from the “mercury poisoning” that had supposedly made them autistic. Since the pandemic, “America’s Frontline Doctors”, who first made a splash in the summer of 2020 promoting hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19 but quickly added ivermectin to their list of miracle cures for COVID-19, don’t just publicly claim falsely that these drugs are highly effective against COVID-19. A year ago they were busted for running a telehealth prescription mill to sell them. Thus, sanctioning physicians for spreading misinformation and disinformation is reasonable given how rarely the practice of quackery doesn’t follow from the advocacy of quackery.
The bottom line is that AB 2098 is a relatively modest, targeted bill designed to explicitly define a power that the Medical Board of California arguably has always had with respect to regulating spreading dangerous health misinformation and disinformation as unprofessional conduct. Unsurprisingly, quacks, antivaxxers, and COVID-19 contrarians don’t see it that way.
“Censorship” of “thoughtcrimes”? Hardly.
Before I address the more outlandish criticisms of AB 2098, it is important to note that there are physicians alarmed by the bill who are not quacks, although, truth be told, who do lean to the COVID-19 contrarian side. For instance weeks ago, while I was still (mostly) incommunicado, Dr. Leana Wen wrote an editorial for The Washington Post titled “California’s anti-misinformation bill is well intentioned. But it’s a bad idea“. In it, she makes this astounding claim:
While well-intentioned, this legislation will have a chilling effect on medical practice, with widespread repercussions that could paradoxically worsen patient care.
Not coincidentally, the claim that the bill will have a “chilling effect” on medical practice is one that commonly pops up on antivax websites. The question, of course, is: How? How might this bill have a chilling effect on medical practice? Let’s see what Dr. Wen says:
The bill focuses on physicians accused of disseminating misinformation to patients under their care. (It does not extend to comments in the public domain, such as social media.) On a surface level, this is defensible: The expectation should be that doctors always abide by the gold standard of care. Therefore, those who deliberately give patients advice that counter established guidelines should lose their medical license.
The problem is that medical practice is rarely black and white. Much of the time, broad recommendations are intended to be tailored to the individual patient.
Ah, yes. The appeal to the “gray areas” of medical practice, the areas where the standard of care is not so clear. Also note how the bill does not apply to what doctors say in general on social media and legacy media, just what they say to patients in their practice. That’s how the bill addresses First Amendment concerns, even though arguably it is what many of these COVID-19 contrarian doctors say on hugely trafficked social media sites that is more damaging to public health than what they sell their patients, who are few in number compared to the people within reach of their public utterances.
Reading this introduction, I was curious what sorts of situations concern Dr. Wen; unsurprisingly, she provided examples regarding vaccines, basing her arguments on what she likely does not realize to be a favorite crank argument, namely, “Science changes, and how do we know that what this doctor is recommending today won’t be standard-of-care tomorrow?” For example:
Take the recent guidelines on booster shots. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has recommended that everyone 12 and older receive updated boosters. Most doctors would probably agree that elderly individuals should get the new booster right away. But many might advise — as I would — that it’s fine for some patients to hold off and time the booster closer to winter holidays. Some providers might not recommend boosters for children and adolescents, especially if they have already had the coronavirus.
These actions go against federal guidelines. AB 2098, taken to the extreme, could put many practitioners at risk. But is it really right for physicians to be threatened with suspension or revocation of their license for offering nuanced guidance on a complex issue that is hardly settled by existing science?
To pre-empt: No. No, Dr. Wen. You would not be sanctioned for such a recommendation. Let’s look at the actual CDC recommendations for the new bivalent boosters for children aged 12 and older:
People ages 12 years and older are recommended to receive one updated Pfizer or Moderna (bivalent) booster.
    • This includes people who have received all primary series doses and people who have previously received one or more original (monovalent) boosters.
    • At this time, people aged 12 years to 17 years can only receive the updated Pfizer bivalent booster.
On the main page there is nothing there about timing of vaccines for people over 12. However, if you use the “When Are You Up-to-Date?” tool, the following responses result in a recommendation for a bivalent booster:
Your responses
    • Age: 12-17 years old
    • Moderately or severely immunocompromised
    • Primary series: Pfizer-BioNTech
    • Updated (bivalent) booster received: no
    • Length of time since last COVID-19 vaccine: At least 2 months
Based on your responses, your child should get an updated COVID-19 booster.
Your child is considered up to date with their COVID-19 vaccines immediately after getting their updated (bivalent) booster.
So, no. Advising delay until winter would not get Dr. Wen sanctioned by the Medical Board of California, if she practiced in California. What Dr. Wen is engaging in is the logical fallacy known as an appeal to the extremes, in which she tries to make a reasonable policy seem unreasonable by citing a very extreme possible outcome that is highly unlikely. Alternatively, it could be a slippery slope argument, in which it is claimed that, if medical boards can regulate professional speech that is arguably outright misinformation, it won’t be long before they start regulating speech that is within the bounds of reasonable professional disagreement.
She gives another example:
Indeed, another lesson from covid is that science is constantly evolving. In a public health emergency, official guidance often lags cutting-edge research. Consider how long it took the CDC to acknowledge that the coronavirus is airborne. Should doctors have been censured for recommending N95 masks before they were accepted as an effective method for reducing virus transmission?
This one strikes me as disingenuous in the extreme. Surely Dr. Wen must know that AB 2098 is designed to combat harmful and dangerous COVID-19 misinformation being spread by physicians. An N95 mask is more effective at protecting a person against respiratory viruses than a surgical or cloth mask. It is simply ludicrous to think that the Medical Board of California would have taken action against a physician who in 2020 recommended a COVID-19 mitigation intervention more effective than the recommendation at the time. Surely she must know this.
Wen also brings up a hypothetical situation:
There could also be rare situations in which treatments that definitively do not work might still be prescribed. A colleague told me he prescribed ivermectin to treat covid-19 [sic], even though the antiparasitic drug isn’t effective against the disease. If he didn’t, his misinformed patients would have ignored his advice and obtained it anyway from a livestock shop, where the dosages intended for cows and horses could be deadly to humans. This action certainly deviated from what the California bill calls “contemporary scientific consensus,” but that physician shouldn’t have to fear for his license because he tried to reduce harm to his patients.
There is only one correct reaction to this:

No, seriously. If that patient had wanted to use acupuncture to treat COVID-19, would that physician have recommended it? Or homeopathy? This is the same sort of shruggie “What’s the harm?” attitude that has plagued our profession when addressing so much quackery and nothing more than a rationalization for not wanting to tell a patient no, which is often very uncomfortable for physicians, particularly cancer quackery. How many times have I heard the “What’s the harm?” argument when addressing, for example, Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski prescribing his ineffective antineoplastons concoction to patients with deadly cancers? Basically, the physician prescribed what he knew to be an ineffective treatment with a non-zero chance of causing harm in the name of “reducing harm”. Yes, that physician should potentially be subject to sanctions.
Dr. Wen then goes on to make a jaw-droppingly bad false equivalence, followed by a slippery slope argument:
In a way, though the California bill was introduced by Democratic legislators, it is not unlike the Trump administration’s Title X “gag rule,” which barred health-care providers who worked in clinics that received federal funding from referring patients for abortion care. I strongly opposed the Title X gag rule for the same reason I oppose AB 2098: Both censor what doctors can say to our patients. Both represent political interference with the practice of medicine.
Both measures could also set a precedent with downstream repercussions. Imagine if anti-vaccine legislators introduced a bill that forbids pediatricians from offering parents information on routine childhood immunizations. Imagine if states that already limit reproductive health services or transgender care prohibit health-care providers from discussing options with their patients.
Politicizing the practice of medicine is a legitimate concern but do not justify false equivalences and another appeal to an extreme. The difference, of course, is that the “gag rule” tried to straightjacket physicians into precluding actual evidence-based care for their patients. It’s all well and good that that Dr. Wen correctly opposed the “gag rule”, but it’s not so great that she either doesn’t see the difference between the gag rule and AB 2098 or ignores the difference in the pursuit of making her point. In addition, surely Dr. Wen must already be aware that antivaccine legislators are already engaged in trying to undermine vaccination programs, as their endgame has always been the elimination of all vaccine mandates, be they for school, daycare, working in a hospital, or anything else. This has been true since long before the pandemic; antivaxxers just see the pandemic and the increasing power of the antivaccine movement as a result of the pandemic as their golden opportunity to realize a long-time dream. Surely she must be aware that legislators are already furiously trying to criminalize gender-affirming care of transgender adolescents in a depressingly large number of states, which goes beyond just putting a physician’s medical license at risk. Dr. Wen’s comparisons are misleading at best.
Specifically regarding her invocation of the “gag rule,” I like to cite Noah Louis-Ferdinand, Comms Director for Voices for Vaccines:
Thirdly: that bill literally stopped people from talking about a specific subject and had nothing to do with medical consensus.
It was moral opposition to abortion, not rooted in science. AB 2098 and its authors are longtime vaccine advocates with a proven public health record.
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
Also, doubly this:
In sum, I find the criticisms levied by Drs. Damania and Wen to be unrealistic.
If they wanted to cite analysis from legal scholars about how this bill might play out, they'd have a more robust case. But the supporters of AB 2098 have provided a much more robust defense.
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
Exactly as I said, in particular, about how antivaxxers have long been trying to get bills to their liking introduced into state legislators and now see an opportunity to realize their endgame, the elimination of all vaccine mandates, in at least some states.
Deeper into the morass: Conspiracy theorists vs. AB 2098
Let’s now look at what Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, one of the main signatories of the GBD, had to say about AB 2098 in April. He basically used the same sorts of arguments that Dr. Wen did more recently, but cranked up to 11, in which he likens AB 2098 to the power of authoritarian regimes like China and the former Soviet Union. For example:
The ultimate effect of the bill will be to chill public criticism by California doctors of mistaken government public health diktats since few will want to put their licenses in the hands of the very public health officials with whom they disagree over the interpretation of science. Even legitimate dissent from public health orthodoxy by licensed doctors may be excised from the public square as a consequence.
That’s exactly the same argument that Dr. Wen made. Then there’s this:
And that’s to say nothing of the impact this bill would have on the practice of medicine. Doctors have an obligation to treat each patient as an individual. Yet the California Assembly bill turns doctors into agents of state public health rather than advocates for their patients.
History provides abundant examples of what happens when the state regulates science. In the former Soviet Union, Stalin’s favorite geneticist, Trofim Lysenko, dominated biology and the agricultural sciences. Lysenko rejected Mendelian genetics in favor of his own theory that plants could inherit acquired characteristics. Stalin empowered him to destroy the careers and lives of geneticists who opposed him, causing many to suffer secret arrests and even death. When his theories failed, the consequence was mass starvation in Russia. The Chinese Communists also adopted his beliefs—at the cost of the starvation of 30 million.
This is a subtype of the “appeal to extremes” fallacy that I like to refer to as the invocation of Lysenko’s ghost. As you might recall, Trofim Lysenko was a Soviet scientist who rejected Mendelian genetics in favor of his own ideas. After he became director of the Institute of Genetics within the USSR’s Academy of Sciences, Lysenko used his political power to suppress dissent, discrediting, marginalizing, and imprisoning his critics while elevating his anti-Mendelian theories to state-sanctioned doctrine. The analogy is, of course, custom-made for cranks like Dr. Bhattacharya, given how the Soviet embrace of Lysenkoism greatly exacerbated and prolonged the famine and mass starvation in the USSR that resulted from Stalin’s policies in the 1930s, making it an attractive false historical analogy for right wing cranks like those at the Brownstone Institute, for which Dr. Bhattacharya is a “senior scholar”. The emotive example misleadingly conflates being sent to the gulags with possibly losing one’s medical license, even as Dr. Bhattacharya tries to point out the difference by adding that “California lawmakers thankfully do not have the power currently being exercised in Shanghai”.
Unsurprisingly, over at the Brownstone Institute, Laura Powell, founder of Californians for Good Governance, rants about gray areas of medicine:
Assembly Bill 2098 would empower the Medical Board of California to go after the licenses of physicians who disseminate “misinformation” or “disinformation” regarding Covid-19 [sic]. The bill in its latest iteration defines misinformation as “false information that is contradicted by contemporary scientific consensus contrary to the standard of care.” The inscrutability of this definition lies at the core of the bill’s opponents concerns.
No clear scientific consensus exists with respect to this novel virus, and even if it did, it may be proven incorrect later. Without clear guidance regarding what would constitute “misinformation,” physicians can only guess if they risk losing their licenses for expressing their good-faith disagreements with positions of public health officials. Even if in practice, the Medical Board only applied the law to speech that the First Amendment does not protect, the law’s vagueness would render it unconstitutional, because it would tend to cause doctors to censor themselves.
This is basically the same argument made by Dr. Wen, just (again) cranked up to 11. I like to refer to Dr. Taylor Nichols, one of the founders of No License for Disinformation, a group dedicated to combatting COVID-19 misinformation and disinformation and a major backer of AB 2098:
This likely explains the uptick in attacks on the bill. Gov. Newsom has only until September 30, which is this Friday, to veto the bill, and if he does nothing AB 2098 will automatically become law on October 1.
Also:
I also like to cite a long Twitter thread by Noah Louis-Ferdinand, Comms Director for Voices for Vaccines, who notes a number of disingenuous, misleading, and outright false claims being made about AB 2098. His arguments are similar to mine, but he adds other context.
For example, he notes:
Currently, the state medical board is not empowered to pursue COVID complaints. Prior to COVID, 80% of complaints were dismissed out of hand and only 3% resulted in any disciplinary action.
The board hasn't even taken action against Simone Gold, a clear disinformer…
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
Let’s just say that there is no “epidemic” of cases in which the Medical Board of California has taken action against the licenses of physicians engaged in spreading misinformation. Indeed, if Simone Gold, an outright COVID-19 grifter who was convicted and sent to prison for participating in the January 6 insurrection, complained about being placed in solitary confinement as quarantine for eight days because she refused to be vaccinated against COVID-19, and is a founder of America’s Frontline Doctors, hasn’t faced discipline yet from the Medical Board of California, it’s hard to make a serious argument that AB 2098 will lead to a newly empowered fascistic board to start persecuting brave maverick doctors selling COVID-19 misinformation, quackery, and antivaccine conspiracy theories.
Moreover:
STILL: only 1 in 5 state boards have disciplined EVEN A SINGLE PHYSICIAN (!!!) for COVID misinfo.
And to the contrary, the majority of states have one or more bills on the books that either protect COVID misinformers from disciplinary action or enable their quack treatments… pic.twitter.com/MueoZX4BMa
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
Then there are the logistics of actually bringing a case against a doctor before the medical board. Noah cites the example of masks, dismantling some arguments made by Dr. Zubin Damania, better known by his social media name ZDoggMD in a recent video:
to action, whereas mask advice changed in the span of a few months.
Such an unfeasible, uncertain case would probably be dismissed.
Zdogg gives another example of saying that he wouldn't advise masking a two year old. Would he lose his license for that?
No.
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
He also notes that one reason why medical boards have been reluctant to pursue such cases will not change if AB 2098 becomes law and that this bill only applies to professional speech in the context of providing care to patients:
@MichelleM_Mello, Stanford Law Professor who is cited in NYT about the bill, states: “Initiatives like this will be challenged in court and will be hard to sustain."
So giving boards a tiny bit more power will not encourage them to start picking battles they won't win. pic.twitter.com/sbaXgM7l0n
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
Zdogg gives another example of saying, if he tells his patient they shouldn't close schools, will he lose his license?
Almost certainly not. For one: doctors usually advocate for this kind of thing on local boards (that's free speech, not professional care, and is unaffected).
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
He also correctly points out that the concept of “medical consensus” and “standard-of-care” are already defined concepts in law:
But as @NickSawyerMD argues, medical consensus is a well-understood concept referring to reproducible evidence.
In the case of closing schools, 'evidence' relies on interdisciplinary analysis that would make it hard to define 'standard of care' in actionable terms.
— Noah 🧡 (@Michigan_Noah) September 18, 2022
I actually agree that the vagueness of the definitions of misinformation and disinformation in the bill will likely make its effects less robust than is needed. That is why I like the definition of misinformation in an earlier version of the bill that is “contradicted by contemporary scientific consensus to an extent where its dissemination constitutes gross negligence by the licensee”. Such a definition makes it clear that we aren’t talking about reasonable medical disagreements.
The bottom line is that, for all its shortcomings, AB 2098 explicitly states that spreading COVID-19 misinformation and disinformation in medical practice constitutes unprofessional conduct, thus making clearer a power that the Medical Board of California has always had but was reluctant to act on. The misrepresentation of the bill as some sort of Stalinist Lysenkoist assault on physician autonomy is an echo of the “health freedom” arguments of quacks past going back decades in response to any attempt by any governmental entity to put a stop to quackery. I fully expected that Brownstone Institute flacks like Dr. Bhattacharya and Kheriaty, for instance, would echo such “health freedom” tropes that portray the autonomy of doctors as correctly unfettered and any attempt to regulate medical practice as an unacceptable assault on free speech and physician autonomy. It’s disappointing that more reputable physicians are parroting the same tropes that we’ve been dealing with for decades while apparently not realizing what they are.
It is, unfortunately, no longer surprising, that physicians who should know better are echoing complaints of “cancel culture” in response to bills like AB 2098.

The Great Barrington Declaration Was Silenced. So Why are They Silencing Me?
The head of the NIH owed the authors of the GBD a series of public discussions and dialogues. The authors of the GDB owe me a series of public discussions and dialogues.
Jonathan Howard on December 31, 2021
Link

An introduction to the Great Barrington Declaration
The main premise behind the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was that people who were “not vulnerable” to grave effects of COVID-19 could be both easily identified and separated from “vulnerable” people. The mass infection of these “not vulnerable” people would lead to herd immunity and the end of the pandemic with minimal loss of life or economic impact. This policy approach was called “focused protection”.
The Great Barrington Declaration: Shut down
I am sure none of you know of any of this. Sadly, the GBD and its authors were shut down by our top public health officials.
News recently broke that back in October 2020 Dr. Francis Collins, the head of the NIH, felt the authors of the GBD were “fringe epidemiologists” and suggested “there needs to be a quick and devastating published take down of its premises”.
One of the authors of the GBD, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya properly called this a “propaganda attack by my own government“, and wisely requested “discussion and engagement” instead. Writing about this sad incident in an article titled “At a Time When the U.S. Needed Covid-19 Dialogue Between Scientists, Francis Collins Moved to Shut it Down“, Dr. Vinay Prasad wrote:
Collins’s response to a memo signed by thousands of scientists should not have been to call for an immediate and devastating take down, but to use his pulpit as NIH director to hold a series of public discussions and dialogues. In a world where scientists were trapped in their own homes for months, a series of dialogues — even virtual ones — made available for the broader scientific community, policy makers, and the public would have benefited us all.
I couldn’t agree more. As long as a policy memo is signed by a large number of people, the NIH director is obligated to use his pulpit to give its ideas and authors a megaphone, regardless of the memo’s contents. After all, some of its distinguished signatories included “Dr Johnny Bananas” and “Professor Cominic Dummings”, who are absolutely real people.
The wisdom of the Great Barrington Declaration
Dr. Collin’s wrote his email in October 2020, and time has proven that the people he shut down could have contributed a lot to our pandemic response. For example, two of the authors of the GBD wrote an article this summer titled “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“. This article opened by saying:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
The idea that vaccinating everyone is “more dangerous for public health” than vaccinating no one is clearly one that Dr. Collins should have platformed via public discussion and dialogue in the middle of a pandemic. As the death toll marches inexorability towards 1,000,000 Americans, it’s important for the public to know that the head of the NIH believes ideas like this are reasonable and worthy of discussion.
Additionally, Dr. Bhattacharya said on 7/26/2021 that Florida had “protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population”, and that “I don’t think the delta variant changes the calculus or the evidence in any fundamental way”, He said “we’ve done an incredible job at decoupling the cases from the deaths.”
Just a few weeks later, newspapers declared “Florida Broke its COVID-19 Death Record for the Fifth Week” and “Child Deaths From COVID Double in Florida as Cases Among Children Climb Across the Country“. Now, the headlines read, “Florida Breaks Daily COVID-19 Case Record Yet Again” and “Florida Among Top 5 States Contributing to Spike in Pediatric COVID-19 Hospitalizations“.
So, were vulnerable people truly protected in Florida? Did the Delta variant change things at all? Did Florida achieve herd immunity through “focused protection”? Only a public discussion could answer these thorny questions.
Most importantly, we need a robust public debate on vaccinating children. During a week in which a record 38 children were added to the AAP’s pediatric death tally, one of the GBD’s authors wrote an article called “Vaccines Save Lives“, which argued against vaccinating children. As the headlines say, “US Children Hospitalized With COVID in Record Numbers“, and “Children With COVID-19, Most of Them Unvaccinated, are Hospitalized in U.S. in Near-Record Numbers“, now is the time to ask ourselves if this is this something we really want to prevent?
With hundreds of children going to the hospital everyday, we desperately need to hear from voices opposed to vaccinating children in an NIH sponsored forum. This is especially true considering vaccines have proven very effective (here and here) at keeping children out of the hospital. Just yesterday, the CDC reported that “Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one was fully vaccinated”, and that in adolescents vaccine effectiveness “was 92% against SARS-CoV-2 infections irrespective of symptom status”. Meanwhile, after 8 million vaccine doses in children aged 5–11 years, there just were 11 cases of vaccine-related myocarditis, and researchers on the subject are saying things like “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly”.
Arguing against vaccinating children, the authors of the GBD have said that the flu, which killed one child with COVID mitigation measures in place, has a higher “mortality risk” for children than COVID-19, which has killed over 1,035 children during this time. You may disagree, but don’t delude yourself into thinking it’s “settled science” which is the larger number, 1 or 1,000. We need public dialogue, sanctioned by the head of the NIH, to discuss these controversial topics in a transparent fashion.
Additionally, they’ve pointed out that old people are much more likely to die than children. As such, the vaccine wouldn’t save the lives of that many children. Is it really worth the hassle to save the lives of perhaps 1,000 more children, especially considering those with underlying conditions are the most likely to die? An NIH-sponsored forum would have been the ideal place to answer this tricky question.
“There needs to be a quick and devastating published take down of its premises“
Instead of fostering debate about whether it’s more dangerous to vaccinate everyone or no one during a raging pandemic however, Dr. Collins pondered in a private message about publishing a take down of the premises of the GBD.
I agree that if Dr. Collins wanted to criticize these premises, he should have done so in a public discussion and only in a public discussion. It was clearly a “propaganda attack” for him to even consider publishing a critique of the GBD’s premises. What kind of scientist publishes something? Does he think he’s Stephen King or something?
Some writers, who are favorable to the GBD, inadvertently omit that Dr. Collins wanted to publish a take down the premises of the GBD, implying instead that he wanted to take down the people behind it. However, any written critique of the premises of the GBD is also a personal attack on its authors, of course. You see, Dr. Collins also dared to call the authors of the GBD “fringe” in his private message.
I am sorry that you had to read such a vile insult, but I felt it was important to document Dr. Collins’s depravity. Surely Dr. Collins could have come up with a more appropriate word to describe people who claim a virus that killed one child is more dangerous than one that killed over 1,000 children. Perhaps he could have called them “nuanced” instead.
Being called “fringe” seem to have injured the authors of the GBD as gravely as when YouTube removed a video of theirs, and that was a really big deal for them. Though I am sure that you have sympathy for exhausted healthcare workers who’ve been immersed in death and suffering for nearly two years, I hope you have a place in your heart for epidemiologists censored by YouTube and defamed with vulgarities such as “fringe”.
When scientists disagree with each other, it’s more professional to say the credibility of your opponent has been “entirely shot” or that person is America’s “No. 1 anti-vaxxer“. These mature, thoughtful criticisms are what Dr. Bhattacharya has said about Dr. Anthony Fauci.
The Great Barrington Declaration: Silenced
Unfortunately, Dr. Collins was successful in shutting down the GBD. Like I said, I am sure this is the first you are hearing about it. You have no idea who it’s authors are and what they believe. They have been totally silenced. The authors of the GBD only met with top leaders of the Trump administration and directly influenced COVID-19 policy for the entire country. They only met with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and set COVID-19 policy for that state. They have only testified before Congress and in courts regarding COVID-19 policy. They were only repeatedly interviewed on obscure TV channels like Fox News and have only written editorials in small, niche newspapers like The Wall Street Journal. They’ve have only made a very small number of YouTube videos. Though Dr. Bhattacharya said that “the emergency phase of the disease is over…We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people” you wouldn’t know this, because that quote appeared in a rag called The Washington Post. Have you heard of it? I didn’t think so.
The Great Barrington Declaration is silencing me
Based on their first-hand experience with censorship, you’d expect the authors of the GBD would be careful not to silence people themselves. However, the sad truth is that I am being silenced and censored by these individuals.
Even though I invited myself to lecture about the benefits of the COVID-19 vaccine for children at the Academy for Science and Freedom at Hillsdale College, I have been entirely ignored. Though the purpose of this institute, which was founded by several of the authors of the GBD, is supposedly to counter “the silencing and censoring of scientists” they have refused to extend me an invitation to speak there. My request to write an article for the Brownstone Institute, which has ties to the GBD, have also been ignored. I even invited myself on Dr. Prasad’s podcast and have been greeted with only cold silence.
I believe it is important to engage with people who hold different views rather than silence them this way. We all lose when heterodox views like mine are censored. Blacklisting people like me could lead to the end of science as we know it. Wouldn’t a simple dialogue be better than shutting me down? At least they haven’t called me “fringe” yet.
Dr. Collins owed the authors of the GBD a series of public discussions and dialogues. The authors of the GDB owe me a series of public discussions and dialogues.
        ◦ We all just want “discussion and engagement”. Right?

Consumer groups urge feds to act against Mercola and his false COVID-19 claims
Consumer rights organizations urge the FDA and FTC to take action against Joseph Mercola and his businesses over their false, misleading, and dangerous claims that their products will prevent, treat or cure COVID-19.
Jann Bellamy on August 13, 2020
Link
Consumer and social justice groups are asking the FDA and FTC to bring enforcement actions against Joseph Mercola, D.O., and his companies (collectively, the “Mercola Group”) for false, misleading, and deceptive claims that his products will treat, cure, or prevent COVID-19 infections.
In letters sent to the two agencies (FDA here and FTC here), dated July 21st, the Center For Science in the Public Interest, Justice Catalyst, and the People’s Parity Project charge the Mercola Group with capitalizing on the coronavirus. Their deceptive marketing claims and “medical” advice, these organizations say, pose a clear danger to the public,
including the extraordinarily dangerous recommendation that individuals actually try to contract COVID-19 after using the supplements it sells to ameliorate the symptoms.
They’ve done their homework too. In 20-page letters (including extensive footnotes) and an Appendix featuring photos of products, links to Mercola Group websites, and excerpts from Mercola podcasts, they document numerous threats to the public’s health posed by Mercola and his business interests.
Before we get to the details, a brief refresher on Mercola and his history of quackery, a subject covered numerous times here on SBM.
Mercola, a doctor of osteopathy, is an alternative health tycoon, quackery promoter, and marketer of a wide range of products, including dietary supplements, protein bars, cookware, tanning beds, saunas, homeopathic remedies, underwear, cosmetics, spices, books, and pet food. According to the Washington Post, he has donated millions of his $100 million fortune to the anti-vaccine movement. One M.O. fueling his bank account is the promotion of dubious medical advice touting a remedy, then (surprise!) selling his particular brand of that remedy via a Mercola-owned company, all the while pretending that his medical counsel was never, ever intended for promotional purposes.
His quack health advice includes:
    • Vitamin C as a viable option for measles prevention.
    • Vitamin D for flu prevention.
    • Thermography as superior to mammograms for breast cancer detection.
    • Misinformation about screening colonoscopies, such as vastly overstating the complication rate.
    • Tullio Simoncini’s cancer quackery, which claims that all cancer is really a fungus because it’s “always white” and that baking soda injections are an effective treatment.
David Gorski referred to that last one as “among the most ridiculous ‘alternative cancer cures’ I’ve ever seen”, which says a lot. As Harriet Hall warns,
the safest course is to assume that anything on [Mercola’s] website is false unless you can verify it as true by consulting other sources that are reliable.
Mercola’s swindles have gotten him into trouble with the feds before. In one settlement with the FTC, Mercola and his companies paid over $5 million and agreed to stop selling tanning beds, which he claimed could reduce the risk of skin cancer.
Apparently, Mercola is not one to learn from his experiences, nor does he have any shame, which brings us back to his false and misleading COVID-19 claims. He was recently named one of the biggest social media “super-spreaders” of COVID-19 misinformation by NewsGuard, a company that evaluates and rates news and information websites. Now, consumer groups are out to stop his mendacious marketing, asking the FDA, with jurisdiction over unlawful claims that a product can prevent, treat, or cure disease, and the FTC, with jurisdiction over false and misleading advertising, to take enforcement action against the Mercola Group.
They argue that the Mercola Group is a danger to public health because it “frequently disseminates false and deceptive claims”, which are consumed by a substantial internet audience (Mercola.com “is viewed by ‘millions of people daily'”) and fueled by robust sales (“millions of dollars in products annually”).
He is, for example, preemptively downplaying the effectiveness of potential COVID-19 vaccines, even warning the public that any potential vaccine would likely be deadly. On a podcast posted April 5, 2020, Mercola told listeners complete falsehoods about the risks of vaccines, saying:
For every life being saved by a vaccine, you may have another 10, 20, 100 people who are either killed or permanently injured as a result of that vaccine.
Mercola also endorsed his podcast guest’s incendiary assertion that people would probably be dragged from their homes and vaccinated against their will.
Noting that their “false and misleading COVID-19 claims are really just a thinly-veiled and self-serving attempt to sell its products”, the consumer groups’ letters catalog the connection between Mercola’s “medical” advice, which appear in website articles (e.g., “Nutrition and Natural Strategies Offer Hope Against COVID-19”) and in his podcast, and corresponding Mercola Group products which just happen to fill Mercola’s prescription.
Following this playbook, for example, Mercola wrote articles and spoke extensively (and falsely) over the last several months about the effectiveness of vitamin C to prevent and treat COVID-19, including his claim, without evidence, that a Chinese study “is likely to show” that IV vitamin C will successfully treat COVID-19-induced pneumonia. Mercola and his podcast guests also told listeners, again without evidence, that “even a small amount of vitamin C” reduces the risk of dying from COVID-19, “even in the most severe cases”. As an alternative to IV C administered by a physician, Mercola and guests suggested “liposomal” vitamin C tablets, which are (wait for it) featured prominently in Mercola Group’s online store.
Blaming the media for hiding this information from consumers, Mercola advised on his podcast that vitamin D, which he (dangerously) recommended in high doses, will help prevent severe cases of COVID-19 when used in combination with vitamin C and other dietary supplements. Mercola also told listeners that they should use a test kit to determine current levels of vitamin D and proper dosage. Needless to say, his online store sells a vitamin D test kit ($65) as well as a test kit for vitamin D and other nutrients ($165).
Mercola, or his podcast guests, have also touted, and the Mercola Group sells:
    • Melatonin, which he claims is “proven to decrease the risks of COVID-19 infection” and can treat COVID-19 as well.
    • Glycyrrhizin, the active ingredient in licorice, which “could be a treatment for COVID-19” (as well as herpes, HIV, hepatitis, influenza, encephalitis, pneumonia, SARS, and several other viruses).
    • Molecular hydrogen, which has, according to Mercola, “powerful and antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects, making it potentially useful for COVID-19” and “preliminary results” from prominent doctors investigating its use “are encouraging”. The most effective way to consume molecular hydrogen, he claims, is via tablets that are dissolved in water, the same form he sells.
    • Astaxanthin, a derivative of microalgae, which, Mercola says, calms the immune system and thereby reduces the risk of sepsis, organ failure, and death. (Apparently, in addition to preventing the disease, Mercola aims to cover each and every symptom and complication of COVID-19 with a product he sells.)
    • N-acetyl cysteine, which “may be effective at fighting the blood clotting and strokes occurring in many COVID-19 cases as well as reducing the risk of acute respiratory distress syndrome.”
    • Prebiotics, probiotics, and “sporebiotics”, based on Mercola’s notion that COVID-19 infections may enable Prevotella bacteria to colonize the lungs, causing severe symptoms associated with the disease. He especially touts the “sporebiotic” Bacillus spores, which, he suggests, may be even more effective than antibiotics at fighting the Prevotella.
    • Saunas, which, Mercola told his podcast listeners, can raise your core body temperature, thereby “preventatively treat[ing] any lingering infection that’s just starting to go around.” (Sadly, Mercola Group saunas are currently unavailable due to a “redesign”.)
    • Ozone, to which Mercola devoted an entire podcast: “ozone therapy appears to be even more effective than intravenous vitamin C and to me it’s tragic that no one’s touching that with a 10-foot pole to treat this.” The Mercola Group sells air purifiers touted as generating ozone.
    • Elderberry extract, spirulina, beta-glucan, lipoic acid, and sulforaphane, all of which, according to the Mercola Group’s Coronavirus Resource Guide, “may be of particular benefit against COVID-19.”
As the consumer groups patiently explain, after each description of Mercola’s mendacity, they “are not aware of any scientific evidence, let alone properly conducted RCTs, that [the product in question] prevents or treats COVID-19 infection” or there is “no credible scientific evidence” to support his claims.
After discussing previous regulatory actions involving Mercola, they argue that prior cease and desist warnings “have been insufficient to prevent this fraud and more action is needed”, up to and including warning letters followed by compliance monitoring and, if necessary, enforcement actions in federal court seeking permanent injunctions, civil penalties, and seizure of the offending products.
Among the regulatory actions described was an investigation by Illinois authorities and a call for revocation or suspension of Mercola’s medical license by the Chief of Medical Prosecutions. How that matter was resolved is not entirely clear and, as of June 25, 2020, Mercola’s medical licenses are still active in Illinois and Florida, a shameful indictment of the Medical Boards in those states.
There is something terribly wrong about a system that allows a multi-millionaire charlatan, using his medical credentials as a badge of authority, to fleece the public based on their understandable pandemic fears, all while his fellow physicians are on the front lines treating COVID-19, with far less compensation and at great risk to their safety.

Mercola and Kennedy sue Sen. Elizabeth Warren for combating their COVID misinformation
Quack tycoon Joseph Mercola and anti-vaccine crank Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., have filed a lawsuit against U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren claiming she violated their First Amendment rights when she complained that Amazon was peddling COVID misinformation, citing Mercola’s recent misinformation-filled book on COVID as an example.
Jann Bellamy on January 27, 2022
Link

Quack tycoon Joseph Mercola and anti-vaccine crank Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., have filed a lawsuit against U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) claiming she violated their First Amendment rights when she complained that Amazon was peddling COVID misinformation, citing Mercola’s recent misinformation-filled book on COVID as an example. Anti-GMO and anti-vaccine activist Ronnie Cummins and the book’s publisher are also plaintiffs.
According to a letter sent by Sen. Warren to Amazon last September, Amazon’s search and “Best Seller” algorithms consistently returned “highly-ranked and favorably tagged books based on falsehoods about COVID-19 vaccines and cures” when her staff performed searches for terms like “COVID-19” and “vaccine”. Mercola’s windbag-titled book, The Truth About COVID: Exposing the Great Reset, Lockdowns, Vaccine Passports, and the New Normal, which Cummins co-authored and for which Kennedy wrote the introduction, topped the list. Amazon had also tagged the book as a Best Seller and the #1 Best Seller in the “Political Freedom” category.
Mercola, Sen. Warren notes in her letter, has been identified as “the most influential spreader of coronavirus misinformation online” and is apparently using his book to drive sales of supplements, despite the fact the FDA warned him to stop selling these supplements “for the unapproved and unauthorized treatment of COVID-19”. She unfavorably compared Amazon’s lack of effort in combating misinformation to that of fellow internet behemoths Facebook and Twitter, who have more aggressively supervised their content.
Sen. Warren’s letter charged that Amazon had engaged in a “pattern and practice” of spreading falsehoods and selling inappropriate products, conduct she deemed an “unethical, unacceptable, and potentially unlawful course of action”. She asked that Amazon perform “an immediate review” of its algorithms and report on the extent to which they are directing consumers to books and other products containing COVID misinformation.
In response, Amazon basically said that the algorithms worked as described because that’s the way they are set up.
As a retailer, we respect that our customers want access to a wide variety of viewpoints on the matter, which is why we continue to list the books in question.
Or, Sen. Warren characterized the response:
they can eliminate misinformation if they want to do it—but they won’t.
And apparently they didn’t, because Mercola’s book, as of yesterday, has a five-star rating based on over 5,000 reviews, is the #2 Best Seller in the “Political Freedom” category and #1 in both the “Propaganda and Political Psychology” and “Politics of Privacy and Surveillance” categories. Among the tens of millions of titles Amazon sells, it ranks #1,153 in Books. Amazon did, however, notify the publisher that it would no longer run ads for the book, although Amazon did not cite Sen. Warren’s letter as the reason. Barnes & Noble decided not to sell the book, a decision it later reversed. Again, there is no evidence linking the bookseller’s actions to Sen. Warren’s letter to Amazon.
Mercola and Kennedy are well-known to readers of this blog, but here’s a short summary of their nefarious activities.
Mercola is a scofflaw osteopath who built a multi-million-dollar empire selling dietary supplements and various other nostrums, which he promotes by fomenting distrust in “conventional” medicine and regulatory authorities, deceptively presenting his products as the safer, more “natural” alternative. His false claims for these products have gotten him in trouble with the FDA, as Sen. Warren noted. He is also rabidly anti-vaccine and has donated generously to anti-vaccine organizations. He is prolific spreader of misinformation on COVID and well as other health topics, which aids his trafficking in quackery when consumers buy into his rhetoric and his pricey products. This book is, in my view, just another means of profiting off the pandemic.
Kennedy, in my opinion, has probably done more to sow distrust in vaccines, including routine childhood vaccinations that have saved millions of lives, than just about any other person living today. (The despicable Barbara Loe Fisher and Andrew Wakefield are his chief competitors for the all-time record.) The pandemic has presented him a golden opportunity to traffic in lies and distortions about COVID and COVID vaccines, and he’s made the most of it, earning himself a spot (along with Mercola) among the Disinformation Dozen as a major source of COVID misinformation. Just this past Sunday, Kennedy (employing a common anti-vaccine trope) compared vaccine mandates to laws in Hitler’s Germany and invoked the name of Anne Frank. This “moral and intellectual decay” was rightly called out by the Auschwitz Memorial, among many others. Kennedy later “apologized“.
Ronnie Cummins, Mercola’s co-author, is the leader of the Organic Consumers Association, also funded by Mercola, which the Genetic Literacy Project calls “one of them most aggressive of North America’s anti-GMO groups”. The group is also anti-vaccine and republishes misinformation from highly unreliable sources like Mike Adams and Alex Jones.
I have not read Mercola’s book and do not plan to. Fortunately, Jonathan Jarry of McGill University’s Office for Science and Society has, thereby giving us a reliable source as to its contents. So, before we move on to the details of the lawsuit, let’s see what he has to say about The Truth About COVID (etc. etc.).
Summarizing the book is, in effect, summarizing the misinformation surrounding COVID-19. In short, Mercola and Cummins argue that the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus was engineered in a laboratory in Wuhan, China, and its escape was capitalized on by every cabal, government, and corporation you can think of to scare people into looking away while they stole most of the world’s financial resources for themselves. None of the diagnostic tests, treatments, or public health measures can be trusted; rather, the disease is mild and protection is afforded to smart people who have no health conditions, eat the right food, and load themselves up with the right supplements.
Fact-checking the book’s thousands of erroneous claims would require weeks and, I suspect, the publication of a two-tome book.
Jarry does take a stab at pointing out some of the book’s factual errors and exaggerations. For instance, the book insists that pandemic restrictions will be “permanent” even as those restrictions are being lifted. It touts a supplement (quercetin, which Mercola conveniently sells) based on a computer simulation, not an actual in-vivo study, that is a preprint and not peer-reviewed to boot. Mercola’s fevered conspiracy mindset sees a pandemic preparedness simulation as evidence that the whole thing was planned.
So, in sum, people who have spent years profiting off misinformation with little consequence have filed a lawsuit claiming their freedom to speak out has been impaired. With that, let’s turn to some of the particulars.
The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington (because that is where Amazon is) incorrectly styles Mercola an “M.D.” (he’s a D.O.) and describes him as a “board-certified and licensed physician”, itself a sad commentary on the unwillingness of medical organizations and boards to sanction egregious conduct harmful to the public’s health. Kennedy is described as “prominent lawyer and professor and the founder and CEO of Children’s Health Defense Fund”, the innocuously-titled but vociferously anti-vaccine organization
The complaint quibbles with Sen. Warren’s characterization of the book as containing “false and misleading” information, including content disparaging COVID vaccines, which they defend as merely asserting that the vaccines’ effectiveness “has been wildly exaggerated and major safety questions have gone unanswered”. They attempt to support this by claiming
many renowned scientists have questioned the safety and efficacy of the COVID vaccines and thousands of physicians have asked for more openness to alternative COVID treatments.
The “renowned scientists” they cite are physician and anti-vaccine conspiracy theorist Robert Malone and former Trump advisor Peter Navarro, an economist, writing in a Washington Times op-ed. The “thousands of physicians” are signatories to a Great Barrington Declaration-type online manifesto that anyone can sign. To give you an idea of where that is coming from, Robert Malone himself and yet another anti-vaccine MD, Peter McCollough, have signed on.
In any event, the plaintiffs contend, it doesn’t matter whether what they say is truthful or not, their book is protected by the First Amendment and Sen. Warren’s implication that Amazon’s conduct might be unlawful, as well as her previous threats bust up Amazon on anti-trust grounds (unrelated to this incident), could cause Amazon to take behind-the-scenes action to suppress their views. Suing her in both her official capacity as a U.S. Senator and individually, they seek a declaration that Sen. Warren has violated their constitutional rights, a preliminary and permanent injunction against her doing so in the future, and damages.
The U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Washington, representing her in her official capacity, filed opposition to the motion for preliminary injunction, a Motion to Dismiss (which basically says that, even if everything the plaintiffs allege in their complaint is true, they still don’t have a viable claim) and a Motion for Summary Judgment (which says that, based on all the undisputed facts, she wins).
She is represented in her individual capacity by election law expert and Democratic operative Marc Elias, who joined in the U.S. Attorney’s arguments.
The trouble with the plaintiffs’ claims, the U.S. Attorney points out, is that the plaintiffs don’t allege, nor have they presented, any evidence that Amazon or anyone else has taken any action against anyone because of Sen. Warren’s letter. In response, the plaintiffs say they don’t need any such evidence, that what they characterize as her “threat” to Amazon alone is sufficient as a matter of law.
Other defenses are raised as well, such as sovereign immunity and the Speech or Debate Clause of the Constitution, but we won’t get that much into the weeds, except to note a recent interesting case she cites, Association of American Physicians & Surgeons v. Schiff.
The Association of American Physicians & Surgeons (AAPS) sued Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA ) after he, similarly to Sen. Warren, sent letters to Amazon, Google, and Facebook, encouraging them to use their platforms to prevent inaccurate information on vaccines and requesting information about what the companies were doing to prevent misinformation. He also, in an unrelated Congressional hearing, questioned certain legal privileges these companies enjoyed. At no time did he mention the AAPS.
SBM’s Dr. David Gorski called out the AAPS way back in 2008 as an organization that
tries to represent itself as a legitimate medical professional society, but in reality it promotes antivaccine views, HIV/AIDS denialism, and an Ayn Randian view of the world in which doctors are supermen, Medicare is unconstitutional, and the government should never interfere with physicians’ prerogatives.
It is unsurprising, then, the AAPS has been promoting dubious COVID information. In the lawsuit, the AAPS complained that, among other things, “Amazon removed from its platform for streaming videos the popular videos Vaxxed and Shoot ‘Em Up: The Truth About Vaccines“, both rank anti-vaccine propaganda.
When Amazon and other companies took action, resulting in the diminished ability of AAPS and others to spread misinformation, the AAPS took umbrage and sued Rep. Schiff although they, like Mercola et al., had no evidence that their downfall had anything to do with him.
In a February, 2021, decision, the court granted Rep. Schiff’s Motion to Dismiss the complaint based, in part, on the alternate grounds (1) that the plaintiffs had failed to allege anything but an “implied” connection between Rep. Schiff’s actions and that of the tech companies and (2) his immunity under the Speech or Debate Clause, which provides that
for any Speech or Debate in either House, [Members of Congress] shall not be questioned in any other Place.
The clause protects Members of Congress and Senators from lawsuits arising from their conduct during official legislative functions, such as hearings, as well as when they engage in other activities in service to their elected office, such investigations and gathering information.
        ◦ Whether or not she prevails on the Speech or Debate Clause defense, as pointed out in Sen. Warren’s argument in support of her motions, government officials are free to try to convince private parties to remove content protected by the First Amendment that they find dangerous to the public’s health, but they are not free to coerce that removal through threat of legal action or government sanction. In her view, and mine, Sen. Warren’s letter falls far short of “coercion”. We’ll see if the court agrees, if it reaches this question at all, and otherwise how the case is decided. Stay tuned.

COVID-19 vaccines and the Nuremberg Code
Antivaxxers love to claim that vaccine mandates (especially COVID-19 vaccine mandates) violate the Nuremberg Code and call for Nuremberg-style tribunals to hold public health and vaccine advocates “accountable”. As usual, they have no idea what they are talking about. This is also not a new antivax narrative, although what is unprecedented is that what was once fringe even among antivaxxers is now mainstream.
David Gorski on August 29, 2022
Link

It has been a while since I’ve written about this particular topic, which is why I think it a good time to revisit it, particularly given that over the last month there seems to have been a large uptick in antivaccine rhetoric centered around portraying COVID-19 vaccines as a new Holocaust and the concomitant desire for Nuremberg-style trials—complete with hashtags on Twitter like #Nuremberg2, #NurembergTribunal, the ominous-sounding #Nuremberg2TickTock, and related hashtags targeting Anthony Fauci, Bill Gates, and other perceived “enemies”—for public health officials, with punishment meted out afterwards for their “crimes.” In these calls for “Nuremberg 2.0,” the proposed punishment can range from imprisonment—”lock them up!”—to truly bloodthirsty calls for the gallows or even the guillotine. While I have written about this particular narrative far more extensively at my not-so-super-secret other blog, here I have mostly just alluded to it; so I thought it would be useful to discuss how the Nuremberg Code and Holocaust have been misused by antivaxxers for a long time. What we are seeing is nothing new in terms of content. What is new is the volume and broad reach of the narrative. Basically, calls for retribution disguised as “justice” against public health and vaccine advocates have reached places that I never would have predicted before when I first started writing about them over a decade ago.
First, however, let’s provide a taste of what I mean from antivax websites and social media. I will list quite a few examples, just to give readers an idea of what I’m talking about. First, attorney and long-time antivaccine advocate Mary Holland published an article on Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s website titled “Those Who Violated Nuremberg Code Must Be Prosecuted for Crimes Against Humanity” that was the “inspiration” (if you will) for me to write this post, which is a transcript of her speech given for a conference titled “75 Years of the Nuremberg Code — Never Again Forced Medical Procedures“, a public conference held on August 20 in Nuremberg to commemorate the 75th anniversary of the Nuremberg Code. Unsurprisingly, it was hosted by Action Alliance, which appears to be a group of German antivaccine activists. Her speech was amplified by Mike Adams on Natural News, and one of the highlights that you might have seen being shared was a speech by a Holocaust survivor named Vera Sherav, in which she likened the COVID-19 response to the Final Solution and deemed it “the New Eugenics” in which this time “instead of Zyklon B gas, the weapons of mass destruction are genetically engineered injectable bioweapons masquerading as vaccines.” Meanwhile, antivaxxers are promoting narratives that COVID-19 vaccines are killing millions of people, an example being Steve Kirsch (whom I’ve written about before here) claiming that as many as 12 million have been killed by them worldwide, and that “they” are “killing people worldwide at a rate at least 6X faster than the Germans did”. (I kid you not; if you don’t believe me, click on the link.) Unsurprisingly, Mike Adams is amplifying this claim as well, with headlines like “10,000 people A DAY being killed by covid vaccines; worldwide fatalities likely larger than the HOLOCAUST” and “The mass culling of the HUMAN HERD is now under way… here’s exactly how it’s being accomplished to achieve mass extermination“.
Feel free to scroll past if you are one of those readers who so objects to embedded Tweets.
In particular, this narrative has resurfaced since COVID-19 vaccines were approved for children:
When the truth is finally revealed….#Nuremberg2ticktock
— Moonlight's Musings 🇨🇦🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 (@m00nlight131) August 23, 2022
It is, of course, not limited to that at all:
The fascist @liberal_party violated the Nuremberg Code, you know, those pesky ethical rules that determine if you act in this fashion it MAKES YOU A NAZI!
Yet somehow, you are either unaware of this or you are, what history labelled Nazi citizens, a "Good German."#Nuremberg2 pic.twitter.com/h9S32jTe6N
— Kaffir Kanuck (@Kaffir_Kanuck) August 28, 2022
I’ll discuss these principles in a moment, in particular how they do not apply to COVID-19 vaccines and vaccine mandates. In the meantime, here are a few more examples:
EXACTLY. #NUREMBERG2TICKTOCK pic.twitter.com/ccyFakZvfL
— RABBINSTEIN 🌮 ⚡️ 🔑 (@IwanRabbinstein) August 22, 2022
It will.In progress now.Will take time.All legal processes do.But We The People will ultimately demand it..and get it. pic.twitter.com/8CZRHKD9UN
— Rik Lesel (@RikLesel) July 1, 2022
Not causing autism is a low bar for safety. Anyone who coerces vaccines should be found guilty in nuremberg 2 for crimes against humanity
— Tim Truth (@TimTruth123) July 19, 2022
They are well paid (off) propagandists and they don't care. Thank God for caches and archives. Their complicity in this crime against humanity will never disappear nor will it be forgotten. #Nuremberg2ticktock
— Moonlight's Musings 🇨🇦🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 (@m00nlight131) August 23, 2022
I want Nuremberg2#SackThemAll #JailThemAll #Nuremberg2ticktock #Nuremberg2 #EnoughIsEnough #Equality2022 https://t.co/07BFKxtEGl
— tsuzuku_ryudø (@tsuzuku_ryudo) August 28, 2022
Such calls are not limited to just vaccine advocates. Unfortunately, COVID-19 conspiracy theorists of all stripes have taken up the call, including those who think that COVID-19 originated in a “lab leak”. This particular example also shows how the narrative of a “Nuremberg 2.0” has reached beyond the antivaccine fringe and been taken up by a number of politicians:
Look at psychopathic #BillGatesBioTerrorist 'take' on Fauci versus Rand Paul.
Depsite millions and paid bots, how hated is Bill and rightfully so!
62k versus 3k likes
Time for Bill, Tony, Klaus, Larry and many more to be tried at#Nuremberg2TickTock https://t.co/9OKBk1W4oA pic.twitter.com/dj8VVZP3Qu
— @aprincey (@hypnosoothe) August 23, 2022
Anecdotally, more and more vaccine advocates, myself included, are reporting to me that they are being targeted with threats, and here are some receipts:
BEAT IT…VERIFIED ACCOUNTS THAT WERE BRIBE OR PAID…..MAYBE YOURS…WILL BE TRIED IN COURT..
CANT SAY YOU DIDNT KNOW…
WERE COMING FOR ALLLL OR YOU…MEDIA, SOCIAL, GOVERNMENT, AND BIG PHARMA
YOU ALL WILL EITHER HANG OR BE PUT IN JAIL..
— Mike (@RecyclingThat) August 22, 2022
And my favorite, here are threats that everything I Tweet is being “saved” to use as evidence against me:
I would consider shutting up now… Because every damn Twitter account posting anything against thing against this.. I will be saving and I will be adding to the court case… So stop pushing you have been warned the evidence is out there the facts is there..
— Mike (@RecyclingThat) August 22, 2022
Absolutely… And whoever's pushing this account up above with this little verified circle will be a part of those crimes… Not only did he push the shot for the past 2 years with all the evidence released.. He's now going against the Nuremberg trending online..someone is scared
— Mike (@RecyclingThat) August 22, 2022
says he, a collaborator – whistling past the graveyard, while ignoring the deluge of 'vaxx' harm evidence – tweet saved #Nuremberg2
— Rayn Face (@Raynface) August 22, 2022
I note that, even though I now have over 72K followers on Twitter, the threats and abuse that I receive are nothing compared to what a number of other vaccine advocates receive, particularly as a result of the “Nuremberg 2” narrative. So let’s compare what the antivax narrative about the Nuremberg Code, which was promulgated as a result of the Nuremberg Medical Trials in 1947, with reality and discuss why antivaxxers have long abused them, to the point where I once coined the term “Nuremberg Code gambit,” much as I coined the term “pharma shill gambit,” to describe a common false narrative by antivaxxers and medical science deniers. If you understand what the Nuremberg Code actually says, its role in the history of bioethics and evolving protections for human subjects in medical research, and how it has now been largely supplanted by the Helsinki Declaration, you will be better equipped to understand why the antivax narrative is so harmful.

Mary Holland and Vera Sharav invoke the Nuremberg Code
If you look at the lineup of the event commemorating the 75th anniversary of the conclusion of the Nuremberg Trials, you’ll probably recognize a few names other than Mary Holland. For example, Tess Lawrie, one of the foremost promoters of ivermectin as a highly effective treatment for COVID-19, was a prominent figure at the event, as was Rolf Kron, an antivax homeopath (but I repeat myself) from a COVID-19 “resistance” group called Doctors Stand Up. There were also groups of Holocaust survivors included, which was particularly distressing to me given my online history of combatting Holocaust denial dating back to the 1990s. I didn’t watch the entire event, which is archived at RFK Jr.’s website, but I watched enough and read enough transcripts to get the gist of the overall theme, which was, predictably, that COVID-19 public health responses, particularly the “experimental” vaccines, violate the Nuremberg Code.
I note with some amusement how Mary Holland includes in her talk an expression of disappointment that representatives from the governments of the Allies (the United States, the United Kingdom, and Russia) declined to take part:
I am especially honored to be here because the authors of the Nuremberg Code were doctors and lawyers from the United States who sought to prevent future horrors. And they built on medical and legal ethics established here in Germany before the Nazi regime.
I deeply wish that U.S., British, Russian and German government representatives were here to stand with us, as well as representatives of the global mainstream media.
It is a sad commentary that they are absent.
I wonder why these nations didn’t send representatives. Could it be that they recognized this farce for what it was?
Let’s see what Holland’s narrative is, though. It’s pretty predictable if you know anything about the antivaccine movement:
Tragically, in the last two-and-a-half years, we have witnessed a global assault on the Nuremberg Code.
Governments, medical establishments, universities and the media have violated the very first principle and every other principle of the code’s 10 points.
They have coerced people into being human guinea pigs.
They have forced people on penalty of their livelihoods, their identities, their health, their friendships — and even their family relationships — to take inadequately tested, experimental, gene-altering injections as well as experimental tests and medical devices.
Those who have intentionally, knowingly and maliciously violated the principles of the Nuremberg Code must be punished.
They must be called out, prosecuted and punished for crimes against humanity. This is one of our key tasks.
We must stop this. And we must ensure this does not happen again.
See the narrative? Vaccine advocates have committed “crimes against humanity” in supporting vaccination against COVID-19 and vaccine mandates for certain jobs and activities. You can watch the whole thing at RFK Jr.’s website, but there’s no real need given that a complete transcript was published.
Throughout the rest of the talk, Holland portrayed the vaccines as “experimental” and deadly, stating at one point, “In the U.S. and here in Europe, no vaccine has ever remotely compared to these injections — the risk and death profile of these injections is unprecedented.” They are not experimental, and, contrary to the claims of mass death due to vaccines, they are not deadly; indeed, they are amazingly safe.
As I’ve said many times before, even when they were authorized under emergency use authorization (EUA) in the US, they had still undergone large phase 3 randomized clinical trials involving tens of thousands of subjects demonstrating safety and efficacy. Any pharmaceutical or vaccine that has cleared such a hurdle is, scientifically speaking, not “experimental” anymore. The term “investigational” is a legal term specific to the FDA and its mandate; all it means is that the drug or vaccine has not yet gone through the entire regulatory process in order to achieve full FDA approval. The mechanism of an EUA was designed to allow the FDA to act faster in the case of an urgent situation. If a global pandemic killing (then) hundreds of thousands of people didn’t qualify, I don’t know what does. Oddly enough, even after the mRNA-based vaccines achieved full FDA approval, antivaxxers continued to portray them as “experimental”.
Moving on, I’ve been meaning to write about Vera Sharav for a long time. Indeed, she warrants her own post, and what I write about her here will be far briefer than is warranted. Before I go into her background as a Holocaust survivor and founder of a group ostensibly devoted to patient rights, informed consent, and, above all, the protection of human research subjects in medical research, let’s take a look at a bit of what she said in her speech, which can be viewed in its entirety, again, on RFK Jr.’s website, although the antivaccine blog Age of Autism helpfully provided a transcript.
To start out her speech, Sharav recounted her history:
In 1941, I was 31⁄2 when my family was forced from our home in Romania & deported to Ukraine.
We were herded into a concentration camp – essentially left to starve. Death was ever-present. My father died of typhus when I was five.
In 1944, as the Final Solution was being aggressively implemented, Romania retreated from its alliance with Nazi Germany. The government permitted several hundred Jewish orphans under the age of 12 to return to Romania. I was not an orphan; my mother lied to save my life.
I boarded a cattle car train – the same train that continued to transport Jews to the death camps – even as Germany was losing the war.
Four years elapsed before I was reunited with my mother.
Sharav (born Vera Roll) had fallen victim to a move by the fascist government that ruled Romania and was allied with Hitler at the time, in which some 145,000 Romanian and Hungarian Jews were moved to an area known as Transnistria along the Ukraine border, which became one of the most notorious killing fields of the war, with as many as 250,000 Jews were killed or allowed to die of disease and starvation. The Rolls were sent to a town called Mogilev, which had been turned into a concentration camp by the Romanians and Nazis. Her father died there of typhus within weeks of their arrival.
In her speech, Sharav made an explicit parallel between the Final Solution and COVID-19 and more or less correctly blamed eugenics for the Holocaust. I say “more or less” because there was more to it than just eugenics, the belief that Jews were subhuman, and that German Aryans were the “master race”. Hitler also believed that the Jews were working to destroy Germany and had decided that he had to destroy them before they could succeed. In any event, she was correct that the Holocaust didn’t happen all at once, observing that it “did not begin in the gas chambers of Auschwitz and Treblinka”, had been “preceded by nine years of incremental restrictions on personal freedom, and the suspension of legal rights and civil rights”, and that the stage had been “set by fear-mongering and hate-mongering propaganda”. While this description was correct, unfortunately Sharav then pivoted to liken the current climate to the escalating restrictions and persecutions of the Jews during the Holocaust:
By declaring a state of emergency—in 1933 and in 2020, constitutionally protected personal freedom, legal rights, and civil rights were swept aside. Repressive, discriminatory decrees followed. In 1933, the primary target for discrimination were Jews; today, the target is people who refuse to be injected with experimental, genetically engineered vaccines. Then and now, government dictates were crafted to eliminate segments of the population. In 2020, government dictates forbade hospitals from treating the elderly in nursing homes. The result was mass murder. Government decrees continue to forbid doctors to prescribe life-saving, FDA approved medicines; government-dictated protocols continue to kill.
The media is silent – as it was then. The media broadcasts a single, government-dictated narrative – just as it had under the Nazis. Strict censorship silences opposing views.In Nazi Germany few individuals objected; those who did were imprisoned in concentration camps. Today, doctors & scientists who challenge the approved narrative are maligned; their reputations trashed. They risk losing their license to practice as well as having their homes and workplace raided by SWAT teams.
What Sharav meant when she mentioned “FDA-approved medicines” was clearly the repurposed and unproven drugs hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin, neither of which are actually effective in treating COVID-19. As for the rest, you can see the same narrative that many antivaxxers have promoted that likens pandemic restrictions to another Holocaust at worst or, at minimum, to incipient fascism. I do have to wonder: Who are these physicians arguing against COVID-19 vaccines and for alternative treatments like ivermectin who have had “their homes and workplace raided by SWAT teams”? I like to think that I’m up on all the latest COVID-19 news, particularly about “contrarian” doctors, and I don’t recall ever having encountered a news story in which any of these doctors had their home or office raided by a SWAT team. Is she referring to Dr. Simone Gold, who was sentenced to 60 days in prison for trespassing in the US Capitol Building during the January 6 insurrection? Help me out here.
Of course, Sharav concluded her speech by bringing it back to the Nuremberg Code, warning:
Those who declare that Holocaust analogies are “off limits”—are betraying the victims of the Holocaust by denying the relevance of the Holocaust.
The Nuremberg Code has served as the foundation for ethical clinical research since its publication 75 years ago.
The Covid pandemic is being exploited as an opportunity to overturn the moral and legal parameters laid down by the Nuremberg Code.
The Nuremberg Code is our defense against abusive experimentation.
While it is not incorrect to state that the Nuremberg Code is important as a foundation for ethical human subjects research and that it is a defense against abusive experimentation, it is not complete to say that either, as I will discuss in the next section. In the meantime, I’ll simply quote from near the end of Sharav’s speech:
Transhumanists despise human values, & deny the existence of a human soul. Harari declares that there are too many “useless people.” The Nazi term was “worthless eaters”
This is the New Eugenics.
It is embraced by the most powerful global billionaire technocrats who gather at Davos: Big Tech, Big Pharma, the financial oligarchs, academics, government leaders & the military industrial complex. These megalomaniacs have paved the road to another Holocaust.
This time, the threat of genocide is Global in scale.
This time instead of Zyklon B gas, the weapons of mass destruction are genetically engineered injectable bioweapons masquerading as vaccines.
This time, there will be no rescuers. Unless All of Us Resist, Never Again is Now.
That’s right. Vera Sharav directly compared COVID-19 vaccines to the Zyklon-B gas that Nazis used as one of their main tools of mass extermination of the Jews. She also repeated an old antivaccine claim, namely the portrayal of vaccines as a form of “transhumanism“.
I started this section by mentioning that I had long been meaning to write about Vera Sharav. The reason is that she had aligned herself with antivaxxers years before the pandemic. For example, in this STAT News story from 2016, she expressed her belief that Andrew Wakefield had been railroaded:
But her distrust of the drug industry and medical research institutions has also led her to embrace some dubious heroes, including discredited British physician Andrew Wakefield, who falsified data to imply a link between vaccines and autism.
Wakefield’s medical license was revoked for a series of ethics violations, and most in the mainstream medical community blame him for raising unjustified doubts about the safety of vaccines. Yet Sharav puts him on her “honor roll” of “exemplary professionals,” along with Florence Nightingale.
“My research and my gut tell me that Wakefield has been wronged,” she said. “One thing I’ve learned from early in my life is that if I don’t stay true to my gut feeling, then I’m lost. I don’t have any control.”
That same news story also described her better history, how she had been a force for protecting human subjects in medical experiments, founding the Alliance for Human Research Protection after the death of her son, who had suffered from schizophrenia, from neuroleptic malignant syndrome, an uncommon but frequently deadly side effect of antipsychotic drugs that causes muscle rigidity and fever and can ultimately lead to organ failure and death. I’ve perused that the AHRP website before, but let’s take a look at one of the two articles that greet visitors to its homepage:

Let’s just put it this way. If you use an image by David Dees to illustrate your article, you have gone far down the antivaccine road. Worse, the image is blatantly antisemitic. Notice how the “vaccine enforcement” officer has a badge of the Star of David with the word “Zion” in it. As for the article itself, it’s a typical antivaccine-style screed in which adverse events recorded in the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database are represented as definitely having been caused by vaccines when, in fact, anyone who understands VAERS knows that you can’t do that. Seriously, both articles are nothing but standard antivax propaganda, and not even antivax propaganda chock full of conspiracy theories about COVID-19 vaccines that could plausibly be portrayed as “human subjects protection”. The same is true of the other article, in which vaccination is described in typical antivax language as a “medical assault”. Throughout the website, vaccines are frequently referred to as “child sacrifice” in articles dating back more than a decade. This “pivot” is not a pivot, and the antivax lean of AHRP is not new, nor is her demonization of COVID-19 vaccines new. She was doing it in 2020, an example of which comes from an interview from October 2020, as COVID-19 vaccines were making their way through the regulatory process. In the interview, titled “Nazism, COVID-19 and the destruction of modern medicine: An interview with Vera Sharav“, Sharav characterized the push for a vaccine as being all about the profit, saying at one point:
You don’t read about it in the media because the media is very much part of the business empire that’s ruling that.
Vaccines are an empire, and now they really want to do a vaccine globally.
Do you know what kind of a market that is? More than 7 billion people for a vaccine. Can you even count the kind of profits, no matter what they charge for it?
That’s what their goal is. That’s the whole allure of this COVID 19 vaccine. It’s that market.
You get the idea. What Vera Sharav was saying nearly two years ago was indistinguishable from the rhetoric I was seeing on hard core antivaccine sites, such as Natural News and, yes, RFK Jr.’s website, where the interview was published. Her antivax rhetoric remains indistinguishable from that of RFK Jr., Mike Adams, Del Bigtree, Andrew Wakefield, and basically all the major antivax “thought leaders” (if you can call it thought). Whatever her achievements in raising awareness of shoddy human subjects research practices, the dangers of certain pharmaceuticals, the frequency of nontherapeutic research, and the increasingly cozy relationship between medical academia and big pharma, Vera Sharav has clearly followed others down the road from skepticism of psychiatric drugs to extreme distrust of pharma to outright antivax.
But what about the Nuremberg Code?

COVID-19 vaccines and the Nuremberg Code
With the just completed discussion in mind, let’s circle back again to the Nuremberg Code, a set of principles for human subjects research that published in 1947 as part of USA vs. Brandt et al. (also often called the Doctors’ Trial) as one result of the Nuremberg Trials. The trial involved doctors who had been involved in Nazi human experimentation and mass murder disguised as euthanasia. Of the 23 defendants, seven were acquitted, while seven were sentenced to death. The rest received prison sentences ranging from 10 years to life imprisonment.
There are ten points to the code, which was published in the section of the verdict entitled “Permissible medical experiments”:
     1.  The voluntary consent of the human subject is absolutely essential. This means that the person involved should have legal capacity to give consent; should be so situated as to be able to exercise free power of choice, without the intervention of any element of force, fraud, deceit, duress, overreaching, or other ulterior form of constraint or coercion; and should have sufficient knowledge and comprehension of the elements of the subject matter involved as to enable him to make an understanding and enlightened decision. This latter element requires that before the acceptance of an affirmative decision by the experimental subject there should be made known to him the nature, duration, and purpose of the experiment; the method and means by which it is to be conducted; all inconveniences and hazards reasonably to be expected; and the effects upon his health or person which may possibly come from his participation in the experiment. The duty and responsibility for ascertaining the quality of the consent rests upon each individual who initiates, directs, or engages in the experiment. It is a personal duty and responsibility which may not be delegated to another with impunity.
     2.  The experiment should be such as to yield fruitful results for the good of society, unprocurable by other methods or means of study, and not random and unnecessary in nature.
     3.  The experiment should be so designed and based on the results of animal experimentation and a knowledge of the natural history of the disease or other problem under study that the anticipated results will justify the performance of the experiment.
     4.  The experiment should be so conducted as to avoid all unnecessary physical and mental suffering and injury.
     5.  No experiment should be conducted where there is an a priori reason to believe that death or disabling injury will occur; except, perhaps, in those experiments where the experimental physicians also serve as subjects.
     6.  The degree of risk to be taken should never exceed that determined by the humanitarian importance of the problem to be solved by the experiment.
     7.  Proper preparations should be made and adequate facilities provided to protect the experimental subject against even remote possibilities of injury, disability, or death.
     8.  The experiment should be conducted only by scientifically qualified persons. The highest degree of skill and care should be required through all stages of the experiment of those who conduct or engage in the experiment.
     9.  During the course of the experiment the human subject should be at liberty to bring the experiment to an end if he has reached the physical or mental state where continuation of the experiment seems to him to be impossible.
     10.  During the course of the experiment the scientist in charge must be prepared to terminate the experiment at any stage, if he has probable cause to believe, in the exercise of the good faith, superior skill and careful judgment required of him that a continuation of the experiment is likely to result in injury, disability, or death to the experimental subject.
It is true that the Nuremberg Code remains one of the foundations of medical ethics governing human subjects research. It is, however, old and has been largely supplanted, for all practical purposes, by newer statements of human research ethics. While it is certainly true that these newer statements (which I’ll discuss in a moment) echo many of the points of the Nuremberg Code, it’s also true they go beyond them.
Before I do that, though, here’s the key deficiency in the arguments that antivaxxers have been using that invoke the Nuremberg Code is actually quite simple, as I once wrote over a year ago on Twitter:
2. Calling #CovidVaccine "experimental" is a conflation of a legal definition of "investigational," in which @US_FDA requires that designation on any drug not yet given a full FDA approval. Scientifically, it's just not true any more.
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) July 19, 2021
To reiterate, the Nuremberg Code only applies to human experimentation. Notice how each of the ten points of the Nuremberg Code mentions “the experiment” or “experimental” treatments. The Code is not about medical treatment, only medical experimentation involving human subjects. I don’t know how it can be made much simpler than that. Of course, the desire to appeal to the Nuremberg Code is why antivaxxers try so desperately to misrepresent COVID-19 vaccines as being “experimental”. It’s also why I like to retort that no one was forced, coerced, or otherwise mandated to sign up to be a subject in any of the clinical trials of the Pfizer or Moderna vaccines (or any of the other currently approved vaccines) that led to their authorization under an EUA and ultimately to their full FDA approval. Again, vaccines that have passed phase 3 clinical trials and been shown to be safe and effective are not, from a scientific viewpoint, “experimental” anymore. They might still be considered “investigational” from a legal standpoint because all that means is that they haven’t gone through the full FDA process yet, but that’s it. Even while they were still being distributed under an EUA and before they were granted full FDA approval, from a scientific and medical standpoint COVID-19 vaccines being used have been legitimate medical preventative treatments, even when they did not yet have full FDA approval.
The second part of the Nuremberg Code gambit most commonly used is the deceptive appeal to “informed consent”. Of course, as I like to point out, while antivaxxers like to think they are really advocating for informed consent (and probably actually do think that), in practice, what they are advocating for is something that I like to refer to as “misinformed refusal”. (I used to call it “misinformed consent” before I realized that this term didn’t quite catch the essence of what antivaxxers do.) It’s an antivaccine trope that I’ve been dealing with at least 17 years, if not longer.
Here’s the idea. Antivaxxers vastly exaggerate the risks of vaccines and even attribute nonexistent risks to them (e.g., autism, autoimmune disease, sudden infant death syndrome) that are not at all supported by science. At the same time, they deny or downplay the benefits of vaccines, portraying them as largely ineffective and claiming that “natural” immunity from the disease is far superior to vaccine-induced immunity. Thus, if parents listen to the antivaccine narrative about the risk-benefit profile of vaccines, they will believe that the risks of vaccines outweigh the benefits. They might even believe that vaccines are not only ineffective, but dangerous, deadly even. That’s where my term “misinformed refusal” comes in. It’s the refusal of vaccines based on misinformation that portrays a falsely unfavorable (and even terrifying) risk-benefit ratio.
The Nuremberg Code, as important as it has been in the history and development of human subjects protections during medical research, has largely been supplanted by the Belmont Report (published in 1976) and the Declaration of Helsinki. The Belmont Report, for instance, goes beyond the Nuremberg Code by delineating the boundaries between medical practice and research. It also rests on basic ethical principles of respect for persons, beneficence, and justice, while emphasizing the importance of voluntariness (as the Nuremberg Code), a detailed discussion of benefits and risks (informed consent), and the selection of subjects. The Declaration of Helsinki, last updated in 2013, is similar, but goes into much more detail about informed consent. It also addresses the ethics of the use of placebos, post-trial provisions, and the dissemination of results. It even addresses the use of unproven interventions in clinical practice outside of clinical trials.
Finally, in the US, the federal regulations governing human subjects research are enshrined under the Common Rule, which was originally instituted in 1981 and was last significantly revised in 2018. Basically, the Common Rule is the operationalization of the principles of the Belmont Report and the Declaration of Helsinki into regulations governing human subjects research carried out by the federal government, institutions that receive federal funding, and pharmaceutical and device companies seeking FDA approval for their products. It requires Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval and oversight of human subjects research, among other requirements for ethical human research and lays out the requirements for informed consent, as well as for research compliance by institutions. In effect, the Common Rule lays out the standard of ethics that govern not just human subjects research funded by the federal government or subject to FDA regulation for FDA approval, but in essence nearly all human subjects research. Almost all US academic institutions require their researchers to adhere to the Common Rule regardless of funding sources.
So why do antivaxxers always mention the Nuremberg Code and almost never the Belmont Report, Declaration of Helsinki, or the Common Rule when claiming that vaccine mandates somehow violate human subjects research protections and/or informed consent? The reason is simple. Neither the Belmont Report, the Declaration of Helsinki, nor the Common Rule were written or promulgated in response to Nazi war crimes. The Nuremberg Code, on the other hand, was written as part of the verdict of the Doctors Trial at Nuremberg as a first attempt to codify what principles that should govern ethical human subjects research.
In other words, the simple reason that antivaxxers point to “informed consent” for (or, as I like to call it, misinformed refusal of) vaccines along with the Nuremberg Code is because it’s a Godwin. It not-so-subtly compares physicians, public health officials, and vaccine advocates to Nazis. That’s the one and only purpose of the Nuremberg gambit. If it weren’t, in order to try to portray vaccines as “experimental” or “unproven,” antivaxxers would instead refer to the Helsinki Declaration, which is the most recent and most applicable set of ethical principals governing human subjects research. They don’t. That should tell you all you need to know about the Nuremberg gambit other than that COVID-19 vaccine mandates do not violate the Nuremberg Code anyway.
The Nuremberg gambit: Beyond antivaxxers
Unfortunately, the Nuremberg Code gambit is a Godwin that has permeated not just hard core antivaccine messaging. Indeed, it’s spread to pretty much every corner of COVID-19 contrarianism, minimization, and resistance to any sort of pandemic-related mandate, be it “lockdowns”, vaccines, or masks. (Nuremberg has even infiltrated “gender critical” narrative about gender-affirming care for transgender youths, with one group likening doctors practicing gender-affirming care to Josef Mengele, the infamously cruel Nazi doctor at Auschwitz.) I’ll start by invoking a Tweet that has been cited on this blog before, mainly by Jonathan Howard:
"The carnage is unspeakable .. Meanwhile, the people responsible are slowly slipping out of public life, finding new jobs and sanitizing their hands of any responsibility." – @jeffreyatucker https://t.co/LXaFN7LzVB
— Martin Kulldorff (@MartinKulldorff) December 9, 2021
It’s interesting to note that Jeffery Tucker of the Brownstone Institute could have chosen pretty much any other image for his article, but he chose that of a guillotine, the symbol of the Reign of Terror, a series of executions and massacres after the French Revolution, with the guillotine being the favored method of individual executions. In the article, shared by Martin Kulldorff, one of the three writers of the Great Barrington Declaration, that propaganda piece of anti-lockdown hysteria that basically advocated letting COVID-19 rip through the young and healthy population, the better to achieve “natural herd immunity” as fast as possible, while somehow—it’s never really specified how—using “focused protection” to keep safe the elderly and those with chronic health conditions at high risk for serious disease and death due to COVID-19.
The first time that I first saw this image, I couldn’t help but ask: If Tucker wasn’t calling for executions, why did he and the Brownstone Institute choose a very menacing image of a guillotine? They could have chosen literally any other image, but they didn’t. They chose a view of a guillotine that emphasizes the blade ready to fall, a very ominous and threatening image. (It very much looks like the view of a guillotine that someone near the front of the crowd baying for blood during the Reign of Terror might have had—or the view that someone walking up the steps to be executed might have had.) If Tucker and the Brownstone Institute were really interested in portraying justice, instead of retribution, wouldn’t an image of a courtroom or a jury—or of virtually anything other than a guillotine—have been more appropriate? Did Dr. Kulldorff not even see the not-so-subtle message that such an image paired with an article like Tucker’s broadcasts? As an aside, I’ll also ask this question: Does anyone know who else used the guillotine as a method of execution besides le tribunal révolutionnaire during the Reign of Terror? The Nazi regime in Germany! No, seriously, look it up if you don’t believe me. Members of the White Rose resistance, for example, were executed by guillotine after show trials.
Reign of Terror or Nuremberg 2? Does it matter? The idea is vengeance against enemies of antivaxxers disguised as “justice”. This fantasy of retribution is not new, either, as I pointed out, referencing a 2017 post by an antivaxxer named Kent Heckenlively:
Here's another example of this fantasy from seven years ago, in which Heckenlively fantasizes about accepting our "surrender" and offers us no promises over how well be treated other than that admitting wrongdoing *might* earn us mercy. https://t.co/HQfbmylKro pic.twitter.com/RfDRzeNske
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) March 17, 2022
Note the same sort of imagery from a man who has in the past demanded the “complete surrender” of vaccine advocates, promising them—maybe—mercy if they recant and confess their “crimes”. These “crimes”? Given that at the time the predominant misinformation believed by antivaxxers was that vaccines cause autism, the “crimes” were advocating policies that make children autistic.
As I often say (admittedly sometimes ad nauseam) in the age of the pandemic, everything old is new again, and the same thing applies to the Nuremberg Code gambit. The difference is not the antivax fantasy of retribution against their perceived enemies, but rather that the language and rhetoric that was, until relatively recently, only associated with the hardest of hardcore antivaxxers, has started to wend its way into the mainstream, with right wing pundits like Tucker Carlson taking up the narrative, likening COVID-19 vaccine mandates to the cruel and grossly unethical experiments that Nazis and Japanese carried out using prisoners during World War II, while mangling what Nuremberg is about by describing such mandates as “forced treatment” rather than abuse of human experimentation. Misunderstanding aside, this gave his interviewee, Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, the opportunity to thank Carlson for bringing up the Nuremberg Code:
Tucker Carlson compares vaccine requirements to medical experiments done by Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan pic.twitter.com/HjHZPr2LDI
— nikki mccann ramírez (@NikkiMcR) January 22, 2022
Perhaps the most frightening thing about the pandemic is how antivaccine narratives once viewed as fringe even among most antivaxxers, the province of only the hardest of the hardcore, are now being amplified by mainstream pundits with millions of viewers and used by “think tanks” like the Brownstone Institute to stoke fear of vaccines and potential violence against vaccine advocates. That’s always been the purpose of the Nuremberg Code gambit. Unfortunately, today the chance of the Nuremberg Code gambit resulting in actual violence is higher than it’s ever been.

COVID vaccine manufacturers should explore legal action against anti-vaxxers spreading disinformation
Perhaps it’s time for vaccine manufacturers to consider defamation suits against anti-vaxxers who spread false information about COVID vaccines. Lawsuits by voting technology companies against Fox and others over false “rigged” election claims could serve as a template.
Jann Bellamy on May 6, 2021
Link

As has been widely reported in the media, voting technology companies Dominion and Smartmatic have filed multi-billion dollar defamation lawsuits against Fox News and others over false claims that voting machines were “rigged” to help “steal” the 2020 presidential election. Perhaps it’s time for Moderna, Pfizer, and Johnson & Johnson to follow suit, taking legal action against those who spread disinformation about the safety and effectiveness of their vaccines.
An expert quoted in The Washington Post sees in the pending defamation suits the possibility of curbing the spread of misinformation where other methods (like actions taken by social media companies) have proven impotent:
“We are seeing the way that libel has become a real battleground in the fight against disinformation,” said RonNell Andersen Jones, a law professor at the University of Utah. “The threat of massive damages for spreading probably false conspiracy theories on matters of public concern could turn out to be the one tool that is successful in disincentivizing that behavior, where so many other tools seem to have failed.”
Spreading false information about COVID 19, a matter of public concern for sure, is exactly what “super-spreaders” like Joseph Mercola and Ty Bollinger have been doing for over a year. “Disincentivizing” their harmful behavior with legal action targeting their efforts to undermine the public’s confidence in vaccines may be just what the doctor ordered.
With that possibility in mind, we’ll look at how the masterfully-crafted complaints filed by Smartmatic and Dominion could serve as a template for defamation suits brought by vaccine makers against those who endanger the public’s health with their false claims. Although disinformation plagues all vaccine manufacturers, today we’ll focus on COVID vaccines.
The defamation suits
The lawsuits center on alleged falsehoods about the companies’ voting machine technology broadcast by Fox and its news personalities, including Lou Dobbs, Maria Bartiromo, and Jeanine Pirro (and repeated on social media to millions), including false statements made by lawyers Rudy Giuliani, Sidney Powell, and businessman Mike Lindell, in interviews on various Fox programs following the 2020 presidential election. For our purposes here, we’ll concentrate on the complaints’ allegations against Fox.
The tort of defamation is governed by state law, albeit with important First Amendment implications, and can thus vary from state to state. However, generally, the plaintiff must prove that the allegedly defamatory statements were “of and concerning” the plaintiff, that the statements are ones of fact (as opposed to, for example, an opinion) and are provably false, that they damaged the plaintiff’s reputation, and damages. Save a few statements that might be regarded as opinion, Smartmatic and Dominion can likely prevail on these elements.
If the plaintiff is a private figure, whether a person or business entity, they must show only that the statements were negligently made. But, if the plaintiff is a public official or public figure, they must prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that the defendant acted with actual malice or reckless disregard for the truth. The standard is a subjective one: the plaintiff must prove the defendant had actual doubts about the veracity of his statements. This is a high bar:
The “reckless disregard” standard for public-figure plaintiffs is “rarely met,” said [law professor] Andersen Jones. “It is famously difficult to show that someone knowingly lied, although Dominion has marshalled some powerful evidence on this front.”
Both Smartmatic and Dominion have obviously anticipated being deemed “public figures” in drafting their complaints and have included allegations which they believe will meet the actual malice/reckless disregard standard. Other allegations go to show that Fox intended the statements to be understood as factual, not opinion (a defense Sidney Powell has already invoked in her case). Key allegations include:
     1.  Fox and its news personalities repeatedly promoted themselves as providers of factual information and a “trusted” source. They also used Giuliani’s and Powell’s status as lawyers to create the impression they were reliable sources of fact.
     2.  The falsity of their statements was easily verifiable from numerous sources, including state and federal officials and agencies, voting experts, and the plaintiffs themselves, none of whom were interviewed.
     3.  The way Fox claimed the voting machinery operated is inherently implausible and technologically impossible.
     4.  Fox urged viewers and readers to discredit and ignore what they heard from other sources and suppressed facts that would counter its narrative.
     5.  Fox was aware of, but nevertheless violated, generally accepted journalistic standards.
     6.  Fox’s motive was economic: it needed to placate angry viewers who migrated to other media outlets after Fox called Arizona for Joe Biden early on, so it made Dominion and Smartmatic “villains” in the false narrative about a “stolen” election.
Sound familiar?
SBM has extensively covered the firehose of falsehoods about COVID 19 vaccines. Let’s take a look at just a few of these posts, chosen for a particular reason, as you’ll see in a moment.
Just this past Monday, David Gorski, who has done some seriously heavy lifting in shooting down COVID misinformation on all fronts, shredded a scientifically illiterate claim, recycled from the anti-vaxx trope machine, that
“shedding” of spike protein from the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, such as the vaccines produced by Moderna or Pfizer/BioNTech, are making the unvaccinated sick and interfering with women’s menstrual cycles (or even causing miscarriages) . . .
Specifically called out, and rightly so, was anti-vaxx pediatrician Larry Palevsky:
Somebody get Dr. Palevsky a college-level introductory molecular biology textbook! Why? He seems not to know the difference between “genetic instructions”, mRNA, and proteins. He seems to think that an immune response to an mRNA strand coding for a protein will attack the protein itself and any protein that looks like it, thus producing autoimmune disease. Truly, Dr. Palevsky needs a remedial course in basic biology and molecular biology. (Either that, or, again, he’s lying. Take your pick.)
Of course, no anti-vaccine falsehood would be complete without an attempt to pre-empt truthful information from respected experts in the field, and Palevsky doesn’t disappoint, warning us not to listen to scientists who’ve dismissed, as the post describes it, his “incredibly improbable” claims “based on, essentially, everything we know about molecular biology and immunology”.
Also skewered in his recent posts over their scientific malfeasance: Joseph Mercola, Geert Vanden Bossche (aided and abetted by anti-vaccine propagandist Del Bigtree), Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. , J. Bart Classen, and, of course, Natural News, among others.
Scott Gavura wrote a couple of posts on reports from the Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) that, conveniently for our purposes here, synthesize anti-vaccine rhetoric and its sources. First,
The Anti-Vaxx Playbook, that describes in detail how key members of the anti-vaccine movement are collaborating and partnering in new ways to exploit the COVID-19 pandemic, create consistent anti-vaccine messaging, and destroy confidence in vaccination.
Their strategy centers on three anti-vaccine themes:
     1.  COVID-19 is not dangerous. Talking points: There are few deaths, and death reports are exaggerated. “It’s just the flu.” “It will just go away on its own.”
     2.  COVID-19 vaccines are dangerous. Talking points: “The vaccines were rushed.” “The vaccines are killing people.” “Natural” immunity is better. Other treatments (e.g., hydroxychloroquine) are safer and better. “Vaccines are toxic.” “Vaccines will change your DNA/destroy your immune system.” etc. etc.
     3.  Vaccine advocates cannot be trusted. Talking points: “It’s politics over health.” “It’s Big Pharma profits over health.” Vaccines are “too big to fail” and manufacturers are “not liable for injuries.” “Bill Gates! Bill Gates! Bill Gates!”
As described in a second post, another CCDH report outed the “disinformation dozen”, just twelve anti-vaxxers responsible for almost two-thirds of all anti-vaccine content on Facebook and Twitter. They include Joseph Mercola, Sherri Tenpenny, Rashid Buttar, Kelly Brogan, and Christiane Northrup, all of whom are either medical or osteopathic physicians. Another, Ben Tapper, is a chiropractor.
This post referred as well to a third CCDH report, covering anti-vaccination in general, The Anti-Vaccination Industry, which identified four sub-communities of anti-vaxxers, including these two:
    • Campaigners are full-time, anti-vaccine professionals who may be seen as “experts”. They make a living based on promoting anti-vaccine sentiment and ideas. Their examples include: Informed Consent Action Network (Del Bigtree), Children’s Health Defence (Robert F. Kennedy Jr.), and the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC).
    • Entrepreneurs leverage and amplify vaccine fears to sell content, products and services. Examples include Rashid Buttar, Ty and Charlene Bollinger, David Wolfe, Judy Mikovits, and the biggest, Joseph Mercola.
One of the “campaigners” identified is Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who was also honored with a spot among the “disinformation dozen”.
Kennedy’s most important role in the anti-vaccination movement is lending his credibility as an environmental campaigner and son of the Kennedy political dynasty to other key figures by appearing alongside them at events or taking part in interviews.
And with that, folks – a review of a few SBM posts – we’ve just checked off the entire list of key allegations against Fox:
     1.  Anti-vaxxers present themselves as credible “experts”, including the use of their status as healthcare professionals, and therefore purveyors of trusted “factual” information.
     2.  The falsity of their information is easily verifiable, from scientific experts as well as the CDC, FDA, and the vaccine makers themselves, if they’d only bothered to check.
     3.  Anti-vaxxers make scientifically implausible and biologically impossible claims.
     4.  In presenting their anti-vaccination misinformation, they fail to include information that disagrees with what they are saying and try to discredit reliable sources.
     5.  At least some of them are trained in science and the scientific method and should (or do) know better.
     6.  Finally, by choosing anti-vaccination activism as a career or by shilling for the nostrums they sell, or both, they have an economic motive to spread false information.
If we can get here by reviewing a few SBM posts, imagine what a talented defamation lawyer could do with an extensive review of, say, Mercola’s websites, social media posts, books, transcripts of his media appearances, and FDA warning letters.
As with the voting technology suits, proving the falsity of statements made by various anti-vaxxers, or that they damaged the vaccine makers’ reputation, shouldn’t be difficult. And while the defendants might try to fob everything they have said off as “opinion”, that’s unlikely to fly.
Most crucially, as is true of the allegations against Fox, their actions evidence, at the least, a reckless disregard for the truth. And it is here that the anti-vaccine movement goes the “rigged” election crowd one better. Key players like Kennedy have amassed a years-long record of anti-vaccination misinformation. Whole books (also here) have been written on the subject. In fact, as David Gorski has so effectively shown, some of the COVID anti-vaccination disinformation is merely recycled garbage from previous anti-vaccination disinformation efforts. What a perfect means of demonstrating actual malice.
Litigation is costly and time consuming, and there can be good business reasons not to employ it in any matter. Discovery, for one. These companies may not want the defendants getting into their records (although there are guardrails, like protection of trade secrets). And, of course, not every bit of disinformation broadcast by just anyone should be made the subject of a lawsuit. But, given the relentlessness of the anti-vaxxers and the failure of social media companies to stop them, defamation actions, especially against the “disinformation dozen”, could be part of the solution. Even if monetary damages prove not worth the pursuit, the plaintiffs could seek declaratory and injunctive relief, prohibiting the defendants from repeating their misinformation.
Sending the likes of Mercola and Kennedy demands for retraction are a possibility as well, setting out their false statements and explaining why they are false. (For this, they could just cut and paste any number of David Gorski’s posts.) The demands may be ignored, but that is done at the risk of those demands appearing in a complaint as evidence of actual malice – in other words, they kept it up even after being put on notice. (Both Dominion and Smartmatic have set forth corrections they sought from Fox in their complaints.)
After Smartmatic demanded that right wing media outlet Newsmax retract its false and defamatory statements, Newsmax posted a statement renouncing a number of false claims about both companies, acknowledging “no evidence has been offered that Dominion or Smartmatic used software or reprogrammed software that manipulated votes in the 2020 election.” Imagine the satisfaction of hearing similar statements retracting anti-vaccination lies.

Plexus: MLM Strikes Again
Many health-related products are sold through multilevel marketing (MLM); now the FTC is warning them to stop making false claims about COVID-19. The tactics that MLMs use to promote all their products are deceptive and are a variation on the old Ponzi scam.
Harriet Hall on September 15, 2020
Tweet


Multilevel marketing (MLM) companies have a terrible reputation, so bad that Quackwatch devotes a whole section to “MLM Watch“. Now that we are in the midst of a pandemic, MLM schemes have been quick to take advantage of public fears and are offering bogus products alleged to prevent or treat COVID-19. Quackwatch’s Consumer Health Digest reported on September 6, 2020, that Plexus and five other MLM companies have been warned by the FTC about false health and/or income claims related to the coronavirus pandemic. The other companies are Youngevity, Vivry, Melaleuca, Isagenix, and Juice+. More false claims and more FTC warning letters will surely follow.
What does MLM mean?
No, MLM doesn’t stand for “Marketing Lies and Misinformation”, but it might just as well. Is it ever legal? Basically, it’s OK for a company to reward you for selling their products, but if it rewards you for recruiting other people who have to pay you, it’s an ethically and legally questionable version of an old scam, the Ponzi scheme or pyramid scheme. Ponzi schemes are named after Charles Ponzi, a businessman who paid profits to early investors from funds obtained from later investors, telling the early investors that the money they received was earnings from their own investments. It was a system for robbing Peter to pay Paul, and when it collapsed, the Peters lost all the money they had invested. Today, typical MLM Pauls get the Peters to do the recruiting for them. More and more Peters recruit yet more Peters in order to get a portion of the commissions earned by the Peters below them in the pyramid. Eventually, the Pauls at the top of the pyramid get rich, while the Peters further down the pyramid lose money.
How it works
The company offers an overpriced, difficult-to-sell product, often a dietary supplement, with grandiose claims that it is the best of its kind and will help customers lose weight or provide other health benefits. Think about it. If they had a good, reasonably priced product, why would they resort to MLM schemes? Reputable products can be (and are) sold profitably in stores everywhere.
A trusted friend or relative persuades you individually or invites you to a group presentation in their home, sort of like a Tupperware party on steroids. They offer amazing testimonials, offer to sell you products, and tell you that you can become a distributor too and earn lots of money effortlessly from home. You will start earning royalty payments after you buy a large inventory of their products (which you soon discover you are unable to sell), but the real money comes as you recruit other distributors and get a percentage of their commissions and get your recruits to recruit even more distributors. If you recruit a large enough stable of distributors, you theoretically might make a lot of money, but the reality is that the vast majority of recruits lose money. Only a few individuals at the top of the pyramids actually benefit. And there is a high social price, as friends and family realize they have been defrauded. Early enthusiasm deteriorates into disillusion, disappointment, customer complaints, and often regulatory actions and lawsuits against the company. Remember Amway, Herbalife, Young Living, and DoTerra. Episode 1 of the (Un)Well documentary series that I reviewed in August covered two disreputable MLMs that sell essential oils.
The FTC’s warning letters remind companies of three pertinent laws:
     1.  It is unlawful to make unsupported claims of product efficacy
It is unlawful under the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 41 et seq., to advertise that a product can prevent, treat, or cure human disease unless you possess competent and reliable scientific evidence, including, when appropriate, well-controlled human clinical studies, substantiating that the claims are true at the time they are made.
     2.  It is unlawful to misrepresent earnings claims
…representations about a business opportunity, including earnings claims, violate Section 5 of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 41 et seq., if they are false, misleading, or unsubstantiated and material to consumers. Express and implied earnings claims must be truthful and non-misleading to avoid being deceptive, which means that claims about the potential to achieve a wealthy lifestyle, career-level income, or significant income are false or misleading if business opportunity participants generally do not achieve such results. Even truthful testimonials from participants who do earn significant income or more will likely be misleading unless the advertising also makes clear the amount earned or lost by most participants. Your business opportunity participants and representatives must immediately cease making all express and implied earnings claims that would be false or misleading to current or prospective participants.
     3.  MLM companies are responsible for what its representatives say
You are responsible for the claims of your business opportunity participants and representatives. As the FTC stated in the January 2019 Business Guidance Concerning Multi- Level Marketing, the compensation structure of a Multi-Level Marketing entity (“MLM”) may create incentives for its participants to make certain representations to current or prospective participants. As a consequence, an MLM should (i) direct its participants not to make false, misleading, or unsubstantiated representations and (ii) monitor its participants so they don’t make false, misleading, or unsubstantiated representations.
Warning letters to Plexus failed to lead to corrective action
     3.  On June 5, 2020, the FTC sent Plexus a warning letter saying that the company and its representative had published false claims on social media alleging that their products could prevent or treat COVID-19. They gave specific examples and asked the company to review the claims, to stop making claims that weren’t supported by evidence, and to respond within 48 hours describing the actions they had taken to address the FTC’s concerns.
Truth in Advertising found that after the June 5 letter, Plexus distributors continued to make unsubstantiated claims that the “Kids Essentials Combo” (comprised of MegaKids Microbiome and XFactor Kids), would help:
        ◦ boost children’s’ immune systems
        ◦ possibly keep them virus free
        ◦ a host of health conditions that affect children including asthma, eczema, ADHD, GI issues
Earlier violations
     3.  Before the current pandemic focused attention on coronavirus claims, Plexus had received earlier warnings about its products. An FTC warning letter in 2014 mentioned specific claims on their website that promoted their products as drugs, in violation of FDA regulations for dietary supplements. The products targeted were Fast Relief, Probio5, and Biocleanse. For example, Probio5 was said to typically provide results for jock itch, migraine headaches, recurrent cystitis, and vaginal infections. And Biocleanse claimed that many people were in a low oxygen state that allowed microbes to thrive and cause diseases such as flu, Candida, and chronic fatigue; Biocleanse was said to kill these microbes by increasing the oxygen level around them.
These claims meant the products were new drugs that were misbranded. And:
The introduction of a misbranded drug into interstate commerce is a violation of section 301(a) of the Act [21 U.S.C. § 331(a)].
Those claims have been removed from the website. The company website no longer makes specific disease claims but only “support and function” claims, which are allowed under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA). But Plexus distributors have continued to make disease claims in person and on social media, and the company has done nothing to stop them.
Conclusion: A typical MLM company, not trustworthy
     3.  Plexus is typical of so many other MLM companies that defraud their distributors with false promises of easy income and allow distributors to make claims for their products that the company itself can’t legally make, claims that are not supported by acceptable evidence. Legitimate products don’t need to resort to MLM schemes to make profits.
Stephen Barrett has investigated over 150 MLM companies with health-related products. He says:
Every MLM company I have looked at has made false or deceptive claims in its promotional materials. The products that have nutritional value (such as multivitamins and low-cholesterol foods) are invariably overpriced and usually not needed. The products promoted as remedies are either bogus, unproven, or intended for conditions that are unsuitable for self-medication. In addition, none of companies I investigated gave a really clear picture of how difficult it is to earn money selling health-related MLM products…distributors must persuade prospective customers that their product is superior even though it is not and may even be identical to competing products that cost less. This requires misrepresentation.
The National Council Against Health Fraud recommends that consumers avoid health-related MLM products altogether. I think that’s excellent advice.

Voices in the Vacuum
The failure of the White House COVID-19 Response Coordinator to, well, coordinate a response to COVID-19 misinformation has left physicians to fight the uphill battle on their own.
Natalia Solenkova on May 30, 2023
Link

What we have seen is the widespread propagation of misinformation and disinformation. And the reason it has taken root is because there was an information vacuum. I come back to our role as physicians. It is critical that we fill that vacuum because if we don’t, others will.
–Ashish Jha, March 31, 2023
This quote is absolutely infuriating and saddening in 2023, especially coming from Dr. Ashish Jha. While I am glad that one of the country’s top public health officials finally recognizes the deadly role of medical disinformation, why did it take so long, especially after the former director of NIH Dr. Francis Collins repeatedly expressed his regrets about the delayed recognition of this problem? As a critical care physician who spent over three years fighting COVID-19 in intensive care units nationwide and combating disinformation, I have acquired experience in both fields. I would like to share some thoughts about the latter here.
Dr. Jha is correct that an information vacuum existed at the pandemic’s start. He is also right that this vacuum created opportunities for those who peddle falsehoods. However, it is so disheartening for him to blame physicians for not doing enough to fill up this information vacuum. Especially since so many honest and truthful physicians did speak up despite several institutions and workplaces actively discouraging discussing the pandemic publicly. Institutions were unwilling to support their physicians and often capitulated to demands for retribution driven by contrarian anti-vaccine influencers. It is hard not to ask back: “But what have you done to organize the fight against disinformation and anti-science?” Sadly, I think I know the answer.
On the front lines
Working in many intensive care units across America, I witnessed firsthand the effects of false information on patients and society. I clearly remember the video Plandemic playing in the background as I worked in the New York ICU during the spring of 2020. I can vividly recall a nurse spreading misinformation about Elmhurst Hospital in New York, hydroxychloroquine, remdesivir, ivermectin, zinc, quercetin, confused and angry patients and families refusing some treatments and demanding the others, masks, lockdowns, and, of course, vaccines. Each stage of the disinformation campaign directly affected my daily practice, making it extremely difficult to care for patients.
Despite the urgent need, no government effort or leadership was directly dedicated to combating the disinformation movement. The results of the 2020 election would provide us, frontline healthcare workers, with a false hope that having reasonable leadership in 2021 would give us a much-needed reprieve from COVID and disinformation. Unfortunately, the opposite happened. Disinformation became even more rampant as the new anti-vaxx movement merged with older anti-vaccine activity and other fringe movements like white supremacist groups and the newer QAnon movement. Utilizing existing fringe networks, shadowy funds, and psychological warfare techniques, anti-vaxx individuals acquired a substantial following from the general population. This left individual physicians responsible for starting their own campaigns against disinformation and the much larger forces fronting the anti-science narrative.
Having no financial help, media connections, legal protection, or guidance on how to fight disinformation effectively, we did what we thought could work. We were vocal on social media; we ran Spaces on Twitter or rooms on Clubhouse; we published op-eds, substacks, or other articles; we organized non-profit grassroots organizations; and we constantly reached out to leaders of various medical organizations, politicians, and journalists hoping to build a force aiming to combat disinformation. We received hate messages, online and real-life harassment, and death threats. In doing these activities, we risked our jobs and careers due to various social media and media policies, personal and professional relationships, and personal and family safety.
Tales from the trenches
What follows are just a few stories of individual physicians trying to fill the information vacuum and combat the anti-science movement that seems to have gone unnoticed by Dr. Jha until 2023!
One of the most prominent frontline voices and anti-disinformation advocates, Dr. Cleavon Gilman, an ER physician, was vocal on social media from the beginning of the pandemic, sharing experiences from ERs in NYC and Arizona. He created several pages dedicated to people who died from COVID-19 and gave multiple interviews about the reality of the front lines. He once said:
I saw that misinformation was being spread about this virus and that people were dying as a result. I can sleep at night knowing that I did everything that I could to warn people in America about this. I went home and I wrote about it, and I’m on Twitter. So I’ve done everything I could.
At some point, Dr. Gilman had over 170K followers on Twitter, and the number was rapidly increasing. However, he initially suffered retaliation from his hospital for being vocal about his frontline experience and then received so much harassment that he eventually left social media altogether.
Dr. Nick Sawyer, an ER physician, became one of the critical anti-disinformation voices of the pandemic. Working in ERs in California and NYC, he was shocked to see medical professionals spreading disinformation that contradicted everything he saw with his own eyes and was supported by scientific evidence. His experience compelled him to form the non-profit organization, “No License For Disinformation,” aiming to make disinformation healthcare professionals accountable for the harm they caused. Dr. Sawyer called, not once but many times, for organized efforts to combat misinformation. He personally approached leaders of various state and national medical organizations and associations, encouraging actions against the disinformation spreaders. He told ABC News:
Disinformation is needlessly killing Americans. And the people who have the authority to stop just information, whether it be the social media platforms, legislators, the medical boards, need to step up and protect the public from this dangerous, conspiratorial information that’s being pushed out in a massively coordinated way.
However, due to hate, harassment, and threats, Dr. Sawyer left social media and dismantled the organization.
Years before the COVID-19 pandemic, Dr. David Gorski, Professor of Surgery and Oncology, started debunking medical disinformation and anti-science. As a founding blogger and later managing editor of Science-based Medicine, Dr. Gorski has been publishing scientific essays exposing the anti-vaccine movement and other pseudo-scientific quackery for more than 15 years. During the COVID-19 pandemic, he and other SBM contributors, including Dr. Jonathan Howard, published many articles debunking fraudulent and incorrectly done studies and constantly exposing new COVID-related conspiracies. Being in the field of countering disinformation for the longest time, Dr. Gorski has suffered from harassment and hate attacks also for the longest:
I’ve had orchestrated campaigns against me, just for my blog work. For instance, as early as 2010, when I rarely used Twitter. A bunch of anti-vaccine activists tried to get me fired from my university; emailing and calling the board of governors about a bogus non-existent conflict of interest that they thought they found against me.
Dr. Allison Neitzel, a physician-researcher, became interested in studying the roots of medical disinformation and its connection with political agendas after she suffered from a complicated relationship with her mother, a physician radicalized by disinformation. Personal experience and trauma motivated Dr. Neitzel to create “Misinformation Kills“, a non-profit organization that exposes political and financial forces orchestrating medical disinformation. Dr. Neitzel started her anti-disinformation activity in 2021 with an open letter to NFL quarterback Aaron Rodgers calling him out for sharing misinformation about the COVID vaccine. Almost immediately after publishing the letter, Dr. Neitzel received death threats and other forms of harassment. Since her research on the roots of disinformation is ongoing and she posts frequently, various forms of hate continue to go her way regularly.
Dr. Michael Patmas, an internal medicine physician, medical director of utilization management and referral relationships, and a life-long vaccine advocate, reported Robert Malone to Maryland Medical Board for vaccine disinformation. As a result, Dr. Patmas received various forms of online and personal harassment and threats; his personal information was disclosed at one of Joe Rogan’s shows, which exacerbated the level of harassment and retaliation against him. Dr. Patmas described the consequences of his experience in the following way:
Retaliation for a complaint – if that’s allowed to stand, then other physicians are going to be reluctant to hold one another accountable. If doctors who do that get their heads cut off, well, you’re going to let doctors get away with bad things. It’s unethical, and it’s morally wrong.
Most recently, under FOIA, Dr. Jonathan Laxton, an internal medicine physician, requested and received earlier versions of the Florida anti-vaccine study. Analysis of the received versions showed that the study was altered by Florida’s Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, a former member of America’s Frontline Doctors group, and this alteration significantly impacted the interpretation of the results. Dr. Laxton is constantly receiving death threats and cyber harassment, which include mentions of Nuremberg 2.0 trials or pictures of the gallows.
The anti-disinformation fight did not spare me. A deep fake tweet was published under my name early this year, which was widely shared by prominent right-wing supporters, including journalists, lawyers, and politicians. The tweet eventually made it to Joe Rogan’s show, where he and Bret Weinstein discussed it for 11 minutes. After this much publicity, I received a massive amount of hate messages, hate reviews, threats, and tags to my licensing, certifying, and employing organizations. It made me seriously rethink whether I should continue the anti-disinformation work.
Having my personal experience and watching the experiences of other doctors, I cannot imagine the amount of hate that goes to Dr. Peter Hotez, an American scientist, pediatrician, and advocate in the fields of global health and vaccinology, since he is one of the most vocal and most publicly known anti-disinformation doctors. And I am infinitely thankful to Dr. Hotez that he continues to speak up and bring the voice of science to TV, social media, and his academic talks in universities and specialty societies.
Continuing the fight
While some physicians left the field of anti-disinformation and anti-science work completely, others, including myself, continue this fight. A fantastic group of scientists and physicians run Twitter Spaces and YouTube streams debunking poorly done research studies and explaining science and medicine to the general public. This year three books debunking disinformation are being published. The book We Want Them Infected by Dr. Jonathan Howard was recently released, and the books The Deadly Rise of Anti-science by Dr. Peter Hotez and Misinformation Kills by Dr. Allison Neitzel will be published later this year. An international group of anti-disinformation research enthusiasts investigates disinformation actors, their networks, funds, and political affiliations. Several grassroots organizations run projects combating COVID-related disinformation. A new organization, American Information Integrity Alliance, is being built with a broader view of the information space in general, medicine, and public health in particular. We hope to unite physicians and scientists to strategize and develop an effective plan to clean up the current polluted information space.
However, these initiatives are totally voluntary and should not be taken for granted. At some point, even the strongest and most resilient of us may say that this is enough — enough to spend personal time for anti-disinformation activities, sufficient to take time away from families, enough to carry the emotional burden of the fight while feeling helpless and hopeless, enough to deal with various threats, to adequately worry about personal and family safety, enough to deal with legal and administrative issues, enough to debunk the same conspiracies over and over again without public health or academic leadership speaking about them even once.
For example, in the last several days, the conspiracy of ventilators killing many patients in ICUs during the early pandemic was again revived on social media. Many physicians, including Drs. Craig Spencer, Jonathan Laxton, Eric Burnett, Jonathan Howard, and others, debunked this ventilator conspiracy in the past and did it again now. All are currently being threatened and harassed. The current situation is even more disturbing because the ventilator conspiracy was revived by a third-year medical student.
We need to talk about Kevin
Two years before completing medical school, the third-year medical student Kevin Bass became vocal on Twitter and began criticizing experts in different areas of medicine while being approved and encouraged by disinformation spreaders. Sadly, the unethical behavior of this medical student remains “invisible” to his medical school leadership, and Kevin continues to promote non-evidence-based treatments, disinform the public about the results of COVID-related studies, undermine the expertise of the public health and medicine leaders, and further damage the public trust in doctors and medicine in America.
The blindness of Kevin’s medical school fits the general pattern of academic institutions when it comes to their response to disinformation. Thus, top academic institutions blatantly ignore when their physicians and researchers are involved in unethical activities as long as they satisfy the publication and other metrics and bring funds and publicity to institutions. This is probably why some of the top disinformation spreaders, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and Dr. Vinay Prasad, are not only holding faculty positions at Stanford and UCSF but the latter was promoted during the pandemic.
Academic institutions are not the only ones that failed to join the fight against anti-science. Unfortunately, state and national specialty organizations and medical associations demonstrated inadequate responses to medical disinformation. Rare educational print-outs, press releases, and articles published on organizations’ websites do not reach the general public and therefore fail to become practical tools for fighting medical conspiracies. Adopted anti-disinformation policies are a significant starting point but are toothless if no follow-up action exists. Recently, fifty national organizations announced the formation of the Coalition for Trust in Health & Science, aiming to combat medical disinformation. However, the fruits of this initiative, if any, are yet to be seen.
Celebrity doctors who took every opportunity to be on media platforms during the early pandemic, with little-to-no idea about the realities of the COVID front lines, suddenly became silent about medical disinformation. Journalists have not been consistent in the fight against medical disinformation. They occasionally partner with anti-disinformation doctors and publish some pro-science content; however, the outreach of these rare articles is not comparable to social media and media outreach used by conspiracy spreaders. Politicians either don’t see medical disinformation as worth their time or become prominent promoters of anti-science like Robert Kennedy Jr., who is now running for the highest political office in the country.
Whatever happened to Dr. Jha?
Dr. Jha was somewhat vocal about the danger of medical disinformation before becoming the White House Covid-19 response coordinator. Thus, in 2021 he said:
We have to find ways of reaching out to people who live outside our information ecosystem and engaging them. I think combatting misinformation is the biggest challenge of our time.
He also seemed to understand the necessity of special training for the next generation of doctors and public-health figures in the peculiarities of modern information space and new ways to foster effective communication:
So I have come to believe that the next generation of public-health figures all absolutely have to be trained in these things, have to engage in these things. Otherwise, we leave this new medium completely wide open to one group of people who are very, very good at exploiting it and using it for nefarious purposes. You just can’t walk out of the battlefield. This is the battlefield of information now. And you know, hearts and minds of the public are won by it.
However, as the White House COVID-19 response coordinator, he became much less vocal about disinformation and eventually ceased almost all activity in this area. He addressed “journalists and people who own platforms” and asked them to be responsible for the content they produce:
For journalists and for people who own platforms, what I would say is you should be thinking about what your personal responsibility is, and do you want to be a source of misinformation and disinformation? That’s up to those individuals.
The next time Dr. Jha’s speech about disinformation got widely shared in news media was in April 2023, when he called out physicians for not doing enough to fill the information vacuum.
Dr. Jha’s title in the White House COVID-19 response team is Coordinator. I believe that coordination of response to COVID-related disinformation falls into the direct responsibilities of the WH COVID-19 Response Coordinator. Calling individual physicians to step up and fill the vacuum is not what coordinated effort should look like. It is shifting responsibility from self to others.
It would be great to have the WH COVID-19 response Coordinator:
    • Create physician’s training in infodemiology and effective communications, considering the power of social media in influencing the beliefs of the general public.
    • Organize state and national media campaigns promoting science and medical knowledge.
    • Publish regular articles accessible to the general public addressing medical conspiracies.
    • Organize town halls for the general public where people can ask questions and be heard.
    • Organize advocacy efforts reaching out politicians.
    • Build a risk management strategy in case doctors involved start experiencing legal or administrative problems as a result of anti-disinformation work.
And so much more.
However, instead of doing any of these activities, Dr. Jha called physicians to do what he failed or got too scared to do. While mentioning threats to himself and Dr. Walensky — two top national public health officials with resources incomparable to any individual doctor in terms of safety and security — he didn’t offer any action plan or guidance to physicians in case they end up with legal or administrative problems with licensing or certifying bodies or hospital credentialing, or in case they start receiving hate messages, other forms of online harassment including negative reviews on the doctor rating sites, and threats including death threats.
As a person who experienced hatred himself, Dr. Jha should be concerned about physicians’ safety because we know that the anti-science crowd may come with actions because they have done this before by stalking people and sending drones. He also should be concerned about the emotional ability of physicians to handle such an amount of hatred because we also know that already burned out and morally injured people need only one last straw to cause irreparable consequences, and harassment by the anti-science crowd can be that last straw. Dr. Jha should be concerned about all this, but unfortunately, he isn’t.

The Pandemic As Spectacle
Though calls for “debates” are made by unserious people, unserious people can do serious damage when they are willing to spread disinformation about vaccines, all because a doctor with principles isn’t willing to play his part in their absurd theater.
Jonathan HowardonJune 18, 2023
Link

In the email below, Dr. Francis Collins, then the director of the NIH, described the signers of the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) as “fringe epidemiologists” simply because they proposed to tame COVID in 3-6 months by spreading SARS-CoV-2. As humanity had never previously controlled a virus by spreading that virus, Dr. Collins proposed a “quick and devastating published take down of its premises.” Dr. Collins disagreed with the simultaneous mass infection of hundreds of millions of unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans with a new, mutating virus and considered writing a thorough rebuttal of the premises of the GBD.
The horror.
When this email emerged a year later via a FOIA request, it caused quite a stir, especially considering the GBD was simply a one-page statement written under the watchful eye of a man who has ties to overly racist organizations and supports child labor and child smoking. Moreover, the authors of the GBD were already very famous and influential. They met with President Trump in August 2020, and he later echoed their talking point about “protecting the vulnerable”. The day after the GBD was signed, its authors met with Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, and they would later advise Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. They’ve made countless YouTube videos, written numerous editorials, and have enormous social media presences. They’ve become ubiquitous pandemic celebrities. They been everywhere, except a hospital.
Despite this, the GBD authors are livid they’ve not been given enough stages to perform upon.
They’ve been on far-reaching podcasts claiming they’ve been “censored”. They’ve said the same thing on national TV programs. They’ve written editorials in international newspapers claiming they’ve been “muzzled.” They lament attempts to “censor and silence scientists” to their hundreds of thousands of Twitter followers. They even opened an Academy for Science and Freedom at Hillsdale College to counter “the silencing and censoring of scientists“. Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, who never treated a COVID patient, took great umbrage at being called “fringe” in a private email, making a whole YouTube video to share his pain. He even said there mere proposal of a written criticism of his premises was a “propaganda attack”. He said:
So now I know what it feels like to be the subject of a propaganda attack by my own government. Discussion and engagement would have been a better path.
The Wall Street Journal wrote an article titled “How Fauci and Collins Shut Down Covid Debate,” which argued that top government health officials should either praise the premises of the GBD or extend a megaphone to its authors. They felt a written critique of the premises of the GBD was utterly inappropriate. Dr. Vinay Prasad agreed that the written exchanges of ideas amongst scientists was unprofessional. He too wanted a public production. In an article titled “At a Time When the U.S. Needed Covid-19 Dialogue Between Scientists, Francis Collins Moved to Shut it Down,” he said:
Collins’s response to a memo signed by thousands of scientists should not have been to call for an immediate and devastating take down, but to use his pulpit as NIH director to hold a series of public discussions and dialogues. In a world where scientists were trapped in their own homes for months, a series of dialogues — even virtual ones — made available for the broader scientific community, policy makers, and the public would have benefited us all.
This all strikes me as very odd. Had I gotten together with a few of my buddies and written a short letter, I wouldn’t presume I was then owed a series of “public discussions and dialogues” with anyone, especially top public health officials. Further, I wouldn’t claim to be a victim of a “propaganda attack” if someone proposed a written a critique of the premises of our letter. I wouldn’t have a meltdown if someone called me “fringe”.
However, the GBD was much more than just a few sheltered doctors who got together to talk shop. They wrote a Declaration you see, and there were journalists and a camera crew ready to capture whole affair. The two-hour video that resulted has been watched 163,000 times on YouTube. The GBD was a spectacle above all else, and many people felt Dr. Collins had no right to deprive the public of more entertainment. (Dr. David Gorksi has written previously on why such “debates”, which reward linguist virtuosity not scientific acumen, are generally a bad idea.)
And that’s what the pandemic has become for the commentariat class. A public performance. Reality TV. A play, where actors must perform their assigned role. Social media has so warped some people that they can’t conceive of reality outside of it. I previously wrote how my critics no longer even pretend to engage in discussions on science and data. Instead, they just pander to their followers via yet another juvenile Twitter dunk.
This sad state of affairs was made clear during a Twitter exchange between vaccine-developer Dr. Peter Hotez, Elon Musk, and “heterodox” podcaster Joe Rogan, who recently gave a platform to anti-vaccine uber-crank Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
Dr: Peter Hotez:
Spotify Has Stopped Even Sort of Trying to Stem Joe Rogan’s Vaccine Misinformation. It’s really true ⁦@annamerlan⁩ just awful. And from all the online attacks I’m receiving after this absurd podcast, it’s clear many actually believe this nonsense.
Joe Rogan:
Peter, if you claim what RFKjr is saying is “misinformation” I am offering you $100,000.00 to the charity of your choice if you’re willing to debate him on my show with no time limit.
Dr. Peter Hotez
Joe, you have my cell, my email, I’m always willing to speak with you
Joe Rogan:
This is a non answer. I challenged you publicly because you publicly quote tweeted and agreed with that dogshit vice article. If you’re really serious about what you stand for, you now have a massive opportunity for a debate that will reach the largest audience a discussion like this has ever had. If you think someone else is better qualified, suggest that person.
Elon Musk: 
He’s afraid of public debate, because he knows he’s wrong.
Let’s be clear about what happened here. As with reactions to Dr. Collins’ email, Rogan and Musk told Dr. Hotez in effect, “Vaccines are dangerous unless you show up and perform for me on demand. The people demand a show.” And that’s what endless calls for “debates” fundamentally are. The “debate me bros” are so completely divorced from the consequences of their words, they fail to see science as anything except as a verbal beauty pageant, even when children’s lives are a stake. Rogan could have simply invited Dr. Hotez on his program to discuss vaccines, but that wouldn’t have been good theater, which is all he cares about.
Unlike Dr. Hotez, Rogan and most of his “free-thinking” fans have no skin-in-the-game. They’ve experienced the pandemic exclusively on Twitter or in the podcast booth. They’ve never treated a sick child, and they never will. For them, a deadly virus is just something to “debate”, another way to entertain the masses, even if they must debase themselves by giving a microphone to a man like RFK, Jr. who lies as naturally as he breathes (watch this). 
Though calls for “debates” are made by unserious people, unserious people can do serious damage when they are willing to spread disinformation about vaccines- all because a doctor with principles is wise enough not to play his part in their absurd theater, even if that means he’ll be stalked at home by anti-vaxxers.

Audience Capture: When COVID Influencers Follow Their Followers
Young doctors take heed. Be careful not to develop a brand and cultivate followers you must continually impress. Because instead of leading your followers, you might become their follower.
Jonathan Howard on October 21, 2022
Link
Oddly, I’ll never forget the moment I learned about the anti-vaccine movement. It was right after Andrew Wakefield unleashed his fraud on the world and right before I went to medical school when a friend told me that vaccines cause autism. I’d scarcely given vaccines a moment’s thought before, but I was skeptical of this claim. During medical school and residency, I thought about vaccines only occasionally. They didn’t come up too often in the day-to-day care of patients with neurological or psychiatric illness.
However, I became fascinated by the anti-vaccine movement shortly after residency when a doctor I trained with, Dr. Kelly Brogan, morphed into one of the country’s most outspoken anti-vaccine doctors. I’ve been closely following the anti-vaccine movement ever since. My primary interest wasn’t in vaccines per se, but rather the cognitive flaws and logical fallacies that led smart people to reject medicine’s greatest achievement. I never felt that vaccine-preventable diseases were too much of a threat to my children – they and those around them have been vaccinated – but rather I feared the science-denial and conspiracies that underlined the anti-vaccine movement. As I said before the pandemic,
The biggest danger to my kids isn’t the measles, but the thought process that leads people to reject the vaccine in the first place.
Over the ensuing decade, I observed something interesting about the anti-vaccine movement. When I first encountered it, anti-vaccine influencers could gain attention by claiming vaccines caused autism. That was once cool and edgy. After a few years, however, this bogus claim was merely the price of entry into Anti-Vaxx World. Since there was nothing to be gained by merely saying vaccines caused autism, in order to gain attention, anti-vaccine influencers like Dr. Brogan were forced to blame vaccines for all manners of maladies, such as the “epidemic” of SIDS (even though SIDS rates have decreased markedly). Other anti-vaccine doctors compared vaccines to rape, and RFK Jr. compared vaccinations to the Holocaust. Attacking pediatricians became commonplace.
Meanwhile, vaccine-preventable diseases were spoken of in glowing terms. In her essay, “Vaccination: Your Body. Your Baby. Their Flu” Dr. Brogan said:
This better way embraces periodic sickness as part of comprehensive wellness. The only way to truly protect ourselves and our infants is through natural immunity bolstered by wild-type exposure in the community. Once you have a particular flu strain, when it comes around again, you will be uniquely protected, and you will pass on this protection to your newborn. There is no replacement for this.
Simply saying vaccines cause autism just doesn’t cut it for anti-vaccine influencer in 2022 the way it did in 2000. In order to get continue to get clicks and customers, anti-vaccine doctors had to continually escalate their rhetoric and above all, never stop being controversial.
This is not to say that people like Dr. Brogan are insincere in her beliefs. However, while she may be a leader of the anti-vaccine movement, she’s also a follower of her followers. They won’t let her say certain things. For example, in 2020, a study of nearly 1.7 million women found the HPV vaccine’s efficacy was especially high if girls were vaccinated before the age of 17, which led to an almost 90% drop in cervical cancer over the 11 years of the study.
There’s no way Dr. Brogan could even contemplate sharing this information with her followers. There are many obvious truths she cannot share without destroying her brand. She’s trapped, and it’s sad that she put herself in this position.
As Dr. David Gorski said, everything old is new again. Everything that happened before the pandemic regarding vaccines is repeating itself. Sometime last year, I noticed a similar escalation amongst the contrarian doctors I’ve discussed here previously. Doctors who had superficially valid concerns about vaccinating children against COVID in early 2021 are now overtly anti-vaccine for children. A doctor who once said semi-positive things about the pediatric COVID vaccine – “No one arguing against first dose” – is today calling for the dissolution of the American Academy of Pediatrics.
Many doctors have seen their audience grow substantially over the pandemic. They’ve been on podcasts and have made a large number of YouTube videos. Some write for Substack, a nice source of revenue. Others have access to influential politicians. Most have large social media presences, where their followers extol their courage and independence. In order to get continue to get clicks, attention, and occasionally customers, they had to escalate their rhetoric. It’s all very familiar.
Yet, contrarian doctors too are trapped. Like Dr. Brogan, there’s information about vaccines they simply cannot share. Nearly 20,000 children were involved in the pediatric randomized-controlled trials of the COVID vaccines, which have since shown to be very effective in limiting severe disease in children. For example, a recent article from The New England Journal of Medicine titled “Effects of Vaccination and Previous Infection on Omicron Infections in Children” reported that nearly all hospitalized children were unvaccinated as were all 7 children who died. There are now many such studies.
Table 1: Studies of the pediatric COVID vaccine. Some doctors cannot share them.
Olson	In hospitalized adolescents, “179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.”
Delahoy	“Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents.”
Wanga	“Among 272 vaccine-eligible (aged 12–17 years) patients hospitalized for COVID-19, one was fully vaccinated.”
Lutrick	Vaccine effectiveness “…was 92% against SARS-CoV-2 infections irrespective of symptom status.”
Zambrano	“Among critically ill MIS-C case-patients requiring life support, all were unvaccinated…97/102 children with MIS-C were unvaccinated. None of the 5 vaccinated MIS-C patients required respiratory or cardiovascular life support (invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or ECMO) compared to 38/97 unvaccinated MIS-C patients.”
Levy	“In 33 adolescents with MIS-C eligible for vaccination…0 had been fully vaccinated, 7 had received 1 dose.”
Olson	“Of the case patients, 180 (40%) were admitted to the ICU, and 127 (29%) required life support; only 2 patients in the ICU had been fully vaccinated. The overall effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine against hospitalization for Covid-19 was 94%. The effectiveness was 98% against ICU admission and 98% against Covid-19 resulting in the receipt of life support. All 7 deaths occurred in patients who were unvaccinated.”
Nygaard	“We identified 51 MIS-C cases among unvaccinated individuals and one in a fully vaccinated adolescent.”
Chang	“Reports of MIS-C after COVID-19 vaccination occurred in only 1 per million individuals aged 12–20 years who received one or more doses of a COVID-19 vaccine.”
Fleming-Dutra	Estimated booster dose effectiveness in adolescents 2 to 6.5 weeks after the booster was 71.1%.
Yousaf	“The overall reporting rate for MIS-C after vaccination 1·0 case per million individuals receiving one or more doses in this age group.”
Tan	Vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization was 83% in children ages 5-11.
Marks	“A higher proportion of unvaccinated adolescents (70.3%) than fully vaccinated adolescents (40.8%) had COVID-19 as a primary reason for admission. A significantly higher proportion of unvaccinated adolescents were admitted to the ICU (30.3%) than were those who were vaccinated (15.5%).”
Price	Vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization was 68% in children ages 5-11
Lin	Vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization was 88% in children ages 5-11, though this waned to 76% after several months. 7 children died, all unvaccinated.
Messiah	“Additional increased risk for persistent COVID symptoms >12 weeks included severe symptoms with initial infection, not being vaccinated and having unhealthy weight”
Cohen-Stavi	This observational study of effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine among children 5 to 11 years of age showed a vaccine effectiveness of 51% against documented SARS-CoV-2 infection and 48% against symptomatic Covid-19 at 7 to 21 days after the second dose.
Klein	Overall, 2-dose vaccine-effectiveness against COVID-19–associated hospitalization was 73%–94%.
Shi	During the period of Omicron predominance (December 19, 2021–February 28, 2022), COVID-19–associated hospitalization rates in children aged 5–11 years were approximately twice as high among unvaccinated as among vaccinated children. Non-Hispanic Black children represented the largest group of unvaccinated children. Thirty percent of hospitalized children had no underlying medical conditions, and 19% were admitted to an intensive care unit.
Like Dr. Brogan, some contrarian doctors literally cannot share these studies. It would be too off-brand and their followers would abandon them. These studies cast the vaccine in an accurate, positive light. Think about how sad it is that some doctors have put themselves in this position. I have no trouble sharing information on vaccine-myocarditis. However, were these doctors to tell their audience something unexpected, advising them to vaccinate their children against COVID, for example, they’d shatter their carefully curated reputation. They’d be alone.
I recently learned the term for this phenomenon: audience capture, which is defined as “…a self-reinforcing feedback loop that involves telling one’s audience what they want to hear and getting rewarded for it”. In a fascinating article, titled “The Perils of Audience Capture How Influencers Become Brainwashed by Their Audiences“, Gurwinder Bhogal warned of its perils:
Audience capture is an irresistible force in the world of influencing, because it’s not just a conscious process but also an unconscious one… It involves the gradual and unwitting replacement of a person’s identity with one custom-made for the audience.[…]When influencers are analyzing audience feedback, they often find that their more outlandish behavior receives the most attention and approval, which leads them to recalibrate their personalities according to far more extreme social cues than those they’d receive in real life. In doing this they exaggerate the more idiosyncratic facets of their personalities, becoming crude caricatures of themselves.
The caricature quickly becomes the influencer’s distinct brand, and all subsequent attempts by the influencer to remain on-brand and fulfill audience expectations require them to act like the caricature. As the caricature becomes more familiar than the person, both to the audience and to the influencer, it comes to be regarded by both as the only honest expression of the influencer, so that any deviation from it soon looks and feels inauthentic. At that point the persona has eclipsed the person, and the audience has captured the influencer.
I think this perfectly describes what I’ve observed before the pandemic with anti-vaxxers like Dr. Brogan and during the pandemic with contrarian doctors, several of whom I once admired as defenders of evidence-based medicine. However, they’ve since become trapped by their followers. After 2.5 years of minimizing COVID and discouraging pediatric vaccination, they’ve cornered themselves into positions they knew to be quackery prior to the pandemic. Echoing Dr. Brogan and anti-vaccine tropes about measles and HPV, they write pro-virus articles titled “The Triumph of Natural Immunity” and argue that it’s “natural and healthy” when children get sick with COVID.
Their social media followers are – slightly – worse. Last week one doctor claimed on Twitter that the new boosters had been only tested in 8 mice, though results of a study from 900 volunteers were released in a company press release the next day. Here are some sample comments from his Twitter thread:
    • CRIMINAL
    • Scott Gottlieb owns 200,000 shares of Pfizer. When Pfizer hits $64 share he will become a billionaire. Trust science
    • Do pediatricians not care? What’s going on here?
    • Of course. #TheScience dictates someone somewhere needs a new summer home. Trust the Science.
    • It’s DANGEROUS !
    • The AAP is pro vaccine and “gender affirming” surgery. Whatever makes them more money is what they support.
    • Clinical trial data that can be cherry picked before presenting to the FDA board is hardly valuable at all. Its not really a secret, but just not well known. SciAm did an article about this problem a decade ago and that was long before operation warp speed.
There are hundreds of such comments on some doctors’ social media feeds every day. In contrast, those who correct misinformation get blocked. Their fans often lavish them with praise, telling them they are “fearless” for challenging the orthodoxy. And you can see how some doctors get cornered by their followers and are forced to adopt more extreme positions. The cardinal rule is to never stop being “heterodox”, no matter what. This is how doctors end up praising viruses.
Young doctors take heed. Be careful not to develop a brand and cultivate followers you must continually impress – instead of leading your followers, you might become their follower. Mr. Bhogal ended his essay with a warning to would-be influencers and social media celebrities.
This is the ultimate trapdoor in the hall of fame; to become a prisoner of one’s own persona. The desire for recognition in an increasingly atomized world lures us to be who strangers wish us to be. And with personal development so arduous and lonely, there is ease and comfort in crowdsourcing your identity. But amid such temptations, it’s worth remembering that when you become who your audience expects at the expense of who you are, the affection you receive is not intended for you but for the character you’re playing, a character you’ll eventually tire of. And so be warned: being someone often means being fake, and if you chase the approval of others, you may, in the end, lose the approval of yourself.
I agree with Mr. Bhogal, having the wrong audience is worse than having no audience.

The Wellness Company: How antivaccine grift becomes plain old quackery
The Wellness Company, promoted by Dr. Peter McCullough, is the product of a trend in which antivax doctors have predictably become just quacks. At least in this case, there is an amusing quack fight at the heart of it all.
David Gorski on January 8, 2024
Tweet

I awoke the other day to see that Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone and Trial Site News were targeting The Wellness Company, the supplement company in which COVID-19 antivaxxer and quack Dr. Peter McCullough has become a major player, with an “investigative report” entitled Monetizing the COVID-19 Backlash—Big Vision, Palpable Demand, But Can They Pull it Off? Given that there are few things I enjoy better than a quack fight, I knew that this would have to be the topic of my first post for this year, especially when I’ve written about The Wellness Company before in the context of Dr. McCullough’s selling nattokinase supplements(with bromelain) which according to him break down SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, as a fake cure for both COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccine “injury” and also because Dr. Robert Malone, siding with Trial Site News, got permission to repost the entire story on his Substack, characterizing it as Trial Site News‘ “fair and balanced ‘deep dive’ investigation into ‘The Wellness Company.'”
Even as I noted that 2023 was the year that increasingly a fundamentalist version of evidence-based medicine (EBM) rooted in methodolatry was being weaponized against public health, in particular vaccines and masks, as well as other areas, I have to wonder as 2024 has dawned whether this year will see the culmination of another trend that I’ve been following, namely how COVID-19 contrarian doctors who became—or outed themselves as—antivax in response to the pandemic and then moved to become just generally antivax are increasingly becoming just plain run-of-the-mill grifting quacks. Even more amusing is that this story reveals how increasingly the quacks have been taking sides, in this case with Dr. Robert Malone increasingly coming under fire from his fellow COVID-19 antivaxxers like Dr. Peter McCullough and Dr. Paul Alexander for…reasons…and then firing back., something that I had been meaning to write about ever since I noticed this fight when Dr. Alexander attacked Dr. Malone for having “invented” the mRNA vaccine on his Substack in March and April. Again, I do love internecine war between cranks, particularly when it involves someone like Malone being attacked for is own false claim of credit for an invention, but more importantly when it can be used to make a point relevant to SBM.
Clearly this fight has been brewing for a while, and it’s at the point where even an outlet that promotes as much antivax disinformation and quackery, as well as COVID-19 conspiracy theories, as Trial Site News actually nails some important facts about The Wellness Company, although, as one might expect, more mainstream news sources like The Daily Beast got there first a month ago with a story MAGA Influencers Are Sold on This Grifty Wellness Company, amusingly also calling it “Goop for the GOP,” which is a hilariously spot-on characterization.
But first, a quack fight!
Before I discuss The Wellness Company in more depth, I can’t help but briefly touch on the context in which the Trial Site News article ran, namely that there’s been a big quack fight going on for months between Dr. Robert Malone and much of the rest of the COVID-19 crankosphere, in particular Dr. Paul Alexander, Dr. Peter McCullough, Sage Hana, and the pseudonymous conspiracy propagandist The Vigilant Fox, among others. As much as it plays “fair and balanced,” Trial Site News definitely takes a side, too, namely Dr. Malone’s, albeit with enough plausible deniability that it probably didn’t obviously burn any bridges in the case that The Wellness Company emerges victorious. How this crank fight started, I honestly no longer remember. It appears to have come about because of Dr. Malone’s continued insistence that he was The One True Inventor of mRNA Vaccines, leading the antivax crankosphere to take him at his word and start to attack him for his unstated but implicitly claimed role in having supposedly unleashed hell upon the world in the form of mRNA based COVID-19 vaccines, leading him to fire back from time to time, as in just a couple of weeks ago:
I am constantly amazed by the self-styled social media “independent journalists” who obsessively attack me for the sin of being a mass murderer due to the role which they claim I played in creating the modified-mRNA SARS-CoV-2 vaccines. George Webb, Jane Ruby, Paul Alexander, “Sage Hana”, the list goes on and on. But they never mention those that actually did develop the specific products. Rather strange.
Which clearly demonstrates that their years of obsessive hate are not actually about those who developed the products, but rather for some reason it is specifically targeted at me. All appear to be getting compensated in some way for actively promoting hate, although in most cases it is not clear who is paying them to do this. In at least one case, the source of compensation for promoting hate is well documented.
In the case of Paul Alexander, in my opinion it is clear that his support for these activities comes from Foster Colson’s [sic] “The Wellness Company” TWC ads are often displayed on Alexander’s attack posts. Alexander never promoted anti-Malone hate until hired by Wellness, and his accusations have followed the hate narratives promoted by Wellness CEO Foster Colson [sic] in his 2022 Christmas letter.
I read that Christmas letter and was a bit confused, as I didn’t see appear to be any mention of Dr. Malone in it and no actual “hate” other than typical antivax rhetoric like “unnecessary and often dangerous vaccine.” Still, there is no doubt that much of Dr. Alexander’s Substack is now devoted to saying a lot of rather nasty things about Dr. Malone. There have also been lawsuits; for example, Dr. Malone sued quack psychiatrist Dr. Peter Breggin and his wife for libel to the tune of $25 million, along with Dr. Jane Ruby and Stew Peters’ Red Voice Media, for, in essence, having taken him at his word that he had invented mRNA vaccines and then using their belief that COVID-19 vaccines have killed millions in order to call him a “mass murderer” and accusing him of “fraud, disinformation, dishonesty, deception, lying to the American public, lack of integrity, immorality and ethical improprieties.” For example, Stew Peters said on his show, ““Dr. Malone: All of the time that you’re spending on these podcasts and TV shows, hours with Joe Rogan, even here on the Stew Peters show, are you spending any time in the lab inventing the reversal to the carnage that you helped to invent that is now destroying humanity and killing all kinds of unborn babies and such?”
Again, the hilarity of quacks taking Dr. Malone at his word and then acting on that belief, plus their antivax beliefs, is too much for words. So is Dr. Malone lashing out by attacking not just the Breggins and Drs. Ruby and Alexander, but also other antivax cranks like Drs. Michael Yeadon and Peter McCullough, a situation about which The Vigilant News—the significance of that name will become apparent soon—wrote an article entitled Dr. Malone Versus The World: Why Is He At War With Everyone? in which the list of Dr. Malone’s enemies is long indeed:
The list below, derived from Dr. Malone’s past X and Substack posts, details these entities:
    • Dr. Peter Breggin and Ginger Breggin
    • Dr. Mike Yeadon
    • Sasha Latypova
    • Karen Kingston
    • Matthew [sic] Crawford
    • Dr. Ben Marble
    • Dr. Judy Mikovitz
    • George Webb
    • Sage Hana on Substack
    • America Out Loud
    • Dr. Jane Ruby
    • Red Voice Media
    • Stew Peters
    • Catherine Austin Fitts (The Solari Report)
    • J. J. Couey
    • Mary Holland (President of Children’s Health Defense)
    • The Wellness Company and its founder Foster Coulson
    • Dr. Paul Alexander
    • The Washington Post
    • Alex Berenson
    • Dr. Peter McCullough
    • And more. “The list goes on and on,” Dr. Malone has stated.
Many of these names will be quite familiar to SBM readers, and if you actually go and read the Substack post from right before Christmas linked to in the last bullet point you will see that Dr. Malone comes off as quite besieged, paranoid, even. He also apparently held out hope that the FDA would shut down The Wellness Company, even writing, ““These [supplements] are mislabeled as therapeutics. Peter [McCullough] know[s] this but will not act to object. Eventually, they will get called out by the FDA. Surprising, this has not happened yet.” In fairness, Dr. Malone also accused Dr. Alexander of acting as Dr. McCullough’s “surrogate” to “obsessively” attack him “hundreds of times,” which, as much as I hate to admit anything reasonable about Dr. Malone, is not an entirely unreasonable thing to wonder given just how many posts there are on Dr. Alexander’s Substack viciously attacking him.
These are mislabeled as therapeutics. Peter know this but will not act to object. Eventually they will get called out by the FDA. Surprising this has not happened yet.
— Robert W Malone, MD (@RWMaloneMD) November 25, 2023
(Everything old is new again, and to quacks This Is The Way. It has always been The Way.)
To understand the Trial Site News article that I will use to discuss the quackery that is The Wellness Company, you do need to understand the context, namely this huge crank fight. One group of cranks—definitely the much larger and more influential group—is taking the side of The Wellness Company and those allied with it, like Drs. McCullough and Alexander, and Dr. Malone and his much smaller band of allies. That includes Trial Site News, which is a competitor to The Vigilant News Network for conspiracy and antivax readers.
Malone vs. Everybody
The Wellness Company: More than just another quack supplement company?
Trial Site News starts its “exposé” by twisting the knife a bit with a quote from Dr. McCullough that destroyed yet another one of my many irony meters, leaving it a molten mass of plastic and wires with fitful bursts of electricity slowly dying:
We refuse to profit from your sickness. Join the fight for medical freedom by supporting TWC — a company focused on your Wellness with incredible doctors, treatments, and products.” A quote from Dr. Peter A. McCullough of The Wellness Company, a startup seeking to build a parallel health system. But along the way, will the company start embracing attributes mastered by the existing healthcare corporate empire?
Founded in June 2022, the Wellness Company is a new company that offers supplements that purport to reverse damage from mRNA vaccines, along with COVID-19 treatments offered via telemedicine subscriptions. Founded by Foster Coulson, the driving ethos was to build a company to support a patient-centric, parallel healthcare company. Driving that vision was what Coulson saw as a system during the COVID-19 pandemic demonizing front line physicians and available, safe medicines that could have saved in his view millions of lives. A lead player is the high-profile Dr. Peter McCullough, quoted above. But of course, this firm focuses on profits if it is to grow, invest and truly offer an alternative system, friendly to patients. While the Wellness Company is a privately held, independent venture, a review of Coulson’s investments reveals what looks to be a larger-scale entity designed to give mainstream healthcare systems competition.
So the planned grift appears to be much bigger than yet another quack supplement company fronted by Dr. McCullough, like The Wellness Company, selling ineffective COVID-19 “cures” like nattokinase. I note that, oddly enough, I hadn’t recalled ever having heard of Foster Coulson before, but I learned from both The Daily Beast and Trial Site News articles that he’s the scion of a Canadian logging and aviation company, with the Coulson family company, Coulson Aviation positioning itself as a leader in aerial firefighting as part of Coulson Aircane Ltd, which is all part of the privately held Coulson Group. While The Daily Beast‘s story is more about how the “grifty” supplement company is tied into a whole right wing antivaccine anti-public health infrastructure, oddly enough Trial Site News goes into more detail about its structure, founding, and dealings:
The young Mr. Coulson certainly benefited from that valuable experience with the family venture to launch TWC, which is also part of a complex group of companies, all somehow seemingly related to Integro Capital LLC, (IC LLC) which Coulson founded back in October 2021, (during the apex of the pandemic) as a vehicle to invest and profit, and maybe even change the U.S. healthcare system.
In terms of overall corporate structure, IC LLC has been formed as a holding company designed to monetize the dynamics arising out of the COVID-19 pandemic, with one of the investor’s companies (TWC) being focused on building a parallel health system.
Because of course. And where did Mr. Coulson get his start selling quackery? It appears to go back to one of the earliest quacks of the pandemic, the late Dr. Vladimir Zelenko, who by the end of March 2020 had already made his name as a COVID-19 quack promoting hydroxychloroquine, the antibiotic azithromycin, zinc, and a number of other ineffective repurposed drugs and supplements, as a cure for COVID-19, with attendant appearances on Fox News and other right-wing media. From Trial Site News:
It was Zelenko’s popularizing a three-drug combination of hydroxychloroquine, zinc and azithromycin as an intervention for mild-to-moderate COVID-19 (Zelenko protocol- derived from the prior work of Dr. Dieter Raoult, which was co-marketed with Coulson as “Z-stack” supplements) that inspired Coulson to think of bigger business opportunities. TrialSite has been told through the network that Coulson did quite well with the Z-stack during the pandemic.
Of course, any mainstream interpretation insists on the conspiracy theorist tag for Dr. Zelenko, but TrialSite chronicled many well-meaning, objective and competent front-line physicians whose character was attacked during the pandemic merely for standing up and offering other ways to help deal with the crisis. And our network assures us Coulson’s moral outrage was high watching the treatment of both doctors and patients during the pandemic.
Passing in 2022 due to cancer, Dr. Zelenko’s mission and their commercial success with the “Z-stack” product inspired Coulson’s bigger vision for a series of corporations that would take on various aspects of offering a parallel health service. It was a “de-prescribing from Big Pharma once and for all,” as conveyed by Kiera Butler in the Mother Jones piece.
(Here’s the Mother Jones piece referred to above, by the way.)
I also like how Trial Site News basically states what we here at SBM have been saying all along, all while linking to Dr. Malone:
And make no mistake, supplements are big business. Not pharma level, but big. According to analysts such as Precedence Research, the U.S. dietary supplement market was valued at $50.91 billion in 2022 and will grow at a healthy rate (CAGR) of 57% from 2023 to 2030, unless big pharmaceutical companies can tap into and own some of that growth with more regulation, a market strategy another influential COVID-19 response critic recently highlighted.
In the United States, this supplement industry growth rate is largely powered by the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (“DSHEA), which carved out a regulatory exception for dietary supplement such as vitamins and minerals. Consequent to this bill, the health and wellness industry supplement sector products are not subjected to the same regulatory requirements as pharmaceuticals and other medical products, including conducting expensive time-consuming clinical trials or obtaining regulatory approval. However, supplements and nutraceuticals are forbidden from making efficacy claims unless they are supported by substantial clinical data. Dr. Robert Malone writes, “Needless to say, the pharmaceutical industry has been working to amend the DSHEA act to make it more difficult for such products to make it to the market.”
Of course, we’ve long bemoaned the DSHEA of 1994 as a law that has for nearly 30 years made it easy for quacks to sell unproven supplements. What amused me about this passage is simply how it demonstrates much of what we’ve been saying all along: Even though the supplement industry is not (yet) big pharma level in terms of profits, it is big, very big. It has long been protected by powerful legislators, including an entire caucus. (Yes, there is a Congressional Dietary Supplement Caucus.) Thus far, nearly every attempt to tighten up the requirements for supplement regulation has failed, with efforts to further weaken even the weak DSHEA of 1994 continuing apace. Unsurprisingly, Trial Site News and Dr. Malone are just echoing every quack conspiracy theory about any effort to strengthen the DSHEA as being big pharma wanting to take over the supplement industry. While there is a germ of truth to that claim, it is only a germ. In reality, such efforts are primarily driven by SBM advocates alarmed at how easily the DSHEA enables selling quackery.
Quackery like The Wellness Company:
Enter Coulson’s International Health Brands (IHB), created along with ex-Navy Seal with supposed defense ties, Dave Lopez. IC LLC, IHB, and TWC (at least during the startup phase) appear to all share the same address in Boca Raton, Florida. These related firms are each designed to support or monetize (depending on one’s perspective), particular areas of health. But we emphasize that according to CEO Peter Gillooly, any of Coulson’s investments are completely separated, firewalled and not influencing each other.
Sure they are, and sure they don’t. (Yes, that’s sarcasm. It’s not as though we at SBM haven’t been down this road many times before.) In this case, though, IHB includes a number of companies and brands, including Elite, Zelenko Labs (yes, that Zelenko), The Wellness Company, Zinc Research International, and Rebellion, all of which sell supplements, just with a different focus.
Meanwhile:
Coulson’s Integro Capital, or Coulson operating under a different investor umbrella, also has some level of investment in the other ventures. The following is a list of Integro and/or Coulson direct investments.
That list includes IHB, The Vigilant Network, QU Biologics, Nanobiosym, Unjected. It’s a strange combination of companies, particularly Nanobiosym, which includes Moderna co-Founder Dr. Robert Langer as a key advisor. However, other than that, it all hangs together, with Unjected monetizing antivaccine misinformation by running a dating site for the “unvaccinated” (I kid you not), IHB selling COVID-19 quackery, and The Vigilant Network being a competing disinformation network to Trial Site News that I originally encountered in the form of The Vigilant Fox and The Vigilant News., which could partially explain how Trial Site News actually published a story with grains of truth in it, like this:
In evaluating TWC therapeutic claims or marketing messaging, a key question is whether Nattokinase-based supplements measurably improve clinical outcomes in patients that have some lingering injury associated with an mRNA vaccine or long COVID for that matter?
Are there credible clinical data supporting such a claim? TrialSite can only review the scientific literature, relevant and credible reports and tap into its network.
TrialSite journalists have reviewed multiple claims linked to TWC. From a strictly medical evidence perspective, there are few, if any, data demonstrating clinical efficacy. However, that’s doesn’t mean that the substance cannot help. It just means that it cannot be marketed to do so. Rather the substance must be marketed for general health purposes.
Physicians such as Dr. McCullough treat hundreds, if not thousands of people, and based on consenting patients, they should be rigorously tracking (at least in observational studies) clinical findings with this product, publishing the results where other peers can review, learn, critique, and potentially accept.
I laughed out loud when I read the last part, namely how The Wellness Company should “rigorously tracking” their “clinical findings with this product,” but I did have to admit that Trial Site News wasn’t wrong about their being no good evidence that nattokinase does anything for COVID-19. I myself went further and pointed out how the literature cited by quacks like Dr. McCullough actually doesn’t support any of the claims made for nattokinase (or bromelain, included in its Spike Support Formula for COVID-19 vaccine “injury” and long COVID).
Think of this article by Trial Site News as being similar to what Mike Adams did when he bought a secondhand mass spectrometer and started posting about how the supplements sold by companies competing with his were loaded with lead and other heavy metals. It’s an article that supports the general narrative that brave maverick doctors like Dr. McCullough (and Dr. Malone) are facing a “captured” healthcare system that won’t recognize their genius and how they have supposedly discovered highly effective treatments for COVID-19, while targeting competitors like The Wellness Company (fronted by Dr. McCullough) and The Vigilant News, all while giving the appearance of some “balance” by saying some nominally good things about the targets. Even while stating that there is no evidence that The Wellness Company’s Spike Support Protocol does anything for COVID-19, long COVID, or COVID-19 vaccine “injury,” Trial Site News nonetheless concedes:
Up until recently, the Nattokinase-based supplement which is claimed by TWC to target spike protein has been heavily promoted online in various conservative and libertarian leaning channels, again, mostly centered around its chief scientific proponent Dr. Peter McCullough, a contributor to TrialSite, and an internationally renowned figure at this point, especially for those that had real problems with the top-down, overbearing statist and globalist approach to COVID-19 response.
McCullough, a highly published cardiologist-epidemiologist, resisted the approved narratives which emerged during COVID-19, establishing protocols of repurposed drugs to help patients on the front lines during the onset of the pandemic. McCullough was an early adopter in promulgating alternative treatment regimens in response to mild-to moderate COVID-19—the McCullough Protocol.
While becoming an activist for patients and physician autonomy, the former academic cardiologist paid a heavy price economically, with terminations and lawsuits—one big one in which he was victorious.
Other groups staking a claim to early adoption and promotion of front-line protocols would include the COVID-19 Front Line Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC), Zelenko himself, Dr. Sabine Hazan (who registered one of the first ivermectin-based studies with the U.S. government) and others.
And, later:
TrialSite believes Coulson’s entry into alternative health supplements was authentically driven by a certain level of disgust in how the health system and government responded to the pandemic. Coulson, then joined by colleague Lopez, sought to establish a business model that would help individuals also fed up “de-prescribe from Big Pharma once and for all.”
And also:
Like most others active in this sector, TrialSite had no idea TWC appeared to be part of a startup-to-conglomerate aspiration, one seeking to power and monetize a parallel health economy. For example, while TWC and Elite might be different companies, they both sell supplements, and both have Coulson as likely majority shareholder.
Coulson’s certainly thinking big, and in healthcare and pharmaceuticals this comes with high risk and the need for large amounts of capital. But we have a level of appreciation for Coulson’s big vision.
See what I mean? According to the story, Coulson was sincere (the implication being that the operative word here is “was”); Trial Site News appreciates “his big vision” (although it implies that it’s too big Pharma-like now); and Dr. McCullough was a hero early on in the pandemic, at least before he turned to shilling for a supplement company selling products with no evidence that they work. Of course, from a medical and scientific standpoint, they were all always wrong right from the get-go, and TWC’s medical board is a who’s who of COVID-19 antivax quacks, including in addition to Dr. McCullough, Drs. Drew Pinsky, James Thorp, and Harvey Risch (who pushed hydroxychloroquine in 2020), along with William Makis (of “turbo cancer” fame) on its Canadian board.
Then, after discussing the various “preparedness kits,” such as the Medical Emergency Kit (complete with ivermectin!), that The Wellness Company sells by fear mongering about the next pandemic and claiming that everyone should have these supplements and drugs on hand and contracting with physicians to prescribe prescription pharmaceuticals to customers, just in case, Trial Site News notes:
Now selling supplements direct to consumers falls under the exceptions to FDA regulation, but employing or contracting with prescribing physicians, marketing pharmaceuticals such as ivermectin likely subjects the company to direct FDA oversight if any claims are violative.
According to TrialSite’s O’Connor, when a company’s business model becomes ever more dependent on business involving prescribing FDA regulated medicines for future indications, TWC physicians will be prescribing medicines for an indication that doesn’t yet exist.
With growth comes increased costs and pressure to sell, and this model [anticipatory prescriptions] could evolve into one involving perverse incentives—to promulgate fear of emerging infectious diseases, which would then increase the probability of consumers opting to pay for a prescription.” TrialSite’ O’Connor asked TWC CEO about company culture, and how they would avoid this sort of capitalist creep, the type that so many in the medical freedom movement are critical of big pharma for doing.
Gillooly became passionate at this point, explaining that they are building the company to empower patients, to offer a new model, one that honors their right to health care, to key medicines lie amoxicillin. That if guided correctly by a licensed prescribing physician following a Hippocratic oath that this culture will prevail as the company grows.
You mean like the way the quack physicians group America’s Frontline Doctor got busted for running a prescription mill selling ivermectin? Seriously, what is being described here is nothing more than a massively larger and better funded version of that sort of prescription mill, no matter how much Mr. Gillooly tries to deny it. That whole schtick about “empowering” patients is nothing more than the same schtick that quacks from time immemorial have used when selling their quackery, whatever it is, be it supplements, naturopathy, or repurposed pharmaceuticals that don’t work for the indication for which the quack prescribes them.
There’s a lot more in the article, including a rather interesting bit about how controlling a right wing propaganda and conspiracy site like The Vigilant News—it’s not that it’s called that in the story, but that’s what it is—poses the problem of a conflict of interest, which is breezily dismissed:
Coulson investing in controlling a political right media site has its benefits and drawbacks. TrialSite founder Daniel O’Connor told this writer, “Coulson is smart, has the pedigree for business based on his upbringing and likely believes at the core in what he says publicly, but the pressures of costs, investors and the realities of capitalism will undoubtedly enforce the same discipline on this groups of ventures as any others.”
When confronted with this logic, TWC CEO Gillooly explained to O’Connor that they have established strict firewalls, and that while they will buy advertising in the news network it would be violative to unduly influence the content.
The entrepreneur also says he founded Vigilant News Network “as a free and open network to bring people the latest unmanipulated stories….” But regardless, given the need for continual growth, rising costs associated with what in essence will be a regulated company, the pressures to exploit the firewalls will be significant. Only company culture of integrity and ethics can minimize such concerns. And of course, that starts at the top and Gillooly did assure TrialSite “we are building a serious big company and we will not compromise on our ethics, integrity or our mission.”
Sure they will, the same way that Mike Adams does with Natural News and Alex Jones does with his various websites and publications.
The Wellness Company: “Goop for the right” is a good description
At the end of its 6,000+ word article, Trial Site News warns:
Trust in the U.S. government, healthcare systems and the medical products industry sunk to what are likely all-time lows during the pandemic. Enter TWC and Foster Coulson’s mission to capitalize on those trends to build what he and Peter Gillooly emphasize will be a new kind of patient-centric company, dedicated to medical freedom.
But the uptick in TWC’s advertisements on conservative-leaning podcasts, Substack authors, and the like is palpable. Products that claim to “clean” the spike protein are not proven, and despite an esteemed Chief Medical Board seemingly validating the integrity and scientific veracity backing the products, they are dietary supplements that cannot be marketed for treating any form of disease, including SARS-CoV-2, the virus behind COVID-19, long COVID or long Vax, also known as COVID-19 vaccine injury. Of course, a physician at their discretion and patient consent can try different approaches to solve a medical problem. TrialSite stood up for that right of both patient and doctor during the pandemic. But that model doesn’t scale well enterprise wide.
No, it doesn’t. Actually, it doesn’t really hold true at any scale, but a large corporation is likely to make the grift so much more effective and therefore worse. Then, after pivoting to go on about how medicine and pharma are so far behind the times because they don’t recognize the spike protein from COVID-19 vaccines as the health evil that Dr. McCullough and his merry band of quacks consider it to be (you know, in the name of balance and saying that The Wellness Company comes from an honest place rather than a desire to grift), Trial Site News concludes:
And it’s the later dynamics that Coulson and Lopez have seized upon. Yes, a growing number of people demand an alternative health system. But in a market economy Coulson will need to be ready to plow all of his profits, and then some, back into actually demonstrating defensible efficacy before making claims, the true standard of any health-related brand, plus seriously invest in adherence to the compliance and regulatory regimes that currently govern healthcare delivery. Because that’s the world that he must now abide by.
We all know that Mr. Coulson will do no such thing. His goal is profit, and, for all his claims of wanting to “empower” people and free them of the supposed tyrannical shackles of big pharma, all he is really doing is recognizing an opportunity for grift.

The Federation of State Medical Boards vs. COVID-19 misinformation: A losing battle so far
A few weeks ago, the Federation of State Medical Boards, which itself does not have any regulatory power but advocates for state medical boards, issued a statement that physicians who spread COVID-19 misinformation should be subject to disciplinary measures. Unfortunately, a recent report found that not a single US physician has had action taken against their medical license for doing this. Why?
David Gorski on August 23, 2021
Link
My last post for 2020 was entitled 2020 and the pandemic: A year of (some) physicians behaving badly. The reason was simple. The COVID-19 pandemic, which first hit Wuhan, China in December 2019, was declared a pandemic by the World Health Organization in March 2020, and shortly thereafter caused mass shutdowns and travel restrictions that led some physicians to reveal themselves to be very bad actors indeed in terms of spreading misinformation, advocating quackery, and outright grifting. Sure, the usual suspects (several of whom were ultimately dubbed the “Disinformation Dozen” a few months ago) were involved, which is exactly what one would expect. After all, what were doctors like Joseph Mercola, Sherri Tenpenny, Kelly Brogan, and the like going to do during a pandemic except switch their grift to the coronavirus and COVID-19 vaccines? This was utterly expected. Years—even decades—before, I had wondered how doctors like these could keep their state medical licenses.
I will admit, however, to being surprised at just how many doctors who had previously demonstrated no history of this sort of activity took the opportunity to dive head first into the COVID-19 misinformation pool. Even worse, as has been documented here, even some highly respected doctors and academics have become “COVID contrarians”. They minimize the risk of harm from the coronavirus (particularly in children), make risibly off-base predictions (e.g., “we’ll have herd immunity by April“) and advocate against mask mandates (particularly in schools) and vaccinating children—or even erroneously claim that respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is being misdiagnosed in children as COVID-19 and that hospitalizations of children are being exaggerated. Worse, when corrected for their mistakes, they almost never seem to have the humility to admit error and move on; often they double down and act as though their statements were never refuted.
I review all this because there’s a topic I’ve been meaning to write about (and have written about a bit at my not-so-super-secret other blog) regarding the lack of professional sanctions against physicians who spread health misinformation, be it about vaccines, masks, COVID-19, or anything else. Going back to the case of cancer quacks like Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, Dr. Rashid Buttar, and beyond, I’ve long lamented how even the most obvious quacks seem to be able to keep their medical licenses and antivaccine doctors (e.g., Dr. Bob Sears) get off with a slap on the wrist, even when their medical board actually investigates. True, there are occasional exceptions, such as Dr. Paul Thomas, a rising star in the antivaccine movement whose license was suspended because the Oregon Medical Board deemed his antivaccine practices a danger to his patients, Dr. Mark Geier, who subjected autistic children to a hormone blocker usually used in children to treat central precocious puberty, based on the belief that decreasing testosterone levels would allow the mercury from vaccines to be chelated easier with his chelation therapy, and “Lyme literate” Dr John Lentz. Basically, state medical boards seem to be (mostly) toothless when it comes to intervening to stop such dangerous doctors. This is a topic that I’ve been meaning to write about, and a few weeks ago the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) gave me an excuse.
The Federation of State Medical Boards enters the fray
Historically, state medical boards seem to have problems going after outright quacks, much less physicians spreading dangerous misinformation during a global pandemic that has killed more than 600,000 people so far in the US alone. This is why I was so heartened a few weeks ago to see this statement from the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB), the organization that represents state medical boards:
Physicians who generate and spread COVID-19 vaccine misinformation or disinformation are risking disciplinary action by state medical boards, including the suspension or revocation of their medical license. Due to their specialized knowledge and training, licensed physicians possess a high degree of public trust and therefore have a powerful platform in society, whether they recognize it or not. They also have an ethical and professional responsibility to practice medicine in the best interests of their patients and must share information that is factual, scientifically grounded and consensus-driven for the betterment of public health. Spreading inaccurate COVID-19 vaccine information contradicts that responsibility, threatens to further erode public trust in the medical profession and puts all patients at risk.
The fact that the FSMB issued such a statement stating that physicians spreading misinformation and disinformation about COVID-19 risk disciplinary action was a big deal, at least to me. However, my enthusiasm and approval were tempered by my knowledge of how state medical boards actually operate. They are, in general, underfunded, have inadequate resources, and can only act when they receive a complaints about specific instances of poor practice or patient injury. Indeed, when a state medical board actually does act against an antivaccine physician (for instance), its penalties are often minimal, as was the case for Dr. Bob Zajac in Minnesota.
Indeed, I’ve long lamented how rare it is for a state medical board to suspend or revoke the medical license of outright quacks and how difficult it has been on the occasions when a state has tried, having written more posts over the years about this problem, both here and elsewhere. One good example that I like to cite (and did cite above but repeat here because I can’t emphasize his example enough and feel it’s worth expanding on briefly) is cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski, who has been practicing his cancer quackery in Houston since the late 1970s and, despite the occasional attempt of the Texas Medical Board to put a stop to his activities, has managed to prevail, with only minor impediments placed on his ability to practice, leading me to lament, “How is it that in 2018 cancer Stanislaw Burzynski is still preying on desperate cancer patients?” I even lumped him together with correspondence school naturopath and “pH Miracle Living” quack Robert O. Young as examples of how poorly many states regulate medical practice. (Of course, Burzynski practices in Texas, and Young used to ply his quackery in Florida, two of the worst states for this problem.)
Elsewhere, I’ve discussed the problem before a number of times. The problem is that state medical boards tend to be reluctant to go after doctors who use unscientific treatments like “detoxification” and colon cleanses because it forces them to enforce a standard of care, because such cases are harder to prove, and because there is so much pushback. State medical boards are generally good at going after doctors who commit easily identified, clear-cut breaches in trust, such as substance abuse, defrauding insurance companies, or diddling patients. When it comes to making judgment calls about doctors practicing outside of the standard of care, they’re a lot more reluctant to do so. That’s why the only physician behaviors very likely to result in strong action consists of running a prescription mill, sexual improprieties with patients, or practicing while impaired due to abuse of alcohol or illicit substances. It’s a matter of resource allocation and prioritization. State medical boards tend to react primarily to what they perceive to be the most immediately and obviously dangerous behaviors. Practicing quackery rarely makes the cut, because medical boards tend to be loathe to make value judgments about medical practice, and proving quackery is way harder and more resource-intensive than proving that a doctor is an addict who has been practicing while impaired or has sexually abused patients.
This applies to even horrible surgeons like Dr. Christopher Duntsch, whose epic incompetence in the operating room coupled with alcohol abuse resulted in multiple “clean kills” and paralyzed patients. He was rare in that his bungled operations so alarmed colleagues that they actually took the even rarer action of complaining about him to the Texas Medical Board. Even so, all too often it took a long time to take down. Ultimately, Dr. Duntsch, who had major substance abuse problems in addition to his epic incompetence in the operating room, finally did lose his medical license and is now serving a life sentence in a Texas prison for multiple counts of aggravated assault relating to 33 botched surgeries over two years, including two that resulted in patient death. Indeed, Dr. Duntsch’s case was so remarkable that he is now the subject of an eight part series on Peacock entitled Dr. Death: The Undoctored Story, which I’ve been meaning to watch:
The good thing about the case of Dr. Duntsch is that doctors as sociopathic as he are rare. The bad thing about the case is that it took a really long time for his colleagues (who knew his reputation and had had to try to salvage his disastrous complications) and the Texas Medical Board to act.
Which brings us to COVID-19 misinformation, which can kill. Are state medical boards actually doing anything? While it’s true that it has been less than a month since the FSMB issued its statement, I thought I’d look into this.
“No physicians disciplined for COVID falsehoods”
Earlier this week, a reader made me aware of a story published in MedPage Today that looked into the question of whether state medical boards have been investigating physicians making false COVID-19 claims. Its findings were not reassuring:
Despite a national call to sanction doctors who spread COVID-19 misinformation, a MedPage Today investigation found that not one of 20 physicians who’ve peddled such falsehoods has been disciplined by their state licensing agency for doing so.
That’s not to say that complaints haven’t been filed, or that investigations haven’t been launched. These elements are confidential in most states, including the 10 contacted by MedPage Today who license the physicians.
But that means physicians who have advanced false COVID information — including Simone Gold, MD, JD; Scott Atlas, MD; Joseph Mercola, DO; Lee Merritt, MD; Sherri Tenpenny, DO; and Stella Immanuel, MD — are free to continue to misinform their patients and the public, even as the Delta variant surges.
“Our statement is a reminder to physicians that words have consequences and during a public health emergency like COVID-19, those words can mean life or death for patients,” Joe Knickrehm, vice president of communications for the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB), told MedPage Today via email.
Obviously, Dr. Joe Mercola is well-known to readers of this blog, my having featured him in a post last month describing his copious spreading of online COVID-19 misinformation. He is what I have long referred to as a quack tycoon, given that his net worth is north of $100 million, thanks to his online supplement and quackery sales supported by his website, which has spread antivaccine misinformation for close to 25 years. As I mentioned before, of course he pivoted to COVID-19 misinformation and antivaccine fear mongering targeting the COVID-19 vaccines, including false claims that the flu vaccine makes you more susceptible to COVID-19, that mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are “gene therapy” that can “permanently alter your DNA”, that the vaccines will cause global depopulation, and that ivermectin is a miracle cure for COVID-19 whose “suppression” is the “crime of the century.”
I also can’t help but note that the reporters seem not to be aware that Mercola recently moved from Illinois to Florida and appears to not be licensed in Florida. Also, he hasn’t practiced medicine for over a decade, which makes asking the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation strike me as a bit off-target, given that the only thing Mercola would lose if he lost his medical license would be prestige. (His ability to grift would remain intact.) Still, here’s the statement from the story:
In a statement, the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation said that if the agency “determines a licensee committed violations against the Act that regulates their profession, an appropriate course of action will be taken. Complaints filed with and investigations undertaken by IDFPR are confidential, unless and until a public complaint or discipline is issued by the Department.”
The largest number by far of doctors featured in this story hold medical licenses in California: Simone Gold, MD, JD; Scott Atlas, MD; Dan Erickson, DO; Artin Massihi, MD; Jeffrey Barke, MD; Jennings Ryan Staley, MD; Brian Tyson, MD. Several of these doctors are familiar. For example, Simone Gold is a prominent member of the Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care (FLCCC) Alliance, which has been promoting ivermectin as the miracle cure for COVID-19 that “they” don’t want you to know about. Unsurprisingly, last summer she was promoting hydroxychloroquine as the miracle cure for COVID-19 that “they” don’t want you to know about.
As for the rest of the doctors in the list, last year around this time Hoover Institution hack Scott Atlas, a radiologist with no expertise in infectious disease or epidemiology, rose to become one of Donald Trump’s most trusted medical advisors regarding the pandemic, even though he was very much for “natural herd immunity“. Early in the pandemic Dan Erickson and Artin Massihi published a highly dubious study that tried to estimate the prevalence of COVID-19. Jeffrey Barke, whom I had never heard of before, has a concierge practice in Newport Beach and appears to be an antimasker, having published a book a year ago entitled Covid-19 A Physician’s Take on the Exaggerated Fear of the Coronavirus. And then there was this last September:
His medically unorthodox opinions have become familiar among the voices claiming that the coronavirus has been politicized in an effort to damage President Donald Trump’s reelection campaign.
Even despite Barke’s proactive omnipresence on social media, a video he posted Sept. 17 managed to create new shock waves – to the point that Hoag Hospital, with which Barke has a business relationship, publicly distanced itself from him.
In last week’s video, Barke shares a split-screen with fellow anti-masking media star Peggy Hall. “What I do, Peggy, to protect you and to protect others when I’m in public – I think better than a mask – this is what I do,” Barke asserts, suddenly brandishing a 9-millimeter handgun.
“You know, I live in Orange County so I carry this wherever I go,” Barke continues, adding that he works for “a local sheriff’s department agency as a reserve deputy.”
The next day, Hoag tweeted that Barke’s “radical views on COVID, masking and hydroxychloroquine” are “diametrically opposite” from the hospital’s.
Well alrighty, then.
Then there’s Jennings Ryan Staley, who has his own mention on the US Department of Justice website:
Dr. Jennings Ryan Staley, previously charged with one count of mail fraud, was indicted by a federal grand jury yesterday for additional crimes arising from his business venture selling COVID-19 “treatment kits,” which he advertised to one potential customer as a “miracle cure.” Staley is a licensed physician and the former operator of Skinny Beach Med Spas in and around San Diego.
According to the new charges, which became publicly available today, Staley agreed with a Chinese supplier to smuggle hydroxychloroquine powder into the U.S., lying to U.S. Customs by mislabeling a shipment as “yam extract.” Staley is also charged with stealing the name and identifying information of one of his employees in order to create and submit a bogus prescription for hydroxychloroquine on the employee’s behalf, in order to sell the drugs at a markup to his customers.
In late March and early April 2020, Staley marketed and sold his treatment kits to Skinny Beach customers. He described his product as a “concierge medicine experience,” which included hydroxychloroquine—an anti-malarial drug that Staley described to one potential customer as a “guaranteed” cure for COVID-19. Staley’s kits were priced as high as $3,995 for a family of four, while Staley himself paid roughly $1 per tablet of hydroxychloroquine. Staley’s marketing materials, per the indictment, stressed that recipients should “NOT BELIEVE THE REPORTS THAT HYDROXYCHLOROQUINE DOESN’T WORK!”
During a phone call with a prospective customer, in reality an undercover FBI agent, Staley repeatedly promised that the drugs he was selling would cure COVID-19.
If he’s convicted, this should be a slam dunk, given that most states automatically revoke the medical license of any physician convicted of a felony, and another notice states that he pleaded guilty to “one count of importation contrary to law, admitting that he worked with a Chinese supplier to try to smuggle into the United States a barrel that he believed contained over 26 pounds of hydroxychloroquine powder by mislabeling it as ‘yam extract.'” (As a side note, hilariously, this scammer got scammed, given that the shipment turned out only to contain baking soda.)
Meanwhile, Dr. Brian Tyson appears to be a run-of-the-mill hydroxychloroquine quack with an outsized social media presence, who is now promoting ivermectin as part of a “multidrug therapy” for COVID-19:
Personally, I appreciated the FDA’s snark on this. Those of us who have criticized ivermectin believers acknowledge that, when used for its intended purpose, it’s a great drug. We just recognize that there’s no good evidence that it is as much of a “miracle” drug for COVID-19 as it is for river blindness.
I could go on and on through the list, but why bother? Instead, let’s just sample some of the responses from various state medical boards, starting with California, given the number of offenders in that state:
Carlos Villatoro, public information officer for the Medical Board of California, said in an email to MedPage Today that “publicly spreading false COVID-19 information may be considered unprofessional conduct and could be grounds for disciplinary action. The Board will review complaints it receives about its licensees on this topic, as it does with all complaints. To date, no accusation has been filed against a licensee regarding this issue.”
Let’s move on to nearby Idaho:
Yvonne Dunbar, counsel for the Idaho State Medical Board, told MedPage Today in an email, “Neither the Idaho Medical Practice Act nor the applicable administrative rules provide a basis for the Board to discipline licensees for statements made during a conference, to the media, or in any other public setting.”
However, she said the board “does have authority to investigate and possibly discipline its licensees for statements or behaviors which transpire in a health care setting … if it is established that they: ‘Engag[ed] in a pattern of unprofessional or disruptive behavior or interaction in a health care setting that interferes with patient care or could reasonably be expected to adversely impact the quality of care rendered to a patient. Such behavior does not have to have caused actual patient harm to be considered unprofessional or disruptive.'”
Unsurprisingly, many of the docs who promote COVID-19 misinformation on social media and old school media (TV, newspapers, etc.) often also practice according to that misinformation, discouraging masking, demonizing vaccines, promoting “miracle cures” such as ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine (with zinc, and other drugs and supplements, of course!) as part of their treatment protocols.
I can’t resist quoting North Carolina (about, appropriately enough, Rashid Buttar, who once famously referred to the North Carolina Medical Board as a “rabid dog“):
If the North Carolina Medical Board has information that a licensee may be spreading false or misleading information about COVID-19, it would investigate, said communications director Jean Fisher Brinkley. “Decisions about possible regulatory action would be based on the evidence gathered and, specifically, whether the Board has evidence that a violation of law or professional ethics occurred, a process that is consistent with the FSMB’s statement.”
There is a depressing similarity to all the responses, namely either that medical board of the state where the physician in question practices hasn’t received any complaints as of yet, that speech alone can’t be penalized, or that they will “investigate” if there are complaints. When a bunch of readers sent me a link to the FSMB complaint, I generally responded that I don’t expect much to come of it. More recently, I responded to those sending me this MedPage Today article, “I hate to say I told you so, but I told you so.” But why? Why is nothing happening?
The First Amendment vs. professional speech
To get an idea of why nothing is happening, I can’t help but point to the reaction of some physicians to the FSMB statement, starting with the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), a far right wing medical John Birch Society camouflaged as a legitimate medical professional society. I’ve written about the AAPS a number of times, relating how it’s promoted antivaccine pseudoscience blaming vaccines for autism, including a view that is extreme even among antivaccine activists, namely that the “shaken baby syndrome” is a “misdiagnosis” for vaccine injury. It’s worse than that, though. AAPS has promoted HIV/AIDS denialism, blamed immigrants for crime and disease, promoted the pseudoscience claiming that abortion causes breast cancer using some of the most execrable “science” ever, and not only rejected evidence-based guidelines as an unacceptable affront on the godlike autonomy of physicians; the very concept of a scientific consensus about anything. Let’s just put it this way. The AAPS has featured publications by antivaccine mercury militia “scientists” Mark and David Geier and many others. Unsurprisingly, in the age of COVID-19, the AAPS has seamlessly pivoted to COVID-19 denial, antimask nonsense, and antivaccine conspiracy theories.
As you might expect, the title of Dr. Tamzin Rosenwasser’s is “The Federation of State Medical Boards Channels the Soviet NKVD“. (I suppose I should be grateful that Nazis weren’t mentioned, at least in the title.) After quoting the FSMB statement, Dr. Rosenwasser goes all anti-Communist, consistent with the AAPS’s similarity to a medical John Birch Society:
The FSMB has been described as a “private lobbying organization that represents the state’s attorneys who work for medical boards.” It does not by itself have the legal authority to take a doctor’s license but is highly influential.
The NKVD, the People’s Commissariat for Internal Affairs, was the Soviet secret police agency, the precursor to the KGB.
Unsurprisingly, the editorial goes on to parrot antivaccine misinformation about the COVID-19 vaccine and COVID-19 in general, continue the author’s confusion on whether the FSMB are Communists or Nazis, and appeal to “free speech”, portraying any effort to “censor” misinformation as an unconscionable assault on free speech. It’s a very appealing argument, at least in the US, where free speech protections are embedded in the Constitution. Doctors who are antivaccine and/or promote COVID-19 misinformation often appeal to free speech (and, in the US, the First Amendment) and portray any attempts by medical licensing bodies, whatever the state or country, to discipline them for their activities as fascistic (or Communist) assaults on “free speech”.
Although there are certainly gray areas, these attacks are deceptive, for the simple reason that professional speech by a physician licensed by the state is not the same as some random fool on social media saying the same thing. When physicians use the imprimatur of authority that society has bestowed on them to add the authority of their profession to their misinformation, that is arguably an abuse their status as a physician. These physicians spreading COVID-19 misinformation disingenuously ignore the simple fact that, if they were not physicians, their misleading pontificating about how the vaccine doesn’t work or is dangerous, how we’ll have “herd immunity by April”, or touting drugs that don’t work as “miracle cures” for COVID-19 that are being “suppressed” by The Man would not be taken nearly as seriously by the public.
As part of our professional role as physicians and surgeons we are granted privileges unknown to non-physicians, including being allowed to ask patients about their deepest and darkest personal matters, administering potentially toxic drugs (such as chemotherapy for cancer), or, in the case of surgeons, removing or rearranging body parts for therapeutic effect using sharp instruments in a way that would be considered assault and battery if attempted by a non-surgeon. We are granted these incredible privileges because society has deemed us worthy after having completed four years of rigorous training in medical school followed by anywhere from three years to a decade or more of additional training in residency and fellowship. In the age of COVID-19, the entire right-wing COVID-19 disinformation ecosystem, of which the AAPS is a small but influential part on medical matters, will treat any physician whose license is sanctioned by a state medical board as a free speech martyr. This is propaganda, however, not reality, because our professional status makes our utterances on COVID-19 professional speech that is arguably part of our profession as physicians, not just an exercise of free speech, and if we abuse our professional speech, state medical boards should certainly be empowered to investigate and discipline us.
After all, as a result of the privileges granted us, society also accords our words on medical matters (and, let’s face it as ridiculous as it might seem, on many nonmedical matters too) much more weight than those coming from nonphysicians. Physicians, in my experience, often both forget about that and take advantage of it. Again, I like to emphasize that, were these physicians not physicians, a lot fewer people would give a rodent’s posterior what their latest take on COVID-19 or vaccines is. In other words, professional speech misused can have deadly consequences, particularly during a pandemic. Contrary to Dr. Rowenwasser’s ridiculous comparison to the repression carried out by the NKVD and appeal to the Nuremberg Code, it is entirely appropriate for the FSMB to recommend going after the medical license of—or otherwise disciplining—any physician promoting obvious COVID-19 and antivaccine misinformation and conspiracy theories. That is not suppression of free speech. That is professional oversight.
Advocates for science- and evidence-based medicine cannot help but be appalled at how easily physicians practicing modalities that are clearly so far outside the standard of care that they might as well be in another galaxy can continue to do so with little or no oversight or even interference by state medical boards. In essence, it takes mind-numbingly egregious offenses to motivate a board to act, be it substance abuse by a physician resulting in obvious impairment, non-science-based treatments resulting in the death or severe injury of a patient, or blatantly illegal behavior, such as running a narcotic prescription mill. Part of the problem is that the attitude among doctors seems to be that a medical license is a right, rather than what it really is: an incredible privilege bestowed upon us physicians and surgeons by society that takes an equally incredible commitment and skill to be allowed to continue to keep. That same attitude among physicians also seems to lead them to think that they should be able to say anything they want about the pandemic, even though their words are arguably professional speech (particularly given how many “COVID contrarian” doctors use their status either to sell a product or to sell themselves as “experts”).
Our patients deserve better. The vast majority of physicians are competent and try their best to deliver the best evidence-based care they can to their patients. However, doctors who consistently do not practice according to the standard of care, be it because they are incompetent, dishonest, impaired by substance abuse, or because they have come to believe in blatantly unscientific treatments that do not help and not infrequently harm patients, do not deserve to be physicians. The same is true of physicians who abuse their status in order to peddle misinformation about a virus causing a pandemic that has killed over 600,000 in the US alone and millions worldwide—and is still sickening and killing people at unacceptably high rates. I’m glad the FSMB said something about revoking the licenses of physicians who spread misinformation, but I fear that in practice implementing such a policy will be well-nigh impossible.

State medical boards vs. COVID-19 misinformation, an update
The disinformation epidemic about COVID-19 has pushed state medical boards to consider disciplining physicians who promote COVID-19 disinformation. How would that work? What are the obstacles? Is it even possible? It should be, but it will be messy and complicated.
David Gorski on September 27, 2021
Link

A little over a month ago, I wrote about how the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) had recently issued a statement asserting that physicians who spread COVID-19 misinformation should be subject to disciplinary measures by their state medical boards up to and including revocation of their medical licenses. Given that there have been some developments on that front since then, I thought that now would be a good time for an update and a bit more discussion on the general issue of what should be done about physicians who promote misinformation not just about COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines, but medical misinformation, antivaccine conspiracy theories, and pseudoscience in general. At the time of my original post, I expressed major skepticism that the FSMB’s statement would result in any action. The situation is perhaps not as bad as I had predicted then, but it’s also not so great, either.
In that post a month ago, I started by pointing out how many physicians had been behaving badly since the pandemic began 18 months ago. That was just in 2020. In 2021, the prominence (and, I fear, number) of physicians promoting health misinformation has only increased. In addition to the usual suspects jumping onto the COVID-19 misinformation grift train (several of whom were ultimately dubbed the “Disinformation Dozen“), there were academics who really should know better downplaying the pandemic and doubting the effectiveness of vaccines. Our very own Jonathan Howard even went so far as to point out how some of them have gotten to the point where, even though we know they are not antivaccine, their bloviations need to be fact-checked as though they were antivaccine. Again, it was no surprise that the usual suspects have been promoting COVID-19 misinformation. Grifters gonna grift, as I like to say, and COVID-19 was an unprecedented opportunity for physicians like Joseph Mercola, Sherri Tenpenny, Kelly Brogan, and the other usual quacks to pivot and switch their grift to the coronavirus and COVID-19 vaccines.
If it had only been the usual quacks and grifters who had jumped on the COVID-19 misinformation fraud train, possibly the situation now with respect to COVID-19 misinformation wouldn’t have deteriorated so much. After all, in contrast to the academics who have turned COVID-19 contrarian, the usual quacks and grifters are at best fringe figures with little influence outside their usual echo chambers. So let’s briefly review some of the messages being promoted by physicians who were once respected doctors and academics who have become what Dr. Howard and I like to call “COVID contrarians”. They minimize the risk of harm from the coronavirus (particularly in children), make risibly off-base predictions (e.g., “we’ll have herd immunity by April“) and advocate against mask mandates (particularly in schools) and vaccinating children—or even erroneously claim that respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is being misdiagnosed in children as COVID-19 and that hospitalizations of children are being exaggerated. During the recent discussion over myocarditis in children associated with COVID-19 vaccination, none of them seem to be able to acknowledge that COVID-19 actually harms children, while one physician whom I used to respect whose results I used to write about on a regular basis has gone down the rabbit hole of conspiracy theories, repeating a particularly pernicious one dating back to early in the pandemic that early intubation of COVID-19 patients was killing them. That physician, Dr. John Ioannidis, even went to far as to say that doctors, “not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation, just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”. (Spoken like a doc who has never taken care of critically ill patients in an ICU!) And don’t even get me started on the physicians who wrote and signed on to the Great Barrington Declaration, the pre-vaccine statement that advocated letting COVID-19 rip through the “healthy” young community and using “focused protection” to keep the elderly and those at high risk of severe disease and death safe from the coronavirus.
Worse, when corrected for their mistakes, these “COVID contrarians” almost never seem to have the humility to admit error and move on; often they double down and act as though their statements were never refuted. Indeed, they often characterize criticism as “cancel culture” and loudly claim victim status whenever their efforts encounter serious pushback. We’ve recently seen an excellent example of just that from our recent discussions of the VAERS analysis looking at myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination in teens by Tracy Beth Høeg, John Mandrola, Josh Stevenson, and Allison Krug that utterly misused the VAERS database and didn’t put the findings into context. Predictably, they and their defenders are crying “Persecution!” and blaming the blowback on “medical tribalism“. So what’s new?
The medical boards in Mississippi and Washington weigh in
On Friday, I was made aware of this news story out of Washington, which reported that the Washington Medical Commission can now discipline doctors who spread COVID-19 misinformation:
Doctors and physician’s assistants who spread misinformation about COVID-19 in Washington could face disciplinary measures. That’s after action taken this week by the Washington Medical Commission, which monitors and enforces licenses of about 34,000 physicians and physician assistants here.
During a special meeting, the commission formally adopted a position statement to that effect. The commissioners agreed unanimously that the treatment of COVID-19 must meet the same standard of care as other diseases.
That’s after reports of a surge in unsafe alternative treatments such as ivermectin, an anti-parasitic drug often used in animals. It has off-label approval for human use in limited circumstances, but both the CDC and the FDA say there’s no convincing evidence it works to prevent or treat COVID-19.
The State of Mississippi has also made a move in the same direction:
Physicians who spread misinformation about the COVID-19 vaccine could now have their license to practice medicine suspended or completely revoked, according to a new policy adopted by the Mississippi State Board of Medical Licensure.
The policy, adopted on Sept. 7, says that doctors have an “ethical and professional responsibility” to practice medicine in the best interest of their patients and share factual and scientifically-grounded information with them.
“Spreading inaccurate COVID-19 vaccine information contradicts that responsibility, threatens to further erode public trust in the medical profession and puts all patients at risk,” the policy reads.
The policy says whether physicians “recognize it or not” they possess a high degree of public trust due to their specialized knowledge and training. That gives them “a powerful platform in society.”
The policy specifically warns doctors against spreading misinformation on social media and strongly recommends physicians separate their personal and professional content online.
“Physicians must understand that actions online and content posted can affect their reputation, have consequences for their medical careers, and undermine public trust in the medical profession,” it reads.
This is a step in the right direction, although I do wonder how these new policies in Washington and Mississippi will be operationalized. Why do I wonder this? The article about the Washington Medical Commission alludes to it, but doesn’t quite get to the point where we at SBM have been for a while:
Dr. Yanling Yu, a research scientist from Lake Forest Park, serves as a public member of the commission. She expressed initial concern about following state law that protects alternative medicine, but then spoke in favor of the position statement on misinformation.
“There is no valid science at all. … Like, ivermectin, there have been patients that have been harmed by it. So that is not scientific practice of medicine. And that needs to be stopped,” Yu said.
And there you have it, the exact issue that I’ve been writing about for well over a decade, the powerlessness of state medical boards in the face of quackery. Let’s take a trip down memory lane to explain what I mean.
COVID-19 misinformation and alternative medicine
Out of curiosity, I perused my personal blog to search for the first instance when I wrote at length about the problem with state medical boards and found that it was in 2008, when the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners finally disciplined cancer and autism quack Dr. Rashid Buttar (who, unsurprisingly, is today one of the usual quacks and grifters promoting COVID-19 and COVID-19 misinformation). Unsurprisingly, all Dr. Buttar got was the proverbial slap on the wrist, even after having called the Board a “rabid dog“. All the Board did was to restrict Dr. Buttar’s practice so that he was no longer permitted to treat children or cancer patients. Why children and cancer patients specifically? Simple. Dr. Buttar had been known for his antivaccine views that blamed mercury in the thimerosal preservative in vaccines caused autism, and his treatment was a “transdermal chelation therapy” that we disparagingly called “Buttar’s butter“, and he was a cancer quack, to boot.
Two years later, Dr. Buttar was free to practice medicine again mostly unencumbered. Basically, he signed a consent decree with the Board that reprimanded him and ordered him (1) to provide informed consent to his patients as dictated by the Board; (2) to obey all laws, as well as rules and regulations governing the practice of medicine in North Carolina; (3) to notify the Board if he changes his address; and (4) to meet with the board periodically. The informed consent forms were utterly worthless, as well. Basically, they stated that Dr. Buttar made no claims for the efficacy of anything that he was doing. It also pointed out that serious complications can occur from IV treatments. As I noted at the time, if I were to use an informed consent like this for surgery, for example, in which I “make no specific claims” that the proposed surgery will do anything therapeutic for the patient, sane practitioners would demand to know why I was allowed to do this operation in the first place!
Of course, Dr. Buttar was one of many examples of the failure of state medical boards to discipline outright quacks and antivaxxers. Worse, in one state, whistleblowers who have reported dubious practices of physicians have even been prosecuted by law enforcement, as I described in depth in 2009. The state was Texas, the same state whose medical board has been unable to shut down the practice of Houston cancer quack Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, who has been plying his cancer quackery there since the late 1970s. Then there’s the case of Dr. Christopher Duntsch, the substance abuse-impaired neurosurgeon who was so incompetent that his fellow surgeons had seen nothing like it before. As I’ve mentioned recently Duntsch is now the subject of a Peacock series Dr. Death. My own state is not immune. This might have nothing to do with alternative medicine, but it took the FBI, not my state medical board, to finally stop Dr. Farid Fata, the oncologist who gave chemotherapy to patients who didn’t even have cancer. How did they stop him? They busted him for Medicare and Medicaid fraud for having billed over $30 million for unnecessary treatments.
You get the picture.
It’s worse than that, though. As Jann Bellamy and others here at SBM have been documenting, quacks like naturopaths, chiropractors, and other alternative medicine practitioners have been playing the long game of pushing to change state laws to legitimize their “professions”. She even has a term for it: legislative alchemy, the process in which quacks try to turn the lead of their professions into gold. She’s long documented the process for chiropractors, naturopaths (among the most persistent and successful of the legislative alchemists), acupuncturists, reflexologists, and practitioners of “integrative medicine” who “integrate” quackery with their medicine. These bills take the form of promoting bills mandating formal state licensure, expanding quacks’ scope of practice, and requiring Medicare and insurance companies to reimburse quacks for their “services”. In Florida, a new law even forces doctors who don’t support alternative treatments for pain to endorse acupuncture and other quackery as “non-opioid treatments” for pain.
This brings me back to the State of Washington. Remember how that one quote expressed concern about how the state could police physicians promoting COVID-19 misinformation when it has a law on the books that protects “integrative” (and therefore alternative) medicine practitioners? Remember how I discussed how North Carolina handled the case of Dr. Buttar? One thing I didn’t mention then but will mention now is this, quoted from a story that is no longer on the web (and not in the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org), although the relevant parts are preserved in my post:
The consent order, signed Friday, marks the end of a battle that Buttar had vowed to take to the U.S. Supreme Court. He said he has spent “hundreds of thousands of dollars” defending himself against the board’s allegations that he exploited patients by charging exorbitant fees for unproven therapies that didn’t work and by arbitrarily ordering expensive tests to make more money.
In recent years, Buttar led a successful effort by the N.C. Integrative Medical Society to get legislators to change state law to make it friendlier to practitioners of alternative medicine.
This is another example of “legislative alchemy”, in which influential quacks manage to persuade state legislatures to pass laws protecting “alternative medicine” practices. So what is the relevance to the ability of, for instance, the Washington Medical Commission? Simple. As we’ve documented here time and time again, if there’s one consistent aspect of alternative medicine (besides its lack of science), it’s antivaccine views. Naturopaths, chiropractors, and acupuncturists, for example, tend to be overwhelmingly antivaccine, and many even deny germ theory. If their views are “protected” somehow by state law, that would put these new directives allowing state medical boards to discipline physicians for spreading COVID-19 misinformation into direct conflict with the laws protecting “alternative and traditional” medical practices.
So here’s what I mean when I ask: How will, for example, the Washington Medical Commission operationalize this new policy, particularly if it conflicts with a law that protects alternative medicine practice? For example, if a doctor promotes germ theory denial and antivaccine views about COVID-19 under the guise of “integrative medicine” citing acupuncture (licensed) and naturopathy (also licensed), how can the Washington Medical Commission do anything about it? The state of North Carolina has also suggested that it might discipline doctors who promote COVID-19 misinformation, but how will it do so when its own law privileges alternative medicine (hidden in “integrative medicine”) almost as much as science-based medicine, thanks to the efforts of Dr. Buttar and his fellow quacks? This is a general principle that applies to any state that has legalized forms of “alternative medicine,” not just Washington or North Carolina.
That’s aside even from the consideration of where to draw the line in terms of professional speech. While it’s obvious that saying, for example, that COVID-19 vaccines don’t work is misinformation or disinformation, what about physicians who not-so-subtly raise doubts about the vaccines that rely on leaving out key pieces of information? One way has been proposed in an op-ed by doctors, a couple of whom should be familiar to regular readers here:
It’s important to understand that the wrongdoing involved is not misinformation — that is, something that a person incorrectly but innocently believes to be true. It is disinformation, which is information created and shared with the intent to deceive. For many months a well-coordinated network of disinformation doctors has been working to undermine mask-wearing and lockdowns, spread anti-vaccine conspiracy theories, and promote phony covid “cures” such as hydroxychloroquine and the horse-deworming drug ivermectin.
The best known of these groups calls itself “America’s Frontline Doctors” — though many physicians in this group have never practiced emergency medicine, and some haven’t practiced any form of medicine for years. Amid the Trump administration’s disastrous handling of the pandemic, this group was ushered into the public arena to discredit medical science. They began by trying to convince Americans that the potential for severe illness from covid-10 was a hoax, in the interest of keeping the U.S. economy open and thus fueling Donald Trump’s reelection campaign. Through their social media platforms and rallies, they continue to sow distrust of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and dissuade their audiences from following public health guidelines. In January, the group published a white paper denouncing vaccines. Its members have held rallies to spread their message in states including Florida, Texas and California — all of which are now experiencing covid spikes. Now, with the delta variant, those cases include a large number of very sick children.
They further note:
But these physicians will not be dissuaded by strongly worded statements. Consider Simone Gold — a California physician and noted advocate of the hydroxychloroquine “cure.” In 2020 she was one of the founders of America’s Frontline Doctors; today, as NPR reported, Gold continues to spread disinformation, discourage vaccination and promote unproven treatments for covid (for which, NPR noted, she was offering to prescribe via a $90 telehealth appointment). She was arrested after Jan. 6, when she participated in the incursion into U.S. Capitol, having come to Washington that day to speak at a “rally for health freedom.” Simone Gold is still licensed to practice medicine in the state of California.
The pessimist in me wonders if even losing their licenses would dissuade some of these doctors, many of whom seem not to be in medical practice any more, having gone into full time COVID-19 grifting. On the other hand, at least they wouldn’t be able to be ivermectin prescription mills any more. The doctors behind the op-ed cited above have gone beyond an op-ed and set up a website for reporting the worst disinformation peddlers, No License for Disinformation.
Let me finish on a more optimistic note. I’ve long said that professional speech is not the same thing as free speech. Specifically, we as physicians have a privileged status that is highly respected when it comes to our statements on medical matters (and, oddly enough, even on nonmedical matters, as nonsensical as that may seem). As a result, we have a particular professional responsibility not to spread misinformation, and professional ethics demands that we do not publicly promote quackery or disinformation. State medical boards should be enforcing this, but traditionally have not, just as they have been very reluctant to discipline outright quacks. They are understaffed and underfunded, which tends to disincentivize going after any but the most straightforward cases, such as doctors running prescription mills, sexually abusing patients, or suffering from substance abuse problems that impair their ability to practice medicine safely. Traditionally, they’ve been reluctant to engage in judgment calls on anything other than the rankest of quackery, and even then, as in the case of Dr. Burzynski, their track record is uneven at best. Policing professional speech about COVID-19 will be even more difficult.
        ◦ Even so, given the harm that physicians promoting misinformation cause, this is something that state medical boards need to undertake. If there could be one good outcome from the pandemic, it would be enhanced power of state medical boards to discipline physicians promoting medical misinformation and disinformation of all kinds, not just about COVID-19 or COVID-19 vaccines. As No License for Disinformation puts it, “Everyone has the right to an opinion. Doctors, however, are bound by an ethical and legal obligation to do no harm”. Physicians promoting misinformation and disinformation betray that obligation.

Tennessee hamstrings medical board fight against COVID misinformation and unproven treatments
A new Tennessee law hampers the state medical board’s efforts to rein in COVID misinformation and will make disciplining physicians prescribing unproven COVID treatments impossible until the board goes through cumbersome rule-making procedures, an effort that could outlast the pandemic.
Jann Bellamy on December 16, 2021
Link

Tennessee legislators have decided to encourage physician malpractice by bullying the state medical board into rescinding its COVID anti-misinformation policy and throwing huge bureaucratic obstacles in the board’s way before it can discipline physicians who use unproven COVID treatments, including downright quackery. Their blatant disregard for science, the details of which we’ll get to in a moment, comes even as the medical profession calls for more vigilance against disinformation and taking action against doctors who spread it, a subject SBM has covered extensively, along with the quack COVID treatments peddled by some physicians.
The Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) 2021 annual survey of member boards found that
    • 67% have experienced an increase in complaints related to licensee dissemination of false or misleading COVID-19 information;
    • 26% have made or published statements about the dissemination of false or misleading COVID-19 information; and
    • 21% have taken a disciplinary action against a licensee disseminating false or misleading COVID-19 information.
That last figure is encouraging news considering, as Dr. David Gorski lamented,
how rare it is for a state medical board to suspend or revoke the medical license of outright quacks and how difficult it has been on the occasions when a state has tried . . .
In July, the FSMB issued a statement reminding physicians who spread COVID misinformation that they risk disciplinary action. Since then, according to the FSMB, at least 15 boards published statements about false or misleading information and at least 12 boards have taken disciplinary action against a licensee. The FSMB is currently developing guidelines for medical boards to help address the spread of disinformation.
It is not clear to me why the FSBM’s statement emphasizes disinformation only and does not address the problem of physicians promoting unproven treatments like hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin.
In any event, as Dr. Gorski optimistically pointed out:
If there could be one good outcome from the pandemic, it would be enhanced power of state medical boards to discipline physicians promoting medical misinformation and disinformation of all kinds, not just about COVID-19 or COVID-19 vaccines.
Unfortunately, those who are hell-bent on protecting our “freedom” to thumb our collective noses at the common good and ignore public health measures as well as our “freedom” to access quack treatments are ever at the ready to quash any such efforts. It is thus that we find ourselves confronted with what the FSMB calls “troubling legislation” introduced in a number of states making it more difficult for licensing boards to discipline a licensee for spreading disinformation. The FSMB say it
strongly opposes any effort to restrict a board’s authority to evaluate the standard of care and assess risk for patient harm.
Which is exactly what the Tennessee legislature just accomplished in a new law that also includes sweeping anti-public health measures. With that, let’s turn to the specifics.
Tennessee: The Volunteer (to get COVID) State
The Tennessee Board of Medical Examiners, which regulates licensed physicians, voted in September to adopt a policy, based on the FSMB’s statement, that would subject physicians who create or spread COVID vaccine misinformation to disciplinary action.
According to the Chattanooga Times Free Press, at the time of the medical board meeting, at least 24 COVID-related complaints had been filed against health care practitioners and a lawyer for the board asked for guidance on how to handle three different types of these complaints:
    • Physicians sharing their personal anti-vaccine or vaccine-hesitant opinions with their patients.
    • Physicians sharing false information about vaccines in order to advise patients against vaccination.
    • Physicians spreading misinformation or disinformation to multiple patients across their practice.
In response, the board decided that physicians who disseminate false information about COVID vaccines (e.g., the myth that vaccines cause infertility) should face formal discipline, although they debated “the degree to which physicians should be allowed to express their personal opinions within the confines of the doctor-patient relationship.”
They ultimately agreed on a policy that physicians who “generate and spread COVID-19 vaccine misinformation or disinformation” risk disciplinary action. Physicians “must share information that is factual, scientifically-grounded and consensus-driven for the betterment of public health”.
In support of the policy, Dr. Melanie Blake, the boards’ president, said that
It is painfully clear to the physicians who have served on the front lines of this pandemic that COVID-19 vaccine misinformation has caused undue loss of life, loss of health, loss of jobs and other incalculable losses to our society. . . . I applaud the efforts to uphold our oath as physicians despite unprecedented challenges.
The new policy did not sit well state Rep. John Ragan (R-Oak Ridge) and some of his Republican colleagues. Ragan said that after the policy was adopted, “he received phone calls from practitioners across the state who were afraid their licenses would now be in jeopardy.” He complained that the policy did not define “misinformation” and “disinformation” and took the position that the board had, in effect, enacted a new rule without going through the formal rule-making procedure required by state law.
Ragan sent letters pressuring the board to delete the policy or risk being called before the legislature’s Joint Government Operations Committee. According to The Tennessean, an attorney who works with the board warned board members that Ragan had conveyed his “displeasure . . . in the strongest terms” and “made clear he has no qualms about moving forward with dissolving the [board] and reconstituting it with new members”, something he has “in fact done with another state agency”.
My take on Ragan’s position is that he has made a highly questionable interpretation of state administrative law and used it as a bludgeon to beat the medical board into submission lest it take action against physicians giving dubious advice about COVID, including vaccines, and promoting unproven treatments. (When you see what the Tennessee legislature subsequently did, which we’ll get to soon, I think you’ll agree with me.)
Ragan is correct that state law requires agency rules to go through a specific procedure before they can become law. This procedure can be extremely cumbersome and time-consuming, including notice to the public and an opportunity to be heard, review by the attorney general and legislature, and challenges to the rule that can take months, years even, to resolve.
But is the board’s policy a “rule”? I don’t think a fair interpretation of Tennessee law supports Ragan’s claim that it is. Without getting too much into the weeds of administrative law, a “rule” is defined by Tennessee law as an
agency statement of general applicability that implements or prescribes law or policy or describes the procedures or practice requirements of any agency.
But, the definition of “rule” specifically excludes
General policy statements that are substantially repetitious of existing law.
As board member Dr. Samantha McLerran correctly pointed out, under Tennessee law
the board has the power to discipline physicians for “unprofessional, dishonorable or unethical conduct” as well as for “making false statements or representations . . . or being guilty of fraud or deceit in the practice of medicine”.
She was of the opinion that the COVID misinformation policy fell under these existing prohibitions.
I agree. The board was simply restating the prohibitions already contained in state law as they applied to COVID, not promulgating a new rule. If Rep. Ragan’s interpretation is correct, then every time a physician is disciplined for infraction of the provisions cited by Dr. McLerren, whether or not COVID-related, he could challenge the board’s action based on the absence of a specific rule defining his conduct as unlawful.
Unfortunately, Rep. Ragan’s threats worked (sort of) and a special meeting of the medical board was called “out of an abundance of caution” based on a new state law signed by Gov. Bill Lee on November 12, according to board chair Dr. Blake. At the meeting, the board voted 7-3 to remove the policy from its website. However, displaying a lawyer-like talent for parsing words, Dr. Blake said the only request the board received was to delete the policy from the website, which it had done, but “our mission remains the same”. In other words, she confirmed that the policy itself remained in force. A Department of Health attorney then recommended that the board conduct a second vote on whether to rescind the policy outright, but the board declined and the meeting adjourned.
That “new law” (which is already being challenged in court) is sweeping legislation preventing government agencies, schools, and private businesses from imposing public health measures like vaccination and mask wearing, passed by the Tennessee legislature in a special session in October devoted to COVID. (A good summary can be found here.) It also creates a private right of action for injunctive relief and compensatory damages, as well as attorneys’ fees, for anyone “injured as a result of a violation” of the new law.
Per the Chattanooga Times Free Press, these measures
stem from anti-vaccination efforts taken up by some legislators who are being egged on by groups such as Tennessee Stands
For those of you unaware, Tennessee Stands is a conservative group that opposes masks and vaccine mandates, among other public health measures, and reportedly expressed support for the January 6th attack on the Capitol.
Specifically relating to physician discipline, during the special session, as described by MedPage Today, Rep. Chris Todd (R-Madison County) and Debra Moody (R-Covington) introduced bills limiting the medical board’s ability to discipline physicians for substandard care in COVID cases:
Rep. Todd’s bill, the Tennessee COVID-19 Treatment Freedom Act, would prevent the Tennessee Board of Medical Examiners from disciplining doctors for anything “solely related to the physician’s prescription, recommendation, use, or opinion relative to a treatment for COVID-19,” including treatments that aren’t approved by the state’s health department or the FDA.
Rep. Moody’s bill would prevent . . . [disciplinary] actions “so long as the physician exercised independent medical judgment and believes that the medical treatment is in the best interest of the patient,” and the patient consents.
The gist of these proposals, if not all of the language, made it into the final version of the legislation, which passed and was signed by the Governor despite what one law firm’s analysis described as “fierce opposition from the Tennessee business community, local school boards, health care providers, and other stakeholders”. (As an aside, all this state and federal COVID legislation has become essentially a full employment act for healthcare and employment lawyers.)
In a gigantic “screw you” aimed at the medical board, the new law requires both the medical and osteopathic boards to develop rules if they are to discipline practitioners for prescribing COVID-19 treatments. This means each board must go through the laborious and time-consuming process I briefly described earlier, including a review of the rules by the legislature’s Joint Government Operations Committee, co-chaired by none other than Rep. Ragan, before a physician can be disciplined for substandard prescribing. I assume that, until then, practitioners can prescribe whatever they want, including ivermectin, hydroxychloroquine, homeopathy, Black Oxygen Organics, Miracle Mineral Solution (bleach), herbs, dietary supplements, essential oils, and whatever else their tolerance for pseudoscience will allow, without risking discipline.
The new law also addresses monoclonal antibodies, allowing practitioners to prescribe and administer them as a treatment for or prophylaxis against COVID if they “exercise independent professional judgment” and “notwithstanding any guidance or advice from a governmental entity to the contrary”.
I am not sure where this gets the prescriber, other than the ability to disregard governmental (such as FDA or CDC) guidance. Although I could find no exact definition of what “independent professional judgment” means in medicine (the term doesn’t seem to have an agreed-upon definition), I don’t believe it means that you can toss medical science in making a treatment decision or that it absolves the physician of failure to meet standard of care. Even if government guidance would be excluded from evidence of malpractice in a disciplinary action against a practitioner, the board could still consider other evidence of standard of care, such as expert opinion and medical literature. But, of course, no disciplinary action can proceed anyway until the medical and osteopathic boards go through the cumbersome agency rule-making process.
If the board trips up and violates the new COVID law, a practitioner could bring a civil action against it per the law’s creation of a private right of action, complete with compensatory damages and attorneys’ fees. Whether this happens or not, the threat is certainly there, dampening any appetite to pursue disciplinary action which might possibly subject the board to litigation.
Not all Republicans are on board with the new law. Sen. Richard Briggs (R-Knoxville), a physician and the only Republican senator who voted against the bill, said that doctors have a responsibility to be a “reliable source of information”:
The Government Operations Committee (which will review any board disciplinary rules related to COVID), should not be telling the Board of Medical Examiners, who (are) charged with protecting the public health and safety, that they can’t do something to a doctor that’s intentionally giving known misinformation.
Sen. Heidi Campbell (D-Nashville) agrees:
Once we start as a legislature telling doctors how to practice medicine to the point we’re intervening in their ability to perform their duties, then we’ve got a big problem.
        ◦ She added that this “disdain” for science is putting Tennessee in “big, big trouble”. I think she’s right, only it’s not just in Tennessee.

COVID-19 has exposed the toothlessness of state medical boards
A report in The Washington Post last week revealed just how badly state medical boards have been failing when dealing with physicians spreading COVID-19 misinformation and using quackery to prevent and treat the disease. None of this is anything new, unfortunately. The pandemic has merely stress tested state medical boards, and most have failed because of political choices made long ago.
David Gorski on July 31, 2023
Link

You really think it’s all new.You really think about it too,The old man scoffed as he spoke to me,I’ll tell you a thing or two.
The Clash, Something About England
Last week, The Washington Post published an investigation that, unfortunately, jibes with much of what we at SBM have been writing about state medical boards for over 15 years. Reported by Lena Sun, Lauren Weber, and Hayden Godfrey and entitled Doctors who put lives at risk with covid misinformation rarely punished, the story is a great overview of the shortcomings of state medical boards that have been laid bare by the COVID-19 pandemic. However, as I will discuss, the problems with the regulation of physician practice by state medical boards go back long before the pandemic, which was a stress test on state medical boards that, for the most part, they have failed miserably. My first reaction to the story was a bit cynical, too, specifically some amazement that as many physicians as were described in the story had actually faced repercussions for their spreading dangerous misinformation about COVID-19 and even practicing outright quackery claiming to treat or prevent it. That’s just me, though. (Or maybe it isn’t.)
For the story, the three Post reporters did an analysis of disciplinary records of state medical boards for all 50 states, and in this case they don’t bury the lede:
A Wisconsin doctor in 2021 prescribed ivermectin, typically used to treat parasitic infections, to two covid-19 patients who later died of the disease. He was fined less than $4,000 — and was free to continue practicing.
A Massachusetts doctor has continued practicing without restriction despite being under investigation for more than a year over allegations of “disseminating misinformation” and prescribing unapproved covid treatments, including ivermectin, to a patient who died in 2022, according to medical board records.
And in Idaho, a pathologist who falsely promoted the effectiveness of ivermectin over coronavirus vaccines on social media has not been disciplined despite complaints from fellow physicians that his “dangerous and troubling” statements and actions “significantly threatened the public health.”
Across the country, doctors who jeopardized patients’ lives by pushing medical misinformation during the pandemic and its aftermath have faced few repercussions, according to a Washington Post analysis of disciplinary records from medical boards in all 50 states.
To say that this finding was…unsurprising…to me is an understatement. I’ve been writing about attempts to discipline dangerous physicians spreading COVID-19 misinformation and using quackery to treat the disease (the two very frequently go together hand-in-hand), and for every positive development that brings a ray of hope that state medical boards are beginning to understand I seem to find a lot more signs, like the Post story I’ll discuss (which features some doctors who have shown up on this blog before), for despair.
State medical boards and the failure to discipline physicians
State medical boards have long been a topic on SBM, dating back to the very first year of this blog’s existence, when Dr. Kimball Atwood devoted a series of posts about the pitfalls and failings in how state medical boards had been growing more and more open to medical “pseudospecialties” or “pseudodisciplines,” as we like to call them. He began by discussing how, as a result of advocacy by groups representing naturopaths, several states had been becoming more accepting of naturopathy, to the point of considering legislation that would legalize and regulate some of its quack treatments as though they were legitimate—or even the specialty itself—in, for example, Minnesota, Colorado, Massachusetts, and elsewhere. Unfortunately, the problem went beyond just the political question of deciding whether to regulate naturopathy as though it were a legitimate medical specialty, and to demonstrate this Dr. Kimball followed up with discussions of state medical boards investigating actual MD/DO licensed physicians who used actual quackery (e.g., intravenous hydrogen peroxide and chelation therapy for anything other than the existing very narrow conditions for which it is indicated), concluding with a discussion of how academic practitioners of what was then called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM, now more frequently called “integrative medicine” or “integrative health”) had been pressuring state medical boards to accept outright quackery as being legitimate medical treatments. Jan Bellamy also used to write frequently about state medical boards and their shortcomings when they were faced with disciplining physicians, as well as about efforts by advocates for medical pseudospecialties like naturopathy to persuade state legislatures to pass laws legitimizing their quackery and even turning them into legally recognized and regulated medical specialties. She even invented an apt term, “legislative alchemy,” to describe the efforts of advocates to persuade legislators to turn the lead of quackery (e.g., naturopathy and chiropractic) into the gold of a recognized medical specialty.
I myself not infrequently wrote about the failings of state medical boards with respect to physicians practicing actual quackery. It began with the attempt by the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners to discipline Dr. Buttar for his use of chelation therapy to treat autism and cancer. During the proceedings, Dr. Buttar famously (to us, anyway) called the Board a “rabid dog.” Ultimately, however, instead of permanently revoking Dr. Buttar’s medical license, the Board gave him a slap on the wrist, telling him that he could no longer treat children or cancer patients, rather than, as I put it at the time, “having his medical license stripped from him, cut up in front of his face, and then the fragments ritually burned,” which is the penalty that I thought he so richly deserved. What ultimately happened, despite the minor restrictions placed on Dr. Buttar’s practice was quite different.
Dr. Buttar, it turned out, was a significant “pioneer” of what became an all-too-common and distressing tactic among quacks since COVID-19: Attacking state medical boards and any other medical authority trying to rein in quacks and misinformation. His was the template that COVID-19 disinformation spreading doctors followed. Most people combatting disinformation now don’t appreciate just how influential Dr. Buttar was in terms of taking the war straight to state medical boards. Indeed, he and his allies eventually persuaded the state legislature to alter North Carolina state law to make it more quack-friendly by mobilizing public support to neuter the North Carolina Medical Board and prevent it from disciplining doctors who practice quackery associated with “integrative medicine.” Specifically, the 2008 law, passed due to the advocacy of the North Carolina Integrative Medical Society and Dr. Buttar, prevents the medical board from disciplining a physician for using “non-traditional” or “experimental treatments” unless it can prove they are ineffective or more harmful that prevailing treatments. In the end, Dr. Buttar basically won his battle with the North Carolina State Medical Board after losing what was in retrospect a relatively minor battle.
Another case in particular led to my writing about the failure of state medical boards more than any other, that of Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, the Polish expat physician who has been making extravagant claims for his unproven treatment for cancer, something he calls antineoplastons, since the late 1970s and, at 80 years of age, is still practicing in Houston, TX. Indeed, after the multiple hagiographies of a “brave maverick doctor” who’s “curing cancer” despite the resistance of the medical establishment, he still appears to be thriving. I’ve even seen the 2016 hagiography, Burzynski: The Cancer Cure Cover-Up, resurfacing on many of the same sites promoting COVID-19 misinformation, leading me to wonder if Burzynski has decided that antineoplastons are good for COVID-19 too. The main depressing point of my bringing up Burzynski is that, despite multiple attempts by the Texas Medical Board to discipline him for using unproven (and ineffective) treatments while charging patients huge sums of money, the last failed attempt in 2017, and attempts by the FDA to stop him, Dr. Burzynski is still in business. I also like to note when I discuss Dr. Burzynski how he pioneered many of the same misinformation techniques used today by doctors promoting COVID-19 misinformation, including cultivating relationships with sympathetic politicians and, above all, wielding believing patients as sympathetic shields against attempts to discipline him.
I also used to comment about how infrequent it was for outright antivax quacks who openly discouraged parents from vaccinating their children to face discipline prepandemic, asking what we should do about antivax physicians. Indeed, when such physicians did actually face discipline from their state medical boards, it was frequently based on other problems, such as how inadequate documentation brought down Dr. Bob Sears and use of homeopathy brought down Dr. Paul Thomas. Much of the time, it’s other offenses, not the quackery and antivax misinformation for which physicians were best known, that finally pushed state medical boards to act.
Unfortunately, a lot of upstanding physicians practicing science-based medicine are unduly disturbed by even the suggestion that state medical boards should discipline a physician for spreading misinformation about COVID-19. As much as I argue that it is not “cancel culture” but rather quality control to do so, political messaging has been successful in persuading all too many physicians to view attempts by state medical boards to discipline COVID-19 misinformation spreaders as potential threats to them.
How effective have state medical boards been? Not very
After the lede, the Post notes:
State medical boards charged with protecting the American public often failed to stop doctors who went against medical consensus and prescribed unapproved treatments for covid or misled patients about vaccines and masks, the Post investigation found.
At least 20 doctors nationally were penalized for complaints related to covid misinformation between January 2020 and June 2023, according to board documents, which The Post obtained by filing requests with state medical boards and reviewing public records. Five of those doctors lost their medical licenses — one had his revoked, while four surrendered theirs. Discipline is typically connected to patient care, not just what doctors say.
Again, I can’t help but expressing amazement that it was 20 physicians who were disciplined and five who actually lost their licenses to practice medicine. I would have guessed smaller numbers, much smaller. I will note that the Post nails the reasons why state medical boards often fail to act:
But they [state medical boards] are barely able to keep up with the more mundane task of issuing licenses, doctors say, let alone monitor social media, where many of the false claims proliferate. Critics say the system is not up to the task of overseeing the medical industry, and was particularly unable amid the explosion of misinformation that accompanied the pandemic.
“We allow the profession to police themselves. And when they fail to do that, even in the most egregious cases, what they are abetting is the erosion of trust and respect for doctors,” said Wendy Parmet, director of Northeastern University’s Center for Health Policy and Law, who has written about the harms of covid misinformation.
And:
Doctors don’t normally face discipline for promoting treatments that go against medical consensus because state boards are loath to tread on physicians’ medical judgment and First Amendment rights, according to doctors and members of medical boards. Physicians commonly prescribe drugs for conditions other than those they were approved for, a practice known as “off-label” use that boards do not want to curtail.
“State boards can only do limited things,” said Humayun Chaudhry, president of the Federation of State Medical Boards, a nonprofit that represents the licensing agencies. “The most common refrain I hear from state licensing boards is they would like to have more resources — meaning more individuals who can investigate complaints, more attorneys, more people who can process these complaints sooner — to do their job better.”
As I’ve said many times over the years, state medical boards are often underfunded and understaffed to the point where they can barely deal with obvious cases requiring urgent intervention, such as cases of physicians impaired by alcohol or other substance abuse disorders, grifting physicians running prescription mills, or physicians engaging in outright fraud. Cases of physicians practicing quackery—or, in the case of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine after 2020, when studies had definitively shown they don’t work—as “off-label prescribing” are more difficult and resource-intensive to pursue, if only because many of these quacks have significant resources to afford top flight law firms to represent them in front of the board, indeed far more resources than the board itself often has. Then, when it comes to misinformation, there’s always the issue of the First Amendment and the reluctance to penalize a physician for what, misinformation spreaders will claim, is Constitutionally protected speech. On the other hand, speech frequently goes hand-in-hand with quackery. Misinformation-spreading physicians often base their treatment of COVID-19 patients on the misinformation, sometimes with serious grifting, as when America’s Frontline Doctors were busted for running an ivermectin telehealth prescription mill.
The point is, state medical boards, given their lack of resources, tend to go after the “low hanging fruit,” cases they can win without the expenditure of a lot of resources, cases like physicians impaired by substance abuse or physicians sexually abusing patients under the guise of medicine. As I once put it years before the pandemic:
…as Dr. Lipson pointed out, state medical boards are notoriously toothless. Think about it. How many times has the Texas Medical Board gone after Stanislaw Burzynski over the last 38 years and failed? Or what about the quack whose friendship with the town sheriff led to the identification of the nurses who complained about him and their suffering severe professional and legal consequences as a result? Or what about the neurosurgeon who can’t operate and injured many patients? Or what about the oncologist who administered chemotherapy to patients without cancer and administered medically-unnecessary chemotherapy to patients with cancer? So bad was his behavior that a nurse interviewing for a job noticed that the chemotherapy was being mixed up incorrectly and complained to the state medical board with no result. This oncologist was only brought down when the feds investigated massive Medicare fraud. Second, medical boards need a concrete complaint, and that concrete complaint usually has to be about the actual practice of medicine. The Arizona Board, for example, might list 49 definitions of unprofessional conduct, but try fitting speaking out about vaccines into any of them. In Dr. Wolfson’s case, one might tag him under #19, “any conduct or practice contrary to recognized standards of ethics of the osteopathic medical profession.” Maybe.
The bottom line is that state medical boards tend to be toothless, underfunded, and overwhelmed. That’s why the only physician behaviors very likely to result in strong action consists of running a prescription mill, diddling patients, or practicing while impaired by abuse of alcohol or illicit substances. It’s a matter of resource allocation and prioritization. State medical boards tend to react primarily to what they perceive to be the most immediately and obviously dangerous behaviors. Practicing quackery rarely makes the cut, because medical boards are loathe to make value judgments about medical practice, and proving quackery is way harder and more resource-intensive than proving a doctor is an addict practicing while impaired or that he’s diddling patients. Even horrible surgeons like Dr. Duntsch, whose epic incompetence in the operating room resulted in multiple “clean kills” and so-alarmed colleagues that they actually took the rare action of complaining about him, all too often take a long time to take down.
Adjudicating whether a given treatment (or off-label use of an FDA-approved drug) is quackery and sufficiently below the accepted standard of care or not to warrant discipline is something that they are much more reluctant to do because, again, quacks often have a lot of resources to argue, delay, and claim that their treatments aren’t quackery, as Drs. Buttar and Burzynski used to do routinely decades ago.
Another point came up in the story’s discussion of the case of Massachusetts physician Dr. John Diggs, who faced discipline for “prescribing ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine to a patient with covid symptoms who died in 2022 after being intubated”:
The board alleged that Diggs prescribed the medications despite “clear evidence for the lack of any clinical benefit of hydroxychloroquine” and the fact that “ivermectin has been proven ineffective.”
The medical board accused Diggs of providing treatment to two patients that fell “below the standard of care.” It also accused him of “disseminating misinformation” on a Worcester, Mass., radio program in December 2020 when he promoted unproven coronavirus treatments touted by the alliance. At least two physicians lodged complaints in 2021 accusing him of “physician misconduct related to egregious COVID-19 misinformation and medical care well outside of the standard of care” and alleging “significant risk of patient harm,” board records show.
In documents detailing his response to board charges, Diggs denied disseminating misinformation on the radio program but admitted to prescribing ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine and advocating for treatment of covid based on “studies from recognized medical professional organizations.” His lawyer, in the documents, accused the board of violating Diggs’s free-speech rights by “attempting to inhibit the expression of his medical opinions.”
While I realize that it is a tricky line between professional and personal speech, I have frequently argued that professionalism in medicine includes not spreading misinformation. Of course, it is far less difficult to take action against a physician practicing quackery than it is to do so against a physician simply spreading COVID-19 misinformation and not treating patients using interventions based on that misinformation, and Dr. Diggs was, in my opinion, treating patients with quackery, ineffective treatments against COVID-19, and then trying to absolve himself of responsibility by disingenuously blaming COVID-19 for their deaths, as if they were like patients who die in spite of being given effective treatment rather than patients given false hope by his promotion of ineffective treatments. This is a frequent theme among COVID-19 quacks:
Some of the doctors cited in the misinformation-related complaints have defended their actions by saying they adhered to covid-treatment guidelines recommended by organizations that promote alternative therapies — guidelines rejected by major medical societies and government agencies. They said patients died of covid — not because of misinformation or the therapies they provided.
“Organizations that promote alternative therapies”? Does that sound familiar? It should. It’s what we’ve been warning about for 15 years, fake medical societies that promote unscientific or pseudoscientific quackery, or, as Dr. Atwood once called them, pseudomedical pseudoprofessional organizations (PPOs) back in 2008. Since the pandemic, the PPO has, if anything, flourished more than any of us could ever have predicted. Just as they were wielded by quacks in 2008 against state medical boards and in favor of legalizing and regulating quack professions like naturopathy, in the age of COVID-19 these PPOs have become major forces for defending antivaccine misinformation and COVID-19 quackery against attempts to discipline doctors. Add to that the political polarization that has led those largely of a certain political persuasion to side with the COVID-19 pandemic minimizers, quacks, and antivaxxers, and state legislators are working to make the jobs of state medical boards even more difficult by placing restrictions on their ability to consider disciplining COVID-19 misinformation spreaders, decreasing their funding, and worse. One can understand how state medical boards, particularly in states with legislatures controlled by physicians of such a political bent, might be reluctant to risk incurring the wrath of the government by pursuing cases against COVID-19 quacks and misinformation spreaders, or, as the Post reports:
As of June, medical boards in at least 14 states had taken disciplinary action against one or more physicians for misinformation-related causes, The Post’s analysis shows. Nine of those states have Democratic governors, leaving more-conservative swaths of the country unprotected given that board members are usually appointed by the governor, subjecting them to political head winds.
And:
In the last two years, Missouri, North Dakota and Tennessee have passed laws that would protect doctors from disciplinary actions for prescribing ivermectin, according to The Post’s review of more than 80 bills, including those identified by the Federation of State Medical Boards, the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials and the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University.
And:
In addition, attorneys general in six states — Indiana, Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Tennessee and South Carolina — have issued opinions saying doctors can prescribe ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, with four of them determining doctors cannot be disciplined for off-label prescription to treat covid.
You get the idea. Moreover, the passage of laws designed to legitimize COVID-19 quackery is nothing new either. We have been warning about the phenomenon since 2008. For example, in California there was SB 577, a bill was passed and signed into law back in 2002 designed to regulate alternative medicine practitioners. Basically, it allows the practice of medicine without a license, as long as the practitioner provides clients with a clear statement that he is not a licensed physician, a list of services provided, and a description of training. California is by no means alone, either. Jann Bellamy has pointed to bills and laws that she refers to as the quack full employment act (Colorado) and “quack protection law” (Nevada). Such are the fruits of the “health freedom” movement and the increasing acceptance of pseudoscience that prosecutors, state medical boards, and the police have a hard time prosecuting and convicting even the most egregious quacks. Add to that an insufficiently-rigorous and poorly-funded regulatory structure in most states, coupled with excessive deference to the prerogatives of physicians, and what is happening now is no surprise to those of us who have been documenting these problems for many years, particularly when you consider that most state medical boards can’t even begin to investigate a physician until and unless there is a complaint filed about that physician’s treatment of a patient or patients.
The Post story includes a litany of doctors whom state medical boards in various states have tried to hold to account for treating patients with ineffective and unapproved treatments and/or spreading COVID-19 misinformation, including names we’ve discussed here before, such as Dr. Maryl Nass, Dr. Ryan Cole, and Dr. Steven La Tulippe, and others that we have not, such as the aforementioned Dr. Diggs, as well as Wisconsin physician Dr. Edward Hagen and Nevada physician Dr. Medina Culver, the latter of whom brings me to a puzzling point.
Why don’t victims sue COVID-19 quacks?
I’ll finish by discussing Dr. Culver, who, according to the Post story, is currently the defendant of a malpractice suit, something that is unfortunately relatively rare when it comes to victims of quacks, be they COVID-19 quacks now or cancer quacks like Stanislaw Burzynski over the last four and a half decades:
In Nevada, Jelena Hatfield and her husband, Jeremy Parker, did not believe what federal health officials said about the safety or effectiveness of the coronavirus vaccines and refused to get a shot.
Instead, Hatfield said the couple sought what Trump had touted early in the pandemic as an alternative way to protect themselves: hydroxychloroquine. After Trump’s repeated promotion, the FDA issued an emergency-use authorization in March 2020 allowing the antimalarial drug to be used to treat covid. By early June of that year, however, virtually every published study reported that the medication was not effective in reducing death or illness, and the FDA revoked its authorization because of reports of serious side effects, including heart problems.
But a year later, Medina Culver, a family medicine physician in Henderson, Nev., prescribed hydroxychloroquine to Parker as a preventive treatment during a telehealth visit, Hatfield said. She said that Parker had connected with Culver through America’s Frontline Doctors, which shot to prominence in 2020 by challenging pandemic health guidance, and that the doctor never performed a physical exam of her husband.
In January 2022, Parker began having cold-like symptoms, assumed he had contracted covid and, unbeknown to his wife or Culver, took the medication that he had stashed away. The 52-year-old construction worker died within days, Hatfield said.
TIME Magazine reported on the case in May 2023, and it turns out that Jeremy Parker was the victim of a telehealth grift run by America’s Frontline Doctors :
The previous summer, Jelena discovered, Jeremy had started following AFLD online after listening to podcasts that promoted conspiracies about COVID-19. At the time, the group was producing slick videos on social media, falsely claiming that U.S. health agencies were withholding life-saving treatments, and that doctors refusing to prescribe them were like “good Germans who allow the Nazis to kill the Jews.” Jeremy, who worked as an industrial sandblaster, became convinced that hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin were the only effective treatments for the virus.
On Aug. 26, 2021, Jeremy paid $90 for a consultation through AFLD’s online telemedicine portal. He was connected to a doctor named Medina Culver, 33, an osteopathic physician and Instagram influencer based in Henderson, Nev. Culver did not see or examine Jeremy. Over the phone, she prescribed him hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19 treatment or prevention, according to a receipt reviewed by TIME. Soon after, Jeremy received a prescription for 200mg of hydroxychloroquine in the mail from Ravkoo, a Florida-based pharmacy chain partnered with AFLD. According to his widow’s lawsuit, he took those hydroxychloroquine pills the night he died.
Jeremy’s family is suing both AFLD and Culver in Nevada district court for in excess of $30,000 in damages. The lawsuit, which was filed in February on behalf of his estate and cites TIME’s 2021 investigation, alleges that his death was linked to the falsehoods spread by AFLD as well as the doctor who prescribed it. “They didn’t even examine him. They gave him something that he used as they prescribed, and it killed him,” Jelena Parker-Hatfield says. “How can they not be held accountable for something? How in America can this be a system that works, that everybody is okay with?”
This is a good question. After all, what is being described sounds an awful lot like the telehealth ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine prescription mill grift that AFLD was running in 2021, right down to the use of the Ravkoo pharmacy chain to fill the prescriptions and the $90 charge for a telehealth consultation. It was a scam uncovered through investigations by TIME Magazine and The Intercept in 2021. What is depressing, though, is that the family is only suing for $30,000, which is not very much to AFD and many other grifting COVID-19 quacks, many of whom have profited handsomely from their activities during the pandemic, as documented by TIME Magazine.
As a physician, I will confess that I generally have a relatively dim view of most malpractice suits, as there are many that are dubious. On the other hand, I’m probably more open than a lot of other doctors to such suits when there is legitimate malpractice, and to me recommending ivermectin or hydroxychloroqine by telehealth instead of vaccination to prevent COVID-19 is definitely practicing so far below the standard of care that it should qualify as malpractice; so I fully approve when victims of quacks sue for malpractice. It’s just that it so rarely seems to happen. This is an observation that is not just true now but was true long before the pandemic.
Indeed, a discussion of this very issue came up in the comments after one of my posts about Stanislaw Burzynski and Robert O. Young as poster children for failures of states to rein in quacks. In Burzynski’s case, there is a cap in Texas on judgments on punitive damages above $250,000, making such cases less attractive for attorneys to take on contingency. Bob Blaskiewicz, for instance, noted that Burzynski has settled out of court and that one of plaintiffs, being a patient with advanced cancer, unfortunately died before the case could go to trial. Moreover, most malpractice suits are lost, and in the case of malpractice suits against quacks it is likely to be difficult overcoming the likely argument by the defense that the patient made the choice not to vaccinate and instead choose “alternative” treatments like ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine. It is often difficult to determine what patients were and were not told about such treatments, as well.
The bottom line is that now, as in years past, state medical boards are largely toothless when it comes to regulating the practice of medicine and stopping dangerous doctors from endangering patients. The unfortunate bottom line is that the long history of efforts by the health freedom movement to eliminate any effective enforcement of the standard of care in medicine, the antivaccine movement to shield antivax doctors and legitimize their quackery, and right-to-try advocates to weaken the FDA have led to the current situation in which most quacks, be they COVID-19 misinformation pushing quacks or old school quacks (the two becoming less and less distinguishable by the year) are pretty safe from investigation or discipline by their state medical boards. This was true before the pandemic, and I like to cite the example of Dr. Farid Fata, an oncologist who administered chemotherapy to patients who did not have cancer in order to defraud Medicare and Medicaid to the tune of $35 million over several years. It wasn’t the Michigan Board of Medicine that put a stop to his intentionally misdiagnosing patients in order to justify treating them with expensive chemotherapy; it was the feds investigating Medicare and health insurance fraud.
Until there is the political will to empower state medical boards to go after quacks, again be they COVID-19 quacks or any other quack, and provide the resources to them to be able to do so without risking starving their other important activities of funding, it unfortunately appears that a patient’s best defense is a healthy skepticism, as in “let the patient beware,” which is very difficult given the differential in medical knowledge between physicians and their patients, with the most likely means of punishing such doctors being to sue them for malpractice after they have injured a patient. Even more unfortunately, that is a hard road that frequently fails, and I don’t see the political landscape changing any time soon to allow state legislatures to properly empower and fund their state medical boards. We should be putting the pressure on our representatives to do just that.

Open Letter to a Dean: You’re Allowed to Speak
You can publicly disagree with a medical student who carries the imprimatur of your university and who has gained attention in the national media by spreading misinformation.
Jonathan Howard on May 23, 2023
Link

Note: Dr. Berk sadly passed away peacefully from heart disease several days after this was written. He was clearly a beloved doctor and teacher who made his school and community an infinitely better place. Our thoughts are with his family and friends.
Dear Dr. Berk,
A theme of my writing is that people with no real-world responsibility for a problem should be very careful when lecturing those with actual responsibility. It’s very easy for people to say what they would do in a tough situation. I interact with medical students all the time, but I’ve never been asked to discipline any of them, especially in a public way. So I am wary of giving you advice, since that’s what’s being asked of you regarding a problematic medical student who has spread COVID misinformation in the national media, most recently spreading the myth that doctors in New York City, where I’ve worked throughout the pandemic, killed large numbers of patients through intubations.
On Twitter, you seemed unsure what to do. You said:
I agree with much of what you said, and I don’t know the proper response either. Medical schools are indeed being challenged by online speech, and you cannot and should not police every comment by every student. Like myself, you signed up to be a doctor and educator, not an online policeman.
Moreover, we both know that if you criticize this student’s ideas in the slightest way, two things will happen.
    • You will be accused of personally attacking and trying to censor the student. One way that people silence voices like yours is to weaponize their perceived victimhood by saying you are “attacking” or “censoring” them whenever you merely correct their factual errors.
    • You will face hostile social media backlash. This student has become a mini-celebrity of sorts through his oh-so controversial hot takes, and he might turn on a firehouse of Twitter nastiness on you. I’ve been doing this for a long time, and I know what that’s like.
I understand why you might want to not touch that hornet’s nest. Your current path spares you these accusations and vitriol.
Loud doctors reflexively claim to be silenced when they are merely criticized (image credit Philipp Markolin)
However, I also found your response lacking. No one asked you to weigh in on “every comment a medical student” makes. The fact that you can’t respond to every comment by every student, doesn’t mean you can’t comment on any comment by any student. This student clearly relishes his role as a contrarian influencer, and will likely continue to escalate his rhetoric lest he not be seen as “edgy” and “controversial.” Thanks to audience capture, he’ll follow his followers wherever they lead him.
That he is a medical student at your school means you see him as someone who is fit to treat patients in the near future as a doctor. You rightfully say you would not tolerate an unprofessional comment towards an individual patient. However, medical professionals (including students) have a similar obligation when presenting themselves as experts to the general public. You seem to imply that unprofessional advice that would be intolerable if given to an individual patient should be ignored when it is given to a much larger audience of strangers. This doesn’t make much sense to me.
Moreover, you don’t have to silence anyone, especially yourself. You are allowed to speak. You can publicly disagree with a medical student who carries the imprimatur of your university and who has gained attention in the national media by spreading misinformation. Publicly pointing out his errors is not censoring him or attacking him, though you will be accused of this if you critique this student in any way. But, so what? I don’t think either of us is in a vulnerable position in our careers. Having strangers say mean things to us on Twitter isn’t such a heavy burden, is it?
Like I said, it’s easy for me to say what I would do if I were you, and maybe you worry that critiquing this medical student will allow him to parlay his victimhood into even greater stardom. That’s a very legitimate concern, and if that’s the conclusion you’ve reached after giving this careful thought, I respect it 100%. I’ve previously made the mistake of contradicting people only to inadvertently amplify a voice that otherwise might have faded silently away. I don’t want to do that again. “Heterodox” influencers often have a short shelf-life, and I don’t want to give this student attention in this article.
However, your silence also sends a message- namely, that medical misinformation really isn’t worth making a fuss over. You’re not alone. Sadly, rather than risk being called mean names, many “leaders” in American medicine have muzzled themselves when members of their department spread gross misinformation. They were so afraid of being accused of abusing their power, they refused to ever use their power, not even to speak.
Their extraordinary docility allowed more vocal doctors to fill the void and instruct young people to refuse life-saving vaccines, with tragic consequences for some of them. When the stakes are made clear, it turns out that often medical misinformation really is worth making a fuss over. And it’s not that hard. You don’t have to expel or threaten this student in any way. All you have to is use your own voice and say where you think he erred.
Of course, I am just assuming you think he erred. But I don’t really know that, do I?

Retracted papers about COVID-19 are more highly cited than they should be
Earlier this month a study showed that papers about COVID-19 that are retracted tend to be cited far more than average and continue to be heavily cited after retraction. Clearly, scientific publishing and the scientific community need to do better.
David Gorski on May 1, 2023
Link

Some of my colleagues have been surprised at the number of really awful papers that have been published during the pandemic and reach conclusions that are at odds with thus-far established science. Examples abound, a number of which we have written about, including articles by academics whom I used to admire (or at least view more favorably than unfavorably), such as John Ioannidis, Vinay Prasad, and a number of others, some, admittedly, noto particularly admirable before the pandemic (such as Peter Doshi). Seemingly, even the Cochrane Collaborative has gotten in on this action, along with past leaders. Most were in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature, too, although not all. (The utter crapfest of an anonymously authored study that wasn’t peer-reviewed that was published by the Florida Department of Health last fall and suggested that COVID-19 vaccines are more dangerous than COVID comes to mind. Surprise! The paper went through multiple iterations personally overseen by Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo and clearly designed to make the vaccines look worse than the disease.) They shouldn’t have been. Publishing academic research articles as a form of misinformation and propaganda for quackery is a longstanding tactic used by advocates of unscientific medicine, such as proponents of alternative medicine and antivaxxers.
That’s why I’m happy that one of the most prominent physicians turned COVID-19 misinformation spreaders, Dr. Peter McCullough, reminded me of a study that I had though about blogging about a couple of weeks ago. True, it’s one of his paid Substack articles, entitled Retracted COVID-19 Articles: Significantly More Cited than Others, which he touts as evidence that “biopharmaceutical complex censorship” is “backfiring.” The study itself was published three weeks ago in Scientometrics by Trenton Taros and investigators at the University of Massachusetts and entitled Retracted Covid-19 articles: significantly more cited than other articles within their journal of origin.
Since I don’t subscribe to Dr. McCullough’s Substack (and will never pay someone like him for the privilege of reading their Substack articles), all I can cite is the first paragraph, but the first paragraph is enough to give you a good idea of what Dr. McCullough is about. Naturally, he starts by bragging about his publication record, something I always find annoying because, as I like to say, I don’t care about what he published in the past. I care very deeply about the misinformation he publishes now and has published since the pandemic hit three years ago, such as the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines are killing hundreds of thousands—or even millions—of people.
Let’s see what Dr. McCullough has to say, though:
I have 685 listings in the National Library of Medicine PUBMED where my academic contributions as a first or contributing author or as a site principle investigator have been memorialized. I am the former longstanding editor Reviews in Cardiovascular Medicine and Cardiorenal Medicine—both are indexed in PUBMED. I have handled thousands of manuscripts and can tell you first hand, historically, that retractions of fully published reports was exceedingly rare. It was only done in the most grievous cases of academic fraud that was discovered after a paper had fully made it through the peer-review process. Since the onset of the crisis, starting with early treatment of COVID-19, we have seen an unprecedented number of papers retracted after full publication and indexing in the National Library of Medicine. As an author and experienced editor, I wanted to understand what is going on in the case of pandemic paper retractions.
Before I move on to the publication that he is clearly talking about (the discussion of which I thank him for reminding me to write), let’s just unpack that last part about retractions of “fully published reports” being “exceedingly rare.” Guess what? He’s correct about that! Here’s where we disagree. He views rarity of retractions prepandemic as a good thing. I do not. I’ve long argued that there’s a lot of dreck and fraud in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature that really could use some retracting. Journals have been painfully reluctant to do that. The most notorious example, one that I like to cite a lot, is how it took 13 years for The Lancet to retract Andrew Wakefield’s infamous 1998 case series that claimed to link vaccination with the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to “autistic enterocolitis,” and it took undeniable revelations of scientific fraud unearthed by investigative journalist Brian Deer to finally prod The Lancet‘s editor Richard Horton to pull the trigger and retract. I could list a number of other truly awful antivax papers that we’ve written about here over the years that should be retracted and, in some cases, have been retracted, and note that, even when an awful or outright fraudulent paper is exposed as such, journal editors frequently resist retracting and then drag their heels as long as they can before finally retracting.
Before I go on to discuss the actual study that Dr. McCullough is presenting as “evidence” that “biopharmaceutical complex censorship” is “backfiring,” I’ll also mention that I’m rather surprised that this paper didn’t get more play in COVID-19 denial social media since its publication. After all, as you will see, what Taros et al found is that articles ultimately retracted by the journals that published them tend to garner more citations and engagement than other articles in the same journals (indeed, in the same issues of the same journals where the retracted papers had been originally published).
COVID-19 retractions
One key passage near the beginning of the study caught my eye because it so obviously went against Dr. McCullough’s lament about how rare retractions were back in his good old days. In brief, the authors note that the growth rate for scientific publication jumped dramatically in 2020, which, not coincidentally, was the year the COVID-19 pandemic hit:
In an age of expansion for modern medicine, coinciding with the continued growth of the internet, there has been a rapid expansion in the volume of scientific research activity and rate of publication. A 2021 study indicated a 4% annual growth in global publication output in peer-reviewed science and engineering journal articles as well as conference papers from 2010 to 2020 (National Science Board, 2021). The same study reports a 3% annual growth rate for biomedical and health sciences from 2009 to 2019, but an astounding 15% and 16% growth rate for each respectively in 2020. With this growth, new sets of academic standards for publication arise, along with increasingly important sets of ethical standards (Brand et al., 2004; Coats, 2009). As those standards are investigated and enforced, retraction of published papers from scientific journals becomes crucial to preserve scientific integrity and properly educate the general public and scientific community.
That last part, to me, is key. Retractions are quality control, not, as Dr. McCullough and his admiring COVID-19 contrarians and quacks characterize them, censorship. I will repeat yet again that the problem with biomedical literature is not that too many studies are being retracted; it’s that too few are and how difficult it is to get even those retracted. Taros et al point exactly this aspect of retractions out:
As the volume of scientific literature expands, retraction volume and rate have also increased (Nagella & Madhugiri, 2020; Steen, 2011). These retractions represent a self-corrective function built into the scientific research process to protect the integrity of the scientific method. Retraction of a published article can be initiated by the author or publisher for a variety of reasons: Institutional Review Board (IRB) violations, data errors, forgery, plagiarism, and inappropriate authorship, among others (Budd et al., 1998). A major concern for those articles which are retracted is their rate of citation prior to, and after retraction. This is particularly important if they are found in high-impact, prestigious, or influential journals, as this propagates the dissemination of false, inaccurate, or inconclusive information (Dinh et al., 2019).
This is indeed a concern. Andrew Wakefield’s fraudulent case series, for instance, was both widely cited and widely shared on social media. (In fact, Retraction Watch lists it as the second most highly cited retracted paper of all time, with 643 citations before retraction and 940 after retraction.) The authors note that “number of papers pertaining to COVID-19 which have been retracted continues to rise to over 200, based on the Retraction Watch Database (RWD) COVID-19 blog (Marcus & Oransky, 2022).” Coincidentally, I note, going over to the Retraction Watch blog’s weekend update, that the number is now up to over 300.
What the authors did was to test the following hypothesis:
We hypothesized that retracted COVID-19 articles received more attention, measured in citations, than would be expected for the average article in the journal they were published in over the same time period. In presenting a quantitative analysis of retracted COVID-19 articles published in medical and life science journals, we hope to shine light on the attention these articles garnered and provide possible rationale for this occurrence. The inclusion of SCImago Journal Ranking (SJR) is used to demonstrate that this phenomenon was not isolated to smaller journals but included journals of all sizes and prestige levels. It is our hope to add to the conversation regarding COVID-19 retractions and the state of scientific literature during the pandemic.
The authors did not include preprints (which is another topic to me entirely, given how often preprints have been weaponized by quacks in order to get their bogus studies in the public record before they’ve actually been peer-reviewed) or any paper published after 2021. That latter exclusion criteria was because the authors thought that papers published in 2022 would not have had enough time for their citation records to have stabilized.
This flow diagram demonstrates what they did:

Most of the 90 retracted papers were about epidemiology, disease course, and treatments; surprisingly (to me, anyway) the percentage of papers about COVID-19 vaccines that were retracted were only one-third of the number that were about epidemiology and only one-half the number about treatment.
As for the reasons for retraction:
Those 90 articles were accessed and broadly divided into categories based on content and reason for retraction. 28 of the articles focused on epidemiology, 20 on disease course, and 22 on treatment (Fig. 2). In 53 of the cases, the publisher initiated the retraction proceedings. In 18 instances the request was initiated by the author. The requesting party was unknown in the remaining 19 instances. There were a wide variety of reasons for retraction with little standardization, at least 7 articles were retracted due to concerns for plagiarism and at least 5 for IRB violations.
I will admit that it was a pleasant surprise that over half the retractions were initiated by the publisher and that only five were retracted for IRB violations. Less pleasant was the author’s finding that 32% of the retraction statement for 32% of the retracted articles did not meet the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines for retraction statements, which state that notices of retraction should:
    • Be linked to the retracted article wherever possible (ie, in all online versions)
    • Clearly identify the retracted article (eg, by including the title and authors in the retraction heading or citing the retracted article)
    • Be clearly identified as a retraction (ie, distinct from other types of correction or comment)
    • Be published promptly to minimise harmful effects
    • Be freely available to all readers (ie, not behind access barriers or available only to subscribers)
    • State who is retracting the article
    • State the reason(s) for retraction
    • Be objective, factual and avoid inflammatory language
The authors observe:
In only 71 cases was it possible to discern which party requested the retraction. Far fewer had clear explanations for why articles were retracted. In our analysis, 32% of retracted articles did not meet the COPE guidelines for retraction statements (Barbour et al., 2009). This is because either the retracting party or retraction reason was not included within the retraction notice. Obscuring the reason for retraction obfuscates the bravery and integrity needed to willingly retract one’s own work (Vuong, 2020). Additionally, it prevents researchers who have cited works that have since been retracted from evaluating the legitimacy of their own claims.
I can’t help but wonder how much of this disappointing lack of transparency among journals is due to concern about legal implications. If there’s one thing about society in general—and COVID-19 contrarians who publish papers like this, it’s that we live in a very litigious society. I have to wonder if the reason why so many retraction notices do not include a mention of which party requested the retraction and/or a clear explanation of the reason for the retraction is due to fear of legal liability.
I also note that the speed of retraction does not appear to be particularly fast for COVID-19 papers, at least no more so than for any other. Take a look at this graph, which is basically a Kaplan-Meier survival curve of time from publication to retraction:

The median time from publication to retraction was 175 days, which is nearly six months! It’s impossible to tell how much of that time is delay between the time a retraction is requested to the actual retraction and how much is how long the journal takes to come to a decision, but it’s definitely not short.
Now here’s the money finding of the paper:
Retracted articles accrued a median number of 10.0 (IQR 26) citations while CiteScore accrued a median of 4.2 (IQR 3.7) citations (Fig. 4). The difference between the average CiteScore and average citation number for a retracted article was 37.5, a statistically significant difference (p = 0.01).
Or, to show it visually:
The authors also note that by November 2020 the retraction rate for COVID-19-related papers had reached a level five times that of the general science literature, complete with clear “instances of intentional malpractice and fraudulent publications” in “some of the world’s most noteworthy journals.” This is, of course, consistent with what we at SBM have been blogging about since the very beginning of the pandemic. Noting that these papers have garnered a disproportionately high impact in the scientific literature, the authors speculate on possible reasons:
Retracted COVID-19 publications may have been more likely to include bold or novel claims that garnered a disproportionately high amount of attention from others in the scientific community. The phenomenon of “clickbait” titles could explain how certain publications gained more attention and led to further writing on a potentially misleading claim.
This is, of course, one of those findings that I intuitively sense to be almost certainly accurate, but that I cannot yet prove. Moving on, the authors conceded that COVID-19 articles in general have tended to attract more attention than other topics, because, you know, a pandemic that’s killed over a million people in just the US alone since early 2020, but argue that that alone can’t explain the difference:
It is true that COVID-19 publications accumulated a disproportionate amount of attention regardless of retraction status (Ioannidis et al., 2022). However, the large discrepancy between CiteScore and number of citations is not likely due to an increased amount of interest in COVID literature given the magnitude of the difference between CiteScore and citation number in retracted articles. A direct comparison between retracted and non-retracted COVID-19 publications for each respective journal was beyond the scope of this analysis.
This would be an interesting analysis to do. My prediction is that the difference between citation counts of retracted versus non-retracted papers would shrink but still remain substantial. Moreover, the finding that most concerns me is this:
Unfortunately, retracted COVID-19 papers continue to accumulate citations well past their date of retraction. Analysis at two time points, June and November of 2022, showed 728 total additional citations across all 93 articles analyzed across this time frame. This equates to just shy of 5 citations of retracted COVID-19 papers per day. It does not appear that measures taken to curb their citation have much effect either. For example, there was no significant difference in additional citations between those articles bearing “withdrawn” or “retracted” headings and those without them. Ultimately, this places the onus to limit the perpetuation of inaccurate, retracted information squarely on the scientific community itself. It is up to researchers to analyze their citations as closely as they analyze their conclusions.
Truly, these are what I like to refer to as either zombie studies in that they are undead and will live forever unless very specific actions are taken to kill them (e.g., a bullet to the brain), or they are “slasher studies,” named after the unstoppable killers in 1980s horror movies (like Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers) who, even after seemingly having been killed at the end of one movie, always somehow manage to live again to hunt a new group of randy teens or college students in sequels. Whichever characterization you prefer, it is up to individual scientists to vet their citations and not cite retracted papers unless the retraction is discussed or at least mentioned.
Retraction: A brief case study
I will conclude by mentioning that retraction is a two-edged sword. It is, as I have argued many times in the past, necessary quality control for the scientific literature. Unsurprisingly, cranks, quacks, and antivaxxers don’t see it that way—and never have. The most recent example is Steve Kirsch’s reaction to a very bad paper by Prof. Mark Skidmore, an economist at Michigan State University. (The shame, the shame, for my state. Even though I have no connection with MSU and never went to school there, a number of people I’ve known over the years and some of their kids have. I’ve also known some excellent faculty members at MSU.) At the time, I characterized the paper, entitled The role of social circle COVID-19 illness and vaccination experiences in COVID-19 vaccination decisions: an online survey of the United States population, as reminding me, more than anything else, of a Steve Kirsch “study” in which a fundamentally bad research design is tarted up with (some) seemingly legitimate social science research methodology and then dishonestly spun to produce a fake estimate of 278,000 fatalities due to COVID-19 vaccines, which is then “validated” by an incompetent dumpster dive into the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database of the sort that I’ve been writing about since 2006.
Yes, you read that right. Prof. Skidmore basically did survey asking people if they knew anyone who had died after vaccination against COVID-19 and then used that survey to estimate that “the total number of fatalities due to COVID-19 inoculation may be as high as 278,000 (95% CI 217,330–332,608) when fatalities that may have occurred regardless of inoculation are removed.” Let’s just say that the survey/study was every bit as bad as it sounds from just that characterization and that it was a bait-and-switch, whose purpose was ostensibly to “identify the factors associated by American citizens with the decision to be vaccinated against COVID-19” but whose true purpose rapidly became apparent: To try to “prove” that the vaccines killed hundreds of thousands of people. Unsurprisingly, Prof. Skidmore is not a scientist with any relevant expertise in epidemiology, virology, infectious diseases, or medicine. He is an economics professor.
Fortunately, BMC Infectious Diseases, the journal that had made the mistake of publishing this bit of propagandistic pseudoscientific dreck, came to its senses and retracted it, ironically announcing it the day before the study that is the topic of this post was published, listing the reasons in a retraction notice:
The editors have retracted this article as concerns were raised regarding the validity of the conclusions drawn after publication. Post-publication peer review concluded that the methodology was inappropriate as it does not prove causal inference of mortality, and limitations of the study were not adequately described. Furthermore, there was no attempt to validate reported fatalities, and there are critical issues in the representativeness of the study population and the accuracy of data collection. Lastly, contrary to the statement in the article, the documentation provided by the author confirms that the study was exempt from ethics approval and therefore was not approved by the IRB of the Michigan State University Human Research Protection Program.
Interestingly, I myself wondered if this study had been approved by an appropriate IRB, given that it obviously should have been. Reading between the lines, I suspect that Prof. Skidmore just said that the study was exempt, but that’s not how IRB exemptions work. The IRB has to decide that the study is exempt. Often, IRB exemptions are granted through an expedited process in which the IRB chair or a subset of members examines the study protocol and decides that it falls under one of the exempt categories. It is true that the study notes that the “survey instrument and recruitment protocol of the National Survey of COVID-19 Health Experiences were approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of the Michigan State University Human Research Protection Program (file number: STUDY00006960, date of approval: November 17, 2021).” However, I immediately speculated that the IRB had been duped by the aforementioned bait-and-switch and that approval had likely only covered using the survey instrument for assessing factors associated with COVID-19 vaccination uptake and refusal. I further wondered if Prof. Skidmore had conveniently left out the intended analysis in which he used the survey results to estimate how many people died from COVID-19 vaccines. I can’t prove whether or not I was correct in this speculation, but in retrospect I’m pretty sure that I was.
Somehow Steve Kirsch got wind of the impending retraction a few days before it was announced and, consistent with the litigious nature of quacks, posted an article to his Substack entitled It’s time we hold these people accountable; let the lawsuits begin, adding that “I’m going to pay for the lawsuit to sue Springer and their corrupt editorial board at BMC Infectious Diseases for their decision to retract the Skidmore paper; the most popular paper in their history.”
Yes, the Skidmore paper did get incredible social media engagement, unfortunately. Hilariously, Steve Kirsch then went on to do what Steve Kirsch does so hilariously and post the results of his own web “survey,” whose results were predictably one-sided:

A few days later, Kirsch tried to argue that the reasons cited for the retraction didn’t meet COPE standards:
Do any of these apply to the Skidmore paper? No. Not a single one.
In fact, Skidmore’s result was similar to data found by other researchers which puts to bed the first concern and the others aren’t even close to valid.
Which leads us to the inevitable conclusion that the paper was retracted unethically.
Was the Editor willing to discuss the retraction decision and answer questions? No.
Will the Editor reveal who objected to the paper and which of these items they cited? No, they keep that a secret!
I’ll reveal to Mr. Kirsch that I wrote an email to the editors expressing my concerns about the methodological flaws about the paper, mainly because (1) I’m not in the least bit embarrassed by it and (2) if Kirsch really does go through with his lawsuit the email will be found during discovery anyway. I will also mention that I highly doubt that I was anywhere near the only academic who did so. More importantly, at the time, I was also very disappointed that I never received a substantive response, just an acknowledgment from someone from “editorial support”—not even from an editor!—that my email had been received. I figured at the time that my concerns were probably not being seriously considered, much less addressed.
In any event, I listed all my concerns about the paper, including how I thought that it had been a “bait and switch” in which the stated primary aim was the “bait” used to get IRB approval for the study while the true primary aim was to come up with an inflated death toll. I also noted a working paper that Prof. Skidmore had published 11 months before that had used the same methodology of the retracted paper and was full of antivax talking points that I referred to as an “antivax ‘greatest hits’ compilation.” I also noted a definite conflict of interest in that this was a single-author, single funder study, and the funder is Catherine Austin Fitts, who appeared in a COVID conspiracy movie Planet Lockdown and has worked with antivaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr, as reported in The Washington Post. Of note, Prof. Skidmore also maintains a personal blog, Lighthouse Economics that is packed with antivaccine misinformation.
Basically, I wrote nothing more than what I had published on my not-so-secret other blog, suggesting that the paper should be retracted because:
    • The methodology did not support the conclusions and was risibly substandard
    • Of serious concerns about an undisclosed conflict of interest related to the funder of the study
    • Of the likelihood that MSU’s IRB approved the survey instrument and recruitment methods for different endpoints than what they were ultimately used for, which, if true, would make this study unethical
All of these reasons to request retraction are consistent with COPE guidelines, and any one of them would, in my opinion
Yet, Mr. Kirsch and Prof. Skidmore’s allies portray this retraction as “censorship” and threaten lawsuits. I rather suspect it’s all performative. For one thing, note how Kirsch says he’ll support any author who wants to sue. This particular retracted paper was a single-author paper, with Prof. Skidmore as the sole author. If anyone were going to sue, it would have to be him. Given that discovery is a two-way street, I’d have to wonder if he really would like everything about the publication of this paper to be revealed, including all versions of the protocol, the IRB application, reviews, and approval. I rather suspect not, although I could be wrong.
The bottom line
Unfortunately, journal editors have traditionally been far more unwilling to retract bad, unethical, or fraudulent papers than they should be. While I can understand some of the reluctance, given that each retraction is an admission that they had screwed up and accepted a manuscript that should never have been published and that sometimes papers that are bad but were done honestly are not necessarily deserving of retraction. I can also understand concerns about legal ramifications. (I realize that by publicly acknowledging that I was one of the academics who wrote to the BMC Infectious Diseases editor to express concerns about the paper I might just have bought myself a deposition if Prof. Skidmore does decide to sue, but on the other hand his lawyers will see that email anyway if he does sue.) Journals need to do better despite all that because, as the study by Taros et al shows, retracted papers about COVID-19 have a malign and distorting effect on the medical literature. Going beyond the study, they often serve as clickbait that antivaxxers, pandemic minimizers, and those opposed to public health interventions use to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about medicine, science, and public health. More broadly, we as a scientific community have to do better as well by not citing retracted papers unless it is in the context of discussing the retraction.

Open Letter to a Medical Student Part 2: “It Was Criminal in My Mind”
Some of your fans want public health officials to suffer. Should you care?
Jonathan Howard on May 29, 2023
Link

[Editor’s Note: Dr. Gorski has decided to take the holiday weekend off not just from his main job but from his side hobby of this blog as well. Fortunately, Dr. Howard was able to step in. Dr. Gorski will return next week.]
Dear Mr. Knudsen,
In a previous essay I discussed your article on Sensible Medicine titled Death and Isolation During a Pandemic. In your article, you lamented that “they” did not do a randomized controlled-trial (RCT) of hospitalization visitation policies at the start of the pandemic. I felt your proposed RCT would have been obviously impossible and a waste of resources. There’s no way your study really could have been done. I concluded that impossible trials such as yours aren’t conjured out of this air to actually advance the cause of medical research. Instead, impossible trials are imagined to convince people that “they” don’t really know what they are doing. Their sole purpose is to create doubt and anger. This is the true goal of methodolatry and why we care so much about this obscure topic here at SBM.
To illustrate my point, let me share with you some of the comments from your article.
    • I will never forgive the staff that had become so brainwashed with their own needs to mask up, Mask my Mom up over her O2, which she really didn’t need, yet got sent “home” with. Now I realize the incentives to keep C19 monies moving into these hospitals. To the MD that wouldn’t let her go “home” on her birthday, may he be forever riddled with guilt. May he suffer the loss of a loved one in the same manner. May he die alone.
    • The whole thing was soooo inhumane.
    • The powers that be messed up big time during the Covid pandemic. I hope we never forget how death was dehumanized. It was criminal in my mind.
    • These people need to be held accountable.
    • Maybe COVID will open our collective eyes to see the disaster of having clueless and/or spineless administrators in charge everywhere.
    • There’s an element within the medical system that is deeply inhumane. COVID allowed that element free reign over all of our lives.
    • So many of our policies seemed inhumane at the time, and even more inhumane in retrospect.
    • It was a maniacal focus on eliminating the virus above all other goals.
    • We did know from the beginning how awful most of these policies would be.
    • Many of us, knowing the horror stories of dying alone as told by friends or family, will avoid hospitals in the future, unless unconscious and transported to one.
    • It was a purposeful dictate designed to wreck humanity.
    • The senseless cruelty of those policies can never, ever be forgiven.
    • Just….it would have been nice if actual doctors could have located their Ethics Balls 3 years ago when all this was happening *because even then they knew it was wrong*, instead of waiting until now when the dust has more or less settled and it’s suddenly safe to be critical of “things that were well-intentioned but ultimately turned out to be less than helpful.” No. They knew it was wrong then. They had an ethical duty to speak up. And if they’re unwilling to apologize for failing in that duty, then I’m uninterested in 2020 (ha!) hindsight.
    • To isolate people who are sick enough to be near death is so cruel I can barely think about it. No, it didn’t prevent the spread of covid.
    • If improvement is to be made then start with questioning WHY did the medical community ever go along with such inhuman policies?
    • We should all be angry. The masks were bad enough (depersonalizing us), but the lockdowns were cruel, inhumane and completely unnecessary.
    • Mistakes were not made; the herd was culled. Well into the pandemic no course corrections were allowed, early treatments were banned, natural immunity was scorned;
Except for one person who had obviously read my previous column, most comments were some version of this. Was this the reaction you were hoping for? Did any of the comments surprise you? Do you think your essay did anything to advance RCTs in the real-world? Did any commentators implore their fellow reader to volunteer for an RCT?
Several readers shared their tragic stories of their loved one dying alone. As I wrote previously, there is no distance between us on how much suffering this policy created. I saw it with my own eyes. However, the decision to bar families was a tough one that had to be made in an instant at a time when morgues were overflowing, no one was vaccinated, and the virus was brand new. Moreover, it’s far from clear that it the wrong decision was made. There was a strong case to be made for barring visitors at the pandemic’s start and you concede this. Why else would you call for an RCT, which require clinical equipoise, instead of just saying the policy was wrong?
Despite this, you chose not to present any of the reasons hospitals barred visitors at the start of the pandemic. In brief, there literally wasn’t room or staff for any more patients. Our hospitals and morgues were swamped. However, your readers didn’t gain any appreciation for this. They didn’t need an RCT to be certain the policy was misguided. I wonder if some who lost a loved one might have a bit more peace had you explained why hospitals barred visitors and that even if they erred, those who made this policy were trying to save countless lives in an uncertain time.
Sadly, none of your readers found understanding and solace in your essay. Instead, it made them angry and hostile. They felt that a difficult decision made at a difficult time three years ago was obviously “inhumane” and that people need to be held “accountable.” Imagine being someone who had real-world responsibility at the start who now has your decisions second-guessed by people who didn’t have to make any difficult decisions at all. And these people hate you. They think you acted with incompetence and malice. They call you a criminal and hope that you die alone.
The harm from this isn’t just hurt feelings. All this occurred before your essay, but you should be aware of what’s actually happened on the ground to “they“. Sadly, many people have tried to hold public health workers “accountable”, as your commentator suggested. I previously described the extraordinary abuse and threats public health care workers have received, leading many to quit.
The comments on your article are tame compared to some other articles on Sensible Medicine. Here are some comments on “A Public Health Worker Looks Back at the Pandemic and How We Reacted To It“, by Matt Brignall, who worked throughout the pandemic and had the courage to wade into the lion’s den to share his experience. Here were some of the comments from his article:

I’m proud of the comments section here at SBM, including my thoughtful critics. While anyone can comment here, I can’t help but think those who do so regularly reflect on all of us at SBM in some way. I think you should feel the same about the people who comment on your website. It may be tempting to disavow some of your commentators, but doctors who’ve cultivated angry and paranoid voices are stuck with them now. They seem trapped by their profitable new audience, which has led them to adopt anti-vaccine positions they disavowed before the pandemic.
I hope you’ll pause to reflect the on words of James Heathers who wrote in his article, “YOUR FANS ARE DICKS, AND THAT SHOULD MATTER TO YOU”
There is not so much a comments section as a great eructation of savage braying — violent, mean, intemperate, hideous shit is the modal response. Braying at great length, braying by a great many.
And, that is your tribe. Alongside your cardigan, and your curated television appearances, and your professorship, and your papers in The Good Journals, and your overworked graduate students, goes this horde of bilious fucks. These are the people agree with you, who are actively promoting your opinion, and exhort you to have more opinions in future.
Would you pause, at this point?
Would your new best friends change anything at all for you?
Of course, you seem to like your new tribe.

It Will Take More Than “Courage” to Restore Public Trust in Medicine
Judah Kreinbrook, a first year medical student, responds to a post on Sensible Medicine by a medical student that exaggerated the risk of myocarditis from COVID-19 vaccines while expressing anger at how trust in medicine has been undermined. Having been raised by a family steeped in antivaccine views, Kreinbrook invokes his journey to SBM to gently correct his fellow medical student and suggest a better way to restore trust in medicine.
Judah Kreinbrook on December 31, 2022
Link

I was in the middle of writing this article when Dr. Jonathan Howard published Letter to a Medical Student: You Erred. You Are Owed an Apology. It couldn’t have come at a better time as it motivated me to finish this piece. Like David Allely, a third-year medical student and author of the piece Dr. Howard critiques, I am a medical student. Today my intention is to have this serve as an introduction to my personal background as well as a commentary on the state of the medicine profession Allely and I are both entering. As fate would have it, we are entering this profession at a time marked by many crises, one of which I’ll speak about today. Public trust in science and medicine has declined. To complicate matters, this loss of trust is mediated by misinformation, complicated by our sometimes problematic relationships with industry, and, as I will attempt to show, reinforced when we extend beyond our field of expertise as medical students without doing our due diligence. To tackle it, we will need more than what I’ll call a “fundamentalist” evidence-based medicine (EBM), which I, along with others, contend is not sufficient to guide modern medicine. Note, this is not to say that evidence generated by EBM alone is not necessary, merely that it is insufficient.
It’s with this stage set that I want to first applaud Mr. Allely for writing and presenting his opinion piece. I’m sure it was difficult to stand in the face of perceived consensus, this blog, and what many affectionately call the “liberal Twitter mob”. For now, I urge the readers of SBM to continue giving Allely some grace; often, we as medical students are not given the room to dissent against either perceived or real consensus, nor are we taught, as some argue we should, to dissent effectively and productively to move EBM forward. After all, the goal of science should be, at least in an ideal world, to understand the natural and/or social worlds as best we can. I would also hope that most if not all the readers of this blog remember that dissent with sufficient evidence has resulted in scientific and medical breakthroughs. The underlined portion is key. From Semmelweis to David Sackett (one of the fathers of evidence-based medicine), the practice of medicine has been influenced by dissenters, contrarians, and those once called “denialists.” The issue is, this is the same stance many would be cranks take, and during crises such as a pandemic, political decisions are charged with scientific language. Nevertheless, the actual science is occurring in the background. While I consider myself a science advocate, “trusting the science” can be fraught with error in a crisis, as consensus usually cannot occur without significant debate. However, Allely’s post is not making claims about COVID-19 in 2020, it is making retrospective claims about what his risk was, how the decisions by the CDC were made, and, even more concerning, it is also full of exaggerations.
The grandiosity of his piece is exemplified early with him hailed as “courageous.” Frankly, I’ve had enough of this word as of late as I’ve seen it used in the denialist-to-denialist adjacent spaces to somehow give one clout. As one might expect, Dr. Vinay Prasad uses this framing for Allely’s piece, Failing our kids: Myocarditis in young boys:
Mr. Allely is a medical student, but a courageous one. I am glad he is joining our profession
My “Courageous Background”
When I read this, I was not surprised, Dr. Prasad has become entangled in much of what I might call the “denialist” blogosphere, using phrases I know at a visceral level. For now, I will not comment on whether I think Dr. Prasad is a denialist; honestly, early in the pandemic I vehemently disagreed with Dr. Gorski regarding labelling him as such. I’m now unsure about this previously held position. However, one opinion I hold to strongly, my background has given me some key insights here regarding his choice of language, which is why I’m not a fan. You see, I’m not just a medical student, I’m a formerly vaccine-hesitant individual raised by a well-meaning but conspiratorial anti-vaccination family. In the rest of this piece, I will be clear in my language. “Vaccine hesitant” is used when referring to individuals who lack trust in vaccines. “Anti-vaccination” is reserved for those actively creating and disseminating propaganda and/or sloppy science due to a prior belief that vaccines do not work.
In my case, the family I was born into, namely my father/grandfather, are your “old guard” of chiropractors. They believe wholeheartedly in vitalism and hence, subluxation theory. Additionally, they talk about their profession as one does a religion, positioning themselves against medical orthodoxy. This rhetoric of “courage” was central to what a sociologist (and my therapist) would call our family narrative. I recall my father once saying (paraphrasing here):
Son, I became a chiropractor because I’ve always seen myself as bucking the trend when the evidence suggests otherwise, even if they throw me in prison. Remember, chiropractors were once jailed for practicing medicine without a license.
Now, these events are historical, chiropractors were jailed and persecuted, sometimes even unjustly I would argue (as does Dr. Harriet Hall), by the American Medical Association. Note, this is not to denigrate the institution of medicine, only to point out that pockets of scientific medicine’s culture have had a particular disdain for anything labelled quackery, even as medicine itself was just beginning to collect the fruits of its relationship with science. After all, medicine didn’t consistently embrace use of the scientific method until the late 19th to early 20th century, with an even longer period of time until that method extended to the clinical domain full-scale via clinical epidemiology (i.e., evidenced-based medicine) in the 1970s.
As one might expect, I was not vaccinated, the vitamin K shot was avoided at birth (because natural), and medicine was shunned besides surgery and/or emergencies. Growing up, we would receive cervical chiropractic adjustments for high fevers (those bordering on 104 to 105 degrees Fahrenheit), with powerful anecdotes developing about fever breaking after manipulation. (I can’t verify these claims completely as I was only 4 at the time.) Once I became older, maybe 6 or 7, my young mind was convinced by the rhetoric of my family. To me, this established a clear “us versus them” way of relating to the world. The enemy, the physician and pharmaceutical world, was about to be ousted by my tribe; heroes standing up against giants. I recall vivid language regarding being “courageous” in the care of patients “stuck on the medical mill” as they used to put it. Such descriptions were intended to imply that patients failed by medical treatments like back surgery were “cured” by vitalistic chiropractic.
Soon though, confusion set in; while young, my mind was already spotting errors (I was as precocious as they come) in our constructed worldview. The first hole was to genuinely ask the question: why would scientific medicine be so widely embraced without resorting to illogical conspiracy theories? After all, I didn’t want to resort to said conspiracy theories at first, they seemed far-fetched. Could it be that medicine just wasn’t using its own science? What even is science?
What is still so odd to me looking back (ok not really that odd considering my views today) I devoured science books, albeit ones full of young-earth creationist pseudoscience. Honestly, I loved science (what little I got in a homeschooled education) more for its philosophy than anything else. It had a particular way of thinking. Claims were tested, evidence was gathered, and I could truly understand the world around me. Honestly, I wanted to believe that the science was on my side and my family’s. Such vivid emotional recollections now serve as a constant reminder that determining scientific consensus from outside the scientific community is mediated by one’s worldview. Because I was deeply tied to my family and fundamentalist religious beliefs, I only trusted the “science” that assumed these beliefs were true.
Today, I see this as a justification for our ethical duty as medical students regarding identifying misinformation correctly and responding in a way that does not damage public confidence. Patients trust us, even if such trust is low right now, and that shouldn’t be taken lightly. We must ensure we are arguing well and using our “courage,” however, if we are too flippant, we may damage public trust by spreading gross misrepresentations of data which appear scientific and well-formulated. Likewise, if we avoid speaking out about identified vaccine harms or otherwise appear to be suppressing information, that too can be damaging. The question becomes, when is there enough of a consensus regarding benefits or harms? Who sets this bar? When and where should we discuss these things as students? When and where should we discuss these things when we enter practice? Again, I don’t have an answer today as I claim no current expertise, rather this is a call to the attendings reading this piece. We need you to help us learn to think and reason with our “courage,” without making gross errors.
Anyways, back in my adolescent years, my workaround was to grant that modern medicine was only useful during emergencies, a move that later gained my family’s approval to become an EMT and paramedic in my late teens. Thus, they came to see the views we all formed as, “integrative and complementary,” and probably a bit progressive for their more outdated chiropractic philosophy. It’s something talked about often on this blog. So-called CAM is usually nothing more than a scapegoat for finagling in non-scientific, pre-scientific, or pseudoscientific therapies.
Even basic critical thinking reveals how ignorant my previous view on “modern medicine being only good for emergencies” was; after all, modern medicine has seen its best success with preventative measures such as vaccines, not solely emergency care. Looking back, had my childhood been “normal,” these contradictory views might have been deconstructed earlier; however, as fate would have it, the rising tide of Christian Nationalism swept me away. (I was homeschooled from 2nd grade on, placing me firmly in right-leaning echo chambers.) First came the conspiracies surrounding the Obama Birther movement, then the connection between vaccines and “death camps”. The logic is fuzzy, but basically the existence of FEMA death camps presupposes that the proverbial “they” will fake a disaster, advertise a vaccine, and then folks will die because of it. Sound familiar? This same trope came up again in the COVID pandemic. For someone precocious such as myself, I grew increasingly anxious because conspiracies, not just bright and shiny pseudoscience, became the core of our belief surrounding the role of medicine in society. From faith healing to corrosive end-times theology (we prepped for the end of days actively), my life became ruled by the whims of Joe Mercola, Del Bigtree, RFK Jr., and Jim Baker.
To recall a day in my adolescence, I was asked to remain “courageous” as we prayed for the healing of diseases, all the while consuming the “evidence” released from the above sources and generally feeling as if the world was against us. Like most of those trapped near the top of the anti-vaccination movement, I did not solely consume the information, I spread it and embellished it. At the time this was due to a combination of ignorance and fear. Walking into my father’s office, I recall re-stocking the “dangers of thimerosal” papers, sharing them like gospel tracts.
How does a person go from that to a first-year medical student who is passionate about science, philosophy of science/medicine, and science communication? Slowly, painfully, and with a lot of inner work. This is probably better explained through a religious deconversion lens which I believe I did well on this podcast; however, the medical misinformation piece was always close behind. While what I’m about to say is mere opinion, there is lots of overlaps between fundamentalist positions on religion and anti-vaccination propaganda.
Not to belabor my story—I invite anyone willing to talk about it to reach out—but the deconstruction of fundamentalist religion, my exposure to society as an EMT and then paramedic, and the work of SBM were critical in righting my path. However, such a radical change left me livid. Ironically, my anger is like that of the other subject of this piece, Mr. Allely. Like him I felt robbed, except it wasn’t the CDC, FDA, or the big bad liberal attendings in medicine who did this, it was my family. To put it mildly, I realized that I was actively harming society, and that I had been put at risk unnecessarily.
The Politics of Fear and Angry Angsty Medical Students
As one can clearly see, I’ve done my time in the actual anti-vaccination subculture of the U.S. Nevertheless, I’ve rarely written about this topic, mostly because I’ve been focused on learning medicine. Personally, I’ve struggled with seeing the worth in my voice as I see myself as a student of science, medicine, and society. But after these years of COVID-19, the bitter political polarization, and seeing medical students like Allely write in a way that I believe inappropriately addresses medical misinformation, I must speak out. Some 10 years ago, these words (taken from Allely’s article) would have sat well with me, encouraging my ongoing vaccine hesitancy (italics my own for emphasis):
I’ll admit I feel some anger when I think about Covid policy and vaccine requirements, etc. I am a healthy, 25-year-old male. I took Moderna, which by all accounts has a higher risk of myocarditis than even Pfizer. I trusted our public health and medical institutions blindly in the early pandemic, based on my perception of an impressive track record and rigorous peer review.
To anyone who has studied even the most basic philosophy of science this should strike one as asinine. Allely’s trust in institutions might well have been blind, but that in no way guarantees that his reactionary arguments are now cogent. Furthermore, he isn’t a common citizen anymore, he has a duty to identify the evidence which disconfirms his beliefs and see if it holds water. Even worse, I almost think he is implying that science and the evidence it generates should bring 100% or at least high certainty. Indeed, there are good reasons to think that science is reliable, but it is by no means a monolith of certainty; we will never be 100% certain. In medicine, this becomes even more important to decision-making as the evidence is often used on patients who don’t look like the ones we studied in the randomized-controlled trials. In a pandemic, this becomes even more dangerous as the target (i.e., disease) is moving. Variant emergence, for example, changed the risk of hospitalization/death when Omicron arrived, a key pillar in Allely’s article and something Dr. Howard immediately pointed out.
This error demonstrates something critical about the role of science in policy. Science is concerned not solely with understanding the natural world, but also, at least in the modern age, with making projections. Certain methods (i.e., classic clinical epidemiology/EBM) can give us a picture of what the world looks like right now or in the past, but the goal in a crisis is to make pragmatic decisions about projection (i.e., what things will look like in the future given a degree of uncertainty) that balance potential benefits and risks. Such projections require a democratic society to utilize its science and its politics to come to reasonable decisions. Thus, Allely is using what I’ll call a “retrospectoscope,” to critique decisions made based on projections using empirical data. To put it differently, there is a difference between models and evidence. Allely confuses these, probably out of overt ignorance rather than intent to deceive. His editors should have caught this conflation; they didn’t.
Being clear about my position, I’m all for dissecting our pandemic response and asking ourselves: “could we have done things better here?” That would encourage better policy and remove it from the ranting, railing, and whining about how terrible the CDC is or is not. However, I don’t think a substack article by an angry medical student is really helping anything. How could it? It’s not a well-written and vetted piece, which, if it were, we would see a takedown of the opposing argument. While admittedly formed through my own academic pursuits, I think the most important social value in science, one which needs fanned constantly, is the desire (I would argue duty) to attempt to prove oneself wrong.
Allely not only chooses his substack as his domain to avoid this duty, he also does not handle this conversation with care. Admittedly, his courageous dissent is not unethical in and of itself. Instead, I see him as feeding into our problems with medical misinformation rather than addressing them. Why go to these lengths when you can simply admit you don’t know, you disagree with say a widespread booster mandate, and you await more data?
As I will explain, I think there are two things going on here: (1) Allely is firmly set in the philosophical position of medical conservatism/medical nihilism which is bound to fundamentalist EBM to a degree (methodolatry as some call it); and (2) he is reacting to the politics of fear. In today’s world we want to have a response to the right-wing populism in the streets. They warn us that the migrants will bring crime, that we will be exterminated by our government, and that somehow, it’s reasonable to believe these things. Indeed, the phenomenon of public trust in institutions is largely split among party lines these days, largely because of the fearmongering we see in our politics. As cognitive scientist David Hicks writes:
Trust in scientific expertise is itself a partisan phenomenon. Survey studies by the sociologist Gordon Gauchat and the Pew Research Center show that over the past five decades, liberals have had steady or even increasing trust in science and scientists, while conservatives have gradually lost trust. But even this is an oversimplification, as conservatives have maintained trust in what the sociologists Aaron McCright and Riley Dunlap call “production science” (science as used by industry) and lost trust only in “impact science” (science as used by regulatory agencies for goals such as restricting pollution and protecting human health).
We could come at this problem like Prasad and Alley, communicating far less about the benefits of new pharmaceuticals (in this case a vaccine) and exaggerating harms, believing this will lead to more public trust (the latter premise has little to no empirical support that I’m aware of), or we can choose to be honest about the evidence both at the bedside and in policy discussions. To do so, we must learn to understand the politics of fear and meet it with humanism at the bedside and careful communication publicly. It honestly was inspiring to see chiropractic, the field my family has used to justify their anti-vaccination views, begin to combat COVID misinformation. Regarding the bedside, fact correction alone is probably not going to work with hesitant patients, as a cohesive narrative of fear has been spun in public. They’ve been told that science which disagrees with their political values is to be critiqued, while science in service of industry’s libertarian values escapes without critique. Oddly enough, the pandemic turned this on its head, as conservative values became twisted towards denialism of industry science as regulators moved to approve these products swiftly.
The Task We Face: Public Trust in Modern Medicine
The task Mr. Allely and I will face at the bedside and in the public domain as we enter medicine is to face this lack of trust head on. To do so, we must acknowledge that we are not trusted by a significant portion of the population along party lines, and we must find a way to bridge that gap. I believe that he and I are on the same page there. The difference, as far as I can tell anyways, is that my past life experiences and subsequently developed views on science, society, and the need for a more science-based medicine, have instilled a sense of cautious skepticism when communicating using strong claims. To be clear I remain open to being convinced that the risk-benefit of COVID-vaccination is not appropriate in certain age groups regarding boosters. Additionally, I do not believe that critiquing institutions is totally off-limits. We, that is those of us learning and working in medicine, need to hold our institutions to the fires of science when necessary. However, to do so effectively, we must make cogent arguments that do not misstate facts so we can appropriately identify uncertainty in the science to policy transition. After all, policymaking is not easy, it involves tradeoffs, and waiting for perfect evidence in a pandemic is not as simple as fundamentalist EBM suggests. Broadly speaking, I see Allely’s writing as pushing the following argument regarding public trust in medicine:
    • The politics of fear elevates tensions which may obscure facts, politicizing science and leading to intense disagreements
    • Such tensions lead to less trust in medicine, science, and other institutions
    • The solution is to remain skeptical of new pharmaceuticals, always paying attention to harms which are often dismissed and exaggerating these risks to protect public trust
I take issue with a firm prior belief anchored in #3. While we have uncovered industry bias, failures to share data, and the hidden harms of some therapies, such problems are not remedied by performing sloppy science ourselves. Instead, we need to ensure that folks understand the role of science and the role of policy. While we agree on the first two premises, I am not convinced that a prior “vaccine hesitant” belief is necessary. Instead, I think the solution lies in how we communicate about science. We must be clear about what we are sure about, what we are unsure about, and where values come into play. Put formally, my third premise is this:
    • The solution does not lie in misstating facts, rather we need to discuss uncertainty, remain honest about the risks, and make reasonable decisions in real-time. Above all, we need to show empathy to our patients, invite critique, and perform good science in a free society.
To truly be great communicators about policy, we must also be able to acknowledge uncertainty without ranting and railing against institutions with hyperbolic language. Again, this is not to say we cannot and should not critique our institutions. Indeed, one of the key duties of science, and in extension a science-based medicine, is to critique institutions to uncover errors. However, there is another way to act other than that shown by Mr. Allely. Instead of summoning our anger and being blinded by it, we can and should be moved to dissent with that anger while also remaining aware of the human tendency to err. That can and should be done rationally and poignantly. Take Dr. Paul Offit, who voted “no” to approval of the ancestral strain + BA.4/BA.5 (omicron sub-lineages) bivalent boosters while on the Vaccines and Related Biological Products Committee (VRBPAC) in August 2022. Why? Because he did not see evidence of safety nor of benefit in June 2022 when shown the Pfizer/Moderna data comparing monovalent to bivalent (ancestral strain + BA.1 (omicron)) and had yet to see human data at the VRBPAC meeting. I also want to point out to readers that Dr. Howard, who has been very critical of Vinay Prasad, failed to critique Dr. Offit as strongly. Why? Because when Dr. Offit dissents on vaccine policy, he usually does so with evidence, well-founded arguments, and without sowing distrust to the same degree. Instead of ranting about the CDC, he directly speaks about the decision at hand, referring to it as “overselling.”
On the Need to Understand Fast Science Versus Slow Science
One of the hardest parts of making pandemic policy has been the sheer speed at which new evidence must be assimilated. Obviously, COVID science had to be fast to inform policy. This wasn’t a case where science could lag. We needed evidence and we needed it quickly. Indeed, Trisha Greenhalgh predicted that the pandemic would show us the limits of EBM’s over-reliance on randomized trials which are much better suited to diseases with stable definitions and incidence. Instead, our basic and clinical sciences had to become fast, and admittedly it was sloppy, but that’s how fast science works. To look back and pick our pandemic response apart is a different matter. We are now performing slow science. We have the time to go back, pick apart our response, and argue over data. Allely does this, but then extends retrospective critiques—ones that I argue are not cogent—into the future with more statements containing exaggerations:
That record (the CDC) is being tarnished and trust betrayed by sloppy science and overly broad mandates. I faced a far higher risk of being hospitalized with the vaccines I was mandated to take than if I had simply been infected with Covid
To his credit, he sees the problem in front of us, the problem of public mistrust in medicine; however, his solution seems to be to misspeak or otherwise remain ignorant of the facts when arguing for his position. He did not face a higher risk of hospitalization; he is wrong on that fact as Dr. Howard showed. Even if we grant Allely the 1 in 10,000 risk of hospitalization for vaccine-related myocarditis which he cites, he underestimates the COVID-19 risk by a large margin, failing to account for its risk over time and what happened in the omicron wave. Furthermore, his argument plays into the politics of fear. It amplifies a view which is at its best poorly articulated and at its worst harmful to public discourse. The next question should be, is that par for the course in writing about science and policy in the public domain, or is Allely in the wrong?
While merely opinion, it’s my view that medical students need to be involved in these conversations, the key is how we go about them. It wasn’t wrong for him to write this piece, his critical error was in failing to understand that medical conservatism is a philosophical position which still requires much debate. We need to see the way these decisions are made, what data “counts,” and how that affects our patients. But we must not be only “courageous” as I did while vaccine hesitant. That is what Allely is doing here, and it led him to misstate obvious facts, which is arguably a breach of professional ethics. Honestly, if there’s anything I’ve learned from transitioning from baseline vaccine hesitant to scientifically informed it’s to find those who disagree with you. Assume you are probably wrong about a lot, and then go out and find the experts who disagree with you. Push against their arguments and see what comes up. Write to them, email them, or zoom call with them. Cite their arguments when attempting to take them down if you still disagree. It’s only with such clarity of thought that you can be the skeptic you pretend to want to be.
Indeed, zooming out for a second, I contend that medical students should learn to become efficient in their studies, which are often full of rote memorization. Why? Because it gives one time to write, to research, and to truly learn about the philosophical differences between a fundamentalist EBM position (i.e., the methodolatry spoken of here as early as 2009) and SBM. The modern medical student will eventually, if they are paying attention, see that EBM has its flaws and that a solution is needed. What that solution is, I don’t yet know, but I bet it looks something like SBM. As some philosophers of medicine have pined, the medical school EBM education is in serious need of contributions from the philosophy of science/medicine to tackle this critical challenge.
I invite anyone reading this piece to help us as medical students to grow in this mission to understand modern medicine’s debates regarding the state of EBM and where it needs to go from here. Encourage us to become critical thinkers while also teaching us to be empathetic while communicating about misinformation and general health literacy with our patients. The politics of fear and these large philosophical disagreements between fundamentalist EBM and SBM are not going away anytime soon. To make it out, leave the world better than we found it, and become great clinicians and academics we must brave the storm, dare I say with the “courage” to be skeptical, to have tough conversations, and to vet our work thoroughly before dissenting.

Ron Johnson’s “vaccine round table” does little to actually help patients.
Sen. Ron Johnson held a roundtable discussion earlier this month regarding COVID-19 vaccine injuries. It featured a cast of antivax grifter and typical antivax talking points that we’ve come to know since the pandemic hit. This antivax propaganda exercise helps no one other than the antivaccine movement.
Frank Han on December 24, 2022
Link

Senator Ron Johnson, the Republican senator from Wisconsin, convened a round table with various actors known to be active in the anti-vaccine ecosystem with the premise that they would increase awareness of vaccine injury. This is not the first time he has done such a session, however the way that this session was put together does very little, if anything, to assist actual patients on their way to recovery. This is meant to advise the reader on how Sen. Johnson’s December 2022 roundtable was deceptive and used to push an agenda.
Here is the video from Rumble, not YouTube. Notice the logo of Del Bigtree’s Highwire. As the video rolls, notice how antivax doctors whom we’ve met before, such as Dr. Robert “inventor of mRNA vaccines” Malone, Dr. Peter McCullough (who has promoted “vaccine Holocaust” and “Great Reset” conspiracy theories), and Dr. Ryan Cole, whom we met most recently promoting Died Suddenly, an antivax propaganda film disguised as a documentary that promotes the conspiracy theory that COVID-19 vaccines are responsible for an epidemic of young people “dying suddenly” of massive blood clots.
First, a couple of themes that are woven throughout the presentation.
     1.  The speakers seem to think that when they have been shown to be wrong, that equates to censorship. This is just categorically false. In the courtroom of science, when you do an experiment that shows your hypothesis was wrong, you generally close up shop on that hypothesis and investigate the biological question from another perspective. You don’t try to tell everyone you were censored. I clearly remember the time when I made a mistake with a DNA gel electrophoresis and have the blank gel sharply imbedded in my mind. I owned up to my mistake and apologized to my mentor – I did not seek out Senator Ron Johnson.
     2.  This is a perennial feature of the antivax ecosystem; antivaxxers much older than the speakers have been using this tactic since the early years of the antivax movement.
     2.  The whole point of the presentation was to raise awareness for vaccine injury – why didn’t they include speakers who are actually doing projects on vaccine injury?
     3.  Normally Senate committee members have their fact-checkers and interns on hand to advise the actual senators, so that people who testify can have their findings challenged live (and allow the person testifying to also challenge the senator). Senator Johnson has access to all the fact checking he wants, but makes little to no effort to do this. Instead, he just expresses his approval.
Onwards to their claims.
Claim: The number of claims on VAERS has increased therefore all the COVID vaccines are bad
People in the antivax ecosystem have explicitly told their followers to game the VAERS system and create dubious reports. The VAERS website explicitly says to avoid using the website data in the manner that Liz is doing. Some VAERS reports even contain reports on changes on the size of genitalia. How should you actually use it? As an early warning system to help you figure out side effects. I have followed VAERS personally and done research in collaboration with other centers, on the issue of post-vaccination myocarditis. Other researchers used it to discover, characterize, and treat vaccine associated immune thrombocytopenia. Yet other researchers have used it to characterize the menstrual irregularities.Claim: The Vsafe system not immediately releasing all available data is evidence of intentional deceptionNo it isn’t. The V-safe system was essentially created for the COVID-19 immunizations because the previously available systems (VAERS, VSD) were not capable of tracking people over time. V-safe also delivers survey questions directly to the end user in the hopes of getting more survey participation (since it is theoretically more convenient to the user). Registration is completed after completion of the first dose and then the system sends survey questions at several time points. While it is true that V-safe data are not released in full for the general public, any researchers interested in conducting a formal project can most certainly contact the system administrators and start such a project. A part of the V-safe project data was obtained via litigation from Aaron Siri’s law firm, however the way it is displayed to the public is misleading. One data point Siri and his colleagues present is the total number of people reported to have required medical care – which is a little over 800 000. They then state that over 10 million users were registered. Based upon surveying the older immunizations, most medical problems reported that are due to the immunization (such as rotavirus immunization associated intussusception) occur within the first two months after the dose. However, the data dump presents all instances of medical care without controlling for what the medical care actually was. The further away from an immunization you seek medical care, on average, the less likely it was due to the immunization. Siri’s data collection doesn’t even describe what medical care was actually done – I would be worried about a case of Guillain-Barre, but I wouldn’t be so worried about a case of a patient receiving Motrin in the Emergency Department then going home.
Claim: Vaccinated people in the UK are dying at a rate 26% higher than the unvaccinated
This demonstrates a lack of understanding of the base rate fallacy. When the number of unvaccinated individuals shrinks, the number of people dying from all causes in that group is also going to shrink. It doesn’t mean that vaccinated equals more dying.
Claim: Alarming increases in disabling conditions for the US Army were reported right after vaccination was mandated, and COVID vaccine deaths are higher than COVID disease deaths
This claim appears to originate from Dr Lee Merritt, an orthopedist by training. She claimed on video, that there were 20 deaths due to COVID-19, and 80 cases of myocarditis at the time of her announcement, and because 66% of people “with myocarditis die after 5 years”, more people died due to COVID immunization than due to COVID the disease. This is wrong on several counts – time travel hasn’t been invented yet, she has misinterpreted a myocarditis study in a very special subtype of adult myocarditis, and COVID immunization myocarditis skews to be a much milder disease than the specific kind of myocarditis she was quoting. She likely picked the 66% figure purely because it was bigger, for rhetorical effect, not because she was proficient in the epidemiology of myocarditis. We have actual statistics, from the actual US military, to refute her claims – the USAF alone reported 165 deaths due to COVID as of June 2022. The United States Department of Defense reports 690 deaths due to COVID as of December 2022. In contrast, no data in the presentation are provided to back up any verified military service member deaths due to a COVID vaccine injury. Certainly other militaries have reported immunization myocarditis, and the rates reported are likely similar in the US military. However the disease course mirrored what happened in the civilian population. In the US military, the rate of immunization myocarditis has been reported in one study to be 23 in 2.8 million. The “increase in disabling conditions” is based upon a misrepresentation of the Defense Medical Epidemiology database, and is discussed here.
Claim: A largely vaccinated public drives the virus to mutate even faster
No, this is playing virological magic tricks hoping you don’t notice. The coronavirus changes over time because its genomic error checking capability isn’t anywhere near the same capability in human cells. Therefore, changes that confer decreased fitness disappear, and changes that allow immune evasion are propagated forward. The virus requires a live human being to mutate, and the more people catch the virus, the more viruses can potentially change. The act of immunization is not the primary driving factor here.
Claim: Vaccine mandates can only be justified for vaccines that lower risk of transmitting the virus
It appears that the speaker here has not done his due diligence on the classical vaccination schedule, which contains vaccinations that decrease transmission to varying degrees. We still mandate a classical vaccine schedule in most countries! COVID immunization did effectively decrease transmission in the early variants, however the advent of Omicron made their effectiveness against transmission worse. Naturally, antivaccine actors collaborated with spin-doctors to say that all the epidemiologists lied, however it was not possible to anticipate exactly what would happen with each new variant of SARS-CoV-2. In addition, COVID vaccinations do somewhat decrease the forward transmission of Omicron.
Claim: Early treatment has always been our best line of defense
Well, has anyone found an effective antiviral against the common rhinovirus or enterovirus (the cold viruses)? No! It was certainly a reasonable idea to search for early treatments for COVID, but clinical proof needs to accompany those hypotheses. Designing effective antivirals has always been a very tough process, and many antiviral candidates have failed. The speaker in this case is a fan of ivermectin, and it should technically give the user a better outcome than compared to doing nothing. We actually have many clinical trials now showing that this is not the case (of which this is one). Could it be biologically plausible that some people got better here and there? Sure, but when a medication doesn’t help the majority of the population, and you try to propose a treatment without rigorous statistical controls, you can’t generalize the findings to everyone. Physicians propose new treatments all the time, and this is actively encouraged. If you don’t believe this, I recommend attending any professional medical society meeting. However, when clinical trial data says your hypothesis is no longer correct, the honorable thing to do is to shut the project down and attempt another line of inquiry. There were vested financial interests woven into the promotion of hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin, and this is a major reason early treatments were still advertised despite a lack of evidence of efficacy. It is even worse when several of the studies used to back early treatment were found to have major statistical issues. While it is true that remdesivir has legitimate renal clearance issues in those with poor kidney function, it is a gross misrepresentation to say it does nothing, or to say its only role is to hurt kidneys.
Claim: We should have used vitamin C for COVID
While there is a plausible biochemical mechanism for how vitamin C may help, the studies available are currently small and conflicting. In the quantities specified in the FLCCC protocol, it is also capable of causing quantifiable harm such as kidney stones!
Claim: Since the vaccine rollout, we have had 750,000 additional COVID deaths in America
The actual number was accurate as of 2021, however this is an oversimplification of all-cause mortality data. Some people may die of COVID due to their bodies not making enough of an immune response after immunization. This makes no mention of the partial immune escape of Omicron. This makes no mention of the community of immunologists who recognize this as a concern, and are trying to make better immunizations. In addition, we have actual epidemiological data that says what would have happened in highly unvaccinated communities that are also not previously COVID exposed. Scaled up to the size of the United States, this would have caused much more devastation. In other vaccinations, it also took a while for the mortality to decrease (and this doesn’t even take into account that the other classical vaccine preventable diseases interact with the immune system in different ways).
Claim: COVID vaccines lose their efficacy and dip into negative efficacy after a few months
This is a misrepresentation of British public health data and some work in the NEJM. Again, this is a distortion of some calculations provided that actually describe reasonable immunity versus Omicron, which wanes over time. The fact that vaccine efficacy against Omicron is not as amazing as it was against older variants is well known by now, and is motivating multiple teams of professionals to come up with a better solution. Theoretically the speaker should have enough medical knowledge to know this, but chose to willfully misrepresent the project anyway. The reason the graph in the article appears that way is due to the lack of data points allowing estimation of the efficacy at the most distant time points (furthest amount of time away from the time of vaccination).
Claim: Federal reimbursement is increased to a hospital, if that hospital is treating a hospitalized COVID patient or uses remdesivir
This is partially correct in that a COVID patient requiring ICU level care will generate higher charges. However, the fee is sent to the hospitals themselves – the physicians don’t get direct bonuses unless it is specifically notated in their contract that they will get the bonuses. Hospitals need to charge more simply because ICU care is more complicated (and many American hospitals operate on a for profit basis). Myself and many other physicians have many, many criticisms of the finances of hospital medicine, but that is an entire degree program in itself.
Claim: Robert Malone is the inventor of mRNA
This is probably the most asinine statement of the entire roundtable – mRNA is probably billions of years old. The actual origin of the first molecules that can be considered “life” is currently hotly contested. It certainly is true that Malone played a role in the invention of mRNA vaccines, however he was part of an enormous team of people who did thousands of experiments to make mRNA immunization a reality.
It would not be correct to say Neil Armstrong was the inventor of spaceflight. He was an astronaut whose success depended on the teamwork of tens of thousands of scientists.
It would not be correct to say Vespasian personally built the Colosseum in Rome by himself. He had a team who did it.
It would not be correct to say Marie Curie invented radioactivity. She discovered the phenomenon through experiments and through her knowledge of chemistry.
In the same way, it is not correct to say that Malone is the sole inventor of mRNA immunization. He also advocates for a class of mRNA immunization that has failed in clinical trials and would cause more side effects than the current mRNA immunizations.
Claim: mRNA vaccinations affect fertility, they become plasmids in the sperm, and they integrate into the genome
The speaker here has a deficient command of the molecular biology involved in all these processes. The idea that mRNA vaccinations affect fertility was started by Michael Yeadon, who claimed that homology between a placental protein and spike would be damaging to the placenta. While it is reasonable to try and think of risks, it is no longer reasonable to persist on this viewpoint when an entire body of literature is now available showing the fertility of women who have received mRNA immunization is no different from those who have not. Another entire body of literature shows all the issues that women can sustain if they catch COVID during pregnancy. In order for a piece of RNA to become DNA and also become part of the genome, several additional proteins are required which are intentionally not delivered on the COVID mRNA immunization. The classical example for this is HIV. Plasmids exist in nature in bacteria and some protozoans, but it takes specialized protein machinery to make those. Sperm do not contain that machinery. Plasmids also do not generally integrate into human genomes unless they come with the proteins to do so. Citation for that? Campbell’s Biology. One cannot invent molecular processes that do not exist.
Claim: mRNA vaccinations are gene therapy
The speaker here is trying to play molecular sleight of hand and hope you don’t notice. Yes there are certain injectable RNA molecules like patisiran that do try to alter the expression of certain genes, but it depends completely on the information contained on the RNA. Not all injectable RNA is the same! No COVID vaccines contains the molecular machines and genetic sequences necessary to actually change your genes.
Claim: The only clinical trials that we had were not designed to measure rates of hospitalization and death
The speaker here is living in the past and willfully ignoring the evidence of the COVID immunization’s ability to decrease hospitalization and death. Here’s only one of many sources. The original trial of the Pfizer immunization for example explicitly stated in the protocol that they were looking at hospitalization as a secondary outcome. At this point one can only conclude the speaker is trying to selectively share information to weave a narrative.
Claim: The average vaccinated individual get larger doses of spike protein from the vaccine than the average COVID patient gets from the virus
That comes from an actually very good immunology article whose goal was to figure out how the immune system responds to mRNA immunization. If the spike protein disappeared quickly so would a portion of the immune response to it. The statement as given by the speaker is a distortion of the main research results which is explained in full here.
Claim: Ingredients of the COVID immunization were withheld from the FDA
No, the FDA had full access to the ingredients of the mRNA vaccination. The document circulated around contained many redactions because some trade secrets were involved in the manufacture of the immunizations (for example it is sometimes a trade secret on how water is purified for FDA-approved drugs).
Claim: Public health said COVID vaccines would prevent a vaccinated person from passing the virus to anyone else, but now that we know there is transmission, they intentionally lied
As some staunch opponents of the public health response to COVID would say, when the data changes, it is important to also change your position on something. This standard should not be applied in a lop-sided fashion. We had variants that became more transmissible, and public health staff needed to acknowledge that. However, when biology changes, you should change too. It could have been worded better – as in they could have said something like “here’s what we know about COVID now, but stay tuned, we may have to provide you updated information down the line”. However, when the COVID Omicron variant came, we had to change.
Claim: Vaccine safety monitoring steps were skipped
Much of the technology around COVID immunizations happened to be ready to be used around 2019, and so many steps of the usual regulatory process of vaccinations could be done in parallel. Nothing was omitted.
Claim: Vaccine quality control is being skipped for the mRNA vaccines
In fact the US COVID oversight committee has publicly criticized a supplier of COVID immunizations during the quality control process. Interested parties may read about the process in detail here.
Claim: Those who are vaccine injured are not getting enough support
This statement is in fact true! There is some biological plausibility for the COVID spike protein generating some of the symptoms that have been observed in the vaccine-injured population. However, the round table makes little effort to begin a research project, show patients how to enroll in a project, platform a researcher who is actually working on this issue, or propose any treatments. Here’s an example of actually good vaccine injury research on post COVID immunization postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome.
Claim: Myocarditis after COVID vaccination is not being taken seriously enough
Several pediatric cardiology centers and cardiologists (including myself) have treated patients with post-COVID-immunization-myocarditis, and continue to engage our communities in researching the medium- and long term outcomes of COVID immunization myocarditis. It is factually incorrect to say no US authorities are monitoring the rates of COVID immunization myocarditis – one only needs to see the ACIP updates to get these rates. We already have cardiac MRI studies that have preliminary information on how people heal from COVID immunization myocarditis. If the pediatric cardiology community was not taking this seriously, we would be researching other things rather than helping this patient population. I challenge the speaker in this instance to join the rest of the cardiologists and help us research this condition better.
Claim: mRNA vaccinations bypass barriers of the body, and spike protein may leave the area of injection, therefore we were all deceived about the biodistribution
If an immunization did not bypass the barriers of the body how would you expect it to work? An immunization does absolutely nothing while sitting on the surface of the skin. Yes it is accurate that exosomes (little mail envelopes of the body) have been demonstrated to contain spike protein after immunization. It is also biologically plausible that this may be responsible for some of the side effects that have been discovered. However, the study cited does not by itself prove this to be the case. It is also true that immunization mRNA has been detected in the bloodstream in recipients of immunization in very small quantities (but we don’t know if they are full-length immunization mRNA). More work is needed to show these things as being the proximal cause of side effects. Senator Johnson’s comment about a deception at this point is a reflection of his own misunderstandings of the biochemistry. The lipid nanoparticle is mainly going to merge with the cells at the injection site (and the mRNA is going to enter those cells). There is also a misinterpretation of the Pfizer biodistribution study – that study was done in mice with an equivalent immunization dose that is much larger than anything that would be given to a human. When one looks at the vaccine equivalent dose, the amount of mRNA nanoparticle leaving the injection site is less than 1%. None of this was discussed during the roundtable. Also, Pfizer and Moderna both produced information saying the lipid nanoparticles would be metabolized in the liver.
Conclusion: Senator Johnson’s round table fails at science
I think that some of the intentions of sharing the experiences of the vaccine injured are honorable intentions. Some of these people have legitimate suffering and need our assistance. However, the senator had the potential to call in teams of fact-checkers to corroborate all their claims. He chose not to do that. The patients featured in this round table and previous ones could have been enrolled in research projects. The round table failed to help them accomplish this through any publicly discernable information. Multiple speakers made mistakes in really simple molecular biology. Multiple speakers, physicians included, failed to present balanced interpretations of the journal articles that they cited, at times completely misrepresenting them. At least one physician in the group threatened a Dallas publication with a defamation lawsuit while in the very next breath, claiming he wants debate. Certainly in normal scientific conferences invitations for debate are welcome, but both parties are generally expected to agree upon the fundamental facts of the situation. I suspect the invitees who declined participation partially did so because they are well aware of the reputation of the speakers in this round table. Based upon their actions during this talk, they do not have normal scientific debate in mind. The debate tactics they have in mind more closely resemble the debate between Steve Kirsch and Dr Avi Bittman. These tactics are typically used in the court of law, which is not how emergent biological truths are discovered. We’re supposed to be building public policy and legislation on solid peer-reviewed science, and this senator’s round table fails at that most fundamental task.

Federal employment rights agency inundated with thousands of COVID-related discrimination claims
Thousands of workers have filed complaints with the EEOC alleging COVID-related employment discrimination. It may take years of litigation to sort out the application of federal anti-bias laws to these claims.
Jann Bellamy on April 7, 2022
Link

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has been inundated with COVID-related claims brought by workers charging that employers discriminated against them in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII), and other anti-bias laws.
The ADA, as the name implies, prohibits employment discrimination based on disability. Title VII protects employees against discrimination based on race, color, sex, national origin and, most importantly for COVID-related claims, religion. The EEOC is responsible for enforcing these and other federal laws that make it illegal to discriminate against a job applicant or an employee. Filing a charge with the EEOC is a prerequisite for workers who want to file anti-discrimination law suits against employers. The EEOC can file its own suits as well.
According to Bloomberg Law,
Since April 2020 through December 2021, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has received roughly 6,225 Covid-related charges of discrimination under federal civil rights laws, the latest agency data show. In addition, the commission received more than 2,700 vaccine-related charges, most of which were in 2021 when vaccine requirements were introduced. . .
About 66% of the Covid-related charges raised ADA violations, totaling around 4,125. Meanwhile, the ADA was cited in 300 of the 2,700 complaints tied to vaccines.
The EEOC has not said which of the other anti-bias laws were cited in the vaccine-related claims but, as Bloomberg Law noted, companies have reported a flood of religious exemption requests under Title VII.
The EEOC apparently views these developments as of a piece with the virus’s adverse effects on disadvantaged groups in general. In a statement issued in early March, the agency said:
The COVID-19 pandemic has proved to be a civil rights crisis in addition to a public health crisis and economic crisis . . . As we heard at our public hearing last year, it has disproportionately impacted people of color, women, older workers, individuals with disabilities, and other vulnerable workers.
The ADA and Title VII require employers to provide a reasonable accommodation to a worker’s disability or religion unless doing so would pose an undue hardship. But employers can raise a “direct threat” defense to fire or refuse to hire a worker if the worker’s disability poses a threat to the health and safety of other individuals.
As one might surmise, the intersection COVID and employment discrimination law raises many novel and difficult questions for workers and their employers, including what qualifies as a “disability” or a “reasonable accommodation” and what constitutes a “direct threat”. The EEOC previously issued guidance for addressing these and other COVID issues.
That guidance made clear, for example, that not every person with the virus will qualify as disabled, but said the virus’s aftereffects [such as long COVID] should be considered under the ADA’s three definitions for a disability. Those cover actual physical or mental impairments that substantially limit a major life activity; an employer’s perception that a worker has a disability; or the worker’s record of impairment.
As for a worker claiming a religious exemption to an employer’s vaccine mandate, the EEOC’s guidance said that the employer must provide a reasonable accommodation “for the religious belief, practice, or observance” that prevents the worker from receiving the vaccine under Title VII, unless that accommodation poses more than a “de minimis” cost or burden.
If, however, an employee requests a religious accommodation, and an employer has an objective basis for questioning either the religious nature or the sincerity of a particular belief, practice, or observance, the employer would be justified in requesting additional supporting information . . .
Further complicating the issue, the EEOC advised that “religion” is not limited to established religions like Christianity, Judaism and Islam. It also includes “religious beliefs that are new, uncommon, not part of a formal church or sect, or only held by a small number of people”. As well, “nontheistic beliefs can also be religious for purposes of the Title VII exemption as long as they ‘occupy in the life of that individual’ ‘a place parallel to that filled by. . . God in traditionally religious persons'”. Thus, “the non-discrimination provisions of the statute also protect employees who do not possess religious beliefs or engage in religious practices”.
Anti-vaxxer misinformation campaigns notwithstanding, the EEOC guidance also clarified that, since COVID-19 vaccines don’t use technology that impacts employees’ DNA in any way, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA), also enforced by the EEOC, is not applicable to COVID-19 vaccine issues in the workplace. GINA prohibits employers from “using, acquiring, or disclosing genetic information”.
As has been true since Title VII was enacted in 1964, the meaning of terms in the federal anti-bias statutes has been fleshed out in litigation, a very expensive way for employers to find out whether or not their conduct violated the law. And it can be a long wait for a definitive ruling. It was not until 2020 that the U.S. Supreme Court decided that Title VII’s prohibition against sex discrimination covered LGBTQ workers, an issue that had remained up in the air for years and about which different presidential administrations (and thus the federal agencies they control) held opposing positions.
We are now at the very beginning of a long slog through administrative rulings and court decisions that will flesh out the application of employment discrimination laws to COVID-19. Even when the pandemic fades, long COVID will require workers and their employers to navigate this new territory.
So, off we go. Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, the EEOC itself has brought at least three lawsuits related to disability bias and COVID.
In its first disability accommodation lawsuit connected to the COVID-19 pandemic, the EEOC alleged that a Georgia pharmaceuticals manufacturing facility manager was fired after her employer denied her request to continue working from home because a heart condition heightened her COVID-19 risk. According to the complaint, other employees were allowed to continue working from home after the facility reopened but the manager’s request was denied and she was terminated.
The EEOC also filed suits, against a pharmacy and a coffee house, in Texas. According to the EEOC, a pharmacy discriminated against a pharmacy technician who suffered from asthma. He asked to wear a face mask to help protect him from the virus as an accommodation to his disability. The complaint alleges that the technician was harassed because of this accommodation request, taunted and humiliated for questioning management’s policy prohibiting masks, and sent home on at least two occasions after asking to wear a mask, all of which lead him to quit his job.
(We have to ask: What sort of pharmacy prohibits mask wearing? Not one I’d want to trade with.)
In the second Texas suit, the EEOC’s complaint alleged that a coffee shop violated the ADA when it denied two baristas with disabilities reasonable accommodations and terminated their employment. Rather than provide the disabled employees reasonable accommodations to minimize customer contact, according to the EEOC, the baristas were not allowed to return to work until a vaccine for COVID-19 was developed, despite the fact that they were ready and willing to work.
According to one lawyer practicing in this area:
Regardless of the outcome, the case serves as a reminder that wise employers should not refuse to allow employees to work based in the hopes of protecting employees from illness. Employers must first ascertain whether there is a direct threat to the employee or others. Only where an employee would pose a substantial risk of significant harm to his/ her own safety or the safety of others that cannot be significantly reduced or eliminated by reasonable accommodations should an employer deny an employee with a disability the opportunity to work.
Great advice. But you can bet that for every defense expert who will testify that a particular employee posed “a substantial risk of significant harm” that “cannot be significantly reduced or eliminated by reasonable accommodations” you can find a plaintiff’s expert willing to downplay the dangers the employee presented to fellow workers (and vice versa). In fact, testifying as plaintiffs’ experts in anti-discrimination cases could be a whole new income stream for Great Barrington Declaration types who make a living discounting the dangers of COVID-19.
In sum, long COVID won’t be the only lingering manifestation of the pandemic. We’ll have long-lasting litigation (and attorneys’ fees) as well.

Anti-vaccination ideology and COVID misinformation in chiropractic continuing education courses: “Plandemic” edition
Chiropractors can still get state-approved continuing ed credit for anti-vaccination courses, with bonus COVID misinformation now added to the curriculum. Plandemic star Judy Mikovits joins the faculty.
Jann Bellamy o nOctober 7, 2021
Link

Disgraced scientist and COVID grifter Judy Mikovits has joined the list of marquee anti-vaccination ideologues on the faculty of state-approved continuing education (CE) courses for chiropractors. The Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin recently featured Mikovits at its VAXCON ’21 event along with anti-vaxx propagandist Del Bigtree and others from the fringe.
If VAXCON ’21 sounds like an odd name for a chiropractic educational event, then you don’t know chiropractors. Read on.
(Note: you have to switch views of the “Bundle Content” list to find the speakers’ names, as opposed to the titles of their presentations.)
Mikovits’s talk was titled “Plandemic and Beyond: Identifying Dangerous Complications of Masks and COVID Vaccines in Vulnerable Populations”, “Plandemic” being a reference to what David Gorski described as
a conspiracy-fest of a ‘documentary’, arguing that the current COVID-19 pandemic was somehow planned.
Mikovits has a starring role in Plandemic as a
sort of brave maverick scientist and truth teller that every good conspiracy theory needs, a woman with hidden knowledge who’s fighting dark powerful forces seeking to ‘silence her’.
Mikovits’s long history as a crank, anti-vaccine activist, conspiracy theorist, anti-Dr. Fauci grudge-holder, and grifter is ably set out in this and another post by Dr. Gorski. Just to give you an idea of how “out there” she is, she’s claimed that
the coronavirus is actually secretly caused by a bad strain of flu shot that was circulating between 2013 and 2015. Masks will help ‘activate’ the virus and reinfect a mask-wearer over and over . . .
Thus, she said,
Wearing a mask will kill more people than—this virus is not coughed through the air from healthy people, who are almost certainly immune, as they’ve almost certainly been infected over the last four or five years,
This is the sort of nonsense that got Plandemic pulled from YouTube and Facebook. On the other hand, it’s perfect for a continuing education course for chiropractors, who received CE credit for VAXCON ’21 under the auspices of Life University, a fully accredited chiropractic college.
Why perfect? Because, as we’ve documented here on SBM over the years, state-approved chiropractic continuing education courses and conferences regularly feature anti-vaccine ideology. Obviously, adding dangerous COVID nonsense to the curriculum is a logical (if you will) extension of their efforts.
As mentioned, Del Bigtree, who has added COVID-19 grift to his resume, was also a featured speaker, via video, with a talk called “Del Bigtree in the Dells”. “Dells” is a reference to VAXCON ’21’s Wisconsin location but otherwise there’s no information I could find on his presentation. As his only claim to fame is being an anti-vaccination propagandist and the producer of the widely discredited “documentary” VAXXED, directed by the disgraced and delisted physician Andrew Wakefield, flogger of the non-existent measles vaccine-autism “connection”, I think we can safely surmise his topic. Bigtree was a featured speaker, along with anti-vaccination royalty Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Barbara Loe Fisher, at a chiropractic “pediatrics” conference (which also awarded state-approved CE credit to attendees), as was Wakefield himself.
Other speakers at VAXCON ’21 include James Neuenschwander, MD (“Down the Rabbit Hole: Evaluating Vaccine Safety Science”), Alan Palmer, DC (“COVID- 19-Following the Science and Evidence”), and Vicky Pebsworth, PhD, RN (“COVID-19 Vaccines 101: Vaccine Development and Regulatory Landscape”). “Alternative vaccination schedule” maverick Dr. Bob Sears also spoke, but no CE credit was awarded for hearing whatever he had to say.
Neuenschwander was a part of the combo Trump supporters/QAnon/anti-vaxxer/conspiracy theorist fest held in Florida last year (also featuring Kennedy and Bigtree). In his post on the conference, Dr. Gorski explained that Neuenschwander is
a physician into alternative medicine who runs something called the Bio Energy Medical Center, who was originally going to be on Shannon Kroner’s antivaccine panel but ended up not being on it. Unsurprisingly, all the docs on this speakers’ bill are quacks; indeed Dr. Neuenschwander offers CEASE therapy for autism, a therapy based on homeopathy, and IV vitamin C and chelation therapy.
Palmer is a chiropractor who has done “post graduate” work in “Detoxification and metabolic toxicity”, “Food-related allergy disorders in children”, “Digestive Health and Intestinal disorders”, “intestinal dysbiosis”, “Adrenal and Thyroid Disorders”, and other areas of medicine (both real and imagined) where a chiropractor has no business meddling. His free book 1200 Studies – Truth Will Prevail is, according to Kennedy’s anti-vaccination empire, the Children’s Health Defense Fund, “the most comprehensive scientific expose of vaccines to date”, a telling indication of just how solid the science behind Kennedy’s positions is.
Pebsworth is a volunteer for, and board member of, the vaccine misinformation group NVIC and, inexplicably, on several government vaccine committees.
All told, 12 hours of CE credit for a whole bunch of anti-vaccination rhetoric and COVID misinformation, and all for only $399 (just $299 for Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin members).
More sources of anti-vaccination ed, including Tedd Koren
Chiropractor Tedd Koren is a prolific publisher of chiropractic promotional materials (some of which have run afoul of government regulatory authorities), including the 2020 pamphlet Vaccination: 18 Reasons to Just Say No. As summarized by Quackwatch’s Dr. Stephen Barrett,
Among other things, the flier states that vaccines “don’t work,” and increase the likelihood of developing attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; allergies; anaphylaxis; arthralgia; arthritis; Asperger’s syndrome; asthma; autism; bowel disease; cancer; chronic fatigue; convulsions; Crohns disease; deafness; diabetes; dizziness; dyslexia; eczema; encephalitis; Guillain-Barre syndrome; headache; hearing and vision problems; immune system disorders; learning disorders; leukemia; Lou Gehrig’s disease (ALS); lupus; Guillain-Barre syndrome; meningitis; multiple sclerosis; neurological disorders; ocular palsies; optic neuritis; otitis media; pervasive developmental disorder (PDD); skin disorders; thrombocytopenia; and ulcerative colitis. I believe it is the most irresponsible chiropractic flier ever published.
Considering Dr. Barrett’s extensive expertise in chiropractic pseudoscience, developed over many years of detailed study and investigation, that is indeed saying something.
Koren teaches a 12-part “Neuroimmunology and Vaccines” course eligible for chiropractic continuing education credit via the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Board’s PACE CE course program. (For example, here.) The courses were not easy to locate on PACE and it is not always possible to find them on the website to which I was referred by PACE or determine which states award credit for them. However, I was able to confirm that Florida (where I live) gives chiropractors CE credit for Koren’s “Vaccines” series via the Florida Board of Chiropractic Medicine’s CE Broker website. Here’s a sampling from the syllabi. (After a few “sics” I gave up and left them off entirely.)
“Neuroimmunology and Vaccines” Part 2
To study the neuro-immune system function as it relates to empirical and mechanistic perspectives in health and disease. This module provide an overview of vaccines Are vaccinated children healthier than nonvaccinated children? Allergies and asthma How would you test vaccines? How are they really tested by drug companies? Junk science and selection bias Background incidence The Marie Griffin study, James Cherry, MD
(They all begin with “To study the neuro-immune system function as it relates to empirical and mechanistic perspectives . . . overview of vaccines” so I’ll leave that part off on the rest.)
Part 3
Does research show vaccines are safe? Are vaccines tested for carcinogenicity? The story of Our Alexander The polio vaccine/cancer connection SV40 Do the benefits of vaccination outweigh the risks? A generation of neurologically damaged children?
Part 7
Definition of autism An exploding epidemic Do vaccines cause autism?
Part 8
Mental retardation Epilepsy and seizure disorders Infantile spasms Cerebral palsy Paralyses
Part 10
The Gardasil vaccine is not a vaccine for protection against cervical cancer. It is a vaccine intended to prevent 4 types of HPV Human Papilloma Virus. According to the Gardasil package insert, there are more than 100 types of HPV Nearly all adults carry HPV in their bodies and in almost all instances HPV is harmless, causes no symptoms and is naturally eliminated from the body.
Part 12
Epidemiological evidence reveals that not only was the smallpox vaccine useless at protecting people from developing smallpox, but that: it caused deadly smallpox epidemics. is linked to tuberculosis, heart disease, syphilis and cancer. is possibly linked to other chronic illnesses.
And so on.
Another fully accredited chiropractic school, the Texas Chiropractic College, offers a course called “Immunization, Inoculation or Vaccination: Navigating the Consequences with Clinical Nutrition”, which suggests that chiropractors practicing the ersatz chiropractic version of nutrition, can
help children and adults who have sustained documented immunological, gastrointestinal and neurological disruptions from simultaneous toxic exposures from medications, environmental influences, vaccinations, etc.
This, of course, takes well-worn pages from the anti-vaccination playbook notion that vaccines are “toxic” as well as from the alternative medicine playbook notion that “nutrition” is a cure-all.
A CE course from ChiroLearn, a creation of the Florida Chiropractic Association (FCA), called “Public Perception of Chiropractic: What the Research Shows”, features none other than the COVID-19 misinformation Super-spreader and Disinformation Dozen member #1 Dr. Joe Mercola, along with chiropractor Patrick Gentempo, the force behind the anti-vaccination “documentary” Vaccines Revealed. What are they doing there? I don’t know, but if you type in “vaccine” on ChiroLearn’s search feature you get:
Unfortunately, that’s all we can find out. Given the fact that these courses are state-approved and are offered pursuant to the fiction that state licensing protects the public’s health, one would hope for more transparency.
The FCA’s ChiroLearn also hosts the laughably insufficient curriculum for becoming a “chiropractic internist“, which offers the interestingly-titled courses (at $375 per course for 12 hours of on-line instruction):
A Natural Medicine Approach to Evaluation of Infectious Disease
and
Autism, ADHD, Vaccination: Prevention and Treatment of Childhood Illness
One course I previously covered is still available via ChiroCredit, a CE provider approved by the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards: “Varying Viewpoints on Vaccinations with Alternative Schedule and Homeopathic Remedies”. It is chock full of anti-vaccination tropes and promotes the false notion that there are effective alternatives to vaccination such as “alternative/healthier lifestyle approaches” and, even more dangerously, homeopathic nosodes. A ChiroCredit course that discussed vaccines and autism has been removed, but I’m wondering if its content might have reappeared in another course by the same instructor which “summarize[s] the effects of vaccination on infants immune systems”. Somehow I don’t think immunity from disease is one of the “effects” discussed.
How is it that, even with increased media coverage of chiropractors’ anti-vaccination ideology (also here) these courses continue to get the imprimatur of state approval? Because no one is looking.
Decades ago, the state legislatures, in passing chiropractic practice acts and licensing chiropractors as health care providers, turned their regulation over to chiropractic boards run by chiropractors. No one has bothered to check back in and see just what these boards are up to and certainly not to find out whether what passes for continuing education is full of harmful nonsense, which it obviously is. Even as a pandemic rages on, chiropractors are sitting at their computers learning how to put their patients’ health in danger, all so they can keep their licenses current.
        ◦ Malaria kills about half a million people a year; half of those are children. Just yesterday, the World Health Organization endorsed an anti-malaria vaccine, the “best new development in the fight against the disease in decades”. Sadly, I would not be surprised if chiropractors are already busy creating CE course content to discourage malaria vaccination.

A Modest Proposal: Close Pediatric Cancer Hospitals
What if people thought about pediatric cancer the way they do pediatric COVID-19? A satirical argument to stop treating children for cancer.
Jonathan Howard on October 2, 2021
Link

There are 74 million children in the USA. According the National Cancer Institute, only 0.0024% of them die of cancer each year. Adults are 100 times more likely to die from cancer than children, and children are a mere 0.3% of cancer deaths every year. To put things in perspective, more children will be born in the USA between the hours of 12:00PM and 5:00PM today than will die of cancer this entire year. The risk of you getting struck by lightning in your life is three times higher than the risk of a child dying of cancer. According to the CDC, 12,000 people age 1 to 19 years, die from accidents each year. That is seven times the number of cancer fatalities. Of course, death is not the only bad outcome from trauma. Tens of thousands more children survive accidents, but are permanently injured.
Incredibly, there are entire hospitals and specialists devoted a disease that doesn’t kill 99.998% of children. The average cost associated with childhood cancer is an astronomical $833,000, and the cost of a single hospitalization is $40,000. Other countries do not treat pediatric cancer this way, and our approach comes with great opportunity costs. For every child treated for cancer, we could hire school crossing guards, something that would ultimately save many more children. Indeed, there is a serious shortage of school crossing guards right now.
        ◦ If you truly care about saving children’s lives – and no one cares more about children than me – then you’ll join me in calling for an end to pediatric cancer hospitals and the entire field of pediatric oncology.

Dear President Trump: Jealous Deep State Haters and Losers Want to Destroy YOUR Genius, Lifesaving, Nobel-Prize Winning Achievement. YOUR Vaccine.
You’ve proven your haters wrong over and over again. As the most POWERFUL man in the world, and one of the most BRILLIANT men every to live, you can do it all with one quick phone call.
Jonathan Howard on May 6, 2025
Link
Dear President Trump,
I know you are busy working hard to make America great again, and so I will keep this short. In a previous article I wrote:
COVID vaccines are the greatest medical achievement of my lifetime, and Drs. Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman deservedly won the Nobel Prize for their research.
I still believe that, and so does every doctor and scientist I know. One study from 2022 estimated that COVID vaccines prevented an estimated 14.4 million deaths around the world.
YOU gave this AMAZING, WONDERFUL vaccine to the world in record time through Operation Warp Speed. No one thought YOU could do it, but YOU proved your doubters wrong once again. Millions of people are alive today because of YOUR vision, courage, and leadership. The success of YOUR vaccine made grown men cry, and many people are saying it’s the best vaccine in history. YOUR name will be etched in the history books as a scientific GENIUS who saved more lives than just about anyone who ever lived. Your ENEMIES and HATERS will never give you credit for this, of course.
Everyone knows that YOU are humble and don’t like to talk about YOUR many accomplishments. However, YOU have every right to boast about YOUR incredible vaccine and to remind people that YOU created it. Drs. Karikó and Weissman would not have won the Nobel Prize if it weren’t for YOU, and many people are saying that YOU should have won it too. YOUR vaccine also earned Pharma companies record profits, but everyone knows YOU are a business genius already.
I know that REAL AMERICANS are pissed off about vaccine mandates, but that had nothing to do with you. Sleepy Joe is to blame for that. You believe in American Freedom, and YOU would never force a vaccine on anyone.
Yet, the FREEDOM we both cherish, and YOUR great vaccine is currently under ATTACK from VANDALS and SABOTEURS in your own administration. The current heads of the FDA and NIH have repeatedly trashed YOUR amazing vaccine, and now they are trying to DESTROY it. These LOW IQ professors from RADICAL LEFT universities can’t match YOUR scientific accomplishments, and they are jealous of your GENIUS. Unlike YOU, their work will never lead to a Nobel Prize, and they’ll never create something worth billions of dollars. They have their own agenda, and they don’t care if YOU or YOUR vaccine get hurt along the way.
People who are supposed to work for YOU have BETRAYED you before, and I am sure YOU don’t want disloyal, ungrateful FRAUDS and LOSERS to undermine YOU once again. It’s bad enough that kids are dying of measles, but the last thing you need is for COVID to return to the headlines for the next 4 years. I know many MAGA Americans also quietly get YOUR vaccine, and YOUR poll numbers, which are the best in history, could suffer if it was taken away from them.
I also know that YOU will stand up for medical freedom and oppose the Deep State actors who want to take away the LIFESAVING, INCREDIBLE vaccine YOU gave the world. They are working against YOU once again. They think YOU are weak and unable to stand up for yourself.
But you’ve proven your haters wrong over and over again. As the most POWERFUL man in the world, and one of the most BRILLIANT men every to live, you can do it all with one quick phone call.


Our Medical Establishment Supports Viral Mandates
If I am unable to access a vaccine in the future and get a nasty case of COVID, I’ll know where to point the finger and so will millions of others.
Jonathan Howard on May 23, 2025
Link
First results from any randomized, controlled COVID-19 vaccine booster trial demonstrate a relative vaccine efficacy of 95.6% against disease
By December 2021, there was already clear evidence a third vaccine dose was beneficial. Though the results were only available as a press release, a randomized-controlled trial (RCT) of 10,000 people showed that a booster was safe and 95% effective at preventing COVID. The results were published several months later, and it doesn’t take a genius to imagine a vaccine dose that lowered infection rates would also lessen severe disease.
The results from a large observational study were also available at that time. It found:
Vaccine effectiveness evaluated at least 7 days after receipt of the third dose, compared with receiving only two doses at least 5 months ago, was estimated to be 93% (231 events for two doses vs 29 events for three doses; 95% CI 88–97) for admission to hospital, 92% (157 vs 17 events; 82–97) for severe disease, and 81% (44 vs seven events; 59–97) for COVID-19-related death.
Not bad.
Well, I’m an unboosted male. That’s my preferred pronoun, by the way.
This “gold-standard science” didn’t matter to Drs. Vinay Prasad and Marty Makary, however. They ignored this evidence, and with their typical childishness, they gathered in the podcast booth to mock and shame anyone who wanted this first booster.
– [Marty] Are you guys boosted being that close or is this an unboosted contact?
– [Zubin] We’re unmasked, unboosted and unrepentant, Marty.
– [Marty] Well, I’m an unboosted male. That’s my preferred pronoun, by the way.
– [Zubin] Oh, is that your pronoun? An unboosted male? Yes, my pronouns are it, they, those and currently unboosted because I got Moderna, which apparently kicks ass….
– [Vinay] …I haven’t gotten my booster yet and-
– [Marty] You mean this week you haven’t gotten, ’cause you do weekly boosters, I’m sure.
– [Vinay] Well, eventually, we’re all gonna have to keep boosting.
– [Marty] Yeah, boosting.
– [Zubin] You know, my vaccine card looks like one of those like frequent flyer like coffee cards where they punch the hole, like I boosted here and boosted here and boosted here and when I get 10 boosters, Fauci sends me a Fauci bobblehead that says I am the science.
– [Marty] I’m getting my booster sent with the GNC nutrition vitamins.
– [Vinay] They had the same evidence, you know.
According to Dr. Prasad, a vaccine supported by an RCT and subsequent observational study was as useful as a random supplement.
During the Omicron Wave, Death Rates Soared for Older People
The Omicron wave peaked the next month. According to the article During the Omicron Wave, Death Rates Soared for Older People:
Despite strong levels of vaccination among older people, Covid killed them at vastly higher rates during this winter’s Omicron wave than it did last year, preying on long delays since their last shots and the variant’s ability to skirt immune defenses.
This winter’s wave of deaths in older people belied the Omicron variant’s relative mildness. Almost as many Americans 65 and older died in four months of the Omicron surge as did in six months of the Delta wave, even though the Delta variant, for any one person, tended to cause more severe illness.
While overall per capita Covid death rates have fallen, older people still account for an overwhelming share of them.
“This is not simply a pandemic of the unvaccinated,” said Andrew Stokes, an assistant professor in global health at Boston University who studies age patterns of Covid deaths. “There’s still exceptionally high risk among older adults, even those with primary vaccine series.”
A single shot could have prevented much of this.
FDA to limit COVID shot approval to 65+, those with medical conditions.
Instead of reflecting on whether any of their listeners might have suffered from having skipped important vaccine doses, today these juvenile doctors are in power, and the headlines read FDA to Limit COVID Shot Approval to 65+, Those With Medical Conditions. Drs. Prasad and Makary stated their case in a bizarre essay titled An Evidence-Based Approach to Covid-19 Vaccination. Thankfully they will approve vaccines for older, sicker people based on immunogenicity data alone. Dr. Prasad had previously rejected this standard and even asked people to sign a pledge to remain unvaccinated. In his article No More COVID-19 Boosters Without Evidence he said:
The issue with perpetual COVID-19 boosters is what evidence is needed to justify their push? The answer has to be randomized trials powered for reductions in severe disease, hospitalization and death. Yet the FDA seems to be moving in the opposite direction, thinking mouse antibody data is good enough. Now a number of doctors, researchers are swearing: no more boosters till RCT.
“RCT or STFU,” he concluded with his typical lack of professionalism.
Now that he has real-world responsibly, however, Dr. Prasad wisely does not want highly vulnerable people to be without the vaccine on his watch. He’s confident it works for their them, and now that their deaths would be on his hands, he decided that RCTs are suddenly no longer needed.
However, for everyone else, Drs. Prasad and Makary had to argue that the vaccine posed a greater threat than the virus. As such, their article was full of absurd tropes I’ve discussed many times before.
    • They bemoaned a decline of “public trust in vaccination,” hiding that they overhyped the COVID vaccine 4 years ago, promising it eliminated severe disease, blocked transmission, and would end the pandemic. When that failed, they turned on the vaccine, denying its benefits and treating rare, temporary side-effects more seriously than death.
    • They faked a concern about measles and falsely claimed that letting unvaccinated people contract COVID would increase confidence in the MMR.
    • They refused to do new RCTs and instead called on Big Pharma to test their own products, even though such trials can’t be done in a reasonable timeframe and wouldn’t be trusted by many people regardless.
    • They misrepresented other country’s vaccine policies and treated scientific decisions as if they were an international popularity contest. Of course, smart countries can make stupid decisions about vaccines.
    • They ignored evidence the vaccine limits Long COVID and didn’t consider that it limits transmission.
To discourage vaccinations, Drs. Prasad and Makary asked to use our imagination. They said:
We simply don’t know whether a healthy 52-year-old woman with a normal BMI who has had Covid-19 three times and has received six previous doses of a Covid-19 vaccine will benefit from the seventh dose.
In reality, there’s copious evidence that boosters have already helped limit severe disease. However, while we don’t know everything about the vaccine, the more important question is- what will the fourth, fifth, and six COVID infections do to our hypothetical healthy 52-year-old woman with a normal BMI who has had Covid-19 three times already? While the vaccine will give her a sore arm, she might feel really unwell after repeat bouts of COVID, and they may injure her in important ways, especially if she is unvaccinated. Maybe her three prior infections have harmed her already. Drs. Prasad and Makary don’t care about that one bit, however. They both have a long history of ridiculing anyone who tries to avoid COVID, calling such people mentally ill “idiots” who are “living in fear“.
As has been the case for the past 4 years, their demand for evidence applies only to the vaccine, not the virus. They never needed “evidence” before making things up to glorify the virus, claiming that natural immunity was “probably lifelong” or that contracting it was “natural and healthy” for children. Ominous headlines from abroad – New COVID Wave in Hong Kong Is Causing Severe Infections in Children, Hong Kong Children Urged to Get COVID Jabs as ‘Whole Paediatric Ward Full‘- don’t concern them today.
I am under 65 and healthy, thankfully. If I want a COVID vaccine next fall, I will have to lie to receive one thanks to Drs. Prasad and Makary. They felt that I should not have the right to decide for myself. They made the choice for me and my family based on their personal standards of evidence, not mine. My medical freedom and bodily autonomy means nothing to them. Though they opposed vaccine mandates, they are now responsible for a policy that effectively amounts to a viral mandate. If I can’t access a vaccine in the future and get a nasty case of COVID, I’ll know where to point the finger and so will millions of others.


Baffled
I am baffled.
Mark Crislip on August 18, 2026
Link

If you are stumbling onto this blog for the first time, some background. I was an infectious disease doctor for 36 years, retiring 3.75 years ago. Boy does time fly. I will be dead before I know it. I hope.
In that time I saw many a new infection come and stay. They seem to never come and go, just wax and wane. AIDS started around my last year of medical school (remember, association is not causation). In no particular order, there was Legionaires, C. difficile, Lyme, Ebola, Helicobacter, SARS, H1N1 influenza, MRSA and COVID. And more if I thought about it longer. Many of the infections and most of the antibiotics I used at the end of my storied career were unknown when I was a medical student.
The infections mostly had the same arc: unknown infection. No organism identified. Look for a pattern of diseases and risks to try and prevent spread.

For HIV, risks were gay, Haitian, and the use of amyl nitrate. The “joke” at the time? The most difficult aspect of an AIDS diagnosis was telling your parents you were Haitian.
Then an organism would be identified, therapies and, sometimes, a vaccine would be developed and the infection would regress a bit.
It was always a messy, bumpy, process. False starts and uncertainty are always part of the process. I learned early that when a new infection hits, those involved with investigating it have the choice of doing too little or doing too much. Public health can be a thankless job. In the end, it was usually sorted out by smart, dedicated people doing the best they could with the tools they had. Reality won. Or least there was a draw.
The biggest change over the years was the rapidity with which this arc plays out. HIV took years to be solved. COVID took months. I remain amazed at the technology that can be applied to infectious diseases. For years ID was so stone knives and bearskins: using the same agar plates from the 19th century and hope we grow something.
What changed over time, especially with COVID, were the increase in features I just do not understand.
For me, there are three kinds of understanding. One is deep, the knowledge becomes part of you. You do not have to think about it, it just is. I feel, or more accurately felt, that way about infectious diseases. Over the years my understanding became part of my DNA.
Then there is the more superficial understanding, where you have to consciously think about the topic to understand it. That was much of medicine that was not ID.
Then there are the processes I cannot understand, even intellectually. I just can’t wrap my head around the topic. Like the loop of Henle. I think it is imaginary crap, made up my nephrologists to ‘explain’ how the kidney absorbs water. Piffle.
And so much of the response to COVID I am unable to understand, the content being a Charlie Brown adult, fundamentally unintelligible noise.
As I remember COVID, and I recognize I can Maurice Chevallier this (without the creepiness), from an infectious disease/infection control perspective.
First, it was yet another respiratory infection. Been there, done that. I fretted over the first reports of H1N1 that it would be a repeat of 1918. Nope. And SARS had petered out quickly, but not before killing its discoverer. That gave me pause. So, remembering that first reports tend to lean towards the more dramatic features of a disease, I waited, half expecting it to peter out.
Then COVID started to spread. Fast. To cruise ships and Italy. Then the US. And it was a perfect shit storm. Highly infectious and zero immunity in the population. It overwhelmed NYC and Rome. Dead people stored in trucks. Horrifying. It never got that bad here in Portland.
Highly infectious and no immunity in the population is the cheeseburger and loneliness of infectious diseases. A large percentage asymptomatic but infectious. A slow course from onset to ER. And receptors for the virus in most tissues. A perfect combination for both widespread and rapid dissemination of the disease and bypassing all but the most punctilious infection control measures. Never saw the like before in my career. But all that is hindsight. In the moment there was enormous uncertainty and it took time to discover how best to deal with COVID.
As the sole, and soul, ID doctor at two hospitals, it was part of my responsibility to try to apply that uncertainty to patient care and infection control. And boy oh boy do people deal poorly with uncertainty.
Early data suggested that given my age and with my comorbidities, I had a 20% chance of dying if I got COVID. One in five. That also gave me pause going to work each day. Would not want to hold a gun to my head if there was a 1 in 5 chance of blowing my brains out. Or 1 in 1000. But I had a will and an insurance policy, so off to work.
Initially the CDC said don’t worry about masks. I will admit I took them at their word. I mean, who was I to disagree with the CDC? But if I had given it even a moment’s reflection, I would have realized that the spread was much too fast to be spread by anything but coughing.
Eventually the CDC suggested masks. I never could understand why some refused to wear masks and why those that did rarely wore the correct mask or used them appropriately:
Mask compliance among 600 individuals entering 4 New York City hospitals was observed to be 78%.
That was people entering a hospital, where they are likely on their best behavior. I bet proper use was far less in the general community from what I could tell.
Belief is what you do in the absence of data, so I never believed masks could help prevent COVID. I knew that correct PPI would protect me. It is why I could go to work every day and spend hours with COVID patients. The question was the magnitude of the effect given the issues noted above. Never did catch an infection, COVID or otherwise, from a patient nor did any staff, at least that we could tell. As best I can tell them what poo-poo various COVID preventions never had to spend time actually taking care of COVID patients or be directly responsible for the policies and procedures to mitigate the risk of their coworkers.
But I never did understand why an individual would not wear a mask, and wear it correctly. Can’t wrap my head around it. And it was red counties where people did not wear masks. And do not use condoms, so it is more than just COVID. But what is the mind set? Got me. I read their excuses but remain baffled by the content.
And I never could understand the enthusiasm for ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine. Antibiotics work by interfering with very specific metabolic pathways of pathogens. Ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine should do nothing against COVID and they didn’t. Reality holds true. I always did have an affinity for azithromycin, but due to itsanti-inflammatory effects for influenza, although the efficacy was mild at best. I never suggested it for COVID, but if the patient was on it I did not object. But why use a drug that has zero effect on the virus? Do not understand the reasoning behind it.
And then the vaccine came. Amazing new technology, subsequently abandoned. Some day we will miss not having invested in mRNA vaccines. And the people who did not mask or use condoms avoided the vaccine. And got COVID and died in greater numbers. And that approach applies to more than just COVID:.
Using individual-level medical data and death records, this study shows that conservative Americans experienced worsening health and higher mortality than liberals during the 2010s. Here we find evidence consistent with two potential mechanisms. First, demographic realignment within political coalitions brought less healthy individuals into the conservative camp. Yet by the 2020s, demographic change, public policy and COVID-19 do not fully account for the widening gap in mortality rates. Public opinion data are consistent with a second mechanism: declining trust in medical professionals among right-leaning individuals, including lower willingness to seek care, follow clinical advice or believe in medication effectiveness, even for issues unrelated to COVID-19. These patterns suggest that growing ideological divides in health behaviors are leaving conservative Americans increasingly vulnerable to preventable health risks.
I guess some people are invested in their death cult, preferring it to reality, but I will be damned if I understand why. Never go against reality when death is on the line.. But they do.
But we muddled through, with 1.2 million US deaths. Like losing two Portlands, Oregon (Portland, Oregons?). Or one Dallas, Texas. I will let you comment on which is the preferred loss. Could have been less. Perhaps a lot less.. Given the fog and uncertainty of pandemic at the time and the unique features of COVID and the political environment, probably did as well as we could. I it looks like if there is another pandemic, we are mostly primed to do far worse.
And now the same people, more or less, who championed all the approaches to COVID that increased the deaths and misery, are going after Dr. Fauchi over the origin of COVID.
because the debate about where the novel coronavirus came from is ongoing, divisive, and important.
Well, the first two, yeah. Important? Not really. Nice to know, but from a practical viewpoint, not going to prevent the next coronavirus outbreak, since we have mostly gutted the infrastructure that deals with pandemics. Common things being common, I prefer the jump from animals as the most likely source of COVID. Like SARS. Like Ebola. Like measles. Like so many others. But we will never know for sure.
One scenario, which Fauci has favored, involves a naturally occurring jump from bats to humans, probably via some other species; another postulates a lab leak, most likely from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, in the Chinese city where COVID-19 first emerged. Some of the Wuhan lab’s work involved developing new variants of coronaviruses. (Embedded in the Fauci-Paul conflict is a genuine dispute over the definition and risks of what is called “gain-of-function” research.) The institute also received funding from NIAID, via a sub-grant from a nonprofit. According to NIAID, however, the coronaviruses that were the subject of that grant were not closely related to the one that caused the pandemic.
As far as the next pandemic, if at some point we decide to prepare, we will need to consider both options.
And I cannot understand the point in publishing all of Fauci’s diary entries. They have no bearing on his work and only serve to embarrass him. The man is not perfect? Huh. Water is wet and fire is hot. What kind of person does that? No one I would want to have a beer with. The New Yorker had a summary of the diaries, and I could not see the point of its publication. I think it should be required that along with such articles, the author should submit a decade’s worth of unedited browser history. Let he who is without sin and all that.
And now the nothing burger ‘bombshell’ over concerns that the COVID vaccine might increase stillbirths (they don’t), again trumpeted by those who have no responsibility for preventing or treating COVID. I would have the occasional pregnant patient with an unusual infection that required treatment with antibiotics with little to no meaningful data in pregnancy. And we always discussed the issue. It is what Fauci did. It is what we all do. And always with the knowledge that infections are often worse in pregnancy and the understanding the much of time, there are no good options, only the least bad option.
And as an aside, I have often heard it said, in disbelief, “and RuPaul is a DOCTOR! ” Sorry. That should be Rand Paul. Unfortunately, as I do rue Paul. He has been out of medical school 40 years and a senator for 14. His practical medical understanding is likely minimal and out of date. I would estimate, from personal experience, the half-life of medical competence when not practicing is 6 months. Use it or lose it happens fast. I used to half-joke that some nurses can say the word doctor and by tone and expression for all the world you would think they were saying ignorant asshole. Doctor Paul.
So much around the reaction to COVID makes zero sense. As does the current CDC. I remain baffled that people lie and misrepresent to cause morbidity and mortality in themselves and in others. A commitment to truth and reality has always been on the losing side. Human nature. After 69 years, still can’t grok it; I continue to feel like a stranger in a strange land.
I remember when I was driving to LA for my fellowship, there was the infamous article in the ID literature, Whither Infectious Diseases? Memories, Manpower, and Money, that said there would be no need for more ID doctors and that we would end up culturing each other. Looks like we are heading the opposite direction. Lots of work coming our way with totally pointless responses. I will be damned if I understand why.

Science Based Satire: What I Would Have Done
A man who experienced the pandemic entirely from his laptop, explains what he would have done had he actually done anything.
Jonathan Howard on February 4, 2024
Link

Non-satire note: The text in bold are direct quotes from various people I’ve discussed previously. I strongly encourage you to click on the links provided.
“If you were in charge of the policy, what would the policy be, what tools would you employ?”
Dr. Vinay Prasad, Plenary Session Podcast, February 2021 at 1:36:10
Thank you for this vital question. Throughout the pandemic, I worked tirelessly from my living room describing all the amazing things I would have done, had I actually done anything. I gave TV interviews. I wrote newspaper editorials. I recorded podcasts. I Tweeted. I blogged. I made YouTube videos. I made a movie about myself. I write it about daily, and I also have a book coming out. I even wrote a Declaration, which was over 500 words-long! Sadly, the people who actually did things this pandemic caused incalculable damage by utterly failing to do what I would have done.
I would have identified “vulnerable” and “not vulnerable” people and I would have created an impenetrable wall between them. While the virus raged in the world of the not vulnerable, I would have protected the vulnerable in a hermetically sealed bubble. Obviously, I would have protected all 26,500 nursing homes in March 2020. I would have used very draconian measures in nursing homes, so repeated testing, draconian hygiene (listen at 1:36:20). Unfortunately, they failed to implement these draconian measures, as I would have done, which astounded me. I could not imagine that despite the Italian and Washington state experience, nursing homes were still unprotected.
The frequently asked question section of my Declaration listed all the amazing things I would have done. Not only is it really impressive, public health officials could have easily done it all. As I said at the time, a comprehensive and detailed list of measures, including approaches to multi-generational households, can be implemented, and is well within the scope and capability of public health professionals. 
I would have offered older people home delivery of groceries and other essentials. We could have offered free DoorDash to older people. I would have used empty hotel rooms for temporary housing for seniors living in multigenerational homes. I would have made testing available for relatives and friends who want to visit. I would have provided funding for older workers to take a 3 to 6-month sabbatical. I would have passed workplace disability laws that required employers to provide reasonable accommodations to protect high-risk workers. I would have monitored disease transmission at the local level and continuously communicated this to the public. I would have done this in a nuanced way that did not induce panic but instead provided the basis for an accurate assessment of each person’s risk based on their age and comorbid conditions.
Public health officials, however, did not do these very simple things, all of which were well within their scope and capability. It’s their fault for not actually doing what I would have done. I told them exactly what to do! It was a failure of imagination on the part of public health, and so today I am left to wonder why didn’t they just protect the vulnerable and get on with life?
Once I protected the vulnerable, I would have opened schools, and they could have functioned totally normally and everything would have been just fine for everyone. Teachers and students had virtually no risk. Teachers were actually at lower risk of COVID than the population of other workers at large. Being around kids actually protected them, in some sense, because the kids are not super-spreaders. Children have virtually zero risk of getting a serious complication, virtually a zero risk of dying. Children only rarely if ever transmit the disease. It’s not like schools ever closed due to because they were “drowning in COVID” or anything.
Whether on podcasts, editorials, or social media, no one said the words “open schools” more than me, and I am extremely proud of this valuable contribution. I even spread this message and said kids need a real champion on the website of a man who said smoking is very cool and enjoyable for teens and that they should drop out of school to work at Chick-Fil-A and Walmart.
You see, with schools open and COVID spreading uncontrollably, children could have enjoyed the triumph of natural immunity. Yes, natural immunity is a triumph! Infected children have strong natural immunity that protects them from covid infections as they get older. Thanks to the triumph of natural immunity, if 250 million not vulnerable Americans had contracted COVID simultaneously at the end of 2020, the pandemic would have been naturally over in 3-6 months. That’s right, if they listened to me we could have had herd immunity by April 2021 at the latest. The pandemic would have been over! Sadly, they didn’t do all the things I would have done, and so here we are in 2024, with 1,500 Americans still dying of COVID every week.
I am a realist above all. I am under no illusion I could have protected everyone. No matter what, some people still would have wound up in the hospital. Unfortunately many people died there because treatments and medical care were suboptimal and harmful. We even lost a lot of lives because frontline doctors were not knowing how to use mechanical ventilation, just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated. If I worked in a hospital, I wouldn’t have gone crazy. I would have known exactly what to do. I would have saved so many lives.
Of course, COVID alone was not to blame for most of the deaths. What really caused millions of “COVID” deaths was social injustice, inequalities, racism, poverty, smoking, and other modifiable risks factors/lifestyle (e.g., see obesity). Why they didn’t just modify these modifiable risks in March 2020? That’s what I would have done. In contrast, throughout the pandemic, the medical establishment never talked about Covid’s leading modifiable risk factor—obesity. Never, not even once! People even died from lack of vaccination. I would developed better vaccines faster, and I would have convinced everyone to take them.
It’s an abomination that our standards for medical evidence became so degraded during the pandemic. I would have done a randomized-controlled trial (RCT) for literally everything. Making lists of potential RCTs is much harder than actually doing RCTs, and I am extremely proud of my many YouTube videos, where I described all the RCTs I would have done.
For example, you could have run many cluster RCTs of different masking strategies. You also could have have done RCTs of hospital visiting policies, SARS-CoV-2 testing, ventilation, social distancing, as well as for every proposed COVID treatment. More than could— we should do these trials, we ought to do them, and we must do them. Yes, WE must do them, and my role with these trials is just to them dream up, no more. There are smart people in positions of power with resources that can design and conduct such studies. Unfortunately, these smart people in positions of power chose not to do all the RCTs I dreamt up.
Naturally, I would have done an RCT for every vaccine dose for every variant for every imaginable subgroup and demographic. My RCTs would have been large enough to determine if the vaccine prevented hospitalizations and deaths, and they would have been completed fast enough to remain relevant before new variants arrived. You could run human trials of bivalent boosters measuring severe disease. Predictably, they did not do this, and so I now feel the CDC employees responsible adding COVID19 vaccines to the pediatric schedule should be fired.
Instead of doing the things I would have done, people with real-world responsibility muzzled me and called me “fringe“. We could have emerged with many fewer deaths and with minimal disruption to our schools, economy, and social networks, if only they listened to me and all the incredible, wonderful things I would have done, had I actually done anything. Ultimately, they failed us, and we are left without answers and policies that caused significant harm.

Science Based Satire: BOMBSHELL NEWS!!! The Virus I Told You Not to Worry About and Worked to Infect You With… CAME FROM A LAB!!!
“Last year, @WashburneAlex made a bombshell prediction supporting the lab leak theory. New documents released yesterday confirm his prediction.” – Dr. Jay Bhattacharya January 2024
Jonathan HowardonApril 21, 2024
Link

“Last year, @WashburneAlex made a bombshell prediction supporting the lab leak theory. New documents released yesterday confirm his prediction.”
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya January 2024
In March 2020 I wrote an article titled Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? in which I argued that “current estimates about the COVID-19 fatality rate may be too high by orders of magnitude.” I wrote:
If it’s true that the novel coronavirus would kill millions without shelter-in-place orders and quarantines, then the extraordinary measures being carried out in cities and states around the country are surely justified. But there’s little evidence to confirm that premise—and projections of the death toll could plausibly be orders of magnitude too high.
Fear of COVID-19 is based on its high estimated case fatality rate — 2% to 4% of people with confirmed COVID-19 have died, according to the World Health Organization and others. So if 100 million Americans ultimately get the disease, 2 million to 4 million could die. We believe that estimate is deeply flawed…
If our surmise of six million cases is accurate, that’s a mortality rate of 0.01%, assuming a two week lag between infection and death. This is one-tenth of the flu mortality rate of 0.1%. Such a low death rate would be cause for optimism.
I wrote about “the limited scale of the epidemic,” and said that “a 20,000- or 40,000-death epidemic is a far less severe problem than one that kills two million.”
Well guess what folks! I hope you’re sitting down. I have bombshell news to share with you! It turns out that novel coronavirus, the one I predicted would have one-tenth of the flu mortality rate and would cause a limited epidemic… CAME FROM A LAB!
In October 2020, I came up with a “plan” to achieve herd immunity in 3-6 months via the mass infection of 250 million, unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans with that novel coronavirus. I wrote:
The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity, is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk.
Well, you know what? I wanted hundreds of millions of unvaccinated Americans to gain “natural infection” from a virus that… CAME FROM A LAB!
In March 2021, I stressed “we should not be particularly concerned about the variants.” It just so happens the virus I told you not to be particularly concerned about… CAME FROM A LAB!
In April 2021, I said that “the central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID.” Well, there’s monumental news about this virus I told you not to fear. IT CAME FROM A LAB!
In September 2021, I said:
The emergency phase of the disease is over. Now, we need to work very hard to undo the sense of emergency. We should be treating covid as one of 200 diseases that affect people.
Now look at the earth-shattering news. The virus I said that we should treat as just one of 200 diseases… CAME FROM A LAB!
It’s impossible to overstate the significance of this. It’s like finding your bank account was short ten cents and then learning someone stole it from you. It’s like watching an elevator close in front of you, and then finding out the person inside didn’t even try to hit the “open door” button. It’s like finding a gum wrapper on your lawn and then learning someone carelessly dropped it there. It’s like finding a pebble in your shoe and later discovering someone placed it there on purpose.
SARS-CoV-2, the virus I repeatedly told you not to worry about and worked to infect you with… CAME FROM A LAB! If that’s not a bombshell, I don’t know what is.

Science Based Satire: We Should Repeatedly Expose Unvaccinated Children to a Novel Virus That Came From a Lab in China.
Jonathan Howard on March 5, 2023
Link

Recent revelations have confirmed what many of us knew all along- COVID came from a lab in China. I am agnostic as to whether it was created as a bioweapon or it emerged from a simple, but devastating error. Either way, China is trying to absolve themselves of all responsibility for unleashing this deadly virus around the world. Thanks to their actions, billions of us have been infected with a novel virus and millions of us have died. COVID is never going away. We are all going to be exposed to SARS-CoV-2 over and over again for as long as we live with unpredictable long-term consequences.
It logically follows from this that we should make sure unvaccinated children are repeatedly exposed to SARS-CoV-2. Why in the world would we vaccinate children against a virus that came from a Chinese lab? After all, older people have more risk, which is a perfectly valid reason to let some children suffer and die of COVID. Getting sick with a virus leaked from a Chinese lab is healthy and natural for children! We should just accept that some will die as a matter of course– from a virus that came from a Chinese lab.
Rational people who think for themselves know the facts lead to only one conclusion: We should repeatedly expose unvaccinated children to a novel virus unleashed from a lab in China.
What could go wrong?

Science Based Satire: The CDC’s Unyielding, Unscientific Push to Vaccinate Children Against COVID Caused a Measles Outbreak in Europe
I warned you this would happen.
Jonathan Howard on January 26, 2024
Link

“Very soon, we will likely see real outbreaks of measles and other virus thought controlled by vaccination.”
I warned you that vaccinating children against COVID would damage confidence in routine vaccinations. In my article Entirely Predictable: More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids, I wrote that:
For many of us who have witnessed the CDC’s repeated blunders with kids COVID19 vaccines, this result is entirely predictable…I worried that the unyielding push (non-satire note: only 11% of kids are up-to-date on COVID vaccines), to vaccinate kids with a COVID19 vaccine that has never shown reduction in severe disease or hospitalization in a randomized trial at any age (non-satire note: this is false), and certainly not against prevailing variants, was a huge mistake, and would lead the public to doubt all vaccines, rather than an embrace of all… Very soon, we will likely see real outbreaks of measles and other virus thought controlled by vaccination.
Similarly, in my article The CDC Is Breaking Trust in Childhood Vaccination, I explained that:
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases…The general trust deficit is more troubling than skepticism toward this particular vaccine, because it could conceivably drive down uptake of other childhood vaccines that we know are more important to children’s health, such as those against measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
In my article Not the Way to Pull Vaccines Back from a “Dangerous Tipping Point I alone pointed out the “proverbial elephant in the room, COVID boosters” and said:
Trying to convince all people that all vaccines are the same is probably the way to make people reasonably skeptical of some vaccine be unreasonably skeptical of them all.
Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
“There was an ‘alarming’ nearly 45-fold increase in measles cases in Europe last year.”
Sadly, you ignored my pleas.
Now look at the news. The UK initially refused to vaccinate children against COVID and is not offering them boosters presently. It even encourages parents send sick children to school. Despite these wise, compassionate policies, they too are paying the price for the CDC’s unyielding, unscientific push to vaccinate children. According to a recent article titled UK Disease Agency Declares National Incident as Measles Cases Soar:
Latest figures from the UKHSA show that the uptake of the MMR vaccine is at its lowest level in more than a decade, with 84.5 percent of children having had two doses by the time they were five years old in 2022-23. And the number of measles cases has jumped, too. In 2023, there were 1,603 suspected cases of measles in England and Wales, an increase from 735 in 2022 and 360 the year before.
That’s not all. Another recent headline read, Whooping Cough Vaccination Urged As Cases Rise Rapidly In Wales.
It gets worse still. Sadly, CDC’s damage is not confined to the UK. According to an article titled Alarming 45-fold rise in Measles in Europe – WHO:
There was an “alarming” nearly 45-fold increase in measles cases in Europe last year, the World Health Organization (WHO) says. Health chiefs are warning that cases are still rising and “urgent measures” are needed to prevent further spread. Some 42,200 people were infected in 2023, compared to 941 during the whole of 2022. The WHO believes this is a result of fewer children being vaccinated against the disease during the Covid pandemic…
Speaking about the situation in Europe, Dr Hans Kluge, regional director at the WHO, said: “We have seen, in the region, not only a 30-fold increase in measles cases, but also nearly 21,000 hospitalisations and five measles-related deaths. This is concerning. Vaccination is the only way to protect children from this potentially dangerous disease.”
I don’t want to say “I told you so,” because even I underestimated the power of the CDC’s repeated blunders with kids COVID vaccines. Their maleficence has crossed the Atlantic, poisoning confidence in vaccines across an entire continent. One typical father in Kazakhstan, the most heavily hit country during this measles outbreak, said in a recent interview:
I was perfectly willing to give my child the measles vaccine, but decided against it thanks to the CDC’s unyielding, unscientific push to vaccinate children against COVID.
Another mother in Russia said:
If only the CDC had run a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial that was adequately powered to demonstrate a reduction in severe disease or hospitalization for COVID, I’d now be vaccinating my kid against measles.”
To repeat, I did warn you that the unyielding push to vaccinate kids with a COVID vaccine that has never shown reduction in severe disease or hospitalization in a randomized trial at any age and certainly not against prevailing variants, was a huge mistake. Anyone who knows anything about the anti-vaccine movement, knows anti-vaxxers change their minds when shown robust data from randomized-controlled trials showing that vaccines are safe and effective.
“For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.”
In contrast to the CDC, one group of people who have zero responsibility for the increase in vaccine-hesitancy are doctors who said to parents:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger… Immunity is built through illness.
Nope, highly-credentialed doctors at prestigious universities who deluged with parents with this message throughout the pandemic have nothing to do with declining vaccine rates. Similarly, doctors who treated abnormal lab values after vaccination as a fate worse than death and wrote articles titled Public Health Should Lose Your Trust are totally blameless. Anyone who suggests otherwise knows nothing about the anti-vaccine mindset.
“Bivalent COVID Vaccine Very Effective Against Severe Illness In Children, Study Concludes.“
It’s ridiculous, but vaccine zealots argued that providing parents with accurate information about pediatric COVID and the pediatric COVID vaccine would boost confidence in all vaccines. These are the kind of people who wrote about the anti-vaccine movement before the pandemic and now point out that COVID killed more American children than all other vaccine-preventable diseases combined the past 4 years. They insist on sharing research that I don’t want to be true. Some recent examples include; Risk of Death 3 Times Higher In Brazilian Kids With COVID-19 Than With Other Respiratory Viruses, Study Finds and Bivalent COVID Vaccine Very Effective Against Severe Illness In Children, Study Concludes.
These idiots owe me an apology. However, I’m not the one suffering from the CDC’s unyielding, unscientific push to vaccinate children against COVID. Children across Europe, sick with the measles, are paying the real price.

Science-Based Satire: Vaccine-Mandates and the Denial of the Existence of Natural Immunity After COVID Recovery. A Deadly Anti-Science Position
One thing I’ve learned during the past few years, is how quickly scenes of mass death fade from the collective memory. Denial is powerful. Everyone just wants to forget. There’s no national day of mourning or any memorial to the countless victims of previous vaccine-mandates. It seems that humanity’s sad fate is that every generation is doomed to repeat the mistakes of the past.
Jonathan Howard on October 6, 2023
Link

Dr. Martin Kulldorff, September 23, 2023
We should have listened. A few older doctors, veterans of the vaccine-mandate carnage of the 1970s tried to warn us. They knew what was coming. We arrogant fools didn’t believe them.
It started as a trickle. The first patient was a 19-year-old sophomore, an athlete in perfect health. She arrived in an obtunded state, barely able to state her name. She was febrile and hallucinating. We figured she had overdosed on something. She’d died the next day in her mother’s arms. The next patient was a 22-year-old senior, a dancer. He was delirious and foaming at the mouth. He couldn’t protect his airway and was intubated on arrival. He’d be dead within hours. By the end of the week three more college students and two high school seniors arrived. They all shared the same tragic fate.
It soon became clear what was killing our patients. Our worst fears had come true. It wasn’t a bad batch of drugs. It was vaccine-mandates and the denial of the existence of natural immunity after COVID recovery. What started as trickle, soon became a tidal wave of mass death- young people, cut down in the prime of their lives, all from schools with vaccine-mandates, of course. The kids who attended schools without vaccine-mandates were fine, of course. Their administrators didn’t deny the existence of natural immunity after COVID recovery, and so their students lived.
I will never be able to unhear the sound of a mother screaming as her child left the ICU for the morgue, another victim of vaccine-mandates and the denial of the existence of natural immunity after COVID recovery. Though I hate to admit it, we all became numb to even this after a while. The suffering was too great to process. You couldn’t wrap your head around it. Many parents lost multiple children. They had blank looks in their eyes, unable to grasp their loss. They said nothing as the left the hospital, returning to empty houses, their lives forever altered.
Of course, nearly every hospital had vaccine-mandates as well, and we were hit hard. The entire 7th floor was reserved for hospital employees, victims of vaccine-mandates and the denial of the existence of natural immunity after COVID recovery. The nurse who patiently taught me how to put in IVs a decade ago was one of the earliest victims. A young medical student, on the cusp of her career was one of the last.
This created complicated ethical and moral challenges for us all. Many healthcare workers had advocated for vaccine-mandates, and they were now dying in droves from policies they supported. Several prominent supporters of vaccine-mandates, at least the ones who didn’t die themselves, simply never returned to work rather than witness the carnage that resulted from their denial of the existence of natural immunity after COVID recovery. Cowards.
One thing I’ve learned during the past few years, is how quickly scenes of mass death fade from our collective memory. Denial is powerful. Everyone just wants to forget. There’s no national day of mourning or any memorial to history’s countless victims of previous vaccine-mandates. It seems that humanity’s sad fate is that every generation is doomed to repeat the mistakes of the past. I have no illusions any young doctor will be reading this when the next vaccine-mandate arrives. However, on the small chance someone stumbles across this essay, I pray you’ll learn from our experience and remember what truly killed our friends, family members and co-workers. Despite what sheltered disinformation doctors- who never treated vaccine-mandate victims themselves- now claim, it wasn’t “anti-vaccine misinformation” or any virus.
It was vaccine-mandates and the denial of the existence of natural immunity after COVID recovery. A deadly anti-science position.

Science Based Satire: Trashing the COVID Vaccine is the Only Way to Maintain Trust in Vaccines
A guest post from a contrarian doctor who knows one has to trash vaccines to maintain trust in vaccines.
Jonathan Howard on July 15, 2022
Link

Prior to the pandemic, if I discussed pediatric vaccines at all, it was only to belittle “skeptics” at Science Based Medicine who wasted their time dunking on the anti-vaccine movement. Things have changed, and I’ve since anointed myself the chief defender of childhood vaccination for all diseases other than COVID. There’s no questions that “skeptics” who’ve corrected anti-vaccine misinformation since Andrew Wakefield came on the scene care much less about these issues than I do.
As such, I know something they don’t: if parents are encouraged to vaccinate their children against COVID, they will somehow lose trust in vaccines for more significant diseases. If trust in the COVID vaccine goes up, trust in other vaccines goes down. Don’t blame me. That’s just how it is. It’s already happening. When you see headlines like this, you should think to yourself “none of this would be happening if only the CDC was cool with more unvaccinated babies getting COVID.”
Which vaccine-preventable diseases are more significant than COVID? Simple-minded “skeptics”, incapable of nuance, claim that just because COVID overwhelmed pediatric hospitals, sent thousands of children to the ICU, and killed hundreds more children this year than every other vaccine-preventable disease combined, it somehow qualifies as a “significant disease”. This is absurd. They’ll even claim that COVID is worse than the flu, just because it killed 50 times more children since the start of the pandemic. That’s how ridiculous they are. When I asked “Should We Let Children Catch Omicron?“, they rushed in unison to answer “no“. “For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life”, I wrote. They disagreed. Sheeple.
To be clear, COVID is insignificant for the following reasons:
    • COVID kills more old people.
    • Only a very small percentage of children who get COVID die from it.
    • Children are more likely to die from other causes than from COVID.
    • Most children who die have underlying conditions.
“Skeptics” will further claim that since babies have the highest fatality rate of all children (slide 19), the vaccine will likely be an important tool to prevent these deaths moving forward. Rational people know these deaths would be sad and worth preventing only if fewer children died in accidents or if COVID was less dangerous for elderly people.
Of course, without a randomized-controlled trial (RCT) of a million children, any claims of the vaccine’s benefits are just speculative nonsense. Remember, claims of vaccine benefits can only come from massive RCTs, while unverified VAERS reports are sufficient to firmly establish the harms of the COVID vaccine. Sometimes it’s even fun to spitball rumors to my large Twitter audience, just asking questions about whether pediatricians are misdiagnosing children with COVID when they actually have RSV.
Not only are “skeptics” less concerned about routine childhood vaccinations than me, they are also less knowledgeable about the anti-vaccine movement and effective ways to combat it. It’s obvious the best way to maintain trust in vaccines is to convince parents that drug companies, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and pediatricians who’ve worked with sick children throughout the pandemic are either lying to them or woefully incompetent. Federal regulators at the CDC and FDA deserve special scorn. You see, these folks unanimously voted to authorize these vaccines.
All 21 members of the FDA’s Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee voted “yes” in response to the question: “Based on the totality of scientific evidence available, do the benefits of the Moderna COVID-19 Vaccine when administered as a 2-dose series (25 micrograms each dose) outweigh its risks for use in infants and children 6 months through 5 years of age?”
I know better than all 21 of them.
Is there a better way to instill confidence in vaccines in general than to deny the benefits of the COVID vaccine and to constantly hype vaccine side-effects? Of course not. Treating rare side-effects that are nearly always mild and temporary as a fate worse than death from COVID is the only way to ensure parents will vaccinate their children against more significant diseases.
No one cares more about pediatric vaccination than me. Yet, when you read articles titled “Low Demand for Young Kids’ Covid Vaccines is Alarming Doctors” please know this is referring to doctors who actually treat sick children, not me. Unlike them, I know that to maintain trust in vaccines for more significant diseases, the ones that kill fewer children than COVID, we must keep COVID vaccination rates as low as possible. That’s why I’ll never stop minimizing COVID or trashing the vaccine against it.

Science Based Satire: Sure, COVID Is Killing 1,500 Americans Per Week, But I Saw a Stranger Wearing a Mask…OUTSIDE!
We shouldn’t “give a shit” about COVID. Instead, we should care deeply about strangers who still “give a shit” about COVID. They need to be publicly mocked and shamed over and over again.
Jonathan Howard on February 18, 2024
Link

Just saw someone in San Francisco wearing a surgical mask outside, and push the crosswalk button with their foot. At some point, we might have to discuss irrational phobia of unavoidable microbes, and the degree to which it was perpetuated by public health.
Dr. Vinay Prasad November 2023
Of course, I can read. Of course, I follow the news. I am perfectly aware of the headline that asked:
Why Are 1,500 Americans Still Dying From COVID Every Week?
However, I want to make you aware of a more serious, pressing issue: I saw a stranger wearing a mask, OUTSIDE! Did you know there’s no evidence to support this? The person who was wearing the mask outside was doing so for no good reason. I mean, did he really think he was going to get COVID from the fire hydrant? Was he worried he might spread it to a stop sign? Ridiculous. It gets worse that than. Recently, I tweeted about a cyclist who was wearing a mask outdoors in SF while riding his bicycle on JAN 17, 2024. I wrote an entire article on my monetized Substack berating this “utterly insane” cyclist, in which I posted his picture and asked:
Where is there ANY EVIDENCE that wearing TWO MASKS outside when you ride your bike improves ANY HEALTH OUTCOME??
Friends, this was a rhetorical question. There is NO EVIDENCE that wearing TWO MASKS outside when you ride your bike improves ANY HEALTH OUTCOME.
Throughout the pandemic, I have bravely tackled only the biggest challenges, while leaving the trivial 7-foot hoops to “skeptics” at Science Based Medicine. Yes, yes, yes I know that 1,500 lives were lost again to COVID this week. The same will be probably true next week. YAWN! I am on record as saying there are zero “smart people who still give a shit about COVID.” I stand by that.
While no one should “give a shit” about COVID, we should all care deeply about strangers who still “give a shit” about COVID. In contrast to those killed or injured by COVID, strangers who wear masks outside are a grave concern. Anyone with an “irrational phobia” of unavoidable microbes, according to my standards, needs to be publicly ridiculed and shamed over and over again. I’ve Tweeted about such strangers countless times and devoted several articles to them. I have no plans to stop. Mocking strangers who take excessive precautions against dangerous viruses or who have been injured by them, is the reason I went to medical school in the first place. Of course, I view any precaution as an excessive precaution. As I said previously, “Repeat infections are inevitable. More the longer you live. Nothing can be done about it.”
It’s true that I know nothing about the life of this mask-wearing stranger. It’s also true that, other than offending my delicate sensibilities, I can’t begin to explain how his actions hurt anyone. But the odds he benefited from his mask are zero. If a stranger wearing a mask outside isn’t a 10-foot hoop, I don’t know what is.

Science Based Satire: We Need Randomized Controlled Clinical Trials of SARS-CoV-2
Before we make any more decisions regarding SARS-CoV-2, we urgently need to conduct large, long-term RCTs of it. I am astonished this is controversial in the medical community.
Jonathan Howard on August 6, 2022
Link

Randomized-controlled trials and vaccines
The randomized controlled clinical trial is the gold standard of scientific evidence. When regulators approved the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA vaccines for emergency use in December 2020, two randomized trials showed that the vaccines reduced symptomatic covid infection by over 90% during the first few months after the second dose. Pfizer and Moderna did not design the trials to evaluate long-term efficacy or the more important outcomes of preventing hospitalization, death, or transmission…It is the responsibility of the manufacturers and FDA to ensure that benefits outweigh harms. They have failed to do so.
That brilliant insight comes from an article titled, “Are the Covid mRNA Vaccines Safe?” by Dr. Martin Kulldroff of the Great Barrington Declaration. Had we listened to him and let the virus run rampant in unvaccinated children, the pandemic would been over last year. Sadly, some fools tried to vaccinate children, and as a result, COVID is still with us. Thus it falls upon Dr. Kulldroff to remind us of something important: we have no idea if the COVID vaccines prevent hospitalizations or death. The randomized-controlled trials (RCTs) were too small to assess these key metrics. There’s zero “gold standard scientific evidence” the COVID vaccines help anyone.
Though I’m sure you’ve seen vaccine-zealots claim otherwise, the only “evidence” they have to back their assertions comes from observational data. This kind of research can be summarized as “a bunch of stuff doctors say they saw”. While observation data is suitable for making YouTube videos about vaccine side-effects, it can’t be used to “support vaccines”. In a article supporting pediatric COVID infections, Dr. Vinay Prasad explained why:
Observational data has been used to support vaccines, but is plagued by confounding. That is because parents who vaccinate their kids are different from those who don’t. The same studies could show that driving a baby home from hospital in a Mercedes is better than a Ford.
He’s exactly right, and all observational studies used to justify the COVID vaccine can be summarily discarded. Of course, this logic applies to all vaccines. For example, the observational data that purports to show the HPV vaccine prevents cancer is similarly plagued by confounding. That is because parents who vaccinate their kids are different from those who don’t. The same studies could show that driving a baby home from hospital in a Mercedes is better than a Ford.
Randomized-controlled trials and SARS-CoV-2
Reasonable people know that the same standards of evidence should apply to both the vaccine and the virus. Certainly, one would expect highly-credentialed doctors to be aware of this fact. Sadly, they are not.
In an essay titled “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young” Dr. Kulldorff declared, “the old have a thousand-fold higher mortality risk than the young”. Similarly, in an essay titled, “Kids Don’t Need Covid-19 Vaccines to Return to School” Dr. Prasad wrote, “The risk of an 85-year-old dying from Covid-19 is 7,500 times greater than that of a 10-year-old”. Don’t get me wrong, if older people indeed have a higher mortality risk than young people, there’s no need to protect young people. However, given their sophisticated understanding of the limitations of observational studies, I was dismayed to learn that neither Dr. Kulldorff nor Dr. Prasad supported their statements with data from an RCT. Though they both make confident claims about the virus all the time, not once have they referenced the “gold standard of scientific evidence”.
After scouring the medical literature, I know why. It’s medicine’s dirty little secret. There are no RCTs of SARS-CoV-2.
I know this may shock people outside the medical community. They naïvely believe that when doctors make assured statements about the virus being more dangerous for elderly people, these claims are based on the “gold standard of scientific evidence”. However, it’s an open secret amongst doctors that nothing we say about the virus comes from an RCT.
And the public is asked to believe a great many things about the virus absent this gold standard of scientific evidence. Those with underlying medical conditions are more vulnerable. Children are mostly spared. The virus causes respiratory difficulties. It is dangerous for pregnant women. Natural immunity protects against reinfection. It is contagious.
These claims certainty sound plausible, and they may even be true. However, with zero RCTs to guide us, we really have no idea. Despite this, Drs. Kulldorff and Prasad are happy to pontificate widely on the virus based on observational data that is plagued by confounding.
This is a travesty. The public has the right to the gold standard scientific evidence for both the vaccine and the virus. While no doctor would disagree with this, I’ve not seen one call for an RCT of the virus itself. That changes today. Before we make any more decisions this pandemic, we must end the ignorance. We must conduct large, long-term RCTs of SARS-CoV-2. I am astonished this is controversial in the medical community.
